id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08010v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08010v3
|
Debatrix: Multi-dimensional Debate Judge with Iterative Chronological Analysis Based on LLM
| 2024-03-12T18:19:47 | 2024-06-19T19:39:42 |
Jingcong Liang, Rong Ye, Meng Han, Ruofei Lai, Xinyu Zhang, Xuanjing Huang, Zhongyu Wei
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
How can we construct an automated debate judge to evaluate an extensive,
vibrant, multi-turn debate? This task is challenging, as judging a debate
involves grappling with lengthy texts, intricate argument relationships, and
multi-dimensional assessments. At the same time, current research mainly
focuses on short dialogues, rarely touching upon the evaluation of an entire
debate. In this paper, by leveraging Large Language Models (LLMs), we propose
Debatrix, which makes the analysis and assessment of multi-turn debates more
aligned with majority preferences. Specifically, Debatrix features a vertical,
iterative chronological analysis and a horizontal, multi-dimensional evaluation
collaboration. To align with real-world debate scenarios, we introduced the
PanelBench benchmark, comparing our system's performance to actual debate
outcomes. The findings indicate a notable enhancement over directly using LLMs
for debate evaluation. Source code and benchmark data are available online at
https://github.com/ljcleo/debatrix .
|
[
-0.8354514837265015,
-0.8831055760383606,
0.5998095870018005,
0.37327900528907776,
-0.534165620803833,
0.37080472707748413,
-0.07020337134599686,
0.04639020189642906,
0.34880906343460083,
0.6876691579818726,
-0.1731962412595749,
-0.5092048048973083,
-0.6051740050315857,
-0.1467703878879547,
-0.3355172276496887,
0.6530976891517639,
-0.11938875168561935,
0.2165302336215973,
-0.15427882969379425,
-0.32595962285995483,
-0.29769110679626465,
-0.32763245701789856,
-0.43716126680374146,
-0.5538774728775024,
0.5603818297386169,
0.6795029044151306,
0.7629445791244507,
0.2746366262435913,
0.30599620938301086,
0.46448302268981934,
-0.2201266586780548,
-0.00021817207743879408,
-0.4042454957962036,
0.348314493894577,
-0.29123470187187195,
-0.051020488142967224,
-0.475644052028656,
0.055994339287281036,
0.6659590601921082,
0.4771680235862732,
-0.4679080843925476,
-0.06590404361486435,
-0.39741334319114685,
0.8975688219070435,
-0.50679612159729,
-0.08936268836259842,
-0.8308461308479309,
0.25557026267051697,
-0.3342128098011017,
-0.30154526233673096,
-0.38527536392211914,
-0.742556631565094,
0.20192477107048035,
-0.058939602226018906,
-0.07079903781414032,
0.03950802981853485,
0.4751037657260895,
0.10510975122451782,
-0.6924717426300049,
-0.027606453746557236,
-0.7861815094947815,
0.4029369652271271,
-0.7870833873748779,
0.1909397393465042,
0.03835884854197502,
0.5905824303627014,
-0.4225147068500519,
-0.8154606819152832,
-0.7256320714950562,
-0.520698606967926,
0.2974134683609009,
0.41646608710289,
-0.5205828547477722,
0.04604646563529968,
0.21550819277763367,
0.3126162588596344,
-0.411892831325531,
0.49797147512435913,
-0.1586928814649582,
0.3235831558704376,
0.5222843885421753,
0.6086801290512085,
-0.1458871066570282,
-0.4526994824409485,
-0.4221675992012024,
-0.10292814671993256,
-0.4340584874153137,
-0.01775246486067772,
0.7356216311454773,
0.11911974847316742,
0.18215101957321167,
0.5087428092956543,
-0.3245598077774048,
0.7009468078613281,
0.2454162836074829,
0.18580900132656097,
-0.11909804493188858,
-0.05715687945485115,
-0.2290106564760208,
0.11960745602846146,
1.0613994598388672,
0.42790669202804565,
-0.2654344141483307,
0.2656181752681732,
0.20458672940731049,
-0.015512592159211636,
0.4848661720752716,
-1.1425045728683472,
-0.3273979723453522,
0.40108373761177063,
-0.4953213930130005,
-0.18186688423156738,
-0.24958853423595428,
-1.390250325202942,
-0.973678469657898,
-0.47447410225868225,
0.13519731163978577,
-0.028096681460738182,
-0.24077828228473663,
0.33366066217422485,
-0.24546854197978973,
-0.20049066841602325,
0.7082543969154358,
-0.48514288663864136,
0.4574112296104431,
0.84638911485672,
0.7757061719894409,
-0.39495158195495605,
0.13876973092556,
-0.7439796924591064,
-0.34674498438835144,
-0.4271225929260254,
1.1600065231323242,
-0.9658384919166565,
-0.5937662720680237,
-0.05352119728922844,
-0.27683913707733154,
0.025525573641061783,
-0.4072488844394684,
0.6076969504356384,
-0.9523181915283203,
0.2184308022260666,
-0.22479459643363953,
-0.7040734887123108,
0.021701278164982796,
0.6175551414489746,
-1.0455961227416992,
0.51743084192276,
-0.45672041177749634,
-1.115118384361267,
0.37977030873298645,
-0.5822536945343018,
-0.11544108390808105,
0.1290423423051834,
-0.4054318368434906,
-0.49750348925590515,
-0.17587368190288544,
0.1677519977092743,
0.13269686698913574,
-0.4673844873905182,
0.47203007340431213,
-0.6559457182884216,
-0.23708036541938782,
0.26216650009155273,
-0.45040878653526306,
0.6410055160522461,
0.2051798701286316,
-0.38523995876312256,
0.5430434346199036,
-0.7776122093200684,
-0.35240525007247925,
-0.08282815665006638,
-0.20841911435127258,
-0.13356328010559082,
0.37034857273101807,
-0.08655902743339539,
0.0780765563249588,
-0.09457018226385117,
-0.5997339487075806,
0.6336669921875,
-0.20838135480880737,
0.32361602783203125,
0.8720043301582336,
0.02755144238471985,
0.3350590765476227,
-0.1013028472661972,
0.7553579211235046,
-0.05958769842982292,
0.08105165511369705,
0.09555445611476898,
-0.3505391478538513,
-0.6592812538146973,
-0.23194630444049835,
0.5439130067825317,
0.4634755849838257,
-0.6833100318908691,
0.09541924297809601,
-0.3608371913433075,
-0.6433199644088745,
-0.20683850347995758,
-0.02182340994477272,
-0.08234100043773651,
0.17767742276191711,
0.29644644260406494,
-0.26528269052505493,
-0.5859918594360352,
-0.8614055514335632,
-0.07593663036823273,
-0.27407220005989075,
0.4096966087818146,
0.17093180119991302,
0.45058709383010864,
-0.14882244169712067,
0.739242434501648,
-0.43438249826431274,
0.012681235559284687,
-0.35088610649108887,
0.6243903040885925,
0.2512015998363495,
0.06478870660066605,
0.22113728523254395,
-0.46710896492004395,
-0.44599366188049316,
0.051001179963350296,
-0.24175259470939636,
0.001997472019866109,
-0.21278659999370575,
-0.3328946828842163,
0.2352193146944046,
0.6148173809051514,
-0.5281062722206116,
0.3892546594142914,
0.3871326148509979,
-0.2982248067855835,
0.4553557336330414,
-0.039116669446229935,
0.4432166516780853,
-0.9962831735610962,
0.16617515683174133,
-0.06827066838741302,
-0.13461165130138397,
-0.4159337282180786,
-0.32800763845443726,
-0.06826774775981903,
0.22518740594387054,
-0.1777670830488205,
0.5978392362594604,
0.010685515590012074,
0.05413044989109039,
-0.4656528830528259,
0.5822687149047852,
-0.050442419946193695,
0.1916923075914383,
0.14953535795211792,
0.31551608443260193,
-0.12687990069389343,
-0.2111423909664154,
0.5338535308837891,
0.3675682842731476,
-0.8061710596084595,
0.7384187579154968,
-0.5520681142807007,
0.4464842975139618,
-0.012651466764509678,
0.631320595741272,
-1.4011257886886597,
0.05143176019191742,
0.12189772725105286,
-0.03913726285099983,
0.39439377188682556,
-0.42610588669776917,
-0.39982423186302185,
-0.7234210968017578,
-0.5881756544113159,
0.11073809117078781,
0.0896865725517273,
-0.5701456665992737,
0.49988681077957153,
0.6209220886230469,
-0.5145794749259949,
-0.886322021484375,
0.08553746342658997,
0.5173295140266418,
-0.281426340341568,
-0.48200204968452454,
0.5081192851066589,
-0.15974612534046173,
-0.7424934506416321,
-0.28613463044166565,
-0.08854039758443832,
0.09713755548000336,
-0.004079153295606375,
0.17646116018295288,
0.18018418550491333,
-0.016440726816654205,
0.06279902160167694,
0.25231999158859253,
-0.10188083350658417,
-0.07689597457647324,
0.11218418180942535,
0.6024450063705444,
-0.10424879938364029,
-0.5290389657020569,
-0.13637752830982208,
0.23910468816757202,
0.7284333109855652,
-0.07392038404941559,
0.23676851391792297,
0.24527916312217712,
0.09480477124452591,
-0.22769656777381897,
-0.887999415397644,
0.1912079006433487,
-0.450478196144104,
0.43616777658462524,
-0.48425042629241943,
-0.8739787936210632,
0.4147220849990845,
-0.2463659644126892,
0.36380037665367126,
0.4910290241241455,
0.9883851408958435,
0.17323759198188782,
1.040542483329773,
0.17947636544704437,
-0.11787354946136475,
0.5570089221000671,
0.06187694892287254,
-0.07170923054218292,
-0.767586886882782,
-0.23964731395244598,
-0.8332023620605469,
-0.5854893922805786,
-0.36077430844306946,
-0.460663378238678,
0.243915393948555,
-0.10880880802869797,
-0.5654608607292175,
0.12368480116128922,
-0.19442406296730042,
0.4420134723186493,
0.11755359917879105,
-0.27412059903144836,
0.5569564700126648,
-0.10074148327112198,
-0.41886836290359497,
-0.22061918675899506,
-0.3830071985721588,
-0.6193290948867798,
0.8571793437004089,
0.36761292815208435,
0.9846274256706238,
0.14912690222263336,
0.5500349402427673,
0.4696390926837921,
0.590463399887085,
-0.6853765845298767,
0.5756908655166626,
-0.05671820044517517,
-0.4661204218864441,
-0.17056839168071747,
-0.5419032573699951,
-1.1551092863082886,
0.8535463213920593,
-0.038583241403102875,
-0.6946610808372498,
0.20430496335029602,
-0.14286041259765625,
-0.5113010406494141,
0.6067018508911133,
-0.046674296259880066,
0.9446843862533569,
-0.38973313570022583,
-0.5498220920562744,
-0.5624722242355347,
-0.44063600897789,
0.3954025208950043,
0.20387157797813416,
0.16508959233760834,
-0.07556182146072388,
0.27552279829978943,
0.8094836473464966,
-0.30977851152420044,
0.6390553712844849,
-0.3322727084159851,
-0.3356163203716278,
0.19205895066261292,
0.3176301419734955,
0.2683941721916199,
0.34255504608154297,
-0.17887800931930542,
-0.0723927840590477,
0.006205691024661064,
0.12814253568649292,
-0.4240683317184448,
0.912690281867981,
-0.7934767007827759,
-0.9969847798347473,
-0.525401771068573,
-0.292670875787735,
-0.2960701882839203,
-0.11377354711294174,
-0.253278523683548,
0.2851252853870392,
-0.7811611890792847,
0.2751776874065399,
0.3883754014968872,
-0.29080769419670105,
0.38981109857559204,
0.8398965001106262,
-0.6816710829734802,
-0.7115999460220337,
0.4784329831600189,
-0.020696906372904778,
-0.22817379236221313,
0.3633311986923218,
0.4720011055469513,
-0.43770483136177063,
-0.5507140159606934,
-0.7474954128265381,
-0.18749269843101501,
-0.8273666501045227,
-0.3543512523174286,
-1.0002537965774536,
0.10761066526174545,
0.08314221352338791,
0.1833762377500534,
-0.5908308029174805,
-0.733628511428833,
0.06722836196422577,
-0.2038358747959137,
0.361072838306427,
0.8182064294815063,
-0.019351324066519737,
0.17232181131839752,
-0.5176151990890503,
0.5466604828834534,
0.6258189678192139,
0.3929593861103058,
-0.019687548279762268,
-0.7051149606704712,
0.1590508222579956,
-0.30324220657348633,
-0.8050798177719116,
-0.8306177258491516,
0.22036100924015045,
-0.32884785532951355,
0.773138165473938,
0.39606618881225586,
-0.007521163206547499,
0.812287449836731,
-0.7369590997695923,
0.6919131278991699,
0.10303128510713577,
-0.957334578037262,
0.371660441160202,
-0.20401816070079803,
0.098740354180336,
0.7593661546707153,
0.15393634140491486,
-0.5320597887039185,
-0.22679872810840607,
-0.3334120213985443,
-0.8998913168907166,
0.6717490553855896,
-0.005591139197349548,
0.04805300384759903,
-0.0620676688849926,
-0.038209520280361176,
0.35415899753570557,
0.3029898703098297,
-0.3274305462837219,
0.015162936411798,
-0.27089035511016846,
0.21057410538196564,
0.02177564799785614,
-0.22979073226451874,
-0.4577285051345825,
-0.4914098381996155,
0.36669206619262695,
-0.07491811364889145,
-0.10156748443841934,
-0.14616167545318604,
-0.05295943468809128,
-0.2485225945711136,
0.6002094149589539,
0.8042942881584167,
0.6816460490226746,
-0.29073795676231384,
0.22774936258792877,
0.2708657681941986,
-0.02943315915763378,
0.09989223629236221,
0.5136087536811829,
0.1746956706047058,
0.012484225444495678,
0.020996328443288803,
0.9199873208999634,
0.1542799174785614,
-0.3146071135997772,
0.3740568459033966,
-0.3611963987350464,
-0.3033784031867981,
-0.26441124081611633,
-0.2942063510417938,
0.44911816716194153,
0.551026463508606,
0.2008139193058014,
0.02452213503420353,
0.2807227373123169,
-0.3000722825527191,
0.29655250906944275,
0.5631229877471924,
-0.394567608833313,
0.04903415963053703,
0.5716715455055237,
0.3717222511768341,
0.03365573287010193,
0.36738482117652893,
-0.07071814686059952,
-0.6635412573814392,
0.7945173382759094,
0.1587652713060379,
0.8915866017341614,
-0.24282725155353546,
0.45557039976119995,
0.3064207434654236,
0.1930236667394638,
-0.10682196170091629,
0.23844075202941895,
-0.06989503651857376,
-0.4137271046638489,
-0.42678678035736084,
-0.5425937175750732,
-1.0626325607299805,
0.1862032264471054,
-0.4433634877204895,
0.2574542164802551,
-0.6574722528457642,
-0.4203219413757324,
0.36659491062164307,
0.2530754506587982,
-0.45372122526168823,
-0.48912498354911804,
0.5826100707054138,
0.8600475192070007,
-0.5703505277633667,
0.5965960621833801,
0.47532919049263,
-0.06257110089063644,
0.2528397738933563,
-0.22716906666755676,
0.1100548803806305,
-0.3317095637321472,
0.7030865550041199,
0.07602477073669434,
-0.5391527414321899,
-0.4956894814968109,
-0.4702824354171753,
-0.4378229081630707,
0.8206206560134888,
0.3442190885543823,
-0.8746327757835388,
0.6172662377357483,
-0.030835777521133423,
0.6563282608985901,
-0.2769191861152649,
0.7588678002357483,
0.6104806065559387,
0.675743818283081,
0.34812110662460327,
-0.7163416743278503,
-0.15336193144321442,
-0.3836385905742645,
-0.006582554895430803,
0.18401943147182465,
-0.8915795087814331,
0.9275097250938416,
-0.05689952149987221,
-0.0008981366408988833,
0.06548137217760086,
0.7416831254959106,
0.22946777939796448,
0.31266340613365173,
0.521472692489624,
0.701957106590271,
0.6988277435302734,
0.03290928155183792,
0.8294943571090698,
-0.17589426040649414,
0.2673885226249695,
1.529026985168457,
-0.8592348694801331,
0.9910862445831299,
0.21541042625904083,
-0.31896230578422546,
0.9135215878486633,
0.4917377531528473,
-0.03631732612848282,
0.2173212170600891,
0.7078127861022949,
-0.042868390679359436,
-0.5274883508682251,
0.16796620190143585,
-0.2951492667198181,
0.4470890760421753,
0.3612077832221985,
-0.03648660331964493,
-0.5750040411949158,
-0.15483903884887695,
0.2158859223127365,
0.2796367406845093,
-0.058801013976335526,
0.8464257717132568,
-0.02058504708111286,
-0.7394629716873169,
0.2405615597963333,
0.22870345413684845,
0.3482847809791565,
-0.3892391622066498,
-0.15030106902122498,
-0.4533878564834595,
0.434253066778183,
0.0004085069813299924,
-0.8431562781333923,
-0.10674144327640533,
0.10189814120531082,
0.19493770599365234,
-0.10635460168123245,
0.4348464012145996,
-0.2861942648887634,
-0.46395549178123474,
0.5243947505950928,
0.4729483723640442,
-0.21375641226768494,
0.15529201924800873,
-0.843428373336792,
0.36970916390419006,
-0.21186934411525726,
-0.7369267344474792,
0.20688435435295105,
0.3099350035190582,
-0.19642604887485504,
0.6026535630226135,
0.3558044731616974,
-0.3880172371864319,
-0.24979588389396667,
0.5438694357872009,
1.1368569135665894,
-0.6616171598434448,
-0.3042399287223816,
-1.2294105291366577,
0.34064242243766785,
-0.4392629861831665,
-0.1808779537677765,
0.7026153802871704,
0.6606734991073608,
0.15908214449882507,
0.23723135888576508,
0.6885122060775757,
0.127153679728508,
0.4169189929962158,
-0.2839161455631256,
0.6785651445388794,
-0.3862065076828003,
0.09000296890735626,
-0.43881356716156006,
-0.7250719666481018,
-0.13450013101100922,
0.5588166117668152,
-0.5013182759284973,
-0.1388058364391327,
0.6203617453575134,
0.3469681143760681,
-0.05188264325261116,
0.39950093626976013,
0.03738326579332352,
0.4382448196411133,
0.6147130131721497,
0.4143989682197571,
1.3671225309371948,
-0.024933597072958946,
0.4975053369998932,
0.03680974617600441,
-0.19257140159606934,
-0.4081774950027466,
-0.9276375770568848,
-1.3119691610336304,
-0.30788618326187134,
-0.42296701669692993,
-0.3967272937297821,
-0.290010541677475,
1.05998694896698,
0.16003458201885223,
-0.7871376276016235,
-0.6000267267227173,
0.2233845591545105,
0.3112543523311615,
0.1107143759727478,
-0.1387161910533905,
0.4371221661567688,
-0.20122197270393372,
-0.8652342557907104,
0.5158867239952087,
0.36258411407470703,
-0.4385715425014496,
-0.40268415212631226,
0.0998387336730957,
-0.3708873391151428,
0.428571879863739,
0.7221446633338928,
0.13532654941082,
-0.6054198145866394,
-0.12140939384698868,
-0.21494819223880768,
-0.155720055103302,
0.37251266837120056,
0.9416671395301819,
-0.6990564465522766,
0.9366212487220764,
0.7199779748916626,
0.40322262048721313,
1.0724382400512695,
0.11729151755571365,
0.4488397538661957,
-0.13946764171123505,
0.0077987113036215305,
0.2623189091682434,
0.4660518765449524,
0.1868727207183838,
0.33324381709098816,
0.35147133469581604,
-0.1376853734254837,
-0.5710000991821289,
-0.721337616443634,
0.1737757921218872,
-1.1835304498672485,
-0.315165638923645,
1.1465585231781006,
0.0601482130587101,
0.09919542819261551,
-0.27251067757606506,
-0.5865206718444824,
0.10713300853967667,
-0.5125204920768738,
1.0425270795822144,
0.7882512807846069,
-0.048888757824897766,
0.0744561180472374,
-0.4961403012275696,
0.3312847912311554,
0.30290019512176514,
-0.8567326664924622,
0.25483977794647217,
0.5966127514839172,
0.08629219979047775,
0.23225708305835724,
0.7670127749443054,
-0.3325081765651703,
0.0347684770822525,
-0.0890507772564888,
0.02327466942369938,
0.19431257247924805,
-0.34675362706184387,
-0.42199286818504333,
0.4608876407146454,
-0.09272397309541702,
0.1694631576538086
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08004v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08004v1
|
Pix2Pix-OnTheFly: Leveraging LLMs for Instruction-Guided Image Editing
| 2024-03-12T18:12:50 | 2024-03-12T18:12:50 |
Rodrigo Santos, João Silva, António Branco
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV
|
The combination of language processing and image processing keeps attracting
increased interest given recent impressive advances that leverage the combined
strengths of both domains of research. Among these advances, the task of
editing an image on the basis solely of a natural language instruction stands
out as a most challenging endeavour. While recent approaches for this task
resort, in one way or other, to some form of preliminary preparation, training
or fine-tuning, this paper explores a novel approach: We propose a
preparation-free method that permits instruction-guided image editing on the
fly. This approach is organized along three steps properly orchestrated that
resort to image captioning and DDIM inversion, followed by obtaining the edit
direction embedding, followed by image editing proper. While dispensing with
preliminary preparation, our approach demonstrates to be effective and
competitive, outperforming recent, state of the art models for this task when
evaluated on the MAGICBRUSH dataset.
|
[
-0.2316083163022995,
-0.88802570104599,
0.6632024049758911,
0.09727203100919724,
-0.3596016466617584,
0.3724592328071594,
-0.17698535323143005,
-0.12239012867212296,
0.09412847459316254,
0.7834128141403198,
-0.8892691731452942,
-0.6153981685638428,
-0.7777647376060486,
-0.016772083938121796,
-0.3063610792160034,
0.6546235680580139,
-0.17690157890319824,
0.1377539038658142,
-0.31963634490966797,
0.17291989922523499,
-0.6937969326972961,
-0.22404985129833221,
-1.0567587614059448,
0.11717499047517776,
0.48474493622779846,
0.6702905893325806,
0.8557271957397461,
1.0880467891693115,
0.6276454329490662,
0.15624594688415527,
-0.23995338380336761,
0.5942533016204834,
-0.2969825863838196,
0.053431957960128784,
-0.41606810688972473,
-0.6721325516700745,
-0.5240991115570068,
0.08588933944702148,
0.41688504815101624,
0.576575517654419,
0.14988552033901215,
-0.016522586345672607,
-0.04251476377248764,
0.9193123579025269,
-0.9831404089927673,
-0.11363241076469421,
-0.6821532845497131,
0.40497058629989624,
-0.1435568779706955,
-0.51277756690979,
-0.3263494372367859,
-0.19891972839832306,
-0.568527340888977,
-0.9775607585906982,
0.2602497637271881,
0.02311822399497032,
0.4887737035751343,
0.4857751131057739,
-0.13527314364910126,
-0.468582421541214,
-0.4391157031059265,
0.6753671169281006,
-0.3043701648712158,
0.145185649394989,
0.5236297249794006,
0.3352369964122772,
-0.497913122177124,
-0.9671069979667664,
-0.5507002472877502,
0.4308088421821594,
0.19715602695941925,
0.3416202962398529,
-0.17790305614471436,
0.30935558676719666,
0.14330382645130157,
0.2536550462245941,
-0.43517395853996277,
0.4398542046546936,
-0.27620965242385864,
-0.0877552181482315,
0.532733142375946,
0.10160718858242035,
0.5066000819206238,
0.20330710709095,
-0.2855511009693146,
0.018761401996016502,
-0.8338422775268555,
0.018615879118442535,
0.058233462274074554,
0.0675881877541542,
0.02859036810696125,
0.8604702949523926,
0.13975007832050323,
0.8423558473587036,
0.26718828082084656,
-0.01855430006980896,
-0.5020419955253601,
0.21069011092185974,
-0.33280009031295776,
0.07296349108219147,
0.49238914251327515,
0.9126666784286499,
0.06159580126404762,
-0.24945096671581268,
-0.2363712340593338,
-0.10403720289468765,
0.20384261012077332,
-0.9752038717269897,
-0.3242010474205017,
0.2375478297472,
-0.21224087476730347,
-0.14142373204231262,
0.07355962693691254,
-1.0979918241500854,
-0.6364565491676331,
-0.5950446128845215,
0.38043808937072754,
-0.3815179467201233,
0.13082388043403625,
-0.05989150330424309,
-0.2245752215385437,
0.4696585536003113,
0.5172288417816162,
-0.9592664241790771,
0.18082527816295624,
1.0060288906097412,
1.0051785707473755,
-0.132767453789711,
-0.21785204112529755,
-0.6830267310142517,
0.4111748933792114,
-0.7912744283676147,
1.067312479019165,
-0.9395867586135864,
-0.8164700269699097,
-0.23965254426002502,
-0.08325622975826263,
-0.06935545057058334,
-0.39124995470046997,
0.3858310878276825,
-0.9550240635871887,
0.27593904733657837,
-0.07094332575798035,
-1.0235267877578735,
-0.35606682300567627,
-0.025927912443876266,
-0.4281237721443176,
0.6426635384559631,
0.13447439670562744,
-0.5507417321205139,
0.03730010613799095,
-0.9312883615493774,
-0.34553593397140503,
-0.10863300412893295,
-0.3118448257446289,
-0.4298604428768158,
0.07692724466323853,
0.6869373917579651,
0.46984192728996277,
0.19463559985160828,
-0.19808615744113922,
-0.02153380960226059,
-0.824428915977478,
0.12360537797212601,
-0.2562744617462158,
0.7814956307411194,
0.1652318239212036,
-0.36430808901786804,
-0.01855120249092579,
-0.6538631916046143,
0.2944813370704651,
0.18707402050495148,
-0.1860630065202713,
-0.1806727945804596,
-0.1955021172761917,
-0.28632521629333496,
-0.15252041816711426,
0.05822020769119263,
-0.2160916030406952,
0.8689318895339966,
-0.40445923805236816,
0.09658051282167435,
0.8779966235160828,
0.5231232047080994,
0.733378529548645,
0.06770902127027512,
0.7103959918022156,
-0.23866012692451477,
0.3508239984512329,
-0.5708856582641602,
-0.45413830876350403,
-0.9443556070327759,
-0.5005553960800171,
0.03949416056275368,
0.7353973388671875,
-0.9945338368415833,
0.06867215037345886,
-0.07982548326253891,
-0.3975161910057068,
-0.3996712863445282,
0.48836901783943176,
0.5481452345848083,
0.36438485980033875,
0.4372078776359558,
-0.07196883112192154,
-0.5144428610801697,
-0.7104738354682922,
-0.3494284152984619,
0.5734903216362,
-0.06496065109968185,
-0.10147404670715332,
0.04592953622341156,
-0.5029454827308655,
0.9386922717094421,
-0.8335452079772949,
-0.2759740650653839,
-0.03651862591505051,
0.11517941951751709,
0.09798832982778549,
0.710472822189331,
0.520759642124176,
-0.7494186758995056,
-0.6947358846664429,
-0.13017943501472473,
-0.695166826248169,
-0.22301556169986725,
-0.2840105891227722,
-0.5479789972305298,
0.3866598606109619,
0.45578083395957947,
-0.41115784645080566,
0.7166928648948669,
0.39287087321281433,
-0.24561458826065063,
0.20830421149730682,
-0.5007774233818054,
0.5356147885322571,
-0.868621289730072,
-0.30763766169548035,
-0.17895811796188354,
-0.03447014465928078,
-0.619473397731781,
0.3557472825050354,
0.2937665283679962,
-0.1937018185853958,
-0.5781048536300659,
0.5126725435256958,
-0.7914695739746094,
0.03311886638402939,
-0.8940762281417847,
-0.15257978439331055,
0.33210068941116333,
0.621702253818512,
0.14574553072452545,
1.1311677694320679,
0.8567052483558655,
-0.6533963680267334,
0.3828091323375702,
0.22585609555244446,
0.01803554967045784,
0.6344653964042664,
-0.319440096616745,
0.900894284248352,
-0.31786367297172546,
-0.1917712241411209,
-0.863799512386322,
-0.31198057532310486,
0.8150386214256287,
-0.27066174149513245,
0.5733219981193542,
-0.3299071788787842,
-0.507564902305603,
-0.11134213209152222,
-0.40681108832359314,
0.09423914551734924,
0.41603896021842957,
-0.7072445750236511,
0.5407391786575317,
0.06434239447116852,
-0.1156972274184227,
-0.3105676770210266,
-0.7126400470733643,
0.5393146872520447,
-0.0471097007393837,
-0.35093003511428833,
0.5584745407104492,
0.022386722266674042,
-0.3351439833641052,
0.052473630756139755,
-0.09546736627817154,
-0.3019159734249115,
0.06429184973239899,
0.5547097325325012,
0.4564800560474396,
0.1343429982662201,
-0.17040662467479706,
0.5230839848518372,
-0.26112550497055054,
-0.3074384033679962,
-0.11883050203323364,
0.007517494261264801,
0.37541234493255615,
-0.6091724038124084,
-0.8138720393180847,
0.4021350145339966,
0.25868362188339233,
-0.35285326838493347,
0.42608311772346497,
0.323053777217865,
-0.30966266989707947,
-0.2291671633720398,
-0.3545878231525421,
-0.10142216831445694,
-0.5492318272590637,
0.14381219446659088,
-0.19453352689743042,
-0.5197041630744934,
-0.06609403342008591,
-0.13582256436347961,
0.13390664756298065,
-0.0007192639168351889,
0.16385579109191895,
-0.5384734272956848,
0.6502820253372192,
0.737747073173523,
0.3676847517490387,
0.3966614603996277,
-0.5155093669891357,
0.06219608336687088,
-0.855191171169281,
-0.15495017170906067,
-0.1445629894733429,
-0.376011461019516,
-0.16688965260982513,
-0.9215825796127319,
0.5048064589500427,
0.21073926985263824,
0.06919775158166885,
0.11368010938167572,
-0.6709369421005249,
1.0697479248046875,
0.5470816493034363,
0.415292352437973,
0.07392968237400055,
0.31945526599884033,
0.15132330358028412,
-0.3238961696624756,
-0.5255698561668396,
-0.6286593675613403,
1.311827301979065,
-0.30982428789138794,
0.5992582440376282,
-0.2498103529214859,
0.5154951810836792,
0.5122493505477905,
0.28060778975486755,
-0.8041431903839111,
0.9539788961410522,
-0.3128243386745453,
-0.2503044009208679,
-0.03448978811502457,
0.09018117934465408,
-0.9307676553726196,
0.18983834981918335,
-0.20122115314006805,
-0.3757762312889099,
-0.08566218614578247,
0.2803639769554138,
-0.45337268710136414,
0.6270846128463745,
-0.8418498039245605,
0.5097002983093262,
-0.7103772759437561,
-0.7727310061454773,
-0.2594150900840759,
-0.5166550874710083,
0.32112061977386475,
-0.014601806178689003,
0.3463737666606903,
-0.026768634095788002,
-0.6889135837554932,
0.5438803434371948,
-0.4092341661453247,
0.796028196811676,
-0.5606480240821838,
0.05778639391064644,
0.4884885251522064,
0.38945725560188293,
0.28475692868232727,
-0.3250620365142822,
-0.06727717071771622,
-0.04377230256795883,
-0.0933712050318718,
-0.1597461849451065,
-1.1197614669799805,
0.5636295080184937,
-0.5894092321395874,
-0.745452344417572,
-0.2635381519794464,
-0.1776047796010971,
-0.22599932551383972,
0.18682165443897247,
0.06457244604825974,
0.377409964799881,
0.3053387999534607,
-0.2245052605867386,
0.6496953368186951,
-0.44982364773750305,
0.6779006719589233,
0.3481398820877075,
-0.6047056317329407,
-0.8044286966323853,
0.8440788388252258,
0.1795903593301773,
-0.0323607437312603,
0.5518620014190674,
0.17303571105003357,
-0.15292857587337494,
-0.7392165064811707,
-0.517267107963562,
0.01829136535525322,
-0.9693036079406738,
-0.14449304342269897,
-0.3741827607154846,
-0.017445284873247147,
-0.2634831964969635,
-0.6523634195327759,
-0.30716368556022644,
-0.4838096797466278,
-0.5972452163696289,
0.29184815287590027,
0.31912654638290405,
0.5235161781311035,
0.03510473296046257,
0.7593371868133545,
-0.8633890748023987,
0.5077553987503052,
0.47543150186538696,
0.38526827096939087,
-0.28827446699142456,
-0.5505490899085999,
-0.22512905299663544,
0.31673476099967957,
-0.5740922093391418,
-0.8620527386665344,
0.2856447994709015,
0.5292622447013855,
0.6541736721992493,
0.5836105942726135,
-0.09163529425859451,
1.1465283632278442,
-0.4939400255680084,
0.8844270706176758,
0.05851542577147484,
-0.7560415863990784,
1.1111034154891968,
0.06607899814844131,
0.15840880572795868,
0.2712699770927429,
0.3668276369571686,
-0.42000406980514526,
-0.28770342469215393,
-0.32915741205215454,
-0.5993214845657349,
0.7371898293495178,
0.07829082757234573,
0.23362427949905396,
0.34086349606513977,
0.8293842077255249,
0.17539288103580475,
0.18244950473308563,
-0.36968111991882324,
-0.09706395119428635,
-0.36628392338752747,
-0.020831279456615448,
0.08765201270580292,
-0.48393189907073975,
-0.13862814009189606,
-0.5272612571716309,
0.7862530946731567,
0.03660929203033447,
0.41107213497161865,
0.009064040146768093,
-0.14059656858444214,
-0.10705995559692383,
0.07315357774496078,
0.7302411198616028,
0.5798240900039673,
-0.06151912361383438,
0.20977520942687988,
-0.18635492026805878,
-0.564167320728302,
0.20006757974624634,
-0.22264261543750763,
-0.24557088315486908,
-0.19961875677108765,
0.5122051239013672,
0.8614022731781006,
0.3260739743709564,
-0.6569525003433228,
0.45635998249053955,
0.07156182825565338,
-0.23837189376354218,
-0.14750520884990692,
0.5655595064163208,
-0.10969230532646179,
0.04314776510000229,
0.34548479318618774,
0.2701192796230316,
0.13220663368701935,
0.10627205669879913,
-0.10874492675065994,
0.3516649305820465,
0.21013420820236206,
-0.18205320835113525,
0.7229474782943726,
0.046768929809331894,
-0.47792619466781616,
0.6397340297698975,
-0.2866384983062744,
-0.29637375473976135,
0.6080085039138794,
0.37553244829177856,
0.9597868323326111,
0.058743998408317566,
-0.09371931850910187,
0.3652823865413666,
0.21481169760227203,
0.2883422076702118,
0.23006004095077515,
-0.00506165623664856,
-0.4359618127346039,
-0.35597309470176697,
-0.3566049635410309,
-0.7906347513198853,
-0.16235484182834625,
-0.3260018229484558,
0.45890042185783386,
-0.8205083012580872,
0.10831745713949203,
-0.19555360078811646,
-0.27717891335487366,
-0.40398961305618286,
0.25984886288642883,
0.3901151120662689,
1.0023404359817505,
-0.29973164200782776,
0.7511767148971558,
0.9271370768547058,
-0.17155574262142181,
-0.6697350144386292,
0.2044975906610489,
0.2600175738334656,
-0.9462763667106628,
0.45424166321754456,
0.5400773286819458,
-0.24598678946495056,
0.33425283432006836,
-0.842727541923523,
-0.4957968294620514,
1.0758668184280396,
0.3844701647758484,
-0.6131393313407898,
0.10172651708126068,
0.1867283135652542,
0.23269453644752502,
0.029489314183592796,
-0.056782349944114685,
0.3196140229701996,
0.5487672090530396,
0.5608038306236267,
-0.07660816609859467,
-0.36045655608177185,
-0.11609695106744766,
0.42999207973480225,
-0.24241235852241516,
-0.452625036239624,
0.4364231824874878,
-0.38550159335136414,
-0.5017288327217102,
0.03671620413661003,
0.6686491966247559,
-0.11996112018823624,
0.41868799924850464,
0.3766702115535736,
0.4741247892379761,
0.55418461561203,
0.04217977076768875,
0.7491044998168945,
-0.50752854347229,
-0.13282333314418793,
1.1946587562561035,
-0.0793784037232399,
0.8743261694908142,
0.8371895551681519,
-0.38252633810043335,
0.2087049037218094,
0.8957379460334778,
-0.13740891218185425,
0.8019511103630066,
-0.006232728250324726,
-0.37456560134887695,
-0.16236332058906555,
0.31857243180274963,
-0.1046985387802124,
0.6967755556106567,
0.45877349376678467,
-0.10397844761610031,
-0.34597525000572205,
0.43025970458984375,
0.24440622329711914,
0.5519410967826843,
-0.9403122663497925,
0.7394338250160217,
-0.09514100849628448,
-0.7724316120147705,
0.5131932497024536,
0.36907628178596497,
0.8412037491798401,
-0.5785827040672302,
-0.2116246372461319,
-0.565297544002533,
-0.09388703107833862,
-0.4539133310317993,
-1.112046241760254,
0.7118770480155945,
0.3755224347114563,
0.013906572945415974,
-0.3930397927761078,
0.8024804592132568,
-0.19211336970329285,
-0.8131309747695923,
-0.15330453217029572,
0.1854780614376068,
0.19048939645290375,
-0.19800414144992828,
-0.5337704420089722,
0.2866623103618622,
-0.018369702622294426,
-0.2799786627292633,
0.04259798675775528,
0.15991492569446564,
0.23247715830802917,
0.6228185892105103,
0.5813230276107788,
0.19826926290988922,
0.2398867905139923,
-0.27359509468078613,
0.7220005393028259,
-0.4378002882003784,
-0.2650497853755951,
-1.1002146005630493,
0.5244562029838562,
0.012121997773647308,
0.39445436000823975,
0.6999088525772095,
0.6112950444221497,
0.45225510001182556,
-0.5274255871772766,
0.8067519068717957,
0.051307450979948044,
0.30286744236946106,
-1.0061918497085571,
0.6266734004020691,
-0.495482474565506,
0.16112801432609558,
0.02853468805551529,
-0.7519437670707703,
-0.7475116848945618,
0.3661842942237854,
-0.38467204570770264,
-0.3758710026741028,
0.33173811435699463,
1.3680787086486816,
-0.151123508810997,
0.01931273750960827,
0.24204957485198975,
-0.3888944089412689,
0.3740648627281189,
0.3335167467594147,
0.7436846494674683,
-0.14401492476463318,
0.3320772051811218,
-0.6879148483276367,
-0.29791760444641113,
-0.11381128430366516,
-1.2078570127487183,
-0.8208045959472656,
-0.16991956532001495,
-0.6838182210922241,
0.17117159068584442,
0.3696326017379761,
1.182453989982605,
0.39792877435684204,
-0.574371337890625,
0.07253283262252808,
-0.22393837571144104,
0.15594491362571716,
-0.6463825702667236,
-0.15013620257377625,
0.5011888742446899,
-0.35423997044563293,
-0.9663552045822144,
0.5366326570510864,
0.6200214624404907,
0.5272840261459351,
-0.01581035554409027,
-0.15476295351982117,
0.11077746003866196,
0.011103719472885132,
0.4856874346733093,
0.30950480699539185,
-0.5316579937934875,
0.0676027163863182,
-0.04635941609740257,
-0.13733744621276855,
0.17784474790096283,
0.6845279335975647,
-0.396594762802124,
0.7924964427947998,
-0.14244498312473297,
0.9353244304656982,
0.1117638424038887,
-0.04450591281056404,
0.05221884697675705,
-0.7538600564002991,
0.32413503527641296,
-0.13508114218711853,
0.1145372986793518,
0.477714866399765,
-0.5404037833213806,
0.4533340036869049,
0.4629775285720825,
-0.397396445274353,
-0.5950818657875061,
-0.22241052985191345,
-1.0522830486297607,
-0.40029075741767883,
1.2277997732162476,
-0.16135047376155853,
-0.22676469385623932,
0.6176096200942993,
-0.8573119044303894,
0.4472390115261078,
0.14077796041965485,
0.5893286466598511,
0.4020303189754486,
-0.3786601126194,
-0.6007685661315918,
-0.32209375500679016,
0.1535671502351761,
-0.05800338461995125,
-0.8039788603782654,
-0.28686925768852234,
0.7395637035369873,
0.1266341656446457,
-0.31827986240386963,
0.5711841583251953,
-0.048700351268053055,
0.35780268907546997,
-0.07619576901197433,
0.30258768796920776,
-0.7484743595123291,
-0.17427749931812286,
-0.3445172905921936,
0.05417460575699806,
0.32146838307380676,
-0.8196271657943726
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08002v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08002v5
|
Towards a clinically accessible radiology foundation model: open-access and lightweight, with automated evaluation
| 2024-03-12T18:12:02 | 2024-06-27T02:51:29 |
Juan Manuel Zambrano Chaves, Shih-Cheng Huang, Yanbo Xu, Hanwen Xu, Naoto Usuyama, Sheng Zhang, Fei Wang, Yujia Xie, Mahmoud Khademi, Ziyi Yang, Hany Awadalla, Julia Gong, Houdong Hu, Jianwei Yang, Chunyuan Li, Jianfeng Gao, Yu Gu, Cliff Wong, Mu Wei, Tristan Naumann, Muhao Chen, Matthew P. Lungren, Akshay Chaudhari, Serena Yeung-Levy, Curtis P. Langlotz, Sheng Wang, Hoifung Poon
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
The scaling laws and extraordinary performance of large foundation models
motivate the development and utilization of such models in biomedicine.
However, despite early promising results on some biomedical benchmarks, there
are still major challenges that need to be addressed before these models can be
used in real-world clinics. Frontier general-domain models such as GPT-4V still
have significant performance gaps in multimodal biomedical applications. More
importantly, less-acknowledged pragmatic issues, including accessibility, model
cost, and tedious manual evaluation make it hard for clinicians to use
state-of-the-art large models directly on private patient data. Here, we
explore training open-source small multimodal models (SMMs) to bridge
competency gaps for unmet clinical needs in radiology. To maximize data
efficiency, we adopt a modular approach by incorporating state-of-the-art
pre-trained models for image and text modalities, and focusing on training a
lightweight adapter to ground each modality to the text embedding space, as
exemplified by LLaVA-Med. For training, we assemble a large dataset of over 697
thousand radiology image-text pairs. For evaluation, we propose CheXprompt, a
GPT-4-based metric for factuality evaluation, and demonstrate its parity with
expert evaluation. For best practice, we conduct a systematic ablation study on
various choices in data engineering and multimodal training. The resulting
LlaVA-Rad (7B) model attains state-of-the-art results on standard radiology
tasks such as report generation and cross-modal retrieval, even outperforming
much larger models such as GPT-4V and Med-PaLM M (84B). The inference of
LlaVA-Rad is fast and can be performed on a single V100 GPU in private
settings, offering a promising state-of-the-art tool for real-world clinical
applications.
|
[
-0.10452283173799515,
-0.3353659212589264,
0.9199350476264954,
-0.09163745492696762,
-0.3467474579811096,
-0.22734153270721436,
-0.21120651066303253,
-0.5540187954902649,
-0.25426381826400757,
0.36831700801849365,
-0.33592453598976135,
-0.47313183546066284,
-0.795344352722168,
0.1174544245004654,
-0.07697911560535431,
0.7519015669822693,
-0.083208829164505,
0.45118021965026855,
-0.38527175784111023,
-0.4626758098602295,
-0.2888554036617279,
-0.12773992121219635,
-0.15263070166110992,
-0.3787209093570709,
0.37342122197151184,
0.22194699943065643,
1.0430586338043213,
0.7737826704978943,
0.814603865146637,
0.3085465729236603,
0.13476021587848663,
-0.017792899161577225,
-0.2877114415168762,
-0.11798615008592606,
-0.2599925994873047,
-0.07476504147052765,
-0.5722335577011108,
-0.12421969324350357,
0.6131560206413269,
0.8876678347587585,
-0.05226292833685875,
-0.19729304313659668,
-0.4745926260948181,
0.6437540054321289,
-0.668967068195343,
0.13803085684776306,
-0.34355443716049194,
-0.061871014535427094,
-0.2612190246582031,
-0.1505603939294815,
-0.3793173134326935,
-0.3701356053352356,
0.17978592216968536,
-0.4314027428627014,
0.2163168489933014,
-0.21609251201152802,
0.7856333255767822,
0.14179986715316772,
-0.4906034767627716,
-0.4641885459423065,
-0.5678567886352539,
0.5872336030006409,
-0.48665735125541687,
0.7415223121643066,
0.24653729796409607,
0.7348567843437195,
0.07624568045139313,
-1.039441466331482,
-0.032682377845048904,
-0.3389504551887512,
-0.2538997232913971,
0.14137640595436096,
-0.2830973267555237,
0.3578697144985199,
0.11299674212932587,
0.6599828600883484,
-0.644794762134552,
-0.08231918513774872,
-0.4344683885574341,
-0.1422758847475052,
0.3400464951992035,
0.21804910898208618,
0.22536379098892212,
-0.22734001278877258,
-0.3890584409236908,
0.06628813594579697,
-0.6398075222969055,
-0.3168103098869324,
-0.25470107793807983,
0.179635688662529,
-0.1601681262254715,
0.6409649848937988,
-0.2991321384906769,
0.5054476261138916,
0.05233294144272804,
-0.3569079637527466,
0.4373697340488434,
-0.4684535264968872,
-0.46559035778045654,
-0.20250444114208221,
0.5046499967575073,
-0.23534324765205383,
-0.22913986444473267,
-0.1485978364944458,
-0.17131932079792023,
0.2066100537776947,
0.2942790389060974,
-0.8640212416648865,
-0.2447604089975357,
0.41175949573516846,
-0.7020411491394043,
-0.31377658247947693,
-0.26377102732658386,
-0.5671566724777222,
-0.4377067983150482,
-0.24578222632408142,
0.8437632322311401,
-0.6510942578315735,
-0.30025768280029297,
0.3917064964771271,
0.2027447521686554,
-0.13528044521808624,
0.5636398196220398,
-0.6946631669998169,
0.36668726801872253,
0.2772452235221863,
0.9543156623840332,
0.2915065586566925,
0.16758033633232117,
-0.40471482276916504,
0.24297687411308289,
0.045311909168958664,
0.6129693984985352,
-0.5853966474533081,
-0.3896370232105255,
-0.3356001377105713,
0.09219177067279816,
-0.3079652190208435,
-0.3791489601135254,
0.31607890129089355,
-0.4307873845100403,
0.19419705867767334,
-0.0797870084643364,
-0.14396131038665771,
-0.1345665007829666,
0.21464338898658752,
-0.7145768404006958,
0.4847131371498108,
0.36213940382003784,
-0.753104567527771,
0.2405271828174591,
-0.7368531823158264,
-0.2140003889799118,
0.09285791963338852,
-0.567001223564148,
-0.550532877445221,
0.1296531856060028,
0.30997809767723083,
0.4863673150539398,
-0.5179508328437805,
0.27586209774017334,
-0.272341787815094,
-0.1165323331952095,
0.08691926300525665,
-0.1369231939315796,
0.6232334971427917,
0.40989214181900024,
-0.17605285346508026,
0.2827548682689667,
-0.6925187706947327,
-0.09601006656885147,
-0.003957018721848726,
-0.18836858868598938,
-0.31316497921943665,
-0.49204137921333313,
-0.005608392413705587,
0.3107373118400574,
-0.1434902846813202,
-0.5837530493736267,
0.010218863375484943,
-0.2610664963722229,
0.3714325428009033,
0.6632153987884521,
-0.19404974579811096,
0.3421795666217804,
-0.4933592677116394,
0.5625309348106384,
0.10160019993782043,
0.42168498039245605,
-0.1755998134613037,
-0.496429979801178,
-0.22908401489257812,
-1.0783573389053345,
0.4401090741157532,
0.15716488659381866,
-0.698049008846283,
-0.23326927423477173,
-0.4246189296245575,
-0.6177020072937012,
-0.7045310139656067,
-0.0071793547831475735,
0.43751028180122375,
0.5024983882904053,
0.24984818696975708,
-0.5764127969741821,
-0.18460288643836975,
-0.9540539383888245,
0.15099509060382843,
0.21611471474170685,
-0.05071117356419563,
0.48240113258361816,
0.5906121730804443,
-0.5275894999504089,
0.6684073805809021,
-0.3683117628097534,
-0.5618084669113159,
-0.1638038009405136,
0.08250685781240463,
0.151519313454628,
0.4029315710067749,
0.34349325299263,
-0.8262423872947693,
-0.23361694812774658,
0.41285741329193115,
-1.0421243906021118,
0.039239123463630676,
0.09158706665039062,
0.07023734599351883,
-0.033261388540267944,
0.2589569389820099,
-0.4585970640182495,
0.4936565160751343,
0.5957444310188293,
-0.040090516209602356,
0.11411912739276886,
-0.49196451902389526,
0.45988914370536804,
-0.7076123952865601,
0.3781765401363373,
-0.06319210678339005,
-0.485735684633255,
-0.43832170963287354,
0.18017753958702087,
0.3371591866016388,
-0.40807512402534485,
-0.45104822516441345,
0.48227715492248535,
-0.7161158323287964,
-0.4103659987449646,
-0.009119008667767048,
-0.18349392712116241,
0.03929435461759567,
0.10811907052993774,
0.3044041693210602,
0.4704127013683319,
0.45096373558044434,
-0.2151821404695511,
-0.024818312376737595,
0.2132871448993683,
-0.33476072549819946,
0.4711766242980957,
-0.5296281576156616,
0.21676014363765717,
-0.32867705821990967,
0.2522268295288086,
-0.8178044557571411,
-0.5426633358001709,
0.03230065107345581,
-0.26111742854118347,
0.4989708364009857,
-0.3652283251285553,
-0.11734797060489655,
-0.18092453479766846,
-0.20405204594135284,
0.6848288774490356,
0.4802318811416626,
-0.36373433470726013,
0.8623323440551758,
0.308203786611557,
-0.12006732076406479,
-0.6243001222610474,
-0.6011224389076233,
-0.08800836652517319,
0.12761573493480682,
-1.0009385347366333,
0.21185414493083954,
-0.03823809325695038,
-0.1605793684720993,
0.19118641316890717,
-0.04386472702026367,
-0.3900716304779053,
-0.11509423702955246,
0.4620509743690491,
0.1331424117088318,
-0.33162760734558105,
-0.010533872991800308,
-0.022782573476433754,
-0.21616996824741364,
-0.23090676963329315,
-0.10059557855129242,
0.08665972203016281,
-0.4426216185092926,
-0.5689690709114075,
-0.30635786056518555,
0.2676789164543152,
0.552670955657959,
-0.05333000794053078,
0.3791798949241638,
0.5811529755592346,
-0.7178734540939331,
0.08299840986728668,
-0.6052089333534241,
-0.1050795242190361,
-0.42048734426498413,
0.38543277978897095,
-0.42571088671684265,
-0.9592247605323792,
0.19915400445461273,
-0.34056660532951355,
-0.07323452830314636,
0.24682307243347168,
0.9798633456230164,
0.1205819696187973,
0.7940291166305542,
0.6952276229858398,
0.6175537109375,
0.029384570196270943,
-0.19615893065929413,
-0.15522554516792297,
-0.5215049982070923,
-0.43357136845588684,
-0.3902498185634613,
0.06471730023622513,
-0.2301207184791565,
-0.7843649387359619,
0.8029378056526184,
-0.3415631651878357,
0.10113726556301117,
-0.09717506915330887,
-0.35316628217697144,
0.3952449560165405,
0.04270026832818985,
0.48542746901512146,
0.5734500288963318,
-0.05954628065228462,
-0.17106662690639496,
-0.16197343170642853,
-0.871895968914032,
-0.25297585129737854,
1.357095718383789,
0.6186438798904419,
0.9112575650215149,
0.11636035144329071,
0.5977524518966675,
0.34377267956733704,
0.7299124002456665,
-0.6457743644714355,
0.19923564791679382,
-0.278425008058548,
-0.7659828662872314,
0.007830184884369373,
-0.34376057982444763,
-0.7777310013771057,
0.3432747423648834,
-0.2648521363735199,
-0.21660162508487701,
0.43420612812042236,
0.20464037358760834,
-0.44214579463005066,
0.16727302968502045,
-0.5391548871994019,
0.9788036942481995,
-0.11226940155029297,
-0.5198389887809753,
-0.23753593862056732,
-0.7196162343025208,
0.772500216960907,
-0.2532687187194824,
0.7717037796974182,
-0.111042320728302,
-0.09902521222829819,
0.16998229920864105,
-0.4922940135002136,
0.7120610475540161,
-0.13572995364665985,
0.272734135389328,
-0.08012120425701141,
0.06898421049118042,
0.15298080444335938,
0.15077725052833557,
0.2063644677400589,
0.22752754390239716,
0.14447157084941864,
-0.5010735988616943,
-0.3624296486377716,
0.7769411206245422,
-1.0163241624832153,
-0.09080690890550613,
-0.738966166973114,
-0.5521299242973328,
-0.36343076825141907,
0.16407351195812225,
0.20989306271076202,
0.8546526432037354,
-0.24549001455307007,
0.3042135536670685,
0.8407496213912964,
-0.3381572365760803,
-0.11673516780138016,
0.4699273109436035,
-0.02176811918616295,
-0.6310356259346008,
0.7166098952293396,
-0.09116149693727493,
0.4723304808139801,
0.4162493944168091,
0.3941774070262909,
-0.25557124614715576,
-0.7795754075050354,
-0.5700371861457825,
0.36449065804481506,
-0.9168521761894226,
-0.24754028022289276,
-0.7315319180488586,
-0.15156567096710205,
-0.39654526114463806,
-0.4007856249809265,
-0.6115338802337646,
-0.3236861824989319,
0.1065070703625679,
0.25073936581611633,
0.1983112245798111,
0.767816960811615,
-0.3772777020931244,
0.2777411937713623,
-0.6985293030738831,
0.3585343658924103,
0.16709868609905243,
0.3706341087818146,
-0.2110253870487213,
-0.5114453434944153,
-0.4656943678855896,
-0.430152028799057,
-0.11171803623437881,
-0.6287506222724915,
0.21347062289714813,
0.06724027544260025,
0.33529627323150635,
0.2968793511390686,
-0.22547617554664612,
0.44703999161720276,
-0.3971376121044159,
0.3256799876689911,
0.3186344504356384,
-0.7538387179374695,
0.4105226695537567,
-0.5482621192932129,
0.20410645008087158,
0.7000595927238464,
0.526089608669281,
-0.19574208557605743,
-0.0012201970675960183,
-0.55342036485672,
-0.6970486640930176,
0.5304701328277588,
0.2378498613834381,
-0.32956433296203613,
0.059297531843185425,
0.2713693678379059,
0.4260985851287842,
0.20990943908691406,
-0.7271190285682678,
0.12200663983821869,
-0.35039693117141724,
-0.3878949284553528,
0.2186143398284912,
-0.03468210622668266,
-0.43933162093162537,
-0.03915998712182045,
0.5306481122970581,
-0.3661823272705078,
0.6382076144218445,
0.33942708373069763,
-0.3625016212463379,
-0.17068371176719666,
0.2744126617908478,
0.5972657799720764,
0.8628907799720764,
-0.49070197343826294,
0.13194367289543152,
-0.08132508397102356,
-0.688327431678772,
0.13471870124340057,
0.06029488146305084,
0.16538314521312714,
-0.0036955869290977716,
0.3001779317855835,
0.5018535256385803,
0.5241119265556335,
-0.6646348237991333,
0.8825663924217224,
-0.153507262468338,
-0.37056976556777954,
-0.16246363520622253,
-0.2388104796409607,
0.0032903202809393406,
0.2696155309677124,
0.07316724956035614,
0.3176983594894409,
0.2676785886287689,
-0.37718233466148376,
0.32216987013816833,
0.34777048230171204,
-0.5040090084075928,
-0.3334922790527344,
0.9442252516746521,
0.13355033099651337,
0.4038500189781189,
0.3941479027271271,
0.314157634973526,
0.21736609935760498,
0.3306243121623993,
0.33006131649017334,
0.6739776730537415,
-0.1706974059343338,
0.1617068648338318,
0.25872528553009033,
0.4250999391078949,
-0.24477067589759827,
0.2274746298789978,
0.2024572193622589,
-0.4065469205379486,
-0.5293252468109131,
-0.34489473700523376,
-0.5243977308273315,
0.1533822864294052,
-0.557263195514679,
0.44460543990135193,
-0.8444825410842896,
-0.12389630079269409,
0.05931511148810387,
-0.19937355816364288,
-0.8096892833709717,
0.5719560384750366,
0.149267315864563,
0.941167414188385,
-0.801239013671875,
0.9987103343009949,
0.5407369136810303,
-0.4904005527496338,
-0.5063400864601135,
-0.5918084383010864,
0.1396261602640152,
-0.9310520887374878,
0.4094308316707611,
0.09966890513896942,
0.09040061384439468,
-0.1566421240568161,
-0.23975537717342377,
-0.7170934081077576,
1.427413821220398,
0.41145986318588257,
-0.3471311032772064,
-0.26195627450942993,
-0.0032970404718071222,
0.33511245250701904,
-0.34186139702796936,
0.5450355410575867,
0.31284838914871216,
0.19424106180667877,
0.2798924446105957,
-0.9836537837982178,
0.27835050225257874,
0.0027575537096709013,
-0.11749319732189178,
0.07777512818574905,
-0.5851729512214661,
0.8670524954795837,
-0.35872212052345276,
0.01158198807388544,
0.15423814952373505,
0.3952057361602783,
0.1780933141708374,
0.5324717164039612,
0.42591506242752075,
0.5504381656646729,
0.6614311933517456,
-0.04512938857078552,
1.2783148288726807,
-0.1100870743393898,
0.3213775157928467,
0.579404354095459,
-0.3091166913509369,
0.3608032763004303,
0.25820574164390564,
-0.07122103124856949,
0.296924889087677,
0.31765440106391907,
0.23063595592975616,
0.6979132890701294,
-0.1872057169675827,
-0.4965396821498871,
-0.39393699169158936,
-0.018971659243106842,
-0.5853573083877563,
0.2625352442264557,
0.4223138988018036,
-0.42219051718711853,
-0.4300428330898285,
0.28911885619163513,
-0.056558407843112946,
-0.07220624387264252,
-0.4486168324947357,
0.492502897977829,
0.32939210534095764,
0.015058724209666252,
0.41979995369911194,
0.21514476835727692,
0.4143417775630951,
-1.1029260158538818,
0.12671299278736115,
-0.20297971367835999,
0.38770079612731934,
-0.45644471049308777,
-0.20068766176700592,
0.40221914649009705,
-0.16070520877838135,
-0.009162187576293945,
-0.10951834172010422,
0.9234000444412231,
-0.15763163566589355,
-0.3236534297466278,
0.06999025493860245,
0.5063791871070862,
0.19908633828163147,
0.2232518494129181,
-0.47299471497535706,
0.41704055666923523,
-0.169173002243042,
-0.17530198395252228,
0.7671583890914917,
0.3409893214702606,
-0.216269388794899,
0.5797718167304993,
0.534109354019165,
0.013675673864781857,
-0.3467974364757538,
-0.14062152802944183,
1.0869261026382446,
-0.48731493949890137,
-0.34500065445899963,
-0.44589731097221375,
0.4529970586299896,
0.284186989068985,
-0.24256093800067902,
0.21121352910995483,
0.4346097409725189,
0.5064751505851746,
-0.09149233996868134,
0.8533191084861755,
-0.02417168579995632,
0.46386387944221497,
-0.6547160744667053,
0.5939546227455139,
-0.5903249979019165,
0.11831670254468918,
-0.3241104483604431,
-0.34894004464149475,
-0.40992218255996704,
0.7205460071563721,
-0.4225706458091736,
0.15274041891098022,
0.830237627029419,
0.6810820698738098,
-0.40098464488983154,
0.11733192950487137,
0.5751345157623291,
0.2587454319000244,
0.27753570675849915,
0.7458364963531494,
0.5606595873832703,
-0.35434240102767944,
0.47254613041877747,
-0.3069237768650055,
-0.5868176817893982,
-0.19040682911872864,
-0.926984965801239,
-0.7495290637016296,
-0.329828143119812,
-0.3843570351600647,
-0.5703827738761902,
0.25797420740127563,
0.9270691871643066,
0.8648441433906555,
-0.42929837107658386,
-0.1065887063741684,
0.37584188580513,
-0.2103496640920639,
-0.08086247742176056,
-0.06349445134401321,
0.5508939027786255,
0.007770502474159002,
-0.3951197862625122,
0.5554641485214233,
0.5034880638122559,
-0.03962893411517143,
-0.24884888529777527,
0.05710512772202492,
-0.0027789906598627567,
-0.06968246400356293,
0.5014135837554932,
0.3465389013290405,
-0.44776010513305664,
-0.19070373475551605,
-0.058811403810977936,
-0.3236878514289856,
0.15351349115371704,
0.8564267158508301,
-0.8412171602249146,
0.698814332485199,
0.2558209300041199,
0.8430079817771912,
0.6778724193572998,
-0.11512443423271179,
0.4256654381752014,
-0.4602692127227783,
0.2905940115451813,
0.3869214355945587,
0.2828347980976105,
0.4857678711414337,
-0.3447742760181427,
0.49855294823646545,
0.5438499450683594,
-0.6419750452041626,
-0.9231868386268616,
0.12319955229759216,
-1.1043564081192017,
-0.24175406992435455,
0.9441959261894226,
-0.2717779278755188,
-0.22729499638080597,
-0.28349408507347107,
-0.03149881586432457,
-0.10448330640792847,
-0.05967359617352486,
0.5089446902275085,
0.3220932185649872,
-0.3877502381801605,
-0.184489443898201,
-0.7329423427581787,
0.52681565284729,
0.0644669383764267,
-0.7610722780227661,
-0.27481111884117126,
0.7594497799873352,
0.7558823227882385,
-0.19590891897678375,
1.4005523920059204,
-0.6559075117111206,
0.7024390697479248,
0.026455894112586975,
0.13751040399074554,
-0.4763467311859131,
-0.4532052278518677,
-0.584337055683136,
0.3805789351463318,
0.21737365424633026,
0.11587758362293243
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07872v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07872v1
|
Rethinking Generative Large Language Model Evaluation for Semantic Comprehension
| 2024-03-12T17:59:48 | 2024-03-12T17:59:48 |
Fangyun Wei, Xi Chen, Lin Luo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite their sophisticated capabilities, large language models (LLMs)
encounter a major hurdle in effective assessment. This paper first revisits the
prevalent evaluation method-multiple choice question answering (MCQA), which
allows for straightforward accuracy measurement. Through a comprehensive
evaluation of 24 models across 11 benchmarks, we highlight several potential
drawbacks of MCQA, for instance, the inconsistency between the MCQA evaluation
and the generation of open-ended responses in practical scenarios. In response,
we introduce an RWQ-Elo rating system, engaging 24 LLMs such as GPT-4, GPT-3.5,
Google-Gemini-Pro and LLaMA-1/-2, in a two-player competitive format, with
GPT-4 serving as the judge. Each LLM receives an Elo rating thereafter. This
system is designed to mirror real-world usage, and for this purpose, we have
compiled a new benchmark called ``Real-world questions'' (RWQ), comprising
20,772 authentic user inquiries. Additionally, we thoroughly analyze the
characteristics of our system and compare it with prior leaderboards like
AlpacaEval and MT-Bench. Our analysis reveals the stability of our RWQ-Elo
system, the feasibility of registering new models, and its potential to reshape
LLM leaderboards.
|
[
-0.4999908208847046,
-0.9695138931274414,
0.7717864513397217,
0.1433161050081253,
-0.08788465708494186,
0.13234896957874298,
-0.27339863777160645,
-0.553796112537384,
-0.2603049874305725,
0.5978866815567017,
-0.6577509045600891,
-0.49082690477371216,
-0.5390058755874634,
0.21724335849285126,
-0.5340758562088013,
0.7419427633285522,
-0.03947949782013893,
-0.12790115177631378,
-0.4402192533016205,
-0.29970496892929077,
-0.5279662609100342,
-0.36891970038414,
-0.62034010887146,
-0.43444007635116577,
0.6818335056304932,
0.27811399102211,
0.9522519707679749,
0.24120622873306274,
0.3259713053703308,
0.33157163858413696,
-0.2592213451862335,
0.16137659549713135,
-0.49376410245895386,
0.18396112322807312,
-0.15244747698307037,
-0.43926841020584106,
-0.46369996666908264,
0.01549325417727232,
0.5550658702850342,
0.6710633039474487,
-0.37486937642097473,
0.2370186746120453,
-0.04114348813891411,
0.48546093702316284,
-0.5800282955169678,
-0.0240467581897974,
-0.8407490849494934,
0.10210487991571426,
0.21526026725769043,
0.04838631674647331,
-0.6583065390586853,
-0.06863011419773102,
0.24622616171836853,
-0.7244220972061157,
-0.021418124437332153,
0.03221483156085014,
0.7751310467720032,
0.14700579643249512,
-0.5982963442802429,
-0.3233776092529297,
-0.5746370553970337,
0.8554728627204895,
-0.7682851552963257,
0.5161583423614502,
0.22046281397342682,
0.5855628252029419,
-0.1681106984615326,
-0.7157305479049683,
-0.714635968208313,
-0.5769173502922058,
0.34252142906188965,
0.4357829689979553,
-0.06090300902724266,
-0.03670214116573334,
0.19395805895328522,
0.3270912170410156,
-0.6852081418037415,
0.39745479822158813,
-0.16362936794757843,
-0.16825193166732788,
0.6051245927810669,
0.43533360958099365,
0.31423693895339966,
-0.13929301500320435,
-0.3866460919380188,
-0.11577384918928146,
-0.6788288950920105,
-0.11997250467538834,
0.30599045753479004,
0.056943535804748535,
0.2317373901605606,
0.7675329446792603,
-0.46420231461524963,
0.8667736649513245,
-0.3356963098049164,
-0.22845609486103058,
0.1710183024406433,
-0.19044101238250732,
-0.29536229372024536,
-0.47375544905662537,
0.8140550851821899,
0.534231424331665,
0.489176869392395,
-0.15769024193286896,
-0.2809607982635498,
0.042821820825338364,
0.35405081510543823,
-0.6708120107650757,
0.0023563371505588293,
0.47170743346214294,
-0.2313443273305893,
-0.1681356132030487,
-0.018712233752012253,
-0.5835667848587036,
-0.1986946314573288,
-0.28453391790390015,
0.519884467124939,
-0.24444915354251862,
-0.23675815761089325,
0.2845768928527832,
-0.018727079033851624,
0.418567031621933,
0.53461754322052,
-0.6765579581260681,
0.2235395461320877,
0.8688451051712036,
0.5822142958641052,
-0.17049717903137207,
-0.5571464896202087,
-0.3179793953895569,
-0.14801938831806183,
-0.21664543449878693,
0.7471076250076294,
-0.47764113545417786,
-0.2851159870624542,
0.010989733040332794,
-0.14291875064373016,
-0.2394964098930359,
-0.7069370150566101,
0.6198858618736267,
-0.9058917164802551,
0.25461435317993164,
-0.21057429909706116,
-0.5410594344139099,
-0.04057566449046135,
0.7540425658226013,
-0.5905165076255798,
1.0321816205978394,
0.03713907673954964,
-0.683310866355896,
0.2720441222190857,
-0.432099312543869,
0.04831556975841522,
0.07721716910600662,
-0.007846184074878693,
-0.07296517491340637,
0.02956538088619709,
0.4212280511856079,
0.39031296968460083,
-0.340156227350235,
0.27769356966018677,
-0.27902504801750183,
-0.45944827795028687,
0.4260886013507843,
-0.6521595120429993,
0.6596457958221436,
0.20495343208312988,
-0.015465675853192806,
0.21871885657310486,
-0.7651017308235168,
0.45845744013786316,
0.047310970723629,
-0.40367645025253296,
-0.018473554402589798,
-0.0008844336261972785,
-0.0869036316871643,
0.4614675045013428,
0.007560550235211849,
-0.6074691414833069,
-0.17435245215892792,
-0.4767676293849945,
0.5817696452140808,
0.7950326204299927,
-0.08096589148044586,
0.10783139616250992,
-0.3858735263347626,
0.8463528156280518,
-0.25432783365249634,
0.26516568660736084,
0.142960786819458,
-0.6095255613327026,
-0.7048612236976624,
-0.20205797255039215,
0.43559786677360535,
0.6005309224128723,
-0.8330972194671631,
0.2450082153081894,
-0.4871196448802948,
-0.6657102704048157,
-0.5637590289115906,
0.05808493122458458,
0.2828513979911804,
0.4323686361312866,
0.3281228542327881,
-0.11396193504333496,
-0.05023139342665672,
-0.7498117685317993,
-0.29713377356529236,
-0.3301587998867035,
-0.2407827079296112,
0.41299599409103394,
0.6885895729064941,
-0.27071550488471985,
0.7110831141471863,
-0.27890369296073914,
0.15329191088676453,
-0.2746921181678772,
-0.05532147362828255,
0.17529161274433136,
0.09697091579437256,
0.183263897895813,
-0.6590223908424377,
-0.23336049914360046,
-0.030318547040224075,
-0.7075905203819275,
-0.06089449301362038,
0.08708725869655609,
-0.12106267362833023,
-0.009622332639992237,
0.4090562164783478,
-0.8048418760299683,
0.03098176047205925,
0.8491615056991577,
-0.23200270533561707,
0.8270236849784851,
-0.1087363064289093,
0.2016659379005432,
-0.7672542929649353,
0.08803510665893555,
-0.2765306532382965,
-0.061007555574178696,
-0.3436024487018585,
0.6396459937095642,
0.05451265722513199,
-0.06027359142899513,
-0.6583467721939087,
0.6796401739120483,
-0.23684172332286835,
-0.22073587775230408,
-0.07649213075637817,
0.6977314352989197,
0.20313173532485962,
0.2015085220336914,
-0.29699504375457764,
0.672507643699646,
0.1620049625635147,
-0.5163259506225586,
0.6144912838935852,
0.24640728533267975,
-0.7472499012947083,
0.5248265266418457,
-0.9220207929611206,
0.24450060725212097,
-0.23905369639396667,
0.42779579758644104,
-1.1825878620147705,
-0.06430868804454803,
0.007731530349701643,
-0.5404866933822632,
-0.10559684038162231,
-0.043296802788972855,
-0.58784419298172,
-0.3784940838813782,
-0.23412664234638214,
0.432372510433197,
0.3155696392059326,
-0.5749752521514893,
0.5790484547615051,
0.20352928340435028,
-0.04575319215655327,
-0.7423442602157593,
-0.47408151626586914,
0.18857859075069427,
-0.28599897027015686,
-0.9053353071212769,
0.18766027688980103,
-0.19309160113334656,
-0.3807275593280792,
-0.08143370598554611,
-0.041166577488183975,
0.1591375470161438,
0.4355715215206146,
0.02534542605280876,
0.29969730973243713,
-0.24577586352825165,
0.24437232315540314,
-0.11079826205968857,
-0.0980999693274498,
0.21687425673007965,
0.04169372469186783,
0.5229904651641846,
-0.072260782122612,
-0.4809272885322571,
-0.17185938358306885,
0.21579261124134064,
0.7185961008071899,
-0.4587292969226837,
0.6748981475830078,
0.4567059576511383,
-0.22613438963890076,
-0.41597723960876465,
-0.5225059390068054,
0.03958459571003914,
-0.4136759638786316,
0.5063052177429199,
-0.7954674363136292,
-1.1884920597076416,
0.6735605001449585,
0.1138601079583168,
0.23689956963062286,
0.7669320106506348,
0.7303082346916199,
-0.036038823425769806,
1.1858577728271484,
0.163363978266716,
0.3358759880065918,
0.12752333283424377,
-0.06203417852520943,
0.07093894481658936,
-1.1213268041610718,
-0.2594321668148041,
-0.5577254891395569,
-0.04688282310962677,
-0.545018196105957,
-0.35796165466308594,
0.2657862901687622,
0.11008501797914505,
-0.3052852749824524,
0.0869336649775505,
-0.2346259355545044,
0.4792589843273163,
0.14708128571510315,
0.09660829603672028,
0.5534100532531738,
-0.26903584599494934,
-0.4272952675819397,
0.014373769983649254,
-0.6569320559501648,
-0.8326748013496399,
1.0793293714523315,
0.5900444388389587,
0.7765819430351257,
0.2690003514289856,
0.43221569061279297,
0.16216006875038147,
0.6661652326583862,
-1.154423713684082,
0.6480211615562439,
0.16309858858585358,
-0.6634485125541687,
-0.5752401947975159,
-0.5517003536224365,
-0.8298317193984985,
0.9351252317428589,
-0.24857504665851593,
-0.605691134929657,
-0.2408304512500763,
-0.16823837161064148,
-0.3991101384162903,
0.00010690998169593513,
-0.6443554162979126,
0.9389329552650452,
-0.06163429841399193,
-0.13763512670993805,
-0.053034838289022446,
-0.4484710693359375,
0.6708669066429138,
-0.09070324152708054,
0.36584627628326416,
-0.22628521919250488,
-0.02127118781208992,
0.7578877210617065,
-0.37864112854003906,
0.48671919107437134,
0.05586016923189163,
-0.35762470960617065,
0.3817823529243469,
-0.018515709787607193,
0.34859344363212585,
0.23737189173698425,
-0.2847483456134796,
-0.19141992926597595,
0.31893518567085266,
-0.410666823387146,
-0.7864027619361877,
0.7581014633178711,
-0.7519621253013611,
-0.6994206309318542,
-0.3871750831604004,
-0.4268147945404053,
-0.5809932351112366,
-0.04891498014330864,
0.011979935690760612,
0.37922677397727966,
-0.3258453607559204,
0.1689048707485199,
0.5553308725357056,
-0.37042370438575745,
0.12294847518205643,
0.43932193517684937,
-0.382081538438797,
-0.4669052064418793,
0.541797935962677,
0.08954843133687973,
0.6076666712760925,
0.333173006772995,
0.2771930396556854,
-0.4790095388889313,
-0.6162023544311523,
-0.7212330102920532,
0.26854100823402405,
-0.9421413540840149,
-0.04324927553534508,
-0.7392210364341736,
-0.1785537600517273,
-0.20721100270748138,
0.22936862707138062,
-0.22253134846687317,
-0.26860591769218445,
-0.06682110577821732,
-0.22818008065223694,
-0.08439850062131882,
0.735435962677002,
0.4902958273887634,
0.13144080340862274,
-0.7700437307357788,
0.18285752832889557,
0.6159451007843018,
0.2503250539302826,
0.3273938000202179,
-0.8461008667945862,
0.0051750242710113525,
0.02318197675049305,
-0.24414286017417908,
-0.7034980058670044,
0.028115589171648026,
0.0914807990193367,
0.800234854221344,
0.02191455289721489,
0.08264575153589249,
0.7135889530181885,
-0.5903806090354919,
0.7699363231658936,
-0.09687678515911102,
-0.9614235162734985,
0.20647433400154114,
-0.2475796788930893,
0.4194130301475525,
0.606313943862915,
0.2456430196762085,
-0.706451952457428,
-0.5187710523605347,
-0.5626260638237,
-0.7879261374473572,
0.32454973459243774,
-0.03243821859359741,
0.37143296003341675,
-0.1965576708316803,
0.4008433520793915,
0.021237265318632126,
-0.021601654589176178,
-0.7587200999259949,
0.11577020585536957,
-0.07502424716949463,
-0.19924843311309814,
-0.030773699283599854,
-0.4186336398124695,
-0.014657150954008102,
-0.002333724405616522,
0.6147027611732483,
-0.18847133219242096,
0.041581060737371445,
0.15252409875392914,
-0.23549784719944,
0.12959957122802734,
0.5931606292724609,
0.5858548283576965,
1.0940674543380737,
-0.10562935471534729,
0.14454738795757294,
0.36580076813697815,
-0.2507426142692566,
0.05422690138220787,
-0.1645415872335434,
0.02055944874882698,
-0.2934688627719879,
0.6427577137947083,
0.5382882356643677,
0.1471407562494278,
-1.076542615890503,
0.4524085223674774,
-0.12491832673549652,
-0.3869737386703491,
-0.17118117213249207,
0.05402884632349014,
0.2871290445327759,
0.06981249898672104,
0.19167853891849518,
-0.4345415532588959,
0.042068444192409515,
-0.8300641775131226,
0.15114741027355194,
0.4702130854129791,
-0.33983445167541504,
-0.07889264076948166,
0.5113661885261536,
0.14196960628032684,
-0.10080257803201675,
0.7716488242149353,
-0.056066062301397324,
-0.6929817795753479,
0.5809118151664734,
0.5567763447761536,
0.5031160116195679,
-0.20366983115673065,
0.3421635627746582,
0.38497617840766907,
0.5396198630332947,
-0.14996367692947388,
0.274224191904068,
0.016943922266364098,
-0.9229419827461243,
-0.7835191488265991,
-0.762503981590271,
-0.6544061303138733,
0.1540820151567459,
-0.6875957250595093,
-0.08016860485076904,
-0.32085347175598145,
-0.18414320051670074,
0.007043797988444567,
0.027332311496138573,
-0.5680912733078003,
0.4549207389354706,
-0.00150396884419024,
1.1292080879211426,
-0.8442050814628601,
0.663440465927124,
0.6295077800750732,
-0.12286575883626938,
-0.6220079064369202,
-0.12672637403011322,
-0.26066333055496216,
-0.9369721412658691,
0.5695806741714478,
0.15840552747249603,
-0.01843808777630329,
0.03376269340515137,
-0.3374505639076233,
-0.7328616976737976,
1.1876258850097656,
0.05093397572636604,
-0.512961208820343,
0.11147759854793549,
-0.019061287865042686,
0.7025026082992554,
-0.3275173008441925,
0.47442445158958435,
0.7147758603096008,
0.45404958724975586,
0.16021588444709778,
-1.0052417516708374,
0.08286668360233307,
-0.07567217946052551,
0.09972705692052841,
0.07333574444055557,
-0.5135611891746521,
0.7160581946372986,
-0.2961249351501465,
-0.3090953230857849,
0.33419376611709595,
0.5343870520591736,
0.6024794578552246,
0.10620765388011932,
0.5798380374908447,
0.7877606749534607,
0.6061579585075378,
-0.20765717327594757,
1.1944297552108765,
0.15358804166316986,
0.5139346718788147,
1.1232795715332031,
-0.4235619604587555,
1.2811379432678223,
0.4725639224052429,
-0.391873300075531,
0.40177059173583984,
0.6258070468902588,
0.07880324870347977,
0.1551811695098877,
0.7533949613571167,
-0.2218552976846695,
-0.4892064034938812,
0.0618477500975132,
-0.13118687272071838,
0.5546234846115112,
0.33067113161087036,
-0.1167692095041275,
-0.2682640552520752,
0.0516461543738842,
-0.11820156872272491,
0.19501861929893494,
-0.19561539590358734,
0.5773670077323914,
0.14512620866298676,
-0.7444042563438416,
0.47216796875,
0.18706302344799042,
0.5083749294281006,
-0.3786473572254181,
0.04110259935259819,
-0.191676527261734,
0.026571374386548996,
-0.08818966150283813,
-0.9788731932640076,
0.13209572434425354,
0.034285321831703186,
0.04891165718436241,
0.10933750122785568,
0.3622000217437744,
-0.2111245095729828,
-0.4664769470691681,
0.4056053161621094,
0.8297738432884216,
0.10407509654760361,
-0.15154020488262177,
-0.8535454869270325,
0.30675065517425537,
-0.28925395011901855,
-0.4152812361717224,
0.25491636991500854,
0.4303824305534363,
-0.09589185565710068,
0.9391353726387024,
0.6509358882904053,
-0.26538023352622986,
0.11300375312566757,
0.4555312991142273,
0.5636668801307678,
-0.6390674710273743,
-0.28372785449028015,
-0.7431523203849792,
0.4055638313293457,
0.09654583036899567,
-0.575893759727478,
0.8037682175636292,
0.29680538177490234,
0.9676141738891602,
0.1576707363128662,
0.5063635110855103,
0.13796578347682953,
0.362883597612381,
-0.7198121547698975,
0.5915724635124207,
-0.49879002571105957,
0.4361035227775574,
-0.26763761043548584,
-1.0979331731796265,
-0.32825329899787903,
0.37579941749572754,
-0.35078394412994385,
0.2927914559841156,
0.7063392400741577,
0.6788305044174194,
0.20119790732860565,
0.06132713705301285,
0.726725161075592,
0.20353905856609344,
0.3973461091518402,
0.6214460730552673,
1.4526022672653198,
-0.6332362294197083,
0.5631303787231445,
0.0551440455019474,
-0.19262827932834625,
-0.06754077225923538,
-0.7096139788627625,
-0.8536750078201294,
-0.30399230122566223,
-0.19947318732738495,
-0.3950386047363281,
-0.05775352194905281,
0.6421419978141785,
0.4202025830745697,
-0.5881184339523315,
-0.14859941601753235,
0.2847813069820404,
0.18578603863716125,
-0.08520575612783432,
-0.27582085132598877,
0.3084564805030823,
-0.2089657038450241,
-0.7044423818588257,
0.3513720631599426,
0.12357063591480255,
-0.2019062340259552,
-0.4353434443473816,
-0.10730031132698059,
-0.06834589689970016,
0.14109815657138824,
1.089896321296692,
-0.051004935055971146,
-1.1015076637268066,
-0.5334923267364502,
0.10491760075092316,
-0.1946554332971573,
-0.26772910356521606,
0.3858378529548645,
-0.7736591100692749,
0.35879912972450256,
0.4591914415359497,
0.819654107093811,
0.3276003301143646,
0.09266026318073273,
0.31617382168769836,
-0.20531736314296722,
-0.4033494293689728,
0.27322307229042053,
0.25263985991477966,
0.3562575578689575,
0.09230580180883408,
0.41606730222702026,
0.019939573481678963,
-0.6178554892539978,
-0.801608681678772,
0.28357139229774475,
-1.0775119066238403,
-0.24047799408435822,
1.1962186098098755,
-0.19751794636249542,
-0.16821710765361786,
-0.15630510449409485,
-0.11352603137493134,
-0.2646137773990631,
-0.028263365849852562,
0.5790324807167053,
1.049202799797058,
-0.07638435065746307,
-0.288076251745224,
-0.9783139824867249,
0.030133847147226334,
0.4843448996543884,
-0.791867733001709,
0.016772005707025528,
0.5023313164710999,
0.5021334290504456,
0.025378959253430367,
0.5683992505073547,
-0.3486948311328888,
0.281583309173584,
-0.024821074679493904,
-0.22228600084781647,
0.04906243085861206,
-0.30910131335258484,
-0.29770317673683167,
0.25855591893196106,
0.4378089904785156,
0.10413868725299835
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07974v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07974v2
|
LiveCodeBench: Holistic and Contamination Free Evaluation of Large Language Models for Code
| 2024-03-12T17:58:04 | 2024-06-06T17:41:21 |
Naman Jain, King Han, Alex Gu, Wen-Ding Li, Fanjia Yan, Tianjun Zhang, Sida Wang, Armando Solar-Lezama, Koushik Sen, Ion Stoica
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) applied to code-related applications have
emerged as a prominent field, attracting significant interest from both
academia and industry. However, as new and improved LLMs are developed,
existing evaluation benchmarks (e.g., HumanEval, MBPP) are no longer sufficient
for assessing their capabilities. In this work, we propose LiveCodeBench, a
comprehensive and contamination-free evaluation of LLMs for code, which
continuously collects new problems over time from contests across three
competition platforms, namely LeetCode, AtCoder, and CodeForces. Notably, our
benchmark also focuses on a broader range of code related capabilities, such as
self-repair, code execution, and test output prediction, beyond just code
generation. Currently, LiveCodeBench hosts four hundred high-quality coding
problems that were published between May 2023 and May 2024. We have evaluated
18 base LLMs and 34 instruction-tuned LLMs on LiveCodeBench. We present
empirical findings on contamination, holistic performance comparisons,
potential overfitting in existing benchmarks as well as individual model
comparisons. We will release all prompts and model completions for further
community analysis, along with a general toolkit for adding new scenarios and
model
|
[
-0.37550869584083557,
-0.5757043361663818,
0.3588396906852722,
0.34782710671424866,
-0.1683749258518219,
0.36905360221862793,
-0.40375447273254395,
-0.6363434791564941,
0.10860587656497955,
0.8233773112297058,
-0.1269642859697342,
-0.6963997483253479,
-0.46354803442955017,
-0.07203585654497147,
-0.5709270238876343,
0.6686688661575317,
-0.1417478770017624,
-0.06070353835821152,
-0.4454478919506073,
-0.14483939111232758,
-0.3567204177379608,
-0.6615062952041626,
-0.14601711928844452,
-0.18591013550758362,
0.2539430558681488,
0.2918110489845276,
0.6244598627090454,
0.5796904563903809,
0.648279070854187,
0.24595244228839874,
-0.17470411956310272,
-0.012553135864436626,
-0.344682514667511,
0.270297110080719,
-0.0538545697927475,
-0.14474035799503326,
-0.6312049627304077,
0.035433776676654816,
0.23879855871200562,
0.6803341507911682,
-0.23470793664455414,
0.35257893800735474,
0.07743880152702332,
0.4821805953979492,
-0.8571467399597168,
0.04176047816872597,
-0.5133821368217468,
0.2354206144809723,
-0.010445930063724518,
-0.06936779618263245,
-0.462959349155426,
-0.6643506288528442,
-0.4045701026916504,
-0.1297861486673355,
-0.059834837913513184,
-0.2232140600681305,
0.4612593650817871,
0.3288722336292267,
-0.3163227140903473,
-0.08518947660923004,
-0.5685786604881287,
0.5955813527107239,
-0.9930741786956787,
0.2735840082168579,
0.14633023738861084,
0.4184711277484894,
-0.07066593319177628,
-0.7042253017425537,
-0.10127662122249603,
-0.3203319311141968,
0.45853590965270996,
0.0853344276547432,
-0.26908373832702637,
-0.058253176510334015,
0.09235657751560211,
0.516779899597168,
-0.5875329971313477,
0.13052354753017426,
-0.27159926295280457,
-0.33874398469924927,
0.6734603643417358,
0.10218851268291473,
0.318729043006897,
-0.12768173217773438,
-0.3875032365322113,
0.09473780542612076,
-0.9207457900047302,
-0.24298922717571259,
0.1391739845275879,
0.0064031281508505344,
-0.1611202508211136,
0.4638505280017853,
-0.24258697032928467,
0.6391834616661072,
-0.4514397978782654,
0.17676788568496704,
0.25863420963287354,
-0.36057430505752563,
-0.13773921132087708,
-0.21626663208007812,
0.7632787823677063,
0.40421175956726074,
0.346693754196167,
-0.3967769145965576,
-0.3236435651779175,
0.17074182629585266,
0.2632010281085968,
-0.9269156455993652,
-0.20416486263275146,
0.4046209454536438,
-0.5126911401748657,
-0.7133862376213074,
-0.1139715313911438,
-0.9967310428619385,
-0.7186670899391174,
-0.13726942241191864,
0.2167690545320511,
0.10661999881267548,
-0.3646307587623596,
0.24667227268218994,
0.16732382774353027,
-0.008905088528990746,
0.22462213039398193,
-0.519923985004425,
0.0397275872528553,
0.9797860383987427,
0.7975735068321228,
-0.4260671138763428,
-0.25065523386001587,
-0.887493908405304,
-0.11648888885974884,
-0.2814486026763916,
0.7563281059265137,
-0.649110734462738,
-0.5374012589454651,
0.15029174089431763,
-0.09801408648490906,
0.26096221804618835,
-0.9418332576751709,
0.27132588624954224,
-0.7144138813018799,
-0.4912843108177185,
-0.01937510073184967,
-0.594916820526123,
0.23161137104034424,
0.272476464509964,
-0.9383765459060669,
0.9982032775878906,
0.061731625348329544,
-0.5960941314697266,
0.06176147609949112,
-0.3415584862232208,
-0.369573712348938,
0.264005184173584,
-0.2439175546169281,
-0.24833185970783234,
0.11827483028173447,
-0.1492042988538742,
0.5301135182380676,
-0.18323354423046112,
0.5798514485359192,
-0.7100303173065186,
-0.44540974497795105,
0.3275471329689026,
-0.44402799010276794,
0.7137412428855896,
0.44725823402404785,
-0.40425097942352295,
0.4164646863937378,
-0.879478394985199,
0.32619911432266235,
-0.22399820387363434,
-0.5826376080513,
0.06828778982162476,
0.09869666397571564,
0.08787379413843155,
0.3399369418621063,
0.1818276345729828,
-0.5859538316726685,
0.17383962869644165,
-0.20443890988826752,
0.584174633026123,
0.6320499777793884,
0.10834658890962601,
0.16781628131866455,
-0.17273776233196259,
0.7156215310096741,
-0.24802814424037933,
0.3564910292625427,
-0.157981276512146,
-0.330066442489624,
-0.5635161399841309,
-0.12020175904035568,
0.38580435514450073,
0.5147037506103516,
-0.4608875513076782,
0.49102815985679626,
-0.3688901960849762,
-0.642730176448822,
-0.22465820610523224,
0.2110987901687622,
0.45568346977233887,
-0.17310452461242676,
0.18056325614452362,
-0.4057586193084717,
-0.5636819005012512,
-0.6342183351516724,
-0.40958309173583984,
0.20678015053272247,
-0.12124889343976974,
0.027076100930571556,
0.5040200352668762,
-0.4688006341457367,
0.7601161599159241,
-0.39887383580207825,
0.04936928674578667,
-0.3299863338470459,
-0.048982445150613785,
0.14434702694416046,
0.3555428087711334,
0.372371643781662,
-0.23082469403743744,
-0.4881019592285156,
0.021126126870512962,
-0.7292791604995728,
-0.15374048054218292,
0.3090575039386749,
-0.05416649207472801,
0.22339069843292236,
0.9438945651054382,
-0.17722243070602417,
0.3919084072113037,
1.0088719129562378,
-0.1811584085226059,
0.6165876388549805,
-0.1829877644777298,
0.1049368605017662,
-0.859837532043457,
0.27631983160972595,
-0.32156500220298767,
-0.4423723816871643,
-0.3843604624271393,
0.6288049221038818,
0.23392613232135773,
-0.46252989768981934,
-0.6111331582069397,
0.6969286799430847,
-0.4042355418205261,
-0.24651959538459778,
-0.23355743288993835,
0.28505006432533264,
0.11348603665828705,
0.29284098744392395,
-0.13379016518592834,
0.8800062537193298,
0.14247262477874756,
-0.31872159242630005,
0.5322007536888123,
-0.03020266257226467,
-0.7734432816505432,
-0.16899144649505615,
-0.8166811466217041,
0.3132215738296509,
0.46499204635620117,
0.24173374474048615,
-0.6503899693489075,
-0.22678029537200928,
-0.15941078960895538,
-0.2817247807979584,
0.11980551481246948,
-0.07656095176935196,
-0.685950756072998,
-0.17912277579307556,
-0.45980304479599,
0.3408859074115753,
0.6030222177505493,
-0.5149528980255127,
0.41007640957832336,
0.4764364957809448,
-0.05461753532290459,
-0.42361316084861755,
-0.4577629268169403,
0.13954409956932068,
-0.08685444295406342,
-0.4675328731536865,
-0.01168238278478384,
-0.32087334990501404,
-0.3105970025062561,
-0.07082188129425049,
-0.3187386393547058,
-0.034407466650009155,
0.5806631445884705,
0.3649033308029175,
0.17266841232776642,
-0.07506997138261795,
-0.13671012222766876,
-0.238246351480484,
-0.1365841031074524,
0.2573077380657196,
-0.03238803148269653,
0.5884753465652466,
-0.2073783129453659,
-0.597527027130127,
0.20029222965240479,
0.17096389830112457,
0.566875696182251,
-0.699644148349762,
0.5287886261940002,
0.2267579287290573,
-0.37244653701782227,
-0.29385778307914734,
-0.5777171850204468,
0.24978870153427124,
-0.45848166942596436,
0.43117573857307434,
-0.08729085326194763,
-0.9982019066810608,
0.6972721219062805,
-0.22957727313041687,
0.20456275343894958,
0.13549810647964478,
0.6780532598495483,
0.26670384407043457,
0.7880117297172546,
0.5244531631469727,
-0.11030369997024536,
0.27465248107910156,
0.04619699716567993,
0.17624923586845398,
-0.6026856303215027,
-0.16381041705608368,
-0.6855645179748535,
0.09794249385595322,
-0.3594634532928467,
-0.8365734815597534,
0.2463197112083435,
0.16976742446422577,
-0.3306025564670563,
0.42076408863067627,
-0.2709015905857086,
0.8449297547340393,
0.19756950438022614,
0.0051084766164422035,
0.5295100212097168,
-0.10135649144649506,
-0.2831505835056305,
0.1317078024148941,
-0.4930192232131958,
-0.6081885099411011,
1.2028859853744507,
0.49135589599609375,
0.820063054561615,
-0.02930382452905178,
0.8160926103591919,
0.3952551484107971,
0.6276335120201111,
-0.41872483491897583,
0.4613878130912781,
-0.13855674862861633,
-0.9269106388092041,
-0.018031883984804153,
-0.40331774950027466,
-0.6544668078422546,
0.1724931001663208,
0.13357959687709808,
-0.8170490860939026,
-0.010849365964531898,
0.004388018511235714,
-0.4126615822315216,
0.3901914358139038,
-0.3870241641998291,
1.0392102003097534,
-0.3813933730125427,
-0.6275339126586914,
-0.17817513644695282,
-0.5365815758705139,
0.4241631031036377,
-0.3736133873462677,
0.5654993653297424,
-0.2793199419975281,
0.12746889889240265,
0.4527975618839264,
-0.36493992805480957,
0.8453083038330078,
0.004084459971636534,
-0.5179884433746338,
0.22155781090259552,
0.4921679198741913,
0.3307674527168274,
0.07916498929262161,
-0.3353595733642578,
0.3160119950771332,
0.3905504047870636,
-0.2020931988954544,
-0.31921935081481934,
0.7756352424621582,
-0.5094969868659973,
-0.3170906603336334,
-0.22843782603740692,
-0.21297776699066162,
-0.31186598539352417,
0.321808785200119,
0.2509269714355469,
0.6068283319473267,
-0.27345481514930725,
0.5298245549201965,
0.7125162482261658,
-0.7017285227775574,
0.37223127484321594,
0.41838791966438293,
-0.7485169768333435,
-0.4280998706817627,
0.9415447115898132,
-0.2841850519180298,
0.5352271795272827,
0.11693119257688522,
-0.09081601351499557,
-0.004452377557754517,
-0.534568190574646,
-0.2587783932685852,
0.023479992523789406,
-0.9951131343841553,
-0.5226160883903503,
-0.4670078158378601,
-0.20489513874053955,
-0.21954405307769775,
-0.15269647538661957,
-0.6209993958473206,
-0.056788716465234756,
-0.0978672206401825,
0.1279129832983017,
0.01730159856379032,
0.7416267395019531,
0.015690170228481293,
-0.01888905093073845,
-1.3023086786270142,
0.22679443657398224,
-0.17049355804920197,
0.8379347920417786,
0.009233432821929455,
-0.29661744832992554,
-0.42319777607917786,
0.026621397584676743,
-0.30709052085876465,
-0.8151061534881592,
0.41049620509147644,
-0.03950132057070732,
0.6638736128807068,
0.3316406309604645,
0.2528328001499176,
0.38208088278770447,
-0.4448893666267395,
0.7164117097854614,
-0.06110610067844391,
-1.187292456626892,
0.42293715476989746,
-0.26936963200569153,
0.27024343609809875,
0.7736315727233887,
0.011487751267850399,
-0.6443134546279907,
-0.5625039339065552,
-0.49867624044418335,
-0.7620493173599243,
0.2386769950389862,
-0.03929682821035385,
0.1757056564092636,
-0.11410518735647202,
0.21276235580444336,
-0.003947807010263205,
0.3138994872570038,
-0.7473453879356384,
-0.001343823503702879,
-0.04995189979672432,
-0.0570186972618103,
-0.061395082622766495,
-0.3438374102115631,
-0.03763410076498985,
-0.04712630808353424,
0.4847771227359772,
-0.0806984081864357,
0.22380679845809937,
-0.29968664050102234,
-0.2945951819419861,
-0.19914287328720093,
0.48808175325393677,
0.35337209701538086,
0.6632311940193176,
-0.3084034025669098,
0.06916402280330658,
0.1826813668012619,
-0.28156742453575134,
0.09754770994186401,
-0.13125789165496826,
0.13613158464431763,
-0.1732061505317688,
0.7540409564971924,
0.3244907855987549,
0.6608322262763977,
-1.1331591606140137,
0.6787275075912476,
-0.02795840986073017,
-0.11376230418682098,
-0.2970059812068939,
0.23938722908496857,
0.39408981800079346,
0.27701810002326965,
-0.028042389079928398,
0.0461588054895401,
0.198350191116333,
-0.5194435119628906,
0.3121245205402374,
0.33582931756973267,
-0.40169352293014526,
-0.050381191074848175,
0.7900494933128357,
0.4549647569656372,
-0.14497849345207214,
0.6007094383239746,
-0.23407995700836182,
-0.6242058277130127,
0.8275812864303589,
0.23188436031341553,
0.7771869897842407,
0.011540450155735016,
-0.1294267475605011,
0.22414860129356384,
0.21230806410312653,
0.05574427917599678,
0.25470373034477234,
0.09251441061496735,
-0.5339299440383911,
-0.6868641376495361,
-0.7870401740074158,
-0.4237736761569977,
0.2652188539505005,
-0.8150154948234558,
0.24292606115341187,
-0.49679628014564514,
0.0926857590675354,
-0.26378002762794495,
0.13745969533920288,
-0.30562856793403625,
-0.10464810580015182,
0.43601173162460327,
1.3711920976638794,
-0.6775557994842529,
0.8526660799980164,
0.5270919799804688,
-0.18093551695346832,
-0.8321837782859802,
-0.00016847690858412534,
-0.04026796668767929,
-0.5007099509239197,
0.37620577216148376,
0.3027980327606201,
-0.08105640858411789,
0.009190850891172886,
-0.5848760604858398,
-0.7829861640930176,
0.9189030528068542,
0.49770233035087585,
-0.6433184742927551,
0.10468978434801102,
-0.025643646717071533,
0.4403388500213623,
-0.11537202447652817,
0.2614278197288513,
0.6287446618080139,
0.30042335391044617,
-0.08159758895635605,
-0.8825712203979492,
-0.041259460151195526,
-0.5192297697067261,
0.0032355941366404295,
0.167444109916687,
-0.5623818635940552,
0.5969170928001404,
-0.10948164016008377,
-0.18595543503761292,
0.2664402723312378,
0.38583555817604065,
0.42769333720207214,
0.13061343133449554,
0.19212250411510468,
0.26850754022598267,
0.390811026096344,
-0.07437806576490402,
1.0774387121200562,
-0.7080985307693481,
0.7369765043258667,
1.1583236455917358,
-0.7621321678161621,
1.1015712022781372,
0.10648796707391739,
-0.38415059447288513,
0.2503347098827362,
0.5320923328399658,
-0.0792989581823349,
0.3433806896209717,
0.5629404187202454,
-0.2206602245569229,
-0.4636659026145935,
0.10820260643959045,
-0.610543966293335,
0.3028068244457245,
0.0077156792394816875,
-0.020380118861794472,
-0.43842071294784546,
-0.008940450847148895,
0.06744749844074249,
0.041997794061899185,
0.031480129808187485,
0.49548402428627014,
-0.03139636293053627,
-0.6621226668357849,
0.6134629249572754,
0.17957958579063416,
0.6256967186927795,
-0.42486605048179626,
0.027125991880893707,
-0.6305296421051025,
0.42894652485847473,
-0.24570630490779877,
-0.6423023343086243,
0.4515981078147888,
0.10992458462715149,
0.17524439096450806,
-0.1818796992301941,
0.6599780917167664,
-0.13064567744731903,
-0.23024064302444458,
0.681115984916687,
0.4635770618915558,
0.17947641015052795,
-0.23579555749893188,
-0.5805967450141907,
0.7335944771766663,
0.01433255523443222,
-0.3454883098602295,
0.42719772458076477,
0.2424234002828598,
-0.0006086519570089877,
0.7468580007553101,
0.4734780490398407,
0.10458265990018845,
0.2812911570072174,
0.16900354623794556,
0.8999249339103699,
-0.5185074806213379,
-0.16685357689857483,
-0.6994689106941223,
0.36968129873275757,
0.14049392938613892,
-0.014883439056575298,
0.6996070146560669,
0.8404422998428345,
0.83138108253479,
-0.19658495485782623,
0.7781004905700684,
0.06830722838640213,
0.41224589943885803,
-0.4570538401603699,
0.6922703981399536,
-0.5024596452713013,
0.6348021626472473,
-0.4049582779407501,
-0.9642004370689392,
-0.37248146533966064,
0.3711051344871521,
-0.1172904297709465,
0.0743441954255104,
0.6728833913803101,
0.7763334512710571,
-0.04404502734541893,
-0.017062438651919365,
0.4356204569339752,
0.03071308508515358,
0.4959157407283783,
0.5796389579772949,
1.0014747381210327,
-0.16756783425807953,
0.5054924488067627,
-0.23311616480350494,
-0.25207075476646423,
-0.4360649585723877,
-1.202535629272461,
-0.7686597108840942,
-0.12340790033340454,
-0.3653879165649414,
-0.41080760955810547,
-0.016764039173722267,
0.8911468386650085,
0.5132579803466797,
-0.9498382806777954,
-0.3394146263599396,
-0.12002868950366974,
-0.07489330321550369,
-0.04380674287676811,
-0.13033457100391388,
0.04751003161072731,
-0.29811322689056396,
-0.4367089569568634,
0.4982023239135742,
0.2637799084186554,
-0.28511640429496765,
-0.4575076699256897,
-0.08500196784734726,
0.12947851419448853,
-0.0021687543485313654,
0.6660344004631042,
0.17814645171165466,
-0.5006873607635498,
-0.2905324399471283,
0.15622733533382416,
-0.3533340096473694,
-0.08296738564968109,
0.8611435890197754,
-0.6482815146446228,
0.3158872425556183,
0.37886103987693787,
0.860532820224762,
0.20988912880420685,
-0.07073535770177841,
0.4422740638256073,
-0.6140443086624146,
-0.09502637386322021,
0.16333983838558197,
0.38292887806892395,
0.08808431774377823,
-0.2852591276168823,
0.6094863414764404,
-0.01886749267578125,
-0.6100602149963379,
-1.0113937854766846,
0.14897307753562927,
-0.7862641215324402,
-0.49196237325668335,
1.4349489212036133,
-0.32979121804237366,
-0.015924058854579926,
-0.0037083441857248545,
0.21736128628253937,
0.2571675777435303,
0.06496985256671906,
0.4365587532520294,
0.8590496182441711,
0.13932690024375916,
-0.05797824263572693,
-1.028721809387207,
0.1574677675962448,
0.2646501958370209,
-1.2362406253814697,
0.44467002153396606,
0.6861833930015564,
0.6113352179527283,
-0.010568613186478615,
0.4901314973831177,
-0.4411213994026184,
0.31741178035736084,
-0.038074325770139694,
0.5372526049613953,
-0.17230606079101562,
-0.4479440450668335,
-0.6332082748413086,
0.20034654438495636,
0.4077504873275757,
0.1940682977437973
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07865v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07865v4
|
CodeAttack: Revealing Safety Generalization Challenges of Large Language Models via Code Completion
| 2024-03-12T17:55:38 | 2024-06-09T15:04:34 |
Qibing Ren, Chang Gao, Jing Shao, Junchi Yan, Xin Tan, Wai Lam, Lizhuang Ma
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG, cs.SE
|
The rapid advancement of Large Language Models (LLMs) has brought about
remarkable generative capabilities but also raised concerns about their
potential misuse. While strategies like supervised fine-tuning and
reinforcement learning from human feedback have enhanced their safety, these
methods primarily focus on natural languages, which may not generalize to other
domains. This paper introduces CodeAttack, a framework that transforms natural
language inputs into code inputs, presenting a novel environment for testing
the safety generalization of LLMs. Our comprehensive studies on
state-of-the-art LLMs including GPT-4, Claude-2, and Llama-2 series reveal a
new and universal safety vulnerability of these models against code input:
CodeAttack bypasses the safety guardrails of all models more than 80\% of the
time. We find that a larger distribution gap between CodeAttack and natural
language leads to weaker safety generalization, such as encoding natural
language input with data structures. Furthermore, we give our hypotheses about
the success of CodeAttack: the misaligned bias acquired by LLMs during code
training, prioritizing code completion over avoiding the potential safety risk.
Finally, we analyze potential mitigation measures. These findings highlight new
safety risks in the code domain and the need for more robust safety alignment
algorithms to match the code capabilities of LLMs.
|
[
-0.05831054970622063,
-0.6380835175514221,
0.420116126537323,
0.11906809359788895,
-0.07895029336214066,
0.4833945333957672,
-0.06111729145050049,
-0.5181625485420227,
-0.30360832810401917,
0.5947016477584839,
-0.2458484023809433,
-0.6830616593360901,
-0.5868908762931824,
-0.09269978851079941,
-0.47515031695365906,
1.1576887369155884,
-0.3038901388645172,
-0.14917466044425964,
-0.16251802444458008,
0.1307978630065918,
-0.6672040820121765,
-0.8166201114654541,
-0.28337177634239197,
-0.2806594967842102,
0.22546078264713287,
0.21410851180553436,
0.7682110071182251,
0.4767618179321289,
0.7138923406600952,
0.3077430725097656,
0.04972792789340019,
-0.1412905901670456,
-0.32033687829971313,
-0.049259159713983536,
-0.004295789636671543,
-0.5844540596008301,
-0.68431156873703,
-0.09004931151866913,
0.4426683187484741,
0.3366476595401764,
-0.2114407867193222,
0.060059625655412674,
0.2330934703350067,
0.5726155042648315,
-0.6672134399414062,
0.04183376207947731,
-0.8819650411605835,
0.09898050129413605,
-0.038154106587171555,
-0.26304638385772705,
-0.5051267147064209,
-0.5841627717018127,
-0.02829773724079132,
-0.33829623460769653,
0.14027360081672668,
0.12407781928777695,
0.7275159358978271,
0.4094405472278595,
-0.5041022896766663,
-0.18260817229747772,
-0.6983894109725952,
0.8111105561256409,
-0.5977344512939453,
-0.09085074812173843,
0.45058315992355347,
0.3505757749080658,
-0.29323941469192505,
-0.3301986753940582,
-0.2815060019493103,
-0.3384188711643219,
0.03787084296345711,
-0.33889874815940857,
-0.16828088462352753,
0.43936893343925476,
0.19454313814640045,
0.39536407589912415,
-0.9629442691802979,
0.26615360379219055,
-0.30273115634918213,
-0.4516407549381256,
0.6925387978553772,
0.11863976716995239,
0.7163593173027039,
0.001859604031778872,
-0.2823159396648407,
-0.13987362384796143,
-1.0234311819076538,
0.049267660826444626,
0.648661196231842,
0.07513219863176346,
-0.3164190649986267,
0.3077761232852936,
-0.06146594136953354,
0.7847567796707153,
-0.582727313041687,
-0.05669336020946503,
0.24038909375667572,
-0.29712384939193726,
-0.3969237506389618,
-0.0396878719329834,
0.8269848823547363,
0.353544145822525,
0.6901874542236328,
-0.24832795560359955,
-0.0915500670671463,
0.11271980404853821,
0.3627970218658447,
-0.3634302616119385,
-0.28300929069519043,
0.4201180338859558,
-0.14875581860542297,
-1.0561572313308716,
0.06513407081365585,
-0.8784420490264893,
-0.3359295427799225,
-0.015661384910345078,
0.10849763453006744,
-0.22445090115070343,
-0.18459272384643555,
0.43228963017463684,
0.11489222198724747,
0.3944052457809448,
-0.04581381008028984,
-0.874915361404419,
0.0771738663315773,
0.8393374681472778,
0.7412420511245728,
-0.19136479496955872,
-0.3004299998283386,
-0.5497876405715942,
0.2732100784778595,
-0.33060938119888306,
0.8140449523925781,
-0.4274786412715912,
-0.3975718319416046,
0.2796313464641571,
-0.1007239818572998,
0.10179860144853592,
-0.4800645112991333,
0.3464046120643616,
-0.6266860961914062,
-0.2292483150959015,
0.24969689548015594,
-0.1977711319923401,
0.03132552653551102,
0.45625001192092896,
-0.5364502668380737,
0.782434344291687,
-0.11751590669155121,
-0.5777230858802795,
0.24160529673099518,
-0.6232035756111145,
-0.6622636914253235,
-0.2823772430419922,
-0.2810380160808563,
-0.48955246806144714,
0.04847462475299835,
0.19980548322200775,
0.3447147309780121,
-0.1552554816007614,
0.5781635046005249,
-0.4554769992828369,
-0.47137168049812317,
0.47124895453453064,
-0.4819369614124298,
0.6514742970466614,
0.039111506193876266,
-0.37628284096717834,
0.020748822018504143,
-0.6638914942741394,
0.2351495623588562,
0.24161797761917114,
-0.5479809045791626,
-0.19937734305858612,
-0.07672377675771713,
0.05306699126958847,
0.11505647748708725,
0.2096952646970749,
-0.3476875424385071,
0.3366135358810425,
-0.29721349477767944,
0.442668616771698,
0.8795126080513,
-0.0045219059102237225,
0.49764731526374817,
-0.2207469493150711,
0.8452828526496887,
-0.26370641589164734,
0.27324169874191284,
-0.12839902937412262,
-0.24767427146434784,
-0.36335474252700806,
-0.13411082327365875,
0.36752939224243164,
0.7989879846572876,
-0.572763979434967,
0.43067091703414917,
-0.1766982078552246,
-0.22169902920722961,
-0.10378029197454453,
0.23615935444831848,
0.7602707147598267,
0.035691648721694946,
0.11144416779279709,
-0.0791056677699089,
-0.7244008183479309,
-0.8053130507469177,
-0.37698662281036377,
-0.2471756488084793,
-0.18531189858913422,
-0.1464739590883255,
0.46087583899497986,
-0.5637004375457764,
0.873656153678894,
-0.6597439646720886,
-0.14044450223445892,
-0.3232390880584717,
0.0282156839966774,
-0.12062225490808487,
0.7017232179641724,
0.5287115573883057,
-0.5504319071769714,
-0.056516047567129135,
-0.07565062493085861,
-0.8009783625602722,
0.08116987347602844,
0.01245231181383133,
0.04153822362422943,
0.2196936309337616,
0.5167328119277954,
-0.3689483106136322,
0.4974305331707001,
0.939999520778656,
-0.12707436084747314,
0.5444556474685669,
-0.14114300906658173,
-0.0639476478099823,
-0.8483768105506897,
0.08826135098934174,
-0.28139573335647583,
-0.14006850123405457,
-0.6260480880737305,
0.5277155041694641,
0.09998749196529388,
-0.31602463126182556,
-0.43316954374313354,
0.04261906072497368,
-0.3975140154361725,
-0.03204915300011635,
-0.22682489454746246,
-0.15615566074848175,
-0.036330509930849075,
0.5048924088478088,
-0.3170631229877472,
0.853111743927002,
0.5453274250030518,
-0.5022794604301453,
0.1302311271429062,
0.1137394905090332,
-0.24385596811771393,
0.05876205116510391,
-0.8016961216926575,
0.5777692198753357,
-0.06977277994155884,
0.3156771659851074,
-1.0132544040679932,
-0.5398052334785461,
-0.07678566873073578,
-0.2890583872795105,
0.2972424626350403,
-0.442705363035202,
-0.6242808103561401,
-0.19716306030750275,
-0.4662081003189087,
0.514477550983429,
0.5982851982116699,
-0.3124382495880127,
0.23190191388130188,
0.6492265462875366,
-0.08258255571126938,
-0.6036038994789124,
-0.8649792075157166,
0.22207064926624298,
-0.29928675293922424,
-0.5937708020210266,
0.06749075651168823,
-0.2843015193939209,
-0.21045151352882385,
-0.44080880284309387,
-0.21005849540233612,
-0.23706457018852234,
0.505363404750824,
0.37621498107910156,
0.5628142356872559,
-0.0044509065337479115,
0.08427470177412033,
0.062334731221199036,
-0.3193638026714325,
0.2011609971523285,
-0.020206931978464127,
0.5422354340553284,
-0.3691852390766144,
-0.4663167893886566,
-0.11464160680770874,
0.40405911207199097,
0.4660194516181946,
-0.22738929092884064,
0.29703930020332336,
-0.002636972814798355,
-0.46309930086135864,
-0.19900618493556976,
-0.3380952477455139,
-0.01699376292526722,
-0.5636977553367615,
0.5524073839187622,
-0.0874214768409729,
-1.0472408533096313,
0.222720205783844,
-0.17569883167743683,
0.34154561161994934,
0.04349647834897041,
0.23192265629768372,
-0.05824197456240654,
1.0379037857055664,
0.7875117659568787,
-0.42558950185775757,
0.25107234716415405,
-0.2362002432346344,
0.3432404696941376,
-0.31013938784599304,
-0.0871438980102539,
-0.6559585332870483,
-0.17882125079631805,
-0.43726709485054016,
-0.3568270802497864,
0.2037973403930664,
0.01573115400969982,
-0.2474052459001541,
0.587131142616272,
-0.4847944974899292,
0.9658783078193665,
0.215822234749794,
-0.05504103749990463,
0.5937331318855286,
0.17866988480091095,
-0.14183180034160614,
0.025056829676032066,
-0.37677139043807983,
-0.6246246099472046,
1.2081708908081055,
0.5401943922042847,
1.0406439304351807,
0.15387603640556335,
0.9076712727546692,
0.24119015038013458,
0.2259223461151123,
-0.5675564408302307,
0.5251111388206482,
0.01422381866723299,
-0.5642249584197998,
-0.15991869568824768,
-0.277536541223526,
-0.7680427432060242,
0.006085310131311417,
0.013339368626475334,
-0.6802531480789185,
-0.09246666729450226,
0.4235103726387024,
-0.31374886631965637,
0.2351883500814438,
-0.6747450232505798,
0.8069552183151245,
-0.31862500309944153,
-0.06413309276103973,
-0.15074937045574188,
-0.5888934135437012,
0.7201942801475525,
-0.16396936774253845,
0.482570081949234,
-0.18197935819625854,
0.08457913249731064,
0.43047574162483215,
-0.13101588189601898,
0.8370590806007385,
0.06162562593817711,
-0.47996094822883606,
0.11977165192365646,
0.3998878002166748,
0.7093647122383118,
0.08515092730522156,
0.19913652539253235,
0.24701295793056488,
-0.10758350044488907,
-0.36602598428726196,
-0.44371336698532104,
0.6151154637336731,
-0.5608015656471252,
-0.4833143651485443,
-0.5018805265426636,
-0.658377468585968,
-0.47508034110069275,
-0.011240029707551003,
0.30037158727645874,
0.5153336524963379,
-0.15748466551303864,
-0.05877460539340973,
0.8285331726074219,
-0.4184723198413849,
0.42995867133140564,
0.3474029004573822,
-0.3180526793003082,
-0.4106450378894806,
0.8867668509483337,
-0.23596902191638947,
0.4428097903728485,
0.1996457725763321,
-0.15473926067352295,
0.09445081651210785,
-0.8227113485336304,
-0.2196889966726303,
-0.05167171359062195,
-0.6572806239128113,
-0.5249480605125427,
-0.4531031548976898,
-0.37898939847946167,
-0.2456323802471161,
-0.38654226064682007,
-0.18178114295005798,
-0.17209985852241516,
0.07511262595653534,
-0.45860806107521057,
0.27316826581954956,
0.8079895973205566,
0.00903209950774908,
0.13975761830806732,
-0.9122017621994019,
0.19014722108840942,
0.35713207721710205,
0.5923547148704529,
-0.18578386306762695,
-0.18201327323913574,
-0.18547986447811127,
-0.10952028632164001,
-0.40202873945236206,
-0.6752566695213318,
0.15544429421424866,
-0.10230995714664459,
0.4333191514015198,
0.18123194575309753,
0.03714035823941231,
0.41993871331214905,
-0.6806396842002869,
0.6271910667419434,
0.17531517148017883,
-0.8588886260986328,
0.5721756815910339,
-0.5360424518585205,
0.19152015447616577,
0.7646222114562988,
0.01571926847100258,
-0.3721356689929962,
-0.6085719466209412,
-0.4396999478340149,
-0.8622065186500549,
0.2480931282043457,
0.15732774138450623,
0.2540213465690613,
0.1255732774734497,
0.03160320594906807,
-0.13748426735401154,
0.1584673374891281,
-0.8802806735038757,
0.05097994953393936,
0.16670557856559753,
-0.23009225726127625,
0.1352228820323944,
-0.3379022181034088,
-0.347623735666275,
-0.03435494005680084,
0.4069487154483795,
-0.2521355450153351,
0.4436517059803009,
-0.12412533909082413,
-0.38058534264564514,
-0.03705693781375885,
0.5603613257408142,
0.7987879514694214,
0.4239840507507324,
-0.13755975663661957,
0.3111773729324341,
0.10090241581201553,
-0.5883398056030273,
0.4490768313407898,
-0.09328550100326538,
0.04675782844424248,
-0.2125062346458435,
0.5370700359344482,
0.3561747372150421,
0.5395715832710266,
-0.9057786464691162,
0.5249261856079102,
0.009973348118364811,
-0.22599180042743683,
-0.4102729558944702,
0.4158003032207489,
-0.10718712955713272,
-0.09129823744297028,
0.3335140347480774,
0.22151383757591248,
0.1856730431318283,
-0.4513164758682251,
0.37132394313812256,
0.4045241177082062,
-0.3300791382789612,
-0.35162028670310974,
0.6599559783935547,
0.24388819932937622,
-0.23432056605815887,
0.08208092302083969,
-0.036486826837062836,
-0.6256011724472046,
0.8883676528930664,
0.43559667468070984,
1.1012561321258545,
-0.09620093554258347,
0.2503601014614105,
0.040718305855989456,
0.7087329626083374,
-0.2165902554988861,
0.1602516770362854,
0.2418876588344574,
-0.5674557089805603,
-0.6084816455841064,
-0.453689843416214,
-0.4243502616882324,
0.17021411657333374,
-0.4889850616455078,
0.08387207984924316,
-0.7620339393615723,
0.09195616841316223,
-0.5280665755271912,
-0.3918706774711609,
-0.490583211183548,
-0.20351102948188782,
0.10031097382307053,
0.9518692493438721,
-0.8428955078125,
0.8681324124336243,
0.58488529920578,
-0.18194034695625305,
-0.7896671891212463,
0.5461198091506958,
0.1602364331483841,
-0.819079577922821,
0.47910067439079285,
0.348020076751709,
-0.015420152805745602,
-0.15145429968833923,
-0.8211501240730286,
-0.8539846539497375,
0.9709556698799133,
0.6820934414863586,
-0.5717056393623352,
-0.28187841176986694,
0.5311758518218994,
0.34712234139442444,
-0.0789526179432869,
-0.22117233276367188,
0.8718129396438599,
0.33879783749580383,
-0.39544206857681274,
-0.8815522789955139,
0.2311241179704666,
-0.17891119420528412,
0.23257312178611755,
0.1798282265663147,
-0.39246422052383423,
0.4386284649372101,
-0.20226258039474487,
0.0675460696220398,
0.12888787686824799,
0.23338323831558228,
0.5591220855712891,
0.23466254770755768,
0.43356215953826904,
0.4563453793525696,
0.5296686887741089,
0.04749144986271858,
1.0861934423446655,
-0.11886153370141983,
0.44098928570747375,
0.9419574737548828,
-0.373526394367218,
0.7298229932785034,
0.39130699634552,
-0.3885442018508911,
0.5619862079620361,
0.3148026168346405,
0.16823258996009827,
0.5645729303359985,
0.39616942405700684,
-0.23680716753005981,
-0.1578298807144165,
0.2780953645706177,
-0.31188008189201355,
0.24014756083488464,
0.11257683485746384,
-0.15817223489284515,
-0.2550388276576996,
0.03584587574005127,
0.23659823834896088,
-0.032828059047460556,
-0.05054806172847748,
0.6930543184280396,
0.15521907806396484,
-0.5514925122261047,
0.6874725222587585,
-0.09441358596086502,
0.7790456414222717,
-0.6380462646484375,
-0.07175982743501663,
-0.23761533200740814,
0.167862668633461,
-0.20942041277885437,
-0.6152548789978027,
0.42818260192871094,
0.2700124680995941,
0.020596224814653397,
-0.1136728897690773,
0.6639072895050049,
-0.299743115901947,
-0.2663901746273041,
0.3321583867073059,
-0.2171647846698761,
-0.1277596354484558,
-0.12620247900485992,
-0.443685382604599,
0.30571743845939636,
-0.04040468856692314,
-0.004520975518971682,
0.6404078602790833,
-0.00011204028851352632,
0.06720887869596481,
0.6534161567687988,
0.6564857363700867,
-0.20226028561592102,
0.10202770680189133,
-0.32920190691947937,
0.7570780515670776,
-0.5691959261894226,
-0.45186105370521545,
-0.9283004403114319,
0.6955326199531555,
-0.07924242317676544,
-0.15633200109004974,
0.4706631302833557,
0.34924620389938354,
0.6235159635543823,
-0.2552882432937622,
1.067763328552246,
0.05268050730228424,
0.030045486986637115,
-0.7626460194587708,
0.8143832087516785,
-0.17585186660289764,
0.5535328984260559,
-0.5797823667526245,
-0.5845745205879211,
-0.5026364326477051,
0.3472498059272766,
-0.24270804226398468,
-0.12094295024871826,
0.7520050406455994,
0.9255414009094238,
0.03214304521679878,
-0.11171668767929077,
0.4408283531665802,
-0.04224741458892822,
0.5372589230537415,
0.8330991268157959,
0.6908126473426819,
-0.5123725533485413,
0.9395132064819336,
0.047931257635354996,
-0.36633971333503723,
-0.22585594654083252,
-1.0582417249679565,
-0.9269817471504211,
-0.26515597105026245,
-0.3119443356990814,
-0.42869916558265686,
0.1482432782649994,
0.8442499041557312,
0.4857192933559418,
-0.939517080783844,
-0.042040351778268814,
-0.4961317479610443,
0.20271623134613037,
0.04198569431900978,
-0.24918828904628754,
0.10522571206092834,
-0.41111481189727783,
-0.40586087107658386,
0.5061198472976685,
0.310960590839386,
0.24076682329177856,
-0.28242698311805725,
-0.05598852038383484,
0.16058789193630219,
0.001897428766824305,
0.30538779497146606,
0.42099499702453613,
-0.5530303716659546,
-0.5713184475898743,
-0.10890328139066696,
-0.21534958481788635,
-0.015260028652846813,
0.9828470945358276,
-0.5812298655509949,
0.04090838134288788,
0.4742680490016937,
1.0002014636993408,
-0.13802286982536316,
-0.35835036635398865,
0.9945920705795288,
-0.9874367713928223,
0.29875877499580383,
-0.005789502058178186,
0.45260515809059143,
0.13067659735679626,
-0.48818260431289673,
0.649098813533783,
0.10788027942180634,
-0.6573734283447266,
-1.171839952468872,
0.5075141787528992,
-0.6234750747680664,
-0.12755891680717468,
1.2544186115264893,
-0.12405349314212799,
-0.02888372354209423,
-0.3098503351211548,
-0.25155937671661377,
-0.0913141518831253,
-0.2354971021413803,
0.9103546142578125,
0.5879634022712708,
0.4095350205898285,
0.02712152898311615,
-0.7981024384498596,
0.6962602734565735,
0.2769424021244049,
-1.0246022939682007,
0.18984873592853546,
0.2870631515979767,
0.49886852502822876,
0.02258550003170967,
0.5289907455444336,
-0.2708927094936371,
0.5366631150245667,
-0.32858484983444214,
0.24382221698760986,
-0.12061428278684616,
-0.3365643322467804,
-0.7802963256835938,
0.12300336360931396,
0.18414615094661713,
-0.2198767215013504
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09725v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09725v1
|
RAD-PHI2: Instruction Tuning PHI-2 for Radiology
| 2024-03-12T17:27:22 | 2024-03-12T17:27:22 |
Mercy Ranjit, Gopinath Ganapathy, Shaury Srivastav, Tanuja Ganu, Srujana Oruganti
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, J.3
|
Small Language Models (SLMs) have shown remarkable performance in general
domain language understanding, reasoning and coding tasks, but their
capabilities in the medical domain, particularly concerning radiology text, is
less explored. In this study, we investigate the application of SLMs for
general radiology knowledge specifically question answering related to
understanding of symptoms, radiological appearances of findings, differential
diagnosis, assessing prognosis, and suggesting treatments w.r.t diseases
pertaining to different organ systems. Additionally, we explore the utility of
SLMs in handling text-related tasks with respect to radiology reports within
AI-driven radiology workflows. We fine-tune Phi-2, a SLM with 2.7 billion
parameters using high-quality educational content from Radiopaedia, a
collaborative online radiology resource. The resulting language model,
RadPhi-2-Base, exhibits the ability to address general radiology queries across
various systems (e.g., chest, cardiac). Furthermore, we investigate Phi-2 for
instruction tuning, enabling it to perform specific tasks. By fine-tuning Phi-2
on both general domain tasks and radiology-specific tasks related to chest
X-ray reports, we create Rad-Phi2. Our empirical results reveal that Rad-Phi2
Base and Rad-Phi2 perform comparably or even outperform larger models such as
Mistral-7B-Instruct-v0.2 and GPT-4 providing concise and precise answers. In
summary, our work demonstrates the feasibility and effectiveness of utilizing
SLMs in radiology workflows both for knowledge related queries as well as for
performing specific tasks related to radiology reports thereby opening up new
avenues for enhancing the quality and efficiency of radiology practice.
|
[
-0.0983298048377037,
-0.7011054754257202,
0.7273070216178894,
-0.20373132824897766,
-0.38350239396095276,
-0.42574626207351685,
-0.060466162860393524,
-0.7233002781867981,
-0.18057066202163696,
0.4938803017139435,
-0.4634959101676941,
-0.26720649003982544,
-0.6018900275230408,
-0.16435958445072174,
0.03836638852953911,
0.9515641927719116,
0.050160687416791916,
0.492675244808197,
-0.17070962488651276,
0.07452266663312912,
-0.639573872089386,
0.006017893087118864,
-0.7577651143074036,
-0.7401444315910339,
0.587807297706604,
0.7866849899291992,
1.153415322303772,
0.8583235144615173,
0.9831780195236206,
0.01662684604525566,
0.37393301725387573,
0.3148639500141144,
-0.3494005799293518,
0.3473535180091858,
-0.46798112988471985,
-0.42000851035118103,
-0.5919433832168579,
-0.3031129539012909,
0.23781076073646545,
0.5235416889190674,
0.1409943401813507,
0.1485007405281067,
-0.1331101804971695,
0.9597558975219727,
-0.5686057806015015,
0.3545154929161072,
-0.09230563044548035,
-0.028845610097050667,
-0.38326889276504517,
-0.659343421459198,
-0.47470414638519287,
-0.31352147459983826,
0.38964226841926575,
-0.6821838021278381,
0.040015146136283875,
0.19002582132816315,
0.8183645009994507,
0.3595995008945465,
-0.364256888628006,
-0.9112183451652527,
-0.8715246319770813,
0.6884101629257202,
-0.37364670634269714,
0.1482800841331482,
0.8620127439498901,
0.4247616231441498,
0.372007817029953,
-1.1006704568862915,
-0.04354479908943176,
0.35626021027565,
-0.412110835313797,
0.030678728595376015,
-0.4439164698123932,
0.37008219957351685,
0.16326873004436493,
0.5228747725486755,
-1.094216227531433,
0.3072459399700165,
-0.590599000453949,
-0.09152986854314804,
0.4577731788158417,
0.31534242630004883,
0.5212933421134949,
-0.1752527505159378,
-0.07712125778198242,
-0.07757831364870071,
-0.7102768421173096,
-0.3176387548446655,
-0.452580064535141,
-0.06061391532421112,
-0.18974697589874268,
0.6981058120727539,
-0.10590007156133652,
0.710683286190033,
0.02676100842654705,
-0.2760099172592163,
-0.055336710065603256,
-0.03748628497123718,
-0.44058024883270264,
-0.21426497399806976,
0.24187497794628143,
0.41604524850845337,
0.0010999137302860618,
-0.016132192686200142,
-0.07619135826826096,
0.17848347127437592,
0.11850646138191223,
-0.8579262495040894,
-0.4726472496986389,
0.2326548546552658,
-0.668794572353363,
-0.13335902988910675,
-0.005594071000814438,
-0.7805137038230896,
-0.38720354437828064,
-0.272751122713089,
0.6216226816177368,
-0.501624345779419,
-0.3000137507915497,
0.4217459559440613,
0.10125558078289032,
0.48773589730262756,
0.2057437151670456,
-0.981772780418396,
0.4258505702018738,
0.6752189993858337,
0.7264612317085266,
0.11804880201816559,
0.2600449025630951,
-0.8047159314155579,
0.2938157618045807,
-0.2995506823062897,
0.8086574673652649,
-0.650917112827301,
-0.3680685758590698,
0.03994340822100639,
-0.1934894621372223,
-0.19210423529148102,
-0.6641197204589844,
0.42835479974746704,
-0.7095413208007812,
0.35294947028160095,
-0.4039098024368286,
-0.675395667552948,
-0.228652223944664,
-0.19551749527454376,
-0.41482916474342346,
0.9128667712211609,
0.461892306804657,
-0.706825315952301,
-0.18763035535812378,
-0.6295160055160522,
-0.6197533011436462,
0.2544923722743988,
-0.40962857007980347,
-0.2156895101070404,
0.25955069065093994,
0.08709273487329483,
0.2939307689666748,
-0.7919224500656128,
-0.26162710785865784,
0.2319992184638977,
-0.4650510549545288,
0.10407549142837524,
0.18171659111976624,
0.3967248499393463,
0.5123899579048157,
-0.41348129510879517,
-0.07998001575469971,
-0.24751399457454681,
0.6738284230232239,
0.0658373013138771,
0.01687295362353325,
-0.3522374927997589,
-0.20132200419902802,
0.012208527885377407,
0.26613321900367737,
-0.17240913212299347,
-0.11234443634748459,
0.10986115783452988,
-0.657290518283844,
0.22983354330062866,
0.07429131865501404,
0.3422989547252655,
0.5226292610168457,
-0.8799450397491455,
0.8425211906433105,
-0.17850473523139954,
0.09239251911640167,
-0.16461682319641113,
-0.8855951428413391,
-0.7078607678413391,
-0.08777372539043427,
0.07519285380840302,
0.6129944324493408,
-0.6636927723884583,
0.010644684545695782,
-0.1426907628774643,
-0.411129891872406,
-0.6407377123832703,
-0.10119940340518951,
0.6890162229537964,
0.6435746550559998,
0.3581779897212982,
-0.07802782207727432,
-0.4904201924800873,
-0.8498304486274719,
0.15035325288772583,
-0.05098536238074303,
-0.13702569901943207,
0.4923591613769531,
0.10478770732879639,
-0.32813704013824463,
0.5954315662384033,
-0.6732383966445923,
-0.5338320732116699,
-0.28067052364349365,
0.24442853033542633,
-0.21663495898246765,
0.26883354783058167,
0.29072651267051697,
-0.4749143123626709,
-0.5814263224601746,
0.08442255109548569,
-0.9429435133934021,
-0.12725189328193665,
0.08624941110610962,
-0.060983866453170776,
0.25492095947265625,
0.2686637341976166,
-0.5823207497596741,
0.4545058310031891,
0.17134998738765717,
-0.23570150136947632,
0.07820963114500046,
-0.6803271770477295,
0.23092663288116455,
-0.6544122695922852,
0.10183794796466827,
-0.14556464552879333,
-0.06337597221136093,
-0.7453441023826599,
0.2636118531227112,
0.243133544921875,
-0.214520663022995,
-0.20618541538715363,
0.46663007140159607,
-0.5771809220314026,
-0.42948296666145325,
-0.5573728680610657,
0.05672106891870499,
0.14579279720783234,
0.2751462459564209,
0.236723393201828,
0.6916773319244385,
0.7128002047538757,
-0.6108952164649963,
0.11584781110286713,
0.0722794234752655,
-0.4379844665527344,
0.33092328906059265,
-0.7583853006362915,
0.6144249439239502,
-0.24254819750785828,
-0.12879104912281036,
-0.6626994609832764,
-0.3603360056877136,
0.27794426679611206,
-0.35222142934799194,
0.5669215321540833,
-0.07618971914052963,
-0.49982377886772156,
-0.18481408059597015,
-0.1483803540468216,
0.5787196755409241,
0.8272507190704346,
-0.09794027358293533,
0.4095425009727478,
0.41979408264160156,
-0.2600522041320801,
-0.13535498082637787,
-1.0176126956939697,
-0.22014911472797394,
-0.021013889461755753,
-0.7831792831420898,
0.2967396676540375,
0.013257120735943317,
-0.448150098323822,
-0.038432542234659195,
0.03958885744214058,
-0.2943049371242523,
-0.2547875642776489,
0.38430261611938477,
0.2786429822444916,
-0.5304763317108154,
0.2420562356710434,
0.4096735417842865,
-0.4486885368824005,
-0.06629239022731781,
-0.4837569296360016,
0.4920297861099243,
-0.17607185244560242,
-0.4569814205169678,
-0.693440854549408,
0.32905054092407227,
0.5217431783676147,
-0.18861804902553558,
0.3265804946422577,
0.525183916091919,
-0.7532685995101929,
-0.04835381358861923,
-0.4300999343395233,
-0.5394699573516846,
-0.37029021978378296,
0.4576190710067749,
-0.2645697295665741,
-0.894467294216156,
0.13897675275802612,
0.07382095605134964,
-0.0628766119480133,
0.40307000279426575,
0.8446699976921082,
-0.3855208456516266,
0.9921349287033081,
0.3677394688129425,
0.2732701301574707,
-0.2833439111709595,
-0.3705829977989197,
0.2538812458515167,
-0.7686651349067688,
-0.5087888240814209,
-0.48456621170043945,
-0.33065807819366455,
-0.26621800661087036,
-0.9036214351654053,
0.7149506211280823,
0.08647148311138153,
0.06660433113574982,
-0.2685408294200897,
-0.6376103162765503,
0.49040135741233826,
0.26223820447921753,
0.2704026699066162,
0.2993007302284241,
0.2497531771659851,
0.4192902147769928,
-0.6041820049285889,
-0.822687029838562,
-0.3727259635925293,
1.176454782485962,
0.4883376657962799,
0.8957884907722473,
0.27562791109085083,
0.22309757769107819,
0.5355852246284485,
-0.08129636943340302,
-0.8130025863647461,
0.1055624857544899,
-0.3841887414455414,
-0.5138236284255981,
-0.2625488042831421,
0.08604746311903,
-0.7350130081176758,
-0.07790619134902954,
0.05885595828294754,
-0.40831154584884644,
-0.019701983779668808,
0.29823771119117737,
-0.6322896480560303,
-0.014232001267373562,
-0.4573535621166229,
0.6075100302696228,
-0.3527061641216278,
-0.2558232843875885,
-0.7190863490104675,
-0.6043424606323242,
0.35960671305656433,
0.1631072610616684,
0.28575399518013,
-0.10245619714260101,
-0.3333390951156616,
0.4910535514354706,
-0.4063335955142975,
0.48303067684173584,
-0.1267688125371933,
-0.1172826811671257,
0.22386376559734344,
0.1493103802204132,
0.2568210959434509,
0.42349523305892944,
-0.09300058335065842,
-0.2902017831802368,
0.3116813004016876,
-0.2883959114551544,
-0.8279660940170288,
0.8277099132537842,
-0.9164126515388489,
-0.232456773519516,
-0.5744088888168335,
-0.7285894155502319,
-0.3385229706764221,
0.09898938238620758,
0.6762207746505737,
0.8813579082489014,
0.3111077547073364,
-0.016057075932621956,
1.1600805521011353,
-0.3058270514011383,
-0.21127018332481384,
0.6658498644828796,
-0.2612789273262024,
0.0021646174136549234,
0.8980082869529724,
-0.09191819280385971,
0.2416577786207199,
0.7236590385437012,
0.2814899981021881,
-0.23822493851184845,
-0.48420488834381104,
-0.5209981799125671,
0.40539485216140747,
-0.7001640796661377,
-0.49960774183273315,
-0.3796399235725403,
-0.3050926625728607,
-0.3651674687862396,
-0.13717560470104218,
-0.21457155048847198,
-0.5714290738105774,
-0.3726511597633362,
0.23560316860675812,
0.4097329080104828,
0.8600267171859741,
0.03169441595673561,
0.020034683868288994,
-0.591746985912323,
0.4222239553928375,
0.4113047122955322,
0.3003445565700531,
-0.18605923652648926,
-0.9199680685997009,
-0.35716497898101807,
0.1798560619354248,
-0.041670188307762146,
-0.9849616289138794,
0.10649063438177109,
0.5345444083213806,
0.19799374043941498,
0.45109823346138,
0.2000620812177658,
0.42168471217155457,
0.0025605279952287674,
0.433957040309906,
-0.09168555587530136,
-0.5697932839393616,
0.9755458235740662,
-0.30237987637519836,
0.3825705051422119,
0.33475515246391296,
0.17064179480075836,
-0.4660312533378601,
-0.28981688618659973,
-0.3338244557380676,
-0.5125311017036438,
0.9422679543495178,
0.2115391194820404,
-0.0202464759349823,
0.017064938321709633,
0.8943858742713928,
-0.12577754259109497,
-0.29307660460472107,
-0.15963976085186005,
-0.45421937108039856,
0.0716143399477005,
-0.12738998234272003,
0.3814796805381775,
-0.8171398043632507,
-0.22913715243339539,
-0.2917502522468567,
0.8431252241134644,
-0.13992424309253693,
0.47233331203460693,
0.17429351806640625,
-0.39466118812561035,
-0.4917791783809662,
0.2848948836326599,
0.8449515700340271,
0.9503037333488464,
0.040321629494428635,
0.22604994475841522,
-0.10522472858428955,
-0.4042763411998749,
-0.08284828811883926,
-0.17766201496124268,
-0.4219706058502197,
0.05333244055509567,
0.2822101414203644,
0.6848090291023254,
0.4423910081386566,
-0.7520713806152344,
0.36810192465782166,
-0.0707709863781929,
-0.19423417747020721,
-0.1566539704799652,
0.37674108147621155,
0.15810953080654144,
0.17299360036849976,
0.2602657079696655,
0.029025258496403694,
0.13367953896522522,
-0.3441064655780792,
0.2565930187702179,
0.1872992068529129,
-0.45170125365257263,
-0.22361277043819427,
0.5920939445495605,
0.004274364560842514,
-0.29311636090278625,
0.8736448884010315,
-0.166691854596138,
0.026742443442344666,
0.5749484300613403,
0.6670346260070801,
0.39497148990631104,
-0.20951664447784424,
0.2777406871318817,
0.40089327096939087,
0.33658838272094727,
-0.1534968614578247,
0.5361766219139099,
0.23833268880844116,
-0.4686166048049927,
-0.17273688316345215,
-0.20780719816684723,
-0.1678714007139206,
0.4317449927330017,
-1.2453244924545288,
0.3599405586719513,
-0.689844012260437,
-0.022311218082904816,
0.10969069600105286,
0.19305533170700073,
-0.5106794834136963,
0.34623250365257263,
0.21003544330596924,
0.8747106790542603,
-0.5794737935066223,
1.3548341989517212,
0.8916544914245605,
-0.3412957787513733,
-0.9391367435455322,
-0.22038576006889343,
0.248798206448555,
-0.8616829514503479,
0.40721115469932556,
-0.03291591256856918,
-0.10846834629774094,
0.03916601464152336,
0.1302603930234909,
-0.7648389935493469,
1.284553050994873,
0.2826390266418457,
-0.5146830677986145,
-0.29247191548347473,
0.2799127995967865,
0.6758974194526672,
-0.39384058117866516,
0.3092065453529358,
0.7913104295730591,
0.3484126031398773,
-0.008948356844484806,
-0.9730473756790161,
-0.10566966980695724,
-0.2552819848060608,
0.0885816141963005,
-0.12152007967233658,
-0.3465716242790222,
0.5204671621322632,
-0.6356340646743774,
-0.06353291869163513,
0.3222915232181549,
0.605006217956543,
0.27052056789398193,
0.559224545955658,
0.17229123413562775,
0.41218990087509155,
0.9053557515144348,
-0.1891908049583435,
1.0386192798614502,
-0.6205546855926514,
0.24084119498729706,
0.8619593381881714,
-0.2687084376811981,
0.5765374302864075,
0.2031138390302658,
0.05833869427442551,
0.4046514332294464,
0.4662041664123535,
0.1652679592370987,
0.6746072769165039,
-0.11327191442251205,
-0.2483859807252884,
-0.1484035849571228,
-0.04026944190263748,
-0.7215181589126587,
0.33791348338127136,
0.6558173894882202,
-0.35125261545181274,
-0.10220973938703537,
0.2474125623703003,
0.0388999879360199,
0.14704830944538116,
-0.23694980144500732,
0.7687383890151978,
0.23086273670196533,
-0.76222163438797,
0.4540852904319763,
0.48464247584342957,
0.31430500745773315,
-0.8102114200592041,
0.08484447002410889,
-0.30624622106552124,
0.3577514886856079,
-0.402519553899765,
-0.6265033483505249,
0.7552124857902527,
-0.0669662281870842,
-0.657382071018219,
-0.14522141218185425,
0.8618370294570923,
-0.3931155800819397,
-0.39029404520988464,
0.08292975276708603,
0.3045963644981384,
0.08381136506795883,
0.11484285444021225,
-0.5913443565368652,
0.24929480254650116,
0.00995365995913744,
0.12758156657218933,
0.6484053730964661,
0.04270600900053978,
-0.08748266845941544,
0.7182181477546692,
0.014168206602334976,
0.20221105217933655,
-0.36254218220710754,
0.155714750289917,
0.5792171955108643,
-0.09073088318109512,
-0.48418161273002625,
-0.275764524936676,
0.07413674890995026,
0.35790935158729553,
-0.2917831242084503,
0.3516867160797119,
0.6808949112892151,
0.5255635976791382,
-0.028090307489037514,
0.828122079372406,
-0.03306776285171509,
0.8518581986427307,
-0.7607473731040955,
0.6987277269363403,
-0.500249981880188,
0.573884129524231,
0.10461658984422684,
-0.3902510404586792,
-0.18780387938022614,
0.8924001455307007,
-0.35606497526168823,
0.02763969637453556,
0.8417630195617676,
0.982783317565918,
-0.024839725345373154,
0.30281487107276917,
0.19649837911128998,
-0.02959839254617691,
0.10657958686351776,
0.7483350038528442,
0.3023667335510254,
-0.6451749801635742,
0.5442240834236145,
-0.5701137185096741,
-0.20907412469387054,
-0.25975775718688965,
-0.23624587059020996,
-0.6038162708282471,
-0.5015667676925659,
-0.5750155448913574,
-0.4494936168193817,
0.35078585147857666,
0.714371383190155,
0.8410374522209167,
-0.7708408832550049,
-0.13905097544193268,
0.22301770746707916,
-0.050466619431972504,
-0.15294012427330017,
-0.19236266613006592,
0.7364621162414551,
-0.3469911813735962,
-0.2728229761123657,
0.33231255412101746,
0.6737557053565979,
-0.162311851978302,
-0.1134658083319664,
-0.5085218548774719,
0.2654186487197876,
-0.12229438871145248,
0.40945273637771606,
0.4621642231941223,
-0.7806891798973083,
-0.16939221322536469,
0.3107151985168457,
-0.5868198871612549,
-0.06101800873875618,
1.2836575508117676,
-0.3842368721961975,
0.49729636311531067,
0.34872132539749146,
0.5817562937736511,
0.5326793789863586,
-0.07244585454463959,
0.4106254279613495,
-0.5116029977798462,
0.15342001616954803,
0.49443715810775757,
-0.05942948907613754,
0.23104456067085266,
-0.49785715341567993,
0.2524844706058502,
0.08726605772972107,
-0.6465752720832825,
-0.5123159289360046,
0.27623364329338074,
-0.8905985355377197,
-0.40784162282943726,
1.1595386266708374,
-0.017468499019742012,
0.4072878360748291,
-0.41961559653282166,
-0.05988764390349388,
0.09004838764667511,
0.1581207513809204,
0.6179855465888977,
0.1861276477575302,
-0.7000439167022705,
-0.5720700025558472,
-0.6856875419616699,
0.8733078837394714,
0.6514140367507935,
-0.8447793126106262,
-0.25892695784568787,
0.4970996081829071,
0.3993619680404663,
-0.383892297744751,
1.1680288314819336,
-0.30652424693107605,
1.045040249824524,
-0.44044604897499084,
-0.5355143547058105,
-0.33337488770484924,
-0.1474771648645401,
-0.39111459255218506,
0.13832256197929382,
0.46434786915779114,
-0.06471626460552216
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09724v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09724v2
|
ClaimVer: Explainable Claim-Level Verification and Evidence Attribution of Text Through Knowledge Graphs
| 2024-03-12T17:07:53 | 2024-06-24T01:08:24 |
Preetam Prabhu Srikar Dammu, Himanshu Naidu, Mouly Dewan, YoungMin Kim, Tanya Roosta, Aman Chadha, Chirag Shah
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
In the midst of widespread misinformation and disinformation through social
media and the proliferation of AI-generated texts, it has become increasingly
difficult for people to validate and trust information they encounter. Many
fact-checking approaches and tools have been developed, but they often lack
appropriate explainability or granularity to be useful in various contexts. A
text validation method that is easy to use, accessible, and can perform
fine-grained evidence attribution has become crucial. More importantly,
building user trust in such a method requires presenting the rationale behind
each prediction, as research shows this significantly influences people's
belief in automated systems. Localizing and bringing users' attention to the
specific problematic content is also paramount, instead of providing simple
blanket labels. In this paper, we present ClaimVer, a human-centric framework
tailored to meet users' informational and verification needs by generating rich
annotations and thereby reducing cognitive load. Designed to deliver
comprehensive evaluations of texts, it highlights each claim, verifies it
against a trusted knowledge graph (KG), presents the evidence, and provides
succinct, clear explanations for each claim prediction. Finally, our framework
introduces an attribution score, enhancing applicability across a wide range of
downstream tasks.
|
[
-0.07597778737545013,
-0.4847085177898407,
0.7341932654380798,
0.09875898063182831,
0.13229414820671082,
0.09645857661962509,
-0.025388842448592186,
-0.5553247928619385,
-0.03741304203867912,
0.29764652252197266,
-0.2597886919975281,
-0.4983395040035248,
-0.6157442927360535,
0.22267723083496094,
-0.389952152967453,
1.0966986417770386,
-0.393112450838089,
-0.5978014469146729,
-0.8083675503730774,
-0.02606678009033203,
-0.4020548164844513,
-0.17433743178844452,
-0.7084121704101562,
-0.8061256408691406,
0.5319185256958008,
0.5079799294471741,
0.6259668469429016,
0.3766769766807556,
0.3398386240005493,
0.3234708309173584,
0.1374502032995224,
0.36213210225105286,
-0.23352424800395966,
0.0933079794049263,
-0.522575855255127,
-0.6797748804092407,
-0.46833232045173645,
-0.05169987305998802,
0.3411720097064972,
0.3908193111419678,
-0.09248004853725433,
0.3828880488872528,
0.18521177768707275,
0.4255980849266052,
-0.7181212902069092,
0.3931657075881958,
-0.6017262935638428,
-0.14922375977039337,
-0.18911495804786682,
-0.3740793764591217,
-0.5746872425079346,
-0.7020745873451233,
0.12481188774108887,
-0.9032073020935059,
0.39279904961586,
0.16264863312244415,
1.1456806659698486,
0.3030494749546051,
-0.8130637407302856,
-0.34619995951652527,
-0.49004068970680237,
0.5449774861335754,
-0.2754491865634918,
0.020723536610603333,
0.8156002163887024,
0.5037867426872253,
-0.07027352601289749,
-0.7678881287574768,
-0.8260764479637146,
0.0019703556317836046,
-0.5295097231864929,
0.0714792013168335,
-0.3304210901260376,
-0.07412795722484589,
0.24306273460388184,
0.2990046739578247,
-0.4516809582710266,
-0.14355619251728058,
-0.027108393609523773,
-0.9097689986228943,
0.6085252165794373,
-0.15128976106643677,
0.465896874666214,
-0.34719040989875793,
-0.5787652134895325,
-0.1077546626329422,
-0.580173671245575,
0.19666577875614166,
0.32645994424819946,
0.101914182305336,
-0.19963520765304565,
0.6291856169700623,
-0.3967551290988922,
0.6373142004013062,
-0.1731313169002533,
-0.27374598383903503,
0.24448375403881073,
-0.1905648112297058,
-0.06892214715480804,
0.5462513566017151,
0.9528200626373291,
0.44495970010757446,
0.10734603554010391,
-0.16828523576259613,
-0.1437293142080307,
0.33498215675354004,
0.19339533150196075,
-0.8305818438529968,
-0.1749582290649414,
0.2387232631444931,
-0.5439717173576355,
-0.6428642272949219,
0.06766074150800705,
-0.6464739441871643,
-1.0219268798828125,
0.015455856919288635,
0.4267951250076294,
-0.5359070301055908,
-0.34261640906333923,
0.18895450234413147,
-0.3202486038208008,
-0.13650478422641754,
0.5902901291847229,
-0.41801124811172485,
0.1893879771232605,
0.38250991702079773,
0.7205488085746765,
0.05107409879565239,
-0.12872853875160217,
-0.5186206102371216,
0.3558238446712494,
-0.2634456157684326,
1.030784249305725,
-0.2653678059577942,
0.10576871782541275,
0.1971919685602188,
0.012362545356154442,
0.0028267991729080677,
-0.29271048307418823,
1.0086525678634644,
-0.65349280834198,
0.36739128828048706,
-0.6462094187736511,
-0.5955955386161804,
-0.3643524646759033,
0.6945858597755432,
-0.7758506536483765,
0.9442595839500427,
0.12537041306495667,
-1.0523004531860352,
0.6703320145606995,
-0.9381797313690186,
-0.7063480615615845,
0.2980634570121765,
-0.2705031931400299,
-0.27899256348609924,
-0.07516205310821533,
0.1934424638748169,
0.32916566729545593,
-0.4729219973087311,
0.1304769217967987,
-0.05013177543878555,
0.1242094337940216,
0.5173050761222839,
-0.5593926310539246,
0.9098814129829407,
0.36147430539131165,
-0.39560002088546753,
0.0628490149974823,
-0.8060880899429321,
-0.08404573053121567,
0.3708212971687317,
-0.36596235632896423,
-0.5210603475570679,
0.18571048974990845,
-0.15010616183280945,
-0.150778129696846,
0.3072303235530853,
-0.889316201210022,
-0.0751262903213501,
-0.21767844259738922,
0.3804548978805542,
0.46899428963661194,
-0.052827704697847366,
0.06473274528980255,
-0.3991054892539978,
0.6109892725944519,
-0.07907570898532867,
-0.08211842179298401,
-0.3376266062259674,
-0.32449761033058167,
-0.27858614921569824,
-0.2511870265007019,
0.42343980073928833,
0.6433417797088623,
-0.811870276927948,
0.32688388228416443,
-0.6096307635307312,
-0.3275831639766693,
-0.3043653964996338,
0.18100827932357788,
0.38476085662841797,
1.0586460828781128,
0.2726253867149353,
-0.11948394775390625,
-0.2501234710216522,
-0.8175384402275085,
-0.598108172416687,
-0.798265814781189,
-0.42968833446502686,
0.25408315658569336,
0.2892278730869293,
-0.17298994958400726,
1.3993725776672363,
-0.6253628730773926,
-0.4097927212715149,
-0.28933700919151306,
0.23745602369308472,
-0.21944114565849304,
0.145894393324852,
0.40861940383911133,
-0.988278865814209,
-0.2913665771484375,
0.11046145111322403,
-0.8548441529273987,
-0.22746160626411438,
-0.1668226569890976,
-0.011377605609595776,
0.09609381854534149,
0.33481457829475403,
-0.6271241903305054,
0.5023361444473267,
0.2728990912437439,
-0.8535520434379578,
0.4266386330127716,
-0.27008822560310364,
0.4766496419906616,
-1.0091205835342407,
0.14407745003700256,
0.09849510341882706,
-0.9046791791915894,
-0.15297099947929382,
-0.21246474981307983,
0.07793638110160828,
0.07825768738985062,
-0.04453190788626671,
0.36466288566589355,
-0.1981864720582962,
0.29986119270324707,
-0.2358098179101944,
0.4766257703304291,
0.5368775129318237,
-0.14423318207263947,
-0.4076676070690155,
0.4827633202075958,
0.24000674486160278,
-0.39873290061950684,
0.4079320430755615,
0.3556652367115021,
-0.41434621810913086,
0.8413551449775696,
-0.763236403465271,
-0.2640538811683655,
-0.12433994561433792,
0.5318686366081238,
-1.2458146810531616,
-0.586061418056488,
0.22939786314964294,
-0.6608769297599792,
0.07781978696584702,
-0.21497103571891785,
-0.6790907382965088,
-0.3514156639575958,
-0.06197778135538101,
0.39935851097106934,
0.2795202136039734,
-0.6689090728759766,
0.9996976256370544,
0.48071572184562683,
0.06194042041897774,
-0.4591993987560272,
-0.5981309413909912,
0.41744643449783325,
-0.40301936864852905,
-0.6542734503746033,
0.5397388935089111,
0.46942171454429626,
-0.4154963493347168,
0.16433894634246826,
-0.17598338425159454,
-0.05673249810934067,
0.2204156517982483,
0.34022992849349976,
0.17691409587860107,
0.03296365216374397,
0.4300413727760315,
0.012780888937413692,
-0.42545533180236816,
0.3103104531764984,
-0.2471097856760025,
0.09905905276536942,
-0.20611058175563812,
-0.503797709941864,
-0.49341869354248047,
0.14587412774562836,
0.47838085889816284,
-0.17920275032520294,
0.47037118673324585,
0.6994823217391968,
-0.7218750715255737,
-0.05491609126329422,
-0.639045774936676,
-0.020688271149992943,
-0.45168036222457886,
0.0745154395699501,
-0.2539433538913727,
-0.7410951852798462,
0.5513767600059509,
-0.34860098361968994,
-0.006362855434417725,
0.8239216804504395,
0.41944098472595215,
0.022346431389451027,
0.7854800224304199,
0.4893510937690735,
0.1074938103556633,
0.03008541464805603,
0.2572547197341919,
0.15699797868728638,
-0.17112834751605988,
-0.3859306275844574,
-0.6391777396202087,
-0.0002338962658541277,
-0.2652711868286133,
-0.2796177864074707,
0.12246484309434891,
0.05928829684853554,
-0.09381129592657089,
0.23396572470664978,
-0.6397421360015869,
0.719265341758728,
0.29943740367889404,
0.23231136798858643,
0.5706723928451538,
0.13918107748031616,
0.022684836760163307,
0.11770084500312805,
-0.5056907534599304,
-0.8218371868133545,
0.798590898513794,
0.4457014203071594,
0.7301459312438965,
0.3206236958503723,
0.5204770565032959,
0.9931721091270447,
0.472351610660553,
-0.7570339441299438,
0.42177197337150574,
0.2006073296070099,
-0.9801785349845886,
-0.18972282111644745,
-0.5213622450828552,
-0.7947412729263306,
-0.09208760410547256,
-0.41935819387435913,
-0.8774909377098083,
-0.21336539089679718,
0.5867586731910706,
-0.3753184378147125,
0.11645574122667313,
-0.8388262391090393,
0.9480969905853271,
-0.06584793329238892,
-0.2278841733932495,
-0.34914085268974304,
-0.6883630156517029,
0.21554985642433167,
0.21485015749931335,
0.2936834692955017,
-0.08658138662576675,
0.15533246099948883,
0.9205614328384399,
-0.8072260618209839,
1.0995936393737793,
-0.5149759650230408,
-0.3085813522338867,
0.6606808304786682,
0.15230236947536469,
0.6919128894805908,
0.1297738403081894,
0.06275524199008942,
-0.04389788210391998,
-0.06285478174686432,
-0.22139334678649902,
-0.5957807302474976,
0.4769725203514099,
-0.5384289622306824,
-0.32417306303977966,
-0.3476591408252716,
-0.33509230613708496,
-0.12438581883907318,
0.5555136203765869,
0.1836490035057068,
0.44428905844688416,
-0.19194477796554565,
0.06419871002435684,
0.875065267086029,
-0.2570492625236511,
0.0785742849111557,
0.15879160165786743,
-0.21877318620681763,
-0.3246876299381256,
1.1657956838607788,
-0.19799460470676422,
0.028817882761359215,
0.41517961025238037,
0.51377272605896,
-0.5350048542022705,
-0.25161176919937134,
-0.43710383772850037,
-0.2058916985988617,
-0.8168284893035889,
-0.43440327048301697,
-0.659259021282196,
0.1406775712966919,
-0.24261368811130524,
-0.17002007365226746,
-0.4805227220058441,
-0.5648586750030518,
0.19619576632976532,
-0.30760735273361206,
0.5304067730903625,
0.7402538061141968,
0.1425105482339859,
0.3083660900592804,
-0.4756004810333252,
0.4178537428379059,
0.31626179814338684,
0.3900570273399353,
-0.23545020818710327,
-0.14576615393161774,
-0.27749764919281006,
-0.007396463770419359,
-0.3133887052536011,
-0.7335828542709351,
-0.2123880833387375,
0.0688546821475029,
0.4840150475502014,
0.5494272708892822,
0.566722571849823,
0.3125349283218384,
-0.19152279198169708,
0.7054585814476013,
0.42086535692214966,
-1.0523287057876587,
0.7210049629211426,
-0.1458284705877304,
-0.2998846471309662,
0.7181164622306824,
0.3191118836402893,
-0.3523654043674469,
-0.27246198058128357,
-0.6211056113243103,
-0.8491913676261902,
0.42105036973953247,
0.261564701795578,
-0.15970823168754578,
0.19736914336681366,
0.36036574840545654,
0.16646768152713776,
-0.02723185159265995,
-0.568981945514679,
-0.18377019464969635,
-0.554877758026123,
-0.6137910485267639,
0.09603787213563919,
-0.3296007513999939,
-0.6330863237380981,
0.1617702692747116,
0.6066340804100037,
-0.5032070875167847,
0.16187837719917297,
0.5761281847953796,
-0.3576180934906006,
0.049513112753629684,
0.3206319510936737,
0.3958995044231415,
0.7772432565689087,
-0.08717279881238937,
0.5822533965110779,
-0.0005265962099656463,
-0.4677969515323639,
0.16397155821323395,
0.49516433477401733,
-0.2754451632499695,
0.08311301469802856,
0.611612856388092,
0.4926638901233673,
-0.115272656083107,
-0.452153742313385,
0.8921571373939514,
-0.2635853588581085,
-0.2230977863073349,
-0.3406921327114105,
0.041310325264930725,
0.0848969891667366,
0.2153189331293106,
0.4089835286140442,
0.2836329936981201,
0.1651235967874527,
-0.10793400555849075,
0.14742715656757355,
0.13029398024082184,
-0.5767229795455933,
-0.1714278757572174,
0.9075875878334045,
0.20221321284770966,
-0.09499240666627884,
0.19702789187431335,
-0.24331232905387878,
-0.6039558053016663,
0.388403058052063,
0.5631222724914551,
0.6272622346878052,
0.22138266265392303,
0.506057858467102,
0.2592117488384247,
0.33170703053474426,
-0.08598509430885315,
-0.0561305470764637,
-0.2759253680706024,
-0.9084662199020386,
-0.5212814807891846,
-0.36336442828178406,
-0.3177882432937622,
-0.23863551020622253,
-0.7252860069274902,
-0.009366746060550213,
-0.18577581644058228,
-0.47366002202033997,
0.31834396719932556,
-0.03438462316989899,
-0.5806549787521362,
0.2624286115169525,
0.2187032252550125,
1.0662765502929688,
-1.0983476638793945,
0.3686036169528961,
0.9178926348686218,
-0.4751623272895813,
-0.7921546697616577,
0.14730075001716614,
0.3356423079967499,
-0.8345933556556702,
0.4464271366596222,
0.28512099385261536,
-0.3363044857978821,
-0.12648926675319672,
-0.620254635810852,
-0.31787288188934326,
1.2570953369140625,
0.6809976696968079,
0.026780234649777412,
0.10546177625656128,
0.1286645233631134,
0.25326964259147644,
-0.31993257999420166,
0.30515018105506897,
0.1502581089735031,
0.5523185133934021,
0.18187306821346283,
-0.6132906675338745,
0.7012906074523926,
-0.07337645441293716,
-0.11557574570178986,
-0.12925061583518982,
-0.31928980350494385,
0.2656146287918091,
-0.2681676745414734,
-0.23952150344848633,
-0.5087786316871643,
0.7625982165336609,
0.3127574026584625,
0.5687264800071716,
1.0257469415664673,
0.3953477740287781,
1.2785557508468628,
-0.04850907251238823,
1.261055588722229,
-0.09614348411560059,
0.33858969807624817,
1.1607319116592407,
-0.1459134966135025,
0.440091609954834,
0.3291451036930084,
-0.2769521474838257,
0.9636372923851013,
0.5163308382034302,
0.2148478627204895,
0.16144931316375732,
0.14736121892929077,
-0.41318896412849426,
-0.49866336584091187,
-0.6285451054573059,
-0.12641340494155884,
0.3973313868045807,
0.36745983362197876,
-0.4739978313446045,
-0.38951337337493896,
-0.18687647581100464,
0.4027998745441437,
0.24766622483730316,
-0.09205171465873718,
0.6099852919578552,
-0.16684742271900177,
-0.7935518622398376,
0.2278381586074829,
-0.03251873701810837,
0.3119530975818634,
-0.6537666320800781,
-0.07857532799243927,
0.2864994704723358,
0.39086297154426575,
-0.6882840991020203,
-0.862571656703949,
0.14160248637199402,
0.13913559913635254,
-0.41938161849975586,
-0.38327404856681824,
1.3866441249847412,
-0.22801826894283295,
-0.2725304067134857,
0.07629280537366867,
0.2939159572124481,
0.005873590707778931,
-0.3007117509841919,
-0.4490355849266052,
-0.11667854338884354,
0.08448758721351624,
-0.3151145577430725,
-0.026222575455904007,
0.680386483669281,
-0.1622661054134369,
0.7514746785163879,
0.6310184001922607,
-0.06779706478118896,
-0.435589998960495,
0.1601283997297287,
0.7518887519836426,
-0.3122894763946533,
-0.4928702414035797,
-0.923101544380188,
0.71621173620224,
-0.5512292385101318,
-0.04540025815367699,
0.8887505531311035,
0.6306871771812439,
0.4612688422203064,
0.3604417145252228,
1.2336485385894775,
-0.5051171779632568,
0.547872006893158,
-0.20205479860305786,
1.1123743057250977,
-0.509962797164917,
-0.010997672565281391,
-0.2977340519428253,
-0.38423797488212585,
-0.4132848083972931,
0.6190240979194641,
-0.16820943355560303,
-0.2057526558637619,
0.5672934651374817,
0.40105941891670227,
0.0725189596414566,
0.12117999792098999,
-0.15691764652729034,
0.17323975265026093,
0.7655642628669739,
0.3608584403991699,
0.7087005972862244,
-0.4350012540817261,
0.8744399547576904,
0.1265944093465805,
-0.6254420876502991,
-0.17614448070526123,
-1.3058624267578125,
-0.7429599165916443,
-0.4267234802246094,
-0.7477937340736389,
-0.9324537515640259,
-0.38112398982048035,
0.6126844882965088,
0.5023994445800781,
-0.6643417477607727,
0.2889981269836426,
-0.2134062498807907,
0.46782463788986206,
-0.0503915436565876,
-0.27490511536598206,
0.41844597458839417,
-0.32579129934310913,
-0.01932854950428009,
0.16144432127475739,
-0.07081376761198044,
0.024400390684604645,
-0.037397876381874084,
-0.07231692969799042,
0.06153154373168945,
-0.049358539283275604,
0.5517066717147827,
0.4767970144748688,
-0.45909976959228516,
-0.46556830406188965,
-0.4176073372364044,
-0.1929982751607895,
-0.08880164474248886,
0.8708675503730774,
-0.9325990676879883,
0.6098648309707642,
0.437050461769104,
0.7771322727203369,
0.3585754930973053,
0.2544703483581543,
0.6042788028717041,
-0.634712815284729,
-0.3153539001941681,
-0.1253681182861328,
0.3326801657676697,
0.5223155617713928,
-0.5653771758079529,
0.44539833068847656,
0.3383634686470032,
-0.5010786056518555,
-0.8815947771072388,
0.23347274959087372,
-1.0166118144989014,
0.07086106389760971,
0.9593801498413086,
-0.5752467513084412,
-0.20863698422908783,
-0.4477320611476898,
-0.10368015617132187,
0.36367011070251465,
-0.3368866741657257,
0.9441549777984619,
0.8093827962875366,
0.09214965254068375,
0.4282943308353424,
-0.33373621106147766,
0.6795181632041931,
0.20985352993011475,
-0.8586304783821106,
0.574467658996582,
0.5399202108383179,
0.4685499966144562,
0.5489134788513184,
0.7430211305618286,
-0.19990287721157074,
-0.016750864684581757,
0.17947712540626526,
0.15916109085083008,
-0.27024704217910767,
-0.14680440723896027,
0.2406441867351532,
0.36626750230789185,
0.20648185908794403,
-0.24577923119068146
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07825v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07825v2
|
The Missing Piece in Model Editing: A Deep Dive into the Hidden Damage Brought By Model Editing
| 2024-03-12T17:04:28 | 2024-07-02T14:07:56 |
Jianchen Wang, Zhouhong Gu, Xiaoxuan Zhu, Lin Zhang, Haoning Ye, Zhuozhi Xiong, Hongwei Feng, Yanghua Xiao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models have revolutionized numerous tasks with their
remarkable efficacy. However, editing these models, crucial for rectifying
outdated or erroneous information, often leads to a complex issue known as the
ripple effect in the hidden space. While difficult to detect, this effect can
significantly impede the efficacy of model editing tasks and deteriorate model
performance. This paper addresses this scientific challenge by proposing a
novel evaluation methodology, Graphical Impact Evaluation(GIE), which
quantitatively evaluates the adaptations of the model and the subsequent impact
of editing. Furthermore, we introduce the Selective Impact Revision(SIR), a
model editing method designed to mitigate this ripple effect. Our comprehensive
evaluations reveal that the ripple effect in the hidden space is a significant
issue in all current model editing methods. However, our proposed methods, GIE
and SIR, effectively identify and alleviate this issue, contributing to the
advancement of LLM editing techniques.
|
[
-0.27959364652633667,
-0.9528645873069763,
0.6014392971992493,
0.15633825957775116,
0.03549849987030029,
0.38216808438301086,
0.19541329145431519,
-0.43076297640800476,
0.17816591262817383,
0.5583804845809937,
-0.5428656935691833,
-0.2584758996963501,
-0.8552423119544983,
-0.21041564643383026,
-0.3516991138458252,
0.8211910128593445,
-0.06359512358903885,
0.11468835175037384,
-0.14353106915950775,
0.04107503220438957,
-0.7807907462120056,
-0.11155306547880173,
-0.5276987552642822,
-0.08077491074800491,
0.7424216270446777,
0.07854370772838593,
0.9245061278343201,
0.4710787832736969,
0.8135426640510559,
0.2638015151023865,
-0.7359447479248047,
0.23327916860580444,
-0.8224744200706482,
-0.2697223126888275,
-0.3903864026069641,
-0.3698878586292267,
-0.6865952014923096,
0.0964711457490921,
1.0426474809646606,
0.7833208441734314,
0.3601336181163788,
0.008236771449446678,
0.20801283419132233,
0.667708694934845,
-0.8240987658500671,
0.08501259982585907,
-0.5575549006462097,
-0.011707928963005543,
-0.23148877918720245,
0.20560143887996674,
-0.468243271112442,
-0.12787725031375885,
-0.1270357221364975,
-0.3359721004962921,
0.012814847752451897,
-0.2604931890964508,
0.883509635925293,
0.13424938917160034,
-0.3713914453983307,
0.045091889798641205,
-0.8724896311759949,
0.5775571465492249,
-0.9029998779296875,
0.24738584458827972,
-0.10827624052762985,
0.1006011888384819,
-0.5160517692565918,
-0.6466054916381836,
-0.44775694608688354,
-0.218182772397995,
0.09718137234449387,
0.08637646585702896,
-0.45355555415153503,
0.362035870552063,
0.4127606749534607,
0.4729189872741699,
-0.14676113426685333,
0.07758813351392746,
-0.4051041603088379,
-0.1704438179731369,
0.6799713373184204,
0.12773756682872772,
0.7864959836006165,
-0.3075353801250458,
0.08714692294597626,
-0.14555226266384125,
-0.6006325483322144,
-0.08648116886615753,
0.5039799809455872,
0.23708322644233704,
0.04709026962518692,
0.7103539109230042,
0.06381890177726746,
0.4713402986526489,
0.10475514084100723,
-0.007181643508374691,
0.02633979544043541,
-0.3256123661994934,
-0.2870917320251465,
-0.5082468390464783,
0.6622647047042847,
0.006064250599592924,
-0.2605128884315491,
0.1579364538192749,
-0.37595927715301514,
-0.24528852105140686,
0.20412577688694,
-0.4490199685096741,
0.02800135873258114,
-0.23574133217334747,
-0.34662333130836487,
-0.4608862102031708,
0.15528713166713715,
-0.5492467284202576,
-0.68852698802948,
-0.007475599646568298,
0.5336355566978455,
-0.1484937071800232,
-0.10455825179815292,
0.04650251939892769,
-0.5227123498916626,
-0.34524357318878174,
0.6311221122741699,
-0.5892479419708252,
0.030407369136810303,
0.872422993183136,
0.9499598145484924,
0.17840056121349335,
-0.24557657539844513,
-0.4856940805912018,
0.22011548280715942,
-0.4202996492385864,
0.9458969235420227,
-0.992315411567688,
-0.9642094969749451,
-0.4051857590675354,
-0.19209611415863037,
-0.18913155794143677,
-0.33911457657814026,
0.6441170573234558,
-0.4046241343021393,
0.22276537120342255,
-0.37491101026535034,
-0.5204324722290039,
-0.3365307152271271,
-0.09069161117076874,
-0.8750396966934204,
1.0507493019104004,
0.40437260270118713,
-0.8302721381187439,
0.07595063745975494,
-0.7572399973869324,
-0.2270391881465912,
-0.06160789355635643,
-0.10342725366353989,
-0.46358129382133484,
0.5411530137062073,
0.30744385719299316,
-0.038231704384088516,
0.13038957118988037,
0.24233900010585785,
-0.48938894271850586,
-0.4361341595649719,
0.23115895688533783,
-0.551285445690155,
0.8474512100219727,
-0.28100407123565674,
-0.1670534461736679,
0.5420437455177307,
-0.8138201832771301,
-0.07148093730211258,
-0.058735936880111694,
-0.27374860644340515,
-0.5654804110527039,
-0.11865189671516418,
-0.1357438713312149,
0.15810394287109375,
0.12033047527074814,
-0.4016055464744568,
0.6109154224395752,
-0.30779293179512024,
0.20111846923828125,
1.0632381439208984,
0.4616776704788208,
0.551264226436615,
-0.1238628402352333,
0.6827088594436646,
-0.17644378542900085,
0.7491006255149841,
0.1547972708940506,
-0.7433554530143738,
-0.6585955023765564,
-0.33606502413749695,
0.6445422768592834,
0.409420907497406,
-0.6243499517440796,
0.0007260215934365988,
-0.20030266046524048,
-0.6870556473731995,
-0.7003549337387085,
-0.022411929443478584,
0.33311060070991516,
0.4596455693244934,
0.16182589530944824,
-0.4826606214046478,
-0.4905957579612732,
-1.1079894304275513,
-0.7891391515731812,
-0.1419275850057602,
-0.07577293366193771,
0.3616396486759186,
0.6257712841033936,
-0.7898164987564087,
0.9178285598754883,
-0.5866791009902954,
-0.10219535231590271,
-0.2460993379354477,
0.22488458454608917,
-0.0008260139147751033,
0.4573526382446289,
0.3382413983345032,
-0.20018336176872253,
-0.24053651094436646,
-0.12184996902942657,
-0.5356162190437317,
-0.4507838785648346,
-0.44721049070358276,
-0.3509595990180969,
-0.22034333646297455,
0.20776458084583282,
-0.6730045676231384,
0.6632428169250488,
0.44933170080184937,
-0.26911282539367676,
0.803695023059845,
-0.2449052929878235,
0.2879064381122589,
-0.26713892817497253,
0.05975637212395668,
-0.11465239524841309,
0.11554509401321411,
-0.7055878043174744,
0.16467653214931488,
0.42346715927124023,
-0.353559672832489,
-0.2755695581436157,
0.9282366633415222,
-0.5923919081687927,
-0.10457190126180649,
-0.21541756391525269,
0.24457143247127533,
0.27584031224250793,
0.1234579011797905,
-0.5347235798835754,
0.613667368888855,
0.01913071982562542,
-0.2780275046825409,
-0.3746546506881714,
0.3268546462059021,
-0.4472464323043823,
0.040071770548820496,
-0.5613088607788086,
0.4872644543647766,
-0.3267398178577423,
0.08821503072977066,
-0.7317643165588379,
0.02095530554652214,
0.5092934370040894,
-0.14459021389484406,
0.6656122207641602,
-0.2963848412036896,
-0.11842655390501022,
-0.43553370237350464,
-0.5433617830276489,
0.244549959897995,
0.07114573568105698,
-0.14251874387264252,
0.7512610554695129,
0.522122859954834,
-0.4032641649246216,
-0.7101419568061829,
-0.5044786334037781,
0.517060399055481,
0.08705144375562668,
-0.9745684266090393,
0.22154119610786438,
-0.19437234103679657,
-0.5893982648849487,
-0.10631641000509262,
-0.1593926101922989,
0.03389904275536537,
0.257519006729126,
0.14084693789482117,
0.4703603982925415,
0.06189859285950661,
-0.23778143525123596,
0.41579604148864746,
-0.15069246292114258,
-0.18544921278953552,
0.45314639806747437,
0.1896103173494339,
0.15303312242031097,
-0.48527470231056213,
-0.5096332430839539,
0.360275000333786,
0.6032732725143433,
-0.3203684687614441,
0.3878171741962433,
0.2602987587451935,
-0.24219948053359985,
-0.19268624484539032,
-0.5172141790390015,
0.010220331139862537,
-0.4840744137763977,
0.9213687181472778,
-0.2940540611743927,
-0.6800450682640076,
0.5784083008766174,
-0.09563517570495605,
0.08263976126909256,
0.6659719347953796,
-0.006201510317623615,
0.13190366327762604,
1.3003977537155151,
1.0594748258590698,
-0.03139909729361534,
0.9396867752075195,
-0.09562601894140244,
0.48926249146461487,
-1.150483250617981,
-0.10869747400283813,
-0.5851582884788513,
-0.32330775260925293,
-0.36336854100227356,
-0.6581697463989258,
0.5214996933937073,
0.6116735935211182,
-0.011475997045636177,
-0.032261986285448074,
-0.29523709416389465,
0.3377948999404907,
0.3700704872608185,
0.24416525661945343,
0.40663328766822815,
-0.12818297743797302,
-0.0013609164161607623,
-0.2691451907157898,
-0.686005175113678,
-0.6520646214485168,
0.6828768253326416,
0.5553389191627502,
0.7738623023033142,
-0.1026645377278328,
0.4239601194858551,
0.4370553493499756,
0.4787425696849823,
-0.7764215469360352,
0.6300470232963562,
-0.004047330003231764,
-0.3814672827720642,
-0.533966600894928,
-0.4010036289691925,
-0.6866906881332397,
0.46804383397102356,
-0.19000940024852753,
-0.6564721465110779,
0.29857462644577026,
0.010973458178341389,
-0.17613762617111206,
0.3987455666065216,
-0.5674662590026855,
0.9806129932403564,
-0.2222413420677185,
-0.29341334104537964,
-0.49752169847488403,
-0.10242681950330734,
0.5497148633003235,
-0.08940394222736359,
0.6356435418128967,
-0.081985242664814,
0.09676816314458847,
0.8710413575172424,
-0.6665242314338684,
0.905121386051178,
-0.34028688073158264,
-0.15005528926849365,
0.11249052733182907,
0.5602326393127441,
0.9295479655265808,
0.0036988332867622375,
-0.03446144238114357,
0.4051842987537384,
-0.2790300250053406,
-0.37650540471076965,
-0.9344069957733154,
0.5373860597610474,
-0.581997275352478,
-0.9730258584022522,
-0.23949362337589264,
-0.6657712459564209,
-0.2660156786441803,
0.31532490253448486,
-0.0855545923113823,
0.2766225039958954,
-0.40505263209342957,
-0.36608240008354187,
0.31522634625434875,
-0.5794270038604736,
0.3812219798564911,
0.609501302242279,
-0.441612184047699,
-0.4581838846206665,
0.6472908854484558,
0.42515966296195984,
0.2425016313791275,
0.09317097812891006,
0.325355589389801,
0.16957606375217438,
-0.765566349029541,
-0.41877132654190063,
0.5392930507659912,
-0.8052056431770325,
0.28534314036369324,
-0.6574442386627197,
-0.26013097167015076,
-0.30798450112342834,
-0.2598532438278198,
-0.4478907287120819,
-0.37346333265304565,
-0.3560716211795807,
-0.01891751028597355,
-0.009639522060751915,
1.1580461263656616,
-0.26584169268608093,
0.3400328457355499,
-1.014089584350586,
0.05578504130244255,
0.2751924991607666,
0.4287935793399811,
0.1522398591041565,
-0.7217498421669006,
-0.3324132263660431,
0.2969374656677246,
-0.4044804573059082,
-0.6255172491073608,
0.27269288897514343,
0.09148984402418137,
0.6700582504272461,
0.3046796917915344,
-0.25640493631362915,
1.068114995956421,
-0.5756251811981201,
0.7359603643417358,
0.08235084265470505,
-1.2756800651550293,
0.7088797092437744,
-0.2145700305700302,
0.45333385467529297,
0.24757784605026245,
-0.18192975223064423,
-0.9595335721969604,
-0.5781835317611694,
-0.6818010807037354,
-0.7299985289573669,
0.3266775906085968,
0.02362716756761074,
0.18760645389556885,
-0.13605844974517822,
0.3546021580696106,
0.22598443925380707,
0.14437565207481384,
-0.5715875029563904,
0.005130136851221323,
0.26226985454559326,
0.29843708872795105,
0.21825385093688965,
-0.8047443628311157,
0.14347746968269348,
-0.20328888297080994,
0.8965312838554382,
0.26398715376853943,
0.12742814421653748,
0.13417214155197144,
-0.35956406593322754,
-0.4210299849510193,
0.2978421449661255,
0.6444997191429138,
0.7710989713668823,
-0.18109345436096191,
-0.2659038007259369,
0.03423335403203964,
-0.5428323149681091,
-0.3392232358455658,
-0.45833131670951843,
-0.7266125679016113,
0.31277963519096375,
0.7232445478439331,
1.101681113243103,
0.6126450300216675,
-0.5496590733528137,
0.43230774998664856,
0.044532738626003265,
0.17975766956806183,
0.2514835298061371,
0.14645306766033173,
-0.2998838424682617,
0.1870943307876587,
0.39724233746528625,
0.6278039216995239,
0.25834354758262634,
-0.4476875364780426,
0.09717626124620438,
0.5821822881698608,
-0.7057768702507019,
-0.38115373253822327,
0.6603667140007019,
0.09738320857286453,
-0.44669845700263977,
0.5677117109298706,
0.34806427359580994,
-0.4500122666358948,
0.5497857928276062,
0.17816151678562164,
0.9931876063346863,
-0.38607820868492126,
0.359796404838562,
0.24125204980373383,
0.527184009552002,
-0.09578686207532883,
0.230431467294693,
0.6327267289161682,
-0.4428254961967468,
-0.6762538552284241,
-0.2696046531200409,
-0.4526149332523346,
0.11059662699699402,
-0.6114650368690491,
0.35368475317955017,
-0.5920745134353638,
-0.20017331838607788,
-0.011545464396476746,
-0.3093133866786957,
-0.28339627385139465,
0.0017486723372712731,
0.026413599029183388,
0.845621645450592,
-0.6242809891700745,
0.44103312492370605,
0.2565002143383026,
-0.3411894142627716,
-0.5825331807136536,
-0.08528126776218414,
0.12105105072259903,
-0.7451766133308411,
0.4232043921947479,
-0.109162837266922,
-0.14496459066867828,
-0.18070681393146515,
-0.4962019920349121,
-1.078532338142395,
0.4966283142566681,
0.5902966856956482,
-0.9512344598770142,
-0.06683732569217682,
-0.02841411530971527,
0.5021065473556519,
0.15136094391345978,
0.5059968829154968,
0.4645216166973114,
0.760174036026001,
-0.16353584825992584,
-1.0044292211532593,
-0.08467863500118256,
-0.2856481373310089,
0.2791956663131714,
0.17264260351657867,
-0.6910422444343567,
0.7612547874450684,
-0.4333169460296631,
-0.3740327060222626,
-0.151841938495636,
0.41790133714675903,
-0.1179867535829544,
-0.07648003101348877,
0.34109386801719666,
0.3276374638080597,
1.083032488822937,
0.24571026861667633,
1.2824534177780151,
-0.07424895465373993,
0.5194573998451233,
1.0704795122146606,
-0.20508886873722076,
0.7734856605529785,
0.37621310353279114,
-0.173313170671463,
0.3374629318714142,
0.5485192537307739,
-0.1119014248251915,
0.4992215931415558,
0.184724360704422,
-0.2069975882768631,
0.04663608595728874,
0.05511388182640076,
-0.3985225260257721,
0.3231094479560852,
0.2866206467151642,
-0.32079219818115234,
-0.10972940921783447,
0.18294930458068848,
0.2959790825843811,
-0.19598878920078278,
-0.6205760836601257,
0.49102920293807983,
0.11136305332183838,
-0.09885567426681519,
0.4205544590950012,
0.24541279673576355,
0.36018308997154236,
-0.45226389169692993,
-0.1095430850982666,
-0.5025131702423096,
0.1211005449295044,
-0.2903802692890167,
-0.618273913860321,
0.3310604989528656,
-0.11142230033874512,
-0.4228113889694214,
-0.08004012703895569,
0.8355138301849365,
-0.021981067955493927,
-0.923346221446991,
0.5777655243873596,
0.5198650360107422,
-0.18558792769908905,
-0.29030969738960266,
-0.8461217880249023,
0.3926681876182556,
0.26289090514183044,
-0.5307672619819641,
0.40917661786079407,
0.2150050401687622,
-0.27211764454841614,
0.7063306570053101,
0.44771450757980347,
0.17436392605304718,
-0.03688093647360802,
0.5266357660293579,
0.7901465892791748,
-0.8543962836265564,
-0.3598129451274872,
-0.7983675599098206,
0.7447913289070129,
-0.19080817699432373,
-0.22110547125339508,
0.9726935625076294,
0.5470402240753174,
0.6724804639816284,
-0.24460795521736145,
1.1714268922805786,
0.16624756157398224,
0.3532121777534485,
-0.18440313637256622,
0.8044012784957886,
-0.3318435549736023,
0.6242038607597351,
-0.9467208981513977,
-0.8077006936073303,
-0.5914711952209473,
0.43089979887008667,
-0.7266836166381836,
-0.14414842426776886,
0.7488243579864502,
0.9635278582572937,
0.08273971825838089,
-0.11327800899744034,
0.4337504804134369,
0.73906409740448,
0.39496472477912903,
0.10415829718112946,
0.8988350629806519,
-0.6261447072029114,
0.2768974006175995,
-0.31584420800209045,
-0.45350295305252075,
-0.09378528594970703,
-0.6947125196456909,
-0.8132736682891846,
-0.21030016243457794,
-0.6568231582641602,
-0.2572772204875946,
0.2051326036453247,
0.43287980556488037,
0.2568742632865906,
-0.644449770450592,
-0.011730621568858624,
0.1579975038766861,
0.48159435391426086,
-0.3774627447128296,
-0.20683112740516663,
0.62608402967453,
0.1195005401968956,
-0.8379502296447754,
0.7187427282333374,
0.7883639931678772,
0.031464528292417526,
-0.026973435655236244,
0.09571224451065063,
-0.1055426150560379,
0.18889543414115906,
0.7054345607757568,
0.046709898859262466,
-0.7345141172409058,
-0.6874156594276428,
-0.37608492374420166,
-0.06450604647397995,
0.1461711972951889,
0.8942118287086487,
-0.4959525465965271,
0.6953345537185669,
0.4847851097583771,
0.4799332022666931,
0.408072829246521,
-0.11659172922372818,
0.5848871469497681,
-0.33513978123664856,
0.05676849186420441,
0.18578968942165375,
0.37983113527297974,
0.12413030117750168,
-0.5470483303070068,
0.44566625356674194,
0.4442072808742523,
-0.35243088006973267,
-1.1529878377914429,
-0.01763625256717205,
-0.8986095786094666,
-0.5379443168640137,
0.9780951142311096,
-0.049677737057209015,
-0.3295256197452545,
-0.0186415147036314,
-0.7332549691200256,
0.309032142162323,
-0.16240720450878143,
1.1549867391586304,
0.7996500730514526,
-0.06228576600551605,
-0.3236583471298218,
-0.5964583158493042,
0.05880862474441528,
0.27417728304862976,
-0.5070534348487854,
0.08001215755939484,
0.7310034036636353,
0.27910539507865906,
-0.2784465551376343,
0.38116180896759033,
-0.3452020287513733,
0.12026825547218323,
0.40623563528060913,
0.291186660528183,
-0.21845610439777374,
-0.1023443266749382,
-0.538908064365387,
0.1543034166097641,
0.26580068469047546,
0.38825559616088867
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07816v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07816v1
|
Branch-Train-MiX: Mixing Expert LLMs into a Mixture-of-Experts LLM
| 2024-03-12T16:54:58 | 2024-03-12T16:54:58 |
Sainbayar Sukhbaatar, Olga Golovneva, Vasu Sharma, Hu Xu, Xi Victoria Lin, Baptiste Rozière, Jacob Kahn, Daniel Li, Wen-tau Yih, Jason Weston, Xian Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We investigate efficient methods for training Large Language Models (LLMs) to
possess capabilities in multiple specialized domains, such as coding, math
reasoning and world knowledge. Our method, named Branch-Train-MiX (BTX), starts
from a seed model, which is branched to train experts in embarrassingly
parallel fashion with high throughput and reduced communication cost. After
individual experts are asynchronously trained, BTX brings together their
feedforward parameters as experts in Mixture-of-Expert (MoE) layers and
averages the remaining parameters, followed by an MoE-finetuning stage to learn
token-level routing. BTX generalizes two special cases, the Branch-Train-Merge
method, which does not have the MoE finetuning stage to learn routing, and
sparse upcycling, which omits the stage of training experts asynchronously.
Compared to alternative approaches, BTX achieves the best accuracy-efficiency
tradeoff.
|
[
-0.6538287997245789,
-0.6300991773605347,
0.32118794322013855,
0.4387305974960327,
-0.30741119384765625,
0.8324518799781799,
-0.28901270031929016,
-0.38351404666900635,
0.22554144263267517,
0.6602155566215515,
-0.6702827215194702,
-0.2245084047317505,
-0.5846132636070251,
-0.24643681943416595,
-0.5642814636230469,
0.5767655968666077,
-0.11519154161214828,
0.23850436508655548,
-0.03884383663535118,
0.03084828145802021,
-0.47766533493995667,
-0.6175090074539185,
-0.7743541598320007,
-0.5627132654190063,
0.2755674123764038,
0.499441921710968,
0.39382895827293396,
0.7448038458824158,
0.23887847363948822,
0.3371116518974304,
-0.3473745286464691,
0.4280693531036377,
-0.4886549115180969,
0.19474826753139496,
-0.14279335737228394,
-0.40243661403656006,
-0.5097874402999878,
-0.21233560144901276,
0.48222407698631287,
0.8411998748779297,
-0.26667875051498413,
-0.30646780133247375,
-0.11644507944583893,
0.4994910955429077,
-0.37908971309661865,
0.09551043063402176,
-1.0308029651641846,
-0.04591958597302437,
0.030739931389689445,
-0.30371764302253723,
-0.23709657788276672,
-0.19094668328762054,
0.07291807234287262,
-0.22879624366760254,
0.09948534518480301,
0.2032911330461502,
0.5327978730201721,
0.13316218554973602,
-0.4934454560279846,
-0.04288831353187561,
-0.6258787512779236,
0.8150803446769714,
-0.8311880230903625,
0.6212639212608337,
0.1318574696779251,
0.4324074387550354,
0.06702019274234772,
-0.35368046164512634,
-0.3768335282802582,
0.09847332537174225,
0.21232223510742188,
0.19349338114261627,
0.08737683296203613,
0.24690932035446167,
0.1613723784685135,
0.33837857842445374,
-0.25503072142601013,
0.3420104682445526,
-0.2882613241672516,
-0.0016854784917086363,
0.7935181856155396,
0.08652675896883011,
0.09540033340454102,
0.1189378947019577,
-0.31188297271728516,
-0.07632840424776077,
-0.751837432384491,
-0.11913887411355972,
0.3438359200954437,
0.19268563389778137,
0.13663753867149353,
0.39686813950538635,
-0.31441548466682434,
0.9075399041175842,
0.1819903403520584,
-0.4057178497314453,
-0.13700397312641144,
-0.4805781841278076,
-0.13037514686584473,
0.0657934918999672,
0.5957593321800232,
0.03225713223218918,
0.3777833878993988,
-0.6164044141769409,
-0.4086361825466156,
-0.2591157555580139,
0.25010672211647034,
-0.6905085444450378,
-0.3499508500099182,
0.1342320442199707,
-0.010967587120831013,
-0.4034709930419922,
-0.2542484402656555,
-0.5161313414573669,
-0.07620973885059357,
-0.6065764427185059,
0.41755953431129456,
-0.5158782601356506,
-0.410127192735672,
-0.10398635268211365,
-0.2318774163722992,
0.09507894515991211,
0.47328367829322815,
-1.0124763250350952,
0.6097449660301208,
0.8827871084213257,
0.6439778208732605,
-0.26680314540863037,
-0.424095094203949,
-0.45948705077171326,
0.10154642164707184,
-0.39292046427726746,
0.6998321413993835,
-0.385093629360199,
-0.523377537727356,
-0.14322839677333832,
-0.5146852135658264,
0.04440340772271156,
-0.7519121170043945,
0.12532766163349152,
-0.6828218698501587,
-0.22805221378803253,
-0.12002680450677872,
-0.6167500615119934,
-0.28830212354660034,
0.1425689309835434,
-0.21959303319454193,
1.0426905155181885,
0.2963555157184601,
-0.5711511373519897,
0.3798774182796478,
-0.04285759851336479,
-0.42629873752593994,
-0.11929867416620255,
-0.21913783252239227,
-0.0832739919424057,
0.07488737255334854,
0.3618784248828888,
0.5738009214401245,
0.03095276467502117,
0.2588563561439514,
-0.2563847303390503,
-0.24938255548477173,
0.22621402144432068,
-0.2441495954990387,
0.7746789455413818,
0.07797421514987946,
-0.22609113156795502,
0.17017851769924164,
-0.7358949184417725,
0.07452550530433655,
-0.26856204867362976,
-0.3947249948978424,
-0.5674565434455872,
0.022316759452223778,
0.11420890688896179,
0.30884024500846863,
-0.02573779784142971,
-0.23214486241340637,
0.2936074137687683,
-0.31772705912590027,
0.5045545697212219,
0.8271685838699341,
-0.04627063497900963,
0.5386568307876587,
-0.3429834544658661,
0.25337961316108704,
0.2678695619106293,
-0.2725977897644043,
-0.2204868048429489,
-0.5695763826370239,
-1.1157516241073608,
-0.37337955832481384,
0.5965273380279541,
0.47065624594688416,
-0.7501323819160461,
0.7038923501968384,
-0.16114938259124756,
-0.6374348402023315,
-0.46559128165245056,
0.41802626848220825,
0.35426706075668335,
0.2143259048461914,
0.4125557541847229,
-0.5237306356430054,
-0.4549958109855652,
-0.621696412563324,
-0.17382562160491943,
0.11529164016246796,
0.27477139234542847,
0.15612094104290009,
0.3257942795753479,
-0.36220088601112366,
1.0754504203796387,
-0.4473285675048828,
0.283383846282959,
-0.3701012134552002,
0.2853759825229645,
-0.012736066244542599,
0.6698166131973267,
0.3487708270549774,
-0.4530307948589325,
-0.7484992742538452,
0.2909713685512543,
-0.46850869059562683,
0.037095461040735245,
-0.02488022670149803,
-0.16314545273780823,
0.08455770462751389,
0.43058058619499207,
-0.5989211797714233,
-0.0000352670977008529,
0.5162912607192993,
-0.08530683815479279,
0.46092480421066284,
-0.14228811860084534,
0.13646884262561798,
-1.1498795747756958,
-0.4377869963645935,
-0.05496969819068909,
-0.5536935329437256,
-0.6989056468009949,
0.31603896617889404,
0.20820832252502441,
-0.029434075579047203,
-0.21213337779045105,
0.4902345836162567,
-0.73124098777771,
-0.039685722440481186,
-0.4396434724330902,
-0.03843839839100838,
-0.28946805000305176,
0.6025025844573975,
0.15378597378730774,
0.6815992593765259,
0.8721314668655396,
-0.5063151121139526,
0.41515272855758667,
-0.057107336819171906,
-0.09946752339601517,
0.33092179894447327,
-0.37131595611572266,
0.24869205057621002,
0.16286104917526245,
-0.12256073951721191,
-0.853303074836731,
-0.20616522431373596,
0.05717986449599266,
-0.2861245274543762,
0.6461376547813416,
-0.16032123565673828,
-0.4827924370765686,
-0.4051588475704193,
-0.16649580001831055,
0.33361828327178955,
0.8434193730354309,
-0.4805254638195038,
0.6600422263145447,
0.2331824004650116,
-0.24212035536766052,
-0.7209909558296204,
-0.7160120010375977,
0.059632185846567154,
-0.16382302343845367,
-0.626602292060852,
0.3916434347629547,
-0.12216539680957794,
-0.22090008854866028,
0.1704769879579544,
-0.42661044001579285,
-0.5784195065498352,
0.11926697194576263,
0.03187587112188339,
-0.1074855700135231,
-0.18224672973155975,
-0.3545137941837311,
0.5308164358139038,
-0.0026835447642952204,
0.017011726275086403,
-0.3293682634830475,
0.5390874743461609,
0.09752318263053894,
-0.609423041343689,
-0.07717817276716232,
0.596141517162323,
0.46872395277023315,
-0.09495922178030014,
0.5741260647773743,
0.42739230394363403,
-0.2965530455112457,
-0.5234102606773376,
-0.8891345262527466,
-0.27556511759757996,
-0.4414348602294922,
0.4660249948501587,
-0.2276599258184433,
-1.0405272245407104,
0.512894868850708,
-0.24862632155418396,
0.2004077434539795,
0.05435381084680557,
0.5212569236755371,
0.06362198293209076,
0.8750056624412537,
0.7080265283584595,
-0.16165006160736084,
0.3453921973705292,
-0.47569769620895386,
0.32032132148742676,
-0.5598178505897522,
-0.1437220573425293,
-0.42859604954719543,
-0.08906064927577972,
-0.3018465042114258,
-0.8265361785888672,
0.19002418220043182,
0.4000641703605652,
-0.2873786985874176,
0.30440467596054077,
-0.20464648306369781,
0.507872462272644,
0.8031706809997559,
0.1965682953596115,
0.5783655047416687,
0.3130602538585663,
-0.007708755787461996,
0.18638424575328827,
-1.1781634092330933,
0.06778039783239365,
1.2056810855865479,
0.408700555562973,
0.9619103074073792,
-0.1985689252614975,
1.0271140336990356,
-0.11292075365781784,
0.2696034014225006,
-0.9628463983535767,
0.5618681907653809,
-0.026517413556575775,
-0.5443975329399109,
-0.13671714067459106,
-0.6533321738243103,
-0.4986802339553833,
0.33211758732795715,
-0.3434787690639496,
-0.4797673523426056,
0.06644708663225174,
0.09546133875846863,
-0.1599286049604416,
0.5779783129692078,
-0.6672743558883667,
0.41511163115501404,
-0.5042097568511963,
-0.16113728284835815,
-0.5827442407608032,
-0.5770664215087891,
0.5975809693336487,
-0.4900888204574585,
0.1777869164943695,
0.21341556310653687,
-0.041943736374378204,
0.7698872685432434,
-0.5287299156188965,
0.749660849571228,
0.1191611960530281,
0.2915648818016052,
0.18549275398254395,
0.07333189249038696,
0.3717021942138672,
-0.060923539102077484,
0.24043715000152588,
0.2629956007003784,
-0.4360017776489258,
-0.43045783042907715,
-0.566118597984314,
0.6310861110687256,
-1.3408308029174805,
-0.55876624584198,
-0.1996125727891922,
-0.8348283171653748,
-0.5192518830299377,
0.19976437091827393,
-0.024077588692307472,
0.6747843027114868,
0.2330714613199234,
0.17173928022384644,
0.8685031533241272,
0.2403111457824707,
0.4309018552303314,
0.4054965078830719,
-0.18354931473731995,
-0.7855426073074341,
0.8439173698425293,
0.30717629194259644,
0.41526973247528076,
0.4811418056488037,
0.07751461863517761,
-0.11113230139017105,
-0.9048644304275513,
-0.3259020447731018,
0.2755882740020752,
-0.7974002361297607,
-0.24023765325546265,
-0.8925812244415283,
-0.6469704508781433,
-0.1012263372540474,
-0.3292630910873413,
-0.5414876341819763,
-0.2479858100414276,
-0.001642474438995123,
0.0029727655928581953,
0.41193297505378723,
0.7166391611099243,
0.08653608709573746,
0.7967458367347717,
-0.8926517367362976,
0.06578689068555832,
0.7243439555168152,
0.2096882313489914,
0.17821085453033447,
-0.4817942678928375,
-0.4840802848339081,
-0.0010151425376534462,
-0.37603408098220825,
-1.004111886024475,
0.33073368668556213,
-0.045877207070589066,
1.0000079870224,
0.4750042259693146,
-0.3439175486564636,
0.8259068727493286,
-0.5479649305343628,
0.44059887528419495,
0.5168206691741943,
-1.0904573202133179,
0.19623538851737976,
-0.3511028587818146,
-0.17467965185642242,
0.5323215126991272,
0.6769301295280457,
-0.26818037033081055,
-0.6340183615684509,
-0.7363245487213135,
-1.0297737121582031,
0.7971212267875671,
0.1594681292772293,
-0.06396625936031342,
0.374073326587677,
0.11273138970136642,
0.39208945631980896,
0.5242191553115845,
-0.6538098454475403,
-0.3285422623157501,
-0.0783248171210289,
-0.10423935949802399,
-0.05695194751024246,
-0.2620544135570526,
-0.3863716423511505,
-0.5737659931182861,
0.5957105159759521,
-0.03692149370908737,
0.2341311126947403,
-0.25909075140953064,
-0.033248160034418106,
-0.15025047957897186,
0.13120697438716888,
0.2847073972225189,
1.191949486732483,
-0.32485830783843994,
0.17260995507240295,
0.2714337408542633,
-0.120254285633564,
0.27769631147384644,
0.03318169340491295,
-0.056790608912706375,
-0.0090872161090374,
0.4975879192352295,
0.9543654322624207,
0.3849973678588867,
-0.5439472794532776,
0.2648484408855438,
0.2387668639421463,
-0.5537367463111877,
0.1289147436618805,
0.36234045028686523,
0.421222060918808,
0.41607940196990967,
0.42776358127593994,
0.3959049582481384,
-0.06011992320418358,
-0.5870897769927979,
0.21928702294826508,
0.35423293709754944,
-0.17623920738697052,
-0.01583542302250862,
0.4118553400039673,
0.4700638949871063,
-0.38607844710350037,
0.4502484202384949,
-0.15965212881565094,
-0.6934151649475098,
0.5478194355964661,
0.4442664682865143,
0.9443609714508057,
-0.1054651141166687,
-0.044628143310546875,
-0.05161657929420471,
0.2733384668827057,
-0.2915998101234436,
0.046565942466259,
-0.26681795716285706,
-0.7690470218658447,
-0.8661782741546631,
-0.45706430077552795,
-0.7334828972816467,
-0.19915065169334412,
-0.4015079140663147,
0.28161945939064026,
-0.37273871898651123,
0.03010915406048298,
-0.37446969747543335,
-0.1057714968919754,
-0.6059581637382507,
0.22621820867061615,
0.2032599002122879,
1.2333885431289673,
-1.0036998987197876,
0.9998169541358948,
0.9073631763458252,
0.009143172763288021,
-1.216817021369934,
0.11366681754589081,
-0.4182560443878174,
-0.9094674587249756,
0.851987898349762,
0.04167849197983742,
0.15020249783992767,
0.2412194013595581,
-0.23305468261241913,
-0.6342160701751709,
1.0295805931091309,
0.030057862401008606,
-0.6004330515861511,
-0.10321827232837677,
-0.09865923225879669,
0.29666346311569214,
-0.488649845123291,
0.6488721370697021,
0.5729386210441589,
0.16487950086593628,
0.3742750287055969,
-0.8716069459915161,
-0.19764596223831177,
0.009089303202927113,
0.02683974802494049,
0.03650304302573204,
-0.7426957488059998,
0.8902660012245178,
0.21812725067138672,
0.24479974806308746,
-0.3531952202320099,
0.7702704668045044,
0.43259525299072266,
0.22055494785308838,
0.7153465151786804,
0.7637280225753784,
0.6938280463218689,
-0.17127878963947296,
0.5894548892974854,
-0.5846460461616516,
0.4221723675727844,
0.6447256207466125,
-0.0153952706605196,
0.7636116147041321,
0.4730856716632843,
-0.330462247133255,
0.44610831141471863,
0.9625284075737,
0.4109228849411011,
0.7003716826438904,
0.06866642087697983,
-0.10838568210601807,
-0.5480972528457642,
0.4224664270877838,
-0.6264395117759705,
0.12061675637960434,
0.24675071239471436,
0.07235319167375565,
-0.4378090500831604,
-0.12078993022441864,
0.08549433946609497,
-0.1487477719783783,
-0.5437279343605042,
0.8411678671836853,
0.2550792396068573,
-0.8043190240859985,
0.703620433807373,
0.004133422393351793,
0.8964189887046814,
-0.8290210962295532,
0.21533995866775513,
-0.40902766585350037,
0.010821666568517685,
-0.1906338930130005,
-0.9533471465110779,
0.21106630563735962,
-0.13226987421512604,
-0.09276296943426132,
-0.3347547650337219,
0.5523516535758972,
-0.7411372065544128,
-0.5547078251838684,
0.43122801184654236,
0.7761796712875366,
0.09059632569551468,
-0.11747344583272934,
-0.7499508857727051,
-0.06586325168609619,
-0.1518646776676178,
-0.15369673073291779,
0.4598082900047302,
0.6553623676300049,
0.1385086625814438,
0.7557875514030457,
0.387378454208374,
0.4551243185997009,
0.3504672646522522,
-0.05017543211579323,
1.2987207174301147,
-0.6222659349441528,
-0.6517249345779419,
-0.7938418984413147,
0.5199570059776306,
-0.207823246717453,
-0.06858163326978683,
0.75419020652771,
0.4250587522983551,
0.958263635635376,
-0.15567325055599213,
0.9215278625488281,
0.12046400457620621,
0.29721564054489136,
-0.6017295718193054,
0.4437149167060852,
-0.7513020634651184,
0.26987224817276,
-0.16578848659992218,
-1.0204386711120605,
0.1984194666147232,
0.2679048478603363,
-0.16642656922340393,
0.40441614389419556,
0.7919902205467224,
0.6588404178619385,
-0.4349076449871063,
-0.17892052233219147,
0.31816360354423523,
0.09757786244153976,
0.1585695445537567,
0.527357280254364,
0.8720721006393433,
-0.01844925247132778,
0.3019310235977173,
-0.5562087893486023,
-0.45715978741645813,
-0.5589513182640076,
-0.699501097202301,
-1.3443031311035156,
-0.12296499311923981,
-0.3543018698692322,
-0.1398502141237259,
0.18247951567173004,
1.1078150272369385,
1.2191047668457031,
-0.8239972591400146,
-0.6879934072494507,
-0.3238365054130554,
0.34184175729751587,
-0.40683192014694214,
-0.16544808447360992,
-0.021977636963129044,
-0.5397408604621887,
-0.6975106000900269,
0.39614641666412354,
0.38155847787857056,
-0.18258918821811676,
-0.5221745371818542,
-0.09303852915763855,
0.00988688226789236,
0.11931294947862625,
0.541716992855072,
-0.11361785978078842,
-0.6176230311393738,
0.1306421011686325,
0.030790185555815697,
-0.06806762516498566,
0.07447236776351929,
1.007112979888916,
-0.4903504550457001,
0.5306529998779297,
0.7883594036102295,
1.0822231769561768,
0.5708951950073242,
0.2200954109430313,
0.5606405138969421,
-0.7910486459732056,
0.18313242495059967,
0.1668778508901596,
0.2815786302089691,
0.25611841678619385,
-0.15419313311576843,
0.33232948184013367,
0.7219553589820862,
-0.6218978762626648,
-0.7582448124885559,
0.05738653242588043,
-1.5221840143203735,
-0.43461593985557556,
1.1759731769561768,
0.029622694477438927,
-0.06691943854093552,
-0.14882679283618927,
-0.19683429598808289,
0.15892404317855835,
-0.4666755795478821,
0.5349615216255188,
0.6474115252494812,
-0.1022343635559082,
-0.3095957934856415,
-0.5168589353561401,
0.25826528668403625,
0.3429594933986664,
-0.7361069321632385,
-0.3124048709869385,
0.03143919259309769,
0.43352562189102173,
-0.030669977888464928,
0.6477185487747192,
0.39297741651535034,
-0.01764794997870922,
0.20182617008686066,
0.10858359932899475,
-0.29195454716682434,
-0.5232479572296143,
-0.06777207553386688,
0.02628057450056076,
0.40757083892822266,
0.12849339842796326
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07809v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07809v1
|
pyvene: A Library for Understanding and Improving PyTorch Models via Interventions
| 2024-03-12T16:46:54 | 2024-03-12T16:46:54 |
Zhengxuan Wu, Atticus Geiger, Aryaman Arora, Jing Huang, Zheng Wang, Noah D. Goodman, Christopher D. Manning, Christopher Potts
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Interventions on model-internal states are fundamental operations in many
areas of AI, including model editing, steering, robustness, and
interpretability. To facilitate such research, we introduce $\textbf{pyvene}$,
an open-source Python library that supports customizable interventions on a
range of different PyTorch modules. $\textbf{pyvene}$ supports complex
intervention schemes with an intuitive configuration format, and its
interventions can be static or include trainable parameters. We show how
$\textbf{pyvene}$ provides a unified and extensible framework for performing
interventions on neural models and sharing the intervened upon models with
others. We illustrate the power of the library via interpretability analyses
using causal abstraction and knowledge localization. We publish our library
through Python Package Index (PyPI) and provide code, documentation, and
tutorials at https://github.com/stanfordnlp/pyvene.
|
[
-0.07540977001190186,
-0.5645995140075684,
0.2838946282863617,
0.21388162672519684,
0.12954339385032654,
-0.7731737494468689,
-0.3102825880050659,
-0.22175683081150055,
0.24865569174289703,
0.23246966302394867,
-0.27563202381134033,
-0.4781988561153412,
-0.4422401487827301,
-0.21969281136989594,
-0.23553456366062164,
1.0516635179519653,
-0.46473488211631775,
0.2254723161458969,
-0.053599171340465546,
-0.3099851906299591,
-0.5622106194496155,
-0.10745007544755936,
-0.40732038021087646,
-0.47512349486351013,
1.0791704654693604,
0.06279046833515167,
0.38695329427719116,
0.2502574026584625,
0.592035710811615,
0.4103148579597473,
-0.19616669416427612,
-0.04965660721063614,
-0.24782685935497284,
0.3064842224121094,
-0.744641125202179,
-0.2337668538093567,
-0.08972576260566711,
0.054053135216236115,
0.4282699227333069,
0.6219012141227722,
-0.17080961167812347,
0.09337072819471359,
0.1195313036441803,
0.2649625837802887,
-0.9984728693962097,
0.22250857949256897,
-0.16922886669635773,
-0.2579197883605957,
0.3108222186565399,
0.36465033888816833,
-0.2600752115249634,
-0.3558902144432068,
0.5186727046966553,
-0.5496963858604431,
-0.09046834707260132,
-0.5048030018806458,
0.33255892992019653,
0.5460227131843567,
-0.31066566705703735,
-0.3362409770488739,
-0.4954378306865692,
0.21046583354473114,
-0.544755220413208,
-0.03624221310019493,
0.02283887192606926,
0.385881632566452,
-0.44959932565689087,
-1.1966147422790527,
-0.2010207623243332,
-0.22327691316604614,
-0.266299307346344,
0.01067791786044836,
-0.438632994890213,
0.7133639454841614,
0.35481348633766174,
0.24473918974399567,
-0.2678500711917877,
-0.06927649676799774,
-0.0925053060054779,
-0.35354965925216675,
0.4298994243144989,
0.072612464427948,
0.6106504797935486,
-0.02217983640730381,
0.09578975290060043,
-0.09040895104408264,
-0.14037521183490753,
0.16374030709266663,
0.653724730014801,
-0.13543884456157684,
-0.010976024903357029,
0.8649934530258179,
-0.19020189344882965,
0.6880263686180115,
-0.29629090428352356,
0.5959876179695129,
-0.24611349403858185,
-0.05782248452305794,
-0.4067382216453552,
0.07396715134382248,
0.5446503162384033,
0.29688137769699097,
-0.31798404455184937,
-0.4076918065547943,
-0.1188034936785698,
-0.11516356468200684,
0.4754313826560974,
-0.936119019985199,
-0.888133704662323,
0.6348604559898376,
-0.5183706283569336,
-0.23387238383293152,
0.24754497408866882,
-0.4739576578140259,
-0.7975221276283264,
-0.5380366444587708,
0.9288020133972168,
-0.31658852100372314,
-0.5014050006866455,
0.273445188999176,
-0.7490494251251221,
-0.13006876409053802,
0.32375890016555786,
-0.641551673412323,
0.10411915183067322,
0.5865986347198486,
1.0252918004989624,
-0.05106674134731293,
-0.3840928077697754,
-0.34291529655456543,
-0.1029399037361145,
-0.11332513391971588,
0.6065283417701721,
-0.20300224423408508,
-0.1565985530614853,
0.26149600744247437,
0.39232200384140015,
-0.3119506537914276,
-0.2362930178642273,
0.3668210506439209,
-0.38025084137916565,
0.02350323460996151,
-0.005667696241289377,
-0.7678367495536804,
-0.6018338799476624,
-0.0712011307477951,
-0.6409750580787659,
0.4462682008743286,
0.05283058062195778,
-1.0538891553878784,
0.18585406243801117,
-1.228954553604126,
-0.12535181641578674,
-0.3295080363750458,
0.4507847726345062,
-0.42193707823753357,
0.46146857738494873,
0.06696222722530365,
0.2031535655260086,
0.1045115515589714,
0.3489314913749695,
-0.3544406294822693,
-0.3040168285369873,
0.2075757533311844,
-0.459598571062088,
0.7741155624389648,
0.024818075820803642,
-0.2735261023044586,
1.0725090503692627,
-0.6828351616859436,
0.020810209214687347,
-0.11560758203268051,
0.021236656233668327,
-0.5776307582855225,
0.02006043680012226,
0.18965549767017365,
-0.30176785588264465,
0.47259989380836487,
-0.36876627802848816,
0.5067582130432129,
-0.6866323351860046,
0.5463936924934387,
0.5929874777793884,
0.2613765001296997,
0.6268912553787231,
0.02800580859184265,
0.18665817379951477,
-0.2487703263759613,
0.25722381472587585,
-0.360533744096756,
-0.5066894888877869,
-0.3109092712402344,
-0.5478764176368713,
0.08733958005905151,
0.427611380815506,
-0.7397342920303345,
0.23334947228431702,
0.3268415629863739,
-0.4334946572780609,
-0.2471340298652649,
-0.09413658827543259,
0.3465457260608673,
0.4782189726829529,
0.36461618542671204,
0.0713396742939949,
-0.6225801110267639,
-0.9933987259864807,
-0.4914076030254364,
-0.15878310799598694,
-0.18121778964996338,
0.2771632671356201,
0.8084540963172913,
-0.310564249753952,
0.9238105416297913,
-0.2796199321746826,
0.31118452548980713,
0.12810257077217102,
0.49826860427856445,
0.6011950969696045,
0.677566409111023,
0.13901332020759583,
-0.4223173260688782,
-0.13434767723083496,
0.07172751426696777,
-0.8756372928619385,
-0.3417714238166809,
-0.06031929329037666,
-0.3685820996761322,
-0.06894851475954056,
0.1891390085220337,
-0.43855202198028564,
0.6610265374183655,
0.4057597219944,
-0.4413227140903473,
0.6621947884559631,
-0.6549685597419739,
0.23876714706420898,
-0.9649094343185425,
0.3594866991043091,
0.08589468151330948,
0.3077572286128998,
-0.8190186023712158,
0.1486644297838211,
0.2602645456790924,
-0.06984399259090424,
-0.4974239766597748,
0.6068273782730103,
-0.0002878560626413673,
0.08553974330425262,
-0.24526278674602509,
-0.3180047571659088,
-0.3245044946670532,
0.10673898458480835,
0.18951372802257538,
0.7269055247306824,
0.5469345450401306,
-0.2953885793685913,
0.33836930990219116,
0.30388393998146057,
-0.4667946994304657,
0.2787626087665558,
-1.0306730270385742,
0.19366563856601715,
-0.0807827040553093,
-0.0908660814166069,
-0.7066395282745361,
-0.7990878820419312,
0.5958754420280457,
-0.20568042993545532,
0.17467744648456573,
-0.6656555533409119,
-0.12304478138685226,
-0.09569790214300156,
-0.16990357637405396,
0.338024377822876,
0.035708699375391006,
-0.9310246109962463,
0.6809781789779663,
0.25898537039756775,
0.2773638069629669,
-0.6163070797920227,
-0.1890084147453308,
0.11680608242750168,
-0.3725597560405731,
-0.8252238631248474,
-0.004275239072740078,
-0.06924997270107269,
-0.45586779713630676,
0.23218464851379395,
0.20325174927711487,
-0.27444523572921753,
0.05498399958014488,
0.40821751952171326,
0.13958421349525452,
-0.20759515464305878,
0.26847612857818604,
0.20655439794063568,
-0.1378827691078186,
0.06428386270999908,
-0.7552271485328674,
0.20099136233329773,
-0.06718260794878006,
-0.3652366101741791,
-0.8800808787345886,
0.12826907634735107,
0.46384018659591675,
-0.15053874254226685,
0.6728648543357849,
0.6373530030250549,
-0.4463343918323517,
-0.027318265289068222,
-0.07140840590000153,
-0.23960518836975098,
-0.45641806721687317,
0.47275006771087646,
-0.25182396173477173,
-0.4679431617259979,
0.2517496943473816,
-0.2727982699871063,
0.051823049783706665,
0.11379209905862808,
0.7041357159614563,
-0.05911571905016899,
1.067945122718811,
0.4521610736846924,
-0.11496054381132126,
0.857520341873169,
-0.3605416417121887,
0.05942410230636597,
-0.8833181858062744,
-0.2108679562807083,
-0.3279980421066284,
-0.36920440196990967,
-0.5850735902786255,
-0.36715298891067505,
0.564336895942688,
0.5754982829093933,
-0.7379370331764221,
0.4794843792915344,
-1.0269030332565308,
0.5884942412376404,
0.4696303606033325,
0.14574961364269257,
-0.2571253180503845,
0.12354019284248352,
0.34071409702301025,
0.025525866076350212,
-0.8964733481407166,
-0.39436978101730347,
0.789210319519043,
0.2954387962818146,
0.9879283308982849,
-0.05721291899681091,
0.5899289846420288,
0.02319788560271263,
0.5273041725158691,
-1.0817961692810059,
-0.044782787561416626,
0.30591219663619995,
-0.3517058789730072,
-0.2474166303873062,
-0.3359445333480835,
-1.2309627532958984,
0.31134068965911865,
-0.19623780250549316,
-1.3125990629196167,
0.4322291612625122,
0.23178113996982574,
-0.24012747406959534,
0.4445285201072693,
-1.0017443895339966,
1.2695988416671753,
0.011445555835962296,
-0.6782010197639465,
-0.571515679359436,
-0.34812596440315247,
0.40429678559303284,
0.5562511086463928,
-0.20656493306159973,
0.2738533914089203,
-0.026734784245491028,
0.3354904353618622,
-0.4746096432209015,
0.9887855648994446,
-0.4811336100101471,
0.02971489354968071,
0.3225937783718109,
0.302282452583313,
0.6488777995109558,
0.44584646821022034,
-0.006502874195575714,
0.3088739216327667,
0.24547527730464935,
-0.2594531774520874,
-0.873185932636261,
0.8310390710830688,
-0.8782987594604492,
-0.4105605483055115,
-0.41791316866874695,
-1.15354585647583,
0.2149474024772644,
0.12144692987203598,
-0.11230933666229248,
0.7267666459083557,
-0.21733348071575165,
0.07276884466409683,
0.6473379731178284,
-0.5610415935516357,
0.4554333984851837,
0.36855554580688477,
-0.09726765751838684,
-0.7229419350624084,
0.9904815554618835,
-0.04068944603204727,
-0.07978438585996628,
-0.021830961108207703,
0.48917123675346375,
-0.39605462551116943,
-0.4294428825378418,
0.005000989884138107,
0.08334441483020782,
-0.9076430797576904,
0.28427600860595703,
-0.45195165276527405,
0.09249460697174072,
-0.18471381068229675,
-0.24137084186077118,
-0.16783350706100464,
-0.42681005597114563,
-0.2664867043495178,
0.32542309165000916,
0.5415486097335815,
1.1074252128601074,
-0.5551204085350037,
0.5896578431129456,
-0.520452082157135,
0.062232308089733124,
0.1708456575870514,
0.2534586787223816,
-0.08874072134494781,
-0.21177420020103455,
-0.31543785333633423,
-0.015104502439498901,
-0.032860059291124344,
-0.9136132001876831,
0.23115260899066925,
-0.10209011286497116,
0.5592986941337585,
0.1735563427209854,
-0.11842693388462067,
0.4324475824832916,
-0.27983686327934265,
0.639153778553009,
0.38802245259284973,
-0.7816037535667419,
0.7612251043319702,
-0.2897000014781952,
0.0007535450276918709,
0.11738765984773636,
0.3011726140975952,
-0.6503345370292664,
0.034129753708839417,
-0.6006760597229004,
-1.0551648139953613,
0.7020838856697083,
0.24635380506515503,
0.00009755803330335766,
0.1282140463590622,
0.7538573145866394,
-0.18641716241836548,
0.19328485429286957,
-0.2846820652484894,
-0.06788582354784012,
-0.42406898736953735,
-0.41158774495124817,
0.27805060148239136,
-0.054642289876937866,
-0.4639216661453247,
-0.37853920459747314,
0.6848271489143372,
-0.24948222935199738,
0.1385766714811325,
0.45421263575553894,
-0.2935006022453308,
0.2025272250175476,
-0.2113770693540573,
0.28630223870277405,
0.3726988434791565,
-0.1921951025724411,
0.03609335422515869,
0.02713869698345661,
-0.22707723081111908,
-0.05360635370016098,
0.059582214802503586,
-0.15521657466888428,
-0.2510092556476593,
0.649280846118927,
0.809168815612793,
0.2020215392112732,
-0.459333598613739,
0.3039243221282959,
-0.27742528915405273,
0.21818770468235016,
-0.14331087470054626,
0.26056107878685,
-0.1490260660648346,
0.728694498538971,
-0.4928864538669586,
0.12741374969482422,
0.36996081471443176,
-0.20582938194274902,
0.23795098066329956,
0.2785969078540802,
-0.7265303134918213,
-0.3078148066997528,
0.7875869870185852,
0.021239053457975388,
-0.4913591742515564,
0.6279001235961914,
0.07453341037034988,
-0.06713645160198212,
0.7932664155960083,
0.3227061629295349,
0.9539790749549866,
-0.01957855187356472,
0.3124455511569977,
0.7326979041099548,
0.23873956501483917,
-0.10123524069786072,
0.17392438650131226,
-0.04842774569988251,
-0.595563530921936,
-0.6158533692359924,
-0.3080448508262634,
-0.3459145724773407,
-0.05683831125497818,
-0.5867871642112732,
0.23393180966377258,
-0.2765992283821106,
0.08192700147628784,
-0.07619372010231018,
-0.21960245072841644,
-0.28285616636276245,
-0.28022196888923645,
-0.2545056939125061,
0.948203980922699,
-0.5204375386238098,
0.9075801372528076,
0.9146818518638611,
-0.7977184057235718,
-0.559668779373169,
-0.1308533251285553,
0.04882552847266197,
-0.44507336616516113,
0.5723590850830078,
0.002390884794294834,
0.11407335847616196,
0.07201214879751205,
-0.809688925743103,
-0.544688880443573,
0.8440452814102173,
0.3678835928440094,
-0.18494907021522522,
0.20726822316646576,
-0.21977289021015167,
0.3856242895126343,
-0.01497648935765028,
0.7329638600349426,
0.7978768348693848,
0.7611644268035889,
-0.2763443887233734,
-0.46962931752204895,
-0.3184182345867157,
-0.24669678509235382,
0.06845492869615555,
0.0654551088809967,
-0.11023600399494171,
0.517892599105835,
-0.0037248628214001656,
0.20934250950813293,
0.5800264477729797,
0.44936907291412354,
-0.22301708161830902,
0.14711077511310577,
0.40016040205955505,
0.21115870773792267,
0.9104439616203308,
-0.17906588315963745,
1.547116994857788,
-0.4991600513458252,
0.4102567732334137,
1.0882411003112793,
0.28088873624801636,
0.3714514672756195,
0.5409497618675232,
0.12065516412258148,
0.1030355915427208,
0.5130314826965332,
0.1695527881383896,
0.40261831879615784,
0.3106502890586853,
-0.4701942801475525,
-0.18856747448444366,
-0.19020424783229828,
0.13296180963516235,
0.038259271532297134,
0.3671690821647644,
-0.16196030378341675,
-0.3312378525733948,
0.1311141848564148,
-0.16121289134025574,
-0.0554828904569149,
-0.3653360903263092,
0.6061363816261292,
-0.00891674030572176,
-0.48523905873298645,
0.20037345588207245,
-0.23391319811344147,
0.30865418910980225,
-0.7011246085166931,
-0.4278202950954437,
0.02746887318789959,
0.5365920662879944,
-0.3109693229198456,
-0.729414165019989,
0.3899259567260742,
-0.44376665353775024,
-0.2792878746986389,
0.20821751654148102,
0.8756310939788818,
-0.38945990800857544,
-0.2024855762720108,
0.3675138056278229,
0.2142990678548813,
0.06272076815366745,
-0.2698308825492859,
-0.6033079028129578,
-0.04267125576734543,
-0.209077388048172,
-0.5186266303062439,
0.3286963701248169,
0.2938728332519531,
-0.2234635204076767,
0.46706992387771606,
0.7570860385894775,
0.07980863749980927,
-0.0830618217587471,
0.13017737865447998,
0.7058352828025818,
-0.29648521542549133,
0.031003836542367935,
-0.615572452545166,
0.9258373379707336,
-0.3095030188560486,
-0.5411953330039978,
0.619365394115448,
0.13467293977737427,
0.36874258518218994,
-0.07515515387058258,
0.6313274502754211,
-0.27136391401290894,
-0.1914551556110382,
-0.3900652825832367,
0.813511848449707,
-0.5027610659599304,
-0.02348211593925953,
0.05913667008280754,
-0.5873062014579773,
-0.6343472599983215,
0.9725388288497925,
-0.3724282681941986,
-0.5698240399360657,
0.5225902795791626,
1.1696630716323853,
-0.07567628473043442,
0.04003985971212387,
0.2179686725139618,
0.5403783917427063,
0.5501400232315063,
0.18866248428821564,
1.235079288482666,
-0.2527894973754883,
0.17939065396785736,
-0.3035621643066406,
-0.4044867753982544,
0.10018527507781982,
-0.9381137490272522,
-0.9924538135528564,
-0.4638631045818329,
-0.30598559975624084,
-0.49474406242370605,
0.21328099071979523,
1.32027006149292,
0.561285674571991,
-0.9994914531707764,
-0.281124472618103,
-0.4895418882369995,
0.48800134658813477,
-0.5403147339820862,
-0.12262610346078873,
0.7237420082092285,
-0.8300642371177673,
-0.9607564806938171,
0.6059995889663696,
0.19557030498981476,
-0.3778606057167053,
-0.1388143002986908,
-0.1563091278076172,
0.04959867522120476,
-0.06483157724142075,
0.4331606924533844,
0.3874473571777344,
-0.41319748759269714,
-0.293561190366745,
-0.36672428250312805,
0.32095593214035034,
-0.2370947301387787,
1.4792295694351196,
-0.508288562297821,
0.8802074790000916,
0.821830689907074,
0.7881777882575989,
0.31378331780433655,
-0.5347214341163635,
0.7067289352416992,
-0.2324034571647644,
0.6053833365440369,
0.1438813954591751,
0.8336731791496277,
-0.16544109582901,
-0.36244040727615356,
0.5795282125473022,
0.2794919013977051,
-0.8149605393409729,
-0.6838776469230652,
0.038329824805259705,
-0.34886014461517334,
-0.5143467783927917,
1.023000717163086,
-0.536619246006012,
-0.44662925601005554,
-0.28596803545951843,
-0.724292516708374,
0.5827369093894958,
-0.13954879343509674,
0.7710074186325073,
0.46937060356140137,
-0.11052834242582321,
0.09534763544797897,
-0.814491331577301,
0.32328101992607117,
0.09612499177455902,
-0.6170094609260559,
0.25167736411094666,
0.6295649409294128,
0.30160531401634216,
-0.005128762684762478,
0.04425833746790886,
0.1153814047574997,
0.3024529218673706,
0.04480589181184769,
0.502250075340271,
-0.2439677119255066,
-0.35694053769111633,
-0.797331690788269,
0.013845816254615784,
-0.1737898588180542,
-0.022637231275439262
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07805v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07805v2
|
Beyond Memorization: The Challenge of Random Memory Access in Language Models
| 2024-03-12T16:42:44 | 2024-03-13T12:46:38 |
Tongyao Zhu, Qian Liu, Liang Pang, Zhengbao Jiang, Min-Yen Kan, Min Lin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent developments in Language Models (LMs) have shown their effectiveness
in NLP tasks, particularly in knowledge-intensive tasks. However, the
mechanisms underlying knowledge storage and memory access within their
parameters remain elusive. In this paper, we investigate whether a generative
LM (e.g., GPT-2) is able to access its memory sequentially or randomly. Through
carefully-designed synthetic tasks, covering the scenarios of full recitation,
selective recitation and grounded question answering, we reveal that LMs manage
to sequentially access their memory while encountering challenges in randomly
accessing memorized content. We find that techniques including recitation and
permutation improve the random memory access capability of LMs. Furthermore, by
applying this intervention to realistic scenarios of open-domain question
answering, we validate that enhancing random access by recitation leads to
notable improvements in question answering. The code to reproduce our
experiments can be found at https://github.com/sail-sg/lm-random-memory-access.
|
[
-0.035912953317165375,
-0.9725736379623413,
0.8644760847091675,
-0.06548202037811279,
-0.19385826587677002,
0.22082699835300446,
-0.22847265005111694,
-0.37593305110931396,
-0.4855705797672272,
0.5242856740951538,
-0.4578861892223358,
-0.3396822214126587,
-0.3796929121017456,
-0.23888103663921356,
-0.5760704874992371,
0.9949247241020203,
-0.2196076363325119,
-0.1463439166545868,
-0.19247548282146454,
-0.1905241310596466,
-0.6682580709457397,
-0.881153404712677,
-0.9378165006637573,
-0.16093800961971283,
0.633667528629303,
0.24903376400470734,
0.6366046667098999,
0.33198612928390503,
0.31708553433418274,
0.2981555759906769,
-0.10641175508499146,
0.17984652519226074,
-0.5459029078483582,
0.3184850215911865,
-0.27427423000335693,
-0.9751845598220825,
-0.20868279039859772,
-0.12190275639295578,
0.8698228597640991,
0.3821326494216919,
-0.6126114130020142,
-0.01742330752313137,
-0.07299383729696274,
0.5331496596336365,
-0.2593271732330322,
-0.021743755787611008,
-1.0410182476043701,
0.12199164181947708,
-0.31626418232917786,
-0.5189532041549683,
-0.40415194630622864,
-0.19617025554180145,
0.3374512195587158,
-0.6465141773223877,
0.5625098943710327,
0.2344522923231125,
0.7110751867294312,
0.0064557562582194805,
0.20193535089492798,
-0.4682011902332306,
-1.015319585800171,
0.7701539397239685,
-0.5399739146232605,
0.40165066719055176,
0.32019200921058655,
0.36484503746032715,
-0.08007566630840302,
-0.6975879073143005,
-0.705097496509552,
0.022211074829101562,
0.03757638484239578,
-0.0057974220253527164,
0.02212194725871086,
0.021552199497818947,
0.3566341996192932,
0.5445685982704163,
-0.7158947587013245,
-0.22194215655326843,
-0.37476226687431335,
0.03286002203822136,
0.19039373099803925,
0.26949214935302734,
0.6710553169250488,
0.1837899088859558,
-0.3081461191177368,
-0.06382526457309723,
-0.6048067212104797,
-0.04151143133640289,
0.23169784247875214,
0.14455309510231018,
0.19376133382320404,
0.7554605603218079,
0.19397781789302826,
0.7347135543823242,
-0.29067593812942505,
0.05754317715764046,
0.16521592438220978,
-0.3092074692249298,
-0.2843790650367737,
-0.3814111351966858,
0.21963182091712952,
-0.04397716373205185,
0.47101891040802,
-0.3541339635848999,
-0.14682714641094208,
-0.5815266966819763,
0.540266215801239,
-0.3691312372684479,
-0.36756768822669983,
0.4048006236553192,
-0.2445053905248642,
0.10314852744340897,
-0.05604979395866394,
-0.5226401686668396,
-0.24252386391162872,
-0.04926139861345291,
0.5814045071601868,
-0.6626419425010681,
-0.4253573715686798,
0.25785642862319946,
-0.4653814435005188,
-0.0009670892031863332,
0.3723701238632202,
-1.0200438499450684,
0.32946234941482544,
0.6708443760871887,
0.7003741264343262,
-0.1139584630727768,
-0.42611163854599,
-0.12513767182826996,
0.25558122992515564,
-0.18625956773757935,
0.6710089445114136,
-0.4761355519294739,
-0.09235425293445587,
-0.08215796202421188,
-0.26328063011169434,
-0.5429932475090027,
-0.885470449924469,
0.19319914281368256,
-1.0006508827209473,
0.16561076045036316,
-0.4270492196083069,
-0.5855278372764587,
-0.36592501401901245,
0.06602030992507935,
-0.6071287393569946,
0.948199987411499,
0.25363224744796753,
-0.6323579549789429,
0.08790237456560135,
-0.31016820669174194,
-0.05360313132405281,
-0.08126544952392578,
-0.26965999603271484,
-0.1748257428407669,
0.4519698917865753,
-0.04098203033208847,
0.19506649672985077,
-0.32887518405914307,
0.09047923237085342,
-0.05197243392467499,
-0.31313908100128174,
0.6194959878921509,
-0.40675684809684753,
0.2910721004009247,
0.3369470238685608,
0.12109442800283432,
0.009670243598520756,
-0.6738982200622559,
0.25561022758483887,
0.5708486437797546,
-0.2474079430103302,
-0.5493608117103577,
0.21862469613552094,
-0.2940709888935089,
0.1922937035560608,
0.03163290396332741,
-0.2708530128002167,
0.2898704707622528,
-0.33966296911239624,
0.44214677810668945,
0.6868225336074829,
0.17971251904964447,
0.5750649571418762,
-0.6664323806762695,
0.44157159328460693,
0.26200348138809204,
-0.14334134757518768,
-0.33141037821769714,
-0.695486843585968,
-0.6351000070571899,
-0.08299373835325241,
-0.12240187078714371,
0.7748692631721497,
-0.7356794476509094,
-0.2802111506462097,
-0.13683730363845825,
-0.07607264816761017,
-0.5808686017990112,
0.32229048013687134,
0.569422721862793,
0.36217328906059265,
0.48934048414230347,
-0.3591628670692444,
-0.4108617305755615,
-0.7312108874320984,
-0.39199933409690857,
-0.2677425742149353,
-0.3047511577606201,
0.5609788298606873,
0.13865867257118225,
0.17695094645023346,
0.7728877067565918,
-0.6145975589752197,
-0.09900075942277908,
-0.43068888783454895,
0.22741879522800446,
0.2036864310503006,
0.28413042426109314,
0.21451279520988464,
-0.690292239189148,
-0.12478813529014587,
-0.33768969774246216,
-0.6501415967941284,
0.09172587096691132,
-0.49205711483955383,
-0.0066004120744764805,
0.24786227941513062,
0.39867228269577026,
-0.8690309524536133,
0.07964499294757843,
0.2612093985080719,
0.0744842141866684,
0.436413049697876,
-0.45708948373794556,
-0.029872721061110497,
-0.7181772589683533,
-0.08499330282211304,
-0.4858054518699646,
0.0129083301872015,
-0.8058670163154602,
0.36977419257164,
-0.1135275736451149,
-0.0407399944961071,
-0.40006986260414124,
0.4942108392715454,
-0.5074424743652344,
-0.14266397058963776,
-0.22011640667915344,
0.35286179184913635,
-0.2113497257232666,
0.49571776390075684,
0.32217347621917725,
1.0787503719329834,
0.24228955805301666,
-0.4135891795158386,
-0.2557049095630646,
0.12631742656230927,
-0.5256136059761047,
0.05847024545073509,
-0.44803017377853394,
0.5731409192085266,
-0.5242571830749512,
0.059693727642297745,
-1.2762811183929443,
0.02420169860124588,
0.15165476500988007,
-0.25433462858200073,
0.5191375017166138,
-0.019831599667668343,
-0.5843327045440674,
-0.29833731055259705,
-0.017568109557032585,
0.628948450088501,
0.6677605509757996,
-0.29832765460014343,
0.39419156312942505,
0.3407236933708191,
-0.4067802131175995,
-0.34628909826278687,
-0.5108017921447754,
-0.10417380183935165,
-0.134486123919487,
-0.5205360054969788,
0.23905500769615173,
-0.07978194952011108,
-0.15173649787902832,
-0.056008826941251755,
-0.2878868877887726,
-0.18908348679542542,
0.026569677516818047,
-0.039682429283857346,
0.025478601455688477,
-0.1843377649784088,
0.31186461448669434,
-0.15067343413829803,
0.058484483510255814,
-0.12475641071796417,
-0.48650673031806946,
0.8379632830619812,
0.006324884947389364,
-0.19668692350387573,
-0.06828464567661285,
0.4850994348526001,
0.18410326540470123,
-0.1055414155125618,
0.7696804404258728,
0.24169163405895233,
-0.3507121503353119,
-0.5233091115951538,
-0.8019128441810608,
-0.22737297415733337,
-0.47034403681755066,
0.6276558637619019,
-0.6842672824859619,
-1.0972801446914673,
0.659618079662323,
0.18306593596935272,
0.07475216686725616,
0.022272368893027306,
0.5725489258766174,
-0.3856540322303772,
0.4626396894454956,
0.44351086020469666,
0.0777982547879219,
0.30774375796318054,
-0.0026263161562383175,
0.15395943820476532,
-0.8911305665969849,
-0.040275342762470245,
-0.3315463066101074,
-0.21983009576797485,
-0.2770553529262543,
-0.9025578498840332,
0.14308607578277588,
0.6070404052734375,
-0.2137630730867386,
0.27098366618156433,
-0.3038175702095032,
0.5186382532119751,
0.6481004953384399,
0.11841458827257156,
0.5188212990760803,
0.19402873516082764,
-0.480549156665802,
-0.21579407155513763,
-1.016369342803955,
-0.2937883734703064,
0.9955502152442932,
0.5143234133720398,
0.5545962452888489,
0.03811259940266609,
0.7289209961891174,
-0.20831090211868286,
0.4900329113006592,
-0.19605514407157898,
0.6818408370018005,
-0.050203513354063034,
-0.9078823328018188,
-0.4487749934196472,
-0.3565438985824585,
-0.5891188383102417,
0.2989486753940582,
0.16683083772659302,
-0.9803399443626404,
-0.09607716649770737,
0.27288293838500977,
-0.4292018711566925,
0.6183686852455139,
-0.48488882184028625,
0.5251755714416504,
-0.05696303769946098,
-0.07535446435213089,
-0.288366436958313,
-0.6030447483062744,
0.4014098346233368,
-0.029031557962298393,
0.1424359828233719,
0.07922204583883286,
-0.029995694756507874,
0.5267142653465271,
-0.15356512367725372,
0.6283348798751831,
-0.1480773687362671,
-0.18622983992099762,
0.6175354719161987,
0.16210858523845673,
0.6538155674934387,
0.0018649676349014044,
0.0828976258635521,
0.015551107935607433,
-0.18932434916496277,
-0.21687351167201996,
-0.8849422931671143,
0.47260698676109314,
-0.7234489917755127,
-0.9097787737846375,
-0.44325223565101624,
-0.8842115998268127,
-0.41358792781829834,
-0.10017875581979752,
0.011700929142534733,
0.007485374342650175,
-0.05388451740145683,
-0.08626176416873932,
1.0662723779678345,
-0.6913242936134338,
0.3075379431247711,
0.7353101968765259,
-0.2887110710144043,
-0.36033645272254944,
1.0935392379760742,
0.2458537071943283,
0.7047851085662842,
0.652686595916748,
-0.04442118480801582,
-0.3068041503429413,
-0.9367891550064087,
-0.26856425404548645,
0.24751564860343933,
-0.6377507448196411,
0.31541815400123596,
-0.8184523582458496,
-0.5563716888427734,
-0.0036965960171073675,
0.1329706907272339,
-0.19657915830612183,
-0.819692850112915,
-0.13901682198047638,
-0.37623924016952515,
0.16176648437976837,
0.3602201044559479,
0.09632282704114914,
0.15926434099674225,
-0.7200429439544678,
0.5922039151191711,
0.43788793683052063,
0.2912095785140991,
0.3430437743663788,
-0.763812780380249,
0.09347667545080185,
-0.10266829282045364,
-0.1631813496351242,
-0.7156164050102234,
0.2060772031545639,
-0.04770173504948616,
0.3985692262649536,
-0.004934131633490324,
-0.3637682795524597,
0.7057775259017944,
-0.8690431118011475,
0.5392063856124878,
-0.16577795147895813,
-0.27098697423934937,
0.21740587055683136,
-0.5886849164962769,
0.3973360061645508,
0.5478745102882385,
0.396859735250473,
-0.5019904971122742,
-0.8476852774620056,
-0.5953356027603149,
-1.0762882232666016,
0.6371802091598511,
0.3566557765007019,
0.21255162358283997,
-0.26340678334236145,
0.6048812866210938,
-0.11985182017087936,
0.4351505935192108,
-0.5454342365264893,
-0.31533095240592957,
-0.006661601830273867,
-0.04686276987195015,
-0.20424328744411469,
-0.7513651251792908,
-0.08655071258544922,
-0.07958755642175674,
0.5469561815261841,
0.3708534836769104,
0.6125696897506714,
0.28849735856056213,
-0.09279954433441162,
-0.0949404314160347,
0.4745883643627167,
0.8792958855628967,
0.45018547773361206,
-0.3810993731021881,
0.15635946393013,
0.2054135650396347,
-0.6943645477294922,
0.1356537789106369,
0.1189388856291771,
-0.6203866600990295,
-0.07017716020345688,
-0.003966282121837139,
0.4812617003917694,
0.32733970880508423,
-0.6818186044692993,
-0.04658878967165947,
0.10857777297496796,
-0.11238165944814682,
-0.43695351481437683,
0.3144286870956421,
0.503038227558136,
0.2624228596687317,
0.6432361006736755,
-0.11871952563524246,
-0.11346083879470825,
-0.5977945327758789,
0.4528304934501648,
0.38859623670578003,
-0.1393042355775833,
-0.21138860285282135,
1.0195889472961426,
-0.33457672595977783,
-0.33601465821266174,
0.9165254831314087,
-0.02350028045475483,
-0.23047423362731934,
0.5616925358772278,
0.9682958722114563,
1.0035483837127686,
-0.3617347478866577,
0.11837907135486603,
0.35385313630104065,
0.3331708312034607,
-0.2430700808763504,
0.7655536532402039,
0.025485973805189133,
-1.0933892726898193,
-0.16068343818187714,
-0.6057052612304688,
-0.3049868941307068,
0.22503018379211426,
-0.528990626335144,
-0.30534660816192627,
-0.5175344944000244,
0.06757024675607681,
-0.17057761549949646,
-0.25757768750190735,
-0.6149271130561829,
0.23569613695144653,
-0.04636663571000099,
0.8308313488960266,
-0.38370341062545776,
1.3025401830673218,
0.3929637670516968,
-0.40093570947647095,
-0.8128136992454529,
-0.01089862734079361,
0.08947372436523438,
-1.0062743425369263,
0.42736050486564636,
-0.03385050594806671,
0.3141794502735138,
0.29444482922554016,
-0.07228443771600723,
-0.7439067363739014,
1.1610833406448364,
0.10290317237377167,
-0.7516487836837769,
-0.34044957160949707,
0.5018125176429749,
0.5552390217781067,
-0.03039930760860443,
0.20748215913772583,
0.4654657244682312,
0.32253631949424744,
0.06522536277770996,
-0.540723443031311,
0.06343289464712143,
-0.16235758364200592,
0.11590494215488434,
0.14895804226398468,
-0.5760667324066162,
0.8427481651306152,
-0.5050830245018005,
-0.4353136122226715,
0.4364882707595825,
0.7343282699584961,
0.7031199932098389,
0.24479196965694427,
0.3772963881492615,
0.805187463760376,
0.8522009253501892,
0.0034624042455106974,
1.3680305480957031,
0.010025224648416042,
0.15314967930316925,
1.5576764345169067,
-0.3061811625957489,
0.8846566081047058,
0.5724546909332275,
-0.33321937918663025,
0.18782839179039001,
0.06909430027008057,
0.16862721741199493,
0.5891988277435303,
0.4556225538253784,
-0.6453685760498047,
0.007950564846396446,
0.2057221531867981,
-0.32463201880455017,
-0.22763732075691223,
0.4347291588783264,
-0.39059019088745117,
-0.15921124815940857,
-0.016201915219426155,
-0.12566214799880981,
0.10571874678134918,
-0.17776300013065338,
0.7073423862457275,
0.42631837725639343,
-0.6288489699363708,
0.5315961241722107,
0.06203083321452141,
0.12519507110118866,
-0.7370729446411133,
-0.11676111817359924,
-0.1066541001200676,
0.16390381753444672,
0.04683014005422592,
-0.8247072100639343,
0.5017411112785339,
-0.2666582465171814,
-0.41181689500808716,
-0.3635220527648926,
0.6537899374961853,
-0.8672515749931335,
-0.24748112261295319,
0.1463349610567093,
0.574593186378479,
0.05312451720237732,
-0.052759330719709396,
-0.5483503937721252,
-0.07924875617027283,
-0.20706237852573395,
-0.560307502746582,
0.7354952096939087,
0.3933563530445099,
-0.18067550659179688,
0.8718997240066528,
0.5868983268737793,
0.04248817265033722,
0.38769859075546265,
0.26182228326797485,
0.7008951306343079,
-0.7141230702400208,
-0.14564216136932373,
-0.7247109413146973,
0.4115429222583771,
0.24761667847633362,
-0.17412406206130981,
0.8524251580238342,
0.53216153383255,
0.984873354434967,
-0.385564923286438,
0.794208288192749,
-0.04476478323340416,
0.6494166254997253,
-0.6842342019081116,
0.6486889123916626,
-0.29641127586364746,
0.3692574203014374,
-0.2586040794849396,
-0.705122709274292,
-0.28592684864997864,
0.5597095489501953,
-0.33781662583351135,
-0.13796840608119965,
0.8125426769256592,
0.8712793588638306,
0.018103057518601418,
0.13616666197776794,
0.3337189555168152,
0.44178757071495056,
0.10446766018867493,
0.9354252815246582,
0.7762840986251831,
-0.286925345659256,
0.5041189193725586,
-0.2017190307378769,
0.0913623720407486,
0.2961321473121643,
-0.5737432837486267,
-0.9117283225059509,
-0.659288227558136,
-0.05608857050538063,
-0.2806743085384369,
0.5413653254508972,
0.5591707825660706,
0.21092982590198517,
-0.8656279444694519,
-0.19537627696990967,
-0.4205613136291504,
0.22282499074935913,
-0.3664514720439911,
-0.2324989289045334,
0.3099237084388733,
-0.5801774859428406,
-0.5315923690795898,
0.47475308179855347,
0.31629300117492676,
0.2421415150165558,
0.07953210920095444,
0.23269620537757874,
-0.18389040231704712,
0.18942932784557343,
0.4035966992378235,
0.6447443962097168,
-0.5403831005096436,
-0.35147881507873535,
0.2027430385351181,
-0.06347386538982391,
0.05773891508579254,
1.0528377294540405,
-0.5289174914360046,
0.28107449412345886,
0.5668761134147644,
0.8690747022628784,
0.5769481658935547,
0.22260241210460663,
0.7176797986030579,
-0.6404149532318115,
0.17175716161727905,
0.324245810508728,
0.12001675367355347,
-0.0815943256020546,
-0.15151703357696533,
0.3490513265132904,
0.20583747327327728,
-0.43962332606315613,
-0.7122676968574524,
0.346828430891037,
-0.9304748773574829,
-0.342163622379303,
1.0743812322616577,
-0.16981549561023712,
0.07186684757471085,
-0.3146853744983673,
-0.07843709737062454,
-0.1908612996339798,
0.051049619913101196,
0.8377913236618042,
1.0121304988861084,
0.05152757093310356,
-0.5368170142173767,
-1.1856099367141724,
0.6516241431236267,
0.7038914561271667,
-0.44300734996795654,
0.11239010095596313,
0.19088712334632874,
0.4953496754169464,
-0.07030589878559113,
1.2736738920211792,
-0.3649335205554962,
0.2599223852157593,
-0.248968705534935,
-0.15621137619018555,
-0.1363798975944519,
-0.614195704460144,
-0.23135338723659515,
0.4533582627773285,
0.21668092906475067,
0.1271376609802246
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07794v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07794v3
|
Fine-tuning Large Language Models with Sequential Instructions
| 2024-03-12T16:33:30 | 2024-07-03T08:18:44 |
Hanxu Hu, Simon Yu, Pinzhen Chen, Edoardo M. Ponti
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite the success of existing instruction-tuned models, we find that they
usually struggle to respond to queries with multiple instructions. This impairs
their performance in complex problems whose solution consists of multiple
intermediate tasks. Thus, we contend that part of the fine-tuning data mixture
should be sequential--containing a chain of interrelated tasks. We first
approach sequential instruction tuning from a task-driven perspective, manually
creating interpretable intermediate tasks for multilingual and visual question
answering: namely "translate then predict" and "caption then answer". Next, we
automate this process by turning instructions in existing datasets (e.g.,
Alpaca and FlanCoT) into diverse and complex sequential instructions, making
our method general-purpose. Models that underwent our sequential instruction
tuning show improved results in coding, maths, and open-ended generation.
Moreover, we put forward a new benchmark named SeqEval to evaluate a model's
ability to follow all the instructions in a sequence, which further
corroborates the benefits of our fine-tuning method. We hope that our
endeavours will open new research avenues on instruction tuning for complex
tasks.
|
[
-0.4070782959461212,
-1.1306580305099487,
0.47639209032058716,
0.3671887516975403,
-0.175909623503685,
-0.011626516468822956,
-0.4841702878475189,
-0.23797395825386047,
-0.349497526884079,
0.629264235496521,
-0.7230939865112305,
-0.39729127287864685,
-0.5964688062667847,
0.08355509489774704,
-0.46445006132125854,
0.9321496486663818,
-0.13628703355789185,
0.1755174696445465,
-0.07460670173168182,
-0.03814731538295746,
-0.7835677266120911,
-0.11361943185329437,
-0.8553421497344971,
-0.13028474152088165,
0.6191929578781128,
0.913296103477478,
0.8045769929885864,
0.8785645365715027,
0.3834769129753113,
0.31042635440826416,
0.23917202651500702,
0.6277387142181396,
-0.558822751045227,
0.1400761902332306,
-0.40607744455337524,
-0.602073609828949,
-0.09420586377382278,
-0.19403761625289917,
0.6550229787826538,
0.8721120953559875,
-0.08384687453508377,
0.35659360885620117,
0.13715827465057373,
0.783379852771759,
-0.4036368131637573,
0.23529033362865448,
-0.5541516542434692,
-0.20863944292068481,
-0.20790398120880127,
-0.45626965165138245,
-0.4899347722530365,
-0.33970165252685547,
-0.06127818673849106,
-0.46603479981422424,
0.2327292114496231,
0.2226797342300415,
0.5077067017555237,
0.30974575877189636,
-0.35020703077316284,
-0.3221985995769501,
-0.9318674802780151,
0.7246391177177429,
-0.7165538668632507,
0.1441935896873474,
0.19688430428504944,
0.241216242313385,
-0.31070375442504883,
-0.524473249912262,
-0.4798911511898041,
-0.06964161247015,
0.07277815788984299,
-0.056888680905103683,
0.14632105827331543,
0.052855994552373886,
0.45304062962532043,
0.20090413093566895,
-0.5914828777313232,
0.452325701713562,
-0.3464999794960022,
0.12087206542491913,
0.660578191280365,
0.42234012484550476,
0.3048032522201538,
0.39507848024368286,
-0.033883918076753616,
-0.04642625153064728,
-0.6693071126937866,
0.1028008759021759,
0.4556984603404999,
0.5265385508537292,
-0.057413697242736816,
0.6115275025367737,
-0.5722130537033081,
1.0103702545166016,
0.19654381275177002,
0.11608195304870605,
0.04061998054385185,
-0.4766779839992523,
-0.09311825037002563,
-0.04515500366687775,
0.5977593660354614,
0.1576443761587143,
0.4698358178138733,
-0.06531847268342972,
-0.21724821627140045,
-0.05743991583585739,
0.26329997181892395,
-0.8833392262458801,
-0.28438618779182434,
0.2368565797805786,
-0.2790702283382416,
0.03759895637631416,
-0.08031456172466278,
-0.5026225447654724,
-0.07250141352415085,
-0.7837425470352173,
0.6097400188446045,
-0.37391796708106995,
0.12131650745868683,
0.41503000259399414,
0.3827134072780609,
0.2918778955936432,
0.4065130650997162,
-1.1030919551849365,
0.42772263288497925,
0.9215127825737,
0.5656229257583618,
-0.1030271127820015,
-0.5425765514373779,
-0.8087541460990906,
-0.023286795243620872,
-0.4470175504684448,
0.7572676539421082,
-0.8497411012649536,
-0.14336727559566498,
-0.05620821937918663,
0.331996351480484,
-0.27681005001068115,
-0.5484724044799805,
0.3259831964969635,
-0.4467073678970337,
0.2247631549835205,
-0.4495479464530945,
-0.6215901970863342,
-0.14228451251983643,
-0.10974999517202377,
-0.5323817133903503,
0.7931519746780396,
-0.0803307518362999,
-0.41540777683258057,
-0.01665950007736683,
-0.37880223989486694,
-0.7987955212593079,
-0.16077539324760437,
-0.17172420024871826,
-0.18429633975028992,
0.2965565621852875,
0.26752224564552307,
0.5055529475212097,
-0.6196712851524353,
0.15281447768211365,
-0.20151856541633606,
-0.5255382061004639,
-0.0056021977216005325,
-0.3325948417186737,
0.416277676820755,
0.17030955851078033,
-0.29700911045074463,
0.32259252667427063,
-0.6473687291145325,
0.20134036242961884,
0.012716017663478851,
-0.2111855000257492,
-0.14699698984622955,
0.18750770390033722,
-0.24898993968963623,
0.2310427874326706,
0.3387329876422882,
-0.16698218882083893,
0.35476425290107727,
-0.33905142545700073,
0.48530614376068115,
0.7332819104194641,
0.00471930205821991,
0.4542160630226135,
-0.2838757634162903,
0.4173639416694641,
0.21236617863178253,
0.16377471387386322,
-0.6192150115966797,
-0.41834205389022827,
-0.9703958630561829,
0.22663046419620514,
0.3353869318962097,
0.6980085968971252,
-0.7740558385848999,
0.30160650610923767,
-0.1564720869064331,
-0.3518447279930115,
-0.5644696950912476,
0.09723173826932907,
0.5888463258743286,
0.44753971695899963,
0.4122755825519562,
-0.36963799595832825,
-0.22062037885189056,
-0.967551052570343,
-0.29148462414741516,
0.27254560589790344,
0.1406165361404419,
0.27463215589523315,
0.4951624274253845,
0.04709427431225777,
0.31037938594818115,
-0.5233098864555359,
0.07424725592136383,
0.20266661047935486,
0.41068723797798157,
0.2455710768699646,
0.7527590990066528,
0.17380975186824799,
-0.6709958910942078,
-0.6638362407684326,
0.170588880777359,
-0.44959354400634766,
0.03059106133878231,
-0.334826797246933,
-0.3098536431789398,
-0.018241319805383682,
0.6144078373908997,
-0.4641520380973816,
-0.040004946291446686,
0.2647719085216522,
-0.1701054871082306,
0.5256220102310181,
-0.40845707058906555,
0.46152830123901367,
-0.7726536393165588,
-0.10848121345043182,
-0.16334059834480286,
-0.04244949668645859,
-0.6181361079216003,
0.2848735451698303,
0.11214382946491241,
-0.08044928312301636,
-0.20929425954818726,
0.2507372200489044,
-0.49598729610443115,
-0.053347740322351456,
-0.34813472628593445,
-0.2369750440120697,
-0.07499092072248459,
0.6584802269935608,
-0.1070505678653717,
0.912286639213562,
0.6296408772468567,
-0.5591986775398254,
0.16984593868255615,
0.015468083322048187,
-0.5654631853103638,
0.3070288300514221,
-0.8872115612030029,
0.34331321716308594,
-0.29565101861953735,
-0.21939752995967865,
-1.0316818952560425,
-0.2899196743965149,
0.0885983258485794,
-0.12522047758102417,
0.5394331216812134,
-0.05231091007590294,
-0.7368239760398865,
-0.35666465759277344,
0.16055013239383698,
0.26618653535842896,
0.37132760882377625,
-0.2639991343021393,
0.30940213799476624,
0.06435573846101761,
-0.368703156709671,
-0.44496703147888184,
-0.31040945649147034,
-0.3004124164581299,
-0.07213311642408371,
-0.5437238812446594,
0.36928921937942505,
-0.1390485316514969,
0.01515237521380186,
-0.09049909561872482,
-0.15671633183956146,
-0.0867081880569458,
0.193003311753273,
-0.03142547979950905,
-0.013220428489148617,
-0.3689883351325989,
0.08656108379364014,
0.4790871739387512,
-0.004877462051808834,
-0.10036590695381165,
-0.4563365578651428,
0.6073026657104492,
-0.14550384879112244,
-0.3995470106601715,
-0.3770163655281067,
0.5932714343070984,
0.565244197845459,
-0.514933705329895,
0.790869414806366,
0.5806496143341064,
-0.3084908127784729,
-0.2830732762813568,
-0.47913360595703125,
-0.13986362516880035,
-0.4525962471961975,
0.4842222332954407,
-0.48497456312179565,
-0.8568603992462158,
0.5761678814888,
-0.2439848780632019,
0.2173415571451187,
0.22471609711647034,
0.5877382755279541,
-0.1406579464673996,
1.3712105751037598,
0.5355882048606873,
0.12048862129449844,
0.4552977681159973,
-0.14862214028835297,
0.022070059552788734,
-0.5254637002944946,
-0.008900575339794159,
-0.6033968329429626,
-0.5013994574546814,
-0.5968976020812988,
-0.3974204659461975,
0.3041612505912781,
0.4236009418964386,
-0.46440136432647705,
0.26141032576560974,
-0.44057878851890564,
0.7735021114349365,
0.6048378348350525,
0.2518950402736664,
0.15006116032600403,
-0.10912162065505981,
0.09917185455560684,
0.1573914736509323,
-0.7288936376571655,
-0.3786391615867615,
0.8948426246643066,
0.017513219267129898,
0.8097193837165833,
-0.09814343601465225,
0.5182355046272278,
-0.08328579366207123,
-0.10590904951095581,
-0.4989806115627289,
0.3918894827365875,
-0.6570332646369934,
-0.3282982110977173,
-0.37877240777015686,
-0.2778351902961731,
-0.9986419677734375,
0.24399037659168243,
-0.11892298609018326,
-0.6070004105567932,
0.07162977010011673,
0.2586616277694702,
-0.5940202474594116,
-0.1889020800590515,
-0.943808913230896,
1.1255015134811401,
-0.39703723788261414,
-0.613505482673645,
-0.4463745951652527,
-0.7781718969345093,
0.5143332481384277,
-0.032910242676734924,
0.22831057012081146,
-0.19710269570350647,
0.048157233744859695,
0.5049524903297424,
-0.3690652847290039,
0.8424055576324463,
-0.10190802067518234,
-0.12349999696016312,
0.12944620847702026,
0.04510684683918953,
0.5930403470993042,
-0.028147229924798012,
0.06460843235254288,
-0.18305988609790802,
0.1773390918970108,
-0.5032215118408203,
-0.7249547243118286,
0.891353964805603,
-0.7591143250465393,
-0.6957933902740479,
0.036230698227882385,
-0.6587450504302979,
-0.3094724118709564,
0.31927022337913513,
0.10825418680906296,
0.5743328332901001,
0.1534818857908249,
0.20089930295944214,
0.909319281578064,
-0.29769599437713623,
0.20339642465114594,
0.6492228507995605,
-0.0100324098020792,
-0.1607094407081604,
0.9155464768409729,
0.1819472759962082,
0.4306011497974396,
0.5756260752677917,
0.14274440705776215,
-0.10275115817785263,
-0.6770826578140259,
-0.5929442048072815,
0.08463731408119202,
-0.5642736554145813,
-0.11410941183567047,
-0.4430026412010193,
-0.039346352219581604,
-0.2411482036113739,
0.12860369682312012,
-0.36263203620910645,
-0.3004972040653229,
-0.47409164905548096,
0.2927014231681824,
0.22009117901325226,
0.513006865978241,
0.3554503321647644,
0.3937782049179077,
-0.9285154342651367,
0.5825899839401245,
0.2591862380504608,
0.3889177441596985,
0.10208934545516968,
-0.5301908850669861,
-0.5103743672370911,
0.24234753847122192,
-0.09568741172552109,
-0.6225783824920654,
0.1813059002161026,
0.4935820996761322,
0.4274159073829651,
0.0629798024892807,
-0.07500112056732178,
1.0641541481018066,
-1.051558494567871,
0.3740345239639282,
-0.16458190977573395,
-0.7606670260429382,
0.6388339400291443,
-0.32618385553359985,
0.7415160536766052,
0.6143129467964172,
0.5685257911682129,
-0.3952212631702423,
-0.2828364670276642,
-0.15359695255756378,
-0.8043528199195862,
0.7655407190322876,
-0.09727440774440765,
0.16325758397579193,
-0.09322100877761841,
0.46876224875450134,
0.41830629110336304,
0.3214004635810852,
-0.11762429773807526,
-0.22162456810474396,
0.20682600140571594,
-0.3386075496673584,
-0.2170836329460144,
-0.1989089846611023,
-0.09458646923303604,
-0.39787915349006653,
0.46897661685943604,
-0.26705077290534973,
0.051362164318561554,
-0.1265541911125183,
-0.17468342185020447,
-0.2439947873353958,
0.24884530901908875,
0.6879201531410217,
0.7126271724700928,
0.21066100895404816,
-0.04491240903735161,
-0.1653285175561905,
-0.18956761062145233,
-0.027959736064076424,
0.34789544343948364,
-0.26226532459259033,
-0.38097238540649414,
0.27580538392066956,
1.0478696823120117,
0.46549850702285767,
-0.6478742957115173,
0.1727677434682846,
-0.022982286289334297,
0.0017911694012582302,
-0.11718098819255829,
0.40574246644973755,
0.0711001306772232,
0.37908896803855896,
0.17201963067054749,
0.31775468587875366,
0.23370443284511566,
-0.6632496118545532,
0.18156562745571136,
0.327109158039093,
-0.05527608096599579,
-0.31143346428871155,
0.7083331346511841,
0.15951034426689148,
-0.2962368130683899,
0.7532904744148254,
-0.0677632987499237,
-0.20097625255584717,
0.7660636305809021,
0.5078936219215393,
0.631604790687561,
-0.2091137170791626,
0.048573993146419525,
0.45728573203086853,
0.3005359172821045,
-0.5110936760902405,
0.7362057566642761,
-0.07930716127157211,
-0.6189756989479065,
-0.7628829479217529,
-0.6301328539848328,
-0.2725510001182556,
-0.09979129582643509,
-0.8020079731941223,
0.2535078823566437,
-0.3359040915966034,
0.30729785561561584,
0.23914143443107605,
-0.09640283137559891,
-0.800750195980072,
0.1976991593837738,
0.1917639672756195,
0.8177375197410583,
-0.786304235458374,
0.9964671730995178,
0.4597902297973633,
-0.32314687967300415,
-0.8397221565246582,
-0.1944114714860916,
-0.39882829785346985,
-0.7220606207847595,
0.46597859263420105,
0.2603909373283386,
-0.07735884189605713,
0.38378986716270447,
-0.6203606724739075,
-0.9291108250617981,
0.873539388179779,
0.31099042296409607,
-1.0033910274505615,
-0.09511464834213257,
0.056210435926914215,
0.5605219006538391,
-0.39870262145996094,
0.12870930135250092,
0.7505701184272766,
0.24658629298210144,
0.0611538328230381,
-0.9204081296920776,
-0.027447886765003204,
-0.2692088782787323,
0.03688344731926918,
0.3135146200656891,
-0.6543406248092651,
1.0144716501235962,
-0.3812389671802521,
-0.3396410346031189,
0.3491581380367279,
0.6809741258621216,
-0.07350607216358185,
0.0009739893139339983,
0.39553573727607727,
0.33707481622695923,
0.8367918133735657,
-0.15194563567638397,
1.0293962955474854,
-0.5376524925231934,
0.047203537076711655,
1.6056208610534668,
-0.3020382821559906,
0.9062361717224121,
0.22224989533424377,
-0.09049578011035919,
0.4470245838165283,
0.7395787239074707,
0.04159151017665863,
0.546066164970398,
0.19625750184059143,
0.04789974167943001,
-0.33805936574935913,
0.005094295367598534,
-0.2997027039527893,
0.4133184552192688,
0.49650341272354126,
-0.2782195210456848,
0.03299470618367195,
0.08850017189979553,
-0.4187200665473938,
0.1804209202528,
-0.4910683333873749,
0.7369034886360168,
-0.05542842298746109,
-1.0295580625534058,
0.7312391400337219,
0.11068350821733475,
0.3267447352409363,
-0.5706915855407715,
-0.20488452911376953,
-0.13373331725597382,
0.11348488181829453,
-0.07507730275392532,
-0.8451603651046753,
0.13490113615989685,
-0.2582666277885437,
-0.25500595569610596,
-0.10774565488100052,
0.38705572485923767,
-0.9265530705451965,
-0.4473192095756531,
-0.1366327702999115,
0.49736666679382324,
-0.021529056131839752,
0.04604988917708397,
-0.7049980163574219,
0.1306617259979248,
-0.051214657723903656,
-0.08060399442911148,
0.2531610429286957,
0.6078707575798035,
-0.2660151720046997,
0.7188040018081665,
0.5550660490989685,
-0.11833002418279648,
0.2377334088087082,
0.28808608651161194,
0.7236123085021973,
-0.6501724720001221,
-0.4715607166290283,
-0.7771586775779724,
0.5093132853507996,
0.13130787014961243,
-0.25659728050231934,
0.6852790117263794,
0.5773226022720337,
1.0765422582626343,
-0.2801249921321869,
0.5174139142036438,
0.15155045688152313,
0.4443483054637909,
-0.8173190951347351,
0.2389461249113083,
-0.49127212166786194,
0.2784433662891388,
0.04585110396146774,
-0.8288736939430237,
-0.22606414556503296,
0.2662356197834015,
-0.3157062828540802,
-0.08300856500864029,
0.6781434416770935,
0.8150398135185242,
-0.14639022946357727,
0.17762823402881622,
0.1160627156496048,
0.31092602014541626,
-0.009947186335921288,
0.6062508821487427,
0.7837089896202087,
-0.39034736156463623,
0.23811927437782288,
-0.444685697555542,
-0.1110340878367424,
-0.13635817170143127,
-0.5085955262184143,
-0.7090120315551758,
-0.5047398209571838,
-0.4091799557209015,
0.011438838206231594,
0.12392593920230865,
0.8541765809059143,
0.6147512793540955,
-1.0771119594573975,
-0.3305303454399109,
-0.26310086250305176,
0.0197162963449955,
-0.5430928468704224,
-0.1623343527317047,
0.11735044419765472,
-0.7555150985717773,
-0.8909995555877686,
0.32071030139923096,
0.34966376423835754,
-0.14797383546829224,
-0.18350079655647278,
0.14683951437473297,
-0.16758853197097778,
0.06031336262822151,
0.7357330918312073,
0.28328147530555725,
-0.7253496050834656,
-0.3242552876472473,
0.10165437310934067,
-0.11513493955135345,
-0.01443980447947979,
0.9908007383346558,
-0.41375693678855896,
0.6020147204399109,
0.5473893284797668,
0.6609671115875244,
0.543377161026001,
0.10239832103252411,
0.7069598436355591,
-0.6749920845031738,
0.011917350813746452,
0.16237783432006836,
0.25951728224754333,
0.1433967798948288,
-0.3509892225265503,
0.3418475091457367,
-0.26317787170410156,
-0.6948434710502625,
-0.6464144587516785,
0.3035140335559845,
-0.8169034123420715,
-0.4205297529697418,
0.8710773587226868,
-0.019036853685975075,
-0.2710513770580292,
0.07094632089138031,
-0.2615332007408142,
0.2025088369846344,
-0.19185005128383636,
0.5703785419464111,
0.5804032683372498,
-0.269345223903656,
-0.2537563741207123,
-0.6441723704338074,
0.2953556180000305,
0.46887728571891785,
-0.8049218654632568,
0.2253539264202118,
0.5627766251564026,
0.11799544095993042,
-0.18078181147575378,
0.34949812293052673,
0.05183279514312744,
0.4338105320930481,
-0.09529844671487808,
-0.2643740475177765,
0.022588178515434265,
-0.6324959397315979,
-0.3845744729042053,
0.05346037447452545,
0.19722948968410492,
-0.2390625774860382
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13000v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13000v1
|
Duwak: Dual Watermarks in Large Language Models
| 2024-03-12T16:25:38 | 2024-03-12T16:25:38 |
Chaoyi Zhu, Jeroen Galjaard, Pin-Yu Chen, Lydia Y. Chen
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR
|
As large language models (LLM) are increasingly used for text generation
tasks, it is critical to audit their usages, govern their applications, and
mitigate their potential harms. Existing watermark techniques are shown
effective in embedding single human-imperceptible and machine-detectable
patterns without significantly affecting generated text quality and semantics.
However, the efficiency in detecting watermarks, i.e., the minimum number of
tokens required to assert detection with significance and robustness against
post-editing, is still debatable. In this paper, we propose, Duwak, to
fundamentally enhance the efficiency and quality of watermarking by embedding
dual secret patterns in both token probability distribution and sampling
schemes. To mitigate expression degradation caused by biasing toward certain
tokens, we design a contrastive search to watermark the sampling scheme, which
minimizes the token repetition and enhances the diversity. We theoretically
explain the interdependency of the two watermarks within Duwak. We evaluate
Duwak extensively on Llama2 under various post-editing attacks, against four
state-of-the-art watermarking techniques and combinations of them. Our results
show that Duwak marked text achieves the highest watermarked text quality at
the lowest required token count for detection, up to 70% tokens less than
existing approaches, especially under post paraphrasing.
|
[
-0.18690255284309387,
-0.6447908282279968,
0.373073935508728,
0.4485165476799011,
-0.8471381068229675,
0.2168465405702591,
-0.015704574063420296,
-0.44484224915504456,
0.19099430739879608,
0.7916536927223206,
-0.38090580701828003,
-0.7217680811882019,
-0.8664741516113281,
0.0661887601017952,
-0.4224603772163391,
0.7288798689842224,
-0.2524876594543457,
-0.1893308013677597,
0.008858714252710342,
-0.4691021144390106,
-0.4291515350341797,
-0.7650876641273499,
-0.7515345811843872,
-0.20573757588863373,
0.45335090160369873,
0.03571387007832527,
0.6058554649353027,
0.7060845494270325,
0.41110509634017944,
0.2426072657108307,
-0.37332016229629517,
0.33733004331588745,
-0.3054811954498291,
0.5876237154006958,
-0.02514897845685482,
-0.38339027762413025,
-0.012342318892478943,
0.07497944682836533,
0.6677284240722656,
0.24808669090270996,
0.18606729805469513,
0.04214279726147652,
0.30602073669433594,
0.7892123460769653,
-0.8760929703712463,
0.2471625655889511,
-0.6144090294837952,
0.08587679266929626,
-0.6818353533744812,
-0.14156247675418854,
-0.11644390970468521,
-0.028197742998600006,
-0.3285871148109436,
-0.5458611249923706,
-0.07781293988227844,
-0.11260270327329636,
0.7085620760917664,
0.48929187655448914,
-0.4541758894920349,
-0.21237556636333466,
-0.45106834173202515,
0.9162847399711609,
-0.8223321437835693,
0.1386805921792984,
0.5063977837562561,
0.11890792846679688,
-0.18567228317260742,
-0.7946493625640869,
-0.7096498012542725,
-0.034114520996809006,
-0.003088613972067833,
0.23376283049583435,
-0.16459301114082336,
-0.004259227775037289,
0.3516623079776764,
0.549907386302948,
-0.22655512392520905,
0.22018760442733765,
0.2091989517211914,
-0.3323955535888672,
0.7462941408157349,
0.27226021885871887,
0.33671891689300537,
0.12748000025749207,
-0.3581160604953766,
-0.3025250732898712,
-0.7983264327049255,
-0.04929246008396149,
0.8656181693077087,
0.1343688666820526,
-0.15507498383522034,
0.5417068004608154,
-0.2106436938047409,
0.40053099393844604,
-0.29851439595222473,
-0.0990549698472023,
0.10923236608505249,
-0.5270656943321228,
-0.00815572403371334,
-0.17770081758499146,
0.8411493897438049,
0.09013337641954422,
0.04029650613665581,
0.2221609205007553,
-0.3754722774028778,
0.22525784373283386,
-0.06922554224729538,
-0.7753797769546509,
-0.2942139208316803,
0.14651809632778168,
-0.4760333299636841,
-0.7431755065917969,
0.2598475217819214,
-0.7764130234718323,
-0.7139571309089661,
-0.1578352302312851,
0.5245747566223145,
-0.08389567583799362,
-0.44529199600219727,
0.11509339511394501,
-0.3560808300971985,
-0.02791683003306389,
0.24309459328651428,
-0.8191553354263306,
0.2587921917438507,
0.8508761525154114,
0.750030517578125,
-0.2854394316673279,
-0.09347942471504211,
-0.5434737205505371,
0.4215249717235565,
-0.3796152174472809,
0.7958757877349854,
-0.7791734337806702,
-0.3994210958480835,
0.10895591229200363,
-0.39813417196273804,
0.4196406602859497,
-0.6333103775978088,
0.46129122376441956,
-0.7097222805023193,
0.05457353964447975,
-0.5163280367851257,
-0.5912678241729736,
0.03282832354307175,
-0.17559751868247986,
-1.018427848815918,
1.3478015661239624,
-0.050313930958509445,
-1.0800714492797852,
0.46642959117889404,
-0.7649670243263245,
-0.644524872303009,
0.037215206772089005,
-0.11732764542102814,
-0.556205689907074,
0.18514469265937805,
0.2728567123413086,
0.18707361817359924,
-0.08916564285755157,
0.01896608993411064,
-0.2558765709400177,
-0.3737810254096985,
0.40391284227371216,
-0.6164482235908508,
0.6546839475631714,
0.00009730083547765389,
-0.4268084466457367,
0.014764165505766869,
-0.5992134809494019,
0.1432100236415863,
0.26153579354286194,
-0.6298693418502808,
-0.6760227680206299,
-0.22669169306755066,
-0.06236761063337326,
0.06727565079927444,
0.3321045935153961,
-0.5202983617782593,
0.18934926390647888,
-0.23725171387195587,
0.35529085993766785,
0.8852829933166504,
0.17891204357147217,
0.06472992897033691,
-0.24132442474365234,
0.3823443055152893,
0.17041616141796112,
0.15920346975326538,
-0.1275794357061386,
-0.7228221893310547,
-0.6547157168388367,
-0.5850426554679871,
0.6165295839309692,
0.4449446201324463,
-0.6046791076660156,
0.5547701120376587,
-0.05377199873328209,
-0.22961239516735077,
-0.5832346081733704,
0.4892531633377075,
0.5078216195106506,
0.10333436727523804,
0.33249521255493164,
-0.3621525466442108,
-0.5293197631835938,
-1.023558259010315,
-0.7174909710884094,
-0.03375054523348808,
-0.07017555087804794,
0.16711048781871796,
0.5160877704620361,
-0.23348049819469452,
0.7586880326271057,
-0.46849489212036133,
-0.25922974944114685,
-0.2112433761358261,
0.2680751085281372,
-0.022064683958888054,
0.2859531342983246,
0.35549718141555786,
-1.1337734460830688,
-0.7060666680335999,
-0.24951636791229248,
-0.45636269450187683,
-0.7068889737129211,
0.2307596057653427,
-0.21170711517333984,
0.37942540645599365,
0.4376891255378723,
-0.5588845014572144,
0.7714584469795227,
0.915800154209137,
-0.3393852412700653,
0.4085201621055603,
-0.05649295076727867,
0.19871081411838531,
-0.9542834758758545,
0.2699660360813141,
-0.5342370271682739,
-0.16825081408023834,
-0.4672785997390747,
0.1113867312669754,
0.0976286381483078,
0.011982505209743977,
0.03938496857881546,
0.734201967716217,
-0.32435011863708496,
0.1544843167066574,
-0.6380248665809631,
-0.17459812760353088,
0.24754904210567474,
0.23278869688510895,
-0.1725751757621765,
0.775718629360199,
0.21423456072807312,
-0.330294668674469,
0.28500714898109436,
0.05814824998378754,
-0.49344709515571594,
0.3232767581939697,
-0.6878222823143005,
0.43498048186302185,
-0.0021694456227123737,
0.38121581077575684,
-1.1432015895843506,
0.05962974950671196,
0.23360279202461243,
-0.09975244849920273,
0.37122172117233276,
-0.26580917835235596,
-0.9812568426132202,
-0.16354741156101227,
-0.6995139122009277,
0.3326681852340698,
0.6021800637245178,
-0.7488080859184265,
0.3099936246871948,
0.3962825536727905,
-0.26667460799217224,
-0.8986275792121887,
-0.8890436291694641,
0.246810182929039,
-0.12358354777097702,
-0.6620470285415649,
0.4871510863304138,
0.021305130794644356,
-0.26050493121147156,
0.005550846923142672,
-0.4657129943370819,
-0.04694776237010956,
0.19943660497665405,
0.5114429593086243,
0.0045779081992805,
-0.03353520482778549,
0.05751032009720802,
0.4580148458480835,
-0.5641657114028931,
-0.44461700320243835,
-0.19805221259593964,
0.6200929880142212,
0.28219661116600037,
-0.4564322531223297,
-0.6168797016143799,
0.6860020160675049,
0.41760504245758057,
-0.3469274640083313,
0.8281663060188293,
0.3965066373348236,
-0.2606843411922455,
-0.3185780644416809,
-0.8273012042045593,
-0.13248541951179504,
-0.5241664052009583,
0.18633414804935455,
-0.40354710817337036,
-0.9876867532730103,
0.44773292541503906,
-0.10914050042629242,
0.26866623759269714,
0.4053519666194916,
0.42971277236938477,
-0.07449411600828171,
0.7663205862045288,
0.6466004848480225,
-0.033098381012678146,
0.572117805480957,
-0.10519833117723465,
0.3057246506214142,
-0.7476321458816528,
0.05882186070084572,
-0.4306366741657257,
-0.3066513240337372,
-0.28214386105537415,
-0.45674335956573486,
-0.026286065578460693,
0.5312488675117493,
0.06306152790784836,
0.16305452585220337,
-0.3376862108707428,
0.5550932884216309,
0.7198742032051086,
-0.03481336683034897,
0.5559155344963074,
0.388235479593277,
-0.28346556425094604,
-0.18102312088012695,
-0.29292088747024536,
-0.6601729393005371,
1.0564990043640137,
0.05422213301062584,
0.5048108696937561,
0.07441091537475586,
0.9107884168624878,
0.4006175100803375,
0.4375774562358856,
-0.19210082292556763,
0.4599539637565613,
-0.4079045355319977,
-0.6118192076683044,
-0.34870636463165283,
-0.5090442895889282,
-0.8587266802787781,
0.4116528332233429,
0.00773941446095705,
-0.40244242548942566,
-0.10935764759778976,
0.3151409327983856,
-0.05064985901117325,
0.4971134662628174,
-0.5625572800636292,
0.9062781929969788,
-0.07799142599105835,
-0.3380756676197052,
-0.47604647278785706,
-0.32052239775657654,
0.17497774958610535,
-0.40234652161598206,
0.1584731638431549,
-0.1951136440038681,
-0.6433191299438477,
0.9772635698318481,
-0.5726715922355652,
0.8107982873916626,
-0.34618574380874634,
-0.337167352437973,
0.3330078423023224,
0.16621552407741547,
0.8160114288330078,
0.13053031265735626,
-0.07791025191545486,
0.5486038327217102,
-0.14727962017059326,
-0.32621124386787415,
-0.5461461544036865,
0.6523011326789856,
-0.451148122549057,
-0.6838332414627075,
-0.2872326970100403,
-0.23318053781986237,
-0.14623543620109558,
0.16824181377887726,
0.28614941239356995,
0.22377155721187592,
0.092481330037117,
0.07988251745700836,
0.24609273672103882,
-0.37185201048851013,
0.38650715351104736,
0.5480139851570129,
0.0935482457280159,
-0.5035029053688049,
0.611882209777832,
0.07599492371082306,
0.1766684502363205,
0.37648510932922363,
0.4824621379375458,
-0.35545051097869873,
-0.911587655544281,
-0.14719180762767792,
0.3243664503097534,
-0.7203480005264282,
-0.31433314085006714,
-0.7365896701812744,
-0.14459756016731262,
-0.233622744679451,
0.10427286475896835,
-0.36928826570510864,
-0.46054527163505554,
-0.03334071487188339,
-0.020632769912481308,
0.5028167366981506,
0.7891688942909241,
-0.34723803400993347,
0.2762812376022339,
-0.5617914199829102,
0.6275907754898071,
0.5809116959571838,
0.568131148815155,
-0.15439145267009735,
-0.5758620500564575,
0.018674686551094055,
0.10367490351200104,
-0.20808565616607666,
-0.5963683724403381,
0.07315371930599213,
-0.02451140061020851,
0.3281857371330261,
0.35678327083587646,
0.07765544205904007,
0.6392266750335693,
-0.3399825990200043,
0.7468987107276917,
0.22707973420619965,
-1.0489976406097412,
0.49989014863967896,
-0.03495223447680473,
0.1503576785326004,
0.6200727224349976,
-0.05696108564734459,
-0.6392624378204346,
-0.45701903104782104,
-0.4400445818901062,
-1.0579832792282104,
0.5451939105987549,
0.3931982219219208,
0.4680759906768799,
0.30399027466773987,
0.2574058473110199,
0.39399123191833496,
0.3490465581417084,
-0.6268506050109863,
-0.38630327582359314,
-0.20165812969207764,
-0.3451986014842987,
0.26994404196739197,
-0.823466956615448,
-0.08226214349269867,
0.02722107619047165,
0.7017287611961365,
0.12564213573932648,
-0.04033751040697098,
-0.017281508073210716,
-0.01626969873905182,
-0.04776628315448761,
0.24544952809810638,
0.37219473719596863,
0.21500152349472046,
0.23932503163814545,
0.2909195125102997,
0.035708237439394,
-0.6721588373184204,
0.16447195410728455,
0.08883810043334961,
-0.20091694593429565,
0.11479704827070236,
0.6853920817375183,
0.5862981677055359,
0.1887444108724594,
-0.5992116332054138,
0.6294345259666443,
-0.02923460491001606,
0.06116092577576637,
-0.04219137132167816,
0.1622343212366104,
0.22437141835689545,
0.15674977004528046,
0.44067373871803284,
-0.1952049881219864,
-0.10199623554944992,
-0.19274580478668213,
0.05343148484826088,
0.5208486318588257,
0.0681133046746254,
-0.25717782974243164,
0.4474289119243622,
0.29482802748680115,
-0.31049835681915283,
0.3446633219718933,
-0.05151025205850601,
-0.5660377740859985,
0.48656970262527466,
0.2719876766204834,
0.8922080993652344,
-0.37603893876075745,
-0.1758929193019867,
0.1628909856081009,
0.19999070465564728,
-0.22897763550281525,
0.35724812746047974,
-0.3649522364139557,
-0.7195227146148682,
-0.2659667730331421,
-0.7582002282142639,
-0.32905155420303345,
0.4380148649215698,
-0.3155830204486847,
0.15161755681037903,
-0.5423694252967834,
-0.2289363294839859,
0.09030786901712418,
0.17556601762771606,
-0.4105904996395111,
-0.24246074259281158,
0.2992388606071472,
0.7008752226829529,
-0.7019416093826294,
0.8240513801574707,
0.3445087969303131,
-0.044353459030389786,
-0.40380311012268066,
0.08268897980451584,
0.017515717074275017,
-0.8012827634811401,
0.691987931728363,
0.4516555070877075,
-0.12150691449642181,
-0.21365204453468323,
-0.5271411538124084,
-0.9429260492324829,
0.7798259258270264,
0.4682428240776062,
-0.5555418729782104,
0.29698458313941956,
0.3477313816547394,
0.460214227437973,
0.09666115790605545,
-0.29250237345695496,
0.4057188928127289,
0.7275774478912354,
-0.22916775941848755,
-0.6783424615859985,
0.29180270433425903,
-0.35884013772010803,
0.12745356559753418,
0.3309507369995117,
-0.6980913281440735,
0.6055853366851807,
0.03089032880961895,
-0.5915483236312866,
0.3737139105796814,
0.34946587681770325,
0.3015810549259186,
0.01719602756202221,
0.49051064252853394,
0.7561420202255249,
0.6298739314079285,
-0.05358987674117088,
1.0805063247680664,
-0.18872234225273132,
0.08255211263895035,
0.9538280963897705,
-0.4750436544418335,
0.7548484802246094,
0.6751792430877686,
-0.38840287923812866,
0.5594818592071533,
0.19508838653564453,
-0.10438805818557739,
0.6633614301681519,
0.42631205916404724,
-0.5498494505882263,
-0.2514420449733734,
-0.09751389175653458,
-0.46814030408859253,
0.2472204715013504,
0.27281665802001953,
-0.4206972122192383,
-0.0036546015180647373,
-0.2760266065597534,
0.03834982588887215,
0.11213093996047974,
0.11618658155202866,
0.8020504713058472,
0.36003369092941284,
-0.3511773347854614,
0.2849865257740021,
0.3240479826927185,
0.9692564606666565,
-0.8639388680458069,
-0.13631227612495422,
-0.4003097414970398,
0.0999145656824112,
-0.10889507085084915,
-0.8247215151786804,
0.12905721366405487,
0.11747447401285172,
-0.041993044316768646,
-0.3224148452281952,
0.7224663496017456,
-0.4249631464481354,
-0.18893301486968994,
0.5037369132041931,
0.12540514767169952,
-0.04221465438604355,
-0.40924790501594543,
-0.7106662392616272,
0.43654030561447144,
-0.11649909615516663,
-0.5665407776832581,
0.13332964479923248,
0.33302661776542664,
-0.017428182065486908,
0.547511875629425,
0.9328272938728333,
0.12922704219818115,
0.02196453884243965,
0.3678736388683319,
0.5700361728668213,
-0.6189761757850647,
-0.7696642279624939,
-1.165008544921875,
0.26127681136131287,
-0.4861033856868744,
-0.30091938376426697,
0.8508440256118774,
0.5046011805534363,
0.506666362285614,
0.07987934350967407,
0.9782013297080994,
0.3055188059806824,
0.2052629441022873,
-0.6508585214614868,
0.7763838768005371,
-0.3669573962688446,
0.20958130061626434,
-0.3716256320476532,
-0.7627588510513306,
-0.5346463918685913,
0.35628142952919006,
-0.06957054138183594,
-0.003071126528084278,
0.6611326336860657,
0.9071254134178162,
0.037667885422706604,
0.09258564561605453,
0.278987854719162,
0.03550295904278755,
0.3822476863861084,
0.503624439239502,
1.082870364189148,
-0.4772038757801056,
0.747248649597168,
-0.4575824439525604,
-0.1254807412624359,
-0.23666755855083466,
-0.7897768616676331,
-1.0197679996490479,
-0.5558310747146606,
-0.49552807211875916,
-0.15192021429538727,
0.05628013610839844,
0.4146140217781067,
0.630968451499939,
-0.9379633069038391,
0.23633919656276703,
-0.0311823021620512,
0.08360212296247482,
-0.11811503767967224,
-0.17766113579273224,
0.7170552015304565,
-0.006850450299680233,
-0.4068893492221832,
0.18046487867832184,
0.6018072366714478,
0.41730380058288574,
-0.051252398639917374,
0.024420246481895447,
0.2253888100385666,
0.24820338189601898,
0.4372624158859253,
0.020493056625127792,
-0.6169689297676086,
-0.27390503883361816,
-0.5428410768508911,
-0.2888619005680084,
-0.07361723482608795,
1.2580374479293823,
-0.542147696018219,
0.202101469039917,
0.48806074261665344,
0.6051790118217468,
0.5575847625732422,
-0.013982902280986309,
0.2504715919494629,
-0.8497334718704224,
0.40962982177734375,
0.20177602767944336,
0.43892210721969604,
0.5159180164337158,
-0.27728402614593506,
0.42331409454345703,
0.4477747082710266,
-0.022712700068950653,
-0.9614405632019043,
0.2483498603105545,
-0.6344239115715027,
-0.30937647819519043,
1.2317348718643188,
-0.18826107680797577,
0.04136612266302109,
-0.33072182536125183,
-0.39716359972953796,
0.255927711725235,
-0.32781001925468445,
0.8522775173187256,
0.8292521238327026,
0.3118349015712738,
0.15482090413570404,
-0.2825191915035248,
0.6440904140472412,
0.5490016341209412,
-0.7005915641784668,
0.49766796827316284,
0.03938974812626839,
0.4334661662578583,
-0.10011616349220276,
0.49291425943374634,
-0.4144327640533447,
0.2428082823753357,
0.2412928193807602,
-0.10789407789707184,
-0.43554556369781494,
0.14290407299995422,
-0.3763948678970337,
0.07301386445760727,
-0.07468466460704803,
-0.12940235435962677
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07769v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07769v3
|
Transforming Competition into Collaboration: The Revolutionary Role of Multi-Agent Systems and Language Models in Modern Organizations
| 2024-03-12T15:56:10 | 2024-03-15T11:44:51 |
Carlos Jose Xavier Cruz
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.MA
|
This article explores the dynamic influence of computational entities based
on multi-agent systems theory (SMA) combined with large language models (LLM),
which are characterized by their ability to simulate complex human
interactions, as a possibility to revolutionize human user interaction from the
use of specialized artificial agents to support everything from operational
organizational processes to strategic decision making based on applied
knowledge and human orchestration. Previous investigations reveal that there
are limitations, particularly in the autonomous approach of artificial agents,
especially when dealing with new challenges and pragmatic tasks such as
inducing logical reasoning and problem solving. It is also considered that
traditional techniques, such as the stimulation of chains of thoughts, require
explicit human guidance. In our approach we employ agents developed from large
language models (LLM), each with distinct prototyping that considers behavioral
elements, driven by strategies that stimulate the generation of knowledge based
on the use case proposed in the scenario (role-play) business, using a
discussion approach between agents (guided conversation). We demonstrate the
potential of developing agents useful for organizational strategies, based on
multi-agent system theories (SMA) and innovative uses based on large language
models (LLM based), offering a differentiated and adaptable experiment to
different applications, complexities, domains, and capabilities from LLM.
|
[
-0.6080465912818909,
-0.855574369430542,
0.7947774529457092,
0.24584504961967468,
0.1295260488986969,
0.8286989331245422,
-0.14634880423545837,
-0.8144891262054443,
0.35500451922416687,
0.6466946601867676,
-0.7334849834442139,
0.006849825382232666,
-0.05881628394126892,
0.30848395824432373,
0.012613522820174694,
0.7289871573448181,
0.15115107595920563,
0.11410872638225555,
-0.47526219487190247,
-0.14702585339546204,
-0.5034934282302856,
-0.7516257166862488,
-0.5435069799423218,
-0.6467878818511963,
0.2876957952976227,
0.26364997029304504,
0.8174955248832703,
0.4257315695285797,
0.5232362151145935,
0.5833134055137634,
0.018222076818346977,
0.19208192825317383,
-0.3331529200077057,
0.4210421144962311,
-0.1854580193758011,
-0.5521090626716614,
-0.5401358008384705,
0.16024601459503174,
0.5063750743865967,
0.8310412168502808,
-0.5818781852722168,
-0.09007851034402847,
0.16110284626483917,
0.5523607730865479,
-0.1508036106824875,
0.4256354570388794,
-0.6474990844726562,
-0.12095868587493896,
0.10977230966091156,
-0.22124263644218445,
-0.2785509526729584,
-0.1448369175195694,
0.2531971335411072,
-0.8158146739006042,
-0.18359480798244476,
0.0915546715259552,
0.4572610557079315,
-0.06388408690690994,
-0.22242315113544464,
-0.5998441576957703,
-1.1716804504394531,
0.7501566410064697,
-0.26868605613708496,
0.17466218769550323,
-0.13172754645347595,
0.4020655155181885,
-0.5170425772666931,
-0.8385705351829529,
-0.365959107875824,
-0.28889280557632446,
0.2940825819969177,
0.03041834756731987,
-0.24516980350017548,
0.10810042917728424,
-0.12885266542434692,
-0.10805904120206833,
-0.09581929445266724,
-0.10973116755485535,
-0.3815571963787079,
0.12622103095054626,
0.6301486492156982,
0.2382562756538391,
0.5079584121704102,
0.6693925261497498,
-0.42704036831855774,
-0.15038959681987762,
-0.3864480257034302,
-0.06594335287809372,
0.05422171205282211,
0.17976807057857513,
0.15877006947994232,
0.08446603268384933,
-0.07181133329868317,
0.3296462893486023,
0.20111919939517975,
-0.1550382375717163,
0.2457895278930664,
-0.2980327606201172,
-0.4375419020652771,
-0.141256183385849,
0.5814715027809143,
0.050278034061193466,
0.18572868406772614,
-0.6591722965240479,
-0.03282831236720085,
0.4153585731983185,
0.641767680644989,
-0.48207440972328186,
0.08435245603322983,
-0.005285974126309156,
-0.2429416924715042,
-0.5545426607131958,
0.26739728450775146,
-0.7205874919891357,
-0.461944043636322,
-0.5279439687728882,
0.2712780237197876,
-0.019220199435949326,
-0.21650558710098267,
-0.08578084409236908,
-0.22213537991046906,
0.14143598079681396,
0.5267120003700256,
-0.5306881666183472,
0.752106785774231,
0.77284175157547,
0.46968191862106323,
-0.08614735305309296,
-0.6885019540786743,
-0.21452510356903076,
0.28796637058258057,
-0.681502640247345,
0.6117185950279236,
-0.465621680021286,
-0.5172165632247925,
-0.019612587988376617,
-0.14105843007564545,
-0.08072323352098465,
-0.9119811058044434,
0.25796717405319214,
-0.6062500476837158,
-0.011364293284714222,
-0.10424846410751343,
-0.1484077125787735,
-0.045062653720378876,
0.4693375527858734,
-0.5899047255516052,
0.47493574023246765,
-0.02641933783888817,
-0.14405855536460876,
0.13690416514873505,
-0.9709107875823975,
-0.2382068783044815,
0.5149606466293335,
-0.6661965847015381,
-0.22016975283622742,
0.013307243585586548,
-0.3886757493019104,
0.05750315263867378,
-0.6457661986351013,
0.279238760471344,
-0.17268864810466766,
-0.15583431720733643,
0.5289941430091858,
0.1909547597169876,
0.6235278844833374,
0.18026116490364075,
-0.3986676335334778,
0.37469667196273804,
-0.5316708087921143,
0.035828251391649246,
0.2164195030927658,
-0.43239814043045044,
-0.2771437168121338,
0.19223377108573914,
-0.3859421908855438,
0.5159713625907898,
0.28158247470855713,
-0.06581825017929077,
0.3291296660900116,
-0.06963703781366348,
0.32426196336746216,
0.8084090948104858,
0.004268897231668234,
0.6334040760993958,
-0.5432544946670532,
0.7620514631271362,
-0.31912967562675476,
0.4530601501464844,
0.11051394045352936,
-0.5393907427787781,
-0.5059133768081665,
-0.17140357196331024,
-0.2294890582561493,
0.3656885325908661,
-1.0659490823745728,
0.21181921660900116,
-0.1757834255695343,
-0.627068281173706,
-0.4580457806587219,
0.085040383040905,
0.07788972556591034,
0.18805931508541107,
0.005268561188131571,
-0.5000060796737671,
-0.6434502005577087,
-0.6034789085388184,
-0.21911971271038055,
-0.37020036578178406,
0.16812539100646973,
0.5743597745895386,
0.401652067899704,
-0.5110803842544556,
0.894661545753479,
-0.26074016094207764,
-0.4146836996078491,
-0.5161941051483154,
0.16065603494644165,
-0.04890913516283035,
0.15700015425682068,
0.24469450116157532,
-1.123629093170166,
-0.7825937271118164,
0.19258101284503937,
-0.8976975679397583,
-0.1033160462975502,
-0.09848975390195847,
-0.22669848799705505,
0.108462855219841,
0.556187093257904,
-0.5182271003723145,
-0.06056824326515198,
0.5486314296722412,
-0.513931155204773,
0.8303220868110657,
-0.17695574462413788,
0.23752743005752563,
-1.081917405128479,
0.012475035153329372,
-0.2821890115737915,
0.014476735144853592,
-0.9786854982376099,
0.3930226266384125,
-0.49481096863746643,
-0.11346183717250824,
-0.24484768509864807,
0.3323310911655426,
-0.6544526219367981,
-0.04915741831064224,
-0.4457853436470032,
0.30782002210617065,
-0.057257357984781265,
0.44999775290489197,
-0.028513796627521515,
0.7802414894104004,
0.4182896316051483,
-0.8086491227149963,
0.5896880030632019,
0.3611999750137329,
-0.25148940086364746,
0.5725691318511963,
-0.5344583988189697,
0.36371925473213196,
0.1366119533777237,
0.26058652997016907,
-0.3796069920063019,
-0.12488605827093124,
-0.036693572998046875,
-0.28140610456466675,
-0.16851826012134552,
0.19465836882591248,
-0.7046279907226562,
-0.28295236825942993,
-0.2862281799316406,
0.20576529204845428,
0.21943770349025726,
-0.0869547575712204,
0.9214283227920532,
0.5928672552108765,
-0.33351314067840576,
-0.2844845652580261,
-0.7279639840126038,
0.5174282789230347,
-0.2404322475194931,
-0.8296524286270142,
0.41767755150794983,
-0.3286822438240051,
-0.7668878436088562,
-0.10333874821662903,
0.16407325863838196,
-0.2934858202934265,
0.35326215624809265,
0.34077638387680054,
0.4021725356578827,
-0.09011103957891464,
-0.03541410341858864,
-0.4641772508621216,
0.16525810956954956,
0.06513600796461105,
-0.26108318567276,
0.6104628443717957,
-0.33868762850761414,
-0.12407354265451431,
-0.25892165303230286,
0.5647528171539307,
1.0694386959075928,
-0.3766705393791199,
0.9743987917900085,
0.11001120507717133,
-0.25632578134536743,
-0.26693129539489746,
-0.5584036111831665,
-0.4354492127895355,
-0.4885847866535187,
0.32738617062568665,
-0.15098263323307037,
-0.74773770570755,
0.7029117941856384,
-0.6185033917427063,
-0.06883957982063293,
0.11519687622785568,
0.6630164384841919,
0.15569986402988434,
0.9487037658691406,
1.0712085962295532,
0.0720653086900711,
0.5023379921913147,
-0.08979719132184982,
0.05255887657403946,
-0.6897532939910889,
-0.49061352014541626,
-0.5837847590446472,
-0.141667902469635,
-0.6260930299758911,
-0.37203213572502136,
0.5995841026306152,
-0.1648784875869751,
-0.050704196095466614,
0.15819470584392548,
-0.17417123913764954,
0.355482816696167,
0.4722488224506378,
-0.4283720850944519,
0.3492336869239807,
-0.19933147728443146,
-0.27433478832244873,
0.1434880793094635,
-0.763038694858551,
-0.66164630651474,
0.5792245268821716,
0.2942711412906647,
0.7205340266227722,
0.3814353346824646,
0.6841285824775696,
0.3083238899707794,
0.23423175513744354,
-0.710369348526001,
0.6743127107620239,
0.37524276971817017,
-0.6212667226791382,
-0.35263702273368835,
-0.3784440755844116,
-1.069188117980957,
0.4844681918621063,
-0.47284701466560364,
-0.7979141473770142,
0.2581067681312561,
-0.3458101451396942,
-0.23884057998657227,
0.20934264361858368,
-0.5650613903999329,
0.7211881279945374,
-0.0771801620721817,
-0.5562906265258789,
-0.2990837097167969,
-0.40167221426963806,
0.09592851996421814,
-0.17602427303791046,
0.5884316563606262,
0.30513444542884827,
-0.055994510650634766,
0.723604679107666,
-0.10705213993787766,
0.8043364882469177,
0.2660530209541321,
-0.1217866912484169,
0.4548693895339966,
0.21183030307292938,
0.7462142705917358,
-0.594970703125,
-0.22582292556762695,
-0.26938769221305847,
-0.3200901448726654,
-0.10510601103305817,
-0.4122539162635803,
0.5085846781730652,
-0.7831476926803589,
-0.5993807911872864,
-0.27835386991500854,
-0.3747406303882599,
-0.4098241627216339,
0.3425796329975128,
-0.2088577300310135,
0.0301629938185215,
-0.8592228889465332,
0.46627357602119446,
0.2636907994747162,
0.28324902057647705,
0.3616834878921509,
0.6502413749694824,
0.06418251991271973,
-0.5062800049781799,
0.6619368195533752,
0.11425107717514038,
0.3909015953540802,
0.03643345087766647,
0.2121659368276596,
-0.02534373849630356,
-0.2401236593723297,
0.09352489560842514,
0.28889670968055725,
-0.5601272583007812,
-0.03826339915394783,
-0.3358443081378937,
0.060151878744363785,
-0.44721442461013794,
-0.42945626378059387,
-0.41815319657325745,
0.0720377191901207,
-0.11517578363418579,
0.11156785488128662,
-0.5444340109825134,
1.1416125297546387,
0.04603626951575279,
0.16280768811702728,
-0.7385396361351013,
-0.008865569718182087,
0.46655625104904175,
0.2731991410255432,
0.30403009057044983,
0.2455066442489624,
-0.6671710014343262,
-0.17928171157836914,
-0.7304231524467468,
-1.0826071500778198,
0.46143805980682373,
-0.1576160490512848,
0.7972891926765442,
0.23221498727798462,
-0.027491243556141853,
0.2771206796169281,
-0.35878849029541016,
0.7831314206123352,
0.14024803042411804,
-0.8917819857597351,
0.11924149096012115,
-0.4215317964553833,
0.0004949595313519239,
0.33530157804489136,
0.22434373199939728,
-0.6726157665252686,
-0.20421382784843445,
-0.8584074378013611,
-0.751995325088501,
1.0680559873580933,
0.4324014186859131,
-0.22365956008434296,
0.3535456955432892,
0.09934115409851074,
-0.25798267126083374,
0.6796714067459106,
-0.6029261350631714,
-0.09866390377283096,
0.5042861104011536,
0.187178373336792,
-0.01421890128403902,
-0.053068194538354874,
-0.28373652696609497,
0.13696272671222687,
0.7734572887420654,
-0.21850889921188354,
0.09268434345722198,
0.13121281564235687,
0.2698809504508972,
-0.3470500409603119,
0.5186567902565002,
0.5000499486923218,
0.9558268189430237,
0.27212023735046387,
-0.13226354122161865,
-0.16840462386608124,
-0.18827588856220245,
0.1955004185438156,
-0.20257386565208435,
-0.04389696195721626,
-0.5439377427101135,
0.22531746327877045,
0.5916123390197754,
-0.20930488407611847,
-0.6589083075523376,
0.1289168894290924,
0.06701331585645676,
-0.451040655374527,
-0.12642624974250793,
0.20559188723564148,
0.23218470811843872,
0.9222481846809387,
0.5202438235282898,
-0.0465284138917923,
0.10496091097593307,
-1.3129156827926636,
0.12705464661121368,
0.5112149119377136,
-0.28768542408943176,
-0.2583053410053253,
0.4094354212284088,
0.46681132912635803,
-0.7650406360626221,
0.12485633045434952,
-0.18183116614818573,
-0.6954299211502075,
0.7605525255203247,
0.5137307643890381,
1.020965337753296,
-0.5111640095710754,
0.35922932624816895,
-0.37972334027290344,
0.31608566641807556,
-0.1414942890405655,
-0.09761587530374527,
-0.10740917921066284,
-0.8816021084785461,
-0.1364404708147049,
-0.200270414352417,
-0.6723920702934265,
0.07823173701763153,
-0.3507205545902252,
0.07223013788461685,
-0.2950252890586853,
-0.38318556547164917,
0.15703238546848297,
0.30250075459480286,
-0.38643142580986023,
-0.10794363170862198,
0.1576710045337677,
0.44032615423202515,
-0.4842086732387543,
0.6321296095848083,
0.9725499153137207,
-0.4081922471523285,
-0.5432119965553284,
0.08893229067325592,
-0.006498162634670734,
-0.2970883846282959,
0.3910130262374878,
-0.1296812891960144,
-0.5327618718147278,
-0.10498247295618057,
-0.6452927589416504,
-0.4563577473163605,
1.285995602607727,
0.22509406507015228,
-0.4179465174674988,
-0.26901277899742126,
0.20027656853199005,
0.7909731268882751,
-0.8365596532821655,
-0.23565535247325897,
0.3450840413570404,
0.3277966380119324,
0.09556983411312103,
-1.0850334167480469,
-0.08822683990001678,
-0.16311860084533691,
-0.042395446449518204,
-0.008386529050767422,
-0.904395341873169,
0.9432510733604431,
-0.1367969512939453,
-0.16192151606082916,
0.07649298757314682,
0.3597608804702759,
0.393789678812027,
0.4922342598438263,
0.5260440707206726,
-0.19896717369556427,
0.6267340779304504,
0.35655277967453003,
0.6512789726257324,
-0.2773101329803467,
0.20622535049915314,
0.8452444672584534,
-0.576552152633667,
0.5807117819786072,
0.5848236680030823,
-0.1308245062828064,
0.8327944874763489,
-0.16794273257255554,
0.026225749403238297,
0.1504705399274826,
0.2536178529262543,
-0.33930277824401855,
-0.26107192039489746,
-0.3277758061885834,
0.1290614753961563,
0.6146770119667053,
0.4073846638202667,
-0.18118928372859955,
0.1036982387304306,
-0.17503085732460022,
-0.04273786023259163,
0.5334428548812866,
-0.09598857909440994,
1.2417190074920654,
0.0348406545817852,
-0.9343331456184387,
0.17237678170204163,
0.14144067466259003,
0.35898303985595703,
-0.7050125002861023,
-0.10556470602750778,
0.19539709389209747,
0.3495563566684723,
0.07466480135917664,
-0.46520984172821045,
0.17435403168201447,
-0.23062950372695923,
-0.08003265410661697,
-0.220916748046875,
0.5993121266365051,
-0.4329313337802887,
0.04709260165691376,
0.6655635833740234,
0.935457170009613,
-0.1364617645740509,
-0.23389537632465363,
-0.7336253523826599,
0.36793819069862366,
-0.21224968135356903,
0.09883558750152588,
0.25948265194892883,
0.5060642957687378,
-0.13733893632888794,
0.7922021746635437,
0.5338566899299622,
0.07935164868831635,
-0.2612590193748474,
-0.09770426899194717,
0.9947851896286011,
-0.6290494203567505,
-0.8699856996536255,
-0.6127853989601135,
0.2939768135547638,
-0.1556270569562912,
0.40791550278663635,
0.5110464096069336,
0.3013101816177368,
0.5770317912101746,
-0.04569922387599945,
0.7832120656967163,
0.043351344764232635,
0.224325031042099,
-0.022012710571289062,
0.672379195690155,
-0.46685677766799927,
0.18638834357261658,
-0.5764440894126892,
-0.7401666045188904,
-0.005676582455635071,
0.32075151801109314,
0.11457265168428421,
0.22836220264434814,
0.5276856422424316,
0.4274464547634125,
0.22886542975902557,
-0.12573756277561188,
0.39694830775260925,
0.4256376326084137,
0.8239057064056396,
0.3245413899421692,
0.8208186030387878,
-0.03708598390221596,
0.5975100994110107,
0.021400541067123413,
-0.5115343332290649,
-0.3576229512691498,
-0.5707311630249023,
-0.6564211249351501,
-0.800810694694519,
-0.24628502130508423,
-0.29320967197418213,
0.12670159339904785,
1.154154658317566,
0.6800686717033386,
-0.3078947961330414,
-0.9384354948997498,
-0.21768715977668762,
0.19320537149906158,
-0.3545549809932709,
-0.22981025278568268,
-0.21604235470294952,
-0.3540405333042145,
-0.6096765995025635,
0.6076018214225769,
0.30935320258140564,
0.2861420214176178,
-0.4978489875793457,
-0.39246225357055664,
-0.36355602741241455,
0.6770595908164978,
0.7439568042755127,
0.42163559794425964,
-0.45852574706077576,
0.3569483160972595,
0.15535178780555725,
-0.13351941108703613,
0.008975229226052761,
0.8855477571487427,
-0.6663915514945984,
0.4671795964241028,
0.2482585459947586,
0.5454074144363403,
0.03579943999648094,
-0.013699427247047424,
0.8196951746940613,
-0.43120235204696655,
0.12171724438667297,
0.35458946228027344,
0.0015100741293281317,
0.29201462864875793,
-0.28683778643608093,
0.5642534494400024,
0.49232932925224304,
-0.6806802749633789,
-0.6868618726730347,
0.26140254735946655,
-0.6268245577812195,
-0.4869078993797302,
0.9861652255058289,
0.2505662143230438,
-0.4038011133670807,
-0.17359118163585663,
-0.3426683247089386,
0.2081889659166336,
-0.540199339389801,
0.9937370419502258,
0.7672225832939148,
-0.4765740633010864,
0.17700716853141785,
-0.2501574754714966,
0.7051209211349487,
0.05476514250040054,
-1.027562141418457,
0.08079323172569275,
0.32514363527297974,
-0.0722605511546135,
0.7976207137107849,
0.8530855774879456,
0.08335872739553452,
0.14130251109600067,
0.22914628684520721,
0.0823240578174591,
-0.0633159875869751,
-0.8525020480155945,
0.027342921122908592,
0.3023509085178375,
0.3848753571510315,
-0.18714015185832977
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07747v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07747v1
|
FineMath: A Fine-Grained Mathematical Evaluation Benchmark for Chinese Large Language Models
| 2024-03-12T15:32:39 | 2024-03-12T15:32:39 |
Yan Liu, Renren Jin, Lin Shi, Zheng Yao, Deyi Xiong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
To thoroughly assess the mathematical reasoning abilities of Large Language
Models (LLMs), we need to carefully curate evaluation datasets covering diverse
mathematical concepts and mathematical problems at different difficulty levels.
In pursuit of this objective, we propose FineMath in this paper, a fine-grained
mathematical evaluation benchmark dataset for assessing Chinese LLMs. FineMath
is created to cover the major key mathematical concepts taught in elementary
school math, which are further divided into 17 categories of math word
problems, enabling in-depth analysis of mathematical reasoning abilities of
LLMs. All the 17 categories of math word problems are manually annotated with
their difficulty levels according to the number of reasoning steps required to
solve these problems. We conduct extensive experiments on a wide range of LLMs
on FineMath and find that there is still considerable room for improvements in
terms of mathematical reasoning capability of Chinese LLMs. We also carry out
an in-depth analysis on the evaluation process and methods that have been
overlooked previously. These two factors significantly influence the model
results and our understanding of their mathematical reasoning capabilities. The
dataset will be publicly available soon.
|
[
-0.43094930052757263,
-0.8893674612045288,
0.5632550120353699,
0.3082161843776703,
-0.1288837194442749,
-0.19114509224891663,
-0.5420416593551636,
-0.1534382849931717,
-0.35995471477508545,
0.3502792418003082,
-0.3905273973941803,
-0.5778273940086365,
-0.45593321323394775,
0.006672112736850977,
-0.25548145174980164,
0.7435047626495361,
-0.17775607109069824,
0.511846661567688,
-0.2833998203277588,
-0.1239154189825058,
-0.38752061128616333,
-0.2909049987792969,
-0.5834599733352661,
-0.5512984991073608,
0.2923162579536438,
0.3781568706035614,
0.9587183594703674,
0.7026393413543701,
0.9524780511856079,
0.35880112648010254,
-0.06467701494693756,
0.27178701758384705,
-0.5167548060417175,
-0.1907413750886917,
-0.3204580247402191,
-0.4436936676502228,
-0.518835723400116,
-0.019151192158460617,
0.724236786365509,
1.0511120557785034,
-0.2907044291496277,
0.34412094950675964,
0.11941253393888474,
0.6651709675788879,
-0.44377586245536804,
0.3570309281349182,
-0.6758157014846802,
0.056379567831754684,
-0.5933910608291626,
0.1291307508945465,
-0.07723338901996613,
-0.5317914485931396,
0.08964555710554123,
-0.6255390048027039,
-0.07934629917144775,
-0.11429413408041,
0.6396317481994629,
0.011898210272192955,
-0.058993466198444366,
-0.20400406420230865,
-0.422969251871109,
1.0052058696746826,
-0.7929301261901855,
0.11278840899467468,
0.3757592737674713,
0.7256971597671509,
-0.1742042899131775,
-0.6924203038215637,
-0.4508967101573944,
-0.3730264902114868,
0.19314630329608917,
0.04243602603673935,
-0.031229456886649132,
-0.015530852600932121,
0.3595605194568634,
0.8153185844421387,
-0.5431461334228516,
0.2635214328765869,
-0.17130419611930847,
-0.26869210600852966,
0.8385120630264282,
0.7325912117958069,
0.452661395072937,
-0.04869416728615761,
0.07942806929349899,
-0.009537794627249241,
-0.5737935900688171,
0.15176483988761902,
0.09063847362995148,
0.49295687675476074,
-0.12794129550457,
0.6384792327880859,
-0.4452866315841675,
0.6787102222442627,
-0.441069096326828,
-0.11099845170974731,
0.11948081851005554,
-0.3065963089466095,
-0.3333614766597748,
-0.21401719748973846,
0.7060122489929199,
0.3667190968990326,
0.5491357445716858,
0.14050598442554474,
-0.5408977270126343,
0.2689937949180603,
-0.36322739720344543,
-1.1555181741714478,
-0.2956213355064392,
0.08108282834291458,
-0.40888041257858276,
-0.03611091896891594,
0.03484407067298889,
-0.6070491075515747,
-0.4729723036289215,
-0.5589936375617981,
0.3875693380832672,
-0.46722185611724854,
0.10226649791002274,
0.3751627802848816,
0.26445430517196655,
0.06686227768659592,
0.6170918345451355,
-0.836388885974884,
0.49581068754196167,
1.2046620845794678,
0.6873087882995605,
-0.16447438299655914,
-0.4482254683971405,
-0.6217103004455566,
-0.38823992013931274,
-0.47048497200012207,
0.7955395579338074,
-0.7147315144538879,
-0.12488684803247452,
0.11572688072919846,
-0.15254978835582733,
0.0314641110599041,
-0.768647313117981,
0.8478902578353882,
-0.16470369696617126,
0.05186649411916733,
-0.20789076387882233,
-0.7104722261428833,
-0.3219745457172394,
0.5435903668403625,
-0.451482355594635,
0.7316601872444153,
0.1132761612534523,
-0.4576544463634491,
-0.07355916500091553,
-0.6051461696624756,
-0.3190261423587799,
0.15246911346912384,
-0.15541581809520721,
-0.25573140382766724,
0.20650218427181244,
0.22930532693862915,
0.5537244081497192,
-0.8270238041877747,
0.5173829197883606,
-0.6600677967071533,
-0.4461205005645752,
0.2942870259284973,
-0.7061310410499573,
0.7215514779090881,
0.4213514029979706,
-0.015087719075381756,
0.14608563482761383,
-0.9028332829475403,
0.26659101247787476,
0.4160151183605194,
0.06189248338341713,
-0.5030003190040588,
-0.032786887139081955,
0.03413331136107445,
0.12919284403324127,
0.5885936617851257,
-0.37140214443206787,
0.11774268746376038,
-0.5238013863563538,
0.4924567937850952,
0.7508507966995239,
-0.26768994331359863,
0.20328521728515625,
-0.4656972289085388,
0.1864754855632782,
-0.1655704379081726,
0.059666626155376434,
-0.26118823885917664,
-0.36181312799453735,
-0.6867183446884155,
-0.09484385699033737,
0.4719156324863434,
0.4557664096355438,
-0.3633002042770386,
0.15714357793331146,
-0.15899032354354858,
-0.8006069660186768,
-0.37498337030410767,
0.23104427754878998,
0.5494703054428101,
0.19688822329044342,
0.25385385751724243,
-0.043080031871795654,
-0.006356033030897379,
-0.8429298996925354,
-0.39426878094673157,
0.37441396713256836,
-0.2681348919868469,
0.5471723675727844,
0.5061184763908386,
-0.09303530305624008,
0.4328826665878296,
-0.6318483352661133,
-0.33250629901885986,
-0.03044155240058899,
-0.03706488013267517,
0.3728588819503784,
0.377580851316452,
0.32853803038597107,
-0.2805463373661041,
-0.45890456438064575,
0.30858272314071655,
-0.629044234752655,
-0.47417473793029785,
-0.0037363064475357533,
-0.24478131532669067,
-0.16785305738449097,
0.2574876844882965,
-0.39223429560661316,
0.044437240809202194,
0.4473411738872528,
-0.2934083044528961,
0.5887859463691711,
-0.1322258710861206,
-0.05704360827803612,
-0.7345090508460999,
-0.01879471354186535,
0.15013426542282104,
0.1487862467765808,
-0.30214405059814453,
0.4527350962162018,
0.1614643782377243,
-0.13585776090621948,
-0.35803350806236267,
0.7644926309585571,
-0.1835031360387802,
-0.2265356183052063,
-0.021187709644436836,
0.4514586925506592,
-0.009577755816280842,
0.4129330813884735,
-0.269030898809433,
0.6035090684890747,
0.600098729133606,
-0.5256088376045227,
0.5359143018722534,
-0.02701377309858799,
-0.6171573400497437,
0.6230882406234741,
-0.645446240901947,
-0.14745871722698212,
0.16402113437652588,
-0.053962357342243195,
-0.8561785817146301,
-0.20545104146003723,
-0.11655647307634354,
-0.1800311654806137,
-0.11061961948871613,
0.24184542894363403,
-0.6566265821456909,
-0.2953909635543823,
-0.3859182298183441,
0.4650780260562897,
0.19288040697574615,
-0.44830507040023804,
0.23243704438209534,
0.2345464527606964,
-0.15328551828861237,
-0.09866058081388474,
-0.4203835129737854,
-0.13087309896945953,
-0.18827682733535767,
-0.8158785104751587,
0.1368771344423294,
-0.1926618367433548,
-0.6530904173851013,
-0.10971762984991074,
-0.14461760222911835,
-0.3327885866165161,
0.31580671668052673,
-0.12588489055633545,
0.32878515124320984,
-0.5471029877662659,
0.02066079154610634,
-0.11713003367185593,
-0.20796296000480652,
0.2452305555343628,
0.05010392516851425,
0.7013602256774902,
-0.4034259021282196,
-0.4829263687133789,
-0.33829423785209656,
-0.1702241152524948,
0.4603253901004791,
-0.45703378319740295,
0.08363848924636841,
0.40659037232398987,
-0.8033239841461182,
-0.3103145360946655,
-0.228395476937294,
0.013540026731789112,
-0.4371070861816406,
0.5078684687614441,
-0.5233723521232605,
-0.7114248275756836,
0.739927351474762,
-0.19491229951381683,
0.41748812794685364,
0.817925214767456,
0.6862587928771973,
0.31095752120018005,
1.0910567045211792,
0.05569775402545929,
-0.09820247441530228,
0.07321180403232574,
-0.20420315861701965,
-0.17609141767024994,
-0.6436352729797363,
-0.04877876862883568,
-0.5561487674713135,
-0.24829700589179993,
-0.43715256452560425,
-0.563116192817688,
-0.08819546550512314,
0.23710867762565613,
-0.6273969411849976,
0.12436364591121674,
-0.3940882384777069,
0.5565987825393677,
0.1731412708759308,
-0.023438485339283943,
0.46471521258354187,
-0.10896369069814682,
-0.24460269510746002,
-0.28397849202156067,
-0.28354471921920776,
-0.5332231521606445,
0.95685213804245,
0.4720326066017151,
0.8074905872344971,
0.03387527912855148,
0.32958298921585083,
-0.03569866344332695,
0.4309881925582886,
-1.0018954277038574,
0.6483228802680969,
-0.5922238230705261,
-0.4291112720966339,
-0.4029138386249542,
-0.6643131375312805,
-0.9041292071342468,
0.3368448317050934,
-0.041445549577474594,
-0.6621938943862915,
-0.4889240860939026,
-0.3297761380672455,
-0.5889616012573242,
0.18594826757907867,
-0.5338510274887085,
0.9441843032836914,
-0.4457833468914032,
-0.40050169825553894,
-0.3469436764717102,
-0.18519392609596252,
0.8546998500823975,
-0.4223147928714752,
0.29777297377586365,
-0.50682532787323,
0.23001928627490997,
0.8067870140075684,
-0.7711392045021057,
0.4489530026912689,
-0.05052543804049492,
-0.28598374128341675,
0.30659639835357666,
0.4372883141040802,
0.298809289932251,
0.20939914882183075,
-0.1961844265460968,
0.3648460805416107,
0.2500379681587219,
-0.25196564197540283,
-0.5412794351577759,
0.8716267943382263,
-0.6729416251182556,
-0.4828741252422333,
-0.37102431058883667,
-0.7586933374404907,
-0.2661281228065491,
0.3898119628429413,
-0.14258252084255219,
0.62364661693573,
-0.1749620884656906,
0.3647783398628235,
0.3908328413963318,
-0.3391529321670532,
0.34685030579566956,
0.6222874522209167,
-0.5917078852653503,
-0.3923008143901825,
1.1191725730895996,
0.3554457426071167,
0.10395418852567673,
0.2494240254163742,
0.6757771372795105,
-0.17681829631328583,
-0.5912927985191345,
-0.41066163778305054,
0.04710710048675537,
-0.5686171650886536,
-0.32304999232292175,
-0.05882833153009415,
-0.4853264093399048,
0.0598439984023571,
-0.11245175451040268,
-0.5999237298965454,
-0.2602614164352417,
-0.051968857645988464,
0.4501490890979767,
0.17688928544521332,
0.49961990118026733,
0.198270782828331,
0.241556316614151,
-0.8233805298805237,
0.5746820569038391,
0.3730866312980652,
0.7548782229423523,
0.13649320602416992,
-0.6887398958206177,
-0.1710343062877655,
0.2848968803882599,
-0.44304290413856506,
-0.026970461010932922,
0.1858590692281723,
0.18423359096050262,
0.5444138646125793,
0.7341088652610779,
-0.014323403127491474,
0.9190689921379089,
-0.6777220964431763,
0.5839765071868896,
0.0052468483336269855,
-1.1366167068481445,
0.2413998693227768,
-0.38118207454681396,
0.30830052495002747,
0.37902095913887024,
-0.1550714671611786,
-0.5261934995651245,
-0.06797678023576736,
-0.49229905009269714,
-0.42125290632247925,
0.6396899819374084,
0.26366785168647766,
0.24180640280246735,
0.18871648609638214,
0.06273907423019409,
0.16248808801174164,
-0.08789217472076416,
-0.35041606426239014,
-0.21304547786712646,
0.1166800931096077,
-0.2487672120332718,
-0.15676455199718475,
-0.09775562584400177,
-0.08897364884614944,
-0.35793957114219666,
0.29347631335258484,
-0.09837621450424194,
-0.10613797605037689,
-0.2860989570617676,
-0.02752658724784851,
-0.18144267797470093,
0.19125668704509735,
0.6708731055259705,
0.8643597960472107,
-0.2127956598997116,
0.0033639261964708567,
0.45891615748405457,
-0.5896046161651611,
-0.3058648407459259,
0.4950698912143707,
0.09247658401727676,
-0.1890489012002945,
0.43936431407928467,
0.46070602536201477,
0.27374616265296936,
-0.8438999056816101,
0.4458646774291992,
-0.032818861305713654,
-0.2866482734680176,
-0.15153811872005463,
0.07336756587028503,
0.11096721887588501,
0.16897836327552795,
0.2198789119720459,
-0.019136913120746613,
0.24497061967849731,
-0.4861249625682831,
0.2714361250400543,
0.4790526330471039,
-0.15161524713039398,
-0.27545294165611267,
0.48837125301361084,
0.10691405832767487,
-0.3342697024345398,
0.42410916090011597,
-0.12086432427167892,
-0.5231541991233826,
0.8011497855186462,
0.5461161732673645,
0.6316366791725159,
-0.2290724366903305,
-0.12814922630786896,
0.42318299412727356,
0.20679309964179993,
-0.28457629680633545,
0.308782696723938,
0.20655731856822968,
-0.7047849297523499,
-0.3819083869457245,
-0.6808549761772156,
-0.6189078688621521,
0.41670456528663635,
-0.49076369404792786,
0.5622759461402893,
-0.7409785389900208,
0.25912678241729736,
0.227449432015419,
0.5573142170906067,
-0.5835228562355042,
0.38737979531288147,
0.4520964026451111,
1.0625523328781128,
-0.47844198346138,
0.6488549113273621,
0.49776172637939453,
-0.0800839513540268,
-0.8330371379852295,
-0.10214448720216751,
-0.08209475874900818,
-1.2274961471557617,
0.43121957778930664,
0.48774948716163635,
0.05628318712115288,
-0.11635367572307587,
-0.5070030093193054,
-0.7054068446159363,
0.885528564453125,
0.4069230556488037,
-0.8282914161682129,
0.4800306260585785,
0.3113207221031189,
0.62215656042099,
-0.2591497302055359,
0.44043707847595215,
0.6818936467170715,
0.5691338181495667,
0.12288368493318558,
-0.9978753924369812,
-0.055320508778095245,
-0.33324187994003296,
-0.024191269651055336,
0.17215509712696075,
-0.7583643198013306,
1.0868116617202759,
-0.09918023645877838,
-0.23612898588180542,
0.325048565864563,
0.6379626393318176,
0.548907995223999,
0.776655912399292,
0.31188496947288513,
0.6408604383468628,
0.753547191619873,
-0.24056580662727356,
0.802990198135376,
-0.35144805908203125,
0.5994165539741516,
1.097137689590454,
-0.3067326843738556,
0.8526713252067566,
-0.024608328938484192,
-0.5922321677207947,
-0.014729104936122894,
0.8027476072311401,
-0.2687724232673645,
0.19450095295906067,
0.8461278080940247,
0.06937354058027267,
-0.5367938876152039,
-0.1878960132598877,
-0.6180763840675354,
0.528857409954071,
0.551642656326294,
0.02563932165503502,
-0.6692702770233154,
-0.3574971556663513,
0.14776365458965302,
0.4027881324291229,
-0.7663689851760864,
0.3810833990573883,
0.32649028301239014,
-0.4219091832637787,
0.706795334815979,
0.2986433804035187,
0.6039146780967712,
-0.48251545429229736,
-0.12179656326770782,
-0.5176645517349243,
0.3624296486377716,
-0.2820454239845276,
-1.1254780292510986,
0.12758669257164001,
-0.02593386545777321,
0.2240104228258133,
0.37000414729118347,
0.5687439441680908,
-0.408604234457016,
-0.706810474395752,
0.01349046640098095,
0.4370325803756714,
0.2952573597431183,
-0.26776212453842163,
-0.8124403357505798,
0.0632699653506279,
-0.1887618452310562,
-0.16525410115718842,
0.2818816900253296,
0.96317458152771,
-0.39185047149658203,
0.7037975192070007,
0.8228874802589417,
0.046156372874975204,
-0.18235692381858826,
0.43786609172821045,
0.7687160968780518,
-0.7631228566169739,
-0.30993494391441345,
-1.1713805198669434,
0.1807449758052826,
0.06792549788951874,
-0.5233123302459717,
0.8557154536247253,
0.739660382270813,
0.7814847826957703,
0.10233357548713684,
0.5443323850631714,
0.3298962712287903,
0.4149811565876007,
-0.41419845819473267,
0.7590150833129883,
-0.5556246638298035,
0.33426377177238464,
-0.47505372762680054,
-1.153598427772522,
-0.6302673816680908,
0.7046549916267395,
-0.47130173444747925,
-0.04142633453011513,
0.5673064589500427,
0.5133326649665833,
-0.19866295158863068,
0.09421109408140182,
0.6218825578689575,
0.14218105375766754,
0.13522467017173767,
0.908112108707428,
1.0039267539978027,
-0.4842529892921448,
0.35472285747528076,
-0.38823407888412476,
-0.08613520860671997,
-0.17970289289951324,
-0.7199215888977051,
-1.0472098588943481,
-0.2040005922317505,
-0.13812175393104553,
-0.1828504353761673,
-0.4137357473373413,
0.9798210859298706,
0.0748162791132927,
-0.9244965314865112,
-0.36069345474243164,
-0.12629066407680511,
0.1672751009464264,
-0.12867000699043274,
-0.22916589677333832,
0.6601788997650146,
-0.47016462683677673,
-0.9813589453697205,
-0.036056969314813614,
0.26194047927856445,
-0.14016950130462646,
-0.34460005164146423,
-0.0350506566464901,
0.27987489104270935,
0.16310182213783264,
0.6112498641014099,
-0.0053841061890125275,
-0.7175907492637634,
-0.06936970353126526,
-0.06954243034124374,
-0.42021963000297546,
-0.07563577592372894,
0.5927456617355347,
-0.2963472902774811,
0.4862860441207886,
0.5412390232086182,
0.9078130722045898,
0.05013996735215187,
-0.16976861655712128,
0.31503477692604065,
-0.035421013832092285,
0.01554408110678196,
0.011782796122133732,
0.6086467504501343,
0.20379498600959778,
0.06344040483236313,
0.46937456727027893,
0.19901946187019348,
-0.4245888888835907,
-0.9478180408477783,
-0.18901970982551575,
-0.9337734580039978,
-0.22671745717525482,
1.1481374502182007,
-0.2673230767250061,
-0.1279067099094391,
0.2018551081418991,
-0.3508787751197815,
0.029204504564404488,
-0.21855996549129486,
0.8372159004211426,
0.9556763172149658,
0.16895270347595215,
0.08096947520971298,
-0.7791429758071899,
0.29394498467445374,
0.6389830708503723,
-0.9377772212028503,
0.35781383514404297,
0.37534552812576294,
0.10088108479976654,
0.030413316562771797,
0.1730731725692749,
-0.2576860189437866,
0.2929503917694092,
-0.0645204409956932,
-0.19165629148483276,
-0.10291614383459091,
-0.11295085400342941,
-0.36143600940704346,
0.11885172873735428,
0.1013602763414383,
-0.05786573141813278
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07726v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07726v3
|
SemEval-2024 Shared Task 6: SHROOM, a Shared-task on Hallucinations and Related Observable Overgeneration Mistakes
| 2024-03-12T15:06:22 | 2024-03-29T17:59:07 |
Timothee Mickus, Elaine Zosa, Raúl Vázquez, Teemu Vahtola, Jörg Tiedemann, Vincent Segonne, Alessandro Raganato, Marianna Apidianaki
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper presents the results of the SHROOM, a shared task focused on
detecting hallucinations: outputs from natural language generation (NLG)
systems that are fluent, yet inaccurate. Such cases of overgeneration put in
jeopardy many NLG applications, where correctness is often mission-critical.
The shared task was conducted with a newly constructed dataset of 4000 model
outputs labeled by 5 annotators each, spanning 3 NLP tasks: machine
translation, paraphrase generation and definition modeling.
The shared task was tackled by a total of 58 different users grouped in 42
teams, out of which 27 elected to write a system description paper;
collectively, they submitted over 300 prediction sets on both tracks of the
shared task. We observe a number of key trends in how this approach was tackled
-- many participants rely on a handful of model, and often rely either on
synthetic data for fine-tuning or zero-shot prompting strategies. While a
majority of the teams did outperform our proposed baseline system, the
performances of top-scoring systems are still consistent with a random handling
of the more challenging items.
|
[
-0.4797724485397339,
-0.6605365872383118,
0.677009105682373,
0.36347752809524536,
-0.24881349503993988,
-0.3452449440956116,
-0.027516113594174385,
-0.6869515776634216,
0.38153624534606934,
0.7607030868530273,
-0.791523277759552,
-0.39961230754852295,
-0.8300955891609192,
0.3965778648853302,
-0.45300328731536865,
0.8555400967597961,
-0.0021344905253499746,
-0.024294251576066017,
-0.3709968328475952,
-0.08482062816619873,
-0.8503009676933289,
-0.6867775917053223,
-0.28861287236213684,
-0.4005849361419678,
0.44209545850753784,
0.42894652485847473,
0.5037147402763367,
0.35782548785209656,
0.6460686922073364,
0.2232949286699295,
0.21915172040462494,
0.3367319405078888,
-0.5237725377082825,
0.42209380865097046,
-0.1948222815990448,
-0.002515289932489395,
-0.49177688360214233,
-0.3040306568145752,
-0.04682472348213196,
0.666580319404602,
-0.3594379723072052,
0.07615732401609421,
0.4108670651912689,
0.4963682293891907,
-0.5805050134658813,
0.430501252412796,
-0.7614185214042664,
0.3325946629047394,
-0.1442076414823532,
-0.4145755469799042,
-0.4662473201751709,
-0.13352994620800018,
0.039325326681137085,
-0.5423451066017151,
0.4465572237968445,
0.010467985644936562,
0.5627699494361877,
0.7223365306854248,
-0.2026483565568924,
-0.5014771819114685,
-0.5244284868240356,
0.9263743758201599,
-0.6993123888969421,
0.033570144325494766,
0.5600185394287109,
0.4261195957660675,
-0.2550978362560272,
-0.7804163098335266,
-0.340763121843338,
0.200273796916008,
-0.04710953310132027,
0.1885099560022354,
-0.12772344052791595,
0.13731232285499573,
0.3510623872280121,
0.1773177832365036,
-0.5736021995544434,
-0.12394777685403824,
-0.8044610023498535,
-0.39527857303619385,
0.791190505027771,
0.35344648361206055,
0.0959581658244133,
-0.45667216181755066,
-0.33961063623428345,
0.056013017892837524,
-0.3544829189777374,
-0.6196008920669556,
-0.020614948123693466,
0.30772238969802856,
0.36424335837364197,
0.5737420916557312,
-0.38541293144226074,
0.44214606285095215,
0.028556648641824722,
0.3846099078655243,
0.46109282970428467,
-0.42107313871383667,
-0.304898738861084,
0.4563017785549164,
0.5774974822998047,
0.6424756050109863,
0.12434523552656174,
-0.20333123207092285,
-0.3114650249481201,
0.45040297508239746,
0.680554211139679,
-0.4927157163619995,
-0.3424270451068878,
0.15644197165966034,
-0.4212191700935364,
-0.5654654502868652,
-0.1524297147989273,
-0.997294545173645,
-0.8764632344245911,
-0.4537501037120819,
1.0416449308395386,
-0.4133395552635193,
0.015034622512757778,
0.3080810606479645,
-0.28592243790626526,
0.051846399903297424,
0.44716039299964905,
-0.7934626936912537,
0.3950698673725128,
0.6348935961723328,
0.7892033457756042,
-0.5761176347732544,
-0.6389524936676025,
-0.5680869221687317,
0.10661767423152924,
-0.24298785626888275,
0.8083882927894592,
-0.15610478818416595,
-0.46188032627105713,
-0.1061457097530365,
0.034880176186561584,
-0.14061082899570465,
-0.7780801057815552,
0.7397292256355286,
0.18253125250339508,
0.5144870281219482,
-0.6747142672538757,
-0.5595752596855164,
-0.11470522731542587,
0.06423705071210861,
-0.6242532134056091,
1.0173614025115967,
0.11653508245944977,
-0.771226167678833,
0.5790401697158813,
-0.6949260234832764,
-0.31335195899009705,
0.393218457698822,
-0.3527795076370239,
-0.21093317866325378,
0.3716505765914917,
0.3341067433357239,
0.7114371061325073,
0.01134978886693716,
0.7274333238601685,
-0.03815874457359314,
-0.7456985116004944,
-0.2672906517982483,
-0.3883431851863861,
0.5485740303993225,
0.21879181265830994,
-0.7169825434684753,
0.22956056892871857,
-0.8853508234024048,
-0.059563834220170975,
-0.05997039005160332,
-0.11756087839603424,
-0.15296673774719238,
-0.011311756446957588,
-0.08290765434503555,
0.2826695442199707,
0.32479995489120483,
-0.43744152784347534,
-0.053996067494153976,
-0.06514889001846313,
0.3917103409767151,
0.8660396337509155,
0.29684725403785706,
0.2293396145105362,
-0.6078261137008667,
0.3482171893119812,
-0.024800920858979225,
0.35454124212265015,
-0.19477525353431702,
-0.6497190594673157,
-0.7939005494117737,
0.15295827388763428,
-0.14890381693840027,
0.41743895411491394,
-0.7174237966537476,
0.5427440404891968,
-0.10025425255298615,
-0.4747125804424286,
-0.3642992675304413,
-0.18629273772239685,
0.062435638159513474,
0.3939116895198822,
0.6876139640808105,
-0.24870175123214722,
-1.0748833417892456,
-0.9435478448867798,
-0.11963699758052826,
0.10240400582551956,
0.022907773032784462,
0.24723170697689056,
0.6852155327796936,
-0.6577484607696533,
0.39412224292755127,
-0.4602104127407074,
-0.681358814239502,
-0.1353868693113327,
0.45027682185173035,
-0.0017586895264685154,
0.4860537052154541,
0.19832660257816315,
-0.3823809027671814,
-0.27731722593307495,
-0.19089540839195251,
-1.105790615081787,
-0.39517661929130554,
-0.03308354690670967,
-0.07613786309957504,
0.6075398325920105,
0.689674973487854,
-0.3182825744152069,
0.3763182461261749,
0.8099856376647949,
-0.27602699398994446,
0.5699569582939148,
-0.21335062384605408,
0.308093786239624,
-1.1602739095687866,
-0.09839817136526108,
-0.38567498326301575,
0.01896352879703045,
-0.668662965297699,
0.011665684171020985,
-0.26672986149787903,
-0.08561690151691437,
-0.12611351907253265,
0.26299938559532166,
-0.3148633539676666,
-0.0011900190729647875,
-0.2933056354522705,
-0.15052101016044617,
-0.05010191723704338,
0.7772303819656372,
0.11381510645151138,
0.4185750484466553,
0.40994805097579956,
-0.39549243450164795,
0.20314888656139374,
0.04592796042561531,
-0.21323180198669434,
0.4087052047252655,
-0.6038156747817993,
0.32900187373161316,
0.07285798341035843,
0.07087399810552597,
-0.6834990382194519,
-0.8059900999069214,
0.296251505613327,
-0.5865371227264404,
-0.17754100263118744,
0.4692842662334442,
-0.40242013335227966,
-0.2672480344772339,
-0.20102937519550323,
0.04888075962662697,
0.4871465861797333,
-0.39180392026901245,
0.693188488483429,
0.48663756251335144,
0.0408547967672348,
-0.3873024582862854,
-0.8340498208999634,
0.26801279187202454,
-0.2523898184299469,
-0.7932361364364624,
0.3121674358844757,
0.1856636106967926,
-0.25065696239471436,
0.04358480125665665,
-0.36199015378952026,
-0.1725030541419983,
-0.1592279076576233,
0.7059628963470459,
0.09929715842008591,
-0.04260924458503723,
0.03380686417222023,
-0.058259520679712296,
-0.04969058930873871,
0.19594614207744598,
0.023375313729047775,
0.7262943387031555,
-0.11571457237005234,
-0.33340176939964294,
-0.14360930025577545,
0.459181547164917,
0.5709319114685059,
0.2078534960746765,
0.8308547139167786,
0.4892578423023224,
-0.8872654438018799,
-0.37033215165138245,
-0.6304142475128174,
-0.4381667971611023,
-0.47459176182746887,
0.18145568668842316,
-0.1487404853105545,
-0.9321991205215454,
0.7332908511161804,
0.24388627707958221,
0.23037193715572357,
0.6274369955062866,
0.40061691403388977,
-0.17191599309444427,
1.1764005422592163,
0.43641677498817444,
0.4300590455532074,
-0.05096865072846413,
-0.13075797259807587,
0.3373405635356903,
-0.3923977017402649,
-0.46934568881988525,
-0.4481309950351715,
-0.2742127776145935,
-0.43255266547203064,
-0.7167147397994995,
0.3115493953227997,
-0.03297819569706917,
0.12753182649612427,
0.617509126663208,
-0.7923142313957214,
0.1909174621105194,
0.771087110042572,
0.0480009950697422,
0.31511467695236206,
-0.08539419621229172,
0.19386470317840576,
-0.47447457909584045,
-0.6268083453178406,
-0.3951753079891205,
0.8328577876091003,
0.11321801692247391,
0.5297152400016785,
-0.41873037815093994,
1.2548348903656006,
0.5278206467628479,
-0.16967175900936127,
-0.6658434271812439,
0.6727200150489807,
-0.0801929235458374,
-0.6418567299842834,
-0.6407081484794617,
-0.2827039062976837,
-0.6386486291885376,
0.2378000020980835,
-0.07883846759796143,
-0.46239444613456726,
0.436663419008255,
0.18087029457092285,
-0.3959396183490753,
-0.023560961708426476,
-0.671416163444519,
0.8348823189735413,
0.05129057541489601,
-0.10255834460258484,
-0.2969616949558258,
-0.48934030532836914,
0.46581289172172546,
-0.4144841432571411,
0.151558518409729,
0.0772319883108139,
0.44723817706108093,
0.8815681338310242,
-0.36271822452545166,
0.8443532586097717,
-0.3196457326412201,
0.0436314232647419,
0.27488163113594055,
0.0788641944527626,
0.5283985733985901,
-0.3734530508518219,
-0.15528130531311035,
0.24742138385772705,
0.1219387948513031,
-0.24133840203285217,
-0.5112614631652832,
0.6288573145866394,
-0.6078894138336182,
-0.48481249809265137,
-0.7767799496650696,
-0.5284109711647034,
-0.10223975032567978,
0.1443985551595688,
0.7895744442939758,
0.5565279722213745,
-0.15510565042495728,
0.6919492483139038,
0.5995355844497681,
-0.3510077893733978,
0.13974550366401672,
-0.05618097260594368,
-0.15807168185710907,
-0.38594284653663635,
0.9681775569915771,
0.4374314844608307,
0.07781913131475449,
-0.16516879200935364,
0.16834977269172668,
-0.01247631199657917,
-0.5544777512550354,
0.06394533812999725,
0.08848097920417786,
-0.6729433536529541,
-0.18287958204746246,
-0.8941980600357056,
-0.4829551577568054,
-0.7076952457427979,
-0.39900830388069153,
-0.35350242257118225,
-0.38023531436920166,
-0.1078224629163742,
-0.2747328579425812,
-0.10222500562667847,
0.882921040058136,
-0.3428743779659271,
0.08235178142786026,
-0.9013394117355347,
0.26423752307891846,
0.36255303025245667,
0.029584037140011787,
-0.22395122051239014,
-0.4645748436450958,
-0.27597343921661377,
0.020882096141576767,
-0.30841127038002014,
-0.9166865348815918,
0.6139844655990601,
0.09219450503587723,
0.7247592210769653,
0.16332975029945374,
0.36847466230392456,
0.9126170873641968,
-0.27541908621788025,
1.040575385093689,
0.08816783875226974,
-0.9718039631843567,
0.6677111387252808,
-0.4783656895160675,
0.3635927140712738,
0.8394143581390381,
0.2123367339372635,
-0.7501486539840698,
-0.6327908039093018,
-0.8408336043357849,
-0.895054280757904,
0.7904605865478516,
0.3300221562385559,
-0.01281348429620266,
0.0009297726210206747,
-0.05052391439676285,
0.3957401216030121,
0.3003162443637848,
-0.6578577160835266,
0.23999682068824768,
-0.3500734269618988,
-0.08669857680797577,
0.13119959831237793,
-0.32686468958854675,
-0.19396893680095673,
-0.16533449292182922,
0.6810441017150879,
-0.13208964467048645,
0.24436810612678528,
0.27621203660964966,
-0.0017940336838364601,
-0.48912346363067627,
0.19443684816360474,
0.66225266456604,
0.7264018058776855,
-0.4186580181121826,
0.2009279727935791,
0.4003804326057434,
-0.4330325722694397,
-0.3318866789340973,
-0.09805575013160706,
-0.08010009676218033,
0.20010551810264587,
0.6212934851646423,
0.9829912781715393,
0.27222782373428345,
-0.6970743536949158,
0.34448331594467163,
-0.10165350139141083,
-0.7927179932594299,
-0.38577279448509216,
0.22825512290000916,
-0.08592988550662994,
0.14580686390399933,
0.4551202654838562,
0.5345816016197205,
0.4097345471382141,
-0.6575412750244141,
0.5723503232002258,
-0.11726537346839905,
-0.7010212540626526,
-0.36649560928344727,
0.6252012848854065,
0.18603940308094025,
-0.3888271749019623,
0.45158007740974426,
-0.2891406714916229,
-0.620278537273407,
0.4764239490032196,
0.25946614146232605,
0.9758009910583496,
-0.21492886543273926,
0.35572725534439087,
0.5424729585647583,
0.3370065689086914,
-0.515983521938324,
0.44705161452293396,
0.012460707686841488,
-0.7290231585502625,
-0.31812798976898193,
-0.5817425847053528,
-0.24914507567882538,
0.45880088210105896,
-0.8889696598052979,
0.4407897889614105,
-0.14709120988845825,
-0.06799524277448654,
-0.18597853183746338,
-0.014494865201413631,
-0.4121077060699463,
0.11843186616897583,
0.0772237554192543,
0.5205559730529785,
-1.0605816841125488,
0.5796645283699036,
0.35885536670684814,
-0.07647447288036346,
-0.8709484338760376,
-0.05064412206411362,
0.19038471579551697,
-0.5972872972488403,
0.3597748279571533,
0.3600127100944519,
0.03928065672516823,
-0.1622917354106903,
-0.6244984269142151,
-0.5929594039916992,
1.1391651630401611,
0.0841924399137497,
-0.6901496052742004,
-0.48631611466407776,
-0.018211282789707184,
0.7996002435684204,
-0.11630159616470337,
-0.46546560525894165,
0.5467710494995117,
0.487751305103302,
0.3529182970523834,
-1.0336891412734985,
-0.021430790424346924,
-0.1080259159207344,
-0.4555433690547943,
0.24398888647556305,
-0.15360723435878754,
0.6617860198020935,
-0.08421268314123154,
-0.29289710521698,
-0.13600361347198486,
0.48412078619003296,
0.7265992760658264,
0.681355893611908,
0.5715400576591492,
0.6121744513511658,
0.727165937423706,
-0.24108277261257172,
0.718751847743988,
-0.147650808095932,
0.15516366064548492,
1.4291338920593262,
-0.4704880714416504,
0.7270738482475281,
0.700559675693512,
0.21818262338638306,
-0.15253499150276184,
0.43691450357437134,
-0.182459756731987,
0.6618263125419617,
0.04744508117437363,
0.07443176209926605,
-0.3564259707927704,
-0.24854977428913116,
-0.47974100708961487,
0.35155919194221497,
0.38866227865219116,
-0.36427193880081177,
-0.22264064848423004,
0.255888968706131,
-0.2775847315788269,
0.1671801507472992,
0.013096602633595467,
0.7186238169670105,
0.26927557587623596,
-1.061279058456421,
0.2696269750595093,
-0.41304677724838257,
0.9083413481712341,
-0.27033671736717224,
-0.26238182187080383,
-0.22714026272296906,
0.21224933862686157,
-0.3480392098426819,
-0.6940231919288635,
0.8151724934577942,
-0.1019233912229538,
0.07646120339632034,
-0.5021369457244873,
1.0074666738510132,
-0.3023533523082733,
-0.38469237089157104,
0.5207535624504089,
0.5433329343795776,
0.21556705236434937,
-0.3598948121070862,
-0.3342341482639313,
0.22624866664409637,
0.23866455256938934,
0.009296164847910404,
0.06730105727910995,
0.6346707940101624,
-0.16518455743789673,
0.3735677897930145,
0.16944438219070435,
0.2295541763305664,
0.5209742784500122,
0.24401584267616272,
0.4701524078845978,
-0.605107307434082,
-0.2905789911746979,
-0.6680755615234375,
0.3125452697277069,
-0.17437204718589783,
-0.4073684513568878,
0.8828625082969666,
0.4305919110774994,
0.8883481621742249,
-0.057723987847566605,
0.7628449201583862,
-0.11474563181400299,
0.5379340052604675,
-0.20882129669189453,
0.5038356184959412,
-0.48086318373680115,
0.02782796323299408,
-0.3639565110206604,
-1.0804823637008667,
-0.15787126123905182,
0.7002410888671875,
-0.03503011167049408,
-0.2373332530260086,
0.8808846473693848,
0.8277129530906677,
0.3340591490268707,
0.3955777585506439,
0.6544264554977417,
0.14124415814876556,
0.3357323110103607,
0.5261245369911194,
0.9078212380409241,
-0.6326432228088379,
0.4879295527935028,
-0.5563791394233704,
0.1161470115184784,
-0.29643553495407104,
-0.599091112613678,
-0.730328381061554,
-1.0370432138442993,
-0.330467164516449,
-0.2692723274230957,
0.24245649576187134,
0.9195335507392883,
0.44137561321258545,
-1.0435198545455933,
-0.08093506097793579,
-0.4058336615562439,
-0.5072100162506104,
-0.32711222767829895,
-0.28571709990501404,
0.1406875103712082,
-0.2808239459991455,
-0.6432027220726013,
0.24574404954910278,
0.3472226858139038,
-0.1444011777639389,
-0.3190148174762726,
-0.126059889793396,
0.07322515547275543,
0.08150314539670944,
0.5589540600776672,
-0.30764222145080566,
-0.7268313765525818,
-0.6037800312042236,
0.4064532220363617,
-0.2873573899269104,
-0.13719569146633148,
0.589353621006012,
-0.6014465093612671,
0.48141759634017944,
1.0059170722961426,
0.4275272786617279,
0.3503558933734894,
0.010343117639422417,
0.88763028383255,
-0.5569709539413452,
-0.2571142315864563,
0.5578251481056213,
0.36816656589508057,
0.2387852519750595,
-0.5162684917449951,
0.928876519203186,
0.29278504848480225,
-1.0212849378585815,
-1.2709579467773438,
-0.3168802857398987,
-0.8513525724411011,
-0.3708793520927429,
0.9276618957519531,
0.28333064913749695,
-0.0960962325334549,
-0.28826960921287537,
-0.3835315704345703,
0.3464263677597046,
-0.4248882532119751,
1.2924871444702148,
1.0705326795578003,
-0.23954299092292786,
-0.05167040228843689,
-0.7978954911231995,
0.8097060322761536,
0.4529123902320862,
-0.8736107349395752,
-0.004477137234061956,
0.8298905491828918,
-0.15574394166469574,
0.536121129989624,
0.7577731013298035,
-0.05469073727726936,
0.4711798131465912,
0.16097742319107056,
0.15845037996768951,
0.01488479133695364,
-0.6256826519966125,
-0.4797683656215668,
0.2614333927631378,
-0.3064980208873749,
-0.20417943596839905
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07714v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07714v4
|
StableToolBench: Towards Stable Large-Scale Benchmarking on Tool Learning of Large Language Models
| 2024-03-12T14:57:40 | 2024-06-19T11:59:08 |
Zhicheng Guo, Sijie Cheng, Hao Wang, Shihao Liang, Yujia Qin, Peng Li, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun, Yang Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have witnessed remarkable advancements in recent
years, prompting the exploration of tool learning, which integrates LLMs with
external tools to address diverse real-world challenges. Assessing the
capability of LLMs to utilise tools necessitates large-scale and stable
benchmarks. However, previous works relied on either hand-crafted online tools
with limited scale, or large-scale real online APIs suffering from instability
of API status. To address this problem, we introduce StableToolBench, a
benchmark evolving from ToolBench, proposing a virtual API server and stable
evaluation system. The virtual API server contains a caching system and API
simulators which are complementary to alleviate the change in API status.
Meanwhile, the stable evaluation system designs solvable pass and win rates
using GPT-4 as the automatic evaluator to eliminate the randomness during
evaluation. Experimental results demonstrate the stability of StableToolBench,
and further discuss the effectiveness of API simulators, the caching system,
and the evaluator system.
|
[
-0.429668128490448,
-0.7316451668739319,
0.44356703758239746,
0.39464113116264343,
-0.43301326036453247,
0.24033088982105255,
-0.6399677991867065,
-0.45066654682159424,
-0.10818388313055038,
0.19186656177043915,
-0.11651608347892761,
-0.5026799440383911,
-0.4958629310131073,
0.17288729548454285,
-0.2681823968887329,
0.6177278757095337,
-0.15094254910945892,
0.36954954266548157,
-0.18667733669281006,
-0.5207822918891907,
-0.6983655691146851,
-0.45550835132598877,
-0.9507126212120056,
-0.24421510100364685,
0.32383954524993896,
-0.06348904967308044,
0.5315406918525696,
0.6275730729103088,
0.43676841259002686,
0.4058476388454437,
0.09705690294504166,
-0.3049859404563904,
-0.7671334743499756,
0.5675245523452759,
-0.35105010867118835,
-0.5794100761413574,
-0.24230298399925232,
-0.11153340339660645,
0.6598679423332214,
0.48946085572242737,
-0.40420934557914734,
0.21443073451519012,
-0.15141354501247406,
0.20139993727207184,
-0.6007574200630188,
0.30632495880126953,
-0.9599429368972778,
-0.09429320693016052,
-0.0673704668879509,
0.24649810791015625,
-0.41643980145454407,
-0.691636860370636,
0.10739480704069138,
-0.22949352860450745,
-0.15228627622127533,
-0.20174095034599304,
0.7256032228469849,
0.37142860889434814,
-0.2212105691432953,
0.02212761901319027,
-0.4712035357952118,
0.834865152835846,
-0.8600930571556091,
0.6874753832817078,
0.24179258942604065,
0.7441742420196533,
-0.2307521402835846,
-0.7526155114173889,
-0.32909122109413147,
-0.565146803855896,
0.6630567312240601,
-0.041855547577142715,
0.24244017899036407,
-0.28135040402412415,
0.1859942525625229,
0.10080600529909134,
-0.3281911313533783,
0.47373315691947937,
0.021768586710095406,
-0.34771454334259033,
0.3020358085632324,
0.020888546481728554,
0.08041968941688538,
0.35095536708831787,
-0.24840779602527618,
-0.36016616225242615,
-0.7223244905471802,
-0.07411301136016846,
0.21307508647441864,
0.3625839352607727,
-0.06569070369005203,
0.36825883388519287,
0.19146598875522614,
0.4872731864452362,
-0.07320576906204224,
-0.254036545753479,
0.6569738388061523,
0.08583209663629532,
-0.051710207015275955,
-0.05046666041016579,
0.6072952151298523,
0.4490989148616791,
0.1704772412776947,
-0.4306390583515167,
-0.47750598192214966,
0.22449997067451477,
0.27034661173820496,
-0.8988950848579407,
-0.05021961033344269,
0.3199476897716522,
-0.2808303236961365,
-0.2688085734844208,
-0.04099845141172409,
-0.7048646211624146,
-0.5010699033737183,
-0.21333925426006317,
0.47146058082580566,
-0.0602501817047596,
-0.5775526165962219,
-0.2238471359014511,
-0.03721604123711586,
0.22002825140953064,
0.4521677792072296,
-0.42974674701690674,
0.48445454239845276,
0.8798956871032715,
0.8294470310211182,
-0.29566481709480286,
-0.33664149045944214,
-0.8600979447364807,
-0.02397722750902176,
-0.39067691564559937,
0.5067091584205627,
-0.36438292264938354,
-0.42353206872940063,
0.11301247030496597,
0.28137391805648804,
0.3254150450229645,
-0.7462881803512573,
0.5559630393981934,
-0.6699243187904358,
-0.1745145618915558,
-0.2035493701696396,
-0.4859256148338318,
0.3134937286376953,
0.7166224122047424,
-0.8731561303138733,
1.2349164485931396,
0.06552394479513168,
-0.5415967106819153,
0.5160974860191345,
-0.09464443475008011,
-0.2314581423997879,
-0.007910192012786865,
-0.2748483121395111,
-0.6614602208137512,
0.07754738628864288,
-0.22083324193954468,
0.0377323180437088,
-0.3451407253742218,
0.1637071967124939,
-0.7656188607215881,
-0.4727288484573364,
0.004062964580953121,
-0.3400011956691742,
0.5795704126358032,
0.1294400990009308,
-0.6917611956596375,
0.18341141939163208,
-0.7138999104499817,
0.19087819755077362,
0.16206403076648712,
-0.5622466802597046,
-0.2408222258090973,
0.056390803307294846,
0.09942662715911865,
0.3002571165561676,
0.25226375460624695,
-0.65118408203125,
0.4975473880767822,
-0.519560694694519,
0.3498724102973938,
0.9484979510307312,
-0.4073464870452881,
0.17070022225379944,
0.060951683670282364,
0.44282442331314087,
-0.2186911255121231,
0.07257158309221268,
0.15391302108764648,
-0.21914765238761902,
-0.5461148619651794,
-0.035396430641412735,
0.6570141315460205,
0.4010855555534363,
-0.600228488445282,
0.38224339485168457,
-0.4668046236038208,
-0.6823227405548096,
-0.4444442391395569,
0.40844807028770447,
0.44000980257987976,
0.12757328152656555,
0.1063939779996872,
-0.31406721472740173,
-0.3260699510574341,
-0.6137701272964478,
-0.17944355309009552,
-0.24963578581809998,
-0.18379390239715576,
-0.01316767930984497,
0.18356268107891083,
-0.164319708943367,
0.6640936732292175,
0.0397377647459507,
-0.018093930557370186,
-0.27120131254196167,
0.14609406888484955,
0.29369184374809265,
0.3878428637981415,
0.7462726831436157,
-0.462770015001297,
-0.47292816638946533,
0.038898639380931854,
-0.45117124915122986,
-0.2441655695438385,
0.33204564452171326,
0.06606049090623856,
0.37260085344314575,
0.6147363781929016,
-0.7524003386497498,
0.038374632596969604,
0.8541300892829895,
-0.006796709727495909,
0.5617129802703857,
-0.17799362540245056,
-0.16145269572734833,
-0.9186308979988098,
0.06932292878627777,
-0.17265142500400543,
-0.5064980387687683,
0.03761405497789383,
0.201449915766716,
0.3276229500770569,
-0.12940195202827454,
-0.5212136507034302,
0.9244001507759094,
-0.515494167804718,
-0.06690663844347,
-0.4463047385215759,
0.3134409785270691,
-0.19937650859355927,
-0.05378374829888344,
-0.24429364502429962,
0.6561818718910217,
0.4871819019317627,
-0.23326337337493896,
0.4733763039112091,
-0.34107649326324463,
-0.17391757667064667,
0.18083825707435608,
-0.577582597732544,
0.30078381299972534,
0.27016767859458923,
0.40372586250305176,
-0.897658109664917,
-0.003995245322585106,
0.03058064915239811,
-0.12493808567523956,
0.3355405628681183,
-0.39174777269363403,
-0.8195468783378601,
-0.49101030826568604,
-0.5329781770706177,
0.25260254740715027,
0.6190738081932068,
-0.4566539525985718,
0.6035943031311035,
0.5392960906028748,
-0.06700089573860168,
-0.6751863956451416,
-0.345131516456604,
0.05189300701022148,
0.03576580435037613,
-0.3191109001636505,
-0.13448955118656158,
-0.16613639891147614,
-0.3513326346874237,
-0.047808486968278885,
-0.47968819737434387,
0.08271265774965286,
0.224052295088768,
0.3150453269481659,
0.010399273596704006,
-0.20429007709026337,
0.3023303747177124,
-0.2943006157875061,
-0.2654615044593811,
0.09943892806768417,
-0.3054111897945404,
0.8416845202445984,
-0.36096543073654175,
-0.4878060817718506,
-0.27499884366989136,
-0.24748963117599487,
0.846000075340271,
-0.20881804823875427,
0.7839531898498535,
0.5329456329345703,
-0.23194999992847443,
-0.4410778284072876,
-0.8728196024894714,
-0.20187151432037354,
-0.46108657121658325,
0.2583157420158386,
-0.4580538868904114,
-0.7343764305114746,
0.8340705037117004,
-0.6824350953102112,
0.37712362408638,
0.3378942608833313,
0.785006046295166,
0.3551764190196991,
1.0867606401443481,
0.5144385695457458,
-0.37298572063446045,
0.28744634985923767,
0.031249769032001495,
-0.02766118012368679,
-0.19759029150009155,
0.17955531179904938,
-0.5789069533348083,
-0.21423299610614777,
-0.5004255771636963,
-0.3866550326347351,
0.043480996042490005,
0.24161621928215027,
-0.3116127848625183,
0.08717938512563705,
-0.17438802123069763,
0.6521353125572205,
0.30810874700546265,
-0.1355915516614914,
0.09475094825029373,
-0.2768964171409607,
-0.49332085251808167,
0.16730020940303802,
-0.20103365182876587,
-0.4204671382904053,
1.2300143241882324,
0.4115458130836487,
0.9508863091468811,
0.15843433141708374,
0.4546862542629242,
0.08776918053627014,
0.602626621723175,
-0.5424543619155884,
0.573029100894928,
0.09142669290304184,
-0.5588144659996033,
-0.24794435501098633,
-0.40257254242897034,
-0.8798279166221619,
0.33225399255752563,
-0.10311265289783478,
-0.660228967666626,
-0.12552016973495483,
0.20389963686466217,
0.08402734249830246,
0.3532542288303375,
-0.7804388403892517,
1.076357364654541,
-0.6578877568244934,
-0.8712479472160339,
-0.16452303528785706,
-0.524574875831604,
0.04344763979315758,
-0.2801084816455841,
0.30272167921066284,
-0.2513192892074585,
-0.13810995221138,
0.2883749008178711,
-0.5500337481498718,
0.6768442988395691,
-0.4129681885242462,
-0.22105850279331207,
0.0055497861467301846,
0.4082847237586975,
0.7727438807487488,
0.24970859289169312,
-0.6381306648254395,
0.19355615973472595,
0.10726341605186462,
-0.39724117517471313,
-0.5181634426116943,
1.1160434484481812,
-0.9312719106674194,
-0.48636817932128906,
-0.36099302768707275,
-0.15592971444129944,
-0.38945117592811584,
0.5921301245689392,
-0.28373122215270996,
0.29131972789764404,
-0.15147165954113007,
0.40982699394226074,
0.4027560353279114,
-0.2310885339975357,
0.2514483630657196,
0.5243961811065674,
-0.7610682845115662,
-0.32535094022750854,
0.6995806097984314,
0.1015186682343483,
0.37222346663475037,
-0.10158400982618332,
0.1632685661315918,
-0.37468841671943665,
-0.8061220049858093,
-0.45755937695503235,
0.15343044698238373,
-0.929859459400177,
-0.2751782238483429,
-0.33646371960639954,
-0.03685951977968216,
-0.08736054599285126,
0.030004169791936874,
-0.8414841294288635,
-0.11532150208950043,
0.28458401560783386,
-0.17213617265224457,
0.3192598521709442,
0.481845885515213,
0.15140458941459656,
0.042505763471126556,
-0.779622495174408,
0.1374278962612152,
0.11347785592079163,
0.9570403695106506,
0.08808022737503052,
-0.015097769908607006,
-0.11742919683456421,
-0.22682401537895203,
-0.14414170384407043,
-0.4630963206291199,
-0.04659633710980415,
0.02624575048685074,
0.8828733563423157,
0.5352209210395813,
0.15011635422706604,
0.5119506120681763,
-0.49840012192726135,
0.6726765036582947,
0.01676029898226261,
-0.7973963618278503,
0.20118752121925354,
-0.4882867634296417,
0.5234315991401672,
1.0186259746551514,
0.0773504301905632,
-0.3117642402648926,
-0.7635335922241211,
-0.3579288423061371,
-1.1222501993179321,
0.3849509358406067,
-0.12035507708787918,
0.2074836790561676,
-0.004809229634702206,
0.33102747797966003,
0.4528064429759979,
0.31979900598526,
-0.9243911504745483,
0.0003700964734889567,
-0.26131364703178406,
-0.16346058249473572,
0.04403851181268692,
0.06875336170196533,
-0.13367660343647003,
-0.12063305824995041,
0.5869422554969788,
-0.06562257558107376,
-0.27149954438209534,
-0.41761741042137146,
-0.11664334684610367,
-0.10321255028247833,
0.16545942425727844,
0.18582233786582947,
1.1386011838912964,
-0.46278446912765503,
0.3751632571220398,
0.3876410126686096,
-0.5002803802490234,
0.17718680202960968,
0.08100929856300354,
0.12548628449440002,
-0.014278808608651161,
0.1876828372478485,
0.4806831181049347,
0.5069622993469238,
-1.1714569330215454,
0.6067250967025757,
-0.4552763104438782,
0.04971339926123619,
-0.3730679452419281,
-0.05263172462582588,
0.4695799648761749,
0.07927794754505157,
0.27770334482192993,
-0.23934265971183777,
-0.3195934295654297,
-0.53416907787323,
0.24052128195762634,
0.4827139675617218,
-0.3719916045665741,
-0.28646835684776306,
0.5947999954223633,
0.36189016699790955,
-0.2589881122112274,
0.5619643926620483,
-0.11757583171129227,
-0.4032871127128601,
0.45440924167633057,
0.5565873384475708,
0.8985497355461121,
-0.32758036255836487,
-0.11411299556493759,
0.24882788956165314,
0.2972061336040497,
-0.39970675110816956,
0.2765970230102539,
0.13129177689552307,
-0.3372843265533447,
-0.25499099493026733,
-0.7884033918380737,
-0.644009530544281,
0.23490610718727112,
-0.2615027129650116,
0.5185387134552002,
-0.7435851693153381,
-0.4819073975086212,
-0.23190326988697052,
-0.11646009236574173,
-0.5118339657783508,
-0.17353399097919464,
0.07654871046543121,
1.090462327003479,
-0.5757923722267151,
0.9578834176063538,
0.6434682011604309,
-0.10061794519424438,
-0.723030686378479,
-0.012747254222631454,
0.20754149556159973,
-0.5878681540489197,
0.5896289348602295,
0.3955784738063812,
-0.270920068025589,
-0.0033710559364408255,
-0.30736809968948364,
-0.9196652770042419,
0.7593947649002075,
0.7083741426467896,
-0.8367641568183899,
0.31501826643943787,
-0.07514149695634842,
0.7194156646728516,
0.05067187175154686,
0.4206235706806183,
0.2959975302219391,
0.5645740628242493,
0.008977851830422878,
-1.2958439588546753,
-0.07052620500326157,
-0.4145342707633972,
-0.05415214225649834,
0.49649351835250854,
-0.6378284096717834,
0.7759665250778198,
0.24122357368469238,
-0.07263252139091492,
0.1739499270915985,
0.10177641361951828,
0.44373267889022827,
-0.013528282754123211,
0.7167031168937683,
0.8705065846443176,
0.35066133737564087,
-0.3133901059627533,
1.1509329080581665,
-0.44549691677093506,
0.46061307191848755,
1.103454351425171,
-0.7211726307868958,
1.239898920059204,
0.46186691522598267,
-0.18943336606025696,
0.22063472867012024,
0.5994274616241455,
-0.17369361221790314,
0.442571222782135,
0.5156082510948181,
-0.14927537739276886,
-0.29719120264053345,
0.23421774804592133,
-0.5120106339454651,
0.33384525775909424,
0.0069086262956261635,
-0.0687112957239151,
-0.6162115931510925,
0.07696597278118134,
0.06251198053359985,
-0.17715531587600708,
-0.2570418417453766,
0.7398067712783813,
0.07813708484172821,
-0.4622536599636078,
0.8531083464622498,
-0.07855702936649323,
0.4006723165512085,
-0.819090723991394,
0.02158992365002632,
0.06150092929601669,
0.6606159806251526,
0.23253628611564636,
-0.5619063973426819,
-0.25718072056770325,
-0.19481591880321503,
0.15123909711837769,
-0.055593833327293396,
0.4503486454486847,
-0.08014814555644989,
-0.529691219329834,
0.7325034737586975,
0.41628411412239075,
0.08549018949270248,
0.26516246795654297,
-0.8807773590087891,
0.8785063028335571,
-0.4287402331829071,
-0.42750856280326843,
0.5937808156013489,
0.5914039611816406,
-0.2783011198043823,
0.7172181606292725,
0.5708787441253662,
0.18081116676330566,
0.23532068729400635,
0.48693469166755676,
0.9188920855522156,
-0.38310694694519043,
-0.45700719952583313,
-0.8674784302711487,
0.3110663890838623,
-0.26356619596481323,
-0.19089949131011963,
1.0780577659606934,
0.7156919836997986,
0.9188020825386047,
-0.03933398425579071,
0.7274672985076904,
0.055131539702415466,
0.5840679407119751,
-0.3009965717792511,
0.8008725643157959,
-0.5373311638832092,
0.4085962474346161,
-0.39990636706352234,
-1.3271872997283936,
-0.3802836835384369,
0.3137739896774292,
-0.34829387068748474,
0.010275942273437977,
0.3689861595630646,
0.33951640129089355,
-0.2560519278049469,
-0.2173885852098465,
0.11304083466529846,
0.46038439869880676,
0.5456885695457458,
0.0041117616929113865,
0.7169591188430786,
-0.06761430948972702,
0.5929026007652283,
-0.17114996910095215,
-0.21273654699325562,
-0.3829196095466614,
-1.0184072256088257,
-0.8530113101005554,
-0.17993497848510742,
-0.07162117213010788,
-0.332004576921463,
0.35031628608703613,
0.9864783883094788,
0.6501302719116211,
-0.8532236218452454,
-0.392692893743515,
-0.06437002867460251,
-0.05202522128820419,
-0.23900428414344788,
-0.19643427431583405,
0.47388529777526855,
-0.4718649387359619,
-0.67275071144104,
0.23792347311973572,
0.32698866724967957,
-0.15966551005840302,
-0.4435071349143982,
0.0014065576251596212,
0.047306861728429794,
-0.2532346844673157,
0.5627744197845459,
0.40263867378234863,
-0.7943849563598633,
-0.4479457139968872,
-0.3389413058757782,
-0.04514633119106293,
0.0878419280052185,
0.46764785051345825,
-0.8422526717185974,
0.7632601857185364,
0.3169676959514618,
1.1467050313949585,
0.358365923166275,
0.1483159214258194,
0.59203040599823,
-0.44888266921043396,
0.40200644731521606,
0.29284408688545227,
0.3621762692928314,
0.2294602394104004,
0.2761000990867615,
0.42550334334373474,
-0.07335498929023743,
-0.6083311438560486,
-1.272154450416565,
-0.13582390546798706,
-0.9934667348861694,
-0.24829421937465668,
0.9194950461387634,
-0.24987833201885223,
-0.2751520276069641,
-0.20679272711277008,
-0.2391025274991989,
0.14617925882339478,
-0.458522766828537,
0.9135305285453796,
0.7480090260505676,
0.20947802066802979,
-0.21642641723155975,
-0.8219451904296875,
0.16636605560779572,
0.18993976712226868,
-0.866129457950592,
0.3520960211753845,
0.40784549713134766,
0.704563319683075,
0.18169599771499634,
0.2996942400932312,
-0.20644447207450867,
0.23490068316459656,
0.046915825456380844,
0.14819669723510742,
0.08219544589519501,
-0.02226165309548378,
-0.045802466571331024,
0.38352781534194946,
0.6030259132385254,
0.17876258492469788
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07708v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07708v2
|
Improving Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback Using Contrastive Rewards
| 2024-03-12T14:51:57 | 2024-03-14T02:02:31 |
Wei Shen, Xiaoying Zhang, Yuanshun Yao, Rui Zheng, Hongyi Guo, Yang Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF) is the mainstream paradigm
used to align large language models (LLMs) with human preferences. Yet existing
RLHF heavily relies on accurate and informative reward models, which are
vulnerable and sensitive to noise from various sources, e.g. human labeling
errors, making the pipeline fragile. In this work, we improve the effectiveness
of the reward model by introducing a penalty term on the reward, named as
\textit{contrastive rewards}. %Contrastive rewards Our approach involves two
steps: (1) an offline sampling step to obtain responses to prompts that serve
as baseline calculation and (2) a contrastive reward calculated using the
baseline responses and used in the Proximal Policy Optimization (PPO) step. We
show that contrastive rewards enable the LLM to penalize reward uncertainty,
improve robustness, encourage improvement over baselines, calibrate according
to task difficulty, and reduce variance in PPO. We show empirically contrastive
rewards can improve RLHF substantially, evaluated by both GPTs and humans, and
our method consistently outperforms strong baselines.
|
[
-0.21117091178894043,
-0.26536622643470764,
0.3310913145542145,
-0.02724427543580532,
-0.17154690623283386,
-0.04720977321267128,
-0.5019301176071167,
-0.33737912774086,
0.08591806143522263,
0.3694091737270355,
-0.7901111245155334,
-0.21766650676727295,
-0.5252914428710938,
-0.040456146001815796,
0.3827451467514038,
1.22900390625,
-0.1393030732870102,
0.030549749732017517,
-0.10020275413990021,
-0.14557568728923798,
-0.3506019711494446,
-0.524709939956665,
-0.8422208428382874,
-0.77899169921875,
0.9957600235939026,
0.5433765649795532,
0.5201447010040283,
0.5045459270477295,
0.44396188855171204,
0.2766355872154236,
-0.13499094545841217,
0.2774432599544525,
-0.7324168682098389,
0.030872151255607605,
-0.24275101721286774,
-0.3493226170539856,
-0.048665426671504974,
0.03889835998415947,
0.45234715938568115,
0.4381962716579437,
-0.5690837502479553,
-0.33674895763397217,
0.46236953139305115,
0.8381070494651794,
-0.9227724075317383,
0.3135632872581482,
-0.166299968957901,
0.21335862576961517,
0.04159754514694214,
-0.46742746233940125,
-0.3270948827266693,
-0.5968610048294067,
0.06678618490695953,
-0.7689008712768555,
-0.007546152453869581,
-0.07652318477630615,
0.8886559009552002,
0.4493880867958069,
-0.11064346134662628,
-0.18890051543712616,
-0.6633300185203552,
0.9145525693893433,
-0.6592609882354736,
0.18483427166938782,
0.3320995569229126,
0.27589717507362366,
-0.28351902961730957,
-0.47698062658309937,
-0.2639653980731964,
-0.6436041593551636,
-0.1878269463777542,
0.4062361717224121,
0.1501980423927307,
0.20721124112606049,
0.08305872231721878,
0.2392548769712448,
-0.1993911862373352,
0.43819406628608704,
-0.019933568313717842,
-0.46727728843688965,
0.47989773750305176,
0.3021760880947113,
-0.25059232115745544,
0.14974920451641083,
-0.38441553711891174,
-0.7096251845359802,
-0.6667073369026184,
0.6274164915084839,
0.5778802037239075,
0.43598729372024536,
-0.0884421244263649,
0.2383793592453003,
-0.4071609377861023,
0.5305320024490356,
0.09063686430454254,
-0.1662440150976181,
0.13633155822753906,
-0.20779426395893097,
0.24177981913089752,
-0.16564629971981049,
0.5872105360031128,
0.4679540693759918,
0.134871244430542,
-0.19656537473201752,
-0.6043885946273804,
0.06106764078140259,
0.3821652829647064,
-0.8292050957679749,
-0.41468867659568787,
0.07781102508306503,
-0.4331933557987213,
-0.5508527755737305,
0.1829146146774292,
-0.6263105273246765,
-0.6706353425979614,
-0.3229651153087616,
0.3777903616428375,
-0.2067278027534485,
-0.18914756178855896,
-0.09593560546636581,
-0.1444484293460846,
0.19311034679412842,
0.49642473459243774,
-1.1592634916305542,
0.40914836525917053,
0.6025052666664124,
0.4922424256801605,
-0.22704508900642395,
-0.32621631026268005,
-1.1157007217407227,
-0.09941455721855164,
-0.187184676527977,
0.9733601808547974,
-0.5184366106987,
-0.4178764820098877,
0.1669403612613678,
-0.2320190817117691,
0.13589976727962494,
-0.9630969762802124,
0.7674441933631897,
-0.4875153601169586,
0.3141787648200989,
-0.5118040442466736,
-0.4251401126384735,
0.03786947578191757,
0.40286678075790405,
-0.5975908041000366,
0.8159343600273132,
0.2710482180118561,
-0.8121286034584045,
0.37945204973220825,
-0.7287081480026245,
-0.31535184383392334,
0.04773806408047676,
-0.12867078185081482,
-0.5867315530776978,
-0.03609072417020798,
0.3155013620853424,
0.05870423838496208,
-0.032283965498209,
0.22445398569107056,
-0.20652532577514648,
-0.7502722144126892,
0.3177895247936249,
-0.20691674947738647,
0.26530322432518005,
0.2037895768880844,
-0.5713450908660889,
0.6575786471366882,
-0.40013980865478516,
-0.06819501519203186,
0.06312176585197449,
-0.8510730862617493,
-0.09330624341964722,
0.08916865289211273,
0.2411566823720932,
0.08629563450813293,
-0.04736737161874771,
-0.4249511957168579,
0.013138113543391228,
-0.3724440932273865,
0.2967117130756378,
1.1649781465530396,
-0.026501920074224472,
0.3444100022315979,
-0.5866953730583191,
0.6304867267608643,
0.034789640456438065,
0.12110619246959686,
0.07205531001091003,
-0.09806615859270096,
-0.5529811978340149,
-0.20012444257736206,
0.557067334651947,
0.5548150539398193,
-0.7145150899887085,
0.5229161977767944,
-0.04150768369436264,
-0.20039930939674377,
-0.49373382329940796,
0.09839890897274017,
0.6767156720161438,
0.7724905610084534,
0.39293530583381653,
-0.38429024815559387,
-0.403839111328125,
-0.7383571267127991,
-0.12811090052127838,
-0.2882341742515564,
-0.3472861051559448,
0.5317558646202087,
0.35147127509117126,
-0.06980026513338089,
0.6553842425346375,
-0.418879896402359,
-0.3923719823360443,
-0.12543919682502747,
0.526378870010376,
0.045539479702711105,
0.541239321231842,
-0.16044777631759644,
-0.704384446144104,
-0.2363763302564621,
-0.14004342257976532,
-0.3410605788230896,
-0.14210520684719086,
-0.06411980837583542,
0.13497015833854675,
0.12308260053396225,
0.41699057817459106,
-0.07288388162851334,
0.05865110829472542,
0.44465354084968567,
-0.21946832537651062,
0.6352855563163757,
-0.4454423189163208,
0.18736441433429718,
-0.45621660351753235,
0.130768820643425,
-0.08366566151380539,
-0.4195811152458191,
-0.1326916217803955,
-0.10715091228485107,
0.02875114418566227,
0.1587221622467041,
-0.48353704810142517,
0.4854687750339508,
-0.06429492682218552,
0.09496840834617615,
-0.4379662871360779,
0.03231903538107872,
-0.2940618693828583,
0.84084552526474,
0.3692491948604584,
0.8941801190376282,
-0.05402683466672897,
-0.6841286420822144,
0.38688647747039795,
-0.009554199874401093,
-0.23250016570091248,
0.8968403935432434,
-0.7177825570106506,
0.05806882306933403,
-0.16019180417060852,
0.587986946105957,
-0.822739839553833,
-0.30912497639656067,
0.5156520009040833,
-0.28224170207977295,
0.23004880547523499,
0.21256178617477417,
-0.1483202874660492,
0.011602208949625492,
-0.6559157371520996,
0.2442750185728073,
0.46361449360847473,
-0.6646749377250671,
0.20053769648075104,
0.30408257246017456,
-0.13769426941871643,
-0.7724705934524536,
-0.295482873916626,
-0.11144515126943588,
-0.319627970457077,
-0.16795192658901215,
0.6434860825538635,
-0.08871735632419586,
-0.052508722990751266,
0.07793313264846802,
-0.11612449586391449,
0.2883806824684143,
0.27069520950317383,
0.13630267977714539,
0.26162075996398926,
0.12601794302463531,
0.2357816845178604,
-0.3131101131439209,
-0.43177077174186707,
0.06637704372406006,
-0.30755704641342163,
0.4411623477935791,
-0.15660683810710907,
-0.1095428466796875,
-0.44200602173805237,
0.05370781943202019,
-0.16953450441360474,
-0.10181791335344315,
0.5545800924301147,
0.6570963859558105,
-0.08589682728052139,
-0.10552806407213211,
-0.43190544843673706,
-0.715350866317749,
-0.43971168994903564,
0.37282878160476685,
-0.2322106510400772,
-1.0775277614593506,
0.280513197183609,
-0.2522578239440918,
-0.026705455034971237,
0.11850354075431824,
0.3736899793148041,
-0.27700531482696533,
1.0466614961624146,
0.4970134198665619,
-0.16265031695365906,
0.7555609941482544,
0.05641218274831772,
-0.2555387020111084,
-0.8238280415534973,
-0.4659580588340759,
-0.4749718904495239,
-0.45970627665519714,
-0.5843057036399841,
-0.2440788298845291,
0.33075910806655884,
0.21744322776794434,
-0.40358808636665344,
-0.050105225294828415,
-0.34263721108436584,
0.5053232908248901,
0.7239105701446533,
0.6612673401832581,
0.0703795850276947,
-0.13987518846988678,
-0.15291827917099,
-0.230404332280159,
-0.7816193103790283,
-0.3047817647457123,
0.857228696346283,
0.36855533719062805,
0.8899495601654053,
0.017184380441904068,
0.9545636177062988,
0.38619673252105713,
0.5574561357498169,
-0.614933431148529,
0.12864865362644196,
-0.049758750945329666,
-0.029947254806756973,
-0.5849101543426514,
-0.7711634635925293,
-1.1149591207504272,
0.2149217277765274,
-0.31200775504112244,
-0.6407471895217896,
0.11784520745277405,
0.5645836591720581,
-0.5351322293281555,
0.03933188319206238,
-0.5645750164985657,
0.9817749857902527,
-0.21509402990341187,
-0.6516948342323303,
-0.31169500946998596,
-0.8022018074989319,
0.22401632368564606,
0.3790270686149597,
0.17185929417610168,
0.1363048106431961,
-0.17080681025981903,
0.9160093069076538,
-0.5179638862609863,
0.9879721403121948,
-0.4239106774330139,
-0.07457490265369415,
-0.16240206360816956,
-0.12502573430538177,
0.8743568062782288,
-0.026908108964562416,
0.09232676029205322,
-0.4107721447944641,
-0.357607901096344,
-0.6960245370864868,
-0.6170477867126465,
0.563452422618866,
-0.7823294401168823,
-0.3717002868652344,
-0.4071737825870514,
-0.6901941895484924,
-0.3699531853199005,
-0.18274065852165222,
0.1891941875219345,
0.21385852992534637,
-0.20495878159999847,
0.027537308633327484,
0.9311313629150391,
-0.24858346581459045,
0.2425302416086197,
0.40068772435188293,
0.13297314941883087,
-0.5373526215553284,
0.9259836673736572,
-0.3956880569458008,
0.2347768396139145,
0.6848379969596863,
0.5327068567276001,
-0.7141603827476501,
-0.3861214518547058,
-0.13142818212509155,
0.18041779100894928,
-0.7605730891227722,
-0.16006934642791748,
-0.05362292006611824,
0.12660272419452667,
-0.18145796656608582,
-0.16366691887378693,
-0.2318781167268753,
-0.04758197441697121,
-0.03341928869485855,
0.03622032701969147,
0.06937522441148758,
0.7663356065750122,
-0.3351791501045227,
0.23919439315795898,
-0.6133590340614319,
0.056869957596063614,
0.6436464786529541,
0.491066575050354,
-0.023130007088184357,
-0.6566101908683777,
-0.33504101634025574,
-0.03875389322638512,
-0.2625279426574707,
-0.6853082180023193,
0.16994576156139374,
-0.08551698923110962,
0.6979093551635742,
0.22927527129650116,
0.34889963269233704,
0.5344138145446777,
-0.17551769316196442,
0.4613454341888428,
0.42957568168640137,
-0.7647424340248108,
0.4181571304798126,
-0.22927820682525635,
0.4283617436885834,
0.6747775077819824,
0.1462600827217102,
-0.6317154765129089,
-0.1131507009267807,
-0.4919256269931793,
-0.8830932378768921,
0.8563232421875,
-0.057666972279548645,
-0.08115608245134354,
0.3016999065876007,
0.27660563588142395,
-0.10479046404361725,
0.14268815517425537,
-0.9652416706085205,
0.05162573233246803,
-0.2465846985578537,
-0.10225183516740799,
-0.30012765526771545,
-0.15916591882705688,
-0.5340893864631653,
0.07741011679172516,
0.7214294672012329,
-0.2932474911212921,
0.037938158959150314,
0.15047599375247955,
-0.10131190717220306,
-0.2706756889820099,
0.5160595178604126,
0.8578696846961975,
0.4044680595397949,
-0.45261654257774353,
0.2925057113170624,
0.1549827754497528,
-0.041551604866981506,
0.2691960632801056,
0.12729373574256897,
-0.07663808017969131,
-0.4528864026069641,
0.3641279935836792,
0.8483618497848511,
0.5141169428825378,
-0.8839359879493713,
0.47453927993774414,
-0.1331224888563156,
-0.3266075551509857,
-0.03834773227572441,
0.17349658906459808,
0.1564783751964569,
0.33192309737205505,
-0.05821437016129494,
-0.07733334600925446,
0.08472525328397751,
-0.3539736270904541,
0.1978553831577301,
0.26930221915245056,
-0.8029047846794128,
0.14571861922740936,
0.5602126717567444,
0.39676153659820557,
-0.357109397649765,
0.6583881974220276,
-0.3598535358905792,
-0.6989076733589172,
0.4571334719657898,
0.4186593294143677,
0.5647081136703491,
-0.2554270923137665,
0.4049092233181,
0.37397876381874084,
0.09989364445209503,
-0.2745535671710968,
0.059351928532123566,
-0.3422616422176361,
-0.7406405806541443,
-0.4778388440608978,
-0.3641846776008606,
-0.9005799889564514,
0.11180976778268814,
-0.6525259017944336,
-0.00949010904878378,
-0.3449339270591736,
0.09303633123636246,
-0.1774701625108719,
0.0520077608525753,
-0.3407198190689087,
0.19296742975711823,
0.11130714416503906,
0.5438866019248962,
-0.8264706134796143,
0.7081539630889893,
0.8461936116218567,
-0.6660274267196655,
-0.8500154614448547,
0.08856987953186035,
-0.06927435845136642,
-0.6802030205726624,
0.7614356279373169,
0.1763913780450821,
-0.3244488835334778,
-0.1401911824941635,
-0.2959636449813843,
-0.4456723630428314,
0.9793869853019714,
0.2639298439025879,
-0.6154569983482361,
0.3328143060207367,
-0.06171421334147453,
0.5480945706367493,
-0.2624868154525757,
0.4207044839859009,
0.5741888880729675,
0.6014388799667358,
0.11470621824264526,
-0.7046617865562439,
0.20458978414535522,
-0.1779533326625824,
0.18860651552677155,
0.23382806777954102,
-0.445575475692749,
0.5716351270675659,
-0.3318205177783966,
-0.017812950536608696,
-0.053266748785972595,
0.6021683812141418,
0.6235653758049011,
0.209298774600029,
0.90623939037323,
0.5723699331283569,
0.8661593198776245,
-0.13200730085372925,
1.2664334774017334,
0.15262474119663239,
0.2880875766277313,
1.1337803602218628,
-0.2450929880142212,
1.01906418800354,
0.6595944166183472,
-0.3510187864303589,
0.7084770798683167,
0.9186031222343445,
0.18508005142211914,
0.861595094203949,
0.6887099742889404,
-0.25253650546073914,
-0.3610128164291382,
-0.3882807791233063,
-0.18344978988170624,
-0.07887183874845505,
-0.08927138149738312,
0.1255650669336319,
-0.25863179564476013,
-0.09483106434345245,
0.058903370052576065,
0.5210727453231812,
-0.3737075924873352,
0.9151025414466858,
-0.15299247205257416,
-1.0404763221740723,
0.6725422143936157,
0.07808652520179749,
0.9655154347419739,
-0.6363298296928406,
-0.24070407450199127,
-0.3532238304615021,
0.5100489854812622,
-0.2568212151527405,
-0.6551498770713806,
0.07562854140996933,
-0.22145283222198486,
-0.06675611436367035,
-0.24706201255321503,
0.4153461754322052,
-0.5081810355186462,
0.13266626000404358,
0.3084329664707184,
-0.014712333679199219,
-0.08289653807878494,
-0.2046944797039032,
-0.7398592233657837,
-0.028245093300938606,
-0.06633574515581131,
-0.1357654333114624,
0.5793260335922241,
-0.08804220706224442,
-0.031474269926548004,
0.5427181124687195,
0.6705443859100342,
0.16020242869853973,
-0.45867815613746643,
0.11411098390817642,
0.8744708299636841,
-0.6609193086624146,
-0.8328585624694824,
-0.6027892827987671,
0.6112040281295776,
-0.17980824410915375,
-0.3797019124031067,
0.18449974060058594,
0.2896389663219452,
1.0045945644378662,
-0.028225090354681015,
0.5451554656028748,
0.2698100805282593,
0.6142145395278931,
-0.7526022791862488,
0.26026591658592224,
-0.5006169080734253,
0.5550735592842102,
0.08954063057899475,
-0.7349857687950134,
-0.26969531178474426,
0.6738049983978271,
-0.25368383526802063,
0.12209594994783401,
0.6976011991500854,
1.0215460062026978,
0.17703919112682343,
-0.21295583248138428,
0.19081954658031464,
-0.15783333778381348,
0.2314193695783615,
0.7943613529205322,
1.0791524648666382,
0.02079598791897297,
0.818255603313446,
-0.5142149925231934,
-0.35595473647117615,
-0.38717424869537354,
-0.9380959272384644,
-0.5401666760444641,
-0.24769417941570282,
-0.2395864576101303,
-0.5703274011611938,
0.43937283754348755,
1.1434558629989624,
0.9105750322341919,
-1.1473557949066162,
-0.4939555525779724,
-0.3287856876850128,
0.2837987244129181,
-0.667326807975769,
-0.2332124412059784,
0.36146607995033264,
-0.8120922446250916,
-0.594801664352417,
0.39086970686912537,
0.0927322655916214,
-0.12737596035003662,
-0.11187173426151276,
-0.9385748505592346,
0.0780678540468216,
-0.060510240495204926,
0.2330140620470047,
0.4734054505825043,
-0.6913073658943176,
-0.4015843868255615,
-0.25126543641090393,
-0.30691683292388916,
0.09794962406158447,
1.1100481748580933,
-0.8658280968666077,
0.25582459568977356,
0.4821483790874481,
0.8600336909294128,
0.5156933069229126,
0.16448496282100677,
0.6101533770561218,
-0.703559160232544,
0.05476623401045799,
0.38460782170295715,
0.27404582500457764,
0.4750065803527832,
-0.2912571430206299,
0.5743527412414551,
0.26989710330963135,
-0.6739301681518555,
-0.7087475061416626,
0.42572474479675293,
-0.7929770350456238,
-0.45154330134391785,
0.9351673722267151,
-0.38370051980018616,
-0.00992099940776825,
-0.05895302817225456,
-0.3461044728755951,
0.15208357572555542,
-0.6152982711791992,
1.1915494203567505,
0.5642322301864624,
-0.2683189809322357,
-0.46843767166137695,
-0.03466108441352844,
0.8629277348518372,
0.9115065336227417,
-1.0351877212524414,
0.023512093350291252,
0.4740854799747467,
0.07795299589633942,
-0.14147883653640747,
0.6857384443283081,
-0.057173117995262146,
0.6085373759269714,
-0.0604526549577713,
0.12045226991176605,
-0.16409175097942352,
-0.13711267709732056,
-0.8833360075950623,
0.13085855543613434,
0.4861278235912323,
-0.24232375621795654
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07693v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07693v2
|
Large, Small or Both: A Novel Data Augmentation Framework Based on Language Models for Debiasing Opinion Summarization
| 2024-03-12T14:37:03 | 2024-03-19T19:20:05 |
Yanyue Zhang, Pengfei Li, Yilong Lai, Deyu Zhou, Yulan He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
As more than 70$\%$ of reviews in the existing opinion summary data set are
positive, current opinion summarization approaches are reluctant to generate
negative summaries given the input of negative texts. To address such sentiment
bias, a direct approach without the over-reliance on a specific framework is to
generate additional data based on large language models to balance the
emotional distribution of the dataset. However, data augmentation based on
large language models faces two disadvantages: 1) the potential issues or
toxicity in the augmented data; 2) the expensive costs. Therefore, in this
paper, we propose a novel data augmentation framework based on both large and
small language models for debiasing opinion summarization. In specific, a small
size of synthesized negative reviews is obtained by rewriting the positive text
via a large language model. Then, a disentangle reconstruction model is trained
based on the generated data. After training, a large amount of synthetic data
can be obtained by decoding the new representation obtained from the
combination of different sample representations and filtering based on
confusion degree and sentiment classification. Experiments have proved that our
framework can effectively alleviate emotional bias same as using only large
models, but more economically.
|
[
-0.6059133410453796,
-0.7851227521896362,
0.4943864047527313,
0.13177438080310822,
-0.39464566111564636,
0.06291253864765167,
-0.09501132369041443,
-0.4637247920036316,
0.6282342672348022,
0.4932654798030853,
-0.473534494638443,
-0.28827711939811707,
-0.5321518778800964,
0.004069003276526928,
-0.17679840326309204,
0.9704138040542603,
0.2532809376716614,
0.3515993654727936,
-0.10369046777486801,
-0.2600836753845215,
-0.25192177295684814,
-0.6227898001670837,
-0.33220094442367554,
-0.4277869462966919,
0.2953868806362152,
0.34158045053482056,
0.9614908695220947,
0.17957034707069397,
0.36513546109199524,
0.27998071908950806,
-0.13290734589099884,
0.21699588000774384,
-0.5400828719139099,
-0.2244441956281662,
-0.23684169352054596,
-0.4447726607322693,
-0.7780197262763977,
-0.060167741030454636,
0.5154065489768982,
0.8523989915847778,
0.1571972817182541,
0.08488737046718597,
0.002042017411440611,
1.1886342763900757,
-0.6612226963043213,
0.02466471679508686,
-0.417779803276062,
0.19128690659999847,
0.25318801403045654,
0.19645288586616516,
-0.08212461322546005,
-0.5180850028991699,
0.13894613087177277,
-0.25053271651268005,
-0.04275638610124588,
-0.1654064655303955,
0.33612877130508423,
0.19067896902561188,
-0.6479721665382385,
-0.2879282236099243,
-0.7735766768455505,
0.9377275705337524,
-1.1044318675994873,
0.29431381821632385,
0.07949205487966537,
0.17327745258808136,
0.17672933638095856,
-0.14240053296089172,
-0.862793505191803,
-0.02277623489499092,
-0.13754336535930634,
0.12241985648870468,
-0.36184990406036377,
-0.023777110502123833,
0.0845957100391388,
0.6856807470321655,
-0.3585125207901001,
0.10441485047340393,
-0.19093014299869537,
0.14446650445461273,
0.868227481842041,
0.23529307544231415,
0.22653482854366302,
-0.2882314920425415,
-0.2528505027294159,
-0.06717918813228607,
-0.7468335032463074,
-0.17325782775878906,
0.6996938586235046,
0.23068448901176453,
-0.24292926490306854,
0.8516985774040222,
-0.4398704469203949,
0.5427848696708679,
0.3156089782714844,
-0.08302988857030869,
0.7202418446540833,
-0.24635227024555206,
-0.40473872423171997,
0.3365072011947632,
0.7837363481521606,
0.9635875821113586,
0.03040674701333046,
0.17742730677127838,
-0.2767879068851471,
0.38890522718429565,
0.009614843875169754,
-1.0603148937225342,
-0.058457594364881516,
0.495123028755188,
-0.6309462785720825,
-0.7133342623710632,
-0.003152565797790885,
-1.0852162837982178,
-0.9123202562332153,
-0.4945480525493622,
0.3354435861110687,
-0.10012257099151611,
-0.6839480996131897,
0.43328461050987244,
-0.07279361039400101,
-0.14344893395900726,
0.24031877517700195,
-0.755027174949646,
0.004575876519083977,
0.6336304545402527,
0.7351132035255432,
0.01970161870121956,
0.0009089519153349102,
-0.13675031065940857,
-0.21102459728717804,
-0.4653770327568054,
0.6290591955184937,
-0.5046886801719666,
-0.4257146418094635,
-0.17044450342655182,
-0.10432000458240509,
0.530504584312439,
-0.3889694809913635,
0.21372617781162262,
-0.48639705777168274,
0.38781455159187317,
-0.11573798954486847,
-0.3777393400669098,
-0.4003041386604309,
0.48312097787857056,
-0.9905357360839844,
0.5977263450622559,
0.3348740339279175,
-1.015383005142212,
0.2383241057395935,
-0.403437077999115,
-0.6120753884315491,
-0.43316489458084106,
0.13326917588710785,
-0.44015541672706604,
0.2653590738773346,
0.5278274416923523,
0.366504967212677,
-0.5028521418571472,
0.2901614010334015,
-0.7628931403160095,
-0.2878268361091614,
0.4832192659378052,
-0.45927223563194275,
0.7526024580001831,
0.19823715090751648,
-0.24843505024909973,
-0.10133986920118332,
-0.7501605749130249,
-0.2537788152694702,
-0.18319877982139587,
-0.16151054203510284,
-0.5802755355834961,
-0.09908842295408249,
-0.055578283965587616,
0.4185436964035034,
0.35753604769706726,
-0.5637125372886658,
0.11848316341638565,
-0.8077454566955566,
0.2830001413822174,
0.6300196051597595,
0.43465471267700195,
0.9614442586898804,
-0.2121656835079193,
0.48728278279304504,
0.3534325361251831,
-0.08084489405155182,
-0.0659991055727005,
0.0020054643973708153,
-0.5142188668251038,
-0.22396793961524963,
0.3174428641796112,
0.39244410395622253,
-0.9404756426811218,
0.645824134349823,
-0.34747806191444397,
-0.517961859703064,
-0.7056474089622498,
0.17023514211177826,
0.1666789948940277,
0.47189247608184814,
0.27798983454704285,
-0.04002860188484192,
-0.8382098078727722,
-1.0777130126953125,
-0.10727996379137039,
-0.11694248765707016,
-0.10161329060792923,
-0.014214507304131985,
0.3437855839729309,
-0.39047300815582275,
0.8448913097381592,
-0.6906804442405701,
-0.4279862642288208,
-0.43986594676971436,
0.06058637425303459,
0.4152000844478607,
0.2518613040447235,
0.60151606798172,
-0.866309642791748,
-0.33707305788993835,
-0.10485722124576569,
-0.7570204138755798,
0.005953571759164333,
-0.16404326260089874,
0.06768297404050827,
0.23492707312107086,
0.08899340778589249,
-0.4220615029335022,
0.15939711034297943,
0.5591786503791809,
-0.1656232327222824,
0.32300642132759094,
-0.08038429915904999,
0.3601759970188141,
-1.1834232807159424,
-0.10041846334934235,
0.2540466785430908,
-0.1365576535463333,
-0.4488118290901184,
-0.1886722892522812,
-0.028889747336506844,
-0.007015005219727755,
-0.27457478642463684,
0.5093590617179871,
-0.42168813943862915,
0.2793293595314026,
-0.6475160717964172,
0.16911770403385162,
0.27505823969841003,
0.5364282131195068,
0.1346343457698822,
0.2657051086425781,
0.41726675629615784,
-0.40207067131996155,
0.6279287934303284,
0.2506938576698303,
-0.5076087713241577,
0.7853955626487732,
-0.6506210565567017,
-0.30695194005966187,
-0.4893864691257477,
0.4442325532436371,
-0.8773268461227417,
-0.2484298050403595,
-0.032148875296115875,
-0.3737339675426483,
0.07364007830619812,
-0.11825168877840042,
-0.1902971863746643,
-0.4864903390407562,
-0.8513660430908203,
0.12130466848611832,
0.6952006220817566,
-0.6597220301628113,
0.5490795373916626,
0.9524534940719604,
-0.4227426052093506,
-0.7183661460876465,
-1.119016170501709,
0.0915163978934288,
-0.370048850774765,
-0.44350501894950867,
0.2051130086183548,
-0.0028902494814246893,
-0.49078255891799927,
0.19911211729049683,
-0.028557240962982178,
0.1336890310049057,
-0.36675456166267395,
0.15322306752204895,
0.43432021141052246,
-0.05725718289613724,
0.21514764428138733,
0.26898810267448425,
-0.13347013294696808,
0.16619566082954407,
-0.02682105265557766,
0.27805158495903015,
0.015813637524843216,
-0.11578546464443207,
-0.09929637610912323,
0.5227293372154236,
0.7749941349029541,
-0.12229843437671661,
0.5749883055686951,
0.4494078457355499,
-0.5188400149345398,
-0.33346810936927795,
-0.5617132186889648,
-0.2325461059808731,
-0.40546494722366333,
0.794816255569458,
-0.15330611169338226,
-0.6062290668487549,
0.242140993475914,
0.18487395346164703,
-0.022289108484983444,
0.3746456205844879,
0.8767611980438232,
0.09861040115356445,
1.5409173965454102,
0.366863876581192,
-0.6700805425643921,
0.4653729200363159,
-0.24837347865104675,
0.582744836807251,
-0.7355657815933228,
0.24910901486873627,
-0.1566040962934494,
-0.5222356915473938,
-0.3716641962528229,
-0.22674649953842163,
0.40313050150871277,
0.03175363689661026,
-0.005678746849298477,
-0.19754871726036072,
-0.5945777893066406,
0.4364677965641022,
0.28884488344192505,
0.2732582092285156,
0.3678993284702301,
0.1904500275850296,
0.3951411545276642,
-0.015433825552463531,
-0.39180564880371094,
-0.4697752296924591,
1.1587578058242798,
0.4430747330188751,
0.9641750454902649,
0.1483437865972519,
0.4299516975879669,
0.4861624240875244,
0.2789607346057892,
-0.7973028421401978,
0.3837200403213501,
-0.2068859189748764,
-0.5246322751045227,
-0.19234699010849,
-0.6149201393127441,
-0.34502553939819336,
0.3730183243751526,
-0.5317104458808899,
-0.47083988785743713,
0.5117675065994263,
0.20509745180606842,
-0.24774524569511414,
0.36115145683288574,
-0.8886542320251465,
0.5035790205001831,
-0.17098164558410645,
-0.42305663228034973,
-0.40211617946624756,
-0.5020418763160706,
0.7343801856040955,
-0.20016904175281525,
0.372388631105423,
0.07942274212837219,
0.11831706017255783,
0.5935497879981995,
-0.5502031445503235,
0.7943398952484131,
-0.5629734992980957,
-0.22483694553375244,
0.448770672082901,
0.002051670104265213,
0.7056514024734497,
0.32242611050605774,
-0.33406418561935425,
0.009359468705952168,
-0.1944560557603836,
-0.030412381514906883,
-0.7357243299484253,
0.9428189396858215,
-0.5352060198783875,
-0.40669548511505127,
-0.3333163261413574,
-0.537172257900238,
-0.4702051877975464,
0.05706224590539932,
0.08962145447731018,
0.395061731338501,
-0.18212391436100006,
0.2138989120721817,
0.4433106482028961,
-0.24547089636325836,
0.26397761702537537,
0.441190242767334,
-0.3014736771583557,
-0.7181034684181213,
0.9735655784606934,
0.09008846431970596,
0.08853849023580551,
0.4341050088405609,
0.13181765377521515,
-0.563532829284668,
-0.4280242323875427,
-0.5522010326385498,
0.1799686998128891,
-0.4978829026222229,
-0.30273497104644775,
-0.7810419797897339,
0.04453520476818085,
-0.36955925822257996,
-0.17279748618602753,
-0.4103746712207794,
-0.7237104177474976,
0.04657368361949921,
-0.49086037278175354,
0.40675100684165955,
0.5466212034225464,
-0.22731386125087738,
0.32278817892074585,
-0.7399182915687561,
0.6050875782966614,
0.20438605546951294,
0.3469870686531067,
0.27026548981666565,
-0.28788071870803833,
-0.36365050077438354,
0.51207435131073,
-0.14882424473762512,
-0.9104606509208679,
0.6305927634239197,
-0.2633412480354309,
0.021710937842726707,
0.42115554213523865,
0.277812123298645,
0.6340868473052979,
-0.17994725704193115,
0.8240728974342346,
0.4903056025505066,
-0.8871618509292603,
0.1654890477657318,
-0.21302711963653564,
0.2994881272315979,
0.5816489458084106,
0.11202426999807358,
-0.41028928756713867,
-0.364473819732666,
-0.5451595783233643,
-1.0022395849227905,
0.729113757610321,
-0.12193689495325089,
0.29816630482673645,
0.16081376373767853,
0.04192290082573891,
0.19341009855270386,
0.5397127270698547,
-0.6781019568443298,
-0.09411845356225967,
-0.20696869492530823,
-0.513813853263855,
-0.30471494793891907,
-0.4355136454105377,
0.02224412001669407,
-0.14498965442180634,
1.0506764650344849,
-0.033064376562833786,
0.11173580586910248,
-0.02204359695315361,
-0.2037789523601532,
-0.07122684270143509,
0.4678853750228882,
0.21250848472118378,
0.32652896642684937,
-0.3175201416015625,
0.17952638864517212,
0.1966952383518219,
-0.3241465985774994,
0.29070785641670227,
0.12707266211509705,
-0.3276156783103943,
-0.04441385343670845,
0.10452411323785782,
0.7386455535888672,
-0.003806611755862832,
-0.6183037161827087,
0.6266066431999207,
0.14212659001350403,
-0.10889716446399689,
-0.18857912719249725,
-0.317453533411026,
0.21600361168384552,
0.2512957751750946,
0.27755090594291687,
0.13333918154239655,
0.37804943323135376,
-0.45214852690696716,
0.046049077063798904,
0.4869939982891083,
-0.37029457092285156,
-0.3341810405254364,
0.3798174560070038,
0.30680030584335327,
0.33575108647346497,
0.09698745608329773,
-0.3202022612094879,
-0.4250749945640564,
0.5181187987327576,
0.42298680543899536,
0.7818552851676941,
-0.17386849224567413,
0.32617437839508057,
0.6197398900985718,
0.1833273321390152,
-0.2569599151611328,
0.22216324508190155,
0.22652482986450195,
-0.5995134115219116,
-0.5315651297569275,
-0.5768560171127319,
-0.3105706572532654,
0.20447294414043427,
-0.5311487913131714,
0.29650333523750305,
-0.21851123869419098,
-0.06996524333953857,
-0.019907234236598015,
-0.03146570175886154,
-0.22423702478408813,
0.5466888546943665,
0.09542468190193176,
0.4903973937034607,
-0.8894806504249573,
0.553546667098999,
0.7260381579399109,
-0.4253513813018799,
-0.5268253087997437,
-0.31207045912742615,
0.11321260035037994,
-0.3022838234901428,
0.05043135583400726,
0.15895268321037292,
-0.284609854221344,
-0.34931889176368713,
-0.09870703518390656,
-0.4780173897743225,
0.7000844478607178,
0.27367815375328064,
-0.801996111869812,
-0.1336371898651123,
0.07988783717155457,
0.6322312355041504,
-0.558096170425415,
0.18883876502513885,
0.6696321368217468,
0.4506014287471771,
0.008068331517279148,
-0.22659823298454285,
0.09747102111577988,
-0.43504223227500916,
-0.18531176447868347,
0.2849743366241455,
-0.47308349609375,
0.8509789705276489,
-0.19925783574581146,
-0.016971779987215996,
-0.2275051474571228,
0.36756834387779236,
0.02125428058207035,
0.3980543315410614,
0.6602386832237244,
0.465793639421463,
0.5625535249710083,
0.1202017292380333,
0.8702555298805237,
-0.2837028503417969,
0.471816748380661,
1.288783073425293,
-0.5110982060432434,
0.5925663709640503,
0.5860859155654907,
-0.26637598872184753,
0.36766067147254944,
0.4598062038421631,
-0.07030727714300156,
0.5698596239089966,
-0.02410370670258999,
-0.300566703081131,
0.015791544690728188,
0.08070367574691772,
-0.46428126096725464,
0.21405059099197388,
0.4023224711418152,
-0.530428946018219,
-0.27968829870224,
0.3436639904975891,
-0.07005642354488373,
0.1405872255563736,
-0.5536701679229736,
0.9248062372207642,
0.11125561594963074,
-0.579458475112915,
0.3736886978149414,
0.11718276888132095,
0.7863356471061707,
-0.4020409882068634,
0.02979332022368908,
-0.3116914927959442,
0.4453682601451874,
-0.5281120538711548,
-0.6662269234657288,
0.3416177034378052,
0.2592509090900421,
-0.461902916431427,
0.050031885504722595,
0.6854687929153442,
-0.5627650022506714,
-0.8451593518257141,
0.0414913184940815,
0.4245297908782959,
-0.25072231888771057,
-0.20139604806900024,
-0.46824535727500916,
-0.0657423883676529,
0.30377134680747986,
-0.5086169838905334,
0.13063518702983856,
0.2817891836166382,
-0.03912591561675072,
0.26227128505706787,
0.5401555299758911,
0.3979179859161377,
-0.502169132232666,
0.15830937027931213,
0.9294425249099731,
-0.6045985221862793,
-0.9330638647079468,
-1.063500165939331,
0.7039788961410522,
-0.4250151216983795,
0.15920327603816986,
0.6871445178985596,
0.5168386101722717,
0.41935187578201294,
-0.3110853135585785,
1.0851001739501953,
-0.14444231986999512,
0.7346785068511963,
-0.4394010007381439,
0.7719334363937378,
-0.5607447624206543,
0.3377094566822052,
-0.49609431624412537,
-1.1414481401443481,
-0.2879401743412018,
0.5871065855026245,
-0.664825975894928,
0.07498456537723541,
0.5114020705223083,
1.106351613998413,
-0.057865552604198456,
0.18163642287254333,
0.09013287723064423,
0.40672895312309265,
0.17220814526081085,
0.7010418772697449,
0.7797563076019287,
-0.3523518741130829,
0.16909314692020416,
-0.3198488652706146,
-0.541930615901947,
-0.3373526930809021,
-0.7920292615890503,
-0.8127501010894775,
-0.3966706395149231,
-0.2861553728580475,
-0.4837629497051239,
-0.31580987572669983,
1.0583332777023315,
0.4692254662513733,
-0.7247452139854431,
0.19144313037395477,
-0.08839491009712219,
0.3356917202472687,
-0.11118675023317337,
-0.26834145188331604,
0.37034809589385986,
0.06798099726438522,
-0.9466608762741089,
0.23565678298473358,
0.17111988365650177,
0.06486514210700989,
-0.5448686480522156,
-0.07904186099767685,
0.08975987136363983,
0.30260056257247925,
0.721032440662384,
0.02340817265212536,
-0.24826686084270477,
-0.09135130047798157,
-0.35980015993118286,
-0.16104798018932343,
-0.00446249358355999,
0.7489916086196899,
-0.7532821297645569,
0.6750574111938477,
0.6086550951004028,
0.5534882545471191,
0.37905648350715637,
0.16040551662445068,
0.6586764454841614,
-0.7206157445907593,
0.4025171399116516,
0.12415457516908646,
0.4972638785839081,
0.5544062256813049,
-0.5919474363327026,
0.37169164419174194,
-0.2033844143152237,
-0.24507106840610504,
-1.0153942108154297,
0.2905164062976837,
-1.0021389722824097,
-0.30114874243736267,
1.0643917322158813,
0.2312333583831787,
-0.19629374146461487,
0.2709536552429199,
-0.48742491006851196,
0.005654862150549889,
-0.32170286774635315,
1.009434461593628,
0.5615035891532898,
0.08346063643693924,
0.09747032821178436,
-0.07264582067728043,
0.26916223764419556,
0.3040827214717865,
-0.8197264075279236,
0.33496221899986267,
0.9799479246139526,
0.10050976276397705,
0.16701677441596985,
0.470739483833313,
-0.37776973843574524,
0.23525553941726685,
0.13125775754451752,
0.11395636945962906,
-0.3866218626499176,
-0.07851070910692215,
-0.6172646284103394,
0.3178156316280365,
-0.15915966033935547,
-0.0747157633304596
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07691v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07691v2
|
ORPO: Monolithic Preference Optimization without Reference Model
| 2024-03-12T14:34:08 | 2024-03-14T07:47:08 |
Jiwoo Hong, Noah Lee, James Thorne
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
While recent preference alignment algorithms for language models have
demonstrated promising results, supervised fine-tuning (SFT) remains imperative
for achieving successful convergence. In this paper, we study the crucial role
of SFT within the context of preference alignment, emphasizing that a minor
penalty for the disfavored generation style is sufficient for
preference-aligned SFT. Building on this foundation, we introduce a
straightforward and innovative reference model-free monolithic odds ratio
preference optimization algorithm, ORPO, eliminating the necessity for an
additional preference alignment phase. We demonstrate, both empirically and
theoretically, that the odds ratio is a sensible choice for contrasting favored
and disfavored styles during SFT across the diverse sizes from 125M to 7B.
Specifically, fine-tuning Phi-2 (2.7B), Llama-2 (7B), and Mistral (7B) with
ORPO on the UltraFeedback alone surpasses the performance of state-of-the-art
language models with more than 7B and 13B parameters: achieving up to 12.20% on
$\text{AlpacaEval}_{2.0}$ (Figure 1), 66.19% on IFEval (instruction-level
loose, Table 6), and 7.32 in MT-Bench (Figure 12). We release code and model
checkpoints for Mistral-ORPO-$\alpha$ (7B) and Mistral-ORPO-$\beta$ (7B).
|
[
-0.4682753086090088,
-0.5250131487846375,
0.19358396530151367,
0.08027621358633041,
-0.44102782011032104,
-0.3550483286380768,
-0.27557361125946045,
-0.3692673146724701,
0.005530831404030323,
0.7056586742401123,
-0.7990055680274963,
-0.32146692276000977,
-0.5217446088790894,
-0.15667781233787537,
-0.059058159589767456,
1.2324862480163574,
-0.02332584373652935,
-0.023099206387996674,
0.00040548929246142507,
-0.08140239119529724,
-0.20376724004745483,
-0.2727445662021637,
-0.8277831673622131,
-0.3419581353664398,
0.029504751786589622,
0.8324874043464661,
0.8988171815872192,
0.999859094619751,
0.4677816927433014,
0.2834463119506836,
-0.04363076761364937,
0.2665390968322754,
-0.5430319905281067,
-0.10901465266942978,
-0.09957263618707657,
-0.13218864798545837,
-0.6700391173362732,
0.12089543044567108,
0.3639783263206482,
0.8698481321334839,
-0.29971203207969666,
0.11894328147172928,
0.14868895709514618,
0.946851909160614,
-0.6949089169502258,
-0.07192064076662064,
-0.84971022605896,
0.11045297235250473,
-0.3906741738319397,
-0.37085193395614624,
-0.5704062581062317,
-0.48707619309425354,
0.2913011312484741,
-0.75736403465271,
0.1433112770318985,
0.1912524551153183,
0.791217029094696,
0.6187458038330078,
-0.35502347350120544,
-0.2330499291419983,
-0.462314248085022,
1.065882921218872,
-0.632739245891571,
0.31013911962509155,
0.19734229147434235,
-0.07682359218597412,
-0.6048538088798523,
-0.017941216006875038,
-0.37528741359710693,
-0.022373590618371964,
-0.0034444923512637615,
-0.019026681780815125,
-0.1559804081916809,
0.3275831341743469,
0.059144120663404465,
0.43320736289024353,
-0.3200847804546356,
0.11791381984949112,
-0.1927267462015152,
-0.16724838316440582,
0.4255242347717285,
-0.1785275787115097,
-0.06990745663642883,
-0.13663992285728455,
-0.558546245098114,
0.05402524769306183,
-0.4506806433200836,
0.3497510552406311,
0.524361789226532,
0.618502676486969,
-0.06897836178541183,
0.6198100447654724,
-0.4772129952907562,
0.9129605293273926,
0.46220263838768005,
-0.43162792921066284,
-0.0027302252128720284,
-0.4211677312850952,
-0.2301059067249298,
0.28033098578453064,
0.9172586798667908,
0.2796670198440552,
0.4585282802581787,
0.12464246153831482,
0.10779370367527008,
0.02800443395972252,
0.2374335527420044,
-0.630448579788208,
0.021719077602028847,
0.17398181557655334,
-0.46125543117523193,
-0.5652538537979126,
-0.0328015461564064,
-0.7904707193374634,
-0.22667910158634186,
-0.3736509084701538,
0.1560608297586441,
-0.7072821259498596,
0.022366251796483994,
0.4724527597427368,
-0.07343597710132599,
0.06312774121761322,
0.1655675321817398,
-1.2789158821105957,
0.2650509476661682,
0.6513777375221252,
0.4100351333618164,
-0.32033228874206543,
-0.2796764075756073,
-0.5155745148658752,
-0.231511652469635,
-0.3881811201572418,
0.6323878169059753,
-0.4631107747554779,
-0.36403217911720276,
-0.10691875964403152,
-0.36127546429634094,
0.15151645243167877,
-0.14703825116157532,
0.9578415751457214,
-0.281644344329834,
0.07279171049594879,
-0.07167249172925949,
-0.37329360842704773,
0.07746180146932602,
-0.12182489037513733,
-0.44457584619522095,
1.016459584236145,
-0.1240314468741417,
-0.7768577337265015,
0.7853764295578003,
-0.48161178827285767,
-0.49751603603363037,
-0.3487943708896637,
-0.0014862807001918554,
-0.4982241094112396,
0.24560116231441498,
0.07227308303117752,
0.12580040097236633,
-0.23058873414993286,
0.16353268921375275,
-0.8633660674095154,
-0.30257898569107056,
-0.192440465092659,
-0.37823358178138733,
0.9355410933494568,
0.19747549295425415,
-0.6029747724533081,
-0.009101144969463348,
-1.1251413822174072,
0.08408074826002121,
0.0023464076220989227,
-0.14640672504901886,
-0.7720043063163757,
0.19975051283836365,
-0.33037427067756653,
0.1344313770532608,
0.4180280268192291,
-0.7546566128730774,
0.45977917313575745,
-0.13008838891983032,
0.3928469121456146,
0.8101663589477539,
-0.47940394282341003,
0.5150457620620728,
0.025261016562581062,
0.2213226705789566,
-0.3878422975540161,
0.5750362277030945,
0.2818078398704529,
-0.39986690878868103,
-0.9127679467201233,
-0.43506717681884766,
0.224605530500412,
0.20556840300559998,
-0.5202837586402893,
0.5687975883483887,
-0.2915644347667694,
-0.43854057788848877,
-0.8546414375305176,
0.14835228025913239,
0.5366431474685669,
0.87921142578125,
0.32871052622795105,
-0.3289910852909088,
-0.5250926613807678,
-1.156473159790039,
0.041734978556632996,
-0.24033114314079285,
0.32826685905456543,
0.3019058406352997,
-0.1547478437423706,
0.2210749089717865,
1.1411997079849243,
-0.49892130494117737,
-0.2180180698633194,
0.1365002989768982,
0.09108137339353561,
0.1710674911737442,
0.6094385981559753,
0.5440365076065063,
-0.7252915501594543,
-0.48152250051498413,
0.2539619207382202,
-0.4490744471549988,
-0.3954804837703705,
0.2936606705188751,
-0.31279048323631287,
0.4128115177154541,
0.40747085213661194,
-0.26591232419013977,
0.18095828592777252,
0.8112505674362183,
-0.23662996292114258,
0.46832749247550964,
-0.1512325555086136,
0.2620861828327179,
-0.8186401128768921,
0.04454433172941208,
-0.13143527507781982,
-0.18126100301742554,
-0.5115751028060913,
0.09835758060216904,
0.15405789017677307,
-0.12849631905555725,
-0.35326626896858215,
0.5155767202377319,
-0.23144158720970154,
0.17228829860687256,
-0.3730478286743164,
-0.09316665679216385,
-0.08414102345705032,
0.49228060245513916,
0.43788790702819824,
0.8209973573684692,
0.4222722053527832,
-0.5380607843399048,
-0.25895315408706665,
0.12544411420822144,
-0.18822741508483887,
0.5980026721954346,
-0.5135956406593323,
0.18774448335170746,
0.14743198454380035,
0.0416862815618515,
-1.0174859762191772,
0.030583428218960762,
-0.0089272391051054,
-0.23118767142295837,
0.2850668430328369,
-0.4383296072483063,
-0.1967763453722,
-0.16097420454025269,
-0.5999336838722229,
0.6116787791252136,
0.3030746281147003,
-0.4972875416278839,
0.2061261683702469,
0.42685168981552124,
-0.23907603323459625,
-0.9223448038101196,
-0.2873033583164215,
-0.4991002380847931,
-0.11095821857452393,
-0.5576896667480469,
0.4020698070526123,
-0.11675762385129929,
0.09835352748632431,
-0.2156532257795334,
-0.2817893624305725,
0.2224842756986618,
-0.11083950102329254,
0.15526260435581207,
0.5297006368637085,
-0.20658713579177856,
-0.1371881663799286,
0.48837053775787354,
-0.513827383518219,
-0.5757114887237549,
-0.6427266597747803,
0.5653791427612305,
0.00958994496613741,
-0.19390146434307098,
-0.08403921127319336,
0.22893793880939484,
0.7651102542877197,
-0.1986456662416458,
0.43291720747947693,
0.15864261984825134,
-0.09069851785898209,
-0.04708860442042351,
-0.6886721849441528,
0.20217329263687134,
-0.459719181060791,
0.11477252095937729,
-0.44880059361457825,
-1.0675256252288818,
0.22933350503444672,
0.18161870539188385,
0.30747145414352417,
0.4249870479106903,
0.3927499055862427,
0.20008641481399536,
0.899665117263794,
1.0868325233459473,
-0.33635053038597107,
0.7389901280403137,
0.28775250911712646,
-0.009372297674417496,
-0.6103994250297546,
0.10452611744403839,
-0.6790360808372498,
-0.21574683487415314,
-1.0231404304504395,
-0.0721314400434494,
0.343146950006485,
0.2751126289367676,
-0.2442031353712082,
0.6484231948852539,
-0.6696563959121704,
0.41661545634269714,
0.8297023177146912,
-0.031656548380851746,
0.5926128625869751,
-0.02958425134420395,
-0.18497128784656525,
-0.047689735889434814,
-0.7097686529159546,
-0.427530974149704,
1.3509169816970825,
0.09627407044172287,
0.9620324373245239,
-0.2476789355278015,
0.6948777437210083,
0.0061064003966748714,
0.06607300043106079,
-0.7450107336044312,
0.2901214361190796,
-0.6614309549331665,
-0.7480133175849915,
-0.535819947719574,
-0.4297575354576111,
-0.6113104820251465,
0.16547182202339172,
-0.19218188524246216,
-0.7665139436721802,
0.6838964819908142,
0.5145673751831055,
-0.7028436064720154,
0.11652950942516327,
-0.81076580286026,
0.9387690424919128,
-0.02873377501964569,
-0.17342296242713928,
-0.044558748602867126,
-0.5956999063491821,
0.48093903064727783,
-0.1532806009054184,
0.08672361075878143,
-0.16165150701999664,
-0.11479556560516357,
0.3848128616809845,
-0.5616072416305542,
0.4720531105995178,
0.24687258899211884,
0.024260787293314934,
0.0012553848791867495,
-0.01873980648815632,
0.48628708720207214,
-0.018535273149609566,
-0.5687461495399475,
0.20137585699558258,
0.1390358805656433,
-0.5242471098899841,
-0.25999677181243896,
0.8539378643035889,
-0.7716646194458008,
-0.3339710831642151,
-0.17098771035671234,
-0.5696444511413574,
-0.2763688862323761,
0.4973103702068329,
0.6220598220825195,
0.33398470282554626,
-0.19738644361495972,
0.1700800210237503,
0.7373337149620056,
-0.015936436131596565,
0.25901058316230774,
0.6619367599487305,
-0.13676223158836365,
-0.4025755822658539,
0.8374307751655579,
-0.05470418184995651,
0.6816504597663879,
0.3667271137237549,
0.3422330915927887,
-0.04302508011460304,
-0.555957555770874,
-0.46243754029273987,
0.09945028275251389,
-0.3024073839187622,
-0.16204477846622467,
-0.5254241824150085,
0.15559755265712738,
-0.4761906862258911,
-0.369574636220932,
-0.8746510148048401,
-0.4875907599925995,
0.07681772857904434,
0.19910961389541626,
0.2298838496208191,
0.22945934534072876,
0.058609601110219955,
0.11212816834449768,
-0.2502109110355377,
0.1796397864818573,
0.3029162883758545,
0.5358874797821045,
-0.3318631052970886,
-0.538184642791748,
0.06350421905517578,
-0.046866219490766525,
-0.2813667356967926,
-0.3969650864601135,
-0.10804753005504608,
0.08535580337047577,
0.1372971087694168,
0.6671945452690125,
0.27321168780326843,
0.9631021618843079,
-0.6948038339614868,
0.4057716727256775,
-0.05639077350497246,
-1.0513473749160767,
0.5406858325004578,
-0.31303712725639343,
0.20488429069519043,
1.255738615989685,
0.35505133867263794,
-0.33065900206565857,
-0.4016846716403961,
-0.569170355796814,
-0.5656178593635559,
1.0637140274047852,
0.14393141865730286,
0.02037365920841694,
-0.016019783914089203,
0.31041330099105835,
0.5729532837867737,
0.4934057891368866,
-0.6199697256088257,
-0.5254013538360596,
-0.099294014275074,
0.12536115944385529,
-0.044956330209970474,
-0.23442703485488892,
0.034384846687316895,
-0.1994839757680893,
0.9168019890785217,
-0.19049352407455444,
-0.1150040328502655,
0.07127939164638519,
0.34571415185928345,
-0.4541327953338623,
0.299150288105011,
0.7116661071777344,
0.30990979075431824,
-0.6249368786811829,
-0.06671712547540665,
-0.10692112892866135,
-0.3125683665275574,
0.002798468340188265,
0.4145157039165497,
-0.5499590635299683,
-0.01618816889822483,
-0.027117373421788216,
0.7803832292556763,
0.2511965036392212,
-0.3000389635562897,
0.17473836243152618,
0.04206335172057152,
-0.05342474579811096,
0.16032840311527252,
-0.028714977204799652,
-0.3493211269378662,
-0.17448440194129944,
0.12674857676029205,
0.3335720896720886,
0.388726145029068,
-0.6703377366065979,
0.2165648490190506,
0.8473948836326599,
-0.7528395056724548,
0.05630571395158768,
0.43948894739151,
0.16962973773479462,
-0.07075481116771698,
0.348869651556015,
-0.024264050647616386,
-0.24063169956207275,
0.34871906042099,
0.3741617202758789,
0.7508824467658997,
-0.19087262451648712,
0.057667654007673264,
0.16192743182182312,
0.36673974990844727,
-0.09900975972414017,
-0.015005304478108883,
-0.07180305570363998,
-0.9813839197158813,
-0.2153511345386505,
-0.7895491719245911,
-0.5028498768806458,
0.030240265652537346,
-0.7491392493247986,
0.6944124698638916,
-0.5000181198120117,
-0.052573151886463165,
0.4063531160354614,
-0.06886713951826096,
-0.30094510316848755,
0.21063625812530518,
0.01278041210025549,
0.9213738441467285,
-0.6122074127197266,
1.0382957458496094,
0.6445865035057068,
-0.10768667608499527,
-0.7682096362113953,
-0.1401326060295105,
0.36472809314727783,
-0.7974138259887695,
0.09379686415195465,
-0.30292341113090515,
-0.4408057928085327,
0.07017584145069122,
-0.32303130626678467,
-0.875468373298645,
0.7635963559150696,
0.7265127301216125,
-0.3869362473487854,
0.06178346648812294,
-0.10667117685079575,
0.4231919050216675,
-0.47970050573349,
0.22968775033950806,
0.7550216317176819,
0.24142608046531677,
0.14254747331142426,
-1.1514911651611328,
-0.08186745643615723,
-0.19038358330726624,
-0.029204383492469788,
0.7539060711860657,
-1.0013463497161865,
0.7327136993408203,
-0.09716682881116867,
0.1441565752029419,
0.19074644148349762,
0.4879958927631378,
0.37475186586380005,
-0.13864606618881226,
0.4500159025192261,
0.5057404041290283,
0.448341429233551,
-0.14279091358184814,
1.2655375003814697,
-0.4735462963581085,
0.5108463168144226,
1.0907102823257446,
-0.028482940047979355,
0.7560840845108032,
0.8218133449554443,
-0.1863524466753006,
0.14184904098510742,
0.7198420166969299,
0.536571741104126,
0.6192237138748169,
-0.17561155557632446,
0.12709404528141022,
-0.5383749008178711,
-0.277109295129776,
-0.4916192889213562,
0.49913641810417175,
-0.18554817140102386,
-0.2680078446865082,
-0.19729630649089813,
-0.3177127242088318,
0.19572913646697998,
-0.08775854110717773,
-0.1757042557001114,
0.5930585861206055,
0.039592862129211426,
-1.0004922151565552,
0.6440428495407104,
0.00012510904343798757,
0.9483944773674011,
-0.9590486288070679,
0.16689875721931458,
-0.46912434697151184,
0.2823702096939087,
-0.14891722798347473,
-0.4187348783016205,
0.06477255374193192,
-0.1547660529613495,
-0.4774998128414154,
-0.12654399871826172,
0.5204697251319885,
-0.5318289995193481,
-0.5074203014373779,
0.25796547532081604,
-0.17954544723033905,
-0.21518826484680176,
0.1150759905576706,
-0.6635544896125793,
0.14133816957473755,
0.16819310188293457,
-0.2223643958568573,
0.4570568799972534,
0.5472432971000671,
-0.18143899738788605,
0.6658519506454468,
0.5403337478637695,
0.2001970410346985,
-0.0900476798415184,
-0.148501917719841,
0.651813268661499,
-0.1862996518611908,
-0.3406972587108612,
-0.9142568707466125,
0.42221352458000183,
0.031067416071891785,
-0.7653532028198242,
0.5011277198791504,
0.6144284009933472,
0.9902408123016357,
-0.05049823969602585,
0.5391204357147217,
-0.20075570046901703,
0.2577269673347473,
-0.5939114093780518,
0.5268795490264893,
-0.7960757613182068,
-0.053565770387649536,
-0.821279764175415,
-0.9867967963218689,
-0.07583823055028915,
0.4297550618648529,
-0.4338940978050232,
-0.08714961260557175,
0.676622748374939,
0.6504642367362976,
-0.3432599604129791,
0.014955985359847546,
0.32807111740112305,
-0.27770987153053284,
-0.09642954170703888,
0.4907466769218445,
0.018358416855335236,
-0.4995816648006439,
0.7412101626396179,
-0.5438475608825684,
-0.8559035658836365,
-0.22813551127910614,
-1.2029091119766235,
-0.5783563256263733,
-0.3667230010032654,
-0.2799244821071625,
-0.16490843892097473,
0.1959405094385147,
1.1704825162887573,
0.8697000741958618,
-0.95152348279953,
-0.41601988673210144,
-0.024143032729625702,
0.22391866147518158,
-0.3686436116695404,
-0.15762017667293549,
0.19511757791042328,
-0.5225914120674133,
-1.0429836511611938,
0.24063684046268463,
0.7438703179359436,
-0.00604372238740325,
0.009769872762262821,
-0.03990178555250168,
-0.12853118777275085,
0.2532239258289337,
0.5596827864646912,
0.48186638951301575,
-0.7796363234519958,
-0.3703826665878296,
0.00396990031003952,
-0.2978447377681732,
0.05131381377577782,
0.8303402662277222,
-0.29517775774002075,
0.7637250423431396,
0.3387918770313263,
0.5394829511642456,
0.2813580334186554,
0.2225864678621292,
0.8932334780693054,
-0.6115270853042603,
0.455891489982605,
-0.11156152933835983,
0.49845820665359497,
-0.032775670289993286,
-0.33825886249542236,
0.535247802734375,
0.14699624478816986,
-0.4751386046409607,
-0.5771179795265198,
0.29165884852409363,
-1.1960562467575073,
0.008529155515134335,
1.0435941219329834,
0.18789832293987274,
0.10193336755037308,
0.024331089109182358,
-0.3327854871749878,
0.04176685959100723,
-0.762238621711731,
0.9816262125968933,
0.9722611308097839,
-0.17216378450393677,
0.05362069234251976,
-0.308108925819397,
0.8877546191215515,
0.8822339177131653,
-0.541339099407196,
0.13702408969402313,
0.2805977463722229,
0.16287195682525635,
0.3639299273490906,
0.8119730353355408,
-0.26774802803993225,
0.41567420959472656,
-0.16986539959907532,
0.44204336404800415,
-0.09797744452953339,
-0.1747668981552124,
-0.15245173871517181,
0.08226440846920013,
0.2870275676250458,
-0.3307483494281769
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07690v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07690v1
|
SATDAUG -- A Balanced and Augmented Dataset for Detecting Self-Admitted Technical Debt
| 2024-03-12T14:33:53 | 2024-03-12T14:33:53 |
Edi Sutoyo, Andrea Capiluppi
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL
|
Self-admitted technical debt (SATD) refers to a form of technical debt in
which developers explicitly acknowledge and document the existence of technical
shortcuts, workarounds, or temporary solutions within the codebase. Over recent
years, researchers have manually labeled datasets derived from various software
development artifacts: source code comments, messages from the issue tracker
and pull request sections, and commit messages. These datasets are designed for
training, evaluation, performance validation, and improvement of machine
learning and deep learning models to accurately identify SATD instances.
However, class imbalance poses a serious challenge across all the existing
datasets, particularly when researchers are interested in categorizing the
specific types of SATD. In order to address the scarcity of labeled data for
SATD \textit{identification} (i.e., whether an instance is SATD or not) and
\textit{categorization} (i.e., which type of SATD is being classified) in
existing datasets, we share the \textit{SATDAUG} dataset, an augmented version
of existing SATD datasets, including source code comments, issue tracker, pull
requests, and commit messages. These augmented datasets have been balanced in
relation to the available artifacts and provide a much richer source of labeled
data for training machine learning or deep learning models.
|
[
-0.5142112374305725,
-0.7522986531257629,
0.16609421372413635,
0.42736852169036865,
-0.15453214943408966,
0.734509289264679,
0.18355301022529602,
-0.13510474562644958,
0.5275322198867798,
0.6209172606468201,
-0.5816652774810791,
-0.30949515104293823,
-0.256507009267807,
-0.1524513065814972,
-0.4906657934188843,
1.4963066577911377,
-0.11520141363143921,
-0.0852171778678894,
-0.6526466608047485,
-0.34018629789352417,
-1.1682652235031128,
-0.4337601363658905,
-0.22072532773017883,
-0.3497638702392578,
0.21689969301223755,
0.7507851123809814,
0.36615267395973206,
0.46939754486083984,
0.7506364583969116,
0.2953999638557434,
0.33994436264038086,
0.16862119734287262,
-0.41578471660614014,
-0.06653144955635071,
0.1163967102766037,
-0.17419026792049408,
-0.8016398549079895,
0.2754423916339874,
0.33122313022613525,
0.5307066440582275,
-0.36055415868759155,
0.5717280507087708,
0.19166406989097595,
0.6251039505004883,
-0.7328307032585144,
-0.06293488293886185,
-0.08575955778360367,
0.03665816783905029,
-0.5277983546257019,
-0.16673240065574646,
-0.21712012588977814,
-0.36482638120651245,
-0.21372085809707642,
-0.8603629469871521,
0.4509696364402771,
-0.12555283308029175,
1.0498905181884766,
0.6454905271530151,
-0.504967451095581,
-0.236548513174057,
-0.5687867999076843,
0.546475350856781,
-0.6032533049583435,
-0.27750763297080994,
0.2297159880399704,
0.368612140417099,
-0.01823752373456955,
-0.6395618915557861,
-0.36494559049606323,
0.07929175347089767,
-0.1939706653356552,
0.2282395362854004,
0.06817633658647537,
0.08103644847869873,
0.2238025963306427,
1.0657459497451782,
-0.710938036441803,
0.38062718510627747,
-0.7029281854629517,
-0.21638450026512146,
0.7907553315162659,
0.18383990228176117,
0.23802505433559418,
-0.2696685492992401,
-0.6999508142471313,
0.3652861416339874,
-0.6592133045196533,
-0.4463818371295929,
0.2623452842235565,
0.2863978445529938,
-0.4906899631023407,
0.7040194869041443,
-0.012083897367119789,
0.8694618940353394,
0.29147833585739136,
0.2151319831609726,
0.6381947994232178,
-0.2534523010253906,
-0.4328414499759674,
0.36334773898124695,
0.36924612522125244,
0.22863052785396576,
0.16040103137493134,
0.17262905836105347,
-0.47080275416374207,
0.07826808094978333,
0.603486180305481,
-0.39927810430526733,
-0.27228644490242004,
0.2655859589576721,
-0.32943961024284363,
-0.5910454988479614,
0.0071175736375153065,
-0.7203230857849121,
-0.948818027973175,
-0.6059750914573669,
0.4931957423686981,
-0.11390211433172226,
-0.4867849349975586,
-0.07946180552244186,
0.0698612630367279,
0.06583006680011749,
0.22287335991859436,
-0.21819694340229034,
0.21025697886943817,
0.8275671601295471,
0.9824658036231995,
-0.46941253542900085,
-0.2534925639629364,
-0.40227556228637695,
0.24162696301937103,
-0.2873319387435913,
1.0813099145889282,
-0.27659904956817627,
-0.5351231098175049,
-0.051401425153017044,
0.010767282918095589,
0.17481108009815216,
-0.5107315182685852,
0.8316624164581299,
-0.24273541569709778,
0.13457906246185303,
-0.4597439169883728,
-0.7431862950325012,
-0.07695402950048447,
0.10818439722061157,
-0.7113322615623474,
1.2542378902435303,
0.5501800775527954,
-0.851780116558075,
0.8906610012054443,
-0.8670833110809326,
-0.49160802364349365,
0.7262940406799316,
-0.20683348178863525,
-0.6679965853691101,
0.07812938839197159,
0.05828257277607918,
0.2941475808620453,
-0.42431527376174927,
0.6445590853691101,
-0.48261427879333496,
-0.45370906591415405,
-0.04938604310154915,
0.026945196092128754,
0.9422264695167542,
0.6885599493980408,
-0.26587215065956116,
0.051078129559755325,
-0.9029774069786072,
-0.09870079159736633,
0.004982671234756708,
-0.175675630569458,
-0.7616208791732788,
-0.23242990672588348,
0.09978596121072769,
-0.09996594488620758,
0.32798585295677185,
-0.7231599688529968,
0.45886266231536865,
-0.05310134217143059,
0.0773283988237381,
1.1593234539031982,
0.04281458631157875,
0.1317424774169922,
-0.20085392892360687,
0.7740497589111328,
0.15319468080997467,
0.05326920747756958,
-0.007979534566402435,
-0.07531537860631943,
-0.9630030393600464,
-0.7034254670143127,
0.4873628616333008,
0.6056538224220276,
-0.5772355794906616,
0.5330935716629028,
-0.15096653997898102,
-0.2864687740802765,
-0.8259977102279663,
0.021647894755005836,
0.23751384019851685,
0.7306705117225647,
0.25388967990875244,
-0.008798358030617237,
-0.6795818209648132,
-0.8840470314025879,
-0.10217548161745071,
0.008308597840368748,
0.2209225744009018,
0.3250987231731415,
0.3075310289859772,
-0.21907342970371246,
0.8536087274551392,
-0.7576876282691956,
-0.6932260990142822,
0.07539794594049454,
0.6819639801979065,
0.23899312317371368,
0.798738420009613,
0.6885506510734558,
-0.522274374961853,
-0.293401300907135,
-0.0650242418050766,
-1.0945169925689697,
-0.39993661642074585,
-0.4769054055213928,
0.263123095035553,
0.17086857557296753,
0.3546348214149475,
-0.41214239597320557,
0.6210021376609802,
0.2886977195739746,
-0.7664368748664856,
0.4360135793685913,
-0.3316223621368408,
0.324222207069397,
-0.975389838218689,
-0.06815865635871887,
-0.10081232339143753,
-0.123591348528862,
-0.32286614179611206,
0.14835382997989655,
0.15168777108192444,
-0.31477779150009155,
0.11065437644720078,
0.18729542195796967,
-0.38847413659095764,
-0.4821705222129822,
-0.2953547239303589,
-0.010472902096807957,
-0.18809154629707336,
-0.02551274374127388,
-0.5628862380981445,
1.3057003021240234,
0.8273980021476746,
-0.5533360838890076,
0.7012616395950317,
0.17375992238521576,
-0.21914777159690857,
1.1972713470458984,
-0.8237111568450928,
0.029513079673051834,
0.03472188487648964,
-0.17857155203819275,
-1.0121694803237915,
-0.22130343317985535,
0.03473895415663719,
-0.3544312119483948,
0.594734787940979,
-0.017030471935868263,
-0.26020875573158264,
-0.7424138188362122,
-0.002180166309699416,
0.6531020402908325,
0.04457949846982956,
-0.8023863434791565,
0.709298849105835,
0.6116973757743835,
-0.18257057666778564,
-0.5789211392402649,
-0.7125645279884338,
0.3065550923347473,
-0.3761310875415802,
-0.629397988319397,
0.15261784195899963,
-0.019015593454241753,
-0.13128775358200073,
0.20827925205230713,
-0.16677629947662354,
-0.1762290745973587,
0.16115494072437286,
0.5280249714851379,
0.5510638356208801,
-0.4164187014102936,
0.3937312364578247,
-0.11664392054080963,
-0.32512184977531433,
0.12441320717334747,
-0.16661888360977173,
0.4139648973941803,
-0.509978711605072,
-0.4060889780521393,
-0.16966357827186584,
0.2754085659980774,
0.7338525652885437,
-0.2049628347158432,
0.4008212089538574,
0.41862502694129944,
-0.35049936175346375,
-0.3747885227203369,
-0.8037722110748291,
0.2715965509414673,
-0.564142107963562,
-0.16664841771125793,
-0.42619800567626953,
-0.6638841032981873,
0.6076910495758057,
-0.03381235897541046,
0.020232772454619408,
0.5803316831588745,
0.4831063747406006,
-0.29567503929138184,
0.601867139339447,
0.5879114270210266,
-0.16473650932312012,
0.05379973724484444,
-0.3873453736305237,
0.27115413546562195,
-0.49428847432136536,
-0.3513852059841156,
-0.44192636013031006,
-0.41648295521736145,
-0.6448181867599487,
-0.08204831182956696,
0.1387454718351364,
-0.4874137341976166,
-0.352620393037796,
0.20812858641147614,
-0.8720174431800842,
0.6053591966629028,
0.6211968064308167,
0.13577410578727722,
0.14438165724277496,
-0.17012721300125122,
0.28659531474113464,
-0.12360544502735138,
-0.479837030172348,
-0.028400849550962448,
1.3525044918060303,
0.07846110314130783,
0.9837963581085205,
-0.4419517517089844,
0.8547544479370117,
1.3173357248306274,
0.1519034504890442,
-0.5875490307807922,
0.31245559453964233,
-0.11214466392993927,
-0.7218360304832458,
0.04594624042510986,
-0.5794312953948975,
-0.8171935677528381,
-0.35417723655700684,
0.023970622569322586,
0.038861069828271866,
0.7474309802055359,
0.34186187386512756,
-0.2454175353050232,
0.19097280502319336,
-0.9059237837791443,
1.0405043363571167,
-0.49349910020828247,
-0.1754436045885086,
-0.649808406829834,
-0.34645748138427734,
0.6652384400367737,
-0.39661380648612976,
0.07500120252370834,
0.10249855369329453,
0.2428586632013321,
0.8085231781005859,
-0.7274671792984009,
0.6008909344673157,
-0.47315195202827454,
-0.13135464489459991,
0.5726890563964844,
0.09168245643377304,
0.2611262798309326,
0.034381963312625885,
0.3066759705543518,
0.07277879118919373,
0.020864950492978096,
-0.8539829254150391,
-0.11872919648885727,
1.0676182508468628,
-0.9436116814613342,
-0.3318743407726288,
-1.1187587976455688,
-0.9318931102752686,
0.016798492521047592,
0.24009265005588531,
-0.02837282232940197,
0.3867792785167694,
0.016278821974992752,
0.10723927617073059,
0.6562931537628174,
-0.30651918053627014,
0.2686544358730316,
0.6163123846054077,
-0.05087827518582344,
-0.5204951763153076,
1.1863999366760254,
0.3135436773300171,
0.03734413534402847,
-0.4108743667602539,
-0.09989964962005615,
0.15706518292427063,
-0.19389763474464417,
-0.17377741634845734,
0.36830633878707886,
-0.6113157868385315,
-0.7317420840263367,
-0.2948984205722809,
-0.25788089632987976,
-0.3286718726158142,
-0.2955321967601776,
-0.494498074054718,
-0.6448640823364258,
-0.5146262049674988,
-0.6079105138778687,
0.6479959487915039,
0.826262891292572,
-0.36509037017822266,
0.33660048246383667,
-0.2767883241176605,
0.8153892755508423,
0.20981015264987946,
0.6544432044029236,
-0.4466441869735718,
-0.38979196548461914,
-0.25899073481559753,
0.12731406092643738,
-0.13490043580532074,
-0.4997945725917816,
0.180763378739357,
0.15097565948963165,
0.5029966831207275,
0.5801500082015991,
0.3246504068374634,
1.0172309875488281,
0.21126261353492737,
0.6236355304718018,
0.09665040671825409,
-0.8669022917747498,
0.5490112900733948,
-0.21495988965034485,
-0.01412947941571474,
0.5929806232452393,
0.08859723806381226,
-0.12997759878635406,
-0.3028572201728821,
-0.7643852829933167,
-0.661171555519104,
0.8424991965293884,
-0.11950379610061646,
-0.20177055895328522,
0.21618720889091492,
0.3512243628501892,
0.10684988647699356,
0.3308144509792328,
-0.6621677875518799,
-0.4352283775806427,
-0.5313487648963928,
-0.12938292324543,
0.04184787720441818,
-0.16906790435314178,
-0.3554060757160187,
-0.38314729928970337,
0.7142241597175598,
0.08049023151397705,
0.014540782198309898,
-0.0011833715252578259,
-0.1845346838235855,
-0.2746860384941101,
0.06531845033168793,
0.4378834068775177,
0.7120398879051208,
-0.4759659469127655,
0.20436622202396393,
-0.1672481894493103,
-0.7331225872039795,
0.28034114837646484,
0.2555629014968872,
-0.3820054531097412,
-0.023124855011701584,
-0.08971446007490158,
0.505942702293396,
-0.24936924874782562,
-0.5357009768486023,
0.6459824442863464,
0.2691422402858734,
-0.09988608211278915,
-0.4810074269771576,
-0.19910739362239838,
-0.4170447289943695,
-0.02615087293088436,
0.42460623383522034,
0.21532925963401794,
0.21459917724132538,
-0.40907883644104004,
0.4949586093425751,
0.34662434458732605,
-0.3742179274559021,
-0.043085090816020966,
0.43162789940834045,
0.4485667943954468,
-0.19773826003074646,
0.9165820479393005,
-0.2348204106092453,
-0.23326881229877472,
0.8418700098991394,
0.5396507978439331,
1.1041477918624878,
-0.4167139530181885,
0.6649649739265442,
0.33219385147094727,
0.5915823578834534,
0.38698968291282654,
0.5582717061042786,
-0.014208687469363213,
-0.3867855966091156,
-0.5042826533317566,
-0.4328577220439911,
0.0676528811454773,
0.219567209482193,
-1.0363153219223022,
0.5341882109642029,
-0.6290675401687622,
-0.24415476620197296,
-0.2164008617401123,
-0.03300396725535393,
-0.33479270339012146,
0.2553640305995941,
-0.034606777131557465,
0.8742021918296814,
-1.2453079223632812,
0.5747631788253784,
0.6414807438850403,
-0.5039680600166321,
-0.4302246570587158,
-0.3651474118232727,
0.10071304440498352,
-0.8652264475822449,
0.5478885769844055,
-0.08731673657894135,
0.11301736533641815,
-0.06674021482467651,
-0.6142642498016357,
-0.831622838973999,
0.9157419800758362,
0.22913745045661926,
-0.2943100929260254,
0.2751663625240326,
0.1514510214328766,
0.5342031717300415,
-0.3526996076107025,
-0.2844160795211792,
0.6946265697479248,
0.6017199158668518,
0.16228510439395905,
-0.6539183259010315,
0.03481127694249153,
-0.3112710416316986,
-0.47953248023986816,
0.5700781941413879,
-0.4594128429889679,
0.8547024726867676,
-0.3383530080318451,
-0.12385361641645432,
-0.18541721999645233,
0.6936274766921997,
0.2114245593547821,
0.8549686670303345,
0.3657573163509369,
1.090741515159607,
0.9043248295783997,
-0.5025623440742493,
0.9403993487358093,
-0.08880740404129028,
0.393710196018219,
1.2136629819869995,
-0.4631258249282837,
0.07390646636486053,
0.46355387568473816,
-0.17586912214756012,
0.4270761013031006,
0.8222894072532654,
-0.7656762003898621,
0.49912965297698975,
-0.06916116923093796,
-0.1067662462592125,
-0.35853320360183716,
-0.3156711459159851,
-0.779078483581543,
0.13987135887145996,
0.48774266242980957,
0.014963485300540924,
-0.22038739919662476,
0.4163837134838104,
-0.16420242190361023,
-0.03424582630395889,
-0.439505934715271,
0.8783376216888428,
-0.12486859411001205,
-0.4565480053424835,
0.8048142790794373,
-0.35906869173049927,
0.3015952408313751,
-0.35638681054115295,
-0.12347282469272614,
-0.4928494393825531,
0.2944084107875824,
-0.6530430912971497,
-0.8560579419136047,
0.28941360116004944,
0.068268321454525,
-0.06195051968097687,
-0.029020147398114204,
0.7520350813865662,
-0.0410783626139164,
-0.7454586029052734,
-0.13059259951114655,
0.18863815069198608,
-0.1277506947517395,
0.2806589901447296,
-0.6752697229385376,
-0.16776436567306519,
-0.1962994486093521,
0.21091023087501526,
0.2550618350505829,
0.5172107815742493,
0.052062228322029114,
0.9679121971130371,
0.3709895610809326,
0.3278800845146179,
0.12199714779853821,
0.014043989591300488,
1.1620268821716309,
-0.3937574326992035,
-0.6707091331481934,
-0.2991597354412079,
0.4583628475666046,
-0.40534311532974243,
-0.4077037572860718,
1.030774712562561,
0.9613140821456909,
0.47368305921554565,
-0.1304987519979477,
0.6659179925918579,
-0.44418394565582275,
0.8284170627593994,
-0.15906555950641632,
0.5193805694580078,
-0.7156493663787842,
0.6866602301597595,
-0.4227205812931061,
-0.5575854182243347,
-0.09139348566532135,
0.4966127574443817,
-0.0646064281463623,
-0.058728981763124466,
0.45367711782455444,
0.5759091973304749,
-0.3354376256465912,
-0.018067795783281326,
-0.15773539245128632,
0.3510442078113556,
-0.018362680450081825,
0.09038309752941132,
0.886483371257782,
-0.2961060106754303,
0.38660284876823425,
-0.26128050684928894,
-0.32033494114875793,
-0.2429690808057785,
-0.7287879586219788,
-0.874306321144104,
-0.3774876594543457,
-0.8181638717651367,
-0.6078347563743591,
0.009230065159499645,
0.5423107147216797,
0.49023061990737915,
-1.1909215450286865,
-0.39633336663246155,
-0.4587152600288391,
0.27404332160949707,
-0.2992999851703644,
-0.3609267473220825,
0.4765290319919586,
-0.45411065220832825,
-0.14473581314086914,
0.21505790948867798,
0.2805533707141876,
-0.011439885944128036,
-0.22995243966579437,
0.002529582940042019,
-0.2801364064216614,
-0.1714969277381897,
0.22222661972045898,
0.44250860810279846,
-0.39557966589927673,
-0.09575078636407852,
-0.041903093457221985,
-0.018952446058392525,
0.10577709227800369,
1.061399221420288,
-1.0107508897781372,
0.6376577019691467,
0.4926895797252655,
0.6871985197067261,
0.5460011959075928,
0.3091132938861847,
0.6565775275230408,
-1.017399549484253,
0.2633659243583679,
0.28152090311050415,
0.2253163903951645,
0.16181506216526031,
-0.6034364104270935,
0.8568928837776184,
0.3668214976787567,
-0.909473180770874,
-1.3481930494308472,
-0.15430893003940582,
-1.1427273750305176,
-0.40442371368408203,
0.5203129649162292,
-0.040584150701761246,
0.3571508228778839,
-0.21801649034023285,
-0.34464773535728455,
0.0907866507768631,
-0.33397403359413147,
1.2362785339355469,
0.4439699947834015,
0.17266243696212769,
-0.03277236595749855,
-0.5124919414520264,
0.4118037223815918,
0.37402042746543884,
-1.1484570503234863,
0.3441328704357147,
0.9865432977676392,
-0.06987783312797546,
0.19626203179359436,
0.15060465037822723,
0.0981634333729744,
0.5582177042961121,
-0.16844257712364197,
0.14577217400074005,
-0.2792012393474579,
-0.3806445300579071,
-0.34767499566078186,
0.12791655957698822,
-0.269538551568985,
-0.418650358915329
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07687v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07687v1
|
Annotations on a Budget: Leveraging Geo-Data Similarity to Balance Model Performance and Annotation Cost
| 2024-03-12T14:27:17 | 2024-03-12T14:27:17 |
Oana Ignat, Longju Bai, Joan Nwatu, Rada Mihalcea
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Current foundation models have shown impressive performance across various
tasks. However, several studies have revealed that these models are not
effective for everyone due to the imbalanced geographical and economic
representation of the data used in the training process. Most of this data
comes from Western countries, leading to poor results for underrepresented
countries. To address this issue, more data needs to be collected from these
countries, but the cost of annotation can be a significant bottleneck. In this
paper, we propose methods to identify the data to be annotated to balance model
performance and annotation costs. Our approach first involves finding the
countries with images of topics (objects and actions) most visually distinct
from those already in the training datasets used by current large
vision-language foundation models. Next, we identify countries with higher
visual similarity for these topics and show that using data from these
countries to supplement the training data improves model performance and
reduces annotation costs. The resulting lists of countries and corresponding
topics are made available at
https://github.com/MichiganNLP/visual_diversity_budget.
|
[
-0.8806015849113464,
-0.2294958382844925,
0.2586107850074768,
0.28466060757637024,
-0.38172662258148193,
0.004247378092259169,
-0.046443644911050797,
-0.8549262881278992,
0.41997960209846497,
0.760547935962677,
-0.5609645843505859,
-0.3477194905281067,
-0.575853168964386,
-0.052577100694179535,
-0.19813376665115356,
0.8646482229232788,
-0.2243572324514389,
0.04757640138268471,
-0.40876951813697815,
-0.7118386626243591,
-0.1946423053741455,
-0.46851712465286255,
-0.2580675482749939,
-0.5061537027359009,
0.2212841957807541,
0.5285437107086182,
0.6102568507194519,
0.8017690181732178,
0.8592907190322876,
0.2726917266845703,
-0.06290097534656525,
0.08456788212060928,
-0.4800526201725006,
-0.410273939371109,
-0.23561780154705048,
-0.27755632996559143,
-0.06544733792543411,
0.02285979501903057,
0.5634763836860657,
0.8237635493278503,
-0.01422358863055706,
0.48666974902153015,
-0.02464042790234089,
0.6736446619033813,
-0.9942504167556763,
0.3754473924636841,
-0.5055215358734131,
0.12847372889518738,
-0.15229713916778564,
0.1340034306049347,
0.3346295952796936,
-0.3371167480945587,
0.7372153401374817,
-0.6413511037826538,
0.32343363761901855,
-0.06439425051212311,
1.2044748067855835,
0.3611803650856018,
-0.04263893887400627,
-0.20555110275745392,
-0.3056214451789856,
0.5138365626335144,
-0.03409489244222641,
0.04750458896160126,
0.5484894514083862,
0.21951770782470703,
0.3121792674064636,
-0.4370526671409607,
-0.11959991604089737,
-0.04748634994029999,
-0.26289689540863037,
0.05154099687933922,
-0.13395997881889343,
-0.25771790742874146,
0.5535482168197632,
0.34041184186935425,
-0.140522301197052,
-0.2072199583053589,
-0.6633021831512451,
-0.2909074127674103,
0.7682820558547974,
0.04770275950431824,
0.2831575870513916,
-0.23534825444221497,
-0.5617443919181824,
-0.24229015409946442,
-0.6962843537330627,
0.17952774465084076,
0.4091535806655884,
0.4386754035949707,
-0.537498414516449,
0.7430503964424133,
-0.8564325571060181,
0.7067705392837524,
-0.3520249128341675,
-0.09749583899974823,
0.4098152220249176,
-0.415469765663147,
-0.3082624077796936,
0.02966497093439102,
0.20679189264774323,
0.8461560606956482,
0.7018478512763977,
-0.04915296286344528,
-0.3041989505290985,
-0.023922331631183624,
0.15445104241371155,
-0.9362553358078003,
-0.45196545124053955,
-0.43061569333076477,
-0.38887327909469604,
-0.11697028577327728,
0.26106739044189453,
-0.8508776426315308,
-0.38729771971702576,
-0.5593775510787964,
0.4862632155418396,
0.13134631514549255,
-0.04269322752952576,
-0.30728983879089355,
-0.24157491326332092,
-0.0604773685336113,
0.19644854962825775,
-1.1158804893493652,
0.16044847667217255,
0.4426230490207672,
1.1774792671203613,
0.25519275665283203,
-0.308780699968338,
-0.0440857820212841,
-0.13258585333824158,
-0.37425753474235535,
0.8052429556846619,
-0.46107351779937744,
-0.2866264283657074,
-0.07500317692756653,
0.06793496012687683,
0.163614422082901,
-0.6928238868713379,
0.08295360952615738,
-0.11095398664474487,
-0.11467920988798141,
-1.0445095300674438,
-0.16148924827575684,
-0.21427428722381592,
0.3665565252304077,
-1.1201751232147217,
1.0351476669311523,
0.4643164277076721,
-1.0060853958129883,
1.0138236284255981,
-0.6359784603118896,
-0.2360987812280655,
0.08708464354276657,
-0.17010930180549622,
-0.5663991570472717,
0.14227955043315887,
0.7009328007698059,
0.41146320104599,
-0.45638254284858704,
0.4964658319950104,
-0.32271257042884827,
-0.5234834551811218,
-0.19228969514369965,
-0.05989516153931618,
0.870442271232605,
0.24609684944152832,
-0.3857390880584717,
0.05341525003314018,
-0.835155725479126,
-0.30390262603759766,
0.12433797866106033,
-0.28566405177116394,
-0.5007359385490417,
-0.11920688301324844,
0.43320903182029724,
0.04064619913697243,
0.2431386113166809,
-0.42160338163375854,
0.13432736694812775,
-0.34701234102249146,
0.44108152389526367,
0.5153336524963379,
-0.13137024641036987,
0.6383026242256165,
-0.3662445843219757,
0.36977818608283997,
-0.16361355781555176,
0.19089139997959137,
-0.18419323861598969,
-0.5353982448577881,
-0.5434086322784424,
-0.5251457691192627,
0.33776742219924927,
0.47269314527511597,
-0.4857136309146881,
-0.23843158781528473,
-0.3666900098323822,
-0.3818875849246979,
-0.4744856059551239,
-0.03078284114599228,
0.07661612331867218,
0.7762640714645386,
0.4161451458930969,
-0.6575533151626587,
-0.6385142803192139,
-1.2060933113098145,
-0.027264928445219994,
-0.1796991378068924,
0.09364394098520279,
0.47396647930145264,
0.8302391171455383,
0.3513774871826172,
1.2370853424072266,
-0.4189589023590088,
-0.30597805976867676,
0.24079570174217224,
0.12572379410266876,
-0.3088783323764801,
0.5532603859901428,
1.0055828094482422,
-1.1060528755187988,
-0.1483624428510666,
-0.18082481622695923,
-0.5238779783248901,
-0.38952046632766724,
-0.037854909896850586,
-0.09282104671001434,
0.10781370848417282,
0.2774786651134491,
-0.28851956129074097,
0.735964834690094,
0.46360376477241516,
-0.3382967710494995,
-0.07232552766799927,
-0.037339918315410614,
0.4078512191772461,
-0.7244110107421875,
0.35821399092674255,
0.08261249214410782,
0.08876612782478333,
0.022371919825673103,
0.2168666422367096,
0.01404742244631052,
-0.3578745424747467,
-0.19704309105873108,
0.6707624197006226,
-0.22833704948425293,
-0.31744664907455444,
-0.07383545488119125,
-0.015329948626458645,
-0.09452661126852036,
0.31861287355422974,
0.16141057014465332,
0.8927555084228516,
0.48454830050468445,
0.04728549346327782,
0.4111131727695465,
0.3112163245677948,
-0.6973525285720825,
0.8081161379814148,
-0.3506275415420532,
-0.612623929977417,
-0.2474154233932495,
0.27061963081359863,
-0.717721700668335,
-0.49583348631858826,
0.23661641776561737,
0.03585983067750931,
-0.07851406186819077,
-0.6144384145736694,
-0.26663559675216675,
-0.04624700918793678,
-0.05107606574892998,
0.31871816515922546,
0.34074243903160095,
-0.8711552023887634,
0.5687445402145386,
0.5909726023674011,
-0.18137900531291962,
-0.8153214454650879,
-0.9482179880142212,
0.08636251837015152,
-0.5192375183105469,
-0.4619218111038208,
0.28287410736083984,
0.3833560645580292,
-0.2986191511154175,
0.37859585881233215,
-0.17615199089050293,
-0.011707811616361141,
0.545271098613739,
0.5540479421615601,
0.10399425774812698,
-0.15355700254440308,
0.053146909922361374,
-0.3453522026538849,
-0.1444438099861145,
0.11476276069879532,
-0.5146969556808472,
0.2006569504737854,
0.14690564572811127,
-0.4280300736427307,
-0.058206114917993546,
0.36064016819000244,
0.3197459578514099,
-0.7335082292556763,
0.7268016934394836,
0.5436195731163025,
-0.7606185674667358,
0.03952877223491669,
-0.6580414175987244,
0.06812863051891327,
-0.34343230724334717,
0.3319868743419647,
-0.45138782262802124,
-0.6088521480560303,
0.7876349687576294,
-0.3163106441497803,
0.1555996835231781,
0.3925096392631531,
0.340392142534256,
0.1357232928276062,
0.525888204574585,
0.8030919432640076,
-0.26854637265205383,
0.7487899661064148,
-0.48515093326568604,
0.10713620483875275,
-0.3013392686843872,
-0.5184012651443481,
-0.6285702586174011,
-0.6172597408294678,
-0.6873683929443359,
-0.36905643343925476,
-0.04245191812515259,
0.5285345315933228,
-0.35522687435150146,
0.1543358564376831,
-0.29787734150886536,
0.8412697911262512,
0.8581137657165527,
-0.023512477055191994,
-0.027661651372909546,
0.5788795948028564,
-0.020646413788199425,
-0.059337034821510315,
-0.5868090987205505,
-0.5237942934036255,
1.279154896736145,
0.030715838074684143,
0.6260898113250732,
-0.2156304270029068,
0.7594525814056396,
-0.015655161812901497,
0.4968537986278534,
-0.340188205242157,
0.2805456519126892,
-0.23410679399967194,
-0.5306639075279236,
-0.1672259420156479,
-0.4843209683895111,
-0.4566972851753235,
0.3253903090953827,
-0.6905762553215027,
-0.9044877886772156,
0.35877537727355957,
0.2545987069606781,
-0.329856812953949,
0.4064764380455017,
-0.5107386708259583,
0.9326747059822083,
-0.16230899095535278,
-0.32520678639411926,
-0.08054353296756744,
-0.48646336793899536,
0.0995456650853157,
-0.19521978497505188,
-0.03283706679940224,
-0.4331502616405487,
0.05233249440789223,
0.6556695699691772,
-0.19978398084640503,
0.6049917936325073,
-0.2883666157722473,
0.3630027174949646,
0.38416653871536255,
-0.3703625798225403,
0.20627544820308685,
0.13124805688858032,
0.14641530811786652,
0.31816577911376953,
-0.29203638434410095,
-0.6851566433906555,
-0.3277517855167389,
0.887791097164154,
-0.6860101222991943,
-0.38239437341690063,
-0.21555690467357635,
-0.7899490594863892,
0.019169064238667488,
-0.005570973735302687,
0.20727047324180603,
0.550048828125,
-0.11528395116329193,
0.20165951550006866,
0.1920805722475052,
0.011902148835361004,
0.47919800877571106,
0.13769124448299408,
-0.07979107648134232,
-0.7214439511299133,
0.932651162147522,
0.5653698444366455,
0.0989808589220047,
0.2240690290927887,
0.05911528319120407,
-0.2032855600118637,
-0.4378078579902649,
-0.5429649949073792,
-0.08082868903875351,
-0.9594043493270874,
-0.1506546139717102,
-0.5632638335227966,
0.19897335767745972,
-0.09402576833963394,
-0.5411456823348999,
-0.20206283032894135,
-0.5918834805488586,
-0.14493797719478607,
-0.35114553570747375,
0.5985507369041443,
0.4655133783817291,
-0.38356176018714905,
0.5674435496330261,
-0.06835300475358963,
0.08932483196258545,
0.2931293845176697,
0.42897769808769226,
-0.055633824318647385,
0.07662606239318848,
-0.48778626322746277,
0.025560980662703514,
-0.13848485052585602,
-0.44053053855895996,
0.23445536196231842,
0.05291321501135826,
0.49190953373908997,
0.27908456325531006,
0.09477076679468155,
1.3549290895462036,
-0.15564678609371185,
0.6427412629127502,
-0.011814683675765991,
-1.0451397895812988,
0.4427396357059479,
0.14298537373542786,
0.2419232577085495,
0.8047689199447632,
0.3164892792701721,
-0.07523542642593384,
-0.2649407386779785,
-0.6588885188102722,
-1.164499044418335,
0.6818917989730835,
0.16336093842983246,
0.15369415283203125,
0.4449584186077118,
0.4397340714931488,
-0.2647407054901123,
0.03702031448483467,
-0.7417709827423096,
-0.025791363790631294,
-0.20977909862995148,
-0.47975441813468933,
-0.08394107967615128,
-0.17704689502716064,
-0.5961490869522095,
-0.04137394204735756,
0.42233040928840637,
-0.21276259422302246,
-0.35568785667419434,
0.43465250730514526,
-0.24895739555358887,
-0.29005083441734314,
-0.36945444345474243,
0.6452585458755493,
1.0797864198684692,
-0.1342872977256775,
0.08840255439281464,
0.4470616281032562,
-0.39930373430252075,
-0.051321763545274734,
0.44306614995002747,
-0.5246193408966064,
-0.10303255170583725,
0.6271516680717468,
0.8392797112464905,
0.2689431309700012,
-0.8502344489097595,
0.45857471227645874,
0.07323235273361206,
-0.29235219955444336,
-0.08943954855203629,
-0.16985104978084564,
0.233316570520401,
0.8151248693466187,
0.0795888751745224,
0.17709721624851227,
0.08011972904205322,
-0.3155157268047333,
0.2605084478855133,
0.562313437461853,
-0.3924151062965393,
0.16395270824432373,
0.6931204795837402,
0.3906916379928589,
-0.1978309601545334,
0.813765287399292,
0.2712055742740631,
-0.7317519783973694,
1.089501976966858,
0.1549856960773468,
0.3549133539199829,
0.11426186561584473,
0.11052890866994858,
0.57403165102005,
0.7176271080970764,
-0.2916291058063507,
0.42501717805862427,
-0.2071208506822586,
-0.28867867588996887,
-0.19469258189201355,
-0.559909999370575,
-0.3995468020439148,
-0.09507288038730621,
-0.8139495253562927,
0.4822372496128082,
-0.49516722559928894,
-0.22864246368408203,
-0.05773419141769409,
0.3818157911300659,
-1.0775924921035767,
0.5626532435417175,
0.5838454365730286,
0.7894264459609985,
-1.3584877252578735,
0.38750723004341125,
0.7663026452064514,
-0.5514021515846252,
-0.6134903430938721,
-0.3635406494140625,
-0.03043064847588539,
-0.7963816523551941,
0.7860852479934692,
0.4973180890083313,
0.09982381761074066,
-0.4490494728088379,
-0.443677693605423,
-1.0316696166992188,
1.1204149723052979,
0.5806453227996826,
-0.7552791237831116,
0.13119348883628845,
0.10440924763679504,
0.17652374505996704,
-0.7331099510192871,
0.13235938549041748,
0.42052069306373596,
0.25706350803375244,
0.05881034955382347,
-0.9070250391960144,
-0.08875272423028946,
0.07596969604492188,
0.028554288670420647,
0.38102617859840393,
-0.3691231608390808,
1.0564146041870117,
-0.4680585265159607,
-0.12082023918628693,
-0.054016292095184326,
0.4212423861026764,
0.21092171967029572,
0.6660610437393188,
0.4451214671134949,
0.8901913166046143,
0.7644070982933044,
-0.37757787108421326,
0.7263540029525757,
-0.3425503373146057,
0.793295681476593,
0.9656987190246582,
-0.2524580955505371,
0.648169755935669,
0.5205417275428772,
0.022456949576735497,
-0.008554471656680107,
0.8228945732116699,
-0.7283709645271301,
0.7366737127304077,
0.38151517510414124,
0.021594593301415443,
-0.27190521359443665,
-0.27300742268562317,
-0.32299473881721497,
0.4218992292881012,
0.06548304110765457,
-0.4286426305770874,
-0.5158194899559021,
0.11992490291595459,
-0.1092064157128334,
-0.1234002634882927,
-0.37141504883766174,
0.6319200992584229,
-0.15558592975139618,
-0.4125981628894806,
-0.004010020289570093,
-0.13343551754951477,
0.20705546438694,
-0.4802826941013336,
-0.31168416142463684,
-0.42899349331855774,
0.02472909726202488,
-0.2227037101984024,
-0.5839558243751526,
0.41425344347953796,
0.28578224778175354,
-0.360734760761261,
0.029943406581878662,
0.3506211042404175,
-0.5304129123687744,
-0.8098928332328796,
0.2922265827655792,
0.1060345247387886,
0.127554789185524,
-0.09688851982355118,
-0.6644394993782043,
0.18577732145786285,
-0.08336330950260162,
0.03170425817370415,
0.11052781343460083,
0.30592361092567444,
-0.6984717845916748,
0.5207903385162354,
0.5448235273361206,
0.33075112104415894,
-0.20281848311424255,
0.12565581500530243,
0.7189006805419922,
-0.4575451612472534,
-0.7261063456535339,
-0.973507821559906,
0.5129889249801636,
-0.40415671467781067,
-0.5970580577850342,
0.28171980381011963,
0.5856313109397888,
1.3922326564788818,
0.13312746584415436,
0.5340355038642883,
0.0527910515666008,
0.06770852953195572,
-0.4751741588115692,
0.7499456405639648,
-0.7294939756393433,
0.032488271594047546,
-0.231342613697052,
-1.0864176750183105,
-0.5011777281761169,
1.052687644958496,
-0.36313700675964355,
-0.12500110268592834,
0.07328198850154877,
0.721672534942627,
-0.25887635350227356,
0.2535731792449951,
0.04436817765235901,
-0.4929320514202118,
0.08714001625776291,
0.3097134232521057,
0.7371942400932312,
-0.25290361046791077,
0.38696515560150146,
-0.8291545510292053,
-0.13571614027023315,
-0.26735347509384155,
-1.0836057662963867,
-1.0076779127120972,
-0.5563063025474548,
-0.6374061107635498,
-0.028086518868803978,
0.1552697718143463,
0.9071391820907593,
1.1545109748840332,
-0.8113446235656738,
-0.22328363358974457,
0.1167115792632103,
0.03767384588718414,
-0.038179662078619,
-0.07455715537071228,
0.5114482045173645,
0.15022355318069458,
-0.5612867474555969,
-0.2566596269607544,
0.24335822463035583,
0.36588743329048157,
-0.19299188256263733,
0.39652755856513977,
0.09646465629339218,
-0.10823606699705124,
0.3206055760383606,
0.11659332364797592,
-1.041571855545044,
-0.2820850610733032,
-0.3606838881969452,
0.1385822892189026,
-0.09248335659503937,
0.9970178008079529,
-0.786201000213623,
0.6088670492172241,
0.27371734380722046,
0.8588787913322449,
0.5412182211875916,
0.2724435031414032,
0.3314014971256256,
-0.5544887185096741,
0.49057677388191223,
-0.16036199033260345,
0.5208269953727722,
0.7258899211883545,
-0.26560673117637634,
0.8431873321533203,
0.3106207251548767,
-0.34012338519096375,
-0.8297833204269409,
-0.10003962367773056,
-0.7250641584396362,
-0.08298731595277786,
0.3822022080421448,
-0.5459333658218384,
0.03205881640315056,
0.18641996383666992,
-0.20608119666576385,
-0.05056265741586685,
-0.05509344860911369,
0.8088231086730957,
1.1110666990280151,
0.181895449757576,
-0.09308258444070816,
-0.6559969186782837,
0.4545808732509613,
0.27870261669158936,
-0.6649627685546875,
-0.015034972690045834,
0.6060874462127686,
0.34888944029808044,
0.32866454124450684,
0.20709116756916046,
0.11625634133815765,
0.03154527768492699,
0.20236414670944214,
0.1840684413909912,
-0.07914511859416962,
-0.5001266002655029,
-0.2714630365371704,
0.4324893057346344,
-0.2145427018404007,
-0.32629114389419556
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07678v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07678v1
|
MoralBERT: Detecting Moral Values in Social Discourse
| 2024-03-12T14:12:59 | 2024-03-12T14:12:59 |
Vjosa Preniqi, Iacopo Ghinassi, Kyriaki Kalimeri, Charalampos Saitis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Morality plays a fundamental role in how we perceive information while
greatly influencing our decisions and judgements. Controversial topics,
including vaccination, abortion, racism, and sexuality, often elicit opinions
and attitudes that are not solely based on evidence but rather reflect moral
worldviews. Recent advances in natural language processing have demonstrated
that moral values can be gauged in human-generated textual content. Here, we
design a range of language representation models fine-tuned to capture exactly
the moral nuances in text, called MoralBERT. We leverage annotated moral data
from three distinct sources: Twitter, Reddit, and Facebook user-generated
content covering various socially relevant topics. This approach broadens
linguistic diversity and potentially enhances the models' ability to comprehend
morality in various contexts. We also explore a domain adaptation technique and
compare it to the standard fine-tuned BERT model, using two different
frameworks for moral prediction: single-label and multi-label. We compare
in-domain approaches with conventional models relying on lexicon-based
techniques, as well as a Machine Learning classifier with Word2Vec
representation. Our results showed that in-domain prediction models
significantly outperformed traditional models. While the single-label setting
reaches a higher accuracy than previously achieved for the task when using BERT
pretrained models. Experiments in an out-of-domain setting, instead, suggest
that further work is needed for existing domain adaptation techniques to
generalise between different social media platforms, especially for the
multi-label task. The investigations and outcomes from this study pave the way
for further exploration, enabling a more profound comprehension of moral
narratives about controversial social issues.
|
[
-0.28940311074256897,
-0.6782048940658569,
0.5213366150856018,
0.23448020219802856,
-0.48994016647338867,
0.08894912898540497,
-0.08252043277025223,
-0.5327374935150146,
-0.1691126525402069,
0.48480725288391113,
-0.3005110025405884,
-0.6477298140525818,
-0.9441573023796082,
-0.1099591851234436,
-0.03032430075109005,
1.2435896396636963,
0.4211569130420685,
0.10339988023042679,
-0.1993357092142105,
-0.507070779800415,
-0.19619141519069672,
-0.7618457078933716,
-0.7121064066886902,
-0.44103139638900757,
0.6323045492172241,
0.3014402985572815,
0.5944181680679321,
0.22000452876091003,
0.333949476480484,
0.19039100408554077,
-0.4242236614227295,
0.06035691127181053,
-0.878448486328125,
-0.05247132107615471,
-0.5579331517219543,
-0.1767246574163437,
-0.34709614515304565,
0.3743399381637573,
0.21943771839141846,
0.3770911693572998,
0.27835220098495483,
0.3081851005554199,
0.0926559641957283,
0.7649015784263611,
-0.61119145154953,
0.10040297359228134,
-0.6752133965492249,
-0.027118459343910217,
0.15545400977134705,
-0.11762529611587524,
-0.5475314855575562,
-0.9566261172294617,
0.26113617420196533,
-0.37662020325660706,
0.13296590745449066,
-0.20554150640964508,
0.9374197125434875,
-0.08969350159168243,
-0.7456876635551453,
-0.5008316040039062,
-0.4453681707382202,
1.2383390665054321,
-0.5138394236564636,
0.35244661569595337,
0.6864259839057922,
-0.17625029385089874,
0.08534847944974899,
-0.6902022957801819,
-0.46038657426834106,
-0.11154145747423172,
0.01048486027866602,
0.06138226017355919,
-0.2410658448934555,
-0.13373197615146637,
0.04689454287290573,
-0.08705877512693405,
-0.12156012654304504,
-0.2926308810710907,
-0.45448097586631775,
-0.07375768572092056,
0.7822422385215759,
-0.1534900814294815,
0.0797451063990593,
-0.5168955326080322,
-0.32833361625671387,
-0.17540709674358368,
-0.5154584050178528,
0.6243175864219666,
0.5471810698509216,
0.11207173764705658,
-0.004957773722708225,
0.2850286066532135,
0.41176068782806396,
0.3143588900566101,
0.19895903766155243,
0.22302857041358948,
0.13263314962387085,
-0.27129483222961426,
-0.016489338129758835,
0.11757386475801468,
0.6705844402313232,
0.7813816070556641,
0.9605266451835632,
0.6040533185005188,
0.008990989997982979,
0.040457215160131454,
0.4942450225353241,
-0.8292496800422668,
-0.312846302986145,
0.25084754824638367,
-0.7927741408348083,
-0.6181735992431641,
-0.0805056169629097,
-0.4787435233592987,
-0.8175018429756165,
-0.27682891488075256,
-0.1734897643327713,
-0.6444598436355591,
0.04252365604043007,
0.3040221631526947,
-0.24240799248218536,
0.3820556402206421,
0.5553544163703918,
-0.7078399062156677,
-0.08151960372924805,
0.7395459413528442,
0.7890432476997375,
0.024592868983745575,
0.18483157455921173,
-0.6488158702850342,
0.12207285314798355,
-0.29895123839378357,
0.6736853718757629,
-0.822166919708252,
-0.41278794407844543,
0.2077810913324356,
0.22662116587162018,
0.4767531156539917,
-0.12333612143993378,
1.1013715267181396,
-0.4856779873371124,
-0.030403709039092064,
-0.4535793662071228,
-0.6068133115768433,
-0.3431645333766937,
0.2574785053730011,
-0.49758872389793396,
0.6370742917060852,
-0.1714898943901062,
-0.9513354301452637,
0.4086834788322449,
-0.4649556577205658,
-0.49207478761672974,
0.048386335372924805,
-0.04818124324083328,
-0.4940294027328491,
0.14089679718017578,
0.14172586798667908,
0.8093327879905701,
-0.13533450663089752,
0.43097031116485596,
-0.6030081510543823,
-0.3041015863418579,
0.5172524452209473,
-0.34695523977279663,
1.2149077653884888,
-0.011457867920398712,
-0.017625736072659492,
0.06205430626869202,
-0.3104168176651001,
0.008282911963760853,
0.1950283795595169,
-0.16375960409641266,
-0.6870758533477783,
0.33091971278190613,
0.25497719645500183,
0.042064495384693146,
0.2521865665912628,
-0.5736657381057739,
-0.1163160651922226,
-0.27612051367759705,
0.46018919348716736,
1.0152467489242554,
0.11411941051483154,
0.40563181042671204,
-0.4215679168701172,
0.14292354881763458,
-0.23465532064437866,
0.44752806425094604,
0.3296862542629242,
-0.795158326625824,
-0.505949079990387,
-0.010039863176643848,
0.060611624270677567,
0.5378926396369934,
-0.3176247179508209,
0.35681217908859253,
0.08118852227926254,
-0.3757656216621399,
-0.570827305316925,
-0.11505486071109772,
0.30205219984054565,
0.09424607455730438,
0.5197334885597229,
-0.20996534824371338,
-0.20445342361927032,
-0.8905221819877625,
-0.6934056878089905,
-0.5721103549003601,
-0.026494605466723442,
0.5485191345214844,
0.49352365732192993,
-0.2295657992362976,
0.7286334037780762,
-0.5394713878631592,
-0.24470748007297516,
-0.16261950135231018,
0.5319826602935791,
0.19641467928886414,
0.3075941503047943,
0.656587541103363,
-1.1826187372207642,
-0.507185697555542,
0.08587291091680527,
-0.6142045855522156,
-0.038940317928791046,
0.125510573387146,
-0.020525040104985237,
-0.022167768329381943,
0.16090066730976105,
0.07962336391210556,
0.5017929077148438,
0.5180118083953857,
-0.4593503773212433,
0.35710272192955017,
-0.002540809102356434,
0.380115270614624,
-0.7944812178611755,
-0.2928921580314636,
0.13675004243850708,
-0.3685773015022278,
-0.6026268005371094,
-0.5162491798400879,
0.29995036125183105,
0.2879998981952667,
-0.7621271014213562,
0.41165149211883545,
0.1210840716958046,
0.39695122838020325,
-0.0962081030011177,
0.28353655338287354,
0.22622598707675934,
0.1508203148841858,
-0.061189863830804825,
0.6309725046157837,
0.39988186955451965,
-0.5100184082984924,
0.27789318561553955,
0.467617005109787,
-0.01865307055413723,
0.5852003693580627,
-0.7054091691970825,
0.20102933049201965,
-0.4784305989742279,
0.24908038973808289,
-0.7861144542694092,
-0.01879817619919777,
0.352492094039917,
-0.7905316352844238,
-0.22858738899230957,
-0.5976205468177795,
-0.1613742709159851,
-0.006790211424231529,
-0.723606288433075,
0.4508637487888336,
0.44457870721817017,
-0.47234606742858887,
0.4394029676914215,
0.7536970973014832,
-0.43440118432044983,
-0.6983110904693604,
-0.5179738998413086,
-0.06203975901007652,
-0.1798008531332016,
-0.5771804451942444,
0.2955133020877838,
0.051526810973882675,
-0.39541563391685486,
0.05505644530057907,
0.11977078765630722,
-0.2700752913951874,
-0.01031313557177782,
0.22060514986515045,
0.24940113723278046,
0.050731707364320755,
0.5677014589309692,
0.3255479633808136,
0.05361442267894745,
0.21579380333423615,
-0.34477654099464417,
0.34147346019744873,
-0.7666991949081421,
0.04033328592777252,
-0.07779159396886826,
0.3914388120174408,
0.3521387577056885,
-0.29438602924346924,
0.7372357249259949,
0.6673964262008667,
-0.4810801148414612,
-0.21090814471244812,
-0.3708052933216095,
-0.052951935678720474,
-0.4642195999622345,
-0.03538179025053978,
0.27852219343185425,
-0.9958122372627258,
0.23159104585647583,
-0.08885586261749268,
0.20386792719364166,
0.3127164840698242,
0.47234711050987244,
-0.612619936466217,
0.8093656301498413,
0.6693883538246155,
0.21807242929935455,
0.5538410544395447,
-0.14160211384296417,
0.3529908061027527,
-0.5366848111152649,
0.01795964315533638,
-0.445604145526886,
-0.07160646468400955,
-0.82401442527771,
-0.5803118348121643,
0.0878046452999115,
0.13515859842300415,
-0.35232165455818176,
0.3556947708129883,
-0.6884623765945435,
0.5653050541877747,
0.32890433073043823,
0.11168262362480164,
0.3193158507347107,
0.07991037517786026,
0.05340683087706566,
-0.19279372692108154,
-0.21241265535354614,
-1.1649625301361084,
0.9539850950241089,
0.19974230229854584,
0.5991276502609253,
0.1635376662015915,
0.5024746656417847,
0.942872166633606,
0.6493057608604431,
-0.7695551514625549,
0.4218389093875885,
-0.7452616095542908,
-0.7526929378509521,
-0.1898682862520218,
-0.16784879565238953,
-0.9307055473327637,
0.21361954510211945,
-0.2843662202358246,
-0.8901220560073853,
0.5261316895484924,
0.07331985235214233,
-0.2780551016330719,
0.25983452796936035,
-0.5129294395446777,
0.6434918642044067,
-0.4878317713737488,
-0.6283261775970459,
-0.39014095067977905,
-0.6761029958724976,
0.05646972730755806,
-0.18208278715610504,
0.18683315813541412,
-0.6168218851089478,
0.19480106234550476,
0.72080397605896,
0.1709066927433014,
1.0583711862564087,
0.023686712607741356,
-0.1613430678844452,
0.45227497816085815,
-0.16592532396316528,
0.3552749454975128,
0.48504728078842163,
-0.35898786783218384,
0.45079901814460754,
0.23292942345142365,
-0.4461442232131958,
-0.08610048145055771,
0.5712270736694336,
-0.7317984104156494,
-0.4163491725921631,
-0.5546590089797974,
-0.3124282956123352,
-0.21389703452587128,
0.045657701790332794,
0.10267096012830734,
0.16331931948661804,
-0.5985754132270813,
0.4013771712779999,
0.7405076622962952,
-0.7399613857269287,
0.25948888063430786,
0.27613380551338196,
-0.0875212773680687,
-0.45813220739364624,
0.7874011397361755,
-0.1717994064092636,
0.090575210750103,
0.12375972419977188,
0.4230700433254242,
-0.41087788343429565,
-0.09346547722816467,
-0.28660595417022705,
0.3145486116409302,
-1.044777750968933,
-0.11804060637950897,
-0.7956519722938538,
-0.12339196354150772,
-0.266569048166275,
-0.7456115484237671,
-0.4105108678340912,
-0.29871365427970886,
-0.5496364235877991,
-0.1281397044658661,
0.6379882097244263,
0.8415185809135437,
-0.0013946315739303827,
0.1598241776227951,
-1.029893398284912,
0.32126736640930176,
0.2780749797821045,
0.33347249031066895,
-0.3860139846801758,
-0.3661069869995117,
0.15609200298786163,
0.2694629728794098,
-0.4746145009994507,
-0.8909421563148499,
0.3041592240333557,
0.06873108446598053,
0.11271492391824722,
0.4497416019439697,
0.4762117266654968,
0.25499066710472107,
-0.3308407962322235,
0.7060109376907349,
0.22760768234729767,
-1.1470355987548828,
0.7353216409683228,
-0.3177092671394348,
-0.20901930332183838,
0.5740786790847778,
0.6970934867858887,
-0.6148220300674438,
-0.366814523935318,
-0.6713497638702393,
-0.6892220973968506,
0.4957452416419983,
0.5348376631736755,
0.47484540939331055,
-0.10032504051923752,
0.3013313114643097,
0.22551457583904266,
0.16307245194911957,
-0.8194007277488708,
-0.14453290402889252,
-0.5081342458724976,
-0.2290881872177124,
0.024553393945097923,
-0.330173522233963,
-0.19714929163455963,
-0.349286288022995,
0.497774213552475,
-0.19352559745311737,
0.20706917345523834,
0.17795675992965698,
0.023406336084008217,
-0.012285505421459675,
0.38247188925743103,
0.3661786913871765,
0.7737129330635071,
-0.38473042845726013,
0.007634781766682863,
0.1405373066663742,
-0.49483057856559753,
0.1871149092912674,
0.0771283283829689,
-0.05115767940878868,
0.12226364761590958,
0.28533151745796204,
0.4774569571018219,
-0.13590168952941895,
-0.5465534329414368,
0.8730402588844299,
-0.34703707695007324,
-0.10359756648540497,
-0.43357497453689575,
-0.03583163395524025,
0.16795015335083008,
0.4600352346897125,
0.078547902405262,
0.045848410576581955,
0.09644127637147903,
-0.5676978230476379,
0.3819436728954315,
0.2914107143878937,
-0.696750283241272,
-0.2931249439716339,
0.5841932892799377,
0.2992730438709259,
-0.3359719216823578,
0.43787023425102234,
-0.14997391402721405,
-0.6456702351570129,
0.7417522072792053,
0.22125931084156036,
0.8734628558158875,
-0.16086581349372864,
0.7043826580047607,
0.354131817817688,
0.2741664946079254,
0.16830676794052124,
0.4094526171684265,
0.1711488515138626,
-1.078600287437439,
-0.3677533268928528,
-0.584922194480896,
-0.4527522623538971,
-0.002503899857401848,
-0.6386962532997131,
0.2203597128391266,
-0.5194188952445984,
-0.5323544144630432,
0.09990065544843674,
-0.08957140147686005,
-0.4918946325778961,
0.15083257853984833,
0.18026034533977509,
0.40290671586990356,
-0.7106000185012817,
0.8714355826377869,
0.7193424105644226,
-0.2730846703052521,
-0.264493465423584,
0.3120971918106079,
-0.05491172894835472,
-0.6279968023300171,
0.5463483333587646,
0.24173597991466522,
-0.6246113777160645,
-0.18768912553787231,
-0.9399203658103943,
-0.37133848667144775,
0.6799798011779785,
0.30967822670936584,
-0.2961183488368988,
0.3406454920768738,
0.07441883534193039,
0.5430359244346619,
-0.43715208768844604,
-0.20535297691822052,
0.4015583097934723,
0.5199753642082214,
-0.06764362752437592,
-0.2673873007297516,
-0.057823605835437775,
-0.17508473992347717,
-0.13860584795475006,
0.11044111102819443,
-0.3943713307380676,
0.7857549786567688,
-0.37003830075263977,
-0.14412185549736023,
-0.4394046366214752,
0.4259088933467865,
0.34972938895225525,
0.5493853688240051,
0.5558623671531677,
-0.27361223101615906,
0.9934579730033875,
-0.02967497706413269,
0.8930423259735107,
-0.16608138382434845,
0.7801030278205872,
0.8426238894462585,
-0.17755381762981415,
0.5933175086975098,
0.35346144437789917,
0.09283498674631119,
0.34156477451324463,
0.5443348288536072,
-0.11960752308368683,
0.4526655375957489,
0.15824279189109802,
-0.25026458501815796,
-0.4229651689529419,
-0.66276615858078,
-0.22915491461753845,
0.4317384362220764,
0.705325186252594,
-0.5317062139511108,
0.14936427772045135,
-0.13245639204978943,
-0.009635119698941708,
0.08714079111814499,
-0.2958534061908722,
0.6951053142547607,
0.39561688899993896,
-0.33241188526153564,
0.5445801615715027,
0.03523752838373184,
0.45166411995887756,
-0.3122178316116333,
-0.26670053601264954,
0.0363767072558403,
0.23935124278068542,
-0.03497525304555893,
-1.260682463645935,
0.19390550255775452,
0.2616930603981018,
-0.004927889443933964,
-0.6743370890617371,
1.2268325090408325,
-0.23354285955429077,
-0.4847981035709381,
0.7513219118118286,
0.44545748829841614,
-0.003965367563068867,
-0.0065893931314349174,
-0.8056339025497437,
-0.013341602869331837,
0.22324581444263458,
-0.08817890286445618,
-0.10853429138660431,
0.6057277917861938,
-0.22093366086483002,
0.6238868832588196,
0.7903077602386475,
-0.23003293573856354,
-0.17713455855846405,
0.2062423825263977,
0.8603032231330872,
-0.8268117904663086,
-0.28558823466300964,
-0.8281137347221375,
0.5403760671615601,
-0.4241248369216919,
-0.40821248292922974,
0.3766476809978485,
0.09497270733118057,
0.8707135319709778,
0.06581620872020721,
0.8698787689208984,
0.037282105535268784,
0.15554647147655487,
-0.3144810199737549,
0.9378891587257385,
-0.7218025326728821,
0.046327121555805206,
-0.4604645073413849,
-0.4822826683521271,
-0.2781871557235718,
0.9332480430603027,
-0.45804154872894287,
-0.03885740041732788,
0.5138188004493713,
0.3854726254940033,
0.04790154844522476,
0.36744096875190735,
0.326577752828598,
0.18751417100429535,
0.4147978723049164,
0.3432634174823761,
1.1879782676696777,
-0.1905745565891266,
0.5587669610977173,
-0.2006060928106308,
-0.0849715918302536,
-0.29046431183815,
-0.9531944394111633,
-1.0499860048294067,
-0.6073966026306152,
-0.22859147191047668,
-0.43090566992759705,
0.20804689824581146,
0.8007930517196655,
0.4562584459781647,
-0.9317145347595215,
-0.09134262800216675,
0.06210407614707947,
0.3921396732330322,
-0.04338568076491356,
-0.2043067365884781,
0.34903544187545776,
-0.08074164390563965,
-0.6196386814117432,
-0.0207643024623394,
0.33909088373184204,
-0.12063473463058472,
0.29452386498451233,
0.02072070725262165,
-0.4223755896091461,
0.503048300743103,
1.0303573608398438,
-0.2663407027721405,
-0.7322208881378174,
-0.7306732535362244,
-0.14364010095596313,
-0.21196025609970093,
0.10481654852628708,
0.783934473991394,
-0.39788755774497986,
0.3810597062110901,
0.3615038990974426,
0.5786042213439941,
0.30243098735809326,
0.30152103304862976,
0.5067206621170044,
-0.5169174671173096,
-0.20427155494689941,
0.6908128261566162,
0.3620915412902832,
0.36763671040534973,
-0.48864153027534485,
0.4514329731464386,
0.16766168177127838,
-0.5253403186798096,
-0.2797180712223053,
0.556065559387207,
-0.9752195477485657,
-0.4997818171977997,
1.2165296077728271,
-0.1455887407064438,
0.038913071155548096,
-0.5576023459434509,
-0.36805614829063416,
0.3177580237388611,
-0.741884708404541,
0.7472115159034729,
0.7143970727920532,
0.006262034643441439,
0.009849180467426777,
-0.7100645303726196,
0.41713523864746094,
0.3202855885028839,
-0.6325136423110962,
0.3719417154788971,
0.4330768287181854,
0.16410014033317566,
0.05560058355331421,
0.5170480608940125,
-0.08510719239711761,
0.2593991458415985,
-0.5623419880867004,
0.1011420488357544,
0.4192463755607605,
-0.10472501814365387,
-0.13174091279506683,
0.24823115766048431,
-0.25950783491134644,
0.04876391589641571
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07652v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07652v1
|
Harder Tasks Need More Experts: Dynamic Routing in MoE Models
| 2024-03-12T13:41:15 | 2024-03-12T13:41:15 |
Quzhe Huang, Zhenwei An, Nan Zhuang, Mingxu Tao, Chen Zhang, Yang Jin, Kun Xu, Kun Xu, Liwei Chen, Songfang Huang, Yansong Feng
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
In this paper, we introduce a novel dynamic expert selection framework for
Mixture of Experts (MoE) models, aiming to enhance computational efficiency and
model performance by adjusting the number of activated experts based on input
difficulty. Unlike traditional MoE approaches that rely on fixed Top-K routing,
which activates a predetermined number of experts regardless of the input's
complexity, our method dynamically selects experts based on the confidence
level in expert selection for each input. This allows for a more efficient
utilization of computational resources, activating more experts for complex
tasks requiring advanced reasoning and fewer for simpler tasks. Through
extensive evaluations, our dynamic routing method demonstrates substantial
improvements over conventional Top-2 routing across various benchmarks,
achieving an average improvement of 0.7% with less than 90% activated
parameters. Further analysis shows our model dispatches more experts to tasks
requiring complex reasoning skills, like BBH, confirming its ability to
dynamically allocate computational resources in alignment with the input's
complexity. Our findings also highlight a variation in the number of experts
needed across different layers of the transformer model, offering insights into
the potential for designing heterogeneous MoE frameworks. The code and models
are available at https://github.com/ZhenweiAn/Dynamic_MoE.
|
[
-0.5717450976371765,
-0.9086796045303345,
0.6062474250793457,
0.2872593402862549,
-0.005784589797258377,
0.47144049406051636,
-0.14466553926467896,
-0.43905869126319885,
0.016451841220259666,
0.2949282228946686,
-0.75667804479599,
0.05589451640844345,
-0.6761220693588257,
-0.0702638253569603,
-0.20962269604206085,
0.45879337191581726,
0.08589726686477661,
-0.07143953442573547,
-0.36617255210876465,
0.330340176820755,
-0.674259603023529,
0.14808745682239532,
-0.6565999984741211,
-0.6021717190742493,
0.5883937478065491,
0.5491727590560913,
0.8041718602180481,
0.5703855156898499,
0.6725292205810547,
0.44242939352989197,
-0.2576158940792084,
0.2587338089942932,
-0.4051794707775116,
0.6476407647132874,
-0.3615269958972931,
-0.4460432231426239,
-0.7510479092597961,
-0.37446457147598267,
0.26200297474861145,
0.6121530532836914,
-0.4546535313129425,
-0.10820706933736801,
-0.3795202076435089,
0.5699135065078735,
-0.551751434803009,
0.08278316259384155,
-0.9733461141586304,
0.26972371339797974,
-0.2333400696516037,
-0.3340654671192169,
-0.3816387951374054,
0.014311305247247219,
0.4569283425807953,
-0.8787683248519897,
0.3058248460292816,
0.10941662639379501,
0.5342905521392822,
0.7118399143218994,
-0.6772196292877197,
-0.07553461939096451,
-0.7931550741195679,
0.7881423234939575,
-0.42548495531082153,
0.41657915711402893,
0.15605704486370087,
0.6442214846611023,
0.05372612178325653,
-0.6868981122970581,
-0.203411266207695,
-0.02995937503874302,
0.20433309674263,
0.40420016646385193,
-0.10025337338447571,
0.02275838889181614,
0.22174035012722015,
0.36271941661834717,
-0.15933336317539215,
0.3171853721141815,
-0.31167083978652954,
-0.009976048953831196,
0.8813499808311462,
0.28198957443237305,
0.04034034535288811,
0.1171121820807457,
-0.38001736998558044,
0.18733437359333038,
-0.3536657392978668,
0.05337655544281006,
0.628108024597168,
-0.11272696405649185,
0.10793144255876541,
0.08130095899105072,
-0.5564032793045044,
0.5964857935905457,
0.674538254737854,
-0.22555343806743622,
0.24289564788341522,
0.1648201197385788,
0.09163771569728851,
-0.07386881113052368,
0.43002426624298096,
0.20341677963733673,
0.19739733636379242,
-0.40403294563293457,
-0.27737486362457275,
-0.6055428385734558,
0.7365081310272217,
-0.6394771933555603,
-0.8019402623176575,
0.07105450332164764,
-0.2797127664089203,
-0.5117221474647522,
-0.06058685854077339,
-1.1936204433441162,
-0.5044664740562439,
-0.2130657285451889,
0.4427686929702759,
-0.16342656314373016,
-0.7486110925674438,
0.06337787210941315,
-0.1779213845729828,
-0.17124898731708527,
0.6126696467399597,
-0.9498110413551331,
0.17515265941619873,
0.5368303060531616,
0.4496699273586273,
-0.29331305623054504,
-0.12414026260375977,
-0.3462383449077606,
0.4052805006504059,
-0.11735233664512634,
0.7687771916389465,
-0.9785804748535156,
-0.527877688407898,
-0.30413755774497986,
-0.544549286365509,
-0.2569379508495331,
-0.6185088753700256,
0.464320570230484,
-1.0326616764068604,
-0.052754007279872894,
-0.27521848678588867,
-0.2121250331401825,
-0.5198236107826233,
0.22842863202095032,
-0.5846971869468689,
1.1521528959274292,
0.08685297518968582,
-0.5769727826118469,
0.10509670525789261,
-0.6992298364639282,
-0.5918627381324768,
0.07445864379405975,
-0.1550356149673462,
-0.15904563665390015,
0.18218041956424713,
0.2639956474304199,
0.48520898818969727,
-0.2563941776752472,
0.435381680727005,
-0.27880269289016724,
-0.24909280240535736,
0.0655943751335144,
-0.5664554834365845,
0.6062167882919312,
0.38012033700942993,
-0.6483824253082275,
0.23154187202453613,
-0.9859451055526733,
-0.046164970844984055,
0.04572738707065582,
-0.5140965580940247,
-0.09408382326364517,
0.31905171275138855,
-0.21080787479877472,
0.2814662754535675,
0.22676712274551392,
-0.3578408658504486,
0.38542675971984863,
-0.15327216684818268,
0.23836107552051544,
1.0918415784835815,
0.10119511187076569,
0.5316802859306335,
-0.25401103496551514,
0.606713056564331,
0.08123056590557098,
0.10942762345075607,
0.08980163186788559,
-0.7529627680778503,
-0.9056341052055359,
-0.2639288604259491,
0.3400006592273712,
0.8518354892730713,
-1.0252219438552856,
0.42647427320480347,
-0.25805917382240295,
-0.8038802146911621,
-0.4338885247707367,
0.05473610386252403,
0.21429497003555298,
0.5888049006462097,
0.5053427219390869,
-0.058606091886758804,
-0.18860627710819244,
-0.933955192565918,
-0.064787857234478,
-0.000417559698689729,
0.10223626345396042,
0.4422808885574341,
0.12897992134094238,
-0.22868703305721283,
0.9592974781990051,
-0.8157064318656921,
-0.05510149151086807,
-0.15308071672916412,
0.19092416763305664,
0.13856475055217743,
0.6093086004257202,
0.6344954371452332,
-1.0513370037078857,
-0.644903838634491,
0.038115814328193665,
-0.7142570614814758,
-0.23049260675907135,
-0.0769285038113594,
-0.5691140294075012,
-0.441922664642334,
0.2691117525100708,
-0.7648279666900635,
0.1586245447397232,
0.28769949078559875,
-0.14378665387630463,
0.3041263818740845,
-0.048463571816682816,
0.07800973951816559,
-0.8920263648033142,
-0.20934180915355682,
0.10130325704813004,
-0.07471910864114761,
-0.562065601348877,
0.45252710580825806,
-0.21976464986801147,
-0.024961231276392937,
-0.14413118362426758,
0.41352102160453796,
-0.5272795557975769,
0.31408458948135376,
-0.04742303490638733,
-0.38111060857772827,
-0.2017524093389511,
0.8052991032600403,
-0.09361967444419861,
0.5149441361427307,
1.018287181854248,
-0.5821009278297424,
0.8173102140426636,
0.11935801804065704,
-0.37678688764572144,
0.6200845241546631,
-0.5179235935211182,
0.21567870676517487,
0.19798974692821503,
0.19417156279087067,
-0.7463951110839844,
-0.4468224346637726,
0.28563442826271057,
-0.28885331749916077,
0.4509681463241577,
-0.01798918843269348,
-0.4281972348690033,
-0.37554338574409485,
0.17272494733333588,
0.49266430735588074,
0.7656347751617432,
-0.008560174144804478,
1.1646734476089478,
0.3253459334373474,
-0.4250909984111786,
-0.356315016746521,
-0.6844035983085632,
-0.10792231559753418,
0.018898822367191315,
-0.7435929179191589,
0.5714165568351746,
-0.18202897906303406,
-0.20590557157993317,
0.034719984978437424,
-0.2558495104312897,
-0.5278229117393494,
0.579344630241394,
0.14599473774433136,
-0.23790103197097778,
-0.15834975242614746,
-0.14359264075756073,
0.6940383911132812,
-0.3792896270751953,
0.20418211817741394,
-0.03591317683458328,
0.33440104126930237,
0.20428651571273804,
-0.7983109951019287,
-0.6128106713294983,
0.5954744815826416,
0.7688441872596741,
-0.4608970582485199,
0.5794315934181213,
0.9196042418479919,
-0.2727557420730591,
-0.2106609046459198,
-0.8428425192832947,
-0.32563862204551697,
-0.5441873073577881,
0.5422729849815369,
-0.46277692914009094,
-0.6278555393218994,
0.5970566868782043,
-0.3507387340068817,
0.1780880093574524,
0.5052146315574646,
0.7551857233047485,
-0.11791690438985825,
1.0797873735427856,
0.48714640736579895,
0.015859952196478844,
0.3132874369621277,
-0.2122127264738083,
0.49300679564476013,
-0.5121894478797913,
-0.5070457458496094,
-0.26259908080101013,
-0.7241781949996948,
-0.44026991724967957,
-0.455668181180954,
0.7767627239227295,
-0.11295022070407867,
-0.18939727544784546,
-0.33696240186691284,
-0.5446269512176514,
0.1901647448539734,
0.7845118045806885,
0.3221718668937683,
0.17947109043598175,
0.05623030662536621,
-0.29023608565330505,
0.3375241756439209,
-1.1194334030151367,
-0.06196851283311844,
0.6094520092010498,
0.35153162479400635,
0.6120924353599548,
0.22018663585186005,
0.2570040225982666,
0.4453422725200653,
0.06814517080783844,
-0.5973135232925415,
0.8413876891136169,
0.16876450181007385,
-0.9307390451431274,
-0.33437225222587585,
-0.45801806449890137,
-0.6366311311721802,
0.13883866369724274,
-0.45892882347106934,
-0.44755643606185913,
0.37573155760765076,
0.40413379669189453,
-0.8025421500205994,
0.7996690273284912,
-0.46850475668907166,
0.23329555988311768,
-0.2559853792190552,
-0.45289939641952515,
-0.536532998085022,
-0.7247832417488098,
0.17363156378269196,
-0.35088181495666504,
-0.011383002623915672,
-0.14767585694789886,
0.014601226896047592,
0.5168874859809875,
-0.3032209277153015,
0.6108220815658569,
-0.39026352763175964,
-0.017698194831609726,
0.29453980922698975,
0.163810133934021,
0.5830318331718445,
-0.0572190061211586,
-0.8181665539741516,
0.186065673828125,
-0.6789073944091797,
-0.36914995312690735,
-0.5727503299713135,
0.6203352808952332,
-0.8349218964576721,
-0.7330155372619629,
-0.03824124112725258,
-0.7972019910812378,
-0.35639211535453796,
0.2982328534126282,
0.3824082612991333,
0.5462231040000916,
0.48379746079444885,
0.635030210018158,
0.955677330493927,
0.034563157707452774,
0.34398573637008667,
0.32740461826324463,
0.37571725249290466,
-0.3953470289707184,
0.8243700861930847,
0.392275869846344,
-0.04252448305487633,
0.5550398826599121,
0.06368260830640793,
0.14594094455242157,
-0.9123920202255249,
-0.6462074518203735,
-0.4070572555065155,
-0.36975473165512085,
-0.17490920424461365,
-0.925239622592926,
-0.14018411934375763,
-0.1147579476237297,
-0.36793890595436096,
-0.6870304942131042,
-0.23521994054317474,
-0.2717370092868805,
-0.11453209072351456,
0.40108269453048706,
0.5317081809043884,
0.22954252362251282,
0.6523647904396057,
-0.6902656555175781,
0.31113308668136597,
0.6596923470497131,
0.5264279246330261,
0.6698970198631287,
-0.4157392680644989,
-0.46421825885772705,
-0.07678478956222534,
-0.7569069862365723,
-0.8631873726844788,
-0.05220310389995575,
-0.036013588309288025,
1.1208124160766602,
0.6406198740005493,
0.3979208767414093,
0.5843210816383362,
-0.7261428833007812,
0.5994320511817932,
0.1121046394109726,
-0.7679283618927002,
0.16655634343624115,
-0.7534142732620239,
0.07214558869600296,
0.43069785833358765,
0.39911144971847534,
0.14051148295402527,
-0.27273547649383545,
-0.6318166851997375,
-1.0445259809494019,
0.6235226392745972,
0.44810760021209717,
0.15692350268363953,
0.30845415592193604,
0.16309787333011627,
0.36667031049728394,
0.38832172751426697,
-0.18847393989562988,
-0.2889624238014221,
0.0748608410358429,
-0.24885937571525574,
0.563292920589447,
-0.42240238189697266,
-0.11808044463396072,
-0.5102081894874573,
0.7457621097564697,
0.1666719913482666,
0.6428224444389343,
-0.0899878442287445,
0.12048853933811188,
-0.4475163221359253,
-0.07379267364740372,
0.48920318484306335,
1.0761739015579224,
-0.22561311721801758,
-0.209944486618042,
0.4646171033382416,
-0.25106367468833923,
0.005894748959690332,
0.25180670619010925,
-0.2616974711418152,
-0.022250544279813766,
0.3877827823162079,
1.0733363628387451,
0.4741048812866211,
-0.31105953454971313,
0.3028407394886017,
0.44664227962493896,
-0.435235857963562,
-0.2653612494468689,
0.739896833896637,
-0.068787582218647,
0.5690966844558716,
0.8972054123878479,
0.6315738558769226,
0.036047615110874176,
0.06986421346664429,
0.043207138776779175,
0.048485059291124344,
-0.07681770622730255,
-0.2841305732727051,
0.8361339569091797,
0.9221428036689758,
-0.6618719100952148,
0.575039267539978,
-0.1684088110923767,
-0.592252790927887,
0.6397964954376221,
-0.10231368988752365,
0.8003236055374146,
-0.43346768617630005,
-0.1154852956533432,
-0.026869459077715874,
0.1349688172340393,
-0.06370967626571655,
-0.029275372624397278,
-0.05984445661306381,
-0.5547205209732056,
-0.3939603865146637,
-0.22693955898284912,
-0.6378229260444641,
-0.3162507116794586,
-0.7575483322143555,
0.2623402178287506,
-0.3086332082748413,
-0.361127644777298,
-0.3103264570236206,
-0.16692371666431427,
-0.7723821401596069,
0.4458957016468048,
-0.0015545792412012815,
0.9111096858978271,
-0.6157591938972473,
0.5029295682907104,
1.0863574743270874,
0.19232960045337677,
-0.6606585383415222,
0.0828767865896225,
-0.09276636689901352,
-0.5279212594032288,
0.3441384732723236,
-0.15832208096981049,
-0.058041732758283615,
0.32260406017303467,
-0.3009827136993408,
-0.7609937787055969,
1.2281838655471802,
0.17213121056556702,
-0.47146227955818176,
-0.31877538561820984,
-0.2974603474140167,
0.39952173829078674,
-0.1781327873468399,
0.6876996159553528,
-0.09299466758966446,
0.6166553497314453,
0.2539985477924347,
-0.9147564172744751,
-0.2618420422077179,
-0.5054700374603271,
-0.09955087304115295,
-0.03541989624500275,
-0.9988527894020081,
0.9977609515190125,
0.00016312225488945842,
0.47670796513557434,
-0.09113477915525436,
0.9332465529441833,
0.3579409122467041,
0.595177412033081,
0.9566860795021057,
0.4469294548034668,
0.9355270266532898,
0.03211083635687828,
0.7150445580482483,
-0.3677319586277008,
0.28122562170028687,
0.6669081449508667,
-0.18394511938095093,
0.5356190204620361,
0.2390737384557724,
-0.11946799606084824,
0.8122013211250305,
0.8001083135604858,
-0.08041362464427948,
0.7653332948684692,
0.0725589469075203,
-0.17341507971286774,
-0.7397299408912659,
0.33011868596076965,
-0.5633261203765869,
0.33367857336997986,
0.12432484328746796,
-0.12617667019367218,
-0.19180923700332642,
0.07384141534566879,
0.11148832738399506,
-0.21942251920700073,
-0.44228997826576233,
0.5110403299331665,
-0.2738460600376129,
-0.7064300775527954,
0.1975553333759308,
0.1471056342124939,
0.685258686542511,
-0.5691303014755249,
0.05630384385585785,
-0.032154861837625504,
-0.02195926383137703,
-0.3018803000450134,
-0.7641893625259399,
0.034018028527498245,
0.033048149198293686,
-0.5953291654586792,
-0.4312798082828522,
0.8172528147697449,
-0.23196697235107422,
-0.8002803921699524,
0.05689115449786186,
0.6184065937995911,
0.02388991415500641,
-0.18809156119823456,
-0.6922965049743652,
-0.20344939827919006,
0.07410576194524765,
-0.7541062235832214,
0.13465456664562225,
0.765787661075592,
0.010570970363914967,
1.0337775945663452,
0.5775641798973083,
-0.027750814333558083,
0.3331007957458496,
-0.25695347785949707,
1.0182546377182007,
-0.30805131793022156,
-0.6609972715377808,
-0.6045753359794617,
0.9713339805603027,
-0.2574474513530731,
-0.2840045988559723,
0.43758589029312134,
0.18813727796077728,
0.8080908060073853,
-0.3497368097305298,
0.723739504814148,
-0.06698903441429138,
0.47764894366264343,
-0.4363926649093628,
0.8133643269538879,
-0.768250584602356,
0.3444753587245941,
-0.3296867907047272,
-0.8306339383125305,
0.09354210644960403,
0.5852614045143127,
-0.3794229030609131,
0.3775530457496643,
0.3615674674510956,
0.5550909042358398,
-0.4977414309978485,
-0.040736861526966095,
0.09788625687360764,
0.2881659269332886,
0.40077561140060425,
0.5280301570892334,
0.7123792171478271,
0.1287534385919571,
0.36374202370643616,
-0.5222195982933044,
-0.17628169059753418,
-0.69219970703125,
-0.9577962160110474,
-0.6707587242126465,
-0.2670958638191223,
-0.6039106845855713,
0.2336762696504593,
-0.08784318715333939,
1.0073745250701904,
1.1148308515548706,
-0.5599514842033386,
0.026944223791360855,
0.035270389169454575,
0.39165517687797546,
-0.4435670077800751,
-0.2117631882429123,
-0.003927298355847597,
-0.08243897557258606,
-0.7907301187515259,
0.47201216220855713,
0.16389253735542297,
-0.5556395649909973,
-0.24099068343639374,
-0.058577392250299454,
-0.2149830013513565,
0.11362385004758835,
0.5608938932418823,
-0.31544816493988037,
-0.6239826679229736,
-0.03774647414684296,
0.025462836027145386,
0.10661033540964127,
-0.06217748299241066,
0.5685111880302429,
-0.5881875157356262,
0.48145467042922974,
0.8182687759399414,
0.9995099306106567,
0.17235608398914337,
0.13686147332191467,
0.5677544474601746,
-0.3499249219894409,
-0.04576527699828148,
0.2655150890350342,
0.2235765904188156,
-0.026926694437861443,
-0.6362027525901794,
0.5774058103561401,
0.7813610434532166,
-0.5813408493995667,
-0.9366323947906494,
0.1661052405834198,
-1.2097352743148804,
-0.1787242740392685,
1.0742956399917603,
-0.09100280702114105,
0.31106695532798767,
-0.1609383523464203,
-0.19585464894771576,
0.2540217339992523,
-0.5879202485084534,
0.7789722681045532,
0.7864261269569397,
-0.32660603523254395,
-0.2814340591430664,
-0.8268703818321228,
-0.028189346194267273,
0.6132622361183167,
-0.4552238881587982,
-0.5910689830780029,
0.19798438251018524,
0.15701179206371307,
0.1817978322505951,
0.28548696637153625,
0.48712632060050964,
0.08610857278108597,
-0.20570357143878937,
-0.05268062651157379,
-0.7287323474884033,
-0.6146617531776428,
0.35968902707099915,
0.5425906777381897,
-0.18671002984046936,
-0.05562322959303856
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07581v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07581v1
|
LLMvsSmall Model? Large Language Model Based Text Augmentation Enhanced Personality Detection Model
| 2024-03-12T12:10:18 | 2024-03-12T12:10:18 |
Linmei Hu, Hongyu He, Duokang Wang, Ziwang Zhao, Yingxia Shao, Liqiang Nie
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Personality detection aims to detect one's personality traits underlying in
social media posts. One challenge of this task is the scarcity of ground-truth
personality traits which are collected from self-report questionnaires. Most
existing methods learn post features directly by fine-tuning the pre-trained
language models under the supervision of limited personality labels. This leads
to inferior quality of post features and consequently affects the performance.
In addition, they treat personality traits as one-hot classification labels,
overlooking the semantic information within them. In this paper, we propose a
large language model (LLM) based text augmentation enhanced personality
detection model, which distills the LLM's knowledge to enhance the small model
for personality detection, even when the LLM fails in this task. Specifically,
we enable LLM to generate post analyses (augmentations) from the aspects of
semantic, sentiment, and linguistic, which are critical for personality
detection. By using contrastive learning to pull them together in the embedding
space, the post encoder can better capture the psycho-linguistic information
within the post representations, thus improving personality detection.
Furthermore, we utilize the LLM to enrich the information of personality labels
for enhancing the detection performance. Experimental results on the benchmark
datasets demonstrate that our model outperforms the state-of-the-art methods on
personality detection.
|
[
-0.5295877456665039,
-0.7589665055274963,
0.7262240648269653,
0.2574409246444702,
-0.36371204257011414,
-0.07329703122377396,
-0.351126104593277,
-0.47417861223220825,
0.42305949330329895,
0.6964592337608337,
-0.8402518630027771,
-0.6630552411079407,
-0.7554490566253662,
0.08241252601146698,
-0.1139395609498024,
0.8987810611724854,
0.18084633350372314,
0.05033480376005173,
-0.3631492853164673,
-0.031860772520303726,
-0.21304307878017426,
-0.7303707003593445,
-0.529693603515625,
-0.4588612914085388,
0.5575246810913086,
0.2597941756248474,
0.29152119159698486,
0.26727813482284546,
0.45294126868247986,
0.30790919065475464,
-0.32677677273750305,
0.38178345561027527,
-0.6466206312179565,
0.08459325134754181,
-0.2567787766456604,
-0.2593883275985718,
-0.6389868855476379,
-0.16098687052726746,
0.5592450499534607,
0.2716992199420929,
0.10383722186088562,
0.130079984664917,
0.04322987049818039,
0.5660579800605774,
-0.440520316362381,
0.09001167118549347,
-0.5516536831855774,
-0.06456900388002396,
-0.19617687165737152,
-0.09603540599346161,
-0.24616968631744385,
-0.38762593269348145,
-0.0019310533534735441,
-0.05334491655230522,
-0.0345730297267437,
-0.05405006185173988,
0.3879631757736206,
0.0953453853726387,
-0.463205486536026,
-0.2473183274269104,
-0.6893138885498047,
0.7222933173179626,
-0.7115397453308105,
0.29450446367263794,
0.44690343737602234,
0.23978638648986816,
0.09627246111631393,
-0.13454250991344452,
-0.6962527632713318,
-0.23453454673290253,
-0.12543779611587524,
-0.02122613973915577,
-0.006455245893448591,
-0.14430482685565948,
0.12321474403142929,
0.5046424269676208,
-0.5710792541503906,
0.26476386189460754,
0.08218050748109818,
0.031225696206092834,
0.7320597171783447,
0.1633433699607849,
0.021400567144155502,
-0.2238304615020752,
-0.10284081846475601,
-0.061545394361019135,
-0.5117091536521912,
-0.13804322481155396,
0.6920936703681946,
0.051322486251592636,
-0.210486501455307,
0.5224407911300659,
-0.2637711465358734,
0.40339457988739014,
0.3712359070777893,
-0.30868232250213623,
0.43789079785346985,
-0.06035083159804344,
0.07208597660064697,
-0.13985231518745422,
0.7622002959251404,
0.26221269369125366,
0.4639278054237366,
0.08093871921300888,
-0.3212164640426636,
0.06766214966773987,
0.10851773619651794,
-1.10057532787323,
-0.34428131580352783,
0.3496406376361847,
-0.58488929271698,
-0.5376164317131042,
-0.06813985854387283,
-0.7153226733207703,
-0.6799642443656921,
-0.1986672729253769,
0.18869005143642426,
-0.6495169401168823,
-0.6026520729064941,
-0.031159643083810806,
0.25475001335144043,
0.2972906231880188,
0.3102182149887085,
-0.9404377341270447,
0.0344550684094429,
0.67665696144104,
0.6528385281562805,
-0.323055237531662,
-0.03969790041446686,
-0.4401929974555969,
-0.16791488230228424,
-0.05187049135565758,
1.030649185180664,
-0.7241374850273132,
-0.473310649394989,
0.12992225587368011,
-0.07104583829641342,
0.28496691584587097,
-0.4671150743961334,
0.5341449975967407,
-0.4301905930042267,
-0.055016979575157166,
-0.43654707074165344,
-0.6863625049591064,
0.07151660323143005,
0.3788592517375946,
-0.45878344774246216,
0.9405772686004639,
0.20863376557826996,
-0.8024003505706787,
0.2266683131456375,
-0.5353941917419434,
-0.3372403383255005,
0.21661080420017242,
-0.024707207456231117,
-0.6157031059265137,
-0.0029033857863396406,
0.41884645819664,
0.83272385597229,
-0.010023086331784725,
0.3642752170562744,
-0.5837381482124329,
-0.3573259711265564,
0.5777057409286499,
-0.16438430547714233,
0.3916386663913727,
-0.038057416677474976,
0.24660928547382355,
0.3328166604042053,
-0.7257163524627686,
-0.26785269379615784,
0.18992064893245697,
-0.49879026412963867,
-0.384218692779541,
0.05869298428297043,
0.18359315395355225,
0.31588342785835266,
0.5176979303359985,
-0.8457661271095276,
0.10074885934591293,
-0.37631842494010925,
0.07372642308473587,
0.6631578207015991,
0.03012586385011673,
0.39441192150115967,
-0.24558129906654358,
0.3031908869743347,
0.16614146530628204,
0.013829231262207031,
-0.12817148864269257,
-0.26735639572143555,
-0.4936703145503998,
-0.5659276843070984,
-0.034757666289806366,
0.6688807606697083,
-0.606513500213623,
1.1754775047302246,
-0.22734330594539642,
-0.6348493099212646,
-0.4619670808315277,
0.4241974353790283,
0.4082092344760895,
0.35743728280067444,
0.2971128523349762,
-0.17127054929733276,
-0.7394272685050964,
-0.8022171258926392,
-0.5179259777069092,
0.05842508748173714,
-0.14622440934181213,
0.2900083065032959,
0.5254617929458618,
-0.4876290559768677,
0.696636974811554,
-0.6263720393180847,
-0.18260836601257324,
-0.5592327117919922,
-0.011705485172569752,
0.12176567316055298,
0.30207836627960205,
0.45911461114883423,
-0.8198751211166382,
-0.541015088558197,
-0.13593073189258575,
-0.7700017094612122,
-0.2589717209339142,
0.252013623714447,
0.08592918515205383,
-0.005178061313927174,
0.45092299580574036,
-0.4412706196308136,
0.2123473584651947,
0.4455401599407196,
-0.37975093722343445,
0.7025700211524963,
0.0677628293633461,
-0.002685176907107234,
-1.0433106422424316,
-0.0779053270816803,
0.48900988698005676,
-0.40303298830986023,
-0.5373308658599854,
0.054725173860788345,
0.11935631185770035,
-0.035546425729990005,
-0.3422400653362274,
0.6182276010513306,
-0.21578678488731384,
0.060659974813461304,
-0.5487084984779358,
0.0063328430987894535,
-0.08928219228982925,
0.541028618812561,
0.1789783090353012,
0.5723543167114258,
0.4222012460231781,
-0.5416243076324463,
0.4055255055427551,
0.3155484199523926,
-0.2779741883277893,
1.0795055627822876,
-0.5618075728416443,
0.26829642057418823,
-0.48674026131629944,
0.24750442802906036,
-1.1617220640182495,
-0.3820421099662781,
-0.054430268704891205,
-0.5755200982093811,
0.40177980065345764,
-0.011849253438413143,
-0.5657304525375366,
-0.38257697224617004,
-0.47436609864234924,
-0.06974746286869049,
0.5054854154586792,
-0.7430212497711182,
0.6813231706619263,
0.24309562146663666,
-0.27420535683631897,
-0.14162501692771912,
-0.6016758680343628,
-0.18147814273834229,
-0.2047261893749237,
-0.6731603145599365,
0.4442071318626404,
-0.22886095941066742,
-0.15081657469272614,
-0.09079337865114212,
0.2382311075925827,
-0.025384435430169106,
-0.11984168738126755,
0.07881410419940948,
0.2927273213863373,
-0.11032867431640625,
0.33010056614875793,
-0.00946391187608242,
-0.037037745118141174,
-0.01229115854948759,
0.12228190898895264,
0.8106054663658142,
-0.22610469162464142,
-0.12910020351409912,
-0.40464282035827637,
0.3570094108581543,
0.49468275904655457,
-0.31116220355033875,
1.011487603187561,
0.9891761541366577,
-0.23795866966247559,
-0.11340991407632828,
-0.7917079925537109,
-0.3669491112232208,
-0.5413525104522705,
0.6543816924095154,
-0.35021328926086426,
-1.1925077438354492,
0.47391486167907715,
-0.2131352722644806,
-0.28594711422920227,
0.2029304951429367,
0.5619452595710754,
-0.10338924080133438,
1.0311235189437866,
0.7997352480888367,
-0.005859340075403452,
0.6906730532646179,
0.16591207683086395,
0.2417028397321701,
-1.0879631042480469,
-0.11281075328588486,
-0.08639845997095108,
-0.10425569862127304,
-0.6236934661865234,
-0.25743940472602844,
0.17418085038661957,
-0.25059592723846436,
-0.2852123975753784,
0.2774859368801117,
-0.5583948493003845,
0.38135606050491333,
0.08658905327320099,
0.5811348557472229,
0.23935845494270325,
-0.10647211223840714,
0.24477648735046387,
-0.42807531356811523,
0.00019810271624010056,
-0.4868406355381012,
1.1585859060287476,
0.5688201189041138,
0.7146283984184265,
0.22837939858436584,
0.7024164199829102,
0.3136926591396332,
0.6254913210868835,
-0.8555627465248108,
0.6714940667152405,
-0.42366287112236023,
-0.32988518476486206,
-0.09497816115617752,
-0.4123571217060089,
-0.30633994936943054,
0.24844063818454742,
-0.6333481073379517,
-0.8122151494026184,
0.011567964218556881,
0.10576853901147842,
-0.1100558415055275,
0.20489472150802612,
-0.6459072232246399,
0.692108154296875,
-0.20541071891784668,
-0.36691033840179443,
-0.11493557691574097,
-0.3850838840007782,
0.6384470462799072,
-0.3270111382007599,
-0.0006577824824489653,
-0.10235941410064697,
0.12120186537504196,
0.5759721398353577,
-0.2988794147968292,
0.8396870493888855,
-0.19009113311767578,
-0.13029217720031738,
-0.10712935775518417,
0.013232559897005558,
0.7195220589637756,
-0.09991450607776642,
-0.2779785394668579,
0.06949101388454437,
-0.2136106938123703,
-0.13467846810817719,
-0.5384196639060974,
0.8831656575202942,
-0.7292792797088623,
-0.3780128061771393,
-0.030901595950126648,
-0.41605812311172485,
-0.3791990280151367,
-0.03161212056875229,
0.11350587010383606,
0.22324822843074799,
-0.5092776417732239,
0.2801159918308258,
0.9407075047492981,
-0.5027175545692444,
0.1599324494600296,
0.6439735889434814,
-0.5117542147636414,
-0.31921184062957764,
0.8571033477783203,
-0.13532932102680206,
0.038185618817806244,
0.3335881233215332,
0.23918510973453522,
-0.3628533184528351,
-0.4558878242969513,
0.10728352516889572,
0.5001933574676514,
-0.7557158470153809,
0.0882476419210434,
-0.9640941619873047,
-0.24352996051311493,
-0.6875974535942078,
-0.16498109698295593,
-0.45015841722488403,
0.19317437708377838,
-0.2053842544555664,
-0.03315756097435951,
0.606323778629303,
0.6634975075721741,
0.14544132351875305,
0.7054495215415955,
-0.54053795337677,
0.4814460277557373,
0.3550563156604767,
0.2720569968223572,
0.0065470850095152855,
-0.6875583529472351,
0.07547205686569214,
-0.2541651725769043,
-0.48164698481559753,
-0.9184308052062988,
0.6560508608818054,
0.05971939116716385,
0.27269619703292847,
0.7332574129104614,
-0.3086143732070923,
0.3374604880809784,
-0.21136416494846344,
0.40686652064323425,
0.115142822265625,
-0.7971200346946716,
0.7214531898498535,
-0.4485424757003784,
0.29149869084358215,
0.475553423166275,
0.4432370960712433,
-0.4222900867462158,
-0.24263466894626617,
-0.2960226833820343,
-0.5632415413856506,
0.38433459401130676,
0.09825105220079422,
0.27556970715522766,
-0.10818920284509659,
0.6236586570739746,
0.02218962274491787,
0.27692097425460815,
-1.018230676651001,
-0.11543924361467361,
-0.1012483462691307,
-0.5112226009368896,
-0.022244136780500412,
-0.47258704900741577,
0.42326468229293823,
-0.583592414855957,
0.6353747248649597,
-0.14596371352672577,
0.3360704779624939,
0.09716454148292542,
0.014198757708072662,
0.14241227507591248,
0.2880440652370453,
0.27588585019111633,
0.2556702196598053,
-0.43272462487220764,
-0.07860874384641647,
0.20016798377037048,
-0.4370545744895935,
-0.12988977134227753,
0.12707480788230896,
-0.021032271906733513,
-0.2097017914056778,
0.25592541694641113,
0.8325480222702026,
0.1643688678741455,
-0.5881645679473877,
0.7445936799049377,
0.05642994865775108,
-0.04314614459872246,
-0.512485146522522,
0.11643673479557037,
0.41351887583732605,
0.2061033546924591,
0.30219292640686035,
-0.1041838675737381,
0.08095375448465347,
-0.5940366983413696,
0.16728965938091278,
0.6147432327270508,
-0.49932998418807983,
-0.3019048869609833,
0.2670544683933258,
0.2255864441394806,
-0.3733178675174713,
0.1844668984413147,
-0.4591570198535919,
-0.7369903326034546,
0.5507189631462097,
0.5744912624359131,
0.7241974472999573,
-0.5947874784469604,
0.25396496057510376,
0.35442259907722473,
0.16585859656333923,
0.014774086885154247,
0.41293564438819885,
-0.04865984246134758,
-1.0249111652374268,
-0.4507156014442444,
-0.9385362863540649,
-0.39980146288871765,
0.5070452690124512,
-0.3536796569824219,
0.3893100321292877,
-0.6471145153045654,
0.09890277683734894,
0.0431952141225338,
0.014866475015878677,
-0.7117289900779724,
0.14284838736057281,
0.30249473452568054,
0.5671654343605042,
-0.8667495250701904,
0.8223893046379089,
0.6818684339523315,
-0.11259236931800842,
-0.3678651750087738,
0.1366700977087021,
0.2309466153383255,
-0.7680729627609253,
0.5478479266166687,
0.5270195603370667,
-0.14355401694774628,
0.0554952397942543,
-0.6790207624435425,
-0.6601352095603943,
0.849389910697937,
0.259561151266098,
-0.5693660378456116,
0.19802527129650116,
-0.10940717905759811,
0.7794569730758667,
-0.6979144215583801,
0.30076879262924194,
0.5252116918563843,
0.4266507029533386,
0.2925494313240051,
-0.5044676065444946,
0.1272447109222412,
-0.29197728633880615,
0.13338075578212738,
0.07244061678647995,
-0.5661099553108215,
0.9259878396987915,
-0.029253605753183365,
0.10963936150074005,
-0.025247180834412575,
0.7616687417030334,
0.4114537537097931,
0.051497384905815125,
0.3929985761642456,
0.5967249870300293,
0.6687374114990234,
0.10829540342092514,
1.0475425720214844,
-0.2361028641462326,
0.2898024618625641,
1.0448756217956543,
-0.5060180425643921,
0.9776635766029358,
0.1910369098186493,
-0.1490318924188614,
0.8248729109764099,
0.5903341770172119,
-0.20412053167819977,
0.46816107630729675,
0.05439189448952675,
-0.4682813286781311,
-0.41555291414260864,
-0.22034326195716858,
-0.08676807582378387,
0.5268694758415222,
0.5919545888900757,
-0.5585238337516785,
-0.011950423941016197,
0.23821000754833221,
0.04282595217227936,
0.32692766189575195,
-0.44733646512031555,
0.7810081243515015,
-0.052203599363565445,
-0.40435174107551575,
0.24398940801620483,
0.10725175589323044,
1.4129036664962769,
-0.5505360960960388,
0.1542937308549881,
-0.1040964424610138,
0.362591952085495,
-0.35497647523880005,
-0.9458460807800293,
0.5044788122177124,
0.0013971623266115785,
-0.1535099893808365,
-0.16394482553005219,
1.3337939977645874,
-0.5357552766799927,
-0.606837809085846,
0.5086554884910583,
0.49666765332221985,
0.04681747406721115,
-0.5266439914703369,
-0.5484808683395386,
-0.037536393851041794,
-0.29128801822662354,
-0.23828931152820587,
0.35276007652282715,
0.29441699385643005,
0.29585573077201843,
0.6352705359458923,
0.6373909711837769,
0.11522898077964783,
-0.45462149381637573,
0.1274758130311966,
0.9352670311927795,
-0.5711495280265808,
-0.6948680281639099,
-1.1274495124816895,
0.24876044690608978,
-0.46448901295661926,
-0.19493408501148224,
0.7923467755317688,
0.22093984484672546,
0.4869515895843506,
-0.18047572672367096,
0.7441501617431641,
0.20247511565685272,
0.8219320178031921,
-0.3471481502056122,
0.7379533052444458,
-0.4474690556526184,
0.15119707584381104,
-0.5010517239570618,
-0.8705598711967468,
-0.033897802233695984,
0.5815655589103699,
-0.649475634098053,
0.3318077325820923,
0.5862470865249634,
0.9803091287612915,
-0.08942238241434097,
-0.06665821373462677,
0.46384698152542114,
0.3147852122783661,
0.1106254905462265,
0.6024194359779358,
0.608767569065094,
-0.12209007143974304,
0.23899637162685394,
-0.08834659308195114,
-0.39933350682258606,
-0.39327624440193176,
-0.6537129878997803,
-1.454312801361084,
-0.36969783902168274,
-0.3022606372833252,
-0.4577598571777344,
-0.1566942185163498,
0.779630720615387,
0.5889452695846558,
-0.5626001954078674,
0.23655195534229279,
-0.05774454027414322,
0.1226266473531723,
0.1944267451763153,
-0.3226335346698761,
0.10866323113441467,
0.1560923159122467,
-0.48997068405151367,
0.1642819195985794,
0.31030362844467163,
-0.012878338806331158,
-0.6782739162445068,
-0.07089778780937195,
-0.20691099762916565,
0.23815838992595673,
0.9137911200523376,
0.04124700650572777,
-0.5332719087600708,
-0.3945910930633545,
0.01316251140087843,
-0.08659134060144424,
0.12908773124217987,
0.5987012982368469,
-0.5018741488456726,
0.14174292981624603,
0.35596007108688354,
0.5210296511650085,
0.6263036131858826,
0.08188724517822266,
0.12568125128746033,
-1.0322188138961792,
0.1545899361371994,
0.10718245804309845,
0.40418457984924316,
0.8682127594947815,
-0.8597041368484497,
0.09890235215425491,
0.27307721972465515,
-0.43458592891693115,
-0.4507061541080475,
0.5062836408615112,
-0.9511594176292419,
-0.3322022557258606,
1.3691107034683228,
-0.06076708063483238,
-0.3426530361175537,
-0.24751725792884827,
-0.27378353476524353,
0.06061643362045288,
-0.44617700576782227,
0.7587241530418396,
0.7856915593147278,
-0.18442557752132416,
-0.43950527906417847,
-0.22570009529590607,
0.34963175654411316,
0.1334182769060135,
-1.0640054941177368,
-0.03624039515852928,
0.3865530490875244,
0.4927173852920532,
0.11001753062009811,
0.8605073094367981,
-0.19582724571228027,
0.0395253524184227,
-0.30654242634773254,
0.29404059052467346,
-0.0035653512459248304,
0.02857385203242302,
-0.4014625549316406,
0.14160875976085663,
-0.10281649976968765,
0.19339215755462646
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07567v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07567v1
|
Triples-to-isiXhosa (T2X): Addressing the Challenges of Low-Resource Agglutinative Data-to-Text Generation
| 2024-03-12T11:53:27 | 2024-03-12T11:53:27 |
Francois Meyer, Jan Buys
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Most data-to-text datasets are for English, so the difficulties of modelling
data-to-text for low-resource languages are largely unexplored. In this paper
we tackle data-to-text for isiXhosa, which is low-resource and agglutinative.
We introduce Triples-to-isiXhosa (T2X), a new dataset based on a subset of
WebNLG, which presents a new linguistic context that shifts modelling demands
to subword-driven techniques. We also develop an evaluation framework for T2X
that measures how accurately generated text describes the data. This enables
future users of T2X to go beyond surface-level metrics in evaluation. On the
modelling side we explore two classes of methods - dedicated data-to-text
models trained from scratch and pretrained language models (PLMs). We propose a
new dedicated architecture aimed at agglutinative data-to-text, the Subword
Segmental Pointer Generator (SSPG). It jointly learns to segment words and copy
entities, and outperforms existing dedicated models for 2 agglutinative
languages (isiXhosa and Finnish). We investigate pretrained solutions for T2X,
which reveals that standard PLMs come up short. Fine-tuning machine translation
models emerges as the best method overall. These findings underscore the
distinct challenge presented by T2X: neither well-established data-to-text
architectures nor customary pretrained methodologies prove optimal. We conclude
with a qualitative analysis of generation errors and an ablation study.
|
[
-0.060882117599248886,
-0.5238732099533081,
0.5170845985412598,
0.4976665675640106,
-0.6408524513244629,
0.3206397593021393,
-0.20255593955516815,
-0.3691941201686859,
0.08209823817014694,
0.5006341338157654,
-0.3351175785064697,
-0.4261687695980072,
-0.8245415091514587,
0.2703976333141327,
-0.6146077513694763,
1.0459177494049072,
-0.09310884028673172,
-0.16137465834617615,
-0.16815122961997986,
-0.17435088753700256,
-0.21524260938167572,
-0.6552826166152954,
-0.7574643492698669,
-0.23639461398124695,
0.15788280963897705,
0.6254344582557678,
0.8208767175674438,
0.8279637694358826,
0.06144468113780022,
0.1363667994737625,
0.032826319336891174,
0.2533341348171234,
-0.5332627296447754,
-0.19953066110610962,
-0.2448819875717163,
-0.34586000442504883,
-0.2299526035785675,
0.02168627455830574,
0.7437586784362793,
0.7528372406959534,
-0.13313522934913635,
0.3146055042743683,
0.06155252084136009,
0.7713392376899719,
-0.4851601719856262,
0.1598261594772339,
-0.6456572413444519,
0.09115757793188095,
-0.6193673610687256,
-0.19546380639076233,
-0.2641797959804535,
-0.3347514271736145,
0.1230335459113121,
-0.4903038740158081,
0.03721119090914726,
0.3578450083732605,
0.6190996170043945,
0.2905638813972473,
-0.6370130777359009,
-0.6876592040061951,
-0.7131392359733582,
0.8413951992988586,
-0.46255409717559814,
0.2727361023426056,
0.340618371963501,
-0.021425386890769005,
-0.009184014983475208,
-0.6673265695571899,
-0.5200366973876953,
0.09957557171583176,
-0.06582050025463104,
-0.01845177449285984,
-0.4326094686985016,
-0.4085894823074341,
0.19659411907196045,
0.41796618700027466,
-0.5604549050331116,
0.1616026908159256,
-0.6716972589492798,
0.26124459505081177,
0.7688571810722351,
0.04622263088822365,
0.4030366837978363,
-0.37804943323135376,
-0.4704633355140686,
0.14019665122032166,
-1.072108268737793,
-0.2737768590450287,
0.5705640912055969,
0.47224435210227966,
-0.34842222929000854,
0.6990009546279907,
0.048624224960803986,
0.4631939232349396,
0.05528527870774269,
0.028113167732954025,
0.2034362256526947,
-0.5294056534767151,
0.08345155417919159,
0.06436628848314285,
0.8774606585502625,
0.1049237847328186,
0.25213363766670227,
-0.3799470067024231,
-0.156393900513649,
0.2349630445241928,
0.3792857229709625,
-0.583248496055603,
-0.21826398372650146,
0.2812351584434509,
-0.33622217178344727,
-0.41950979828834534,
-0.4208762049674988,
-0.8763080835342407,
-0.03731023892760277,
-0.24343109130859375,
0.33713141083717346,
-0.3861274719238281,
-0.3008629083633423,
0.21351447701454163,
0.05173340439796448,
-0.027316471561789513,
-0.008103393949568272,
-1.041845679283142,
0.6125492453575134,
0.49405768513679504,
0.8471011519432068,
-0.5997614860534668,
-0.2947300374507904,
-0.3940311372280121,
0.31297972798347473,
-0.33046749234199524,
0.8437256813049316,
-0.5029016733169556,
-0.6609026193618774,
-0.00665282690897584,
-0.2506948411464691,
-0.04106519743800163,
-0.3582689166069031,
0.4215052127838135,
-0.27891579270362854,
0.5460501909255981,
-0.0017897681100293994,
-0.4221934378147125,
-0.03137886896729469,
0.10225345939397812,
-0.4636753797531128,
1.326767921447754,
0.22183944284915924,
-0.7548387050628662,
0.1317642629146576,
-0.5627126097679138,
-0.6158190965652466,
0.06257297098636627,
-0.3205343186855316,
-0.5856403112411499,
0.3350304365158081,
0.20938868820667267,
0.2878877520561218,
-0.7200748324394226,
0.2053963989019394,
-0.23555560410022736,
-0.0584978424012661,
-0.0731009989976883,
-0.31241732835769653,
0.5594696998596191,
0.1540815681219101,
-0.19443590939044952,
-0.08215592056512833,
-0.8764687180519104,
0.2531006336212158,
0.2785598635673523,
-0.4226871132850647,
-0.3140605390071869,
0.3380332589149475,
0.08049625903367996,
0.3118715286254883,
0.2312941700220108,
-0.48866555094718933,
0.1837591528892517,
-0.28980469703674316,
0.6031567454338074,
0.423247367143631,
-0.17432810366153717,
0.34988510608673096,
0.001860901014879346,
0.5433083176612854,
0.06356137990951538,
0.08899752795696259,
0.10553388297557831,
-0.449807733297348,
-0.8522952795028687,
0.08129992336034775,
0.4345448613166809,
0.5493008494377136,
-1.192071557044983,
0.16023793816566467,
-0.6029861569404602,
-0.44812145829200745,
-0.39375990629196167,
-0.09131238609552383,
0.5153618454933167,
0.28532537817955017,
0.490203320980072,
-0.14019566774368286,
-0.38524097204208374,
-0.8878148794174194,
-0.04324807971715927,
-0.11004011332988739,
-0.06658396124839783,
0.07366739958524704,
0.42227688431739807,
-0.2478228062391281,
0.6181058287620544,
-0.45522382855415344,
-0.078196220099926,
-0.37109336256980896,
0.19972477853298187,
-0.03822266682982445,
0.45016953349113464,
0.6559293270111084,
-0.6570155024528503,
-0.7577311396598816,
-0.027500925585627556,
-0.5240498781204224,
-0.3306758403778076,
0.3582690358161926,
0.1327919363975525,
0.1314159333705902,
0.3346213102340698,
-0.3384469449520111,
0.2438647598028183,
0.8028327226638794,
-0.31495118141174316,
0.3987645208835602,
-0.19270271062850952,
-0.046087753027677536,
-1.4622446298599243,
0.2057175189256668,
-0.1600944846868515,
-0.20592626929283142,
-0.7704050540924072,
-0.02433808520436287,
0.16284994781017303,
-0.38223692774772644,
-0.5398520827293396,
0.5837971568107605,
-0.45897501707077026,
-0.4645542502403259,
-0.4798796772956848,
0.19240619242191315,
0.07539389282464981,
0.4551352560520172,
0.15868501365184784,
1.1281391382217407,
0.47746723890304565,
-0.6394973397254944,
0.2098393440246582,
0.4900156855583191,
-0.16434316337108612,
0.46672114729881287,
-0.6471893787384033,
0.292479544878006,
-0.14569604396820068,
0.0011188077041879296,
-0.6991305351257324,
-0.0656297355890274,
0.13763262331485748,
-0.34689095616340637,
0.17039112746715546,
-0.15904860198497772,
-0.603428065776825,
-0.5020113587379456,
-0.3474186062812805,
0.6959622502326965,
0.3028694987297058,
-0.7209891676902771,
0.30390632152557373,
0.673774242401123,
-0.5573849678039551,
-0.4486634135246277,
-0.4230714738368988,
0.3458869755268097,
-0.3058100640773773,
-0.6608856916427612,
0.6212533116340637,
0.03280745819211006,
-0.025677761062979698,
0.021262355148792267,
0.15654797852039337,
-0.04103243723511696,
0.06650257855653763,
-0.0735531747341156,
0.16060909628868103,
0.005084547214210033,
0.18948857486248016,
0.3006630837917328,
-0.43065953254699707,
-0.12211553007364273,
-0.5018272995948792,
0.5731479525566101,
-0.05453014001250267,
-0.06916366517543793,
0.01745334453880787,
0.7252753973007202,
0.2563726603984833,
-0.24403588473796844,
0.4593592882156372,
0.2345414161682129,
-0.37657418847084045,
-0.27351632714271545,
-0.24868144094944,
0.17709027230739594,
-0.4168587625026703,
0.2512197494506836,
-0.4347791373729706,
-0.824116587638855,
0.23860082030296326,
-0.1522730141878128,
0.1537168323993683,
0.4180150330066681,
0.5517086386680603,
0.03141326829791069,
1.122309684753418,
0.8346256017684937,
0.1878967434167862,
0.007222895976155996,
-0.10214974731206894,
0.22721873223781586,
-0.7554261684417725,
-0.1140090823173523,
-0.7429834604263306,
-0.014009667560458183,
-0.4728446900844574,
-0.44631534814834595,
0.620474636554718,
0.08602720499038696,
0.1397833377122879,
0.36159592866897583,
-0.17492219805717468,
0.4272747039794922,
0.4460182189941406,
-0.35249942541122437,
0.2680606544017792,
0.4392523467540741,
0.019965071231126785,
0.1627359241247177,
-0.8676654696464539,
-0.7693130373954773,
1.2195671796798706,
0.15768182277679443,
0.590324342250824,
0.23976974189281464,
0.3575873076915741,
0.4051629304885864,
0.09361378848552704,
-0.7362874746322632,
0.31914952397346497,
-0.6734730005264282,
-0.293268084526062,
-0.09707484394311905,
-0.310316801071167,
-0.9443311095237732,
0.4013909101486206,
-0.2330603003501892,
-0.4878365993499756,
-0.060859404504299164,
0.31453490257263184,
-0.6199184060096741,
0.2621636986732483,
-0.6317209005355835,
0.5376375913619995,
-0.23345956206321716,
-0.5157604813575745,
-0.10563064366579056,
-0.5608922839164734,
0.15845999121665955,
-0.2972840964794159,
0.2047019898891449,
-0.0397661030292511,
-0.19649936258792877,
0.7244616150856018,
-0.5595999956130981,
0.5573259592056274,
0.21072539687156677,
-0.3288709223270416,
0.24487581849098206,
-0.17105956375598907,
0.5409302115440369,
0.028606263920664787,
-0.34325432777404785,
0.30438071489334106,
0.14346632361412048,
-0.6583357453346252,
-0.10576030611991882,
0.5455305576324463,
-0.9429457187652588,
-0.2545200288295746,
-0.452472060918808,
-0.3488277792930603,
-0.5469545125961304,
0.24995273351669312,
0.5829923748970032,
0.4736367464065552,
-0.17991448938846588,
0.024767404422163963,
0.5934697985649109,
-0.3310640752315521,
0.3525846302509308,
0.7193275094032288,
-0.214984729886055,
-0.5391831398010254,
0.8851938843727112,
0.13767580687999725,
0.15309900045394897,
0.19979332387447357,
0.08062204718589783,
-0.49272996187210083,
-0.774605929851532,
-0.92153400182724,
0.39042776823043823,
-0.2394048273563385,
-0.18713203072547913,
-0.6549972295761108,
-0.14383383095264435,
-0.39293181896209717,
-0.06175808236002922,
-0.4855973720550537,
-0.6039532423019409,
-0.3914659023284912,
-0.13977260887622833,
0.02948755770921707,
0.940315306186676,
-0.23353169858455658,
0.6804994344711304,
-0.9603360891342163,
0.3045371174812317,
0.23615762591362,
0.24951425194740295,
-0.3275366723537445,
-0.19577093422412872,
-0.38256561756134033,
0.0021171376574784517,
-0.14204047620296478,
-0.8116351962089539,
0.5046520829200745,
0.09695716202259064,
0.12309329211711884,
0.0423566997051239,
-0.14497590065002441,
0.33394432067871094,
-0.7538573145866394,
0.8412140011787415,
0.19379453361034393,
-1.1031999588012695,
0.56021648645401,
-0.35893669724464417,
0.2507288157939911,
0.41813308000564575,
0.3956771492958069,
-0.7113828063011169,
-0.032116301357746124,
-0.504009485244751,
-0.8397814035415649,
1.045860767364502,
0.421848863363266,
-0.016519183292984962,
-0.1397724598646164,
0.38458847999572754,
0.4976785182952881,
0.5674082040786743,
-0.6927868127822876,
-0.02895740047097206,
-0.12471190840005875,
-0.2107563614845276,
-0.15708456933498383,
-0.6539328098297119,
0.04947030171751976,
0.4394465684890747,
0.9815502762794495,
-0.21583668887615204,
0.06653955578804016,
-0.42057812213897705,
-0.033079374581575394,
-0.239698126912117,
0.3830164968967438,
0.46302106976509094,
0.571698784828186,
0.10646703094244003,
0.2642008662223816,
0.03676602989435196,
-0.48770830035209656,
0.30849406123161316,
0.2599926292896271,
-0.3774764835834503,
-0.18001322448253632,
0.18758857250213623,
1.132655382156372,
-0.07217570394277573,
-0.3394899070262909,
0.5559740662574768,
-0.06530113518238068,
-0.15875031054019928,
-0.2866643965244293,
-0.20695669949054718,
-0.11424551904201508,
-0.12793751060962677,
0.215947687625885,
-0.039521824568510056,
-0.05043872445821762,
-0.31747984886169434,
-0.014911480247974396,
0.06740293651819229,
-0.3156055212020874,
-0.7085863351821899,
0.6221961379051208,
0.6209206581115723,
-0.1322431117296219,
0.6396827101707458,
-0.1851871758699417,
-0.40744614601135254,
0.35784488916397095,
0.6861283779144287,
0.7877733707427979,
-0.26567816734313965,
0.3910198211669922,
0.15058045089244843,
0.3529455065727234,
-0.11377887427806854,
0.7150389552116394,
0.05258095636963844,
-0.5963973999023438,
-0.3022773861885071,
-0.559622585773468,
-0.2367878407239914,
0.3430631458759308,
-0.5797892212867737,
0.20984825491905212,
-0.23367777466773987,
-0.087673619389534,
-0.1086338683962822,
0.0994105339050293,
-0.3967280983924866,
0.17751482129096985,
0.2902677655220032,
0.6871086955070496,
-0.9579832553863525,
0.8647187948226929,
0.6888807415962219,
-0.10915907472372055,
-0.5324703454971313,
-0.014166142791509628,
-0.13393080234527588,
-0.9688610434532166,
0.3038558065891266,
0.03564624860882759,
-0.10526982694864273,
0.22312931716442108,
-0.39683797955513,
-1.1048460006713867,
0.8092303276062012,
0.32588860392570496,
-0.2995419204235077,
-0.15954071283340454,
0.6981036067008972,
0.586142897605896,
-0.31290480494499207,
-0.15047402679920197,
0.5035877227783203,
0.29322677850723267,
-0.03302749991416931,
-0.8225059509277344,
-0.1517641246318817,
-0.3370584547519684,
0.31316477060317993,
0.40741753578186035,
-0.9871298670768738,
0.8901034593582153,
-0.09100567549467087,
-0.5985382199287415,
0.09844368696212769,
0.5962265729904175,
0.18266789615154266,
0.018355602398514748,
0.5559213757514954,
0.7475314736366272,
0.5108367800712585,
-0.13666430115699768,
0.9983935356140137,
-0.48795169591903687,
0.20350635051727295,
1.0975786447525024,
-0.446479469537735,
0.7830543518066406,
0.6054208278656006,
-0.3746803104877472,
0.21054518222808838,
0.5786735415458679,
0.33298298716545105,
0.4727838337421417,
0.22016143798828125,
-0.2677823305130005,
-0.1656491905450821,
-0.1468731015920639,
-0.31783971190452576,
0.49496516585350037,
0.7893514037132263,
-0.14037835597991943,
-0.5394293665885925,
0.22954325377941132,
0.13604843616485596,
0.09853950887918472,
-0.18963921070098877,
0.7157643437385559,
0.07506933063268661,
-0.7759597897529602,
0.351666659116745,
0.3482680916786194,
0.48210176825523376,
-0.7136383652687073,
0.1359591782093048,
-0.3255823254585266,
-0.054757263511419296,
-0.08970192074775696,
-0.8199037313461304,
0.4075017273426056,
0.23964425921440125,
-0.21134164929389954,
-0.42416325211524963,
0.6291263699531555,
-0.7586132287979126,
-0.5394918322563171,
0.16443873941898346,
0.5791515111923218,
0.17942216992378235,
0.07610183209180832,
-0.658328115940094,
0.15456676483154297,
0.19289588928222656,
0.017796147614717484,
0.05516398325562477,
0.36704427003860474,
-0.07925804704427719,
0.43920573592185974,
0.2961152493953705,
0.10944082587957382,
0.14667867124080658,
-0.21092775464057922,
0.7035749554634094,
-0.4488062560558319,
-0.6854456067085266,
-0.530363917350769,
0.1542350798845291,
-0.04756886139512062,
-0.2092781513929367,
0.6233887076377869,
0.799984872341156,
0.6780546307563782,
-0.008713996037840843,
1.2700368165969849,
-0.08326487243175507,
0.9133740067481995,
-0.6978212594985962,
0.32059651613235474,
-0.5836797952651978,
0.19887171685695648,
0.20519505441188812,
-0.9366809129714966,
0.06399620324373245,
0.024361351504921913,
-0.27206459641456604,
-0.37996575236320496,
0.6325106620788574,
0.4190278947353363,
-0.34627196192741394,
0.2508695721626282,
0.09525849670171738,
0.15836535394191742,
0.43310853838920593,
0.6293851733207703,
0.6962448358535767,
-0.6874420642852783,
0.5978603959083557,
-0.24699373543262482,
-0.24049879610538483,
-0.043636880815029144,
-0.7658931016921997,
-0.7165364027023315,
-0.581533670425415,
-0.3354470729827881,
-0.2153429090976715,
0.139435276389122,
0.779466450214386,
0.41515523195266724,
-0.667091429233551,
-0.41533833742141724,
-0.06177009269595146,
-0.03372073546051979,
0.05993253365159035,
-0.09133174270391464,
0.4649755656719208,
-0.34502866864204407,
-1.032954454421997,
0.49762478470802307,
0.5590457320213318,
0.42671602964401245,
-0.3578662574291229,
0.2717988193035126,
-0.12038105726242065,
0.2329399436712265,
0.8837321996688843,
0.3636949062347412,
-0.23887424170970917,
-0.20358964800834656,
-0.2679561674594879,
-0.12311400473117828,
0.04894514009356499,
0.6297124624252319,
-0.7186023592948914,
0.21466317772865295,
0.3969583809375763,
0.5928031802177429,
0.6064092516899109,
-0.047267474234104156,
0.7886294722557068,
-0.9763669371604919,
0.13463588058948517,
0.00849980115890503,
0.2553173899650574,
0.48626890778541565,
-0.1368904709815979,
0.7953550219535828,
0.1486029028892517,
-0.1995730847120285,
-0.6760618090629578,
0.47367751598358154,
-0.5586738586425781,
-0.12042544037103653,
1.3297457695007324,
-0.09499097615480423,
-0.1784946620464325,
-0.10388726741075516,
-0.14404655992984772,
0.07568417489528656,
-0.12719513475894928,
0.9257870316505432,
0.5666894316673279,
-0.023621242493391037,
0.265605092048645,
-0.19452063739299774,
0.7100428938865662,
0.5646681785583496,
-1.095517873764038,
0.1669875830411911,
0.4823439121246338,
0.14010512828826904,
0.18035930395126343,
0.8502841591835022,
-0.21869966387748718,
-0.018212253227829933,
-0.05789373070001602,
-0.21920977532863617,
0.12730750441551208,
-0.39406731724739075,
-0.1368618905544281,
0.26023516058921814,
-0.13395477831363678,
-0.08543707430362701
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07557v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07557v1
|
SIFiD: Reassess Summary Factual Inconsistency Detection with LLM
| 2024-03-12T11:41:51 | 2024-03-12T11:41:51 |
Jiuding Yang, Hui Liu, Weidong Guo, Zhuwei Rao, Yu Xu, Di Niu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Ensuring factual consistency between the summary and the original document is
paramount in summarization tasks. Consequently, considerable effort has been
dedicated to detecting inconsistencies. With the advent of Large Language
Models (LLMs), recent studies have begun to leverage their advanced language
understanding capabilities for inconsistency detection. However, early attempts
have shown that LLMs underperform traditional models due to their limited
ability to follow instructions and the absence of an effective detection
methodology. In this study, we reassess summary inconsistency detection with
LLMs, comparing the performances of GPT-3.5 and GPT-4. To advance research in
LLM-based inconsistency detection, we propose SIFiD (Summary Inconsistency
Detection with Filtered Document) that identify key sentences within documents
by either employing natural language inference or measuring semantic similarity
between summaries and documents.
|
[
-0.18388088047504425,
-0.8344835638999939,
0.8188624382019043,
0.03283083066344261,
-0.18909408152103424,
0.14805789291858673,
0.07443495839834213,
-0.3499784767627716,
0.19555479288101196,
0.5779007077217102,
-0.5002560019493103,
-0.5233809947967529,
-0.9156358242034912,
0.3328678607940674,
-0.4212745428085327,
1.1524945497512817,
-0.3412003219127655,
-0.0997515618801117,
-0.3937857151031494,
-0.3640119135379791,
-0.24816159904003143,
-0.3045618534088135,
-0.6491759419441223,
-0.3686485290527344,
0.2670280635356903,
0.4307047724723816,
0.5164351463317871,
0.29970553517341614,
0.6314822435379028,
0.3834213316440582,
-0.26380810141563416,
0.5265461206436157,
-0.2659651041030884,
0.1511150598526001,
-0.07307058572769165,
-0.2971826195716858,
-0.7439051866531372,
-0.018797293305397034,
0.9155646562576294,
0.40348172187805176,
0.1256624162197113,
0.0644436627626419,
0.07550894469022751,
0.6294273138046265,
-0.41091233491897583,
0.34781375527381897,
-0.5716757774353027,
0.11184659600257874,
-0.11992739886045456,
-0.13269075751304626,
-0.14510990679264069,
-0.45835819840431213,
0.036870963871479034,
-0.19083243608474731,
0.8045355081558228,
-0.06700622290372849,
0.977400541305542,
0.3953637182712555,
-0.6109986305236816,
-0.3955737054347992,
-0.5228687524795532,
0.37929362058639526,
-1.184969425201416,
0.5751468539237976,
0.13716533780097961,
-0.2506428062915802,
-0.4608265161514282,
-0.7765761613845825,
-0.7949988842010498,
-0.28481024503707886,
-0.15592505037784576,
0.028287064284086227,
0.05678166076540947,
0.12191362679004669,
0.5434549450874329,
0.5276281833648682,
-0.6845346093177795,
0.13668689131736755,
-0.22642439603805542,
-0.41067638993263245,
0.51213538646698,
0.14813809096813202,
0.1757625788450241,
-0.21569818258285522,
-0.3508519232273102,
0.17836210131645203,
-0.8326042890548706,
-0.16387100517749786,
0.468526154756546,
-0.06404826045036316,
-0.3670245409011841,
0.5805351734161377,
-0.3379908800125122,
0.2361704260110855,
0.15337340533733368,
-0.7961279153823853,
0.48850858211517334,
-0.5722401142120361,
-0.4353353977203369,
0.0720767080783844,
0.7565745711326599,
0.4267139434814453,
0.24434643983840942,
0.05794719606637955,
-0.36718013882637024,
-0.2611165940761566,
-0.18849200010299683,
-0.6317715644836426,
-0.1747625321149826,
0.1938655823469162,
-0.40598511695861816,
-0.1890559196472168,
0.03733286261558533,
-0.29174038767814636,
-0.24613788723945618,
-0.22289828956127167,
0.3269095718860626,
-0.31176018714904785,
-0.27535367012023926,
-0.16132932901382446,
-0.13136009871959686,
0.32206857204437256,
0.661281406879425,
-0.8057675957679749,
0.15750035643577576,
0.7806451916694641,
0.927212655544281,
-0.4544593095779419,
-0.41224902868270874,
-0.40319037437438965,
0.17947304248809814,
-0.26013055443763733,
1.2895498275756836,
-0.16250073909759521,
-0.43247082829475403,
-0.2474794238805771,
0.3444485366344452,
-0.2573755383491516,
-0.5166753530502319,
0.7761206030845642,
-0.3258288502693176,
0.4200754463672638,
-0.3961244225502014,
-1.0084776878356934,
-0.32130277156829834,
0.5447786450386047,
-0.6361052989959717,
0.9871200323104858,
0.2542111575603485,
-1.151354432106018,
0.667879581451416,
-0.5668964982032776,
-0.34245800971984863,
-0.026428446173667908,
-0.44093647599220276,
-0.8600379824638367,
0.11948031187057495,
0.25210800766944885,
0.4553491175174713,
-0.13610422611236572,
0.4129287004470825,
-0.2520207166671753,
-0.6590980291366577,
0.06394051760435104,
-0.6929770112037659,
0.4474946856498718,
0.10638032853603363,
-0.21452605724334717,
0.10916385799646378,
-0.496587336063385,
-0.30574071407318115,
0.0406845360994339,
-0.5467653870582581,
0.1790488064289093,
0.0899880900979042,
-0.2943471372127533,
-0.1393481343984604,
0.2652950882911682,
-0.44902926683425903,
0.10122834146022797,
-0.4110660254955292,
0.15556365251541138,
0.6565136909484863,
0.22399932146072388,
0.1997314691543579,
-0.501451849937439,
0.5814192295074463,
-0.04610942676663399,
-0.33518627285957336,
-0.3760881721973419,
-0.515723466873169,
-0.580909252166748,
-0.380644828081131,
0.3275104761123657,
0.6592488884925842,
-0.5862031579017639,
0.4144992530345917,
-0.3832789659500122,
-0.09219952672719955,
-0.09643025696277618,
0.17208564281463623,
0.23350825905799866,
0.6673301458358765,
0.20264789462089539,
0.18494999408721924,
-0.25203797221183777,
-0.9235012531280518,
-0.4380739629268646,
-0.47489914298057556,
-0.060072433203458786,
-0.16510768234729767,
0.782452404499054,
-0.5045714378356934,
0.7893822193145752,
-0.3977344036102295,
-0.21247470378875732,
-0.31734931468963623,
0.23803147673606873,
0.03967820480465889,
0.35530421137809753,
0.6222931742668152,
-0.8665435910224915,
-0.3726535141468048,
-0.14228270947933197,
-0.8216390013694763,
-0.31223562359809875,
-0.02523217722773552,
0.39458101987838745,
0.5595946311950684,
0.8743658661842346,
-0.4642734229564667,
0.6026723384857178,
0.24125827848911285,
-0.359684556722641,
0.608328104019165,
-0.40438705682754517,
0.6558884382247925,
-0.8776528239250183,
-0.15507681667804718,
-0.028583217412233353,
-0.6519541144371033,
-0.3032699525356293,
-0.03449670225381851,
0.3022710680961609,
0.302729994058609,
-0.4072781503200531,
0.31486934423446655,
-0.4034198820590973,
-0.2331743836402893,
-0.3996673822402954,
0.17204436659812927,
0.14784085750579834,
0.28017938137054443,
-0.10529471188783646,
1.0157020092010498,
-0.11131004989147186,
-0.3358316123485565,
0.2961297929286957,
0.19315753877162933,
-0.34815356135368347,
0.7161043286323547,
-0.5884243249893188,
-0.24463753402233124,
-0.23729923367500305,
0.42930886149406433,
-1.2981886863708496,
-0.42862656712532043,
0.26923611760139465,
-0.4384584426879883,
0.46404922008514404,
-0.18986809253692627,
-0.48385506868362427,
-0.16460661590099335,
-0.7277460694313049,
0.24776367843151093,
0.08705384284257889,
-0.3071807622909546,
0.6291282176971436,
0.2237100452184677,
-0.4665416479110718,
-0.3992500603199005,
-0.6749776601791382,
0.05980244278907776,
-0.21895477175712585,
-0.821816623210907,
0.23213845491409302,
-0.10053940862417221,
-0.2623036503791809,
-0.05015282705426216,
-0.4890972971916199,
-0.0872785672545433,
0.15676942467689514,
0.08352925628423691,
0.22968730330467224,
-0.5520642995834351,
0.052100472152233124,
0.14335662126541138,
-0.1768723875284195,
0.05566193163394928,
0.07763276994228363,
0.09226900339126587,
-0.14775626361370087,
-0.7075084447860718,
-0.48072174191474915,
0.2927541136741638,
0.7878409028053284,
0.054180193692445755,
0.5091352462768555,
0.6307811141014099,
-0.39840906858444214,
0.23706258833408356,
-0.9896872639656067,
0.25312337279319763,
-0.41035687923431396,
0.3067333996295929,
-0.3957737684249878,
-1.0713696479797363,
0.5786519050598145,
-0.11026362329721451,
0.01274172030389309,
0.7293017506599426,
0.40674278140068054,
-0.19879382848739624,
0.7407828569412231,
0.798311173915863,
0.058056462556123734,
0.40863171219825745,
-0.017606154084205627,
0.3192346692085266,
-1.014665961265564,
-0.22998061776161194,
-0.5393286943435669,
0.0069180880673229694,
-0.6415108442306519,
-0.24280662834644318,
0.367819607257843,
0.03489193692803383,
-0.2730447053909302,
-0.005840914789587259,
0.015711307525634766,
0.7272183299064636,
0.11682911962270737,
-0.1751348078250885,
0.6682462096214294,
-0.09631353616714478,
-0.16692380607128143,
0.029001662507653236,
-0.3436020314693451,
-0.7477924823760986,
0.8754253387451172,
0.3402267396450043,
0.7586057186126709,
0.3250511884689331,
0.6219733953475952,
0.6732761263847351,
0.4308413565158844,
-0.5574056506156921,
0.3400975167751312,
-0.11583907902240753,
-0.22972019016742706,
-0.24797911942005157,
-0.3927992880344391,
-0.4850277602672577,
0.4590407907962799,
-0.2017362415790558,
-0.7604392766952515,
0.09151982516050339,
0.015622299164533615,
-0.24108199775218964,
0.36432456970214844,
-0.9282041192054749,
0.9473783373832703,
-0.057151664048433304,
0.061440516263246536,
0.11338404566049576,
-0.31001007556915283,
0.7485787272453308,
-0.3048475682735443,
0.12069950997829437,
-0.41598570346832275,
-0.050260793417692184,
0.6398952603340149,
-0.6695091128349304,
0.4725833535194397,
0.028836125507950783,
-0.39951980113983154,
-0.00901002250611782,
-0.09893040359020233,
0.6909162998199463,
0.26379069685935974,
-0.10297171771526337,
-0.03458963334560394,
0.1699068695306778,
-0.36271369457244873,
-0.34241631627082825,
0.9082446098327637,
-0.479879766702652,
-0.7495076060295105,
-0.6895972490310669,
-0.4834532141685486,
-0.10873385518789291,
0.10716179013252258,
0.4731166958808899,
0.36010468006134033,
-0.33631592988967896,
0.007417107932269573,
0.8201801776885986,
-0.22018277645111084,
0.44086959958076477,
0.8207061886787415,
-0.16074521839618683,
-0.2165447473526001,
0.4190821349620819,
0.2181253880262375,
0.41253361105918884,
0.30603140592575073,
-0.16166314482688904,
-0.40823498368263245,
-0.7895860075950623,
-0.47390711307525635,
0.4174725413322449,
-0.7745311260223389,
-0.2944982051849365,
-0.9550472497940063,
-0.3293672800064087,
-0.7267231941223145,
-0.17842352390289307,
-0.17110663652420044,
-0.21082870662212372,
-0.12259098887443542,
-0.2392287701368332,
0.3162507712841034,
0.9818037152290344,
0.04770921543240547,
0.27566027641296387,
-0.7959573268890381,
0.5712042450904846,
0.04657670855522156,
0.08484765887260437,
-0.3651808798313141,
-0.8617507815361023,
-0.08652395009994507,
-0.0449712835252285,
-0.27801844477653503,
-0.8532873392105103,
0.18478958308696747,
0.08167818933725357,
0.5730335116386414,
0.4395527243614197,
-0.08268195390701294,
0.483167827129364,
-0.38053199648857117,
0.8838233351707458,
-0.06917085498571396,
-0.9677497744560242,
0.4404680132865906,
-0.22690734267234802,
0.4990323781967163,
0.3961993157863617,
0.17071256041526794,
-0.31554701924324036,
-0.6626274585723877,
-0.8032482862472534,
-0.7101067900657654,
0.6299786567687988,
0.17432139813899994,
-0.2890460789203644,
-0.10342595726251602,
0.3611268103122711,
-0.08051079511642456,
0.1812320202589035,
-0.5274235010147095,
-0.019255397841334343,
0.21263433992862701,
-0.22221846878528595,
0.10788457840681076,
-0.5997980833053589,
0.20962341129779816,
0.03314952552318573,
0.7442915439605713,
-0.31965091824531555,
0.2424098551273346,
0.49648720026016235,
-0.31746792793273926,
0.03243689611554146,
0.24278560280799866,
0.8296705484390259,
0.9321359992027283,
-0.3026731610298157,
0.20790615677833557,
0.7664413452148438,
-0.5330125093460083,
0.2174241989850998,
0.09002360701560974,
-0.24785898625850677,
0.19961799681186676,
0.8544161319732666,
0.5304499864578247,
0.39608466625213623,
-0.6287994384765625,
0.8649023175239563,
-0.23361022770404816,
-0.2643408477306366,
-0.3928620219230652,
0.16551975905895233,
0.2390582263469696,
0.39915913343429565,
0.1610986739397049,
0.18504342436790466,
0.19688273966312408,
-0.4688250422477722,
0.33730047941207886,
0.3543550372123718,
-0.036879248917102814,
-0.07934639602899551,
0.6046897172927856,
0.08272962272167206,
-0.1476789265871048,
0.3727385699748993,
-0.383421391248703,
-0.6877103447914124,
0.8233888149261475,
0.3460577130317688,
0.9002845287322998,
-0.12083467841148376,
0.2743839621543884,
-0.009052030742168427,
0.4938198924064636,
-0.3030470013618469,
0.18249517679214478,
-0.11211530864238739,
-0.9910628795623779,
-0.6072429418563843,
-0.36973997950553894,
-0.4820942282676697,
0.18620216846466064,
-0.4018389880657196,
0.30828210711479187,
-0.40213125944137573,
0.07556497305631638,
0.09831957519054413,
0.0601222887635231,
-0.4366598427295685,
0.08740234375,
-0.01334272138774395,
0.7999824285507202,
-0.9046603441238403,
0.7879364490509033,
0.40670692920684814,
-0.4244762361049652,
-0.6892221570014954,
0.4547184407711029,
0.3977670967578888,
-0.45117196440696716,
0.5449763536453247,
-0.005175756290555,
-0.3691331148147583,
-0.3343743085861206,
-0.42747029662132263,
-0.8127051591873169,
1.3576301336288452,
0.6409084796905518,
-0.3656249940395355,
0.20645232498645782,
-0.21833853423595428,
0.2732398509979248,
-0.2980104386806488,
0.3954181969165802,
0.8767842054367065,
0.4724203050136566,
0.294505774974823,
-0.9206573367118835,
-0.040596723556518555,
0.08488757163286209,
-0.22552618384361267,
0.323909193277359,
-0.705904483795166,
0.9067299365997314,
-0.2535662353038788,
-0.35668182373046875,
0.032983437180519104,
0.7437414526939392,
0.35543927550315857,
0.5665072798728943,
0.3941101133823395,
0.6108103394508362,
1.1573385000228882,
-0.1880255490541458,
0.8804304003715515,
0.011640634387731552,
0.5242898464202881,
1.2157738208770752,
-0.6251212358474731,
0.6344111561775208,
0.14673183858394623,
-0.3317454159259796,
0.25075045228004456,
0.6406933069229126,
0.01049302238970995,
0.1798858791589737,
-0.3476305902004242,
-0.5683302283287048,
-0.12719930708408356,
0.27188536524772644,
-0.6606301665306091,
0.288585364818573,
0.41616740822792053,
-0.318899929523468,
-0.549547016620636,
-0.16375602781772614,
0.289014607667923,
-0.06762803345918655,
-0.15782003104686737,
0.8589019775390625,
-0.06013612449169159,
-0.5341718196868896,
0.3425220549106598,
0.30990445613861084,
0.7478693127632141,
-0.5775868892669678,
-0.19122537970542908,
-0.6280391812324524,
0.21752426028251648,
-0.3520887792110443,
-0.7469550371170044,
0.5202319025993347,
0.23230373859405518,
-0.4154711663722992,
-0.03918481990695,
0.9643761515617371,
-0.36494994163513184,
-0.44874727725982666,
0.08889532834291458,
0.5190367698669434,
0.2994824945926666,
-0.027736354619264603,
-0.5440687537193298,
0.18475046753883362,
0.31326544284820557,
0.02093729004263878,
0.1577802151441574,
0.812018632888794,
-0.12932315468788147,
0.5109850168228149,
0.597451388835907,
-0.06741039454936981,
-0.27305588126182556,
-0.08726756274700165,
0.6986683011054993,
-0.6598694324493408,
-0.5184597373008728,
-0.9167173504829407,
0.09405282139778137,
-0.25803595781326294,
-0.29157555103302,
0.8405349850654602,
0.6350674629211426,
0.9272173047065735,
0.05036502704024315,
0.8069002032279968,
0.10176153481006622,
0.6693716645240784,
-0.870536744594574,
0.5653609037399292,
-0.2973964512348175,
0.6958167552947998,
-0.2758035361766815,
-0.9550531506538391,
-0.3354139029979706,
0.6860221028327942,
-0.26574939489364624,
-0.0331919826567173,
0.9556474089622498,
0.9189250469207764,
-0.17110539972782135,
0.21188880503177643,
0.26709383726119995,
0.44063666462898254,
0.595531165599823,
0.1245867982506752,
0.720702588558197,
-0.5109664797782898,
0.2903507947921753,
0.5038749575614929,
-0.05496662110090256,
-0.2626342177391052,
-1.0851995944976807,
-0.6969896554946899,
-0.29022416472435,
-0.6734490394592285,
-0.27760735154151917,
0.037517476826906204,
0.9050639271736145,
0.2888544797897339,
-1.0102818012237549,
0.1412803828716278,
0.025025535374879837,
0.6883552074432373,
0.18156543374061584,
-0.2240220308303833,
0.4230234622955322,
-0.300869882106781,
-0.6782011389732361,
0.48299798369407654,
0.5787780284881592,
0.3087199330329895,
-0.165021151304245,
-0.07921948283910751,
-0.3943752348423004,
0.1436055302619934,
0.5196685194969177,
0.2796356678009033,
-0.9034240245819092,
-0.5700297355651855,
-0.5225151777267456,
-0.0954836830496788,
-0.013259646482765675,
0.7523344159126282,
-0.651344895362854,
-0.003766372799873352,
0.7794808149337769,
0.680290937423706,
0.6111603379249573,
0.04246767982840538,
0.43775245547294617,
-0.5780516266822815,
0.07891377061605453,
-0.2061692774295807,
0.7441719770431519,
0.5335605144500732,
-0.5124069452285767,
0.623013436794281,
0.5455905795097351,
-0.7731121182441711,
-0.7157022356987,
0.1384144425392151,
-0.8024583458900452,
-0.10618829727172852,
0.9271005988121033,
-0.5075809359550476,
-0.10078764706850052,
-0.29542776942253113,
-0.23141838610172272,
0.012858620844781399,
-0.30352887511253357,
0.38799065351486206,
0.9491416811943054,
-0.27948197722435,
-0.035823531448841095,
-0.6941489577293396,
0.5036468505859375,
0.13547223806381226,
-0.7015002369880676,
-0.18447798490524292,
0.6113208532333374,
0.7634495496749878,
-0.10025263577699661,
1.0275371074676514,
-0.11069849133491516,
0.20358799397945404,
-0.12422999739646912,
-0.35466456413269043,
0.13365651667118073,
-0.08788977563381195,
-0.22058972716331482,
0.1352936029434204,
-0.03365406021475792,
-0.12470895797014236
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07556v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07556v3
|
Truth-Aware Context Selection: Mitigating Hallucinations of Large Language Models Being Misled by Untruthful Contexts
| 2024-03-12T11:40:44 | 2024-06-11T03:53:10 |
Tian Yu, Shaolei Zhang, Yang Feng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Although Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive text
generation capabilities, they are easily misled by untruthful contexts provided
by users or knowledge augmentation tools, leading to hallucinations. To
alleviate LLMs from being misled by untruthful context and take advantage of
knowledge augmentation, we propose Truth-Aware Context Selection (TACS), a
lightweight method to adaptively recognize and mask untruthful context from the
inputs. TACS begins by performing truth detection on the input context,
leveraging the parameterized knowledge within the LLM. Subsequently, it
constructs a corresponding attention mask based on the truthfulness of each
position, selecting the truthful context and discarding the untruthful context.
Additionally, we introduce a new evaluation metric, Disturbance Adaption Rate,
to further study the LLMs' ability to accept truthful information and resist
untruthful information. Experimental results indicate that TACS can effectively
filter untruthful context and significantly improve the overall quality of
LLMs' responses when presented with misleading information.
|
[
-0.4787321984767914,
-0.9197494983673096,
0.7757489085197449,
0.21862229704856873,
-0.36522597074508667,
0.08449313044548035,
-0.45496702194213867,
-0.5211072564125061,
0.10734598338603973,
0.6592118144035339,
-0.48758020997047424,
-0.4556193947792053,
-0.5379441976547241,
0.1319199502468109,
-0.27272990345954895,
1.0380356311798096,
0.21795965731143951,
-0.29922783374786377,
-0.30969488620758057,
-0.19001014530658722,
-0.6380963325500488,
-0.41279640793800354,
-0.5165748000144958,
-0.2961583137512207,
0.3355368375778198,
0.34109005331993103,
0.7263492345809937,
0.3900948464870453,
0.3285323977470398,
0.26253461837768555,
-0.06088404357433319,
0.48824286460876465,
-0.3704727292060852,
0.5535983443260193,
-0.36391720175743103,
-0.10778986662626266,
-0.23593591153621674,
-0.21435615420341492,
0.42509734630584717,
0.5280426740646362,
-0.09644685685634613,
0.03554144129157066,
0.0874682068824768,
0.5760476589202881,
-1.0336164236068726,
-0.15363623201847076,
-0.9583689570426941,
0.05012201517820358,
0.15007536113262177,
-0.4281154274940491,
-0.6919081211090088,
-0.21507206559181213,
0.11847849935293198,
-0.6337805390357971,
0.04555153474211693,
0.18117572367191315,
0.32161930203437805,
0.42747923731803894,
-0.45937493443489075,
-0.32195818424224854,
-0.8438819646835327,
0.7531314492225647,
-0.5924327969551086,
0.6376372575759888,
0.43127238750457764,
0.2708689868450165,
-0.29918572306632996,
-0.5629614591598511,
-0.5884785056114197,
-0.22461417317390442,
-0.002609585179015994,
0.14124837517738342,
-0.19557198882102966,
-0.022121164947748184,
0.24652668833732605,
-0.0509822703897953,
-0.3343087434768677,
0.02225182205438614,
-0.12309131771326065,
-0.49939337372779846,
0.33036598563194275,
-0.04884091019630432,
0.02181091718375683,
-0.09058675169944763,
-0.5835325717926025,
0.020636098459362984,
-0.667498767375946,
-0.19744658470153809,
0.13231492042541504,
0.24169671535491943,
0.17424143850803375,
0.3563697636127472,
-0.09447496384382248,
0.8967363238334656,
0.12082793563604355,
-0.5823487639427185,
0.007663739379495382,
-0.1138167753815651,
-0.36979204416275024,
0.43912237882614136,
0.5143761038780212,
0.32093313336372375,
0.040381405502557755,
-0.3034146726131439,
-0.4997919797897339,
-0.00769358454272151,
0.4348999559879303,
-0.7913980484008789,
0.12462961673736572,
0.14105984568595886,
-0.34454020857810974,
-0.5011862516403198,
0.022672759369015694,
-0.8836997747421265,
-0.7999155521392822,
-0.16060799360275269,
0.5663834810256958,
-0.3391077220439911,
-0.16412143409252167,
0.14823785424232483,
0.027343716472387314,
-0.14251801371574402,
0.4032594561576843,
-0.4670819938182831,
0.2435053288936615,
0.2445073276758194,
0.8123129606246948,
-0.3251655101776123,
-0.08070339262485504,
-0.6625547409057617,
0.33700913190841675,
-0.4002479314804077,
0.8404428362846375,
-0.6798252463340759,
-0.4250794053077698,
-0.11370976269245148,
-0.052153512835502625,
0.1305592805147171,
-0.4800037443637848,
0.8561744093894958,
-0.731744110584259,
0.24723288416862488,
-0.4996192157268524,
-0.2982945144176483,
-0.4431380331516266,
0.16916906833648682,
-0.5835930109024048,
0.9822531938552856,
0.30252310633659363,
-0.932141125202179,
0.39216989278793335,
-0.7013638615608215,
-0.6392034292221069,
-0.025970326736569405,
0.007659414783120155,
-0.3537719249725342,
0.2162778675556183,
0.292655885219574,
0.2918393611907959,
-0.1007770523428917,
0.5106064081192017,
-0.27247536182403564,
-0.3832832872867584,
0.4145345687866211,
-0.41125035285949707,
0.6383649110794067,
0.48594221472740173,
-0.508080005645752,
0.3162294030189514,
-0.552097737789154,
-0.2033369392156601,
0.011215582489967346,
-0.30718255043029785,
-0.6149068474769592,
0.06351400166749954,
0.04986417666077614,
0.2023867666721344,
0.029663780704140663,
-0.5025404095649719,
-0.08768639713525772,
-0.287246435880661,
0.16689099371433258,
0.9948886036872864,
0.11322883516550064,
0.23385566473007202,
-0.4059552848339081,
0.22377049922943115,
0.3064112663269043,
0.16734032332897186,
0.09679633378982544,
-0.13048821687698364,
-0.7132024168968201,
-0.24822641909122467,
0.2118835747241974,
0.33203625679016113,
-1.1356514692306519,
0.9052853584289551,
-0.06371104717254639,
-0.29139775037765503,
-0.33660849928855896,
-0.01789468713104725,
0.16792596876621246,
1.039705514907837,
0.3832714259624481,
-0.22582510113716125,
-0.7769076824188232,
-0.7849765419960022,
-0.4941268265247345,
-0.26258981227874756,
0.12802258133888245,
0.12165120989084244,
0.42057672142982483,
-0.3591294288635254,
1.074113130569458,
-0.3610573410987854,
-0.4198053777217865,
-0.033287413418293,
-0.011852066032588482,
-0.3780350685119629,
0.22550185024738312,
0.5248895883560181,
-0.9030333757400513,
-0.0034887883812189102,
-0.09065748751163483,
-0.591413676738739,
-0.4063076376914978,
-0.32381516695022583,
0.12864278256893158,
0.6375056505203247,
0.353993684053421,
-0.22084267437458038,
0.4934774339199066,
0.5676825046539307,
-0.6766765117645264,
0.6267202496528625,
-0.12345757335424423,
0.21720236539840698,
-1.007967233657837,
0.3069014251232147,
-0.12088724225759506,
-0.6209540963172913,
-0.4209449291229248,
-0.27092239260673523,
-0.06801819801330566,
0.3923290967941284,
-0.28527629375457764,
0.5755014419555664,
-0.502606987953186,
-0.2914544641971588,
-0.5001100897789001,
0.30846723914146423,
0.1410973221063614,
0.3309868276119232,
0.15319550037384033,
0.9690617322921753,
0.5119265913963318,
-0.8283257484436035,
0.3567148745059967,
0.1393282562494278,
-0.5372301936149597,
0.32105523347854614,
-0.1251641809940338,
0.12972639501094818,
-0.1408635675907135,
0.2751142680644989,
-0.8184825778007507,
-0.22133949398994446,
0.313250869512558,
-0.4800381660461426,
-0.08693761378526688,
0.16476906836032867,
-0.48855191469192505,
-0.0006248673889786005,
-0.2829970121383667,
0.32157212495803833,
0.3617972433567047,
-0.8076698184013367,
0.6721190214157104,
0.5023974776268005,
0.06531606614589691,
-0.6741312742233276,
-0.8496336936950684,
0.31000202894210815,
-0.17298530042171478,
-0.13326679170131683,
0.17328204214572906,
-0.30918070673942566,
-0.2906016707420349,
-0.07396164536476135,
-0.38840460777282715,
0.06034556031227112,
0.23073571920394897,
0.2356153130531311,
0.24076151847839355,
-0.03628156706690788,
0.29158490896224976,
0.17880505323410034,
0.0877179503440857,
0.21365457773208618,
-0.28897377848625183,
0.3693388104438782,
-0.19619585573673248,
-0.3468165099620819,
-0.13723735511302948,
0.15195055305957794,
0.6198286414146423,
-0.12744253873825073,
0.8667687773704529,
0.6448081135749817,
-0.5125899314880371,
-0.2993396818637848,
-0.8706388473510742,
-0.45981016755104065,
-0.4949618875980377,
0.4342413544654846,
-0.20142197608947754,
-1.1286388635635376,
0.4218112528324127,
-0.09714706987142563,
-0.06265399605035782,
0.17158591747283936,
0.7190676927566528,
0.4541091024875641,
0.8292246460914612,
0.5937623381614685,
-0.03175992891192436,
0.4307660460472107,
0.4095846712589264,
0.4189642369747162,
-0.7325448989868164,
-0.28512680530548096,
-0.4240071475505829,
-0.15026620030403137,
-0.40575769543647766,
-0.31647196412086487,
0.5846063494682312,
-0.16093091666698456,
-0.042526595294475555,
-0.10315047949552536,
-0.7769216895103455,
0.7085987329483032,
0.39055335521698,
0.171054407954216,
0.6476618051528931,
0.1733427792787552,
-0.015334629453718662,
-0.12060920149087906,
-0.539044201374054,
-0.5886313319206238,
0.9573812484741211,
0.188050776720047,
0.8326219916343689,
0.2634798288345337,
0.049401719123125076,
0.4629937410354614,
0.3716271221637726,
-0.8772720098495483,
0.5416067838668823,
0.2094932198524475,
-0.6477140188217163,
-0.17538860440254211,
-0.43549245595932007,
-0.47928106784820557,
0.23805372416973114,
-0.43232572078704834,
-0.7653826475143433,
0.11442004889249802,
0.011153528466820717,
-0.6281487941741943,
0.642787516117096,
-0.6309723854064941,
0.43724116683006287,
-0.09835444390773773,
-0.2947389483451843,
-0.1475115865468979,
-0.6930750012397766,
0.49210935831069946,
-0.4179380238056183,
0.3286433517932892,
0.1965174525976181,
-0.3109477162361145,
0.7427923679351807,
0.10884852707386017,
0.8611552715301514,
-0.2488124519586563,
-0.09385869652032852,
0.38373327255249023,
0.6347153782844543,
0.4060126841068268,
0.17441821098327637,
-0.11734148859977722,
-0.08157054334878922,
-0.14297285676002502,
0.0018183814827352762,
-0.6199740767478943,
0.8180233240127563,
-0.6138328313827515,
-0.6627461910247803,
-0.38546493649482727,
-0.7566858530044556,
-0.45219025015830994,
0.26064297556877136,
0.3332332968711853,
0.23256339132785797,
-0.18451251089572906,
0.3591328561306,
0.9289951324462891,
-0.1574830263853073,
0.6982455253601074,
0.6581965684890747,
-0.22490635514259338,
-0.3175775408744812,
0.623371422290802,
0.07361795008182526,
0.11017271876335144,
0.17764411866664886,
0.3000814616680145,
-0.4307331442832947,
-0.5567949414253235,
-0.25539737939834595,
-0.08521607518196106,
-0.7521185874938965,
-0.5072841644287109,
-0.7452936768531799,
-0.23755991458892822,
-0.5825722813606262,
-0.1815786212682724,
-0.26167452335357666,
-0.3284713327884674,
-0.10299629718065262,
-0.0907544493675232,
0.428385466337204,
0.6227131485939026,
-0.1472635120153427,
0.38436758518218994,
-0.48451170325279236,
0.3543725907802582,
0.38456928730010986,
0.4063735008239746,
-0.20459114015102386,
-0.8891216516494751,
-0.05528315156698227,
-0.10771495848894119,
-0.3864558935165405,
-0.859196662902832,
0.25162482261657715,
-0.004633190110325813,
0.33779633045196533,
0.4159950911998749,
0.5818610191345215,
0.4438442885875702,
-0.03499219939112663,
0.6577847003936768,
0.12874490022659302,
-1.0780295133590698,
0.5584529042243958,
-0.051613062620162964,
0.08694473654031754,
0.5921105742454529,
-0.054372645914554596,
-0.6709300875663757,
-0.34510910511016846,
-0.5094689726829529,
-0.48208799958229065,
0.6951678991317749,
0.12232673168182373,
-0.08811183273792267,
0.24208274483680725,
0.4139489531517029,
0.38552939891815186,
0.26911666989326477,
-1.032219409942627,
-0.03876351937651634,
-0.2841409742832184,
-0.15421977639198303,
0.09643465280532837,
-0.47378721833229065,
-0.3940710425376892,
-0.08177938312292099,
0.8488737940788269,
-0.4306989312171936,
0.16103163361549377,
0.642045259475708,
-0.2201329618692398,
-0.5488958358764648,
0.36075544357299805,
0.9623974561691284,
0.719361424446106,
-0.04371011629700661,
0.4557267427444458,
0.3261631429195404,
-0.5615276098251343,
-0.056819651275873184,
-0.19527234137058258,
-0.3502773344516754,
0.07297122478485107,
0.3049294352531433,
0.933521032333374,
-0.24430035054683685,
-0.7217852473258972,
0.7921330332756042,
-0.09832113981246948,
0.08049947768449783,
-0.16054674983024597,
0.2459627091884613,
-0.19694958627223969,
0.10485386848449707,
0.2838365137577057,
0.4780447483062744,
0.17404620349407196,
-0.4331691861152649,
0.21618644893169403,
0.4739263653755188,
-0.4500362277030945,
-0.23673690855503082,
0.47837886214256287,
0.14595705270767212,
-0.19264081120491028,
0.14819462597370148,
-0.023055721074342728,
-0.5190144181251526,
0.2541886568069458,
0.9202815890312195,
0.8988039493560791,
-0.45812857151031494,
0.10025953501462936,
0.23890630900859833,
0.5013256669044495,
-0.038575101643800735,
-0.06054888293147087,
-0.02725805528461933,
-0.875038206577301,
-0.4399941563606262,
-0.39983639121055603,
-0.3111790418624878,
0.5194365382194519,
-0.5198003649711609,
0.15808464586734772,
-0.6355287432670593,
-0.16991297900676727,
-0.4585660696029663,
-0.0230820681899786,
-0.21255245804786682,
0.4544066786766052,
0.106486476957798,
0.9826429486274719,
-0.8312324285507202,
0.8915562629699707,
0.7260053753852844,
0.09342223405838013,
-0.5606046319007874,
0.3599623441696167,
0.060227055102586746,
-0.8634689450263977,
0.1585022211074829,
0.0744989812374115,
-0.5524887442588806,
-0.12222791463136673,
-0.7806804180145264,
-0.39788052439689636,
0.8615335822105408,
0.6623261570930481,
-0.3767022490501404,
0.19507107138633728,
-0.07971625030040741,
0.3268294632434845,
-0.637608528137207,
0.03710336610674858,
0.6568971872329712,
0.6063913106918335,
0.36221981048583984,
-0.6578962802886963,
0.4475588798522949,
0.1352205127477646,
-0.06241597607731819,
-0.14096103608608246,
-0.6591836214065552,
0.41371747851371765,
-0.3674817383289337,
-0.1206834614276886,
-0.22174938023090363,
0.5709461569786072,
0.4285580515861511,
0.27124541997909546,
0.8435398936271667,
0.24268613755702972,
0.7074432969093323,
-0.03567714989185333,
0.5901100039482117,
-0.2024584710597992,
0.16276401281356812,
1.1139448881149292,
-0.255379319190979,
0.4642403721809387,
0.7176822423934937,
0.31580105423927307,
0.5727003812789917,
0.6449457406997681,
0.16852566599845886,
0.6742815375328064,
-0.09365502744913101,
-0.5367236137390137,
-0.4546824097633362,
-0.4572816491127014,
-0.48703160881996155,
0.49810850620269775,
0.33002692461013794,
-0.06537216156721115,
-0.18349827826023102,
0.1741042584180832,
0.08164358884096146,
0.23708923161029816,
-0.11290426552295685,
0.9263378977775574,
-0.05207809433341026,
-0.7876337170600891,
0.6316121220588684,
0.18263737857341766,
0.7127730846405029,
-0.5437037944793701,
0.11559661477804184,
-0.18920780718326569,
-0.011669878847897053,
-0.3803730607032776,
-0.847065269947052,
0.39905762672424316,
0.09316986799240112,
-0.22184056043624878,
-0.05503083020448685,
1.2211858034133911,
-0.35432103276252747,
-0.23087681829929352,
0.37801793217658997,
0.460843563079834,
-0.10920310765504837,
-0.4257836937904358,
-0.4886608123779297,
0.36711883544921875,
0.11702951788902283,
-0.36929404735565186,
0.1534140408039093,
0.6065158843994141,
-0.048076651990413666,
0.7506939768791199,
0.5666557550430298,
0.22849242389202118,
-0.32400965690612793,
0.034885063767433167,
1.0316516160964966,
-0.7891702651977539,
-0.7107464671134949,
-0.8653537631034851,
0.31419697403907776,
-0.03743307292461395,
-0.17315013706684113,
0.5049014091491699,
0.4661586880683899,
0.7172013521194458,
0.011496908031404018,
0.8822576999664307,
0.04717708379030228,
0.5743881464004517,
-0.49358654022216797,
0.824945867061615,
-0.5649699568748474,
0.42335012555122375,
-0.21352176368236542,
-0.9258604645729065,
-0.4084531366825104,
0.5559118390083313,
-0.1575009673833847,
0.1570381075143814,
0.7992815971374512,
0.8250865936279297,
0.000668791588395834,
0.22037172317504883,
0.4782158136367798,
0.3683123290538788,
0.1326655000448227,
0.4617205560207367,
0.8446086645126343,
-0.3143092691898346,
0.5014786124229431,
-0.12658318877220154,
-0.302737295627594,
-0.2432655692100525,
-1.0176314115524292,
-0.9565980434417725,
-0.6074729561805725,
-0.1831134855747223,
-0.5090504884719849,
-0.03890472277998924,
0.9380611777305603,
0.7225104570388794,
-0.9419225454330444,
0.05596359446644783,
-0.019845716655254364,
0.4829583764076233,
0.09691300243139267,
-0.2558826804161072,
0.14190798997879028,
-0.3443863093852997,
-0.4961027503013611,
0.5099223256111145,
0.30864620208740234,
0.13225436210632324,
-0.18698816001415253,
-0.21772265434265137,
0.09386929869651794,
0.09925839304924011,
0.6182176470756531,
-0.054000481963157654,
-0.9159403443336487,
-0.706475019454956,
-0.13735470175743103,
-0.1971113383769989,
0.1498420089483261,
0.9275404810905457,
-1.0760607719421387,
0.556860089302063,
0.13056577742099762,
0.7366288304328918,
-0.15452887117862701,
-0.03145560994744301,
0.2096894234418869,
-0.8605713248252869,
0.35197052359580994,
0.364116370677948,
0.08490858972072601,
0.5316751003265381,
-0.6661157608032227,
0.32694655656814575,
0.4768144488334656,
-0.43735966086387634,
-1.1081496477127075,
0.17180190980434418,
-1.072142243385315,
-0.7546471953392029,
1.2343696355819702,
0.3454802930355072,
-0.28143739700317383,
-0.21078531444072723,
-0.40016260743141174,
0.37365418672561646,
-0.37460044026374817,
1.0841392278671265,
0.7238446474075317,
0.10103127360343933,
0.036090753972530365,
-0.4136546850204468,
0.7616371512413025,
0.5001519918441772,
-0.8491663932800293,
0.42736488580703735,
0.6008481979370117,
0.322845995426178,
0.06551961600780487,
0.33948686718940735,
-0.055813610553741455,
0.11336643248796463,
-0.24633873999118805,
0.18402798473834991,
-0.25124391913414,
-0.5319281220436096,
-0.34554365277290344,
0.12208211421966553,
0.09926265478134155,
-0.027161769568920135
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07544v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07544v1
|
MAMMOTH: Massively Multilingual Modular Open Translation @ Helsinki
| 2024-03-12T11:32:30 | 2024-03-12T11:32:30 |
Timothee Mickus, Stig-Arne Grönroos, Joseph Attieh, Michele Boggia, Ona De Gibert, Shaoxiong Ji, Niki Andreas Lopi, Alessandro Raganato, Raúl Vázquez, Jörg Tiedemann
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
NLP in the age of monolithic large language models is approaching its limits
in terms of size and information that can be handled. The trend goes to
modularization, a necessary step into the direction of designing smaller
sub-networks and components with specialized functionality. In this paper, we
present the MAMMOTH toolkit: a framework designed for training massively
multilingual modular machine translation systems at scale, initially derived
from OpenNMT-py and then adapted to ensure efficient training across
computation clusters. We showcase its efficiency across clusters of A100 and
V100 NVIDIA GPUs, and discuss our design philosophy and plans for future
information. The toolkit is publicly available online.
|
[
-0.4328553080558777,
-0.5755376219749451,
0.1606142371892929,
0.2876253128051758,
-0.3808286190032959,
-0.17947746813297272,
-0.4166451096534729,
-0.22910146415233612,
0.3758987486362457,
0.44998589158058167,
-0.5215562582015991,
-0.3549160361289978,
-0.5804704427719116,
0.21058233082294464,
-0.29191115498542786,
0.9434258937835693,
0.16518168151378632,
0.03548601269721985,
-0.17907249927520752,
-0.4859006702899933,
-0.25771307945251465,
-0.5885820984840393,
-0.48323139548301697,
-0.2355043739080429,
0.7202103734016418,
0.21655040979385376,
0.7837284207344055,
0.8738282918930054,
0.3823694586753845,
0.35217350721359253,
-0.2733788788318634,
0.18596108257770538,
-0.4065535366535187,
-0.0848635584115982,
-0.05311167612671852,
-0.3531448245048523,
-0.6298253536224365,
-0.46906957030296326,
0.8223286867141724,
0.7952268123626709,
-0.17776234447956085,
0.6251603364944458,
-0.13137957453727722,
0.4789371192455292,
-0.4836100935935974,
0.44524359703063965,
-0.5982193350791931,
0.2734593451023102,
-0.3137483298778534,
0.221113920211792,
-0.5089272856712341,
-0.12397783994674683,
-0.08087334781885147,
-0.7942973971366882,
-0.149643674492836,
0.013510528951883316,
0.1857897937297821,
0.2751009166240692,
-0.34809955954551697,
-0.2244180291891098,
-0.3133809566497803,
0.9056862592697144,
-0.6763814687728882,
0.3619348406791687,
0.22703301906585693,
0.3172623813152313,
0.03849301487207413,
-0.4851222336292267,
-0.4358428418636322,
0.0147682074457407,
-0.120293989777565,
-0.01148020476102829,
-0.10487724095582962,
-0.12954182922840118,
0.18266266584396362,
0.705382764339447,
-0.7009689211845398,
0.2819777727127075,
-0.49258336424827576,
-0.08633223176002502,
0.3565765917301178,
0.255145400762558,
0.27533677220344543,
-0.10524732619524002,
-0.07480895519256592,
0.04814272001385689,
-0.5981854200363159,
-0.39573153853416443,
0.2807455360889435,
0.5714375376701355,
-0.0830492153763771,
0.7092469930648804,
-0.1515364646911621,
0.8323823809623718,
-0.1727573573589325,
-0.33433911204338074,
0.34241577982902527,
-0.15726906061172485,
-0.36433735489845276,
0.2275928258895874,
0.5639911890029907,
-0.04515858739614487,
-0.3700827658176422,
-0.3775749206542969,
-0.37840911746025085,
-0.20831745862960815,
0.45833495259284973,
-0.6967665553092957,
0.08742108941078186,
0.3531387150287628,
-0.36521294713020325,
-0.03881364315748215,
-0.06882286816835403,
-0.4102773070335388,
-0.16868560016155243,
-0.42917072772979736,
0.430423766374588,
-0.07708827406167984,
-0.5376349687576294,
0.366646409034729,
-0.0793214812874794,
-0.047559719532728195,
0.2746030390262604,
-1.1158862113952637,
0.1267985850572586,
0.8480773568153381,
1.1120398044586182,
-0.15611469745635986,
-0.33106058835983276,
-0.5278477072715759,
0.3772139251232147,
-0.3659548759460449,
0.3255300223827362,
-0.13825075328350067,
-0.4264117181301117,
0.20358945429325104,
0.06756095588207245,
-0.17803046107292175,
-0.6541440486907959,
0.3947411775588989,
-0.4006791114807129,
0.10061109811067581,
0.055340785533189774,
-0.030395690351724625,
-0.3965151309967041,
0.5008009076118469,
-0.6757524609565735,
0.9029126763343811,
0.23947837948799133,
-0.6294944882392883,
0.3198533356189728,
-0.8059777021408081,
-0.3865370452404022,
0.26638782024383545,
0.2012239694595337,
-0.102872833609581,
0.4388580322265625,
0.22255322337150574,
0.32742035388946533,
-0.36954349279403687,
0.24185682833194733,
-0.304185152053833,
-0.051847364753484726,
-0.22895388305187225,
0.15280196070671082,
0.6374779939651489,
0.4190632402896881,
-0.20605795085430145,
0.4371258616447449,
-0.5693364143371582,
-0.0061914012767374516,
-0.11455769836902618,
-0.8001282811164856,
-0.23386794328689575,
-0.2845234274864197,
0.2955106198787689,
0.3115732967853546,
0.3795740306377411,
-0.5969876050949097,
0.5053721070289612,
-0.33113425970077515,
0.6770229935646057,
0.579376220703125,
-0.7226749658584595,
0.587491512298584,
-0.17336198687553406,
0.40363118052482605,
-0.014074347913265228,
0.296443372964859,
-0.3822397291660309,
-0.7165938019752502,
-0.8153285384178162,
-0.3433597981929779,
0.17949505150318146,
0.49615687131881714,
-1.0007675886154175,
0.6070448756217957,
-0.40135127305984497,
-0.5587306022644043,
-0.4887671172618866,
0.21194054186344147,
0.37785816192626953,
0.050110019743442535,
0.4138225317001343,
-0.5955414772033691,
-0.45881208777427673,
-1.0458793640136719,
-0.031140414997935295,
-0.14933107793331146,
-0.35501164197921753,
0.12442938983440399,
0.5031174421310425,
-0.5230236649513245,
0.5653532147407532,
-0.35891804099082947,
-0.3041100800037384,
-0.3542320728302002,
0.09019961208105087,
0.5944894552230835,
0.7343672513961792,
0.3770236074924469,
-0.7336142063140869,
-0.2514350116252899,
0.6958150267601013,
-0.7942054271697998,
0.05733349919319153,
0.16323155164718628,
-0.052056632936000824,
0.14276888966560364,
0.48649516701698303,
-0.7969885468482971,
-0.08460985124111176,
0.8965141773223877,
0.1794123500585556,
0.5967395901679993,
-0.36877089738845825,
-0.15669937431812286,
-1.2984308004379272,
0.36729538440704346,
-0.251873642206192,
-0.22375579178333282,
-0.4950978457927704,
0.5740898847579956,
0.08524306863546371,
-0.2630074918270111,
-0.6126993894577026,
0.5303200483322144,
-0.22145934402942657,
-0.0903318002820015,
-0.1192750483751297,
-0.04797215014696121,
-0.3890998959541321,
0.4704832434654236,
-0.1127675399184227,
0.9041772484779358,
0.44925230741500854,
-0.44974327087402344,
0.32719895243644714,
0.4383130967617035,
-0.4036816656589508,
0.6282545924186707,
-0.5156055092811584,
0.2624586522579193,
-0.05513246729969978,
0.16901418566703796,
-0.48970016837120056,
-0.39418745040893555,
-0.012491968460381031,
-0.2461848258972168,
0.18510444462299347,
-0.39383605122566223,
-0.7844290137290955,
-0.5100710988044739,
-0.043658457696437836,
0.5652614235877991,
0.2752430737018585,
-0.6682347655296326,
0.7280934453010559,
0.7804706692695618,
-0.20308424532413483,
-0.5891743898391724,
-0.6977344751358032,
0.3650337755680084,
-0.12194325029850006,
-0.766182005405426,
-0.13586004078388214,
-0.07233481109142303,
-0.12324435263872147,
-0.26672330498695374,
-0.11858068406581879,
-0.4153234362602234,
-0.09555624425411224,
0.20906135439872742,
-0.048846881836652756,
-0.6266735196113586,
0.2601380944252014,
0.07735580205917358,
-0.2771419882774353,
-0.09643340110778809,
-1.185496211051941,
0.5427492260932922,
-0.279958039522171,
-0.16000530123710632,
-0.3370579481124878,
0.4510088860988617,
0.7106991410255432,
-0.1308022439479828,
0.7600538730621338,
0.7902034521102905,
-0.29513072967529297,
0.01769009791314602,
-0.5251918435096741,
0.20230816304683685,
-0.48745980858802795,
0.5103086829185486,
-0.3400997519493103,
-1.222527027130127,
0.29144287109375,
-0.09148842841386795,
0.38284239172935486,
0.6480004787445068,
0.9762933850288391,
0.5636130571365356,
1.079665184020996,
0.8217370510101318,
-0.17121146619319916,
0.29845884442329407,
-0.13911449909210205,
0.0077000274322927,
-0.8469879627227783,
-0.2026892751455307,
-0.4775027930736542,
-0.22450609505176544,
-0.25715720653533936,
-0.7878957390785217,
0.5294890403747559,
-0.10137366503477097,
-0.08621978014707565,
0.5682544112205505,
-0.39949601888656616,
0.41636309027671814,
0.6039385199546814,
-0.25846704840660095,
0.20240522921085358,
-0.15159735083580017,
-0.39133697748184204,
0.15251287817955017,
-1.0792336463928223,
-0.5306580066680908,
0.8594643473625183,
0.15774202346801758,
0.45891186594963074,
0.3359360694885254,
0.17694739997386932,
0.0638202354311943,
0.4344352185726166,
-0.8446528911590576,
0.47269773483276367,
-0.25499922037124634,
-0.9485376477241516,
-0.3123340308666229,
-0.5330567955970764,
-0.8490917682647705,
0.5963940024375916,
-0.2936258316040039,
-0.5130992531776428,
-0.2765352725982666,
0.09057436883449554,
-0.010414239019155502,
0.6672317385673523,
-0.6908211708068848,
0.9822949767112732,
0.1659582406282425,
0.07818006724119186,
-0.4440125823020935,
-0.45486193895339966,
0.38626885414123535,
-0.5107086300849915,
0.2967448830604553,
0.17837895452976227,
-0.21354170143604279,
0.5079315304756165,
-0.3562474846839905,
0.6410086154937744,
0.10819985717535019,
-0.07822232693433762,
0.05319824442267418,
0.18003226816654205,
0.2739820182323456,
0.22270096838474274,
-0.16451527178287506,
0.3324872851371765,
-0.1147988811135292,
-0.7029286623001099,
-0.08369297534227371,
0.7341161966323853,
-0.7191358208656311,
-0.35822832584381104,
0.03215634822845459,
-0.9089754819869995,
-0.022661374881863594,
0.5163097977638245,
-0.19591271877288818,
0.6525229811668396,
-0.31905391812324524,
0.5130066275596619,
0.6251547336578369,
-0.37586143612861633,
0.4336667060852051,
0.229080930352211,
-0.5186880826950073,
-0.5446146726608276,
0.977097749710083,
0.1647496074438095,
0.23773302137851715,
0.5863681435585022,
0.22665180265903473,
-0.07448066025972366,
-0.623935341835022,
-1.1618452072143555,
0.10001058131456375,
-0.7940134406089783,
0.057109344750642776,
-0.8054061532020569,
0.27646803855895996,
-0.40280184149742126,
-0.18645648658275604,
-0.4874073565006256,
-0.8149976134300232,
-0.05058422312140465,
0.05289396643638611,
-0.05344186723232269,
1.1694527864456177,
-0.06924264878034592,
0.4856400191783905,
-1.0128172636032104,
-0.05513908714056015,
0.6547067165374756,
0.16163721680641174,
0.008238688111305237,
-0.22870555520057678,
-0.6677539348602295,
-0.27608218789100647,
-0.1950640082359314,
-0.11247674375772476,
0.36835020780563354,
0.030056118965148926,
0.4641001224517822,
0.34349343180656433,
-0.37365037202835083,
0.3553975224494934,
-0.674652636051178,
0.779761791229248,
0.437516987323761,
-0.883324146270752,
0.16476953029632568,
-0.6947818398475647,
0.8510890603065491,
0.34784725308418274,
0.38329336047172546,
-1.0141818523406982,
-0.29464441537857056,
-0.3982900083065033,
-0.8610117435455322,
0.6447610855102539,
-0.02917611226439476,
0.29075148701667786,
0.015494323335587978,
0.19771935045719147,
0.53326815366745,
0.5459511876106262,
-0.4142979681491852,
-0.04668137803673744,
-0.08534569293260574,
-0.017792943865060806,
-0.40441957116127014,
-0.048916373401880264,
-0.2991863489151001,
-0.1876755952835083,
0.6950827240943909,
-0.5470465421676636,
0.053063031286001205,
-0.16175702214241028,
-0.38506853580474854,
-0.003451787168160081,
0.0999884158372879,
0.777037501335144,
0.9792419075965881,
0.10492020845413208,
0.14034855365753174,
0.4305896461009979,
-0.5936685800552368,
-0.17604951560497284,
-0.33468589186668396,
-0.03104306198656559,
0.03224136680364609,
0.21692155301570892,
0.7046473622322083,
0.1973661482334137,
-0.6287126541137695,
0.2833142578601837,
0.013875901699066162,
-0.24808461964130402,
-0.05107267200946808,
-0.1368577778339386,
0.2906443476676941,
0.16461406648159027,
0.28653857111930847,
0.026321295648813248,
-0.068227618932724,
-0.37915050983428955,
0.027040237560868263,
0.16916033625602722,
-0.6773669123649597,
-0.6312492489814758,
0.6872810125350952,
0.16357119381427765,
-0.4153730869293213,
0.4625930190086365,
-0.06440450996160507,
-0.3984766900539398,
0.16104115545749664,
0.5683299899101257,
0.8615783452987671,
-0.03592628985643387,
0.21109627187252045,
0.5253365635871887,
0.6859874129295349,
-0.2106570452451706,
-0.05579223483800888,
-0.13617154955863953,
-0.08002486824989319,
-0.7760643362998962,
-0.7878598570823669,
-0.5666542053222656,
-0.1659800261259079,
-0.38451048731803894,
0.09929652512073517,
-0.379300594329834,
-0.05784694850444794,
-0.15138007700443268,
-0.3753195106983185,
-0.3886664807796478,
0.033016931265592575,
0.16073879599571228,
1.0281771421432495,
-0.6237087249755859,
0.913966715335846,
1.044318675994873,
-0.04154137894511223,
-0.29684922099113464,
-0.6847179532051086,
0.1751534640789032,
-0.8941028714179993,
0.49231022596359253,
0.3169535994529724,
0.12712474167346954,
-0.03019692189991474,
-0.3092798590660095,
-0.7441678047180176,
0.8132148385047913,
0.4940965175628662,
-0.2074788212776184,
0.13126066327095032,
0.2762705087661743,
0.33746373653411865,
-0.36267584562301636,
-0.01742790825664997,
0.2913927733898163,
0.6685563921928406,
-0.02535063400864601,
-1.3840259313583374,
-0.2513449490070343,
-0.37596508860588074,
-0.04469825327396393,
0.5697832107543945,
-0.5075215697288513,
1.105594515800476,
0.17698851227760315,
0.10309183597564697,
0.23892582952976227,
0.431948721408844,
-0.3519837558269501,
-0.12748879194259644,
0.509926974773407,
0.9013160467147827,
0.5822688937187195,
-0.07766573131084442,
1.2084085941314697,
-0.1453944742679596,
0.37236201763153076,
0.6623798608779907,
0.3610592186450958,
0.8143419027328491,
0.5028805136680603,
-0.06378215551376343,
0.018256686627864838,
0.37090668082237244,
0.39617231488227844,
0.13209979236125946,
0.32059165835380554,
-0.4291483461856842,
-0.4263591766357422,
-0.26002776622772217,
-0.4890631437301636,
0.11764213442802429,
0.443905770778656,
0.006690712179988623,
-0.3792133331298828,
0.162697896361351,
0.017548054456710815,
-0.30144062638282776,
-0.5909191966056824,
0.7406577467918396,
0.07337101548910141,
-0.3761836290359497,
0.6216495037078857,
0.09967980533838272,
0.7524788975715637,
-0.7506203651428223,
0.5173134207725525,
0.038607921451330185,
0.31989386677742004,
-0.17663860321044922,
-0.4693382680416107,
0.4270879924297333,
-0.4196295142173767,
-0.20877347886562347,
-0.3499992787837982,
0.313595175743103,
-0.3253643214702606,
-0.43359631299972534,
0.0011847050627693534,
0.5973615050315857,
0.276092529296875,
-0.22675305604934692,
-0.6941575407981873,
0.04786047339439392,
-0.3542031943798065,
-0.09821897745132446,
0.5558566451072693,
0.5322939157485962,
0.022204995155334473,
0.560670793056488,
0.8559000492095947,
-0.03809448704123497,
0.36487072706222534,
-0.2803921401500702,
1.0323739051818848,
-0.4431892931461334,
-0.7281762957572937,
-0.49210473895072937,
0.38203951716423035,
-0.03748886659741402,
-0.627293586730957,
0.8505306839942932,
0.888616681098938,
0.9690101146697998,
-0.33303624391555786,
0.622427761554718,
-0.21524673700332642,
0.04677852243185043,
-0.2897704839706421,
0.5889580249786377,
-0.6605058908462524,
-0.20694653689861298,
0.05417500436306,
-1.2082858085632324,
-0.6841292381286621,
0.2863519787788391,
-0.10621761530637741,
-0.4678533673286438,
0.695223331451416,
0.6551429033279419,
-0.29642200469970703,
0.18300151824951172,
0.5258402228355408,
0.2600165605545044,
0.22725263237953186,
0.31614992022514343,
0.6017728447914124,
-0.04401575028896332,
0.511384129524231,
0.029416866600513458,
-0.29848504066467285,
-0.26553764939308167,
-0.8283752202987671,
-0.8544391393661499,
-0.6661797761917114,
-0.009184935130178928,
-0.11313760280609131,
-0.09502151608467102,
1.0005470514297485,
0.9343420267105103,
-0.6592137217521667,
-0.6666116118431091,
0.34922558069229126,
0.11431825160980225,
-0.2953733205795288,
0.00346054183319211,
0.0973101258277893,
-0.607296347618103,
-0.7168570756912231,
0.6086000800132751,
0.8142547607421875,
-0.3026851713657379,
-0.6060782670974731,
0.048462580889463425,
-0.12605604529380798,
-0.11145070195198059,
0.978600025177002,
0.25013038516044617,
-0.43500614166259766,
-0.15726648271083832,
-0.08769642561674118,
-0.0074669667519629,
0.21219870448112488,
1.1427031755447388,
-0.47111350297927856,
0.7074639797210693,
0.44997239112854004,
0.942544162273407,
0.42925137281417847,
-0.5495160222053528,
0.63515305519104,
-0.6148291826248169,
0.6575522422790527,
0.06922231614589691,
0.22224600613117218,
0.3573954701423645,
0.1794837862253189,
0.5409135818481445,
0.2103308141231537,
-0.6233716011047363,
-0.7992252111434937,
0.19746993482112885,
-1.0215356349945068,
-0.19941078126430511,
0.9638756513595581,
-0.15900646150112152,
-0.5672993659973145,
-0.45243117213249207,
-0.36836138367652893,
-0.21522609889507294,
-0.17261256277561188,
0.5957311391830444,
0.6515461206436157,
0.5055644512176514,
0.44879499077796936,
-0.9322572350502014,
0.08725015074014664,
0.2612481415271759,
-0.6973907351493835,
0.04491302743554115,
0.32632917165756226,
-0.19669109582901,
0.5414835214614868,
0.39967918395996094,
-0.12825974822044373,
0.23589709401130676,
0.04840436205267906,
0.2070658653974533,
-0.11762212216854095,
-0.25865617394447327,
-0.23614545166492462,
0.43099111318588257,
0.014786488376557827,
0.10608266294002533
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07440v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07440v3
|
Matrix-Transformation Based Low-Rank Adaptation (MTLoRA): A Brain-Inspired Method for Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning
| 2024-03-12T09:32:25 | 2024-03-30T04:36:54 |
Yao Liang, Yuwei Wang, Yang Li, Yi Zeng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Fine-tuning techniques based on Large Pretrained Language Models (LPLMs) have
been proven to significantly enhance model performance on a variety of
downstream tasks and effectively control the output behaviors of LPLMs. Recent
studies have proposed numerous methods for fine-tuning a small number of
parameters based on open-source LPLMs, reducing the demand for computational
and storage resources. Among these, reparameterization fine-tuning methods
represented by LoRA (Low-Rank Adaptation) have gained popularity. We find that
although these methods perform well in many aspects, there is still
considerable room for improvement in terms of complex task adaptability,
performance, stability, and algorithm complexity. In response to this, inspired
by the idea that the functions of the brain are shaped by its geometric
structure, this paper integrates this idea into LoRA technology and proposes a
new matrix transformation-based reparameterization method for efficient
fine-tuning, named Matrix-Transformation based Low-Rank Adaptation (MTLoRA).
MTLoRA aims to dynamically alter its spatial geometric structure by applying a
transformation-matrix T to perform linear transformations, such as rotation,
scaling, and translation, on the task-specific parameter matrix, generating new
matrix feature patterns (eigenvectors) to mimic the fundamental influence of
complex geometric structure feature patterns in the brain on functions, thereby
enhancing the model's performance in downstream tasks. In Natural Language
Understanding (NLU) tasks, it is evaluated using the GLUE benchmark test, and
the results reveal that MTLoRA achieves an overall performance increase of
about 1.0% across eight tasks; in Natural Language Generation (NLG) tasks,
MTLoRA improves performance by an average of 0.95% and 0.56% in the DART and
WebNLG tasks, respectively.
|
[
-0.5080121159553528,
-1.0897808074951172,
0.3574448525905609,
0.010977203957736492,
-0.36270514130592346,
-0.003172652330249548,
-0.3851204216480255,
-0.4209185838699341,
0.3003994822502136,
0.4001004993915558,
-0.593026340007782,
-0.6322034001350403,
-0.4747936427593231,
-0.026425562798976898,
0.08595801889896393,
0.828432559967041,
-0.12175491452217102,
0.04421372339129448,
0.4324966371059418,
-0.4169290065765381,
-0.8753401041030884,
-0.24450963735580444,
-0.8043734431266785,
-0.35631313920021057,
1.1271781921386719,
0.4745601415634155,
0.427428275346756,
0.6565396189689636,
0.46891462802886963,
0.3007298409938812,
-0.00468435836955905,
0.4195445477962494,
-0.8571557402610779,
-0.22503720223903656,
-0.1738831102848053,
-0.7969694137573242,
-0.8439095616340637,
-0.03212934732437134,
0.6255331039428711,
0.7642291784286499,
-0.4064440429210663,
0.6087505221366882,
0.4932209849357605,
1.131313443183899,
-0.7272302508354187,
0.09595536440610886,
-0.8640483617782593,
0.08820562064647675,
-0.204532653093338,
-0.592976987361908,
-0.337462842464447,
-0.664365828037262,
-0.27817845344543457,
-0.8250514268875122,
-0.18019065260887146,
0.1986706554889679,
0.6635774970054626,
0.656015932559967,
0.08894082903862,
0.0382862351834774,
-0.707239031791687,
0.7103761434555054,
-0.8970413208007812,
0.36706531047821045,
0.28757399320602417,
0.7279819846153259,
-0.37872979044914246,
-0.4841671288013458,
-0.44448521733283997,
0.002246609190478921,
0.17555584013462067,
-0.0839061364531517,
-0.2952233850955963,
0.02850654534995556,
0.20194604992866516,
-0.02910085953772068,
-0.570082426071167,
0.5080598592758179,
-0.4278298020362854,
0.19273599982261658,
0.13021470606327057,
0.09870658069849014,
0.2846304178237915,
-0.01033878605812788,
-0.046865496784448624,
-0.30442771315574646,
-1.034375548362732,
0.2382422834634781,
0.08441286534070969,
0.7761781811714172,
-0.06725771725177765,
0.5765768885612488,
-0.3234561085700989,
0.8924322128295898,
0.20549102127552032,
-0.3343063294887543,
0.1247510239481926,
-0.04064512252807617,
-0.571024477481842,
0.2993217706680298,
0.3843800127506256,
0.06122119352221489,
0.17162437736988068,
0.060221023857593536,
0.05526633560657501,
0.16750162839889526,
0.19947795569896698,
-0.8461082577705383,
-0.031755413860082626,
-0.0639115646481514,
-0.697243869304657,
-0.13272686302661896,
-0.3547753393650055,
-0.7313745021820068,
-0.3614668846130371,
-0.617705762386322,
0.6669033765792847,
-0.4715486764907837,
0.1656004935503006,
0.32643258571624756,
0.3536630868911743,
0.19802099466323853,
0.6838026642799377,
-0.704418957233429,
0.2107018083333969,
0.6129105091094971,
0.8484461307525635,
-0.31039220094680786,
-0.32752352952957153,
-0.8244161605834961,
0.11034812033176422,
-0.2915070950984955,
1.033270239830017,
-0.3633146286010742,
0.12204296141862869,
-0.23749008774757385,
-0.03719470277428627,
-0.40438947081565857,
-0.5258752703666687,
0.2931312620639801,
-0.4614136815071106,
0.2218686193227768,
-0.2478032261133194,
0.2200109213590622,
-0.3586800992488861,
0.2398691326379776,
-0.5278958082199097,
1.0139825344085693,
0.23540645837783813,
-0.5533700585365295,
0.24676315486431122,
-1.037563681602478,
-0.19534873962402344,
-0.2310132533311844,
0.13323494791984558,
-0.3174062967300415,
0.17673087120056152,
0.24217303097248077,
0.045456282794475555,
-0.28827786445617676,
-0.21184706687927246,
-0.38348475098609924,
-0.5339748859405518,
0.30453595519065857,
-0.24283114075660706,
0.5027894377708435,
0.15046869218349457,
-0.24114252626895905,
0.3479282557964325,
-0.8636059761047363,
0.3041001260280609,
-0.16575199365615845,
-0.6265065670013428,
-0.41697928309440613,
-0.030480410903692245,
-0.09818314760923386,
0.3686913549900055,
0.3198418915271759,
-0.34198346734046936,
0.3261781632900238,
-0.601719856262207,
0.3484865427017212,
0.8082568049430847,
-0.05377639830112457,
0.42427071928977966,
-0.22254429757595062,
0.32764899730682373,
0.035254914313554764,
0.18511426448822021,
0.5509859323501587,
-0.37304818630218506,
-0.9891827702522278,
-0.2920258641242981,
0.35599687695503235,
0.5034172534942627,
-0.9668850898742676,
0.490707665681839,
-0.40420612692832947,
-0.6777477264404297,
-0.7809230089187622,
0.37167271971702576,
0.3346221446990967,
0.5568349361419678,
0.600510835647583,
-0.20619158446788788,
-0.6310057640075684,
-1.0304081439971924,
-0.4177696406841278,
0.09361040592193604,
-0.04576152563095093,
0.09400814771652222,
0.24850186705589294,
-0.20511135458946228,
0.7170732617378235,
-0.5949376225471497,
-0.700628936290741,
-0.13039015233516693,
0.0911577045917511,
0.5714678764343262,
0.5118392109870911,
0.6399425864219666,
-0.1435355693101883,
-0.5417631268501282,
0.3343448340892792,
-0.4838315546512604,
-0.16114099323749542,
0.25254207849502563,
-0.3447364270687103,
0.21481361985206604,
0.3636558949947357,
-0.3142552375793457,
0.444339781999588,
0.7366598844528198,
-0.33057665824890137,
0.014664570800960064,
-0.5052326321601868,
0.1415703147649765,
-1.0189145803451538,
0.304787814617157,
-0.30867549777030945,
-0.1730511635541916,
-0.711645245552063,
-0.044337693601846695,
-0.13632044196128845,
-0.027949942275881767,
-0.4486302435398102,
0.12076595425605774,
-0.35007473826408386,
-0.18154817819595337,
-0.5552660822868347,
0.38474738597869873,
-0.3035053312778473,
0.9872360229492188,
-0.5210348963737488,
0.7218188643455505,
0.1594199687242508,
-0.6247531175613403,
-0.16267147660255432,
0.1721988469362259,
-0.3609807789325714,
0.6684021353721619,
-0.43307510018348694,
0.25195077061653137,
-0.05264807492494583,
0.015662143006920815,
-0.8141604661941528,
0.393231064081192,
0.22869957983493805,
-0.13702625036239624,
0.04576052725315094,
-0.17156115174293518,
-0.5223304629325867,
0.001991395838558674,
-0.23772229254245758,
0.2799614369869232,
0.5708878636360168,
-0.47821712493896484,
0.6388556957244873,
0.29394662380218506,
-0.29694855213165283,
-0.3706749677658081,
-0.5655189156532288,
0.007137080188840628,
-0.3636311888694763,
-0.33377689123153687,
0.19390299916267395,
-0.22999881207942963,
-0.020786378532648087,
-0.416469931602478,
0.08949173986911774,
0.13707885146141052,
0.1409374624490738,
0.23312443494796753,
0.1577490270137787,
-0.5809440612792969,
-0.25827106833457947,
0.4502471387386322,
-0.23805563151836395,
-0.44837284088134766,
-0.19459961354732513,
0.7610229849815369,
-0.09947742521762848,
-0.2163350135087967,
-0.6929928660392761,
-0.05877210944890976,
0.5600597858428955,
-0.15986952185630798,
0.6865310668945312,
0.7573255896568298,
-0.3109184503555298,
-0.4032639265060425,
-0.3349308371543884,
-0.3100277781486511,
-0.5482938289642334,
0.4812682271003723,
-0.4608532786369324,
-0.8161961436271667,
0.465415358543396,
-0.23297585546970367,
0.04983657971024513,
0.3024503290653229,
0.660261869430542,
-0.12561628222465515,
0.927789032459259,
0.7249417901039124,
-0.058872900903224945,
0.6916850805282593,
-0.1486690640449524,
0.2390815019607544,
-1.0986852645874023,
0.17093515396118164,
-0.6787643432617188,
-0.9846524000167847,
-0.6099669337272644,
-0.5524791479110718,
0.4420625865459442,
0.16145707666873932,
-0.2269594371318817,
0.5022239089012146,
-0.6622060537338257,
0.13789203763008118,
0.30435895919799805,
0.22093644738197327,
0.4600023925304413,
0.3217287063598633,
0.056624580174684525,
-0.3146915137767792,
-0.7028066515922546,
-0.414580762386322,
0.8630781173706055,
0.3056849539279938,
0.6645299196243286,
0.27782192826271057,
0.2770322561264038,
0.24091187119483948,
0.4699828028678894,
-0.6434658169746399,
0.5780177116394043,
-0.41977348923683167,
-0.06121603026986122,
-0.4931345582008362,
-0.2871689796447754,
-1.1502439975738525,
0.5457132458686829,
-0.3940592110157013,
-0.9096405506134033,
0.49537500739097595,
0.13401411473751068,
-0.434944212436676,
0.3211528956890106,
-0.5385945439338684,
0.5504652857780457,
-0.10326055437326431,
-0.26685237884521484,
-0.5516144037246704,
-0.05460411682724953,
0.16231493651866913,
-0.21630768477916718,
0.16008500754833221,
-0.17925167083740234,
0.1174924224615097,
0.8922375440597534,
-0.19470268487930298,
0.812086284160614,
-0.46419715881347656,
-0.36858364939689636,
-0.07631177455186844,
0.22508373856544495,
0.5317522883415222,
-0.12377231568098068,
-0.13074178993701935,
0.15346507728099823,
0.12680473923683167,
-0.23541651666164398,
-0.8805981278419495,
0.8843498826026917,
-0.9879950881004333,
-0.4608021378517151,
-0.06542167067527771,
-0.7672480940818787,
-0.415569007396698,
0.4877251088619232,
-0.15352433919906616,
0.15200121700763702,
-0.24652419984340668,
0.33192339539527893,
0.4996740221977234,
-0.23034685850143433,
0.3980475962162018,
0.6214176416397095,
-0.3542023003101349,
-0.5506207346916199,
1.018868088722229,
0.23444698750972748,
0.02756670117378235,
0.49342238903045654,
0.11755993962287903,
0.21704016625881195,
-0.7786794304847717,
-0.4238787591457367,
0.30323728919029236,
-0.46969541907310486,
-0.1963871717453003,
-0.0970359519124031,
-0.016882574185729027,
-0.021565118804574013,
-0.14971493184566498,
-0.5744938850402832,
-0.5066794753074646,
-0.2963395118713379,
0.2069011777639389,
0.2151421159505844,
0.689759373664856,
0.1988077014684677,
0.39494749903678894,
-0.2686171531677246,
0.5905274748802185,
0.27388837933540344,
0.3642030656337738,
0.025731392204761505,
-0.6829344034194946,
-0.3995063006877899,
0.2840856611728668,
-0.2265550047159195,
-0.3789147436618805,
0.5164780020713806,
0.2291368991136551,
0.345528244972229,
0.29137909412384033,
-0.25965455174446106,
1.07280433177948,
-0.7608832120895386,
0.24722525477409363,
0.10268332064151764,
-0.6439042091369629,
0.39175158739089966,
-0.3121354281902313,
0.24019885063171387,
0.6634051203727722,
-0.3403635323047638,
-0.2419053465127945,
-0.04582294449210167,
0.042337093502283096,
-0.3915540277957916,
0.6678655743598938,
0.3509643077850342,
-0.3108060657978058,
0.7644663453102112,
0.5044794082641602,
0.23191995918750763,
0.12142513692378998,
-0.46437254548072815,
-0.30352523922920227,
-0.25850731134414673,
-0.21147727966308594,
-0.3160266578197479,
0.01889604702591896,
-0.30082160234451294,
-0.48391130566596985,
0.4834917485713959,
-0.5381969213485718,
0.35953953862190247,
0.024133337661623955,
-0.27215835452079773,
-0.2944276034832001,
0.44420018792152405,
1.1753257513046265,
0.8074887990951538,
-0.4152723252773285,
0.05758262798190117,
0.5593429207801819,
-0.5408993363380432,
0.004204301163554192,
0.05477825552225113,
-0.12802445888519287,
-0.20972037315368652,
-0.054344769567251205,
0.8718571066856384,
0.42194145917892456,
-0.16122925281524658,
-0.16760797798633575,
-0.10475107282400131,
-0.10908649861812592,
-0.07747477293014526,
0.36578986048698425,
0.11300873011350632,
0.24962124228477478,
0.5061965584754944,
0.22396336495876312,
-0.19732508063316345,
-0.5153844952583313,
-0.23939751088619232,
0.3753114640712738,
-0.4458799958229065,
-0.5403770804405212,
0.3929995894432068,
-0.147884801030159,
-0.4695691466331482,
0.038933344185352325,
0.2857833206653595,
0.0686032772064209,
0.2792320251464844,
0.7423511743545532,
0.6614305377006531,
-0.2991352081298828,
-0.018400069326162338,
0.29758960008621216,
0.41438746452331543,
0.17814147472381592,
0.43943122029304504,
0.2042042464017868,
-0.5549063086509705,
-0.2746998965740204,
-0.7979773879051208,
-0.04293026402592659,
0.0372394323348999,
-0.5800700783729553,
0.21514903008937836,
-0.689842164516449,
-0.2479674220085144,
-0.035062406212091446,
-0.0018573402194306254,
-0.5283116698265076,
-0.03010525181889534,
-0.008769568987190723,
0.9169954657554626,
-0.4878387749195099,
1.3155841827392578,
0.5600888133049011,
-0.20958009362220764,
-0.48331978917121887,
-0.3754365146160126,
-0.38008913397789,
-0.8173597455024719,
0.7743207216262817,
-0.23288047313690186,
-0.45591747760772705,
0.1987232118844986,
-0.434372216463089,
-1.0753198862075806,
1.471798062324524,
0.8175884485244751,
-0.46859410405158997,
-0.2513214945793152,
0.40493983030319214,
0.8101271390914917,
-0.5551895499229431,
-0.25250503420829773,
0.48302462697029114,
0.665685772895813,
-0.2901829481124878,
-0.9991358518600464,
0.15822134912014008,
-0.10652231425046921,
0.3992500603199005,
0.12699942290782928,
-0.48137861490249634,
0.909094512462616,
0.11328612267971039,
-0.1381809413433075,
0.19632722437381744,
0.6619088649749756,
0.6398494243621826,
0.16215954720973969,
0.5325965881347656,
0.43500715494155884,
0.7788814306259155,
0.0769651010632515,
0.6142287850379944,
-0.37163782119750977,
0.2693454623222351,
1.0525686740875244,
-0.1993294209241867,
1.3515543937683105,
0.8198318481445312,
-0.11631087958812714,
0.9854756593704224,
0.25464144349098206,
0.15028752386569977,
0.5841334462165833,
0.17679399251937866,
0.38983502984046936,
-0.08797587454319,
0.11618070304393768,
-0.36280861496925354,
0.5173932313919067,
0.5441036224365234,
-0.20460140705108643,
-0.324218213558197,
0.1474599838256836,
-0.08643749356269836,
0.036664821207523346,
-0.5004189610481262,
0.6738370060920715,
0.315186083316803,
-0.5306673645973206,
1.0659185647964478,
0.18443888425827026,
0.6152756214141846,
-0.577370285987854,
-0.14400281012058258,
-0.06658707559108734,
0.5553311705589294,
-0.17527413368225098,
-0.20941802859306335,
-0.01823441870510578,
-0.2528430223464966,
-0.16809312999248505,
-0.01344174612313509,
0.6630228161811829,
-0.2547491788864136,
-0.3949642479419708,
0.289908230304718,
0.6005358099937439,
-0.1352231353521347,
-0.10637082159519196,
-0.778711199760437,
0.12191957235336304,
-0.011530138552188873,
-0.2026176154613495,
0.6720398664474487,
0.10653728991746902,
-0.05757107213139534,
0.6732521057128906,
0.9973316788673401,
0.313017874956131,
0.017158398404717445,
-0.06304587423801422,
0.8770813345909119,
-0.7043272852897644,
-0.5857503414154053,
-0.5886926054954529,
0.1776636689901352,
0.2053173929452896,
-0.17177419364452362,
0.6906853318214417,
0.3863382637500763,
0.24637193977832794,
-0.1435861438512802,
0.3179479241371155,
0.23022359609603882,
0.49076712131500244,
-0.756547212600708,
1.1299912929534912,
-0.525993824005127,
0.10923886299133301,
-0.3404301106929779,
-1.2801345586776733,
-0.31871604919433594,
0.6474341750144958,
-0.3511817753314972,
-0.027194762602448463,
0.9461107850074768,
0.8901985883712769,
-0.2772144675254822,
-0.4132843315601349,
0.5238109230995178,
0.5080182552337646,
0.2868891954421997,
0.7632739543914795,
0.2997511923313141,
-0.6493845582008362,
0.4163295030593872,
0.02931184321641922,
-0.07657845318317413,
-0.41120901703834534,
-0.6379094123840332,
-0.9414452314376831,
-0.5537245273590088,
-0.1671430617570877,
-0.332466185092926,
0.1574007272720337,
0.6630351543426514,
0.6864569783210754,
-0.9315652251243591,
-0.3543309271335602,
0.08879261463880539,
0.026508817449212074,
-0.3879869282245636,
-0.19289372861385345,
0.6968340277671814,
-0.1380935162305832,
-0.6541025638580322,
0.6557900905609131,
0.502935528755188,
-0.2054445743560791,
-0.36542296409606934,
-0.11445260792970657,
-0.2658088505268097,
0.09104795008897781,
0.8352543711662292,
0.4653615355491638,
-0.6974115371704102,
-0.4299648106098175,
-0.11869240552186966,
-0.32592105865478516,
0.4097069501876831,
0.6344081163406372,
-0.8411390781402588,
0.08624793589115143,
0.5323807001113892,
0.38752007484436035,
0.2843109667301178,
-0.01738245226442814,
0.4858020544052124,
-0.3153417110443115,
0.2249523252248764,
-0.2822902500629425,
0.34726789593696594,
0.19658371806144714,
-0.18289288878440857,
0.3963810205459595,
-0.132371723651886,
-0.3148091733455658,
-0.9415347576141357,
0.06010109931230545,
-1.3752760887145996,
-0.21969923377037048,
0.9639847278594971,
0.2465517222881317,
-0.7182008624076843,
-0.11846065521240234,
-0.5560736060142517,
0.30080410838127136,
-0.3028794229030609,
1.0265907049179077,
-0.018217334523797035,
-0.2304137647151947,
-0.2515186369419098,
-0.5757156610488892,
0.5602606534957886,
0.42773646116256714,
-1.0578211545944214,
0.03549175709486008,
0.06149774789810181,
0.3130303919315338,
0.35943707823753357,
0.2564520537853241,
-0.13663089275360107,
0.25357604026794434,
-0.5649752020835876,
0.1861766129732132,
-0.23309920728206635,
0.03373972326517105,
-0.4702722430229187,
0.38841119408607483,
0.3686297833919525,
-0.1481652706861496
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09722v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09722v2
|
Enhancing Readmission Prediction with Deep Learning: Extracting Biomedical Concepts from Clinical Texts
| 2024-03-12T09:03:44 | 2024-04-06T10:39:02 |
Rasoul Samani, Mohammad Dehghani, Fahime Shahrokh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Hospital readmission, defined as patients being re-hospitalized shortly after
discharge, is a critical concern as it impacts patient outcomes and healthcare
costs. Identifying patients at risk of readmission allows for timely
interventions, reducing re-hospitalization rates and overall treatment costs.
This study focuses on predicting patient readmission within less than 30 days
using text mining techniques applied to discharge report texts from electronic
health records (EHR). Various machine learning and deep learning methods were
employed to develop a classification model for this purpose. A novel aspect of
this research involves leveraging the Bio-Discharge Summary Bert (BDSS) model
along with principal component analysis (PCA) feature extraction to preprocess
data for deep learning model input. Our analysis of the MIMIC-III dataset
indicates that our approach, which combines the BDSS model with a multilayer
perceptron (MLP), outperforms state-of-the-art methods. This model achieved a
recall of 94% and an area under the curve (AUC) of 75%, showcasing its
effectiveness in predicting patient readmissions. This study contributes to the
advancement of predictive modeling in healthcare by integrating text mining
techniques with deep learning algorithms to improve patient outcomes and
optimize resource allocation.
|
[
0.08710633963346481,
-0.39384084939956665,
0.9936972260475159,
0.03903929889202118,
-0.12220250815153122,
0.3495267331600189,
0.051905322819948196,
-0.49501290917396545,
-0.020356595516204834,
0.9855051636695862,
-0.633158802986145,
-0.6160390377044678,
-0.6390191912651062,
-0.06621816754341125,
-0.35056570172309875,
0.9123849272727966,
-0.22780857980251312,
0.10531540215015411,
-0.20246857404708862,
0.28437647223472595,
-0.4213201701641083,
-0.5150981545448303,
-0.5665351152420044,
-0.9752131104469299,
0.44576436281204224,
0.3108356297016144,
0.13855738937854767,
0.16730748116970062,
1.0827932357788086,
0.2174248844385147,
-0.022626196965575218,
-0.028298720717430115,
-0.1536422222852707,
0.10382994264364243,
0.17501917481422424,
-0.2994258403778076,
-0.31337666511535645,
-0.30074551701545715,
0.5875746011734009,
0.8450351357460022,
-0.34424352645874023,
0.03285284712910652,
0.20719854533672333,
0.8475044965744019,
-0.35277408361434937,
0.10819868743419647,
-0.2335526943206787,
0.7412751913070679,
-0.08946999907493591,
-0.13558509945869446,
-0.6041233539581299,
-0.43405142426490784,
0.648638904094696,
-0.36358359456062317,
0.5441078543663025,
-0.21846237778663635,
0.7780548334121704,
0.19900043308734894,
-0.11822374910116196,
-0.019659891724586487,
-0.48343977332115173,
0.7377381920814514,
-0.5970795154571533,
0.4513390064239502,
0.3577524721622467,
0.6585392951965332,
0.03648938611149788,
-0.9236747026443481,
-0.24768012762069702,
-0.1554400473833084,
-0.2633417546749115,
0.14510959386825562,
-0.05201413109898567,
0.09593162685632706,
0.1440865397453308,
0.3317723274230957,
-0.6597185134887695,
0.39574551582336426,
-0.4911394715309143,
-0.18897762894630432,
0.25395095348358154,
0.5873609781265259,
0.11514773219823837,
-0.40323227643966675,
-0.6326163411140442,
0.1372295320034027,
-0.3473910689353943,
0.1262095421552658,
-0.3281252682209015,
0.32546746730804443,
-0.4276392161846161,
0.3246396780014038,
0.08113837987184525,
0.02080291137099266,
0.22598552703857422,
0.20286518335342407,
0.4264988601207733,
-0.04935076832771301,
-0.5633560419082642,
0.3390664756298065,
0.7267207503318787,
0.35095930099487305,
0.05598168820142746,
-0.0016233014175668359,
-0.1289064884185791,
-0.10099684447050095,
0.5526436567306519,
-1.2116903066635132,
-0.5998439192771912,
0.33046844601631165,
-1.2331547737121582,
-0.5638743042945862,
0.007305287290364504,
-0.9893638491630554,
-0.8313780426979065,
-0.4084647297859192,
0.07591871917247772,
-0.8594629764556885,
-0.12206362187862396,
-0.06714215129613876,
0.11636906862258911,
0.015487009659409523,
0.6193217635154724,
-0.5724406838417053,
0.4032015800476074,
0.5144373774528503,
1.0524934530258179,
-0.4922533631324768,
-0.04433432221412659,
-0.3259551525115967,
0.014822456985712051,
-0.1908930540084839,
0.5195870995521545,
-0.2048497200012207,
-0.39675629138946533,
0.3064703643321991,
0.07503478974103928,
-0.17098605632781982,
-0.4884239137172699,
0.5640579462051392,
-0.3258245587348938,
-0.06304517388343811,
0.21336793899536133,
-0.8290828466415405,
-0.43906769156455994,
0.09659557789564133,
-0.7975850105285645,
-0.005089099053293467,
0.34578800201416016,
-0.4611703157424927,
0.4637701213359833,
-0.4761015474796295,
-0.43859872221946716,
0.40794920921325684,
0.13447050750255585,
-0.8246355056762695,
0.36989763379096985,
0.26509127020835876,
0.9675437808036804,
-0.024524474516510963,
0.14107920229434967,
-0.28345704078674316,
-0.17408642172813416,
0.2555588185787201,
-0.1826874017715454,
0.538761556148529,
0.6094788312911987,
0.2503468990325928,
0.03332754969596863,
-0.5843822360038757,
-0.10747847706079483,
-0.14308343827724457,
-0.3033108115196228,
-0.14636225998401642,
0.09706419706344604,
0.0010440419428050518,
-0.07046632468700409,
0.1314029097557068,
-0.504649817943573,
0.002171938307583332,
-0.3797045052051544,
0.04255654662847519,
0.7269031405448914,
0.14841106534004211,
0.381963849067688,
-0.363594114780426,
0.5489051342010498,
0.1725212037563324,
0.229275181889534,
-0.35473352670669556,
-0.363640695810318,
-0.25571247935295105,
-0.3533368408679962,
0.2748507857322693,
0.6199946403503418,
-0.12751001119613647,
0.6116134524345398,
-0.17535151541233063,
-0.5351048111915588,
-0.40805885195732117,
-0.3077227771282196,
0.3569527268409729,
0.6052585244178772,
0.4287618398666382,
-0.13229431211948395,
-0.6904484629631042,
-0.5599371194839478,
0.043028347194194794,
-0.1003955602645874,
0.007841129787266254,
0.24061882495880127,
0.3302910625934601,
-0.7539234161376953,
0.34082454442977905,
-0.830583393573761,
-0.8484087586402893,
-0.33751410245895386,
0.18999630212783813,
0.7339946031570435,
0.5541555881500244,
0.35153818130493164,
-0.4587317705154419,
-0.4568350613117218,
0.40290942788124084,
-0.942730724811554,
0.23335683345794678,
-0.3484949767589569,
0.36221766471862793,
-0.03907110542058945,
0.5353411436080933,
-0.3540011942386627,
0.6088129281997681,
0.5994353294372559,
-0.37484756112098694,
0.2537323534488678,
-0.41604724526405334,
0.0767597183585167,
-0.948211133480072,
0.09579898416996002,
0.06390710920095444,
-0.15825004875659943,
-0.5567030906677246,
-0.2462134063243866,
0.05762670934200287,
-0.462259441614151,
-0.009615571238100529,
0.3637661933898926,
-0.02006549760699272,
0.32530486583709717,
-0.03669244423508644,
-0.6234657764434814,
0.14962194859981537,
-0.1719641536474228,
0.1393274962902069,
0.11053842306137085,
0.5370945930480957,
-0.49424856901168823,
0.13629665970802307,
0.34963396191596985,
-0.4708537459373474,
0.05665998160839081,
-0.5817088484764099,
-0.31565362215042114,
-0.23385219275951385,
0.42059987783432007,
-0.8701489567756653,
-0.33499041199684143,
0.14261415600776672,
-0.4650733172893524,
0.5331548452377319,
-0.23459087312221527,
0.034085243940353394,
-0.33926352858543396,
-0.32481566071510315,
0.2434832602739334,
0.48556771874427795,
-0.4279513955116272,
0.7649895548820496,
0.06936222314834595,
-0.34241288900375366,
-0.3968256115913391,
-0.8286510705947876,
-0.1164623275399208,
0.09320606291294098,
-0.16262289881706238,
0.7105671763420105,
0.08715204894542694,
0.0709993839263916,
0.1609213799238205,
0.27754104137420654,
-0.18289530277252197,
0.14950360357761383,
0.5024489164352417,
0.339380145072937,
-0.09556081146001816,
0.24851563572883606,
0.31832969188690186,
-0.17350830137729645,
0.25098103284835815,
-0.031675051897764206,
0.6651656031608582,
0.11230948567390442,
-0.11803784221410751,
-0.9201827645301819,
0.549027681350708,
0.7466550469398499,
0.0071151661686599255,
0.773158848285675,
0.6301752924919128,
-0.6966412663459778,
0.04209383577108383,
-0.4822234511375427,
-0.3125951290130615,
-0.35601940751075745,
0.4078100323677063,
-0.13593177497386932,
-0.3695434331893921,
0.6345454454421997,
-0.36449483036994934,
0.2116878181695938,
0.4576663076877594,
0.5079811215400696,
-0.47915610671043396,
0.5473206639289856,
0.7615171670913696,
0.10577692836523056,
0.5048062801361084,
-0.4673561155796051,
0.020585933700203896,
-0.7883633375167847,
-0.8241550326347351,
-0.4335610866546631,
-0.16555750370025635,
-0.7440791130065918,
-0.4230569303035736,
0.09668396413326263,
-0.10577540844678879,
-0.324759304523468,
-0.07682427018880844,
-0.4770645797252655,
-0.11697226762771606,
0.06778750568628311,
0.6340155601501465,
0.003350920509546995,
0.26354536414146423,
-0.17753280699253082,
-0.12295473366975784,
-0.24957959353923798,
-0.2647901177406311,
1.3041019439697266,
0.6248692870140076,
0.6470332145690918,
-0.12344563752412796,
1.2365329265594482,
0.7810642123222351,
0.39654889702796936,
-0.7183266282081604,
0.10577301681041718,
-0.6908918619155884,
-0.29030725359916687,
-0.12772493064403534,
-0.4384341835975647,
-1.1213852167129517,
-0.20458482205867767,
-0.3892704248428345,
-0.5068452954292297,
0.536750316619873,
-0.014930381439626217,
-0.5762963891029358,
0.22156840562820435,
-0.8045527935028076,
0.6336616277694702,
-0.13752037286758423,
0.23253494501113892,
-0.41230571269989014,
-0.6351063251495361,
0.1893184930086136,
-0.460121750831604,
0.0828392282128334,
0.12266532331705093,
0.151239275932312,
0.7161197662353516,
-0.4060227870941162,
0.7941644787788391,
-0.06696238368749619,
0.10153347998857498,
-0.053593043237924576,
-0.06596944481134415,
0.12038828432559967,
-0.1356484442949295,
-0.2606349289417267,
0.46797239780426025,
0.024289611726999283,
-0.18577535450458527,
-0.4026258587837219,
0.6332753300666809,
-0.8850346207618713,
0.31077057123184204,
-0.5089626312255859,
-0.20837073028087616,
0.04460787773132324,
0.3035753667354584,
0.2926977872848511,
0.40721121430397034,
-0.16325968503952026,
0.22768865525722504,
0.8352181315422058,
-0.49667397141456604,
0.47284063696861267,
0.35912200808525085,
-0.3914142847061157,
-0.6984529495239258,
0.9089947938919067,
0.07925979048013687,
-0.12846097350120544,
0.7154706716537476,
0.5651857256889343,
-0.25129052996635437,
-0.7637215852737427,
-0.1774059683084488,
0.2248009443283081,
-0.3276437819004059,
-0.38019102811813354,
-0.7575260996818542,
-0.6677740216255188,
-0.5607498288154602,
-0.3312470614910126,
-0.039488229900598526,
0.004980148747563362,
-0.5612579584121704,
-0.32598045468330383,
0.06910790503025055,
0.7818127274513245,
0.1632714867591858,
0.3376202881336212,
-1.0511562824249268,
0.5702444314956665,
-0.17280200123786926,
0.47528204321861267,
0.08487163484096527,
-0.5356335639953613,
-0.3853051960468292,
-0.4327336847782135,
-0.41001343727111816,
-0.8888826370239258,
0.6355583667755127,
-0.0045977081172168255,
0.6098058223724365,
0.868033766746521,
-0.02380971610546112,
0.4465956687927246,
-0.5175203680992126,
0.711472749710083,
0.7400977611541748,
-0.6461518406867981,
0.7424540519714355,
-0.09971881657838821,
-0.11582650989294052,
0.46637463569641113,
0.41193488240242004,
-0.1592579483985901,
0.2815849781036377,
-0.573520839214325,
-0.8068522810935974,
0.6276893615722656,
-0.04990646243095398,
-0.11882561445236206,
0.3095220625400543,
0.3937242031097412,
0.4107920229434967,
0.09546131640672684,
-0.3948725163936615,
-0.12363680452108383,
-0.20019172132015228,
-0.41495609283447266,
-0.3418053388595581,
-0.5508767366409302,
0.16891658306121826,
-0.28086307644844055,
0.3469694256782532,
0.05462179332971573,
0.36130601167678833,
0.2879362106323242,
0.06194763258099556,
-0.3653907775878906,
0.05783611163496971,
0.3397993743419647,
0.6431514024734497,
-0.5252857804298401,
-0.3207622468471527,
-0.06590364128351212,
-0.8767890930175781,
-0.047372039407491684,
0.49967777729034424,
-0.14981654286384583,
0.18602097034454346,
0.5450683236122131,
0.6447364091873169,
-0.1934473067522049,
-0.41279351711273193,
0.3326282203197479,
-0.08204804360866547,
-0.32277369499206543,
-0.5142011642456055,
-0.2741529941558838,
-0.3184964656829834,
0.26826727390289307,
0.3128090798854828,
0.19143794476985931,
0.45841118693351746,
-0.3276401460170746,
0.4776332378387451,
-0.061441682279109955,
-0.693893313407898,
-0.037984225898981094,
0.3276490271091461,
0.3751832842826843,
-0.24421656131744385,
0.7369273900985718,
0.597780168056488,
-0.1593349426984787,
0.7009665369987488,
0.39343294501304626,
1.1739089488983154,
-0.588489294052124,
0.30508869886398315,
0.2052060216665268,
-0.03327006474137306,
0.1781485229730606,
0.26621776819229126,
0.24301189184188843,
-0.4076429009437561,
-0.4804784059524536,
-0.8334892988204956,
-0.3589774966239929,
0.1350635588169098,
-0.80580073595047,
0.19541874527931213,
-0.8067374229431152,
-0.30203092098236084,
-0.021448759362101555,
0.3964385688304901,
-0.514549732208252,
0.5045656561851501,
0.5591679215431213,
0.7017443180084229,
-0.7821918725967407,
0.4351513385772705,
0.7246330380439758,
-0.24924497306346893,
-0.7648607492446899,
0.19986498355865479,
-0.23793719708919525,
-0.38560667634010315,
0.5848882794380188,
0.536618173122406,
0.20276041328907013,
-0.22061210870742798,
0.08869895339012146,
-0.25072818994522095,
0.938567042350769,
0.12154532968997955,
-0.7711679935455322,
-0.01352326013147831,
-0.20442168414592743,
0.5515937209129333,
-0.39431020617485046,
0.0245417021214962,
0.46734490990638733,
0.26041707396507263,
-0.1003301739692688,
-0.5872743129730225,
0.14510373771190643,
0.19764122366905212,
-0.3512822687625885,
0.3069359064102173,
-0.3235276937484741,
0.8468043208122253,
-0.5772786140441895,
0.25737613439559937,
0.09010306745767593,
0.6607748866081238,
0.1238216906785965,
0.8887161016464233,
0.2164323478937149,
0.7863835096359253,
0.9754430055618286,
-0.0058943722397089005,
1.1890475749969482,
0.24586902558803558,
0.2995339334011078,
0.6043159365653992,
-0.2732279300689697,
0.5726237297058105,
0.3160021901130676,
-0.3218865394592285,
0.9699375033378601,
0.46730682253837585,
-0.12503191828727722,
0.7684391736984253,
0.06662580370903015,
-0.3323279917240143,
-0.3429638743400574,
-0.20998142659664154,
-0.44513043761253357,
0.24414508044719696,
0.6061655282974243,
-0.9534440636634827,
-0.13426248729228973,
0.30196845531463623,
-0.08880029618740082,
0.053226303309202194,
-0.3969283401966095,
1.0279022455215454,
0.4039877653121948,
-0.6033550500869751,
0.22915033996105194,
-0.28918492794036865,
0.11682606488466263,
-0.5517033338546753,
-0.3705700635910034,
-0.22593726217746735,
0.8158450126647949,
-0.5330222845077515,
-0.9380861520767212,
0.05454191565513611,
-0.08630408346652985,
-0.7650160789489746,
-0.40379828214645386,
0.5613543391227722,
-0.0052926018834114075,
-0.8094708919525146,
0.4376474916934967,
0.3742567300796509,
0.12978030741214752,
0.2411850541830063,
-0.9742146730422974,
0.0014845619443804026,
-0.0390113890171051,
0.1561719924211502,
0.41311630606651306,
0.5875110626220703,
0.15764163434505463,
0.7766909599304199,
0.748469352722168,
0.5352005958557129,
-0.3124343752861023,
0.4503041207790375,
0.7747668027877808,
-0.6094787120819092,
-0.4113542437553406,
-0.9772050380706787,
0.25456926226615906,
-0.15547332167625427,
-0.0026616910472512245,
0.12621448934078217,
0.44054239988327026,
-0.022570740431547165,
-0.2418428361415863,
0.8449768424034119,
0.15047436952590942,
1.0113364458084106,
-0.6079017519950867,
0.9409011006355286,
-0.440600723028183,
0.2470725029706955,
-0.4085843563079834,
-0.13041798770427704,
-0.422826886177063,
0.3479055166244507,
-0.06710483133792877,
-0.06287342309951782,
0.6601147055625916,
0.03384628891944885,
0.19390669465065002,
-0.4187794625759125,
0.2078235000371933,
0.04515659809112549,
0.8290446400642395,
0.5839768648147583,
0.5369789004325867,
-0.26438167691230774,
0.2098565250635147,
-0.4998954236507416,
-0.26773905754089355,
-0.8069250583648682,
-0.8110781311988831,
-0.9661723971366882,
-0.20851466059684753,
-0.317063570022583,
-0.5509161949157715,
0.11005771905183792,
0.5450659394264221,
0.6702139377593994,
-1.080333948135376,
-0.052606575191020966,
-0.08972421288490295,
0.2422567754983902,
-0.35321927070617676,
-0.26688647270202637,
0.8416922688484192,
-0.46113133430480957,
-0.2510591447353363,
-0.058361299335956573,
0.19418367743492126,
0.1671617329120636,
-0.010580919682979584,
-0.05299757421016693,
0.09645231068134308,
-0.284833699464798,
0.6351990699768066,
-0.06391344219446182,
-0.5678954124450684,
0.22642602026462555,
0.030612166970968246,
-0.2558491826057434,
-0.3619258403778076,
0.9329314231872559,
-1.1542110443115234,
0.34448251128196716,
0.5052258372306824,
0.6983665227890015,
0.31295931339263916,
0.19988618791103363,
0.5078455209732056,
-0.0850304588675499,
-0.22040784358978271,
0.5828900933265686,
0.4274332523345947,
0.2193518579006195,
-0.8032719492912292,
0.14938099682331085,
0.20853561162948608,
-0.5651622414588928,
-0.6433291435241699,
0.013832728378474712,
-1.1302908658981323,
-0.3720587193965912,
0.542729914188385,
-0.4291427433490753,
0.037216734141111374,
-0.23927342891693115,
-0.02310607023537159,
0.19635528326034546,
-0.4989319443702698,
0.7193928956985474,
0.09893593937158585,
-0.4029794931411743,
-0.19229403138160706,
-0.4294857680797577,
0.5084808468818665,
0.27835792303085327,
-0.8010517358779907,
0.18914593756198883,
0.3441799283027649,
0.2194863110780716,
0.2014065980911255,
0.3265892267227173,
-0.11153744161128998,
0.5224744081497192,
-0.4462928771972656,
-0.07148005813360214,
-0.027496490627527237,
-0.5324674844741821,
-0.28416186571121216,
0.40556347370147705,
-0.40535876154899597,
-0.4880986511707306
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09721v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09721v1
|
A Semantic Mention Graph Augmented Model for Document-Level Event Argument Extraction
| 2024-03-12T08:58:07 | 2024-03-12T08:58:07 |
Jian Zhang, Changlin Yang, Haiping Zhu, Qika Lin, Fangzhi Xu, Jun Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Document-level Event Argument Extraction (DEAE) aims to identify arguments
and their specific roles from an unstructured document. The advanced approaches
on DEAE utilize prompt-based methods to guide pre-trained language models
(PLMs) in extracting arguments from input documents. They mainly concentrate on
establishing relations between triggers and entity mentions within documents,
leaving two unresolved problems: a) independent modeling of entity mentions; b)
document-prompt isolation. To this end, we propose a semantic mention Graph
Augmented Model (GAM) to address these two problems in this paper. Firstly, GAM
constructs a semantic mention graph that captures relations within and between
documents and prompts, encompassing co-existence, co-reference and co-type
relations. Furthermore, we introduce an ensembled graph transformer module to
address mentions and their three semantic relations effectively. Later, the
graph-augmented encoder-decoder module incorporates the relation-specific graph
into the input embedding of PLMs and optimizes the encoder section with
topology information, enhancing the relations comprehensively. Extensive
experiments on the RAMS and WikiEvents datasets demonstrate the effectiveness
of our approach, surpassing baseline methods and achieving a new
state-of-the-art performance.
|
[
-0.6813464760780334,
-1.0963335037231445,
0.5211175084114075,
-0.3218276798725128,
-0.4220767915248871,
-0.13929344713687897,
0.012198593467473984,
-0.5960263013839722,
0.19295433163642883,
0.4093495011329651,
-0.5211256146430969,
-0.5877120494842529,
-0.8298258781433105,
0.28408172726631165,
-0.49069246649742126,
1.0642647743225098,
-0.06367319077253342,
-0.12153598666191101,
-0.40175920724868774,
-0.03942164406180382,
-0.3727787137031555,
-0.5494890809059143,
-0.8904994130134583,
-0.18359480798244476,
0.6064138412475586,
0.10414613783359528,
0.33162227272987366,
0.3926031291484833,
0.34958499670028687,
0.25960785150527954,
-0.14087751507759094,
0.4751046895980835,
-0.02892717532813549,
0.12875397503376007,
-0.21457640826702118,
0.046151820570230484,
-0.6813769936561584,
0.08918603509664536,
0.5820616483688354,
0.549801230430603,
0.2293953001499176,
-0.08789365738630295,
-0.027737542986869812,
-0.07434666156768799,
-0.4295541048049927,
0.3744538426399231,
-0.7690941095352173,
-0.28392720222473145,
-0.1019306555390358,
-0.2722863554954529,
-0.5917921662330627,
-0.0913224145770073,
0.07637536525726318,
-0.7420957684516907,
0.315314918756485,
0.0441962331533432,
1.4513288736343384,
-0.14479778707027435,
-0.34803590178489685,
-0.4741904139518738,
-0.4137028753757477,
0.3174329698085785,
-0.6974536180496216,
0.2791517674922943,
0.24829089641571045,
-0.05489173159003258,
-0.49658772349357605,
-1.0718278884887695,
-0.653860867023468,
-0.13901609182357788,
-0.1573837846517563,
0.17852476239204407,
-0.32671046257019043,
0.27320918440818787,
0.3149830102920532,
0.20286960899829865,
-0.17652736604213715,
0.03284500166773796,
-0.12151581794023514,
-0.28764334321022034,
0.427639365196228,
0.04729343578219414,
0.6580531001091003,
-0.4105094373226166,
-0.49261608719825745,
0.11861243844032288,
-0.5024285316467285,
-0.09297618269920349,
0.4159749150276184,
0.2080320417881012,
0.103725366294384,
0.39728665351867676,
0.0022417258005589247,
0.914713978767395,
0.32211577892303467,
0.1526099294424057,
-0.14371149241924286,
-0.3880596160888672,
-0.05865311622619629,
0.03404683619737625,
1.024896502494812,
0.1164906919002533,
0.18934683501720428,
-0.5065012574195862,
0.08386223018169403,
0.17102596163749695,
0.10396591573953629,
-0.7904092669487,
-0.32871013879776,
0.1897076815366745,
-0.13531138002872467,
-0.11541512608528137,
0.11111240088939667,
-0.9208768010139465,
-0.5403133630752563,
-0.1614348292350769,
0.40997493267059326,
-0.5050444602966309,
-0.2120780497789383,
-0.09502578526735306,
-0.6259260177612305,
0.16451705992221832,
0.45988965034484863,
-0.7956216335296631,
0.5660983920097351,
0.7105468511581421,
0.6029654741287231,
-0.18636637926101685,
-0.13847468793392181,
-0.8882769346237183,
0.4576234519481659,
-0.1566142439842224,
1.1870445013046265,
-0.8283925652503967,
-0.5320557355880737,
-0.02729908935725689,
0.05089343339204788,
-0.35583028197288513,
-0.41348525881767273,
0.8159738183021545,
-0.7440300583839417,
0.3157923221588135,
-0.18363438546657562,
-1.0730899572372437,
-0.2364485114812851,
0.3750641345977783,
-0.812462568283081,
1.050325632095337,
0.07140208035707474,
-0.8059774041175842,
0.6408106088638306,
-0.97091144323349,
-0.2995091378688812,
0.3927757143974304,
-0.3429134786128998,
-0.24553027749061584,
-0.23453707993030548,
0.5176833271980286,
0.3541439473628998,
-0.2860453724861145,
0.11709532886743546,
-0.37668707966804504,
0.09850120544433594,
-0.11171247810125351,
-0.04077513888478279,
0.7251875400543213,
0.017294446006417274,
0.07125626504421234,
0.3909624218940735,
-0.8894422054290771,
-0.3792019188404083,
0.07131553441286087,
-0.1265600621700287,
-0.542013943195343,
0.09137548506259918,
-0.35129818320274353,
0.48438209295272827,
0.24318267405033112,
-0.8411110639572144,
0.09557972848415375,
-0.49542760848999023,
0.2892712950706482,
0.36315274238586426,
0.6796045899391174,
0.4729996621608734,
0.2783687710762024,
0.48727086186408997,
0.3010435402393341,
-0.11518193036317825,
-0.3437306880950928,
-0.5163879990577698,
-0.5225250720977783,
-0.44949251413345337,
0.30623674392700195,
0.41819149255752563,
-0.6152582764625549,
0.5911142230033875,
-0.38071390986442566,
0.0186797846108675,
-0.4208061993122101,
0.1566494256258011,
-0.10946681350469589,
0.9446539282798767,
0.2701752781867981,
0.056644316762685776,
-0.6306185126304626,
-0.5676183700561523,
-0.17214171588420868,
-0.30498960614204407,
0.021521784365177155,
0.23666448891162872,
0.3201429843902588,
0.005216054152697325,
1.288324236869812,
-0.4533379375934601,
-0.19529269635677338,
-0.40054836869239807,
0.3877481520175934,
-0.06211399659514427,
0.1375100016593933,
0.3890233337879181,
-0.5485751628875732,
-0.2029443085193634,
0.21703889966011047,
-0.8688181638717651,
-0.15326961874961853,
-0.03971272334456444,
-0.22006240487098694,
0.18322697281837463,
0.5191295742988586,
-0.853351891040802,
0.472320020198822,
-0.06150444224476814,
-0.4038190245628357,
0.25847548246383667,
-0.17576026916503906,
0.0008230403182096779,
-1.285902738571167,
-0.16638024151325226,
0.038894038647413254,
-0.15461090207099915,
-0.5022847652435303,
-0.08995448797941208,
-0.20819306373596191,
-0.4051489233970642,
-0.1447901576757431,
0.7558770775794983,
-0.5924109816551208,
0.185553640127182,
-0.33579155802726746,
0.5815002918243408,
0.3714992105960846,
0.37255263328552246,
0.39402031898498535,
0.3148731291294098,
0.5415962338447571,
-0.5981569290161133,
0.4415195882320404,
0.4336228668689728,
-0.08604633808135986,
0.5148048400878906,
-0.5864356756210327,
0.3384395241737366,
-0.013445205986499786,
0.2556902766227722,
-1.0476255416870117,
-0.08648458868265152,
0.36130592226982117,
-0.43812447786331177,
0.5016471743583679,
-0.40889567136764526,
-0.6277462840080261,
-0.2558852434158325,
-0.16143004596233368,
0.0010455275187268853,
0.21705207228660583,
-0.5808620452880859,
0.9957011938095093,
0.5708959698677063,
-0.3148757815361023,
-0.1970730423927307,
-0.1853625327348709,
0.472262978553772,
-0.3351249098777771,
-0.8827082514762878,
0.19893860816955566,
0.40461283922195435,
-0.03141745552420616,
0.21795055270195007,
-0.023294780403375626,
-0.16492745280265808,
0.09244117140769958,
0.17910067737102509,
0.46325457096099854,
-0.16114842891693115,
0.06511885672807693,
0.027931179851293564,
-0.3545014560222626,
0.2077730894088745,
-0.33028098940849304,
0.43009263277053833,
0.11830136179924011,
-0.14463046193122864,
-0.32410934567451477,
0.8293865919113159,
0.2503747344017029,
-0.40173453092575073,
0.6253344416618347,
0.6681942343711853,
-0.5803159475326538,
-0.10837767273187637,
-0.3844451308250427,
-0.17024628818035126,
-0.3869228661060333,
0.5289775133132935,
-0.526024580001831,
-0.6385313868522644,
0.8469312191009521,
-0.4782683849334717,
0.12369967997074127,
0.7064458131790161,
0.34795939922332764,
-0.04058586806058884,
0.9058629274368286,
0.24517901241779327,
0.06164119392633438,
0.4634300768375397,
-0.3080551028251648,
0.3131169378757477,
-0.8809557557106018,
-0.27343910932540894,
-0.5513147711753845,
0.19560544192790985,
-0.20647399127483368,
-0.25174108147621155,
0.24623747169971466,
0.4526318609714508,
-0.0019248236203566194,
0.44168612360954285,
-0.31681591272354126,
0.14199891686439514,
0.1735142022371292,
-0.29738637804985046,
0.20140643417835236,
0.05978596210479736,
-0.21441061794757843,
0.11767734587192535,
-0.8941707015037537,
-0.660327672958374,
0.3576330840587616,
0.18511521816253662,
0.461618036031723,
-0.15702958405017853,
0.9297423362731934,
0.276635080575943,
0.2173183262348175,
-0.8218610882759094,
0.6975107789039612,
-0.05451612174510956,
-0.4091475307941437,
-0.2500114142894745,
-0.18541884422302246,
-1.1441768407821655,
0.23402686417102814,
-0.04014044255018234,
-1.159767746925354,
0.4016075134277344,
-0.053495995700359344,
-0.16433240473270416,
0.3779081106185913,
-0.7749862670898438,
1.0565152168273926,
0.3592665493488312,
-0.17823322117328644,
0.039047740399837494,
-0.4932314455509186,
0.032442931085824966,
0.26133841276168823,
0.09949474036693573,
-0.05582357197999954,
0.0033395017962902784,
1.0647003650665283,
-0.6777403354644775,
0.6734163761138916,
-0.25304892659187317,
-0.2455248385667801,
0.8133329153060913,
-0.008553978987038136,
0.8570470213890076,
0.017530374228954315,
-0.16011768579483032,
0.20699389278888702,
-0.03477593511343002,
-0.17087434232234955,
-0.7177585959434509,
0.6967746019363403,
-0.6245250105857849,
-0.7201455235481262,
-0.11495950073003769,
-0.6787346601486206,
-0.40025874972343445,
0.2222810685634613,
0.2763475179672241,
0.9823433756828308,
-0.24396856129169464,
-0.22428779304027557,
0.3581025004386902,
0.0756845772266388,
0.7812654972076416,
0.4609821140766144,
0.030369983986020088,
-0.5851280689239502,
0.9591248035430908,
0.16886349022388458,
0.025929506868124008,
0.3393424153327942,
0.15226764976978302,
-0.5297984480857849,
-0.4128439426422119,
-0.7625266909599304,
0.06469635665416718,
-1.013129711151123,
-0.1639612466096878,
-1.1436268091201782,
-0.09778416901826859,
-0.40689781308174133,
-0.08294165879487991,
0.07426416128873825,
-0.41184791922569275,
-0.4460706114768982,
-0.3555085062980652,
0.5565451383590698,
0.4906061589717865,
0.19195686280727386,
0.12498220801353455,
-0.961791455745697,
0.39383018016815186,
0.0465078242123127,
0.11448726058006287,
0.04216362535953522,
-0.4172056019306183,
-0.06697343289852142,
-0.2982727289199829,
-0.12982505559921265,
-1.0806666612625122,
0.10071257501840591,
0.16934005916118622,
0.6870750784873962,
0.36955466866493225,
0.20352816581726074,
0.6480618119239807,
-0.3972286581993103,
0.8754593133926392,
0.20774170756340027,
-0.6888490915298462,
0.6105706691741943,
-0.4617629647254944,
-0.038091253489255905,
0.2637408375740051,
0.19507509469985962,
-0.3299430012702942,
-0.5319820642471313,
-0.819074809551239,
-0.838080644607544,
0.8647803664207458,
-0.11435547471046448,
0.001291288179345429,
-0.6545918583869934,
0.3703869581222534,
0.05861198529601097,
-0.15705998241901398,
-0.4824180006980896,
0.0011063871206715703,
0.05414189398288727,
-0.2207058072090149,
0.44198480248451233,
-0.41012343764305115,
-0.1336243897676468,
-0.1866070181131363,
0.48088985681533813,
-0.028218774124979973,
0.11732848733663559,
0.2282225489616394,
-0.23969513177871704,
0.10714467614889145,
0.2991633713245392,
0.28521594405174255,
0.4492912292480469,
-0.10205298662185669,
0.25914621353149414,
0.3072343170642853,
-0.3540564179420471,
-0.07318618893623352,
0.4833921790122986,
-0.19619041681289673,
0.3722359538078308,
0.4830115735530853,
0.904223620891571,
0.1281505525112152,
-0.08017775416374207,
0.3803899884223938,
0.0678936243057251,
-0.06931230425834656,
0.12580814957618713,
-0.05242471396923065,
0.28065699338912964,
-0.2148859202861786,
0.2244117110967636,
-0.14694029092788696,
0.15867193043231964,
-0.34731075167655945,
0.38482099771499634,
0.4310767650604248,
-0.3926236927509308,
-0.3799385130405426,
0.6441924571990967,
0.5621691346168518,
-0.2572939693927765,
0.25073185563087463,
-0.29859572649002075,
-0.2816034257411957,
0.5690495371818542,
0.6126050353050232,
0.9480345249176025,
0.0985451266169548,
0.1852339804172516,
0.3632003664970398,
0.047955770045518875,
0.5795466303825378,
0.004174572881311178,
-0.341459184885025,
-0.7116081714630127,
-0.4458923041820526,
-0.5740236043930054,
-0.1396811157464981,
0.07900682091712952,
-0.6426489353179932,
0.5301035642623901,
-0.2586849331855774,
-0.23292583227157593,
0.35412898659706116,
0.20179307460784912,
-0.42287567257881165,
0.02277512475848198,
0.10249409079551697,
0.9435217976570129,
-0.7207612991333008,
0.7817959785461426,
0.8371729254722595,
-0.7508842349052429,
-0.7978351712226868,
-0.242601677775383,
-0.49730926752090454,
-0.25773972272872925,
0.5538454055786133,
-0.22378049790859222,
-0.2676221430301666,
0.2952699065208435,
-0.1750352829694748,
-0.4784330725669861,
0.6887637376785278,
0.4511919617652893,
-0.1589687168598175,
0.026035066694021225,
-0.039381951093673706,
0.34619656205177307,
-0.5229926705360413,
0.38432809710502625,
0.2977569103240967,
0.3655069172382355,
0.32593485713005066,
-0.4047955870628357,
0.16808585822582245,
-0.1505395770072937,
-0.12968610227108002,
0.47575005888938904,
-0.257320761680603,
0.4309394955635071,
-0.08842531591653824,
-0.4834601581096649,
-0.2078462690114975,
0.8831267356872559,
-0.009631121531128883,
0.4089401662349701,
0.4142763912677765,
0.5076270699501038,
0.8223390579223633,
0.0501229465007782,
1.2903822660446167,
-0.34800443053245544,
0.19823670387268066,
1.2351540327072144,
-0.4927038848400116,
0.5548437833786011,
0.3068518042564392,
0.034378327429294586,
0.8060102462768555,
0.6095602512359619,
0.10405341535806656,
0.27805212140083313,
-0.20651505887508392,
-0.4829171299934387,
-0.4385843276977539,
-0.27870145440101624,
-0.23125618696212769,
0.21202422678470612,
0.5698732733726501,
-0.3884899318218231,
-0.8118373155593872,
-0.2185467630624771,
0.18388411402702332,
-0.039972711354494095,
-0.2430269569158554,
1.2642784118652344,
0.04202227666974068,
-0.5965933203697205,
0.2669856548309326,
-0.008199124597012997,
0.14185741543769836,
-0.7598617076873779,
-0.2866166830062866,
0.07510798424482346,
-0.05530019477009773,
-0.2719459533691406,
-0.5282671451568604,
0.23857519030570984,
0.16251324117183685,
-0.42507973313331604,
0.26599857211112976,
1.277268409729004,
-0.5308330655097961,
-0.43741846084594727,
0.42476746439933777,
0.4287715256214142,
0.12783797085285187,
0.23751099407672882,
-0.32358860969543457,
-0.0638994425535202,
-0.48485028743743896,
-0.17142269015312195,
0.40662306547164917,
0.6279860138893127,
-0.3505856990814209,
0.13765935599803925,
0.5922093987464905,
0.06704497337341309,
0.1443435698747635,
0.30558228492736816,
0.8826099038124084,
-0.4085898697376251,
-0.5823147296905518,
-0.9693179130554199,
0.39768534898757935,
-0.5625823140144348,
-0.22571724653244019,
0.796788215637207,
0.4829772710800171,
0.22048276662826538,
0.029751604422926903,
0.664756178855896,
-0.03646393120288849,
0.16400568187236786,
-0.24183426797389984,
0.3835235834121704,
-0.02710823155939579,
0.08426842838525772,
-0.43319031596183777,
-0.5605229139328003,
-0.20167754590511322,
0.2524414360523224,
-0.5036766529083252,
-0.047567933797836304,
0.6553452014923096,
0.6573785543441772,
0.04562430456280708,
0.23916752636432648,
0.30306458473205566,
-0.07001499831676483,
0.561157763004303,
0.43747782707214355,
0.8065134286880493,
-0.4065952003002167,
0.5360406041145325,
0.26315969228744507,
-0.052411314100027084,
0.07044588774442673,
-1.0322647094726562,
-0.7976841926574707,
-0.5856242179870605,
-0.8979911208152771,
-0.2761039733886719,
-0.06426043808460236,
0.6685003042221069,
0.5113728046417236,
-0.8087444305419922,
0.18052637577056885,
-0.19965264201164246,
0.2665424942970276,
-0.03069758042693138,
-0.25888121128082275,
0.7310503125190735,
-0.6400864124298096,
-0.6428899168968201,
0.367664635181427,
0.497744619846344,
-0.27091115713119507,
0.1994224339723587,
0.02499149553477764,
-0.6038013100624084,
0.23677487671375275,
0.5802891254425049,
0.20511935651302338,
-0.6825845241546631,
-0.551177442073822,
-0.3638617694377899,
0.038128748536109924,
0.050834499299526215,
0.7570816278457642,
-0.7589859366416931,
0.6651094555854797,
0.569485604763031,
0.6804136037826538,
0.4554806351661682,
0.2610574960708618,
0.5294336676597595,
-0.846696138381958,
0.2062521129846573,
0.009619430638849735,
0.6781294345855713,
0.24171842634677887,
-0.42918267846107483,
0.29426825046539307,
0.49088943004608154,
-0.13688184320926666,
-0.709601879119873,
0.10897665470838547,
-1.2209019660949707,
-0.056180961430072784,
1.3216971158981323,
-0.5632826685905457,
-0.3111332058906555,
-0.39775776863098145,
-0.3550494611263275,
0.5224519371986389,
-0.30556386709213257,
0.4503277838230133,
0.9917658567428589,
-0.27538955211639404,
-0.19336125254631042,
-0.15863251686096191,
0.43459784984588623,
-0.08277774602174759,
-0.8577244877815247,
0.1366003304719925,
0.6478559374809265,
0.28125038743019104,
0.33679988980293274,
0.5102789402008057,
-0.43372270464897156,
0.3285464644432068,
0.4241478443145752,
0.17003288865089417,
-0.4504055082798004,
-0.12151035666465759,
-0.2520467936992645,
0.5317698121070862,
0.041645489633083344,
-0.568440318107605
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09720v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09720v1
|
Fine-tuning vs Prompting, Can Language Models Understand Human Values?
| 2024-03-12T08:49:31 | 2024-03-12T08:49:31 |
Pingwei Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Accurately handling the underlying support values in sentences is crucial for
understanding the speaker's tendencies, yet it poses a challenging task in
natural language understanding (NLU). In this article, we explore the potential
of fine-tuning and prompt tuning in this downstream task, using the Human Value
Detection 2023. Additionally, we attempt to validate whether models can
effectively solve the problem based on the knowledge acquired during the
pre-training stage. Simultaneously, our interest lies in the capabilities of
large language models (LLMs) aligned with RLHF in this task, and some
preliminary attempts are presented.
|
[
-0.6139663457870483,
-0.8407713770866394,
0.7050715088844299,
-0.07983432710170746,
-0.2887527644634247,
-0.30438628792762756,
-0.2390858381986618,
-0.6906837821006775,
-0.3448213040828705,
0.6687005758285522,
-1.0416193008422852,
-0.03870217129588127,
-0.4999569058418274,
0.2819419205188751,
0.06198015809059143,
0.8619459271430969,
0.23473595082759857,
0.07570567727088928,
-0.1585281640291214,
-0.17563679814338684,
-0.7633286118507385,
-0.48970094323158264,
-0.8003094792366028,
-0.559032142162323,
0.5768439173698425,
0.743632435798645,
0.8206019401550293,
0.7362608313560486,
0.22373461723327637,
0.23276765644550323,
-0.34128352999687195,
0.11803855746984482,
-0.3683793544769287,
0.2833597958087921,
-0.12010617554187775,
-0.3515419363975525,
-0.4736245572566986,
0.1487577110528946,
0.5677119493484497,
0.8733499646186829,
-0.03473708778619766,
0.07516326010227203,
0.07468610256910324,
0.7376638650894165,
-0.2841004431247711,
0.10961693525314331,
-0.8462700247764587,
-0.1958504021167755,
-0.05930235981941223,
-0.12581941485404968,
-0.40929731726646423,
-0.25257742404937744,
0.06247042864561081,
-0.4746292233467102,
0.19467979669570923,
0.15776152908802032,
1.3668137788772583,
0.5787261128425598,
-0.3167910873889923,
-0.21950536966323853,
-0.2678639888763428,
0.8530031442642212,
-0.6765304803848267,
0.4491384029388428,
0.7242700457572937,
0.14600197970867157,
-0.3980819582939148,
-0.18970231711864471,
-0.5459129214286804,
-0.3231164216995239,
-0.026793168857693672,
-0.21099022030830383,
-0.15601158142089844,
0.2772939205169678,
0.32040977478027344,
0.465522438287735,
-0.2929479777812958,
0.6423258781433105,
-0.2194424271583557,
-0.08820662647485733,
0.5288112759590149,
0.2619125545024872,
0.27236366271972656,
-0.4505345821380615,
-0.041816167533397675,
-0.034747179597616196,
-0.625277578830719,
0.4852101504802704,
0.448968768119812,
0.6934648752212524,
0.10607630014419556,
0.2966959476470947,
-0.38833698630332947,
0.9299843311309814,
0.22123616933822632,
0.0908665880560875,
-0.08390538394451141,
-0.48927611112594604,
-0.4769071042537689,
-0.024759627878665924,
0.4438532590866089,
0.4193120002746582,
0.8341796398162842,
0.15744921565055847,
-0.27704930305480957,
-0.11950340121984482,
0.3830503225326538,
-0.7589982748031616,
-0.10647750645875931,
0.13989801704883575,
-0.5455633997917175,
-0.39400044083595276,
-0.2866784930229187,
-0.4616667330265045,
-0.5031092762947083,
-0.7011553049087524,
0.17031630873680115,
-0.28396841883659363,
-0.2285970002412796,
0.3648226261138916,
0.14860424399375916,
0.4478241503238678,
0.5973067283630371,
-1.3701109886169434,
0.14118124544620514,
0.6280945539474487,
0.5100276470184326,
0.03525415435433388,
-0.13187746703624725,
-0.8270564079284668,
-0.36619600653648376,
-0.10822643339633942,
0.9268078804016113,
-0.49299558997154236,
-0.513467013835907,
-0.14154814183712006,
0.18478575348854065,
0.06962784379720688,
-0.6852685809135437,
0.7284818291664124,
-0.6151383519172668,
0.1561078131198883,
-0.6764638423919678,
-0.6193650960922241,
0.018588466569781303,
0.3525432348251343,
-0.8158441185951233,
0.8995409607887268,
0.26726585626602173,
-0.4706404507160187,
0.5463281273841858,
-0.6981897354125977,
-0.3047828674316406,
0.17117606103420258,
0.10736966878175735,
-0.5642634034156799,
0.2068423181772232,
0.3870377242565155,
0.7057816386222839,
-0.1674399971961975,
0.4705975353717804,
-0.32103943824768066,
-0.2980208396911621,
0.22177448868751526,
-0.5896334052085876,
0.6375676393508911,
0.18740737438201904,
0.05982470512390137,
0.43720513582229614,
-0.7940565347671509,
-0.05253063142299652,
0.0188467837870121,
-0.35624030232429504,
-0.13358239829540253,
0.05619882792234421,
-0.0036671292036771774,
0.1530979424715042,
0.04763678461313248,
-0.10483993589878082,
0.3070618808269501,
-0.40974029898643494,
0.494523823261261,
0.984342098236084,
0.019224483519792557,
0.4965537488460541,
-0.223059743642807,
0.7758671641349792,
-0.2170286625623703,
0.040204547345638275,
-0.45471420884132385,
-0.5743481516838074,
-0.6578353047370911,
-0.04990772157907486,
0.1601947844028473,
0.4285648763179779,
-0.17175701260566711,
0.5383660793304443,
0.1365552395582199,
-0.03124583140015602,
-0.7897429466247559,
0.2711378037929535,
0.023112988099455833,
0.8285686373710632,
0.6077969074249268,
0.41321370005607605,
-0.6507992744445801,
-0.8386197090148926,
-0.5337699055671692,
-0.2293647825717926,
-0.13519559800624847,
0.3512097895145416,
0.34238338470458984,
-0.2597300708293915,
1.0002403259277344,
-0.27857086062431335,
-0.012339302338659763,
-0.4476245045661926,
0.24906006455421448,
0.26300331950187683,
0.3714706003665924,
0.20070098340511322,
-0.8707129955291748,
-0.20661883056163788,
-0.03829622641205788,
-0.43973755836486816,
-0.3824145495891571,
-0.08295530825853348,
0.1029367595911026,
0.16109009087085724,
0.7799351215362549,
-0.37410634756088257,
0.33425259590148926,
0.47024083137512207,
-0.5175641179084778,
0.5606673359870911,
-0.33040234446525574,
0.22835564613342285,
-0.8849533796310425,
0.05355369672179222,
0.14433996379375458,
-0.4777206480503082,
-0.7402190566062927,
-0.12589384615421295,
0.2056947499513626,
0.16890718042850494,
-0.32435721158981323,
0.6378105282783508,
-0.2371063232421875,
0.17636488378047943,
-0.5258203148841858,
0.15312938392162323,
0.07713362574577332,
0.12735769152641296,
0.06790963560342789,
0.8474698066711426,
0.0409221388399601,
-0.8095724582672119,
0.41008099913597107,
0.15379464626312256,
-0.42648687958717346,
0.7655907869338989,
-0.7598094344139099,
-0.0944262370467186,
-0.2939912676811218,
0.02979441173374653,
-0.9065672755241394,
-0.46253108978271484,
0.09952601045370102,
-0.5505719780921936,
0.05344498157501221,
-0.25850555300712585,
-0.40565305948257446,
-0.23240062594413757,
0.0549929104745388,
0.17543892562389374,
0.5019083619117737,
-0.39550334215164185,
0.24556073546409607,
0.3140665292739868,
-0.18443943560123444,
-0.4187716245651245,
-0.28600963950157166,
0.11008176952600479,
-0.49053680896759033,
-0.576117753982544,
0.1813834011554718,
-0.02217574417591095,
-0.4387259781360626,
-0.27902573347091675,
0.17361252009868622,
0.03197415545582771,
0.533873438835144,
0.2095845639705658,
0.31883084774017334,
-0.13392993807792664,
0.43468669056892395,
-0.028557434678077698,
-0.46814224123954773,
0.15264171361923218,
-0.3143231272697449,
0.506159245967865,
-0.2497054487466812,
-0.19364817440509796,
-0.7590847015380859,
0.11255092173814774,
0.4133918881416321,
-0.38796183466911316,
0.655418872833252,
0.6851935982704163,
-0.4509398937225342,
0.04669986665248871,
-0.5569056868553162,
-0.49813926219940186,
-0.49468758702278137,
0.37683627009391785,
-0.2693859338760376,
-1.2792341709136963,
0.5848281979560852,
0.11625083535909653,
-0.2374320924282074,
0.3642321825027466,
0.6065784692764282,
-0.2715621590614319,
1.1523511409759521,
0.767405092716217,
-0.15957020223140717,
0.45177915692329407,
0.15150849521160126,
0.19593143463134766,
-0.687338650226593,
-0.08706185966730118,
-0.80129075050354,
-0.18535462021827698,
-0.5667881369590759,
-0.061454739421606064,
0.14759284257888794,
0.4546012580394745,
-0.16967566311359406,
0.11314144730567932,
-0.2673227787017822,
0.477500855922699,
0.3832135498523712,
0.14827609062194824,
0.20189645886421204,
-0.4077068567276001,
0.24666152894496918,
-0.04923715069890022,
-0.4157918393611908,
-0.6992583870887756,
0.5225939154624939,
0.6458906531333923,
0.6016897559165955,
-0.2428133636713028,
0.23433458805084229,
0.0860462412238121,
0.10902903228998184,
-1.1102571487426758,
0.4011066257953644,
0.19954435527324677,
-0.5058730244636536,
-0.6487531065940857,
-0.30099502205848694,
-1.069477915763855,
0.11176186800003052,
-0.15379035472869873,
-0.7686036229133606,
0.015724483877420425,
0.5789251327514648,
-0.7953752875328064,
0.14721491932868958,
-0.7289020419120789,
1.2453645467758179,
-0.14470043778419495,
-0.104204460978508,
-0.2824622690677643,
-0.6727487444877625,
0.1063457727432251,
0.14060699939727783,
0.3190278708934784,
-0.5157228708267212,
0.19335104525089264,
0.6204392910003662,
-0.11586146056652069,
0.7740455269813538,
-0.26352056860923767,
-0.34650853276252747,
0.0065324376337230206,
-0.15436619520187378,
0.469952255487442,
0.2140703648328781,
-0.2857327461242676,
-0.41434094309806824,
-0.07133951783180237,
-0.6545840501785278,
-0.42750152945518494,
0.4734686017036438,
-0.46651339530944824,
-0.7989168763160706,
-0.1973205804824829,
-0.67513108253479,
-0.29451310634613037,
0.2441912293434143,
0.1382436454296112,
0.11710724979639053,
-0.1760205775499344,
0.053241487592458725,
0.9979873895645142,
-0.31977105140686035,
0.492255836725235,
0.2490018606185913,
-0.0638745054602623,
-0.017817150801420212,
0.4641125202178955,
-0.17393991351127625,
0.5018121600151062,
0.2919965088367462,
0.4467966854572296,
-0.39362862706184387,
-0.5645647048950195,
-0.5965502262115479,
0.11203918606042862,
-0.619661271572113,
-0.16011250019073486,
-0.5286445617675781,
0.22024020552635193,
-0.3853021264076233,
-0.2753984034061432,
-0.13085085153579712,
0.07902012020349503,
-0.8917637467384338,
-0.3264729678630829,
0.7281214594841003,
0.9545828700065613,
0.07646102458238602,
0.3085353672504425,
-0.9651303887367249,
0.3519246280193329,
0.5150864720344543,
0.38460761308670044,
-0.10440309345722198,
-0.6897185444831848,
-0.3044559061527252,
0.31071922183036804,
0.055463992059230804,
-0.7565696835517883,
0.4418187439441681,
0.01987001672387123,
0.5196334719657898,
0.4339180886745453,
0.07427377998828888,
0.8401012420654297,
-0.304536372423172,
0.8636845350265503,
-0.19631779193878174,
-1.0571941137313843,
0.8731738924980164,
-0.40735170245170593,
0.5534403920173645,
0.7792935371398926,
0.3825468122959137,
-0.7411104440689087,
-0.03303060680627823,
-0.44780299067497253,
-0.5559360980987549,
0.8158637285232544,
-0.33135104179382324,
0.2651214003562927,
0.10363548994064331,
0.6437534689903259,
-0.07648016512393951,
0.04337393492460251,
-0.6127721071243286,
0.2257448434829712,
-0.06088446080684662,
-0.150126650929451,
-0.051246292889118195,
-0.3224332630634308,
0.23556289076805115,
-0.3727916479110718,
0.37728944420814514,
-0.37623313069343567,
-0.10899963974952698,
-0.015603945590555668,
-0.19230949878692627,
-0.42812561988830566,
0.5059968829154968,
0.7938364148139954,
0.630562961101532,
-0.384762704372406,
0.04989778622984886,
0.47162526845932007,
-0.24483859539031982,
0.032560087740421295,
-0.11501467227935791,
0.07598471641540527,
-0.453812837600708,
0.37626364827156067,
1.048763394355774,
0.2806152105331421,
-0.7443904280662537,
0.4551032483577728,
-0.06307227909564972,
-0.01388523168861866,
0.00453599076718092,
0.20261064171791077,
0.0902319923043251,
-0.003570142900571227,
0.2832735776901245,
0.07422690093517303,
-0.06577134132385254,
-0.5673250555992126,
0.2485419511795044,
0.47947514057159424,
-0.7696964740753174,
-0.3717976212501526,
0.5598227381706238,
0.18560416996479034,
-0.4660720229148865,
0.8139616847038269,
-0.35457509756088257,
-0.7369593381881714,
0.5594805479049683,
0.31162092089653015,
0.5850590467453003,
-0.32124239206314087,
-0.0683981403708458,
0.27534881234169006,
0.038694094866514206,
-0.08603988587856293,
0.25053778290748596,
-0.15868383646011353,
-1.1472177505493164,
-0.7134038209915161,
-0.6229188442230225,
-0.39504629373550415,
0.23257671296596527,
-0.9355268478393555,
0.4572415351867676,
-0.2505064606666565,
0.019970150664448738,
0.17566606402397156,
0.05628442391753197,
-0.588449239730835,
0.3477972745895386,
0.15646575391292572,
0.8993483185768127,
-0.8575072884559631,
1.1047730445861816,
0.5132712125778198,
-0.3147021234035492,
-0.907601535320282,
-0.03795018792152405,
-0.013961615040898323,
-0.8798248767852783,
0.8540149927139282,
0.35481277108192444,
-0.253060519695282,
0.10881352424621582,
-0.5545147061347961,
-0.2986992597579956,
0.8308678269386292,
0.33162498474121094,
-0.4274787902832031,
-0.17857448756694794,
-0.09542085230350494,
0.4056028425693512,
-0.10326851904392242,
0.13282844424247742,
0.9902633428573608,
0.8820225596427917,
-0.14069412648677826,
-1.0405000448226929,
-0.13393032550811768,
-0.04910529404878616,
-0.03688260540366173,
0.10803531855344772,
-0.18516412377357483,
0.7637984752655029,
-0.291513592004776,
-0.12534932792186737,
0.03000473603606224,
0.6767682433128357,
0.24444742500782013,
0.057386111468076706,
0.8267054557800293,
0.4428892135620117,
0.9571632146835327,
-0.2094733566045761,
0.987578809261322,
-0.08359044790267944,
0.25456884503364563,
0.8385825157165527,
-0.026438135653734207,
0.8470631241798401,
0.47466105222702026,
-0.23336827754974365,
0.2778656482696533,
0.920315682888031,
0.20391471683979034,
0.16076385974884033,
0.11420836299657822,
-0.14215020835399628,
-0.7265496253967285,
-0.282022088766098,
-0.28296470642089844,
0.4932447373867035,
0.504023015499115,
-0.1373678594827652,
-0.14097411930561066,
0.22628599405288696,
0.20372316241264343,
0.3190443813800812,
-0.46761733293533325,
0.8470826148986816,
0.06121347099542618,
-0.9239916205406189,
0.7434389591217041,
-0.056843169033527374,
0.6589559316635132,
-0.36066150665283203,
0.061386458575725555,
-0.039577364921569824,
0.08593898266553879,
-0.11086633056402206,
-0.9948506355285645,
0.366549551486969,
-0.03549911081790924,
-0.3420889675617218,
-0.7035293579101562,
0.6714881062507629,
-0.30623599886894226,
-0.14519917964935303,
0.315532922744751,
0.3066718578338623,
-0.2354685515165329,
-0.38431742787361145,
-0.5635361075401306,
0.0645420029759407,
0.032368775457143784,
-0.07843601703643799,
0.26195454597473145,
0.4821363389492035,
-0.0073314569890499115,
0.8027753829956055,
0.6248360276222229,
-0.07617030292749405,
-0.12049620598554611,
0.37039607763290405,
0.6858786940574646,
-0.8216128945350647,
-0.5019885897636414,
-1.125796914100647,
0.47326138615608215,
0.08280543237924576,
-0.49606603384017944,
0.5868328809738159,
-0.0013905209489166737,
0.7951226234436035,
-0.044366247951984406,
0.5382286310195923,
0.39999285340309143,
0.5494331121444702,
-0.7183821201324463,
0.5674315094947815,
-0.40908145904541016,
0.1576913595199585,
-0.07626303285360336,
-0.41951262950897217,
-0.5844200253486633,
0.8157472610473633,
-0.28903377056121826,
0.013534264639019966,
0.23620815575122833,
0.8165299296379089,
0.15762434899806976,
0.2585403621196747,
0.44171783328056335,
0.025808120146393776,
0.45177197456359863,
0.4124967157840729,
1.0375264883041382,
-0.11808029562234879,
0.174859419465065,
0.14647024869918823,
-0.09841825813055038,
-0.5260213613510132,
-1.09139883518219,
-0.8324744701385498,
-0.5550745725631714,
-0.051943015307188034,
-0.3086891174316406,
-0.027781657874584198,
1.2264363765716553,
0.8694102168083191,
-1.0430582761764526,
-0.1753237098455429,
-0.43530067801475525,
0.24605226516723633,
-0.13461518287658691,
-0.1501902937889099,
0.044414155185222626,
-0.8318890333175659,
-0.7167364954948425,
0.4222261905670166,
0.30358439683914185,
0.23632484674453735,
-0.36341458559036255,
-0.24066083133220673,
-0.3061721622943878,
0.09597344696521759,
0.5100241899490356,
0.28039243817329407,
-0.8942726850509644,
-0.6286845207214355,
0.21438997983932495,
-0.025690587237477303,
0.16834841668605804,
0.9249276518821716,
-0.9582259058952332,
0.36706680059432983,
0.5509822964668274,
0.7241368293762207,
0.10116105526685715,
0.1807900071144104,
0.6792764663696289,
-0.582692563533783,
0.051045384258031845,
0.24117523431777954,
0.44200167059898376,
0.44729751348495483,
-0.5080077052116394,
0.021167710423469543,
0.08856210857629776,
-0.840787410736084,
-0.822318434715271,
0.5714431405067444,
-0.8876392841339111,
-0.2704457938671112,
0.9300251603126526,
0.05692606046795845,
0.04239252209663391,
-0.37558940052986145,
-0.4009664058685303,
0.20789898931980133,
-0.3570726215839386,
0.5968655943870544,
0.767470121383667,
-0.17304232716560364,
-0.6744500994682312,
-0.7445918917655945,
0.8826231360435486,
0.5274226069450378,
-0.9213643074035645,
0.34894800186157227,
0.29145944118499756,
0.05288397893309593,
-0.20010633766651154,
0.49265149235725403,
0.19884271919727325,
0.21775829792022705,
-0.6729426383972168,
-0.2174900770187378,
0.004499278496950865,
-0.10670382529497147,
-0.7727873921394348,
-0.029153985902667046,
0.47950100898742676,
0.0449991300702095
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09719v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09719v1
|
Mevaker: Conclusion Extraction and Allocation Resources for the Hebrew Language
| 2024-03-12T08:40:44 | 2024-03-12T08:40:44 |
Vitaly Shalumov, Harel Haskey, Yuval Solaz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this paper, we introduce summarization MevakerSumm and conclusion
extraction MevakerConc datasets for the Hebrew language based on the State
Comptroller and Ombudsman of Israel reports, along with two auxiliary datasets.
We accompany these datasets with models for conclusion extraction (HeConE,
HeConEspc) and conclusion allocation (HeCross). All of the code, datasets, and
model checkpoints used in this work are publicly available.
|
[
-0.23183365166187286,
-0.3314475119113922,
0.12201932817697525,
0.21414059400558472,
-0.37398967146873474,
0.028802447021007538,
-0.19480223953723907,
-0.13824330270290375,
0.24110573530197144,
0.7719895243644714,
-0.3022956848144531,
-0.5159606337547302,
-0.5330913662910461,
-0.08372560143470764,
-0.5536423921585083,
1.0270543098449707,
-0.16858814656734467,
0.08148624747991562,
-0.12322963029146194,
-0.37051883339881897,
-0.743895947933197,
-0.1573082059621811,
-0.34679853916168213,
-0.5026726722717285,
0.20001563429832458,
1.0674877166748047,
0.523567795753479,
0.5053890347480774,
0.48508593440055847,
0.4995620846748352,
0.1404167264699936,
-0.3513462245464325,
-0.1382961869239807,
0.19035345315933228,
-0.4917893707752228,
-0.4384860694408417,
-0.1320788413286209,
0.03282495215535164,
0.8271552920341492,
0.5738040804862976,
-0.5100881457328796,
0.5306603312492371,
-0.41118595004081726,
0.8237283825874329,
-1.323446273803711,
0.2787092328071594,
-0.1375322937965393,
0.17504331469535828,
-0.3808908462524414,
-0.4558688700199127,
-0.5221782326698303,
-0.4945582449436188,
0.437135249376297,
-0.2618483304977417,
0.2806586027145386,
0.3380240797996521,
0.44972532987594604,
0.26701971888542175,
-0.17626871168613434,
-0.5904698967933655,
-0.7961450219154358,
1.0429253578186035,
-0.6862573027610779,
0.4036194384098053,
0.38220351934432983,
0.7277882099151611,
0.01441558264195919,
-0.8378134965896606,
-0.3144212067127228,
-0.03739463537931442,
-0.08618041127920151,
0.6581723690032959,
-0.6459907293319702,
-0.3718460202217102,
0.03545163944363594,
0.5109136700630188,
-0.486521452665329,
0.154282346367836,
-1.0564990043640137,
-0.28736650943756104,
0.3586947023868561,
0.43001046776771545,
0.26251232624053955,
-0.5077194571495056,
-0.14798152446746826,
-0.214423269033432,
-0.7627447843551636,
0.1803121268749237,
0.4322623014450073,
-0.14409716427326202,
-0.4049346446990967,
1.0271698236465454,
-0.5308946967124939,
0.9445133209228516,
-0.4193625748157501,
-0.30662280321121216,
0.2305656224489212,
-0.47978514432907104,
-0.3648741543292999,
0.6024472117424011,
0.917940080165863,
0.35358569025993347,
0.2605535686016083,
-0.08735058456659317,
0.22340627014636993,
-0.2677079141139984,
0.32010942697525024,
-0.6513991951942444,
-0.24713143706321716,
0.20274870097637177,
-0.9579585790634155,
-0.23404663801193237,
0.3411550521850586,
-0.7661603689193726,
-0.0687258243560791,
-0.2627734839916229,
-0.3185967206954956,
-0.3148696720600128,
-0.4466213285923004,
0.23936691880226135,
-0.5683108568191528,
0.4060596227645874,
0.25731244683265686,
-0.7951385974884033,
0.5789976119995117,
0.4069488048553467,
0.7639586329460144,
-0.14310665428638458,
-0.24226129055023193,
-0.6667930483818054,
0.09602708369493484,
-0.31843751668930054,
0.8914973735809326,
-0.7029229402542114,
-0.35625025629997253,
0.048366863280534744,
0.05615571513772011,
0.17610488831996918,
-0.612544059753418,
0.5263527631759644,
-0.6216871738433838,
0.29664817452430725,
-0.25259101390838623,
-0.6576219201087952,
-0.06694118678569794,
-0.11399827897548676,
-0.8713787198066711,
0.5144206881523132,
0.13831652700901031,
-0.8762376308441162,
-0.06850520521402359,
-0.5989497900009155,
-0.22292527556419373,
0.09746237844228745,
-0.5046310424804688,
-0.16110339760780334,
0.493710994720459,
-0.09405293315649033,
0.5389174222946167,
-0.6722813248634338,
0.1252548098564148,
0.3571110963821411,
-0.02754870243370533,
0.21201884746551514,
-0.15096980333328247,
1.1485178470611572,
0.7634588479995728,
-0.010006769560277462,
0.16320517659187317,
-0.9253076910972595,
-0.34931352734565735,
0.13115112483501434,
-0.563138484954834,
-0.4073566794395447,
0.25273436307907104,
0.07060332596302032,
-0.04075703024864197,
0.2513532042503357,
-0.6885350942611694,
-0.2234443724155426,
-0.1920684576034546,
-0.08123452216386795,
0.6881804466247559,
-0.11503569036722183,
0.6045254468917847,
0.15297184884548187,
0.9158102869987488,
-0.20159927010536194,
-0.1923028826713562,
-0.18925917148590088,
-0.2770114541053772,
-0.523193895816803,
-0.11977139115333557,
0.5097777843475342,
0.5553893446922302,
-0.7035725116729736,
0.6303512454032898,
-0.2630106806755066,
-0.41768503189086914,
-0.3270317614078522,
-0.2908961772918701,
0.6353446841239929,
0.7072493433952332,
0.2306753545999527,
-0.19805078208446503,
-0.4951918423175812,
-1.1406528949737549,
-0.10112851858139038,
-0.14946463704109192,
0.0697903111577034,
-0.21838676929473877,
0.4208395481109619,
0.6103276610374451,
1.0673496723175049,
-0.7164872288703918,
0.14276419579982758,
-0.48721736669540405,
0.24986866116523743,
0.21624943614006042,
0.494369238615036,
0.5367531776428223,
-0.5685873627662659,
-0.39756524562835693,
0.008737822994589806,
-0.8438674807548523,
-0.11781421303749084,
0.2161421775817871,
-0.06304336339235306,
-0.2819910943508148,
0.8064284920692444,
0.04536794498562813,
0.7346011400222778,
0.5027698278427124,
-0.7431573867797852,
1.136555552482605,
-0.11907479166984558,
0.20013095438480377,
-1.2385156154632568,
-0.0509888231754303,
-0.30044272541999817,
-0.7092669606208801,
-0.3661648631095886,
-0.07018467783927917,
0.011932099238038063,
0.3338607847690582,
-0.524392306804657,
0.4916260540485382,
-0.6913977265357971,
-0.5136809349060059,
-0.3925285339355469,
-0.023325534537434578,
-0.23781590163707733,
0.14658072590827942,
-0.17858755588531494,
0.8884774446487427,
0.5187040567398071,
-0.3677683472633362,
0.953050971031189,
0.8105208873748779,
-0.6842507719993591,
0.45775511860847473,
-0.684331476688385,
-0.46469491720199585,
-0.26648038625717163,
0.010814526118338108,
-0.7717804312705994,
-0.2422706037759781,
0.4441903233528137,
-0.35650143027305603,
0.35271239280700684,
-0.10393915325403214,
-0.4553147852420807,
-0.2283843755722046,
-0.2796781063079834,
0.36647942662239075,
0.704450249671936,
-0.422349214553833,
0.43368059396743774,
0.4593864977359772,
-0.6361119151115417,
-0.8613900542259216,
-0.6218738555908203,
-0.03159581869840622,
0.07532920688390732,
-0.14974425733089447,
0.014587387442588806,
-0.0007594741182401776,
-0.7334263920783997,
0.417827844619751,
0.05044941231608391,
0.15426188707351685,
-0.13771234452724457,
0.24709050357341766,
0.13089942932128906,
-0.18368636071681976,
-0.061904966831207275,
0.08736690878868103,
-0.5738666653633118,
-0.06944345682859421,
0.2963670492172241,
0.6147608160972595,
-0.27860206365585327,
-0.5882989764213562,
-0.13248039782047272,
0.48920494318008423,
-0.0405496321618557,
-0.5299709439277649,
0.5855702757835388,
0.43111416697502136,
-0.2876567542552948,
0.3306125998497009,
-0.6437689065933228,
0.21143384277820587,
-0.4251423478126526,
0.3861943185329437,
-0.46413394808769226,
-0.8075194954872131,
0.6393201351165771,
-0.1576584130525589,
0.38895612955093384,
0.6410000324249268,
1.0916633605957031,
0.2908494770526886,
0.6194455027580261,
0.264689177274704,
-0.2896936237812042,
0.6026760935783386,
-0.18682198226451874,
-0.20653827488422394,
-0.876061201095581,
-0.21929404139518738,
-0.825979471206665,
-0.20511266589164734,
-0.659115731716156,
-0.056837525218725204,
0.04791200906038284,
-0.036693353205919266,
0.2972177565097809,
0.23917816579341888,
-0.18454256653785706,
0.9027695059776306,
0.8986928462982178,
-0.3443770706653595,
0.36026158928871155,
0.29475659132003784,
-0.1686973124742508,
0.008980480022728443,
-0.5673837065696716,
-0.4721212685108185,
0.859982967376709,
0.1322821080684662,
0.5885584354400635,
0.31402093172073364,
0.6089034676551819,
0.4268365502357483,
0.1665876805782318,
-0.4912998080253601,
0.146848663687706,
-0.20878471434116364,
-0.8730757832527161,
-0.21637868881225586,
-0.3658412992954254,
-0.9205693602561951,
0.278449147939682,
-0.007618149276822805,
-1.0973031520843506,
0.38298237323760986,
-0.31258147954940796,
-0.38543829321861267,
0.10427887737751007,
-0.6390644907951355,
0.7430434226989746,
0.3504583537578583,
-0.08114499598741531,
-0.7320098876953125,
-0.6718828678131104,
0.3472669720649719,
0.3252630829811096,
0.1253095418214798,
-0.48061230778694153,
0.3666679859161377,
1.3886773586273193,
-0.7447461485862732,
0.3416300415992737,
-0.1568903774023056,
0.14742764830589294,
0.6859793066978455,
-0.02291853167116642,
0.339082807302475,
-0.12178493291139603,
-0.16617082059383392,
-0.14226257801055908,
0.10608638823032379,
-0.567858099937439,
-0.12800659239292145,
0.5580515265464783,
-0.6841630935668945,
-0.09733768552541733,
-0.6064574122428894,
-0.5643734335899353,
0.17388153076171875,
0.23971164226531982,
0.40815049409866333,
1.0479419231414795,
-0.3964071571826935,
0.3867144286632538,
0.11195840686559677,
-0.6528060436248779,
0.5895949006080627,
0.7120115160942078,
-0.14586424827575684,
-0.5499816536903381,
1.0936410427093506,
0.08159897476434708,
-0.1787901520729065,
0.10866440087556839,
0.4684685170650482,
-0.26599377393722534,
-0.6811813116073608,
-0.22966232895851135,
-0.026911241933703423,
-1.0881277322769165,
-0.31270065903663635,
-0.4123958945274353,
-0.22708328068256378,
-0.12097471207380295,
-0.1227516233921051,
-0.7344321012496948,
-0.7034567594528198,
0.009359221905469894,
-0.3243737816810608,
0.2492508441209793,
1.0631941556930542,
-0.2314990907907486,
0.8269166350364685,
-0.8236582279205322,
0.3884751796722412,
-0.06357137113809586,
0.23594515025615692,
-0.14551304280757904,
-0.2656005918979645,
-0.5155792832374573,
-0.33151674270629883,
-0.17312076687812805,
-0.9518001675605774,
0.161504328250885,
-0.10718950629234314,
0.48503077030181885,
0.6704816222190857,
-0.0737779438495636,
0.598090410232544,
-0.7418975234031677,
0.7117983102798462,
0.8861114382743835,
-0.6183294057846069,
0.2235487699508667,
-0.12067285925149918,
0.313713014125824,
0.5764226317405701,
-0.030851848423480988,
-0.4672324061393738,
-0.5317409038543701,
-0.6977657675743103,
-0.6670293807983398,
1.0255275964736938,
0.5837317109107971,
-0.06974582374095917,
-0.12595762312412262,
0.4697219133377075,
0.5146288275718689,
0.2719348669052124,
-0.17008619010448456,
-0.801558792591095,
-0.09749232977628708,
-0.5235802531242371,
0.169300377368927,
-0.8083613514900208,
0.1877569854259491,
-0.2988472580909729,
0.5541696548461914,
0.13408716022968292,
0.19021756947040558,
-0.03751065954566002,
-0.3494478762149811,
0.03206608444452286,
0.48699286580085754,
0.5570589303970337,
1.3083891868591309,
-0.3435352146625519,
0.31973856687545776,
-0.08568406105041504,
-0.33904901146888733,
0.21352776885032654,
0.012103240936994553,
0.04885499179363251,
0.0017591404030099511,
0.8722564578056335,
0.49822503328323364,
0.039443567395210266,
-0.690808892250061,
0.5081186890602112,
-0.367059588432312,
-0.15690283477306366,
-0.5658532977104187,
-0.05178400129079819,
0.19980914890766144,
0.7041072845458984,
0.14523106813430786,
-0.19008199870586395,
0.6662741899490356,
-0.10464689135551453,
0.21096663177013397,
0.1507757604122162,
-0.10086122900247574,
-0.5761404633522034,
0.4781694710254669,
-0.08900836110115051,
0.12243271619081497,
0.7099052667617798,
-0.23277202248573303,
-0.1627914011478424,
0.5755221843719482,
0.5703608393669128,
0.7880504727363586,
-0.4282447099685669,
0.26617351174354553,
0.5531613230705261,
-0.06939902901649475,
-0.035783298313617706,
0.5770813226699829,
-0.049452099949121475,
-0.6778733730316162,
-0.7267842292785645,
-0.6149501800537109,
-0.2974218428134918,
-0.18880745768547058,
-0.9787670373916626,
0.11360464245080948,
-0.5071709156036377,
0.10246846824884415,
0.36413758993148804,
-0.20702168345451355,
-0.7451501488685608,
-0.009139549918472767,
0.0964156985282898,
0.7866144180297852,
-0.6451087594032288,
0.41382062435150146,
0.5760526657104492,
-0.6131919026374817,
-0.3996695280075073,
-0.4708520770072937,
0.01193979661911726,
-0.9808841943740845,
0.41827142238616943,
-0.2806258499622345,
-0.06346254795789719,
0.0036784231197088957,
-0.7208986878395081,
-0.721512496471405,
1.052700161933899,
0.40888819098472595,
-0.5368225574493408,
0.28862112760543823,
-0.23956671357154846,
-0.004724313039332628,
-0.20581413805484772,
0.339633047580719,
0.9429469108581543,
0.38687044382095337,
0.0979006290435791,
-0.6359766721725464,
-0.04467076063156128,
-0.21406574547290802,
-0.37892577052116394,
0.03497277945280075,
-0.6218924522399902,
0.7416799068450928,
0.10930800437927246,
-0.11792825907468796,
-0.05890081450343132,
0.8577567934989929,
0.050842758268117905,
-0.2625921070575714,
0.2925681173801422,
0.5745985507965088,
0.546072781085968,
0.19036389887332916,
1.248747706413269,
-0.051723070442676544,
0.18317897617816925,
1.4919012784957886,
0.18172399699687958,
0.7502712607383728,
0.5200660228729248,
-0.3446629047393799,
0.5868449211120605,
0.6526071429252625,
0.014708691276609898,
0.7200513482093811,
0.1858263462781906,
-0.11296027153730392,
0.015384860336780548,
-0.5410290360450745,
-0.36000576615333557,
0.8378506302833557,
0.12087078392505646,
-0.20298850536346436,
-0.7426236867904663,
-0.365127295255661,
0.16549181938171387,
-0.33999186754226685,
-0.1202135682106018,
0.9880368709564209,
0.19030286371707916,
-0.6177763342857361,
0.3190450072288513,
0.4464043080806732,
-0.06623834371566772,
-0.4210512042045593,
-0.15203264355659485,
0.13234101235866547,
0.22100992500782013,
-0.28697067499160767,
-0.6960484385490417,
0.5856694579124451,
0.11041171848773956,
-0.2842486798763275,
0.04665752127766609,
0.810518741607666,
-0.3213527202606201,
-0.6943880319595337,
0.17441298067569733,
0.77143794298172,
0.44338902831077576,
0.18170808255672455,
-0.5946717858314514,
-0.10730572044849396,
-0.014919837936758995,
-0.3985096216201782,
-0.15765677392482758,
0.11967384815216064,
-0.0959700420498848,
0.3159284293651581,
0.4605037271976471,
0.3791870176792145,
0.37461909651756287,
0.5122942328453064,
0.832086443901062,
-0.8692247271537781,
-0.5964264273643494,
-1.3110675811767578,
0.5378299951553345,
-0.28747618198394775,
-0.16549645364284515,
0.751833438873291,
0.6624252200126648,
0.3733612298965454,
-0.06060267612338066,
1.057519555091858,
-0.3838847875595093,
0.4302866756916046,
-0.6759015321731567,
0.3369872272014618,
-0.4250829815864563,
-0.21254774928092957,
-0.08303038775920868,
-0.8871451616287231,
0.038418322801589966,
0.6383894681930542,
-0.26720842719078064,
-0.22013048827648163,
0.746568500995636,
0.10188687592744827,
-0.3174445629119873,
0.04893515259027481,
0.1802886426448822,
0.062029510736465454,
0.36246418952941895,
-0.006990875117480755,
0.9810476899147034,
-0.18831557035446167,
0.22124220430850983,
-0.219391867518425,
-0.369056761264801,
-0.3377856910228729,
-0.6735100746154785,
-1.0580979585647583,
-0.5653989315032959,
-0.3499677777290344,
-0.18863512575626373,
-0.3326718509197235,
1.0450360774993896,
0.35435909032821655,
-1.2456905841827393,
-0.5784189701080322,
-0.04798019677400589,
0.27367669343948364,
0.21480108797550201,
-0.0779150053858757,
0.6687504649162292,
-0.32805636525154114,
-0.5149651765823364,
0.3755344748497009,
0.3554002344608307,
-0.16042174398899078,
-0.08416574448347092,
-0.4621180295944214,
-0.2874070405960083,
-0.3347582519054413,
0.3883476257324219,
0.145649254322052,
-0.5717584490776062,
0.025657178834080696,
-0.30646005272865295,
0.3114202618598938,
0.09701047837734222,
0.9466429352760315,
-0.2129034847021103,
0.8602515459060669,
0.7597259283065796,
0.4098261892795563,
0.7156044840812683,
0.18172433972358704,
0.8317878842353821,
-1.2116361856460571,
0.6541749238967896,
-0.3420476019382477,
0.8326507806777954,
0.2310706377029419,
0.2561506927013397,
0.5725836753845215,
-0.08299803733825684,
-0.15567095577716827,
-0.3034939169883728,
0.2702910602092743,
-0.5584573149681091,
-0.25745511054992676,
0.8873711824417114,
-0.08828280866146088,
-0.5792755484580994,
-0.4082622826099396,
-0.055346958339214325,
0.4341893494129181,
-0.42069050669670105,
0.24993081390857697,
0.9631013870239258,
0.085819773375988,
-0.16419994831085205,
-0.9139717221260071,
0.34079647064208984,
0.1772245615720749,
-0.6965804100036621,
-0.03241084888577461,
0.6171545386314392,
0.36881008744239807,
0.4602673649787903,
1.0394680500030518,
-0.3900294005870819,
0.3098132312297821,
0.17831778526306152,
0.522124171257019,
-0.007731789257377386,
-0.26921412348747253,
-0.2047077715396881,
0.006502656731754541,
0.02403857931494713,
-0.5198630690574646
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00012v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00012v1
|
Stress index strategy enhanced with financial news sentiment analysis for the equity markets
| 2024-03-12T08:23:30 | 2024-03-12T08:23:30 |
Baptiste Lefort, Eric Benhamou, Jean-Jacques Ohana, David Saltiel, Beatrice Guez, Thomas Jacquot
|
q-fin.ST
|
q-fin.ST, cs.AI, cs.CL, q-fin.RM
|
This paper introduces a new risk-on risk-off strategy for the stock market,
which combines a financial stress indicator with a sentiment analysis done by
ChatGPT reading and interpreting Bloomberg daily market summaries. Forecasts of
market stress derived from volatility and credit spreads are enhanced when
combined with the financial news sentiment derived from GPT-4. As a result, the
strategy shows improved performance, evidenced by higher Sharpe ratio and
reduced maximum drawdowns. The improved performance is consistent across the
NASDAQ, the S&P 500 and the six major equity markets, indicating that the
method generalises across equities markets.
|
[
-0.30540111660957336,
-0.41539788246154785,
0.037169620394706726,
0.3282890319824219,
-0.1761346459388733,
0.3200756311416626,
0.1074998527765274,
0.09634130448102951,
0.6515415906906128,
0.03638756647706032,
-0.5955703854560852,
-0.5278415679931641,
-0.49533843994140625,
-0.3639238774776459,
-0.20116999745368958,
1.4436488151550293,
-0.03278955817222595,
0.13091428577899933,
0.2462201714515686,
0.4088941514492035,
0.17532603442668915,
-0.3216041028499603,
-0.8567573428153992,
0.23059678077697754,
0.6376528739929199,
0.30516523122787476,
0.79209303855896,
0.25592684745788574,
1.3586803674697876,
0.21745294332504272,
0.14989428222179413,
-0.00527222640812397,
-0.3205767869949341,
-0.02330966480076313,
0.31665050983428955,
-0.1913481056690216,
-0.6732399463653564,
0.2673203945159912,
0.5374659299850464,
0.1402900218963623,
-0.37865328788757324,
0.21941612660884857,
0.1958635449409485,
0.47337478399276733,
-0.9655188322067261,
0.043656475841999054,
-0.3410383462905884,
0.2419719696044922,
-0.44328272342681885,
-0.5935495495796204,
0.03303287923336029,
-0.7142925262451172,
0.521251380443573,
-0.6367692947387695,
-0.08526072651147842,
0.5629183053970337,
0.9506112337112427,
0.21364650130271912,
-0.3389292061328888,
-0.2829984724521637,
-0.5210250616073608,
0.6326049566268921,
-0.3485157787799835,
-0.01384953036904335,
0.08707521855831146,
0.48790353536605835,
0.3452378511428833,
-0.5459555387496948,
-0.11269635707139969,
0.11471232026815414,
0.33770328760147095,
0.6337913274765015,
-0.16825151443481445,
-0.1531999707221985,
0.13297542929649353,
0.6815770864486694,
-0.18280817568302155,
-0.1608983278274536,
-0.8599840402603149,
-0.17126984894275665,
0.6778005361557007,
0.05938376858830452,
0.1685333549976349,
-0.11679601669311523,
-0.7486054301261902,
-0.20455069839954376,
-0.7289638519287109,
0.2193138152360916,
0.5395447015762329,
0.11374174058437347,
0.17647027969360352,
0.5148190855979919,
0.38217124342918396,
-0.2971726059913635,
0.0651869922876358,
-0.02301199920475483,
0.4362708330154419,
-0.1072273775935173,
-0.16033847630023956,
0.39175257086753845,
0.2248433232307434,
0.969702959060669,
-0.038350027054548264,
0.06431148946285248,
-0.12336667627096176,
-0.16247372329235077,
0.4240039587020874,
-0.6850426197052002,
0.035959865897893906,
-0.15906764566898346,
-0.4541098177433014,
-0.570349931716919,
0.38482582569122314,
-1.1909252405166626,
-0.34100282192230225,
0.2401343137025833,
0.47838109731674194,
-0.5895729660987854,
-0.3471057116985321,
0.12629930675029755,
-0.5865405201911926,
0.8017367720603943,
0.020237423479557037,
-0.506721556186676,
0.516262948513031,
0.6605545878410339,
0.7943986058235168,
-0.34557902812957764,
0.2743964195251465,
-0.5851067304611206,
0.3270658254623413,
-0.3638300895690918,
0.736461877822876,
-0.44735240936279297,
-0.7258709669113159,
-0.08749718219041824,
-0.3180559277534485,
0.022158734500408173,
-0.23320871591567993,
0.8157799243927002,
-0.16948455572128296,
0.09473390132188797,
-0.5949458479881287,
-0.3358834385871887,
-0.5719473361968994,
0.36840328574180603,
-0.615013837814331,
1.3021273612976074,
0.21435041725635529,
-1.0344297885894775,
0.6321014761924744,
-1.3036268949508667,
-0.3121582269668579,
-0.2234136015176773,
0.3655664622783661,
-0.523277997970581,
-0.018125077709555626,
0.554799497127533,
-0.017926910892128944,
-0.37808993458747864,
-0.5166003704071045,
-0.7572230100631714,
-0.41947582364082336,
0.2731715738773346,
-0.36925962567329407,
0.005903198383748531,
0.347167044878006,
-0.4293878972530365,
-0.019851235672831535,
-0.6273481845855713,
0.21816694736480713,
0.08010397851467133,
0.16117480397224426,
-0.8103396892547607,
0.15769566595554352,
0.21540290117263794,
0.23984496295452118,
0.09575315564870834,
-0.3921341896057129,
0.36720719933509827,
-0.5465541481971741,
0.2716616094112396,
0.7236107587814331,
0.4727210998535156,
0.19092725217342377,
-0.19869345426559448,
0.7338700890541077,
0.16912348568439484,
0.6316831707954407,
0.24637624621391296,
0.04020920768380165,
-0.7906311750411987,
-0.5325081944465637,
-0.02839888446033001,
1.1667722463607788,
-0.16391386091709137,
-0.03052707575261593,
0.01689402014017105,
-0.41819822788238525,
-0.7353034019470215,
-0.10590803623199463,
0.10071878135204315,
-0.05224576219916344,
0.400460422039032,
-0.5608752965927124,
-0.8462846279144287,
-0.9046308994293213,
-0.4016350209712982,
0.23569226264953613,
0.2525613307952881,
0.01958959549665451,
0.18811236321926117,
-0.1627512276172638,
0.5915583372116089,
-0.8643604516983032,
-0.006632768549025059,
-0.07743632793426514,
0.434587299823761,
0.41582411527633667,
0.2502463459968567,
0.47016823291778564,
-0.5195083618164062,
-0.2489304542541504,
-0.08256582170724869,
-0.03160245716571808,
0.15692377090454102,
-0.2546757161617279,
-0.2964024841785431,
0.06857878714799881,
0.4741438627243042,
-0.21714268624782562,
0.6668292880058289,
0.01634247414767742,
-0.254996657371521,
0.0930435061454773,
-0.036915093660354614,
-0.0035339328460395336,
-1.145952582359314,
0.05338005721569061,
0.6229989528656006,
0.18805332481861115,
-0.4230707883834839,
-0.40460655093193054,
-0.3469611406326294,
-0.23942452669143677,
-0.2191092073917389,
0.14664892852306366,
-0.3638698160648346,
-0.25227785110473633,
-0.12583862245082855,
0.15679067373275757,
0.03092002123594284,
0.09437135607004166,
-0.2653171718120575,
0.7197123765945435,
0.7035866975784302,
-0.22105959057807922,
0.24339835345745087,
-0.04600705951452255,
-0.2439952939748764,
0.6576947569847107,
-0.7055739760398865,
0.007490696385502815,
-0.11780985444784164,
-0.07953866571187973,
-1.2458058595657349,
0.2845630645751953,
0.2488754391670227,
0.0011990173952654004,
0.35913723707199097,
0.5622839331626892,
0.20813213288784027,
-0.84926438331604,
-0.8423078656196594,
-0.11397985368967056,
0.30287671089172363,
-0.12275578081607819,
0.43565964698791504,
0.262640118598938,
-0.5323615074157715,
-0.783751368522644,
-0.6511723399162292,
0.062882199883461,
-0.7505277991294861,
-0.4375820755958557,
0.3151560425758362,
0.2062607705593109,
-0.6171824336051941,
0.07831012457609177,
-0.19275343418121338,
-0.13396801054477692,
0.17942017316818237,
0.41489818692207336,
0.6498737931251526,
-0.16411611437797546,
0.12324491143226624,
-0.089799664914608,
-0.36389052867889404,
-0.035867251455783844,
-0.18714192509651184,
0.23403136432170868,
-0.5511648654937744,
-0.36060890555381775,
-0.5115195512771606,
0.6928066611289978,
0.3485129475593567,
-0.2513046860694885,
0.48897695541381836,
0.8385591506958008,
0.1667640507221222,
0.1865641474723816,
-0.4488762617111206,
-0.17437301576137543,
-0.49269241094589233,
0.37949442863464355,
-0.3299550712108612,
-0.5302584171295166,
0.5047268867492676,
-0.36343324184417725,
-0.08355268836021423,
0.9128441214561462,
0.36998140811920166,
-0.38053545355796814,
0.917486310005188,
0.747208833694458,
-0.5028935670852661,
0.24754415452480316,
-0.33720991015434265,
0.6593160629272461,
-0.5308846235275269,
0.0407494455575943,
-0.15643800795078278,
-0.9475072026252747,
-0.4651287794113159,
-0.22100500762462616,
0.5726974010467529,
-0.17144054174423218,
-0.44037526845932007,
-0.08233550935983658,
-0.3998323678970337,
0.1516619771718979,
0.935826301574707,
-0.16010957956314087,
0.09112989157438278,
-0.033179983496665955,
-0.2839350402355194,
-0.18669959902763367,
-0.17437249422073364,
-0.01886618696153164,
1.2448080778121948,
0.5599210858345032,
0.9099755883216858,
-0.0960136353969574,
0.4147469699382782,
0.3450055718421936,
0.5684458613395691,
-0.5321647524833679,
0.06989973783493042,
0.008177516981959343,
-0.7765363454818726,
0.036948055028915405,
-0.18076710402965546,
-0.37370947003364563,
-0.12916548550128937,
-0.1564890593290329,
-0.14816711843013763,
0.43232935667037964,
-0.2593725621700287,
-0.8463267087936401,
0.09214449673891068,
-0.7711856365203857,
0.3801192045211792,
-0.2616419494152069,
-0.04825983941555023,
-0.1311044842004776,
-0.22366565465927124,
0.3508273959159851,
-0.12315168976783752,
-0.08141432702541351,
-0.11245177686214447,
-0.46513113379478455,
0.6392466425895691,
-0.3663201332092285,
0.6816205382347107,
-0.30585619807243347,
0.0831977054476738,
0.2977502942085266,
-0.49081119894981384,
0.5264258980751038,
0.1428029090166092,
-0.09711968153715134,
-0.30556929111480713,
0.008796634152531624,
-0.2768448293209076,
-0.5011351108551025,
0.38379228115081787,
-0.8502881526947021,
-0.4649689495563507,
-0.6845273971557617,
-0.766160249710083,
-0.18536265194416046,
-0.27087724208831787,
0.17292433977127075,
0.03891943395137787,
-0.24418380856513977,
0.06935080885887146,
-0.13397246599197388,
0.05015406012535095,
0.606160581111908,
0.22376926243305206,
0.08625274896621704,
-0.7906681299209595,
0.6951494216918945,
0.37437230348587036,
0.1104995384812355,
0.03577389940619469,
0.05378393828868866,
-0.5294229388237,
-0.09746208786964417,
0.4776120185852051,
-0.10530805587768555,
-0.3591068983078003,
0.016576625406742096,
-0.22157476842403412,
-0.40896230936050415,
-0.600233256816864,
-0.30124059319496155,
-0.4868711233139038,
-0.25029510259628296,
0.09174127131700516,
-0.5069413185119629,
0.5550990700721741,
0.40205568075180054,
-0.20941230654716492,
0.3034508526325226,
-0.5447859168052673,
-0.05618522688746452,
0.3230164349079132,
0.4205580949783325,
-0.3819480538368225,
-0.11148124188184738,
-0.3713739216327667,
-0.214063361287117,
-0.9437338709831238,
-0.9710004329681396,
0.4878062605857849,
0.44485849142074585,
0.6200448870658875,
1.0888928174972534,
0.34010112285614014,
0.7938122153282166,
0.15561844408512115,
0.13562707602977753,
0.23591619729995728,
-1.0894509553909302,
0.5663975477218628,
-0.1793421357870102,
-0.11826439946889877,
0.446481853723526,
0.874457836151123,
-0.7474863529205322,
-0.5014653205871582,
-0.7334405183792114,
-0.998625636100769,
0.3468223810195923,
0.21340312063694,
-0.2730022966861725,
-0.12076667696237564,
0.4575275778770447,
-0.26032817363739014,
0.21295499801635742,
-0.4235500991344452,
-0.14479121565818787,
-0.5133242607116699,
-0.17688685655593872,
0.16602274775505066,
-0.6688843965530396,
-0.26385411620140076,
-0.37317711114883423,
0.6827149391174316,
0.01320284977555275,
0.5431420803070068,
0.35868850350379944,
0.33701398968696594,
-0.11141002178192139,
0.16712956130504608,
0.35867294669151306,
0.44726234674453735,
-0.7741564512252808,
-0.13235898315906525,
0.4183713495731354,
-0.4693387448787689,
-0.1225118637084961,
0.29739895462989807,
-0.03949352353811264,
-0.3031308054924011,
0.07445787638425827,
0.8592922687530518,
0.4933730363845825,
-0.16047640144824982,
0.3437483310699463,
0.004631729796528816,
-0.7720664143562317,
-0.16654250025749207,
-0.03063446283340454,
-0.28608328104019165,
0.7164693474769592,
0.7737600207328796,
0.05488581955432892,
0.42707303166389465,
-0.5182428359985352,
0.44927045702934265,
0.2780197858810425,
-0.781739354133606,
-0.25767067074775696,
0.3808327913284302,
0.25130191445350647,
0.5019896030426025,
0.4823693633079529,
-0.06627565622329712,
-0.5830278396606445,
0.6414574384689331,
0.4876594543457031,
1.0685757398605347,
-0.5664042234420776,
0.1929900050163269,
0.16681939363479614,
0.71961510181427,
-0.05806785821914673,
0.8875061869621277,
0.49427884817123413,
-0.6666765809059143,
-0.5810906291007996,
-0.2132469266653061,
-0.5613574385643005,
-0.08797454833984375,
-1.028820514678955,
0.3892405033111572,
-0.6990487575531006,
-0.4902189075946808,
-0.0509042888879776,
0.4409450590610504,
-0.2940167188644409,
0.403807133436203,
0.22965234518051147,
0.9385031461715698,
-0.7655065059661865,
0.556327760219574,
0.6116332411766052,
-0.15664440393447876,
-0.8105032444000244,
0.16905337572097778,
0.25622475147247314,
-0.8922484517097473,
0.5943601727485657,
0.20599448680877686,
0.25819456577301025,
-0.10128781199455261,
-0.14054995775222778,
-1.2550674676895142,
0.9700214862823486,
0.01701098307967186,
-0.256104052066803,
0.22993724048137665,
-0.22177481651306152,
0.20360775291919708,
-0.5071691870689392,
0.419326514005661,
0.603614866733551,
0.9798274636268616,
0.5071955323219299,
-0.25936800241470337,
-0.14332398772239685,
-0.7186138033866882,
-0.09759034961462021,
0.3841501474380493,
-0.859417200088501,
0.7132944464683533,
-0.1976335048675537,
-0.3085258901119232,
-0.6269080638885498,
0.7747437953948975,
-0.2415258139371872,
0.46367114782333374,
0.569068193435669,
0.8062527775764465,
0.7431150674819946,
-0.31612733006477356,
1.114405870437622,
-0.5388972163200378,
0.4553937315940857,
0.5411617755889893,
-0.5403136014938354,
0.8910988569259644,
0.4149584174156189,
-0.3625543415546417,
0.1687503159046173,
0.9345874786376953,
-0.42520835995674133,
0.7532815933227539,
0.37483227252960205,
-0.12484073638916016,
0.0028841618914157152,
-0.0416073203086853,
-0.5765731930732727,
0.728816032409668,
0.43381717801094055,
-0.28374195098876953,
-0.3920607268810272,
0.08179881423711777,
0.31048986315727234,
-0.3378109037876129,
-0.539862334728241,
0.34783610701560974,
0.07841793447732925,
-0.41692134737968445,
0.009532368741929531,
0.01758352294564247,
0.7632223963737488,
-0.5238503217697144,
0.6704814434051514,
-0.21474722027778625,
0.529571533203125,
0.24267087876796722,
-0.44050461053848267,
0.7953916192054749,
-0.11950448900461197,
0.04464226961135864,
-0.32562321424484253,
0.6814592480659485,
-0.20795698463916779,
-0.9870191216468811,
0.1962238997220993,
0.16045597195625305,
-0.15206237137317657,
-0.16425924003124237,
-0.635794997215271,
-0.3322436511516571,
-0.30548274517059326,
-0.8051548004150391,
0.12861959636211395,
0.5255371928215027,
0.22013559937477112,
0.632456362247467,
0.6728001832962036,
-0.027253201231360435,
-0.12760917842388153,
-0.3358408212661743,
0.9334189295768738,
-1.059865117073059,
-0.68112713098526,
-0.9400667548179626,
0.18533624708652496,
-0.38802778720855713,
-0.6614935398101807,
0.7433823347091675,
0.5134819149971008,
-0.23579369485378265,
0.24492210149765015,
0.7525150775909424,
0.3116373121738434,
0.5383049249649048,
-0.3138800263404846,
0.6545303463935852,
-0.4730667471885681,
-0.010222292505204678,
-0.5033005475997925,
-0.8283684253692627,
-0.39567831158638,
0.4312262237071991,
-0.8114224076271057,
0.021798262372612953,
0.9482394456863403,
0.7842549085617065,
0.25488725304603577,
0.3144349455833435,
-0.0925712138414383,
0.006798580754548311,
0.1305088847875595,
0.48340123891830444,
0.4175243079662323,
-0.21951115131378174,
0.5174465179443359,
-0.07100047171115875,
-0.14875417947769165,
-0.471914142370224,
-1.0070950984954834,
-0.5290559530258179,
-0.22155159711837769,
-0.4231953024864197,
-0.2541155219078064,
-0.08833515644073486,
0.7130311727523804,
0.39686551690101624,
-0.4489315450191498,
0.008124053478240967,
0.5066006183624268,
-0.10703468322753906,
-0.6529725790023804,
-0.26448434591293335,
0.5881850123405457,
-0.49484455585479736,
-0.4000885784626007,
0.08855680376291275,
0.9550087451934814,
0.10630955547094345,
-0.08647405356168747,
0.05641881003975868,
-0.2666551172733307,
0.5773603916168213,
0.16740937530994415,
-0.036676958203315735,
0.1539059728384018,
-0.10268548130989075,
0.015993090346455574,
-0.25192221999168396,
-0.05657808482646942,
0.5978618264198303,
0.2575337886810303,
-0.19261592626571655,
0.3378828763961792,
0.6769028306007385,
0.5098204016685486,
0.021730653941631317,
0.7473881244659424,
-0.6716403365135193,
0.36505126953125,
0.07503937184810638,
0.2998335659503937,
-0.22447569668293,
-0.6564741134643555,
0.4185051918029785,
0.23254507780075073,
-0.27711883187294006,
-0.3598393201828003,
-0.6386122107505798,
-1.059324860572815,
0.07954688370227814,
0.9350196123123169,
-0.07835468649864197,
-0.5030025839805603,
0.2512161135673523,
-0.20449723303318024,
-0.008045901544392109,
-0.5268344283103943,
0.8043435215950012,
0.9994735717773438,
0.420207679271698,
-0.4950815737247467,
-0.6643831729888916,
0.5281016230583191,
0.4731435775756836,
-0.6860389709472656,
-0.43082305788993835,
-0.2424115091562271,
-0.06080341339111328,
0.0329509973526001,
0.5560708045959473,
-0.07942536473274231,
0.44544050097465515,
0.007035966496914625,
0.3768112361431122,
-0.11178631335496902,
-0.08181487768888474,
0.3528488874435425,
0.5783076882362366,
-0.3855079412460327,
-0.5222722887992859
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07398v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07398v2
|
Complex Reasoning over Logical Queries on Commonsense Knowledge Graphs
| 2024-03-12T08:13:52 | 2024-06-22T17:32:05 |
Tianqing Fang, Zeming Chen, Yangqiu Song, Antoine Bosselut
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Event commonsense reasoning requires the ability to reason about the
relationship between events, as well as infer implicit context underlying that
relationship. However, data scarcity makes it challenging for language models
to learn to generate commonsense inferences for contexts and questions
involving interactions between complex events. To address this demand, we
present COM2 (COMplex COMmonsense), a new dataset created by sampling multi-hop
logical queries (e.g., the joint effect or cause of both event A and B, or the
effect of the effect of event C) from an existing commonsense knowledge graph
(CSKG), and verbalizing them using handcrafted rules and large language models
into multiple-choice and text generation questions. Our experiments show that
language models trained on COM2 exhibit significant improvements in complex
reasoning ability, resulting in enhanced zero-shot performance in both
in-domain and out-of-domain tasks for question answering and generative
commonsense reasoning, without expensive human annotations. Code and data are
available at https://github.com/tqfang/complex-commonsense-reasoning.
|
[
-0.19240325689315796,
-1.1846446990966797,
0.6876803040504456,
-0.15188607573509216,
-0.049716874957084656,
-0.16911357641220093,
-0.1947631537914276,
-0.5289100408554077,
-0.16215208172798157,
0.5447700023651123,
-0.5107324123382568,
-0.3324030339717865,
-0.43719667196273804,
-0.025913527235388756,
-0.015715796500444412,
0.6743848323822021,
0.2283809334039688,
0.08019194006919861,
-0.4465079605579376,
-0.18118619918823242,
-0.510391354560852,
-0.5569537878036499,
-0.8138948082923889,
-0.363900363445282,
0.41792669892311096,
0.6581599712371826,
0.6792313456535339,
0.1444506198167801,
0.19493752717971802,
0.25955864787101746,
0.07793963700532913,
0.6632588505744934,
-0.6146091818809509,
0.3075944185256958,
-0.47080743312835693,
-0.6732743978500366,
-0.3159087896347046,
0.030429350212216377,
0.26514095067977905,
0.9270615577697754,
0.05784408375620842,
-0.07919856160879135,
-0.1359005868434906,
0.437126100063324,
-0.7300545573234558,
0.274245023727417,
-0.7985548377037048,
-0.07046041637659073,
-0.17533466219902039,
-0.2431105673313141,
-0.5724427700042725,
-0.17212945222854614,
0.18662318587303162,
-0.9112699031829834,
0.191752091050148,
0.12140488624572754,
0.7016736268997192,
0.15700145065784454,
-0.5935189127922058,
-0.27512356638908386,
-0.45171982049942017,
0.7932903170585632,
-0.4330938756465912,
0.3653259873390198,
0.39280399680137634,
0.5219059586524963,
-0.4134967625141144,
-0.9255740642547607,
-0.9844396710395813,
-0.1764088273048401,
-0.18947528302669525,
0.2751349210739136,
-0.44792723655700684,
0.023396404460072517,
0.5118297338485718,
-0.29277360439300537,
-0.653982400894165,
-0.13072407245635986,
-0.2497742772102356,
-0.08447878062725067,
0.6632618308067322,
0.20844675600528717,
0.3576706051826477,
-0.18797855079174042,
-0.33374014496803284,
0.043667081743478775,
-0.8222663998603821,
-0.0037993560545146465,
0.30728453397750854,
0.148039311170578,
-0.10438951849937439,
0.5841434597969055,
-0.521220862865448,
1.0317736864089966,
-0.22169554233551025,
-0.04545361548662186,
0.035540223121643066,
-0.26665380597114563,
-0.007914763875305653,
-0.016480600461363792,
0.40895286202430725,
0.499508798122406,
0.5856554508209229,
-0.15252216160297394,
0.1934911012649536,
0.03256526216864586,
-0.3344087600708008,
-0.607005774974823,
-0.30623987317085266,
0.4793901741504669,
-0.18774716556072235,
-0.0829239934682846,
0.04639925807714462,
-0.4675185978412628,
-0.39097246527671814,
-0.7807097434997559,
0.17837055027484894,
-0.2660701870918274,
-0.4546462893486023,
0.4352363049983978,
-0.5856657028198242,
0.15817613899707794,
0.6682903170585632,
-0.3508332371711731,
0.2759692668914795,
0.7446424961090088,
0.4136215150356293,
0.02159169688820839,
-0.34209558367729187,
-1.0573594570159912,
0.28822508454322815,
-0.03964225575327873,
1.1225422620773315,
-0.8180471658706665,
0.10720402002334595,
-0.07197126746177673,
-0.18017327785491943,
-0.1477566659450531,
-0.7140491604804993,
0.5771145224571228,
-0.5872202515602112,
0.049977321177721024,
-0.3751411736011505,
-0.6141980886459351,
-0.07258325070142746,
0.4697023034095764,
-0.5548176169395447,
0.6270579695701599,
-0.1619023233652115,
-0.7639350295066833,
0.23161210119724274,
-0.6612272262573242,
-0.704595148563385,
0.19762973487377167,
-0.30850687623023987,
-0.04328389838337898,
-0.2611740827560425,
0.0711686909198761,
0.41902828216552734,
-0.449302613735199,
0.46302932500839233,
-0.7048359513282776,
0.008421293459832668,
0.5204964280128479,
-0.37818726897239685,
0.9693071842193604,
0.3082294166088104,
-0.23304952681064606,
-0.16726908087730408,
-0.8079187273979187,
0.030125025659799576,
0.0787123292684555,
-0.0802176222205162,
-0.43217265605926514,
0.32958996295928955,
-0.025191130116581917,
0.27438876032829285,
-0.08339545875787735,
-0.48194557428359985,
0.2567594051361084,
-0.22094936668872833,
0.44694796204566956,
0.20616959035396576,
0.11071203649044037,
0.2741026282310486,
-0.24741385877132416,
0.1383255124092102,
0.2858847379684448,
0.12223736941814423,
0.07616245746612549,
-0.66404128074646,
-0.538841962814331,
-0.1161322146654129,
-0.14572744071483612,
0.6822741031646729,
-0.8104864358901978,
0.043152958154678345,
-0.10918162763118744,
-0.31680071353912354,
0.07690685987472534,
-0.2404785007238388,
0.2995690405368805,
0.7340326309204102,
0.4669318199157715,
0.24746282398700714,
-0.40143731236457825,
-0.6352255344390869,
-0.4380834102630615,
-0.015282617881894112,
0.05283201485872269,
0.48322632908821106,
0.4540024697780609,
0.0730520710349083,
1.0508034229278564,
-1.047528624534607,
-0.031204918399453163,
-0.4907653033733368,
0.4302561581134796,
-0.15074999630451202,
0.38169151544570923,
0.3178343176841736,
-0.9218098521232605,
-0.2365698218345642,
-0.08765500038862228,
-0.8525332808494568,
-0.2535000741481781,
-0.37244829535484314,
-0.36207422614097595,
0.07192416489124298,
0.6309004426002502,
-0.8883554935455322,
0.27343353629112244,
0.19157494604587555,
-0.6074766516685486,
0.7131904363632202,
0.08149567246437073,
0.07250505685806274,
-1.012850046157837,
0.09091684967279434,
-0.1465635746717453,
-0.3024962246417999,
-0.7265907526016235,
0.16408978402614594,
-0.16635183990001678,
-0.20703329145908356,
-0.5501099824905396,
0.7908209562301636,
-0.3330031633377075,
0.06398119032382965,
-0.10148891806602478,
0.5464165806770325,
0.2676381468772888,
0.3589649200439453,
0.29614782333374023,
0.39107227325439453,
0.506018340587616,
-0.6392654776573181,
0.4690588414669037,
0.21884393692016602,
-0.2668483555316925,
0.7928594946861267,
-0.5898944735527039,
-0.11258997768163681,
-0.19510382413864136,
0.4042605757713318,
-0.9976909756660461,
-0.46297594904899597,
0.2578418552875519,
-0.5714621543884277,
0.03250324726104736,
-0.2429894059896469,
-0.6656938791275024,
-0.17239287495613098,
0.10504891723394394,
0.45621153712272644,
0.041933272033929825,
-0.5191489458084106,
0.6027919054031372,
0.4348320960998535,
0.035477809607982635,
-0.5807204246520996,
-0.6440621614456177,
0.10797077417373657,
0.1434793621301651,
-0.8373777866363525,
-0.20425592362880707,
-0.012132719159126282,
-0.6062253713607788,
0.07658318430185318,
0.061256151646375656,
-0.39811912178993225,
0.15443162620067596,
-0.04969630390405655,
0.04766573756933212,
-0.017557188868522644,
0.3385532796382904,
0.37489789724349976,
-0.1441446989774704,
0.1842755526304245,
-0.38865336775779724,
0.5586089491844177,
-0.00022231803450267762,
-0.4254421889781952,
-0.40130314230918884,
0.4472888112068176,
0.5630012154579163,
-0.43026137351989746,
0.5031474232673645,
0.3990771770477295,
-0.4223780930042267,
-0.5107226371765137,
-0.571927011013031,
-0.39614763855934143,
-0.36937329173088074,
0.27872228622436523,
-0.5542478561401367,
-0.9063588976860046,
0.4737183451652527,
-0.3784719705581665,
-0.23659835755825043,
0.3212999701499939,
0.44304296374320984,
-0.23464973270893097,
0.8917754888534546,
-0.23936447501182556,
0.5375587940216064,
-0.0035184803418815136,
-0.2967087924480438,
0.20512695610523224,
-0.5242809057235718,
-0.38742318749427795,
-0.3719201982021332,
-0.17704933881759644,
-0.30677762627601624,
-0.5974418520927429,
0.42036253213882446,
0.2746366560459137,
-0.2779659032821655,
0.08507803827524185,
-0.11480765044689178,
0.7051519155502319,
0.7055354118347168,
0.2104048728942871,
0.552745521068573,
-0.08959875255823135,
0.030658848583698273,
0.24024829268455505,
-0.9717466831207275,
-0.24550236761569977,
0.7627446055412292,
-0.24344970285892487,
0.6019818782806396,
0.29233044385910034,
0.3018139898777008,
0.06132236495614052,
0.02006980963051319,
-0.6093509197235107,
0.5688679814338684,
-0.08723591268062592,
-0.8667899966239929,
-0.2729603052139282,
-0.6649662256240845,
-1.0010305643081665,
0.2577020525932312,
-0.3563542664051056,
-0.5776711106300354,
0.22399744391441345,
0.260111540555954,
-0.3770330250263214,
0.3136462867259979,
-0.8161292672157288,
0.9399093985557556,
-0.00046007102355360985,
-0.5588101744651794,
-0.4856070280075073,
-0.8132880926132202,
0.60079026222229,
0.26538199186325073,
0.16301630437374115,
-0.11001697927713394,
0.2611844837665558,
0.3837621808052063,
-0.43783068656921387,
0.9758328795433044,
-0.1813572198152542,
0.25501564145088196,
0.7971307039260864,
0.24253863096237183,
0.6483274698257446,
0.3219972848892212,
-0.05323001369833946,
-0.005756991449743509,
0.0718659833073616,
-0.5045974254608154,
-0.7650240063667297,
0.6503865718841553,
-0.6841621398925781,
-0.5034875273704529,
-0.3812152147293091,
-0.6880787014961243,
-0.3259701132774353,
0.20799945294857025,
0.10907246917486191,
0.8477612137794495,
0.07887285947799683,
0.16185998916625977,
0.7858209013938904,
-0.3183344602584839,
0.13526006042957306,
0.4098188877105713,
0.265878826379776,
-0.31916940212249756,
0.6626706719398499,
0.23064623773097992,
0.624610185623169,
0.5233867168426514,
0.28117942810058594,
-0.34447288513183594,
-0.11814038455486298,
-0.5198386311531067,
0.13661432266235352,
-0.7416988015174866,
-0.39096906781196594,
-0.904630720615387,
0.04010312631726265,
-0.36951830983161926,
-0.16071900725364685,
-0.1037735566496849,
-0.845650851726532,
-0.21634264290332794,
-0.05609383434057236,
0.26444393396377563,
0.323648601770401,
-0.1383945792913437,
-0.020926058292388916,
-0.774368405342102,
0.4822636842727661,
0.49785834550857544,
0.22975564002990723,
0.08590736240148544,
-0.12768803536891937,
0.16658739745616913,
-0.004526988603174686,
-0.19769969582557678,
-0.8463003635406494,
-0.0814332515001297,
0.1820542961359024,
0.4692118167877197,
0.4391224682331085,
0.4571683406829834,
0.6464150547981262,
-0.26381391286849976,
0.6393074989318848,
0.257668137550354,
-0.740257203578949,
0.5694804191589355,
-0.537860095500946,
0.28981778025627136,
0.39601317048072815,
0.3812718391418457,
-0.5135977268218994,
-0.3838333785533905,
-0.6840760111808777,
-0.5267145037651062,
0.8253237009048462,
0.412781298160553,
-0.03541140630841255,
-0.2543855309486389,
0.2751627266407013,
-0.054377470165491104,
0.059819240123033524,
-0.5304176211357117,
-0.2702052593231201,
-0.09591636806726456,
-0.0818759948015213,
0.5136304497718811,
-0.22205346822738647,
-0.35438108444213867,
-0.2292625457048416,
0.3477085828781128,
-0.21149688959121704,
0.011672057211399078,
0.25913652777671814,
-0.1015545204281807,
-0.04824024438858032,
0.2695744037628174,
0.46553510427474976,
0.6351926922798157,
-0.04071974381804466,
0.5105151534080505,
0.2815544903278351,
-0.18123763799667358,
-0.163148894906044,
0.3302907645702362,
-0.08473721146583557,
-0.2682640552520752,
0.6025713086128235,
0.4685218334197998,
0.0853138417005539,
-1.099932074546814,
0.6588270664215088,
0.019204964861273766,
-0.29667940735816956,
-0.1210155263543129,
0.15331754088401794,
0.3173668384552002,
0.3841002583503723,
0.1382203847169876,
0.16731590032577515,
0.3831177353858948,
-0.666343629360199,
0.42982378602027893,
0.2584671974182129,
-0.04224872961640358,
-0.1328694075345993,
0.666006326675415,
0.29158487915992737,
0.19792026281356812,
0.7612595558166504,
-0.6014060974121094,
-0.5105134844779968,
0.6795057654380798,
0.635227382183075,
0.46089252829551697,
0.24660591781139374,
0.25600671768188477,
0.7311627268791199,
0.1342492252588272,
0.17137587070465088,
0.527899444103241,
-0.1284674108028412,
-0.9167802333831787,
-0.5698343515396118,
-0.20707187056541443,
-0.4623662829399109,
0.09126444160938263,
-0.23006434738636017,
0.2825796902179718,
-0.2187010794878006,
0.2065640240907669,
0.012291978113353252,
-0.02978498674929142,
-0.49445807933807373,
0.34425967931747437,
0.14992353320121765,
0.8431932926177979,
-0.8348720669746399,
0.6408624649047852,
0.6014807224273682,
-0.5715106129646301,
-0.8478077054023743,
-0.20154815912246704,
0.028334813192486763,
-0.5953880548477173,
0.8250280618667603,
-0.03943631052970886,
-0.17824630439281464,
-0.06371553987264633,
-0.8056530356407166,
-0.7544174790382385,
0.8910464644432068,
0.3131537139415741,
-0.6336259841918945,
0.30177831649780273,
0.4858865737915039,
0.28145304322242737,
-0.05140504240989685,
0.22926072776317596,
0.48908308148384094,
0.585029125213623,
0.4280262291431427,
-0.5055361390113831,
0.10790219902992249,
-0.021949775516986847,
-0.5079718828201294,
0.15517161786556244,
-0.6621133685112,
0.7144613862037659,
-0.44822967052459717,
-0.20585456490516663,
-0.25296473503112793,
0.5833458304405212,
0.6501896381378174,
0.8368144035339355,
0.5258918404579163,
0.8618470430374146,
0.9353485703468323,
-0.23689676821231842,
0.9181820750236511,
-0.16361820697784424,
0.1795017570257187,
1.5394426584243774,
-0.40389570593833923,
0.7596052289009094,
0.15362165868282318,
0.21228308975696564,
0.3880535066127777,
0.34643542766571045,
0.2662403881549835,
0.22445999085903168,
0.11708179116249084,
-0.44266971945762634,
-0.8507187366485596,
-0.1814127117395401,
-0.17196771502494812,
0.5483879446983337,
0.4008345603942871,
0.25814831256866455,
-0.6180617213249207,
-0.04325146600604057,
0.3268914222717285,
0.12483159452676773,
-0.03779353201389313,
0.6331631541252136,
0.09193451702594757,
-0.9632878303527832,
0.3726773262023926,
-0.11235547065734863,
-0.0067447456531226635,
-0.44472113251686096,
-0.2308942973613739,
-0.3177553415298462,
0.17884933948516846,
-0.22408507764339447,
-1.017098307609558,
0.4127395749092102,
-0.010929816402494907,
0.02651137113571167,
0.21088732779026031,
0.8324518203735352,
-0.5295395255088806,
-0.2799530029296875,
0.14443901181221008,
0.6465451121330261,
0.14742204546928406,
-0.18767277896404266,
-0.7150320410728455,
-0.19041427969932556,
-0.2107214331626892,
-0.18399059772491455,
0.005852073896676302,
0.897375226020813,
-0.2866581976413727,
0.6796206831932068,
0.8285543322563171,
-0.13263998925685883,
0.006702556274831295,
0.36283913254737854,
0.8443170189857483,
-0.3882714509963989,
-0.24759286642074585,
-0.6470221877098083,
0.555959165096283,
-0.38552433252334595,
-0.3575626611709595,
0.43430909514427185,
0.8268195986747742,
0.8618696331977844,
-0.07356245070695877,
0.9556149244308472,
-0.24591386318206787,
0.3234318196773529,
-0.4811364412307739,
0.4477895498275757,
-0.5965219140052795,
0.011682593263685703,
0.019420787692070007,
-0.4484645426273346,
-0.7345315217971802,
0.40040886402130127,
-0.45529380440711975,
-0.2883736491203308,
0.6454639434814453,
0.9853963255882263,
-0.2388235479593277,
0.029320526868104935,
0.3287959694862366,
0.27164310216903687,
0.5086193680763245,
0.6144109964370728,
0.965635359287262,
-0.20923592150211334,
0.6106482744216919,
0.06553138047456741,
-0.35527896881103516,
-0.25022315979003906,
-0.7702903747558594,
-0.7798359394073486,
-0.5355673432350159,
-0.3891112804412842,
-0.37444883584976196,
0.13153120875358582,
1.089467167854309,
0.5881640315055847,
-0.6837472319602966,
-0.12450910359621048,
-0.4330599904060364,
0.3234722316265106,
-0.1770554631948471,
-0.2757929861545563,
0.43761759996414185,
-0.6907293796539307,
-0.5992228984832764,
0.08684846758842468,
0.15549129247665405,
-0.34303683042526245,
0.28216031193733215,
0.03924053534865379,
-0.543425440788269,
0.27987387776374817,
1.0238815546035767,
0.2431764453649521,
-0.5227876901626587,
-0.25065183639526367,
-0.05558213219046593,
0.0011375935282558203,
-0.21196503937244415,
0.7153430581092834,
-0.6474933624267578,
0.590726375579834,
0.817197859287262,
0.44758668541908264,
0.40354788303375244,
-0.09472588449716568,
0.34858331084251404,
-0.5521063804626465,
0.02899426966905594,
0.17325708270072937,
0.28940218687057495,
0.13315142691135406,
-0.2480422407388687,
0.47409918904304504,
0.6246405839920044,
-0.3754318654537201,
-0.5959163904190063,
0.6276076436042786,
-1.3006023168563843,
-0.5990782380104065,
1.4982328414916992,
0.0922304093837738,
-0.008590676821768284,
-0.4311942458152771,
-0.3019815683364868,
0.40851932764053345,
-0.1735447198152542,
0.5318771004676819,
0.4132533669471741,
-0.3975699245929718,
0.07025612145662308,
-0.4671475887298584,
0.44694530963897705,
0.24991419911384583,
-1.0631461143493652,
0.3935025930404663,
0.8129048347473145,
0.18947981297969818,
-0.10597255080938339,
0.5211395025253296,
0.11175013333559036,
0.48291003704071045,
0.07306624203920364,
-0.14345355331897736,
-0.15346366167068481,
-0.4644712805747986,
0.4286331534385681,
0.39751070737838745,
-0.13238322734832764,
0.10013844817876816
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07384v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07384v1
|
SmallToLarge (S2L): Scalable Data Selection for Fine-tuning Large Language Models by Summarizing Training Trajectories of Small Models
| 2024-03-12T07:45:33 | 2024-03-12T07:45:33 |
Yu Yang, Siddhartha Mishra, Jeffrey N Chiang, Baharan Mirzasoleiman
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Despite the effectiveness of data selection for large language models (LLMs)
during pretraining and instruction fine-tuning phases, improving data
efficiency in supervised fine-tuning (SFT) for specialized domains poses
significant challenges due to the complexity of fine-tuning data. To bridge
this gap, we introduce an effective and scalable data selection method for SFT,
SmallToLarge (S2L), which leverages training trajectories from small models to
guide the data selection for larger models. We demonstrate through extensive
experiments that S2L significantly improves data efficiency in SFT for
mathematical problem-solving, reducing the training data to just 11% of the
original MathInstruct dataset (Yue et al., 2023) to match full dataset
performance while outperforming state-of-the-art data selection algorithms by
an average of 4.7% across 6 in- and out-domain evaluation datasets. Remarkably,
selecting only 50K data for SFT, S2L achieves a 32.7% accuracy on the most
challenging MATH (Hendrycks et al., 2021) benchmark, improving Phi-2 (Li et
al., 2023b) by 16.6%. In clinical text summarization on the MIMIC-III dataset
(Johnson et al., 2016), S2L again outperforms training on the full dataset
using only 50% of the data. Notably, S2L can perform data selection using a
reference model 40x smaller than the target model, proportionally reducing the
cost of data selection.
|
[
-0.3385346233844757,
-0.7339729070663452,
0.5211896896362305,
0.009975981898605824,
-0.3530869781970978,
-0.042260970920324326,
-0.6324741244316101,
-0.19060757756233215,
0.02033087983727455,
0.37270066142082214,
-0.6132246255874634,
-0.37039896845817566,
-0.7117855548858643,
-0.04707982391119003,
-0.19185854494571686,
0.9949586391448975,
0.15092885494232178,
0.3067210614681244,
-0.35120418667793274,
-0.13784073293209076,
-0.4442860186100006,
0.04810098558664322,
-0.8612794876098633,
-0.3697115480899811,
0.4227463901042938,
0.8255045413970947,
0.6501601934432983,
0.871073842048645,
0.7323487401008606,
0.20445822179317474,
-0.13127903640270233,
0.45643648505210876,
-0.7570897340774536,
0.06233248859643936,
-0.02827286720275879,
-0.6549718379974365,
-0.4617941081523895,
-0.3133784830570221,
0.6695243120193481,
1.0060542821884155,
-0.03489608317613602,
0.3633248209953308,
0.116249680519104,
1.1172977685928345,
-0.46254968643188477,
0.31276318430900574,
-0.5806102752685547,
0.12066546827554703,
-0.3207440674304962,
0.035890135914087296,
-0.38440632820129395,
-0.4339003264904022,
0.0824594795703888,
-0.42968204617500305,
0.22318920493125916,
0.16844429075717926,
0.41602715849876404,
0.5264205932617188,
-0.2850637137889862,
-0.29679903388023376,
-0.47572189569473267,
0.9797347784042358,
-0.5806758999824524,
0.48288989067077637,
0.4183429181575775,
0.5405484437942505,
0.15924574434757233,
-0.8682349324226379,
-0.05445298179984093,
-0.10306500643491745,
-0.161691352725029,
-0.12788605690002441,
-0.4237152934074402,
0.033016227185726166,
0.5179806351661682,
0.29772263765335083,
-0.8830240964889526,
0.33685776591300964,
-0.5650345087051392,
-0.1317262053489685,
0.702435314655304,
0.29779255390167236,
0.06148355454206467,
0.2772879898548126,
0.30629873275756836,
-0.013600289821624756,
-1.0201109647750854,
-0.23372289538383484,
-0.04209361970424652,
0.6060991287231445,
-0.008157256990671158,
0.6180962324142456,
-0.2862030565738678,
0.8595305681228638,
0.1720755398273468,
-0.1662834733724594,
0.19927071034908295,
-0.33642899990081787,
-0.2792740762233734,
-0.07422038912773132,
0.5547597408294678,
0.2735305726528168,
0.2558077275753021,
-0.11892649531364441,
-0.05843362957239151,
-0.28087738156318665,
0.14555412530899048,
-1.233973503112793,
-0.24547244608402252,
0.19061383605003357,
-0.5291719436645508,
-0.23581093549728394,
-0.13071084022521973,
-0.7829047441482544,
-0.20745527744293213,
-0.3975185453891754,
0.14101426303386688,
-0.2378920465707779,
0.12902741134166718,
0.0899282842874527,
0.17578691244125366,
-0.3338807225227356,
0.5151184797286987,
-0.959566056728363,
0.29534783959388733,
0.6264089941978455,
0.9267054200172424,
-0.3680965304374695,
-0.08649610728025436,
-0.9578260779380798,
-0.026747243478894234,
-0.6002004742622375,
0.6524200439453125,
-0.5201533436775208,
-0.4124032258987427,
-0.021440349519252777,
-0.13890933990478516,
0.023375900462269783,
-0.774852991104126,
0.29395270347595215,
-0.34848371148109436,
0.08416088670492172,
-0.1329837590456009,
-0.538793683052063,
0.25462543964385986,
-0.09395202994346619,
-0.689598023891449,
1.0922863483428955,
0.28047287464141846,
-0.6312520503997803,
0.44685766100883484,
-0.29510241746902466,
-0.622969388961792,
-0.14532025158405304,
-0.335258811712265,
-0.7456855773925781,
0.30843377113342285,
0.29151222109794617,
0.6284145712852478,
-0.5062223672866821,
0.002165216952562332,
-0.3393440842628479,
-0.46264952421188354,
-0.40362027287483215,
-0.05461341142654419,
0.46904873847961426,
0.23712876439094543,
-0.1248028352856636,
0.06628970056772232,
-0.6541056632995605,
0.12978430092334747,
0.19633202254772186,
-0.2225470244884491,
-0.401176780462265,
-0.11748487502336502,
-0.23998084664344788,
0.1806204468011856,
0.20390671491622925,
-0.253191739320755,
0.4971860349178314,
-0.6432215571403503,
0.35183238983154297,
0.32233425974845886,
-0.06216351315379143,
0.7093551754951477,
-0.2871731221675873,
0.5551867485046387,
-0.19836455583572388,
0.024615850299596786,
0.1321350783109665,
-0.3380274176597595,
-0.6191741824150085,
-0.3224848508834839,
0.5763550400733948,
0.24038971960544586,
-0.9635843634605408,
0.321571946144104,
-0.5193088054656982,
-0.7034440636634827,
-0.4922923743724823,
0.23279209434986115,
0.3872760236263275,
0.42625778913497925,
0.44034847617149353,
0.06066364049911499,
-0.4387896955013275,
-1.0266119241714478,
-0.23373040556907654,
0.10256113111972809,
-0.3158225119113922,
0.41870999336242676,
0.36862093210220337,
-0.2508220970630646,
0.8126893639564514,
-0.9322770833969116,
-0.4624619483947754,
-0.44192779064178467,
0.028064651414752007,
0.12166748195886612,
0.4256521463394165,
0.6922340989112854,
-0.5662180185317993,
-0.8559539914131165,
0.046021752059459686,
-0.3742521107196808,
-0.03858539089560509,
-0.026891188696026802,
0.023692138493061066,
-0.01932435855269432,
0.496072381734848,
-0.48083898425102234,
0.41261884570121765,
0.32743164896965027,
-0.17453452944755554,
0.28112852573394775,
-0.37402063608169556,
-0.019929153844714165,
-0.9349702596664429,
-0.03154744580388069,
-0.039395034313201904,
-0.43764716386795044,
-0.47808608412742615,
-0.20462819933891296,
0.38554781675338745,
0.12536197900772095,
-0.28575316071510315,
0.5796267986297607,
-0.3956732749938965,
-0.14925050735473633,
-0.15641500055789948,
0.21304573118686676,
-0.39289310574531555,
0.2520825266838074,
-0.012355952523648739,
0.9979153871536255,
0.5554431676864624,
-0.5108595490455627,
0.12059345096349716,
0.4248911440372467,
-0.3848849833011627,
0.2085610032081604,
-0.5389083623886108,
-0.01011993084102869,
0.040172919631004333,
0.15585170686244965,
-0.8550878167152405,
-0.2251954972743988,
-0.23868632316589355,
-0.36048758029937744,
0.42283037304878235,
-0.25985223054885864,
-0.8094721436500549,
-0.3294990360736847,
-0.3378290832042694,
0.4435357451438904,
0.5384860038757324,
-0.6325213313102722,
0.30892470479011536,
0.45938393473625183,
-0.523762583732605,
-0.2009298950433731,
-0.9137452840805054,
-0.143734872341156,
-0.1206095889210701,
-0.5147250890731812,
0.1935994029045105,
-0.18784160912036896,
-0.12257356941699982,
-0.3374033272266388,
-0.24371574819087982,
-0.024945685639977455,
-0.14058947563171387,
-0.0744967982172966,
0.2040875256061554,
-0.22017410397529602,
0.3200695812702179,
0.5739136338233948,
-0.2959768772125244,
-0.1541534662246704,
-0.3378361165523529,
0.478496253490448,
-0.1013968288898468,
-0.1388758271932602,
-0.11705215275287628,
0.0705919936299324,
0.29746776819229126,
-0.11056957393884659,
0.5889127254486084,
0.48526570200920105,
-0.43247365951538086,
-0.5506631731987,
-0.26872479915618896,
-0.47264227271080017,
-0.4357900023460388,
0.6303428411483765,
-0.2394455224275589,
-1.1909877061843872,
0.0765182301402092,
-0.20135991275310516,
0.14656366407871246,
0.5955939292907715,
0.7717320919036865,
0.03209094703197479,
1.2755705118179321,
0.6005386114120483,
-0.07456677407026291,
0.5351629257202148,
-0.345383882522583,
0.035008713603019714,
-0.6455426812171936,
0.08967020362615585,
-0.48307350277900696,
-0.2832159996032715,
-0.5595014691352844,
-0.5804001092910767,
0.4581386148929596,
-0.03792443498969078,
-0.04215644299983978,
0.2537531852722168,
-0.4637383222579956,
0.6911375522613525,
0.1553359180688858,
0.05564377084374428,
0.2863005995750427,
0.3096625804901123,
0.0032885523978620768,
-0.45191624760627747,
-0.8670752644538879,
-0.19767965376377106,
1.4513128995895386,
0.3190550208091736,
0.6781286597251892,
0.1633182168006897,
0.5587289333343506,
0.22531108558177948,
0.21517448127269745,
-0.8211356997489929,
0.4943128228187561,
-0.6853477358818054,
-0.33818182349205017,
-0.47146865725517273,
-0.6060848832130432,
-0.9455470442771912,
0.2963173985481262,
-0.081562839448452,
-0.7687307596206665,
0.03948063403367996,
0.2728029787540436,
-0.680855393409729,
0.14210772514343262,
-0.47770869731903076,
0.7038230299949646,
0.024131599813699722,
-0.42961469292640686,
-0.522521436214447,
-0.54270339012146,
0.27430546283721924,
-0.46013861894607544,
0.10005639493465424,
0.1677260547876358,
-0.17289242148399353,
0.8236841559410095,
-0.6811563968658447,
0.6135247349739075,
-0.06734584271907806,
-0.12225984036922455,
0.008732585236430168,
0.2137225717306137,
0.7706566452980042,
0.2335558831691742,
-0.05310559645295143,
0.13176725804805756,
0.10430426150560379,
-0.28940635919570923,
-0.7892032861709595,
0.7386752367019653,
-0.42722973227500916,
-0.21838754415512085,
-0.17318104207515717,
-0.3754085898399353,
-0.71407151222229,
0.32681694626808167,
0.2965618968009949,
0.34746745228767395,
0.08364459872245789,
0.7252854108810425,
0.8861128091812134,
0.05297515541315079,
0.11017124354839325,
0.4620979428291321,
-0.21813075244426727,
-0.35562270879745483,
1.0517116785049438,
0.23229946196079254,
0.30845966935157776,
0.4097502827644348,
0.3329371511936188,
-0.272171288728714,
-0.7690492272377014,
-0.46418890357017517,
0.29683294892311096,
-0.4055986702442169,
-0.4459982216358185,
-0.5550146102905273,
-0.16938453912734985,
-0.2785729169845581,
-0.16429594159126282,
-0.6616764664649963,
-0.8241055011749268,
-0.2684002220630646,
-0.0539579913020134,
0.12627536058425903,
0.3900127708911896,
-0.06014564260840416,
0.4873250424861908,
-0.6815394163131714,
0.4063658118247986,
0.24688564240932465,
0.25942137837409973,
-0.1712697595357895,
-0.724671483039856,
-0.6093811988830566,
-0.007054001558572054,
-0.010348704643547535,
-0.2917811870574951,
0.2891983091831207,
0.23286251723766327,
0.2989574074745178,
0.44302746653556824,
-0.20844252407550812,
0.8142912983894348,
-0.5929888486862183,
0.6322051286697388,
0.2101081907749176,
-0.5688108801841736,
0.8094611167907715,
-0.22744962573051453,
0.2824464738368988,
0.7927176356315613,
0.03784387558698654,
-0.23341304063796997,
-0.18440496921539307,
-0.6495497226715088,
-0.7461718916893005,
0.9867023229598999,
0.33796823024749756,
-0.319425106048584,
0.4032149910926819,
0.43609702587127686,
0.26916298270225525,
0.34925949573516846,
-0.2277890294790268,
-0.45037972927093506,
0.3997943103313446,
-0.4122210741043091,
-0.39064937829971313,
-0.19733218848705292,
-0.09661924839019775,
-0.48318904638290405,
0.6232311725616455,
-0.4780171811580658,
0.24979864060878754,
-0.27805396914482117,
-0.18198631703853607,
-0.27216389775276184,
-0.02637406997382641,
0.5814781188964844,
0.6012251377105713,
-0.13846157491207123,
-0.1112089455127716,
0.43115437030792236,
-0.712282121181488,
-0.2566656172275543,
0.2662767767906189,
-0.21421852707862854,
0.06757938861846924,
0.5266945958137512,
0.686771810054779,
0.3084444999694824,
-0.7982676029205322,
0.6003080606460571,
-0.23240216076374054,
-0.293976753950119,
0.045880019664764404,
0.3009839653968811,
-0.12521739304065704,
0.3070327639579773,
0.15515883266925812,
0.13729530572891235,
0.231204092502594,
-0.14576110243797302,
0.3114078640937805,
0.3353128731250763,
-0.317196786403656,
-0.1273108869791031,
0.6206185221672058,
-0.09473215788602829,
0.04500601440668106,
0.5063710808753967,
-0.02433856949210167,
-0.007371550891548395,
0.6880477666854858,
0.36168187856674194,
0.6637819409370422,
-0.0009967167861759663,
0.10235711932182312,
0.59192955493927,
0.25704681873321533,
-0.42670419812202454,
0.22035111486911774,
-0.05365115404129028,
-0.3501056134700775,
-0.3237409293651581,
-0.46972012519836426,
-0.20680546760559082,
0.14682896435260773,
-0.7198131084442139,
0.258593887090683,
-0.5982106924057007,
0.043853405863046646,
-0.0024669913109391928,
0.4577367901802063,
-0.713209867477417,
0.4324580729007721,
-0.059974703937768936,
1.1458362340927124,
-0.629349946975708,
1.1602725982666016,
0.5724944472312927,
-0.23610250651836395,
-0.7477035522460938,
0.10269617289304733,
0.22288092970848083,
-0.8164353370666504,
0.6810970902442932,
-0.1598065197467804,
0.02440975233912468,
0.09863591939210892,
-0.45636630058288574,
-0.8518909811973572,
1.255879521369934,
0.4069635272026062,
-0.9486852288246155,
-0.10290081053972244,
0.21070793271064758,
0.7261579632759094,
-0.6030905842781067,
0.15997926890850067,
0.9349011182785034,
0.3076157569885254,
0.27862557768821716,
-0.9018632769584656,
-0.06120472028851509,
0.01069665513932705,
0.15330369770526886,
0.22997504472732544,
-0.8811715245246887,
0.6090236306190491,
-0.3484196066856384,
0.07158096879720688,
0.13132911920547485,
0.5473582148551941,
0.3292565941810608,
0.32012760639190674,
0.5262951254844666,
0.3197372555732727,
0.8256040215492249,
-0.256729394197464,
0.7697793841362,
-0.2547621726989746,
0.5700046420097351,
1.265132188796997,
0.008107747882604599,
0.9047268629074097,
0.47885534167289734,
-0.398264616727829,
-0.019528459757566452,
0.827880322933197,
-0.1220719963312149,
0.6264581084251404,
-0.011885138228535652,
0.15852075815200806,
-0.38040754199028015,
0.2304954081773758,
-0.47012001276016235,
0.25257202982902527,
0.43893665075302124,
-0.3016635477542877,
-0.3524303138256073,
-0.007807101123034954,
-0.10564803332090378,
-0.23329544067382812,
-0.4034939110279083,
0.790844202041626,
0.14168024063110352,
-0.43518495559692383,
0.42582592368125916,
0.022842708975076675,
0.3426651954650879,
-0.818756639957428,
0.11828725785017014,
-0.48944541811943054,
0.2354077249765396,
-0.3230776786804199,
-0.5988683700561523,
0.3130936622619629,
0.03856302797794342,
-0.07994198054075241,
-0.23218467831611633,
0.748167872428894,
-0.5285148024559021,
-0.5792697668075562,
-0.012474851682782173,
0.45614731311798096,
0.0009819428669288754,
-0.16413258016109467,
-0.6614992618560791,
0.050938930362463,
0.3190244734287262,
-0.22013574838638306,
0.469745010137558,
0.36864131689071655,
-0.15156152844429016,
0.7537816166877747,
0.5323299169540405,
0.5592268705368042,
-0.28043749928474426,
0.10814397782087326,
0.9953839778900146,
-0.46039262413978577,
-0.6922646164894104,
-0.682648777961731,
0.37778183817863464,
-0.2790517210960388,
-0.2041018158197403,
0.6732034683227539,
1.0351229906082153,
0.7967961430549622,
-0.08231556415557861,
0.8091326355934143,
0.0910162404179573,
0.8236844539642334,
-0.6639606356620789,
0.7084358930587769,
-0.923136830329895,
0.4934801757335663,
-0.019408496096730232,
-0.8359190225601196,
-0.5411776304244995,
0.670123279094696,
-0.6000688076019287,
0.14831864833831787,
0.6848716735839844,
0.7930456399917603,
-0.2628141939640045,
0.018955769017338753,
0.43526238203048706,
0.3724828064441681,
0.27411791682243347,
0.4602522850036621,
0.36824941635131836,
-0.402023047208786,
0.4931184649467468,
-0.1860569268465042,
-0.3850138485431671,
-0.585401177406311,
-0.4717995524406433,
-1.133017897605896,
-0.38928908109664917,
-0.4321536123752594,
-0.23644623160362244,
-0.05782000720500946,
1.0281033515930176,
0.8751271367073059,
-0.9672067165374756,
-0.05474069342017174,
0.053400564938783646,
0.0003778749087359756,
-0.20982199907302856,
-0.12261081486940384,
0.5749619603157043,
-0.39961445331573486,
-0.7137302160263062,
0.38772302865982056,
0.471865177154541,
-0.03345360979437828,
-0.07849035412073135,
-0.1556934118270874,
0.3899867534637451,
-0.14078201353549957,
0.7605621218681335,
0.25024276971817017,
-0.47237709164619446,
0.003584056394174695,
-0.32274365425109863,
-0.206856831908226,
0.014584893360733986,
0.9159390926361084,
-0.5019358992576599,
0.3791747987270355,
0.37742045521736145,
0.8065306544303894,
0.7575235962867737,
-0.191255584359169,
0.33681821823120117,
-0.8835640549659729,
0.24030834436416626,
0.31626012921333313,
0.24840685725212097,
-0.018929878249764442,
-0.37101566791534424,
0.6928634643554688,
0.09262380748987198,
-0.5158432722091675,
-0.8503486514091492,
0.1014849990606308,
-0.765647292137146,
-0.4056774079799652,
1.2333965301513672,
0.29990577697753906,
0.020389793440699577,
0.24514761567115784,
-0.3676762580871582,
0.009497134014964104,
-0.2997266948223114,
0.7818665504455566,
0.50562584400177,
-0.3389926552772522,
-0.10206470638513565,
-0.7980318069458008,
0.9306248426437378,
0.48479703068733215,
-0.8380418419837952,
0.2668994069099426,
0.5393203496932983,
0.2619112730026245,
-0.2739971876144409,
0.5006361603736877,
0.007224628701806068,
0.2293846309185028,
-0.15413585305213928,
-0.5821772813796997,
-0.15069246292114258,
-0.4198223650455475,
-0.4446113705635071,
0.06120515987277031,
-0.010804950259625912,
0.07015722244977951
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07379v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07379v2
|
Hallmarks of Optimization Trajectories in Neural Networks: Directional Exploration and Redundancy
| 2024-03-12T07:32:47 | 2024-06-24T04:53:34 |
Sidak Pal Singh, Bobby He, Thomas Hofmann, Bernhard Schölkopf
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
We propose a fresh take on understanding the mechanisms of neural networks by
analyzing the rich directional structure of optimization trajectories,
represented by their pointwise parameters. Towards this end, we introduce some
natural notions of the complexity of optimization trajectories, both
qualitative and quantitative, which hallmark the directional nature of
optimization in neural networks: when is there redundancy, and when
exploration. We use them to reveal the inherent nuance and interplay involved
between various optimization choices, such as momentum and weight decay.
Further, the trajectory perspective helps us see the effect of scale on
regularizing the directional nature of trajectories, and as a by-product, we
also observe an intriguing heterogeneity of Q,K,V dynamics in the middle
attention layers in LLMs and which is homogenized by scale. Importantly, we put
the significant directional redundancy observed to the test by demonstrating
that training only scalar batchnorm parameters some while into training matches
the performance of training the entire network, which thus exhibits the
potential of hybrid optimization schemes that are geared towards efficiency.
|
[
-0.15405482053756714,
-0.37900930643081665,
0.4361063539981842,
0.37397101521492004,
-0.23476846516132355,
0.048341602087020874,
-0.09012798964977264,
-0.08773636072874069,
0.6315043568611145,
0.2002408504486084,
-0.9777040481567383,
-0.05483289062976837,
-0.4853058159351349,
-0.11912142485380173,
-0.49049896001815796,
0.9830233454704285,
0.0925760343670845,
0.11389973014593124,
-0.18302947282791138,
-0.5226150751113892,
-0.39304524660110474,
-0.23046427965164185,
-0.9729293584823608,
-0.46599632501602173,
1.089464545249939,
-0.07478870451450348,
0.4764804244041443,
0.8985998034477234,
0.42404603958129883,
0.3063018321990967,
-0.4780401587486267,
-0.09832543134689331,
-0.6169667840003967,
0.32640621066093445,
0.05149553716182709,
-0.5461932420730591,
0.0004073909076396376,
-0.0036411189939826727,
0.6988245844841003,
1.1174607276916504,
-0.14952440559864044,
-0.04753974825143814,
0.18694740533828735,
1.0372815132141113,
-0.5370945930480957,
-0.1752791553735733,
-0.32113340497016907,
0.4946291446685791,
-0.01600790210068226,
-0.3189307451248169,
0.3447667956352234,
-0.6153327822685242,
0.5087631940841675,
-0.43954557180404663,
0.1102508082985878,
-0.3445247709751129,
0.5058726668357849,
0.5563277006149292,
-0.43011096119880676,
-0.04795277491211891,
-0.991446316242218,
1.0109540224075317,
-0.1788162738084793,
0.23498836159706116,
-0.24237662553787231,
0.5344041585922241,
0.032024577260017395,
-0.8047381043434143,
0.055139075964689255,
-0.1289440095424652,
0.16074489057064056,
0.06385970115661621,
-0.2312857061624527,
0.24257320165634155,
0.17033669352531433,
-0.009186896495521069,
-0.436661034822464,
0.2091829627752304,
-0.5100741982460022,
-0.1370001584291458,
0.7500771880149841,
0.3568190038204193,
0.19784151017665863,
0.30035001039505005,
-0.2460029423236847,
-0.09756603091955185,
-0.5322099924087524,
0.3035857677459717,
0.6240091323852539,
0.09010643512010574,
-0.011335285380482674,
0.3390732407569885,
-0.34682053327560425,
0.6472482085227966,
-0.042882777750492096,
0.06067341938614845,
-0.036100681871175766,
-0.6141353845596313,
0.08304016292095184,
0.12016113102436066,
0.5708412528038025,
0.16465017199516296,
0.12508037686347961,
-0.23171605169773102,
-0.1928052008152008,
-0.4232610762119293,
0.6230036020278931,
-0.49128708243370056,
-0.19163969159126282,
0.5484500527381897,
-0.4414885342121124,
-0.6376286149024963,
-0.3358913064002991,
-0.6388818621635437,
-0.24087196588516235,
-0.4573143720626831,
0.30935409665107727,
-0.16182246804237366,
-0.08690843731164932,
0.2729734778404236,
-0.2911076545715332,
0.1829458773136139,
0.2622925639152527,
-0.7306970953941345,
-0.07981184124946594,
0.8873382806777954,
0.8538792133331299,
-0.05931925028562546,
-0.5035673379898071,
-0.28448474407196045,
-0.32544657588005066,
-0.3168151378631592,
0.20360298454761505,
-0.29972749948501587,
-0.18018099665641785,
-0.13982608914375305,
-0.31771376729011536,
-0.08700075000524521,
-0.3443900942802429,
0.35934972763061523,
-0.6826005578041077,
-0.061278171837329865,
-0.41278085112571716,
0.00627758726477623,
-0.7693191170692444,
0.4882250130176544,
-0.688300609588623,
0.684089183807373,
-0.14838698506355286,
-0.3714316487312317,
0.24255070090293884,
-0.8139600157737732,
-0.6504242420196533,
-0.07101083546876907,
-0.13002386689186096,
-0.5131486058235168,
0.61850905418396,
-0.3170219361782074,
0.15259402990341187,
-0.09268264472484589,
0.07130231708288193,
-0.08409447222948074,
-0.42220091819763184,
0.0506509505212307,
-0.1467956155538559,
1.080715298652649,
-0.03651478514075279,
-0.5147544145584106,
0.3320530951023102,
-0.9604321718215942,
0.0789811983704567,
0.08949191868305206,
-0.42769965529441833,
-0.25084611773490906,
0.3529250919818878,
-0.37464603781700134,
0.17745228111743927,
0.437441349029541,
-0.17736773192882538,
0.11114996671676636,
-0.24404729902744293,
0.8843448162078857,
0.5894185304641724,
0.34197375178337097,
0.46584612131118774,
-0.07135035842657089,
0.5774388313293457,
0.18533483147621155,
0.613345742225647,
0.26941797137260437,
-0.3827403783798218,
-0.7339735627174377,
0.11102811992168427,
0.03467204049229622,
0.15252599120140076,
-0.10565216839313507,
0.27756229043006897,
-0.30574271082878113,
-0.5012814998626709,
-0.15016061067581177,
-0.17364834249019623,
0.23285019397735596,
0.48702093958854675,
0.13384424149990082,
-0.12361253052949905,
-0.5799514055252075,
-1.0616087913513184,
-0.3893465995788574,
-0.02269372157752514,
0.24521955847740173,
0.36750489473342896,
0.5365472435951233,
-0.28168848156929016,
0.4833190143108368,
-0.03717702999711037,
0.249965101480484,
-0.09542065858840942,
0.3253624737262726,
0.1729171723127365,
0.5922695398330688,
0.3073689341545105,
-0.9810553193092346,
-0.10145517438650131,
-0.01711307466030121,
-0.6659712791442871,
0.19456444680690765,
-0.44952937960624695,
-0.1341639906167984,
-0.3619828224182129,
0.40308791399002075,
-0.5548033714294434,
0.3200761079788208,
0.18670016527175903,
0.1320641040802002,
0.49023181200027466,
-0.12270815670490265,
-0.24428057670593262,
-0.300260454416275,
-0.0227813720703125,
0.0712018609046936,
0.3180255889892578,
-0.7573975920677185,
0.08748511970043182,
-0.19221912324428558,
0.05712931603193283,
-0.396356463432312,
0.01327531412243843,
-0.5319095253944397,
-0.552611768245697,
0.0460897795855999,
0.22469617426395416,
0.12668590247631073,
0.7768070101737976,
-0.20923323929309845,
0.3974740207195282,
0.46016785502433777,
-0.7244249582290649,
0.396109402179718,
-0.2726752460002899,
0.20870037376880646,
0.2684468626976013,
-0.9132466316223145,
-0.09649065136909485,
-0.34259945154190063,
-0.24936771392822266,
-0.8723715543746948,
0.23199865221977234,
-0.006398103665560484,
-0.40791845321655273,
0.25760966539382935,
-0.15305906534194946,
-0.0439300611615181,
-0.27505871653556824,
-0.46319180727005005,
0.6310644149780273,
0.28463104367256165,
-0.26867371797561646,
0.6163877248764038,
-0.06652212888002396,
0.5397117733955383,
-0.6999499797821045,
-0.5659416913986206,
-0.2103070616722107,
-0.4176323711872101,
-0.49356862902641296,
-0.02047322504222393,
0.22413721680641174,
-0.21372845768928528,
-0.18656134605407715,
-0.2688320577144623,
0.24981121718883514,
0.5139705538749695,
0.21952633559703827,
0.07418720424175262,
-0.3828960359096527,
-0.1592051237821579,
0.054737139493227005,
0.10816467553377151,
0.5425680875778198,
-1.0381098985671997,
0.49128782749176025,
-0.1673799455165863,
-0.19887666404247284,
-0.4198148846626282,
0.22995005548000336,
0.6122177839279175,
-0.2643497884273529,
0.5651724934577942,
0.5514878034591675,
-0.28722918033599854,
-0.006556354463100433,
-0.06910547614097595,
-0.18146167695522308,
-0.4662419855594635,
0.7775430679321289,
-0.31771841645240784,
-0.5574749112129211,
0.7396735548973083,
0.03404780477285385,
0.07525418698787689,
0.43928009271621704,
0.3650779128074646,
-0.3091856837272644,
0.9313817620277405,
0.5115339756011963,
0.0632006824016571,
0.44175219535827637,
-0.6731098890304565,
0.19219984114170074,
-0.944054901599884,
-0.498109370470047,
-0.4094065725803375,
-1.3250327110290527,
-0.902313768863678,
-0.14987759292125702,
0.6048484444618225,
0.18488618731498718,
-0.6501452922821045,
0.10248913615942001,
-0.735954225063324,
0.7829327583312988,
0.7482945322990417,
0.0025184559635818005,
-0.10521429777145386,
0.02322390116751194,
-0.34880709648132324,
-0.11675173789262772,
-0.9763237833976746,
-0.09872512519359589,
1.0695581436157227,
0.2532988488674164,
0.31026163697242737,
-0.1120699867606163,
0.8506630063056946,
-0.1336047500371933,
-0.17053596675395966,
-0.907973051071167,
0.6128132343292236,
0.06305261701345444,
-0.3902350068092346,
-0.4274626672267914,
-0.4617544114589691,
-1.0566755533218384,
0.11815674602985382,
-0.1173490360379219,
-0.8264402151107788,
0.49070942401885986,
0.06733495742082596,
-0.7177065014839172,
0.4371298849582672,
-0.2640412449836731,
0.8132854700088501,
-0.701217770576477,
-0.6458779573440552,
-0.11862210184335709,
-1.0430985689163208,
0.2212226837873459,
0.18984363973140717,
-0.4463755190372467,
0.369575560092926,
-0.3778856098651886,
0.7521300315856934,
-0.28134477138519287,
0.6681578159332275,
-0.20665018260478973,
0.28330284357070923,
0.21945950388908386,
0.2822713553905487,
0.44618886709213257,
-0.15394474565982819,
0.21478135883808136,
0.28942960500717163,
-0.4655231237411499,
-0.47189652919769287,
-0.7426382303237915,
0.713614284992218,
-0.9364097714424133,
-0.4463043510913849,
-0.16573986411094666,
-0.581757128238678,
-0.18633344769477844,
0.3247067630290985,
0.25342345237731934,
0.48943719267845154,
0.005401580594480038,
0.3061563968658447,
0.6955083012580872,
-0.029585571959614754,
0.6489955186843872,
-0.38579225540161133,
0.13784420490264893,
-0.1585657149553299,
0.8778989315032959,
0.13866282999515533,
0.2889816462993622,
0.5445461869239807,
0.3603206276893616,
-0.2645644545555115,
-1.0709598064422607,
-0.021030692383646965,
0.2648852467536926,
-0.6645253896713257,
0.20147918164730072,
-0.5534080266952515,
-0.30873778462409973,
0.27231892943382263,
-0.27236250042915344,
-0.5377865433692932,
-0.8026617765426636,
-0.5412358045578003,
-0.0412580631673336,
-0.07482447475194931,
0.7985589504241943,
-0.23280690610408783,
0.5355777144432068,
-0.6140609383583069,
-0.22705601155757904,
0.40259870886802673,
-0.08954504877328873,
0.3282213509082794,
-0.17147816717624664,
-0.46151015162467957,
0.2196945995092392,
-0.46376869082450867,
-0.514941930770874,
0.25129640102386475,
-0.061722591519355774,
0.5536284446716309,
0.7715850472450256,
-0.4505474269390106,
0.46779078245162964,
-0.27785712480545044,
0.8083312511444092,
0.3655586838722229,
-0.2834334671497345,
0.4905523657798767,
-0.4640118479728699,
0.07559932768344879,
0.45314130187034607,
0.941821813583374,
-0.2531897723674774,
0.09141743928194046,
-0.7210180759429932,
-0.6768144369125366,
0.45720869302749634,
0.16594019532203674,
-0.11355321109294891,
0.42453399300575256,
0.7428443431854248,
-0.2237386256456375,
0.49455028772354126,
-0.5762883424758911,
-0.38387492299079895,
-0.32601314783096313,
-0.11211670190095901,
0.06250282377004623,
-0.25574520230293274,
-0.6699522733688354,
-0.12851139903068542,
0.32179591059684753,
0.08373451977968216,
0.33876973390579224,
0.12520606815814972,
0.33849000930786133,
0.012266043573617935,
-0.3198416829109192,
1.1220637559890747,
0.5881654024124146,
-0.3090633749961853,
-0.0973997488617897,
-0.26544445753097534,
-0.475042462348938,
0.21898694336414337,
-0.26266807317733765,
-0.33516043424606323,
-0.16603592038154602,
0.5017635822296143,
0.8734855055809021,
0.1593942791223526,
-0.04221699386835098,
0.11844375729560852,
0.09261395037174225,
-0.3660900592803955,
-0.17891457676887512,
0.15857046842575073,
-0.008680818602442741,
0.6953791379928589,
0.32927563786506653,
0.5701188445091248,
0.26789337396621704,
-0.32167112827301025,
-0.30133289098739624,
0.6304700374603271,
-0.4933280348777771,
-0.5022516250610352,
0.7686607241630554,
0.11175836622714996,
-0.6577244400978088,
0.6350803971290588,
-0.07977034151554108,
-0.8187920451164246,
0.9965931177139282,
0.015092211775481701,
1.3919750452041626,
0.3780786097049713,
0.0008722493075765669,
0.4761887192726135,
0.5905103087425232,
0.005290189757943153,
0.0982394888997078,
-0.2568914592266083,
-0.5430985689163208,
-0.24989205598831177,
-0.5180816650390625,
-0.13921105861663818,
0.03786009922623634,
-0.6223289966583252,
-0.06496616452932358,
-0.7541526556015015,
-0.13949395716190338,
0.009053087793290615,
0.014474681578576565,
-0.3617941439151764,
0.09842787683010101,
-0.12128069996833801,
0.6350722908973694,
-0.4167886972427368,
0.2751588225364685,
0.7637656331062317,
-0.289752334356308,
-0.7862304449081421,
0.01806492730975151,
0.20202820003032684,
-0.8627150058746338,
1.1663732528686523,
0.07477910071611404,
-0.32315701246261597,
-0.01837381348013878,
-0.499462753534317,
-0.7623969912528992,
1.219740867614746,
-0.2054232954978943,
-0.5873986482620239,
-0.4466979205608368,
0.23289424180984497,
0.5844322443008423,
-0.35020577907562256,
0.06747040152549744,
0.5904423594474792,
0.29695364832878113,
0.22811280190944672,
-0.2972204089164734,
-0.19894567131996155,
0.08289951831102371,
0.3750399947166443,
0.258725643157959,
-0.8389553427696228,
0.8707396984100342,
-0.43872421979904175,
-0.019221175462007523,
-0.02826392464339733,
0.39165177941322327,
0.06872323155403137,
0.21836058795452118,
0.4096423089504242,
0.6226997375488281,
0.39004987478256226,
-0.2819395661354065,
0.9968491196632385,
-0.317554235458374,
0.1758623570203781,
0.6520134210586548,
0.1673198640346527,
0.2859972417354584,
0.8310098648071289,
-0.22213242948055267,
0.2400214672088623,
0.7371611595153809,
0.29067766666412354,
0.578495442867279,
0.5398904085159302,
-0.1166517361998558,
-0.02485957369208336,
0.294792115688324,
-0.014710492454469204,
0.27011024951934814,
0.1014789342880249,
-0.15263451635837555,
-0.1935027688741684,
-0.1384831666946411,
-0.28934481739997864,
-0.0971783995628357,
-0.5675459504127502,
0.5203941464424133,
-0.10081800073385239,
-0.6122933626174927,
0.6427202820777893,
-0.2725723683834076,
0.3927080035209656,
-0.6992666125297546,
0.21669748425483704,
-0.6444398164749146,
0.07746902853250504,
-0.17624996602535248,
-0.4617284834384918,
0.3460995554924011,
-0.7432344555854797,
-0.21580687165260315,
-0.0031739091500639915,
0.5237171053886414,
-0.06552144140005112,
-0.14449957013130188,
0.2850005626678467,
0.24592316150665283,
-0.0888858214020729,
0.06231063976883888,
-0.7078233957290649,
0.22752349078655243,
0.25125977396965027,
-0.36647069454193115,
0.22354227304458618,
0.6184670925140381,
0.14521820843219757,
0.9612253904342651,
0.4549720585346222,
0.4252910017967224,
0.3955608010292053,
-0.16401901841163635,
0.5702452063560486,
-0.7871623039245605,
-0.4668886661529541,
-0.8093976974487305,
0.41868460178375244,
0.01801397278904915,
-0.49756553769111633,
0.4847354292869568,
0.32570257782936096,
0.7169618606567383,
0.08337853848934174,
0.21291889250278473,
0.4805144667625427,
-0.14110159873962402,
-0.4297332763671875,
0.5914012789726257,
-0.9657914638519287,
0.40126022696495056,
0.27109774947166443,
-1.024283766746521,
-0.3042479455471039,
0.5942625403404236,
-0.2687672972679138,
0.2804947793483734,
0.6087343692779541,
0.6882932186126709,
-0.05715727433562279,
0.11908962577581406,
0.15102753043174744,
0.04300551488995552,
0.07337023317813873,
0.7043430209159851,
0.8659207224845886,
-0.30355870723724365,
0.38483747839927673,
-0.42670705914497375,
-0.020543504506349564,
-0.4670911431312561,
-0.7566189765930176,
-0.5341577529907227,
-0.5480852723121643,
-0.5831539034843445,
-0.44573715329170227,
-0.0198894664645195,
0.48152291774749756,
0.7890392541885376,
-0.36981213092803955,
-0.34323379397392273,
-0.5532293319702148,
0.3778075575828552,
-0.3217603266239166,
-0.2519577741622925,
0.050582095980644226,
-0.41066721081733704,
-0.5242708921432495,
0.15713971853256226,
0.5191757082939148,
0.23125649988651276,
-0.6655222773551941,
0.08720425516366959,
-0.31871530413627625,
-0.15070654451847076,
0.4285151958465576,
0.6753093004226685,
-0.3471105992794037,
0.09622671455144882,
0.06884182244539261,
-0.016210539266467094,
0.059070900082588196,
1.0021467208862305,
-0.4042785167694092,
0.15074512362480164,
0.498802125453949,
0.905515730381012,
0.47960343956947327,
-0.2368091642856598,
0.4763469099998474,
-0.8877465724945068,
0.20677271485328674,
0.648777961730957,
0.2997726500034332,
0.07039661705493927,
-0.400897741317749,
0.5894032716751099,
0.3373148441314697,
-0.5261442065238953,
-0.8351350426673889,
0.2811638116836548,
-1.0230028629302979,
0.01688458025455475,
0.9160231947898865,
0.13053248822689056,
-0.48993346095085144,
0.4443727135658264,
0.25519251823425293,
0.1188729852437973,
0.05765283852815628,
0.6326658725738525,
0.501092255115509,
-0.47391027212142944,
-0.07906891405582428,
-0.5486568808555603,
0.5934851765632629,
0.6775199770927429,
-0.21010766923427582,
-0.29735225439071655,
0.41832461953163147,
0.06792628020048141,
0.554477334022522,
0.04571428894996643,
-0.1068103164434433,
0.27523383498191833,
0.03630463778972626,
-0.32421132922172546,
-0.051223378628492355,
-0.5951640605926514,
-0.761882483959198,
0.12509450316429138,
-0.10433154553174973,
-0.6371140480041504
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07378v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07378v4
|
SVD-LLM: Truncation-aware Singular Value Decomposition for Large Language Model Compression
| 2024-03-12T07:31:18 | 2024-05-28T13:41:26 |
Xin Wang, Yu Zheng, Zhongwei Wan, Mi Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have been hindered by their
substantial sizes, which necessitate LLM compression methods for practical
deployment. Singular Value Decomposition (SVD) offers a promising solution for
LLM compression. However, state-of-the-art SVD-based LLM compression methods
have two key limitations: truncating smaller singular values may lead to higher
compression loss, and the lack of update on the compressed weight after SVD
truncation. In this work, we propose SVD-LLM, a new SVD-based LLM compression
method that addresses the limitations of existing methods. SVD-LLM incorporates
a truncation-aware data whitening strategy to ensure a direct mapping between
singular values and compression loss. Moreover, SVD-LLM adopts a layer-wise
closed-form model parameter update strategy to compensate for accuracy
degradation under high compression ratios. We evaluate SVD-LLM on a total of 10
datasets and eight models from three different LLM families at four different
scales. Our results demonstrate the superiority of SVD-LLM over
state-of-the-arts, especially at high model compression ratios.
|
[
-0.2719462513923645,
-0.5124316811561584,
0.2518002390861511,
0.18630024790763855,
-0.6549579501152039,
0.19990727305412292,
-0.4566914141178131,
-0.2659553289413452,
0.22593021392822266,
0.582391083240509,
-0.6542662978172302,
-1.0441174507141113,
-0.44951125979423523,
-0.10598744451999664,
-0.12210022658109665,
0.6832107305526733,
0.07289841026067734,
0.06864681094884872,
-0.5003274083137512,
-0.10525239259004593,
-0.5035644173622131,
-0.8585384488105774,
-0.342459499835968,
0.1208476647734642,
0.3290688991546631,
0.2916015088558197,
0.3789832592010498,
0.8240650296211243,
0.5581651329994202,
0.21095800399780273,
-0.5862624645233154,
0.24147726595401764,
-0.6405337452888489,
0.5491903424263,
0.3738822638988495,
-0.2103239744901657,
-0.6284281015396118,
-0.3380213975906372,
0.9222469925880432,
0.8277782797813416,
-0.2391742765903473,
0.4678996801376343,
-0.042634040117263794,
0.6596689820289612,
-0.80205237865448,
0.21059377491474152,
-0.5266918540000916,
0.06479690223932266,
-0.12853801250457764,
-0.0444972924888134,
-0.5315290689468384,
-0.572566568851471,
-0.20912186801433563,
-0.19199754297733307,
0.15222103893756866,
-0.2754520773887634,
0.6157358884811401,
0.6896699070930481,
-0.33829137682914734,
0.2776947319507599,
-1.1424620151519775,
0.7609975934028625,
-1.0674242973327637,
0.6046661734580994,
-0.1601915955543518,
0.14276310801506042,
-0.21150271594524384,
-0.31611835956573486,
-0.5074183344841003,
-0.013278081081807613,
0.4840335547924042,
-0.1355951428413391,
-0.00698121078312397,
0.18751606345176697,
0.24794191122055054,
0.4325571060180664,
-0.36273282766342163,
0.4354854226112366,
-0.6096571087837219,
-0.06796915829181671,
0.5733078718185425,
0.021636607125401497,
0.08709947019815445,
-0.18428555130958557,
-0.5199903845787048,
-0.0626748576760292,
-1.0424073934555054,
-0.18821077048778534,
0.5162850618362427,
0.5160220861434937,
0.03659462556242943,
0.49756792187690735,
0.09256680309772491,
0.6545282006263733,
-0.3760424852371216,
-0.5320559144020081,
0.208258256316185,
0.05981386825442314,
-0.32104888558387756,
0.02615613117814064,
0.49831855297088623,
0.6056578159332275,
-0.16665932536125183,
-0.1457500159740448,
-0.3270396292209625,
0.07298748195171356,
-0.01379281934350729,
-0.6873800158500671,
0.0679507851600647,
0.24235911667346954,
-0.498979389667511,
-0.41431206464767456,
-0.1806265115737915,
-0.5406484603881836,
-0.2567380666732788,
-0.18607619404792786,
0.4020899832248688,
-0.0611015185713768,
-0.370048850774765,
0.3342873454093933,
0.011198095977306366,
0.08797252923250198,
0.4397483468055725,
-0.8151439428329468,
0.4309505820274353,
0.6299124956130981,
0.9136845469474792,
-0.5183120369911194,
0.21245448291301727,
-0.5824165344238281,
0.1779753714799881,
-0.08855592459440231,
0.7042213678359985,
-0.3485665023326874,
-0.365675687789917,
-0.03239656984806061,
-0.3869148790836334,
0.32755789160728455,
-0.6934120059013367,
0.8113468885421753,
-0.4328075647354126,
-0.20431602001190186,
-0.03815896436572075,
-0.5218514800071716,
-0.176469087600708,
0.29398760199546814,
-0.8905573487281799,
1.2535954713821411,
0.3052188456058502,
-0.5409422516822815,
0.1687520444393158,
-0.319845587015152,
-0.4385469853878021,
0.36531826853752136,
0.04622572287917137,
-0.7150856256484985,
0.4198625981807709,
0.10820577293634415,
0.7105984687805176,
-0.45408591628074646,
0.0721973329782486,
-0.5596343874931335,
-0.3770137131214142,
-0.30413973331451416,
-0.49865084886550903,
0.6273143887519836,
0.024320343509316444,
0.07034847885370255,
0.08788499236106873,
-0.8481923341751099,
0.11235369741916656,
0.1627117395401001,
-0.4613892734050751,
-0.47303712368011475,
-0.14076200127601624,
-0.023657478392124176,
0.36703091859817505,
0.25601425766944885,
-0.6744883060455322,
0.5447788238525391,
-0.4822937250137329,
0.32348668575286865,
1.08516526222229,
0.06744614243507385,
0.12353344261646271,
-0.17841240763664246,
0.7881720066070557,
-0.13325156271457672,
0.15453948080539703,
0.08693334460258484,
0.0490933321416378,
-0.8348839282989502,
-0.4191429316997528,
0.5851302742958069,
0.28029942512512207,
-0.47853416204452515,
0.556856095790863,
-0.6586140394210815,
-0.5586570501327515,
-0.619010865688324,
-0.1540663242340088,
0.10331074148416519,
0.5135923027992249,
0.3228425085544586,
-0.10228314995765686,
-0.5674008727073669,
-0.8139330744743347,
0.1436219960451126,
-0.12315424531698227,
0.008429461158812046,
0.2981938123703003,
0.2937951982021332,
-0.009663647040724754,
0.6910273432731628,
-0.7800906896591187,
-0.3346286416053772,
-0.2672128975391388,
-0.036167025566101074,
-0.016748761758208275,
0.5479678511619568,
0.2511935532093048,
-0.5642513036727905,
-0.19495798647403717,
-0.22297805547714233,
-0.1685878485441208,
-0.2530640959739685,
0.13738690316677094,
0.25115880370140076,
0.4215090870857239,
0.32927411794662476,
-0.5342754125595093,
0.33220943808555603,
0.8378034234046936,
-0.008127494715154171,
0.9560419321060181,
-0.38860589265823364,
0.015554914250969887,
-0.9278054237365723,
-0.10360106825828552,
0.018543370068073273,
-0.38969722390174866,
-0.7368873953819275,
-0.017654815688729286,
0.07394906878471375,
-0.17095765471458435,
-0.95899498462677,
0.32934749126434326,
-0.44699960947036743,
-0.4374828040599823,
-0.07822704315185547,
-0.028784142807126045,
-0.14936581254005432,
0.5452941656112671,
-0.10518025606870651,
0.5968906879425049,
0.33812519907951355,
-0.789371907711029,
0.5068395733833313,
0.09368672966957092,
-0.23808057606220245,
0.14236067235469818,
-0.5157731771469116,
0.16872188448905945,
-0.31657305359840393,
0.25816255807876587,
-0.8096902966499329,
0.26120373606681824,
-0.013560370542109013,
-0.057653266936540604,
0.2746695578098297,
-0.6026145219802856,
-0.7342981696128845,
-0.42107000946998596,
-0.6403067111968994,
0.6675200462341309,
0.6116913557052612,
-0.6227057576179504,
0.5914710164070129,
0.5607043504714966,
-0.4947511553764343,
-0.4170791804790497,
-0.5002362132072449,
0.16167809069156647,
-0.3505723774433136,
-0.7892839312553406,
0.6045281291007996,
-0.6431143283843994,
-0.08386349678039551,
-0.17650963366031647,
-0.35234689712524414,
0.07227147370576859,
0.08168746531009674,
0.23431475460529327,
0.5344296097755432,
-0.14960339665412903,
0.0733351781964302,
0.12377365678548813,
-0.14217650890350342,
-0.15425452589988708,
-0.34936389327049255,
0.7965933084487915,
-0.015529008582234383,
-0.3467869162559509,
-0.1141107827425003,
0.309527188539505,
0.8058045506477356,
-0.19392089545726776,
0.6211721301078796,
0.31373995542526245,
-0.5617188215255737,
-0.5247530341148376,
-0.67657071352005,
0.2557791471481323,
-0.45801180601119995,
0.15484768152236938,
-0.3846244513988495,
-1.1945253610610962,
0.5168225169181824,
-0.42645376920700073,
0.08811691403388977,
0.47254645824432373,
0.520473837852478,
0.015521259978413582,
0.9410322308540344,
0.8689298629760742,
0.10595109313726425,
0.1672646552324295,
-0.36283883452415466,
0.06498322635889053,
-0.8673731684684753,
-0.24840600788593292,
-0.7278263568878174,
-0.2147148847579956,
-0.42193105816841125,
-0.5755736827850342,
0.4238678514957428,
-0.0887598767876625,
0.10246361792087555,
0.10205541551113129,
-0.6937127709388733,
0.5490431189537048,
0.19919073581695557,
-0.11272944509983063,
0.26211845874786377,
-0.022423094138503075,
-0.02805967628955841,
-0.14678719639778137,
-0.5701804757118225,
-0.3075645864009857,
0.8402690887451172,
0.3940393328666687,
0.8603555560112,
0.2076830416917801,
0.5520156025886536,
0.3502765893936157,
-0.04989170283079147,
-0.9804396033287048,
0.734731912612915,
-0.45347246527671814,
0.08562608808279037,
-0.3381243944168091,
-0.5150919556617737,
-0.5406520962715149,
0.3830149173736572,
-0.17137756943702698,
-0.5229506492614746,
0.032576046884059906,
0.055532727390527725,
-0.3706769645214081,
0.6352391242980957,
-0.5958133339881897,
0.48275938630104065,
-0.03326449170708656,
0.1272864192724228,
0.027413133531808853,
-0.38015982508659363,
0.4743848741054535,
-0.0034995730966329575,
0.048108525574207306,
-0.38885271549224854,
-0.1120440810918808,
0.937739908695221,
-0.792364239692688,
0.6818328499794006,
-0.30769112706184387,
-0.5548603534698486,
-0.24725928902626038,
0.17930388450622559,
0.7707527279853821,
-0.1905319094657898,
-0.10345768928527832,
0.30166956782341003,
0.01616271771490574,
-0.26344603300094604,
-0.7595633864402771,
0.9240925312042236,
-0.4003777503967285,
-0.6701266169548035,
-0.2669924795627594,
-0.5501159429550171,
-0.05521338805556297,
0.24611076712608337,
0.005806486587971449,
0.5822649002075195,
-0.03071923926472664,
0.22523942589759827,
0.7855917811393738,
-0.16168169677257538,
0.4361230731010437,
0.3543514609336853,
0.15733416378498077,
-0.38019344210624695,
0.8118325471878052,
0.2761984169483185,
0.4100837707519531,
0.2089756280183792,
0.08112636208534241,
-0.28728124499320984,
-1.189584732055664,
-0.2012331187725067,
0.3411298990249634,
-0.7506647109985352,
-0.5096891522407532,
-0.3530399799346924,
-0.3168964684009552,
-0.6313464641571045,
-0.21920007467269897,
-0.6314733624458313,
-0.6364009380340576,
-0.07084739953279495,
-0.1704360991716385,
0.20888899266719818,
0.7995790243148804,
0.13777083158493042,
0.02274986356496811,
-0.7093643546104431,
0.3108886480331421,
0.06572733074426651,
0.6034790873527527,
-0.14542989432811737,
-0.3252373933792114,
-0.18812432885169983,
-0.011697717942297459,
0.21317130327224731,
-0.5054461359977722,
0.6219765543937683,
-0.03181890770792961,
0.2735637128353119,
0.11521535366773605,
0.634778618812561,
0.8100831508636475,
-0.5155404210090637,
1.0239943265914917,
0.09639714658260345,
-0.896891713142395,
0.34267327189445496,
-0.06082984060049057,
0.3820823132991791,
0.15256811678409576,
-0.07418225705623627,
-0.7888387441635132,
-0.5658231973648071,
-0.5692697167396545,
-0.9898707866668701,
0.6120588779449463,
-0.10094179958105087,
0.1706572324037552,
0.2741495966911316,
0.5213845372200012,
0.32528156042099,
0.05356921628117561,
-0.7061935663223267,
-0.6028914451599121,
0.04066304489970207,
-0.28644993901252747,
0.15816491842269897,
-0.6239790320396423,
0.22506925463676453,
-0.22331728041172028,
0.7455911040306091,
-0.06756047159433365,
0.32057785987854004,
0.0018905886681750417,
-0.37828508019447327,
-0.07151371240615845,
0.46472615003585815,
0.9038589000701904,
0.4471612870693207,
-0.37240996956825256,
0.3409777581691742,
0.3456666171550751,
-0.5108602643013,
0.4481388032436371,
-0.08459341526031494,
-0.3968900144100189,
0.025414057075977325,
0.014710570685565472,
0.8989077210426331,
0.1494610756635666,
-0.7025186419487,
0.5987340211868286,
-0.2365218549966812,
-0.3515341877937317,
-0.3320651948451996,
0.08559620380401611,
-0.1080964058637619,
0.0028677701484411955,
0.4425158202648163,
0.12591738998889923,
-0.1395443230867386,
0.05288946256041527,
-0.05618661269545555,
0.3448467552661896,
-0.3418484628200531,
-0.3295784890651703,
0.5092841982841492,
0.08310818672180176,
-0.29592257738113403,
0.39300665259361267,
-0.06992635130882263,
-0.60289466381073,
0.3130668103694916,
0.5712217688560486,
0.7673945426940918,
-0.22631730139255524,
0.0880572721362114,
0.18742622435092926,
0.29775533080101013,
-0.036761268973350525,
0.2521267533302307,
-0.022274408489465714,
-0.5549996495246887,
-0.8315508961677551,
-0.5707701444625854,
-0.28774958848953247,
0.6765665411949158,
-0.6089653372764587,
0.5438359379768372,
-0.5264700651168823,
0.03550714999437332,
-0.25230300426483154,
0.11366710066795349,
-0.4008534848690033,
0.1486912965774536,
0.15388180315494537,
0.8383128046989441,
-0.586534321308136,
0.7246509790420532,
0.2223268300294876,
-0.1212746649980545,
-0.6525159478187561,
0.05906812846660614,
-0.02009361796081066,
-0.29146623611450195,
0.636682391166687,
-0.013695094734430313,
-0.3574122190475464,
0.22862012684345245,
-0.49831750988960266,
-0.9925060272216797,
1.030327320098877,
0.9036972522735596,
-0.391216516494751,
-0.045136671513319016,
0.05454815924167633,
0.25922691822052,
-0.2593625485897064,
-0.22862598299980164,
0.4492013454437256,
0.44910573959350586,
0.42418593168258667,
-0.7796181440353394,
0.18532773852348328,
-0.2486490160226822,
0.33201658725738525,
0.40195414423942566,
-0.5608530044555664,
0.6058423519134521,
-0.31235185265541077,
-0.4816122353076935,
-0.08456753194332123,
0.8253487944602966,
0.02714783325791359,
-0.4382880628108978,
0.7883685231208801,
0.6217443943023682,
0.8520088791847229,
0.05822833999991417,
0.6169626116752625,
-0.17255055904388428,
0.3990929424762726,
0.8698093295097351,
-0.25167903304100037,
0.9136144518852234,
0.3234346807003021,
0.0027852440252900124,
0.16918042302131653,
0.4919911026954651,
-0.11815625429153442,
0.4810425639152527,
0.39583057165145874,
-0.5731909275054932,
-0.20553277432918549,
-0.26252368092536926,
-0.2807106077671051,
0.2563362121582031,
0.24678348004817963,
0.15794110298156738,
-0.17473842203617096,
0.18230991065502167,
0.12161307036876678,
-0.1046457290649414,
-0.39777958393096924,
0.63602614402771,
-0.21132467687129974,
-0.2660714387893677,
1.1221195459365845,
0.3501966595649719,
0.8368838429450989,
-0.3000633716583252,
0.04576185718178749,
-0.010500196367502213,
-0.04157186672091484,
0.01705545373260975,
-0.48748940229415894,
0.22605696320533752,
0.01662355847656727,
-0.3147655129432678,
-0.5615513920783997,
0.830624520778656,
-0.7861789464950562,
-0.31038519740104675,
0.12779292464256287,
0.13468781113624573,
0.04074828699231148,
0.09800204634666443,
-0.3053975999355316,
0.5716445446014404,
-0.013277138583362103,
0.027322234585881233,
0.1771066039800644,
0.040782149881124496,
-0.032355379313230515,
0.9209535121917725,
0.8142296075820923,
0.6856359243392944,
0.01731841266155243,
0.25013798475265503,
0.9946659803390503,
-0.6869203448295593,
-0.553385317325592,
-0.6913949251174927,
0.447294145822525,
0.0997895896434784,
0.027530131861567497,
0.5597739815711975,
0.6423252820968628,
0.7368308305740356,
-0.053122710436582565,
0.8490914702415466,
0.31392157077789307,
0.5389528870582581,
-0.6365842223167419,
0.4953089952468872,
-0.4692392945289612,
0.47792893648147583,
-0.3233853876590729,
-0.8600942492485046,
-0.8488999009132385,
0.23726026713848114,
0.05141548439860344,
-0.15970510244369507,
0.5362350940704346,
0.7193993926048279,
0.12953762710094452,
-0.3992246985435486,
0.4800294041633606,
0.46576786041259766,
0.5245993137359619,
0.31617271900177,
0.5274337530136108,
-0.34344133734703064,
0.8253896832466125,
-0.18685874342918396,
0.018160421401262283,
-0.36196571588516235,
-1.0361261367797852,
-0.6590092182159424,
-0.7669380903244019,
-0.5396522879600525,
-0.20675475895404816,
-0.12294454127550125,
1.0291693210601807,
0.8260772228240967,
-0.43647223711013794,
0.06998402625322342,
0.31483420729637146,
0.3541682958602905,
-0.2776995897293091,
-0.13391809165477753,
0.6202330589294434,
0.021419022232294083,
-0.6737303733825684,
0.4431664049625397,
0.6956117153167725,
0.40736475586891174,
-0.5877109169960022,
-0.2288365662097931,
0.07756078243255615,
0.04834494739770889,
0.7928067445755005,
0.06347040832042694,
-0.6986645460128784,
-0.4704282879829407,
-0.2737492620944977,
-0.022329146042466164,
0.23664399981498718,
0.7270154356956482,
-0.7832509875297546,
0.3122670352458954,
0.5470021963119507,
0.5161696672439575,
0.7269381284713745,
-0.0744483545422554,
0.6467088460922241,
-1.2032870054244995,
0.15755918622016907,
0.3936083912849426,
0.2459752857685089,
0.3867768943309784,
-0.49867570400238037,
0.12862001359462738,
0.3084055185317993,
-0.24448645114898682,
-1.2148778438568115,
0.06645122170448303,
-1.181954264640808,
-0.18868495523929596,
1.336977481842041,
-0.04140513762831688,
-0.49733471870422363,
-0.00038049626164138317,
-0.15176106989383698,
0.19765900075435638,
-0.4193568229675293,
0.5325334668159485,
0.6760029196739197,
0.33601850271224976,
-0.5394080281257629,
-0.3404214382171631,
0.5084524750709534,
0.04950788617134094,
-0.7854292392730713,
0.4930068552494049,
0.6157044768333435,
0.22639328241348267,
-0.27407902479171753,
0.5205420851707458,
-0.15969333052635193,
0.15402810275554657,
-0.39597272872924805,
0.49927759170532227,
-0.5188294649124146,
-0.2807374894618988,
-0.5941665172576904,
0.3982180655002594,
-0.015538698062300682,
-0.1267436146736145
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07376v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07376v1
|
NavCoT: Boosting LLM-Based Vision-and-Language Navigation via Learning Disentangled Reasoning
| 2024-03-12T07:27:02 | 2024-03-12T07:27:02 |
Bingqian Lin, Yunshuang Nie, Ziming Wei, Jiaqi Chen, Shikui Ma, Jianhua Han, Hang Xu, Xiaojun Chang, Xiaodan Liang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.RO
|
Vision-and-Language Navigation (VLN), as a crucial research problem of
Embodied AI, requires an embodied agent to navigate through complex 3D
environments following natural language instructions. Recent research has
highlighted the promising capacity of large language models (LLMs) in VLN by
improving navigational reasoning accuracy and interpretability. However, their
predominant use in an offline manner usually suffers from substantial domain
gap between the VLN task and the LLM training corpus. This paper introduces a
novel strategy called Navigational Chain-of-Thought (NavCoT), where we fulfill
parameter-efficient in-domain training to enable self-guided navigational
decision, leading to a significant mitigation of the domain gap in a
cost-effective manner. Specifically, at each timestep, the LLM is prompted to
forecast the navigational chain-of-thought by: 1) acting as a world model to
imagine the next observation according to the instruction, 2) selecting the
candidate observation that best aligns with the imagination, and 3) determining
the action based on the reasoning from the prior steps. Through constructing
formalized labels for training, the LLM can learn to generate desired and
reasonable chain-of-thought outputs for improving the action decision.
Experimental results across various training settings and popular VLN
benchmarks (e.g., Room-to-Room (R2R), Room-across-Room (RxR), Room-for-Room
(R4R)) show the significant superiority of NavCoT over the direct action
prediction variants. Through simple parameter-efficient finetuning, our NavCoT
outperforms a recent GPT4-based approach with ~7% relative improvement on the
R2R dataset. We believe that NavCoT will help unlock more task-adaptive and
scalable LLM-based embodied agents, which are helpful for developing real-world
robotics applications. Code is available at
https://github.com/expectorlin/NavCoT.
|
[
-0.41778311133384705,
-0.7514768838882446,
0.6899809837341309,
-0.09365393221378326,
-0.37570664286613464,
0.2908186614513397,
0.0639290139079094,
-0.36374661326408386,
0.13402044773101807,
0.47153741121292114,
-0.6416271328926086,
-0.4441258907318115,
-0.39143672585487366,
-0.14381466805934906,
-0.1369977444410324,
0.45578810572624207,
0.07563155889511108,
-0.032720159739255905,
-0.26689884066581726,
0.03968314081430435,
-0.6092368364334106,
-0.5773648023605347,
-0.34646689891815186,
-0.4666014611721039,
0.35177937150001526,
0.16359511017799377,
0.6785645484924316,
0.4243910610675812,
0.3721207082271576,
0.32256782054901123,
-0.018615441396832466,
0.719506025314331,
-0.3457401692867279,
0.15999625623226166,
-0.25047045946121216,
-0.4468994140625,
-0.6099215149879456,
-0.41094329953193665,
0.32934772968292236,
0.4266204535961151,
-0.3299486041069031,
-0.26102936267852783,
0.016947027295827866,
0.9964616298675537,
-0.679988443851471,
0.2651402950286865,
-0.4791770279407501,
0.14725789427757263,
0.0994412899017334,
-0.33854836225509644,
-0.2719050645828247,
-0.02122790738940239,
0.31380924582481384,
-0.7639981508255005,
-0.14129766821861267,
0.19585226476192474,
0.4657427668571472,
0.7275891900062561,
-0.40917956829071045,
-0.2335914969444275,
-0.5329489707946777,
0.5914298295974731,
-0.5527970194816589,
0.6091606616973877,
0.21051549911499023,
0.29843688011169434,
-0.3569963276386261,
-0.6583361029624939,
-0.6108388304710388,
-0.19202518463134766,
0.2530003488063812,
0.48639941215515137,
-0.19664008915424347,
0.2519747018814087,
0.18804529309272766,
0.26581916213035583,
-0.7053165435791016,
-0.037880584597587585,
-0.21418078243732452,
0.08948666602373123,
0.561387836933136,
0.05699675530195236,
0.15821057558059692,
0.09559972584247589,
-0.721217155456543,
-0.20672263205051422,
-0.7068440914154053,
-0.26820477843284607,
-0.045123886317014694,
0.20158874988555908,
-0.08452179282903671,
0.30854976177215576,
-0.3743271827697754,
0.9499848484992981,
0.21780925989151,
-0.03644070401787758,
0.18605579435825348,
-0.10985955595970154,
-0.16335847973823547,
0.29346659779548645,
0.4548022747039795,
0.5652486681938171,
0.31131240725517273,
-0.08566310256719589,
-0.191672220826149,
0.00006277659849729389,
0.45590701699256897,
-0.5731841921806335,
-0.3056705594062805,
0.008363927714526653,
-0.023156704381108284,
-0.04835588485002518,
-0.17580217123031616,
-0.7142494320869446,
-0.48102641105651855,
-0.45541951060295105,
0.3684133291244507,
-0.2693321406841278,
-0.35213932394981384,
0.5706296563148499,
0.12517049908638,
0.514554500579834,
0.645872175693512,
-0.7465272545814514,
0.1707650125026703,
0.509806215763092,
0.9297025203704834,
-0.28994619846343994,
-0.08126068115234375,
-0.4579754173755646,
0.010083550587296486,
-0.41873499751091003,
0.7119855284690857,
-0.3730336129665375,
-0.297983855009079,
-0.047884706407785416,
-0.30788034200668335,
0.02931046113371849,
-0.2425333857536316,
0.13767804205417633,
-0.5896981954574585,
-0.06354176253080368,
-0.1841757446527481,
-0.504059910774231,
-0.38055720925331116,
0.611441433429718,
-0.6701710820198059,
0.7501691579818726,
-0.14909422397613525,
-0.4859521985054016,
0.20534445345401764,
-0.5460475087165833,
-0.36826545000076294,
0.265724241733551,
-0.3572885990142822,
-0.20769189298152924,
-0.011863435618579388,
0.5302234888076782,
0.5164392590522766,
-0.2668387293815613,
0.18948400020599365,
-0.03592591732740402,
-0.41717761754989624,
0.009417463093996048,
-0.5425600409507751,
0.5101792812347412,
0.027174171060323715,
-0.6357108354568481,
-0.13667833805084229,
-0.5412545204162598,
0.0879911258816719,
0.08714126795530319,
-0.2510417103767395,
-0.5149806141853333,
0.0892975702881813,
-0.4393383264541626,
0.34666892886161804,
0.17824701964855194,
-0.2141256034374237,
0.5886704921722412,
-0.7872738242149353,
0.20871713757514954,
0.7630537152290344,
0.15757958590984344,
0.5832542181015015,
-0.09816061705350876,
0.6046943068504333,
-0.10101563483476639,
0.2769745886325836,
0.13216064870357513,
-0.6592274308204651,
-0.9211562275886536,
-0.1233985424041748,
-0.03520456701517105,
0.3575081527233124,
-1.558044195175171,
0.18590450286865234,
-0.23613879084587097,
-0.38606297969818115,
-0.35287630558013916,
-0.042878177016973495,
0.5531136393547058,
0.3343934714794159,
0.5273594856262207,
-0.16589130461215973,
-0.40467730164527893,
-0.3370840847492218,
0.06734854727983475,
-0.3265411853790283,
0.24734294414520264,
0.06032329425215721,
0.5744146704673767,
-0.3092039227485657,
0.751613199710846,
-0.5634444952011108,
-0.18941347301006317,
-0.36447620391845703,
-0.020405374467372894,
0.10300633311271667,
0.2986775040626526,
0.1364136040210724,
-1.0339457988739014,
-0.3163595199584961,
0.1330489069223404,
-0.7647107839584351,
0.2431279867887497,
-0.3712167739868164,
-0.4161052107810974,
0.1308714747428894,
0.5310736894607544,
-0.4276697635650635,
0.6966904401779175,
0.4286939799785614,
-0.20527048408985138,
0.2144276201725006,
-0.38550373911857605,
-0.03508886322379112,
-0.8625692129135132,
-0.3859213888645172,
-0.11265572905540466,
-0.24980497360229492,
-0.6313962936401367,
0.1380579173564911,
-0.00490950420498848,
0.34836480021476746,
-0.6828803420066833,
0.68165123462677,
-0.7601732611656189,
0.038513682782649994,
-0.5075332522392273,
0.4645252227783203,
-0.00981121975928545,
1.0085769891738892,
0.3233213722705841,
0.5539254546165466,
0.7220519185066223,
-0.8889328837394714,
0.4758506119251251,
0.43065816164016724,
-0.3147573471069336,
0.5041090250015259,
-0.4334399700164795,
0.300380676984787,
-0.013916151598095894,
0.26149243116378784,
-0.750358521938324,
0.1427920013666153,
0.2995234429836273,
-0.43381932377815247,
0.2940205931663513,
-0.16105473041534424,
-0.44256383180618286,
-0.3084081709384918,
-0.07010280340909958,
0.46804288029670715,
0.48601818084716797,
-0.8891116380691528,
0.8457730412483215,
0.36896228790283203,
0.24550646543502808,
-0.6320710778236389,
-0.7935032844543457,
0.12604981660842896,
-0.12123092263936996,
-0.29122892022132874,
0.2609665095806122,
-0.1737082153558731,
-0.06494006514549255,
-0.3164786696434021,
-0.4427419900894165,
0.13084229826927185,
0.10308146476745605,
0.3855597972869873,
0.5248585343360901,
0.0762413889169693,
0.3096468448638916,
0.09059753268957138,
-0.16854387521743774,
0.09593220800161362,
-0.6655827760696411,
0.4598391354084015,
-0.6191073060035706,
-0.6673506498336792,
-0.03683760017156601,
-0.09755507856607437,
0.4209997057914734,
-0.2943112552165985,
0.27394533157348633,
0.3053755760192871,
-0.1505526304244995,
-0.46404924988746643,
-0.34727251529693604,
-0.12300162017345428,
-0.5213537216186523,
0.37912169098854065,
-0.2408573180437088,
-0.8609157800674438,
0.04172545298933983,
-0.4599621295928955,
0.04469970986247063,
-0.04562458395957947,
0.7201295495033264,
-0.08485278487205505,
0.7617112994194031,
0.4589717388153076,
0.09114310890436172,
0.3870115876197815,
-0.6501755118370056,
0.312273234128952,
-1.0260744094848633,
-0.42291197180747986,
0.2468591183423996,
-0.33355778455734253,
-0.6767315864562988,
-1.1088484525680542,
0.5574909448623657,
-0.07827546447515488,
-0.0868782103061676,
0.23673462867736816,
-0.6790329813957214,
0.5402933359146118,
0.5563995242118835,
0.08794862031936646,
0.30109673738479614,
-0.1046602800488472,
-0.43631434440612793,
0.29748374223709106,
-0.962439239025116,
-0.26709380745887756,
0.9241297841072083,
0.025313830003142357,
0.9174714088439941,
0.10775960981845856,
0.7248530387878418,
0.25197046995162964,
-0.07792701572179794,
-0.8474262952804565,
0.7911994457244873,
0.36796507239341736,
-0.506644606590271,
-0.2828809916973114,
-0.14089329540729523,
-0.8658449649810791,
0.623072624206543,
-0.15688879787921906,
-0.5515967011451721,
0.32216593623161316,
0.2367289960384369,
-0.32432249188423157,
0.4358268082141876,
-0.33345258235931396,
0.45125091075897217,
-0.705086350440979,
-0.6726294755935669,
-0.1417713761329651,
-0.870227038860321,
0.10278575122356415,
0.09835559874773026,
-0.05732278525829315,
0.13879069685935974,
-0.10750439763069153,
0.3776618540287018,
-0.3716879189014435,
0.823675811290741,
-0.17568790912628174,
-0.1815962940454483,
0.5822108387947083,
0.07076001912355423,
0.44905737042427063,
-0.02880667708814144,
0.21586042642593384,
0.35352623462677,
-0.4587820768356323,
-0.11554380506277084,
-0.7775704264640808,
0.6111781597137451,
-0.47316795587539673,
-0.5680830478668213,
-0.7172339558601379,
-0.30455949902534485,
-0.45304542779922485,
0.031171569600701332,
0.09140807390213013,
0.5640250444412231,
-0.08963695913553238,
0.11236598342657089,
0.9023354053497314,
-0.2396606057882309,
0.4007028341293335,
0.42201313376426697,
-0.2892857491970062,
-0.2892158627510071,
0.9244293570518494,
-0.19307081401348114,
0.37959733605384827,
0.839134931564331,
0.11520781368017197,
-0.6059839129447937,
-0.4468384087085724,
-0.5436149835586548,
0.09115176647901535,
-0.7501307129859924,
-0.3670732378959656,
-0.4123850166797638,
-0.2454155832529068,
0.15474100410938263,
-0.3459431231021881,
-0.55048006772995,
-0.2847267985343933,
0.01850019209086895,
-0.3080253303050995,
0.2701997756958008,
0.5737776756286621,
-0.15908198058605194,
0.126136913895607,
-0.37287425994873047,
0.3897409439086914,
0.5294044017791748,
0.13564859330654144,
0.27755171060562134,
-0.3753502368927002,
-0.3260408639907837,
0.23367559909820557,
-0.39864248037338257,
-0.5378109216690063,
0.3498419523239136,
-0.04146013408899307,
0.6100777983665466,
0.27251842617988586,
0.24000991880893707,
0.9290739297866821,
-0.4822331368923187,
0.5939522385597229,
0.45653608441352844,
-0.7502373456954956,
0.6739422082901001,
-0.15750783681869507,
0.6057611107826233,
0.3691054880619049,
0.23644903302192688,
-0.2645740211009979,
-0.4235091805458069,
-0.46195805072784424,
-0.9357168078422546,
0.38586464524269104,
0.4705726206302643,
-0.23385314643383026,
-0.055508941411972046,
0.25319787859916687,
-0.06438948214054108,
0.2190876603126526,
-0.6714133620262146,
-0.23655645549297333,
-0.23111587762832642,
0.07011204957962036,
0.10807202011346817,
0.06069714203476906,
0.2764851152896881,
-0.41783061623573303,
0.6278690695762634,
-0.32205528020858765,
0.3826843798160553,
0.44267919659614563,
-0.18984408676624298,
0.23057235777378082,
0.029750751331448555,
0.5675005316734314,
0.5877435803413391,
-0.13324293494224548,
0.11857972294092178,
0.2934727370738983,
-0.480501651763916,
0.2513515055179596,
-0.35651639103889465,
0.11278338730335236,
-0.03243665769696236,
0.3568083643913269,
0.9092318415641785,
0.2179107964038849,
-0.7733674645423889,
0.5867332816123962,
-0.20734353363513947,
-0.40271198749542236,
-0.26067686080932617,
0.15961743891239166,
0.13951422274112701,
0.6317726373672485,
0.0728742852807045,
0.1717601865530014,
0.29503390192985535,
-0.2881978452205658,
0.11759704351425171,
0.20573098957538605,
-0.449616014957428,
-0.12969055771827698,
0.6082510352134705,
0.3750545382499695,
-0.13003547489643097,
0.6778721809387207,
-0.2807413637638092,
-0.6100793480873108,
0.3829543888568878,
0.22028270363807678,
0.9612390398979187,
-0.21390168368816376,
0.12219824641942978,
0.4055601954460144,
0.3325257897377014,
-0.2817833423614502,
0.19013148546218872,
-0.44907960295677185,
-0.6246000528335571,
-0.3994288146495819,
-0.6050386428833008,
-0.4243805706501007,
-0.1707548201084137,
-0.68013596534729,
0.007761884015053511,
-0.2871333658695221,
-0.10193193703889847,
-0.605412483215332,
-0.0895863026380539,
-0.6883958578109741,
0.24369047582149506,
0.5963695645332336,
0.6076216697692871,
-0.34940293431282043,
1.0348328351974487,
0.5361170172691345,
-0.2549205720424652,
-0.6261863112449646,
0.1856798380613327,
0.05513034760951996,
-0.8998368978500366,
0.5920801162719727,
0.15729054808616638,
-0.8725581765174866,
-0.05045638978481293,
-0.40571945905685425,
-0.8627665042877197,
1.2782398462295532,
0.20737119019031525,
-1.0183382034301758,
-0.22605428099632263,
-0.023423919454216957,
0.5344311594963074,
-0.26370611786842346,
-0.010316242463886738,
0.4089956283569336,
0.30435192584991455,
0.5017830729484558,
-0.6711783409118652,
0.03570900484919548,
-0.24059022963047028,
0.1794418841600418,
0.3122064173221588,
-0.5718408226966858,
0.5053212642669678,
-0.443993479013443,
-0.10832495987415314,
-0.027592772617936134,
0.648445725440979,
0.42501300573349,
0.29292523860931396,
0.5608291029930115,
0.3421894609928131,
0.8251110911369324,
0.0072145420126616955,
0.9902974963188171,
-0.052372388541698456,
0.2699401378631592,
1.2943389415740967,
-0.328235924243927,
0.9049506783485413,
0.6027076840400696,
0.13832888007164001,
0.5490975975990295,
0.3245696425437927,
0.1965658813714981,
1.0108991861343384,
0.38731762766838074,
-0.0765385627746582,
-0.5123187899589539,
0.3513793349266052,
-0.303710013628006,
0.6692196726799011,
0.4459671378135681,
0.17106612026691437,
-0.13021647930145264,
0.3297138810157776,
-0.22060300409793854,
-0.01757826656103134,
-0.4334982633590698,
0.8333578705787659,
0.2850345969200134,
-0.6569582223892212,
0.8383946418762207,
-0.4503016173839569,
0.5867382287979126,
-0.5191691517829895,
-0.4052504301071167,
-0.13621370494365692,
0.3280086815357208,
0.1074642464518547,
-0.6972866654396057,
-0.07904937863349915,
-0.015419213101267815,
0.2897343337535858,
-0.38810744881629944,
0.6489235758781433,
-0.3772859275341034,
-0.3161305785179138,
0.44215619564056396,
0.670872688293457,
0.10171901434659958,
-0.1808621734380722,
-0.8226850032806396,
0.005226012319326401,
0.08825396746397018,
-0.2111131101846695,
0.21953390538692474,
0.48416978120803833,
-0.02582729421555996,
1.034075379371643,
0.3856493830680847,
-0.016392771154642105,
0.03086743876338005,
0.03742770105600357,
1.03043794631958,
-0.6626403331756592,
-0.6727277636528015,
-0.8981048464775085,
0.6217758059501648,
-0.09716462343931198,
-0.1508014053106308,
0.625960648059845,
0.35260552167892456,
0.9154177904129028,
0.05444299802184105,
0.5599743127822876,
0.15413251519203186,
0.029214994981884956,
-0.9051131010055542,
0.5429573655128479,
-0.7842410206794739,
0.31693145632743835,
-0.31107592582702637,
-0.6470755338668823,
-0.19025646150112152,
0.9645200371742249,
-0.39315006136894226,
0.12607920169830322,
0.811479389667511,
0.7581396698951721,
0.08627646416425705,
-0.19437092542648315,
0.6409333944320679,
0.15013359487056732,
0.3608003258705139,
0.897231936454773,
1.0494252443313599,
-0.4012084901332855,
0.337329238653183,
0.0027380473911762238,
-0.0832671970129013,
-0.45000502467155457,
-0.7797093391418457,
-0.9710686206817627,
-0.7347438931465149,
-0.48337432742118835,
0.0001155352292698808,
0.2929822504520416,
0.8326575756072998,
0.8226326107978821,
-0.21442624926567078,
-0.29449349641799927,
-0.48409172892570496,
0.11598493903875351,
-0.49173659086227417,
-0.10384669154882431,
0.18846926093101501,
-0.04307202994823456,
-0.5604079365730286,
0.5999501347541809,
0.6316691637039185,
-0.03085675649344921,
-0.28172653913497925,
-0.5544030666351318,
-0.47430384159088135,
0.09452447295188904,
0.7109444737434387,
0.08348050713539124,
-0.972960889339447,
-0.03748004510998726,
-0.1423524171113968,
0.04652104899287224,
0.08765412867069244,
0.4022402763366699,
-0.9958481788635254,
0.9939160346984863,
0.1376970261335373,
0.6918745040893555,
0.7667670249938965,
0.003696863539516926,
0.5496735572814941,
-0.587217390537262,
0.12914100289344788,
0.4219677448272705,
0.3237556517124176,
0.2534950375556946,
-0.2721823751926422,
0.6196491122245789,
-0.06362950056791306,
-0.44716984033584595,
-0.45403483510017395,
0.1709737777709961,
-1.257369041442871,
-0.3800993859767914,
1.2075749635696411,
0.002667734632268548,
-0.5256305932998657,
-0.14120979607105255,
-0.4145106375217438,
0.15737901628017426,
-0.30119916796684265,
0.6193305253982544,
0.3458832800388336,
-0.213726207613945,
-0.11383063346147537,
-0.6222608685493469,
0.45656877756118774,
0.1289948672056198,
-0.8105336427688599,
0.011777439154684544,
0.46002528071403503,
-0.16096729040145874,
0.08131808042526245,
0.5607556104660034,
0.17706185579299927,
0.47449180483818054,
0.02874036692082882,
0.21416880190372467,
-0.27876195311546326,
-0.5447930693626404,
-0.209156334400177,
-0.25472578406333923,
-0.0894128680229187,
-0.5236819982528687
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09718v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09718v1
|
Comprehensive Implementation of TextCNN for Enhanced Collaboration between Natural Language Processing and System Recommendation
| 2024-03-12T07:25:53 | 2024-03-12T07:25:53 |
Xiaonan Xu, Zheng Xu, Zhipeng Ling, Zhengyu Jin, ShuQian Du
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Natural Language Processing (NLP) is an important branch of artificial
intelligence that studies how to enable computers to understand, process, and
generate human language. Text classification is a fundamental task in NLP,
which aims to classify text into different predefined categories. Text
classification is the most basic and classic task in natural language
processing, and most of the tasks in natural language processing can be
regarded as classification tasks. In recent years, deep learning has achieved
great success in many research fields, and today, it has also become a standard
technology in the field of NLP, which is widely integrated into text
classification tasks. Unlike numbers and images, text processing emphasizes
fine-grained processing ability. Traditional text classification methods
generally require preprocessing the input model's text data. Additionally, they
also need to obtain good sample features through manual annotation and then use
classical machine learning algorithms for classification. Therefore, this paper
analyzes the application status of deep learning in the three core tasks of NLP
(including text representation, word order modeling, and knowledge
representation). This content explores the improvement and synergy achieved
through natural language processing in the context of text classification,
while also taking into account the challenges posed by adversarial techniques
in text generation, text classification, and semantic parsing. An empirical
study on text classification tasks demonstrates the effectiveness of
interactive integration training, particularly in conjunction with TextCNN,
highlighting the significance of these advancements in text classification
augmentation and enhancement.
|
[
-0.4372519850730896,
-0.8322049379348755,
0.34431472420692444,
0.22552838921546936,
-0.08402275294065475,
0.2891301214694977,
-0.5338552594184875,
-0.858989417552948,
-0.07372315227985382,
0.6705514788627625,
-0.2513880729675293,
-0.6626375913619995,
-0.578866183757782,
0.30160579085350037,
-0.4716346859931946,
0.9558635950088501,
-0.0661996603012085,
0.05296121910214424,
-0.19575096666812897,
-0.08710288256406784,
-0.6250500082969666,
-0.7129223942756653,
-0.7192422747612,
-0.6069045662879944,
0.25813475251197815,
0.28124651312828064,
0.6861376166343689,
0.29810017347335815,
0.8274127244949341,
0.45323166251182556,
-0.18997661769390106,
0.43853577971458435,
0.03270966187119484,
0.446333646774292,
-0.11701742559671402,
-0.35774868726730347,
-0.3554844558238983,
0.0021908641792833805,
0.4375711977481842,
0.7172861099243164,
-0.0859314352273941,
-0.2720520496368408,
0.4666811525821686,
0.6181604266166687,
-0.5913292765617371,
0.025374537333846092,
-0.40365496277809143,
0.28088730573654175,
-0.0935145914554596,
-0.32096225023269653,
-0.24246779084205627,
-0.26440486311912537,
0.455789178609848,
-0.4098866581916809,
0.07770644873380661,
-0.06283005326986313,
0.44208890199661255,
0.28565531969070435,
-0.3798968195915222,
-0.7595275640487671,
-0.7680615186691284,
0.873177170753479,
-0.7744772434234619,
0.2210635244846344,
0.31586021184921265,
0.22119835019111633,
-0.2052415907382965,
-0.7835362553596497,
-0.6271528005599976,
-0.07189830392599106,
-0.12876980006694794,
0.07729233801364899,
-0.08529285341501236,
0.4608920216560364,
0.030667494982481003,
0.5954042673110962,
-0.5329475998878479,
0.3064464032649994,
-0.0005904018762521446,
-0.10692964494228363,
0.5998477935791016,
0.15677928924560547,
0.589539110660553,
-0.23009471595287323,
-0.20728251338005066,
-0.04939793050289154,
0.1672089397907257,
-0.03808618709445,
0.07199430465698242,
0.41192513704299927,
0.049362000077962875,
0.5097090005874634,
-0.429642915725708,
0.8233043551445007,
-0.264293372631073,
0.04628249257802963,
0.2283814698457718,
-0.5386059880256653,
-0.5053364634513855,
0.4485301971435547,
1.021784782409668,
0.09458304941654205,
0.110734723508358,
-0.17372040450572968,
0.05006992816925049,
-0.0027265504468232393,
0.3687174320220947,
-0.4898802638053894,
-0.09128279983997345,
-0.012365099042654037,
-0.3478934168815613,
-0.48356589674949646,
0.14521566033363342,
-0.43078359961509705,
-0.41132792830467224,
-0.7927115559577942,
0.031075086444616318,
-0.5251578688621521,
-0.16409485042095184,
0.24352650344371796,
0.09713264554738998,
0.15453390777111053,
0.4781704843044281,
-0.9673062562942505,
0.6731683015823364,
0.9665042757987976,
0.9566462635993958,
-0.5449079275131226,
-0.10966606438159943,
-0.25677722692489624,
-0.11760072410106659,
0.004795682150870562,
0.7821999788284302,
-0.3998267948627472,
0.11229033768177032,
0.07841106504201889,
-0.23068568110466003,
-0.1205080896615982,
-0.4082490801811218,
0.8710908889770508,
-0.5766105651855469,
0.24095579981803894,
0.26264968514442444,
-0.6432092189788818,
-0.38722631335258484,
0.6576516032218933,
-0.7172003984451294,
1.0102401971817017,
-0.3105565905570984,
-1.1119719743728638,
0.2848416566848755,
-0.6719908714294434,
-0.613019585609436,
0.3215181231498718,
-0.0050059035420417786,
-0.2589700222015381,
-0.13094155490398407,
0.3539430499076843,
0.7922214269638062,
-0.29537633061408997,
0.5114865303039551,
-0.014941553585231304,
-0.42446017265319824,
0.11970958858728409,
-0.41097408533096313,
0.8442691564559937,
0.14079484343528748,
-0.612394392490387,
0.05646378546953201,
-0.743638813495636,
0.14665587246418,
-0.37105613946914673,
-0.5205314755439758,
-0.5253304243087769,
-0.19484460353851318,
0.3950992524623871,
0.030360156670212746,
0.2702249586582184,
-0.19445392489433289,
0.22377920150756836,
-0.8172999620437622,
0.2609238028526306,
0.27560535073280334,
-0.08087841421365738,
0.8520693778991699,
0.17576870322227478,
0.24609076976776123,
-0.2986562252044678,
0.004327127244323492,
-0.16659331321716309,
-0.5006164908409119,
-0.9569659233093262,
0.15344765782356262,
0.4507652223110199,
1.0440384149551392,
-0.981012225151062,
0.8883398175239563,
-0.019187863916158676,
-0.2698889374732971,
-0.25722941756248474,
0.3157775104045868,
0.1811215579509735,
0.3040317893028259,
0.4615916609764099,
-0.11599592864513397,
-0.7901735305786133,
-0.6675243973731995,
-0.2544674575328827,
-0.12751634418964386,
0.024325888603925705,
-0.15240271389484406,
0.2276497781276703,
-0.4821390211582184,
0.809146523475647,
-0.2578980326652527,
-0.5080125331878662,
-0.5497397184371948,
0.48769110441207886,
0.24580368399620056,
0.5560017824172974,
0.1578586995601654,
-1.0433400869369507,
-0.5194603204727173,
0.40998202562332153,
-0.8766646385192871,
-0.03648049384355545,
0.07928748428821564,
-0.03849699720740318,
0.31161609292030334,
0.5039983987808228,
-0.1545979231595993,
0.5078703165054321,
0.5287662744522095,
-0.011560763232409954,
0.37844333052635193,
-0.17903026938438416,
0.12713511288166046,
-1.1106330156326294,
-0.03378752991557121,
-0.04271790385246277,
-0.32902517914772034,
-0.8271867632865906,
0.003925889730453491,
-0.18447506427764893,
-0.03485787659883499,
-0.056208621710538864,
0.28441303968429565,
-0.21686196327209473,
0.2587462067604065,
-0.6499603986740112,
0.12598666548728943,
0.01476295292377472,
0.22553066909313202,
0.28270775079727173,
0.4034290313720703,
0.45116734504699707,
-0.8438994288444519,
0.6080812215805054,
0.17096292972564697,
-0.1910020411014557,
0.5001486539840698,
-0.3573966920375824,
0.11212674528360367,
0.23325395584106445,
-0.021005237475037575,
-0.5739613771438599,
-0.023987766355276108,
0.23631849884986877,
-0.3947732448577881,
0.36592897772789,
0.4544907510280609,
-0.6547195315361023,
-0.24556155502796173,
-0.08938072621822357,
0.2351352423429489,
0.046538881957530975,
-0.4510332942008972,
0.5802409052848816,
0.2771323025226593,
-0.03356804698705673,
-0.6041286587715149,
-0.9953656196594238,
0.5012774467468262,
0.2281663864850998,
-0.46389541029930115,
0.520912766456604,
0.11579374969005585,
-0.2244170904159546,
0.09280485659837723,
0.11852812767028809,
-0.33449074625968933,
0.04457688331604004,
0.16299626231193542,
0.09205454587936401,
-0.08964662998914719,
0.3087807297706604,
0.03520955890417099,
-0.27531033754348755,
-0.17573200166225433,
-0.40653878450393677,
0.39782387018203735,
-0.21968543529510498,
-0.14521543681621552,
-0.6818228960037231,
0.3750453293323517,
0.14588768780231476,
-0.15415403246879578,
0.6209686398506165,
1.0176728963851929,
-0.49879035353660583,
-0.25017377734184265,
-0.6149276494979858,
0.00008432846516370773,
-0.41782253980636597,
0.2468506395816803,
0.0490996316075325,
-1.093518614768982,
0.04190715774893761,
-0.04644482210278511,
0.057884953916072845,
0.3982014060020447,
0.278825044631958,
-0.14717347919940948,
0.9378751516342163,
0.9908794164657593,
-0.16677935421466827,
0.5045720934867859,
-0.25657570362091064,
0.2294437438249588,
-0.6606613397598267,
-0.29451078176498413,
-0.6565068960189819,
-0.21325306594371796,
-0.6999644041061401,
-0.23181791603565216,
-0.07547558844089508,
0.23677988350391388,
-0.05022963881492615,
0.5467065572738647,
-0.8381675481796265,
0.31237369775772095,
0.6481181979179382,
0.2125067263841629,
0.4121018946170807,
0.19189570844173431,
-0.21631470322608948,
-0.20412364602088928,
-0.6550556421279907,
-0.4723277986049652,
0.5916396379470825,
0.27505236864089966,
0.4015704095363617,
-0.19720180332660675,
0.8427788019180298,
0.3990503251552582,
0.1078304871916771,
-1.0683302879333496,
0.5519604682922363,
-0.45675235986709595,
-0.1321249008178711,
-0.2615715563297272,
-0.4803644120693207,
-0.670375645160675,
-0.129665806889534,
-0.5946685075759888,
-0.6064199209213257,
-0.014846861362457275,
-0.11943044513463974,
-0.18052153289318085,
0.2464451789855957,
-0.6198316812515259,
0.7264240384101868,
-0.29983824491500854,
-0.12388412654399872,
-0.24301350116729736,
-0.5224869251251221,
0.3337916135787964,
0.1493789702653885,
0.08289090543985367,
0.277485728263855,
-0.037725068628787994,
0.8671712875366211,
-0.2194315642118454,
0.780905544757843,
0.10527064651250839,
0.11997590959072113,
0.2532176077365875,
-0.09282214939594269,
0.29946112632751465,
0.07836262881755829,
-0.27069759368896484,
0.08251035958528519,
-0.2671404778957367,
-0.06699920445680618,
-0.6804230809211731,
0.671517014503479,
-0.5753291249275208,
-0.18275335431098938,
-0.6011998653411865,
-0.3280268609523773,
-0.10073034465312958,
0.3860652446746826,
0.042065829038619995,
0.32468265295028687,
-0.24092765152454376,
0.37343716621398926,
0.811151385307312,
-0.2940801978111267,
0.7268202900886536,
0.033942509442567825,
-0.11642422527074814,
-0.7476922273635864,
0.6663510203361511,
-0.10860800743103027,
-0.03658408671617508,
0.9071776270866394,
0.16469156742095947,
-0.1022324338555336,
-0.8528439402580261,
-0.1535719633102417,
-0.15774784982204437,
-0.6665796041488647,
-0.30711978673934937,
-1.0134083032608032,
-0.5077782869338989,
-0.39069172739982605,
-0.284237802028656,
-0.03628947213292122,
-0.22241230309009552,
-0.5333852171897888,
0.06820343434810638,
0.23486605286598206,
0.8414705991744995,
0.28032106161117554,
0.37313660979270935,
-0.9042714834213257,
0.26943522691726685,
0.418801873922348,
0.35720348358154297,
0.14972952008247375,
-0.08423870801925659,
-0.3741886019706726,
-0.20252199470996857,
-0.26787540316581726,
-0.6250587701797485,
0.26832348108291626,
0.18705764412879944,
0.5109564065933228,
0.1901567280292511,
0.09729824960231781,
0.4464244842529297,
-0.31627392768859863,
0.7287786602973938,
0.3911917805671692,
-1.0522230863571167,
0.5743067264556885,
-0.05589570850133896,
0.676415205001831,
0.913689136505127,
0.20809869468212128,
-0.6605873703956604,
-0.33162474632263184,
-0.3863292336463928,
-0.8931435346603394,
0.7773821353912354,
0.5061861276626587,
-0.07686617225408554,
0.13222768902778625,
0.36940813064575195,
-0.07607729732990265,
0.27897992730140686,
-0.686333179473877,
-0.10676729679107666,
-0.0598125159740448,
-0.4602448344230652,
0.00848122127354145,
-0.13907280564308167,
0.3397202491760254,
-0.33981940150260925,
0.5606258511543274,
-0.26898902654647827,
0.04335790127515793,
0.3720113933086395,
-0.2059662789106369,
0.3718879222869873,
0.34027454257011414,
0.3689129650592804,
0.26636701822280884,
-0.013957560062408447,
0.10316336154937744,
0.3104051947593689,
-0.7172756195068359,
-0.13455407321453094,
0.15245142579078674,
-0.09777684509754181,
0.06167755648493767,
0.7937691807746887,
0.6517232656478882,
0.304202139377594,
-0.4117044508457184,
0.5021312236785889,
-0.3380323052406311,
-0.14500394463539124,
-0.34698429703712463,
0.14816097915172577,
-0.056672997772693634,
0.2775366008281708,
0.44777899980545044,
0.43533554673194885,
0.6800777912139893,
-0.3758389949798584,
0.29153499007225037,
0.3766852021217346,
-0.8778671026229858,
0.026025015860795975,
0.18159325420856476,
0.27683284878730774,
-0.4772292673587799,
0.5785185098648071,
-0.22482351958751678,
-0.8825328946113586,
0.5241823792457581,
0.3150933086872101,
1.1278518438339233,
-0.05995412543416023,
0.2956591546535492,
0.3554256558418274,
0.2869786322116852,
-0.17000716924667358,
0.005939355585724115,
-0.38514459133148193,
-0.6983771324157715,
-0.6855279207229614,
-0.8578689694404602,
-0.4309985637664795,
-0.06834026426076889,
-0.417783260345459,
0.4715239107608795,
-0.5578123331069946,
-0.06840525567531586,
-0.01898963376879692,
0.3154284656047821,
-0.6671506762504578,
0.2953525185585022,
0.3428739309310913,
0.8781808018684387,
-0.4940173029899597,
0.6760540008544922,
0.7653721570968628,
-0.07098373025655746,
-0.5472624897956848,
-0.018603604286909103,
-0.19810616970062256,
-0.18579967319965363,
0.7891255617141724,
0.5299817323684692,
-0.09768887609243393,
-0.12490241229534149,
-0.5061408281326294,
-0.3319067358970642,
0.9119108319282532,
-0.04964274913072586,
-0.5909910798072815,
-0.01806686446070671,
0.28050562739372253,
0.8668085932731628,
-0.3929668068885803,
0.23943623900413513,
0.4545772671699524,
0.49039191007614136,
0.04860112816095352,
-1.033232569694519,
0.045750368386507034,
-0.2777215838432312,
0.1474795937538147,
0.21958152949810028,
-0.08648127317428589,
0.3999471068382263,
0.27519917488098145,
-0.18055927753448486,
-0.06962602585554123,
0.7264641523361206,
0.01211596466600895,
0.4467594623565674,
0.5948891639709473,
0.5751394033432007,
0.6754719614982605,
-0.11825933307409286,
0.6507405042648315,
0.0645516887307167,
0.14512310922145844,
0.969577431678772,
-0.07692621648311615,
0.8366783857345581,
0.24832549691200256,
-0.05371041223406792,
0.6151528358459473,
0.38073498010635376,
0.0714348703622818,
0.23174786567687988,
0.021891765296459198,
-0.4010142683982849,
-0.06489624828100204,
-0.3850642144680023,
-0.14962029457092285,
0.4571080207824707,
0.37144798040390015,
-0.40819263458251953,
-0.16728518903255463,
0.34921494126319885,
-0.16634488105773926,
0.4251020550727844,
-0.3511902987957001,
1.2147377729415894,
0.21758334338665009,
-0.4529801309108734,
0.131730854511261,
-0.02655353769659996,
1.1961358785629272,
-0.4733963906764984,
-0.28845542669296265,
0.25361132621765137,
0.31121742725372314,
-0.48469552397727966,
-0.8571586608886719,
0.5244985222816467,
-0.08977151662111282,
-0.38147982954978943,
-0.3459191918373108,
1.145183801651001,
-0.3476901650428772,
-0.5006323456764221,
0.6411449313163757,
0.13388998806476593,
-0.1232178807258606,
-0.260736882686615,
-0.8778360486030579,
-0.054781846702098846,
-0.10971424728631973,
-0.14351268112659454,
0.15067961812019348,
0.544653058052063,
0.10922233760356903,
0.47802048921585083,
0.7134279012680054,
0.17817631363868713,
-0.08545279502868652,
0.24822601675987244,
0.7384007573127747,
-0.7572072744369507,
-0.6208195090293884,
-0.8777109980583191,
0.3409231901168823,
-0.45804089307785034,
-0.08841212093830109,
0.651898205280304,
0.43794775009155273,
0.7371205687522888,
0.2838323712348938,
0.7942311763763428,
-0.11695799976587296,
0.36368340253829956,
-0.6150934100151062,
0.6846808195114136,
-0.21070897579193115,
0.19724731147289276,
-0.4635247588157654,
-1.134913444519043,
-0.8766377568244934,
0.3764447867870331,
-0.23421382904052734,
-0.14907506108283997,
0.8748906850814819,
0.22515077888965607,
0.08898123353719711,
0.3872455060482025,
0.1576450616121292,
-0.3409586548805237,
0.24344941973686218,
0.39632973074913025,
0.5228961706161499,
-0.6112194061279297,
0.6567920446395874,
-0.58545982837677,
-0.25927257537841797,
-0.1729584038257599,
-0.9413673281669617,
-1.0713918209075928,
-0.5584511756896973,
-0.22683915495872498,
-0.09796775877475739,
0.02172684110701084,
0.9533211588859558,
0.6543891429901123,
-1.014977216720581,
-0.19703900814056396,
-0.6140097975730896,
0.25828051567077637,
-0.3796949088573456,
-0.3265688419342041,
0.3391008973121643,
-0.6454132795333862,
-0.8581546545028687,
0.25533369183540344,
0.5230535864830017,
0.002485930919647217,
-0.3494870662689209,
0.016288643702864647,
-0.6276217699050903,
-0.5103817582130432,
0.6997172236442566,
0.05781804397702217,
-0.44092339277267456,
0.17133426666259766,
0.09770077466964722,
-0.21210475265979767,
-0.14771421253681183,
0.9596196413040161,
-0.7684491276741028,
0.5779334306716919,
0.840554416179657,
1.2175614833831787,
0.30541032552719116,
-0.2415042370557785,
0.6795918941497803,
-0.6871596574783325,
0.12096508592367172,
0.48804816603660583,
0.018554087728261948,
0.5499417185783386,
-0.5374625325202942,
0.47893714904785156,
0.05817398428916931,
-0.7463638186454773,
-0.6279261708259583,
0.027269208803772926,
-0.9649521708488464,
-0.2988806366920471,
0.7941587567329407,
0.03336777165532112,
-0.2050459086894989,
-0.5972808599472046,
-0.40526944398880005,
0.4301411509513855,
-0.37810689210891724,
0.39606884121894836,
0.7429224252700806,
-0.1786748468875885,
-0.3247876763343811,
-0.6812818646430969,
0.5258313417434692,
0.2331266701221466,
-0.8313590288162231,
-0.2300739735364914,
0.05871506780385971,
-0.46475011110305786,
0.5362750887870789,
0.3270939588546753,
0.18142394721508026,
-0.09455251693725586,
-0.3637462258338928,
0.3140352964401245,
0.031015295535326004,
-0.250224769115448,
-0.4847772717475891,
0.32093924283981323,
-0.21089795231819153,
0.0011994577944278717
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09717v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09717v1
|
Enhancing Depression-Diagnosis-Oriented Chat with Psychological State Tracking
| 2024-03-12T07:17:01 | 2024-03-12T07:17:01 |
Yiyang Gu, Yougen Zhou, Qin Chen, Ningning Zhou, Jie Zhou, Aimin Zhou, Liang He
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Depression-diagnosis-oriented chat aims to guide patients in self-expression
to collect key symptoms for depression detection. Recent work focuses on
combining task-oriented dialogue and chitchat to simulate the interview-based
depression diagnosis. Whereas, these methods can not well capture the changing
information, feelings, or symptoms of the patient during dialogues. Moreover,
no explicit framework has been explored to guide the dialogue, which results in
some useless communications that affect the experience. In this paper, we
propose to integrate Psychological State Tracking (POST) within the large
language model (LLM) to explicitly guide depression-diagnosis-oriented chat.
Specifically, the state is adapted from a psychological theoretical model,
which consists of four components, namely Stage, Information, Summary and Next.
We fine-tune an LLM model to generate the dynamic psychological state, which is
further used to assist response generation at each turn to simulate the
psychiatrist. Experimental results on the existing benchmark show that our
proposed method boosts the performance of all subtasks in
depression-diagnosis-oriented chat.
|
[
-0.5444769263267517,
-0.9112580418586731,
0.9865993857383728,
0.5221720337867737,
-0.5024867057800293,
-0.12565743923187256,
-0.41816264390945435,
-0.47296181321144104,
0.7900543212890625,
0.21604953706264496,
-1.1261659860610962,
-0.5266983509063721,
-0.4714426100254059,
0.19038330018520355,
-0.29926589131355286,
1.0235991477966309,
0.11377592384815216,
0.08470692485570908,
0.06363881379365921,
0.5758396983146667,
-0.7566972374916077,
-0.5285569429397583,
-1.0216960906982422,
-0.20188163220882416,
0.31867095828056335,
0.24531684815883636,
0.5185306072235107,
0.043608106672763824,
0.4614512026309967,
0.22673587501049042,
-0.12091134488582611,
0.13690079748630524,
-0.7568152546882629,
0.4066329300403595,
-0.1386507898569107,
-0.7458003163337708,
-0.9223651885986328,
-0.28990650177001953,
0.3517795205116272,
0.5357875227928162,
-0.26191291213035583,
-0.10565517097711563,
0.45134827494621277,
0.019198093563318253,
-0.3814235031604767,
0.4001276195049286,
-0.13005124032497406,
0.10106461495161057,
0.03379382938146591,
-0.33759140968322754,
-0.1769101619720459,
-0.20750907063484192,
0.03474662825465202,
-0.33258846402168274,
0.08366739749908447,
-0.5290167927742004,
0.3884296417236328,
0.272808700799942,
-0.3446803390979767,
-0.14095917344093323,
-1.001010775566101,
0.5050471425056458,
-0.8931722640991211,
0.1438235193490982,
0.6970496773719788,
0.2831730842590332,
-0.2537660300731659,
-0.23787561058998108,
-0.30529025197029114,
-0.03985237330198288,
0.03662668541073799,
0.20517532527446747,
-0.2781457006931305,
0.20562653243541718,
0.2978833317756653,
0.4220161437988281,
-0.35778409242630005,
0.1515180617570877,
-0.02224053628742695,
-0.28111568093299866,
0.49358001351356506,
0.5133846998214722,
0.35513392090797424,
-0.22062185406684875,
-0.08739229291677475,
0.22859549522399902,
-0.1897624284029007,
-0.051094915717840195,
-0.028659792616963387,
0.33964329957962036,
-0.42968112230300903,
0.47362250089645386,
-0.3842763900756836,
0.5436445474624634,
0.38586968183517456,
-0.41829609870910645,
0.0570208765566349,
-0.4371233582496643,
-0.05993131548166275,
0.05338392034173012,
0.9309912323951721,
0.641011118888855,
-0.21499280631542206,
0.22448505461215973,
-0.08228377252817154,
0.4485511779785156,
0.3101072311401367,
-0.8970094919204712,
-0.6066576242446899,
0.5405017733573914,
-0.5197955369949341,
-0.1623314619064331,
-0.5965626835823059,
-0.8977637887001038,
-0.8622783422470093,
-0.2916356921195984,
0.3854861855506897,
-0.7762022018432617,
-0.6286258697509766,
0.10773445665836334,
0.16820001602172852,
-0.17760585248470306,
0.7268905639648438,
-0.6488791704177856,
0.3156958222389221,
0.7021357417106628,
0.8286004066467285,
0.03782447427511215,
0.17405812442302704,
-0.4644941985607147,
-0.20889215171337128,
-0.4561145007610321,
0.8747768402099609,
-0.5524819493293762,
-0.3417886197566986,
0.10171546041965485,
0.057100359350442886,
0.13108548521995544,
-0.24337394535541534,
0.32074594497680664,
0.194083571434021,
0.3808349072933197,
-0.2419217824935913,
-0.6799707412719727,
0.2203582227230072,
0.3745204508304596,
-0.3419116139411926,
0.8771858215332031,
0.19468915462493896,
-0.6704143285751343,
0.2133738249540329,
-0.5161609053611755,
-0.25640368461608887,
0.2727907598018646,
-0.13312193751335144,
-0.035056713968515396,
0.12760140001773834,
0.19460567831993103,
0.687139093875885,
-0.36750704050064087,
0.26483583450317383,
-0.43441441655158997,
-0.4464200437068939,
0.34135088324546814,
-0.06890591233968735,
0.3556661903858185,
0.101305291056633,
-0.12049154937267303,
-0.03353725001215935,
-0.6675917506217957,
-0.15830613672733307,
-0.3490470349788666,
-0.21866324543952942,
-0.3220013678073883,
0.3312737047672272,
-0.3687758147716522,
0.15183676779270172,
0.4157581031322479,
-0.7466269135475159,
0.14492042362689972,
-0.4363669753074646,
0.13177801668643951,
0.3923659026622772,
0.29215359687805176,
0.19087426364421844,
-0.05980449169874191,
0.9290289878845215,
0.1554235965013504,
0.48454561829566956,
-0.31528282165527344,
-0.5313783884048462,
-0.3744300305843353,
-0.8671895265579224,
0.09675578027963638,
0.7507163286209106,
-0.4613094627857208,
0.7283968329429626,
0.08345123380422592,
-0.5548632740974426,
-0.6088718771934509,
-0.08425252884626389,
0.2338285893201828,
0.4472578465938568,
0.33173757791519165,
-0.3898508548736572,
-0.5721126794815063,
-0.6756270527839661,
0.005305233411490917,
0.0050803194753825665,
-0.2994964122772217,
0.20151416957378387,
-0.12313212454319,
-0.346627801656723,
0.6511392593383789,
-0.7645484805107117,
-0.5072764158248901,
-0.5093608498573303,
0.16138184070587158,
0.28897348046302795,
0.34083133935928345,
0.40413665771484375,
-0.06761384755373001,
-0.4676288068294525,
-0.2725072205066681,
-0.7426390051841736,
-0.2383752167224884,
-0.09733868390321732,
-0.33279380202293396,
0.006197192240506411,
0.38256457448005676,
-0.6873645186424255,
0.6962138414382935,
0.5410133600234985,
-0.5775946378707886,
0.4121294617652893,
-0.06963921338319778,
0.42838266491889954,
-1.4365968704223633,
-0.21644021570682526,
0.16216011345386505,
-0.42231321334838867,
-0.5712141990661621,
-0.49004000425338745,
-0.1599024534225464,
-0.507163941860199,
-0.05019368603825569,
0.09380678087472916,
-0.2013426572084427,
0.2680286467075348,
-0.6764926910400391,
0.31028005480766296,
-0.3276560604572296,
0.293901652097702,
0.05837612971663475,
0.27909770607948303,
1.0025694370269775,
-0.4754692018032074,
0.44969436526298523,
0.1998448371887207,
-0.3070463538169861,
1.0563913583755493,
-0.24788430333137512,
-0.10429279506206512,
-0.09584622085094452,
0.7068997025489807,
-1.1773914098739624,
-0.027760356664657593,
0.3252629339694977,
-0.38382622599601746,
0.30485406517982483,
-0.03935398906469345,
-0.5107048749923706,
-0.1827002912759781,
-0.0966254472732544,
0.3508007526397705,
0.5440039038658142,
0.07912717759609222,
0.5470131039619446,
0.21588751673698425,
-0.5553978085517883,
-0.07256089150905609,
-0.5460849404335022,
0.3127986788749695,
-0.3309485614299774,
-0.3362364172935486,
0.4068987965583801,
-0.09650085121393204,
0.06455687433481216,
-0.19142770767211914,
-0.06849495321512222,
0.04287207871675491,
0.11353283375501633,
0.18163709342479706,
0.24585101008415222,
-0.11319086700677872,
0.2959766387939453,
0.05647338181734085,
-0.24039149284362793,
0.29107925295829773,
0.10482702404260635,
1.0837379693984985,
0.24531570076942444,
-0.1411074548959732,
-1.2742395401000977,
0.7779421806335449,
0.2793349325656891,
0.09266366064548492,
0.8092738389968872,
0.44168296456336975,
-0.5340242385864258,
-0.09946416318416595,
-0.38000741600990295,
-0.6535491347312927,
-0.4016270935535431,
0.31595173478126526,
-0.42230162024497986,
-0.8877896666526794,
0.5053827166557312,
-0.42064541578292847,
-0.08699233084917068,
-0.04155329242348671,
0.5564265847206116,
-0.5179867744445801,
1.581465721130371,
0.8830592036247253,
-0.15615122020244598,
0.64556884765625,
0.14196212589740753,
0.6756147146224976,
-0.8031895756721497,
0.10955274105072021,
-0.3883996307849884,
-0.48322075605392456,
-0.47777366638183594,
-0.42579489946365356,
0.43173912167549133,
0.2706545293331146,
-0.07808176428079605,
0.30993223190307617,
-0.2826690375804901,
-0.10406810790300369,
0.16732028126716614,
0.5219040513038635,
0.2134646624326706,
-0.24429236352443695,
0.1068623885512352,
-0.5661932826042175,
-0.4822884202003479,
-0.16859446465969086,
0.6857166886329651,
0.22877775132656097,
1.0518380403518677,
0.03950279951095581,
0.8212132453918457,
0.2700245678424835,
0.18112528324127197,
-0.7986835837364197,
0.6553999185562134,
-0.020710241049528122,
-0.2113846093416214,
-0.09992248564958572,
-0.4423280656337738,
-0.7771283388137817,
-0.09247297793626785,
-0.2176387757062912,
-1.2582696676254272,
0.25473523139953613,
0.38317134976387024,
-0.40664443373680115,
-0.17155970633029938,
-0.5416596531867981,
0.886227011680603,
-0.06582466512918472,
0.34635159373283386,
-0.7196829915046692,
-0.2997570335865021,
0.5154441595077515,
-0.2029145509004593,
0.17445944249629974,
-0.17171017825603485,
0.07576484233140945,
0.6054105162620544,
-0.3929238021373749,
1.3445309400558472,
-0.27513450384140015,
-0.49402308464050293,
-0.005585039965808392,
0.5402768850326538,
0.26707789301872253,
0.04109000414609909,
0.13157489895820618,
-0.11176937073469162,
0.4189148545265198,
-0.1009940430521965,
-0.8698868751525879,
0.5427500009536743,
-0.5794742703437805,
-0.5712519288063049,
-0.1465332955121994,
-0.47895804047584534,
-0.5750738978385925,
0.059833772480487823,
0.16313563287258148,
0.4957161247730255,
-0.13143745064735413,
-0.0005142837762832642,
0.5254100561141968,
-0.5135679841041565,
-0.07911807298660278,
0.8137004971504211,
-0.5863638520240784,
-0.24205382168293,
0.5394336581230164,
-0.26125580072402954,
0.18556533753871918,
0.33697590231895447,
0.2433021366596222,
-0.28120407462120056,
0.0868542343378067,
0.28011611104011536,
0.6666606068611145,
-0.6304164528846741,
-0.37892502546310425,
-0.7239145040512085,
-0.10136057436466217,
-0.5463219881057739,
0.0991925597190857,
-0.5315052270889282,
-0.2557489275932312,
-0.3456711769104004,
-0.23441576957702637,
0.6269937753677368,
0.3158482015132904,
-0.27699214220046997,
0.34065619111061096,
-0.6029363870620728,
0.5267502069473267,
-0.06307386606931686,
0.5285767912864685,
-0.0439557246863842,
-0.4539075493812561,
-0.3118196129798889,
0.28052252531051636,
-0.19827668368816376,
-1.0553967952728271,
0.19278904795646667,
0.15196332335472107,
0.23488293588161469,
0.7604855895042419,
0.3476635813713074,
1.072020411491394,
-0.311292827129364,
0.8486620187759399,
0.562042772769928,
-0.9041880369186401,
1.1738554239273071,
-0.28527456521987915,
0.3468565344810486,
0.26395702362060547,
0.6219431161880493,
-0.8419386744499207,
-0.9539432525634766,
-0.3070266544818878,
-0.4742083251476288,
0.9434745907783508,
-0.12349908798933029,
0.17616793513298035,
-0.33768248558044434,
0.19775912165641785,
-0.12572956085205078,
-0.06891640275716782,
-0.4744795858860016,
-0.07426565885543823,
-0.16235582530498505,
-0.4211101531982422,
-0.32969364523887634,
-0.46177640557289124,
-0.39403465390205383,
-0.3869275450706482,
0.47560927271842957,
-0.08698027580976486,
0.8472965359687805,
0.23519763350486755,
0.22899988293647766,
-0.10264106839895248,
0.13628089427947998,
0.33284085988998413,
0.5606428384780884,
-0.17123372852802277,
0.040773987770080566,
-0.183712437748909,
-0.22147436439990997,
-0.12734289467334747,
0.17677316069602966,
0.11915592104196548,
-0.0007918860064819455,
0.028981396928429604,
0.9075711369514465,
0.30265012383461,
-0.7024055123329163,
0.6597269773483276,
-0.28280147910118103,
-0.15427443385124207,
-0.1774318367242813,
0.223007470369339,
0.5148237347602844,
0.6600805521011353,
0.014583793468773365,
-0.2689964771270752,
0.13968943059444427,
-0.8365036249160767,
0.09143439680337906,
0.32401618361473083,
-0.5802368521690369,
-0.6146561503410339,
0.37699413299560547,
0.28969496488571167,
-0.7549508213996887,
0.50180983543396,
-0.2138725221157074,
-0.5618466734886169,
0.19934846460819244,
0.78811115026474,
0.7092207670211792,
-0.4351617395877838,
0.46281197667121887,
0.3566630780696869,
0.03467540070414543,
-0.08443710952997208,
0.8182153105735779,
-0.3524033725261688,
-0.6367441415786743,
-0.6440899968147278,
-0.5612086653709412,
-0.37706103920936584,
0.37460383772850037,
-0.6850939989089966,
0.39511680603027344,
-0.2552260756492615,
-0.5399949550628662,
-0.37059545516967773,
-0.11844854056835175,
-0.5201948881149292,
0.17827777564525604,
0.4833206534385681,
0.7658236622810364,
-0.730548083782196,
0.576076328754425,
0.5617407560348511,
-0.04922951012849808,
-0.6808767914772034,
0.17481161653995514,
0.11896805465221405,
-0.39141854643821716,
0.1570821851491928,
0.11816772073507309,
0.006726452149450779,
-0.09134463965892792,
-0.29419776797294617,
-0.894259512424469,
0.7609111666679382,
0.34702014923095703,
-0.4168553948402405,
0.22406445443630219,
0.04347202181816101,
0.9890398979187012,
-0.40709319710731506,
0.2947745621204376,
0.4711240828037262,
0.08721504360437393,
-0.17446425557136536,
-1.2982693910598755,
0.18306276202201843,
-0.10898959636688232,
-0.11424750834703445,
0.3358302116394043,
-0.4225969910621643,
0.6515879034996033,
0.2451535165309906,
-0.42052555084228516,
0.03467763215303421,
0.47771865129470825,
0.08560606092214584,
-0.16318964958190918,
0.7156553268432617,
0.4858406186103821,
0.7495909333229065,
0.14922262728214264,
1.0048998594284058,
-0.7492044568061829,
0.17625591158866882,
1.0260881185531616,
-0.4130847156047821,
0.9119742512702942,
0.04400581866502762,
-0.10374241322278976,
0.6027926206588745,
0.6377573609352112,
0.2778880000114441,
0.3588326871395111,
-0.0227106474339962,
-0.5052362680435181,
-0.45209506154060364,
-0.20939229428768158,
-0.253280907869339,
0.4804200232028961,
0.8110584020614624,
-0.29108351469039917,
-0.45256590843200684,
0.29032787680625916,
0.26622310280799866,
-0.21420986950397491,
-0.21833130717277527,
0.9301580190658569,
0.1865691989660263,
-0.7891210317611694,
0.6975566148757935,
-0.04980470612645149,
0.5869616866111755,
-0.7010717391967773,
0.029074635356664658,
-0.3578189015388489,
0.2914254367351532,
-0.08360248059034348,
-0.633261501789093,
0.1758420169353485,
0.4249587059020996,
-0.16146278381347656,
-0.2505039870738983,
0.6413646340370178,
-0.5105109810829163,
-0.5464288592338562,
0.5226045250892639,
0.49923938512802124,
0.4768647253513336,
-0.2902051508426666,
-0.649317741394043,
0.05387119576334953,
-0.11183168739080429,
0.05808941647410393,
0.6099596619606018,
0.6893910765647888,
0.15616433322429657,
0.6436486840248108,
0.23561422526836395,
0.31130629777908325,
-0.1888662576675415,
0.2620488703250885,
0.7043973803520203,
-0.6961579918861389,
-0.938021183013916,
-0.6326586008071899,
0.2980322539806366,
-0.08323775231838226,
-0.2548975348472595,
0.43440231680870056,
0.15760156512260437,
0.30841365456581116,
0.06484133750200272,
0.6116644740104675,
-0.2578854560852051,
0.9342981576919556,
-0.04341980069875717,
0.41329047083854675,
-0.5470783114433289,
0.058610621839761734,
-0.5551691055297852,
-0.8317481875419617,
0.06752492487430573,
0.6756924986839294,
-0.15955887734889984,
-0.3040355145931244,
0.8662535548210144,
0.7826489210128784,
0.0137025136500597,
0.10790201276540756,
0.2116086333990097,
0.5809959769248962,
0.38718149065971375,
0.6410479545593262,
0.9931685328483582,
0.01670783944427967,
0.4215797483921051,
-0.41130420565605164,
-0.5842065811157227,
-0.19895103573799133,
-0.6960911750793457,
-0.7956750988960266,
-0.49250683188438416,
-0.6082959175109863,
-0.14562250673770905,
-0.2824259102344513,
0.5929190516471863,
0.5242725014686584,
-0.42310449481010437,
-0.23645929992198944,
0.15104620158672333,
-0.43620824813842773,
-0.47983279824256897,
-0.329287052154541,
0.0032479348592460155,
-0.4781017005443573,
-0.4742612838745117,
0.48712244629859924,
0.29008275270462036,
-0.30287113785743713,
-0.4443763792514801,
0.36948782205581665,
-0.05927689000964165,
-0.037375740706920624,
0.8133600354194641,
-0.11252206563949585,
-0.5408810377120972,
-0.14074118435382843,
-0.22834940254688263,
-0.037246447056531906,
0.07136643677949905,
0.8610548377037048,
-0.7800836563110352,
0.3850538730621338,
0.3819754421710968,
0.33385857939720154,
0.4362214505672455,
0.24839608371257782,
0.8779234290122986,
-0.4540131986141205,
0.025051066651940346,
0.3516974449157715,
0.2963562607765198,
0.2232912927865982,
-0.7322593331336975,
0.009286979213356972,
0.08547753095626831,
-0.5059722065925598,
-0.8209993243217468,
0.3213083744049072,
-0.9782952666282654,
-0.34097856283187866,
0.8213933706283569,
-0.34401991963386536,
0.042554616928100586,
-0.10604299604892731,
-0.2971574366092682,
0.2658948004245758,
-0.5179198980331421,
1.1036962270736694,
0.751233696937561,
-0.7726011872291565,
-0.342934787273407,
-0.3793907165527344,
0.6192033886909485,
0.31662148237228394,
-0.7587108612060547,
0.07022769749164581,
0.7244243025779724,
0.31239017844200134,
0.03295078128576279,
1.1361467838287354,
0.033437084406614304,
0.2899903953075409,
-0.2236577421426773,
-0.045691411942243576,
0.6432247161865234,
-0.03136204928159714,
-0.11067716777324677,
-0.09591705352067947,
-0.29209592938423157,
-0.21610680222511292
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07350v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07350v2
|
VLKEB: A Large Vision-Language Model Knowledge Editing Benchmark
| 2024-03-12T06:16:33 | 2024-06-13T10:47:48 |
Han Huang, Haitian Zhong, Tao Yu, Qiang Liu, Shu Wu, Liang Wang, Tieniu Tan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV
|
Recently, knowledge editing on large language models (LLMs) has received
considerable attention. Compared to this, editing Large Vision-Language Models
(LVLMs) faces extra challenges from diverse data modalities and complicated
model components, and data for LVLMs editing are limited. The existing LVLM
editing benchmark, which comprises three metrics (Reliability, Locality, and
Generality), falls short in the quality of synthesized evaluation images and
cannot assess whether models apply edited knowledge in relevant content.
Therefore, we employ more reliable data collection methods to construct a new
Large $\textbf{V}$ision-$\textbf{L}$anguage Model $\textbf{K}$nowledge
$\textbf{E}$diting $\textbf{B}$enchmark, $\textbf{VLKEB}$, and extend the
Portability metric for more comprehensive evaluation. Leveraging a multi-modal
knowledge graph, our image data are bound with knowledge entities. This can be
further used to extract entity-related knowledge, which constitutes the base of
editing data. We conduct experiments of different editing methods on five
LVLMs, and thoroughly analyze how do they impact the models. The results reveal
strengths and deficiencies of these methods and hopefully provide insights for
future research. The codes and dataset are available at:
$\href{https://github.com/VLKEB/VLKEB}{\text{https://github.com/VLKEB/VLKEB}}$.
|
[
-0.3223469853401184,
-0.7765588164329529,
0.6180099248886108,
0.09923579543828964,
-0.20463600754737854,
-0.05428457632660866,
-0.37825071811676025,
-0.7371055483818054,
0.070160411298275,
0.6799790859222412,
-0.16587720811367035,
-0.7567502856254578,
-0.48171207308769226,
-0.014603185467422009,
-0.5669285655021667,
0.5622372031211853,
-0.167596235871315,
0.2151007503271103,
-0.45064255595207214,
-0.3302486836910248,
-0.4718446433544159,
-0.27912527322769165,
-0.2746488153934479,
0.025157280266284943,
0.5446850657463074,
0.15681207180023193,
0.6603314280509949,
0.7969885468482971,
0.6790629029273987,
0.32973793148994446,
-0.3760693669319153,
0.2551139295101166,
-0.47866150736808777,
0.22098928689956665,
-0.26547902822494507,
-0.31324976682662964,
-0.7665122151374817,
-0.35888907313346863,
1.0107237100601196,
0.4705756604671478,
0.01413735095411539,
0.41128697991371155,
-0.15718750655651093,
0.5909326076507568,
-0.7744997143745422,
0.2720335125923157,
-0.7620836496353149,
-0.10829134285449982,
-0.4466373026371002,
0.13596127927303314,
-0.3765893578529358,
-0.3120574355125427,
0.048944003880023956,
-0.549776554107666,
-0.02586388774216175,
0.059204962104558945,
0.9481521844863892,
0.39099976420402527,
-0.4180937707424164,
0.062057048082351685,
-0.5566754937171936,
0.5589535236358643,
-0.699496328830719,
0.7483349442481995,
0.26447296142578125,
0.30797848105430603,
-0.13839231431484222,
-0.8569188714027405,
-0.6837996244430542,
-0.15436270833015442,
0.19754815101623535,
0.10329999774694443,
-0.39163050055503845,
0.02326165698468685,
0.37368717789649963,
0.13269060850143433,
-0.23582428693771362,
0.19695064425468445,
-0.5536129474639893,
-0.25444528460502625,
0.35372084379196167,
0.2872534692287445,
-0.0071763936430215836,
-0.2955091595649719,
-0.300403892993927,
-0.11495474725961685,
-0.7997006773948669,
0.09607308357954025,
0.2460930049419403,
-0.1612580418586731,
0.17083165049552917,
0.8866467475891113,
-0.396642804145813,
1.1299604177474976,
-0.2603053152561188,
-0.14170490205287933,
0.5192700624465942,
-0.3654140830039978,
-0.31197458505630493,
-0.2776918113231659,
0.6358718276023865,
0.8753507137298584,
0.02969403751194477,
-0.011889743618667126,
-0.33535900712013245,
-0.21106219291687012,
0.2706488072872162,
-0.836589515209198,
-0.14952175319194794,
0.024903705343604088,
-0.5214735865592957,
-0.24518786370754242,
-0.24850736558437347,
-0.6757164001464844,
-0.4383976459503174,
-0.4977409541606903,
0.40876778960227966,
-0.3988320529460907,
-0.06469187140464783,
0.17616738379001617,
-0.07802005112171173,
0.2857115864753723,
0.6660933494567871,
-0.20796740055084229,
-0.054091621190309525,
0.6489930152893066,
0.6715106964111328,
-0.3139917850494385,
-0.4486390948295593,
-0.5544746518135071,
0.13776561617851257,
-0.3803144693374634,
0.8898313045501709,
-0.5986071825027466,
-0.3805009126663208,
0.06394360959529877,
-0.05687152221798897,
0.22728149592876434,
-0.6457639336585999,
0.43290701508522034,
-0.7310075759887695,
-0.1974075585603714,
-0.5304323434829712,
-0.8472471237182617,
-0.20308589935302734,
0.4129897952079773,
-0.845197856426239,
1.0555185079574585,
0.04132382571697235,
-0.5557123422622681,
0.501941978931427,
-0.40633347630500793,
-0.23266634345054626,
0.006485546473413706,
-0.09392356127500534,
-0.5163233876228333,
0.10489153116941452,
0.16084183752536774,
0.578321099281311,
-0.340130478143692,
0.34263744950294495,
-0.5635808706283569,
-0.022403420880436897,
0.28326255083084106,
-0.3386729657649994,
0.5209356546401978,
0.05955861881375313,
-0.06391900777816772,
0.10791909694671631,
-1.0842530727386475,
0.1197107583284378,
-0.012800958007574081,
-0.5963917970657349,
-0.4540339410305023,
-0.09955015033483505,
0.11204199492931366,
0.04067297652363777,
0.4224945902824402,
-0.5146132111549377,
0.3838735818862915,
0.11275513470172882,
0.13328944146633148,
0.9030198454856873,
0.02337017096579075,
0.06484877318143845,
-0.04931756854057312,
0.30549362301826477,
0.12086538970470428,
0.2937426269054413,
0.06146583706140518,
-0.3661498725414276,
-0.8427583575248718,
-0.3086482882499695,
0.4945656359195709,
0.3739447593688965,
-1.1037591695785522,
0.14997398853302002,
-0.5449774861335754,
-0.8016887307167053,
-0.572251558303833,
0.30730336904525757,
0.5764418244361877,
0.6604747176170349,
0.45279568433761597,
-0.4410149157047272,
-0.30878883600234985,
-1.0034937858581543,
-0.3138929009437561,
-0.10330767184495926,
0.16469471156597137,
0.28854960203170776,
0.5232964158058167,
-0.268665611743927,
0.9679241180419922,
-0.3858073949813843,
-0.09377142041921616,
-0.0387859046459198,
-0.22673827409744263,
-0.08852243423461914,
0.2623302638530731,
0.693437397480011,
-0.6241495013237,
-0.2916564345359802,
0.04233162850141525,
-0.8626763224601746,
-0.23619432747364044,
0.1676689088344574,
-0.2467329204082489,
0.25551748275756836,
0.6088963150978088,
-0.6215040683746338,
0.4432997405529022,
0.6974157691001892,
-0.4443913996219635,
0.7718791961669922,
-0.197545126080513,
0.4199454188346863,
-0.9363508820533752,
0.010169361717998981,
0.11205869168043137,
-0.3518931269645691,
-0.478051096200943,
0.10899940133094788,
0.4772675335407257,
0.220773383975029,
-0.7135607004165649,
0.5793437361717224,
-0.5370810031890869,
-0.29763075709342957,
-0.041376642882823944,
0.10383191704750061,
0.11841873079538345,
0.30923888087272644,
0.062196142971515656,
0.5705776810646057,
0.460794061422348,
-0.3385540843009949,
0.685799241065979,
0.17418678104877472,
-0.7932974696159363,
0.8703868985176086,
-0.7477189302444458,
0.15067921578884125,
-0.14344143867492676,
0.041579388082027435,
-0.5371091961860657,
-0.020301999524235725,
0.11083045601844788,
-0.08157040178775787,
0.2711295485496521,
-0.15963037312030792,
-0.6119656562805176,
-0.07929299771785736,
-0.216410830616951,
0.3912244439125061,
0.32636234164237976,
-0.49027150869369507,
0.7138357758522034,
0.40553659200668335,
-0.06186295673251152,
-0.656058669090271,
-0.48860082030296326,
0.38537049293518066,
0.029499948024749756,
-0.7500239014625549,
0.2562350034713745,
-0.17654502391815186,
-0.4484127461910248,
0.392223596572876,
0.04806607961654663,
-0.07571465522050858,
-0.12393558025360107,
0.0733487457036972,
0.516401469707489,
-0.3340897262096405,
0.06986003369092941,
0.016933251172304153,
-0.17401404678821564,
-0.1403251588344574,
0.05444222688674927,
0.14553505182266235,
-0.2712906002998352,
-0.6474202871322632,
-0.16685551404953003,
-0.045153096318244934,
0.7066514492034912,
-0.5240192413330078,
0.5932150483131409,
0.5423901081085205,
-0.27781805396080017,
-0.06529238075017929,
-0.8129087686538696,
0.2341013252735138,
-0.3968845009803772,
0.7163059115409851,
-0.46431371569633484,
-0.8877540826797485,
0.40727683901786804,
-0.11371050029993057,
0.22493046522140503,
0.33358776569366455,
0.536619246006012,
-0.028649738058447838,
0.3523053526878357,
0.42493173480033875,
-0.14965735375881195,
0.4990111291408539,
-0.2086889147758484,
-0.1892189234495163,
-0.9202430844306946,
-0.13532325625419617,
-0.5291273593902588,
-0.2852059006690979,
-0.2698444724082947,
-0.8638399839401245,
0.5266375541687012,
0.008820075541734695,
0.14492052793502808,
0.33742791414260864,
-0.21956691145896912,
0.647698163986206,
0.5939390063285828,
0.15391035377979279,
0.45166847109794617,
-0.1924574077129364,
0.1884654462337494,
-0.23310346901416779,
-0.5355079174041748,
-0.23722109198570251,
1.327304720878601,
0.3409549295902252,
0.807201623916626,
0.1480577141046524,
0.3383379280567169,
0.2568114697933197,
0.3031240701675415,
-0.5885584354400635,
0.6757487654685974,
-0.13079951703548431,
-0.4731929302215576,
-0.34091028571128845,
-0.3499597907066345,
-0.5897569060325623,
0.4327312707901001,
-0.403110533952713,
-0.6041883826255798,
0.29729586839675903,
0.40946027636528015,
-0.06232359632849693,
0.5293825268745422,
-0.6102160811424255,
1.0141080617904663,
-0.3351622223854065,
-0.493936687707901,
-0.23785564303398132,
-0.46792659163475037,
0.29310789704322815,
-0.17944836616516113,
0.3073541224002838,
0.06477855890989304,
0.0075234039686620235,
0.4987359941005707,
-0.3709259033203125,
0.715025007724762,
-0.29499438405036926,
-0.16631944477558136,
0.2599167227745056,
0.23278850317001343,
0.7268791794776917,
-0.11848413944244385,
-0.08064471185207367,
0.48423314094543457,
0.020376183092594147,
-0.217898890376091,
-0.4718697667121887,
0.5270816087722778,
-0.5640631318092346,
-0.29985037446022034,
-0.06915943324565887,
-0.503816545009613,
-0.314831018447876,
0.25766757130622864,
0.12429599463939667,
0.7655624151229858,
-0.17018719017505646,
0.6561302542686462,
0.7580195665359497,
-0.4409565031528473,
0.2537407875061035,
0.6440631747245789,
-0.5354901552200317,
-0.44194191694259644,
0.9630609750747681,
0.3130849003791809,
0.44123366475105286,
0.21489720046520233,
-0.07073263078927994,
-0.08897628635168076,
-0.8535295724868774,
-0.5129851698875427,
0.015588962472975254,
-1.0066646337509155,
-0.289261132478714,
-0.5282581448554993,
-0.13058631122112274,
-0.19314418733119965,
-0.04567248374223709,
-0.664483904838562,
-0.1322479397058487,
0.04833728075027466,
0.02481793612241745,
0.477173388004303,
0.8234394788742065,
0.05083318427205086,
0.09510698914527893,
-0.8449409008026123,
0.46750497817993164,
0.2957509160041809,
0.5054765939712524,
-0.14906944334506989,
-0.3739842474460602,
-0.3551628291606903,
-0.14366008341312408,
0.010316974483430386,
-0.6272426247596741,
0.09242349863052368,
0.06729517132043839,
0.5251592397689819,
0.017812680453062057,
-0.18727700412273407,
0.7872529029846191,
-0.5268844962120056,
0.833274781703949,
0.03489154949784279,
-1.01105797290802,
0.3216519057750702,
-0.3092685639858246,
0.29252269864082336,
0.5010512471199036,
-0.09414463490247726,
-0.6012507677078247,
-0.41153258085250854,
-0.4065033793449402,
-0.9001303315162659,
0.3441199064254761,
-0.022555269300937653,
-0.17069697380065918,
0.24267931282520294,
0.25455719232559204,
0.021743057295680046,
0.40539315342903137,
-0.7194058895111084,
-0.2988847494125366,
0.0151260020211339,
-0.15035170316696167,
0.0869859829545021,
-0.5222190618515015,
0.01575121469795704,
-0.3562636971473694,
0.7853214144706726,
0.055899765342473984,
-0.14670342206954956,
0.21651175618171692,
-0.4075452387332916,
-0.012267294339835644,
0.1391531229019165,
0.6156433820724487,
0.8076763153076172,
-0.031105952337384224,
0.05153588578104973,
0.3981238603591919,
-0.5603437423706055,
-0.22286270558834076,
-0.11771754920482635,
-0.465370774269104,
0.1605183184146881,
0.632031261920929,
0.9441470503807068,
0.2560967206954956,
-0.7986030578613281,
0.5839306116104126,
-0.1398564726114273,
-0.21592241525650024,
-0.14753496646881104,
0.010755321010947227,
0.09297622740268707,
0.514837384223938,
-0.023060547187924385,
0.25101038813591003,
0.07475388795137405,
-0.07975659519433975,
-0.0016030665719881654,
0.41068392992019653,
-0.2924305200576782,
-0.1110394299030304,
0.46358779072761536,
0.10612040013074875,
-0.24732165038585663,
0.3622412383556366,
-0.03265884891152382,
-0.3655065894126892,
0.3631816804409027,
0.11947871744632721,
0.586641252040863,
0.09898515790700912,
0.012658863328397274,
0.2363286018371582,
0.518609344959259,
0.012942861765623093,
0.09298861771821976,
0.1337893158197403,
-0.7744764089584351,
-0.5710864663124084,
-0.6347196698188782,
-0.47773122787475586,
0.20089609920978546,
-0.5704044699668884,
0.3816096782684326,
-0.18325330317020416,
-0.16245566308498383,
-0.03152408450841904,
-0.4474846124649048,
-0.8802523612976074,
0.0661531314253807,
-0.06597664207220078,
1.0166012048721313,
-0.4631611704826355,
0.8900107145309448,
0.6963263154029846,
-0.1779356747865677,
-0.7118464112281799,
-0.24719983339309692,
0.05985365808010101,
-0.8931987881660461,
0.6096218228340149,
-0.24983423948287964,
-0.11099167168140411,
-0.0863630548119545,
-0.5948042273521423,
-0.8822275996208191,
1.0286203622817993,
0.4943895936012268,
-0.856724739074707,
0.026112409308552742,
0.0023538561072200537,
0.47191697359085083,
0.04045531526207924,
-0.09787401556968689,
0.5080369114875793,
0.7547673583030701,
-0.026679128408432007,
-1.0744106769561768,
-0.17415453493595123,
-0.3336336314678192,
0.0999242514371872,
0.08796726167201996,
-0.6408693790435791,
0.7191044092178345,
-0.023564355447888374,
0.21362216770648956,
-0.03286552429199219,
0.619254469871521,
0.056732986122369766,
0.12393101304769516,
0.6043208241462708,
0.8112667202949524,
0.5855648517608643,
-0.10063852369785309,
0.8218564391136169,
-0.3022482991218567,
0.4408942461013794,
1.283218502998352,
-0.2558757960796356,
0.935541570186615,
0.6971610188484192,
-0.15411069989204407,
0.18521569669246674,
0.15559017658233643,
-0.2878085970878601,
0.3745757043361664,
0.12827585637569427,
-0.09079147130250931,
-0.3512413203716278,
0.06656279414892197,
-0.44543007016181946,
0.5990508794784546,
0.14081233739852905,
-0.29075154662132263,
-0.13764512538909912,
0.044511400163173676,
0.16919288039207458,
-0.11411342024803162,
-0.33611106872558594,
0.7371882200241089,
-0.10239763557910919,
-0.47029104828834534,
0.40261945128440857,
-0.08084258437156677,
0.4858807325363159,
-0.546576738357544,
-0.06269685924053192,
0.004602313507348299,
0.16521096229553223,
-0.0436408556997776,
-1.0602467060089111,
0.04832345247268677,
0.17123256623744965,
-0.09261418133974075,
-0.20325927436351776,
0.7735081315040588,
-0.42072615027427673,
-0.6380852460861206,
0.26169851422309875,
0.5426051616668701,
0.02567133679986,
0.09037557244300842,
-0.5227451920509338,
0.6090229749679565,
0.0035594231449067593,
-0.6329143643379211,
0.22691062092781067,
0.6302802562713623,
0.057302214205265045,
0.5735669136047363,
0.5817066431045532,
0.4902540445327759,
0.16329064965248108,
0.11790213733911514,
0.7484727501869202,
-0.6441868543624878,
-0.07904820889234543,
-0.7722949981689453,
0.7943934798240662,
-0.3094561696052551,
-0.4705221652984619,
0.6620355844497681,
0.6213721632957458,
1.0353056192398071,
-0.17605742812156677,
0.807806670665741,
-0.1715969741344452,
0.3259342312812805,
-0.8428657054901123,
0.7061786651611328,
-0.5964667201042175,
0.18032968044281006,
-0.5335726737976074,
-1.0608152151107788,
-0.29415223002433777,
0.37884199619293213,
-0.2178339958190918,
-0.18806277215480804,
0.5379406809806824,
0.8473689556121826,
-0.03187147527933121,
-0.27035126090049744,
0.516550600528717,
0.5171792507171631,
0.3884383738040924,
0.3697589039802551,
0.7809962034225464,
-0.32651013135910034,
0.4462406635284424,
-0.2967509329319,
-0.07949783653020859,
-0.2365022450685501,
-1.1191473007202148,
-0.7140944004058838,
-0.7025363445281982,
-0.26382842659950256,
-0.35544031858444214,
0.05860115587711334,
0.7879016995429993,
0.3822036385536194,
-0.45959389209747314,
-0.07367920130491257,
0.3829472064971924,
0.12011280655860901,
-0.08367472887039185,
-0.12102404981851578,
0.3333079516887665,
-0.0008596897823736072,
-0.593570351600647,
0.29083123803138733,
0.3109416961669922,
0.027056710794568062,
-0.28178155422210693,
0.03514615073800087,
0.17852884531021118,
-0.28360748291015625,
0.8584108948707581,
0.09642782062292099,
-0.7143851518630981,
-0.6172075867652893,
-0.02521650306880474,
-0.07714690268039703,
-0.1393110603094101,
0.5036534667015076,
-0.471969872713089,
0.7636252045631409,
0.30531924962997437,
0.9516036510467529,
0.3868468403816223,
-0.3215709924697876,
0.41242849826812744,
-0.5172282457351685,
0.02057400345802307,
-0.12081502377986908,
0.7588925361633301,
0.26235395669937134,
-0.013642905279994011,
0.416193425655365,
0.39372867345809937,
-0.580376386642456,
-1.0043996572494507,
0.012968853116035461,
-1.1760127544403076,
-0.1439792364835739,
1.3408511877059937,
-0.12245449423789978,
-0.3343542218208313,
0.13185808062553406,
-0.4692862033843994,
0.13697904348373413,
-0.2407376915216446,
0.6082521080970764,
0.8196269869804382,
0.16262899339199066,
-0.08310753852128983,
-0.7214125394821167,
0.21205496788024902,
0.11507050693035126,
-0.9119675159454346,
0.20374105870723724,
1.0878479480743408,
0.4133130609989166,
-0.07706610858440399,
0.48315638303756714,
-0.023639054968953133,
0.41965052485466003,
-0.05618554353713989,
0.4343838095664978,
-0.388980507850647,
-0.40856048464775085,
-0.21217729151248932,
0.19257089495658875,
0.26914942264556885,
0.09334544837474823
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07342v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07342v2
|
Rethinking ASTE: A Minimalist Tagging Scheme Alongside Contrastive Learning
| 2024-03-12T06:01:04 | 2024-04-14T20:53:02 |
Qiao Sun, Liujia Yang, Minghao Ma, Nanyang Ye, Qinying Gu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Aspect Sentiment Triplet Extraction (ASTE) is a burgeoning subtask of
fine-grained sentiment analysis, aiming to extract structured sentiment
triplets from unstructured textual data. Existing approaches to ASTE often
complicate the task with additional structures or external data. In this
research, we propose a novel tagging scheme and employ a contrastive learning
approach to mitigate these challenges. The proposed approach demonstrates
comparable or superior performance in comparison to state-of-the-art
techniques, while featuring a more compact design and reduced computational
overhead. Notably, even in the era of Large Language Models (LLMs), our method
exhibits superior efficacy compared to GPT 3.5 and GPT 4 in a few-shot learning
scenarios. This study also provides valuable insights for the advancement of
ASTE techniques within the paradigm of large language models.
|
[
-0.4316902458667755,
-0.3846011161804199,
0.39670470356941223,
0.14997239410877228,
-0.4820542633533478,
0.2391289919614792,
-0.35042163729667664,
-0.6815845966339111,
0.42892006039619446,
0.12948447465896606,
-0.6233996748924255,
-0.7902965545654297,
-0.5551182627677917,
0.017780497670173645,
-0.07999410480260849,
1.3200055360794067,
-0.0682363286614418,
-0.15541565418243408,
0.2759367525577545,
-0.12116643786430359,
-0.002097013173624873,
-0.27791261672973633,
-0.9629421830177307,
-0.4636843502521515,
0.5828972458839417,
0.5573309063911438,
0.3458429276943207,
0.3589426279067993,
0.624029278755188,
0.19361336529254913,
-0.15070278942584991,
-0.03499080240726471,
0.06127883866429329,
-0.013991031795740128,
-0.16774122416973114,
-0.27279898524284363,
-0.49873438477516174,
0.12259521335363388,
0.4888501465320587,
0.6793715953826904,
0.08405828475952148,
0.048326533287763596,
0.5445627570152283,
0.8576249480247498,
-0.5401619672775269,
0.31002911925315857,
-0.6709597706794739,
-0.08755619078874588,
-0.20076002180576324,
-0.02330911159515381,
-0.2789439260959625,
-0.2133137732744217,
0.17609064280986786,
-0.4106764793395996,
0.3575524389743805,
-0.13772696256637573,
1.144349455833435,
0.10074935108423233,
-0.1124010756611824,
-0.25401636958122253,
-0.3274984359741211,
0.7595873475074768,
-0.5783305764198303,
0.11316466331481934,
0.05146568641066551,
0.11285238713026047,
0.505231499671936,
-0.6025807857513428,
-0.5247001647949219,
0.03253370150923729,
-0.13999058306217194,
0.2684510052204132,
-0.10191691666841507,
-0.01909906603395939,
0.04875849559903145,
0.6853466033935547,
-0.2207137495279312,
0.13312044739723206,
-0.16474667191505432,
0.005291101988404989,
0.4765852689743042,
-0.08544515818357468,
-0.03659682348370552,
-0.692317545413971,
-0.7290505766868591,
0.16602632403373718,
-0.7929524779319763,
0.13026516139507294,
0.3606530725955963,
0.7142987251281738,
-0.22733311355113983,
0.234497532248497,
-0.37047088146209717,
0.027216149494051933,
-0.00524035282433033,
0.2151232808828354,
0.48078641295433044,
-0.3031311333179474,
-0.1713085174560547,
-0.2043306827545166,
1.074120283126831,
0.44031253457069397,
-0.14027473330497742,
0.04554521664977074,
-0.5539725422859192,
0.27301815152168274,
0.16218774020671844,
-0.6719697117805481,
-0.7074021697044373,
-0.0011041810503229499,
-0.3902604579925537,
-0.5566527247428894,
-0.008724038489162922,
-1.0338677167892456,
-0.34258994460105896,
-0.14072437584400177,
0.5240212082862854,
-0.619926929473877,
-0.3025880753993988,
0.03811773285269737,
0.08180733770132065,
0.5180222392082214,
0.4618791341781616,
-0.8273565173149109,
0.3815009593963623,
0.8018284440040588,
0.9505086541175842,
-0.3325446844100952,
-0.0532715767621994,
-0.18884330987930298,
-0.040540631860494614,
-0.0006079375743865967,
1.1025793552398682,
-0.7780351638793945,
-0.5741620659828186,
-0.09674262255430222,
-0.4057769477367401,
0.24893750250339508,
-0.4235665798187256,
0.7559704184532166,
-0.503304660320282,
0.031959954649209976,
-0.49074995517730713,
-0.21391312777996063,
-0.41451695561408997,
0.5247306823730469,
-0.7014926075935364,
1.0284727811813354,
-0.23413114249706268,
-0.9556806087493896,
0.3325090706348419,
-1.0037684440612793,
-0.4294838011264801,
0.08426939696073532,
-0.5233115553855896,
-0.4881877899169922,
0.18830949068069458,
0.28347811102867126,
0.4886881113052368,
-0.4022228717803955,
-0.20956653356552124,
-0.133906289935112,
-0.10973551869392395,
0.03069714643061161,
-0.31582924723625183,
0.42998006939888,
0.21946899592876434,
-0.34039831161499023,
0.04660523310303688,
-0.6124396920204163,
-0.04180310294032097,
0.014201031066477299,
-0.5029577016830444,
-0.24098722636699677,
-0.016677087172865868,
0.10581155866384506,
0.07777003198862076,
0.11878084391355515,
-0.8640708923339844,
0.2577385902404785,
-0.7501063942909241,
0.3567294776439667,
0.7404293417930603,
-0.047053780406713486,
0.47297704219818115,
-0.2432132512331009,
0.29168468713760376,
0.12192285060882568,
-0.2866280972957611,
-0.07679051905870438,
-0.1716209501028061,
-0.8743273615837097,
-0.3957766592502594,
0.46370959281921387,
0.306057333946228,
-1.2324161529541016,
0.23928822576999664,
-0.48395588994026184,
-0.043355148285627365,
-0.660361111164093,
0.06183459237217903,
0.5763272643089294,
0.36756137013435364,
0.646081268787384,
-0.14134423434734344,
-0.5403621792793274,
-1.0176644325256348,
-0.42000457644462585,
-0.12118586152791977,
-0.040166229009628296,
0.13001517951488495,
0.5325351357460022,
-0.12920735776424408,
0.8314997553825378,
-0.8258695602416992,
-0.3556176722049713,
-0.5532702803611755,
0.4341607987880707,
0.12749506533145905,
0.5220502614974976,
0.15539157390594482,
-0.796391487121582,
-0.6570490598678589,
0.17961640655994415,
-0.5401087403297424,
-0.07762957364320755,
0.21112115681171417,
0.24074344336986542,
0.46171411871910095,
0.45478367805480957,
-0.4621753692626953,
0.3209681510925293,
0.176286980509758,
0.016886869445443153,
0.3840794265270233,
0.34041616320610046,
0.05777773633599281,
-1.2851299047470093,
0.013589846901595592,
0.36308857798576355,
-0.18793515861034393,
-0.4517853260040283,
0.29704636335372925,
0.1288994550704956,
0.00830784346908331,
-0.33307456970214844,
0.36303186416625977,
-0.5173624157905579,
0.09243766218423843,
-0.3986266851425171,
0.09606841951608658,
0.16001780331134796,
0.44029828906059265,
0.22582672536373138,
0.5620904564857483,
0.4534090459346771,
-0.23481418192386627,
0.11633280664682388,
-0.008122448809444904,
-0.015496838837862015,
0.606640636920929,
-0.3472733497619629,
0.09759032726287842,
-0.11616746336221695,
0.18856394290924072,
-0.9254783987998962,
-0.03570188581943512,
0.3791309595108032,
-0.7015592455863953,
0.5698725581169128,
-0.10557875782251358,
-0.41059207916259766,
-0.21345941722393036,
-1.1213947534561157,
0.3249742090702057,
0.4146193265914917,
-0.7677741050720215,
0.8516835570335388,
0.1515255719423294,
-0.2727551758289337,
-0.7033326029777527,
-0.5209363102912903,
0.004382869694381952,
-0.5657476782798767,
-0.2721845209598541,
0.3025733232498169,
0.1002173125743866,
-0.0998392105102539,
0.011668500490486622,
-0.5331718325614929,
0.05919371545314789,
0.2098335474729538,
0.0507260262966156,
0.32884541153907776,
-0.40220388770103455,
0.14412708580493927,
-0.25245872139930725,
-0.4312129020690918,
0.021036839112639427,
-0.0715138390660286,
0.5867155194282532,
-0.5526696443557739,
-0.08966591954231262,
-0.5308849215507507,
0.6619125604629517,
-0.11336319893598557,
-0.12037897109985352,
0.26209756731987,
0.6427896022796631,
-0.4359201192855835,
-0.3851224482059479,
-0.5949543714523315,
-0.11149540543556213,
-0.5106552243232727,
0.22508813440799713,
-0.730848491191864,
-0.8766811490058899,
0.36052343249320984,
-0.08301455527544022,
0.10685577988624573,
0.5637704133987427,
0.28005942702293396,
-0.45897194743156433,
0.5197257995605469,
0.8153262138366699,
-0.13394510746002197,
0.501031219959259,
-0.3336096704006195,
0.36940714716911316,
-1.1023623943328857,
-0.2106134444475174,
-0.5476123690605164,
-0.35785427689552307,
-0.6868802905082703,
-0.3620011806488037,
0.2235221266746521,
0.08639045804738998,
-0.06697199493646622,
0.03143322840332985,
-0.2890061140060425,
0.7536918520927429,
0.3383835554122925,
0.3500499725341797,
0.44123613834381104,
0.1807958483695984,
0.14091670513153076,
-0.07366206496953964,
-0.2629490792751312,
-0.5754691958427429,
0.9653141498565674,
0.37207886576652527,
0.7102470993995667,
0.2832607328891754,
1.1628352403640747,
-0.024125201627612114,
0.4022499620914459,
-1.1477322578430176,
0.5976693630218506,
-0.5645772814750671,
-0.14639300107955933,
0.07622891664505005,
-0.32666149735450745,
-0.7567477822303772,
0.43678244948387146,
-0.12814530730247498,
-0.8536107540130615,
0.014825726859271526,
0.1479303389787674,
-0.7277311682701111,
0.42165184020996094,
-0.7160471081733704,
0.5277551412582397,
0.33097153902053833,
-0.5637826323509216,
-0.027920544147491455,
-0.8207270503044128,
0.19942711293697357,
0.04374634847044945,
0.1955639123916626,
-0.1468556523323059,
-0.42844119668006897,
0.7528888583183289,
-0.059869617223739624,
1.0948282480239868,
-0.08189602196216583,
-0.022570451721549034,
0.12190621346235275,
0.10550811141729355,
0.3307516872882843,
0.18031297624111176,
-0.022244075313210487,
0.030016973614692688,
-0.3162785470485687,
-0.45078015327453613,
-0.41703757643699646,
0.9360939860343933,
-0.72605299949646,
-0.6086071133613586,
-0.4611923396587372,
-0.27738651633262634,
-0.46719279885292053,
0.013028759509325027,
0.33332759141921997,
0.4066331386566162,
-0.08698674291372299,
0.11618498712778091,
0.6590154767036438,
0.07593328505754471,
0.8676709532737732,
0.4928024709224701,
0.05984578654170036,
-0.386307954788208,
1.0608291625976562,
-0.23442719876766205,
0.1660664677619934,
0.4434065520763397,
0.3023507595062256,
-0.2332279235124588,
-0.6206616163253784,
-0.012512466870248318,
0.32058659195899963,
-0.9347792267799377,
-0.5792252421379089,
-0.8193402886390686,
-0.19048140943050385,
-0.30799153447151184,
-0.4741680920124054,
-0.6009950041770935,
-0.2082139104604721,
-0.27083155512809753,
-0.09249702095985413,
0.2519463300704956,
0.9193189740180969,
-0.19018866121768951,
0.6133525371551514,
-0.6589817404747009,
0.3619133234024048,
0.18386293947696686,
0.5054199695587158,
-0.17214663326740265,
-0.3331804573535919,
0.08910725265741348,
-0.37343156337738037,
-0.48021483421325684,
-0.852150022983551,
0.23714111745357513,
0.32421860098838806,
0.19266396760940552,
0.2890411615371704,
-0.14009620249271393,
0.4664268493652344,
-0.3663806915283203,
0.8665523529052734,
0.4028196632862091,
-1.1001137495040894,
0.6108083128929138,
-0.38348808884620667,
0.182168111205101,
0.92987459897995,
0.6384164690971375,
-0.34301623702049255,
0.0894356444478035,
-0.9292300343513489,
-1.1899625062942505,
0.7833474278450012,
0.08176913112401962,
0.10652530193328857,
-0.011152484454214573,
0.4258209764957428,
0.2474406212568283,
0.3424580991268158,
-1.1857346296310425,
-0.11108160763978958,
-0.040999479591846466,
-0.5184921622276306,
-0.04812481626868248,
-0.32038751244544983,
0.031237350776791573,
-0.22304804623126984,
0.6931815147399902,
-0.2962474524974823,
0.13264133036136627,
0.010254748165607452,
-0.12441620975732803,
0.30466875433921814,
0.4557969868183136,
-0.038414984941482544,
-0.15281330049037933,
-0.11458907276391983,
0.5478407740592957,
0.10587915778160095,
-0.30671653151512146,
-0.24505503475666046,
-0.018874863162636757,
-0.02716446854174137,
-0.2936076819896698,
0.2620270550251007,
0.5949284434318542,
0.40030398964881897,
-0.11800206452608109,
0.8246724605560303,
0.118621826171875,
-0.21580763161182404,
-0.1428709328174591,
-0.2495603710412979,
0.0991356149315834,
0.3706763982772827,
0.07077441364526749,
0.19236475229263306,
0.48129281401634216,
-0.6122868061065674,
0.27856501936912537,
0.5422255396842957,
-0.5143761038780212,
-0.5911875367164612,
0.1856459379196167,
0.5453864336013794,
-0.10386047512292862,
0.09475430101156235,
-0.39386090636253357,
-0.6754183769226074,
0.21041977405548096,
0.40433213114738464,
1.0339723825454712,
-0.2764419913291931,
0.09259406477212906,
0.32559436559677124,
0.2774253487586975,
-0.11250964552164078,
0.38124141097068787,
-0.25934144854545593,
-0.8651203513145447,
-0.3092292249202728,
-0.8828441500663757,
-0.1882857084274292,
0.088015116751194,
-0.8085982203483582,
0.40308877825737,
-0.5435056090354919,
0.1685037463903427,
0.26948198676109314,
0.2953392565250397,
-0.5264690518379211,
0.19518935680389404,
0.5129241347312927,
0.6439254283905029,
-1.1524378061294556,
0.9690257906913757,
0.9321784377098083,
-0.6406455636024475,
-0.8531404137611389,
0.48207011818885803,
0.18937291204929352,
-0.8685432076454163,
0.5678218007087708,
0.5364235043525696,
-0.5737502574920654,
0.18807081878185272,
-0.6037006378173828,
-0.5249391198158264,
0.7536605000495911,
-0.2308170646429062,
-0.09570828825235367,
-0.033720407634973526,
-0.29905566573143005,
0.41868236660957336,
-0.48245957493782043,
0.1030697301030159,
1.0262733697891235,
0.1416170448064804,
0.4350336790084839,
-0.7254342436790466,
0.07515924423933029,
-0.4323708713054657,
0.03935299441218376,
0.34947553277015686,
-0.6388998031616211,
0.9721890091896057,
-0.002130183158442378,
-0.4909856617450714,
-0.12273046374320984,
0.8348507881164551,
-0.050797026604413986,
0.05000749230384827,
0.42775484919548035,
0.4947366416454315,
0.5435236096382141,
-0.18266303837299347,
0.9040026068687439,
0.0780857503414154,
0.6079078912734985,
1.2745119333267212,
-0.2953091263771057,
1.2560725212097168,
0.6307610869407654,
-0.08910714834928513,
0.5705914497375488,
0.444529265165329,
0.19899654388427734,
0.44905924797058105,
0.04565651714801788,
-0.49257251620292664,
-0.2858019471168518,
0.0034157095942646265,
-0.11480043083429337,
0.511709988117218,
0.549838125705719,
-0.07091664522886276,
-0.5744631886482239,
-0.0817398950457573,
0.41202566027641296,
0.35318371653556824,
-0.488936185836792,
1.0602086782455444,
0.1547996550798416,
-0.11626595258712769,
0.2931925654411316,
-0.06682472676038742,
1.3387614488601685,
-0.3444690704345703,
-0.017456604167819023,
-0.16478277742862701,
0.13573454320430756,
-0.4848071038722992,
-1.0001569986343384,
0.35389289259910583,
0.09619926661252975,
-0.06802631169557571,
-0.25915151834487915,
0.6320599317550659,
-0.4124090373516083,
-0.3880016803741455,
0.257281631231308,
0.45108750462532043,
-0.03743496909737587,
-0.1341755986213684,
-0.7059744000434875,
0.13285000622272491,
0.2815234363079071,
-0.30477920174598694,
0.14541058242321014,
0.4786294400691986,
0.15216372907161713,
0.42757630348205566,
0.16446562111377716,
0.1410829722881317,
-0.4337463080883026,
-0.10489312559366226,
1.2004529237747192,
-0.8500192761421204,
-0.6852800846099854,
-1.0755726099014282,
0.6246652007102966,
-0.3480384349822998,
-0.049207836389541626,
0.6521569490432739,
0.5351993441581726,
0.7372257113456726,
0.24096067249774933,
0.8881106376647949,
-0.040304239839315414,
0.7252780795097351,
-0.6714019775390625,
0.34487950801849365,
-0.662496030330658,
0.6912912726402283,
-0.33025678992271423,
-0.8274347186088562,
-0.5536779165267944,
0.7094998955726624,
-0.5193689465522766,
0.002995317103341222,
1.2815507650375366,
0.6193018555641174,
-0.053658101707696915,
0.47554418444633484,
0.059524089097976685,
0.22846730053424835,
0.3494051694869995,
0.603011429309845,
1.029085636138916,
-0.4636019170284271,
0.36381959915161133,
-0.26977208256721497,
-0.24503977596759796,
-0.08384934067726135,
-0.8361484408378601,
-0.7547616362571716,
-0.5199127793312073,
-0.5076361298561096,
-0.14956717193126678,
-0.13839063048362732,
1.2555755376815796,
0.1658729761838913,
-0.6465165019035339,
-0.017094219103455544,
0.24949347972869873,
-0.11504632234573364,
0.30490851402282715,
-0.19372956454753876,
0.5408157706260681,
-0.635367214679718,
-0.6439847946166992,
0.28657883405685425,
0.3405263423919678,
-0.03443552553653717,
0.23170243203639984,
0.3907199203968048,
-0.20111055672168732,
-0.035697802901268005,
0.645634114742279,
0.08660430461168289,
-0.6393200159072876,
-0.7018645405769348,
-0.5988314747810364,
-0.11474046111106873,
0.5677332282066345,
0.8332887291908264,
-0.6366420388221741,
0.0397198349237442,
0.26255616545677185,
0.6182337999343872,
0.3839103877544403,
0.17879442870616913,
0.09944657236337662,
-1.0805400609970093,
0.054795295000076294,
0.4093017876148224,
0.2507188618183136,
0.5132701396942139,
-0.09622129052877426,
0.37113118171691895,
0.266324520111084,
-0.07235118001699448,
-0.6133127212524414,
0.5454654097557068,
-1.182864785194397,
-0.2406412959098816,
1.3832063674926758,
-0.13900835812091827,
-0.2501382827758789,
-0.17198604345321655,
-0.21221821010112762,
-0.03887809440493584,
-0.6393395066261292,
0.6717784404754639,
0.4281664788722992,
-0.20043541491031647,
-0.019869310781359673,
-0.4656330347061157,
0.7927681803703308,
0.3674365282058716,
-0.8510599136352539,
0.12455972284078598,
0.46952059864997864,
0.4619976282119751,
0.20370100438594818,
0.7730206847190857,
-0.16899432241916656,
0.05290699377655983,
0.01957230269908905,
0.428075909614563,
0.30255231261253357,
-0.47487446665763855,
-0.694678008556366,
0.5698469281196594,
0.3753882646560669,
-0.2636829912662506
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07339v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07339v1
|
IM-Unpack: Training and Inference with Arbitrarily Low Precision Integers
| 2024-03-12T05:44:27 | 2024-03-12T05:44:27 |
Zhanpeng Zeng, Karthikeyan Sankaralingam, Vikas Singh
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
GEneral Matrix Multiply (GEMM) is a central operation in deep learning and
corresponds to the largest chunk of the compute footprint. Therefore, improving
its efficiency is an active topic of ongoing research. A popular strategy is
the use of low bit-width integers to approximate the original entries in a
matrix. This allows efficiency gains, but often requires sophisticated
techniques to control the rounding error incurred. In this work, we first
verify/check that when the low bit-width restriction is removed, for a variety
of Transformer-based models, whether integers are sufficient for all GEMMs need
-- for {\em both} training and inference stages, and can achieve parity with
floating point counterparts. No sophisticated techniques are needed. We find
that while a large majority of entries in matrices (encountered in such models)
can be easily represented by {\em low} bit-width integers, the existence of a
few heavy hitter entries make it difficult to achieve efficiency gains via the
exclusive use of low bit-width GEMMs alone. To address this issue, we develop a
simple algorithm, Integer Matrix Unpacking (IM-Unpack), to {\em unpack} a
matrix with large integer entries into a larger matrix whose entries all lie
within the representable range of arbitrarily low bit-width integers. This
allows {\em equivalence} with the original GEMM, i.e., the exact result can be
obtained using purely low bit-width integer GEMMs. This comes at the cost of
additional operations -- we show that for many popular models, this overhead is
quite small.
|
[
-0.7977034449577332,
-0.4611436128616333,
0.41609200835227966,
0.06279859691858292,
-0.4527444541454315,
0.15672729909420013,
-0.3106321692466736,
-0.14212441444396973,
-0.017358949407935143,
0.3565381169319153,
-0.3096923232078552,
-0.1521458774805069,
-0.7953500747680664,
0.024131041020154953,
-0.2792368233203888,
0.742618978023529,
0.13132071495056152,
0.19917036592960358,
-0.2220390886068344,
-0.20909622311592102,
0.03507954254746437,
-0.45705631375312805,
-0.09789352118968964,
-0.5460081696510315,
0.3183317184448242,
0.6462556719779968,
0.7565668821334839,
0.41773271560668945,
0.8778054714202881,
0.3983609080314636,
-0.17545609176158905,
0.411121129989624,
-0.21729688346385956,
-0.4379098415374756,
0.05716573819518089,
-0.6116708517074585,
-0.6190543174743652,
0.019227802753448486,
0.9189925789833069,
0.6835828423500061,
-0.36470118165016174,
0.4440906345844269,
-0.09464634209871292,
1.1104317903518677,
-0.7992103099822998,
-0.2005404233932495,
-0.7565200328826904,
0.21207334101200104,
-0.17011898756027222,
0.11503991484642029,
-0.9943645000457764,
-0.24159042537212372,
-0.3714137077331543,
-0.5605521202087402,
0.37658244371414185,
0.04257606714963913,
0.5294428467750549,
0.39493364095687866,
-0.3993822932243347,
-0.027677694335579872,
-0.9624395370483398,
0.8964484333992004,
-0.8357602953910828,
0.20295898616313934,
0.054497383534908295,
0.3933345079421997,
-0.30581098794937134,
-0.5128961801528931,
-0.5465795397758484,
0.20170490443706512,
-0.11728206276893616,
-0.13074564933776855,
-0.6231986284255981,
0.42760658264160156,
0.8380970358848572,
0.794302761554718,
-0.4900033473968506,
0.11061995476484299,
-0.6601306796073914,
0.251032292842865,
0.43527546525001526,
0.020058631896972656,
0.16656821966171265,
0.0030061625875532627,
-0.3861711323261261,
-0.3320130407810211,
-0.7917954921722412,
0.3228120803833008,
0.49400338530540466,
0.09778378903865814,
-0.14873768389225006,
0.843080461025238,
-0.30149388313293457,
0.6062768697738647,
0.3130415081977844,
0.10159178823232651,
0.18550235033035278,
0.2684243321418762,
-0.4326930344104767,
-0.04574768617749214,
0.48578161001205444,
0.07163004577159882,
0.4854658842086792,
-0.11629007756710052,
-0.31799206137657166,
0.0817730501294136,
0.6835771799087524,
-0.971836268901825,
-0.27411991357803345,
0.0970531478524208,
-0.6290621161460876,
-0.0692346841096878,
-0.037295952439308167,
-0.8095333576202393,
-0.2369767278432846,
-0.45818859338760376,
0.7426937222480774,
-0.3097865581512451,
0.1095167025923729,
0.2979385554790497,
0.01291386317461729,
0.12431000918149948,
0.5266379117965698,
-0.8193027377128601,
0.35712170600891113,
0.44601449370384216,
0.7413783669471741,
0.1773226112127304,
0.06363537162542343,
-0.7447349429130554,
-0.24594484269618988,
-0.32218068838119507,
0.6761072874069214,
-0.4822447597980499,
-0.330679327249527,
-0.356733500957489,
-0.2520027458667755,
0.22957611083984375,
-0.4295433461666107,
0.2480333298444748,
-0.5304197669029236,
-0.03773565590381622,
0.021285640075802803,
-0.4035260081291199,
-0.319914847612381,
0.01870080642402172,
-0.5065984725952148,
0.7859742641448975,
0.22685469686985016,
-0.4619944095611572,
0.08836766332387924,
-0.5145543813705444,
-0.08415497839450836,
-0.19270628690719604,
-0.15146195888519287,
-0.6982364058494568,
0.9702405333518982,
0.2517532408237457,
0.10527951270341873,
-0.7199816703796387,
0.09683701395988464,
-0.45987528562545776,
-0.8087143301963806,
0.2676472067832947,
-0.8364932537078857,
0.5793067216873169,
0.1254030019044876,
-0.2080547958612442,
-0.22884494066238403,
-0.7457469701766968,
0.24999645352363586,
-0.09312284737825394,
-0.45861464738845825,
0.01604635640978813,
-0.19926738739013672,
-0.6002638936042786,
0.14776121079921722,
-0.08408445119857788,
-0.5956936478614807,
0.6526686549186707,
-0.05704992264509201,
0.2083868682384491,
0.9033092260360718,
-0.3295372724533081,
0.7951496839523315,
-0.32793572545051575,
0.31088516116142273,
0.10788111388683319,
0.2041642963886261,
-0.044824182987213135,
-0.5186536312103271,
-0.9784786701202393,
-0.49439653754234314,
0.5071545839309692,
0.3334098756313324,
-0.9211993217468262,
0.4414729177951813,
-0.5676207542419434,
-0.6191082000732422,
-0.5193924307823181,
0.09381137043237686,
0.21895545721054077,
0.17085352540016174,
0.5647727847099304,
-0.2647920846939087,
-0.31332242488861084,
-1.0661190748214722,
-0.1657400131225586,
-0.04588627815246582,
-0.18541251122951508,
-0.032545555382966995,
0.39827555418014526,
-0.06693216413259506,
0.655799388885498,
-0.5108646154403687,
-0.03823252394795418,
0.1038818359375,
0.5601658225059509,
0.6521970629692078,
0.7334833145141602,
0.15812872350215912,
-0.5872702598571777,
-0.5477524399757385,
-0.40277403593063354,
-0.6484897136688232,
0.2494463175535202,
-0.06391849368810654,
-0.09683600068092346,
-0.10363933444023132,
0.3392956256866455,
-0.6647530198097229,
0.9157081246376038,
0.31017056107521057,
-0.07118432968854904,
0.2550942599773407,
-0.7910962700843811,
0.043499454855918884,
-0.5504912734031677,
-0.18526697158813477,
0.14728833734989166,
-0.05729315057396889,
-0.6749408841133118,
-0.3588268458843231,
0.39646175503730774,
-0.11712917685508728,
-0.41755855083465576,
0.10607831925153732,
-0.5413013696670532,
-0.18820999562740326,
-0.2152412086725235,
-0.6264351010322571,
0.21077723801136017,
0.802894651889801,
-0.006731186527758837,
0.869678795337677,
0.22126035392284393,
-0.3289938271045685,
-0.02402418851852417,
-0.10108599811792374,
-0.302400678396225,
0.8600374460220337,
-0.6298645734786987,
0.19187501072883606,
-0.522636353969574,
0.35917404294013977,
-0.8801432847976685,
0.16648833453655243,
-0.07422038167715073,
-0.5606173872947693,
0.5639521479606628,
-0.7475558519363403,
-0.5653119683265686,
-0.26472920179367065,
-0.3304571509361267,
0.694779634475708,
1.027574896812439,
-0.8056612014770508,
0.8793001174926758,
0.16450466215610504,
0.24324245750904083,
-0.7826929688453674,
-0.549950897693634,
-0.14406543970108032,
-0.4030286967754364,
-0.5036282539367676,
0.053316980600357056,
-0.2940950095653534,
-0.3686465322971344,
-0.2638247609138489,
-0.07502882927656174,
0.07418031245470047,
0.034253280609846115,
0.22076942026615143,
0.3564821183681488,
-0.33676064014434814,
0.032660845667123795,
0.11053260415792465,
-0.5790907740592957,
0.07596851140260696,
-0.2751234173774719,
0.3288940489292145,
-0.5755130052566528,
-0.6204570531845093,
0.11347999423742294,
0.6243863701820374,
0.6026914119720459,
-0.167083278298378,
0.6492139101028442,
0.9579178690910339,
-0.6073942184448242,
-0.2788706421852112,
-0.5282394886016846,
-0.10796281695365906,
-0.5318858623504639,
0.017679698765277863,
-0.4100390076637268,
-0.530941367149353,
0.3818591237068176,
-0.16217510402202606,
0.007262667641043663,
0.49021390080451965,
0.4412021338939667,
-0.114448681473732,
1.2320818901062012,
0.2263779193162918,
0.4157542586326599,
0.09613275527954102,
-0.5777847170829773,
0.4390944242477417,
-1.1400840282440186,
0.013075954280793667,
-0.5492512583732605,
-0.73685622215271,
-0.5052817463874817,
-0.7925391793251038,
0.47382721304893494,
0.38100531697273254,
-0.5391614437103271,
-0.013225558213889599,
-0.8125701546669006,
0.6376820802688599,
0.7462590932846069,
0.1852879375219345,
0.3120654225349426,
0.3311348557472229,
0.048798978328704834,
-0.09547159075737,
-0.5760388374328613,
-0.31370869278907776,
0.9786457419395447,
0.29752638936042786,
1.299521803855896,
0.4798067808151245,
0.4024699330329895,
0.47203460335731506,
0.45820528268814087,
-0.7456334233283997,
0.3797192871570587,
-0.7175896763801575,
-0.3096219003200531,
-0.023222580552101135,
-0.568545401096344,
-0.5154270529747009,
0.3994320034980774,
-0.3635369539260864,
-1.0064334869384766,
0.6523679494857788,
0.31813016533851624,
-0.40938910841941833,
0.9436525702476501,
-0.9246461391448975,
0.3544224202632904,
0.056208815425634384,
-0.1439152956008911,
-0.1913788616657257,
-0.6217676997184753,
0.5405815839767456,
0.06335457414388657,
0.11306767910718918,
-0.39904096722602844,
0.23338808119297028,
0.48502540588378906,
-0.5224763751029968,
0.6242928504943848,
-0.22990326583385468,
0.20245766639709473,
0.17482887208461761,
0.32409077882766724,
0.801943302154541,
0.15175755321979523,
0.006976189091801643,
0.35551172494888306,
-0.21031688153743744,
-0.6128035187721252,
-0.551364004611969,
0.3279604911804199,
-0.9394571185112,
-0.459915429353714,
-0.45701277256011963,
-0.7408913969993591,
-0.25565382838249207,
0.05260789766907692,
0.5455449223518372,
0.7940195798873901,
0.20455613732337952,
0.5368109345436096,
1.0340224504470825,
0.0288083516061306,
0.586479902267456,
0.4530669152736664,
0.24982406198978424,
-0.5453035831451416,
0.888892650604248,
0.23688988387584686,
0.38855552673339844,
0.503872811794281,
-0.03399406746029854,
-0.29755547642707825,
-0.6901112794876099,
-0.9375362396240234,
0.015303286723792553,
-0.8059751987457275,
-0.45927977561950684,
-0.33709707856178284,
-0.16210901737213135,
-0.024489693343639374,
-0.37179943919181824,
-0.6073935627937317,
-0.6388768553733826,
-0.05236562713980675,
0.30208244919776917,
0.34702563285827637,
0.5342691540718079,
-0.6793797612190247,
0.7799420356750488,
-0.8631927371025085,
0.45211270451545715,
0.4002862274646759,
0.378269225358963,
0.14625899493694305,
-0.5932195782661438,
-0.4335528016090393,
0.18681010603904724,
0.00949309766292572,
-0.49254533648490906,
0.08304336667060852,
0.038474228233098984,
0.35614311695098877,
0.5177122354507446,
0.2741891145706177,
0.4228782057762146,
-0.5155420303344727,
0.3547711670398712,
0.34779074788093567,
-1.005986213684082,
-0.02113267593085766,
-0.12451689690351486,
0.27939945459365845,
0.6463304758071899,
0.1014380231499672,
-0.28621742129325867,
0.14921554923057556,
-0.9240965247154236,
-0.7809495329856873,
0.6861713528633118,
0.35440492630004883,
-0.11479296535253525,
0.2992631196975708,
0.11944185197353363,
-0.0902857556939125,
0.2498367428779602,
-0.5492164492607117,
-0.4408470392227173,
0.026889726519584656,
-0.17757897078990936,
-0.24686960875988007,
-0.32504990696907043,
-0.06672552227973938,
-0.11193876713514328,
0.7802402377128601,
-0.39570143818855286,
0.7048606276512146,
-0.06515312939882278,
-0.4069165587425232,
-0.17089584469795227,
0.4092402756214142,
0.43158596754074097,
0.7132393717765808,
-0.6017886400222778,
0.8736289143562317,
0.3753015995025635,
-0.580714762210846,
0.6634277701377869,
0.08203329145908356,
0.008625521324574947,
-0.17258012294769287,
-0.07869289070367813,
0.5229555368423462,
-0.13866953551769257,
-0.39705803990364075,
0.36610978841781616,
-0.37310990691185,
0.14421413838863373,
-0.16679714620113373,
0.10468104481697083,
-0.1901094913482666,
0.13470539450645447,
0.35106566548347473,
0.4506979286670685,
-0.003724488662555814,
0.039685238152742386,
0.16294682025909424,
0.5799614787101746,
-0.508016049861908,
-0.1776379942893982,
0.28065043687820435,
-0.02922368235886097,
-0.34917116165161133,
1.1631792783737183,
-0.4351056218147278,
-0.238591730594635,
0.6302122473716736,
0.33558493852615356,
0.7493398785591125,
0.02209700644016266,
0.09623762965202332,
0.39144545793533325,
0.6646718978881836,
-0.06392577290534973,
0.09779144823551178,
-0.05229227617383003,
-0.7036452889442444,
-0.4163277745246887,
-0.46578800678253174,
-0.38515976071357727,
-0.19006705284118652,
-0.987454891204834,
0.1447916477918625,
-0.3991163969039917,
0.03962824493646622,
0.13707289099693298,
-0.050148673355579376,
-0.7430427670478821,
0.2503821551799774,
0.39633235335350037,
1.0534930229187012,
-0.9212400913238525,
0.8405291438102722,
0.5391815900802612,
-0.11236895620822906,
-0.47273942828178406,
-0.6543294787406921,
0.10374654829502106,
-0.9458778500556946,
0.05000484734773636,
0.22482246160507202,
0.03132317587733269,
0.0756085142493248,
-0.4544565677642822,
-0.5720994472503662,
0.8656776547431946,
0.33527642488479614,
-0.30615612864494324,
-0.05873006582260132,
0.5692734122276306,
0.11359735578298569,
-0.2649383246898651,
0.6830635070800781,
0.5446117520332336,
0.4221181571483612,
0.14056238532066345,
-0.3290383815765381,
-0.0704898089170456,
-0.5117736458778381,
0.0695689246058464,
0.7559754848480225,
-0.4393637180328369,
1.1605467796325684,
-0.23404301702976227,
0.23576760292053223,
-0.17471449077129364,
0.582017183303833,
0.2824977934360504,
-0.021479129791259766,
0.7973887920379639,
1.0855275392532349,
0.6591745018959045,
-0.26448655128479004,
0.8334698677062988,
-0.08949413895606995,
0.5797642469406128,
0.882720947265625,
0.37047505378723145,
0.542544960975647,
0.47626641392707825,
-0.4997580051422119,
0.12363391369581223,
0.6957951784133911,
-0.06600309163331985,
0.28823110461235046,
0.35162782669067383,
-0.39446669816970825,
-0.6598520278930664,
0.03031495027244091,
-0.3136775493621826,
0.08634957671165466,
0.5699260830879211,
-0.11885174363851547,
-0.5692886114120483,
-0.11121568828821182,
0.029568281024694443,
-0.41947975754737854,
-0.4193102717399597,
0.7146670818328857,
0.20742680132389069,
-0.4649370014667511,
0.5428907871246338,
0.09023813903331757,
0.6882451176643372,
-0.4811801016330719,
-0.2669204771518707,
-0.23804277181625366,
0.46003833413124084,
-0.1704222410917282,
-0.7110982537269592,
0.2852550446987152,
-0.0411251038312912,
-0.50537109375,
-0.05068850517272949,
0.8066345453262329,
-0.22714027762413025,
-0.7610948085784912,
-0.1979524940252304,
0.42060235142707825,
0.11853872984647751,
-0.39513909816741943,
-0.4430401027202606,
-0.19994278252124786,
0.09910549968481064,
-0.03704394772648811,
0.434611439704895,
0.45457151532173157,
0.11126744747161865,
0.3441036641597748,
0.8460534811019897,
-0.07520902901887894,
0.09859573841094971,
-0.3970126211643219,
0.7225486636161804,
-0.49334511160850525,
-0.3219677209854126,
-0.8452655076980591,
0.8938887119293213,
0.0865507423877716,
-0.23088513314723969,
0.36213403940200806,
0.5800731778144836,
0.3895348310470581,
-0.04512917995452881,
0.4860970079898834,
0.038685113191604614,
0.012035601772367954,
-0.3865702152252197,
0.3195645809173584,
-0.42137202620506287,
0.2942059636116028,
0.0014139700215309858,
-0.9047605395317078,
-0.17110177874565125,
0.5050337910652161,
-0.22740276157855988,
-0.18941794335842133,
0.29206302762031555,
0.5879549384117126,
-0.40798795223236084,
-0.030498988926410675,
0.2475372701883316,
-0.10269863158464432,
0.4867713451385498,
0.7350058555603027,
0.9400706887245178,
-0.4601600170135498,
0.32250121235847473,
-0.623955249786377,
-0.2845304608345032,
-0.19514837861061096,
-0.9857929944992065,
-0.6681720018386841,
-0.26297903060913086,
-0.21926669776439667,
-0.5692298412322998,
-0.3500407338142395,
1.0173125267028809,
0.8829498887062073,
-0.5460060238838196,
-0.028056824579834938,
0.04908031225204468,
0.4708581268787384,
0.07745403796434402,
-0.08848222345113754,
0.3557148873806,
-0.11516616493463516,
-0.7216588854789734,
0.12296842038631439,
0.2963593006134033,
0.43083012104034424,
-0.2541027069091797,
0.023509861901402473,
-0.07159509509801865,
0.331059068441391,
0.44604647159576416,
0.1685805469751358,
-0.33557838201522827,
-0.2842596769332886,
0.057339511811733246,
0.16267000138759613,
0.6309942603111267,
0.8436936736106873,
-0.7588458061218262,
0.5909438729286194,
0.6611788272857666,
0.48443934321403503,
0.6145240068435669,
0.12474443763494492,
0.5760719776153564,
-0.748912513256073,
0.1701837033033371,
0.062178827822208405,
0.5564054250717163,
0.2034367173910141,
-0.22483335435390472,
0.6600499153137207,
0.0012994927819818258,
-0.5771557092666626,
-0.9274275898933411,
-0.08214457333087921,
-1.039528250694275,
-0.0959969237446785,
0.9052552580833435,
-0.1305685043334961,
-0.17339321970939636,
0.24433963000774384,
0.12859034538269043,
0.02306395024061203,
-0.38421308994293213,
0.6735421419143677,
0.46151769161224365,
-0.2974563539028168,
0.06301841139793396,
-0.3405795991420746,
0.46524325013160706,
0.17270882427692413,
-0.6415778994560242,
-0.15042351186275482,
-0.038966190069913864,
-0.09866613894701004,
0.47155511379241943,
0.40571510791778564,
-0.008378643542528152,
0.2956012785434723,
0.031674981117248535,
0.35909995436668396,
-0.04535229504108429,
-0.3017819821834564,
-0.5872756242752075,
-0.08275666832923889,
0.17629612982273102,
-0.18450748920440674
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07321v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07321v1
|
GPT-generated Text Detection: Benchmark Dataset and Tensor-based Detection Method
| 2024-03-12T05:15:21 | 2024-03-12T05:15:21 |
Zubair Qazi, William Shiao, Evangelos E. Papalexakis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As natural language models like ChatGPT become increasingly prevalent in
applications and services, the need for robust and accurate methods to detect
their output is of paramount importance. In this paper, we present GPT Reddit
Dataset (GRiD), a novel Generative Pretrained Transformer (GPT)-generated text
detection dataset designed to assess the performance of detection models in
identifying generated responses from ChatGPT. The dataset consists of a diverse
collection of context-prompt pairs based on Reddit, with human-generated and
ChatGPT-generated responses. We provide an analysis of the dataset's
characteristics, including linguistic diversity, context complexity, and
response quality. To showcase the dataset's utility, we benchmark several
detection methods on it, demonstrating their efficacy in distinguishing between
human and ChatGPT-generated responses. This dataset serves as a resource for
evaluating and advancing detection techniques in the context of ChatGPT and
contributes to the ongoing efforts to ensure responsible and trustworthy
AI-driven communication on the internet. Finally, we propose GpTen, a novel
tensor-based GPT text detection method that is semi-supervised in nature since
it only has access to human-generated text and performs on par with
fully-supervised baselines.
|
[
-0.5114849209785461,
-1.0055749416351318,
0.23891055583953857,
-0.009849646128714085,
-0.3533235788345337,
0.10914527624845505,
-0.30934056639671326,
-0.2835363745689392,
0.02162793092429638,
0.1532374769449234,
-0.5821712017059326,
-0.6281429529190063,
-0.633100152015686,
0.3438085913658142,
-0.7778864502906799,
1.2420756816864014,
-0.12123830616474152,
-0.438705712556839,
-0.08489179611206055,
0.25112631916999817,
-0.5026326179504395,
-0.26303401589393616,
-0.7053483724594116,
-0.09684186428785324,
0.24080178141593933,
0.2217210978269577,
0.5038591623306274,
0.24956440925598145,
0.5012274980545044,
0.34270399808883667,
0.13483037054538727,
0.12178549915552139,
-0.7113576531410217,
0.10586396604776382,
0.16940650343894958,
-0.19197140634059906,
-0.17253509163856506,
-0.014135115779936314,
0.597441554069519,
-0.24170640110969543,
-0.11470742523670197,
0.2712094187736511,
0.18096597492694855,
0.2939567565917969,
-0.5696906447410583,
0.10479040443897247,
-0.7025166153907776,
0.10695718973875046,
-0.41853100061416626,
-0.13475510478019714,
-0.4518106281757355,
-0.31514519453048706,
-0.03989426791667938,
-0.5860410332679749,
0.7571029663085938,
-0.0634549930691719,
0.9589675068855286,
0.0691552609205246,
-0.2928744852542877,
-0.45539358258247375,
-0.4057677686214447,
0.5047195553779602,
-0.43614596128463745,
0.28344184160232544,
0.33918967843055725,
0.6577497720718384,
-0.09891895204782486,
-1.1385126113891602,
-0.7889592051506042,
-0.07485909014940262,
-0.5196719765663147,
0.23136968910694122,
-0.35989925265312195,
-0.21661821007728577,
0.0860208049416542,
0.5201455950737,
-1.0923980474472046,
-0.08750927448272705,
0.07322549819946289,
-0.4287872016429901,
0.4311244487762451,
0.10887660831212997,
0.7626078128814697,
-0.27873891592025757,
-0.26912012696266174,
-0.2350800633430481,
-0.4877281188964844,
-0.4114786982536316,
0.530261754989624,
0.14385540783405304,
-0.24111308157444,
0.3384459316730499,
-0.234546959400177,
0.7726744413375854,
-0.33340194821357727,
0.09358017891645432,
0.13410405814647675,
-0.5588446855545044,
-0.06451602280139923,
-0.11193891614675522,
1.274076223373413,
0.28640979528427124,
0.5807647109031677,
-0.17217764258384705,
-0.3721201419830322,
0.4104016125202179,
0.2815783619880676,
-0.8937416076660156,
-0.4447980523109436,
-0.23066139221191406,
-0.5633542537689209,
-0.5851511359214783,
-0.023196760565042496,
-0.9027653932571411,
-0.37577489018440247,
-0.11594413220882416,
0.07198255509138107,
-0.14059144258499146,
-0.6623991131782532,
0.12957502901554108,
-0.07839355617761612,
0.12565699219703674,
0.04011736810207367,
-0.9025539755821228,
0.25712668895721436,
0.7806608080863953,
0.9059293866157532,
-0.2899196147918701,
-0.1751195192337036,
-0.36352288722991943,
-0.3271912932395935,
-0.04212703928351402,
1.2342408895492554,
-0.5566067099571228,
-0.3421252369880676,
0.1474851816892624,
-0.10874633491039276,
-0.06924638152122498,
-0.42963990569114685,
0.9084485769271851,
-0.5313819646835327,
0.5037891268730164,
-0.15106584131717682,
-0.4277617335319519,
0.32267239689826965,
0.4750523865222931,
-0.6536851525306702,
1.0925023555755615,
0.17401745915412903,
-1.2463661432266235,
0.5682017803192139,
-0.9124079346656799,
-0.46537283062934875,
0.4142470359802246,
-0.160267174243927,
-0.6775965094566345,
-0.15015162527561188,
0.5015988349914551,
0.5219808220863342,
-0.37240296602249146,
0.2292003631591797,
-0.10872673988342285,
-0.45700669288635254,
0.3074367642402649,
-0.8886985182762146,
0.3574327826499939,
0.2991946041584015,
-0.28588002920150757,
0.13007529079914093,
-0.7669169902801514,
0.1911267638206482,
0.3617730438709259,
-0.09309595078229904,
-0.10374768078327179,
-0.0775720477104187,
0.6000350713729858,
0.07956131547689438,
0.07394026964902878,
-0.7308850884437561,
-0.034613773226737976,
0.1311510056257248,
0.7076441645622253,
0.5937223434448242,
-0.027852540835738182,
-0.026521863415837288,
-0.13836298882961273,
0.5860217213630676,
-0.05591076612472534,
0.02914631925523281,
-0.3194808065891266,
-0.5439292788505554,
-0.37682750821113586,
-0.23912686109542847,
0.26029491424560547,
0.4423251748085022,
-1.0376710891723633,
0.3156053423881531,
-0.5050607919692993,
-0.38396376371383667,
-0.4186418056488037,
-0.18401581048965454,
0.30864647030830383,
0.6307939887046814,
0.31231367588043213,
-0.023789558559656143,
-0.5398647785186768,
-0.8611509799957275,
-0.6490565538406372,
-0.26373350620269775,
-0.3492774963378906,
0.1886514574289322,
0.5260844230651855,
-0.41455143690109253,
1.021135926246643,
-0.6156740784645081,
-0.11645152419805527,
-0.09320533275604248,
0.6394681930541992,
0.07521037012338638,
0.15429912507534027,
0.4304243326187134,
-1.0718716382980347,
-0.9278306365013123,
0.005436012987047434,
-0.7136712670326233,
-0.3686659038066864,
0.019229067489504814,
0.05051072686910629,
-0.12332838773727417,
0.3993374705314636,
-0.4955517053604126,
0.4731666147708893,
0.44008657336235046,
-0.43976613879203796,
0.635614812374115,
0.08538413792848587,
0.3464888036251068,
-1.29976487159729,
0.06274250149726868,
0.273512601852417,
-0.5881124138832092,
-0.720827043056488,
-0.37712252140045166,
0.1590430587530136,
-0.2817305326461792,
-0.26387977600097656,
0.49869218468666077,
-0.2913670241832733,
-0.06504956632852554,
-0.44430792331695557,
0.19880540668964386,
-0.11198042333126068,
0.340796560049057,
0.03287217393517494,
1.3318212032318115,
0.17886759340763092,
-0.2542506754398346,
0.5056059956550598,
0.37439703941345215,
-0.5570741891860962,
0.708025336265564,
-0.8900190591812134,
0.2792368233203888,
-0.1715206354856491,
0.21858036518096924,
-1.259686827659607,
-0.2223721742630005,
0.3747875392436981,
-0.6635483503341675,
0.08550208061933517,
-0.24028727412223816,
-0.7670943737030029,
-0.38750529289245605,
-0.07787371426820755,
0.3355730473995209,
0.31621959805488586,
-0.5162224173545837,
0.21505936980247498,
0.3186247646808624,
-0.24033156037330627,
-0.43712207674980164,
-0.4853615462779999,
0.2824532389640808,
-0.14564239978790283,
-0.5732331871986389,
0.2811726927757263,
0.15073363482952118,
0.1310664266347885,
0.09493079781532288,
0.12148154526948929,
-0.18554185330867767,
0.10038074105978012,
-0.04761075973510742,
0.17224252223968506,
-0.2079734057188034,
0.060484834015369415,
-0.19494220614433289,
-0.44398751854896545,
0.024374129250645638,
-0.24466857314109802,
0.8096092343330383,
-0.34111738204956055,
-0.3596600592136383,
-0.566907525062561,
0.23333348333835602,
0.4975556433200836,
-0.1975664347410202,
0.35937386751174927,
1.1887755393981934,
-0.17670994997024536,
-0.009098022244870663,
-0.3386166989803314,
-0.34728094935417175,
-0.4908333420753479,
0.4562973082065582,
-0.25068068504333496,
-0.9941545128822327,
0.4416382908821106,
0.23571300506591797,
-0.0968000665307045,
0.3558460772037506,
0.7334111332893372,
0.2080095112323761,
0.9303592443466187,
0.2584684193134308,
-0.3127039968967438,
0.6507919430732727,
0.0880780816078186,
0.3692552447319031,
-0.5783231258392334,
0.2866332232952118,
-0.5523517727851868,
-0.28423330187797546,
-0.9357308745384216,
0.013816388323903084,
0.11810898035764694,
-0.46664461493492126,
-0.2950340807437897,
0.4545735716819763,
-0.8186377882957458,
0.7940701842308044,
0.4707794189453125,
0.09296204149723053,
0.3886105716228485,
-0.12109500914812088,
0.2089480310678482,
0.026768093928694725,
-0.4391867220401764,
-0.5819567441940308,
1.1681631803512573,
0.18618707358837128,
0.6909576654434204,
-0.12775243818759918,
0.4035213887691498,
0.6295674443244934,
0.7193241715431213,
-0.4601326882839203,
0.4141804873943329,
0.03885239362716675,
-0.319364458322525,
-0.06539375334978104,
-0.6939003467559814,
-1.0225261449813843,
0.21518579125404358,
-0.17224539816379547,
-0.6244500279426575,
-0.3677418828010559,
-0.0455646812915802,
0.09309986978769302,
0.27249839901924133,
-0.9691527485847473,
1.0725338459014893,
0.024914516136050224,
-0.20869825780391693,
0.24316184222698212,
-0.3837577700614929,
0.28991830348968506,
0.12567120790481567,
-0.19764263927936554,
-0.09554272145032883,
0.21134480834007263,
0.6608031392097473,
-0.08451694250106812,
0.7793310284614563,
-0.14205394685268402,
-0.049123335629701614,
0.38198384642601013,
-0.08952086418867111,
0.6918010711669922,
0.39070239663124084,
0.46560296416282654,
0.11249111592769623,
-0.2839353382587433,
-0.2860740125179291,
-0.3458952307701111,
0.5916974544525146,
-0.7173375487327576,
-0.2330993115901947,
-0.26391229033470154,
-0.42104828357696533,
-0.1284237802028656,
0.523697555065155,
0.8102626204490662,
0.42419159412384033,
-0.3837440311908722,
0.11058150231838226,
0.40125587582588196,
-0.07609473168849945,
0.45110926032066345,
0.39795103669166565,
-0.19838310778141022,
-0.3954493999481201,
0.8447535037994385,
-0.3957282602787018,
-0.15304625034332275,
0.3589068055152893,
-0.017620166763663292,
-0.49556872248649597,
-0.5032811164855957,
-0.4573303163051605,
-0.05440877005457878,
-0.42633718252182007,
-0.3874247670173645,
-0.5407729148864746,
-0.24714386463165283,
-0.320475697517395,
0.06272419542074203,
-0.3720766007900238,
0.2522013485431671,
-0.23880474269390106,
0.05855153873562813,
0.28105083107948303,
0.7046527862548828,
0.41418418288230896,
0.4913434386253357,
-0.6843645572662354,
0.48117929697036743,
0.3774648904800415,
0.47159135341644287,
-0.259784996509552,
-0.06130533292889595,
0.08990280330181122,
0.27336013317108154,
-0.31931284070014954,
-0.5136075615882874,
0.46717578172683716,
0.06018044799566269,
0.33722826838493347,
0.32122159004211426,
0.09480331093072891,
0.22358030080795288,
-0.4785469174385071,
0.6478459239006042,
0.08422243595123291,
-0.7211594581604004,
0.4042666256427765,
-0.592495322227478,
0.31556791067123413,
0.37717169523239136,
0.1510162055492401,
-0.9582589268684387,
-0.26687225699424744,
-0.44145601987838745,
-0.4688166379928589,
0.4991731345653534,
0.6619725823402405,
0.3035827577114105,
-0.08270625025033951,
0.22810648381710052,
0.04407282546162605,
0.11062650382518768,
-0.7287411689758301,
0.0009529876988381147,
-0.4388769268989563,
-0.4631233215332031,
0.028163965791463852,
-0.1937413513660431,
-0.010659228079020977,
0.2103833258152008,
0.3906998634338379,
-0.256152868270874,
0.7177602052688599,
-0.01663212850689888,
-0.267735093832016,
0.19105884432792664,
0.34626004099845886,
0.7755641937255859,
0.4818686246871948,
0.01319645531475544,
0.018004639074206352,
-0.17760160565376282,
-0.9752867817878723,
0.09507075697183609,
0.18033280968666077,
-0.06542359292507172,
0.15269680321216583,
0.4168836772441864,
0.7912523150444031,
-0.05757233873009682,
-0.4316951334476471,
0.7407627701759338,
-0.8129273653030396,
-0.12361304461956024,
-0.09138481318950653,
-0.02546573244035244,
-0.09714032709598541,
-0.016084343194961548,
0.3252705931663513,
-0.032406847923994064,
0.20490971207618713,
-0.0005623787292279303,
0.45144209265708923,
0.40455856919288635,
-0.35809218883514404,
-0.5052816271781921,
0.6840165853500366,
0.2430371344089508,
-0.4543215036392212,
0.7561639547348022,
-0.20956571400165558,
-0.784781813621521,
0.5232870578765869,
0.6374472379684448,
1.1123238801956177,
0.1902763545513153,
0.554978609085083,
0.2421903908252716,
0.17231564223766327,
-0.06088818609714508,
-0.10421733558177948,
-0.3269107937812805,
-1.126438021659851,
-0.28411611914634705,
-0.3511570394039154,
-0.2965231239795685,
0.46104663610458374,
-0.6512285470962524,
0.39845308661460876,
0.014331912621855736,
-0.2555679678916931,
-0.017681293189525604,
-0.10013419389724731,
-0.6267512440681458,
-0.02824416570365429,
0.05800798535346985,
0.5906399488449097,
-0.9801482558250427,
0.5852470397949219,
0.6154850721359253,
-0.039749372750520706,
-0.2740970253944397,
0.29924505949020386,
0.052808891981840134,
-0.8953104615211487,
0.37223660945892334,
0.3576186001300812,
0.06200942397117615,
0.18457646667957306,
-0.4724058508872986,
-0.2942520081996918,
0.969770610332489,
0.2882651388645172,
-0.27417418360710144,
0.25334298610687256,
0.43368133902549744,
0.6151168942451477,
0.02032351866364479,
0.6834472417831421,
0.5224107503890991,
0.45244187116622925,
-0.15408852696418762,
-0.8472751975059509,
-0.07848236709833145,
-0.5843144655227661,
0.12453735619783401,
0.5229889750480652,
-0.3840101659297943,
0.7823315262794495,
0.5443975329399109,
-0.5220152735710144,
-0.17709602415561676,
0.5880335569381714,
0.09567593038082123,
0.21216139197349548,
0.36265164613723755,
0.6897643208503723,
0.6848389506340027,
-0.27194783091545105,
1.010637879371643,
-0.18815124034881592,
0.8575056791305542,
0.8275468349456787,
-0.09449158608913422,
0.47655579447746277,
0.06929260492324829,
-0.18539385497570038,
0.3377412259578705,
0.6406103372573853,
-0.017208388075232506,
0.6093138456344604,
0.09140761196613312,
-0.6185621023178101,
-0.03366833180189133,
-0.015735270455479622,
-0.4508192241191864,
0.3659556806087494,
0.19136159121990204,
-0.259766161441803,
-0.7249675393104553,
0.03274262323975563,
0.1485075205564499,
0.09915091097354889,
-0.21586348116397858,
0.8726653456687927,
-0.2511625289916992,
-0.601048469543457,
0.6821439266204834,
-0.17163296043872833,
1.0017447471618652,
-0.3701978623867035,
0.09353375434875488,
-0.2887289822101593,
0.328767865896225,
-0.02148759365081787,
-0.9183148741722107,
0.1549367606639862,
0.2628357410430908,
0.02418312430381775,
-0.23882770538330078,
1.4442976713180542,
-0.37973204255104065,
-0.26310965418815613,
-0.26097187399864197,
0.3218717873096466,
-0.16682513058185577,
-0.2323952317237854,
-0.6335077285766602,
-0.08673173189163208,
-0.18161994218826294,
-0.3286753296852112,
0.34096112847328186,
0.6355034708976746,
0.07159097492694855,
0.5830264687538147,
0.6355184316635132,
-0.22802838683128357,
-0.20157235860824585,
-0.12270636856555939,
0.9274300932884216,
-0.22871911525726318,
-0.6633923053741455,
-0.970141589641571,
0.3014180660247803,
-0.4788118600845337,
-0.5323179364204407,
0.6208507418632507,
0.5822196006774902,
0.8523423671722412,
-0.29579484462738037,
1.0181756019592285,
0.007582629099488258,
0.45901745557785034,
-0.39630427956581116,
1.0244169235229492,
-0.06828143447637558,
0.0883353054523468,
-0.16933639347553253,
-0.864064633846283,
-0.29581621289253235,
0.6136487722396851,
-0.4223771393299103,
0.16856613755226135,
0.6443231701850891,
0.8529739379882812,
-0.32654568552970886,
0.4780993163585663,
0.2583615481853485,
-0.23344773054122925,
0.6827437877655029,
0.5801874995231628,
0.9383722543716431,
-0.6669097542762756,
0.6320175528526306,
0.17634455859661102,
-0.009870650246739388,
-0.19946260750293732,
-1.01299250125885,
-1.03567636013031,
-0.691066563129425,
-0.18077316880226135,
-0.21003320813179016,
-0.032999902963638306,
0.41796815395355225,
0.5366212129592896,
-0.9582231044769287,
0.11321479082107544,
-0.6438770294189453,
0.0017337603494524956,
0.050331976264715195,
-0.3029717206954956,
0.38633450865745544,
-0.477372944355011,
-0.7165830135345459,
0.02207978069782257,
0.07466454803943634,
0.1670675426721573,
-0.06905804574489594,
0.18283642828464508,
-0.024242734536528587,
-0.42390209436416626,
0.46085700392723083,
0.3312228322029114,
-0.1192927286028862,
-0.4178885817527771,
0.028643399477005005,
-0.21589677035808563,
0.0725565254688263,
1.0321054458618164,
-0.7194607853889465,
0.3231014609336853,
0.7266536951065063,
0.8120495080947876,
0.5828065872192383,
0.06573772430419922,
0.49989834427833557,
-1.0183535814285278,
0.21296827495098114,
0.267055869102478,
0.1892487108707428,
0.375712513923645,
-0.38041064143180847,
0.48406538367271423,
0.436199426651001,
-0.7883524298667908,
-0.8297492265701294,
0.15979261696338654,
-0.5416392087936401,
0.08430946618318558,
1.1430621147155762,
-0.21904002130031586,
-0.13627277314662933,
-0.35664477944374084,
-0.3465336263179779,
0.1852981150150299,
-0.4561189115047455,
0.7969303727149963,
0.7230620384216309,
0.19170138239860535,
-0.34243473410606384,
-0.5524570941925049,
0.6181466579437256,
0.0729658454656601,
-1.1872327327728271,
0.2819077670574188,
0.2741435766220093,
0.2033722698688507,
-0.10293864458799362,
0.5839568376541138,
-0.03400782123208046,
0.15884751081466675,
-0.08359139412641525,
0.04346831515431404,
-0.1711931824684143,
0.005538887344300747,
0.12192894518375397,
0.22379715740680695,
-0.3751699924468994,
-0.3644142746925354
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07311v6
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07311v6
|
Knowledge Graph Large Language Model (KG-LLM) for Link Prediction
| 2024-03-12T04:47:29 | 2024-06-28T22:03:33 |
Dong Shu, Tianle Chen, Mingyu Jin, Chong Zhang, Mengnan Du, Yongfeng Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The task of multi-hop link prediction within knowledge graphs (KGs) stands as
a challenge in the field of knowledge graph analysis, as it requires the model
to reason through and understand all intermediate connections before making a
prediction. In this paper, we introduce the Knowledge Graph Large Language
Model (KG-LLM), a novel framework that leverages large language models (LLMs)
for knowledge graph tasks. We first convert structured knowledge graph data
into natural language and then use these natural language prompts to fine-tune
LLMs to enhance multi-hop link prediction in KGs. By converting the KG to
natural language prompts, our framework is designed to learn the latent
representations of entities and their interrelations. To show the efficacy of
the KG-LLM Framework, we fine-tune three leading LLMs within this framework,
including Flan-T5, LLaMa2 and Gemma. Further, we explore the framework's
potential to provide LLMs with zero-shot capabilities for handling previously
unseen prompts. Experimental results show that KG-LLM significantly improves
the models' generalization capabilities, leading to more accurate predictions
in unfamiliar scenarios.
|
[
-0.4877725839614868,
-0.8061865568161011,
0.6593457460403442,
-0.015659045428037643,
-0.11999014765024185,
0.153828427195549,
-0.1118106096982956,
-0.5759919285774231,
0.20141810178756714,
0.5084124207496643,
-0.5965902805328369,
-0.6183213591575623,
-0.6798949837684631,
0.2732776701450348,
-0.021956712007522583,
0.7821343541145325,
-0.023021196946501732,
-0.03452399745583534,
-0.14798779785633087,
0.06823351979255676,
-0.5558692216873169,
-0.19800104200839996,
-0.7776234745979309,
-0.5680258274078369,
1.013905644416809,
0.25398319959640503,
0.7782829403877258,
0.5996882319450378,
0.20865243673324585,
0.23458394408226013,
-0.1577882170677185,
0.20634634792804718,
-0.6291218400001526,
0.11579881608486176,
0.0662301555275917,
-0.3933984041213989,
-0.48626288771629333,
-0.11942040920257568,
0.7553618550300598,
1.0750879049301147,
0.2747134864330292,
-0.06074371933937073,
-0.11646831780672073,
0.7363060116767883,
-0.2252955138683319,
0.5675876140594482,
-0.6332497000694275,
0.056414611637592316,
-0.07774854451417923,
-0.0378664955496788,
-0.5591514110565186,
-0.3314821124076843,
0.2574746906757355,
-0.6161792874336243,
-0.31448468565940857,
0.4723365008831024,
0.4265216886997223,
0.010401392355561256,
-0.8892669081687927,
-0.17717953026294708,
-0.4989113211631775,
0.5036953687667847,
-0.5900194644927979,
0.7677109837532043,
0.3647502064704895,
0.6257573962211609,
-0.6103777885437012,
-0.6662207841873169,
-0.5345852375030518,
-0.4477664828300476,
-0.12972190976142883,
-0.20388378202915192,
-0.05949949473142624,
0.24303500354290009,
0.2547479271888733,
0.005197370424866676,
-0.3932282328605652,
0.276793509721756,
-0.240906223654747,
-0.27328115701675415,
0.45641353726387024,
0.3081788718700409,
0.2860157787799835,
-0.11603903025388718,
-0.2917427718639374,
0.07899239659309387,
-0.8052794337272644,
-0.034912217408418655,
0.526313066482544,
0.6120004653930664,
-0.16457781195640564,
0.6790673136711121,
-0.5908303260803223,
1.1488854885101318,
-0.10022979974746704,
-0.4600844979286194,
0.2311515212059021,
0.0703551322221756,
-0.06516795605421066,
0.04906656965613365,
0.8769002556800842,
0.33536896109580994,
0.4926011860370636,
-0.6255189776420593,
0.16357456147670746,
-0.22599361836910248,
-0.12856245040893555,
-0.8642046451568604,
-0.4217466413974762,
0.015177241526544094,
-0.2832936644554138,
-0.2515585422515869,
-0.3193805515766144,
-0.5427858233451843,
-0.5629252791404724,
-0.22987152636051178,
0.27052411437034607,
-0.6694376468658447,
-0.15192994475364685,
0.13593944907188416,
-0.01850508525967598,
-0.07032594084739685,
0.4707692563533783,
-0.6090412139892578,
-0.07365402579307556,
0.40263691544532776,
0.6568007469177246,
-0.05548492819070816,
-0.4753880500793457,
-0.7179573774337769,
0.5946786999702454,
-0.3124742805957794,
0.6324387788772583,
-0.6799107789993286,
-0.21008172631263733,
-0.018836868926882744,
-0.054623477160930634,
-0.03502622991800308,
-0.19786545634269714,
0.31649649143218994,
-1.0119094848632812,
-0.02295871265232563,
-0.2845432162284851,
-0.7783896923065186,
-0.5174016356468201,
0.6597403287887573,
-0.8049832582473755,
0.6170495748519897,
0.11637971550226212,
-0.7755672931671143,
0.26433008909225464,
-0.687585711479187,
-0.5848243832588196,
0.05087551474571228,
0.04545280337333679,
-0.12257690727710724,
-0.2983839511871338,
0.2578800916671753,
0.705799400806427,
-0.4873986840248108,
0.4525299370288849,
-0.7548759579658508,
0.03622012212872505,
0.04961739853024483,
-0.34699633717536926,
0.43335261940956116,
0.12704922258853912,
0.3296360671520233,
0.08156891912221909,
-0.8490700721740723,
0.03014408051967621,
0.07272232323884964,
-0.5703519582748413,
-0.16295291483402252,
-0.08378913253545761,
-0.4858238995075226,
0.294655442237854,
0.3011499047279358,
-0.4135187864303589,
0.39874324202537537,
-0.49451345205307007,
0.09674514830112457,
0.6041592955589294,
0.004322450142353773,
0.5277042388916016,
-0.13473567366600037,
0.46093571186065674,
0.020079299807548523,
-0.14437463879585266,
-0.20969447493553162,
-0.8031505346298218,
-0.39884600043296814,
-0.053076278418302536,
0.15849623084068298,
0.1968250870704651,
-0.9218193292617798,
0.2075563669204712,
-0.47884601354599,
-0.6090617179870605,
-0.09272578358650208,
0.32606855034828186,
0.14035369455814362,
0.7944560050964355,
0.3790951371192932,
0.17942512035369873,
-0.33045291900634766,
-0.6098554730415344,
-0.3903370797634125,
-0.3314352035522461,
-0.043075449764728546,
0.5354152321815491,
0.19359993934631348,
-0.47835323214530945,
1.1434684991836548,
-0.7230276465415955,
-0.21033267676830292,
-0.4912380874156952,
0.18916456401348114,
0.4982227087020874,
-0.033259499818086624,
0.35676902532577515,
-0.7434269785881042,
-0.7825736403465271,
0.0010057792533189058,
-0.7597928047180176,
-0.04061049595475197,
0.3223207890987396,
0.03914114087820053,
-0.18763570487499237,
0.5296052694320679,
-0.556128978729248,
-0.015743473544716835,
0.6510331630706787,
-0.4917270541191101,
0.6528284549713135,
0.12553751468658447,
-0.029078658670186996,
-1.258496880531311,
-0.06970793753862381,
-0.037541698664426804,
-0.17012283205986023,
-0.6606478691101074,
-0.3122851848602295,
0.10532014071941376,
-0.15704478323459625,
-0.29779985547065735,
0.8687472343444824,
-0.3651648759841919,
-0.05357096716761589,
-0.10780799388885498,
0.1593429297208786,
-0.1117631271481514,
0.4687085449695587,
-0.06061930954456329,
0.5214297771453857,
0.5587170124053955,
-0.6815851926803589,
0.824542760848999,
0.37024348974227905,
-0.16343866288661957,
0.3539646565914154,
-0.4699897766113281,
0.04038885608315468,
-0.2984336316585541,
0.3557015359401703,
-0.9667609333992004,
-0.5112242698669434,
0.13879959285259247,
-0.4510524272918701,
0.5041743516921997,
-0.41904738545417786,
-0.5690487027168274,
-0.662819504737854,
-0.1895754337310791,
0.4294860363006592,
0.14489184319972992,
-0.5561128258705139,
0.8417739868164062,
0.18334701657295227,
-0.021231794729828835,
-0.4929407238960266,
-0.21898600459098816,
0.26579156517982483,
-0.11951052397489548,
-0.9230562448501587,
0.0851912721991539,
-0.24892453849315643,
0.12177694588899612,
0.11226598918437958,
0.21894404292106628,
0.053456198424100876,
0.1649925261735916,
0.30039846897125244,
0.2224910855293274,
-0.09752697497606277,
0.34774839878082275,
-0.20509962737560272,
-0.3315111994743347,
0.11243002861738205,
-0.5391321182250977,
0.7636107206344604,
0.05046461150050163,
-0.45286843180656433,
-0.10840273648500443,
-0.29310479760169983,
0.5929337739944458,
-0.041067417711019516,
0.9368888139724731,
0.6422372460365295,
-0.22438427805900574,
-0.04880816861987114,
-0.5306337475776672,
-0.0684584379196167,
-0.46343037486076355,
0.5913228392601013,
-0.44558629393577576,
-1.198522925376892,
0.434291809797287,
-0.6049412488937378,
-0.5089065432548523,
0.3386710584163666,
0.2346997857093811,
0.02977059967815876,
0.9147372245788574,
0.746376097202301,
-0.6040219068527222,
0.26760706305503845,
-0.12463231384754181,
0.5081692934036255,
-0.8051630854606628,
-0.3945525288581848,
-0.2660769820213318,
-0.1817648559808731,
-0.43110617995262146,
-0.30386433005332947,
0.5618789792060852,
0.6269938349723816,
-0.3952471911907196,
0.33134979009628296,
0.20996783673763275,
0.5227543711662292,
0.30631014704704285,
-0.13415411114692688,
0.3178524971008301,
0.09179051965475082,
-0.5918158888816833,
0.13802702724933624,
-0.857009768486023,
-0.2191295176744461,
1.2380796670913696,
0.4886202812194824,
0.8827604651451111,
0.15352937579154968,
0.4451901614665985,
0.10251855105161667,
0.37926408648490906,
-0.9329445362091064,
0.6019924283027649,
0.09378724545240402,
-0.2888109087944031,
-0.48754262924194336,
-0.6744818687438965,
-0.814110279083252,
-0.254279226064682,
-0.37841796875,
-0.9333399534225464,
-0.48069047927856445,
-0.03809826821088791,
-0.1838691681623459,
0.6551478505134583,
-0.3377373218536377,
0.6918062567710876,
-0.13418757915496826,
-0.14882709085941315,
0.03369281068444252,
-0.5785278677940369,
0.4291147291660309,
-0.26211467385292053,
0.17844481766223907,
-0.3129272758960724,
0.1912263184785843,
0.6699298024177551,
-0.24189245700836182,
0.9509621858596802,
0.05398663878440857,
-0.26682931184768677,
0.34882792830467224,
0.24281124770641327,
1.0028142929077148,
-0.0669950619339943,
-0.2919071912765503,
0.1642545461654663,
-0.5687162280082703,
-0.0461403951048851,
-0.46911701560020447,
0.6680610179901123,
-0.8242800831794739,
-0.3106919527053833,
0.15321369469165802,
-0.819387674331665,
-0.7221624255180359,
0.4586905241012573,
0.03901292383670807,
0.5447669625282288,
-0.012891176156699657,
0.20672884583473206,
0.45706722140312195,
-0.3755357563495636,
0.38861083984375,
0.573776125907898,
-0.48773011565208435,
-0.6033110618591309,
0.6757619976997375,
0.040686462074518204,
0.325776606798172,
0.5947343111038208,
0.28122955560684204,
-0.6714528799057007,
-0.5891292691230774,
-0.40337127447128296,
0.313660591840744,
-0.9116928577423096,
-0.5168097615242004,
-0.8671209812164307,
-0.23052315413951874,
-0.6202861070632935,
-0.10169128328561783,
-0.09308209270238876,
-0.04522765427827835,
-0.07790913432836533,
-0.21552668511867523,
0.5973875522613525,
0.951677680015564,
0.11486858874559402,
0.3947097957134247,
-1.0618430376052856,
0.41528788208961487,
0.4739553928375244,
0.7293041944503784,
0.18102554976940155,
-0.2682739794254303,
-0.24196986854076385,
-0.046119239181280136,
-0.04570077359676361,
-0.9241431951522827,
0.35689282417297363,
0.01212272047996521,
0.5479835271835327,
0.5192447304725647,
0.10768484324216843,
0.5124953985214233,
-0.564067542552948,
0.6270092725753784,
0.713861346244812,
-0.5286483764648438,
0.4385014772415161,
-0.6656742095947266,
0.16158097982406616,
0.11022002249956131,
0.6874575018882751,
-0.6767894625663757,
-0.15886880457401276,
-0.20448046922683716,
-0.6414826512336731,
0.6244142055511475,
-0.14379683136940002,
-0.09511937946081161,
-0.27001097798347473,
0.24266502261161804,
-0.0459337942302227,
0.3218640983104706,
-0.9522979855537415,
-0.32929515838623047,
0.3052309453487396,
-0.26249945163726807,
-0.11464747041463852,
-0.5161409378051758,
0.07609820365905762,
-0.10071474313735962,
0.6210747957229614,
-0.5303317308425903,
0.04892430081963539,
-0.23192813992500305,
-0.005454100668430328,
-0.4629457890987396,
0.21743223071098328,
-0.1022416278719902,
0.628135621547699,
-0.13519753515720367,
0.18190038204193115,
0.4490204453468323,
-0.15386663377285004,
0.07010594755411148,
0.1276516169309616,
-0.07737695425748825,
-0.26425057649612427,
0.5301157236099243,
0.8211153745651245,
0.30306607484817505,
-0.4917328357696533,
0.45446085929870605,
0.21883712708950043,
0.005598035641014576,
-0.051988471299409866,
0.031701765954494476,
0.5956882834434509,
0.4881700575351715,
0.18180887401103973,
-0.16205987334251404,
-0.2133706957101822,
-0.4511328339576721,
0.010239698924124241,
0.5524873733520508,
-0.3705812990665436,
-0.21851150691509247,
0.7145116329193115,
0.15994298458099365,
-0.19727583229541779,
0.5606459379196167,
-0.5187616348266602,
-0.7398362755775452,
0.5575793385505676,
0.7111895680427551,
0.5934053063392639,
-0.11139053851366043,
0.23775580525398254,
0.4874175190925598,
0.11743323504924774,
0.050417374819517136,
0.010560128837823868,
0.2284206598997116,
-1.0355255603790283,
-0.6443294286727905,
-0.940622866153717,
-0.19564729928970337,
0.10649119317531586,
-0.09125497937202454,
0.47955846786499023,
-0.28923702239990234,
0.03725888952612877,
-0.12884241342544556,
0.11545892059803009,
-0.7159429788589478,
0.09118632227182388,
0.2788301706314087,
1.1042132377624512,
-0.7301018238067627,
1.0522608757019043,
0.6595478653907776,
-0.3387801945209503,
-1.1811286211013794,
-0.14760778844356537,
-0.05737387016415596,
-0.8880645036697388,
0.97636479139328,
0.23615281283855438,
-0.16718097031116486,
0.21346798539161682,
-0.3652954697608948,
-1.089753270149231,
1.386110782623291,
0.42907509207725525,
-0.5580806136131287,
-0.07706954330205917,
0.510214626789093,
0.16466811299324036,
-0.4666026532649994,
0.13752904534339905,
0.11373875290155411,
0.5307742357254028,
0.524048388004303,
-0.9345532059669495,
0.05340779945254326,
0.2671056389808655,
-0.05755436792969704,
0.4155644178390503,
-0.4721130132675171,
0.8267128467559814,
-0.44404682517051697,
0.11411846429109573,
-0.08552256226539612,
0.5622867345809937,
0.27955004572868347,
0.35841065645217896,
0.4377288818359375,
0.6590530872344971,
0.8013660907745361,
0.2023240327835083,
0.9271066784858704,
-0.5714213252067566,
0.26726922392845154,
1.0845553874969482,
-0.4170225262641907,
0.6436429619789124,
0.2528758645057678,
-0.2909506559371948,
0.4634285271167755,
0.3092103600502014,
0.14601409435272217,
0.41104239225387573,
0.1049395501613617,
-0.2766895592212677,
-0.35918986797332764,
-0.279404878616333,
-0.3759026527404785,
0.318147212266922,
0.3287722170352936,
-0.27648869156837463,
-0.42008763551712036,
-0.20253346860408783,
0.08596199750900269,
-0.29735445976257324,
-0.6041768789291382,
0.7237472534179688,
0.07687605172395706,
-0.3868301510810852,
0.30191850662231445,
0.09716527163982391,
0.5022622346878052,
-0.9312410950660706,
-0.020946720615029335,
0.06825309991836548,
-0.12900614738464355,
-0.03349408507347107,
-0.7602620720863342,
-0.06031849607825279,
-0.22873298823833466,
-0.13174743950366974,
0.03243440389633179,
1.2768882513046265,
-0.5615499019622803,
-0.4515226483345032,
0.7789024710655212,
0.5978443622589111,
-0.05672147497534752,
-0.17048385739326477,
-0.429559588432312,
-0.2278207391500473,
-0.04048607870936394,
-0.2829737365245819,
0.36611688137054443,
0.7108205556869507,
0.026606183499097824,
1.1064040660858154,
0.7412840723991394,
0.10648299753665924,
0.03735492751002312,
0.04540356248617172,
1.0506908893585205,
-0.7637413144111633,
-0.49554523825645447,
-0.8127310276031494,
0.23364666104316711,
-0.01995878294110298,
0.08200137317180634,
0.6756409406661987,
0.41038134694099426,
0.595554769039154,
0.036451224237680435,
0.797370970249176,
0.14036858081817627,
0.312035471200943,
-0.626022219657898,
0.6867281198501587,
-0.3245464265346527,
0.18397851288318634,
-0.19622588157653809,
-0.9193166494369507,
-0.21686944365501404,
0.16214539110660553,
-0.47542229294776917,
0.186616450548172,
0.5466766953468323,
0.7072768211364746,
-0.09432347118854523,
0.007715779822319746,
0.5601378679275513,
0.4105229079723358,
0.32106465101242065,
0.6870958805084229,
0.7395842671394348,
-0.0698905736207962,
0.7207499742507935,
-0.03860601410269737,
0.07396258413791656,
-0.2110327035188675,
-1.2992318868637085,
-1.1115620136260986,
-0.2912113070487976,
-0.10799843072891235,
-0.37150838971138,
-0.10944203287363052,
0.9491741061210632,
0.5614392757415771,
-0.5337293744087219,
-0.10815253108739853,
-0.11754897236824036,
0.3440309166908264,
0.3896790146827698,
-0.16708257794380188,
0.20565804839134216,
-0.4788811504840851,
-0.2603246867656708,
0.6476956009864807,
0.44919082522392273,
0.10509331524372101,
-0.1307697296142578,
-0.5438422560691833,
-0.16515401005744934,
-0.3114258348941803,
0.8037856817245483,
0.03471239656209946,
-0.5135157108306885,
-0.48041412234306335,
-0.10913176089525223,
0.12720414996147156,
-0.2001951038837433,
0.4540422856807709,
-0.9019590616226196,
0.48868975043296814,
0.35798734426498413,
0.8348668217658997,
0.36285147070884705,
-0.3517674207687378,
0.7068918347358704,
-0.8112266063690186,
-0.10413235425949097,
0.0034289106260985136,
0.5736381411552429,
0.23501352965831757,
-0.28634145855903625,
0.5424137115478516,
0.3060808479785919,
-0.14946766197681427,
-0.39519262313842773,
0.6128877997398376,
-0.7607417106628418,
-0.24994175136089325,
1.4591432809829712,
-0.17037387192249298,
-0.07280633598566055,
-0.22002477943897247,
-0.01991143822669983,
0.3903781771659851,
-0.1910223513841629,
0.4286395311355591,
0.701276421546936,
0.007449788507074118,
0.02091197855770588,
-0.5515151023864746,
0.3400958776473999,
-0.06008246913552284,
-0.639570951461792,
-0.04240376874804497,
0.5821129083633423,
0.4210478663444519,
0.09151643514633179,
0.6421477794647217,
0.1657623052597046,
-0.19124315679073334,
-0.2441512942314148,
-0.1653802990913391,
-0.5171481966972351,
-0.5021685361862183,
0.015567087568342686,
0.3222481906414032,
0.37499329447746277,
0.2717735171318054
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07300v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07300v2
|
CALF: Aligning LLMs for Time Series Forecasting via Cross-modal Fine-Tuning
| 2024-03-12T04:04:38 | 2024-05-23T04:47:29 |
Peiyuan Liu, Hang Guo, Tao Dai, Naiqi Li, Jigang Bao, Xudong Ren, Yong Jiang, Shu-Tao Xia
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Deep learning (e.g., Transformer) has been widely and successfully used in
multivariate time series forecasting (MTSF). Unlike existing methods that focus
on training models from a single modal of time series input, large language
models (LLMs) based MTSF methods with cross-modal text and time series input
have recently shown great superiority, especially with limited temporal data.
However, current LLM-based MTSF methods usually focus on adapting and
fine-tuning LLMs, while neglecting the distribution discrepancy between textual
and temporal input tokens, thus leading to sub-optimal performance. To address
this issue, we propose a novel Cross-Modal LLM Fine-Tuning (CALF) framework for
MTSF by reducing the distribution discrepancy between textual and temporal
data, which mainly consists of the temporal target branch with temporal input
and the textual source branch with aligned textual input. To reduce the
distribution discrepancy, we develop the cross-modal match module to first
align cross-modal input distributions. Additionally, to minimize the modality
distribution gap in both feature and output spaces, feature regularization loss
is developed to align the intermediate features between the two branches for
better weight updates, while output consistency loss is introduced to allow the
output representations of both branches to correspond effectively. Thanks to
the modality alignment, CALF establishes state-of-the-art performance for both
long-term and short-term forecasting tasks with low computational complexity,
and exhibiting favorable few-shot and zero-shot abilities similar to that in
LLMs. Code is available at \url{https://github.com/Hank0626/LLaTA}.
|
[
-0.16773931682109833,
-0.5103023052215576,
0.1907883882522583,
0.23621723055839539,
-0.6300673484802246,
0.24611130356788635,
-0.1709289401769638,
-0.41224995255470276,
0.2323416769504547,
0.08084266632795334,
-0.9033196568489075,
-0.4497396647930145,
-0.4569201171398163,
-0.1611780971288681,
-0.06110115721821785,
0.8582858443260193,
-0.2602950930595398,
0.3051966428756714,
0.17565575242042542,
-0.19641388952732086,
-0.6409017443656921,
-0.05367830768227577,
-0.41382846236228943,
-0.5721995234489441,
0.6578347086906433,
0.0417095422744751,
0.7114424705505371,
1.0463461875915527,
0.3523268401622772,
0.2333695888519287,
0.20474569499492645,
0.6109241247177124,
-0.409159392118454,
0.21703973412513733,
-0.14574028551578522,
-0.3044958710670471,
-0.5390371084213257,
-0.3680146038532257,
0.6854845881462097,
0.5602244734764099,
-0.1339690387248993,
0.4771164655685425,
0.10355694591999054,
0.4727565348148346,
-0.5330444574356079,
0.15449917316436768,
-0.6668076515197754,
0.14810249209403992,
-0.32393336296081543,
-0.645298421382904,
-0.17846815288066864,
-0.05383941903710365,
-0.09133794903755188,
-0.5627776980400085,
0.29700687527656555,
0.4104638993740082,
0.9397299289703369,
0.7117570042610168,
-0.48648566007614136,
0.5370315909385681,
-0.6349868178367615,
0.995374858379364,
-0.8479183912277222,
0.5663446187973022,
0.14014293253421783,
0.4129420220851898,
0.07942406833171844,
-0.2588443458080292,
-0.38987669348716736,
0.34043508768081665,
-0.04438682273030281,
0.016399867832660675,
-0.19866341352462769,
-0.14414912462234497,
-0.1582348495721817,
0.13842548429965973,
-0.5344721674919128,
0.5155944228172302,
-0.027527494356036186,
-0.17454124987125397,
0.36035606265068054,
0.5459169149398804,
-0.4187832772731781,
0.0793047547340393,
-0.7094455361366272,
0.12268604338169098,
-0.6409858465194702,
0.1755487322807312,
0.4546138048171997,
0.5948338508605957,
-0.501185953617096,
0.5541113615036011,
0.046780239790678024,
0.46807944774627686,
0.3408953845500946,
-0.38443049788475037,
0.31994563341140747,
-0.29362136125564575,
-0.6925331950187683,
0.10118710994720459,
0.7590846419334412,
0.6800492405891418,
-0.06346013396978378,
-0.1697036772966385,
-0.22360192239284515,
0.07401242107152939,
-0.027706805616617203,
-0.898842453956604,
0.21456918120384216,
0.055962882936000824,
-0.44794002175331116,
-0.4477030038833618,
-0.2290525883436203,
-0.6747561693191528,
-0.38369548320770264,
-0.7678971290588379,
0.2678678631782532,
-0.14906473457813263,
0.010261394083499908,
0.08969736844301224,
0.09755238890647888,
0.15778394043445587,
0.31266626715660095,
-1.1302309036254883,
0.10006552934646606,
0.7538442015647888,
0.6244293451309204,
-0.3451713025569916,
-0.325290709733963,
-0.7153933048248291,
0.35987240076065063,
-0.2865551710128784,
0.5031651854515076,
-0.5352615118026733,
0.03462732210755348,
0.08079538494348526,
0.26548221707344055,
0.0005703384522348642,
-0.23360846936702728,
0.13275346159934998,
-0.6137686967849731,
0.0697382315993309,
-0.1648627370595932,
-0.15635047852993011,
-0.18260301649570465,
0.38560280203819275,
-0.33614060282707214,
1.0933490991592407,
0.07375415414571762,
-0.7681478261947632,
0.6733478903770447,
-0.16591207683086395,
-0.4952898323535919,
-0.5110321640968323,
-0.02395031973719597,
-0.5664424300193787,
-0.15856851637363434,
0.6910384297370911,
0.8390060067176819,
-0.7914749383926392,
0.5162726044654846,
-0.37692543864250183,
-0.17197568714618683,
0.1956823170185089,
-0.8811716437339783,
0.20108473300933838,
0.11610659211874008,
-0.5088121294975281,
0.4924367666244507,
-0.8059545755386353,
-0.06953053921461105,
-0.11255509406328201,
-0.13634130358695984,
-0.0030819738749414682,
-0.0646677240729332,
0.349362850189209,
-0.09827437251806259,
0.16251905262470245,
-0.4275561273097992,
0.468686044216156,
-0.3918371796607971,
0.5192498564720154,
0.9352982640266418,
-0.3024953603744507,
0.5144954323768616,
-0.6540317535400391,
0.5645056366920471,
0.3044479489326477,
0.27701088786125183,
-0.21999704837799072,
-0.01596638187766075,
-0.5310824513435364,
-0.5089194774627686,
0.34961387515068054,
0.5621368288993835,
-0.6161020398139954,
0.3975059390068054,
-0.50246262550354,
-0.45527195930480957,
-0.3863726556301117,
0.08753502368927002,
0.20498444139957428,
0.632233738899231,
0.5677074790000916,
-0.02925792895257473,
-0.5968411564826965,
-0.7323446869850159,
0.14576144516468048,
0.1874324530363083,
0.13474750518798828,
0.2003062218427658,
0.005222206935286522,
-0.3904573619365692,
0.8254415988922119,
-0.36114564538002014,
-0.38794785737991333,
-0.061570171266794205,
0.03376294672489166,
0.2396712452173233,
0.3589800000190735,
0.6932254433631897,
-0.3601510226726532,
-0.1592470109462738,
0.2106345146894455,
-0.4255691468715668,
-0.264607310295105,
-0.12206117063760757,
0.025885459035634995,
0.3773225247859955,
0.2411179393529892,
-0.23423317074775696,
0.25770390033721924,
0.8613772988319397,
-0.43402743339538574,
0.39276090264320374,
0.015833798795938492,
-0.010502124205231667,
-1.3789342641830444,
-0.04514244571328163,
0.1236434280872345,
-0.5431813597679138,
-0.04987500235438347,
-0.3522951006889343,
0.0650927722454071,
0.052886925637722015,
-0.4863511323928833,
0.502070426940918,
-0.34838199615478516,
0.11096210032701492,
-0.029763609170913696,
-0.18010592460632324,
0.19490642845630646,
0.4981999099254608,
-0.3193323612213135,
0.7169522047042847,
0.46958765387535095,
-0.4204452931880951,
0.3084467947483063,
0.035315919667482376,
-0.19370628893375397,
0.42910799384117126,
-0.49139437079429626,
-0.2310432493686676,
-0.09815947711467743,
0.22816866636276245,
-0.689583957195282,
0.1764756143093109,
0.35567721724510193,
0.02276652120053768,
0.6882631182670593,
-0.25718557834625244,
-0.2973400354385376,
0.0404890738427639,
-0.37812891602516174,
0.8156607747077942,
0.1853758990764618,
-0.5849452614784241,
0.745139479637146,
0.042071059346199036,
-0.04800264164805412,
-1.1597603559494019,
-0.8101965188980103,
-0.16955943405628204,
-0.22056837379932404,
-0.5592238306999207,
0.6836193203926086,
-0.03408825397491455,
0.12514878809452057,
-0.17111535370349884,
-0.2501388490200043,
0.21133600175380707,
-0.22343185544013977,
0.20974260568618774,
0.46278175711631775,
-0.3786037862300873,
0.21000130474567413,
0.28424471616744995,
-0.14070576429367065,
-0.3067499101161957,
-0.35339730978012085,
0.7663884162902832,
0.014620563015341759,
-0.44766324758529663,
-0.5513391494750977,
0.17250694334506989,
0.6363266706466675,
-0.044904328882694244,
0.519565224647522,
1.0331428050994873,
-0.17362505197525024,
-0.20513662695884705,
-0.7576332092285156,
0.0048540011048316956,
-0.48398536443710327,
0.2678056061267853,
-0.1998494267463684,
-0.8106291890144348,
0.4120347201824188,
-0.043339941650629044,
-0.014298828318715096,
0.4677366614341736,
0.6023910641670227,
0.021425588056445122,
0.9002447724342346,
0.7590328454971313,
-0.4262913465499878,
0.6038613319396973,
-0.420064240694046,
0.05228220298886299,
-0.9167525768280029,
-0.3885769844055176,
-0.1911134421825409,
-0.8540372252464294,
-0.3594592809677124,
-0.6407759189605713,
0.11627160012722015,
-0.1088193729519844,
-0.6341956257820129,
0.3073817789554596,
-0.5305988192558289,
0.16027960181236267,
0.33197227120399475,
-0.016516659408807755,
0.2288164645433426,
-0.014935929328203201,
-0.19581779837608337,
-0.3232188820838928,
-0.6351615786552429,
-0.1901635229587555,
0.9636208415031433,
0.5356091260910034,
1.3032392263412476,
-0.12430593371391296,
0.3670932352542877,
0.32899153232574463,
0.18641962110996246,
-0.7845003008842468,
0.18544645607471466,
-0.2657053470611572,
-0.13469550013542175,
-0.252900093793869,
-0.3627346456050873,
-0.9418296217918396,
0.23689822852611542,
-0.32924190163612366,
-0.4621746242046356,
0.47233670949935913,
0.04721800237894058,
-0.24268245697021484,
0.5224690437316895,
-0.44431132078170776,
0.7844171524047852,
-0.4197944700717926,
-0.3380095958709717,
-0.10850760340690613,
-0.7532649040222168,
0.13805991411209106,
-0.009050729684531689,
0.02871372178196907,
-0.5616244673728943,
-0.4316398799419403,
0.3940838873386383,
-0.4379115700721741,
1.158806324005127,
0.05743218958377838,
-0.14286792278289795,
-0.2153087854385376,
0.055361904203891754,
0.5457378029823303,
0.2200896441936493,
-0.20445610582828522,
0.22193904221057892,
0.25133633613586426,
-0.3132123649120331,
-0.3855229914188385,
0.695276141166687,
-0.936870276927948,
-0.39870670437812805,
-0.41399016976356506,
-0.9061389565467834,
-0.270381361246109,
0.08139561116695404,
0.18566076457500458,
0.6407255530357361,
-0.18339526653289795,
0.20109030604362488,
0.2584863305091858,
0.2826773524284363,
0.79789137840271,
0.5330958366394043,
-0.24882909655570984,
-0.9357898831367493,
0.9049714207649231,
0.011915176175534725,
0.11802687495946884,
0.9392461180686951,
0.2985762357711792,
-0.3459731340408325,
-0.5368984341621399,
-0.7384263873100281,
0.30528807640075684,
-0.5856583118438721,
-0.7288115620613098,
-0.35048049688339233,
0.07788359373807907,
-0.3437492251396179,
-0.29979342222213745,
-0.1838429570198059,
-0.2729800343513489,
-0.6244150400161743,
0.07882779091596603,
0.2943609356880188,
0.4380064308643341,
0.1762302964925766,
0.45976707339286804,
-0.8360724449157715,
0.3032682538032532,
0.1255960762500763,
0.4003458321094513,
-0.13718312978744507,
-0.5517553091049194,
-0.08920323103666306,
0.04480958729982376,
-0.5345258712768555,
-0.4623813033103943,
0.6654671430587769,
0.148110032081604,
0.11417406797409058,
0.5079030394554138,
-0.07786545902490616,
1.0966731309890747,
-0.48909640312194824,
0.6470187902450562,
0.5922532081604004,
-0.9738304615020752,
0.2147963047027588,
-0.5160599946975708,
0.2733144462108612,
0.2676316797733307,
0.09966659545898438,
-0.4818514585494995,
-0.0307482797652483,
-0.14541813731193542,
-0.7096585631370544,
0.5897093415260315,
-0.18726645410060883,
0.034472204744815826,
0.2979169189929962,
-0.06018950045108795,
0.7073577046394348,
0.4897540211677551,
-0.650439977645874,
-0.4227607548236847,
-0.4352392256259918,
-0.36977115273475647,
-0.14966699481010437,
-0.050057776272296906,
-0.44146445393562317,
-0.5453541278839111,
0.7289612889289856,
-0.6275789141654968,
0.05996812880039215,
0.09935204684734344,
0.12001419067382812,
-0.6192506551742554,
0.18908466398715973,
0.6863417625427246,
0.7890973687171936,
0.038324031978845596,
0.01010909304022789,
0.4503367245197296,
-0.14947102963924408,
0.21293441951274872,
0.6370357275009155,
-0.1214551255106926,
-0.06118230149149895,
0.13933561742305756,
0.999762237071991,
0.4010659158229828,
-0.4102634787559509,
0.4761813282966614,
0.09932234138250351,
-0.09811626374721527,
-0.12898992002010345,
-0.3291250169277191,
0.006564575247466564,
0.8762931823730469,
0.5554574131965637,
0.5916849374771118,
-0.42150962352752686,
-0.41575098037719727,
-0.24531178176403046,
0.6065806746482849,
-0.270925372838974,
-0.36899805068969727,
0.9904365539550781,
0.18191803991794586,
-0.09777557104825974,
0.08608654886484146,
0.195240780711174,
-0.35585859417915344,
0.4536038637161255,
0.6257311701774597,
0.8574356436729431,
0.10801462829113007,
0.12200748175382614,
-0.24188344180583954,
0.27148082852363586,
0.026749441400170326,
0.2905143201351166,
0.08617086708545685,
-0.5857459902763367,
-0.7190781235694885,
-0.8630059957504272,
-0.21009261906147003,
0.2029080092906952,
-0.20610836148262024,
0.5933613777160645,
-0.4620910584926605,
-0.35113683342933655,
-0.00715493131428957,
0.031092870980501175,
-0.9725828170776367,
0.2615029513835907,
0.12221634387969971,
0.7684915065765381,
-0.7591498494148254,
0.9024617075920105,
0.44168180227279663,
-0.1808973103761673,
-0.8559985160827637,
-0.047791898250579834,
-0.12851497530937195,
-1.0628302097320557,
0.5371360182762146,
0.09571132808923721,
-0.1519065499305725,
-0.1156490296125412,
-0.1892520636320114,
-0.9379156827926636,
1.4125748872756958,
0.7169236540794373,
-0.8135663270950317,
-0.1534731239080429,
0.38353052735328674,
0.31896352767944336,
-0.5580692887306213,
-0.00862845778465271,
0.22115293145179749,
0.5725040435791016,
0.033641230314970016,
-1.0332980155944824,
0.2503109574317932,
-0.1070483848452568,
0.025812773033976555,
0.678403377532959,
-0.8159464001655579,
0.550088107585907,
-0.11041750758886337,
-0.01586904749274254,
0.12671609222888947,
0.7301658987998962,
-0.13351839780807495,
0.593904972076416,
0.46643292903900146,
0.5670640468597412,
0.541083037853241,
-0.32160574197769165,
0.6550317406654358,
-0.2987425625324249,
0.24139699339866638,
0.8816248774528503,
-0.21973176300525665,
0.6130061745643616,
0.6724642515182495,
-0.15036897361278534,
0.4794888496398926,
0.6935115456581116,
-0.2561774253845215,
0.4777337610721588,
-0.09981770813465118,
0.11168864369392395,
-0.5183010697364807,
-0.3377878665924072,
-0.665824830532074,
0.3452926278114319,
0.14490342140197754,
-0.4951459765434265,
-0.1323869675397873,
-0.04222061112523079,
-0.21468782424926758,
-0.15349172055721283,
-0.22858965396881104,
0.3602958023548126,
0.06022872030735016,
-0.41385847330093384,
0.7958477139472961,
-0.033196110278367996,
0.9473464488983154,
-0.6821646094322205,
0.2979534864425659,
0.05879181623458862,
0.25176888704299927,
-0.23941782116889954,
-0.33644458651542664,
0.22198110818862915,
-0.32231900095939636,
-0.4668467044830322,
-0.36414510011672974,
0.39764338731765747,
-0.5470557808876038,
-0.5796991586685181,
0.2979322373867035,
0.5118827819824219,
-0.48849958181381226,
0.2465023398399353,
-0.5819675922393799,
0.29658734798431396,
-0.2605740427970886,
-0.22990547120571136,
0.27368199825286865,
0.5691838264465332,
-0.008107767440378666,
0.6894330978393555,
0.777277410030365,
0.11330319195985794,
0.047665148973464966,
0.43717944622039795,
0.9240213632583618,
-0.6574645042419434,
-0.36991024017333984,
-0.8098630905151367,
0.46547067165374756,
0.2950424253940582,
-0.48750635981559753,
0.14716966450214386,
0.6200770139694214,
0.478738397359848,
-0.03852790594100952,
0.4746907353401184,
0.22323672473430634,
0.29311034083366394,
-0.4920143783092499,
0.34653276205062866,
-0.7355524897575378,
0.3755725622177124,
0.03449411317706108,
-1.1368671655654907,
-0.2837620973587036,
-0.20623981952667236,
-0.09424926340579987,
-0.1501457244157791,
0.7856094241142273,
0.676284670829773,
-0.32549598813056946,
-0.1418459564447403,
0.3921249806880951,
-0.01734120398759842,
0.1545933485031128,
0.29402872920036316,
0.603141188621521,
-0.5382385849952698,
0.867801308631897,
-0.3925974667072296,
0.11061947047710419,
-0.3568887710571289,
-1.169637680053711,
-0.9110618233680725,
-0.41281944513320923,
-0.1420224905014038,
-0.05290395766496658,
0.22954460978507996,
1.2232924699783325,
0.7625641822814941,
-0.6891358494758606,
-0.08092248439788818,
0.25758057832717896,
-0.04833001270890236,
-0.5876556634902954,
-0.2630068063735962,
0.37449732422828674,
-0.2351880818605423,
-0.9086495041847229,
0.581989049911499,
0.220722958445549,
0.23516887426376343,
-0.3369843661785126,
-0.05316651985049248,
0.17203092575073242,
-0.0994141548871994,
0.5297916531562805,
-0.0648735836148262,
-1.0403531789779663,
-0.43722307682037354,
0.22948969900608063,
-0.07558398693799973,
0.23678410053253174,
0.9095830321311951,
-0.9404546022415161,
0.16044986248016357,
0.5572616457939148,
0.8887874484062195,
0.5516557693481445,
-0.05825963243842125,
0.7042648196220398,
-0.9853441119194031,
0.10707710683345795,
0.24729058146476746,
0.6773258447647095,
0.37851864099502563,
-0.40645167231559753,
0.358379602432251,
0.22510701417922974,
-0.6501891016960144,
-0.6367206573486328,
0.09367207437753677,
-1.5250537395477295,
0.03306196630001068,
0.9718922972679138,
0.4677937626838684,
-0.07675831764936447,
0.006092793308198452,
-0.36663520336151123,
0.6113799214363098,
-0.6687046885490417,
0.6962549686431885,
0.23338618874549866,
0.2331809401512146,
-0.10185709595680237,
-0.24960164725780487,
0.19546426832675934,
0.528928816318512,
-0.4567480981349945,
0.14484095573425293,
0.19018109142780304,
0.30582866072654724,
-0.2452676147222519,
-0.054325882345438004,
0.18712450563907623,
0.10536177456378937,
-0.4859049916267395,
-0.19144722819328308,
-0.5454410314559937,
-0.21382223069667816,
-0.1487790197134018,
0.15368756651878357,
-0.25199809670448303,
-0.32794201374053955
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07283v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07283v1
|
A Framework for Cost-Effective and Self-Adaptive LLM Shaking and Recovery Mechanism
| 2024-03-12T03:30:04 | 2024-03-12T03:30:04 |
Zhiyu Chen, Yu Li, Suochao Zhang, Jingbo Zhou, Jiwen Zhou, Chenfu Bao, Dianhai Yu
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
As Large Language Models (LLMs) gain great success in real-world
applications, an increasing number of users are seeking to develop and deploy
their customized LLMs through cloud services. Nonetheless, in some specific
domains, there are still concerns regarding cost and trade-offs between privacy
issues and accuracy. In this study, we introduce a cost-effective and
self-adaptive LLM shaking tuning and recovery mechanism, named CypherTalk. With
carefully designed horizontal and vertical shaking operators, we can achieve
comparable accuracy results with SOTA privacy-preserving LLM schemes using
Cryptography-based or Differential Privacy-based methods. Experiments also show
that with the CypherTalk framework, users can achieve reliable accuracy when
using optimized shaking operator settings. To our best knowledge, this is the
first work that considers cost, and trade-off between model utility and privacy
in LLM scenarios.
|
[
-0.2454945147037506,
-0.7414031624794006,
0.38388770818710327,
0.3606802523136139,
-0.20536863803863525,
0.1608915477991104,
0.010878216475248337,
-0.7066018581390381,
0.5186074376106262,
0.9622194170951843,
-0.709449291229248,
-0.5293563008308411,
-0.5825510025024414,
-0.08633115887641907,
-0.7223284840583801,
0.8379431366920471,
0.4253835678100586,
-0.4964575171470642,
0.05550725758075714,
0.08885977417230606,
-0.1423075944185257,
-0.4929979145526886,
-0.6670618057250977,
-0.12046053260564804,
0.021397123113274574,
0.2817479074001312,
1.2107666730880737,
0.7572038173675537,
0.22932109236717224,
0.4375275671482086,
-0.04403278976678848,
0.10027746111154556,
-0.4835696518421173,
0.16166841983795166,
-0.18056611716747284,
-0.4619993269443512,
-0.6841647028923035,
-0.22971251606941223,
0.4016306400299072,
0.3573671579360962,
-0.657220721244812,
-0.1883266717195511,
0.0969047024846077,
0.6282537579536438,
-0.6235398650169373,
-0.12341474741697311,
-1.1215479373931885,
0.04895870387554169,
-0.12386075407266617,
-0.27494367957115173,
-0.04227786883711815,
-0.3237164616584778,
-0.21730713546276093,
-0.5081354975700378,
-0.1507280319929123,
0.08929003775119781,
0.6471377611160278,
0.19180022180080414,
-0.07480919361114502,
-0.2933981120586395,
-0.28211790323257446,
0.6261229515075684,
-0.890424370765686,
0.42824283242225647,
0.6022661328315735,
0.16568391025066376,
-0.3142815828323364,
-0.8057157397270203,
-0.27284786105155945,
0.12524659931659698,
0.19864670932292938,
0.15034392476081848,
-0.2517565190792084,
0.14167281985282898,
0.03605135902762413,
0.3466854393482208,
0.017665430903434753,
0.3784746825695038,
-0.16193236410617828,
-0.5362012982368469,
0.41821637749671936,
0.5325813293457031,
0.25718826055526733,
-0.1181042343378067,
-0.5973035097122192,
0.2931252419948578,
-0.7338830232620239,
-0.048870984464883804,
0.45784708857536316,
0.31570887565612793,
-0.4460775554180145,
0.17974968254566193,
-0.517426073551178,
0.7008246779441833,
0.2551412582397461,
-0.36046525835990906,
0.11773622781038284,
-0.40374451875686646,
-0.325926274061203,
0.10124487429857254,
0.9583243727684021,
0.5890411138534546,
0.24040842056274414,
-0.39054417610168457,
-0.19472181797027588,
-0.13852539658546448,
0.38236212730407715,
-0.9019942879676819,
-0.18305309116840363,
0.29351961612701416,
-0.5076713562011719,
-0.6496196389198303,
-0.24173225462436676,
-1.047663927078247,
-0.586469292640686,
-0.16280309855937958,
0.29376524686813354,
-0.22860845923423767,
-0.47736862301826477,
0.4423750936985016,
0.3009814918041229,
0.008478062227368355,
0.3494510352611542,
-1.1940367221832275,
0.9201245903968811,
0.8896024823188782,
0.9489992260932922,
-0.2775295674800873,
-0.19087372720241547,
-0.5793938040733337,
-0.17581626772880554,
-0.2769329249858856,
0.36487075686454773,
-0.2386530041694641,
-0.5496889352798462,
0.005991482175886631,
-0.18795005977153778,
0.23305220901966095,
-0.6232374906539917,
0.10581542551517487,
-0.5655173659324646,
0.25427335500717163,
0.020152326673269272,
-0.38437187671661377,
0.1843176633119583,
0.3628142178058624,
-0.14068971574306488,
0.9209567308425903,
0.06337080150842667,
-0.8802916407585144,
0.04926074296236038,
-0.16421878337860107,
-0.08891557902097702,
0.16635654866695404,
-0.12356352061033249,
-0.670983612537384,
0.13540032505989075,
0.032804496586322784,
0.33257612586021423,
-0.3615862727165222,
0.058936797082424164,
-0.5256404876708984,
-0.3224780559539795,
0.39050498604774475,
-0.2662053108215332,
0.9005953073501587,
0.2855677306652069,
-0.44251754879951477,
-0.10660958290100098,
-1.213557481765747,
0.3577560782432556,
-0.2621438205242157,
-0.3285249173641205,
-0.31667381525039673,
0.039798274636268616,
-0.28439173102378845,
0.25369930267333984,
0.3673722445964813,
-0.35703206062316895,
-0.023416075855493546,
-0.5191490054130554,
0.42677122354507446,
0.6350194215774536,
-0.1932477056980133,
0.2852904200553894,
0.057337235659360886,
0.6323063373565674,
-0.0525144562125206,
0.06792326271533966,
-0.04315899685025215,
-0.14119431376457214,
-0.5051963925361633,
-0.7478320598602295,
0.14072726666927338,
0.25389301776885986,
-0.5274335741996765,
0.45791566371917725,
-0.06687065213918686,
-0.16267673671245575,
-0.7056524753570557,
0.2745758295059204,
0.416177898645401,
0.7111876010894775,
0.3724045157432556,
-0.16637346148490906,
-0.5185466408729553,
-0.8827337026596069,
-0.4975772202014923,
0.09185071289539337,
-0.1823071539402008,
0.17594517767429352,
-0.016392966732382774,
-0.2334219366312027,
0.9651190638542175,
-0.1281048059463501,
-0.21320125460624695,
0.10896699130535126,
0.030887102708220482,
0.16675427556037903,
0.3498440682888031,
0.494490385055542,
-0.35141468048095703,
-0.4148401916027069,
-0.11303772032260895,
-0.5820465087890625,
-0.6275204420089722,
-0.013583383522927761,
-0.19612251222133636,
0.4242643415927887,
0.6579489707946777,
-0.7529439926147461,
0.5934824347496033,
1.0241601467132568,
-0.39818018674850464,
0.5233529210090637,
-0.24881775677204132,
-0.048627495765686035,
-1.1333873271942139,
-0.20151124894618988,
-0.552875280380249,
-0.8703278303146362,
-0.5700238943099976,
-0.0004232049686834216,
0.3164023458957672,
0.060419633984565735,
-0.4395781457424164,
0.2117825299501419,
-0.6627410650253296,
-0.30310171842575073,
-1.0686759948730469,
0.5256055593490601,
-0.12946352362632751,
-0.011440553702414036,
-0.0659879520535469,
0.7232683300971985,
0.9794286489486694,
-0.8764421343803406,
-0.0810733437538147,
-0.09943565726280212,
-0.11953596025705338,
0.852789580821991,
-0.6152492165565491,
0.31969794631004333,
-0.018725266680121422,
-0.1753055900335312,
-0.8274977207183838,
0.09134644269943237,
0.6334505081176758,
-0.22430242598056793,
0.25407955050468445,
-0.3477216362953186,
-0.08019707351922989,
0.0852135717868805,
-0.3924165964126587,
-0.15625113248825073,
0.5722206234931946,
-0.8284469842910767,
0.8158611059188843,
0.6121687889099121,
0.018964245915412903,
-0.8889200091362,
-0.5474359393119812,
0.439613938331604,
-0.3954974412918091,
-0.3478393852710724,
0.48403772711753845,
0.12065938860177994,
-0.3520764112472534,
-0.11122659593820572,
-0.49842196702957153,
0.1927729994058609,
0.36290013790130615,
0.47588109970092773,
0.08601564168930054,
0.1321219652891159,
-0.03267136216163635,
-0.038660090416669846,
-0.4357031285762787,
0.284199059009552,
-0.49335458874702454,
0.64983731508255,
-0.227126345038414,
0.10698634386062622,
-0.44085782766342163,
-0.10347676277160645,
0.4767024517059326,
0.09524169564247131,
0.7926097512245178,
0.46854424476623535,
-0.30481117963790894,
-0.21747015416622162,
-0.6195281744003296,
-0.23766112327575684,
-0.6290464401245117,
0.4579300582408905,
-0.44206300377845764,
-0.8250389695167542,
0.620027482509613,
-0.17470072209835052,
0.12938521802425385,
0.006554048042744398,
0.7844754457473755,
-0.07383257895708084,
0.47136998176574707,
0.6910752058029175,
-0.32609444856643677,
0.32351914048194885,
0.250100314617157,
0.1384364813566208,
-0.555641233921051,
-0.04352596029639244,
-0.7780598402023315,
-0.17445632815361023,
-0.6583701968193054,
-0.20887276530265808,
0.12633715569972992,
0.2311595231294632,
-0.09498516470193863,
0.5332661867141724,
-0.3908956050872803,
0.5040937662124634,
0.3916325271129608,
-0.009349917992949486,
0.6211720108985901,
0.19179701805114746,
0.1562640219926834,
-0.006509819068014622,
-0.4389273226261139,
-0.3171389400959015,
0.6971222162246704,
0.27175816893577576,
1.1652562618255615,
0.1815781593322754,
0.9261524677276611,
-0.016770929098129272,
0.22060953080654144,
-0.6843959093093872,
0.5922305583953857,
0.21329756081104279,
-0.63279789686203,
-0.45953983068466187,
-0.8324589729309082,
-1.0819470882415771,
0.8677160739898682,
-0.4600403904914856,
-1.3027180433273315,
0.09847783297300339,
0.4732518792152405,
0.015597190707921982,
0.20424966514110565,
0.02346692606806755,
0.39855074882507324,
-0.21672853827476501,
-0.6031869053840637,
-0.3493936359882355,
-0.6949930191040039,
0.33615416288375854,
-0.2054436057806015,
0.47079774737358093,
-0.40987953543663025,
-0.2831883430480957,
0.41449224948883057,
-0.6148931384086609,
0.8986276984214783,
-0.3091651499271393,
-0.15595006942749023,
0.136324942111969,
0.5387238264083862,
0.5438567399978638,
0.2843788266181946,
-0.23530861735343933,
0.478200227022171,
0.20537516474723816,
-0.10897445678710938,
-0.6075120568275452,
0.8259870409965515,
-0.89496910572052,
-0.735101044178009,
-0.30338266491889954,
-0.655541181564331,
-0.19644391536712646,
0.3919547498226166,
0.16786770522594452,
0.25480395555496216,
0.06513019651174545,
0.31815895438194275,
0.475034236907959,
-0.18972285091876984,
0.6865056753158569,
1.0589386224746704,
-0.6243032217025757,
-0.7079924941062927,
0.48567909002304077,
-0.19568771123886108,
0.49252432584762573,
0.21410344541072845,
0.32648611068725586,
-0.38168835639953613,
-0.5176663994789124,
-0.10507497191429138,
0.014373286627233028,
-0.4656626582145691,
-0.6242423057556152,
-0.8229924440383911,
-0.16495047509670258,
-0.11080150306224823,
-0.03314880654215813,
-0.9598657488822937,
-0.7024551033973694,
-0.23413586616516113,
-0.1706097573041916,
0.29404518008232117,
-0.034706298261880875,
-0.1572437435388565,
0.5797918438911438,
-0.5664259791374207,
0.40533533692359924,
0.08395370841026306,
0.4668850004673004,
-0.3225042223930359,
-0.6311572194099426,
-0.10821718722581863,
0.09942808002233505,
-0.4073309004306793,
-0.6271148324012756,
0.5295370221138,
0.17448627948760986,
0.18569804728031158,
0.25316065549850464,
0.16642849147319794,
0.7695639133453369,
-0.2755168378353119,
0.4073261022567749,
0.5033389925956726,
-1.3554764986038208,
0.19358018040657043,
0.007376824505627155,
0.3637930452823639,
0.5503446459770203,
0.04357876256108284,
-0.5289956331253052,
-0.35723671317100525,
-0.5117752552032471,
-0.9733423590660095,
0.7436941862106323,
0.21665050089359283,
0.4394337832927704,
0.1309988647699356,
0.6451469659805298,
0.18459448218345642,
0.36337143182754517,
-0.9461254477500916,
-0.11937141418457031,
-0.3638569414615631,
-0.4348180592060089,
0.3504471480846405,
-0.24366512894630432,
-0.43245184421539307,
0.3446533679962158,
0.6377984881401062,
-0.38817349076271057,
0.13991594314575195,
-0.1782120019197464,
0.019306395202875137,
0.005544543731957674,
0.28985297679901123,
0.3004927337169647,
0.5269242525100708,
0.01681126281619072,
0.3801673352718353,
0.31774550676345825,
-0.44948750734329224,
0.01546294055879116,
-0.1672658771276474,
-0.4745483696460724,
-0.42699602246284485,
-0.16530480980873108,
0.6155175566673279,
0.36337947845458984,
-0.5271949172019958,
0.4765617847442627,
-0.10715263336896896,
-0.46459802985191345,
-0.1364758163690567,
0.2308424562215805,
0.4722021818161011,
0.19377413392066956,
-0.16247834265232086,
0.057257670909166336,
0.3735445439815521,
-0.4286218583583832,
0.011564909480512142,
0.6670722365379333,
-0.16690722107887268,
-0.297568678855896,
0.7803897857666016,
-0.044568341225385666,
-0.6151546239852905,
0.7357273101806641,
0.38780713081359863,
-0.1626930683851242,
0.22974051535129547,
0.9990175366401672,
0.8482850790023804,
-0.0759916827082634,
0.1306283324956894,
-0.06051017716526985,
0.27498936653137207,
-0.2063748687505722,
0.4699179530143738,
-0.01061568595468998,
-0.8101209402084351,
0.11743194609880447,
-0.3893166482448578,
-0.47147098183631897,
-0.230239138007164,
-0.6431654095649719,
0.2986126244068146,
-0.8944784998893738,
-0.5235925912857056,
-0.34131568670272827,
-0.32377657294273376,
-0.35554394125938416,
0.2510923743247986,
0.14054015278816223,
0.8851020336151123,
-0.09496357291936874,
0.7939819693565369,
0.0990283340215683,
0.31959086656570435,
-0.38386034965515137,
0.017286580055952072,
0.18642759323120117,
-1.1297639608383179,
0.14018970727920532,
-0.013633616268634796,
-0.9202812314033508,
-0.17665116488933563,
-0.6214042901992798,
-1.2806510925292969,
1.028786540031433,
0.6324658989906311,
-0.9261523485183716,
0.40646907687187195,
0.1807408481836319,
0.7337529063224792,
-0.25218406319618225,
0.07819904386997223,
0.392072856426239,
0.1954779475927353,
-0.09287630021572113,
-0.8790141344070435,
0.2404431849718094,
0.30548498034477234,
0.0725923478603363,
0.3357771337032318,
-0.9832568764686584,
0.1958826333284378,
0.036115698516368866,
-0.20864614844322205,
0.012855109758675098,
0.6651178002357483,
0.24776311218738556,
0.27250784635543823,
0.5637163519859314,
0.37699073553085327,
0.9141026139259338,
0.021791020408272743,
0.8875715136528015,
-0.8653894662857056,
0.4548780620098114,
1.1820120811462402,
-0.1242218092083931,
0.6720657348632812,
0.4775070548057556,
-0.2371661216020584,
0.2526857852935791,
0.20623865723609924,
0.37457510828971863,
0.7201159596443176,
0.4034651815891266,
0.053131166845560074,
-0.33048078417778015,
0.3079545497894287,
-0.34275150299072266,
0.4857099950313568,
0.4872724115848541,
-0.36589083075523376,
0.06539855152368546,
-0.46245628595352173,
0.5951664447784424,
-0.05457976087927818,
-0.32379090785980225,
0.6603338718414307,
0.4801173508167267,
-0.5318647623062134,
0.6712502837181091,
0.19185040891170502,
0.5394118428230286,
-0.6736124753952026,
0.6251948475837708,
-0.23775413632392883,
0.3429833948612213,
-0.5174873471260071,
-0.3601263761520386,
0.5645664930343628,
-0.38872092962265015,
0.24745656549930573,
-0.05374285951256752,
0.8388654589653015,
-0.6109287738800049,
-0.3557927906513214,
0.4334651529788971,
0.20696209371089935,
0.06855283677577972,
0.021773463115096092,
-0.8003731369972229,
0.5099286437034607,
-0.24745935201644897,
-0.15771953761577606,
0.5756020545959473,
0.2719576060771942,
0.4072902202606201,
0.9798744320869446,
0.26679718494415283,
-0.0035108772572129965,
0.14871284365653992,
0.09056968986988068,
0.7311552166938782,
-0.598563551902771,
-0.7682436108589172,
-1.0791410207748413,
0.3746221363544464,
-0.08677104860544205,
-0.257185697555542,
0.8054584860801697,
0.30617716908454895,
0.4033193588256836,
0.16444343328475952,
0.5273656845092773,
0.20773397386074066,
0.48257264494895935,
-0.820094883441925,
0.43451136350631714,
-0.47751209139823914,
0.5911663770675659,
-0.4407271444797516,
-0.723408579826355,
-0.2692832350730896,
0.7844166159629822,
-0.008707262575626373,
0.029188543558120728,
0.524204671382904,
1.1363133192062378,
-0.08705907315015793,
0.3088056147098541,
0.5126974582672119,
0.34041833877563477,
0.18469107151031494,
0.16777296364307404,
0.720793604850769,
-0.4787345826625824,
0.4257606863975525,
-0.25539979338645935,
-0.39215514063835144,
-0.028310516849160194,
-1.0581752061843872,
-0.8044167160987854,
0.17074395716190338,
-0.733919620513916,
-0.7622306942939758,
0.4197559654712677,
0.9296168088912964,
0.9859570264816284,
-0.6392099261283875,
-0.4282344877719879,
-0.17138221859931946,
0.002906187204644084,
-0.40167224407196045,
-0.17266537249088287,
0.16174040734767914,
-0.46949052810668945,
-0.5626055002212524,
0.46193620562553406,
0.7686235904693604,
-0.08479290455579758,
-0.0296127051115036,
-0.1524496227502823,
0.612411618232727,
0.21847650408744812,
0.37095320224761963,
0.3816882371902466,
-0.684828519821167,
-0.2290622442960739,
-0.09660516679286957,
-0.08333335071802139,
0.36706098914146423,
0.6731372475624084,
-0.5342373251914978,
0.45381101965904236,
0.14509575068950653,
0.7558231353759766,
0.8152487874031067,
0.38619598746299744,
0.48152637481689453,
-0.4317803978919983,
0.13157455623149872,
-0.20814281702041626,
0.3038434386253357,
0.2733382284641266,
-0.6042025089263916,
0.3462476134300232,
0.13655564188957214,
-0.6370243430137634,
-0.5231181383132935,
0.30440986156463623,
-0.8870253562927246,
-0.09396392852067947,
0.8117613792419434,
-0.22193875908851624,
-0.008491208776831627,
-0.25903457403182983,
-0.2893897593021393,
-0.32197293639183044,
-0.18268895149230957,
1.6198982000350952,
0.42809340357780457,
-0.18920081853866577,
-0.5331534147262573,
0.06968101859092712,
0.5580004453659058,
0.4026300013065338,
-0.9838820099830627,
0.32147958874702454,
0.39051729440689087,
0.6538055539131165,
0.011735334992408752,
0.9938811659812927,
-0.6021854877471924,
-0.004808477126061916,
0.1422734558582306,
0.06986650824546814,
-0.12336844950914383,
-0.3379717469215393,
-0.2519843578338623,
0.36864277720451355,
0.013053539209067822,
-0.15229062736034393
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07279v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07279v1
|
A Survey of Explainable Knowledge Tracing
| 2024-03-12T03:17:59 | 2024-03-12T03:17:59 |
Yanhong Bai, Jiabao Zhao, Tingjiang Wei, Qing Cai, Liang He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the long term accumulation of high quality educational data, artificial
intelligence has shown excellent performance in knowledge tracing. However, due
to the lack of interpretability and transparency of some algorithms, this
approach will result in reduced stakeholder trust and a decreased acceptance of
intelligent decisions. Therefore, algorithms need to achieve high accuracy, and
users need to understand the internal operating mechanism and provide reliable
explanations for decisions. This paper thoroughly analyzes the interpretability
of KT algorithms. First, the concepts and common methods of explainable
artificial intelligence and knowledge tracing are introduced. Next, explainable
knowledge tracing models are classified into two categories: transparent models
and black box models. Then, the interpretable methods used are reviewed from
three stages: ante hoc interpretable methods, post hoc interpretable methods,
and other dimensions. It is worth noting that current evaluation methods for
explainable knowledge tracing are lacking. Hence, contrast and deletion
experiments are conducted to explain the prediction results of the deep
knowledge tracing model on the ASSISTment2009 by using three XAI methods.
Moreover, this paper offers some insights into evaluation methods from the
perspective of educational stakeholders. This paper provides a detailed and
comprehensive review of the research on explainable knowledge tracing, aiming
to offer some basis and inspiration for researchers interested in the
interpretability of knowledge tracing.
|
[
-0.3085649609565735,
-0.6725538969039917,
0.8020296096801758,
-0.18317152559757233,
-0.11169076710939407,
0.3155839741230011,
-0.02807212993502617,
-0.7912265062332153,
-0.24231936037540436,
0.3841589689254761,
-0.6769468188285828,
-0.1698673963546753,
-0.63334059715271,
-0.4265204668045044,
-0.5688508749008179,
0.9868137240409851,
-0.25570106506347656,
-0.09896067529916763,
-0.13126441836357117,
-0.1774134784936905,
-0.8136800527572632,
-0.24342228472232819,
-0.7482920289039612,
-0.6137879490852356,
0.16950255632400513,
0.4988953471183777,
0.6087545156478882,
0.7019214034080505,
0.3555278182029724,
0.32977646589279175,
-0.19364261627197266,
-0.28985175490379333,
-0.4925343990325928,
-0.06500697880983353,
-0.20583441853523254,
-0.8119447231292725,
-0.2598353922367096,
-0.12068749219179153,
0.5428617596626282,
0.5852817893028259,
-0.07062067836523056,
0.209436297416687,
0.2804464101791382,
0.8648692965507507,
-0.520172119140625,
0.4620046317577362,
-0.2907172739505768,
-0.08441727608442307,
-0.03152189403772354,
-0.08934150636196136,
-0.3268526792526245,
-0.5500508546829224,
0.6843283772468567,
-0.7021316885948181,
0.29550036787986755,
-0.06001530960202217,
0.38363519310951233,
0.19201035797595978,
-0.47112801671028137,
-0.9484283328056335,
-0.997175395488739,
0.9520103931427002,
-0.4132583439350128,
0.3764052987098694,
0.3559473156929016,
0.989130437374115,
0.18726785480976105,
-0.8031575083732605,
-0.49077755212783813,
-0.07111126184463501,
-0.07155890762805939,
0.3143872618675232,
0.0644904151558876,
-0.0016751764342188835,
0.0647265762090683,
0.3345918357372284,
-0.23977360129356384,
0.1058967188000679,
-0.5568563938140869,
-0.2035357654094696,
0.5863473415374756,
0.04728240519762039,
0.1545519232749939,
-0.08938353508710861,
-0.5136895179748535,
0.1620541363954544,
-0.4353718161582947,
0.265617311000824,
0.39766472578048706,
-0.08978162705898285,
-0.15979376435279846,
0.20230934023857117,
-0.3047430217266083,
0.4596411883831024,
-0.21781425178050995,
-0.1306118220090866,
-0.3019433915615082,
-0.43383654952049255,
-0.047467153519392014,
0.2912799119949341,
0.23321865499019623,
0.359487920999527,
0.387203574180603,
-0.4838525354862213,
0.12603603303432465,
0.18381169438362122,
0.2777343690395355,
-0.6341462731361389,
-0.5190654397010803,
0.10704479366540909,
-0.6954057216644287,
-0.184794619679451,
-0.07991747558116913,
-0.8237476348876953,
-0.4480556845664978,
-0.40237143635749817,
0.5410149097442627,
-0.6360160112380981,
-0.37948763370513916,
0.02789551205933094,
-0.05638406425714493,
0.363696426153183,
0.6780697703361511,
-0.4817030131816864,
0.15896441042423248,
0.8050539493560791,
0.6477514505386353,
-0.1222987174987793,
-0.14456036686897278,
0.2303936928510666,
0.09141708165407181,
-0.0716545432806015,
0.6195103526115417,
-0.5242909789085388,
-0.09693921357393265,
-0.25955909490585327,
-0.09420579671859741,
-0.23069651424884796,
-0.12655174732208252,
0.5339743494987488,
-0.6957250833511353,
0.23504050076007843,
-0.41413816809654236,
-0.933432936668396,
-1.0306034088134766,
0.06700602173805237,
-0.5704753398895264,
0.4642059803009033,
0.10112069547176361,
-0.7103350162506104,
0.5471639633178711,
-0.979686439037323,
-0.003411125158891082,
0.18989111483097076,
0.16443629562854767,
-0.28292885422706604,
-0.08796889334917068,
0.13285256922245026,
0.2688030004501343,
-0.1243269219994545,
0.4114355742931366,
-0.0200758408755064,
-0.5593335628509521,
0.13353490829467773,
-0.6088968515396118,
1.1659531593322754,
0.2353437840938568,
-0.7597650289535522,
0.00640206690877676,
-0.8056406378746033,
0.10905298590660095,
-0.08879641443490982,
0.04261118918657303,
-0.4252837300300598,
0.25545209646224976,
-0.4683545231819153,
0.15086841583251953,
-0.011355859227478504,
-0.49069157242774963,
-0.09790011495351791,
-0.26720353960990906,
0.6237401962280273,
1.0598537921905518,
0.12108816206455231,
0.3595866858959198,
-0.07290850579738617,
0.8638849258422852,
-0.14308498799800873,
0.3170144259929657,
-0.5054765343666077,
-0.6087158918380737,
-0.5862590074539185,
-0.10404527187347412,
0.32883208990097046,
0.24787171185016632,
-0.7026292681694031,
-0.20544672012329102,
-0.15826480090618134,
-0.5766485929489136,
-0.7597185373306274,
-0.15874560177326202,
0.5366618633270264,
0.9540494084358215,
0.07552613317966461,
0.03554034233093262,
-0.4147476255893707,
-0.834736168384552,
-0.40786540508270264,
-0.2422144114971161,
0.22129736840724945,
0.3964961767196655,
0.6897926330566406,
0.015544912777841091,
0.7029690146446228,
-0.2334667593240738,
0.2415098398923874,
0.0914033055305481,
0.17846845090389252,
-0.1049465462565422,
0.4386001527309418,
0.20636408030986786,
-0.7721744775772095,
-0.22285617887973785,
0.028234628960490227,
-0.8091525435447693,
0.44565004110336304,
-0.05265148729085922,
-0.254165917634964,
0.12279129028320312,
0.20262804627418518,
-0.4052469730377197,
0.6646910309791565,
0.15622638165950775,
-0.6485133767127991,
0.5705146789550781,
-0.021898826584219933,
0.32178202271461487,
-0.5903487205505371,
0.1996612250804901,
-0.02606048807501793,
-0.1939585953950882,
-0.3875526487827301,
0.36770403385162354,
0.025049377232789993,
0.10319948941469193,
-0.14943067729473114,
0.45555445551872253,
-0.34415608644485474,
-0.05778030678629875,
-0.1947821080684662,
0.28393375873565674,
0.019004719331860542,
0.2943803369998932,
-0.3610885441303253,
0.3757360279560089,
0.6042784452438354,
-0.5764512419700623,
0.39889025688171387,
0.14601503312587738,
-0.5445116758346558,
0.7775042057037354,
-0.5946294665336609,
-0.0073036435060203075,
-0.2648869752883911,
0.21832126379013062,
-1.2269883155822754,
0.01703931763768196,
0.45620399713516235,
-0.5204261541366577,
-0.028162864968180656,
-0.15211720764636993,
-0.19688254594802856,
-0.2903909683227539,
-0.1663694679737091,
0.43471696972846985,
0.7357770204544067,
-0.7798446416854858,
0.3769415616989136,
0.006510287523269653,
-0.011571461334824562,
-0.5757885575294495,
-0.2694702446460724,
-0.23933906853199005,
-0.4317038953304291,
-0.6001537442207336,
-0.0990220382809639,
-0.1348240226507187,
-0.15904760360717773,
0.31367793679237366,
-0.32149261236190796,
-0.1810578554868698,
0.4298062026500702,
0.4732168912887573,
0.2191028594970703,
-0.5116322040557861,
-0.06287795305252075,
-0.18673312664031982,
-0.29362818598747253,
0.5429970026016235,
-0.12377676367759705,
0.08516591787338257,
0.06737343221902847,
-0.49920323491096497,
-0.6892073154449463,
-0.06768722832202911,
0.5158610343933105,
-0.009745371527969837,
0.6340404152870178,
0.6007141470909119,
-0.3467154800891876,
-0.08914203941822052,
-0.4346994459629059,
-0.1791130006313324,
-0.41099023818969727,
0.2538658082485199,
-0.14059598743915558,
-0.6777564287185669,
0.768024206161499,
-0.09211739897727966,
-0.0031897302251309156,
0.7365258932113647,
0.27621570229530334,
-0.06848378479480743,
1.206753134727478,
0.7655985355377197,
-0.0341966450214386,
0.06920831650495529,
-0.34853553771972656,
0.34195002913475037,
-0.5190093517303467,
-0.631890594959259,
-0.726033627986908,
-0.311503142118454,
-0.7428378462791443,
0.11636987328529358,
0.08438311517238617,
0.22966282069683075,
-0.1110493391752243,
-0.16486676037311554,
-0.656348466873169,
0.5936098694801331,
0.7317774295806885,
0.06480111926794052,
0.4300042986869812,
-0.046218596398830414,
0.26630091667175293,
0.10030246526002884,
-0.7017765045166016,
-0.321973592042923,
1.0576773881912231,
0.5941330194473267,
0.5311294198036194,
-0.25054728984832764,
0.31160396337509155,
0.27866512537002563,
0.374414324760437,
-0.7662353515625,
0.21208146214485168,
0.17468664050102234,
-0.8504067659378052,
-0.4741804301738739,
-0.39307084679603577,
-0.7329623103141785,
-0.06671422719955444,
0.10077598690986633,
-0.8950628042221069,
0.05402465909719467,
0.2514749765396118,
-0.20548738539218903,
0.38762009143829346,
-1.0700840950012207,
0.7511391043663025,
-0.17710725963115692,
-0.13458314538002014,
-0.4581480026245117,
-0.8044045567512512,
0.7508573532104492,
-0.23484203219413757,
0.21720246970653534,
0.2154756784439087,
0.3319495916366577,
1.1911630630493164,
-0.30582568049430847,
0.6558864116668701,
-0.7309876084327698,
0.004036980681121349,
0.5128725171089172,
-0.12859809398651123,
0.29214906692504883,
-0.2488151639699936,
-0.32186514139175415,
0.17097117006778717,
0.32957589626312256,
-0.42532098293304443,
-0.8674527406692505,
0.7120662927627563,
-0.7220426797866821,
-0.3395283818244934,
-0.21087270975112915,
-0.5653793215751648,
0.06977812200784683,
0.2936801016330719,
0.11908742785453796,
0.3577093780040741,
0.14575766026973724,
0.10437289625406265,
0.5290293097496033,
-0.09537000209093094,
0.41163870692253113,
0.46636396646499634,
-0.00985562801361084,
0.06908904016017914,
1.1712137460708618,
0.5658270716667175,
-0.11197924613952637,
0.0710466057062149,
0.31310373544692993,
-0.36952951550483704,
-0.805700421333313,
-0.4867059886455536,
0.09242869913578033,
-0.6565527319908142,
0.09244289249181747,
-0.3122725784778595,
-0.23797494173049927,
-0.08204472810029984,
-0.31438279151916504,
-0.12852449715137482,
-0.5931807160377502,
0.047013722360134125,
-0.26488909125328064,
0.2435331493616104,
1.1703211069107056,
0.18345677852630615,
0.6282647848129272,
-0.30862125754356384,
0.4341069459915161,
0.19451546669006348,
0.8286691308021545,
0.6253165006637573,
-0.34139305353164673,
-0.547234833240509,
0.24442532658576965,
-0.28103747963905334,
-0.8338881134986877,
-0.19063052535057068,
-0.14975868165493011,
0.7901729941368103,
0.6339949369430542,
0.1686990112066269,
0.8097351789474487,
0.23014335334300995,
0.7002676129341125,
-0.18564583361148834,
-0.9674285054206848,
0.5369334816932678,
0.03485768660902977,
0.16131684184074402,
0.37462395429611206,
0.5627346634864807,
-0.22154447436332703,
-0.2511025369167328,
-0.8517443537712097,
-0.8985096216201782,
1.2147269248962402,
0.1794559508562088,
-0.29478442668914795,
0.615844190120697,
0.5882695913314819,
0.6698991060256958,
0.14193569123744965,
-0.30724620819091797,
-0.4793863892555237,
-0.2674112617969513,
-0.16314706206321716,
-0.20040443539619446,
-0.5281804203987122,
0.012927314266562462,
0.013493373058736324,
0.8671576380729675,
0.3573938012123108,
0.29328393936157227,
-0.04391615837812424,
-0.2449217289686203,
-0.08476434648036957,
0.2814551293849945,
0.46108484268188477,
1.4165993928909302,
-0.3163970112800598,
-0.02868347242474556,
-0.27112486958503723,
-0.5065115094184875,
0.028920037671923637,
0.24492661654949188,
-0.43650633096694946,
-0.26357972621917725,
0.5921563506126404,
0.6115182638168335,
-0.11288987100124359,
-0.47321000695228577,
0.2933313548564911,
-0.01733558624982834,
-0.16818733513355255,
-0.43650761246681213,
0.1499236524105072,
0.026304535567760468,
0.3177383244037628,
0.3733923137187958,
0.040974318981170654,
0.41956251859664917,
-0.45778200030326843,
-0.004399934783577919,
0.3405647277832031,
-0.6927027106285095,
-0.588888943195343,
0.6844335198402405,
0.18248504400253296,
-0.19911377131938934,
0.8488733172416687,
0.11851321160793304,
-0.41209182143211365,
0.8288131952285767,
0.261789470911026,
0.6679819226264954,
-0.47003453969955444,
0.4763948917388916,
0.15592166781425476,
0.38697952032089233,
0.11277361214160919,
0.2048911154270172,
-0.475336492061615,
-0.2813931703567505,
-0.6077213287353516,
-0.14635628461837769,
-0.49743223190307617,
0.19700810313224792,
-1.0446795225143433,
-0.2767152190208435,
-0.23577924072742462,
0.3843049705028534,
0.34447696805000305,
0.08038590848445892,
-0.8165723085403442,
0.48865658044815063,
-0.2887781262397766,
0.7616268396377563,
-0.895277738571167,
0.30272549390792847,
0.6368329524993896,
-0.015037397854030132,
-0.8953322768211365,
-0.18776342272758484,
-0.11292127519845963,
-1.1948682069778442,
0.3827499449253082,
0.10959356278181076,
0.021151918917894363,
-0.08057811856269836,
-0.6794147491455078,
-0.538782000541687,
1.0896706581115723,
0.17492054402828217,
-0.31201037764549255,
-0.17691867053508759,
0.011757912114262581,
0.6246705651283264,
0.002736463211476803,
0.46975818276405334,
0.8288188576698303,
0.7368431687355042,
-0.012464119121432304,
-0.6154102683067322,
0.16809549927711487,
-0.023197637870907784,
-0.4055311381816864,
0.19226884841918945,
-0.3727118670940399,
0.4541211426258087,
-0.08551131933927536,
-0.16679906845092773,
-0.07591602206230164,
0.2950676381587982,
0.014655581675469875,
1.1592233180999756,
0.3403559923171997,
0.2918567657470703,
0.6984827518463135,
0.04049475118517876,
1.0435339212417603,
-0.2720966935157776,
0.2214040756225586,
0.8456937670707703,
0.33321088552474976,
0.3463766872882843,
0.3625769317150116,
-0.19603566825389862,
0.520290732383728,
0.48231279850006104,
0.012374804355204105,
0.4167081117630005,
0.09057218581438065,
-0.008706454187631607,
-0.010323802940547466,
-0.07768227905035019,
-0.2802431583404541,
0.6026354432106018,
0.2864232659339905,
-0.5832610130310059,
-0.33562466502189636,
0.12357074022293091,
-0.027908669784665108,
-0.16734002530574799,
-0.6449636816978455,
0.6534144282341003,
-0.1774323731660843,
-0.740481436252594,
0.25353875756263733,
-0.030917758122086525,
0.29549798369407654,
-0.44021302461624146,
-0.5083004832267761,
-0.05209676921367645,
0.10905244201421738,
-0.42078056931495667,
-0.9656698703765869,
0.17663274705410004,
-0.1728031188249588,
-0.13040339946746826,
-0.15667220950126648,
0.8583899140357971,
-0.022885259240865707,
-0.38233068585395813,
0.1548565775156021,
0.7027234435081482,
0.2946736812591553,
-0.13118720054626465,
-0.6084012985229492,
-0.22107994556427002,
0.30461013317108154,
-0.23292778432369232,
0.04739459231495857,
0.5981742739677429,
-0.2898867130279541,
1.053019642829895,
0.28464651107788086,
-0.0947335883975029,
0.09022071212530136,
-0.34249451756477356,
0.5335537791252136,
-0.6895842552185059,
-0.6157244443893433,
-0.8396316766738892,
0.6510520577430725,
0.26923391222953796,
-0.023210588842630386,
0.9347699880599976,
0.38999953866004944,
0.6548852920532227,
0.074570432305336,
0.9157804250717163,
0.12452716380357742,
0.7293641567230225,
-0.45923155546188354,
0.9020252227783203,
-0.13975462317466736,
0.26189863681793213,
-0.2805914282798767,
-0.7429948449134827,
0.24016232788562775,
0.3084883391857147,
-0.37976017594337463,
0.41125476360321045,
0.401710569858551,
0.20631472766399384,
-0.1838499754667282,
0.5335898995399475,
0.03290662169456482,
0.5191730260848999,
0.24556799232959747,
0.3554055094718933,
1.0138822793960571,
-0.424981951713562,
0.7443240284919739,
-0.613043487071991,
-0.26547297835350037,
-0.34514278173446655,
-0.6877056956291199,
-0.5457010269165039,
-0.6155967116355896,
-0.5624832510948181,
-0.24558188021183014,
0.29658013582229614,
-0.1605939120054245,
0.8219038844108582,
-0.7096166014671326,
0.11296281218528748,
-0.13885009288787842,
0.7596017718315125,
-0.4548100531101227,
-0.31719550490379333,
0.8696120381355286,
0.22000324726104736,
-0.4035269021987915,
0.06837508082389832,
-0.1620321422815323,
-0.1507323831319809,
-0.2966170310974121,
-0.09239610284566879,
0.15814737975597382,
-0.16010814905166626,
0.5340679883956909,
0.4270530641078949,
-0.6550137996673584,
-0.4575014114379883,
-0.167343869805336,
0.5124064683914185,
-0.08046972751617432,
0.7472488284111023,
-0.8623810410499573,
0.9528669118881226,
0.4285050928592682,
0.47801434993743896,
0.4512135982513428,
0.17165087163448334,
0.36419594287872314,
-0.056347329169511795,
-0.4774497151374817,
0.03706448897719383,
-0.11662060767412186,
0.1808640956878662,
-0.4277757406234741,
0.5414308309555054,
0.00805317610502243,
-0.8385851979255676,
-0.8003209829330444,
-0.005294039845466614,
-0.8676930665969849,
-0.16844722628593445,
0.5861877799034119,
-0.4859825670719147,
-0.11012986302375793,
-0.47927913069725037,
-0.1958729326725006,
0.39499136805534363,
-0.22968485951423645,
1.1243152618408203,
0.8304728865623474,
-0.5193759799003601,
-0.295915812253952,
-0.8704355955123901,
0.38422489166259766,
0.15047740936279297,
-0.4908497929573059,
-0.0410836786031723,
0.4480300843715668,
0.42357534170150757,
0.11851954460144043,
0.3768386244773865,
-0.10717566311359406,
0.28363147377967834,
0.08437535911798477,
-0.21461956202983856,
-0.39264345169067383,
-0.2542029917240143,
-0.4069134294986725,
0.35288119316101074,
0.17390425503253937,
-0.3917817175388336
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00011v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00011v1
|
A novel interface for adversarial trivia question-writing
| 2024-03-12T02:37:24 | 2024-03-12T02:37:24 |
Jason Liu
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.CL
|
A critical component when developing question-answering AIs is an adversarial
dataset that challenges models to adapt to the complex syntax and reasoning
underlying our natural language. Present techniques for procedurally generating
adversarial texts are not robust enough for training on complex tasks such as
answering multi-sentence trivia questions. We instead turn to human-generated
data by introducing an interface for collecting adversarial human-written
trivia questions. Our interface is aimed towards question writers and players
of Quiz Bowl, a buzzer-based trivia competition where paragraph-long questions
consist of a sequence of clues of decreasing difficulty. To incentivize usage,
a suite of machine learning-based tools in our interface assist humans in
writing questions that are more challenging to answer for Quiz Bowl players and
computers alike. Not only does our interface gather training data for the
groundbreaking Quiz Bowl AI project QANTA, but it is also a proof-of-concept of
future adversarial data collection for question-answering systems. The results
of performance-testing our interface with ten originally-composed questions
indicate that, despite some flaws, our interface's novel question-writing
features as well as its real-time exposure of useful responses from our machine
models could facilitate and enhance the collection of adversarial questions.
|
[
-0.6292535662651062,
-1.1043864488601685,
0.3048345148563385,
-0.15497784316539764,
0.02386953867971897,
0.4112926125526428,
0.22492662072181702,
-0.4018608033657074,
0.13878297805786133,
0.5199273824691772,
-0.6669046878814697,
-0.149943009018898,
-0.09765269607305527,
0.19540080428123474,
-0.4300500750541687,
1.2275605201721191,
-0.01742229424417019,
-0.08157798647880554,
-0.4055676758289337,
-0.04593554884195328,
-0.18314695358276367,
-0.560556948184967,
-0.967178463935852,
-0.028107110410928726,
0.691834032535553,
0.3899986743927002,
0.8984281420707703,
0.3890065848827362,
0.6198749542236328,
0.22934827208518982,
0.09830383211374283,
0.49219775199890137,
-0.5038588643074036,
0.149333655834198,
0.004091675393283367,
-0.7820596098899841,
-0.0792662501335144,
0.17960000038146973,
0.3931921124458313,
0.5269210338592529,
0.09139381349086761,
0.22909685969352722,
-0.23881371319293976,
0.43679141998291016,
-0.49491333961486816,
-0.25362807512283325,
-0.5709686279296875,
0.22673313319683075,
-0.29091981053352356,
-0.5020778179168701,
-0.1921892911195755,
-0.7784837484359741,
0.0223711971193552,
-0.7403904795646667,
0.39786314964294434,
0.3307531476020813,
0.9031116366386414,
0.39824730157852173,
-0.1930956095457077,
-0.5461047291755676,
-0.7790912985801697,
0.12028179317712784,
-0.3192078173160553,
-0.28400918841362,
0.1372864842414856,
0.6199522614479065,
-0.21994611620903015,
-0.5408373475074768,
-0.6927244067192078,
-0.458882600069046,
0.11210764944553375,
0.005455709993839264,
-0.0720546543598175,
-0.1020059660077095,
0.21012383699417114,
0.22873711585998535,
-0.7482399940490723,
-0.08675709366798401,
-0.46495863795280457,
-0.10121644288301468,
0.8480072021484375,
0.5857384204864502,
0.5696374177932739,
0.13371160626411438,
-0.26648345589637756,
0.015205884352326393,
-0.7128613591194153,
0.3373855650424957,
0.4628959894180298,
-0.0662110447883606,
0.26480937004089355,
0.574094295501709,
-0.25437358021736145,
0.5340654850006104,
0.03404402732849121,
0.293072909116745,
-0.057910241186618805,
-0.24103109538555145,
0.31462419033050537,
0.01968572475016117,
0.8847895860671997,
0.49281227588653564,
0.47166135907173157,
-0.5179389715194702,
0.03494194522500038,
0.24515774846076965,
0.382182240486145,
-0.48971250653266907,
-0.6604019403457642,
0.44749900698661804,
-0.020602287724614143,
-0.7841267585754395,
-0.013153845444321632,
-0.5412357449531555,
-0.7654006481170654,
0.0988200455904007,
0.6487032771110535,
-0.4346039295196533,
-0.006915529724210501,
-0.04466412588953972,
-0.8655918836593628,
0.259576678276062,
0.18066564202308655,
-0.5313435792922974,
0.11640964448451996,
0.4473300576210022,
0.4796830415725708,
0.01874711737036705,
-0.5629608631134033,
-0.7289001941680908,
0.1131146177649498,
-0.3810723125934601,
0.7455172538757324,
-0.301552414894104,
-0.31061843037605286,
-0.06530852615833282,
-0.32935816049575806,
-0.05174417421221733,
-0.5889451503753662,
0.32943615317344666,
-0.7072375416755676,
0.4211050868034363,
-0.17010372877120972,
-0.4561701714992523,
0.13855814933776855,
0.33800673484802246,
-0.7121278643608093,
0.8140609264373779,
-0.041467487812042236,
-0.8633406758308411,
0.1539936363697052,
-0.9483418464660645,
-0.6639074087142944,
0.3316115736961365,
-0.11168405413627625,
-0.45648884773254395,
-0.03547026962041855,
0.17739026248455048,
0.1416012942790985,
-0.3053698241710663,
0.1905592679977417,
-0.5702399611473083,
-0.6142245531082153,
0.8535346984863281,
-0.539849579334259,
1.0595992803573608,
0.15940776467323303,
-0.3057858943939209,
-0.12694187462329865,
-0.7457618713378906,
0.02470274455845356,
0.3315083980560303,
-0.28329312801361084,
-0.058697886765003204,
-0.11380261182785034,
-0.21015915274620056,
0.08939896523952484,
0.34621381759643555,
-0.8087289929389954,
0.15754905343055725,
-0.1840185821056366,
0.4579608142375946,
0.5161807537078857,
0.2425733059644699,
0.11540494114160538,
-0.6489170789718628,
0.8148620128631592,
-0.1327611207962036,
0.3534316420555115,
0.148103266954422,
-0.3907087445259094,
-0.6389697194099426,
0.20285147428512573,
0.2006213515996933,
0.8509944081306458,
-1.143736481666565,
-0.02835072949528694,
0.013654684647917747,
-0.5850909948348999,
-0.8808817863464355,
0.04940922185778618,
0.5339505076408386,
0.6409683227539062,
0.25557389855384827,
0.2430880218744278,
-0.49214738607406616,
-0.8365561962127686,
-0.2652343511581421,
-0.3647221624851227,
-0.12756848335266113,
0.6567582488059998,
0.39341795444488525,
0.3795577585697174,
0.8765448927879333,
-0.8545402884483337,
-0.028677456080913544,
-0.27429771423339844,
0.4949055314064026,
-0.30891701579093933,
0.11517888307571411,
0.4579485356807709,
-1.100287675857544,
-0.4557786285877228,
-0.3107481896877289,
-0.8876327872276306,
-0.10797720402479172,
-0.12918077409267426,
-0.11916820704936981,
-0.011828110553324223,
0.4201311767101288,
-0.6871926188468933,
0.0781986266374588,
0.1501212865114212,
-0.2962096333503723,
0.688447117805481,
-0.0188593752682209,
0.3303399085998535,
-1.031114935874939,
0.39323359727859497,
-0.4046420753002167,
0.06219540908932686,
-0.8554632067680359,
0.17781692743301392,
-0.12609446048736572,
-0.33124035596847534,
-0.6314757466316223,
0.49008092284202576,
-0.03641817346215248,
0.2795838415622711,
-0.21936507523059845,
0.31797435879707336,
0.36729028820991516,
0.4740506112575531,
-0.029878348112106323,
1.125012755393982,
0.26224225759506226,
-0.6708563566207886,
0.7653777599334717,
0.45970839262008667,
0.05592813715338707,
0.5951347947120667,
-0.67850661277771,
0.194038525223732,
-0.2558773159980774,
0.1341424435377121,
-1.0036101341247559,
-0.18148577213287354,
0.4636572003364563,
-0.9892005324363708,
0.15761448442935944,
0.3954232931137085,
-0.08651449531316757,
-0.6815230846405029,
-0.5164417624473572,
0.3036549687385559,
0.20495034754276276,
-0.4124634563922882,
0.45924127101898193,
0.5456712245941162,
-0.23087096214294434,
-0.4951865077018738,
-0.6866821646690369,
0.4848302900791168,
-0.5000025033950806,
-0.5824767351150513,
-0.0018240271601825953,
-0.37540683150291443,
-0.1321234405040741,
0.16118738055229187,
0.46238934993743896,
-0.3430396318435669,
0.6113445162773132,
0.02393156848847866,
0.3024956285953522,
-0.2733701467514038,
-0.05322166532278061,
-0.36126771569252014,
0.1304684281349182,
0.4076196551322937,
-0.07957613468170166,
0.29859593510627747,
-0.03044428676366806,
0.06794518977403641,
-0.42411482334136963,
0.6701096892356873,
0.45875173807144165,
-0.34078919887542725,
0.3957943916320801,
0.6312364935874939,
-0.2751508057117462,
-0.21211187541484833,
-0.378449410200119,
-0.00138370250351727,
-0.45708024501800537,
0.4474814236164093,
-0.5488100051879883,
-0.8818352818489075,
0.28182724118232727,
0.36997881531715393,
0.1600535660982132,
0.46802207827568054,
0.25484591722488403,
-0.6249964833259583,
1.2365436553955078,
0.23811261355876923,
-0.1312856823205948,
0.023816252127289772,
-0.11299721896648407,
0.009518803097307682,
-0.6750191450119019,
-0.23424021899700165,
-0.6479695439338684,
-0.3978883922100067,
-0.1998140960931778,
0.13583721220493317,
0.41970497369766235,
-0.24238061904907227,
-0.2390275001525879,
0.1936117559671402,
-0.4278014898300171,
0.38049429655075073,
1.0218216180801392,
0.12888872623443604,
0.038420941680669785,
-0.5781173706054688,
0.20766673982143402,
0.23531363904476166,
-0.7853109836578369,
-0.22325195372104645,
1.2236242294311523,
0.053848423063755035,
0.5816149711608887,
0.1328386515378952,
0.7206259965896606,
0.5628257989883423,
0.022956591099500656,
-0.3122238218784332,
0.5760071873664856,
-0.22211533784866333,
-0.86275714635849,
-0.5355631709098816,
-0.5191587805747986,
-0.6508943438529968,
-0.33358240127563477,
-0.09960205852985382,
-0.4455409049987793,
-0.10794638097286224,
0.2983580529689789,
-0.9266382455825806,
0.3995407819747925,
-0.5721280574798584,
0.8774083256721497,
-0.3812188506126404,
-0.17714689671993256,
0.29578185081481934,
-0.733054518699646,
0.36164143681526184,
0.26986992359161377,
-0.18825864791870117,
0.26675155758857727,
0.09651494026184082,
0.7641803026199341,
-0.14466848969459534,
0.7436473369598389,
-0.24499283730983734,
0.018681542947888374,
0.6922745704650879,
0.28825002908706665,
0.32500964403152466,
0.2175222784280777,
0.05790477246046066,
-0.29750242829322815,
-0.0803816094994545,
-0.16825909912586212,
-0.651684045791626,
0.4834393262863159,
-0.8643937110900879,
-0.7986716032028198,
-0.4064357876777649,
-0.95745849609375,
-0.3902401328086853,
-0.0033234022557735443,
0.44838815927505493,
0.6419040560722351,
-0.5066236853599548,
0.09353912621736526,
0.8410294651985168,
-0.09715192764997482,
0.31371012330055237,
0.26447319984436035,
0.13107088208198547,
-0.3754412829875946,
1.3153482675552368,
-0.27971115708351135,
0.2482745200395584,
0.7333514094352722,
0.09776481240987778,
-0.5468840003013611,
-0.570277988910675,
-0.8014839887619019,
-0.09723465144634247,
-0.356853187084198,
-0.13890135288238525,
-0.5327885150909424,
-0.4751195013523102,
-0.2292310893535614,
-0.1868550330400467,
0.08137542754411697,
-0.7175348997116089,
-0.4031953811645508,
0.17784874141216278,
0.20755553245544434,
0.6754634976387024,
0.1413269191980362,
0.15585492551326752,
-0.6923919916152954,
0.5856006741523743,
0.5020714402198792,
0.046085696667432785,
-0.3153665065765381,
-0.32096055150032043,
-0.1250414401292801,
0.20304472744464874,
-0.330119252204895,
-0.7089169025421143,
-0.0946759283542633,
0.39097511768341064,
0.14124149084091187,
0.2930944263935089,
0.24611689150333405,
0.35762879252433777,
-0.26470741629600525,
0.9011969566345215,
-0.0480574406683445,
-0.37248942255973816,
0.41866734623908997,
-0.41231948137283325,
0.2627159655094147,
0.8445410132408142,
0.45760810375213623,
-0.6494368314743042,
-0.7534364461898804,
-0.5895799398422241,
-0.3011288046836853,
0.7376141548156738,
0.05668230727314949,
-0.021128788590431213,
-0.056516408920288086,
0.43798622488975525,
0.0422370545566082,
0.44637584686279297,
-0.36271700263023376,
-0.37594902515411377,
-0.2562347650527954,
-0.31331512331962585,
-0.1544688194990158,
-0.08780456334352493,
-0.29964354634284973,
0.23819680511951447,
0.6069838404655457,
-0.08825435489416122,
-0.03711685910820961,
-0.0035436402540653944,
-0.02352958358824253,
0.12333399057388306,
0.13555040955543518,
0.5010642409324646,
0.27047401666641235,
-0.36235079169273376,
0.0572379007935524,
0.1093490794301033,
-0.456258624792099,
0.04445739462971687,
0.35176947712898254,
-0.7448537349700928,
-0.18708688020706177,
0.0667252168059349,
0.6631243228912354,
-0.10748126357793808,
-0.6778411269187927,
0.42795342206954956,
-0.5230758786201477,
-0.39237093925476074,
-0.37478873133659363,
0.4786036014556885,
0.19405005872249603,
0.08297814428806305,
0.3786606192588806,
0.12461291998624802,
0.4612617790699005,
-0.49006783962249756,
0.4040538966655731,
0.6547890901565552,
-0.4490795135498047,
0.021152101457118988,
0.9625774621963501,
0.3316514790058136,
-0.6384267210960388,
0.5965730547904968,
-0.41318920254707336,
-0.6988834142684937,
0.7815543413162231,
0.290764719247818,
0.8025268912315369,
-0.1636982560157776,
0.6279799938201904,
0.14355875551700592,
0.14251738786697388,
0.561082661151886,
0.4820144474506378,
-0.072601817548275,
-0.3792514204978943,
0.2617376446723938,
-0.37430185079574585,
-0.5590142011642456,
0.15950965881347656,
-0.43936458230018616,
0.17196369171142578,
-0.47012537717819214,
0.07841580361127853,
0.11701478064060211,
0.21292737126350403,
-0.4318158030509949,
0.3703201711177826,
0.2153952419757843,
0.8296740651130676,
-0.7126851081848145,
0.1430605798959732,
0.7579262852668762,
-0.6819624900817871,
-0.44777026772499084,
-0.1566653698682785,
-0.11350850015878677,
-0.786261796951294,
0.09572675079107285,
0.03195442259311676,
-0.0529511384665966,
0.16594502329826355,
-0.5355200171470642,
-0.5653709769248962,
0.9320341944694519,
-0.042862892150878906,
0.0021705524995923042,
-0.4720194935798645,
0.6715100407600403,
0.4972008466720581,
-0.35364311933517456,
0.4010356068611145,
0.5096692442893982,
0.23293659090995789,
0.1052519679069519,
-0.48412269353866577,
0.05192188173532486,
-0.6157770156860352,
-0.2653592824935913,
0.2353227138519287,
-0.7562059164047241,
0.7594892382621765,
-0.2748456299304962,
-0.1898428499698639,
0.2888876795768738,
0.6084355115890503,
0.17302094399929047,
0.37797072529792786,
0.3304426074028015,
0.4818238317966461,
0.7978107333183289,
-0.1427210420370102,
0.9581906795501709,
-0.2711208462715149,
-0.21305842697620392,
1.0219810009002686,
-0.15958993136882782,
0.5713458061218262,
0.3328508138656616,
-0.10449887067079544,
0.1302643120288849,
0.4552692472934723,
-0.12841376662254333,
0.29180240631103516,
0.37671223282814026,
-0.28154128789901733,
-0.2222374528646469,
-0.46738192439079285,
-0.3556017279624939,
0.5354139804840088,
0.10170714557170868,
0.287407249212265,
-0.15048527717590332,
0.03459779918193817,
-0.04311342164874077,
0.18062876164913177,
-0.04163498431444168,
0.8853796124458313,
-0.1853926181793213,
-0.8871163725852966,
0.4802919626235962,
-0.34604665637016296,
0.3787834048271179,
-0.4956813156604767,
-0.00023699492157902569,
-0.27556172013282776,
0.1477546989917755,
0.07087624818086624,
-1.0621769428253174,
0.024869011715054512,
-0.05247332900762558,
-0.08096294105052948,
0.332302451133728,
0.298799067735672,
-0.4771476686000824,
-0.48794183135032654,
-0.3672599494457245,
0.28293904662132263,
0.10083726793527603,
-0.057407934218645096,
-0.700505793094635,
-0.2073020040988922,
-0.09995467960834503,
-0.07293035089969635,
0.022484835237264633,
0.42376258969306946,
0.21113939583301544,
0.8785058856010437,
0.45212283730506897,
0.26899105310440063,
0.09174327552318573,
0.09851565212011337,
0.878363311290741,
-0.6022325158119202,
-0.6627945899963379,
-0.4636211693286896,
0.4483584463596344,
-0.28028956055641174,
-0.6880281567573547,
0.5638713240623474,
0.7814881205558777,
0.49369147419929504,
0.05157246068120003,
1.2207024097442627,
-0.16100634634494781,
0.6931670308113098,
-0.2348388284444809,
0.8392305970191956,
-0.6608757376670837,
-0.08018847554922104,
0.13593100011348724,
-0.3267861008644104,
-0.15755176544189453,
-0.26191261410713196,
0.00720710214227438,
-0.21623878180980682,
0.6289306879043579,
0.7342559099197388,
0.11769267171621323,
0.3097865879535675,
0.039013076573610306,
0.14146175980567932,
0.44153308868408203,
1.2280033826828003,
1.1318790912628174,
-0.5965244770050049,
1.2078145742416382,
-0.3319195806980133,
-0.3291754722595215,
-0.24812394380569458,
-0.3464513421058655,
-1.0146875381469727,
-0.545176088809967,
-0.2942931354045868,
-0.3559887707233429,
0.32160934805870056,
0.39106568694114685,
-0.07431794703006744,
-0.7710087299346924,
-0.052244026213884354,
0.002205644501373172,
-0.03085109405219555,
-0.014225061051547527,
-0.2708263397216797,
0.3692781329154968,
-0.32306182384490967,
-0.621496319770813,
0.2998499572277069,
0.042616214603185654,
-0.08837111294269562,
-0.4482557475566864,
0.054288942366838455,
-0.335110604763031,
0.07109127193689346,
0.09945070743560791,
0.7629252672195435,
-0.3940596282482147,
-0.27434492111206055,
0.4216463267803192,
-0.1434592455625534,
-0.018206778913736343,
0.5907665491104126,
-0.6152437925338745,
0.34956493973731995,
0.34955182671546936,
1.0282986164093018,
0.12180694937705994,
0.2735641598701477,
0.696701169013977,
-0.43263906240463257,
-0.3604041337966919,
0.5129241943359375,
-0.09788274765014648,
0.3422076404094696,
-0.6133657097816467,
0.15328578650951385,
0.1043141633272171,
-0.5620768070220947,
-0.785463809967041,
0.2371155172586441,
-0.569221556186676,
-0.29876306653022766,
0.9792062044143677,
0.02249952405691147,
-0.4569008946418762,
-0.37062808871269226,
-0.42681100964546204,
0.3141690790653229,
-0.20855973660945892,
1.279327154159546,
0.7126502990722656,
-0.2856124937534332,
0.1547004133462906,
-0.2019682377576828,
0.8267417550086975,
0.3341326117515564,
-0.8515543937683105,
0.12230457365512848,
0.4704943299293518,
0.1939762830734253,
0.07266560196876526,
0.6377203464508057,
0.17147642374038696,
0.9926981925964355,
0.29201027750968933,
-0.12410995364189148,
-0.600442111492157,
-0.7102401256561279,
-0.1527264565229416,
0.6190817952156067,
-0.018179738894104958,
-0.48004892468452454
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07260v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07260v1
|
CKERC : Joint Large Language Models with Commonsense Knowledge for Emotion Recognition in Conversation
| 2024-03-12T02:37:11 | 2024-03-12T02:37:11 |
Yumeng Fu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Emotion recognition in conversation (ERC) is a task which predicts the
emotion of an utterance in the context of a conversation. It tightly depends on
dialogue context, speaker identity information, multiparty dialogue scenario
and so on. However, the state-of-the-art method (instructERC) solely
identifying speaker, and ignores commonsense knowledge(i.e., reaction of the
listeners and intention of the speaker, etc.) behind speakers during a
conversation, which can deeply mine speaker information. To this end, we
propose a novel joint large language models with commonsense knowledge
framework for emotion recognition in conversation, namely CKERC.We design
prompts to generate interlocutors' commonsense based on historical utterances
with large language model. And we use the interlocutor commonsense
identification task for LLM pre-training to fine-tune speaker implicit clues
information.By solving above challenge, our method achieve state-of-the-art.We
extensive experiment on three widely-used datasets, i.e., IEMOCAP, MELD,
EmoryNLP, demonstrate our method superiority. Also, we conduct in-depth
analysis and further demonstrate the effectiveness of commonsense knowledge in
ERC task in large language model.
|
[
-0.5250086784362793,
-0.6796472072601318,
0.4596027135848999,
0.03442816063761711,
-0.14821875095367432,
-0.3598126471042633,
-0.3013404607772827,
-0.4054359197616577,
0.038308121263980865,
0.254986047744751,
-0.6183739900588989,
-0.668269693851471,
-0.6247308850288391,
0.07709550857543945,
-0.19540171325206757,
0.8103245496749878,
-0.024775946512818336,
0.12968122959136963,
-0.3869183361530304,
-0.4624663293361664,
-0.22442246973514557,
-0.5325489044189453,
-0.45235979557037354,
-0.18869194388389587,
0.3368116617202759,
0.7858906984329224,
0.07194043695926666,
-0.20503631234169006,
0.22551804780960083,
0.4062134325504303,
-0.2782209515571594,
0.09431509673595428,
-0.663774311542511,
0.21867483854293823,
-0.011547128669917583,
-0.1422683745622635,
-0.27228844165802,
-0.1777113676071167,
0.42877793312072754,
0.1449074000120163,
-0.32747602462768555,
-0.2152857929468155,
0.09859000146389008,
0.5976243615150452,
-0.7703840136528015,
0.3752635419368744,
-0.7223576307296753,
0.24449533224105835,
-0.06913565844297409,
-0.2642744183540344,
-0.5946158766746521,
-0.3006863594055176,
0.1843632012605667,
-0.1367216408252716,
0.09937936812639236,
0.24113574624061584,
0.5548297762870789,
0.03546870872378349,
-0.5895801186561584,
-0.5249156355857849,
-0.3594609200954437,
0.5500388741493225,
-0.9871106147766113,
0.5487625002861023,
0.31062373518943787,
0.08164571225643158,
-0.08947325497865677,
-0.3391793966293335,
-0.9883975982666016,
-0.3854720890522003,
-0.07767694443464279,
0.4238443970680237,
-0.16457496583461761,
0.25384488701820374,
0.4350621700286865,
0.29590484499931335,
-0.39331546425819397,
0.2821759283542633,
-0.20597326755523682,
-0.05391492322087288,
0.3839617669582367,
0.3113822937011719,
0.2627958059310913,
-0.12093384563922882,
-0.5179154276847839,
-0.13860467076301575,
-0.6058587431907654,
0.05079501494765282,
0.4398193061351776,
0.1213601753115654,
-0.41296666860580444,
0.2568339407444,
-0.38118472695350647,
0.12732313573360443,
-0.03842676058411598,
0.11704674363136292,
0.09690652042627335,
0.21197187900543213,
-0.02313041500747204,
0.34028926491737366,
0.9469976425170898,
0.3701452314853668,
0.37505272030830383,
0.2944314479827881,
0.10979422926902771,
-0.2672697901725769,
0.043109435588121414,
-0.7192978262901306,
-0.243086040019989,
0.39288538694381714,
-0.30977949500083923,
-0.05086154863238335,
-0.1854574829339981,
-1.2066457271575928,
-0.4365849792957306,
-0.26479631662368774,
0.13474693894386292,
-0.25944751501083374,
-0.5204668641090393,
-0.22351109981536865,
0.24328561127185822,
0.33010444045066833,
0.5697842836380005,
-0.9989827275276184,
0.33410558104515076,
0.6279438138008118,
0.6566672921180725,
0.12946228682994843,
-0.17808650434017181,
-0.4813988208770752,
-0.13332094252109528,
0.025804461911320686,
0.6045188903808594,
-0.6648390889167786,
-0.4356394112110138,
0.23611336946487427,
-0.05835554376244545,
0.1941380649805069,
-0.3248656392097473,
0.5186053514480591,
-0.4244672656059265,
0.11914752423763275,
-0.1666342318058014,
-0.516189694404602,
-0.09347928315401077,
0.2672949433326721,
-0.6298506855964661,
0.8340692520141602,
-0.1219908595085144,
-1.1441338062286377,
-0.043794047087430954,
-0.6381955742835999,
-0.3809701204299927,
0.20869211852550507,
0.09697605669498444,
-0.2775733172893524,
0.19021151959896088,
0.3153439462184906,
0.7649441957473755,
-0.285695880651474,
0.2911929488182068,
-0.7105686664581299,
0.02573435939848423,
0.4428131878376007,
-0.5190955400466919,
0.33943042159080505,
0.21059650182724,
-0.22367674112319946,
-0.01781250536441803,
-0.5556826591491699,
-0.15761929750442505,
-0.11221442371606827,
0.010868008248507977,
-0.2586005926132202,
-0.16488295793533325,
0.026936009526252747,
0.3239820897579193,
-0.05155659839510918,
-0.5676013827323914,
-0.20380976796150208,
-0.18711814284324646,
0.4156701862812042,
1.07183039188385,
-0.10768662393093109,
0.2495490461587906,
0.40670663118362427,
0.23467043042182922,
0.14077945053577423,
0.060693733394145966,
-0.09633345901966095,
-0.26142826676368713,
-0.8721646666526794,
-0.16241909563541412,
0.13239380717277527,
0.522962749004364,
-0.3863440454006195,
0.4465935528278351,
-0.14132945239543915,
-0.2689688801765442,
-0.4671511650085449,
-0.17473085224628448,
0.5187820196151733,
0.6356968879699707,
0.31618785858154297,
-0.2450392246246338,
-0.32249003648757935,
-0.8535311818122864,
-0.191090926527977,
-0.2833383083343506,
0.11896511912345886,
0.7286808490753174,
0.4096582531929016,
0.07385855913162231,
0.5659106969833374,
-0.5374886393547058,
-0.0743921771645546,
-0.31862732768058777,
0.6629518270492554,
-0.0485692135989666,
0.5542447566986084,
-0.09088914841413498,
-0.8519734144210815,
-0.5812048316001892,
0.16732405126094818,
-0.5752601027488708,
-0.14579139649868011,
0.1673835813999176,
-0.1207500547170639,
0.4003128707408905,
0.59438556432724,
-0.3737778961658478,
0.54100102186203,
0.665595293045044,
0.017015567049384117,
0.3351038098335266,
-0.2795765697956085,
0.5155161023139954,
-1.070291519165039,
0.042010705918073654,
0.219976544380188,
0.028137879446148872,
-0.6773733496665955,
-0.3872886300086975,
0.15910211205482483,
-0.18543222546577454,
-0.6035405993461609,
0.7451649308204651,
-0.27569079399108887,
0.14083407819271088,
-0.05647043138742447,
0.3170446753501892,
-0.34526246786117554,
0.9531915187835693,
0.37021031975746155,
0.21371549367904663,
0.3547554612159729,
-0.4617704153060913,
0.563130795955658,
0.29245758056640625,
-0.5115920901298523,
1.1177953481674194,
-0.34716731309890747,
0.46738165616989136,
-0.23283715546131134,
0.4460214674472809,
-1.0173454284667969,
-0.46241989731788635,
0.21632936596870422,
-0.33929499983787537,
0.4861714243888855,
-0.17963044345378876,
-0.3621635138988495,
-0.23744608461856842,
0.24714885652065277,
0.46478644013404846,
0.45329490303993225,
-0.8082365393638611,
0.9979880452156067,
0.19213660061359406,
-0.7263461351394653,
-0.6023378968238831,
-0.5503938794136047,
-0.056449491530656815,
-0.2542557716369629,
-0.5311403870582581,
-0.10409986972808838,
-0.17299184203147888,
-0.12717632949352264,
-0.3571607172489166,
-0.03356868773698807,
-0.08634325116872787,
-0.28744515776634216,
0.5389339327812195,
0.23077118396759033,
0.1074867695569992,
0.4341888129711151,
0.07370433211326599,
-0.24557296931743622,
0.013533859513700008,
0.3758591115474701,
0.49590247869491577,
-0.23406973481178284,
-0.4968888461589813,
-0.7740657329559326,
0.6050869226455688,
0.4253746271133423,
-0.23335471749305725,
0.5722033977508545,
0.5895935893058777,
-0.18644002079963684,
-0.028673402965068817,
-0.900766909122467,
-0.2322102040052414,
-0.4424745440483093,
0.6998395323753357,
-0.36211466789245605,
-1.0798579454421997,
0.47830238938331604,
-0.500467836856842,
-0.2261626422405243,
0.19908957183361053,
0.5900309085845947,
-0.18430523574352264,
0.8617009520530701,
0.35815224051475525,
-0.34351295232772827,
0.4641292095184326,
0.1783181130886078,
0.37906625866889954,
-0.9551711082458496,
-0.32253026962280273,
-0.6574413180351257,
-0.3448033034801483,
-0.3431375324726105,
-0.2464628368616104,
0.40784114599227905,
-0.08518485724925995,
-0.17290712893009186,
0.022930460050702095,
-0.11726117134094238,
0.5025072693824768,
0.37699708342552185,
0.23528160154819489,
0.017012055963277817,
-0.2824765741825104,
-0.029925057664513588,
-0.13391099870204926,
-0.36507540941238403,
-0.2534990608692169,
0.6750797033309937,
0.39223799109458923,
0.6507741808891296,
-0.07511846721172333,
0.7512595057487488,
0.05928397551178932,
0.4320588707923889,
-0.6788185238838196,
0.7329865097999573,
0.062320392578840256,
-0.5252168774604797,
-0.16995269060134888,
-0.738649308681488,
-0.2998470067977905,
-0.016001032665371895,
-0.23544201254844666,
-1.2347710132598877,
0.10778386145830154,
0.40726953744888306,
-0.006514927837997675,
0.4275768995285034,
-0.7669263482093811,
0.8980845808982849,
-0.2212403416633606,
-0.336979478597641,
-0.6324821710586548,
-0.8787861466407776,
0.24363724887371063,
0.2500396966934204,
0.1894630491733551,
-0.18282422423362732,
0.4844885766506195,
0.6144962906837463,
-0.3857133686542511,
0.8840592503547668,
-0.2580675482749939,
-0.12524208426475525,
0.23253200948238373,
0.028277931734919548,
1.1016132831573486,
0.10536518692970276,
-0.037550102919340134,
0.18615873157978058,
-0.38804957270622253,
-0.12775586545467377,
-0.5719267725944519,
0.8191501498222351,
-0.40029215812683105,
-0.42585489153862,
-0.15918473899364471,
-0.44888079166412354,
-0.3278244137763977,
-0.22736001014709473,
0.30525919795036316,
0.584722638130188,
-0.5934388041496277,
0.1657279133796692,
0.9137119054794312,
-0.41618210077285767,
0.20209874212741852,
0.5316060185432434,
0.45813071727752686,
-0.4774205684661865,
0.7234525680541992,
-0.37830275297164917,
0.37309205532073975,
0.7764549255371094,
0.17380288243293762,
-0.3204628825187683,
-0.31284573674201965,
0.0036731127183884382,
0.11846646666526794,
-0.951135516166687,
-0.2673550844192505,
-0.9021478295326233,
0.06430664658546448,
-0.4999047815799713,
-0.2344222515821457,
-0.31795814633369446,
0.010296843945980072,
-0.2585286796092987,
-0.26314008235931396,
0.6170339584350586,
0.5793821811676025,
-0.12578332424163818,
0.2376953810453415,
-0.8725889325141907,
0.21402493119239807,
0.6748021245002747,
0.3483002483844757,
0.2597085237503052,
-0.3942670226097107,
-0.0872490182518959,
0.15674786269664764,
-0.13055221736431122,
-0.8197661638259888,
0.4574035704135895,
0.10643358528614044,
0.29474589228630066,
0.6859733462333679,
0.4718687832355499,
0.5717250108718872,
-0.2736032009124756,
0.6037866473197937,
0.5653189420700073,
-1.2953370809555054,
0.2893478572368622,
0.04284963384270668,
0.2712726593017578,
0.5141815543174744,
0.4832517206668854,
-0.8910900354385376,
-0.20813503861427307,
-0.7487912774085999,
-0.9729844927787781,
0.921584963798523,
0.0464789904654026,
0.14556513726711273,
0.09255769103765488,
-0.14463399350643158,
-0.005055909510701895,
0.11741486191749573,
-0.7083384394645691,
0.15418806672096252,
-0.01737077906727791,
-0.6752317547798157,
0.26310259103775024,
-0.5325784087181091,
-0.1903410106897354,
0.01547178253531456,
0.6700950860977173,
-0.2357138693332672,
0.3005279302597046,
0.11926830559968948,
-0.10966431349515915,
-0.20648935437202454,
0.6593148112297058,
0.5295108556747437,
-0.18106867372989655,
-0.3205971419811249,
0.12336652725934982,
0.7820993065834045,
-0.1762082576751709,
-0.2249976545572281,
-0.01665046438574791,
0.7214789986610413,
-0.4158031940460205,
0.42099636793136597,
1.2136601209640503,
0.522604763507843,
-0.742078423500061,
0.6730992197990417,
-0.05381518974900246,
-0.08807828277349472,
-0.26426512002944946,
-0.2491028904914856,
0.23668338358402252,
0.6599968075752258,
-0.006386615335941315,
-0.05184875801205635,
0.1914702206850052,
-0.4960341453552246,
-0.1298571079969406,
0.41552579402923584,
-0.6977711915969849,
-0.3121227025985718,
0.17035920917987823,
0.5445688366889954,
-0.03635004907846451,
0.9838070273399353,
-0.055471476167440414,
-0.9807036519050598,
0.5094254016876221,
0.28466981649398804,
1.0477510690689087,
-0.4334539473056793,
-0.017869222909212112,
0.5300852656364441,
-0.24265901744365692,
0.10115224123001099,
0.11572635918855667,
-0.5603857636451721,
-0.6370154023170471,
-0.08180279284715652,
-0.360995352268219,
-0.5717662572860718,
-0.12355921417474747,
-0.6571091413497925,
0.25579503178596497,
-0.1847040355205536,
0.20155559480190277,
-0.4483031630516052,
-0.21033085882663727,
-0.7704525589942932,
0.019858146086335182,
0.44127389788627625,
0.6795424818992615,
-0.9303415417671204,
0.7399170398712158,
0.20393893122673035,
-0.022619279101490974,
-0.8552887439727783,
-0.1288214921951294,
0.2182445228099823,
-0.6143383979797363,
0.8249478936195374,
0.23584815859794617,
-0.11189520359039307,
-0.02698446437716484,
-0.7329744100570679,
-0.347060889005661,
0.9394700527191162,
0.035145100206136703,
-0.8107120990753174,
0.18661177158355713,
-0.01166209951043129,
0.38803955912590027,
-0.4203130006790161,
0.7366490960121155,
0.1982027292251587,
0.529114305973053,
0.6344623565673828,
-0.8458445072174072,
-0.09205885231494904,
-0.306048184633255,
-0.290318101644516,
0.41878873109817505,
-0.679882287979126,
0.4813983738422394,
-0.346123605966568,
-0.40088900923728943,
0.07169213891029358,
0.7567365169525146,
0.2734789252281189,
0.5575167536735535,
0.671556293964386,
0.6933375000953674,
0.6571794748306274,
-0.1761517971754074,
0.6198703646659851,
-0.08425997197628021,
0.29679328203201294,
1.226523518562317,
-0.5578073263168335,
1.0975008010864258,
0.3264574706554413,
-0.2841235399246216,
0.453078955411911,
0.25866585969924927,
0.22995738685131073,
0.39435839653015137,
0.21757352352142334,
-0.5451716184616089,
-0.30480656027793884,
-0.18848346173763275,
-0.28309130668640137,
0.2538483142852783,
0.6379610896110535,
-0.20145291090011597,
0.007163162808865309,
0.10985269397497177,
0.22510799765586853,
-0.1976378709077835,
-0.26540443301200867,
1.123518943786621,
0.22337087988853455,
-0.44230952858924866,
0.4386900067329407,
-0.4847182035446167,
0.7668870091438293,
-0.7779476046562195,
-0.21708527207374573,
-0.2384338676929474,
0.12332762777805328,
-0.2354705035686493,
-0.731881320476532,
-0.2377137690782547,
0.05930528789758682,
0.15374788641929626,
-0.042122501879930496,
0.6046399474143982,
-0.7966569066047668,
0.018186494708061218,
0.2516416311264038,
-0.20907209813594818,
0.2516535818576813,
-0.1961551457643509,
-0.45080992579460144,
0.05967690423130989,
0.023836862295866013,
-0.14294224977493286,
0.318701833486557,
0.9038167595863342,
0.2761572599411011,
0.6528174877166748,
0.36839452385902405,
-0.15613557398319244,
-0.29043570160865784,
0.1507692039012909,
0.840910792350769,
-0.7397814393043518,
-0.3757613003253937,
-0.5865323543548584,
0.7151298522949219,
-0.2779873013496399,
-0.3900828957557678,
0.2204124629497528,
-0.0001220308622578159,
0.5860405564308167,
-0.1419222503900528,
0.5701791644096375,
-0.1814424693584442,
0.3260118067264557,
-0.6949606537818909,
0.49045228958129883,
-0.42671069502830505,
-0.03983674570918083,
-0.717944324016571,
-0.6661695837974548,
0.006039408501237631,
0.3925337791442871,
-0.35408931970596313,
0.034374963492155075,
0.7438051104545593,
1.0906314849853516,
-0.0005232301773503423,
0.608527660369873,
0.29995012283325195,
0.48085635900497437,
0.18126243352890015,
0.8369945883750916,
1.0154564380645752,
-0.037021271884441376,
0.4913117587566376,
-0.2937929034233093,
-0.1801917403936386,
-0.629503607749939,
-0.991622269153595,
-0.7576765418052673,
-0.8953108787536621,
-0.44671911001205444,
-0.22891466319561005,
0.06053241342306137,
1.1590707302093506,
0.5442507863044739,
-0.9332517981529236,
-0.008539226837456226,
-0.09665308892726898,
-0.01735389418900013,
-0.055966444313526154,
-0.24126115441322327,
0.3646480143070221,
-0.07140091061592102,
-0.8928329348564148,
0.16690227389335632,
0.44726529717445374,
0.0447150394320488,
0.06597481667995453,
-0.40155693888664246,
-0.18993866443634033,
-0.09074398130178452,
0.375201016664505,
0.40135031938552856,
-0.6524649262428284,
-0.32140564918518066,
-0.4353068470954895,
0.023358028382062912,
0.046668484807014465,
1.0086668729782104,
-0.41551831364631653,
0.7382248044013977,
0.6294683218002319,
0.20030634105205536,
0.4029027819633484,
-0.11965280771255493,
0.581449568271637,
-0.7100396752357483,
0.29413479566574097,
0.4038653075695038,
0.577501654624939,
0.4073823392391205,
-0.3390202820301056,
0.1483563929796219,
-0.14649634063243866,
-0.7078097462654114,
-0.7048923373222351,
0.4316459894180298,
-1.2382848262786865,
-0.04861225560307503,
0.9652448892593384,
-0.43712225556373596,
-0.12036991864442825,
0.051479142159223557,
-0.4196528494358063,
0.3024841547012329,
-0.7939286828041077,
0.6275104880332947,
0.7249233722686768,
0.058393217623233795,
-0.5563687086105347,
-0.17056287825107574,
0.2958524525165558,
0.310798317193985,
-0.8883825540542603,
0.5530025362968445,
0.47475576400756836,
-0.11754864454269409,
0.0274028480052948,
0.5788297653198242,
-0.0951596051454544,
-0.05260240659117699,
-0.024230683222413063,
0.4950602054595947,
0.18950511515140533,
-0.20663322508335114,
-0.19260480999946594,
0.0930030569434166,
-0.09209297597408295,
0.3099721372127533
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07230v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07230v1
|
Curry-DPO: Enhancing Alignment using Curriculum Learning & Ranked Preferences
| 2024-03-12T00:58:19 | 2024-03-12T00:58:19 |
Pulkit Pattnaik, Rishabh Maheshwary, Kelechi Ogueji, Vikas Yadav, Sathwik Tejaswi Madhusudhan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) is an effective technique that leverages
pairwise preference data (usually one chosen and rejected response pair per
user prompt) to align LLMs to human preferences. In practice, multiple
responses can exist for a given prompt with varying quality relative to each
other. With availability of such quality ratings for multiple responses, we
propose utilizing these responses to create multiple preference pairs for a
given prompt. Our work focuses on systematically using the constructed multiple
preference pair in DPO training via curriculum learning methodology. In
particular, we order these multiple pairs of preference data from easy to hard
(emulating curriculum training) according to various criteria. We show detailed
comparisons of our proposed approach to the standard single-pair DPO setting.
Our method, which we call Curry-DPO consistently shows increased performance
gains on MTbench, Vicuna, WizardLM, and the UltraFeedback test set,
highlighting its effectiveness. More specifically, Curry-DPO achieves a score
of 7.43 on MT-bench with Zephy-7B model outperforming majority of existing LLMs
with similar parameter size. Curry-DPO also achieves the highest adjusted win
rates on Vicuna, WizardLM, and UltraFeedback test datasets (90.7%, 87.1%, and
87.9% respectively) in our experiments, with notable gains of upto 7.5% when
compared to standard DPO technique.
|
[
-0.26382383704185486,
-0.3342720568180084,
0.4563368558883667,
0.18017742037773132,
-0.246336430311203,
0.4339553117752075,
-0.04998287558555603,
0.14348839223384857,
0.17852073907852173,
0.35586926341056824,
-0.4594219923019409,
-0.42064183950424194,
-0.5323954224586487,
0.014149943366646767,
0.3576216399669647,
0.644946277141571,
-0.1614982932806015,
0.3019275963306427,
-0.1525818556547165,
-0.129178985953331,
-0.9732365608215332,
-0.3161431550979614,
-0.34112653136253357,
-0.5447784662246704,
0.3911210298538208,
1.0666043758392334,
0.6981328129768372,
0.8289453387260437,
0.786445677280426,
0.2242342084646225,
0.29701006412506104,
0.43612492084503174,
-0.7808122634887695,
0.3691912293434143,
-0.01638765260577202,
-0.24973301589488983,
-0.6328609585762024,
0.3097933530807495,
0.7784465551376343,
0.6295773983001709,
-0.2416260540485382,
0.037079162895679474,
0.26660841703414917,
1.2175049781799316,
-0.8081670999526978,
-0.15392212569713593,
-0.636664867401123,
0.43252435326576233,
-0.0088079534471035,
-0.4772889018058777,
-0.6151227951049805,
-0.6896890997886658,
0.09965275973081589,
-0.8024831414222717,
-0.18705688416957855,
0.20375575125217438,
0.5347447991371155,
0.32323214411735535,
-0.6678435802459717,
-0.08447808027267456,
-0.39687225222587585,
1.0800870656967163,
-0.21175935864448547,
0.34770485758781433,
0.30783534049987793,
0.4516497850418091,
-0.4949566125869751,
-0.1514137238264084,
-0.49358341097831726,
-0.05099168047308922,
0.17029932141304016,
0.7650591731071472,
0.5024617910385132,
0.15288497507572174,
0.017329629510641098,
0.550701916217804,
-0.3359270691871643,
0.3314514756202698,
-0.06243607774376869,
-0.02908332273364067,
0.6533293128013611,
0.35763174295425415,
0.04419993609189987,
-0.19252727925777435,
-0.8584679365158081,
-0.4042195975780487,
-0.5689578652381897,
0.44209837913513184,
0.565472424030304,
0.30300334095954895,
0.12158507853746414,
0.5448228120803833,
-0.13695597648620605,
0.8044401407241821,
0.5205974578857422,
-0.6605153679847717,
0.1502058207988739,
-0.1867966502904892,
-0.2269352823495865,
0.3276664912700653,
0.7373272180557251,
0.8780173659324646,
0.11845012754201889,
0.050479572266340256,
0.05631093680858612,
-0.09472816437482834,
0.157437264919281,
-0.7335639595985413,
-0.20404662191867828,
0.14452655613422394,
-0.4790496230125427,
-0.670911967754364,
0.00034135463647544384,
-0.850929856300354,
-0.434722900390625,
-0.8087450861930847,
0.18264394998550415,
-0.5997105836868286,
-0.21249422430992126,
0.1934889703989029,
-0.17030560970306396,
0.5118979811668396,
0.3949754536151886,
-1.2758204936981201,
0.3323349952697754,
0.6299681663513184,
0.7190952897071838,
-0.5570158362388611,
-0.2812221050262451,
-0.6840524673461914,
0.3257703185081482,
-0.5077229142189026,
0.5076311826705933,
-0.7963289618492126,
-0.6319981217384338,
-0.16144831478595734,
-0.46852606534957886,
-0.09502779692411423,
-0.44817054271698,
0.534744918346405,
-0.4993062913417816,
0.11166030913591385,
-0.49743133783340454,
-0.7562091946601868,
0.1251000165939331,
0.2930881679058075,
-0.4454575181007385,
1.2318693399429321,
0.039394546300172806,
-0.5414579510688782,
0.5050833225250244,
-0.46052286028862,
-0.07558251172304153,
-0.1686103194952011,
-0.32544654607772827,
-0.22953492403030396,
-0.19772495329380035,
0.20191670954227448,
0.4805794060230255,
-0.30326634645462036,
0.22373022139072418,
-0.4345121383666992,
-0.4486692249774933,
0.0942312628030777,
-0.14595496654510498,
0.7440546751022339,
0.18628941476345062,
-0.0538594126701355,
-0.08077198266983032,
-0.9323908090591431,
0.18224376440048218,
0.09383700042963028,
-0.3868257999420166,
-0.48919519782066345,
-0.1697576642036438,
-0.6165251731872559,
0.12309090793132782,
0.08668022602796555,
-0.5185837745666504,
0.6836152672767639,
-0.25370997190475464,
-0.05076628550887108,
1.250951886177063,
-0.33925145864486694,
0.6768047213554382,
-0.42477717995643616,
0.47960901260375977,
0.055559273809194565,
0.2485922873020172,
0.23410387337207794,
-0.5649590492248535,
-0.24567075073719025,
-0.412731796503067,
0.11298388987779617,
0.6077295541763306,
-0.619478166103363,
0.483455628156662,
-0.17892500758171082,
-0.3505953252315521,
-0.5404762029647827,
0.3559064269065857,
0.4301215708255768,
1.2771188020706177,
0.42667698860168457,
-0.46266499161720276,
-0.3464869558811188,
-0.782170832157135,
0.030351197347044945,
-0.19720815122127533,
0.23153825104236603,
0.40065377950668335,
-0.05381381884217262,
0.10005050897598267,
1.185416340827942,
-0.9933916926383972,
-0.10972931236028671,
0.09517665207386017,
-0.22880104184150696,
0.06644994765520096,
0.5244137048721313,
0.6537628173828125,
-0.6678309440612793,
-0.8673644661903381,
-0.09781107306480408,
-0.5383189916610718,
-0.04103659465909004,
0.27539560198783875,
-0.6496952176094055,
-0.17827756702899933,
-0.342559278011322,
0.07937240600585938,
0.09182777255773544,
0.37117576599121094,
0.1483955830335617,
0.48066386580467224,
-0.04798704758286476,
0.7026277780532837,
-1.3920207023620605,
-0.3495514392852783,
0.029204031452536583,
0.18070265650749207,
-0.5537645816802979,
-0.24004504084587097,
0.2621830701828003,
-0.16248930990695953,
-0.47617608308792114,
0.6200515031814575,
-0.2691554129123688,
0.027578335255384445,
-0.2524537146091461,
0.0828230082988739,
0.15435682237148285,
0.516528308391571,
0.13966040313243866,
0.8126997947692871,
0.5965589880943298,
-0.582476794719696,
0.7407366037368774,
0.5718621015548706,
-0.027898967266082764,
0.9480348825454712,
-0.25575771927833557,
0.39062318205833435,
0.024482103064656258,
0.28343239426612854,
-1.4072967767715454,
-0.18667906522750854,
0.44282612204551697,
-0.22161568701267242,
0.4292849898338318,
-0.1926208734512329,
-0.21167851984500885,
-0.30422136187553406,
-0.9962931275367737,
0.5458633899688721,
0.6093195676803589,
-0.9567583799362183,
0.11894156783819199,
0.09408188611268997,
0.2242562472820282,
-1.0192738771438599,
-0.3061029314994812,
-0.20408053696155548,
-0.28855836391448975,
-0.5826002955436707,
0.5487681031227112,
-0.2674643397331238,
-0.1861404925584793,
-0.5312038064002991,
-0.38884449005126953,
-0.1277116984128952,
-0.04268321022391319,
0.30973735451698303,
0.6639348268508911,
-0.13101424276828766,
0.2864995300769806,
0.16922883689403534,
-0.2460223138332367,
-0.40040841698646545,
-0.08397512882947922,
0.2810286283493042,
0.18901768326759338,
-0.22251205146312714,
-0.677737832069397,
0.30589643120765686,
0.44952574372291565,
-0.09467591345310211,
0.5395604372024536,
0.27310359477996826,
0.03886996954679489,
-0.009757188148796558,
-0.6580846905708313,
-0.21425816416740417,
-0.5183129906654358,
-0.2602650821208954,
-0.5924040079116821,
-0.4456573724746704,
0.18454574048519135,
-0.3065725862979889,
0.10645628720521927,
0.15243786573410034,
0.401538223028183,
0.041680969297885895,
1.0455318689346313,
0.4438284933567047,
-0.11980663239955902,
0.6416851282119751,
-0.03989732638001442,
-0.08507044613361359,
-1.0431169271469116,
-0.17004209756851196,
-0.173514723777771,
-0.5761868953704834,
-0.6071668267250061,
-0.30864205956459045,
0.15512937307357788,
0.009596784599125385,
-0.4918537437915802,
0.09556762129068375,
-0.9484350681304932,
0.5605038404464722,
0.8699131608009338,
0.520391047000885,
0.3282414972782135,
0.16234445571899414,
-0.4400637149810791,
-0.33124667406082153,
-0.5327342748641968,
-0.5939689874649048,
1.553114652633667,
0.07186070084571838,
0.9345723986625671,
0.12799622118473053,
1.0952993631362915,
0.0515873059630394,
0.07271227985620499,
-1.0593267679214478,
0.5197804570198059,
-0.1836233139038086,
-0.2374330312013626,
-0.0953880324959755,
-0.2981792092323303,
-0.7250545024871826,
0.24670039117336273,
-0.26004451513290405,
-0.4706369638442993,
0.1552501618862152,
0.2708108723163605,
-0.5962214469909668,
0.22674402594566345,
-0.8494038581848145,
0.4911574125289917,
-0.4516921639442444,
-0.8420372605323792,
-0.02410683035850525,
-0.9222347140312195,
0.45829254388809204,
0.08207090944051743,
-0.2631237804889679,
-0.34299811720848083,
-0.22954519093036652,
0.6547804474830627,
-0.23228785395622253,
0.5627744793891907,
-0.08883683383464813,
-0.09740772843360901,
0.10879257321357727,
-0.1882375329732895,
0.17597055435180664,
0.2524082660675049,
-0.4602850675582886,
-0.2505629062652588,
-0.032750751823186874,
-0.5163034200668335,
-0.6074712872505188,
1.0207194089889526,
-1.1974811553955078,
-0.7841482758522034,
-0.5672109127044678,
-0.6262496113777161,
-0.4421326518058777,
0.09447027742862701,
-0.14144404232501984,
0.3773302733898163,
-0.04155278205871582,
-0.09239954501390457,
0.6946377754211426,
0.05411984398961067,
0.17663954198360443,
0.6033116579055786,
0.037019938230514526,
-0.6973410248756409,
0.8480439782142639,
0.017859067767858505,
0.4210928976535797,
0.6059998273849487,
0.7127479314804077,
-0.2258848398923874,
-0.32291918992996216,
-0.5215930342674255,
-0.03300105407834053,
-0.6983833909034729,
-0.31003791093826294,
-0.26108717918395996,
0.04357900843024254,
-0.705623984336853,
-0.43935659527778625,
-0.3262282609939575,
-0.4714595377445221,
-0.22644813358783722,
0.022418804466724396,
0.267133504152298,
0.4202742576599121,
0.008605249226093292,
0.27214425802230835,
-0.6798138618469238,
0.45585623383522034,
0.5301162004470825,
0.4357825219631195,
-0.12767818570137024,
-0.4373175799846649,
0.2622285783290863,
0.13581117987632751,
-0.8813124895095825,
-1.034533977508545,
0.07046640664339066,
0.036913737654685974,
0.5494483709335327,
0.6279783844947815,
0.3345302939414978,
0.9040177464485168,
-0.5094746351242065,
0.6168352961540222,
0.5280935764312744,
-0.5574541091918945,
1.0813653469085693,
-0.21043242514133453,
-0.02278275229036808,
0.9332680106163025,
0.7200989127159119,
-0.0518404021859169,
0.0868363007903099,
-0.2863065004348755,
-0.43786153197288513,
0.766217052936554,
-0.07073044776916504,
-0.040236033499240875,
-0.024686701595783234,
0.6898238062858582,
0.5295339822769165,
0.1538752168416977,
-0.3201686143875122,
-0.4752174913883209,
-0.22899162769317627,
-0.2541874647140503,
0.16309143602848053,
-0.2688887119293213,
-0.4888026714324951,
-0.44930821657180786,
0.6988872289657593,
-0.11493907868862152,
-0.1641167551279068,
0.06772366166114807,
0.1999400109052658,
-0.10344856232404709,
0.20288385450839996,
0.5367975234985352,
0.6902910470962524,
-0.6042801141738892,
-0.04424896836280823,
-0.06568233668804169,
-0.6151832938194275,
0.5730865597724915,
-0.12224982678890228,
0.30607926845550537,
-0.4034314751625061,
-0.1496642827987671,
0.37750163674354553,
0.15601949393749237,
-0.2005426287651062,
0.4420773983001709,
-0.08960340917110443,
-0.13629770278930664,
0.07975076138973236,
0.22100333869457245,
-0.420907586812973,
-0.08856882154941559,
0.19820012152194977,
0.0015120567986741662,
0.15473859012126923,
-0.5335715413093567,
0.09609419852495193,
0.46351322531700134,
-0.2957434058189392,
-0.01128819677978754,
0.4721617102622986,
0.599342942237854,
-0.1513991802930832,
0.6428048610687256,
0.08257433027029037,
-0.3059496283531189,
0.5398704409599304,
0.6484538912773132,
0.5158476829528809,
-0.5243263840675354,
0.2601763904094696,
0.606123685836792,
-0.28176024556159973,
-0.2708556056022644,
-0.01118130050599575,
-0.3746558725833893,
-0.9668675065040588,
-0.0072984411381185055,
-0.47953203320503235,
-0.9095063209533691,
-0.33696362376213074,
-0.884322464466095,
0.6765739917755127,
-0.45761415362358093,
-0.1211378201842308,
-0.03531213849782944,
0.39431050419807434,
-0.5086662769317627,
0.03449677675962448,
-0.01983209326863289,
0.45805516839027405,
-0.7117060422897339,
0.8744370341300964,
0.8269957304000854,
-0.391765296459198,
-0.8625503182411194,
-0.05926148220896721,
0.4157995879650116,
-1.4413080215454102,
0.882977306842804,
0.18043728172779083,
-0.27910688519477844,
0.11392847448587418,
-0.034026507288217545,
-0.689898669719696,
1.4263291358947754,
0.4585759937763214,
-0.6809073090553284,
0.2716372609138489,
0.029256829991936684,
0.0938071757555008,
-0.369698166847229,
0.4077678620815277,
0.5252673029899597,
0.30833518505096436,
0.6739781498908997,
-0.8338161110877991,
-0.0255141481757164,
0.11576884239912033,
-0.018831957131624222,
0.36277005076408386,
-1.0501468181610107,
0.4708409905433655,
-0.21565589308738708,
0.0440455824136734,
-0.10424131900072098,
0.2150006890296936,
0.5092598795890808,
0.4914195239543915,
0.31012097001075745,
0.6800152659416199,
0.9031314849853516,
0.011025937274098396,
0.8137023448944092,
-0.49715158343315125,
0.2294788360595703,
1.0899577140808105,
-0.8167080283164978,
0.6605294942855835,
0.8153373599052429,
-0.2896500825881958,
0.24572230875492096,
0.8586722016334534,
0.26817554235458374,
0.6922446489334106,
0.2908531725406647,
-0.3037581443786621,
-0.23399710655212402,
-0.11410059779882431,
-0.6829968094825745,
0.48029759526252747,
-0.06335659325122833,
-0.1747698336839676,
0.09667041897773743,
-0.01931910216808319,
-0.14961689710617065,
0.36889609694480896,
-0.20774492621421814,
0.7062526345252991,
-0.10327235609292984,
-0.9487429261207581,
0.523678183555603,
-0.4393826723098755,
0.8324165344238281,
-0.49950143694877625,
-0.21005353331565857,
-0.3465142250061035,
0.31574761867523193,
-0.31321480870246887,
-0.8260985016822815,
-0.25669485330581665,
-0.327640175819397,
-0.26466429233551025,
-0.5745435953140259,
0.6134393215179443,
-0.27342596650123596,
-0.3992588222026825,
0.15858124196529388,
0.3667699098587036,
-0.16730466485023499,
0.4905477464199066,
-0.6192564964294434,
-0.06570231169462204,
-0.09578116983175278,
-0.08842511475086212,
0.5357564091682434,
0.14032112061977386,
0.4117833971977234,
0.404424786567688,
0.4807164967060089,
-0.03045177459716797,
-0.1689901053905487,
0.09977217763662338,
0.8230215311050415,
-0.40949520468711853,
-0.28261706233024597,
-1.057497262954712,
0.23521554470062256,
-0.37005752325057983,
-0.2837252914905548,
0.883600115776062,
0.7647532820701599,
0.6181838512420654,
0.13542084395885468,
0.48565515875816345,
0.2452138066291809,
0.3299793004989624,
-0.523581326007843,
0.16580088436603546,
-0.517570972442627,
0.35927435755729675,
-0.30875518918037415,
-1.030029535293579,
-0.14819180965423584,
0.4962063431739807,
-0.4372352063655853,
-0.18118073046207428,
0.589589536190033,
0.6532123684883118,
-0.0977381020784378,
-0.035429082810878754,
0.2852731943130493,
-0.5320084691047668,
0.2774949073791504,
0.7709917426109314,
0.8565471172332764,
-0.27683910727500916,
0.43333736062049866,
-0.5915852189064026,
-0.7845357656478882,
-0.29790356755256653,
-0.9585724472999573,
-0.7696565389633179,
-0.3509148955345154,
-0.4159626364707947,
-0.20997817814350128,
0.20225144922733307,
1.231899619102478,
0.5795255303382874,
-0.481353223323822,
-0.5022375583648682,
0.2616598606109619,
0.3432203233242035,
-0.3459872901439667,
-0.22818931937217712,
0.37758269906044006,
-0.5157115459442139,
-0.7928517460823059,
0.3308805227279663,
0.3779747784137726,
0.15728583931922913,
0.16530665755271912,
-0.21606339514255524,
-0.27903980016708374,
0.021947091445326805,
0.6790172457695007,
0.08177746087312698,
-0.6513509154319763,
-0.47215306758880615,
0.24130883812904358,
-0.11889182031154633,
0.4383311867713928,
0.8259086012840271,
-0.674773097038269,
0.9497184753417969,
0.461847186088562,
0.7038812637329102,
0.054156310856342316,
0.29992833733558655,
0.7033102512359619,
-0.7068742513656616,
0.1045011356472969,
0.17580699920654297,
0.23352141678333282,
0.10889202356338501,
-0.4297114908695221,
0.6341484189033508,
0.24323850870132446,
-0.7484827041625977,
-0.6888896822929382,
0.21014870703220367,
-1.39873206615448,
0.10152095556259155,
1.160181999206543,
0.05860717594623566,
0.1414276361465454,
0.24948692321777344,
-0.575350284576416,
0.2521516978740692,
-0.6478215456008911,
0.9048857092857361,
0.7725814580917358,
-0.603278398513794,
0.37217041850090027,
-0.4293021261692047,
0.27040907740592957,
0.6198415160179138,
-0.43106815218925476,
-0.3037084639072418,
0.45684853196144104,
0.25592005252838135,
-0.06617514789104462,
0.7865755558013916,
0.13799415528774261,
0.36804845929145813,
-0.160471573472023,
-0.1314743459224701,
-0.22013047337532043,
-0.05834744870662689,
-0.049066029489040375,
0.16125835478305817,
0.1521124541759491,
-0.8662881851196289
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12088v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12088v1
|
TMU at TREC Clinical Trials Track 2023
| 2024-03-12T00:45:49 | 2024-03-12T00:45:49 |
Aritra Kumar Lahiri, Emrul Hasan, Qinmin Vivian Hu, Cherie Ding
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
This paper describes Toronto Metropolitan University's participation in the
TREC Clinical Trials Track for 2023. As part of the tasks, we utilize advanced
natural language processing techniques and neural language models in our
experiments to retrieve the most relevant clinical trials. We illustrate the
overall methodology, experimental settings, and results of our implementation
for the run submission as part of Team - V-TorontoMU.
|
[
-0.33290034532546997,
-0.7611494660377502,
1.099840521812439,
-0.01969478651881218,
-0.10776472836732864,
0.5854339003562927,
0.2307065725326538,
-0.5612777471542358,
0.4183378219604492,
0.512638509273529,
-0.6240872144699097,
-0.7219050526618958,
-0.49333348870277405,
0.24193088710308075,
-0.2460639327764511,
0.7436691522598267,
-0.2535250186920166,
0.3868831694126129,
0.25635311007499695,
-0.4656403660774231,
-0.8679975271224976,
-0.5159743428230286,
-1.148451805114746,
-0.6448698043823242,
1.0639451742172241,
0.6807038187980652,
0.23880510032176971,
0.6399437785148621,
0.690024197101593,
0.1577291637659073,
0.08190634101629257,
-0.3878519833087921,
-0.31865137815475464,
-0.06428904831409454,
-0.19615545868873596,
-0.5324194431304932,
-0.7085623741149902,
0.09072121977806091,
0.5004738569259644,
0.8332435488700867,
-0.22709344327449799,
-0.2953348159790039,
-0.5749744176864624,
-0.03402769938111305,
-0.36584794521331787,
-0.2296062409877777,
-0.15135139226913452,
0.13170059025287628,
-0.5720624923706055,
-0.5698116421699524,
-0.46879392862319946,
-0.800739049911499,
0.17662720382213593,
-0.5271146297454834,
0.4570738673210144,
0.2518937289714813,
0.6289003491401672,
-0.37724772095680237,
-0.9434120059013367,
-0.13498029112815857,
-0.44103163480758667,
0.8080344796180725,
-0.5130611658096313,
0.39713209867477417,
0.6071930527687073,
0.4079954922199249,
-0.11409833282232285,
-1.1016337871551514,
-0.04635830596089363,
-0.46783435344696045,
0.07805422693490982,
0.39591825008392334,
0.031903304159641266,
0.4630277752876282,
0.022824183106422424,
0.30940642952919006,
-0.5150707364082336,
0.043188974261283875,
-0.6676328778266907,
0.010047615505754948,
0.4054427444934845,
0.7758601903915405,
0.43278786540031433,
0.27763989567756653,
-0.2305426150560379,
0.4335865080356598,
-0.4907331168651581,
-0.20562028884887695,
-0.3099113702774048,
0.026697199791669846,
-0.10158006101846695,
0.6866409778594971,
-0.15827997028827667,
0.38957735896110535,
-0.45419809222221375,
0.5137682557106018,
0.14805655181407928,
-0.5180160999298096,
-0.32346948981285095,
0.2128101885318756,
0.9858500361442566,
0.4294126331806183,
-0.05747013911604881,
-0.6736927032470703,
-0.37795397639274597,
0.17028939723968506,
0.628044068813324,
-0.4541695713996887,
-0.40535077452659607,
0.4157329499721527,
-0.34786590933799744,
-0.31756070256233215,
0.034511011093854904,
-0.8530009984970093,
-0.0309014692902565,
-0.24025194346904755,
0.4956396818161011,
-0.6638880968093872,
-0.29804256558418274,
0.20462794601917267,
-0.31194451451301575,
-0.07488404214382172,
0.04241370037198067,
-0.8623915910720825,
0.6619173288345337,
0.5039104223251343,
1.023024320602417,
-0.4293484091758728,
-0.3560778796672821,
-0.7149118781089783,
0.6606223583221436,
-0.4218328595161438,
0.7061672210693359,
-0.46964290738105774,
-0.8478745222091675,
0.09073032438755035,
-0.03603346645832062,
-0.1588050276041031,
-0.403300940990448,
0.6369708776473999,
-0.4620456397533417,
0.19734236598014832,
-0.5271605849266052,
-0.2947821319103241,
0.14800304174423218,
0.13585233688354492,
-0.6837323904037476,
1.090720534324646,
0.1769617795944214,
-0.5915666222572327,
0.37405574321746826,
-1.5631388425827026,
-0.72857666015625,
0.30633431673049927,
0.44179654121398926,
-0.46070393919944763,
0.4677795171737671,
0.1867024451494217,
0.003098849207162857,
0.04878511279821396,
0.6997944116592407,
-0.5206096768379211,
-0.43931666016578674,
0.23221582174301147,
0.012840050272643566,
0.9046106338500977,
0.37645331025123596,
-0.4432039260864258,
0.1486150324344635,
-0.5307123064994812,
-0.1718941330909729,
0.06865512579679489,
-0.38585925102233887,
0.058452755212783813,
-0.3134325444698334,
0.2944130301475525,
-0.06276100128889084,
-0.09108560532331467,
-0.8948100209236145,
0.6024431586265564,
0.14281335473060608,
0.8258287906646729,
0.49398207664489746,
0.18005362153053284,
0.3118444085121155,
-0.3424454927444458,
0.8375792503356934,
-0.10588525980710983,
0.6011855602264404,
0.3256757855415344,
-0.545638918876648,
-0.7457361817359924,
0.22267958521842957,
0.3123887777328491,
0.19001050293445587,
-0.8705912232398987,
-0.25009989738464355,
-0.03401678428053856,
-0.2800373435020447,
-0.2309236228466034,
-0.8147206902503967,
-0.015729181468486786,
0.6954398155212402,
0.6103339195251465,
-0.16597160696983337,
-0.9868006110191345,
-0.9842156171798706,
-0.1205865889787674,
-0.31541985273361206,
0.0930628851056099,
-0.041509613394737244,
0.6361896395683289,
-0.1017843708395958,
0.6953099966049194,
-0.44884079694747925,
-0.5015880465507507,
-0.5717110633850098,
0.592337965965271,
-0.10830250382423401,
0.39890581369400024,
0.45018690824508667,
-0.6945526003837585,
-0.048787545412778854,
-0.16994595527648926,
-0.8224430084228516,
-0.5358109474182129,
0.3103693127632141,
-0.1378692388534546,
-0.33914393186569214,
0.5620310306549072,
-0.36175212264060974,
0.6162199378013611,
0.3787294924259186,
-0.6458336710929871,
0.004050297662615776,
-0.10262975096702576,
0.7315353155136108,
-0.9891572594642639,
0.03379451483488083,
-0.0520661287009716,
-0.4269213378429413,
-0.7964674830436707,
-0.24359533190727234,
0.026611486449837685,
0.03437246009707451,
-0.3149842619895935,
0.291669100522995,
-0.32706746459007263,
0.11221835017204285,
-0.11391213536262512,
-0.04995611682534218,
0.029650676995515823,
0.07139912247657776,
0.027614576742053032,
0.6186828017234802,
0.36978843808174133,
-0.7583038806915283,
0.1709781438112259,
0.08658959716558456,
-0.07896196097135544,
0.3887253999710083,
-0.5115694403648376,
0.13993670046329498,
0.35098376870155334,
0.25819140672683716,
-0.7558020949363708,
-0.2709340453147888,
0.04568864405155182,
-0.6122252345085144,
0.16882887482643127,
0.46328479051589966,
-0.5300785899162292,
-0.7639111876487732,
-0.16147474944591522,
0.47850292921066284,
0.09923433512449265,
0.10481433570384979,
0.8480158448219299,
0.572738528251648,
0.2347489297389984,
-0.1513689011335373,
-1.424515724182129,
0.6122980713844299,
-0.34230610728263855,
-0.0032429280690848827,
0.4178355932235718,
0.029483402147889137,
-0.12580309808254242,
-0.20401999354362488,
0.4448327422142029,
0.06518538296222687,
0.38598328828811646,
0.16512544453144073,
0.1506679207086563,
-0.4241671562194824,
-0.06444084644317627,
-0.30820849537849426,
0.028987333178520203,
0.35125941038131714,
-0.2915533185005188,
0.6597974896430969,
0.33647671341896057,
0.02883744426071644,
-0.6087998151779175,
0.7143962979316711,
0.544457197189331,
-0.026047339662909508,
0.585235059261322,
0.3851572573184967,
-0.6545937061309814,
0.42188429832458496,
-0.6437187194824219,
-0.23153568804264069,
-0.42743536829948425,
0.2604500949382782,
-0.18726462125778198,
-0.9200724959373474,
0.4142564535140991,
0.2513245642185211,
0.32013440132141113,
0.35908037424087524,
0.6538759469985962,
-0.25633469223976135,
1.0441508293151855,
0.936339795589447,
0.18307970464229584,
0.4271978437900543,
-0.2608512043952942,
0.10691281408071518,
-0.9104843139648438,
-0.6826632022857666,
-0.5484548211097717,
-0.4834849238395691,
-0.22686727344989777,
-0.034492552280426025,
0.38580402731895447,
-0.5351046919822693,
-0.28570204973220825,
0.6646409034729004,
-0.202302485704422,
-0.08901368826627731,
0.7220539450645447,
0.3677835762500763,
0.43521392345428467,
-0.5554633140563965,
-0.42271745204925537,
-0.1491028070449829,
-0.5328863859176636,
-0.27615365386009216,
1.3704794645309448,
0.34108030796051025,
0.09348645061254501,
0.11809752136468887,
0.6745668053627014,
0.45395976305007935,
1.0348750352859497,
-0.44937992095947266,
0.7433064579963684,
0.11738612502813339,
-1.1637202501296997,
0.12296432256698608,
-0.2047315388917923,
-0.92007976770401,
-0.37111392617225647,
0.08910897374153137,
-0.9778900146484375,
-0.16382892429828644,
-0.24888630211353302,
-0.21883413195610046,
0.7040256261825562,
-0.7629387378692627,
0.7699310779571533,
-0.29450419545173645,
-0.09821378439664841,
-0.05067351087927818,
-0.5839149951934814,
0.4210374057292938,
-0.20465180277824402,
-0.04485142230987549,
0.04102815315127373,
-0.3198029398918152,
0.9120158553123474,
-0.21912036836147308,
0.3555844724178314,
-0.03457107022404671,
0.15965673327445984,
0.17597194015979767,
0.16428795456886292,
0.01615307480096817,
0.2325689196586609,
-0.13715341687202454,
0.017906581982970238,
-0.27965205907821655,
-0.5628365278244019,
0.006460160482674837,
0.5842610001564026,
-0.49030911922454834,
-0.5377572178840637,
-0.6446656584739685,
-0.7024778127670288,
-0.5587846636772156,
0.11197848618030548,
0.48709332942962646,
0.519932210445404,
-0.5165616869926453,
0.035296451300382614,
0.1945936679840088,
-0.20309589803218842,
0.7309984564781189,
0.43770864605903625,
-0.45026248693466187,
-0.9489836692810059,
0.3490825891494751,
-0.03763573244214058,
0.18101471662521362,
0.8660962581634521,
0.14313043653964996,
-0.6429721713066101,
-1.278252363204956,
-0.045446138828992844,
0.18804453313350677,
-0.13609963655471802,
-0.10895775258541107,
-1.0645326375961304,
0.09405982494354248,
-0.6741317510604858,
-0.18003375828266144,
-0.13301733136177063,
-0.05307147279381752,
-0.36391890048980713,
-0.3227260112762451,
0.1549716293811798,
1.0722384452819824,
0.13365142047405243,
0.8541689515113831,
-0.6932215094566345,
0.5670422911643982,
-0.2854072153568268,
0.5384133458137512,
-0.5153588056564331,
-0.36394742131233215,
-0.4034848213195801,
0.030177295207977295,
-0.8197596669197083,
-0.5503597259521484,
0.39719662070274353,
-0.08039826899766922,
0.40753069519996643,
0.01374407671391964,
-0.1828790307044983,
0.8043555021286011,
-0.3124113976955414,
1.1426979303359985,
0.5426716804504395,
-0.8811819553375244,
1.1221433877944946,
-0.652296245098114,
0.5668119192123413,
0.7660208940505981,
0.31729987263679504,
-0.34538954496383667,
-0.6994867920875549,
-0.8604554533958435,
-0.2574889063835144,
0.9205838441848755,
0.3624165654182434,
-0.367374449968338,
-0.05387193709611893,
0.18607711791992188,
-0.09215033799409866,
0.07662550359964371,
-0.7276784777641296,
-0.2957999110221863,
-0.0519193597137928,
-0.20718422532081604,
-0.047386202961206436,
-0.4611194431781769,
-0.14854669570922852,
-0.008160620927810669,
0.3517526686191559,
-0.07275153696537018,
0.42534321546554565,
0.05608370155096054,
0.32656583189964294,
-0.5711367726325989,
0.07705099135637283,
0.6870320439338684,
1.0840855836868286,
-0.6300684213638306,
0.052854087203741074,
0.4230816960334778,
-0.9934703707695007,
-0.05266823247075081,
0.026912176981568336,
-0.04914816468954086,
0.24137674272060394,
0.39363783597946167,
0.553554117679596,
0.2529948651790619,
-0.3386109471321106,
0.18182475864887238,
-0.5319228768348694,
-0.6558310985565186,
-0.2498520463705063,
-0.16521397233009338,
0.07581093907356262,
0.15301012992858887,
0.5035622119903564,
-0.004561753943562508,
0.4739547371864319,
-0.7449814081192017,
0.31631743907928467,
-0.03646746277809143,
-0.8316249847412109,
-0.5841068029403687,
1.3876796960830688,
0.023739736527204514,
-0.3417055904865265,
0.737865149974823,
0.6113193035125732,
-0.7117918133735657,
0.6917252540588379,
0.4719069004058838,
1.126714825630188,
-0.14102400839328766,
-0.019897591322660446,
0.28552380204200745,
0.16912074387073517,
-0.2146361917257309,
0.40401536226272583,
0.3598688244819641,
-0.03132723271846771,
-0.1753729283809662,
-0.3447350561618805,
-0.495934396982193,
0.29907116293907166,
-0.6771279573440552,
0.7860428094863892,
-0.5530456304550171,
-0.7781862616539001,
-0.0803503692150116,
0.2159883975982666,
-0.39329794049263,
0.7019612193107605,
0.5064377784729004,
1.0987437963485718,
-0.30794981122016907,
1.1896600723266602,
0.8688117265701294,
-0.09912291169166565,
-0.717822790145874,
-0.1495770514011383,
-0.05735181272029877,
-0.42461344599723816,
0.46986278891563416,
0.10635803639888763,
0.14020144939422607,
-0.12646515667438507,
-0.5613037943840027,
-0.25119099020957947,
1.374205231666565,
0.42396819591522217,
-0.34026074409484863,
-0.30658602714538574,
0.5841850638389587,
0.48308467864990234,
-0.1567145735025406,
0.5108094215393066,
0.8851934671401978,
0.5482918620109558,
0.23436342179775238,
-0.8967445492744446,
-0.28680187463760376,
-0.005475948564708233,
-0.31875935196876526,
0.3565804958343506,
-0.7513476014137268,
0.6307517290115356,
-0.2904219627380371,
-0.1707819253206253,
0.2987902760505676,
0.7564159035682678,
0.48124146461486816,
0.9040765762329102,
0.2077624648809433,
0.7878016829490662,
0.41136929392814636,
-0.8141966462135315,
1.1740014553070068,
0.26171237230300903,
0.4836355149745941,
0.7404910326004028,
-0.09301892668008804,
0.2508159279823303,
0.7773643136024475,
-0.47215816378593445,
0.10358801484107971,
0.9182300567626953,
0.18747365474700928,
0.5653299689292908,
-0.016417711973190308,
-0.3244631588459015,
0.001631458173505962,
-0.7537981271743774,
-0.17637735605239868,
0.04808938130736351,
0.2662575840950012,
-0.3047501742839813,
-0.12831754982471466,
0.20145151019096375,
-0.08846868574619293,
-0.13563986122608185,
-0.3651740252971649,
0.5507758259773254,
0.6176724433898926,
-0.9108178615570068,
0.25324541330337524,
-0.04806035757064819,
0.37115007638931274,
-0.712501049041748,
0.07753098756074905,
-0.33611613512039185,
0.38152751326560974,
-0.09335461258888245,
-1.0394971370697021,
0.389984130859375,
-0.1297997534275055,
0.3691931366920471,
-0.42432865500450134,
0.14510922133922577,
-0.07536151260137558,
-0.2504676580429077,
0.5222576260566711,
0.1909344345331192,
-0.2750217020511627,
0.21127143502235413,
-0.6156985759735107,
0.06651978194713593,
0.04267388582229614,
-0.3736147880554199,
0.12804405391216278,
0.9117085933685303,
-0.06793080270290375,
0.9354142546653748,
0.30280324816703796,
0.42730265855789185,
0.42960843443870544,
0.5478602647781372,
0.7298027873039246,
-1.1610935926437378,
-0.3970727026462555,
-0.9885447025299072,
0.13331793248653412,
0.11001648753881454,
-0.8672565221786499,
0.2424038052558899,
0.9305846691131592,
0.19929727911949158,
-0.049598805606365204,
0.6375163197517395,
-0.25048550963401794,
0.3720288574695587,
-0.5168375968933105,
0.4415891468524933,
-0.7512649297714233,
-0.001175010809674859,
0.08036483824253082,
-0.7624430060386658,
-0.6623814105987549,
-0.3598622977733612,
-0.2262626588344574,
-0.18518775701522827,
1.2536064386367798,
0.11779488623142242,
-0.0856928601861,
0.7173211574554443,
0.2856025993824005,
0.05044318735599518,
0.8828242421150208,
1.3846125602722168,
0.9650112390518188,
-0.7361490726470947,
0.5894321203231812,
-0.45979756116867065,
0.24613668024539948,
-0.1339186578989029,
-0.5696443915367126,
-0.9116253852844238,
-0.49061137437820435,
-0.30688557028770447,
-0.5651338696479797,
0.33790653944015503,
0.5133515000343323,
0.35955774784088135,
-1.0288975238800049,
-0.2834736406803131,
-0.3982004225254059,
-0.2810131907463074,
0.1767822504043579,
-0.24443165957927704,
0.18911156058311462,
0.023110605776309967,
-0.8894977569580078,
0.17997430264949799,
0.4821077883243561,
0.25510647892951965,
0.09493578970432281,
0.2106722891330719,
-0.868579626083374,
-0.45770615339279175,
0.003210748080164194,
0.11400044709444046,
-0.4176332354545593,
-0.26210030913352966,
0.3349885046482086,
-0.5283209085464478,
0.5346587300300598,
1.2467190027236938,
-0.8768306374549866,
0.1435997188091278,
0.398007333278656,
0.5186858177185059,
0.6931152939796448,
-0.13477012515068054,
1.1866096258163452,
-0.06915343552827835,
-0.2001422494649887,
0.8458030223846436,
0.46971988677978516,
0.3007984459400177,
-0.05041574686765671,
0.9796848297119141,
0.6056214570999146,
-0.5037714838981628,
-0.8274345993995667,
-0.23914924263954163,
-1.4236750602722168,
0.1766379326581955,
0.8805105090141296,
0.041693951934576035,
-0.29979047179222107,
-0.6903844475746155,
-0.17801158130168915,
0.6547448635101318,
-0.4231301546096802,
0.7571125030517578,
0.7428933382034302,
-0.15382005274295807,
-0.33280497789382935,
-1.3403230905532837,
0.16392141580581665,
0.2517503798007965,
-0.864501953125,
-0.22990866005420685,
-0.03181002289056778,
0.2586425244808197,
-0.2427368313074112,
0.7462885975837708,
-0.3951171338558197,
0.25527122616767883,
-0.3889407813549042,
0.03813435137271881,
0.03643440827727318,
-0.06618933379650116,
0.04254986345767975,
0.14998658001422882,
-0.31931596994400024,
-0.425815612077713
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07202v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07202v1
|
SPAWNing Structural Priming Predictions from a Cognitively Motivated Parser
| 2024-03-11T22:58:58 | 2024-03-11T22:58:58 |
Grusha Prasad, Tal Linzen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Structural priming is a widely used psycholinguistic paradigm to study human
sentence representations. In this work we propose a framework for using
empirical priming patterns to build a theory characterizing the structural
representations humans construct when processing sentences. This framework uses
a new cognitively motivated parser, SPAWN, to generate quantitative priming
predictions from theoretical syntax and evaluate these predictions with
empirical human behavior. As a case study, we apply this framework to study
reduced relative clause representations in English. We use SPAWN to generate
priming predictions from two theoretical accounts which make different
assumptions about the structure of relative clauses. We find that the
predictions from only one of these theories (Participial-Phase) align with
empirical priming patterns, thus highlighting which assumptions about relative
clause better capture human sentence representations.
|
[
-0.1484130620956421,
-0.526624858379364,
0.874512255191803,
0.41452038288116455,
-0.05882532149553299,
-0.1362290233373642,
-0.3385204076766968,
-0.22969676554203033,
0.17331016063690186,
0.21322928369045258,
-0.5462431311607361,
-0.39722487330436707,
-0.12234703451395035,
0.22838620841503143,
-0.20161302387714386,
0.4288497269153595,
0.2338300496339798,
0.1079847440123558,
-0.44941702485084534,
0.48071950674057007,
-0.721570611000061,
-0.983437180519104,
-0.620201587677002,
-0.27358847856521606,
0.37853720784187317,
0.32645541429519653,
0.4084002375602722,
0.8177397847175598,
0.03875628486275673,
0.23512627184391022,
-0.29081374406814575,
-0.3105025589466095,
-0.3853290379047394,
0.44172024726867676,
-0.10625877231359482,
-1.013761043548584,
-0.06111414358019829,
0.24549375474452972,
0.8206331729888916,
1.147612452507019,
-0.19851301610469818,
-0.21299177408218384,
0.37845975160598755,
0.6173921823501587,
-0.7423316240310669,
0.6232819557189941,
-0.8243735432624817,
0.07437262684106827,
-0.2286001741886139,
-0.39025598764419556,
-0.8832792043685913,
0.05715503171086311,
-0.02333209663629532,
-0.5136724710464478,
0.5080229043960571,
0.27351054549217224,
0.7685799598693848,
0.008494961075484753,
-0.3511165678501129,
0.09369061887264252,
-0.4973922073841095,
0.7879698872566223,
-0.5335803627967834,
0.3219327926635742,
0.9234870076179504,
0.04726467654109001,
-0.3362503945827484,
-0.6366807818412781,
-0.27410346269607544,
-0.5103442072868347,
-0.3842354118824005,
0.09585621953010559,
0.36354830861091614,
0.24828509986400604,
0.406493216753006,
0.35866329073905945,
-0.552473247051239,
-0.3797799050807953,
-0.41964882612228394,
-0.09063181281089783,
0.27908259630203247,
0.227517232298851,
0.11002488434314728,
-0.4664410352706909,
-0.24197618663311005,
-0.14748774468898773,
-0.6700209975242615,
0.27343258261680603,
0.25091028213500977,
0.5625308752059937,
-0.09390047192573547,
0.6843532919883728,
-0.46191930770874023,
0.6835054159164429,
0.3861916959285736,
0.16792885959148407,
0.22361896932125092,
-0.10843599587678909,
-0.17256951332092285,
0.46060681343078613,
0.43980395793914795,
0.4403453767299652,
0.5742629766464233,
-0.2954544723033905,
0.0679674819111824,
0.5213454365730286,
0.46971628069877625,
-0.5698004364967346,
-0.141041100025177,
0.16687586903572083,
-0.4478500187397003,
-0.4316386282444,
0.2959986925125122,
-0.5205793976783752,
-0.12339471280574799,
-0.17181788384914398,
-0.4050692617893219,
-0.7758983969688416,
-0.046270955353975296,
0.2713378369808197,
-0.29650571942329407,
0.20026984810829163,
-0.14366751909255981,
-0.8423126339912415,
0.40602102875709534,
0.7857398986816406,
0.8489494919776917,
0.18550324440002441,
-0.3436632454395294,
-0.271971195936203,
0.6715137958526611,
-0.43091586232185364,
0.9068635702133179,
-0.6361689567565918,
-0.21506009995937347,
0.2713800072669983,
0.04530895873904228,
-0.19986997544765472,
-0.6241958141326904,
0.5963796973228455,
-0.4478011131286621,
0.3810066878795624,
-0.3655720055103302,
-0.7584438920021057,
-0.4372010827064514,
0.4229927062988281,
-0.5498791337013245,
0.714174747467041,
0.014154528267681599,
-0.5102734565734863,
0.5839840769767761,
-0.3602182865142822,
-0.43123507499694824,
0.23034854233264923,
-0.32060471177101135,
-0.1901721954345703,
0.3366994559764862,
-0.07910341024398804,
0.4528430998325348,
-0.16545821726322174,
0.3232949376106262,
-0.3307690918445587,
-0.1912960261106491,
0.2829550802707672,
-0.04200569540262222,
0.6718173027038574,
0.0923207551240921,
-0.39601191878318787,
-0.07200625538825989,
-0.6898180246353149,
0.10029865801334381,
0.18970409035682678,
-0.2139681726694107,
-0.38173121213912964,
0.5168116092681885,
-0.2698749899864197,
-0.13415637612342834,
-0.05367907136678696,
-0.5605728030204773,
0.1182456985116005,
-0.6993270516395569,
0.5557388067245483,
0.4638729393482208,
0.4883995056152344,
0.6808778643608093,
-0.4596009850502014,
0.5152680277824402,
-0.23872797191143036,
-0.18703420460224152,
-0.5164201855659485,
-0.5561338067054749,
-0.44396844506263733,
-0.4594171643257141,
0.09400132298469543,
0.47993189096450806,
-0.02942807786166668,
0.5147386789321899,
-0.250522643327713,
0.1706560105085373,
0.12645438313484192,
-0.1704397052526474,
0.44882774353027344,
0.2608299255371094,
0.18123669922351837,
0.11294548958539963,
-0.8769489526748657,
-1.1272560358047485,
-0.22346097230911255,
-0.6716084480285645,
-0.17372947931289673,
-0.11234539747238159,
0.15739277005195618,
0.3092278242111206,
1.1659915447235107,
-0.5521776676177979,
-0.4952515959739685,
-0.23066043853759766,
0.2642990052700043,
0.15040987730026245,
0.5378300547599792,
0.6988133192062378,
-0.8164975643157959,
-0.43640783429145813,
-0.3753461539745331,
-0.842864453792572,
0.05447213724255562,
-0.12084227055311203,
0.016395434737205505,
-0.2400992214679718,
0.7256045937538147,
-0.7480456233024597,
0.3154910206794739,
0.18136204779148102,
-0.45845603942871094,
0.6159647703170776,
0.2764005661010742,
0.16995996236801147,
-1.0388270616531372,
-0.3395737111568451,
-0.08752158284187317,
-0.4277813136577606,
-0.3038652241230011,
0.20672498643398285,
-0.06351369619369507,
-0.19793500006198883,
-0.35943546891212463,
-0.15115641057491302,
-0.854790449142456,
0.17881302535533905,
-0.08079789578914642,
-0.49177542328834534,
0.02378983236849308,
0.5213938355445862,
0.18133144080638885,
0.8803909420967102,
0.43710851669311523,
-0.47238224744796753,
-0.16856639087200165,
0.09482353925704956,
-0.3748411536216736,
0.19578757882118225,
-0.7346163392066956,
-0.022374015301465988,
-0.344748854637146,
0.3476616442203522,
-1.0548087358474731,
-0.4504179060459137,
0.060109205543994904,
-0.38586190342903137,
0.19589315354824066,
-0.629834771156311,
-0.5237566232681274,
-0.06435984373092651,
-0.4713069498538971,
0.6353350281715393,
0.6164085268974304,
0.1655932068824768,
0.4850461184978485,
0.2592337429523468,
-0.29362353682518005,
-0.08290450274944305,
-0.7365438938140869,
-0.0531410276889801,
-0.3571920394897461,
-0.6399379968643188,
0.8147998452186584,
0.2579631209373474,
-0.49507322907447815,
0.14017558097839355,
0.024827083572745323,
0.030822133645415306,
-0.11744645237922668,
0.5036311745643616,
0.2859461307525635,
-0.5966487526893616,
-0.04351170361042023,
-0.06534478068351746,
-0.19925028085708618,
0.4125019907951355,
-0.35889655351638794,
0.7352005243301392,
-0.07374947518110275,
-0.15723448991775513,
-0.3623189628124237,
0.46015340089797974,
0.5955876111984253,
0.022931206971406937,
0.7875637412071228,
-0.28306645154953003,
-0.4690256714820862,
-0.14522671699523926,
-0.4973122775554657,
-0.3079359829425812,
-0.44144558906555176,
0.1689181923866272,
-0.5986594557762146,
-0.5132202506065369,
0.5350134372711182,
-0.0747179463505745,
-0.2067502737045288,
0.25435298681259155,
0.406964510679245,
-0.4318007230758667,
0.9065880179405212,
0.5234562158584595,
0.29967018961906433,
0.6897706985473633,
-0.45415133237838745,
-0.22362364828586578,
-0.790348470211029,
-0.16444189846515656,
-0.3526444137096405,
-0.24438884854316711,
-0.044139306992292404,
-0.4779476821422577,
0.2050081044435501,
0.34736260771751404,
-0.10574152320623398,
0.2888350784778595,
-0.47705569863319397,
0.7738374471664429,
0.35710909962654114,
0.04408194124698639,
0.004928357899188995,
0.24415647983551025,
-0.306131511926651,
-0.2521311044692993,
-0.43848639726638794,
-0.635149359703064,
0.9689970016479492,
-0.04783305525779724,
0.1681773066520691,
-0.09683755040168762,
0.4461282789707184,
0.41663679480552673,
0.11609791964292526,
-0.8240841627120972,
0.6587251424789429,
0.09922704845666885,
-0.830440104007721,
-0.0919998437166214,
-0.3441864252090454,
-1.1051323413848877,
0.2765238285064697,
-0.06862225383520126,
-0.8943027257919312,
0.21236273646354675,
0.08412019908428192,
-0.4771901071071625,
0.02599315531551838,
-0.8338713645935059,
0.8884139060974121,
0.1469278186559677,
-0.314853310585022,
-0.3595227897167206,
-0.47287097573280334,
0.2924438714981079,
0.3886169195175171,
0.1759985238313675,
-0.28936389088630676,
0.04730324447154999,
0.7615606784820557,
-0.3616962134838104,
1.208544135093689,
-0.3425707221031189,
0.19663314521312714,
0.6552358865737915,
0.2897036671638489,
0.45154109597206116,
-0.025124065577983856,
-0.27162936329841614,
-0.057521771639585495,
-0.011444521136581898,
-0.48737236857414246,
-0.5833688378334045,
0.41697919368743896,
-0.5037850141525269,
-0.6370373368263245,
-0.4532962143421173,
-0.34921514987945557,
-0.33660635352134705,
-0.01623453013598919,
0.46006539463996887,
0.4191175401210785,
-0.28095144033432007,
0.27976030111312866,
0.2421768754720688,
0.3692673444747925,
0.2892416715621948,
0.25164106488227844,
-0.19383694231510162,
-0.44658908247947693,
0.5517402291297913,
0.13242746889591217,
0.14584961533546448,
0.5327373147010803,
0.0478331558406353,
-0.1607217639684677,
-0.612393856048584,
0.03873095288872719,
0.4085233509540558,
-0.3833499848842621,
-0.04739431291818619,
-0.3937755823135376,
-0.0572517067193985,
-0.5580215454101562,
-0.39614126086235046,
-0.2042202204465866,
-0.35636845231056213,
-0.05349826440215111,
-0.4786151647567749,
0.022603265941143036,
0.5410199761390686,
0.14654980599880219,
0.3561271131038666,
-0.5227599143981934,
0.2977961301803589,
0.16726601123809814,
0.06917686760425568,
-0.23090502619743347,
-0.35579174757003784,
-0.1439370959997177,
0.14552471041679382,
-0.16260050237178802,
-1.2772462368011475,
0.15988720953464508,
0.2158137857913971,
0.44928061962127686,
0.3210863173007965,
0.2093459516763687,
0.8297291398048401,
-0.7234695553779602,
0.9636134505271912,
0.17751210927963257,
-0.7997919321060181,
0.7368723154067993,
-0.4663548469543457,
-0.02194301225244999,
0.8188065886497498,
0.2117280513048172,
-0.2657163441181183,
-0.625662624835968,
-0.707024097442627,
-0.89654541015625,
0.5513653755187988,
0.26128485798835754,
0.15615451335906982,
-0.39987289905548096,
0.7048546671867371,
0.0675327330827713,
0.05883204564452171,
-0.7129136919975281,
-0.20942142605781555,
-0.01298128068447113,
-0.12518364191055298,
-0.019771454855799675,
-0.531755805015564,
0.11288097500801086,
-0.2847975492477417,
0.39471015334129333,
-0.10641495138406754,
0.35373562574386597,
0.27219924330711365,
-0.1621840000152588,
-0.17360645532608032,
0.08192144334316254,
0.32383498549461365,
0.5887042880058289,
-0.4467334449291229,
0.22015789151191711,
-0.17106257379055023,
-0.28284910321235657,
0.324463814496994,
-0.14988060295581818,
-0.5341712832450867,
0.10404135286808014,
0.5995652079582214,
0.4694068431854248,
0.5506888031959534,
-0.5248253345489502,
0.46258851885795593,
0.1785198301076889,
-0.23460891842842102,
-0.8430131673812866,
-0.08699330687522888,
-0.019258230924606323,
0.16457383334636688,
0.6150265336036682,
0.18779854476451874,
0.17369838058948517,
-0.8432499170303345,
0.4225865602493286,
0.3010523021221161,
-0.29998600482940674,
-0.7638652920722961,
0.7914777398109436,
-0.01683567650616169,
-0.25790131092071533,
0.5225632190704346,
-0.4229884147644043,
-0.6470871567726135,
0.48070061206817627,
0.7021096348762512,
1.1165409088134766,
0.13101333379745483,
0.2173587679862976,
0.4478676915168762,
0.23235420882701874,
-0.07989131659269333,
0.11345396190881729,
-0.33571019768714905,
-0.8645250201225281,
-0.9323100447654724,
-0.552450954914093,
-0.08989579975605011,
0.09267957508563995,
-0.8717849850654602,
0.33216890692710876,
-0.46813181042671204,
-0.40942680835723877,
0.08267088979482651,
-0.27436766028404236,
-0.1336139738559723,
-0.14042574167251587,
0.5986273884773254,
0.5701078176498413,
-0.8269473910331726,
0.6657871007919312,
1.1310123205184937,
-0.6223455667495728,
-0.8866157531738281,
0.47847872972488403,
-0.0049450211226940155,
-0.5267655849456787,
0.8394441604614258,
0.24753664433956146,
-0.09789728373289108,
-0.047836508601903915,
-0.5048608779907227,
-0.9066581130027771,
0.7089315056800842,
0.7593109011650085,
-0.1443016529083252,
-0.43899229168891907,
-0.02312656119465828,
0.22602754831314087,
-0.5183677077293396,
-0.22327391803264618,
0.21675631403923035,
0.39209774136543274,
0.028020502999424934,
-0.5438796877861023,
0.2748294770717621,
-0.22945144772529602,
0.022116830572485924,
0.09900315850973129,
-0.3675774931907654,
0.9920844435691833,
-0.05616267770528793,
-0.7872388362884521,
0.10382207483053207,
0.8019850850105286,
0.3426293730735779,
0.22154249250888824,
0.7179199457168579,
0.4703609049320221,
0.4706268608570099,
0.11545310169458389,
1.1558829545974731,
-0.5407003164291382,
0.28497371077537537,
1.044981837272644,
-0.3902185559272766,
1.0304511785507202,
0.49848511815071106,
-0.40890973806381226,
1.0491160154342651,
0.38595908880233765,
0.3310889005661011,
0.777191698551178,
0.12281431257724762,
-0.058499518781900406,
-0.2829737663269043,
-0.03037259168922901,
-0.31357064843177795,
0.4775357246398926,
0.4901065528392792,
-0.2900809943675995,
-0.12263801693916321,
-0.09055071324110031,
-0.06375569105148315,
0.31897789239883423,
-0.12603043019771576,
0.8420560359954834,
0.06741368025541306,
-0.8135541081428528,
0.7847358584403992,
0.0684828832745552,
0.37303996086120605,
-0.5838567614555359,
-0.15466639399528503,
0.05678587034344673,
0.19424328207969666,
-0.020479785278439522,
-0.6276309490203857,
0.5157977342605591,
-0.07472093403339386,
-0.6828799247741699,
-0.6721208095550537,
0.608189046382904,
-0.37195801734924316,
-0.2134799063205719,
0.1926780492067337,
0.41425687074661255,
0.2174309343099594,
-0.5312339663505554,
-0.421860933303833,
-0.15950480103492737,
0.08247248083353043,
-0.40384864807128906,
0.340641587972641,
0.5878499746322632,
-0.001904651871882379,
0.25077754259109497,
0.9766208529472351,
0.2924138903617859,
0.30512332916259766,
-0.004005437716841698,
0.7084606885910034,
-0.9288264513015747,
-0.888302743434906,
-0.9085016250610352,
0.5307857990264893,
-0.113774374127388,
-0.17759405076503754,
0.5107048153877258,
0.7986551523208618,
0.6916306614875793,
-0.1469188630580902,
0.5195273160934448,
-0.11846420168876648,
0.2693186104297638,
-0.6006073951721191,
0.31324219703674316,
-0.23812901973724365,
0.06084941700100899,
0.0633150041103363,
-1.1655340194702148,
-0.19772370159626007,
0.7869348526000977,
-0.42280852794647217,
-0.18698982894420624,
1.0752300024032593,
0.486571729183197,
0.022523993626236916,
0.1090501993894577,
0.3965893089771271,
0.4753348231315613,
-0.01628478802740574,
0.3567259907722473,
1.1801035404205322,
-0.030512195080518723,
0.35231688618659973,
-0.5125904679298401,
-0.25768059492111206,
-0.14304424822330475,
-0.6142911911010742,
-0.7018827199935913,
-0.7927971482276917,
-0.2524219751358032,
-0.1688997447490692,
0.024357613176107407,
0.8700430393218994,
1.026598334312439,
-0.7761266827583313,
-0.3955894708633423,
-0.5397067666053772,
-0.3256285488605499,
-0.5264045000076294,
-0.39283397793769836,
0.04415694996714592,
-0.8233203291893005,
-0.5169005393981934,
0.8088380694389343,
0.24957944452762604,
-0.08001900464296341,
-0.1789870411157608,
0.22289282083511353,
-0.23547478020191193,
0.03275766968727112,
0.6697219014167786,
0.18326681852340698,
-0.7663840651512146,
-0.30541709065437317,
-0.06534036993980408,
-0.24274343252182007,
0.12508933246135712,
1.322333812713623,
-1.2152642011642456,
-0.10422467440366745,
0.5283452272415161,
0.08747100085020065,
0.5083303451538086,
0.36958545446395874,
0.8945971727371216,
-1.0449512004852295,
0.7293145656585693,
0.43466711044311523,
0.6218356490135193,
0.15760643780231476,
-0.45787501335144043,
0.6401312351226807,
0.49134719371795654,
-0.029616786167025566,
-0.9544067978858948,
0.32457563281059265,
-1.0700032711029053,
-0.4231513738632202,
1.051851749420166,
-0.11920783668756485,
-0.6912039518356323,
-0.08397874981164932,
-0.21372954547405243,
0.019789082929491997,
-0.5307455062866211,
0.6623638868331909,
0.7624397277832031,
-0.07362934947013855,
-0.0015107712242752314,
-0.21712903678417206,
0.3172554671764374,
0.8208315372467041,
-0.37049075961112976,
0.26632624864578247,
0.6809899210929871,
0.04936710000038147,
0.5414990186691284,
0.5566917657852173,
-0.0150539455935359,
0.1678231954574585,
0.4459189474582672,
-0.01145829726010561,
-0.12241333723068237,
-0.2081097960472107,
0.23862247169017792,
0.9273386001586914,
-0.0014912007609382272,
-0.5169467329978943
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07193v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07193v1
|
CuentosIE: can a chatbot about "tales with a message" help to teach emotional intelligence?
| 2024-03-11T22:27:16 | 2024-03-11T22:27:16 |
Antonio Ferrández, Rocío Lavigne-Cerván, Jesús Peral, Ignasi Navarro-Soria, Ángel Lloret, David Gil, Carmen Rocamora
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.0
|
In this article, we present CuentosIE (TalesEI: chatbot of tales with a
message to develop Emotional Intelligence), an educational chatbot on emotions
that also provides teachers and psychologists with a tool to monitor their
students/patients through indicators and data compiled by CuentosIE. The use of
"tales with a message" is justified by their simplicity and easy understanding,
thanks to their moral or associated metaphors. The main contributions of
CuentosIE are the selection, collection, and classification of a set of highly
specialized tales, as well as the provision of tools (searching, reading
comprehension, chatting, recommending, and classifying) that are useful for
both educating users about emotions and monitoring their emotional development.
The preliminary evaluation of the tool has obtained encouraging results, which
provides an affirmative answer to the question posed in the title of the
article.
|
[
-0.34332075715065,
-0.6036457419395447,
0.40864846110343933,
0.41144371032714844,
-0.36956125497817993,
0.07505444437265396,
-0.3217368423938751,
-0.43726763129234314,
0.4490607976913452,
0.19767898321151733,
-0.9360042214393616,
-0.4913747012615204,
-0.5993884801864624,
-0.019435716792941093,
-0.3869273364543915,
0.8770526647567749,
0.44030362367630005,
0.0548468679189682,
-0.03616150841116905,
-0.27310752868652344,
-0.4658883810043335,
-0.3237772285938263,
-1.0856940746307373,
-0.02357393130660057,
0.7829990983009338,
0.6759226322174072,
0.44816264510154724,
0.39958950877189636,
0.5267544984817505,
0.3123615086078644,
0.14802667498588562,
0.10083351284265518,
-0.3869260251522064,
0.42996716499328613,
-0.0963226929306984,
-0.8852108120918274,
-0.40176352858543396,
0.10841842740774155,
0.1923455446958542,
0.41768187284469604,
-0.059098806232213974,
0.2538962662220001,
-0.11246392875909805,
0.8366783857345581,
-0.44290414452552795,
-0.0075116828083992004,
-0.07310778647661209,
0.3441242575645447,
0.17039082944393158,
-0.3072884976863861,
-0.3683072626590729,
-0.5180894136428833,
0.18213514983654022,
-0.412983775138855,
-0.2020861655473709,
0.07324433326721191,
0.4005800783634186,
0.39677783846855164,
-0.7264617681503296,
-0.7107536792755127,
-0.46161535382270813,
0.7745365500450134,
-0.23708395659923553,
-0.021657362580299377,
0.352877676486969,
0.5110975503921509,
0.1725163459777832,
-0.3928167521953583,
-0.43495073914527893,
-0.008699151687324047,
-0.07345672696828842,
0.5731790065765381,
-0.4130130410194397,
-0.23253846168518066,
0.27288660407066345,
-0.2036581039428711,
-0.13961859047412872,
0.08923901617527008,
-0.32752302289009094,
-0.057472020387649536,
0.842547595500946,
0.46192461252212524,
0.644900381565094,
-0.03612307086586952,
-0.2489984780550003,
-0.31357628107070923,
-0.4092726409435272,
0.3237623870372772,
0.7614203691482544,
0.2619578540325165,
-0.08185269683599472,
0.3791281580924988,
0.18214908242225647,
0.018932433798909187,
0.08736979961395264,
0.07081244885921478,
0.38011083006858826,
0.24410779774188995,
0.26982221007347107,
0.5096212029457092,
0.6856207251548767,
0.6811028718948364,
0.27683892846107483,
0.4265139102935791,
-0.13687656819820404,
0.36819222569465637,
0.1564323604106903,
-0.9444260001182556,
-0.23075270652770996,
0.5496169924736023,
-0.41643646359443665,
-0.5766750574111938,
-0.07363665848970413,
-1.215253472328186,
-0.7529885172843933,
0.16576942801475525,
0.05512037128210068,
-0.6183708310127258,
-0.4043450355529785,
0.00019984153914265335,
-0.21159951388835907,
-0.11022721976041794,
0.49384331703186035,
-0.9065506458282471,
0.18313361704349518,
0.5797911882400513,
0.5850440859794617,
0.14534805715084076,
-0.28261327743530273,
-0.6211578845977783,
-0.43590879440307617,
-0.3628334105014801,
1.0054231882095337,
-0.8126547932624817,
-0.5999435186386108,
0.3665112555027008,
0.015424727462232113,
-0.10095804929733276,
0.11273027956485748,
0.8436520099639893,
0.18529170751571655,
0.5398791432380676,
-0.16946688294410706,
-0.5636953115463257,
-0.36492806673049927,
0.3256177604198456,
-0.49018093943595886,
1.0032567977905273,
0.17842493951320648,
-0.6244738698005676,
-0.03331811726093292,
-0.8203773498535156,
-0.515401303768158,
0.1471533328294754,
0.22960345447063446,
0.09067966043949127,
0.14853444695472717,
0.12522989511489868,
0.1735762357711792,
-0.07515747100114822,
0.06409133225679398,
-0.05733466520905495,
-0.3906998038291931,
0.3587297797203064,
-0.4965859055519104,
0.8506454229354858,
0.2527816891670227,
-0.42331674695014954,
0.14717254042625427,
-0.36090517044067383,
0.03162848949432373,
0.04730771481990814,
-0.04835835471749306,
-0.2846190929412842,
0.34314003586769104,
0.12590765953063965,
0.2835284471511841,
0.36691316962242126,
-0.41482648253440857,
-0.10340695828199387,
-0.19022361934185028,
0.0374143160879612,
0.5121880173683167,
0.0461556501686573,
0.16791634261608124,
-0.492041677236557,
0.5919333100318909,
0.10104135423898697,
0.3748101592063904,
-0.5723031163215637,
-0.4999069273471832,
-0.9209578037261963,
-0.05361432209610939,
-0.3098364472389221,
0.7901675701141357,
-0.40648147463798523,
0.49742791056632996,
0.17511574923992157,
-0.9917839765548706,
-0.9606773257255554,
-0.19273464381694794,
0.16394038498401642,
0.6830891370773315,
0.13493043184280396,
-0.15208800137043,
-0.1868218183517456,
-0.49285537004470825,
-0.23985923826694489,
-0.4868375062942505,
-0.00820635724812746,
0.5223835110664368,
0.3935871720314026,
-0.02880139648914337,
0.4196847677230835,
-0.16422495245933533,
-0.0798594132065773,
-0.3524076044559479,
0.27020612359046936,
0.13335224986076355,
0.34436848759651184,
0.955495297908783,
-0.6495242714881897,
-0.47872036695480347,
-0.047956015914678574,
-0.7180866599082947,
-0.23829011619091034,
-0.04011779651045799,
-0.43455421924591064,
-0.2248915582895279,
-0.02375097945332527,
-0.5090698003768921,
0.31458780169487,
0.03706888481974602,
-0.7880750894546509,
0.5601456165313721,
-0.21245385706424713,
0.6604201793670654,
-0.8156803846359253,
-0.17955929040908813,
0.2639780342578888,
-0.06634471565485,
-0.7786960601806641,
-0.46385690569877625,
0.048823032528162,
-0.1361459642648697,
-0.934103786945343,
0.6975403428077698,
0.046391312032938004,
0.2406163513660431,
-0.31911689043045044,
0.586742639541626,
-0.11632177233695984,
0.30548086762428284,
0.1837102770805359,
0.5426702499389648,
0.8619416356086731,
-0.38142311573028564,
0.9689900875091553,
0.5427595376968384,
0.1327657699584961,
1.5669649839401245,
-0.4486730992794037,
0.15890271961688995,
-0.20945928990840912,
-0.08771269023418427,
-0.39586836099624634,
-0.18138308823108673,
0.4499635100364685,
-0.6398975253105164,
0.023675410076975822,
0.05245978385210037,
-0.28972160816192627,
-0.6483494639396667,
-0.5079712271690369,
-0.3394935429096222,
0.7701199054718018,
-0.6742169260978699,
0.3888821601867676,
0.4405439794063568,
-0.2976789176464081,
-0.568709671497345,
-0.4908508360385895,
-0.01880302093923092,
-0.6214987635612488,
-0.5191894173622131,
-0.42113348841667175,
-0.3147743344306946,
-0.3068845272064209,
0.25766363739967346,
-0.039825256913900375,
-0.09607283025979996,
0.30723345279693604,
0.25671839714050293,
0.20848910510540009,
-0.4226627051830292,
0.9130979180335999,
0.41281598806381226,
-0.16991980373859406,
0.5797781944274902,
-0.02794453874230385,
0.36764979362487793,
-0.7680333852767944,
-0.3638977110385895,
-0.4578480124473572,
0.5312493443489075,
0.5685673356056213,
-0.18648453056812286,
0.6826260089874268,
0.8301435708999634,
-0.3051469326019287,
-0.42699840664863586,
-0.3019947409629822,
-0.41233304142951965,
-0.4318900406360626,
0.5124658942222595,
0.12490345537662506,
-0.49790552258491516,
0.45591089129447937,
-0.2168184518814087,
-0.09167623519897461,
0.4943450391292572,
0.4787364900112152,
-0.7117330431938171,
1.124903678894043,
0.46810370683670044,
-0.12157367169857025,
0.5866752862930298,
0.08355196565389633,
0.18599580228328705,
-0.5094455480575562,
-0.35679173469543457,
-0.5459374785423279,
-0.7872509956359863,
-0.23598100244998932,
0.15765729546546936,
-0.02557336539030075,
-0.5735040307044983,
-0.6517844200134277,
-0.051295578479766846,
-0.6502788662910461,
0.4983561933040619,
0.6505999565124512,
0.28125202655792236,
-0.053039707243442535,
-0.37580418586730957,
0.5536057949066162,
-0.02974175475537777,
-0.4443278908729553,
-0.9508280158042908,
0.7827375531196594,
0.1545821875333786,
0.5057671070098877,
-0.007691046688705683,
0.6282433867454529,
0.47046399116516113,
0.3586488366127014,
-0.9940601587295532,
0.7489768266677856,
0.1844153255224228,
-0.4051479995250702,
-0.2667563855648041,
-0.20988957583904266,
-1.0360310077667236,
-0.0008122442523017526,
-0.4812617897987366,
-1.0286105871200562,
0.12093506008386612,
-0.08755018562078476,
-0.2025192826986313,
0.3451990783214569,
-0.7971141338348389,
0.9789941906929016,
-0.8618758916854858,
-0.13532713055610657,
-0.4192304313182831,
-0.7805205583572388,
-0.06457698345184326,
-0.0015730845043435693,
0.1621083915233612,
-0.7197183966636658,
-0.17427782714366913,
1.085900902748108,
-0.26645463705062866,
1.0366524457931519,
-0.25592419505119324,
0.4014984965324402,
0.7638868093490601,
0.1293417364358902,
0.12058132886886597,
-0.041647929698228836,
-0.0830199122428894,
-0.6146770715713501,
0.20758064091205597,
-0.4123152494430542,
-0.7405773997306824,
0.6282269358634949,
-1.0653891563415527,
-0.7137098908424377,
-0.4030842185020447,
-0.5346987843513489,
-0.3291533887386322,
0.20162564516067505,
-0.10058321803808212,
0.4139499366283417,
-0.04339956119656563,
0.17216727137565613,
0.5639051198959351,
-0.18043029308319092,
0.44940051436424255,
0.47012463212013245,
0.006322834640741348,
0.1712673306465149,
0.9036322832107544,
-0.28312399983406067,
-0.21906563639640808,
0.04130562022328377,
0.4005688428878784,
-0.18933989107608795,
0.03046204335987568,
-0.06348371505737305,
0.21701698005199432,
-1.030208945274353,
-0.253188818693161,
-0.4509083032608032,
-0.028156202286481857,
0.07104259729385376,
-0.6070593595504761,
-0.39052194356918335,
-0.2921385169029236,
-0.5048394799232483,
-0.6015213131904602,
0.8899920582771301,
0.7106235027313232,
0.03223911300301552,
0.6135782599449158,
-0.9407830834388733,
-0.596333920955658,
0.39982470870018005,
0.026161961257457733,
-0.13628791272640228,
-0.09461473673582077,
-0.12151523679494858,
0.29536277055740356,
-0.27553704380989075,
-1.3211404085159302,
0.7003639340400696,
0.28670766949653625,
0.439548134803772,
0.6604980230331421,
0.5180312395095825,
-0.058641497045755386,
0.20775893330574036,
0.5608210563659668,
0.347468763589859,
-0.866658627986908,
1.1448665857315063,
-0.42785021662712097,
-0.07051797956228256,
0.5492771863937378,
0.6105923652648926,
-0.983953595161438,
-0.7070485353469849,
-0.865536630153656,
-0.6068207621574402,
0.8076823949813843,
-0.027227748185396194,
0.6583602428436279,
-0.21525728702545166,
-0.20722660422325134,
0.027876848354935646,
0.397103488445282,
-0.23696120083332062,
-0.302877277135849,
-0.47907719016075134,
-0.8314164280891418,
0.23098844289779663,
-0.39284586906433105,
-0.26971933245658875,
0.018407298251986504,
0.6528452634811401,
-0.0326526015996933,
0.24924229085445404,
-0.03194889426231384,
-0.133973628282547,
-0.06281443685293198,
0.21080522239208221,
0.0170762836933136,
0.14182817935943604,
-0.07412190735340118,
0.2985207736492157,
0.3108985424041748,
-0.7957045435905457,
0.058581337332725525,
-0.3568875789642334,
0.21143706142902374,
-0.2508136034011841,
0.36210569739341736,
0.9289557337760925,
0.3454694449901581,
-1.1270520687103271,
0.7074407935142517,
-0.24245670437812805,
0.023502042517066002,
-0.11341564357280731,
0.4467369318008423,
0.10526028275489807,
0.6902744174003601,
0.21327467262744904,
0.11307477951049805,
0.07821138203144073,
-0.49797549843788147,
0.17754921317100525,
-0.341788649559021,
-0.9228346347808838,
-0.42824751138687134,
0.48492830991744995,
0.6409562230110168,
-0.5776611566543579,
1.238619089126587,
-0.1643059402704239,
-0.6990967392921448,
1.1304728984832764,
0.5943813323974609,
0.8252353072166443,
-0.42977818846702576,
0.7825282216072083,
0.3817835748195648,
0.35120201110839844,
0.04987289384007454,
0.36755988001823425,
0.16915149986743927,
-0.7362658381462097,
0.41507256031036377,
-0.012721279636025429,
-0.7660950422286987,
-0.5703412294387817,
-0.690948486328125,
0.27971237897872925,
-0.27252572774887085,
-0.13633592426776886,
-0.36917585134506226,
0.09361330419778824,
-0.8731139302253723,
0.36796197295188904,
0.26327186822891235,
0.9683977365493774,
-1.1818162202835083,
0.535696804523468,
0.8711608648300171,
-0.46162790060043335,
-0.7538517117500305,
-0.43118295073509216,
0.1883353739976883,
-0.7820979356765747,
0.40467068552970886,
0.38046467304229736,
-0.14536714553833008,
-0.11969595402479172,
-0.5052714943885803,
-0.40755558013916016,
0.9186201691627502,
0.09294072538614273,
-0.1861547827720642,
0.460750013589859,
-0.30581262707710266,
0.8282507658004761,
-0.7651995420455933,
0.8551252484321594,
0.5943358540534973,
0.7345325350761414,
0.09999944269657135,
-0.3111460506916046,
-0.21205876767635345,
-1.0118108987808228,
-0.7354823350906372,
-0.14082323014736176,
-0.5915947556495667,
0.4644104540348053,
-0.31512612104415894,
-0.2697352170944214,
-0.3351188600063324,
0.6526898741722107,
-0.08982377499341965,
0.6163121461868286,
0.31969496607780457,
-0.08015447109937668,
1.4607685804367065,
-0.3931434452533722,
1.049896478652954,
-0.6075699329376221,
0.33011624217033386,
0.7445230484008789,
-0.1854691505432129,
0.8897369503974915,
0.14334474503993988,
-0.06295076757669449,
0.3846498131752014,
0.8627603650093079,
-0.1425565928220749,
0.2998286187648773,
-0.12018701434135437,
-0.495542049407959,
-0.2861831784248352,
-0.42464756965637207,
-0.1702416092157364,
0.12718653678894043,
0.8115128874778748,
0.09435969591140747,
0.014682252891361713,
0.308599054813385,
0.38516008853912354,
0.15940667688846588,
-0.5785207748413086,
0.2620994448661804,
0.09419647604227066,
-0.41621288657188416,
-0.19227774441242218,
-0.5912485122680664,
0.44170793890953064,
-0.34700673818588257,
0.29739120602607727,
-0.4648243486881256,
0.015151617117226124,
-0.19401389360427856,
-1.0963729619979858,
0.14437371492385864,
0.2803131937980652,
0.44480568170547485,
-0.18767397105693817,
1.0096032619476318,
-0.506618320941925,
-0.5686869025230408,
0.17253348231315613,
0.9366930723190308,
0.3582901358604431,
0.19065313041210175,
-0.649981677532196,
-0.225848987698555,
-0.37164440751075745,
-0.4504522979259491,
0.09026102721691132,
0.8537895679473877,
0.08636237680912018,
0.9693520665168762,
0.3050546944141388,
-0.11847905814647675,
-0.20679736137390137,
0.15626735985279083,
0.6815190315246582,
-0.5909975171089172,
-0.6214446425437927,
-0.588752031326294,
0.5786455273628235,
-0.3382798433303833,
-0.44611480832099915,
0.7306984066963196,
0.14238961040973663,
0.14253252744674683,
-0.08342907577753067,
0.6522498726844788,
0.019698558375239372,
0.23815391957759857,
0.08012890815734863,
1.0047458410263062,
-0.4355505108833313,
-0.04993361607193947,
-0.09358442574739456,
-0.7292906641960144,
-0.22555390000343323,
0.8172649145126343,
-0.3586950898170471,
-0.03210867568850517,
0.938525378704071,
0.25821807980537415,
0.479521244764328,
0.4657926559448242,
0.2787642776966095,
0.19445905089378357,
0.13830997049808502,
0.7504589557647705,
1.3840712308883667,
0.04717240855097771,
0.5266111493110657,
-0.3566442131996155,
-0.34710967540740967,
-0.4880927503108978,
-0.6676637530326843,
-1.2738381624221802,
-0.5036560893058777,
-0.5163362622261047,
-0.06279291957616806,
0.19186539947986603,
1.181225061416626,
0.21037493646144867,
-0.5055379271507263,
-0.13524210453033447,
0.32389289140701294,
0.47242751717567444,
-0.3059295117855072,
-0.10338292270898819,
0.44331860542297363,
-0.5086776614189148,
-0.923721969127655,
0.20230238139629364,
0.2657044529914856,
-0.0014022362884134054,
0.09174630790948868,
0.13090912997722626,
0.15232150256633759,
0.4568745791912079,
0.3831743001937866,
0.28116631507873535,
0.058094944804906845,
-0.7319621443748474,
0.2113470882177353,
-0.24768881499767303,
0.07271246612071991,
0.4036729037761688,
-0.5741984248161316,
0.4351184666156769,
0.24153637886047363,
0.33249416947364807,
0.298263281583786,
-0.35002031922340393,
0.3640584945678711,
-0.3767729103565216,
0.4495360255241394,
0.5784995555877686,
0.6193629503250122,
0.04587719216942787,
-0.6054998636245728,
0.684928834438324,
0.04206492006778717,
-0.3257621228694916,
-0.651915967464447,
0.06171681731939316,
-0.9061026573181152,
0.22464187443256378,
0.7070491909980774,
-0.299490362405777,
-0.5095221996307373,
0.26727166771888733,
-0.8007317781448364,
0.16533829271793365,
-0.7830447554588318,
0.7110307812690735,
0.6156682372093201,
0.006573486141860485,
-0.39648428559303284,
-0.6250120401382446,
0.1960366815328598,
0.3490836024284363,
-1.2223211526870728,
-0.14165911078453064,
0.4611622989177704,
-0.14208438992500305,
0.03397202491760254,
0.2203703671693802,
0.15763156116008759,
0.5019108653068542,
0.4135841131210327,
0.11336525529623032,
-0.02643742971122265,
-0.2854611873626709,
0.09517685323953629,
0.06558190286159515,
-0.22596390545368195,
-0.13821455836296082
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07191v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07191v1
|
$\mathbf{(N,K)}$-Puzzle: A Cost-Efficient Testbed for Benchmarking Reinforcement Learning Algorithms in Generative Language Model
| 2024-03-11T22:24:14 | 2024-03-11T22:24:14 |
Yufeng Zhang, Liyu Chen, Boyi Liu, Yingxiang Yang, Qiwen Cui, Yunzhe Tao, Hongxia Yang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Recent advances in reinforcement learning (RL) algorithms aim to enhance the
performance of language models at scale. Yet, there is a noticeable absence of
a cost-effective and standardized testbed tailored to evaluating and comparing
these algorithms. To bridge this gap, we present a generalized version of the
24-Puzzle: the $(N,K)$-Puzzle, which challenges language models to reach a
target value $K$ with $N$ integers. We evaluate the effectiveness of
established RL algorithms such as Proximal Policy Optimization (PPO), alongside
novel approaches like Identity Policy Optimization (IPO) and Direct Policy
Optimization (DPO).
|
[
-0.31993940472602844,
-0.6877802610397339,
0.3551245629787445,
0.5469126105308533,
-0.18363434076309204,
0.3669900596141815,
-0.2801598608493805,
-0.09176161885261536,
-0.34033235907554626,
0.2705340087413788,
-0.9392780661582947,
-0.2934345304965973,
-0.43667206168174744,
0.22193749248981476,
-0.031502317637205124,
0.8899654746055603,
-0.16956603527069092,
-0.0070951757952570915,
-0.0551350973546505,
-0.06930098682641983,
-0.39447277784347534,
-0.107882559299469,
-0.8249251246452332,
-0.41645658016204834,
0.5545832514762878,
0.46830233931541443,
0.79732745885849,
0.5347102284431458,
0.4870195984840393,
0.29204151034355164,
0.04363805055618286,
0.254731148481369,
-0.6364692449569702,
0.14166690409183502,
0.07001644372940063,
-0.8099381923675537,
0.09115128219127655,
0.08228888362646103,
0.7980474829673767,
0.4704289734363556,
-0.2538810074329376,
-0.10275017470121384,
-0.446488618850708,
1.003172755241394,
-0.8115372061729431,
0.32572752237319946,
-0.5759639143943787,
0.36004242300987244,
0.10809207707643509,
0.2382860630750656,
-0.5244467854499817,
-0.7994840741157532,
-0.038467902690172195,
-0.8104153275489807,
-0.1582263559103012,
0.12720061838626862,
0.9699342250823975,
0.2837822139263153,
-0.35173362493515015,
-0.41174665093421936,
-0.6612958312034607,
0.9927198886871338,
-0.4976676106452942,
0.4618692994117737,
0.3584722578525543,
0.5293796062469482,
-0.4155794382095337,
-0.3391340970993042,
-0.5663893818855286,
-0.6351276636123657,
0.36124902963638306,
0.21483728289604187,
-0.12080160528421402,
-0.13096930086612701,
0.13581836223602295,
0.5964074730873108,
-0.5684229135513306,
0.3391813635826111,
-0.0155183682218194,
-0.19134914875030518,
0.7788128852844238,
0.3668835163116455,
0.1697389930486679,
0.05327260121703148,
-0.15843625366687775,
-0.6010482907295227,
-0.7374580502510071,
0.10794026404619217,
0.7854403853416443,
0.01712382398545742,
-0.1539636105298996,
0.25832298398017883,
-0.3808707892894745,
0.43686360120773315,
-0.0453166738152504,
-0.017566073685884476,
0.3747106194496155,
-0.33495816588401794,
0.10353006422519684,
-0.3772870600223541,
0.8851991891860962,
0.32922789454460144,
0.5598663687705994,
-0.36582228541374207,
-0.31052231788635254,
0.5269506573677063,
0.29971960186958313,
-0.6185491681098938,
-0.5151335597038269,
-0.041551608592271805,
-0.17525367438793182,
-0.7138615250587463,
-0.5679225325584412,
-1.0251421928405762,
0.03409210219979286,
0.0067452541552484035,
0.5539918541908264,
-0.4508883059024811,
-0.5009177923202515,
-0.05198398604989052,
-0.17584609985351562,
0.4729277491569519,
0.2768958508968353,
-0.9210088849067688,
0.5776274800300598,
0.7218443751335144,
0.6807432174682617,
-0.17414188385009766,
-0.08183924108743668,
-0.5227147340774536,
-0.5262972712516785,
-0.862668514251709,
0.48047491908073425,
-0.8122318387031555,
-0.581685483455658,
0.06008513271808624,
-0.2142031043767929,
-0.22341838479042053,
-0.7793065309524536,
0.334406316280365,
-0.7683607935905457,
0.2540717124938965,
-0.23608672618865967,
-0.6006189584732056,
0.050713054835796356,
0.598395824432373,
-0.6760319471359253,
1.101306676864624,
0.2628816068172455,
-0.25781193375587463,
0.16079081594944,
-0.7173791527748108,
-0.1667332500219345,
0.2903517782688141,
-0.5525829195976257,
-0.789380669593811,
0.07963255047798157,
0.07314122468233109,
-0.06988827884197235,
-0.44244325160980225,
0.20446808636188507,
-0.16067758202552795,
-0.4805664122104645,
0.3047912120819092,
-0.4048905372619629,
0.6007769703865051,
0.3126872181892395,
-0.5057321190834045,
0.15458616614341736,
-0.920205295085907,
0.16865672171115875,
0.6270533800125122,
-0.6063537001609802,
-0.12146884948015213,
-0.017028933390975,
-0.2752797305583954,
-0.004910459741950035,
0.21515946090221405,
-0.6831002831459045,
0.28453490138053894,
-0.3846774995326996,
0.4568134844303131,
0.8835291862487793,
-0.056479018181562424,
0.4539145231246948,
-0.28206223249435425,
0.8831307291984558,
-0.0890175849199295,
0.5034221410751343,
0.09040788561105728,
-0.6506516933441162,
-0.6567654609680176,
-0.17073212563991547,
0.5875672101974487,
0.5158674120903015,
-0.9790216088294983,
0.12361755967140198,
-0.015522172674536705,
-0.6248283982276917,
-0.6398932337760925,
-0.21288463473320007,
1.0114120244979858,
0.1068609282374382,
0.30117323994636536,
-0.15153367817401886,
-0.11662744730710983,
-0.9390185475349426,
-0.2966609299182892,
-0.11765928566455841,
0.22772721946239471,
0.5377320647239685,
0.5858898162841797,
-0.033057719469070435,
0.7011419534683228,
-0.5529865026473999,
0.06178155913949013,
-0.09400370717048645,
0.30492842197418213,
0.19443190097808838,
0.41584905982017517,
0.3437429964542389,
-0.9357566833496094,
-0.8006483912467957,
0.0795874372124672,
-0.5188775658607483,
0.016581611707806587,
0.10536810755729675,
0.21645386517047882,
0.3486489951610565,
0.4049469828605652,
-0.4353257715702057,
0.25742238759994507,
0.6960550546646118,
-0.20626300573349,
1.0758590698242188,
-0.5510650277137756,
0.02781100757420063,
-0.39355629682540894,
-0.364834189414978,
-0.318196177482605,
0.05205972120165825,
-0.4815114736557007,
0.4232752025127411,
0.40323466062545776,
-0.19258423149585724,
-0.029583554714918137,
0.07170597463846207,
-0.38576772809028625,
-0.14882579445838928,
-0.14107149839401245,
-0.026297591626644135,
-0.20727598667144775,
0.7658680081367493,
-0.4212900996208191,
1.0030505657196045,
0.23155318200588226,
-0.663438618183136,
0.20120248198509216,
-0.05981176346540451,
-0.5128096342086792,
0.5278723239898682,
-0.402399480342865,
0.3109125792980194,
-0.30638641119003296,
0.07844073325395584,
-0.8680313229560852,
0.27027878165245056,
0.2412228137254715,
-0.3216933012008667,
0.0025942197535187006,
0.09572213143110275,
-0.4732171595096588,
-0.15602149069309235,
-0.30379778146743774,
0.49737438559532166,
0.8939639329910278,
-0.4616827070713043,
0.25981923937797546,
0.10228776931762695,
0.3328442871570587,
-0.6256951689720154,
-0.12062089890241623,
-0.01424526609480381,
-0.48924118280410767,
-0.14434564113616943,
0.5808035731315613,
-0.304179847240448,
-0.12161918729543686,
0.15065357089042664,
-0.12462705373764038,
0.17556385695934296,
0.3758184611797333,
-0.05003238841891289,
0.09519284963607788,
-0.2192981243133545,
0.14782723784446716,
-0.3778800070285797,
-0.23506833612918854,
0.2843800187110901,
0.04309961572289467,
0.6570876240730286,
-0.2879875600337982,
-0.25526511669158936,
-0.011780817061662674,
0.10972906649112701,
0.2616208791732788,
-0.31503817439079285,
0.3806624114513397,
0.3822286128997803,
-0.19633178412914276,
-0.5822161436080933,
-0.3596790134906769,
0.02927865833044052,
-0.545945942401886,
0.6289018392562866,
-0.7876452803611755,
-1.0174517631530762,
0.5080515146255493,
-0.4869905114173889,
0.06296844780445099,
0.4337688684463501,
0.3871981203556061,
0.27070191502571106,
1.0279955863952637,
0.3769943416118622,
-0.07284605503082275,
0.37261441349983215,
-0.16765227913856506,
0.47107741236686707,
-0.8642533421516418,
-0.41208401322364807,
-0.5859351754188538,
-0.3725188374519348,
-0.8235024213790894,
-0.4182897210121155,
0.2894008457660675,
0.19734741747379303,
-0.41816404461860657,
0.5169032216072083,
-0.48488426208496094,
0.558770477771759,
0.8393837809562683,
-0.04849380627274513,
0.27300938963890076,
-0.38380467891693115,
-0.6633713245391846,
-0.27943819761276245,
-0.617007851600647,
-0.07237211614847183,
1.3436181545257568,
0.20489563047885895,
0.46070295572280884,
0.32337525486946106,
0.8259495496749878,
0.28734299540519714,
0.20764002203941345,
-0.5299177169799805,
0.6351235508918762,
-0.07611877471208572,
-0.39069822430610657,
-0.5027401447296143,
-0.7315707802772522,
-1.1398684978485107,
0.5426194667816162,
-0.15574677288532257,
-0.8560688495635986,
0.22086407244205475,
-0.0675220638513565,
-0.16779227554798126,
0.09391786903142929,
-0.608668327331543,
1.0549111366271973,
-0.2622718811035156,
-0.08720146119594574,
-0.4745402932167053,
-0.24658431112766266,
0.3653058409690857,
-0.03697042167186737,
0.29976484179496765,
-0.40250346064567566,
0.08267036825418472,
0.7364256978034973,
-0.42658481001853943,
0.32327577471733093,
-0.27563178539276123,
0.04203565791249275,
-0.06868735700845718,
0.17861898243427277,
0.7284939885139465,
0.02938031777739525,
0.3264187276363373,
-0.3074665069580078,
-0.10067551583051682,
-0.3160437345504761,
-0.764586865901947,
0.643237829208374,
-1.1620309352874756,
-0.3187808394432068,
-0.3733008801937103,
-0.6758897304534912,
-0.4287770092487335,
-0.07506023347377777,
-0.021322784945368767,
0.3173238933086395,
-0.3517555296421051,
0.18941010534763336,
0.9895424246788025,
-0.5584633946418762,
0.5006644129753113,
0.7593482732772827,
-0.3569228947162628,
-0.5439108610153198,
1.1893974542617798,
0.12853960692882538,
0.4437672197818756,
0.4979656934738159,
0.4697447419166565,
-0.16793833673000336,
-0.722249448299408,
-0.16836591064929962,
0.09464740008115768,
-0.616098940372467,
0.009005102328956127,
-0.5038419365882874,
-0.3061201870441437,
-0.07955826073884964,
0.11108867079019547,
-0.699403703212738,
-0.09784979373216629,
0.24673902988433838,
0.0007198014063760638,
0.34880441427230835,
0.6360085606575012,
-0.3416859805583954,
0.19330383837223053,
-0.14511962234973907,
0.386955201625824,
0.6576276421546936,
0.5252199172973633,
0.06886190176010132,
-0.10674960911273956,
-0.05379475653171539,
-0.15820106863975525,
-0.3770920932292938,
-0.781469464302063,
0.05584491044282913,
0.04791007190942764,
0.6075888276100159,
0.41042158007621765,
0.22949716448783875,
0.407744824886322,
-0.7561246156692505,
0.48391422629356384,
0.23636789619922638,
-0.6690587997436523,
0.21368750929832458,
-0.18402507901191711,
0.35126474499702454,
0.6016170978546143,
0.37099263072013855,
-0.644406795501709,
-0.16006867587566376,
-0.8156426548957825,
-0.7458174228668213,
0.4393218159675598,
0.3966293931007385,
0.03550931066274643,
-0.17654642462730408,
0.09760961681604385,
-0.1018446758389473,
0.2164819985628128,
-0.6473979949951172,
-0.31618374586105347,
0.11622786521911621,
-0.2438526302576065,
-0.19355568289756775,
-0.19205158948898315,
-0.022718222811818123,
-0.0110575370490551,
0.7023097276687622,
0.005745710805058479,
0.45145782828330994,
-0.1584855169057846,
-0.0439722053706646,
0.02270464040338993,
0.30315837264060974,
0.7475236058235168,
0.3924737870693207,
-0.44358766078948975,
-0.1023794636130333,
-0.008287777192890644,
-0.3532344102859497,
0.4058704078197479,
-0.09510385245084763,
-0.29910793900489807,
-0.11115063726902008,
0.09466883540153503,
1.0589864253997803,
0.6670857667922974,
-0.8625009655952454,
0.45437124371528625,
-0.16301333904266357,
-0.8663926720619202,
-0.3396896421909332,
0.2695778012275696,
0.2306717485189438,
0.4267272353172302,
0.22187992930412292,
-0.4906478226184845,
0.008087866008281708,
-0.41279831528663635,
0.14732195436954498,
0.498819500207901,
-0.43331336975097656,
-0.07538916170597076,
0.4770549237728119,
0.018839413300156593,
-0.9462918043136597,
0.9271373748779297,
-0.5418325662612915,
-0.6935404539108276,
0.7774333953857422,
0.6226427555084229,
0.767491340637207,
-0.07766973972320557,
0.6847432255744934,
0.29857727885246277,
0.5607154965400696,
-0.09857743233442307,
0.4278219938278198,
-0.16336429119110107,
-1.0291402339935303,
-0.652646541595459,
-0.35730206966400146,
-0.7637535929679871,
0.26022064685821533,
-0.7137951254844666,
-0.2873937785625458,
-0.597422182559967,
0.06542094796895981,
-0.1436215341091156,
0.31488725543022156,
-0.726916491985321,
0.08184336870908737,
0.08847081661224365,
0.8831133842468262,
-0.8159301280975342,
0.6705750226974487,
0.3495757579803467,
-0.22224576771259308,
-0.6946315169334412,
-0.3287505507469177,
-0.21817350387573242,
-1.0967507362365723,
0.7921679615974426,
0.09206262975931168,
0.20401053130626678,
0.07634195685386658,
-0.46934765577316284,
-0.814597487449646,
0.789250910282135,
0.10383468866348267,
-0.7826513648033142,
0.16029489040374756,
0.2184755653142929,
0.39605894684791565,
-0.29723304510116577,
0.24393755197525024,
0.7549490928649902,
0.527542769908905,
-0.12012715637683868,
-0.7435794472694397,
-0.033974092453718185,
-0.3349554240703583,
0.16058599948883057,
0.5749289393424988,
-0.7355586886405945,
1.0164470672607422,
0.03787365183234215,
-0.01945362612605095,
-0.1603003591299057,
0.5255908370018005,
0.6157072186470032,
0.10656215250492096,
0.8360944986343384,
1.0011414289474487,
0.6547260284423828,
-0.23906858265399933,
0.9075459241867065,
-0.013298656791448593,
0.547029972076416,
1.039562702178955,
-0.38786906003952026,
0.8128982782363892,
0.4614574909210205,
-0.8071094155311584,
0.6896553635597229,
0.5863099098205566,
-0.10239876061677933,
1.152700424194336,
1.02680242061615,
-0.25085923075675964,
-0.32695963978767395,
0.15305699408054352,
-0.328208863735199,
0.16795006394386292,
0.31789278984069824,
0.20689204335212708,
-0.5531783103942871,
-0.13584111630916595,
0.03535160422325134,
0.31751322746276855,
-0.15924324095249176,
0.8509368896484375,
0.01880386844277382,
-0.7381322979927063,
0.43101927638053894,
0.1882467269897461,
0.541736900806427,
-0.7719160318374634,
-0.129342183470726,
-0.36472025513648987,
0.44505706429481506,
0.3771759271621704,
-0.3108174502849579,
0.07970556616783142,
-0.286578506231308,
0.1775994598865509,
-0.14523611962795258,
0.28205546736717224,
-0.31733572483062744,
-0.31431078910827637,
0.30186331272125244,
0.12294951826334,
0.107367143034935,
-0.1219029650092125,
-0.983066737651825,
0.2623234689235687,
-0.13018463551998138,
-0.18760554492473602,
0.6087731122970581,
0.24813616275787354,
-0.14681662619113922,
0.7860392332077026,
0.6145045757293701,
-0.15019245445728302,
0.27837151288986206,
-0.03735848143696785,
0.6406530141830444,
-0.6520823240280151,
-0.8350725769996643,
-0.8389725089073181,
0.3112727999687195,
-0.1432739794254303,
-0.5221681594848633,
0.6257562637329102,
0.33983731269836426,
1.0177336931228638,
-0.0778122991323471,
0.5613166093826294,
0.0881970077753067,
0.19667138159275055,
-0.44774171710014343,
0.2795660197734833,
-0.30416160821914673,
-0.2626563310623169,
-0.12657363712787628,
-0.8339630961418152,
0.012153868563473225,
0.8112091422080994,
-0.3433546721935272,
-0.07930808514356613,
0.8383206129074097,
0.6903250813484192,
0.491445392370224,
0.2135033905506134,
0.3948468565940857,
-0.12509827315807343,
0.3003249168395996,
1.1090679168701172,
0.973281741142273,
-0.6456406116485596,
0.46105316281318665,
-0.40058600902557373,
-0.29585209488868713,
-0.2920292019844055,
-0.8076017498970032,
-0.8110551834106445,
-0.35913050174713135,
-0.6539227962493896,
-0.23004500567913055,
0.34254175424575806,
0.742345929145813,
0.446928471326828,
-0.7621585130691528,
-0.18669894337654114,
-0.41053643822669983,
0.31320494413375854,
-0.7600528597831726,
-0.20975403487682343,
0.3740961253643036,
-0.5866568088531494,
-0.6948972940444946,
0.6248465180397034,
0.2485203742980957,
-0.24660418927669525,
-0.5294727683067322,
-0.36354246735572815,
-0.30129122734069824,
0.10235612839460373,
0.21496106684207916,
0.30197882652282715,
-0.5670456290245056,
-0.13652925193309784,
-0.03840374946594238,
0.1598280817270279,
-0.045950718224048615,
0.756504476070404,
-0.5913003087043762,
0.5256866216659546,
0.21011126041412354,
1.1396697759628296,
0.7472981214523315,
-0.25910481810569763,
0.7284125685691833,
-0.38996878266334534,
-0.14917881786823273,
0.2576337158679962,
-0.057041704654693604,
0.05576557293534279,
-0.029384231194853783,
0.5797919631004333,
0.23236829042434692,
-0.5743394494056702,
-1.0879230499267578,
0.5015968680381775,
-0.3046019673347473,
-0.24933436512947083,
0.7834291458129883,
-0.26868265867233276,
-0.3095322847366333,
0.022998496890068054,
0.31680595874786377,
-0.07726985216140747,
-0.14304368197917938,
0.7845450639724731,
0.8070476651191711,
0.1904236227273941,
-0.4642849266529083,
-0.7474685311317444,
0.687370777130127,
0.6681327223777771,
-0.6297435760498047,
-0.4063594937324524,
0.14606483280658722,
0.173605278134346,
0.056818220764398575,
0.6862095594406128,
-0.21192088723182678,
0.25213170051574707,
0.12164168804883957,
0.06255766749382019,
0.00941277015954256,
-0.40131881833076477,
-0.24932248890399933,
0.1932910829782486,
0.16014565527439117,
-0.643229603767395
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07183v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07183v2
|
Monitoring AI-Modified Content at Scale: A Case Study on the Impact of ChatGPT on AI Conference Peer Reviews
| 2024-03-11T21:51:39 | 2024-06-15T05:23:06 |
Weixin Liang, Zachary Izzo, Yaohui Zhang, Haley Lepp, Hancheng Cao, Xuandong Zhao, Lingjiao Chen, Haotian Ye, Sheng Liu, Zhi Huang, Daniel A. McFarland, James Y. Zou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SI, I.2.7
|
We present an approach for estimating the fraction of text in a large corpus
which is likely to be substantially modified or produced by a large language
model (LLM). Our maximum likelihood model leverages expert-written and
AI-generated reference texts to accurately and efficiently examine real-world
LLM-use at the corpus level. We apply this approach to a case study of
scientific peer review in AI conferences that took place after the release of
ChatGPT: ICLR 2024, NeurIPS 2023, CoRL 2023 and EMNLP 2023. Our results suggest
that between 6.5% and 16.9% of text submitted as peer reviews to these
conferences could have been substantially modified by LLMs, i.e. beyond
spell-checking or minor writing updates. The circumstances in which generated
text occurs offer insight into user behavior: the estimated fraction of
LLM-generated text is higher in reviews which report lower confidence, were
submitted close to the deadline, and from reviewers who are less likely to
respond to author rebuttals. We also observe corpus-level trends in generated
text which may be too subtle to detect at the individual level, and discuss the
implications of such trends on peer review. We call for future
interdisciplinary work to examine how LLM use is changing our information and
knowledge practices.
|
[
-0.2902888357639313,
-0.7619844079017639,
0.43530896306037903,
-0.0010584747651591897,
-0.010405112989246845,
0.01538489107042551,
-0.3250761926174164,
-0.6456109285354614,
0.236541748046875,
0.3288443982601166,
-0.12862280011177063,
-0.37658393383026123,
-0.883095920085907,
0.43455466628074646,
-0.8248605132102966,
1.2598365545272827,
0.06356129795312881,
0.08997795730829239,
-0.17229145765304565,
0.053293246775865555,
-0.10695615410804749,
-0.6381502747535706,
-0.7824001312255859,
-0.5186766386032104,
0.5900516510009766,
0.23941238224506378,
0.6933380961418152,
0.27387064695358276,
1.0268738269805908,
0.26068365573883057,
-0.46893808245658875,
-0.04330866411328316,
-0.48158568143844604,
-0.03870011121034622,
-0.03142933174967766,
-0.4699697494506836,
-0.7025752663612366,
0.27333545684814453,
1.0068747997283936,
0.564941942691803,
0.04606841504573822,
0.22615908086299896,
0.3817686438560486,
0.5165184140205383,
-0.34321027994155884,
0.29322680830955505,
-0.8317734003067017,
0.1251245141029358,
-0.1313774138689041,
-0.18682092428207397,
-0.4957062304019928,
0.04673171415925026,
0.08813362568616867,
-0.392063170671463,
0.1596977412700653,
0.16940025985240936,
0.6678985953330994,
0.45470720529556274,
-0.2476489245891571,
-0.3697267770767212,
-0.7661312222480774,
0.6848918795585632,
-0.7407843470573425,
0.1927594691514969,
0.43348953127861023,
-0.11541570723056793,
-0.29906368255615234,
-0.9617127776145935,
-0.7228976488113403,
-0.5078697800636292,
-0.055568546056747437,
0.04620042443275452,
-0.3641684651374817,
0.1634504646062851,
0.25995248556137085,
0.3474580943584442,
-0.15637265145778656,
-0.02208055555820465,
-0.4498632848262787,
-0.2521449625492096,
0.7719681262969971,
0.1684408336877823,
0.3258550763130188,
-0.04667770117521286,
-0.04863450303673744,
-0.11550459265708923,
-0.9438149333000183,
-0.1145709976553917,
0.23761171102523804,
-0.10963235050439835,
0.06190313771367073,
0.8018336892127991,
0.02514851652085781,
0.4423970878124237,
0.07429218292236328,
0.054654479026794434,
0.10492964833974838,
-0.727851390838623,
-0.11870723962783813,
0.010486660525202751,
1.072736144065857,
0.45887839794158936,
0.29289934039115906,
0.2472597360610962,
-0.22597984969615936,
-0.2669772207736969,
0.3272460699081421,
-0.8236141204833984,
-0.23969368636608124,
0.04393672198057175,
-0.6794162392616272,
-0.5446412563323975,
-0.1107671931385994,
-0.6279374361038208,
-0.7684663534164429,
-0.25375470519065857,
0.06407000869512558,
-0.24941802024841309,
-0.06162241846323013,
-0.10556618124246597,
0.050976965576410294,
-0.016152789816260338,
0.5961565971374512,
-0.5769102573394775,
0.05320701375603676,
0.8393284678459167,
1.0369946956634521,
-0.463746577501297,
-0.3763815462589264,
-0.3684135973453522,
-0.12586727738380432,
-0.35941529273986816,
0.9170980453491211,
-0.49089938402175903,
-0.5498050451278687,
-0.041339971125125885,
-0.4358932673931122,
0.14676101505756378,
-0.5066635012626648,
0.601275622844696,
-0.5319281816482544,
0.18836922943592072,
0.04626872390508652,
-0.739531934261322,
0.2416987270116806,
0.48336562514305115,
-0.5836167335510254,
0.9434563517570496,
-0.19169075787067413,
-0.9800688624382019,
0.5852348804473877,
-0.5861521363258362,
-0.14564399421215057,
0.05792360380291939,
-0.1439129114151001,
-0.609779417514801,
-0.02574039250612259,
0.13199275732040405,
0.2424042522907257,
-0.14101634919643402,
0.44996607303619385,
-0.20987367630004883,
-0.29280102252960205,
0.589285671710968,
-0.4148136377334595,
0.4241437017917633,
0.24696961045265198,
-0.2434379607439041,
0.4201965034008026,
-0.5721641778945923,
-0.33227676153182983,
-0.27447113394737244,
-0.5269802808761597,
-0.028888199478387833,
0.3887302875518799,
0.16066719591617584,
-0.16461420059204102,
0.2587561309337616,
-0.6941513419151306,
0.1409120261669159,
-0.17754009366035461,
0.6676515340805054,
0.7235330939292908,
0.41614896059036255,
0.3977167308330536,
-0.3848748803138733,
0.3481329679489136,
-0.32108253240585327,
0.35257992148399353,
-0.24422802031040192,
-0.8067917227745056,
-0.6573957800865173,
-0.08592921495437622,
0.37049850821495056,
0.15480820834636688,
-0.39040201902389526,
0.30348560214042664,
-0.22491344809532166,
-0.6415295600891113,
-0.4904803931713104,
-0.08146503567695618,
0.17718914151191711,
0.3487812280654907,
0.13579367101192474,
-0.28936007618904114,
-0.2072869837284088,
-0.671770453453064,
-0.6092156767845154,
-0.8503029346466064,
-0.14072895050048828,
0.39447420835494995,
0.5226478576660156,
-0.3134697377681732,
0.9509381651878357,
-0.34531596302986145,
-0.40410131216049194,
-0.08339089900255203,
0.3312000632286072,
0.041694626212120056,
0.40099042654037476,
0.22924216091632843,
-0.8032337427139282,
-0.6079667210578918,
-0.09155618399381638,
-0.5084800124168396,
-0.3822864294052124,
-0.3586108684539795,
0.21723869442939758,
0.0846666470170021,
0.9333747029304504,
-0.5128828883171082,
0.40651214122772217,
0.492683470249176,
-0.42948517203330994,
0.5678495168685913,
-0.10237662494182587,
0.3888951539993286,
-0.8033462166786194,
-0.03718356415629387,
0.15679286420345306,
-0.12235412746667862,
-0.4671035706996918,
0.2937599718570709,
0.030772868543863297,
-0.09069471806287766,
-0.19974209368228912,
0.49117326736450195,
-0.19914981722831726,
0.05363091826438904,
-0.538418173789978,
0.2063538283109665,
-0.1722833514213562,
0.07162388414144516,
0.02693517506122589,
1.0593974590301514,
0.19216200709342957,
-0.29942649602890015,
0.10767282545566559,
0.2535594403743744,
-0.5660115480422974,
0.31742751598358154,
-0.9103493094444275,
0.16549117863178253,
-0.0159052275121212,
0.5611986517906189,
-1.077458143234253,
-0.1764800250530243,
0.1288534700870514,
-0.7632772326469421,
0.17612940073013306,
-0.21974629163742065,
-0.7170073390007019,
0.036076869815588,
-0.3574889898300171,
0.2850116193294525,
0.3470955491065979,
-0.13237157464027405,
0.594428300857544,
0.6620115041732788,
-0.5906158089637756,
-0.27167344093322754,
-0.4540310800075531,
0.6725231409072876,
-0.0032942849211394787,
-0.6071907877922058,
0.310069739818573,
-0.3188406825065613,
-0.7377212047576904,
-0.07662508636713028,
0.10030091553926468,
-0.028144169598817825,
-0.0131785087287426,
0.16348415613174438,
0.22623269259929657,
0.027572236955165863,
0.155753493309021,
0.05676323175430298,
0.13149665296077728,
0.2802281975746155,
-0.05736526846885681,
0.5740082859992981,
-0.09573104977607727,
-0.39248645305633545,
-0.5055564641952515,
0.08984450995922089,
0.5144944787025452,
-0.10466092079877853,
0.4947676360607147,
0.7676151394844055,
-0.07413873821496964,
0.1777220219373703,
-0.5587523579597473,
-0.5569577813148499,
-0.40965768694877625,
0.5195696353912354,
0.0704357847571373,
-1.031134843826294,
0.4182373583316803,
0.03532920032739639,
0.28283047676086426,
0.6661356687545776,
0.8361803293228149,
-0.17333003878593445,
0.8849985003471375,
0.6992905735969543,
-0.1398344188928604,
0.8766207098960876,
0.15013912320137024,
0.24428987503051758,
-0.8111469745635986,
-0.23225447535514832,
-0.7761964201927185,
-0.35430893301963806,
-0.891446053981781,
-0.46857118606567383,
0.6989612579345703,
-0.22297702729701996,
-0.0709165409207344,
-0.033318083733320236,
-0.3901151716709137,
0.4033672511577606,
0.6285834908485413,
0.01982700079679489,
0.5442405939102173,
-0.027743998914957047,
0.26241546869277954,
-0.14272692799568176,
-0.53718101978302,
-0.6119801998138428,
1.4777607917785645,
0.37716391682624817,
0.7075750827789307,
-0.27348366379737854,
0.5646907091140747,
0.8449556231498718,
0.6847426891326904,
-0.7681183218955994,
0.5849866271018982,
0.2475246787071228,
-0.5162379145622253,
-0.38067132234573364,
-0.4599098265171051,
-0.7581178545951843,
0.1800200641155243,
-0.4512440860271454,
-0.48170775175094604,
0.020981289446353912,
-0.01953708939254284,
0.06614115834236145,
0.3416101932525635,
-0.4334712028503418,
0.2590644657611847,
0.23328596353530884,
-0.3163938522338867,
-0.7027798295021057,
-0.4906673729419708,
-0.03549463674426079,
-0.430110901594162,
0.2676421105861664,
-0.07828216999769211,
-0.14824165403842926,
0.8896955847740173,
-0.4049946963787079,
1.029449224472046,
0.1783929318189621,
-0.18279238045215607,
0.6097073554992676,
0.2000657618045807,
0.5782321095466614,
0.4657151699066162,
-0.16467976570129395,
0.475265234708786,
-0.10668110847473145,
-0.20834311842918396,
-0.20936483144760132,
0.6775488257408142,
-1.0208204984664917,
-0.6642103791236877,
-0.6656998991966248,
-0.5405300855636597,
-0.014274167828261852,
0.19394147396087646,
0.34506410360336304,
0.2064812183380127,
-0.29510536789894104,
0.22992685437202454,
0.561763346195221,
-0.30183926224708557,
0.4399038851261139,
0.5727680921554565,
-0.1387198269367218,
-0.4422980546951294,
0.47876614332199097,
-0.009029094129800797,
0.11450982093811035,
0.34064292907714844,
0.3676268756389618,
0.15585297346115112,
-0.9488988518714905,
-0.351068377494812,
0.15882204473018646,
-0.29527655243873596,
-0.12752991914749146,
-0.7721512913703918,
-0.12413186579942703,
-0.47265782952308655,
0.10312406718730927,
-0.2404165416955948,
-0.4339326322078705,
-0.2540268301963806,
0.0281826201826334,
0.21798549592494965,
0.9906718730926514,
-0.11662980914115906,
0.42472150921821594,
-0.6870215535163879,
-0.11222682893276215,
-0.006840983405709267,
0.1548391580581665,
-0.10291902720928192,
-0.7923200130462646,
-0.23893196880817413,
0.07982266694307327,
-0.4138582944869995,
-0.5916357040405273,
0.33900314569473267,
0.4339362680912018,
0.22409005463123322,
0.08997169882059097,
-0.1263691633939743,
0.15328943729400635,
-0.5626935958862305,
1.2158360481262207,
0.019417215138673782,
-0.8782302737236023,
0.4183022081851959,
-0.4371491074562073,
0.41293761134147644,
0.2896026074886322,
0.2280985713005066,
-0.8201412558555603,
-0.8923812508583069,
-0.5471445322036743,
-0.7466066479682922,
0.48145592212677,
0.27593547105789185,
0.41893136501312256,
0.03312861546874046,
0.4281139373779297,
0.04542427137494087,
0.43869274854660034,
-0.779600203037262,
-0.18222230672836304,
0.28410401940345764,
0.04749585688114166,
-0.03947725519537926,
-0.5554560422897339,
-0.04211288318037987,
-0.015291011892259121,
0.6820219159126282,
-0.12327128648757935,
0.29599329829216003,
0.3723655641078949,
0.054899536073207855,
-0.17698529362678528,
0.22553862631320953,
0.48675820231437683,
0.7953691482543945,
-0.16219963133335114,
-0.07687133550643921,
0.016555530950427055,
-0.8455004692077637,
-0.44834282994270325,
-0.11707241833209991,
-0.596721887588501,
0.03804197162389755,
0.7466792464256287,
0.32224491238594055,
0.005784996785223484,
-0.7012798190116882,
0.44296160340309143,
-0.18460138142108917,
-0.27621349692344666,
-0.4327359199523926,
-0.13421031832695007,
-0.34501752257347107,
0.22802966833114624,
0.5230939388275146,
0.21208737790584564,
0.3460429608821869,
-0.4622451663017273,
0.3770602345466614,
0.32901716232299805,
-0.5032524466514587,
-0.4265558421611786,
0.6140294075012207,
0.17499886453151703,
-0.2067069411277771,
0.6288819313049316,
0.12978477776050568,
-0.3205314874649048,
0.5230320692062378,
0.1851327121257782,
0.7958472371101379,
-0.07255110144615173,
0.1258792281150818,
0.41037940979003906,
0.49128708243370056,
0.2495623081922531,
-0.10541585087776184,
0.15795692801475525,
-0.7498039603233337,
-0.6802393794059753,
-0.4703974723815918,
-0.7915816903114319,
0.03945568948984146,
-0.3475916385650635,
0.3496539890766144,
-0.5016782283782959,
-0.5028406977653503,
0.17449793219566345,
0.079769067466259,
-0.20867836475372314,
-0.08436407148838043,
0.2199946641921997,
0.7890099883079529,
-0.6443403959274292,
0.5410801768302917,
0.782302737236023,
-0.42827799916267395,
-0.4948616623878479,
0.20729079842567444,
0.2711780369281769,
-0.7366225123405457,
0.3959288001060486,
-0.3528989851474762,
0.080066978931427,
-0.17622318863868713,
-0.9051631689071655,
-0.848911702632904,
0.8462302684783936,
0.04867817834019661,
-0.49256548285484314,
0.14821651577949524,
0.21904844045639038,
1.0293548107147217,
-0.185615673661232,
0.4879480004310608,
0.372647762298584,
0.30648693442344666,
-0.00011246947542531416,
-1.188896656036377,
-0.3017963469028473,
-0.23118126392364502,
-0.3656728267669678,
0.32832780480384827,
-0.8150097131729126,
0.8534569144248962,
-0.1750517338514328,
-0.0301358625292778,
-0.042307425290346146,
0.751137912273407,
0.09978846460580826,
0.39798569679260254,
0.23126539587974548,
0.2389681339263916,
0.6454744935035706,
0.03093688189983368,
1.0179557800292969,
-0.6385576725006104,
0.40927261114120483,
0.9268431067466736,
-0.2737688422203064,
1.0105277299880981,
0.6902065873146057,
-0.2751075327396393,
0.30195072293281555,
0.5909730195999146,
-0.08372616767883301,
0.1424502730369568,
0.26464009284973145,
-0.3563413619995117,
-0.0248467605561018,
-0.5043889284133911,
-0.3298361003398895,
0.38875898718833923,
0.47267386317253113,
-0.47852158546447754,
0.008582351729273796,
-0.04470394551753998,
0.45409831404685974,
0.08568914979696274,
-0.4937377870082855,
1.0973118543624878,
0.2327582985162735,
-0.7570980787277222,
0.2562066614627838,
0.20376704633235931,
0.7079739570617676,
-0.33897483348846436,
-0.04571041837334633,
-0.32129260897636414,
0.1636044979095459,
-0.23198918998241425,
-1.1350176334381104,
0.24233540892601013,
0.420801043510437,
-0.05917593464255333,
-0.4263078570365906,
0.7633159756660461,
-0.29830414056777954,
-0.6222505569458008,
0.1119443029165268,
0.5827270150184631,
0.21459294855594635,
-0.24893225729465485,
-0.5635499358177185,
0.2637372612953186,
0.07109496742486954,
-0.39234673976898193,
0.6199696063995361,
0.33591803908348083,
-0.1332056075334549,
0.6764906644821167,
0.6532222032546997,
0.29473593831062317,
0.06791869550943375,
0.09770628064870834,
0.8290050029754639,
-0.20296186208724976,
-0.24060510098934174,
-0.9432689547538757,
-0.041651129722595215,
-0.1127043142914772,
-0.34942319989204407,
0.5978819727897644,
0.46995607018470764,
0.9059081673622131,
0.15746945142745972,
0.9078076481819153,
-0.27189192175865173,
0.34025508165359497,
-0.26297175884246826,
0.9006386399269104,
-0.34755703806877136,
0.3581012487411499,
-0.33287203311920166,
-0.9720476865768433,
-0.2831113338470459,
0.2262241393327713,
-0.3698751628398895,
-0.09357565641403198,
0.674701988697052,
0.6302879452705383,
0.34429916739463806,
0.12042361497879028,
0.1582770049571991,
0.3343210816383362,
0.6040152907371521,
0.10107334703207016,
0.757659375667572,
-0.21728630363941193,
0.6217163801193237,
-0.07062298059463501,
-0.4383925795555115,
-0.15561223030090332,
-0.9964650869369507,
-0.8067387342453003,
-0.6494758129119873,
-0.6055319905281067,
-0.367980420589447,
0.03334623575210571,
0.8980928063392639,
0.20460714399814606,
-0.8937821984291077,
-0.284301221370697,
-0.0409226156771183,
-0.03529990836977959,
0.09602368623018265,
-0.20937670767307281,
0.5162346363067627,
-0.45364755392074585,
-0.8861011862754822,
0.11751778423786163,
0.21822908520698547,
-0.24418456852436066,
-0.2039213925600052,
0.22630931437015533,
-0.017245573922991753,
0.11827909201383591,
0.681283712387085,
-0.15329408645629883,
-0.48222261667251587,
-0.28732460737228394,
0.026802146807312965,
-0.16113580763339996,
0.06059538200497627,
0.954901397228241,
-0.5118502378463745,
0.3772055208683014,
0.6670311093330383,
0.49493318796157837,
0.4494212865829468,
-0.12717074155807495,
0.6824203729629517,
-0.4945676624774933,
-0.2607397735118866,
0.3830108344554901,
0.43562009930610657,
0.23162110149860382,
-0.29648357629776,
0.6245304346084595,
0.29411736130714417,
-1.0317726135253906,
-0.7766664028167725,
0.041590649634599686,
-0.7707329392433167,
0.035430263727903366,
1.3591550588607788,
-0.1741744428873062,
0.044341567903757095,
0.14822041988372803,
-0.3525233864784241,
-0.038740124553442,
-0.6592422723770142,
1.2156251668930054,
0.9625477194786072,
-0.26222556829452515,
-0.03976890444755554,
-0.4653422236442566,
0.5679072737693787,
0.24908635020256042,
-0.7126102447509766,
0.08396144956350327,
0.5979350209236145,
0.12301869690418243,
0.1584625244140625,
0.654450535774231,
-0.38190022110939026,
0.13141033053398132,
-0.1077769324183464,
0.12290439754724503,
0.12105843424797058,
-0.16299386322498322,
-0.3219427764415741,
0.05974225327372551,
0.4743557274341583,
0.44738540053367615
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07179v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07179v1
|
3M-Diffusion: Latent Multi-Modal Diffusion for Text-Guided Generation of Molecular Graphs
| 2024-03-11T21:44:54 | 2024-03-11T21:44:54 |
Huaisheng Zhu, Teng Xiao, Vasant G Honavar
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, q-bio.BM
|
Generating molecules with desired properties is a critical task with broad
applications in drug discovery and materials design. Inspired by recent
advances in large language models, there is a growing interest in using natural
language descriptions of molecules to generate molecules with the desired
properties. Most existing methods focus on generating molecules that precisely
match the text description. However, practical applications call for methods
that generate diverse, and ideally novel, molecules with the desired
properties. We propose 3M-Diffusion, a novel multi-modal molecular graph
generation method, to address this challenge. 3M-Diffusion first encodes
molecular graphs into a graph latent space aligned with text descriptions. It
then reconstructs the molecular structure and atomic attributes based on the
given text descriptions using the molecule decoder. It then learns a
probabilistic mapping from the text space to the latent molecular graph space
using a diffusion model. The results of our extensive experiments on several
datasets demonstrate that 3M-Diffusion can generate high-quality, novel and
diverse molecular graphs that semantically match the textual description
provided.
|
[
-0.34731248021125793,
-1.1335346698760986,
0.9062158465385437,
-0.0021761246025562286,
-0.3692918121814728,
0.22679777443408966,
0.08110692352056503,
-0.17913080751895905,
0.36986058950424194,
0.49330073595046997,
-0.2235262542963028,
-0.6381127834320068,
-0.5457686185836792,
0.030938968062400818,
-0.08251944184303284,
0.8691433668136597,
-0.29360586404800415,
0.025369422510266304,
-0.07361450791358948,
0.14805439114570618,
0.0326426737010479,
-0.08338194340467453,
-0.2771390974521637,
-0.41651272773742676,
0.7382254004478455,
0.13390834629535675,
0.668445885181427,
0.5743961930274963,
0.30530160665512085,
0.2669590413570404,
-0.24182242155075073,
0.28342461585998535,
-0.17742478847503662,
0.10441961884498596,
0.3053368628025055,
-0.13264785706996918,
-0.7450917959213257,
0.33258286118507385,
0.8034946322441101,
1.0168447494506836,
-0.0621112659573555,
-0.4155474603176117,
0.10821069031953812,
0.6640380620956421,
-0.45369982719421387,
-0.05076600983738899,
-0.3287331461906433,
0.18292634189128876,
-0.41196489334106445,
-0.30848997831344604,
-0.27731457352638245,
-0.3506462275981903,
0.11884532868862152,
-0.7519776225090027,
0.5656866431236267,
0.048938386142253876,
0.6826160550117493,
-0.2242240309715271,
-0.9032961130142212,
-0.4383876919746399,
-0.5684292912483215,
0.3171660304069519,
-0.5853651762008667,
0.3213423192501068,
0.3604459762573242,
0.46818703413009644,
-0.30178365111351013,
-0.7770065665245056,
-0.6708938479423523,
-0.46394413709640503,
-0.03347499296069145,
0.25270259380340576,
0.2574866712093353,
0.09977420419454575,
-0.28534266352653503,
0.3561161160469055,
-0.7725796103477478,
-0.4096505045890808,
-0.35316169261932373,
-0.18746958673000336,
0.17603711783885956,
0.10434198379516602,
0.12722715735435486,
-0.3120666444301605,
-0.5130038857460022,
0.12920787930488586,
-0.5027994513511658,
-0.48804235458374023,
0.5764608383178711,
0.5074583888053894,
0.050593819469213486,
0.795418918132782,
-0.013027177192270756,
0.8534660935401917,
-0.3704659640789032,
-0.2904510200023651,
0.6348353624343872,
-0.6888667941093445,
-0.1257794052362442,
0.1255490630865097,
0.9750468134880066,
0.26590803265571594,
-0.1374354213476181,
-0.0671999529004097,
-0.05185055732727051,
-0.2855776250362396,
0.13183216750621796,
-1.1130492687225342,
-0.4596191644668579,
0.1789582073688507,
-0.7871792912483215,
-0.34717071056365967,
-0.061691660434007645,
-1.0148342847824097,
-0.49516236782073975,
0.20804761350154877,
0.4982677102088928,
-0.5148317217826843,
-0.3566513955593109,
0.30719563364982605,
-0.5849215388298035,
-0.40273985266685486,
0.3044605851173401,
-0.8154719471931458,
0.130487322807312,
0.16069136559963226,
1.212140440940857,
-0.44199520349502563,
-0.22347994148731232,
-0.20116345584392548,
0.6515011191368103,
-0.16417019069194794,
0.6942844390869141,
-0.739084780216217,
-0.6625478267669678,
-0.4158506691455841,
-0.15995021164417267,
0.07022017985582352,
-0.6387398838996887,
-0.32484686374664307,
-0.5009644627571106,
0.3134339451789856,
0.10418064147233963,
-0.4310283958911896,
-0.26653826236724854,
0.14214180409908295,
-0.800495445728302,
0.7404271364212036,
0.5054954886436462,
-0.5073179602622986,
0.4739067852497101,
-1.0514990091323853,
-0.49999064207077026,
0.03566453978419304,
-0.09304241091012955,
-0.6361410617828369,
-0.035211920738220215,
-0.048298776149749756,
0.6308285593986511,
-0.11120657622814178,
0.03152865171432495,
-0.4188480079174042,
0.18538081645965576,
0.35226869583129883,
-0.4354535937309265,
0.27479198575019836,
0.4605141580104828,
-0.07536140829324722,
0.0012615680461749434,
-0.793622612953186,
-0.34932172298431396,
-0.07573399692773819,
-0.6259389519691467,
0.0946943387389183,
-0.039130035787820816,
0.18617554008960724,
0.18406666815280914,
0.25437864661216736,
-0.43368613719940186,
0.2326715886592865,
-0.278637558221817,
0.3865785598754883,
0.6969420909881592,
0.6636326313018799,
0.7421908974647522,
-0.24390146136283875,
0.6534220576286316,
0.371888130903244,
-0.07975511252880096,
-0.08750967681407928,
-0.8274114727973938,
-0.3176931142807007,
-0.5294762849807739,
0.012725511565804482,
0.1837126761674881,
-0.674990713596344,
0.15058225393295288,
0.15476016700267792,
-0.4963027238845825,
0.18792708218097687,
0.3643677532672882,
-0.05323448404669762,
0.6057767868041992,
0.5561361908912659,
-0.09128731489181519,
-0.10759054869413376,
-0.9071712493896484,
-0.12017368525266647,
0.0804261565208435,
0.03719380870461464,
0.6378304362297058,
0.5024113655090332,
-0.5051606893539429,
0.7820618748664856,
-0.9841814637184143,
-0.4073806405067444,
-0.15857963263988495,
0.33663511276245117,
-0.015257202088832855,
0.4177992045879364,
0.4731391966342926,
-0.8747795224189758,
-0.4100988507270813,
0.11708708107471466,
-0.5011718273162842,
0.019689813256263733,
-0.10672076791524887,
-0.61971116065979,
-0.12932807207107544,
0.5316778421401978,
-0.5204936265945435,
-0.04959041252732277,
0.41065549850463867,
-0.4786844849586487,
0.16929709911346436,
-0.2868133783340454,
0.13360007107257843,
-1.5223033428192139,
0.17065949738025665,
0.050852399319410324,
-0.4395962655544281,
-0.41854724287986755,
-0.24810367822647095,
-0.3666665554046631,
-0.25059494376182556,
-0.6365035772323608,
0.565051794052124,
-0.5627487897872925,
0.2716215252876282,
-0.32030627131462097,
0.3428126275539398,
0.13306167721748352,
0.3998119831085205,
-0.0817796066403389,
0.5770716667175293,
0.4848138988018036,
-0.791560709476471,
0.13166144490242004,
0.04467175155878067,
0.12397550791501999,
0.487236887216568,
-0.23233763873577118,
-0.1192091628909111,
-0.009385930374264717,
0.32555222511291504,
-1.1214580535888672,
-0.37554845213890076,
0.6204163432121277,
-0.23930783569812775,
0.19017036259174347,
-0.1381336897611618,
-0.34167805314064026,
-0.26585641503334045,
-0.10652285069227219,
0.4752311408519745,
0.21202194690704346,
-0.1711125522851944,
1.0420759916305542,
0.321243017911911,
-0.06947007030248642,
0.03060978837311268,
-0.665143609046936,
-0.19532158970832825,
-0.2786523699760437,
-0.5032840967178345,
0.5373173952102661,
-0.41087421774864197,
0.12971077859401703,
0.17900757491588593,
-0.03805933892726898,
-0.2803458869457245,
0.12967966496944427,
0.2726815640926361,
0.0814446210861206,
-0.15179532766342163,
-0.10816644877195358,
0.16555173695087433,
-0.16081303358078003,
-0.025484690442681313,
-0.5428028702735901,
0.4572620689868927,
0.09751223772764206,
-0.20623765885829926,
-0.2515488862991333,
0.5002022385597229,
0.5029656887054443,
0.008872327394783497,
0.6453251838684082,
0.7980272173881531,
-0.18587738275527954,
-0.11355399340391159,
0.25817376375198364,
-0.08922089636325836,
-0.5243831872940063,
0.2600689232349396,
-0.37890854477882385,
-0.8188883662223816,
0.3396965563297272,
-0.417798787355423,
-0.31012362241744995,
0.28628626465797424,
0.8086795806884766,
0.026973694562911987,
1.2534979581832886,
0.4545694887638092,
0.6633369326591492,
0.6485859155654907,
-0.34185466170310974,
0.3339252471923828,
-0.7202722430229187,
-0.6356632113456726,
-0.2639174461364746,
-0.5466066598892212,
-0.39979416131973267,
-0.8194522857666016,
0.7276020050048828,
0.3713543117046356,
-0.007330465130507946,
-0.0472375862300396,
-0.6496959924697876,
0.40517887473106384,
0.3393106460571289,
0.23455436527729034,
0.024760307744145393,
0.24939729273319244,
-0.457998126745224,
0.2977965474128723,
-0.38157588243484497,
-0.6982465386390686,
1.075430154800415,
-0.200123131275177,
0.7809087038040161,
0.5585734844207764,
0.8550268411636353,
0.3414602279663086,
0.27364885807037354,
-0.567724347114563,
0.6375434994697571,
0.17401564121246338,
-0.36542394757270813,
-0.0771821066737175,
-0.7462537884712219,
-1.2267839908599854,
0.21929028630256653,
-0.33918458223342896,
-0.40616023540496826,
-0.02243788354098797,
0.38620200753211975,
-0.054417435079813004,
0.3471197783946991,
-0.7013152837753296,
0.7265658974647522,
-0.0037946661468595266,
-0.20525863766670227,
-0.08499287813901901,
-0.5983954071998596,
0.3169395923614502,
-0.2557467818260193,
0.19152507185935974,
-0.3739132583141327,
-0.3355393409729004,
0.6652191281318665,
-0.5167657136917114,
0.43523332476615906,
-0.3374863266944885,
-0.1953839212656021,
0.35170769691467285,
0.5359677076339722,
0.10425159335136414,
0.291920930147171,
0.045427944511175156,
-0.19710752367973328,
-0.40974268317222595,
-0.5142176747322083,
-0.5039419531822205,
0.7683073282241821,
-0.574647843837738,
-0.278134286403656,
-0.11538062989711761,
-0.38336196541786194,
0.010322794318199158,
0.774843156337738,
0.22071729600429535,
0.3351123034954071,
-0.19066527485847473,
-0.2059556543827057,
0.4406680166721344,
-0.02600867487490177,
0.6411706209182739,
0.5393524169921875,
-0.4001641869544983,
-0.6877955794334412,
1.4686871767044067,
0.041302602738142014,
0.4565608501434326,
0.4842185080051422,
0.3597336709499359,
-0.09382321685552597,
-0.6935770511627197,
-0.34271952509880066,
0.1436232477426529,
-0.43019580841064453,
-0.1197349950671196,
-0.8791090250015259,
0.13644832372665405,
-0.1992749124765396,
-0.5748596787452698,
-0.4004417657852173,
-0.7062379717826843,
-0.6853621602058411,
-0.06656702607870102,
0.5764729380607605,
0.9723414182662964,
-0.30743804574012756,
0.41517043113708496,
-0.6574836373329163,
0.8985816240310669,
0.34900057315826416,
0.4040972590446472,
-0.1619451344013214,
0.07411496341228485,
-0.37835946679115295,
0.05060642585158348,
-0.5973318815231323,
-1.2647082805633545,
0.3075471520423889,
0.18652087450027466,
0.5469726324081421,
0.3553548753261566,
-0.4986833333969116,
0.11704348772764206,
-0.5233432054519653,
1.072448968887329,
0.2535140812397003,
-0.5795247554779053,
0.7799617648124695,
-0.6182881593704224,
0.11004665493965149,
0.05877692997455597,
0.4025465250015259,
-0.02310030348598957,
-0.4795236587524414,
-0.5953630805015564,
-1.2532511949539185,
0.4396860897541046,
0.43838781118392944,
-0.04524484649300575,
-0.4251108169555664,
0.26693087816238403,
0.17438547313213348,
0.1943715214729309,
-0.7046329975128174,
-0.41914117336273193,
-0.46626681089401245,
-0.19494964182376862,
0.10207318514585495,
-0.02785286121070385,
-0.33153146505355835,
0.2213868647813797,
0.6988632082939148,
-0.26165732741355896,
0.4819307327270508,
-0.03391110897064209,
-0.10052190721035004,
0.3017527461051941,
0.026148824021220207,
0.787555456161499,
0.5177866220474243,
-0.5155112147331238,
0.4698788821697235,
-0.30712950229644775,
-0.5984470844268799,
0.45669373869895935,
0.29556092619895935,
0.0538548119366169,
0.021416161209344864,
-0.18498340249061584,
0.47521770000457764,
-0.42893388867378235,
-0.23439820110797882,
0.5393728017807007,
0.061609409749507904,
-0.3694233000278473,
0.2685491740703583,
0.1113521158695221,
0.17083165049552917,
0.14069081842899323,
0.34415724873542786,
0.43004629015922546,
0.4009416103363037,
-0.22071006894111633,
0.24355317652225494,
0.26722252368927,
-0.3791044056415558,
-0.19411110877990723,
0.9060313701629639,
0.2712215185165405,
-0.3634563088417053,
0.29160934686660767,
-0.2764206826686859,
-0.15800906717777252,
0.31862273812294006,
0.6976730227470398,
0.8385967016220093,
-0.08072738349437714,
0.3899382948875427,
0.08937019109725952,
-0.12885518372058868,
0.10685401409864426,
0.3437180817127228,
-0.32053041458129883,
-0.6662612557411194,
0.2853960394859314,
-0.49081307649612427,
-0.06726307421922684,
-0.3545430898666382,
-0.2533116042613983,
0.1271906942129135,
-0.5309562087059021,
-0.305372029542923,
0.1832791566848755,
-0.31131723523139954,
-0.3091173470020294,
0.04343001917004585,
0.06837167590856552,
0.5147346258163452,
-0.8280478715896606,
0.46847063302993774,
0.4568127691745758,
-0.6237583756446838,
-0.3563876152038574,
-0.022478517144918442,
0.09331830590963364,
-0.4011892080307007,
0.40919753909111023,
0.020602773874998093,
-0.4206925630569458,
0.022494131699204445,
-0.5200848579406738,
-0.7409971356391907,
1.1219338178634644,
0.1703634262084961,
0.14926064014434814,
0.1888149231672287,
0.06701473146677017,
0.25214093923568726,
-0.5309510827064514,
0.2531440854072571,
0.3291690945625305,
0.5229836106300354,
0.11598742008209229,
-0.2798507511615753,
0.06841841340065002,
-0.37767255306243896,
0.22027862071990967,
0.31559106707572937,
-0.6735775470733643,
0.9536656737327576,
-0.1304319202899933,
0.04708264023065567,
-0.04710857570171356,
0.5858694314956665,
0.5192680358886719,
0.03663044422864914,
0.19260257482528687,
0.3530143201351166,
0.9015427231788635,
0.05900479480624199,
0.8886933922767639,
-0.43923357129096985,
0.1898418664932251,
0.8072829842567444,
-0.34985780715942383,
0.5204768180847168,
0.4934858977794647,
0.013657331466674805,
0.7628476619720459,
0.45797646045684814,
-0.046255167573690414,
0.5641728043556213,
0.28667816519737244,
-0.6029308438301086,
-0.07394833862781525,
0.036202702671289444,
-0.42049840092658997,
0.06651680171489716,
0.5170269012451172,
-0.5600200295448303,
-0.35564523935317993,
0.3166123032569885,
0.2340891808271408,
-0.3035409450531006,
0.20721235871315002,
0.5537223219871521,
-0.18530520796775818,
-0.20670120418071747,
0.3114272654056549,
0.22812753915786743,
0.434804230928421,
-0.6767133474349976,
-0.4323836863040924,
-0.16045363247394562,
-0.07648106664419174,
-0.056104131042957306,
-0.9247729182243347,
0.04028661549091339,
-0.4654588997364044,
-0.5010400414466858,
-0.6028825640678406,
0.30381351709365845,
-0.48106709122657776,
-0.3701079487800598,
0.14066612720489502,
0.46859657764434814,
0.3469943106174469,
0.23918190598487854,
-0.5480702519416809,
-0.20998303592205048,
-0.06498313695192337,
-0.4239301085472107,
0.08030331879854202,
0.6527726650238037,
0.2901836037635803,
0.6053824424743652,
0.6480605006217957,
-0.005153350532054901,
0.18062222003936768,
0.02528376318514347,
0.9433274865150452,
-0.7409505844116211,
-0.4373502731323242,
-0.8339395523071289,
0.4504583477973938,
0.19110539555549622,
-0.34854936599731445,
0.8058724403381348,
1.1617826223373413,
0.3255506455898285,
-0.0007435560110025108,
0.7670554518699646,
-0.07692801207304001,
0.23769071698188782,
-0.7871554493904114,
0.6514028310775757,
-0.754470705986023,
0.264657199382782,
-0.3518919348716736,
-0.8663641810417175,
-0.46986648440361023,
0.7394077181816101,
0.5227348804473877,
0.46059325337409973,
0.8455299139022827,
1.173069715499878,
-0.236456960439682,
-0.23087593913078308,
-0.07305832207202911,
0.3107139468193054,
0.7636550068855286,
0.46036460995674133,
0.726498007774353,
-0.2743665874004364,
0.6249769926071167,
0.16615864634513855,
-0.09930998086929321,
-0.18432621657848358,
-0.8267765641212463,
-0.8229615092277527,
-0.49229395389556885,
-0.25281092524528503,
-0.8635565638542175,
-0.4437430202960968,
0.5713269710540771,
1.0526453256607056,
-0.28468310832977295,
-0.16834589838981628,
-0.5298007130622864,
0.2612634003162384,
0.06659718602895737,
-0.28243833780288696,
0.3364371359348297,
0.019315849989652634,
-0.527517557144165,
0.7758467197418213,
0.574271023273468,
0.7108259201049805,
-0.4692037105560303,
-0.16749973595142365,
-0.35743603110313416,
0.002104597631841898,
0.4828830659389496,
0.026227785274386406,
-0.536136269569397,
0.18801549077033997,
-0.19257302582263947,
-0.22792385518550873,
0.28972411155700684,
0.9497857689857483,
-0.8043752908706665,
0.5878122448921204,
0.6930172443389893,
0.1188913956284523,
0.8234043717384338,
-0.30781155824661255,
0.7745322585105896,
-0.8193315863609314,
0.04558553174138069,
0.1716473400592804,
0.1425125002861023,
0.2344028651714325,
-0.28554242849349976,
0.2596936523914337,
0.5981261134147644,
-0.4734421968460083,
-0.5721122622489929,
0.3259650468826294,
-1.3444550037384033,
-0.7476528286933899,
1.1767300367355347,
0.3847554624080658,
-0.28080618381500244,
-0.19267719984054565,
-0.3520868718624115,
0.2898091673851013,
-0.5420377850532532,
0.31433916091918945,
0.37330907583236694,
-0.681069016456604,
0.20932899415493011,
-0.46590080857276917,
0.6605314016342163,
0.019441092386841774,
-0.8588725924491882,
0.07707357406616211,
0.7648611664772034,
0.271880179643631,
0.19530777633190155,
1.0223147869110107,
-0.1090962216258049,
0.0427304245531559,
0.14157089591026306,
-0.20122389495372772,
-0.20677480101585388,
-0.4838760793209076,
0.03302326798439026,
0.47400984168052673,
-0.07684928923845291,
-0.03989049792289734
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07175v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07175v2
|
Rebuilding ROME : Resolving Model Collapse during Sequential Model Editing
| 2024-03-11T21:33:05 | 2024-04-16T17:32:45 |
Akshat Gupta, Sidharth Baskaran, Gopala Anumanchipalli
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent work using Rank-One Model Editing (ROME), a popular model editing
method, has shown that there are certain facts that the algorithm is unable to
edit without breaking the model. Such edits have previously been called
disabling edits. These disabling edits cause immediate model collapse and
limits the use of ROME for sequential editing. In this paper, we show that
disabling edits are an artifact of irregularities in the implementation of
ROME. With this paper, we provide a more stable implementation ROME, which we
call r-ROME and show that model collapse is no longer observed when making
large scale sequential edits with r-ROME, while further improving
generalization and locality of model editing compared to the original
implementation of ROME. We also provide a detailed mathematical explanation of
the reason behind disabling edits.
|
[
-0.38223615288734436,
-0.9405971169471741,
0.8297388553619385,
0.014639820903539658,
0.13682745397090912,
0.19415298104286194,
-0.12321788817644119,
-0.36711642146110535,
0.16848209500312805,
0.42438849806785583,
-0.554097056388855,
-0.30148375034332275,
-0.7392327189445496,
0.1445649415254593,
-0.6700605750083923,
1.1746940612792969,
-0.21534839272499084,
0.10628347098827362,
-0.20326201617717743,
-0.25117921829223633,
-0.5329469442367554,
-0.16780206561088562,
-1.0204236507415771,
-0.18407130241394043,
0.6802027225494385,
0.4439331889152527,
1.1125115156173706,
0.9473340511322021,
0.8964135050773621,
0.549125611782074,
-0.5137345194816589,
0.2303827553987503,
-0.7735033631324768,
0.021480031311511993,
-0.2282421588897705,
-0.4515204429626465,
-0.9484274983406067,
0.03494831547141075,
1.2023848295211792,
0.5487861037254333,
-0.021186286583542824,
0.1657467484474182,
0.01151593029499054,
0.7752101421356201,
-0.5793267488479614,
-0.07296708226203918,
-0.5486657023429871,
-0.1453433781862259,
-0.24474714696407318,
-0.2125261127948761,
-0.6164035201072693,
-0.21485836803913116,
-0.2597748935222626,
-0.5633223652839661,
0.5557078719139099,
-0.15627092123031616,
0.9503206610679626,
0.7536762952804565,
0.05360332503914833,
-0.15524396300315857,
-1.1463220119476318,
0.27362900972366333,
-0.7129335403442383,
0.14434507489204407,
0.06123929098248482,
0.10327204316854477,
-0.3150339722633362,
-0.8080285787582397,
-0.5014735460281372,
-0.04814053699374199,
-0.15786871314048767,
0.004418203607201576,
-0.06618986278772354,
0.22046075761318207,
0.6223607063293457,
0.5163396000862122,
-0.43660783767700195,
0.15736471116542816,
-0.4739423990249634,
0.2786853015422821,
0.490619033575058,
0.362985223531723,
0.45319828391075134,
0.056249119341373444,
-0.1917431354522705,
-0.034131377935409546,
-1.0269808769226074,
-0.2643427848815918,
0.3667473793029785,
0.13515636324882507,
0.12178042531013489,
0.24577262997627258,
0.23110105097293854,
0.772553026676178,
0.09306910634040833,
-0.2682599723339081,
-0.16950000822544098,
0.09658051282167435,
-0.4786739647388458,
-0.3013152778148651,
0.3357199430465698,
0.34933874011039734,
-0.10101617127656937,
-0.22666840255260468,
-0.07513268291950226,
-0.28729721903800964,
0.2687797248363495,
-0.6437179446220398,
-0.061150990426540375,
0.47200316190719604,
-0.3803812265396118,
-0.15277701616287231,
0.4022669494152069,
-0.21190166473388672,
-0.21989226341247559,
-0.05686531960964203,
0.1978210061788559,
0.08214136213064194,
-0.16676045954227448,
0.09396728128194809,
-0.0257591400295496,
-0.669228196144104,
0.5677821040153503,
-0.7580502033233643,
0.2569313049316406,
0.8022528886795044,
0.9564588069915771,
0.13024786114692688,
-0.64520263671875,
-0.5088491439819336,
-0.002971039852127433,
-0.48878800868988037,
0.648119330406189,
-0.2684990465641022,
-0.7828172445297241,
-0.05649374797940254,
0.30822837352752686,
0.0011463224655017257,
-0.6781365871429443,
0.4653550386428833,
-0.6230818629264832,
0.036288321018218994,
-0.40836262702941895,
-0.5303751826286316,
-0.06871742010116577,
0.17641183733940125,
-0.9226502180099487,
0.8078504204750061,
-0.17724384367465973,
-0.9354054927825928,
0.37670496106147766,
-0.5474507212638855,
-0.1862969994544983,
-0.2672038972377777,
0.142933651804924,
-0.8794136643409729,
0.468199759721756,
-0.21619592607021332,
-0.00006038480205461383,
0.10771013796329498,
0.4028046429157257,
-0.4801531136035919,
-0.6453071236610413,
0.09184493124485016,
0.05315716937184334,
0.7246145606040955,
0.03562348335981369,
-0.0649476945400238,
0.35027211904525757,
-0.622403085231781,
-0.15321184694766998,
0.03687288239598274,
-0.06808608770370483,
-0.3483142554759979,
0.40955108404159546,
-0.28448644280433655,
0.060063742101192474,
0.15043030679225922,
-0.35400035977363586,
0.7798188924789429,
-0.1091686487197876,
0.601372480392456,
0.9817938208580017,
0.2174409031867981,
0.5174956917762756,
-0.6058473587036133,
0.30176636576652527,
-0.0861433893442154,
0.209772527217865,
-0.1781935840845108,
-0.4523968994617462,
-1.0531935691833496,
-0.13019517064094543,
0.6532264947891235,
0.48956844210624695,
-0.6597079038619995,
-0.3616287112236023,
-0.48295852541923523,
-0.38443994522094727,
-0.37225183844566345,
-0.2168819159269333,
0.4302978217601776,
0.551300585269928,
0.31501510739326477,
-0.19054429233074188,
-0.5788986682891846,
-0.8619107604026794,
-0.23025210201740265,
-0.4682404398918152,
0.3018013834953308,
-0.11673068255186081,
0.932928740978241,
-0.236592099070549,
0.7106853723526001,
-0.6345998048782349,
-0.0978260487318039,
-0.056591954082250595,
0.3762539327144623,
0.12637969851493835,
0.803139328956604,
0.5848929286003113,
-0.7292695641517639,
-0.18586023151874542,
-0.369951069355011,
-0.6639676690101624,
0.34331727027893066,
-0.48317751288414,
-0.009544270113110542,
0.19948546588420868,
0.4384647011756897,
-0.2731747627258301,
1.0333552360534668,
0.30856382846832275,
-0.3105434477329254,
0.7272618412971497,
-0.7175907492637634,
0.5685532093048096,
-0.8343321681022644,
-0.06160661205649376,
-0.32692036032676697,
-0.2784441113471985,
-0.5792502760887146,
0.3738712668418884,
0.04504488408565521,
-0.0914493277668953,
-0.2215048223733902,
0.45672357082366943,
-0.5114908218383789,
-0.32917627692222595,
-0.45561739802360535,
0.09889690577983856,
0.015178635716438293,
0.08813191205263138,
0.09085946530103683,
0.7903850078582764,
0.14667604863643646,
-0.6102921962738037,
-0.047491371631622314,
0.6993684768676758,
-0.14164216816425323,
-0.052737899124622345,
-0.7234941124916077,
0.356646865606308,
-0.326208233833313,
0.1288868635892868,
-0.7198966145515442,
-0.06347530335187912,
0.11981058120727539,
-0.354351669549942,
0.3544926047325134,
-0.3715134561061859,
-0.35474398732185364,
-0.07205119729042053,
-0.2125273197889328,
0.43137598037719727,
0.1243874579668045,
-0.558343768119812,
0.15989848971366882,
0.21951079368591309,
-0.2647467851638794,
-0.47954460978507996,
-0.8902403116226196,
0.14471657574176788,
-0.07498771697282791,
-0.944933295249939,
0.6854485273361206,
-0.42350128293037415,
-0.8440099358558655,
0.3470548987388611,
-0.06802936643362045,
-0.1321878582239151,
0.1863042563199997,
0.3287046253681183,
0.5882359147071838,
0.02192232944071293,
-0.011269076727330685,
0.031175237149000168,
-0.38561949133872986,
-0.20879685878753662,
0.32247453927993774,
0.039160557091236115,
0.09398430585861206,
-0.3729292154312134,
-0.7043303847312927,
0.4547109305858612,
0.9975662231445312,
-0.353531152009964,
0.8988593816757202,
0.006765653844922781,
-0.4148206114768982,
-0.13522124290466309,
-0.490831583738327,
-0.1753298044204712,
-0.4369501769542694,
0.3840863108634949,
-0.43216484785079956,
-0.8674415349960327,
0.8750291466712952,
-0.11809961497783661,
0.41994810104370117,
0.49400338530540466,
0.3761228024959564,
0.013963980600237846,
0.929268479347229,
0.9448798298835754,
0.17232324182987213,
0.607369065284729,
-0.46643760800361633,
0.04920771345496178,
-0.9859974384307861,
0.05926254764199257,
-0.7881649732589722,
-0.34046831727027893,
-0.6559426784515381,
-0.31439194083213806,
0.3900856077671051,
0.29500386118888855,
-0.22232457995414734,
0.26507288217544556,
-0.401062548160553,
0.504647433757782,
0.2665497958660126,
0.2841179668903351,
0.6229565739631653,
-0.17697767913341522,
0.2195534110069275,
-0.24562489986419678,
-0.8742701411247253,
-0.4985077381134033,
0.6820262670516968,
0.24269314110279083,
0.6104923486709595,
0.15106578171253204,
0.9645189642906189,
0.34881943464279175,
0.6303116083145142,
-0.40175238251686096,
0.21511568129062653,
-0.24560631811618805,
-0.8386586308479309,
-0.42021644115448,
-0.38079893589019775,
-0.39004042744636536,
0.17759889364242554,
-0.3095513582229614,
-0.6858927607536316,
0.6220701932907104,
0.37640380859375,
-0.7397336363792419,
0.7068677544593811,
-0.446561723947525,
0.8550204634666443,
0.0802876278758049,
-0.5278122425079346,
-0.46812257170677185,
-0.1582893580198288,
0.5211344957351685,
0.2180642932653427,
0.5339796543121338,
0.30758631229400635,
0.33903852105140686,
0.3796383738517761,
-0.9136571884155273,
0.38053590059280396,
0.01975422538816929,
0.05483470484614372,
-0.06294751912355423,
0.36178988218307495,
0.8192309141159058,
0.4572356641292572,
-0.2061196267604828,
-0.15024210512638092,
-0.21951495110988617,
-0.34684091806411743,
-0.890961229801178,
0.8079522252082825,
-0.4686829447746277,
-0.7703917026519775,
-0.6803988814353943,
-0.5295470952987671,
0.11863264441490173,
-0.05771058425307274,
0.36813628673553467,
0.7907694578170776,
-0.36409133672714233,
-0.24312856793403625,
0.6505492329597473,
-0.1446671336889267,
0.6721519231796265,
0.5075539350509644,
-0.5035843253135681,
-0.48259812593460083,
0.6626805067062378,
0.5262971520423889,
0.44410908222198486,
-0.1738414168357849,
-0.3844847083091736,
0.3301408290863037,
-0.9266666173934937,
-0.5057786107063293,
0.11591169238090515,
-0.5497376918792725,
0.1511547863483429,
-0.11368700861930847,
-0.09730497747659683,
-0.2699291408061981,
-0.46181827783584595,
-0.575410783290863,
-0.6771425008773804,
-0.15458373725414276,
-0.06331303715705872,
0.004522942937910557,
1.27925705909729,
-0.5039305090904236,
0.30934029817581177,
-0.7274232506752014,
0.4549318552017212,
0.08922724425792694,
0.28182780742645264,
-0.029197748750448227,
-0.5954058766365051,
-0.5400998592376709,
0.014779905788600445,
-0.06908895075321198,
-0.865265965461731,
0.1497899889945984,
0.07006633281707764,
0.1845434159040451,
0.5517784953117371,
-0.18830645084381104,
1.326978325843811,
-0.8088427186012268,
0.4315981864929199,
-0.05482947453856468,
-1.0189160108566284,
0.420185923576355,
-0.3587524890899658,
0.3882705271244049,
0.6320490837097168,
0.044000089168548584,
-0.5280498266220093,
-0.5077011585235596,
-0.7790298461914062,
-0.6919912099838257,
0.6326340436935425,
0.18380314111709595,
-0.29494479298591614,
-0.05928640812635422,
0.9287041425704956,
-0.19675377011299133,
-0.18237194418907166,
-0.42608314752578735,
-0.6003904342651367,
0.06676170974969864,
0.7286120057106018,
0.09748940169811249,
-0.8491030335426331,
-0.3746534585952759,
-0.5264784693717957,
1.0831643342971802,
0.39694175124168396,
0.06790908426046371,
0.5603528618812561,
-0.4341769814491272,
-0.2665495276451111,
0.19994693994522095,
1.1588197946548462,
1.1995028257369995,
-0.19330349564552307,
-0.21779616177082062,
0.1639983355998993,
-0.2776961922645569,
-0.007124741096049547,
-0.04069313034415245,
-0.8031631708145142,
0.09212026745080948,
0.5330156683921814,
0.8846584558486938,
0.6538858413696289,
-0.11357992887496948,
-0.12207427620887756,
-0.24179911613464355,
-0.02139122411608696,
-0.45296338200569153,
-0.0276766587048769,
-0.18013493716716766,
0.31238412857055664,
0.2948669195175171,
0.5332865715026855,
0.17871519923210144,
-0.6722290515899658,
0.30656903982162476,
0.2438822239637375,
-0.12514135241508484,
-0.15548506379127502,
1.1064189672470093,
0.010536789894104004,
-0.4388030469417572,
0.9780200719833374,
-0.15157929062843323,
-0.4353061616420746,
0.7360944747924805,
0.3080701529979706,
0.8724768161773682,
-0.30435827374458313,
0.41123250126838684,
0.7846561670303345,
0.5953333377838135,
-0.4654519259929657,
0.09309399873018265,
0.39005357027053833,
-0.7189035415649414,
-0.6498252153396606,
-0.30021634697914124,
-0.6152049899101257,
-0.2971538007259369,
-1.078832983970642,
0.19042420387268066,
-0.8164211511611938,
-0.38600295782089233,
-0.14567111432552338,
-0.2856298089027405,
-0.07238010317087173,
0.1957700252532959,
-0.042777009308338165,
1.0631307363510132,
-0.5717079043388367,
0.7887480854988098,
0.6313006281852722,
-0.6214945912361145,
-0.4947228729724884,
-0.051585935056209564,
0.22372788190841675,
-0.2590172588825226,
0.5153480768203735,
-0.2676900029182434,
-0.11629325896501541,
0.06651217490434647,
-0.49255120754241943,
-0.6103702783584595,
1.0567150115966797,
0.6590979695320129,
-0.6797158718109131,
-0.33125144243240356,
-0.027957815676927567,
0.22174297273159027,
-0.24668000638484955,
0.09565672278404236,
0.3155212104320526,
0.7629597187042236,
0.022884631529450417,
-1.0688172578811646,
-0.1216793805360794,
-0.2044994831085205,
0.0726282149553299,
0.35954397916793823,
-0.7304732203483582,
1.0518898963928223,
-0.5243507623672485,
-0.3354923129081726,
0.7703306674957275,
0.5508749485015869,
0.07153823971748352,
0.012748762033879757,
0.4752041697502136,
1.189231038093567,
0.7080579400062561,
-0.49459338188171387,
1.0418277978897095,
-0.3834879994392395,
0.8126810789108276,
1.4386152029037476,
0.022631414234638214,
0.8804983496665955,
0.05929411202669144,
-0.08004963397979736,
0.8039849996566772,
0.5881760120391846,
0.01354594063013792,
0.11323777586221695,
-0.11860071867704391,
-0.39790061116218567,
-0.4876004159450531,
0.44602885842323303,
-0.5301002264022827,
0.3186857998371124,
0.04203544929623604,
-0.37444084882736206,
-0.39606577157974243,
-0.12048925459384918,
0.490740031003952,
0.04998829588294029,
-0.4091189503669739,
0.6044663190841675,
-0.2250295877456665,
-0.6575798988342285,
0.5067344903945923,
0.12396237254142761,
-0.1500258594751358,
-0.39858365058898926,
-0.33696699142456055,
-0.25271543860435486,
0.31822046637535095,
-0.3728799521923065,
-0.2197575718164444,
0.7539529800415039,
-0.040192585438489914,
-0.7196334004402161,
-0.5332980751991272,
0.30978280305862427,
-0.4004434049129486,
-0.5179883241653442,
0.1899452805519104,
0.2478446513414383,
-0.011786326766014099,
-0.0166175477206707,
-0.6568403840065002,
0.6804121732711792,
-0.14201167225837708,
-0.24270352721214294,
0.18221959471702576,
0.034066617488861084,
0.0353972464799881,
0.5514053106307983,
0.4708743691444397,
-0.02409600093960762,
-0.1279480755329132,
-0.14201733469963074,
0.9047821164131165,
-0.6287894248962402,
-0.2704007625579834,
-0.9204806685447693,
1.114844799041748,
0.018061835318803787,
-0.27595922350883484,
0.7834699749946594,
0.6541687250137329,
0.723637044429779,
0.17941418290138245,
0.5547618269920349,
-0.3131972849369049,
0.21227505803108215,
-0.5503125786781311,
1.074291467666626,
-0.7279341816902161,
0.4179702699184418,
-0.4802447557449341,
-0.7860284447669983,
-0.46040424704551697,
0.46889233589172363,
-0.5445603728294373,
-0.3025129735469818,
0.9728068113327026,
0.8037925958633423,
0.21482522785663605,
-0.03696775808930397,
0.471799373626709,
0.8676310181617737,
-0.0497669018805027,
0.10602689534425735,
0.5473325252532959,
-0.47421905398368835,
0.08400929719209671,
-0.25776270031929016,
-0.33010008931159973,
0.09713812917470932,
-0.7654569745063782,
-0.6840860247612,
-0.6928648352622986,
-0.5148345232009888,
-0.7165057063102722,
0.555994987487793,
0.2685530185699463,
0.6312286853790283,
-0.8025940656661987,
-0.05047789588570595,
-0.1684761494398117,
0.5619882345199585,
-0.24160344898700714,
-0.10150901973247528,
0.39472028613090515,
-0.2728880047798157,
-1.0907762050628662,
0.5386490225791931,
0.5226790904998779,
-0.19888494908809662,
-0.38716810941696167,
-0.02933437004685402,
-0.38082805275917053,
-0.34982118010520935,
0.13456518948078156,
0.6998653411865234,
-0.5194209814071655,
-0.4502427279949188,
-0.26779863238334656,
0.39524412155151367,
0.21776561439037323,
1.079671859741211,
-0.5887874364852905,
0.601389467716217,
0.5628751516342163,
0.25251394510269165,
0.42145657539367676,
0.13371220231056213,
0.7073432207107544,
-0.21657471358776093,
0.37675365805625916,
-0.16425740718841553,
0.8714933395385742,
0.13072988390922546,
-0.24833747744560242,
0.5467634797096252,
0.3406274914741516,
-0.8173632025718689,
-1.1430222988128662,
0.3735528588294983,
-0.5478799343109131,
-0.3028380870819092,
0.5196900367736816,
-0.4797267019748688,
-0.2617556154727936,
0.12075907737016678,
-0.0661376491189003,
0.2862872779369354,
0.049927130341529846,
1.0335407257080078,
0.8874282240867615,
-0.3472706377506256,
-0.14004257321357727,
-0.6058127284049988,
0.5457727909088135,
0.31518974900245667,
-0.6426448225975037,
-0.16137652099132538,
0.6546425223350525,
0.34325695037841797,
0.31889331340789795,
0.5367760062217712,
-0.32798922061920166,
0.5864534378051758,
-0.022285880520939827,
0.03430064767599106,
-0.4092434346675873,
-0.750974714756012,
-0.4442097246646881,
0.4257300794124603,
0.28952711820602417,
0.21555203199386597
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09715v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09715v1
|
Textual analysis of End User License Agreement for red-flagging potentially malicious software
| 2024-03-11T20:45:27 | 2024-03-11T20:45:27 |
Behraj Khan, Tahir Syed, Zeshan Khan, Muhammad Rafi
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG
|
New software and updates are downloaded by end users every day. Each
dowloaded software has associated with it an End Users License Agreements
(EULA), but this is rarely read. An EULA includes information to avoid legal
repercussions. However,this proposes a host of potential problems such as
spyware or producing an unwanted affect in the target system. End users do not
read these EULA's because of length of the document and users find it extremely
difficult to understand. Text summarization is one of the relevant solution to
these kind of problems. This require a solution which can summarize the EULA
and classify the EULA as "Benign" or "Malicious". We propose a solution in
which we have summarize the EULA and classify the EULA as "Benign" or
"Malicious". We extract EULA text of different sofware's then we classify the
text using eight different supervised classifiers. we use ensemble learning to
classify the EULA as benign or malicious using five different text
summarization methods. An accuracy of $95.8$\% shows the effectiveness of the
presented approach.
|
[
-0.3503912091255188,
-0.5409396886825562,
0.15295255184173584,
0.14479036629199982,
-0.4790753126144409,
0.2102481573820114,
0.0372249037027359,
-0.9819164872169495,
0.27723681926727295,
0.8630579710006714,
-0.13681811094284058,
-0.6430993676185608,
-0.3786240518093109,
0.5450154542922974,
-0.4575325548648834,
1.515333890914917,
0.14508189260959625,
-0.5403264164924622,
-0.25173014402389526,
-0.29035231471061707,
-0.41301441192626953,
-0.6177689433097839,
-0.5655120015144348,
-0.005255785770714283,
0.15659713745117188,
0.4569624662399292,
0.4559732675552368,
0.29151302576065063,
0.9491980075836182,
0.4304586946964264,
-0.43650132417678833,
-0.14385761320590973,
-0.43722644448280334,
0.2929103374481201,
0.008887022733688354,
-0.3496449887752533,
-0.5210718512535095,
-0.1575499325990677,
0.06921232491731644,
0.10578978806734085,
-0.05720583349466324,
0.2264581024646759,
-0.09307587146759033,
0.6901259422302246,
-0.7061511278152466,
-0.08977439999580383,
-0.5424206256866455,
0.04620230570435524,
-0.079615019261837,
-0.28590109944343567,
-0.753409743309021,
-0.2724100649356842,
0.23059037327766418,
-0.7748256325721741,
-0.11315853148698807,
0.17660290002822876,
0.7683060169219971,
0.5010477900505066,
-0.28549087047576904,
-0.1693817526102066,
-0.5584536790847778,
0.6854073405265808,
-0.7501017451286316,
-0.174418643116951,
0.20859067142009735,
0.32977375388145447,
-0.2803344130516052,
-0.5419522523880005,
-0.4662315249443054,
-0.0646505281329155,
-0.15345969796180725,
0.5686293244361877,
-0.9241006970405579,
0.06942638754844666,
0.10013660788536072,
-0.04916585236787796,
-0.6789731979370117,
0.19184908270835876,
-0.9045798778533936,
-0.4404664933681488,
1.0949667692184448,
0.15934570133686066,
0.5421270728111267,
0.33298319578170776,
-0.8084031939506531,
0.2741045355796814,
-0.6478571891784668,
0.026636863127350807,
0.5272905230522156,
0.039286572486162186,
-0.2003798931837082,
0.4013625681400299,
-0.09685177356004715,
0.7422317266464233,
-0.1287347972393036,
0.0454009547829628,
0.3898997902870178,
-0.15580330789089203,
-0.4362252652645111,
0.2829746901988983,
0.7091875672340393,
0.7955282330513,
0.3939383625984192,
-0.15460920333862305,
-0.46495747566223145,
0.1415019929409027,
0.1905662715435028,
-0.613459050655365,
-0.10879005491733551,
0.8271576166152954,
-0.6864264011383057,
-0.4263838529586792,
0.13099323213100433,
-0.7474659085273743,
-0.4271850287914276,
-0.23576052486896515,
0.24262695014476776,
-0.38104012608528137,
-0.1469106525182724,
0.08979786932468414,
-0.3520177900791168,
0.12940068542957306,
0.28944626450538635,
-0.7275967597961426,
0.48606306314468384,
0.5432695150375366,
0.6118403673171997,
-0.2343408316373825,
-0.2050309181213379,
-0.3725154995918274,
0.2903469204902649,
-0.13468299806118011,
0.8472828269004822,
-0.4319405257701874,
-0.3998014032840729,
0.06944156438112259,
-0.0009426400647498667,
0.18972976505756378,
-0.5542736649513245,
0.17693674564361572,
-0.7025495171546936,
0.49604660272598267,
0.13339842855930328,
-0.440360963344574,
-0.4970974326133728,
0.14841444790363312,
-0.5301201939582825,
0.7679488062858582,
0.07809475064277649,
-0.7147157788276672,
0.5129380822181702,
-0.6558248996734619,
-0.48380887508392334,
0.2656296193599701,
0.06404770910739899,
-0.574788510799408,
0.016425739973783493,
-0.024852296337485313,
0.5833361744880676,
0.24540461599826813,
0.18105193972587585,
-0.09837188571691513,
-0.22696949541568756,
0.413192480802536,
0.04178078845143318,
1.0313478708267212,
0.8057526350021362,
-0.15951162576675415,
0.39479637145996094,
-0.7590060830116272,
-0.3093099892139435,
-0.14062482118606567,
-0.4072425067424774,
-0.611606776714325,
0.068788543343544,
0.4574897587299347,
0.10370776057243347,
0.6201629638671875,
-0.8467450141906738,
-0.06612636893987656,
-0.42025119066238403,
0.16041140258312225,
0.6296831965446472,
0.15918295085430145,
0.24105429649353027,
-0.24468453228473663,
0.6560555696487427,
0.13538794219493866,
0.30368945002555847,
-0.388381689786911,
-0.647680401802063,
-0.24351254105567932,
-0.1600806713104248,
0.1828026920557022,
0.7294685244560242,
-0.45091018080711365,
0.4825955927371979,
-0.2419322431087494,
-0.32719656825065613,
0.00941016711294651,
-0.04436406493186951,
0.6300523281097412,
0.1344677209854126,
0.40532857179641724,
-0.17411816120147705,
-0.4053882360458374,
-0.6121680736541748,
-0.2823202908039093,
-0.4060632586479187,
-0.009672143496572971,
-0.03597274795174599,
0.6798824071884155,
-0.19579434394836426,
1.0705307722091675,
-0.5820156335830688,
-0.8254944682121277,
-0.43640366196632385,
0.28374946117401123,
-0.008549519814550877,
0.07360798120498657,
0.8687476515769958,
-0.8966872096061707,
-0.7984389066696167,
0.504178524017334,
-0.4933844208717346,
-0.38077422976493835,
-0.43077921867370605,
0.3538508713245392,
0.5935568809509277,
0.5770835280418396,
0.09400557726621628,
0.3460722863674164,
0.3559054136276245,
-0.7838021516799927,
0.2749381959438324,
-0.7796547412872314,
0.02550363354384899,
-1.05172860622406,
0.06083061918616295,
0.23674149811267853,
-0.49017244577407837,
-0.7095764875411987,
0.44886723160743713,
-0.13141874969005585,
-0.10648268461227417,
-0.5268055200576782,
0.2436198592185974,
-0.3853116035461426,
-0.009059259667992592,
-0.16315726935863495,
0.46676766872406006,
-0.5067049860954285,
0.23898710310459137,
-0.11822491139173508,
0.7664289474487305,
0.08291327953338623,
-0.5993779897689819,
0.20690561830997467,
-0.006724364124238491,
0.2239394187927246,
0.3061361014842987,
-0.6306895017623901,
-0.2955246567726135,
-0.19820545613765717,
-0.020380372181534767,
-0.8698407411575317,
-0.2338908463716507,
0.23816734552383423,
-0.6971360445022583,
0.276723176240921,
0.07746823877096176,
-0.01600985787808895,
0.07217779755592346,
-0.6857949495315552,
0.06747578829526901,
0.5758360028266907,
-0.32634279131889343,
0.684252917766571,
0.9623870253562927,
-0.08341334015130997,
-0.7241315841674805,
-0.5859687924385071,
0.14005473256111145,
-0.45770198106765747,
-0.584797203540802,
0.3900737762451172,
0.27291339635849,
-0.45584818720817566,
0.22078529000282288,
0.27661266922950745,
-0.3453925848007202,
0.22184985876083374,
0.08561985194683075,
0.25374796986579895,
0.06754166632890701,
-0.18651074171066284,
0.04235469922423363,
-0.5753573775291443,
0.11957099288702011,
0.21032056212425232,
0.03707404062151909,
-0.21541130542755127,
0.1625639945268631,
-0.4848478138446808,
0.40463852882385254,
0.7926895618438721,
-0.3783547580242157,
0.38106974959373474,
0.2427540272474289,
-0.4182310700416565,
-0.21214109659194946,
-0.01162877306342125,
0.1011095941066742,
-0.4603163003921509,
0.25530242919921875,
0.05396903678774834,
-0.6040098667144775,
0.8459866046905518,
-0.03566903620958328,
0.6278802156448364,
0.6672278046607971,
0.41494515538215637,
-0.1985408216714859,
0.646047055721283,
0.9489419460296631,
-0.280697226524353,
0.4685589373111725,
-0.08867938816547394,
0.04435719922184944,
-0.4272540509700775,
-0.4751858711242676,
-0.6458254456520081,
-0.3084154427051544,
-0.4333494305610657,
0.13827821612358093,
0.281598836183548,
-0.26097869873046875,
0.10198023170232773,
0.664262592792511,
-0.9101625680923462,
0.7780721187591553,
0.20457400381565094,
-0.12749075889587402,
0.3505507707595825,
0.1109401136636734,
-0.023787980899214745,
0.14702747762203217,
-0.1611672341823578,
-0.6464082598686218,
1.1031055450439453,
0.48843827843666077,
0.5207868218421936,
0.6045243740081787,
0.978539228439331,
0.8831546902656555,
0.5026522874832153,
-0.6368628740310669,
0.6502359509468079,
-0.594007134437561,
-0.5313172340393066,
-0.6257254481315613,
-0.22422802448272705,
-1.1925476789474487,
0.1517542153596878,
-0.17296603322029114,
-1.0927666425704956,
0.22243939340114594,
0.21036158502101898,
-0.5055718421936035,
0.12640270590782166,
-0.7647257447242737,
0.6506870985031128,
-0.05943716689944267,
-0.006125598680227995,
-0.21314260363578796,
-0.825728178024292,
0.2860594391822815,
-0.22755061089992523,
0.5196847915649414,
0.07658332586288452,
-0.28198087215423584,
1.1582987308502197,
-0.5580418705940247,
0.8698458671569824,
-0.24545413255691528,
-0.24604210257530212,
0.32737934589385986,
-0.22786220908164978,
0.5702670216560364,
-0.2711625397205353,
0.3206285536289215,
-0.15466047823429108,
0.37735655903816223,
-0.04739980772137642,
-0.21984753012657166,
0.21316950023174286,
-0.7519037127494812,
-0.11087388545274734,
-0.8460851311683655,
-0.15823161602020264,
0.237842857837677,
0.3776170313358307,
0.47311919927597046,
0.26522907614707947,
0.05725598707795143,
0.12638233602046967,
0.7826831340789795,
-0.23482593894004822,
0.754246175289154,
0.789532482624054,
-0.5069699287414551,
-0.21999576687812805,
1.2471644878387451,
0.20442532002925873,
0.11526418477296829,
0.4438176155090332,
0.11670706421136856,
-0.3044515550136566,
-0.9138610363006592,
-0.3823781907558441,
-0.0992269441485405,
-0.6199160218238831,
-0.35534805059432983,
-0.5367722511291504,
-0.10419151186943054,
-0.09331456571817398,
-0.31992071866989136,
0.08514316380023956,
-0.36372238397598267,
-0.5089162588119507,
0.12520325183868408,
0.4171679615974426,
0.813578188419342,
0.22551044821739197,
0.595570981502533,
-1.007722020149231,
0.1469055712223053,
-0.200301393866539,
0.07183533906936646,
-0.5993579626083374,
-0.4746168255805969,
-0.1974065899848938,
-0.35357704758644104,
-0.4400370717048645,
-1.3743706941604614,
0.5691702961921692,
0.13468754291534424,
0.6403259038925171,
0.7906205654144287,
0.5110520720481873,
0.23145800828933716,
-0.16085322201251984,
0.9679222106933594,
0.5523127317428589,
-0.8536036014556885,
0.4283170700073242,
-0.2081388533115387,
-0.15892307460308075,
0.582486093044281,
0.4099317789077759,
-0.4263753890991211,
-0.7845427989959717,
-0.41568461060523987,
-1.0282180309295654,
0.3746555745601654,
0.10746660828590393,
0.22199465334415436,
0.14810216426849365,
0.14125990867614746,
-0.0957934707403183,
-0.16356679797172546,
-0.7312623858451843,
-0.4360003173351288,
0.3083809018135071,
-0.25894880294799805,
0.1391897052526474,
-0.4270346462726593,
-0.14544430375099182,
0.17930777370929718,
0.8873233795166016,
0.12489580363035202,
0.08144164085388184,
0.11879324913024902,
-0.11798989027738571,
-0.022333567962050438,
0.7774848341941833,
0.7946062684059143,
0.6580542325973511,
-0.2816532552242279,
-0.018123995512723923,
0.1958124190568924,
-0.9814223647117615,
0.23776347935199738,
-0.1261875480413437,
-0.2509319484233856,
0.05624253675341606,
0.2625090181827545,
-0.11050162464380264,
-0.036708295345306396,
-0.8016376495361328,
0.6621404886245728,
-0.10606565326452255,
-0.36327534914016724,
-0.44209903478622437,
0.1326381117105484,
-0.2719336450099945,
0.09720633924007416,
0.42713484168052673,
0.2137925773859024,
0.6031182408332825,
-0.25430598855018616,
0.22061382234096527,
0.2291567027568817,
-0.6800471544265747,
-0.19590099155902863,
0.687710702419281,
0.501719057559967,
-0.15331381559371948,
0.24762891232967377,
-0.3104451298713684,
-0.7215566039085388,
0.7473078966140747,
0.7842519879341125,
1.0564961433410645,
-0.3492266833782196,
0.32638341188430786,
0.049177635461091995,
0.7350569367408752,
0.4218060374259949,
0.68011075258255,
0.07556352764368057,
-0.5064958333969116,
-0.3329278528690338,
-0.28014981746673584,
-0.37143707275390625,
-0.06212511286139488,
-0.6471247673034668,
0.37183263897895813,
-0.3477712571620941,
-0.29228079319000244,
0.17659221589565277,
-0.1256093829870224,
0.13053679466247559,
0.323637992143631,
-0.19665196537971497,
0.7800202369689941,
-1.0877685546875,
0.2806834876537323,
0.952863872051239,
-0.3085775375366211,
-0.5196796655654907,
-0.1543499231338501,
0.059091877192258835,
-0.20772941410541534,
0.3199158012866974,
0.12967020273208618,
-0.2486618310213089,
-0.26680609583854675,
-0.33962541818618774,
-0.3422503173351288,
0.9312571287155151,
0.1051473319530487,
-0.6108343005180359,
0.6024926900863647,
-0.07216843217611313,
0.6929499506950378,
-0.34125012159347534,
0.01706785336136818,
0.46182340383529663,
0.22972609102725983,
0.03974353149533272,
-0.6451206803321838,
0.06969999521970749,
-0.49747538566589355,
-0.3790544867515564,
0.5263479351997375,
-0.36242082715034485,
0.4923717677593231,
-0.44762271642684937,
-0.5561036467552185,
-0.3630642890930176,
0.46183308959007263,
-0.0025108004920184612,
0.9404096603393555,
0.28133752942085266,
0.4393680691719055,
0.6684392094612122,
-0.11745333671569824,
0.7317275404930115,
-0.3883393704891205,
0.5413937568664551,
1.039996862411499,
-0.2704564332962036,
1.234675407409668,
0.5884783864021301,
-0.5478023886680603,
0.3037564158439636,
0.6479276418685913,
-0.24392767250537872,
0.38524022698402405,
0.15339338779449463,
-0.41461220383644104,
0.011740749701857567,
0.08814777433872223,
-0.5451769232749939,
0.21161584556102753,
0.28857070207595825,
-0.4725832939147949,
-0.3131849765777588,
-0.03331432864069939,
-0.09771779924631119,
0.27189376950263977,
-0.20656783878803253,
1.192771077156067,
-0.1606987714767456,
-0.2067730724811554,
0.022171247750520706,
0.3319943845272064,
0.6610237956047058,
-0.33532392978668213,
0.1433720737695694,
-0.04845130071043968,
0.09928388893604279,
-0.601535975933075,
-0.6760420799255371,
0.559407114982605,
0.33709344267845154,
-0.10443433374166489,
0.14736875891685486,
0.8283505439758301,
0.05970114469528198,
-0.2857449948787689,
0.3531728982925415,
0.06931088119745255,
0.572827160358429,
0.3157793879508972,
-0.4445430636405945,
-0.2752353549003601,
0.21384958922863007,
-0.16405342519283295,
0.30838972330093384,
0.10082446038722992,
-0.23581764101982117,
0.714077889919281,
0.8235813975334167,
0.19342917203903198,
0.05824688822031021,
-0.28240689635276794,
0.9688369631767273,
-0.2609284222126007,
-1.0837348699569702,
-0.9879903197288513,
0.7700907588005066,
-0.3487599790096283,
-0.4977165758609772,
0.6139971017837524,
0.912264883518219,
0.7249662280082703,
0.18068452179431915,
0.8846864700317383,
-0.02242952026426792,
0.054971665143966675,
-0.39238378405570984,
1.0355713367462158,
-0.5611703991889954,
0.90647292137146,
-0.2245834320783615,
-0.7775758504867554,
-0.6954132318496704,
0.3319045305252075,
-0.1824263632297516,
-0.24147450923919678,
0.5052093267440796,
0.40052902698516846,
0.18951964378356934,
0.3867909908294678,
0.597811222076416,
-0.0013992910971865058,
0.21177200973033905,
0.3585633933544159,
0.6520370841026306,
-0.27548569440841675,
0.6254794001579285,
-0.14042481780052185,
-0.6284826397895813,
-0.31813645362854004,
-0.8077670335769653,
-0.9291756749153137,
-0.4196503758430481,
-0.33859819173812866,
-0.2747029960155487,
-0.058547090739011765,
0.7082768082618713,
0.24827778339385986,
-0.9993991255760193,
-0.08486712723970413,
0.04748301953077316,
0.08930191397666931,
-0.22561810910701752,
-0.22488228976726532,
0.14091815054416656,
-0.5559933185577393,
-0.36649662256240845,
-0.24347151815891266,
0.5130578875541687,
0.14347299933433533,
-0.1371927708387375,
-0.08621738106012344,
0.2234504222869873,
-0.01521244551986456,
0.5840246081352234,
0.44415736198425293,
-0.6413276791572571,
0.020706498995423317,
-0.13137301802635193,
0.0216340571641922,
-0.3282766044139862,
0.610663890838623,
-0.5330967903137207,
0.5741643309593201,
0.5418439507484436,
0.5100562572479248,
0.08123951405286789,
-0.07503587007522583,
0.4357040822505951,
-0.5770794749259949,
-0.14149607717990875,
0.07701737433671951,
0.39381396770477295,
-0.3400633931159973,
-0.7333008646965027,
0.35509899258613586,
-0.16393324732780457,
-0.5557345151901245,
-0.6957716941833496,
-0.05013550445437431,
-1.0564959049224854,
-0.5066974759101868,
0.7422401309013367,
-0.6885326504707336,
-0.2834518551826477,
-0.805502712726593,
-0.28325995802879333,
0.0005249081877991557,
-0.5575293302536011,
0.7297611832618713,
0.30753281712532043,
-0.2642888128757477,
0.20778734982013702,
-0.3338954448699951,
0.4707094132900238,
0.05303914472460747,
-1.2451010942459106,
0.2421634942293167,
0.5772892832756042,
0.21111224591732025,
0.5884591937065125,
0.6106555461883545,
-0.25627779960632324,
0.5571184754371643,
-0.1691925823688507,
-0.21539616584777832,
-0.30835089087486267,
-0.5129733681678772,
-0.6354792714118958,
0.3554908335208893,
-0.3165293037891388,
-0.42500224709510803
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07144v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07144v1
|
Thought Graph: Generating Thought Process for Biological Reasoning
| 2024-03-11T20:28:27 | 2024-03-11T20:28:27 |
Chi-Yang Hsu, Kyle Cox, Jiawei Xu, Zhen Tan, Tianhua Zhai, Mengzhou Hu, Dexter Pratt, Tianlong Chen, Ziniu Hu, Ying Ding
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present the Thought Graph as a novel framework to support complex
reasoning and use gene set analysis as an example to uncover semantic
relationships between biological processes. Our framework stands out for its
ability to provide a deeper understanding of gene sets, significantly
surpassing GSEA by 40.28% and LLM baselines by 5.38% based on cosine similarity
to human annotations. Our analysis further provides insights into future
directions of biological processes naming, and implications for bioinformatics
and precision medicine.
|
[
-0.5900655388832092,
-0.9480676651000977,
0.8671751022338867,
-0.38606685400009155,
-0.27936941385269165,
0.15151770412921906,
0.3301618993282318,
-0.6984235644340515,
0.5947427153587341,
0.5825082063674927,
-1.000475287437439,
-0.41606444120407104,
-0.6191142201423645,
0.06684442609548569,
-0.08553560823202133,
0.8100414276123047,
0.05103350058197975,
0.27200937271118164,
-0.11363070458173752,
-0.15944182872772217,
-0.09232930094003677,
-0.34520044922828674,
-0.7396333813667297,
-0.9923497438430786,
0.7475830912590027,
-0.0008816324989311397,
0.6360312700271606,
0.5271461606025696,
0.7651636004447937,
0.2046257108449936,
-0.10570889711380005,
0.11067409813404083,
-0.628364622592926,
0.1380787044763565,
-0.4647168219089508,
-0.4480855464935303,
-0.7089865803718567,
0.12232347577810287,
0.2577519118785858,
1.1979701519012451,
0.49867185950279236,
0.34476199746131897,
-0.3683626353740692,
1.0006904602050781,
-0.19113054871559143,
0.10766091197729111,
-0.4413362443447113,
0.5530647039413452,
-0.4758639633655548,
-0.4519951641559601,
-0.19057990610599518,
-0.5872473120689392,
0.20412278175354004,
-0.6128684282302856,
0.352323442697525,
0.07023519277572632,
0.6831458210945129,
0.33484193682670593,
-0.3447251617908478,
-0.2667948305606842,
-0.39329829812049866,
0.32249903678894043,
-0.7082825303077698,
0.0709044560790062,
0.07421303540468216,
0.33053186535835266,
-0.8728629350662231,
-1.0209786891937256,
-0.6729738116264343,
0.09919530898332596,
0.0870894342660904,
0.08314050734043121,
-0.02968674525618553,
0.2970171272754669,
0.8201727271080017,
0.41095224022865295,
-0.39717260003089905,
-0.3548734486103058,
-0.4610908329486847,
-0.1689286231994629,
0.47563689947128296,
0.12716539204120636,
0.5449159145355225,
-0.1325371265411377,
-0.13186486065387726,
0.06827177852392197,
-0.667593777179718,
0.2238578349351883,
0.24330806732177734,
0.16287173330783844,
0.3983724117279053,
0.8154258728027344,
-0.19480951130390167,
0.7081348299980164,
-0.0748087614774704,
0.06110116094350815,
0.6407323479652405,
-0.17874829471111298,
-0.6083385348320007,
0.10183349996805191,
0.6631603837013245,
0.5068966150283813,
0.21607501804828644,
-0.12294697761535645,
0.2485954761505127,
0.5143933892250061,
0.15020011365413666,
-0.9016777276992798,
-0.3819871246814728,
0.4293038547039032,
-0.4150291085243225,
-0.2507799565792084,
-0.04337412118911743,
-0.7792419195175171,
-0.48794275522232056,
-0.3777918815612793,
0.07072732597589493,
-0.6261448264122009,
-0.1500362604856491,
0.241921529173851,
-0.7794710993766785,
0.19285131990909576,
0.29019874334335327,
-0.5325195789337158,
0.04005131870508194,
0.7265618443489075,
0.6621858477592468,
-0.1306668072938919,
0.12879110872745514,
-0.09199050813913345,
0.41900086402893066,
-0.35786816477775574,
1.0458309650421143,
-0.8043121695518494,
-0.4320691227912903,
-0.5316590666770935,
-0.07435693591833115,
-0.11744926869869232,
-0.3400022089481354,
0.3029930889606476,
-0.454881489276886,
-0.08875799179077148,
-0.7457677721977234,
-1.1302987337112427,
-0.4200652241706848,
0.10548260062932968,
-0.7900088429450989,
0.8365273475646973,
-0.06769506633281708,
-0.9216216206550598,
0.6884714365005493,
-1.063355565071106,
-0.32689720392227173,
0.388174444437027,
-0.5523409843444824,
-0.02359418012201786,
-0.37347930669784546,
0.010380201041698456,
0.5002297163009644,
-0.19077587127685547,
0.3682357668876648,
-0.8555046916007996,
-0.1153038889169693,
0.3302766680717468,
0.26945075392723083,
0.9396114945411682,
0.27864977717399597,
-0.5126088857650757,
0.20900209248065948,
-0.7610058188438416,
0.5362155437469482,
-0.02494008280336857,
0.175129696726799,
-0.08225203305482864,
0.040220510214567184,
-0.7776474356651306,
0.2542476952075958,
-0.11945651471614838,
-0.6883633732795715,
0.41983723640441895,
-0.39169830083847046,
0.6687464714050293,
0.6898220777511597,
0.6174641251564026,
0.2116037905216217,
-0.19282130897045135,
0.35776689648628235,
0.041135046631097794,
-0.14935244619846344,
0.11537425220012665,
-0.9535534977912903,
-0.5489708185195923,
-0.11985305696725845,
0.00015882935258559883,
0.5337057113647461,
-0.43488645553588867,
0.45693621039390564,
-0.28276684880256653,
-0.5135145783424377,
-0.2622557282447815,
-0.11614774167537689,
0.5238247513771057,
0.7841151356697083,
0.3362766206264496,
-0.36578646302223206,
-0.6798744797706604,
-1.1556720733642578,
0.04911315441131592,
0.006058158818632364,
0.006576660554856062,
0.2138802856206894,
0.8383111953735352,
-0.5378422141075134,
0.8504567742347717,
-0.9217677116394043,
0.11976297199726105,
-0.12416262179613113,
0.3353314697742462,
0.42174094915390015,
0.37702128291130066,
0.5173375606536865,
-0.5786924362182617,
0.02791556715965271,
0.003928902093321085,
-1.106513500213623,
-0.20449824631214142,
0.2236568182706833,
-0.8792520761489868,
-0.21695736050605774,
0.5617433190345764,
-0.5444039106369019,
0.7358945608139038,
0.16095022857189178,
-0.5278209447860718,
0.3741461932659149,
0.1464366912841797,
0.34576767683029175,
-1.0511176586151123,
0.27580615878105164,
-0.05699693411588669,
-0.11870075762271881,
-0.5857242345809937,
0.03301802650094032,
-0.380923330783844,
-0.12809154391288757,
-0.16761599481105804,
0.21692335605621338,
-0.3244202733039856,
-0.4846324324607849,
-0.1117139682173729,
0.15417440235614777,
0.04650786146521568,
0.560024619102478,
-0.21532297134399414,
0.5682300925254822,
0.49907156825065613,
-0.4940759241580963,
0.4452878534793854,
0.37934520840644836,
-0.2522238790988922,
0.3274039924144745,
-0.5397458672523499,
0.25352373719215393,
-0.10156581550836563,
0.4800548255443573,
-0.7307866215705872,
-0.4309110641479492,
0.4471188187599182,
-0.4154073894023895,
-0.11800310760736465,
0.3268820643424988,
-0.20927929878234863,
-0.7483748197555542,
-0.23453111946582794,
0.11453325301408768,
0.35383763909339905,
-0.08183781057596207,
0.39930954575538635,
0.7121306657791138,
0.15272419154644012,
-0.33221331238746643,
-0.7944138646125793,
0.06755799800157547,
0.0021105087362229824,
-0.8304980993270874,
0.29736337065696716,
-0.15384984016418457,
-0.4411521553993225,
0.2508559823036194,
-0.011310639791190624,
0.051747940480709076,
-0.21090899407863617,
0.5256612300872803,
0.10679212957620621,
-0.21573270857334137,
0.39894479513168335,
-0.053456373512744904,
-0.17783650755882263,
0.16562125086784363,
-0.3549070656299591,
0.4598776698112488,
-0.07438646256923676,
-0.3946222960948944,
-0.13063326478004456,
0.5238355398178101,
0.5791729688644409,
-0.0065520876087248325,
0.3001651465892792,
0.3785003125667572,
-0.7171375155448914,
-0.2386767715215683,
0.07522404193878174,
-0.06382651627063751,
-0.4045603573322296,
0.2652883529663086,
-0.4549259841442108,
-0.7848323583602905,
0.75151526927948,
-0.39981159567832947,
-0.07254905253648758,
0.5343970656394958,
0.5760247111320496,
-0.45653778314590454,
0.8077441453933716,
0.39032307267189026,
0.2680663466453552,
0.07380501925945282,
-0.5847920179367065,
0.5642196536064148,
-0.8508781790733337,
-0.4136575758457184,
-0.016867998987436295,
-0.6526463627815247,
-0.35208338499069214,
-0.719421923160553,
0.32513168454170227,
0.3319534361362457,
-0.2276313453912735,
0.23209664225578308,
-0.6687423586845398,
0.4755205512046814,
0.6558489799499512,
0.33196038007736206,
-0.022729260846972466,
-0.22799460589885712,
-0.43755480647087097,
0.27758345007896423,
-0.5500897765159607,
-0.8577914834022522,
0.8786317110061646,
-0.028784651309251785,
0.16950619220733643,
-0.1844954490661621,
0.564879834651947,
0.5258000493049622,
0.3775901794433594,
-0.693517804145813,
0.9296622276306152,
-0.05652434378862381,
-0.7455101609230042,
-0.4940565228462219,
-0.22523652017116547,
-1.0032027959823608,
0.04685438051819801,
-0.46096304059028625,
-0.8511923551559448,
-0.03384372219443321,
0.23452416062355042,
-0.22047577798366547,
0.7213515639305115,
-0.5174720883369446,
0.7348251342773438,
0.10452938079833984,
-0.00856055598706007,
-0.20624394714832306,
-0.779499351978302,
0.5077911019325256,
-0.023778051137924194,
0.01839948073029518,
-0.4548415243625641,
0.36356988549232483,
0.972935676574707,
-0.42112380266189575,
0.7806647419929504,
-0.04682778939604759,
0.17296583950519562,
0.6551394462585449,
-0.03243791311979294,
0.12284482270479202,
-0.2092946469783783,
-0.20686659216880798,
0.13091404736042023,
-0.1510542631149292,
-0.4294101595878601,
-0.5737423896789551,
0.5471506118774414,
-0.5599908232688904,
-0.5819193720817566,
-0.31931257247924805,
-0.6191768646240234,
-0.32741719484329224,
0.4946063160896301,
0.47763800621032715,
0.3670831024646759,
-0.01812971942126751,
-0.13293126225471497,
0.80072420835495,
0.09572490304708481,
0.2566989064216614,
-0.22349445521831512,
-0.4901607632637024,
-0.43299436569213867,
0.45714420080184937,
0.24725301563739777,
0.24471557140350342,
0.19525814056396484,
0.06099436804652214,
-0.052026715129613876,
-0.5931223630905151,
-0.25565963983535767,
0.13766862452030182,
-0.8963373899459839,
-0.06488437950611115,
-0.7815311551094055,
-0.1568700522184372,
-0.5357784032821655,
-0.3625742793083191,
0.15305127203464508,
-0.5110065937042236,
-0.16623052954673767,
-0.6659846901893616,
0.4669330418109894,
0.7515392899513245,
0.2272346466779709,
0.029437948018312454,
-0.7474657893180847,
0.6041990518569946,
0.2928791046142578,
0.21894748508930206,
-0.20194728672504425,
0.14654488861560822,
0.0730666071176529,
0.3781229555606842,
-0.36093467473983765,
-1.2551335096359253,
0.11302249878644943,
0.25309550762176514,
0.8217901587486267,
0.3894062638282776,
-0.4632858633995056,
0.8733447194099426,
-0.4640684127807617,
0.9160194993019104,
0.3026544451713562,
-0.7854564785957336,
0.8689187169075012,
-0.46352657675743103,
0.1568358838558197,
0.2465752363204956,
0.33402708172798157,
-0.43511834740638733,
-0.45087024569511414,
-0.9672656059265137,
-0.7261261343955994,
0.1535935252904892,
0.30931356549263,
-0.49202924966812134,
-0.3086160123348236,
0.7286313772201538,
0.09149535745382309,
-0.014485248364508152,
-0.5183513760566711,
-0.1576414406299591,
-0.01230357401072979,
-0.10609059780836105,
0.20766903460025787,
-0.044147320091724396,
-0.4998679459095001,
-0.45010611414909363,
0.7542368173599243,
-0.47487547993659973,
0.44272011518478394,
0.37087488174438477,
0.2040751874446869,
-0.5507317185401917,
0.03619430586695671,
0.3034832775592804,
0.7529086470603943,
-0.19570334255695343,
0.3036215901374817,
0.1595851629972458,
-0.3499731123447418,
-0.007387774530798197,
-0.2669510245323181,
-0.09762095659971237,
-0.44351521134376526,
0.8603047728538513,
0.6620835661888123,
-0.04878472164273262,
-0.7420100569725037,
0.01299359556287527,
0.24478396773338318,
-0.46419939398765564,
-0.04076484218239784,
0.5401256680488586,
0.5316928625106812,
0.4136340320110321,
0.09471922367811203,
0.487822949886322,
0.4160560071468353,
-0.5814553499221802,
0.49955108761787415,
0.3835611939430237,
-0.3761110305786133,
-0.32348722219467163,
0.5550854802131653,
0.14268583059310913,
-0.09514336287975311,
0.6047381162643433,
-0.4116500914096832,
-0.5531166195869446,
1.0988926887512207,
0.5559626817703247,
0.9005750417709351,
0.1680680513381958,
0.3050767779350281,
0.541559636592865,
-0.13339398801326752,
0.2055530995130539,
0.719655454158783,
0.21865606307983398,
-1.005566954612732,
-0.43924638628959656,
-0.7489479184150696,
-0.4715043008327484,
0.15535445511341095,
-0.4707595705986023,
0.07453520596027374,
-0.5529853701591492,
-0.5842830538749695,
0.7283472418785095,
-0.09877762943506241,
-0.3602282702922821,
0.5272504687309265,
0.29282647371292114,
0.8936072587966919,
-0.8837471604347229,
0.8309711813926697,
0.7983807325363159,
-0.3384314179420471,
-0.7743244171142578,
-0.4022064208984375,
0.10350412875413895,
-0.8174347281455994,
0.775813639163971,
0.33073997497558594,
-0.5392321944236755,
-0.1718614548444748,
-0.6449025869369507,
-1.064764380455017,
1.260194182395935,
0.31336113810539246,
-0.4356471598148346,
0.20710968971252441,
-0.05328202247619629,
0.8425874710083008,
-0.6601824164390564,
-0.1762462854385376,
0.662685751914978,
0.5602033734321594,
0.5784927010536194,
-0.29886549711227417,
0.15863630175590515,
-0.7038158774375916,
-0.17949113249778748,
0.6920480132102966,
-0.294445276260376,
0.7388997673988342,
-0.6291028261184692,
-0.5013335943222046,
-0.44660821557044983,
0.4617536664009094,
0.3425265848636627,
0.6603140234947205,
0.30848315358161926,
0.8743903040885925,
1.2251555919647217,
-0.06816711276769638,
0.931963324546814,
-0.18964490294456482,
-0.002485164673998952,
0.9146954417228699,
-0.3541228473186493,
0.5286275148391724,
0.4813096225261688,
-0.38787680864334106,
0.5865755081176758,
0.9603099822998047,
0.026909304782748222,
0.18848693370819092,
0.3083491921424866,
-0.04161518067121506,
-0.3057280480861664,
0.05015512928366661,
-0.3042379915714264,
-0.1276981085538864,
0.7621185183525085,
-0.5845113396644592,
0.03450577333569527,
-0.2323991060256958,
-0.008118241094052792,
0.0007220179541036487,
-0.5600118637084961,
0.4923708140850067,
0.2203579992055893,
-0.6491565704345703,
0.0633407011628151,
-0.619195282459259,
0.06684758514165878,
-0.48789945244789124,
-0.34180471301078796,
0.2354247272014618,
-0.05229302868247032,
-0.3248418867588043,
-1.2279740571975708,
0.4337832033634186,
-0.18431374430656433,
-0.3918801248073578,
-0.12358080595731735,
0.9390996098518372,
-0.08996845781803131,
-0.5898950695991516,
0.48002368211746216,
0.5557010173797607,
0.26285943388938904,
0.560058057308197,
-0.7069595456123352,
-0.5409023761749268,
0.3306456208229065,
-0.407797247171402,
-0.10705748945474625,
0.6160301566123962,
-0.3046841025352478,
0.9428199529647827,
0.8721501231193542,
0.18688265979290009,
0.15795709192752838,
0.13018089532852173,
0.8827055096626282,
-1.0737974643707275,
-0.26267388463020325,
-0.8472347259521484,
0.029258741065859795,
-0.49843448400497437,
-0.35855740308761597,
0.47962555289268494,
0.3900619447231293,
0.6682184934616089,
-0.055494554340839386,
0.953346312046051,
-0.1663074493408203,
0.40128570795059204,
-0.44470125436782837,
0.40096378326416016,
-0.16796232759952545,
-0.05901539325714111,
-0.4021192193031311,
-0.8738932609558105,
-0.5634292960166931,
0.3529369533061981,
-0.37456172704696655,
-0.03073524311184883,
1.1208045482635498,
0.6187583804130554,
0.27147769927978516,
0.5817658305168152,
0.11927369982004166,
0.09786004573106766,
0.6677042841911316,
0.7983501553535461,
0.4366910457611084,
0.06757306307554245,
-0.12088889628648758,
-0.0532839372754097,
-0.4705086350440979,
0.09118853509426117,
-1.0934103727340698,
-0.9713369607925415,
-0.361659973859787,
-0.3048197627067566,
-0.2721838057041168,
-0.0755191519856453,
0.9879037737846375,
0.5380207896232605,
-0.8914400339126587,
0.09696941077709198,
-0.4931342899799347,
-0.10416597872972488,
-0.409506231546402,
-0.21803466975688934,
0.5393537282943726,
-0.28615567088127136,
-0.3743864893913269,
0.11587757617235184,
0.6303130388259888,
0.1925623118877411,
-0.04267719015479088,
0.021473437547683716,
-0.37448564171791077,
0.26801711320877075,
0.5402743220329285,
0.2804109752178192,
-0.6942715644836426,
-0.5735386610031128,
-0.11753480136394501,
-0.18884828686714172,
0.18533453345298767,
0.9983060956001282,
-0.7479944229125977,
0.5248023271560669,
0.837293267250061,
0.33248385787010193,
0.5032358765602112,
-0.14940980076789856,
0.7255271077156067,
-0.2257268875837326,
-0.03393693268299103,
0.43102529644966125,
0.650829017162323,
0.2678247094154358,
-0.5848969221115112,
0.8949370980262756,
0.4705711305141449,
-0.4832679331302643,
-0.3617381155490875,
0.6967498064041138,
-1.2095072269439697,
-0.42727312445640564,
0.8289685845375061,
-0.09113780409097672,
-0.5922335982322693,
-0.013990200124680996,
-0.24305817484855652,
0.6520818471908569,
-0.08507394045591354,
0.6426787972450256,
0.6847426295280457,
-1.0373655557632446,
0.2809302508831024,
-0.34650760889053345,
0.5810860395431519,
-0.044473133981227875,
-1.2361751794815063,
-0.08745948225259781,
0.6253536939620972,
0.0890389010310173,
0.3800559937953949,
0.9396718144416809,
-0.1386473923921585,
0.08864529430866241,
0.18207696080207825,
0.12086860090494156,
0.009131158702075481,
0.020064255222678185,
0.4681570529937744,
0.4028042256832123,
-0.38411787152290344,
0.03437012806534767
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07142v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07142v1
|
One Category One Prompt: Dataset Distillation using Diffusion Models
| 2024-03-11T20:23:59 | 2024-03-11T20:23:59 |
Ali Abbasi, Ashkan Shahbazi, Hamed Pirsiavash, Soheil Kolouri
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The extensive amounts of data required for training deep neural networks pose
significant challenges on storage and transmission fronts. Dataset distillation
has emerged as a promising technique to condense the information of massive
datasets into a much smaller yet representative set of synthetic samples.
However, traditional dataset distillation approaches often struggle to scale
effectively with high-resolution images and more complex architectures due to
the limitations in bi-level optimization. Recently, several works have proposed
exploiting knowledge distillation with decoupled optimization schemes to scale
up dataset distillation. Although these methods effectively address the
scalability issue, they rely on extensive image augmentations requiring the
storage of soft labels for augmented images. In this paper, we introduce
Dataset Distillation using Diffusion Models (D3M) as a novel paradigm for
dataset distillation, leveraging recent advancements in generative
text-to-image foundation models. Our approach utilizes textual inversion, a
technique for fine-tuning text-to-image generative models, to create concise
and informative representations for large datasets. By employing these learned
text prompts, we can efficiently store and infer new samples for introducing
data variability within a fixed memory budget. We show the effectiveness of our
method through extensive experiments across various computer vision benchmark
datasets with different memory budgets.
|
[
-0.4519144892692566,
-0.6443536281585693,
0.5223973393440247,
0.10672478377819061,
-0.39222750067710876,
-0.11190854012966156,
-0.1718473732471466,
0.11211849004030228,
-0.373873233795166,
0.4201304018497467,
-0.45787903666496277,
-0.3126504123210907,
-0.7963994145393372,
0.1196150854229927,
-0.6400526165962219,
0.9433882832527161,
-0.21187300980091095,
0.04769502952694893,
-0.2859600782394409,
-0.08917025476694107,
-0.5609834790229797,
-0.12550000846385956,
-0.7162584066390991,
-0.4721284806728363,
0.44747844338417053,
0.18250907957553864,
0.4833250343799591,
0.8766045570373535,
0.5014434456825256,
0.23797607421875,
-0.3067699372768402,
0.34236618876457214,
-0.5240838527679443,
0.22314336895942688,
0.06936147809028625,
-0.4711194932460785,
0.1205729991197586,
0.02688094973564148,
0.5057850480079651,
0.8474399447441101,
-0.347636878490448,
0.029014967381954193,
0.2837842106819153,
1.261420488357544,
-0.7549570202827454,
0.021783707663416862,
-0.7707938551902771,
0.19338059425354004,
-0.06517592072486877,
0.16372321546077728,
-0.18543389439582825,
-0.3687671720981598,
0.4195917546749115,
-0.7015445828437805,
0.564050555229187,
-0.218976691365242,
0.6340809464454651,
0.7417140007019043,
-0.24791409075260162,
-0.2989555597305298,
-0.9636519551277161,
0.5287128686904907,
-0.4365060031414032,
-0.2200693041086197,
0.24207185208797455,
0.48333656787872314,
0.027796177193522453,
-0.8810857534408569,
-0.7459848523139954,
0.19611048698425293,
-0.0015827545430511236,
0.0533459447324276,
-0.33450639247894287,
-0.24430952966213226,
0.22251157462596893,
0.7760695219039917,
-0.22715649008750916,
0.06593972444534302,
-0.34518560767173767,
0.3561020493507385,
0.39562904834747314,
0.2858161926269531,
-0.165180042386055,
0.23965401947498322,
-0.4396074414253235,
-0.257546603679657,
-0.3162711262702942,
-0.6460404992103577,
0.3694421947002411,
0.1995057612657547,
0.07041483372449875,
0.3087318241596222,
-0.01692613959312439,
0.8974924087524414,
0.30860018730163574,
0.003965881187468767,
0.2257600724697113,
-0.29220855236053467,
-0.43828678131103516,
0.0946979820728302,
0.5537976026535034,
0.4440467655658722,
0.10419834405183792,
0.04560212790966034,
-0.16728244721889496,
-0.17392098903656006,
0.16711720824241638,
-1.0570954084396362,
-0.5976819396018982,
0.2117139846086502,
-0.5156702399253845,
-0.5542984008789062,
-0.2480808049440384,
-1.0458461046218872,
-0.8885278701782227,
-0.46519485116004944,
0.3631706237792969,
-0.2647552490234375,
-0.36747628450393677,
0.4672693610191345,
-0.6129400134086609,
-0.2742166519165039,
0.39221081137657166,
-1.0251026153564453,
0.18544289469718933,
0.34881412982940674,
1.0648133754730225,
-0.2817991375923157,
0.10101200640201569,
0.06731900572776794,
0.052278995513916016,
-0.5075926184654236,
0.3911432921886444,
-0.2642360031604767,
-0.410352885723114,
-0.2992599904537201,
-0.19828172028064728,
0.27181124687194824,
-0.9143593311309814,
0.135780930519104,
-0.47670161724090576,
-0.060387395322322845,
-0.03628110513091087,
-0.3946205973625183,
-0.2622288763523102,
0.24510805308818817,
-1.0707547664642334,
0.9371215105056763,
-0.0012631333665922284,
-0.7986770868301392,
0.5650532841682434,
-0.5816725492477417,
-0.33922672271728516,
-0.0029381513595581055,
-0.016598979011178017,
-0.6240925192832947,
0.3490758538246155,
0.40198561549186707,
0.6312549710273743,
-0.6516145467758179,
0.4769044816493988,
-0.2357916384935379,
-0.1718553900718689,
0.05829161778092384,
-1.0100786685943604,
0.5636756420135498,
0.3352386951446533,
-0.18097470700740814,
-0.5666647553443909,
-0.9971951246261597,
-0.47600311040878296,
-0.007131529506295919,
-0.33512261509895325,
-0.6247158646583557,
-0.1721120923757553,
-0.19655661284923553,
-0.09479659050703049,
0.1601570099592209,
-0.4686693251132965,
0.385390967130661,
-0.0429585725069046,
0.5996711850166321,
0.6491550207138062,
0.1731072962284088,
0.5769643783569336,
-0.07418736815452576,
0.07299639284610748,
0.6053653359413147,
0.039932459592819214,
-0.31214430928230286,
-0.3166484236717224,
-0.5653629302978516,
-0.45723482966423035,
0.304348349571228,
0.3440625071525574,
-0.9466020464897156,
0.2581665515899658,
-0.34681567549705505,
-0.4403681457042694,
-0.32673269510269165,
0.29179078340530396,
-0.11774314194917679,
1.0273631811141968,
0.40459945797920227,
0.2674725651741028,
-0.34522080421447754,
-1.0390560626983643,
0.3019019365310669,
0.18149405717849731,
-0.12450174987316132,
0.1250045895576477,
0.475055456161499,
-0.14207716286182404,
0.8628537058830261,
-0.8607193827629089,
-0.38563328981399536,
-0.03794928640127182,
0.3498886823654175,
0.6045675873756409,
0.5267935395240784,
0.5849574208259583,
-1.1818747520446777,
-0.39965561032295227,
-0.00508155720308423,
-0.7923439145088196,
0.2646460235118866,
-0.2597774267196655,
-0.01971025951206684,
-0.20980793237686157,
0.33222824335098267,
-0.28178051114082336,
0.4834396243095398,
0.513312816619873,
0.17686958611011505,
0.09607896953821182,
-0.2934788465499878,
0.132025808095932,
-1.395981788635254,
0.08594591915607452,
0.3303067982196808,
-0.07982813566923141,
-0.4744959771633148,
-0.47153839468955994,
0.14321213960647583,
-0.06757915765047073,
-0.353375107049942,
0.23006723821163177,
-0.46967941522598267,
0.18742598593235016,
-0.36350396275520325,
-0.18060053884983063,
0.5771450400352478,
0.13886798918247223,
0.13132789731025696,
0.6363763809204102,
0.8157110214233398,
-0.8090539574623108,
0.7864148616790771,
0.3359551429748535,
-0.47043368220329285,
0.6804581880569458,
-0.5842363238334656,
-0.06500719487667084,
-0.5174673199653625,
0.38087743520736694,
-1.1799284219741821,
0.010646450333297253,
-0.005825372878462076,
0.0348518043756485,
0.6046333909034729,
-0.40279054641723633,
-0.4795725345611572,
-0.4020139276981354,
-0.15001973509788513,
0.4922650158405304,
0.6751265525817871,
-0.9401743412017822,
0.5067515969276428,
0.008095179684460163,
0.19570620357990265,
-0.5989953875541687,
-1.1239632368087769,
0.15147049725055695,
-0.8266044855117798,
-0.43508675694465637,
0.4222196340560913,
0.07042685151100159,
-0.26463985443115234,
-0.003746243892237544,
-0.07529884576797485,
-0.3354909121990204,
0.08490347862243652,
0.14515012502670288,
0.4892299473285675,
-0.08063755184412003,
0.2850007712841034,
0.10273266583681107,
-0.10084163397550583,
-0.1614307314157486,
-0.7472702264785767,
0.03635844215750694,
0.30608537793159485,
0.11856234818696976,
-0.5786769390106201,
0.13080602884292603,
0.3666781485080719,
0.3992210328578949,
0.6985272169113159,
0.3539353311061859,
-0.31477028131484985,
-0.17351199686527252,
-0.4279894232749939,
-0.060497600585222244,
-0.48977455496788025,
0.2091735303401947,
-0.35877397656440735,
-0.4814664423465729,
0.4052126705646515,
-0.6245454549789429,
0.0934617891907692,
0.3589548170566559,
0.447913259267807,
-0.3549406826496124,
0.6442526578903198,
0.2799983322620392,
-0.018856123089790344,
0.4721083641052246,
-0.696804940700531,
-0.040598489344120026,
-0.7154450416564941,
-0.18560370802879333,
-0.44463256001472473,
-0.8563413023948669,
-0.13626937568187714,
-0.6429600119590759,
0.3173861503601074,
0.12666228413581848,
-0.09322627633810043,
0.1844237744808197,
-0.746799886226654,
0.6876480579376221,
0.25981277227401733,
0.32701191306114197,
0.3377770483493805,
0.32368406653404236,
0.015362759120762348,
0.05867673456668854,
-0.6231979727745056,
-0.31061434745788574,
1.2108497619628906,
0.3256179392337799,
1.052062749862671,
-0.21172325313091278,
0.724623441696167,
0.37741386890411377,
0.10042181611061096,
-0.7016206383705139,
0.20037324726581573,
-0.6052543520927429,
-0.5239413380622864,
-0.3112151324748993,
-0.4493921399116516,
-0.782271683216095,
0.15557871758937836,
0.09303171932697296,
-0.21579985320568085,
0.7972366809844971,
0.2860112190246582,
-0.41227710247039795,
0.5172758102416992,
-0.7425583004951477,
0.5130223035812378,
0.0965799018740654,
-0.5063097476959229,
0.1172197088599205,
-0.5204076170921326,
0.39653250575065613,
-0.2787737548351288,
0.04527900367975235,
-0.0790378749370575,
-0.06785833090543747,
0.4258696734905243,
-0.6034265160560608,
0.7434169054031372,
-0.4367244839668274,
-0.36049720644950867,
0.4079398512840271,
0.0158707145601511,
0.3559231758117676,
0.20443841814994812,
-0.16485044360160828,
0.19239138066768646,
-0.3195526897907257,
-0.29094770550727844,
-0.8982690572738647,
0.7341084480285645,
-0.558707594871521,
-0.42360225319862366,
-0.06269959360361099,
-0.41128507256507874,
-0.03874476999044418,
-0.05982907861471176,
0.37690749764442444,
0.507941722869873,
-0.06909128278493881,
0.3930768370628357,
1.1020199060440063,
0.01692509837448597,
0.6055119037628174,
0.13990886509418488,
0.17605793476104736,
-0.38365423679351807,
0.8031010031700134,
0.01615385338664055,
0.3669288754463196,
0.324663907289505,
0.22776219248771667,
-0.350894033908844,
-0.9054086804389954,
-0.7219234108924866,
-0.2867307960987091,
-0.737017035484314,
-0.4769107699394226,
-0.39740490913391113,
0.019553102552890778,
0.03363344818353653,
0.0012431507930159569,
-0.58828204870224,
-0.5695222020149231,
-0.8537031412124634,
-0.13610492646694183,
0.7038415670394897,
0.6277528405189514,
-0.32199686765670776,
0.3577747941017151,
-0.5979775786399841,
0.6137970685958862,
0.2686713635921478,
0.24379801750183105,
0.03949981555342674,
-0.4967374801635742,
-0.34120431542396545,
0.38136371970176697,
-0.14392319321632385,
-0.5289729833602905,
0.2533577084541321,
0.3044666051864624,
0.2750057280063629,
0.31422489881515503,
0.03094419650733471,
0.7735375165939331,
-0.45167964696884155,
0.8005706071853638,
0.38869795203208923,
-0.48416411876678467,
0.6558251976966858,
-0.1636829674243927,
0.22482432425022125,
0.9103270769119263,
0.6295947432518005,
0.00039070783532224596,
0.16198231279850006,
-0.26868051290512085,
-0.9173097014427185,
0.3441917896270752,
0.1549239158630371,
0.3628215193748474,
0.06770720332860947,
0.7219737768173218,
0.4877663552761078,
0.31966596841812134,
-0.34431934356689453,
-0.45321017503738403,
-0.3420853018760681,
-0.3462877869606018,
-0.02249767631292343,
0.023045707494020462,
-0.327025443315506,
-0.3345833122730255,
0.4189146161079407,
-0.017631951719522476,
-0.19563834369182587,
0.15372446179389954,
0.11930356174707413,
0.4749617576599121,
-0.19198058545589447,
0.11056511104106903,
0.3313432037830353,
-0.01245166640728712,
0.30408215522766113,
-0.07804826647043228,
-0.7621732950210571,
0.65938401222229,
0.11556027084589005,
-0.1906862109899521,
-0.004278123378753662,
-0.11032403260469437,
0.9899528622627258,
-0.1844467967748642,
-0.04332937300205231,
0.33945420384407043,
-0.3501037657260895,
-0.7136048078536987,
-0.03122604638338089,
0.02419762872159481,
0.06231699511408806,
0.22291281819343567,
0.5592135190963745,
0.22155536711215973,
0.41179153323173523,
-0.2134573757648468,
0.22590816020965576,
0.014837934635579586,
-0.30231592059135437,
0.17067256569862366,
0.5965458154678345,
0.185715451836586,
0.3950432538986206,
0.9796292781829834,
0.050370655953884125,
0.14421360194683075,
0.7709916830062866,
0.19930525124073029,
0.9356427788734436,
0.1264132708311081,
0.27423444390296936,
0.46362099051475525,
-0.07525447010993958,
-0.5407288670539856,
-0.11614339798688889,
-0.3008570969104767,
-0.7416330575942993,
-0.0222439207136631,
-0.623417317867279,
-0.032484523952007294,
0.22785885632038116,
-0.7528123259544373,
0.18353056907653809,
-0.3138335347175598,
-0.2285805195569992,
0.3190769851207733,
-0.3296199440956116,
-0.6497541666030884,
0.3636304438114166,
0.16339868307113647,
0.7893785238265991,
-0.9170457124710083,
0.7159931659698486,
0.16387678682804108,
-0.2776789665222168,
-0.4870053827762604,
0.006461216136813164,
-0.13054011762142181,
-0.5161498188972473,
0.71018385887146,
0.07771700620651245,
0.26467397809028625,
0.15841254591941833,
-0.523838460445404,
-0.4659304618835449,
1.3384473323822021,
0.4585624635219574,
-0.828577995300293,
0.041708000004291534,
0.12584073841571808,
0.36727941036224365,
-0.4026108682155609,
-0.1264311522245407,
0.8950647115707397,
0.45489606261253357,
0.7761316299438477,
-0.18709154427051544,
0.005511034745723009,
-0.21649403870105743,
0.5020115375518799,
0.014998534694314003,
-0.41029638051986694,
0.7811800837516785,
-0.13282570242881775,
-0.07742653787136078,
-0.05263642221689224,
0.37878942489624023,
0.0609155148267746,
0.2180517315864563,
0.5619555711746216,
0.7760987877845764,
0.7441565990447998,
-0.2242174744606018,
0.8654872179031372,
0.24109388887882233,
0.15071243047714233,
1.324690341949463,
-0.38283365964889526,
0.27587756514549255,
0.7142031192779541,
-0.051496751606464386,
0.37442994117736816,
0.6982486844062805,
-0.37953639030456543,
1.0046199560165405,
0.4674008786678314,
-0.4426993727684021,
0.07847197353839874,
0.10621752589941025,
-0.31370794773101807,
0.13026505708694458,
0.4569653570652008,
-0.6167483925819397,
-0.4236986041069031,
0.5155079960823059,
-0.21796025335788727,
-0.026226600632071495,
-0.20551683008670807,
1.059207797050476,
-0.1414758563041687,
-0.5734844207763672,
0.7875115871429443,
-0.3755105435848236,
0.7123726010322571,
-0.3069716691970825,
-0.15764009952545166,
-0.37901848554611206,
0.2700819671154022,
-0.16323566436767578,
-0.8305101990699768,
0.42268961668014526,
-0.01617925986647606,
-0.4559711217880249,
-0.5124291777610779,
0.5817766785621643,
-0.35000309348106384,
-0.6583113074302673,
-0.10689955204725266,
0.10629751533269882,
0.17818033695220947,
-0.13581551611423492,
-0.5237588882446289,
-0.038080550730228424,
-0.036003272980451584,
-0.3851141333580017,
0.20119152963161469,
0.8143929243087769,
0.34505000710487366,
0.4311593770980835,
0.391250342130661,
0.04530520737171173,
0.057269107550382614,
0.1687030792236328,
1.2221976518630981,
-0.1354651302099228,
-0.11490116268396378,
-1.1378642320632935,
0.6336368322372437,
-0.24003738164901733,
-0.13689059019088745,
0.4283040761947632,
0.7353247404098511,
0.3497331142425537,
-0.1725795865058899,
1.0564597845077515,
0.0684502124786377,
0.0729154720902443,
-0.5748652219772339,
0.550592839717865,
-0.4839789569377899,
0.29424864053726196,
-0.05379485338926315,
-0.7582536339759827,
-0.1535746157169342,
0.4073372185230255,
-0.04557628184556961,
-0.032875481992959976,
0.3802150785923004,
0.6050758361816406,
-0.12109988927841187,
0.19482192397117615,
0.25003060698509216,
-0.04575970396399498,
0.20883290469646454,
0.4478929340839386,
0.7608006596565247,
-0.6042258739471436,
0.4683140814304352,
-0.28719013929367065,
-0.24171820282936096,
0.07090196013450623,
-1.0686506032943726,
-0.7549995183944702,
-0.7354662418365479,
-0.6887446045875549,
-0.291046679019928,
-0.07703498005867004,
0.10753241181373596,
0.8468006253242493,
-0.33671775460243225,
0.20314309000968933,
-0.7004435062408447,
-0.10612606257200241,
-0.16061186790466309,
-0.1820175051689148,
0.2471179962158203,
-0.10044850409030914,
-0.8923425674438477,
0.14947983622550964,
0.2564702033996582,
0.6871257424354553,
-0.5071728229522705,
0.4330354630947113,
-0.08277953416109085,
-0.11094679683446884,
0.16986145079135895,
-0.0818878561258316,
-0.21912387013435364,
0.311477392911911,
-0.34109818935394287,
0.024190476164221764,
0.16267041862010956,
0.8046382069587708,
-0.931338906288147,
0.5290269255638123,
0.4191218614578247,
0.6744437217712402,
1.0408092737197876,
-0.014285678043961525,
0.7136874794960022,
-1.0090835094451904,
0.34964093565940857,
0.16841687262058258,
0.08750475943088531,
0.4618116319179535,
-0.5887885093688965,
0.5257108211517334,
0.07194940745830536,
-0.2869083881378174,
-0.7445635199546814,
0.04180438071489334,
-0.6405344605445862,
-0.45419052243232727,
0.8622658252716064,
-0.31532108783721924,
-0.2522256076335907,
-0.01767042651772499,
-0.18781650066375732,
0.13355426490306854,
-0.1269700527191162,
0.7947264313697815,
0.7879148721694946,
0.012455998919904232,
-0.058012496680021286,
-0.3654525578022003,
0.6193455457687378,
-0.16182948648929596,
-0.6652584075927734,
0.4306352436542511,
0.5898807644844055,
0.30420827865600586,
0.15775620937347412,
0.2791060507297516,
-0.1598605364561081,
-0.13462774455547333,
0.32411932945251465,
-0.2910090684890747,
-0.25860077142715454,
-0.4471973478794098,
-0.52406245470047,
0.1566583514213562,
-0.4209459125995636,
-0.5079730153083801
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07118v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07118v1
|
Narrating Causal Graphs with Large Language Models
| 2024-03-11T19:19:59 | 2024-03-11T19:19:59 |
Atharva Phatak, Vijay K. Mago, Ameeta Agrawal, Aravind Inbasekaran, Philippe J. Giabbanelli
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The use of generative AI to create text descriptions from graphs has mostly
focused on knowledge graphs, which connect concepts using facts. In this work
we explore the capability of large pretrained language models to generate text
from causal graphs, where salient concepts are represented as nodes and
causality is represented via directed, typed edges. The causal reasoning
encoded in these graphs can support applications as diverse as healthcare or
marketing. Using two publicly available causal graph datasets, we empirically
investigate the performance of four GPT-3 models under various settings. Our
results indicate that while causal text descriptions improve with training
data, compared to fact-based graphs, they are harder to generate under
zero-shot settings. Results further suggest that users of generative AI can
deploy future applications faster since similar performances are obtained when
training a model with only a few examples as compared to fine-tuning via a
large curated dataset.
|
[
0.08944271504878998,
-0.7934507727622986,
1.07466721534729,
0.0960964635014534,
-0.24828095734119415,
-0.33330631256103516,
-0.11218545585870743,
-0.46965527534484863,
-0.041864123195409775,
0.44995734095573425,
-0.2844429314136505,
-0.5466628670692444,
-0.6117945313453674,
0.31761837005615234,
-0.5990141034126282,
1.2960147857666016,
-0.009933971799910069,
-0.18246355652809143,
-0.1711837649345398,
0.16911274194717407,
-0.5102574825286865,
-0.46657225489616394,
-0.854212760925293,
-0.5470457673072815,
0.9315670728683472,
0.13136547803878784,
0.8813978433609009,
0.7259126901626587,
0.3668801784515381,
0.2771071493625641,
0.3861570656299591,
0.0458967387676239,
-0.6048465371131897,
0.09496355056762695,
-0.1669374704360962,
-0.34890127182006836,
-0.23069769144058228,
0.08318313211202621,
0.6554222702980042,
0.7272469997406006,
0.1561572104692459,
-0.17534996569156647,
-0.04458796977996826,
0.4387132227420807,
-0.35885658860206604,
0.6107248663902283,
-0.3640720546245575,
-0.037216685712337494,
-0.21813832223415375,
-0.21514534950256348,
-0.5191081762313843,
-0.602232038974762,
0.389987051486969,
-0.8942738771438599,
0.3954199254512787,
0.11682572960853577,
1.1030141115188599,
0.2286294549703598,
-0.5660104751586914,
-0.3541666865348816,
-1.0755025148391724,
0.31711071729660034,
-0.6068487763404846,
0.03569001331925392,
0.3581530451774597,
0.30741581320762634,
-0.0026439179200679064,
-0.9261787533760071,
-0.6470560431480408,
-0.33118557929992676,
-0.39454877376556396,
0.20288032293319702,
-0.46047860383987427,
0.1143546849489212,
0.39137133955955505,
0.06722411513328552,
-0.661458432674408,
0.37211087346076965,
-0.40415242314338684,
0.025222280994057655,
0.7172746658325195,
0.3650989830493927,
0.38060131669044495,
-0.1694294959306717,
-0.05906788259744644,
-0.05269933491945267,
-0.889415442943573,
-0.532529890537262,
0.30800965428352356,
0.45758670568466187,
-0.19816164672374725,
0.8211359977722168,
-0.31035616993904114,
0.9544501304626465,
-0.2239851951599121,
-0.16007043421268463,
0.056611187756061554,
-0.24637188017368317,
-0.33068612217903137,
0.1520238071680069,
1.0082200765609741,
0.3966812491416931,
0.39508625864982605,
-0.5292080640792847,
0.16594387590885162,
0.09423268586397171,
0.20044516026973724,
-0.8581852912902832,
-0.32081273198127747,
-0.06783327460289001,
-0.2641269266605377,
-0.15868791937828064,
-0.2810453772544861,
-0.4734250009059906,
-0.5135530233383179,
-0.5033910274505615,
0.252662718296051,
-0.5057260990142822,
-0.03489900007843971,
0.25318989157676697,
-0.22862105071544647,
0.04387320950627327,
0.36867332458496094,
-0.6860373020172119,
0.058406174182891846,
0.5081793069839478,
0.8888698220252991,
0.14927813410758972,
-0.2992374897003174,
-0.28072845935821533,
0.5938165187835693,
-0.45315760374069214,
0.6173208951950073,
-0.32235172390937805,
-0.26458483934402466,
0.1250310242176056,
-0.28127869963645935,
-0.3031316101551056,
-0.033640459179878235,
0.3616134226322174,
-0.6603474020957947,
0.10867699980735779,
-0.25491321086883545,
-0.5897302031517029,
-0.09754758328199387,
0.07775941491127014,
-0.7152166962623596,
0.4690086543560028,
-0.024515630677342415,
-1.0614068508148193,
0.5163710713386536,
-0.6233365535736084,
-0.9339920878410339,
0.18506409227848053,
-0.34238994121551514,
-0.45723092555999756,
-0.03212253376841545,
0.1140606626868248,
0.7694481611251831,
-0.6778390407562256,
0.7188637852668762,
-0.03066421113908291,
-0.19239118695259094,
0.10602010041475296,
-0.6006369590759277,
0.4760594069957733,
0.29268190264701843,
-0.6964333653450012,
0.14206305146217346,
-0.724055290222168,
-0.4754313826560974,
0.29349789023399353,
0.018778225407004356,
-0.22977107763290405,
0.2334938645362854,
-0.237054243683815,
0.11574436724185944,
-0.2473095953464508,
-0.29427579045295715,
0.09705233573913574,
-0.20303182303905487,
0.42640599608421326,
0.6818663477897644,
-0.0010821853065863252,
-0.011533921584486961,
-0.12584032118320465,
0.4791584610939026,
-0.009982997551560402,
-0.06274077296257019,
-0.06462015211582184,
-0.5760364532470703,
-0.8284183740615845,
-0.08435732871294022,
0.02646312117576599,
0.29864609241485596,
-1.2375413179397583,
0.12230446934700012,
-0.5730614066123962,
-0.5453454256057739,
-0.0867152214050293,
-0.3289346694946289,
0.4541102647781372,
1.0365725755691528,
0.33908966183662415,
0.16012205183506012,
-0.067763552069664,
-0.9261733889579773,
-0.03857532888650894,
-0.46351122856140137,
0.012837992049753666,
0.3655998706817627,
0.49511244893074036,
-0.04019123688340187,
0.8119461536407471,
-0.9525423049926758,
0.025343218818306923,
-0.2219364047050476,
0.48871612548828125,
0.060520321130752563,
0.10226209461688995,
0.5367090702056885,
-0.585029661655426,
-0.4226357936859131,
0.1295485496520996,
-1.087651252746582,
0.01923808641731739,
-0.2917138636112213,
-0.06742123514413834,
-0.056913696229457855,
0.5759039521217346,
-0.6642169952392578,
0.3982645869255066,
0.3698461651802063,
-0.45542269945144653,
0.7417912483215332,
-0.21531370282173157,
0.06436921656131744,
-0.9892801642417908,
0.2943200469017029,
0.15988677740097046,
-0.06455139070749283,
-0.6168935298919678,
-0.3194442689418793,
-0.4173673987388611,
-0.47502174973487854,
-0.20580574870109558,
0.4322994351387024,
-0.39679887890815735,
0.14239494502544403,
-0.05655043199658394,
0.3425636887550354,
-0.09150715917348862,
0.3552069664001465,
0.257242351770401,
0.671001672744751,
0.6488345861434937,
-0.7390974164009094,
0.31943467259407043,
0.31481480598449707,
-0.4241395890712738,
0.4623459279537201,
-0.8164564371109009,
-0.13913200795650482,
-0.2944519519805908,
0.4370264708995819,
-0.6279719471931458,
-0.5847651362419128,
0.1532411277294159,
-0.0659332126379013,
0.2191307544708252,
0.039503518491983414,
-0.7709803581237793,
-0.5387123823165894,
0.306019127368927,
0.40369707345962524,
0.44179484248161316,
-0.46985867619514465,
0.21223480999469757,
0.14868658781051636,
-0.14099782705307007,
-0.330218106508255,
-0.5889148712158203,
0.08865983784198761,
-0.42428451776504517,
-0.39065346121788025,
0.092084601521492,
0.4171457588672638,
0.03832601383328438,
0.23846471309661865,
0.4563918113708496,
0.10593878477811813,
0.14705348014831543,
0.331463485956192,
0.11286754161119461,
-0.1896703839302063,
0.5247042179107666,
-0.09478799253702164,
-0.2872958481311798,
0.06673682481050491,
-0.46524348855018616,
0.4138925075531006,
0.08716356009244919,
-0.3689402937889099,
-0.4859634041786194,
0.29441630840301514,
0.4876086711883545,
-0.09196843951940536,
0.9746395945549011,
0.5906534790992737,
-0.1153576597571373,
0.1327345222234726,
-0.18809810280799866,
0.20748060941696167,
-0.3813769817352295,
0.36305660009384155,
-0.255902498960495,
-1.092684268951416,
0.27477383613586426,
-0.004760489333420992,
-0.23733417689800262,
0.7083069682121277,
0.4826945662498474,
0.1931324154138565,
1.1142597198486328,
0.48166754841804504,
-0.24614019691944122,
0.3074119985103607,
-0.16334350407123566,
0.5158543586730957,
-0.45355698466300964,
-0.2437998652458191,
-0.652442455291748,
0.2520569860935211,
-0.6607393622398376,
-0.2363671362400055,
0.6222068071365356,
0.19731272757053375,
-0.6602572202682495,
0.12975874543190002,
-0.4311439096927643,
0.30068492889404297,
0.61799556016922,
0.07691285759210587,
0.2635848820209503,
0.0850202739238739,
0.11097443848848343,
0.3506697714328766,
-0.9290599822998047,
-0.5501883029937744,
1.035092830657959,
0.061263278126716614,
0.7739018201828003,
0.043033480644226074,
0.3630407154560089,
0.10056908428668976,
0.6379822492599487,
-0.3743603229522705,
0.3754039704799652,
-0.23210327327251434,
-0.45203280448913574,
-0.432056725025177,
-0.6983417868614197,
-1.0766208171844482,
-0.15864071249961853,
-0.22814343869686127,
-0.640414834022522,
-0.07619135826826096,
0.33078551292419434,
-0.40624332427978516,
0.30712783336639404,
-0.7554423809051514,
0.8833272457122803,
-0.14384086430072784,
-0.2334429919719696,
-0.10865435004234314,
-0.6217634081840515,
0.40685081481933594,
0.03165225684642792,
0.002166310092434287,
-0.06684029847383499,
0.6164997220039368,
0.7609204649925232,
-0.6232727766036987,
1.1006232500076294,
-0.13147065043449402,
-0.17393985390663147,
0.5152709484100342,
-0.2420354038476944,
0.4959651529788971,
-0.16691291332244873,
-0.05122964084148407,
0.10459266602993011,
-0.475347101688385,
-0.3243775963783264,
-0.5610037446022034,
0.5018247961997986,
-0.9213269352912903,
-0.6952750086784363,
-0.2026083767414093,
-0.403840035200119,
-0.3408733904361725,
0.32928791642189026,
0.3224036991596222,
0.7741854190826416,
-0.30625343322753906,
-0.11261285841464996,
0.22718258202075958,
-0.43712809681892395,
0.32054653763771057,
0.2174767553806305,
-0.014309978112578392,
-0.09293684363365173,
0.9881633520126343,
0.08153635263442993,
0.30982041358947754,
0.467070072889328,
0.2554103136062622,
-0.3917519450187683,
-0.4887736737728119,
-0.4436628520488739,
0.3328246772289276,
-0.6336695551872253,
-0.4334140717983246,
-0.7993394732475281,
-0.2662608027458191,
-0.34325671195983887,
-0.333218514919281,
-0.05436255410313606,
-0.46903395652770996,
-0.3906916081905365,
-0.4797182083129883,
0.6229593753814697,
1.0852469205856323,
-0.1531054973602295,
0.5452765226364136,
-0.43024274706840515,
0.32622313499450684,
0.5426520109176636,
0.36168187856674194,
0.3256550133228302,
0.14540866017341614,
-0.504302442073822,
-0.0719350278377533,
-0.19813846051692963,
-0.8360641002655029,
0.23742559552192688,
0.029657455161213875,
0.2028985470533371,
0.58433997631073,
-0.08214205503463745,
0.6483504176139832,
-0.8249967694282532,
0.8977367281913757,
0.49833470582962036,
-0.7567360997200012,
0.6531381011009216,
-0.7309529185295105,
0.13558726012706757,
0.19962529838085175,
0.7547199726104736,
-0.323254257440567,
-0.5643981099128723,
-0.5274018049240112,
-0.7329006195068359,
0.6339768171310425,
0.37836161255836487,
0.18170371651649475,
-0.4583844542503357,
0.4681365191936493,
-0.018722370266914368,
0.10846536606550217,
-0.6845458745956421,
-0.29765546321868896,
-0.4299260675907135,
-0.2735596299171448,
-0.4890790283679962,
-0.23133310675621033,
-0.23980456590652466,
-0.15920643508434296,
0.5435062050819397,
-0.1748931109905243,
0.39017823338508606,
0.16604165732860565,
0.09861686825752258,
0.11003752052783966,
0.14776243269443512,
0.40931642055511475,
0.5785606503486633,
0.12179955095052719,
0.3574712872505188,
-0.4212147295475006,
-0.16635586321353912,
0.11626065522432327,
0.47393375635147095,
-0.44355642795562744,
-0.09926523268222809,
0.8397360444068909,
1.3690142631530762,
0.09403092414140701,
-0.41005292534828186,
0.43432146310806274,
0.004217141307890415,
-0.08888949453830719,
0.16180111467838287,
0.07642269134521484,
0.140067920088768,
0.011860677041113377,
0.055112626403570175,
-0.3217461407184601,
0.24526342749595642,
-0.46703600883483887,
-0.030606042593717575,
0.21317462623119354,
-0.41341632604599,
-0.3853345513343811,
1.087481141090393,
0.2776187062263489,
0.13991914689540863,
0.982100784778595,
-0.12205321341753006,
-0.35819950699806213,
0.5770187973976135,
0.8913822174072266,
0.817827582359314,
0.16286370158195496,
0.6619894504547119,
0.4012923240661621,
0.1092475950717926,
-0.00736771896481514,
-0.382769376039505,
0.09089146554470062,
-0.7858688235282898,
-0.5871962904930115,
-0.5431960225105286,
-0.1184135377407074,
-0.035137586295604706,
-0.5514505505561829,
-0.06286382675170898,
-0.08141553401947021,
-0.3295944035053253,
0.1808043122291565,
-0.3495914936065674,
-0.9230535626411438,
0.38863405585289,
-0.10592694580554962,
0.28651291131973267,
-1.221103310585022,
0.5356731414794922,
0.2771437168121338,
-0.8554484844207764,
-1.1690735816955566,
-0.13079160451889038,
-0.2599112093448639,
-0.6362106800079346,
0.8562946915626526,
0.016488537192344666,
-0.10984937846660614,
0.14909334480762482,
-0.5018954277038574,
-0.6703617572784424,
1.1956995725631714,
0.532862663269043,
-0.34723326563835144,
-0.18331199884414673,
0.3618760108947754,
0.710638165473938,
-0.26778513193130493,
0.28638532757759094,
0.48986610770225525,
0.4392063617706299,
0.06120859086513519,
-0.7285575866699219,
0.276292085647583,
-0.017314251512289047,
0.01896597631275654,
-0.13920484483242035,
-0.5603536367416382,
0.8865750432014465,
-0.21192188560962677,
-0.47406259179115295,
-0.17573606967926025,
0.6340693831443787,
0.0742468386888504,
0.1915973424911499,
0.10467533022165298,
0.4875110387802124,
0.7961641550064087,
-0.12465093284845352,
1.7784037590026855,
-0.15953689813613892,
0.19217953085899353,
1.1859647035598755,
-0.31622835993766785,
0.16569826006889343,
-0.08974777162075043,
-0.01971721462905407,
0.6948615908622742,
0.4364836812019348,
0.1661204844713211,
0.47195231914520264,
0.17854703962802887,
-0.27687692642211914,
-0.01475933101028204,
-0.34734007716178894,
-0.47532427310943604,
0.2313847839832306,
0.11664939671754837,
-0.40301236510276794,
-0.40012046694755554,
0.006682293489575386,
0.31017231941223145,
-0.06172575056552887,
-0.290361225605011,
0.7648296356201172,
0.04350415989756584,
-0.6819183826446533,
0.36921870708465576,
-0.03495879843831062,
0.04700777679681778,
-0.47087666392326355,
-0.20436593890190125,
-0.08424253761768341,
-0.12156741321086884,
0.02130754478275776,
-0.6198998689651489,
0.23025108873844147,
0.1374150812625885,
-0.15436182916164398,
-0.34486082196235657,
0.5744014382362366,
-0.2986244261264801,
-0.45741650462150574,
0.06169058382511139,
0.48279061913490295,
0.1839795708656311,
0.09515894949436188,
-0.29719188809394836,
-0.26450279355049133,
-0.17396822571754456,
0.05011695250868797,
-0.04199758172035217,
0.6923144459724426,
-0.26608115434646606,
0.5968377590179443,
0.4144514501094818,
0.09306260198354721,
0.018939031288027763,
0.45595255494117737,
0.8728067874908447,
-0.6393078565597534,
-0.48324862122535706,
-0.9371113181114197,
0.4307841956615448,
-0.11219225078821182,
-0.30847418308258057,
0.9415090084075928,
0.506786584854126,
0.5976670980453491,
-0.21226248145103455,
0.920768678188324,
-0.08205968141555786,
0.13191603124141693,
-0.8018638491630554,
0.7692979574203491,
-0.20124763250350952,
-0.13451233506202698,
-0.4657837450504303,
-0.5081693530082703,
-0.4685763418674469,
0.37713077664375305,
-0.5918938517570496,
0.08184269070625305,
0.7301185727119446,
0.47154197096824646,
0.15759579837322235,
0.001829286920838058,
0.29280173778533936,
0.45234161615371704,
0.6011697053909302,
0.46052056550979614,
0.8527638912200928,
-0.12704455852508545,
0.15572291612625122,
0.19615821540355682,
-0.1662350445985794,
-0.07589814811944962,
-0.8360879421234131,
-0.9543200135231018,
-0.6409191489219666,
-0.3731442093849182,
-0.2648482322692871,
0.13842624425888062,
0.06485087424516678,
0.7081810235977173,
-0.44633156061172485,
0.021724872291088104,
-0.4771272838115692,
0.26995670795440674,
-0.002378089353442192,
-0.2536291480064392,
0.9187730550765991,
-0.47721919417381287,
-0.391955703496933,
0.2047412097454071,
0.1749381273984909,
0.07552466541528702,
-0.12193595618009567,
-0.011724923737347126,
-0.09089664369821548,
0.0768742561340332,
0.7487648129463196,
0.23633477091789246,
-0.31115296483039856,
-0.5089138746261597,
-0.48058295249938965,
-0.04871012642979622,
-0.2930910885334015,
1.151057243347168,
-0.6498242020606995,
0.4116339087486267,
0.08431904762983322,
0.5416768193244934,
0.8687357306480408,
0.05540144443511963,
0.8478240966796875,
-0.6132119297981262,
0.16813558340072632,
0.030556846410036087,
0.13582436740398407,
0.42885443568229675,
-0.3798132836818695,
0.5683011412620544,
0.2118353545665741,
-0.37124162912368774,
-0.5671339631080627,
0.31787043809890747,
-0.5873382091522217,
-0.19913634657859802,
1.113418698310852,
-0.18208633363246918,
0.002040195045992732,
-0.24432572722434998,
0.12303568422794342,
0.5791609287261963,
0.00627659447491169,
0.5524303317070007,
0.4446459412574768,
-0.516897976398468,
0.28951945900917053,
-0.4885129928588867,
0.6952561140060425,
-0.006190354470163584,
-0.9755115509033203,
0.06995869427919388,
0.9521549940109253,
0.07838063687086105,
0.12011479586362839,
1.120187520980835,
-0.056689001619815826,
-0.1277347058057785,
0.32612553238868713,
-0.16366267204284668,
-0.07846978306770325,
-0.5399595499038696,
-0.017304114997386932,
0.17503537237644196,
0.07768871635198593,
0.18505661189556122
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07088v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07088v5
|
SPA: Towards A Computational Friendly Cloud-Base and On-Devices Collaboration Seq2seq Personalized Generation
| 2024-03-11T18:26:02 | 2024-06-20T06:01:25 |
Yanming Liu, Xinyue Peng, Jiannan Cao, Le Dai, Xingzu Liu, Ruilin Nong, Weihao Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models(LLMs) have shown its outperforming ability on various
tasks and question answering. However, LLMs require substantial memory storage
on low-resource devices. More critically, the computational speed on these
devices is also severely limited. In this paper, we propose SPA(Side Plugin
Adaption), a lightweight architecture for fast on-devices inference on the
constraints of strict on-devices computation and memory constraints. Compared
with other on-devices seq2seq generation, SPA could make a fast and stable
inference on low-resource constraints, allowing it to obtain cost effiency. Our
method establish an interaction between a pretrained LLMs on-cloud and additive
parameters on-devices, which could provide the knowledge on both pretrained
LLMs and featured personal feature. Further more, SPA provides a framework to
keep feature-base parameters on low computational devices while leave the
parameters containing general information on the high computational devices.
|
[
-0.7779489159584045,
-0.9519907236099243,
0.6701092720031738,
0.1543291211128235,
-0.03530753776431084,
-0.16562819480895996,
-0.1957872062921524,
-0.1657697856426239,
0.505387008190155,
0.820597767829895,
-0.6058135032653809,
-0.1967264860868454,
-0.18874625861644745,
-0.094131238758564,
-0.13847430050373077,
0.667326033115387,
0.36366450786590576,
-0.2548712193965912,
-0.40626275539398193,
-0.36036622524261475,
-0.33518993854522705,
-0.5942372679710388,
-0.5743741393089294,
0.11872723698616028,
0.409058541059494,
0.4846128225326538,
0.7787389159202576,
0.3973759710788727,
0.03814687207341194,
0.3830591142177582,
-0.026912664994597435,
0.20897765457630157,
-0.5809841752052307,
0.34359490871429443,
-0.5350845456123352,
-0.43683820962905884,
-0.5858412384986877,
-0.46579137444496155,
0.3798256516456604,
0.7038253545761108,
-0.0048572043888270855,
0.18120001256465912,
0.006383107975125313,
0.4105575978755951,
-0.7923935055732727,
-0.6025770306587219,
-0.8481916189193726,
0.02700950764119625,
-0.18147525191307068,
-0.1928730607032776,
-0.455301970243454,
0.005485722329467535,
-0.04862871766090393,
-0.6323897838592529,
0.5807953476905823,
0.1747446060180664,
0.7328698039054871,
0.5699126720428467,
-0.22025786340236664,
0.06614109128713608,
-0.6518726348876953,
0.7539274096488953,
-0.5863960385322571,
0.6415584087371826,
0.36934757232666016,
0.16856522858142853,
-0.32996806502342224,
-0.8743549585342407,
-0.5102075338363647,
-0.0015451081562787294,
0.07323770970106125,
-0.20088838040828705,
-0.03251716122031212,
-0.03893043473362923,
0.3500511348247528,
0.04146130755543709,
-0.373060941696167,
0.22934436798095703,
0.0614890530705452,
-0.05291987583041191,
0.6277080774307251,
0.16250531375408173,
0.2086733877658844,
0.1331801563501358,
-0.18891409039497375,
0.6705960035324097,
-1.1635679006576538,
-0.19535614550113678,
-0.057214971631765366,
0.2984294593334198,
-0.32186055183410645,
0.569701075553894,
-0.26038259267807007,
0.6570920348167419,
0.409625768661499,
0.13184350728988647,
0.2825119197368622,
-0.605329155921936,
-0.2780762314796448,
-0.06181560829281807,
0.7389808893203735,
-0.09508644789457321,
-0.441731721162796,
-0.4792564809322357,
-0.0805896669626236,
-0.20302553474903107,
0.1767035871744156,
-0.9285310506820679,
-0.08862444758415222,
0.12284280359745026,
-0.17678865790367126,
0.0029906979762017727,
-0.15774597227573395,
-0.7834163308143616,
-0.6190006136894226,
0.027964849025011063,
0.3512527644634247,
-0.11427902430295944,
0.03261026740074158,
-0.021706784144043922,
0.13172216713428497,
-0.07935869693756104,
0.495528906583786,
-0.8662691116333008,
0.7618600726127625,
0.5026652812957764,
0.9113863706588745,
-0.14770260453224182,
-0.3028162717819214,
-1.0138635635375977,
0.5222302079200745,
0.070454902946949,
0.5863048434257507,
-0.1695767343044281,
-0.42416903376579285,
-0.43652966618537903,
0.12490729242563248,
-0.15564021468162537,
-0.31970489025115967,
0.2891462445259094,
-0.5761978030204773,
0.26736170053482056,
-0.41895759105682373,
-0.6445029377937317,
0.22598595917224884,
-0.2882039546966553,
-0.7137790322303772,
1.0152122974395752,
0.2711780071258545,
-0.9554901123046875,
0.12153156101703644,
-0.5664808750152588,
-0.5588184595108032,
0.37164440751075745,
-0.4880826771259308,
-0.4816499948501587,
0.15679365396499634,
0.1494041532278061,
0.5158706307411194,
-0.591429591178894,
0.25245967507362366,
-0.7373975515365601,
-0.5120190382003784,
0.36937588453292847,
0.09543117135763168,
0.6784877777099609,
0.42702358961105347,
-0.5296554565429688,
-0.13000822067260742,
-0.5876866579055786,
0.0327720120549202,
0.05271380394697189,
-0.27627795934677124,
-0.22320570051670074,
0.15955324470996857,
-0.2222352921962738,
0.1323995292186737,
0.5579462647438049,
-0.5518403053283691,
0.030069228261709213,
-0.22036010026931763,
0.617584764957428,
0.37812426686286926,
0.12521059811115265,
0.5332914590835571,
-0.06029818207025528,
0.43902724981307983,
-0.33485737442970276,
-0.05221611261367798,
0.10254829376935959,
-0.28832682967185974,
-0.8334672451019287,
-0.4969312250614166,
0.2945415675640106,
0.4832775592803955,
-0.8192359209060669,
0.8023815155029297,
-0.327851265668869,
-0.31179189682006836,
-0.34297555685043335,
0.5923354625701904,
0.39394959807395935,
0.4570046067237854,
0.26945117115974426,
-0.23641255497932434,
-0.46973225474357605,
-0.8417323231697083,
-0.12485020607709885,
0.17931489646434784,
-0.18993736803531647,
0.8061116933822632,
-0.04279351606965065,
-0.4340156614780426,
0.9446833729743958,
-0.2774445414543152,
0.05724620819091797,
-0.4557041823863983,
-0.1347457319498062,
-0.10796905308961868,
0.34615540504455566,
0.5927709937095642,
-0.5893418192863464,
-0.20866835117340088,
0.042666107416152954,
-0.5085293054580688,
-0.49957287311553955,
0.03801175579428673,
-0.1714818924665451,
0.18651528656482697,
0.5610146522521973,
-0.6698330044746399,
0.06826909631490707,
0.6984624862670898,
-0.5855095982551575,
0.031087152659893036,
-0.21752704679965973,
0.06590522825717926,
-1.1397374868392944,
-0.06629536300897598,
0.02304948680102825,
-0.4511764347553253,
-0.6876785159111023,
-0.15269140899181366,
-0.1037333682179451,
-0.2220899760723114,
-0.6231762766838074,
0.7244701981544495,
-0.314782053232193,
-0.5041604042053223,
-0.2751065492630005,
0.2423134446144104,
0.4876977801322937,
0.24194121360778809,
0.032930873334407806,
1.0004863739013672,
0.40907105803489685,
-0.8144834041595459,
0.20445583760738373,
0.1983398199081421,
0.11610981822013855,
0.24249084293842316,
-0.6488513946533203,
0.2950167953968048,
0.2487042397260666,
0.20130696892738342,
-0.5024376511573792,
-0.16738542914390564,
-0.21341288089752197,
-0.182992622256279,
-0.19303999841213226,
-0.12268701195716858,
-0.616916298866272,
0.04585188254714012,
-0.2917906641960144,
0.5383098125457764,
0.4574298560619354,
-0.6660140752792358,
0.9297846555709839,
0.6480462551116943,
-0.3216147720813751,
-0.06159112602472305,
-0.7359132766723633,
-0.005192975513637066,
-0.3200458288192749,
-0.841906726360321,
0.6915228366851807,
0.11240284889936447,
-0.14976243674755096,
0.204383984208107,
0.3354971706867218,
-0.15672938525676727,
0.26777201890945435,
0.4911659359931946,
0.10260175168514252,
-0.39068132638931274,
0.13199347257614136,
0.40633052587509155,
0.15462137758731842,
-0.4104764461517334,
0.22614285349845886,
0.5094977617263794,
-0.18882057070732117,
-0.28555285930633545,
-0.2637079060077667,
0.3056144416332245,
0.4387412667274475,
-0.1786290556192398,
0.7482609152793884,
0.5775147080421448,
-0.4131651818752289,
-0.525468647480011,
-0.7722027897834778,
-0.0393202044069767,
-0.607602596282959,
0.40214407444000244,
-0.730156421661377,
-1.2709546089172363,
0.4061839282512665,
-0.3612326979637146,
-0.21423639357089996,
0.3819406032562256,
0.7915534377098083,
-0.0007572377217002213,
0.7652885913848877,
0.5742810964584351,
-0.1351587176322937,
0.4339582026004791,
0.0505332425236702,
0.14758270978927612,
-0.7440332770347595,
0.005600938107818365,
-0.5295444130897522,
-0.1445721536874771,
-0.35381922125816345,
-0.550778329372406,
0.2904733121395111,
0.4480631351470947,
-0.5676390528678894,
0.4451539218425751,
-0.34229645133018494,
0.2675638198852539,
0.5031629204750061,
0.22032323479652405,
0.0728832259774208,
-0.004017811268568039,
0.11235514283180237,
-0.04870370402932167,
-0.8191496729850769,
-0.13013923168182373,
0.7263298630714417,
0.3885959982872009,
0.757527232170105,
0.36841899156570435,
0.7021004557609558,
0.4332079291343689,
-0.05043772980570793,
-0.35976776480674744,
0.7601608633995056,
-0.21564607322216034,
-0.30500683188438416,
-0.17034880816936493,
-0.5607772469520569,
-0.7800859212875366,
0.1495572328567505,
-0.19277448952198029,
-0.8762258887290955,
0.14005164802074432,
0.33296120166778564,
-0.6210599541664124,
0.010011831298470497,
-0.8950448036193848,
0.8235923647880554,
-0.5023059248924255,
-0.9429255127906799,
-0.2768493890762329,
-0.25022152066230774,
0.19116432964801788,
-0.02298010140657425,
0.1812916100025177,
-0.1604691445827484,
-0.4734492599964142,
0.6394553184509277,
-0.7423200607299805,
0.7289851903915405,
-0.37995731830596924,
0.2933291792869568,
0.5945324897766113,
0.26907503604888916,
0.4799777567386627,
0.28458279371261597,
-0.24114954471588135,
-0.025519778952002525,
-0.12851932644844055,
-0.3151281774044037,
-0.7406083345413208,
1.1680446863174438,
-0.8059055805206299,
-0.6208465099334717,
0.07091031223535538,
-0.38789230585098267,
-0.6175029277801514,
0.06839242577552795,
0.2976831793785095,
0.1510176956653595,
-0.1501678079366684,
0.17693552374839783,
0.6568726301193237,
-0.3433566093444824,
0.14538556337356567,
0.5057479739189148,
-0.17017346620559692,
-0.43435433506965637,
0.9455508589744568,
-0.0733167827129364,
0.24728257954120636,
0.09591956436634064,
0.19983506202697754,
-0.26889199018478394,
-0.318271666765213,
-0.8294527530670166,
0.2743786871433258,
-0.37945324182510376,
-0.09578732401132584,
-0.702881932258606,
-0.20875418186187744,
-0.36198094487190247,
-0.5593510866165161,
-0.6454111933708191,
-0.5489753484725952,
-0.6058259606361389,
0.02116210386157036,
0.6742986440658569,
0.42500486969947815,
0.2951757609844208,
0.5989826321601868,
-0.7518485188484192,
0.3730935752391815,
0.042799029499292374,
0.25450876355171204,
-0.3072276711463928,
-0.6241123676300049,
-0.5201271772384644,
-0.15441621840000153,
-0.24727065861225128,
-0.6910204291343689,
0.039992962032556534,
0.310533732175827,
0.4662292003631592,
0.3719658851623535,
-0.17898014187812805,
0.6241082549095154,
-0.3560877740383148,
0.8360573053359985,
0.16380536556243896,
-1.129017949104309,
0.41525471210479736,
-0.07408053427934647,
0.13797958195209503,
0.691154420375824,
0.027489349246025085,
-0.24522462487220764,
-0.10040581226348877,
-0.7491717338562012,
-0.674290657043457,
0.543691873550415,
0.023777630180120468,
0.06448466330766678,
0.23520903289318085,
0.5279600620269775,
0.020807139575481415,
0.1859765350818634,
-0.3976604640483856,
-0.11622501909732819,
-0.06470987945795059,
-0.26135414838790894,
0.019872251898050308,
-0.13354435563087463,
-0.1075439304113388,
-0.32134634256362915,
0.6213054656982422,
-0.07752899825572968,
0.276374489068985,
0.05558347329497337,
-0.13040050864219666,
0.03874099627137184,
0.1779790073633194,
0.3323972821235657,
0.42766058444976807,
0.15350626409053802,
0.341852068901062,
0.6531462073326111,
-0.1719946414232254,
-0.011533192358911037,
0.10876473784446716,
-0.42758798599243164,
-0.0037790059577673674,
-0.007626410108059645,
0.9438409805297852,
0.2935605049133301,
-0.6892388463020325,
0.5874987840652466,
-0.1108715757727623,
0.04439258575439453,
-0.1176668182015419,
0.4589053988456726,
0.4294393062591553,
0.2593209147453308,
-0.21534478664398193,
-0.022107847034931183,
0.18978653848171234,
-0.17224162817001343,
0.2997695207595825,
0.6622018218040466,
-0.11620183289051056,
-0.39763256907463074,
0.7117159366607666,
0.5047458410263062,
-0.3816632032394409,
0.06433094292879105,
-0.3658265769481659,
-0.29402732849121094,
0.3982076346874237,
0.6045110821723938,
0.8673001527786255,
-0.2614765763282776,
-0.0019074126612395048,
-0.04169763997197151,
0.011167401447892189,
0.07874532043933868,
0.4303213059902191,
-0.15289737284183502,
-0.804533839225769,
-0.30956438183784485,
-0.580380916595459,
-0.3565748929977417,
0.22847558557987213,
-0.14107809960842133,
0.6160275340080261,
-0.8378353714942932,
-0.29424095153808594,
-0.09646131843328476,
-0.0775657594203949,
-0.8229584097862244,
0.10062924027442932,
0.05872189998626709,
0.6487802863121033,
-0.7104711532592773,
1.0181593894958496,
0.5721889734268188,
0.03961411863565445,
-0.7558063268661499,
-0.4347990155220032,
-0.03507880121469498,
-0.502680242061615,
0.2926957309246063,
-0.04875694215297699,
-0.4057193100452423,
-0.040409717708826065,
-0.10932726413011551,
-0.8963285684585571,
1.243752360343933,
0.5629974603652954,
-0.554165244102478,
-0.04072554036974907,
0.16131925582885742,
0.5162960290908813,
-0.5920592546463013,
0.07492516189813614,
0.2454656958580017,
0.12922877073287964,
0.015301025472581387,
-0.8035615086555481,
0.41261807084083557,
-0.15946869552135468,
0.06956003606319427,
0.13744018971920013,
-0.6173965930938721,
0.8418178558349609,
-0.21629607677459717,
-0.016426023095846176,
0.017462903633713722,
0.6397019028663635,
0.34259194135665894,
0.457989364862442,
0.523033857345581,
0.7096237540245056,
0.6190468668937683,
0.424614816904068,
0.7792823314666748,
-0.5159783363342285,
0.2822175621986389,
1.3143600225448608,
-0.5778253674507141,
0.8511304259300232,
0.4951302409172058,
-0.15394002199172974,
0.3267577886581421,
0.4032605290412903,
-0.029906006529927254,
0.5645570755004883,
0.1464524120092392,
-0.7806466221809387,
-0.24340225756168365,
-0.1982831358909607,
-0.44469326734542847,
-0.042733512818813324,
0.5084231495857239,
-0.4416002929210663,
0.051802389323711395,
-0.1680060774087906,
-0.03971370682120323,
-0.07995474338531494,
-0.36723315715789795,
0.7900359630584717,
0.10884049534797668,
-0.5685845017433167,
0.4511467218399048,
0.4618862271308899,
0.6081284284591675,
-0.3156149387359619,
0.1809089034795761,
0.030009938403964043,
0.2048964649438858,
-0.42927294969558716,
-0.2972579896450043,
0.16609619557857513,
0.06273302435874939,
-0.019962457939982414,
0.19564762711524963,
1.046003818511963,
-0.22149479389190674,
-0.5173947215080261,
0.27737995982170105,
0.8075949549674988,
0.031172847375273705,
0.06527621299028397,
-0.6985429525375366,
0.35795727372169495,
-0.11243695020675659,
-0.5358699560165405,
0.5607903003692627,
0.5069596767425537,
-0.0010036457097157836,
0.6371232271194458,
0.407596230506897,
0.13919155299663544,
0.2955950200557709,
0.22609180212020874,
1.002570629119873,
-0.5281836986541748,
-0.6521122455596924,
-0.7434417605400085,
0.2256593257188797,
-0.04273861274123192,
-0.17564839124679565,
0.7192472219467163,
0.716748833656311,
0.4793182611465454,
0.13073772192001343,
0.919209361076355,
-0.22018234431743622,
0.5814028382301331,
-0.4470234215259552,
0.5371376872062683,
-0.5032411813735962,
0.48674407601356506,
0.06911969184875488,
-0.7821162343025208,
0.03960660099983215,
0.2960468828678131,
-0.2942568361759186,
-0.0281923096626997,
0.4754483699798584,
0.8453360795974731,
-0.4127182066440582,
0.2772389352321625,
0.3086187243461609,
-0.0284899715334177,
0.14763303101062775,
0.456254780292511,
0.3106670081615448,
-0.11642985045909882,
0.16057899594306946,
-0.45086586475372314,
-0.2285754680633545,
-0.3224997818470001,
-0.6515166163444519,
-0.9301382303237915,
-0.4961032569408417,
-0.34656643867492676,
-0.6238332390785217,
0.04975268244743347,
0.957584798336029,
0.567707896232605,
-0.5284650921821594,
-0.2007167637348175,
-0.35959675908088684,
-0.031062627211213112,
0.17125390470027924,
-0.1934530884027481,
0.3103252351284027,
-0.04875686392188072,
-0.37557223439216614,
0.5728853344917297,
0.17506301403045654,
-0.1625274419784546,
-0.3579510450363159,
-0.5442806482315063,
0.10103215277194977,
0.16243195533752441,
0.5327737331390381,
0.5462604761123657,
-0.5998314619064331,
-0.23778337240219116,
0.0049317991361021996,
-0.27760449051856995,
-0.11075670272111893,
1.016282081604004,
-0.8656308054924011,
0.036547835916280746,
0.4037182033061981,
1.1910886764526367,
0.6834939122200012,
0.20777148008346558,
0.3896784484386444,
-0.7177863717079163,
0.287948876619339,
0.217027947306633,
0.5606153011322021,
0.2812502384185791,
-0.706916332244873,
0.24224433302879333,
0.3170236051082611,
-0.6210992932319641,
-0.7916268706321716,
0.468331903219223,
-0.9695574641227722,
-0.08854895830154419,
1.1959360837936401,
-0.27033939957618713,
-0.29549792408943176,
-0.1878921240568161,
0.03696504235267639,
0.10769540071487427,
-0.2729211151599884,
0.4638051986694336,
0.18022188544273376,
-0.5243563652038574,
-0.40992268919944763,
-0.2979292571544647,
0.40021082758903503,
0.6918349266052246,
-0.972100019454956,
-0.0006305666174739599,
0.5613242387771606,
0.42822638154029846,
0.031247302889823914,
0.9336044788360596,
0.23436643183231354,
0.2899533808231354,
0.04170481860637665,
0.12546946108341217,
-0.221639484167099,
-0.2606876790523529,
-0.015478784218430519,
0.16629564762115479,
0.36557966470718384,
-0.058576975017786026
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07087v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07087v1
|
LSTM-Based Text Generation: A Study on Historical Datasets
| 2024-03-11T18:25:01 | 2024-03-11T18:25:01 |
Mustafa Abbas Hussein Hussein, Serkan Savaş
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper presents an exploration of Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM) networks
in the realm of text generation, focusing on the utilization of historical
datasets for Shakespeare and Nietzsche. LSTMs, known for their effectiveness in
handling sequential data, are applied here to model complex language patterns
and structures inherent in historical texts. The study demonstrates that
LSTM-based models, when trained on historical datasets, can not only generate
text that is linguistically rich and contextually relevant but also provide
insights into the evolution of language patterns over time. The finding
presents models that are highly accurate and efficient in predicting text from
works of Nietzsche, with low loss values and a training time of 100 iterations.
The accuracy of the model is 0.9521, indicating high accuracy. The loss of the
model is 0.2518, indicating its effectiveness. The accuracy of the model in
predicting text from the work of Shakespeare is 0.9125, indicating a low error
rate. The training time of the model is 100, mirroring the efficiency of the
Nietzsche dataset. This efficiency demonstrates the effectiveness of the model
design and training methodology, especially when handling complex literary
texts. This research contributes to the field of natural language processing by
showcasing the versatility of LSTM networks in text generation and offering a
pathway for future explorations in historical linguistics and beyond.
|
[
-0.09787318110466003,
-0.8457903265953064,
0.6811106204986572,
-0.10487730801105499,
-0.34528160095214844,
-0.20855307579040527,
-0.3482556939125061,
-0.41500017046928406,
0.2709115445613861,
0.8032808899879456,
-0.5446288585662842,
-0.409579336643219,
-0.23277883231639862,
0.1320463865995407,
-0.8762074112892151,
0.9920548796653748,
-0.14969821274280548,
-0.09701407700777054,
0.1982564777135849,
-0.15621212124824524,
-0.41730520129203796,
-0.5660110116004944,
-0.8171905279159546,
-0.627022922039032,
0.8816299438476562,
-0.07957850396633148,
0.7576091289520264,
0.6564647555351257,
0.24804815649986267,
0.20855222642421722,
-0.355739951133728,
0.20483721792697906,
-0.9175030589103699,
0.5306147336959839,
-0.43590229749679565,
-0.3290746510028839,
-0.10655125230550766,
-0.34634333848953247,
0.9807655811309814,
0.41984522342681885,
-0.05008601024746895,
-0.004004184622317553,
0.0747225359082222,
0.8860886693000793,
-0.16657082736492157,
-0.21703051030635834,
-0.6550342440605164,
0.4524868428707123,
-0.529509961605072,
-0.3411043584346771,
-0.6379390954971313,
-0.7201899886131287,
0.18900980055332184,
-0.33477911353111267,
0.17995445430278778,
0.17782647907733917,
0.6401812434196472,
-0.3417219817638397,
-0.3905365467071533,
-0.63673996925354,
-0.8615021705627441,
1.115746259689331,
-0.8001331686973572,
0.196094810962677,
0.1750144362449646,
0.22308453917503357,
-0.577005922794342,
-1.1012840270996094,
-0.44677844643592834,
-0.19624988734722137,
-0.10455393046140671,
0.06085970625281334,
-0.1562153846025467,
-0.15401019155979156,
0.16723383963108063,
0.3493185043334961,
-0.5488045811653137,
0.2725943922996521,
-0.4887104332447052,
-0.0018351563485339284,
0.41537967324256897,
0.29994699358940125,
0.3851917088031769,
-0.4536328911781311,
-0.46430233120918274,
0.04310522601008415,
-0.5273164510726929,
-0.04757660999894142,
0.23536519706249237,
0.49337038397789,
0.2103428989648819,
0.49079978466033936,
-0.008582026697695255,
0.6448228359222412,
-0.178798645734787,
-0.3692992925643921,
-0.009757813066244125,
-0.20139527320861816,
-0.10483185201883316,
0.3165000081062317,
0.9133208990097046,
0.20276513695716858,
0.6664540767669678,
-0.28952667117118835,
-0.257502019405365,
-0.04021570459008217,
0.37910744547843933,
-0.7374818921089172,
0.0039581130258738995,
-0.16356110572814941,
-0.7110441327095032,
-0.4293185770511627,
-0.2906799614429474,
-0.7041744589805603,
-0.18948256969451904,
-0.19078028202056885,
0.5429336428642273,
-0.7950755953788757,
0.07548242062330246,
0.1736106276512146,
-0.024321410804986954,
-0.05965445935726166,
0.07213732600212097,
-0.6264191269874573,
0.2730189263820648,
0.4609995186328888,
1.026081919670105,
-0.43886685371398926,
-0.2914831042289734,
-0.40469178557395935,
0.4568660259246826,
-0.4551087021827698,
0.28098148107528687,
-0.18813356757164001,
-0.3082151412963867,
0.3275917172431946,
-0.16754424571990967,
0.24497652053833008,
-0.14372816681861877,
1.0635921955108643,
-0.6204116940498352,
0.48068055510520935,
0.046903159469366074,
-0.8016358613967896,
-0.464558482170105,
0.0781964361667633,
-0.9838253855705261,
1.3547701835632324,
-0.21889062225818634,
-0.8413823843002319,
-0.059034962207078934,
-0.39014849066734314,
-0.463833749294281,
-0.11673008650541306,
-0.22082430124282837,
-0.5708534717559814,
0.2446124404668808,
-0.042583536356687546,
0.7215137481689453,
-0.46477577090263367,
0.7031428217887878,
-0.08084465563297272,
-0.4099177122116089,
0.34154507517814636,
-0.30691540241241455,
0.3689670264720917,
0.29701000452041626,
-0.44676825404167175,
-0.2759758532047272,
-0.8486415147781372,
0.08960497379302979,
0.2660329043865204,
-0.3713890612125397,
-0.6157641410827637,
0.4337612986564636,
0.10178523510694504,
0.1079496294260025,
0.14916187524795532,
-0.39544397592544556,
-0.06633074581623077,
-0.5977317690849304,
0.3348519206047058,
0.9364278316497803,
-0.02116883359849453,
0.1778043955564499,
-0.6175413727760315,
0.22469870746135712,
0.05412442237138748,
-0.34945592284202576,
-0.39709776639938354,
-0.252578467130661,
-0.7111903429031372,
0.25990137457847595,
0.1814323514699936,
0.3107127249240875,
-0.8568669557571411,
0.2525986433029175,
-0.5080678462982178,
-0.6037135720252991,
0.21912650763988495,
0.023694925010204315,
0.35175588726997375,
0.6596373319625854,
0.2792038023471832,
-0.48517850041389465,
-0.4862147867679596,
-0.9714062809944153,
-0.5816670060157776,
-0.0761742815375328,
0.32400357723236084,
0.13134081661701202,
0.41286391019821167,
-0.15898674726486206,
1.14934241771698,
-0.43216150999069214,
-0.05858880653977394,
-0.40193697810173035,
0.26056110858917236,
0.42148035764694214,
0.4104079604148865,
0.7416555881500244,
-0.5984963178634644,
-0.2576814591884613,
-0.10066242516040802,
-0.5670651197433472,
0.024706585332751274,
-0.17893418669700623,
-0.21529071033000946,
0.2903429865837097,
0.39531293511390686,
-0.08747617900371552,
0.2672121524810791,
0.3222771883010864,
-0.17816096544265747,
0.4394458532333374,
-0.0884471908211708,
0.02042827382683754,
-1.6496164798736572,
0.17120999097824097,
0.06943850964307785,
-0.49030929803848267,
-0.8941954374313354,
-0.43666720390319824,
-0.036575108766555786,
-0.16700710356235504,
-0.6145585775375366,
0.6095494031906128,
-0.37430885434150696,
0.146336629986763,
-0.363185852766037,
0.2066609263420105,
-0.36115190386772156,
0.5790170431137085,
0.12181715667247772,
0.35203489661216736,
0.2558087110519409,
-0.6563906073570251,
0.20115841925144196,
-0.03365246206521988,
-0.5426768660545349,
0.3751503527164459,
-0.33464720845222473,
0.10830214619636536,
-0.3585352599620819,
0.09142906963825226,
-0.7410153150558472,
-0.036063212901353836,
0.06852979958057404,
-0.030105769634246826,
0.22677980363368988,
0.2534533739089966,
-0.7046764492988586,
-0.21194374561309814,
-0.14119485020637512,
0.4389092028141022,
0.6694650650024414,
-0.4295141100883484,
0.615970253944397,
-0.030756056308746338,
-0.3532336950302124,
-0.5595642328262329,
-0.6967914700508118,
0.006280428729951382,
-0.5049571990966797,
-0.6036633849143982,
0.33638396859169006,
-0.05667600408196449,
-0.14371421933174133,
-0.06659814715385437,
0.11213484406471252,
-0.08067219704389572,
-0.041398853063583374,
0.1276445835828781,
-0.14767920970916748,
-0.32328081130981445,
0.5007734894752502,
0.10232414305210114,
0.04198792204260826,
-0.1601470410823822,
-0.34315600991249084,
0.6928390860557556,
0.11074118316173553,
0.015641450881958008,
-0.4139378070831299,
0.4577588140964508,
0.3000645935535431,
0.26698750257492065,
0.654536247253418,
0.4666183292865753,
-0.39346227049827576,
-0.618691086769104,
-0.42466700077056885,
-0.1353311836719513,
-0.4652068316936493,
0.47216296195983887,
-0.14873504638671875,
-1.0193780660629272,
0.4369424283504486,
-0.3040476441383362,
0.05116640403866768,
0.8012914061546326,
0.6208587288856506,
-0.2300916463136673,
0.33224883675575256,
0.5025427341461182,
-0.20394830405712128,
0.7773208022117615,
0.06495615839958191,
-0.1083584651350975,
-0.3534463942050934,
0.18394587934017181,
-0.3898283839225769,
-0.7450271248817444,
-0.6673967838287354,
-0.12558476626873016,
0.2031700164079666,
0.017429156228899956,
-0.3357958197593689,
0.09970427304506302,
-0.24089458584785461,
0.46580782532691956,
0.6610941886901855,
0.21154378354549408,
0.3143697679042816,
0.27307480573654175,
-0.21927031874656677,
-0.16359637677669525,
-0.5523793697357178,
-0.75753253698349,
1.1681928634643555,
0.2689681351184845,
0.832572877407074,
0.14077092707157135,
0.7022901773452759,
0.591479480266571,
-0.1359495222568512,
-0.5315801501274109,
0.6109214425086975,
-0.34855496883392334,
-0.4297434687614441,
-0.25898492336273193,
-0.4656091332435608,
-1.2045021057128906,
-0.09114227443933487,
-0.05094537511467934,
-0.5298430323600769,
-0.027579111978411674,
0.04567833989858627,
-0.2904854118824005,
0.5747112035751343,
-0.25587400794029236,
0.5717254281044006,
-0.4748976230621338,
-0.31996193528175354,
-0.31055504083633423,
-0.759474515914917,
0.2573242783546448,
-0.3215384781360626,
0.1180819571018219,
0.11518200486898422,
0.08805687725543976,
1.1327069997787476,
-0.1587507277727127,
1.0507234334945679,
0.344796746969223,
-0.20343711972236633,
0.3385985493659973,
0.31001999974250793,
0.6947683095932007,
-0.30794140696525574,
-0.3765806555747986,
-0.18440541625022888,
-0.11212144792079926,
-0.21915128827095032,
-0.21032455563545227,
0.7748475670814514,
-0.6961119174957275,
-0.08485378324985504,
-0.757941484451294,
-0.4766465723514557,
0.016906242817640305,
0.43501177430152893,
0.2191043198108673,
0.7814566493034363,
-0.5315352082252502,
0.31812188029289246,
0.6643807888031006,
-0.16572925448417664,
0.944699227809906,
0.32002508640289307,
-0.3519851863384247,
-0.6210644841194153,
0.5261649489402771,
0.3404114544391632,
0.24660634994506836,
0.4870193600654602,
0.18896879255771637,
0.00029865355463698506,
-0.6880759000778198,
-0.16323553025722504,
0.23186001181602478,
-0.6122570633888245,
-0.1507042646408081,
-0.34277376532554626,
-0.2978844940662384,
0.19593262672424316,
-0.0871608778834343,
-0.2096451371908188,
-0.4618363082408905,
-0.6433501839637756,
-0.08203763514757156,
0.675312876701355,
0.9260528683662415,
0.09669974446296692,
0.7035233974456787,
-0.787219762802124,
0.21078616380691528,
0.02031850442290306,
0.45184653997421265,
0.20295922458171844,
-0.25109684467315674,
-0.6356986165046692,
-0.03345220535993576,
-0.5427334904670715,
-1.1597384214401245,
0.5839630365371704,
0.4038732647895813,
0.2807755768299103,
0.16106247901916504,
-0.03995978459715843,
0.363076388835907,
-0.9558789134025574,
0.9939537644386292,
0.37937450408935547,
-0.7858831286430359,
0.49288296699523926,
-0.4823301136493683,
0.20471063256263733,
0.33889418840408325,
0.33164650201797485,
-0.9221180081367493,
-0.34809786081314087,
-0.5454359650611877,
-0.8201146721839905,
0.8978409171104431,
0.3224719762802124,
0.14131200313568115,
0.03589571639895439,
0.6841073036193848,
0.5655326247215271,
0.11978840827941895,
-1.0839426517486572,
-0.21667782962322235,
0.05364828184247017,
-0.3494729995727539,
-0.47261375188827515,
-0.46233880519866943,
0.09711893647909164,
0.047621481120586395,
0.731203556060791,
0.04873695224523544,
0.006679695099592209,
0.18375617265701294,
-0.3293212056159973,
-0.04993573948740959,
0.3790040612220764,
0.9095177054405212,
0.7619765400886536,
-0.05330782011151314,
0.10864627361297607,
0.1573517918586731,
-0.48016640543937683,
0.01571742072701454,
-0.13235366344451904,
-0.35152947902679443,
0.5357577204704285,
0.19962568581104279,
1.0450773239135742,
0.17869475483894348,
-0.5349218845367432,
0.08434315025806427,
0.13376522064208984,
0.006091455928981304,
-0.7482531070709229,
-0.0363687127828598,
0.1637212038040161,
0.4083227515220642,
0.5549516081809998,
-0.30852994322776794,
-0.14264461398124695,
-0.604235053062439,
0.16756859421730042,
0.13731248676776886,
-0.2881089746952057,
-0.18634644150733948,
0.47259554266929626,
0.02424541674554348,
-0.48949363827705383,
0.41749250888824463,
0.12925182282924652,
-0.3386467695236206,
0.31774917244911194,
0.6621081829071045,
0.9313398599624634,
-0.056774355471134186,
0.07926181703805923,
0.3676021099090576,
0.08564476668834686,
-0.3158893883228302,
0.3441089391708374,
0.16150376200675964,
-0.5501366853713989,
-0.3614179491996765,
-0.9357836246490479,
-0.1956566423177719,
0.2734159827232361,
-0.3001735508441925,
0.3355942368507385,
-0.17482790350914001,
-0.4151282012462616,
-0.38431575894355774,
-0.1422366052865982,
-0.3865019977092743,
0.40470483899116516,
0.054498717188835144,
0.66867595911026,
-0.5886554718017578,
0.8556289076805115,
0.17241248488426208,
-0.0658005103468895,
-0.466335654258728,
-0.02276083268225193,
-0.23867985606193542,
-0.5202831029891968,
0.7891666293144226,
-0.04844479635357857,
-0.19940784573554993,
0.1506432145833969,
-0.2983497679233551,
-0.8052448630332947,
1.183857798576355,
0.2636587917804718,
-0.782092809677124,
-0.32458245754241943,
0.2873813211917877,
0.7096408009529114,
-0.22492200136184692,
-0.0034360182471573353,
0.2743286192417145,
0.19571983814239502,
-0.035206809639930725,
-0.8239365220069885,
-0.045154426246881485,
-0.011062290519475937,
0.3454979956150055,
0.7759937047958374,
-0.4863036572933197,
0.9350734353065491,
0.30367064476013184,
-0.3992946743965149,
0.5775861144065857,
0.9727959632873535,
0.04227915033698082,
0.2514815330505371,
0.20288783311843872,
0.748140275478363,
0.6570612192153931,
-0.11934060603380203,
0.7795171141624451,
-0.22007979452610016,
0.3083076477050781,
1.0799319744110107,
-0.0005814473843201995,
0.8542728424072266,
0.5265610814094543,
0.21704062819480896,
0.7182652354240417,
0.6191506385803223,
0.20466084778308868,
0.5346464514732361,
0.5096513032913208,
-0.2601829469203949,
-0.03375352546572685,
-0.004263084381818771,
-0.6688106656074524,
0.0968935638666153,
0.0055399504490196705,
-1.0718885660171509,
-0.3473217487335205,
0.11704973876476288,
0.3186523914337158,
0.1339854896068573,
-0.6369855403900146,
0.9062437415122986,
0.3101605772972107,
-0.4600472152233124,
0.36777621507644653,
0.16176016628742218,
0.78554767370224,
-0.8162779808044434,
0.3251814544200897,
-0.008245248347520828,
0.32089707255363464,
0.09978139400482178,
-0.7515078783035278,
0.12727688252925873,
0.11867497116327286,
-0.30609390139579773,
-0.6788111925125122,
0.8543738126754761,
-0.48678138852119446,
-0.6797409057617188,
0.13992337882518768,
0.6734603047370911,
0.2192634493112564,
0.41612258553504944,
-0.2732585072517395,
-0.08335709571838379,
0.02690604329109192,
-0.3769259452819824,
0.0988229289650917,
0.6367539763450623,
-0.11619597673416138,
0.3045196533203125,
0.4307961165904999,
0.2925132215023041,
0.12804681062698364,
-0.08870146423578262,
0.48289141058921814,
-1.233469009399414,
-0.6700483560562134,
-1.1973111629486084,
0.36920562386512756,
0.026631126180291176,
-0.2967984676361084,
0.5921664237976074,
0.6163195371627808,
0.5662512183189392,
-0.1370050460100174,
0.660741925239563,
0.32195621728897095,
0.916533350944519,
-0.6851154565811157,
0.9799150228500366,
-0.5445486903190613,
-0.1975587010383606,
-0.21645934879779816,
-0.6785390973091125,
-0.12155015766620636,
0.259476900100708,
-0.23334093391895294,
0.10819118469953537,
0.6945366263389587,
0.31816571950912476,
-0.03933966904878616,
0.31805557012557983,
0.015942446887493134,
0.3915764093399048,
0.3157382011413574,
0.5550949573516846,
0.9287343621253967,
-0.2606585919857025,
0.4768364727497101,
-0.043837759643793106,
0.2842373251914978,
-0.23568350076675415,
-1.0842722654342651,
-0.8814031481742859,
-0.7011797428131104,
0.1271066665649414,
-0.3218115568161011,
0.3238619863986969,
0.7027094960212708,
-0.021031418815255165,
-0.47978538274765015,
-0.6279030442237854,
-0.143098384141922,
-0.06274019181728363,
-0.060724832117557526,
-0.18134525418281555,
0.6499512791633606,
-0.28747987747192383,
-0.7751929759979248,
0.30618536472320557,
0.0649942085146904,
0.24344149231910706,
-0.1992090493440628,
-0.13863679766654968,
-0.2522224187850952,
0.37467947602272034,
0.7693612575531006,
0.20693446695804596,
-0.6536403894424438,
-0.42593076825141907,
-0.16879412531852722,
-0.29355525970458984,
0.23094023764133453,
0.7357803583145142,
-0.9035852551460266,
0.501037061214447,
0.6313194036483765,
0.4448249042034149,
0.6372637152671814,
-0.26732394099235535,
0.8539188504219055,
-0.6357142925262451,
-0.041963934898376465,
0.5551037788391113,
0.43710261583328247,
0.19067886471748352,
0.043347202241420746,
0.4461238384246826,
0.1857989877462387,
-0.48602116107940674,
-0.881767988204956,
0.3751596510410309,
-1.0576224327087402,
-0.2987586259841919,
1.0299689769744873,
0.2724132239818573,
-0.2679363489151001,
0.18778817355632782,
-0.3781455159187317,
0.43371862173080444,
-0.32127904891967773,
0.6558273434638977,
0.9175358414649963,
-0.039379093796014786,
0.01214422844350338,
-0.5073350667953491,
0.6010123491287231,
0.4842100143432617,
-0.4950668215751648,
-0.3846587538719177,
0.5939273238182068,
-0.033880576491355896,
0.21799975633621216,
0.3564136326313019,
0.08714162558317184,
0.08589215576648712,
-0.607628583908081,
-0.036518681794404984,
0.1134900376200676,
-0.07531817257404327,
-0.18665063381195068,
0.6269609928131104,
-0.17925532162189484,
0.05941280722618103
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06970v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06970v1
|
MRL Parsing Without Tears: The Case of Hebrew
| 2024-03-11T17:54:33 | 2024-03-11T17:54:33 |
Shaltiel Shmidman, Avi Shmidman, Moshe Koppel, Reut Tsarfaty
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Syntactic parsing remains a critical tool for relation extraction and
information extraction, especially in resource-scarce languages where LLMs are
lacking. Yet in morphologically rich languages (MRLs), where parsers need to
identify multiple lexical units in each token, existing systems suffer in
latency and setup complexity. Some use a pipeline to peel away the layers:
first segmentation, then morphology tagging, and then syntax parsing; however,
errors in earlier layers are then propagated forward. Others use a joint
architecture to evaluate all permutations at once; while this improves
accuracy, it is notoriously slow. In contrast, and taking Hebrew as a test
case, we present a new "flipped pipeline": decisions are made directly on the
whole-token units by expert classifiers, each one dedicated to one specific
task. The classifiers are independent of one another, and only at the end do we
synthesize their predictions. This blazingly fast approach sets a new SOTA in
Hebrew POS tagging and dependency parsing, while also reaching near-SOTA
performance on other Hebrew NLP tasks. Because our architecture does not rely
on any language-specific resources, it can serve as a model to develop similar
parsers for other MRLs.
|
[
-0.07042203843593597,
-0.48715075850486755,
0.5066863298416138,
0.41032934188842773,
-0.4334528148174286,
0.2927367389202118,
0.06692823022603989,
-0.3748056888580322,
0.4343177378177643,
0.47315025329589844,
-0.46235737204551697,
-0.2883225381374359,
-0.6179791688919067,
0.035855624824762344,
-0.310827374458313,
1.0519354343414307,
0.13775084912776947,
0.2659558355808258,
0.03255685791373253,
-0.4186370074748993,
-0.06486853957176208,
-0.17861492931842804,
-0.6853088140487671,
-0.3689001500606537,
0.6968954801559448,
0.2997654676437378,
1.1287784576416016,
1.0585087537765503,
0.46956291794776917,
0.2980469763278961,
-0.17939640581607819,
0.06047401577234268,
0.08651049435138702,
0.35813549160957336,
-0.2337048202753067,
-0.584324300289154,
-0.36376774311065674,
-0.11047197878360748,
0.6008020639419556,
0.8350626230239868,
-0.1416422575712204,
0.5531620979309082,
-0.2739909887313843,
1.0338780879974365,
-0.9094395041465759,
-0.04810183495283127,
-0.768103837966919,
0.7097370028495789,
-0.6679345965385437,
-0.39788544178009033,
-0.48004812002182007,
-0.2860356569290161,
0.12493747472763062,
-0.26601505279541016,
0.22931857407093048,
0.09491153806447983,
0.8157854676246643,
0.4043407440185547,
0.04459533467888832,
-0.08053342998027802,
-0.47267499566078186,
0.7482726573944092,
-0.5317652225494385,
0.8053489327430725,
0.15121828019618988,
0.14729541540145874,
-0.011833331547677517,
-1.0053476095199585,
-0.3986286222934723,
-0.10940710455179214,
0.0703197494149208,
0.22031721472740173,
0.056150883436203,
-0.21282199025154114,
0.0865742564201355,
0.3531845808029175,
-0.7015531063079834,
-0.11122962087392807,
-0.2688807547092438,
-0.04788677766919136,
0.22920595109462738,
0.23220673203468323,
0.5465208292007446,
-0.43089568614959717,
-0.6004384756088257,
-0.006278721150010824,
-0.6689262390136719,
-0.10976198315620422,
0.3319445252418518,
0.4465656876564026,
0.06964059919118881,
0.7372007966041565,
0.1848827749490738,
0.5790846347808838,
-0.18621261417865753,
-0.23961412906646729,
0.3498173952102661,
-0.07347947359085083,
-0.5823838114738464,
0.3014885187149048,
0.8439455032348633,
-0.20133036375045776,
0.15204989910125732,
-0.1323973387479782,
-0.09864480793476105,
0.20276480913162231,
0.2897687554359436,
-0.4415103793144226,
-0.3248448967933655,
0.12768016755580902,
-0.6481349468231201,
-0.3862186074256897,
-0.12777245044708252,
-0.8727855682373047,
-0.48833638429641724,
-0.15510255098342896,
0.02437373250722885,
-0.5723186135292053,
-0.2791283428668976,
0.2096358835697174,
-0.20706555247306824,
0.25855544209480286,
0.14916379749774933,
-0.8117189407348633,
0.2630525529384613,
0.7352710366249084,
0.8739517331123352,
0.08219873160123825,
-0.6069499254226685,
-0.9032565951347351,
-0.03390013426542282,
-0.38039088249206543,
0.8229020237922668,
-0.8196308612823486,
0.14107169210910797,
-0.06811277568340302,
-0.5373552441596985,
-0.2629886865615845,
-0.7396246194839478,
0.44232481718063354,
-0.740231454372406,
0.014355774037539959,
-0.12554672360420227,
-0.14993546903133392,
0.07394510507583618,
0.07806945592164993,
-0.5582841634750366,
1.0318547487258911,
0.2221352905035019,
-0.9488351345062256,
0.38602370023727417,
-0.5727306008338928,
-0.43720051646232605,
0.2075868397951126,
-0.3410303592681885,
-0.2461397796869278,
0.2557539939880371,
0.002174774184823036,
0.18683429062366486,
-0.146663635969162,
0.32904863357543945,
-0.10288209468126297,
-0.01538864802569151,
0.0007788262446410954,
-0.23597338795661926,
0.998874306678772,
0.2843751013278961,
-0.3784705400466919,
0.3169960677623749,
-0.915874719619751,
0.06134038046002388,
0.3742132782936096,
-0.5578717589378357,
-0.15572382509708405,
0.10353046655654907,
0.01082802377641201,
0.3621814250946045,
0.06801003217697144,
-0.4143736958503723,
0.04286378249526024,
-0.578536331653595,
0.20029981434345245,
0.8327180743217468,
-0.55079585313797,
0.4496723711490631,
0.10331658273935318,
0.6536642909049988,
0.16213296353816986,
0.20617535710334778,
-0.12204170227050781,
-0.4326161742210388,
-1.2260249853134155,
-0.27027156949043274,
0.37321385741233826,
0.6587387919425964,
-0.7327811121940613,
0.38120537996292114,
-0.17746250331401825,
-0.41811656951904297,
-0.8504288196563721,
0.15230922400951385,
0.5951876044273376,
0.5285511612892151,
0.47913023829460144,
-0.5106119513511658,
-0.6901683807373047,
-0.8328664302825928,
-0.39701181650161743,
-0.32327932119369507,
0.1981649100780487,
-0.059043556451797485,
0.0436985157430172,
0.027360495179891586,
0.9067254662513733,
-0.35027652978897095,
-0.3527945280075073,
-0.7543558478355408,
-0.010713557712733746,
0.046615052968263626,
0.222499817609787,
0.10179229080677032,
-0.5870776772499084,
-0.5356650352478027,
0.07079046964645386,
-0.9221347570419312,
-0.13710765540599823,
-0.0464184433221817,
-0.02877056784927845,
0.17502214014530182,
0.6040297150611877,
-0.8089062571525574,
0.37460675835609436,
0.5757849216461182,
-0.5935176610946655,
0.6922388672828674,
-0.023269155994057655,
-0.4577100872993469,
-0.6108290553092957,
-0.01840633898973465,
-0.1280701756477356,
-0.3558122515678406,
-0.6113010048866272,
0.37764349579811096,
0.05781274288892746,
-0.08500343561172485,
-0.7759721875190735,
0.43999117612838745,
-0.35487833619117737,
-0.41409480571746826,
-0.00045467825839295983,
0.16637815535068512,
0.18915124237537384,
0.36544984579086304,
-0.1628713458776474,
0.770464301109314,
0.5533323884010315,
-0.17395174503326416,
0.21032750606536865,
0.3996439278125763,
-0.23085518181324005,
0.09557066112756729,
-0.33556199073791504,
0.05605583265423775,
-0.3442928194999695,
0.14820414781570435,
-0.515447735786438,
0.1289588361978531,
0.5767008662223816,
-0.21973468363285065,
0.4603251516819,
-0.2469463348388672,
-0.4832862913608551,
0.11619504541158676,
-0.3270761966705322,
0.424299418926239,
0.32044973969459534,
-0.4143487215042114,
0.9749637842178345,
0.24606452882289886,
-0.20590025186538696,
-0.8147972226142883,
-0.7255462408065796,
0.3036574721336365,
-0.1357416808605194,
-0.6976513862609863,
0.15186895430088043,
0.1890045702457428,
-0.3887758255004883,
0.19510316848754883,
-0.2684122622013092,
-0.14633387327194214,
0.01674371212720871,
0.10823699086904526,
0.24041058123111725,
-0.6442449688911438,
0.033044833689928055,
-0.15564703941345215,
-0.5110249519348145,
-0.2635708451271057,
-0.1968502700328827,
0.9450063109397888,
-0.42062023282051086,
-0.4803447127342224,
-0.49049219489097595,
0.45183536410331726,
0.6443212032318115,
-0.8044555187225342,
0.7142167687416077,
0.6598393321037292,
-0.0054406458511948586,
-0.039548393338918686,
-0.7086415886878967,
0.2867010831832886,
-0.46388134360313416,
0.3644007444381714,
-0.44657453894615173,
-0.607574999332428,
0.4954182803630829,
0.049260079860687256,
-0.11579219251871109,
0.4679015278816223,
0.3255040645599365,
0.08744330704212189,
0.5959956645965576,
0.4045904278755188,
-0.08434301614761353,
0.37147966027259827,
0.026839619502425194,
0.5798963308334351,
-0.7956505417823792,
-0.28213685750961304,
-0.5729841589927673,
-0.31663215160369873,
-0.2755239009857178,
-0.39647364616394043,
0.19482839107513428,
0.07668595016002655,
-0.021194271743297577,
0.2569834291934967,
-0.259127676486969,
0.7000387907028198,
0.7257791757583618,
-0.15666906535625458,
0.349399596452713,
0.0012588187819346786,
-0.2380516678094864,
-0.12472181022167206,
-0.7979373335838318,
-0.5952640175819397,
0.5731641054153442,
0.45355620980262756,
0.3707810640335083,
-0.07072260230779648,
0.744286298751831,
0.06303726136684418,
0.1573721170425415,
-0.9416128993034363,
0.7507954239845276,
-0.3965015411376953,
-0.3006021976470947,
-0.25007787346839905,
-0.3662409484386444,
-0.9920057654380798,
0.6313421130180359,
-0.04120922461152077,
-0.47838884592056274,
-0.08360705524682999,
-0.07962335646152496,
-0.5374731421470642,
0.6235648989677429,
-0.7904812693595886,
0.9223190546035767,
-0.12557533383369446,
-0.2603873908519745,
-0.022946514189243317,
-1.0288985967636108,
0.09142249822616577,
0.12848706543445587,
0.23860381543636322,
-0.2397722601890564,
-0.059301409870386124,
0.7484407424926758,
-0.40290191769599915,
0.5802373290061951,
-0.2018934041261673,
0.33377259969711304,
0.24072587490081787,
0.5036239624023438,
0.2571299374103546,
-0.30643177032470703,
0.00747809000313282,
0.05210199952125549,
-0.15212836861610413,
-0.4230448007583618,
-0.6325373649597168,
0.48015251755714417,
-0.5069494247436523,
-0.500106930732727,
-0.5124976634979248,
-0.4190903306007385,
-0.09797272831201553,
0.19285553693771362,
-0.1298399120569229,
0.422224760055542,
0.2601168751716614,
-0.210997074842453,
0.42585569620132446,
-0.29763033986091614,
0.493156373500824,
0.24202360212802887,
-0.3384265601634979,
-0.4286175072193146,
0.9678436517715454,
0.1430409699678421,
0.022537512704730034,
0.18186785280704498,
0.520249605178833,
-0.16097141802310944,
-0.698993444442749,
-0.8382423520088196,
0.3534316420555115,
-0.7241225838661194,
-0.2778482437133789,
-0.8779571652412415,
-0.3297433853149414,
-0.20407846570014954,
-0.06235453113913536,
-0.9598780274391174,
-0.41869819164276123,
-0.2284385710954666,
-0.22277972102165222,
-0.21613743901252747,
0.6759934425354004,
0.2306279093027115,
0.000535914150532335,
-1.1761647462844849,
0.3194426894187927,
0.15209080278873444,
0.4444550573825836,
0.06478860229253769,
-0.2795694172382355,
-0.04382656514644623,
-0.5683984160423279,
-0.353013813495636,
-0.7744873762130737,
0.4328823387622833,
0.16372978687286377,
0.12012141197919846,
0.4471319317817688,
-0.12540483474731445,
1.1007987260818481,
-0.9253756403923035,
0.7497493028640747,
0.4551723897457123,
-1.1004083156585693,
0.3890669345855713,
-0.013025877997279167,
0.07361607998609543,
0.6050325632095337,
0.22049082815647125,
-0.7027813792228699,
-0.5551069378852844,
-0.7744551301002502,
-1.1553590297698975,
0.7538864016532898,
0.09452301263809204,
0.16238488256931305,
-0.17903468012809753,
0.08533890545368195,
0.36358821392059326,
0.09355814009904861,
-0.797431468963623,
-0.48039379715919495,
-0.15686629712581635,
-0.17217886447906494,
0.2853921949863434,
-0.5138806104660034,
0.11259835213422775,
-0.21471092104911804,
0.5521775484085083,
0.17096567153930664,
-0.03955942019820213,
0.4435708224773407,
-0.2066085934638977,
-0.33109965920448303,
0.295917272567749,
0.40632376074790955,
0.7750790119171143,
-0.03164100646972656,
0.6862336993217468,
-0.03482791781425476,
-0.24009665846824646,
-0.060360878705978394,
-0.2634214162826538,
-0.037083949893713,
0.18185503780841827,
0.6157562732696533,
0.7729266881942749,
0.0916815921664238,
-0.8675917983055115,
0.5075680017471313,
0.16079209744930267,
0.060218166559934616,
-0.3252522945404053,
-0.13312889635562897,
0.2148812860250473,
0.619888961315155,
0.22232981026172638,
0.6247145533561707,
0.06164975091814995,
-0.5768121480941772,
0.2569015920162201,
0.21383768320083618,
-0.44707977771759033,
-0.4632311463356018,
0.29290568828582764,
-0.04985807090997696,
-0.5237259268760681,
0.6940413117408752,
-0.3217337131500244,
-0.6798326969146729,
0.11456076055765152,
0.5401633977890015,
0.905731201171875,
-0.3177984058856964,
0.29046833515167236,
-0.0467381551861763,
0.0631222054362297,
0.024484902620315552,
0.07235651463270187,
0.10764578729867935,
-0.9257664680480957,
-0.6882176995277405,
-1.0128600597381592,
-0.16872523725032806,
0.07691358029842377,
-0.5649498701095581,
0.08791492879390717,
-0.65849369764328,
0.1654406040906906,
0.03588336333632469,
-0.40401360392570496,
-0.5416942834854126,
0.12818849086761475,
0.2098049819469452,
0.9723597168922424,
-0.8894036412239075,
0.7285061478614807,
0.6715179681777954,
-0.36752834916114807,
-0.6486696600914001,
-0.06717580556869507,
-0.1297147125005722,
-1.1188312768936157,
0.928760826587677,
0.1276407092809677,
-0.2581292390823364,
-0.14274053275585175,
-0.005676968954503536,
-0.7370286583900452,
0.6976691484451294,
0.6312165260314941,
-0.2335873693227768,
-0.09137508273124695,
0.12354404479265213,
0.480598509311676,
-0.14505527913570404,
0.18323686718940735,
0.7042469382286072,
0.33564135432243347,
0.07300394028425217,
-0.8729178309440613,
0.002410630928352475,
-0.1410750150680542,
-0.1930057853460312,
0.49642759561538696,
-0.6961917877197266,
0.76988285779953,
-0.019002851098775864,
-0.3208998441696167,
-0.2369219809770584,
0.5995931029319763,
0.1667977273464203,
0.43567875027656555,
0.5839376449584961,
1.0560319423675537,
0.6204995512962341,
0.27341946959495544,
1.0167182683944702,
-0.01596924476325512,
0.11197062581777573,
1.1911451816558838,
-0.4197966754436493,
1.0402523279190063,
0.7615290284156799,
-0.4260351061820984,
0.542815625667572,
0.28960806131362915,
0.14978466928005219,
0.33501267433166504,
0.09685691446065903,
-0.37401312589645386,
-0.46509814262390137,
-0.5367791652679443,
-0.19060255587100983,
0.7067164778709412,
-0.03560236468911171,
-0.4975222945213318,
-0.532587468624115,
-0.3507143259048462,
0.2212095707654953,
0.08284846693277359,
-0.10307003557682037,
0.6301929354667664,
0.11916345357894897,
-0.5302097797393799,
0.26674631237983704,
0.08672221750020981,
0.2788495719432831,
-0.657782793045044,
0.15672028064727783,
-0.2126544713973999,
0.07030293345451355,
-0.41143256425857544,
-0.6150248646736145,
0.8553035855293274,
0.09460035711526871,
-0.10243086516857147,
-0.41989582777023315,
0.7595702409744263,
-0.10069718956947327,
-0.5011814832687378,
0.5213596820831299,
0.961145281791687,
0.28698065876960754,
0.010709935799241066,
-0.707176685333252,
0.26168766617774963,
0.14979004859924316,
-0.4738483428955078,
0.5666511058807373,
0.41153407096862793,
0.22141270339488983,
0.851355791091919,
0.6997746825218201,
0.41604483127593994,
0.45268335938453674,
0.40478312969207764,
1.0378731489181519,
-0.8635007739067078,
-0.07627978920936584,
-1.2578076124191284,
0.7033941745758057,
0.2379940003156662,
-0.22872628271579742,
0.4668302536010742,
0.6313977837562561,
0.7191404104232788,
-0.07134818285703659,
0.48628246784210205,
0.039916716516017914,
0.24371758103370667,
-0.527158260345459,
0.46283429861068726,
-0.5512757301330566,
-0.049039747565984726,
-0.09815410524606705,
-0.9648646116256714,
-0.8758425116539001,
0.7647585868835449,
-0.15799416601657867,
-0.3559098243713379,
0.9823066592216492,
0.4846113324165344,
-0.19673316180706024,
0.024877265095710754,
0.40959542989730835,
0.02821187861263752,
0.2460610419511795,
0.08756905794143677,
0.9830048680305481,
-0.22760111093521118,
0.6821025013923645,
-0.19696006178855896,
-0.06636075675487518,
0.09533809125423431,
-0.8128624558448792,
-0.7113601565361023,
-0.19246302545070648,
-0.3490566611289978,
-0.2729986310005188,
-0.0896216481924057,
1.2454431056976318,
0.4473322629928589,
-0.5934613347053528,
-0.15226896107196808,
-0.09414680302143097,
0.1483333557844162,
-0.04432374984025955,
-0.26757755875587463,
0.4264724552631378,
-0.915581226348877,
-0.3702344000339508,
0.7704050540924072,
0.9564259648323059,
-0.36526718735694885,
-0.029795439913868904,
0.08898194879293442,
-0.1490984559059143,
-0.17520365118980408,
0.6386198997497559,
-0.004790416453033686,
-0.8714360594749451,
-0.2170981466770172,
-0.3297707736492157,
0.05867229774594307,
0.6001231670379639,
0.8926331996917725,
-0.6188916563987732,
0.41396647691726685,
0.46565234661102295,
0.8630826473236084,
0.2960365116596222,
-0.16483651101589203,
0.23230332136154175,
-0.6769165396690369,
0.16255782544612885,
0.43521401286125183,
0.46952202916145325,
0.3295843005180359,
0.12987002730369568,
0.43657928705215454,
0.4166947603225708,
-0.3234125077724457,
-0.6496012806892395,
0.6212442517280579,
-0.9514496922492981,
-0.10678613185882568,
0.8194095492362976,
-0.3367820084095001,
-0.2507982850074768,
-0.3132571578025818,
-0.15393292903900146,
0.3961549997329712,
-0.2953870892524719,
0.6991493105888367,
0.5374817848205566,
-0.19459016621112823,
-0.19312798976898193,
-0.40071606636047363,
0.3388388156890869,
0.8819628953933716,
-0.3632824122905731,
0.23962974548339844,
0.1626749187707901,
0.1687876582145691,
0.5340913534164429,
0.6877411603927612,
-0.3554021120071411,
-0.16868554055690765,
0.10032285749912262,
0.01801929995417595,
-0.051516152918338776,
-0.6481828689575195,
-0.192380890250206,
0.6240516901016235,
0.32124075293540955,
-0.12340109795331955
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06965v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06965v1
|
Hybrid Human-LLM Corpus Construction and LLM Evaluation for Rare Linguistic Phenomena
| 2024-03-11T17:47:47 | 2024-03-11T17:47:47 |
Leonie Weissweiler, Abdullatif Köksal, Hinrich Schütze
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Argument Structure Constructions (ASCs) are one of the most well-studied
construction groups, providing a unique opportunity to demonstrate the
usefulness of Construction Grammar (CxG). For example, the caused-motion
construction (CMC, ``She sneezed the foam off her cappuccino'') demonstrates
that constructions must carry meaning, otherwise the fact that ``sneeze'' in
this context causes movement cannot be explained. We form the hypothesis that
this remains challenging even for state-of-the-art Large Language Models
(LLMs), for which we devise a test based on substituting the verb with a
prototypical motion verb. To be able to perform this test at statistically
significant scale, in the absence of adequate CxG corpora, we develop a novel
pipeline of NLP-assisted collection of linguistically annotated text. We show
how dependency parsing and GPT-3.5 can be used to significantly reduce
annotation cost and thus enable the annotation of rare phenomena at scale. We
then evaluate GPT, Gemini, Llama2 and Mistral models for their understanding of
the CMC using the newly collected corpus. We find that all models struggle with
understanding the motion component that the CMC adds to a sentence.
|
[
-0.2508658766746521,
-0.862687349319458,
0.5966838002204895,
0.08474138379096985,
-0.3568337559700012,
0.10184445232152939,
-0.18021546304225922,
-0.5196970105171204,
0.4738466441631317,
0.472901314496994,
-0.5216484069824219,
-0.5715004801750183,
-0.6993003487586975,
0.2285972684621811,
-0.762923002243042,
1.0915120840072632,
-0.08120738714933395,
-0.1010083258152008,
-0.1375643014907837,
-0.17013227939605713,
-0.07933246344327927,
-0.7813937067985535,
-0.31802454590797424,
-0.05707627162337303,
0.3153829574584961,
0.12520165741443634,
0.7719271779060364,
0.572853684425354,
0.41455256938934326,
0.2012302726507187,
-0.5081398487091064,
0.1271754950284958,
-0.03971511870622635,
-0.15752193331718445,
-0.07879851758480072,
-0.33307307958602905,
-0.3822447955608368,
0.05433046072721481,
0.7571455240249634,
1.1876744031906128,
-0.21469643712043762,
-0.020742425695061684,
0.04894951358437538,
0.4226975440979004,
-0.5582893490791321,
-0.09057704359292984,
-0.5500732660293579,
0.1250169426202774,
-0.3610513210296631,
-0.046640992164611816,
-0.22397707402706146,
0.10035552829504013,
-0.06734129041433334,
-0.1536819487810135,
0.3896610140800476,
-0.05765465274453163,
0.8061017394065857,
0.42438629269599915,
-0.37018513679504395,
-0.26798003911972046,
-0.4426439106464386,
0.3404892086982727,
-0.5596182346343994,
0.30317744612693787,
0.2509017884731293,
-0.17079713940620422,
-0.3726995885372162,
-0.6798157095909119,
-0.5362869501113892,
-0.7083749175071716,
0.052442681044340134,
0.08341004699468613,
-0.05696840584278107,
0.11358422040939331,
0.2856539189815521,
0.5200948715209961,
-0.7056625485420227,
0.275253027677536,
-0.3513859808444977,
-0.32564058899879456,
0.48915964365005493,
0.42425286769866943,
0.41828668117523193,
-0.5217615365982056,
-0.49535509943962097,
0.34542593359947205,
-0.8080030679702759,
-0.12288249284029007,
0.31917694211006165,
0.09073547273874283,
-0.24522164463996887,
0.7250924706459045,
-0.07944609224796295,
0.7636779546737671,
-0.12334658205509186,
0.23230302333831787,
0.18045195937156677,
-0.372496634721756,
0.012714097276329994,
-0.01827090047299862,
0.8658006191253662,
0.06927510350942612,
0.031197842210531235,
-0.10146798193454742,
-0.00741944182664156,
0.37776991724967957,
0.1861560046672821,
-0.39793944358825684,
-0.2297283262014389,
0.21560119092464447,
-0.41710495948791504,
-0.374636709690094,
-0.05243513733148575,
-0.4316613972187042,
-0.3037099242210388,
-0.2209727168083191,
0.02014859952032566,
-0.16952422261238098,
-0.3642202913761139,
0.2261250615119934,
-0.0009596762247383595,
0.0008285178919322789,
0.1592051386833191,
-0.8961418867111206,
0.2407218962907791,
0.7613860964775085,
0.8193022012710571,
-0.495606005191803,
-0.39665091037750244,
-0.5940226316452026,
-0.14566849172115326,
-0.24316953122615814,
1.3378419876098633,
-0.4652177095413208,
-0.46169501543045044,
0.02571168728172779,
0.012752548791468143,
-0.032921936362981796,
-0.7696406841278076,
0.579582154750824,
-0.08517888933420181,
0.18099181354045868,
0.15782730281352997,
-0.594368040561676,
-0.028035880997776985,
0.07549277693033218,
-0.4274507462978363,
0.984274685382843,
0.17082975804805756,
-0.8560370802879333,
0.2796555161476135,
-0.6934148073196411,
-0.5662071704864502,
0.07975446432828903,
-0.48148590326309204,
-0.2304888814687729,
0.26753664016723633,
-0.0650341585278511,
0.6829645037651062,
-0.37009257078170776,
0.4570746421813965,
-0.3273570239543915,
-0.12531942129135132,
0.27784502506256104,
-0.2344685047864914,
0.833690345287323,
0.05038747563958168,
-0.39480048418045044,
0.13333085179328918,
-0.983595609664917,
-0.4118693172931671,
0.0511007122695446,
-0.47664982080459595,
-0.10484027117490768,
0.11319521069526672,
0.11857596784830093,
0.14065997302532196,
0.06629420071840286,
-0.30180802941322327,
0.19393916428089142,
-0.4995763897895813,
0.2886151373386383,
0.46665701270103455,
0.023189205676317215,
0.0778917446732521,
-0.2021181732416153,
0.5763276815414429,
0.09830126166343689,
-0.09508707374334335,
-0.11690393835306168,
-0.8419816493988037,
-0.7152165174484253,
-0.3780580759048462,
0.051326390355825424,
0.47458091378211975,
-0.5340419411659241,
0.34758836030960083,
-0.09590653330087662,
-0.341301828622818,
-0.3948550820350647,
0.20808009803295135,
0.29409027099609375,
0.4718261659145355,
0.16810403764247894,
-0.11635254323482513,
-0.602346658706665,
-0.9318597912788391,
-0.38317692279815674,
-0.2883620858192444,
-0.24426130950450897,
-0.0676620826125145,
0.3698989748954773,
-0.34820443391799927,
0.7473756074905396,
-0.47704580426216125,
0.07581166923046112,
-0.4305950701236725,
0.46743834018707275,
0.047386061400175095,
0.21070218086242676,
0.4953054189682007,
-0.5277834534645081,
-0.01613316312432289,
-0.09280683845281601,
-0.6146461367607117,
-0.4758507013320923,
-0.13403233885765076,
0.18061894178390503,
0.38094374537467957,
0.7178299427032471,
-0.7129940986633301,
0.47799623012542725,
0.6389199495315552,
-0.6773474812507629,
0.8575344085693359,
-0.0760573223233223,
-0.10633186995983124,
-1.071393370628357,
-0.05588068813085556,
0.027322378009557724,
-0.2890227735042572,
-0.5200449824333191,
0.21750780940055847,
-0.021801123395562172,
-0.020015334710478783,
-0.7861226201057434,
0.32657432556152344,
-0.21107064187526703,
0.04884389415383339,
-0.5059483051300049,
0.2477426528930664,
-0.2575027048587799,
0.3563113212585449,
0.25131136178970337,
0.39327341318130493,
0.3428769111633301,
-0.614755392074585,
0.1493472158908844,
0.12447818368673325,
-0.1931747943162918,
0.23861926794052124,
-0.38647061586380005,
0.07530727982521057,
-0.07121643424034119,
0.10424324125051498,
-0.7432836294174194,
-0.27296051383018494,
0.22935369610786438,
-0.33916547894477844,
0.07385800033807755,
0.02869928628206253,
-0.6705304384231567,
-0.12277856469154358,
-0.22910170257091522,
0.21791541576385498,
0.2663576602935791,
-0.7143616676330566,
0.6861446499824524,
0.47946974635124207,
-0.0324883759021759,
-0.1836457997560501,
-0.6191524267196655,
0.3380797803401947,
-0.44050493836402893,
-0.7366209626197815,
0.2751181721687317,
-0.13313302397727966,
-0.543534517288208,
-0.17680293321609497,
-0.08249448984861374,
-0.0652739554643631,
0.433755099773407,
0.38741445541381836,
0.35804370045661926,
-0.32922273874282837,
0.0464591309428215,
-0.0956297293305397,
-0.10927663743495941,
0.23351500928401947,
0.09978833794593811,
0.4904862940311432,
-0.2491910606622696,
-0.39136961102485657,
-0.3890819549560547,
0.5384966135025024,
0.4346613883972168,
0.15736587345600128,
0.5511765480041504,
0.457197368144989,
-0.4728461802005768,
-0.06546805799007416,
-0.6171250939369202,
0.009810633957386017,
-0.3638682961463928,
0.39536434412002563,
-0.30849412083625793,
-1.1265445947647095,
0.47563689947128296,
-0.14657656848430634,
-0.11651039123535156,
0.6658965945243835,
0.7683522701263428,
-0.11938610672950745,
0.6190765500068665,
0.3860979676246643,
0.04330211132764816,
0.17177626490592957,
-0.05191992223262787,
0.15864358842372894,
-0.757594108581543,
0.03325989097356796,
-0.550974428653717,
0.03729448467493057,
-0.6429938077926636,
-0.4580903947353363,
0.28194206953048706,
0.057013966143131256,
0.1308707594871521,
0.5166878700256348,
-0.2567838132381439,
0.241346076130867,
0.313922256231308,
-0.08245807141065598,
0.4875827133655548,
-0.08537375926971436,
-0.24933700263500214,
0.06251125782728195,
-0.6669667363166809,
-0.7001199126243591,
0.8904246091842651,
0.34027549624443054,
0.34294673800468445,
0.1178576722741127,
0.613442599773407,
0.11108893901109695,
0.5274955034255981,
-0.933766782283783,
0.7204207181930542,
-0.3539641201496124,
-0.6647535562515259,
-0.01658191718161106,
-0.3814815580844879,
-0.930635392665863,
0.432241827249527,
-0.3487275242805481,
-0.891010046005249,
-0.1948210746049881,
0.09383691102266312,
-0.577792763710022,
0.17967885732650757,
-0.6328439116477966,
0.7659617066383362,
-0.1663466989994049,
-0.21686072647571564,
-0.31275707483291626,
-0.4190848469734192,
0.5785461068153381,
-0.19395555555820465,
0.3276030421257019,
-0.17382872104644775,
-0.14082247018814087,
0.6813833713531494,
-0.613712728023529,
0.9499213099479675,
0.2536323070526123,
-0.1896653026342392,
0.5986814498901367,
0.16115564107894897,
0.31373894214630127,
0.003205806715413928,
0.20164449512958527,
0.43258798122406006,
-0.14864811301231384,
-0.2805424928665161,
-0.5360137820243835,
0.5067721605300903,
-0.3909090757369995,
-0.8117357492446899,
-0.34270551800727844,
-0.40363913774490356,
-0.1422775834798813,
-0.3518450856208801,
0.26935508847236633,
0.18593017756938934,
-0.2833711802959442,
0.13169428706169128,
0.262346476316452,
-0.1377587914466858,
0.5976535677909851,
0.6301284432411194,
-0.1464238166809082,
-0.29062455892562866,
0.533584475517273,
-0.017151907086372375,
0.1623615026473999,
0.1654534786939621,
0.4174480438232422,
-0.157830610871315,
-0.7249252796173096,
-0.25190210342407227,
0.2691726088523865,
-0.5189879536628723,
0.010499628260731697,
-0.9259039759635925,
-0.23129932582378387,
-0.20912882685661316,
-0.1070697158575058,
-0.33798179030418396,
-0.6633384227752686,
-0.5014099478721619,
-0.2903340458869934,
0.24968957901000977,
0.7088080644607544,
-0.18102316558361053,
0.21248723566532135,
-0.9318579435348511,
0.37425968050956726,
0.14497849345207214,
0.04859456419944763,
-0.33460572361946106,
-0.6246267557144165,
-0.11213307082653046,
-0.24873776733875275,
-0.31936150789260864,
-0.7745664119720459,
0.288275808095932,
0.03529844060540199,
0.3613101541996002,
0.5084872841835022,
-0.083426833152771,
0.594531238079071,
-0.4893636107444763,
1.0573586225509644,
0.32038822770118713,
-0.9040541648864746,
0.5966854095458984,
-0.5269181728363037,
0.11468487977981567,
0.24758602678775787,
0.2572815716266632,
-0.41615206003189087,
-0.5553077459335327,
-0.97013258934021,
-0.965988039970398,
0.3018952012062073,
0.217351496219635,
-0.1838623285293579,
-0.4351939857006073,
0.4656020998954773,
0.037264008074998856,
-0.11470502614974976,
-0.6321030855178833,
-0.056105099618434906,
0.23399797081947327,
-0.14283591508865356,
0.0019238138338550925,
-0.4497799277305603,
0.01125186774879694,
-0.03637991100549698,
0.3220743238925934,
-0.07929372042417526,
-0.16313782334327698,
0.19112513959407806,
-0.17593388259410858,
0.09996800869703293,
0.21804971992969513,
0.7917177677154541,
0.20935547351837158,
-0.10723711550235748,
0.4078613817691803,
0.4353383779525757,
-0.47176700830459595,
0.13507626950740814,
0.08494517207145691,
0.027106862515211105,
0.1146782711148262,
0.5875340700149536,
0.6165867447853088,
0.5520949959754944,
-0.8691545724868774,
0.5479462146759033,
0.15929758548736572,
-0.3180735409259796,
-0.46840694546699524,
0.15392321348190308,
0.408687025308609,
0.1428353637456894,
0.05583302676677704,
0.11622984707355499,
0.23600925505161285,
-0.5692186951637268,
0.18867771327495575,
0.37596145272254944,
-0.13552570343017578,
-0.47565627098083496,
0.6951566934585571,
0.07505222409963608,
-0.37672194838523865,
0.4321940541267395,
-0.20143301784992218,
-0.44090554118156433,
0.5452073812484741,
0.38350313901901245,
0.942549467086792,
-0.15780483186244965,
0.05391747131943703,
0.17332813143730164,
0.24429914355278015,
-0.2886228859424591,
0.29495736956596375,
-0.012661580927670002,
-0.7764509320259094,
-0.5969486832618713,
-0.5227523446083069,
-0.3107122480869293,
0.12777602672576904,
-0.45775744318962097,
0.45609867572784424,
-0.45184922218322754,
-0.04388933256268501,
0.11514968425035477,
-0.2687491476535797,
-0.5507851839065552,
0.004208356607705355,
0.36952608823776245,
0.7088456153869629,
-1.0280280113220215,
0.6524869203567505,
0.8553388118743896,
-0.47148776054382324,
-0.6213684678077698,
0.18061396479606628,
0.18857009708881378,
-0.7122400403022766,
0.7061223983764648,
0.0016267432365566492,
-0.2149842530488968,
-0.367827832698822,
-0.43145209550857544,
-0.5772502422332764,
0.5798576474189758,
0.5188299417495728,
-0.4899812638759613,
0.13318447768688202,
0.20591963827610016,
0.6732660531997681,
-0.41431161761283875,
0.16994597017765045,
0.6419450044631958,
0.24889522790908813,
-0.004792668391019106,
-0.9938826560974121,
0.18430428206920624,
-0.0036173711996525526,
-0.10155431926250458,
0.06260257959365845,
-0.6250557899475098,
0.5594612956047058,
-0.319793701171875,
-0.3018101155757904,
0.10654377937316895,
0.6418224573135376,
0.5242146253585815,
0.3165036141872406,
0.6054937243461609,
0.6596981883049011,
0.7209169864654541,
0.24904818832874298,
1.0705410242080688,
-0.22920559346675873,
0.15188048779964447,
1.3053735494613647,
-0.11941605061292648,
1.1548986434936523,
0.4875134825706482,
-0.257606565952301,
0.38977137207984924,
0.6765574216842651,
0.26169058680534363,
0.05445016175508499,
0.5352051258087158,
-0.5441743731498718,
-0.4303465187549591,
-0.1904153823852539,
-0.14375878870487213,
0.7509626150131226,
0.5226022005081177,
-0.2795621454715729,
-0.18550007045269012,
-0.04099921137094498,
0.18020476400852203,
0.16998854279518127,
-0.16312243044376373,
0.6225346922874451,
0.3155927062034607,
-0.44110220670700073,
0.6513702869415283,
-0.20547860860824585,
0.6858296394348145,
-0.3026107847690582,
0.13230161368846893,
-0.22564515471458435,
-0.16579893231391907,
-0.318056583404541,
-0.512499988079071,
0.816089391708374,
0.29093581438064575,
0.045478325337171555,
0.00015810702461749315,
0.36510154604911804,
-0.2929624915122986,
-0.5978286862373352,
0.3540562689304352,
0.5811882615089417,
0.5652596354484558,
-0.21546991169452667,
-0.3337470293045044,
0.02375667728483677,
0.011976304464042187,
-0.26102977991104126,
0.4148138165473938,
0.4260876774787903,
-0.11674026399850845,
0.48944252729415894,
0.5852635502815247,
0.1961006075143814,
-0.01348091196268797,
0.3066444993019104,
0.8367037773132324,
-0.9449777603149414,
-0.25759419798851013,
-0.9220351576805115,
0.7264230251312256,
0.20789432525634766,
-0.31787794828414917,
0.4379649758338928,
0.5154480338096619,
0.5812734961509705,
-0.05356565862894058,
0.6472293734550476,
0.18847769498825073,
0.5740331411361694,
-0.6794171929359436,
0.6168875098228455,
-0.43304839730262756,
0.3899341821670532,
-0.23038512468338013,
-0.7785699963569641,
-0.7574647068977356,
0.5834334492683411,
-0.041912611573934555,
-0.4344155788421631,
1.1153645515441895,
0.7614237070083618,
0.07098203897476196,
0.16255609691143036,
0.49560195207595825,
0.2595895230770111,
0.11952922493219376,
0.47066065669059753,
1.1855542659759521,
-0.1974300891160965,
0.5592960715293884,
-0.01969021186232567,
-0.26012206077575684,
-0.2259649634361267,
-1.0945460796356201,
-1.0986645221710205,
-0.6195894479751587,
-0.9872883558273315,
-0.42722922563552856,
-0.2077207714319229,
1.2382149696350098,
0.45956388115882874,
-0.7596575021743774,
-0.18561893701553345,
-0.2120637744665146,
-0.057295020669698715,
-0.03303009644150734,
-0.18728910386562347,
0.503731906414032,
-0.28756189346313477,
-0.42223626375198364,
0.7561450600624084,
0.3627641499042511,
0.20126700401306152,
-0.22635959088802338,
0.3261716663837433,
-0.12385150790214539,
-0.273179292678833,
0.7607724666595459,
0.19605611264705658,
-0.9094420075416565,
-0.44093623757362366,
-0.23993942141532898,
0.22356103360652924,
0.09592394530773163,
0.940631628036499,
-0.6893866658210754,
0.05646994337439537,
0.3661704361438751,
0.6458225250244141,
0.32700687646865845,
-0.24662694334983826,
0.46613359451293945,
-0.5595384240150452,
0.28671973943710327,
0.21250125765800476,
0.7302255034446716,
0.33858051896095276,
-0.4641435742378235,
0.5614393353462219,
0.5598074197769165,
-0.25122201442718506,
-0.7412071228027344,
0.26256096363067627,
-0.9967803955078125,
-0.2405940443277359,
1.3922876119613647,
-0.14854177832603455,
-0.26383358240127563,
-0.292451947927475,
-0.25548145174980164,
0.13847820460796356,
-0.11556650698184967,
1.051024079322815,
0.7673412561416626,
-0.413131445646286,
-0.2205454707145691,
-0.42314237356185913,
0.3065294921398163,
0.6036543846130371,
-0.6823870539665222,
0.04841285198926926,
0.5367189645767212,
0.3830966651439667,
0.20121552050113678,
0.4916256368160248,
-0.09202403575181961,
0.06634041666984558,
0.09449867159128189,
0.17516307532787323,
0.1896783411502838,
-0.08861181885004044,
-0.5916441082954407,
0.41660887002944946,
0.13963589072227478,
-0.245966374874115
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06963v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06963v1
|
The pitfalls of next-token prediction
| 2024-03-11T17:47:30 | 2024-03-11T17:47:30 |
Gregor Bachmann, Vaishnavh Nagarajan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Can a mere next-token predictor faithfully model human intelligence? We
crystallize this intuitive concern, which is fragmented in the literature. As a
starting point, we argue that the two often-conflated phases of next-token
prediction -- autoregressive inference and teacher-forced training -- must be
treated distinctly. The popular criticism that errors can compound during
autoregressive inference, crucially assumes that teacher-forcing has learned an
accurate next-token predictor. This assumption sidesteps a more deep-rooted
problem we expose: in certain classes of tasks, teacher-forcing can simply fail
to learn an accurate next-token predictor in the first place. We describe a
general mechanism of how teacher-forcing can fail, and design a minimal
planning task where both the Transformer and the Mamba architecture empirically
fail in that manner -- remarkably, despite the task being straightforward to
learn. We provide preliminary evidence that this failure can be resolved when
training to predict multiple tokens in advance. We hope this finding can ground
future debates and inspire explorations beyond the next-token prediction
paradigm. We make our code available under
https://github.com/gregorbachmann/Next-Token-Failures
|
[
-0.3001418113708496,
-0.3195335566997528,
0.3602549433708191,
-0.1687779575586319,
-0.12936033308506012,
0.24134260416030884,
0.21763178706169128,
-0.16815046966075897,
0.0922527089715004,
0.29674193263053894,
-0.7977412939071655,
0.10875367373228073,
-0.805229663848877,
-0.11728744953870773,
-0.5912531018257141,
0.8131512403488159,
0.14991271495819092,
0.2570953071117401,
-0.4374614357948303,
0.018905600532889366,
-1.0186952352523804,
-0.6818383932113647,
-0.5407605171203613,
-0.6884937286376953,
0.5082009434700012,
0.96830153465271,
0.8095476031303406,
0.6528100371360779,
0.3374091386795044,
0.14230717718601227,
0.13181376457214355,
0.024488164111971855,
-0.22672784328460693,
-0.09178417176008224,
0.04256494343280792,
-0.7390614151954651,
-0.1200898215174675,
0.2586144208908081,
0.32784757018089294,
1.0067038536071777,
-0.057241618633270264,
0.09876713901758194,
-0.05936821550130844,
0.4894134998321533,
-0.6057736277580261,
0.07930425554513931,
-0.947462797164917,
0.3018227219581604,
0.026902077719569206,
0.25640517473220825,
-0.5906087160110474,
-0.15068158507347107,
0.04026272892951965,
-0.27569639682769775,
0.29245421290397644,
0.2283647507429123,
0.5973806977272034,
0.6812694668769836,
-0.5802934765815735,
-0.20680168271064758,
-0.7820343375205994,
0.5913283824920654,
-0.06506503373384476,
0.20398567616939545,
0.6881077885627747,
0.5628948211669922,
-0.21872298419475555,
-0.785077691078186,
-0.7927788496017456,
-0.16327248513698578,
-0.04101744666695595,
0.03821045532822609,
0.055994369089603424,
-0.12602044641971588,
0.3611671030521393,
-0.09019680321216583,
-0.2623897194862366,
0.07698866724967957,
-0.6898831725120544,
-0.1436895728111267,
0.09432598948478699,
0.3225623369216919,
0.048582784831523895,
-0.2806839346885681,
-0.5914108753204346,
-0.23382653295993805,
-0.7507979869842529,
0.11642704159021378,
0.5200760960578918,
0.22291409969329834,
0.10215786844491959,
0.5632448196411133,
0.2852621376514435,
0.340894877910614,
0.1200733557343483,
0.45451149344444275,
0.05267370864748955,
-0.09622295200824738,
-0.03319719433784485,
-0.04816094785928726,
0.4732822775840759,
0.19352534413337708,
0.22082549333572388,
-0.16246481239795685,
-0.343465656042099,
0.33259204030036926,
0.5136279463768005,
-0.5157681703567505,
-0.744024932384491,
0.11414580792188644,
-0.2625190317630768,
-0.5228855013847351,
0.07153359055519104,
-0.7036517262458801,
-0.4342988133430481,
-0.143077552318573,
0.49069344997406006,
-0.46329620480537415,
-0.040160443633794785,
-0.39964187145233154,
-0.155936136841774,
0.06331763416528702,
0.006787721998989582,
-0.938398003578186,
0.3846294581890106,
0.9197795987129211,
0.7760674953460693,
0.04702251777052879,
-1.0123858451843262,
-0.5770471096038818,
-0.07898234575986862,
-0.5189794301986694,
0.8628202676773071,
-0.4782946705818176,
-0.7627661824226379,
-0.13548749685287476,
-0.24303238093852997,
-0.2263181358575821,
-0.36577022075653076,
0.5496483445167542,
-0.2722640633583069,
0.08447723835706711,
-0.7223566174507141,
-0.5581941604614258,
-0.06328286975622177,
0.08719383180141449,
-0.5332602262496948,
0.6545307040214539,
0.08390390127897263,
-0.5382019281387329,
0.7748919725418091,
-0.4372783899307251,
-0.4904577434062958,
-0.2512809634208679,
-0.156541645526886,
-0.48441293835639954,
0.19396626949310303,
-0.06795928627252579,
0.27812492847442627,
-0.25990092754364014,
0.441128671169281,
-0.49116745591163635,
-0.5916562676429749,
0.3236924409866333,
-0.5834671854972839,
0.8225818872451782,
-0.06814179569482803,
-0.5479462742805481,
-0.1893712282180786,
-0.5138080716133118,
-0.30061349272727966,
0.15100717544555664,
0.13878333568572998,
0.23671796917915344,
0.3264118432998657,
-0.18695610761642456,
0.3941146731376648,
-0.008866400457918644,
-0.33662885427474976,
0.20568184554576874,
-0.2254941761493683,
0.3964436948299408,
1.1204814910888672,
-0.31347939372062683,
0.7726702690124512,
-0.5342541337013245,
0.48882153630256653,
-0.02623594179749489,
0.5591480731964111,
-0.38049593567848206,
-0.4887787401676178,
-0.572626531124115,
0.3321779668331146,
0.3797854483127594,
0.4615356922149658,
-0.5828374028205872,
0.11317628622055054,
-0.28926020860671997,
-0.7768141627311707,
-0.04760712385177612,
0.10352443903684616,
0.5685794949531555,
0.7549636960029602,
0.3778385818004608,
-0.43415567278862,
-0.7343015074729919,
-0.5498005151748657,
-0.5782991051673889,
-0.5016413331031799,
0.27846235036849976,
0.08166724443435669,
0.702455461025238,
-0.21109448373317719,
1.007422685623169,
-0.3096869885921478,
-0.3416082561016083,
0.034357987344264984,
0.4372784197330475,
-0.049876514822244644,
0.94793301820755,
0.5398066639900208,
-0.8700518608093262,
-0.11805447190999985,
-0.40402358770370483,
-0.2592073082923889,
0.3016762137413025,
-0.01789765991270542,
-0.1772325038909912,
0.23136867582798004,
0.45670363306999207,
-0.7987746000289917,
0.5728166699409485,
0.296419620513916,
-0.40438511967658997,
0.738399863243103,
0.051729727536439896,
-0.3555023670196533,
-0.750681459903717,
-0.13267949223518372,
-0.5149273872375488,
0.2161482274532318,
-0.5239573121070862,
-0.413152277469635,
-0.04204276204109192,
-0.06228167563676834,
-0.1610885113477707,
0.5777822136878967,
-0.2491048276424408,
-0.3082624077796936,
-0.3631218373775482,
-0.34932103753089905,
-0.14615578949451447,
0.6677250862121582,
-0.45557790994644165,
0.6072324514389038,
0.33475857973098755,
-0.5419352650642395,
0.23431672155857086,
0.5152327418327332,
-0.08360865712165833,
0.2527382969856262,
-0.5065162181854248,
0.36291012167930603,
-0.048379212617874146,
0.46267274022102356,
-1.05268394947052,
-0.5710734128952026,
0.3164089620113373,
-0.8754248023033142,
0.30465933680534363,
-0.25202372670173645,
-0.6055551171302795,
-0.7369768023490906,
-0.08868607133626938,
0.3282988965511322,
0.7727741599082947,
-0.721057116985321,
0.8001479506492615,
0.20944038033485413,
0.27271929383277893,
-0.9136421084403992,
-1.0166192054748535,
0.1795814335346222,
0.10067707300186157,
0.08254985511302948,
0.12631525099277496,
0.007961626164615154,
0.02931911312043667,
0.32210761308670044,
-0.21621565520763397,
-0.10154062509536743,
0.40439072251319885,
0.7867034673690796,
0.4518270790576935,
0.22248537838459015,
0.15094146132469177,
-0.0864928737282753,
-0.433537095785141,
0.5114468336105347,
-0.5572066903114319,
0.42478689551353455,
0.050126027315855026,
-0.9747371077537537,
-0.3795439898967743,
0.13246668875217438,
0.7631586790084839,
0.06515201926231384,
0.6665816307067871,
0.5193251371383667,
-0.40991777181625366,
0.04052523896098137,
-0.5322596430778503,
-0.4052380323410034,
-0.3806357979774475,
0.3783048093318939,
-0.35754621028900146,
-0.09496095776557922,
0.40566080808639526,
-0.02337050437927246,
0.2934112250804901,
0.43926578760147095,
0.17785347998142242,
-0.1816478967666626,
1.220299243927002,
0.7296817898750305,
-0.13228529691696167,
0.4978499412536621,
-0.4213581681251526,
0.1329658180475235,
-0.3905170261859894,
-0.5059614777565002,
-0.43262794613838196,
-0.4159777760505676,
-0.33356401324272156,
-0.06738819926977158,
0.04156164824962616,
-0.17772066593170166,
-0.6017560958862305,
0.08284760266542435,
-0.34744468331336975,
0.5348089337348938,
0.8439223170280457,
-0.2551689147949219,
-0.23029209673404694,
-0.007529793307185173,
-0.17645183205604553,
0.08539900928735733,
-1.0197972059249878,
-0.3103354871273041,
1.2184568643569946,
0.04366247355937958,
0.30256035923957825,
-0.13931973278522491,
0.588854193687439,
0.04270287975668907,
0.5237244963645935,
-0.5505826473236084,
0.367415189743042,
-0.065566785633564,
-0.81363844871521,
-0.1438279002904892,
-0.14460080862045288,
-0.6347412467002869,
0.12372065335512161,
-0.15895789861679077,
-0.457316517829895,
0.46498915553092957,
0.4173377454280853,
-0.3216674029827118,
0.5845996737480164,
-1.0508099794387817,
0.9660547971725464,
-0.22025685012340546,
-0.1956453025341034,
-0.04470064491033554,
-0.9602800607681274,
0.42386534810066223,
-0.21850250661373138,
0.30068597197532654,
-0.18102522194385529,
-0.11798253655433655,
0.6226025819778442,
-0.6124359965324402,
1.247113823890686,
-0.6239553093910217,
0.5211259126663208,
0.4523024559020996,
0.2165648192167282,
0.7259277701377869,
-0.25830909609794617,
-0.03910558670759201,
-0.31435513496398926,
-0.20549584925174713,
-0.8459550738334656,
-0.8047327995300293,
0.23820576071739197,
-1.0059572458267212,
-0.5967817902565002,
-0.34115272760391235,
-0.32577067613601685,
-0.3474630117416382,
0.12697511911392212,
0.6380209922790527,
0.5184407234191895,
0.04086590185761452,
-0.1988164782524109,
0.09127252548933029,
0.5957872867584229,
0.7282648682594299,
-0.16927000880241394,
-0.06320938467979431,
-0.7131091952323914,
0.9823583960533142,
0.38549116253852844,
0.20728321373462677,
-0.13504499197006226,
0.19167755544185638,
-0.22595074772834778,
-0.6075745224952698,
-0.29513439536094666,
-0.08136492222547531,
-0.9881715178489685,
-0.3055453300476074,
-0.5858569741249084,
0.1007358729839325,
-0.31008055806159973,
-0.3257450461387634,
-0.4407837390899658,
-0.29728078842163086,
-0.6132786870002747,
-0.2643067538738251,
0.06434924900531769,
1.068812608718872,
-0.13055187463760376,
0.3619220554828644,
-0.6750532984733582,
-0.17350588738918304,
0.36406955122947693,
0.10192365944385529,
0.29318463802337646,
-0.6147540807723999,
-0.21901659667491913,
-0.0801122710108757,
-0.3559187650680542,
-0.8206831812858582,
0.07893793284893036,
0.06843734532594681,
0.4305957555770874,
0.4651569426059723,
0.16664659976959229,
0.7967849373817444,
-0.5832003951072693,
0.7244402766227722,
0.47351691126823425,
-0.9047380089759827,
0.4273064136505127,
0.0919843539595604,
0.13792645931243896,
0.772900402545929,
0.3510819375514984,
-0.3225417137145996,
-0.4138912260532379,
-1.1795408725738525,
-0.8584117889404297,
0.6848676800727844,
-0.13344058394432068,
0.471536785364151,
-0.06304659694433212,
0.6671711802482605,
0.5186141729354858,
0.2812339961528778,
-0.7312073707580566,
-0.3552132248878479,
-0.5440491437911987,
-0.021934334188699722,
-0.3446597158908844,
-0.6623656749725342,
0.1379687637090683,
-0.3534926772117615,
0.6725949645042419,
-0.32688549160957336,
0.2971903383731842,
0.09324976801872253,
-0.042323999106884,
-0.14479227364063263,
-0.30334076285362244,
0.5856470465660095,
0.6539236307144165,
0.2244981974363327,
0.25346899032592773,
0.6509020924568176,
-0.48654675483703613,
0.334976464509964,
0.00879584439098835,
0.04217926785349846,
0.035524237900972366,
0.6068477034568787,
0.7273106575012207,
0.3598024249076843,
-0.5180532932281494,
0.6809856295585632,
-0.0025650865864008665,
-0.4297277629375458,
-0.8431203961372375,
-0.029054803773760796,
-0.20893731713294983,
0.22421160340309143,
0.6898696422576904,
0.910430371761322,
-0.25332143902778625,
-0.607998251914978,
0.2655860483646393,
0.2653389871120453,
-0.6524807214736938,
-0.5693933963775635,
0.8136167526245117,
0.0007764870533719659,
-0.45942017436027527,
0.4859199821949005,
-0.4882313311100006,
-0.8929205536842346,
0.815585196018219,
0.36343175172805786,
0.8377882838249207,
-0.20421727001667023,
-0.01521427370607853,
0.1761382818222046,
0.4013708233833313,
-0.20064528286457062,
0.06420332938432693,
-0.12911821901798248,
-0.6235112547874451,
-0.502793550491333,
-0.0278495941311121,
-0.7679742574691772,
-0.40321770310401917,
-0.37575849890708923,
0.39637359976768494,
-0.6804131269454956,
-0.2117518037557602,
-0.35696467757225037,
0.11667022854089737,
-0.5457692742347717,
0.2450646162033081,
0.00635981559753418,
0.8779715895652771,
-0.8356215357780457,
0.7041769027709961,
0.8599398732185364,
-0.2862265110015869,
-1.0704387426376343,
0.1904497593641281,
0.008572704158723354,
-0.8253675699234009,
0.8840586543083191,
0.1821526139974594,
-0.09580686688423157,
-0.15481026470661163,
-0.4908604323863983,
-0.903214156627655,
1.1540528535842896,
0.41456538438796997,
-0.37633344531059265,
-0.3524843454360962,
-0.14623293280601501,
0.05668455734848976,
-0.22768144309520721,
0.28393158316612244,
0.4460602402687073,
0.47564440965652466,
0.3857116103172302,
-0.525227963924408,
0.007936151698231697,
-0.028065841645002365,
-0.29174676537513733,
0.17841045558452606,
-0.7133886814117432,
1.1743121147155762,
-0.6917855739593506,
-0.06358299404382706,
0.046066392213106155,
0.8299657702445984,
-0.24277810752391815,
0.5814017653465271,
0.802829921245575,
0.4343770742416382,
0.9669195413589478,
-0.082317054271698,
1.059023380279541,
-0.3204044997692108,
0.2038174420595169,
1.0651741027832031,
-0.12168274074792862,
0.7326647639274597,
0.32356342673301697,
-0.167955219745636,
0.4680519104003906,
0.7535954117774963,
-0.2714562714099884,
0.5965186357498169,
-0.11461784690618515,
-0.04061560705304146,
-0.17780020833015442,
0.2049696296453476,
-0.09095080196857452,
0.726406455039978,
0.0958501473069191,
0.032589588314294815,
0.11066135764122009,
0.17769283056259155,
-0.045383863151073456,
-0.11863203346729279,
-0.23681846261024475,
0.41552284359931946,
0.07007495313882828,
-0.981743574142456,
0.3339182734489441,
-0.39579537510871887,
0.4317534863948822,
0.12012218683958054,
0.1296900063753128,
-0.08081083744764328,
0.01925390399992466,
-0.14613427221775055,
-0.3705218434333801,
0.46707016229629517,
-0.2797938585281372,
-0.031809721142053604,
-0.1301855444908142,
0.7811422348022461,
0.11961887776851654,
-0.3885739743709564,
0.16311036050319672,
0.6338608264923096,
-0.10843653231859207,
0.11845840513706207,
-0.5769884586334229,
-0.2661866843700409,
-0.031243083998560905,
-0.09799844026565552,
0.2197689414024353,
0.5101008415222168,
0.3124587833881378,
0.7429571747779846,
0.6790897250175476,
-0.11898777633905411,
0.2184440642595291,
-0.3144422173500061,
0.829131543636322,
-0.7715487480163574,
-0.5055423974990845,
-1.0889478921890259,
0.2531874477863312,
0.1752423495054245,
-0.49235033988952637,
0.18641246855258942,
0.27739232778549194,
0.8298477530479431,
0.22915798425674438,
0.6940180659294128,
0.30918750166893005,
0.34499967098236084,
-0.3095802068710327,
0.5567726492881775,
-0.502105712890625,
0.1871972680091858,
0.11761380732059479,
-0.4780883193016052,
-0.14744316041469574,
0.05830203741788864,
-0.46412646770477295,
0.12229032814502716,
0.8771765232086182,
0.22588379681110382,
0.1995176374912262,
0.32405057549476624,
0.27997249364852905,
0.03711150586605072,
0.1745188981294632,
0.6147382855415344,
1.0823301076889038,
-0.35555535554885864,
1.0989731550216675,
-0.5364758968353271,
0.22237445414066315,
-0.4673454165458679,
-0.5073822736740112,
-1.0687239170074463,
-0.8371703624725342,
-0.1410149484872818,
-0.4415825605392456,
0.10814987868070602,
1.0238457918167114,
0.6417253613471985,
-0.4853781759738922,
0.15834276378154755,
-0.7242965698242188,
0.463334321975708,
-0.10447300225496292,
-0.07386327534914017,
0.16445887088775635,
-0.6814942955970764,
-0.7265064120292664,
0.00020793158910237253,
-0.27957451343536377,
0.3734513521194458,
-0.24323926866054535,
-0.06288733333349228,
0.27020886540412903,
-0.07519449293613434,
0.1639213114976883,
0.4141119718551636,
-0.8183221220970154,
-0.44022002816200256,
-0.16673119366168976,
-0.10393207520246506,
0.016583887860178947,
0.9497033357620239,
-1.1004267930984497,
0.17070141434669495,
-0.03768237680196762,
0.7579380869865417,
0.19754482805728912,
-0.3600466847419739,
0.6128458380699158,
-0.40500709414482117,
0.02234102599322796,
0.40315690636634827,
0.45205599069595337,
0.17490704357624054,
-0.36847415566444397,
0.4036802649497986,
0.6787794232368469,
-0.5104780197143555,
-1.2047092914581299,
0.44462358951568604,
-0.2566799223423004,
-0.2892671227455139,
0.6918559074401855,
-0.010101872496306896,
-0.5364000797271729,
-0.19083841145038605,
-0.00768930884078145,
0.2789512872695923,
-0.18085066974163055,
0.8347294926643372,
0.8509796261787415,
-0.17544880509376526,
-0.005982307251542807,
-0.8041400909423828,
0.5834548473358154,
0.857100248336792,
-0.14775346219539642,
-0.016631782054901123,
0.2774001657962799,
0.036711979657411575,
0.26166006922721863,
0.4271737039089203,
0.37427830696105957,
0.7481333613395691,
0.6943169236183167,
-0.08959966897964478,
-0.42423632740974426,
-0.4494929909706116,
-0.27620989084243774,
0.32133111357688904,
0.23746612668037415,
-0.42114385962486267
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13835v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13835v1
|
SMART: Automatically Scaling Down Language Models with Accuracy Guarantees for Reduced Processing Fees
| 2024-03-11T17:45:47 | 2024-03-11T17:45:47 |
Saehan Jo, Immanuel Trummer
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.DB
|
The advancement of Large Language Models (LLMs) has significantly boosted
performance in natural language processing (NLP) tasks. However, the deployment
of high-performance LLMs incurs substantial costs, primarily due to the
increased number of parameters aimed at enhancing model performance. This has
made the use of state-of-the-art LLMs more expensive for end-users. AI service
providers, such as OpenAI and Anthropic, often offer multiple versions of LLMs
with varying prices and performance. However, end-users still face challenges
in choosing the appropriate LLM for their tasks that balance result quality
with cost.
We introduce SMART, Scaling Models Adaptively for Reduced Token Fees, a novel
LLM framework designed to minimize the inference costs of NLP tasks while
ensuring sufficient result quality. It enables users to specify an accuracy
constraint in terms of the equivalence of outputs to those of the most powerful
LLM. SMART then generates results that deviate from the outputs of this LLM
only with a probability below a user-defined threshold. SMART employs a
profiling phase that evaluates the performance of multiple LLMs to identify
those that meet the user-defined accuracy level. SMART optimizes the tradeoff
between profiling overheads and the anticipated cost savings resulting from
profiling. Moreover, our approach significantly reduces inference costs by
strategically leveraging a mix of LLMs. Our experiments on three real-world
datasets show that, based on OpenAI models, SMART achieves significant cost
savings, up to 25.6x in comparison to GPT-4.
|
[
-0.12325914949178696,
-0.5364590287208557,
0.29939204454421997,
0.14383578300476074,
0.02757592871785164,
-0.021677710115909576,
-0.2879301905632019,
-0.6736013293266296,
0.0886121317744255,
0.8954863548278809,
-0.43748143315315247,
-0.19668897986412048,
-0.42886435985565186,
0.012553579173982143,
-0.2626369595527649,
0.894633412361145,
0.25179749727249146,
-0.05150147154927254,
-0.15903031826019287,
-0.3696170449256897,
-0.32293999195098877,
-0.33877214789390564,
-0.911006510257721,
-0.40430957078933716,
0.4010753035545349,
0.3377994894981384,
1.0783008337020874,
1.136295199394226,
0.6975088715553284,
0.3625887930393219,
-0.021046336740255356,
0.3159101605415344,
-0.26918837428092957,
0.10343191027641296,
-0.32021477818489075,
-0.8707574009895325,
-0.901276707649231,
0.07479894161224365,
0.5173903703689575,
0.5899716019630432,
-0.1269875317811966,
0.3723088502883911,
-0.19962477684020996,
0.9201581478118896,
-0.6813226938247681,
0.07977095991373062,
-0.8967896699905396,
-0.16996057331562042,
-0.3102226257324219,
-0.04411711171269417,
-0.3734702467918396,
-0.2956686019897461,
-0.02022634632885456,
-0.5516599416732788,
0.26643478870391846,
0.021836061030626297,
0.9640080332756042,
0.5961513519287109,
0.023720480501651764,
-0.11268673092126846,
-0.7151365280151367,
0.9921739101409912,
-0.9689982533454895,
0.1536460816860199,
0.37798091769218445,
0.27116110920906067,
-0.09853901714086533,
-0.810124933719635,
-0.5287454724311829,
-0.013192586600780487,
-0.014166491106152534,
-0.1331365406513214,
-0.1729390174150467,
0.11192575097084045,
0.2575022578239441,
0.38712573051452637,
-0.43255820870399475,
0.42366915941238403,
-0.1446024775505066,
-0.22172223031520844,
0.7366277575492859,
0.23236289620399475,
0.007028356194496155,
0.049072735011577606,
-0.04693825915455818,
0.10351202636957169,
-0.5012449026107788,
-0.04407019540667534,
0.5601687431335449,
0.5768086910247803,
0.09059792757034302,
0.5071359872817993,
-0.35726648569107056,
0.607205867767334,
0.09089723974466324,
-0.42636021971702576,
0.21014872193336487,
-0.5403997898101807,
-0.21494856476783752,
-0.12534233927726746,
0.6604746580123901,
0.33058881759643555,
0.5420811176300049,
-0.1526661366224289,
-0.42736440896987915,
-0.046740129590034485,
0.24548490345478058,
-0.9555097818374634,
-0.25259101390838623,
0.41421329975128174,
-0.26621535420417786,
-0.2403450608253479,
-0.48941823840141296,
-0.6404895782470703,
-0.374383807182312,
-0.40371084213256836,
0.38765671849250793,
-0.19626015424728394,
-0.01516642700880766,
0.08393976837396622,
0.1917072832584381,
-0.08094286173582077,
0.33567699790000916,
-1.1043626070022583,
0.48164284229278564,
0.6965957283973694,
1.060471534729004,
-0.08443078398704529,
-0.09859935194253922,
-0.762776792049408,
0.11380885541439056,
-0.3211372494697571,
0.6764453053474426,
-0.3585413694381714,
-0.053969502449035645,
-0.2930883467197418,
-0.3481222987174988,
-0.042588647454977036,
-0.8463934063911438,
0.5719583630561829,
-0.5625548362731934,
0.14137139916419983,
-0.10996314883232117,
-0.5679460167884827,
-0.04771421104669571,
0.23497968912124634,
-0.7627189755439758,
1.0640095472335815,
0.060544393956661224,
-0.7341360449790955,
0.49549251794815063,
-0.7640938758850098,
-0.35170555114746094,
0.4137590229511261,
0.10587867349386215,
-0.5951907634735107,
0.05002092197537422,
0.4386540353298187,
0.48148953914642334,
-0.42523327469825745,
0.41915810108184814,
-0.16853147745132446,
-0.3365424573421478,
-0.08271528780460358,
-0.3559352159500122,
0.7530964612960815,
0.27436622977256775,
-0.3401978611946106,
0.5520017743110657,
-0.9212648272514343,
-0.0031731980852782726,
0.15880286693572998,
-0.45243561267852783,
-0.30638977885246277,
0.2548314332962036,
-0.03595352917909622,
0.04598487541079521,
0.43160533905029297,
-0.48564568161964417,
0.07816132158041,
-0.6006290316581726,
0.5280923247337341,
0.8387979865074158,
-0.6214194297790527,
0.5069460868835449,
-0.3197263479232788,
0.34661155939102173,
-0.29337504506111145,
0.46420663595199585,
-0.001959150657057762,
-0.5203322768211365,
-0.8002398014068604,
-0.861620306968689,
0.4045315384864807,
0.6416017413139343,
-0.49184831976890564,
0.46167075634002686,
-0.5078722834587097,
-0.47741031646728516,
-0.8845804333686829,
0.3351511061191559,
0.15243278443813324,
0.6995101571083069,
0.35517987608909607,
-0.17466580867767334,
-0.25441503524780273,
-0.9323075413703918,
-0.5895991921424866,
-0.2950717508792877,
-0.29550305008888245,
0.2440493255853653,
0.2580651044845581,
-0.15864704549312592,
1.2379356622695923,
-0.25025367736816406,
-0.49065089225769043,
-0.3073924779891968,
0.09699312597513199,
0.3086259961128235,
0.37721389532089233,
0.43860265612602234,
-1.0570732355117798,
-0.3829382061958313,
-0.02579500898718834,
-0.20701974630355835,
-0.32772302627563477,
-0.2424010932445526,
0.16958658397197723,
0.3655179440975189,
0.40446844696998596,
-0.6200048327445984,
0.33042824268341064,
0.700169026851654,
-0.32222020626068115,
0.6085512042045593,
-0.4852104187011719,
-0.2802402377128601,
-0.9785495400428772,
0.28184470534324646,
-0.004302691202610731,
-0.45155060291290283,
-0.5500413775444031,
0.17989709973335266,
0.09981769323348999,
0.05677449330687523,
-0.3504050672054291,
0.7465413212776184,
-0.03423554077744484,
-0.18191243708133698,
-0.25190794467926025,
0.0800420269370079,
0.2511826157569885,
0.5639207363128662,
-0.1717751920223236,
0.8885627388954163,
0.3380763828754425,
-0.5330702662467957,
0.32296428084373474,
-0.08077652752399445,
-0.12284039705991745,
0.4456770718097687,
-0.7072166204452515,
0.05947970598936081,
0.03549925982952118,
0.22170870006084442,
-0.6124914288520813,
-0.2144695371389389,
0.042168039828538895,
-0.197816401720047,
0.19017848372459412,
-0.11668040603399277,
-0.7943946719169617,
-0.06101373955607414,
-0.44870755076408386,
0.23849554359912872,
0.39802736043930054,
-0.5397580862045288,
0.969660758972168,
0.30857962369918823,
-0.27519842982292175,
-0.5337884426116943,
-0.8863773941993713,
0.25228351354599,
-0.1546694040298462,
-0.578131377696991,
0.5086343288421631,
-0.07336810976266861,
-0.359937459230423,
0.0742986723780632,
0.03751382604241371,
0.06937632709741592,
0.28409343957901,
0.034284807741642,
0.1540803611278534,
-0.16321061551570892,
0.20007003843784332,
-0.1910184919834137,
-0.290815144777298,
-0.18505391478538513,
-0.6596674919128418,
0.42124855518341064,
-0.17765182256698608,
-0.2609074115753174,
-0.5446511507034302,
0.17839494347572327,
0.8888888955116272,
-0.5675471425056458,
0.9867988228797913,
0.6660533547401428,
-0.46786609292030334,
-0.13964365422725677,
-0.6771783828735352,
-0.04416622593998909,
-0.5469823479652405,
0.5405039191246033,
-0.3249949812889099,
-0.7475935220718384,
0.7852517366409302,
-0.029635822400450706,
0.6690290570259094,
0.44931039214134216,
0.6490983963012695,
0.2593759596347809,
1.2953450679779053,
0.7645896673202515,
-0.24576517939567566,
0.5315455794334412,
0.22565026581287384,
0.5422054529190063,
-0.4837763011455536,
-0.18980059027671814,
-0.6607288718223572,
-0.3470945656299591,
-0.8578545451164246,
-0.5733556151390076,
0.24189375340938568,
0.12865903973579407,
-0.3011544346809387,
0.03480801358819008,
-0.5570245981216431,
0.5462263226509094,
0.8374683260917664,
-0.07119821757078171,
0.5723118185997009,
-0.06671059131622314,
0.26324042677879333,
0.050710007548332214,
-0.8034948110580444,
-0.6161401867866516,
1.194252371788025,
0.4901207387447357,
0.5521820187568665,
0.3396930992603302,
0.34178364276885986,
0.33376479148864746,
0.47610729932785034,
-0.9163690209388733,
0.6094037890434265,
-0.4330615699291229,
-0.5030704140663147,
-0.5711315274238586,
-0.7943419218063354,
-0.6936609745025635,
0.16517780721187592,
-0.07444072514772415,
-0.715995728969574,
-0.0697050616145134,
0.39194220304489136,
-0.3861241638660431,
0.6212688088417053,
-0.6178637146949768,
0.5157628059387207,
-0.29291659593582153,
-0.42612898349761963,
-0.27213090658187866,
-0.5387495756149292,
0.19221638143062592,
-0.4288516938686371,
0.267630934715271,
-0.3646283447742462,
-0.2644161283969879,
0.7494069933891296,
-0.6438260078430176,
0.6285035014152527,
-0.035370416939258575,
0.12280021607875824,
0.10944801568984985,
0.10015156865119934,
0.6823140978813171,
-0.018698962405323982,
-0.5122193098068237,
0.16920754313468933,
-0.13668201863765717,
-0.6450955271720886,
-0.5125226378440857,
0.755283772945404,
-0.5588189363479614,
-0.5007123351097107,
-0.06544015556573868,
-0.9480671286582947,
-0.15455064177513123,
0.32179275155067444,
0.05854582041501999,
0.2824822962284088,
0.42510098218917847,
-0.040486760437488556,
0.6404401659965515,
-0.2500532567501068,
0.4768042266368866,
0.44234174489974976,
-0.1215062215924263,
-0.23641161620616913,
0.9328039884567261,
0.2007913887500763,
0.5169930458068848,
0.3088296055793762,
0.6380367875099182,
-0.34953367710113525,
-0.8353987336158752,
-0.39973628520965576,
0.25693279504776,
-0.6464490294456482,
-0.26747414469718933,
-0.752037525177002,
0.08528366684913635,
-0.5587238073348999,
-0.19377067685127258,
-0.7048136591911316,
-0.5140827894210815,
-0.28185275197029114,
-0.06937283277511597,
0.6158088445663452,
0.2760334610939026,
-0.04975983873009682,
0.31542983651161194,
-0.5733163952827454,
0.1930370330810547,
0.36593514680862427,
0.5146324634552002,
-0.12975507974624634,
-0.6410661935806274,
-0.3491641581058502,
-0.14520405232906342,
-0.09755142033100128,
-0.19279438257217407,
0.5798556804656982,
0.5159355998039246,
0.100159652531147,
0.32265186309814453,
0.27538353204727173,
0.6419116854667664,
-0.4164038300514221,
0.7264900207519531,
0.06635472178459167,
-1.115056037902832,
0.31695371866226196,
-0.310671865940094,
0.4617259204387665,
0.6421506404876709,
0.04558577388525009,
-0.33818820118904114,
-0.34098219871520996,
-0.4018486738204956,
-1.1691975593566895,
0.6372373700141907,
-0.07878362387418747,
0.1674368679523468,
0.19209709763526917,
0.6152693629264832,
-0.06411129236221313,
0.03360382467508316,
-0.6762193441390991,
-0.05773130804300308,
0.017189258709549904,
-0.5128568410873413,
-0.00829548854380846,
-0.11647212505340576,
-0.052068453282117844,
-0.21067997813224792,
0.8181077241897583,
-0.6029105186462402,
-0.02909846231341362,
-0.03003743290901184,
0.04678715392947197,
-0.07057750970125198,
0.02900591492652893,
0.43276289105415344,
0.6036444902420044,
-0.27972137928009033,
0.09100809693336487,
0.229638010263443,
-0.45859506726264954,
-0.261335551738739,
-0.012113405391573906,
-0.3357658386230469,
-0.04823847487568855,
0.30564039945602417,
0.7274700403213501,
-0.023620275780558586,
-1.0563372373580933,
0.3798471689224243,
-0.1407003551721573,
-0.15289776027202606,
-0.06417762488126755,
0.16854430735111237,
0.25134044885635376,
0.3250647783279419,
0.2801200747489929,
0.26519519090652466,
0.08304738998413086,
-0.3331212103366852,
0.10027946531772614,
0.34971749782562256,
-0.24914498627185822,
-0.21228857338428497,
0.8134340643882751,
0.30416783690452576,
-0.6092250943183899,
0.8239480257034302,
-0.030674807727336884,
-0.43436703085899353,
0.5029832720756531,
0.229651540517807,
0.7951782941818237,
-0.13000410795211792,
0.06247580423951149,
0.04483809322118759,
0.31735366582870483,
-0.2471693754196167,
0.2623940706253052,
0.1398131549358368,
-0.6862667202949524,
-0.8331592082977295,
-0.7543227076530457,
-0.6120116114616394,
0.10094144940376282,
-0.5870115756988525,
0.14956073462963104,
-0.6488886475563049,
-0.33657267689704895,
-0.04560916870832443,
0.2503165006637573,
-0.6836196184158325,
0.24478384852409363,
0.12189769744873047,
0.9038276672363281,
-0.5467263460159302,
0.7845474481582642,
0.36328190565109253,
-0.01640487089753151,
-0.7491917014122009,
-0.17658790946006775,
-0.08556795865297318,
-0.5739587545394897,
0.4710807800292969,
0.2190958708524704,
-0.21375668048858643,
0.09819638729095459,
-0.38382774591445923,
-0.8143967390060425,
0.9211904406547546,
0.7962076663970947,
-0.6293877363204956,
-0.07013911753892899,
0.2733006477355957,
0.526423454284668,
-0.08628057688474655,
0.20288951694965363,
0.6357921361923218,
0.4813348352909088,
-0.1413072645664215,
-1.0083725452423096,
0.05454052612185478,
-0.0029631992802023888,
-0.20842863619327545,
0.2782924771308899,
-0.6548528671264648,
0.9678646922111511,
-0.3495323359966278,
-0.13835614919662476,
-0.001406962750479579,
0.5812737345695496,
0.2304631620645523,
0.28649312257766724,
0.4107086956501007,
0.4420015215873718,
1.0690953731536865,
-0.010861409828066826,
1.0554417371749878,
-0.38489723205566406,
0.29019516706466675,
0.9845997095108032,
-0.45156851410865784,
0.7371346354484558,
0.6095536351203918,
-0.10744800418615341,
0.198629230260849,
0.5987191200256348,
0.04829011484980583,
0.21551045775413513,
0.3335844576358795,
-0.21325115859508514,
-0.18633735179901123,
-0.42142412066459656,
0.2759993374347687,
0.3583272397518158,
0.17958799004554749,
-0.20934748649597168,
0.05868902429938316,
-0.3044172525405884,
0.15985721349716187,
0.2320539951324463,
-0.4616836607456207,
0.5260114073753357,
-0.1269625574350357,
-0.484782874584198,
0.26854822039604187,
0.33861875534057617,
0.9552441835403442,
-0.7886485457420349,
0.3025383949279785,
-0.38569197058677673,
0.49496468901634216,
-0.287297785282135,
-0.19749264419078827,
0.4622834324836731,
0.10339467972517014,
-0.3141849935054779,
-0.48913440108299255,
0.5329630374908447,
-0.24477195739746094,
-0.7644842863082886,
0.2769707441329956,
0.36395683884620667,
0.04705610126256943,
-0.2698918879032135,
-0.8293235898017883,
-0.14077426493167877,
-0.1522337794303894,
-0.4957277178764343,
0.46244460344314575,
0.2385084331035614,
-0.33091068267822266,
0.9839507937431335,
0.8484314680099487,
0.47649863362312317,
0.08789299428462982,
0.21842236816883087,
0.5948573350906372,
-0.34102863073349,
-0.6054213643074036,
-0.9312138557434082,
0.2915266156196594,
-0.0837530568242073,
-0.3226369321346283,
0.47920602560043335,
0.3199586570262909,
0.8460904359817505,
0.34150058031082153,
0.5384510159492493,
0.28945982456207275,
0.49172520637512207,
-0.47665441036224365,
0.7328043580055237,
-0.572880208492279,
0.45429882407188416,
-0.009810686111450195,
-0.7393754720687866,
-0.6219645738601685,
0.35762786865234375,
-0.29274681210517883,
-0.054650042206048965,
0.14119209349155426,
0.9410027265548706,
0.09787922352552414,
-0.1567627489566803,
0.3247178792953491,
-0.15697018802165985,
0.6801927089691162,
0.16967810690402985,
0.11339189112186432,
-0.24372385442256927,
0.37182551622390747,
-0.24301907420158386,
-0.2591160833835602,
-0.21580757200717926,
-1.0199792385101318,
-0.6443229913711548,
-0.07496456056833267,
-0.5966924428939819,
-0.1450974941253662,
-0.028685033321380615,
0.927169919013977,
0.9677169919013977,
-0.8357589840888977,
-0.1120719313621521,
-0.12854959070682526,
0.08562878519296646,
-0.44168004393577576,
-0.2684745490550995,
0.5824893712997437,
-0.41441234946250916,
-0.9121798276901245,
0.2796241343021393,
0.42623379826545715,
-0.1866794228553772,
-0.3174770772457123,
-0.07471814006567001,
-0.06995049118995667,
0.5591496229171753,
0.3767338693141937,
0.22356252372264862,
-0.6528028845787048,
-0.26180312037467957,
-0.0660172775387764,
-0.0956304594874382,
0.08196436613798141,
0.7198675870895386,
-0.7960459589958191,
0.43634217977523804,
0.5007949471473694,
0.9396372437477112,
0.2148713618516922,
-0.12818193435668945,
0.5154269337654114,
-0.721699595451355,
0.14665980637073517,
0.41872113943099976,
0.15364214777946472,
0.6390910148620605,
-0.4803244471549988,
0.4683043360710144,
0.2201491743326187,
-0.5461479425430298,
-0.9660833477973938,
0.3028263747692108,
-0.5563896894454956,
-0.29597988724708557,
0.7789404988288879,
-0.17846623063087463,
-0.10897707939147949,
-0.15012037754058838,
0.22500133514404297,
0.18484105169773102,
-0.19298528134822845,
0.7175711393356323,
0.41107410192489624,
-0.23843346536159515,
0.008049976080656052,
-0.6239981651306152,
0.4589579701423645,
0.8472545742988586,
-0.7058823108673096,
0.2863124907016754,
0.1866149604320526,
0.21990293264389038,
0.1843017339706421,
0.39961183071136475,
-0.06302014738321304,
-0.14456675946712494,
-0.1524486094713211,
0.28224778175354004,
-0.2753296494483948,
-0.20290303230285645,
-0.3276400566101074,
0.26751309633255005,
0.09421682357788086,
-0.12360405176877975
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06952v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06952v1
|
SELMA: Learning and Merging Skill-Specific Text-to-Image Experts with Auto-Generated Data
| 2024-03-11T17:35:33 | 2024-03-11T17:35:33 |
Jialu Li, Jaemin Cho, Yi-Lin Sung, Jaehong Yoon, Mohit Bansal
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Recent text-to-image (T2I) generation models have demonstrated impressive
capabilities in creating images from text descriptions. However, these T2I
generation models often fall short of generating images that precisely match
the details of the text inputs, such as incorrect spatial relationship or
missing objects. In this paper, we introduce SELMA: Skill-Specific Expert
Learning and Merging with Auto-Generated Data, a novel paradigm to improve the
faithfulness of T2I models by fine-tuning models on automatically generated,
multi-skill image-text datasets, with skill-specific expert learning and
merging. First, SELMA leverages an LLM's in-context learning capability to
generate multiple datasets of text prompts that can teach different skills, and
then generates the images with a T2I model based on the prompts. Next, SELMA
adapts the T2I model to the new skills by learning multiple single-skill LoRA
(low-rank adaptation) experts followed by expert merging. Our independent
expert fine-tuning specializes multiple models for different skills, and expert
merging helps build a joint multi-skill T2I model that can generate faithful
images given diverse text prompts, while mitigating the knowledge conflict from
different datasets. We empirically demonstrate that SELMA significantly
improves the semantic alignment and text faithfulness of state-of-the-art T2I
diffusion models on multiple benchmarks (+2.1% on TIFA and +6.9% on DSG), human
preference metrics (PickScore, ImageReward, and HPS), as well as human
evaluation. Moreover, fine-tuning with image-text pairs auto-collected via
SELMA shows comparable performance to fine-tuning with ground truth data.
Lastly, we show that fine-tuning with images from a weaker T2I model can help
improve the generation quality of a stronger T2I model, suggesting promising
weak-to-strong generalization in T2I models.
|
[
-0.41856229305267334,
-0.5158708691596985,
0.5383061170578003,
-0.2212701439857483,
-0.38695523142814636,
0.06285019218921661,
-0.18802018463611603,
-0.6605544686317444,
-0.05262499675154686,
0.420121967792511,
-0.21800857782363892,
-0.7039541602134705,
-0.94709712266922,
-0.13660509884357452,
-0.48888808488845825,
1.027948260307312,
-0.1655035763978958,
-0.028407979756593704,
-0.31966111063957214,
-0.2029668688774109,
-0.691489577293396,
-0.005547080654650927,
-0.7498481869697571,
0.024743257090449333,
0.6303097009658813,
0.8217235207557678,
0.7803477048873901,
0.9410764575004578,
0.4329242408275604,
0.23462550342082977,
0.3789573013782501,
0.5707767605781555,
-0.6836546659469604,
0.21468089520931244,
-0.43976980447769165,
-0.15683236718177795,
-0.4622882306575775,
0.13656149804592133,
0.45562419295310974,
0.34956836700439453,
0.22878135740756989,
0.22290703654289246,
0.20043276250362396,
0.5413586497306824,
-0.5479271411895752,
-0.1291877180337906,
-0.8928685188293457,
-0.022474786266684532,
-0.13041669130325317,
-0.16292782127857208,
-0.22074155509471893,
-0.542505145072937,
0.20120027661323547,
-0.5560653209686279,
0.5462791919708252,
-0.0405062772333622,
1.073380470275879,
0.7888182997703552,
-0.5977038145065308,
-0.35083866119384766,
-0.7195414304733276,
0.9249053001403809,
-0.6243385076522827,
0.0711607038974762,
0.41784581542015076,
0.4195014238357544,
-0.057976897805929184,
-0.27017858624458313,
-0.5165759921073914,
0.3043856620788574,
0.16854044795036316,
0.04740676283836365,
-0.08491252362728119,
-0.34545767307281494,
-0.24422375857830048,
0.16369280219078064,
-0.2110579013824463,
0.2618141770362854,
-0.505856454372406,
0.09891989827156067,
0.7711862325668335,
0.07346495985984802,
0.0909440666437149,
0.16694380342960358,
-0.3320702016353607,
-0.12235639989376068,
-0.5478847026824951,
-0.21219296753406525,
0.28099343180656433,
-0.07177378982305527,
0.016472861170768738,
0.6630683541297913,
0.14538869261741638,
0.7734084129333496,
0.3420763909816742,
-0.24964457750320435,
-0.012833747081458569,
-0.37638160586357117,
0.002048047259449959,
-0.07884524017572403,
0.7526422142982483,
0.654749870300293,
0.3064446747303009,
-0.34297484159469604,
-0.13428331911563873,
0.2098216414451599,
0.2834537923336029,
-0.473824679851532,
-0.34728968143463135,
-0.034376803785562515,
-0.4473823308944702,
-0.7408616542816162,
-0.15941692888736725,
-0.6777690052986145,
-0.43331804871559143,
-0.38158276677131653,
0.4077533781528473,
-0.43525540828704834,
-0.12006457895040512,
-0.14255908131599426,
-0.09835018217563629,
0.26826608180999756,
0.3718739449977875,
-0.6663175225257874,
0.035469770431518555,
0.31408756971359253,
0.5012349486351013,
-0.44615381956100464,
-0.2723969519138336,
-0.44208088517189026,
0.4671919345855713,
-0.5681472420692444,
1.148005723953247,
-0.4857947826385498,
-0.22729185223579407,
-0.1205858513712883,
-0.2928563356399536,
-0.09333918243646622,
-0.31709471344947815,
0.407593309879303,
-0.5562745332717896,
0.47257569432258606,
-0.24306143820285797,
-0.5272776484489441,
-0.1402946561574936,
0.0666884034872055,
-0.4853378236293793,
1.1830309629440308,
0.19611644744873047,
-0.6796301007270813,
0.6480483412742615,
-0.4897707402706146,
-0.3101249039173126,
-0.18865907192230225,
-0.2592479884624481,
-0.7616101503372192,
0.040518153458833694,
0.26554152369499207,
0.7072589993476868,
-0.15053412318229675,
0.3609936535358429,
-0.3878559172153473,
-0.11138425022363663,
0.17407746613025665,
-0.22819258272647858,
0.2030535489320755,
0.16631866991519928,
-0.41403090953826904,
0.061966150999069214,
-0.6664208769798279,
-0.027720483019948006,
0.08254149556159973,
-0.2595682144165039,
-0.08502960950136185,
0.08547060936689377,
0.10641183704137802,
0.48584067821502686,
0.32944628596305847,
-0.34146615862846375,
0.08150657266378403,
-0.1423008292913437,
0.20490705966949463,
0.6664584279060364,
0.08292746543884277,
0.7915236949920654,
-0.5639800429344177,
0.13676081597805023,
0.1663675606250763,
-0.09629876911640167,
-0.20117737352848053,
-0.750190794467926,
-1.1099892854690552,
-0.11981333792209625,
0.4335397779941559,
0.6173590421676636,
-0.6774685978889465,
0.6130273342132568,
-0.3408401608467102,
-0.5423235893249512,
-0.922319769859314,
0.4190911650657654,
0.5944563150405884,
0.9771212339401245,
0.5631553530693054,
-0.5456348657608032,
-0.39616143703460693,
-0.8463060855865479,
-0.20061351358890533,
0.13925528526306152,
-0.028983477503061295,
0.4297731816768646,
0.34252363443374634,
-0.3786161243915558,
1.2246214151382446,
-0.2582470178604126,
-0.6619676351547241,
0.19346855580806732,
0.3906453251838684,
-0.28190088272094727,
0.6400864720344543,
0.6775990724563599,
-0.6054250597953796,
-0.6577971577644348,
0.008242557756602764,
-0.9232597351074219,
0.05387628823518753,
-0.1485009789466858,
-0.28446248173713684,
0.4624733626842499,
0.23087939620018005,
-0.21405723690986633,
0.6058255434036255,
0.35915887355804443,
-0.48218584060668945,
0.28512537479400635,
-0.4006121754646301,
0.3255350589752197,
-1.4594626426696777,
-0.003951870370656252,
0.27790334820747375,
-0.4590481221675873,
-0.44038599729537964,
-0.021920140832662582,
-0.015101442113518715,
-0.061850037425756454,
-0.2205158919095993,
0.4493322968482971,
-0.3638226389884949,
-0.30708467960357666,
-0.4346998333930969,
-0.06773076206445694,
0.005255441647022963,
0.3657551407814026,
0.1464199423789978,
0.891341507434845,
0.6425486207008362,
-0.6762349605560303,
0.2424282282590866,
0.5844833850860596,
-0.3282485902309418,
0.5934832096099854,
-0.4875991940498352,
0.4436747431755066,
-0.13844728469848633,
0.08642487972974777,
-1.1387680768966675,
-0.4350232183933258,
0.15567202866077423,
-0.4676498472690582,
0.2542513906955719,
-0.16985762119293213,
-0.47942599654197693,
-0.15725843608379364,
0.04878409206867218,
0.4368806779384613,
0.6787922978401184,
-0.3989575207233429,
0.5751417279243469,
0.3342786729335785,
-0.1993725448846817,
-0.4141782522201538,
-0.7173378467559814,
0.42110419273376465,
-0.21599127352237701,
-0.7527942657470703,
0.44199079275131226,
0.03665415197610855,
0.01023122575134039,
0.19440849125385284,
0.2463139295578003,
-0.2865114212036133,
-0.1424461007118225,
0.04601055383682251,
0.2362147569656372,
-0.005192547105252743,
0.22331976890563965,
0.5568795800209045,
-0.2819181978702545,
-0.3565463721752167,
-0.4609384536743164,
0.03425708785653114,
0.16075925529003143,
-0.26187664270401,
-0.6647195816040039,
0.553026020526886,
0.44530853629112244,
-0.24635626375675201,
0.6910105347633362,
0.898762583732605,
-0.02341254986822605,
0.22981543838977814,
-0.9129894375801086,
0.01435315702110529,
-0.42616909742355347,
0.16512076556682587,
-0.48294374346733093,
-0.6498696804046631,
0.34226441383361816,
-0.25881069898605347,
0.43795907497406006,
0.5460789799690247,
0.41936296224594116,
-0.7121291160583496,
1.0478233098983765,
0.8169942498207092,
-0.10385453701019287,
0.46017760038375854,
-0.3775554597377777,
-0.16560547053813934,
-0.5123327374458313,
-0.3934822380542755,
-0.2836781144142151,
-0.6444751620292664,
-0.13117505609989166,
-0.6652811169624329,
0.4198180139064789,
-0.17546860873699188,
-0.2857828140258789,
0.1981903612613678,
-0.5948043465614319,
0.5696592926979065,
0.621731162071228,
0.6189455389976501,
0.2051074504852295,
0.4411514699459076,
0.0954321026802063,
-0.19241808354854584,
-0.7853810787200928,
-0.6628479957580566,
1.3331875801086426,
0.39032819867134094,
0.613414466381073,
-0.0847921222448349,
0.6695688962936401,
0.5276840329170227,
0.007082902826368809,
-0.6268643140792847,
0.4861759841442108,
-0.45214933156967163,
-0.014298082329332829,
-0.16560479998588562,
-0.1802927702665329,
-0.8880618214607239,
-0.20644240081310272,
-0.7183671593666077,
0.0015179893234744668,
0.44292736053466797,
0.34906965494155884,
-0.25885385274887085,
0.3086201548576355,
-0.7415673732757568,
0.5447652339935303,
-0.20978935062885284,
-0.3985135555267334,
-0.4818327724933624,
-0.6237930655479431,
0.22652633488178253,
-0.23446893692016602,
0.11856963485479355,
-0.08971568942070007,
-0.33672210574150085,
0.6544886827468872,
-0.19305205345153809,
0.8939371705055237,
-0.06658303737640381,
-0.38123390078544617,
0.13901053369045258,
0.15654325485229492,
0.5681441426277161,
-0.3111115097999573,
-0.18528826534748077,
0.22546210885047913,
-0.4656778573989868,
-0.6681424379348755,
-0.49058952927589417,
0.6841726899147034,
-1.0418879985809326,
-0.3704766631126404,
0.07487159967422485,
-0.6360957622528076,
-0.23341123759746552,
0.03656044602394104,
0.5770688652992249,
0.41187405586242676,
-0.13421142101287842,
-0.1846787929534912,
1.0303599834442139,
0.02891717664897442,
0.2403845638036728,
0.26861876249313354,
0.34638556838035583,
-0.6875092387199402,
0.9705522656440735,
-0.16213007271289825,
0.03557305410504341,
0.0032076023053377867,
-0.2600989043712616,
-0.18333470821380615,
-0.5437875986099243,
-0.5741256475448608,
0.13894322514533997,
-0.6146748065948486,
-0.4276465177536011,
-0.5459100008010864,
0.020921073853969574,
-0.4355509281158447,
-0.42190927267074585,
-0.28337010741233826,
-0.4680543839931488,
-0.8408007621765137,
0.19269731640815735,
0.5080798268318176,
0.9307531714439392,
0.09124486148357391,
0.3701855540275574,
-0.6994028687477112,
0.3817475736141205,
0.5890810489654541,
0.32474106550216675,
-0.06309349834918976,
-0.7812128067016602,
-0.38819271326065063,
0.15020263195037842,
-0.45028722286224365,
-0.962117075920105,
0.3584044873714447,
0.5435751080513,
0.28818848729133606,
0.6829515099525452,
-0.15981973707675934,
0.8658422827720642,
-0.6118996143341064,
0.6354453563690186,
0.41417184472084045,
-0.7632388472557068,
0.6721429228782654,
-0.652870774269104,
0.09286081045866013,
0.6429247856140137,
0.25452136993408203,
-0.11469096690416336,
-0.6559388041496277,
-0.5165590643882751,
-0.6002435088157654,
0.47536760568618774,
0.27675774693489075,
0.007286291103810072,
0.31901583075523376,
0.596505880355835,
0.3238643407821655,
0.07064790278673172,
-0.4122173488140106,
0.026985367760062218,
-0.4081912040710449,
-0.7515191435813904,
-0.12239908427000046,
-0.30223700404167175,
-0.3339625298976898,
-0.4880780875682831,
0.48866164684295654,
-0.2070978879928589,
0.4062871038913727,
0.0205672699958086,
-0.23419395089149475,
-0.3120934069156647,
0.07444767653942108,
0.41730162501335144,
0.492494136095047,
0.2035960704088211,
0.02125019207596779,
0.31611815094947815,
-0.1403307467699051,
0.11284353584051132,
-0.027927421033382416,
-0.16116242110729218,
-0.018626950681209564,
0.25767362117767334,
0.9541442394256592,
0.36638185381889343,
-0.2760436534881592,
0.39912140369415283,
0.06571336835622787,
-0.5584063529968262,
-0.20136207342147827,
0.3998672068119049,
-0.29605427384376526,
0.4023892283439636,
0.594591498374939,
0.6688855290412903,
-0.0064997561275959015,
-0.26740777492523193,
0.24013374745845795,
0.5110355615615845,
-0.29782792925834656,
-0.1436246633529663,
0.8142276406288147,
0.3713501989841461,
-0.21415746212005615,
0.38457196950912476,
-0.06849528104066849,
-0.2493734061717987,
0.5611660480499268,
0.34708234667778015,
0.6386353373527527,
-0.14136116206645966,
0.2764485776424408,
0.2535955309867859,
0.04935020953416824,
-0.08223047852516174,
0.18759553134441376,
-0.2519085705280304,
-0.6643163561820984,
-0.2897745966911316,
-0.2439371943473816,
-0.30752259492874146,
-0.21261398494243622,
-0.5101772546768188,
0.42368024587631226,
-0.20902931690216064,
-0.3383823037147522,
-0.13225679099559784,
0.06124388426542282,
-0.8357682824134827,
0.3624092936515808,
0.11116389185190201,
0.8308209776878357,
-0.9751404523849487,
0.8926224112510681,
0.8164730668067932,
-0.23342935740947723,
-0.6710473299026489,
-0.026536855846643448,
-0.39278483390808105,
-0.47631779313087463,
0.4282728433609009,
-0.04636853188276291,
0.12136825174093246,
0.3569650650024414,
-0.7701622843742371,
-0.9212612509727478,
1.366987943649292,
0.5166028141975403,
-0.37893038988113403,
-0.17956580221652985,
0.19682008028030396,
0.5139989256858826,
-0.8045914769172668,
0.2521028220653534,
0.5056067109107971,
0.389097660779953,
0.4018394947052002,
-0.8690348267555237,
-0.11291776597499847,
-0.17927251756191254,
0.16039201617240906,
-0.04536597058176994,
-0.4598761796951294,
0.4454922080039978,
-0.42170286178588867,
-0.1249256506562233,
0.3378438651561737,
0.8296918272972107,
0.1601828932762146,
0.5529360771179199,
0.5271075367927551,
0.8434126973152161,
0.8362562656402588,
-0.0025020865723490715,
0.4833148121833801,
-0.3739653527736664,
0.12865085899829865,
0.9942119121551514,
0.011245908215641975,
0.8570555448532104,
0.17812517285346985,
0.3646794557571411,
0.972448468208313,
0.7769339084625244,
-0.4059581756591797,
0.6585015058517456,
-0.6171212792396545,
-0.2620016932487488,
-0.551694393157959,
-0.018785621970891953,
-0.3334168493747711,
0.3938470184803009,
0.31627973914146423,
-0.5997014045715332,
-0.49413514137268066,
0.3528701364994049,
-0.26198509335517883,
0.3013210892677307,
-0.25590598583221436,
1.1477257013320923,
-0.25427529215812683,
-0.7192728519439697,
0.5102642774581909,
0.06601380556821823,
0.7352936267852783,
-0.1339479386806488,
-0.13436917960643768,
0.0239963848143816,
-0.025319885462522507,
-0.2904958128929138,
-0.9961612820625305,
0.4527909755706787,
0.18011362850666046,
-0.48595744371414185,
-0.33149009943008423,
1.01627516746521,
-0.7918325662612915,
-0.4240781366825104,
-0.15059229731559753,
0.26659494638442993,
0.30470678210258484,
0.2164148986339569,
-0.8278825879096985,
-0.1966152787208557,
-0.06338758766651154,
0.3894423842430115,
0.22028857469558716,
0.2936074733734131,
-0.01032467745244503,
0.4800218641757965,
0.5228572487831116,
-0.0743359923362732,
-0.03735455870628357,
-0.260283499956131,
1.0150033235549927,
-0.4198713004589081,
-0.40991103649139404,
-0.4035634994506836,
0.5022136569023132,
-0.17045798897743225,
-0.19783630967140198,
0.5100526213645935,
0.5310980081558228,
0.42273810505867004,
-0.1828548163175583,
0.8957180976867676,
0.16005446016788483,
0.5571582913398743,
-0.3445618152618408,
0.9942867755889893,
-0.5386152267456055,
-0.13307315111160278,
-0.19027340412139893,
-0.7988820672035217,
-0.01861777901649475,
0.41449111700057983,
-0.5205150246620178,
0.025321219116449356,
0.29536172747612,
0.7098022699356079,
-0.2766658663749695,
-0.4161904454231262,
0.25182226300239563,
-0.06362347304821014,
-0.013328556902706623,
0.7287707328796387,
0.44662007689476013,
-0.7382700443267822,
0.7056871652603149,
0.018410025164484978,
-0.36953005194664,
-0.13312894105911255,
-0.7162824869155884,
-1.1130832433700562,
-0.8259730339050293,
-0.47965818643569946,
-0.34845593571662903,
0.16517944633960724,
0.5616958141326904,
0.8448364734649658,
-0.6775200963020325,
0.16063357889652252,
-0.2717142105102539,
0.12009263038635254,
-0.11239305138587952,
-0.17790204286575317,
0.48820286989212036,
-0.5304464101791382,
-0.840279757976532,
0.2665618360042572,
-0.053446024656295776,
0.4397413730621338,
-0.18672814965248108,
-0.07006476819515228,
0.09757297486066818,
0.19825796782970428,
0.4069772958755493,
0.2770916819572449,
-0.4903779923915863,
0.04098531976342201,
-0.24541890621185303,
-0.28309348225593567,
0.09730036556720734,
0.5504412055015564,
-1.164106845855713,
0.46811267733573914,
0.1836378574371338,
0.6442223191261292,
0.33776530623435974,
0.19291947782039642,
0.7051641941070557,
-0.8242854475975037,
0.0458388514816761,
0.03555545583367348,
0.01338488981127739,
0.4367777407169342,
-0.5149990916252136,
0.3503592610359192,
0.19021888077259064,
-0.5613861083984375,
-0.5144781470298767,
0.21678918600082397,
-0.857744574546814,
-0.09548619389533997,
1.2032994031906128,
-0.023031946271657944,
-0.019964607432484627,
-0.3553839921951294,
-0.3344433903694153,
0.5942200422286987,
-0.3751519024372101,
1.2448220252990723,
0.3912518322467804,
0.1802634298801422,
-0.4220305383205414,
-0.13138888776302338,
0.5723732709884644,
0.4568515121936798,
-0.7630269527435303,
-0.48020192980766296,
0.5328049659729004,
0.4015616476535797,
-0.06340967118740082,
0.3234873414039612,
0.09230003505945206,
0.5616534352302551,
-0.4390636384487152,
0.0962546095252037,
-0.36628347635269165,
-0.3614232838153839,
-0.29174891114234924,
0.055996306240558624,
-0.03542935475707054,
-0.2911424934864044
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06949v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06949v1
|
Materials science in the era of large language models: a perspective
| 2024-03-11T17:34:25 | 2024-03-11T17:34:25 |
Ge Lei, Ronan Docherty, Samuel J. Cooper
|
cond-mat.mtrl-sci
|
cond-mat.mtrl-sci, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have garnered considerable interest due to their
impressive natural language capabilities, which in conjunction with various
emergent properties make them versatile tools in workflows ranging from complex
code generation to heuristic finding for combinatorial problems. In this paper
we offer a perspective on their applicability to materials science research,
arguing their ability to handle ambiguous requirements across a range of tasks
and disciplines mean they could be a powerful tool to aid researchers. We
qualitatively examine basic LLM theory, connecting it to relevant properties
and techniques in the literature before providing two case studies that
demonstrate their use in task automation and knowledge extraction at-scale. At
their current stage of development, we argue LLMs should be viewed less as
oracles of novel insight, and more as tireless workers that can accelerate and
unify exploration across domains. It is our hope that this paper can
familiarise material science researchers with the concepts needed to leverage
these tools in their own research.
|
[
-0.09716389328241348,
-0.6620832681655884,
1.048210859298706,
-0.14334607124328613,
-0.0048575131222605705,
0.36982062458992004,
-0.27761247754096985,
-0.5568667650222778,
-0.04275825619697571,
0.31738781929016113,
-0.30556437373161316,
-0.009051044471561909,
-0.7609401345252991,
0.3556434214115143,
-0.65184485912323,
0.4391997456550598,
-0.4112491309642792,
0.05838796868920326,
-0.32746875286102295,
0.18107882142066956,
-0.2157997339963913,
-0.3366222381591797,
-0.36284637451171875,
-0.7815638780593872,
0.7417858242988586,
0.3417540490627289,
0.6763582825660706,
0.5417153835296631,
0.6985533237457275,
0.33374765515327454,
-0.42431092262268066,
0.2709217071533203,
-0.1423768401145935,
0.1716156303882599,
-0.39571449160575867,
-0.726489245891571,
-0.3603138029575348,
0.14279232919216156,
0.6327147483825684,
1.121856927871704,
-0.13299164175987244,
0.080134816467762,
0.31357255578041077,
0.44686076045036316,
-0.19479809701442719,
0.10257422924041748,
-0.5697119235992432,
0.22997942566871643,
-0.30454379320144653,
-0.5275118947029114,
-0.37938427925109863,
0.1671314239501953,
0.22602438926696777,
-0.49893566966056824,
0.1955123096704483,
0.3133350610733032,
0.7327113151550293,
-0.14861832559108734,
-0.3625600337982178,
-0.39249882102012634,
-1.0600836277008057,
0.9190225601196289,
-0.6297014951705933,
0.35854506492614746,
0.264250785112381,
0.37252649664878845,
-0.407107412815094,
-0.6918890476226807,
-0.48694875836372375,
-0.20472416281700134,
-0.00872606597840786,
-0.20958362519741058,
0.2745470106601715,
0.09532194584608078,
0.1556185781955719,
0.7005531191825867,
-0.3458271324634552,
0.42753875255584717,
-0.557029128074646,
-0.10829007625579834,
0.3576130270957947,
0.42160263657569885,
0.29455873370170593,
-0.1319415420293808,
-0.1516493558883667,
0.32964158058166504,
-0.8810175657272339,
-0.41668689250946045,
0.1730690747499466,
0.4828510880470276,
-0.05514601990580559,
0.9018359780311584,
-0.0033194534480571747,
0.49909260869026184,
-0.41092848777770996,
-0.12435811758041382,
0.06473294645547867,
-0.3175034821033478,
-0.22623245418071747,
-0.3210833668708801,
0.6147446632385254,
-0.2549252212047577,
0.22714266180992126,
-0.6069374680519104,
-0.21284136176109314,
-0.0885142982006073,
0.25078248977661133,
-0.711689293384552,
-0.014019316993653774,
0.3891395330429077,
-0.5151245594024658,
-0.03275400400161743,
-0.09002166241407394,
-0.574569046497345,
-0.841621994972229,
-0.7140774726867676,
0.182713583111763,
-0.0486394539475441,
-0.7065054774284363,
0.2592453360557556,
-0.2541346549987793,
0.2631370723247528,
0.5131940245628357,
-0.9964880347251892,
0.317737877368927,
0.86459881067276,
0.9765290021896362,
-0.4512935280799866,
-0.41182446479797363,
-0.11721143126487732,
0.20500433444976807,
-0.34476256370544434,
0.6623514294624329,
-0.5113397240638733,
-0.660313606262207,
-0.05614480376243591,
0.14646509289741516,
0.15113498270511627,
-0.6353894472122192,
0.28481853008270264,
-0.36906352639198303,
0.06096616014838219,
-0.418669730424881,
-0.2911030650138855,
-0.00003178818224114366,
0.18696856498718262,
-0.6437865495681763,
1.007153034210205,
0.20169180631637573,
-0.5312424302101135,
0.25349533557891846,
-0.445264995098114,
-0.34035560488700867,
0.21655327081680298,
-0.26134705543518066,
0.1042414978146553,
0.42335838079452515,
-0.5638896822929382,
0.7617127895355225,
-0.997430145740509,
0.35318201780319214,
-0.5006338357925415,
-0.16581471264362335,
0.526343822479248,
-0.34713444113731384,
0.3596777617931366,
0.4455828070640564,
-0.20225465297698975,
-0.09182380139827728,
-0.4418390989303589,
-0.24005500972270966,
0.08190346509218216,
-0.44627660512924194,
-0.3059661090373993,
0.21100367605686188,
0.23527683317661285,
0.1996595412492752,
0.2989529073238373,
-0.5437449812889099,
0.19943910837173462,
-0.3902341425418854,
0.6142169237136841,
0.7827072143554688,
-0.40919673442840576,
0.7444117069244385,
-0.22395886480808258,
0.41091081500053406,
-0.3010866045951843,
-0.15267300605773926,
-0.09344537556171417,
0.05626441538333893,
-0.6316114664077759,
-0.10388410091400146,
0.15999963879585266,
0.2843932807445526,
-0.6804590821266174,
-0.03628315404057503,
-0.09327886998653412,
-0.5122306942939758,
-0.05694430321455002,
0.5728744864463806,
-0.074088916182518,
0.11236736923456192,
-0.04684945195913315,
-0.18645921349525452,
-0.6527038216590881,
-0.6771271228790283,
-0.300972044467926,
-0.04998921602964401,
-0.019042037427425385,
0.4458770453929901,
0.6028379201889038,
-0.16111579537391663,
1.2648335695266724,
-0.5182887315750122,
-0.07555824518203735,
-0.30757343769073486,
0.18806856870651245,
0.3906693458557129,
0.26766225695610046,
0.05487740784883499,
-1.0191892385482788,
-0.09795213490724564,
0.2575768828392029,
-1.2441301345825195,
0.09962385147809982,
0.059578943997621536,
0.15753303468227386,
0.08487842977046967,
0.8034334182739258,
-0.7601122856140137,
-0.11141756922006607,
0.41971853375434875,
-0.16294270753860474,
0.5222840309143066,
-0.19756731390953064,
-0.1700805127620697,
-1.1126470565795898,
0.23916615545749664,
0.23538745939731598,
-0.046944208443164825,
-0.8091439008712769,
0.09894947707653046,
-0.1461915224790573,
-0.020413175225257874,
-0.6682799458503723,
0.9110451936721802,
-0.9820123910903931,
-0.25673890113830566,
-0.7387816309928894,
0.04608411341905594,
-0.06452605128288269,
-0.05402708053588867,
0.12462581694126129,
0.678183913230896,
0.5455625057220459,
-0.7929328083992004,
0.26093789935112,
-0.10422677546739578,
-0.5630125403404236,
0.4752051830291748,
-0.5271667242050171,
-0.0507994182407856,
-0.02075773850083351,
0.021497653797268867,
-0.7976826429367065,
-0.2056024819612503,
-0.08654824644327164,
-0.10160797089338303,
0.5323870778083801,
0.19732648134231567,
-1.0998508930206299,
-0.6352899670600891,
-0.08328867703676224,
0.35722240805625916,
0.23096700012683868,
-0.3279581367969513,
1.0025317668914795,
0.4445751905441284,
-0.5286003351211548,
-0.3773304522037506,
-0.47236621379852295,
0.08914872258901596,
-0.4843588173389435,
-0.4461362361907959,
0.22311875224113464,
-0.42282548546791077,
-0.59193354845047,
-0.22374026477336884,
-0.45242902636528015,
-0.21224579215049744,
0.4472869336605072,
0.292993426322937,
0.3189128637313843,
-0.08915291726589203,
0.26584985852241516,
-0.41604453325271606,
0.06506171822547913,
0.12208425998687744,
-0.12385033816099167,
0.7719165086746216,
-0.03738771751523018,
-0.2700967490673065,
0.022542554885149002,
0.15858788788318634,
0.8435994386672974,
0.02862836793065071,
0.5522515177726746,
0.4059426784515381,
-0.49870869517326355,
-0.26536425948143005,
-0.6599770784378052,
-0.30805349349975586,
-0.6318076252937317,
0.45903724431991577,
-0.36312606930732727,
-1.016176700592041,
0.6322115659713745,
-0.3839728534221649,
0.16505949199199677,
0.3682500123977661,
0.5761281251907349,
-0.1589440107345581,
0.5719445943832397,
0.9070600867271423,
-0.06930765509605408,
0.47598204016685486,
-0.1605224907398224,
0.1887597292661667,
-1.0944373607635498,
-0.3259010314941406,
-0.5321785807609558,
0.041880059987306595,
-0.07721802592277527,
-0.3825158178806305,
0.21799589693546295,
-0.10249868780374527,
-0.15659618377685547,
0.05960278585553169,
-0.22065863013267517,
0.5551846623420715,
-0.09260538965463638,
-0.13995376229286194,
0.2606034576892853,
0.08473408222198486,
0.3057374060153961,
0.22599369287490845,
-0.7166197299957275,
-0.6604141592979431,
0.9643794298171997,
0.4948972761631012,
1.0327924489974976,
-0.1245693638920784,
0.2613367736339569,
0.40850329399108887,
0.11091502010822296,
-0.8226211071014404,
0.6870381832122803,
-0.04020385071635246,
-0.8171118497848511,
-0.3983922600746155,
-0.3094175457954407,
-1.1254470348358154,
0.36523979902267456,
-0.0447973906993866,
-0.6636128425598145,
0.08851931989192963,
-0.14702410995960236,
-0.23065678775310516,
0.5625402927398682,
-0.5030041933059692,
0.4166792631149292,
-0.4441545605659485,
-0.5065307021141052,
-0.1764780431985855,
-0.2448883056640625,
0.27860894799232483,
-0.33192697167396545,
0.7041733860969543,
-0.37600019574165344,
-0.05349074676632881,
0.7506440877914429,
-0.08497787266969681,
1.1505529880523682,
0.17033202946186066,
-0.6913352608680725,
0.4818902909755707,
0.37125152349472046,
0.34907251596450806,
-0.24381054937839508,
-0.22620142996311188,
0.014769477769732475,
-0.015339511446654797,
-0.26081761717796326,
-0.17124523222446442,
0.6824650764465332,
-0.46490707993507385,
-0.8697760105133057,
-0.4402005970478058,
-0.9879946708679199,
-0.07499641925096512,
0.26676246523857117,
-0.1007174402475357,
0.30850303173065186,
-0.0915147140622139,
0.27720382809638977,
0.8115521669387817,
-0.0036410752218216658,
0.5453587174415588,
0.5715386271476746,
-0.05519583076238632,
0.27268654108047485,
1.179234266281128,
0.31042423844337463,
0.2940863370895386,
0.35881975293159485,
0.23069174587726593,
-0.029113443568348885,
-0.7816346883773804,
-0.004422535188496113,
0.4420125484466553,
-0.7946361899375916,
-0.049710098654031754,
-0.6440584659576416,
-0.18007130920886993,
-0.06171003356575966,
-0.3468416631221771,
-0.2180657684803009,
-0.34801167249679565,
-0.6161404848098755,
-0.12311891466379166,
0.32349640130996704,
0.8719797134399414,
0.06866435706615448,
0.3365916609764099,
-0.6951925754547119,
0.345760703086853,
0.17121252417564392,
0.4137459397315979,
0.07057976722717285,
-0.5305483937263489,
-0.5395789742469788,
-0.22457675635814667,
-0.050327450037002563,
-0.6197914481163025,
0.30888086557388306,
-0.14941337704658508,
0.8480889201164246,
0.0281789880245924,
-0.2678989768028259,
0.21012546122074127,
-0.5894942283630371,
0.702951967716217,
0.06253881007432938,
-0.725159764289856,
0.14590634405612946,
-0.6742938160896301,
0.050794150680303574,
0.194081112742424,
0.46072861552238464,
-0.42660802602767944,
-0.12375129759311676,
-0.3998195230960846,
-1.101702332496643,
0.6074493527412415,
-0.1371806114912033,
0.125498965382576,
0.44451019167900085,
0.2525424063205719,
0.3860260248184204,
0.3941528797149658,
-0.7391795516014099,
-0.1363956332206726,
0.32863742113113403,
-0.18183307349681854,
-0.16890600323677063,
-0.4074646234512329,
-0.29393911361694336,
0.03875621408224106,
0.4547025263309479,
-0.18119439482688904,
0.1159653514623642,
-0.11850105226039886,
-0.23698781430721283,
-0.055989451706409454,
0.5657356381416321,
0.3632870316505432,
0.8250711560249329,
-0.10065960139036179,
0.23123465478420258,
0.2503051161766052,
-0.3325960338115692,
0.0883275717496872,
-0.0246846042573452,
0.1513959765434265,
-0.29906320571899414,
0.1208079382777214,
0.29372549057006836,
0.09451674669981003,
-0.751842200756073,
-0.04795519635081291,
0.4379726052284241,
-0.3726337254047394,
-0.27393749356269836,
-0.05522436648607254,
0.15147258341312408,
0.5160656571388245,
0.5815847516059875,
-0.25970134139060974,
0.15590986609458923,
-0.9248579740524292,
-0.043663159012794495,
0.6011090874671936,
-0.16512148082256317,
-0.3154177665710449,
0.31107187271118164,
0.2754665017127991,
-0.25048142671585083,
0.14906957745552063,
-0.05170096457004547,
-0.28586262464523315,
0.7397772669792175,
0.4776381254196167,
0.650455117225647,
-0.021634474396705627,
0.07680167257785797,
-0.20245595276355743,
0.4500196576118469,
-0.4508330225944519,
0.15357130765914917,
0.09763990342617035,
-0.697012186050415,
-0.41287025809288025,
-0.6641367077827454,
-0.7120538353919983,
0.1250184327363968,
-0.20129072666168213,
0.14016829431056976,
-0.40949803590774536,
0.1362556368112564,
0.09487105906009674,
-0.015046510845422745,
-0.48235687613487244,
0.11591439694166183,
0.29976990818977356,
0.7866891622543335,
-0.8643569946289062,
0.5938189029693604,
0.5861745476722717,
-0.2223265916109085,
-0.6061639785766602,
-0.5317519307136536,
0.23598483204841614,
-0.6992145776748657,
0.9370875358581543,
-0.036934543401002884,
-0.1740085333585739,
-0.2977583110332489,
-0.44760680198669434,
-1.2066937685012817,
1.24355947971344,
0.21060208976268768,
-0.3132686913013458,
-0.319577157497406,
0.19936944544315338,
0.4081844687461853,
-0.2828313708305359,
0.1939588338136673,
0.5575827956199646,
0.44133734703063965,
0.06156975030899048,
-1.023500680923462,
0.0449751652777195,
-0.2240564525127411,
-0.2650320529937744,
0.340573251247406,
-0.6970366835594177,
1.090960144996643,
-0.05997293442487717,
-0.23545552790164948,
0.22066263854503632,
0.7245569229125977,
0.2100372314453125,
0.340529203414917,
0.20276959240436554,
-0.031019214540719986,
0.7427080273628235,
-0.018386702984571457,
1.026713252067566,
-0.2228487730026245,
0.11169920861721039,
0.6829670071601868,
-0.7085863947868347,
0.5248702168464661,
0.716344952583313,
-0.2215166836977005,
0.3981645107269287,
0.6583307385444641,
-0.0027839024551212788,
0.14294050633907318,
0.36848971247673035,
-0.13314248621463776,
-0.35223785042762756,
-0.3789185583591461,
-0.27356916666030884,
0.1500975340604782,
0.7882634997367859,
-0.2523174583911896,
-0.14756540954113007,
0.029758069664239883,
0.09116163849830627,
-0.04639412462711334,
-0.44748324155807495,
0.3995160460472107,
0.4958106577396393,
-0.2971251904964447,
0.2205856293439865,
-0.029477659612894058,
0.8017644286155701,
-0.622856616973877,
0.009908062405884266,
0.05656096339225769,
0.05366355925798416,
-0.26410746574401855,
-0.8622797131538391,
0.1775653064250946,
-0.10424348711967468,
-0.4230481684207916,
-0.4746868312358856,
0.8539415597915649,
-0.07509232312440872,
-0.28995007276535034,
0.11336605250835419,
0.8745547533035278,
0.09328773617744446,
0.1473468691110611,
-0.28048938512802124,
0.10449565947055817,
-0.2637801468372345,
-0.3998161554336548,
0.503119170665741,
0.535720944404602,
0.025473520159721375,
0.9173089265823364,
0.5889970064163208,
0.21714627742767334,
-0.13590094447135925,
-0.2150649130344391,
0.9019159078598022,
-0.8431427478790283,
0.00935288891196251,
-0.8813168406486511,
0.37375983595848083,
0.1372358351945877,
-0.10257405787706375,
0.8432765603065491,
0.6373076438903809,
0.47928550839424133,
0.06453441083431244,
0.8828507661819458,
-0.01939980871975422,
0.5680202841758728,
-0.5847229361534119,
0.4907904863357544,
-0.692031741142273,
0.6072280406951904,
-0.20570604503154755,
-0.8665682077407837,
-0.15019823610782623,
0.30026012659072876,
-0.3015785217285156,
0.1673753708600998,
0.9444554448127747,
0.5443260073661804,
-0.11263566464185715,
0.04243237152695656,
0.1169499009847641,
0.227037712931633,
0.4839557707309723,
0.17126943171024323,
1.0338834524154663,
0.1733708530664444,
0.4699663519859314,
0.22516420483589172,
0.15801167488098145,
-0.16292475163936615,
-0.9251445531845093,
-0.9863067269325256,
-0.5423286557197571,
-0.06535962224006653,
-0.15696562826633453,
-0.3027527630329132,
0.6616604924201965,
0.5120667815208435,
-0.12738998234272003,
-0.7418161630630493,
-0.1097419485449791,
0.23089173436164856,
0.2486209273338318,
-0.20370328426361084,
0.18815359473228455,
-0.246551975607872,
-0.6685521602630615,
0.5604526400566101,
0.36117714643478394,
0.3012405335903168,
-0.46362391114234924,
-0.0895574688911438,
0.006846927106380463,
0.3691743016242981,
0.7474912405014038,
0.5611864924430847,
-0.5609408020973206,
0.025192154571413994,
0.29009827971458435,
-0.2210894674062729,
-0.08298309892416,
0.984293520450592,
-0.6938787698745728,
0.10485543310642242,
0.44997113943099976,
0.7859768867492676,
0.47668132185935974,
-0.6336398124694824,
0.6628647446632385,
-0.4799604117870331,
0.06752555817365646,
0.13541360199451447,
0.6916683912277222,
0.5188581943511963,
-0.1919388324022293,
0.7127646207809448,
0.20292958617210388,
-0.48637619614601135,
-1.335768699645996,
0.3968893885612488,
-1.0479084253311157,
-0.6749730110168457,
1.454028606414795,
0.3499301075935364,
-0.27765336632728577,
-0.14016079902648926,
-0.11669894307851791,
0.0631958618760109,
-0.11366942524909973,
0.7084556221961975,
0.8981611728668213,
-0.03634721040725708,
-0.14918290078639984,
-0.8324941396713257,
0.17012785375118256,
0.6277552843093872,
-1.0266766548156738,
0.3393835127353668,
0.1276145577430725,
0.192322239279747,
0.27964863181114197,
0.531950056552887,
-0.07201828807592392,
0.06484489887952805,
-0.1416049301624298,
-0.022494230419397354,
-0.023918768391013145,
-0.4947170615196228,
-0.1750737428665161,
0.25235673785209656,
0.5641126036643982,
0.5741782784461975
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06936v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06936v1
|
Counterfactual Reasoning with Knowledge Graph Embeddings
| 2024-03-11T17:21:39 | 2024-03-11T17:21:39 |
Lena Zellinger, Andreas Stephan, Benjamin Roth
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Knowledge graph embeddings (KGEs) were originally developed to infer true but
missing facts in incomplete knowledge repositories. In this paper, we link
knowledge graph completion and counterfactual reasoning via our new task CFKGR.
We model the original world state as a knowledge graph, hypothetical scenarios
as edges added to the graph, and plausible changes to the graph as inferences
from logical rules. We create corresponding benchmark datasets, which contain
diverse hypothetical scenarios with plausible changes to the original knowledge
graph and facts that should be retained. We develop COULDD, a general method
for adapting existing knowledge graph embeddings given a hypothetical premise,
and evaluate it on our benchmark. Our results indicate that KGEs learn patterns
in the graph without explicit training. We further observe that KGEs adapted
with COULDD solidly detect plausible counterfactual changes to the graph that
follow these patterns. An evaluation on human-annotated data reveals that KGEs
adapted with COULDD are mostly unable to recognize changes to the graph that do
not follow learned inference rules. In contrast, ChatGPT mostly outperforms
KGEs in detecting plausible changes to the graph but has poor knowledge
retention. In summary, CFKGR connects two previously distinct areas, namely KG
completion and counterfactual reasoning.
|
[
-0.6428942680358887,
-0.9769370555877686,
0.7727259397506714,
-0.3322112560272217,
-0.4335189759731293,
-0.022835055366158485,
0.15607903897762299,
-0.14597824215888977,
0.10455765575170517,
0.463149756193161,
-0.6149375438690186,
-0.5170657634735107,
-0.6235101819038391,
-0.18489506840705872,
-0.11108603328466415,
0.9571493268013,
-0.3480079770088196,
0.001055000931955874,
-0.5022811889648438,
-0.13633713126182556,
-0.5759429931640625,
-0.2963866591453552,
-0.4748319983482361,
-0.7607361674308777,
0.4156329333782196,
0.465056449174881,
0.5560912489891052,
0.29345256090164185,
-0.054020654410123825,
0.1915852576494217,
0.3196336627006531,
0.2470138967037201,
-0.6520771980285645,
-0.013609479181468487,
-0.25913193821907043,
-0.3253321945667267,
-0.10743322968482971,
0.0796385332942009,
0.22121430933475494,
0.6683459281921387,
-0.0800444483757019,
-0.1957060545682907,
0.18616554141044617,
0.4695891737937927,
-0.5174453258514404,
0.6058657765388489,
-0.2990666627883911,
0.3326345980167389,
0.2804800570011139,
0.05996820330619812,
-0.3345908224582672,
-0.31172919273376465,
0.3371754586696625,
-0.9988215565681458,
0.14539110660552979,
0.10557426512241364,
0.5148582458496094,
0.4107438325881958,
-0.7611545920372009,
-0.38214173913002014,
-0.42398110032081604,
0.2734645903110504,
-0.4507659077644348,
0.9495390057563782,
0.42241421341896057,
0.2077004760503769,
-0.45458802580833435,
-0.9604636430740356,
-0.7875023484230042,
-0.1095246821641922,
-0.39821523427963257,
0.3218194246292114,
-0.3499339818954468,
0.0678906962275505,
0.5673962831497192,
-0.11730322986841202,
-0.5213745832443237,
-0.2661720812320709,
0.05588312819600105,
-0.4344460666179657,
0.4015849828720093,
-0.03274384140968323,
0.04723559319972992,
-0.23832683265209198,
-0.373066246509552,
-0.329648494720459,
-0.7582685351371765,
-0.017357783392071724,
0.0032029305584728718,
0.018853608518838882,
-0.12178904563188553,
0.3906460702419281,
-0.295773983001709,
0.7042617797851562,
0.1831618994474411,
-0.020564937964081764,
0.17054858803749084,
0.06105341017246246,
-0.284451961517334,
0.06944530457258224,
0.3142373561859131,
0.6244563460350037,
0.40573856234550476,
-0.541567325592041,
0.17519916594028473,
0.047756586223840714,
0.2920105457305908,
-0.5694882869720459,
-0.5896676778793335,
0.019372783601284027,
-0.4389306604862213,
-0.06579439342021942,
-0.08146126568317413,
-0.48698505759239197,
-0.4593908190727234,
-0.28329402208328247,
0.7264611721038818,
-0.6529641151428223,
-0.28424128890037537,
-0.23535899817943573,
-0.6694841384887695,
0.13547761738300323,
0.5695633292198181,
-0.3787687122821808,
0.12580738961696625,
0.641084611415863,
0.6805222034454346,
0.26967522501945496,
-0.2754395604133606,
-0.1589067280292511,
0.28927040100097656,
-0.6111028790473938,
0.8543793559074402,
-0.5007494688034058,
-0.5096950531005859,
-0.1860874444246292,
0.19930970668792725,
-0.18886791169643402,
-0.2694939970970154,
0.4028608798980713,
-0.7231795191764832,
0.12306373566389084,
-1.1609095335006714,
-1.078964114189148,
-0.6591629981994629,
0.6757035255432129,
-0.39311617612838745,
0.6730334758758545,
0.24577073752880096,
-0.984614908695221,
0.7457348704338074,
-0.56370609998703,
-0.34396836161613464,
0.0023920645471662283,
-0.15846651792526245,
-0.21782079339027405,
-0.2482656091451645,
0.05908502638339996,
0.33961448073387146,
0.04534648358821869,
0.3848983347415924,
-0.7992712259292603,
-0.13820156455039978,
0.12818625569343567,
-0.21328499913215637,
0.7313736081123352,
0.1809370368719101,
-0.12308317422866821,
-0.40868815779685974,
-0.5076781511306763,
0.009388688020408154,
-0.01935156248509884,
-0.1456730216741562,
-0.43333426117897034,
0.2630704939365387,
-0.3779231607913971,
0.09022974967956543,
-0.15904536843299866,
-0.7745629549026489,
0.34097886085510254,
0.10550367832183838,
0.17124824225902557,
0.6120090484619141,
0.3663536608219147,
0.10388852655887604,
-0.4325825870037079,
0.21769315004348755,
0.17075477540493011,
-0.07359949499368668,
0.1242387443780899,
-0.6131596565246582,
-0.5781935453414917,
-0.22667236626148224,
0.29674339294433594,
0.63141268491745,
-1.2474929094314575,
0.062268201261758804,
-0.15035869181156158,
-0.4300130605697632,
0.15373140573501587,
-0.08923082053661346,
0.36568233370780945,
0.948271632194519,
0.47003358602523804,
-0.1816052347421646,
-0.6467356085777283,
-0.6515995264053345,
-0.328381210565567,
-0.23278102278709412,
0.0962820053100586,
0.5155396461486816,
0.7268738150596619,
-0.13127310574054718,
1.1825120449066162,
-0.7998223900794983,
-0.13510577380657196,
0.17353756725788116,
0.17643804848194122,
-0.056841105222702026,
0.44154998660087585,
0.8677201867103577,
-0.8901068568229675,
-0.37476226687431335,
-0.1082056313753128,
-1.005121111869812,
-0.10565583407878876,
0.12475607544183731,
-0.020777247846126556,
0.053218577057123184,
0.8844704031944275,
-0.6885401010513306,
0.6307236552238464,
0.2836914360523224,
-0.4710730314254761,
0.49048134684562683,
-0.16905425488948822,
0.3975425362586975,
-0.6740970015525818,
-0.05347524583339691,
-0.2972455620765686,
-0.2823024392127991,
-0.6676217913627625,
-0.19167836010456085,
0.04931500181555748,
0.04314666613936424,
-0.17277902364730835,
0.6633242964744568,
0.026411229744553566,
-0.07696393132209778,
-0.13129658997058868,
0.02798081375658512,
-0.12942355871200562,
0.5754466652870178,
0.1096586212515831,
0.2083403766155243,
0.30648186802864075,
-0.4178917407989502,
0.5141979455947876,
0.2769497036933899,
-0.3569487929344177,
0.6815962195396423,
-0.3756066858768463,
0.12426004558801651,
-0.23959915339946747,
0.6995704770088196,
-1.2907928228378296,
-0.23766891658306122,
0.5869516134262085,
-0.34423935413360596,
0.15267325937747955,
-0.5828152894973755,
-0.4545272886753082,
-0.4411938190460205,
-0.02319779060781002,
0.06881023198366165,
0.5605821013450623,
-0.6083913445472717,
0.7241775393486023,
0.005852748639881611,
0.0711100697517395,
-0.4389978051185608,
-0.5310415029525757,
0.05273500084877014,
0.03146040067076683,
-0.385515958070755,
0.29263824224472046,
-0.054291244596242905,
-0.21542377769947052,
0.6273021101951599,
-0.255633145570755,
0.08759120851755142,
0.1628788411617279,
0.2833118736743927,
-0.07995718717575073,
-0.301204115152359,
0.28884488344192505,
0.29088878631591797,
-0.16784565150737762,
0.10633549094200134,
-0.6008877754211426,
0.17361915111541748,
0.2272386997938156,
-0.6303772926330566,
0.11827734857797623,
0.1948976069688797,
0.29589712619781494,
0.43866491317749023,
0.6651760339736938,
0.5987216830253601,
-0.5785301923751831,
-0.018464352935552597,
-0.6123543381690979,
-0.03765013813972473,
-0.3850817382335663,
0.2494499236345291,
-0.4037499725818634,
-0.8815400004386902,
0.6425454020500183,
-0.24096834659576416,
-0.0845496729016304,
0.43777942657470703,
0.2749960720539093,
-0.269527405500412,
0.7750720381736755,
0.29122695326805115,
0.4172568619251251,
0.24493926763534546,
-0.2976300120353699,
0.12606361508369446,
-0.6532195210456848,
-0.4302715063095093,
-0.07111251354217529,
-0.18545888364315033,
-0.7344961166381836,
-0.2905953526496887,
0.3769928216934204,
0.3149144947528839,
-0.5028891563415527,
0.1234847903251648,
0.03531946614384651,
0.5057289004325867,
0.48910048604011536,
0.47016945481300354,
0.03352421149611473,
-0.2145906537771225,
-0.6780460476875305,
0.09781216830015182,
-1.0965484380722046,
-0.08138445019721985,
0.9846665859222412,
-0.31195446848869324,
0.44815969467163086,
0.16059139370918274,
0.5214089751243591,
0.7077755928039551,
0.7498465180397034,
-0.5709286332130432,
0.399330198764801,
-0.3526957631111145,
-0.4602563977241516,
-0.16018640995025635,
-0.434421181678772,
-0.6861640810966492,
0.4115842878818512,
-0.3784429132938385,
-0.7638472318649292,
0.3986082971096039,
0.5144705176353455,
-0.10319788008928299,
0.43065088987350464,
-1.0152333974838257,
1.121337890625,
0.17517739534378052,
-0.09309996664524078,
-0.35158994793891907,
-0.4311666190624237,
0.21429423987865448,
0.08269068598747253,
0.25089994072914124,
0.35745471715927124,
0.3828904330730438,
0.7433711886405945,
-0.5399558544158936,
1.0733270645141602,
-0.7578278183937073,
0.025016549974679947,
0.4240720570087433,
0.1810019612312317,
0.6537399291992188,
0.02274363674223423,
0.16614100337028503,
0.07893610745668411,
0.13522440195083618,
-0.48332980275154114,
-0.9132217168807983,
0.6548774242401123,
-0.779881477355957,
-0.9172266721725464,
-0.2447120100259781,
-0.4995783865451813,
-0.3607604503631592,
0.34132814407348633,
0.1502818614244461,
0.4879867136478424,
-0.514725387096405,
0.13930444419384003,
0.4877043068408966,
-0.18406693637371063,
0.21789254248142242,
0.556878387928009,
-0.20836617052555084,
-0.48176541924476624,
0.6890018582344055,
0.5137575268745422,
0.1274651139974594,
0.36309710144996643,
0.2987411320209503,
-0.5023147463798523,
-0.3842880129814148,
-0.4794721007347107,
-0.049758054316043854,
-1.0576791763305664,
-0.19467394053936005,
-0.7004380226135254,
-0.12734182178974152,
-0.5347311496734619,
-0.2810947299003601,
0.015811923891305923,
-0.37340879440307617,
-0.03517694026231766,
-0.15347644686698914,
0.5718169212341309,
0.7509451508522034,
-0.42609143257141113,
0.02315709739923477,
-0.5429625511169434,
0.49236994981765747,
0.8845461010932922,
0.2972353398799896,
0.3883458375930786,
-0.21544820070266724,
-0.14794984459877014,
0.40119728446006775,
-0.18516655266284943,
-0.9146670699119568,
-0.047070521861314774,
-0.016994260251522064,
0.7473796606063843,
0.4464314877986908,
0.2992894947528839,
0.6415864825248718,
-0.4187857210636139,
0.5045374035835266,
0.0691717118024826,
-0.7163113355636597,
0.1970270723104477,
-0.2970595955848694,
0.19649431109428406,
0.049395885318517685,
0.6496114134788513,
-0.7973888516426086,
-0.16446495056152344,
-0.6837279796600342,
-0.2436380684375763,
0.6346493363380432,
-0.17130720615386963,
-0.1802574247121811,
-0.20502501726150513,
0.44977203011512756,
0.20110733807086945,
0.08791474997997284,
-0.27823173999786377,
-0.1829899698495865,
-0.9647360444068909,
-0.1354941576719284,
-0.07121496647596359,
-0.0462258979678154,
-0.2812897861003876,
-0.16260316967964172,
0.5477103590965271,
-0.23481740057468414,
0.1488674134016037,
0.4036877751350403,
-0.33749648928642273,
0.0001082250673789531,
0.14692538976669312,
0.33396074175834656,
0.5786712169647217,
-0.30676525831222534,
0.3094520568847656,
0.5567733645439148,
-0.2926541566848755,
0.11154642701148987,
0.33142340183258057,
-0.2220362275838852,
-0.32046714425086975,
0.6418909430503845,
0.8131008744239807,
0.2097690850496292,
-0.30214524269104004,
0.5068379640579224,
0.05881857872009277,
-0.39290693402290344,
-0.21217504143714905,
0.26554182171821594,
0.35752230882644653,
0.5683295726776123,
0.4517996311187744,
0.2596331536769867,
-0.19793464243412018,
-0.5205826759338379,
0.3909440338611603,
0.3789921700954437,
-0.5250887274742126,
-0.25636351108551025,
0.3981017768383026,
-0.00033188884845003486,
-0.17352767288684845,
0.7106730341911316,
-0.5820382833480835,
-0.8597100973129272,
0.6913217902183533,
0.4201396107673645,
0.5066720247268677,
0.06485765427350998,
0.339713990688324,
0.2509610056877136,
0.15129776298999786,
0.10881038755178452,
0.2268439084291458,
-0.2061501294374466,
-1.1994620561599731,
-0.4376808702945709,
-0.09461069107055664,
-0.3723895847797394,
-0.028256122022867203,
-0.2302926480770111,
0.07496318966150284,
-0.43606626987457275,
-0.03859708085656166,
0.0017125470330938697,
-0.06217348203063011,
-0.8560978770256042,
0.33008185029029846,
-0.036471664905548096,
0.8431460857391357,
-1.1792497634887695,
0.6162369251251221,
0.5815548896789551,
-0.13691262900829315,
-0.4403434693813324,
-0.04240947589278221,
0.2870320975780487,
-0.9129825234413147,
0.6705809831619263,
-0.2268698513507843,
-0.039900653064250946,
0.04682810604572296,
-0.564676821231842,
-0.7064701914787292,
1.1905012130737305,
0.3724175691604614,
-0.4025260806083679,
0.28734123706817627,
-0.17215485870838165,
0.4621710777282715,
-0.33716174960136414,
0.09873134642839432,
0.23702660202980042,
0.5851085186004639,
0.3168238699436188,
-0.5566226243972778,
0.38292351365089417,
0.08859443664550781,
-0.3515011966228485,
0.2002715915441513,
-0.6276105046272278,
0.6543454527854919,
-0.4788384437561035,
-0.08888506889343262,
-0.2910252511501312,
0.3032470941543579,
0.10721578449010849,
0.5239583253860474,
0.8331435322761536,
1.0515908002853394,
0.6709741353988647,
-0.14811287820339203,
0.9905844330787659,
-0.05176135152578354,
0.34394800662994385,
0.913909912109375,
-0.308432400226593,
0.4434235990047455,
0.10836143791675568,
-0.23250256478786469,
0.7139062881469727,
0.6512943506240845,
0.019648032262921333,
0.8332810401916504,
-0.15367092192173004,
-0.05221765115857124,
-0.7880955934524536,
-0.12339861690998077,
-0.5048627257347107,
0.4922851324081421,
0.4474799633026123,
-0.09608672559261322,
-0.4889445900917053,
-0.01071120798587799,
0.22212007641792297,
-0.34875819087028503,
-0.13274253904819489,
0.7564826607704163,
0.014905142597854137,
-0.837368905544281,
0.44996535778045654,
-0.2514486610889435,
0.10395601391792297,
-0.47364485263824463,
-0.39370161294937134,
-0.22213242948055267,
0.03846404328942299,
-0.19384759664535522,
-0.8163217902183533,
0.24439668655395508,
-0.29499495029449463,
-0.15790529549121857,
-0.22313518822193146,
0.762478232383728,
-0.2744751274585724,
-0.35113081336021423,
0.3402182459831238,
0.6776242256164551,
-0.16972580552101135,
0.2023322433233261,
-0.5003258585929871,
-0.4291123151779175,
0.21067672967910767,
-0.25956547260284424,
0.3579656481742859,
0.6965758204460144,
-0.3551332652568817,
0.6516944766044617,
0.6849481463432312,
-0.27622514963150024,
-0.34346306324005127,
0.05877980962395668,
0.9723474979400635,
-0.5366441607475281,
-0.5357347130775452,
-0.7012236714363098,
0.0020758367609232664,
0.05959516763687134,
-0.06592278927564621,
0.590438723564148,
0.30260586738586426,
0.9439508318901062,
-0.010809089988470078,
0.896007776260376,
-0.3650508224964142,
0.37110722064971924,
-0.6673963069915771,
0.6486418843269348,
-0.4570017158985138,
-0.05514877289533615,
-0.4915769398212433,
-0.5510541796684265,
0.0019926209934055805,
0.4634901285171509,
-0.584313154220581,
0.11993588507175446,
0.6914150714874268,
0.6697081923484802,
-0.36131590604782104,
0.318501740694046,
0.2630294859409332,
0.5762413740158081,
0.20796427130699158,
0.4753057360649109,
0.7855406999588013,
-0.23455466330051422,
0.5716224908828735,
-0.030136987566947937,
-0.05884486064314842,
-0.07013590633869171,
-1.171875,
-0.7015634179115295,
-0.5307910442352295,
-0.5281102657318115,
-0.3299071788787842,
0.29335230588912964,
0.7139187455177307,
0.48004624247550964,
-0.7757670879364014,
0.3846997916698456,
-0.09672229737043381,
0.5099310278892517,
-0.25704362988471985,
-0.22676247358322144,
0.5144649744033813,
0.15955299139022827,
-0.0311473086476326,
0.1447063535451889,
0.047322168946266174,
0.1809026300907135,
0.2426413595676422,
-0.2293686717748642,
-0.3575553596019745,
-0.1503829061985016,
0.6234422326087952,
0.37161096930503845,
-0.6940829753875732,
-1.0333703756332397,
-0.2729239761829376,
0.4888828694820404,
-0.146713525056839,
0.9429003000259399,
-1.1382828950881958,
0.5783109068870544,
0.6167702078819275,
0.44715285301208496,
0.8397372364997864,
-0.1037239134311676,
0.4109867215156555,
-0.7045474648475647,
0.03345746174454689,
-0.23275387287139893,
0.450572669506073,
0.29119959473609924,
-0.0685766339302063,
0.36556312441825867,
0.8201305866241455,
-0.23667101562023163,
-0.49456754326820374,
0.3325986862182617,
-0.583046019077301,
-0.6225976347923279,
0.7974472045898438,
-0.6886129975318909,
0.08441497385501862,
-0.575945258140564,
0.05776813253760338,
0.5776560306549072,
-0.16508856415748596,
0.8154198527336121,
1.1075712442398071,
-0.44381970167160034,
-0.19824227690696716,
-0.26411908864974976,
0.3907018303871155,
0.12718895077705383,
-0.4964345395565033,
-0.04367693141102791,
0.6649523377418518,
0.5335140228271484,
0.0667397677898407,
0.729088306427002,
0.35502004623413086,
0.43929505348205566,
0.5299188494682312,
-0.402424693107605,
-0.3003424108028412,
0.09276716411113739,
0.42935898900032043,
0.06437558680772781,
-0.1340269297361374,
0.11385361850261688
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06935v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06935v3
|
Naming, Describing, and Quantifying Visual Objects in Humans and LLMs
| 2024-03-11T17:20:12 | 2024-06-04T09:49:06 |
Alberto Testoni, Juell Sprott, Sandro Pezzelle
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While human speakers use a variety of different expressions when describing
the same object in an image, giving rise to a distribution of plausible labels
driven by pragmatic constraints, the extent to which current Vision & Language
Large Language Models (VLLMs) can mimic this crucial feature of language use is
an open question. This applies to common, everyday objects, but it is
particularly interesting for uncommon or novel objects for which a category
label may be lacking or fuzzy. Furthermore, similar patterns of variation are
observed among human speakers for highly context-sensitive expressions, such as
the quantifiers 'few' or 'most'. In our work, we evaluate VLLMs (FROMAGe,
BLIP-2, LLaVA) on three categories (nouns, attributes, and quantifiers) where
humans show great subjective variability concerning the distribution over
plausible labels, using datasets and resources mostly under-explored in
previous work. Our results reveal mixed evidence on the ability of VLLMs to
capture human naming preferences at generation time: while some models are good
at mimicking human distributions for nouns and attributes, all of them fail to
assign quantifiers, a task that requires more accurate, high-level reasoning.
|
[
-0.43470650911331177,
-0.5309943556785583,
0.5097256898880005,
0.17527198791503906,
-0.1756546050310135,
-0.12044540047645569,
-0.2152279168367386,
-0.9080690741539001,
-0.09388794004917145,
0.4449012577533722,
-0.18660441040992737,
-0.37535572052001953,
-0.545508086681366,
0.15489058196544647,
-0.3650463819503784,
0.4952910244464874,
0.002392002148553729,
-0.08899613469839096,
-0.5486047863960266,
-0.24054266512393951,
-0.3639879822731018,
-0.842943012714386,
-0.27249613404273987,
-0.22452189028263092,
0.8696189522743225,
0.3338502049446106,
0.9082604646682739,
0.7286147475242615,
0.8065307140350342,
0.2656027376651764,
-0.21723118424415588,
0.1288893073797226,
-0.28757941722869873,
-0.2144903987646103,
-0.3442988395690918,
-0.5217658877372742,
-0.22589728236198425,
0.039710499346256256,
0.5072505474090576,
0.9308328032493591,
-0.02423071302473545,
0.20106838643550873,
0.015239844098687172,
0.4679991900920868,
-0.6486844420433044,
0.23583157360553741,
-0.6076827049255371,
0.2440946102142334,
-0.27698129415512085,
-0.09951802343130112,
-0.30489349365234375,
-0.09183917939662933,
0.45076632499694824,
-0.6127237677574158,
0.13290461897850037,
0.5491639971733093,
1.3490813970565796,
0.10181862115859985,
-0.33229580521583557,
-0.1579122096300125,
-0.8094421029090881,
1.107002854347229,
-0.4834199547767639,
0.5066140294075012,
0.4841378927230835,
0.36598825454711914,
0.10192212462425232,
-0.6328439712524414,
-0.5104750990867615,
-0.3757823407649994,
-0.3012092113494873,
-0.11606864631175995,
-0.2509375214576721,
-0.02809310331940651,
0.43478116393089294,
0.22274816036224365,
-0.4601079821586609,
0.2573654055595398,
-0.32388439774513245,
-0.22309543192386627,
0.6118281483650208,
0.4803736209869385,
0.367819607257843,
-0.2412470579147339,
-0.7093407511711121,
-0.1656225323677063,
-0.7157950401306152,
0.17232851684093475,
0.10287429392337799,
0.08077038824558258,
-0.04529405012726784,
0.8396674990653992,
-0.35970503091812134,
1.1128106117248535,
-0.36188438534736633,
-0.24087107181549072,
0.335945725440979,
-0.3646930158138275,
-0.4120108187198639,
-0.36381465196609497,
0.653110146522522,
0.749676525592804,
0.5189418792724609,
0.06066145375370979,
-0.20986787974834442,
0.011542708612978458,
0.17100337147712708,
-0.5903835892677307,
-0.2659354507923126,
-0.17588721215724945,
-0.5550103783607483,
-0.19213427603244781,
0.13369673490524292,
-0.49505558609962463,
-0.6523426175117493,
-0.4155174195766449,
0.5110215544700623,
-0.0847463458776474,
-0.1128331646323204,
0.2582581341266632,
-0.1765657663345337,
0.5496183037757874,
0.4754642844200134,
-0.8816615343093872,
0.16143567860126495,
0.5217382311820984,
0.5195208787918091,
-0.4013005197048187,
-0.4883953630924225,
-0.08818403631448746,
0.2171294093132019,
-0.41770267486572266,
1.0258915424346924,
-0.619128942489624,
-0.4463885724544525,
-0.14707286655902863,
0.04338182136416435,
0.3108093738555908,
-0.8998483419418335,
-0.06906899809837341,
-0.2182299792766571,
0.005814407020807266,
-0.590005099773407,
-0.44042858481407166,
-0.07858626544475555,
0.12107042968273163,
-0.46122610569000244,
0.5783779621124268,
0.09664744138717651,
-0.6913158297538757,
0.822969377040863,
-0.16362255811691284,
-0.2752920091152191,
0.2987789809703827,
-0.4145890772342682,
-0.4582175016403198,
0.4254067540168762,
-0.16973111033439636,
0.6641606688499451,
-0.3890831470489502,
0.0604071319103241,
-0.30735352635383606,
-0.27591338753700256,
0.7513077259063721,
-0.21323919296264648,
0.4114289879798889,
0.22709904611110687,
0.027198242023587227,
0.16466225683689117,
-0.5805881023406982,
-0.11775979399681091,
0.14886489510536194,
-0.18501779437065125,
-0.4581024944782257,
0.33513352274894714,
0.08369509130716324,
0.02904207445681095,
0.39339515566825867,
-0.3553970456123352,
0.10977976024150848,
-0.023945165798068047,
0.35267332196235657,
0.5937792062759399,
-0.16927391290664673,
0.36800360679626465,
-0.4198570251464844,
0.3264904320240021,
0.3642272651195526,
0.2772890031337738,
0.04975210875272751,
-0.6574878692626953,
-0.8256532549858093,
-0.3628762364387512,
-0.037153251469135284,
0.4644843637943268,
-0.5479140281677246,
0.07390641421079636,
-0.2290002554655075,
-0.3114054501056671,
-0.11520986258983612,
0.19848424196243286,
0.5088858604431152,
0.2930319905281067,
0.13669510185718536,
-0.4244867265224457,
-0.49489885568618774,
-1.4299901723861694,
-0.25864535570144653,
-0.4049244523048401,
-0.3321846127510071,
0.8435579538345337,
0.2864401340484619,
-0.3177421987056732,
1.046486496925354,
-0.6514186263084412,
-0.36967214941978455,
-0.08125718683004379,
0.13749487698078156,
0.017569649964571,
0.06772152334451675,
0.6708706617355347,
-0.8769976496696472,
-0.23307928442955017,
0.06675723195075989,
-0.820304274559021,
-0.034120652824640274,
-0.024684151634573936,
0.03191310912370682,
0.12950970232486725,
0.2960335612297058,
-0.39784303307533264,
0.47814327478408813,
0.16505485773086548,
-0.5149340629577637,
0.5606634616851807,
-0.09961524605751038,
-0.15909834206104279,
-0.747517466545105,
-0.129317507147789,
0.05841386690735817,
-0.23231160640716553,
-0.4021991789340973,
0.032211579382419586,
-0.018407288938760757,
0.0866241380572319,
-0.8741229772567749,
0.891612708568573,
-0.6822963356971741,
-0.3963199853897095,
-0.0811779648065567,
-0.009029099717736244,
-0.056685104966163635,
0.343804270029068,
0.4847258925437927,
0.6524389386177063,
0.7843431234359741,
-0.6208814382553101,
0.483185350894928,
0.1422366201877594,
-0.5668268203735352,
0.8734179735183716,
-0.6633287072181702,
-0.1492149829864502,
-0.3491124212741852,
-0.2551348805427551,
-0.9178164005279541,
-0.49214884638786316,
0.26693177223205566,
-0.16442027688026428,
0.09786175936460495,
0.22673393785953522,
-0.48749294877052307,
-0.41790464520454407,
-0.2597176730632782,
0.38750797510147095,
0.6555572152137756,
-0.4594838619232178,
0.5267159342765808,
0.4355812966823578,
0.009641771204769611,
-0.33612334728240967,
-0.7891451716423035,
0.31489694118499756,
-0.5397866368293762,
-0.31839489936828613,
0.08671800792217255,
-0.20501922070980072,
-0.5896937251091003,
0.03630385547876358,
-0.062332767993211746,
-0.2124943733215332,
0.0983920767903328,
0.5654509663581848,
0.24950338900089264,
-0.10322129726409912,
0.2403222620487213,
-0.6664540767669678,
0.10419182479381561,
-0.05460391566157341,
-0.030143514275550842,
0.21330703794956207,
-0.35636505484580994,
-0.20335902273654938,
-0.36441242694854736,
0.2222115695476532,
0.2854108512401581,
-0.02363130822777748,
0.41494065523147583,
0.39313003420829773,
-0.2896100580692291,
-0.12937307357788086,
-0.43870243430137634,
0.089084193110466,
-0.43468794226646423,
0.5527971386909485,
-0.6648354530334473,
-0.8758253455162048,
0.3731696903705597,
0.22503824532032013,
-0.15616543591022491,
0.12728112936019897,
0.6478099226951599,
-0.4870370626449585,
0.8598082065582275,
0.5787250399589539,
0.10406295210123062,
0.4335497319698334,
-0.05904079228639603,
0.0869768038392067,
-0.8021169304847717,
-0.3992387354373932,
-0.350821852684021,
-0.37169885635375977,
-0.5790539979934692,
-0.603203296661377,
0.002490667626261711,
0.19397103786468506,
0.05244549363851547,
0.2256443053483963,
-0.5557716488838196,
0.6365363597869873,
0.5127169489860535,
0.018315395340323448,
0.23786693811416626,
0.17071408033370972,
0.3755171597003937,
-0.11993852257728577,
-0.4334847629070282,
-0.721735954284668,
1.0259767770767212,
0.23259834945201874,
0.9746016263961792,
-0.0033733989112079144,
0.5598812103271484,
0.13743939995765686,
0.47162386775016785,
-0.9203131794929504,
0.7595968842506409,
-0.4101600646972656,
-0.4981478750705719,
-0.280102401971817,
-0.3416283428668976,
-1.1280606985092163,
0.21561594307422638,
-0.04967379570007324,
-1.037461757659912,
0.40208062529563904,
0.3263486623764038,
-0.21484331786632538,
0.08708157390356064,
-0.596299946308136,
0.7186587452888489,
-0.4042647182941437,
-0.1860637068748474,
0.11757449060678482,
-0.5545640587806702,
0.40939703583717346,
-0.06359313428401947,
0.1958034783601761,
-0.32795828580856323,
-0.3486805856227875,
0.6671995520591736,
-0.19742310047149658,
0.9428046345710754,
0.10375809669494629,
-0.12256044894456863,
0.4574873745441437,
0.07514122873544693,
0.04773041233420372,
-0.04696032777428627,
0.3417794406414032,
0.41683229804039,
-0.013401081785559654,
-0.5665507316589355,
-0.5213996767997742,
0.587026834487915,
-0.7914934158325195,
-0.7226977348327637,
-0.3966909646987915,
-0.4812829792499542,
-0.12735120952129364,
-0.02400391921401024,
0.3130101263523102,
0.29058030247688293,
-0.12125130742788315,
0.2532331645488739,
0.5363214015960693,
-0.4361371397972107,
0.3061354458332062,
0.35131391882896423,
-0.5465215444564819,
-0.10534199327230453,
1.2259628772735596,
0.1618683785200119,
0.3128475546836853,
0.4909701645374298,
0.30124059319496155,
-0.20794035494327545,
-0.45726099610328674,
-0.2175605446100235,
0.23345546424388885,
-0.6812415719032288,
-0.13141648471355438,
-0.4396394193172455,
-0.09459371864795685,
0.1031205803155899,
-0.10329686850309372,
-0.002191483275964856,
-0.26365724205970764,
-0.4680192172527313,
-0.11112663894891739,
0.315105140209198,
0.9397286772727966,
0.1706215888261795,
0.20952756702899933,
-0.4680289626121521,
0.6535088419914246,
0.9191949963569641,
0.4207613468170166,
-0.13156846165657043,
-0.33768993616104126,
-0.01390080526471138,
0.08557136356830597,
0.007182834204286337,
-0.811758816242218,
0.30506715178489685,
0.39277470111846924,
0.5520651340484619,
0.4339539110660553,
-0.27104705572128296,
0.6919075846672058,
-0.38694265484809875,
1.0108067989349365,
0.27900204062461853,
-0.7121238112449646,
0.3181401789188385,
-0.15563449263572693,
0.1399874985218048,
0.12491893768310547,
0.22048866748809814,
-0.45175787806510925,
-0.2785674035549164,
-0.3833863437175751,
-0.814852774143219,
0.47690269351005554,
0.14857396483421326,
0.24893498420715332,
-0.12595878541469574,
0.1278143674135208,
0.06809951364994049,
0.29096347093582153,
-0.7861889600753784,
-0.30407172441482544,
-0.2510533034801483,
-0.12303885072469711,
-0.20387409627437592,
-0.40857911109924316,
-0.023548411205410957,
-0.215279683470726,
-0.03986804559826851,
0.10340440273284912,
0.290703684091568,
0.1121678501367569,
-0.21779240667819977,
0.06036025658249855,
0.1437469869852066,
0.7617667317390442,
0.635602593421936,
-0.18907292187213898,
0.6081499457359314,
0.027016079053282738,
-0.27155810594558716,
0.19366194307804108,
-0.3680844008922577,
-0.1792401224374771,
0.03583689406514168,
0.4122340679168701,
1.0411090850830078,
0.19540691375732422,
-0.9484061598777771,
0.41172075271606445,
-0.019243868067860603,
-0.1882523000240326,
-0.29291898012161255,
0.24043188989162445,
0.2997347414493561,
0.16956275701522827,
0.23233658075332642,
-0.042776044458150864,
0.1328708827495575,
-0.7718608975410461,
-0.03739733621478081,
0.5159399509429932,
-0.371600866317749,
-0.49081891775131226,
0.6134688258171082,
-0.041051074862480164,
-0.5556422472000122,
0.37259501218795776,
-0.31696245074272156,
-0.18821056187152863,
0.7965502142906189,
0.2749898135662079,
0.7156049609184265,
0.09726662188768387,
0.2030131071805954,
0.04455789178609848,
0.13591817021369934,
-0.21762336790561676,
0.4519665539264679,
-0.053277622908353806,
-0.9671292901039124,
0.007303252350538969,
-0.9896939992904663,
-0.35368868708610535,
-0.042975492775440216,
-0.5237035751342773,
0.202166348695755,
-0.40407899022102356,
-0.2842368483543396,
0.18451917171478271,
-0.5016339421272278,
-0.9977400898933411,
0.2992667257785797,
0.5506343841552734,
0.5609921813011169,
-0.8002220988273621,
0.6925259828567505,
1.0793253183364868,
-0.40477046370506287,
-0.6983140110969543,
-0.26366984844207764,
-0.13735581934452057,
-0.6326944828033447,
1.1702650785446167,
0.07647984474897385,
-0.03912147134542465,
-0.04812919348478317,
-0.6794520616531372,
-0.9684930443763733,
0.929512619972229,
0.2023116499185562,
-0.6054435968399048,
-0.015089360997080803,
0.45874038338661194,
0.6324787139892578,
-0.3508788049221039,
0.10426833480596542,
0.3808557987213135,
0.6371471285820007,
0.16738197207450867,
-0.9228036999702454,
-0.2547571659088135,
-0.022017301991581917,
0.545637309551239,
0.004295186139643192,
-0.5843778252601624,
0.8381245732307434,
-0.5110595226287842,
-0.39775168895721436,
0.1557953953742981,
0.4967212677001953,
0.34358564019203186,
0.32242923974990845,
0.43979498744010925,
0.4497474730014801,
0.5387208461761475,
-0.15057213604450226,
1.1691845655441284,
0.18628159165382385,
0.4774543344974518,
0.9918799996376038,
-0.38728591799736023,
0.8645889759063721,
0.6038778424263,
-0.5181933045387268,
0.09141068160533905,
0.7329365611076355,
-0.2653169333934784,
0.4010373651981354,
0.46941980719566345,
-0.022599590942263603,
-0.36399343609809875,
-0.4144277572631836,
-0.12581385672092438,
0.5804585218429565,
0.3522782027721405,
-0.23395109176635742,
0.03252864629030228,
0.23725856840610504,
-0.2906521260738373,
-0.11463381350040436,
-0.3387543559074402,
0.8911927938461304,
0.2633586823940277,
-0.2695698142051697,
0.756567120552063,
-0.2886061370372772,
0.6834003925323486,
-0.2122873216867447,
0.060841433703899384,
-0.24157266318798065,
-0.18887631595134735,
-0.1999048888683319,
-0.9585055708885193,
0.21772968769073486,
-0.12443937361240387,
-0.17578965425491333,
-0.35080796480178833,
0.49434542655944824,
-0.3269951343536377,
-0.669888973236084,
0.17360815405845642,
0.4660985469818115,
0.45461612939834595,
0.18470285832881927,
-0.28196537494659424,
-0.0030274256132543087,
-0.06899942457675934,
-0.3934388756752014,
0.2872307002544403,
0.34686267375946045,
-0.3576837480068207,
0.8630334138870239,
0.2922917306423187,
0.38823920488357544,
0.44638949632644653,
0.18841633200645447,
0.3817899227142334,
-1.0035666227340698,
-0.022721953690052032,
-0.9120197296142578,
0.35669443011283875,
-0.03940174728631973,
-0.26909974217414856,
0.6866685152053833,
0.5011675357818604,
1.0419734716415405,
-0.4886934757232666,
0.5243063569068909,
0.0927271619439125,
0.2193448692560196,
-0.3790196180343628,
0.46819183230400085,
-0.7102638483047485,
0.10512267053127289,
-0.2590343654155731,
-1.1722331047058105,
-0.4890144169330597,
0.6256961822509766,
-0.0991261675953865,
-0.20087429881095886,
0.506309449672699,
0.6514590978622437,
0.023085298016667366,
-0.5068395733833313,
0.8515671491622925,
0.30805259943008423,
0.06618660688400269,
0.6251286864280701,
1.3268030881881714,
0.12222938239574432,
0.37308546900749207,
-0.20690517127513885,
-0.04866468533873558,
-0.42185595631599426,
-0.7904390692710876,
-0.8539384007453918,
-0.5795651078224182,
-0.5528827905654907,
0.22541402280330658,
0.08858618140220642,
0.6730103492736816,
0.8729394674301147,
-0.6110720038414001,
-0.43564319610595703,
0.14982594549655914,
0.0925876796245575,
-0.11107594519853592,
-0.23894940316677094,
0.08146841078996658,
-0.10216806828975677,
-0.6731752753257751,
-0.012565613724291325,
0.5036882758140564,
0.372751921415329,
-0.37643277645111084,
-0.0804174393415451,
0.35066238045692444,
0.1858881562948227,
0.7739182710647583,
0.17212143540382385,
-1.280338168144226,
-0.6188346147537231,
0.034593451768159866,
-0.398233026266098,
0.2285437434911728,
0.6403071880340576,
-0.9337647557258606,
0.4164275825023651,
0.6174870729446411,
0.19528116285800934,
0.1475580334663391,
0.07094614952802658,
0.2938495874404907,
-0.6895554661750793,
0.23695915937423706,
0.1057836264371872,
0.48726576566696167,
0.42421582341194153,
-0.18121036887168884,
0.29888156056404114,
0.2950998842716217,
-0.24406717717647552,
-0.8725976943969727,
0.6439082026481628,
-1.1907716989517212,
-0.3805309236049652,
1.2195634841918945,
-0.04776130989193916,
-0.34838396310806274,
0.08295238763093948,
-0.3201102912425995,
-0.21990834176540375,
-0.17622654139995575,
0.7711657881736755,
0.6487027406692505,
-0.20830389857292175,
-0.3775673806667328,
-0.49273061752319336,
0.41883230209350586,
0.1889820545911789,
-0.8371257781982422,
0.11328922212123871,
0.6013119220733643,
0.38897302746772766,
0.2029668390750885,
0.4109206199645996,
0.060260750353336334,
0.18219967186450958,
-0.2779172956943512,
0.23691989481449127,
0.025641323998570442,
-0.37411147356033325,
-0.18178215622901917,
0.18679465353488922,
0.4598771035671234,
-0.2183886021375656
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06932v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06932v2
|
ERA-CoT: Improving Chain-of-Thought through Entity Relationship Analysis
| 2024-03-11T17:18:53 | 2024-06-06T11:54:56 |
Yanming Liu, Xinyue Peng, Tianyu Du, Jianwei Yin, Weihao Liu, Xuhong Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have achieved commendable accomplishments in
various natural language processing tasks. However, LLMs still encounter
significant challenges when dealing with complex scenarios involving multiple
entities. These challenges arise from the presence of implicit relationships
that demand multi-step reasoning. In this paper, we propose a novel approach
ERA-CoT, which aids LLMs in understanding context by capturing relationships
between entities and supports the reasoning of diverse tasks through
Chain-of-Thoughts (CoT). Experimental results show that ERA-CoT demonstrates
the superior performance of our proposed method compared to current CoT
prompting methods, achieving a significant improvement of an average of 5.1\%
on GPT3.5 compared to previous SOTA baselines. Our analysis indicates that
ERA-CoT increases the LLM's understanding of entity relationships,
significantly improves the accuracy of question answering, and enhances the
reasoning ability of LLMs.
|
[
-0.7205854058265686,
-1.2531929016113281,
0.9802384972572327,
0.14141219854354858,
-0.29256242513656616,
0.22020754218101501,
-0.18409477174282074,
-0.6990467309951782,
0.1576349437236786,
0.5646382570266724,
-0.6344215869903564,
-0.47122448682785034,
-0.3881044089794159,
0.2520134449005127,
-0.24232132732868195,
0.8066205382347107,
-0.359762966632843,
0.0024086006451398134,
-0.04704205319285393,
0.008562962524592876,
-0.5156195759773254,
-0.3877066671848297,
-1.0155056715011597,
-0.08886323124170303,
0.4647890031337738,
0.24816259741783142,
0.3431587815284729,
0.1735767424106598,
0.33248865604400635,
0.24689988791942596,
-0.20733773708343506,
0.6360037326812744,
-0.2715015113353729,
0.5494920611381531,
-0.41621875762939453,
-0.47703203558921814,
-1.0039657354354858,
-0.37762293219566345,
0.4830782413482666,
0.6942943930625916,
-0.11739035695791245,
0.2647620141506195,
0.12447036057710648,
0.703738272190094,
-0.7962601780891418,
0.09135890007019043,
-0.7763149738311768,
-0.1637468934059143,
-0.021240342408418655,
-0.5595106482505798,
-0.5873934030532837,
-0.07481135427951813,
0.21949242055416107,
-0.6951834559440613,
0.015562884509563446,
0.38726121187210083,
0.6599113345146179,
0.056205496191978455,
-0.575090765953064,
-0.4493599236011505,
-0.7222409844398499,
0.6011956930160522,
-0.4459403455257416,
0.6673416495323181,
0.12879085540771484,
0.018167149275541306,
-0.40841132402420044,
-0.6251713037490845,
-0.7890445590019226,
-0.03848792240023613,
0.1456989198923111,
-0.037915583699941635,
0.11613371223211288,
-0.011623203754425049,
0.28114768862724304,
0.25766775012016296,
-0.23239518702030182,
-0.23943769931793213,
-0.0749632865190506,
0.22222702205181122,
0.31064432859420776,
0.28303059935569763,
0.2868669331073761,
-0.07810318470001221,
-0.8859465718269348,
0.2565695345401764,
-0.9128963947296143,
-0.16838937997817993,
-0.05184391513466835,
0.22264644503593445,
0.1512487381696701,
0.297392874956131,
-0.03217223286628723,
0.6242627501487732,
-0.11560225486755371,
-0.020199129357933998,
-0.07701551169157028,
-0.4624812602996826,
-0.42702457308769226,
-0.06216554716229439,
0.581472635269165,
0.33004188537597656,
0.18243354558944702,
-0.05189838632941246,
-0.13468670845031738,
-0.08232913166284561,
0.02037971466779709,
-0.5882559418678284,
0.1028662621974945,
0.2951626479625702,
-0.2836655080318451,
0.13943661749362946,
-0.024457132443785667,
-1.0518132448196411,
-0.20100407302379608,
-0.5514265298843384,
0.14766229689121246,
-0.5555794835090637,
-0.39466822147369385,
-0.14625483751296997,
0.042590077966451645,
0.40163159370422363,
0.5870099663734436,
-0.6470739245414734,
0.6076667308807373,
0.6674759984016418,
0.9044429659843445,
0.012843099422752857,
-0.17260585725307465,
-0.5255152583122253,
0.5979203581809998,
-0.38893556594848633,
1.034053921699524,
-0.6496816873550415,
-0.2486472725868225,
-0.22749768197536469,
-0.2324712872505188,
-0.16495908796787262,
-0.2103114128112793,
0.20405162870883942,
-0.6429767608642578,
-0.06312661617994308,
-0.4319984018802643,
-0.6577150821685791,
0.1621060073375702,
0.4375234544277191,
-0.6790364980697632,
1.1130635738372803,
-0.23281504213809967,
-0.6896755695343018,
0.49747970700263977,
-0.7249496579170227,
-0.15882858633995056,
0.04435412585735321,
-0.5188314914703369,
-0.08622493594884872,
-0.1543136090040207,
0.7857490181922913,
0.4542796015739441,
-0.5222230553627014,
0.3622661530971527,
-0.246144101023674,
-0.17993420362472534,
0.23965823650360107,
-0.2151142805814743,
0.594540536403656,
0.2659229636192322,
-0.4174305498600006,
0.027020206674933434,
-0.6655938625335693,
0.09672828763723373,
0.06660889089107513,
-0.029175961390137672,
-0.6930070519447327,
-0.11960854381322861,
-0.2997869551181793,
0.31997328996658325,
0.1766289323568344,
-0.27257683873176575,
0.35175853967666626,
-0.3307577669620514,
0.29726362228393555,
0.8493527770042419,
0.4216279983520508,
0.5175995230674744,
0.05436718091368675,
0.6845855116844177,
0.04340076819062233,
-0.069485142827034,
-0.10789842903614044,
-0.4477616846561432,
-0.9327294230461121,
-0.15176428854465485,
0.20875295996665955,
0.3564639091491699,
-1.053952932357788,
0.49052974581718445,
-0.193582683801651,
-0.14403092861175537,
-0.2628219723701477,
0.1601974368095398,
0.52345871925354,
0.4685603082180023,
0.5570456981658936,
-0.25571054220199585,
-0.7055267691612244,
-0.41010934114456177,
-0.2682479918003082,
-0.29887062311172485,
0.057066410779953,
0.2776428461074829,
0.5880395174026489,
-0.004449325613677502,
0.9627463817596436,
-0.631239116191864,
-0.2118939310312271,
-0.4806625545024872,
0.1682174801826477,
-0.11425132304430008,
0.36450400948524475,
0.17921370267868042,
-0.6262413263320923,
-0.21772201359272003,
-0.027156909927725792,
-0.6417928338050842,
0.07544104754924774,
-0.14133015275001526,
-0.5737165808677673,
0.30448728799819946,
0.7187420725822449,
-0.5764622092247009,
0.41048914194107056,
0.20469169318675995,
-0.5810757279396057,
0.337117075920105,
-0.12794502079486847,
0.30489256978034973,
-1.2205044031143188,
0.05690538510680199,
-0.07308664917945862,
-0.34334704279899597,
-0.4069591164588928,
0.1552879959344864,
-0.007921498268842697,
0.09689290076494217,
-0.35202014446258545,
0.47570621967315674,
-0.7195726633071899,
-0.14937183260917664,
0.06797376275062561,
0.6210131049156189,
0.06939461827278137,
0.5208091735839844,
0.09733804315328598,
0.9232195615768433,
0.455402135848999,
-0.9394693970680237,
0.05391174182295799,
0.361531525850296,
0.03413443639874458,
0.9173739552497864,
-0.2274874746799469,
0.5072087049484253,
-0.24209240078926086,
0.6951525807380676,
-0.7818897366523743,
0.18990792334079742,
0.061209600418806076,
-0.4019944369792938,
0.19754084944725037,
-0.0549263097345829,
-0.31637558341026306,
-0.02056262269616127,
-0.4427531957626343,
0.3296282887458801,
-0.03058001957833767,
-0.5821177363395691,
1.022443175315857,
0.3927271366119385,
-0.18804523348808289,
-0.7307885885238647,
-0.4001125991344452,
0.15900756418704987,
-0.24466019868850708,
-0.44825300574302673,
0.3676817715167999,
0.16727447509765625,
-0.4307165741920471,
0.18193146586418152,
-0.4674757421016693,
-0.18143248558044434,
-0.051565006375312805,
-0.0579373762011528,
0.6588846445083618,
-0.3104557991027832,
0.4250652492046356,
0.002782955300062895,
-0.11524792015552521,
0.25106173753738403,
-0.3334687650203705,
0.7428271174430847,
-0.16780978441238403,
0.15523791313171387,
-0.09419962763786316,
0.36089903116226196,
0.33480992913246155,
-0.39157676696777344,
1.0756596326828003,
0.21230120956897736,
-0.5710492134094238,
-0.5607428550720215,
-0.5116384625434875,
0.12482881546020508,
-0.40224161744117737,
0.18417935073375702,
-0.8197675347328186,
-0.7719282507896423,
0.41570383310317993,
-0.3665529489517212,
0.0162871852517128,
0.37502536177635193,
0.4407929480075836,
-0.0534830242395401,
0.7516897916793823,
0.7036237120628357,
-0.072499118745327,
0.45159825682640076,
-0.5004484057426453,
0.5677038431167603,
-1.4642291069030762,
-0.39986303448677063,
-0.43285009264945984,
0.09789770841598511,
-0.42565542459487915,
-0.48590657114982605,
0.356592059135437,
0.36087125539779663,
-0.3113729655742645,
0.4165938198566437,
-0.18806709349155426,
0.438486784696579,
0.011567201465368271,
0.22262144088745117,
0.6979461312294006,
-0.36573678255081177,
-0.27051863074302673,
0.31625059247016907,
-0.47624945640563965,
-0.9375002980232239,
1.0355842113494873,
0.3772956430912018,
0.8195556998252869,
0.24862773716449738,
0.7477608919143677,
-0.0713644027709961,
0.2786862552165985,
-0.5912631750106812,
0.7739940881729126,
0.16477784514427185,
-0.6050252914428711,
-0.4689602851867676,
-0.47729596495628357,
-0.9352947473526001,
0.3416630029678345,
-0.2171332985162735,
-1.164778232574463,
0.07130926102399826,
0.19549554586410522,
-0.43906766176223755,
0.41142338514328003,
-0.5401278734207153,
0.5445229411125183,
-0.1820255070924759,
-0.42051875591278076,
-0.19510649144649506,
-0.4500662684440613,
0.3877316415309906,
0.1287315934896469,
0.2908415198326111,
-0.1442754566669464,
-0.3475818634033203,
0.7682192325592041,
-0.4611165523529053,
0.4335537552833557,
0.029395222663879395,
-0.36028584837913513,
0.5386971831321716,
0.10253167152404785,
0.5841382145881653,
0.3104516267776489,
0.16885380446910858,
-0.18538762629032135,
-0.12994502484798431,
-0.14746373891830444,
-0.7785502076148987,
0.9308173656463623,
-0.37248939275741577,
-0.5181367993354797,
-0.3185436725616455,
-0.545458197593689,
-0.566113293170929,
0.09030858427286148,
0.014761164784431458,
0.49264103174209595,
-0.18045328557491302,
-0.09711036831140518,
0.6804871559143066,
-0.054667066782712936,
0.4186380207538605,
0.24284256994724274,
-0.4113205671310425,
-0.35819774866104126,
0.2910612225532532,
0.03223191574215889,
0.4695710837841034,
0.4566642940044403,
-0.2323654145002365,
-0.4972703754901886,
-0.11849858611822128,
-0.3806605339050293,
0.04935663938522339,
-0.877084493637085,
-0.3445405662059784,
-1.036664605140686,
0.08356821537017822,
-0.4115700423717499,
-0.06558741629123688,
-0.31967756152153015,
-0.20506909489631653,
0.15790775418281555,
-0.29043859243392944,
0.4188889265060425,
0.6754571199417114,
0.5535202026367188,
-0.024122944101691246,
-0.5398040413856506,
0.44958066940307617,
0.4013371467590332,
0.3134908676147461,
0.30447378754615784,
0.0869474858045578,
0.09206468611955643,
-0.29361286759376526,
-0.314199298620224,
-1.040204405784607,
0.18943966925144196,
-0.04042985662817955,
0.3816094696521759,
0.05176614224910736,
-0.013244600966572762,
1.1968978643417358,
-0.5451582074165344,
0.7343803644180298,
0.1293279230594635,
-1.328825831413269,
0.8241628408432007,
-0.0717683732509613,
0.022865403443574905,
0.4916515052318573,
0.2792843282222748,
-0.2068542242050171,
-0.6712222099304199,
-0.7905064821243286,
-1.3187307119369507,
0.42961934208869934,
0.4649663269519806,
-0.2688920795917511,
-0.18172921240329742,
0.23956246674060822,
-0.05883077532052994,
0.13987961411476135,
-0.6376235485076904,
-0.3019216060638428,
0.49644914269447327,
-0.1343630850315094,
0.29679781198501587,
-0.08440186828374863,
0.1479051411151886,
-0.13092517852783203,
0.6823475360870361,
-0.09391677379608154,
0.4250430166721344,
0.5777387022972107,
-0.2982121706008911,
-0.3823610544204712,
0.6999334096908569,
0.1946629136800766,
1.2263108491897583,
-0.1116870641708374,
0.5224344730377197,
0.794241189956665,
-0.33339303731918335,
0.08776603639125824,
-0.08200643211603165,
0.17166954278945923,
-0.1415308266878128,
0.5241923332214355,
0.6181929707527161,
0.1685326248407364,
-0.566250205039978,
0.30939629673957825,
-0.22269058227539062,
0.27548331022262573,
-0.4275050759315491,
0.03630814328789711,
0.28666937351226807,
0.2872624099254608,
0.3456130921840668,
-0.07608608901500702,
0.24877099692821503,
-0.8856601119041443,
0.25309932231903076,
0.22127586603164673,
-0.3041664659976959,
0.03891649842262268,
0.6024587154388428,
0.3652064800262451,
-0.13041052222251892,
0.41891807317733765,
-0.13831394910812378,
-0.5811625123023987,
0.7129871845245361,
0.7815601825714111,
0.742465615272522,
-0.23491033911705017,
-0.152828648686409,
0.3606252670288086,
0.25058162212371826,
-0.08048490434885025,
0.4913656413555145,
-0.18073026835918427,
-0.7447400689125061,
-0.6842445135116577,
-0.46064573526382446,
-0.41183242201805115,
0.1395265758037567,
-0.7752299904823303,
0.46163439750671387,
-0.5543971657752991,
-0.19993941485881805,
-0.11946845799684525,
-0.003450585762038827,
-1.0173548460006714,
0.25849488377571106,
0.009184049442410469,
0.9299752712249756,
-0.6460500955581665,
0.7891920208930969,
0.6607198119163513,
-0.6692918539047241,
-1.1326438188552856,
0.3653695285320282,
-0.14258792996406555,
-0.5260567665100098,
0.6029890179634094,
0.2926265001296997,
-0.6129497289657593,
0.13834664225578308,
-0.31580692529678345,
-0.8154162168502808,
1.3308907747268677,
0.17682324349880219,
-0.938199520111084,
-0.006281902547925711,
-0.407693475484848,
0.5134949088096619,
-0.7644551992416382,
0.45276230573654175,
0.9770089387893677,
0.1684533953666687,
-0.10796437412500381,
-0.9364978075027466,
0.3835058808326721,
-0.12174522131681442,
0.18298746645450592,
0.7443076968193054,
-0.4235076904296875,
0.8104543685913086,
-0.13961158692836761,
-0.2942763864994049,
-0.030009565874934196,
0.7231119275093079,
0.7771205902099609,
0.51894611120224,
0.8310037851333618,
0.36563390493392944,
0.8679990768432617,
0.1155075803399086,
0.8954563140869141,
-0.20398131012916565,
0.5368260741233826,
1.438334345817566,
-0.4334245026111603,
1.1795936822891235,
0.7180185317993164,
-0.2912355661392212,
0.8686865568161011,
0.29751908779144287,
0.5474188923835754,
0.18342094123363495,
0.08755242079496384,
-0.2659474313259125,
-0.22985579073429108,
-0.1323777735233307,
-0.362806111574173,
0.1248553916811943,
0.5719203948974609,
-0.2853131592273712,
0.01852313242852688,
-0.22753123939037323,
0.22945299744606018,
0.14849144220352173,
-0.43063369393348694,
0.7686361074447632,
0.3535776138305664,
-0.6581034660339355,
0.2663044035434723,
-0.4290403127670288,
0.45850613713264465,
-0.26920437812805176,
-0.36787980794906616,
-0.03179651126265526,
0.11567060649394989,
-0.08327095210552216,
-0.759441077709198,
0.11073510348796844,
0.4124322533607483,
0.09717582911252975,
-0.04692218452692032,
0.6319664716720581,
-0.5117952227592468,
-0.34074416756629944,
0.5969099402427673,
0.8107163310050964,
-0.03640247508883476,
0.10166820883750916,
-0.5640789270401001,
0.07580998539924622,
-0.37431803345680237,
-0.35830432176589966,
-0.11950687319040298,
0.8110033869743347,
-0.2899395525455475,
0.5877731442451477,
0.46762990951538086,
0.168686181306839,
-0.2070430964231491,
0.16448310017585754,
0.9818143844604492,
-1.0346800088882446,
-0.678926408290863,
-1.0972422361373901,
0.4751288592815399,
-0.42689594626426697,
-0.3452835977077484,
0.3474794328212738,
0.35545775294303894,
0.9054410457611084,
0.26595884561538696,
0.5526981353759766,
-0.35196012258529663,
0.44963717460632324,
-1.0235689878463745,
0.21027906239032745,
-0.28617534041404724,
0.7689900398254395,
-0.6227850914001465,
-1.2216567993164062,
-0.1619226038455963,
0.6054127216339111,
-0.4149317443370819,
0.12416817247867584,
1.4574658870697021,
0.5313221216201782,
0.10950350016355515,
0.14980284869670868,
-0.07351147383451462,
0.18312835693359375,
0.544989287853241,
0.8142535090446472,
1.088147759437561,
-0.313101589679718,
0.5334264039993286,
-0.0027378019876778126,
-0.2561042904853821,
0.29204174876213074,
-0.849495530128479,
-1.0457395315170288,
-0.5123836994171143,
-0.18616770207881927,
-0.2831747233867645,
0.17520980536937714,
1.410823106765747,
0.44479435682296753,
-0.6804077625274658,
-0.1424446851015091,
-0.41060900688171387,
0.054784562438726425,
-0.2860548794269562,
-0.21301497519016266,
0.4578324556350708,
-0.5713104605674744,
-0.6203598380088806,
0.26850101351737976,
0.4417297840118408,
-0.31910595297813416,
-0.29034891724586487,
0.014955315738916397,
-0.610480785369873,
0.2110443264245987,
0.7269741892814636,
-0.31634074449539185,
-0.8985260128974915,
-0.41237136721611023,
-0.14475086331367493,
0.06411992758512497,
-0.023861221969127655,
1.0699800252914429,
-0.7891787886619568,
0.38934069871902466,
0.38671866059303284,
0.5138261318206787,
0.5130946636199951,
0.10413981229066849,
0.8327233195304871,
-0.7528060078620911,
0.057782985270023346,
0.16222362220287323,
0.6384603977203369,
0.15506228804588318,
-0.6850886344909668,
0.7723577618598938,
-0.1350054144859314,
-0.4170404374599457,
-0.5550791025161743,
0.30727899074554443,
-0.8913546204566956,
-0.3761926591396332,
1.0198512077331543,
-0.29403430223464966,
-0.4452117383480072,
-0.3044525682926178,
-0.45364001393318176,
0.41950446367263794,
-0.6058467030525208,
0.591931164264679,
0.6269850134849548,
-0.4929931163787842,
-0.15654191374778748,
-0.622912585735321,
0.3599262833595276,
0.3700074851512909,
-1.2699066400527954,
0.0675937682390213,
0.32522764801979065,
0.16243520379066467,
0.19770541787147522,
0.9652301073074341,
-0.13919207453727722,
0.08464309573173523,
-0.15004776418209076,
-0.16513344645500183,
0.30246028304100037,
-0.62916499376297,
-0.00042971016955561936,
0.06250419467687607,
0.21749456226825714,
-0.15462371706962585
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06925v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06925v1
|
Simplicity Bias of Transformers to Learn Low Sensitivity Functions
| 2024-03-11T17:12:09 | 2024-03-11T17:12:09 |
Bhavya Vasudeva, Deqing Fu, Tianyi Zhou, Elliott Kau, Youqi Huang, Vatsal Sharan
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
Transformers achieve state-of-the-art accuracy and robustness across many
tasks, but an understanding of the inductive biases that they have and how
those biases are different from other neural network architectures remains
elusive. Various neural network architectures such as fully connected networks
have been found to have a simplicity bias towards simple functions of the data;
one version of this simplicity bias is a spectral bias to learn simple
functions in the Fourier space. In this work, we identify the notion of
sensitivity of the model to random changes in the input as a notion of
simplicity bias which provides a unified metric to explain the simplicity and
spectral bias of transformers across different data modalities. We show that
transformers have lower sensitivity than alternative architectures, such as
LSTMs, MLPs and CNNs, across both vision and language tasks. We also show that
low-sensitivity bias correlates with improved robustness; furthermore, it can
also be used as an efficient intervention to further improve the robustness of
transformers.
|
[
-0.7428827881813049,
-0.36241230368614197,
0.3338748812675476,
-0.03601055219769478,
0.21396544575691223,
-0.5239009261131287,
-0.31925082206726074,
-0.18799538910388947,
0.02979911118745804,
0.020368097350001335,
-0.7860223650932312,
-0.29035183787345886,
-0.3797576129436493,
-0.04726371914148331,
-0.4303654730319977,
0.9126174449920654,
0.42248275876045227,
0.10554540157318115,
-0.029537515714764595,
-0.4554187059402466,
-0.01650228537619114,
-0.08159522712230682,
-0.33607348799705505,
-0.6967992186546326,
0.851215660572052,
0.3860609531402588,
0.7936797142028809,
0.253744512796402,
0.7211519479751587,
0.2405172437429428,
-0.1787670999765396,
-0.4113653600215912,
-0.19834211468696594,
0.07627783715724945,
-0.007638458162546158,
-0.8911692500114441,
-0.012804382480680943,
-0.49443915486335754,
0.40304526686668396,
1.0287524461746216,
0.18183499574661255,
0.5075029134750366,
0.6348291635513306,
0.9531143307685852,
-0.7371336221694946,
0.10158062726259232,
-0.7157411575317383,
0.28238171339035034,
-0.1961178481578827,
0.07799390703439713,
-0.5214813351631165,
0.06358655542135239,
0.23959966003894806,
-0.5761469006538391,
0.8117779493331909,
-0.3399551510810852,
0.6272557377815247,
0.8830426335334778,
-0.4824395477771759,
-0.07488153129816055,
-0.9849796295166016,
0.7699247598648071,
-0.22453467547893524,
0.49937084317207336,
-0.01031612977385521,
0.384714812040329,
0.1506580114364624,
-0.9415626525878906,
-0.22711749374866486,
-0.1817089170217514,
-0.22173544764518738,
0.21118760108947754,
-0.38154974579811096,
0.13246771693229675,
0.6295941472053528,
-0.009424358606338501,
-0.06370916962623596,
0.3017210066318512,
-0.25960564613342285,
-0.35947978496551514,
0.04334516450762749,
0.053012631833553314,
-0.15334707498550415,
-0.3626362383365631,
-0.4497055113315582,
-0.37198606133461,
-0.5952828526496887,
0.4883902370929718,
0.6015240550041199,
0.37564921379089355,
-0.26448535919189453,
0.4149572253227234,
0.005197176244109869,
0.4594478905200958,
0.243846133351326,
-0.07413158565759659,
0.05918483808636665,
-0.13529472053050995,
-0.3024046719074249,
-0.16667281091213226,
0.6009203791618347,
-0.11229181289672852,
0.2568202316761017,
-0.03416410833597183,
-0.2640152871608734,
0.1795135885477066,
0.5935277342796326,
-0.352759450674057,
-0.5386202931404114,
-0.2521972358226776,
-0.6944098472595215,
-0.44834446907043457,
-0.24976219236850739,
-0.6674116253852844,
-0.4027220606803894,
-0.3696023225784302,
0.5370156764984131,
-0.18158385157585144,
0.2896179258823395,
-0.21047870814800262,
0.03348991647362709,
0.5343796610832214,
0.33952876925468445,
-1.100817322731018,
0.4742310047149658,
0.30992361903190613,
0.498015820980072,
-0.3247932493686676,
-0.1528151035308838,
-0.2403407245874405,
-0.21358613669872284,
-0.05605672299861908,
0.7331416606903076,
0.07036154717206955,
-0.19658704102039337,
-0.27388593554496765,
-0.34715890884399414,
-0.15887878835201263,
-0.4817071855068207,
0.8715512156486511,
-0.3446844816207886,
-0.132102832198143,
-0.18863259255886078,
0.16614875197410583,
-0.027838507667183876,
-0.24177195131778717,
-0.9867885708808899,
1.0107753276824951,
0.23012609779834747,
-0.9917147755622864,
0.5157023668289185,
-0.6571996212005615,
-0.6456379294395447,
-0.3467993438243866,
-0.17601163685321808,
-0.6753082871437073,
0.30359867215156555,
0.17793041467666626,
0.1442604660987854,
-0.023959215730428696,
-0.19162246584892273,
-0.5408614873886108,
-0.535143256187439,
0.3578425943851471,
-0.9112508893013,
0.9083095192909241,
0.39105701446533203,
-0.4744379222393036,
0.09260378777980804,
-0.8283917307853699,
-0.1865227073431015,
-0.14678995311260223,
-0.32698097825050354,
-0.2055300921201706,
0.05548891797661781,
0.07112228870391846,
0.011147035285830498,
-0.1513262689113617,
-0.4097038805484772,
-0.041734177619218826,
-0.4417368769645691,
0.24924740195274353,
0.8919166326522827,
-0.32592639327049255,
0.9037129878997803,
-0.3356315791606903,
0.17426368594169617,
0.3085784316062927,
0.39841699600219727,
0.06264632195234299,
-0.392373651266098,
-1.1254494190216064,
-0.31032973527908325,
0.29882940649986267,
0.41031718254089355,
-0.6769663095474243,
0.26986265182495117,
-0.38726991415023804,
-0.31654563546180725,
-0.6145904064178467,
0.5158418416976929,
-0.08584512770175934,
0.7667611837387085,
0.2652854323387146,
-0.28860563039779663,
-0.32688063383102417,
-1.228402018547058,
-0.36451539397239685,
0.07493159174919128,
-0.5394331216812134,
0.3193279802799225,
0.22930137813091278,
-0.2023850977420807,
0.9033086895942688,
-0.41395923495292664,
-0.5045512914657593,
-0.09073862433433533,
-0.147242471575737,
0.3709864318370819,
0.27186688780784607,
0.6056280136108398,
-0.7216872572898865,
-0.44867390394210815,
-0.1774476021528244,
-0.5355525016784668,
0.12879933416843414,
0.02239074930548668,
0.027478745207190514,
-0.11764601618051529,
0.3981173038482666,
-0.6788609027862549,
0.6172538995742798,
0.03699984401464462,
0.30370640754699707,
0.07298821955919266,
0.48287108540534973,
-0.3399026691913605,
-0.8088958263397217,
0.21236197650432587,
0.2716962695121765,
-0.13617399334907532,
-0.8931599259376526,
-0.022126322612166405,
-0.06234830245375633,
0.01774703897535801,
-0.7869479060173035,
0.05288950353860855,
-0.05199045687913895,
-0.18448767066001892,
0.07661053538322449,
-0.10728730261325836,
-0.2688847482204437,
0.8476541638374329,
-0.3060872256755829,
0.590542197227478,
0.7103739976882935,
-0.8307167291641235,
0.15244850516319275,
0.188895121216774,
-0.20912189781665802,
0.4431340992450714,
-0.7450184226036072,
0.0181156937032938,
-0.4293263256549835,
-0.20544058084487915,
-1.0517860651016235,
-0.19019445776939392,
0.20462796092033386,
-0.4041544795036316,
0.3161219656467438,
-0.3501369059085846,
-0.05756634473800659,
-0.3629167377948761,
-0.40309929847717285,
0.402445524930954,
0.7055005431175232,
-0.6580983996391296,
0.6521195769309998,
-0.11020159721374512,
0.2924257516860962,
-0.7518066167831421,
-0.9669606685638428,
-0.49076980352401733,
-0.23739193379878998,
-0.6201915144920349,
-0.0013749017380177975,
-0.014362482354044914,
-0.25471624732017517,
-0.20733578503131866,
-0.43488481640815735,
0.006508766207844019,
0.5256004929542542,
0.3798104524612427,
0.05485009774565697,
-0.4175981283187866,
0.14618365466594696,
-0.11747989803552628,
-0.25879645347595215,
0.003060214454308152,
-0.20240850746631622,
0.5370065569877625,
-0.21618466079235077,
-0.7976769208908081,
-0.36724331974983215,
-0.012192822992801666,
0.38310688734054565,
0.3592691123485565,
0.15862281620502472,
0.6538311839103699,
-0.2464708685874939,
-0.5823572278022766,
-0.13623397052288055,
-0.7160245776176453,
-0.618200957775116,
0.14236614108085632,
-0.43928930163383484,
-0.7586297988891602,
0.5580096244812012,
0.0019772604573518038,
-0.21611273288726807,
0.7549597024917603,
0.6889522671699524,
-0.411878764629364,
0.753297746181488,
0.6277337074279785,
0.06111730635166168,
0.4804151952266693,
-0.0636448934674263,
0.30373066663742065,
-0.6678633093833923,
0.06235175579786301,
-0.7516881823539734,
-0.900501549243927,
-0.8693994283676147,
0.1281883716583252,
0.5116718411445618,
-0.30113571882247925,
-0.5835564136505127,
0.18326599895954132,
-0.6772416830062866,
0.2921871542930603,
0.9690767526626587,
0.3260239362716675,
0.06428609788417816,
0.4186500012874603,
-0.17537164688110352,
-0.26875606179237366,
-0.9234764575958252,
-0.23597025871276855,
1.1007338762283325,
0.5772128701210022,
1.3182185888290405,
0.002742130309343338,
0.5486879348754883,
0.30602145195007324,
0.2070392370223999,
-1.0275501012802124,
0.118927963078022,
-0.2054915875196457,
-0.338915079832077,
-0.17978797852993011,
-0.295348584651947,
-0.8071872591972351,
-0.06663358211517334,
-0.1707405149936676,
-0.6904021501541138,
0.6777985095977783,
0.4689582586288452,
-0.5482260584831238,
0.3251798450946808,
-0.7951986789703369,
0.40928876399993896,
0.02995477057993412,
-0.39530742168426514,
0.46176356077194214,
-0.930477499961853,
0.3844476044178009,
-0.02818514220416546,
-0.17394478619098663,
0.2931680679321289,
0.1328766793012619,
0.41066935658454895,
-0.036388274282217026,
1.3723597526550293,
-0.11133579909801483,
0.1706373393535614,
0.29860764741897583,
0.25940456986427307,
0.39460489153862,
-0.07253484427928925,
-0.033237993717193604,
0.1928064227104187,
-0.4105773866176605,
-0.41934874653816223,
-0.4152824580669403,
0.5159373879432678,
-1.000541090965271,
-0.40567466616630554,
-0.16239705681800842,
-0.3709936738014221,
-0.36165621876716614,
0.2758253514766693,
0.7405374050140381,
0.1032194271683693,
-0.042512401938438416,
0.5305546522140503,
1.0372207164764404,
0.08282613754272461,
0.781145453453064,
-0.016702275723218918,
0.19780445098876953,
0.0876912921667099,
0.37038421630859375,
0.0142848901450634,
0.47982439398765564,
0.3379952013492584,
0.04388725012540817,
-0.025212982669472694,
-0.17480674386024475,
-0.23360508680343628,
-0.3013899326324463,
-0.987838864326477,
-0.2703896760940552,
-0.5087487697601318,
-0.3069216310977936,
-0.034998923540115356,
-0.13001354038715363,
-0.4803939759731293,
-0.6353366374969482,
-0.34957435727119446,
-0.20886580646038055,
0.06955762207508087,
0.602385401725769,
0.05070317164063454,
0.7139561772346497,
-0.24519596993923187,
0.5126686096191406,
0.7245281934738159,
0.5300796031951904,
0.16364642977714539,
-0.6060150861740112,
-0.16130374372005463,
0.17227666079998016,
-0.5954656004905701,
-0.5240800380706787,
0.06757422536611557,
0.4041444659233093,
0.4377397298812866,
0.49743834137916565,
0.011483248323202133,
0.11004898697137833,
-0.2018449455499649,
0.6699001789093018,
0.3382173180580139,
-1.0549886226654053,
0.3382101356983185,
-0.1951041966676712,
0.4058375656604767,
0.760536253452301,
0.1579073667526245,
-0.05375523120164871,
0.05784410983324051,
-0.36304792761802673,
-0.5575965642929077,
0.7611687183380127,
0.24117334187030792,
0.3665153682231903,
0.5007607936859131,
0.304618239402771,
0.19217318296432495,
0.38532599806785583,
-1.0305745601654053,
-0.8025915026664734,
-0.4951467514038086,
-0.30621713399887085,
0.14999066293239594,
0.057235512882471085,
-0.5691660046577454,
-0.2838073670864105,
0.13518698513507843,
-0.5286201238632202,
0.7673189640045166,
0.23240242898464203,
-0.264247864484787,
-0.3261851966381073,
0.353369802236557,
0.6627758145332336,
0.23158665001392365,
-0.03301404416561127,
0.5373630523681641,
0.5303356051445007,
-0.6816064119338989,
0.25995776057243347,
-0.3209008276462555,
-0.6397923231124878,
0.004065138287842274,
0.4572729766368866,
1.0336946249008179,
0.25815773010253906,
0.1053866595029831,
0.6940833330154419,
-0.0691685676574707,
-0.15848521888256073,
-0.28786414861679077,
0.23246417939662933,
0.016750385984778404,
-0.0590038038790226,
0.537533700466156,
1.1086021661758423,
0.21416008472442627,
-0.1549312323331833,
0.4740216135978699,
0.4086373746395111,
-0.8638314604759216,
-0.3825313150882721,
0.738053560256958,
0.012485234998166561,
-0.16998688876628876,
0.5056340098381042,
0.17741814255714417,
-0.3726293444633484,
0.762965738773346,
0.3596225678920746,
1.0630844831466675,
-0.010005486197769642,
-0.013672500848770142,
-0.007740864064544439,
0.725845992565155,
0.2662922739982605,
0.06528666615486145,
-0.20822393894195557,
-0.8499134182929993,
-0.3287380039691925,
-0.5772691965103149,
-0.04528692364692688,
-0.22411979734897614,
-0.8908587694168091,
0.4808582365512848,
-0.6465209126472473,
-0.4083843529224396,
0.08573466539382935,
-0.44296202063560486,
-1.2925881147384644,
0.10600542277097702,
0.07620644569396973,
0.8919152021408081,
-0.8992191553115845,
0.8352260589599609,
0.5257135629653931,
-0.2661924958229065,
-0.9394873976707458,
0.0975799635052681,
0.03221588581800461,
-0.9541797041893005,
0.8273597955703735,
0.11172718554735184,
-0.24920795857906342,
0.017500389367341995,
-0.6684824228286743,
-0.7594690918922424,
1.028236746788025,
0.6921527981758118,
-0.3841645121574402,
0.045637380331754684,
0.3853256106376648,
0.7160502076148987,
-0.15867987275123596,
0.26837876439094543,
0.3498052954673767,
0.4866410791873932,
0.007610216736793518,
-0.6289438009262085,
-0.3314264416694641,
-0.1328504979610443,
-0.09641753882169724,
0.1910324990749359,
-0.6147323846817017,
0.9643929600715637,
-0.1127203181385994,
-0.16251876950263977,
-0.2691406309604645,
0.5178420543670654,
-0.5740211606025696,
0.45086365938186646,
0.4361002743244171,
0.62738436460495,
0.3414754569530487,
-0.4300015866756439,
0.9760262370109558,
-0.192569300532341,
0.5305934548377991,
0.8276169300079346,
-0.09847943484783173,
0.38359391689300537,
0.6921994090080261,
-0.36738863587379456,
0.30002593994140625,
0.22963985800743103,
-0.14715026319026947,
0.6827194094657898,
0.12954241037368774,
-0.26016804575920105,
-0.2502095401287079,
0.09065797179937363,
-0.01720874197781086,
0.44363489747047424,
0.21288995444774628,
-0.3821265399456024,
-0.21277925372123718,
0.35243287682533264,
-0.20350264012813568,
-0.16379155218601227,
-0.5423811674118042,
0.8910008072853088,
0.44172292947769165,
-0.42907118797302246,
0.40183791518211365,
-0.3135184049606323,
0.8788214921951294,
-0.6638056039810181,
0.41506528854370117,
-0.1684103161096573,
0.3231408894062042,
-0.5687844753265381,
-0.5422317981719971,
0.34058457612991333,
-0.41912129521369934,
-0.46056851744651794,
0.09057363122701645,
0.9415351748466492,
0.10377436131238937,
-0.32061567902565,
0.4114649295806885,
0.2758660316467285,
-0.6300686001777649,
0.24008898437023163,
-0.3892737925052643,
-0.09693349152803421,
0.19399702548980713,
-0.36658167839050293,
0.23994295299053192,
-0.0002677784359548241,
0.18691642582416534,
0.9799221158027649,
0.569413423538208,
-0.07011696696281433,
0.5214816927909851,
-0.023617025464773178,
0.7451506853103638,
-0.42195266485214233,
-0.11131840944290161,
-0.6856003999710083,
0.48817315697669983,
0.18717403709888458,
-0.33596929907798767,
0.6226210594177246,
0.14584170281887054,
0.7939385771751404,
-0.4679219722747803,
0.7435534596443176,
0.09824878722429276,
0.32015401124954224,
-0.3782157599925995,
0.7052187919616699,
-0.35555213689804077,
0.5242083072662354,
-0.11876276880502701,
-1.0889629125595093,
-0.5803899765014648,
0.5139623880386353,
-0.06614375114440918,
0.1795179396867752,
0.7012758255004883,
0.8723440766334534,
-0.6137202978134155,
-0.1832655370235443,
0.3759719729423523,
0.1677776575088501,
-0.030738590285182,
0.404583215713501,
0.456132173538208,
-0.557470977306366,
0.5984910726547241,
-0.7233482003211975,
0.22125263512134552,
-0.13595730066299438,
-0.6347549557685852,
-0.7430832386016846,
-0.41221871972084045,
-0.026209089905023575,
-0.40421420335769653,
-0.3357895314693451,
0.7730109691619873,
0.5963413119316101,
-1.0648239850997925,
0.042111799120903015,
-0.10768945515155792,
0.3324996531009674,
-0.1992378979921341,
-0.20849503576755524,
0.3833790123462677,
-0.4371172785758972,
-0.5310239791870117,
0.12986552715301514,
0.21442414820194244,
0.03008224442601204,
-0.23602809011936188,
0.022701190784573555,
0.22052599489688873,
0.20300394296646118,
0.4263074994087219,
0.38457828760147095,
-0.40880286693573,
-0.5936991572380066,
0.3780211806297302,
-0.4926869869232178,
0.37845465540885925,
0.8215513825416565,
-0.8686635494232178,
0.296367347240448,
0.47566357254981995,
0.5509901642799377,
0.4714777171611786,
-0.2698441445827484,
0.18646517395973206,
-1.006843090057373,
0.3569066822528839,
0.28375062346458435,
0.39487695693969727,
0.3993121087551117,
-0.40015557408332825,
0.3892878592014313,
0.280011385679245,
-0.4435529112815857,
-0.6769510507583618,
0.6260685920715332,
-1.2430853843688965,
0.11173291504383087,
0.8230627775192261,
0.2782597243785858,
-0.2981032729148865,
-0.08974310755729675,
-0.13801592588424683,
0.2156611829996109,
-0.10125456750392914,
0.7788333892822266,
0.37956634163856506,
-0.1060185357928276,
-0.1305263191461563,
-0.38452786207199097,
0.8489445447921753,
0.7626543641090393,
-0.308806836605072,
-0.3967381417751312,
0.1270420402288437,
0.39806193113327026,
0.35094380378723145,
0.0513559989631176,
0.09835834056138992,
0.50935298204422,
0.09575310349464417,
0.05690979212522507,
0.1945379227399826,
-0.31301867961883545,
-0.8308919668197632,
0.4833548963069916,
0.36539119482040405,
-0.04216986522078514
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06914v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06914v2
|
MEND: Meta dEmonstratioN Distillation for Efficient and Effective In-Context Learning
| 2024-03-11T17:03:04 | 2024-03-12T15:52:14 |
Yichuan Li, Xiyao Ma, Sixing Lu, Kyumin Lee, Xiaohu Liu, Chenlei Guo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive in-context learning
(ICL) capabilities, where a LLM makes predictions for a given test input
together with a few input-output pairs (demonstrations). Nevertheless, the
inclusion of demonstrations leads to a quadratic increase in the computational
overhead of the self-attention mechanism. Existing solutions attempt to distill
lengthy demonstrations into compact vectors. However, they often require
task-specific retraining or compromise LLM's in-context learning performance.
To mitigate these challenges, we present Meta dEmonstratioN Distillation
(MEND), where a language model learns to distill any lengthy demonstrations
into vectors without retraining for a new downstream task. We exploit the
knowledge distillation to enhance alignment between MEND and LLM, achieving
both efficiency and effectiveness simultaneously. MEND is endowed with the
meta-knowledge of distilling demonstrations through a two-stage training
process, which includes meta-distillation pretraining and fine-tuning.
Comprehensive evaluations across seven diverse ICL task partitions using
decoder-only (GPT-2) and encoder-decoder (T5) attest to MEND's prowess. It not
only matches but often outperforms the Vanilla ICL as well as other
state-of-the-art distillation models, while significantly reducing the
computational demands. This innovation promises enhanced scalability and
efficiency for the practical deployment of large language models
|
[
-0.3513709008693695,
-0.7364272475242615,
0.4690018594264984,
0.3411957025527954,
-0.5329652428627014,
0.17109191417694092,
-0.3308071196079254,
0.12095465511083603,
-0.18068966269493103,
0.14986974000930786,
-0.6041786670684814,
-0.4011656641960144,
-0.6800971627235413,
0.1051260381937027,
-0.4438977539539337,
1.130272388458252,
-0.1382458359003067,
-0.11146598309278488,
-0.604585587978363,
-0.1553497612476349,
-0.5591012239456177,
-0.4017188549041748,
-0.461256206035614,
-0.6052253246307373,
0.18264655768871307,
0.6254063248634338,
0.03608018532395363,
0.4603623151779175,
0.2315923124551773,
0.3390394449234009,
0.12178505212068558,
0.2460210770368576,
-0.5209986567497253,
0.18071624636650085,
-0.27485743165016174,
-0.19461973011493683,
-0.27559858560562134,
0.1845090687274933,
0.48576346039772034,
0.7716612219810486,
-0.3817974627017975,
0.4273228645324707,
0.7422924637794495,
0.5996424555778503,
-0.904117226600647,
0.19200068712234497,
-0.6451766490936279,
-0.11781361699104309,
-0.19075070321559906,
0.04533613100647926,
-0.4715701937675476,
-0.08779384195804596,
0.3276444971561432,
-0.2862744927406311,
0.1724999099969864,
-0.2274310439825058,
0.4094277024269104,
0.672942042350769,
-0.3956139385700226,
-0.10986105352640152,
-0.7946814298629761,
0.7620422840118408,
-0.7646869421005249,
0.3045329749584198,
0.3104877471923828,
0.610252857208252,
0.03838373348116875,
-0.9905327558517456,
-0.5353224873542786,
-0.0537569522857666,
-0.15651120245456696,
0.04418199136853218,
-0.1509561836719513,
-0.08216314762830734,
0.35482728481292725,
0.17489571869373322,
-0.4073016047477722,
-0.15349848568439484,
-0.14993959665298462,
-0.05790717527270317,
0.25359484553337097,
0.040025461465120316,
0.07989208400249481,
0.16633188724517822,
-0.468647301197052,
-0.13343068957328796,
-0.6849130392074585,
-0.09362836182117462,
-0.15371383726596832,
0.08192168176174164,
0.004252471495419741,
0.3650663495063782,
-0.3075328767299652,
0.6462905406951904,
0.5936627388000488,
-0.4010429084300995,
0.268179714679718,
-0.18410243093967438,
-0.4115201234817505,
0.04255172610282898,
0.8541325926780701,
0.1684252768754959,
-0.17454640567302704,
-0.13694295287132263,
-0.1947338730096817,
-0.158718079328537,
0.09137409180402756,
-1.0885883569717407,
-0.21142390370368958,
0.04923878237605095,
-0.2871195375919342,
-0.20300328731536865,
-0.10501176863908768,
-0.7127031087875366,
-0.13002066314220428,
-0.5443291068077087,
0.7418529391288757,
-0.34786659479141235,
-0.24851912260055542,
0.1353445202112198,
-0.25426560640335083,
0.028939420357346535,
0.113008514046669,
-1.0080432891845703,
0.18487580120563507,
0.7178690433502197,
0.8108314871788025,
-0.015238198451697826,
-0.4283139705657959,
-0.6945800185203552,
0.47412100434303284,
-0.0600467175245285,
0.4204719066619873,
-0.4357835352420807,
-0.19297350943088531,
-0.2657790780067444,
-0.07581999897956848,
-0.06118208169937134,
-0.6717396378517151,
0.43577292561531067,
-0.22975124418735504,
0.21684303879737854,
-0.2917160987854004,
-0.5801609754562378,
-0.13721705973148346,
0.331712543964386,
-0.4323418140411377,
0.8071951270103455,
0.016988907009363174,
-0.9490815997123718,
0.4870656728744507,
-0.6927260756492615,
-0.6377567052841187,
-0.2167423665523529,
-0.343014657497406,
-0.40863940119743347,
0.22748863697052002,
0.31550002098083496,
0.5890774130821228,
-0.27369508147239685,
0.4710524380207062,
-0.30665650963783264,
-0.19985395669937134,
0.07943421602249146,
-0.6313921809196472,
0.4879189729690552,
0.1900794804096222,
-0.8281198143959045,
0.03412308543920517,
-0.5914707183837891,
-0.3242354393005371,
-0.05309547483921051,
-0.35044634342193604,
-0.42977848649024963,
0.13227929174900055,
-0.3264364004135132,
0.35604915022850037,
0.18626733124256134,
-0.34499165415763855,
0.2683289349079132,
-0.3335663974285126,
0.6292399764060974,
0.6375734210014343,
-0.2718672454357147,
0.5303376317024231,
-0.0046576764434576035,
0.4522686004638672,
0.02535427175462246,
0.15043963491916656,
-0.22883349657058716,
-0.002364779356867075,
-0.7271061539649963,
-0.3554914593696594,
0.23395682871341705,
0.33599212765693665,
-1.0949857234954834,
0.17419731616973877,
-0.35329344868659973,
-0.329860121011734,
-0.46230024099349976,
0.2651938498020172,
0.704123854637146,
0.9395594596862793,
0.4305771291255951,
0.15471020340919495,
-0.3145800828933716,
-0.8848894238471985,
-0.15448151528835297,
0.14420458674430847,
-0.12632228434085846,
-0.05068909749388695,
0.4270840883255005,
-0.260904461145401,
1.046886682510376,
-0.4903702139854431,
-0.3784896433353424,
-0.490505576133728,
0.4756706655025482,
0.1905684620141983,
0.2774375081062317,
0.5342268347740173,
-0.6292456388473511,
-0.8883100748062134,
-0.10499653965234756,
-0.6421287059783936,
-0.41322061419487,
0.08390413224697113,
0.06934235244989395,
0.03746362775564194,
0.8406035900115967,
-0.2098703384399414,
0.2441057413816452,
0.7060872912406921,
-0.14733654260635376,
0.4624529778957367,
-0.4039900600910187,
0.13952408730983734,
-1.2565641403198242,
0.020261935889720917,
-0.34920814633369446,
-0.4855552613735199,
-0.5391578674316406,
-0.12092828750610352,
0.2621479630470276,
-0.000213155202800408,
-0.5039415955543518,
0.4243032932281494,
-0.5699703693389893,
0.023416442796587944,
-0.6725896596908569,
0.08236484229564667,
0.11206095665693283,
0.43511632084846497,
0.0832839235663414,
0.8161325454711914,
0.6009384989738464,
-0.705045759677887,
0.15662308037281036,
0.020014818757772446,
-0.3940674960613251,
0.47417184710502625,
-0.6308419108390808,
0.11732132732868195,
-0.10363747924566269,
0.3771417737007141,
-1.0023311376571655,
-0.12590427696704865,
0.06425433605909348,
-0.03585420921444893,
0.5933492183685303,
-0.21725314855575562,
-0.25527307391166687,
-0.24866852164268494,
-0.1917877495288849,
0.5984915494918823,
0.5931596159934998,
-0.7549152374267578,
0.7410959005355835,
0.1181703731417656,
0.10771582275629044,
-0.9717970490455627,
-0.7349188327789307,
-0.0045082406140863895,
-0.5433346033096313,
-0.36355531215667725,
0.3231457769870758,
-0.04792448505759239,
-0.10102604329586029,
-0.15428955852985382,
-0.1772504299879074,
0.12585465610027313,
0.2631521224975586,
0.22918878495693207,
-0.23146404325962067,
0.09577115625143051,
0.11653734743595123,
0.30003079771995544,
-0.3355967700481415,
-0.049299318343400955,
-0.4860757291316986,
0.629325270652771,
0.05374739319086075,
-0.6472395062446594,
-0.6069287061691284,
0.2788170874118805,
0.7912158370018005,
-0.2686646580696106,
0.7357994318008423,
0.7572765946388245,
-0.20138609409332275,
-0.2745197117328644,
-0.4680505394935608,
-0.3315342366695404,
-0.5146539807319641,
0.44014230370521545,
-0.4710257053375244,
-0.914193868637085,
0.14574041962623596,
-0.4597707688808441,
0.3378729820251465,
0.24138188362121582,
0.44009554386138916,
-0.3013285994529724,
0.9150683283805847,
0.5296400189399719,
-0.17167605459690094,
0.5583510398864746,
-0.38132327795028687,
0.02424667403101921,
-1.037216305732727,
-0.08140568435192108,
-0.24533474445343018,
-0.6544167995452881,
0.09573481976985931,
-0.6343183517456055,
0.5353376269340515,
0.23875899612903595,
-0.12772993743419647,
0.28509339690208435,
-0.26106521487236023,
0.7156819105148315,
0.5516661405563354,
0.12133084982633591,
0.2065480798482895,
-0.12885038554668427,
-0.2014601081609726,
-0.1610870063304901,
-0.6915996074676514,
-0.4872288107872009,
1.1777479648590088,
0.1474204659461975,
0.8433627486228943,
0.12074185162782669,
0.8702720999717712,
0.2652204930782318,
0.381462037563324,
-0.41880175471305847,
0.43609029054641724,
-0.4033358097076416,
-0.33446991443634033,
-0.39711976051330566,
-0.28789278864860535,
-0.6702972054481506,
0.30161401629447937,
0.05988869071006775,
-0.32527807354927063,
0.0907367393374443,
0.5536837577819824,
-0.3163360357284546,
0.22135613858699799,
-0.7178745865821838,
1.0983175039291382,
-0.26318100094795227,
-0.4203808307647705,
-0.4599062502384186,
-0.6556954383850098,
0.5254099369049072,
-0.15017548203468323,
0.3174687623977661,
0.14399991929531097,
0.14595428109169006,
0.4764217138290405,
-0.4951833188533783,
1.0679148435592651,
-0.4042972922325134,
-0.2604018747806549,
0.27422118186950684,
0.16788050532341003,
0.6436434984207153,
-0.07013171911239624,
0.22861334681510925,
-0.2722424864768982,
-0.2657754719257355,
-0.1642044186592102,
-0.7323242425918579,
0.5049801468849182,
-0.43320152163505554,
-0.73729008436203,
-0.04886425659060478,
-0.2680526673793793,
-0.0589732825756073,
-0.07203560322523117,
0.38534897565841675,
0.7000834345817566,
-0.3296752870082855,
0.36898666620254517,
0.8822706937789917,
-0.15064360201358795,
0.6916949152946472,
0.4420562982559204,
-0.2801332175731659,
-0.3497569262981415,
0.9399187564849854,
-0.08495165407657623,
0.7848940491676331,
0.5579012632369995,
0.38497623801231384,
-0.48607271909713745,
-0.5425794124603271,
-0.35240283608436584,
-0.05794869363307953,
-0.7171521186828613,
-0.16717784106731415,
-0.8043718934059143,
0.0931800827383995,
-0.35305526852607727,
0.037891898304224014,
-0.49364644289016724,
-0.30133557319641113,
-0.34347668290138245,
-0.06884286552667618,
0.028262605890631676,
0.4884110987186432,
-0.1446518748998642,
0.4688819646835327,
-0.6464969515800476,
0.4393899440765381,
0.8705492615699768,
0.0002797324559651315,
-0.016056420281529427,
-0.7077560424804688,
-0.31873682141304016,
0.30358225107192993,
-0.5288560390472412,
-0.7366886734962463,
0.16578105092048645,
0.7139330506324768,
0.5319985151290894,
0.9226834177970886,
0.22249780595302582,
0.9829957485198975,
-0.7991573810577393,
0.5831071138381958,
0.14468343555927277,
-1.2056822776794434,
0.6077107787132263,
-0.08488931506872177,
0.3170420527458191,
0.7195239067077637,
0.3089500665664673,
-0.43091660737991333,
-0.3948315382003784,
-0.35951656103134155,
-0.6468746066093445,
0.6468603610992432,
-0.13939940929412842,
0.05659571290016174,
-0.11015763878822327,
0.3434104919433594,
0.25269615650177,
0.25774329900741577,
-0.6848763227462769,
-0.12451490014791489,
-0.28375864028930664,
-0.29513630270957947,
-0.25465768575668335,
-0.38333961367607117,
-0.23513750731945038,
-0.42843031883239746,
0.654367208480835,
-0.3624115586280823,
-0.21582840383052826,
0.08242903649806976,
-0.5168896913528442,
0.3851403295993805,
0.22898130118846893,
0.7679682374000549,
0.6627541780471802,
0.04091271758079529,
0.49040552973747253,
0.4171247184276581,
-0.3085022568702698,
0.38244953751564026,
-0.22273863852024078,
0.07229676842689514,
-0.07364372909069061,
0.4459802508354187,
0.946300745010376,
0.47354045510292053,
-0.5870872139930725,
0.7474341988563538,
-0.18705330789089203,
-0.38952717185020447,
-0.04654359072446823,
-0.0044754547998309135,
0.32396870851516724,
0.6427444219589233,
0.21596671640872955,
-0.23305286467075348,
0.3549808859825134,
-0.5473103523254395,
0.3095329701900482,
0.5490270256996155,
-0.2295394092798233,
-0.35828495025634766,
0.7816528677940369,
0.328127920627594,
-0.021133093163371086,
0.4990074932575226,
-0.4131307899951935,
-0.6518848538398743,
0.30426377058029175,
0.662545382976532,
1.1408166885375977,
-0.37934553623199463,
0.23617230355739594,
0.3441006541252136,
0.1271645575761795,
-0.27192363142967224,
-0.059287603944540024,
-0.4566502571105957,
-0.41174837946891785,
-0.6149123311042786,
-0.6855388879776001,
-0.11452016234397888,
-0.021607419475913048,
-0.5657868981361389,
0.32066598534584045,
-0.20312754809856415,
-0.11961854249238968,
-0.2957186996936798,
-0.3136620819568634,
-0.38923633098602295,
-0.18250934779644012,
0.18415933847427368,
0.6956707239151001,
-1.1333422660827637,
1.0535656213760376,
0.4450615346431732,
-0.04338812455534935,
-0.5109782814979553,
0.18425624072551727,
-0.07939749211072922,
-0.4343070387840271,
0.8410213589668274,
0.28653615713119507,
-0.1816166639328003,
0.02368038333952427,
-0.39049652218818665,
-0.6444748044013977,
1.532171607017517,
0.7400256991386414,
-0.87373286485672,
0.1944764405488968,
0.16197282075881958,
0.3503083884716034,
-0.4410698413848877,
0.29063814878463745,
0.5404264330863953,
0.35353168845176697,
0.22135303914546967,
-1.0166865587234497,
0.001062213210389018,
0.22966593503952026,
-0.1767309606075287,
0.1529291421175003,
-0.7354615330696106,
0.7372018098831177,
-0.229159876704216,
-0.4017691910266876,
-0.3519260883331299,
0.7663194537162781,
0.2553836703300476,
0.3080080449581146,
0.7415253520011902,
0.676674485206604,
0.597087562084198,
-0.1910393089056015,
0.6592345833778381,
-0.07471193373203278,
0.29607534408569336,
1.574366569519043,
-0.356236070394516,
0.7713397741317749,
0.7022355794906616,
-0.09695925563573837,
0.547130823135376,
0.39891576766967773,
0.41660645604133606,
0.9734619855880737,
0.0838630199432373,
-0.42472216486930847,
-0.40555477142333984,
0.21174688637256622,
-0.21696019172668457,
0.43870434165000916,
0.24952374398708344,
-0.2519678473472595,
-0.4475294053554535,
0.5192968249320984,
-0.21102871000766754,
0.11427338421344757,
0.059848930686712265,
1.0942565202713013,
-0.011546655558049679,
-0.6280952095985413,
0.6261332035064697,
-0.23186041414737701,
0.732963502407074,
-0.5363127589225769,
-0.11183599382638931,
-0.23586057126522064,
0.3396012783050537,
0.021052993834018707,
-0.4211212396621704,
0.46017834544181824,
-0.037902962416410446,
-0.3888116180896759,
-0.47500279545783997,
0.3997260332107544,
-0.8448622822761536,
-0.28717315196990967,
0.2725464999675751,
0.2875458896160126,
0.13629643619060516,
-0.2812061309814453,
-0.48034369945526123,
-0.19115640223026276,
0.03456666320562363,
-0.03537773713469505,
0.5045649409294128,
0.744507372379303,
-0.013198243454098701,
0.8116155862808228,
0.34513601660728455,
-0.4509517252445221,
0.15459442138671875,
0.1488395631313324,
1.0105234384536743,
-0.19647780060768127,
-0.2953982949256897,
-1.4168905019760132,
0.5496324896812439,
-0.03683897852897644,
0.100920170545578,
0.6798998713493347,
0.5937780141830444,
0.7498959302902222,
-0.27910393476486206,
0.7296185493469238,
-0.1108269989490509,
0.4112776219844818,
-0.5362794995307922,
0.741482675075531,
-0.6140440702438354,
0.21862855553627014,
-0.3127257227897644,
-0.8423691987991333,
0.10559683293104172,
0.3527306616306305,
-0.040095265954732895,
-0.13811255991458893,
0.6818231344223022,
0.3248995542526245,
-0.42307353019714355,
-0.344131737947464,
0.2726665437221527,
0.12324230372905731,
0.5655956268310547,
0.6764938235282898,
0.9148611426353455,
-0.17954380810260773,
0.4946163296699524,
-0.3255308270454407,
-0.4266251027584076,
-0.18509477376937866,
-1.2307112216949463,
-1.1477707624435425,
-0.7541060447692871,
-0.36581340432167053,
0.11390586197376251,
-0.1827598661184311,
0.869077742099762,
0.8230359554290771,
-0.5689011216163635,
-0.2650010883808136,
-0.03749743476510048,
0.015796292573213577,
-0.4589860141277313,
-0.16466841101646423,
0.4228194057941437,
-0.6321630477905273,
-0.8538467288017273,
0.49357274174690247,
0.2204672396183014,
0.06823830306529999,
-0.23080742359161377,
-0.14301888644695282,
-0.1339958757162094,
-0.31933021545410156,
0.6984487771987915,
0.08950164914131165,
-0.6901069283485413,
-0.07368938624858856,
-0.2602141797542572,
0.15967071056365967,
-0.20836687088012695,
0.8660048842430115,
-0.8631137013435364,
0.4045100212097168,
0.4812919497489929,
0.7288191914558411,
0.6349682807922363,
0.08862806856632233,
0.7394701838493347,
-1.1509238481521606,
0.2366204708814621,
-0.11498140543699265,
0.3974480926990509,
0.20285984873771667,
0.010892779566347599,
0.3446958661079407,
0.10121890157461166,
-0.5590577721595764,
-0.7217551469802856,
0.13364295661449432,
-0.5746299624443054,
-0.3945426046848297,
1.0365840196609497,
-0.2616412937641144,
-0.14208470284938812,
-0.02480822615325451,
-0.26854556798934937,
0.35522472858428955,
-0.13133502006530762,
0.8591893911361694,
0.7118621468544006,
0.13666117191314697,
-0.15005631744861603,
-0.43663930892944336,
0.6561203002929688,
0.2796209156513214,
-0.7129103541374207,
0.5638540983200073,
0.295748770236969,
0.5889618396759033,
-0.04850063845515251,
0.46217912435531616,
0.1154477596282959,
-0.013386363163590431,
-0.4364515542984009,
0.09963538497686386,
-0.2842659056186676,
-0.6116366386413574,
-0.35594111680984497,
0.024113193154335022,
-0.08578821271657944,
-0.44471126794815063
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09714v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09714v1
|
Linguistic Structure Induction from Language Models
| 2024-03-11T16:54:49 | 2024-03-11T16:54:49 |
Omar Momen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Linear sequences of words are implicitly represented in our brains by
hierarchical structures that organize the composition of words in sentences.
Linguists formalize different frameworks to model this hierarchy; two of the
most common syntactic frameworks are Constituency and Dependency. Constituency
represents sentences as nested groups of phrases, while dependency represents a
sentence by assigning relations between its words. Recently, the pursuit of
intelligent machines has produced Language Models (LMs) capable of solving many
language tasks with a human-level performance. Many studies now question
whether LMs implicitly represent syntactic hierarchies. This thesis focuses on
producing constituency and dependency structures from LMs in an unsupervised
setting. I review the critical methods in this field and highlight a line of
work that utilizes a numerical representation for binary constituency trees
(Syntactic Distance). I present a detailed study on StructFormer (SF) (Shen et
al., 2021), which retrofits a transformer encoder architecture with a parser
network to produce constituency and dependency structures. I present six
experiments to analyze and address this field's challenges; experiments include
investigating the effect of repositioning the parser network within the SF
architecture, evaluating subword-based induced trees, and benchmarking the
models developed in the thesis experiments on linguistic tasks. Models
benchmarking is performed by participating in the BabyLM challenge, published
at CoNLL 2023 (Momen et al., 2023). The results of this thesis encourage
further development in the direction of retrofitting transformer-based models
to induce syntactic structures, supported by the acceptable performance of SF
in different experimental settings and the observed limitations that require
innovative solutions to advance the state of syntactic structure induction.
|
[
0.029120080173015594,
-0.6833526492118835,
0.5282650589942932,
0.1078425869345665,
0.06900694966316223,
-0.17982105910778046,
-0.13542088866233826,
-0.39436712861061096,
0.09329503774642944,
0.35323312878608704,
-0.3904082775115967,
-0.3412914574146271,
-0.41718676686286926,
0.10390658676624298,
-0.5318490862846375,
0.4964868724346161,
0.008205626159906387,
0.17506317794322968,
-0.3536136746406555,
-0.07392983883619308,
-0.3220437169075012,
-0.7262812256813049,
-0.03883988410234451,
-0.4706974923610687,
0.2609199285507202,
0.03306174650788307,
0.6744834184646606,
0.8711246252059937,
0.16634336113929749,
0.5120008587837219,
-0.2648801803588867,
-0.21326318383216858,
-0.18263287842273712,
0.3834352195262909,
-0.18981148302555084,
-0.7481024265289307,
-0.07789250463247299,
-0.24548663198947906,
0.9044619798660278,
1.366491675376892,
-0.23043935000896454,
0.02257140353322029,
0.17693600058555603,
0.6509135365486145,
-0.40665173530578613,
0.5241096019744873,
-0.7806743383407593,
-0.01667933538556099,
-0.36290422081947327,
-0.05659053474664688,
-0.5308971405029297,
-0.3175654709339142,
-0.030910445377230644,
-0.08847390860319138,
0.3989216387271881,
0.10683076083660126,
0.7641865015029907,
0.2681097388267517,
-0.1839231252670288,
-0.2852484881877899,
-0.6628395318984985,
0.3461732864379883,
-0.7492721676826477,
0.6791248321533203,
0.07387365400791168,
0.10073624551296234,
-0.6272214651107788,
-0.5959364175796509,
-0.40786126255989075,
-0.19236817955970764,
-0.4932178556919098,
-0.12501487135887146,
0.03461355343461037,
0.20620466768741608,
0.2831060290336609,
0.3728119432926178,
-0.5995028614997864,
0.28910645842552185,
-0.40733546018600464,
0.03006872721016407,
0.228127583861351,
0.1575646996498108,
0.2884729504585266,
-0.6689702868461609,
0.020808357745409012,
-0.019952913746237755,
-0.8258594274520874,
0.04538554325699806,
0.5019444227218628,
0.5448532700538635,
0.02007441222667694,
0.8674691319465637,
-0.28266122937202454,
0.5229412913322449,
0.13122843205928802,
0.24458597600460052,
0.15904179215431213,
-0.35328441858291626,
-0.29423704743385315,
0.26640626788139343,
0.8020330667495728,
-0.0940418690443039,
0.3355710804462433,
-0.28405511379241943,
-0.36306264996528625,
0.5066574215888977,
0.11989805102348328,
-0.6360563039779663,
-0.25341880321502686,
0.10585901141166687,
-0.6737787127494812,
-0.3744014799594879,
-0.020109664648771286,
-0.6443003416061401,
-0.4083414375782013,
-0.38490262627601624,
0.19362440705299377,
-0.4017234742641449,
-0.2698820233345032,
-0.0423433892428875,
-0.01185048557817936,
0.18486712872982025,
-0.15926606953144073,
-1.179649829864502,
0.4554796516895294,
0.5362434983253479,
0.4945516884326935,
0.15351669490337372,
-0.3871903717517853,
-0.19257669150829315,
0.08034909516572952,
-0.3384012281894684,
0.8351539969444275,
-0.6106516122817993,
-0.21882596611976624,
0.3057976961135864,
0.17322330176830292,
-0.1659088134765625,
-0.8076556921005249,
0.16865384578704834,
-0.2537679672241211,
0.4915028512477875,
-0.021532179787755013,
-0.7314512133598328,
-0.024798527359962463,
-0.13897334039211273,
-0.6585167646408081,
1.0306565761566162,
0.363180935382843,
-0.6824843883514404,
0.1523510366678238,
-0.6627917289733887,
-0.49581995606422424,
0.14068108797073364,
-0.4236240088939667,
-0.252513587474823,
0.4389907121658325,
0.08684244006872177,
0.33940353989601135,
-0.07432390749454498,
0.46465417742729187,
-0.0345073901116848,
-0.1652834266424179,
0.060469452291727066,
-0.17483071982860565,
1.0025596618652344,
-0.16766898334026337,
-0.5272200107574463,
0.35196229815483093,
-0.8321637511253357,
-0.07704830914735794,
0.31603285670280457,
-0.2557891011238098,
-0.32307520508766174,
0.35552042722702026,
-0.24570083618164062,
0.016730913892388344,
-0.046345390379428864,
-0.4650813341140747,
0.16013215482234955,
-0.9528312087059021,
0.5549842715263367,
0.5134021043777466,
0.023630253970623016,
0.6200183629989624,
-0.007060761097818613,
0.3067069947719574,
0.24665911495685577,
-0.07261800020933151,
-0.32241255044937134,
-0.2781493067741394,
-0.8061977624893188,
0.3513984680175781,
0.41788193583488464,
0.2693498730659485,
-0.724590539932251,
0.49335765838623047,
-0.2373364269733429,
-0.15647658705711365,
-0.5123081803321838,
-0.11502660810947418,
0.3631077706813812,
0.34447214007377625,
0.19842348992824554,
-0.21173526346683502,
-0.7782443761825562,
-1.077437162399292,
-0.0954149067401886,
-0.4300762116909027,
0.01430427748709917,
-0.18612007796764374,
0.47756293416023254,
0.03977995738387108,
0.7403554320335388,
-0.3060600757598877,
0.09275757521390915,
-0.24595405161380768,
0.16986949741840363,
0.2250215858221054,
0.4205184578895569,
0.44019410014152527,
-0.48854926228523254,
-0.09146852791309357,
-0.17323580384254456,
-0.7532300353050232,
-0.26446405053138733,
0.10451004654169083,
0.03839331492781639,
0.23281516134738922,
0.5648924708366394,
-0.7940431833267212,
0.5094400644302368,
0.4626430869102478,
-0.21769151091575623,
0.7560685276985168,
0.021845048293471336,
-0.1392097920179367,
-1.216406226158142,
-0.09064007550477982,
-0.2607499063014984,
-0.07762283831834793,
-0.6892716884613037,
0.14448429644107819,
-0.19752149283885956,
-0.07733641564846039,
-0.4924514591693878,
0.012741073034703732,
-0.7005888819694519,
-0.37434273958206177,
-0.06852912902832031,
-0.0660814493894577,
-0.15537892282009125,
0.6010275483131409,
-0.010575810447335243,
0.5060914754867554,
0.38502463698387146,
-0.33232003450393677,
0.3008933365345001,
0.16080094873905182,
-0.4767936170101166,
0.1620703935623169,
-0.7347645163536072,
0.025929773226380348,
-0.3600160479545593,
0.10309264808893204,
-0.9593138694763184,
-0.1999913901090622,
0.3418336808681488,
-0.26046478748321533,
0.20120593905448914,
-0.21974660456180573,
-0.7514430284500122,
-0.15425242483615875,
0.10656396299600601,
0.48250868916511536,
0.41341927647590637,
-0.4603225588798523,
0.36366793513298035,
0.36493757367134094,
-0.1337200403213501,
-0.1859242171049118,
-0.5540273785591125,
0.01278852391988039,
-0.17179562151432037,
-0.5112748146057129,
0.4347858428955078,
0.3064199984073639,
-0.5514202117919922,
0.26854491233825684,
0.09255515784025192,
0.1385042667388916,
0.005870624911040068,
0.5653499364852905,
0.11415185034275055,
-0.6650253534317017,
0.22495195269584656,
-0.03599832206964493,
0.04198277369141579,
0.36902016401290894,
-0.5456016659736633,
0.5946956276893616,
-0.12485654652118683,
-0.40750852227211,
-0.35629215836524963,
0.6557856798171997,
0.6590946912765503,
-0.2821952700614929,
0.787367045879364,
-0.012821203097701073,
-0.5868421196937561,
-0.4420681297779083,
-0.3563115894794464,
-0.2676423192024231,
-0.4573945105075836,
0.39484095573425293,
-0.4365891218185425,
-0.8588662147521973,
0.4369576871395111,
-0.08790238946676254,
-0.02744613215327263,
0.33663293719291687,
0.6611236333847046,
0.07645124197006226,
0.9166293144226074,
0.5232247114181519,
0.10232740640640259,
0.5054612159729004,
-0.0018828563624992967,
0.3007194697856903,
-0.5578641891479492,
-0.3543858826160431,
-0.7492786049842834,
-0.3352670967578888,
-0.7523847818374634,
-0.3397805690765381,
0.22779740393161774,
0.1237981766462326,
-0.0007758762803860009,
0.5510321855545044,
-0.5712494254112244,
0.3010156750679016,
0.4041595458984375,
-0.19147871434688568,
0.02716195583343506,
0.030219467356801033,
-0.49294260144233704,
0.01571200229227543,
-0.8097336888313293,
-0.3701746165752411,
0.5879711508750916,
0.36264723539352417,
0.5750919580459595,
0.09206420183181763,
0.5606068968772888,
-0.14068154990673065,
0.20343017578125,
-0.9097736477851868,
0.6413857340812683,
-0.2518567442893982,
-0.3950026035308838,
-0.26628464460372925,
-0.30009204149246216,
-0.9966350793838501,
0.3771161735057831,
-0.14972704648971558,
-0.9046278595924377,
0.3864072263240814,
-0.04639849439263344,
-0.0956227257847786,
0.13249236345291138,
-0.6584839224815369,
0.7602057456970215,
-0.18394522368907928,
-0.2751109302043915,
0.17256875336170197,
-0.7223429679870605,
0.33523598313331604,
0.3227818012237549,
-0.14942269027233124,
0.15272808074951172,
0.452928364276886,
0.6079075932502747,
-0.5118017792701721,
0.9379609227180481,
-0.2535088062286377,
-0.10181935131549835,
0.258226603269577,
0.26093563437461853,
0.39695441722869873,
-0.44011932611465454,
-0.2411179393529892,
0.0013444501673802733,
0.03917127102613449,
-0.15456680953502655,
-0.6556397676467896,
0.44118815660476685,
-0.46441468596458435,
-0.685995876789093,
-0.13869760930538177,
-0.7344892024993896,
-0.24279449880123138,
0.3465673327445984,
0.2151377648115158,
0.7689580321311951,
-0.11323846876621246,
0.42433789372444153,
0.3481893837451935,
-0.07069206982851028,
0.6241061091423035,
0.11435933411121368,
-0.2662889361381531,
-0.11356909573078156,
0.3070358335971832,
0.18571990728378296,
0.12934812903404236,
0.6234703063964844,
0.27660369873046875,
-0.5806565284729004,
-0.6087355613708496,
-0.47366437315940857,
0.23686325550079346,
-0.5914492011070251,
-0.038431111723184586,
-0.48803985118865967,
-0.5293070673942566,
-0.6218318939208984,
0.13212737441062927,
-0.43364956974983215,
-0.5415481328964233,
0.012283304706215858,
-0.2865380346775055,
-0.10578238219022751,
1.2118494510650635,
0.3045197129249573,
0.2660253345966339,
-0.40987300872802734,
0.029543722048401833,
-0.002580580534413457,
0.26543742418289185,
0.08014161884784698,
-0.12116441875696182,
-0.18250715732574463,
0.037428952753543854,
-0.10169815272092819,
-0.9332983493804932,
0.19816991686820984,
0.08654625713825226,
0.5777660608291626,
0.3296329379081726,
-0.1330423206090927,
0.7473705410957336,
-0.8886148929595947,
0.7067368626594543,
0.1343146562576294,
-0.8822743892669678,
0.5934439897537231,
-0.39977899193763733,
0.27171599864959717,
0.3818091154098511,
0.12874731421470642,
-0.23693938553333282,
-0.5493482351303101,
-0.5462622046470642,
-0.6357958316802979,
0.4394879937171936,
0.24666842818260193,
-0.1285613477230072,
-0.08864396810531616,
0.5765670537948608,
0.11850346624851227,
0.08751289546489716,
-0.7312315106391907,
-0.03896265849471092,
-0.26209554076194763,
-0.3647853136062622,
0.1688496172428131,
-0.15819166600704193,
0.2429441511631012,
-0.22001473605632782,
0.19734635949134827,
-0.041657667607069016,
0.21158912777900696,
0.10718513280153275,
-0.2572098970413208,
-0.17846283316612244,
0.3486769199371338,
0.5407379269599915,
0.6956318616867065,
-0.0006884984322823584,
0.6450932025909424,
-0.086290143430233,
0.1530289500951767,
0.24902747571468353,
0.05109241604804993,
-0.2311420440673828,
0.3080131411552429,
0.5717632174491882,
0.7594913840293884,
0.4393281638622284,
-0.11738963425159454,
0.2471327781677246,
0.15983720123767853,
-0.1666826754808426,
-0.14378862082958221,
-0.0801619216799736,
0.47874438762664795,
0.1365930587053299,
-0.05985395982861519,
-0.10688582807779312,
0.08141881227493286,
-0.816703200340271,
0.3251754939556122,
0.48881298303604126,
-0.23731692135334015,
-0.6675809025764465,
0.6710315942764282,
0.04285986348986626,
-0.5785995125770569,
0.655600368976593,
-0.041786547750234604,
-0.7038078904151917,
0.4664207100868225,
0.9101093411445618,
0.8572452664375305,
-0.46103668212890625,
0.11676595360040665,
0.22192759811878204,
0.3523409366607666,
-0.04611857980489731,
0.07637694478034973,
-0.036629755049943924,
-0.84101402759552,
-0.4668947756290436,
-0.9040054678916931,
-0.07500948011875153,
0.21575678884983063,
-0.5874339938163757,
0.009555176831781864,
-0.24951791763305664,
0.10198722779750824,
0.22738033533096313,
-0.1696801781654358,
-0.43954601883888245,
-0.07579366117715836,
0.25085514783859253,
0.6902004480361938,
-1.0378061532974243,
0.9178253412246704,
0.8393400311470032,
-0.26332953572273254,
-1.0049721002578735,
-0.0020071312319487333,
-0.01731918379664421,
-0.6495893597602844,
0.7649065852165222,
0.23710621893405914,
-0.1318880021572113,
-0.08273736387491226,
-0.34517452120780945,
-0.5498397946357727,
0.7069214582443237,
0.3716258108615875,
-0.5294509530067444,
-0.22376705706119537,
0.6370685696601868,
0.7056200504302979,
-0.5448847413063049,
0.007133361883461475,
0.46233615279197693,
0.1668672114610672,
-0.10356169193983078,
-0.5834564566612244,
0.37003159523010254,
-0.32076939940452576,
0.4046846032142639,
0.5189644694328308,
-0.0876215472817421,
0.8123393654823303,
0.16937348246574402,
-0.37993645668029785,
0.33883655071258545,
0.653978168964386,
0.19002288579940796,
-0.17001910507678986,
0.7382237911224365,
0.5514644980430603,
0.44526156783103943,
-0.08446966856718063,
0.7538426518440247,
-0.37203893065452576,
0.0786467120051384,
1.0903412103652954,
-0.35653799772262573,
0.8495889902114868,
0.5811969637870789,
-0.17903904616832733,
0.869810163974762,
0.456996351480484,
0.06441226601600647,
0.35698363184928894,
0.6243865489959717,
-0.06196121498942375,
0.1291792243719101,
-0.506834089756012,
-0.30682143568992615,
0.5999947190284729,
0.36261898279190063,
-0.5240803360939026,
-0.26075658202171326,
-0.2909795641899109,
-0.1467144936323166,
0.27823686599731445,
-0.006222494412213564,
0.7501218318939209,
0.15340203046798706,
-0.774578869342804,
0.3415123522281647,
-0.028158340603113174,
0.22735318541526794,
-0.5470700860023499,
-0.10696587711572647,
-0.35096582770347595,
0.19006314873695374,
-0.18371041119098663,
-0.4722710847854614,
0.5131545662879944,
-0.15686999261379242,
-0.29701995849609375,
-0.4434954524040222,
0.7014026045799255,
-0.6250962018966675,
-0.5759573578834534,
0.4134026765823364,
0.6734286546707153,
0.14607349038124084,
0.18684221804141998,
-0.38144877552986145,
0.1257791966199875,
-0.37297114729881287,
-0.17524860799312592,
0.256265252828598,
0.6076451539993286,
-0.13602405786514282,
0.17347435653209686,
0.6035804152488708,
0.30068185925483704,
0.1522190421819687,
0.4341766834259033,
0.8738468289375305,
-0.6533069610595703,
-0.4446741044521332,
-0.9220938682556152,
0.49892035126686096,
0.18581850826740265,
-0.013853874057531357,
0.6164833307266235,
0.539751410484314,
0.7752113342285156,
-0.09359490126371384,
0.46984270215034485,
-0.20460456609725952,
0.11963410675525665,
-0.5613789558410645,
0.6319882869720459,
-0.37955591082572937,
0.13673195242881775,
-0.05849441885948181,
-1.0475692749023438,
-0.3757414221763611,
0.37754538655281067,
-0.20979085564613342,
-0.23425939679145813,
1.0010167360305786,
1.0562164783477783,
0.038076020777225494,
0.0299964789301157,
0.27411824464797974,
0.4934503734111786,
0.19347266852855682,
0.5027105212211609,
1.1668373346328735,
-0.2955001890659332,
0.268779993057251,
-0.45053228735923767,
-0.11878371983766556,
0.07428678870201111,
-0.6110499501228333,
-0.911769688129425,
-0.8321194648742676,
-0.16637758910655975,
-0.36264556646347046,
0.12909822165966034,
0.770381510257721,
0.7352439165115356,
-1.0412673950195312,
-0.4897386431694031,
-0.4352014660835266,
0.19205136597156525,
-0.17887993156909943,
-0.28860804438591003,
0.47755980491638184,
-0.3647197186946869,
-0.6164018511772156,
0.7317582964897156,
0.3115379810333252,
-0.17733708024024963,
-0.4671853184700012,
0.3195386826992035,
-0.3558138608932495,
-0.2023358792066574,
0.6661599278450012,
-0.043507564812898636,
-0.9511675834655762,
-0.5803912878036499,
-0.08916817605495453,
-0.11880052834749222,
0.15821720659732819,
0.9300172328948975,
-0.8530171513557434,
0.19817091524600983,
0.7664735913276672,
0.4997119903564453,
0.01786281168460846,
0.17678837478160858,
0.6773168444633484,
-0.8848315477371216,
0.11233218759298325,
0.15154775977134705,
0.6150453686714172,
0.3678317666053772,
-0.2996658682823181,
0.44067904353141785,
0.37877699732780457,
-0.3548702895641327,
-0.8300306797027588,
0.43847107887268066,
-0.5382532477378845,
-0.35461872816085815,
0.951930820941925,
0.1284775286912918,
-0.546491801738739,
-0.15056121349334717,
0.020244412124156952,
0.3778080344200134,
0.1304050236940384,
0.5803453326225281,
0.5134685635566711,
-0.202057346701622,
-0.3516779839992523,
-0.2456367462873459,
0.3196770250797272,
0.5161334276199341,
-0.7250424027442932,
0.18201462924480438,
0.46131569147109985,
0.226042702794075,
0.3794192373752594,
0.2868165075778961,
-0.3172036111354828,
-0.22527723014354706,
0.32136639952659607,
0.19967128336429596,
-0.06830334663391113,
-0.30405136942863464,
-0.39470845460891724,
0.5567044615745544,
-0.10505745559930801,
-0.2970663607120514
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06892v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06892v1
|
Real-time Transformer-based Open-Vocabulary Detection with Efficient Fusion Head
| 2024-03-11T16:48:25 | 2024-03-11T16:48:25 |
Tiancheng Zhao, Peng Liu, Xuan He, Lu Zhang, Kyusong Lee
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
End-to-end transformer-based detectors (DETRs) have shown exceptional
performance in both closed-set and open-vocabulary object detection (OVD) tasks
through the integration of language modalities. However, their demanding
computational requirements have hindered their practical application in
real-time object detection (OD) scenarios. In this paper, we scrutinize the
limitations of two leading models in the OVDEval benchmark, OmDet and
Grounding-DINO, and introduce OmDet-Turbo. This novel transformer-based
real-time OVD model features an innovative Efficient Fusion Head (EFH) module
designed to alleviate the bottlenecks observed in OmDet and Grounding-DINO.
Notably, OmDet-Turbo-Base achieves a 100.2 frames per second (FPS) with
TensorRT and language cache techniques applied. Notably, in zero-shot scenarios
on COCO and LVIS datasets, OmDet-Turbo achieves performance levels nearly on
par with current state-of-the-art supervised models. Furthermore, it
establishes new state-of-the-art benchmarks on ODinW and OVDEval, boasting an
AP of 30.1 and an NMS-AP of 26.86, respectively. The practicality of
OmDet-Turbo in industrial applications is underscored by its exceptional
performance on benchmark datasets and superior inference speed, positioning it
as a compelling choice for real-time object detection tasks. Code:
\url{https://github.com/om-ai-lab/OmDet}
|
[
-0.7318097949028015,
-0.7148705124855042,
0.24467287957668304,
-0.35030198097229004,
-0.3837328553199768,
-0.07310085743665695,
-0.2192704677581787,
-0.8439319729804993,
-0.3007865250110626,
0.13676181435585022,
-0.3885359764099121,
-0.2072490006685257,
-0.2088606059551239,
0.03673020377755165,
-0.28798574209213257,
0.31439653038978577,
-0.18206030130386353,
-0.35402294993400574,
0.18421779572963715,
-0.3517003357410431,
-0.35680222511291504,
-0.42494437098503113,
-0.5201613306999207,
-0.09237691015005112,
0.028722478076815605,
0.30581799149513245,
0.6345658898353577,
0.9850063920021057,
0.5101884007453918,
0.20850524306297302,
0.07737680524587631,
-0.06872615218162537,
-0.3781697154045105,
0.4134680926799774,
-0.24239018559455872,
-0.08244461566209793,
-0.3345821499824524,
-0.5131731629371643,
0.4977687895298004,
0.2742641866207123,
-0.09895308315753937,
-0.08079449087381363,
-0.39275825023651123,
0.26025390625,
-1.2670611143112183,
0.21863530576229095,
-0.4623870551586151,
0.1763659417629242,
-0.33088070154190063,
0.12980817258358002,
-0.19940835237503052,
0.22053225338459015,
0.028457842767238617,
-0.39769983291625977,
0.2873440384864807,
-0.03975905478000641,
1.1540729999542236,
0.558928370475769,
0.10125922411680222,
0.4282199442386627,
-1.0769474506378174,
0.7348010540008545,
-0.39562878012657166,
0.9514068961143494,
-0.15399855375289917,
0.9472382664680481,
0.27315753698349,
-0.6952977776527405,
-0.6792106628417969,
0.03530469909310341,
0.26268091797828674,
0.5537015795707703,
-0.15663106739521027,
-0.20210708677768707,
0.1820339858531952,
0.4951757788658142,
-0.5140564441680908,
0.39163899421691895,
-0.0571785494685173,
0.06441010534763336,
-0.046976488083601,
0.06514257192611694,
-0.03246777877211571,
-0.13095077872276306,
-0.2553664445877075,
-0.4305788576602936,
-0.4240269064903259,
-0.09558926522731781,
0.21860454976558685,
0.24236740171909332,
0.10378081351518631,
0.504189133644104,
-0.5899642705917358,
0.9725496768951416,
-0.0937294140458107,
0.022266438230872154,
0.13600265979766846,
-0.3707388937473297,
-0.3246203660964966,
0.17097795009613037,
0.634692370891571,
-0.02357332967221737,
0.3532542586326599,
-0.18055777251720428,
-0.25777947902679443,
0.2404567450284958,
0.25015443563461304,
-1.0039434432983398,
-0.03400367498397827,
0.23097820580005646,
-0.48398399353027344,
-0.3399152457714081,
0.424823522567749,
-0.5599836111068726,
-0.02466905117034912,
-0.03622410073876381,
0.18373361229896545,
-0.5336674451828003,
-0.6444328427314758,
0.5884044170379639,
-0.08948808163404465,
0.7218313217163086,
0.12405460327863693,
-0.3356938660144806,
-0.06873030215501785,
0.913088858127594,
0.7791576385498047,
-0.1354730874300003,
-0.1915433257818222,
-0.8695252537727356,
-0.052434228360652924,
-0.02372472546994686,
1.0824531316757202,
-0.3407529592514038,
-0.22726653516292572,
-0.009403502568602562,
-0.09114910662174225,
-0.034849490970373154,
-0.6415168046951294,
0.877912163734436,
-0.45407938957214355,
-0.1265234649181366,
0.1201399713754654,
-0.019979925826191902,
0.06453803926706314,
0.32233187556266785,
-0.5466209650039673,
0.8842853307723999,
0.22638161480426788,
-0.5149587392807007,
0.5234223008155823,
-0.6077567338943481,
-0.2948300242424011,
0.20357346534729004,
-0.2611950635910034,
-0.5281006693840027,
-0.04819967597723007,
0.08429236710071564,
0.4550482928752899,
-0.506597101688385,
0.030914559960365295,
-0.2745661437511444,
-0.38131392002105713,
-0.1664622724056244,
-0.4758935272693634,
0.47625604271888733,
0.343950092792511,
-0.36461713910102844,
0.12394537776708603,
-0.7242532968521118,
-0.26779356598854065,
0.3064703345298767,
0.00025959016056731343,
-0.2518240511417389,
0.06363143026828766,
0.1272110939025879,
0.1824435591697693,
-0.2292393445968628,
-0.9730724096298218,
-0.1574215143918991,
-0.4557420313358307,
0.423206090927124,
0.3359237015247345,
-0.4014488160610199,
0.1266154646873474,
-0.027810653671622276,
0.45480433106422424,
0.05382419750094414,
0.22405438125133514,
-0.4803929328918457,
-0.5589659214019775,
-0.5367617607116699,
-0.5832648873329163,
0.2966483235359192,
0.636121928691864,
-0.8343852162361145,
0.8862069845199585,
-0.40617263317108154,
-0.5602508783340454,
-0.562454342842102,
-0.6852404475212097,
0.3572593033313751,
0.7512704730033875,
0.3716796040534973,
-0.2897733449935913,
-0.43071356415748596,
-0.8602125644683838,
-0.16512517631053925,
-0.048668552190065384,
-0.19734761118888855,
0.19963429868221283,
0.5597864985466003,
0.129968523979187,
1.2495266199111938,
-0.8854689002037048,
-0.399469256401062,
-0.03324652463197708,
0.09698088467121124,
0.1246599406003952,
0.2850291430950165,
0.7502375841140747,
-0.8708029985427856,
-0.605511486530304,
0.14431828260421753,
-0.8793613314628601,
-0.05312638729810715,
0.4042993187904358,
0.10835731029510498,
0.24368107318878174,
0.6870042085647583,
-0.5909245610237122,
0.889419436454773,
-0.023090217262506485,
-0.11762714385986328,
0.6451499462127686,
-0.048915766179561615,
0.09193867444992065,
-0.7526180744171143,
0.11391867697238922,
-0.0835157036781311,
-0.3230183720588684,
-0.7591617107391357,
0.41593584418296814,
0.3015206754207611,
-0.15579915046691895,
-1.1564339399337769,
0.37071967124938965,
-0.18716932833194733,
-0.24932913482189178,
-0.2780458927154541,
-0.14421437680721283,
-0.28644973039627075,
0.3806048333644867,
0.5124938488006592,
0.8607154488563538,
0.6302019357681274,
-0.6866165399551392,
0.1283920258283615,
0.11961688101291656,
-0.3690486550331116,
1.0798853635787964,
-0.5939258933067322,
-0.2390642613172531,
-0.3643016517162323,
0.24333734810352325,
-0.7262178063392639,
-0.14692381024360657,
0.34968194365501404,
-0.23168693482875824,
0.2708026170730591,
-0.1497277021408081,
-0.6253803372383118,
-0.6378129720687866,
-0.5536633729934692,
0.6760117411613464,
0.672988772392273,
-0.901908278465271,
0.6889920830726624,
0.05421214550733566,
0.5953473448753357,
-0.6877744793891907,
-0.45794612169265747,
-0.25161755084991455,
0.06110453978180885,
-0.7904651761054993,
0.6427995562553406,
0.26451778411865234,
-0.08258481323719025,
0.28355830907821655,
-0.4669686257839203,
-0.22791250050067902,
0.06156271696090698,
0.12385857850313187,
0.2350207418203354,
-0.48030680418014526,
-0.03740870952606201,
-0.3381351828575134,
-0.5377697348594666,
-0.2956410348415375,
-0.5258693099021912,
0.7839059829711914,
-0.2195107638835907,
-0.5971406698226929,
-0.25507885217666626,
-0.014407738111913204,
0.8328463435173035,
-0.5338365435600281,
0.9304419159889221,
1.0130594968795776,
-0.6134458184242249,
-0.03881022334098816,
-0.5391117930412292,
-0.2914925217628479,
-0.4362831711769104,
0.3440851867198944,
-0.6466239094734192,
-0.46118396520614624,
0.3823714256286621,
0.09809707850217819,
0.07421424984931946,
0.7162104845046997,
0.4984721839427948,
0.3156049847602844,
0.7712090015411377,
0.22570766508579254,
0.05158238112926483,
0.43818986415863037,
-0.4562806487083435,
0.5353879928588867,
-0.8367290496826172,
-0.026179324835538864,
-0.6042785048484802,
-0.04221723973751068,
-0.13221445679664612,
-0.45985493063926697,
0.41895875334739685,
-0.09022256731987,
-0.2662539482116699,
0.6220102906227112,
-0.6905375719070435,
0.4544512629508972,
0.40107396245002747,
0.010736365802586079,
0.45290154218673706,
-0.2879861295223236,
0.10713309794664383,
0.2750774621963501,
-0.6353848576545715,
-0.08858831971883774,
0.8988078236579895,
0.2824208438396454,
0.8675581812858582,
-0.07686717063188553,
0.2570210099220276,
0.06440840661525726,
-0.06553761661052704,
-0.9613726735115051,
0.39236992597579956,
-0.20503371953964233,
-0.4164610505104065,
-0.2903737425804138,
0.03379092365503311,
-0.7914640307426453,
0.5141544938087463,
0.10326563566923141,
-0.36818426847457886,
0.3661158084869385,
-0.22462239861488342,
-0.4618585407733917,
0.8640284538269043,
-0.38514065742492676,
0.9536475539207458,
-0.07833181321620941,
-0.3847692310810089,
0.10995923727750778,
-0.4818650484085083,
0.4055524468421936,
-0.11757154762744904,
-0.09789222478866577,
-0.2737100124359131,
0.011820589192211628,
0.48316705226898193,
-0.5995184183120728,
0.3422216475009918,
-0.14652273058891296,
-0.2254074066877365,
0.4286486506462097,
-0.1368202269077301,
0.3336937129497528,
-0.18971262872219086,
-0.0564749501645565,
0.33116307854652405,
-0.3261606693267822,
-0.04686493054032326,
-0.1020190492272377,
0.8720467686653137,
-0.36547723412513733,
-0.20882980525493622,
-0.5505630970001221,
-0.4573996961116791,
0.2426329106092453,
0.357531875371933,
0.3678686022758484,
0.518625795841217,
-0.19605055451393127,
0.47148919105529785,
0.712421715259552,
-0.18270927667617798,
0.5017824172973633,
0.6210496425628662,
-0.06090421974658966,
0.13495966792106628,
1.107075810432434,
0.10759220272302628,
0.322000652551651,
0.4309142529964447,
0.17636138200759888,
-0.19562019407749176,
-0.14277951419353485,
-0.6197212934494019,
0.24921102821826935,
-0.6163025498390198,
-0.5067058801651001,
-0.9600567817687988,
-0.3573513925075531,
-0.45707041025161743,
-0.22621262073516846,
-0.6406846642494202,
-0.17873473465442657,
-0.3104332387447357,
0.15506869554519653,
0.3266269564628601,
0.18922647833824158,
0.022184304893016815,
0.19108936190605164,
-0.47481441497802734,
0.850371778011322,
0.4028579890727997,
0.5268522500991821,
0.18200775980949402,
-0.3183797299861908,
0.07274717837572098,
-0.15335959196090698,
-0.17840182781219482,
-0.4258877635002136,
0.2639443278312683,
0.08693572878837585,
0.4549574851989746,
0.4818861782550812,
0.2743721604347229,
0.43995556235313416,
-0.29613226652145386,
0.5336431860923767,
-0.1730043888092041,
-0.6713917255401611,
0.2570847272872925,
-0.2319745570421219,
0.6361281871795654,
0.26583006978034973,
0.09238255769014359,
-0.19115209579467773,
-0.24278908967971802,
-0.4244023263454437,
-0.775932788848877,
1.1573460102081299,
0.3115403354167938,
-0.6747753620147705,
0.004008209798485041,
0.07515241205692291,
0.07621107995510101,
0.08408717066049576,
0.032199688255786896,
-0.25170478224754333,
-0.5810970067977905,
-0.09699127823114395,
0.27707722783088684,
0.16313010454177856,
0.5034474730491638,
-0.18650102615356445,
0.35323774814605713,
-0.13177168369293213,
0.5304666757583618,
0.2277119755744934,
-0.28223901987075806,
-0.2266877293586731,
0.0934797078371048,
0.6697818040847778,
0.17630460858345032,
-0.7698115110397339,
-0.05567426607012749,
0.06893579661846161,
-0.5952981114387512,
-0.07347048819065094,
0.1173892393708229,
-0.08237850666046143,
-0.015329758636653423,
0.09217622876167297,
0.7189253568649292,
0.17471805214881897,
-0.8835738301277161,
0.4290138781070709,
0.015877505764365196,
-0.1475995033979416,
-0.3448335826396942,
0.0004167234292253852,
-0.15868738293647766,
-0.04787808284163475,
0.42437684535980225,
0.25083059072494507,
0.09884318709373474,
-0.6131150126457214,
0.25996655225753784,
0.3805221915245056,
-0.5894312858581543,
-0.3704087734222412,
0.9343539476394653,
0.013356479816138744,
-0.20068874955177307,
0.4195655882358551,
-0.10636000335216522,
-0.7588487267494202,
0.9514943957328796,
0.35792022943496704,
1.1797831058502197,
-0.3349006772041321,
-0.33375775814056396,
0.2250082939863205,
0.21967576444149017,
-0.16309872269630432,
0.322823703289032,
-0.12484678626060486,
-0.967814028263092,
-0.2785413861274719,
-0.5972849726676941,
-0.49135321378707886,
0.1307624876499176,
-0.6547628045082092,
0.5660266876220703,
-0.23989425599575043,
0.05193869769573212,
0.1419767290353775,
-0.8722110986709595,
-0.8812953233718872,
0.08500897884368896,
0.10337913036346436,
1.141223669052124,
-0.5165454149246216,
0.7873639464378357,
0.5179994106292725,
-0.31299224495887756,
-0.14146548509597778,
-0.06406576931476593,
-0.12613195180892944,
-0.7927005290985107,
0.7040303945541382,
0.3872039020061493,
-0.35075071454048157,
0.23351846635341644,
0.12104823440313339,
-0.4951414167881012,
1.0402228832244873,
0.11391793191432953,
-0.1386713683605194,
0.028810136020183563,
-0.0366918109357357,
0.27954721450805664,
-0.1771683692932129,
0.5376584529876709,
0.8435630202293396,
0.6904107928276062,
0.08926131576299667,
-0.932623028755188,
-0.21563108265399933,
0.2395121455192566,
-0.210032120347023,
0.7727627754211426,
-0.41366130113601685,
1.2747517824172974,
0.16659462451934814,
-0.31038057804107666,
-0.0670943632721901,
0.5966518521308899,
0.017828818410634995,
-0.04744923487305641,
0.7728897333145142,
0.8774653673171997,
0.009538417682051659,
-0.36923694610595703,
1.2367339134216309,
-0.38846391439437866,
0.40111294388771057,
0.6519381999969482,
-0.6999749541282654,
0.8679264783859253,
0.040657564997673035,
-0.04405872896313667,
0.041792258620262146,
0.11175274848937988,
-0.04348258301615715,
0.6709350347518921,
-0.0241306871175766,
-0.32499247789382935,
-0.3328402042388916,
-0.5860841870307922,
-0.5944108963012695,
0.522212564945221,
0.3116708993911743,
0.2474033385515213,
-0.6951401233673096,
0.5525069832801819,
-0.29523181915283203,
-0.12795937061309814,
-0.16994929313659668,
0.3577049672603607,
-0.37242406606674194,
-0.5247656106948853,
0.8471443057060242,
0.20149162411689758,
1.1638976335525513,
-0.538989782333374,
0.0038658089470118284,
0.1845720261335373,
0.534211277961731,
-0.16224832832813263,
-0.7947046160697937,
0.3451472222805023,
0.038844093680381775,
0.14785383641719818,
-0.11147183924913406,
1.1543872356414795,
-0.15715883672237396,
-0.12448369711637497,
0.264024555683136,
0.48459866642951965,
-0.03685145825147629,
-0.5970042943954468,
-0.11396505683660507,
0.23176006972789764,
-0.45232510566711426,
0.0474732480943203,
0.12166566401720047,
0.12291652709245682,
-0.12089886516332626,
0.4757125675678253,
0.5982345938682556,
-0.30655646324157715,
-0.0032024825923144817,
-0.12083496153354645,
0.8325809240341187,
-0.6223933696746826,
-0.32423388957977295,
-0.649312436580658,
0.2932981550693512,
0.0551052950322628,
-0.03244481235742569,
0.5030248165130615,
0.7479570508003235,
1.0017246007919312,
-0.5269418358802795,
0.5684838891029358,
-0.38493987917900085,
0.6078290343284607,
-0.34366944432258606,
0.5296772122383118,
-0.5095365047454834,
-0.04079632833600044,
0.031639214605093,
-1.0785266160964966,
-0.36392685770988464,
0.7061756253242493,
-0.0006328045274131,
-0.1390940248966217,
0.8707675933837891,
0.49978888034820557,
-0.5983437299728394,
0.04621133953332901,
0.589835524559021,
0.09292832762002945,
0.7118155360221863,
0.46291518211364746,
0.6183091998100281,
-0.7602309584617615,
0.6967940926551819,
-0.42424601316452026,
-0.1623205691576004,
-0.6191549897193909,
-0.9929879903793335,
-0.7257087230682373,
-0.27551472187042236,
-0.476394921541214,
-0.14922864735126495,
-0.15591967105865479,
0.690147876739502,
0.7067636251449585,
-0.8283878564834595,
-0.1730201244354248,
-0.1619248390197754,
-0.15996213257312775,
-0.6110782027244568,
-0.2841090261936188,
0.2256970852613449,
0.07173863053321838,
-0.7532241940498352,
0.7008656859397888,
0.5685436129570007,
-0.059987328946590424,
-0.44591838121414185,
0.0002395233605057001,
-0.3840845227241516,
0.002765306271612644,
0.7446912527084351,
0.7032867670059204,
-0.8269678950309753,
-0.5083353519439697,
0.11059515178203583,
0.05621974170207977,
0.23386704921722412,
0.7281755208969116,
-1.3001985549926758,
0.561451256275177,
0.8960588574409485,
0.5476688146591187,
0.5323314666748047,
0.04976090416312218,
0.3306879699230194,
-0.43841370940208435,
0.526080310344696,
0.25703004002571106,
0.3874838352203369,
0.05127774551510811,
-0.06812476366758347,
0.934228241443634,
0.425578773021698,
-0.20687814056873322,
-1.1143324375152588,
0.33412304520606995,
-0.9419347643852234,
-0.2720968425273895,
0.5743738412857056,
0.15573056042194366,
-0.485921710729599,
-0.4416033625602722,
-0.1772499978542328,
0.3672655522823334,
-0.5379196405410767,
0.20795057713985443,
0.22342102229595184,
0.11164780706167221,
0.21953009068965912,
-0.6011515855789185,
0.13375665247440338,
0.08715111017227173,
-0.7557159662246704,
-0.012637734413146973,
0.16030631959438324,
-0.1857682764530182,
0.39976736903190613,
0.22519485652446747,
0.010526084341108799,
0.5467392802238464,
-0.015780843794345856,
0.17825981974601746,
-0.6064731478691101,
-0.45481762290000916,
-0.2953043580055237,
0.3247169256210327,
-0.33775386214256287,
-0.5102781653404236
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06872v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06872v1
|
Exploring Large Language Models and Hierarchical Frameworks for Classification of Large Unstructured Legal Documents
| 2024-03-11T16:24:08 | 2024-03-11T16:24:08 |
Nishchal Prasad, Mohand Boughanem, Taoufiq Dkaki
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Legal judgment prediction suffers from the problem of long case documents
exceeding tens of thousands of words, in general, and having a non-uniform
structure. Predicting judgments from such documents becomes a challenging task,
more so on documents with no structural annotation. We explore the
classification of these large legal documents and their lack of structural
information with a deep-learning-based hierarchical framework which we call
MESc; "Multi-stage Encoder-based Supervised with-clustering"; for judgment
prediction. Specifically, we divide a document into parts to extract their
embeddings from the last four layers of a custom fine-tuned Large Language
Model, and try to approximate their structure through unsupervised clustering.
Which we use in another set of transformer encoder layers to learn the
inter-chunk representations. We analyze the adaptability of Large Language
Models (LLMs) with multi-billion parameters (GPT-Neo, and GPT-J) with the
hierarchical framework of MESc and compare them with their standalone
performance on legal texts. We also study their intra-domain(legal) transfer
learning capability and the impact of combining embeddings from their last
layers in MESc. We test these methods and their effectiveness with extensive
experiments and ablation studies on legal documents from India, the European
Union, and the United States with the ILDC dataset and a subset of the LexGLUE
dataset. Our approach achieves a minimum total performance gain of
approximately 2 points over previous state-of-the-art methods.
|
[
-0.06281031668186188,
-0.6408490538597107,
0.5598961114883423,
-0.044524695724248886,
-0.47759270668029785,
0.36579135060310364,
-0.25495314598083496,
-0.4886581003665924,
0.06269416213035583,
0.4698849618434906,
-0.07262160629034042,
-0.7675912976264954,
-0.707150936126709,
-0.21715094149112701,
-0.4838259518146515,
1.021744728088379,
0.23187094926834106,
0.1619548797607422,
-0.04224054515361786,
-0.17276090383529663,
-0.21004055440425873,
-0.789789080619812,
-0.25722363591194153,
-0.4181285798549652,
0.22502540051937103,
0.2617761790752411,
0.41786110401153564,
0.4270936846733093,
0.34251686930656433,
0.35061123967170715,
-0.2703966796398163,
-0.39615097641944885,
-0.13680784404277802,
-0.09334883838891983,
-0.2826312482357025,
-0.43383926153182983,
-0.3059682846069336,
-0.09702816605567932,
0.6040586829185486,
0.6572377681732178,
-0.4612113833427429,
0.007839572615921497,
0.01751944050192833,
0.6253947019577026,
-0.5692617893218994,
0.3777836561203003,
-0.6234301328659058,
0.29378071427345276,
-0.23050612211227417,
-0.140556201338768,
-0.6401350498199463,
-0.07285891473293304,
0.1364573836326599,
-0.3407028615474701,
0.24875132739543915,
0.27255019545555115,
0.5291035771369934,
0.15878593921661377,
-0.6160696148872375,
-0.41250789165496826,
-0.6188504099845886,
0.49633049964904785,
-0.7404723763465881,
0.4400344789028168,
0.2659144699573517,
0.3754088580608368,
-0.21605883538722992,
-0.7448602318763733,
-0.4334051311016083,
-0.4346834421157837,
-0.02176353707909584,
0.42549899220466614,
-0.1514027863740921,
0.3896580934524536,
0.3228118121623993,
0.2655719816684723,
-0.6372044086456299,
0.587612509727478,
-0.4598012864589691,
-0.3002553880214691,
0.4662542939186096,
-0.09640654176473618,
-0.020725777372717857,
-0.33859965205192566,
-0.01375525537878275,
-0.21504303812980652,
-0.530407190322876,
0.30916839838027954,
0.36580246686935425,
0.38482001423835754,
0.011092756874859333,
0.6225100159645081,
-0.0388273186981678,
0.343573659658432,
0.27852824330329895,
-0.2371412217617035,
0.32380107045173645,
-0.15236367285251617,
-0.513237476348877,
0.5548236966133118,
0.8160233497619629,
0.12767843902111053,
0.007083786651492119,
0.004279914312064648,
-0.2160692811012268,
-0.0621243380010128,
0.33611711859703064,
-0.8601742386817932,
0.10307241976261139,
0.1532922089099884,
-0.7527713179588318,
-0.19339367747306824,
0.2979218661785126,
-0.885746955871582,
-0.6413089036941528,
-0.5452174544334412,
-0.12698647379875183,
-0.30401378870010376,
0.03652207925915718,
0.23391292989253998,
0.029638124629855156,
0.1554078608751297,
0.46855229139328003,
-0.8877074122428894,
0.3438083231449127,
0.6352092027664185,
0.6203737854957581,
0.23511433601379395,
-0.13932347297668457,
-0.4533875584602356,
0.15034018456935883,
-0.3699709475040436,
0.7193791270256042,
-0.7812203168869019,
-0.2017437368631363,
0.29316291213035583,
0.06428232043981552,
-0.019292321056127548,
-0.5054208636283875,
0.8266681432723999,
-0.534035325050354,
0.0024586038198322058,
0.15507133305072784,
-0.6380636692047119,
-0.21723873913288116,
0.37499549984931946,
-0.6268693804740906,
0.5982633233070374,
0.1400393694639206,
-0.6898186206817627,
0.8043927550315857,
-0.5967279076576233,
-0.6711254119873047,
0.2150196135044098,
-0.424011766910553,
-0.43065759539604187,
0.3159874677658081,
0.030830498784780502,
0.6795303821563721,
-0.45125100016593933,
0.5935177803039551,
-0.23802335560321808,
-0.24743422865867615,
-0.16696324944496155,
-0.30469053983688354,
0.5231152772903442,
0.3808988034725189,
-0.25780534744262695,
0.2829892337322235,
-0.9042069911956787,
-0.2823544144630432,
-0.08770225942134857,
-0.7385290861129761,
-0.44033753871917725,
0.11638986319303513,
0.0435480959713459,
0.4162325859069824,
0.06727301329374313,
-0.758450448513031,
0.1929216831922531,
-0.18879097700119019,
0.6013973355293274,
0.6752643585205078,
-0.1720723956823349,
0.5408225059509277,
0.06852354854345322,
0.3989630937576294,
0.2960891127586365,
-0.057897597551345825,
-0.06185330078005791,
-0.13653194904327393,
-0.5515245795249939,
0.0793636292219162,
0.6081082224845886,
0.47426584362983704,
-0.4334498643875122,
0.57197105884552,
-0.49745845794677734,
-0.36710652709007263,
-0.5317026972770691,
0.0343664288520813,
0.2432476431131363,
0.18439961969852448,
0.4427180588245392,
-0.08035259693861008,
-0.45946091413497925,
-0.8611363172531128,
-0.15822704136371613,
-0.2991454005241394,
0.06286793202161789,
0.2736406624317169,
0.7881335020065308,
-0.36907249689102173,
0.4486752152442932,
-0.06888928264379501,
-0.5513195395469666,
-0.17782434821128845,
0.4257301986217499,
0.4420553147792816,
0.35792386531829834,
0.41392040252685547,
-0.7945880889892578,
-0.28514692187309265,
0.5079500079154968,
-0.6970434784889221,
0.18151487410068512,
-0.4238480031490326,
0.43269211053848267,
0.21572764217853546,
1.0388689041137695,
-0.2346586436033249,
0.3129560947418213,
0.2329723834991455,
-0.5201098918914795,
0.6000455021858215,
-0.5521116852760315,
0.17678657174110413,
-0.9963427186012268,
-0.15705709159374237,
0.24373511970043182,
-0.24563194811344147,
-0.4385256767272949,
0.11680462211370468,
0.3258157968521118,
0.1637933999300003,
-0.35122042894363403,
0.22767144441604614,
-0.5287391543388367,
-0.2713972330093384,
-0.14163579046726227,
-0.2329304814338684,
-0.23326267302036285,
0.5574860572814941,
-0.08165521174669266,
0.44196459650993347,
0.4052285850048065,
-0.33973047137260437,
0.12492615729570389,
0.2129444181919098,
-0.6940724849700928,
0.6624934673309326,
-0.3177729547023773,
-0.08711028099060059,
-0.3075661361217499,
0.24631384015083313,
-0.49241477251052856,
-0.16059748828411102,
-0.028444673866033554,
-0.07699522376060486,
0.6402491927146912,
-0.5217476487159729,
-0.8085966110229492,
-0.5054267048835754,
-0.21436108648777008,
0.2757430076599121,
0.3176140785217285,
-0.5028781890869141,
0.9286056160926819,
0.5523279309272766,
-0.21603535115718842,
-0.7543444037437439,
-0.7891429662704468,
0.2443813979625702,
-0.29467177391052246,
-0.15783503651618958,
0.3718784749507904,
0.10859950631856918,
-0.24987174570560455,
0.1146068200469017,
0.014851429499685764,
-0.12361204624176025,
-0.04327112436294556,
0.6182249188423157,
-0.11924093216657639,
-0.24395684897899628,
0.1786695420742035,
0.5209853649139404,
0.04981246590614319,
0.18703527748584747,
-0.4575400650501251,
0.4739575982093811,
-0.316326379776001,
-0.5537214279174805,
-0.12247592955827713,
0.20439745485782623,
0.8915297389030457,
-0.17220576107501984,
0.39597129821777344,
0.08338281512260437,
-0.4153682589530945,
-0.2856625020503998,
-0.6636789441108704,
0.40909042954444885,
-0.42387279868125916,
0.44347208738327026,
-0.4431452453136444,
-1.2689393758773804,
0.45112499594688416,
-0.28744468092918396,
0.18137654662132263,
0.7348814010620117,
0.7437516450881958,
0.14521010220050812,
0.7283746004104614,
0.6696406602859497,
-0.46708354353904724,
0.5251824259757996,
-0.14510685205459595,
0.19425389170646667,
-0.5810941457748413,
-0.49691131711006165,
-0.6771612167358398,
-0.11043470352888107,
-0.5463846325874329,
-0.4695128798484802,
0.17971615493297577,
0.009993216954171658,
-0.2504740357398987,
0.30004772543907166,
-0.17304351925849915,
0.5807767510414124,
0.4654651880264282,
-0.09567610919475555,
0.43169111013412476,
0.10449647158384323,
-0.6595357060432434,
0.20714321732521057,
-0.5422312021255493,
-0.39294499158859253,
1.0175434350967407,
0.5204131603240967,
0.7543933987617493,
-0.14727619290351868,
0.5705310106277466,
0.40230822563171387,
0.15885046124458313,
-0.8617255091667175,
0.3347567021846771,
-0.6473029255867004,
-0.3334527313709259,
-0.24261030554771423,
-0.45124316215515137,
-0.9563409686088562,
0.43405604362487793,
-0.47734707593917847,
-0.4791155159473419,
0.3796923756599426,
-0.38114580512046814,
-0.44414258003234863,
0.3930746614933014,
-0.3220341205596924,
0.5673343539237976,
-0.4162818491458893,
-0.29091012477874756,
-0.4541134834289551,
-0.6133413910865784,
0.12022043764591217,
-0.4127192795276642,
0.45839229226112366,
0.043941937386989594,
0.39426517486572266,
0.7992126941680908,
-0.33060237765312195,
0.6490586996078491,
-0.1900618076324463,
-0.031083084642887115,
0.3512914478778839,
-0.05410114303231239,
0.2418665587902069,
-0.19936883449554443,
-0.25976982712745667,
0.2222597450017929,
0.18747912347316742,
-0.01964312233030796,
-0.5280430912971497,
0.46696823835372925,
-0.49869251251220703,
-0.30906549096107483,
-0.5446981191635132,
-0.5263679027557373,
0.0685860887169838,
0.44446685910224915,
0.20784702897071838,
0.3474210798740387,
-0.3114963471889496,
0.5763213634490967,
0.21630297601222992,
-0.15928058326244354,
0.35654082894325256,
0.6621460318565369,
0.09016396850347519,
-0.1898672729730606,
0.7046236395835876,
0.4181818664073944,
-0.5154816508293152,
0.46160149574279785,
0.2904210090637207,
-0.5910714268684387,
-1.1140162944793701,
-0.3744463622570038,
0.11267490684986115,
-0.8366513848304749,
-0.26004451513290405,
-0.5211997628211975,
-0.2594008445739746,
-0.40302181243896484,
-0.008893130347132683,
-0.20317916572093964,
-0.26864758133888245,
-0.23277145624160767,
-0.4218660295009613,
-0.12231919914484024,
0.9862182140350342,
0.3012029528617859,
0.22888346016407013,
-0.8712425827980042,
-0.043898552656173706,
-0.1080796867609024,
0.6101580858230591,
-0.08666181564331055,
-0.7016852498054504,
-0.1816270649433136,
-0.21298570930957794,
-0.018171265721321106,
-0.29185816645622253,
0.23801681399345398,
0.06933309882879257,
0.6031348705291748,
0.7026901245117188,
-0.0062891957350075245,
0.7184008359909058,
-0.7955293655395508,
0.4137963056564331,
0.2639353573322296,
-0.7985807657241821,
0.28610098361968994,
-0.288129597902298,
-0.19663894176483154,
0.8451343178749084,
0.18825741112232208,
-0.3055068850517273,
-0.35518866777420044,
-0.5782517194747925,
-0.7171211242675781,
0.5299248695373535,
-0.21831507980823517,
0.164179727435112,
0.2516041696071625,
0.6784530282020569,
-0.000274363235803321,
0.2842017114162445,
-0.7562609314918518,
0.3756350576877594,
0.0045272610150277615,
-0.3553291857242584,
-0.09268194437026978,
-0.23589912056922913,
0.11675088107585907,
-0.39476096630096436,
0.33663472533226013,
-0.3646807372570038,
-0.2070428431034088,
0.08064272254705429,
-0.37762361764907837,
-0.03845297917723656,
0.5606886148452759,
0.33443504571914673,
0.5462443232536316,
-0.17840182781219482,
0.15253637731075287,
0.026461319997906685,
-0.4509957730770111,
0.29296621680259705,
0.15755420923233032,
-0.08924391120672226,
-0.33702272176742554,
0.44997361302375793,
0.6696045398712158,
0.3529895544052124,
-0.6747388243675232,
0.5750728249549866,
-0.14421820640563965,
-0.7372864484786987,
-0.393585205078125,
-0.25554898381233215,
-0.1454203873872757,
0.6043305397033691,
0.28039687871932983,
-0.05227736756205559,
0.3564992845058441,
-0.704498291015625,
0.3021138608455658,
0.4128433167934418,
-0.4183672070503235,
-0.08699844777584076,
0.5791054368019104,
-0.07254750281572342,
0.24689701199531555,
0.5250324606895447,
-0.11009163409471512,
-0.45311111211776733,
0.5463806986808777,
0.4564164876937866,
0.6641659736633301,
-0.04987068474292755,
0.1505822241306305,
0.3115983009338379,
0.2257710099220276,
-0.5649036765098572,
-0.31201502680778503,
-0.10173799097537994,
-0.4934156835079193,
-0.4220094084739685,
-0.9302107095718384,
-0.2960456609725952,
0.19152016937732697,
-0.5864867568016052,
0.08077357709407806,
-0.7942444682121277,
0.008734604343771935,
0.018160879611968994,
0.009148431941866875,
-0.467568576335907,
0.10014726221561432,
0.24574339389801025,
0.9383769631385803,
-0.8426042795181274,
0.8700342774391174,
0.48678871989250183,
-0.4225713610649109,
-0.6065698862075806,
-0.04116019234061241,
0.04911019653081894,
-0.5267741084098816,
0.3868318498134613,
0.23021160066127777,
0.04088656231760979,
-0.22292593121528625,
-0.40234845876693726,
-0.43827617168426514,
1.044495701789856,
0.363511860370636,
-0.8986207246780396,
-0.29615649580955505,
0.22952283918857574,
0.8753972053527832,
-0.395948201417923,
-0.005935783497989178,
0.7918137311935425,
0.3696012496948242,
0.40476861596107483,
-0.6483505368232727,
0.054655689746141434,
-0.49609291553497314,
-0.23490333557128906,
0.20596906542778015,
-0.32595929503440857,
0.8141516447067261,
-0.12134785950183868,
-0.16746504604816437,
-0.17766007781028748,
0.584222674369812,
-0.01655246689915657,
0.34964415431022644,
0.5223790407180786,
0.8184217810630798,
1.0483057498931885,
-0.07867734134197235,
1.1085938215255737,
-0.2737901508808136,
0.2994881868362427,
1.1395008563995361,
-0.42167627811431885,
0.910829484462738,
0.24001896381378174,
-0.035818032920360565,
0.688532829284668,
0.6272470951080322,
-0.5478795170783997,
0.24608267843723297,
0.40521836280822754,
0.1226305365562439,
-0.07060661911964417,
-0.16914835572242737,
-0.07649172842502594,
0.48959895968437195,
0.4588789939880371,
-0.5211071372032166,
-0.3041854500770569,
-0.05919913947582245,
-0.19280299544334412,
0.028236543759703636,
-0.5281945466995239,
0.976190447807312,
0.10920026898384094,
-0.5473127961158752,
0.11440974473953247,
0.2587110698223114,
0.6981437802314758,
-0.40107667446136475,
-0.08587156236171722,
-0.001177217811346054,
0.3119969964027405,
-0.379622220993042,
-0.8615273833274841,
0.20242126286029816,
0.06253937631845474,
-0.17312292754650116,
-0.20421357452869415,
0.767573893070221,
-0.37779945135116577,
-0.7258822917938232,
0.7288193702697754,
0.38949668407440186,
0.18375377357006073,
-0.257506787776947,
-0.8497599363327026,
-0.33522364497184753,
-0.3178747594356537,
-0.1383824646472931,
0.7075453400611877,
0.5801948308944702,
-0.4408380687236786,
0.3329200744628906,
0.7667334675788879,
0.12217765301465988,
0.05871674418449402,
0.5568587183952332,
0.9777518510818481,
-0.592616617679596,
-0.6948782801628113,
-0.8036103248596191,
0.3505350649356842,
0.00966982264071703,
0.04102747142314911,
0.4367455840110779,
0.7595714926719666,
0.7771246433258057,
0.16716860234737396,
0.7615588307380676,
0.042477697134017944,
0.2651093006134033,
-0.824527382850647,
0.811609148979187,
-0.5694206953048706,
0.08246004581451416,
-0.40812045335769653,
-0.9183915853500366,
-0.4830695390701294,
0.5541107058525085,
-0.24533046782016754,
-0.0916886180639267,
0.771443784236908,
0.4064442813396454,
-0.20144477486610413,
-0.10369039326906204,
0.4737975299358368,
0.3429938852787018,
0.4243776202201843,
0.5682949423789978,
0.7323352098464966,
-0.15505459904670715,
0.4721836447715759,
0.03822346031665802,
-0.12527190148830414,
-0.2105884552001953,
-0.748595118522644,
-0.9472520351409912,
-0.49006953835487366,
0.004970584996044636,
-0.3389720320701599,
-0.2757306396961212,
0.8833525776863098,
0.534994900226593,
-0.9562411904335022,
-0.3344219923019409,
-0.17203977704048157,
-0.1674502193927765,
0.2474856972694397,
-0.11513897031545639,
0.5705687403678894,
-0.15483060479164124,
-0.5043167471885681,
0.4060738682746887,
0.3401664197444916,
0.16138607263565063,
0.08609583973884583,
-0.037753816694021225,
-0.18514230847358704,
-0.255199134349823,
0.8249455094337463,
0.20888084173202515,
-0.580826997756958,
-0.057308685034513474,
-0.4048464596271515,
-0.031684551388025284,
0.2757363021373749,
1.0898560285568237,
-0.42458775639533997,
0.31330588459968567,
0.3084004521369934,
0.7859524488449097,
0.6233438849449158,
0.25125619769096375,
0.3114125430583954,
-0.5749416351318359,
0.2566245496273041,
0.2909776270389557,
0.9021427035331726,
0.09704551100730896,
-0.2658648192882538,
0.5391231775283813,
0.025500793009996414,
-0.4078075885772705,
-0.4927103817462921,
-0.18200130760669708,
-0.8432939648628235,
-0.7288760542869568,
0.9556942582130432,
-0.19719861447811127,
-0.25577861070632935,
-0.3317866027355194,
-0.06422163546085358,
0.18416190147399902,
-0.5274784564971924,
0.6620751619338989,
0.7342436909675598,
0.11122173815965652,
-0.1452292650938034,
-0.68080073595047,
0.21074087917804718,
0.2289687991142273,
-0.8864203691482544,
0.16862857341766357,
0.773497462272644,
0.1869189590215683,
0.5504481196403503,
0.5581389665603638,
-0.5295009613037109,
0.06822998821735382,
-0.006534808315336704,
-0.07641377300024033,
-0.12639939785003662,
-0.6268228888511658,
-0.8384358882904053,
0.48517197370529175,
-0.04223104938864708,
0.4156671464443207
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06869v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06869v1
|
Learning with Noisy Foundation Models
| 2024-03-11T16:22:41 | 2024-03-11T16:22:41 |
Hao Chen, Jindong Wang, Zihan Wang, Ran Tao, Hongxin Wei, Xing Xie, Masashi Sugiyama, Bhiksha Raj
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Foundation models are usually pre-trained on large-scale datasets and then
adapted to downstream tasks through tuning. However, the large-scale
pre-training datasets, often inaccessible or too expensive to handle, can
contain label noise that may adversely affect the generalization of the model
and pose unexpected risks. This paper stands out as the first work to
comprehensively understand and analyze the nature of noise in pre-training
datasets and then effectively mitigate its impacts on downstream tasks.
Specifically, through extensive experiments of fully-supervised and image-text
contrastive pre-training on synthetic noisy ImageNet-1K, YFCC15M, and CC12M
datasets, we demonstrate that, while slight noise in pre-training can benefit
in-domain (ID) performance, where the training and testing data share a similar
distribution, it always deteriorates out-of-domain (OOD) performance, where
training and testing distributions are significantly different. These
observations are agnostic to scales of pre-training datasets, pre-training
noise types, model architectures, pre-training objectives, downstream tuning
methods, and downstream applications. We empirically ascertain that the reason
behind this is that the pre-training noise shapes the feature space
differently. We then propose a tuning method (NMTune) to affine the feature
space to mitigate the malignant effect of noise and improve generalization,
which is applicable in both parameter-efficient and black-box tuning manners.
We additionally conduct extensive experiments on popular vision and language
models, including APIs, which are supervised and self-supervised pre-trained on
realistic noisy data for evaluation. Our analysis and results demonstrate the
importance of this novel and fundamental research direction, which we term as
Noisy Model Learning.
|
[
-0.6258207559585571,
-0.6727361679077148,
0.012743355706334114,
0.11010556668043137,
-0.33925822377204895,
-0.31410592794418335,
-0.20961983501911163,
-0.7940680384635925,
-0.06521901488304138,
0.7712904810905457,
-0.7243375778198242,
-0.3156818151473999,
-0.6414473056793213,
-0.282228946685791,
-0.5563105940818787,
0.969570517539978,
0.2232060581445694,
0.09681844711303711,
-0.19515544176101685,
0.15294937789440155,
-0.1545581966638565,
-0.1302081197500229,
-0.6217963695526123,
-0.2113153338432312,
0.4524560868740082,
-0.06504762917757034,
0.6183529496192932,
0.7941997051239014,
0.5949091911315918,
0.2706882655620575,
-0.12701311707496643,
-0.16519491374492645,
-0.8374131321907043,
0.11193691194057465,
-0.009307521395385265,
-0.283550888299942,
-0.10969427973031998,
0.10011828690767288,
0.45370179414749146,
0.9927576184272766,
0.15132242441177368,
-0.014536388218402863,
0.32394692301750183,
0.7596220970153809,
-0.8542996644973755,
0.32006195187568665,
-0.5652979016304016,
0.08065202087163925,
-0.1878950446844101,
0.0255892314016819,
-0.04428698495030403,
-0.053983334451913834,
0.3820568323135376,
-0.754507303237915,
0.5024590492248535,
-0.10335970669984818,
1.2453742027282715,
0.8568084836006165,
-0.09113963693380356,
-0.344623327255249,
-0.777263343334198,
0.7829437851905823,
-0.3628711998462677,
0.4520573914051056,
0.4883907735347748,
0.008144314400851727,
-0.2061963826417923,
-0.8305583000183105,
0.10356639325618744,
-0.04727727919816971,
-0.0621722973883152,
0.07353811711072922,
-0.2129395604133606,
0.16153044998645782,
0.2531166970729828,
0.6768009662628174,
-0.21189245581626892,
0.2140398621559143,
-0.5046612024307251,
-0.26098132133483887,
0.40190890431404114,
-0.3999418020248413,
-0.1353316605091095,
0.4979346990585327,
-0.12504743039608002,
-0.2587064504623413,
-0.5927965044975281,
0.1559670865535736,
0.4628928601741791,
0.336694598197937,
-0.08554764091968536,
-0.1479436457157135,
-0.3971296548843384,
0.9300627708435059,
0.2714639902114868,
0.03448248282074928,
0.24953986704349518,
-0.33650198578834534,
-0.30447521805763245,
-0.08744698762893677,
0.4952079951763153,
-0.07512779533863068,
0.5091054439544678,
-0.3132525682449341,
-0.3045971691608429,
0.14350777864456177,
0.4492335021495819,
-1.246290922164917,
-0.7286846041679382,
-0.1353784054517746,
-0.511724591255188,
-0.7547872066497803,
-0.008167545311152935,
-0.6878664493560791,
-0.4521271586418152,
-0.6579039096832275,
0.7272612452507019,
-0.1658300906419754,
-0.5930414795875549,
0.23503343760967255,
0.29699406027793884,
-0.08682110905647278,
0.19123239815235138,
-0.6714012622833252,
0.3355973958969116,
0.3393304646015167,
0.3763953447341919,
-0.04720448702573776,
-0.19273968040943146,
-0.3876628577709198,
-0.2286231964826584,
-0.5552653670310974,
0.6940288543701172,
-0.3266013264656067,
-0.27444562315940857,
-0.35359421372413635,
-0.04681580886244774,
-0.0660310685634613,
-0.8763498663902283,
0.2161717563867569,
-0.3753798305988312,
-0.24256350100040436,
-0.13952641189098358,
-0.11895090341567993,
0.034150637686252594,
-0.1425272524356842,
-0.7734273672103882,
0.9279478192329407,
0.2228626161813736,
-0.5709848403930664,
0.5968988537788391,
-0.6333330869674683,
-0.7132930159568787,
-0.3812166452407837,
-0.18261754512786865,
-0.8339272737503052,
0.31678828597068787,
0.12598063051700592,
0.5287618041038513,
-0.03884616494178772,
0.25809064507484436,
-0.18434637784957886,
-0.5700699687004089,
0.10982424765825272,
-0.20703265070915222,
0.5426695346832275,
0.2839847505092621,
-0.5587225556373596,
-0.09798920154571533,
-1.0391238927841187,
0.0013553554890677333,
-0.19344115257263184,
-0.02412683144211769,
-0.32729390263557434,
-0.2647418975830078,
-0.30365288257598877,
0.22510285675525665,
-0.12860709428787231,
-0.15639209747314453,
-0.4764403998851776,
-0.4305607080459595,
0.4397374391555786,
0.5915125012397766,
0.028063634410500526,
0.4826192557811737,
-0.3409702181816101,
0.3118849992752075,
0.537465512752533,
0.3003336489200592,
-0.21134863793849945,
-0.2975780665874481,
-0.6562864780426025,
-0.47937846183776855,
0.5220606923103333,
-0.10678461194038391,
-0.25025156140327454,
0.0884614810347557,
-0.148046612739563,
-0.31512805819511414,
-0.39856770634651184,
0.4733118712902069,
0.37892407178878784,
0.856014609336853,
0.36664140224456787,
-0.5221361517906189,
-0.5921565890312195,
-0.7834550142288208,
-0.06839670985937119,
0.13015080988407135,
0.24783875048160553,
0.307974249124527,
0.5042310357093811,
-0.3792356252670288,
0.8280954957008362,
-0.30040067434310913,
-0.35751253366470337,
0.40784335136413574,
0.3397526144981384,
-0.003196025500074029,
0.6545711159706116,
0.542522132396698,
-1.0911015272140503,
-0.2604965567588806,
-0.2765652537345886,
-0.4238801598548889,
-0.16796495020389557,
0.11304105818271637,
-0.27825817465782166,
-0.23299220204353333,
0.7729685306549072,
-0.3071218430995941,
0.7814657688140869,
0.46959859132766724,
0.09873753786087036,
0.5370454788208008,
0.11449214816093445,
-0.16316495835781097,
-0.794410765171051,
0.037196993827819824,
0.020414849743247032,
0.14791721105575562,
-0.40626347064971924,
0.0081224599853158,
-0.2536274194717407,
-0.19722704589366913,
-0.16068361699581146,
0.21096475422382355,
-0.530040979385376,
-0.0563712902367115,
-0.3541487455368042,
-0.467586874961853,
0.12304949015378952,
0.3721410036087036,
0.22881671786308289,
0.7988210320472717,
0.8725918531417847,
-1.0031038522720337,
-0.269553005695343,
0.03489271178841591,
-0.5240368843078613,
0.4468717873096466,
-0.49118611216545105,
-0.241857647895813,
-0.32749655842781067,
0.013413134962320328,
-0.9286279082298279,
-0.28149402141571045,
0.077611543238163,
-0.28863033652305603,
0.6554286479949951,
-0.21211719512939453,
-0.16042253375053406,
-0.10048947483301163,
0.1722704917192459,
0.33953437209129333,
0.4317385256290436,
-0.46561238169670105,
0.3166532814502716,
0.3442637622356415,
0.10744879394769669,
-0.6314927339553833,
-0.8838251233100891,
-0.3128131330013275,
-0.2084500640630722,
-0.5412824153900146,
0.2535662353038788,
-0.05476798862218857,
-0.10963807255029678,
0.1442614197731018,
-0.523815929889679,
-0.6491303443908691,
0.4397796094417572,
0.7247534394264221,
-0.12995757162570953,
-0.6243674159049988,
0.3056081533432007,
-0.18770891427993774,
-0.1637192815542221,
0.1851925551891327,
-0.4912513792514801,
0.12692712247371674,
-0.29024550318717957,
-0.017699575051665306,
-0.11636438220739365,
0.040922392159700394,
0.3241084814071655,
-0.182726189494133,
0.5286087989807129,
0.7088528871536255,
-0.4361388385295868,
-0.3496188521385193,
-0.446298748254776,
-0.4765191078186035,
-0.4838521480560303,
0.6623139381408691,
-0.3717954158782959,
-0.6944711804389954,
0.3459366261959076,
-0.6634867191314697,
-0.03358858823776245,
0.23095925152301788,
0.26982957124710083,
-0.3246844410896301,
0.49842461943626404,
0.8863308429718018,
0.11543835699558258,
0.6701921820640564,
-0.5300271511077881,
0.10871326178312302,
-0.42976242303848267,
-0.0009772996418178082,
-0.5949779748916626,
-0.5012739896774292,
-0.36779817938804626,
-0.12116707116365433,
0.10604038834571838,
0.4310774803161621,
-0.44213858246803284,
0.12337678670883179,
-0.4811529219150543,
0.6420938968658447,
0.46245384216308594,
0.2762044668197632,
0.13108964264392853,
0.441101610660553,
-0.05783195421099663,
-0.18509142100811005,
-0.703233540058136,
0.02328432910144329,
1.1280239820480347,
0.06761368364095688,
0.9164609909057617,
-0.26114752888679504,
0.6915633082389832,
-0.12354812771081924,
0.4836745262145996,
-0.5545124411582947,
-0.024249762296676636,
-0.3847133219242096,
-0.7413706183433533,
-0.3878931403160095,
-0.546701967716217,
-1.089890480041504,
0.011008061468601227,
-0.3988865911960602,
-0.6402024030685425,
0.7460018396377563,
0.4185263514518738,
-0.3794315755367279,
0.2478097826242447,
-0.5847906470298767,
0.8879371285438538,
-0.08311370015144348,
-0.5072271227836609,
-0.02092583477497101,
-0.7879217863082886,
0.47216805815696716,
-0.4353151023387909,
0.4320348799228668,
0.07136444002389908,
0.333517462015152,
0.4957262873649597,
-0.26675790548324585,
1.0232447385787964,
-0.1204206794500351,
0.08140035718679428,
0.35132190585136414,
0.040965914726257324,
0.32415783405303955,
-0.187856063246727,
-0.023825133219361305,
0.3800356090068817,
-0.30795523524284363,
-0.35830819606781006,
-0.40819793939590454,
0.6807770133018494,
-1.1871569156646729,
-0.21382474899291992,
0.12179186195135117,
-0.4321691691875458,
-0.33284875750541687,
0.347528338432312,
0.7977739572525024,
0.5486502051353455,
-0.1713045835494995,
0.6549668908119202,
1.2302253246307373,
0.08954282104969025,
0.19759759306907654,
0.3485170006752014,
0.0017132011707872152,
-0.15955208241939545,
1.065558671951294,
0.367380827665329,
0.28888484835624695,
0.17141775786876678,
0.1889452487230301,
-0.14061293005943298,
-0.703538715839386,
0.04555949568748474,
-0.07369190454483032,
-0.5934528112411499,
-0.15861395001411438,
-0.7399934530258179,
-0.4996711015701294,
-0.14384740591049194,
-0.0968671441078186,
-0.6797975897789001,
-0.19934898614883423,
-0.6001615524291992,
-0.0533970445394516,
0.061444684863090515,
0.5927826762199402,
-0.2654716372489929,
0.701259970664978,
-0.24065689742565155,
0.5564711093902588,
0.3287087380886078,
0.7793841361999512,
0.07803243398666382,
-0.45387184619903564,
-0.48684626817703247,
0.1623406857252121,
-0.1677183359861374,
-0.3886355757713318,
-0.0056715477257966995,
0.5442854762077332,
0.5442525148391724,
0.6247543692588806,
0.1484508365392685,
0.7399629354476929,
0.07962663471698761,
0.20848818123340607,
0.13760046660900116,
-0.6219111084938049,
0.5388771891593933,
-0.20528078079223633,
0.06487070024013519,
0.8100297451019287,
0.2983325123786926,
0.42909517884254456,
-0.08220741152763367,
-0.7597410678863525,
-0.7256103754043579,
0.4878554046154022,
0.31969279050827026,
-0.1264536827802658,
0.35989055037498474,
0.5742073059082031,
0.10311572253704071,
0.48497000336647034,
-0.7321662902832031,
-0.27721261978149414,
-0.5260300636291504,
0.040512941777706146,
-0.12893567979335785,
-0.029500208795070648,
-0.11082633584737778,
-0.2745121717453003,
0.576239287853241,
-0.020878922194242477,
-0.10765200108289719,
0.09811511635780334,
-0.3695586323738098,
-0.37629255652427673,
-0.10760341584682465,
0.36130306124687195,
0.5363364815711975,
-0.2248631715774536,
-0.09425695240497589,
-0.37897616624832153,
-0.7875781655311584,
0.14424768090248108,
0.16146224737167358,
-0.301639586687088,
-0.08720441162586212,
0.26770323514938354,
0.9388557076454163,
0.572370707988739,
-0.16136051714420319,
0.5588619709014893,
-0.05880224332213402,
-0.572543740272522,
-0.11940174549818039,
0.2510858476161957,
-0.031180836260318756,
0.052898555994033813,
0.185979962348938,
0.7263823747634888,
0.18011969327926636,
-0.2312912791967392,
0.34781980514526367,
0.23472225666046143,
-0.7688120007514954,
-0.18841393291950226,
0.6908160448074341,
0.2669423222541809,
0.2004769742488861,
0.6084113121032715,
0.1370743066072464,
-0.029865579679608345,
0.8554070591926575,
0.28223320841789246,
0.7516393661499023,
0.04189588129520416,
0.10581043362617493,
0.18324650824069977,
0.6065212488174438,
-0.1929100900888443,
-0.0012186720268800855,
-0.21585281193256378,
-0.8811113238334656,
-0.6552227735519409,
-0.9150218367576599,
-0.06764444708824158,
0.5542002320289612,
-0.8836867809295654,
0.12274951487779617,
-0.5285952091217041,
-0.27060040831565857,
0.08933346718549728,
0.014836303889751434,
-0.8497527241706848,
0.63613361120224,
0.03944246843457222,
0.4738660156726837,
-0.8166594505310059,
0.6365201473236084,
0.762428343296051,
-0.056595053523778915,
-0.8802369236946106,
-0.12682433426380157,
-0.08718618750572205,
-0.5219513177871704,
0.6513903141021729,
0.28024783730506897,
-0.23819561302661896,
0.367913156747818,
-0.7867523431777954,
-0.9051576256752014,
0.7899041175842285,
0.5559864640235901,
-0.5313277840614319,
0.29917171597480774,
0.25535425543785095,
0.4929048418998718,
-0.3518672287464142,
-0.04214002937078476,
0.4051845967769623,
0.37952566146850586,
0.27931028604507446,
-0.5729538202285767,
-0.1933460384607315,
-0.2425462305545807,
-0.22405566275119781,
0.16779175400733948,
-0.645331859588623,
0.9370894432067871,
-0.27712321281433105,
-0.1554633527994156,
-0.016119739040732384,
0.3158479928970337,
-0.07378693670034409,
0.2502877414226532,
0.6394060254096985,
0.6698195338249207,
0.7832499742507935,
-0.22090229392051697,
0.5992906093597412,
-0.38204383850097656,
0.04989010468125343,
1.1527416706085205,
0.028552254661917686,
0.2744511365890503,
0.3928506672382355,
-0.013379148207604885,
0.19520504772663116,
0.9043809771537781,
0.03185885772109032,
0.6957460045814514,
0.5302801728248596,
0.021759113296866417,
-0.4851096570491791,
-0.01734612137079239,
-0.619927167892456,
0.2537112236022949,
0.5452772974967957,
-0.35395169258117676,
-0.3367123603820801,
0.03952634334564209,
-0.47176992893218994,
-0.11213076114654541,
-0.4285191595554352,
0.6522268056869507,
0.20893442630767822,
-0.15150754153728485,
0.5148583650588989,
-0.46101677417755127,
0.7086314558982849,
-0.6628499031066895,
0.15470175445079803,
-0.16326287388801575,
0.19301222264766693,
-0.2595997750759125,
-0.1456168293952942,
0.44916409254074097,
-0.5916998982429504,
-0.47563689947128296,
-0.05940202623605728,
0.7773905396461487,
-0.25559550523757935,
-0.41763630509376526,
0.4053359031677246,
0.43276679515838623,
0.27468693256378174,
-0.5508462190628052,
-0.6874808669090271,
0.08754969388246536,
-0.11385442316532135,
-0.3363514542579651,
0.6383790969848633,
0.5249103307723999,
-0.04662008583545685,
0.664738655090332,
0.7984476685523987,
0.12014418095350266,
0.19176732003688812,
-0.04915746673941612,
1.0881946086883545,
-0.31931862235069275,
-0.5855832099914551,
-0.4144238829612732,
0.4086386561393738,
0.07419748604297638,
-0.48542895913124084,
0.14700910449028015,
0.42917001247406006,
0.9361079931259155,
-0.1234680712223053,
0.5290572643280029,
0.3644477128982544,
0.3043017089366913,
-0.45931804180145264,
0.8649436235427856,
-0.489075243473053,
0.26422542333602905,
-0.36067405343055725,
-0.8646271824836731,
-0.21814756095409393,
0.6736920475959778,
-0.19732515513896942,
0.2139730304479599,
0.44391128420829773,
1.0520844459533691,
-0.29608264565467834,
0.14154180884361267,
0.5599344372749329,
0.4770660698413849,
-0.29292407631874084,
0.252500057220459,
0.8006978034973145,
-0.5406209826469421,
0.7959995865821838,
-0.6512475609779358,
-0.0844748467206955,
-0.07646339386701584,
-0.8091813325881958,
-0.8146270513534546,
-0.38639509677886963,
-0.7815091609954834,
-0.42304056882858276,
0.23369576036930084,
0.12086008489131927,
1.2985687255859375,
-0.9693374037742615,
-0.06053368002176285,
-0.3024434745311737,
0.047054924070835114,
-0.31050583720207214,
-0.2108517587184906,
0.27198272943496704,
-0.3667525351047516,
-0.3994852304458618,
0.1854896992444992,
-0.0016304427990689874,
0.36314448714256287,
-0.014070090837776661,
0.014033677987754345,
0.15157948434352875,
-0.24281629920005798,
0.20136207342147827,
0.3537665009498596,
-0.3318861722946167,
0.2694033980369568,
-0.2783008813858032,
-0.035181015729904175,
0.08219379931688309,
0.8564455509185791,
-0.8702124357223511,
0.4180371165275574,
-0.04807811602950096,
0.6611266136169434,
0.7465363144874573,
0.02613372541964054,
0.4859491288661957,
-0.8179590106010437,
0.5074937343597412,
0.08573471009731293,
0.054718416184186935,
0.12289673835039139,
-0.7090737819671631,
0.6009540557861328,
0.19953563809394836,
-0.4007776975631714,
-0.7479069232940674,
0.10047001391649246,
-0.4148738980293274,
-0.46104195713996887,
0.7162220478057861,
-0.19706426560878754,
-0.11198202520608902,
-0.3518972098827362,
0.17028404772281647,
0.22143137454986572,
-0.08497443050146103,
0.7229993939399719,
0.8122739791870117,
-0.02002834901213646,
-0.2639982998371124,
-0.5751630663871765,
0.8496448397636414,
0.3121424913406372,
-0.3670599162578583,
-0.16672269999980927,
0.320932000875473,
0.4273008704185486,
0.10044976323843002,
0.38756799697875977,
-0.2268550544977188,
0.2700614035129547,
0.22244058549404144,
-0.07620900869369507,
-0.3563095033168793,
-0.43686458468437195,
-0.4483770430088043,
0.20731274783611298,
-0.1362001597881317,
-0.013727354817092419
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06857v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06857v1
|
Development of a Reliable and Accessible Caregiving Language Model (CaLM)
| 2024-03-11T16:12:34 | 2024-03-11T16:12:34 |
Bambang Parmanto, Bayu Aryoyudanta, Wilbert Soekinto, I Made Agus Setiawan, Yuhan Wang, Haomin Hu, Andi Saptono, Yong K. Choi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Unlike professional caregivers, family caregivers often assume this role
without formal preparation or training. Because of this, there is an urgent
need to enhance the capacity of family caregivers to provide quality care.
Large language models can potentially be used as a foundation technology for
supporting caregivers as educational tools or as adjunct to care. This study
aimed to develop a reliable Caregiving Language Model (CaLM) by using FMs and a
caregiving knowledge base, develop an accessible CaLM using a small FM that
requires fewer computing resources, and evaluate the performance of the model
compared to a large FM. We developed CaLM using the Retrieval Augmented
Generation (RAG) framework combined with FM fine-tuning for improving the
quality of FM answers by grounding the model on a caregiving knowledge base. We
used two small FMs as candidates for the FM of CaLM (LLaMA-2 and Falcon with 7B
parameters) and larger FM GPT-3.5 as a benchmark. We developed the caregiving
knowledge base by gathering various types of documents from the Internet. In
this study, we focused on caregivers of individuals with Alzheimer's Disease
Related Dementias. We evaluated the models' performance using the benchmark
metrics commonly used in evaluating language models and their reliability to
provide accurate references with the answers. The RAG framework improved the
performance of all FMs used in this study across all measures. As expected, the
large FM performed better than small FMs across all metrics. The most
interesting result is that small fine-tuned FMs with RAG performed
significantly better than GPT 3.5 across all metrics. The fine-tuned LLaMA-2
small FM performed better than GPT 3.5 (even with RAG) in returning references
with the answers. The study shows that reliable and accessible CaLM can be
developed by using small FMs with a knowledge base specific to the caregiving
domain.
|
[
-0.16462908685207367,
-0.5939153432846069,
0.4982905983924866,
0.1613289713859558,
-0.31836792826652527,
-0.28177955746650696,
-0.40901660919189453,
-0.7885528206825256,
-0.1351272314786911,
0.05408628284931183,
-0.39122912287712097,
-0.157462477684021,
-0.5181190371513367,
-0.09607511013746262,
-0.036576926708221436,
0.8324504494667053,
-0.05191642791032791,
0.2327926605939865,
-0.011890281923115253,
-0.16512617468833923,
0.026967361569404602,
-0.36584946513175964,
-1.2648401260375977,
-0.5407410860061646,
0.306654691696167,
0.182046577334404,
0.7774457931518555,
0.6774564385414124,
0.6191532611846924,
0.2664090096950531,
-0.40576109290122986,
0.2315182089805603,
-0.5140408873558044,
0.15302903950214386,
-0.14097167551517487,
-0.45334771275520325,
-0.7266402244567871,
-0.20185920596122742,
0.044520534574985504,
0.20232972502708435,
-0.5367266535758972,
0.02375173009932041,
-0.18528391420841217,
0.7362920045852661,
-0.5349725484848022,
0.4707756042480469,
-0.5194658637046814,
0.15422098338603973,
-0.09406785666942596,
-0.069621741771698,
-0.2741335332393646,
-0.43436238169670105,
-0.09748868644237518,
-0.7026605606079102,
0.26259875297546387,
-0.03371049463748932,
1.009040117263794,
0.3405328691005707,
-0.17655746638774872,
-0.5075039863586426,
-0.7557421922683716,
0.7491843700408936,
-1.042824387550354,
0.29662612080574036,
0.9229046702384949,
0.33703750371932983,
-0.41644448041915894,
-0.4941033124923706,
-0.4638482332229614,
-0.39397144317626953,
-0.017982441931962967,
0.13294833898544312,
-0.06611742079257965,
0.04920988529920578,
0.14879831671714783,
0.6299863457679749,
-0.19768822193145752,
-0.004589477553963661,
-0.12114614993333817,
0.027648409828543663,
0.49982866644859314,
0.24556709825992584,
0.36809423565864563,
-0.0934542864561081,
-0.31504812836647034,
0.06818801164627075,
-0.3029838502407074,
0.23770396411418915,
-0.15187326073646545,
0.27228325605392456,
-0.2547812759876251,
0.6524739265441895,
-0.2780980169773102,
0.5592349171638489,
0.3063512146472931,
-0.8514807224273682,
0.13595011830329895,
-0.18316076695919037,
-0.08532650768756866,
-0.22167734801769257,
0.4499412178993225,
0.4495476484298706,
0.5091851949691772,
-0.15400180220603943,
-0.43632131814956665,
0.034115880727767944,
0.21778689324855804,
-0.5742432475090027,
-0.0635470300912857,
0.24051114916801453,
-0.5219340324401855,
-0.13050571084022522,
-0.2219080775976181,
-0.284842312335968,
-0.3873441219329834,
-0.35400164127349854,
0.2260672152042389,
-0.670718789100647,
-0.5026866793632507,
0.16901454329490662,
-0.006875823251903057,
0.16091997921466827,
0.517140805721283,
-0.8281639218330383,
0.4094155728816986,
0.5987729430198669,
0.5507336854934692,
-0.25896981358528137,
0.0956324115395546,
-0.47580400109291077,
0.21673063933849335,
-0.049796946346759796,
0.714460551738739,
-0.40744638442993164,
-0.4995306730270386,
0.09684406965970993,
-0.1693762242794037,
-0.065984345972538,
-0.5089142918586731,
0.5853714346885681,
-0.7748054265975952,
0.111359141767025,
-0.10860791802406311,
-0.42825981974601746,
-0.08716646581888199,
0.41112133860588074,
-0.8876004219055176,
0.9676032066345215,
0.7071980834007263,
-0.7330648303031921,
0.288239061832428,
-0.45047011971473694,
-0.5630770325660706,
0.10327539592981339,
-0.04149497300386429,
-0.31750020384788513,
0.19961366057395935,
0.043088216334581375,
0.46220263838768005,
-0.3764842748641968,
0.25250244140625,
-0.2330753654241562,
-0.45960238575935364,
0.16096694767475128,
-0.4235752522945404,
0.6074529886245728,
0.3323635160923004,
-0.18395887315273285,
-0.2610388994216919,
-0.5845441818237305,
0.11056308448314667,
0.07228418439626694,
-1.018304467201233,
-0.30765894055366516,
-0.03338039293885231,
-0.006709444336593151,
0.4707660675048828,
0.23925115168094635,
-0.3060559034347534,
-0.06387655436992645,
-0.15212096273899078,
0.13310424983501434,
0.3972860872745514,
0.016260739415884018,
0.3466704189777374,
-0.5945142507553101,
0.7266544103622437,
0.1267409324645996,
0.3289739191532135,
-0.09974192082881927,
-0.29754799604415894,
-0.6671237349510193,
-0.47744154930114746,
0.06926266103982925,
0.44915106892585754,
-0.760868489742279,
0.18175695836544037,
-0.163311168551445,
-0.37482455372810364,
-0.6405758857727051,
0.20006853342056274,
0.6695500016212463,
0.5403791666030884,
0.42701175808906555,
-0.0469193309545517,
-0.1718091070652008,
-0.5999315977096558,
0.04255174472928047,
-0.29049262404441833,
0.02187250927090645,
0.6472695469856262,
-0.12405578047037125,
-0.4065784513950348,
0.5113415122032166,
-0.32350724935531616,
-0.2423197478055954,
-0.07807490229606628,
-0.025680460035800934,
-0.065925233066082,
0.3510034680366516,
0.2526439428329468,
-0.6302080154418945,
-0.19922935962677002,
0.3445519506931305,
-0.7137444019317627,
0.3360122740268707,
0.45725947618484497,
-0.16057173907756805,
0.6622536778450012,
0.44119375944137573,
-0.9218750596046448,
0.4419335424900055,
0.5515015125274658,
-0.36724862456321716,
0.3674716353416443,
-0.1014021560549736,
-0.05530056357383728,
-1.2192480564117432,
0.4186868667602539,
-0.15307895839214325,
-0.2442142218351364,
-0.4798276126384735,
0.13986065983772278,
-0.16407035291194916,
0.1648390293121338,
-0.4019199013710022,
0.8130710124969482,
-0.380612313747406,
0.23742243647575378,
-0.1332431435585022,
0.02956732176244259,
0.06287302076816559,
0.3377797305583954,
-0.008715832605957985,
0.48830312490463257,
0.24450615048408508,
-0.4405119717121124,
0.06895528733730316,
0.06367877125740051,
-0.2196114957332611,
0.5306699275970459,
-0.46035560965538025,
0.12015509605407715,
-0.02045510523021221,
0.07620985805988312,
-0.6701725125312805,
-0.4416131377220154,
0.11000678688287735,
-0.12302509695291519,
0.6280484199523926,
-0.1555793732404709,
-0.2382025271654129,
-0.19115415215492249,
0.012612968683242798,
0.2508317530155182,
0.3968678414821625,
-0.3787480890750885,
0.7888016104698181,
0.6108587980270386,
-0.4577769935131073,
-0.6191824078559875,
-0.36467304825782776,
-0.4015856385231018,
-0.13814687728881836,
-0.6871324181556702,
0.15918514132499695,
-0.10521817207336426,
-0.40552717447280884,
0.1257888525724411,
-0.5059519410133362,
-0.35179659724235535,
0.03406853228807449,
0.2411770224571228,
0.19316154718399048,
-0.4792596697807312,
0.4589313566684723,
-0.08975592255592346,
-0.10254185646772385,
-0.061248503625392914,
0.21508389711380005,
0.5246681571006775,
-0.5877229571342468,
0.02370881289243698,
-0.2444932907819748,
0.3511753976345062,
0.6593936085700989,
-0.30082792043685913,
0.7725527882575989,
0.6334304809570312,
-0.49986782670021057,
-0.27250760793685913,
-0.8688478469848633,
-0.125718355178833,
-0.47489604353904724,
-0.14749078452587128,
-0.3872595727443695,
-1.3917934894561768,
0.5529371500015259,
-0.23076069355010986,
0.0045685782097280025,
0.133568674325943,
0.3006898760795593,
-0.2087518721818924,
0.8080587387084961,
0.9049739241600037,
0.008121686056256294,
0.4479842782020569,
0.04061716049909592,
0.09018855541944504,
-0.8970096111297607,
-0.3830990791320801,
-0.5674653649330139,
0.10467276722192764,
-0.38713788986206055,
-0.6829966902732849,
0.05252557992935181,
0.39865124225616455,
-0.3563196063041687,
-0.09386440366506577,
-0.10806410759687424,
-0.03447951003909111,
0.23796050250530243,
0.3911290466785431,
0.4790462553501129,
0.126250758767128,
-0.19201192259788513,
0.16211655735969543,
-0.7089641094207764,
-0.600708544254303,
0.5373788475990295,
0.46531879901885986,
0.9996492862701416,
0.18755333125591278,
0.4869161546230316,
0.1496945470571518,
0.7477630376815796,
-1.0190706253051758,
0.36508840322494507,
-0.4427298903465271,
-0.4928266108036041,
-0.31775254011154175,
-0.6493744254112244,
-0.8004811406135559,
-0.12155678123235703,
-0.08160173892974854,
-0.4580182433128357,
0.1700015366077423,
0.33909374475479126,
-0.2753312587738037,
-0.006091290153563023,
-0.7278077602386475,
0.5249086022377014,
-0.4346597194671631,
-0.16978320479393005,
-0.0067335437051951885,
-0.5998762845993042,
0.397420197725296,
-0.1757238656282425,
0.1710914671421051,
-0.28901687264442444,
0.01913348399102688,
0.431031733751297,
-0.40037792921066284,
0.5688031911849976,
-0.07880574464797974,
-0.005734897684305906,
0.393195778131485,
0.39445024728775024,
0.4961639940738678,
-0.053751323372125626,
-0.5711305737495422,
-0.027918947860598564,
-0.07901395857334137,
-0.2467142939567566,
-0.545954704284668,
0.979528546333313,
-0.7698000073432922,
-0.5717538595199585,
-0.16764284670352936,
-0.5816987156867981,
-0.4569002687931061,
0.41836240887641907,
-0.06167081370949745,
0.18035949766635895,
-0.24822929501533508,
0.141863614320755,
0.9244073629379272,
-0.045538146048784256,
0.25432467460632324,
0.9055857062339783,
-0.18037892878055573,
0.007708016317337751,
0.5412818193435669,
-0.10776205360889435,
0.1253434717655182,
0.33932074904441833,
0.41244664788246155,
-0.16226765513420105,
-0.1474875509738922,
-0.1281021386384964,
0.36970967054367065,
-0.6075822114944458,
-0.4172893464565277,
-0.6083853840827942,
-0.3185575604438782,
-0.0655430406332016,
-0.202860489487648,
-0.3753359913825989,
-0.510368824005127,
-0.2996428310871124,
-0.2614474594593048,
0.616273045539856,
0.7982808947563171,
0.0072941649705171585,
0.2056320756673813,
-0.5872887969017029,
0.4495988190174103,
0.2597171366214752,
0.7128992080688477,
0.03380661457777023,
-0.366364061832428,
-0.2772388458251953,
-0.10301674902439117,
0.2018142193555832,
-0.509270191192627,
0.02483266405761242,
0.073882557451725,
0.5473477840423584,
0.5883969068527222,
0.06316182017326355,
0.7503981590270996,
-0.3565971255302429,
0.46441850066185,
0.09535521268844604,
-0.6688076257705688,
0.5242273807525635,
-0.5596238970756531,
0.36954519152641296,
0.9488289952278137,
0.27123600244522095,
-0.142635315656662,
-0.1445259302854538,
-0.6979123950004578,
-0.9681299924850464,
0.6699718832969666,
-0.07321881502866745,
-0.027298228815197945,
-0.2232191115617752,
0.6099599003791809,
-0.15931890904903412,
0.0638660341501236,
-0.3271786868572235,
0.05530311539769173,
-0.07705201208591461,
-0.19151967763900757,
-0.0477655827999115,
-0.45199453830718994,
-0.17725904285907745,
0.0713939517736435,
0.7051411271095276,
-0.04227270185947418,
0.43533340096473694,
-0.0030441787093877792,
0.34846508502960205,
-0.7522640228271484,
0.1669231802225113,
0.43831902742385864,
0.4313752353191376,
-0.24116294085979462,
0.16066494584083557,
-0.017644066363573074,
-0.5720232725143433,
0.02196154184639454,
0.09097588062286377,
-0.15337850153446198,
0.003160374006256461,
0.24081245064735413,
0.38518789410591125,
0.4753074645996094,
-0.6901500821113586,
0.3762156665325165,
-0.37027478218078613,
0.4554533362388611,
-0.40812745690345764,
0.4490112364292145,
0.5430789589881897,
0.02017122134566307,
-0.19761314988136292,
0.1987341195344925,
-0.08789514750242233,
-0.3200659155845642,
0.25004467368125916,
0.3745877742767334,
-0.47602954506874084,
0.032283321022987366,
0.44021186232566833,
0.03946434706449509,
-0.41068652272224426,
0.8938279151916504,
-0.010035392828285694,
-0.041977740824222565,
0.41726040840148926,
0.7313668131828308,
0.5349140167236328,
-0.7394003868103027,
0.1675841063261032,
0.2903464138507843,
0.3479420840740204,
-0.5817809700965881,
0.7734780311584473,
0.060312796384096146,
-0.6932013630867004,
-0.20121750235557556,
-0.8656149506568909,
-0.3449726998806,
0.25505226850509644,
-1.1721962690353394,
-0.1045883521437645,
-0.4647272229194641,
-0.7184181809425354,
-0.32596421241760254,
0.0908864364027977,
-1.0537748336791992,
0.45775893330574036,
-0.1500047743320465,
1.2743299007415771,
-0.5737204551696777,
0.7913508415222168,
0.9706485867500305,
-0.2803208529949188,
-1.3600635528564453,
0.112484410405159,
-0.0804637148976326,
-0.6789370179176331,
0.2976319491863251,
-0.11720907688140869,
-0.607028067111969,
-0.20342783629894257,
-0.405260294675827,
-0.9261278510093689,
1.289897084236145,
0.3367239236831665,
-0.23523098230361938,
0.013819998130202293,
-0.3316931426525116,
0.9512323141098022,
-0.37320956587791443,
-0.11298927664756775,
0.4379725158214569,
0.43759092688560486,
0.16063237190246582,
-0.8433492183685303,
0.14043182134628296,
-0.6254520416259766,
0.13184121251106262,
-0.1839451789855957,
-0.8420076966285706,
0.6797412037849426,
-0.24028462171554565,
-0.14674478769302368,
0.20138996839523315,
0.6007659435272217,
0.7918741106987,
0.35552099347114563,
0.2765856385231018,
0.5932488441467285,
0.863178014755249,
-0.019179945811629295,
1.4555526971817017,
-0.37046733498573303,
0.07860268652439117,
1.2776272296905518,
-0.3593614995479584,
1.1305924654006958,
0.4987393021583557,
0.21380461752414703,
0.2710020840167999,
0.05154986307024956,
0.4878726601600647,
0.2827809154987335,
0.06132414564490318,
-0.6426256895065308,
-0.2779386639595032,
-0.6010510921478271,
-0.1751338392496109,
0.3858691453933716,
0.7201520204544067,
-0.4402579367160797,
0.029898421838879585,
-0.285146027803421,
0.6813048720359802,
-0.014234930276870728,
-0.33423930406570435,
0.7573167085647583,
0.5298247933387756,
-0.9226034283638,
0.3246045410633087,
0.271533727645874,
0.25340715050697327,
-0.8431698083877563,
-0.1589728593826294,
-0.5021449327468872,
0.3444281816482544,
-0.21853595972061157,
-0.5074282884597778,
0.1299019604921341,
0.24471834301948547,
-0.40189868211746216,
0.0037343662697821856,
1.0127357244491577,
-0.31021031737327576,
-0.5628260970115662,
0.4461936950683594,
0.7201629877090454,
0.2663205564022064,
0.45241180062294006,
-0.4618043005466461,
0.25155138969421387,
-0.26157110929489136,
-0.5210765600204468,
0.3129391372203827,
0.5241534113883972,
-0.3265245854854584,
0.956562876701355,
0.5354868173599243,
0.12482471764087677,
0.06263726949691772,
0.05214175954461098,
0.993837296962738,
-0.43172717094421387,
-0.10241863876581192,
-0.23522362112998962,
0.4272247552871704,
0.28541451692581177,
-0.5328637361526489,
0.47025585174560547,
0.17775356769561768,
0.6134013533592224,
-0.16400253772735596,
0.7601743340492249,
-0.16993437707424164,
0.5323889255523682,
-0.4101908504962921,
0.8173533082008362,
-0.41803279519081116,
0.12170447409152985,
0.04346371442079544,
-0.4943222105503082,
-0.28362685441970825,
1.0438928604125977,
-0.2953510880470276,
0.5179219841957092,
0.4219558835029602,
0.88841313123703,
-0.17436547577381134,
-0.03577963635325432,
0.21697121858596802,
0.3934110105037689,
0.16290996968746185,
0.43097275495529175,
0.639142632484436,
-0.20321086049079895,
0.32702919840812683,
-0.4746319651603699,
-0.2793404161930084,
-0.4898880422115326,
-0.8913629055023193,
-0.9761508703231812,
-0.09804734587669373,
-0.15236443281173706,
-0.47758999466896057,
0.29779231548309326,
0.8698213696479797,
0.5886295437812805,
-0.7183476090431213,
-0.05709224194288254,
0.37068334221839905,
-0.17938339710235596,
-0.38022053241729736,
-0.23849299550056458,
0.49841171503067017,
-0.14320142567157745,
-0.20852741599082947,
0.5182188153266907,
0.26798737049102783,
-0.02195322886109352,
-0.15838968753814697,
-0.3280748724937439,
-0.04719958454370499,
0.1527167111635208,
0.700709342956543,
0.5451868772506714,
-0.6914184093475342,
-0.17795582115650177,
0.11568538844585419,
-0.7411711812019348,
-0.19552277028560638,
0.6021151542663574,
-0.4037102460861206,
0.45936277508735657,
0.24797362089157104,
0.4838220477104187,
0.43827375769615173,
0.4520200192928314,
0.44443637132644653,
-0.44635239243507385,
-0.07035443186759949,
0.3639538288116455,
0.3616887927055359,
0.47785115242004395,
-0.6344110369682312,
0.6034928560256958,
-0.4197934865951538,
-0.4963274598121643,
-0.2509167790412903,
0.20001058280467987,
-1.303117275238037,
0.04341521114110947,
1.3648896217346191,
-0.5617663860321045,
-0.015032688155770302,
-0.35272684693336487,
-0.29868143796920776,
0.3315730690956116,
-0.5194844603538513,
1.0761229991912842,
0.4882439374923706,
-0.37130388617515564,
-0.2045862078666687,
-0.5664678812026978,
0.6971867084503174,
0.15588007867336273,
-0.7689160704612732,
-0.2582469582557678,
0.4841405749320984,
0.42747771739959717,
0.14140911400318146,
1.0828192234039307,
-0.4658821225166321,
0.36197221279144287,
-0.08955976366996765,
0.04366138577461243,
-0.2643239200115204,
-0.1565525233745575,
-0.3848947286605835,
0.20269741117954254,
0.4357137680053711,
0.4840632379055023
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06840v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06840v2
|
RA-ISF: Learning to Answer and Understand from Retrieval Augmentation via Iterative Self-Feedback
| 2024-03-11T16:01:05 | 2024-06-06T11:55:36 |
Yanming Liu, Xinyue Peng, Xuhong Zhang, Weihao Liu, Jianwei Yin, Jiannan Cao, Tianyu Du
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) demonstrate exceptional performance in numerous
tasks but still heavily rely on knowledge stored in their parameters. Moreover,
updating this knowledge incurs high training costs. Retrieval-augmented
generation (RAG) methods address this issue by integrating external knowledge.
The model can answer questions it couldn't previously by retrieving knowledge
relevant to the query. This approach improves performance in certain scenarios
for specific tasks. However, if irrelevant texts are retrieved, it may impair
model performance. In this paper, we propose Retrieval Augmented Iterative
Self-Feedback (RA-ISF), a framework that iteratively decomposes tasks and
processes them in three submodules to enhance the model's problem-solving
capabilities. Experiments show that our method outperforms existing benchmarks,
performing well on models like GPT3.5, Llama2, significantly enhancing factual
reasoning capabilities and reducing hallucinations.
|
[
-0.4358768165111542,
-0.7294612526893616,
0.5471126437187195,
0.2703971564769745,
-0.18667122721672058,
0.26232385635375977,
-0.2310602217912674,
-0.5033860802650452,
0.25731149315834045,
0.7447587251663208,
-0.672251284122467,
-0.10349518060684204,
-0.6005110144615173,
0.19926442205905914,
-0.4558691382408142,
1.1537147760391235,
0.1566055864095688,
0.05209147557616234,
-0.5249905586242676,
-0.10970485210418701,
-0.34190383553504944,
-0.3994187116622925,
-0.4359838664531708,
-0.6736178398132324,
0.2366826981306076,
0.6570290923118591,
0.20897118747234344,
0.4708361327648163,
0.6628851294517517,
0.3872639536857605,
0.04686538875102997,
0.4696773588657379,
-0.4345369338989258,
0.447184681892395,
-0.4540356695652008,
-0.24641726911067963,
-0.13465949892997742,
-0.16657736897468567,
0.5519720911979675,
0.44569218158721924,
-0.42791563272476196,
0.19047299027442932,
0.126851886510849,
0.9696926474571228,
-0.7270037531852722,
0.24657420814037323,
-0.5691668391227722,
-0.228435218334198,
0.008636141195893288,
-0.5955360531806946,
-0.5509277582168579,
-0.008280536159873009,
-0.13300561904907227,
-0.566331684589386,
0.2461639940738678,
0.1541050672531128,
0.7569502592086792,
0.6774842739105225,
-0.21386775374412537,
-0.5548083782196045,
-0.8425654768943787,
0.659446656703949,
-0.5532768368721008,
0.19766946136951447,
0.7783756852149963,
0.2874070405960083,
-0.10438711196184158,
-0.6464725136756897,
-0.3689611554145813,
-0.3114788830280304,
-0.16890349984169006,
0.21665719151496887,
-0.13895750045776367,
0.12757140398025513,
0.23044154047966003,
0.6232010722160339,
-0.271014928817749,
-0.25074127316474915,
-0.5478445291519165,
0.07731407135725021,
0.654251754283905,
-0.058783505111932755,
0.07967334240674973,
-0.46219801902770996,
-0.4129842519760132,
0.05054258555173874,
-0.7017261385917664,
-0.20143719017505646,
0.26513922214508057,
0.3891218304634094,
0.2849126160144806,
0.782731831073761,
-0.30803146958351135,
0.7349910736083984,
0.27412232756614685,
-0.233046755194664,
0.056227076798677444,
-0.4004541039466858,
0.058514051139354706,
-0.20069850981235504,
0.38224348425865173,
-0.11165332049131393,
-0.05568244680762291,
-0.31490325927734375,
-0.37912607192993164,
-0.21002614498138428,
0.5393116474151611,
-0.763201892375946,
-0.11246109008789062,
0.05651724338531494,
-0.2246583253145218,
-0.1256936639547348,
-0.047308363020420074,
-0.3874627649784088,
-0.26362162828445435,
-0.2085396647453308,
0.8285856246948242,
-0.44233617186546326,
-0.26540106534957886,
0.08968744426965714,
0.10836964845657349,
0.0979725793004036,
0.3194899559020996,
-0.7589203715324402,
0.38673320412635803,
0.44086557626724243,
0.4322914481163025,
-0.07224676758050919,
-0.08304493129253387,
-0.8844311833381653,
0.1482338309288025,
-0.21746064722537994,
1.1087307929992676,
-0.6223616003990173,
-0.5008231401443481,
-0.24328447878360748,
-0.3083869218826294,
-0.013837607577443123,
-0.8416820168495178,
0.36969470977783203,
-0.7734724283218384,
0.14741301536560059,
-0.48804253339767456,
-0.6132175326347351,
-0.571723222732544,
0.3692169785499573,
-0.4979884624481201,
1.4488892555236816,
0.11085987091064453,
-0.8075289726257324,
-0.11571520566940308,
-0.6497290730476379,
-0.44155773520469666,
0.15466800332069397,
-0.16011276841163635,
-0.27971428632736206,
0.20404818654060364,
0.5355360507965088,
0.2650383412837982,
-0.6381955146789551,
0.1634792685508728,
-0.1961180865764618,
-0.27988535165786743,
0.1660195291042328,
-0.030496634542942047,
0.30060598254203796,
0.42090845108032227,
-0.25320014357566833,
0.05490541458129883,
-0.9212919473648071,
0.1402270346879959,
0.009671936742961407,
-0.5147861838340759,
-0.22563527524471283,
-0.07843088358640671,
-0.23376625776290894,
-0.08057761192321777,
0.05040321871638298,
-0.4631352126598358,
0.2077264040708542,
-0.3670666515827179,
0.11522082984447479,
0.5308141708374023,
0.2550809681415558,
0.43143630027770996,
-0.44814029335975647,
0.7145404815673828,
0.043512579053640366,
-0.23173068463802338,
-0.4714910089969635,
-0.14330102503299713,
-0.9305059313774109,
-0.3283483684062958,
0.3179226517677307,
0.32475510239601135,
-0.9862322807312012,
0.07140310853719711,
-0.15810832381248474,
-0.22150182723999023,
-0.6150681972503662,
0.4676656126976013,
0.4749676585197449,
0.716064453125,
0.5433378219604492,
0.02103332430124283,
-0.5621909499168396,
-0.6353040337562561,
-0.23672910034656525,
-0.2833174169063568,
0.19409839808940887,
0.23400738835334778,
0.48088136315345764,
-0.3189519941806793,
0.7541529536247253,
-0.23604469001293182,
-0.6167409420013428,
-0.38598203659057617,
0.4132747948169708,
0.05457703769207001,
0.4074944853782654,
0.090047188103199,
-0.5705205798149109,
-0.21798905730247498,
-0.09946943074464798,
-0.6837649941444397,
-0.17847053706645966,
0.08978218585252762,
0.17552675306797028,
0.19692394137382507,
0.49662864208221436,
-0.37488505244255066,
0.37170663475990295,
0.3714922368526459,
-0.18247728049755096,
0.22178466618061066,
-0.5076038837432861,
0.36741483211517334,
-0.9137870669364929,
0.18404588103294373,
-0.2311604768037796,
-0.2740209400653839,
-0.2966007888317108,
0.3161843419075012,
0.22546280920505524,
0.09907237440347672,
0.10820116102695465,
0.5725972652435303,
-0.5852985382080078,
-0.4405277371406555,
-0.7119264602661133,
0.2867470681667328,
0.06698661297559738,
0.3426039218902588,
-0.05771332606673241,
0.9733999967575073,
0.1865663379430771,
-0.6605997085571289,
0.12614767253398895,
0.2436418980360031,
-0.38613805174827576,
0.41841408610343933,
-0.41519448161125183,
0.404369056224823,
-0.540077805519104,
0.0316038578748703,
-1.157583475112915,
-0.39353621006011963,
-0.07618225365877151,
-0.5238383412361145,
0.389884889125824,
-0.16362424194812775,
-0.5373902320861816,
-0.3946234881877899,
-0.08824216574430466,
0.38529250025749207,
0.11115247011184692,
-0.8458696603775024,
1.156908631324768,
0.3046554923057556,
-0.08894254267215729,
-0.9943475127220154,
-0.461282879114151,
-0.03779181092977524,
0.22099608182907104,
-0.6144500970840454,
0.36975526809692383,
-0.24410173296928406,
-0.30018892884254456,
0.30349424481391907,
-0.11773233860731125,
0.07167533040046692,
0.04458510875701904,
0.05877246335148811,
0.10415450483560562,
0.03612757474184036,
0.3838983178138733,
0.10676181316375732,
-0.31204652786254883,
-0.16951964795589447,
-0.012398297898471355,
0.28039130568504333,
-0.19330842792987823,
-0.5068109631538391,
-0.056738413870334625,
0.48775964975357056,
0.3655204772949219,
-0.6491723656654358,
0.37812307476997375,
0.3365045189857483,
-0.34996649622917175,
-0.39690348505973816,
-0.8337925672531128,
-0.3877373933792114,
-0.49739885330200195,
0.38887307047843933,
-0.5206931233406067,
-1.0010477304458618,
0.5300118327140808,
-0.08207127451896667,
-0.05121934041380882,
0.23497465252876282,
0.615291178226471,
-0.17213217914104462,
1.065575122833252,
0.7110118269920349,
0.2616255283355713,
0.15091927349567413,
-0.4462756812572479,
0.3365846574306488,
-0.7386263012886047,
-0.39381539821624756,
-0.4817335903644562,
0.0029884008690714836,
-0.22546961903572083,
-0.555119514465332,
0.5217891931533813,
0.2686190605163574,
0.00829133577644825,
-0.035499587655067444,
-0.45931562781333923,
0.5072779059410095,
0.4629766047000885,
0.23863419890403748,
0.625091552734375,
-0.08242228627204895,
-0.010622124187648296,
0.10979931801557541,
-0.663295328617096,
-0.09266906976699829,
0.8863810896873474,
0.21693055331707,
1.096638560295105,
0.1523887813091278,
0.7048116326332092,
0.35989782214164734,
0.5990009307861328,
-0.9015706181526184,
0.3943465054035187,
-0.07960304617881775,
-0.688914954662323,
0.019681716337800026,
-0.2793443500995636,
-0.4793155789375305,
0.36473652720451355,
-0.27391332387924194,
-0.4463811218738556,
-0.05241599678993225,
0.40953513979911804,
-0.4984106421470642,
0.13695693016052246,
-0.4197233021259308,
0.14597660303115845,
-0.12290149182081223,
-0.3583126664161682,
-0.45854222774505615,
-0.3448774516582489,
0.38242343068122864,
0.07254946231842041,
0.34546512365341187,
0.12555474042892456,
0.04884221777319908,
0.5799058675765991,
-0.4828393757343292,
0.4418639540672302,
-0.18747511506080627,
-0.054722223430871964,
0.44711482524871826,
0.03205835074186325,
0.7402141094207764,
0.015482794493436813,
-0.21711012721061707,
-0.48416054248809814,
0.09133412688970566,
-0.28336796164512634,
-0.9084635376930237,
0.6079245209693909,
-0.6883149743080139,
-0.956870436668396,
-0.42183583974838257,
-0.8493290543556213,
-0.4226563274860382,
0.025820724666118622,
0.3032246530056,
0.5617313385009766,
0.33067846298217773,
0.28743183612823486,
0.8077216744422913,
-0.0675569698214531,
0.27294406294822693,
0.7760148644447327,
-0.710956871509552,
-0.6170660853385925,
0.667923092842102,
0.2786366045475006,
0.03213046118617058,
0.28555312752723694,
0.1605808287858963,
-0.616730272769928,
-0.513008177280426,
-0.3552069664001465,
0.533509373664856,
-1.1330268383026123,
-0.648395299911499,
-0.845059871673584,
-0.24637098610401154,
-0.3557959496974945,
0.2335849553346634,
-0.4670673906803131,
-0.40143537521362305,
-0.14979970455169678,
-0.3328048288822174,
0.5742432475090027,
1.1888350248336792,
-0.5468425750732422,
0.24260827898979187,
-0.7318313717842102,
0.38778868317604065,
0.34049326181411743,
0.26829367876052856,
0.11902850866317749,
-0.7366498112678528,
-0.34281790256500244,
-0.21214815974235535,
-0.19068217277526855,
-0.8599293828010559,
0.2654176652431488,
0.2069566696882248,
0.481607586145401,
0.06075553968548775,
0.22048188745975494,
0.8054145574569702,
-0.28709521889686584,
0.43242332339286804,
-0.13741977512836456,
-0.8232939839363098,
0.4694737493991852,
-0.2398252785205841,
0.32842928171157837,
0.5779852867126465,
0.18616817891597748,
-0.0717768520116806,
-0.262349933385849,
-0.34566524624824524,
-0.816755473613739,
0.750856876373291,
-0.10795348137617111,
0.12350703030824661,
-0.1406707763671875,
0.779057502746582,
0.0029831130523234606,
0.0682431235909462,
-0.755409836769104,
-0.26365530490875244,
-0.06775759905576706,
-0.18810734152793884,
0.18988405168056488,
-0.5877805352210999,
-0.08218484371900558,
-0.28583765029907227,
1.0982073545455933,
-0.3260377049446106,
0.41563963890075684,
0.3000698387622833,
-0.2924245595932007,
-0.4965536594390869,
0.13297449052333832,
0.47856202721595764,
0.6813063621520996,
-0.09749533981084824,
0.22042420506477356,
0.19547569751739502,
-0.30767711997032166,
0.24212633073329926,
0.1243290826678276,
-0.09547577798366547,
-0.30236780643463135,
0.12643219530582428,
0.5690280199050903,
0.1292121410369873,
-0.5967406034469604,
0.43747270107269287,
-0.12452110648155212,
-0.2199157178401947,
-0.3344854712486267,
0.1488005667924881,
0.007747973315417767,
0.4918079972267151,
0.8016842007637024,
0.04160992428660393,
0.27752649784088135,
-0.41758596897125244,
0.5065382122993469,
0.39189499616622925,
-0.34510958194732666,
-0.08868332207202911,
0.5687031745910645,
-0.04578573256731033,
-0.3015473783016205,
0.5592762231826782,
-0.04690580070018768,
-0.5670806765556335,
0.21303170919418335,
0.9410101175308228,
0.6593087315559387,
-0.21210435032844543,
0.3349360525608063,
0.7777577638626099,
0.19300463795661926,
-0.21634997427463531,
0.49224767088890076,
-0.5034478902816772,
-0.5389760136604309,
-0.949138343334198,
-0.5918928980827332,
-0.3005160689353943,
0.14151804149150848,
-0.909134566783905,
-0.08443719893693924,
-0.4602430760860443,
-0.03408905118703842,
-0.27767473459243774,
0.06600560247898102,
-0.3749123215675354,
0.23868447542190552,
-0.2729562222957611,
0.7461657524108887,
-0.5211747288703918,
0.8037384152412415,
0.6360878944396973,
-0.6125311255455017,
-0.7707676291465759,
0.022780437022447586,
-0.3039882779121399,
-0.8056996464729309,
0.9877482652664185,
0.1229385957121849,
-0.4840792715549469,
0.3202095627784729,
-0.6283853650093079,
-1.2879446744918823,
0.7755259275436401,
0.42783305048942566,
-0.27347421646118164,
-0.03710572421550751,
-0.0917438343167305,
0.3906062841415405,
-0.2656254172325134,
0.3025696575641632,
0.35125869512557983,
0.3697856664657593,
0.3458404242992401,
-0.5957136750221252,
-0.04418458417057991,
-0.4694655239582062,
0.1130901575088501,
0.11723750829696655,
-0.538647472858429,
0.4347743093967438,
-0.5694748163223267,
-0.2656708061695099,
0.36236345767974854,
0.9665509462356567,
0.3937714993953705,
-0.0436532162129879,
0.4482985734939575,
0.81922447681427,
0.7288074493408203,
-0.012223141267895699,
1.0837111473083496,
-0.33588603138923645,
0.43148326873779297,
1.3360642194747925,
0.02465301938354969,
0.9013271331787109,
0.5100773572921753,
0.11328326910734177,
0.5425767302513123,
0.44408708810806274,
0.3996543884277344,
0.7569314241409302,
0.10177040845155716,
-0.38030654191970825,
-0.6058177947998047,
-0.11183790117502213,
-0.22315354645252228,
0.6005446910858154,
0.44200819730758667,
-0.13122478127479553,
-0.5719031095504761,
0.49004876613616943,
-0.0456971637904644,
0.44782453775405884,
-0.18588069081306458,
0.9051185250282288,
0.02713797427713871,
-1.083804726600647,
0.5685484409332275,
0.03231695666909218,
0.40267181396484375,
-0.551394522190094,
-0.3812572956085205,
-0.27939969301223755,
0.2903892397880554,
-0.2127608358860016,
-0.5334631204605103,
0.37051719427108765,
0.047605812549591064,
-0.4627832770347595,
-0.09295912086963654,
0.8193114399909973,
-0.49625441431999207,
-0.3931991159915924,
0.4895574748516083,
0.4797854721546173,
-0.18399669229984283,
0.07727651298046112,
-0.7583216428756714,
0.22602717578411102,
0.06122874468564987,
-0.24684303998947144,
0.09967363625764847,
0.13412998616695404,
0.2458602339029312,
0.959434449672699,
0.35583260655403137,
-0.1543598771095276,
-0.008913219906389713,
-0.06779170781373978,
0.887369692325592,
-0.471345454454422,
-0.2815701961517334,
-0.42871132493019104,
0.4909462630748749,
0.15534436702728271,
0.07147148996591568,
0.6572428345680237,
0.21819794178009033,
0.800532877445221,
0.17283083498477936,
0.8268007040023804,
-0.08936939388513565,
1.141223669052124,
-0.5202454924583435,
0.38053199648857117,
-0.7241082191467285,
0.730472981929779,
-0.07353128492832184,
-0.7984164953231812,
-0.22353874146938324,
0.7763633131980896,
-0.38318654894828796,
0.29963117837905884,
0.4586818516254425,
0.9861374497413635,
0.15242178738117218,
0.0867513045668602,
0.37798240780830383,
0.29545146226882935,
0.2921306788921356,
-0.10976500809192657,
1.0268666744232178,
-0.5821813941001892,
0.5235515236854553,
-0.4960445463657379,
-0.15993472933769226,
0.011288560926914215,
-0.7564371228218079,
-0.7225246429443359,
-0.8495518565177917,
-0.23148593306541443,
-0.5194694399833679,
0.13392148911952972,
1.0454870462417603,
0.5216459035873413,
-0.7492998838424683,
-0.17465756833553314,
-0.0535564050078392,
0.030707936733961105,
0.00773256178945303,
-0.19494540989398956,
0.34631070494651794,
-0.9916743636131287,
-0.5235494375228882,
0.5553584694862366,
0.5058021545410156,
-0.2504276931285858,
-0.37635985016822815,
-0.09246118366718292,
-0.4225514829158783,
0.1817416250705719,
0.5404714941978455,
0.3561211824417114,
-0.6630092859268188,
-0.3051764965057373,
0.25591570138931274,
0.2340390384197235,
0.12803669273853302,
0.7165956497192383,
-0.9210431575775146,
0.8393555879592896,
0.40171003341674805,
1.0966370105743408,
0.860910177230835,
0.2539057731628418,
0.4481133818626404,
-0.6741547584533691,
-0.14999167621135712,
0.17753294110298157,
0.2738373577594757,
0.5913868546485901,
-0.4249545633792877,
0.6835187077522278,
0.051358580589294434,
-0.708724319934845,
-0.8581817150115967,
0.21882225573062897,
-0.5611526966094971,
-0.3329494893550873,
1.1445213556289673,
-0.11765551567077637,
-0.18293419480323792,
-0.11429070681333542,
-0.24459221959114075,
0.07761429995298386,
-0.025871295481920242,
0.9577038884162903,
0.4602280259132385,
-0.3983580768108368,
-0.49384185671806335,
-0.2152407467365265,
0.5506579875946045,
0.6462297439575195,
-0.7183550000190735,
0.06897526979446411,
0.4309505522251129,
0.3186592757701874,
0.21594420075416565,
0.9463547468185425,
-0.3804997503757477,
0.31937310099601746,
-0.3170608878135681,
-0.11019359529018402,
-0.1476820409297943,
-0.49242904782295227,
-0.19470778107643127,
0.11631383746862411,
0.4400728940963745,
0.13918554782867432
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06835v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06835v1
|
Medical Image Synthesis via Fine-Grained Image-Text Alignment and Anatomy-Pathology Prompting
| 2024-03-11T15:56:17 | 2024-03-11T15:56:17 |
Wenting Chen, Pengyu Wang, Hui Ren, Lichao Sun, Quanzheng Li, Yixuan Yuan, Xiang Li
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Data scarcity and privacy concerns limit the availability of high-quality
medical images for public use, which can be mitigated through medical image
synthesis. However, current medical image synthesis methods often struggle to
accurately capture the complexity of detailed anatomical structures and
pathological conditions. To address these challenges, we propose a novel
medical image synthesis model that leverages fine-grained image-text alignment
and anatomy-pathology prompts to generate highly detailed and accurate
synthetic medical images. Our method integrates advanced natural language
processing techniques with image generative modeling, enabling precise
alignment between descriptive text prompts and the synthesized images'
anatomical and pathological details. The proposed approach consists of two key
components: an anatomy-pathology prompting module and a fine-grained
alignment-based synthesis module. The anatomy-pathology prompting module
automatically generates descriptive prompts for high-quality medical images. To
further synthesize high-quality medical images from the generated prompts, the
fine-grained alignment-based synthesis module pre-defines a visual codebook for
the radiology dataset and performs fine-grained alignment between the codebook
and generated prompts to obtain key patches as visual clues, facilitating
accurate image synthesis. We validate the superiority of our method through
experiments on public chest X-ray datasets and demonstrate that our synthetic
images preserve accurate semantic information, making them valuable for various
medical applications.
|
[
-0.4060761332511902,
-0.7783125042915344,
0.8537063002586365,
-0.129548579454422,
-0.42413005232810974,
-0.11893130838871002,
0.1528846025466919,
-0.440387099981308,
0.3559195399284363,
0.5446981191635132,
-0.6192950010299683,
-0.8040318489074707,
-0.24588608741760254,
0.20911364257335663,
-0.3322659432888031,
0.8390442132949829,
0.022626034915447235,
0.1981181651353836,
-0.0841311439871788,
0.009342732839286327,
-0.45977291464805603,
-0.07856608182191849,
-0.46787115931510925,
-0.011677687987685204,
0.36079898476600647,
0.031984761357307434,
0.9590528011322021,
1.1720905303955078,
0.5412791967391968,
0.21030987799167633,
0.1939731240272522,
0.4266969859600067,
0.005368258338421583,
0.188437357544899,
-0.06619250774383545,
-0.05203580856323242,
-0.47508934140205383,
-0.24406512081623077,
0.47006848454475403,
0.41091451048851013,
0.15770664811134338,
-0.07895481586456299,
-0.05373283103108406,
0.9415844082832336,
-0.38951733708381653,
0.003314095316454768,
-0.5378512740135193,
0.16380108892917633,
-0.045926500111818314,
-0.6135352849960327,
-0.2106286734342575,
-0.5813436508178711,
0.12758590281009674,
-0.7616367340087891,
0.41615843772888184,
-0.2576810419559479,
0.9342213869094849,
0.2701757848262787,
-0.009192372672259808,
-0.43940919637680054,
-0.45652827620506287,
0.3529222309589386,
-0.5287116169929504,
0.15852142870426178,
0.09187950193881989,
0.5842532515525818,
-0.21948589384555817,
-0.8340738415718079,
-0.1102537289261818,
-0.10248768329620361,
-0.24206805229187012,
0.33036476373672485,
-0.09587480872869492,
0.049284618347883224,
-0.2274993509054184,
0.4022083878517151,
-0.6490393877029419,
-0.1527615189552307,
-0.5559260249137878,
-0.3296341300010681,
0.5760315656661987,
0.5275731086730957,
0.587303102016449,
-0.30066511034965515,
-0.5081639289855957,
-0.06862223893404007,
-0.8100141286849976,
-0.27879858016967773,
-0.07710286229848862,
0.33257219195365906,
0.01910076104104519,
0.6075646281242371,
-0.30519264936447144,
0.90052330493927,
0.06214136630296707,
-0.251506507396698,
0.02964385785162449,
-0.31466206908226013,
-0.35096365213394165,
0.3297961354255676,
0.8304761052131653,
0.9396325349807739,
-0.25588715076446533,
0.18988251686096191,
-0.07101603597402573,
0.29085999727249146,
0.33177250623703003,
-0.8562374711036682,
-0.1407107263803482,
0.6608699560165405,
-0.7848562002182007,
-0.8815965056419373,
-0.17098289728164673,
-0.8295483589172363,
-0.5165563225746155,
-0.3502350449562073,
0.39275071024894714,
-0.5374125242233276,
0.3003689646720886,
0.27302759885787964,
0.1468573361635208,
-0.07643524557352066,
0.4955347776412964,
-0.5925331711769104,
0.19286192953586578,
0.24217192828655243,
0.7388579249382019,
0.10806559771299362,
-0.05107186734676361,
-0.5995112061500549,
0.4094795286655426,
-0.6024174094200134,
0.724372148513794,
-0.3324301540851593,
-0.2730373740196228,
-0.01264807116240263,
-0.02895648404955864,
0.5392805933952332,
-0.6318781971931458,
0.27119511365890503,
0.03314320743083954,
0.2682706415653229,
0.0855727270245552,
-0.22514066100120544,
0.013341712765395641,
0.45174524188041687,
-0.6553587317466736,
0.6424599885940552,
0.08859941363334656,
-0.499801367521286,
-0.07446576654911041,
-0.4952102303504944,
-0.45991864800453186,
-0.019170738756656647,
-0.46836549043655396,
-0.25118571519851685,
0.16229437291622162,
0.7120277285575867,
0.4834004044532776,
-0.4640439748764038,
0.4608372747898102,
0.18548908829689026,
-0.08155126869678497,
0.5594078302383423,
-0.3544131815433502,
0.3120197653770447,
0.269924521446228,
-0.06859944015741348,
0.1118079274892807,
-1.0429818630218506,
0.04728890210390091,
0.3008134365081787,
-0.05038981884717941,
-0.21484658122062683,
-0.08733547478914261,
-0.062253188341856,
0.1587134748697281,
0.22035181522369385,
-0.47634539008140564,
0.4481145739555359,
-0.691729724407196,
0.3124665915966034,
0.3981434106826782,
0.26310935616493225,
0.30443310737609863,
-0.6444473266601562,
0.37735825777053833,
-0.07205256819725037,
0.34511372447013855,
-0.40934789180755615,
-0.6403155326843262,
-0.22308462858200073,
-0.35439786314964294,
0.14029467105865479,
0.4982072710990906,
-0.43155643343925476,
0.25204604864120483,
-0.18888050317764282,
-0.49403125047683716,
-0.7118200063705444,
-0.48757296800613403,
0.4752972424030304,
0.8231069445610046,
0.5643129944801331,
-0.554796040058136,
-0.6007339954376221,
-0.9144214391708374,
0.12940342724323273,
-0.06471230834722519,
-0.27510496973991394,
0.24020254611968994,
-0.0888134092092514,
-0.3559435307979584,
0.5891323089599609,
-0.9767903089523315,
-0.7013351321220398,
0.3284972906112671,
0.18564225733280182,
0.1737138032913208,
0.7259706854820251,
0.4641414284706116,
-0.3901061713695526,
-0.25449028611183167,
0.48924338817596436,
-0.6078080534934998,
-0.24352824687957764,
-0.4171321988105774,
-0.2890850901603699,
0.17352542281150818,
0.6393551826477051,
-0.5406535863876343,
0.5573251247406006,
0.32836151123046875,
0.05006861314177513,
0.5326361060142517,
-0.370950311422348,
0.5295430421829224,
-1.2468366622924805,
0.2585078477859497,
-0.16418321430683136,
-0.23234745860099792,
-0.554907500743866,
0.34616023302078247,
-0.1318095475435257,
-0.44505274295806885,
-0.39835411310195923,
0.6450096964836121,
-0.4566870331764221,
0.10395986586809158,
-0.12479031085968018,
-0.23913225531578064,
0.3510635197162628,
0.1058335229754448,
0.21572627127170563,
0.2742353677749634,
0.7612305879592896,
-0.37203076481819153,
0.12916210293769836,
0.4948430359363556,
-0.19557923078536987,
0.6393482685089111,
-0.5879316329956055,
0.10400023311376572,
-0.16233542561531067,
0.21674425899982452,
-0.7219210267066956,
-0.8602777123451233,
0.32266518473625183,
-0.2628095746040344,
0.36701399087905884,
-0.3240979313850403,
-0.15236696600914001,
-0.13357584178447723,
-0.21265290677547455,
0.5694946050643921,
0.8195111155509949,
-0.27009373903274536,
0.587184727191925,
0.10003682225942612,
-0.33400511741638184,
-0.05973750352859497,
-1.0286511182785034,
0.12878602743148804,
0.18793760240077972,
-0.6062416434288025,
0.7450871467590332,
0.04854671284556389,
0.05490399897098541,
0.08055195212364197,
0.09284002333879471,
-0.21578355133533478,
-0.35657215118408203,
0.34540098905563354,
0.5521308183670044,
-0.21721479296684265,
-0.13852575421333313,
0.31645461916923523,
-0.057540394365787506,
-0.1484472155570984,
-0.34664857387542725,
0.29360902309417725,
0.2395934760570526,
-0.553008496761322,
-0.6435073018074036,
0.43780916929244995,
0.8054532408714294,
-0.07466495782136917,
-0.10005441308021545,
0.37625807523727417,
-0.7858554720878601,
0.2175808995962143,
-0.38558512926101685,
-0.2900635004043579,
-0.42742419242858887,
0.27705618739128113,
-0.048342347145080566,
-0.44364938139915466,
0.4354146420955658,
0.0013738321140408516,
-0.07546477019786835,
0.1546379178762436,
0.681264340877533,
-0.13659045100212097,
1.2853211164474487,
-0.35147973895072937,
0.4352734386920929,
-0.013021619990468025,
-0.003248632187023759,
-0.056071002036333084,
-0.6542361378669739,
-0.2830267548561096,
-0.2598450779914856,
-0.24179276823997498,
-0.5107133388519287,
-0.6216601133346558,
0.7598111033439636,
-0.38775476813316345,
0.08201967179775238,
0.0006224105600267649,
-1.2622822523117065,
0.6509796977043152,
0.27505674958229065,
0.6399668455123901,
0.13717542588710785,
0.26423922181129456,
0.07999426871538162,
-0.0974789410829544,
-0.23122434318065643,
-0.6625617742538452,
0.87635737657547,
0.03469257429242134,
0.9044795632362366,
-0.11237769573926926,
1.021219253540039,
-0.08424077183008194,
0.009455171413719654,
-0.889715850353241,
0.4472866952419281,
-0.4957045316696167,
-0.4915769398212433,
0.03693949431180954,
0.0624951496720314,
-1.0685359239578247,
-0.30318036675453186,
-0.466002494096756,
-0.41805630922317505,
0.1151418462395668,
0.39910805225372314,
-0.6499151587486267,
0.0865422710776329,
-0.5768312215805054,
0.6128500699996948,
-0.07326292246580124,
-0.1381763070821762,
0.1424189656972885,
-0.9881139397621155,
0.2456446886062622,
-0.06874874234199524,
0.24426089227199554,
0.08055035024881363,
0.04895256459712982,
0.17571178078651428,
-0.651827871799469,
0.8861969709396362,
0.025580761954188347,
-0.0177023783326149,
0.3012522757053375,
0.5350165963172913,
0.38492244482040405,
0.0683646872639656,
0.19855090975761414,
-0.1132550835609436,
0.11049272119998932,
-0.34448689222335815,
-0.528135359287262,
0.6464942693710327,
-0.254631906747818,
-0.5117123126983643,
0.06525316089391708,
-0.7114886045455933,
-0.1192290186882019,
0.2192738801240921,
0.5171381235122681,
1.0549461841583252,
-0.4266192615032196,
-0.259547621011734,
0.26314109563827515,
-0.5179430246353149,
-0.07090719044208527,
-0.1544807404279709,
-0.3159715235233307,
-0.7807555794715881,
0.9512266516685486,
-0.10590197890996933,
0.338706374168396,
0.5803852081298828,
0.345657616853714,
0.05722172558307648,
-0.6491256356239319,
-0.696195662021637,
-0.0011495155049487948,
-0.7291077375411987,
-0.5430325269699097,
-0.25815656781196594,
-0.1177738681435585,
-0.368276983499527,
-0.8211466073989868,
-0.5089730024337769,
-0.3009047210216522,
-0.33632442355155945,
0.4814005196094513,
0.244728684425354,
0.683647632598877,
0.15790703892707825,
-0.011784370057284832,
-1.3108288049697876,
0.47488027811050415,
0.3207288980484009,
0.1317821592092514,
-0.2399968057870865,
-0.008175180293619633,
0.046351153403520584,
-0.13847778737545013,
-0.37423190474510193,
-0.8087820410728455,
0.5185277462005615,
0.03870505094528198,
-0.05433451756834984,
0.24020719528198242,
-0.10636093467473984,
0.8791863322257996,
-0.7300272583961487,
0.8913467526435852,
0.48968300223350525,
-0.7656431198120117,
0.9811649918556213,
-0.3484134376049042,
0.48247650265693665,
0.4551311433315277,
-0.08303219825029373,
-0.04008214548230171,
-0.8188723921775818,
-0.6203415989875793,
-0.6812301278114319,
0.46116915345191956,
0.2892422378063202,
0.02029997855424881,
-0.18223430216312408,
0.25890445709228516,
0.38168108463287354,
-0.17677228152751923,
-0.2621130049228668,
-0.05200235918164253,
-0.1879551112651825,
-0.6283153891563416,
0.5679241418838501,
-0.031483154743909836,
-0.5967172980308533,
-0.11495866626501083,
0.5414366126060486,
-0.3987399935722351,
0.3953458368778229,
0.6087419390678406,
0.2300562709569931,
-0.12107320129871368,
0.1710607409477234,
0.5892332792282104,
0.25434669852256775,
-0.18915486335754395,
0.172210231423378,
-0.4230162501335144,
-0.4330713450908661,
0.3155680298805237,
0.27202945947647095,
-0.18380476534366608,
0.21061930060386658,
0.11579889804124832,
0.5057901740074158,
-0.11731076240539551,
-0.5154209136962891,
0.4174029529094696,
-0.07360319793224335,
-0.30528900027275085,
0.13406619429588318,
0.024443240836262703,
0.14878273010253906,
0.1334795504808426,
0.18123197555541992,
0.598317563533783,
0.3532862663269043,
-0.24376580119132996,
0.1053089126944542,
0.2763536274433136,
-0.08534154295921326,
-0.31571629643440247,
0.6819919943809509,
0.026908868923783302,
0.09601692855358124,
0.4650058448314667,
-0.01415746845304966,
-0.0381900854408741,
0.49491092562675476,
0.5434273481369019,
0.6394357085227966,
-0.25069379806518555,
0.25591805577278137,
0.47921454906463623,
0.02663072757422924,
-0.06979255378246307,
0.4558833837509155,
0.32232314348220825,
-0.2417006641626358,
-0.3655543923377991,
-0.47448602318763733,
-0.1533956080675125,
0.05507584661245346,
-0.6653037071228027,
0.6424298286437988,
-0.6085700988769531,
-0.14825797080993652,
0.5101056694984436,
-0.6695647239685059,
-0.229076087474823,
0.7323720455169678,
0.200572207570076,
0.7040923237800598,
-0.6558608412742615,
0.6334322094917297,
0.7392802238464355,
-0.35319027304649353,
-0.9417402148246765,
0.08661388605833054,
0.052018411457538605,
-0.8047007322311401,
0.13114440441131592,
0.32170239090919495,
0.29596322774887085,
0.04122471064329147,
-0.5279834270477295,
-0.5856289267539978,
0.900109052658081,
0.5318547487258911,
-0.4277936518192291,
-0.03401042893528938,
0.1055741012096405,
0.5507739782333374,
-0.5151147246360779,
-0.2625902593135834,
0.19411727786064148,
0.34815895557403564,
0.5057018399238586,
-0.6921409368515015,
0.6095519661903381,
-0.19892354309558868,
0.17169927060604095,
0.2946361005306244,
-0.02638559229671955,
0.4725898802280426,
-0.2522318959236145,
-0.24373680353164673,
0.5747715830802917,
0.28717681765556335,
0.3650451600551605,
0.4800788164138794,
0.12017950415611267,
0.5170034766197205,
0.5146870613098145,
-0.19530780613422394,
1.0919297933578491,
-0.20373089611530304,
0.08358190208673477,
0.8090918064117432,
-0.21480698883533478,
0.2632421851158142,
0.6343134045600891,
-0.07893172651529312,
0.36266493797302246,
0.43426746129989624,
-0.10731104016304016,
0.7280979156494141,
-0.10087469965219498,
-0.36737963557243347,
-0.14642152190208435,
-0.17292937636375427,
-0.4240480661392212,
0.2624700665473938,
0.47523826360702515,
-0.725579023361206,
-0.271226167678833,
0.0036443814169615507,
-0.3628075420856476,
-0.15232256054878235,
-0.3381176292896271,
0.8292881846427917,
-0.10477527976036072,
-0.6927164196968079,
0.9403446316719055,
-0.1791618913412094,
0.2271968424320221,
-0.42313382029533386,
-0.16571365296840668,
0.06534698605537415,
-0.2097538411617279,
-0.4830794036388397,
-1.0250244140625,
0.524899423122406,
-0.25274857878685,
0.016842951998114586,
0.15941061079502106,
0.6791017055511475,
-0.4951370656490326,
-0.4405727684497833,
-0.4541647434234619,
0.07932072877883911,
0.32291287183761597,
0.1558382511138916,
-0.5804868936538696,
0.2042396366596222,
0.12475534528493881,
0.0920340046286583,
0.3260028064250946,
0.4947319030761719,
-0.24647629261016846,
0.10689150542020798,
0.7275508046150208,
0.28446248173713684,
-0.4028140902519226,
-0.06756370514631271,
0.8446977138519287,
-0.2833195924758911,
-0.32839709520339966,
-0.6610896587371826,
0.6316234469413757,
0.08463841676712036,
-0.22267407178878784,
-0.16097579896450043,
0.30133506655693054,
0.5093691945075989,
-0.5469693541526794,
0.7582671046257019,
-0.1413586586713791,
-0.27984702587127686,
-0.9196524620056152,
0.6322394013404846,
-0.7580792307853699,
-0.15935228765010834,
-0.27194446325302124,
-0.44626757502555847,
-0.8214911818504333,
0.4799801707267761,
0.18071793019771576,
-0.4625530242919922,
0.6664083003997803,
1.2096896171569824,
-0.22880937159061432,
-0.03076384775340557,
0.34968650341033936,
0.1696726381778717,
0.19528472423553467,
0.4613979458808899,
0.42456045746803284,
-0.45206284523010254,
0.4892154932022095,
-0.2581993639469147,
-0.18955765664577484,
-0.30888134241104126,
-1.040055513381958,
-0.48919862508773804,
-0.7177644968032837,
-0.7040930986404419,
-0.6827559471130371,
-0.09278876334428787,
1.0025346279144287,
0.7212523818016052,
-0.6459162831306458,
0.3265911340713501,
-0.3761962950229645,
-0.25760501623153687,
-0.14702440798282623,
-0.24198387563228607,
0.7207628488540649,
-0.11493893712759018,
-0.6829407215118408,
0.2742651402950287,
0.84330815076828,
0.6547618508338928,
0.012145510874688625,
0.015940280631184578,
0.2109472155570984,
0.06207055225968361,
0.3344591557979584,
0.24687524139881134,
-0.7965307235717773,
-0.026668403297662735,
-0.13142479956150055,
-0.5112478137016296,
0.43036341667175293,
0.633253812789917,
-0.5626318454742432,
0.8849087357521057,
0.5051259994506836,
0.6873106956481934,
0.15590326488018036,
0.03792675957083702,
0.482486754655838,
-0.9690567255020142,
0.1355728954076767,
0.17668449878692627,
0.28238213062286377,
0.5273148417472839,
-0.6812742948532104,
0.2454976588487625,
-0.02654041349887848,
-0.40087175369262695,
-0.8227405548095703,
0.3351134955883026,
-1.362990379333496,
-0.46004098653793335,
0.9632607698440552,
0.02238398604094982,
-0.5100871920585632,
0.239857017993927,
-0.7601372599601746,
0.2864893972873688,
-0.20977549254894257,
0.8261492848396301,
0.18095503747463226,
-0.29365187883377075,
0.1988457888364792,
0.018570411950349808,
0.4375794231891632,
0.09593270719051361,
-1.0062389373779297,
-0.20088393986225128,
0.8700196743011475,
0.21712476015090942,
0.3691231906414032,
0.6712453365325928,
-0.7449551224708557,
0.6797258853912354,
-0.282174676656723,
0.08913582563400269,
-0.17505145072937012,
-0.013885349966585636,
-0.06792517006397247,
0.0783308744430542,
-0.027263948693871498,
-0.3306092917919159
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06833v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06833v2
|
Can LLMs Separate Instructions From Data? And What Do We Even Mean By That?
| 2024-03-11T15:48:56 | 2024-06-03T12:04:50 |
Egor Zverev, Sahar Abdelnabi, Soroush Tabesh, Mario Fritz, Christoph H. Lampert
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Instruction-tuned Large Language Models (LLMs) show impressive results in
numerous practical applications, but they lack essential safety features that
are common in other areas of computer science, particularly an explicit
separation of instructions and data. This makes them vulnerable to
manipulations such as indirect prompt injections and generally unsuitable for
safety-critical tasks. Surprisingly, there is currently no established
definition or benchmark to quantify this phenomenon. In this work, we close
this gap by introducing a formal measure for instruction-data separation and an
empirical variant that is calculable from a model's outputs. We also present a
new dataset, SEP, that allows estimating the measure for real-world models. Our
results on various LLMs show that the problem of instruction-data separation is
real: all models fail to achieve high separation, and canonical mitigation
techniques, such as prompt engineering and fine-tuning, either fail to
substantially improve separation or reduce model utility. The source code and
SEP dataset are openly accessible at
https://github.com/egozverev/Shold-It-Be-Executed-Or-Processed.
|
[
-0.2000262588262558,
-1.109279990196228,
0.6514435410499573,
0.049499645829200745,
-0.28108033537864685,
0.14180870354175568,
-0.23039162158966064,
-0.6407995223999023,
-0.16411148011684418,
0.6467980146408081,
-0.5632078051567078,
-0.48993170261383057,
-0.6829575896263123,
-0.07945390790700912,
-0.8195750117301941,
0.6389060616493225,
-0.11720947176218033,
0.18449699878692627,
-0.23310412466526031,
0.25898993015289307,
-0.39958783984184265,
-0.45801106095314026,
-0.21252086758613586,
-0.04802779480814934,
0.5064939260482788,
0.5739901065826416,
0.40661612153053284,
1.3182026147842407,
0.8300751447677612,
0.2633712887763977,
-0.12608380615711212,
0.2541522979736328,
-0.3640303313732147,
0.1278495192527771,
0.022490890696644783,
-0.7619538903236389,
-0.3834279477596283,
0.3101526200771332,
0.9609013199806213,
0.9897554516792297,
-0.162191241979599,
-0.06142398715019226,
0.156540185213089,
0.7880523204803467,
-0.6222083568572998,
0.037631794810295105,
-0.5320320725440979,
0.0047331140376627445,
-0.17443516850471497,
-0.09269022196531296,
-0.562533438205719,
-0.6200867295265198,
-0.10578291863203049,
-0.10458996146917343,
-0.08386079967021942,
0.06633070856332779,
0.8598452806472778,
0.22612373530864716,
-0.31335964798927307,
-0.3703867197036743,
-1.0098252296447754,
1.0147130489349365,
-0.7084048986434937,
0.4226391315460205,
0.38167843222618103,
0.39034131169319153,
-0.2048805207014084,
-0.5474262833595276,
-0.20957864820957184,
-0.25796449184417725,
0.132720947265625,
-0.26509127020835876,
-0.11266910284757614,
0.08121462911367416,
0.40594303607940674,
0.2911931276321411,
-0.26338472962379456,
0.3977060317993164,
-0.7576133012771606,
0.037116896361112595,
0.5561309456825256,
0.5854325890541077,
0.5435075163841248,
0.18039274215698242,
-0.6027003526687622,
0.1922304481267929,
-1.315009355545044,
0.001320547773502767,
0.48375871777534485,
0.25663885474205017,
-0.29503634572029114,
0.478013813495636,
-0.09091659635305405,
0.6677020192146301,
-0.2619718313217163,
-0.14682140946388245,
-0.16290655732154846,
-0.1381726711988449,
-0.27373623847961426,
-0.09293624013662338,
0.8171404600143433,
0.04252771660685539,
0.1668223887681961,
-0.3524863123893738,
-0.37745654582977295,
-0.1908503919839859,
0.15034866333007812,
-1.0130778551101685,
-0.3726747930049896,
0.16240254044532776,
-0.2371981292963028,
-0.3718161880970001,
0.06924953311681747,
-0.6729919910430908,
-0.3711428940296173,
-0.5162473320960999,
0.023586848750710487,
-0.24026046693325043,
-0.02838277816772461,
0.06702665984630585,
0.24550068378448486,
0.28529661893844604,
0.16662639379501343,
-0.770605206489563,
0.44646957516670227,
1.0914568901062012,
0.6998443603515625,
-0.3657410740852356,
-0.13994406163692474,
-0.5621324181556702,
-0.051920220255851746,
-0.5145233869552612,
0.7004280686378479,
-0.8621332049369812,
-0.28297197818756104,
-0.04162789136171341,
0.1043296828866005,
-0.12459052354097366,
-0.6279876828193665,
0.3291798532009125,
-0.5439811944961548,
0.06670845299959183,
-0.3294481039047241,
-1.0564255714416504,
0.008949845097959042,
-0.10148951411247253,
-0.7491483092308044,
0.5194288492202759,
-0.24926847219467163,
-0.3676833510398865,
0.10067501664161682,
-0.09295515716075897,
-0.5734214186668396,
-0.15610329806804657,
-0.27529680728912354,
-0.2843247056007385,
0.19193291664123535,
-0.1843409687280655,
0.335574209690094,
-0.5803748369216919,
0.2714616358280182,
-0.6506769061088562,
-0.5635838508605957,
0.663246214389801,
-0.893079936504364,
0.6849773526191711,
0.20331047475337982,
-0.17911984026432037,
-0.04308262839913368,
-0.941096305847168,
0.11582790315151215,
-0.16641613841056824,
-0.5462794303894043,
-0.23074433207511902,
0.16679437458515167,
-0.42589014768600464,
0.14397947490215302,
0.4490341246128082,
-0.3740321397781372,
0.1775587946176529,
-0.3513343036174774,
0.4236298203468323,
0.8802026510238647,
-0.1755581796169281,
0.6717087030410767,
-0.22854934632778168,
0.5415897369384766,
-0.022050416097044945,
0.26006853580474854,
-0.14185969531536102,
-0.2361551970243454,
-0.7135366201400757,
-0.5629206895828247,
0.4283329248428345,
0.6952487230300903,
-0.3462589681148529,
0.6914681792259216,
-0.06239129230380058,
-0.48416244983673096,
-0.36986660957336426,
0.1958286166191101,
0.669797956943512,
0.5185163617134094,
0.1475980579853058,
-0.03921188786625862,
-0.20952223241329193,
-0.874561607837677,
-0.23751220107078552,
0.03541400283575058,
-0.06791577488183975,
0.10835062712430954,
0.20125485956668854,
0.15700937807559967,
0.6356837153434753,
-0.5547072887420654,
0.32816070318222046,
-0.11931345611810684,
0.041423626244068146,
0.05669475719332695,
0.46174296736717224,
0.07408653199672699,
-0.32056957483291626,
-0.10672205686569214,
-0.2244027704000473,
-1.0761139392852783,
-0.4003482162952423,
0.12066782265901566,
-0.21628844738006592,
-0.11393412947654724,
0.6752555966377258,
-0.6611162424087524,
0.39797142148017883,
0.2909899055957794,
0.05724315717816353,
0.7437633872032166,
-0.2745356261730194,
0.19429823756217957,
-0.7978044748306274,
-0.02532375045120716,
-0.07414954900741577,
-0.08984101563692093,
-0.6807968020439148,
0.32066577672958374,
0.36088287830352783,
0.11375732719898224,
-0.7627288103103638,
0.33638134598731995,
-0.5839084982872009,
-0.21638859808444977,
-0.4373006522655487,
-0.006441280245780945,
0.12552714347839355,
0.19947101175785065,
-0.1362171173095703,
0.6977178454399109,
0.5836647152900696,
-0.6905444264411926,
0.40054503083229065,
-0.08308646827936172,
-0.6599135398864746,
0.3512036204338074,
-0.8168199062347412,
0.31248408555984497,
0.19819362461566925,
0.09767894446849823,
-0.804978609085083,
-0.5325591564178467,
0.500660240650177,
0.07609092444181442,
0.5292397737503052,
-0.3172930181026459,
-0.518336832523346,
0.1475098431110382,
-0.21206682920455933,
0.3060055673122406,
0.6874865293502808,
-0.5941714644432068,
0.1590380221605301,
0.4208168387413025,
-0.28256726264953613,
-0.5232648253440857,
-0.6592154502868652,
-0.05863446369767189,
-0.3850870728492737,
-0.5704286694526672,
0.034888118505477905,
-0.14250020682811737,
-0.5509868860244751,
0.03739504516124725,
-0.1878318339586258,
-0.5332275629043579,
0.32203158736228943,
0.3420269191265106,
0.4446738660335541,
-0.21845844388008118,
0.1300538331270218,
0.38873526453971863,
-0.00949566438794136,
0.38295432925224304,
0.19045695662498474,
0.27013421058654785,
0.12918181717395782,
-0.8554172515869141,
-0.5986417531967163,
0.336143434047699,
0.4769032299518585,
-0.05820820480585098,
0.8750496506690979,
0.1436932533979416,
-0.4479823410511017,
-0.2702793776988983,
-0.33248281478881836,
-0.29651105403900146,
-0.49368107318878174,
0.17572125792503357,
-0.11538402736186981,
-0.6013064384460449,
0.45011723041534424,
-0.1754743456840515,
0.3584865629673004,
-0.0533144548535347,
0.21592062711715698,
-0.2741135358810425,
1.1566276550292969,
0.2867802381515503,
-0.014813131652772427,
0.48729634284973145,
0.12575183808803558,
0.3712954819202423,
-0.58745938539505,
-0.0579935722053051,
-0.6382758617401123,
-0.4418657720088959,
-0.32584014534950256,
-0.20488204061985016,
0.21550457179546356,
0.4279171824455261,
-0.13678862154483795,
0.005576963536441326,
-0.3341914713382721,
0.8497374057769775,
0.425622820854187,
0.16638708114624023,
0.21634243428707123,
0.027107808738946915,
0.13838645815849304,
-0.0368114598095417,
-0.32845503091812134,
-0.7401078939437866,
0.9530580639839172,
0.26812589168548584,
1.071480393409729,
-0.23391272127628326,
0.7258122563362122,
0.3015437722206116,
0.21142765879631042,
-0.5585586428642273,
0.8862611651420593,
-0.2955649495124817,
-0.40441715717315674,
-0.13112229108810425,
-0.9080245494842529,
-0.914301872253418,
0.07230678200721741,
0.08834660053253174,
-0.7167128324508667,
-0.09196510910987854,
0.026729725301265717,
-0.28970736265182495,
0.34691375494003296,
-0.9937031865119934,
0.656323254108429,
-0.45253095030784607,
-0.4773600995540619,
-0.14678066968917847,
-0.551283597946167,
0.6927005648612976,
-0.11082246899604797,
0.2777615487575531,
-0.46532225608825684,
0.05894042178988457,
0.6797609329223633,
-0.5909032821655273,
0.9470301866531372,
-0.03843068331480026,
-0.2989969253540039,
0.3259887993335724,
0.2900134325027466,
0.5244681239128113,
-0.30448243021965027,
0.1044568195939064,
0.15762068331241608,
0.1646466851234436,
-0.33184316754341125,
-0.5953234434127808,
0.772304892539978,
-0.5268199443817139,
-0.6123945713043213,
-0.000498768815305084,
-0.7497299909591675,
-0.03670226410031319,
0.0946093499660492,
0.18758836388587952,
0.6909642219543457,
-0.04997348040342331,
0.23450639843940735,
0.6959735751152039,
-0.3535136580467224,
0.37211525440216064,
0.7923120260238647,
-0.05053722485899925,
-0.13174791634082794,
1.0624256134033203,
0.2636093199253082,
0.46643632650375366,
0.321586012840271,
0.2516799569129944,
-0.27470606565475464,
-0.4508778154850006,
-0.4122312068939209,
0.1748238056898117,
-0.8826856017112732,
0.038602862507104874,
-0.21512776613235474,
-0.37324392795562744,
-0.01783130317926407,
0.041151728481054306,
-0.3708384335041046,
-0.5075684785842896,
-0.6044538617134094,
-0.1879545897245407,
0.2099345326423645,
0.9000267386436462,
0.029772475361824036,
0.18517006933689117,
-1.1656380891799927,
0.02918229252099991,
0.10103669762611389,
0.2294427454471588,
-0.2585040032863617,
-0.48331326246261597,
-0.33300647139549255,
0.17592397332191467,
-0.03590700402855873,
-0.8091851472854614,
0.3861943781375885,
-0.021601825952529907,
0.4069144129753113,
0.527153491973877,
0.13234491646289825,
0.49343955516815186,
-0.581322431564331,
0.6144040822982788,
0.036668770015239716,
-0.7725251317024231,
0.3658667802810669,
-0.058232832700014114,
0.13158051669597626,
0.27147176861763,
0.16757947206497192,
-0.1427711397409439,
-0.5125184655189514,
-0.2664322853088379,
-0.8663163185119629,
0.6875231862068176,
-0.18797613680362701,
-0.03235485404729843,
-0.09292885661125183,
0.31467655301094055,
0.16292092204093933,
0.08542080968618393,
-0.20143046975135803,
-0.16491496562957764,
0.7671996355056763,
-0.3990233540534973,
0.35543301701545715,
-0.304811030626297,
-0.2835187017917633,
0.027091648429632187,
0.3576122522354126,
0.4156343638896942,
0.09859678894281387,
-0.5050572156906128,
-0.23600059747695923,
-0.11147839576005936,
0.3159923255443573,
0.5569248795509338,
0.6539220809936523,
-0.03870794549584389,
0.366032212972641,
-0.16020750999450684,
-0.5095160007476807,
0.24297553300857544,
0.099603071808815,
-0.2178904414176941,
-0.39306962490081787,
0.48143288493156433,
0.4286685287952423,
0.36831316351890564,
-0.7860528230667114,
0.3064464330673218,
-0.13517750799655914,
-0.03038889169692993,
0.03159556910395622,
0.5538092851638794,
0.02337314933538437,
0.23799829185009003,
-0.03547360375523567,
-0.02184104174375534,
0.05614734813570976,
-0.18043608963489532,
0.33077144622802734,
0.2470349371433258,
-0.33813950419425964,
-0.5172202587127686,
0.5615172982215881,
0.3286263346672058,
-0.2823275029659271,
0.5984593629837036,
-0.09093496948480606,
-0.10582401603460312,
0.9371572136878967,
0.35594406723976135,
0.9549693465232849,
-0.19027262926101685,
-0.09167279303073883,
-0.045351654291152954,
0.5011962056159973,
-0.21078915894031525,
0.19392900168895721,
0.18433557450771332,
-0.4715479612350464,
-0.44412437081336975,
-0.41609615087509155,
-0.5554028749465942,
0.19352419674396515,
-0.6870438456535339,
0.21212893724441528,
-0.683754563331604,
0.15494965016841888,
-0.11405730992555618,
-0.26334017515182495,
-0.528374433517456,
0.010869377292692661,
0.19975699484348297,
0.7692946195602417,
-0.9198929667472839,
0.6830763816833496,
0.2851830720901489,
-0.11267492175102234,
-0.7395228147506714,
-0.08896306902170181,
0.053937122225761414,
-0.5647949576377869,
0.4540252983570099,
0.25781676173210144,
-0.15514297783374786,
-0.5094360709190369,
-0.8127520680427551,
-0.6867882013320923,
0.6596595048904419,
0.8669834136962891,
-0.8007479310035706,
0.04425882548093796,
0.35515066981315613,
0.28022679686546326,
-0.19790004193782806,
0.25106948614120483,
0.9159092307090759,
0.3315255641937256,
-0.2025943100452423,
-0.4324786961078644,
-0.037070777267217636,
-0.07475733757019043,
-0.4146268963813782,
0.39868542551994324,
-0.3933286964893341,
0.9465973973274231,
-0.026798950508236885,
-0.4010525643825531,
0.00546515267342329,
0.5442874431610107,
0.29248616099357605,
0.372768372297287,
0.3474954664707184,
0.5113930106163025,
0.9007490873336792,
-0.14580276608467102,
1.0044969320297241,
-0.49742391705513,
-0.017600294202566147,
1.2122502326965332,
-0.5432330965995789,
0.7907571792602539,
0.26022428274154663,
-0.2783440947532654,
0.18756017088890076,
0.623429536819458,
0.3971972167491913,
0.49629777669906616,
0.17788107693195343,
-0.4877086579799652,
-0.27771008014678955,
0.09577268362045288,
-0.19947205483913422,
0.26332777738571167,
0.5161531567573547,
-0.5936053395271301,
-0.08089619129896164,
-0.3220990002155304,
0.09715136140584946,
-0.19445015490055084,
-0.06132323294878006,
0.5819656252861023,
0.3052924871444702,
-0.6112768054008484,
0.6422633528709412,
-0.10262814909219742,
0.009313272312283516,
-0.40116581320762634,
-0.2761496305465698,
-0.30974748730659485,
0.19088155031204224,
-0.15089058876037598,
-0.8862940073013306,
0.2799534797668457,
0.4304907023906708,
-0.1607036590576172,
-0.11438021808862686,
0.7396397590637207,
-0.5335255265235901,
-0.488643616437912,
0.08758580684661865,
0.584449052810669,
0.4802868366241455,
0.17078275978565216,
-0.4185502231121063,
0.3929123878479004,
-0.1210353821516037,
-0.391623318195343,
0.6136012673377991,
0.4933483898639679,
0.08345004916191101,
0.7289474010467529,
0.5133805871009827,
0.20863904058933258,
0.38005414605140686,
0.08115185797214508,
0.7182409763336182,
-0.5058701038360596,
-0.26305192708969116,
-1.1608518362045288,
0.24782676994800568,
0.026556208729743958,
-0.07863709330558777,
0.598720371723175,
0.49958986043930054,
0.4798569083213806,
0.21661627292633057,
0.7911668419837952,
0.19924522936344147,
0.41905707120895386,
-0.6783537864685059,
0.4800957143306732,
-0.33082661032676697,
0.8211917877197266,
0.10531482100486755,
-0.7429298162460327,
-0.09106304496526718,
0.12327588349580765,
-0.47894352674484253,
-0.15456807613372803,
0.5526588559150696,
0.9309144020080566,
-0.14410218596458435,
0.2014075666666031,
0.4277104139328003,
0.09982775896787643,
0.36254358291625977,
0.4598768651485443,
1.2060291767120361,
0.0016098404303193092,
0.4598148465156555,
-0.3039224147796631,
-0.3291381299495697,
-0.1359284371137619,
-0.807429850101471,
-0.7632325887680054,
-0.1911381483078003,
-0.2747989296913147,
-0.010266789235174656,
0.1561131328344345,
0.7460323572158813,
0.6016450524330139,
-0.5714913606643677,
-0.25407469272613525,
-0.2646069824695587,
0.42789334058761597,
-0.31642237305641174,
-0.141896590590477,
0.2363671064376831,
-0.39033079147338867,
-0.6758626699447632,
0.8229623436927795,
0.3543745279312134,
-0.15864108502864838,
-0.33429351449012756,
0.16230660676956177,
0.40476274490356445,
0.3421022891998291,
0.35267773270606995,
0.3081629276275635,
-0.5183009505271912,
-0.2071549892425537,
-0.018476152792572975,
-0.536751389503479,
0.01760837249457836,
0.6776305437088013,
-0.21041151881217957,
0.4350791871547699,
0.7154460549354553,
0.7486537098884583,
0.015917649492621422,
-0.0409243144094944,
0.5709226727485657,
-0.8436141014099121,
-0.10474889725446701,
-0.05589806288480759,
0.4322887361049652,
0.1443891078233719,
-0.40576252341270447,
0.36957183480262756,
0.10924951732158661,
-0.6969038248062134,
-1.0082581043243408,
0.3792223334312439,
-0.6530682444572449,
-0.23160608112812042,
1.2626677751541138,
-0.4145675599575043,
-0.590259313583374,
0.15983206033706665,
0.12429067492485046,
0.22519144415855408,
-0.33544379472732544,
0.853641152381897,
0.7472564578056335,
-0.09518209844827652,
-0.17686015367507935,
-0.7855813503265381,
0.10141362994909286,
0.12445048242807388,
-1.1930052042007446,
0.4626710116863251,
0.7779185771942139,
0.3472181260585785,
-0.3128432333469391,
0.1367088258266449,
-0.28392520546913147,
0.2638963460922241,
0.017518848180770874,
0.057221416383981705,
-0.032878052443265915,
-0.6823456883430481,
-0.4506310522556305,
0.12734109163284302,
-0.006873801350593567,
-0.38982483744621277
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06832v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06832v2
|
The Power of Noise: Toward a Unified Multi-modal Knowledge Graph Representation Framework
| 2024-03-11T15:48:43 | 2024-03-20T10:02:54 |
Zhuo Chen, Yin Fang, Yichi Zhang, Lingbing Guo, Jiaoyan Chen, Huajun Chen, Wen Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The advancement of Multi-modal Pre-training highlights the necessity for a
robust Multi-Modal Knowledge Graph (MMKG) representation learning framework.
This framework is crucial for integrating structured knowledge into multi-modal
Large Language Models (LLMs) at scale, aiming to alleviate issues like
knowledge misconceptions and multi-modal hallucinations. In this work, to
evaluate models' ability to accurately embed entities within MMKGs, we focus on
two widely researched tasks: Multi-modal Knowledge Graph Completion (MKGC) and
Multi-modal Entity Alignment (MMEA). Building on this foundation, we propose a
novel SNAG method that utilizes a Transformer-based architecture equipped with
modality-level noise masking for the robust integration of multi-modal entity
features in KGs. By incorporating specific training objectives for both MKGC
and MMEA, our approach achieves SOTA performance across a total of ten datasets
(three for MKGC and seven for MEMA), demonstrating its robustness and
versatility. Besides, SNAG can not only function as a standalone model but also
enhance other existing methods, providing stable performance improvements. Our
code and data are available at: https://github.com/zjukg/SNAG.
|
[
-0.4051617980003357,
-0.5738928318023682,
0.43934765458106995,
0.10668442398309708,
-0.5261576771736145,
0.15758639574050903,
-0.3882811665534973,
-0.25489112734794617,
0.3957977890968323,
0.22799204289913177,
-0.6736979484558105,
-0.5798468589782715,
-0.6916649341583252,
0.06439158320426941,
0.007989861071109772,
0.6375100612640381,
0.2646562457084656,
0.35960888862609863,
-0.26959505677223206,
-0.04102865234017372,
-0.4904308319091797,
-0.26817044615745544,
-0.1552736461162567,
-0.24138502776622772,
0.5116445422172546,
0.08810502290725708,
0.7115506529808044,
0.6281803846359253,
0.1804298311471939,
0.22740806639194489,
0.09284215420484543,
0.47496092319488525,
-0.20025579631328583,
0.21214371919631958,
0.12251648306846619,
-0.28871485590934753,
-0.4663875997066498,
-0.12172728031873703,
0.738789975643158,
0.7045339941978455,
-0.2185833752155304,
0.1556481271982193,
0.20301413536071777,
0.2505398392677307,
-0.43357348442077637,
0.7172468304634094,
-0.6246311068534851,
-0.06541427224874496,
-0.20894134044647217,
0.04325239732861519,
-0.5543738007545471,
-0.03474443033337593,
-0.02611132711172104,
-0.6634835004806519,
-0.3868858218193054,
0.08310116082429886,
0.9266536831855774,
0.7672542333602905,
-0.8183568716049194,
-0.2014630138874054,
-0.39395231008529663,
0.5692535042762756,
-0.7349127531051636,
1.2376419305801392,
0.2380610853433609,
0.16259586811065674,
-0.1838693618774414,
-0.6619585752487183,
-0.4896980822086334,
-0.2747385799884796,
-0.18123161792755127,
0.13424628973007202,
-0.16031119227409363,
0.141118586063385,
0.29903367161750793,
0.09370260685682297,
-0.233110249042511,
0.04643390327692032,
-0.18087951838970184,
-0.3777415454387665,
0.2810831665992737,
-0.18401463329792023,
-0.060419712215662,
-0.5785398483276367,
-0.6163827776908875,
0.1384018212556839,
-0.598012387752533,
0.006163825746625662,
0.5643395781517029,
0.4414527714252472,
0.17402589321136475,
0.3080780804157257,
-0.05965399742126465,
0.740351140499115,
0.2158452868461609,
-0.5991312265396118,
0.44499748945236206,
-0.42873626947402954,
-0.21900469064712524,
-0.05849244073033333,
0.9433457851409912,
0.22226333618164062,
-0.27607908844947815,
-0.6268877387046814,
0.016467565670609474,
-0.21796023845672607,
0.5284477472305298,
-0.7769035696983337,
0.013331905007362366,
-0.1996060013771057,
-0.45732101798057556,
-0.3658771812915802,
-0.13624949753284454,
-0.7243002653121948,
-0.3551473319530487,
-0.5499582290649414,
0.647466242313385,
-0.44524869322776794,
-0.4978109896183014,
0.08990587294101715,
0.2701738774776459,
-0.1755351722240448,
0.08815094828605652,
-0.6439119577407837,
-0.22878581285476685,
0.2588851749897003,
0.47928330302238464,
0.04547368362545967,
-0.18978996574878693,
-0.08219703286886215,
0.32500290870666504,
-0.23743218183517456,
0.6591507196426392,
-0.49787843227386475,
-0.0808335393667221,
-0.2553510069847107,
0.03095361590385437,
-0.4703116714954376,
-0.30148181319236755,
0.4440321624279022,
-0.792650580406189,
-0.1316428929567337,
-0.4784116744995117,
-0.4242324233055115,
-0.5393033027648926,
0.25098931789398193,
-0.7302780151367188,
1.2351511716842651,
0.2829693853855133,
-0.6324337124824524,
0.671745777130127,
-0.5868855118751526,
-0.3597906529903412,
-0.23535855114459991,
-0.5310550332069397,
-0.6211951971054077,
-0.13682128489017487,
0.17062364518642426,
0.6930574178695679,
-0.2475576400756836,
0.41965019702911377,
-0.30569490790367126,
-0.04521442577242851,
0.11960753053426743,
-0.36389848589897156,
0.6459501385688782,
0.2392936795949936,
-0.3503374755382538,
0.0028511472046375275,
-1.0331366062164307,
-0.08122603595256805,
-0.1931251585483551,
-0.6027860641479492,
-0.07602441310882568,
-0.10891615599393845,
-0.24037064611911774,
0.41223230957984924,
0.2579713761806488,
-0.2079257220029831,
0.37712112069129944,
-0.013579156249761581,
0.4123143255710602,
0.690166711807251,
-0.20785345137119293,
0.5495791435241699,
-0.048929307609796524,
0.5536832809448242,
0.304086297750473,
0.054426442831754684,
-0.2962152361869812,
-0.3938918709754944,
-0.38273724913597107,
-0.6805300712585449,
0.858137845993042,
0.04678206890821457,
-0.8810762166976929,
0.6622987389564514,
-0.5848673582077026,
-0.4453612267971039,
-0.28074759244918823,
0.1997033953666687,
0.043395910412073135,
0.5667893290519714,
0.33153489232063293,
-0.2830505073070526,
-0.6291072964668274,
-0.6786395907402039,
-0.068670354783535,
0.07605543732643127,
-0.13252024352550507,
0.41118887066841125,
0.17699885368347168,
-0.4936032295227051,
0.8024217486381531,
-0.05918675661087036,
-0.2239816039800644,
0.014742094092071056,
0.02067951299250126,
-0.07549246400594711,
0.2636122703552246,
0.6320340633392334,
-0.5497792363166809,
-0.18280649185180664,
-0.13893485069274902,
-0.7584340572357178,
-0.19393233954906464,
-0.05126618221402168,
-0.042663998901844025,
-0.09925851970911026,
0.7840080261230469,
-0.6685393452644348,
0.3090164363384247,
0.6668999195098877,
-0.263779878616333,
0.6331303715705872,
0.3298680782318115,
0.36331239342689514,
-1.2999281883239746,
-0.046968553215265274,
-0.3598540425300598,
-0.3487030267715454,
-0.5110544562339783,
0.031447578221559525,
0.2874792516231537,
-0.06853315979242325,
-0.1580491065979004,
-0.1545981466770172,
-0.5288226008415222,
0.06891082227230072,
0.023243717849254608,
0.0522598959505558,
0.07705235481262207,
0.7816392183303833,
-0.4875650405883789,
0.5422877669334412,
0.8071906566619873,
-0.6478692293167114,
0.11472093313932419,
-0.0574183315038681,
-0.2540184259414673,
0.5629841089248657,
-0.030238626524806023,
0.1358339935541153,
-0.16156096756458282,
0.25018197298049927,
-0.8945980072021484,
-0.31691524386405945,
0.4446648061275482,
-0.17904016375541687,
0.5708475708961487,
-0.45566704869270325,
-0.6485653519630432,
-0.036025192588567734,
-0.03956233337521553,
0.5509781837463379,
0.07428999245166779,
-0.47879359126091003,
1.414137840270996,
0.470083624124527,
0.2681295871734619,
-0.5896974802017212,
-0.577934741973877,
-0.02622022107243538,
-0.178681880235672,
-0.7277905941009521,
0.2612251043319702,
0.11311514675617218,
0.386849045753479,
-0.00486789783462882,
-0.6203625798225403,
0.0003368206671439111,
-0.013320346362888813,
0.4705529808998108,
-0.0000524155366292689,
-0.3015398681163788,
0.5100675821304321,
0.039899975061416626,
-0.21238437294960022,
-0.042702242732048035,
-0.3471784293651581,
0.7417387962341309,
-0.02472810633480549,
-0.696993887424469,
-0.08947274088859558,
0.0048500532284379005,
0.7588717937469482,
-0.21103926002979279,
0.5653253793716431,
0.829832911491394,
-0.3968926668167114,
-0.11356494575738907,
-0.6685855984687805,
-0.18121598660945892,
-0.4999326467514038,
0.5044375061988831,
-0.39300936460494995,
-0.8516994118690491,
0.5437314510345459,
-0.5299217700958252,
-0.10149140655994415,
0.2597063183784485,
0.33901724219322205,
-0.024532092735171318,
0.9790236949920654,
0.5219361782073975,
0.013369939289987087,
0.5268511772155762,
-0.25704723596572876,
0.6222108006477356,
-0.7278565168380737,
-0.5950491428375244,
-0.28433388471603394,
-0.39987078309059143,
-0.27626681327819824,
-0.748597264289856,
0.5333775281906128,
0.706676185131073,
0.0012991486582905054,
0.3985247015953064,
-0.4519427418708801,
0.3514801859855652,
0.3997507393360138,
0.2781662046909332,
0.44338691234588623,
0.13484247028827667,
-0.2696223556995392,
-0.18318241834640503,
-1.054050087928772,
-0.328561395406723,
1.2592664957046509,
0.3054598569869995,
0.729627788066864,
0.055773306638002396,
0.501630961894989,
-0.023925447836518288,
0.16094328463077545,
-0.9287840723991394,
0.4093627333641052,
0.045113611966371536,
-0.3334484100341797,
-0.32922443747520447,
-0.4393936097621918,
-0.8736191391944885,
0.3707495629787445,
-0.336270272731781,
-0.7489045858383179,
0.18247351050376892,
-0.0018040344584733248,
-0.4830213189125061,
0.4961576461791992,
-0.5194537043571472,
0.7937206625938416,
0.02256069891154766,
0.15789522230625153,
-0.16432420909404755,
-0.49020203948020935,
0.42299684882164,
-0.08457553386688232,
0.526286780834198,
-0.12562717497348785,
0.12688082456588745,
0.828387439250946,
-0.21032904088497162,
0.8398987650871277,
-0.003394866595044732,
-0.10450362414121628,
0.39448457956314087,
0.14100348949432373,
0.4180251955986023,
-0.00866603571921587,
0.0686890035867691,
0.5457239151000977,
-0.02638346329331398,
-0.16896697878837585,
-0.7030516266822815,
0.40997257828712463,
-0.6327318549156189,
-0.2824949622154236,
-0.04911210760474205,
-0.7674413919448853,
-0.3194162845611572,
0.38490697741508484,
0.07754874229431152,
0.5210357904434204,
0.29600176215171814,
0.4533608555793762,
0.6384687423706055,
0.27336132526397705,
0.4760664105415344,
0.3650319278240204,
-0.29564064741134644,
-0.515148401260376,
0.9070844054222107,
0.647467315196991,
0.061210524290800095,
-0.1167667806148529,
0.14822393655776978,
-0.46210116147994995,
-0.2679893374443054,
-0.7585768103599548,
0.003659921232610941,
-0.8213360905647278,
-0.673886239528656,
-0.8849568963050842,
-0.19957038760185242,
-0.40894895792007446,
0.06378933787345886,
-0.5318872332572937,
-0.2207840234041214,
-0.16575776040554047,
-0.16412092745304108,
0.16887713968753815,
0.7056635022163391,
-0.1929776817560196,
0.4775775671005249,
-0.6213740706443787,
0.25818079710006714,
0.467478483915329,
0.5315995812416077,
0.02840190939605236,
-0.25378480553627014,
-0.47139599919319153,
0.018684836104512215,
-0.4259001910686493,
-1.1623215675354004,
-0.217433899641037,
-0.01032344438135624,
0.6694483160972595,
0.7428364753723145,
-0.0657443106174469,
0.8485240340232849,
-0.326480507850647,
0.7655717134475708,
0.49092090129852295,
-1.0179736614227295,
0.11669696122407913,
-0.37474000453948975,
0.10318838804960251,
0.4320787489414215,
0.3218109905719757,
-0.24812157452106476,
-0.287987619638443,
-0.7659207582473755,
-0.800285279750824,
0.5725934505462646,
-0.09920437633991241,
-0.16508285701274872,
0.13448508083820343,
0.2699785530567169,
-0.0541420541703701,
0.5751904249191284,
-1.0292043685913086,
-0.3963429033756256,
-0.32394328713417053,
-0.18203817307949066,
0.3591708540916443,
-0.16887326538562775,
-0.2901090681552887,
-0.19610638916492462,
0.5041422843933105,
-0.4914212226867676,
0.16067075729370117,
-0.0857195034623146,
-0.3626568019390106,
-0.13520482182502747,
0.14406192302703857,
0.4239778518676758,
0.630176842212677,
0.12361626327037811,
0.4991021752357483,
0.348393976688385,
-0.387763112783432,
0.18987663090229034,
0.08395164459943771,
-0.20411163568496704,
0.17679299414157867,
0.22219380736351013,
0.5280369520187378,
0.810201108455658,
-0.3942004144191742,
0.7005898356437683,
0.19160975515842438,
-0.19811031222343445,
0.2559857964515686,
-0.16014143824577332,
0.2812480330467224,
0.4973607063293457,
0.23587270081043243,
0.5940590500831604,
-0.01824355125427246,
-0.3043977618217468,
0.2682846486568451,
0.3854398727416992,
-0.4498326778411865,
-0.37788125872612,
0.7037524580955505,
-0.20919787883758545,
-0.06193094700574875,
0.046541664749383926,
-0.41819578409194946,
-0.6660348773002625,
0.18719837069511414,
0.3085082173347473,
0.5125631093978882,
-0.2555650770664215,
0.033289771527051926,
0.26551634073257446,
0.4915659427642822,
-0.01717440038919449,
0.13622364401817322,
-0.21427203714847565,
-0.770639955997467,
-0.7163164615631104,
-0.7071762084960938,
0.1288786679506302,
0.041754480451345444,
-0.48538511991500854,
0.3174982964992523,
-0.3857303261756897,
-0.3690115511417389,
-0.1568983793258667,
-0.21598686277866364,
-0.8971045017242432,
-0.010999687947332859,
-0.014085879549384117,
0.552731454372406,
-0.8036380410194397,
0.6811678409576416,
0.48249533772468567,
-0.510694146156311,
-1.3762073516845703,
-0.0524585023522377,
-0.09845633804798126,
-0.7216541767120361,
0.44273605942726135,
0.10383938997983932,
-0.2870739996433258,
0.06371878832578659,
-0.3224075734615326,
-1.1758928298950195,
1.4338048696517944,
0.7927805781364441,
-0.47286492586135864,
0.06140126660466194,
0.28804218769073486,
0.04955461621284485,
-0.32319149374961853,
0.19335196912288666,
0.535290002822876,
0.6871318817138672,
0.0960528776049614,
-1.0188764333724976,
0.16313998401165009,
0.2418714314699173,
-0.18767830729484558,
0.04117443040013313,
-0.963810384273529,
0.5977448225021362,
0.15798138082027435,
-0.2879798412322998,
-0.6149922013282776,
0.6523457765579224,
0.11996885389089584,
0.11336631327867508,
0.8769735097885132,
0.8548974394798279,
1.0212222337722778,
-0.2842199206352234,
0.4478312134742737,
-0.6699737906455994,
0.32968127727508545,
0.7963224649429321,
0.22120234370231628,
0.3119449317455292,
0.5585080981254578,
-0.17765416204929352,
0.5069867968559265,
0.4706668555736542,
0.12248709797859192,
0.6086376905441284,
0.12416639178991318,
-0.11822504550218582,
-0.5529851317405701,
-0.04476235434412956,
-0.5653875470161438,
0.5844486951828003,
0.15194523334503174,
-0.30109068751335144,
-0.49663057923316956,
0.09247048944234848,
0.2335398644208908,
-0.40607792139053345,
-0.19556128978729248,
0.714410126209259,
-0.06521182507276535,
-0.2233649641275406,
0.34551292657852173,
-0.1293269246816635,
0.6546185612678528,
-0.7487449049949646,
0.10882401466369629,
0.22960107028484344,
-0.3420122265815735,
-0.3279697000980377,
-0.09253176301717758,
0.2397937774658203,
-0.5201648473739624,
-0.2956241965293884,
-0.25287359952926636,
0.7339233756065369,
-0.5967616438865662,
-0.4436339735984802,
0.30336225032806396,
0.6139689087867737,
-0.00080292479833588,
-0.0753498375415802,
-0.4307193458080292,
0.2764083445072174,
0.012471518479287624,
-0.34455424547195435,
0.3014978766441345,
0.6750718951225281,
0.16885346174240112,
0.5304715633392334,
0.7173692584037781,
-0.13495339453220367,
0.5562514662742615,
0.32330211997032166,
1.1867218017578125,
-0.28972697257995605,
-0.6060856580734253,
-0.8022885918617249,
0.7383189797401428,
0.09443610161542892,
-0.05084361508488655,
0.8746247887611389,
0.5969427227973938,
0.7694656848907471,
0.0631885826587677,
0.5903881788253784,
-0.1713028848171234,
0.026087947189807892,
-0.5451396703720093,
0.80064857006073,
-0.4106115698814392,
0.3952406346797943,
-0.25769639015197754,
-0.9106273055076599,
-0.34019434452056885,
0.715160071849823,
-0.0125151127576828,
0.0050386288203299046,
0.6390593647956848,
1.0984883308410645,
-0.3165523111820221,
0.03368755057454109,
0.6189095377922058,
0.28056448698043823,
0.2508109509944916,
-0.014388860203325748,
0.8843923807144165,
-0.698329746723175,
0.7904253602027893,
-0.1474909633398056,
-0.09070368856191635,
-0.1743975281715393,
-1.01064932346344,
-0.7757918238639832,
-0.6499326229095459,
-0.4222390353679657,
-0.5390158891677856,
-0.4281266927719116,
1.0516971349716187,
1.1133711338043213,
-0.5334868431091309,
0.15236015617847443,
0.3169865310192108,
0.22276929020881653,
-0.3173360228538513,
-0.20102231204509735,
0.4522440433502197,
-0.5555678606033325,
-0.43450722098350525,
0.8055254220962524,
0.3544662296772003,
-0.1747465431690216,
-0.38261497020721436,
-0.0570954792201519,
0.009395546279847622,
-0.04201427847146988,
0.5680081844329834,
-0.3188161551952362,
-0.8026353716850281,
-0.5511673092842102,
-0.012390184216201305,
-0.029617279767990112,
0.12784722447395325,
0.9825525879859924,
-0.6641587018966675,
0.5765392780303955,
0.09957365691661835,
0.7176191806793213,
0.46571770310401917,
-0.28621751070022583,
0.27625492215156555,
-1.0399020910263062,
0.07915032655000687,
0.04269970580935478,
0.5423955321311951,
-0.02469518966972828,
-0.30765172839164734,
0.3915608525276184,
0.36381790041923523,
-0.4697258770465851,
-0.9250437021255493,
0.31000277400016785,
-1.0630478858947754,
-0.22093990445137024,
1.0686532258987427,
-0.05890456214547157,
-0.12520748376846313,
-0.30828481912612915,
-0.1741616427898407,
0.5383254289627075,
-0.32077839970588684,
0.8604531288146973,
0.7688125967979431,
-0.05433191359043121,
-0.17937326431274414,
-0.4801880717277527,
0.5381783246994019,
0.1985970139503479,
-0.3912726938724518,
-0.10136985033750534,
0.4995982348918915,
0.3936097025871277,
0.5506406426429749,
0.4747839868068695,
-0.09949317574501038,
-0.017307303845882416,
0.24416755139827728,
0.18882201611995697,
-0.49667975306510925,
-0.45725688338279724,
-0.26034197211265564,
0.4660860300064087,
-0.22856421768665314,
-0.17635692656040192
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09713v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09713v1
|
A Hybrid Intelligence Method for Argument Mining
| 2024-03-11T15:15:27 | 2024-03-11T15:15:27 |
Michiel van der Meer, Enrico Liscio, Catholijn M. Jonker, Aske Plaat, Piek Vossen, Pradeep K. Murukannaiah
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Large-scale survey tools enable the collection of citizen feedback in opinion
corpora. Extracting the key arguments from a large and noisy set of opinions
helps in understanding the opinions quickly and accurately. Fully automated
methods can extract arguments but (1) require large labeled datasets that
induce large annotation costs and (2) work well for known viewpoints, but not
for novel points of view. We propose HyEnA, a hybrid (human + AI) method for
extracting arguments from opinionated texts, combining the speed of automated
processing with the understanding and reasoning capabilities of humans. We
evaluate HyEnA on three citizen feedback corpora. We find that, on the one
hand, HyEnA achieves higher coverage and precision than a state-of-the-art
automated method when compared to a common set of diverse opinions, justifying
the need for human insight. On the other hand, HyEnA requires less human effort
and does not compromise quality compared to (fully manual) expert analysis,
demonstrating the benefit of combining human and artificial intelligence.
|
[
-0.6428532004356384,
-0.5276358723640442,
0.45487359166145325,
0.03938022628426552,
-0.5549995303153992,
0.3610100746154785,
-0.19227948784828186,
-0.585953950881958,
0.4303569793701172,
0.2671252489089966,
-0.4381037950515747,
-0.3717873990535736,
-0.28144609928131104,
0.1626691073179245,
-0.13709166646003723,
0.8605734705924988,
0.23642659187316895,
0.11262265592813492,
-0.4268689453601837,
-0.35538142919540405,
-0.05767342448234558,
-0.8198395371437073,
-0.4436805248260498,
-0.3941291272640228,
0.7500224709510803,
0.60699462890625,
0.798459529876709,
0.5475785732269287,
0.08341051638126373,
0.3305932283401489,
0.1512131243944168,
0.5575428605079651,
0.010580668225884438,
-0.2675212025642395,
-0.41395825147628784,
-0.32283976674079895,
-0.2423906922340393,
0.35534459352493286,
0.22750239074230194,
0.3509940803050995,
-0.07501644641160965,
0.39169177412986755,
-0.2469005435705185,
0.5152938961982727,
-0.7806687355041504,
-0.02575785666704178,
-0.353903591632843,
-0.06429008394479752,
-0.2729112207889557,
-0.31839272379875183,
-0.012176613323390484,
-0.6811372637748718,
0.4276909828186035,
-0.6295263171195984,
0.013269576244056225,
0.12527455389499664,
0.9585915207862854,
0.3130842447280884,
-0.05787357687950134,
-0.33111414313316345,
-0.8212660551071167,
0.9354876279830933,
-0.8197727799415588,
-0.07236812263727188,
0.18093349039554596,
0.24880452454090118,
-0.06364774703979492,
-0.3122284412384033,
-0.9615508913993835,
-0.07548531144857407,
-0.1368522346019745,
0.3751380741596222,
-0.17781752347946167,
-0.18686212599277496,
0.11693649739027023,
0.4128497540950775,
-0.08098793774843216,
0.3386772871017456,
-0.643267810344696,
-0.3476545810699463,
0.9471806287765503,
-0.10881876945495605,
0.10549778491258621,
-0.8699072003364563,
-0.21498355269432068,
-0.4070650339126587,
-0.31910520792007446,
0.3834795653820038,
0.7420151233673096,
-0.12683254480361938,
0.08820362389087677,
0.5560411810874939,
-0.10138924419879913,
0.5459429025650024,
0.16141799092292786,
-0.07732618600130081,
0.22021842002868652,
-0.10353875160217285,
-0.21598859131336212,
0.08780598640441895,
1.1656690835952759,
0.1967618763446808,
0.09660230576992035,
-0.07306959480047226,
0.16100820899009705,
0.40721964836120605,
0.21431811153888702,
-0.7309573292732239,
-0.3213726580142975,
0.4663270115852356,
-0.8188514113426208,
-0.448600172996521,
0.327938973903656,
-1.5317835807800293,
-0.8535518646240234,
-0.5564447641372681,
-0.00921999104321003,
-0.15483002364635468,
-0.688404381275177,
0.09463200718164444,
-0.5421319007873535,
0.4710647463798523,
0.33328136801719666,
-0.6888100504875183,
0.2252558022737503,
0.8161945343017578,
0.48881858587265015,
-0.3305249512195587,
-0.09073136746883392,
-0.7100585103034973,
-0.41347119212150574,
-0.33373281359672546,
1.409759759902954,
-0.7589371800422668,
-0.22065667808055878,
-0.08995606005191803,
-0.23423540592193604,
-0.012598352506756783,
-0.9405809640884399,
0.8468714356422424,
-0.3534853160381317,
0.42563146352767944,
-0.3466179668903351,
-0.33269405364990234,
-0.5497508645057678,
0.2958764433860779,
-0.9058194756507874,
1.1366791725158691,
0.04964207112789154,
-0.7335875034332275,
0.6465749740600586,
-0.8187377452850342,
-0.5660738945007324,
0.21848516166210175,
-0.35244059562683105,
-0.3668232858181,
-0.20865921676158905,
0.5556492209434509,
0.40919435024261475,
-0.38691166043281555,
0.13921329379081726,
-0.4872230589389801,
0.07817603647708893,
0.04685073718428612,
0.07765644788742065,
0.9436857104301453,
0.2439355105161667,
-0.6524443626403809,
0.243870809674263,
-0.6653600931167603,
-0.13558726012706757,
-0.04195619747042656,
-0.6113162636756897,
-0.6751550436019897,
0.5087698698043823,
0.04049632325768471,
0.4378528296947479,
0.15268650650978088,
-0.7493113279342651,
-0.004096641670912504,
-0.3903919756412506,
0.5449244379997253,
0.7299748063087463,
0.21727602183818817,
0.2802605926990509,
-0.28400081396102905,
0.4562303125858307,
-0.07048676908016205,
-0.10139533877372742,
0.18112343549728394,
-0.6030351519584656,
-0.604901909828186,
-0.3990459144115448,
0.37924572825431824,
0.6690999269485474,
-0.467756986618042,
0.6833092570304871,
0.03405100852251053,
-0.5821592807769775,
-1.1017030477523804,
0.35925567150115967,
-0.0714089646935463,
0.2686600387096405,
0.17609557509422302,
-0.18816782534122467,
-0.874739944934845,
-1.0449602603912354,
-0.16927041113376617,
-0.5545928478240967,
0.06841802597045898,
0.24530406296253204,
0.47468143701553345,
-0.19908219575881958,
1.405758023262024,
-0.13969087600708008,
0.025801487267017365,
-0.34216755628585815,
0.6451210975646973,
-0.02428928017616272,
0.16921928524971008,
0.15328852832317352,
-0.6969924569129944,
0.0651157796382904,
0.16478529572486877,
-0.8738497495651245,
0.01130154449492693,
-0.33180859684944153,
-0.3285629451274872,
0.08137906342744827,
0.1279517412185669,
-0.5705325603485107,
0.3582460284233093,
0.2835530936717987,
0.0007498788181692362,
0.5886701345443726,
-0.12128137052059174,
0.1272871196269989,
-1.292834758758545,
0.0551266185939312,
0.6221809387207031,
-0.24266870319843292,
-0.18706420063972473,
-0.04035278409719467,
-0.31641706824302673,
0.06375519186258316,
-0.22094599902629852,
0.250341534614563,
-0.3199862241744995,
0.205826997756958,
-0.4597531855106354,
0.14128296077251434,
-0.13824141025543213,
0.48952022194862366,
0.49576035141944885,
0.3815588355064392,
-0.014771383255720139,
-0.4662841558456421,
0.8129225373268127,
0.07352620363235474,
-0.3066518008708954,
0.8228426575660706,
-0.632811427116394,
0.40798401832580566,
-0.026098152622580528,
0.4117480516433716,
-0.5956684350967407,
-0.2788471281528473,
0.20942071080207825,
-0.40584835410118103,
-0.4184218645095825,
0.07192548364400864,
-0.6055710911750793,
-0.5760829448699951,
-0.6324717402458191,
0.02149689383804798,
0.538253128528595,
-0.9257217049598694,
0.974854052066803,
0.9027966260910034,
-0.13951170444488525,
-0.30769839882850647,
0.05539851263165474,
0.3639465868473053,
-0.42172324657440186,
-0.6527672410011292,
0.03361017629504204,
0.10916286706924438,
-0.838709831237793,
0.032275959849357605,
0.3485410213470459,
0.1174568235874176,
-0.05852515995502472,
0.3211892247200012,
0.3432517349720001,
-0.2407992035150528,
-0.007206645328551531,
-0.20880818367004395,
-0.03423738107085228,
0.4240352511405945,
0.030939288437366486,
0.374929815530777,
-0.39841267466545105,
-0.045622024685144424,
-0.6389486789703369,
0.7142056226730347,
0.9667409062385559,
-0.46602723002433777,
0.30912691354751587,
0.5200497508049011,
-0.5038303136825562,
-0.19925422966480255,
-0.8185502886772156,
-0.10654769092798233,
-0.396965354681015,
0.05895279720425606,
0.03779814764857292,
-0.33123916387557983,
0.26503974199295044,
-0.4445723593235016,
0.5842575430870056,
0.7675161957740784,
0.9000077843666077,
-0.24970929324626923,
0.9302838444709778,
0.30683207511901855,
-0.7571004629135132,
0.184922456741333,
-0.20804421603679657,
0.3320445120334625,
-0.5241715908050537,
-0.3054397404193878,
-0.8088310360908508,
-0.29350534081459045,
-0.3675244152545929,
-0.20059816539287567,
0.1188676655292511,
-0.30516234040260315,
0.11579106748104095,
0.08074592798948288,
-0.7076736092567444,
0.09025833755731583,
0.9136030077934265,
0.012622864916920662,
0.33853432536125183,
0.031183142215013504,
0.2991589903831482,
0.009166674688458443,
-0.5635862946510315,
-0.7474744319915771,
0.650714099407196,
0.39297986030578613,
0.4307001531124115,
-0.11801116168498993,
0.6883441805839539,
0.6406638026237488,
0.4933539032936096,
-1.10692298412323,
0.5396677255630493,
0.08083584904670715,
-0.6373587846755981,
-0.200621098279953,
-0.26458680629730225,
-0.7201523780822754,
0.5420435667037964,
-0.7036766409873962,
-0.43737077713012695,
0.2722632586956024,
-0.03873061761260033,
-0.7377906441688538,
0.5531663298606873,
-0.8654807209968567,
0.6985137462615967,
-0.1585598886013031,
-0.2894562780857086,
-0.5731890797615051,
-0.38150858879089355,
0.3463626205921173,
0.20323804020881653,
0.30260324478149414,
0.1036238893866539,
0.38728955388069153,
1.34755539894104,
-0.6835224628448486,
0.8508638143539429,
-0.25000593066215515,
-0.09348031133413315,
0.5974884033203125,
-0.2694058418273926,
0.32617953419685364,
0.033372242003679276,
-0.18473556637763977,
-0.09787905961275101,
0.07989893853664398,
-0.3925414979457855,
-0.6414170265197754,
0.4470156729221344,
-1.032692313194275,
-0.6967652440071106,
-0.5564252138137817,
-0.24396389722824097,
-0.2015487402677536,
-0.1222827285528183,
0.11763567477464676,
0.2742004096508026,
-0.17857980728149414,
0.0835745632648468,
0.39206162095069885,
0.07161106169223785,
0.5406705737113953,
0.13848043978214264,
0.36380672454833984,
-0.5444161295890808,
1.072077989578247,
-0.07930619269609451,
-0.3791482746601105,
-0.009334121830761433,
0.765483021736145,
-0.4076852798461914,
-0.33059510588645935,
-1.0133566856384277,
0.29400479793548584,
-0.5000708699226379,
0.1326606124639511,
-0.7503411173820496,
0.15452413260936737,
-0.25346827507019043,
-0.055746547877788544,
-0.18293851613998413,
-0.32911327481269836,
-0.23829816281795502,
-0.23715150356292725,
0.3191092014312744,
0.7753381133079529,
-0.11966986954212189,
-0.17852617800235748,
-0.7997208833694458,
0.5219122767448425,
0.6585260033607483,
-0.12404194474220276,
0.165603905916214,
0.13982923328876495,
-0.03163841366767883,
-0.15773800015449524,
-0.1337258666753769,
-1.038644790649414,
0.2040816694498062,
-0.18896353244781494,
0.7080927491188049,
0.5707380175590515,
0.35202574729919434,
0.6625008583068848,
0.11014889925718307,
0.9407165050506592,
0.02105608582496643,
-0.7427826523780823,
0.4065930247306824,
-0.19003039598464966,
-0.0301755890250206,
0.7161975502967834,
0.15176215767860413,
-0.35129597783088684,
-0.14642333984375,
-0.5804663300514221,
-0.5565158724784851,
0.4362545907497406,
-0.16854329407215118,
-0.26992616057395935,
0.15031148493289948,
0.10816524177789688,
0.40828049182891846,
0.06684013456106186,
-0.4573236405849457,
0.30605414509773254,
-0.3909395933151245,
-0.09893377125263214,
0.25324180722236633,
0.05257563292980194,
-0.3549654483795166,
-0.6551174521446228,
0.7197548151016235,
-0.24785034358501434,
-0.2064932882785797,
0.2945888638496399,
-0.06849732995033264,
-0.24056664109230042,
0.5109604597091675,
0.3353310227394104,
0.6667040586471558,
-0.2110413908958435,
0.0940433219075203,
0.23140184581279755,
-0.3112812936306,
0.1361669898033142,
0.0695025622844696,
-0.1618858277797699,
0.023290647193789482,
0.42268121242523193,
0.3754348158836365,
-0.20691236853599548,
-0.7046985626220703,
0.4155867099761963,
-0.07602906972169876,
-0.44424885511398315,
-0.49589598178863525,
-0.22422659397125244,
0.21954497694969177,
0.011143567971885204,
0.41340377926826477,
0.39021697640419006,
0.03716196492314339,
-0.9177500605583191,
-0.07870014756917953,
0.4527120292186737,
-0.2684682607650757,
-0.3789738416671753,
0.23520231246948242,
0.6322482824325562,
-0.4147254228591919,
0.5460074543952942,
-0.17803190648555756,
-0.7213847041130066,
0.5996448397636414,
0.04538438469171524,
0.9014557003974915,
0.17881852388381958,
0.5548394322395325,
0.35811468958854675,
0.2717439532279968,
-0.008207045495510101,
0.09449636191129684,
-0.22653727233409882,
-0.4573877453804016,
-0.438037246465683,
-0.4213578402996063,
-0.7820375561714172,
0.1668243259191513,
-0.6027359962463379,
-0.00798642449080944,
-0.6672818064689636,
0.10020265728235245,
0.36088797450065613,
0.29357483983039856,
-0.3112487494945526,
0.1629268378019333,
0.37891900539398193,
0.7956228852272034,
-0.9207531213760376,
0.5332415699958801,
0.8864409923553467,
-0.3700055480003357,
-0.7747856378555298,
0.022573022171854973,
0.05639675259590149,
-0.2004476636648178,
0.18184374272823334,
0.10616303235292435,
-0.7267788052558899,
-0.6334158778190613,
-0.7739661931991577,
-0.13706181943416595,
0.6582059264183044,
0.11433461308479309,
-0.2898014187812805,
0.1867833137512207,
-0.1788707822561264,
0.699235737323761,
-0.33717337250709534,
0.1555948406457901,
0.950837254524231,
0.7901427149772644,
-0.053144969046115875,
-0.6281618475914001,
0.07368561625480652,
-0.5612392425537109,
-0.5346858501434326,
-0.11714359372854233,
-0.7152724266052246,
0.6155551671981812,
-0.19397158920764923,
-0.24541188776493073,
-0.07830771803855896,
1.0676050186157227,
0.21546800434589386,
0.4019966721534729,
1.0834685564041138,
0.5681772828102112,
1.171764612197876,
0.37079814076423645,
1.0801786184310913,
0.17049434781074524,
-0.16084566712379456,
0.6628653407096863,
-0.4893839657306671,
1.0038470029830933,
0.449739933013916,
0.08557593077421188,
0.989199161529541,
1.0143886804580688,
0.0867236852645874,
0.10226346552371979,
0.3024461269378662,
-0.2745360732078552,
-0.8027090430259705,
-0.0617288239300251,
-0.04609726369380951,
0.47876644134521484,
0.2036430388689041,
0.158955916762352,
-0.14763984084129333,
-0.2016342133283615,
0.28393325209617615,
0.4136430323123932,
-0.3260107636451721,
0.9313302636146545,
-0.02965351939201355,
-1.3162156343460083,
0.429512083530426,
0.07344094663858414,
0.9414324164390564,
-0.15566937625408173,
-0.2026517391204834,
0.13294066488742828,
0.1940375566482544,
-0.6505640745162964,
-0.5275669097900391,
0.08810321241617203,
0.3148868680000305,
-0.34695369005203247,
0.27348214387893677,
0.5498867034912109,
0.10394327342510223,
-0.6262701749801636,
0.26074692606925964,
0.5458047389984131,
-0.00436229445040226,
-0.17417535185813904,
-0.584678590297699,
-0.48476970195770264,
-0.17012426257133484,
-0.07625523954629898,
0.05110570415854454,
0.09076395630836487,
-0.5018348693847656,
0.248311847448349,
1.056329607963562,
0.21597008407115936,
-0.029440781101584435,
0.044264208525419235,
1.0053017139434814,
-0.6426007747650146,
-0.5654085278511047,
-0.9478898048400879,
0.11127689480781555,
-0.816870391368866,
-0.4341948628425598,
0.5175890326499939,
0.6015855073928833,
0.33132869005203247,
0.19676288962364197,
1.3150845766067505,
-0.02773090824484825,
0.8686439990997314,
-0.16703276336193085,
0.6046610474586487,
-0.27707746624946594,
-0.1054154559969902,
-0.1547207534313202,
-0.7998494505882263,
-0.06193060055375099,
0.6283131241798401,
-0.41277918219566345,
-0.41986283659935,
0.6428931355476379,
0.6747177839279175,
-0.06620002537965775,
0.5362260341644287,
-0.35391584038734436,
-0.1641940474510193,
0.6258278489112854,
0.43909981846809387,
1.1584981679916382,
0.07942112535238266,
0.553692638874054,
-0.11742424964904785,
-0.5914727449417114,
-0.21321623027324677,
-0.8062153458595276,
-1.190864086151123,
-0.4609861373901367,
-0.29535287618637085,
-0.5498783588409424,
-0.29040974378585815,
1.412398099899292,
1.11199152469635,
-0.8420703411102295,
-0.4170639216899872,
0.4944441318511963,
0.11663934588432312,
-0.49195414781570435,
-0.19948890805244446,
0.5702817440032959,
0.07264308631420135,
-0.6507395505905151,
0.5223826169967651,
0.19443129003047943,
-0.7121115922927856,
-0.8275525569915771,
-0.20756228268146515,
-0.37840980291366577,
0.5273699164390564,
0.4584459960460663,
0.8595651984214783,
-0.7108771204948425,
-0.3082328140735626,
-0.18872472643852234,
-0.0029639294371008873,
0.2850630581378937,
1.1565271615982056,
-1.0915884971618652,
0.5099025964736938,
0.6754704713821411,
0.7993519902229309,
0.5562940239906311,
0.48347094655036926,
0.6278334259986877,
-0.12551239132881165,
0.14301827549934387,
0.275852233171463,
0.40933316946029663,
0.5654676556587219,
-0.3741036653518677,
0.14616811275482178,
0.2497650682926178,
-0.34299102425575256,
-0.40138888359069824,
-0.06915126740932465,
-1.239309549331665,
-0.14887432754039764,
1.3105462789535522,
-0.006361173465847969,
-0.6889579892158508,
-0.5783612132072449,
-0.6704117059707642,
-0.1798991858959198,
-0.7385724782943726,
1.160412311553955,
0.7707511782646179,
-0.1021832674741745,
-0.13562113046646118,
-0.20769062638282776,
0.46862855553627014,
0.2566002905368805,
-1.279325246810913,
-0.11684872210025787,
0.4784706234931946,
0.07434509694576263,
0.5104770660400391,
0.6833454370498657,
-0.07401023805141449,
0.5310757160186768,
-0.24261100590229034,
-0.014018334448337555,
-0.013682445511221886,
-0.11755376309156418,
-0.10904452949762344,
0.7385955452919006,
-0.15596124529838562,
-0.3909352123737335
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07947v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07947v1
|
The evaluation of a code-switched Sepedi-English automatic speech recognition system
| 2024-03-11T15:11:28 | 2024-03-11T15:11:28 |
Amanda Phaladi, Thipe Modipa
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Speech technology is a field that encompasses various techniques and tools
used to enable machines to interact with speech, such as automatic speech
recognition (ASR), spoken dialog systems, and others, allowing a device to
capture spoken words through a microphone from a human speaker. End-to-end
approaches such as Connectionist Temporal Classification (CTC) and
attention-based methods are the most used for the development of ASR systems.
However, these techniques were commonly used for research and development for
many high-resourced languages with large amounts of speech data for training
and evaluation, leaving low-resource languages relatively underdeveloped. While
the CTC method has been successfully used for other languages, its
effectiveness for the Sepedi language remains uncertain. In this study, we
present the evaluation of the Sepedi-English code-switched automatic speech
recognition system. This end-to-end system was developed using the Sepedi
Prompted Code Switching corpus and the CTC approach. The performance of the
system was evaluated using both the NCHLT Sepedi test corpus and the Sepedi
Prompted Code Switching corpus. The model produced the lowest WER of 41.9%,
however, the model faced challenges in recognizing the Sepedi only text.
|
[
-0.41099557280540466,
-0.34095150232315063,
0.04189320281147957,
0.2889062166213989,
-0.6284772753715515,
0.41757893562316895,
-0.44336116313934326,
-0.5724647045135498,
-0.026118803769350052,
0.12296536564826965,
-0.16382113099098206,
-0.2890389561653137,
-0.6569783687591553,
0.6826087236404419,
-0.6874258518218994,
0.690460741519928,
-0.04489781707525253,
0.10512831062078476,
0.33512988686561584,
-0.20929498970508575,
-0.6401817798614502,
-0.6716362237930298,
-0.90242600440979,
-0.31668025255203247,
0.22131937742233276,
0.2959636151790619,
0.36928248405456543,
0.39260512590408325,
0.6333528757095337,
0.3097713589668274,
-0.35587432980537415,
-0.13705044984817505,
-0.06462356448173523,
-0.27149078249931335,
0.010190155357122421,
-0.5636048316955566,
0.04652651026844978,
-0.13689757883548737,
0.6695240139961243,
0.4719831943511963,
-0.03279861807823181,
0.03356073424220085,
-0.0026693870313465595,
0.5677030086517334,
-0.6817972660064697,
0.28470519185066223,
-0.6180590987205505,
0.20128397643566132,
-0.2879667282104492,
-0.2839501202106476,
-0.627316415309906,
-0.3855511546134949,
0.1770859807729721,
-0.09281322360038757,
-0.17411625385284424,
-0.33941102027893066,
0.5770936012268066,
0.4113208055496216,
-0.5151315927505493,
-0.5230873227119446,
-0.9094836115837097,
0.7880703210830688,
-0.7480515837669373,
0.9282577633857727,
0.2919290363788605,
0.46242502331733704,
0.4181702733039856,
-0.3834747076034546,
-0.4318794906139374,
-0.27161455154418945,
0.03747032210230827,
0.3428496718406677,
-0.16477517783641815,
-0.22630232572555542,
0.26038849353790283,
-0.026172515004873276,
-0.49526774883270264,
0.17205765843391418,
-0.67292720079422,
-0.30311232805252075,
0.6056928634643555,
-0.14411292970180511,
0.32284510135650635,
0.011455146595835686,
-0.3851143717765808,
0.04179651662707329,
-0.46386095881462097,
0.383851021528244,
0.27593564987182617,
0.5274069905281067,
-0.270402729511261,
0.3231116533279419,
0.004313262179493904,
0.8563534021377563,
0.1354311853647232,
-0.27892178297042847,
0.4535919725894928,
-0.18590295314788818,
-0.2740766406059265,
0.5432792901992798,
0.7165429592132568,
0.2582629323005676,
0.23471125960350037,
-0.18796946108341217,
-0.4670483469963074,
0.55948805809021,
0.09406796842813492,
-0.7530755400657654,
0.06559144705533981,
0.1261669397354126,
-0.4881742596626282,
-0.23897942900657654,
0.006111075170338154,
-0.4123387038707733,
0.13672995567321777,
-0.30886101722717285,
0.3244534134864807,
-0.6084436178207397,
-0.23457403481006622,
-0.0074498774483799934,
-0.05348527431488037,
0.33888673782348633,
0.16714446246623993,
-0.6051138043403625,
0.3955538272857666,
0.23890431225299835,
1.0098543167114258,
-0.6695323586463928,
-0.17207026481628418,
-0.3841477930545807,
-0.08574587106704712,
-0.304289311170578,
0.7246569395065308,
-0.6499555110931396,
-0.7317202091217041,
-0.007857270538806915,
0.0727735385298729,
-0.5860112905502319,
-0.5812347531318665,
0.6467928886413574,
-0.8326743841171265,
0.26536715030670166,
0.1090247854590416,
-0.5057618618011475,
-0.07339290529489517,
0.05867075175046921,
-0.6577625870704651,
0.6036059856414795,
-0.32338637113571167,
-0.9857401847839355,
0.27347350120544434,
-0.6476133465766907,
-0.5675519704818726,
0.16260172426700592,
-0.2719549238681793,
-0.3494783043861389,
-0.2637856900691986,
-0.004337030462920666,
0.09436687082052231,
-0.19826121628284454,
0.28182798624038696,
0.3044810891151428,
-0.7517174482345581,
0.5739238262176514,
-0.7279716730117798,
0.9549638032913208,
0.6484248042106628,
-0.3401777744293213,
-0.13997869193553925,
-0.9916374087333679,
0.15507520735263824,
-0.13600070774555206,
-0.8432624936103821,
-0.3026268482208252,
-0.032658275216817856,
0.36601588129997253,
0.22825172543525696,
0.30875566601753235,
-0.695909321308136,
-0.23399239778518677,
-0.3596273958683014,
0.5732318162918091,
0.20092976093292236,
-0.2346080094575882,
0.2688130736351013,
-0.15689298510551453,
0.6071133613586426,
0.18624255061149597,
0.004936248529702425,
0.08390853554010391,
-0.4561050832271576,
-0.6565350294113159,
-0.0709751695394516,
0.5444238781929016,
1.0178302526474,
-0.7958663702011108,
0.5500538945198059,
-0.002452892018482089,
-0.35643696784973145,
-0.3956725299358368,
-0.4367714822292328,
0.6459171175956726,
0.2150944322347641,
0.18063250184059143,
-0.4879441559314728,
-0.5421242713928223,
-0.8241598606109619,
-0.18261933326721191,
-0.29688459634780884,
-0.10972275584936142,
0.3297184407711029,
0.25582385063171387,
-0.2628132998943329,
0.8537574410438538,
-0.14086027443408966,
-0.051224932074546814,
-0.3626597821712494,
0.032828669995069504,
0.2675767242908478,
0.27508702874183655,
0.09551671892404556,
-0.7360851764678955,
-0.47310614585876465,
0.21272794902324677,
-0.3430027961730957,
-0.41255757212638855,
-0.27173590660095215,
0.3333156108856201,
0.4097399115562439,
0.5703206062316895,
-0.15244023501873016,
0.5750333070755005,
0.6310532689094543,
-0.14353984594345093,
0.4292357265949249,
-0.1740703284740448,
0.6873183250427246,
-0.9693974852561951,
0.37344130873680115,
-0.20113159716129303,
-0.11618457734584808,
-0.7788209915161133,
-0.23580966889858246,
0.3024037778377533,
-0.22397303581237793,
-0.7395934462547302,
0.17749306559562683,
-0.5173919200897217,
-0.389613538980484,
-0.35419362783432007,
0.013674722984433174,
-0.33356165885925293,
0.2863241732120514,
0.3427528738975525,
1.246583104133606,
0.35805416107177734,
-0.7311447262763977,
0.10066461563110352,
0.2716509699821472,
-0.19270294904708862,
0.30364254117012024,
-0.41746971011161804,
0.43469610810279846,
0.24018077552318573,
-0.08955157548189163,
-0.7523095607757568,
0.3261028528213501,
-0.06441468000411987,
-0.668438732624054,
0.30355873703956604,
-0.17662420868873596,
-0.14997370541095734,
-0.21420076489448547,
0.0535169281065464,
0.7930731773376465,
0.4524078369140625,
-0.5934543609619141,
0.2515689432621002,
0.4491245746612549,
-0.09648686647415161,
-0.22188732028007507,
-0.8242149949073792,
0.35109400749206543,
-0.3112172782421112,
-0.46400976181030273,
0.2555882930755615,
-0.05747891217470169,
-0.19016970694065094,
-0.4636783301830292,
-0.0029299964662641287,
-0.5854218006134033,
-0.19265595078468323,
0.05705852434039116,
0.22519318759441376,
-0.19119559228420258,
-0.18125231564044952,
0.08717956393957138,
-0.29283058643341064,
0.04193967580795288,
-0.1170431524515152,
0.6775595545768738,
-0.12912893295288086,
-0.4116430878639221,
-0.7104372978210449,
0.3414575755596161,
0.5830516815185547,
-0.5471597909927368,
0.18481461703777313,
0.23982763290405273,
-0.45826828479766846,
-0.027640655636787415,
-0.3604568839073181,
0.12544727325439453,
-0.38295742869377136,
0.21345335245132446,
-0.4406225085258484,
-0.884865939617157,
0.6579098701477051,
-0.07382086664438248,
-0.014152226969599724,
0.1943391114473343,
0.5512017607688904,
0.2502216696739197,
0.7142836451530457,
0.4572628140449524,
-0.21418984234333038,
0.6225820183753967,
-0.09932602196931839,
0.26866212487220764,
-0.6414222717285156,
-0.02728029154241085,
-0.9081286191940308,
-0.22382178902626038,
-0.549275815486908,
-0.3480064868927002,
0.36747631430625916,
-0.04295897111296654,
0.03752204775810242,
0.7973443865776062,
-0.688331663608551,
0.3712300658226013,
0.346032977104187,
0.13828520476818085,
0.6999098062515259,
-0.13118597865104675,
0.01079073827713728,
-0.033356357365846634,
-0.528282642364502,
-0.5165573954582214,
0.8706740736961365,
0.1926330327987671,
0.7156988978385925,
0.06793878972530365,
0.7752238512039185,
0.4432084560394287,
-0.23134258389472961,
-0.794417142868042,
0.6067298054695129,
-0.4387072026729584,
-0.3471422493457794,
-0.37274807691574097,
-0.3789846897125244,
-0.9479498863220215,
0.13441798090934753,
0.2614540457725525,
-0.5081400275230408,
0.4605063199996948,
-0.08380187302827835,
-0.5063010454177856,
0.27564334869384766,
-1.0562856197357178,
0.40375828742980957,
-0.17788241803646088,
0.18958985805511475,
-0.3711436688899994,
-0.9149729609489441,
0.05553443357348442,
-0.21445876359939575,
0.12344043701887131,
0.35756558179855347,
0.04086434468626976,
1.0281941890716553,
-0.1358334720134735,
0.7259755730628967,
0.0022323166485875845,
0.07408111542463303,
0.4498227834701538,
0.021547580137848854,
0.07506735622882843,
-0.17562182247638702,
-0.17968903481960297,
0.44490525126457214,
0.27509304881095886,
0.11490414291620255,
-0.3831422030925751,
0.43546295166015625,
-0.8164563179016113,
-0.2373388260602951,
-0.44168034195899963,
-0.1725866049528122,
-0.20626747608184814,
0.12495346367359161,
0.32987362146377563,
0.6259790658950806,
-0.2651159465312958,
0.0210927352309227,
0.6400895714759827,
-0.35477539896965027,
0.7988842725753784,
0.8657956123352051,
-0.09853067994117737,
-0.5068456530570984,
0.8002667427062988,
0.22729840874671936,
0.3777030408382416,
0.523439347743988,
0.10227742791175842,
-0.23026876151561737,
-0.5992571711540222,
-0.743186891078949,
0.05393105372786522,
-0.33697959780693054,
-0.15931975841522217,
-0.4778716564178467,
-0.7451644539833069,
-0.26904842257499695,
-0.25264838337898254,
-0.3402079939842224,
-0.31006181240081787,
-0.28075337409973145,
0.14052020013332367,
0.1898401826620102,
0.44995763897895813,
0.0788162499666214,
0.06345517188310623,
-0.9541239738464355,
0.11089716106653214,
0.2154969871044159,
0.2926327884197235,
-0.4313744604587555,
-0.8723862171173096,
-0.29242587089538574,
-0.12952181696891785,
0.04013068228960037,
-1.2351703643798828,
0.4193946421146393,
0.142220601439476,
0.26523810625076294,
0.3062589764595032,
0.13836440443992615,
0.3003329038619995,
-0.49729275703430176,
0.4668835997581482,
0.2502165138721466,
-1.0194919109344482,
0.6325962543487549,
-0.129349023103714,
0.6362800598144531,
0.686165988445282,
-0.05710574984550476,
-0.7695231437683105,
-0.3427512049674988,
-0.34027329087257385,
-0.493594229221344,
0.8247683048248291,
0.3266558051109314,
-0.3603164553642273,
0.10539373010396957,
-0.013743868097662926,
0.07396631687879562,
0.26039206981658936,
-0.5626033544540405,
0.008622205816209316,
-0.06970299035310745,
-0.19001756608486176,
0.2964184582233429,
0.037568386644124985,
0.12359024584293365,
-0.0023495168425142765,
0.5402982234954834,
0.027373874559998512,
0.32372209429740906,
0.2748073637485504,
-0.32735103368759155,
0.013986448757350445,
0.8417991399765015,
0.4507134258747101,
0.4418867230415344,
-0.10494409501552582,
-0.024987149983644485,
0.3543003797531128,
-0.7083724141120911,
0.22221770882606506,
0.37655216455459595,
-0.5141853094100952,
0.14531542360782623,
0.12683768570423126,
0.9042102694511414,
0.10293442010879517,
-0.7181248664855957,
0.4483208954334259,
-0.13036906719207764,
0.13550710678100586,
-0.3525403141975403,
-0.15080289542675018,
0.023258419707417488,
0.16747763752937317,
0.06033380702137947,
0.21174408495426178,
0.3495735228061676,
-0.28825995326042175,
0.30063140392303467,
0.12225993722677231,
-0.5569378137588501,
-0.306576132774353,
0.4206320643424988,
0.6788396239280701,
-0.7641451954841614,
0.4136951267719269,
-0.142370343208313,
-0.5906782746315002,
0.7852494716644287,
0.7826417088508606,
1.112715244293213,
-0.781090259552002,
0.0821409597992897,
0.2630959153175354,
0.49115192890167236,
0.26359403133392334,
0.33028414845466614,
-0.22237522900104523,
-0.8239917755126953,
-0.34560173749923706,
-0.3777672052383423,
-0.3709476888179779,
-0.05139719694852829,
-0.7316015958786011,
0.6573035717010498,
-0.2677011787891388,
-0.20692132413387299,
-0.31395667791366577,
-0.23964542150497437,
-0.5589413642883301,
0.4464415907859802,
0.2579125165939331,
0.9895405769348145,
-0.8084192872047424,
0.9599472284317017,
0.8517664074897766,
-0.2398354560136795,
-0.8930798768997192,
-0.013676710426807404,
-0.11360591650009155,
-0.7210133671760559,
0.683131217956543,
0.11280029267072678,
-0.48401719331741333,
-0.03904160112142563,
-0.05264677852392197,
-0.7218196988105774,
0.9359041452407837,
0.046735864132642746,
-0.7180536985397339,
0.14046065509319305,
0.2623431086540222,
0.6620375514030457,
-0.26049596071243286,
0.574489951133728,
0.753106951713562,
0.019393980503082275,
0.07673324644565582,
-1.5497446060180664,
-0.2738262414932251,
-0.23412483930587769,
0.16691383719444275,
0.12363899499177933,
-0.7604173421859741,
0.6410359144210815,
-0.21225062012672424,
-0.6568166613578796,
-0.371793657541275,
0.3142513036727905,
0.23852241039276123,
0.4618123471736908,
1.0147597789764404,
0.385808527469635,
0.20633651316165924,
0.31133419275283813,
0.3381098806858063,
-0.5413926243782043,
0.3046564757823944,
0.8563485741615295,
-0.5793766975402832,
1.1946464776992798,
0.3733177185058594,
-0.49932894110679626,
0.11167877912521362,
0.38945963978767395,
0.22551006078720093,
0.5693520307540894,
0.05357539653778076,
-0.5148079991340637,
0.0002453633933328092,
-0.014062546193599701,
-0.43262067437171936,
0.6270541548728943,
0.1241704449057579,
-0.31386440992355347,
-0.2343539446592331,
0.14483937621116638,
-0.12653416395187378,
-0.10600121319293976,
0.05427456274628639,
1.0465182065963745,
0.03427453339099884,
-0.4682712256908417,
0.6797758936882019,
-0.051261935383081436,
0.9247316122055054,
-0.5565288662910461,
-0.05790017917752266,
-0.042843371629714966,
0.0004989714943803847,
-0.2898615598678589,
-0.5113294124603271,
0.5596755743026733,
0.5173535346984863,
-0.18528412282466888,
-0.18486939370632172,
0.7592245936393738,
-0.508547306060791,
-0.5595433115959167,
0.4003602862358093,
0.28898727893829346,
0.4522362947463989,
0.22222554683685303,
-0.474072128534317,
0.36609363555908203,
0.34511736035346985,
0.19355346262454987,
0.20914708077907562,
0.10232312232255936,
-0.07311541587114334,
0.5450320243835449,
0.5127426385879517,
0.12588678300380707,
-0.03767183795571327,
0.44423890113830566,
0.6852526068687439,
-0.5998114943504333,
-0.922066330909729,
-0.5449661016464233,
0.2726793885231018,
0.16149389743804932,
-0.3621387481689453,
0.41134530305862427,
0.8982396125793457,
0.7510421872138977,
0.01632910780608654,
1.0420242547988892,
-0.1195257380604744,
0.918669581413269,
-0.494748055934906,
0.8790411949157715,
-0.11166754364967346,
0.43358930945396423,
-0.23293884098529816,
-0.6089578866958618,
-0.16081154346466064,
0.5850874781608582,
-0.10740061849355698,
-0.0732116624712944,
1.0052106380462646,
0.6833527088165283,
0.09739819169044495,
0.4475751519203186,
0.6706963777542114,
0.099562868475914,
0.22387729585170746,
0.6081451773643494,
0.7928668260574341,
-0.4732792377471924,
0.8047053217887878,
-0.11875438690185547,
-0.5045017004013062,
0.127101331949234,
-0.3802946209907532,
-0.728870153427124,
-0.6689308881759644,
-0.5068837404251099,
-0.1979379951953888,
0.39810553193092346,
0.8089885115623474,
0.31318843364715576,
-1.085044026374817,
-0.6632140278816223,
0.09947293251752853,
-0.357308954000473,
-0.08631440252065659,
-0.19284403324127197,
0.18861214816570282,
0.017674414440989494,
-0.7489567399024963,
0.6248258352279663,
0.40088745951652527,
-0.15765255689620972,
-0.07938840985298157,
0.11409935355186462,
-0.13192118704319,
-0.10158891975879669,
0.5032938718795776,
0.3147105574607849,
-0.6404922008514404,
-0.25810757279396057,
0.06677287071943283,
-0.15661267936229706,
0.1359301656484604,
1.049613356590271,
-0.8485161066055298,
0.37337788939476013,
0.6154059767723083,
0.863609254360199,
0.20581892132759094,
0.025570746511220932,
0.48160481452941895,
-0.27264508605003357,
0.16292063891887665,
0.3228064179420471,
0.34900984168052673,
0.33264824748039246,
-0.24160197377204895,
0.29569166898727417,
0.2463529258966446,
-0.7304527163505554,
-0.522646427154541,
0.21555843949317932,
-0.9658249020576477,
0.05395666882395744,
1.1745049953460693,
-0.07951802015304565,
0.021816357970237732,
-0.3936178386211395,
-0.5339997410774231,
0.4246481955051422,
-0.738444447517395,
0.7102625966072083,
0.5859606266021729,
-0.30966272950172424,
-0.17754799127578735,
-0.29083696007728577,
0.2893964350223541,
0.33039590716362,
-0.9590585231781006,
-0.06689099222421646,
0.3543148636817932,
0.24916158616542816,
0.224823996424675,
0.8089789152145386,
-0.2242622673511505,
0.1540134847164154,
-0.13125619292259216,
0.23806928098201752,
0.32984524965286255,
-0.14447279274463654,
-0.7129757404327393,
-0.08824151009321213,
-0.06107937544584274,
-0.7587775588035583
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06789v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06789v1
|
SPLADE-v3: New baselines for SPLADE
| 2024-03-11T15:04:55 | 2024-03-11T15:04:55 |
Carlos Lassance, Hervé Déjean, Thibault Formal, Stéphane Clinchant
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
A companion to the release of the latest version of the SPLADE library. We
describe changes to the training structure and present our latest series of
models -- SPLADE-v3. We compare this new version to BM25, SPLADE++, as well as
re-rankers, and showcase its effectiveness via a meta-analysis over more than
40 query sets. SPLADE-v3 further pushes the limit of SPLADE models: it is
statistically significantly more effective than both BM25 and SPLADE++, while
comparing well to cross-encoder re-rankers. Specifically, it gets more than 40
MRR@10 on the MS MARCO dev set, and improves by 2% the out-of-domain results on
the BEIR benchmark.
|
[
-0.5867812633514404,
-0.18625016510486603,
0.1642008274793625,
0.35748961567878723,
-0.008527033030986786,
-0.13356296718120575,
0.0850759893655777,
-0.621673047542572,
0.2755836546421051,
0.5617464780807495,
-0.4639931917190552,
-0.542152464389801,
-0.7091761231422424,
0.373332142829895,
-0.5091909766197205,
1.1554328203201294,
-0.17647305130958557,
0.38778191804885864,
-0.0683504268527031,
-0.3190374970436096,
-0.608258068561554,
-0.17449814081192017,
-0.3981471359729767,
-0.254419207572937,
1.0365875959396362,
0.1963454931974411,
0.6156519651412964,
0.6684245467185974,
0.867572546005249,
0.18613779544830322,
-0.23243986070156097,
-0.3515673279762268,
-0.47225263714790344,
0.2542516589164734,
-0.18508142232894897,
-0.3806924819946289,
-0.9873122572898865,
-0.09376717358827591,
0.5508356690406799,
0.6687244772911072,
0.00863565318286419,
0.3641655147075653,
-0.2937527894973755,
0.8283202648162842,
-0.9914196133613586,
-0.07125397771596909,
-0.4410855770111084,
0.12443996965885162,
-0.2333848923444748,
-0.15150701999664307,
-0.609281599521637,
-0.407187819480896,
0.510749876499176,
-0.21844570338726044,
0.6623446941375732,
-0.33065202832221985,
1.1303250789642334,
0.23669150471687317,
-0.4578532576560974,
-0.06883195042610168,
-0.37629443407058716,
0.44298866391181946,
-0.40352004766464233,
1.122381567955017,
0.10715340077877045,
0.8239174485206604,
0.1555904597043991,
-1.043006420135498,
-0.1817210465669632,
-0.3076343238353729,
0.29605600237846375,
-0.12543848156929016,
0.04753589630126953,
-0.22173207998275757,
0.1613316833972931,
0.7848830223083496,
-0.5054067969322205,
-0.111208975315094,
-0.8192468881607056,
0.01524992287158966,
0.7664337754249573,
-0.2837607264518738,
-0.031041370704770088,
0.14738833904266357,
-0.6149097681045532,
-0.2694777250289917,
-1.131622314453125,
-0.3653005361557007,
0.1201668232679367,
-0.04265424609184265,
0.3457994759082794,
0.559997022151947,
-0.4121008515357971,
0.7741498947143555,
0.12853458523750305,
0.10428332537412643,
0.41185638308525085,
-0.0557270348072052,
-0.3766847848892212,
-0.2057860642671585,
0.11692921072244644,
0.8722387552261353,
-0.2092905342578888,
-0.20095422863960266,
-0.35094884037971497,
-0.30645349621772766,
0.24453584849834442,
-0.8933693170547485,
-0.643999457359314,
0.21398209035396576,
-0.4824700355529785,
-0.23068998754024506,
0.07812155038118362,
-0.41757047176361084,
-0.6738135814666748,
-0.2853822112083435,
0.6142337918281555,
-0.5254825353622437,
-0.13029591739177704,
0.5263478755950928,
-0.43705448508262634,
0.6529715657234192,
0.6626139879226685,
-0.8450676798820496,
0.5528719425201416,
0.4987000823020935,
0.7898922562599182,
-0.44611358642578125,
-0.7162287831306458,
-0.523122251033783,
0.0568963922560215,
-0.3789631724357605,
0.7428804039955139,
-0.040661294013261795,
-0.4048510193824768,
0.031070947647094727,
0.283711314201355,
0.26194822788238525,
-0.8534157872200012,
0.3415284752845764,
-0.718300461769104,
0.1952592432498932,
-0.7403417825698853,
-0.5072773098945618,
-0.2790994942188263,
0.2884387969970703,
-0.9027875065803528,
1.1878567934036255,
0.13814471662044525,
-0.6050853729248047,
0.8010340332984924,
-0.5894849300384521,
0.031708791851997375,
0.07512877881526947,
0.25608697533607483,
-0.6698353290557861,
-0.04444187879562378,
0.16548532247543335,
0.3888052701950073,
-0.21847008168697357,
0.023567283526062965,
-0.46121564507484436,
-0.42361390590667725,
-0.05005229637026787,
0.005867939908057451,
1.0871102809906006,
0.1940675526857376,
-0.17133933305740356,
0.2502748966217041,
-0.6099188923835754,
-0.1655491292476654,
-0.028470149263739586,
-0.2778831422328949,
0.3511439263820648,
-0.10355439782142639,
-0.1805485486984253,
0.046653296798467636,
0.5749722123146057,
-0.4915272295475006,
-0.07751873880624771,
-0.006779123563319445,
0.003814493538811803,
0.51432865858078,
0.09887100011110306,
0.4021969437599182,
-0.7080717086791992,
0.2840453088283539,
-0.09022213518619537,
0.4236925542354584,
-0.11943066865205765,
-0.4703533351421356,
-0.7279431819915771,
-0.62254399061203,
0.5089675784111023,
0.5355261564254761,
-0.45036572217941284,
0.30631446838378906,
-0.5096158981323242,
-0.7541846036911011,
-0.3961668014526367,
-0.029802516102790833,
0.2012511044740677,
-0.21627050638198853,
0.6375641226768494,
-0.37452933192253113,
-0.7411996126174927,
-1.0454154014587402,
-0.2912265956401825,
0.14101196825504303,
-0.1365320235490799,
-0.09758691489696503,
0.7625690698623657,
-0.22151577472686768,
0.8454177379608154,
-0.34360238909721375,
0.15857577323913574,
-0.5039606094360352,
-0.15058745443820953,
-0.0551467202603817,
0.45379751920700073,
0.7282333374023438,
-0.6431321501731873,
-0.8150562047958374,
0.05087043344974518,
-0.5543696284294128,
-0.0918038859963417,
0.331778883934021,
-0.07065233588218689,
0.030163222923874855,
0.30664142966270447,
-0.368288516998291,
0.20611818134784698,
0.1548510193824768,
-0.05833706632256508,
0.3887360095977783,
-0.0955243930220604,
0.18623262643814087,
-0.9092932343482971,
-0.0426241010427475,
0.21222564578056335,
-0.17071792483329773,
-0.5892070531845093,
0.34361326694488525,
0.5059002637863159,
-0.442190021276474,
-0.548275887966156,
0.3631025552749634,
-0.708012580871582,
-0.46741288900375366,
0.00852042157202959,
0.1686594933271408,
0.058521803468465805,
0.1701560765504837,
0.14524829387664795,
0.6870112419128418,
0.7319178581237793,
-0.43026003241539,
0.6014052629470825,
0.2054840326309204,
-0.3420664370059967,
0.5140087008476257,
-0.8112337589263916,
-0.08004718273878098,
-0.3951760530471802,
0.5229336023330688,
-0.546718418598175,
-0.17026080191135406,
-0.17830972373485565,
-0.6292216777801514,
0.5516493320465088,
-0.02375049889087677,
-0.23419690132141113,
-0.36262068152427673,
-0.9489762187004089,
-0.07926382124423981,
0.12953485548496246,
-0.744691014289856,
0.207307368516922,
0.4048466384410858,
-0.08468256890773773,
-0.5878162384033203,
-0.5171433091163635,
0.18269729614257812,
-0.2520940899848938,
-0.6766685843467712,
0.434367299079895,
-0.2983476221561432,
0.030591115355491638,
-0.13766014575958252,
-0.2342456579208374,
-0.20139682292938232,
0.01346659380942583,
-0.25406086444854736,
0.29366806149482727,
-0.36131763458251953,
-0.41871118545532227,
-0.32575997710227966,
-0.02126990631222725,
-0.055359527468681335,
0.13462954759597778,
0.38734614849090576,
-0.0999227911233902,
-0.029326878488063812,
-0.402249813079834,
0.11574076861143112,
0.5900801420211792,
-0.6459674835205078,
0.8799704909324646,
0.4791770875453949,
-0.4829019010066986,
-0.08028803765773773,
-0.6120094656944275,
-0.21360176801681519,
-0.47007161378860474,
0.6664135456085205,
-0.6342751979827881,
-0.5324966311454773,
0.39011886715888977,
0.1599428802728653,
0.07889187335968018,
0.25146451592445374,
0.35081011056900024,
0.2463672161102295,
1.087672233581543,
0.5544547438621521,
0.1306363046169281,
0.7594974040985107,
-0.4647024869918823,
0.1730971336364746,
-0.993546187877655,
-0.5973092913627625,
-0.3009575605392456,
-0.179809108376503,
-0.6005256175994873,
-0.3836962878704071,
0.39725059270858765,
0.18909701704978943,
-0.43693453073501587,
0.9840726852416992,
-0.325030118227005,
0.6046776175498962,
0.2768106758594513,
0.17074935138225555,
-0.05455334112048149,
-0.1583862155675888,
0.5420680642127991,
-0.07317022234201431,
-0.5532324314117432,
-0.3213900625705719,
1.2971240282058716,
0.6527060866355896,
0.26466989517211914,
0.4577389061450958,
0.5858074426651001,
0.2767632305622101,
0.6429088711738586,
-0.4189835786819458,
0.6589155197143555,
0.07572990655899048,
-1.1291168928146362,
-0.05209128558635712,
-0.15135298669338226,
-0.6666751503944397,
0.6505835056304932,
-0.335173100233078,
-0.6639745831489563,
0.4396723210811615,
-0.30088376998901367,
-0.05785880237817764,
0.22731080651283264,
-0.6905732750892639,
1.2046517133712769,
0.08846109360456467,
-0.7277559638023376,
0.06733345240354538,
-0.7820104956626892,
0.3636251986026764,
0.21298553049564362,
-0.47985655069351196,
-0.19196903705596924,
-0.19286340475082397,
0.4727742075920105,
-0.48389166593551636,
0.3270576000213623,
-0.3617429733276367,
-0.16046270728111267,
-0.06583555787801743,
-0.16062460839748383,
0.6574629545211792,
0.010676469653844833,
-0.4989607334136963,
-0.2184993475675583,
0.10474780201911926,
-0.8813450336456299,
-0.6182226538658142,
0.6442521214485168,
-0.688612699508667,
-0.41820093989372253,
-0.5720072984695435,
-0.2919692397117615,
-0.21963129937648773,
0.35430073738098145,
0.26962044835090637,
0.686888575553894,
-0.16120897233486176,
0.6923350095748901,
0.8455158472061157,
-0.2705896496772766,
-0.0763976201415062,
0.9617035984992981,
-0.45965254306793213,
-0.8250165581703186,
0.7788704037666321,
0.20566436648368835,
0.3425779640674591,
0.5308374762535095,
-0.22233901917934418,
-0.3743840456008911,
-0.9492371678352356,
-0.4315357804298401,
0.4655018150806427,
-0.8068581819534302,
-0.268825501203537,
-0.49486738443374634,
-0.17816868424415588,
-0.420014351606369,
-0.33840203285217285,
-0.5035709142684937,
-0.17690704762935638,
0.3517504334449768,
-0.33546435832977295,
0.23382480442523956,
0.6998987197875977,
-0.02118205837905407,
0.5419833660125732,
-0.3342471122741699,
0.08040838688611984,
0.2422475516796112,
0.3114114999771118,
-0.5102823972702026,
-0.2990467846393585,
-0.5446375012397766,
-0.12234946340322495,
-0.5294490456581116,
-1.143202543258667,
0.1808590143918991,
-0.09668958187103271,
0.5364595651626587,
-0.0743580013513565,
-0.28246214985847473,
0.5849396586418152,
-0.5076265931129456,
0.9584709405899048,
0.09033647179603577,
-0.7772536277770996,
0.5285803079605103,
-0.5974884629249573,
0.04381759837269783,
0.599922239780426,
0.5620004534721375,
-0.2241884022951126,
-0.24088306725025177,
-0.7381328344345093,
-0.6163250207901001,
0.486328125,
0.11497802287340164,
-0.4225289821624756,
-0.20125631988048553,
0.4256025552749634,
0.09631139785051346,
0.40800365805625916,
-0.7732846736907959,
-0.4318549633026123,
-0.22588947415351868,
0.20085026323795319,
0.03834277391433716,
-0.3680870532989502,
0.2427152693271637,
-0.36365970969200134,
0.8992614150047302,
0.2661067545413971,
0.15535275638103485,
0.06318220496177673,
-0.14632312953472137,
0.02452796883881092,
-0.2076520323753357,
0.36359599232673645,
0.7668026685714722,
-0.9760289192199707,
0.060156214982271194,
0.6513892412185669,
-0.24440476298332214,
-0.18087473511695862,
0.19174668192863464,
0.05500020086765289,
0.1423376053571701,
0.2810070216655731,
1.1299021244049072,
0.2951819896697998,
-0.38122671842575073,
0.8527893424034119,
0.1909734010696411,
-0.18529722094535828,
-0.050458427518606186,
-0.020621350035071373,
-0.30384477972984314,
0.1435292512178421,
0.13043415546417236,
0.32109934091567993,
0.5469039678573608,
-0.7325480580329895,
0.42608776688575745,
0.09867868572473526,
-0.384914368391037,
-0.36747679114341736,
0.7484190464019775,
0.23603945970535278,
-0.1336664855480194,
-0.0567282997071743,
-0.2546185553073883,
-0.3572109639644623,
0.320386677980423,
0.8015393018722534,
0.6178876757621765,
-0.3946409523487091,
0.23916946351528168,
0.516513466835022,
0.24476230144500732,
-0.4895026981830597,
0.30944785475730896,
-0.18339823186397552,
-0.4781210720539093,
-0.3440376818180084,
-0.33095496892929077,
-0.5314119458198547,
0.06206951662898064,
-1.0227971076965332,
0.7876719236373901,
-0.11992014199495316,
-0.024376126006245613,
-0.12292539328336716,
0.5679723024368286,
-0.35233935713768005,
0.37444809079170227,
-0.2692488729953766,
1.2086235284805298,
-0.7308073043823242,
0.8652807474136353,
0.8991290926933289,
-0.46344053745269775,
-0.1434028297662735,
-0.10444094985723495,
-0.19736216962337494,
-0.4468564987182617,
0.2936743497848511,
0.1185135543346405,
-0.23683598637580872,
0.02934723161160946,
-0.4164358377456665,
-0.939217209815979,
1.6866414546966553,
0.3860776722431183,
-0.08094968646764755,
0.10151536017656326,
-0.18810974061489105,
0.34477078914642334,
-0.0979473739862442,
0.2911219894886017,
0.6252599358558655,
0.25672289729118347,
-0.07450572401285172,
-0.8162722587585449,
-0.2716131806373596,
-0.42515361309051514,
0.22968751192092896,
0.4844847321510315,
-0.5595884919166565,
0.9022668600082397,
0.08871655911207199,
-0.10498281568288803,
0.2942837178707123,
0.8247924447059631,
0.6275414824485779,
0.39715811610221863,
0.3337511718273163,
0.46895334124565125,
0.7673358917236328,
0.06291940063238144,
1.2287005186080933,
-0.4004214406013489,
0.49368202686309814,
0.923775315284729,
-0.5713510513305664,
1.0106816291809082,
0.010488365776836872,
-0.43907463550567627,
0.3942289352416992,
0.7515352964401245,
0.005532641429454088,
0.5297921299934387,
0.06099045276641846,
-0.42464911937713623,
0.11330049484968185,
0.20685777068138123,
-0.7140927910804749,
-0.2072300910949707,
-0.04021088778972626,
-0.044152725487947464,
-0.30286461114883423,
-0.01376593392342329,
0.2303888499736786,
-0.20422719419002533,
-0.08688315749168396,
0.49209657311439514,
-0.3555784225463867,
-0.4307749271392822,
0.8062251210212708,
0.14095920324325562,
0.4661804437637329,
-0.5153784155845642,
0.41601112484931946,
-0.4676772654056549,
0.37698301672935486,
-0.13729485869407654,
-0.5837729573249817,
0.3209831416606903,
0.08579259365797043,
-0.1912173181772232,
-0.3208133578300476,
0.5220217108726501,
-0.3072231113910675,
-0.31332868337631226,
0.20612438023090363,
0.4339694380760193,
0.27450472116470337,
0.05722283944487572,
-0.4731656312942505,
0.431946724653244,
0.002422728342935443,
-0.003076135879382491,
0.29261651635169983,
0.650594174861908,
0.15708664059638977,
0.62618088722229,
0.41113972663879395,
0.22126320004463196,
0.5371131300926208,
-0.13266266882419586,
0.6565775871276855,
-0.7254372239112854,
-0.17599906027317047,
-0.28112322092056274,
0.30348533391952515,
-0.44202566146850586,
-0.4471020996570587,
1.0200533866882324,
1.086954116821289,
0.9581261873245239,
-0.18085834383964539,
0.5189283490180969,
0.03389696404337883,
0.6874303221702576,
-0.11485914885997772,
0.27747294306755066,
-0.7925965785980225,
0.4954581558704376,
-0.07134547829627991,
-1.10086989402771,
-0.6103687882423401,
0.6408166289329529,
-0.461112380027771,
-0.029630711302161217,
0.8084158301353455,
0.9910672307014465,
-0.11826290935277939,
0.20232301950454712,
0.19499751925468445,
-0.061026934534311295,
0.3960348665714264,
0.37925997376441956,
0.848619818687439,
-0.9329522252082825,
0.20854449272155762,
-0.3975095748901367,
-0.046549759805202484,
-0.3875812888145447,
-0.5754656791687012,
-0.8008051514625549,
-0.5399510860443115,
-0.38574865460395813,
-0.22011247277259827,
0.4697357416152954,
0.7035883069038391,
0.7681930661201477,
-0.75650954246521,
-0.40818676352500916,
-0.17570896446704865,
-0.1159384623169899,
-0.34801164269447327,
-0.13214053213596344,
0.2627633810043335,
-0.3209633529186249,
-0.8392544984817505,
0.683268129825592,
0.16693557798862457,
-0.06847845762968063,
-0.17034479975700378,
-0.3200773596763611,
-0.2856787443161011,
-0.0051745944656431675,
0.6876831650733948,
0.08052445203065872,
-0.23146604001522064,
-0.4348352551460266,
0.05829014256596565,
-0.051041461527347565,
0.13928835093975067,
0.5836282968521118,
-0.4933498203754425,
0.09129198640584946,
0.7943220138549805,
0.46085885167121887,
0.9716301560401917,
-0.25496944785118103,
0.7706204652786255,
-0.4590258002281189,
-0.0036896481178700924,
-0.03653274103999138,
0.566155731678009,
0.5466877222061157,
0.4187021255493164,
0.5937996506690979,
0.21591083705425262,
-0.6751790642738342,
-1.3241498470306396,
0.3037746846675873,
-0.8042781352996826,
-0.16867218911647797,
0.8628886938095093,
0.1412835419178009,
-0.3682711720466614,
0.04287909343838692,
-0.24025876820087433,
0.2887175679206848,
-0.09028580784797668,
0.4812382757663727,
0.5959448218345642,
0.16414442658424377,
-0.3253644108772278,
-0.9312432408332825,
0.4775632619857788,
0.5604127049446106,
-0.7254170179367065,
-0.17857638001441956,
0.5315845012664795,
0.47769927978515625,
-0.08404465764760971,
0.7270656228065491,
-0.39540037512779236,
0.5238916277885437,
0.09280204772949219,
0.0463964007794857,
0.08555182814598083,
-0.7754732966423035,
-0.19754816591739655,
0.26302728056907654,
0.2762019634246826,
-0.30885136127471924
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06769v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06769v2
|
Strength Lies in Differences! Towards Effective Non-collaborative Dialogues via Tailored Strategy Planning
| 2024-03-11T14:38:16 | 2024-05-07T02:14:02 |
Tong Zhang, Chen Huang, Yang Deng, Hongru Liang, Jia Liu, Zujie Wen, Wenqiang Lei, Tat-Seng Chua
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We investigate non-collaborative dialogue agents, which are expected to
engage in strategic conversations with diverse users, for securing a mutual
agreement that leans favorably towards the system's objectives. This poses two
main challenges for existing dialogue agents: 1) The inability to integrate
user-specific characteristics into the strategic planning, and 2) The
difficulty of training strategic planners that can be generalized to diverse
users. To address these challenges, we propose Trip to enhance the capability
in tailored strategic planning, incorporating a user-aware strategic planning
module and a population-based training paradigm. Through experiments on
benchmark non-collaborative dialogue tasks, we demonstrate the effectiveness of
Trip in catering to diverse users.
|
[
-0.7679428458213806,
-0.04249969869852066,
0.4834217429161072,
0.3554103374481201,
-0.04148329794406891,
0.7148565053939819,
-0.35111990571022034,
-0.23874501883983612,
0.7904177308082581,
0.46113312244415283,
-1.0128754377365112,
-0.05386790260672569,
-0.3674979507923126,
0.28342878818511963,
0.25632962584495544,
0.8464661836624146,
-0.017521314322948456,
0.038120388984680176,
0.045931100845336914,
-0.8066228628158569,
-0.8450015783309937,
-0.31730878353118896,
-0.5065879821777344,
-0.5556514859199524,
0.41748982667922974,
0.9081094264984131,
0.9831024408340454,
-0.15017762780189514,
0.4741652011871338,
0.26133763790130615,
0.07380819320678711,
0.4505161643028259,
-0.8241705894470215,
0.2473396360874176,
-0.7478692531585693,
-0.4122861921787262,
-0.3475634455680847,
0.01872776448726654,
0.6215500235557556,
0.8999912738800049,
-0.2781559228897095,
-0.11994820088148117,
-0.0863172709941864,
0.6329243183135986,
-0.534614622592926,
-0.30323055386543274,
-0.9629798531532288,
0.16739122569561005,
0.2712961435317993,
0.09005367755889893,
-0.14724168181419373,
0.12036018073558807,
0.5246052742004395,
-0.9393945932388306,
-0.013566428795456886,
0.14715784788131714,
0.5697721838951111,
0.09625911712646484,
-0.7121502757072449,
-0.19406433403491974,
-1.1111018657684326,
0.9514474272727966,
-0.3028393089771271,
0.38889503479003906,
0.18715257942676544,
0.35490813851356506,
-0.4548177123069763,
-0.5730502605438232,
-0.47250527143478394,
-0.05943726375699043,
0.18656025826931,
0.4970945119857788,
-0.11146216094493866,
0.09964707493782043,
0.3513735234737396,
0.04846067354083061,
-0.5696691274642944,
0.12858638167381287,
-0.3892459571361542,
0.029457855969667435,
0.8338598608970642,
0.32777348160743713,
0.2791244387626648,
0.03341781720519066,
-0.5973125100135803,
0.08025595545768738,
-0.3467257618904114,
0.14903484284877777,
0.4103107452392578,
0.49630746245384216,
-0.2387275993824005,
0.3274986445903778,
-0.5604572296142578,
0.25514766573905945,
0.27191710472106934,
-0.14449582993984222,
0.02181170880794525,
-0.5420361161231995,
-0.12708336114883423,
-0.07029443979263306,
0.5312220454216003,
0.6408692002296448,
0.14039131999015808,
-0.23471984267234802,
-0.2739866375923157,
-0.17550520598888397,
0.3469829261302948,
-0.6631843447685242,
-0.44554153084754944,
-0.11630972474813461,
-0.583304226398468,
-0.07935670763254166,
-0.09991563856601715,
-0.8553142547607422,
-0.316745400428772,
-0.15399843454360962,
0.3207055628299713,
-0.28995203971862793,
-0.4224720895290375,
-0.015012416057288647,
-0.5771762132644653,
0.46000999212265015,
0.32027193903923035,
-1.2836588621139526,
0.5717673897743225,
0.2439802587032318,
0.8988182544708252,
-0.3182229697704315,
-0.20925094187259674,
-0.26409128308296204,
0.17972368001937866,
-0.28160369396209717,
0.9313322901725769,
-0.6098750829696655,
-1.2095221281051636,
-0.2700653076171875,
-0.5538020133972168,
-0.35848933458328247,
-0.632289469242096,
0.49156826734542847,
-0.02951366826891899,
0.2923244833946228,
-0.903181254863739,
-0.0009492090903222561,
0.008476173505187035,
0.5903868079185486,
-0.4492951035499573,
0.5017386674880981,
0.36581194400787354,
-0.26281777024269104,
0.6629160642623901,
-0.9604314565658569,
-0.536454439163208,
0.35615602135658264,
-0.42986422777175903,
-0.31285789608955383,
0.06673242151737213,
0.4248759150505066,
-0.4037851393222809,
-0.12673871219158173,
-0.07789493352174759,
-0.3618159592151642,
-0.33566293120384216,
0.2676502764225006,
0.16873793303966522,
0.7051286697387695,
0.2533189058303833,
-0.29656675457954407,
0.5335144996643066,
-0.45981836318969727,
0.41504454612731934,
0.03911038115620613,
-0.5572083592414856,
0.07459535449743271,
0.08847738057374954,
0.0966208279132843,
0.37902799248695374,
0.08395574986934662,
-0.2984374761581421,
0.6404035687446594,
-0.431984007358551,
0.31093212962150574,
0.7200013995170593,
0.16400974988937378,
0.7032425999641418,
-0.6284509301185608,
0.7348901033401489,
-0.21780450642108917,
0.43034422397613525,
0.38943877816200256,
-0.7356944680213928,
-0.7398413419723511,
-0.19828203320503235,
-0.14203913509845734,
0.5872395634651184,
-0.9499928951263428,
0.20672476291656494,
-0.3106130063533783,
-0.5951124429702759,
0.07293595373630524,
0.1922813057899475,
0.26588255167007446,
0.26060882210731506,
0.22346898913383484,
-0.8905991315841675,
-0.7171348929405212,
-0.7338276505470276,
-0.4669992923736572,
-0.6447027325630188,
0.16337434947490692,
0.5028329491615295,
0.3822174668312073,
-0.2413484901189804,
0.9690060615539551,
-0.27041321992874146,
-0.42150405049324036,
-1.256244421005249,
0.034866757690906525,
-0.23554843664169312,
0.1454969048500061,
0.36292359232902527,
-0.8671236634254456,
-0.7907094359397888,
-0.23970550298690796,
-0.47819700837135315,
-0.018000004813075066,
-0.5336503982543945,
-0.24420543015003204,
-0.13625799119472504,
0.16939319670200348,
-0.4840480387210846,
0.31819209456443787,
0.408657431602478,
-0.20108196139335632,
0.34175825119018555,
-0.1235404834151268,
0.12844190001487732,
-1.2242388725280762,
-0.16676732897758484,
-0.18884381651878357,
-0.021865012124180794,
-1.012722373008728,
-0.37455326318740845,
-0.4982433617115021,
-0.5220816135406494,
-0.33878690004348755,
0.27749764919281006,
-0.2816047668457031,
-0.3090479373931885,
-0.1125556230545044,
0.07996366173028946,
0.0228697769343853,
0.6553120017051697,
0.19679704308509827,
0.7814830541610718,
0.24831891059875488,
-0.4960480332374573,
0.1023368090391159,
0.9397927522659302,
-0.009076990187168121,
1.0208921432495117,
-0.4390690326690674,
0.23224793374538422,
0.2602968215942383,
0.44620969891548157,
-0.8066686987876892,
-0.1904934048652649,
0.30186939239501953,
-0.28352901339530945,
-0.04806040599942207,
-0.058131419122219086,
0.217145174741745,
-0.03551040217280388,
-0.4301959276199341,
0.2905702292919159,
0.41594284772872925,
-0.3552536368370056,
0.9546132683753967,
0.35916760563850403,
0.05957117676734924,
-0.34805828332901,
-0.39787882566452026,
0.5622655153274536,
-0.5530117750167847,
-0.7358900904655457,
0.27187299728393555,
-0.014850335195660591,
-0.4233773350715637,
-0.24206186830997467,
-0.20273561775684357,
-0.19953130185604095,
0.04726751521229744,
0.44827988743782043,
0.018797148019075394,
-0.20657551288604736,
-0.034299012273550034,
-0.35069751739501953,
-0.13123299181461334,
-0.3096584379673004,
-0.47803062200546265,
0.4473916292190552,
-0.18941111862659454,
-0.4389553368091583,
-0.5244471430778503,
0.960496187210083,
0.4036481976509094,
-0.4791136085987091,
0.5953984260559082,
0.5020924806594849,
0.14772546291351318,
-0.32164332270622253,
-0.35847726464271545,
-0.2831690311431885,
-0.5542023777961731,
0.20296183228492737,
-0.194311261177063,
-0.6332167387008667,
0.5660720467567444,
-0.5368474125862122,
0.2575739920139313,
0.04873492568731308,
0.47392889857292175,
-0.2663719952106476,
0.8535134792327881,
0.8319810032844543,
0.17607907950878143,
0.5500290989875793,
-0.06440378725528717,
0.34918469190597534,
-0.5785806775093079,
-0.3421705961227417,
-0.23930932581424713,
-1.0738621950149536,
-0.7493399381637573,
-0.19293826818466187,
0.38195693492889404,
-0.2254847288131714,
-0.12648065388202667,
0.28554221987724304,
-0.3550736904144287,
0.4413279891014099,
0.7464746236801147,
-0.3748895227909088,
0.1237582266330719,
-0.07189346849918365,
-0.04383598268032074,
-0.30886244773864746,
-0.7624140381813049,
-0.3891797661781311,
1.0125831365585327,
-0.22141849994659424,
0.6846634745597839,
0.4387107491493225,
0.9175307154655457,
0.23533618450164795,
-0.018754875287413597,
-0.910728931427002,
0.8917137384414673,
0.1259133666753769,
-0.6765519976615906,
-0.30259081721305847,
-0.41914650797843933,
-0.9357720017433167,
0.2539416551589966,
-0.5794271230697632,
-1.0288798809051514,
0.4328731894493103,
-0.1681017428636551,
-0.5332515239715576,
0.49998337030410767,
-0.9742127656936646,
0.7181912064552307,
-0.33808887004852295,
0.02111230604350567,
-0.20739153027534485,
-0.6330451369285583,
-0.16837292909622192,
0.050633445382118225,
-0.4816998243331909,
-0.17240719497203827,
-0.01441072765737772,
0.844548761844635,
-0.292513906955719,
0.5675840377807617,
-0.17357607185840607,
0.5816795825958252,
0.5047304630279541,
0.08818209916353226,
0.25097018480300903,
-0.026685034856200218,
0.23653586208820343,
0.029466187581419945,
-0.3065824806690216,
-0.5148502588272095,
-0.6010335087776184,
0.41830122470855713,
-0.930273175239563,
-0.8756404519081116,
-0.3215234875679016,
-0.8570882081985474,
-0.7025500535964966,
0.24358481168746948,
0.23657920956611633,
0.12522222101688385,
-0.5798731446266174,
0.05403367802500725,
0.3176909387111664,
-0.02514827437698841,
0.5459608435630798,
0.5531571507453918,
0.1389179676771164,
-0.5020179152488708,
0.84632807970047,
0.37105700373649597,
0.6861572265625,
0.14013467729091644,
0.06947251409292221,
-0.23563359677791595,
-0.796908438205719,
-0.22755341231822968,
-0.08402039110660553,
-0.5550218224525452,
0.29440930485725403,
-0.3409120440483093,
0.062184542417526245,
-0.2194814682006836,
-0.5471065044403076,
-0.3857671618461609,
-0.6547917127609253,
0.0872262567281723,
-0.10858234018087387,
-0.2111913412809372,
0.8510955572128296,
-0.28804758191108704,
0.5529606342315674,
-0.2595362365245819,
0.15745598077774048,
0.520850658416748,
-0.041394129395484924,
-0.48018506169319153,
-0.06095866113901138,
-0.1066092699766159,
-0.18037725985050201,
-0.9993181228637695,
-1.029473066329956,
0.27933791279792786,
0.22062915563583374,
0.6958579421043396,
0.5719006657600403,
0.2160549759864807,
0.8030909895896912,
0.025269022211432457,
0.9598416686058044,
0.3452610373497009,
-0.6353052258491516,
0.6959792375564575,
-0.38221338391304016,
0.32048264145851135,
0.9887223243713379,
0.271027535200119,
-0.5311485528945923,
-0.26664984226226807,
-0.6792494654655457,
-0.5987111330032349,
0.7670354843139648,
0.4795168340206146,
0.055950846523046494,
0.34059128165245056,
-0.11567851901054382,
-0.06609033048152924,
0.1140817403793335,
-0.5979559421539307,
0.04961230605840683,
-0.22946925461292267,
0.2218780815601349,
0.05986057221889496,
-0.11225996911525726,
-0.341017484664917,
0.10587172210216522,
0.4970158338546753,
-0.00245794584043324,
0.10371702164411545,
0.24620892107486725,
0.34782886505126953,
-0.20721650123596191,
0.518804132938385,
0.6326183080673218,
1.0179650783538818,
-0.13699305057525635,
-0.16690649092197418,
0.6724513173103333,
-0.4406331181526184,
0.13246481120586395,
-0.16257406771183014,
0.022319169715046883,
-0.030992021784186363,
0.27441367506980896,
0.4752373993396759,
0.08891081809997559,
-0.5915442705154419,
0.1889016181230545,
-0.4847089648246765,
-0.5689011216163635,
0.0036759949289262295,
0.33647072315216064,
-0.04898828640580177,
0.4261523485183716,
0.04989403113722801,
0.19215457141399384,
0.03863254934549332,
-0.6068301200866699,
0.17475196719169617,
0.562661349773407,
-0.6235978603363037,
-0.17673328518867493,
0.3343777060508728,
0.8030415773391724,
-0.8047956824302673,
0.7692207098007202,
-0.38676100969314575,
-0.4862886071205139,
0.2341366410255432,
0.32040566205978394,
0.7382846474647522,
-0.4263213276863098,
0.451748788356781,
0.043229840695858,
0.47825491428375244,
0.36069002747535706,
0.45588698983192444,
-0.24850711226463318,
-0.7985051870346069,
0.14313967525959015,
0.027600180357694626,
-0.8633196353912354,
-0.07351177930831909,
-0.4812827706336975,
0.24788473546504974,
-0.9080160856246948,
-0.5847252011299133,
-0.24345560371875763,
0.3773391544818878,
-0.6298173666000366,
-0.1229739636182785,
-0.09140799194574356,
0.5720564723014832,
-0.6397138237953186,
0.31701287627220154,
0.8265840411186218,
-0.5909918546676636,
-0.9181295037269592,
0.36253276467323303,
0.07709138095378876,
-0.6899576783180237,
0.59522944688797,
0.18322592973709106,
-0.19747066497802734,
-0.4914548695087433,
-0.02560514397919178,
-0.43393954634666443,
1.0736836194992065,
0.2664712071418762,
-0.42913374304771423,
-0.14192909002304077,
0.5267047882080078,
0.2484959214925766,
-0.4590175151824951,
0.10960933566093445,
0.2418898493051529,
0.28055018186569214,
0.46989136934280396,
-1.265028953552246,
-0.23166601359844208,
0.1960919052362442,
-0.10030769556760788,
0.158259317278862,
-0.9234378933906555,
0.6748729944229126,
-0.4679717421531677,
-0.32409265637397766,
-0.041075922548770905,
0.49360716342926025,
-0.10100909322500229,
0.6522424221038818,
0.6500673890113831,
0.5291037559509277,
0.8242462277412415,
0.0448162704706192,
0.4909289479255676,
-0.008575374260544777,
-0.03844832256436348,
1.248861312866211,
-0.7246420979499817,
0.5182526707649231,
0.47866523265838623,
0.07312958687543869,
0.702928364276886,
0.37274840474128723,
0.09092254936695099,
0.575371265411377,
-0.0823807418346405,
-0.590835690498352,
-0.5790637731552124,
-0.294562429189682,
-0.09232994168996811,
0.8553879857063293,
0.23279136419296265,
-0.08835911750793457,
-0.3635311424732208,
-0.1965135931968689,
-0.18614064157009125,
0.2904076874256134,
-0.19634665548801422,
1.0355173349380493,
0.2329338788986206,
-0.7575356960296631,
0.2904747426509857,
0.0029729939997196198,
0.1781657338142395,
-0.7131040692329407,
0.2851739525794983,
-0.2307993471622467,
0.1722833812236786,
-0.24255411326885223,
-0.6307174563407898,
0.25705140829086304,
-0.18364977836608887,
0.20977745950222015,
-0.445475697517395,
0.6734820604324341,
0.008262709714472294,
-0.2221996933221817,
0.15921153128147125,
0.9257992506027222,
-0.17307904362678528,
0.10219041258096695,
-0.7725718021392822,
-0.06363624334335327,
0.21415241062641144,
0.08656405657529831,
0.2061440795660019,
0.28964558243751526,
-0.1445179134607315,
0.7948402166366577,
0.5983291268348694,
-0.024002183228731155,
-0.35812318325042725,
0.039242252707481384,
0.8642873167991638,
-0.4609085023403168,
-0.85877525806427,
-0.7252622842788696,
0.4161584675312042,
-0.5735419392585754,
-0.6499940752983093,
0.7257906198501587,
0.6058349609375,
0.8208861947059631,
0.14739002287387848,
0.7023113965988159,
0.24787989258766174,
-0.14234954118728638,
-0.00287494994699955,
0.36818140745162964,
-0.23824237287044525,
0.042927589267492294,
0.09230603277683258,
-0.9157249927520752,
0.10174201428890228,
0.6044778227806091,
-0.5626643300056458,
0.08903501182794571,
0.5210191607475281,
0.6819132566452026,
-0.14533329010009766,
0.27567920088768005,
0.31207361817359924,
-0.4833580553531647,
0.8659059405326843,
1.1686776876449585,
1.087145209312439,
0.3122788369655609,
0.7972758412361145,
0.1704424023628235,
-0.31476905941963196,
-0.23210278153419495,
-0.4166078269481659,
-1.4159562587738037,
-0.5872255563735962,
-0.1652923971414566,
-0.10587923973798752,
0.17316733300685883,
1.2238560914993286,
0.9040277600288391,
-0.34739285707473755,
-0.4655352532863617,
-0.021341482177376747,
0.15756237506866455,
-0.0009715193882584572,
-0.11467918753623962,
-0.3660469055175781,
-0.1992323100566864,
-0.2649342715740204,
0.5771275758743286,
0.6273373961448669,
0.0873747393488884,
-0.2835168242454529,
-0.3240458071231842,
-0.08129104226827621,
0.5940081477165222,
0.1662178784608841,
0.7456633448600769,
-0.26610803604125977,
-0.24010442197322845,
-0.11397605389356613,
0.19216670095920563,
0.31733599305152893,
1.1187114715576172,
-0.6207964420318604,
0.6657651662826538,
0.18352292478084564,
0.5747491121292114,
0.3737777769565582,
-0.015607502311468124,
0.6853463649749756,
-0.6646564602851868,
0.3036412000656128,
0.475139856338501,
0.16262073814868927,
0.481498658657074,
-0.15536943078041077,
0.37459173798561096,
0.23399057984352112,
-0.502512514591217,
-0.5280899405479431,
0.9583401679992676,
-1.1995047330856323,
0.0948321670293808,
1.1000679731369019,
0.029914341866970062,
0.3543660640716553,
-0.26470810174942017,
-0.48331472277641296,
-0.031100109219551086,
-0.5630136728286743,
0.7373975515365601,
0.6785345077514648,
-0.6719886064529419,
0.4041315019130707,
-0.22008006274700165,
0.575456440448761,
0.50356125831604,
-0.756493091583252,
-0.30236318707466125,
0.2546669542789459,
0.23627537488937378,
0.2422494739294052,
0.9440711736679077,
0.46098917722702026,
0.00870921928435564,
0.2703237235546112,
-0.6014711856842041,
0.02329816296696663,
-0.43473806977272034,
0.27855029702186584,
0.11507813632488251,
0.3555944263935089,
-0.22860071063041687
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06765v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06765v2
|
ConspEmoLLM: Conspiracy Theory Detection Using an Emotion-Based Large Language Model
| 2024-03-11T14:35:45 | 2024-05-17T03:04:40 |
Zhiwei Liu, Boyang Liu, Paul Thompson, Kailai Yang, Sophia Ananiadou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The internet has brought both benefits and harms to society. A prime example
of the latter is misinformation, including conspiracy theories, which flood the
web. Recent advances in natural language processing, particularly the emergence
of large language models (LLMs), have improved the prospects of accurate
misinformation detection. However, most LLM-based approaches to conspiracy
theory detection focus only on binary classification and fail to account for
the important relationship between misinformation and affective features (i.e.,
sentiment and emotions). Driven by a comprehensive analysis of conspiracy text
that reveals its distinctive affective features, we propose ConspEmoLLM, the
first open-source LLM that integrates affective information and is able to
perform diverse tasks relating to conspiracy theories. These tasks include not
only conspiracy theory detection, but also classification of theory type and
detection of related discussion (e.g., opinions towards theories). ConspEmoLLM
is fine-tuned based on an emotion-oriented LLM using our novel ConDID dataset,
which includes five tasks to support LLM instruction tuning and evaluation. We
demonstrate that when applied to these tasks, ConspEmoLLM largely outperforms
several open-source general domain LLMs and ChatGPT, as well as an LLM that has
been fine-tuned using ConDID, but which does not use affective features. This
project will be released on https://github.com/lzw108/ConspEmoLLM/.
|
[
-0.7524346709251404,
-1.020569086074829,
0.4956240952014923,
0.07317748665809631,
-0.3435984253883362,
-0.02028081566095352,
-0.5768101215362549,
-0.42894554138183594,
0.5091714262962341,
0.3842129409313202,
-0.7894331216812134,
-0.687369704246521,
-0.814232349395752,
0.12089169770479202,
-0.7848087549209595,
0.8138682842254639,
0.09272399544715881,
-0.07329591363668442,
-0.18126586079597473,
0.17469599843025208,
0.23856426775455475,
-0.5408485531806946,
-0.5205869674682617,
-0.14935383200645447,
0.4523283541202545,
0.7846366167068481,
0.6635869741439819,
0.23642607033252716,
0.8160107731819153,
0.23644110560417175,
0.11777666211128235,
0.14585213363170624,
-0.7690680027008057,
0.05903676897287369,
-0.20438876748085022,
-0.3642463684082031,
-0.049656473100185394,
-0.012136328034102917,
0.31434983015060425,
0.2490539252758026,
-0.294277548789978,
-0.10743939876556396,
-0.26095208525657654,
0.7327895760536194,
-0.8548592329025269,
-0.1555209755897522,
-0.694489598274231,
-0.09992864727973938,
-0.3004222512245178,
-0.04959499463438988,
-0.5311464071273804,
-0.6435524225234985,
0.07672654092311859,
-0.5303683280944824,
0.23473919928073883,
0.15255121886730194,
0.34623128175735474,
0.2621190547943115,
-0.5961649417877197,
-0.8487136960029602,
-0.6077536344528198,
0.5959394574165344,
-0.81459641456604,
0.4702323079109192,
-0.04333144798874855,
-0.1162010133266449,
-0.4603498876094818,
-0.4066009521484375,
-1.1629602909088135,
-0.07850702106952667,
-0.015199854969978333,
0.12935851514339447,
-0.5040338039398193,
0.09284596890211105,
0.3273385763168335,
0.42925745248794556,
-0.8466856479644775,
0.21530930697917938,
-0.06438535451889038,
-0.11962011456489563,
0.6453539133071899,
0.04761736840009689,
0.30275076627731323,
-0.14256422221660614,
-0.32957422733306885,
-0.06330449879169464,
-0.6801868081092834,
-0.26907482743263245,
0.5647915601730347,
-0.02363532967865467,
-0.3400718867778778,
0.5062593221664429,
-0.18628937005996704,
0.3828834593296051,
0.1475701630115509,
0.07370057702064514,
-0.004267021548002958,
0.4243015944957733,
-0.4887579679489136,
0.29752159118652344,
0.8459153771400452,
0.33788028359413147,
0.2516550123691559,
0.08130111545324326,
0.21667197346687317,
0.61369788646698,
0.23782944679260254,
-0.9746077060699463,
-0.2568560242652893,
0.2619039714336395,
-0.42005833983421326,
-0.28285151720046997,
0.1075567975640297,
-1.0570489168167114,
-0.7470082640647888,
-0.3835819363594055,
0.2658628225326538,
-0.58124840259552,
-0.4455299973487854,
0.2387201488018036,
-0.03818950802087784,
-0.08106037974357605,
0.43386951088905334,
-0.5341697335243225,
0.23462137579917908,
1.017815113067627,
0.7504015564918518,
-0.4455486536026001,
0.047098558396101,
-0.18710720539093018,
-0.008462026715278625,
-0.2885238230228424,
0.7031604051589966,
-0.7304894924163818,
-0.211962029337883,
0.29426050186157227,
0.028480123728513718,
0.128818541765213,
-0.06464936584234238,
0.6811671257019043,
-0.6380015015602112,
0.3910301923751831,
0.03750985860824585,
-1.014662504196167,
-0.4170106053352356,
0.404946893453598,
-0.6622880697250366,
0.5576887726783752,
-0.1992940455675125,
-0.927057683467865,
0.0417521633207798,
-0.742699921131134,
-0.5880753397941589,
-0.10125473141670227,
0.034848857671022415,
-0.44146764278411865,
0.2335454225540161,
-0.19862613081932068,
0.4540244936943054,
-0.26465100049972534,
0.15949182212352753,
-0.5455894470214844,
-0.22048434615135193,
0.46108803153038025,
-0.209011048078537,
0.4759807586669922,
0.3685503900051117,
-0.5057573318481445,
0.08785341680049896,
-0.5872876644134521,
-0.23685391247272491,
-0.10460133850574493,
-0.12286178022623062,
-0.4242866337299347,
0.0474446639418602,
-0.07680036127567291,
0.09726531058549881,
0.2611137926578522,
-0.5077077150344849,
0.0890544056892395,
-0.20622916519641876,
-0.18085452914237976,
0.6653033494949341,
0.1559653878211975,
0.33125486969947815,
-0.01597668044269085,
0.4821736216545105,
0.15223214030265808,
0.22261440753936768,
-0.10485450178384781,
-0.35327640175819397,
-1.3165334463119507,
-0.07934929430484772,
-0.45064109563827515,
0.519529402256012,
-0.5760797262191772,
0.40760424733161926,
0.11003393679857254,
-0.7676518559455872,
-0.18744198977947235,
-0.12433435022830963,
0.4497315287590027,
0.25857803225517273,
0.24902381002902985,
0.22665603458881378,
-0.6429446339607239,
-0.8444114923477173,
-0.4951590299606323,
0.0425768680870533,
0.18543905019760132,
-0.09393787384033203,
0.33151698112487793,
-0.18578040599822998,
0.5767688155174255,
-0.6288334131240845,
-0.13751477003097534,
-0.000876762205734849,
0.3716888725757599,
0.4117927849292755,
0.34924957156181335,
0.2911461591720581,
-0.8684849739074707,
-0.48707839846611023,
-0.08718609064817429,
-0.5901259183883667,
0.023529091849923134,
0.1266799122095108,
-0.04816674813628197,
0.38535255193710327,
0.4750717878341675,
-0.8902754187583923,
0.2664262056350708,
0.7171461582183838,
-0.542354941368103,
0.4366665780544281,
0.1688251942396164,
0.5309474468231201,
-1.1060073375701904,
-0.09377715736627579,
0.26518720388412476,
-0.13441292941570282,
-0.9146766662597656,
0.03748999536037445,
0.19751258194446564,
-0.05965467169880867,
-0.7435206174850464,
0.12746521830558777,
-0.3993220627307892,
0.35000136494636536,
-0.448740154504776,
0.2157311588525772,
-0.36258986592292786,
0.382427841424942,
0.05459033325314522,
0.16009418666362762,
0.49208179116249084,
-0.5708522200584412,
0.34474730491638184,
0.08875971287488937,
-0.4918990433216095,
0.7368253469467163,
0.036232274025678635,
0.36908239126205444,
-0.10782045125961304,
-0.0156398918479681,
-0.783382773399353,
-0.6139777898788452,
0.4865196943283081,
-0.30323854088783264,
0.3150409162044525,
-0.12375642359256744,
-0.2304476946592331,
-0.19683267176151276,
-0.252597838640213,
0.014493542723357677,
0.5489540100097656,
-0.39566895365715027,
0.5980224609375,
0.35077622532844543,
0.11068380624055862,
-0.23000001907348633,
-0.4452780485153198,
0.1555868536233902,
-0.4168666899204254,
-0.5796827077865601,
0.021174145862460136,
-0.21513603627681732,
-0.49877309799194336,
-0.08006757497787476,
-0.11320675909519196,
0.0912117213010788,
0.13809220492839813,
0.634225606918335,
-0.10758665204048157,
-0.06867296248674393,
0.24398697912693024,
-0.020973868668079376,
0.1255846619606018,
0.16081801056861877,
-0.1876756101846695,
0.42861297726631165,
0.020842980593442917,
-0.4516720473766327,
-0.5258690714836121,
0.395010769367218,
0.6775603890419006,
0.150542750954628,
0.6395378112792969,
0.3558213412761688,
-0.5931349396705627,
-0.6399339437484741,
-0.6696266531944275,
-0.3261411190032959,
-0.44251081347465515,
0.2887357473373413,
0.0332367829978466,
-1.301318645477295,
0.1146375834941864,
-0.42088890075683594,
-0.26072707772254944,
0.44586145877838135,
0.615169107913971,
-0.1308094710111618,
0.7416390776634216,
0.6636430621147156,
-0.1366560012102127,
0.5866068005561829,
-0.06503850966691971,
0.20580896735191345,
-0.4847719073295593,
-0.21936458349227905,
-0.5307057499885559,
-0.5756065845489502,
-0.5895249843597412,
-0.25855162739753723,
0.33405327796936035,
0.10874197632074356,
-0.2374264895915985,
0.05718259885907173,
-0.4807756543159485,
0.5800149440765381,
0.38099148869514465,
0.1386553943157196,
0.31791505217552185,
0.004284538794308901,
0.4790530204772949,
0.08219186961650848,
-0.3945164978504181,
-0.5214358568191528,
0.8684377074241638,
0.1380382776260376,
0.8451881408691406,
0.3918098509311676,
0.4280097186565399,
0.6414077877998352,
0.6514760851860046,
-0.7058708071708679,
0.6425283551216125,
-0.4668157994747162,
-0.3998783528804779,
-0.22948390245437622,
-0.29888442158699036,
-0.6349104642868042,
0.02740744687616825,
-0.41701045632362366,
-0.7355995178222656,
0.23927035927772522,
0.3504610061645508,
0.07631829380989075,
0.4069922864437103,
-0.5750269293785095,
0.7693551778793335,
-0.17452582716941833,
-0.05437951907515526,
-0.826010525226593,
-0.2982672452926636,
0.7847558856010437,
-0.15846624970436096,
0.3913481831550598,
-0.3536335527896881,
0.150807723402977,
0.6319528818130493,
-0.2913338840007782,
0.9288350343704224,
-0.16999007761478424,
-0.13533344864845276,
0.107937753200531,
0.5921316146850586,
0.7049159407615662,
-0.0008188607171177864,
-0.3465844392776489,
0.23281410336494446,
-0.3454981744289398,
0.1171208918094635,
-0.5256849527359009,
0.9826574325561523,
-0.6026466488838196,
-0.7001005411148071,
-0.29881006479263306,
-0.4893637001514435,
0.05246654152870178,
0.1788996160030365,
0.2744532525539398,
0.1382150501012802,
-0.4653192460536957,
0.27778753638267517,
0.838947594165802,
-0.04115504026412964,
0.3613060712814331,
0.8152679800987244,
-0.22966615855693817,
-0.30569037795066833,
0.7238923907279968,
-0.28927314281463623,
0.2214253842830658,
0.5028645396232605,
0.25711897015571594,
0.07347249984741211,
-0.6236415505409241,
-0.11128164082765579,
-0.056836504489183426,
-0.8289135098457336,
-0.3420325219631195,
-0.7992320656776428,
0.13198596239089966,
-0.2738826274871826,
-0.17161762714385986,
-0.18409115076065063,
-0.33491432666778564,
-0.3668261170387268,
0.0004069733840879053,
0.7176424860954285,
0.7485001683235168,
0.061410583555698395,
0.6885656714439392,
-0.391416996717453,
0.4037857949733734,
0.02583385817706585,
0.3036534786224365,
-0.31778839230537415,
-0.3885191082954407,
-0.5090671181678772,
0.1380927711725235,
-0.38918495178222656,
-1.0670191049575806,
0.3410691022872925,
0.16446194052696228,
0.0028237069491297007,
0.8322967886924744,
0.35064035654067993,
0.322601318359375,
-0.1077590063214302,
0.7911515831947327,
0.3087882399559021,
-1.1556378602981567,
0.524793267250061,
-0.1297498196363449,
-0.03852556645870209,
0.14433623850345612,
0.61619633436203,
-0.7655710577964783,
-0.7227216958999634,
-0.5526835918426514,
-0.3088676333427429,
0.9018447995185852,
0.05211295560002327,
-0.055426351726055145,
-0.3406431972980499,
0.29032471776008606,
0.20006603002548218,
0.25780412554740906,
-0.5625689625740051,
-0.12892793118953705,
-0.12438540160655975,
-0.48735108971595764,
-0.02687527798116207,
-0.34404653310775757,
-0.06006134673953056,
0.21686600148677826,
0.888901948928833,
-0.22051136195659637,
-0.017023568972945213,
0.19323524832725525,
-0.32043272256851196,
-0.44628891348838806,
0.2799135446548462,
0.6849418878555298,
0.4495393633842468,
-0.07273716479539871,
0.5520807504653931,
0.11427924782037735,
-0.4632211923599243,
0.11932411044836044,
-0.055958833545446396,
-0.17785421013832092,
0.07479933649301529,
0.5292316675186157,
0.830266535282135,
0.31131649017333984,
-0.4972524046897888,
0.6480916142463684,
0.04272875934839249,
-0.09538071602582932,
-0.4575503170490265,
0.27476030588150024,
0.2051999866962433,
0.5661289095878601,
0.37046241760253906,
-0.0356954000890255,
0.31824398040771484,
-0.46230292320251465,
0.15903259813785553,
0.6666470170021057,
-0.287165105342865,
-0.4738192856311798,
0.31050729751586914,
0.2133292853832245,
-0.40518078207969666,
0.4164785146713257,
-0.23829223215579987,
-0.7787283658981323,
0.6903343796730042,
0.402576208114624,
1.0494632720947266,
-0.5927615165710449,
0.2551877498626709,
0.273193895816803,
0.5161882042884827,
-0.04638764262199402,
0.41456493735313416,
0.29873743653297424,
-0.7940983772277832,
-0.16534891724586487,
-0.43839702010154724,
-0.6941298246383667,
0.19047202169895172,
-0.1758676916360855,
0.5470052361488342,
-0.49527275562286377,
0.15264295041561127,
-0.13698551058769226,
-0.16580556333065033,
-0.6236134767532349,
0.3063783347606659,
0.28660619258880615,
1.0154712200164795,
-0.6575660705566406,
0.6834964156150818,
0.50639808177948,
0.10198014229536057,
-0.47934579849243164,
0.1652674823999405,
0.39420753717422485,
-0.30861803889274597,
0.3189812898635864,
0.3474850058555603,
-0.1422446370124817,
0.09309816360473633,
-0.8507315516471863,
-0.7822864055633545,
0.7893919944763184,
0.6188792586326599,
-1.0956698656082153,
0.3769291341304779,
0.2415752112865448,
0.3353579640388489,
-0.4805944859981537,
0.20038582384586334,
0.396666944026947,
0.6404734253883362,
0.15283285081386566,
-0.35844141244888306,
0.19289985299110413,
-0.11387981474399567,
-0.5360033512115479,
0.6104260683059692,
-0.679064929485321,
0.8155397176742554,
0.07394769787788391,
-0.42040568590164185,
-0.3940851390361786,
0.6232157349586487,
-0.15473227202892303,
0.6580661535263062,
0.7163249254226685,
0.8615226745605469,
0.761755645275116,
-0.14631250500679016,
0.8801338076591492,
-0.5513787269592285,
0.44626739621162415,
0.9421442747116089,
-0.2919619381427765,
0.6630458235740662,
0.4788197875022888,
-0.03518059849739075,
0.7198091745376587,
0.5152842402458191,
0.09714913368225098,
0.36987847089767456,
0.4109530746936798,
-0.45065996050834656,
-0.37539225816726685,
0.06423772871494293,
-0.12629707157611847,
0.28627800941467285,
0.5915640592575073,
-0.161356121301651,
-0.12492987513542175,
0.13191308081150055,
0.26384177803993225,
0.10484019666910172,
-0.367257684469223,
0.8203057646751404,
0.18595506250858307,
-0.5789352655410767,
0.21427682042121887,
0.013267949223518372,
0.8172709941864014,
-0.6937173008918762,
0.05351376160979271,
-0.34329837560653687,
0.30924171209335327,
-0.4735356271266937,
-0.7362345457077026,
0.3200635612010956,
0.19673413038253784,
-0.21714435517787933,
0.12268638610839844,
0.7979532480239868,
-0.660650372505188,
-0.4915028214454651,
0.34381189942359924,
0.07695513963699341,
0.12260475009679794,
-0.40809786319732666,
-0.1945732980966568,
0.5698262453079224,
-0.02249688282608986,
-0.5526341199874878,
0.014622291550040245,
0.8153154850006104,
-0.07031524181365967,
0.5695706009864807,
0.8612411618232727,
-0.14364175498485565,
-0.19130884110927582,
-0.11923777312040329,
0.9030827283859253,
-0.6884371638298035,
-0.44604095816612244,
-1.226542592048645,
0.446010023355484,
-0.213119775056839,
-0.17823265492916107,
0.7053644061088562,
0.6552014946937561,
0.5933300256729126,
-0.18358270823955536,
0.827704906463623,
-0.13581512868404388,
0.5162839293479919,
-0.6045578718185425,
0.6546614766120911,
-0.3783946633338928,
-0.03826778754591942,
-0.5893113613128662,
-0.9001829624176025,
-0.38377106189727783,
0.24672265350818634,
-0.16211174428462982,
-0.3867674171924591,
0.7066866755485535,
0.8718510270118713,
-0.22312529385089874,
0.40726494789123535,
0.27617505192756653,
0.524088442325592,
0.38947683572769165,
0.7162737250328064,
0.9996950030326843,
0.06436287611722946,
0.38532257080078125,
-0.26425087451934814,
-0.40117669105529785,
-0.6699145436286926,
-1.1796377897262573,
-1.0006940364837646,
-0.4306051433086395,
-0.4553866684436798,
-0.1817275881767273,
-0.012094588950276375,
0.9854066371917725,
0.5395237803459167,
-0.9093756079673767,
-0.1401483714580536,
-0.24940598011016846,
0.4702698588371277,
0.207112655043602,
-0.24119627475738525,
0.44102153182029724,
-0.1347370445728302,
-0.6192576289176941,
0.496697336435318,
0.405550479888916,
-0.1415487825870514,
-0.26052480936050415,
-0.2986416220664978,
-0.26204636693000793,
0.4450244903564453,
0.46929123997688293,
0.1265440583229065,
-0.5928544998168945,
-0.450042724609375,
-0.22956402599811554,
0.03299607336521149,
-0.2875705659389496,
0.9404523372650146,
-0.39360311627388,
0.2750576138496399,
0.24784722924232483,
0.38751110434532166,
0.5358595848083496,
-0.17507313191890717,
0.325982004404068,
-0.4990244507789612,
0.23499919474124908,
0.10266595333814621,
0.34133222699165344,
0.3454667627811432,
-0.6750848293304443,
0.256920725107193,
0.23755662143230438,
-0.5031315684318542,
-0.6366654634475708,
0.32711735367774963,
-0.9739292860031128,
-0.3167678117752075,
0.987188458442688,
0.07368898391723633,
-0.13093462586402893,
0.1888066977262497,
-0.21288125216960907,
0.3923135995864868,
-0.535237193107605,
0.9909573197364807,
0.6301908493041992,
-0.13201360404491425,
-0.2612954378128052,
0.0018953648395836353,
0.7934980392456055,
0.05141095444560051,
-1.1753125190734863,
0.10216114670038223,
0.8194448351860046,
0.006726096384227276,
0.19367551803588867,
0.2647470235824585,
0.35346999764442444,
0.30710265040397644,
-0.4517667889595032,
0.44861191511154175,
-0.102155402302742,
-0.14591991901397705,
-0.23213784396648407,
0.4318942725658417,
-0.3688041865825653,
-0.004058915190398693
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06764v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06764v2
|
An Image is Worth 1/2 Tokens After Layer 2: Plug-and-Play Inference Acceleration for Large Vision-Language Models
| 2024-03-11T14:35:32 | 2024-03-25T13:29:30 |
Liang Chen, Haozhe Zhao, Tianyu Liu, Shuai Bai, Junyang Lin, Chang Zhou, Baobao Chang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
In this study, we identify the inefficient attention phenomena in Large
Vision-Language Models (LVLMs), notably within prominent models like LLaVA-1.5,
QwenVL-Chat and Video-LLaVA. We find out that the attention computation over
visual tokens is of extreme inefficiency in the deep layers of popular LVLMs,
suggesting a need for a sparser approach compared to textual data handling. To
this end, we introduce FastV, a versatile plug-and-play method designed to
optimize computational efficiency by learning adaptive attention patterns in
early layers and pruning visual tokens in subsequent ones. Our evaluations
demonstrate FastV's ability to dramatically reduce computational costs (e.g., a
45 reduction in FLOPs for LLaVA-1.5-13B) without sacrificing performance in a
wide range of image and video understanding tasks. The computational efficiency
and performance trade-off of FastV are highly customizable and
pareto-efficient. It can compress the FLOPs of a 13B-parameter model to achieve
a lower budget than that of a 7B-parameter model, while still maintaining
superior performance. We believe FastV has practical values for deployment of
LVLMs in edge devices and commercial models. Code is released at
https://github.com/pkunlp-icler/FastV.
|
[
-0.24237988889217377,
-0.678059458732605,
0.5222620964050293,
0.3190556466579437,
-0.41532647609710693,
-0.050810717046260834,
-0.06876452267169952,
-0.47198769450187683,
-0.11428768932819366,
0.517685055732727,
-0.3586040437221527,
-0.11994051933288574,
-0.5332476496696472,
-0.552122175693512,
-0.43614083528518677,
0.32660794258117676,
0.2070969194173813,
-0.07103917002677917,
-0.4591396450996399,
-0.21478025615215302,
-0.3670808970928192,
0.023205813020467758,
-0.8780484795570374,
-0.043650396168231964,
0.6412097215652466,
0.43570607900619507,
0.7171355485916138,
0.9161702990531921,
0.8095444440841675,
0.23675234615802765,
-0.11541269719600677,
0.25967514514923096,
-0.6079419255256653,
-0.13711358606815338,
-0.031220512464642525,
-0.36950722336769104,
-0.3982674181461334,
-0.20844636857509613,
0.6200915575027466,
0.38967597484588623,
0.08336307853460312,
0.48217839002609253,
-0.1436779797077179,
0.980026364326477,
-0.9408357739448547,
0.27014613151550293,
-0.6353093385696411,
0.11335127055644989,
-0.343327134847641,
-0.06478085368871689,
-0.5826794505119324,
-0.01670663245022297,
0.1945207417011261,
-0.7523165941238403,
0.05115242302417755,
0.1204724833369255,
0.7523040175437927,
0.6270119547843933,
-0.08038268238306046,
0.3121514916419983,
-0.5660524964332581,
0.8087747693061829,
-0.5242552161216736,
0.5534757971763611,
-0.05463726446032524,
0.26082947850227356,
-0.11362262070178986,
-1.0775552988052368,
-0.4767870306968689,
0.13277167081832886,
0.174717977643013,
0.04689999297261238,
-0.2083364725112915,
0.14903102815151215,
0.5373925566673279,
0.2652047574520111,
-0.32501840591430664,
0.3530091345310211,
-0.25231119990348816,
-0.12644244730472565,
0.4347441494464874,
0.11845714598894119,
-0.02071794494986534,
0.13789810240268707,
-0.4187060296535492,
-0.09324667602777481,
-0.8672848343849182,
0.4891505837440491,
0.1301567554473877,
0.00176264438778162,
-0.1211317777633667,
0.4101930558681488,
-0.0912744402885437,
0.886812686920166,
0.09373515099287033,
-0.4459327757358551,
0.23598580062389374,
-0.3084704577922821,
-0.5015646815299988,
-0.18724758923053741,
0.5588214993476868,
0.46581217646598816,
0.29168424010276794,
0.01888156495988369,
-0.07853671908378601,
0.11055820435285568,
0.10059382766485214,
-1.0608865022659302,
-0.17430955171585083,
0.39577311277389526,
-0.6521322131156921,
-0.22331540286540985,
-0.4028967618942261,
-0.735397219657898,
-0.5712125897407532,
-0.2737712562084198,
0.4789057970046997,
-0.1269741654396057,
-0.17511503398418427,
0.16967670619487762,
-0.07743325084447861,
0.5284290313720703,
0.565083384513855,
-0.6375612020492554,
0.30333977937698364,
0.7050126194953918,
0.9977962374687195,
-0.22892558574676514,
-0.11978131532669067,
-1.0954469442367554,
-0.20024533569812775,
-0.5552099347114563,
0.6786874532699585,
-0.3889580965042114,
-0.01566573604941368,
-0.007073852699249983,
-0.02315213531255722,
0.1206010952591896,
-0.4709925651550293,
0.4078558087348938,
-0.6308133602142334,
-0.15657778084278107,
-0.14919768273830414,
-0.43664705753326416,
-0.10044742375612259,
-0.11344342678785324,
-0.7858871817588806,
1.0591284036636353,
-0.015824468806385994,
-0.9604659676551819,
0.411319375038147,
-0.6086251139640808,
-0.47820696234703064,
0.3391374349594116,
0.015187175944447517,
-0.4456597566604614,
0.21786947548389435,
0.2689181864261627,
0.6336668729782104,
-0.4831344485282898,
0.110556460916996,
-0.22844630479812622,
-0.808099627494812,
0.1210908442735672,
-0.10965248197317123,
0.6894627213478088,
0.22440510988235474,
-0.46679455041885376,
0.2583385407924652,
-0.8958082795143127,
-0.1544293910264969,
0.25890207290649414,
-0.15144111216068268,
-0.397446870803833,
0.3016885817050934,
-0.027251752093434334,
0.20734478533267975,
-0.003924626857042313,
-0.5238513946533203,
0.07333111763000488,
-0.540550708770752,
0.6666610240936279,
0.7691687941551208,
-0.25633832812309265,
0.5440533757209778,
0.4292440116405487,
0.3744368851184845,
0.18191510438919067,
0.47617822885513306,
-0.6447712779045105,
-0.6102651357650757,
-0.9094990491867065,
-0.6234865188598633,
0.25853073596954346,
0.5005196928977966,
-1.0786298513412476,
-0.18687567114830017,
-0.14268089830875397,
-0.2618330121040344,
-0.7405861020088196,
0.19432246685028076,
0.5787650346755981,
0.6064762473106384,
0.15299944579601288,
-0.4692550599575043,
-0.23672670125961304,
-1.1010239124298096,
-0.29629942774772644,
-0.09125113487243652,
0.02574268728494644,
0.535978376865387,
0.21971480548381805,
0.0975056067109108,
0.6637603640556335,
-0.43263694643974304,
-0.16416558623313904,
-0.0758991688489914,
-0.2798019051551819,
0.026742855086922646,
0.3319983184337616,
0.5069898366928101,
-0.7515354156494141,
-0.31428593397140503,
0.1319042295217514,
-0.47878292202949524,
0.27590230107307434,
-0.22642318904399872,
-0.07744161039590836,
0.21533933281898499,
0.6252803206443787,
-0.6937021613121033,
0.5965632200241089,
0.3288913071155548,
-0.3708094358444214,
0.3384530544281006,
-0.22170108556747437,
-0.013348243199288845,
-0.4652675986289978,
0.03607386350631714,
0.1851816028356552,
-0.4035872220993042,
-0.6268883943557739,
0.3197084367275238,
0.4046679437160492,
-0.007709532510489225,
-1.1048998832702637,
0.8072763085365295,
-0.39150863885879517,
-0.4606935381889343,
-0.11769186705350876,
0.11569219827651978,
0.26287227869033813,
0.6194251179695129,
-0.14498305320739746,
0.9396602511405945,
0.963313639163971,
-0.6390191912651062,
0.4438239336013794,
-0.014218670316040516,
-0.5892217755317688,
0.20963545143604279,
-0.781470775604248,
0.22089551389217377,
-0.25819164514541626,
-0.04185480251908302,
-1.0563801527023315,
-0.20825214684009552,
0.16966228187084198,
-0.25125250220298767,
0.3435421288013458,
-0.176312655210495,
-0.6467006206512451,
-0.361551433801651,
-0.3594617545604706,
0.7671565413475037,
0.7934409976005554,
-0.8274758458137512,
0.5709582567214966,
0.5374531149864197,
0.1917773336172104,
-0.6711446642875671,
-0.8265232443809509,
0.138111412525177,
-0.13574038445949554,
-0.7332209348678589,
0.24715612828731537,
0.13401173055171967,
-0.2517167031764984,
-0.04744347557425499,
0.21016031503677368,
-0.004081892780959606,
0.11199747771024704,
0.09018537402153015,
0.2037593275308609,
-0.22407592833042145,
0.2072550505399704,
-0.3419691026210785,
0.03510152921080589,
0.03465421870350838,
-0.6739209294319153,
0.1429014503955841,
-0.12526044249534607,
-0.10338398814201355,
-0.4940032362937927,
0.1648479700088501,
0.9058439135551453,
-0.585038959980011,
0.4378889799118042,
0.7160927653312683,
-0.27603885531425476,
-0.21063582599163055,
-0.6877713799476624,
0.14787335693836212,
-0.4971356987953186,
0.5782367587089539,
-0.23501355946063995,
-0.8055786490440369,
0.5361567139625549,
0.03970767557621002,
0.2239353358745575,
0.22747401893138885,
0.6831668019294739,
0.04181523993611336,
0.9557438492774963,
0.6114744544029236,
0.2324771285057068,
0.8031604886054993,
-0.2577400207519531,
0.2996100187301636,
-0.7832936644554138,
-0.41917797923088074,
0.018102796748280525,
-0.42592957615852356,
-0.46457499265670776,
-0.9607657194137573,
0.2459266632795334,
-0.33441200852394104,
-0.22969871759414673,
-0.039032962173223495,
-0.5637630224227905,
0.6269477605819702,
0.5705231428146362,
0.19149911403656006,
-0.05658549442887306,
0.16748777031898499,
0.17701806128025055,
-0.1492508351802826,
-0.9147736430168152,
0.10868151485919952,
0.9444486498832703,
0.6468481421470642,
0.8757742047309875,
-0.20437106490135193,
0.0923982486128807,
0.22801987826824188,
-0.025061028078198433,
-1.0746155977249146,
0.6543685793876648,
-0.3063719868659973,
-0.20033259689807892,
-0.22279983758926392,
-0.21866591274738312,
-0.6758685111999512,
0.27961239218711853,
-0.005243359133601189,
-0.6296194195747375,
0.39575761556625366,
0.559906542301178,
-0.4984351098537445,
0.32466909289360046,
-0.8653916716575623,
1.0506110191345215,
-0.2852177321910858,
-1.1234550476074219,
-0.35644885897636414,
-0.6858323216438293,
0.7024039030075073,
0.038893282413482666,
0.1889013946056366,
0.08649807423353195,
-0.17725637555122375,
0.6627169251441956,
-0.3176032304763794,
0.6988050937652588,
-0.3824947774410248,
0.09049223363399506,
0.6218715310096741,
0.039202556014060974,
0.7424893379211426,
-0.011656819842755795,
0.27577537298202515,
-0.05401640385389328,
-0.35817649960517883,
-0.5637120604515076,
-0.6243178248405457,
0.6743443608283997,
-0.4292775094509125,
-0.4353792071342468,
-0.07281283289194107,
-0.5143097043037415,
0.04041534662246704,
0.10918418318033218,
-0.05410659685730934,
0.7045073509216309,
0.17237013578414917,
0.19995573163032532,
1.05711030960083,
-0.5205971598625183,
0.5611690282821655,
0.09239558130502701,
-0.1892063319683075,
-0.2365855872631073,
1.0862679481506348,
-0.03624630719423294,
0.45247507095336914,
0.27092090249061584,
0.10455098003149033,
-0.08506707847118378,
-0.5364702939987183,
-0.576697051525116,
0.1603081077337265,
-0.9257570505142212,
-0.16622072458267212,
-0.7260715961456299,
-0.0025658828672021627,
-0.11034290492534637,
-0.105531707406044,
-0.7809062004089355,
-0.4965478181838989,
-0.3250684142112732,
0.025638321414589882,
0.41874000430107117,
0.27070504426956177,
0.2293088734149933,
0.31321966648101807,
-0.3796589970588684,
0.3457801938056946,
0.39706161618232727,
0.4552227258682251,
0.26132726669311523,
-0.5028541684150696,
-0.6326520442962646,
-0.4749239981174469,
-0.12806834280490875,
-0.33879896998405457,
0.26462140679359436,
0.24464647471904755,
0.32604601979255676,
0.5857630372047424,
-0.38620275259017944,
0.9225233197212219,
-0.6695816516876221,
0.9024739265441895,
0.3430383503437042,
-0.9354663491249084,
0.30049026012420654,
0.0565275140106678,
0.4385754466056824,
0.2324455827474594,
-0.27840444445610046,
-0.19186723232269287,
-0.18299128115177155,
-0.5485617518424988,
-1.06867253780365,
0.6436625719070435,
0.13327735662460327,
-0.07663816958665848,
0.16276849806308746,
0.5417190194129944,
-0.10205229371786118,
0.17900492250919342,
-0.47553756833076477,
-0.18274474143981934,
-0.23409727215766907,
0.01801968924701214,
0.05896410718560219,
-0.3920007050037384,
0.14165844023227692,
-0.5280349254608154,
0.3537675738334656,
-0.3034881353378296,
0.44667115807533264,
0.27663615345954895,
-0.15201474726200104,
-0.007887977175414562,
-0.14779268205165863,
0.5919873714447021,
0.5902945399284363,
-0.10230626910924911,
0.25030964612960815,
0.0321543887257576,
-0.4801696240901947,
-0.018959632143378258,
-0.18839100003242493,
-0.22413522005081177,
-0.09804871678352356,
0.38466647267341614,
1.275608777999878,
0.26614677906036377,
-0.7843601703643799,
0.766568660736084,
-0.2290811687707901,
-0.2138073742389679,
0.009175214916467667,
-0.052714753895998,
0.10026733577251434,
0.4101082384586334,
0.05393857881426811,
0.22769729793071747,
0.3784715235233307,
-0.3070026934146881,
0.08713968098163605,
0.582628071308136,
-0.3859444856643677,
-0.2568453848361969,
0.8764879107475281,
0.3284832835197449,
-0.35652226209640503,
0.44468486309051514,
-0.1393461376428604,
-0.2937988042831421,
0.7938447594642639,
0.24671638011932373,
0.9324938058853149,
0.16317836940288544,
0.07301710546016693,
0.3290429413318634,
0.34587961435317993,
-0.10217242687940598,
0.2859070897102356,
-0.07593413442373276,
-0.34095498919487,
-0.9191592931747437,
-0.515666127204895,
-0.25892025232315063,
0.11854097247123718,
-0.3216625154018402,
0.36235830187797546,
-0.5035310983657837,
-0.045318543910980225,
0.11742629110813141,
-0.2816445231437683,
-1.1816520690917969,
0.2129947394132614,
0.350531667470932,
1.1368869543075562,
-0.5933694839477539,
0.9127103686332703,
0.4759086072444916,
0.024219369515776634,
-0.6747713088989258,
-0.22481492161750793,
-0.2706460952758789,
-0.8387948870658875,
0.8780468702316284,
0.28937533497810364,
-0.1624326854944229,
0.08355765044689178,
-0.6889316439628601,
-0.9536859393119812,
0.9428783655166626,
0.41726675629615784,
-0.7127566337585449,
-0.015163061209022999,
-0.25163036584854126,
0.3848048448562622,
-0.471337229013443,
0.3287539780139923,
0.6168251633644104,
0.3043231964111328,
0.2839580476284027,
-0.5745822787284851,
-0.044260431081056595,
-0.0761004388332367,
0.19489935040473938,
0.21218225359916687,
-0.9146586656570435,
0.8154181838035583,
-0.6153925061225891,
-0.19286687672138214,
-0.22303767502307892,
0.610409677028656,
-0.03642616048455238,
0.31029415130615234,
0.6077446937561035,
0.4851301312446594,
0.5327011346817017,
0.04408254101872444,
1.2046189308166504,
-0.2370963990688324,
0.1302156001329422,
0.7967926263809204,
-0.14287427067756653,
0.6906118988990784,
0.8457872271537781,
-0.050423022359609604,
0.15379534661769867,
0.7108654975891113,
0.02921636402606964,
0.7521559596061707,
0.2017737179994583,
0.1415327787399292,
-0.42685920000076294,
-0.08006204664707184,
-0.058066271245479584,
0.296190470457077,
0.3211890161037445,
-0.31535524129867554,
0.19259370863437653,
0.08195523917675018,
-0.27503231167793274,
-0.49405786395072937,
-0.581951379776001,
0.6551446318626404,
0.10714010894298553,
-0.7578287124633789,
0.5573194026947021,
-0.28372281789779663,
0.2871716320514679,
-0.2719561755657196,
-0.19591712951660156,
-0.17100314795970917,
0.5807878971099854,
-0.2056625634431839,
-0.6803581714630127,
-0.10527543723583221,
0.016543997451663017,
-0.11082921177148819,
-0.0761028602719307,
0.82257479429245,
-0.2747228741645813,
-0.724706768989563,
0.2739728093147278,
0.24582849442958832,
0.1324751079082489,
0.024803385138511658,
-0.6197736263275146,
0.35928547382354736,
-0.09705601632595062,
-0.43273860216140747,
0.31675562262535095,
0.35587748885154724,
-0.17198851704597473,
0.7121068835258484,
0.6877882480621338,
0.08718476444482803,
0.1704133152961731,
0.2034226357936859,
1.063499093055725,
-0.40633824467658997,
-0.6217556595802307,
-0.9200761914253235,
0.9211280345916748,
-0.16041730344295502,
-0.15254735946655273,
0.4995606243610382,
0.4709905982017517,
0.6058784127235413,
-0.012252532877027988,
0.6192426085472107,
0.2327294647693634,
0.07342220097780228,
-0.6853188872337341,
0.30570703744888306,
-0.914694607257843,
0.2442147433757782,
-0.23928186297416687,
-0.792476236820221,
-0.5501481294631958,
0.43880337476730347,
-0.014302153140306473,
-0.49413585662841797,
0.6454496383666992,
0.6490874886512756,
-0.2553997337818146,
-0.43788817524909973,
0.4636193513870239,
0.2555379867553711,
0.42566320300102234,
0.7211172580718994,
0.6051879525184631,
-0.5488605499267578,
0.40995684266090393,
-0.14659583568572998,
-0.392503947019577,
-0.31958577036857605,
-1.0985760688781738,
-0.8910808563232422,
-0.23750466108322144,
-0.5652655363082886,
-0.3580904006958008,
0.18976670503616333,
0.6115608811378479,
0.7573978304862976,
-0.4466725289821625,
-0.04605831950902939,
-0.10218821465969086,
0.14203231036663055,
-0.3749086558818817,
-0.14756813645362854,
0.5837062001228333,
-0.28355732560157776,
-0.5601388812065125,
0.26663151383399963,
0.7507343292236328,
-0.19792428612709045,
-0.5453411340713501,
-0.09020669013261795,
-0.037896305322647095,
0.28192535042762756,
0.8944036960601807,
0.3119623064994812,
-0.9854705929756165,
-0.22007106244564056,
0.13113348186016083,
0.011929405853152275,
0.23666509985923767,
0.9345561265945435,
-1.0342955589294434,
0.8188862204551697,
0.5539904236793518,
0.8452965021133423,
0.8091173768043518,
-0.14587721228599548,
0.3245127201080322,
-0.671154797077179,
0.7753793597221375,
0.00707099586725235,
0.3985117971897125,
0.550443172454834,
-0.48021233081817627,
0.3353947103023529,
0.22674798965454102,
-0.6251513361930847,
-1.0204503536224365,
0.2729904055595398,
-0.991176426410675,
-0.10419178009033203,
1.1411681175231934,
-0.1644086390733719,
-0.6769824624061584,
0.2651618421077728,
-0.17749837040901184,
-0.07537297159433365,
-0.31568366289138794,
0.38021913170814514,
0.39740467071533203,
-0.06171957403421402,
-0.5973827242851257,
-0.8040775060653687,
0.6320891380310059,
0.3571837246417999,
-0.5372916460037231,
0.2664768695831299,
0.31471025943756104,
0.015990883111953735,
-0.026242630556225777,
0.5540541410446167,
-0.036296166479587555,
0.5533867478370667,
0.01436298806220293,
0.07557627558708191,
-0.3040676712989807,
-0.5796469449996948,
-0.2892739772796631,
0.0807473361492157,
0.10961918532848358,
-0.38503342866897583
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06754v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06754v2
|
ALaRM: Align Language Models via Hierarchical Rewards Modeling
| 2024-03-11T14:28:40 | 2024-03-16T12:43:33 |
Yuhang Lai, Siyuan Wang, Shujun Liu, Xuanjing Huang, Zhongyu Wei
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
We introduce ALaRM, the first framework modeling hierarchical rewards in
reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF), which is designed to enhance
the alignment of large language models (LLMs) with human preferences. The
framework addresses the limitations of current alignment approaches, which
often struggle with the inconsistency and sparsity of human supervision
signals, by integrating holistic rewards with aspect-specific rewards. This
integration enables more precise and consistent guidance of language models
towards desired outcomes, particularly in complex and open text generation
tasks. By employing a methodology that filters and combines multiple rewards
based on their consistency, the framework provides a reliable mechanism for
improving model alignment. We validate our approach through applications in
long-form question answering and machine translation tasks, employing
gpt-3.5-turbo for pairwise comparisons, and demonstrate improvements over
existing baselines. Our work underscores the effectiveness of hierarchical
rewards modeling in refining LLM training processes for better human preference
alignment. We release our code at https://ALaRM-fdu.github.io.
|
[
0.18890969455242157,
-0.5343960523605347,
0.5054997801780701,
0.107423797249794,
0.12847186625003815,
0.06291493773460388,
-0.37276291847229004,
-0.5432898998260498,
0.010001473128795624,
0.3663150370121002,
-0.676449716091156,
-0.5491257905960083,
-0.6046930551528931,
-0.1975375860929489,
-0.21952709555625916,
1.0699108839035034,
-0.11296446621417999,
-0.19380569458007812,
-0.16321435570716858,
0.21591055393218994,
-0.28526511788368225,
-0.5447023510932922,
-0.7635163068771362,
-0.5950887799263,
0.7057256102561951,
0.30771899223327637,
0.6065924167633057,
0.8546682596206665,
0.6027416586875916,
0.19893135130405426,
0.12234514206647873,
0.06962138414382935,
-0.4939724802970886,
0.2724824547767639,
-0.07604125887155533,
-0.1756785809993744,
-0.6325061917304993,
-0.22038769721984863,
0.5074092745780945,
0.5252112150192261,
-0.46367719769477844,
0.06162675842642784,
0.13171713054180145,
0.6488574147224426,
-0.7233961224555969,
0.42628639936447144,
-0.5427035689353943,
-0.08552786707878113,
-0.004815706051886082,
-0.26391950249671936,
-0.44885581731796265,
-0.42741987109184265,
0.01574155129492283,
-0.4992896616458893,
-0.17601779103279114,
0.26327553391456604,
0.9780547022819519,
0.5782643556594849,
-0.36217471957206726,
-0.22688136994838715,
-0.6508408188819885,
1.0151481628417969,
-0.7346742153167725,
0.321708619594574,
0.5425090193748474,
0.269975483417511,
-0.38920125365257263,
-0.22075021266937256,
-0.33191823959350586,
-0.25388815999031067,
-0.13786204159259796,
0.12953542172908783,
-0.16240006685256958,
0.22524307668209076,
-0.045981913805007935,
0.22787903249263763,
-0.6643359661102295,
0.38143596053123474,
0.10205142199993134,
-0.04757912829518318,
0.5125002861022949,
0.22689035534858704,
0.35671645402908325,
-0.04465551674365997,
-0.42432901263237,
-0.3002683222293854,
-0.6702744364738464,
0.37951794266700745,
0.496788889169693,
0.6936401128768921,
-0.3526057004928589,
0.37009140849113464,
-0.3862506151199341,
0.6802812814712524,
0.27637651562690735,
-0.4169788062572479,
0.12378503382205963,
-0.09708603471517563,
-0.11334586143493652,
0.4427056312561035,
0.9422357082366943,
0.42412713170051575,
-0.11335776001214981,
-0.048993416130542755,
-0.44750967621803284,
0.14616303145885468,
0.4246245324611664,
-0.5527512431144714,
-0.061497218906879425,
0.3975290060043335,
-0.41815420985221863,
-0.6274577975273132,
-0.19355499744415283,
-0.5364014506340027,
-0.39463505148887634,
-0.3578178286552429,
0.4175697863101959,
-0.18758328258991241,
-0.4819880723953247,
0.476636677980423,
0.28913232684135437,
0.08611131459474564,
0.23878495395183563,
-1.597399115562439,
0.33005544543266296,
1.1233710050582886,
0.5087249875068665,
-0.29355135560035706,
-0.3563552796840668,
-0.6928207278251648,
0.13287529349327087,
-0.22912926971912384,
0.6692802906036377,
-0.4457899332046509,
-0.09860292822122574,
0.342396080493927,
-0.18586623668670654,
-0.33408883213996887,
-0.3513314127922058,
0.7617632150650024,
-0.46225178241729736,
0.5226351022720337,
-0.10302751511335373,
-0.47561055421829224,
0.03612706810235977,
0.3409740626811981,
-0.36814218759536743,
1.2809839248657227,
0.2077925205230713,
-0.6635291576385498,
0.16891135275363922,
-0.8006863594055176,
-0.2923235595226288,
-0.07714583724737167,
-0.2238493412733078,
-0.6464918255805969,
-0.10760007798671722,
0.38044238090515137,
0.2924554646015167,
-0.31495562195777893,
0.5669106841087341,
-0.04991422966122627,
-0.09574900567531586,
0.03721341863274574,
-0.12662744522094727,
0.5330795645713806,
0.28986144065856934,
-0.5639117360115051,
0.8046905398368835,
-0.3942243754863739,
-0.008926238864660263,
0.06519105285406113,
-0.2645098865032196,
-0.21231259405612946,
0.2720949649810791,
-0.007750180084258318,
0.14156991243362427,
0.4949192702770233,
-0.3941250145435333,
0.29174649715423584,
-0.29978564381599426,
0.2487252801656723,
0.9404378533363342,
-0.07059584558010101,
0.31046393513679504,
-0.7265838980674744,
0.7121143341064453,
0.05217224359512329,
0.21362613141536713,
-0.15785405039787292,
-0.2931763529777527,
-0.42345142364501953,
-0.32664403319358826,
0.2222750037908554,
0.6043499708175659,
-0.2057449221611023,
0.8791226148605347,
-0.4545055031776428,
-0.13891108334064484,
-0.6012957692146301,
-0.053058382123708725,
0.5356505513191223,
0.4995870888233185,
0.29993897676467896,
-0.10886386781930923,
-0.6770147681236267,
-0.9069086313247681,
-0.01028680894523859,
-0.5701777338981628,
-0.0711657702922821,
-0.01496127899736166,
0.38344067335128784,
-0.1532425731420517,
0.8367178440093994,
-0.3611563742160797,
-0.08524194359779358,
-0.18127326667308807,
0.29803282022476196,
0.2424754798412323,
0.6086046099662781,
0.3778807818889618,
-0.5662364363670349,
-0.2623693645000458,
0.0762113705277443,
-0.7261940836906433,
-0.21644999086856842,
-0.2352273315191269,
-0.2596682608127594,
0.15161781013011932,
0.3857852518558502,
-0.41624704003334045,
0.035378724336624146,
0.6617456078529358,
-0.08030325919389725,
0.751740038394928,
0.2592296302318573,
0.3624408543109894,
-1.3267371654510498,
-0.12385378777980804,
-0.09293960779905319,
-0.2947145402431488,
-0.5812844634056091,
-0.12107914686203003,
0.09455413371324539,
0.11331213265657425,
-0.2864026427268982,
0.5763502717018127,
-0.21121110022068024,
0.11824918538331985,
-0.431433767080307,
-0.09647136926651001,
-0.2363351285457611,
0.7626338005065918,
0.24379687011241913,
0.8140425086021423,
0.5060377717018127,
-0.5010309219360352,
0.1105150580406189,
0.15749643743038177,
-0.5356906056404114,
0.5254993438720703,
-0.47675302624702454,
0.04773852974176407,
0.13263753056526184,
0.07014676183462143,
-0.8075040578842163,
-0.4887752830982208,
0.3672816753387451,
-0.5511338114738464,
0.2753692865371704,
-0.11425599455833435,
-0.3194463849067688,
-0.09576834738254547,
-0.2952851951122284,
0.3853326737880707,
0.5214938521385193,
-0.6816220283508301,
0.3736494481563568,
0.46797436475753784,
-0.3586033880710602,
-0.8946202993392944,
-0.21630936861038208,
-0.06268014758825302,
-0.24503563344478607,
-0.3740331530570984,
0.40035244822502136,
-0.023272067308425903,
-0.22253236174583435,
-0.035302773118019104,
-0.26973411440849304,
0.33048751950263977,
0.27912431955337524,
0.28276872634887695,
0.4648042619228363,
-0.3664151132106781,
0.2258601188659668,
0.03129246085882187,
-0.17735444009304047,
0.16168205440044403,
-0.7564935088157654,
0.4413285255432129,
-0.27786314487457275,
-0.5885708332061768,
-0.49248206615448,
0.4589427709579468,
0.48620298504829407,
-0.051269058138132095,
0.761506199836731,
0.37274953722953796,
-0.576790988445282,
0.056289076805114746,
-0.44373175501823425,
-0.32533469796180725,
-0.4394368827342987,
0.33830526471138,
-0.24577225744724274,
-1.2157632112503052,
0.25613129138946533,
0.2517138421535492,
0.29681041836738586,
0.256713330745697,
0.681813657283783,
0.027568425983190536,
1.4658104181289673,
0.8327741622924805,
-0.503162682056427,
0.7455604076385498,
0.38423648476600647,
0.4550000727176666,
-0.8578751087188721,
-0.10712116956710815,
-0.7043936848640442,
-0.1768169105052948,
-0.3037647604942322,
0.08573450893163681,
0.35951146483421326,
0.32723304629325867,
-0.5548255443572998,
0.32352522015571594,
-0.6333165168762207,
0.2718901038169861,
0.5483224987983704,
-0.0589413084089756,
0.17735497653484344,
-0.011211562901735306,
-0.1270887851715088,
0.08333917707204819,
-0.623008131980896,
-0.7035161256790161,
0.8262516260147095,
0.3935489356517792,
0.9722533226013184,
0.26359301805496216,
0.8037397265434265,
0.2280454933643341,
0.3690280318260193,
-0.6613232493400574,
0.33661794662475586,
0.2509888708591461,
-0.32035186886787415,
-0.4504750669002533,
-0.49702632427215576,
-1.0151208639144897,
0.06037728488445282,
-0.1864054650068283,
-1.2212939262390137,
-0.0030773042235523462,
0.1822766661643982,
-0.6104149222373962,
0.2302791178226471,
-0.5295932292938232,
1.0842756032943726,
-0.5257323384284973,
-0.29703259468078613,
-0.024058856070041656,
-0.6202780604362488,
0.4493979811668396,
0.25099897384643555,
0.06742346286773682,
-0.4271130859851837,
0.19802504777908325,
0.7945848107337952,
-0.14292696118354797,
1.1049776077270508,
0.162955641746521,
-0.3672606647014618,
-0.03819884732365608,
-0.057907674461603165,
0.571373462677002,
-0.22055716812610626,
-0.005035349167883396,
-0.04077642410993576,
-0.05808980390429497,
-0.48053669929504395,
-0.4948546588420868,
0.6417384147644043,
-0.8964102268218994,
-0.6667537093162537,
-0.6204410791397095,
-0.8406208753585815,
-0.17283278703689575,
0.19736211001873016,
0.06661613285541534,
0.230952188372612,
-0.0446305051445961,
-0.03905882313847542,
0.7094649076461792,
0.007370898500084877,
0.15110249817371368,
0.48076382279396057,
-0.6298090815544128,
-0.4462268352508545,
0.6887983083724976,
-0.6173904538154602,
0.43833237886428833,
0.9616726040840149,
0.28774791955947876,
-0.46660158038139343,
-0.49824681878089905,
-0.33592164516448975,
-0.02779042348265648,
-0.5465773344039917,
-0.2451048493385315,
-0.7056765556335449,
-0.21209029853343964,
-0.8340198397636414,
-0.25534313917160034,
-0.22074854373931885,
-0.3989104628562927,
0.06939380615949631,
-0.17816314101219177,
0.38799768686294556,
0.6532593965530396,
-0.07472432404756546,
0.5076059103012085,
-0.8005629777908325,
0.14319957792758942,
0.25476035475730896,
0.17297309637069702,
-0.05560127645730972,
-0.42602649331092834,
-0.49729683995246887,
0.07448938488960266,
-0.28395554423332214,
-0.5412347912788391,
0.2690703272819519,
-0.1722496747970581,
0.5627156496047974,
0.4371706545352936,
0.27654504776000977,
0.4007875323295593,
-0.32135605812072754,
0.8443797826766968,
0.4505701959133148,
-0.8711754679679871,
0.5312951803207397,
-0.7261624336242676,
0.32096463441848755,
0.4770490527153015,
0.333885133266449,
-0.8473300337791443,
-0.4554649889469147,
-0.4293294847011566,
-0.8141421675682068,
0.7604807615280151,
0.027269775047898293,
-0.3458431661128998,
-0.1613561362028122,
0.07427582144737244,
-0.10766080021858215,
0.3119608461856842,
-0.8631574511528015,
0.07130999118089676,
-0.0423835813999176,
-0.7701252102851868,
0.12945333123207092,
-0.23015345633029938,
-0.3944968581199646,
0.07010158151388168,
1.0032808780670166,
-0.19047866761684418,
0.34186574816703796,
-0.11931456625461578,
-0.016893358901143074,
-0.5729820728302002,
0.627729594707489,
0.919222891330719,
0.36899903416633606,
-0.4289400279521942,
0.3086067736148834,
-0.23162151873111725,
-0.22602704167366028,
0.27957379817962646,
0.008042072877287865,
-0.12972283363342285,
-0.5268117785453796,
0.47817814350128174,
0.9658956527709961,
0.5507621765136719,
-0.5227175951004028,
0.2428695559501648,
-0.08634835481643677,
-0.12502887845039368,
-0.15900354087352753,
0.27243974804878235,
0.18566285073757172,
0.0389975942671299,
0.16375525295734406,
-0.12009546905755997,
-0.203472301363945,
-0.544769287109375,
0.1488485187292099,
0.3566305637359619,
-0.6729825735092163,
-0.27825549244880676,
0.8354083895683289,
0.033483780920505524,
-0.5036245584487915,
0.5041370987892151,
-0.23224741220474243,
-0.7960849404335022,
0.433414101600647,
0.7242463231086731,
1.2200205326080322,
-0.37244030833244324,
0.12241405248641968,
0.4725377857685089,
0.3407958447933197,
-0.36389219760894775,
0.06537050008773804,
-0.22091174125671387,
-0.9041182398796082,
-0.41475722193717957,
-0.8285824060440063,
-0.7180215120315552,
0.062498610466718674,
-0.7296191453933716,
-0.02037460170686245,
-0.03219909220933914,
0.0010548217687755823,
-0.024305690079927444,
-0.14281322062015533,
-0.04086679592728615,
-0.16005609929561615,
0.20126044750213623,
0.49600735306739807,
-0.8823289275169373,
1.054735541343689,
0.6151757836341858,
-0.4012109935283661,
-0.9281460642814636,
0.03734602406620979,
0.3376649022102356,
-0.76250821352005,
0.5380242466926575,
0.22713620960712433,
-0.5099427700042725,
-0.07455290108919144,
-0.44820889830589294,
-0.7991907596588135,
0.8226807117462158,
0.12892472743988037,
-0.5358908772468567,
-0.009930802509188652,
0.19752439856529236,
0.5312449932098389,
-0.8232733607292175,
0.16831927001476288,
0.6432813405990601,
0.4441434144973755,
-0.07806264609098434,
-0.8690482378005981,
-0.04100102186203003,
-0.388576865196228,
-0.1869809329509735,
0.5537652969360352,
-0.2771086096763611,
0.5413211584091187,
-0.11522927135229111,
-0.3103729486465454,
0.19006864726543427,
0.7542177438735962,
0.3733753561973572,
0.1542925387620926,
0.6823243498802185,
0.546765923500061,
0.8503970503807068,
-0.1794928014278412,
1.0651127099990845,
-0.4754367172718048,
0.3097817003726959,
1.418418049812317,
-0.6370398998260498,
0.9051791429519653,
0.3555459976196289,
-0.11915446817874908,
0.5804854035377502,
0.8368989825248718,
0.6046642065048218,
0.5444311499595642,
0.024594765156507492,
-0.3381807804107666,
-0.37451231479644775,
-0.3706206679344177,
-0.41709527373313904,
-0.005864262580871582,
0.29447707533836365,
0.13893666863441467,
-0.18491563200950623,
-0.19134627282619476,
0.03368929401040077,
0.3363187909126282,
-0.10205689072608948,
0.8815423250198364,
0.03706146776676178,
-1.1016387939453125,
0.661838710308075,
0.0061859204433858395,
0.6515334844589233,
-0.8859186172485352,
0.08298733830451965,
0.05600656941533089,
0.37713342905044556,
-0.16906940937042236,
-0.5913165211677551,
0.14480926096439362,
-0.003949714824557304,
-0.4995144307613373,
-0.5280072093009949,
0.41128021478652954,
-0.9194046854972839,
-0.1760285645723343,
0.2989237904548645,
0.15725967288017273,
-0.11954924464225769,
0.08466177433729172,
-0.8307164311408997,
0.02765214629471302,
0.02013743296265602,
-0.014863347634673119,
0.5515031814575195,
0.006871839053928852,
-0.2099708616733551,
0.48519423604011536,
0.8089590668678284,
-0.08588308095932007,
-0.05980205163359642,
0.23225726187229156,
0.37690308690071106,
-0.5964401960372925,
-0.778861403465271,
-0.7342647910118103,
0.4094776511192322,
-0.012412335723638535,
-0.2595708668231964,
0.5545057654380798,
0.6716980934143066,
0.7979128956794739,
-0.03289812058210373,
0.7318844795227051,
0.17118504643440247,
0.621803879737854,
-0.7160892486572266,
0.45762744545936584,
-0.38713255524635315,
0.46975457668304443,
-0.22363601624965668,
-0.7775413990020752,
-0.29679855704307556,
0.5301649570465088,
-0.4305441081523895,
-0.1689906120300293,
0.9049396514892578,
1.075008511543274,
0.06314489990472794,
0.13776922225952148,
0.3094938099384308,
-0.07468719035387039,
0.5249701142311096,
0.8463043570518494,
1.12871515750885,
-0.27097490429878235,
0.20984242856502533,
-0.23784218728542328,
-0.24738192558288574,
-0.34092578291893005,
-1.06266188621521,
-0.6284288167953491,
-0.6602493524551392,
-0.47909069061279297,
-0.3214898705482483,
0.22248093783855438,
1.5519601106643677,
0.8020686507225037,
-1.0910764932632446,
-0.6906219124794006,
0.006496776826679707,
0.5108006596565247,
-0.8044321537017822,
-0.18983711302280426,
0.5181440711021423,
-0.700575053691864,
-0.6372807621955872,
0.5691434741020203,
0.5391086339950562,
-0.08377284556627274,
-0.0017429421423003078,
-0.28128781914711,
-0.28642624616622925,
0.00996914878487587,
0.36591652035713196,
0.46547192335128784,
-0.7662277221679688,
-0.7036076784133911,
0.05868074670433998,
-0.5802236199378967,
0.20020441710948944,
0.8515188694000244,
-0.4299255609512329,
0.07901864498853683,
0.4431351125240326,
0.8627100586891174,
0.09641380608081818,
0.11134607344865799,
0.6304407119750977,
-0.7419186234474182,
0.03831262141466141,
0.11315906792879105,
0.40874460339546204,
0.303489625453949,
-0.5792785286903381,
0.5151290893554688,
-0.29297542572021484,
-0.840075671672821,
-0.9781476855278015,
0.5369012951850891,
-1.0813803672790527,
0.03523843362927437,
0.855287492275238,
0.0008435592753812671,
-0.4117377996444702,
-0.07985489070415497,
0.023389989510178566,
0.1301879584789276,
-0.6686809062957764,
1.0481252670288086,
0.7418919801712036,
-0.10158966481685638,
-0.16392894089221954,
-0.35284027457237244,
0.7310887575149536,
0.7644159197807312,
-0.9484206438064575,
0.3265955150127411,
0.470547080039978,
-0.09073112905025482,
0.1653023511171341,
0.7494305372238159,
-0.10910042375326157,
0.42948269844055176,
-0.21916793286800385,
0.46186643838882446,
0.07686193287372589,
-0.34867212176322937,
-0.5983755588531494,
-0.014468835666775703,
0.2692820131778717,
-0.2372591644525528
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06745v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06745v1
|
ACT-MNMT Auto-Constriction Turning for Multilingual Neural Machine Translation
| 2024-03-11T14:10:57 | 2024-03-11T14:10:57 |
Shaojie Dai, Xin Liu, Ping Luo, Yue Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language model (LLM) has achieved promising performance in multilingual
machine translation tasks through zero/few-shot prompts or prompt-tuning.
However, due to the mixture of multilingual data during the pre-training of
LLM, the LLM-based translation models face the off-target issue in both
prompt-based methods, including a series of phenomena, namely instruction
misunderstanding, translation with wrong language and over-generation. For this
issue, this paper introduces an
\textbf{\underline{A}}uto-\textbf{\underline{C}}onstriction
\textbf{\underline{T}}urning mechanism for \textbf{\underline{M}}ultilingual
\textbf{\underline{N}}eural \textbf{\underline{M}}achine
\textbf{\underline{T}}ranslation (\model), which is a novel supervised
fine-tuning mechanism and orthogonal to the traditional prompt-based methods.
In this method, \model automatically constructs a constrained template in the
target side by adding trigger tokens ahead of the ground truth. Furthermore,
trigger tokens can be arranged and combined freely to represent different task
semantics, and they can be iteratively updated to maximize the label
likelihood. Experiments are performed on WMT test sets with multiple metrics,
and the experimental results demonstrate that \model achieves substantially
improved performance across multiple translation directions and reduce the
off-target phenomena in the translation.
|
[
-0.1943090856075287,
-0.8328590989112854,
0.531528890132904,
0.25114262104034424,
-0.5438811779022217,
0.049178630113601685,
-0.47027167677879333,
-0.055401574820280075,
0.049601417034864426,
0.5157199501991272,
-0.7742599248886108,
-0.5458276867866516,
-0.5651237964630127,
0.3418770730495453,
-0.2951907515525818,
0.8890257477760315,
-0.4271872937679291,
0.31511399149894714,
0.16430015861988068,
-0.34383684396743774,
-0.5830041766166687,
-0.6705945134162903,
-0.6799948215484619,
-0.39474043250083923,
0.7436078190803528,
0.2807483971118927,
0.5341407656669617,
0.735457181930542,
0.41008028388023376,
0.3691421151161194,
-0.03849655017256737,
0.4478275179862976,
-0.073838010430336,
0.29642507433891296,
0.07783204317092896,
-0.5955556631088257,
-0.527309000492096,
0.1700066328048706,
0.6154642105102539,
0.39287686347961426,
-0.08551330864429474,
0.06657841801643372,
0.03055076114833355,
0.2380792796611786,
-0.42199811339378357,
-0.1145281046628952,
-0.7149447798728943,
0.10750437527894974,
-0.19033050537109375,
-0.45857346057891846,
-0.6318151354789734,
-0.06899736076593399,
-0.42771875858306885,
-0.5563110709190369,
-0.024506986141204834,
0.2138669192790985,
0.5895281434059143,
0.584509551525116,
-0.5831035375595093,
-0.2478075921535492,
-0.6134402751922607,
0.8126446008682251,
-0.7008489966392517,
0.48091354966163635,
0.1506783366203308,
0.24568811058998108,
-0.21164079010486603,
-0.5303948521614075,
-0.5146777629852295,
-0.4272992014884949,
0.018539249897003174,
0.170417919754982,
0.022564342245459557,
0.05749575421214104,
0.248426154255867,
0.12927481532096863,
-0.5178738236427307,
0.40529805421829224,
-0.1733858436346054,
-0.1869954913854599,
0.37059286236763,
0.2895585894584656,
0.21156655251979828,
-0.04473215714097023,
-0.8028132319450378,
-0.12121894210577011,
-0.8281580209732056,
-0.1541699767112732,
0.39915668964385986,
0.4666620194911957,
-0.18729251623153687,
0.7749255895614624,
0.06687052547931671,
0.819922685623169,
0.41560471057891846,
0.14190424978733063,
0.25683653354644775,
-0.43620672821998596,
-0.19270914793014526,
0.03951071947813034,
1.0866152048110962,
0.3611660301685333,
0.15060675144195557,
-0.12824399769306183,
-0.38522616028785706,
-0.19451120495796204,
0.23115143179893494,
-0.866470456123352,
0.16567017138004303,
0.17519599199295044,
-0.24851900339126587,
-0.1235659196972847,
-0.29944831132888794,
-0.15439742803573608,
-0.14949378371238708,
-0.7042146325111389,
0.4619673192501068,
-0.5747257471084595,
-0.09964761137962341,
-0.15525229275226593,
0.3992132842540741,
0.10497087240219116,
0.0793248638510704,
-0.5762475728988647,
-0.11267656087875366,
0.3773742914199829,
0.8220623135566711,
-0.6398409605026245,
-0.6800574660301208,
-0.7419506311416626,
-0.058354638516902924,
-0.15588954091072083,
0.5704298615455627,
-0.2896742820739746,
-0.13378334045410156,
-0.06279652565717697,
0.18383611738681793,
-0.5862362384796143,
-0.41079267859458923,
0.4191606938838959,
-0.39714065194129944,
0.2906581461429596,
0.04621628671884537,
-0.3401446044445038,
-0.23069877922534943,
0.4836577773094177,
-0.4368925988674164,
0.9032080769538879,
-0.2591867446899414,
-0.3163268566131592,
0.25903329253196716,
-0.8161501288414001,
-0.5652679800987244,
-0.3676280975341797,
0.014328761957585812,
-0.46970003843307495,
0.23208647966384888,
0.2832861840724945,
0.40172338485717773,
-0.18462184071540833,
0.521580159664154,
-0.04580802097916603,
-0.1524113416671753,
0.7702127695083618,
-0.79095458984375,
0.6769471168518066,
0.22665579617023468,
-0.4179002046585083,
0.5803473591804504,
-0.7367984652519226,
-0.026748092845082283,
0.00824149139225483,
-0.2651228606700897,
-0.1998901665210724,
-0.41052424907684326,
0.12813256680965424,
0.8043975234031677,
0.24001869559288025,
-0.5903185606002808,
0.3020666539669037,
-0.2994380593299866,
0.48548686504364014,
0.494999498128891,
-0.027532879263162613,
0.33747076988220215,
-0.25713595747947693,
0.46682649850845337,
0.23774459958076477,
0.3896316587924957,
-0.2660438120365143,
-0.38979488611221313,
-0.8954582214355469,
-0.2641112804412842,
0.2809123396873474,
0.5830782651901245,
-0.7820131182670593,
0.364652156829834,
0.0656951442360878,
-0.2048170417547226,
-0.6322073340415955,
0.10296084731817245,
0.6804800629615784,
0.47648876905441284,
0.6998974680900574,
-0.1565960943698883,
-0.5025339722633362,
-0.7199702262878418,
-0.14263978600502014,
0.22801573574543,
0.221517413854599,
-0.045899152755737305,
0.2992353141307831,
-0.19568568468093872,
0.43803301453590393,
-0.17621426284313202,
-0.4309794008731842,
-0.26472073793411255,
0.44055959582328796,
0.21691225469112396,
0.6120479702949524,
0.1568027287721634,
-0.7592832446098328,
-0.5341618657112122,
-0.050672195851802826,
-0.5230938196182251,
-0.2986050546169281,
-0.3670913875102997,
-0.3020256757736206,
0.5841811895370483,
0.7571485638618469,
-0.8099170923233032,
0.3444770872592926,
0.4819500744342804,
-0.123160220682621,
0.5035213232040405,
-0.2351444661617279,
0.2960194945335388,
-1.3156380653381348,
0.1860961616039276,
-0.2532709836959839,
-0.09332297742366791,
-0.5231176614761353,
0.2299908995628357,
0.30438289046287537,
-0.055894531309604645,
-0.8215478658676147,
0.4680909514427185,
-0.5593104362487793,
0.19406288862228394,
-0.5503563284873962,
0.09195442497730255,
-0.05430199205875397,
0.8045322895050049,
-0.053222302347421646,
0.610769510269165,
0.2172023355960846,
-0.7397230267524719,
0.38044819235801697,
0.20242273807525635,
0.20265117287635803,
0.8223541975021362,
-0.3881787657737732,
0.2758004665374756,
0.21439196169376373,
0.13112083077430725,
-0.8800910711288452,
0.07221929728984833,
0.3528972566127777,
-0.5360239744186401,
0.59416663646698,
-0.24046802520751953,
-0.6827268004417419,
-0.27274763584136963,
0.059950798749923706,
0.6116697788238525,
0.16119369864463806,
-0.3862672448158264,
0.5866941809654236,
-0.008423120714724064,
0.0675908625125885,
-0.37766969203948975,
-0.7679880261421204,
0.23201902210712433,
-0.26116520166397095,
-0.26168233156204224,
0.3191533386707306,
-0.20068132877349854,
0.06075798720121384,
-0.3273966610431671,
0.08049918711185455,
-0.11528421193361282,
-0.056391630321741104,
0.17929573357105255,
0.2711648643016815,
0.0014464645646512508,
0.18138910830020905,
0.27194786071777344,
-0.3969292640686035,
-0.05988844111561775,
-0.5085645914077759,
0.7565957307815552,
0.22342531383037567,
-0.6441996097564697,
-0.4322001338005066,
0.3358660042285919,
0.9034607410430908,
-0.5024054050445557,
0.6603972315788269,
0.9204838275909424,
-0.21931688487529755,
0.00024615004076622427,
-0.43176376819610596,
-0.31450164318084717,
-0.4192294478416443,
0.4198751449584961,
-0.5520798563957214,
-0.5883675217628479,
0.6089290380477905,
-0.0896141454577446,
0.12286427617073059,
0.46022236347198486,
0.768956184387207,
0.01797420345246792,
1.1897509098052979,
0.39188605546951294,
0.19062426686286926,
0.32567745447158813,
-0.21943745017051697,
0.04378102719783783,
-0.9745914936065674,
-0.24059800803661346,
-0.3911379873752594,
-0.5393410325050354,
-0.5560995936393738,
-0.3322836756706238,
0.37917742133140564,
0.011450251564383507,
-0.12172580510377884,
0.615485668182373,
-0.5345564484596252,
0.027934513986110687,
0.5567882657051086,
-0.0984683632850647,
0.3534877300262451,
-0.17948146164417267,
-0.8442690968513489,
-0.19265547394752502,
-0.8383297920227051,
-0.05142461508512497,
1.0121605396270752,
0.103303924202919,
0.6092602610588074,
-0.010264173150062561,
0.4860766530036926,
0.03363284468650818,
0.4594145715236664,
-0.9339839220046997,
0.5667431354522705,
-0.24133221805095673,
-0.6323923468589783,
-0.29247361421585083,
-0.38147491216659546,
-0.8934305310249329,
0.39397183060646057,
-0.16054069995880127,
-0.35137641429901123,
-0.10344305634498596,
0.19192461669445038,
-0.29382017254829407,
0.3697453737258911,
-0.5194961428642273,
0.7820887565612793,
-0.6352996230125427,
-0.2749112844467163,
-0.07302367687225342,
-0.5291581749916077,
0.24733641743659973,
-0.23968742787837982,
0.06610175967216492,
-0.04760700836777687,
-0.03508592024445534,
0.35367947816848755,
-0.38561421632766724,
0.9973486661911011,
-0.22109730541706085,
-0.3662445545196533,
0.1672443449497223,
0.14457076787948608,
0.8064848184585571,
-0.21730756759643555,
0.01780485361814499,
0.06632082909345627,
-0.3827681243419647,
0.0013973168097436428,
-0.5391435623168945,
0.7509779334068298,
-0.4885552227497101,
-0.41950374841690063,
-0.19242960214614868,
-0.8549724221229553,
-0.15971128642559052,
0.3769557774066925,
0.5986101627349854,
0.5582603812217712,
0.016568318009376526,
0.06632693856954575,
0.4573251008987427,
-0.027333222329616547,
0.6065191626548767,
0.7611039876937866,
-0.4444665014743805,
-0.6461310386657715,
0.7224862575531006,
0.22978053987026215,
0.34948429465293884,
0.38674867153167725,
0.04576348513364792,
-0.6214407086372375,
-0.7006990909576416,
-0.9877493977546692,
0.2258477807044983,
-0.4827513098716736,
-0.3911439776420593,
-0.5729231238365173,
-0.1176309660077095,
-0.2009129524230957,
0.012803440913558006,
-0.5969282388687134,
-0.37485772371292114,
-0.250411719083786,
0.1014380007982254,
0.2588544487953186,
0.3366785943508148,
0.04577906057238579,
0.5916892290115356,
-0.8441094160079956,
0.22006100416183472,
-0.1800329089164734,
0.13884133100509644,
-0.21136710047721863,
-0.8865845203399658,
-0.46299171447753906,
0.10427737981081009,
-0.5104414224624634,
-0.7757973074913025,
0.5383032560348511,
0.09571130573749542,
0.41791099309921265,
0.18439693748950958,
0.10716620832681656,
0.5417346358299255,
-0.6226345896720886,
0.3243464231491089,
0.33112528920173645,
-0.8420823812484741,
0.3031963109970093,
-0.43265262246131897,
0.5962583422660828,
0.4733580946922302,
0.3924850523471832,
-0.6166614890098572,
-0.6423551440238953,
-0.24959701299667358,
-0.9253524541854858,
0.43627750873565674,
0.20743070542812347,
0.08940889686346054,
0.038669951260089874,
0.23048268258571625,
0.2597741186618805,
0.2836606502532959,
-0.8172957301139832,
-0.3461129069328308,
-0.058828383684158325,
-0.302847683429718,
-0.0064681158401072025,
-0.02839849703013897,
-0.06637746840715408,
-0.22884908318519592,
0.7508168816566467,
-0.3971143662929535,
0.16386832296848297,
0.1785467565059662,
-0.4847080409526825,
-0.2101251780986786,
0.38687318563461304,
0.9981032609939575,
0.5050029754638672,
0.07126154005527496,
0.1315494030714035,
0.3808891177177429,
-0.3373320996761322,
0.4260740280151367,
0.3064999282360077,
-0.509605348110199,
0.05370223522186279,
0.1410391628742218,
1.0239654779434204,
0.37646999955177307,
-0.06544385105371475,
0.1728358119726181,
0.18434876203536987,
-0.25118449330329895,
-0.17123693227767944,
-0.07032278925180435,
-0.031170466914772987,
0.12043233960866928,
0.47731292247772217,
0.2269977629184723,
-0.050175584852695465,
-0.16038766503334045,
0.2096148431301117,
0.24164974689483643,
-0.7433146834373474,
-0.4713383615016937,
0.7615054845809937,
0.25517430901527405,
-0.28469395637512207,
0.4472399950027466,
-0.18115176260471344,
-0.742305338382721,
0.37351518869400024,
0.7735126614570618,
1.0468798875808716,
-0.43085455894470215,
-0.03531947359442711,
0.4177912473678589,
0.44823548197746277,
0.13768862187862396,
0.3028523623943329,
-0.004693055059760809,
-0.4919610917568207,
-0.8339214324951172,
-0.5813186764717102,
-0.1614599972963333,
0.24960657954216003,
-0.6108582615852356,
0.22776004672050476,
-0.17522110044956207,
-0.398400217294693,
-0.37796851992607117,
-0.4226868152618408,
-0.34213021397590637,
0.30020806193351746,
0.0399811752140522,
0.8127589821815491,
-0.6297098994255066,
1.0634678602218628,
0.8698084354400635,
-0.33597829937934875,
-0.50562983751297,
0.1019384115934372,
-0.09762305021286011,
-0.7143988609313965,
0.6476624011993408,
0.2665833532810211,
-0.2506880760192871,
0.2652818262577057,
-0.3764885663986206,
-0.7986264228820801,
0.8519164323806763,
0.24100685119628906,
-0.737505316734314,
0.11099632829427719,
0.540992259979248,
0.28632110357284546,
-0.4040589928627014,
0.16239508986473083,
0.30279940366744995,
0.7169066667556763,
0.05208997800946236,
-1.133885383605957,
0.3472803831100464,
-0.13801534473896027,
-0.21155185997486115,
0.4402690529823303,
-0.7132940888404846,
0.8542413115501404,
-0.10155002772808075,
-0.026126302778720856,
0.07970365881919861,
0.5332775712013245,
0.23559468984603882,
0.09335432201623917,
0.4244025945663452,
0.6488966345787048,
0.42251646518707275,
-0.1809014528989792,
0.6967461109161377,
-0.4593883454799652,
0.17901882529258728,
1.2923963069915771,
-0.1883915364742279,
0.7008497714996338,
0.7544053792953491,
0.09784334897994995,
0.14367295801639557,
0.485958456993103,
0.11510646343231201,
0.6108726263046265,
0.29677748680114746,
-0.07010044902563095,
-0.4402637779712677,
-0.17050181329250336,
-0.15402895212173462,
0.6443418264389038,
0.29502853751182556,
-0.48309165239334106,
-0.13076424598693848,
0.39072996377944946,
0.17350058257579803,
0.001614078413695097,
-0.4054948389530182,
0.5243756175041199,
0.45576778054237366,
-0.994268000125885,
1.0299232006072998,
0.2474280148744583,
0.7197549939155579,
-0.523447573184967,
0.17153851687908173,
-0.27942347526550293,
0.29724016785621643,
0.20071576535701752,
-0.5157961845397949,
0.4103569984436035,
-0.037949785590171814,
-0.1098867729306221,
-0.34766167402267456,
0.47239258885383606,
-0.7346773743629456,
-0.3804837763309479,
0.37751179933547974,
0.5687052011489868,
-0.06823552399873734,
-0.22854332625865936,
-0.8753910660743713,
0.06390275061130524,
-0.08964978158473969,
-0.30559876561164856,
0.2154645323753357,
0.6681674718856812,
-0.33118128776550293,
0.7018675208091736,
0.7741056680679321,
-0.06540917605161667,
0.3037169575691223,
0.2750559449195862,
0.5765472054481506,
-0.6938496828079224,
-0.40215277671813965,
-1.0414196252822876,
0.5694575905799866,
0.18483996391296387,
-0.6166529655456543,
0.7891620397567749,
0.5223263502120972,
0.6474743485450745,
-0.06369635462760925,
0.3772256374359131,
0.24619847536087036,
0.14620047807693481,
-0.9363551735877991,
0.8908339738845825,
-0.6064249873161316,
-0.09406904876232147,
0.22224323451519012,
-0.9793257117271423,
-0.4779788851737976,
0.036072470247745514,
-0.2192090004682541,
0.07623470574617386,
0.9617903828620911,
0.6221140027046204,
-0.16407258808612823,
-0.43488746881484985,
0.5219467282295227,
0.2290206402540207,
-0.037840694189071655,
0.5273050665855408,
0.8501477837562561,
-0.3769279718399048,
0.831537127494812,
-0.06158876791596413,
0.13081015646457672,
-0.3989792466163635,
-0.7927573919296265,
-0.9806135296821594,
-0.6249798536300659,
-0.3823447525501251,
-0.1576075553894043,
-0.0023982280399650335,
1.0298302173614502,
0.7698034644126892,
-0.9578883647918701,
-0.10753591358661652,
-0.10937267541885376,
-0.08595424890518188,
-0.20710434019565582,
-0.12614984810352325,
0.3301890194416046,
-0.6101626753807068,
-0.7822481393814087,
0.69309401512146,
0.2055218666791916,
0.3011574447154999,
-0.37933778762817383,
-0.25661563873291016,
-0.38829395174980164,
0.04235950857400894,
0.38987722992897034,
0.07116074115037918,
-0.7633013725280762,
0.08844944834709167,
0.30514177680015564,
-0.32569894194602966,
0.11871315538883209,
0.8383294939994812,
-0.26496708393096924,
0.2870885729789734,
0.15036484599113464,
0.464470773935318,
0.4561450183391571,
-0.13266155123710632,
0.8192347288131714,
-1.013231873512268,
0.17763866484165192,
-0.05084913223981857,
0.2970559597015381,
0.4380081593990326,
-0.3902156949043274,
0.17613402009010315,
0.2586821913719177,
-0.34721148014068604,
-0.6864818334579468,
0.21941879391670227,
-0.760728657245636,
-0.05762694776058197,
1.1972312927246094,
-0.08795587718486786,
-0.25896957516670227,
-0.052683934569358826,
-0.30012959241867065,
0.7793008089065552,
-0.375409334897995,
0.6188978552818298,
0.5729185938835144,
0.02998434193432331,
-0.20715385675430298,
-0.5161412954330444,
0.3184647262096405,
0.6467733383178711,
-0.6159709095954895,
-0.046450354158878326,
0.3368295431137085,
0.015943530946969986,
0.19128189980983734,
0.11537226289510727,
-0.09563024342060089,
0.1876230388879776,
-0.45066219568252563,
0.4353920519351959,
-0.6684618592262268,
-0.5305125713348389,
-0.46697014570236206,
-0.0805220752954483,
0.04228542372584343,
-0.6003174781799316
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06734v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06734v1
|
Real-Time Multimodal Cognitive Assistant for Emergency Medical Services
| 2024-03-11T13:56:57 | 2024-03-11T13:56:57 |
Keshara Weerasinghe, Saahith Janapati, Xueren Ge, Sion Kim, Sneha Iyer, John A. Stankovic, Homa Alemzadeh
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Emergency Medical Services (EMS) responders often operate under
time-sensitive conditions, facing cognitive overload and inherent risks,
requiring essential skills in critical thinking and rapid decision-making. This
paper presents CognitiveEMS, an end-to-end wearable cognitive assistant system
that can act as a collaborative virtual partner engaging in the real-time
acquisition and analysis of multimodal data from an emergency scene and
interacting with EMS responders through Augmented Reality (AR) smart glasses.
CognitiveEMS processes the continuous streams of data in real-time and
leverages edge computing to provide assistance in EMS protocol selection and
intervention recognition. We address key technical challenges in real-time
cognitive assistance by introducing three novel components: (i) a Speech
Recognition model that is fine-tuned for real-world medical emergency
conversations using simulated EMS audio recordings, augmented with synthetic
data generated by large language models (LLMs); (ii) an EMS Protocol Prediction
model that combines state-of-the-art (SOTA) tiny language models with EMS
domain knowledge using graph-based attention mechanisms; (iii) an EMS Action
Recognition module which leverages multimodal audio and video data and protocol
predictions to infer the intervention/treatment actions taken by the responders
at the incident scene. Our results show that for speech recognition we achieve
superior performance compared to SOTA (WER of 0.290 vs. 0.618) on
conversational data. Our protocol prediction component also significantly
outperforms SOTA (top-3 accuracy of 0.800 vs. 0.200) and the action recognition
achieves an accuracy of 0.727, while maintaining an end-to-end latency of 3.78s
for protocol prediction on the edge and 0.31s on the server.
|
[
-0.4991888403892517,
-1.0855180025100708,
0.9509453773498535,
0.21429745852947235,
-0.26275718212127686,
0.3603651523590088,
-0.2715033292770386,
-1.009426474571228,
0.5158432722091675,
0.3693876266479492,
-0.7846515774726868,
-0.11034485697746277,
-0.6773136258125305,
-0.006290314253419638,
-0.09391608834266663,
0.41385963559150696,
0.09615026414394379,
0.2501036524772644,
-0.1501649022102356,
-0.1699763387441635,
-0.5836130976676941,
-0.4866514503955841,
-1.0089402198791504,
-0.09514815360307693,
0.2293321192264557,
0.4977404773235321,
0.5911515355110168,
0.1516476571559906,
0.6320370435714722,
0.4499187767505646,
0.4339039921760559,
0.3178671598434448,
0.18121802806854248,
0.2558710277080536,
0.11645299941301346,
-0.20477503538131714,
-0.8853448033332825,
-0.2980116307735443,
0.10415937006473541,
0.08446474373340607,
-0.45253685116767883,
0.25450578331947327,
-0.35597142577171326,
0.3464955985546112,
-0.6100877523422241,
-0.004203971941024065,
-0.3377837836742401,
-0.07419800013303757,
0.01340540125966072,
-0.25812679529190063,
-0.17430654168128967,
0.002760235220193863,
0.5468829274177551,
-1.0130826234817505,
-0.1439027190208435,
0.24653203785419464,
0.3700183629989624,
0.259970486164093,
-0.41656509041786194,
-0.3971766531467438,
-0.9538856744766235,
0.7403799295425415,
-0.3334191143512726,
0.6115426421165466,
0.5197471380233765,
0.5990950465202332,
0.2604599893093109,
-0.7445167303085327,
-0.753428041934967,
0.06841643899679184,
0.3709641098976135,
0.505181610584259,
0.0008857460925355554,
0.14139604568481445,
-0.07875782996416092,
-0.05239686742424965,
-0.6437580585479736,
-0.014643850736320019,
-0.1352824717760086,
-0.32163724303245544,
0.6251490116119385,
0.46031662821769714,
0.5034529566764832,
0.1264737844467163,
-0.49770084023475647,
0.0635930672287941,
-0.14887019991874695,
-0.024628350511193275,
-0.40497076511383057,
0.019929513335227966,
-0.4951308071613312,
0.31445688009262085,
-0.19261302053928375,
0.41684088110923767,
-0.2034814953804016,
-0.2590045928955078,
0.4323393404483795,
-0.30453285574913025,
-0.4266122579574585,
0.3828074336051941,
0.5978151559829712,
0.5894108414649963,
0.10538304597139359,
-0.006614695303142071,
-0.15955966711044312,
0.3180274963378906,
0.3309749364852905,
-0.2979687750339508,
-0.10627400130033493,
0.5202956199645996,
-0.4167238175868988,
0.05478060618042946,
-0.41835716366767883,
-0.6156777143478394,
-0.07735517621040344,
-0.5422171950340271,
0.46823546290397644,
-0.45740556716918945,
-0.5056506395339966,
0.379960834980011,
-0.06307011097669601,
0.16773569583892822,
0.5596401691436768,
-0.36832091212272644,
0.5340537428855896,
0.20887228846549988,
0.9115837216377258,
0.1281125396490097,
0.10183922201395035,
-0.4452840983867645,
0.3406235873699188,
0.07923552393913269,
0.8963820934295654,
-0.7563045620918274,
-0.5864098072052002,
-0.09091410785913467,
0.08098218590021133,
-0.2384321391582489,
-0.2890721559524536,
0.6586589217185974,
-0.3777533173561096,
-0.16817881166934967,
0.1492031365633011,
-0.12188596278429031,
-0.05079786852002144,
0.41869744658470154,
-0.28301137685775757,
0.769733190536499,
-0.42605000734329224,
-0.17497000098228455,
0.23557814955711365,
-0.8177415132522583,
-0.4149215817451477,
0.28900817036628723,
-0.26656651496887207,
-0.618453323841095,
-0.15581735968589783,
0.5106862783432007,
0.47564294934272766,
-0.3781563937664032,
-0.1117653101682663,
-0.3783588111400604,
-0.039569031447172165,
0.2894003987312317,
-0.4166259765625,
0.49928516149520874,
0.2683235704898834,
-0.19145305454730988,
0.11498893797397614,
-1.0598797798156738,
0.35959556698799133,
0.41092073917388916,
-0.1550450325012207,
-0.33558350801467896,
0.08756621927022934,
0.5408106446266174,
0.3589238226413727,
0.07826447486877441,
-0.9645440578460693,
-0.07724188268184662,
0.2586432695388794,
0.5260391235351562,
0.5745159983634949,
0.10726697742938995,
0.20648233592510223,
-0.38489821553230286,
0.35651886463165283,
-0.1390448957681656,
0.731030285358429,
-0.13650687038898468,
-0.7495641708374023,
-0.3130916953086853,
-0.71535325050354,
-0.19777493178844452,
1.141369342803955,
-0.9383410811424255,
0.2835058867931366,
-0.3256095051765442,
-0.5345324277877808,
-0.6220060586929321,
-0.411092072725296,
0.5653436779975891,
0.47523781657218933,
0.5574191808700562,
-0.2194889336824417,
-0.5891387462615967,
-0.7834610939025879,
0.07811273634433746,
-0.10230107605457306,
-0.22181636095046997,
0.5026089549064636,
0.11552426218986511,
-0.4235915243625641,
0.6047026515007019,
-0.40944284200668335,
-0.6176406145095825,
-0.13988438248634338,
0.08517494052648544,
-0.3173777461051941,
0.5442053079605103,
0.3409736454486847,
-0.8174451589584351,
-0.11734738945960999,
-0.03458934277296066,
-0.975337564945221,
0.1877015084028244,
-0.065875343978405,
0.3636229634284973,
-0.25647062063217163,
0.4110035002231598,
-0.28958097100257874,
0.26317834854125977,
0.6370936036109924,
-0.15007375180721283,
0.11655038595199585,
-0.41461819410324097,
0.40442824363708496,
-1.0879160165786743,
-0.16985517740249634,
-0.10953427851200104,
-0.30580559372901917,
-0.7646438479423523,
-0.2648799419403076,
0.048154883086681366,
-0.4561997056007385,
-0.7742957472801208,
0.3767360746860504,
-0.5902310013771057,
-0.028475653380155563,
-0.002653577132150531,
0.30340299010276794,
-0.2276211380958557,
0.5514867901802063,
0.3799114525318146,
0.46110185980796814,
0.6682072281837463,
-0.7335966229438782,
0.4296083152294159,
0.30316174030303955,
-0.20893782377243042,
0.9233894348144531,
-0.595014750957489,
0.25550299882888794,
0.10993339866399765,
0.32663366198539734,
-0.7373366951942444,
-0.14479754865169525,
-0.053662482649087906,
-0.4324391484260559,
0.059825118631124496,
-0.0432533398270607,
-0.23847216367721558,
-0.1349276453256607,
-0.20609760284423828,
0.7149812579154968,
0.13949847221374512,
-0.029562031850218773,
0.9509379863739014,
0.8195526003837585,
-0.483930379152298,
-0.27055150270462036,
-0.8987680673599243,
0.22020146250724792,
0.20294009149074554,
-0.6287879347801208,
0.20874905586242676,
-0.2697458565235138,
-0.09623215347528458,
-0.13824670016765594,
0.0613221749663353,
-0.13787665963172913,
0.003576437244191766,
0.6443285942077637,
0.5326893925666809,
-0.020895373076200485,
0.04068373143672943,
0.10847297310829163,
-0.16265588998794556,
-0.029167380183935165,
-0.20733478665351868,
0.44311678409576416,
-0.2549421787261963,
-0.615902841091156,
-0.7057675123214722,
0.620410680770874,
0.8729848861694336,
-0.4282536506652832,
0.37742695212364197,
0.5809000730514526,
-0.6918967366218567,
0.5383797287940979,
-0.8052706718444824,
-0.2807205319404602,
-0.44085943698883057,
0.26304560899734497,
-0.28875717520713806,
-0.43968966603279114,
0.6200641989707947,
-0.1428603082895279,
0.16897043585777283,
-0.026741020381450653,
0.5719730854034424,
-0.22347523272037506,
1.0427192449569702,
0.2627345323562622,
0.20281542837619781,
0.6571527719497681,
-0.2027072310447693,
0.10998424887657166,
-1.0464977025985718,
-0.6787146329879761,
-0.06389987468719482,
-0.26414546370506287,
-0.2622581720352173,
-0.2014211267232895,
1.0340585708618164,
-0.4760473072528839,
-0.03669055178761482,
0.11556611210107803,
-0.5078455805778503,
-0.04321015998721123,
0.1970740258693695,
0.5482050776481628,
0.19683833420276642,
-0.08445262163877487,
0.13011454045772552,
0.04723123088479042,
-0.5802037715911865,
-0.36319881677627563,
1.0229318141937256,
0.31673550605773926,
0.5273405909538269,
0.20542101562023163,
0.38526004552841187,
0.4640127420425415,
0.06769996136426926,
-0.5934174060821533,
0.7052821516990662,
0.3386093080043793,
-0.6317688822746277,
-0.34228500723838806,
0.1272558867931366,
-0.8392738103866577,
0.12023835629224777,
-0.8182227611541748,
-0.3692215383052826,
0.46128973364830017,
0.09297257661819458,
-0.6654701828956604,
0.14312462508678436,
-0.8598617911338806,
0.18679703772068024,
-0.16325978934764862,
-0.1988184154033661,
-0.5578616261482239,
-0.9157102704048157,
-0.10817152261734009,
0.17300662398338318,
0.689336359500885,
-0.17123505473136902,
-0.3190259039402008,
0.6246325373649597,
-0.17889679968357086,
0.6702603697776794,
-0.03772084042429924,
0.20410622656345367,
0.5056552290916443,
-0.005140769761055708,
0.49458399415016174,
0.3204455077648163,
0.27208325266838074,
0.33353811502456665,
-0.018877141177654266,
-0.5774416923522949,
-0.4177836775779724,
0.6250282526016235,
-0.6338582634925842,
-0.12423661351203918,
-0.326911985874176,
-0.34705954790115356,
-0.5508275032043457,
0.13910888135433197,
0.02082294411957264,
1.0736935138702393,
-0.18358226120471954,
-0.0681586042046547,
0.545683741569519,
0.07622275501489639,
0.777805507183075,
0.7308264374732971,
0.2598312497138977,
-0.5413954854011536,
1.0856716632843018,
0.3556308150291443,
0.24178946018218994,
0.44598454236984253,
-0.17860104143619537,
-0.0028304490260779858,
-0.4760470986366272,
-0.8203107714653015,
-0.0005787269328720868,
-0.2658553123474121,
-0.09178951382637024,
-0.9284821152687073,
-0.17672868072986603,
-0.2053266018629074,
-0.4458919167518616,
-0.45475882291793823,
-0.483787477016449,
0.0903296172618866,
-0.12494036555290222,
0.2273779809474945,
0.4185684323310852,
0.13737991452217102,
0.2811046242713928,
-1.2042200565338135,
0.27323052287101746,
0.5661154985427856,
0.10937009006738663,
-0.2877614200115204,
0.10303494334220886,
-0.2561641037464142,
-0.15679414570331573,
-0.07631145417690277,
-0.8028023838996887,
0.006422370206564665,
0.06230129301548004,
0.35457244515419006,
0.2416469007730484,
-0.019218850880861282,
0.5098927021026611,
-0.5522916913032532,
0.9246690273284912,
0.5556284785270691,
-0.6733025312423706,
0.4720737636089325,
-0.17614251375198364,
0.1286768913269043,
0.381028413772583,
-0.07632766664028168,
-0.3628977835178375,
-0.28300127387046814,
-0.6779842376708984,
-0.8694276213645935,
0.5169442296028137,
0.36167052388191223,
-0.16855928301811218,
-0.24613237380981445,
-0.18641315400600433,
-0.4401934742927551,
0.15471050143241882,
-0.05914830416440964,
-0.21822792291641235,
-0.10870309919118881,
-0.2667771279811859,
0.17937786877155304,
-0.04008099436759949,
-0.12989196181297302,
0.20712532103061676,
0.5356706976890564,
-0.1662983000278473,
0.5916638374328613,
0.664150059223175,
-0.09099256992340088,
-0.21135833859443665,
0.4962175786495209,
1.011054515838623,
0.47865667939186096,
-0.17634621262550354,
-0.010802585631608963,
0.6263783574104309,
-0.940255880355835,
0.011521240696310997,
-0.06403744220733643,
0.6213107109069824,
-0.06342023611068726,
0.4557192027568817,
0.44482913613319397,
0.14993181824684143,
-1.188862681388855,
0.5958924293518066,
-0.3291381895542145,
0.1464366912841797,
-0.6697151064872742,
-0.2762118875980377,
-0.08192896842956543,
0.2966260015964508,
0.37092840671539307,
0.41323354840278625,
0.2870257496833801,
-0.5415838956832886,
0.20583632588386536,
0.33245179057121277,
-0.5725522041320801,
-0.43918508291244507,
0.5770649313926697,
0.5947334170341492,
-0.45203617215156555,
0.2361493557691574,
0.19358880817890167,
-0.11155285686254501,
0.5596502423286438,
0.4097244143486023,
0.7222458720207214,
-0.88172447681427,
-0.0715920627117157,
0.052333079278469086,
0.37149637937545776,
0.26140621304512024,
0.7597864270210266,
-0.017531337216496468,
-0.548027753829956,
-0.09372442960739136,
0.0012007501209154725,
-0.5481584668159485,
-0.00842810794711113,
-0.8233751654624939,
0.2747924327850342,
-0.7773134112358093,
-0.5402643084526062,
-0.02175838313996792,
-0.4861905872821808,
-0.7423879504203796,
0.7247958183288574,
0.20751726627349854,
0.7204170227050781,
-0.6988081932067871,
0.5958495736122131,
0.9154316186904907,
-0.2715889513492584,
-0.39622870087623596,
-0.3369109630584717,
0.1738387644290924,
-1.055901288986206,
0.1588856726884842,
-0.3487534821033478,
-0.3458326458930969,
-0.1891241818666458,
-0.09485974162817001,
-0.6780202984809875,
1.260585069656372,
0.19031548500061035,
-0.8953655958175659,
-0.1975959986448288,
-0.150216743350029,
0.29001256823539734,
-0.29269424080848694,
0.7012011408805847,
0.1544986069202423,
0.17126435041427612,
-0.1993759125471115,
-1.1926617622375488,
0.05057652294635773,
-0.18016420304775238,
-0.38535797595977783,
0.32739052176475525,
-0.6888647675514221,
0.3550509810447693,
-0.28263089060783386,
0.006751666311174631,
-0.5113589763641357,
0.4799635410308838,
0.23526571691036224,
0.8450843691825867,
0.7243669629096985,
0.3483458459377289,
0.6382375359535217,
0.16593818366527557,
0.9433674812316895,
-0.40506383776664734,
0.0730111226439476,
0.8829731345176697,
-0.20425480604171753,
0.9584345817565918,
0.478702574968338,
-0.020485375076532364,
0.4109806716442108,
0.4128560721874237,
0.6725024580955505,
0.5550822615623474,
-0.570930004119873,
-0.6801002621650696,
-0.40958091616630554,
-0.30873027443885803,
-0.36988139152526855,
0.12659144401550293,
0.9083421230316162,
-0.03882822021842003,
0.07011184096336365,
0.6104036569595337,
-0.12488187849521637,
-0.119069404900074,
-0.42778924107551575,
0.943053126335144,
0.11258910596370697,
-0.29853254556655884,
0.32969269156455994,
-0.2815118432044983,
0.35852712392807007,
-0.5928107500076294,
-0.15056326985359192,
0.4759284555912018,
0.1283283531665802,
-0.3306451141834259,
-0.7840853333473206,
0.19041578471660614,
-0.2597653865814209,
-0.2293328493833542,
0.12781623005867004,
0.6307169795036316,
-0.17028549313545227,
-0.25389397144317627,
0.3658770024776459,
0.4342457354068756,
-0.025786802172660828,
0.01924908347427845,
-0.8200539350509644,
0.2713160812854767,
-0.3610330820083618,
-0.1592840701341629,
0.391701877117157,
0.17236600816249847,
-0.1297505497932434,
0.9349360466003418,
0.8069888353347778,
0.042377542704343796,
0.1365029662847519,
-0.17068122327327728,
0.7596625089645386,
-0.2326105386018753,
-0.6669419407844543,
-0.5530886650085449,
0.5867044925689697,
-0.17821791768074036,
-0.3597795069217682,
0.10251650959253311,
0.5691230893135071,
0.450182169675827,
0.030489107593894005,
0.8784459233283997,
-0.0239742249250412,
0.3702053129673004,
-0.4872095286846161,
0.12427542358636856,
-0.44652971625328064,
0.0639546811580658,
-0.02015356346964836,
-0.34714555740356445,
-0.187505304813385,
0.35880231857299805,
-0.20119798183441162,
-0.25529995560646057,
0.4695410132408142,
0.552631676197052,
-0.25643086433410645,
0.2936660051345825,
0.43024134635925293,
-0.16787241399288177,
0.5227124691009521,
0.5194010734558105,
0.468954473733902,
-0.5165047645568848,
0.5005975961685181,
-0.10392241925001144,
-0.4671228229999542,
-0.4451465904712677,
-0.4504428803920746,
-0.5920047163963318,
-0.72142493724823,
-0.31054750084877014,
-0.15665198862552643,
0.1719587743282318,
1.4103496074676514,
1.0137896537780762,
-0.41314762830734253,
0.20555642247200012,
0.18898290395736694,
-0.38281577825546265,
-0.4796772301197052,
-0.1307770311832428,
0.21916955709457397,
-0.0039587123319506645,
-0.6294016242027283,
0.7617193460464478,
0.7663589715957642,
-0.004530510399490595,
0.1266309767961502,
-0.06820850819349289,
-0.2461899071931839,
0.510467529296875,
0.8970984816551208,
0.250074565410614,
-0.7157913446426392,
-0.44989439845085144,
0.10613862425088882,
-0.14896558225154877,
-0.10901691764593124,
0.8573140501976013,
-0.6335236430168152,
0.7998718619346619,
0.28073444962501526,
0.7280789613723755,
0.3921537399291992,
-0.22141435742378235,
0.30031681060791016,
-0.4886634945869446,
0.2663905918598175,
0.34047114849090576,
0.4273083209991455,
0.17416545748710632,
-0.3737478256225586,
0.40635913610458374,
0.37140241265296936,
-0.6355366110801697,
-0.7662158608436584,
0.28788843750953674,
-1.301471471786499,
0.05543142557144165,
0.6087095737457275,
-0.158919557929039,
-0.15031851828098297,
-0.6261624693870544,
-0.4768539369106293,
0.20882278680801392,
-0.6488106846809387,
0.36711832880973816,
0.19697615504264832,
-0.487989604473114,
-0.15857788920402527,
-0.7905944585800171,
0.16021563112735748,
0.329057514667511,
-0.7655947804450989,
-0.23493242263793945,
0.14769914746284485,
0.3308742940425873,
0.5254479050636292,
0.7522271871566772,
-0.10245145857334137,
0.533668041229248,
-0.23319308459758759,
0.16855388879776,
-0.3098609745502472,
-0.2717325687408447,
-0.057399652898311615,
0.09638740867376328,
-0.4142555594444275,
-0.9016169905662537
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06725v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06725v2
|
Improving Low-Resource Knowledge Tracing Tasks by Supervised Pre-training and Importance Mechanism Fine-tuning
| 2024-03-11T13:44:43 | 2024-03-23T08:14:28 |
Hengyuan Zhang, Zitao Liu, Shuyan Huang, Chenming Shang, Bojun Zhan, Yong Jiang
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Knowledge tracing (KT) aims to estimate student's knowledge mastery based on
their historical interactions. Recently, the deep learning based KT (DLKT)
approaches have achieved impressive performance in the KT task. These DLKT
models heavily rely on the large number of available student interactions.
However, due to various reasons such as budget constraints and privacy
concerns, observed interactions are very limited in many real-world scenarios,
a.k.a, low-resource KT datasets. Directly training a DLKT model on a
low-resource KT dataset may lead to overfitting and it is difficult to choose
the appropriate deep neural architecture. Therefore, in this paper, we propose
a low-resource KT framework called LoReKT to address above challenges. Inspired
by the prevalent "pre-training and fine-tuning" paradigm, we aim to learn
transferable parameters and representations from rich-resource KT datasets
during the pre-training stage and subsequently facilitate effective adaptation
to low-resource KT datasets. Specifically, we simplify existing sophisticated
DLKT model architectures with purely a stack of transformer decoders. We design
an encoding mechanism to incorporate student interactions from multiple KT data
sources and develop an importance mechanism to prioritize updating parameters
with high importance while constraining less important ones during the
fine-tuning stage. We evaluate LoReKT on six public KT datasets and
experimental results demonstrate the superiority of our approach in terms of
AUC and Accuracy. To encourage reproducible research, we make our data and code
publicly available at https://anonymous.4open.science/r/LoReKT-C619.
|
[
-0.295460045337677,
-0.4058431386947632,
0.4936535358428955,
-0.1516108363866806,
-0.29964762926101685,
0.15903246402740479,
-0.2830861210823059,
-0.35695505142211914,
0.04007909819483757,
0.5086236596107483,
-0.5825952887535095,
-0.42206352949142456,
-0.41073277592658997,
-0.39827796816825867,
-0.07222918421030045,
1.1739501953125,
-0.08938894420862198,
-0.21870143711566925,
-0.21578741073608398,
-0.1564285010099411,
-0.5342000722885132,
-0.5402595400810242,
-0.698979914188385,
-0.3268163800239563,
0.8429756760597229,
0.7178806066513062,
0.2569475769996643,
0.6270167827606201,
0.4006962180137634,
0.16179117560386658,
0.050339050590991974,
0.14079293608665466,
-1.0108330249786377,
0.06139315664768219,
-0.13417573273181915,
-0.39035913348197937,
-0.6697649955749512,
-0.05279634892940521,
0.36581048369407654,
0.6498501300811768,
0.1664525717496872,
0.6111294627189636,
0.4944640100002289,
0.8095178008079529,
-0.7990915179252625,
0.5226939916610718,
-0.3102833032608032,
-0.17971168458461761,
-0.2019016146659851,
-0.3069038689136505,
-0.43969807028770447,
-0.400237113237381,
0.613007664680481,
-0.8261789083480835,
0.26207590103149414,
-0.21145200729370117,
0.7365646362304688,
0.5589009523391724,
-0.3739735186100006,
-0.08377444744110107,
-0.5853291153907776,
0.8118909001350403,
-0.4905785322189331,
0.46059682965278625,
0.528548538684845,
0.34211066365242004,
0.1673552244901657,
-0.8367258906364441,
-0.06380362063646317,
-0.02642875909805298,
-0.39265236258506775,
0.409030556678772,
0.021479720249772072,
0.21817800402641296,
0.22367681562900543,
0.14215205609798431,
-0.053743138909339905,
0.16582253575325012,
-0.6899757385253906,
-0.3966493606567383,
0.2334122210741043,
0.19613376259803772,
-0.185194194316864,
-0.24389301240444183,
-0.3274343013763428,
-0.1865958869457245,
-0.6471136212348938,
0.2169264703989029,
0.3581615388393402,
0.49738118052482605,
-0.17136801779270172,
0.25381115078926086,
-0.42259955406188965,
0.5320895910263062,
0.1868133693933487,
-0.004921772982925177,
-0.04461686313152313,
-0.4020356237888336,
-0.1049731969833374,
0.33147940039634705,
0.3277617394924164,
0.24247337877750397,
0.1216050535440445,
-0.19567450881004333,
0.17013970017433167,
-0.18004705011844635,
0.3281134068965912,
-1.035062551498413,
-0.5210782885551453,
-0.31672555208206177,
-0.4246557652950287,
-0.334020733833313,
-0.39774852991104126,
-0.8173462152481079,
-0.3968711793422699,
-0.5486581921577454,
0.6025274991989136,
-0.5521224737167358,
-0.31402409076690674,
0.055697422474622726,
0.41381368041038513,
0.10736508667469025,
0.532744824886322,
-0.8102166652679443,
0.17318856716156006,
0.37189874053001404,
0.6329859495162964,
-0.16529102623462677,
-0.22697363793849945,
-0.5161296129226685,
0.19729314744472504,
-0.04028504341840744,
0.42449334263801575,
-0.20141640305519104,
-0.13565893471240997,
-0.28352639079093933,
0.011651847511529922,
-0.17592491209506989,
-0.03349161520600319,
0.6615716814994812,
-0.7272193431854248,
-0.020940368995070457,
-0.6269208192825317,
-0.739644467830658,
-0.41680189967155457,
0.13651373982429504,
-0.8739483952522278,
0.8417606949806213,
0.2698981463909149,
-0.8490362167358398,
0.5079483389854431,
-0.8591583967208862,
-0.4367125928401947,
0.04513399675488472,
0.08332306146621704,
-0.3687449097633362,
-0.09996914118528366,
0.19344374537467957,
0.5254589915275574,
-0.21223898231983185,
-0.036781881004571915,
-0.1505730152130127,
-0.3359479308128357,
-0.3986417353153229,
-0.451707124710083,
0.715276837348938,
0.219155415892601,
-0.2668076157569885,
0.006121511105448008,
-0.9427143931388855,
0.221866637468338,
-0.14812682569026947,
-0.5165642499923706,
-0.6341087818145752,
-0.16768082976341248,
-0.12392301112413406,
0.052600517868995667,
0.2859727144241333,
-0.28779956698417664,
0.3678401708602905,
-0.35184961557388306,
0.38306137919425964,
0.835477888584137,
0.01916474662721157,
0.6982919573783875,
-0.06400541216135025,
0.6513780355453491,
-0.11631284654140472,
0.06016247719526291,
-0.16354937851428986,
-0.13456545770168304,
-0.7953389883041382,
-0.056752752512693405,
0.3139679431915283,
0.18242619931697845,
-0.7248786091804504,
-0.1665320098400116,
-0.4366428554058075,
-0.4815651774406433,
-0.7821550369262695,
0.1284235566854477,
0.4465370178222656,
0.8811681866645813,
0.4777258336544037,
-0.00344833848066628,
-0.7186752557754517,
-0.5744818449020386,
-0.23351217806339264,
-0.22226876020431519,
0.06366049498319626,
0.638187050819397,
0.2851887345314026,
0.10724375396966934,
1.117512822151184,
-0.5140407681465149,
-0.5043883323669434,
-0.1779298186302185,
0.27097955346107483,
0.07905165106058121,
0.5558241605758667,
0.6045763492584229,
-0.6591926217079163,
-0.5510783195495605,
0.22621959447860718,
-0.5282559990882874,
0.09657979011535645,
-0.020692823454737663,
-0.377930223941803,
0.13773231208324432,
0.6921839118003845,
-0.352790892124176,
0.36380597949028015,
0.4011186361312866,
-0.35860326886177063,
0.3858553469181061,
-0.16608402132987976,
0.31451115012168884,
-1.0541887283325195,
0.16114962100982666,
-0.4903947710990906,
-0.008821260184049606,
-0.4474446177482605,
-0.15814349055290222,
0.07744307070970535,
-0.034974779933691025,
-0.4115549921989441,
0.5679199695587158,
-0.2932033836841583,
0.21708860993385315,
-0.009891049936413765,
-0.21181802451610565,
-0.044815804809331894,
0.6863500475883484,
-0.18864090740680695,
0.4151039719581604,
0.41917017102241516,
-0.5046074986457825,
0.23598027229309082,
-0.13163980841636658,
-0.2781089246273041,
0.6255502700805664,
-0.28411853313446045,
0.204043909907341,
0.12699808180332184,
0.035560838878154755,
-0.8406766057014465,
-0.20235952734947205,
0.07862254977226257,
-0.29175570607185364,
0.31705746054649353,
-0.9218540191650391,
-0.6112242341041565,
-0.18244397640228271,
0.030848270282149315,
0.6041101217269897,
0.7725367546081543,
-0.6143837571144104,
0.9133005142211914,
-0.09822699427604675,
0.10809328407049179,
-0.5838944911956787,
-0.2085374891757965,
-0.3489021956920624,
-0.32558467984199524,
-0.6735253930091858,
0.11657644808292389,
0.08995109051465988,
0.34238457679748535,
0.05998481437563896,
-0.3407220244407654,
-0.24018673598766327,
0.19382117688655853,
0.3196195662021637,
0.13449248671531677,
-0.5317991375923157,
0.20829981565475464,
0.07949678599834442,
-0.23079641163349152,
0.14779643714427948,
-0.5698096752166748,
0.3886137008666992,
-0.18441185355186462,
-0.42239508032798767,
-0.37248775362968445,
-0.3011349141597748,
0.7654809355735779,
-0.0535656213760376,
0.528001070022583,
0.9493770599365234,
-0.017837604507803917,
-0.21955710649490356,
-0.6425264477729797,
-0.4634617865085602,
-0.479987770318985,
0.5180724263191223,
-0.15607497096061707,
-0.9877513647079468,
0.6059150099754333,
-0.3948555290699005,
0.03518535569310188,
0.24336035549640656,
0.27123740315437317,
-0.37317267060279846,
0.5250860452651978,
0.8960280418395996,
-0.3189552426338196,
0.45156559348106384,
-0.4266972541809082,
0.07553401589393616,
-0.6318210363388062,
0.06501661986112595,
-0.15544584393501282,
-0.5387817621231079,
-0.4383435845375061,
-0.18704891204833984,
0.2705160677433014,
0.3033798038959503,
-0.17606490850448608,
0.21327751874923706,
-0.42387494444847107,
0.6205127835273743,
0.712592363357544,
0.20677560567855835,
0.3699578046798706,
0.006493292283266783,
0.05446520820260048,
-0.21030005812644958,
-0.9952875971794128,
-0.06591697037220001,
1.315706491470337,
0.2920590043067932,
0.9356895089149475,
-0.21298590302467346,
0.7486323714256287,
0.14663593471050262,
0.19889405369758606,
-0.7083967924118042,
0.4491875469684601,
-0.2503136992454529,
-0.48893898725509644,
-0.5456711053848267,
-0.5062130689620972,
-0.8261072635650635,
-0.14287249743938446,
-0.017484022304415703,
-0.5405967235565186,
0.1467159539461136,
0.7290913462638855,
-0.6605178117752075,
0.5272865891456604,
-1.0527429580688477,
0.9239826798439026,
-0.006995420437306166,
-0.6576143503189087,
-0.3622998595237732,
-0.6906377077102661,
0.3881448805332184,
-0.16592787206172943,
-0.16040749847888947,
0.2065066397190094,
0.4196220338344574,
0.9822426438331604,
-0.24504812061786652,
1.3196828365325928,
-0.4852496087551117,
-0.12463687360286713,
0.4069525897502899,
0.16191861033439636,
0.7556495666503906,
-0.031053876504302025,
0.15193131566047668,
-0.04912646487355232,
0.027883347123861313,
-0.3771052360534668,
-0.4996187388896942,
0.6248815655708313,
-0.6856270432472229,
-0.3185587525367737,
0.07775944471359253,
-0.6380190253257751,
-0.19199562072753906,
0.4159908890724182,
0.41575002670288086,
0.25957542657852173,
-0.0011532590724527836,
0.5222811102867126,
0.7639638781547546,
0.00010220561671303585,
0.31547585129737854,
0.7029873132705688,
0.2649036943912506,
0.001984001835808158,
1.2202832698822021,
0.4452368915081024,
0.2967415153980255,
0.2239721268415451,
0.26448628306388855,
-0.08296800404787064,
-0.48532599210739136,
-0.28650322556495667,
-0.1426941454410553,
-0.6897578835487366,
-0.3781312108039856,
-0.559997022151947,
-0.289152592420578,
-0.15906110405921936,
-0.3569130003452301,
-0.7436988353729248,
-0.162128746509552,
-0.35743919014930725,
-0.1156732439994812,
0.7806863188743591,
0.44753289222717285,
-0.0884975790977478,
0.6457710266113281,
-0.5878037214279175,
0.2375035136938095,
0.685117244720459,
0.7992361783981323,
0.3949013352394104,
-0.46574199199676514,
-0.6970459222793579,
-0.05759385973215103,
-0.031980473548173904,
-0.2650911211967468,
0.0037569128908216953,
0.021785413846373558,
0.3370915353298187,
0.31575050950050354,
0.4806283116340637,
0.8223687410354614,
-0.2487235814332962,
0.32222816348075867,
-0.09482011944055557,
-0.6966544985771179,
0.6107308864593506,
-0.44389525055885315,
0.22105376422405243,
0.6367343664169312,
0.14278799295425415,
-0.3229469954967499,
-0.2443632036447525,
-0.63215571641922,
-1.0303624868392944,
1.0949772596359253,
0.19603735208511353,
-0.1407775580883026,
0.6605231165885925,
0.3699571490287781,
0.15804648399353027,
-0.06133948266506195,
-0.48270803689956665,
-0.0807652696967125,
-0.45343685150146484,
-0.2575220763683319,
0.18844519555568695,
-0.3521445095539093,
-0.05951106175780296,
-0.29852306842803955,
0.5059995651245117,
-0.19109056890010834,
-0.27176836133003235,
0.08447940647602081,
-0.41603320837020874,
-0.029072023928165436,
0.19990751147270203,
0.34085890650749207,
0.5760222673416138,
-0.43901386857032776,
0.14107699692249298,
0.3411903977394104,
-0.9547541737556458,
0.10681653022766113,
0.22429464757442474,
-0.1949254870414734,
-0.2760123312473297,
0.46354803442955017,
0.5424771904945374,
0.6000446081161499,
-0.2635367512702942,
0.29157131910324097,
0.09979824721813202,
-0.1941433995962143,
-0.018197497352957726,
0.15967097878456116,
0.24432280659675598,
0.3997422456741333,
0.3134832978248596,
0.09843970090150833,
-0.046035442501306534,
0.13188238441944122,
0.2097107470035553,
0.01086283940821886,
-0.3744787573814392,
-0.5118511319160461,
0.48860958218574524,
0.3724452257156372,
0.24328507483005524,
0.5813299417495728,
-0.10866717994213104,
-0.34144163131713867,
0.6010915637016296,
0.03819955512881279,
0.6664006114006042,
-0.2602396011352539,
0.031665366142988205,
0.5453380346298218,
0.3016206622123718,
-0.12117230892181396,
0.06732715666294098,
-0.31672194600105286,
-0.404867947101593,
-0.6649872660636902,
-0.6064413189888,
-0.05339028686285019,
0.28413087129592896,
-0.8406824469566345,
0.2651635706424713,
-0.2660500705242157,
0.07705356925725937,
-0.25718915462493896,
0.1553126722574234,
-1.0569769144058228,
-0.11230150610208511,
-0.07107635587453842,
0.5584622621536255,
-0.8113651275634766,
1.0266268253326416,
0.43012121319770813,
-0.2703896164894104,
-0.9514505863189697,
-0.21162615716457367,
-0.06311620771884918,
-0.8561162948608398,
1.163536548614502,
-0.24932771921157837,
-0.21951188147068024,
0.5096485614776611,
-0.5879824161529541,
-0.9854783415794373,
1.3162953853607178,
0.624531090259552,
-0.5639967322349548,
-0.2610194981098175,
-0.0068136039189994335,
0.507318377494812,
-0.03146188333630562,
-0.21458029747009277,
0.4800903797149658,
0.4930992126464844,
0.043933238834142685,
-0.8590015769004822,
0.08509687334299088,
0.18309536576271057,
-0.4338396191596985,
0.0934842899441719,
-0.6085235476493835,
0.8063917756080627,
-0.30048614740371704,
-0.32071635127067566,
-0.15094366669654846,
0.5519514679908752,
-0.04665578529238701,
0.2577729821205139,
0.49886441230773926,
0.613835871219635,
0.6254155039787292,
-0.02787916362285614,
0.5786675810813904,
-0.2588522136211395,
0.4333983063697815,
1.3842042684555054,
0.2260933220386505,
0.3608594238758087,
0.4776204824447632,
-0.049771152436733246,
0.10646103322505951,
0.42360448837280273,
-0.10696402937173843,
0.7241118550300598,
0.11528550088405609,
0.0048334854654967785,
-0.30752286314964294,
-0.06228706240653992,
-0.4397239089012146,
0.3226412534713745,
0.22351861000061035,
-0.32849857211112976,
-0.5103487372398376,
0.08358673751354218,
0.02226014994084835,
-0.344455361366272,
-0.5425430536270142,
0.7614206671714783,
-0.11787280440330505,
-0.3481375277042389,
0.5583534240722656,
-0.6166228652000427,
0.5429822206497192,
-0.702285885810852,
-0.24699199199676514,
-0.35481390357017517,
0.22336870431900024,
-0.23672625422477722,
-0.4964085519313812,
-0.16964061558246613,
-0.14362064003944397,
-0.3568517565727234,
-0.4897463023662567,
0.8437083959579468,
-0.4091033935546875,
-0.3928706645965576,
0.38014718890190125,
0.635496973991394,
-0.08427149057388306,
0.08079242706298828,
-0.12227066606283188,
-0.2486472874879837,
0.04809609055519104,
-0.390170156955719,
0.47691887617111206,
0.7448309659957886,
-0.059677157551050186,
0.5430600047111511,
0.732943058013916,
0.000512876024004072,
0.09739475697278976,
0.1522316336631775,
0.9552772641181946,
-0.4881002604961395,
-0.7557506561279297,
-0.7794749140739441,
0.45758241415023804,
0.18816901743412018,
-0.27619507908821106,
0.6896318197250366,
0.39195379614830017,
0.8912727236747742,
-0.06013638898730278,
0.6052342653274536,
0.013547276146709919,
0.5266963839530945,
-0.5722516179084778,
1.1722477674484253,
-0.2857789397239685,
0.2784966230392456,
-0.4378267824649811,
-0.48021599650382996,
0.16275429725646973,
0.3569246828556061,
-0.2296592742204666,
-0.024914853274822235,
0.3024306297302246,
0.3068336248397827,
-0.46105697751045227,
-0.12274546921253204,
0.20362074673175812,
0.4904971122741699,
0.274823397397995,
0.6785292029380798,
0.7534428238868713,
-0.25067245960235596,
1.0110697746276855,
-0.4674879312515259,
-0.1602822095155716,
-0.4448058009147644,
-0.9781896471977234,
-0.968102216720581,
-0.6904422044754028,
-0.21208515763282776,
-0.22727325558662415,
0.09933146089315414,
0.4523008465766907,
1.0263396501541138,
-0.45546507835388184,
0.054334741085767746,
-0.07007847726345062,
0.209109365940094,
-0.2570149898529053,
-0.24574051797389984,
0.9952214956283569,
-0.4618297815322876,
-0.1658581644296646,
0.004835507832467556,
-0.08308002352714539,
0.21888844668865204,
-0.15983176231384277,
-0.08915480226278305,
0.24364764988422394,
-0.5575233697891235,
0.74582439661026,
0.34182363748550415,
-0.4692246615886688,
-0.45851781964302063,
0.20646752417087555,
0.08924491703510284,
-0.09724319726228714,
0.927451491355896,
-1.0658708810806274,
0.45178961753845215,
0.3013172745704651,
0.9640048742294312,
0.736030638217926,
-0.2278706580400467,
0.4979710578918457,
-0.9632561802864075,
-0.10526275634765625,
0.44056469202041626,
0.025687431916594505,
-0.0598783977329731,
-0.5885699391365051,
0.5898678302764893,
0.1325269490480423,
-0.41450822353363037,
-0.9004627466201782,
0.027676885947585106,
-1.002555012702942,
-0.05928264558315277,
0.6914102435112,
-0.2646893858909607,
-0.07134251296520233,
-0.22042711079120636,
-0.17270919680595398,
0.3888760805130005,
-0.4015589952468872,
0.9875341057777405,
0.8129512667655945,
-0.10614395886659622,
-0.2221176028251648,
-0.7628681063652039,
0.9785934090614319,
0.4069019556045532,
-0.6530382633209229,
0.5095701217651367,
0.27043649554252625,
0.23198452591896057,
0.10544106364250183,
0.4974443018436432,
0.19363416731357574,
0.28868889808654785,
-0.1501651108264923,
-0.07192768901586533,
-0.3342420160770416,
-0.15157385170459747,
0.12157129496335983,
0.20966188609600067,
-0.24692220985889435,
-0.2697383463382721
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06682v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06682v1
|
Restoring Ancient Ideograph: A Multimodal Multitask Neural Network Approach
| 2024-03-11T12:57:28 | 2024-03-11T12:57:28 |
Siyu Duan, Jun Wang, Qi Su
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.CY
|
Cultural heritage serves as the enduring record of human thought and history.
Despite significant efforts dedicated to the preservation of cultural relics,
many ancient artefacts have been ravaged irreversibly by natural deterioration
and human actions. Deep learning technology has emerged as a valuable tool for
restoring various kinds of cultural heritages, including ancient text
restoration. Previous research has approached ancient text restoration from
either visual or textual perspectives, often overlooking the potential of
synergizing multimodal information. This paper proposes a novel Multimodal
Multitask Restoring Model (MMRM) to restore ancient texts, particularly
emphasising the ideograph. This model combines context understanding with
residual visual information from damaged ancient artefacts, enabling it to
predict damaged characters and generate restored images simultaneously. We
tested the MMRM model through experiments conducted on both simulated datasets
and authentic ancient inscriptions. The results show that the proposed method
gives insightful restoration suggestions in both simulation experiments and
real-world scenarios. To the best of our knowledge, this work represents the
pioneering application of multimodal deep learning in ancient text restoration,
which will contribute to the understanding of ancient society and culture in
digital humanities fields.
|
[
-0.36553314328193665,
-0.7027462124824524,
0.3837568759918213,
-0.39540615677833557,
-0.5620211958885193,
0.05991308018565178,
-0.46233731508255005,
-0.41922783851623535,
0.2112262099981308,
0.6341966390609741,
-0.5428515076637268,
-0.07402373105287552,
-0.45665091276168823,
-0.03795454651117325,
-0.014105984009802341,
1.212195873260498,
-0.04904453828930855,
0.18375180661678314,
-0.24306903779506683,
-0.2095739096403122,
-0.5623441338539124,
-0.18930278718471527,
-0.7061761617660522,
-0.41660985350608826,
0.29920288920402527,
0.09678081423044205,
0.4290515184402466,
0.6511707901954651,
0.5274701118469238,
0.352908730506897,
0.22423240542411804,
0.582570493221283,
-0.4085705578327179,
-0.008255118504166603,
-0.11703599244356155,
0.010497746989130974,
-0.5872129201889038,
-0.10720329731702805,
0.5143751502037048,
0.35783934593200684,
0.2246839851140976,
0.0164430420845747,
0.43492287397384644,
0.6700141429901123,
-0.5999570488929749,
0.3922513425350189,
-0.36395540833473206,
0.07993918657302856,
-0.07730475068092346,
-0.8453544974327087,
-0.38093963265419006,
-0.19281905889511108,
0.09563259780406952,
-0.6174427270889282,
0.032657820731401443,
-0.19100522994995117,
0.33783042430877686,
0.43797051906585693,
-0.7723110318183899,
-0.13722780346870422,
-0.7947617173194885,
0.882362961769104,
-0.7675600647926331,
-0.09707130491733551,
0.5058494806289673,
-0.014513113535940647,
-0.038880281150341034,
-0.6210333704948425,
-0.6871731877326965,
-0.39685875177383423,
-0.24021276831626892,
0.3876881003379822,
0.20150427520275116,
-0.14292941987514496,
0.015619506128132343,
0.7576553821563721,
-0.4721456468105316,
-0.0594622828066349,
-0.29118189215660095,
-0.3688405454158783,
0.14739733934402466,
0.31783968210220337,
0.6164050102233887,
-0.41449928283691406,
-1.0048480033874512,
-0.4040382206439972,
-0.40106797218322754,
-0.0210166797041893,
0.14375263452529907,
0.08184109628200531,
0.12359058111906052,
0.0532618872821331,
-0.09278169274330139,
0.5915359854698181,
-0.46532270312309265,
-0.7664746642112732,
0.22686201333999634,
-0.8007019758224487,
-0.10497565567493439,
0.06139252334833145,
0.47914987802505493,
0.7813045382499695,
0.1178293377161026,
-0.13249552249908447,
0.11528967320919037,
0.268344521522522,
0.39390265941619873,
-0.6732504963874817,
-0.17662498354911804,
-0.3915104269981384,
-0.5381603240966797,
0.002575286664068699,
-0.1711619645357132,
-0.5782406330108643,
-0.795163094997406,
-0.5273762345314026,
0.32516053318977356,
-0.8815110921859741,
-0.7441509962081909,
0.08963239938020706,
-0.154641792178154,
-0.039960216730833054,
0.8213072419166565,
-0.6766378283500671,
-0.13896186649799347,
0.5771234035491943,
0.7906625270843506,
0.09291904419660568,
-0.5655915141105652,
0.13133877515792847,
0.299612820148468,
-0.1203276589512825,
0.5143257975578308,
-0.04970167949795723,
-0.2615292966365814,
-0.34875303506851196,
-0.01134306937456131,
0.04224977269768715,
-0.3381735384464264,
1.0398811101913452,
-0.3367977440357208,
0.12127002328634262,
0.12225762754678726,
-0.17171604931354523,
-0.7593169212341309,
0.8494318723678589,
-1.0732699632644653,
0.8334444761276245,
-0.23351401090621948,
-0.7132426500320435,
0.2258664220571518,
-0.22707197070121765,
-0.3653395175933838,
0.14461031556129456,
0.12188581377267838,
-0.4763215482234955,
-0.05127771198749542,
0.2050226926803589,
0.5230960845947266,
-0.2243979275226593,
0.07952284812927246,
-0.6194195747375488,
-0.06867461651563644,
0.009940080344676971,
-0.8124852180480957,
0.6220124363899231,
0.03700171038508415,
-0.6440231204032898,
-0.005125267896801233,
-0.6323687434196472,
0.050885215401649475,
-0.2903684079647064,
-0.4952561557292938,
-0.898112952709198,
-0.0399051234126091,
0.38115352392196655,
0.44474440813064575,
0.08445674926042557,
-0.6087193489074707,
0.45106741786003113,
-0.2887219488620758,
0.41143620014190674,
0.722213625907898,
-0.10985857248306274,
0.41174226999282837,
-0.7890384197235107,
0.18330244719982147,
-0.00814826413989067,
-0.3253859281539917,
-0.5360117554664612,
-0.24710582196712494,
-0.45772358775138855,
-0.5774938464164734,
-0.09586393088102341,
0.4552421569824219,
-1.1128461360931396,
-0.15876154601573944,
-0.7021884918212891,
-0.454527348279953,
-0.7858726382255554,
-0.1850728839635849,
0.5222812294960022,
0.7873135209083557,
0.29630082845687866,
-0.44398725032806396,
-0.6235408782958984,
-0.7343584895133972,
-0.0693414956331253,
-0.06134585663676262,
0.08721304684877396,
0.6719862818717957,
0.4854647219181061,
-0.21927018463611603,
0.3973240554332733,
0.19933351874351501,
-0.703280508518219,
0.08998783677816391,
0.2715580463409424,
0.061620619148015976,
0.6313434839248657,
0.4135289788246155,
-0.8447850346565247,
-0.45217904448509216,
0.15713125467300415,
-0.7539677619934082,
0.6037436127662659,
-0.4310489296913147,
0.057070694863796234,
0.07678456604480743,
0.307352751493454,
-0.35433441400527954,
0.5702118277549744,
0.5361810922622681,
-0.24231941998004913,
0.6514351963996887,
-0.5005671977996826,
0.8038561940193176,
-1.4160767793655396,
0.13120529055595398,
-0.3709490895271301,
-0.21241097152233124,
-0.5266401171684265,
0.11585918068885803,
0.15715835988521576,
-0.20335184037685394,
-0.3228062093257904,
0.8569638133049011,
-0.793516218662262,
0.38681691884994507,
-0.6263096928596497,
-0.007983896881341934,
0.14706802368164062,
0.3665575087070465,
0.026238899677991867,
0.4037673771381378,
0.5083911418914795,
-0.5301448106765747,
0.2338033765554428,
0.33543527126312256,
-0.4758031368255615,
0.809484601020813,
0.07875261455774307,
0.38032934069633484,
-0.35284513235092163,
0.2066938281059265,
-1.061107873916626,
-0.1170680820941925,
0.22072474658489227,
-0.46480458974838257,
0.29447734355926514,
-0.20675091445446014,
-0.5350117683410645,
-0.15463244915008545,
-0.6352571249008179,
0.6866050362586975,
-0.07931434363126755,
-0.5237886309623718,
0.9980483055114746,
0.13642476499080658,
-0.20058216154575348,
-0.746989905834198,
-0.4106197953224182,
0.4008741080760956,
-0.2649335265159607,
-0.8228539228439331,
0.5424827933311462,
-0.37134119868278503,
-0.10826576501131058,
0.10406336933374405,
0.19839227199554443,
0.055690426379442215,
0.44220229983329773,
0.4365171492099762,
0.33197125792503357,
-0.4115125238895416,
0.2818416953086853,
-0.27568820118904114,
-0.06469853222370148,
-0.34819743037223816,
-0.14534012973308563,
0.6904194355010986,
-0.26919907331466675,
-0.21455372869968414,
-0.7420276403427124,
0.40241625905036926,
1.0484135150909424,
-0.3856828510761261,
0.5349431037902832,
0.6662644147872925,
-0.5208803415298462,
0.2093786895275116,
-0.6612524390220642,
-0.1930243819952011,
-0.3751620948314667,
0.5525431036949158,
-0.33815905451774597,
-0.39911115169525146,
0.24660679697990417,
-0.2725529074668884,
-0.22737689316272736,
0.6186627745628357,
0.9010835886001587,
-0.2104131132364273,
0.45315876603126526,
0.6166360974311829,
-0.28211116790771484,
0.41756632924079895,
-0.3528534471988678,
-0.09155909717082977,
-0.9321434497833252,
-0.36865559220314026,
0.12142255902290344,
-0.5357503294944763,
0.03211866691708565,
-0.13980893790721893,
0.3816734552383423,
0.020718006417155266,
0.26868972182273865,
0.14237411320209503,
-0.3137792646884918,
0.11990339308977127,
0.767250120639801,
0.8118438124656677,
0.4669313132762909,
0.1663835495710373,
-0.026834359392523766,
0.06011679023504257,
-0.19405049085617065,
-0.8310194611549377,
0.9776626825332642,
-0.06661950051784515,
0.5804167985916138,
0.13537728786468506,
0.5168747901916504,
0.3849135637283325,
0.46160292625427246,
-0.8052026033401489,
0.23074714839458466,
-0.15646764636039734,
-0.6312847137451172,
-0.41158488392829895,
-0.1988488882780075,
-0.756351113319397,
0.2743523120880127,
-0.5184435248374939,
-0.336126446723938,
-0.04252564162015915,
0.4200702905654907,
-0.7295065522193909,
0.8524190783500671,
-0.4519365727901459,
0.7940630316734314,
-0.29576054215431213,
-0.3660176992416382,
-0.6103955507278442,
-0.6641764044761658,
0.31048738956451416,
-0.0504530668258667,
0.33198973536491394,
-0.12468994408845901,
0.3295081853866577,
0.4228425920009613,
-0.062255751341581345,
0.7803283929824829,
0.003942444454878569,
0.23799489438533783,
-0.14016056060791016,
0.2001308649778366,
0.37572795152664185,
0.011003642342984676,
-0.13766539096832275,
-0.40001145005226135,
-0.10851592570543289,
-0.15618202090263367,
-0.28714701533317566,
0.8633419275283813,
-0.7024192214012146,
-0.3586139976978302,
-0.22677548229694366,
-0.9844991564750671,
0.2171001434326172,
0.35227319598197937,
-0.0007552437018603086,
0.5981760621070862,
-0.432334840297699,
0.36324864625930786,
0.4314157962799072,
-0.012809456326067448,
1.0710372924804688,
0.10631468892097473,
0.5719078183174133,
-0.6265761852264404,
0.6638980507850647,
-0.1761835366487503,
0.04444049298763275,
0.28322434425354004,
-0.012609043158590794,
0.07777263969182968,
-0.5337622165679932,
-0.8606324791908264,
0.01302595529705286,
-0.6054274439811707,
-0.2564852833747864,
-0.49660202860832214,
0.3889281451702118,
-0.22242674231529236,
0.12275862693786621,
-0.21535004675388336,
-0.2690650522708893,
-0.7601982355117798,
-0.06621214747428894,
0.2028096318244934,
0.38668715953826904,
0.04566891863942146,
0.16099518537521362,
-0.8819673657417297,
0.28911080956459045,
0.19237107038497925,
0.259260892868042,
0.3854025602340698,
-0.20165026187896729,
-0.2471240907907486,
0.12788289785385132,
-0.18365968763828278,
-0.6260110139846802,
0.5632041096687317,
0.49971985816955566,
0.45517709851264954,
0.48880985379219055,
0.10345257073640823,
0.6113380193710327,
-0.8613801002502441,
0.3598976731300354,
0.30233314633369446,
-0.44744744896888733,
0.09714692831039429,
-0.17483749985694885,
0.374804824590683,
0.5172301530838013,
0.3866669535636902,
-0.8051877617835999,
0.09824074059724808,
-0.3381716310977936,
-0.9441633820533752,
0.416199654340744,
-0.21267683804035187,
0.29952165484428406,
0.12592637538909912,
0.18038147687911987,
0.43035149574279785,
0.14765943586826324,
-0.8157592415809631,
-0.07127564400434494,
-0.6365220546722412,
-0.2076069563627243,
-0.3141939640045166,
-0.2786918878555298,
-0.19171082973480225,
-0.03215543180704117,
0.6235357522964478,
0.012398351915180683,
0.19298508763313293,
0.03468728065490723,
-0.7682632803916931,
0.18476034700870514,
0.38388875126838684,
0.8722133040428162,
0.5934046506881714,
-0.02915889583528042,
0.5085406303405762,
-0.08859340846538544,
-0.5211188197135925,
0.07914818823337555,
0.28147703409194946,
0.017667541280388832,
-0.37267711758613586,
0.40405604243278503,
1.059583306312561,
-0.044807318598032,
-0.43036124110221863,
0.4467598497867584,
-0.03578340634703636,
0.1655580699443817,
-0.7899328470230103,
-0.4441749155521393,
0.08499293029308319,
0.5897859334945679,
0.7363492846488953,
0.5843958258628845,
0.13386563956737518,
-0.9256837964057922,
0.34549573063850403,
0.5118367075920105,
-0.3719426393508911,
-0.22743986546993256,
0.7492151856422424,
0.08389284461736679,
-0.4243587553501129,
0.8178688287734985,
0.1665864735841751,
-0.4356197118759155,
0.4876609146595001,
0.41895878314971924,
0.4413820803165436,
-0.09205297380685806,
0.05570822209119797,
0.43959882855415344,
0.41090884804725647,
-0.04828799143433571,
0.11937523633241653,
0.04870806634426117,
-0.5659562945365906,
-0.40044867992401123,
-0.43622851371765137,
-0.046831563115119934,
0.1476084291934967,
-0.3676971197128296,
-0.20697268843650818,
-0.28082215785980225,
-0.3475252091884613,
-0.033264126628637314,
-0.07676087319850922,
-0.7333818674087524,
0.3132384121417999,
0.36498504877090454,
0.4146316945552826,
-0.5807762145996094,
0.8978228569030762,
0.4533708691596985,
-0.4254453480243683,
-0.4322964549064636,
-0.1735808402299881,
0.13021427392959595,
-0.6586117148399353,
0.613948404788971,
0.2010190337896347,
-0.3112901747226715,
0.1991632878780365,
-0.2128387987613678,
-0.6432697176933289,
1.2215461730957031,
0.28018519282341003,
-0.15702368319034576,
-0.03721561282873154,
-0.12429847568273544,
0.4333919286727905,
0.03688681870698929,
0.18174834549427032,
-0.19208326935768127,
0.48051056265830994,
-0.40938276052474976,
-1.1478123664855957,
0.3237820565700531,
-0.5893173813819885,
-0.1597907394170761,
0.28170788288116455,
-0.25771570205688477,
0.975688099861145,
-0.29456064105033875,
-0.19597136974334717,
0.7627478241920471,
0.41394147276878357,
0.03684203699231148,
0.1544199287891388,
0.637521505355835,
0.8216850757598877,
0.7235385179519653,
-0.0811520367860794,
1.1736843585968018,
-0.3008024990558624,
0.24311363697052002,
0.9540278315544128,
0.18650172650814056,
0.5521255731582642,
0.5296159982681274,
0.4709807336330414,
0.5288717150688171,
0.3975457549095154,
-0.0384809635579586,
0.8551996946334839,
-0.01650296151638031,
-0.6404800415039062,
-0.04318154603242874,
-0.25782305002212524,
-0.5359386205673218,
0.5002433061599731,
0.11814260482788086,
-0.6020156741142273,
-0.1786981076002121,
0.6657734513282776,
0.23373576998710632,
-0.10306837409734726,
-0.6595679521560669,
0.8023996949195862,
-0.18353912234306335,
-0.658888578414917,
0.38292577862739563,
-0.018154840916395187,
0.6650699973106384,
-0.38211554288864136,
-0.31011059880256653,
-0.1787814348936081,
0.8267295360565186,
0.0022467433009296656,
-0.4117111265659332,
0.18439048528671265,
-0.9985564947128296,
-0.3595838248729706,
-0.5465131402015686,
0.7916713953018188,
-0.5221009254455566,
-0.10432662814855576,
0.24366837739944458,
0.2281413972377777,
-0.00041356394649483263,
-0.36641213297843933,
-0.392407089471817,
-0.3843306005001068,
0.014842689037322998,
-0.021521318703889847,
0.24105675518512726,
0.47473055124282837,
0.034566909074783325,
0.5012842416763306,
0.6502178907394409,
-0.19431573152542114,
0.03584756329655647,
-0.1618977040052414,
0.7951523065567017,
-0.3659746050834656,
-0.2803347110748291,
-1.1667042970657349,
0.8988470435142517,
0.09306541830301285,
-0.4615080952644348,
0.8893185257911682,
0.5297104716300964,
0.8701506853103638,
-0.5310892462730408,
0.6882449388504028,
0.30252811312675476,
0.42082783579826355,
-0.5788546800613403,
1.120928168296814,
-0.6568064093589783,
-0.3564566373825073,
-0.4995085895061493,
-0.35856640338897705,
-0.18943846225738525,
0.38729777932167053,
0.1598786562681198,
-0.271989643573761,
0.7469823360443115,
0.6436911821365356,
-0.27835121750831604,
-0.2689150869846344,
0.3198702037334442,
0.0690208226442337,
-0.17855694890022278,
0.45878833532333374,
0.8464658260345459,
-0.19564007222652435,
0.8766970634460449,
-0.4040098190307617,
-0.5179318785667419,
-0.08945297449827194,
-0.8511938452720642,
-0.6088292002677917,
-0.943614661693573,
0.02036428265273571,
-0.28154417872428894,
-0.05650833621621132,
0.7216716408729553,
0.4827177822589874,
-0.5217736959457397,
-0.18870975077152252,
0.6426600217819214,
-0.2799904942512512,
-0.5020706653594971,
-0.14140401780605316,
0.7428950071334839,
0.1675771176815033,
-0.6536937355995178,
0.5058960318565369,
0.4945231080055237,
-0.005418406333774328,
-0.21456362307071686,
-0.08563189208507538,
-0.46347421407699585,
-0.5350227952003479,
0.7183277606964111,
0.21866431832313538,
-0.7809994220733643,
-0.33268973231315613,
0.12330086529254913,
-0.11823073029518127,
0.3168533742427826,
1.0425729751586914,
-0.9384169578552246,
0.8727418780326843,
0.3896229863166809,
0.748569905757904,
0.7069973349571228,
-0.36996006965637207,
0.38749098777770996,
-0.6769397854804993,
0.21732091903686523,
0.5695040225982666,
0.9511879086494446,
0.5030627846717834,
-0.317830890417099,
0.41910412907600403,
0.3383445143699646,
-0.37557217478752136,
-0.523481011390686,
0.26976922154426575,
-1.1087254285812378,
-0.6208400726318359,
0.7661808133125305,
-0.24601517617702484,
0.04168049246072769,
-0.07604271918535233,
-0.5856679677963257,
0.662848949432373,
0.0649479404091835,
1.1022460460662842,
0.7534651160240173,
0.28629443049430847,
-0.5335536003112793,
-0.535044252872467,
0.44411948323249817,
0.3197859525680542,
-0.7798088788986206,
-0.11718767136335373,
0.6613409519195557,
0.20097869634628296,
0.4870780110359192,
0.7040128111839294,
-0.14364054799079895,
0.3332214057445526,
-0.3741137385368347,
0.39601847529411316,
-0.3626292645931244,
-0.2120165377855301,
0.10865209996700287,
0.26571816205978394,
-0.23842574656009674,
-0.28831011056900024
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06644v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06644v1
|
Elephants Never Forget: Testing Language Models for Memorization of Tabular Data
| 2024-03-11T12:07:13 | 2024-03-11T12:07:13 |
Sebastian Bordt, Harsha Nori, Rich Caruana
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
While many have shown how Large Language Models (LLMs) can be applied to a
diverse set of tasks, the critical issues of data contamination and
memorization are often glossed over. In this work, we address this concern for
tabular data. Starting with simple qualitative tests for whether an LLM knows
the names and values of features, we introduce a variety of different
techniques to assess the degrees of contamination, including statistical tests
for conditional distribution modeling and four tests that identify
memorization. Our investigation reveals that LLMs are pre-trained on many
popular tabular datasets. This exposure can lead to invalid performance
evaluation on downstream tasks because the LLMs have, in effect, been fit to
the test set. Interestingly, we also identify a regime where the language model
reproduces important statistics of the data, but fails to reproduce the dataset
verbatim. On these datasets, although seen during training, good performance on
downstream tasks might not be due to overfitting. Our findings underscore the
need for ensuring data integrity in machine learning tasks with LLMs. To
facilitate future research, we release an open-source tool that can perform
various tests for memorization
\url{https://github.com/interpretml/LLM-Tabular-Memorization-Checker}.
|
[
-0.03424495831131935,
-0.9726220369338989,
0.46029025316238403,
0.1890212744474411,
-0.056537024676799774,
-0.1287628561258316,
-0.0907030701637268,
-0.33464160561561584,
-0.3114504814147949,
0.9379594922065735,
-0.15145765244960785,
-0.6263656616210938,
-0.49544352293014526,
-0.12889868021011353,
-0.9093915224075317,
1.1866880655288696,
-0.522506058216095,
-0.11361636966466904,
-0.43282943964004517,
-0.35990890860557556,
-0.398798406124115,
-0.6355724930763245,
-0.5065673589706421,
-0.37290844321250916,
0.5411571264266968,
0.468625545501709,
0.4257279932498932,
1.071074366569519,
0.5142475366592407,
0.21099212765693665,
-0.048011165112257004,
0.0798235759139061,
-0.6322506666183472,
0.24274851381778717,
-0.04137573018670082,
-0.6539961099624634,
-0.4998904764652252,
-0.22315602004528046,
0.6568926572799683,
0.7717663645744324,
-0.3698970675468445,
0.37075355648994446,
0.12834592163562775,
0.6742916107177734,
-0.5731614828109741,
0.3724142611026764,
-1.0492627620697021,
0.10121762007474899,
-0.3190394937992096,
-0.1821928173303604,
-0.36763834953308105,
-0.5019570589065552,
-0.1011086106300354,
-0.5256561636924744,
0.326347678899765,
0.1620863378047943,
1.0237382650375366,
0.3280527889728546,
-0.5120591521263123,
-0.20976746082305908,
-0.7537741661071777,
0.9020653963088989,
-0.2779415249824524,
0.5128034949302673,
0.8829401135444641,
0.32757115364074707,
-0.27277377247810364,
-0.7355784177780151,
-0.512182891368866,
-0.5427117943763733,
0.025677867233753204,
-0.07398088276386261,
0.02439962513744831,
-0.024874398484826088,
0.48727118968963623,
0.3709775507450104,
-0.657351016998291,
-0.027698887512087822,
-0.3079599440097809,
-0.17169027030467987,
0.3369710445404053,
0.12207967042922974,
0.5750119686126709,
0.24423055350780487,
-0.3899233937263489,
-0.1451311558485031,
-1.090678334236145,
-0.07422713190317154,
0.11453782767057419,
0.12375319004058838,
0.14007630944252014,
0.678798258304596,
0.0412045493721962,
0.47683364152908325,
-0.5095071792602539,
-0.12082743644714355,
0.20964239537715912,
-0.15522423386573792,
-0.4109143614768982,
0.12454098463058472,
0.4425017833709717,
-0.006558950059115887,
0.5619654655456543,
-0.28326427936553955,
-0.44120168685913086,
0.08380375057458878,
0.2999926507472992,
-0.49102720618247986,
-0.4845949411392212,
0.06383100897073746,
-0.22530660033226013,
-0.042994461953639984,
-0.46021750569343567,
-0.48357611894607544,
-0.4094424545764923,
-0.32918843626976013,
0.653093159198761,
-0.597547709941864,
0.03761151060461998,
0.04945726692676544,
0.1755036860704422,
-0.0030447314493358135,
0.26280394196510315,
-1.0215458869934082,
0.41612568497657776,
0.9115081429481506,
0.3531404137611389,
-0.042743757367134094,
-0.7073667645454407,
-0.6261234283447266,
0.31819403171539307,
-0.6440038681030273,
0.737960159778595,
-0.3361726701259613,
-0.24270223081111908,
0.0951569527387619,
-0.1525309532880783,
-0.15720488131046295,
-0.9002532362937927,
0.5146229267120361,
-0.4266330301761627,
-0.24283495545387268,
-0.5166999101638794,
-0.8429991006851196,
-0.18693961203098297,
0.35218900442123413,
-0.7874869704246521,
0.9976734519004822,
0.1157480999827385,
-0.677320659160614,
0.7019346356391907,
-0.25566089153289795,
-0.436323344707489,
-0.07360785454511642,
-0.35170695185661316,
-0.8620657920837402,
-0.16270694136619568,
-0.048449963331222534,
0.27035555243492126,
0.09423001855611801,
0.22745846211910248,
-0.507368266582489,
-0.32435792684555054,
0.323643296957016,
-0.30196985602378845,
0.42964380979537964,
0.006040952634066343,
-0.08046768605709076,
-0.09884550422430038,
-0.6583804488182068,
0.011960120871663094,
0.0847196877002716,
-0.4869298040866852,
-0.11059263348579407,
0.1457613706588745,
-0.03723795711994171,
-0.1318301111459732,
0.020110635086894035,
-0.27433305978775024,
0.09419760853052139,
0.2364027500152588,
0.17342987656593323,
0.5938206911087036,
0.03639373183250427,
0.23602816462516785,
-0.7553726434707642,
0.3607160151004791,
0.297012060880661,
0.049718841910362244,
-0.353716641664505,
-0.11324990540742874,
-0.9864553809165955,
-0.1346026360988617,
0.2553425431251526,
0.8240808248519897,
-0.5279989838600159,
0.27373024821281433,
-0.23092763125896454,
-0.6436502933502197,
-0.1434185653924942,
0.4828298091888428,
0.4080093801021576,
0.5394106507301331,
0.24090243875980377,
-0.22557663917541504,
-0.6291347742080688,
-0.849408745765686,
-0.4829593300819397,
-0.362470418214798,
-0.02264586091041565,
0.2746099829673767,
0.5830546617507935,
-0.0763043761253357,
0.7030139565467834,
-0.24030636250972748,
-0.46548643708229065,
-0.5065586566925049,
0.2578699588775635,
-0.0344112254679203,
0.4311816990375519,
0.4431927502155304,
-0.3252488374710083,
-0.23136912286281586,
-0.08592820167541504,
-0.7887222170829773,
-0.11294054239988327,
-0.029719848185777664,
0.06902600079774857,
0.28710246086120605,
0.5487060546875,
-0.8322513699531555,
0.3419613540172577,
0.27152636647224426,
-0.0681442990899086,
0.3981867730617523,
-0.3728512227535248,
-0.09268048405647278,
-0.5414316058158875,
0.20040063560009003,
-0.09175968170166016,
-0.29718437790870667,
-0.6350178718566895,
-0.2001391351222992,
0.3718927502632141,
0.012867860496044159,
-0.5421943068504333,
0.42998191714286804,
-0.4218330979347229,
-0.16788464784622192,
0.0742163211107254,
-0.09196095913648605,
-0.014352276921272278,
0.2069288045167923,
-0.18230773508548737,
0.8538752198219299,
0.5784532427787781,
-0.6623672842979431,
-0.17490991950035095,
0.2280794233083725,
-0.5920035243034363,
0.42475903034210205,
-0.508294939994812,
0.11768405884504318,
-0.19929955899715424,
0.07841095328330994,
-1.0126285552978516,
-0.013923071324825287,
-0.03406967222690582,
-0.20530828833580017,
0.4915160536766052,
-0.1863190084695816,
-0.7307727336883545,
-0.044122934341430664,
-0.07540322095155716,
0.1799374520778656,
0.5085154175758362,
-0.3979763984680176,
0.27284732460975647,
0.6472363471984863,
-0.06699367612600327,
-0.8119258284568787,
-0.6859982013702393,
-0.029170308262109756,
-0.600820004940033,
-0.27458298206329346,
-0.15218527615070343,
0.01765545830130577,
-0.17504355311393738,
-0.2776340842247009,
-0.2940024435520172,
-0.4706951081752777,
0.42831456661224365,
0.3283350467681885,
0.14514678716659546,
-0.10704934597015381,
0.374377578496933,
-0.25990405678749084,
0.0811798945069313,
0.047585006803274155,
0.01687677577137947,
0.5653921365737915,
-0.0780375674366951,
-0.46773967146873474,
-0.1968441754579544,
-0.141606405377388,
0.45435887575149536,
-0.1891011893749237,
0.6359311938285828,
0.5176433324813843,
-0.5746304392814636,
-0.39446529746055603,
-0.7488322257995605,
-0.08521761745214462,
-0.46897590160369873,
0.6401999592781067,
-0.2652188837528229,
-0.42274704575538635,
0.7203671336174011,
0.21503733098506927,
0.05630754306912422,
-0.02539541758596897,
0.18806082010269165,
-0.41925325989723206,
0.6042206287384033,
0.7150212526321411,
-0.41056227684020996,
0.4056277275085449,
-0.26986798644065857,
0.2592519223690033,
-0.43329352140426636,
-0.09906123578548431,
-0.6836812496185303,
-0.1865641474723816,
-0.5171875357627869,
-0.10625302046537399,
0.1533564329147339,
0.11093436181545258,
-0.30151233077049255,
0.08839678764343262,
0.16914716362953186,
0.7468500137329102,
0.20288997888565063,
0.008901330642402172,
0.31085658073425293,
0.05819695442914963,
0.03171703219413757,
-0.07089532166719437,
-0.4318197965621948,
-0.7844863533973694,
1.3135995864868164,
0.3676820397377014,
0.8662558794021606,
-0.31392061710357666,
0.765799343585968,
0.18533119559288025,
0.5454232692718506,
-0.4163488745689392,
0.6226410269737244,
-0.15981921553611755,
-0.4160524308681488,
-0.3912445604801178,
-0.5562677979469299,
-1.3325237035751343,
0.027709178626537323,
0.17541489005088806,
-0.7006939053535461,
-0.20068852603435516,
0.5118327736854553,
-0.12801535427570343,
0.4682837724685669,
-0.667572557926178,
1.0673143863677979,
-0.3901079297065735,
-0.1826038956642151,
0.060426015406847,
-0.16998162865638733,
0.48783135414123535,
-0.38745325803756714,
0.19004085659980774,
-0.26377052068710327,
-0.028267115354537964,
0.7934700846672058,
-0.15376755595207214,
0.6968863606452942,
0.029819315299391747,
0.09124653786420822,
0.1842152178287506,
0.5050707459449768,
0.4565935730934143,
-0.17533999681472778,
0.09826453030109406,
0.14961428940296173,
-0.011088515631854534,
-0.4137367606163025,
-0.4102605879306793,
0.6841074824333191,
-0.7422013282775879,
-0.4362494647502899,
-0.25017040967941284,
-0.6833391785621643,
-0.143964022397995,
0.27566155791282654,
-0.033091623336076736,
0.08106504380702972,
-0.24117733538150787,
0.2748604714870453,
1.0421438217163086,
-0.14319577813148499,
0.29626646637916565,
0.4768933653831482,
-0.3670854866504669,
-0.10510994493961334,
1.0896354913711548,
0.5143155455589294,
0.1952347457408905,
0.35250920057296753,
-0.02954229898750782,
-0.06179358810186386,
-0.8209875822067261,
-0.40969452261924744,
0.2195223718881607,
-0.6892436742782593,
-0.08600230515003204,
-0.6806630492210388,
-0.10009454935789108,
-0.05430939421057701,
0.2638169527053833,
-0.38767746090888977,
-0.41822853684425354,
-0.3207501471042633,
-0.3232054114341736,
0.44410350918769836,
0.8356901407241821,
0.042877763509750366,
0.1864970177412033,
-0.7319703102111816,
0.280413419008255,
0.2364678680896759,
0.38048380613327026,
-0.012963341549038887,
-0.3833887279033661,
-0.14896899461746216,
-0.1473199874162674,
-0.5221027135848999,
-0.7608563303947449,
0.5643925070762634,
0.3350573778152466,
0.7572310566902161,
0.359194278717041,
-0.3034605085849762,
0.5260571837425232,
-0.5895550847053528,
0.5781517028808594,
-0.35398802161216736,
-0.8825931549072266,
0.34916406869888306,
-0.4953869581222534,
-0.04908750578761101,
0.6895453333854675,
0.3204348385334015,
-0.6806747317314148,
-0.56479811668396,
-0.5748695135116577,
-0.9085061550140381,
0.563544511795044,
0.03110782615840435,
-0.06404721736907959,
0.17711374163627625,
0.3648523688316345,
0.22808878123760223,
0.42996466159820557,
-0.6344670653343201,
-0.3145396411418915,
-0.03985048085451126,
-0.24224023520946503,
-0.3186127245426178,
-0.41925033926963806,
0.026685206219553947,
-0.006517671048641205,
0.396554559469223,
0.3291551470756531,
-0.2571618854999542,
-0.09271439909934998,
-0.6259146928787231,
-0.20188617706298828,
0.22577236592769623,
0.553857147693634,
0.9741449356079102,
-0.22959184646606445,
0.264849990606308,
0.4070330560207367,
-0.6905131936073303,
0.2045089304447174,
-0.13037890195846558,
-0.25793272256851196,
-0.00412712199613452,
0.32628005743026733,
0.5594877600669861,
0.20670576393604279,
-0.6716844439506531,
0.25584492087364197,
0.09367848187685013,
-0.00283322692848742,
-0.629884660243988,
0.16731037199497223,
0.16601276397705078,
-0.2706904411315918,
0.21515390276908875,
-0.20417700707912445,
-0.0667959600687027,
-0.7215467095375061,
0.575507402420044,
0.25063127279281616,
-0.21506795287132263,
-0.1751386672258377,
0.49475300312042236,
-0.5150394439697266,
-0.28832486271858215,
0.7688235640525818,
-0.07697950303554535,
-0.636539876461029,
0.8402870893478394,
0.4265531599521637,
0.5458253026008606,
-0.5187097191810608,
-0.04504229500889778,
0.03972489386796951,
0.6396334171295166,
-0.19312341511249542,
0.5206931829452515,
0.020666562020778656,
-0.5356919169425964,
-0.11816900968551636,
-0.32458531856536865,
-0.48704981803894043,
0.5680006742477417,
-0.5428161025047302,
0.21118395030498505,
-0.39135780930519104,
-0.0019488733960315585,
-0.12835083901882172,
-0.05290902405977249,
-0.8213111162185669,
0.2003147155046463,
0.13289591670036316,
0.8741312026977539,
-1.119760513305664,
0.8644355535507202,
0.4073159992694855,
-0.37875184416770935,
-0.7540798187255859,
-0.08219875395298004,
-0.1375844031572342,
-0.9219643473625183,
0.8772661089897156,
0.08285875618457794,
0.4796338379383087,
-0.4003188908100128,
-0.31078287959098816,
-0.9332523941993713,
0.8374162316322327,
0.4885796308517456,
-0.36905550956726074,
0.2724522650241852,
0.710687518119812,
0.5925668478012085,
0.08083397895097733,
0.49672213196754456,
1.015563726425171,
0.4976300001144409,
-0.3165162205696106,
-1.0552526712417603,
-0.21280570328235626,
-0.0135775376111269,
-0.1945621818304062,
0.29176121950149536,
-0.4409557282924652,
1.0450084209442139,
-0.16841046512126923,
-0.07256220281124115,
-0.09219740331172943,
0.4990367293357849,
0.48505914211273193,
0.5909795761108398,
0.47847867012023926,
0.8551323413848877,
0.9978537559509277,
-0.17270687222480774,
1.0329883098602295,
-0.010562820360064507,
0.33924615383148193,
1.2289563417434692,
-0.6719006896018982,
0.9923560619354248,
0.5272499918937683,
-0.15931196510791779,
-0.051532939076423645,
0.59084153175354,
-0.06534916907548904,
0.36588478088378906,
0.5874444246292114,
0.06246952712535858,
-0.07168547064065933,
-0.040065567940473557,
-0.17648208141326904,
0.3701529800891876,
0.4944274127483368,
-0.19875359535217285,
-0.4918164908885956,
-0.11529851704835892,
0.293348491191864,
0.025497181341052055,
-0.22479549050331116,
0.7166376709938049,
0.13036398589611053,
-0.4962007701396942,
0.7442336678504944,
-0.48347705602645874,
0.0022173551842570305,
-0.561996579170227,
-0.10979904234409332,
-0.6799650192260742,
0.424111545085907,
-0.09114303439855576,
-0.7938380241394043,
0.2527693212032318,
-0.08933620899915695,
-0.0485663115978241,
-0.34171995520591736,
0.47377392649650574,
-0.750722348690033,
-0.3928984999656677,
0.21620720624923706,
0.43637749552726746,
0.4603182077407837,
-0.09337342530488968,
-0.39616307616233826,
0.23109205067157745,
-0.05042658746242523,
-0.23373742401599884,
0.4833429753780365,
0.47494304180145264,
-0.13671721518039703,
1.2218462228775024,
0.3908940255641937,
0.3975309133529663,
0.38510316610336304,
0.13624702394008636,
0.5775123834609985,
-0.5508279204368591,
-0.246507465839386,
-1.0001507997512817,
0.18484120070934296,
0.14811934530735016,
-0.029841575771570206,
0.8662060499191284,
0.917493999004364,
0.9037166237831116,
-0.13018448650836945,
0.6307920813560486,
0.736855685710907,
0.6001101732254028,
-0.5048182606697083,
1.129706621170044,
-0.3029206693172455,
0.2905663847923279,
-0.09299638867378235,
-0.7693365812301636,
-0.343801349401474,
0.3520503640174866,
-0.33416423201560974,
0.03897317498922348,
0.8325213193893433,
0.7725278735160828,
-0.2487236112356186,
-0.08690950274467468,
0.4362151622772217,
0.3629003167152405,
0.4596026539802551,
0.7459430694580078,
1.0314558744430542,
-0.46318820118904114,
0.8809236288070679,
-0.33636313676834106,
0.08930882066488266,
-0.20726735889911652,
-0.8237294554710388,
-0.898339033126831,
-0.40469151735305786,
-0.41110843420028687,
-0.16561296582221985,
0.21273723244667053,
0.45485350489616394,
0.5447660088539124,
-0.8654874563217163,
-0.4320586323738098,
-0.016130205243825912,
0.35873743891716003,
-0.07814211398363113,
-0.17602339386940002,
0.5918210744857788,
-0.5620912313461304,
-0.32094115018844604,
0.13732734322547913,
0.03942503780126572,
0.3642617464065552,
-0.013726050034165382,
0.31310826539993286,
0.30678790807724,
-0.10859762877225876,
0.23617048561573029,
0.28304365277290344,
-0.3816511631011963,
-0.1825202852487564,
-0.09154514223337173,
-0.23942816257476807,
0.24791154265403748,
0.8370450735092163,
-0.588756263256073,
0.17875322699546814,
0.44547349214553833,
0.6025359630584717,
0.4236254394054413,
-0.19264085590839386,
0.38146641850471497,
-0.623098611831665,
-0.0033496622927486897,
0.20164716243743896,
0.7175710797309875,
0.41343870759010315,
-0.3081393837928772,
0.23510287702083588,
-0.12948951125144958,
-0.8557775020599365,
-1.2202016115188599,
0.06959857046604156,
-0.7797678112983704,
0.17155008018016815,
0.9003798961639404,
-0.3795580565929413,
-0.4530749022960663,
-0.21105560660362244,
-0.07905124127864838,
0.3567635416984558,
-0.23114003241062164,
1.2345249652862549,
0.6868157386779785,
0.25902247428894043,
-0.17510388791561127,
-0.9819664359092712,
0.6559670567512512,
0.6245326399803162,
-0.9369658827781677,
0.3977513313293457,
0.21856370568275452,
0.6338663697242737,
-0.1604251265525818,
0.4449281692504883,
-0.01180447917431593,
0.20315998792648315,
-0.1338847130537033,
0.11218297481536865,
0.038909122347831726,
-0.33469459414482117,
-0.24447716772556305,
-0.004562112037092447,
0.2788349390029907,
-0.41837844252586365
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06642v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06642v2
|
TRAWL: External Knowledge-Enhanced Recommendation with LLM Assistance
| 2024-03-11T12:04:20 | 2024-05-24T09:09:35 |
Weiqing Luo, Chonggang Song, Lingling Yi, Gong Cheng
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Combining semantic information with behavioral data is a crucial research
area in recommender systems. A promising approach involves leveraging external
knowledge to enrich behavioral-based recommender systems with abundant semantic
information. However, this approach faces two primary challenges: denoising raw
external knowledge and adapting semantic representations. To address these
challenges, we propose an External Knowledge-Enhanced Recommendation method
with LLM Assistance (TRAWL). This method utilizes large language models (LLMs)
to extract relevant recommendation knowledge from raw external data and employs
a contrastive learning strategy for adapter training. Experiments on public
datasets and real-world online recommender systems validate the effectiveness
of our approach.
|
[
-0.26717329025268555,
-0.3718737065792084,
0.5306615829467773,
-0.018168488517403603,
-0.4322716295719147,
0.13087767362594604,
-0.27613165974617004,
-0.7977069020271301,
0.25924840569496155,
0.571838915348053,
-0.8511188626289368,
-0.47549962997436523,
-0.5074098110198975,
-0.12816351652145386,
-0.051806285977363586,
1.1460524797439575,
0.10113757103681564,
0.11976281553506851,
-0.19810894131660461,
-0.32598793506622314,
-0.9559205770492554,
-0.3683586120605469,
-0.8179376721382141,
-0.28601229190826416,
0.4397744834423065,
0.4026874005794525,
0.4998857080936432,
0.35395926237106323,
0.6173338294029236,
0.2993744909763336,
-0.052332617342472076,
0.5932432413101196,
-0.772993803024292,
0.3117760717868805,
-0.5668095350265503,
-0.3154376149177551,
-0.2718791663646698,
-0.3569532036781311,
0.3184635043144226,
0.5563684701919556,
-0.2719648778438568,
0.1481010913848877,
0.17297548055648804,
0.9050824642181396,
-0.5948179364204407,
0.2795746624469757,
-0.664619505405426,
0.13096722960472107,
0.06737636774778366,
-0.0013662446290254593,
-0.20986148715019226,
-0.699272632598877,
0.6561776995658875,
-0.8686634302139282,
-0.08280933648347855,
0.17928484082221985,
0.33040300011634827,
0.025946540758013725,
-0.5612297058105469,
-0.47394636273384094,
-0.9722384810447693,
0.7189111709594727,
-0.7444201111793518,
0.5418218374252319,
0.4003892242908478,
0.28538310527801514,
-0.2915210425853729,
-0.7915056943893433,
-0.26509878039360046,
-0.31380024552345276,
-0.19027064740657806,
0.1623590886592865,
-0.2929764986038208,
0.0560724176466465,
0.083011195063591,
0.37554222345352173,
-0.34583187103271484,
-0.22731591761112213,
-0.4975842535495758,
-0.09140661358833313,
0.5763670206069946,
0.07306169718503952,
0.2434578388929367,
0.3387696146965027,
-0.2794298231601715,
-0.22997193038463593,
-0.5295620560646057,
0.07383895665407181,
0.17163988947868347,
0.4155130684375763,
-0.12906533479690552,
0.7272948622703552,
-0.2070605605840683,
0.47550150752067566,
0.21582092344760895,
-0.016080757603049278,
0.16918452084064484,
-0.3782021701335907,
-0.07948079705238342,
0.17557811737060547,
0.28617411851882935,
0.7234567999839783,
0.18533146381378174,
-0.14547258615493774,
-0.13614948093891144,
-0.08164647221565247,
0.2546719014644623,
-0.32013580203056335,
-0.19009079039096832,
0.07284091413021088,
-0.2947046756744385,
-0.1327507346868515,
0.14911261200904846,
-0.8541989326477051,
-0.9136274456977844,
-0.20212388038635254,
0.6947094202041626,
-0.4022221565246582,
-0.3232324719429016,
-0.04931502789258957,
-0.6281076669692993,
0.062424205243587494,
0.31083932518959045,
-0.5226452350616455,
0.36529579758644104,
0.3227185904979706,
0.911633312702179,
-0.19844388961791992,
0.04923618957400322,
-0.6229921579360962,
0.7107366323471069,
0.011514575220644474,
1.0453113317489624,
-0.713244616985321,
-0.541323721408844,
0.2653924822807312,
0.2354959100484848,
0.22101636230945587,
-0.45273953676223755,
0.405988872051239,
-0.6332886219024658,
0.24705077707767487,
-0.36370426416397095,
-0.6739173531532288,
-0.6333684325218201,
0.23344676196575165,
-0.7300175428390503,
1.0607551336288452,
0.3539717197418213,
-0.7526535987854004,
0.4251834750175476,
-0.8078721165657043,
-0.345857709646225,
0.05298120528459549,
0.39062148332595825,
-0.14513881504535675,
0.21718749403953552,
0.3057723343372345,
0.22004902362823486,
-0.22472551465034485,
0.26077115535736084,
-0.7079194188117981,
-0.35563719272613525,
0.029152311384677887,
0.08504462987184525,
0.2837139070034027,
-0.17006157338619232,
0.03542032465338707,
0.5622279047966003,
-0.7717636823654175,
-0.21728187799453735,
0.22624540328979492,
-0.45664942264556885,
-0.7517279982566833,
0.028747305274009705,
-0.06619712710380554,
0.10446227341890335,
0.28872042894363403,
-0.43372491002082825,
0.2680308520793915,
-0.761238157749176,
0.34636762738227844,
1.0095797777175903,
0.18257547914981842,
0.39633581042289734,
-0.6997128129005432,
0.3064877688884735,
0.16223281621932983,
-0.2732286751270294,
0.28942590951919556,
-0.24573640525341034,
-0.781798779964447,
0.15727649629116058,
0.09748315811157227,
0.41102901101112366,
-0.9418320655822754,
0.3496549129486084,
-0.26828980445861816,
-0.3905332684516907,
-0.44919130206108093,
0.3349166512489319,
0.21817710995674133,
0.2470724880695343,
0.6535753011703491,
-0.15801796317100525,
-0.9480983018875122,
-0.5619792938232422,
-0.29469457268714905,
0.0007305066101253033,
-0.14397747814655304,
0.4454604387283325,
0.17056074738502502,
-0.3809560537338257,
0.5943945050239563,
-0.6801851987838745,
-0.7345964312553406,
-0.45826584100723267,
-0.3371492922306061,
0.17517408728599548,
0.26451054215431213,
0.09418333321809769,
-0.33860597014427185,
-0.30998650193214417,
0.03150281310081482,
-0.6033971905708313,
0.12996236979961395,
0.28255951404571533,
-0.2251318395137787,
-0.09684053063392639,
0.31770673394203186,
-0.258157342672348,
0.08941961079835892,
0.3710712492465973,
-0.5107042193412781,
0.3368126451969147,
-0.7299807071685791,
-0.15917210280895233,
-1.0003831386566162,
-0.33525708317756653,
0.3744117319583893,
-0.288024365901947,
-0.5434445142745972,
0.037089504301548004,
-0.2289731353521347,
-0.01391531340777874,
-0.3286808133125305,
0.7324307560920715,
-0.15257295966148376,
0.05343121290206909,
-0.3282206058502197,
0.4529675245285034,
0.017726005986332893,
0.5859726071357727,
0.24417626857757568,
0.6418893337249756,
0.25595542788505554,
-0.8360642790794373,
0.7441673278808594,
0.36760786175727844,
-0.20409606397151947,
0.6571890115737915,
-0.5338351130485535,
0.37246787548065186,
-0.1009334996342659,
0.40575316548347473,
-0.9690066576004028,
0.032712601125240326,
0.1973627209663391,
0.3147142231464386,
-0.2372058779001236,
-0.3151867687702179,
0.021427642554044724,
-0.28399792313575745,
-0.8118268847465515,
0.2681713104248047,
0.3404648005962372,
-0.773297131061554,
0.9780758619308472,
0.5132690072059631,
-0.2629143297672272,
-0.33021318912506104,
-0.47458845376968384,
-0.2633269429206848,
-0.4840026795864105,
-0.508182942867279,
0.44953563809394836,
-0.2634052038192749,
-0.36639806628227234,
-0.024729255586862564,
-0.0819709375500679,
-0.059332866221666336,
-0.20987175405025482,
0.3033859431743622,
0.38022810220718384,
-0.3497426509857178,
0.3248703181743622,
-0.0623197928071022,
-0.014638237655162811,
-0.03448779135942459,
-0.7565321922302246,
0.3335305452346802,
0.02559424191713333,
-0.16428326070308685,
-0.20778888463974,
0.14506421983242035,
0.1767745316028595,
0.07808613032102585,
0.619700014591217,
0.9033320546150208,
-0.16619156301021576,
-0.23677390813827515,
-0.6788678169250488,
-0.20343616604804993,
-0.5687435865402222,
0.439239501953125,
-0.30963459610939026,
-0.5354371070861816,
0.17489279806613922,
-0.1630537360906601,
0.04293552786111832,
0.228231742978096,
0.2842402458190918,
-0.1536230742931366,
0.76957106590271,
0.8962254524230957,
-0.16546347737312317,
0.7015444040298462,
-0.3897463083267212,
-0.0745876282453537,
-1.1172410249710083,
-0.35985681414604187,
-0.1289629340171814,
-0.3770475387573242,
-0.589745044708252,
-0.14103609323501587,
0.10051947087049484,
-0.23991063237190247,
-0.2862092852592468,
0.3217540383338928,
-0.38659510016441345,
0.2934817373752594,
0.8058062195777893,
0.8048288226127625,
0.5990560054779053,
-0.03929263353347778,
-0.42635810375213623,
-0.10078290104866028,
-0.6134009957313538,
0.005924352910369635,
1.1036202907562256,
0.06043365225195885,
0.7591856122016907,
0.31885021924972534,
0.07695703208446503,
0.5999853610992432,
-0.005584274884313345,
-0.9881893992424011,
0.5379343032836914,
-0.3452780544757843,
-0.08456509560346603,
-0.10516299307346344,
-0.11814896762371063,
-0.7045028209686279,
0.33383476734161377,
-0.561769425868988,
-0.6528706550598145,
0.14520278573036194,
0.11853054165840149,
-0.18608905375003815,
0.2994256615638733,
-0.5328074097633362,
0.3303363621234894,
-0.09113211184740067,
-0.5523859262466431,
-0.5941200256347656,
-0.40588122606277466,
0.3537888526916504,
-0.09016836434602737,
0.45653408765792847,
-0.0029128268361091614,
-0.05226787179708481,
1.1526561975479126,
-0.3614886701107025,
0.8155509829521179,
-0.49644485116004944,
-0.21214309334754944,
0.024562619626522064,
0.3112296164035797,
1.1443663835525513,
0.05481749027967453,
-0.2732866406440735,
-0.13712161779403687,
0.22623547911643982,
-0.017977159470319748,
-0.4863819479942322,
0.7760940194129944,
-0.7989464998245239,
-0.7791889309883118,
-0.24814783036708832,
-0.9158955812454224,
-0.7005716562271118,
0.11617863923311234,
-0.2999453842639923,
0.5086162686347961,
0.042575620114803314,
0.25019535422325134,
0.43039193749427795,
-0.1482410430908203,
0.36618414521217346,
0.7491575479507446,
-0.21254593133926392,
-0.7600106000900269,
1.106850504875183,
-0.08350273966789246,
-0.166687473654747,
0.3298962116241455,
0.570743203163147,
-0.716678261756897,
-0.6194073557853699,
-0.1639363169670105,
0.304373562335968,
-0.9457478523254395,
-0.045114386826753616,
-0.49204638600349426,
0.02740558050572872,
-0.23447299003601074,
-0.11495368182659149,
0.019917897880077362,
-0.3831392526626587,
-0.03799654543399811,
-0.22280335426330566,
0.7707350850105286,
1.1427329778671265,
-0.02956577017903328,
0.36786895990371704,
-0.9634040594100952,
0.4215420186519623,
0.3437459468841553,
0.4157130718231201,
0.14946362376213074,
-0.6838040351867676,
-0.4245040714740753,
0.17330870032310486,
-0.03629813715815544,
-0.5260487794876099,
0.22275546193122864,
0.36036524176597595,
0.6598405241966248,
0.6128398776054382,
0.4007797837257385,
0.9496387243270874,
-0.2666409909725189,
0.6888584494590759,
-0.0030540425796061754,
-0.6351927518844604,
0.6096487641334534,
-0.24367792904376984,
0.3285742402076721,
0.4929591715335846,
0.4577924311161041,
-0.4576617181301117,
-0.4662402868270874,
-0.30287444591522217,
-0.7425429821014404,
0.641028642654419,
-0.1429160088300705,
0.08692570775747299,
0.4358418583869934,
0.200605109333992,
0.18389113247394562,
0.14823129773139954,
-0.8663135766983032,
0.001743575558066368,
-0.035306524485349655,
-0.4024551808834076,
-0.19411613047122955,
-0.4040512144565582,
-0.1652299165725708,
-0.2651018500328064,
0.8953338265419006,
-0.019536258652806282,
0.05900133401155472,
0.0928053930401802,
-0.46123600006103516,
-0.07595278322696686,
0.08627032488584518,
0.6333382725715637,
0.6767624616622925,
-0.2993967831134796,
0.06586125493049622,
0.671754002571106,
-0.47522711753845215,
0.2439376413822174,
-0.2477474808692932,
0.17799489200115204,
-0.21700286865234375,
0.38343068957328796,
0.6829720139503479,
0.41709640622138977,
-0.6186764240264893,
0.2115781605243683,
-0.08633925020694733,
0.035228289663791656,
-0.35839053988456726,
0.172035351395607,
0.17747925221920013,
0.4756945073604584,
0.3296917974948883,
-0.05929601565003395,
0.06593172252178192,
-0.4048863649368286,
0.07882393896579742,
0.6655296683311462,
-0.7403047680854797,
-0.28815874457359314,
0.06703343987464905,
0.42830345034599304,
-0.13169007003307343,
0.36826637387275696,
0.2398984730243683,
-0.24771100282669067,
0.16170969605445862,
0.8486544489860535,
0.5846284627914429,
-0.04201501980423927,
-0.06500615179538727,
0.22580963373184204,
-0.004240805748850107,
-0.1859743446111679,
0.15650726854801178,
-0.1601051241159439,
-0.7637919187545776,
-0.16645820438861847,
-0.40488025546073914,
-0.5428891777992249,
0.21617773175239563,
-0.6136021614074707,
0.44362175464630127,
-0.5873197913169861,
0.01080209482461214,
-0.27408382296562195,
0.16718950867652893,
-0.6668477654457092,
0.12014418095350266,
-0.16666309535503387,
0.8190140128135681,
-0.575645387172699,
0.8867142796516418,
0.8284118175506592,
-0.3935929238796234,
-0.6352580189704895,
0.012855106964707375,
-0.02325884997844696,
-0.9666457176208496,
0.6292946934700012,
-0.18861021101474762,
-0.5306861400604248,
0.16504691541194916,
0.009516177698969841,
-0.8322976231575012,
1.0613634586334229,
0.3260222375392914,
-0.5051730871200562,
-0.14247016608715057,
-0.18676015734672546,
0.3679577112197876,
-0.44156530499458313,
0.5880034565925598,
0.3238883316516876,
0.6432325839996338,
0.35997846722602844,
-0.6371545791625977,
0.3688236176967621,
0.004126487299799919,
0.19000005722045898,
-0.0661115050315857,
-0.3830552399158478,
0.1554291993379593,
-0.3911418914794922,
-0.10763687640428543,
-0.27052146196365356,
0.6795828342437744,
0.22684548795223236,
0.1643773466348648,
0.6226467490196228,
0.18441826105117798,
0.8923492431640625,
0.3288346230983734,
0.6609246134757996,
-0.2711941599845886,
-0.05677946284413338,
1.4684094190597534,
-0.552825391292572,
0.968049943447113,
0.43755921721458435,
-0.3097725808620453,
0.9677260518074036,
0.5938694477081299,
-0.225876584649086,
0.7193563580513,
-0.061911121010780334,
-0.22921325266361237,
-0.07390976697206497,
-0.5314727425575256,
-0.49537229537963867,
0.24432820081710815,
0.3500109910964966,
-0.10935056954622269,
-0.23424062132835388,
0.30218398571014404,
-0.5540710687637329,
-0.10916462540626526,
-0.4570409953594208,
1.4920425415039062,
0.08839088678359985,
-0.3055938184261322,
0.22846831381320953,
0.0019291897770017385,
0.8389236927032471,
-0.7664145231246948,
-0.2766447365283966,
-0.2395913153886795,
0.3032255470752716,
-0.3347998559474945,
-0.6515220999717712,
0.3319653868675232,
-0.34693190455436707,
-0.22795595228672028,
0.3127521872520447,
1.1569573879241943,
-0.41611114144325256,
-0.6218365430831909,
0.6393486261367798,
0.4818578064441681,
-0.23739507794380188,
0.07575926929712296,
-0.32701417803764343,
-0.3416188359260559,
-0.0706128403544426,
0.11145269870758057,
0.3478691279888153,
0.22895744442939758,
0.06526882946491241,
1.1875275373458862,
0.8093737959861755,
0.41637080907821655,
-0.2802373766899109,
-0.0593164823949337,
1.0021820068359375,
-0.8506126403808594,
-0.8162128925323486,
-0.8943883776664734,
0.3503415584564209,
-0.052781034260988235,
0.2640348970890045,
0.7556918859481812,
0.21105948090553284,
0.8706334829330444,
-0.26878565549850464,
0.7927054166793823,
0.2949349284172058,
0.4402922987937927,
-0.6799901723861694,
0.3489033877849579,
-0.3318810760974884,
0.6268024444580078,
0.055261801928281784,
-0.9757944941520691,
-0.03303058445453644,
0.2744985520839691,
-0.5157941579818726,
0.06588349491357803,
0.8283312320709229,
0.7840268611907959,
-0.20614232122898102,
0.06484440714120865,
0.30119869112968445,
0.1283399611711502,
0.011538319289684296,
0.6809664368629456,
0.9597680568695068,
-0.1752568930387497,
0.857012927532196,
-0.28836914896965027,
0.20276737213134766,
-0.3351244628429413,
-0.8243244290351868,
-1.037834644317627,
-0.47380921244621277,
-0.2285783588886261,
-0.5184634327888489,
0.4194670021533966,
1.4403364658355713,
0.727927029132843,
-0.965215802192688,
-0.3629300594329834,
-0.04602034389972687,
0.3469468653202057,
-0.39632102847099304,
-0.24812763929367065,
0.44704198837280273,
-0.04962952062487602,
-0.33620792627334595,
0.7622738480567932,
0.10963807255029678,
0.08466257899999619,
-0.27672502398490906,
-0.10537510365247726,
-0.12112368643283844,
0.10880418121814728,
0.5618202090263367,
-0.23725317418575287,
-0.6578444242477417,
-0.3702281415462494,
-0.5135747194290161,
0.2609417140483856,
0.12652985751628876,
0.9717647433280945,
-1.0443443059921265,
0.3591108024120331,
0.37807992100715637,
0.39717692136764526,
0.5448623299598694,
0.05767660588026047,
1.0787501335144043,
-0.6573925018310547,
0.19266648590564728,
-0.252836674451828,
0.43706876039505005,
0.20500558614730835,
-0.5817427635192871,
0.41161268949508667,
0.13882328569889069,
-0.07038814574480057,
-0.599784255027771,
0.07369975000619888,
-0.7829934358596802,
-0.19219255447387695,
1.1261998414993286,
-0.4166669249534607,
0.054243285208940506,
-0.49240991473197937,
-0.4372866749763489,
0.28076833486557007,
-0.7087269425392151,
0.7451617121696472,
0.5876744985580444,
0.01928795874118805,
-0.23909978568553925,
-0.3545398712158203,
0.4860324561595917,
-0.1430322378873825,
-0.7104966044425964,
0.039980705827474594,
0.22830834984779358,
0.4989110827445984,
-0.22273091971874237,
0.3173756003379822,
0.3626423478126526,
0.012817403301596642,
-0.2871539294719696,
-0.2108401358127594,
-0.4401338994503021,
0.002914228243753314,
-0.5639194250106812,
0.292799711227417,
0.357142835855484,
0.057637885212898254
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.