id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14562v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14562v1
|
The Era of Semantic Decoding
| 2024-03-21T17:06:17 | 2024-03-21T17:06:17 |
Maxime Peyrard, Martin Josifoski, Robert West
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.MA
|
Recent work demonstrated great promise in the idea of orchestrating
collaborations between LLMs, human input, and various tools to address the
inherent limitations of LLMs. We propose a novel perspective called semantic
decoding, which frames these collaborative processes as optimization procedures
in semantic space. Specifically, we conceptualize LLMs as semantic processors
that manipulate meaningful pieces of information that we call semantic tokens
(known thoughts). LLMs are among a large pool of other semantic processors,
including humans and tools, such as search engines or code executors.
Collectively, semantic processors engage in dynamic exchanges of semantic
tokens to progressively construct high-utility outputs. We refer to these
orchestrated interactions among semantic processors, optimizing and searching
in semantic space, as semantic decoding algorithms. This concept draws a direct
parallel to the well-studied problem of syntactic decoding, which involves
crafting algorithms to best exploit auto-regressive language models for
extracting high-utility sequences of syntactic tokens. By focusing on the
semantic level and disregarding syntactic details, we gain a fresh perspective
on the engineering of AI systems, enabling us to imagine systems with much
greater complexity and capabilities. In this position paper, we formalize the
transition from syntactic to semantic tokens as well as the analogy between
syntactic and semantic decoding. Subsequently, we explore the possibilities of
optimizing within the space of semantic tokens via semantic decoding
algorithms. We conclude with a list of research opportunities and questions
arising from this fresh perspective. The semantic decoding perspective offers a
powerful abstraction for search and optimization directly in the space of
meaningful concepts, with semantic tokens as the fundamental units of a new
type of computation.
|
[
-0.2344944328069687,
-0.582811713218689,
0.7624300122261047,
0.04644600674510002,
-0.1811695545911789,
0.27845269441604614,
-0.040865227580070496,
-0.48695138096809387,
0.3440355360507965,
0.6060619354248047,
-0.8430091738700867,
-0.5227555632591248,
-0.6952612996101379,
0.2396681010723114,
-0.48264065384864807,
0.7394150495529175,
-0.11269915848970413,
0.2453375607728958,
-0.38250473141670227,
0.08640561997890472,
-0.49687379598617554,
-0.48161765933036804,
-0.3558652698993683,
-0.17222291231155396,
0.30266016721725464,
0.06518112123012543,
0.6436039209365845,
0.7816945314407349,
0.46415242552757263,
0.39566561579704285,
-0.18710054457187653,
0.25155025720596313,
-0.5959838628768921,
0.20986361801624298,
-0.085758276283741,
-0.6410585045814514,
-0.24732543528079987,
-0.031809356063604355,
0.4901037812232971,
1.0811599493026733,
0.07084990292787552,
0.15284223854541779,
0.018427491188049316,
0.4773155152797699,
-0.8363533020019531,
0.45336848497390747,
-0.7750471234321594,
0.24715763330459595,
0.04517900571227074,
-0.6237043142318726,
-0.40049654245376587,
-0.022911464795470238,
-0.15600085258483887,
-0.8442766070365906,
0.034883756190538406,
0.13707147538661957,
0.5624599456787109,
0.5042129158973694,
-0.09217993170022964,
-0.32819509506225586,
-0.6914798021316528,
0.8482361435890198,
-0.3292076289653778,
0.4085722267627716,
0.1488107144832611,
0.07719773054122925,
-0.6442140340805054,
-0.8090684413909912,
-0.4965614378452301,
0.18431146442890167,
-0.020728377625346184,
-0.06754875928163528,
-0.3942568004131317,
0.371702641248703,
-0.12209822982549667,
0.3488098084926605,
-0.13251850008964539,
-0.023548860102891922,
-0.20537762343883514,
-0.5746595859527588,
0.23822090029716492,
0.5465610027313232,
0.47067326307296753,
-0.17565053701400757,
-0.501937210559845,
-0.027731385082006454,
-0.30623844265937805,
-0.12131549417972565,
0.11188463866710663,
0.06440331041812897,
0.30387082695961,
0.5174303650856018,
-0.400407075881958,
0.5483902096748352,
-0.40507975220680237,
0.11658016592264175,
0.05464927852153778,
-0.7006291747093201,
-0.1252388209104538,
0.06710855662822723,
0.2232780158519745,
0.37786591053009033,
0.011717159301042557,
-0.6633216142654419,
-0.25130876898765564,
0.6676969528198242,
0.4001288115978241,
-0.3065999448299408,
-0.0019660198595374823,
0.0762559026479721,
-0.5783924460411072,
-0.41033247113227844,
0.06932573765516281,
-0.41413044929504395,
-0.0766415074467659,
-0.4316340386867523,
0.30627205967903137,
-0.31509414315223694,
-0.09378530830144882,
0.723101794719696,
-0.5009412169456482,
0.5605787634849548,
0.2625974118709564,
-0.9860672354698181,
0.6568747162818909,
1.1961495876312256,
0.5696051716804504,
-0.07699565589427948,
-0.4403173327445984,
-0.3521982431411743,
0.42808589339256287,
-0.36317217350006104,
0.7156742215156555,
-0.541271984577179,
-0.5761597752571106,
-0.13739080727100372,
-0.12137600779533386,
-0.03801208734512329,
-0.32188355922698975,
0.46495747566223145,
-0.7898954749107361,
-0.09172084182500839,
-0.1528654247522354,
-0.7489489912986755,
0.09551302343606949,
0.2646764814853668,
-0.7583439946174622,
0.5928743481636047,
0.019488371908664703,
-0.6922093629837036,
0.37407106161117554,
-0.9478749632835388,
-0.2217344492673874,
0.1915423721075058,
-0.16948948800563812,
0.1066151112318039,
0.4548504054546356,
0.09579824656248093,
0.2890119254589081,
-0.40103879570961,
0.050579264760017395,
-0.06819544732570648,
-0.4063880741596222,
0.18806390464305878,
-0.21406550705432892,
0.6135730147361755,
0.4545705318450928,
-0.17340189218521118,
0.13585136830806732,
-0.7193288207054138,
0.29745975136756897,
0.24626538157463074,
-0.4324415624141693,
-0.34562528133392334,
0.0872747004032135,
-0.2148197889328003,
-0.11614881455898285,
0.5637315511703491,
-0.5831883549690247,
-0.23006245493888855,
-0.952813982963562,
0.7786309719085693,
0.8538246750831604,
-0.03006812557578087,
0.7987853288650513,
-0.036136314272880554,
0.4203167259693146,
0.005467801820486784,
0.21226321160793304,
-0.2752322554588318,
-0.20497792959213257,
-0.8467764258384705,
-0.018515920266509056,
-0.0700550526380539,
0.30890780687332153,
-0.652579665184021,
0.6540442705154419,
-0.2867240905761719,
0.13999220728874207,
-0.7634685039520264,
0.1114526018500328,
0.10374502092599869,
0.3929503858089447,
0.22264887392520905,
-0.1928938329219818,
-0.576740026473999,
-0.8405144214630127,
-0.5903504490852356,
-0.15269742906093597,
0.1547478437423706,
0.026256663724780083,
0.24294811487197876,
-0.26213955879211426,
0.9966341853141785,
-0.3972482681274414,
-0.1788782924413681,
-0.40017494559288025,
-0.31262072920799255,
0.22018496692180634,
0.3759031891822815,
0.05326277017593384,
-0.9126302599906921,
0.2158084660768509,
-0.11768423765897751,
-0.7633464932441711,
0.21714864671230316,
0.08691176772117615,
-0.5204992294311523,
0.12108665704727173,
0.7259715795516968,
-0.7014122605323792,
0.35424530506134033,
0.28050515055656433,
-0.4916445016860962,
0.25124871730804443,
-0.30496832728385925,
-0.25498852133750916,
-0.8562588691711426,
-0.119955874979496,
-0.8316963315010071,
0.12710125744342804,
-0.46189334988594055,
0.43031826615333557,
-0.374353289604187,
-0.01093326322734356,
-0.2973327040672302,
0.38676637411117554,
-0.6777967214584351,
-0.2797725200653076,
-0.3599623143672943,
0.11393380165100098,
0.23053932189941406,
0.4369989037513733,
-0.2349812239408493,
0.5394083857536316,
0.44596195220947266,
-0.2870941162109375,
0.5124134421348572,
0.23372824490070343,
-0.33650827407836914,
0.12819361686706543,
-0.3633947968482971,
0.21953877806663513,
-0.239906445145607,
0.18700510263442993,
-0.7789162397384644,
-0.1352180540561676,
0.1501908004283905,
-0.3429085314273834,
-0.17933662235736847,
0.08097831904888153,
-0.8542444109916687,
-0.18767210841178894,
-0.32809484004974365,
0.6363404393196106,
0.42562901973724365,
-0.3997209668159485,
0.6100746989250183,
0.5249886512756348,
0.35504648089408875,
-0.4584742486476898,
-0.656234860420227,
0.3978271484375,
-0.044751737266778946,
-0.9076369404792786,
0.33576005697250366,
0.2808566093444824,
-0.3371477723121643,
0.5227120518684387,
-0.1843022257089615,
0.1776781678199768,
0.4306267201900482,
0.043772973120212555,
0.39806699752807617,
-0.09124187380075455,
-0.11613860726356506,
-0.02778102457523346,
-0.6921549439430237,
0.35894787311553955,
-1.0177395343780518,
0.5780293941497803,
-0.30213528871536255,
-0.3817620873451233,
-0.3639817237854004,
0.5939468741416931,
0.36323419213294983,
-0.320783793926239,
0.6959503293037415,
0.6239867806434631,
-0.36500102281570435,
-0.19903281331062317,
-0.29260751605033875,
-0.12806615233421326,
-0.5003443956375122,
0.5127682089805603,
-0.49688205122947693,
-1.1420658826828003,
0.5450495481491089,
-0.3414947986602783,
-0.1632833182811737,
0.3547579050064087,
0.645189106464386,
0.0015022519510239363,
0.9172595143318176,
0.9323319792747498,
-0.029527049511671066,
0.4075253903865814,
-0.5549439191818237,
0.3585560917854309,
-0.7084639668464661,
-0.4326673448085785,
-0.37771907448768616,
-0.38606759905815125,
-0.5296947360038757,
-0.48770666122436523,
0.5591281652450562,
-0.03582456707954407,
-0.008251436054706573,
0.16532005369663239,
-0.6182990074157715,
0.7857151031494141,
0.479545533657074,
-0.08431527763605118,
0.2958245575428009,
0.062251750379800797,
-0.25015920400619507,
0.04313826933503151,
-0.8636434078216553,
-0.4109208285808563,
0.7497431635856628,
0.31417813897132874,
0.8012655973434448,
-0.09687130153179169,
0.9050886034965515,
0.2352001816034317,
-0.3779134452342987,
-1.0056840181350708,
0.733546793460846,
-0.11403462290763855,
-0.18213745951652527,
-0.3794659674167633,
-0.29903486371040344,
-1.3118270635604858,
0.2685636281967163,
-0.09086604416370392,
-0.695923924446106,
0.047128383070230484,
-0.21277308464050293,
-0.09021858870983124,
0.344178706407547,
-0.7249013185501099,
1.001632809638977,
0.04823797568678856,
-0.1405550092458725,
-0.6273993849754333,
-0.8568553924560547,
0.07519332319498062,
0.30358216166496277,
0.23539431393146515,
-0.17794297635555267,
-0.36556896567344666,
0.451211154460907,
-0.5056031942367554,
0.6911037564277649,
-0.09763818979263306,
-0.07346723973751068,
0.16330474615097046,
0.203713521361351,
0.4140724241733551,
-0.32956641912460327,
-0.08499639481306076,
0.11843947321176529,
0.30194616317749023,
-0.6083418130874634,
-0.64241623878479,
0.6067987680435181,
-0.8607111573219299,
-0.6077389121055603,
-0.04559401795268059,
-0.5718096494674683,
-0.1769670844078064,
0.370466411113739,
0.1358843594789505,
0.33203285932540894,
-0.3471689522266388,
-0.32049334049224854,
0.5372013449668884,
-0.03648855537176132,
0.2966203987598419,
-0.08547183871269226,
0.22480788826942444,
-0.1528649628162384,
0.8727979063987732,
-0.35927340388298035,
0.13548652827739716,
0.9013623595237732,
0.027704669162631035,
-0.2454553246498108,
-0.7211752533912659,
-0.16288495063781738,
0.19501753151416779,
-1.1257315874099731,
-0.11141595989465714,
-0.6624088883399963,
-0.1350640058517456,
-0.3176895081996918,
-0.3603198528289795,
-0.2950870990753174,
-0.3767576515674591,
-0.44925856590270996,
-0.10563560575246811,
0.1155300959944725,
0.7365397810935974,
0.06825032830238342,
-0.05659214034676552,
-0.8130281567573547,
0.1640036702156067,
-0.09490115940570831,
0.23046737909317017,
0.0709775984287262,
0.12260602414608002,
-0.42737120389938354,
-0.157291978597641,
0.05872156843543053,
-0.42228269577026367,
0.2592233717441559,
-0.18906140327453613,
0.7121570706367493,
-0.03259030357003212,
0.08112524449825287,
0.6453801393508911,
-0.49545344710350037,
0.6619414687156677,
0.08268854767084122,
-1.0054049491882324,
0.3779623210430145,
-0.0633091852068901,
0.24907951056957245,
0.48305192589759827,
-0.12914393842220306,
-0.665230929851532,
-0.42412737011909485,
-0.5631051063537598,
-1.0034890174865723,
0.8386369943618774,
0.17482739686965942,
0.4237636923789978,
-0.22251462936401367,
0.4761582911014557,
0.1252206414937973,
0.1197691336274147,
-0.24328497052192688,
-0.06665406376123428,
-0.031099198386073112,
-0.3160869777202606,
0.11074275523424149,
-0.2574893832206726,
-0.26160308718681335,
-0.05629132688045502,
-0.01041850820183754,
-0.11964581906795502,
0.5520911812782288,
0.14027200639247894,
-0.07930629700422287,
0.06116731837391853,
0.1909269094467163,
0.23408353328704834,
0.37929975986480713,
0.277090460062027,
0.4413052499294281,
0.08766723424196243,
-0.19628502428531647,
0.11155316978693008,
-0.2900933027267456,
0.12344831228256226,
-0.17478232085704803,
0.4396086037158966,
0.9516524076461792,
0.31167086958885193,
-0.609559178352356,
0.46218523383140564,
-0.04987053573131561,
-0.10417802631855011,
-0.5151638984680176,
0.30122441053390503,
-0.005707676522433758,
0.32786959409713745,
0.16632486879825592,
0.23746544122695923,
0.4540163576602936,
-0.6020830273628235,
0.1169864684343338,
0.5982807278633118,
0.08721292018890381,
-0.35619422793388367,
0.7254900932312012,
0.3330751359462738,
-0.3660792410373688,
0.5402888059616089,
-0.11309365183115005,
-0.4038555324077606,
0.5148330330848694,
0.3968515396118164,
1.17896568775177,
0.6820357441902161,
-0.10272578150033951,
-0.19046276807785034,
0.10211444646120071,
0.1017087772488594,
0.08351999521255493,
-0.5977904200553894,
-1.0241918563842773,
-0.6116663813591003,
-0.9868690967559814,
-0.14665822684764862,
-0.3878898620605469,
-0.5968403816223145,
0.16972127556800842,
-0.4233962297439575,
-0.08260823786258698,
0.007420287933200598,
-0.036860112100839615,
-0.5926538109779358,
-0.2739664912223816,
0.195944681763649,
1.039770483970642,
-0.237494558095932,
0.6204412579536438,
0.598980724811554,
0.07608697563409805,
-0.5453217625617981,
-0.11112815886735916,
-0.07056184113025665,
-1.1918468475341797,
0.7666441798210144,
-0.04891131818294525,
-0.7164954543113708,
0.2888581454753876,
-0.40432262420654297,
-0.9166561365127563,
1.06523597240448,
0.540395200252533,
0.0437321811914444,
-0.5115513205528259,
0.26992470026016235,
0.6076726913452148,
-0.44935718178749084,
-0.33394795656204224,
0.7066502571105957,
0.34019798040390015,
0.07764989882707596,
-0.7089676260948181,
0.06905839592218399,
-0.36232367157936096,
0.3534599542617798,
0.4718282222747803,
-0.4443484842777252,
0.44642841815948486,
-0.1898401379585266,
-0.5019620060920715,
0.4735278785228729,
0.5492175221443176,
-0.23181360960006714,
0.2618325352668762,
0.39004597067832947,
0.4454571008682251,
0.3770347833633423,
-0.009151077829301357,
1.155074119567871,
-0.5350149869918823,
0.12964177131652832,
0.34953176975250244,
0.07813824713230133,
0.5641161799430847,
0.8226062059402466,
-0.14659374952316284,
0.3796396255493164,
0.37804874777793884,
0.1524529606103897,
0.6057961583137512,
0.27983328700065613,
-0.2786945700645447,
-0.40677231550216675,
-0.15502870082855225,
0.1739344298839569,
0.5926892161369324,
0.5522913932800293,
-0.11351273953914642,
-0.4532891809940338,
0.043495725840330124,
-0.28617754578590393,
0.23573711514472961,
-0.09224424511194229,
1.1967910528182983,
0.025977013632655144,
-0.39052197337150574,
0.5341469645500183,
0.2749277353286743,
0.5674651861190796,
-0.5042612552642822,
0.0026692699175328016,
0.06656820327043533,
0.10049320012331009,
-0.10110825300216675,
-0.6324548721313477,
0.5554421544075012,
-0.3561098873615265,
-0.21068450808525085,
-0.4855780005455017,
0.8523576855659485,
-0.0210218895226717,
-0.25260087847709656,
0.5915483236312866,
0.5799950361251831,
0.366664320230484,
0.33080172538757324,
-0.6343402862548828,
0.5114271640777588,
-0.1522449105978012,
0.14164650440216064,
0.27543190121650696,
0.7087409496307373,
0.05765128880739212,
0.6272851824760437,
0.6997167468070984,
0.2061837613582611,
0.13348093628883362,
0.05268703028559685,
1.05134117603302,
-0.9515804052352905,
-0.8018227219581604,
-0.8202691674232483,
0.0322994589805603,
0.32644110918045044,
0.04666074365377426,
0.48906633257865906,
0.27927201986312866,
1.2093064785003662,
0.19712786376476288,
0.5366181135177612,
0.08531861752271652,
0.08346539735794067,
-0.8163803815841675,
0.32650578022003174,
-0.452349454164505,
0.40079987049102783,
-0.05611656606197357,
-0.686785876750946,
-0.3565581440925598,
0.4753631055355072,
-0.15888944268226624,
-0.15904200077056885,
0.4464840292930603,
0.6885840892791748,
0.20015303790569305,
0.15194416046142578,
0.44472652673721313,
0.014885198324918747,
0.2127331793308258,
0.7250842452049255,
1.2281841039657593,
-0.10799384117126465,
0.5348015427589417,
-0.008496523834764957,
-0.09512285888195038,
-0.18834976851940155,
-0.4456583261489868,
-0.46740099787712097,
-0.6585564613342285,
0.1954329013824463,
-0.1290765404701233,
0.02076936513185501,
0.9415044188499451,
0.4915662705898285,
-0.25113290548324585,
-0.3158171474933624,
-0.5116713643074036,
0.32792264223098755,
-0.06347261369228363,
-0.26299890875816345,
0.1324208676815033,
-0.916893482208252,
-0.8183478713035583,
0.35014957189559937,
0.6910629868507385,
-0.09369056671857834,
-0.5661134719848633,
-0.22706696391105652,
0.3396371901035309,
-0.042098451405763626,
0.703463613986969,
-0.08216026425361633,
-0.8874941468238831,
-0.08267031610012054,
0.32390066981315613,
-0.13017044961452484,
-0.008417923003435135,
1.1280418634414673,
-0.85396808385849,
0.4020856022834778,
0.5031226277351379,
1.0575658082962036,
0.3529646396636963,
-0.21205654740333557,
0.5047289133071899,
-0.2372996211051941,
0.24441994726657867,
0.3928338587284088,
0.2941280007362366,
0.14182732999324799,
-0.4667012691497803,
0.30472272634506226,
0.4100620448589325,
-0.3009967505931854,
-0.7888386249542236,
0.46242856979370117,
-0.8658208250999451,
-0.5295063257217407,
0.8023442625999451,
0.05506827309727669,
-0.7479221224784851,
-0.20062527060508728,
-0.014974059537053108,
0.13437409698963165,
-0.23722313344478607,
0.694854199886322,
0.7274206280708313,
-0.6144989728927612,
0.09995003044605255,
-0.19429168105125427,
0.4659253656864166,
0.7087231874465942,
-0.4891464114189148,
0.15877531468868256,
0.48929086327552795,
0.04076942428946495,
0.23639976978302002,
0.6378979086875916,
-0.4028850793838501,
0.2080458253622055,
0.39494577050209045,
-0.24899175763130188,
-0.055457282811403275,
-0.12928427755832672,
-0.30995574593544006,
0.1581556648015976,
0.19138315320014954,
-0.3786991238594055
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14551v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14551v1
|
Lexicon-Level Contrastive Visual-Grounding Improves Language Modeling
| 2024-03-21T16:52:01 | 2024-03-21T16:52:01 |
Chengxu Zhuang, Evelina Fedorenko, Jacob Andreas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Today's most accurate language models are trained on orders of magnitude more
language data than human language learners receive - but with no supervision
from other sensory modalities that play a crucial role in human learning. Can
we make LMs' representations and predictions more accurate (and more
human-like) with more ecologically plausible supervision? This paper describes
LexiContrastive Grounding (LCG), a grounded language learning procedure that
leverages visual supervision to improve textual representations.
LexiContrastive Grounding combines a next token prediction strategy with a
contrastive visual grounding objective, focusing on early-layer representations
that encode lexical information. Across multiple word-learning and
sentence-understanding benchmarks, LexiContrastive Grounding not only
outperforms standard language-only models in learning efficiency, but also
improves upon vision-and-language learning procedures including CLIP, GIT,
Flamingo, and Vokenization. Moreover, LexiContrastive Grounding improves
perplexity by around 5% on multiple language modeling tasks. This work
underscores the potential of incorporating visual grounding into language
models, aligning more closely with the multimodal nature of human language
acquisition.
|
[
-0.35845160484313965,
-0.5568774938583374,
0.5577909350395203,
0.10575591772794724,
-0.45814159512519836,
0.00219065067358315,
-0.3619898855686188,
-0.2625252902507782,
-0.1654130071401596,
0.35993364453315735,
-0.24108247458934784,
-0.9196902513504028,
-0.6866520643234253,
-0.17649899423122406,
-0.3211996555328369,
0.6362826228141785,
0.23559191823005676,
0.2805900275707245,
-0.46360594034194946,
-0.13393574953079224,
-0.46636366844177246,
-0.7015869617462158,
-0.5823261737823486,
-0.4721127152442932,
0.6070868968963623,
0.35401931405067444,
0.8898455500602722,
0.7029262781143188,
0.4768490493297577,
0.3172011077404022,
-0.399291068315506,
0.13541175425052643,
-0.5378322005271912,
-0.23301120102405548,
-0.17230373620986938,
-0.6594496965408325,
-0.049994807690382004,
0.12609140574932098,
0.38847509026527405,
0.8715330958366394,
-0.10543425381183624,
-0.26692163944244385,
0.17842735350131989,
0.7791814804077148,
-0.8378143906593323,
0.20770451426506042,
-0.5635711550712585,
0.06859622895717621,
0.21800677478313446,
-0.19152261316776276,
-0.4792455732822418,
0.025527268648147583,
0.12136644124984741,
-0.7091079354286194,
0.1487942785024643,
0.07338521629571915,
0.9504286050796509,
0.40026944875717163,
-0.43484383821487427,
-0.0028436502907425165,
-0.4035627841949463,
0.6522197723388672,
-0.5596829056739807,
0.8250139355659485,
0.26094409823417664,
0.1747763603925705,
0.013888725079596043,
-0.6688515543937683,
-0.24345017969608307,
-0.4771307408809662,
-0.21372029185295105,
0.5018810629844666,
0.1293158233165741,
0.3161163330078125,
0.3154461085796356,
0.25885868072509766,
-0.14489972591400146,
-0.007840446196496487,
-0.09527226537466049,
-0.0837409645318985,
-0.09330878406763077,
-0.06771707534790039,
0.4737815856933594,
-0.09028405696153641,
-0.5461275577545166,
-0.38377171754837036,
-0.6947177648544312,
0.3277803659439087,
-0.07884946465492249,
0.31708988547325134,
-0.300493448972702,
0.4156326353549957,
-0.29218122363090515,
0.6605649590492249,
-0.09693712741136551,
-0.13493391871452332,
0.1190512403845787,
-0.20277604460716248,
-0.22109338641166687,
-0.07530377805233002,
0.27988702058792114,
0.9173813462257385,
0.3051088750362396,
-0.16272960603237152,
-0.1918058842420578,
0.42472970485687256,
0.1288880556821823,
-0.6459246277809143,
-0.4734051823616028,
-0.14144544303417206,
-0.4787622094154358,
-0.5760740041732788,
0.23297828435897827,
-0.8124514818191528,
-0.6881767511367798,
-0.6081416606903076,
0.08512317389249802,
-0.6197521686553955,
-0.28924721479415894,
0.1856752634048462,
-0.25695401430130005,
0.3013174831867218,
0.5487855672836304,
-0.6399701833724976,
0.3316459357738495,
0.5529251098632812,
0.8904849290847778,
-0.05190359801054001,
-0.39441362023353577,
-0.6412125825881958,
0.09498091042041779,
-0.5600053668022156,
0.7453343868255615,
-0.524330735206604,
-0.07133921980857849,
-0.05141277238726616,
-0.14612527191638947,
0.20739327371120453,
-0.5489648580551147,
0.5236996412277222,
-0.293117493391037,
-0.0013691568747162819,
-0.47898179292678833,
-0.2554013133049011,
-0.20870071649551392,
0.4226002097129822,
-0.5551970601081848,
0.8502726554870605,
-0.15796315670013428,
-0.9885162115097046,
0.502736508846283,
-0.08913914859294891,
-0.020775998011231422,
-0.1215648427605629,
-0.34119415283203125,
-0.2991582453250885,
0.31873777508735657,
0.45065388083457947,
0.487383633852005,
0.022948868572711945,
0.20709353685379028,
-0.26832979917526245,
-0.35762694478034973,
-0.11647568643093109,
-0.22666878998279572,
0.42763087153434753,
0.0017928170273080468,
-0.2565706670284271,
0.09025076031684875,
-0.7990882992744446,
-0.21439801156520844,
0.18066100776195526,
-0.3209880590438843,
-0.6883829832077026,
0.14637582004070282,
0.08090575039386749,
0.39445117115974426,
-0.019219454377889633,
-0.12947721779346466,
-0.2075715959072113,
-0.4986676573753357,
-0.035142265260219574,
0.5671820044517517,
-0.18468376994132996,
0.758710503578186,
-0.16024839878082275,
0.31767573952674866,
0.34075096249580383,
-0.2885429263114929,
-0.5858040452003479,
-0.19615618884563446,
-1.0931788682937622,
-0.19825007021427155,
0.1659383922815323,
0.630352258682251,
-0.8097190260887146,
0.3968178629875183,
-0.3051339089870453,
-0.4047975242137909,
-0.18604768812656403,
0.08597496151924133,
0.6014776825904846,
0.707595944404602,
0.49055561423301697,
-0.07726170867681503,
-0.5724596381187439,
-0.741137683391571,
-0.4238821566104889,
-0.20650948584079742,
-0.02695441246032715,
0.17904992401599884,
0.30572202801704407,
-0.25890931487083435,
0.6792356967926025,
-0.2931440472602844,
-0.2549225091934204,
-0.20927497744560242,
0.27614444494247437,
0.09802956134080887,
0.5249466300010681,
0.5561313629150391,
-0.7938042879104614,
-0.47114527225494385,
0.26948314905166626,
-0.8830032348632812,
-0.21683458983898163,
-0.0630403608083725,
-0.1931222677230835,
0.05081694573163986,
0.9734979271888733,
-0.46786704659461975,
0.39348238706588745,
0.5765131711959839,
-0.4587898254394531,
0.32956719398498535,
-0.27953076362609863,
0.08289790898561478,
-0.7568299770355225,
-0.06787439435720444,
0.02271283231675625,
-0.48425358533859253,
-0.678155779838562,
0.33493682742118835,
0.21369607746601105,
-0.16857567429542542,
-0.4360385537147522,
0.4026668071746826,
-0.7579579949378967,
0.04721945524215698,
-0.23245704174041748,
0.3308614194393158,
-0.06936216354370117,
0.4388640224933624,
0.30824190378189087,
0.7645119428634644,
0.9137052297592163,
-0.3828136920928955,
0.20609216392040253,
0.03098759986460209,
-0.22375014424324036,
0.4269372522830963,
-0.45399877429008484,
0.016912132501602173,
-0.5042763352394104,
0.18216867744922638,
-1.0359443426132202,
-0.04037449508905411,
-0.04643126204609871,
-0.36407309770584106,
0.15959593653678894,
-0.17186294496059418,
-0.3443538546562195,
0.15478898584842682,
-0.3121272921562195,
0.19950087368488312,
0.6414758563041687,
-0.8406921029090881,
0.9178537130355835,
0.058898746967315674,
0.11975952237844467,
-0.4591604173183441,
-0.7449256777763367,
0.28450319170951843,
-0.22145569324493408,
-0.35874831676483154,
0.15464432537555695,
0.24568261206150055,
-0.45180627703666687,
-0.15407739579677582,
-0.37472352385520935,
0.29929158091545105,
0.23188619315624237,
0.29386720061302185,
0.28271159529685974,
-0.1474524438381195,
0.2818046510219574,
-0.315405011177063,
-0.33813780546188354,
0.2676549553871155,
-0.46709710359573364,
0.4705277383327484,
-0.20348618924617767,
-0.252465158700943,
-0.2424287348985672,
0.16560550034046173,
0.4572838246822357,
-0.1958692967891693,
0.7357622981071472,
0.49955108761787415,
-0.5215179324150085,
-0.10852880030870438,
-0.5666915774345398,
-0.07516339421272278,
-0.4550980031490326,
0.2995273172855377,
-0.47822538018226624,
-0.6014565825462341,
0.3899987041950226,
-0.30492112040519714,
-0.10369625687599182,
0.22124545276165009,
0.21467269957065582,
-0.2770245373249054,
0.9652045965194702,
0.9363201856613159,
-0.08798553049564362,
0.6545538306236267,
-0.1695488691329956,
0.031860701739788055,
-0.4964393377304077,
-0.3821202218532562,
-0.27835121750831604,
0.07448116689920425,
-0.5571197867393494,
-0.5595552921295166,
0.23300199210643768,
0.5896956324577332,
-0.0337572917342186,
0.0966566726565361,
-0.2353154867887497,
0.6917548775672913,
0.4635235369205475,
0.5126022696495056,
0.26587238907814026,
0.2788292467594147,
-0.6437782049179077,
-0.31053826212882996,
-0.6930294036865234,
-0.5806983709335327,
0.7462850213050842,
0.4059487581253052,
0.7863541841506958,
-0.2370593398809433,
0.7157475352287292,
-0.010048504918813705,
0.2761104106903076,
-0.6277093887329102,
0.4307955205440521,
-0.273880273103714,
0.048463281244039536,
-0.10206452012062073,
-0.3008546829223633,
-0.3921481966972351,
0.7030134201049805,
-0.4864800274372101,
-0.36308595538139343,
0.2775234282016754,
0.39494505524635315,
-0.07402358949184418,
0.3083229660987854,
-0.769310474395752,
0.7876365184783936,
-0.18281976878643036,
-0.39121606945991516,
-0.1863340437412262,
-0.7226088643074036,
0.21801862120628357,
0.24283164739608765,
0.5336170196533203,
0.09247609972953796,
-0.2366819530725479,
0.42615842819213867,
-0.2988412380218506,
0.988461434841156,
-0.24223041534423828,
-0.27206146717071533,
0.04665766656398773,
0.08171138912439346,
0.5302889943122864,
-0.01341252587735653,
0.34278950095176697,
-0.00803755596280098,
-0.4473106563091278,
-0.5147571563720703,
-0.5946508646011353,
0.6798228621482849,
-0.679344892501831,
-0.5650416612625122,
-0.40000292658805847,
-0.2649841904640198,
-0.2613883912563324,
0.2156672179698944,
0.2648654282093048,
0.27981632947921753,
-0.26037678122520447,
0.3401419520378113,
0.7911075353622437,
-0.35758715867996216,
0.1826990395784378,
-0.04845007136464119,
-0.501428484916687,
-0.5192208290100098,
0.8704472780227661,
-0.3093006908893585,
0.481113076210022,
0.6241785883903503,
0.19977644085884094,
-0.19133734703063965,
-0.49392473697662354,
0.15425942838191986,
0.19759629666805267,
-1.2332731485366821,
-0.11634184420108795,
-0.7470076680183411,
-0.008373395539820194,
-0.20479533076286316,
-0.4144841134548187,
-0.29560598731040955,
-0.07772323489189148,
-0.4017677903175354,
-0.4297548532485962,
0.06744224578142166,
0.52451491355896,
-0.04092908650636673,
0.4173849821090698,
-0.5511683821678162,
0.5766932964324951,
0.4070383906364441,
0.358445405960083,
-0.17334286868572235,
-0.42160508036613464,
-0.16738712787628174,
0.11647320538759232,
0.10471796244382858,
-0.6939306259155273,
0.2655310034751892,
0.15462933480739594,
0.40757888555526733,
0.3608357608318329,
-0.3356764614582062,
0.9556136131286621,
-0.5930995941162109,
0.6867848038673401,
0.6167795658111572,
-1.061691164970398,
0.5918086171150208,
-0.42647016048431396,
0.4385851323604584,
0.47951003909111023,
0.09084299206733704,
-0.5933781862258911,
-0.558975100517273,
-0.36900579929351807,
-0.8572039008140564,
0.5052756071090698,
0.18970508873462677,
0.13059307634830475,
-0.007688020821660757,
0.23924459517002106,
-0.19809041917324066,
-0.07530537992715836,
-1.0486105680465698,
-0.11180371046066284,
-0.4760519862174988,
-0.07212967425584793,
-0.5199564695358276,
-0.3784942924976349,
0.004805882461369038,
-0.2906230390071869,
0.25737282633781433,
-0.2640233337879181,
-0.03962666168808937,
0.23482541739940643,
-0.3826296925544739,
-0.0012456951662898064,
0.11069171875715256,
0.5019031763076782,
0.4790101945400238,
-0.25518545508384705,
0.7581339478492737,
0.49461647868156433,
-0.21795184910297394,
0.02061641775071621,
-0.2311420440673828,
0.02684210054576397,
0.15352699160575867,
0.7034617066383362,
0.7782213091850281,
0.45729589462280273,
-0.7131757140159607,
0.6395803093910217,
0.08064521104097366,
-0.15336152911186218,
-0.18640226125717163,
0.007129068020731211,
0.3952539265155792,
0.2524527609348297,
0.20799745619297028,
0.19796523451805115,
0.012953019700944424,
-0.3969762921333313,
0.18076159060001373,
0.29197603464126587,
-0.3249295651912689,
-0.11100320518016815,
0.7955848574638367,
0.18234245479106903,
0.10113406926393509,
0.3044370412826538,
0.27809086441993713,
-0.5819759964942932,
0.6503227949142456,
0.43378564715385437,
0.6541433930397034,
-0.12522847950458527,
-0.07079438120126724,
0.5024147629737854,
0.37785935401916504,
-0.4186401069164276,
0.052199434489011765,
-0.09109988063573837,
-0.7220858335494995,
-0.2530072331428528,
-0.47244611382484436,
-0.3743627667427063,
-0.061040088534355164,
-0.6134108304977417,
0.6950289011001587,
-0.6461876034736633,
0.1059156283736229,
-0.19120556116104126,
-0.4300418198108673,
-0.6183103322982788,
0.5877869129180908,
0.6720139980316162,
0.971734344959259,
-1.1188474893569946,
0.6776108145713806,
0.8487747311592102,
-0.46324774622917175,
-0.4803495407104492,
0.09142787754535675,
-0.1640327274799347,
-0.5957165360450745,
0.840138852596283,
0.509786069393158,
-0.5380634665489197,
0.13188958168029785,
-0.900958240032196,
-0.7508896589279175,
1.0950015783309937,
0.4380810260772705,
-0.6022871732711792,
-0.14606070518493652,
-0.04654194042086601,
0.580142617225647,
-0.5259933471679688,
0.18682634830474854,
0.46337801218032837,
0.31714093685150146,
0.11591435223817825,
-0.4140132963657379,
-0.000001277932824450545,
-0.1626514047384262,
0.38850125670433044,
-0.05483603477478027,
-0.3311764895915985,
0.7361557483673096,
-0.13903126120567322,
-0.5020363926887512,
-0.17852501571178436,
0.8278616666793823,
0.36970749497413635,
0.0670240968465805,
0.767823338508606,
0.7183046340942383,
0.42481428384780884,
-0.18936409056186676,
0.9590771794319153,
-0.3079020082950592,
0.3113997280597687,
1.0767346620559692,
-0.06237997114658356,
0.7477192878723145,
0.665496289730072,
0.07394542545080185,
0.5057639479637146,
0.4458716809749603,
0.22085417807102203,
0.695717453956604,
0.08940445631742477,
-0.07767321914434433,
-0.6839175224304199,
-0.207182839512825,
-0.18099887669086456,
0.2322036325931549,
0.26066073775291443,
-0.2944383919239044,
-0.5552886724472046,
0.03504665940999985,
-0.17593787610530853,
0.6225182414054871,
-0.3757559359073639,
0.8253665566444397,
0.14772024750709534,
-0.4177806079387665,
0.9436754584312439,
-0.03401442617177963,
0.7827176451683044,
-0.3067358732223511,
-0.41206181049346924,
-0.33743321895599365,
0.0722510889172554,
-0.1828700751066208,
-0.49055254459381104,
0.08012361824512482,
-0.05717029795050621,
0.03376423195004463,
-0.579666793346405,
0.9082024693489075,
-0.6296307444572449,
-0.36851605772972107,
0.7747997045516968,
0.43222475051879883,
-0.055332183837890625,
-0.11365914344787598,
-0.3812809884548187,
-0.04587601125240326,
-0.18009808659553528,
-0.06532838195562363,
0.19915179908275604,
0.6334372758865356,
0.004392886068671942,
0.719759464263916,
0.7361364960670471,
0.09141422063112259,
0.24241912364959717,
0.17072027921676636,
1.1636013984680176,
-0.9026209712028503,
-0.6451936960220337,
-0.9252665042877197,
0.6764219403266907,
-0.11081182956695557,
0.04731326922774315,
0.4878634810447693,
0.4361853003501892,
0.968277633190155,
-0.21892660856246948,
0.577786922454834,
0.25092843174934387,
0.23768678307533264,
-0.8918379545211792,
0.5176222324371338,
-0.5684695839881897,
0.13552463054656982,
-0.27899113297462463,
-0.8806984424591064,
-0.6386009454727173,
0.7148349285125732,
0.004898710176348686,
-0.003867123508825898,
0.9887354969978333,
0.6457186937332153,
-0.24479644000530243,
-0.49902451038360596,
0.7979161143302917,
0.137803316116333,
0.20702983438968658,
0.3063967823982239,
1.027439832687378,
-0.2949725091457367,
0.41372981667518616,
-0.44790881872177124,
-0.28236123919487,
-0.06075223535299301,
-1.000978946685791,
-1.3886982202529907,
-0.24712954461574554,
-0.08144780248403549,
-0.1927560716867447,
0.2173367142677307,
0.9615879058837891,
0.5761850476264954,
-0.7344954609870911,
-0.23418661952018738,
-0.7028260827064514,
-0.08312106132507324,
-0.11459998041391373,
-0.1391216218471527,
0.23139500617980957,
-0.7535290718078613,
-0.568503201007843,
0.2252969592809677,
0.3346066474914551,
0.2144869714975357,
-0.026496585458517075,
-0.09159895032644272,
-0.19599498808383942,
-0.23970264196395874,
0.6758838891983032,
-0.15628701448440552,
-1.0696040391921997,
-0.30956387519836426,
-0.10270192474126816,
-0.4526515305042267,
0.22769683599472046,
0.7481599450111389,
-0.887680172920227,
0.32249706983566284,
0.44825416803359985,
0.584298849105835,
0.3118128776550293,
0.20199498534202576,
0.4977125823497772,
-0.7539005279541016,
0.5640711188316345,
-0.047230321913957596,
0.5529575943946838,
0.5148598551750183,
-0.2900904715061188,
0.5421918630599976,
0.3870325982570648,
0.004255399573594332,
-0.5962375402450562,
0.1335987150669098,
-0.8038551211357117,
-0.1682136505842209,
1.1996235847473145,
-0.19676902890205383,
-0.16931284964084625,
0.16819636523723602,
-0.499987930059433,
0.2846309244632721,
-0.24425728619098663,
0.5205363631248474,
0.798092782497406,
0.5692628026008606,
-0.7831007242202759,
-0.5037370920181274,
0.49001848697662354,
0.5857012867927551,
-0.85763019323349,
0.2275092899799347,
0.5990138053894043,
0.29411864280700684,
0.17452342808246613,
0.23071177303791046,
0.06533750146627426,
0.35738831758499146,
0.017287123948335648,
0.27656009793281555,
0.04477016255259514,
-0.5413088798522949,
-0.6560170650482178,
0.009449836798012257,
0.2450004667043686,
-0.1356598436832428
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14541v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14541v2
|
EDT: Improving Large Language Models' Generation by Entropy-based Dynamic Temperature Sampling
| 2024-03-21T16:41:12 | 2024-04-03T16:09:22 |
Shimao Zhang, Yu Bao, Shujian Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recently, Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated outstanding
performance across a wide range of downstream language tasks. Temperature
sampling is a commonly used decoding strategy for LLMs' generation process.
However, a fixed temperature parameter is used in most cases, which may not
always be an optimal choice for balancing generation quality and diversity. In
this paper, we propose an effective Entropy-based Dynamic Temperature (EDT)
Sampling method, to achieve a more balanced performance in terms of both
generation quality and diversity by dynamically selecting the temperature
parameter. Additionally, we also show model performance and comprehensive
analyses for 4 different generation benchmarks. Our experiments show that EDT
significantly outperforms the existing strategies across different tasks.
|
[
-0.33551767468452454,
-0.6945078372955322,
0.3944815397262573,
0.09847403317689896,
-0.7512036561965942,
0.5483366250991821,
-0.41977962851524353,
-0.2975558340549469,
0.14897587895393372,
0.20407576858997345,
-0.48529133200645447,
-0.4380912184715271,
-0.4212654232978821,
0.10175170749425888,
-0.2834950089454651,
0.45515426993370056,
-0.16875728964805603,
-0.21059851348400116,
0.05782105401158333,
0.3387511670589447,
-0.1776924431324005,
-0.20143476128578186,
-0.9321247339248657,
-0.42648380994796753,
0.2747077941894531,
0.2827153503894806,
0.43961334228515625,
0.7858148813247681,
0.3579815924167633,
0.337684690952301,
-0.09199301898479462,
0.32598716020584106,
-0.576560914516449,
0.9795902967453003,
0.2298368662595749,
-0.23820559680461884,
-0.5492764115333557,
-0.20331530272960663,
0.8822854161262512,
0.3521018624305725,
-0.6022073030471802,
0.0694379061460495,
-0.0058295936323702335,
0.40056276321411133,
-0.48728251457214355,
0.0653107613325119,
-1.1009091138839722,
-0.10320325940847397,
-0.2593981623649597,
-0.39581120014190674,
-0.3661121726036072,
-0.363761305809021,
-0.24416783452033997,
-0.023931022733449936,
0.3081812262535095,
-0.2900241017341614,
0.5451647639274597,
0.3562016487121582,
-0.5233978033065796,
-0.15027019381523132,
-0.9162409901618958,
1.0929005146026611,
-1.026663064956665,
0.5871636271476746,
0.31718406081199646,
-0.02562524378299713,
-0.014340224675834179,
-0.6838407516479492,
-0.7131525874137878,
-0.0885985717177391,
0.6225736737251282,
0.301042377948761,
-0.004343586973845959,
-0.23412854969501495,
0.18083232641220093,
0.2908557057380676,
-0.4640512466430664,
0.20163950324058533,
-0.08540112525224686,
0.11332889646291733,
0.7063135504722595,
0.22559872269630432,
0.2765873968601227,
-0.08716762810945511,
-0.14090922474861145,
-0.46077752113342285,
-0.5608104467391968,
-0.17848549783229828,
0.7951591610908508,
0.39603692293167114,
0.0557820089161396,
0.11187390983104706,
-0.3683392107486725,
0.7967485189437866,
0.07523636519908905,
-0.19869011640548706,
0.30515509843826294,
-0.0868714228272438,
-0.25154802203178406,
-0.009294961579144001,
0.4506492018699646,
0.45521074533462524,
-0.16414612531661987,
-0.08251980692148209,
-0.556216835975647,
-0.54409259557724,
-0.1002788096666336,
-0.9195526242256165,
-0.5544674396514893,
0.367538183927536,
-0.06494380533695221,
-0.3856295347213745,
0.03365320712327957,
-1.143385648727417,
-0.04333305358886719,
-0.19275806844234467,
-0.3604728877544403,
-0.3754695951938629,
-0.733242392539978,
0.08352263271808624,
-0.23146525025367737,
0.11759406328201294,
0.22447705268859863,
-1.1014301776885986,
-0.07825510203838348,
0.35589414834976196,
0.7472186088562012,
-0.26384586095809937,
-0.10662160068750381,
-0.3930290639400482,
0.2451976090669632,
-0.1470993459224701,
0.8560931086540222,
-0.64387446641922,
-0.06994885951280594,
-0.14812730252742767,
-0.6375033259391785,
-0.0632890835404396,
-0.4070765972137451,
0.06120716780424118,
-0.9903071522712708,
-0.02282833121716976,
-0.3560202121734619,
-0.2879140377044678,
0.17544740438461304,
0.30658990144729614,
-0.7935835719108582,
1.1229779720306396,
-0.03940713778138161,
-0.6689139008522034,
0.6237088441848755,
-0.36940285563468933,
-0.21830275654792786,
0.38778096437454224,
0.020053649321198463,
-0.2727844715118408,
-0.049945853650569916,
0.30615323781967163,
0.3842734694480896,
-0.22546204924583435,
0.38304728269577026,
-0.20936092734336853,
0.006065532565116882,
0.1182970181107521,
-0.8849565386772156,
0.5334886908531189,
0.86895352602005,
-0.40478771924972534,
-0.12984579801559448,
-1.0705645084381104,
0.4548488259315491,
0.19894607365131378,
-1.010319471359253,
-0.34906676411628723,
0.05795975774526596,
-0.032672252506017685,
-0.2117234170436859,
0.21259979903697968,
-0.5289060473442078,
0.24118927121162415,
-0.4315788149833679,
0.3694840967655182,
0.7353522181510925,
-0.06622827053070068,
0.23635268211364746,
-0.13391759991645813,
0.6968247890472412,
-0.1891244649887085,
-0.47457098960876465,
0.053585898131132126,
-0.14849480986595154,
-0.5337156653404236,
-0.7183064222335815,
0.3654032051563263,
0.7112802863121033,
-1.1986252069473267,
0.5965958833694458,
-0.13885290920734406,
-0.6849702596664429,
-0.18462207913398743,
0.24543508887290955,
0.05271085351705551,
-0.03151005879044533,
0.024231232702732086,
0.12001564353704453,
-0.4479840397834778,
-0.32149434089660645,
-0.28279972076416016,
-0.25662386417388916,
-0.22826185822486877,
0.028276825323700905,
0.08065139502286911,
-0.008190592750906944,
0.8436042666435242,
-0.5478785634040833,
0.8711775541305542,
-0.4416838586330414,
0.21369357407093048,
0.35840561985969543,
0.44366583228111267,
0.6010002493858337,
-0.5580127835273743,
-0.503838062286377,
-0.22433924674987793,
-0.5293128490447998,
-0.25849005579948425,
-0.005176500882953405,
-0.14723297953605652,
0.23377414047718048,
0.598787784576416,
-0.4003317952156067,
-0.11815738677978516,
0.7241529822349548,
-0.35623615980148315,
0.2225673943758011,
-0.06820939481258392,
0.3688947260379791,
-1.4124305248260498,
-0.11062856018543243,
-0.1331583559513092,
-0.2905022203922272,
-0.701718270778656,
0.5391606092453003,
0.07589412480592728,
-0.05389367416501045,
-0.5911248326301575,
0.24983958899974823,
-0.6837135553359985,
0.5723096132278442,
-0.49173635244369507,
-0.4160630702972412,
-0.23984892666339874,
0.016246231272816658,
-0.08302941173315048,
0.4719601571559906,
0.573381781578064,
-0.5180689692497253,
1.2095516920089722,
-0.3166903257369995,
-0.545446515083313,
0.31071650981903076,
-0.49540767073631287,
0.3879457712173462,
-0.1867738664150238,
0.2762293219566345,
-0.9951546788215637,
-0.31289923191070557,
-0.06477315723896027,
-0.09356916695833206,
0.7018651962280273,
0.10236789286136627,
-0.8875900506973267,
-0.35175734758377075,
-0.2137911021709442,
0.7335893511772156,
0.7725178599357605,
-0.5239263772964478,
0.33186131715774536,
0.14644849300384521,
-0.5250428915023804,
-0.20227663218975067,
-0.4973052442073822,
0.16746896505355835,
-0.5998658537864685,
-0.6033692359924316,
0.13312841951847076,
-0.15893158316612244,
-0.4706660807132721,
-0.38940030336380005,
-0.013047265820205212,
0.017005469650030136,
0.06772450357675552,
-0.3947520852088928,
-0.1898299604654312,
-0.1804548054933548,
0.10048015415668488,
0.1483960896730423,
0.18965944647789001,
-0.11407105624675751,
-0.32923123240470886,
1.1542197465896606,
0.22725419700145721,
-0.4134911596775055,
-0.2296515703201294,
0.5229234099388123,
0.578859806060791,
-0.2198573350906372,
0.7587109804153442,
0.5072647333145142,
-0.36236801743507385,
-0.6414252519607544,
-0.5455818176269531,
-0.47588491439819336,
-0.5318043828010559,
0.45066937804222107,
-0.43710237741470337,
-0.5280981659889221,
0.7630515694618225,
-0.024562248960137367,
0.3819243311882019,
0.33003509044647217,
0.7384089231491089,
-0.043952107429504395,
0.8163606524467468,
0.4334750175476074,
0.15974225103855133,
0.672585129737854,
0.06688715517520905,
0.2581697404384613,
-0.4022033214569092,
-0.10525862127542496,
-0.4319826066493988,
-0.4302939772605896,
-0.5263331532478333,
-0.36452504992485046,
0.3752077519893646,
-0.1298677623271942,
-0.1977594494819641,
0.07057879865169525,
-0.34863582253456116,
0.32810598611831665,
1.0245063304901123,
0.4315520226955414,
0.17413553595542908,
0.4631074368953705,
-0.14955782890319824,
0.16749271750450134,
-0.7594322562217712,
-0.35996001958847046,
0.8652507662773132,
0.495927095413208,
1.1164348125457764,
0.2612210810184479,
0.9053747057914734,
0.039373915642499924,
-0.16785195469856262,
-0.1826649010181427,
0.5327141284942627,
-0.036350030452013016,
-0.5227600336074829,
-0.6556205153465271,
-0.6308498382568359,
-0.7733536958694458,
0.20506493747234344,
0.13746383786201477,
-0.5639521479606628,
-0.04799754172563553,
0.2346373051404953,
-0.3796972632408142,
0.9201632738113403,
-0.5587882399559021,
0.17848476767539978,
-0.28499743342399597,
-0.3961421847343445,
-0.0627845898270607,
-0.21195094287395477,
0.3157161474227905,
-0.4460987150669098,
-0.17712220549583435,
-0.23096652328968048,
0.16719022393226624,
0.8781596422195435,
-0.3920098543167114,
0.8841878771781921,
-0.2273847758769989,
-0.5525402426719666,
0.3279796242713928,
0.04741150140762329,
0.7314635515213013,
0.13443918526172638,
-0.7998281717300415,
-0.05664264038205147,
0.08772104978561401,
-0.5726600885391235,
-0.2900426685810089,
0.9042640924453735,
-0.667784571647644,
-0.6908618807792664,
-0.3774722218513489,
-0.9542196989059448,
-0.24795980751514435,
0.11455076932907104,
0.5916774868965149,
0.3452782928943634,
0.10624437034130096,
0.41772761940956116,
0.679207980632782,
-0.5352973341941833,
0.5707289576530457,
0.5058991312980652,
0.27098292112350464,
-0.4076143801212311,
0.7635769844055176,
0.19252558052539825,
0.493612140417099,
0.22191555798053741,
0.08191866427659988,
-0.163589745759964,
-0.736500084400177,
-0.5081034302711487,
-0.09782890975475311,
-0.6284457445144653,
-0.41483569145202637,
-0.6400133371353149,
-0.2227061241865158,
-0.7024922966957092,
-0.07666271179914474,
-0.47500666975975037,
0.03069465421140194,
-0.24887359142303467,
-0.2860077917575836,
0.6590043306350708,
0.27630266547203064,
-0.1903386116027832,
0.4006848931312561,
-0.6636549234390259,
0.25598421692848206,
0.3448961079120636,
0.5021706819534302,
0.07980142533779144,
-0.5041338801383972,
0.006045533809810877,
0.23664340376853943,
-0.3939747214317322,
-0.9353804588317871,
0.6343915462493896,
0.17660978436470032,
0.7916122078895569,
0.33801668882369995,
0.4949897229671478,
0.4259029030799866,
-0.2274734079837799,
0.892961323261261,
0.16893598437309265,
-0.7862303256988525,
0.5861955881118774,
-0.5019536018371582,
0.8664644360542297,
0.3250810503959656,
-0.002584627363830805,
-0.23082903027534485,
-0.8293660879135132,
-0.6268346905708313,
-1.3999347686767578,
0.5376893281936646,
0.23666509985923767,
0.5346413850784302,
-0.14741332828998566,
0.22175288200378418,
0.19165214896202087,
0.1466713547706604,
-0.6080237627029419,
0.026602942496538162,
-0.16812637448310852,
-0.368620902299881,
-0.006228408310562372,
-0.3501247763633728,
0.14080385863780975,
-0.423529714345932,
0.5624454021453857,
0.12379461526870728,
0.24104955792427063,
-0.18862470984458923,
0.27231091260910034,
-0.4927603304386139,
0.27615728974342346,
0.6571775674819946,
0.570061206817627,
-0.5843790769577026,
0.4301816523075104,
0.4548746645450592,
-0.60432368516922,
0.03882339224219322,
-0.031075289472937584,
-0.4016377031803131,
0.05094646289944649,
0.37097710371017456,
0.8202198147773743,
-0.3525650203227997,
-0.5593129396438599,
-0.18356627225875854,
0.02835444174706936,
-0.18510381877422333,
-0.16134700179100037,
0.39066994190216064,
0.021893268451094627,
0.4003956913948059,
0.4244013726711273,
-0.36662769317626953,
-0.31792396306991577,
-0.634128212928772,
0.43596935272216797,
0.5535651445388794,
0.049418531358242035,
-0.21710927784442902,
0.61518394947052,
0.4191782474517822,
-0.017091529443860054,
1.0693293809890747,
-0.20250241458415985,
-0.4723290801048279,
0.8619458079338074,
0.8567194938659668,
0.6918338537216187,
-0.6082798838615417,
-0.08127114921808243,
0.36144572496414185,
0.4371874928474426,
-0.09308378398418427,
0.7821999192237854,
0.0035558254458010197,
-0.8155328035354614,
-0.11723300069570541,
-0.8962758779525757,
-0.2219626009464264,
0.2924844026565552,
-0.5722097158432007,
0.21837560832500458,
-0.2191118448972702,
-0.1927345097064972,
-0.48693904280662537,
-0.147054523229599,
-0.8065811395645142,
0.3365640342235565,
0.2667844295501709,
0.7933588027954102,
-0.8938254117965698,
1.0070090293884277,
0.5970433354377747,
0.07364648580551147,
-0.9546825289726257,
0.3415371775627136,
-0.14622654020786285,
-0.8656995892524719,
0.4885351061820984,
-0.49213284254074097,
-0.09150757640600204,
0.3140028715133667,
-0.5127260088920593,
-1.0937895774841309,
1.1296031475067139,
0.5110449194908142,
-0.6440451145172119,
0.08355026692152023,
0.035434089601039886,
0.4783423840999603,
-0.1038493737578392,
0.22180438041687012,
0.6269499063491821,
0.5607990026473999,
0.6126750111579895,
-0.6912485361099243,
0.11857439577579498,
-0.4102295935153961,
-0.12460564076900482,
0.1963811218738556,
-0.6436591148376465,
0.8325433731079102,
-0.10092870146036148,
-0.28720197081565857,
-0.09357278048992157,
0.8553718328475952,
0.520810604095459,
0.4214482307434082,
0.623443603515625,
0.47693711519241333,
1.0057106018066406,
-0.06955089420080185,
0.9579790830612183,
-0.4396931231021881,
0.3044167459011078,
0.7219674587249756,
-0.4521523416042328,
0.984387993812561,
0.5642116665840149,
-0.11011771112680435,
0.07909075915813446,
0.8020305633544922,
-0.2823096513748169,
0.9279574155807495,
0.4845830798149109,
-0.5445472002029419,
-0.26492682099342346,
0.21377012133598328,
-0.6141680479049683,
0.296563059091568,
0.2771056294441223,
-0.37134668231010437,
-0.33352774381637573,
0.039766825735569,
0.11417444050312042,
-0.16067056357860565,
-0.08007200062274933,
0.8017565011978149,
-0.03597945719957352,
-0.8531941175460815,
0.8393837213516235,
0.2299720048904419,
0.8885288238525391,
-0.40524545311927795,
0.32997533679008484,
-0.4107816219329834,
0.04332221299409866,
-0.021560246124863625,
-0.7895567417144775,
0.11065095663070679,
0.3300536572933197,
-0.2491241991519928,
-0.5828909873962402,
0.42344021797180176,
-0.693777322769165,
-0.7898961901664734,
-0.16386207938194275,
0.4124014377593994,
0.22842475771903992,
0.03537244349718094,
-0.2020777016878128,
0.24005453288555145,
0.23080205917358398,
-0.5961037874221802,
0.067538782954216,
0.5253968238830566,
0.3383512794971466,
0.31260985136032104,
0.5978889465332031,
0.49975961446762085,
0.27295154333114624,
0.0834699496626854,
0.7097615003585815,
-0.6179234385490417,
-0.463122695684433,
-1.1048753261566162,
0.3472955822944641,
-0.035430219024419785,
-0.13709454238414764,
0.6157044172286987,
0.43825840950012207,
0.6640051603317261,
-0.1653134822845459,
0.9028436541557312,
-0.030461912974715233,
0.41327977180480957,
-0.8524672389030457,
0.7030315399169922,
-0.5657103061676025,
0.5757052898406982,
-0.1893952190876007,
-1.2404817342758179,
-0.10153459012508392,
0.26033928990364075,
-0.1291288435459137,
0.4763152599334717,
0.5242949724197388,
0.6711156964302063,
-0.3288247585296631,
-0.19864171743392944,
0.45281070470809937,
0.11108187586069107,
0.7406461238861084,
0.4964779019355774,
0.8844093084335327,
-0.09620682150125504,
0.3029952645301819,
-0.14497146010398865,
-0.44591936469078064,
-0.044279370456933975,
-1.1463687419891357,
-0.669189453125,
-0.5062352418899536,
-0.4147469401359558,
-0.29865410923957825,
0.02389618754386902,
1.1788897514343262,
0.7252090573310852,
-0.6976289749145508,
-0.10472820699214935,
0.2099275141954422,
-0.24872080981731415,
-0.20506784319877625,
-0.15988552570343018,
0.2967957854270935,
-0.17218610644340515,
-1.2245607376098633,
0.4779343008995056,
-0.0519326813519001,
0.0476180836558342,
-0.18609990179538727,
0.04089679569005966,
0.024524981155991554,
0.5287278890609741,
0.5986959338188171,
0.035748761147260666,
-0.5469821095466614,
-0.02070786990225315,
-0.09193938225507736,
-0.20528662204742432,
-0.2506538927555084,
0.6775180697441101,
-0.32661622762680054,
0.2602008283138275,
1.0896475315093994,
0.47511568665504456,
0.27509841322898865,
0.020168978720903397,
0.947618842124939,
-0.9822795987129211,
0.030309369787573814,
0.19167807698249817,
0.2835603356361389,
0.3143330216407776,
-0.4494690001010895,
-0.000920166086871177,
0.29099807143211365,
-0.32175832986831665,
-1.060986042022705,
0.38461431860923767,
-0.97417813539505,
-0.5355928540229797,
1.6466710567474365,
0.22973616421222687,
0.12420576810836792,
0.1162116676568985,
0.1980947107076645,
0.5629425048828125,
-0.6195544004440308,
1.0718735456466675,
0.6096755862236023,
0.10546078532934189,
-0.3471425473690033,
-0.6147430539131165,
0.17327649891376495,
0.31757470965385437,
-0.703574538230896,
0.09573718160390854,
0.272824764251709,
0.3937208354473114,
-0.23790320754051208,
0.3834226727485657,
0.2519393861293793,
-0.10195370018482208,
0.05705912783741951,
0.23267734050750732,
-0.061076123267412186,
-0.15114904940128326,
-0.017533715814352036,
0.36531969904899597,
0.268541157245636,
0.011109384708106518
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14515v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14515v1
|
Building a Language-Learning Game for Brazilian Indigenous Languages: A Case of Study
| 2024-03-21T16:11:44 | 2024-03-21T16:11:44 |
Gustavo Polleti
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper we discuss a first attempt to build a language learning game
for brazilian indigenous languages and the challenges around it. We present a
design for the tool with gamification aspects. Then we describe a process to
automatically generate language exercises and questions from a dependency
treebank and a lexical database for Tupian languages. We discuss the
limitations of our prototype highlighting ethical and practical implementation
concerns. Finally, we conclude that new data gathering processes should be
established in partnership with indigenous communities and oriented for
educational purposes.
|
[
-0.2456308901309967,
-1.0171637535095215,
0.0723842903971672,
0.13522526621818542,
-0.060264311730861664,
0.433244913816452,
-0.33642303943634033,
-0.35094329714775085,
0.3400755822658539,
0.550869345664978,
-0.25299397110939026,
-0.3236880898475647,
-0.3596373498439789,
0.2369210571050644,
-0.03891671821475029,
0.8291977047920227,
-0.13639989495277405,
-0.2631629407405853,
0.03531109541654587,
-0.2754007577896118,
-0.6837100386619568,
-0.354162335395813,
-1.1004443168640137,
-0.3485216796398163,
0.4734590947628021,
0.7236038446426392,
0.5710077285766602,
0.7057105898857117,
0.021725904196500778,
0.2517688572406769,
-0.15567909181118011,
-0.06258205324411392,
-0.7133732438087463,
-0.013105361722409725,
-0.19557489454746246,
-0.8481525778770447,
0.2475535273551941,
-0.02681027725338936,
0.35104599595069885,
0.4742307960987091,
-0.5025893449783325,
0.5631288886070251,
-0.12284102290868759,
0.47558680176734924,
-0.3385530412197113,
0.43694692850112915,
-0.14090575277805328,
0.25013771653175354,
-0.3480568826198578,
-0.2594311833381653,
-0.16495546698570251,
-0.6980348825454712,
0.12598547339439392,
-0.3796798288822174,
0.13235066831111908,
-0.01754935458302498,
1.0514651536941528,
-0.012306423857808113,
-0.15610727667808533,
-0.7574858069419861,
-0.6720780730247498,
0.5470702052116394,
-0.32901063561439514,
0.08453207463026047,
0.8026262521743774,
0.2625799775123596,
-0.08896739035844803,
-0.3071288764476776,
-0.2883233428001404,
-0.2837289869785309,
-0.10353774577379227,
-0.20697592198848724,
-0.1923939287662506,
-0.13332054018974304,
0.27678653597831726,
0.7232010364532471,
-0.5595653057098389,
0.04873187839984894,
-0.7557991147041321,
-0.062441516667604446,
0.5685548186302185,
0.18777789175510406,
0.2766408622264862,
-0.17585515975952148,
0.003393542720004916,
0.2785864770412445,
-1.1453231573104858,
0.24629324674606323,
0.7839712500572205,
0.2747895121574402,
-0.21576517820358276,
0.5551671385765076,
0.017175201326608658,
0.6119999289512634,
-0.19849492609500885,
-0.3385891616344452,
0.3313370943069458,
0.15287329256534576,
-0.027721481397747993,
-0.024006176739931107,
0.7100021243095398,
-0.15813064575195312,
0.37977397441864014,
-0.324820876121521,
-0.20694303512573242,
0.16058620810508728,
-0.04356801137328148,
-0.37562626600265503,
-0.3046574592590332,
0.45169395208358765,
-0.14837685227394104,
-0.5080116391181946,
-0.40487200021743774,
-0.54770827293396,
-0.061467744410037994,
-0.1954611837863922,
0.4469049274921417,
-0.6768544912338257,
-0.5797271132469177,
0.04336324706673622,
-0.006332711316645145,
0.35356834530830383,
0.00003376056702109054,
-1.2880383729934692,
0.11066453903913498,
0.48591241240501404,
0.6531543731689453,
0.20926861464977264,
-0.30868327617645264,
-0.36309516429901123,
0.04735579341650009,
-0.14510221779346466,
0.4137522578239441,
-0.4870988130569458,
-0.8304091095924377,
0.2721700072288513,
-0.03905787318944931,
0.39531612396240234,
-0.4719593822956085,
0.3965929448604584,
-0.22831712663173676,
0.5714300274848938,
-0.28482988476753235,
-0.35831624269485474,
-0.12480835616588593,
0.45410096645355225,
-0.3601837158203125,
1.189821481704712,
0.4414578378200531,
-0.3276381492614746,
0.3790895640850067,
-0.6604686975479126,
-0.7927703857421875,
0.7894007563591003,
-0.35125964879989624,
-0.25721752643585205,
0.15441706776618958,
-0.2621177136898041,
-0.04556773230433464,
-0.1745092123746872,
0.3486787676811218,
0.10832615196704865,
-0.26657259464263916,
-0.27085021138191223,
0.07044658809900284,
1.4209641218185425,
0.35092583298683167,
-0.48943212628364563,
-0.43723976612091064,
-0.5504189729690552,
-0.02289937622845173,
0.40990155935287476,
-0.6025686264038086,
-0.3447915017604828,
0.08942762762308121,
-0.2542678117752075,
0.09809843450784683,
0.0049271187745034695,
-0.41978126764297485,
0.5315457582473755,
-0.11891784518957138,
0.36784660816192627,
0.3461107313632965,
0.04199841246008873,
0.41207075119018555,
-0.4195500314235687,
0.8674125075340271,
-0.5406553745269775,
0.21558155119419098,
-0.2485121190547943,
-0.659103512763977,
-0.8834015727043152,
0.2639422118663788,
0.5683431029319763,
0.7047115564346313,
-0.8373880386352539,
0.2032303810119629,
0.04840175434947014,
-0.43943479657173157,
-0.4400087296962738,
0.18108823895454407,
0.29019102454185486,
0.406730055809021,
-0.07781233638525009,
-0.5794834494590759,
-0.5912798047065735,
-0.34669578075408936,
0.43822038173675537,
-0.6537512540817261,
-0.13559669256210327,
0.49431002140045166,
0.7424503564834595,
-0.0362396165728569,
0.7541762590408325,
-0.3321681618690491,
-0.5296686291694641,
-0.1419069468975067,
0.5368897914886475,
-0.10441970825195312,
0.5964168310165405,
0.8020363450050354,
-0.624489426612854,
-0.4228515326976776,
0.0490189827978611,
-0.9246813654899597,
0.03367672860622406,
0.0925646498799324,
0.09824448078870773,
0.010051479563117027,
0.10491982102394104,
-0.17302480340003967,
0.05588940531015396,
0.3922862112522125,
-0.2665897309780121,
0.5686731934547424,
-0.38874387741088867,
0.10457687079906464,
-0.8268096446990967,
0.17173649370670319,
-0.25188103318214417,
0.2982167601585388,
-0.6521152853965759,
0.5416286587715149,
-0.2507995069026947,
-0.33250290155410767,
-0.5372603535652161,
0.4222191572189331,
-0.5892468690872192,
0.39618176221847534,
-0.08595771342515945,
-0.1313757449388504,
-0.2626379430294037,
0.5917050838470459,
0.5654296875,
0.5637651681900024,
0.6850869655609131,
-0.7870897054672241,
0.4455188810825348,
0.37018758058547974,
-0.5241338610649109,
0.7304213643074036,
-0.6667793393135071,
0.2294847071170807,
-0.27529075741767883,
-0.5331457853317261,
-0.40910905599594116,
0.009895503520965576,
0.4699852764606476,
-0.631742537021637,
-0.005117535591125488,
-0.6189562082290649,
-0.298767626285553,
-0.3686809241771698,
0.2374708652496338,
-0.03815523535013199,
0.5837085843086243,
-0.2567993104457855,
0.2836037874221802,
0.8630071878433228,
-0.526680052280426,
-0.5707812905311584,
-0.7555744647979736,
0.36933502554893494,
-0.5883739590644836,
-0.477254718542099,
-0.13192600011825562,
0.07592270523309708,
-0.3206278681755066,
-0.0257948599755764,
0.5170571804046631,
-0.09151243418455124,
0.35057327151298523,
0.009332201443612576,
-0.07724832743406296,
-0.2985527217388153,
0.2683046758174896,
-0.10676674544811249,
0.05904361978173256,
0.29129382967948914,
-0.12753382325172424,
0.5727713704109192,
-0.2741222381591797,
0.053168702870607376,
0.45990103483200073,
0.5985690951347351,
0.021463265642523766,
-0.5394125580787659,
0.5383104681968689,
0.4731699824333191,
-0.46766147017478943,
-0.028855077922344208,
-0.7090325951576233,
0.2533010244369507,
-0.4490938186645508,
-0.04003484174609184,
-0.4466687738895416,
-1.0783852338790894,
0.7348810434341431,
-0.11194940656423569,
0.32925525307655334,
-0.05063363537192345,
0.7724788784980774,
-0.009362825192511082,
0.48904430866241455,
1.0540201663970947,
-0.14576032757759094,
0.6581172943115234,
-0.41948047280311584,
-0.06223390996456146,
-0.2761414647102356,
-0.4648953676223755,
-0.8396050333976746,
-0.11673298478126526,
-0.44863489270210266,
-0.1873367726802826,
0.05737535282969475,
0.12229090183973312,
-0.09027577191591263,
0.5641428828239441,
-0.3660365641117096,
0.57911616563797,
0.8823928833007812,
-0.021662404760718346,
0.36241772770881653,
0.1538630872964859,
-0.4495653212070465,
0.0934019461274147,
-0.8168488144874573,
-0.7183619141578674,
0.8800097703933716,
-0.010834544897079468,
0.5543727278709412,
0.38760197162628174,
1.1349475383758545,
0.3097054064273834,
0.418240487575531,
-0.5977551341056824,
0.056747835129499435,
0.595474123954773,
-0.8562867045402527,
-0.41051021218299866,
-0.44933709502220154,
-1.3583571910858154,
-0.02670815773308277,
-0.2715681493282318,
-0.7924711108207703,
0.17792652547359467,
-0.09600768983364105,
-0.4131041169166565,
0.10379393398761749,
-0.9762216806411743,
1.0333205461502075,
-0.4670858681201935,
-0.6934081315994263,
-0.09686314314603806,
-0.7203696370124817,
0.24953924119472504,
0.33683592081069946,
0.396798700094223,
0.20201043784618378,
0.3108710050582886,
0.5332068800926208,
-0.40887370705604553,
0.4628196656703949,
-0.22050221264362335,
-0.18310676515102386,
0.8452199697494507,
0.5248433947563171,
0.041935842484235764,
0.35032522678375244,
-0.0519668348133564,
-0.23364374041557312,
0.07242614775896072,
-0.5530740022659302,
-0.29425182938575745,
0.2929155230522156,
-0.6193279027938843,
-0.7678682804107666,
-0.578624963760376,
-0.2485370934009552,
0.013347971253097057,
0.22801867127418518,
0.05841291695833206,
0.07024706155061722,
-0.5992415547370911,
-0.06685042381286621,
0.7141276597976685,
-0.3117993474006653,
0.2709140479564667,
0.8314037322998047,
-0.294592022895813,
-0.10374937951564789,
1.2596486806869507,
0.14304324984550476,
0.18825718760490417,
0.327562540769577,
0.4457359313964844,
-0.18970158696174622,
-0.5777758359909058,
-0.7984015345573425,
-0.0130528649315238,
-0.15523621439933777,
0.16716596484184265,
-0.11801924556493759,
0.1238071620464325,
-0.21463271975517273,
-0.07295262813568115,
0.0004504188837017864,
-0.13345913589000702,
-0.008043628185987473,
-0.16266430914402008,
0.2924257218837738,
0.9298113584518433,
-0.5605476498603821,
0.3271770775318146,
-0.674089252948761,
-0.008003025315701962,
0.4420458674430847,
0.24723033607006073,
-0.20506413280963898,
-0.060562048107385635,
-0.23495551943778992,
0.3337756395339966,
-0.19688297808170319,
-0.7983362078666687,
0.34964439272880554,
0.15909479558467865,
0.5155967473983765,
0.4770347476005554,
-0.21889038383960724,
0.2191014438867569,
-0.2745046019554138,
0.7574862837791443,
0.09134101122617722,
-0.5797385573387146,
0.8595439791679382,
-0.4254644513130188,
0.21039223670959473,
0.7580906748771667,
0.6446858048439026,
-0.998505175113678,
-0.36006850004196167,
-0.8272297978401184,
-0.4838884174823761,
0.7307426929473877,
0.3388449549674988,
0.21375228464603424,
-0.07932223379611969,
0.26489609479904175,
0.27658069133758545,
0.37988755106925964,
-0.7180372476577759,
-0.4622245728969574,
0.005839944817125797,
0.35670000314712524,
-0.06418319046497345,
-0.17158780992031097,
-0.09724154323339462,
-0.23669007420539856,
0.6229231953620911,
0.05607200413942337,
0.05804832652211189,
-0.2709764838218689,
-0.33009612560272217,
-0.09085492789745331,
0.16431309282779694,
0.2887287735939026,
0.44548752903938293,
-0.03213977813720703,
-0.09389302879571915,
0.15961889922618866,
-0.5250558853149414,
0.38441282510757446,
-0.10230318456888199,
-0.6421040296554565,
0.07919204235076904,
-0.11027982831001282,
0.6530066728591919,
-0.141877681016922,
-0.6898594498634338,
0.10095364600419998,
-0.24914100766181946,
-0.10685529559850693,
-0.30595681071281433,
-0.07092059403657913,
0.2258964329957962,
-0.23620113730430603,
0.36632823944091797,
-0.3975112736225128,
-0.019606810063123703,
-0.9629899859428406,
0.14882299304008484,
0.1427019089460373,
-0.36410361528396606,
-0.07953228801488876,
0.6479032635688782,
0.4861302673816681,
-0.8206661939620972,
0.6740055084228516,
-0.7108826041221619,
-0.6428751349449158,
0.5453530550003052,
0.32748857140541077,
0.4149898886680603,
-0.4274084270000458,
0.740812361240387,
0.5692914724349976,
0.47626981139183044,
0.0015417697140946984,
0.6167590022087097,
-0.42394718527793884,
-0.6212114691734314,
-0.5186797976493835,
-0.44953450560569763,
-0.8650636076927185,
0.1035335510969162,
-0.3431072533130646,
0.4611186981201172,
-0.27018553018569946,
-0.011832448653876781,
-0.34796035289764404,
0.29806089401245117,
-0.3585768938064575,
0.17571711540222168,
0.2824597656726837,
0.38202276825904846,
-0.9868860840797424,
0.7125388383865356,
0.69981849193573,
-0.9821110367774963,
-0.653989851474762,
-0.9768893718719482,
-0.0641959086060524,
-0.8928500413894653,
0.3272956907749176,
-0.35587969422340393,
0.1376165896654129,
-0.094487264752388,
-0.4292885959148407,
-0.5213624835014343,
0.5507848858833313,
0.4774324595928192,
-0.11991859972476959,
-0.32634517550468445,
0.794721782207489,
0.704294741153717,
-0.04877106100320816,
0.35587742924690247,
0.4697735607624054,
0.2155482918024063,
0.1299220770597458,
-0.7273553013801575,
-0.3737098276615143,
-0.4068414866924286,
-0.3650267422199249,
0.30309537053108215,
-0.7394413352012634,
0.6062995791435242,
-0.4016154706478119,
-0.42658865451812744,
0.17818742990493774,
0.7864311337471008,
0.011598515324294567,
-0.20043008029460907,
0.20566220581531525,
0.6777064204216003,
0.8998109698295593,
-0.40754058957099915,
0.6549496054649353,
-0.2276104986667633,
0.507715106010437,
1.1188918352127075,
0.00513063371181488,
0.2521231174468994,
0.554222822189331,
-0.3593277037143707,
0.4632425308227539,
0.8254060745239258,
-0.13186946511268616,
0.15777333080768585,
0.6366193294525146,
-0.3687204122543335,
0.10545586049556732,
-0.34406578540802,
-0.5201574563980103,
0.4528745114803314,
0.5807469487190247,
-0.20850466191768646,
-0.42778193950653076,
-0.05850691720843315,
0.2582131624221802,
0.14401598274707794,
-0.20775075256824493,
0.28231897950172424,
-0.023731710389256477,
-0.6803420782089233,
0.2945811450481415,
0.0152766527608037,
0.637091338634491,
-0.5537453293800354,
-0.057918958365917206,
-0.42711448669433594,
-0.06996507197618484,
-0.2143716961145401,
-0.7626826167106628,
0.33398935198783875,
0.059155937284231186,
0.4360038936138153,
-0.29696497321128845,
0.3013249337673187,
-0.7079882025718689,
-0.3124658167362213,
-0.0957537516951561,
0.9260583519935608,
0.40976619720458984,
0.21931162476539612,
-0.6349917054176331,
-0.07973328977823257,
-0.11049402505159378,
0.0639159306883812,
0.29559528827667236,
0.6682454943656921,
-0.002668666886165738,
0.6901025176048279,
0.42943626642227173,
0.2732261121273041,
0.052704814821481705,
0.06972883641719818,
0.06925033032894135,
-0.31453144550323486,
-0.6009958982467651,
-0.6183252334594727,
0.1450248807668686,
0.18319424986839294,
-0.8855425715446472,
0.617993175983429,
0.8608914613723755,
1.132392406463623,
-0.13309243321418762,
0.6608706116676331,
-0.938398540019989,
0.20645879209041595,
-0.0857033059000969,
0.7858540415763855,
-0.24331572651863098,
-0.1600957065820694,
-0.21631620824337006,
-0.6674119830131531,
-0.24557439982891083,
0.6908742785453796,
0.09806858003139496,
-0.3012430965900421,
0.4364226758480072,
0.6719058156013489,
0.2595230042934418,
0.21705351769924164,
0.17664951086044312,
-0.25447800755500793,
0.2744259536266327,
0.9862785935401917,
0.9207800626754761,
-0.5897234082221985,
0.7459968328475952,
-0.822073757648468,
-0.26790130138397217,
0.16272051632404327,
-0.7236576080322266,
-0.788540244102478,
-0.7435218095779419,
-0.44591009616851807,
-0.5778030753135681,
0.08165053278207779,
0.8872064352035522,
0.3486611247062683,
-0.8360665440559387,
-0.8886269927024841,
-0.1914277821779251,
0.6085348725318909,
-0.27595627307891846,
-0.20331767201423645,
0.09092211723327637,
-0.00857378076761961,
-1.0376557111740112,
-0.03209633380174637,
0.021948711946606636,
-0.004326205234974623,
-0.3783077895641327,
-0.18742895126342773,
-0.4806499183177948,
-0.5917977094650269,
0.6272109150886536,
1.155135989189148,
-0.24193555116653442,
-0.549575686454773,
0.08269111812114716,
-0.01482317689806223,
0.14551900327205658,
0.7865288257598877,
-0.852723240852356,
0.5002092719078064,
0.28196319937705994,
0.5170553922653198,
0.7611658573150635,
-0.5134490132331848,
0.7630374431610107,
-0.5048342943191528,
0.2748022675514221,
0.34436658024787903,
0.40664270520210266,
0.1540483683347702,
-0.1104411631822586,
0.9791304469108582,
0.26760241389274597,
-0.35084980726242065,
-0.7379306554794312,
0.23723241686820984,
-0.6092662215232849,
0.573206901550293,
1.0787904262542725,
-0.054589830338954926,
-0.2897416651248932,
-0.5671265125274658,
-0.5765618681907654,
0.16393941640853882,
-0.24191130697727203,
1.0002834796905518,
0.8694689869880676,
-0.02595633454620838,
-0.06290354579687119,
-0.153603658080101,
0.34471595287323,
0.23574337363243103,
-0.5208684802055359,
-0.06119738146662712,
0.48588427901268005,
0.33138370513916016,
0.25299087166786194,
0.646767795085907,
-0.10652278363704681,
0.5255319476127625,
0.3635699152946472,
0.3234180808067322,
-0.09413737803697586,
0.008097933605313301,
-0.10868397355079651,
0.4493122398853302,
0.20051373541355133,
0.07902009040117264
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15491v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15491v1
|
Open Source Conversational LLMs do not know most Spanish words
| 2024-03-21T15:41:02 | 2024-03-21T15:41:02 |
Javier Conde, Miguel González, Nina Melero, Raquel Ferrando, Gonzalo Martínez, Elena Merino-Gómez, José Alberto Hernández, Pedro Reviriego
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The growing interest in Large Language Models (LLMs) and in particular in
conversational models with which users can interact has led to the development
of a large number of open-source chat LLMs. These models are evaluated on a
wide range of benchmarks to assess their capabilities in answering questions or
solving problems on almost any possible topic or to test their ability to
reason or interpret texts. Instead, the evaluation of the knowledge that these
models have of the languages has received much less attention. For example, the
words that they can recognize and use in different languages. In this paper, we
evaluate the knowledge that open-source chat LLMs have of Spanish words by
testing a sample of words in a reference dictionary. The results show that
open-source chat LLMs produce incorrect meanings for an important fraction of
the words and are not able to use most of the words correctly to write
sentences with context. These results show how Spanish is left behind in the
open-source LLM race and highlight the need to push for linguistic fairness in
conversational LLMs ensuring that they provide similar performance across
languages.
|
[
-0.24292616546154022,
-0.6372264623641968,
0.5758852362632751,
0.5049207806587219,
-0.14974358677864075,
0.34698671102523804,
-0.31834137439727783,
-0.6389321088790894,
0.28498154878616333,
0.3795635998249054,
-0.6231368184089661,
-0.5629705786705017,
-0.670232355594635,
0.17359967529773712,
-0.5061854124069214,
0.8060706853866577,
0.04538562148809433,
0.005257661920040846,
-0.3329085111618042,
-0.31976476311683655,
-0.11290217936038971,
-0.38644829392433167,
-0.4106808006763458,
-0.5134222507476807,
0.4971983730792999,
0.4330243468284607,
0.8647259473800659,
0.3440282344818115,
0.6024503707885742,
0.29102131724357605,
-0.433391809463501,
0.0791623666882515,
-0.934118926525116,
-0.13213790953159332,
-0.35924774408340454,
-0.6849043965339661,
-0.03956524655222893,
-0.0839931070804596,
0.3410290479660034,
0.5726974606513977,
-0.04274345189332962,
0.1881546825170517,
-0.07981941103935242,
0.7481226921081543,
-0.6193234324455261,
0.4384864270687103,
-1.0311813354492188,
0.058400146663188934,
-0.2048707902431488,
-0.2346322387456894,
-0.15642088651657104,
-0.6259682178497314,
0.1115996316075325,
-0.4305998384952545,
0.14923906326293945,
0.02380828745663166,
0.8006266951560974,
0.19986701011657715,
-0.051760558038949966,
-0.7557286024093628,
-0.6809166669845581,
0.7869918346405029,
-0.6204358339309692,
0.4584735035896301,
0.4990549385547638,
0.3499821126461029,
-0.5597774386405945,
-0.33671197295188904,
-0.6668142676353455,
-0.4489029049873352,
0.27735504508018494,
-0.000936530705075711,
-0.5671942234039307,
0.08559412509202957,
-0.10676435381174088,
0.46477562189102173,
-0.26503849029541016,
0.40282031893730164,
-0.5028954148292542,
-0.16504208743572235,
0.19014355540275574,
0.023280970752239227,
0.1424316018819809,
-0.03750351816415787,
-0.5915479063987732,
0.014555838890373707,
-1.1841404438018799,
0.13093210756778717,
0.37667831778526306,
0.27971917390823364,
-0.12942548096179962,
0.9358446002006531,
-0.0015435126842930913,
0.4653620719909668,
-0.3194480836391449,
-0.25714370608329773,
0.30313238501548767,
0.03091438114643097,
-0.4803582727909088,
-0.2608707845211029,
1.1123552322387695,
0.402313232421875,
0.5388526320457458,
-0.36870071291923523,
0.12295232713222504,
0.052682578563690186,
-0.1418652981519699,
-0.4068939685821533,
0.07881169766187668,
0.2904922366142273,
-0.11905473470687866,
-0.09294497966766357,
0.015775807201862335,
-0.4525976777076721,
-0.4182080328464508,
0.25763124227523804,
0.2736208140850067,
-0.22602733969688416,
-0.057703983038663864,
0.2008020132780075,
-0.2450147420167923,
0.18803292512893677,
0.27990177273750305,
-0.479746550321579,
0.264421284198761,
0.5331646800041199,
0.8279678821563721,
-0.14493319392204285,
-0.2173406183719635,
-0.08340827375650406,
-0.15416108071804047,
-0.48104286193847656,
0.8109027147293091,
-0.2805984914302826,
-0.7213678359985352,
0.05395956337451935,
0.21477021276950836,
0.0448216088116169,
-0.6310948729515076,
0.2897096872329712,
-0.5309980511665344,
0.3145272433757782,
-0.4210589528083801,
-0.35948845744132996,
-0.1167554184794426,
0.04497455060482025,
-0.25842511653900146,
0.8911320567131042,
-0.030552208423614502,
-0.8229231238365173,
-0.0060435812920331955,
-0.4150870442390442,
-0.142025887966156,
0.20001032948493958,
-0.3087204694747925,
0.3322713375091553,
0.3386691212654114,
-0.08477713167667389,
0.3873142898082733,
-0.42023512721061707,
0.11301412433385849,
-0.41318970918655396,
-0.4654558002948761,
0.6369011998176575,
-0.13659654557704926,
0.6431981325149536,
0.34400513768196106,
-0.2845143675804138,
-0.11394031345844269,
-0.49531397223472595,
-0.12718412280082703,
0.14618325233459473,
-0.5025615692138672,
-0.431029349565506,
0.2472350001335144,
-0.2711001932621002,
0.25193050503730774,
0.16401369869709015,
-0.8182715773582458,
-0.3335728347301483,
-0.8120537996292114,
0.2998511791229248,
0.7755739092826843,
-0.3878135085105896,
0.2830711603164673,
-0.46183085441589355,
0.5817009806632996,
-0.2326219081878662,
-0.2538720667362213,
-0.04920828342437744,
-0.6244431138038635,
-0.9544360041618347,
-0.0627899318933487,
-0.10337226092815399,
0.7501570582389832,
-0.6186437606811523,
0.365116685628891,
-0.28245043754577637,
-0.6523390412330627,
-0.6021677255630493,
0.3049699068069458,
0.5087618231773376,
0.5205489993095398,
0.1116907000541687,
-0.11195633560419083,
-0.48991602659225464,
-1.0941988229751587,
-0.27608370780944824,
-0.37404632568359375,
-0.29686233401298523,
0.4483327567577362,
0.5996900200843811,
-0.08968986570835114,
0.9298752546310425,
-0.2819282114505768,
-0.5691177248954773,
0.05670451745390892,
-0.15425021946430206,
0.07527770847082138,
-0.1345463991165161,
0.4463820457458496,
-0.16816546022891998,
-0.21244196593761444,
0.14140070974826813,
-0.6537743210792542,
-0.25153762102127075,
0.5015620589256287,
0.26942652463912964,
0.1249852403998375,
0.664465606212616,
-0.114803247153759,
0.09754274785518646,
1.1421921253204346,
-0.1461217999458313,
0.11322267353534698,
-0.28329959511756897,
-0.10419679433107376,
-0.9124172925949097,
-0.04213910922408104,
0.024675557389855385,
-0.11196813732385635,
-0.2376740574836731,
0.04569372907280922,
0.0721103698015213,
0.12068495154380798,
-0.992810845375061,
1.0765782594680786,
-0.593056321144104,
-0.1246323436498642,
-0.5005632042884827,
0.6507408618927002,
-0.2780989408493042,
0.2976704239845276,
0.24454212188720703,
0.8050004839897156,
0.37854140996932983,
-0.646858274936676,
0.4329169690608978,
0.03928292915225029,
-0.4847135543823242,
0.5474210381507874,
-0.8959353566169739,
0.20769217610359192,
-0.1767665445804596,
0.011620385572314262,
-1.169385552406311,
-0.05086173117160797,
0.15118196606636047,
-0.3864762485027313,
-0.34737229347229004,
-0.024251524358987808,
-0.4508512318134308,
-0.5254110097885132,
-0.19425378739833832,
-0.12211079150438309,
0.4801679253578186,
-0.47057077288627625,
0.0071921092458069324,
0.7550294399261475,
0.029629694297909737,
-0.7189697623252869,
-1.1662774085998535,
0.021213162690401077,
0.018824923783540726,
-0.6498454213142395,
0.028794432058930397,
0.029002171009778976,
-0.7380876541137695,
0.020114131271839142,
-0.10025297105312347,
-0.14587800204753876,
0.10271984338760376,
0.489875465631485,
-0.13207018375396729,
-0.1151803657412529,
0.4675823450088501,
-0.11108151823282242,
0.3288688063621521,
0.05071994289755821,
0.12291745841503143,
0.5317431688308716,
-0.43288367986679077,
-0.6264458298683167,
-0.017569266259670258,
-0.07246066629886627,
0.6284573078155518,
0.0681942030787468,
0.9088862538337708,
0.17093713581562042,
-0.3178655505180359,
-0.09549923986196518,
-0.8645890951156616,
0.15596789121627808,
-0.44745713472366333,
0.28812605142593384,
-0.34288835525512695,
-1.2115894556045532,
0.9548094868659973,
0.19699351489543915,
0.05441160127520561,
0.3971543610095978,
0.6925700306892395,
-0.1429750770330429,
0.43771329522132874,
0.5225201845169067,
0.11904407292604446,
0.409720242023468,
0.18552039563655853,
0.09872104972600937,
-0.5827935934066772,
-0.413120836019516,
-1.0450334548950195,
-0.07496186345815659,
-0.5024271011352539,
-0.713966965675354,
0.1878834068775177,
-0.1078498363494873,
0.0364978201687336,
0.3200216293334961,
-0.08467208594083786,
0.8177995681762695,
0.440140962600708,
0.09553197771310806,
0.7323645949363708,
-0.06963027268648148,
-0.09998002648353577,
-0.14413681626319885,
-0.7019385695457458,
-0.6924106478691101,
0.9396904110908508,
0.4630162715911865,
0.9221295714378357,
0.05125970020890236,
0.36166927218437195,
0.15202225744724274,
0.24249832332134247,
-0.9207518696784973,
0.5440579652786255,
-0.039344266057014465,
-0.45114070177078247,
-0.1662444770336151,
-0.413432776927948,
-1.0788854360580444,
0.3635539710521698,
-0.12311559170484543,
-0.6459233164787292,
0.0069082980044186115,
-0.14239856600761414,
0.022664159536361694,
0.3115234375,
-0.6249712109565735,
0.5519989132881165,
-0.10192596167325974,
0.011228547431528568,
-0.08482322841882706,
-0.25929901003837585,
0.6354926228523254,
-0.10942517966032028,
0.7234002351760864,
-0.49804455041885376,
-0.30813977122306824,
0.8023124933242798,
-0.5888651609420776,
0.8220575451850891,
0.1027279868721962,
-0.3670719861984253,
0.3470151424407959,
0.17497943341732025,
0.1953076273202896,
-0.17094245553016663,
-0.07928650081157684,
0.42593324184417725,
-0.01627475395798683,
-0.4053436815738678,
-0.13277840614318848,
0.9326976537704468,
-0.7559242844581604,
-0.5249505043029785,
-0.24285687506198883,
-0.30959051847457886,
-0.24586480855941772,
-0.1469167321920395,
0.3190314471721649,
-0.16687317192554474,
-0.6969096064567566,
0.3440167009830475,
0.5570341348648071,
-0.466315895318985,
0.2410498559474945,
0.7297249436378479,
-0.43152010440826416,
-0.15322251617908478,
0.4108220338821411,
-0.07873528450727463,
0.41781026124954224,
0.08180077373981476,
0.28083282709121704,
-0.3296664357185364,
-0.47154977917671204,
-0.3449562191963196,
0.4464951455593109,
-0.6510944366455078,
0.014795727096498013,
-0.5567449927330017,
-0.09847365319728851,
-0.262768417596817,
-0.05669363960623741,
-0.4202128052711487,
-0.19424349069595337,
-0.31145912408828735,
-0.056268904358148575,
0.417800635099411,
0.8251209855079651,
0.14344634115695953,
0.5933007001876831,
-0.8499094843864441,
0.2917685806751251,
0.32068395614624023,
0.4699629247188568,
0.041936758905649185,
-0.6218483448028564,
-0.05542026087641716,
0.2520027756690979,
-0.13989049196243286,
-1.2157748937606812,
0.2545679211616516,
0.23420697450637817,
0.8031542897224426,
0.4119853377342224,
-0.09028872102499008,
0.44797468185424805,
-0.3296884596347809,
0.7073350548744202,
0.227335587143898,
-1.0200577974319458,
0.6969494223594666,
-0.2776772677898407,
0.32034802436828613,
0.4926445186138153,
0.5196760892868042,
-0.7364736199378967,
-0.9931612610816956,
-0.48995518684387207,
-0.40721070766448975,
0.8204199075698853,
0.10557612776756287,
0.5777936577796936,
-0.5605632066726685,
-0.15357963740825653,
0.038747210055589676,
0.3002108037471771,
-0.968400239944458,
-0.2597522735595703,
0.1670016199350357,
0.02725932188332081,
-0.07656926661729813,
-0.25439780950546265,
0.023334695026278496,
0.15091437101364136,
0.6842789053916931,
0.0223065372556448,
0.020905449986457825,
0.15954475104808807,
-0.21478870511054993,
-0.37202581763267517,
0.3912184536457062,
0.6468808650970459,
0.7774904370307922,
-0.23089134693145752,
-0.014942815527319908,
0.06967058032751083,
-0.43152928352355957,
-0.012770508415997028,
-0.24008305370807648,
0.05131679028272629,
0.189950630068779,
0.0698033943772316,
0.7261353731155396,
0.4820461869239807,
-1.080585241317749,
0.7077271938323975,
-0.01951688900589943,
-0.3219318687915802,
-0.2623137831687927,
0.13211724162101746,
0.495411217212677,
0.23164236545562744,
0.27061372995376587,
-0.07401015609502792,
-0.4343360364437103,
-0.7888801097869873,
-0.40512773394584656,
0.6653741598129272,
-0.5247306227684021,
-0.21091605722904205,
0.448289692401886,
0.35853883624076843,
-0.44234296679496765,
0.30755388736724854,
-0.006747553125023842,
-0.3450804650783539,
0.5942110419273376,
0.3887113630771637,
0.5524492859840393,
-0.15076835453510284,
0.18424160778522491,
0.16651734709739685,
0.59892338514328,
-0.3634946346282959,
0.3548259735107422,
0.19217008352279663,
-0.9204139709472656,
-0.36156946420669556,
-0.6146235466003418,
-0.7387480139732361,
0.2827933430671692,
-0.17532165348529816,
0.37979191541671753,
-0.47912853956222534,
-0.042769141495227814,
-0.48742687702178955,
-0.2817310094833374,
-0.7144219279289246,
-0.26950979232788086,
-0.11203408241271973,
1.053033471107483,
-1.0170352458953857,
0.6810529828071594,
0.43474602699279785,
-0.38863611221313477,
-0.4664972126483917,
-0.5079020261764526,
-0.02829805761575699,
-1.1664907932281494,
0.7479729652404785,
-0.08430330455303192,
-0.3072357475757599,
-0.22981499135494232,
-0.3468972444534302,
-0.7648354172706604,
0.6356610059738159,
0.5341883897781372,
-0.6443436145782471,
-0.12200730293989182,
0.3006502389907837,
0.8111305832862854,
-0.17624731361865997,
0.44024303555488586,
0.020263902842998505,
0.34669721126556396,
0.4823617935180664,
-1.3151874542236328,
-0.2976043224334717,
0.05209401249885559,
-0.17027968168258667,
-0.05672181770205498,
-0.38937273621559143,
0.8174104690551758,
-0.2818168103694916,
-0.5009088516235352,
0.014561877585947514,
0.5434114933013916,
0.16878263652324677,
0.22061358392238617,
0.12731508910655975,
0.456094890832901,
0.7984997034072876,
-0.1608894318342209,
0.8766612410545349,
-0.2114778459072113,
0.22596199810504913,
1.2529340982437134,
-0.2903556525707245,
0.9999486207962036,
0.6014002561569214,
-0.3384092152118683,
0.415983110666275,
0.41322025656700134,
0.07737879455089569,
0.20263974368572235,
0.5678732395172119,
-0.08289305865764618,
0.18607044219970703,
-0.018590262159705162,
-0.36497974395751953,
0.6150279641151428,
0.4952273964881897,
-0.7648608088493347,
-0.4749361276626587,
0.12589271366596222,
0.2657290995121002,
0.45311444997787476,
-0.3781682848930359,
0.8732449412345886,
0.1597442626953125,
-0.670905351638794,
0.6673443913459778,
0.17435437440872192,
0.9346078634262085,
-0.5141862630844116,
0.41584253311157227,
-0.4737943410873413,
0.12643371522426605,
-0.28462743759155273,
-0.7895808815956116,
0.46829020977020264,
0.39441806077957153,
0.19291362166404724,
-0.03914179652929306,
0.4778894782066345,
-0.23078840970993042,
-0.3245624899864197,
0.4338299036026001,
1.2393457889556885,
0.6331698894500732,
-0.35789451003074646,
-0.3885136544704437,
-0.0654148980975151,
-0.1133669838309288,
0.034073490649461746,
0.25531306862831116,
0.35189926624298096,
-0.10527890920639038,
0.8101500272750854,
0.6751911640167236,
0.4975481629371643,
0.23437419533729553,
-0.005526780616492033,
0.5803214311599731,
-0.42943549156188965,
-0.21826018393039703,
-1.0541349649429321,
0.061144012957811356,
0.33272266387939453,
-0.30910003185272217,
0.8462362289428711,
0.3939846456050873,
1.0001744031906128,
-0.045790284872055054,
0.5204182267189026,
0.13428707420825958,
0.6491020917892456,
-0.3934459388256073,
0.616399884223938,
-0.3265402615070343,
0.4612795412540436,
-0.31172269582748413,
-1.0187108516693115,
-0.10872066020965576,
0.487088680267334,
-0.3387538194656372,
-0.2020261436700821,
0.6897708177566528,
0.8158605098724365,
-0.017693495377898216,
0.12477131187915802,
0.43265897035598755,
0.3467423915863037,
0.2257252335548401,
0.5607222318649292,
1.1014574766159058,
-0.22366131842136383,
0.7634487152099609,
-0.11482024192810059,
-0.35622531175613403,
-0.11898334324359894,
-1.0127795934677124,
-1.0275144577026367,
-0.5095357298851013,
0.12318065762519836,
-0.3377300202846527,
0.166958287358284,
0.8125813603401184,
0.3214888870716095,
-0.6185481548309326,
-0.5689666867256165,
-0.15840506553649902,
0.4425775706768036,
0.29303833842277527,
-0.21890954673290253,
-0.04021023213863373,
-0.25718045234680176,
-0.7655400037765503,
0.5889533758163452,
0.18020503222942352,
0.05017980560660362,
-0.4432721734046936,
-0.07577832043170929,
-0.04914257302880287,
0.19728921353816986,
0.44315898418426514,
0.5709436535835266,
-0.9837386608123779,
-0.1948738545179367,
0.23012900352478027,
-0.2855776250362396,
0.16850599646568298,
0.4494103491306305,
-1.0125030279159546,
0.24680113792419434,
0.6365830302238464,
0.4014962315559387,
0.15591368079185486,
-0.28795361518859863,
0.4814208149909973,
-0.5661993026733398,
0.32250216603279114,
0.20969243347644806,
0.3402218520641327,
0.350446492433548,
0.10756082832813263,
0.40247881412506104,
0.16001465916633606,
-0.4696519076824188,
-0.5806605815887451,
0.0900440514087677,
-0.7582004070281982,
-0.28988176584243774,
1.1929608583450317,
-0.27393221855163574,
-0.39669525623321533,
-0.1280597448348999,
-0.195648193359375,
-0.09420587867498398,
-0.3963474631309509,
0.7301318645477295,
0.86130690574646,
0.09584823995828629,
0.16182802617549896,
-0.4195235073566437,
0.3602306842803955,
0.07139123976230621,
-0.6392694711685181,
0.06199711561203003,
0.48148205876350403,
0.48422694206237793,
0.0997149720788002,
1.0544365644454956,
-0.26701775193214417,
0.1828475147485733,
-0.3152655363082886,
0.09521136432886124,
-0.09335514158010483,
0.029645023867487907,
-0.39724552631378174,
0.1571388840675354,
0.4093601107597351,
-0.22613120079040527
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14472v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14472v5
|
Detoxifying Large Language Models via Knowledge Editing
| 2024-03-21T15:18:30 | 2024-05-28T09:11:25 |
Mengru Wang, Ningyu Zhang, Ziwen Xu, Zekun Xi, Shumin Deng, Yunzhi Yao, Qishen Zhang, Linyi Yang, Jindong Wang, Huajun Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.HC, cs.LG
|
This paper investigates using knowledge editing techniques to detoxify Large
Language Models (LLMs). We construct a benchmark, SafeEdit, which covers nine
unsafe categories with various powerful attack prompts and equips comprehensive
metrics for systematic evaluation. We conduct experiments with several
knowledge editing approaches, indicating that knowledge editing has the
potential to detoxify LLMs with a limited impact on general performance
efficiently. Then, we propose a simple yet effective baseline, dubbed
Detoxifying with Intraoperative Neural Monitoring (DINM), to diminish the
toxicity of LLMs within a few tuning steps via only one instance. We further
provide an in-depth analysis of the internal mechanism for various detoxifying
approaches, demonstrating that previous methods like SFT and DPO may merely
suppress the activations of toxic parameters, while DINM mitigates the toxicity
of the toxic parameters to a certain extent, making permanent adjustments. We
hope that these insights could shed light on future work of developing
detoxifying approaches and the underlying knowledge mechanisms of LLMs. Code
and benchmark are available at https://github.com/zjunlp/EasyEdit.
|
[
-0.08393275737762451,
-0.7074425220489502,
0.6623758673667908,
-0.3707643151283264,
-0.24043245613574982,
0.16835995018482208,
-0.5516230463981628,
-0.25669416785240173,
-0.3173604905605316,
0.6204943060874939,
-0.22499126195907593,
-0.6274856328964233,
-0.42006227374076843,
0.09162475913763046,
-0.48783615231513977,
0.931926429271698,
0.18238428235054016,
0.08655360341072083,
-0.12077357620000839,
0.07332205027341843,
-0.4031984806060791,
-0.4085245430469513,
-1.0783337354660034,
-0.3323345184326172,
0.7348427772521973,
0.20819061994552612,
0.6564766764640808,
0.6671770215034485,
0.45350608229637146,
0.29317042231559753,
-0.6625059843063354,
0.1318937987089157,
-0.6812983751296997,
0.13610805571079254,
-0.39652219414711,
-0.5485761165618896,
-0.2751341760158539,
-0.1414911150932312,
0.6351901292800903,
0.5515875816345215,
-0.2011076807975769,
-0.14903391897678375,
0.017639003694057465,
0.8319547772407532,
-0.5417636632919312,
-0.1359269618988037,
-0.9335537552833557,
-0.0488925464451313,
-0.09090676158666611,
0.06986188888549805,
-0.5577864646911621,
-0.5012893080711365,
-0.16441303491592407,
-0.45271676778793335,
-0.5236501693725586,
-0.0333554781973362,
0.5838726758956909,
0.6273097991943359,
-0.36391836404800415,
-0.012492185458540916,
-0.5852200984954834,
0.707308828830719,
-1.080992341041565,
0.48436370491981506,
0.25512534379959106,
0.1994611769914627,
-0.1956917941570282,
-0.5652568936347961,
-0.30631986260414124,
-0.3462511897087097,
0.11928917467594147,
-0.06088017299771309,
-0.2496829479932785,
0.43463608622550964,
0.43488362431526184,
0.14784865081310272,
-0.2718554437160492,
0.4410446286201477,
-0.27685004472732544,
-0.13177065551280975,
0.5349454879760742,
0.17219656705856323,
0.6732531189918518,
-0.25364798307418823,
-0.41555550694465637,
0.2754954397678375,
-1.0504624843597412,
-0.3793639838695526,
0.6035712957382202,
0.067276731133461,
0.13203111290931702,
0.459134042263031,
-0.3098354637622833,
0.44950070977211,
-0.20723867416381836,
-0.13082255423069,
0.21297511458396912,
-0.1603371649980545,
-0.3134121298789978,
0.0221867673099041,
0.8903671503067017,
0.5258711576461792,
0.4858954846858978,
-0.4645025134086609,
-0.2960130572319031,
-0.3824247419834137,
0.5479373335838318,
-0.9222943782806396,
-0.2897578477859497,
0.4409484267234802,
-0.32119637727737427,
-0.6345471143722534,
-0.53525710105896,
-0.8397287726402283,
-0.7159496545791626,
-0.2622489631175995,
0.502225935459137,
-0.6944952607154846,
-0.451191782951355,
0.23687198758125305,
-0.1766664832830429,
-0.15999531745910645,
0.4379652738571167,
-0.7279678583145142,
0.20497851073741913,
0.63978111743927,
0.7230489253997803,
-0.19466933608055115,
0.03480859100818634,
-0.3731074035167694,
0.19590793550014496,
-0.5539659261703491,
0.4977853298187256,
-0.24743258953094482,
-0.07044549286365509,
-0.02735491842031479,
-0.39896145462989807,
0.004038073588162661,
-0.8878511190414429,
0.49671638011932373,
-0.8654380440711975,
-0.09130580723285675,
-0.4667750895023346,
-0.603246808052063,
-0.4505290985107422,
0.46901935338974,
-0.7334697842597961,
0.8197972774505615,
-0.23308023810386658,
-0.8731502294540405,
0.20978035032749176,
-0.7291373610496521,
-0.1231006607413292,
-0.024610955268144608,
0.21004103124141693,
-0.07099975645542145,
0.04444537311792374,
-0.03453885763883591,
0.32775065302848816,
-0.2186780869960785,
0.5590662360191345,
-0.35320281982421875,
-0.24971561133861542,
-0.012693732976913452,
-0.32353225350379944,
0.9960682988166809,
0.3328055143356323,
-0.19427287578582764,
0.45620036125183105,
-0.9414097666740417,
-0.03423371538519859,
-0.004584146663546562,
-0.5191669464111328,
-0.7157599329948425,
0.053256966173648834,
-0.2938123345375061,
0.3773767650127411,
0.07714419066905975,
-0.5420780777931213,
0.0837758406996727,
-0.41183051466941833,
0.45721521973609924,
0.8709703683853149,
0.525489330291748,
0.26212751865386963,
-0.3161373436450958,
0.17977678775787354,
0.1294896900653839,
0.16931641101837158,
0.37608006596565247,
-0.12112943083047867,
-0.7788668274879456,
-0.3935994505882263,
0.2231479287147522,
0.5291635990142822,
-0.925277829170227,
0.518002450466156,
-0.3591400980949402,
-0.6097261309623718,
-0.2683020234107971,
0.4649888575077057,
0.34680068492889404,
0.6120873689651489,
0.3561651110649109,
-0.0982852429151535,
-0.2717069387435913,
-0.9876474738121033,
-0.5514892935752869,
-0.18273234367370605,
-0.13714122772216797,
-0.015803521499037743,
0.4723573625087738,
-0.4490521550178528,
0.5415902137756348,
-0.3536217510700226,
-0.08136598020792007,
-0.12258560955524445,
-0.12081126123666763,
0.09823112189769745,
0.3789503574371338,
0.4775235652923584,
-0.1418738216161728,
-0.2327459454536438,
0.07428200542926788,
-0.7683135867118835,
-0.3163699805736542,
-0.25317278504371643,
-0.18350811302661896,
-0.279826819896698,
0.9319849014282227,
-0.6453884840011597,
0.09587293118238449,
0.13079507648944855,
0.016408780589699745,
0.7412264943122864,
-0.020481588318943977,
0.110182985663414,
-0.96743243932724,
0.31870606541633606,
-0.08007858693599701,
-0.16430094838142395,
-1.0565659999847412,
0.27453508973121643,
0.28284066915512085,
0.09481172263622284,
-0.6839852929115295,
0.527987003326416,
-0.3380758464336395,
0.4627928137779236,
-0.16469627618789673,
0.22395437955856323,
-0.09224814176559448,
0.40700680017471313,
0.00807363260537386,
0.48982229828834534,
0.3742034137248993,
-0.4048899710178375,
0.23586879670619965,
0.2216295450925827,
-0.6530216932296753,
0.2494775354862213,
-0.6162449717521667,
0.19951091706752777,
-0.10789185762405396,
-0.028237950056791306,
-1.0443545579910278,
-0.06317978352308273,
0.3744140863418579,
0.1313663125038147,
0.38884419202804565,
-0.22663943469524384,
-0.8248553276062012,
0.06587027758359909,
-0.3333926796913147,
0.14953835308551788,
0.36333781480789185,
-0.46402356028556824,
0.23174548149108887,
0.2969166338443756,
-0.24673669040203094,
-0.40731722116470337,
-0.6060944199562073,
0.3937685787677765,
-0.6985004544258118,
-0.3885140120983124,
-0.0952947810292244,
-0.16408833861351013,
-0.7796339392662048,
-0.27272486686706543,
-0.1918751448392868,
0.003348293947055936,
0.4799436330795288,
0.01583205536007881,
0.15290512144565582,
0.14296887814998627,
0.44804948568344116,
0.42946749925613403,
-0.07868274301290512,
0.4016648232936859,
0.14794425666332245,
0.3663816750049591,
0.11727423220872879,
-0.1313839703798294,
-0.4597433805465698,
0.17474815249443054,
0.7816343903541565,
-0.3839625418186188,
0.8064112067222595,
0.3782863914966583,
-0.5812668800354004,
-0.23578527569770813,
-0.7263815999031067,
-0.22126343846321106,
-0.4945308566093445,
0.45787161588668823,
-0.23099051415920258,
-0.6845534443855286,
0.6418113708496094,
-0.5963959693908691,
0.20439811050891876,
0.3418334126472473,
0.5419996380805969,
0.19104231894016266,
0.7489311695098877,
0.23106008768081665,
-0.16281379759311676,
0.5611898899078369,
-0.07122370600700378,
0.24002858996391296,
-1.0366603136062622,
0.027073217555880547,
-0.4948877990245819,
-0.1719079464673996,
-0.13532394170761108,
-0.3641555607318878,
0.5495534539222717,
0.34246256947517395,
-0.47547996044158936,
0.07866425812244415,
-0.17272938787937164,
0.6824029088020325,
0.23022842407226562,
0.2524256706237793,
0.399347186088562,
-0.2756900489330292,
-0.4392522871494293,
-0.002605631249025464,
-0.5461819171905518,
-0.5323053598403931,
1.0590825080871582,
0.5367864370346069,
0.8777800798416138,
0.0599527470767498,
0.8478658199310303,
-0.11281954497098923,
0.513985812664032,
-0.6777178645133972,
0.6510485410690308,
-0.07963920384645462,
-0.7252877950668335,
-0.269528329372406,
-0.5555399060249329,
-0.28835126757621765,
0.2310478687286377,
-0.22652564942836761,
-0.8850337862968445,
0.0992717519402504,
-0.15189778804779053,
-0.48133790493011475,
0.7880470156669617,
-0.8451391458511353,
0.8253785371780396,
-0.28380271792411804,
-0.4075024127960205,
-0.3537662625312805,
-0.6604490280151367,
0.773495614528656,
-0.4929641783237457,
0.3877776861190796,
-0.07924671471118927,
-0.13965284824371338,
0.8107640743255615,
-0.24665559828281403,
0.8386210203170776,
-0.21396204829216003,
-0.33578935265541077,
0.15396936237812042,
0.41275399923324585,
0.5698736310005188,
0.058753300458192825,
-0.46664491295814514,
0.5272614359855652,
-0.026023833081126213,
0.16064564883708954,
-0.43890589475631714,
0.721193253993988,
-0.7469222545623779,
-0.6618297696113586,
-0.15606652200222015,
-0.7432435750961304,
-0.46079787611961365,
0.5744950175285339,
-0.21419377624988556,
0.15447568893432617,
-0.006379934959113598,
0.34373292326927185,
0.8548384308815002,
-0.7877267003059387,
0.3716437518596649,
0.30723583698272705,
-0.20560961961746216,
-0.44175222516059875,
0.5629181861877441,
-0.0343131385743618,
0.7452706694602966,
0.43029624223709106,
0.4098602831363678,
-0.2953146994113922,
-1.018127202987671,
-0.24393506348133087,
0.24850121140480042,
-0.9300463199615479,
-0.2138604074716568,
-0.7504446506500244,
-0.30382463335990906,
-0.2414971888065338,
0.18852216005325317,
-0.363903671503067,
-0.1599455177783966,
-0.3324867784976959,
-0.4789118468761444,
0.4370693862438202,
0.6878651976585388,
-0.3204899728298187,
0.15734928846359253,
-0.620675265789032,
0.3942064046859741,
0.14806696772575378,
0.5148933529853821,
0.03145378455519676,
-0.4208543598651886,
-0.24468106031417847,
0.08750269562005997,
0.09232527017593384,
-0.9501170516014099,
0.33885934948921204,
0.16114401817321777,
0.6332792043685913,
0.650009274482727,
0.11265270411968231,
0.7104487419128418,
-0.670004665851593,
0.678143322467804,
0.16035804152488708,
-0.928023099899292,
0.4968598484992981,
-0.5290830731391907,
0.42260029911994934,
0.8052675127983093,
0.3038395345211029,
-0.896138072013855,
-0.6651272177696228,
0.03339357301592827,
-0.8925455212593079,
0.37676122784614563,
-0.195086270570755,
0.04995217174291611,
-0.27412480115890503,
0.5931321978569031,
0.11739084124565125,
0.24273206293582916,
-0.47974541783332825,
-0.11750925332307816,
0.21421706676483154,
-0.08214817196130753,
0.1355600506067276,
-0.47695407271385193,
-0.42346498370170593,
-0.36095768213272095,
0.8047275543212891,
0.07464232295751572,
-0.2362578809261322,
0.007803055923432112,
-0.3684127628803253,
-0.21301530301570892,
0.37795865535736084,
0.3667961359024048,
0.5955253839492798,
-0.29155099391937256,
0.19012689590454102,
0.3581830561161041,
-0.3526926040649414,
0.1118011400103569,
-0.22994714975357056,
-0.28371095657348633,
-0.4451204240322113,
0.28756844997406006,
0.4829845428466797,
0.4847022593021393,
-0.8963530659675598,
0.14407294988632202,
-0.12523692846298218,
-0.1853748857975006,
0.05885845422744751,
0.31814441084861755,
0.4361332058906555,
0.1722254455089569,
0.00191986421123147,
0.11655724048614502,
0.06840242445468903,
-0.2750189006328583,
0.3083466589450836,
0.38637101650238037,
-0.22916392982006073,
0.06739389896392822,
0.881829559803009,
0.27083927392959595,
0.08850491046905518,
0.603513777256012,
-0.04536798223853111,
-0.3398827016353607,
0.22640982270240784,
0.13422265648841858,
1.0362999439239502,
-0.24842113256454468,
-0.06786016374826431,
0.5295986533164978,
0.7444036602973938,
0.08758742362260818,
-0.07281699776649475,
0.31908732652664185,
-0.7645962238311768,
-0.40171143412590027,
-0.6057063937187195,
-0.08701422810554504,
0.5195534825325012,
-0.5681781768798828,
-0.015438535250723362,
-0.6987962126731873,
0.13748566806316376,
-0.030641255900263786,
-0.0785551592707634,
-0.37215444445610046,
0.21877755224704742,
0.1463318169116974,
1.0957430601119995,
-0.8127409815788269,
0.9492307901382446,
0.3432537317276001,
-0.2300751507282257,
-0.684175431728363,
-0.036156363785266876,
0.4938553273677826,
-0.48711270093917847,
0.36709165573120117,
0.05063285306096077,
0.09488815814256668,
0.025872893631458282,
-0.33926132321357727,
-0.8167922496795654,
0.8380305171012878,
0.492196261882782,
-0.9192816615104675,
0.09316116571426392,
0.01574925146996975,
0.6402565836906433,
0.3393010199069977,
0.2507695257663727,
0.7021303176879883,
0.6267744302749634,
-0.20718063414096832,
-0.8209337592124939,
0.2732858657836914,
-0.22020648419857025,
-0.022820211946964264,
0.0895858183503151,
-0.46063849329948425,
0.48994824290275574,
-0.24845358729362488,
-0.1342734545469284,
0.05789864808320999,
0.17281511425971985,
-0.08372996002435684,
-0.33771035075187683,
0.8777879476547241,
0.891876757144928,
0.771980345249176,
0.10488566756248474,
0.7421295642852783,
-0.4326031804084778,
0.12291897088289261,
1.110779047012329,
-0.3787033259868622,
0.7156698107719421,
0.6391599178314209,
0.1729501187801361,
0.23929834365844727,
0.5291928052902222,
0.2749064862728119,
0.578251302242279,
0.5066682696342468,
-0.4731252193450928,
-0.3412366807460785,
0.1080324575304985,
-0.23760484158992767,
0.4045999348163605,
0.3683014512062073,
-0.3900638222694397,
-0.5156302452087402,
0.08216997981071472,
0.4182102382183075,
-0.19372545182704926,
-0.3380379378795624,
1.0217888355255127,
0.13923445343971252,
-0.5882285833358765,
0.6752464175224304,
-0.09518603980541229,
0.450784832239151,
-0.7480180859565735,
0.1104874312877655,
-0.1338600069284439,
0.1496894508600235,
-0.11365650594234467,
-0.5742149353027344,
0.4575730860233307,
0.17096826434135437,
0.16185785830020905,
-0.46109744906425476,
0.9983201026916504,
-0.6359645128250122,
-0.13983149826526642,
0.5810468792915344,
0.5934563875198364,
0.08890718221664429,
-0.40304580330848694,
-0.5623824596405029,
0.22647200524806976,
0.012224769219756126,
-0.5630821585655212,
0.47481873631477356,
0.2905757427215576,
-0.05704465135931969,
0.8269238471984863,
0.6882563233375549,
0.3142812252044678,
0.09903652966022491,
0.2788003385066986,
0.9669603109359741,
-0.5600698590278625,
-0.13090193271636963,
-0.9289582371711731,
0.5896036624908447,
0.0407194048166275,
-0.18699146807193756,
0.6524920463562012,
0.5549887418746948,
0.7086015939712524,
-0.09206994622945786,
0.713714599609375,
0.10486208647489548,
0.3723718523979187,
-0.5869011282920837,
1.407092571258545,
-0.5517245531082153,
0.3779207766056061,
-0.33620521426200867,
-0.6238961815834045,
-0.5611680150032043,
0.1841374635696411,
-0.4781791567802429,
-0.043261751532554626,
0.7568851113319397,
0.9794023036956787,
0.17327900230884552,
-0.1312805563211441,
0.5360386967658997,
0.754403293132782,
0.5291600227355957,
0.3921482563018799,
0.8148029446601868,
-0.07260788232088089,
0.42621728777885437,
-0.5666195154190063,
-0.23095399141311646,
-0.05441592261195183,
-0.945658266544342,
-0.9815327525138855,
-0.25049465894699097,
-0.45802685618400574,
-0.18150833249092102,
0.17116418480873108,
0.744836151599884,
0.4214750826358795,
-0.5393595099449158,
-0.01224473025649786,
0.047870151698589325,
0.45751044154167175,
-0.5173014998435974,
-0.19919848442077637,
0.28629767894744873,
-0.31308531761169434,
-0.5917668342590332,
0.6405229568481445,
0.33804619312286377,
-0.4234040081501007,
-0.09629668295383453,
0.24418213963508606,
-0.390905499458313,
0.04228322580456734,
0.6868932247161865,
-0.011489363387227058,
-0.6912806034088135,
-0.7948479652404785,
-0.45296165347099304,
-0.1617944985628128,
-0.11713436990976334,
0.43045300245285034,
-0.455547034740448,
0.6612520813941956,
0.7167748808860779,
0.7161515951156616,
0.031230799853801727,
-0.05635746195912361,
0.31999671459198,
-0.7688019275665283,
-0.18246504664421082,
0.2556278705596924,
0.40881797671318054,
0.24285449087619781,
-0.44399622082710266,
0.49550122022628784,
0.0605817474424839,
-0.46556538343429565,
-1.018154263496399,
0.007368460297584534,
-0.9788461923599243,
-0.2785220444202423,
1.5843544006347656,
-0.15215277671813965,
-0.2803942561149597,
-0.09185667335987091,
-0.33541369438171387,
0.3197820484638214,
-0.029502935707569122,
0.9701291918754578,
0.8283863663673401,
0.15687178075313568,
-0.1761486977338791,
-0.8831009268760681,
0.6051000952720642,
0.047213491052389145,
-1.3938443660736084,
0.363924115896225,
0.6123991012573242,
0.8848603963851929,
-0.09272954612970352,
0.3410222828388214,
-0.4629601836204529,
0.2033180147409439,
-0.09902168810367584,
0.27614825963974,
-0.141403928399086,
-0.3369326889514923,
-0.4941655099391937,
-0.08697758615016937,
0.012205188162624836,
0.09629642963409424
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14469v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14469v1
|
ChatGPT Alternative Solutions: Large Language Models Survey
| 2024-03-21T15:16:50 | 2024-03-21T15:16:50 |
Hanieh Alipour, Nick Pendar, Kohinoor Roy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In recent times, the grandeur of Large Language Models (LLMs) has not only
shone in the realm of natural language processing but has also cast its
brilliance across a vast array of applications. This remarkable display of LLM
capabilities has ignited a surge in research contributions within this domain,
spanning a diverse spectrum of topics. These contributions encompass
advancements in neural network architecture, context length enhancements, model
alignment, training datasets, benchmarking, efficiency improvements, and more.
Recent years have witnessed a dynamic synergy between academia and industry,
propelling the field of LLM research to new heights. A notable milestone in
this journey is the introduction of ChatGPT, a powerful AI chatbot grounded in
LLMs, which has garnered widespread societal attention. The evolving technology
of LLMs has begun to reshape the landscape of the entire AI community,
promising a revolutionary shift in the way we create and employ AI algorithms.
Given this swift-paced technical evolution, our survey embarks on a journey to
encapsulate the recent strides made in the world of LLMs. Through an
exploration of the background, key discoveries, and prevailing methodologies,
we offer an up-to-the-minute review of the literature. By examining multiple
LLM models, our paper not only presents a comprehensive overview but also
charts a course that identifies existing challenges and points toward potential
future research trajectories. This survey furnishes a well-rounded perspective
on the current state of generative AI, shedding light on opportunities for
further exploration, enhancement, and innovation.
|
[
-0.4687040448188782,
-0.9414757490158081,
0.6363345980644226,
-0.04731614142656326,
0.05754760652780533,
0.3260645568370819,
-0.40853607654571533,
-0.37717077136039734,
0.11297617852687836,
0.45365315675735474,
-0.5259109735488892,
-0.3096427321434021,
-0.8315851092338562,
0.013989318162202835,
-0.5725581645965576,
0.9622242450714111,
0.13673433661460876,
0.0930868461728096,
-0.2909882068634033,
-0.06022201105952263,
-0.4164126217365265,
-0.6360658407211304,
-0.9822157621383667,
-0.4251449704170227,
0.4416126012802124,
0.11040753871202469,
0.5862959623336792,
0.0830509290099144,
0.6421656012535095,
0.37089022994041443,
-0.39588913321495056,
0.1274455040693283,
-0.4862997531890869,
0.4243689179420471,
0.3668881356716156,
-0.5284181833267212,
-0.48522892594337463,
0.015786508098244667,
0.7226707935333252,
0.7337009310722351,
-0.3532782196998596,
0.06122308969497681,
0.13985204696655273,
0.5447835922241211,
-0.2398686558008194,
0.230763241648674,
-0.7702308893203735,
0.04274819791316986,
-0.3310076594352722,
-0.1427527815103531,
-0.40488186478614807,
-0.28492239117622375,
0.19351382553577423,
-0.24112538993358612,
0.193076953291893,
0.1283704936504364,
0.3658931255340576,
0.2594597637653351,
-0.38688668608665466,
-0.4597688317298889,
-0.9609933495521545,
0.7241733074188232,
-0.7553391456604004,
0.4986250400543213,
-0.01042237039655447,
0.4593288004398346,
-0.4213724434375763,
-0.8982739448547363,
-0.4948402941226959,
-0.47109290957450867,
0.3091673254966736,
0.1520928144454956,
-0.24364151060581207,
-0.051401253789663315,
0.062056783586740494,
0.6735302805900574,
-0.6778415441513062,
0.4383513331413269,
-0.19862370193004608,
-0.11439593881368637,
0.45595264434814453,
0.41251933574676514,
0.4603462517261505,
0.06659743189811707,
-0.18840031325817108,
-0.014697859063744545,
-1.0429096221923828,
-0.1547987163066864,
0.324008971452713,
0.281893789768219,
-0.11709540337324142,
0.6779194474220276,
-0.1481296718120575,
0.6832346320152283,
-0.3907444179058075,
0.029160521924495697,
0.01167022343724966,
-0.28934356570243835,
-0.22332096099853516,
-0.04619660601019859,
0.9761552214622498,
0.06151595711708069,
0.015450503677129745,
0.014453275129199028,
-0.09729506820440292,
-0.11944525688886642,
0.1501518189907074,
-0.6610012650489807,
-0.16330741345882416,
0.16312383115291595,
-0.40056103467941284,
-0.2669491469860077,
-0.3691897392272949,
-0.7737156748771667,
-0.7780635356903076,
-0.33348673582077026,
-0.10293956845998764,
-0.48657727241516113,
-0.3549550175666809,
0.12348070740699768,
-0.04572658985853195,
0.6897734999656677,
0.4497588872909546,
-0.9149664044380188,
0.018944725394248962,
0.9959320425987244,
1.1069302558898926,
-0.13296350836753845,
0.011879581958055496,
-0.06269782781600952,
-0.18732789158821106,
-0.37053775787353516,
0.880473792552948,
-0.7091732621192932,
-0.7289969325065613,
0.2770143151283264,
-0.2681276500225067,
0.017590360715985298,
-0.4277065396308899,
0.51566481590271,
-0.7945051789283752,
0.3630966544151306,
-0.09012025594711304,
-0.6415073275566101,
-0.07102641463279724,
0.7201358079910278,
-0.44552677869796753,
0.9481456279754639,
-0.0933099091053009,
-0.6783527135848999,
-0.02168026939034462,
-0.8898038864135742,
-0.2351032942533493,
0.27206405997276306,
-0.2904529869556427,
-0.4462563991546631,
0.1391465961933136,
0.21886464953422546,
0.3332711160182953,
-0.6334181427955627,
0.276873916387558,
-0.3120756149291992,
-0.15502163767814636,
0.4139324128627777,
-0.9110451340675354,
0.8645344376564026,
0.24562940001487732,
-0.01205584779381752,
0.3075374364852905,
-0.49053844809532166,
-0.11656637489795685,
0.2654414474964142,
-0.3171306550502777,
-0.048102397471666336,
0.13968157768249512,
0.03370799496769905,
0.07181121408939362,
0.31490644812583923,
-0.4484367072582245,
0.3461284041404724,
-0.5139824748039246,
0.8539801836013794,
0.7467162609100342,
-0.0013961299555376172,
0.4131481647491455,
-0.35404473543167114,
0.7585306167602539,
-0.3445736765861511,
0.16586557030677795,
-0.27546796202659607,
-0.6412328481674194,
-0.9170426726341248,
-0.20719729363918304,
0.1550280749797821,
0.4325271248817444,
-0.6084420084953308,
0.32557693123817444,
-0.4603421688079834,
-0.6423510313034058,
-0.5939179062843323,
-0.05276544764637947,
-0.09976504743099213,
0.234679713845253,
0.12531988322734833,
-0.058657653629779816,
-0.5827130675315857,
-0.7555243372917175,
-0.14025260508060455,
-0.28360387682914734,
-0.08612998574972153,
0.31587547063827515,
0.2666027843952179,
-0.40310004353523254,
0.9023733139038086,
-0.5003570318222046,
-0.14100317656993866,
-0.5436834692955017,
-0.013482091948390007,
0.2681353986263275,
0.2057141214609146,
0.3003137707710266,
-0.7808666229248047,
-0.40532082319259644,
0.004638034384697676,
-0.5742141008377075,
0.15438470244407654,
0.048446644097566605,
0.00850940402597189,
0.0784902349114418,
0.6664107441902161,
-0.8213257789611816,
0.07679256051778793,
0.7256988883018494,
0.0629800483584404,
0.5368943214416504,
-0.06474169343709946,
0.15837796032428741,
-1.1857268810272217,
-0.0359945222735405,
-0.20418736338615417,
-0.08283679187297821,
-0.6982192397117615,
0.009412414394319057,
-0.3589039146900177,
-0.1473841816186905,
-0.33689478039741516,
0.5999963879585266,
-0.5412310361862183,
-0.0735723227262497,
-0.4143078923225403,
0.29687726497650146,
-0.5156424641609192,
0.13555219769477844,
-0.06464260071516037,
0.9262661933898926,
0.6113404631614685,
-0.35090771317481995,
0.6401025652885437,
0.45702773332595825,
-0.3426908850669861,
0.37768152356147766,
-0.5760707259178162,
0.2986406981945038,
-0.17343303561210632,
0.5207546949386597,
-1.1660175323486328,
-0.22397597134113312,
0.3084498941898346,
-0.5475208163261414,
0.20100627839565277,
-0.21104955673217773,
-0.6368477940559387,
-0.38392379879951477,
-0.1279257982969284,
0.3671140968799591,
0.8526758551597595,
-0.5071316957473755,
0.44268473982810974,
0.45579469203948975,
-0.4457464814186096,
-0.2617187201976776,
-0.49486228823661804,
0.5683781504631042,
-0.40254175662994385,
-0.6339067816734314,
0.19917362928390503,
-0.24659746885299683,
-0.38282841444015503,
-0.3025476634502411,
0.1891983151435852,
0.12384079396724701,
0.08968838304281235,
0.061301905661821365,
0.33211401104927063,
-0.39155110716819763,
0.07961837947368622,
-0.3639839291572571,
-0.09868809580802917,
0.05539601296186447,
-0.272597998380661,
0.8802422285079956,
-0.30402377247810364,
-0.6036545038223267,
-0.1463499665260315,
0.17745833098888397,
0.4890431761741638,
-0.2786311209201813,
0.682501494884491,
0.6250760555267334,
-0.22213810682296753,
-0.15377908945083618,
-0.5442417860031128,
0.005285338032990694,
-0.5011569857597351,
0.5547791123390198,
-0.016458403319120407,
-1.328183650970459,
0.47233858704566956,
-0.28875795006752014,
0.25626736879348755,
0.3674882650375366,
0.9028238654136658,
-0.05049603059887886,
0.7930710911750793,
0.7160786986351013,
-0.2388678789138794,
0.6986480951309204,
-0.15362843871116638,
0.5816490650177002,
-0.9248096942901611,
-0.1510971039533615,
-0.4738045930862427,
-0.19476650655269623,
-0.8823830485343933,
-0.4548857510089874,
0.5653417706489563,
-0.30238136649131775,
-0.21175172924995422,
0.021523896604776382,
-0.35585886240005493,
0.2720913589000702,
0.3733445703983307,
-0.13173723220825195,
0.33763599395751953,
-0.20707614719867706,
0.19416676461696625,
0.21873891353607178,
-0.8148240447044373,
-0.7062329053878784,
1.0925509929656982,
0.36467090249061584,
0.6072118878364563,
0.31547972559928894,
0.4505080580711365,
0.26006773114204407,
0.5961539149284363,
-0.9479659795761108,
0.6480701565742493,
-0.07829439640045166,
-0.6665396690368652,
-0.5476818084716797,
-0.3000563383102417,
-1.0424412488937378,
0.30938485264778137,
0.06206053867936134,
-0.744489312171936,
-0.32368892431259155,
0.11010730266571045,
-0.24092356860637665,
0.5195395350456238,
-0.5134041905403137,
0.6991158723831177,
-0.22348931431770325,
-0.14452795684337616,
-0.08402121067047119,
-0.4915012717247009,
0.589547872543335,
0.023232057690620422,
0.12910568714141846,
-0.26903876662254333,
-0.014951749704778194,
0.5097765922546387,
-0.15292835235595703,
0.9577209949493408,
0.15146860480308533,
-0.44382771849632263,
0.49600404500961304,
-0.03570443019270897,
0.5578926801681519,
0.012242366559803486,
-0.0045379032380878925,
0.15463458001613617,
-0.2106056958436966,
-0.21551109850406647,
-0.4466095566749573,
0.7735257148742676,
-0.625464141368866,
-0.7959343194961548,
-0.4170404076576233,
-0.5152714848518372,
-0.5741233229637146,
0.08577215671539307,
0.1663101315498352,
0.28236472606658936,
-0.5426763892173767,
0.2500208020210266,
0.6925968527793884,
-0.4014691412448883,
0.6477990746498108,
0.3224116563796997,
-0.19860230386257172,
-0.20569086074829102,
0.7379418611526489,
-0.13621792197227478,
0.21413280069828033,
0.4652228057384491,
-0.014409517869353294,
-0.46355342864990234,
-0.8366132378578186,
-0.29392296075820923,
0.02470201998949051,
-0.625641942024231,
-0.08580462634563446,
-0.5415853261947632,
-0.6457427740097046,
-0.5569465160369873,
-0.06484389305114746,
-0.5276855230331421,
-0.06255963444709778,
-0.252631276845932,
0.028712058439850807,
0.43943220376968384,
0.8032702207565308,
0.3914428949356079,
0.5105818510055542,
-0.7632271647453308,
0.0771407037973404,
0.2927938401699066,
0.4169289171695709,
0.08300390839576721,
-0.5667993426322937,
0.11278500407934189,
0.11775509268045425,
-0.3622260093688965,
-0.5776427984237671,
0.43034428358078003,
-0.0133680310100317,
0.649062991142273,
0.1897985339164734,
-0.1493346393108368,
0.5182670950889587,
-0.6837977170944214,
1.0674189329147339,
0.2880350947380066,
-0.4722462594509125,
0.26180148124694824,
-0.620212733745575,
0.23573602735996246,
0.16359315812587738,
0.3611707091331482,
-1.1146442890167236,
-0.26954400539398193,
-0.4942639470100403,
-0.8594777584075928,
0.3034503757953644,
0.3023858368396759,
0.4254155158996582,
0.05974402651190758,
0.18056021630764008,
0.09886771440505981,
0.17619606852531433,
-0.7572829127311707,
-0.14581939578056335,
0.1553794890642166,
-0.26778826117515564,
-0.327911376953125,
-0.1879258006811142,
0.0723174437880516,
0.1277843862771988,
0.7072991132736206,
-0.04097365215420723,
0.46152618527412415,
-0.1386859118938446,
-0.006559962406754494,
0.3487953543663025,
0.6155440211296082,
0.5044875144958496,
0.547326385974884,
0.05017349123954773,
0.1345425695180893,
0.28128933906555176,
-0.2329753190279007,
0.14337342977523804,
0.1219644844532013,
-0.11830677092075348,
-0.2090022712945938,
0.3717764616012573,
0.7115303874015808,
-0.04802621155977249,
-0.7694790959358215,
0.4580440819263458,
-0.046602483838796616,
-0.17279386520385742,
-0.6298709511756897,
0.14033149182796478,
0.34906721115112305,
0.3583095371723175,
0.16529187560081482,
-0.017825419083237648,
0.09022394567728043,
-0.5154036283493042,
-0.12866070866584778,
0.70210200548172,
-0.5725123882293701,
-0.22151322662830353,
0.5656710267066956,
0.24727275967597961,
-0.5698498487472534,
0.8510443568229675,
0.009496149607002735,
-0.4000231623649597,
0.5004999041557312,
0.3846638798713684,
1.0179357528686523,
-0.01404896192252636,
0.11335235089063644,
0.07748981565237045,
0.3054058253765106,
-0.11458118259906769,
-0.22023844718933105,
0.03321434184908867,
-0.9422512054443359,
-0.3710636794567108,
-0.6926707625389099,
-0.5068883895874023,
0.4210735261440277,
-0.18372012674808502,
0.21246026456356049,
-0.2196497619152069,
-0.15303659439086914,
-0.12461888045072556,
-0.16338816285133362,
-0.5631376504898071,
-0.18133807182312012,
0.4129406809806824,
0.747148334980011,
-0.605438768863678,
0.6604288220405579,
0.6493540406227112,
-0.30534133315086365,
-0.1442112773656845,
0.03804607316851616,
0.17658351361751556,
-0.9432263374328613,
0.2853374481201172,
-0.011313767172396183,
-0.06091370806097984,
0.11495238542556763,
-0.6239798665046692,
-0.8678669333457947,
1.0556495189666748,
0.2155265212059021,
-0.6321945190429688,
-0.1343640238046646,
0.3271072506904602,
0.7514467835426331,
-0.1625611037015915,
0.3485383093357086,
0.7122344970703125,
0.25535550713539124,
0.23793551325798035,
-0.7513631582260132,
-0.29772016406059265,
-0.2106710970401764,
0.2613079249858856,
0.2282826155424118,
-0.8917018175125122,
0.47339868545532227,
0.017202038317918777,
-0.09696453809738159,
0.42183414101600647,
0.6078273057937622,
0.3681652247905731,
0.0678630843758583,
0.29195764660835266,
0.2946053743362427,
0.4982372224330902,
-0.1472708284854889,
0.9423971772193909,
-0.18402060866355896,
0.24933761358261108,
1.0151323080062866,
-0.24573250114917755,
0.8071212768554688,
0.4784076511859894,
-0.5618221163749695,
0.1917162984609604,
0.8698312044143677,
-0.05304371193051338,
0.13582803308963776,
0.44445034861564636,
-0.5644935965538025,
-0.37314626574516296,
-0.07422929257154465,
-0.4025282561779022,
0.5540708899497986,
0.5348202586174011,
-0.1805238276720047,
-0.28209689259529114,
-0.06589670479297638,
-0.11709024012088776,
-0.027782632037997246,
-0.20928366482257843,
0.8128983974456787,
0.18669748306274414,
-0.6373506188392639,
0.123959019780159,
0.041197679936885834,
0.8512319922447205,
-0.7243013978004456,
-0.08939305692911148,
-0.4173027575016022,
-0.047065429389476776,
0.15604326128959656,
-0.7702007293701172,
0.18936794996261597,
0.017041636630892754,
0.053322236984968185,
-0.5505064129829407,
0.7320427298545837,
-0.22244809567928314,
-0.4822009801864624,
0.024303432554006577,
0.7470476031303406,
0.16215479373931885,
0.08382346481084824,
-0.6466871500015259,
0.16113606095314026,
-0.0638149231672287,
-0.1792815923690796,
0.28808024525642395,
0.3306680917739868,
0.0914856493473053,
0.9595673680305481,
0.6261081695556641,
0.029263053089380264,
0.16993646323680878,
0.07839948683977127,
0.8388540148735046,
-0.6796432733535767,
-0.3292306959629059,
-0.929822564125061,
0.29594188928604126,
0.0171494223177433,
-0.32243332266807556,
0.7580581903457642,
0.6654074192047119,
0.7593538761138916,
0.12304501980543137,
1.0100425481796265,
-0.06788013875484467,
0.4232301712036133,
-0.5307894945144653,
0.6999843716621399,
-0.33910292387008667,
0.49517056345939636,
-0.07840074598789215,
-0.8334203958511353,
-0.3388514518737793,
0.21452845633029938,
-0.5540696382522583,
0.3099824786186218,
0.2870955169200897,
0.8376691341400146,
0.10026051849126816,
0.2601776719093323,
0.3437185287475586,
0.19967971742153168,
0.620456337928772,
0.45706140995025635,
1.4740480184555054,
-0.23737311363220215,
0.6461688876152039,
0.35043248534202576,
-0.08429248631000519,
-0.2632037103176117,
-0.8216012120246887,
-0.8181732892990112,
-0.6052219867706299,
-0.32246869802474976,
0.08178524672985077,
0.045633938163518906,
0.8237351775169373,
0.5448889136314392,
-0.7005282044410706,
-0.2790822982788086,
-0.34994953870773315,
0.06129138916730881,
0.12573520839214325,
-0.19982510805130005,
0.18153022229671478,
-0.49057072401046753,
-0.9040175080299377,
0.409518301486969,
0.2708625793457031,
0.23839420080184937,
-0.4538821876049042,
-0.018595241010189056,
-0.028184808790683746,
0.0011497572995722294,
0.8586399555206299,
0.3103075623512268,
-0.83599853515625,
-0.20170266926288605,
0.026395902037620544,
-0.09668582677841187,
0.23656155169010162,
0.8942934274673462,
-0.42487722635269165,
0.2203330248594284,
0.5496841669082642,
0.9474341869354248,
0.5037876963615417,
-0.32898053526878357,
0.602525532245636,
-0.5068213939666748,
0.0024386814329773188,
0.3772583603858948,
0.40446239709854126,
0.4772540032863617,
-0.10426570475101471,
0.5023363828659058,
0.05300920084118843,
-0.6601243615150452,
-0.8179554343223572,
0.34715256094932556,
-0.8621522188186646,
-0.24686531722545624,
1.2119970321655273,
0.1426408886909485,
0.026390574872493744,
0.03288213536143303,
-0.31608664989471436,
0.21623417735099792,
-0.1552434116601944,
0.8683789968490601,
0.8261420130729675,
-0.43612146377563477,
-0.37631866335868835,
-0.7217456698417664,
0.4420241117477417,
0.27710744738578796,
-0.9224501252174377,
0.25392311811447144,
0.5458115339279175,
0.21103300154209137,
-0.09626977890729904,
0.7466380000114441,
-0.19112446904182434,
-0.24384883046150208,
-0.05000699311494827,
0.032998498529195786,
0.25526222586631775,
-0.025678489357233047,
-0.4569942355155945,
0.2180856466293335,
0.45181891322135925,
-0.026407679542899132
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14467v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14467v2
|
Recourse for reclamation: Chatting with generative language models
| 2024-03-21T15:14:25 | 2024-04-21T10:59:51 |
Jennifer Chien, Kevin R. McKee, Jackie Kay, William Isaac
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Researchers and developers increasingly rely on toxicity scoring to moderate
generative language model outputs, in settings such as customer service,
information retrieval, and content generation. However, toxicity scoring may
render pertinent information inaccessible, rigidify or "value-lock" cultural
norms, and prevent language reclamation processes, particularly for
marginalized people. In this work, we extend the concept of algorithmic
recourse to generative language models: we provide users a novel mechanism to
achieve their desired prediction by dynamically setting thresholds for toxicity
filtering. Users thereby exercise increased agency relative to interactions
with the baseline system. A pilot study ($n = 30$) supports the potential of
our proposed recourse mechanism, indicating improvements in usability compared
to fixed-threshold toxicity-filtering of model outputs. Future work should
explore the intersection of toxicity scoring, model controllability, user
agency, and language reclamation processes -- particularly with regard to the
bias that many communities encounter when interacting with generative language
models.
|
[
-0.07164304703474045,
-0.651199221611023,
0.6350372433662415,
0.3137083351612091,
-0.10472127795219421,
0.12684696912765503,
-0.12031497806310654,
-0.5214002132415771,
0.10283079743385315,
0.9713578820228577,
-0.5729464292526245,
-0.45506471395492554,
-0.46548977494239807,
-0.16798800230026245,
-0.4878515899181366,
1.0607472658157349,
0.26784610748291016,
-0.4181098937988281,
-0.241437628865242,
-0.11784786731004715,
-0.694466233253479,
-0.3470785319805145,
-0.8783039450645447,
-0.5390831232070923,
0.9014301896095276,
0.5370243787765503,
0.9425147175788879,
0.7045319676399231,
0.43841609358787537,
0.3726973831653595,
0.007455558516085148,
-0.4224775731563568,
-0.5970478057861328,
0.5748153924942017,
-0.47144389152526855,
-0.6214127540588379,
-0.18910443782806396,
0.07702093571424484,
0.21361015737056732,
0.5909583568572998,
-0.6803810596466064,
0.02874627709388733,
0.0029359832406044006,
0.6382773518562317,
-0.7062186002731323,
-0.006914996542036533,
-0.8123511672019958,
0.22330355644226074,
-0.24441653490066528,
-0.640501081943512,
-0.7016856670379639,
-0.2964559495449066,
0.0208866186439991,
-0.6151053309440613,
0.14517055451869965,
-0.0947340577840805,
0.8493836522102356,
0.2869023084640503,
-0.048331137746572495,
-0.23543420433998108,
-0.8114402294158936,
1.0109224319458008,
-0.5936776399612427,
-0.026874028146266937,
0.5816720128059387,
0.3735004961490631,
-0.1071765348315239,
-0.846020519733429,
-0.2974787652492523,
-0.4547760486602783,
-0.11202407628297806,
0.09244078397750854,
-0.43917417526245117,
0.07900772988796234,
0.4690084457397461,
0.3697375953197479,
-0.22728373110294342,
0.15441884100437164,
-0.4771277904510498,
-0.33900633454322815,
0.7271521091461182,
0.44279173016548157,
0.5877685546875,
-0.39376866817474365,
-0.5082745552062988,
0.1991419643163681,
-0.8070470690727234,
-0.15208207070827484,
0.47145992517471313,
0.4449540972709656,
0.11755866557359695,
0.4114421010017395,
-0.2571059763431549,
0.5739961266517639,
-0.08919576555490494,
0.38574033975601196,
0.13555456697940826,
-0.049947381019592285,
0.06192122399806976,
-0.3086671233177185,
0.8098761439323425,
0.5904281735420227,
0.2089080661535263,
-0.156086266040802,
-0.14208130538463593,
-0.12875351309776306,
0.7851715683937073,
-0.5271202325820923,
-0.4037564694881439,
0.2507462501525879,
-0.5448333621025085,
-0.659724235534668,
-0.27164748311042786,
-1.2138984203338623,
-0.7433784604072571,
-0.09260707348585129,
0.24860575795173645,
-0.2528995871543884,
-0.7111296057701111,
-0.09893043339252472,
-0.2607146203517914,
-0.05038844421505928,
0.1675528883934021,
-0.9530203938484192,
0.22193001210689545,
0.4507780075073242,
1.0116169452667236,
-0.1038142517209053,
0.025729171931743622,
-0.5603517293930054,
-0.023084888234734535,
-0.18388712406158447,
0.7121192216873169,
-0.952926516532898,
-0.6531459093093872,
0.2448994666337967,
-0.3021497428417206,
0.22029437124729156,
-0.7263420820236206,
0.7366114258766174,
-0.8523299098014832,
0.20132222771644592,
-0.3283773362636566,
-0.12458888441324234,
-0.020063554868102074,
0.11470730602741241,
-0.7519781589508057,
0.7056183815002441,
0.20025725662708282,
-0.831423819065094,
0.3559551537036896,
-0.6645767092704773,
-0.17319318652153015,
0.5034624934196472,
0.15742525458335876,
-0.08365695178508759,
-0.0016724824672564864,
-0.3849446177482605,
0.03526565805077553,
-0.14574876427650452,
0.10711521655321121,
-0.4100154936313629,
-0.1372768133878708,
0.15972965955734253,
-0.8160876631736755,
0.9011113047599792,
0.7458515763282776,
-0.10009248554706573,
0.2996416985988617,
-0.4912439286708832,
0.1709863543510437,
-0.1784454882144928,
-0.7519025206565857,
-0.5400149822235107,
0.26959213614463806,
0.09770585596561432,
0.3483924865722656,
0.08585253357887268,
-0.48615777492523193,
-0.13678821921348572,
-0.2738398313522339,
0.5331639051437378,
0.8985475897789001,
0.1276833415031433,
0.33913692831993103,
-0.43661966919898987,
0.7162247896194458,
-0.11664405465126038,
0.12579616904258728,
-0.06197449937462807,
-0.3929812014102936,
-0.7255136966705322,
-0.11736027896404266,
0.15026840567588806,
0.44516894221305847,
-1.0604311227798462,
0.16845904290676117,
-0.39253613352775574,
-0.5333662629127502,
-0.5369365215301514,
0.05167357996106148,
0.6624258160591125,
0.27600041031837463,
0.1627001166343689,
-0.7340229749679565,
-0.5055628418922424,
-0.6209428906440735,
-0.2845044434070587,
-0.44586247205734253,
-0.35994991660118103,
0.4764423072338104,
0.05723969638347626,
-0.002287842333316803,
0.9432001709938049,
-0.580466091632843,
-0.3255116045475006,
-0.13578630983829498,
0.4346788823604584,
0.042451951652765274,
0.441374808549881,
0.389594703912735,
-0.8921897411346436,
-0.5912412405014038,
-0.1238831952214241,
-0.662128210067749,
-0.5189611911773682,
0.16375412046909332,
-0.34645992517471313,
0.06423022598028183,
0.6573706865310669,
-0.46840426325798035,
0.35627081990242004,
0.42398107051849365,
-0.3776628077030182,
0.4974899888038635,
-0.21947555243968964,
0.21514619886875153,
-0.8284286260604858,
0.27604594826698303,
0.0355568453669548,
-0.3223612904548645,
-0.7428688406944275,
0.4290260374546051,
-0.5142710208892822,
-0.2674417197704315,
-0.4826194941997528,
0.5781428813934326,
-0.2773644030094147,
0.2996709942817688,
-0.5896784067153931,
0.08259908854961395,
-0.16291920840740204,
0.23368528485298157,
0.19914987683296204,
0.6239710450172424,
0.28370267152786255,
-0.6329922676086426,
0.28924238681793213,
-0.049659233540296555,
-0.06222071498632431,
0.7135063409805298,
-0.5215796232223511,
0.061978746205568314,
-0.10250217467546463,
-0.027903912588953972,
-0.9188514947891235,
-0.2037615180015564,
0.3227955102920532,
-0.4769096076488495,
0.1795235425233841,
-0.20110605657100677,
-0.13793551921844482,
-0.32203060388565063,
-0.2982693314552307,
0.38383498787879944,
0.5170281529426575,
-0.30807337164878845,
0.48785215616226196,
0.7047390341758728,
-0.46110451221466064,
-0.5835926532745361,
-0.4996168315410614,
0.28052228689193726,
-0.5211799740791321,
-0.23633703589439392,
0.23928451538085938,
-0.07577291876077652,
-0.30453068017959595,
0.22605188190937042,
0.3131304681301117,
-0.07635857909917831,
0.1885741651058197,
0.466349720954895,
-0.16795291006565094,
0.14615759253501892,
0.3175748586654663,
0.030594680458307266,
-0.3738205134868622,
0.40803763270378113,
0.18080781400203705,
0.7756765484809875,
0.21088893711566925,
-0.2945970594882965,
-0.021824965253472328,
0.5673868060112,
0.7877561450004578,
-0.16562305390834808,
0.7708430290222168,
0.16620028018951416,
-0.5335273146629333,
0.05769309028983116,
-0.5276806354522705,
-0.14025340974330902,
-0.5556966066360474,
0.39387816190719604,
-0.23884104192256927,
-0.6820344924926758,
0.6396786570549011,
0.011263484135270119,
0.18030276894569397,
0.4574354290962219,
0.6887878775596619,
-0.059876758605241776,
0.9866755604743958,
0.6960917711257935,
-0.276576966047287,
0.6034312844276428,
-0.0296785868704319,
0.2932405471801758,
-0.6489911079406738,
0.005457103252410889,
-0.600741446018219,
-0.06405175477266312,
-0.6732043027877808,
-0.20482097566127777,
0.21258319914340973,
-0.23504577577114105,
-0.17614363133907318,
0.24098186194896698,
-0.36691370606422424,
0.5971511602401733,
0.6710020303726196,
0.20962181687355042,
0.5347734093666077,
0.07697699218988419,
-0.1541939675807953,
-0.15429458022117615,
-0.5962809324264526,
-0.6295250058174133,
0.731713056564331,
0.5277787446975708,
0.6680923700332642,
0.17490829527378082,
0.6039411425590515,
0.7539495229721069,
1.0988496541976929,
-0.5489159822463989,
0.4726647436618805,
-0.130280539393425,
-0.8407551646232605,
-0.5102539658546448,
-0.6780272126197815,
-1.0277997255325317,
0.3852021396160126,
-0.07126466929912567,
-0.837533712387085,
0.19003839790821075,
0.19424444437026978,
-0.36096638441085815,
0.37563595175743103,
-0.7285821437835693,
0.7802696824073792,
0.2015441507101059,
-0.5662562251091003,
-0.6802806854248047,
-0.4796634912490845,
0.4337822496891022,
-0.015925852581858635,
0.45237860083580017,
-0.27639880776405334,
0.2993308901786804,
0.47238945960998535,
-0.5014826655387878,
1.081839680671692,
-0.5211506485939026,
-0.21388791501522064,
0.46521592140197754,
0.417277455329895,
0.06943244487047195,
-0.1331884115934372,
-0.2971916198730469,
0.06616630405187607,
0.03933075815439224,
-0.33655068278312683,
-0.3429829478263855,
0.8725265860557556,
-0.5018675327301025,
-0.8039824366569519,
-0.565009355545044,
-0.47495779395103455,
0.011372777633368969,
0.22356359660625458,
0.26076823472976685,
-0.06794318556785583,
-0.14406727254390717,
-0.026552138850092888,
0.3485819399356842,
-0.3914490044116974,
0.3134990930557251,
0.7781602144241333,
-0.1736820638179779,
-0.1823658049106598,
1.0745383501052856,
-0.1016797423362732,
0.570235013961792,
0.12637852132320404,
0.16103464365005493,
-0.26969820261001587,
-0.4088074564933777,
-0.13310623168945312,
0.041393619030714035,
-0.5990424752235413,
-0.5490771532058716,
-0.3365549147129059,
-0.5078796148300171,
0.1495087593793869,
0.1707763373851776,
-0.1682964414358139,
-0.10740478336811066,
-0.2597457766532898,
-0.32842734456062317,
0.2901858985424042,
0.5174736380577087,
-0.3731123208999634,
0.21060383319854736,
-0.9139619469642639,
0.047651998698711395,
0.23748622834682465,
0.6787047982215881,
0.32832351326942444,
-0.6659492254257202,
-0.05792241543531418,
0.240986168384552,
-0.6534896492958069,
-0.8533629775047302,
0.49738195538520813,
0.053958144038915634,
0.49024343490600586,
0.46302202343940735,
0.2053462266921997,
0.5315030813217163,
-0.5892499685287476,
0.5793877243995667,
0.21863332390785217,
-0.8414960503578186,
0.4665888547897339,
-0.4283795654773712,
-0.07364995777606964,
0.6007599830627441,
0.4222332239151001,
-1.1242221593856812,
-0.8476364016532898,
-0.3599379062652588,
-1.0705275535583496,
0.7575152516365051,
0.15267391502857208,
0.8562439680099487,
-0.35370180010795593,
0.43169572949409485,
-0.08154991269111633,
0.10277760028839111,
-0.8877599239349365,
0.014761471189558506,
-0.18697336316108704,
-0.2616721987724304,
0.19107627868652344,
-0.7463982701301575,
-0.08568987250328064,
0.10505885630846024,
0.6085209250450134,
0.27968767285346985,
0.0231598149985075,
-0.16748638451099396,
0.007189563009887934,
-0.6668534278869629,
0.3427278399467468,
0.2298758625984192,
0.4313119053840637,
0.008455129340291023,
0.12992353737354279,
-0.15865479409694672,
-0.40289634466171265,
0.2555736005306244,
-0.04052415117621422,
-0.36549267172813416,
-0.4027165472507477,
0.26345330476760864,
0.5144447088241577,
0.21042366325855255,
-0.8378918170928955,
0.31412041187286377,
-0.029071088880300522,
-0.05090790241956711,
-0.2709381878376007,
0.27144986391067505,
-0.007629308849573135,
0.08115104585886002,
0.17605172097682953,
-0.026242995634675026,
0.3451068103313446,
-0.5528601408004761,
0.3639608323574066,
0.3801443576812744,
-0.7487895488739014,
-0.1568472683429718,
0.6916369199752808,
0.5522918105125427,
-0.39599087834358215,
0.9415708184242249,
-0.187257319688797,
-0.30399298667907715,
0.1680145412683487,
0.302710622549057,
0.754828929901123,
-0.553054928779602,
0.6500090956687927,
0.6133054494857788,
-0.09704913944005966,
0.11304572224617004,
0.1565038561820984,
0.16207443177700043,
-0.9273192286491394,
-0.47879087924957275,
-0.7428522109985352,
-0.24029351770877838,
0.05921347066760063,
-0.6902608871459961,
-0.17501315474510193,
-0.24817119538784027,
-0.42198246717453003,
-0.10434287786483765,
-0.24626843631267548,
-0.1146782860159874,
-0.0795489251613617,
0.0030831184703856707,
0.8383747935295105,
-1.069003939628601,
0.3459676206111908,
0.34001624584198,
-0.8398222923278809,
-0.42011237144470215,
0.007626884616911411,
-0.11382108926773071,
-0.5579180717468262,
0.4997178316116333,
0.03369046002626419,
-0.046175453811883926,
-0.0198582224547863,
-0.48366597294807434,
-0.7834528088569641,
0.8395397663116455,
0.3968935012817383,
-0.27549347281455994,
0.22984687983989716,
0.11136387288570404,
0.8942874073982239,
0.06828907132148743,
0.257475346326828,
0.793628990650177,
0.3349345922470093,
0.23881855607032776,
-0.8021966814994812,
0.26524561643600464,
-0.5595203042030334,
0.18018034100532532,
0.054947782307863235,
-0.44357773661613464,
0.4629349112510681,
-0.23916080594062805,
-0.6693021655082703,
0.43874484300613403,
0.593748152256012,
0.21312403678894043,
0.19583649933338165,
0.8477932810783386,
0.6224035620689392,
0.5836206674575806,
-0.08704405277967453,
1.1112781763076782,
-0.05167089030146599,
0.4175914227962494,
0.8783695697784424,
-0.41702520847320557,
0.9031028151512146,
0.4660617411136627,
-0.3489653468132019,
0.8459302186965942,
0.553892970085144,
0.193743497133255,
0.7864389419555664,
0.5688735246658325,
-0.630012035369873,
-0.1413392275571823,
-0.6721290349960327,
0.03755868598818779,
0.22627006471157074,
0.42036813497543335,
-0.3807530999183655,
-0.3730396628379822,
0.052374403923749924,
0.029211431741714478,
0.5474334955215454,
-0.19564901292324066,
0.8114923238754272,
0.06020476296544075,
-0.9916443824768066,
0.2913273870944977,
0.11173154413700104,
0.40712305903434753,
-0.39344629645347595,
-0.27256685495376587,
-0.29431265592575073,
0.1167903020977974,
-0.27728578448295593,
-0.9724385142326355,
0.5944082736968994,
0.11435875296592712,
-0.3173428475856781,
-0.35148710012435913,
0.655632495880127,
-0.577714741230011,
-0.2116229385137558,
0.4085043668746948,
0.2719540297985077,
0.11006592959165573,
-0.17083296179771423,
-0.6318068504333496,
-0.01500969659537077,
-0.06827362626791,
-0.05888967961072922,
0.3807723820209503,
0.25149330496788025,
-0.2082575261592865,
1.0898466110229492,
0.6580873131752014,
0.18090210855007172,
0.12751246988773346,
0.459302693605423,
0.9068975448608398,
-0.4149964451789856,
-0.27116674184799194,
-0.7683340907096863,
0.5907698273658752,
-0.1137169897556305,
0.16335730254650116,
0.431308388710022,
0.27743053436279297,
0.6849961876869202,
-0.12257731705904007,
0.8218904137611389,
-0.33076950907707214,
0.6245372295379639,
-0.44041040539741516,
0.9263975024223328,
-0.23653553426265717,
0.4265094995498657,
-0.16509118676185608,
-0.5904960036277771,
-0.2962862253189087,
0.48739591240882874,
-0.35509049892425537,
0.3547738194465637,
0.28512558341026306,
0.9247737526893616,
0.2317245751619339,
-0.2736007869243622,
0.2589515149593353,
0.21083621680736542,
0.679275393486023,
0.5860973000526428,
1.0950675010681152,
0.11331885308027267,
0.5864855051040649,
-0.17010794579982758,
-0.3820733428001404,
-0.21384136378765106,
-0.9208794236183167,
-0.36163899302482605,
-0.5241296887397766,
-0.09529158473014832,
-0.3358127176761627,
-0.006232664920389652,
0.5027155876159668,
0.5238259434700012,
-0.7511942982673645,
-0.17199468612670898,
-0.3288284242153168,
0.34923940896987915,
-0.31486696004867554,
-0.39038169384002686,
-0.04199549928307533,
-0.6874390244483948,
-0.6468818187713623,
-0.15261130034923553,
0.09420835971832275,
-0.3468489646911621,
-0.4218203127384186,
-0.1854069083929062,
0.021286817267537117,
0.05136476457118988,
0.5253318548202515,
0.5879248380661011,
-0.7033630013465881,
-0.5463433861732483,
-0.30948755145072937,
-0.19557435810565948,
-0.04325294494628906,
0.8885864019393921,
-0.5540461540222168,
0.6889320611953735,
0.5332909822463989,
0.23043906688690186,
0.08787567168474197,
0.25801244378089905,
0.8484969735145569,
-0.867716908454895,
-0.13162781298160553,
0.30351078510284424,
0.18964464962482452,
0.43303608894348145,
-0.4631868302822113,
0.30527374148368835,
-0.012690049596130848,
-0.4032115340232849,
-0.7772361636161804,
0.4886583983898163,
-0.4814153015613556,
-0.1103324368596077,
1.0637695789337158,
-0.38636794686317444,
0.16949598491191864,
-0.2488335818052292,
-0.4171428084373474,
0.09766177833080292,
-0.30884692072868347,
1.304527759552002,
0.8761636018753052,
0.16781017184257507,
-0.3281632661819458,
-0.5018725991249084,
0.614093542098999,
0.2149389237165451,
-0.7947626709938049,
0.6216631531715393,
0.6269898414611816,
0.4513058662414551,
0.4966466426849365,
1.0077166557312012,
-0.46247538924217224,
0.2484988123178482,
-0.1805957853794098,
0.021127823740243912,
0.23317258059978485,
-0.2994067072868347,
-0.22021181881427765,
0.16505414247512817,
0.44109266996383667,
0.008433761075139046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14460v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14460v1
|
Towards Single-System Illusion in Software-Defined Vehicles -- Automated, AI-Powered Workflow
| 2024-03-21T15:07:57 | 2024-03-21T15:07:57 |
Krzysztof Lebioda, Viktor Vorobev, Nenad Petrovic, Fengjunjie Pan, Vahid Zolfaghari, Alois Knoll
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, D.2.1; D.2.2; D.2.4; I.2.7; I.2.2; I.7.0
|
We propose a novel model- and feature-based approach to development of
vehicle software systems, where the end architecture is not explicitly defined.
Instead, it emerges from an iterative process of search and optimization given
certain constraints, requirements and hardware architecture, while retaining
the property of single-system illusion, where applications run in a logically
uniform environment. One of the key points of the presented approach is the
inclusion of modern generative AI, specifically Large Language Models (LLMs),
in the loop. With the recent advances in the field, we expect that the LLMs
will be able to assist in processing of requirements, generation of formal
system models, as well as generation of software deployment specification and
test code. The resulting pipeline is automated to a large extent, with feedback
being generated at each step.
|
[
-0.5662375092506409,
-0.497068852186203,
0.5795745253562927,
0.014657065272331238,
-0.36135628819465637,
-0.013935592025518417,
0.019158117473125458,
-0.30638012290000916,
0.3362676203250885,
0.8621153235435486,
-0.9152799248695374,
-0.21425025165081024,
-0.1583898663520813,
-0.12454354763031006,
-0.9704323410987854,
0.7565377950668335,
-0.21776168048381805,
-0.17857877910137177,
-0.2473670393228531,
-0.05661616101861,
-0.11148914694786072,
-0.19039322435855865,
-0.3278062343597412,
-0.3503085672855377,
0.09193582087755203,
-0.14614708721637726,
1.122069001197815,
0.9331862330436707,
0.5163548588752747,
0.33034634590148926,
0.08731376379728317,
-0.09786084294319153,
-0.08769961446523666,
0.06063559651374817,
-0.1663125902414322,
-0.13996122777462006,
-0.2832084894180298,
-0.16518476605415344,
0.5718221664428711,
0.5553101897239685,
-0.4662396013736725,
-0.034860994666814804,
-0.02377474680542946,
0.3645586371421814,
-0.7840216755867004,
0.12732556462287903,
-0.41966187953948975,
0.04816693067550659,
-0.09720438718795776,
0.23637518286705017,
0.054778628051280975,
-0.28239840269088745,
0.04974042996764183,
-1.0000821352005005,
0.29183104634284973,
0.035723838955163956,
1.0940247774124146,
0.9370176792144775,
-0.0930335521697998,
-0.2834361493587494,
-1.0868436098098755,
0.46328556537628174,
-0.8656193614006042,
0.557371973991394,
-0.3618316650390625,
0.44304779171943665,
-0.3241431713104248,
-0.8150461912155151,
-0.9607239365577698,
-0.3980328440666199,
0.21259555220603943,
0.14615985751152039,
0.09187351167201996,
0.4243702292442322,
0.013734521344304085,
0.4915388226509094,
-0.5726473927497864,
0.49580633640289307,
-0.6391432881355286,
-0.250550776720047,
0.8332294225692749,
0.33663156628608704,
0.11178460717201233,
0.115274578332901,
-0.7104222774505615,
0.18595314025878906,
-0.7403061985969543,
-0.166006401181221,
0.19390782713890076,
0.31666597723960876,
-0.34596312046051025,
0.5804860591888428,
-0.3719078302383423,
0.8149837255477905,
-0.48296430706977844,
-0.060385704040527344,
0.27658727765083313,
-0.4201669692993164,
-0.694903552532196,
-0.2389708310365677,
0.9459620118141174,
-0.07089320570230484,
-0.0665118545293808,
-0.22799961268901825,
-0.7351663708686829,
0.6762376427650452,
0.7006378173828125,
-0.37871667742729187,
0.14401379227638245,
0.42745980620384216,
-0.35792404413223267,
-0.5817348957061768,
0.27812662720680237,
-0.5659629702568054,
-0.26298758387565613,
-0.4010300636291504,
0.487542986869812,
-0.2838442325592041,
-0.3464353680610657,
0.47398459911346436,
-0.36866194009780884,
0.5986304879188538,
0.335622638463974,
-0.4597516655921936,
0.18045088648796082,
0.7523384690284729,
0.8370586037635803,
-0.126642644405365,
-0.46253031492233276,
-0.35102608799934387,
0.36179664731025696,
-0.47050291299819946,
0.7914931178092957,
-0.6147493720054626,
-0.34119120240211487,
0.24889050424098969,
-0.014383586123585701,
0.5488249659538269,
-0.44525304436683655,
0.39801374077796936,
-0.556279182434082,
-0.031174995005130768,
0.20398925244808197,
-0.42268577218055725,
-0.1473834067583084,
0.08095178753137589,
-0.48902440071105957,
0.8447702527046204,
-0.016840780153870583,
-0.11774178594350815,
0.3241550028324127,
-1.2066302299499512,
-0.5935181975364685,
0.3109740912914276,
-0.4014896750450134,
-0.1463007628917694,
0.38080906867980957,
0.029167478904128075,
0.3220019042491913,
-0.4947265386581421,
0.17448194324970245,
-0.4029470682144165,
-0.24119527637958527,
-0.39050742983818054,
-0.40705233812332153,
0.7235516309738159,
0.3366124629974365,
-0.34799447655677795,
0.233623668551445,
-0.719963550567627,
-0.017999790608882904,
-0.040671899914741516,
-0.18111418187618256,
-0.18436448276042938,
0.01891138218343258,
-0.05859687924385071,
0.1641620397567749,
0.3401988744735718,
-0.5020676255226135,
0.5035317540168762,
-0.6299286484718323,
0.3737281858921051,
0.9388774037361145,
-0.21649520099163055,
0.43100592494010925,
-0.04004306346178055,
0.810914158821106,
0.11703108996152878,
0.4292406737804413,
-0.3175606429576874,
-0.5714948177337646,
-0.8037548065185547,
-0.21694733202457428,
-0.04859606921672821,
0.5103824138641357,
-0.9419125318527222,
0.490275502204895,
0.05392271652817726,
-0.5215254426002502,
-0.6802182197570801,
0.2236206978559494,
0.4423104226589203,
0.08622711151838303,
-0.20496687293052673,
-0.5245630741119385,
-0.1978832334280014,
-1.0772722959518433,
0.18624639511108398,
-0.3164069950580597,
-0.17526109516620636,
-0.12565471231937408,
0.6386243104934692,
-0.437283456325531,
0.7417046427726746,
-0.5137900710105896,
-0.20842866599559784,
0.060092177242040634,
-0.03590132296085358,
-0.14824558794498444,
0.527556300163269,
0.33646711707115173,
-0.8976675271987915,
0.09304201602935791,
0.08041001111268997,
-1.1067757606506348,
-0.027527131140232086,
-0.06896165013313293,
0.12696857750415802,
0.31381502747535706,
0.49437710642814636,
-0.7974675893783569,
0.8195231556892395,
0.43806207180023193,
-0.32346200942993164,
0.4325503706932068,
-0.5797125101089478,
-0.3128386437892914,
-0.7382006049156189,
-0.20113801956176758,
0.14360129833221436,
0.02856198325753212,
-0.570156991481781,
0.3224223554134369,
-0.11204807460308075,
-0.14934474229812622,
-0.43091779947280884,
0.4036114513874054,
-0.4736229181289673,
-0.4681229591369629,
-0.41136249899864197,
0.19418315589427948,
-0.0476531945168972,
0.157907173037529,
0.03161943703889847,
0.9296597242355347,
1.1971267461776733,
-1.175169825553894,
0.7359495759010315,
0.11970486491918564,
-0.5080317258834839,
0.642841637134552,
-0.6525458693504333,
0.06417101621627808,
-0.7435718774795532,
-0.09111103415489197,
-0.7632451057434082,
-0.3394552171230316,
0.015043146908283234,
-0.18736805021762848,
0.009538950398564339,
0.10172586143016815,
-0.597037136554718,
-0.5097928047180176,
0.19426628947257996,
0.02346190996468067,
0.7136172652244568,
-0.4817449152469635,
0.6155555844306946,
0.534669041633606,
0.26160335540771484,
-0.22137713432312012,
-0.523927628993988,
0.2124539315700531,
-0.1282339245080948,
-0.7061421871185303,
0.4701448380947113,
0.08014564961194992,
-0.493038147687912,
0.04859086498618126,
0.1812620908021927,
-0.07402490079402924,
0.2838711440563202,
0.47780364751815796,
0.3880123198032379,
-0.29834863543510437,
0.3549734652042389,
0.1588968187570572,
-0.030249884352087975,
-0.04388994723558426,
-0.7627982497215271,
0.4213293790817261,
-0.18806110322475433,
-0.4175456166267395,
-0.6932889819145203,
0.3198748230934143,
1.1411352157592773,
-0.6261841058731079,
0.7523126006126404,
0.5246898531913757,
-0.4262908399105072,
-0.4331972002983093,
-0.20350228250026703,
-0.05658058449625969,
-0.5876767635345459,
0.35716021060943604,
-0.582684338092804,
-0.4298395812511444,
0.6438255310058594,
-0.11017081141471863,
0.359457790851593,
0.5520749688148499,
0.7246427536010742,
-0.1806996464729309,
1.0417425632476807,
1.3304939270019531,
0.0478806234896183,
0.4646339416503906,
-0.39123913645744324,
-0.02121354267001152,
-0.4723444879055023,
-0.35879456996917725,
-0.44456571340560913,
0.0177374929189682,
-0.4956471920013428,
-0.2723897099494934,
0.7305623888969421,
0.007111318875104189,
-0.53548264503479,
0.19264189898967743,
-0.7693174481391907,
0.24794527888298035,
0.61617112159729,
-0.08931371569633484,
0.31649553775787354,
-0.2556338608264923,
-0.33648890256881714,
0.275628924369812,
-0.906178891658783,
-0.6024445295333862,
0.8434720039367676,
0.17592105269432068,
0.9611120820045471,
0.01725294627249241,
0.5777236819267273,
0.46494629979133606,
0.4739508628845215,
-0.5465741157531738,
0.4667331278324127,
0.06018504500389099,
-0.5849539637565613,
-0.6570085883140564,
-0.11196167767047882,
-0.569753110408783,
-0.024866541847586632,
0.11865413933992386,
-0.5351099967956543,
-0.15550170838832855,
-0.10443349182605743,
-0.5471248030662537,
0.33201420307159424,
-0.5092621445655823,
0.92819744348526,
-0.49867117404937744,
-0.08196514844894409,
-0.0969991609454155,
-0.4910186529159546,
0.4062598943710327,
-0.07107008248567581,
0.3029775619506836,
0.03215749189257622,
-0.34803682565689087,
0.46985554695129395,
-0.972631573677063,
0.5237836837768555,
-0.32485997676849365,
-0.642221987247467,
0.24485376477241516,
-0.13757115602493286,
0.7122666835784912,
-0.1884828507900238,
-0.12444975972175598,
-0.15547630190849304,
-0.19928009808063507,
-0.3832262456417084,
-0.8643754124641418,
0.6976790428161621,
-0.6310069561004639,
-0.6571701169013977,
-0.12862396240234375,
-0.5220230221748352,
0.1557556390762329,
0.3312035799026489,
0.13855355978012085,
0.3249732553958893,
-0.20919448137283325,
-0.44892048835754395,
0.6512248516082764,
-0.3127518892288208,
0.5773637294769287,
0.5300788283348083,
-0.61427903175354,
-0.000795750180259347,
0.6425865292549133,
0.09106012433767319,
0.6198716759681702,
0.027614150196313858,
-0.12464819103479385,
-0.23647309839725494,
-0.641026496887207,
-0.9965787529945374,
0.15362274646759033,
-0.6703513264656067,
0.039450157433748245,
-0.27472683787345886,
-0.27440008521080017,
-0.5106082558631897,
-0.21609878540039062,
-0.9062208533287048,
-0.28082653880119324,
-0.2586691379547119,
0.21968214213848114,
0.2875235974788666,
1.3397605419158936,
0.10877960175275803,
0.4685250222682953,
-0.30630093812942505,
0.5150765180587769,
0.15844134986400604,
0.8640586733818054,
-0.23429076373577118,
-0.5222359299659729,
-0.3196229338645935,
0.1041526347398758,
-0.45020270347595215,
-0.679061770439148,
0.49486616253852844,
0.0017229258082807064,
0.6908581256866455,
0.6560927033424377,
0.04458245635032654,
0.592640221118927,
-0.2942321002483368,
0.9643983840942383,
0.13511592149734497,
-0.8099371790885925,
0.5481388568878174,
-0.12203839421272278,
0.1844407320022583,
0.07802461087703705,
0.0800805315375328,
-0.32449817657470703,
-0.6510208249092102,
-0.44128966331481934,
-0.44941699504852295,
0.4492672383785248,
0.2892010509967804,
0.22507445514202118,
0.41127702593803406,
0.5948582887649536,
0.042632292956113815,
0.4110739231109619,
-0.4168676733970642,
-0.5551031827926636,
-0.4213584363460541,
-0.1496991664171219,
-0.06767868250608444,
0.5000455379486084,
0.023581378161907196,
-0.21359191834926605,
0.7960492372512817,
-0.21178419888019562,
0.3860328495502472,
0.20832929015159607,
0.2079927772283554,
-0.01746813766658306,
0.09546100348234177,
0.9755352735519409,
0.5611342787742615,
0.16839668154716492,
-0.01571112498641014,
-0.1667701154947281,
-0.17046114802360535,
0.34140846133232117,
-0.03982894867658615,
-0.5551364421844482,
0.2673521935939789,
-0.23829881846904755,
1.0692620277404785,
-0.2709047794342041,
-0.6585405468940735,
0.3266483545303345,
0.2784031331539154,
-0.06782697141170502,
-0.7385728359222412,
0.37013283371925354,
-0.16109278798103333,
0.5287529826164246,
0.363616019487381,
0.16855919361114502,
-0.10226543247699738,
-0.5286043882369995,
0.09915578365325928,
0.8216069936752319,
-0.6534841656684875,
-0.29094570875167847,
1.0547072887420654,
0.05440306290984154,
-0.7021462917327881,
0.2977379262447357,
-0.48425188660621643,
-0.4740014672279358,
0.8352285623550415,
0.35122910141944885,
1.1908634901046753,
-0.11041907221078873,
0.18660597503185272,
0.04935687035322189,
0.6160797476768494,
-0.44938188791275024,
0.3665265142917633,
0.1444273144006729,
-0.8135311603546143,
-0.3409174382686615,
-0.7539615035057068,
-0.2891857624053955,
0.16690659523010254,
-0.395191490650177,
0.6010448932647705,
-0.4987187683582306,
0.141677588224411,
0.25013411045074463,
-0.6788361668586731,
-0.7097795009613037,
0.20687854290008545,
0.3014598488807678,
1.0214537382125854,
-0.6301293969154358,
1.05819571018219,
0.930122971534729,
-0.5755631327629089,
-0.5258155465126038,
-0.15097454190254211,
0.10562187433242798,
-0.6698267459869385,
0.426877498626709,
-0.05071403831243515,
-0.23335008323192596,
0.0002666623331606388,
-0.725281834602356,
-1.0166064500808716,
1.0534770488739014,
0.33272722363471985,
-0.45723897218704224,
-0.46426817774772644,
0.1964920163154602,
0.42233195900917053,
-0.7441545128822327,
-0.09507227689027786,
0.5323163866996765,
0.46140581369400024,
0.08823296427726746,
-1.2397518157958984,
-0.21093621850013733,
-0.1329704076051712,
0.3596911132335663,
0.2824607193470001,
-0.7657491564750671,
0.6888654828071594,
-0.25870609283447266,
-0.10903774201869965,
0.13440252840518951,
0.7498463988304138,
0.10584856569766998,
0.12558281421661377,
0.4381043016910553,
0.7127503752708435,
0.7284123301506042,
0.08984289318323135,
1.2185630798339844,
-0.449422687292099,
0.37631669640541077,
0.5186635255813599,
-0.31278669834136963,
0.48297616839408875,
0.5896799564361572,
-0.1849994659423828,
0.5351226329803467,
0.20229807496070862,
-0.08562393486499786,
0.6030519008636475,
0.24825844168663025,
-0.28297004103660583,
-0.3074302077293396,
0.018189528957009315,
-0.16566579043865204,
0.6577635407447815,
0.3828028440475464,
-0.41238948702812195,
-0.2678888440132141,
0.4195888638496399,
-0.3658134937286377,
-0.1572226732969284,
-0.5622018575668335,
0.7619560360908508,
-0.02969728223979473,
-0.7633000612258911,
0.8855776786804199,
0.21056175231933594,
0.8242278099060059,
-0.47601598501205444,
0.15229584276676178,
-0.2729266285896301,
0.20201198756694794,
-0.06450089067220688,
-0.5643650889396667,
0.3517052233219147,
0.04160564765334129,
-0.21224920451641083,
-0.21188266575336456,
0.42297670245170593,
-0.08219453692436218,
-0.7354548573493958,
-0.10556891560554504,
0.3493424952030182,
0.30610695481300354,
-0.02202870324254036,
-0.5894038677215576,
0.28098201751708984,
-0.10304463654756546,
-0.05998258292675018,
-0.0603129118680954,
0.3634701073169708,
-0.011259115301072598,
1.1271247863769531,
0.155874565243721,
0.21813589334487915,
0.3538123369216919,
-0.10666770488023758,
0.8460301756858826,
-0.8108896017074585,
-0.7188414931297302,
-0.8715053200721741,
0.6124714612960815,
0.3198001980781555,
-0.12195469439029694,
0.5046999454498291,
0.5484498143196106,
0.8728547096252441,
0.03659570962190628,
1.3469833135604858,
-0.05565020442008972,
0.13763287663459778,
-0.5378342270851135,
0.6465024352073669,
-0.85441654920578,
0.611542820930481,
-0.38206151127815247,
-0.5759329199790955,
-0.1902153342962265,
0.40241074562072754,
0.13638953864574432,
-0.13462169468402863,
0.17127233743667603,
1.2427270412445068,
-0.3028053641319275,
0.12427134066820145,
0.3975989818572998,
0.10759475082159042,
0.4336725175380707,
0.48712652921676636,
0.9031447768211365,
-0.7172401547431946,
0.42244401574134827,
-0.14606866240501404,
-0.1592252254486084,
0.13409942388534546,
-0.6213613748550415,
-0.2934076189994812,
-0.6643270254135132,
-0.49740922451019287,
-0.4414176940917969,
-0.10304705798625946,
0.699777364730835,
0.6502684950828552,
-0.44418832659721375,
-0.26809313893318176,
-0.6679748296737671,
0.35198089480400085,
-0.2837774455547333,
-0.1554471105337143,
-0.1335543394088745,
-0.4939081072807312,
-0.6905110478401184,
0.36649489402770996,
0.723045825958252,
0.34314173460006714,
-1.333601474761963,
-0.48662230372428894,
0.33255553245544434,
0.21358102560043335,
0.2720336318016052,
0.2570660412311554,
-1.041605830192566,
-0.24440844357013702,
-0.21790659427642822,
-0.05667451024055481,
0.15553785860538483,
0.8179738521575928,
-1.1470876932144165,
0.5532304644584656,
0.04419105499982834,
0.24630622565746307,
0.4699566960334778,
-0.25198882818222046,
0.890457808971405,
-0.43446099758148193,
0.5374081134796143,
0.023271476849913597,
0.08777962625026703,
0.10180504620075226,
-0.09575416147708893,
0.20523923635482788,
0.38641756772994995,
-0.2896474301815033,
-1.046309471130371,
0.5840080380439758,
-0.5810550451278687,
-0.24005641043186188,
0.9528288841247559,
0.0320747084915638,
-0.3085816502571106,
-0.36764442920684814,
0.24183525145053864,
0.22821275889873505,
-0.18231454491615295,
0.8197887539863586,
0.2657831609249115,
0.03154006227850914,
-0.2555810213088989,
-0.6974706053733826,
0.6325817704200745,
0.03127092495560646,
-0.8627291917800903,
0.12688949704170227,
0.45245563983917236,
0.06436504423618317,
0.4559583067893982,
0.3615686595439911,
0.041648928076028824,
0.31003710627555847,
0.11602148413658142,
0.29080724716186523,
-0.06030962988734245,
-0.5698754191398621,
-0.5467032790184021,
0.3492790460586548,
-0.10626166313886642,
-0.23898373544216156
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14459v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14459v1
|
Multi-Level Explanations for Generative Language Models
| 2024-03-21T15:06:14 | 2024-03-21T15:06:14 |
Lucas Monteiro Paes, Dennis Wei, Hyo Jin Do, Hendrik Strobelt, Ronny Luss, Amit Dhurandhar, Manish Nagireddy, Karthikeyan Natesan Ramamurthy, Prasanna Sattigeri, Werner Geyer, Soumya Ghosh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Perturbation-based explanation methods such as LIME and SHAP are commonly
applied to text classification. This work focuses on their extension to
generative language models. To address the challenges of text as output and
long text inputs, we propose a general framework called MExGen that can be
instantiated with different attribution algorithms. To handle text output, we
introduce the notion of scalarizers for mapping text to real numbers and
investigate multiple possibilities. To handle long inputs, we take a
multi-level approach, proceeding from coarser levels of granularity to finer
ones, and focus on algorithms with linear scaling in model queries. We conduct
a systematic evaluation, both automated and human, of perturbation-based
attribution methods for summarization and context-grounded question answering.
The results show that our framework can provide more locally faithful
explanations of generated outputs.
|
[
-0.2292010337114334,
-0.990210771560669,
0.7473081946372986,
0.49396640062332153,
-0.049671318382024765,
0.027733372524380684,
-0.0639093667268753,
-0.17693950235843658,
-0.11344102025032043,
0.40755096077919006,
-0.6063990592956543,
-0.4251846969127655,
-0.401085764169693,
-0.08084842562675476,
-0.5961318612098694,
1.0655505657196045,
-0.2555098235607147,
-0.13895125687122345,
-0.41149118542671204,
0.12461766600608826,
-0.22242438793182373,
-0.8547521829605103,
-0.8054912686347961,
-0.5160620808601379,
0.7680695056915283,
0.6001958847045898,
0.653576135635376,
0.6072182059288025,
0.12305963784456253,
0.31433966755867004,
-0.13734625279903412,
-0.14888545870780945,
-0.4801979959011078,
0.36906927824020386,
-0.1272428333759308,
-0.47394973039627075,
-0.3479520082473755,
-0.029635896906256676,
0.766258716583252,
0.7118355631828308,
-0.07942070066928864,
0.06578893214464188,
0.09677040576934814,
0.2517155706882477,
-0.7770987153053284,
-0.17396670579910278,
-0.3348185420036316,
0.16739948093891144,
-0.13569912314414978,
-0.5179159641265869,
-0.5991595983505249,
-0.19247032701969147,
-0.07577528059482574,
-0.44530197978019714,
0.44683927297592163,
-0.20587164163589478,
0.7116225957870483,
0.2651141881942749,
-0.535139262676239,
-0.32418203353881836,
-1.0392104387283325,
1.1310017108917236,
-0.8194223642349243,
0.037777017802000046,
0.2456732541322708,
0.3627030849456787,
-0.038115616887807846,
-0.6465295553207397,
-0.6868230104446411,
0.13578744232654572,
-0.19401173293590546,
0.17713558673858643,
-0.05345655605196953,
0.24867182970046997,
0.30341029167175293,
0.8096529245376587,
-0.3789900243282318,
0.13057847321033478,
-0.025074651464819908,
-0.350986510515213,
0.4998129606246948,
0.3612639605998993,
0.3239010274410248,
-0.32068535685539246,
-0.41654181480407715,
-0.3367980718612671,
-0.811077356338501,
0.1849171668291092,
0.3749394118785858,
0.11272450536489487,
-0.2502334415912628,
0.40771234035491943,
-0.0776439756155014,
0.780466616153717,
0.1651063859462738,
-0.0553637370467186,
-0.040622953325510025,
-0.6827444434165955,
-0.11413513123989105,
-0.03239651769399643,
0.8729180693626404,
-0.03188827261328697,
0.12743030488491058,
-0.05593639612197876,
-0.09186503291130066,
-0.29590070247650146,
0.08332718908786774,
-0.937789261341095,
-0.11254175007343292,
0.3986872732639313,
-0.6417151093482971,
-0.6713111996650696,
-0.20702748000621796,
-1.106131672859192,
-0.48677054047584534,
-0.1121925413608551,
0.4582885503768921,
-0.15799880027770996,
-0.41579562425613403,
0.07667365670204163,
-0.2005758285522461,
0.3084155023097992,
0.44332247972488403,
-1.2642033100128174,
0.3335162103176117,
0.269929975271225,
0.6407052278518677,
0.1284402459859848,
-0.24701566994190216,
-0.49526262283325195,
0.2387946993112564,
-0.26196786761283875,
0.7781234979629517,
-0.7226402759552002,
-0.19742527604103088,
0.03477821126580238,
-0.511874794960022,
0.07494750618934631,
-0.3620062470436096,
0.44064176082611084,
-0.3412681818008423,
0.5801292657852173,
-0.25083306431770325,
-0.47415509819984436,
-0.2307688146829605,
0.007157830521464348,
-0.40988874435424805,
0.9006003737449646,
0.23550941050052643,
-0.8034982085227966,
0.2877870202064514,
-0.7603173851966858,
-0.5193538069725037,
-0.061777882277965546,
-0.3202578127384186,
-0.33766239881515503,
0.3116649091243744,
0.3197474777698517,
0.7138122916221619,
-0.5782329440116882,
0.2110813558101654,
-0.09462926536798477,
-0.15460893511772156,
0.24361634254455566,
-0.7644310593605042,
1.0064576864242554,
0.27302229404449463,
-0.26366138458251953,
0.5479593276977539,
-0.9195796251296997,
0.10506206750869751,
-0.12121277302503586,
-0.5504210591316223,
-0.36236125230789185,
0.34655293822288513,
0.07414785027503967,
0.16595426201820374,
0.02590014412999153,
-0.4954715967178345,
0.02626611851155758,
-0.17009757459163666,
0.59066241979599,
0.5343248248100281,
0.11944018304347992,
0.5961437821388245,
0.061780788004398346,
0.8524938821792603,
0.029868628829717636,
-0.08150580525398254,
-0.7001703977584839,
-0.2547200322151184,
-0.5604639053344727,
-0.3446405231952667,
0.2247042953968048,
0.43178483843803406,
-0.7907512784004211,
0.21479004621505737,
-0.2447390854358673,
-0.3987753987312317,
-0.2270081490278244,
-0.07370904088020325,
0.6001616716384888,
0.5546152591705322,
0.40799960494041443,
0.18812471628189087,
-0.32215645909309387,
-0.7768734097480774,
-0.27235397696495056,
-0.18645787239074707,
-0.3436921238899231,
0.28370651602745056,
0.26575613021850586,
-0.17547607421875,
0.834406316280365,
-0.5314239263534546,
0.06235642731189728,
-0.24390490353107452,
0.7831030488014221,
0.09264474362134933,
0.5250730514526367,
0.6049082279205322,
-0.7780864238739014,
-0.3371354639530182,
-0.021297642961144447,
-0.6896250247955322,
-0.27313899993896484,
-0.3388367295265198,
0.19145113229751587,
-0.268611878156662,
0.788915753364563,
-0.13165804743766785,
0.3090776205062866,
0.6576922535896301,
-0.5830950736999512,
0.7416616678237915,
-0.18406300246715546,
0.37396910786628723,
-1.2163199186325073,
-0.32866373658180237,
-0.15775460004806519,
-0.4613993763923645,
-0.8694677352905273,
0.3208954632282257,
0.04081954061985016,
-0.18339700996875763,
-0.2517661154270172,
0.4192356467247009,
-0.351157546043396,
0.04065646976232529,
-0.19754694402217865,
-0.11296714842319489,
0.04254892095923424,
0.30398502945899963,
-0.1899150311946869,
0.7971184253692627,
0.5532737374305725,
-0.8113558888435364,
0.5744984745979309,
0.009457897394895554,
0.02523822709918022,
0.2931849956512451,
-0.8370530009269714,
-0.017055658623576164,
-0.3505746126174927,
0.3911058008670807,
-1.3830238580703735,
-0.38536718487739563,
-0.02700570784509182,
-0.7145732045173645,
0.29374203085899353,
-0.24526478350162506,
-0.6168323159217834,
-0.1329430788755417,
-0.4106384813785553,
0.9002549052238464,
0.29355162382125854,
-0.6907050013542175,
0.8873304724693298,
0.029375938698649406,
-0.2831258773803711,
-0.4857068955898285,
-0.5508665442466736,
0.05841289833188057,
-0.5976292490959167,
-0.7582159042358398,
0.49890685081481934,
-0.001869821222499013,
-0.37527185678482056,
-0.2674570381641388,
0.025967465713620186,
-0.2744775414466858,
0.21968527138233185,
0.13504302501678467,
-0.16838262975215912,
-0.3977521061897278,
0.18276692926883698,
0.3409019112586975,
-0.18363718688488007,
0.14912836253643036,
-0.08363614976406097,
0.7005615234375,
-0.04306631535291672,
-0.0650957003235817,
-0.26469436287879944,
0.5939512252807617,
0.4782196581363678,
-0.2728413939476013,
0.6336421370506287,
0.6376007795333862,
-0.3905130624771118,
-0.22740128636360168,
-0.2869214713573456,
-0.20474562048912048,
-0.4417984187602997,
0.3150780200958252,
-0.6428200602531433,
-0.9571573734283447,
0.8264101147651672,
0.015918660908937454,
0.0915398895740509,
0.8141600489616394,
0.9084259271621704,
-0.18091823160648346,
1.1429603099822998,
0.6954612731933594,
0.10431348532438278,
0.5017837882041931,
0.01594320312142372,
0.1966734528541565,
-0.46690046787261963,
0.03603282943367958,
-0.789590060710907,
-0.06281180679798126,
-0.38976219296455383,
-0.5365136861801147,
0.23125074803829193,
0.23063305020332336,
-0.06802172213792801,
0.11872480064630508,
-0.2647955119609833,
0.5299056172370911,
0.43429359793663025,
-0.31746014952659607,
0.2508319020271301,
0.12556485831737518,
0.06975997984409332,
-0.12018968909978867,
-0.6888872385025024,
-0.4322531819343567,
0.8226078748703003,
0.45988041162490845,
1.0083513259887695,
0.2628687918186188,
0.7195783853530884,
0.2485051453113556,
0.25249484181404114,
-0.6347240805625916,
0.18266810476779938,
-0.38931676745414734,
-0.7700508832931519,
-0.6011006236076355,
-0.595245897769928,
-0.7807794809341431,
0.4925057291984558,
-0.22716954350471497,
-0.7820908427238464,
0.25907132029533386,
0.5572298169136047,
-0.4052742123603821,
0.1437666267156601,
-0.698738694190979,
0.8114420175552368,
-0.15955525636672974,
-0.4302930533885956,
-0.4416459798812866,
-0.48899927735328674,
0.5039489269256592,
0.004130487330257893,
0.3842836618423462,
0.141494482755661,
0.18347710371017456,
0.6726329326629639,
-0.509310781955719,
0.7057622671127319,
-0.23355810344219208,
-0.6007300615310669,
0.33742988109588623,
-0.001461637788452208,
0.24488835036754608,
0.0807207003235817,
-0.014401491731405258,
-0.024498527869582176,
0.018861418589949608,
-0.4315755367279053,
-0.6917608380317688,
0.7127706408500671,
-0.6404581069946289,
-0.43450894951820374,
-0.17522650957107544,
-0.6013132929801941,
-0.13159333169460297,
0.10469407588243484,
0.6455217003822327,
0.7155936360359192,
0.2663838267326355,
0.36936748027801514,
0.9400408267974854,
-0.5741246342658997,
0.304067462682724,
0.21414867043495178,
-0.4209861755371094,
-0.23605385422706604,
1.1052041053771973,
-0.15274688601493835,
0.35502126812934875,
0.7766820788383484,
0.4305996596813202,
-0.23386874794960022,
-0.47525686025619507,
-0.4636383354663849,
-0.08471815288066864,
-0.8050841689109802,
-0.05207100883126259,
-0.5029112696647644,
-0.058259349316358566,
-0.3364078998565674,
-0.3044053316116333,
-0.14972688257694244,
-0.6169548630714417,
-0.31084930896759033,
-0.09760784357786179,
0.06561440974473953,
0.6449821591377258,
0.22614292800426483,
0.6341796517372131,
-0.5961167216300964,
0.44113022089004517,
0.37181180715560913,
0.3470592498779297,
0.15836457908153534,
-0.6168801188468933,
-0.1162782609462738,
0.07103846967220306,
-0.3475927710533142,
-1.1402101516723633,
0.06243138760328293,
0.16664719581604004,
0.3603914678096771,
0.6733291149139404,
-0.16812624037265778,
0.857416033744812,
-0.4274856448173523,
0.866229772567749,
0.30534571409225464,
-1.177743673324585,
0.4557313621044159,
-0.6202285289764404,
0.27604618668556213,
0.20373660326004028,
0.26805195212364197,
-0.5163589119911194,
-0.47163125872612,
-0.5022864937782288,
-1.0159789323806763,
0.5095771551132202,
0.1262674629688263,
0.35606279969215393,
0.2020988017320633,
0.7612555623054504,
0.1500319242477417,
0.007941463962197304,
-0.9733338952064514,
-0.3802516758441925,
-0.4285230338573456,
-0.2780803442001343,
-0.2651367783546448,
-0.703305184841156,
0.1713983416557312,
-0.11475088447332382,
0.49645569920539856,
-0.11626291275024414,
0.28708136081695557,
0.14039161801338196,
-0.3065906763076782,
-0.25342074036598206,
0.4740845561027527,
0.7214920520782471,
0.7986862659454346,
0.0892663225531578,
0.5022153854370117,
-0.11105695366859436,
-0.051425304263830185,
0.3345874547958374,
-0.02901601605117321,
-0.218125581741333,
-0.09083233773708344,
0.6952002644538879,
0.5457974076271057,
0.15749986469745636,
-0.47408291697502136,
0.42998048663139343,
-0.15881848335266113,
-0.4995213747024536,
-0.13553255796432495,
0.05918306112289429,
0.06776989251375198,
-0.004451698623597622,
0.4890168309211731,
-0.3963320255279541,
0.41188374161720276,
-0.4361155927181244,
0.026233702898025513,
0.4269871115684509,
-0.4561142325401306,
-0.46289923787117004,
1.0406203269958496,
0.08272922039031982,
0.08185721933841705,
0.4428914785385132,
0.08348442614078522,
-0.5370019674301147,
0.5235525965690613,
0.6166055798530579,
0.78452068567276,
-0.3557201027870178,
0.36279383301734924,
0.42660799622535706,
0.02252095751464367,
0.25267481803894043,
0.2676021456718445,
-0.24209946393966675,
-0.7887952327728271,
-0.9473615884780884,
-0.7225893139839172,
-0.24268199503421783,
0.3776205778121948,
-0.5785488486289978,
-0.022061221301555634,
-0.594062089920044,
0.1521574854850769,
0.6885970234870911,
-0.38910406827926636,
-0.11946279555559158,
0.31337761878967285,
0.13298900425434113,
0.5602625012397766,
-1.1504566669464111,
0.4721201956272125,
0.8482800126075745,
-0.673014223575592,
-0.5994868874549866,
0.185869038105011,
-0.04814867302775383,
-0.5281763076782227,
0.5158748626708984,
-0.15841300785541534,
-0.2451256513595581,
0.10377505421638489,
-0.9115617871284485,
-0.9162574410438538,
0.6755455732345581,
0.24872057139873505,
-0.1171628087759018,
0.015588946640491486,
-0.011902736499905586,
0.7116362452507019,
-0.2195415496826172,
0.047841690480709076,
0.2548280656337738,
0.3969103991985321,
0.08908681571483612,
-0.4881941080093384,
0.08121432363986969,
-0.041025228798389435,
0.12369919568300247,
0.31510215997695923,
-0.2915095090866089,
1.1424657106399536,
-0.1096520721912384,
-0.17901046574115753,
-0.018060896545648575,
0.8047780990600586,
-0.047182466834783554,
-0.030104253441095352,
0.45222795009613037,
0.24594111740589142,
0.5132505893707275,
-0.15390801429748535,
1.3226739168167114,
0.12977351248264313,
0.42432940006256104,
1.0263299942016602,
0.29270946979522705,
0.581114649772644,
0.5984732508659363,
-0.4977153539657593,
0.7862883806228638,
0.7588409185409546,
0.1828940361738205,
0.2449796497821808,
0.6079844832420349,
-0.36983194947242737,
-0.15291011333465576,
0.11712273210287094,
0.0015276467893272638,
0.25068044662475586,
0.4573897123336792,
-0.4412175416946411,
-0.45922988653182983,
-0.005701823625713587,
0.1816602498292923,
0.1672753095626831,
-0.44760793447494507,
0.8685523271560669,
-0.22669021785259247,
-0.6386523842811584,
0.7473848462104797,
0.4333603084087372,
0.509718656539917,
-0.39194241166114807,
-0.16948887705802917,
-0.1133180558681488,
0.42226654291152954,
-0.5012047290802002,
-0.567170262336731,
0.32446354627609253,
-0.049724411219358444,
-0.7114288806915283,
-0.556278645992279,
0.7114934921264648,
-0.6036883592605591,
-0.4599156081676483,
-0.009372130036354065,
0.20499245822429657,
0.2190919667482376,
-0.1885906308889389,
-0.3776939809322357,
-0.37689778208732605,
0.21297799050807953,
-0.10654398798942566,
0.2216649353504181,
0.5059884786605835,
-0.45157548785209656,
0.4928494691848755,
0.4396296441555023,
-0.1439695507287979,
0.3761570155620575,
0.20955488085746765,
0.6700200438499451,
-0.5915862917900085,
-0.29156693816185,
-0.9865147471427917,
0.5663162469863892,
0.13283605873584747,
-0.26427844166755676,
0.7321889400482178,
0.4269300699234009,
0.45037975907325745,
-0.09305406361818314,
0.965269148349762,
-0.16461433470249176,
0.434770792722702,
-0.49894949793815613,
0.3710061311721802,
-0.6378604173660278,
0.12403503060340881,
-0.3827606737613678,
-0.9733123183250427,
-0.4239178001880646,
0.6780025959014893,
-0.04136677086353302,
0.022505316883325577,
0.6470281481742859,
0.22723965346813202,
-0.04044694826006889,
-0.1884964257478714,
0.27058371901512146,
0.4738064706325531,
0.7295497059822083,
0.2663941979408264,
0.8031427264213562,
-0.21753540635108948,
0.5504657030105591,
-0.17612344026565552,
-0.5873234272003174,
-0.10854453593492508,
-0.9405835866928101,
-0.632914125919342,
-0.6620048880577087,
-0.26027584075927734,
-0.21574614942073822,
-0.24853789806365967,
0.35351821780204773,
0.5512701869010925,
-0.9583035707473755,
-0.2885524332523346,
-0.2227238118648529,
0.26019635796546936,
-0.23496727645397186,
-0.30031582713127136,
0.2399338036775589,
-0.6212118864059448,
-0.668659508228302,
0.23631571233272552,
0.27392613887786865,
0.03954780474305153,
-0.49566537141799927,
0.10615535825490952,
-0.059204526245594025,
0.09905361384153366,
0.845880925655365,
0.11749491840600967,
-0.675010085105896,
-0.20235875248908997,
-0.25185608863830566,
0.16777272522449493,
0.029788905754685402,
1.1250355243682861,
-0.5365898609161377,
0.4530852437019348,
0.6810110211372375,
0.5232373476028442,
0.6159044504165649,
0.3852764964103699,
1.0069862604141235,
-1.019783616065979,
-0.03181276097893715,
0.06444644182920456,
0.20827102661132812,
0.28493160009384155,
-0.36821308732032776,
0.2420145869255066,
-0.17487353086471558,
-0.3745552897453308,
-0.6348473429679871,
0.4583990275859833,
-0.40293771028518677,
-0.3561948537826538,
1.249149203300476,
-0.23890361189842224,
0.06641532480716705,
-0.16761870682239532,
-0.04657583683729172,
0.1412794142961502,
-0.17504793405532837,
0.5663602948188782,
1.0597953796386719,
-0.20716634392738342,
-0.2868739068508148,
-0.31079739332199097,
0.6522478461265564,
0.47683054208755493,
-0.9881469011306763,
0.5173795819282532,
0.8007558584213257,
0.07509231567382812,
0.4686940312385559,
0.6526874303817749,
-0.38254398107528687,
0.28150734305381775,
-0.006915811449289322,
0.1449056714773178,
0.40126073360443115,
-0.3760879635810852,
-0.5070641040802002,
0.21440938115119934,
0.13773591816425323,
0.11109136044979095
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14457v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14457v1
|
gTBLS: Generating Tables from Text by Conditional Question Answering
| 2024-03-21T15:04:32 | 2024-03-21T15:04:32 |
Anirudh Sundar, Christopher Richardson, Larry Heck
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Distilling large, unstructured text into a structured, condensed form such as
tables is an open research problem. One of the primary challenges in
automatically generating tables is ensuring their syntactic validity. Prior
approaches address this challenge by including additional parameters in the
Transformer's attention mechanism to attend to specific rows and column
headers. In contrast to this single-stage method, this paper presents a
two-stage approach called Generative Tables (gTBLS). The first stage infers
table structure (row and column headers) from the text. The second stage
formulates questions using these headers and fine-tunes a causal language model
to answer them. Furthermore, the gTBLS approach is amenable to the utilization
of pre-trained Large Language Models in a zero-shot configuration, presenting a
solution for table generation in situations where fine-tuning is not feasible.
gTBLS improves prior approaches by up to 10% in BERTScore on the table
construction task and up to 20% on the table content generation task of the
E2E, WikiTableText, WikiBio, and RotoWire datasets.
|
[
-0.3080156147480011,
-1.0260363817214966,
0.7201530933380127,
0.07463447004556656,
-0.2391824573278427,
-0.17292767763137817,
-0.004582346882671118,
-0.10617651790380478,
0.04481839761137962,
0.48112455010414124,
-0.6424960494041443,
-0.3529128432273865,
-0.2137354165315628,
0.2610263228416443,
-0.8636938333511353,
1.682232141494751,
-0.03582395613193512,
-0.30190446972846985,
-0.3552040755748749,
0.31952863931655884,
-0.5263730883598328,
-0.044700924307107925,
-0.5946958661079407,
-0.32489171624183655,
0.7625048756599426,
0.4869353175163269,
0.7940679788589478,
0.4929599165916443,
0.4676094949245453,
0.33056339621543884,
0.09259399026632309,
-0.06382902711629868,
-0.4846603274345398,
0.4364601969718933,
-0.1740155965089798,
-0.47656992077827454,
-0.24169626832008362,
-0.2881120443344116,
0.45799416303634644,
0.6438849568367004,
-0.19759298861026764,
0.3140718340873718,
0.24851709604263306,
0.7340176701545715,
-0.29144489765167236,
0.32676175236701965,
-0.9189311861991882,
0.3205743134021759,
-0.34124624729156494,
-0.450431764125824,
-0.7576443552970886,
-0.5971478819847107,
0.12123753130435944,
-0.46434158086776733,
0.6863523721694946,
0.04802811145782471,
0.8267610669136047,
0.14934401214122772,
-0.4129829704761505,
-0.2536190152168274,
-0.9474773406982422,
0.21402451395988464,
-0.535293459892273,
0.4300799071788788,
0.1410268247127533,
0.3796350061893463,
-0.3677675724029541,
-1.233936071395874,
-0.891671359539032,
-0.3656713366508484,
-0.6995905041694641,
0.2982775866985321,
-0.11149975657463074,
-0.03724505379796028,
0.5905103087425232,
0.23391781747341156,
-1.167880654335022,
-0.19227442145347595,
-0.40287402272224426,
-0.09615842252969742,
0.3571913242340088,
0.4148147404193878,
0.22514554858207703,
-0.40108388662338257,
-0.20042726397514343,
-0.10128733515739441,
-0.7723122239112854,
-0.0842675268650055,
0.17001017928123474,
0.35693395137786865,
-0.003607821185141802,
0.7752703428268433,
-0.2902412712574005,
0.797514021396637,
0.12287460267543793,
-0.060281507670879364,
-0.20660044252872467,
-0.5124053359031677,
-0.2428123503923416,
-0.24722911417484283,
0.5925977230072021,
0.14837338030338287,
0.11442619562149048,
-0.5263419151306152,
-0.06402081996202469,
0.07564760744571686,
0.4101380407810211,
-0.6202227473258972,
-0.4489436745643616,
0.32380175590515137,
-0.06603462249040604,
-0.09032376110553741,
-0.06032653898000717,
-0.9383530616760254,
-0.12914589047431946,
-0.48181554675102234,
0.49980297684669495,
-0.1334424912929535,
0.2042434960603714,
-0.3452102243900299,
-0.3840608596801758,
0.4621889889240265,
0.2691190540790558,
-0.964993417263031,
0.11744925379753113,
0.1951248049736023,
0.4793528616428375,
-0.09691167622804642,
-0.03337715193629265,
-0.48540765047073364,
0.6681631803512573,
-0.3637307286262512,
0.8663382530212402,
0.00005791840885649435,
-0.43894335627555847,
0.18717552721500397,
-0.3033784329891205,
0.11935921758413315,
-0.33099743723869324,
0.530411958694458,
-0.6040115356445312,
0.49785223603248596,
-0.460429847240448,
-0.38019564747810364,
0.32906144857406616,
0.24445611238479614,
-0.6489819288253784,
1.0057017803192139,
0.22262273728847504,
-0.9128169417381287,
0.6104324460029602,
-0.43985673785209656,
-0.7712044715881348,
0.38627132773399353,
-0.33987897634506226,
-0.3816277086734772,
0.09908853471279144,
0.2491837590932846,
0.33854910731315613,
-0.35241201519966125,
0.6916599273681641,
0.0892048254609108,
0.06641652435064316,
0.088791623711586,
-0.2828942537307739,
0.39156225323677063,
0.1772184520959854,
-0.33143043518066406,
0.27498871088027954,
-0.6049838662147522,
0.288415789604187,
0.25807902216911316,
-0.5222185254096985,
0.07564099878072739,
0.36519625782966614,
-0.011728082783520222,
0.18700826168060303,
-0.006443163845688105,
-0.3276192545890808,
0.14637063443660736,
-0.22772327065467834,
0.4271439015865326,
0.2939969301223755,
0.1337377429008484,
0.3537287414073944,
-0.07378585636615753,
0.2692234516143799,
-0.0042240493930876255,
0.015651334077119827,
-0.15511415898799896,
-0.41205939650535583,
-1.1090954542160034,
0.12815721333026886,
0.3951641321182251,
0.5553770661354065,
-1.32732093334198,
0.4435424506664276,
-0.3596108853816986,
-0.4260757863521576,
0.06337712705135345,
-0.24546843767166138,
0.46311095356941223,
0.9191631078720093,
0.622642993927002,
0.04803293198347092,
-0.7865716218948364,
-1.0677412748336792,
-0.0012291098246350884,
-0.3289003372192383,
-0.22768960893154144,
-0.08481094986200333,
0.5196420550346375,
0.1746927797794342,
1.1972955465316772,
-0.8793806433677673,
-0.15196546912193298,
-0.571341872215271,
0.3946075141429901,
0.11911337077617645,
0.38832956552505493,
0.34179359674453735,
-0.6517968773841858,
-0.7280978560447693,
0.07255533337593079,
-0.716705322265625,
-0.005551645997911692,
-0.2117213010787964,
-0.2594743072986603,
0.2585490942001343,
0.4965105652809143,
-0.8319038152694702,
0.565549373626709,
0.16559484601020813,
-0.2038859724998474,
0.47501635551452637,
-0.14731013774871826,
-0.06832846999168396,
-0.8366782069206238,
0.2714308500289917,
-0.05108537897467613,
-0.1233583465218544,
-0.9871560335159302,
0.03176792338490486,
0.01794903539121151,
-0.504935085773468,
-0.20171183347702026,
0.39237919449806213,
-0.46968555450439453,
-0.10679361969232559,
-0.022677958011627197,
0.23085011541843414,
0.16558142006397247,
0.6318168044090271,
0.03823903575539589,
0.7343824505805969,
0.11327842622995377,
-0.5286723375320435,
0.030600545927882195,
0.5959625244140625,
-0.3425550162792206,
0.459580659866333,
-0.8560374975204468,
0.15581098198890686,
-0.5294572114944458,
0.3397507071495056,
-1.2533107995986938,
-0.3301694989204407,
0.29232659935951233,
-0.20846037566661835,
0.6057961583137512,
0.20960170030593872,
-0.2619147002696991,
-0.9729524850845337,
-0.18931466341018677,
-0.06150701642036438,
0.360982745885849,
-0.29315492510795593,
0.6408683061599731,
0.27566972374916077,
-0.605591893196106,
-0.5323572754859924,
-0.7321427464485168,
0.17075170576572418,
0.01623964123427868,
-0.5221320986747742,
0.5671831965446472,
-0.09707909822463989,
-0.13773521780967712,
0.13433599472045898,
-0.24531316757202148,
-0.05941874161362648,
-0.215518057346344,
-0.0661085993051529,
0.2878253757953644,
-0.07188820093870163,
-0.042964864522218704,
0.3660154938697815,
-0.0230789203196764,
0.014016715809702873,
-0.22098204493522644,
0.659498929977417,
0.31380730867385864,
0.08478346467018127,
-0.3530118465423584,
0.5944098234176636,
0.21712297201156616,
-0.1867941915988922,
0.5696337223052979,
0.4032842814922333,
-0.1582457423210144,
-0.35681119561195374,
-0.49401360750198364,
-0.16881920397281647,
-0.45420852303504944,
0.488452672958374,
-0.39125773310661316,
-0.758361279964447,
0.6219240427017212,
0.7253993153572083,
0.31412196159362793,
0.5476741790771484,
0.7328499555587769,
-0.1820274293422699,
0.7961393594741821,
0.489044725894928,
0.19386544823646545,
0.1455407589673996,
0.12837424874305725,
0.3878500759601593,
-0.2747911214828491,
-0.5459610223770142,
-1.0216913223266602,
-0.19389910995960236,
-0.5996547341346741,
-0.2374396026134491,
0.5441176891326904,
-0.2548087239265442,
-0.16826966404914856,
0.5677655935287476,
-0.3871271014213562,
0.5112321972846985,
0.656941831111908,
0.1400296986103058,
0.32409897446632385,
0.10389211773872375,
0.015927491709589958,
0.091253861784935,
-0.7225041389465332,
-0.360979288816452,
0.7533302307128906,
-0.02168343961238861,
0.6708062291145325,
-0.032729361206293106,
0.6084488034248352,
0.2133781611919403,
0.7503802180290222,
-0.5686702132225037,
0.6629096865653992,
0.06915001571178436,
-0.975982129573822,
-0.7247984409332275,
-0.6164906024932861,
-0.801628828048706,
0.2778266668319702,
-0.2484474927186966,
-0.49253222346305847,
-0.04376634955406189,
0.40301427245140076,
-0.28748247027397156,
-0.10566156357526779,
-0.8639853596687317,
0.8633987903594971,
0.011181612499058247,
-0.36586794257164,
0.2562815248966217,
-0.8581638336181641,
0.4183730483055115,
-0.028551163151860237,
-0.16624890267848969,
0.2984026074409485,
0.36048242449760437,
0.7149940133094788,
-0.38495373725891113,
0.5564060807228088,
-0.3111202120780945,
-0.2212623953819275,
0.6570654511451721,
0.11371523886919022,
0.6688339114189148,
0.16519935429096222,
0.12405417114496231,
-0.24154213070869446,
-0.18132218718528748,
0.023519042879343033,
-0.6484664678573608,
0.29035136103630066,
-0.23963947594165802,
-0.8041945099830627,
-0.22083289921283722,
-0.7308723330497742,
-0.4251185655593872,
0.21564680337905884,
0.46222344040870667,
0.4548332393169403,
-0.21910518407821655,
0.16982343792915344,
0.4477744698524475,
-0.22921530902385712,
0.6448107361793518,
0.3523693084716797,
-0.09943752735853195,
-0.3870789408683777,
0.5395714640617371,
0.12465392798185349,
0.004140028730034828,
0.7369300723075867,
-0.02405017800629139,
-0.5051164627075195,
-0.6770976185798645,
-0.5019314289093018,
-0.03230438381433487,
-0.45281386375427246,
-0.6332604885101318,
-0.6350684762001038,
-0.2737758755683899,
-0.3426405191421509,
-0.025240100920200348,
0.19934801757335663,
-0.4247620105743408,
-0.11494988203048706,
-0.3996416926383972,
0.015695704147219658,
0.48393023014068604,
0.20414923131465912,
0.2697603106498718,
-0.8150874376296997,
0.5872883200645447,
0.7145696878433228,
0.1910594254732132,
0.13715046644210815,
-0.48872217535972595,
-0.009633214212954044,
-0.17905984818935394,
-0.4576326310634613,
-1.0850906372070312,
0.38895106315612793,
0.26100876927375793,
0.5698994994163513,
0.11844083666801453,
-0.1309511810541153,
0.7492422461509705,
-1.1374558210372925,
0.6203338503837585,
0.380447655916214,
-1.0570497512817383,
0.6388006806373596,
-0.4991986155509949,
0.1927834153175354,
0.817876935005188,
0.5436786413192749,
-0.27030569314956665,
-0.6544605493545532,
-0.3297998905181885,
-0.9081165194511414,
0.7217302918434143,
0.4553801119327545,
0.23373977839946747,
-0.2141610085964203,
0.42149487137794495,
0.3361024856567383,
0.33467406034469604,
-1.2395098209381104,
-0.2925409972667694,
-0.22221443057060242,
-0.12035233527421951,
0.017434829846024513,
-0.4544758200645447,
-0.09031309187412262,
-0.3357495665550232,
0.5811709761619568,
-0.01326806377619505,
0.2843814492225647,
0.12079379707574844,
-0.05189426243305206,
-0.2613071799278259,
0.5637285709381104,
0.5357446074485779,
0.731412410736084,
-0.15910404920578003,
0.17232389748096466,
0.03732606768608093,
-0.29491519927978516,
0.15357598662376404,
0.17002248764038086,
-0.7672136425971985,
0.13576126098632812,
0.12782332301139832,
0.816731870174408,
-0.1461736410856247,
-0.295585960149765,
0.2304450273513794,
-0.022096745669841766,
-0.4032517969608307,
0.040747322142124176,
-0.010843816213309765,
0.1291380375623703,
-0.0585373193025589,
0.5973125100135803,
-0.5400939583778381,
0.2441226691007614,
-0.6559985876083374,
0.482784241437912,
0.5194758176803589,
-0.1565321981906891,
-0.28924813866615295,
0.7900848388671875,
0.17247077822685242,
-0.09818486124277115,
0.7220185995101929,
-0.33859893679618835,
-0.21481643617153168,
0.4528111219406128,
0.861267626285553,
0.5857201814651489,
-0.21136532723903656,
0.6710918545722961,
0.4825955331325531,
0.42825812101364136,
0.14119207859039307,
0.4356516897678375,
-0.0028039212338626385,
-0.5633022785186768,
-0.5526062250137329,
-0.7963417768478394,
-0.3648480772972107,
0.2370452880859375,
-0.6633472442626953,
0.08794451504945755,
-0.06426540017127991,
-0.22965914011001587,
0.20970793068408966,
-0.3544245958328247,
-0.6223456263542175,
0.3903561234474182,
0.039473503828048706,
0.5855938792228699,
-0.944294810295105,
0.574411928653717,
0.3502624034881592,
-0.5899641513824463,
-1.008865475654602,
0.0012762494152411819,
-0.6097246408462524,
-0.44687619805336,
0.5785909295082092,
-0.10812089592218399,
0.5720078349113464,
0.1883353441953659,
-0.44950416684150696,
-0.7901848554611206,
0.9316438436508179,
0.3964143693447113,
-0.623428463935852,
-0.44564399123191833,
0.5356191396713257,
0.662127673625946,
0.2986511290073395,
0.23103715479373932,
0.7834203839302063,
0.6885297894477844,
0.051531996577978134,
-0.523264467716217,
0.17207005620002747,
-0.057886600494384766,
0.004149242769926786,
0.5944396257400513,
0.005952551960945129,
0.6475164294242859,
-0.11943677067756653,
-0.44296926259994507,
-0.0548267625272274,
0.9948224425315857,
-0.01820562221109867,
0.031092511489987373,
0.32242703437805176,
0.7653113007545471,
0.5140233039855957,
-0.48462367057800293,
0.8792915344238281,
0.06685426086187363,
0.34367403388023376,
1.0538017749786377,
-0.5080422759056091,
0.5461530089378357,
0.47652965784072876,
-0.4888729155063629,
0.6199280023574829,
0.22913649678230286,
-0.18588106334209442,
0.7768346667289734,
0.3241620361804962,
-0.09658616036176682,
0.05212867632508278,
0.08159390091896057,
-0.49947482347488403,
0.4150390923023224,
0.2670477330684662,
-0.09818416833877563,
-0.7240757346153259,
-0.09743493795394897,
-0.07312868535518646,
-0.039058174937963486,
-0.22006209194660187,
0.8736914992332458,
-0.10317245870828629,
-0.9402613639831543,
0.2038964033126831,
-0.11928261071443558,
0.08466818928718567,
-0.7608665823936462,
0.011676822789013386,
-0.6065646409988403,
-0.4587835371494293,
-0.2071523219347,
-0.7472822666168213,
0.49532753229141235,
0.28052040934562683,
-0.3303484618663788,
-0.16015447676181793,
0.5886912941932678,
-0.6199061274528503,
-0.42333903908729553,
-0.34663471579551697,
0.7647549510002136,
-0.31189998984336853,
0.24031154811382294,
-0.27179285883903503,
-0.24980130791664124,
0.11208963394165039,
-0.4318797290325165,
0.16681471467018127,
0.39338481426239014,
-0.0005720952176488936,
0.2546093463897705,
0.4207499027252197,
-0.24110367894172668,
-0.015100836753845215,
0.1384403258562088,
0.8889659643173218,
-0.5663732290267944,
-0.551831066608429,
-0.7270351052284241,
0.9053331017494202,
0.027896976098418236,
-0.2262946367263794,
0.670409083366394,
0.6952637434005737,
0.6584692597389221,
-0.5041110515594482,
0.6155353784561157,
-0.5581457614898682,
0.31389927864074707,
-0.5894357562065125,
0.6183830499649048,
-0.4038480520248413,
-0.22325028479099274,
-0.38996419310569763,
-1.0575655698776245,
-0.5713140964508057,
0.24922606348991394,
-0.2577332854270935,
-0.06898654252290726,
0.9963504076004028,
0.6900537610054016,
0.27713024616241455,
0.011965333484113216,
0.0933009535074234,
0.08527998626232147,
0.33627352118492126,
0.43634310364723206,
0.9493683576583862,
-0.28590744733810425,
0.7838265299797058,
-0.10384297370910645,
0.013486837036907673,
0.2481117844581604,
-0.9225853681564331,
-0.6832386255264282,
-0.6714555025100708,
-0.21358339488506317,
-0.1465897113084793,
0.0031530337873846292,
0.28953245282173157,
0.22365280985832214,
-0.9786304831504822,
-0.012093155644834042,
-0.4761645495891571,
-0.07202493399381638,
0.19430698454380035,
-0.28713205456733704,
0.5735258460044861,
-0.5896176099777222,
-0.5001233220100403,
0.19136139750480652,
0.2723290026187897,
0.07455150038003922,
0.009131557308137417,
0.5228691697120667,
-0.023942887783050537,
0.07221207022666931,
0.7664883732795715,
0.22084316611289978,
-0.32718485593795776,
-0.4304489195346832,
-0.05965474620461464,
-0.25075897574424744,
0.169086754322052,
0.8670894503593445,
-0.7050344944000244,
-0.05258831009268761,
0.6484350562095642,
0.5124004483222961,
0.802905797958374,
0.12306021898984909,
0.3629610538482666,
-0.9582794904708862,
0.13245445489883423,
0.3762567937374115,
0.26570165157318115,
0.11403929442167282,
-0.20317164063453674,
0.4300948679447174,
-0.08505967259407043,
-0.4760359823703766,
-0.72779381275177,
0.2329476922750473,
-1.013095498085022,
-0.20282211899757385,
0.7239685654640198,
0.24295902252197266,
-0.003879088442772627,
-0.1581721007823944,
-0.08160021156072617,
0.5018234848976135,
-0.10192853957414627,
0.9456993341445923,
0.28720584511756897,
-0.09592073410749435,
0.19921277463436127,
-0.40318503975868225,
0.5922694802284241,
0.4409400522708893,
-1.2839140892028809,
0.11022548377513885,
0.7666892409324646,
-0.14841803908348083,
0.3305302858352661,
0.655971348285675,
-0.12161587178707123,
0.06965049356222153,
0.02480166405439377,
0.1291891485452652,
0.1242729127407074,
-0.6779531836509705,
0.2769959270954132,
0.6496624946594238,
-0.18464981019496918,
0.32709866762161255
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14454v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14454v1
|
Prediction of Translation Techniques for the Translation Process
| 2024-03-21T15:02:03 | 2024-03-21T15:02:03 |
Fan Zhou, Vincent Vandeghinste
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Machine translation (MT) encompasses a variety of methodologies aimed at
enhancing the accuracy of translations. In contrast, the process of
human-generated translation relies on a wide range of translation techniques,
which are crucial for ensuring linguistic adequacy and fluency. This study
suggests that these translation techniques could further optimize machine
translation if they are automatically identified before being applied to guide
the translation process effectively. The study differentiates between two
scenarios of the translation process: from-scratch translation and
post-editing. For each scenario, a specific set of experiments has been
designed to forecast the most appropriate translation techniques. The findings
indicate that the predictive accuracy for from-scratch translation reaches 82%,
while the post-editing process exhibits even greater potential, achieving an
accuracy rate of 93%.
|
[
-0.3957681655883789,
-0.8324456810951233,
0.5522198677062988,
0.10071804374456406,
-0.38871151208877563,
0.33882442116737366,
-0.15651686489582062,
-0.48927026987075806,
0.16230010986328125,
0.5500573515892029,
-0.652076780796051,
-0.14088189601898193,
-0.8989501595497131,
0.4718071222305298,
-0.39547649025917053,
0.6934415102005005,
-0.41916561126708984,
0.4082106947898865,
-0.07198881357908249,
0.06287042796611786,
-0.7750088572502136,
-0.556228518486023,
-0.4783746898174286,
-0.4276330769062042,
0.37441501021385193,
0.3280526101589203,
0.995178759098053,
1.0175821781158447,
0.8797063231468201,
0.36469292640686035,
-0.06562186777591705,
0.18771767616271973,
-0.1086147353053093,
0.1817288100719452,
0.048692092299461365,
-0.7702855467796326,
-0.40777888894081116,
0.2484045922756195,
0.2690398097038269,
0.5669118165969849,
-0.058917492628097534,
0.2185722142457962,
0.16354887187480927,
0.514857292175293,
-0.030139200389385223,
-0.35962143540382385,
-0.7283036112785339,
0.19010354578495026,
-0.3480564057826996,
-0.6715098023414612,
-0.3420170843601227,
-0.398418664932251,
0.10112782567739487,
-0.6258118152618408,
0.30318933725357056,
0.23236627876758575,
0.5016921758651733,
0.4318321645259857,
-0.12686270475387573,
-0.26150619983673096,
-0.7309608459472656,
0.6888981461524963,
-0.7401735782623291,
0.2406039983034134,
0.6240974068641663,
0.42585280537605286,
-0.3781280517578125,
-0.6165355443954468,
-0.3985949754714966,
0.07256906479597092,
-0.09914930909872055,
0.03431985154747963,
0.04154852405190468,
-0.12095961719751358,
0.3735520839691162,
0.26049143075942993,
-0.6395732164382935,
0.10859427601099014,
-0.4771846830844879,
-0.10782837867736816,
0.5575709939002991,
0.17167653143405914,
0.44509249925613403,
-0.32637032866477966,
-0.24074383080005646,
-0.14015927910804749,
-0.4423515200614929,
-0.10616004467010498,
0.1099565401673317,
0.1425105482339859,
0.2970243990421295,
0.7296891808509827,
-0.1576778143644333,
0.6137439608573914,
0.14239145815372467,
-0.38318341970443726,
0.3860040605068207,
-0.5692589282989502,
-0.3864431083202362,
0.03649954870343208,
0.7608948945999146,
0.520804762840271,
0.2327095866203308,
-0.20614168047904968,
-0.5082545876502991,
-0.015104737132787704,
0.458280086517334,
-0.3945430815219879,
-0.009250778704881668,
0.0856582373380661,
-0.46083956956863403,
-0.6321951746940613,
-0.05311967805027962,
-0.4453611969947815,
-0.18096953630447388,
-0.6342270374298096,
0.4891981780529022,
-0.6037460565567017,
0.07218155264854431,
-0.08634554594755173,
-0.15157225728034973,
-0.05928626284003258,
0.5572776794433594,
-0.37075939774513245,
-0.0314599871635437,
0.5671970248222351,
1.0209041833877563,
-0.5047028660774231,
-0.3931616246700287,
-0.515598714351654,
0.07386104017496109,
-0.7278310656547546,
0.8016524314880371,
-0.36394283175468445,
-0.5485199093818665,
-0.19155055284500122,
-0.014918929897248745,
-0.04305996000766754,
-0.3658945560455322,
0.652449905872345,
-0.5003583431243896,
0.20420584082603455,
-0.17314833402633667,
-0.4967684745788574,
-0.4568803906440735,
-0.01057297084480524,
-0.723644495010376,
0.9130613803863525,
0.07954040169715881,
-0.5331630110740662,
0.5660974383354187,
-0.7745857238769531,
-0.7846663594245911,
-0.21611522138118744,
0.5656883716583252,
-0.5373621582984924,
0.4043871760368347,
0.4206719994544983,
0.48874393105506897,
-0.2510555684566498,
0.39945852756500244,
0.0249176025390625,
-0.40502306818962097,
0.6691710948944092,
-0.28850916028022766,
0.40049228072166443,
0.6823286414146423,
-0.1839798241853714,
0.15737657248973846,
-0.33692097663879395,
0.11459837853908539,
-0.22529847919940948,
-0.3235071003437042,
-0.0809062197804451,
-0.1259768158197403,
-0.060198765248060226,
0.5158973336219788,
-0.02599467895925045,
-0.29346024990081787,
0.1360517144203186,
-0.5479364991188049,
0.31334125995635986,
0.5492314696311951,
0.07849787920713425,
0.47139808535575867,
-0.31153836846351624,
0.9595322608947754,
-0.14942678809165955,
0.054070908576250076,
-0.2629008889198303,
-0.7416187524795532,
-0.2839724123477936,
0.188155859708786,
0.6490371227264404,
1.006603479385376,
-0.8796372413635254,
0.32503843307495117,
-0.37585192918777466,
-0.7221295237541199,
-0.6412847638130188,
0.22425250709056854,
0.6126195788383484,
0.2724546194076538,
0.4104871451854706,
-0.3409211337566376,
-0.9694958925247192,
-0.47123023867607117,
-0.6343488693237305,
0.23452067375183105,
0.1238415539264679,
-0.4556587338447571,
0.43613189458847046,
-0.24441415071487427,
0.5072230696678162,
-0.3169154226779938,
0.0426417700946331,
-0.2661760449409485,
0.6178869009017944,
0.1419491469860077,
0.6259697675704956,
0.3048749268054962,
-0.842826247215271,
-0.7934244275093079,
0.22412487864494324,
-0.7487727403640747,
-0.10900001972913742,
-0.05817360430955887,
-0.22623655200004578,
0.4967321455478668,
0.6072688698768616,
-0.43220365047454834,
0.6513935327529907,
0.6323750019073486,
0.07104457169771194,
0.3695431053638458,
-0.3758191466331482,
0.6136162281036377,
-1.2895126342773438,
0.10405262559652328,
-0.059566717594861984,
-0.3337719142436981,
-0.6936405301094055,
-0.05965901538729668,
0.12382981181144714,
-0.08523445576429367,
-0.42010393738746643,
0.10191619396209717,
-0.6028205752372742,
-0.17036651074886322,
-0.3922491669654846,
-0.08943237364292145,
-0.11067914217710495,
-0.018432699143886566,
0.1372343897819519,
1.1674596071243286,
0.09251626580953598,
-0.46329912543296814,
0.029611576348543167,
0.20574218034744263,
-0.6056832075119019,
0.2533226013183594,
-0.6342326402664185,
0.16122755408287048,
0.03243148326873779,
-0.030737904831767082,
-1.1188148260116577,
-0.10434887558221817,
0.2780827581882477,
-1.0539199113845825,
0.42226243019104004,
0.0994078516960144,
-0.7051089406013489,
-0.46929416060447693,
-0.006272451486438513,
-0.1491963118314743,
0.6707144379615784,
0.11265292018651962,
0.28284215927124023,
0.21626655757427216,
-0.36381393671035767,
-0.6327621936798096,
-0.8248811364173889,
0.30118411779403687,
-0.22363688051700592,
-0.40491652488708496,
0.3159717321395874,
-0.1877421885728836,
-0.014550742693245411,
-0.1069851741194725,
0.1872314214706421,
0.028290681540966034,
0.37615740299224854,
0.37334397435188293,
0.40212664008140564,
-0.04446519538760185,
-0.1469297558069229,
0.1781756728887558,
-0.44045907258987427,
-0.15326209366321564,
-0.3701467216014862,
0.3822157680988312,
0.3209528625011444,
-0.10892347991466522,
-0.4199664294719696,
0.20131239295005798,
0.5583942532539368,
-0.2907836139202118,
0.7245348691940308,
0.9047390818595886,
-0.28445783257484436,
0.38332614302635193,
-0.6301385760307312,
-0.12126301974058151,
-0.4049586355686188,
0.3323175013065338,
-0.71107017993927,
-0.15812931954860687,
0.3816549479961395,
-0.21887782216072083,
-0.22389912605285645,
0.5233520269393921,
0.42040109634399414,
-0.45298731327056885,
1.4747473001480103,
0.7087697386741638,
0.08327744156122208,
0.5050914883613586,
-0.14808616042137146,
0.13697673380374908,
-0.7981619834899902,
0.14514388144016266,
-0.5889246463775635,
-0.5744451284408569,
-0.7390158772468567,
-0.7183007597923279,
0.09959375858306885,
0.26852095127105713,
0.5153771638870239,
0.936042308807373,
-0.5405384302139282,
0.3257087469100952,
0.9153794646263123,
-0.2772507965564728,
0.5349823236465454,
0.32338765263557434,
-0.33618417382240295,
-0.2774692475795746,
-0.5028854012489319,
-0.744347333908081,
1.415651798248291,
0.029411232098937035,
0.010038025677204132,
-0.38549497723579407,
0.613384485244751,
0.36301249265670776,
0.5570372939109802,
-0.6596079468727112,
0.3632255792617798,
0.05586133152246475,
-0.6280440092086792,
-0.41424867510795593,
-0.2670169174671173,
-0.9656794667243958,
0.10646183788776398,
-0.48969322443008423,
-0.24285449087619781,
-0.24742622673511505,
0.07033330202102661,
0.0408964678645134,
0.25495007634162903,
-0.6414000391960144,
0.7694379091262817,
-0.14342477917671204,
0.2557210624217987,
-0.30141252279281616,
-0.9470269083976746,
-0.12399372458457947,
-0.7180556654930115,
0.46135440468788147,
0.16139037907123566,
-0.04456626623868942,
0.6374190449714661,
-0.15746071934700012,
0.3296145498752594,
0.03580716252326965,
0.15388678014278412,
0.312792032957077,
0.23543742299079895,
0.5510615110397339,
-0.5755189657211304,
-0.4864141345024109,
0.05933455750346184,
0.18446297943592072,
-0.19140742719173431,
-0.5300551056861877,
0.1438775360584259,
-0.6480782628059387,
-0.358004093170166,
-0.27547308802604675,
-0.5055323839187622,
0.028546271845698357,
0.3594863712787628,
0.8501274585723877,
0.12668098509311676,
-0.3220319449901581,
-0.0852934792637825,
0.3923880159854889,
-0.06262203305959702,
0.3529280126094818,
0.38494330644607544,
-0.3656618595123291,
-0.7598633170127869,
0.869720995426178,
0.44485366344451904,
0.2601771056652069,
0.5359369516372681,
0.22512279450893402,
-0.18094667792320251,
-1.2115293741226196,
-0.5939608812332153,
0.0983143001794815,
-0.559792160987854,
-0.23918519914150238,
-0.49136486649513245,
0.23537564277648926,
-0.5063965320587158,
-0.4768322706222534,
-0.06489799171686172,
-0.6722891330718994,
-0.13433760404586792,
-0.3211521506309509,
0.055714160203933716,
0.5836479067802429,
-0.14893333613872528,
0.5460341572761536,
-1.0666736364364624,
0.2951464354991913,
-0.41165414452552795,
-0.2258625626564026,
-0.6603843569755554,
-0.5612717270851135,
-0.4655577540397644,
0.37789177894592285,
-0.41904616355895996,
-0.6846539378166199,
0.7379156947135925,
-0.07439795881509781,
0.5436995625495911,
0.216304749250412,
-0.25955137610435486,
0.7878182530403137,
-0.6492657661437988,
0.6443274021148682,
0.2880192995071411,
-0.9148549437522888,
0.9106146693229675,
-0.20420771837234497,
0.09633715450763702,
0.4980129301548004,
0.6509801149368286,
-0.6068785190582275,
-0.45521554350852966,
-0.6198791861534119,
-0.390951931476593,
0.6023622155189514,
0.10009156167507172,
-0.14867042005062103,
0.2147083878517151,
0.43574875593185425,
0.4857657253742218,
0.6081293821334839,
-0.2814180850982666,
-0.1352461725473404,
0.07677516341209412,
-0.08929756283760071,
-0.5720090866088867,
-0.08661586791276932,
0.18849752843379974,
-0.4304060935974121,
0.5855816006660461,
0.14386926591396332,
0.24216510355472565,
0.003816742915660143,
-0.2261929214000702,
-0.7436307072639465,
-0.05369686335325241,
0.730502188205719,
1.0284630060195923,
-0.21511945128440857,
-0.32889944314956665,
0.29683977365493774,
-0.5116526484489441,
0.20254644751548767,
-0.2002093493938446,
-0.32934895157814026,
0.23839756846427917,
0.42234107851982117,
0.7926183342933655,
-0.22272992134094238,
-0.4415628910064697,
0.1177598387002945,
0.2861613929271698,
-0.2650887668132782,
-0.2983831763267517,
-0.06956618279218674,
-0.1419428586959839,
0.08497430384159088,
0.1009383425116539,
0.8852169513702393,
0.381833553314209,
-0.5001391172409058,
0.12291806936264038,
0.1321813017129898,
-0.3809276819229126,
-0.525916337966919,
0.6511317491531372,
0.10805743932723999,
-0.7387595772743225,
0.42860332131385803,
-0.15348957479000092,
-0.5600934624671936,
0.3146694004535675,
0.4489023685455322,
0.9611906409263611,
-0.7782383561134338,
0.08100870996713638,
0.47497618198394775,
0.3889084458351135,
-0.3427320718765259,
0.17338940501213074,
0.43092891573905945,
-0.541202187538147,
-0.6690835952758789,
-0.5259673595428467,
-0.29147157073020935,
-0.34011584520339966,
-0.6366038918495178,
0.4910847246646881,
0.016312381252646446,
-0.6035735011100769,
-0.05616994947195053,
0.09800902009010315,
-0.5898712873458862,
0.4643261134624481,
-0.004047709982842207,
0.8688859343528748,
-0.826900839805603,
1.0193195343017578,
0.9045320153236389,
-0.2677931487560272,
-0.5736223459243774,
-0.10169673711061478,
0.24731305241584778,
-0.7230592370033264,
0.48683658242225647,
0.13945633172988892,
-0.16742724180221558,
0.13483600318431854,
-0.16727344691753387,
-0.9525640606880188,
0.9220705032348633,
0.20911380648612976,
-0.2701277732849121,
-0.03898347169160843,
0.24660710990428925,
0.5420725345611572,
-0.20849968492984772,
-0.10816194117069244,
0.6745138764381409,
0.7037678360939026,
0.2823168635368347,
-1.1511403322219849,
0.014957650564610958,
-0.21874505281448364,
0.32588210701942444,
0.3658408522605896,
0.2678627669811249,
0.45330286026000977,
-0.3500764071941376,
-0.06841833144426346,
0.26087716221809387,
0.438393771648407,
-0.2703882157802582,
0.4720965027809143,
0.26616403460502625,
0.40165114402770996,
0.5988828539848328,
-0.13496136665344238,
1.1874327659606934,
-0.2681385576725006,
-0.16159740090370178,
0.7497820258140564,
0.27916017174720764,
1.1169894933700562,
0.5089548826217651,
-0.2520882189273834,
0.2382308840751648,
0.8010213971138,
0.11783178895711899,
0.6276116371154785,
-0.15826940536499023,
0.4176599979400635,
0.01137977372854948,
0.17854075133800507,
-0.47099873423576355,
0.26350873708724976,
0.5366610288619995,
-0.6786192655563354,
0.6221686601638794,
0.2975565791130066,
0.34010931849479675,
0.2771712839603424,
-0.11812160164117813,
0.8989392518997192,
-0.0013932040892541409,
-1.28463613986969,
0.470506489276886,
0.3628097474575043,
0.4623008072376251,
-0.3184618055820465,
0.04121938720345497,
0.1496180146932602,
0.10669711977243423,
-0.0847068652510643,
-0.9861300587654114,
0.5865811705589294,
-0.4589965045452118,
-0.16713038086891174,
-0.6703370213508606,
0.7215213179588318,
-0.38201266527175903,
-0.7139421105384827,
0.00516367657110095,
0.7643619775772095,
0.22883929312229156,
-0.32787367701530457,
-0.6323463320732117,
-0.027079852297902107,
0.18260541558265686,
-0.25147706270217896,
0.27814510464668274,
0.6220012307167053,
0.20783299207687378,
0.5830568671226501,
0.8018460869789124,
0.400059312582016,
0.06879673153162003,
-0.3972811698913574,
0.2760879397392273,
-0.6139046549797058,
-0.2871900498867035,
-0.8602589964866638,
0.6188764572143555,
-0.06531967967748642,
-0.2789500951766968,
0.9012249112129211,
0.31766295433044434,
0.7297094464302063,
-0.36765944957733154,
0.8547890782356262,
0.3242049217224121,
0.7100907564163208,
-0.5485430955886841,
0.41215425729751587,
-0.4088640809059143,
-0.05572052299976349,
-0.7499657273292542,
-1.1000739336013794,
-0.395106703042984,
0.6256467700004578,
-0.6006178259849548,
-0.21713858842849731,
1.0380806922912598,
0.6590092778205872,
0.14965522289276123,
0.16240496933460236,
0.26133057475090027,
-0.22128957509994507,
0.048050105571746826,
0.028215769678354263,
0.5688024759292603,
-0.5999529957771301,
0.5701277852058411,
-0.48249727487564087,
-0.03819562867283821,
-0.5761529803276062,
-0.9389299154281616,
-0.6370524168014526,
-0.7057598233222961,
-0.229664146900177,
-0.11450453847646713,
0.023771725594997406,
0.743285596370697,
0.5599937438964844,
-0.6937314867973328,
-0.2770826518535614,
-0.22702674567699432,
-0.07501748204231262,
-0.8044529557228088,
-0.1005491316318512,
0.07548931241035461,
-0.520950973033905,
-0.767625629901886,
0.37971776723861694,
0.1685658097267151,
0.3322364091873169,
0.11751597374677658,
-0.11462386697530746,
-0.05268920212984085,
0.01773286797106266,
0.6172347068786621,
-0.24292534589767456,
-0.717952311038971,
-0.09744350612163544,
0.2877475917339325,
-0.1940251886844635,
0.2505093514919281,
0.8469935059547424,
-0.46915268898010254,
0.6104410290718079,
0.6243112087249756,
0.5332235097885132,
0.3459393084049225,
0.3711932599544525,
1.1814864873886108,
-0.3184199631214142,
-0.03091799095273018,
0.10598722100257874,
0.19945210218429565,
0.38855603337287903,
-0.3805101811885834,
0.7633125185966492,
0.23955869674682617,
-0.5003231763839722,
-0.7173881530761719,
0.032252103090286255,
-0.45996516942977905,
-0.23237751424312592,
0.6581531763076782,
-0.06320153176784515,
-0.11354649811983109,
-0.09794241189956665,
-0.5166794061660767,
0.7393357157707214,
-0.07246057689189911,
0.5329158902168274,
0.8186714053153992,
0.03586731106042862,
-0.052158650010824203,
-0.9712396264076233,
0.7194212675094604,
0.3389331102371216,
-0.5146374702453613,
-0.2903438210487366,
0.2378159761428833,
0.009276537224650383,
0.3052830398082733,
0.3420161306858063,
-0.09063658118247986,
0.21574647724628448,
-0.1584520936012268,
-0.08146628737449646,
-0.044053900986909866,
-0.2735353410243988,
0.023625323548913002,
-0.22704342007637024,
0.28267088532447815,
-0.07084781676530838
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14444v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14444v1
|
More than Just Statistical Recurrence: Human and Machine Unsupervised Learning of Māori Word Segmentation across Morphological Processes
| 2024-03-21T14:51:51 | 2024-03-21T14:51:51 |
Ashvini Varatharaj, Simon Todd
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Non-M\=aori-speaking New Zealanders (NMS)are able to segment M\=aori words in
a highlysimilar way to fluent speakers (Panther et al.,2024). This ability is
assumed to derive through the identification and extraction of statistically
recurrent forms. We examine this assumption by asking how NMS segmentations
compare to those produced by Morfessor, an unsupervised machine learning model
that operates based on statistical recurrence, across words formed by a variety
of morphological processes. Both NMS and Morfessor succeed in segmenting words
formed by concatenative processes (compounding and affixation without
allomorphy), but NMS also succeed for words that invoke templates
(reduplication and allomorphy) and other cues to morphological structure,
implying that their learning process is sensitive to more than just statistical
recurrence.
|
[
-0.3725888133049011,
-0.7816219329833984,
0.22783823311328888,
-0.06958067417144775,
-0.4979528784751892,
0.21347114443778992,
0.005267549306154251,
-0.3886086046695709,
0.5197426080703735,
0.5686938762664795,
-0.41827234625816345,
-0.07515155524015427,
-0.8640876412391663,
0.4186544418334961,
-0.41170692443847656,
0.7860057353973389,
0.1647690236568451,
0.1449989527463913,
-0.06223830580711365,
-0.37114274501800537,
-0.4547920823097229,
-0.5917890071868896,
-0.8816185593605042,
-0.8412938117980957,
0.7343637943267822,
0.3188134431838989,
0.8410710096359253,
0.625837504863739,
0.11415642499923706,
0.41448625922203064,
-0.3056696951389313,
0.31972435116767883,
-0.33082228899002075,
0.4752635657787323,
-0.3028215169906616,
-0.6032183170318604,
0.486717164516449,
-0.18293897807598114,
0.6911084055900574,
0.9092952609062195,
-0.2860529124736786,
-0.29440799355506897,
0.017628053203225136,
1.0795341730117798,
-0.7251892685890198,
0.07610457390546799,
-0.6776727437973022,
0.3795522451400757,
-0.4270351529121399,
-0.2445472776889801,
-0.4430553615093231,
-0.16282223165035248,
0.2983432114124298,
-0.5128393769264221,
0.3524974584579468,
-0.20529578626155853,
0.6128792762756348,
0.08948604762554169,
-0.4482385814189911,
-0.2192314863204956,
-0.38410472869873047,
0.6604166626930237,
-0.012676498852670193,
0.6547166109085083,
0.35885995626449585,
0.15711718797683716,
-0.6704928874969482,
-0.6522810459136963,
-0.4109380841255188,
-0.10215584188699722,
-0.0765959620475769,
-0.2183586210012436,
-0.506401538848877,
-0.2767421007156372,
0.06903216242790222,
0.1635793298482895,
-0.4176193177700043,
0.1456061601638794,
-0.44097405672073364,
-0.29456835985183716,
0.5887870192527771,
0.15132826566696167,
0.26461735367774963,
-0.3446766138076782,
-0.24929901957511902,
0.11358421295881271,
-0.3708590567111969,
-0.14968039095401764,
0.04028010740876198,
0.1350216418504715,
-0.08509036153554916,
0.7361282110214233,
0.06656654924154282,
0.6324348449707031,
-0.057250071316957474,
-0.27352994680404663,
0.4394683539867401,
0.3583328425884247,
0.01163692306727171,
-0.026353616267442703,
0.9813681244850159,
0.08201918751001358,
0.7178113460540771,
-0.5160630345344543,
-0.19234979152679443,
0.08543424308300018,
0.2671140730381012,
-0.2295505851507187,
-0.49164608120918274,
-0.3225102424621582,
-0.34212997555732727,
-0.196214497089386,
0.1552318036556244,
-0.889561653137207,
-0.32866397500038147,
-0.18862049281597137,
0.45917364954948425,
-0.7396172881126404,
-0.34251731634140015,
0.09431269019842148,
-0.6804245710372925,
-0.047371238470077515,
0.05451812967658043,
-0.7825093865394592,
0.2576080858707428,
0.757462203502655,
1.1158552169799805,
-0.6779435276985168,
-0.6144258379936218,
-0.23166653513908386,
-0.026816830039024353,
-0.4772492051124573,
0.7620931267738342,
-0.7449396848678589,
-0.64996737241745,
-0.2469453662633896,
0.2797253727912903,
-0.5030589699745178,
-0.6798998117446899,
-0.1051720455288887,
-0.6966965794563293,
0.18968115746974945,
0.20242080092430115,
-0.5173143744468689,
-0.569702684879303,
-0.027824433520436287,
-0.5873837471008301,
0.9597108364105225,
0.1563553512096405,
-0.6306745409965515,
0.5043319463729858,
-0.7474366426467896,
-0.8606309294700623,
-0.17521250247955322,
-0.09778283536434174,
-0.4447171986103058,
0.39652755856513977,
-0.10369767993688583,
0.48052746057510376,
-0.30534133315086365,
0.16875329613685608,
-0.04377460479736328,
0.16315406560897827,
0.7550877332687378,
-0.8453197479248047,
0.5368198156356812,
0.4225638806819916,
-0.31943997740745544,
-0.036807555705308914,
-0.9368503093719482,
-0.0726693868637085,
0.17179901897907257,
-0.182175412774086,
-0.3426329493522644,
-0.034381669014692307,
-0.1406487673521042,
-0.08214179426431656,
-0.21994903683662415,
-0.6683175563812256,
-0.06814351677894592,
-0.24062442779541016,
0.841015636920929,
0.4666093587875366,
0.27438703179359436,
0.25439172983169556,
-0.48137417435646057,
0.39111703634262085,
0.3792168200016022,
0.0030561883468180895,
-0.3065294027328491,
-0.8371050953865051,
-0.67473304271698,
-0.5459279417991638,
0.3453649878501892,
0.21646903455257416,
-0.7155705690383911,
0.22868914902210236,
-0.02917974442243576,
-0.6424047350883484,
-0.0360100232064724,
-0.1384623646736145,
0.5907163023948669,
0.45730865001678467,
0.2676750719547272,
-0.818128764629364,
-0.6154875755310059,
-0.8069646954536438,
0.02348683960735798,
-0.08090928941965103,
-0.014734631404280663,
-0.0989517793059349,
0.6314272880554199,
-0.4126181900501251,
0.9553038477897644,
-0.7458320260047913,
0.008863373659551144,
-0.06066841259598732,
0.5271594524383545,
0.08609026670455933,
0.38985133171081543,
0.22367744147777557,
-1.079849362373352,
-0.08184480667114258,
0.10485365986824036,
-0.63398677110672,
-0.013504340313374996,
0.24877996742725372,
-0.04404977709054947,
0.46226146817207336,
0.3321808874607086,
-0.6931380033493042,
0.46834394335746765,
0.30790308117866516,
-0.28089749813079834,
0.3264853060245514,
-0.3341043293476105,
0.038227882236242294,
-1.099914312362671,
-0.12849017977714539,
0.007765885908156633,
-0.06736177206039429,
-0.48620620369911194,
0.07203953713178635,
-0.3481157124042511,
-0.17848460376262665,
-0.534155011177063,
0.2794291377067566,
-0.6400808095932007,
-0.38048255443573,
-0.41912034153938293,
-0.3728603720664978,
-0.013407991267740726,
0.2942476272583008,
0.26006922125816345,
0.7684517502784729,
0.44339412450790405,
-0.9349176287651062,
0.11375889182090759,
0.15239866077899933,
-0.4372391402721405,
0.30592015385627747,
-0.35224562883377075,
-0.1386735737323761,
-0.26024889945983887,
-0.13131435215473175,
-1.2246122360229492,
-0.2056703418493271,
0.12877380847930908,
-0.6519690155982971,
0.24734652042388916,
-0.14032526314258575,
-0.1846320778131485,
-0.09662675857543945,
0.014346366748213768,
0.4206753969192505,
0.5624057650566101,
-0.41165924072265625,
0.48732438683509827,
0.9216125011444092,
-0.05402467027306557,
-0.3275403678417206,
-0.8043365478515625,
-0.021895848214626312,
-0.29655128717422485,
-0.46556714177131653,
0.185908704996109,
0.5461488962173462,
-0.21967290341854095,
0.04805557057261467,
0.28595390915870667,
-0.5248456597328186,
0.3607952892780304,
0.47253090143203735,
-0.0828770324587822,
-0.22201836109161377,
0.23573867976665497,
-0.23291991651058197,
-0.457912802696228,
-0.14618068933486938,
-0.18589027225971222,
1.012866735458374,
0.5347773432731628,
-0.4843854308128357,
-0.44220176339149475,
0.41270655393600464,
0.8852219581604004,
-0.16978991031646729,
0.6915032267570496,
0.3391999304294586,
-0.38345012068748474,
0.27688804268836975,
-0.5776620507240295,
-0.004803466144949198,
-0.37735360860824585,
0.35332924127578735,
-0.593464195728302,
-0.944726288318634,
0.33477744460105896,
0.08677162975072861,
-0.06950878351926804,
0.7268829941749573,
0.38320478796958923,
-0.026216791942715645,
0.9287956357002258,
0.6155127286911011,
-0.1464119404554367,
0.4185217022895813,
-0.18182963132858276,
-0.23207946121692657,
-0.7564516067504883,
-0.46610328555107117,
-0.32721009850502014,
-0.35156041383743286,
-0.8714286684989929,
-0.44922664761543274,
0.0905751883983612,
-0.07636845856904984,
-0.3039206564426422,
0.2554329037666321,
-0.5302024483680725,
0.5594503283500671,
0.46172061562538147,
-0.19220104813575745,
0.06530150771141052,
0.4068254828453064,
-0.37331506609916687,
-0.033644914627075195,
-0.814658522605896,
-0.32413995265960693,
0.724237322807312,
0.1486554890871048,
0.6812437772750854,
0.12063377350568771,
0.6742835640907288,
0.4070509970188141,
0.34717991948127747,
-0.8796703815460205,
0.2734551429748535,
-0.4040432274341583,
-0.31169211864471436,
-0.49853771924972534,
-0.4802922010421753,
-1.610851764678955,
0.5756522417068481,
-0.30833959579467773,
-0.6634862422943115,
0.3081153631210327,
-0.21767017245292664,
0.012635701335966587,
0.5517404675483704,
-0.49703195691108704,
0.3146130442619324,
0.01498359628021717,
-0.023045415058732033,
-0.14419975876808167,
-0.43401190638542175,
0.017077738419175148,
-0.3396093547344208,
0.37700366973876953,
-0.19079293310642242,
0.03874124959111214,
1.0839581489562988,
-0.4786730110645294,
0.9673798084259033,
-0.11059391498565674,
0.09542041271924973,
0.34955060482025146,
0.13436958193778992,
0.02287834696471691,
-0.38227659463882446,
-0.05793134495615959,
0.42866331338882446,
0.026563644409179688,
-0.19952723383903503,
-0.4672682583332062,
0.3280290961265564,
-0.7604827880859375,
-0.5649688243865967,
-0.6299469470977783,
-0.19262807071208954,
-0.020154228433966637,
0.10061179846525192,
0.7033348083496094,
0.2459779977798462,
-0.3002643287181854,
0.1941591501235962,
0.3306390047073364,
0.13402779400348663,
0.39897680282592773,
0.5930487513542175,
-0.20554907619953156,
-0.8657118678092957,
0.7393276691436768,
0.42229780554771423,
-0.07958990335464478,
0.55438232421875,
0.5417298674583435,
-0.3841048777103424,
-0.5118028521537781,
-0.3624199628829956,
0.28666070103645325,
-0.37659451365470886,
-0.049561358988285065,
-0.701923131942749,
-0.23014704883098602,
-0.1642010509967804,
-0.02749294601380825,
-0.17669802904129028,
-0.6191629767417908,
-0.20441968739032745,
-0.08570017665624619,
0.6725742816925049,
0.9792124629020691,
-0.32518312335014343,
0.4547712802886963,
-0.980869710445404,
0.23006944358348846,
0.06348784267902374,
-0.12030363827943802,
0.18915964663028717,
-0.6297538876533508,
0.21623720228672028,
-0.034727711230516434,
-0.3588304817676544,
-0.9744067788124084,
0.5456377267837524,
0.3860897123813629,
0.4986424148082733,
0.6080025434494019,
-0.21165089309215546,
0.9139997363090515,
-0.7814428806304932,
0.7967125177383423,
0.6294388175010681,
-0.5997475385665894,
0.27259311079978943,
0.20707008242607117,
0.18305931985378265,
0.37425854802131653,
0.6929977536201477,
-0.9474866986274719,
-0.26419559121131897,
-0.6102741956710815,
-0.8201471567153931,
0.32307952642440796,
-0.03307827562093735,
0.2239605337381363,
-0.8433108925819397,
0.6050466895103455,
0.49925005435943604,
0.03629792109131813,
-0.318216472864151,
-0.17265352606773376,
0.14702442288398743,
0.09285508841276169,
-0.47773677110671997,
-0.5150460600852966,
-0.08282472938299179,
-0.08308233320713043,
0.49377888441085815,
0.10137097537517548,
0.12933938205242157,
0.1752518117427826,
-0.26158571243286133,
-0.002349768066778779,
0.17790673673152924,
0.5049842596054077,
0.5684364438056946,
0.4640454053878784,
0.28711381554603577,
0.146184504032135,
-0.7037535309791565,
0.5926675796508789,
-0.2320435643196106,
-0.2944515347480774,
0.32461830973625183,
0.7074116468429565,
0.7471786737442017,
0.5756620168685913,
-0.2973499596118927,
0.30390554666519165,
0.09420391172170639,
-0.3422037959098816,
-0.5238762497901917,
0.1714736670255661,
-0.14763563871383667,
0.19921055436134338,
0.4072926342487335,
0.22659730911254883,
-0.04580645635724068,
-0.58384108543396,
0.5285438895225525,
0.416535347700119,
-0.5215844511985779,
-0.3546358048915863,
0.31854870915412903,
0.12199109047651291,
-0.6367838382720947,
0.7323604822158813,
0.023299677297472954,
-0.5798609852790833,
0.5131514072418213,
0.7812337279319763,
0.7592940926551819,
-0.35423675179481506,
0.18585513532161713,
0.25086119771003723,
-0.16498102247714996,
-0.15810450911521912,
0.40142762660980225,
-0.183532252907753,
-1.0585753917694092,
-0.3223801553249359,
-0.7235961556434631,
-0.23133492469787598,
-0.045090626925230026,
-0.8620676398277283,
0.038039352744817734,
-0.4587458372116089,
-0.41083231568336487,
0.37402141094207764,
-0.6383576393127441,
-0.32262688875198364,
0.39995479583740234,
-0.1546543389558792,
0.9283378720283508,
-0.846021831035614,
0.5222716331481934,
0.7443157434463501,
-0.2580185830593109,
-0.4776676297187805,
-0.07860110700130463,
0.11488022655248642,
-1.0771576166152954,
0.8668603301048279,
0.38144171237945557,
-0.40758004784584045,
-0.15064629912376404,
0.1050492599606514,
-0.9006108641624451,
0.8521436452865601,
0.1836937516927719,
-0.3690010607242584,
0.21750712394714355,
0.259497731924057,
0.40333980321884155,
-0.31762340664863586,
0.09167028963565826,
0.6007977724075317,
0.24219770729541779,
0.45732852816581726,
-0.6115697622299194,
-0.3707568943500519,
-0.09789599478244781,
0.06570930778980255,
0.7922242283821106,
-0.41280221939086914,
0.705846905708313,
-0.298740416765213,
-0.5883944630622864,
0.11155427247285843,
0.6636751890182495,
0.08711856603622437,
0.22263412177562714,
0.6212046146392822,
0.6859862804412842,
0.9085554480552673,
-0.09983880072832108,
0.8575635552406311,
-0.24522431194782257,
-0.09366590529680252,
0.7628921270370483,
-0.09481966495513916,
0.9994727969169617,
0.6026725769042969,
-0.35936295986175537,
0.6060929298400879,
0.7817543745040894,
0.11254988610744476,
0.5868381857872009,
0.2116110473871231,
-0.30644264817237854,
-0.23102892935276031,
-0.10304330289363861,
-0.2681131958961487,
0.8800879120826721,
0.254926472902298,
-0.4869832992553711,
-0.042847197502851486,
0.09852640330791473,
0.050240956246852875,
0.11537487059831619,
-0.2931472659111023,
1.0676966905593872,
0.17812339961528778,
-0.740175724029541,
0.5422661900520325,
0.09766146540641785,
0.8979311585426331,
-0.7067322134971619,
-0.0071095009334385395,
-0.01593562588095665,
-0.0010141278617084026,
-0.40295103192329407,
-1.0601823329925537,
0.7069928050041199,
-0.022783756256103516,
-0.3688506782054901,
0.4142744243144989,
0.5142955780029297,
-0.1475682258605957,
-0.40815332531929016,
0.3650025427341461,
0.3782472014427185,
0.5271064043045044,
0.16387049853801727,
-0.37776610255241394,
-0.3396270275115967,
0.09523673355579376,
-0.08760902285575867,
0.22717978060245514,
0.6909493803977966,
-0.436134934425354,
0.9659788608551025,
0.8995893001556396,
0.13461831212043762,
0.20796315371990204,
0.2502489387989044,
0.4530831575393677,
-0.7375954985618591,
-0.5042121410369873,
-1.2096781730651855,
0.3164818286895752,
0.13197799026966095,
-0.5103678107261658,
0.44383513927459717,
0.6852464079856873,
0.8109205961227417,
-0.14743632078170776,
0.5238934755325317,
0.33075329661369324,
0.40910542011260986,
-0.569133460521698,
0.6193508505821228,
-0.3422345519065857,
-0.36323922872543335,
-0.05087124556303024,
-0.7252057194709778,
-0.4466756582260132,
0.8637453317642212,
-0.30842193961143494,
-0.30261293053627014,
0.5619741082191467,
0.6532884240150452,
0.05401230230927467,
0.31419211626052856,
0.6077114939689636,
-0.2287219613790512,
-0.052969902753829956,
0.15173020958900452,
0.9624814391136169,
0.05189447104930878,
0.18086299300193787,
-0.07144279778003693,
-0.23985911905765533,
0.10137470811605453,
-0.5636014342308044,
-0.43994468450546265,
-0.829032838344574,
-0.2976265251636505,
0.042263880372047424,
0.18916554749011993,
0.9249850511550903,
0.5235534906387329,
-0.7317275404930115,
-0.26057279109954834,
-0.04321896284818649,
0.0485406368970871,
-0.14047636091709137,
-0.22465945780277252,
0.15262696146965027,
-0.3471692204475403,
-0.4721742570400238,
0.34726759791374207,
0.39042943716049194,
0.14608116447925568,
-0.11297765374183655,
-0.046211760491132736,
-0.12712962925434113,
-0.17025253176689148,
0.7524465918540955,
0.4615364372730255,
-0.5008969306945801,
-0.2286994308233261,
-0.44654566049575806,
0.2768608331680298,
0.4204586446285248,
0.8055007457733154,
-0.4039508104324341,
0.2847629487514496,
0.5004562139511108,
0.7009587287902832,
0.4854625463485718,
-0.3126429617404938,
0.595211923122406,
-0.5494193434715271,
0.18180152773857117,
-0.06491570174694061,
0.6648867726325989,
0.47116270661354065,
-0.18393534421920776,
0.7180881500244141,
0.5083187818527222,
-0.24631299078464508,
-0.4283558130264282,
0.5704941153526306,
-0.2092527449131012,
-0.37576746940612793,
0.9381839036941528,
-0.15097962319850922,
-0.4751356244087219,
-0.5053220987319946,
-0.16371996700763702,
0.3878509998321533,
-0.11657413840293884,
0.6689634323120117,
0.5997910499572754,
-0.5508407950401306,
-0.18382538855075836,
0.08011547476053238,
0.04286496713757515,
0.4021313190460205,
-0.18139056861400604,
-0.18129195272922516,
0.3668712079524994,
0.7088714241981506,
0.6299435496330261,
0.5815185904502869,
-0.45400312542915344,
0.23886652290821075,
-0.08206136524677277,
-0.05690562725067139,
-0.05831063538789749,
-0.2320248782634735,
-0.3716321587562561,
0.5093232989311218,
0.07596254348754883,
-0.5634075999259949
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14443v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14443v1
|
Language Models Can Reduce Asymmetry in Information Markets
| 2024-03-21T14:48:37 | 2024-03-21T14:48:37 |
Nasim Rahaman, Martin Weiss, Manuel Wüthrich, Yoshua Bengio, Li Erran Li, Chris Pal, Bernhard Schölkopf
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.GT, cs.LG, cs.MA, cs.SI
|
This work addresses the buyer's inspection paradox for information markets.
The paradox is that buyers need to access information to determine its value,
while sellers need to limit access to prevent theft. To study this, we
introduce an open-source simulated digital marketplace where intelligent
agents, powered by language models, buy and sell information on behalf of
external participants. The central mechanism enabling this marketplace is the
agents' dual capabilities: they not only have the capacity to assess the
quality of privileged information but also come equipped with the ability to
forget. This ability to induce amnesia allows vendors to grant temporary access
to proprietary information, significantly reducing the risk of unauthorized
retention while enabling agents to accurately gauge the information's relevance
to specific queries or tasks. To perform well, agents must make rational
decisions, strategically explore the marketplace through generated sub-queries,
and synthesize answers from purchased information. Concretely, our experiments
(a) uncover biases in language models leading to irrational behavior and
evaluate techniques to mitigate these biases, (b) investigate how price affects
demand in the context of informational goods, and (c) show that inspection and
higher budgets both lead to higher quality outcomes.
|
[
-0.25867509841918945,
-0.6251238584518433,
0.4321330487728119,
-0.11090905219316483,
-0.026579806581139565,
-0.03753022104501724,
-0.09590200334787369,
-0.761724054813385,
0.15110385417938232,
0.8209960460662842,
-0.5738094449043274,
-0.16401760280132294,
-0.21624667942523956,
-0.24895595014095306,
-0.6030823588371277,
0.9263747334480286,
-0.03243807703256607,
-0.1430889517068863,
-0.23081637918949127,
0.02349332720041275,
-0.05758411064743996,
-0.5045825242996216,
-0.7119947671890259,
-0.15968292951583862,
0.03747859224677086,
0.2674606144428253,
1.231476902961731,
0.7746390700340271,
0.29198265075683594,
0.386725515127182,
0.23107531666755676,
-0.07530049979686737,
-0.5077496767044067,
0.20182548463344574,
-0.6231690645217896,
-0.7863842248916626,
-0.250611811876297,
0.28766724467277527,
0.2057219296693802,
0.4120669364929199,
-0.3724035322666168,
0.2561868131160736,
-0.05663636326789856,
0.7477508187294006,
-0.7350335121154785,
0.4330403804779053,
-0.6486684083938599,
-0.2508734166622162,
-0.08732929825782776,
-0.520771324634552,
-0.5281182527542114,
-0.33803677558898926,
0.11199530959129333,
-0.7964935302734375,
0.14994525909423828,
0.283867210149765,
1.5602490901947021,
0.22164981067180634,
-0.483074426651001,
-0.5169078707695007,
-0.9660727381706238,
0.6233361959457397,
-0.4513719975948334,
0.5615856647491455,
0.7159734964370728,
0.3812333941459656,
0.04831051453948021,
-0.6950196027755737,
-0.7432748675346375,
-0.022576462477445602,
0.10123026371002197,
0.23176231980323792,
-0.5309025645256042,
-0.01874230057001114,
0.2678404748439789,
0.3797842264175415,
-0.4374590516090393,
-0.17637020349502563,
-0.6278918385505676,
-0.13470491766929626,
0.4975706934928894,
0.255001038312912,
0.7476595640182495,
0.04651973024010658,
-0.4592559039592743,
-0.21006713807582855,
-0.654811680316925,
0.2732788324356079,
0.751186728477478,
0.1733907014131546,
0.17502270638942719,
0.702860951423645,
-0.25717487931251526,
0.372082382440567,
-0.059869952499866486,
-0.05639856308698654,
0.060810744762420654,
-0.48125773668289185,
-0.14050528407096863,
-0.03015115298330784,
0.42361506819725037,
0.5420272350311279,
0.09979590028524399,
-0.09899944812059402,
-0.39524635672569275,
0.24430790543556213,
0.33673521876335144,
-0.6386386752128601,
-0.12654279172420502,
0.41020137071609497,
-0.7153733372688293,
-0.06205547973513603,
0.2792598605155945,
-0.7599470615386963,
-0.4116916358470917,
-0.4901535212993622,
0.6196359395980835,
-0.1577751636505127,
-0.42994222044944763,
0.40958136320114136,
-0.6087622046470642,
0.018293697386980057,
0.15407182276248932,
-0.640908420085907,
0.7604297399520874,
0.5106066465377808,
0.613670825958252,
0.3505651354789734,
-0.3233232796192169,
-0.21676625311374664,
0.28038203716278076,
-0.2410668134689331,
0.6289049983024597,
-0.4503997564315796,
0.013813076540827751,
-0.16357573866844177,
-0.1023775041103363,
-0.008302324451506138,
-0.7440004348754883,
0.07099096477031708,
-1.1078195571899414,
0.22273580729961395,
-0.34177911281585693,
-0.24144913256168365,
-0.2458927184343338,
0.5041079521179199,
-0.8381934762001038,
0.37339502573013306,
0.12254589796066284,
-0.8115652203559875,
0.3153493404388428,
-0.35807743668556213,
-0.0013476720778271556,
-0.12744176387786865,
-0.19571933150291443,
-0.19111381471157074,
-0.024945782497525215,
0.009060743264853954,
-0.159661665558815,
-0.5416193008422852,
0.0584801509976387,
-0.30358508229255676,
-0.4089832305908203,
0.8186125159263611,
-0.4460003674030304,
0.875468373298645,
0.27481868863105774,
-0.6264039874076843,
-0.14206179976463318,
-0.4742441177368164,
-0.1887529492378235,
0.3179596960544586,
-0.23199714720249176,
-0.5946483612060547,
0.20618626475334167,
0.002476008143275976,
0.22519467771053314,
0.2265276312828064,
-0.3488381803035736,
0.1327221691608429,
-0.7541813254356384,
0.2736063003540039,
0.963498592376709,
-0.09754876792430878,
0.5390459299087524,
-0.8096500039100647,
0.5935357809066772,
0.24759013950824738,
0.37938594818115234,
0.011825746856629848,
-0.3701713979244232,
-0.9907494783401489,
-0.20055940747261047,
0.24821417033672333,
0.6632506251335144,
-0.9781839847564697,
-0.02167140692472458,
-0.09516306221485138,
-0.1792420744895935,
-0.820610761642456,
-0.11852465569972992,
0.10137996822595596,
0.12739461660385132,
-0.02388162910938263,
-0.5239517688751221,
-0.20606525242328644,
-0.8949778079986572,
-0.6017647385597229,
-0.3711511790752411,
-0.07300280779600143,
0.417478084564209,
0.11901506781578064,
-0.425651878118515,
0.9409526586532593,
-0.4311371445655823,
-0.3434959650039673,
-0.13620583713054657,
0.09268026053905487,
0.21792371571063995,
0.08413513749837875,
0.3341144919395447,
-0.8689044117927551,
-0.1594053953886032,
-0.06730812042951584,
-0.5911213755607605,
-0.07578213512897491,
-0.4257715046405792,
-0.17342747747898102,
0.5463116765022278,
0.3549782931804657,
-0.9142356514930725,
0.717494547367096,
0.17020884156227112,
-0.6452903151512146,
0.4612642526626587,
-0.4612266719341278,
0.26298508048057556,
-0.7898478507995605,
0.0821455642580986,
-0.3869771361351013,
-0.07719799876213074,
-0.527621865272522,
0.3128669261932373,
0.05706173554062843,
-0.12630651891231537,
-0.17745745182037354,
0.7334228754043579,
-0.6609542369842529,
-0.26857608556747437,
-0.5188204646110535,
0.30189573764801025,
0.20777422189712524,
0.2699260711669922,
-0.10999349504709244,
0.7530887722969055,
0.496272474527359,
-0.6600226759910583,
0.13565441966056824,
0.10995940119028091,
-0.5219227075576782,
0.5368353128433228,
-0.28271475434303284,
-0.15499207377433777,
-0.4929930567741394,
-0.08326798677444458,
-0.8208450675010681,
-0.13566552102565765,
0.4956623911857605,
-0.40005049109458923,
0.12348328530788422,
0.2616058886051178,
-0.6604950428009033,
-0.30468255281448364,
-0.36358001828193665,
0.3634693920612335,
0.3773757815361023,
-0.5810462832450867,
0.6964602470397949,
0.49013403058052063,
-0.3661099076271057,
-0.8201068639755249,
-0.7259718179702759,
0.06792157888412476,
-0.047033946961164474,
-0.7457634210586548,
-0.21176977455615997,
-0.14728884398937225,
-0.7404707074165344,
0.3205207288265228,
-0.08817398548126221,
-0.15264980494976044,
0.31071406602859497,
0.07996509969234467,
0.3094852566719055,
-0.22564421594142914,
0.3204265534877777,
0.09509743005037308,
-0.36763495206832886,
0.2424134910106659,
-0.6983001828193665,
0.5920006036758423,
-0.08364339172840118,
-0.6019300222396851,
-0.4308101236820221,
0.40822091698646545,
0.8081600069999695,
-0.2935711145401001,
0.87502521276474,
-0.23626123368740082,
-0.3695838451385498,
-0.4065391719341278,
-0.7096940279006958,
-0.4895888566970825,
-0.5697676539421082,
0.21765990555286407,
-0.37153342366218567,
-0.4944317638874054,
0.5409097075462341,
0.17289331555366516,
-0.2142312079668045,
0.2299712598323822,
0.47394517064094543,
0.10087180882692337,
1.0565391778945923,
0.6773647665977478,
0.10103612393140793,
0.3444535732269287,
0.02381567470729351,
0.7732133269309998,
-0.17403170466423035,
-0.2561851143836975,
-0.5311659574508667,
-0.27672773599624634,
-0.3837648034095764,
-0.47765427827835083,
0.24006398022174835,
0.09527435898780823,
-0.3876302242279053,
0.0008012080215848982,
-0.33437585830688477,
0.778651237487793,
0.8708088994026184,
0.37301668524742126,
0.6922731399536133,
0.009912584908306599,
0.11623339354991913,
-0.10277806967496872,
-0.4294016361236572,
-0.6996311545372009,
1.1176246404647827,
0.30420807003974915,
0.9686855673789978,
0.22805218398571014,
0.26483795046806335,
0.08868357539176941,
0.11980658024549484,
-0.7542549967765808,
0.5297966599464417,
0.24775682389736176,
-0.7555367350578308,
-0.17990301549434662,
-0.5026694536209106,
-1.0837687253952026,
0.16111570596694946,
-0.015473726205527782,
-0.7600842714309692,
0.5755594968795776,
0.18764322996139526,
-0.055044643580913544,
0.37473440170288086,
-0.538245677947998,
0.8731741309165955,
-0.3985879123210907,
-0.3310917615890503,
-0.40357014536857605,
-0.4299914836883545,
0.3346027731895447,
-0.21761441230773926,
0.43423885107040405,
-0.08630021661520004,
-0.2548414468765259,
0.3363748788833618,
-0.40868717432022095,
0.660913348197937,
0.09696817398071289,
0.38330525159835815,
0.3062363862991333,
0.5486928820610046,
0.56972336769104,
-0.03896138072013855,
-0.046818483620882034,
0.010128802619874477,
0.07350113242864609,
-0.49038779735565186,
-0.6010170578956604,
0.33464735746383667,
-0.96137934923172,
-0.7634959816932678,
-0.34640276432037354,
-0.5351202487945557,
0.04865485802292824,
0.27533671259880066,
0.25982218980789185,
0.08007539808750153,
-0.061920586973428726,
-0.06432735174894333,
0.49129077792167664,
-0.337163507938385,
0.05541887506842613,
0.8461030721664429,
-0.15029920637607574,
0.07909762114286423,
0.979858934879303,
0.2483191341161728,
0.5826072692871094,
0.1701560765504837,
0.2992728650569916,
-0.3110315203666687,
-0.3320774435997009,
-0.20434756577014923,
0.3295123875141144,
-0.9054722785949707,
-0.009096316061913967,
-0.9204429388046265,
-0.16934092342853546,
-0.30415377020835876,
-0.07076770067214966,
-0.3410462737083435,
-0.5205464959144592,
-0.22659073770046234,
-0.18714015185832977,
-0.03463861346244812,
0.6618126034736633,
-0.1532871127128601,
0.14625126123428345,
-0.5656589865684509,
0.3501809239387512,
0.5148115754127502,
0.283071905374527,
0.2609682083129883,
-0.17175087332725525,
-0.17142866551876068,
0.22608248889446259,
-0.3101014196872711,
-0.9830561876296997,
0.5386096239089966,
-0.2780715227127075,
0.6876741647720337,
0.7453195452690125,
0.5028509497642517,
0.4292922019958496,
-0.015023410320281982,
0.5052535533905029,
-0.04792199656367302,
-1.2124391794204712,
0.3724824786186218,
-0.5367340445518494,
0.0022928479593247175,
0.42848390340805054,
0.42221882939338684,
-0.585835874080658,
-0.9072147607803345,
-0.7028496265411377,
-1.25831139087677,
0.9719935655593872,
0.2156694382429123,
0.09928661584854126,
0.0380738265812397,
-0.05335194990038872,
0.050065603107213974,
0.6291030049324036,
-0.8913223743438721,
-0.044213563203811646,
-0.2378193438053131,
-0.1765255481004715,
0.24779215455055237,
-0.4387117922306061,
-0.1917717605829239,
0.12187252193689346,
0.7459355592727661,
0.10219112783670425,
0.23148494958877563,
0.025915639474987984,
-0.12085795402526855,
-0.18876302242279053,
0.3172089159488678,
0.31860142946243286,
0.6058745384216309,
-0.040491435676813126,
0.3107798397541046,
-0.4485493302345276,
-0.29117870330810547,
0.09014448523521423,
0.11142901331186295,
-0.4706055223941803,
-0.2893599569797516,
-0.23452293872833252,
0.5947484970092773,
-0.17491236329078674,
-1.2115414142608643,
0.8276480436325073,
-0.1537325382232666,
-0.00415594270452857,
-0.3752448260784149,
-0.061444241553545,
0.10554640740156174,
0.7481426000595093,
0.21459822356700897,
0.29210442304611206,
0.5008636713027954,
-0.938778281211853,
0.36053207516670227,
0.3064965605735779,
-0.22679656744003296,
-0.2374165654182434,
0.8179652094841003,
-0.19364869594573975,
-0.39197102189064026,
1.0686750411987305,
-0.22295652329921722,
-0.35751795768737793,
0.8068028092384338,
0.5901050567626953,
0.7663654088973999,
-0.2432832568883896,
0.25913864374160767,
0.054134123027324677,
0.8134546875953674,
-0.5151099562644958,
0.4877946674823761,
0.013335783034563065,
-1.010422945022583,
0.2761806845664978,
-0.11822004616260529,
-0.44576388597488403,
-0.13936273753643036,
-0.7451147437095642,
0.11700443923473358,
-0.3237524926662445,
-0.17776614427566528,
-0.3088424801826477,
-0.27304884791374207,
-0.7166932821273804,
-0.07554183155298233,
-0.07780756801366806,
0.6854442358016968,
-0.6604779958724976,
0.567317008972168,
0.23399092257022858,
-0.5447907447814941,
-0.5393958687782288,
0.25199633836746216,
0.21388404071331024,
-0.74106365442276,
0.6212283372879028,
0.3772541284561157,
-0.16640867292881012,
-0.2911878228187561,
-0.5916509032249451,
-0.9604383707046509,
0.8243212103843689,
0.5075783133506775,
-0.29044875502586365,
0.004063037224113941,
0.2768635153770447,
0.5259103775024414,
-0.08287450671195984,
0.32821813225746155,
0.6138720512390137,
0.46218276023864746,
0.03547687828540802,
-0.8464270830154419,
0.08117984235286713,
-0.5634642243385315,
-0.382402241230011,
0.24447830021381378,
-0.5933992266654968,
1.1172082424163818,
-0.23819267749786377,
-0.7580146789550781,
0.25151365995407104,
0.09122514724731445,
0.18235407769680023,
0.605057418346405,
0.5089134573936462,
0.3829135596752167,
0.9862232804298401,
-0.06165445223450661,
1.0525907278060913,
-0.41009199619293213,
0.2673867344856262,
1.1067328453063965,
-0.3571948707103729,
0.8510156273841858,
0.2792856693267822,
0.34747451543807983,
0.43185514211654663,
0.27629929780960083,
0.16602718830108643,
0.41951441764831543,
0.18951021134853363,
-0.22762660682201385,
-0.22617441415786743,
-0.3053968548774719,
-0.15530523657798767,
0.34074780344963074,
0.4266233444213867,
-0.3314812183380127,
0.008214318193495274,
-0.02554420754313469,
0.034898169338703156,
0.2329997569322586,
-0.14734141528606415,
0.6515328288078308,
-0.13225586712360382,
-0.49452871084213257,
0.2007281333208084,
0.10956012457609177,
0.16164931654930115,
-0.5151697993278503,
0.3851687014102936,
-0.22156526148319244,
0.47653380036354065,
0.08311786502599716,
-0.4112667739391327,
0.4567157030105591,
-0.36415037512779236,
-0.19887514412403107,
-0.3741537034511566,
0.6462069749832153,
-0.5127086639404297,
-0.26305222511291504,
0.6165381073951721,
0.49184590578079224,
0.09928623586893082,
-0.39247792959213257,
-0.7092859745025635,
-0.07674423605203629,
-0.1777087301015854,
-0.4800109267234802,
0.2768118679523468,
0.4124448299407959,
-0.2226789891719818,
0.898134708404541,
0.5167979598045349,
0.1810697317123413,
-0.040991123765707016,
-0.23530912399291992,
0.878847062587738,
-0.8883433938026428,
-0.9076186418533325,
-0.610668957233429,
0.5143117308616638,
-0.3591175079345703,
0.2255454659461975,
0.7282865047454834,
0.5786917805671692,
1.2799668312072754,
-0.03927840292453766,
0.7672801613807678,
0.581896185874939,
0.43738722801208496,
-0.47457826137542725,
0.9709935188293457,
-0.7207523584365845,
0.5361601114273071,
-0.03603703901171684,
-0.6547879576683044,
0.04262077435851097,
0.5254088044166565,
-0.2106533795595169,
-0.22104546427726746,
0.6274197101593018,
1.1007293462753296,
-0.05533893406391144,
0.1544337421655655,
0.22284795343875885,
0.5085719227790833,
0.14584222435951233,
0.509738028049469,
1.3105789422988892,
-0.4957644045352936,
0.7747423052787781,
-0.1316182166337967,
-0.3151799738407135,
-0.16378436982631683,
-0.2876654267311096,
-0.9832115769386292,
-0.4313725233078003,
-0.2661834955215454,
-0.6069702506065369,
-0.07652747631072998,
0.8856199383735657,
0.4276793599128723,
-0.5364246964454651,
-0.656308114528656,
0.2858893871307373,
0.3712019920349121,
-0.36347994208335876,
-0.2783780097961426,
0.012910766527056694,
-0.21893294155597687,
-0.5707876682281494,
0.19487924873828888,
0.7475088238716125,
0.31845831871032715,
-0.04719260707497597,
0.10378797352313995,
0.21399855613708496,
0.7600438594818115,
0.1421569138765335,
0.28313153982162476,
-0.6290698647499084,
0.0672648623585701,
0.05603007599711418,
-0.378675639629364,
-0.02945522591471672,
0.9231219291687012,
-0.5386547446250916,
0.9602116346359253,
0.5896257758140564,
0.6423302292823792,
0.36640506982803345,
0.04589840769767761,
0.7216484546661377,
-0.15217377245426178,
0.4783371686935425,
0.22003430128097534,
0.08180170506238937,
-0.07780821621417999,
-0.4438593089580536,
0.12955568730831146,
0.21648381650447845,
-0.36565956473350525,
-0.7159156799316406,
0.46376466751098633,
-0.5437638163566589,
-0.7802087068557739,
0.7153659462928772,
0.11800315976142883,
-0.3522244691848755,
-0.5544446706771851,
-0.16075916588306427,
-0.11726201325654984,
-0.3437773883342743,
1.2778035402297974,
0.6443795561790466,
0.4340320825576782,
-0.1791898012161255,
-0.5554211735725403,
0.28335827589035034,
0.06546718627214432,
-0.7551963925361633,
0.04840221256017685,
0.47493353486061096,
0.06049420312047005,
0.039654262363910675,
1.0885480642318726,
-0.11116921901702881,
0.3796197175979614,
0.25617438554763794,
-0.048127591609954834,
0.046811435371637344,
-0.4021685719490051,
-0.09160023927688599,
0.34267088770866394,
0.31627970933914185,
-0.013979318551719189
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14438v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14438v2
|
A Multimodal Approach to Device-Directed Speech Detection with Large Language Models
| 2024-03-21T14:44:03 | 2024-03-26T11:02:32 |
Dominik Wagner, Alexander Churchill, Siddharth Sigtia, Panayiotis Georgiou, Matt Mirsamadi, Aarshee Mishra, Erik Marchi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS
|
Interactions with virtual assistants typically start with a predefined
trigger phrase followed by the user command. To make interactions with the
assistant more intuitive, we explore whether it is feasible to drop the
requirement that users must begin each command with a trigger phrase. We
explore this task in three ways: First, we train classifiers using only
acoustic information obtained from the audio waveform. Second, we take the
decoder outputs of an automatic speech recognition (ASR) system, such as 1-best
hypotheses, as input features to a large language model (LLM). Finally, we
explore a multimodal system that combines acoustic and lexical features, as
well as ASR decoder signals in an LLM. Using multimodal information yields
relative equal-error-rate improvements over text-only and audio-only models of
up to 39% and 61%. Increasing the size of the LLM and training with low-rank
adaption leads to further relative EER reductions of up to 18% on our dataset.
|
[
-0.7020437717437744,
-0.7146026492118835,
0.7150374054908752,
0.009506977163255215,
-0.17665508389472961,
-0.2603570818901062,
-0.3332754671573639,
-0.4497447907924652,
0.30102458596229553,
0.3396296501159668,
-0.4678458571434021,
-0.2945813536643982,
-0.5606630444526672,
0.06661676615476608,
-0.42106983065605164,
0.5390120148658752,
0.26533934473991394,
0.06542452424764633,
-0.05828879028558731,
-0.16773539781570435,
-0.5262557864189148,
-0.5638229846954346,
-0.8332788348197937,
-0.31191501021385193,
0.5275866985321045,
0.2653810977935791,
0.4707867205142975,
0.5976095795631409,
0.05291178822517395,
0.36913543939590454,
-0.09211263060569763,
0.3284740447998047,
0.17896956205368042,
0.25761494040489197,
0.277904748916626,
-0.29188254475593567,
-0.37423014640808105,
-0.17018817365169525,
0.5368252992630005,
0.45265552401542664,
-0.1018279492855072,
-0.056025970727205276,
0.012416329234838486,
-0.05768581107258797,
-0.5442748665809631,
0.17000451683998108,
-0.4192518889904022,
-0.08183129131793976,
-0.2591654360294342,
-0.3389054536819458,
-0.6461054086685181,
0.09247217327356339,
0.12548404932022095,
-0.4411049485206604,
0.0638185441493988,
-0.23213417828083038,
0.3696782886981964,
0.2784321904182434,
-0.7894776463508606,
-0.3673735558986664,
-1.030228853225708,
0.6424078941345215,
-0.33118391036987305,
1.0566710233688354,
0.5515140295028687,
0.04282490164041519,
0.09578701853752136,
-0.39652004837989807,
-1.1687034368515015,
-0.5090940594673157,
0.2190224975347519,
-0.12146168947219849,
-0.352859228849411,
0.3000449240207672,
0.500545084476471,
-0.03487085551023483,
-0.5750953555107117,
0.28108277916908264,
-0.248885378241539,
-0.33401215076446533,
0.5311872363090515,
-0.16748210787773132,
0.35511747002601624,
-0.07113196700811386,
-0.3466295301914215,
-0.567395031452179,
-0.535373330116272,
0.08921780437231064,
0.22291836142539978,
0.4710538387298584,
-0.23288720846176147,
0.4963637888431549,
0.12060665339231491,
0.6562663316726685,
0.1713186800479889,
-0.5028961896896362,
0.5208632946014404,
-0.4074283540248871,
-0.15123066306114197,
0.46367698907852173,
0.880699098110199,
0.12567679584026337,
0.15312567353248596,
0.11669151484966278,
-0.4363819360733032,
0.346443235874176,
0.037068843841552734,
-0.49114182591438293,
-0.10588180273771286,
0.2213866412639618,
-0.29069575667381287,
-0.09622955322265625,
-0.22824223339557648,
-0.5008381605148315,
-0.46319061517715454,
-0.6191897392272949,
0.6744264364242554,
-0.3913601338863373,
-0.48660990595817566,
0.022199317812919617,
-0.18989214301109314,
0.3586174547672272,
0.36716946959495544,
-0.885290801525116,
0.31385931372642517,
0.3062359392642975,
0.8573035001754761,
0.05141286179423332,
-0.09762423485517502,
-1.181705117225647,
0.3270401954650879,
-0.10047437995672226,
0.7351811528205872,
-0.6255766749382019,
-0.959209680557251,
-0.049485888332128525,
-0.03738800436258316,
-0.24023310840129852,
-0.5275326371192932,
0.6294207572937012,
-0.30242398381233215,
0.2241922914981842,
-0.1448344588279724,
-0.47283661365509033,
0.024942586198449135,
-0.05898797884583473,
-0.6260225176811218,
0.6651179790496826,
-0.5050934553146362,
-0.2658432126045227,
0.631964385509491,
-0.8087065815925598,
-0.776458740234375,
-0.25442904233932495,
-0.20694899559020996,
-0.31534603238105774,
-0.005835206713527441,
0.4534028470516205,
0.3337676525115967,
-0.06074745953083038,
0.10610993206501007,
-0.274095356464386,
0.026895985007286072,
0.07434823364019394,
-0.712557852268219,
0.6754442453384399,
0.3331201672554016,
-0.294303297996521,
0.25416553020477295,
-1.092282772064209,
-0.26556625962257385,
-0.1741430163383484,
-0.6440793871879578,
-0.47693610191345215,
0.0944819524884224,
0.43634140491485596,
0.24122530221939087,
-0.05404067784547806,
-0.8415495157241821,
0.10124734044075012,
-0.10834414511919022,
0.27609163522720337,
0.7984685897827148,
-0.2745511531829834,
0.4647018313407898,
-0.11852769553661346,
0.4828903079032898,
0.06720511615276337,
0.07744105905294418,
-0.4025130271911621,
-0.47477877140045166,
-0.7332599759101868,
-0.7472271919250488,
0.14031118154525757,
0.6575850248336792,
-0.9546828269958496,
0.36024710536003113,
-0.0011758663458749652,
-0.16719499230384827,
-0.47874972224235535,
0.247639000415802,
0.494597852230072,
0.48540547490119934,
0.28132981061935425,
-0.1744781732559204,
-0.6187873482704163,
-0.5649892091751099,
0.030854128301143646,
-0.46331462264060974,
-0.3573758006095886,
0.36266690492630005,
0.03263314813375473,
-0.2079053819179535,
0.8402190208435059,
-0.40004366636276245,
-0.5333218574523926,
-0.30209359526634216,
0.16666974127292633,
0.08510670065879822,
0.32143843173980713,
0.33111393451690674,
-1.0439940690994263,
-0.17388767004013062,
0.3963068723678589,
-0.6780998110771179,
-0.30403923988342285,
-0.13800562918186188,
0.7161792516708374,
0.04896829277276993,
0.8230550289154053,
-0.7852113842964172,
0.309995174407959,
0.38190415501594543,
-0.2919856011867523,
0.16420325636863708,
-0.381759375333786,
0.14512692391872406,
-1.1383614540100098,
-0.2677278220653534,
0.3983074426651001,
-0.28038859367370605,
-1.1110975742340088,
-0.2778974771499634,
0.04997409135103226,
-0.33514106273651123,
-0.5482968688011169,
0.7123304605484009,
-0.5519440770149231,
-0.15215088427066803,
-0.3920920193195343,
0.05536941811442375,
0.010432776995003223,
0.27732789516448975,
0.2351587414741516,
0.8804010152816772,
0.5357720851898193,
-0.906347393989563,
0.5375040769577026,
0.3557182848453522,
-0.040766797959804535,
0.7603994011878967,
-0.7613769173622131,
0.2733152508735657,
-0.16646185517311096,
0.11812080442905426,
-1.132564902305603,
-0.2207561433315277,
-0.1541389375925064,
-0.6312263607978821,
0.2952882647514343,
-0.0008504176512360573,
-0.6203482747077942,
-0.21236945688724518,
-0.2345631867647171,
0.3439845144748688,
0.4163416922092438,
-0.8947975635528564,
0.9121384620666504,
0.6241278648376465,
-0.18645605444908142,
-0.05425640568137169,
-0.4978094696998596,
0.11332462728023529,
-0.45626404881477356,
-0.6595480442047119,
0.1427503526210785,
-0.04530921205878258,
-0.15137717127799988,
-0.48494768142700195,
0.09003639221191406,
-0.17935362458229065,
-0.11645568162202835,
0.38680386543273926,
0.09588094055652618,
-0.16511684656143188,
0.5474228262901306,
0.032560400664806366,
0.001155681791715324,
-0.04039095342159271,
-0.111930251121521,
0.6614539623260498,
0.25097402930259705,
-0.5255483388900757,
-0.9424976706504822,
0.28482216596603394,
0.7862317562103271,
-0.5187171697616577,
0.2694310247898102,
0.9233266115188599,
-0.4266405701637268,
0.13976402580738068,
-0.6282773017883301,
-0.3742996156215668,
-0.5582215189933777,
0.2892228364944458,
-0.7651680111885071,
-0.6264184713363647,
0.27845221757888794,
-0.0047821360640227795,
-0.15936674177646637,
-0.051592566072940826,
0.6033225059509277,
0.02419423498213291,
1.4415018558502197,
0.6782253384590149,
-0.07278980314731598,
0.7277208566665649,
0.04776328057050705,
0.26020169258117676,
-0.8714908361434937,
-0.4566158354282379,
-0.5036636590957642,
0.01697283424437046,
-0.4383102357387543,
-0.3404972553253174,
0.8205815553665161,
-0.2903619110584259,
0.07360450178384781,
0.5032333135604858,
-0.31746357679367065,
0.19469811022281647,
0.8178008198738098,
0.32948142290115356,
0.27944430708885193,
-0.03549637272953987,
0.1472269594669342,
0.2003798931837082,
-0.41176092624664307,
-0.22735829651355743,
1.1049045324325562,
0.43832364678382874,
0.9392934441566467,
0.286285936832428,
0.7401243448257446,
0.34154319763183594,
-0.23107582330703735,
-0.9492579698562622,
0.6135998964309692,
-0.05804472789168358,
-0.36261364817619324,
-0.4483509361743927,
-0.217462420463562,
-0.9719052314758301,
0.3360375761985779,
-0.2977716326713562,
-0.5942959785461426,
0.5035589933395386,
0.31278619170188904,
-0.520791232585907,
0.03188282996416092,
-1.205416202545166,
0.6091636419296265,
-0.18256446719169617,
-0.18276536464691162,
-0.1399487555027008,
-0.2326160967350006,
0.19587908685207367,
-0.08583278954029083,
0.36645644903182983,
0.21323472261428833,
0.019159333780407906,
0.7478758096694946,
-0.2583701014518738,
0.7689487934112549,
-0.5802428722381592,
-0.22829864919185638,
0.1038656085729599,
-0.02878730557858944,
0.3718576729297638,
-0.18050655722618103,
0.09691577404737473,
-0.19537106156349182,
-0.11020617932081223,
0.1080356165766716,
-0.3738163411617279,
0.6730666756629944,
-0.7038848400115967,
-0.46016398072242737,
-0.1610233634710312,
-0.6462720036506653,
-0.29065749049186707,
0.15779688954353333,
0.029448291286826134,
0.8518100380897522,
-0.007838834077119827,
0.11862239986658096,
1.0211517810821533,
-0.2733519673347473,
0.6283188462257385,
0.2868099808692932,
-0.1842784434556961,
-0.14078257977962494,
0.9295145273208618,
-0.05468698963522911,
0.2833510637283325,
0.41534411907196045,
0.3766782879829407,
-0.8014125227928162,
-0.3789777159690857,
-0.6085065603256226,
0.09534357488155365,
-0.5775341391563416,
0.20336037874221802,
-1.048974871635437,
0.14052137732505798,
-0.6640141606330872,
0.0301557295024395,
-0.1659080535173416,
-0.09105346351861954,
-0.4962563216686249,
-0.041000254452228546,
0.39249736070632935,
0.4233431816101074,
-0.2926856279373169,
0.5664835572242737,
-0.6901478171348572,
0.7592567801475525,
0.9047537446022034,
-0.10821304470300674,
-0.25499507784843445,
-0.5306618213653564,
0.2421497106552124,
-0.07916045933961868,
-0.21025137603282928,
-0.8382115960121155,
0.5259310603141785,
0.5547284483909607,
0.548145055770874,
0.8125764727592468,
-0.06261400878429413,
0.5891696810722351,
-0.5878753066062927,
0.6337984204292297,
0.5587165951728821,
-1.0169992446899414,
0.7761203646659851,
-0.3708602786064148,
0.4234938323497772,
0.015785973519086838,
0.24010930955410004,
-0.35436782240867615,
-0.12284751236438751,
-0.2002589851617813,
-0.5776581764221191,
0.7332875728607178,
-0.2720582187175751,
0.27216997742652893,
-0.14282694458961487,
-0.4010464549064636,
-0.2696174085140228,
0.03721427917480469,
-0.7099279165267944,
-0.03758113831281662,
-0.042023271322250366,
-0.2715665102005005,
-0.12903670966625214,
-0.23230470716953278,
-0.043909333646297455,
-0.19379658997058868,
0.3441578447818756,
-0.1350756138563156,
0.32015007734298706,
0.028442712500691414,
-0.2654019594192505,
0.13841836154460907,
0.41171953082084656,
0.7698699831962585,
0.38320159912109375,
0.05370589345693588,
0.30959364771842957,
0.1750694364309311,
-0.39193078875541687,
0.3067343533039093,
0.1836898773908615,
0.1250339299440384,
0.2957294285297394,
0.30500558018684387,
0.9160730838775635,
0.118598572909832,
-0.7995172739028931,
0.6335098147392273,
-0.09435462951660156,
0.051783718168735504,
-0.4207356870174408,
-0.0568305142223835,
-0.05085165798664093,
0.43556851148605347,
0.3094484508037567,
-0.07721734791994095,
0.48586970567703247,
-0.6368546485900879,
0.36829718947410583,
0.5780922174453735,
-0.5337281227111816,
-0.4106665551662445,
0.795809805393219,
0.4119599759578705,
-0.5399265885353088,
0.22747831046581268,
-0.12517906725406647,
-0.3300503194332123,
0.5004613399505615,
0.5262137651443481,
0.7381277084350586,
-0.8665288686752319,
0.09020613878965378,
0.039189863950014114,
0.1636933982372284,
0.16432034969329834,
0.2716820240020752,
-0.4484853148460388,
-0.8214805722236633,
-0.2953914701938629,
-0.5303333401679993,
-0.2779947519302368,
0.3185775876045227,
-0.6280717253684998,
0.6019042730331421,
-0.43697646260261536,
-0.3205052614212036,
0.5613085031509399,
-0.7129036784172058,
-0.6046682596206665,
0.11773204058408737,
0.40139880776405334,
0.3981315493583679,
-0.8626506924629211,
1.059391736984253,
0.6819930672645569,
-0.15335486829280853,
-0.583935022354126,
-0.1695808321237564,
0.4577684700489044,
-0.8704364895820618,
0.7879754900932312,
0.14872968196868896,
-0.36940762400627136,
-0.16923940181732178,
-0.11030204594135284,
-0.44971948862075806,
0.6489115357398987,
0.28000491857528687,
-0.5667926669120789,
-0.12073060870170593,
-0.10267481207847595,
0.3288361728191376,
-0.10529143363237381,
0.18172191083431244,
0.5286992788314819,
0.403265118598938,
0.20378518104553223,
-1.6333730220794678,
-0.419350802898407,
-0.1138024851679802,
-0.01932765729725361,
0.42633652687072754,
-0.06524957716464996,
0.9766029119491577,
-0.25124701857566833,
-0.1846771091222763,
-0.24240000545978546,
0.41895046830177307,
0.14359891414642334,
0.6004683971405029,
0.9648191928863525,
0.3411761224269867,
0.38887569308280945,
0.05291134864091873,
0.9450643658638,
0.14462235569953918,
-0.07352450489997864,
0.9222705364227295,
-0.406995952129364,
0.9514580965042114,
0.6135146617889404,
-0.11214489489793777,
0.04453437402844429,
0.3337584435939789,
0.41695186495780945,
0.6347541213035583,
-0.099993035197258,
-0.7947397232055664,
-0.38528668880462646,
-0.44271546602249146,
-0.22912344336509705,
1.0595660209655762,
0.4819182753562927,
-0.2880517244338989,
-0.09413846582174301,
0.9012644290924072,
0.02109641022980213,
0.06313415616750717,
-0.3788008391857147,
1.074488878250122,
0.040675368160009384,
-0.21856966614723206,
0.5509522557258606,
-0.20726661384105682,
0.8714325428009033,
-0.5043092966079712,
-0.13831214606761932,
0.14369326829910278,
0.21442514657974243,
-0.07341445982456207,
-0.46594861149787903,
-0.02259337157011032,
0.11101064831018448,
-0.17415548861026764,
-0.3450222313404083,
0.6233265995979309,
-0.6029361486434937,
-0.4036329388618469,
0.30567502975463867,
0.458735853433609,
0.09497057646512985,
-0.1067817434668541,
-0.1383177936077118,
0.4607912600040436,
-0.03747422248125076,
-0.053770825266838074,
0.17523936927318573,
0.4297066926956177,
-0.03495476022362709,
0.7715628147125244,
0.9482215642929077,
0.0948108658194542,
0.29212498664855957,
0.18753935396671295,
0.8783410787582397,
-0.27297520637512207,
-0.6703306436538696,
-0.7582445740699768,
0.22603864967823029,
-0.03231695294380188,
-0.14758597314357758,
0.5764354467391968,
0.2526632249355316,
0.870270311832428,
-0.047509532421827316,
0.69195157289505,
0.013232728466391563,
0.5123475790023804,
-0.585334300994873,
0.35013556480407715,
-0.5189363360404968,
0.2858164608478546,
-0.3666836619377136,
-0.6632377505302429,
-0.20099641382694244,
0.7178770303726196,
-0.12705941498279572,
0.008188174106180668,
0.3022242486476898,
0.7321415543556213,
-0.2902115285396576,
-0.0633435770869255,
0.7160649299621582,
-0.02092481404542923,
0.6816219091415405,
0.3355391323566437,
0.774275541305542,
-0.12093974649906158,
0.4768151342868805,
-0.056150879710912704,
-0.41719838976860046,
-0.20050852000713348,
-0.4039594531059265,
-0.8542478084564209,
-0.830603837966919,
-0.19061335921287537,
-0.13328370451927185,
-0.10766398161649704,
1.063544750213623,
0.9134586453437805,
-0.6602140069007874,
-0.41983431577682495,
0.36151495575904846,
-0.09082088619470596,
0.03768250718712807,
-0.19380585849285126,
0.12065514922142029,
-0.07975009083747864,
-0.9028410911560059,
0.9359663724899292,
0.15911030769348145,
0.10586223006248474,
-0.09522692114114761,
-0.1267867386341095,
-0.33466437458992004,
-0.07602281868457794,
1.108335018157959,
0.3741392195224762,
-0.6831417679786682,
-0.5683077573776245,
0.03517484664916992,
0.29244500398635864,
-0.15639027953147888,
0.6328970193862915,
-0.8851322531700134,
0.9454904794692993,
0.2989591956138611,
0.6156235933303833,
0.519810676574707,
-0.29089435935020447,
0.49365904927253723,
-0.8093779683113098,
0.5350906252861023,
0.14332236349582672,
0.38281282782554626,
0.2728821039199829,
-0.14247912168502808,
0.02432936802506447,
0.15111756324768066,
-0.3259492814540863,
-1.0383938550949097,
0.31815221905708313,
-1.1723705530166626,
0.07025253772735596,
1.2664873600006104,
0.16233570873737335,
-0.032741378992795944,
-0.338468074798584,
-0.4903765320777893,
0.14930610358715057,
-0.6676411628723145,
0.47461825609207153,
0.37653252482414246,
-0.379761278629303,
-0.5232459902763367,
-0.4464346468448639,
0.4261455833911896,
0.021443262696266174,
-0.7847808599472046,
-0.07996635138988495,
0.7036457657814026,
-0.013721303083002567,
0.5356109142303467,
0.7407265305519104,
0.1625632792711258,
0.4199965298175812,
0.08247122913599014,
0.2882954478263855,
-0.13229097425937653,
-0.5654119253158569,
-0.5589186549186707,
0.08943457901477814,
0.20771481096744537,
-0.8376469612121582
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14427v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14427v1
|
Emergent communication and learning pressures in language models: a language evolution perspective
| 2024-03-21T14:33:34 | 2024-03-21T14:33:34 |
Lukas Galke, Limor Raviv
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
Language models and humans are two types of learning systems. Finding or
facilitating commonalities could enable major breakthroughs in our
understanding of the acquisition and evolution of language. Many theories of
language evolution rely heavily on learning biases and learning pressures. Yet
due to substantial differences in learning pressures, it is questionable
whether the similarity between humans and machines is sufficient for insights
to carry over and to be worth testing with human participants. Here, we review
the emergent communication literature, a subfield of multi-agent reinforcement
learning, from a language evolution perspective. We find that the emergent
communication literature excels at designing and adapting models to recover
initially absent linguistic phenomena of natural languages. Based on a short
literature review, we identify key pressures that have recovered initially
absent human patterns in emergent communication models: communicative success,
efficiency, learnability, and other psycho-/sociolinguistic factors. We argue
that this may serve as inspiration for how to design language models for
language acquisition and language evolution research.
|
[
-0.3009202182292938,
-0.7291433811187744,
0.37031319737434387,
0.28527936339378357,
-0.08101710677146912,
0.4668217599391937,
-0.3479052782058716,
-0.897064745426178,
0.1368921548128128,
0.2219972014427185,
-0.4500247836112976,
0.15552140772342682,
-0.47643834352493286,
0.23569805920124054,
-0.11800749599933624,
0.9969348907470703,
0.288661390542984,
-0.16279800236225128,
-0.10523030161857605,
-0.06509708613157272,
-0.1832088828086853,
-0.521171510219574,
-0.9241735935211182,
-0.5520216822624207,
0.47124433517456055,
0.1971322000026703,
0.5996960997581482,
0.42008131742477417,
0.31195688247680664,
0.33621713519096375,
-0.4341220557689667,
0.14605656266212463,
-0.328825443983078,
0.44721099734306335,
-0.20388875901699066,
-0.19027411937713623,
0.1837136149406433,
0.062230031937360764,
0.7689417600631714,
0.9260631799697876,
-0.21094217896461487,
-0.12905965745449066,
0.5594772696495056,
0.6697514653205872,
-0.3246723711490631,
0.25399795174598694,
-0.3539228141307831,
-0.007730862591415644,
-0.08155438303947449,
-0.20177443325519562,
-0.6245817542076111,
-0.29497459530830383,
0.5534012913703918,
-0.5142001509666443,
0.13647975027561188,
-0.0451752245426178,
0.6248675584793091,
-0.01054800022393465,
-0.4980320632457733,
-0.45366957783699036,
-1.2305283546447754,
0.5604292750358582,
-0.24297533929347992,
0.359025776386261,
-0.086089588701725,
0.171059250831604,
-0.2211906611919403,
-0.4881955683231354,
-0.2275538146495819,
-0.46210816502571106,
0.04392065852880478,
0.201639786362648,
-0.14934229850769043,
0.05338112637400627,
-0.02061280980706215,
0.11763349920511246,
-0.35987406969070435,
0.3713330328464508,
-0.45391467213630676,
0.05732586607336998,
0.44896200299263,
-0.19141562283039093,
0.4929294288158417,
-0.09710808843374252,
-0.5266469120979309,
-0.21360249817371368,
-0.7588599920272827,
0.2289634495973587,
0.47747543454170227,
0.5210018754005432,
-0.2445363700389862,
-0.09723298996686935,
0.030434010550379753,
0.5012367367744446,
-0.19039946794509888,
0.017002923414111137,
0.21978852152824402,
-0.2217167168855667,
0.3495793044567108,
-0.08077766746282578,
0.6544841527938843,
-0.15825794637203217,
0.2775946855545044,
-0.15947288274765015,
-0.16946744918823242,
-0.10669595748186111,
0.4386709928512573,
-0.4354771673679352,
-0.28121429681777954,
-0.08854173123836517,
-0.4963931143283844,
-0.5325345993041992,
0.2140168696641922,
-0.7856016159057617,
-0.5244126915931702,
0.020412197336554527,
0.2525245249271393,
-0.2397998720407486,
-0.9083614945411682,
-0.20086680352687836,
-0.2546791434288025,
0.33211296796798706,
0.3745732009410858,
-1.0897899866104126,
0.4377736747264862,
0.4718270003795624,
0.622418999671936,
-0.05488308519124985,
-0.5379518866539001,
-0.16652558743953705,
-0.2805740237236023,
-0.4559101462364197,
0.90076744556427,
-0.35938483476638794,
-0.38495776057243347,
0.024778688326478004,
-0.005439115222543478,
-0.14140206575393677,
-0.4773244857788086,
0.4371162950992584,
-0.47130030393600464,
0.13507714867591858,
-0.16232118010520935,
-0.3801329433917999,
-0.22341516613960266,
-0.08005240559577942,
-0.717767059803009,
0.7988696098327637,
0.06448821723461151,
-0.4638160467147827,
0.22382493317127228,
-0.8250382542610168,
-0.4722987115383148,
0.6024294495582581,
-0.2158389538526535,
-0.34567639231681824,
0.32921287417411804,
-0.19297100603580475,
0.10582377761602402,
-0.41756126284599304,
0.08736869692802429,
-0.38491883873939514,
0.0326288640499115,
0.5089910626411438,
-0.377545028924942,
0.9290792346000671,
0.22095362842082977,
-0.4334920346736908,
-0.15306061506271362,
-0.5954297780990601,
0.10796144604682922,
0.30552050471305847,
-0.6951552033424377,
-0.42043015360832214,
0.35783424973487854,
-0.06352290511131287,
0.5910658240318298,
0.058327533304691315,
-0.32630279660224915,
0.14350581169128418,
-0.2494073212146759,
0.5414571166038513,
0.7119344472885132,
0.32525914907455444,
0.45621463656425476,
-0.41486725211143494,
0.47738808393478394,
0.11831238865852356,
0.21741165220737457,
-0.024652564898133278,
-0.505741536617279,
-0.5193503499031067,
0.01845664717257023,
0.14984895288944244,
0.45706772804260254,
-0.6876086592674255,
0.18158382177352905,
0.04947634041309357,
-0.559783399105072,
-0.8009781241416931,
0.18204133212566376,
0.4560750126838684,
0.016703201457858086,
-0.010223067365586758,
-0.2981381118297577,
-0.5355672240257263,
-0.7126542329788208,
-0.3682701885700226,
-0.48403576016426086,
0.21889232099056244,
0.2848031222820282,
0.27218693494796753,
-0.04954082518815994,
0.7923787236213684,
-0.09926234185695648,
0.298631489276886,
-0.5805054903030396,
0.4767058491706848,
-0.21848106384277344,
0.4884208142757416,
0.604177713394165,
-0.9609090685844421,
-0.4363398849964142,
0.01539093628525734,
-0.5880355834960938,
-0.15047141909599304,
-0.23157870769500732,
0.35682812333106995,
0.13694170117378235,
0.48205578327178955,
-0.5254808664321899,
0.11471101641654968,
0.5784569978713989,
-0.07926615327596664,
0.6985797882080078,
-0.3675802946090698,
-0.05708322301506996,
-1.075410008430481,
-0.052592433989048004,
-0.05436175316572189,
0.014945956878364086,
-1.1455360651016235,
0.08720306307077408,
-0.12286524474620819,
-0.07708796113729477,
-0.48699983954429626,
0.4357411563396454,
-0.8518773913383484,
-0.0733790248632431,
-0.47054165601730347,
0.13529598712921143,
-0.14820270240306854,
0.3989994525909424,
0.3305882215499878,
0.3326210379600525,
0.5900735259056091,
-0.9144390225410461,
0.08676756918430328,
-0.01631820946931839,
-0.2110992968082428,
0.3605886697769165,
-0.6494614481925964,
0.3966740667819977,
-0.23799671232700348,
0.15876148641109467,
-0.7791451215744019,
-0.1304454505443573,
0.23493283987045288,
-0.4332261085510254,
0.12464357167482376,
-0.18569432199001312,
-0.2603454291820526,
-0.24299871921539307,
-0.12545862793922424,
0.20193597674369812,
0.46339571475982666,
-0.5676266551017761,
0.18432389199733734,
0.4082404673099518,
-0.2945534884929657,
-0.25528284907341003,
-0.26943889260292053,
0.06950125098228455,
-0.10716484487056732,
-0.27082589268684387,
-0.037534840404987335,
-0.27267515659332275,
-0.4919779598712921,
-0.03747929260134697,
0.19528722763061523,
-0.20710815489292145,
0.5227104425430298,
0.18336768448352814,
0.2788391411304474,
-0.11220845580101013,
0.36155271530151367,
-0.16241435706615448,
0.0009898176649585366,
0.0878826379776001,
-0.5532311797142029,
0.37174317240715027,
-0.2888045907020569,
-0.06773094832897186,
0.03781937062740326,
0.4602106511592865,
0.5123639702796936,
-0.09759362041950226,
1.0523284673690796,
0.40771791338920593,
-0.27562880516052246,
-0.23356547951698303,
-0.20897620916366577,
-0.35736986994743347,
-0.44844502210617065,
0.3271471858024597,
-0.3758554756641388,
-0.8124037981033325,
0.24479682743549347,
-0.4218856394290924,
0.08049438893795013,
0.40152546763420105,
0.41145059466362,
0.06144465506076813,
0.9493354558944702,
0.7801678776741028,
0.15015006065368652,
0.8603270053863525,
0.14962689578533173,
0.015688052400946617,
-0.6392064690589905,
-0.2680300176143646,
-0.6771020293235779,
0.005942517425864935,
-0.7887911200523376,
-0.03984323516488075,
0.18948863446712494,
0.1561373919248581,
0.1026555746793747,
0.22616098821163177,
-0.3531832993030548,
0.4027143716812134,
0.6338502168655396,
-0.12901072204113007,
0.2959004342556,
-0.21801729500293732,
-0.10949793457984924,
0.09276324510574341,
-0.7513386011123657,
-0.526620090007782,
0.9169707894325256,
0.2741122245788574,
0.6118682026863098,
0.4392675757408142,
0.7730236053466797,
0.17642812430858612,
0.2760885953903198,
-0.596290111541748,
0.13425637781620026,
0.3025909662246704,
-0.8366177082061768,
-0.19580043852329254,
-0.5761445164680481,
-1.377743124961853,
0.46544593572616577,
-0.5699529051780701,
-0.9926672577857971,
0.4541333317756653,
-0.1779996007680893,
-0.30638769268989563,
0.26082277297973633,
-0.8289445638656616,
0.6969639658927917,
-0.20376987755298615,
-0.05500589683651924,
-0.1376294195652008,
-0.930709719657898,
0.32400766015052795,
-0.11760403960943222,
0.4704032242298126,
0.1958479881286621,
0.05675317719578743,
0.8938866257667542,
-0.11083763092756271,
0.9358310699462891,
0.07323005050420761,
-0.1728685349225998,
0.6135172247886658,
0.07117000967264175,
0.4585387110710144,
-0.15115998685359955,
0.19046485424041748,
-0.2400769293308258,
0.00569350877776742,
-0.514576256275177,
-0.5749085545539856,
0.21458177268505096,
-1.078797459602356,
-0.29206782579421997,
-0.4049646854400635,
-0.3743497133255005,
-0.05128003656864166,
0.21576499938964844,
0.26066529750823975,
0.43691760301589966,
-0.6693599820137024,
0.12427233159542084,
0.6960123777389526,
-0.04998089373111725,
0.638198733329773,
0.8279881477355957,
-0.1190781220793724,
-0.16473354399204254,
0.993181049823761,
-0.08554105460643768,
0.7830907106399536,
0.2556452453136444,
0.24024760723114014,
-0.13098128139972687,
-0.5231578350067139,
-0.20113736391067505,
0.23890608549118042,
-0.5669413805007935,
0.32406970858573914,
-0.45445355772972107,
-0.670043408870697,
-0.47188255190849304,
0.04434698447585106,
-0.4866970181465149,
-0.2153608500957489,
-0.27440813183784485,
0.013989465311169624,
-0.013921599835157394,
1.5403131246566772,
-0.3759806156158447,
0.1255243718624115,
-0.9649341106414795,
-0.13869830965995789,
0.40637093782424927,
0.04460969939827919,
0.06018928810954094,
-0.3956049680709839,
-0.42190706729888916,
0.1093425378203392,
-0.5658363103866577,
-1.1263326406478882,
0.21744093298912048,
0.30831629037857056,
0.5904602408409119,
0.5999985933303833,
0.11911352723836899,
0.025245491415262222,
-0.2693757116794586,
0.4624033272266388,
0.14957229793071747,
-0.6126588582992554,
0.3374459743499756,
-0.2532961666584015,
0.16735821962356567,
0.13003407418727875,
0.5177046060562134,
-0.8774332404136658,
-0.3309308886528015,
-1.036620020866394,
-0.5158154964447021,
0.5935732126235962,
0.004807469435036182,
-0.022555368021130562,
0.0796377882361412,
0.2390090525150299,
0.2243628203868866,
0.13964389264583588,
-1.0329675674438477,
-0.10214583575725555,
0.18948955833911896,
0.10464823991060257,
-0.4088769853115082,
-0.1159774512052536,
-0.09409601986408234,
-0.14088112115859985,
0.2291078418493271,
0.006544487085193396,
0.27491775155067444,
0.041447799652814865,
-0.310093492269516,
-0.3641101121902466,
0.7618820667266846,
0.6668013334274292,
0.33997437357902527,
-0.0054946294985711575,
0.2527552843093872,
-0.1420508325099945,
-0.5370040535926819,
0.6621502041816711,
0.07333029806613922,
-0.1373763531446457,
-0.13356910645961761,
0.45393505692481995,
1.0133171081542969,
0.3951665759086609,
-0.40961605310440063,
0.13789527118206024,
-0.15006455779075623,
-0.3295876979827881,
-0.05663815885782242,
-0.0025783057790249586,
0.08857761323451996,
0.39087849855422974,
0.48750966787338257,
0.40001824498176575,
-0.2023068070411682,
-0.9728648066520691,
0.134379580616951,
0.23187728226184845,
-0.5112000107765198,
-0.6783668994903564,
0.3723951280117035,
0.43862292170524597,
-0.7262248396873474,
0.47374027967453003,
-0.507541298866272,
-0.6117701530456543,
0.321501225233078,
0.7263818979263306,
0.9646645784378052,
-0.3739049434661865,
0.534858226776123,
-0.026661721989512444,
0.5219315886497498,
-0.14696836471557617,
0.0819258913397789,
-0.10848159343004227,
-0.9028728604316711,
-0.21017387509346008,
-0.303943395614624,
-0.7006112933158875,
0.11593564599752426,
-0.6480275988578796,
0.12456537783145905,
-0.3035723865032196,
0.1293325126171112,
0.11384286731481552,
0.27541977167129517,
-0.4537762403488159,
-0.13645035028457642,
0.3536916673183441,
0.6692381501197815,
-1.1287394762039185,
0.6934688687324524,
0.8302156925201416,
-0.4795711040496826,
-0.7231147885322571,
-0.00044000038178637624,
0.036914579570293427,
-0.35087743401527405,
0.5529768466949463,
0.04896675422787666,
-0.12373509258031845,
0.38017451763153076,
-0.4985504150390625,
-0.945158064365387,
0.6358771920204163,
0.2782752811908722,
-0.1496700644493103,
-0.08560089766979218,
-0.10371813923120499,
0.7364242076873779,
-0.605709433555603,
0.31965383887290955,
0.3118508458137512,
0.1654275357723236,
-0.0027203799691051245,
-0.7414862513542175,
-0.023631999269127846,
-0.35147470235824585,
-0.13683415949344635,
0.2720705568790436,
-0.6753533482551575,
0.895347535610199,
-0.37183457612991333,
-0.4991879463195801,
-0.02029508166015148,
0.5969133973121643,
-0.036889661103487015,
-0.1065421774983406,
0.5470886826515198,
0.004899162799119949,
0.6776043772697449,
0.11440004408359528,
0.8974058032035828,
-0.10955539345741272,
0.27975010871887207,
0.7670625448226929,
-0.25042641162872314,
0.851361870765686,
0.2992764413356781,
-0.2405400425195694,
0.8671656847000122,
0.8125216960906982,
0.5687364339828491,
0.3702063262462616,
0.2600523829460144,
-0.31584399938583374,
-0.2485697865486145,
-0.10686314105987549,
-0.3041965663433075,
0.5377200245857239,
0.42957302927970886,
-0.13472534716129303,
-0.3197386860847473,
-0.020960304886102676,
-0.20943041145801544,
-0.15677329897880554,
0.1545204520225525,
0.9442970156669617,
0.04427684098482132,
-0.8590530753135681,
0.5026208162307739,
-0.37632063031196594,
0.29651203751564026,
-0.36686989665031433,
0.02243257500231266,
0.08132833242416382,
0.06289166957139969,
0.09074075520038605,
-0.5291025638580322,
0.010815226472914219,
-0.3140519857406616,
-0.09794119000434875,
-0.31289470195770264,
0.6756550669670105,
-0.5929359793663025,
-0.0484001599252224,
0.516798734664917,
1.038737416267395,
0.4015055000782013,
0.23184345662593842,
-0.8189160823822021,
0.043997157365083694,
-0.3208194375038147,
-0.25767451524734497,
0.550234854221344,
0.33491435647010803,
0.09908075630664825,
0.8378416895866394,
0.604499876499176,
0.34848183393478394,
0.07632412761449814,
-0.01852288469672203,
0.6417487859725952,
-0.573261022567749,
-0.5737448930740356,
-0.8022341728210449,
0.36454230546951294,
-0.10192614793777466,
-0.3774358034133911,
0.4434718191623688,
0.07901529222726822,
0.5124159455299377,
0.0750136598944664,
0.8902214765548706,
-0.0494568906724453,
0.5446527004241943,
-0.2706216275691986,
0.6684086918830872,
-0.3048207461833954,
0.04485388845205307,
-0.407660573720932,
-0.7712711691856384,
0.05604249984025955,
0.24375887215137482,
-0.09249719232320786,
0.21405689418315887,
0.9892749786376953,
0.34543877840042114,
0.251186341047287,
0.15390823781490326,
0.1260167509317398,
0.12463127821683884,
0.2748584449291229,
0.6968362331390381,
1.330933690071106,
-0.11534419655799866,
0.6384120583534241,
-0.0028297167737036943,
-0.3961799442768097,
-0.3810809552669525,
-0.5842479467391968,
-0.6656831502914429,
-1.0028555393218994,
-0.3059581518173218,
-0.3662131726741791,
0.10105520486831665,
1.148078203201294,
0.7974047064781189,
-0.4133208394050598,
-0.4323541820049286,
-0.29635483026504517,
0.35768911242485046,
-0.6383858323097229,
-0.24919992685317993,
-0.08994077891111374,
-0.5767082571983337,
-0.643645703792572,
0.47852298617362976,
0.26351824402809143,
0.5231700539588928,
-0.4066912531852722,
-0.393952339887619,
-0.3932240605354309,
0.2556867301464081,
0.4335416853427887,
0.976504385471344,
-0.42565032839775085,
-0.3335345685482025,
-0.21125370264053345,
-0.19233138859272003,
-0.05416267737746239,
0.943336009979248,
-0.594308078289032,
0.35485121607780457,
0.21127410233020782,
0.6223973035812378,
0.19035954773426056,
-0.2443506270647049,
0.7600350975990295,
-0.7249339818954468,
0.28670722246170044,
0.09185515344142914,
0.09875943511724472,
0.4440382719039917,
-0.10013920813798904,
0.20816850662231445,
0.5854451060295105,
-0.6120995879173279,
-0.8827527165412903,
0.6524220705032349,
-0.4096635580062866,
-0.3273329436779022,
1.0458542108535767,
-0.01087870728224516,
-0.24757014214992523,
-0.44740352034568787,
-0.07433002442121506,
0.2871103584766388,
-0.2799209654331207,
0.9576085209846497,
0.8759886622428894,
-0.05730563402175903,
-0.5497540235519409,
-0.5228962302207947,
0.8494105935096741,
0.34856531023979187,
-0.9111356735229492,
0.051570143550634384,
0.05928588658571243,
0.12484531104564667,
0.2982628643512726,
0.6258692145347595,
0.2650603950023651,
0.4120066165924072,
0.26397430896759033,
0.10254259407520294,
0.4741264879703522,
-0.5740914940834045,
-0.5210304856300354,
0.06000655144453049,
0.5290128588676453,
-0.018070539459586143
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14409v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14409v1
|
Locating and Mitigating Gender Bias in Large Language Models
| 2024-03-21T13:57:43 | 2024-03-21T13:57:43 |
Yuchen Cai, Ding Cao, Rongxi Guo, Yaqin Wen, Guiquan Liu, Enhong Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models(LLM) are pre-trained on extensive corpora to learn
facts and human cognition which contain human preferences. However, this
process can inadvertently lead to these models acquiring biases and stereotypes
prevalent in society. Prior research has typically tackled the issue of bias
through a one-dimensional perspective, concentrating either on locating or
mitigating it. This limited perspective has created obstacles in facilitating
research on bias to synergistically complement and progressively build upon one
another. In this study, we integrate the processes of locating and mitigating
bias within a unified framework. Initially, we use causal mediation analysis to
trace the causal effects of different components' activation within a large
language model. Building on this, we propose the LSDM (Least Square Debias
Method), a knowledge-editing based method for mitigating gender bias in
occupational pronouns, and compare it against two baselines on three gender
bias datasets and seven knowledge competency test datasets. The experimental
results indicate that the primary contributors to gender bias are the bottom
MLP modules acting on the last token of occupational pronouns and the top
attention module acting on the final word in the sentence. Furthermore, LSDM
mitigates gender bias in the model more effectively than the other baselines,
while fully preserving the model's capabilities in all other aspects.
|
[
-0.3045962154865265,
-0.8178479671478271,
0.726548969745636,
0.05055365711450577,
0.1672339141368866,
-0.13156552612781525,
-0.1909380704164505,
-0.17916327714920044,
-0.05092540383338928,
0.8025937676429749,
-0.6190399527549744,
-0.5206813812255859,
-0.6202151775360107,
0.12797977030277252,
-0.09062246233224869,
0.6355805397033691,
0.1499648094177246,
0.4383762776851654,
-0.35230377316474915,
-0.06632058322429657,
-0.7158423066139221,
-0.6783852577209473,
-0.428190141916275,
-0.3879695534706116,
0.4163988530635834,
0.29650062322616577,
0.5840261578559875,
0.6348481774330139,
0.2920721471309662,
0.24673953652381897,
-0.4304141104221344,
0.10497641563415527,
-0.5749427080154419,
0.14787466824054718,
-0.39687713980674744,
-0.6902762651443481,
-0.5288997888565063,
0.21447357535362244,
0.6984370350837708,
1.2137677669525146,
-0.03745923936367035,
0.3639121651649475,
0.11065486818552017,
0.7663112878799438,
-0.82813560962677,
0.16129891574382782,
-0.5696300268173218,
0.01939482055604458,
-0.275395005941391,
-0.15374891459941864,
-0.35705485939979553,
-0.267246812582016,
0.11931760609149933,
-0.12031133472919464,
0.3973104655742645,
0.08509138971567154,
0.32032132148742676,
0.29972195625305176,
-0.7152662873268127,
-0.021476753056049347,
-0.8760303854942322,
0.9649856090545654,
-0.7035402059555054,
0.5503796935081482,
0.512917160987854,
-0.12061751633882523,
-0.2289409041404724,
0.11588437855243683,
-0.35656681656837463,
-0.15818867087364197,
0.01703863963484764,
-0.15839308500289917,
-0.11831338703632355,
0.11878553777933121,
0.6061923503875732,
-0.20286886394023895,
-0.13263778388500214,
0.3856712579727173,
-0.4701700210571289,
-0.07199228554964066,
0.48385754227638245,
0.15721142292022705,
0.4142564535140991,
-0.015623611398041248,
-0.22638648748397827,
0.11164852231740952,
-1.0855809450149536,
-0.20986896753311157,
0.7320877909660339,
0.4579603672027588,
0.2830100953578949,
0.7456340193748474,
-0.06963340938091278,
0.39089348912239075,
0.13267576694488525,
-0.37589752674102783,
0.17716768383979797,
-0.14633318781852722,
-0.1965533047914505,
0.33849892020225525,
0.4067173898220062,
0.3725605905056,
0.09738299995660782,
-0.12627778947353363,
-0.10754895210266113,
0.17404906451702118,
0.3562907874584198,
-0.46747836470603943,
0.3931344747543335,
0.042907051742076874,
-0.4315573275089264,
-0.34343135356903076,
-0.304081529378891,
-0.677227258682251,
-0.7428505420684814,
-0.5771973729133606,
0.20606639981269836,
-0.0006199218914844096,
-0.3017808496952057,
0.02939990907907486,
-0.053350962698459625,
-0.10394002497196198,
0.0826316773891449,
-0.9704208374023438,
0.20072448253631592,
0.7747310996055603,
0.4994506239891052,
0.00604156544432044,
-0.20570224523544312,
-0.4753672778606415,
0.45051828026771545,
-0.45713257789611816,
0.386209636926651,
-0.48181167244911194,
-0.2283075898885727,
0.1181943416595459,
-0.17349618673324585,
-0.0673891231417656,
-0.6756677031517029,
0.6043422818183899,
-0.3273150622844696,
0.19744782149791718,
-0.5949839949607849,
-0.5557814240455627,
-0.07782504707574844,
0.026035316288471222,
-0.7110402584075928,
1.097373366355896,
-0.0813981145620346,
-1.0773158073425293,
0.4933525323867798,
-0.513102114200592,
-0.11075993627309799,
-0.5136159658432007,
-0.4399355351924896,
-0.2664094865322113,
0.22408762574195862,
0.2383124977350235,
0.3410213887691498,
-0.5080438256263733,
0.6120033860206604,
-0.2840019464492798,
-0.19224774837493896,
0.2614586055278778,
-0.407764196395874,
0.8452864289283752,
-0.3574366271495819,
-0.386698454618454,
0.12113356590270996,
-0.6453158259391785,
-0.6439656019210815,
-0.004589213524013758,
-0.02751043811440468,
-0.8509780168533325,
0.06907250732183456,
-0.28980332612991333,
0.36760038137435913,
-0.051589932292699814,
-0.588648796081543,
0.1251637190580368,
-0.28448963165283203,
0.019078059121966362,
1.163440465927124,
-0.22113071382045746,
0.9433106780052185,
-0.02796771563589573,
0.4676739275455475,
0.23723822832107544,
0.125544011592865,
0.2592732608318329,
-0.1788230538368225,
-0.6098368763923645,
-0.3534788191318512,
0.12010861933231354,
0.4370708167552948,
-0.5184105634689331,
0.43534615635871887,
-0.20323604345321655,
-0.1851404309272766,
-0.6239034533500671,
0.45070767402648926,
0.3292614817619324,
0.6866632103919983,
0.17081281542778015,
-0.15272660553455353,
-0.6027171015739441,
-1.2997431755065918,
-0.43633711338043213,
-0.01812722720205784,
0.04382455348968506,
-0.06256997585296631,
0.515116810798645,
-0.2581496238708496,
1.2259771823883057,
-0.729251503944397,
-0.6847136616706848,
-0.3220050036907196,
0.11108927428722382,
0.18211457133293152,
0.2564865052700043,
0.5971765518188477,
-0.503996729850769,
-0.049758121371269226,
-0.4886895418167114,
-0.5143299698829651,
-0.6130977272987366,
0.06082475185394287,
-0.41183948516845703,
0.22256147861480713,
0.713575541973114,
-0.6315670013427734,
0.39747413992881775,
0.25538530945777893,
-0.3616751730442047,
0.5919790267944336,
-0.010694267228245735,
-0.2384658008813858,
-0.6636499762535095,
0.11663629114627838,
0.10846953094005585,
-0.06844679266214371,
-0.686840832233429,
-0.14873658120632172,
-0.133377805352211,
0.24423010647296906,
-0.3172638714313507,
0.6442816257476807,
-0.4908846318721771,
-0.10866782069206238,
-0.1994020789861679,
0.293362021446228,
-0.16381946206092834,
0.4059809148311615,
-0.07470936328172684,
0.5683642625808716,
0.1941533237695694,
-0.5918932557106018,
-0.12623189389705658,
0.2848537564277649,
-0.3067309856414795,
0.7088342905044556,
-0.4040655195713043,
0.09250272810459137,
-0.7692158818244934,
0.24709433317184448,
-0.8670552968978882,
0.2434433102607727,
0.24231836199760437,
0.036230675876140594,
0.21005846560001373,
-0.08742667734622955,
-0.5128195285797119,
-0.2691692113876343,
-0.47445806860923767,
0.22314366698265076,
0.09014038741588593,
-0.28937390446662903,
0.507096529006958,
0.6218742728233337,
-0.2373925894498825,
-0.8077447414398193,
-0.5831854343414307,
-0.18945638835430145,
-0.29910874366760254,
-0.47028759121894836,
0.19686661660671234,
-0.1283930540084839,
-0.5881709456443787,
-0.3568355441093445,
-0.24253566563129425,
0.1427219957113266,
0.10927404463291168,
0.24174179136753082,
0.39692074060440063,
0.0678027868270874,
0.23723161220550537,
0.10967231541872025,
-0.3423205614089966,
0.23531056940555573,
0.01772855781018734,
0.6183653473854065,
0.4114709198474884,
-0.3047896921634674,
-0.03966391831636429,
0.3914070725440979,
0.5771352648735046,
-0.11842554062604904,
0.9650379419326782,
0.5653863549232483,
-0.36541348695755005,
-0.25856804847717285,
-0.8789911270141602,
-0.36815622448921204,
-0.42102986574172974,
0.5730203986167908,
-0.0038880016654729843,
-0.8745505809783936,
0.4157625436782837,
-0.14359033107757568,
0.0030577736906707287,
0.20317894220352173,
0.5123471021652222,
0.0632888600230217,
1.1899547576904297,
0.7919136881828308,
-0.4082176983356476,
0.3602500557899475,
-0.04759247973561287,
0.4256131052970886,
-1.2318035364151,
-0.021503107622265816,
-0.6260945200920105,
-0.3387395441532135,
-0.3940236270427704,
-0.44166329503059387,
0.46547847986221313,
0.07280846685171127,
-0.4024212062358856,
-0.062290627509355545,
-0.08458463847637177,
0.2522921860218048,
0.6050799489021301,
0.17454908788204193,
0.25448229908943176,
-0.07199269533157349,
-0.3407994210720062,
-0.39472338557243347,
-0.6644919514656067,
-0.5564086437225342,
1.0528839826583862,
0.6120235919952393,
0.6882681250572205,
0.17399172484874725,
0.45375242829322815,
0.2510511875152588,
0.20928438007831573,
-0.24101141095161438,
0.7300103306770325,
-0.24732188880443573,
-0.887568473815918,
-0.3792959749698639,
-0.3919174373149872,
-0.6960737109184265,
0.37303683161735535,
-0.2710280120372772,
-0.8672544360160828,
0.34156477451324463,
0.048511382192373276,
0.001804277882911265,
0.40510743856430054,
-0.31420496106147766,
0.5625863671302795,
-0.15981608629226685,
-0.7251990437507629,
-0.09473641216754913,
-0.45862165093421936,
0.45446568727493286,
-0.14143794775009155,
0.6170652508735657,
-0.42462244629859924,
0.11158762872219086,
0.6756606698036194,
-0.28411123156547546,
1.3178411722183228,
-0.2576919198036194,
-0.6505359411239624,
-0.30262067914009094,
0.1430453062057495,
0.3970905542373657,
-0.29185616970062256,
-0.18191055953502655,
0.15865282714366913,
-0.4018881916999817,
-0.17244672775268555,
-0.22010357677936554,
0.47940921783447266,
-0.6767085194587708,
-0.7345079779624939,
-0.3565931022167206,
-0.7283791303634644,
-0.264173686504364,
0.21630795300006866,
-0.03745494410395622,
0.17250090837478638,
-0.3493421673774719,
-0.06506915390491486,
0.737111508846283,
-0.542491614818573,
0.06993848085403442,
0.5744780898094177,
-0.3875110447406769,
0.004426145926117897,
0.2976424992084503,
0.35178789496421814,
0.40132129192352295,
0.2627526819705963,
0.24775642156600952,
-0.18768317997455597,
-0.01280245091766119,
-0.05586569011211395,
0.4231463372707367,
-0.8210914731025696,
-0.15109601616859436,
-0.6819308400154114,
0.03466157242655754,
-0.4891434907913208,
-0.04547156020998955,
-0.5053449273109436,
-0.18471097946166992,
-0.13599532842636108,
-0.38178855180740356,
0.03018328920006752,
0.46588435769081116,
-0.08886831253767014,
0.20982885360717773,
-0.3826889395713806,
0.49984994530677795,
0.2521495521068573,
0.20629198849201202,
0.17378497123718262,
-0.3254902958869934,
-0.033522676676511765,
0.17457208037376404,
-0.11161500215530396,
-0.8858050107955933,
0.4206157624721527,
-0.20531786978244781,
0.6998004913330078,
0.34926629066467285,
-0.0025466952938586473,
0.4738732874393463,
-0.4492867588996887,
0.6794871091842651,
0.1377001255750656,
-1.1140447854995728,
0.5019570589065552,
-0.4355926513671875,
0.25250786542892456,
0.38856738805770874,
0.3001343607902527,
-0.5139683485031128,
-0.555203914642334,
-0.2161552608013153,
-1.0282135009765625,
0.7792521119117737,
0.13393664360046387,
0.0689912885427475,
-0.17972786724567413,
0.2916839122772217,
0.1626250296831131,
0.40440642833709717,
-0.6349170207977295,
-0.39792510867118835,
0.6564059257507324,
-0.12947764992713928,
0.08904507011175156,
-0.7057242393493652,
-0.28339070081710815,
-0.3041538596153259,
0.8117286562919617,
0.030324552208185196,
0.1536893993616104,
0.06944584846496582,
-0.4164920449256897,
-0.18956680595874786,
0.47967788577079773,
0.6957560777664185,
0.8719059824943542,
-0.3031214773654938,
0.32706218957901,
0.3085658550262451,
-0.48165324330329895,
0.22090329229831696,
-0.2589241862297058,
-0.6990355253219604,
0.02276286669075489,
0.3985566198825836,
0.7808253169059753,
0.42230239510536194,
-0.5011094808578491,
0.45399320125579834,
0.2848068177700043,
0.052142031490802765,
-0.26857301592826843,
-0.049094926565885544,
0.26172539591789246,
0.42387694120407104,
0.40885040163993835,
-0.14882712066173553,
-0.026729745790362358,
-0.6550072431564331,
-0.24866917729377747,
0.5109522938728333,
-0.2705049514770508,
-0.00787628348916769,
0.7719752192497253,
0.14211063086986542,
0.09022384136915207,
0.5415406823158264,
0.1426059603691101,
-0.7324680685997009,
0.7402137517929077,
0.6820122003555298,
0.7738527655601501,
-0.4968342185020447,
0.2514646053314209,
0.4024072289466858,
0.6306139230728149,
-0.30836746096611023,
0.1686510145664215,
0.4408726096153259,
-0.9428220987319946,
-0.2602597773075104,
-0.37956658005714417,
-0.08657407015562057,
-0.037699297070503235,
-0.6193630695343018,
0.4914051592350006,
-0.1804736703634262,
-0.34603404998779297,
-0.020387444645166397,
-0.3265424370765686,
-0.8299214243888855,
0.03470596298575401,
0.3913973271846771,
0.6101951003074646,
-1.1981091499328613,
0.45773109793663025,
0.41488006711006165,
-0.3818165957927704,
-0.3422986567020416,
-0.06612102687358856,
0.28654032945632935,
-0.5667438507080078,
0.9899852871894836,
0.02626752108335495,
-0.17832565307617188,
-0.30318862199783325,
-0.47989439964294434,
-0.8164944648742676,
1.0730258226394653,
0.7358916401863098,
-0.6986733675003052,
-0.02713407762348652,
0.4999278485774994,
0.3790755867958069,
-0.31858569383621216,
0.3370649516582489,
0.7169055938720703,
0.5674226880073547,
-0.5237687826156616,
-0.9567241668701172,
0.14095745980739594,
0.18371140956878662,
0.17863908410072327,
0.1406211107969284,
-0.39776772260665894,
0.8014169335365295,
-0.061389729380607605,
0.1030626893043518,
-0.4088149666786194,
0.38705891370773315,
0.3572615385055542,
0.13991212844848633,
0.6265354752540588,
0.3302553594112396,
0.9424096941947937,
0.13861902058124542,
0.6518502235412598,
-0.019711894914507866,
0.2463146299123764,
1.2480852603912354,
-0.6439659595489502,
0.47259262204170227,
0.7764639258384705,
-0.18261894583702087,
0.2618345022201538,
0.005669310223311186,
0.24842458963394165,
0.3983471691608429,
0.40317878127098083,
-0.19572335481643677,
-0.151050865650177,
-0.4428425133228302,
-0.2356540560722351,
0.565625786781311,
0.2771299183368683,
-0.6647769808769226,
-0.17344863712787628,
0.23294873535633087,
0.4627280533313751,
0.1076497882604599,
-0.34761863946914673,
0.467780202627182,
0.20386172831058502,
-0.4158180058002472,
0.09913821518421173,
0.1895822137594223,
0.700761079788208,
-0.5068453550338745,
0.02545049972832203,
-0.337583065032959,
0.23038579523563385,
-0.15277273952960968,
-0.4859488606452942,
0.16800051927566528,
-0.09250034391880035,
-0.585451602935791,
-0.2844354808330536,
0.8926131129264832,
-0.7851000428199768,
-0.6132211089134216,
0.5209355354309082,
0.5616423487663269,
-0.30546626448631287,
-0.0833970233798027,
-0.23202350735664368,
0.2769439220428467,
-0.04616400972008705,
-0.0957430750131607,
0.3419332504272461,
0.1671556830406189,
-0.32154375314712524,
0.7112672328948975,
0.5306186079978943,
0.13093824684619904,
0.011063730344176292,
0.3063030540943146,
0.6759800314903259,
-0.5807793736457825,
-0.37369227409362793,
-0.9742825031280518,
0.28617629408836365,
-0.17453403770923615,
0.0049639069475233555,
0.7039377093315125,
0.4765549898147583,
0.5315595865249634,
-0.3205936849117279,
0.7338225245475769,
0.3324953317642212,
0.6523566246032715,
-0.4996236264705658,
0.7351758480072021,
-0.25374922156333923,
0.5864672660827637,
-0.7365854978561401,
-1.1287837028503418,
-0.41810742020606995,
0.6209126114845276,
-0.48347461223602295,
0.10982032865285873,
0.49586963653564453,
0.8476360440254211,
0.003916975576430559,
-0.17485052347183228,
0.17510773241519928,
0.5915780663490295,
0.2053692638874054,
0.2803744971752167,
0.6091403365135193,
-0.16106906533241272,
0.015549126081168652,
-0.32598939538002014,
-0.16032740473747253,
-0.17414826154708862,
-1.0410963296890259,
-1.0119712352752686,
-0.39125657081604004,
-0.5086246728897095,
-0.11395854502916336,
0.08336909115314484,
1.0237802267074585,
0.37265557050704956,
-0.25442859530448914,
-0.23343577980995178,
0.25225815176963806,
0.3917539417743683,
-0.12500354647636414,
-0.20590175688266754,
0.4679248332977295,
-0.027909116819500923,
-0.6478638648986816,
0.15551136434078217,
0.2422933131456375,
-0.5136560201644897,
-0.5622714161872864,
0.09253516793251038,
-0.43001577258110046,
0.13341379165649414,
0.8053849935531616,
-0.2655493915081024,
-0.6139098405838013,
-0.4376753866672516,
0.028265194967389107,
-0.1747322678565979,
-0.22051921486854553,
0.7895670533180237,
-0.5355755686759949,
0.452470600605011,
0.5375292897224426,
0.2394200712442398,
0.10535513609647751,
-0.1797942817211151,
0.903167724609375,
-1.0107802152633667,
0.18233436346054077,
-0.09793649613857269,
0.3812171518802643,
0.3837907612323761,
-0.48942914605140686,
0.6317559480667114,
0.10190864652395248,
-0.33655309677124023,
-0.9172921776771545,
0.17407801747322083,
-0.7000969648361206,
-0.3858410120010376,
1.3353201150894165,
0.3448236882686615,
-0.051226433366537094,
-0.21093647181987762,
-0.5065910220146179,
0.44722864031791687,
-0.10702068358659744,
0.9950234889984131,
0.8722078204154968,
0.18296577036380768,
-0.05427137389779091,
-0.9634447693824768,
0.27602753043174744,
0.5527883172035217,
-0.6169545650482178,
0.30323871970176697,
0.5550498366355896,
0.40496620535850525,
0.0485101118683815,
0.6890839338302612,
-0.11008632928133011,
-0.012356335297226906,
-0.27829739451408386,
0.38110145926475525,
0.16002190113067627,
-0.18681694567203522,
-0.20142067968845367,
-0.0640391930937767,
-0.18827591836452484,
0.17914502322673798
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14403v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14403v2
|
Adaptive-RAG: Learning to Adapt Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models through Question Complexity
| 2024-03-21T13:52:30 | 2024-03-28T06:45:11 |
Soyeong Jeong, Jinheon Baek, Sukmin Cho, Sung Ju Hwang, Jong C. Park
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models (LLMs), which incorporate the
non-parametric knowledge from external knowledge bases into LLMs, have emerged
as a promising approach to enhancing response accuracy in several tasks, such
as Question-Answering (QA). However, even though there are various approaches
dealing with queries of different complexities, they either handle simple
queries with unnecessary computational overhead or fail to adequately address
complex multi-step queries; yet, not all user requests fall into only one of
the simple or complex categories. In this work, we propose a novel adaptive QA
framework, that can dynamically select the most suitable strategy for
(retrieval-augmented) LLMs from the simplest to the most sophisticated ones
based on the query complexity. Also, this selection process is operationalized
with a classifier, which is a smaller LM trained to predict the complexity
level of incoming queries with automatically collected labels, obtained from
actual predicted outcomes of models and inherent inductive biases in datasets.
This approach offers a balanced strategy, seamlessly adapting between the
iterative and single-step retrieval-augmented LLMs, as well as the no-retrieval
methods, in response to a range of query complexities. We validate our model on
a set of open-domain QA datasets, covering multiple query complexities, and
show that ours enhances the overall efficiency and accuracy of QA systems,
compared to relevant baselines including the adaptive retrieval approaches.
Code is available at: https://github.com/starsuzi/Adaptive-RAG.
|
[
-0.2731386721134186,
-0.7141239643096924,
0.5057234168052673,
0.08631777763366699,
-0.037181224673986435,
0.47513818740844727,
-0.08915198594331741,
-0.32075873017311096,
0.313812792301178,
0.4749685525894165,
-0.28794440627098083,
-0.16097746789455414,
-0.3306095600128174,
0.11245417594909668,
-0.06730584055185318,
0.8187653422355652,
0.01124594360589981,
0.07007569074630737,
-0.3299790322780609,
-0.5470591187477112,
-0.5259723663330078,
-0.07106289267539978,
-0.7969200611114502,
0.01844693161547184,
0.6431497931480408,
0.45667433738708496,
0.5807205438613892,
0.18422645330429077,
0.30187270045280457,
0.31480252742767334,
-0.2794378697872162,
0.5819475054740906,
-0.41766780614852905,
0.4696061611175537,
-0.5122805237770081,
-0.8189234733581543,
-0.5557981133460999,
-0.5556728839874268,
0.6173675656318665,
0.5877059698104858,
-0.2986745238304138,
0.3821176290512085,
-0.027069872245192528,
0.9245383143424988,
-0.8262160420417786,
-0.06716424971818924,
-1.066697120666504,
-0.3505915403366089,
0.11692241579294205,
-0.34506961703300476,
-0.38725757598876953,
-0.19186480343341827,
0.023520635440945625,
-0.7226252555847168,
0.017883455380797386,
0.25815892219543457,
0.4255913197994232,
0.33872273564338684,
-0.33593854308128357,
-0.6332862377166748,
-0.8092392683029175,
0.5544376969337463,
-0.5599625110626221,
0.4371381998062134,
0.22148039937019348,
0.6529541611671448,
-0.4176712930202484,
-0.5595749020576477,
-0.4693359434604645,
-0.10752314329147339,
0.1651097983121872,
0.2052994668483734,
0.037396155297756195,
-0.21927203238010406,
0.2465505301952362,
0.1536436378955841,
-0.6202125549316406,
0.07553275674581528,
-0.32187873125076294,
0.250913143157959,
0.43876808881759644,
0.22627323865890503,
0.18443536758422852,
-0.11157677322626114,
-0.2211693674325943,
0.03209325298666954,
-0.35626721382141113,
0.3389780521392822,
-0.07950089126825333,
0.4221537411212921,
0.09291611611843109,
0.40652069449424744,
-0.4717189073562622,
0.819550633430481,
0.407528817653656,
-0.22476398944854736,
0.07763638347387314,
0.11769465357065201,
-0.190792977809906,
-0.282972127199173,
0.4059236943721771,
-0.19212044775485992,
-0.036606281995773315,
-0.23957408964633942,
-0.32558125257492065,
-0.5240866541862488,
0.46013835072517395,
-0.5545487999916077,
-0.10702976584434509,
0.42666199803352356,
-0.0771327093243599,
-0.18833941221237183,
-0.13682693243026733,
-0.7211579084396362,
-0.7018163204193115,
-0.08857230842113495,
0.8493226766586304,
-0.23911520838737488,
-0.15618373453617096,
0.25552767515182495,
0.1807616800069809,
0.4264061748981476,
0.51905357837677,
-0.48230576515197754,
0.4142780900001526,
0.5217829942703247,
0.6345421671867371,
-0.20026765763759613,
-0.07535472512245178,
-0.8620530366897583,
0.0917481780052185,
-0.4752260148525238,
0.8486608862876892,
-0.618500828742981,
-0.14176054298877716,
-0.17364367842674255,
0.004861701745539904,
-0.3130822479724884,
-0.6763573884963989,
0.7233725786209106,
-1.259907841682434,
0.23888318240642548,
-0.17570391297340393,
-0.4940970540046692,
-0.2706719636917114,
0.4786793887615204,
-0.6673427820205688,
0.9468424916267395,
0.29671362042427063,
-0.7158756852149963,
0.01206453237682581,
-0.6265166997909546,
-0.27717047929763794,
0.14750489592552185,
0.30802232027053833,
-0.5099260210990906,
0.2525293529033661,
0.3431828022003174,
0.20526665449142456,
-0.4144952595233917,
-0.014414725825190544,
-0.2778753936290741,
-0.39298850297927856,
0.39331477880477905,
0.051848698407411575,
0.5862805247306824,
0.2671014368534088,
0.04854947701096535,
0.3843269944190979,
-0.8464415669441223,
0.20818616449832916,
0.2713004946708679,
-0.5860975980758667,
-0.4302819073200226,
0.049256034195423126,
-0.3124595284461975,
0.07566723227500916,
0.15740640461444855,
-0.21853676438331604,
0.2805553078651428,
-0.6065783500671387,
0.02304428070783615,
0.6715312004089355,
0.046235937625169754,
0.583469808101654,
-0.5708776116371155,
0.8455008268356323,
-0.17062906920909882,
0.07912549376487732,
0.08371202647686005,
-0.22011873126029968,
-0.8989277482032776,
-0.1940104365348816,
0.4779839813709259,
0.7527852654457092,
-1.2468369007110596,
-0.011529168114066124,
-0.34826311469078064,
-0.7242632508277893,
-0.5577071309089661,
0.20454636216163635,
0.2772776484489441,
0.4250607192516327,
0.4239532947540283,
-0.23521041870117188,
-0.45298147201538086,
-0.2891986668109894,
-0.4821918308734894,
-0.35030597448349,
-0.2122921496629715,
0.6990475654602051,
0.19802191853523254,
-0.005038728937506676,
0.5891263484954834,
-0.5275756120681763,
-0.1523059457540512,
-0.09198173880577087,
-0.06594139337539673,
0.42991381883621216,
0.12252098321914673,
0.33234429359436035,
-1.0270843505859375,
-0.5977457165718079,
0.10621793568134308,
-0.4446732997894287,
-0.21727532148361206,
-0.08470793068408966,
-0.21769745647907257,
0.22494564950466156,
0.31430238485336304,
-0.4498445391654968,
-0.05840083956718445,
0.47878435254096985,
-0.31023937463760376,
0.5643585324287415,
-0.30465298891067505,
0.21529926359653473,
-1.190371036529541,
0.01871567964553833,
-0.2786017060279846,
-0.2828960418701172,
-0.6347821950912476,
0.32977160811424255,
0.2787317931652069,
-0.015192135237157345,
-0.22321417927742004,
0.7771908044815063,
-0.47352224588394165,
-0.2528742551803589,
-0.48169752955436707,
0.04871935024857521,
0.0766122117638588,
0.526111900806427,
-0.328418105840683,
0.8049054145812988,
0.44611412286758423,
-0.8479762077331543,
0.35802534222602844,
0.1744869500398636,
-0.2716836929321289,
0.654891312122345,
-0.43539053201675415,
0.24950124323368073,
-0.32890334725379944,
0.17590388655662537,
-1.0146623849868774,
-0.30278074741363525,
0.17328302562236786,
-0.5941868424415588,
0.3947363495826721,
-0.33114558458328247,
-0.23056237399578094,
-0.29475197196006775,
-0.19484661519527435,
0.4961090683937073,
0.43273279070854187,
-0.5531699061393738,
1.1939854621887207,
0.2553940713405609,
-0.3518286347389221,
-0.5884707570075989,
-0.0316876582801342,
-0.03619038686156273,
-0.10144486278295517,
-0.29520097374916077,
0.15720586478710175,
-0.30252334475517273,
0.02532394602894783,
-0.18178430199623108,
-0.26052170991897583,
-0.32068490982055664,
0.3836651146411896,
-0.05101823806762695,
0.17018777132034302,
-0.3004351854324341,
0.43580904603004456,
0.057000573724508286,
0.270195335149765,
-0.14756986498832703,
-0.29461827874183655,
0.4139450490474701,
0.03857428953051567,
-0.38409745693206787,
0.07657475769519806,
0.014341676607728004,
0.6847401261329651,
-0.5291443467140198,
0.5929685831069946,
0.5097236633300781,
-0.3154102861881256,
-0.43337374925613403,
-0.5902532935142517,
-0.06621852517127991,
-0.46218863129615784,
0.48106062412261963,
-0.6458089351654053,
-0.9653354287147522,
0.6663421392440796,
-0.12534089386463165,
0.07096145302057266,
0.2583387792110443,
0.5930172204971313,
-0.13333716988563538,
0.846116840839386,
0.34297803044319153,
0.07765748351812363,
0.2941873371601105,
0.1633802056312561,
-0.054434943944215775,
-0.8868262767791748,
-0.17884138226509094,
-0.6650862693786621,
-0.16473929584026337,
-0.8236254453659058,
-0.8947868943214417,
0.5672644376754761,
0.27342191338539124,
-0.36502379179000854,
-0.16476047039031982,
-0.19240565598011017,
0.3859984576702118,
0.2304157018661499,
0.3142135739326477,
0.2708446979522705,
-0.09731452912092209,
0.14930634200572968,
0.4685593247413635,
-0.8245420455932617,
-0.12431786209344864,
1.0605840682983398,
0.21050046384334564,
0.8427771329879761,
0.5332289934158325,
0.313622385263443,
0.16575749218463898,
0.29517489671707153,
-0.9159781336784363,
0.32994645833969116,
-0.23039045929908752,
-0.5469540357589722,
-0.3961162865161896,
-0.647506058216095,
-0.9907189607620239,
0.4802742600440979,
-0.5680429935455322,
-0.20383435487747192,
0.230892613530159,
0.12368444353342056,
-0.42941179871559143,
0.357948362827301,
-0.49421215057373047,
0.3718104064464569,
-0.2849561274051666,
-0.4497949481010437,
0.04969227313995361,
-0.37198564410209656,
0.244522362947464,
-0.4489781856536865,
0.37610018253326416,
-0.02216034196317196,
-0.33284494280815125,
0.5941841006278992,
0.11106586456298828,
0.5854756236076355,
-0.34741321206092834,
-0.06377092003822327,
0.1980883628129959,
0.33269211649894714,
0.7489153146743774,
-0.02299579232931137,
-0.2697490155696869,
-0.5617180466651917,
0.17808493971824646,
-0.6997056603431702,
-0.8640571236610413,
0.49742525815963745,
-0.522624671459198,
-0.8315436840057373,
-0.3244002163410187,
-0.819529116153717,
-0.7158840298652649,
0.29810410737991333,
-0.3667287826538086,
0.23658618330955505,
0.0025378724094480276,
0.13039807975292206,
0.9108541011810303,
-0.5421316027641296,
0.07174712419509888,
0.9025600552558899,
-0.36871105432510376,
-0.4765560030937195,
0.8847348093986511,
0.09378877282142639,
0.32243743538856506,
0.588714599609375,
0.3845422565937042,
-0.21172861754894257,
-0.8809454441070557,
-0.43101105093955994,
0.22300387918949127,
-0.5539786219596863,
-0.47175857424736023,
-0.7303370833396912,
-0.06116389483213425,
-0.4436498284339905,
0.18140465021133423,
-0.14864960312843323,
-0.3830665647983551,
-0.22499722242355347,
0.2496941089630127,
0.5147914290428162,
0.4628421664237976,
0.43440061807632446,
0.07705989480018616,
-0.9054871797561646,
0.5977566242218018,
0.6391214728355408,
0.6042118668556213,
0.06259138882160187,
-1.0464956760406494,
-0.17949101328849792,
-0.10966859757900238,
-0.13915064930915833,
-0.675918698310852,
0.3174894452095032,
0.4516364634037018,
0.50141841173172,
-0.21769776940345764,
0.43363067507743835,
0.5217289924621582,
-0.5127696394920349,
0.3669702708721161,
-0.2673739194869995,
-0.57415771484375,
0.25637516379356384,
-0.4138088524341583,
0.4627525806427002,
0.46272727847099304,
0.505323052406311,
-0.2568967938423157,
-0.17993885278701782,
-0.27872952818870544,
-0.7837994694709778,
0.5059112310409546,
-0.14099028706550598,
0.1809101402759552,
0.2990700304508209,
0.7990970611572266,
-0.005406118929386139,
-0.047924138605594635,
-0.39461541175842285,
0.039368096739053726,
0.0929112583398819,
-0.3525846004486084,
0.22738048434257507,
-0.5263369679450989,
0.03475640341639519,
0.02137516625225544,
0.8264099359512329,
-0.6119819283485413,
0.04968145489692688,
0.11554498970508575,
-0.27736613154411316,
-0.15575091540813446,
0.5493267178535461,
0.4606177806854248,
0.8840435147285461,
-0.3762495219707489,
-0.1251251995563507,
0.6217201948165894,
-0.3729664087295532,
0.1867530792951584,
0.11710209399461746,
-0.09587129950523376,
-0.3293475806713104,
0.18737144768238068,
0.8201178312301636,
0.16936564445495605,
-0.8687639832496643,
0.3174707889556885,
-0.19903156161308289,
0.00946213398128748,
-0.16838529706001282,
0.23778565227985382,
0.11901339143514633,
0.6372960805892944,
0.4862290918827057,
-0.1823064386844635,
0.182694673538208,
-0.31003525853157043,
0.19109055399894714,
0.3975389301776886,
-0.37524452805519104,
-0.17851963639259338,
0.557256281375885,
-0.08050531893968582,
-0.32917332649230957,
0.039991725236177444,
-0.17750291526317596,
-0.5054848194122314,
0.3825509548187256,
0.4057755768299103,
0.7921596765518188,
-0.464761346578598,
0.2121414840221405,
0.39789092540740967,
0.05260501056909561,
-0.03423405438661575,
0.540862500667572,
0.19435754418373108,
-0.6138677597045898,
-0.5296956896781921,
-1.0135186910629272,
-0.5445809960365295,
-0.03142038360238075,
-0.702414870262146,
0.15030163526535034,
-0.5186249017715454,
0.2188054770231247,
-0.11727818101644516,
0.05433015152812004,
-0.40278419852256775,
0.3315964639186859,
-0.29957225918769836,
1.0123755931854248,
-0.40810900926589966,
0.6334211230278015,
1.002471685409546,
-0.17324517667293549,
-0.7036857604980469,
0.09622886031866074,
-0.3536921441555023,
-0.6614429354667664,
0.2290787696838379,
-0.33991536498069763,
-0.07126641273498535,
0.07203017920255661,
-0.2289455682039261,
-0.9675772190093994,
1.0165292024612427,
0.2857765555381775,
-0.35806265473365784,
0.05454323813319206,
-0.10335879772901535,
0.6819465756416321,
-0.2681955397129059,
0.11218655854463577,
0.33400338888168335,
0.08753737062215805,
0.4215986728668213,
-0.9639489650726318,
0.10057695209980011,
-0.03105369210243225,
0.027213377878069878,
0.12043210119009018,
-0.5400528907775879,
0.6625628471374512,
-0.29226455092430115,
-0.016854532063007355,
0.3063644766807556,
0.6968711018562317,
0.499963641166687,
0.4064235985279083,
0.7148451805114746,
0.33088770508766174,
0.811499297618866,
0.18502113223075867,
0.9699103832244873,
-0.06716626137495041,
0.2166198343038559,
1.3860456943511963,
-0.20380251109600067,
1.1500385999679565,
0.22443558275699615,
-0.3585367202758789,
0.4155122637748718,
0.4526227116584778,
0.33345329761505127,
0.22811193764209747,
0.24705713987350464,
-0.22305132448673248,
-0.2499423772096634,
0.02220347337424755,
-0.0030703656375408173,
0.6372981071472168,
0.4054919183254242,
-0.026052774861454964,
-0.1863640993833542,
0.11294456571340561,
-0.4177914261817932,
0.3339702785015106,
-0.5766869783401489,
1.1600532531738281,
-0.1759064793586731,
-0.6357259154319763,
0.9368957281112671,
0.018544580787420273,
0.5130815505981445,
-0.48827487230300903,
0.09536747634410858,
-0.25335928797721863,
0.02828012965619564,
-0.21391865611076355,
-0.5653848052024841,
0.10398586839437485,
-0.08455044031143188,
-0.39494287967681885,
0.34176522493362427,
0.9667112231254578,
-0.41753217577934265,
-0.5572686791419983,
0.11381759494543076,
0.6190584897994995,
-0.15052759647369385,
-0.24834322929382324,
-0.8629627227783203,
-0.07048825919628143,
-0.1446206271648407,
-0.20182982087135315,
0.405694842338562,
0.6294183731079102,
-0.2069043517112732,
0.7930434942245483,
0.6052966117858887,
0.08401485532522202,
0.15505492687225342,
0.06097252294421196,
0.88719642162323,
-0.540780246257782,
-0.3375389873981476,
-0.18708108365535736,
0.3743433356285095,
0.16413554549217224,
0.32423388957977295,
0.484975665807724,
0.3366309106349945,
0.6695301532745361,
-0.06099023297429085,
0.47319385409355164,
0.1381891965866089,
1.0624189376831055,
-0.5957480072975159,
0.5546343922615051,
-0.8693950772285461,
0.5563851594924927,
-0.11229783296585083,
-0.8417395949363708,
-0.3145796060562134,
0.23269860446453094,
-0.2072102278470993,
0.250305712223053,
0.14649279415607452,
0.9003204107284546,
-0.030816052109003067,
-0.323937326669693,
0.34350961446762085,
0.4319511353969574,
0.4098142683506012,
0.4634380042552948,
0.6085410714149475,
-0.4259991943836212,
0.5881335735321045,
0.08348073065280914,
-0.31385332345962524,
-0.2527318000793457,
-0.6306371092796326,
-0.6282452940940857,
-0.5926015377044678,
-0.15765562653541565,
-0.5097869038581848,
0.12218055874109268,
0.8148945569992065,
0.3154968321323395,
-0.9348247051239014,
-0.15158650279045105,
0.25739237666130066,
0.3477495610713959,
-0.24505022168159485,
-0.20787110924720764,
0.6142755746841431,
-0.6439847946166992,
-0.7226687073707581,
0.3359410762786865,
0.1688634306192398,
-0.11823257058858871,
-0.08247127383947372,
-0.005465687718242407,
-0.48435279726982117,
0.45714452862739563,
0.8244689702987671,
0.4389219284057617,
-0.5660967826843262,
-0.26893430948257446,
0.2783971130847931,
-0.011391104198992252,
0.043831754475831985,
0.460866242647171,
-0.7644528746604919,
0.7367501854896545,
0.6917392015457153,
1.2005603313446045,
0.28124937415122986,
0.06600701808929443,
0.216048926115036,
-0.6390354633331299,
-0.18724356591701508,
0.4114278554916382,
0.002999706892296672,
0.35559287667274475,
-0.2909676432609558,
0.4618525207042694,
0.0026934861671179533,
-0.506937563419342,
-0.981194794178009,
0.307652086019516,
-1.0445834398269653,
-0.5701897740364075,
1.1606980562210083,
0.009571759961545467,
-0.3907199203968048,
-0.2520267367362976,
-0.32456648349761963,
-0.006703617982566357,
-0.034711264073848724,
1.0066457986831665,
0.22001856565475464,
-0.07037312537431717,
-0.3907333314418793,
-0.5660288333892822,
0.44563916325569153,
0.46351367235183716,
-0.8733534812927246,
0.059802889823913574,
0.34092143177986145,
0.5079407691955566,
0.08178393542766571,
0.4629327356815338,
-0.11022496223449707,
0.44006091356277466,
-0.5311298370361328,
-0.23093639314174652,
0.095986008644104,
-0.1272590607404709,
-0.34190016984939575,
0.4659799337387085,
0.6333073377609253,
0.037987787276506424
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14402v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14402v1
|
XLAVS-R: Cross-Lingual Audio-Visual Speech Representation Learning for Noise-Robust Speech Perception
| 2024-03-21T13:52:17 | 2024-03-21T13:52:17 |
HyoJung Han, Mohamed Anwar, Juan Pino, Wei-Ning Hsu, Marine Carpuat, Bowen Shi, Changhan Wang
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
Speech recognition and translation systems perform poorly on noisy inputs,
which are frequent in realistic environments. Augmenting these systems with
visual signals has the potential to improve robustness to noise. However,
audio-visual (AV) data is only available in limited amounts and for fewer
languages than audio-only resources. To address this gap, we present XLAVS-R, a
cross-lingual audio-visual speech representation model for noise-robust speech
recognition and translation in over 100 languages. It is designed to maximize
the benefits of limited multilingual AV pre-training data, by building on top
of audio-only multilingual pre-training and simplifying existing pre-training
schemes. Extensive evaluation on the MuAViC benchmark shows the strength of
XLAVS-R on downstream audio-visual speech recognition and translation tasks,
where it outperforms the previous state of the art by up to 18.5% WER and 4.7
BLEU given noisy AV inputs, and enables strong zero-shot audio-visual ability
with audio-only fine-tuning.
|
[
-0.3296023905277252,
-0.2858542501926422,
0.20959120988845825,
-0.025761321187019348,
-0.5266914963722229,
0.11278238147497177,
-0.3653821051120758,
-0.4657384157180786,
0.21244937181472778,
0.3793239891529083,
-0.6031374335289001,
-0.4513935148715973,
-0.5863954424858093,
0.1290101259946823,
-0.09456585347652435,
0.7767048478126526,
0.1831924468278885,
0.5896261930465698,
0.05507519096136093,
-0.3959534466266632,
-0.3976718783378601,
-0.2715930640697479,
-0.24924737215042114,
0.06660334765911102,
0.6063959002494812,
0.36034056544303894,
0.5350597500801086,
0.6427913308143616,
0.3949500024318695,
0.3040790557861328,
0.13746552169322968,
0.12055109441280365,
-0.4962047338485718,
0.4671960175037384,
0.24469099938869476,
-0.5153529047966003,
-0.5235252976417542,
-0.39690613746643066,
0.9022058248519897,
0.5997352600097656,
-0.24195465445518494,
0.27294448018074036,
-0.00501087075099349,
0.2879795730113983,
-0.5066571831703186,
0.3981126844882965,
-0.6764929890632629,
0.3450581729412079,
-0.41093355417251587,
-0.3386785089969635,
-0.27319300174713135,
0.16506510972976685,
0.19877634942531586,
-0.9401000142097473,
-0.328266978263855,
0.13053007423877716,
0.5895281434059143,
0.4513147473335266,
-0.13289202749729156,
-0.01847529597580433,
-0.7855375409126282,
1.1500273942947388,
-0.2473614513874054,
1.229331374168396,
0.41012680530548096,
0.32347533106803894,
0.36279618740081787,
-0.5403445363044739,
-0.0659409761428833,
0.028111958876252174,
0.26841333508491516,
0.1542873978614807,
-0.5906413197517395,
-0.30020540952682495,
0.27756041288375854,
-0.03379322215914726,
-1.0175460577011108,
-0.06579549610614777,
-0.48737141489982605,
-0.2912321090698242,
0.4019535481929779,
0.008778727613389492,
0.3499266803264618,
0.24210140109062195,
-0.30696675181388855,
-0.4246600866317749,
-0.6141394376754761,
0.15429747104644775,
0.33861783146858215,
0.6301800608634949,
-0.22516019642353058,
0.5228302478790283,
-0.06387349963188171,
0.9417163133621216,
-0.18816982209682465,
-0.4541405141353607,
0.7366266250610352,
-0.5103257298469543,
-0.18374936282634735,
0.2715550661087036,
0.6271585822105408,
-0.08839082717895508,
0.2257537841796875,
-0.135087788105011,
-0.3189224898815155,
0.2433089017868042,
0.043709829449653625,
-0.5730567574501038,
-0.057439811527729034,
-0.11653634905815125,
-0.18539643287658691,
-0.2126188427209854,
-0.17798368632793427,
-0.6319392919540405,
0.062212683260440826,
-0.6152933835983276,
0.39757442474365234,
-0.2649591863155365,
-0.3461991548538208,
-0.002851885976269841,
0.1863090544939041,
-0.067375548183918,
0.12328653782606125,
-0.5691872835159302,
0.2893438935279846,
0.24280881881713867,
0.7004672884941101,
-0.14260505139827728,
-0.2814045250415802,
-1.2603387832641602,
-0.009862957522273064,
-0.5750336647033691,
0.7545132040977478,
-0.7039195895195007,
-0.16672591865062714,
-0.14509208500385284,
-0.18908612430095673,
0.16952872276306152,
-0.5513293147087097,
0.6029558181762695,
-0.23642294108867645,
-0.09720871597528458,
-0.20220023393630981,
-0.0629330649971962,
0.2609236538410187,
0.039348818361759186,
-0.5448932647705078,
0.7673139572143555,
-0.0871085524559021,
-0.5382459163665771,
0.7530220150947571,
-0.2690196931362152,
-0.2084178328514099,
0.24853292107582092,
-0.4633059501647949,
-0.711633026599884,
-0.1397305428981781,
0.26229146122932434,
0.20668189227581024,
0.019939903169870377,
-0.0215518269687891,
-0.33452552556991577,
-0.17304231226444244,
0.17224687337875366,
-0.33863505721092224,
0.7880067825317383,
0.4925384521484375,
-0.16811169683933258,
0.3224869966506958,
-0.9953864216804504,
0.2787376046180725,
-0.055905863642692566,
-0.22589722275733948,
-0.5828819274902344,
-0.2435293197631836,
0.17299354076385498,
0.3712346851825714,
-0.061224907636642456,
-0.7779557704925537,
-0.2115190327167511,
-0.3074687123298645,
0.2206529676914215,
0.38623958826065063,
-0.5724468231201172,
0.4317554533481598,
-0.10164990276098251,
0.8090636730194092,
0.31045663356781006,
0.12613539397716522,
-0.33007678389549255,
-0.4998738765716553,
-0.42048606276512146,
-0.5352766513824463,
0.24131149053573608,
0.6894385814666748,
-0.8666055202484131,
0.14145666360855103,
-0.5085718035697937,
-0.3956771492958069,
-0.5262093544006348,
0.5310326218605042,
0.6272827982902527,
0.29759180545806885,
0.4227007329463959,
-0.08914468437433243,
-1.0267871618270874,
-0.4524855315685272,
-0.2426609992980957,
-0.03551509976387024,
0.14339596033096313,
0.17215292155742645,
0.354597806930542,
-0.18510355055332184,
0.5603859424591064,
-0.078277088701725,
-0.8408892750740051,
-0.5017093420028687,
-0.027496693655848503,
-0.22029133141040802,
0.2791188657283783,
0.5952189564704895,
-0.9280670285224915,
-0.6976402401924133,
0.4988164007663727,
-0.553939163684845,
-0.09204179048538208,
0.028582854196429253,
0.18557940423488617,
0.25449734926223755,
0.6596390604972839,
-0.16814623773097992,
0.48423415422439575,
0.9493780732154846,
-0.1988109052181244,
0.3519575595855713,
-0.11185389012098312,
-0.10042862594127655,
-0.7016580104827881,
-0.0840316042304039,
-0.08710544556379318,
-0.5828959345817566,
-0.6951513886451721,
-0.3573494255542755,
-0.12295391410589218,
-0.5645875930786133,
-0.582074761390686,
0.38701584935188293,
-0.6400365829467773,
-0.4351097345352173,
0.06978968530893326,
0.31527525186538696,
-0.0930343046784401,
0.456637978553772,
0.2838868796825409,
0.7963747978210449,
1.1373540163040161,
-0.2829582691192627,
0.38010913133621216,
0.33186256885528564,
-0.5469102263450623,
0.7662885785102844,
-0.5594879388809204,
-0.13719287514686584,
-0.0404634028673172,
-0.0003781001432798803,
-0.7563452124595642,
-0.058610785752534866,
0.24753256142139435,
-0.6163334250450134,
0.4591876268386841,
-0.12349607795476913,
-0.10339248925447464,
0.10205096751451492,
0.09967533499002457,
0.742515504360199,
0.397117555141449,
-0.4449889659881592,
0.7994765639305115,
0.722148060798645,
-0.4874149262905121,
-0.8323209285736084,
-1.048047661781311,
0.20224125683307648,
-0.047986943274736404,
-0.44172203540802,
-0.03146547079086304,
0.0047521102242171764,
-0.2452104538679123,
0.18490499258041382,
-0.12042530626058578,
-0.24936531484127045,
-0.6764081716537476,
0.07741471379995346,
0.14088433980941772,
-0.43847596645355225,
-0.028572911396622658,
-0.2611050605773926,
-0.2735966444015503,
-0.10184219479560852,
-0.5337350964546204,
0.22956407070159912,
-0.3212816119194031,
-0.3625125288963318,
-0.2752971351146698,
0.57762211561203,
0.536976158618927,
-0.4844645857810974,
0.13997557759284973,
0.7727110385894775,
-0.07765252888202667,
-0.35132038593292236,
-0.27214255928993225,
0.11774461716413498,
-0.3829954266548157,
0.8976142406463623,
-0.37824076414108276,
-0.5763824582099915,
0.3683558702468872,
0.25989148020744324,
0.01375869195908308,
-0.07016566395759583,
0.39135003089904785,
-0.0035774342250078917,
1.1616287231445312,
0.5017016530036926,
0.198877215385437,
0.6247837543487549,
-0.23593448102474213,
0.10081322491168976,
-0.5878844857215881,
-0.3208036720752716,
-0.4594137966632843,
0.06488455832004547,
-0.3704313039779663,
-0.4769406318664551,
0.3550601303577423,
-0.5800808072090149,
0.03263111785054207,
0.3911736309528351,
-0.2890135645866394,
0.2669467031955719,
0.3681570589542389,
0.03127190098166466,
0.2085675746202469,
0.4604179561138153,
-0.11575464904308319,
-0.4966195523738861,
-0.9922330975532532,
0.023439310491085052,
1.0130997896194458,
0.16419708728790283,
1.0362732410430908,
-0.05655694752931595,
0.5584115386009216,
0.09906690567731857,
-0.24738532304763794,
-0.7166538238525391,
0.3898424208164215,
-0.3376307189464569,
-0.5185036659240723,
-0.5186364054679871,
-0.8999972343444824,
-0.9283693432807922,
0.4106048345565796,
-0.45103752613067627,
-0.3820255398750305,
0.4803546965122223,
0.35088348388671875,
-0.3089037835597992,
0.5806923508644104,
-0.48654359579086304,
0.7025961875915527,
-0.6385461688041687,
-0.2918938994407654,
-0.11679317057132721,
-0.7097877264022827,
-0.035756275057792664,
-0.22570861876010895,
0.6592649221420288,
0.21011079847812653,
-0.1513216346502304,
0.594148576259613,
-0.06514941900968552,
0.7515233755111694,
-0.18680697679519653,
-0.041067566722631454,
0.21643207967281342,
-0.03341936320066452,
0.35534486174583435,
-0.2395593523979187,
0.31976959109306335,
0.5027291774749756,
-0.0035866564139723778,
-0.20938150584697723,
-0.43994539976119995,
0.4493083953857422,
-0.7646430134773254,
-0.04959094524383545,
-0.6029852032661438,
-0.6339760422706604,
-0.22550705075263977,
0.40080296993255615,
0.4168842136859894,
0.8041055798530579,
-0.279310405254364,
0.48967012763023376,
0.801903486251831,
-0.3888207674026489,
-0.03662176802754402,
0.2697266936302185,
-0.5604109168052673,
-0.7471069097518921,
1.2889131307601929,
0.39564597606658936,
0.35408687591552734,
0.39871564507484436,
0.07734061777591705,
-0.31723839044570923,
-0.4222540259361267,
-0.4995385706424713,
0.007607785984873772,
-0.786566436290741,
-0.17125780880451202,
-0.5933274626731873,
-0.010772127658128738,
-0.41117849946022034,
0.07253824174404144,
-0.7066284418106079,
-0.23778335750102997,
-0.13037647306919098,
-0.03237799555063248,
-0.04354352131485939,
0.6779706478118896,
-0.7443856000900269,
0.009200738742947578,
-0.580351710319519,
0.7401319146156311,
0.5743527412414551,
0.43856945633888245,
-0.504640519618988,
-0.6352356672286987,
-0.5197094678878784,
0.11700765788555145,
-0.0009428492630831897,
-0.3918818533420563,
0.6956766843795776,
0.5064584016799927,
0.5930412411689758,
0.4024534821510315,
-0.019082333892583847,
0.8887127041816711,
-0.49259868264198303,
0.3613545000553131,
0.42262521386146545,
-0.8798074722290039,
0.3231082856655121,
-0.21267417073249817,
0.3815641403198242,
0.21019858121871948,
0.05951881781220436,
-0.15912719070911407,
-0.3540968596935272,
-0.2593027353286743,
-0.6176329851150513,
0.8031446933746338,
0.39527884125709534,
-0.1081584170460701,
0.47050097584724426,
-0.20460103452205658,
0.15956607460975647,
-0.033698245882987976,
-0.8355117440223694,
-0.2729876637458801,
-0.6734164357185364,
-0.008517777547240257,
-0.11115413159132004,
-0.04731795936822891,
-0.09671613574028015,
-0.2995275855064392,
0.6558557152748108,
-0.00190501450560987,
0.04429915174841881,
0.2057608813047409,
-0.21232962608337402,
-0.42903462052345276,
0.2446981966495514,
0.7954609990119934,
0.5714145302772522,
-0.09349478781223297,
0.1766291707754135,
0.3171655237674713,
-0.7960477471351624,
0.2142031192779541,
0.06332369893789291,
-0.07835157215595245,
0.26926788687705994,
0.36865857243537903,
1.195510745048523,
0.36470386385917664,
-0.8042937517166138,
0.5791386365890503,
-0.4017575979232788,
-0.3906497657299042,
-0.4590943455696106,
-0.2471887767314911,
-0.21680685877799988,
0.24881695210933685,
0.202249675989151,
0.6239741444587708,
0.14645597338676453,
-0.5382494330406189,
0.32664522528648376,
0.4131639003753662,
-0.665306568145752,
-0.4301935136318207,
0.6511239409446716,
0.035074297338724136,
-0.14031516015529633,
0.11879617720842361,
0.031704600900411606,
-0.2664511501789093,
0.26956096291542053,
0.2956414222717285,
0.7136834263801575,
-0.4145067632198334,
0.11343149840831757,
0.435119092464447,
0.3146003484725952,
0.12369965761899948,
0.5731354355812073,
-0.46484455466270447,
-0.48015907406806946,
-0.6055565476417542,
-0.41563549637794495,
-0.4365071952342987,
-0.17128634452819824,
-0.9953629970550537,
0.5073543190956116,
0.1120440885424614,
-0.1677999198436737,
-0.18057818710803986,
-0.3173620402812958,
-0.7894664406776428,
0.2766614854335785,
0.5178973078727722,
0.50435870885849,
-0.8769618272781372,
0.9622515439987183,
0.6183748245239258,
-0.16040071845054626,
-0.6358330249786377,
-0.47398924827575684,
-0.03422372788190842,
-0.8060780167579651,
0.9658049941062927,
-0.19232594966888428,
-0.5453250408172607,
-0.30250653624534607,
-0.4392516613006592,
-1.1653107404708862,
0.6664539575576782,
0.8370879888534546,
-0.9565058946609497,
0.25162389874458313,
0.4927304983139038,
0.4932507276535034,
-0.32413920760154724,
-0.11230847239494324,
0.10146177560091019,
0.5134202837944031,
0.06382989138364792,
-0.9192633628845215,
-0.5490013360977173,
-0.36556774377822876,
-0.14505358040332794,
0.030191440135240555,
-0.2517489790916443,
0.6958171129226685,
-0.38082462549209595,
-0.15178342163562775,
-0.06989781558513641,
0.53913414478302,
0.3157839775085449,
0.36050522327423096,
0.8237667083740234,
0.5448997616767883,
0.46922767162323,
-0.15068486332893372,
0.7879536151885986,
-0.13452744483947754,
-0.005823349114507437,
1.2457908391952515,
-0.25706008076667786,
0.7606981992721558,
0.6011680960655212,
0.03778425604104996,
0.26718711853027344,
0.09612346440553665,
0.20391592383384705,
0.8229301571846008,
-0.1998925805091858,
0.05485085770487785,
-0.7296738028526306,
-0.10350672155618668,
-0.47899776697158813,
0.7460736036300659,
0.3916141390800476,
0.03139396756887436,
-0.07013574242591858,
0.47783827781677246,
-0.3683536946773529,
-0.10927776247262955,
-0.30616670846939087,
0.774972677230835,
0.2742389440536499,
-0.36268290877342224,
0.5255461931228638,
-0.8895726203918457,
0.4181670546531677,
-1.0242938995361328,
-0.21894454956054688,
0.14839771389961243,
0.26897016167640686,
-0.2232336848974228,
-0.675603449344635,
0.4861149787902832,
0.11413378268480301,
0.09416671842336655,
-0.43777868151664734,
0.37570512294769287,
-0.804506778717041,
-0.6716080904006958,
0.6016831994056702,
0.358919620513916,
0.2101549506187439,
0.1853712946176529,
-0.5998140573501587,
0.6149002909660339,
0.06955672055482864,
-0.11898870021104813,
0.3365769386291504,
0.7084062099456787,
0.10847778618335724,
0.7063885927200317,
0.611740231513977,
0.6213425993919373,
0.3248125910758972,
0.10017557442188263,
0.8207136392593384,
-0.2892247438430786,
-0.7072334289550781,
-0.350527822971344,
0.48019376397132874,
0.23344114422798157,
-0.3932340741157532,
0.6412904858589172,
0.4896637797355652,
1.1109322309494019,
-0.06967484951019287,
0.8037935495376587,
0.21475465595722198,
0.5458255410194397,
-0.44569289684295654,
0.5250725150108337,
-0.8839004039764404,
0.1334725320339203,
-0.505813479423523,
-0.7972755432128906,
-0.7624768018722534,
0.7366520762443542,
-0.0632140263915062,
-0.08352036029100418,
0.3518174886703491,
0.6901938915252686,
-0.2869899272918701,
-0.2563844621181488,
1.0624805688858032,
0.35154351592063904,
0.02492605522274971,
0.187687486410141,
0.8517827987670898,
-0.45021018385887146,
1.4301176071166992,
-0.3014301359653473,
-0.08810979127883911,
0.05048944801092148,
-0.5796623826026917,
-0.8037927150726318,
-0.6577059626579285,
-0.3689945638179779,
0.003466423600912094,
0.13103188574314117,
0.7981734275817871,
1.1103200912475586,
-0.8871117234230042,
-0.3290266990661621,
0.06983289867639542,
-0.26931291818618774,
-0.4026487469673157,
-0.02892156131565571,
0.04804633930325508,
-0.3717327415943146,
-0.5110800266265869,
0.7149251699447632,
0.5017393827438354,
-0.04558377340435982,
-0.3529711961746216,
-0.5379770994186401,
0.23153211176395416,
-0.0788433775305748,
0.5294451713562012,
0.528365969657898,
-0.7119665145874023,
0.11135909706354141,
0.25751495361328125,
0.1617615818977356,
0.4293803572654724,
0.7353467345237732,
-0.7565721869468689,
0.9174034595489502,
0.5492579936981201,
0.3067600131034851,
0.5298557877540588,
-0.4157370328903198,
0.5386077761650085,
-0.6814054846763611,
0.5390148162841797,
0.31578072905540466,
0.7394453883171082,
0.4703700542449951,
-0.08188275992870331,
0.17393824458122253,
-0.027963317930698395,
-0.6046311855316162,
-1.1371890306472778,
0.19010747969150543,
-1.2892252206802368,
0.016789192333817482,
1.0785681009292603,
-0.2638063132762909,
-0.13858672976493835,
-0.4776259660720825,
-0.33481889963150024,
0.19452819228172302,
-0.6167960166931152,
0.313904732465744,
0.2300097644329071,
0.07649601250886917,
-0.4704173803329468,
-0.4453149437904358,
0.4341883659362793,
0.46925920248031616,
-0.4838334918022156,
0.2879425287246704,
0.33562934398651123,
0.2088463008403778,
0.2947441339492798,
0.3160163164138794,
-0.44096124172210693,
0.49524566531181335,
0.3262961506843567,
0.061031486839056015,
-0.23472167551517487,
-0.6391271352767944,
-0.5081015229225159,
-0.007490186952054501,
-0.21418577432632446,
-0.20646053552627563
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14399v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14399v1
|
Building Accurate Translation-Tailored LLMs with Language Aware Instruction Tuning
| 2024-03-21T13:47:40 | 2024-03-21T13:47:40 |
Changtong Zan, Liang Ding, Li Shen, Yibing Zhen, Weifeng Liu, Dacheng Tao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Translation-tailored Large language models (LLMs) exhibit remarkable
translation capabilities, even competing with supervised-trained commercial
translation systems. However, off-target translation remains an unsolved
problem, especially for low-resource languages, hindering us from developing
accurate LLMs-based translation models. To mitigate the off-target translation
problem and enhance the performance of LLMs on translation, recent works have
either designed advanced prompting strategies to highlight the functionality of
translation instructions or exploited the in-context learning ability of LLMs
by feeding few-shot demonstrations. However, these methods essentially do not
improve LLM's ability to follow translation instructions, especially the
language direction information. In this work, we design a two-stage fine-tuning
algorithm to improve the instruction-following ability (especially the
translation direction) of LLMs. Specifically, we first tune LLMs with the
maximum likelihood estimation loss on the translation dataset to elicit the
basic translation capabilities. In the second stage, we construct
instruction-conflicting samples by randomly replacing the translation
directions with a wrong one within the instruction, and then introduce an extra
unlikelihood loss to learn those samples. Experiments on IWSLT and WMT
benchmarks upon the LLaMA model spanning 16 zero-shot directions show that,
compared to the competitive baseline -- translation-finetuned LLama, our method
could effectively reduce the off-target translation ratio (averagely -53.3\%),
thus improving translation quality with average +5.7 SacreBLEU and +16.4
BLEURT. Analysis shows that our method could preserve the model's general task
performance on AlpacaEval. Code and models will be released at
\url{https://github.com/alphadl/LanguageAware_Tuning}.
|
[
-0.1402464509010315,
-0.8268130421638489,
0.5696869492530823,
-0.03264849632978439,
-0.4079003632068634,
-0.010902615264058113,
-0.510349452495575,
-0.11211765557527542,
-0.021305378526449203,
0.638382613658905,
-0.824238657951355,
-0.7299457788467407,
-0.73166424036026,
-0.022262051701545715,
-0.1494397222995758,
0.841600775718689,
-0.11498340964317322,
0.1207563728094101,
0.20180264115333557,
-0.1562982052564621,
-0.5821924209594727,
0.0837671309709549,
-0.6626678109169006,
-0.2011655569076538,
0.46756431460380554,
0.7936703562736511,
0.4381070137023926,
0.9682039618492126,
0.2672351896762848,
0.19312602281570435,
-0.2242879420518875,
0.5769447684288025,
-0.6421471834182739,
0.036998942494392395,
-0.08504022657871246,
-0.6471949815750122,
-0.5031194090843201,
-0.053239695727825165,
0.6667611598968506,
0.3855484127998352,
-0.15191049873828888,
0.23724548518657684,
0.29314181208610535,
0.5812931060791016,
-0.4264645576477051,
0.04441634193062782,
-0.7777653932571411,
-0.010832211934030056,
-0.33305394649505615,
-0.5889527201652527,
-0.5264507532119751,
-0.28977489471435547,
-0.18304254114627838,
-0.5941370725631714,
0.09590066969394684,
0.18937349319458008,
0.5585376024246216,
0.4551936089992523,
-0.2086070030927658,
-0.3059004843235016,
-0.47561007738113403,
0.9673069715499878,
-0.9252173900604248,
0.3966864347457886,
0.5819759368896484,
0.1194150447845459,
-0.4626190662384033,
-0.2580339014530182,
-0.17474883794784546,
-0.10658615827560425,
0.14845934510231018,
0.09922415018081665,
-0.14631344377994537,
0.003836259711533785,
0.1399174928665161,
0.06861146539449692,
-0.5470582842826843,
0.5163151621818542,
-0.09558455646038055,
-0.06383573263883591,
0.42102134227752686,
0.11348091065883636,
-0.017013374716043472,
0.09029675275087357,
-0.27966174483299255,
-0.10630350559949875,
-1.03534734249115,
0.11794950813055038,
0.4414611756801605,
0.46361422538757324,
-0.12540794909000397,
0.5082571506500244,
-0.2512888014316559,
0.8996514678001404,
0.43797406554222107,
-0.1680862009525299,
-0.13350577652454376,
-0.22557617723941803,
0.014767812564969063,
0.17989026010036469,
0.4616893231868744,
0.4145396053791046,
0.19076034426689148,
-0.0966050773859024,
-0.44541430473327637,
-0.27869054675102234,
0.14203746616840363,
-0.8172730803489685,
0.03903953731060028,
0.039567362517118454,
-0.20801451802253723,
-0.2482168972492218,
-0.2675267159938812,
-0.41379833221435547,
-0.13401125371456146,
-0.21999366581439972,
0.5859462022781372,
-0.5057826638221741,
0.18223710358142853,
-0.004980908706784248,
0.4127614498138428,
0.4781559109687805,
0.20253489911556244,
-1.054625391960144,
-0.07959434390068054,
0.6015623211860657,
0.7483760118484497,
-0.13045628368854523,
-0.21136218309402466,
-0.9209848642349243,
0.2317754626274109,
-0.4459315240383148,
0.588179886341095,
-0.5647023916244507,
-0.3088549077510834,
0.03886627033352852,
-0.08867195248603821,
-0.023356705904006958,
-0.48086339235305786,
0.3283820152282715,
-0.6392605304718018,
0.07461528480052948,
-0.2958054840564728,
-0.7976236343383789,
-0.2826404869556427,
0.37771573662757874,
-0.1833963245153427,
0.7481673359870911,
-0.05443331226706505,
-0.12946322560310364,
0.09775635600090027,
-0.4301494359970093,
-0.5702397227287292,
-0.1480073779821396,
-0.0372694730758667,
-0.34406834840774536,
0.25629332661628723,
0.406110554933548,
0.4460793733596802,
-0.28795674443244934,
-0.004576206207275391,
0.1447245180606842,
-0.7544989585876465,
0.05566098168492317,
-0.6135399341583252,
0.5021721720695496,
-0.03758116811513901,
-0.5005358457565308,
0.15579628944396973,
-0.6990619897842407,
0.20869684219360352,
0.12654048204421997,
-0.4271658658981323,
-0.1478947103023529,
-0.09117773175239563,
-0.38532617688179016,
0.03319612145423889,
0.37142160534858704,
-0.2838284969329834,
0.4230070114135742,
-0.5317795276641846,
0.22210462391376495,
0.8438116908073425,
-0.004814026411622763,
0.6037139296531677,
-0.16967694461345673,
0.6583373546600342,
-0.28138846158981323,
0.1777610331773758,
-0.2510671019554138,
-0.5015155076980591,
-0.7517422437667847,
-0.1353868842124939,
0.17586465179920197,
0.6730059385299683,
-0.6644770503044128,
0.3679443895816803,
-0.04585867375135422,
-0.22126086056232452,
-0.8085662722587585,
0.562112033367157,
0.798342227935791,
0.5600501894950867,
0.5927144289016724,
-0.17278456687927246,
-0.32278987765312195,
-0.5029643177986145,
-0.2914218604564667,
-0.0038524088449776173,
0.14693357050418854,
0.15922105312347412,
0.07857437431812286,
-0.07166194915771484,
0.49385640025138855,
-0.5347683429718018,
-0.3955390453338623,
-0.36460646986961365,
-0.029324611648917198,
0.23822906613349915,
0.3606908321380615,
0.16745901107788086,
-0.3776532709598541,
-0.5926789045333862,
0.07220146805047989,
-0.3629145622253418,
-0.3624596893787384,
-0.07424933463335037,
-0.3161531686782837,
0.20089754462242126,
0.6619911789894104,
-0.2690574526786804,
0.1940573900938034,
0.5997757911682129,
-0.12659549713134766,
0.3164570927619934,
-0.36888712644577026,
0.13360245525836945,
-0.992537260055542,
-0.1886712908744812,
-0.0819699615240097,
-0.22627218067646027,
-0.6122048497200012,
0.178925558924675,
0.29878368973731995,
0.2536238133907318,
-0.7190144658088684,
0.4806731343269348,
-0.5208513140678406,
0.08242087811231613,
-0.6146471500396729,
0.2341361939907074,
0.21042287349700928,
0.7536323666572571,
-0.0876646414399147,
0.8669899106025696,
0.39424192905426025,
-0.4960939586162567,
0.08559224754571915,
0.16964681446552277,
-0.3550463318824768,
0.468504399061203,
-0.4922572076320648,
0.20985765755176544,
-0.028825290501117706,
0.038624927401542664,
-0.7706024050712585,
-0.11533655226230621,
0.5361011028289795,
-0.25277605652809143,
0.7474623918533325,
-0.24787066876888275,
-0.3429681062698364,
0.04841286689043045,
-0.23670415580272675,
0.20273277163505554,
0.6395326256752014,
-0.5958840250968933,
0.29113736748695374,
-0.1285446733236313,
-0.12199664860963821,
-0.41565608978271484,
-0.7042569518089294,
-0.06768848747015,
-0.08621252328157425,
-0.17492958903312683,
0.3916826844215393,
-0.0702950656414032,
0.051449112594127655,
-0.24029336869716644,
-0.18242678046226501,
0.08869243413209915,
-0.09972353279590607,
-0.05145324394106865,
0.25268545746803284,
-0.13995808362960815,
-0.008525938726961613,
0.43451255559921265,
-0.12928883731365204,
-0.10446759313344955,
-0.4100321829319,
0.420893132686615,
0.015121843665838242,
-0.56205815076828,
-0.5358008146286011,
0.16744767129421234,
0.30588141083717346,
-0.36794978380203247,
0.7464710474014282,
0.626650333404541,
-0.058014433830976486,
-0.21875318884849548,
-0.5266335010528564,
-0.3390273153781891,
-0.487591028213501,
0.6087488532066345,
-0.23928555846214294,
-0.6480785012245178,
0.3832284212112427,
-0.09907098859548569,
0.28921034932136536,
0.08575735241174698,
0.5466486215591431,
-0.2050458937883377,
1.1670496463775635,
0.5902324318885803,
-0.045730218291282654,
0.6446722149848938,
-0.43793925642967224,
0.02036953903734684,
-1.0738695859909058,
-0.1454155147075653,
-0.229352667927742,
-0.5065053701400757,
-0.504938542842865,
-0.6340193152427673,
0.3335360586643219,
0.372536838054657,
-0.008357429876923561,
0.5184581279754639,
-0.32009249925613403,
0.6179074645042419,
0.5461587309837341,
0.2462112009525299,
0.329275518655777,
0.012586427852511406,
-0.13933244347572327,
-0.09744040668010712,
-0.914153516292572,
-0.46302399039268494,
0.9437748193740845,
0.17002174258232117,
0.9328010678291321,
0.062095873057842255,
0.7690912485122681,
-0.009339756332337856,
0.17824052274227142,
-0.8800342679023743,
0.5784436464309692,
-0.3642001152038574,
-0.2518022358417511,
-0.21228806674480438,
-0.4824932813644409,
-0.77398681640625,
0.0507601797580719,
-0.02372788079082966,
-0.44195687770843506,
-0.09885161370038986,
0.42138373851776123,
-0.3325732946395874,
0.2840423882007599,
-0.5559477210044861,
0.7149673700332642,
-0.47947320342063904,
-0.42896270751953125,
-0.24709366261959076,
-0.6323800086975098,
0.13190136849880219,
-0.13293659687042236,
0.08458076417446136,
-0.14811207354068756,
-0.18404127657413483,
0.33178505301475525,
-0.21297895908355713,
0.9277059435844421,
-0.10387888550758362,
-0.484173983335495,
0.2725540101528168,
0.09425552934408188,
0.9160207509994507,
-0.21580497920513153,
-0.19157293438911438,
0.023455021902918816,
-0.37397822737693787,
-0.4281422793865204,
-0.7203256487846375,
0.8321810364723206,
-0.5542997717857361,
-0.7807478904724121,
0.1270747184753418,
-0.7079548835754395,
-0.28510135412216187,
0.24045535922050476,
0.5457710027694702,
0.4818170666694641,
-0.0697583481669426,
-0.055576421320438385,
0.8679261803627014,
-0.19698628783226013,
0.329245388507843,
0.8136034607887268,
-0.04502537474036217,
-0.23453094065189362,
1.0794756412506104,
0.1642352193593979,
0.569755494594574,
0.6219437718391418,
0.1985093355178833,
-0.37696385383605957,
-0.7598748207092285,
-0.8921617865562439,
0.0987001284956932,
-0.5567454099655151,
-0.41151925921440125,
-0.03266197070479393,
-0.013502073474228382,
-0.23359791934490204,
-0.28151747584342957,
-0.5703911185264587,
-0.22302106022834778,
-0.5397248864173889,
0.21576425433158875,
0.37798821926116943,
0.5728480219841003,
0.2372492551803589,
0.46257251501083374,
-0.8605823516845703,
0.11490797996520996,
0.1031053215265274,
0.2920243442058563,
-0.10354343056678772,
-1.138102412223816,
-0.4139143228530884,
0.30855587124824524,
-0.40667542815208435,
-0.7666575908660889,
0.2688063383102417,
0.44486457109451294,
0.47985801100730896,
0.5437660813331604,
0.026870910078287125,
0.8281622529029846,
-0.6934787034988403,
0.33306124806404114,
-0.0785459503531456,
-0.8042538166046143,
0.82989901304245,
-0.2439095377922058,
0.7548084259033203,
0.4719885587692261,
0.18575027585029602,
-0.21715529263019562,
-0.6648679971694946,
-0.05759386345744133,
-0.5662626028060913,
0.8450141549110413,
0.13318617641925812,
0.12427681684494019,
-0.020422330126166344,
0.6114036440849304,
0.05747963860630989,
-0.026278285309672356,
-0.3147754967212677,
-0.2066418081521988,
0.08111440390348434,
-0.3978944420814514,
-0.06147598847746849,
-0.07689584791660309,
0.02125704474747181,
-0.04683137312531471,
0.908257246017456,
-0.30333858728408813,
-0.14633506536483765,
-0.1886562556028366,
-0.2120702713727951,
-0.39347875118255615,
0.28879067301750183,
0.7795270681381226,
0.41272270679473877,
-0.17042814195156097,
-0.1166863664984703,
0.465536504983902,
-0.4397944509983063,
0.36047303676605225,
0.02346576377749443,
-0.4928717315196991,
-0.23985818028450012,
0.31304553151130676,
1.0244263410568237,
0.3852326273918152,
-0.6220462918281555,
0.3238826096057892,
0.10428693890571594,
0.03236629068851471,
0.12381131201982498,
0.3386681377887726,
0.07433789223432541,
0.4772992730140686,
0.19214385747909546,
0.13254669308662415,
-0.109243243932724,
-0.3448854982852936,
-0.09663529694080353,
0.5565888285636902,
-0.46195927262306213,
-0.30118468403816223,
0.5826106667518616,
0.18662361800670624,
-0.4503122568130493,
0.3821974992752075,
-0.34432196617126465,
-0.3688015937805176,
0.36849847435951233,
0.7115975022315979,
0.653465747833252,
-0.41696852445602417,
0.062073346227407455,
0.16711443662643433,
0.45821771025657654,
-0.24129663407802582,
0.1274055540561676,
-0.08977187424898148,
-0.5482279658317566,
-0.5728186964988708,
-0.5848298072814941,
-0.3429815173149109,
-0.037506017833948135,
-0.8411229252815247,
0.3846987783908844,
-0.21596328914165497,
-0.03705203905701637,
-0.5998439788818359,
0.03522871434688568,
-0.47308316826820374,
0.016530118882656097,
0.015270557254552841,
0.8107374310493469,
-0.5454675555229187,
1.0184890031814575,
0.62713223695755,
-0.05668191984295845,
-0.7272708415985107,
0.2123822420835495,
0.033882882446050644,
-1.0308492183685303,
0.20096522569656372,
0.13808196783065796,
-0.40326181054115295,
0.4425612688064575,
-0.3861962854862213,
-0.8037241101264954,
1.1395403146743774,
0.5965448617935181,
-1.1089390516281128,
0.033865850418806076,
0.07256878167390823,
0.31282517313957214,
-0.23126915097236633,
-0.08313153684139252,
0.6556519865989685,
0.3112304210662842,
0.2575589716434479,
-0.5538026690483093,
0.03814749792218208,
0.13546909391880035,
0.0948140099644661,
0.3836362361907959,
-0.7131590843200684,
0.33297547698020935,
-0.521793782711029,
-0.03842705115675926,
0.3409439027309418,
0.5212743878364563,
0.31223902106285095,
0.07080000638961792,
0.3446451425552368,
0.5191518664360046,
0.49633803963661194,
0.05865075811743736,
0.8908661007881165,
-0.44225841760635376,
0.07540730386972427,
1.2171509265899658,
-0.08168262988328934,
0.9546295404434204,
0.5803837776184082,
0.2298702895641327,
0.18391475081443787,
0.49769797921180725,
0.19957338273525238,
0.8559454679489136,
0.06886540353298187,
-0.2645654082298279,
-0.21132735908031464,
-0.12715889513492584,
-0.30457359552383423,
0.6063902378082275,
0.4065627157688141,
-0.43847712874412537,
-0.013034692965447903,
0.1455671340227127,
0.064694844186306,
0.14943616092205048,
-0.4682398736476898,
0.717319667339325,
0.12376753240823746,
-0.8148772120475769,
0.8596360087394714,
0.22975800931453705,
0.6269961595535278,
-0.7145631313323975,
-0.16265757381916046,
-0.4181777238845825,
0.17699211835861206,
0.050992246717214584,
-0.6187524795532227,
0.10282791405916214,
0.2172413021326065,
-0.11150450259447098,
-0.3057003319263458,
0.4694095551967621,
-0.8793131709098816,
-0.5514306426048279,
0.208110049366951,
0.35079100728034973,
0.03087417408823967,
0.15780453383922577,
-0.575593888759613,
0.3098893463611603,
0.23829799890518188,
-0.32475095987319946,
0.45798322558403015,
0.3529502749443054,
0.03151242807507515,
0.5446622967720032,
0.4132872223854065,
0.27022695541381836,
0.09185805171728134,
0.25298434495925903,
0.5926315188407898,
-0.4507993459701538,
-0.22865359485149384,
-0.8512968420982361,
0.19334404170513153,
0.3753199875354767,
-0.312376469373703,
0.7819287776947021,
0.17212970554828644,
0.835662841796875,
0.008974753320217133,
0.24033710360527039,
0.2816677689552307,
0.31161144375801086,
-0.8487499952316284,
0.6535518169403076,
-0.7513678073883057,
0.5043486952781677,
-0.06695100665092468,
-1.0504581928253174,
-0.3068539798259735,
0.5548480153083801,
-0.2711319029331207,
0.025245169177651405,
0.24531486630439758,
1.1569229364395142,
-0.0665726438164711,
-0.25182265043258667,
0.49489283561706543,
0.15989887714385986,
0.1141895279288292,
0.6708667874336243,
0.589396595954895,
-0.5131310224533081,
0.8171558380126953,
-0.20521335303783417,
-0.2452854961156845,
-0.3935123383998871,
-0.7448007464408875,
-0.8079385161399841,
-0.08818624168634415,
-0.32124799489974976,
0.02710546739399433,
0.38444533944129944,
0.9608030915260315,
0.599904477596283,
-0.8017851710319519,
-0.13308103382587433,
-0.256401389837265,
0.06005926802754402,
-0.393917441368103,
-0.12300118058919907,
0.24987363815307617,
-0.3816778063774109,
-0.8542554378509521,
0.8055249452590942,
0.3992011547088623,
0.14049369096755981,
-0.21136239171028137,
-0.4184958338737488,
-0.23624339699745178,
0.18213151395320892,
0.5694330334663391,
0.22438840568065643,
-0.8831711411476135,
-0.2599073350429535,
0.2463713437318802,
-0.2699553966522217,
-0.07883799076080322,
0.4143391251564026,
-0.3979381322860718,
0.5072665810585022,
0.22263126075267792,
0.6319984197616577,
0.35371512174606323,
0.02904358133673668,
0.5473730564117432,
-1.0910884141921997,
0.09044903516769409,
0.08891128748655319,
0.234287828207016,
0.36131325364112854,
-0.41742125153541565,
0.2290419191122055,
-0.26414015889167786,
-0.51622074842453,
-0.4948359429836273,
0.26598864793777466,
-0.5849833488464355,
-0.042573947459459305,
1.070125699043274,
-0.2388845980167389,
-0.13469398021697998,
0.30170005559921265,
-0.2875522971153259,
0.5188180208206177,
-0.3319176435470581,
0.7224277853965759,
0.4558938145637512,
-0.15865115821361542,
-0.2840158939361572,
-0.5661242604255676,
0.3367866575717926,
0.8313305377960205,
-0.4679323434829712,
-0.173417866230011,
0.35221734642982483,
0.17470142245292664,
-0.2834531366825104,
0.3019202649593353,
0.02676423266530037,
0.32783591747283936,
-0.3357789218425751,
-0.14306248724460602,
-0.26198890805244446,
-0.40561291575431824,
-0.4617935121059418,
-0.29615405201911926,
0.3469330966472626,
-0.46624282002449036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14390v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14390v1
|
From Large to Tiny: Distilling and Refining Mathematical Expertise for Math Word Problems with Weakly Supervision
| 2024-03-21T13:29:54 | 2024-03-21T13:29:54 |
Qingwen Lin, Boyan Xu, Zhengting Huang, Ruichu Cai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Addressing the challenge of high annotation costs in solving Math Word
Problems (MWPs) through full supervision with intermediate equations, recent
works have proposed weakly supervised task settings that rely solely on the
final answer as a supervised signal. Existing leading approaches typically
employ various search techniques to infer intermediate equations, but cannot
ensure their semantic consistency with natural language descriptions. The rise
of Large Language Models (LLMs) like ChatGPT has opened up new possibilities
for addressing MWPs directly. However, the computational demands of LLMs make
them less than ideal for use in settings where resources are tight. In light of
these challenges, we introduce an innovative two-stage framework that adeptly
transfers mathematical Expertise from large to tiny language models. In
\emph{Distillation Stage}, we propose a series of extraction processes that
satisfy the properties of MWPs to distill mathematical knowledge from LLMs to
construct problem-equation pairs required for supervised training. In
\emph{Refinement Stage}, Due to Knowledge distilling method cannot guarantee
the full utilization of all data, we further utilize the unsuccessfully
searched data effectively by Knowledge Refine method. Finally, We train a small
model using distilled data generated through two-stage methods. As our method
fully leverages the semantic understanding capabilities during the searching
'problem-equation' pair, it demonstrates significantly improved performance on
the Math23K and Weak12K datasets compared to existing small model methods,
while maintaining a much lower computational cost than ChatGPT.
|
[
-0.3735920786857605,
-1.026911735534668,
0.6614108085632324,
0.23108847439289093,
-0.22908687591552734,
-0.04388574883341789,
-0.5203010439872742,
-0.21727228164672852,
-0.0729508027434349,
0.21994954347610474,
-0.728261411190033,
-0.09538476914167404,
-1.0564700365066528,
-0.027699289843440056,
-0.18351688981056213,
1.0426747798919678,
-0.09511804580688477,
0.09712973982095718,
-0.31824663281440735,
0.192512646317482,
-0.2999299168586731,
-0.20200079679489136,
-0.9840482473373413,
-0.4859144985675812,
0.45944344997406006,
0.6715267300605774,
0.8402876853942871,
0.43997564911842346,
0.8035808205604553,
0.38272738456726074,
-0.20310437679290771,
0.22528085112571716,
-0.6798139810562134,
-0.09957137703895569,
-0.17763596773147583,
-0.5747827887535095,
-0.29348888993263245,
-0.01253049261868,
0.1911604106426239,
1.2648853063583374,
-0.1843278706073761,
0.3740643262863159,
0.35381805896759033,
0.7077488899230957,
-0.4631098806858063,
0.7962069511413574,
-0.8801127672195435,
-0.019667621701955795,
-0.24919334053993225,
0.19417190551757812,
-0.2524413466453552,
-0.15300752222537994,
0.44477811455726624,
-0.6801041960716248,
0.3617929220199585,
-0.17518678307533264,
0.6497867703437805,
0.5278899669647217,
-0.32213282585144043,
-0.5555623769760132,
-0.6427594423294067,
1.044612169265747,
-0.5776153206825256,
-0.16065745055675507,
0.5310143828392029,
0.41526028513908386,
-0.23056504130363464,
-0.9168044328689575,
-0.22781428694725037,
0.0025405636988580227,
-0.11520051956176758,
-0.06955084204673767,
-0.42970529198646545,
-0.005389400292187929,
0.558621346950531,
0.3344326615333557,
0.027168700471520424,
0.03424425795674324,
-0.6822422742843628,
-0.12884992361068726,
0.6968064904212952,
0.07689595222473145,
0.04158681258559227,
-0.024067137390375137,
0.018428605049848557,
0.12496283650398254,
-0.5376928448677063,
-0.28994616866111755,
0.20559626817703247,
0.45596447587013245,
-0.07833430916070938,
0.7519239187240601,
-0.09191378951072693,
0.40454670786857605,
0.002843635156750679,
-0.43840399384498596,
-0.13076432049274445,
-0.2104567587375641,
-0.06996876746416092,
-0.04836120083928108,
0.5530063509941101,
-0.11021334677934647,
0.4958450496196747,
-0.11023380607366562,
-0.2588180601596832,
0.25101128220558167,
0.0782628208398819,
-0.952262282371521,
-0.6254630088806152,
-0.2681313455104828,
-0.13311921060085297,
-0.33037304878234863,
-0.33281758427619934,
-0.7908909320831299,
-0.347258985042572,
-0.8887792229652405,
0.6703298687934875,
-0.2650061547756195,
-0.12466146051883698,
0.05627422034740448,
0.131360724568367,
-0.37735873460769653,
0.4071360230445862,
-0.9819225072860718,
0.5230774283409119,
0.8902051448822021,
0.8461009860038757,
0.16119897365570068,
0.18135234713554382,
-0.5334252119064331,
-0.15992841124534607,
-0.496543288230896,
0.3547927141189575,
-0.29347309470176697,
-0.45055609941482544,
-0.03341769427061081,
-0.33409371972084045,
0.13222350180149078,
-0.6838942766189575,
0.6208202838897705,
-0.3175146281719208,
0.1364668756723404,
-0.0832371711730957,
-0.44646427035331726,
0.02633487619459629,
-0.010699096135795116,
-0.5000960230827332,
1.0960407257080078,
0.2064194232225418,
-0.8266810774803162,
0.138451486825943,
-0.6135460138320923,
-0.35782137513160706,
0.03655421361327171,
-0.09658052027225494,
-0.48708584904670715,
0.5938734412193298,
0.3426591157913208,
0.3127577304840088,
-0.5298664569854736,
0.2165689766407013,
-0.4765501320362091,
-0.16187697649002075,
-0.058698613196611404,
-0.43091925978660583,
0.6016079783439636,
0.12636207044124603,
-0.043379295617341995,
-0.25355735421180725,
-0.7485004663467407,
-0.08036891371011734,
0.30128180980682373,
0.11965235322713852,
-0.5531327724456787,
0.02881508506834507,
-0.4094712734222412,
0.22031600773334503,
0.5865710377693176,
-0.40775996446609497,
0.2703968584537506,
-0.39215588569641113,
0.6569254994392395,
0.6631872057914734,
0.07412857562303543,
0.6740226745605469,
-0.0007262397557497025,
0.22956353425979614,
-0.045311301946640015,
0.1786165088415146,
0.13562938570976257,
-0.7048614025115967,
-0.9681807160377502,
-0.21919655799865723,
0.3558763861656189,
0.30734527111053467,
-1.0709505081176758,
0.1153147965669632,
-0.29302772879600525,
-0.4168667197227478,
-0.505405843257904,
0.635077953338623,
0.4336939752101898,
0.6868926286697388,
0.5073637962341309,
0.19251836836338043,
-0.3191254138946533,
-0.9934311509132385,
-0.02318195253610611,
0.02141048200428486,
-0.24063873291015625,
0.2258998453617096,
0.4652623236179352,
-0.05583444610238075,
0.9579898118972778,
-1.0399889945983887,
-0.873309850692749,
-0.06056325510144234,
0.5518593788146973,
0.4199710488319397,
0.3794306814670563,
0.3564903140068054,
-0.7954741716384888,
-0.6548054814338684,
-0.0507170632481575,
-0.6465222835540771,
-0.2931464612483978,
0.2416834980249405,
-0.2103704810142517,
-0.1737605482339859,
0.6191605925559998,
-0.43444931507110596,
0.44638368487358093,
0.4655906856060028,
-0.043618589639663696,
0.23080946505069733,
-0.30857065320014954,
-0.3370893597602844,
-1.0829837322235107,
-0.19439712166786194,
0.27544498443603516,
-0.08444081246852875,
-0.3325195908546448,
0.06714318692684174,
-0.03628601133823395,
-0.23769983649253845,
-0.1568557769060135,
0.26164206862449646,
-0.6133926510810852,
0.20235902070999146,
-0.3647717237472534,
0.3940723240375519,
-0.10947003215551376,
0.5597947835922241,
-0.13008800148963928,
0.6686245799064636,
0.5799729824066162,
-0.35094940662384033,
0.6129187345504761,
0.06634767353534698,
-0.05859925225377083,
0.5018887519836426,
-0.6659948825836182,
0.11460402607917786,
-0.021826807409524918,
-0.15264464914798737,
-1.1254500150680542,
-0.06108894199132919,
-0.07594427466392517,
-0.3670557141304016,
0.48300036787986755,
-0.7579045295715332,
-0.8799496293067932,
-0.4570271968841553,
-0.1807033121585846,
0.3412971794605255,
0.8089584708213806,
-0.4390203356742859,
0.5491324663162231,
0.37452006340026855,
-0.658142626285553,
-0.21707454323768616,
-0.6574453115463257,
0.025776240974664688,
-0.28190523386001587,
-0.6092314720153809,
0.1220066174864769,
0.20296534895896912,
-0.4590778946876526,
0.1787671595811844,
-0.3867015838623047,
-0.3961193263530731,
0.05644216760993004,
0.05718638375401497,
0.5583688020706177,
-0.12157648056745529,
0.2745673656463623,
0.31417161226272583,
-0.5248830914497375,
0.2889792323112488,
-0.4605647921562195,
0.22004704177379608,
0.12322816252708435,
-0.20649871230125427,
-0.10235700756311417,
0.1765965223312378,
0.2592672109603882,
-0.11903467774391174,
0.6491336226463318,
0.5818317532539368,
-0.647537112236023,
-0.4082755446434021,
-0.4491061866283417,
-0.45570796728134155,
-0.5132603049278259,
0.3967219889163971,
-0.5199601650238037,
-0.8568036556243896,
0.42101380228996277,
-0.4301479756832123,
0.30707046389579773,
0.6074512600898743,
0.5610182881355286,
0.05202580988407135,
1.1957833766937256,
0.6617263555526733,
0.06168156489729881,
0.4231417179107666,
-0.3519003391265869,
0.41304105520248413,
-0.6169129610061646,
-0.07408598065376282,
-0.5629451870918274,
-0.5213654637336731,
-0.23165534436702728,
-0.589418351650238,
0.5967401266098022,
0.4137122333049774,
0.1478598713874817,
0.24574844539165497,
-0.47780588269233704,
0.5397248268127441,
0.31378424167633057,
0.06411271542310715,
0.3630008399486542,
0.13535800576210022,
-0.13974234461784363,
-0.5599564909934998,
-0.621428906917572,
-0.2212725281715393,
1.2264131307601929,
0.2395714372396469,
0.9822156429290771,
0.21272140741348267,
0.7262543439865112,
-0.07191328704357147,
0.49190112948417664,
-1.1081169843673706,
0.4321063160896301,
-0.3600624203681946,
-0.6156737804412842,
-0.34527871012687683,
-0.8174039125442505,
-0.7422787547111511,
0.3213053345680237,
-0.12009169906377792,
-0.8844266533851624,
-0.17956218123435974,
0.1041037067770958,
-0.2763462960720062,
0.10615626722574234,
-1.1663568019866943,
0.6344804167747498,
0.18983285129070282,
-0.6408960819244385,
-0.32383230328559875,
-0.4133732318878174,
0.584915280342102,
-0.45006564259529114,
0.5420352816581726,
-0.22028110921382904,
-0.1362067610025406,
0.7226001620292664,
-0.8700284361839294,
0.8783613443374634,
-0.24430912733078003,
-0.4039927124977112,
0.4772827923297882,
0.398506760597229,
0.5948202610015869,
0.38715118169784546,
0.23996606469154358,
-0.1161535307765007,
0.1328970342874527,
-0.4518073797225952,
-0.8314833045005798,
0.87689608335495,
-0.6007248759269714,
-0.6026942729949951,
-0.21161945164203644,
-0.5769245028495789,
-0.506509006023407,
0.16074202954769135,
0.05439143627882004,
0.4902417063713074,
0.4401649236679077,
0.22465012967586517,
0.8599599599838257,
0.4000996947288513,
0.43478450179100037,
0.20394955575466156,
-0.18943095207214355,
-0.24027086794376373,
0.9271150827407837,
0.34843623638153076,
0.18259750306606293,
0.23460166156291962,
0.4461826682090759,
-0.4618300795555115,
-0.3747057020664215,
-0.19332484900951385,
0.2749883234500885,
-0.7054510712623596,
-0.4360751807689667,
-0.3169679641723633,
-0.2275916486978531,
-0.18380779027938843,
-0.03716110438108444,
-0.6569150686264038,
-0.5987167954444885,
-0.41145646572113037,
0.16774733364582062,
0.5038079023361206,
0.40844428539276123,
-0.23159295320510864,
0.33665046095848083,
-0.7335768938064575,
0.6094127297401428,
0.5402758121490479,
0.10378330945968628,
0.018336884677410126,
-0.8282869458198547,
-0.3023192584514618,
0.10479849576950073,
-0.27058953046798706,
-0.4439152777194977,
0.17829936742782593,
0.22188274562358856,
0.10387666523456573,
0.531615674495697,
0.22175563871860504,
1.0302456617355347,
-0.6767833828926086,
0.3992449641227722,
0.4188394248485565,
-1.0187819004058838,
0.43738627433776855,
-0.016638321802020073,
0.009003200568258762,
0.5984904170036316,
0.3174327611923218,
-0.17355649173259735,
-0.1349184513092041,
-0.7569588422775269,
-0.8178415298461914,
0.7743104696273804,
0.4120948612689972,
0.19508269429206848,
0.2932318449020386,
0.4687456488609314,
0.0006583998329006135,
0.09148062020540237,
-0.23752659559249878,
-0.06568506360054016,
0.41347843408584595,
-0.40543413162231445,
-0.1424512416124344,
-0.2682349383831024,
-0.5011736750602722,
-0.3904110789299011,
0.6538461446762085,
-0.2587641775608063,
0.008128253743052483,
-0.08591336756944656,
-0.09842178225517273,
0.019625766202807426,
0.08600735664367676,
0.11872220039367676,
0.7755910754203796,
0.11160626262426376,
0.301009863615036,
0.38751959800720215,
-0.6053941249847412,
-0.030608851462602615,
0.38128405809402466,
0.017039792612195015,
0.010647797957062721,
0.49334582686424255,
0.3681291937828064,
0.6438405513763428,
-0.31532004475593567,
0.6187207698822021,
0.025839203968644142,
-0.4240368604660034,
-0.24140110611915588,
-0.00911207776516676,
0.24668480455875397,
0.15412189066410065,
0.42778775095939636,
0.00351583119481802,
0.22448000311851501,
-0.2873219847679138,
0.08321071416139603,
0.2107091099023819,
-0.33903494477272034,
-0.25478649139404297,
0.5569408535957336,
0.07104317098855972,
-0.047498106956481934,
0.5844640731811523,
-0.19402272999286652,
-0.24809129536151886,
0.5046864748001099,
0.35370513796806335,
0.5447520017623901,
0.2366359382867813,
-0.006948151625692844,
0.29129528999328613,
0.05528900399804115,
-0.2953649163246155,
-0.014726942405104637,
-0.19136500358581543,
-0.3674978017807007,
-0.6890109777450562,
-0.558355987071991,
-0.35737499594688416,
-0.16477002203464508,
-0.8166149258613586,
0.4045571982860565,
-0.5015560388565063,
-0.23792418837547302,
0.33407726883888245,
0.3551631569862366,
-0.5869466066360474,
0.004762559197843075,
0.16998732089996338,
0.6108431816101074,
-0.7087103724479675,
0.7311020493507385,
0.6309596300125122,
-0.30156153440475464,
-1.0553550720214844,
-0.3835364580154419,
0.2610461413860321,
-0.8992593288421631,
0.7039791941642761,
-0.29220566153526306,
-0.08046535402536392,
0.13336513936519623,
-0.6517940759658813,
-0.6054581999778748,
0.9197664856910706,
0.3749406933784485,
-0.7515246868133545,
-0.27203845977783203,
-0.04931364580988884,
0.554754376411438,
0.03331276401877403,
0.022731956094503403,
0.6373687386512756,
0.17919516563415527,
0.655738890171051,
-0.9792280793190002,
-0.16187185049057007,
-0.08353449404239655,
0.1561751514673233,
0.41659659147262573,
-0.5630791187286377,
0.9241735339164734,
-0.23922398686408997,
-0.04884814843535423,
0.09874531626701355,
0.6729558110237122,
0.10394342988729477,
0.364045113325119,
0.3261236250400543,
0.7601996660232544,
0.5443347692489624,
-0.4690709412097931,
0.5916362404823303,
-0.07904445379972458,
0.7767079472541809,
1.1357120275497437,
-0.0029796562157571316,
0.7363665103912354,
0.7462668418884277,
-0.5955540537834167,
0.02418854832649231,
0.3350062072277069,
0.1490728259086609,
0.44896477460861206,
0.5327897667884827,
-0.30453765392303467,
-0.2717092037200928,
0.009712274186313152,
-0.3856561481952667,
0.1496420055627823,
0.553128182888031,
-0.040728792548179626,
-0.6560964584350586,
-0.08639995008707047,
0.30599045753479004,
0.2522297203540802,
-0.40700075030326843,
0.8025916814804077,
0.5683548450469971,
-0.3839073181152344,
0.24614621698856354,
0.08055993169546127,
0.5476603507995605,
-0.7892265915870667,
-0.08842337876558304,
-0.2489001601934433,
0.500259518623352,
-0.19621160626411438,
-0.5773603320121765,
0.2596870958805084,
0.11858565360307693,
-0.025313161313533783,
-0.15337054431438446,
0.6592344641685486,
-0.45346611738204956,
-0.9698501229286194,
0.05938010662794113,
0.5856102108955383,
0.06951345503330231,
-0.15871012210845947,
-0.5894424915313721,
-0.10191810876131058,
-0.17364579439163208,
0.04103373736143112,
0.30413490533828735,
1.1664787530899048,
-0.018097640946507454,
0.5172427296638489,
0.6952582001686096,
0.2165347933769226,
0.14704172313213348,
0.21299690008163452,
1.1352075338363647,
-0.14638084173202515,
-0.3312342166900635,
-1.002742886543274,
0.2548079788684845,
-0.12413801997900009,
-0.25536537170410156,
0.7285877466201782,
0.47206658124923706,
0.6304959654808044,
-0.02234179899096489,
0.4601626992225647,
-0.06360536813735962,
0.47239750623703003,
-0.4785480201244354,
0.511898398399353,
-0.5059313774108887,
0.2718704044818878,
-0.4023039937019348,
-1.0790817737579346,
-0.3598844110965729,
0.6083731651306152,
-0.6491847634315491,
-0.12675151228904724,
0.7284134030342102,
0.4423866868019104,
-0.2926449179649353,
0.027242742478847504,
0.2497514933347702,
0.1285695880651474,
0.3750223219394684,
0.8034681677818298,
0.6870949864387512,
-0.3748645484447479,
0.7640170454978943,
-0.5947437286376953,
-0.48916229605674744,
-0.08052752166986465,
-0.7288587689399719,
-0.9412580728530884,
-0.3180614411830902,
-0.6119968295097351,
-0.2923184633255005,
-0.42374876141548157,
0.8164493441581726,
0.6965210437774658,
-0.6175000071525574,
0.07062918692827225,
-0.18913301825523376,
0.02992722950875759,
-0.10546883195638657,
-0.2474522888660431,
0.41149160265922546,
-0.7462879419326782,
-0.9304677844047546,
-0.016704507172107697,
0.20853357017040253,
-0.005262959748506546,
-0.2793255150318146,
0.34374484419822693,
0.2768455445766449,
-0.028694065287709236,
0.5921053290367126,
0.018382616341114044,
-0.4131729304790497,
-0.02006588689982891,
-0.29279664158821106,
-0.16622643172740936,
-0.2388933002948761,
0.8666556477546692,
-0.42355093359947205,
0.4093800485134125,
0.20940010249614716,
0.648948073387146,
0.8233495950698853,
-0.13576741516590118,
0.18452823162078857,
-0.8087535500526428,
0.5025257468223572,
0.24507133662700653,
0.3951013684272766,
0.08945164084434509,
-0.21036909520626068,
0.6094284653663635,
0.47308018803596497,
-0.2461903691291809,
-0.7529420256614685,
0.18415381014347076,
-0.820404052734375,
-0.16858841478824615,
1.0468239784240723,
-0.3107864558696747,
-0.15473267436027527,
0.06923431903123856,
-0.44143709540367126,
0.13839378952980042,
-0.2418452799320221,
0.914918839931488,
0.9717537760734558,
-0.04610057175159454,
-0.056225501000881195,
-0.6597386598587036,
0.48092716932296753,
0.39841771125793457,
-0.6171594262123108,
0.062293071299791336,
0.3946828544139862,
0.1186416819691658,
0.2894338071346283,
0.14774921536445618,
-0.40670323371887207,
-0.2089017778635025,
0.3670121729373932,
-0.4584249258041382,
-0.19124627113342285,
-0.2800763249397278,
-0.02035265788435936,
0.19021359086036682,
0.1757211536169052,
-0.16330984234809875
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14381v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14381v2
|
Editing Knowledge Representation of Language Model via Rephrased Prefix Prompts
| 2024-03-21T13:15:25 | 2024-05-11T13:51:32 |
Yuchen Cai, Ding Cao, Rongxi Guo, Yaqin Wen, Guiquan Liu, Enhong Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Neural language models (LMs) have been extensively trained on vast corpora to
store factual knowledge about various aspects of the world described in texts.
Current technologies typically employ knowledge editing methods or specific
prompts to modify LM outputs. However, existing knowledge editing methods are
costly and inefficient, struggling to produce appropriate text. Additionally,
prompt engineering is opaque and requires significant effort to find suitable
prompts. To address these issues, we introduce a new method called PSPEM
(Prefix Soft Prompt Editing Method), that can be used for a lifetime with just
one training. It resolves the inefficiencies and generalizability issues in
knowledge editing methods and overcomes the opacity of prompt engineering by
automatically seeking optimal soft prompts. Specifically, PSPEM utilizes a
prompt encoder and an encoding converter to refine key information in prompts
and uses prompt alignment techniques to guide model generation, ensuring text
consistency and adherence to the intended structure and content, thereby
maintaining an optimal balance between efficiency and accuracy. We have
validated the effectiveness of PSPEM through knowledge editing and attribute
inserting. On the COUNTERFACT dataset, PSPEM achieved nearly 100\% editing
accuracy and demonstrated the highest level of fluency. We further analyzed the
similarities between PSPEM and original prompts and their impact on the model's
internals. The results indicate that PSPEM can serve as an alternative to
original prompts, supporting the model in effective editing.
|
[
-0.06321670860052109,
-0.6987579464912415,
0.8457893133163452,
0.04476478695869446,
-0.12907196581363678,
0.027637382969260216,
-0.5838128924369812,
0.1311025768518448,
0.0855213925242424,
0.4979325830936432,
-0.6749532222747803,
-0.47446244955062866,
-0.2721470892429352,
0.28003230690956116,
0.14977923035621643,
0.6525946855545044,
-0.055153265595436096,
0.23635448515415192,
-0.34044286608695984,
0.02617412619292736,
-0.7216979265213013,
-0.7806178331375122,
-0.6343802213668823,
-0.2614002525806427,
0.4241538345813751,
0.36568763852119446,
0.8457261323928833,
0.28393691778182983,
-0.03585389629006386,
0.346861869096756,
-0.5337682962417603,
0.49999937415122986,
-0.2286561280488968,
0.2397441565990448,
-0.40828537940979004,
-0.20772691071033478,
-0.4686235189437866,
-0.013536624610424042,
0.7941076159477234,
0.8180030584335327,
0.022388393059372902,
-0.1601872444152832,
0.3027106821537018,
0.3530234396457672,
-0.3607957065105438,
0.14280693233013153,
-0.6760441064834595,
0.05142291635274887,
0.11980748921632767,
-0.3610461354255676,
-0.6458353996276855,
-0.5641680955886841,
0.10807076096534729,
-0.6858221888542175,
0.09200301021337509,
-0.08842234313488007,
0.6808849573135376,
0.04265384003520012,
-0.18085557222366333,
-0.0981118455529213,
-0.5655906200408936,
0.6071110367774963,
-0.8526902198791504,
0.35936012864112854,
0.19415992498397827,
0.027034878730773926,
-0.49638643860816956,
-0.8677135109901428,
-0.7074565887451172,
-0.30208519101142883,
-0.18738791346549988,
-0.14453467726707458,
-0.09846042096614838,
0.33512526750564575,
0.36861172318458557,
0.03995709866285324,
-0.3537128269672394,
-0.04056346416473389,
-0.32338401675224304,
-0.4484902024269104,
0.31160876154899597,
0.28432005643844604,
0.6094056963920593,
-0.25414443016052246,
-0.37876924872398376,
0.14345388114452362,
-0.7389031052589417,
0.023975662887096405,
0.3794260025024414,
0.5330032110214233,
0.46662643551826477,
0.5423828959465027,
-0.14228801429271698,
0.8454049825668335,
0.14619691669940948,
-0.2473943531513214,
0.24714821577072144,
-0.1822018176317215,
-0.2353333830833435,
0.07236601412296295,
0.8222900032997131,
0.3721790909767151,
0.21872667968273163,
-0.25518107414245605,
-0.3088757395744324,
-0.3039395213127136,
0.3283790647983551,
-0.6558540463447571,
0.02391551062464714,
-0.011247939430177212,
-0.38617947697639465,
-0.06507403403520584,
-0.09255668520927429,
-0.5130825638771057,
-0.6513361930847168,
-0.5666707754135132,
0.3730532228946686,
-0.9888095259666443,
-0.17231915891170502,
0.3477839231491089,
-0.08538368344306946,
0.03095930628478527,
0.4898260831832886,
-0.5597917437553406,
0.2657078206539154,
0.785463273525238,
0.9078596830368042,
0.1318327933549881,
-0.48304983973503113,
-0.4043582081794739,
-0.22895373404026031,
-0.2495829463005066,
0.5985214114189148,
-0.5251190662384033,
-0.34832191467285156,
-0.09726487100124359,
0.08822543919086456,
-0.12219664454460144,
-0.228247731924057,
0.5209039449691772,
-0.6918882727622986,
0.40269315242767334,
-0.42556312680244446,
-1.0714354515075684,
-0.21609492599964142,
0.04550480097532272,
-0.4150441586971283,
0.9102855920791626,
0.056052032858133316,
-0.5841330289840698,
-0.014397718943655491,
-0.49444249272346497,
-0.0718345195055008,
0.12085337936878204,
0.048270661383867264,
-0.07336430251598358,
0.24391233921051025,
0.2052336186170578,
0.23328253626823425,
-0.035385049879550934,
0.5996387600898743,
0.15320774912834167,
-0.16620349884033203,
0.382107675075531,
-0.26354947686195374,
0.6748141050338745,
-0.00846287701278925,
-0.09918928891420364,
0.39243194460868835,
-0.7054818868637085,
-0.08228769898414612,
-0.022684454917907715,
-0.009827781468629837,
-0.44484350085258484,
-0.0789090245962143,
-0.26973509788513184,
0.405290812253952,
0.3893929421901703,
-0.5051626563072205,
0.5696477293968201,
-0.4283236563205719,
0.30403435230255127,
0.8931564092636108,
0.26937955617904663,
0.6172782182693481,
-0.23737922310829163,
0.698056697845459,
-0.1756274551153183,
0.24194732308387756,
-0.5268348455429077,
-0.7218727469444275,
-0.5697529315948486,
0.04329875856637955,
0.4111070930957794,
0.4886613190174103,
-0.8186927437782288,
0.45206883549690247,
0.011803449131548405,
-0.5017303824424744,
-0.4892144501209259,
0.1726965606212616,
0.09540103375911713,
1.1155767440795898,
0.46485626697540283,
-0.08771839737892151,
-0.4950571060180664,
-0.9382935762405396,
-0.44117507338523865,
-0.20185722410678864,
-0.013691596686840057,
0.004043029621243477,
0.042471714317798615,
0.026154695078730583,
1.3726905584335327,
-0.4858812987804413,
0.11727340519428253,
-0.3985999822616577,
0.1912764012813568,
0.330324649810791,
0.5860320329666138,
0.4571739137172699,
-0.44390547275543213,
-0.24166327714920044,
-0.5562487244606018,
-0.4498809278011322,
-0.5659510493278503,
-0.37030571699142456,
-0.14481006562709808,
-0.02121938206255436,
0.5981544852256775,
-0.6870577931404114,
0.15080764889717102,
0.09651793539524078,
-0.6990918517112732,
0.7686735987663269,
-0.30073150992393494,
0.2828671336174011,
-0.9342491030693054,
0.058667056262493134,
-0.15290869772434235,
-0.25175872445106506,
-0.8971744775772095,
0.05973490700125694,
0.502627432346344,
-0.3919149339199066,
-0.6614350080490112,
0.5925239324569702,
-0.5477216839790344,
0.32479196786880493,
-0.4213424324989319,
0.1976458728313446,
0.25193190574645996,
0.7083414196968079,
0.18008112907409668,
0.7835891246795654,
0.6007295846939087,
-0.5465319156646729,
0.3401349186897278,
0.24517838656902313,
-0.2626491189002991,
0.42397135496139526,
-0.7053406834602356,
0.393977552652359,
-0.5304641127586365,
0.0764814019203186,
-1.0296961069107056,
0.35781019926071167,
0.6174004673957825,
-0.16273154318332672,
0.3067225217819214,
-0.2547030448913574,
-0.6739513278007507,
0.08405084162950516,
-0.21940204501152039,
0.2509557008743286,
0.7054420113563538,
-0.47543656826019287,
0.7714594006538391,
0.057689372450113297,
-0.5283569693565369,
-0.29300668835639954,
-0.35122495889663696,
0.2774498462677002,
-0.007874048314988613,
-0.7211183309555054,
0.5161712169647217,
-0.20429956912994385,
-0.0949065312743187,
0.03259870782494545,
0.06512612849473953,
0.12740902602672577,
0.04815763235092163,
0.1773741990327835,
0.455267995595932,
-0.26449456810951233,
0.4384921193122864,
0.09475469589233398,
-0.2492145597934723,
0.0029584665317088366,
-0.3147299885749817,
0.6457526087760925,
0.062459710985422134,
-0.2503257393836975,
-0.5053197145462036,
0.19072766602039337,
0.5010084509849548,
-0.4109078645706177,
0.925986111164093,
0.1000664159655571,
-0.6425392627716064,
-0.16763991117477417,
-0.5228877663612366,
-0.3356271982192993,
-0.49929311871528625,
0.2334463745355606,
-0.33309540152549744,
-0.6498520374298096,
0.4996570944786072,
-0.30973020195961,
0.10641858726739883,
0.28005310893058777,
0.09277815371751785,
0.24079643189907074,
0.8211064338684082,
0.5920097827911377,
0.18982762098312378,
0.47351065278053284,
0.0934673473238945,
0.06397055089473724,
-0.7770392894744873,
-0.364414781332016,
-0.3648141920566559,
-0.36140117049217224,
0.031876079738140106,
-0.4455850124359131,
0.24107737839221954,
0.3760222792625427,
-0.015176129527390003,
0.268356055021286,
-0.3665779232978821,
0.5240764021873474,
0.41029635071754456,
0.30561721324920654,
0.3365957736968994,
-0.17050591111183167,
-0.2203925997018814,
-0.4445987045764923,
-0.8412285447120667,
-0.7588260769844055,
0.744942307472229,
0.4297494888305664,
0.5350679755210876,
-0.12690961360931396,
0.31279256939888,
0.08126624673604965,
0.20988978445529938,
-0.8081083297729492,
0.7517308592796326,
0.09818662703037262,
-0.06764301657676697,
-0.08299531042575836,
-0.3686414957046509,
-0.5017330050468445,
0.16886861622333527,
-0.21745450794696808,
-0.44576162099838257,
0.34874969720840454,
0.2540905177593231,
-0.6505554914474487,
0.6573221683502197,
-0.755298376083374,
0.8685540556907654,
-0.21985909342765808,
-0.24639292061328888,
0.023022595793008804,
-0.3511787950992584,
0.20189973711967468,
0.003997124265879393,
0.054552748799324036,
0.027615061029791832,
-0.40327972173690796,
0.7770907878875732,
-0.9971336722373962,
1.016394019126892,
-0.3101676106452942,
-0.21466092765331268,
0.2453753799200058,
0.16853326559066772,
0.6534029245376587,
0.03812318295240402,
-0.3630765378475189,
0.043997615575790405,
-0.5244895219802856,
-0.22274249792099,
-0.8911266922950745,
0.5849810242652893,
-0.5386542677879333,
-0.7488261461257935,
-0.538210928440094,
-0.5403456687927246,
-0.4325703978538513,
0.13508829474449158,
0.15375390648841858,
0.7319023013114929,
-0.13601820170879364,
-0.3756977319717407,
0.7291132807731628,
-0.7425670027732849,
0.28623101115226746,
0.7098149061203003,
-0.25315168499946594,
-0.37559208273887634,
0.5291174650192261,
0.17236453294754028,
0.23763801157474518,
0.09222118556499481,
0.3458574414253235,
-0.33598336577415466,
-0.3759809732437134,
-0.36130863428115845,
0.22608578205108643,
-0.8076093196868896,
-0.3599492609500885,
-0.82061767578125,
-0.16009527444839478,
-0.42791810631752014,
-0.07092741131782532,
-0.25619396567344666,
-0.5318174362182617,
-0.3849828839302063,
-0.13075001537799835,
0.7609166502952576,
0.5483435392379761,
-0.04719976335763931,
0.44096699357032776,
-0.6946419477462769,
0.3412556052207947,
0.3227802813053131,
0.3367348611354828,
-0.149765744805336,
-0.8004648089408875,
-0.01020800694823265,
0.046133093535900116,
-0.0650724470615387,
-1.4640247821807861,
0.3255983293056488,
0.26334208250045776,
0.4537627100944519,
0.07282739132642746,
-0.023770414292812347,
0.6166777014732361,
-0.825921893119812,
1.020926833152771,
0.1583772599697113,
-1.2716184854507446,
0.6885706186294556,
0.07638701796531677,
0.3966132700443268,
0.5174165368080139,
0.3648217022418976,
-1.0681089162826538,
-0.31744956970214844,
-0.6781018376350403,
-0.8059605956077576,
0.8755168914794922,
-0.23496046662330627,
0.27745798230171204,
-0.08314875513315201,
0.65071702003479,
0.3997441828250885,
0.2553011476993561,
-0.22659651935100555,
-0.4451605975627899,
-0.31920576095581055,
-0.04055624082684517,
0.22266584634780884,
-0.5638542175292969,
0.26196935772895813,
-0.27425074577331543,
0.9783732891082764,
0.037155881524086,
-0.1259697675704956,
0.36878326535224915,
-0.28634127974510193,
-0.06718208640813828,
0.4745854437351227,
0.586697518825531,
0.9003170132637024,
-0.054018717259168625,
0.28014710545539856,
0.3105604350566864,
-0.2898530066013336,
0.1255888044834137,
-0.028576023876667023,
-0.4835859537124634,
0.5112414360046387,
0.15009309351444244,
0.9275805354118347,
0.38170939683914185,
-0.5950869917869568,
0.4441318213939667,
-0.18363408744335175,
0.04829006642103195,
-0.006189643871039152,
0.04901256412267685,
0.10369262099266052,
-0.06401768326759338,
0.36566486954689026,
0.3365614414215088,
-0.14628536999225616,
-0.41033637523651123,
0.16118255257606506,
0.024502763524651527,
-0.11150512099266052,
-0.3638439178466797,
0.46683555841445923,
0.16800639033317566,
-0.5802547931671143,
0.645864725112915,
-0.4230788052082062,
-0.7962691783905029,
0.35231295228004456,
0.4849824607372284,
0.794126033782959,
-0.567855954170227,
0.39136436581611633,
0.4646819531917572,
0.44833895564079285,
-0.22989356517791748,
0.44883525371551514,
0.38772180676460266,
-0.7646334171295166,
-0.6340335011482239,
-0.4209727644920349,
-0.4905794858932495,
0.5114532113075256,
-0.2989220917224884,
0.45769447088241577,
-0.6301847696304321,
-0.14157763123512268,
-0.3640771508216858,
-0.343638151884079,
-0.6190930008888245,
0.04178061708807945,
0.045884761959314346,
1.3201637268066406,
-0.8144512176513672,
0.674314022064209,
0.8671316504478455,
-0.3739834427833557,
-0.9065112471580505,
-0.11977121233940125,
-0.05378621816635132,
-0.5361033082008362,
0.3516080379486084,
-0.053789425641298294,
0.1684366911649704,
-0.06778877228498459,
-0.4225504994392395,
-0.6076086163520813,
0.7003608345985413,
0.7980635762214661,
-0.8227108120918274,
-0.09266845136880875,
0.0975622832775116,
0.455421507358551,
-0.19661173224449158,
0.3595096468925476,
0.31577664613723755,
0.5356112122535706,
-0.2425769418478012,
-0.673643171787262,
0.306341290473938,
-0.44532477855682373,
0.12976807355880737,
0.007864595390856266,
-0.3227144777774811,
0.8718659281730652,
-0.022740157321095467,
-0.357455313205719,
0.14480391144752502,
0.8566219210624695,
0.28119346499443054,
-0.11577470600605011,
0.6428554654121399,
0.29936903715133667,
0.9926155209541321,
-0.0385422445833683,
0.75022292137146,
-0.6181598901748657,
0.1420513540506363,
1.2481756210327148,
-0.18167202174663544,
0.3400493562221527,
0.6250975728034973,
0.15272164344787598,
0.5145483613014221,
0.5504568219184875,
0.15426196157932281,
0.4289686977863312,
0.28372761607170105,
-0.3102477788925171,
-0.2996079623699188,
-0.22571799159049988,
-0.430308073759079,
0.03512438014149666,
0.1940416842699051,
-0.3716016113758087,
-0.26562315225601196,
0.16740919649600983,
0.19665981829166412,
0.37739402055740356,
-0.4514842629432678,
0.649204671382904,
-0.007194823585450649,
-0.6249536275863647,
0.41022390127182007,
0.3171536326408386,
0.8409073352813721,
-0.8560147881507874,
-0.09759983420372009,
-0.2817193269729614,
-0.2686556577682495,
-0.13189588487148285,
-0.7005217671394348,
0.19756647944450378,
0.19107931852340698,
-0.12079630047082901,
-0.733193039894104,
1.0515055656433105,
-0.7026779651641846,
-0.4865863621234894,
0.016846826300024986,
0.6182904839515686,
-0.029804427176713943,
-0.2711615264415741,
-0.6704491376876831,
0.0050936006009578705,
-0.17156276106834412,
-0.32244738936424255,
-0.050734177231788635,
0.6423292756080627,
0.22434112429618835,
0.3354335427284241,
0.4974820017814636,
0.4588867723941803,
-0.06767892092466354,
0.22616317868232727,
0.8751920461654663,
-0.7511651515960693,
-0.7348341941833496,
-0.9894291162490845,
0.6652332544326782,
-0.05364025756716728,
-0.3832520842552185,
0.6726735234260559,
0.3671886622905731,
0.4676940143108368,
-0.2642800807952881,
0.7835936546325684,
0.12403212487697601,
0.2594349682331085,
-0.6789510250091553,
0.7096251249313354,
-0.22539733350276947,
0.32562175393104553,
-0.2468651831150055,
-0.7865172624588013,
-0.10381171107292175,
0.43344706296920776,
-0.424038290977478,
-0.080283023416996,
0.6606677770614624,
1.018306851387024,
-0.16586923599243164,
0.22679515182971954,
0.14913389086723328,
0.32675373554229736,
-0.010788941755890846,
0.48205605149269104,
1.0821452140808105,
-0.36085444688796997,
0.28625985980033875,
-0.5166163444519043,
-0.19901321828365326,
0.0989573523402214,
-1.0919915437698364,
-0.7816928625106812,
-0.6507815718650818,
-0.5652809143066406,
-0.3740018904209137,
0.20486994087696075,
1.303719401359558,
0.40311652421951294,
-0.7245126366615295,
0.08197867125272751,
-0.028119593858718872,
0.26239314675331116,
-0.3630271852016449,
-0.24464604258537292,
0.42692187428474426,
-0.6168847680091858,
-0.6097550392150879,
0.8243987560272217,
0.16260193288326263,
-0.12588068842887878,
-0.21127906441688538,
-0.18576356768608093,
-0.04335964098572731,
0.08116725832223892,
0.4122847616672516,
0.21902218461036682,
-0.46790173649787903,
-0.42411428689956665,
0.234890416264534,
-0.0753186047077179,
0.1104850172996521,
1.0782771110534668,
-0.9803893566131592,
0.444187194108963,
0.7573844194412231,
0.6938741207122803,
-0.27348601818084717,
-0.0740685760974884,
0.8443537354469299,
-1.0384973287582397,
0.03335773944854736,
0.23339717090129852,
0.7591685056686401,
0.6307552456855774,
-0.5343585014343262,
0.06819971650838852,
0.32252374291419983,
-0.30033645033836365,
-0.6889066100120544,
0.13758888840675354,
-0.7481169104576111,
-0.52728670835495,
1.2357327938079834,
-0.10206197202205658,
-0.3235500156879425,
-0.12606576085090637,
-0.752615213394165,
0.44653114676475525,
-0.519837498664856,
0.612655520439148,
0.7113495469093323,
0.03191813454031944,
-0.3127572536468506,
-0.050260599702596664,
0.5807783007621765,
0.6599401831626892,
-0.6113592982292175,
0.1615169644355774,
0.5340276956558228,
0.4334467649459839,
0.10109230875968933,
0.5161722898483276,
-0.07583869993686676,
0.3733144998550415,
-0.44781336188316345,
0.35978925228118896,
-0.6114839911460876,
-0.14890211820602417,
-0.7817920446395874,
0.38052162528038025,
0.0020725298672914505,
0.07103663682937622
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14374v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14374v1
|
FIT-RAG: Black-Box RAG with Factual Information and Token Reduction
| 2024-03-21T13:05:18 | 2024-03-21T13:05:18 |
Yuren Mao, Xuemei Dong, Wenyi Xu, Yunjun Gao, Bin Wei, Ying Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Due to the extraordinarily large number of parameters, fine-tuning Large
Language Models (LLMs) to update long-tail or out-of-date knowledge is
impractical in lots of applications. To avoid fine-tuning, we can alternatively
treat a LLM as a black-box (i.e., freeze the parameters of the LLM) and augment
it with a Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) system, namely black-box RAG.
Recently, black-box RAG has achieved success in knowledge-intensive tasks and
has gained much attention. Existing black-box RAG methods typically fine-tune
the retriever to cater to LLMs' preferences and concatenate all the retrieved
documents as the input, which suffers from two issues: (1) Ignorance of Factual
Information. The LLM preferred documents may not contain the factual
information for the given question, which can mislead the retriever and hurt
the effectiveness of black-box RAG; (2) Waste of Tokens. Simply concatenating
all the retrieved documents brings large amounts of unnecessary tokens for
LLMs, which degenerates the efficiency of black-box RAG. To address these
issues, this paper proposes a novel black-box RAG framework which utilizes the
factual information in the retrieval and reduces the number of tokens for
augmentation, dubbed FIT-RAG. FIT-RAG utilizes the factual information by
constructing a bi-label document scorer. Besides, it reduces the tokens by
introducing a self-knowledge recognizer and a sub-document-level token reducer.
FIT-RAG achieves both superior effectiveness and efficiency, which is validated
by extensive experiments across three open-domain question-answering datasets:
TriviaQA, NQ and PopQA. FIT-RAG can improve the answering accuracy of
Llama2-13B-Chat by 14.3\% on TriviaQA, 19.9\% on NQ and 27.5\% on PopQA,
respectively. Furthermore, it can save approximately half of the tokens on
average across the three datasets.
|
[
-0.45689910650253296,
-0.7934983968734741,
0.4091770350933075,
-0.18318355083465576,
-0.42429375648498535,
0.4709579050540924,
-0.06798256933689117,
-0.5313488245010376,
0.44402438402175903,
0.5466257929801941,
-0.5029615163803101,
-0.22216051816940308,
-0.42265602946281433,
-0.05087599903345108,
-0.35279667377471924,
1.3149662017822266,
0.08125220984220505,
-0.23239731788635254,
-0.38335132598876953,
-0.2500711679458618,
-0.6507270932197571,
-0.29647374153137207,
-0.6558011770248413,
-0.2099413424730301,
0.32361161708831787,
0.3475251793861389,
0.6190943121910095,
0.6194511651992798,
0.23831824958324432,
0.18635877966880798,
-0.39680248498916626,
0.6364210247993469,
-0.8954036235809326,
0.31750306487083435,
-0.35818612575531006,
-0.7731812596321106,
-0.34220901131629944,
-0.1409381628036499,
0.4954047203063965,
0.20822590589523315,
-0.052116215229034424,
0.6558131575584412,
-0.019529441371560097,
0.6533951163291931,
-0.7697294354438782,
-0.046201661229133606,
-0.8350052237510681,
-0.20904409885406494,
-0.2730078101158142,
-0.46003925800323486,
-0.38534536957740784,
-0.14783430099487305,
-0.3403695225715637,
-0.5988907217979431,
0.49721962213516235,
0.4336128532886505,
0.9440547227859497,
0.7048441767692566,
-0.17618241906166077,
-0.3285478353500366,
-0.8679239153862,
0.608466625213623,
-0.7366787791252136,
0.37294328212738037,
0.4884461760520935,
0.368369460105896,
-0.22392068803310394,
-0.48520150780677795,
-0.7700581550598145,
0.16407880187034607,
-0.2979539632797241,
0.1932477504014969,
0.015412983484566212,
-0.20938876271247864,
0.22799472510814667,
0.36274176836013794,
-0.5596347451210022,
-0.03878042474389076,
-0.6212459206581116,
-0.19707897305488586,
0.6641713976860046,
0.16629962623119354,
0.03936927765607834,
-0.23086468875408173,
-0.4050876200199127,
0.009764048270881176,
-0.5864096879959106,
-0.0390278659760952,
0.15066947042942047,
0.04113946110010147,
0.0030636852607131004,
0.7589676380157471,
-0.08200085163116455,
0.6305444240570068,
0.32439178228378296,
-0.673315703868866,
0.1963089555501938,
-0.3139747083187103,
-0.20167335867881775,
0.03042023256421089,
0.4500596821308136,
0.2583351135253906,
-0.037017643451690674,
-0.27795305848121643,
-0.27119722962379456,
0.028284208849072456,
0.42499685287475586,
-0.857037365436554,
0.26570042967796326,
0.30483973026275635,
-0.3997422754764557,
-0.3284091353416443,
-0.0619644820690155,
-0.8369108438491821,
-0.42918649315834045,
-0.35696542263031006,
0.5356804728507996,
-0.30726608633995056,
-0.010438854806125164,
0.09396420419216156,
-0.18572887778282166,
0.4612100422382355,
0.5074901580810547,
-0.3355657160282135,
0.16038818657398224,
0.8773402571678162,
0.7506614923477173,
-0.15663525462150574,
0.21274422109127045,
-0.8319309949874878,
0.3862461745738983,
-0.44569718837738037,
0.7739275693893433,
-0.5135857462882996,
-0.2519074082374573,
-0.15427230298519135,
-0.062125347554683685,
0.19676342606544495,
-0.4939461648464203,
0.6704887747764587,
-0.6875831484794617,
0.35764917731285095,
-0.024730686098337173,
-0.6625031232833862,
-0.10157269239425659,
0.43689075112342834,
-0.5870270133018494,
1.1922277212142944,
-0.005331151187419891,
-0.9272670149803162,
0.26731446385383606,
-0.400390625,
-0.308737576007843,
0.21834397315979004,
0.04171318560838699,
-0.7477995753288269,
0.15898312628269196,
0.19578495621681213,
0.3267241418361664,
-0.5544724464416504,
0.2655940353870392,
-0.43277379870414734,
-0.6554296016693115,
0.25014030933380127,
-0.2685535252094269,
0.5964767336845398,
0.3295157253742218,
-0.2927769124507904,
-0.3596622943878174,
-0.7443112134933472,
-0.14790740609169006,
0.17596732079982758,
-0.3732064664363861,
-0.4746891260147095,
-0.11055481433868408,
-0.24396070837974548,
0.15923351049423218,
0.38203829526901245,
-0.7242857813835144,
0.03409164771437645,
-0.5795398950576782,
-0.19592098891735077,
0.6149957180023193,
0.053472165018320084,
0.3306382894515991,
-0.797714114189148,
0.64497971534729,
-0.14150197803974152,
-0.009285829961299896,
-0.08322501927614212,
-0.3992072343826294,
-0.9045413136482239,
-0.39747750759124756,
0.5150836110115051,
0.6168414950370789,
-0.7510694861412048,
0.40380942821502686,
-0.17061565816402435,
-0.44326651096343994,
-0.830323338508606,
0.12639187276363373,
0.4995874762535095,
0.5670737624168396,
0.3305707275867462,
0.0322749987244606,
-0.4795913100242615,
-0.7189863324165344,
-0.27875006198883057,
-0.01835665851831436,
-0.014802464284002781,
0.4320964515209198,
0.42130011320114136,
-0.2977166771888733,
1.0306493043899536,
-0.7208646535873413,
-0.3636839687824249,
0.004041499923914671,
-0.12467051297426224,
0.2518400251865387,
0.3015950322151184,
0.5382170677185059,
-0.8478096723556519,
-0.47369110584259033,
-0.03152737766504288,
-0.34839361906051636,
-0.11514134705066681,
0.04299245774745941,
-0.1665155291557312,
0.4990665018558502,
0.5159430503845215,
-0.7577201128005981,
0.8423671722412109,
0.3983047902584076,
-0.405477911233902,
0.5653694868087769,
-0.29680895805358887,
0.00560336047783494,
-1.3555279970169067,
0.3038867712020874,
-0.27287861704826355,
-0.42373621463775635,
-0.47516581416130066,
-0.07066754996776581,
0.13622167706489563,
-0.1616320013999939,
-0.15436622500419617,
1.1355739831924438,
-0.3957490026950836,
-0.04574553295969963,
-0.2788369953632355,
0.19718104600906372,
0.30563586950302124,
0.49301278591156006,
-0.42900967597961426,
0.935062825679779,
0.010526817291975021,
-0.5339422821998596,
0.1664237231016159,
0.45190533995628357,
0.013528256677091122,
0.6801004409790039,
-0.407272070646286,
0.2144378423690796,
-0.6174650192260742,
0.21279683709144592,
-0.9930287003517151,
-0.1325991451740265,
0.2299899160861969,
-0.6853426098823547,
0.7833391427993774,
-0.2219126969575882,
-0.5223915576934814,
-0.32251283526420593,
-0.38148677349090576,
0.340056836605072,
0.610210657119751,
-0.5637466907501221,
0.6526474356651306,
0.5442884564399719,
-0.11004658788442612,
-0.9119782447814941,
-0.47830310463905334,
0.013485671952366829,
-0.2346533238887787,
-0.4189909100532532,
0.5002347230911255,
-0.3960171937942505,
-0.02128434367477894,
0.24216829240322113,
-0.4617052376270294,
-0.0005520163103938103,
-0.02630103938281536,
-0.10368125140666962,
0.38190123438835144,
-0.11984998732805252,
0.2969282567501068,
0.02124147303402424,
-0.09050950407981873,
-0.21479016542434692,
-0.2948344349861145,
0.357366144657135,
0.11551573127508163,
-0.15519995987415314,
0.14091837406158447,
0.20407597720623016,
0.5384340882301331,
-0.5083174109458923,
0.906899094581604,
0.7176675200462341,
-0.3167088031768799,
-0.5001351833343506,
-0.9421785473823547,
0.04433726146817207,
-0.4347049295902252,
0.08505144715309143,
-0.3338368833065033,
-1.0687153339385986,
0.4500108063220978,
-0.023770365864038467,
0.2058376669883728,
0.33318471908569336,
0.6065126061439514,
-0.13792182505130768,
0.642368495464325,
0.4603017568588257,
0.06966754049062729,
0.23111486434936523,
-0.16068270802497864,
0.2814455032348633,
-1.004153847694397,
-0.17155545949935913,
-0.7040358781814575,
-0.2565297782421112,
-0.5704490542411804,
-0.7525443434715271,
0.42793747782707214,
0.01424418669193983,
-0.07659261673688889,
0.019663123413920403,
-0.5837224721908569,
0.44643938541412354,
0.3786647617816925,
0.1952025294303894,
0.2511226534843445,
-0.1567326784133911,
-0.16207878291606903,
0.14381477236747742,
-0.7573560476303101,
-0.2567718029022217,
1.2278975248336792,
0.24264849722385406,
0.8642844557762146,
0.15429618954658508,
0.7699098587036133,
0.22329610586166382,
0.23298487067222595,
-0.7796401381492615,
0.3750481903553009,
-0.2081896811723709,
-0.8961328864097595,
-0.2866932451725006,
-0.5782856941223145,
-1.1213196516036987,
0.12432818114757538,
-0.46392354369163513,
-0.514136016368866,
0.12975239753723145,
0.1258508563041687,
-0.08277922123670578,
0.377441942691803,
-0.5490942597389221,
0.4355308711528778,
-0.21734429895877838,
-0.49091413617134094,
-0.07159257680177689,
-0.4987548589706421,
0.4889756143093109,
-0.521050214767456,
0.4316338896751404,
-0.09589090198278427,
-0.24064750969409943,
0.6637704372406006,
-0.3715995252132416,
0.6881557106971741,
-0.0667252168059349,
0.1001892238855362,
0.17097117006778717,
0.2538589537143707,
0.726879358291626,
0.07871155440807343,
-0.02872404083609581,
-0.187798410654068,
0.09957852959632874,
-0.39973166584968567,
-0.8446877002716064,
0.36467453837394714,
-0.5087903738021851,
-0.6029694676399231,
-0.2818734347820282,
-0.6879298686981201,
-0.29297953844070435,
0.28479650616645813,
-0.00483416672796011,
0.6189781427383423,
-0.011929129250347614,
0.42411985993385315,
0.9201496839523315,
-0.4201357364654541,
0.0780344009399414,
0.6915486454963684,
-0.2838040590286255,
-0.5406093001365662,
0.8427549004554749,
0.20264053344726562,
0.0797630250453949,
0.5408919453620911,
0.3715824484825134,
-0.520188570022583,
-0.5316005945205688,
-0.21953164041042328,
0.7593687772750854,
-0.5441242456436157,
-0.6646257042884827,
-0.577747106552124,
-0.32411885261535645,
-0.3725234568119049,
-0.0684221163392067,
-0.10048889368772507,
-0.4879423975944519,
-0.2553110420703888,
0.08010667562484741,
0.40152519941329956,
0.677031397819519,
0.115543432533741,
0.10425473004579544,
-0.794460654258728,
0.7674626708030701,
0.26442378759384155,
0.7584214806556702,
-0.23108060657978058,
-0.7766710519790649,
-0.38499629497528076,
-0.01649753749370575,
-0.14699231088161469,
-0.7334190607070923,
0.30598944425582886,
0.09717558324337006,
0.6743022203445435,
0.013215640559792519,
0.45809999108314514,
0.789901614189148,
-0.44532716274261475,
0.3355273902416229,
-0.03449109196662903,
-0.5975813269615173,
0.28036731481552124,
-0.28885698318481445,
0.18770524859428406,
0.49343398213386536,
0.10826036334037781,
-0.33370524644851685,
-0.6045387387275696,
-0.9628154039382935,
-0.5834537744522095,
0.8999996781349182,
0.20740756392478943,
-0.1540318876504898,
0.23282574117183685,
0.5812683701515198,
0.0631842240691185,
0.3953794240951538,
-0.32956960797309875,
-0.37770479917526245,
-0.019089320674538612,
-0.37853941321372986,
-0.12756942212581635,
-0.43255510926246643,
-0.12408225238323212,
-0.14284424483776093,
0.8543479442596436,
-0.22937335073947906,
0.21489264070987701,
0.15049882233142853,
-0.014870304614305496,
-0.08084370195865631,
0.3518131971359253,
0.5840120315551758,
0.6341809630393982,
-0.3448087275028229,
-0.034838028252124786,
0.3462470769882202,
-0.4121735394001007,
0.18658261001110077,
0.19675280153751373,
-0.491423636674881,
0.1705755740404129,
0.03693237900733948,
0.7343751192092896,
0.0958002507686615,
-0.5256361961364746,
0.3627021610736847,
-0.09239165484905243,
-0.22722478210926056,
-0.19314321875572205,
0.10971443355083466,
0.13364289700984955,
0.15695272386074066,
0.34128108620643616,
0.17900924384593964,
0.08782064914703369,
-0.4288479685783386,
0.35397985577583313,
0.6893686652183533,
-0.14111275970935822,
0.03204571083188057,
0.6180229783058167,
0.06802503764629364,
-0.5717526078224182,
-0.002243342809379101,
-0.32329505681991577,
-0.5281499624252319,
0.3660720884799957,
0.7020078301429749,
0.6569594740867615,
-0.23530299961566925,
0.25156858563423157,
0.4044335186481476,
0.33142712712287903,
-0.012821794487535954,
-0.04673897102475166,
-0.13661408424377441,
-0.6645583510398865,
-0.712209939956665,
-0.9923422932624817,
-0.4584032893180847,
0.3356287181377411,
-0.4963560402393341,
0.42947158217430115,
-0.3213959336280823,
-0.020497409626841545,
-0.18215888738632202,
0.34879523515701294,
-0.7152140736579895,
0.25076985359191895,
-0.05054277926683426,
0.8468909859657288,
-0.31220176815986633,
0.5908899903297424,
0.6903704404830933,
-0.2822904586791992,
-0.8667516112327576,
0.02876557968556881,
-0.04096683859825134,
-0.7943322658538818,
0.26893025636672974,
0.002827311400324106,
-0.06904518604278564,
-0.13750454783439636,
-0.3938831686973572,
-1.068438172340393,
0.9924285411834717,
0.5634161233901978,
-0.4258884787559509,
-0.15875090658664703,
0.019120076671242714,
0.45376789569854736,
-0.18706604838371277,
0.1278247833251953,
0.6341527104377747,
0.5740671157836914,
0.4808056950569153,
-0.9924485683441162,
0.10912441462278366,
-0.3022914528846741,
-0.14448592066764832,
0.5164151787757874,
-0.7443374991416931,
0.5109621286392212,
0.003362135263159871,
-0.26814165711402893,
-0.13839691877365112,
0.31087204813957214,
0.4747665822505951,
0.47341740131378174,
0.42062678933143616,
0.7305265069007874,
0.9986432194709778,
0.14601199328899384,
0.9042882323265076,
-0.21651414036750793,
0.40253567695617676,
0.9925774335861206,
-0.14918257296085358,
0.640353798866272,
0.3073686361312866,
-0.06835156679153442,
0.21639981865882874,
0.1087254136800766,
0.07711374759674072,
0.05090614780783653,
0.10144218802452087,
-0.012350666336715221,
-0.18932637572288513,
0.05283835157752037,
-0.1600683033466339,
0.5451728701591492,
0.4648467004299164,
0.10110749304294586,
-0.284092515707016,
-0.2272234708070755,
0.3737105429172516,
0.051064375787973404,
-0.19237065315246582,
1.0236310958862305,
0.008890052326023579,
-0.7878726124763489,
0.8876773118972778,
-0.11596047133207321,
0.6750589609146118,
-0.5586513876914978,
-0.11770893633365631,
-0.29995089769363403,
0.10548866540193558,
-0.20485934615135193,
-0.7247616648674011,
0.48553571105003357,
0.0035900301299989223,
-0.2451607584953308,
0.01056783925741911,
1.0473031997680664,
-0.5815533995628357,
-0.5641632080078125,
0.15790797770023346,
0.4997389614582062,
0.031187083572149277,
0.1799772083759308,
-0.7865182757377625,
-0.042421773076057434,
0.07226928323507309,
-0.058052703738212585,
0.36926689743995667,
0.7696068286895752,
0.12272245436906815,
0.6509237289428711,
0.8609345555305481,
0.372890830039978,
-0.043244585394859314,
-0.3915955722332001,
0.8536700010299683,
-0.6632140278816223,
-0.6006268858909607,
-0.32611384987831116,
0.499273419380188,
-0.2837223410606384,
-0.04097265005111694,
0.5760412216186523,
0.6967678666114807,
0.6340570449829102,
0.16656507551670074,
0.7195334434509277,
0.024414191022515297,
1.1787854433059692,
-0.528681755065918,
0.7313245534896851,
-0.941154420375824,
0.3391871750354767,
-0.1742209941148758,
-0.9282666444778442,
-0.19077880680561066,
0.27045610547065735,
0.007331006228923798,
-0.1279565691947937,
0.5118987560272217,
0.9371810555458069,
-0.1243172436952591,
-0.3970048129558563,
0.4602971374988556,
0.24702894687652588,
0.36754077672958374,
0.17730985581874847,
0.551999568939209,
-0.44326886534690857,
0.9463796019554138,
-0.01205944363027811,
-0.189025416970253,
-0.5171427130699158,
-0.6835982799530029,
-0.973296582698822,
-0.5275360941886902,
-0.026357941329479218,
-0.5268040299415588,
-0.000020252155081834644,
0.6272924542427063,
0.6230593323707581,
-0.547430694103241,
0.06432764232158661,
0.4870077669620514,
0.4019987881183624,
0.12163765728473663,
-0.2496354579925537,
0.33201491832733154,
-0.6461122035980225,
-0.4469601809978485,
0.2327483594417572,
0.352480411529541,
0.037730637937784195,
-0.0822446271777153,
-0.1423238217830658,
-0.17329007387161255,
0.45701920986175537,
0.5501677989959717,
0.29706746339797974,
-0.5559479594230652,
-0.3090875446796417,
0.08782541751861572,
0.045119818300008774,
0.16447582840919495,
0.6451756954193115,
-0.9576559066772461,
0.5521585941314697,
0.4653637111186981,
1.0628889799118042,
1.02466881275177,
0.2868194580078125,
0.43183308839797974,
-0.8570219278335571,
0.21364416182041168,
0.38357338309288025,
0.28144675493240356,
0.270613431930542,
-0.5634724497795105,
0.5914167165756226,
0.17065292596817017,
-0.692737340927124,
-0.9841361045837402,
0.12029288709163666,
-0.9342668056488037,
-0.4469703435897827,
1.1914688348770142,
0.23006246984004974,
-0.5710170269012451,
-0.4604181945323944,
-0.4349426329135895,
0.25131407380104065,
-0.36343109607696533,
0.7422484755516052,
0.47025224566459656,
0.19126369059085846,
-0.17925012111663818,
-0.5990052223205566,
0.5774602293968201,
0.3460499048233032,
-0.7295767068862915,
0.07536819577217102,
0.5297532081604004,
0.33996933698654175,
0.31310465931892395,
0.6469619274139404,
-0.07251089066267014,
0.32051196694374084,
-0.1985144466161728,
-0.13815563917160034,
-0.22187669575214386,
-0.2078862190246582,
-0.04028964787721634,
0.2338128685951233,
0.018482036888599396,
-0.02322210930287838
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14364v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14364v1
|
WikiFactDiff: A Large, Realistic, and Temporally Adaptable Dataset for Atomic Factual Knowledge Update in Causal Language Models
| 2024-03-21T12:45:12 | 2024-03-21T12:45:12 |
Hichem Ammar Khodja, Frédéric Béchet, Quentin Brabant, Alexis Nasr, Gwénolé Lecorvé
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The factuality of large language model (LLMs) tends to decay over time since
events posterior to their training are "unknown" to them. One way to keep
models up-to-date could be factual update: the task of inserting, replacing, or
removing certain simple (atomic) facts within the model. To study this task, we
present WikiFactDiff, a dataset that describes the evolution of factual
knowledge between two dates as a collection of simple facts divided into three
categories: new, obsolete, and static. We describe several update scenarios
arising from various combinations of these three types of basic update. The
facts are represented by subject-relation-object triples; indeed, WikiFactDiff
was constructed by comparing the state of the Wikidata knowledge base at 4
January 2021 and 27 February 2023. Those fact are accompanied by verbalization
templates and cloze tests that enable running update algorithms and their
evaluation metrics. Contrary to other datasets, such as zsRE and CounterFact,
WikiFactDiff constitutes a realistic update setting that involves various
update scenarios, including replacements, archival, and new entity insertions.
We also present an evaluation of existing update algorithms on WikiFactDiff.
|
[
-0.2902713716030121,
-0.983022928237915,
0.746159017086029,
0.15118622779846191,
-0.14203129708766937,
-0.13315178453922272,
-0.28713515400886536,
-0.3585463762283325,
-0.19293415546417236,
0.4864759147167206,
-0.598565399646759,
-0.5521526336669922,
-0.25752800703048706,
0.1902410387992859,
-0.5355211496353149,
1.1161614656448364,
-0.17761138081550598,
-0.11266028881072998,
-0.3427548408508301,
-0.399074524641037,
-0.42146027088165283,
-0.26900458335876465,
-0.40559685230255127,
-0.32604143023490906,
0.7256202697753906,
0.541252076625824,
0.8163182139396667,
0.7403157353401184,
0.4410346448421478,
0.25717589259147644,
-0.06684880703687668,
0.2558070719242096,
-0.4229809641838074,
0.13232140243053436,
-0.5244461894035339,
-0.2020532637834549,
-0.20396511256694794,
-0.06790990382432938,
0.6244513392448425,
0.7986941337585449,
-0.29455727338790894,
0.025260666385293007,
-0.3001502752304077,
0.6774157285690308,
-0.8610028028488159,
0.3357267677783966,
-0.6513633131980896,
-0.10349664092063904,
-0.10929495841264725,
-0.0404847152531147,
-0.40188470482826233,
-0.6105629205703735,
0.03129304200410843,
-0.7515813708305359,
0.26619476079940796,
0.02810010313987732,
0.6839306354522705,
0.13648948073387146,
-0.7449021935462952,
-0.28018200397491455,
-0.7187398076057434,
0.26988649368286133,
-0.6168895363807678,
0.5943114161491394,
0.4245081841945648,
0.03486652672290802,
-0.5824753046035767,
-0.5430411100387573,
-0.8686745762825012,
-0.6383089423179626,
-0.04096204414963722,
-0.1346442848443985,
-0.07365800440311432,
-0.09707525372505188,
0.2854119539260864,
0.2334936261177063,
-0.25081175565719604,
0.13202041387557983,
-0.24445559084415436,
-0.12336698919534683,
0.4953373074531555,
0.17292088270187378,
0.43862271308898926,
-0.3119814693927765,
-0.18108433485031128,
-0.012007574550807476,
-0.8047345876693726,
-0.69832843542099,
0.0810900628566742,
-0.09992550313472748,
-0.4562891125679016,
0.5784007906913757,
-0.6091771125793457,
0.6887215375900269,
0.0908135399222374,
-0.40019553899765015,
0.23517972230911255,
-0.3298535943031311,
-0.1560368537902832,
0.19642944633960724,
0.5480590462684631,
0.3705463707447052,
0.024333620443940163,
-0.3177587687969208,
0.09902060031890869,
-0.1519501954317093,
-0.12606225907802582,
-0.6415765285491943,
-0.2769874632358551,
0.13772261142730713,
0.004247721284627914,
-0.4302746057510376,
-0.09180667251348495,
-0.33930712938308716,
-0.6683809757232666,
-0.37530288100242615,
0.4618366062641144,
-0.48877930641174316,
-0.16323387622833252,
-0.05980535224080086,
-0.19627119600772858,
-0.11120413988828659,
0.6669055819511414,
-0.5509750843048096,
0.10884232074022293,
0.7635493874549866,
0.6916201710700989,
-0.03997398167848587,
-0.471771776676178,
-0.2542417347431183,
0.43246757984161377,
-0.7488523125648499,
0.814554750919342,
0.003690582700073719,
-0.12055835872888565,
0.018920330330729485,
0.019524332135915756,
0.20560020208358765,
-0.34531041979789734,
0.4562186300754547,
-1.0231200456619263,
0.1140018031001091,
-0.45708510279655457,
-0.6393101215362549,
-0.025070562958717346,
0.26338082551956177,
-0.9581743478775024,
0.8844563961029053,
0.14129193127155304,
-0.9715874791145325,
0.4994778633117676,
-0.6024711728096008,
-0.4009001553058624,
-0.04163534566760063,
0.14027394354343414,
-0.10294033586978912,
-0.08779607713222504,
-0.3818874955177307,
0.288180947303772,
-0.3356553316116333,
0.5164412260055542,
-0.6653814315795898,
-0.24886177480220795,
0.4563480317592621,
-0.5661194920539856,
0.9212966561317444,
0.1564834713935852,
-0.22250355780124664,
-0.47177404165267944,
-1.0111626386642456,
-0.6521285772323608,
-0.06522497534751892,
-0.430600106716156,
-0.46681755781173706,
0.3511258661746979,
-0.3689272701740265,
0.1949407458305359,
0.31545108556747437,
-0.6447360515594482,
0.2428002506494522,
-0.17428143322467804,
0.023296570405364037,
0.7345787882804871,
0.5971783995628357,
0.18971143662929535,
-0.38049331307411194,
-0.1761396825313568,
0.3929919898509979,
0.3994080722332001,
-0.012865573167800903,
-0.36847227811813354,
-0.9976597428321838,
-0.15971739590168,
0.3673924505710602,
0.5614171028137207,
-0.7187678217887878,
0.32712531089782715,
-0.5503310561180115,
-0.52113276720047,
-0.07269902527332306,
0.2317904829978943,
-0.08639578521251678,
0.7954575419425964,
0.2521137297153473,
0.24241825938224792,
-0.5375723242759705,
-0.8999019265174866,
-0.000959026743657887,
-0.5144185423851013,
0.18770870566368103,
-0.2080342322587967,
0.4640045762062073,
-0.286749005317688,
0.9613223075866699,
-0.6999176740646362,
0.14908230304718018,
0.3391052782535553,
0.400706022977829,
0.15368837118148804,
0.24860376119613647,
0.4049738943576813,
-0.7879694700241089,
-0.27676719427108765,
0.24155832827091217,
-0.8939923644065857,
-0.09755201637744904,
-0.15265555679798126,
0.001659455127082765,
0.4892834722995758,
0.6233474612236023,
-1.0683706998825073,
0.22851240634918213,
0.4725116789340973,
-0.49115148186683655,
0.73151695728302,
-0.20175325870513916,
0.5220881104469299,
-0.8669470548629761,
0.06074259802699089,
-0.25554919242858887,
-0.2963818311691284,
-0.5610251426696777,
0.05261273682117462,
0.32842177152633667,
0.11057440936565399,
-0.5642122030258179,
0.7502601742744446,
-0.27558356523513794,
0.03810488060116768,
-0.16962213814258575,
0.30224013328552246,
-0.028593894094228745,
0.32584336400032043,
-0.1701716184616089,
0.4676094949245453,
0.3254880905151367,
-0.7495160102844238,
0.501830518245697,
0.2353627234697342,
-0.43522343039512634,
0.49394491314888,
-0.017896320670843124,
0.13717283308506012,
-0.1992500275373459,
0.2083871066570282,
-0.6621066331863403,
-0.287031888961792,
0.4175930619239807,
-0.18189002573490143,
0.18367761373519897,
-0.1626432240009308,
-0.7260488271713257,
-0.12473452836275101,
-0.3654817044734955,
-0.12748531997203827,
0.17654961347579956,
-0.624626100063324,
0.5951494574546814,
0.1713426113128662,
-0.2655690610408783,
-0.5274147391319275,
-0.3153763711452484,
0.42947012186050415,
0.1280568391084671,
-0.525546669960022,
0.218426913022995,
-0.4711303114891052,
-0.6689207553863525,
0.6509169936180115,
-0.3111152648925781,
-0.17613156139850616,
0.24074596166610718,
-0.0500318668782711,
0.47592732310295105,
-0.18110336363315582,
0.22104106843471527,
0.049496982246637344,
0.11240041255950928,
0.15779028832912445,
0.09842796623706818,
0.06720075756311417,
0.261593222618103,
-0.22001907229423523,
-0.1995675414800644,
0.07447471469640732,
0.6243331432342529,
0.3945642113685608,
0.915888249874115,
0.37738072872161865,
-0.5358666777610779,
-0.16475166380405426,
-0.9312485456466675,
0.0825168788433075,
-0.4489942491054535,
0.5650845170021057,
-0.3730597198009491,
-0.6322711110115051,
0.25172507762908936,
0.17131361365318298,
0.3586280643939972,
0.7572765946388245,
0.5473641753196716,
-0.3070964217185974,
0.705672025680542,
0.3466491997241974,
-0.05700375884771347,
0.27811434864997864,
0.19573885202407837,
-0.03930215165019035,
-0.44055983424186707,
-0.4278812110424042,
-0.43935152888298035,
0.3616539239883423,
-0.5650603771209717,
-0.6234549283981323,
0.18310290575027466,
0.2287108451128006,
-0.3832346498966217,
0.16886313259601593,
0.4195548892021179,
0.3750012516975403,
0.18501734733581543,
0.24593281745910645,
0.6681869626045227,
-0.19540469348430634,
0.12053065001964569,
0.2606808841228485,
-0.5998337864875793,
-0.15706385672092438,
1.0566338300704956,
-0.006410731468349695,
0.482387512922287,
0.46678662300109863,
0.30205586552619934,
0.9869856834411621,
0.7157453298568726,
-0.641323447227478,
0.5639621615409851,
-0.19899651408195496,
-0.7126301527023315,
-0.13182245194911957,
-0.572323203086853,
-0.3668591380119324,
-0.07389875501394272,
-0.4069971442222595,
-0.325578510761261,
0.3217003047466278,
0.33090609312057495,
0.2819569706916809,
0.3522796034812927,
-0.5803442001342773,
0.5771405696868896,
0.04224139824509621,
-0.15683120489120483,
-0.6953746676445007,
-0.4040292799472809,
0.6325970888137817,
-0.5996690392494202,
0.4403223991394043,
-0.2632788121700287,
-0.009125885553658009,
0.7616386413574219,
-0.5521341562271118,
0.7297131419181824,
-0.11724687367677689,
-0.16973942518234253,
0.19110120832920074,
0.38080033659935,
0.8317674398422241,
0.05463828146457672,
-0.029862090945243835,
0.094450443983078,
0.1464529186487198,
-0.2544490694999695,
-0.882520318031311,
0.8172586560249329,
-0.8543498516082764,
-0.8367596864700317,
-0.5499037504196167,
-0.4619142711162567,
-0.4768490493297577,
0.1760828197002411,
-0.08835706114768982,
0.6566506624221802,
-0.4942705035209656,
0.031017251312732697,
0.9265983700752258,
-0.15297016501426697,
0.26652443408966064,
1.0099873542785645,
0.033567994832992554,
-0.302283376455307,
0.8030329346656799,
0.1867220103740692,
0.2684375047683716,
0.5154239535331726,
0.45031315088272095,
-0.26493725180625916,
-0.4924781620502472,
-0.2189582884311676,
0.4914911985397339,
-1.0175795555114746,
-0.3161182105541229,
-0.7802453637123108,
-0.12268492579460144,
-0.4093247950077057,
0.04220064356923103,
-0.08734148740768433,
-0.6422862410545349,
-0.23562054336071014,
-0.1598685085773468,
0.8742454648017883,
0.8973381519317627,
-0.49876484274864197,
-0.03114800900220871,
-0.6106685400009155,
0.6578941345214844,
0.3274991512298584,
0.21703745424747467,
-0.2639674246311188,
-0.5298696756362915,
-0.4719011187553406,
0.0573505274951458,
0.046232499182224274,
-1.0340781211853027,
-0.40770894289016724,
0.30319154262542725,
0.38963428139686584,
0.28752732276916504,
0.1842971295118332,
0.687012791633606,
-0.6183256506919861,
0.7528982758522034,
0.29969701170921326,
-0.840213418006897,
0.22336122393608093,
-0.4060535728931427,
0.1499001681804657,
0.4415132701396942,
0.41484442353248596,
-0.9160299897193909,
-0.3470474183559418,
-0.6084556579589844,
-0.40534496307373047,
0.7773635387420654,
-0.3138255178928375,
0.13080994784832,
-0.04950582981109619,
0.5850048661231995,
-0.0732690617442131,
0.1430768370628357,
-0.40507668256759644,
-0.4507271945476532,
-0.23355554044246674,
-0.3813130855560303,
-0.04340735450387001,
-0.29112038016319275,
-0.3292239308357239,
-0.21079283952713013,
0.9713807702064514,
0.05818609148263931,
-0.021078797057271004,
0.07253207266330719,
-0.5291175842285156,
0.01746094599366188,
0.3457036018371582,
0.6269650459289551,
0.7172154784202576,
-0.4760158658027649,
0.18072949349880219,
0.44721999764442444,
-0.7128170132637024,
0.27706649899482727,
0.1593751162290573,
-0.2629876732826233,
0.03280654177069664,
0.5658304691314697,
0.8714237213134766,
0.5338467955589294,
-0.5781818628311157,
0.5134478807449341,
0.18784016370773315,
-0.18649156391620636,
-0.3264596164226532,
0.19977717101573944,
0.22638729214668274,
0.0044263810850679874,
0.48339083790779114,
0.03492856025695801,
0.25370123982429504,
-0.7276275753974915,
0.316434770822525,
-0.16333219408988953,
-0.14288125932216644,
-0.39106640219688416,
0.3388071656227112,
0.05426732078194618,
0.0301310233771801,
0.6612489819526672,
-0.38416531682014465,
-0.31939801573753357,
0.30181884765625,
0.4190254211425781,
0.5708133578300476,
-0.10758241266012192,
0.34986889362335205,
0.29359763860702515,
0.230514794588089,
-0.07341063767671585,
-0.13241712749004364,
0.02277279458940029,
-0.9444580078125,
-0.5050065517425537,
-0.4676891565322876,
-0.3879145085811615,
0.29971832036972046,
-0.26956623792648315,
0.42532774806022644,
-0.5141080021858215,
-0.02985856868326664,
-0.03287029638886452,
0.24494147300720215,
-0.6478388905525208,
0.3700356185436249,
0.11360406130552292,
1.3114420175552368,
-1.0343096256256104,
0.8138636946678162,
0.3632524013519287,
-0.1201258972287178,
-0.5028634071350098,
0.05327124521136284,
0.2710316479206085,
-0.43382728099823,
0.8000363707542419,
-0.5623190402984619,
-0.09119437634944916,
-0.033866435289382935,
-0.381107896566391,
-1.0536479949951172,
0.855938732624054,
0.4613857567310333,
-0.42090272903442383,
-0.0490972138941288,
-0.0710964947938919,
0.26181572675704956,
0.09750818461179733,
-0.12288118153810501,
0.683944821357727,
0.7486056685447693,
-0.09579296410083771,
-0.36913859844207764,
0.06374092400074005,
-0.17224550247192383,
-0.2304358035326004,
0.18494516611099243,
-0.5382488369941711,
0.6500391960144043,
-0.19510962069034576,
-0.21288004517555237,
-0.07980125397443771,
0.7789618372917175,
0.26210057735443115,
0.03314273804426193,
0.7073749303817749,
0.6069586277008057,
0.6931889653205872,
-0.06920246034860611,
0.8098098635673523,
-0.24618564546108246,
0.30284640192985535,
1.2466827630996704,
-0.46744492650032043,
0.7178217768669128,
0.3438340127468109,
-0.1000717505812645,
0.7886595726013184,
0.5331947803497314,
-0.1321328729391098,
0.5335522294044495,
-0.18788090348243713,
-0.5512888431549072,
-0.12510694563388824,
-0.08211951702833176,
-0.1733953058719635,
0.19073060154914856,
0.32547110319137573,
0.28017622232437134,
-0.309863805770874,
-0.042144738137722015,
0.6971950531005859,
-0.3407135009765625,
-0.12521038949489594,
0.7221360206604004,
-0.23194509744644165,
-0.6886224150657654,
0.3661562204360962,
0.2867167592048645,
0.1581059694290161,
-0.6998658180236816,
-0.190092533826828,
-0.3591972291469574,
-0.12821419537067413,
-0.19741849601268768,
-0.7406533360481262,
0.00917628314346075,
0.05542531982064247,
-0.38593563437461853,
0.36585891246795654,
0.5440359711647034,
-0.35712099075317383,
-0.45712336897850037,
0.23996922373771667,
0.13360270857810974,
-0.3380439877510071,
0.3778911232948303,
-0.7007839679718018,
0.41910386085510254,
-0.17069979012012482,
-0.31642666459083557,
0.05073724314570427,
0.5909789204597473,
-0.21901953220367432,
0.681525707244873,
0.7597535252571106,
0.377304345369339,
0.10377971082925797,
0.12058478593826294,
0.8337754011154175,
-0.5659425258636475,
-0.4322728216648102,
-0.6907795667648315,
0.34395113587379456,
-0.21102379262447357,
-0.2054925560951233,
0.8213600516319275,
0.41114842891693115,
0.38396820425987244,
0.04776749759912491,
0.7645673751831055,
-0.3438716530799866,
0.47763514518737793,
-0.8131961822509766,
0.6988753080368042,
-0.37001803517341614,
0.07630036771297455,
-0.2739541232585907,
-0.5957233309745789,
-0.042398713529109955,
0.06069400534033775,
-0.005299142096191645,
-0.2545567750930786,
0.923994779586792,
0.9130359888076782,
0.008190197870135307,
0.16152527928352356,
0.1850443184375763,
0.9498764872550964,
0.14238065481185913,
-0.03305961191654205,
0.8613666296005249,
-0.41673246026039124,
0.15062597393989563,
-0.49868088960647583,
-0.30420809984207153,
-0.31273141503334045,
-1.0720938444137573,
-0.5282601118087769,
-0.8560914397239685,
-0.7626160979270935,
-0.3536619246006012,
0.49326279759407043,
0.9560139179229736,
0.48090577125549316,
-0.6747921109199524,
-0.08978022634983063,
0.23286746442317963,
0.2948642075061798,
-0.15233765542507172,
-0.21532252430915833,
0.5871410965919495,
-0.18221385776996613,
-0.3683089017868042,
0.5140665769577026,
0.16069507598876953,
-0.042699623852968216,
-0.16135276854038239,
-0.03094553016126156,
-0.5029720067977905,
0.3252880275249481,
0.7971320152282715,
0.37503400444984436,
-0.292579710483551,
-0.6599927544593811,
-0.2066948115825653,
-0.02113543637096882,
-0.14376837015151978,
0.7131738066673279,
-0.636803150177002,
0.2645013630390167,
0.39827415347099304,
0.4373807907104492,
0.5666819214820862,
-0.23037990927696228,
0.39773547649383545,
-0.4595043361186981,
0.11449647694826126,
-0.23709945380687714,
0.30308985710144043,
0.432028204202652,
-0.36693307757377625,
0.25169891119003296,
0.7377832531929016,
-0.332204133272171,
-0.9230425953865051,
0.03902127593755722,
-1.0287935733795166,
-0.6117123365402222,
1.023257851600647,
0.1813032478094101,
-0.4042964577674866,
-0.5401511788368225,
0.3427773118019104,
0.401750385761261,
-0.13965632021427155,
0.7420665621757507,
0.8948977589607239,
0.19516481459140778,
0.0815577581524849,
-0.41442790627479553,
0.6424247026443481,
-0.17226140201091766,
-0.9002336263656616,
0.3670229911804199,
0.9313186407089233,
0.7743245959281921,
0.05058709532022476,
0.6705726385116577,
-0.14626891911029816,
0.5866677761077881,
-0.006150374189019203,
-0.0852246806025505,
-0.022468863055109978,
-0.446533739566803,
-0.10891291499137878,
-0.17860999703407288,
0.36400607228279114,
0.2992372214794159
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14341v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14341v1
|
Beyond Surface Similarity: Detecting Subtle Semantic Shifts in Financial Narratives
| 2024-03-21T12:17:59 | 2024-03-21T12:17:59 |
Jiaxin Liu, Yi Yang, Kar Yan Tam
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we introduce the Financial-STS task, a financial
domain-specific NLP task designed to measure the nuanced semantic similarity
between pairs of financial narratives. These narratives originate from the
financial statements of the same company but correspond to different periods,
such as year-over-year comparisons. Measuring the subtle semantic differences
between these paired narratives enables market stakeholders to gauge changes
over time in the company's financial and operational situations, which is
critical for financial decision-making. We find that existing pretrained
embedding models and LLM embeddings fall short in discerning these subtle
financial narrative shifts. To address this gap, we propose an LLM-augmented
pipeline specifically designed for the Financial-STS task. Evaluation on a
human-annotated dataset demonstrates that our proposed method outperforms
existing methods trained on classic STS tasks and generic LLM embeddings.
|
[
-0.01099105179309845,
-0.5188921093940735,
0.5162160396575928,
0.2035210281610489,
-0.29557907581329346,
0.6901513934135437,
0.07576773315668106,
-0.6715661883354187,
0.360554039478302,
0.6697617769241333,
-0.8068414926528931,
-0.7468032240867615,
-0.6982600092887878,
-0.0780031681060791,
-0.5199245810508728,
1.0068119764328003,
-0.27397727966308594,
-0.13893383741378784,
-0.296369731426239,
-0.1491430401802063,
-0.11926884204149246,
-0.1425514668226242,
-0.8456825017929077,
-0.0674954354763031,
0.5040695071220398,
0.0019494801526889205,
0.6331106424331665,
0.49511435627937317,
0.6585018634796143,
0.27187949419021606,
0.017330419272184372,
0.2806287407875061,
-0.2543001174926758,
-0.09147915989160538,
-0.22936895489692688,
-0.5959004759788513,
-0.2572598159313202,
0.10552478581666946,
0.5246611833572388,
0.8067361116409302,
0.01265070028603077,
0.461785227060318,
0.4590908885002136,
0.7462946176528931,
-0.5964458584785461,
0.5550327301025391,
-0.46779757738113403,
0.05999239906668663,
-0.1069226935505867,
-0.29414913058280945,
-0.12600861489772797,
-0.12739095091819763,
0.4447139501571655,
-0.7255209684371948,
0.5729060769081116,
0.2847970426082611,
1.193241834640503,
0.44852447509765625,
-0.6129955053329468,
-0.3055857717990875,
-0.5310532450675964,
0.8305192589759827,
-0.5560724139213562,
0.6011347770690918,
0.2191779762506485,
-0.03941960632801056,
0.23699332773685455,
-0.8834131956100464,
-0.23805174231529236,
-0.4004552662372589,
-0.07209062576293945,
0.11414095759391785,
-0.42828571796417236,
-0.20168472826480865,
0.07834643125534058,
0.094699427485466,
-0.20750074088573456,
0.1806453913450241,
-0.21274636685848236,
-0.2324603945016861,
0.4721980094909668,
0.26243317127227783,
-0.004030697047710419,
-0.041798610240221024,
-0.9527114033699036,
-0.44476693868637085,
-0.8708348870277405,
0.06984362751245499,
0.5109116435050964,
0.4767566919326782,
-0.4094415009021759,
0.43344688415527344,
0.12466756254434586,
0.29792341589927673,
0.0006572346901521087,
-0.1962183117866516,
0.2883797585964203,
-0.19989363849163055,
-0.2535209357738495,
0.32384225726127625,
0.14198318123817444,
0.6602031588554382,
0.16867640614509583,
-0.14481401443481445,
-0.37608376145362854,
0.09621976315975189,
0.2964097857475281,
-0.2076655477285385,
-0.09547482430934906,
-0.15094482898712158,
-0.5994011163711548,
-0.3685533404350281,
0.2467612624168396,
-0.30023500323295593,
-0.5522021055221558,
-0.7040500044822693,
0.24426540732383728,
-0.30009934306144714,
-0.1017274260520935,
0.02117505855858326,
-0.7174147367477417,
0.5784808397293091,
0.2286233901977539,
-0.5528771281242371,
0.436526894569397,
1.2633287906646729,
0.852942168712616,
-0.22720620036125183,
-0.16698120534420013,
-0.5273796319961548,
0.556025505065918,
-0.3645400106906891,
0.9590224623680115,
-0.46093618869781494,
-0.30656898021698,
-0.08250749856233597,
-0.2099529206752777,
-0.11335967481136322,
-0.7168331146240234,
0.3092595338821411,
-0.30845147371292114,
-0.10535793006420135,
-0.290833443403244,
-0.6992724537849426,
-0.02564975805580616,
0.27667325735092163,
-0.5076826214790344,
0.9725925326347351,
0.352477103471756,
-0.8466454744338989,
0.9447803497314453,
-0.5887452363967896,
-0.20474933087825775,
0.014273873530328274,
-0.33265942335128784,
-0.4183447062969208,
0.225320503115654,
0.10193885862827301,
0.2933937609195709,
-0.28435707092285156,
0.19888556003570557,
-0.3295380175113678,
-0.25881266593933105,
0.4615539610385895,
-0.3465845584869385,
0.38952505588531494,
-0.028378501534461975,
-0.24397395551204681,
0.16366362571716309,
-0.7608833909034729,
-0.37990543246269226,
0.10110689699649811,
0.16834726929664612,
-0.9324097633361816,
0.1464877724647522,
0.2887996435165405,
-0.07343759387731552,
0.5516077280044556,
-0.49612733721733093,
0.13978751003742218,
-0.6056216955184937,
0.5233633518218994,
0.9970630407333374,
-0.11110106110572815,
0.41834115982055664,
-0.5679333806037903,
0.47106224298477173,
0.2801443338394165,
0.11732089519500732,
-0.05555570498108864,
-0.29864150285720825,
-0.6120815873146057,
-0.3229632079601288,
0.35893142223358154,
0.7169676423072815,
-0.513675332069397,
0.18103331327438354,
-0.277587890625,
-0.31030070781707764,
-0.5261619091033936,
0.09783537685871124,
0.15217499434947968,
0.512152373790741,
0.34108877182006836,
-0.24603399634361267,
-0.3759995996952057,
-1.2247886657714844,
-0.9150921106338501,
-0.11430411785840988,
-0.4175170660018921,
0.25473764538764954,
0.35463276505470276,
-0.05410975217819214,
0.9378053545951843,
-0.8654921650886536,
-0.35502171516418457,
-0.13774536550045013,
0.3422785997390747,
0.1831529140472412,
0.4251777231693268,
0.7350406050682068,
-0.8971982598304749,
-0.24813653528690338,
0.0812341719865799,
-0.4205690324306488,
-0.026471389457583427,
-0.7280376553535461,
0.18138548731803894,
0.14715556800365448,
0.8294155597686768,
-0.3988338112831116,
0.5346353650093079,
0.5345320105552673,
-0.9151932597160339,
0.18293605744838715,
-0.23597314953804016,
0.133572518825531,
-0.895343005657196,
-0.17824678122997284,
0.2234407663345337,
-0.17661087214946747,
-0.25332194566726685,
-0.10084032267332077,
0.0769423395395279,
0.20983771979808807,
-0.25989678502082825,
0.7501675486564636,
-0.33951428532600403,
-0.4315323829650879,
-0.05347897857427597,
0.40300270915031433,
0.18252989649772644,
0.3388797640800476,
-0.10072217136621475,
0.532247006893158,
0.43351250886917114,
-0.4643476903438568,
0.08223281800746918,
0.2809315323829651,
-0.5567466020584106,
0.7424154281616211,
-0.48686710000038147,
-0.0003959878522437066,
0.058071788400411606,
0.15546324849128723,
-1.3064299821853638,
0.33018362522125244,
0.21732409298419952,
-0.23182062804698944,
0.21659761667251587,
-0.1647963672876358,
-0.4746842384338379,
0.032929692417383194,
-0.4529370963573456,
0.29035577178001404,
0.1904972344636917,
-0.5316646695137024,
0.9260168671607971,
0.017825352028012276,
-0.6823487281799316,
-0.4005221128463745,
-1.004281759262085,
0.32692742347717285,
-0.5664322972297668,
-0.8574327826499939,
0.7767743468284607,
0.4172568619251251,
-0.5707329511642456,
0.1408972442150116,
-0.5881093740463257,
0.03382105752825737,
0.1941198706626892,
0.3162238895893097,
0.6163111925125122,
-0.4328102767467499,
-0.0630376860499382,
0.33264273405075073,
-0.3701358139514923,
0.2515394389629364,
-0.47819238901138306,
0.2226964235305786,
-0.08021221309900284,
-0.38178548216819763,
-0.24255616962909698,
0.14019279181957245,
0.030290191993117332,
-0.03532075509428978,
0.7244205474853516,
0.5626437067985535,
-0.09996385127305984,
-0.10206776112318039,
-0.6830087900161743,
0.17264117300510406,
-0.5414071083068848,
-0.0630703866481781,
-0.24613647162914276,
-1.1708290576934814,
0.8886038661003113,
-0.5062362551689148,
0.1555113047361374,
0.8856479525566101,
0.18817289173603058,
-0.22489646077156067,
0.5771258473396301,
0.6456814408302307,
0.2604019045829773,
0.47369512915611267,
-0.23440130054950714,
0.2428496927022934,
-0.6152655482292175,
-0.3816699981689453,
-0.33996817469596863,
-0.7938730716705322,
-0.5137796998023987,
-0.47970712184906006,
0.26131105422973633,
0.06706544756889343,
-0.18299232423305511,
0.36376142501831055,
-0.12052693963050842,
0.48749735951423645,
0.43084582686424255,
-0.12658026814460754,
0.2812628746032715,
-0.17139104008674622,
-0.20676158368587494,
-0.2927916646003723,
-0.23336923122406006,
-0.3854227662086487,
0.9384722113609314,
0.44034501910209656,
0.510310709476471,
-0.14970490336418152,
0.7851306796073914,
0.5918055772781372,
0.15298236906528473,
-0.35314497351646423,
0.3201378285884857,
-0.44285911321640015,
0.02940143086016178,
-0.1316678524017334,
-0.6035294532775879,
-0.9584880471229553,
-0.11031213402748108,
-0.06620441377162933,
-0.4033581018447876,
0.2700316607952118,
-0.23616456985473633,
-0.5057981014251709,
0.2225555181503296,
-0.6984184980392456,
0.8004613518714905,
-0.3007371127605438,
-0.01216463465243578,
-0.32707861065864563,
-0.6331226229667664,
0.007853804156184196,
-0.17855380475521088,
0.2514078617095947,
-0.25943657755851746,
-0.6152006387710571,
0.634409487247467,
-0.23191341757774353,
1.1995450258255005,
-0.1819642037153244,
-0.4355701208114624,
0.23222310841083527,
0.19790314137935638,
0.6133878231048584,
0.1435994803905487,
0.2977042496204376,
0.3555242121219635,
0.126877099275589,
-0.5141443014144897,
-0.6738222241401672,
0.8309295177459717,
-0.4349498450756073,
-0.48206034302711487,
-0.47523197531700134,
-0.5864559412002563,
-0.2468787431716919,
-0.27238261699676514,
-0.21793773770332336,
0.21869885921478271,
-0.37638986110687256,
-0.14157503843307495,
0.18262676894664764,
-0.29903683066368103,
0.41725265979766846,
0.4767545163631439,
-0.0826658383011818,
-0.10760144889354706,
0.6370190382003784,
-0.07513442635536194,
0.12665589153766632,
0.5933507084846497,
0.3334781527519226,
-0.5463389158248901,
-0.4746766984462738,
-0.08367948979139328,
0.14100846648216248,
-0.5212648510932922,
-0.19400575757026672,
-0.255941241979599,
0.06906890124082565,
-0.485236257314682,
-0.5948980450630188,
-0.32925650477409363,
-0.708526074886322,
-0.2836463153362274,
-0.3543369770050049,
0.7216015458106995,
0.7453686594963074,
-0.3331097960472107,
0.05530284717679024,
-1.0746326446533203,
0.4853880703449249,
0.2290319800376892,
0.3579642176628113,
-0.19142240285873413,
-0.6336577534675598,
-0.22024545073509216,
0.06560511887073517,
-0.05501514673233032,
-0.289048433303833,
0.3935793936252594,
0.17452865839004517,
0.3380995988845825,
0.6209568977355957,
0.050878413021564484,
0.7692467570304871,
-0.200489804148674,
0.8514631986618042,
0.20754453539848328,
-1.0828235149383545,
0.5030771493911743,
-0.3393676280975342,
0.3541404902935028,
0.5441270470619202,
0.3187010586261749,
-0.5560012459754944,
-0.5133242011070251,
-0.9550313353538513,
-1.1015238761901855,
0.4587392807006836,
0.09300284087657928,
0.18740202486515045,
-0.1046595424413681,
0.47771191596984863,
0.2777610719203949,
0.37929293513298035,
-0.230477973818779,
-0.23439115285873413,
0.10015638917684555,
-0.11225234717130661,
0.026260046288371086,
-0.026595164090394974,
-0.07786663621664047,
-0.17735861241817474,
0.1690760999917984,
-0.11035528779029846,
-0.13943538069725037,
0.1521817296743393,
0.09570261836051941,
0.0665898323059082,
-0.10965541750192642,
0.3697626292705536,
0.8184562921524048,
-0.14624468982219696,
0.09502169489860535,
0.45405858755111694,
-0.3269038200378418,
-0.37074539065361023,
0.3053573966026306,
0.14619439840316772,
0.13069812953472137,
0.771105945110321,
0.7746211886405945,
1.1111199855804443,
-0.969242513179779,
0.6712284088134766,
0.07693826407194138,
-0.3729165494441986,
-0.5285388827323914,
-0.17597851157188416,
0.21494245529174805,
0.8163033723831177,
0.5265013575553894,
0.39100518822669983,
0.23404738306999207,
-0.6113989353179932,
0.3805229365825653,
0.14317630231380463,
-0.4460676908493042,
-0.118315190076828,
0.5285201668739319,
0.14386001229286194,
-0.1721855252981186,
0.7714486122131348,
-0.06487184017896652,
-0.33775395154953003,
0.7300004363059998,
0.2801833152770996,
1.1901342868804932,
-0.06605323404073715,
0.3516506850719452,
-0.19074638187885284,
0.20264869928359985,
-0.042174458503723145,
0.19618314504623413,
-0.2122625708580017,
-0.669120192527771,
-0.6246832609176636,
-0.5796367526054382,
-0.3075440227985382,
-0.2325958013534546,
-0.9654288291931152,
0.4560593068599701,
-0.6401979327201843,
-0.000008729508408578113,
0.11204172670841217,
-0.31990036368370056,
-0.805230438709259,
0.06690029799938202,
0.38865816593170166,
0.9136760234832764,
-0.7044531106948853,
0.38711175322532654,
0.4773229658603668,
-0.02622835338115692,
-0.29129236936569214,
-0.11704573035240173,
0.2179199457168579,
-1.0445221662521362,
0.9576035141944885,
0.03387467935681343,
-0.18695217370986938,
-0.2778836488723755,
-0.4746289849281311,
-0.7319835424423218,
1.253927230834961,
0.36083608865737915,
-0.9538615345954895,
-0.3644039034843445,
0.5207136273384094,
0.5177040100097656,
-0.5270472764968872,
-0.37116047739982605,
0.6505370736122131,
0.4569047689437866,
0.18260744214057922,
-0.794867217540741,
-0.14596304297447205,
0.11153089255094528,
-0.14796148240566254,
0.5693922638893127,
-0.6778826117515564,
0.7088682651519775,
-0.28405582904815674,
-0.323934942483902,
-0.14406000077724457,
0.6666486859321594,
0.2955048978328705,
0.9732072949409485,
0.7061795592308044,
0.7498839497566223,
0.7438468933105469,
-0.19603696465492249,
1.092820167541504,
-0.4000268578529358,
0.3699183166027069,
1.0794498920440674,
-0.39358091354370117,
0.895763099193573,
0.5481209754943848,
-0.24874387681484222,
0.5541697144508362,
0.46974852681159973,
-0.4849085211753845,
0.4126425087451935,
0.5191020369529724,
-0.17060141265392303,
-0.45676565170288086,
-0.08869948238134384,
-0.20699231326580048,
0.4857999086380005,
0.44478875398635864,
-0.5191123485565186,
-0.27476730942726135,
-0.13966548442840576,
-0.2169395089149475,
0.17136985063552856,
-0.4243949055671692,
0.7674619555473328,
0.6318644285202026,
0.007312378846108913,
-0.06064809113740921,
0.012837596237659454,
0.7205547094345093,
-0.8163899779319763,
-0.07900034636259079,
-0.052307795733213425,
0.12734641134738922,
-0.030554836615920067,
-0.8552964329719543,
0.6783943772315979,
0.036312997341156006,
0.027038665488362312,
-0.8205353617668152,
0.6925780773162842,
-0.32004040479660034,
-0.6542798280715942,
0.574158251285553,
0.5327998995780945,
-0.08322308957576752,
-0.3432537019252777,
-0.9609517455101013,
-0.0684329941868782,
-0.04940105974674225,
-0.12550859153270721,
0.4987211227416992,
0.8011200428009033,
0.005338291171938181,
0.557830274105072,
0.7810224890708923,
-0.2165001481771469,
-0.19202980399131775,
0.5056975483894348,
0.7043200731277466,
-1.1701574325561523,
-0.7265875935554504,
-0.7531322240829468,
0.14822326600551605,
0.03916444256901741,
-0.7173143029212952,
0.7372380495071411,
0.8782356381416321,
0.927275538444519,
-0.13559530675411224,
0.4787841737270355,
0.40285125374794006,
0.5608323216438293,
-0.8754132986068726,
0.460348516702652,
-0.5777971744537354,
0.5672578811645508,
-0.38032639026641846,
-1.095840334892273,
-0.15635688602924347,
0.4218237102031708,
-0.25711238384246826,
-0.32555657625198364,
0.637438952922821,
0.4413471817970276,
-0.05775978043675423,
0.35599854588508606,
0.09753744304180145,
0.19490563869476318,
-0.1597873419523239,
0.34944942593574524,
1.082737922668457,
-0.2569107711315155,
0.46194738149642944,
0.07483038306236267,
0.209756538271904,
0.015226625837385654,
-1.0829153060913086,
-0.6918169260025024,
-0.6568033695220947,
-0.9123496413230896,
-0.19804665446281433,
-0.06617370992898941,
0.7510265111923218,
-0.05066153407096863,
-0.6448875665664673,
-0.21069172024726868,
0.16227856278419495,
-0.060559287667274475,
-0.44769367575645447,
-0.2842390835285187,
0.5358421802520752,
-0.21066343784332275,
-0.47398364543914795,
0.6204712986946106,
0.6534738540649414,
0.1666858047246933,
-0.14035463333129883,
0.2427331954240799,
0.0009585879161022604,
0.16455033421516418,
0.5489587783813477,
-0.19813022017478943,
-0.6190887093544006,
-0.5934193134307861,
-0.08323830366134644,
0.1754705011844635,
-0.10057910531759262,
1.1946312189102173,
-0.6277649402618408,
-0.2546054720878601,
0.37481626868247986,
0.8428220152854919,
0.8001832962036133,
-0.04944191500544548,
0.4954918920993805,
-1.017590880393982,
0.07026482373476028,
0.1816904991865158,
0.250550240278244,
0.19689637422561646,
-0.36162441968917847,
0.5784091949462891,
0.2559957206249237,
-0.1210491731762886,
-0.5150924324989319,
-0.05912824720144272,
-1.3600778579711914,
-0.5129824280738831,
0.9168382287025452,
-0.1716172695159912,
-0.12373290210962296,
-0.1872912049293518,
0.059036631137132645,
-0.09583970904350281,
-0.36307448148727417,
0.817329466342926,
0.7679860591888428,
-0.041357651352882385,
0.17150893807411194,
-0.3123343884944916,
0.4702783524990082,
0.2569659948348999,
-0.40068989992141724,
0.05014483630657196,
0.21020261943340302,
0.3392154574394226,
0.2476998269557953,
0.19582237303256989,
0.0046745892614126205,
-0.021592553704977036,
0.4254286587238312,
-0.3755415380001068,
-0.05014093592762947,
-0.16197086870670319,
-0.11053630709648132,
0.14924761652946472,
-0.29807600378990173,
-0.019754495471715927
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14339v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14339v1
|
$\nabla τ$: Gradient-based and Task-Agnostic machine Unlearning
| 2024-03-21T12:11:26 | 2024-03-21T12:11:26 |
Daniel Trippa, Cesare Campagnano, Maria Sofia Bucarelli, Gabriele Tolomei, Fabrizio Silvestri
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Machine Unlearning, the process of selectively eliminating the influence of
certain data examples used during a model's training, has gained significant
attention as a means for practitioners to comply with recent data protection
regulations. However, existing unlearning methods face critical drawbacks,
including their prohibitively high cost, often associated with a large number
of hyperparameters, and the limitation of forgetting only relatively small data
portions. This often makes retraining the model from scratch a quicker and more
effective solution. In this study, we introduce Gradient-based and
Task-Agnostic machine Unlearning ($\nabla \tau$), an optimization framework
designed to remove the influence of a subset of training data efficiently. It
applies adaptive gradient ascent to the data to be forgotten while using
standard gradient descent for the remaining data. $\nabla \tau$ offers multiple
benefits over existing approaches. It enables the unlearning of large sections
of the training dataset (up to 30%). It is versatile, supporting various
unlearning tasks (such as subset forgetting or class removal) and applicable
across different domains (images, text, etc.). Importantly, $\nabla \tau$
requires no hyperparameter adjustments, making it a more appealing option than
retraining the model from scratch. We evaluate our framework's effectiveness
using a set of well-established Membership Inference Attack metrics,
demonstrating up to 10% enhancements in performance compared to
state-of-the-art methods without compromising the original model's accuracy.
|
[
-0.28713667392730713,
-0.8427963852882385,
-0.14703123271465302,
-0.44646966457366943,
-0.4988277554512024,
0.1974717676639557,
0.03946489840745926,
-0.03154907003045082,
-0.17626498639583588,
0.3839014172554016,
-0.7586845755577087,
-0.4228018522262573,
-0.6376527547836304,
-0.49873191118240356,
-0.470093697309494,
1.2546647787094116,
0.003520335303619504,
0.2636586129665375,
-0.21585328876972198,
-0.32341477274894714,
-0.344968318939209,
-0.64857017993927,
-0.9057600498199463,
-0.5644023418426514,
0.569230854511261,
0.11892998963594437,
0.40919995307922363,
0.7875412702560425,
0.3543083071708679,
0.2368917614221573,
-0.11451908946037292,
0.321541428565979,
-0.7749444842338562,
0.2968096435070038,
-0.35397669672966003,
-0.44983917474746704,
-0.14087985455989838,
-0.08600806444883347,
0.3836950659751892,
0.7845672965049744,
-0.32834920287132263,
0.32971706986427307,
0.2782047986984253,
1.1916197538375854,
-1.2072592973709106,
0.02766677737236023,
-0.7818353772163391,
0.33783936500549316,
-0.1509600579738617,
-0.19727782905101776,
-0.25905662775039673,
0.14172543585300446,
-0.13753405213356018,
-0.8421747088432312,
0.5306370854377747,
-0.18329225480556488,
0.47624340653419495,
0.6324300765991211,
-0.25670501589775085,
-0.19004520773887634,
-0.7145642042160034,
0.9891324639320374,
-0.16350916028022766,
0.6089470386505127,
0.4683191776275635,
0.45314207673072815,
-0.18920066952705383,
-0.9029470682144165,
-0.15527425706386566,
0.44280359148979187,
0.2868993282318115,
0.3030022084712982,
-0.5575509071350098,
0.04337240010499954,
0.29815980792045593,
0.3650156557559967,
-0.31040629744529724,
0.31433573365211487,
-0.42569202184677124,
-0.13847965002059937,
0.4103653132915497,
0.06328028440475464,
-0.048496637493371964,
0.18774385750293732,
-0.5012296438217163,
0.11828581243753433,
-0.7534524202346802,
0.20692165195941925,
0.29865121841430664,
0.13563048839569092,
0.23781554400920868,
0.32650887966156006,
-0.04127559810876846,
0.44043922424316406,
0.17599666118621826,
-0.0469096340239048,
0.3620796501636505,
0.10360479354858398,
-0.5959005951881409,
-0.34840530157089233,
0.46970292925834656,
0.26280033588409424,
0.03266289457678795,
-0.7304766178131104,
-0.5551407337188721,
0.09817792475223541,
0.5695996880531311,
-0.7285066843032837,
-0.16056600213050842,
0.1356399655342102,
-0.8015283942222595,
-0.2726716101169586,
-0.020270084962248802,
-0.8172471523284912,
-0.5410503149032593,
-0.5859261155128479,
0.42874962091445923,
-0.47706565260887146,
0.16888907551765442,
0.001608076156117022,
-0.19562508165836334,
-0.10534609109163284,
0.6332065463066101,
-0.7474210262298584,
0.16706380248069763,
0.5568835139274597,
0.7692868709564209,
-0.20494388043880463,
-0.12832674384117126,
-1.067469596862793,
0.06952733546495438,
-0.07814807444810867,
0.1445579081773758,
-0.5561325550079346,
-0.8911594748497009,
0.02478739060461521,
0.12374083697795868,
-0.19133707880973816,
-0.4230089783668518,
0.7535400986671448,
-0.8254162669181824,
0.16629059612751007,
-0.4065752923488617,
-0.9338777661323547,
-0.5270976424217224,
-0.01665141060948372,
-0.4613014757633209,
0.9565593600273132,
0.12876644730567932,
-0.6622024178504944,
0.5007493495941162,
-0.5753859281539917,
-0.3159540891647339,
-0.0602436400949955,
-0.025579385459423065,
-0.6676180958747864,
0.1133311539888382,
0.2106291949748993,
0.44197216629981995,
-0.5654063820838928,
0.13728073239326477,
-0.2590488791465759,
-0.39715370535850525,
-0.2080073207616806,
-0.4979792833328247,
1.0339683294296265,
0.4327196776866913,
-0.6440309286117554,
-0.010632661171257496,
-0.6971911787986755,
-0.07742568105459213,
-0.013004864566028118,
-0.4572838544845581,
-0.3547622561454773,
-0.037540748715400696,
-0.2135855257511139,
0.05654235929250717,
0.04516688734292984,
-0.7028664946556091,
0.16126292943954468,
-0.12454307079315186,
0.28832393884658813,
0.9209050536155701,
0.1339990794658661,
0.65665602684021,
-0.6948645710945129,
0.6769606471061707,
0.1273338347673416,
0.19985125958919525,
-0.23844654858112335,
-0.4123351275920868,
-0.7466882467269897,
-0.5999845266342163,
0.4474829137325287,
0.42177852988243103,
-0.9327162504196167,
0.4453805387020111,
0.350626140832901,
-0.8049727082252502,
-0.7237948775291443,
0.5340943932533264,
0.780875027179718,
0.9357286691665649,
0.6219810843467712,
-0.5813596844673157,
-0.5460123419761658,
-0.5445298552513123,
-0.14848928153514862,
-0.01586206816136837,
0.10755296051502228,
0.0768812894821167,
0.5563938021659851,
-0.4922311305999756,
0.5904637575149536,
-0.29620498418807983,
-0.5300716161727905,
0.11951780319213867,
0.07409075647592545,
-0.12372109293937683,
0.5965497493743896,
0.5096012353897095,
-0.6491774320602417,
-0.3064800202846527,
0.02263241820037365,
-1.1430449485778809,
0.2507159411907196,
-0.2197025567293167,
-0.14747223258018494,
0.3138963580131531,
0.6333127021789551,
-0.629438579082489,
0.90995192527771,
0.08077731728553772,
0.1761019229888916,
0.4734559655189514,
-0.5915634632110596,
-0.11446459591388702,
-0.7219312191009521,
0.3377685844898224,
0.02917667105793953,
-0.033074114471673965,
-0.8325780630111694,
0.23933608829975128,
0.12170282751321793,
-0.08644383400678635,
-0.42709213495254517,
0.6746712327003479,
-0.5054252743721008,
-0.06998181343078613,
-0.34432533383369446,
-0.32495811581611633,
0.09134287387132645,
0.869047999382019,
-0.3082349896430969,
0.6099910140037537,
0.905547559261322,
-0.8824987411499023,
0.2327657788991928,
0.3575340211391449,
-0.3059294819831848,
0.5238414406776428,
-0.5751456022262573,
0.23776164650917053,
-0.5927650332450867,
0.24065007269382477,
-0.6025095582008362,
0.30322733521461487,
0.32841911911964417,
-0.28918349742889404,
0.3891947865486145,
-0.28748875856399536,
-0.27371785044670105,
-0.2555503845214844,
-0.3682585060596466,
0.33737075328826904,
0.7297996878623962,
-0.9252459406852722,
0.576485812664032,
0.4348248541355133,
0.2964272201061249,
-1.2014142274856567,
-0.28668275475502014,
-0.3540210723876953,
-0.4803585112094879,
-0.012682819738984108,
0.46073225140571594,
-0.01531329657882452,
-0.007486318238079548,
-0.21331341564655304,
-0.286304771900177,
-0.1469225138425827,
0.4330679774284363,
0.5654321908950806,
0.1750093698501587,
0.2585115134716034,
0.3700425624847412,
0.12669987976551056,
-0.12294340878725052,
-0.03700705245137215,
-0.4562026262283325,
0.39289820194244385,
0.21500885486602783,
-0.6533503532409668,
-0.632964551448822,
0.026390142738819122,
0.669899046421051,
-0.3676247298717499,
0.5723862648010254,
0.8927487134933472,
-0.4896797835826874,
-0.44976967573165894,
-0.18553359806537628,
-0.16932186484336853,
-0.47111716866493225,
0.3653704524040222,
-0.06423012912273407,
-0.4770221412181854,
0.5333958864212036,
-0.08972150087356567,
0.7637129426002502,
0.19076915085315704,
0.52543044090271,
-0.32000353932380676,
0.689953625202179,
0.45673567056655884,
-0.48018133640289307,
0.5541086792945862,
-0.4135766327381134,
-0.1177939921617508,
-0.8539570569992065,
-0.5214881896972656,
-0.46846234798431396,
-0.5807291269302368,
-0.1996469795703888,
-0.4329812228679657,
0.16318672895431519,
0.25883761048316956,
-0.6471485495567322,
0.07463396340608597,
-0.49418944120407104,
0.21847830712795258,
0.7781680822372437,
0.3159547448158264,
0.20367929339408875,
0.30884262919425964,
-0.0008047738811001182,
0.010118796490132809,
-0.7124499678611755,
-0.12885242700576782,
1.6252102851867676,
0.3126961290836334,
0.764228343963623,
0.13375510275363922,
0.6484611630439758,
0.6625906229019165,
0.18469297885894775,
-0.6108700037002563,
0.35454264283180237,
-0.32809120416641235,
-0.4755866825580597,
-0.2405809611082077,
-0.5561141967773438,
-1.3997154235839844,
0.40305253863334656,
-0.4001152217388153,
-0.6493882536888123,
0.2889440953731537,
0.30928003787994385,
-0.1077834889292717,
0.7817950248718262,
-0.4218134880065918,
0.5433675646781921,
-0.15488290786743164,
-0.3756193518638611,
-0.15798096358776093,
-0.4702126085758209,
0.13925959169864655,
-0.5423476696014404,
0.13654710352420807,
0.19418901205062866,
-0.039690278470516205,
0.8982530832290649,
-0.5328189134597778,
1.0645999908447266,
-0.7151145935058594,
0.03917529433965683,
0.27029871940612793,
0.04302256926894188,
0.6086261868476868,
-0.16061091423034668,
-0.22041550278663635,
0.05282345041632652,
-0.3733888864517212,
-0.4940553307533264,
-0.6864200830459595,
0.41434264183044434,
-0.8555902242660522,
-0.4622787535190582,
-0.0763268917798996,
-0.611457884311676,
-0.27958041429519653,
0.2642382085323334,
0.5263708233833313,
0.5663250684738159,
-0.34615442156791687,
0.29655158519744873,
0.7175214290618896,
-0.09659762680530548,
0.5856390595436096,
0.4167551100254059,
-0.11771038174629211,
-0.19598887860774994,
1.1553335189819336,
0.018873902037739754,
0.06791186332702637,
0.33607709407806396,
-0.20775429904460907,
-0.34376513957977295,
-0.5948224663734436,
-0.6396891474723816,
0.01530626229941845,
-0.7592909932136536,
-0.3501432538032532,
-0.5967404842376709,
0.021325763314962387,
0.08514756709337234,
-0.3473203480243683,
-0.1989579200744629,
-0.5358662009239197,
-0.63019198179245,
-0.025093022733926773,
0.12122026085853577,
0.40458357334136963,
-0.08534656465053558,
0.572910726070404,
-0.6480172872543335,
0.09091080725193024,
0.16442425549030304,
0.08962933719158173,
0.3688971996307373,
-0.87624192237854,
-0.24727791547775269,
0.23178306221961975,
-0.5811132788658142,
-0.438181608915329,
0.41289663314819336,
0.374999076128006,
0.9014291167259216,
0.729594886302948,
0.10350662469863892,
0.44821295142173767,
-0.4187096357345581,
0.22232528030872345,
0.5609273910522461,
-0.8387011885643005,
0.17299112677574158,
-0.2710128128528595,
0.05376233160495758,
0.7080028057098389,
0.4438435435295105,
-0.21394185721874237,
-0.04332779347896576,
-0.8179572224617004,
-0.6332614421844482,
0.5032659769058228,
0.14348095655441284,
0.04749104008078575,
0.3780233860015869,
0.7210003733634949,
0.2837916910648346,
0.5230864882469177,
-0.17638294398784637,
-0.6467462778091431,
-0.3142125606536865,
-0.014672932215034962,
-0.31843459606170654,
0.17366939783096313,
-0.2494545578956604,
-0.25923678278923035,
0.925132155418396,
-0.02562740631401539,
0.18588665127754211,
-0.4077453911304474,
-0.31749042868614197,
-0.1815042942762375,
-0.11250590533018112,
0.029644202440977097,
0.4976230263710022,
-0.05454924330115318,
-0.09101349860429764,
0.1950971633195877,
-0.5302334427833557,
0.33696824312210083,
0.055700190365314484,
-0.5761438608169556,
0.12909801304340363,
0.07243439555168152,
0.7171855568885803,
0.2359037548303604,
-0.5394561886787415,
0.3322557508945465,
0.19105547666549683,
-0.3570173978805542,
0.03070834092795849,
0.38205254077911377,
-0.16614435613155365,
0.06797545403242111,
0.26998239755630493,
0.31314560770988464,
0.07924382388591766,
-0.4167073667049408,
0.5296863913536072,
0.7006927728652954,
-0.7231637835502625,
-0.21601763367652893,
0.8244228959083557,
0.1907060444355011,
-0.18276368081569672,
0.46516507863998413,
-0.14408454298973083,
-0.134374737739563,
0.6364647746086121,
0.2690308392047882,
0.5750858783721924,
-0.34537768363952637,
0.4042254090309143,
0.24453772604465485,
0.0423424206674099,
-0.05233466997742653,
-0.028898369520902634,
-0.10249750316143036,
-0.6845141649246216,
0.08783795684576035,
-0.48761194944381714,
-0.22638554871082306,
0.14134109020233154,
-1.0224300622940063,
0.007228775881230831,
-0.8912794589996338,
-0.2117881178855896,
0.25010326504707336,
-0.004081567283719778,
-0.6930462121963501,
0.4448869526386261,
-0.4233388304710388,
0.8062397241592407,
-0.47415512800216675,
0.8693137168884277,
0.7424219846725464,
-0.32310375571250916,
-0.23950065672397614,
-0.298374742269516,
0.4239271283149719,
-1.1687688827514648,
0.5096032023429871,
0.040187474340200424,
-0.026308495551347733,
-0.06641972064971924,
0.08049717545509338,
-0.39467307925224304,
1.181145429611206,
0.526695966720581,
-0.622533917427063,
-0.1025332659482956,
-0.22123035788536072,
0.2998197376728058,
-0.30338054895401,
-0.06765397638082504,
0.4316553473472595,
0.060000501573085785,
-0.013769791461527348,
-0.41893067955970764,
-0.14678660035133362,
-0.2959586977958679,
-0.30359387397766113,
0.3673173189163208,
-0.5453506112098694,
0.9334350824356079,
-0.2823081314563751,
-0.10640060901641846,
-0.12804874777793884,
0.6554277539253235,
-0.011166277341544628,
0.47247207164764404,
0.6314101815223694,
0.6303878426551819,
1.4498577117919922,
0.27243801951408386,
0.8335781693458557,
-0.22313466668128967,
0.4608682692050934,
1.0613607168197632,
-0.14387767016887665,
0.28995057940483093,
0.2577632963657379,
-0.033921558409929276,
0.22761718928813934,
0.6213449239730835,
-0.06247948110103607,
0.710080087184906,
0.13706816732883453,
-0.5072328448295593,
-0.2380567342042923,
0.02880665846168995,
-0.38937368988990784,
0.39764565229415894,
0.17527630925178528,
-0.41222307085990906,
-0.4943227469921112,
0.05558185651898384,
0.1942741423845291,
-0.054831378161907196,
-0.6708642840385437,
0.5810177326202393,
0.026223357766866684,
-0.3798066973686218,
0.6638083457946777,
0.16265307366847992,
0.5300094485282898,
-0.49406057596206665,
0.3063303530216217,
-0.25884631276130676,
0.3818848431110382,
-0.18419525027275085,
-0.12003997713327408,
0.04243164137005806,
0.1719541996717453,
-0.29047366976737976,
-0.07124918699264526,
0.7206737995147705,
-0.24440546333789825,
-0.3465701639652252,
0.410171777009964,
0.8411411046981812,
0.03688659891486168,
0.12221229076385498,
-1.0810012817382812,
-0.32351070642471313,
0.3721911311149597,
-0.14857445657253265,
0.8235141634941101,
0.26498666405677795,
-0.028671471402049065,
0.9496106505393982,
0.8446514010429382,
-0.15359383821487427,
-0.25107085704803467,
0.019620846956968307,
1.089500069618225,
-0.18663270771503448,
-0.44140195846557617,
-0.5738027095794678,
0.35554710030555725,
0.09322362393140793,
-0.42659124732017517,
0.6065399646759033,
0.547886848449707,
0.7003287076950073,
0.1968178153038025,
1.005449652671814,
0.4050593376159668,
0.5540860891342163,
-0.5834212303161621,
0.798850953578949,
-0.8206040263175964,
0.3665097653865814,
-0.30564746260643005,
-0.8255923986434937,
-0.1428535133600235,
0.4513118863105774,
0.013547874055802822,
0.298259437084198,
0.31634530425071716,
0.6879173517227173,
-0.2300446331501007,
0.19520357251167297,
0.4610765278339386,
-0.32887712121009827,
0.3247111141681671,
0.4297757148742676,
0.4184851348400116,
-0.26673436164855957,
0.34577956795692444,
-0.22814559936523438,
-0.2402181774377823,
-0.027915235608816147,
-0.5326721668243408,
-1.1523486375808716,
-0.5790256261825562,
-0.2781379520893097,
-0.30423980951309204,
0.3818676173686981,
0.5760380625724792,
0.5755926370620728,
-0.6310888528823853,
0.019648008048534393,
-0.14296481013298035,
0.10292637348175049,
-0.33484524488449097,
-0.03333819657564163,
0.6688403487205505,
-0.5803943872451782,
-0.6276295781135559,
0.44917216897010803,
-0.05954395607113838,
0.09728007018566132,
-0.11441747099161148,
-0.29933568835258484,
-0.04353596642613411,
-0.06061691790819168,
0.3432556390762329,
0.7440075278282166,
-0.36517593264579773,
0.002463471842929721,
-0.23851357400417328,
0.0994749367237091,
-0.11978749185800552,
0.9559041261672974,
-0.8032554984092712,
0.5739638805389404,
-0.10632837563753128,
1.2835488319396973,
0.5637697577476501,
0.12236043065786362,
0.4362999200820923,
-0.8692298531532288,
0.3235027492046356,
-0.037675641477108,
0.7791229486465454,
0.16598837077617645,
-0.3381115794181824,
0.6351310610771179,
0.4388889968395233,
-0.40844181180000305,
-0.9482899904251099,
0.2364996373653412,
-0.5477244257926941,
-0.5588275194168091,
0.8122142553329468,
-0.4479978680610657,
-0.1054789125919342,
-0.4539482295513153,
-0.05443790927529335,
0.34520772099494934,
-0.5079483985900879,
0.8187964558601379,
0.16903486847877502,
0.05067417770624161,
0.11106540262699127,
-0.4929506480693817,
0.6096353530883789,
0.7899376749992371,
-0.687686026096344,
0.34565469622612,
0.4673132598400116,
0.13775308430194855,
-0.1835022270679474,
0.56791090965271,
0.026633935049176216,
0.5373594760894775,
-0.2817516624927521,
0.12810681760311127,
-0.5357317328453064,
-0.42341265082359314,
-0.44573986530303955,
0.27224159240722656,
-0.376846045255661,
-0.5198537707328796
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14312v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14312v1
|
ChainLM: Empowering Large Language Models with Improved Chain-of-Thought Prompting
| 2024-03-21T11:34:26 | 2024-03-21T11:34:26 |
Xiaoxue Cheng, Junyi Li, Wayne Xin Zhao, Ji-Rong Wen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting can enhance the reasoning capabilities of
large language models (LLMs), establishing itself as a primary approach to
solving complex reasoning tasks. Existing CoT synthesis approaches usually
focus on simpler reasoning tasks and thus result in low-quality and
inconsistent CoT prompts. In response to this challenge, we present an
empirical investigation of CoT prompting and introduce CoTGenius, a novel
framework designed for the automatic generation of superior CoT prompts.
CoTGenius is developed based on three major evolution strategies, i.e.,
complicate, diversify, and specify-alongside two filtering mechanisms:
evolutionary success judgement and correctness verification. We further employ
CoTGenius to create an extensive CoT dataset, and subsequently fine-tune the
Llama 2-Chat 7B and 13B models on this dataset. We call the resulting model
ChainLM. To deal with the cumulative error issue in reasoning steps, we propose
a step-level debating method, wherein multiple debaters discuss each reasoning
step to arrive at the correct answer. Extensive experiments demonstrate that
our ChainLM models exhibit enhanced proficiency in addressing a spectrum of
complex reasoning problems compared to existing models. In addition, we conduct
an in-depth analysis of the impact of data categories within CoTGenius on the
model performance. We release our dataset and code at
https://github.com/RUCAIBox/ChainLM.
|
[
-0.6542931795120239,
-0.9859361052513123,
0.6666942238807678,
0.3182552456855774,
-0.26582470536231995,
0.5408993363380432,
-0.2836059629917145,
-0.38364389538764954,
-0.052597057074308395,
0.4836934208869934,
-0.604839563369751,
-0.4918212890625,
-0.3550843894481659,
0.29026156663894653,
-0.4759208858013153,
0.8618620038032532,
-0.17622965574264526,
0.019573936238884926,
-0.22653645277023315,
0.00619585020467639,
-0.5057973265647888,
-0.6616203188896179,
-0.6734240055084229,
-0.39473065733909607,
0.7923856377601624,
0.4238021969795227,
0.6426644325256348,
0.16531403362751007,
0.19918695092201233,
0.17232058942317963,
-0.3553582429885864,
0.739389955997467,
-0.6636775135993958,
0.37456971406936646,
-0.38639962673187256,
-0.38576143980026245,
-0.5882372260093689,
-0.37862470746040344,
0.40040451288223267,
0.690813422203064,
-0.13542862236499786,
0.20641447603702545,
0.06938186287879944,
0.7399319410324097,
-0.7073138952255249,
-0.33883312344551086,
-0.7697718143463135,
-0.2684342861175537,
0.14085574448108673,
-0.3294384181499481,
-0.8464093208312988,
-0.38302892446517944,
0.06562796235084534,
-0.3089747726917267,
0.12673011422157288,
0.4801163971424103,
0.4777715504169464,
0.050663091242313385,
-0.3227387070655823,
-0.5325809121131897,
-0.7729124426841736,
0.5083050727844238,
-0.632317066192627,
0.20345866680145264,
0.16000792384147644,
0.1303943693637848,
-0.509988009929657,
-0.6931265592575073,
-0.6960256695747375,
-0.22629867494106293,
0.08256421983242035,
-0.11302319914102554,
-0.11158129572868347,
0.07846295833587646,
0.27213042974472046,
0.1613844484090805,
-0.548292338848114,
-0.04125339165329933,
-0.5080813765525818,
0.09996805340051651,
0.6635609865188599,
0.3976084291934967,
0.1741483062505722,
0.1076447069644928,
-0.3835282027721405,
-0.3102821409702301,
-0.9267324805259705,
-0.036039385944604874,
0.3754989206790924,
0.37357237935066223,
0.01766202226281166,
0.3340231776237488,
-0.10159606486558914,
0.9888286590576172,
0.09775451570749283,
0.24111878871917725,
-0.07977192103862762,
-0.13758961856365204,
-0.2800753116607666,
0.14774508774280548,
0.7678009271621704,
0.17469120025634766,
0.21043673157691956,
0.15751533210277557,
-0.3629433512687683,
0.20056423544883728,
0.19669000804424286,
-0.3599475026130676,
-0.31933698058128357,
0.5632504820823669,
-0.18536661565303802,
-0.5120112895965576,
0.03749269247055054,
-0.8281804323196411,
-0.4491998851299286,
-0.2869943380355835,
0.193815216422081,
-0.1916300356388092,
-0.3535001277923584,
0.3143356740474701,
-0.1163453534245491,
0.15758110582828522,
0.42821234464645386,
-0.662006139755249,
0.3813738524913788,
0.6969400644302368,
0.6354168653488159,
-0.1886579990386963,
-0.31754639744758606,
-0.6723407506942749,
0.0916236937046051,
-0.6713501811027527,
1.0266352891921997,
-0.7038769125938416,
-0.4704906642436981,
-0.0803508535027504,
-0.19408053159713745,
-0.16155408322811127,
-0.4553137719631195,
0.28726500272750854,
-0.4976573586463928,
0.13490614295005798,
-0.5338922142982483,
-0.5100924968719482,
0.06016208603978157,
0.33676543831825256,
-0.6398369669914246,
1.1327482461929321,
-0.0109826335683465,
-0.6439148187637329,
0.19110433757305145,
-0.6985499858856201,
-0.2989465594291687,
0.08435803651809692,
-0.22170589864253998,
-0.0433088093996048,
0.014328359626233578,
0.36087656021118164,
0.1257229447364807,
-0.7251006364822388,
0.6336588859558105,
-0.37012478709220886,
-0.15108153223991394,
0.26164358854293823,
-0.37145769596099854,
0.6967732310295105,
0.34021446108818054,
-0.32466256618499756,
0.374911367893219,
-0.6366948485374451,
0.19154511392116547,
0.06769124418497086,
0.14777109026908875,
-0.2396470606327057,
0.009087467566132545,
-0.20288841426372528,
0.39156413078308105,
0.030677204951643944,
-0.1992046982049942,
0.39341264963150024,
-0.03816937655210495,
0.45108598470687866,
0.8740683794021606,
0.1460268646478653,
0.14501126110553741,
-0.41357070207595825,
0.6712468266487122,
-0.13300271332263947,
0.3736431300640106,
0.04964087903499603,
-0.49629196524620056,
-0.7572598457336426,
-0.0303009282797575,
0.21573401987552643,
0.3394651710987091,
-0.7944827079772949,
0.2799358069896698,
-0.0947905108332634,
-0.4160720705986023,
-0.35286155343055725,
0.2630605399608612,
0.43573611974716187,
0.28268522024154663,
0.30354708433151245,
-0.05884326249361038,
-0.7621418237686157,
-0.38974276185035706,
-0.09651753306388855,
-0.4595958888530731,
0.20312179625034332,
0.13607370853424072,
0.36556586623191833,
-0.21698251366615295,
0.8565056324005127,
-0.4846175014972687,
0.3886091113090515,
-0.6130086183547974,
0.34867212176322937,
0.22927074134349823,
0.3169940114021301,
0.17032884061336517,
-0.5963910222053528,
-0.1307344138622284,
-0.06691227108240128,
-0.8271692991256714,
-0.298455148935318,
-0.17725752294063568,
-0.6409018039703369,
0.14001809060573578,
0.5604398846626282,
-0.49912190437316895,
0.2550540268421173,
0.5836946368217468,
-0.46692630648612976,
0.8394138813018799,
-0.23256447911262512,
0.03955238685011864,
-0.8449128866195679,
0.10985653102397919,
-0.40351808071136475,
-0.18472209572792053,
-0.6299620866775513,
0.18173867464065552,
-0.053310293704271317,
0.06149568408727646,
-0.49517226219177246,
0.4975029528141022,
-0.42470383644104004,
0.08943286538124084,
-0.35506463050842285,
0.3918112516403198,
0.14590556919574738,
0.3344908356666565,
-0.007409899495542049,
0.6951491236686707,
0.4158951938152313,
-0.9268954992294312,
0.38993018865585327,
0.3107377588748932,
-0.05082916095852852,
0.3753652572631836,
-0.6551264524459839,
0.48509225249290466,
-0.025266515091061592,
0.7197687029838562,
-1.022650957107544,
-0.2494765967130661,
0.11954708397388458,
-0.1299605518579483,
-0.07380784302949905,
0.1322317123413086,
-0.5615631937980652,
-0.784203827381134,
-0.2694607079029083,
0.5682201385498047,
0.5363344550132751,
-0.8946229815483093,
0.6137374043464661,
0.017040695995092392,
0.04598025977611542,
-0.40922030806541443,
-0.3431086242198944,
0.1884620189666748,
-0.007475046440958977,
-0.5555641651153564,
-0.01861676387488842,
-0.18057480454444885,
-0.39981609582901,
-0.2763209640979767,
-0.05177851393818855,
0.2674759030342102,
-0.12893839180469513,
0.02490203268826008,
0.7137603163719177,
-0.10528533160686493,
0.388222873210907,
0.06824477016925812,
0.009265758097171783,
0.24042826890945435,
-0.5425691604614258,
1.017196774482727,
-0.3043574392795563,
-0.2356189638376236,
-0.1359177827835083,
0.17221248149871826,
0.6751193404197693,
-0.16916301846504211,
0.6235493421554565,
0.20530608296394348,
-0.0554775670170784,
-0.5121361613273621,
-0.5719773769378662,
-0.06915296614170074,
-0.4862533211708069,
-0.22406861186027527,
-0.5012871026992798,
-0.7031737565994263,
0.5027320981025696,
-0.25608912110328674,
0.08189070969820023,
0.2881217896938324,
0.6208040118217468,
0.030075276270508766,
1.1088318824768066,
0.20900778472423553,
0.03771551325917244,
0.16478857398033142,
-0.39264917373657227,
0.33492669463157654,
-1.1284990310668945,
-0.2765335440635681,
-0.24043366312980652,
-0.11500123143196106,
-0.3949277698993683,
-0.4826671779155731,
0.22821980714797974,
0.23717273771762848,
-0.38504558801651,
0.286700576543808,
-0.5767201781272888,
0.4133661389350891,
0.3126266896724701,
0.3155266046524048,
0.36003124713897705,
-0.20456457138061523,
-0.4104383587837219,
0.7192341685295105,
-0.9517645239830017,
-0.7964142560958862,
0.928956151008606,
0.07137678563594818,
1.1177338361740112,
-0.007360749877989292,
0.7673568725585938,
0.3643724322319031,
0.2503534257411957,
-0.42644909024238586,
0.6722478270530701,
0.12294624000787735,
-0.5113925337791443,
-0.23106645047664642,
-0.4080578684806824,
-0.9166496992111206,
0.2036966234445572,
-0.12308087944984436,
-0.8854460120201111,
0.31313642859458923,
0.5312362909317017,
-0.43064916133880615,
0.5239108204841614,
-0.5007240772247314,
0.4902665317058563,
-0.27516865730285645,
-0.5477427244186401,
-0.2173665463924408,
-0.6954362392425537,
0.5069087743759155,
0.00212289160117507,
0.3762360215187073,
-0.04124670475721359,
0.09842974692583084,
0.4951457977294922,
-0.6871196031570435,
0.7942733764648438,
0.059006255120038986,
-0.49824702739715576,
0.6723630428314209,
0.2782687246799469,
0.8177302479743958,
-0.14213016629219055,
-0.0914423018693924,
-0.28619876503944397,
-0.00890143308788538,
-0.38257667422294617,
-0.7157524824142456,
0.6587715744972229,
-0.42564821243286133,
-0.9150643944740295,
-0.1723523736000061,
-0.513680636882782,
-0.30208176374435425,
-0.16761399805545807,
0.2946312725543976,
0.6219092011451721,
-0.03890394791960716,
-0.15373410284519196,
0.5911988019943237,
-0.18700429797172546,
0.28648972511291504,
-0.019024981185793877,
-0.6682844758033752,
-0.4917236268520355,
0.7973154783248901,
-0.31227990984916687,
0.7583066821098328,
0.10035064816474915,
0.30120566487312317,
-0.3613089323043823,
-0.10475169867277145,
-0.48673945665359497,
0.11128570139408112,
-0.9886232614517212,
-0.21471787989139557,
-0.7057637572288513,
-0.23692411184310913,
-0.19518043100833893,
-0.3502133786678314,
-0.19528932869434357,
-0.36860308051109314,
-0.027947748079895973,
-0.16359737515449524,
0.5311856865882874,
1.0319113731384277,
0.18002694845199585,
-0.007358222734183073,
-0.5074641704559326,
0.2309572845697403,
0.3112386167049408,
0.17011669278144836,
0.4645950198173523,
-0.17074547708034515,
0.2527852952480316,
0.0900428518652916,
-0.29948848485946655,
-0.5992236733436584,
0.16095688939094543,
-0.0864102691411972,
0.3781985342502594,
0.17215001583099365,
0.4405306875705719,
0.8724895715713501,
-0.3411003351211548,
0.952404260635376,
0.254321813583374,
-1.1902949810028076,
0.7354164123535156,
-0.23715169727802277,
0.43237778544425964,
0.43957188725471497,
0.10585987567901611,
-0.44447436928749084,
-0.8276779651641846,
-0.7065412402153015,
-0.9019762277603149,
0.3749024569988251,
0.30288586020469666,
-0.0850033387541771,
-0.3497103750705719,
0.09252921491861343,
0.21897059679031372,
0.02922966144979,
-0.440252423286438,
0.005430395714938641,
0.12823614478111267,
-0.2793641686439514,
0.17603105306625366,
-0.10159924626350403,
-0.12397546321153641,
-0.40189868211746216,
0.6869589686393738,
-0.16598135232925415,
0.14481280744075775,
0.5431491732597351,
-0.22137369215488434,
-0.29988446831703186,
0.32475242018699646,
0.8138243556022644,
1.0733461380004883,
0.010924933478236198,
0.40798819065093994,
0.5760867595672607,
-0.24089013040065765,
0.3869786262512207,
-0.49555903673171997,
0.11246628314256668,
-0.009452308528125286,
0.546480655670166,
0.9308817982673645,
0.09007833153009415,
-0.8296434879302979,
0.14613814651966095,
-0.119092658162117,
-0.23678436875343323,
-0.11106347292661667,
0.34224408864974976,
-0.03451354801654816,
0.16878613829612732,
0.39812135696411133,
-0.034522220492362976,
-0.044394601136446,
-0.5901073813438416,
0.05933912843465805,
0.1586494892835617,
-0.1969631463289261,
-0.07385935634374619,
0.6816257238388062,
0.25569307804107666,
-0.4572960138320923,
0.4389185309410095,
-0.1251203864812851,
-0.7503904104232788,
0.5099635124206543,
0.6710895895957947,
0.7505752444267273,
-0.14600083231925964,
0.3629794716835022,
0.3213832974433899,
0.09677261114120483,
-0.347276896238327,
0.49009400606155396,
-0.15611141920089722,
-0.5155999660491943,
-0.29046186804771423,
-0.40783631801605225,
-0.6060782074928284,
-0.04310277849435806,
-0.7161186933517456,
0.3935316205024719,
-0.5856773853302002,
-0.15446370840072632,
-0.18797531723976135,
-0.4027911126613617,
-0.597612202167511,
0.10960154235363007,
0.251443088054657,
1.1312915086746216,
-0.552584171295166,
0.7254515290260315,
0.39679834246635437,
-0.18154892325401306,
-0.9210107922554016,
0.07001408189535141,
-0.16141586005687714,
-0.6674841642379761,
0.5870146751403809,
0.04828022047877312,
-0.6266306638717651,
0.10455073416233063,
-0.8690856099128723,
-0.598745584487915,
1.013246774673462,
0.18065810203552246,
-0.9871407747268677,
-0.00003167449540342204,
-0.025729769840836525,
0.5221377611160278,
-0.7829590439796448,
0.21759770810604095,
0.5943461656570435,
0.28001296520233154,
0.4674936830997467,
-0.705987811088562,
0.34803226590156555,
-0.20427945256233215,
0.19943009316921234,
0.27485746145248413,
-0.5386742949485779,
0.8140785098075867,
-0.4563191831111908,
-0.04865831881761551,
0.17222458124160767,
0.3662026524543762,
0.7834585905075073,
0.32627415657043457,
0.69216388463974,
0.09156370162963867,
1.1985172033309937,
0.06989452242851257,
1.14680814743042,
-0.41384467482566833,
0.3258519768714905,
1.3292381763458252,
-0.6422938108444214,
1.0541080236434937,
0.5000566244125366,
0.01061174739152193,
1.0581493377685547,
0.6912299990653992,
0.17650063335895538,
0.3064540922641754,
0.36476457118988037,
-0.42378243803977966,
-0.3992540240287781,
0.08640196174383163,
-0.34561678767204285,
0.0036798117216676474,
0.426655113697052,
-0.4223843812942505,
0.03826054930686951,
0.1663050800561905,
-0.15310677886009216,
-0.05584996938705444,
-0.27251508831977844,
0.804329514503479,
0.1833803504705429,
-1.0071481466293335,
1.0780434608459473,
-0.5774853229522705,
0.24998456239700317,
-0.38821372389793396,
0.007612195331603289,
-0.15357567369937897,
0.08495684713125229,
-0.07555337995290756,
-0.7808964252471924,
-0.0970248132944107,
0.24540504813194275,
0.06343656033277512,
-0.009615819901227951,
0.5592823624610901,
-0.49261999130249023,
-0.5493945479393005,
0.5345141887664795,
0.5141081213951111,
0.10501323640346527,
0.26608145236968994,
-0.48116064071655273,
0.47947758436203003,
-0.20672890543937683,
-0.07662330567836761,
-0.21680812537670135,
0.40143686532974243,
-0.3511068820953369,
0.9340357780456543,
0.745087742805481,
-0.04506814852356911,
-0.09623339027166367,
0.47369951009750366,
1.1524016857147217,
-0.7748863697052002,
-0.4658307731151581,
-1.080613136291504,
0.4800378382205963,
-0.357116162776947,
-0.29773983359336853,
0.3838561475276947,
0.3459610342979431,
0.5655737519264221,
-0.044074706733226776,
0.8214548826217651,
-0.07520420849323273,
0.013319112360477448,
-0.684583306312561,
0.36196234822273254,
-0.1694619506597519,
0.5572617053985596,
-0.3884961009025574,
-0.8661755323410034,
-0.1700596660375595,
0.34181439876556396,
-0.4781043529510498,
-0.13667184114456177,
1.1066182851791382,
0.7943588495254517,
0.15915502607822418,
0.4291253685951233,
0.2924829423427582,
0.2560598850250244,
0.45470312237739563,
0.7069411277770996,
1.256373643875122,
-0.24863573908805847,
0.4250459671020508,
0.27299755811691284,
-0.2229059487581253,
-0.18560296297073364,
-0.7209593653678894,
-1.1770094633102417,
-0.44580256938934326,
-0.28091755509376526,
-0.514710545539856,
0.4277157783508301,
1.4365520477294922,
0.5622197985649109,
-0.8179500699043274,
-0.4319125711917877,
-0.710162878036499,
0.2705557346343994,
-0.2787995934486389,
-0.1746811717748642,
0.21092018485069275,
-0.7502310872077942,
-0.20545317232608795,
0.2498314529657364,
0.2146030068397522,
-0.03316987305879593,
-0.3521187901496887,
-0.3542412519454956,
-0.4100458323955536,
0.45420873165130615,
0.759102463722229,
0.06284579634666443,
-0.95291668176651,
-0.24807113409042358,
-0.08859732002019882,
0.04566088318824768,
0.08052080124616623,
1.0565913915634155,
-0.7541394829750061,
0.5569225549697876,
0.4149612784385681,
0.23163571953773499,
0.500637948513031,
0.038935840129852295,
1.0199581384658813,
-0.41384974122047424,
0.025928141549229622,
0.12192712724208832,
0.3313799798488617,
0.31057900190353394,
-0.4716247022151947,
0.5752580761909485,
0.0012278205249458551,
-0.40630054473876953,
-1.0289416313171387,
0.2592431604862213,
-0.8069179654121399,
-0.4045199155807495,
1.3108114004135132,
-0.0015627344837412238,
-0.550402820110321,
-0.07872605323791504,
-0.6299001574516296,
0.05718308687210083,
-0.3173110783100128,
0.7620847821235657,
0.8447171449661255,
-0.25682204961776733,
-0.26661908626556396,
-0.18307553231716156,
0.43944576382637024,
0.264085978269577,
-0.9369109869003296,
0.444995254278183,
0.22240260243415833,
0.010415768250823021,
-0.02143361046910286,
0.4405395984649658,
0.034072618931531906,
0.4084709882736206,
0.1028701439499855,
-0.15113861858844757,
0.18185101449489594,
-0.45136013627052307,
-0.11638853698968887,
0.03747028857469559,
0.25865912437438965,
0.18125633895397186
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14275v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14275v1
|
Is Reference Necessary in the Evaluation of NLG Systems? When and Where?
| 2024-03-21T10:31:11 | 2024-03-21T10:31:11 |
Shuqian Sheng, Yi Xu, Luoyi Fu, Jiaxin Ding, Lei Zhou, Xinbing Wang, Chenghu Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The majority of automatic metrics for evaluating NLG systems are
reference-based. However, the challenge of collecting human annotation results
in a lack of reliable references in numerous application scenarios. Despite
recent advancements in reference-free metrics, it has not been well understood
when and where they can be used as an alternative to reference-based metrics.
In this study, by employing diverse analytical approaches, we comprehensively
assess the performance of both metrics across a wide range of NLG tasks,
encompassing eight datasets and eight evaluation models. Based on solid
experiments, the results show that reference-free metrics exhibit a higher
correlation with human judgment and greater sensitivity to deficiencies in
language quality. However, their effectiveness varies across tasks and is
influenced by the quality of candidate texts. Therefore, it's important to
assess the performance of reference-free metrics before applying them to a new
task, especially when inputs are in uncommon form or when the answer space is
highly variable. Our study can provide insight into the appropriate application
of automatic metrics and the impact of metric choice on evaluation performance.
|
[
-0.4948591887950897,
-0.29803037643432617,
0.272323340177536,
0.20686976611614227,
-0.27520954608917236,
-0.37098458409309387,
-0.24782732129096985,
-0.8573743104934692,
-0.01210386585444212,
0.18170948326587677,
-0.2623441815376282,
-0.351672500371933,
-0.5147327184677124,
0.5435467958450317,
-0.35698574781417847,
1.2017654180526733,
0.08836996555328369,
-0.007753451820462942,
-0.5866544842720032,
-0.4432162642478943,
-0.5933698415756226,
-0.6126774549484253,
-0.6907026171684265,
-0.6933958530426025,
0.5395765900611877,
0.04753493890166283,
0.8790847063064575,
0.7121204733848572,
0.9903011918067932,
0.22302135825157166,
-0.09126775711774826,
0.14567400515079498,
-0.003952172584831715,
-0.036080073565244675,
-0.41501283645629883,
-0.5414713621139526,
-0.5725509524345398,
0.5175442099571228,
0.49777573347091675,
0.8189823627471924,
-0.03525577485561371,
0.756267249584198,
0.10621141642332077,
0.6712808012962341,
-0.7281450033187866,
0.13760457932949066,
-0.5075984597206116,
0.2502729594707489,
-0.24636885523796082,
-0.05652254447340965,
-0.12222407013177872,
-0.6081996560096741,
0.40349921584129333,
-0.8875057697296143,
0.4475160837173462,
0.15096640586853027,
0.8834096193313599,
0.6456440687179565,
-0.13457272946834564,
-0.5865088701248169,
-0.6942083835601807,
0.8110364079475403,
-0.6430685520172119,
0.3604789972305298,
0.6139570474624634,
0.23994000256061554,
0.04027555137872696,
-0.42956292629241943,
-0.2229781448841095,
-0.4656567871570587,
-0.4557993710041046,
0.2891702950000763,
-0.2681063115596771,
0.075379379093647,
0.24724894762039185,
0.3144940435886383,
-0.4007958471775055,
0.02326168306171894,
-0.4193804860115051,
-0.19821567833423615,
0.6033057570457458,
0.1061989963054657,
0.030743254348635674,
-0.5254233479499817,
-0.4027319848537445,
-0.10208321362733841,
-0.5148327946662903,
-0.29355618357658386,
0.34402528405189514,
0.39788541197776794,
0.057952817529439926,
0.3280876874923706,
0.016353635117411613,
0.7976610064506531,
0.04936031624674797,
-0.06244605407118797,
0.29920175671577454,
-0.7048876285552979,
-0.17799006402492523,
-0.2850610315799713,
1.0972435474395752,
0.4273589253425598,
0.3788684606552124,
-0.6819669008255005,
-0.2139909714460373,
0.15060439705848694,
0.5456741452217102,
-0.17129039764404297,
-0.20195405185222626,
-0.15776735544204712,
-0.3821603059768677,
-0.13992802798748016,
0.007631908170878887,
-0.5756591558456421,
-0.24645188450813293,
-0.35519954562187195,
0.2913171350955963,
-0.09682384133338928,
-0.16992610692977905,
-0.1959889680147171,
-0.2969241440296173,
-0.030658865347504616,
0.31782543659210205,
-0.6344680190086365,
0.29902535676956177,
0.35450708866119385,
0.6986402273178101,
-0.47282955050468445,
-0.07017600536346436,
-0.48864778876304626,
-0.1438319832086563,
-0.6152340173721313,
0.8938474059104919,
-0.3072163462638855,
-0.40882518887519836,
-0.050836674869060516,
-0.17826451361179352,
-0.023952852934598923,
-0.9845770597457886,
1.096230149269104,
-0.4744406044483185,
0.3355565369129181,
-0.3211118280887604,
-0.5532856583595276,
-0.24765995144844055,
0.08735895901918411,
-0.8766152262687683,
1.3007396459579468,
0.13803993165493011,
-0.5976384282112122,
0.6559979319572449,
-0.8015875220298767,
-0.08854739367961884,
0.24951380491256714,
0.1723383218050003,
-0.11901857703924179,
0.2966303825378418,
-0.0006129369139671326,
0.3440152108669281,
-0.6359009146690369,
0.23063935339450836,
-0.13189277052879333,
-0.5423810482025146,
0.12255869060754776,
-0.30463847517967224,
0.6547659635543823,
0.21847623586654663,
-0.17618656158447266,
-0.21401576697826385,
-1.0107753276824951,
0.32284027338027954,
-0.19051593542099,
-0.3911103308200836,
-0.584781289100647,
0.241156667470932,
-0.1984628289937973,
0.11099832504987717,
-0.04286103695631027,
-0.3131810426712036,
-0.2273426651954651,
-0.26233357191085815,
-0.1538928598165512,
0.3071046769618988,
-0.16153334081172943,
0.29237136244773865,
-0.18260200321674347,
0.4843903183937073,
-0.4003770649433136,
0.014750153757631779,
0.3646697402000427,
-0.4210735857486725,
-0.9321760535240173,
0.22046047449111938,
0.6175538301467896,
0.6761256456375122,
-0.5820055603981018,
0.6870731711387634,
-0.1269952356815338,
-0.6197260618209839,
-0.61473149061203,
0.24966277182102203,
0.562154233455658,
0.35029977560043335,
0.4840257465839386,
-0.5750761032104492,
-0.544690728187561,
-0.8900051712989807,
-0.3777502775192261,
-0.6025846600532532,
-0.36127930879592896,
0.3801204562187195,
0.37626805901527405,
0.0686752125620842,
1.0455516576766968,
-0.11756204068660736,
-0.3093706965446472,
0.15724168717861176,
0.2721937298774719,
0.14077003300189972,
0.12536220252513885,
0.763691246509552,
-0.24608460068702698,
-0.13967780768871307,
-0.11686687171459198,
-1.0678173303604126,
-0.7246733903884888,
-0.22273008525371552,
-0.0073127178475260735,
-0.01680746115744114,
0.46086063981056213,
-0.12416213005781174,
0.30625438690185547,
0.7864956259727478,
-0.31661084294319153,
0.8870397210121155,
-0.11089380085468292,
-0.0005308836698532104,
-0.24886399507522583,
0.6598557233810425,
0.3005513548851013,
-0.20735080540180206,
-0.6118376851081848,
0.27139174938201904,
0.05623767152428627,
0.3622680902481079,
-0.1754271239042282,
0.7174085974693298,
-0.24905648827552795,
-0.024998482316732407,
-0.2660892605781555,
0.6597962975502014,
0.06010086461901665,
0.2032925933599472,
-0.2226080745458603,
0.9846464395523071,
-0.08869891613721848,
-0.8161360025405884,
0.3670111298561096,
0.0916438177227974,
-0.5202385187149048,
0.634610116481781,
-0.7287587523460388,
0.34819233417510986,
0.035253558307886124,
0.036131273955106735,
-0.8009576201438904,
0.3374471664428711,
0.47854170203208923,
-0.541935920715332,
-0.0793142169713974,
0.14720143377780914,
-0.5742008090019226,
-0.30931738018989563,
0.03602563589811325,
0.05845174938440323,
0.1537294238805771,
-0.14263089001178741,
0.04457578808069229,
0.18028739094734192,
0.2026449739933014,
-0.5748459100723267,
-0.5780020952224731,
0.03474855050444603,
-0.3042302429676056,
0.0028777301777154207,
0.06226935237646103,
-0.005376626271754503,
-0.42921337485313416,
0.11133971065282822,
-0.25056514143943787,
-0.0656919851899147,
0.3512808382511139,
0.11752218753099442,
0.1777896136045456,
-0.11505944281816483,
0.4236922264099121,
-0.45945480465888977,
-0.4911231994628906,
0.1515473574399948,
-0.2083841860294342,
-0.060244087129831314,
-0.22966386377811432,
-0.4041784405708313,
-0.33232802152633667,
0.16808775067329407,
0.2674497663974762,
-0.1737259030342102,
0.5055310130119324,
0.7357664108276367,
-0.28098031878471375,
0.14963509142398834,
-0.7681018114089966,
0.17335695028305054,
-0.3667103052139282,
0.32552143931388855,
0.047889310866594315,
-0.5491699576377869,
0.45413535833358765,
0.16820327937602997,
0.1716013103723526,
0.7162379622459412,
0.3323991894721985,
-0.2303677350282669,
0.40535715222358704,
0.4356944262981415,
-0.008662879467010498,
0.3276422917842865,
0.2068285197019577,
0.1874566376209259,
-0.9807193875312805,
-0.126887246966362,
-0.796327531337738,
-0.15602637827396393,
-0.554669201374054,
-0.48645272850990295,
0.2721671760082245,
0.4921422004699707,
0.03757148236036301,
0.3525954484939575,
-0.4835207164287567,
0.40940722823143005,
0.3512271046638489,
-0.2687624394893646,
0.44024601578712463,
-0.29147595167160034,
-0.376663476228714,
-0.13420899212360382,
-0.5984259247779846,
-0.7606894969940186,
1.0194839239120483,
0.1831030696630478,
0.4662066102027893,
-0.17714770138263702,
0.31897133588790894,
0.33367928862571716,
0.7680860161781311,
-0.8874188661575317,
0.43885478377342224,
-0.31836509704589844,
-0.9029034376144409,
-0.35095104575157166,
-0.3971073031425476,
-0.962931215763092,
0.5378258228302002,
-0.3065519630908966,
-0.6405268311500549,
-0.040466293692588806,
0.19881097972393036,
-0.6089527010917664,
0.0925823524594307,
-0.9288215041160583,
0.40454789996147156,
-0.15639182925224304,
-0.059935010969638824,
-0.07930554449558258,
-0.4184345304965973,
-0.06696126610040665,
-0.1314081996679306,
0.14165404438972473,
-0.35036036372184753,
-0.12325522303581238,
1.1660984754562378,
0.03431696444749832,
0.5896136164665222,
-0.10455348342657089,
-0.0015321741811931133,
0.5515164732933044,
0.012993228621780872,
0.057595424354076385,
-0.1871262937784195,
-0.4937209486961365,
0.49847880005836487,
0.22619174420833588,
0.02278757467865944,
-0.7549044489860535,
0.3362078070640564,
-0.7869939208030701,
-0.6009492874145508,
-0.5336328744888306,
-0.3182232081890106,
-0.4716338515281677,
0.14854027330875397,
-0.12200204282999039,
0.06971714645624161,
-0.20506413280963898,
0.3840150535106659,
0.12758050858974457,
-0.1864052414894104,
0.5013336539268494,
0.28312650322914124,
0.05071372538805008,
-0.5333071351051331,
0.43779703974723816,
0.12121745198965073,
0.3817104995250702,
0.03603658825159073,
0.19203965365886688,
-0.2808820307254791,
-0.5037973523139954,
-0.47456538677215576,
0.4435223340988159,
-0.6581609845161438,
-0.34224480390548706,
-0.29037031531333923,
0.07140207290649414,
0.09738731384277344,
0.058600980788469315,
-0.21933406591415405,
-0.41061609983444214,
-0.2700442373752594,
-0.08505410701036453,
0.16004882752895355,
0.6220899224281311,
-0.14588721096515656,
0.3496658504009247,
-0.8179343342781067,
0.21688725054264069,
0.2138107717037201,
0.7583682537078857,
0.1203342154622078,
-0.17896263301372528,
-0.498512864112854,
-0.1334606111049652,
-0.17856264114379883,
-0.7531169652938843,
0.06545547395944595,
0.2911361753940582,
0.8771890997886658,
0.21248525381088257,
-0.13417311012744904,
0.7323081493377686,
-0.49051111936569214,
0.9380515813827515,
0.17512430250644684,
-0.8637768030166626,
0.2538437247276306,
-0.27109935879707336,
0.46214237809181213,
0.8261229395866394,
0.3434433043003082,
-0.9158313870429993,
-0.3455532193183899,
-0.4377900958061218,
-0.8567015528678894,
0.7938291430473328,
0.34138962626457214,
-0.16103000938892365,
-0.10612554848194122,
0.7393373847007751,
0.04444025084376335,
0.33605334162712097,
-0.6907082796096802,
-0.5228384137153625,
-0.021675895899534225,
0.22473907470703125,
-0.12533561885356903,
-0.05837327986955643,
-0.2957207262516022,
-0.11604715883731842,
0.3641015291213989,
-0.03224455937743187,
0.5325615406036377,
0.16542868316173553,
-0.09317818284034729,
-0.09232477843761444,
0.10759531706571579,
0.16912858188152313,
0.7180613279342651,
-0.2928469479084015,
-0.21073022484779358,
0.5324426889419556,
-0.43217387795448303,
0.1186043843626976,
-0.24436600506305695,
-0.08201369643211365,
0.3792726695537567,
0.46588045358657837,
0.6810376644134521,
0.0936504676938057,
-0.37272462248802185,
0.23421375453472137,
0.12428166717290878,
-0.20906519889831543,
-0.3040965497493744,
0.07810951769351959,
-0.09576272964477539,
-0.1521376222372055,
0.37826448678970337,
0.2573870122432709,
0.056414466351270676,
-0.07724470645189285,
0.15693449974060059,
0.2912347912788391,
-0.7792214751243591,
-0.30600908398628235,
0.3960476815700531,
0.3251396417617798,
-0.3738214075565338,
0.4413663148880005,
-0.18962958455085754,
-0.09566909819841385,
0.497773677110672,
0.4137590825557709,
0.9323907494544983,
-0.19760797917842865,
0.039029303938150406,
0.6059170961380005,
0.46154555678367615,
0.10934630036354065,
-0.27860498428344727,
0.009727324359118938,
-0.7327476143836975,
-0.5595178604125977,
-0.594219446182251,
-0.38622063398361206,
0.25557228922843933,
-0.7329087853431702,
0.18130381405353546,
-0.471808522939682,
-0.6260603666305542,
-0.04531494528055191,
0.059843581169843674,
-1.0367504358291626,
0.6031910181045532,
0.24878107011318207,
0.7983592748641968,
-0.7545013427734375,
0.2921209931373596,
0.8564997911453247,
-0.1425313651561737,
-0.5497223734855652,
-0.07399247586727142,
0.2170722335577011,
-0.44915252923965454,
0.7229191064834595,
-0.20083492994308472,
-0.4257773756980896,
-0.40839797258377075,
0.05295576527714729,
-1.0917950868606567,
0.7700269222259521,
0.17307105660438538,
-0.04504634439945221,
-0.34923088550567627,
-0.05772227421402931,
0.9437180757522583,
-0.05359729379415512,
0.8194721341133118,
0.6608877182006836,
0.4875110387802124,
-0.21954445540905,
-1.5382009744644165,
-0.13133135437965393,
-0.2762412130832672,
0.11314713209867477,
0.31160181760787964,
-0.6961597204208374,
0.17333485186100006,
0.136126309633255,
-0.39262527227401733,
-0.08790021389722824,
0.47341039776802063,
0.009576249867677689,
0.019010862335562706,
0.6839143633842468,
0.46038737893104553,
0.7530561685562134,
-0.29458439350128174,
0.8964693546295166,
-0.24283000826835632,
0.37969717383384705,
0.8701074123382568,
-0.009775114245712757,
0.8564369082450867,
0.3765070140361786,
-0.4742259979248047,
0.39871451258659363,
0.34385937452316284,
-0.053197674453258514,
0.29427605867385864,
0.2925959527492523,
0.005769713781774044,
-0.11632873117923737,
-0.16197624802589417,
-0.1961812674999237,
0.6561233997344971,
0.5546697378158569,
-0.2445518672466278,
-0.542388379573822,
-0.34063059091567993,
-0.04057087376713753,
-0.07035623490810394,
-0.021622924134135246,
0.7538515329360962,
0.0420922115445137,
-0.8441493511199951,
0.6638782024383545,
-0.04051359370350838,
0.698781430721283,
-0.7226965427398682,
0.12582112848758698,
-0.05540056899189949,
0.05593418329954147,
-0.3579753041267395,
-0.49188753962516785,
0.6993221640586853,
0.20391340553760529,
0.01281712856143713,
-0.3164317011833191,
0.4597018361091614,
0.06936143338680267,
-0.16634346544742584,
0.37658679485321045,
0.7845035791397095,
0.1954222023487091,
0.32693660259246826,
-0.623486340045929,
-0.46856197714805603,
-0.17792567610740662,
-0.18480104207992554,
0.12560531497001648,
0.2641635537147522,
-0.19272033870220184,
0.66799396276474,
0.5655500292778015,
0.4090045988559723,
-0.1232605054974556,
0.047787223011255264,
0.2915104329586029,
-0.5641602873802185,
-0.18777085840702057,
-0.6062429547309875,
0.3479349911212921,
-0.01852736808359623,
-0.5895213484764099,
0.8301374316215515,
0.2600054144859314,
0.948688268661499,
0.14364929497241974,
0.8575288653373718,
-0.043508272618055344,
0.7788463830947876,
-0.2170863002538681,
0.620436429977417,
-0.5069162845611572,
0.03922798112034798,
-0.6157439351081848,
-1.1012122631072998,
-0.731340765953064,
0.9401084184646606,
-0.4726864695549011,
0.11146735399961472,
0.960620105266571,
0.41249358654022217,
0.3397851884365082,
0.09779796004295349,
0.21219123899936676,
-0.4684893786907196,
0.3820086121559143,
0.2555614709854126,
0.7479323744773865,
-0.6002496480941772,
0.645618736743927,
0.08207405358552933,
-0.1564342975616455,
-0.2109328657388687,
-1.210989236831665,
-0.4934057891368866,
-0.5172185897827148,
-0.350747287273407,
-0.1712043136358261,
0.06280746310949326,
0.9561296701431274,
0.4799334406852722,
-0.8537542223930359,
-0.5112419128417969,
0.419749915599823,
-0.18473877012729645,
-0.3298063278198242,
-0.17463502287864685,
0.28831347823143005,
-0.44443970918655396,
-0.6353259682655334,
0.14820429682731628,
0.2192898392677307,
0.02931871823966503,
-0.1418008804321289,
0.34007108211517334,
-0.15741628408432007,
-0.05961672589182854,
0.5198776125907898,
0.23874618113040924,
-0.9326847195625305,
-0.6931542754173279,
0.05051686614751816,
-0.1804962456226349,
0.0986943244934082,
0.7685750126838684,
-1.017160177230835,
0.6028592586517334,
0.4454089105129242,
0.4989148676395416,
-0.03078552708029747,
0.239765465259552,
0.6934207677841187,
-0.8424599766731262,
0.0695895329117775,
0.32928794622421265,
0.14229106903076172,
0.3604896664619446,
-0.11628872901201248,
0.8132476806640625,
0.2563885748386383,
-0.7116730213165283,
-0.5457425713539124,
-0.07384457439184189,
-0.5185233950614929,
0.2344420999288559,
1.2393147945404053,
-0.24321897327899933,
0.24876092374324799,
-0.3787285387516022,
0.05258103832602501,
0.13621848821640015,
-0.16011105477809906,
0.8125975728034973,
1.3329541683197021,
-0.42121389508247375,
0.10916945338249207,
-0.8488710522651672,
0.6834341883659363,
0.526994526386261,
-0.6971253156661987,
0.020749125629663467,
0.4730176627635956,
0.08224066346883774,
0.7680651545524597,
0.6297547221183777,
-0.22196058928966522,
0.22736765444278717,
-0.02250170335173607,
0.028469707816839218,
0.11352843791246414,
-0.1297028809785843,
-0.23768672347068787,
0.16293790936470032,
0.2804076075553894,
-0.11770467460155487
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14270v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14270v1
|
Scene-Graph ViT: End-to-End Open-Vocabulary Visual Relationship Detection
| 2024-03-21T10:15:57 | 2024-03-21T10:15:57 |
Tim Salzmann, Markus Ryll, Alex Bewley, Matthias Minderer
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.RO
|
Visual relationship detection aims to identify objects and their
relationships in images. Prior methods approach this task by adding separate
relationship modules or decoders to existing object detection architectures.
This separation increases complexity and hinders end-to-end training, which
limits performance. We propose a simple and highly efficient decoder-free
architecture for open-vocabulary visual relationship detection. Our model
consists of a Transformer-based image encoder that represents objects as tokens
and models their relationships implicitly. To extract relationship information,
we introduce an attention mechanism that selects object pairs likely to form a
relationship. We provide a single-stage recipe to train this model on a mixture
of object and relationship detection data. Our approach achieves
state-of-the-art relationship detection performance on Visual Genome and on the
large-vocabulary GQA benchmark at real-time inference speeds. We provide
analyses of zero-shot performance, ablations, and real-world qualitative
examples.
|
[
-0.4427136182785034,
-0.8005616664886475,
0.22271619737148285,
-0.11819657683372498,
-0.5957916975021362,
-0.37383773922920227,
0.27527502179145813,
-0.5656254291534424,
-0.10652841627597809,
0.4613295793533325,
-0.6311733722686768,
-0.5261694192886353,
-0.29702940583229065,
-0.000748400401789695,
-0.3993007242679596,
0.3957795798778534,
0.08197803050279617,
-0.07195863872766495,
-0.5407171249389648,
-0.3223901689052582,
-0.20275932550430298,
-0.30110910534858704,
-0.7565391063690186,
-0.03344079107046127,
0.5917669534683228,
0.19466127455234528,
0.7029073238372803,
1.0096793174743652,
0.5593348145484924,
0.3025779724121094,
-0.3003164529800415,
0.2834506928920746,
-0.9391117095947266,
0.17753762006759644,
-0.08916369825601578,
-0.09831634163856506,
-0.3393697440624237,
-0.3819665014743805,
0.2500420808792114,
0.36876437067985535,
0.4097055196762085,
0.36864185333251953,
-0.15744787454605103,
0.764777421951294,
-0.852008581161499,
0.5661162734031677,
-0.6042418479919434,
0.3514236807823181,
-0.3334851562976837,
-0.14285150170326233,
-0.48361149430274963,
0.09092268347740173,
-0.1481291800737381,
-0.6380499601364136,
0.13261693716049194,
0.19359908998012543,
1.2252018451690674,
0.25360745191574097,
-0.376636803150177,
0.06106019392609596,
-0.4672214686870575,
0.10990262031555176,
0.12989811599254608,
0.6520423293113708,
-0.008765330538153648,
0.44525131583213806,
-0.16653545200824738,
-0.935128390789032,
-0.3576131761074066,
0.06533418595790863,
-0.1714615821838379,
0.2996918857097626,
-0.5897613167762756,
0.07107134163379669,
0.1755898892879486,
0.6726824045181274,
-0.6017274856567383,
-0.33110207319259644,
-0.2610153555870056,
0.1094510555267334,
-0.029863640666007996,
0.09927576780319214,
0.5259547233581543,
-0.24218958616256714,
-0.5292696952819824,
0.07321789860725403,
-0.5262640714645386,
0.2500024139881134,
0.22401736676692963,
0.13507196307182312,
-0.10131354629993439,
0.7766401171684265,
-0.09423214942216873,
0.7255228161811829,
-0.13850772380828857,
0.3017812669277191,
0.19886188209056854,
-0.4902840256690979,
-0.2956192195415497,
-0.18823906779289246,
0.9273971319198608,
0.4848414659500122,
0.7459261417388916,
-0.28061142563819885,
0.0770607590675354,
0.45460835099220276,
0.11918661743402481,
-1.1322563886642456,
-0.2756025791168213,
-0.07548335939645767,
-0.507436990737915,
-0.32993748784065247,
-0.029247701168060303,
-0.44641342759132385,
0.11796116083860397,
-0.04724520072340965,
0.5208452939987183,
-0.683724045753479,
-0.2009897530078888,
0.11405667662620544,
-0.4187227785587311,
0.6011969447135925,
0.15302005410194397,
-0.5779860615730286,
0.30951541662216187,
0.49939388036727905,
1.1929490566253662,
0.11598765850067139,
-0.06271900981664658,
-0.8060482144355774,
0.3892418444156647,
-0.5452459454536438,
0.8870002031326294,
-0.47102224826812744,
-0.4581139385700226,
-0.044276513159275055,
0.22091186046600342,
0.07511316984891891,
-0.3218354880809784,
0.14919757843017578,
-0.4211931526660919,
-0.08535703271627426,
-0.23881182074546814,
-0.43314674496650696,
0.10074950009584427,
0.36679142713546753,
-0.8211742639541626,
1.050552248954773,
0.38669708371162415,
-1.0259989500045776,
0.291355699300766,
-0.6774930357933044,
-0.25048744678497314,
0.16962899267673492,
-0.26247933506965637,
-0.44523754715919495,
-0.2886415421962738,
0.5471903085708618,
0.3116050660610199,
-0.021898679435253143,
-0.11575626581907272,
-0.4611365795135498,
-0.4395720958709717,
0.05371527746319771,
-0.07812382280826569,
0.5184870362281799,
0.12644098699092865,
0.39278197288513184,
0.46647679805755615,
-0.6738030314445496,
-0.32404255867004395,
0.3388526439666748,
0.04612676054239273,
-0.48596176505088806,
-0.14866244792938232,
-0.06727024167776108,
0.37004342675209045,
0.1940402388572693,
-0.753153383731842,
0.07990532368421555,
-0.3266080915927887,
0.3825325071811676,
0.5039037466049194,
0.12345197051763535,
0.4108608365058899,
0.15969142317771912,
0.43088382482528687,
0.5428059101104736,
0.29164591431617737,
-0.6820347905158997,
-0.6781015992164612,
-0.7190552949905396,
-0.25503405928611755,
-0.09237992018461227,
0.37294042110443115,
-1.0436229705810547,
0.6181211471557617,
-0.3289813697338104,
-0.04212365299463272,
-0.2581208646297455,
-0.10114746540784836,
0.7688174247741699,
0.781886875629425,
0.46373602747917175,
-0.6736469268798828,
-0.29582956433296204,
-0.8034176826477051,
-0.15798652172088623,
0.06129806861281395,
0.012392152100801468,
0.22986292839050293,
0.5661237239837646,
0.0439877025783062,
1.1251360177993774,
-0.8333466649055481,
-0.6073673367500305,
-0.13162270188331604,
-0.4189220666885376,
0.045484334230422974,
0.24170377850532532,
0.7335829138755798,
-0.673656165599823,
-0.3783420920372009,
0.3178737759590149,
-1.1778062582015991,
0.43451544642448425,
0.5672757625579834,
-0.5068404078483582,
-0.2696678042411804,
0.8299310803413391,
-0.5016334056854248,
0.8510897755622864,
0.025933848693966866,
-0.5463422536849976,
0.15713724493980408,
-0.15434971451759338,
-0.17496269941329956,
-0.8820986747741699,
0.007882525213062763,
0.32229161262512207,
-0.31923508644104004,
-0.7813878059387207,
0.16063566505908966,
0.017877725884318352,
-0.1856149286031723,
-0.7470571398735046,
0.587613046169281,
-0.4209427833557129,
-0.5512928366661072,
0.22695741057395935,
0.01998581923544407,
-0.1596304476261139,
0.8992329239845276,
0.11589187383651733,
0.638757586479187,
0.6397526264190674,
-0.3369487226009369,
0.2452675998210907,
0.6647401452064514,
-0.02577299065887928,
0.7706905007362366,
-0.5448669791221619,
0.18087683618068695,
-0.48515117168426514,
0.01392772514373064,
-1.4116692543029785,
-0.21267998218536377,
0.5179716348648071,
-0.6739615797996521,
0.06360480189323425,
-0.6057187914848328,
-0.3223848342895508,
-0.3451002538204193,
-0.42225030064582825,
0.5285870432853699,
0.33535152673721313,
-0.7759647369384766,
0.5274692177772522,
0.09406869858503342,
0.4463295340538025,
-0.560310959815979,
-0.6804084181785583,
0.06863309442996979,
0.22521820664405823,
-0.7938972115516663,
-0.028858203440904617,
0.35651519894599915,
0.12298305332660675,
0.5547218918800354,
-0.231869176030159,
-0.3707796335220337,
-0.3187745213508606,
0.3574347198009491,
0.2590937316417694,
-0.3602285385131836,
0.12745657563209534,
-0.22785840928554535,
-0.3556426465511322,
-0.09974873811006546,
-0.2747756540775299,
0.43754759430885315,
-0.11880814284086227,
-0.3617510199546814,
-0.14472950994968414,
0.254538893699646,
0.7516189813613892,
-0.5743883848190308,
0.4999796748161316,
0.7660940289497375,
-0.5117905139923096,
0.04944606125354767,
0.07128504663705826,
0.28063228726387024,
-0.5008119940757751,
0.5179806351661682,
-0.6551107168197632,
-0.7709726095199585,
0.5397041440010071,
0.04366543889045715,
-0.31488490104675293,
0.03425892814993858,
0.2128891497850418,
0.258928507566452,
0.6587368249893188,
0.4411742687225342,
-0.02395051158964634,
0.575937032699585,
-0.5621591210365295,
0.43949946761131287,
-1.002868413925171,
-0.45944681763648987,
-0.043960925191640854,
-0.22080563008785248,
-0.2459988296031952,
-0.6349855661392212,
0.33422863483428955,
0.21037620306015015,
-0.5184348821640015,
0.5660250782966614,
-0.7225170135498047,
0.6667701601982117,
0.43060627579689026,
0.5254230499267578,
0.5559295415878296,
-0.03799515962600708,
-0.01289309747517109,
0.10311831533908844,
-0.5315049886703491,
0.0051014176569879055,
0.8261696696281433,
0.21202713251113892,
0.5830575227737427,
-0.09318964183330536,
0.4916123151779175,
-0.11248964816331863,
0.017834387719631195,
-1.0959538221359253,
0.715955913066864,
-0.3429088294506073,
-0.04177475720643997,
-0.41845688223838806,
-0.333391934633255,
-1.0398021936416626,
0.3479844927787781,
0.0800926610827446,
-0.7835274338722229,
0.30017614364624023,
0.19344142079353333,
0.18866084516048431,
0.5308719277381897,
-0.45255544781684875,
1.3230715990066528,
0.03800845891237259,
-0.644169807434082,
0.34297746419906616,
-0.6716129779815674,
0.6560121774673462,
0.40147504210472107,
0.02911699190735817,
0.033069051802158356,
0.09225191175937653,
0.19850578904151917,
-0.43104425072669983,
0.4793069660663605,
-0.1661936193704605,
0.3064461052417755,
0.3157816231250763,
0.20336979627609253,
0.20041237771511078,
-0.03316173702478409,
0.4350338578224182,
0.16641202569007874,
-0.3097988963127136,
-0.2684277594089508,
-0.4277072846889496,
0.35098034143447876,
-0.534001350402832,
-0.12517163157463074,
-0.19543099403381348,
-0.5228400230407715,
0.03182196244597435,
0.14944922924041748,
0.35113149881362915,
0.6319728493690491,
-0.4753305912017822,
0.24549536406993866,
0.6476083397865295,
-0.20806847512722015,
0.48222607374191284,
-0.23395410180091858,
-0.7071717977523804,
-0.5343399047851562,
0.9549766182899475,
-0.04911966994404793,
0.2050921767950058,
0.49662840366363525,
0.024748997762799263,
-0.24278423190116882,
-0.2106999158859253,
-0.70160311460495,
0.022055866196751595,
-0.7100821733474731,
-0.2869691252708435,
-0.7099879384040833,
-0.384734183549881,
-0.10709502547979355,
-0.15467768907546997,
-0.35590794682502747,
0.08666165173053741,
-0.30373162031173706,
-0.09317560493946075,
0.6800103783607483,
0.5237329602241516,
0.2873028516769409,
0.19737273454666138,
-0.6201314330101013,
0.8633965253829956,
0.5199642777442932,
0.36238810420036316,
0.06388764828443527,
0.031958747655153275,
-0.06297727674245834,
-0.3495493233203888,
-0.13312016427516937,
-0.8120352029800415,
0.36352577805519104,
0.2886728346347809,
0.1173156276345253,
0.6961902976036072,
-0.2546805143356323,
0.8028846383094788,
-0.39819076657295227,
0.5418262481689453,
0.40385621786117554,
-0.7780640721321106,
0.3902314007282257,
-0.48775988817214966,
0.346004843711853,
0.011724518612027168,
-0.03393793851137161,
-0.3655417263507843,
-0.09896015375852585,
-0.23824429512023926,
-0.8332191109657288,
0.5827586650848389,
0.4945462942123413,
-0.20041313767433167,
-0.2708636224269867,
0.3908001482486725,
-0.42551490664482117,
0.23706784844398499,
-0.5835058093070984,
-0.24062223732471466,
-0.4786832332611084,
-0.30089110136032104,
0.29399988055229187,
0.005383458454161882,
0.0668981596827507,
-0.5538007616996765,
0.014363185502588749,
-0.3807065486907959,
0.5529975891113281,
0.4050598740577698,
-0.046304695308208466,
-0.44715410470962524,
-0.06723629683256149,
-0.03587963059544563,
0.3040078282356262,
-0.2919457256793976,
-0.126469224691391,
-0.03532477840781212,
-0.36819836497306824,
0.10719332844018936,
-0.14354923367500305,
-0.05620903894305229,
0.14587710797786713,
0.4590323269367218,
0.8113799095153809,
0.46485990285873413,
-0.21292723715305328,
1.0301642417907715,
-0.12387820333242416,
-0.27709072828292847,
-0.15138749778270721,
-0.01866973377764225,
0.48225072026252747,
0.0546557791531086,
0.0549178272485733,
0.12475576251745224,
0.2081466019153595,
-0.7895634174346924,
0.526408314704895,
0.5604025721549988,
-0.8809218406677246,
-0.24071088433265686,
0.7773998379707336,
-0.022033564746379852,
-0.2369518131017685,
0.40565088391304016,
-0.21219408512115479,
-0.3256820738315582,
0.8634812831878662,
0.3923403024673462,
0.9064123630523682,
-0.1387106329202652,
0.047400958836078644,
0.31271594762802124,
0.12737803161144257,
0.21508890390396118,
0.37869876623153687,
-0.14293092489242554,
-0.9199861288070679,
-0.26597288250923157,
-0.6433370113372803,
-0.22782473266124725,
0.21631397306919098,
-0.8273257613182068,
0.40691742300987244,
-0.22840574383735657,
0.19695548713207245,
-0.14952769875526428,
-0.7713362574577332,
-0.8038973808288574,
0.12075796723365784,
-0.08853954076766968,
0.9419375061988831,
-0.565844714641571,
0.7900724411010742,
0.5272216200828552,
-0.6144089102745056,
-0.5874396562576294,
-0.37811708450317383,
-0.10588753968477249,
-0.9046971797943115,
0.6565768718719482,
0.6128756999969482,
-0.35962727665901184,
0.1470421552658081,
-0.5052827596664429,
-0.6214783787727356,
1.1812000274658203,
0.445064902305603,
-0.5669060349464417,
-0.3029974699020386,
-0.09694612771272659,
0.529272198677063,
-0.48154354095458984,
0.22145795822143555,
0.5192398428916931,
0.1507929265499115,
0.6934204697608948,
-0.3456331193447113,
-0.042345546185970306,
-0.22235170006752014,
0.2385602593421936,
0.7600767612457275,
-0.5759846568107605,
1.0411839485168457,
-0.08629690855741501,
-0.37454482913017273,
0.08700807392597198,
0.6695424914360046,
-0.13649693131446838,
0.5540382266044617,
0.48535192012786865,
0.9981023669242859,
0.07007542997598648,
-0.22410964965820312,
0.5765735507011414,
-0.4685685932636261,
0.2558869421482086,
0.9734380841255188,
-0.281659334897995,
0.7358353734016418,
0.34149616956710815,
-0.1201213151216507,
0.30938956141471863,
0.6321650743484497,
-0.10987769067287445,
0.5806782841682434,
0.13643521070480347,
-0.1851603388786316,
-0.27714642882347107,
-0.20915593206882477,
-0.24780121445655823,
0.30273953080177307,
0.3864695429801941,
-0.4811876118183136,
-0.6653124094009399,
-0.08301929384469986,
-0.24941718578338623,
-0.05814000964164734,
-0.48509377241134644,
0.8462418913841248,
0.17305126786231995,
-0.23567144572734833,
0.214845672249794,
-0.6629936099052429,
0.2928977906703949,
-0.5426927804946899,
-0.3411279618740082,
0.03180675208568573,
0.11090606451034546,
-0.2755076587200165,
-0.8368860483169556,
0.0367145761847496,
-0.10277379304170609,
0.14629557728767395,
0.31584635376930237,
1.117254614830017,
-0.5871026515960693,
-0.2894926071166992,
0.6672806143760681,
0.9070345163345337,
0.08573370426893234,
-0.10745439678430557,
-0.22855575382709503,
-0.13520266115665436,
-0.22839300334453583,
-0.2479412704706192,
0.23271042108535767,
0.7260943055152893,
-0.02416706271469593,
0.5746508240699768,
0.8629411458969116,
-0.34212371706962585,
-0.10903529822826385,
0.10615572333335876,
1.185076355934143,
-0.5871148109436035,
-0.5341467261314392,
-0.894129753112793,
0.5281369090080261,
-0.20605216920375824,
-0.37303483486175537,
0.38736268877983093,
0.7509670257568359,
0.8877840638160706,
-0.15534427762031555,
0.5423346161842346,
0.24229639768600464,
-0.22013643383979797,
-0.4450605511665344,
0.19448894262313843,
-0.44067099690437317,
-0.09473859518766403,
-0.35234740376472473,
-0.9520722031593323,
-0.39347174763679504,
0.29910898208618164,
0.10305953025817871,
-0.3582066297531128,
0.7631129622459412,
0.6802266240119934,
-0.3273046910762787,
-0.03343089669942856,
0.6266466379165649,
-0.07090771943330765,
0.3004838526248932,
0.6793075203895569,
0.7994142770767212,
-0.4049226939678192,
0.7754114270210266,
-0.06068451702594757,
-0.1260320544242859,
0.13067489862442017,
-0.7237702012062073,
-1.1416316032409668,
-0.4281099736690521,
-0.08325918018817902,
-0.1754620224237442,
0.28163641691207886,
0.5071852803230286,
0.4218257963657379,
-0.18268805742263794,
-0.22265110909938812,
-0.45931023359298706,
-0.08998388051986694,
-0.2332869917154312,
-0.23394854366779327,
0.3824329078197479,
-0.19909906387329102,
-0.4566483199596405,
0.23625025153160095,
0.8144724369049072,
0.0038538603112101555,
-0.22725720703601837,
-0.03941138833761215,
-0.1442774087190628,
-0.07512495666742325,
0.8148045539855957,
0.17039674520492554,
-0.5094740390777588,
-0.4023969769477844,
0.02665802836418152,
0.24264268577098846,
0.5960827469825745,
0.7832528948783875,
-0.7961711883544922,
0.6343027353286743,
0.5182494521141052,
0.4500548541545868,
0.9066308736801147,
0.16602161526679993,
0.30515891313552856,
-0.7982085943222046,
0.29908573627471924,
-0.22208315134048462,
0.6198136806488037,
0.32784149050712585,
-0.4679914712905884,
0.8389627933502197,
0.46585166454315186,
-0.3152713179588318,
-0.6375638842582703,
0.5762798190116882,
-1.1276079416275024,
-0.2751304805278778,
0.6982446908950806,
-0.323537141084671,
-0.7886443734169006,
-0.2344500869512558,
-0.22900891304016113,
0.5234979391098022,
-0.5001634955406189,
-0.10627705603837967,
0.30709922313690186,
-0.3110550045967102,
-0.2056247442960739,
-0.2458227276802063,
0.22045309841632843,
-0.48808005452156067,
-0.789983332157135,
0.08194487541913986,
0.3841146230697632,
0.21985700726509094,
0.09083962440490723,
0.6013011336326599,
-0.2392493486404419,
0.26888972520828247,
0.26208630204200745,
0.08913122862577438,
-0.550743579864502,
-0.31311580538749695,
-0.13948900997638702,
0.33269229531288147,
-0.2562461793422699,
-0.7907724976539612
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01556v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01556v1
|
Semantically Aligned Question and Code Generation for Automated Insight Generation
| 2024-03-21T10:01:05 | 2024-03-21T10:01:05 |
Ananya Singha, Bhavya Chopra, Anirudh Khatry, Sumit Gulwani, Austin Z. Henley, Vu Le, Chris Parnin, Mukul Singh, Gust Verbruggen
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Automated insight generation is a common tactic for helping knowledge
workers, such as data scientists, to quickly understand the potential value of
new and unfamiliar data. Unfortunately, automated insights produced by
large-language models can generate code that does not correctly correspond (or
align) to the insight. In this paper, we leverage the semantic knowledge of
large language models to generate targeted and insightful questions about data
and the corresponding code to answer those questions. Then through an empirical
study on data from Open-WikiTable, we show that embeddings can be effectively
used for filtering out semantically unaligned pairs of question and code.
Additionally, we found that generating questions and code together yields more
diverse questions.
|
[
-0.47963032126426697,
-0.8462846279144287,
0.6572651863098145,
-0.1751192808151245,
0.019160322844982147,
-0.1481880396604538,
-0.07262607663869858,
-0.42254558205604553,
0.09198088943958282,
0.7404460310935974,
-0.6935059428215027,
-0.5461563467979431,
-0.24630330502986908,
0.023483362048864365,
-0.6968699097633362,
1.0418879985809326,
-0.15694738924503326,
-0.1420053392648697,
-0.6606953740119934,
-0.34135857224464417,
-0.407063752412796,
-0.18114231526851654,
-0.027448056265711784,
-0.06697960942983627,
0.28130286931991577,
0.6613755226135254,
0.8327298760414124,
0.721306562423706,
0.6082534193992615,
0.25083789229393005,
0.50581955909729,
0.2670178711414337,
-0.4287874400615692,
0.19710882008075714,
-0.18967117369174957,
-0.3882425129413605,
0.0835542380809784,
-0.2681657671928406,
0.34159672260284424,
1.0351166725158691,
0.07621321827173233,
0.42430049180984497,
-0.10804654657840729,
0.5073238015174866,
-0.5840891003608704,
0.021486768499016762,
-0.8930922746658325,
0.1803424209356308,
0.05975569784641266,
-0.32824304699897766,
-0.3016834855079651,
-0.7758939862251282,
0.012912590987980366,
-0.6781870126724243,
0.25522786378860474,
0.0738425999879837,
0.7882668375968933,
0.6744345426559448,
-0.5388698577880859,
-0.5888777375221252,
-0.7161312103271484,
0.7562767267227173,
-0.5842829942703247,
0.13420367240905762,
0.2625146210193634,
0.2965896725654602,
-0.1552828550338745,
-0.5495294332504272,
-0.7153836488723755,
0.2701670229434967,
-0.17542707920074463,
0.07102707028388977,
-0.1676003485918045,
-0.27828356623649597,
0.21782606840133667,
0.13520999252796173,
-0.8339043259620667,
0.09556782990694046,
-0.3910363018512726,
-0.0692186951637268,
0.8860069513320923,
0.32571932673454285,
0.3636995553970337,
-0.24638599157333374,
-0.04735982418060303,
-0.08656372874975204,
-0.5347023010253906,
0.05528123676776886,
0.5791962146759033,
0.15483376383781433,
0.21974721550941467,
1.007293462753296,
-0.32147571444511414,
0.9691929221153259,
0.003113887505605817,
0.28742101788520813,
0.24371181428432465,
-0.380641371011734,
0.10563117265701294,
0.22132955491542816,
0.48338884115219116,
0.4748338460922241,
0.45932185649871826,
-0.3498753011226654,
-0.0597631111741066,
0.16483965516090393,
0.6414622664451599,
-0.6420759558677673,
-0.33249199390411377,
0.6009308695793152,
-0.3665415346622467,
-0.5155550837516785,
0.43152424693107605,
-0.7138214111328125,
-0.12312586605548859,
-0.29457685351371765,
0.37625545263290405,
-0.194159597158432,
-0.22687458992004395,
0.20595580339431763,
-0.38927674293518066,
0.5764264464378357,
0.23561085760593414,
-0.737075924873352,
-0.048304565250873566,
0.6427661180496216,
0.2693813443183899,
-0.07291784882545471,
-0.054906975477933884,
-0.4924512207508087,
0.3778075575828552,
-0.5112890005111694,
0.6989333033561707,
-0.7653323411941528,
-0.24512022733688354,
0.0785919576883316,
-0.09188845753669739,
0.09813764691352844,
-0.43449318408966064,
-0.01092172134667635,
-0.8142980933189392,
0.33668220043182373,
-0.32124003767967224,
-0.8208637237548828,
-0.0025725550949573517,
0.30072879791259766,
-0.5531788468360901,
0.9422224164009094,
0.2494441121816635,
-0.9994150400161743,
0.5242837071418762,
-0.7225795388221741,
0.03412461280822754,
0.15256161987781525,
-0.47511035203933716,
-0.25201311707496643,
0.05551878735423088,
0.43886297941207886,
0.35894203186035156,
-0.17530235648155212,
0.29809027910232544,
-0.34274277091026306,
-0.009253356605768204,
0.581701934337616,
-0.06589638441801071,
0.6346490979194641,
0.5424149632453918,
-0.33094045519828796,
-0.03581257164478302,
-0.7986565232276917,
0.6159754395484924,
0.34086963534355164,
-0.2167809158563614,
-0.6152185797691345,
0.020835353061556816,
-0.20853520929813385,
-0.03795703500509262,
0.14997830986976624,
-0.8103667497634888,
0.21181324124336243,
-0.3220908045768738,
0.1539832055568695,
0.6125366687774658,
0.26205143332481384,
0.5183266997337341,
-0.12220454216003418,
0.5931215286254883,
0.15621940791606903,
0.05234619975090027,
0.011148936115205288,
-0.5436797738075256,
-0.5721454620361328,
0.16739864647388458,
0.20006360113620758,
0.5087169408798218,
-0.8704579472541809,
0.6005696058273315,
-0.04096372053027153,
-0.4528641998767853,
-0.8528444170951843,
0.43327587842941284,
0.15773087739944458,
0.813418447971344,
0.38379353284835815,
-0.032574426382780075,
-0.43780696392059326,
-0.804858922958374,
-0.30457597970962524,
-0.020937152206897736,
-0.05970575287938118,
0.4436650574207306,
0.5606452822685242,
-0.3212604224681854,
1.5001112222671509,
-1.0781255960464478,
0.4061504304409027,
-0.006847715936601162,
0.15014910697937012,
0.08855653554201126,
0.7141403555870056,
0.2711164355278015,
-1.0233571529388428,
-0.4009799361228943,
-0.010139692574739456,
-0.9715542197227478,
-0.29309508204460144,
0.03814346343278885,
-0.48528939485549927,
-0.035734623670578,
0.6113541722297668,
-0.42800724506378174,
0.2880494296550751,
0.38878747820854187,
-0.3654775619506836,
0.1306871622800827,
-0.1687157303094864,
0.08761486411094666,
-1.3630750179290771,
0.3606919050216675,
-0.37423017621040344,
-0.08369173109531403,
-0.626839280128479,
0.07186207175254822,
0.26301705837249756,
-0.45116275548934937,
-0.18443205952644348,
0.37656667828559875,
-0.34654736518859863,
-0.11469431966543198,
-0.05915253981947899,
0.17558282613754272,
0.2746593654155731,
0.12451305985450745,
-0.04966877028346062,
0.46212050318717957,
0.18477754294872284,
-0.6316498517990112,
0.5434616804122925,
0.5470844507217407,
-0.5874320864677429,
0.37815821170806885,
-0.6856555342674255,
0.36930549144744873,
-0.3440997302532196,
-0.10792982578277588,
-0.9669531583786011,
-0.5129640102386475,
-0.19696395099163055,
-0.5623719692230225,
0.10239459574222565,
-0.03138723596930504,
-0.4647998511791229,
-0.434423565864563,
-0.20248036086559296,
0.890263557434082,
0.5737758874893188,
-0.7496095299720764,
0.1803085058927536,
0.467917799949646,
-0.12064359337091446,
-0.5493603348731995,
-0.7487007975578308,
-0.4089932143688202,
-0.25686126947402954,
-0.9548428058624268,
0.13960497081279755,
0.13082970678806305,
-0.48128455877304077,
0.5259132385253906,
0.0785343274474144,
-0.16006866097450256,
0.09462416917085648,
0.061290889978408813,
0.31714388728141785,
-0.3637129068374634,
0.3341211676597595,
0.16443388164043427,
-0.03964642807841301,
0.22215838730335236,
-0.5102020502090454,
0.5266990065574646,
0.19928254187107086,
-0.850326418876648,
0.038560401648283005,
0.9139530062675476,
0.4227593243122101,
-0.5014489889144897,
0.6779608726501465,
0.4836476445198059,
-0.2972474694252014,
-0.42381787300109863,
-0.4694596230983734,
-0.07020175457000732,
-0.47827520966529846,
0.29471901059150696,
-0.08004599809646606,
-1.069560170173645,
0.6050576567649841,
0.11801350861787796,
0.1571951061487198,
0.5056781768798828,
0.5736525654792786,
-0.1441616714000702,
1.5794017314910889,
0.6503623723983765,
0.15550829470157623,
0.13023227453231812,
-0.1318747103214264,
0.4817119836807251,
-0.4033253788948059,
-0.43824881315231323,
-0.7379043102264404,
-0.15971848368644714,
-0.5391616821289062,
-0.34335002303123474,
0.41011402010917664,
0.021316837519407272,
-0.08771514892578125,
0.19751526415348053,
-0.8251988291740417,
0.4546858072280884,
0.5292541980743408,
-0.07443391531705856,
0.13049063086509705,
-0.3766728937625885,
0.09875702857971191,
0.2543678879737854,
-0.7172603607177734,
-0.3976629078388214,
1.070788025856018,
0.10730345547199249,
1.1050242185592651,
-0.08870036900043488,
0.9387961030006409,
0.008863021619617939,
-0.18911701440811157,
-0.6171650290489197,
0.16755622625350952,
0.2743696868419647,
-0.7202797532081604,
-0.39194801449775696,
-0.6315925717353821,
-1.109976887702942,
-0.16577374935150146,
-0.08049944043159485,
-0.5112628936767578,
0.24400565028190613,
0.15660956501960754,
-0.3693700432777405,
0.0961768850684166,
-0.9972933530807495,
1.0813151597976685,
-0.17755424976348877,
0.10625102370977402,
-0.020604215562343597,
-0.5340466499328613,
0.24023449420928955,
-0.2207009643316269,
0.15978524088859558,
0.03262515366077423,
0.03711400553584099,
0.7600635290145874,
-0.6947499513626099,
0.5278582572937012,
-0.34088242053985596,
-0.21004320681095123,
0.6020711064338684,
-0.08949360251426697,
0.39097860455513,
0.06182835251092911,
0.13127845525741577,
-0.2821447551250458,
0.09139227867126465,
-0.5470691323280334,
-0.8052693009376526,
0.5527925491333008,
-0.6456536054611206,
-0.5535487532615662,
0.1750098615884781,
-0.9905600547790527,
-0.3290991187095642,
0.10220089554786682,
0.1937788873910904,
0.5042088627815247,
-0.021509019657969475,
0.14121204614639282,
0.7805808186531067,
-0.4677642285823822,
0.22736135125160217,
0.33416733145713806,
-0.1904006153345108,
-0.047037482261657715,
0.8439525365829468,
0.10049491375684738,
0.34408167004585266,
0.35367992520332336,
0.08051209896802902,
-0.3312663733959198,
-0.2049538493156433,
-0.45899999141693115,
0.05304731801152229,
-0.7603158950805664,
-0.4988303780555725,
-0.7531182169914246,
-0.09841788560152054,
-0.6318923830986023,
-0.42488113045692444,
-0.2278035581111908,
-0.5815157294273376,
-0.1567879319190979,
-0.0984496921300888,
0.7412444949150085,
0.8658818006515503,
0.10814638435840607,
-0.24010661244392395,
-1.0083314180374146,
0.23423314094543457,
0.4730669856071472,
0.1668769270181656,
-0.1262352615594864,
0.07645350694656372,
-0.37671980261802673,
0.20684128999710083,
-0.1306050717830658,
-0.9002680778503418,
0.17473600804805756,
-0.07576236128807068,
0.5765269994735718,
0.28957629203796387,
0.5019952058792114,
0.6998220086097717,
-0.28909018635749817,
0.6445625424385071,
0.02978145331144333,
-0.9341444373130798,
0.9609894156455994,
-0.17010018229484558,
0.47122418880462646,
0.7481427192687988,
0.5272780656814575,
-0.3009699583053589,
-0.5869602560997009,
-0.43614697456359863,
-0.7459272742271423,
0.5977282524108887,
-0.015912629663944244,
0.17232808470726013,
-0.1492571383714676,
0.3085300028324127,
0.3627035319805145,
0.19868303835391998,
-0.37919679284095764,
0.08655453473329544,
-0.3268841803073883,
-0.7233958840370178,
0.23474551737308502,
0.15849502384662628,
-0.28352776169776917,
-0.22551634907722473,
0.2791328430175781,
-0.5033888816833496,
0.4552314579486847,
0.14101141691207886,
-0.24895504117012024,
-0.25757914781570435,
0.1847073882818222,
0.04059838503599167,
0.5400208234786987,
-0.06915364414453506,
-0.06391625851392746,
-0.03915175795555115,
-0.3446166515350342,
-0.0021115695126354694,
0.010324442759156227,
-0.22597646713256836,
-0.2752389907836914,
0.29500454664230347,
0.4112003445625305,
-0.15844081342220306,
-0.9127496480941772,
0.5217384696006775,
-0.09018535166978836,
-0.2971230149269104,
-0.20798414945602417,
0.3000665605068207,
0.04841741919517517,
0.25390389561653137,
0.15789534151554108,
-0.11080193519592285,
-0.0614008903503418,
-0.7084981799125671,
0.2405686378479004,
0.7041321396827698,
-0.19834595918655396,
0.09269805997610092,
0.5009133815765381,
0.0938611850142479,
0.032573502510786057,
0.9531823396682739,
0.05065236613154411,
-0.6314990520477295,
0.7693604230880737,
0.5398994088172913,
0.5959020256996155,
0.119325190782547,
0.21688927710056305,
0.09399103373289108,
0.01650218479335308,
0.4363800287246704,
0.5592470765113831,
-0.4908994138240814,
-0.9539878964424133,
-0.4404256343841553,
-0.4547499716281891,
-0.40079638361930847,
-0.38466665148735046,
-1.0563628673553467,
0.15057902038097382,
-0.13781557977199554,
0.21944628655910492,
0.019206253811717033,
-0.14775320887565613,
-0.7614606618881226,
0.3253037631511688,
-0.20051629841327667,
0.8537211418151855,
-0.7867828607559204,
0.8460829257965088,
0.7249708771705627,
-0.5017083883285522,
-1.1786494255065918,
0.07543271034955978,
-0.31466013193130493,
-0.9788170456886292,
0.5159094929695129,
0.12293916195631027,
0.19166895747184753,
0.12223590165376663,
-0.892630934715271,
-1.014470100402832,
0.982891321182251,
0.19833649694919586,
0.02770402282476425,
-0.0849878266453743,
0.43370765447616577,
0.32762035727500916,
-0.44585853815078735,
0.009169095195829868,
0.574027955532074,
0.5050880312919617,
0.005313170608133078,
-0.5013708472251892,
0.09044726938009262,
-0.5457253456115723,
-0.23918657004833221,
0.6022065281867981,
-0.12676756083965302,
0.6118401885032654,
-0.29892680048942566,
-0.011749202385544777,
-0.06521817296743393,
0.5153554081916809,
-0.17868706583976746,
0.3830394446849823,
0.39437055587768555,
0.7755483388900757,
0.9105905294418335,
-0.017231671139597893,
1.0379233360290527,
-0.28126490116119385,
0.26626381278038025,
0.6863211393356323,
-0.3454750180244446,
0.5509620904922485,
0.6114166975021362,
0.11846527457237244,
0.5047103762626648,
0.4190325140953064,
-0.2825433313846588,
0.7639440298080444,
0.1492796242237091,
0.050502125173807144,
-0.19476698338985443,
-0.09186439961194992,
-0.5526065826416016,
0.699828028678894,
0.21785208582878113,
-0.1664251685142517,
-0.2170661836862564,
0.08991806209087372,
-0.30283185839653015,
0.1498047411441803,
-0.1510581225156784,
1.1664155721664429,
-0.24627381563186646,
-0.9175750017166138,
0.3291912376880646,
-0.1050104945898056,
0.3304890990257263,
-0.6066910028457642,
-0.07134023308753967,
-0.11180535703897476,
0.10309789329767227,
-0.5606225728988647,
-1.0710309743881226,
0.7571466565132141,
0.4529256820678711,
-0.20505490899085999,
-0.09310124069452286,
0.5074597597122192,
-0.44775688648223877,
-0.37569287419319153,
0.1570487916469574,
0.6123485565185547,
0.07839205861091614,
0.12336020171642303,
-0.4288254678249359,
-0.17092299461364746,
0.23430584371089935,
-0.09051211178302765,
0.27060428261756897,
0.6147118210792542,
0.10342881083488464,
0.4552450180053711,
0.6708871126174927,
-0.20946943759918213,
0.3304767310619354,
-0.010796274989843369,
1.1427809000015259,
-0.6609541773796082,
-0.43361395597457886,
-0.6092731356620789,
0.7452341318130493,
-0.15918196737766266,
-0.38987240195274353,
0.8131202459335327,
0.5579913854598999,
0.9651628732681274,
-0.003380185691639781,
0.7934278845787048,
-0.31135818362236023,
0.48577386140823364,
-0.6785516142845154,
0.687109112739563,
-0.6989887356758118,
0.03289119154214859,
-0.48080092668533325,
-1.0392444133758545,
-0.13914048671722412,
0.4680333435535431,
-0.32068726420402527,
-0.16430118680000305,
0.597736656665802,
0.9797722101211548,
-0.044768597930669785,
0.2815680205821991,
0.09996724873781204,
-0.1703549474477768,
0.35262033343315125,
0.6203371286392212,
0.9357683062553406,
-0.28899258375167847,
0.591642439365387,
-0.3716678321361542,
-0.10801485925912857,
0.10157471150159836,
-0.6734949350357056,
-0.706404447555542,
-0.7543492317199707,
-0.3878128230571747,
-0.29909345507621765,
-0.4361204206943512,
0.8155754208564758,
0.5334024429321289,
-0.9388224482536316,
0.14330384135246277,
-0.2874641418457031,
0.16944606602191925,
0.2830246388912201,
-0.31002679467201233,
0.3489762246608734,
-0.5404029488563538,
-0.5201124548912048,
0.24394337832927704,
0.075945645570755,
-0.05853331461548805,
-0.275943398475647,
-0.04524747282266617,
-0.046871673315763474,
0.25376635789871216,
0.1552058309316635,
0.07214969396591187,
-0.18005603551864624,
-0.5213903188705444,
0.1296665370464325,
-0.08126886188983917,
-0.13928107917308807,
1.0631229877471924,
-0.6417770385742188,
0.5104764699935913,
0.7018982768058777,
1.0895490646362305,
0.3096204102039337,
0.3354753255844116,
0.7189739346504211,
-0.8221662044525146,
0.07695791125297546,
0.45469096302986145,
0.2711736559867859,
0.22537444531917572,
-0.5204516053199768,
0.41016513109207153,
-0.19429798424243927,
-0.6599442362785339,
-0.9188715815544128,
0.3078092932701111,
-0.7514488697052002,
-0.4430685043334961,
0.9599114656448364,
-0.009913802146911621,
-0.31787943840026855,
-0.27724024653434753,
0.020823989063501358,
0.22064504027366638,
-0.06260481476783752,
0.6867944598197937,
0.5445927977561951,
-0.3852561414241791,
0.19227197766304016,
-0.39952969551086426,
0.2999279201030731,
0.6300666332244873,
-1.0231587886810303,
-0.11134454607963562,
0.4834374189376831,
0.014178360812366009,
0.24396713078022003,
0.21018555760383606,
-0.33378463983535767,
0.2762972414493561,
0.20163977146148682,
-0.12450627237558365,
-0.011672785505652428,
-0.058580536395311356,
-0.2417106330394745,
0.26501941680908203,
0.05125725269317627,
-0.29139837622642517
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14258v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14258v1
|
LLM-based Extraction of Contradictions from Patents
| 2024-03-21T09:36:36 | 2024-03-21T09:36:36 |
Stefan Trapp, Joachim Warschat
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7; H.3.1
|
Already since the 1950s TRIZ shows that patents and the technical
contradictions they solve are an important source of inspiration for the
development of innovative products. However, TRIZ is a heuristic based on a
historic patent analysis and does not make use of the ever-increasing number of
latest technological solutions in current patents. Because of the huge number
of patents, their length, and, last but not least, their complexity there is a
need for modern patent retrieval and patent analysis to go beyond
keyword-oriented methods. Recent advances in patent retrieval and analysis
mainly focus on dense vectors based on neural AI Transformer language models
like Google BERT. They are, for example, used for dense retrieval, question
answering or summarization and key concept extraction. A research focus within
the methods for patent summarization and key concept extraction are generic
inventive concepts respectively TRIZ concepts like problems, solutions,
advantage of invention, parameters, and contradictions. Succeeding rule-based
approaches, finetuned BERT-like language models for sentence-wise
classification represent the state-of-the-art of inventive concept extraction.
While they work comparatively well for basic concepts like problems or
solutions, contradictions - as a more complex abstraction - remain a challenge
for these models. This paper goes one step further, as it presents a method to
extract TRIZ contradictions from patent texts based on Prompt Engineering using
a generative Large Language Model (LLM), namely OpenAI's GPT-4. Contradiction
detection, sentence extraction, contradiction summarization, parameter
extraction and assignment to the 39 abstract TRIZ engineering parameters are
all performed in a single prompt using the LangChain framework. Our results
show that "off-the-shelf" GPT-4 is a serious alternative to existing
approaches.
|
[
-0.3611335754394531,
-0.7764504551887512,
0.6729337573051453,
0.3512079119682312,
-0.3891848623752594,
0.30164635181427,
0.20587414503097534,
-0.3965672254562378,
-0.07398637384176254,
0.4003277122974396,
-0.5243926048278809,
-0.48863330483436584,
-0.4224989712238312,
0.19774000346660614,
-0.2900899648666382,
0.7644962668418884,
-0.3471854329109192,
-0.205063596367836,
0.1053209975361824,
0.28734633326530457,
-0.47469377517700195,
-0.47919028997421265,
-0.1589730829000473,
-0.3954956531524658,
0.23206248879432678,
0.5086343884468079,
0.465000718832016,
0.2920058071613312,
0.436149537563324,
0.3795981705188751,
-0.37288230657577515,
0.04059137776494026,
-0.04993344470858574,
-0.020991768687963486,
0.07315678894519806,
-0.47493889927864075,
-0.11520958691835403,
0.12919922173023224,
0.4275723695755005,
0.32430145144462585,
0.039971280843019485,
0.009968133643269539,
0.15672007203102112,
0.4899972677230835,
-0.44617027044296265,
0.38984018564224243,
-0.7154000997543335,
0.30507370829582214,
-0.337935209274292,
-0.4264149069786072,
-0.22033923864364624,
-0.6025965213775635,
0.39275890588760376,
-0.6062570810317993,
0.6533257365226746,
0.358634352684021,
1.3775392770767212,
0.3262958824634552,
0.16558723151683807,
-0.5377268195152283,
-0.5451756715774536,
0.8282619714736938,
-0.9618556499481201,
-0.0477166622877121,
-0.20769590139389038,
0.33176079392433167,
-0.42436572909355164,
-0.9913141131401062,
-0.9866660833358765,
-0.37042057514190674,
0.11237500607967377,
0.15425731241703033,
-0.20644539594650269,
0.14435148239135742,
0.4135352373123169,
0.42829376459121704,
-0.5144403576850891,
0.3221191465854645,
-0.297446608543396,
-0.22792255878448486,
0.3358747363090515,
0.017523299902677536,
0.625251054763794,
-0.6275752782821655,
-0.699533224105835,
0.06726419180631638,
-1.0354450941085815,
-0.04348759353160858,
0.3339649736881256,
0.19700966775417328,
-0.06816243380308151,
0.8060768842697144,
-0.22526799142360687,
0.5149658918380737,
-0.002189853461459279,
0.05234123021364212,
0.35862645506858826,
-0.5011011958122253,
-0.3513503968715668,
0.11013297736644745,
0.9596091508865356,
0.06595204770565033,
0.23714259266853333,
-0.3885864317417145,
-0.23789797723293304,
-0.3910679519176483,
-0.08120862394571304,
-0.6106122136116028,
0.019152019172906876,
0.3479728400707245,
-0.4199633002281189,
-0.15785440802574158,
0.19548101723194122,
-0.9704277515411377,
-0.4166894257068634,
-0.05641236528754234,
0.49856412410736084,
-0.2837349474430084,
0.04527346044778824,
0.36403247714042664,
-0.5943006277084351,
0.6082351207733154,
-0.032472819089889526,
-0.6653774380683899,
-0.13072434067726135,
0.8591604828834534,
1.1430834531784058,
-0.021747978404164314,
-0.09067708998918533,
-0.10183998942375183,
-0.011808039620518684,
-0.27548083662986755,
0.8994616866111755,
-0.1583266407251358,
-0.5520480871200562,
-0.15184704959392548,
-0.18344001471996307,
0.01956116408109665,
-0.8164641857147217,
0.749424159526825,
-0.8596852421760559,
0.34658363461494446,
-0.3800569474697113,
-0.39221420884132385,
-0.25318121910095215,
0.04601982235908508,
-0.6869511008262634,
0.6912162899971008,
-0.009472819045186043,
-0.8405474424362183,
0.15302212536334991,
-0.8096341490745544,
-0.4180145561695099,
0.3293594419956207,
-0.5300193428993225,
-0.5217971801757812,
0.09214134514331818,
0.3058486878871918,
0.16623663902282715,
-0.8280244469642639,
0.3911626935005188,
-0.3633553385734558,
-0.16931864619255066,
0.21406787633895874,
-0.32280200719833374,
1.1775003671646118,
0.3660559058189392,
-0.5776882171630859,
0.10761629045009613,
-0.5829451680183411,
0.05585646256804466,
0.17696239054203033,
-0.09331219643354416,
-0.09378647059202194,
-0.21471810340881348,
-0.5261498093605042,
0.4238548278808594,
0.4530011713504791,
-0.9080519080162048,
0.029001759365200996,
-0.6560278534889221,
0.4726347327232361,
0.618395984172821,
0.4200790524482727,
0.050926659256219864,
-0.35500437021255493,
0.4756908118724823,
-0.15480108559131622,
0.15597018599510193,
-0.01358410157263279,
-0.8442102074623108,
-0.7799689173698425,
-0.3500194847583771,
0.2516586482524872,
0.6541574597358704,
-1.0727969408035278,
0.4553569257259369,
-0.3404186964035034,
-0.22267308831214905,
-0.6315222978591919,
0.12460431456565857,
0.3104213774204254,
0.8829523921012878,
0.29987433552742004,
0.015514669939875603,
-0.4609794020652771,
-0.97298264503479,
-0.42744091153144836,
-0.13985677063465118,
-0.3027498722076416,
0.21077321469783783,
0.31587842106819153,
0.26719212532043457,
1.1259161233901978,
-0.49732282757759094,
-0.16822148859500885,
-0.2934625446796417,
0.7332308888435364,
0.718742311000824,
0.134831964969635,
0.3013277053833008,
-0.983909547328949,
-0.5606017112731934,
0.09493264555931091,
-0.952418327331543,
-0.3949053883552551,
-0.11019265651702881,
0.1837131828069687,
0.03380383178591728,
0.5136135816574097,
-0.9507433176040649,
0.3723451793193817,
-0.07873904705047607,
-0.0069566452875733376,
0.5935974717140198,
-0.08832376450300217,
-0.023118404671549797,
-1.125308632850647,
0.15025024116039276,
0.02160523273050785,
0.2594822645187378,
-0.460855633020401,
0.0071665504947304726,
0.01906418986618519,
-0.03713976964354515,
-0.5996702313423157,
0.49391722679138184,
-0.5957884788513184,
-0.03224065154790878,
-0.23346851766109467,
0.2775803208351135,
0.10342857241630554,
0.2671619653701782,
-0.43883928656578064,
1.0425633192062378,
0.2976476848125458,
-0.6656984090805054,
0.8105774521827698,
0.32733893394470215,
-0.41840842366218567,
0.25949186086654663,
-0.8926311135292053,
0.1390046775341034,
0.012825428508222103,
-0.11910418421030045,
-1.0458712577819824,
-0.011355545371770859,
0.521701455116272,
-0.3266606330871582,
0.2977096438407898,
0.04818522557616234,
-0.7840674519538879,
-0.7332726120948792,
-0.4001147449016571,
-0.04616013914346695,
0.4901275336742401,
-0.8265207409858704,
0.7773463726043701,
0.09627662599086761,
-0.7378145456314087,
-0.8821481466293335,
-0.4405728578567505,
0.21278156340122223,
-0.2888079583644867,
-0.6741671562194824,
0.695307731628418,
-0.08536375313997269,
-0.1682754009962082,
0.18677854537963867,
-0.18673913180828094,
-0.09738335758447647,
0.034548450261354446,
0.06736291199922562,
0.6310644745826721,
-0.2835206091403961,
-0.016604620963335037,
-0.12988917529582977,
-0.18590980768203735,
0.13213783502578735,
-0.3384200930595398,
0.4781075119972229,
-0.2218480259180069,
-0.2676110863685608,
-0.4806247353553772,
0.1841571033000946,
0.38392674922943115,
0.007149816490709782,
0.13867056369781494,
0.2666797339916229,
-0.16415968537330627,
-0.1808691769838333,
-0.5800142884254456,
0.32302188873291016,
-0.5912211537361145,
0.34083741903305054,
-0.579181969165802,
-0.711171567440033,
0.5002461671829224,
-0.19834810495376587,
0.03248124569654465,
0.78282630443573,
0.6571493148803711,
-0.11834704875946045,
0.44431352615356445,
0.659992516040802,
-0.13212215900421143,
0.34327152371406555,
-0.11438851803541183,
0.6690585613250732,
-0.5766918063163757,
-0.4334564507007599,
-0.7638683915138245,
-0.17270489037036896,
-0.41916000843048096,
-0.015422127209603786,
0.38995522260665894,
0.06629986315965652,
-0.24115271866321564,
0.2405131459236145,
-0.3723137676715851,
0.543976902961731,
0.7452772855758667,
-0.043248970061540604,
0.36864355206489563,
0.11632180213928223,
-0.5078222155570984,
0.2591199576854706,
-0.5936812162399292,
-0.5375717878341675,
1.0229820013046265,
0.21138888597488403,
0.6447767615318298,
-0.04470927640795708,
0.6225656867027283,
0.16565057635307312,
0.24192336201667786,
-0.8670645952224731,
0.631237804889679,
-0.054621707648038864,
-0.6282555460929871,
-0.17672115564346313,
-0.4810752868652344,
-0.688487708568573,
-0.02976028434932232,
0.1754915565252304,
-0.7660061717033386,
0.41573309898376465,
-0.15148548781871796,
-0.6932093501091003,
0.364249050617218,
-1.0167077779769897,
0.6966955065727234,
-0.5243415236473083,
-0.13415738940238953,
0.07313770800828934,
-0.8039202094078064,
0.3819608986377716,
-0.38615188002586365,
-0.11868453025817871,
0.14341981709003448,
0.08846798539161682,
0.6323921084403992,
-0.4204232096672058,
0.728595495223999,
-0.08832588791847229,
-0.3697702884674072,
0.6339627504348755,
-0.27310046553611755,
0.3253263533115387,
-0.30665701627731323,
-0.0719432681798935,
0.14615121483802795,
-0.28600001335144043,
-0.1397540271282196,
-0.7189031839370728,
0.5413625836372375,
-0.6320732235908508,
-0.9623970985412598,
-0.3642785847187042,
-0.5663695335388184,
-0.1534518599510193,
0.46714267134666443,
0.6697171330451965,
0.008241275325417519,
-0.08385834842920303,
-0.07965240627527237,
0.43726059794425964,
-0.5374645590782166,
0.8493267893791199,
0.42262396216392517,
0.26049521565437317,
-0.39363276958465576,
1.0190865993499756,
0.08121951669454575,
0.0779406949877739,
0.541812002658844,
0.2324572205543518,
-0.533187747001648,
-0.6232892870903015,
-0.21701198816299438,
0.22665511071681976,
-0.7922071814537048,
-0.32424402236938477,
-0.4982123076915741,
-0.5143297910690308,
-0.24889715015888214,
0.2673758864402771,
-0.07858897000551224,
-0.5272164344787598,
-0.3765498101711273,
0.029604576528072357,
-0.06936367601156235,
0.7119724750518799,
0.04608313739299774,
0.22752682864665985,
-0.7181673645973206,
0.7640460133552551,
0.4964868724346161,
0.40458011627197266,
-0.09559305757284164,
-0.4310983419418335,
0.05526800453662872,
-0.08535423874855042,
-0.7691211104393005,
-0.813510000705719,
0.24015149474143982,
0.004609862342476845,
0.7220458388328552,
0.39460644125938416,
0.09156421571969986,
0.4643314480781555,
-0.5155673623085022,
0.8549709916114807,
0.31483790278434753,
-1.0069667100906372,
0.3465833067893982,
0.07924026250839233,
-0.16459587216377258,
-0.1527782827615738,
0.44757792353630066,
-0.2587781846523285,
-0.04004228487610817,
-0.6850079298019409,
-0.9645471572875977,
0.5743549466133118,
0.16000406444072723,
-0.061398059129714966,
0.26039212942123413,
0.5333539247512817,
0.13448253273963928,
0.23832489550113678,
-0.7019504308700562,
-0.08889990299940109,
-0.2546464800834656,
-0.43770065903663635,
0.23777452111244202,
-0.3111145496368408,
-0.19620168209075928,
0.16408702731132507,
0.7032891511917114,
0.19699114561080933,
0.36530670523643494,
0.2090563327074051,
0.028902148827910423,
0.12127597630023956,
0.584069013595581,
0.6206487417221069,
0.41638630628585815,
-0.2772575616836548,
0.13164596259593964,
-0.14062370359897614,
-0.30413827300071716,
0.12230285257101059,
0.5367140173912048,
-0.40166303515434265,
0.22439806163311005,
0.2026417851448059,
0.5251212120056152,
-0.19420716166496277,
-0.4663897454738617,
0.5039010047912598,
0.20115604996681213,
-0.2639058828353882,
-0.06274313479661942,
0.003142799250781536,
-0.07500045746564865,
0.570041835308075,
0.4880276322364807,
-0.16008271276950836,
0.2730194330215454,
-0.16788619756698608,
0.2739996910095215,
0.5338459014892578,
-0.10702572017908096,
-0.28240177035331726,
0.5006445646286011,
0.06822788715362549,
-0.2725096046924591,
0.4575757384300232,
-0.1843593418598175,
-0.5599974393844604,
0.7859761118888855,
0.6131979823112488,
1.379178524017334,
0.05985776335000992,
0.21519431471824646,
0.10267578810453415,
0.3702586591243744,
-0.17013131082057953,
0.3817293643951416,
0.031033575534820557,
-0.8236859440803528,
-0.24806569516658783,
-0.2682685852050781,
-0.5322858095169067,
0.26737964153289795,
-0.12926051020622253,
0.3723197281360626,
-0.5576913952827454,
-0.12152494490146637,
0.1841796338558197,
-0.07633896917104721,
-0.5714752078056335,
-0.13887475430965424,
0.00013056390162091702,
0.6832143664360046,
-0.5308739542961121,
0.48045405745506287,
0.23540641367435455,
-0.8402870297431946,
-0.734618067741394,
0.19366970658302307,
0.0074781873263418674,
-0.9322169423103333,
0.9568516612052917,
-0.04756350815296173,
-0.20892027020454407,
0.06933098286390305,
-0.8529329299926758,
-0.524204671382904,
1.0307643413543701,
0.40730342268943787,
-0.4506266415119171,
-0.422569215297699,
0.1994214653968811,
0.40424349904060364,
-0.339668869972229,
-0.0754755437374115,
0.3562113642692566,
0.3798958957195282,
0.29929593205451965,
-0.8009424209594727,
0.15693265199661255,
-0.29814624786376953,
0.016417453065514565,
-0.06673133373260498,
-0.385160893201828,
1.0123149156570435,
-0.47200173139572144,
-0.5904470682144165,
0.38342946767807007,
0.49927616119384766,
0.32242608070373535,
0.3416481614112854,
0.12318248301744461,
0.49652647972106934,
0.696717381477356,
-0.16629721224308014,
0.9724854826927185,
-0.2781577706336975,
0.49635064601898193,
1.118586778640747,
-0.32702723145484924,
0.6421607732772827,
0.62529057264328,
-0.023321393877267838,
0.519572913646698,
0.5445932745933533,
-0.3513593375682831,
0.5560669898986816,
0.2542966306209564,
-0.3645777702331543,
0.1360480934381485,
-0.1429591029882431,
-0.3657255172729492,
0.08209223300218582,
0.3703087270259857,
-0.2935909032821655,
-0.4399491250514984,
-0.3517688512802124,
-0.11993469297885895,
-0.3849692940711975,
0.06622879207134247,
0.6306399703025818,
0.4015064537525177,
-0.4033522307872772,
0.7434064149856567,
0.18074849247932434,
0.49110114574432373,
-0.3719813823699951,
-0.14554788172245026,
-0.0863862931728363,
0.030095843598246574,
0.0569051057100296,
-0.7850595712661743,
-0.06459368765354156,
0.1999005824327469,
0.14443430304527283,
-0.0814862996339798,
0.6591159105300903,
-0.023236917331814766,
-0.17488689720630646,
0.08710622787475586,
0.6336522698402405,
-0.0011854616459459066,
0.01186787337064743,
-0.6807178258895874,
-0.3933199644088745,
0.06241975352168083,
0.07194466888904572,
-0.4568869173526764,
0.8326191306114197,
0.1796153038740158,
0.7870630025863647,
0.5437787175178528,
0.23692376911640167,
0.22637775540351868,
0.0998462662100792,
0.9988005757331848,
-0.8475161194801331,
-0.5828319787979126,
-0.9986041188240051,
0.23466789722442627,
-0.21019916236400604,
-0.15755057334899902,
0.6352681517601013,
0.3814924359321594,
0.46385303139686584,
-0.10690905153751373,
1.123487949371338,
-0.03275986388325691,
0.55617356300354,
-0.732846200466156,
0.4524427652359009,
-0.39046069979667664,
0.64194256067276,
-0.3936048448085785,
-0.8018559217453003,
-0.4962107837200165,
0.24286644160747528,
-0.30630624294281006,
0.09513381123542786,
0.8524507284164429,
0.6920570731163025,
0.0506298691034317,
0.2882263660430908,
-0.04445486143231392,
0.5364382266998291,
0.7181326746940613,
0.48416057229042053,
0.9632149338722229,
-0.3796249330043793,
0.6425313353538513,
0.038770027458667755,
-0.28695276379585266,
-0.21670344471931458,
-0.9723879098892212,
-0.5713112354278564,
-0.3095039129257202,
-0.13569113612174988,
-0.3155387043952942,
-0.05711876228451729,
0.7699778079986572,
0.0900173932313919,
-0.9266993999481201,
-0.061283864080905914,
-0.44884803891181946,
0.467718243598938,
0.06769665330648422,
-0.24890202283859253,
0.5482578873634338,
-0.6467798948287964,
-0.40620705485343933,
0.25149086117744446,
0.5722032189369202,
0.32011786103248596,
0.0025905603542923927,
0.144000843167305,
-0.07890066504478455,
0.015124036930501461,
0.3125556707382202,
0.6923715472221375,
-0.9090631604194641,
-0.3265802562236786,
0.18898603320121765,
-0.056794408708810806,
0.2612311542034149,
0.7949299216270447,
-0.5097171068191528,
0.5638163685798645,
0.611253023147583,
0.9325690865516663,
0.2590714991092682,
0.05058896914124489,
0.6593727469444275,
-0.6517446637153625,
0.011508875526487827,
0.1838870346546173,
0.3948841392993927,
0.3103843033313751,
-0.2434566617012024,
0.1367272287607193,
0.5837448835372925,
-0.2397267371416092,
-0.4180937111377716,
0.2805042564868927,
-0.9234967827796936,
-0.28980740904808044,
0.9639812111854553,
-0.18871396780014038,
-0.1539473682641983,
-0.32280081510543823,
-0.230588898062706,
0.5179858207702637,
-0.06272507458925247,
1.184929370880127,
0.8935935497283936,
-0.20600400865077972,
-0.09865342080593109,
-0.5596296191215515,
0.30187228322029114,
0.3562025725841522,
-0.8132839798927307,
-0.11423192918300629,
0.12146462500095367,
0.28158465027809143,
0.44192925095558167,
0.3632313013076782,
-0.5668929815292358,
0.01579480618238449,
-0.14850321412086487,
0.31612497568130493,
-0.07528777420520782,
-0.23733344674110413,
-0.26855048537254333,
0.40905478596687317,
0.0700521171092987,
-0.560070276260376
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14255v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14255v1
|
ERD: A Framework for Improving LLM Reasoning for Cognitive Distortion Classification
| 2024-03-21T09:28:38 | 2024-03-21T09:28:38 |
Sehee Lim, Yejin Kim, Chi-Hyun Choi, Jy-yong Sohn, Byung-Hoon Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Improving the accessibility of psychotherapy with the aid of Large Language
Models (LLMs) is garnering a significant attention in recent years. Recognizing
cognitive distortions from the interviewee's utterances can be an essential
part of psychotherapy, especially for cognitive behavioral therapy. In this
paper, we propose ERD, which improves LLM-based cognitive distortion
classification performance with the aid of additional modules of (1) extracting
the parts related to cognitive distortion, and (2) debating the reasoning steps
by multiple agents. Our experimental results on a public dataset show that ERD
improves the multi-class F1 score as well as binary specificity score.
Regarding the latter score, it turns out that our method is effective in
debiasing the baseline method which has high false positive rate, especially
when the summary of multi-agent debate is provided to LLMs.
|
[
-0.6042280793190002,
-1.1161457300186157,
0.7049859166145325,
0.15811866521835327,
-0.1202453225851059,
-0.029789447784423828,
-0.5679997205734253,
-0.5160613059997559,
0.16294899582862854,
0.6241223216056824,
-0.31204953789711,
-0.6559377908706665,
-0.7518063187599182,
-0.009430776350200176,
-0.2690609097480774,
0.8297978639602661,
-0.03944114223122597,
0.5980935096740723,
0.08043365925550461,
-0.08251625299453735,
-0.6326364874839783,
-0.5100674033164978,
-0.877941906452179,
-0.44108423590660095,
0.359109103679657,
0.5137273073196411,
0.5623173117637634,
0.17455324530601501,
0.6091524362564087,
0.31350821256637573,
-0.16889795660972595,
0.28335273265838623,
-0.24964627623558044,
0.35655444860458374,
-0.3175457715988159,
-0.6943628191947937,
-0.8434513211250305,
-0.11766476184129715,
0.36193397641181946,
0.43726402521133423,
-0.7081372737884521,
-0.19275718927383423,
0.1557847559452057,
0.33880290389060974,
-0.3480971157550812,
0.013109629973769188,
-0.5544365048408508,
0.1091986894607544,
-0.14369149506092072,
-0.12387154251337051,
-0.748202919960022,
-0.12310831248760223,
0.08935247361660004,
-0.5090792775154114,
0.4609764814376831,
-0.07542301714420319,
0.5310677886009216,
0.4909636676311493,
-0.47334691882133484,
-0.04861811175942421,
-0.8134991526603699,
0.5169079899787903,
-0.5304815173149109,
0.5378153920173645,
0.39357033371925354,
0.3183363378047943,
-0.18781490623950958,
-0.4785259962081909,
-0.4042695164680481,
0.02340414561331272,
0.06728816032409668,
0.11036260426044464,
0.18054507672786713,
0.5172926783561707,
0.4710066616535187,
0.23100534081459045,
-0.22737839818000793,
-0.09191618114709854,
-0.12279011309146881,
-0.2998933792114258,
0.5377305746078491,
0.27939558029174805,
0.07392662763595581,
0.09839222580194473,
-0.07576209306716919,
0.0004615869838744402,
-0.40876877307891846,
-0.42368972301483154,
0.04238389804959297,
0.24050018191337585,
0.1780942976474762,
0.44078847765922546,
-0.007367648649960756,
0.5994792580604553,
0.1868128925561905,
-0.21495965123176575,
0.09351146221160889,
0.04278532788157463,
-0.4571414887905121,
0.2734615206718445,
0.20982782542705536,
0.4585892856121063,
0.13005562126636505,
0.012562054209411144,
0.1082075834274292,
0.15789908170700073,
0.48018497228622437,
-0.46282055974006653,
-0.12191333621740341,
0.17648319900035858,
-0.2938067317008972,
-0.10968887060880661,
-0.06767474859952927,
-0.7496104836463928,
-0.33907178044319153,
-0.37268346548080444,
0.06933297961950302,
-0.67153000831604,
-0.24793942272663116,
0.47699102759361267,
-0.216475710272789,
0.1451684981584549,
0.8889987468719482,
-0.6196361184120178,
0.4329262673854828,
0.5686303973197937,
0.6360968351364136,
-0.14885109663009644,
-0.09012392908334732,
-0.012467311695218086,
0.36729785799980164,
-0.35511818528175354,
1.176851511001587,
-0.7446901202201843,
-0.3592956066131592,
-0.13941584527492523,
-0.21973629295825958,
0.027830099686980247,
-0.629913866519928,
0.7407399415969849,
-0.4513224959373474,
0.344340443611145,
-0.22569943964481354,
-0.482050359249115,
-0.40429234504699707,
0.5760067105293274,
-0.4121197760105133,
0.922527015209198,
0.13826756179332733,
-0.719410240650177,
0.48879486322402954,
-0.7473182082176208,
-0.29549339413642883,
-0.10399124771356583,
-0.2802741527557373,
-0.22902484238147736,
0.09359698742628098,
0.41934871673583984,
0.14150956273078918,
-0.40697214007377625,
0.15814028680324554,
-0.5688089728355408,
-0.1305817812681198,
0.351399302482605,
-0.5674552917480469,
0.5788577198982239,
0.4373082220554352,
-0.24341991543769836,
0.01128203235566616,
-0.6626268625259399,
0.3353711664676666,
-0.17590020596981049,
-0.6283332705497742,
-0.43200913071632385,
-0.1484231799840927,
0.03534087538719177,
0.043052107095718384,
-0.38711655139923096,
-0.40664786100387573,
0.32986629009246826,
-0.361356645822525,
0.18996746838092804,
1.0521403551101685,
0.3009856045246124,
0.10705297440290451,
-0.3674735724925995,
0.5598540306091309,
0.1702456772327423,
0.09832185506820679,
0.23230154812335968,
-0.4477945566177368,
-0.9537473917007446,
-0.7043812870979309,
0.22846142947673798,
0.35591116547584534,
-0.5757839679718018,
0.44157570600509644,
-0.048581112176179886,
-0.21647027134895325,
-0.5482831597328186,
-0.022410955280065536,
0.4325260818004608,
0.25362300872802734,
0.45395171642303467,
-0.49919548630714417,
-0.43837347626686096,
-0.69800865650177,
-0.3671587109565735,
-0.20127244293689728,
0.051084186881780624,
0.2535219192504883,
0.29769593477249146,
-0.2370159924030304,
0.6320887804031372,
-0.7133435606956482,
-0.7068080902099609,
-0.18554691970348358,
0.03258070722222328,
-0.20877833664417267,
0.3502406179904938,
0.2435874193906784,
-0.3374236226081848,
-0.33915719389915466,
-0.2763075828552246,
-0.5885661244392395,
-0.052575964480638504,
-0.13823406398296356,
-0.5370333194732666,
0.3328624665737152,
0.4834323823451996,
-0.5502552390098572,
0.5391421318054199,
-0.1415928155183792,
-0.7206428050994873,
0.44894737005233765,
-0.23878416419029236,
0.33121126890182495,
-0.5932949781417847,
-0.5110775232315063,
-0.2214188277721405,
-0.3624555468559265,
-0.29563888907432556,
0.049347635358572006,
-0.21468432247638702,
0.24249090254306793,
-0.20014946162700653,
0.01483217440545559,
-0.3352830708026886,
0.13808569312095642,
-0.036432456225156784,
0.47316116094589233,
-0.19714020192623138,
0.5355347990989685,
0.23036396503448486,
0.2259867638349533,
0.5777159333229065,
-0.5928831696510315,
0.4101495146751404,
0.258285254240036,
-0.2788602411746979,
1.2246125936508179,
-0.18046021461486816,
0.5476377010345459,
-0.19128799438476562,
0.4913221299648285,
-0.9032469391822815,
-0.09440519660711288,
0.342536598443985,
-0.3484516441822052,
0.5114173293113708,
0.019152192398905754,
-0.1780344694852829,
0.024165600538253784,
-0.26610758900642395,
0.5560026168823242,
0.023763561621308327,
-0.45770323276519775,
0.7738994359970093,
0.25124189257621765,
0.07554148882627487,
-0.5559154152870178,
-0.741740882396698,
0.021349020302295685,
-0.40372100472450256,
-0.6637988686561584,
0.4745173752307892,
-0.3164726495742798,
-0.43307530879974365,
0.09440550208091736,
-0.10542236268520355,
0.019787006080150604,
-0.08005531132221222,
0.09417019039392471,
0.07060257345438004,
-0.25923240184783936,
0.35287103056907654,
-0.004415564239025116,
-0.2450452744960785,
0.10408616065979004,
-0.17150944471359253,
0.5225723385810852,
-0.08729295432567596,
-0.6892971396446228,
-0.18561489880084991,
0.1300012618303299,
0.4779629707336426,
0.017457081004977226,
0.5510548949241638,
0.5206034183502197,
-0.46412450075149536,
-0.631533145904541,
-0.755916178226471,
-0.21767374873161316,
-0.3906978666782379,
0.6384407877922058,
-0.482776403427124,
-0.5859766006469727,
0.27127495408058167,
-0.027034563943743706,
-0.11564760655164719,
0.024385476484894753,
0.7253903746604919,
0.2500477731227875,
1.146241545677185,
0.42234617471694946,
0.019882850348949432,
0.6053800582885742,
-0.3486473560333252,
-0.061854373663663864,
-1.1708000898361206,
-0.18229259550571442,
-0.49523529410362244,
-0.3354564607143402,
-0.04481649026274681,
-0.7506197690963745,
0.38381463289260864,
0.03709428757429123,
-0.47782647609710693,
-0.24463891983032227,
-0.7171980142593384,
0.4063850939273834,
0.20778906345367432,
0.5502346158027649,
0.6212823390960693,
0.16976718604564667,
-0.297500342130661,
-0.2520931661128998,
-0.5238142609596252,
-0.6306541562080383,
1.338923454284668,
0.41285240650177,
0.8894827365875244,
0.5057235360145569,
0.5862816572189331,
0.4686743915081024,
0.8561634421348572,
-0.7607161402702332,
0.6509605050086975,
0.39033186435699463,
-1.0688730478286743,
-0.28601014614105225,
-0.26502540707588196,
-0.6640896201133728,
0.7918682098388672,
-0.12346106767654419,
-0.7633172869682312,
0.20194967091083527,
-0.032693423330783844,
-0.23623624444007874,
0.1922040432691574,
-0.5660248398780823,
0.6400335431098938,
-0.4378947913646698,
-0.12863823771476746,
-0.9359736442565918,
-0.17739178240299225,
0.5415796637535095,
-0.02963794209063053,
0.4532912075519562,
0.020546216517686844,
0.02590150013566017,
0.8622807264328003,
-0.505117654800415,
0.6330221891403198,
-0.39076530933380127,
-0.1551489233970642,
0.2591516077518463,
0.1882670521736145,
0.28355634212493896,
0.3638722896575928,
-0.06207331269979477,
-0.09028837084770203,
0.052730631083250046,
-0.27749472856521606,
-0.8845057487487793,
0.5599818229675293,
-0.7286553382873535,
-0.7225919961929321,
-0.4118655025959015,
-0.41511058807373047,
-0.43547821044921875,
0.02568008191883564,
0.10199020802974701,
0.36027947068214417,
-0.3989098072052002,
-0.09335179626941681,
0.7234201431274414,
-0.2778722941875458,
-0.1735726147890091,
0.8342442512512207,
-0.3605908453464508,
-0.6252509951591492,
0.395376056432724,
0.07676403969526291,
0.3824683725833893,
0.15640851855278015,
-0.16966503858566284,
-0.11310571432113647,
-0.6234484910964966,
0.07295035570859909,
0.29745838046073914,
-1.1476879119873047,
-0.3146912157535553,
-0.2923301160335541,
0.07042823731899261,
-0.5611546635627747,
-0.019623110070824623,
-0.37142422795295715,
-0.4975545406341553,
0.14786267280578613,
-0.6153770685195923,
0.11453836411237717,
0.6694953441619873,
-0.0963941141963005,
0.09563061594963074,
-0.17803196609020233,
0.4314304292201996,
0.028278864920139313,
0.47351112961769104,
0.14563623070716858,
-0.7151771187782288,
-0.09552567452192307,
0.024558084085583687,
-0.7958546876907349,
-0.8901776075363159,
0.16176964342594147,
0.0019243742572143674,
0.6529843211174011,
0.7734473943710327,
0.2836892008781433,
0.9345740079879761,
-0.13496033847332,
0.4442616403102875,
0.23410558700561523,
-0.8155699968338013,
0.47291433811187744,
0.21918067336082458,
-0.2764851450920105,
0.18109609186649323,
0.08477531373500824,
-0.6487399339675903,
-0.81703120470047,
-0.7060374021530151,
-0.7682546377182007,
1.1715537309646606,
0.008190523833036423,
-0.24387545883655548,
-0.3111768960952759,
0.41611379384994507,
-0.22214357554912567,
-0.17106737196445465,
-0.7592447996139526,
-0.38767361640930176,
0.011829066090285778,
-0.4476584494113922,
0.08834219723939896,
-0.2796112596988678,
-0.4791095554828644,
-0.3638803958892822,
1.054441213607788,
0.023083196952939034,
0.5850778222084045,
0.8192527890205383,
-0.26245856285095215,
-0.21163368225097656,
0.3773431181907654,
0.4669939875602722,
0.39923095703125,
-0.3049670457839966,
0.4215058982372284,
0.5909936428070068,
-0.4720522165298462,
0.2633160948753357,
-0.19205768406391144,
0.16825143992900848,
-0.26969054341316223,
0.5481129288673401,
0.5308617949485779,
-0.15240894258022308,
-0.6373544931411743,
0.2622540593147278,
-0.3605501651763916,
-0.17565356194972992,
-0.42180898785591125,
0.24355502426624298,
-0.10536371171474457,
0.6253385543823242,
-0.06089538335800171,
0.23295968770980835,
0.04908836632966995,
-0.5301439166069031,
0.16734513640403748,
0.3395906090736389,
-0.5841450095176697,
-0.02944902889430523,
0.43232715129852295,
0.11133100837469101,
-0.5004091262817383,
0.8611875176429749,
-0.021481292322278023,
-0.5542929172515869,
0.31053465604782104,
0.6852335333824158,
0.7378987073898315,
-0.28331610560417175,
0.010228453204035759,
0.153293639421463,
0.3364317715167999,
-0.14316657185554504,
0.19569703936576843,
-0.015172027051448822,
-1.1759803295135498,
-0.12253286689519882,
-0.20964017510414124,
-0.25011590123176575,
-0.019704069942235947,
-0.7175542712211609,
0.5130147933959961,
-0.6703972220420837,
-0.5542439222335815,
-0.1569051891565323,
-0.2088606208562851,
-0.49500134587287903,
-0.056576985865831375,
0.3390013873577118,
0.9095339179039001,
-0.40460526943206787,
0.8351138234138489,
0.8738637566566467,
-0.4813547730445862,
-0.727511465549469,
-0.1342369019985199,
0.25071981549263,
-0.6327096223831177,
0.5599642395973206,
-0.18937334418296814,
-0.2787669897079468,
-0.1569172739982605,
-0.366250216960907,
-0.6492319107055664,
1.0214122533798218,
0.6705270409584045,
-0.36397260427474976,
-0.016581736505031586,
-0.037175897508859634,
0.5769066214561462,
-0.5423733592033386,
0.8569608926773071,
0.6711881756782532,
0.710766613483429,
-0.013796268962323666,
-0.8404216766357422,
0.3318397104740143,
0.11473142355680466,
-0.16792921721935272,
0.09905266016721725,
-0.469608873128891,
0.28106236457824707,
-0.4981744885444641,
-0.24216003715991974,
-0.13988053798675537,
0.3275010287761688,
0.14965111017227173,
0.3331868052482605,
0.5198731422424316,
0.7883051633834839,
1.0311081409454346,
-0.12810243666172028,
0.8027730584144592,
-0.13127033412456512,
0.5198483467102051,
1.1146222352981567,
-0.11722305417060852,
0.6930015683174133,
0.2521224915981293,
-0.4545580744743347,
0.5624223947525024,
0.3755325675010681,
0.15627513825893402,
0.35099825263023376,
0.20207634568214417,
-0.23106245696544647,
-0.5575962066650391,
0.1623276025056839,
-0.34981590509414673,
0.1449933797121048,
0.6495226621627808,
-0.32279255986213684,
-0.17003630101680756,
0.15951961278915405,
0.016075417399406433,
0.18258754909038544,
-0.11226243525743484,
0.7121952176094055,
0.3164779245853424,
-0.6536315083503723,
0.716461181640625,
0.4470246136188507,
0.5940347909927368,
-0.36161595582962036,
0.000306644884403795,
-0.193147674202919,
0.7692055106163025,
-0.503883421421051,
-0.5345513820648193,
0.500444233417511,
-0.18587760627269745,
-0.07479099184274673,
-0.19443656504154205,
0.4676041901111603,
-0.39198970794677734,
-0.2602313160896301,
0.4449564814567566,
0.29967421293258667,
0.3103373944759369,
-0.17104293406009674,
-0.8249951601028442,
-0.011394807137548923,
0.08606882393360138,
-0.30814415216445923,
0.2606334388256073,
0.6903903484344482,
-0.04303658753633499,
0.7707438468933105,
0.3201090693473816,
0.1754404902458191,
-0.0935315415263176,
0.2416553646326065,
0.6518194675445557,
-0.9959413409233093,
-0.24210461974143982,
-0.8293030858039856,
0.02722644805908203,
-0.06816580146551132,
-0.22378461062908173,
0.5905330181121826,
0.37613895535469055,
0.8736557960510254,
0.11367975175380707,
0.5733481645584106,
-0.2116369605064392,
0.5939180254936218,
-0.6081550717353821,
0.2002914994955063,
-0.20206688344478607,
0.8245875239372253,
-0.5526432991027832,
-0.8731213808059692,
-0.5182093381881714,
1.1664966344833374,
-0.45747992396354675,
0.2697499990463257,
1.1167731285095215,
0.9664784669876099,
0.08830046653747559,
0.1628059595823288,
0.16901393234729767,
0.5615712404251099,
0.751956582069397,
0.7665791511535645,
1.0798646211624146,
-0.1500280648469925,
0.6913968324661255,
-0.052445992827415466,
-0.20097985863685608,
0.031182236969470978,
-0.5266683101654053,
-0.7909141182899475,
-0.2622404098510742,
-0.6199396252632141,
-0.6480355262756348,
0.044805049896240234,
1.182310700416565,
0.7406406402587891,
-0.5247964262962341,
-0.14162002503871918,
-0.04238099232316017,
0.525469958782196,
-0.5233316421508789,
-0.3037702441215515,
0.20287558436393738,
-0.4326874911785126,
-0.5317701697349548,
-0.05218000337481499,
0.1977168768644333,
-0.2429833710193634,
-0.12202557921409607,
-0.49771565198898315,
0.04009603336453438,
0.24400819838047028,
0.5086302757263184,
-0.3414655923843384,
-0.8698722720146179,
-0.6329798102378845,
-0.5167554616928101,
0.12867994606494904,
0.26633894443511963,
0.9825652837753296,
-0.6904206871986389,
0.32535597681999207,
0.11421660333871841,
0.17052024602890015,
0.5598397850990295,
0.059984005987644196,
0.597745954990387,
-0.39160773158073425,
0.09197712689638138,
0.17133359611034393,
0.3662661015987396,
0.10072269290685654,
-0.30410441756248474,
0.6015055775642395,
0.3361513018608093,
-0.4955807030200958,
-0.9530724883079529,
0.35651063919067383,
-1.0087052583694458,
-0.5347050428390503,
1.091695785522461,
-0.29897040128707886,
0.04818057641386986,
-0.6295587420463562,
-0.7900029420852661,
0.14663203060626984,
-0.4455156922340393,
0.9648789167404175,
0.9791151881217957,
-0.4781997799873352,
-0.06209399551153183,
-0.29077622294425964,
0.4090297818183899,
0.4594644606113434,
-0.6638016700744629,
0.35880306363105774,
0.7436292767524719,
0.5183618068695068,
0.21425645053386688,
1.010231852531433,
-0.5315015912055969,
-0.0013856410514563322,
-0.07967260479927063,
0.16747957468032837,
-0.06582866609096527,
-0.2409197986125946,
-0.17981478571891785,
0.038666848093271255,
0.612898588180542,
0.25992682576179504
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14253v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14253v2
|
K-Act2Emo: Korean Commonsense Knowledge Graph for Indirect Emotional Expression
| 2024-03-21T09:26:04 | 2024-03-23T15:53:50 |
Kyuhee Kim, Surin Lee, Sangah Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In many literary texts, emotions are indirectly conveyed through descriptions
of actions, facial expressions, and appearances, necessitating emotion
inference for narrative understanding. In this paper, we introduce K-Act2Emo, a
Korean commonsense knowledge graph (CSKG) comprising 1,900 indirect emotional
expressions and the emotions inferable from them. We categorize reasoning types
into inferences in positive situations, inferences in negative situations, and
inferences when expressions do not serve as emotional cues. Unlike existing
CSKGs, K-Act2Emo specializes in emotional contexts, and experimental results
validate its effectiveness for training emotion inference models.
Significantly, the BART-based knowledge model fine-tuned with K-Act2Emo
outperforms various existing Korean large language models, achieving
performance levels comparable to GPT-4 Turbo.
|
[
0.019380243495106697,
-0.5813773274421692,
0.6599767804145813,
0.46503451466560364,
-0.22388328611850739,
-0.2345053106546402,
0.026578692719340324,
-0.46747612953186035,
0.0434817336499691,
0.600559413433075,
-0.6358668804168701,
-0.44109460711479187,
-0.4731053411960602,
0.11695457994937897,
0.34525758028030396,
0.6345669627189636,
-0.26976466178894043,
0.29500752687454224,
-0.21711888909339905,
-0.29355067014694214,
-0.3657856285572052,
-0.056076738983392715,
-0.7651170492172241,
-0.5704548358917236,
0.5500879287719727,
0.5304327011108398,
0.6465244889259338,
0.30168119072914124,
0.1384132206439972,
0.3743143677711487,
0.23129479587078094,
0.03805694356560707,
-0.47376152873039246,
0.4068968892097473,
-0.1250130534172058,
-0.7402925491333008,
-0.35172420740127563,
-0.04367130249738693,
0.25920572876930237,
0.3783099949359894,
0.057402465492486954,
0.03485419973731041,
-0.4579489231109619,
0.9483821392059326,
-0.7778542637825012,
0.4736308753490448,
-0.22097374498844147,
0.33265992999076843,
0.43007469177246094,
0.28225329518318176,
-0.6425512433052063,
-0.47519996762275696,
0.0682513490319252,
-1.0196408033370972,
-0.3472411036491394,
0.15993648767471313,
0.9500207901000977,
0.3855802118778229,
-1.0653272867202759,
-0.6291723251342773,
-0.2129194587469101,
0.5418095588684082,
-0.51547771692276,
0.31029465794563293,
0.4547843933105469,
0.4971005320549011,
0.011235064826905727,
-0.7406113743782043,
-0.7450007796287537,
-0.21018284559249878,
-0.46467018127441406,
0.7108094096183777,
-0.1791990101337433,
0.328545480966568,
0.10453673452138901,
0.003549163695424795,
-0.5974551439285278,
-0.07889872044324875,
0.010824216529726982,
-0.10505092889070511,
0.7160777449607849,
0.14949524402618408,
0.515953004360199,
-0.6287177205085754,
-0.6544809937477112,
-0.02246255986392498,
-0.5389743447303772,
-0.03732883557677269,
0.5417183637619019,
-0.06293483823537827,
0.0043920353055000305,
0.48206260800361633,
-0.29790180921554565,
0.23023056983947754,
-0.06986165791749954,
0.0035691456869244576,
0.3049921691417694,
0.1335475742816925,
-0.31206196546554565,
0.23888184130191803,
0.5534132122993469,
0.5023576617240906,
0.22654910385608673,
-0.12111467123031616,
0.0694582611322403,
0.2713198959827423,
0.1417495310306549,
-0.8384224772453308,
-0.12477299571037292,
0.2596462666988373,
-0.6111913919448853,
-0.39022061228752136,
-0.19988177716732025,
-0.9518905878067017,
-0.5748056173324585,
-0.5259129405021667,
0.3905533254146576,
-0.3471032679080963,
-0.6269950866699219,
-0.21390898525714874,
-0.46507528424263,
-0.047543346881866455,
0.4329012632369995,
-0.056980472058057785,
0.21397282183170319,
0.3313741087913513,
0.5804250836372375,
-0.008364113979041576,
-0.08174024522304535,
-0.24294644594192505,
0.09120819717645645,
-0.5001354813575745,
0.6097224354743958,
-0.7323904633522034,
-0.13673464953899384,
-0.0010177531512454152,
0.22265683114528656,
-0.25552427768707275,
-0.37200728058815,
0.9980169534683228,
-0.6788413524627686,
0.07837218046188354,
-0.41470909118652344,
-0.8177210092544556,
-0.6348985433578491,
0.015472895465791225,
-0.6562509536743164,
1.2648898363113403,
0.4274182915687561,
-0.2859194278717041,
0.01280335895717144,
-0.7929235696792603,
-0.35676026344299316,
-0.009230055846273899,
0.2517193853855133,
0.05621246248483658,
0.16508112847805023,
-0.06331230700016022,
0.44781190156936646,
-0.0498841255903244,
0.04184109717607498,
-0.6415054798126221,
-0.004226819146424532,
-0.04949334263801575,
0.25335636734962463,
0.604866087436676,
0.6564009785652161,
-0.27108368277549744,
-0.11009249091148376,
-0.6573055982589722,
0.14816217124462128,
0.32595229148864746,
0.13139653205871582,
-0.8079164624214172,
-0.2799758017063141,
-0.2022337168455124,
0.5694411396980286,
0.09834754467010498,
-0.4433090090751648,
0.03523131087422371,
-0.1553143709897995,
0.27315232157707214,
0.5578064322471619,
0.2039932906627655,
0.5767295360565186,
0.18974341452121735,
0.7775638699531555,
0.09839034825563431,
-0.19366224110126495,
-0.2124115377664566,
-0.4162708818912506,
-0.6439793705940247,
-0.2397569864988327,
-0.0998416319489479,
0.6022104024887085,
-1.0379536151885986,
0.15383315086364746,
-0.025465061888098717,
-0.7490413784980774,
-0.5426966547966003,
-0.20055770874023438,
0.720675528049469,
1.057372808456421,
0.08786012977361679,
0.43371886014938354,
-0.4722966253757477,
-0.9364234209060669,
-0.4938734769821167,
-0.10868246853351593,
0.20028112828731537,
0.868388831615448,
0.49341750144958496,
-0.12204649299383163,
0.518351674079895,
-0.6510607600212097,
0.22352057695388794,
-0.185968279838562,
0.6580915451049805,
-0.2683107256889343,
0.09865471720695496,
0.5069313645362854,
-0.7198389768600464,
-0.8335980176925659,
0.26193967461586,
-0.7867377996444702,
-0.5686820149421692,
-0.05675622075796127,
-0.5130088925361633,
0.35267478227615356,
0.6406227946281433,
-0.6919692158699036,
0.12300167977809906,
0.4909454584121704,
-0.6679651737213135,
0.5317836403846741,
0.10295004397630692,
0.5197797417640686,
-0.999162495136261,
0.10815531015396118,
0.0030668764375150204,
-0.3375566899776459,
-0.7447163462638855,
0.15343496203422546,
0.22202016413211823,
-0.2874496877193451,
-0.4108090102672577,
1.1354299783706665,
-0.3701944649219513,
-0.09277181327342987,
-0.31346696615219116,
0.3012782633304596,
0.11485922336578369,
0.7810950875282288,
0.34224554896354675,
0.38516122102737427,
0.2637731730937958,
-0.42394232749938965,
0.34671011567115784,
0.28893381357192993,
-0.14576540887355804,
0.8282277584075928,
-0.3465701937675476,
0.24712106585502625,
-0.1702207773923874,
0.5147472023963928,
-1.2723039388656616,
-0.592576801776886,
0.13782191276550293,
-0.3879268765449524,
0.3250291347503662,
-0.4754168689250946,
-0.3703311085700989,
-0.5708529949188232,
-0.05635383352637291,
0.2507995069026947,
0.4909687042236328,
-0.6324996948242188,
0.7487280964851379,
0.14912107586860657,
-0.3326232135295868,
-0.6949995160102844,
-0.36527395248413086,
-0.07245726883411407,
-0.2534788250923157,
-0.7136948108673096,
-0.15469522774219513,
0.35033056139945984,
-0.15985165536403656,
0.19528187811374664,
-0.09050468355417252,
-0.21119920909404755,
-0.14626115560531616,
0.48306238651275635,
0.1420421600341797,
-0.1763710081577301,
0.4328729212284088,
0.5809202194213867,
-0.08024241775274277,
0.20934614539146423,
0.3470693528652191,
0.2783156633377075,
-0.18308857083320618,
-0.27086859941482544,
-0.38851141929626465,
0.14132991433143616,
0.4717983603477478,
0.3581109941005707,
0.24444957077503204,
0.6122166514396667,
-0.3146745264530182,
-0.39454224705696106,
-0.23915374279022217,
-0.04735931381583214,
-0.4714241921901703,
0.6324949264526367,
-0.3824107348918915,
-0.8972973227500916,
0.5448675155639648,
-0.8633757829666138,
-0.572828471660614,
0.44638776779174805,
0.4476284682750702,
-0.25443214178085327,
1.119766116142273,
-0.1518068164587021,
0.22391963005065918,
0.20984072983264923,
0.14281727373600006,
0.34527161717414856,
-0.7950865626335144,
-0.261671245098114,
-0.3779035210609436,
-0.5373021960258484,
-0.41504889726638794,
-0.3801307678222656,
0.04529910534620285,
0.34877875447273254,
-0.5705252885818481,
0.21167244017124176,
-0.20141780376434326,
0.6306572556495667,
0.3606310784816742,
0.05294471234083176,
-0.08869754523038864,
-0.3697127401828766,
0.12825748324394226,
-0.04740256816148758,
-0.6574072241783142,
-0.580111026763916,
0.8451705574989319,
0.29091399908065796,
0.43088674545288086,
0.0638187825679779,
0.39164265990257263,
0.42036715149879456,
0.6045013070106506,
-0.9257078766822815,
0.6254609227180481,
0.05461416766047478,
-0.792504072189331,
-0.17639929056167603,
-0.5252246856689453,
-0.785759687423706,
0.17387787997722626,
0.08058812469244003,
-0.8368591070175171,
0.2472718358039856,
0.19798076152801514,
0.048824284225702286,
-0.11187954246997833,
-1.3477121591567993,
1.1166000366210938,
-0.0678056925535202,
-0.08222712576389313,
-0.2775144875049591,
-0.7822940945625305,
0.6789090633392334,
0.44713589549064636,
0.08070535957813263,
-0.19033797085285187,
-0.23409713804721832,
0.3986567556858063,
-0.5318187475204468,
0.8446968793869019,
-0.5418956279754639,
0.2404622882604599,
0.7829246520996094,
0.45074549317359924,
0.959218442440033,
-0.10879071056842804,
-0.03828677162528038,
-0.00890890322625637,
-0.24881088733673096,
-0.3129803538322449,
-0.9035801291465759,
0.6839430928230286,
-0.7801182270050049,
0.017594225704669952,
0.010571710765361786,
-0.5739957690238953,
-0.42262691259384155,
0.23282264173030853,
0.016882754862308502,
0.034425586462020874,
-0.16602376103401184,
-0.025275923311710358,
0.33029308915138245,
-0.4093615412712097,
0.2846347391605377,
0.5059085488319397,
-0.10344789177179337,
-0.7627570629119873,
0.9584196209907532,
-0.1472349464893341,
0.48002851009368896,
0.2214137315750122,
0.3261735439300537,
-0.5614435076713562,
0.18402469158172607,
-0.33565086126327515,
0.2652447819709778,
-0.9489548206329346,
-0.3411530554294586,
-0.5919159054756165,
0.1347995102405548,
-0.22973762452602386,
-0.5165534019470215,
-0.49495741724967957,
-0.7412840127944946,
0.05884852260351181,
-0.46099165081977844,
0.39609888195991516,
0.6932731866836548,
-0.10716184973716736,
0.4388144016265869,
-0.5528594255447388,
0.46833139657974243,
0.344146192073822,
0.35820385813713074,
0.1315588802099228,
-0.3860749900341034,
-0.030210327357053757,
-0.20505355298519135,
-0.21869918704032898,
-1.100258231163025,
0.42635583877563477,
0.03525377810001373,
0.026371000334620476,
0.7828273177146912,
0.2778608500957489,
0.5436166524887085,
-0.3510309159755707,
0.7453315258026123,
0.2854946553707123,
-0.8921001553535461,
0.4815191626548767,
-0.6279736161231995,
0.03509968891739845,
0.3819139301776886,
0.6819635629653931,
-0.8647006154060364,
-0.2176581621170044,
-0.7687046527862549,
-0.6521504521369934,
1.088481068611145,
0.19437667727470398,
0.24369081854820251,
-0.20439019799232483,
0.4433266520500183,
0.16705530881881714,
0.26061931252479553,
-0.7527480721473694,
-0.383015900850296,
-0.39467141032218933,
-0.5193161368370056,
0.4755608141422272,
-0.3845897316932678,
-0.1954226791858673,
-0.02091331221163273,
0.8930468559265137,
-0.25786489248275757,
0.4859886169433594,
0.2799892723560333,
-0.27792873978614807,
-0.2674492299556732,
0.02197025902569294,
0.6130073070526123,
-0.0037052708212286234,
-0.11448007076978683,
0.2950625419616699,
0.20856235921382904,
-0.4529450237751007,
0.13995027542114258,
-0.04215831309556961,
0.13719604909420013,
-0.030950656160712242,
0.3348555266857147,
1.0835332870483398,
0.29590871930122375,
-0.8432157039642334,
0.5560710430145264,
0.3109714388847351,
-0.3342781364917755,
0.05158773809671402,
0.03972821682691574,
0.49740535020828247,
0.4811173379421234,
-0.08655191957950592,
-0.09245429933071136,
0.31987714767456055,
-0.509459376335144,
-0.13242478668689728,
0.013303746469318867,
-0.5775142908096313,
-0.3521125018596649,
0.41042360663414,
0.3833833634853363,
-0.05969388410449028,
0.5657736659049988,
-0.622261643409729,
-0.7842537760734558,
1.0564805269241333,
0.6171281933784485,
0.850150465965271,
-0.4746348559856415,
0.5044718384742737,
0.7318507432937622,
0.11758866161108017,
-0.0998435914516449,
0.546576201915741,
0.129654198884964,
-0.730516254901886,
-0.30238503217697144,
-0.22227630019187927,
-0.46434590220451355,
0.2987424433231354,
-0.564681351184845,
0.2179318517446518,
-0.08656544238328934,
0.14231424033641815,
-0.3147682845592499,
-0.12167711555957794,
-0.5606347918510437,
0.4426928162574768,
0.373996376991272,
0.8102778792381287,
-1.096116542816162,
0.42097604274749756,
0.8527553677558899,
-0.2160750925540924,
-0.960890531539917,
-0.5899741649627686,
0.004612666089087725,
-1.0573668479919434,
1.0342811346054077,
0.1530439853668213,
0.0633314847946167,
-0.1708894670009613,
-0.5552412867546082,
-0.7810081243515015,
1.3313610553741455,
0.38115549087524414,
-0.2934548258781433,
0.3447520136833191,
0.18102151155471802,
0.7171821594238281,
-0.3970738351345062,
0.5538933277130127,
0.24325913190841675,
0.7528369426727295,
0.2554064393043518,
-0.3830554783344269,
0.2623995840549469,
-0.2878842055797577,
-0.16433502733707428,
0.2428729087114334,
-0.9619402885437012,
0.27527186274528503,
0.016187511384487152,
-0.16331741213798523,
-0.09243009239435196,
0.5644037127494812,
0.2810220718383789,
0.9182988405227661,
0.5883156657218933,
0.9685887098312378,
0.8488038182258606,
-0.2458880990743637,
1.0674688816070557,
-0.28378137946128845,
0.27603596448898315,
1.409995675086975,
-0.42591509222984314,
0.5783730149269104,
0.13982541859149933,
-0.12076637893915176,
0.60362708568573,
0.6450591683387756,
0.18721036612987518,
0.5309572815895081,
-0.08026036620140076,
-0.24681849777698517,
-0.35616761445999146,
-0.08186527341604233,
-0.10845700651407242,
0.3543359339237213,
0.32553932070732117,
-0.44884195923805237,
-0.120735302567482,
-0.1286298632621765,
0.598298966884613,
-0.14415065944194794,
-0.49002891778945923,
0.6654136180877686,
0.1412038952112198,
-0.8546611070632935,
0.0003014282847288996,
-0.3725143074989319,
-0.19181078672409058,
-0.6347920894622803,
-0.16489680111408234,
-0.36637455224990845,
-0.2085823267698288,
-0.18053919076919556,
-0.8347988724708557,
0.16657103598117828,
-0.005993380211293697,
0.0418955497443676,
-0.16589659452438354,
1.1462725400924683,
-0.35895535349845886,
-0.3235996663570404,
0.27463197708129883,
0.30797696113586426,
0.3328992426395416,
-0.27527159452438354,
-0.6472137570381165,
-0.5250280499458313,
-0.12779046595096588,
-0.8130560517311096,
0.23142726719379425,
1.194821834564209,
0.03399968519806862,
0.5124076008796692,
0.21714377403259277,
-0.44984379410743713,
-0.10973577201366425,
0.11698810011148453,
0.47536492347717285,
-0.44319990277290344,
-0.3878073990345001,
-0.4273104667663574,
0.6044435501098633,
-0.33988478779792786,
-0.4026581346988678,
0.5815824866294861,
0.4024054706096649,
0.28297412395477295,
-0.25970715284347534,
0.8398703932762146,
0.0021458985283970833,
0.3156810700893402,
-0.253630667924881,
0.6840398907661438,
-0.6511189341545105,
-0.6098891496658325,
-0.47380852699279785,
-0.630635142326355,
0.06559441983699799,
0.42467421293258667,
-0.47249680757522583,
0.03477270528674126,
0.8251638412475586,
0.577791154384613,
0.0966140478849411,
0.27817636728286743,
0.24636584520339966,
0.5203173756599426,
-0.14015139639377594,
0.35822758078575134,
0.8076131343841553,
-0.40400445461273193,
0.4750940501689911,
-0.19729267060756683,
-0.18315932154655457,
-0.3585062325000763,
-1.0777572393417358,
-0.6830046772956848,
-0.4700874090194702,
-0.3431952893733978,
-0.5010598301887512,
-0.22801758348941803,
0.7485106587409973,
0.4541414678096771,
-0.5726553201675415,
0.19527390599250793,
-0.3488427698612213,
0.34870851039886475,
-0.12006908655166626,
-0.33841678500175476,
0.43798917531967163,
-0.5242700576782227,
-0.5905049443244934,
0.2411496341228485,
0.28422534465789795,
-0.30429354310035706,
0.48485106229782104,
-0.568642795085907,
0.13096629083156586,
0.5382683277130127,
0.8337085843086243,
0.29752159118652344,
-0.41677820682525635,
-0.24858155846595764,
-0.03236304968595505,
-0.026726337149739265,
-0.06363942474126816,
0.7553396821022034,
-0.410763680934906,
0.6480184197425842,
0.5109784603118896,
0.5568233728408813,
0.4894874691963196,
0.008890806697309017,
0.39745399355888367,
-0.5947508215904236,
0.03571455180644989,
0.23711778223514557,
0.45220938324928284,
-0.06666459888219833,
-0.5001282691955566,
0.9424337148666382,
0.5941033959388733,
-0.6620763540267944,
-0.8478178381919861,
0.39095383882522583,
-1.1600958108901978,
-0.46609675884246826,
1.5320708751678467,
-0.3180443346500397,
-0.2697789967060089,
0.22651976346969604,
-0.48762252926826477,
0.4711788594722748,
-0.6158145666122437,
0.6441666483879089,
0.9042584896087646,
-0.4347567558288574,
-0.13740824162960052,
-0.7866818308830261,
0.44515612721443176,
0.45547112822532654,
-1.202008843421936,
0.2682585120201111,
0.67831951379776,
-0.11303684860467911,
-0.059589676558971405,
0.4461432099342346,
0.0857582837343216,
0.3653935492038727,
0.33013659715652466,
0.3528236150741577,
-0.044026751071214676,
-0.11563136428594589,
0.0874476358294487,
0.09689246863126755,
-0.4714833199977875,
0.19600874185562134
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14252v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14252v1
|
LayoutLLM: Large Language Model Instruction Tuning for Visually Rich Document Understanding
| 2024-03-21T09:25:24 | 2024-03-21T09:25:24 |
Masato Fujitake
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
This paper proposes LayoutLLM, a more flexible document analysis method for
understanding imaged documents. Visually Rich Document Understanding tasks,
such as document image classification and information extraction, have gained
significant attention due to their importance. Existing methods have been
developed to enhance document comprehension by incorporating pre-training
awareness of images, text, and layout structure. However, these methods require
fine-tuning for each task and dataset, and the models are expensive to train
and operate. To overcome this limitation, we propose a new LayoutLLM that
integrates these with large-scale language models (LLMs). By leveraging the
strengths of existing research in document image understanding and LLMs'
superior language understanding capabilities, the proposed model, fine-tuned
with multimodal instruction datasets, performs an understanding of document
images in a single model. Our experiments demonstrate improvement over the
baseline model in various document analysis tasks.
|
[
-0.35628849267959595,
-0.9310729503631592,
0.5921622514724731,
0.32262304425239563,
-0.41118305921554565,
-0.0405770018696785,
-0.2857779562473297,
-0.29232269525527954,
-0.11563173681497574,
0.883947491645813,
-0.5485817193984985,
-0.7372645139694214,
-0.7678276896476746,
-0.29122641682624817,
-0.1754160374403,
0.563115119934082,
-0.2183103859424591,
0.2559763193130493,
-0.3665989637374878,
-0.08581158518791199,
-0.6942172646522522,
0.10364463925361633,
-0.41576874256134033,
-0.1690589189529419,
0.3144914209842682,
0.43134239315986633,
0.8083381056785583,
0.8953664898872375,
0.6735424399375916,
0.389598548412323,
-0.18080322444438934,
0.49675819277763367,
-0.39733922481536865,
-0.0328785665333271,
-0.1235719621181488,
-0.4028254747390747,
-0.6411943435668945,
0.01859867013990879,
0.8276110291481018,
0.8068310618400574,
0.11949864774942398,
-0.06477052718400955,
0.002508987672626972,
0.5785541534423828,
-0.7008785605430603,
0.3083478510379791,
-0.4975998103618622,
0.13930530846118927,
0.060808807611465454,
-0.4783509373664856,
-0.7533984780311584,
-0.13099758327007294,
0.02825794741511345,
-0.8596198558807373,
0.24529626965522766,
0.23005764186382294,
0.7819849848747253,
0.23574198782444,
-0.2584789991378784,
-0.39153560996055603,
-0.45658743381500244,
0.7932183146476746,
-0.3676016330718994,
0.6472581028938293,
0.32197707891464233,
0.2538962960243225,
0.0023846300318837166,
-0.7236243486404419,
-0.4015049338340759,
-0.041338030248880386,
-0.16784946620464325,
0.29850849509239197,
0.10738899558782578,
0.12789782881736755,
0.23066571354866028,
0.6249545216560364,
-0.709736168384552,
0.3398166298866272,
-0.1958518773317337,
-0.13369537889957428,
0.40400153398513794,
0.15158863365650177,
0.7248992323875427,
-0.12943536043167114,
-0.3609979450702667,
-0.23862865567207336,
-0.23981675505638123,
-0.46328970789909363,
0.14570501446723938,
-0.13188908994197845,
-0.19225941598415375,
0.4135684370994568,
0.22717802226543427,
1.0052855014801025,
-0.21604888141155243,
-0.4035092890262604,
-0.05831318348646164,
-0.14397843182086945,
-0.6895970106124878,
-0.02706906758248806,
0.3976697027683258,
0.3863162398338318,
0.17453832924365997,
-0.04438021034002304,
-0.25532132387161255,
-0.2867653965950012,
0.24422599375247955,
-1.026016116142273,
-0.3483389616012573,
0.01917094923555851,
-0.6689028739929199,
-0.041673481464385986,
-0.09055725485086441,
-0.8904029726982117,
-0.6840080618858337,
-0.5154958963394165,
0.36947983503341675,
-0.8178626298904419,
-0.08510076254606247,
0.3152344226837158,
-0.21101658046245575,
0.5146642923355103,
0.924736499786377,
-0.8145236372947693,
0.051282208412885666,
0.6565449237823486,
0.806723952293396,
-0.21197745203971863,
-0.4001776874065399,
-0.6375847458839417,
0.33592382073402405,
-0.36959922313690186,
0.9769337177276611,
-0.7035925984382629,
-0.5102686882019043,
0.02461293525993824,
0.0379570908844471,
-0.42585015296936035,
-0.42248350381851196,
0.5698127150535583,
-0.6890445947647095,
0.4750310778617859,
0.2609371542930603,
-0.7736999988555908,
-0.1627526730298996,
0.42267662286758423,
-0.8181411027908325,
0.6313104629516602,
0.16030554473400116,
-0.8674408197402954,
0.27955058217048645,
-0.6686497926712036,
-0.4752293527126312,
0.21076881885528564,
-0.20026132464408875,
-0.47578176856040955,
0.15553854405879974,
0.5611830353736877,
0.4730958938598633,
0.021610077470541,
0.00366867333650589,
-0.23321916162967682,
-0.4101203680038452,
-0.015768781304359436,
-0.3781052529811859,
0.6026850938796997,
0.3616997301578522,
0.05281570553779602,
0.2977732717990875,
-0.7925909757614136,
0.13082255423069,
0.19987989962100983,
-0.5419913530349731,
-0.35106202960014343,
-0.2889886796474457,
0.4496588706970215,
-0.10660567134618759,
0.46573859453201294,
-0.1493537724018097,
0.23260469734668732,
-0.3365859091281891,
0.011312723159790039,
0.629191517829895,
-0.17236031591892242,
0.851503849029541,
-0.05474909767508507,
0.6979278922080994,
-0.3391428589820862,
0.06645361334085464,
-0.8885325193405151,
-0.17606031894683838,
-0.7885425686836243,
-0.7156873941421509,
0.22359493374824524,
0.4656729996204376,
-0.4471817910671234,
0.4020051956176758,
-0.26810964941978455,
-0.13208091259002686,
-0.3269615173339844,
0.4112136662006378,
0.603713870048523,
0.36203086376190186,
0.2832428216934204,
-0.2350732684135437,
-0.39042899012565613,
-0.7359640598297119,
-0.22030335664749146,
0.36908507347106934,
0.1462012678384781,
0.3388272225856781,
0.28133928775787354,
-0.32445424795150757,
0.4438195526599884,
-0.6828103065490723,
-0.36048996448516846,
-0.5839857459068298,
0.3705090582370758,
0.026087531819939613,
0.49205633997917175,
0.40166956186294556,
-0.8671852946281433,
-0.5711860060691833,
0.21429048478603363,
-0.6612338423728943,
0.05671180784702301,
-0.22830186784267426,
-0.27244776487350464,
0.10889723151922226,
0.7368807792663574,
-0.5342807769775391,
0.4062039852142334,
0.31529557704925537,
-0.304507851600647,
0.2844037413597107,
-0.5348257422447205,
-0.025166165083646774,
-1.1954231262207031,
-0.29320865869522095,
0.2552192211151123,
-0.11853812634944916,
-0.4113902151584625,
0.41799110174179077,
0.6405980587005615,
-0.43447190523147583,
-0.22738651931285858,
0.810400128364563,
-1.0520015954971313,
-0.3190324902534485,
-0.3962134122848511,
0.1489284336566925,
0.48747459053993225,
0.22283637523651123,
0.2190399169921875,
0.670718789100647,
0.46654677391052246,
-0.06879132241010666,
0.03661410138010979,
0.37432652711868286,
-0.5856512188911438,
0.6513031721115112,
-0.32617250084877014,
0.21875058114528656,
-0.3654727339744568,
0.22772550582885742,
-1.2152360677719116,
-0.5659257769584656,
-0.31398093700408936,
-0.059390515089035034,
0.9054383635520935,
-0.15723437070846558,
-0.5221202969551086,
-0.16534419357776642,
-0.33102965354919434,
0.008490106090903282,
0.20609328150749207,
-0.7698242664337158,
0.910213828086853,
0.22932814061641693,
-0.04433365911245346,
-0.4006604254245758,
-0.3875981271266937,
0.06576951593160629,
-0.27399060130119324,
-1.0575658082962036,
0.4261045753955841,
0.04420926794409752,
-0.298220694065094,
-0.2534635663032532,
-0.09706094861030579,
-0.26349306106567383,
0.17311818897724152,
0.22518302500247955,
0.3714958429336548,
-0.427409291267395,
0.1046425998210907,
0.03869882598519325,
-0.032030925154685974,
-0.1655610054731369,
-0.27310580015182495,
0.5845982432365417,
0.07742985337972641,
-0.316882461309433,
-0.5380105972290039,
0.3647933602333069,
0.6390723586082458,
-0.6092561483383179,
0.727149248123169,
0.8708785176277161,
-0.28593626618385315,
-0.3954390585422516,
-0.5844665765762329,
0.2512686848640442,
-0.4940435290336609,
0.6722535490989685,
-0.3849182426929474,
-0.6953973770141602,
0.30748406052589417,
-0.2589004337787628,
0.09887862950563431,
0.2435941994190216,
0.4350763261318207,
-0.3110336661338806,
0.9857194423675537,
0.8921234607696533,
0.08848536014556885,
0.7922783493995667,
-0.2917580306529999,
-0.10488656908273697,
-0.8313608169555664,
-0.3182934522628784,
-0.5175909399986267,
-0.2774600088596344,
-0.15653379261493683,
-0.7304656505584717,
0.2267415076494217,
0.2007502317428589,
0.08757618814706802,
-0.066276915371418,
-0.3086978495121002,
0.8590936660766602,
0.3363233506679535,
0.09583661705255508,
0.2681461572647095,
0.08839572221040726,
-0.08211210370063782,
-0.04288701340556145,
-0.38106146454811096,
-0.6132411956787109,
0.7523161768913269,
0.39177295565605164,
1.3565305471420288,
-0.0723898708820343,
0.509335994720459,
-0.07427418977022171,
0.1629939079284668,
-0.8717482089996338,
0.43133214116096497,
-0.39581602811813354,
-0.1668740063905716,
-0.2995784282684326,
-0.1930541843175888,
-0.994905412197113,
0.3761388957500458,
-0.06872788816690445,
-0.8461120128631592,
-0.05015447363257408,
0.04758308455348015,
-0.03960615396499634,
0.14043617248535156,
-1.0893216133117676,
1.1448129415512085,
-0.5587748289108276,
-0.30004405975341797,
-0.19416208565235138,
-0.3016413748264313,
0.42766982316970825,
0.047348156571388245,
0.34576454758644104,
0.13838805258274078,
0.14131607115268707,
0.6148453950881958,
-0.3133098781108856,
0.6630227565765381,
-0.12889204919338226,
-0.4296719431877136,
-0.10284440219402313,
0.22134874761104584,
0.5447677373886108,
0.024376288056373596,
-0.18117070198059082,
-0.4349316358566284,
-0.2159949541091919,
-0.4250502586364746,
-0.8131574988365173,
0.8129338026046753,
-0.7603777647018433,
-0.6225306391716003,
0.10696543753147125,
-1.0410922765731812,
-0.12986239790916443,
0.29981040954589844,
0.14355647563934326,
0.6079462766647339,
-0.3020001947879791,
0.295419842004776,
1.2147194147109985,
-0.5700585842132568,
0.287560373544693,
0.37140947580337524,
-0.3256412148475647,
-0.20523741841316223,
0.7137377262115479,
-0.18912212550640106,
-0.0020628038328140974,
0.7073511481285095,
0.0716773271560669,
-0.41978561878204346,
-0.8337588906288147,
-0.43124324083328247,
0.06398744881153107,
-0.9236845374107361,
-0.004404271952807903,
-0.8745779395103455,
-0.17747041583061218,
-0.3381354510784149,
-0.33265116810798645,
-0.1374150812625885,
-0.1869439333677292,
-0.47702956199645996,
0.09519445151090622,
0.12299209833145142,
0.6553283333778381,
0.5018434524536133,
0.6266583800315857,
-0.7379712462425232,
0.5319907665252686,
0.3150486946105957,
0.4438040256500244,
-0.09437297284603119,
-0.8030903935432434,
-0.308248907327652,
-0.48476043343544006,
-0.5251611471176147,
-0.7491629123687744,
0.3694643974304199,
0.311331570148468,
0.6769120097160339,
0.4831911623477936,
-0.43572738766670227,
0.8324588537216187,
-0.47283369302749634,
0.28734275698661804,
0.14003263413906097,
-0.7337763905525208,
0.82453453540802,
-0.41309085488319397,
0.6023077368736267,
0.22115804255008698,
0.19756446778774261,
-0.23693019151687622,
-0.16469158232212067,
-0.4011639356613159,
-0.6342484951019287,
0.806861400604248,
-0.1238025575876236,
0.16023015975952148,
0.4037573039531708,
0.29556742310523987,
0.12446961551904678,
-0.2548012137413025,
-0.5683143138885498,
0.3359657824039459,
-0.23283670842647552,
-0.37031012773513794,
-0.057423725724220276,
-0.2957572937011719,
-0.05900265648961067,
-0.2156277298927307,
0.35187530517578125,
-0.3164634704589844,
-0.034088220447301865,
-0.1396053433418274,
-0.6610194444656372,
-0.04940890148282051,
0.34374064207077026,
0.5138935446739197,
0.8902684450149536,
-0.3095828890800476,
0.23116248846054077,
0.03587529808282852,
-0.5440879464149475,
-0.22793932259082794,
0.23224075138568878,
0.15329425036907196,
-0.1755083054304123,
0.8056169748306274,
1.0787242650985718,
0.3284848928451538,
-0.5541297197341919,
0.4690625071525574,
-0.3537832200527191,
-0.3125096261501312,
0.002907413523644209,
0.3249884247779846,
0.2375938892364502,
0.19210579991340637,
0.11497845500707626,
-0.2538922131061554,
-0.052642349153757095,
-0.4754583239555359,
0.18863044679164886,
0.6482264995574951,
-0.3360036611557007,
0.024566924199461937,
0.5074504017829895,
0.1542193740606308,
-0.3497491180896759,
0.572019636631012,
-0.020685309544205666,
-0.25154146552085876,
0.8218036890029907,
0.7890235781669617,
0.6133089661598206,
-0.02566962130367756,
0.29832929372787476,
0.15186578035354614,
0.2991374731063843,
0.07023471593856812,
0.26117372512817383,
-0.014995230361819267,
-0.6646814346313477,
-0.48680442571640015,
-0.88376384973526,
-0.275775671005249,
0.3938988447189331,
-0.5215401649475098,
0.23640041053295135,
-0.5791565179824829,
0.469669371843338,
0.2505132853984833,
0.13474230468273163,
-0.6045810580253601,
0.4324992299079895,
0.2717288136482239,
1.1869637966156006,
-0.5557938814163208,
0.944634735584259,
0.885321319103241,
-0.08794177323579788,
-0.6793957352638245,
0.13527986407279968,
-0.046839646995067596,
-1.0374399423599243,
0.6465837955474854,
0.4320727288722992,
-0.0727982446551323,
0.011440251022577286,
-0.5653131604194641,
-0.5277601480484009,
1.0056406259536743,
0.4509718120098114,
-0.493112713098526,
0.07231471687555313,
-0.19135217368602753,
0.49518993496894836,
-0.5153986811637878,
0.32903000712394714,
0.4281258285045624,
0.6118902564048767,
0.21052871644496918,
-0.47500181198120117,
-0.10522423684597015,
-0.2696157395839691,
0.29313182830810547,
0.2377384454011917,
-0.4876929819583893,
0.6588266491889954,
-0.20699617266654968,
-0.21052740514278412,
0.22672565281391144,
0.5721669793128967,
0.19696326553821564,
0.30322349071502686,
0.4802928864955902,
0.6384214162826538,
0.8467996120452881,
0.022381190210580826,
1.1935489177703857,
-0.0872049629688263,
0.2085176259279251,
1.3626956939697266,
-0.27794238924980164,
0.438845157623291,
0.30179113149642944,
0.1497499942779541,
0.2593367099761963,
0.7137128114700317,
0.0076317936182022095,
0.39533087611198425,
0.025918804109096527,
0.09178204834461212,
-0.5095375776290894,
0.027468571439385414,
-0.321899950504303,
0.6575044393539429,
0.5912549495697021,
-0.6507623791694641,
-0.4293394386768341,
0.006274268496781588,
-0.13335198163986206,
0.3028915226459503,
-0.4019935429096222,
0.919685959815979,
-0.011943068355321884,
-0.4332338571548462,
0.4706248641014099,
0.2060055434703827,
0.396865576505661,
-0.47367048263549805,
-0.006438052281737328,
-0.343610554933548,
0.17659524083137512,
-0.23685316741466522,
-0.9684156179428101,
0.10816527903079987,
-0.05764031037688255,
-0.285042941570282,
-0.41370663046836853,
0.9828536510467529,
-0.3043157458305359,
-0.7286499738693237,
0.31285491585731506,
0.4796788692474365,
-0.08366482704877853,
-0.0486060231924057,
-0.7394604086875916,
0.31507593393325806,
0.03567856177687645,
-0.14016367495059967,
0.5739507675170898,
0.721599280834198,
-0.1558835357427597,
0.34304532408714294,
0.4492996633052826,
-0.16763187944889069,
0.13402555882930756,
0.38161203265190125,
0.7788646221160889,
-0.505340039730072,
-0.5962981581687927,
-0.8070221543312073,
0.38212767243385315,
-0.3425900638103485,
-0.08164685219526291,
0.6201944351196289,
0.6703099012374878,
0.49003997445106506,
-0.17653605341911316,
0.6029364466667175,
0.3894904553890228,
0.035920802503824234,
-0.9757677316665649,
0.8581250905990601,
-0.7883974313735962,
0.12443604320287704,
-0.3599075675010681,
-1.1005468368530273,
-0.4450203478336334,
0.6362785696983337,
-0.41388821601867676,
-0.15450847148895264,
0.6729980111122131,
0.85785973072052,
-0.49287787079811096,
0.1360330730676651,
0.36625733971595764,
0.08500195294618607,
0.2096165418624878,
0.2646745443344116,
0.9541997909545898,
-0.11979463696479797,
0.506874680519104,
-0.006657659541815519,
-0.3148386776447296,
-0.29410895705223083,
-0.7914016246795654,
-1.2213711738586426,
-0.3191755712032318,
-0.25726595520973206,
-0.018203100189566612,
-0.11914625018835068,
0.3377002775669098,
0.8811414837837219,
-0.42232075333595276,
-0.031181802973151207,
0.11000502109527588,
0.37668517231941223,
0.1667914092540741,
-0.21195904910564423,
0.6169092059135437,
-0.5609837770462036,
-0.8167886734008789,
0.40932080149650574,
0.6794828176498413,
0.07869181782007217,
-0.13649265468120575,
-0.15030167996883392,
-0.11728930473327637,
0.06912975758314133,
0.5501288175582886,
-0.02169635519385338,
-0.5203489661216736,
0.09374585002660751,
-0.11538994312286377,
-0.1857180893421173,
0.34622612595558167,
0.7106536030769348,
-0.07769858092069626,
0.6541668772697449,
0.5978463888168335,
0.8294166922569275,
0.7135123610496521,
0.016895858570933342,
0.40209057927131653,
-0.8580361604690552,
0.38185974955558777,
-0.2552797794342041,
0.6888379454612732,
0.510044515132904,
-0.5654111504554749,
0.3092968761920929,
-0.23127537965774536,
-0.2677849233150482,
-0.5445932745933533,
0.1956230103969574,
-1.1186586618423462,
-0.6013006567955017,
0.988592803478241,
-0.2531032860279083,
-0.435259610414505,
0.17109733819961548,
-0.611081063747406,
0.1510828733444214,
-0.11549653112888336,
0.6397300362586975,
0.6349160075187683,
-0.042825452983379364,
-0.6414754986763,
-0.454839289188385,
0.1073625385761261,
0.4234998822212219,
-1.2213436365127563,
0.023946916684508324,
0.6623610854148865,
-0.029949262738227844,
0.26456353068351746,
0.5461512207984924,
-0.18506550788879395,
0.2723062038421631,
-0.23174984753131866,
-0.1605173945426941,
0.02154231071472168,
-0.49276119470596313,
-0.22289493680000305,
0.2567991018295288,
0.12621904909610748,
-0.1554912030696869
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14243v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14243v1
|
Dermacen Analytica: A Novel Methodology Integrating Multi-Modal Large Language Models with Machine Learning in tele-dermatology
| 2024-03-21T09:02:17 | 2024-03-21T09:02:17 |
Dimitrios P. Panagoulias, Evridiki Tsoureli-Nikita, Maria Virvou, George A. Tsihrintzis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV
|
The rise of Artificial Intelligence creates great promise in the field of
medical discovery, diagnostics and patient management. However, the vast
complexity of all medical domains require a more complex approach that combines
machine learning algorithms, classifiers, segmentation algorithms and, lately,
large language models. In this paper, we describe, implement and assess an
Artificial Intelligence-empowered system and methodology aimed at assisting the
diagnosis process of skin lesions and other skin conditions within the field of
dermatology that aims to holistically address the diagnostic process in this
domain. The workflow integrates large language, transformer-based vision models
and sophisticated machine learning tools. This holistic approach achieves a
nuanced interpretation of dermatological conditions that simulates and
facilitates a dermatologist's workflow. We assess our proposed methodology
through a thorough cross-model validation technique embedded in an evaluation
pipeline that utilizes publicly available medical case studies of skin
conditions and relevant images. To quantitatively score the system performance,
advanced machine learning and natural language processing tools are employed
which focus on similarity comparison and natural language inference.
Additionally, we incorporate a human expert evaluation process based on a
structured checklist to further validate our results. We implemented the
proposed methodology in a system which achieved approximate (weighted) scores
of 0.87 for both contextual understanding and diagnostic accuracy,
demonstrating the efficacy of our approach in enhancing dermatological
analysis. The proposed methodology is expected to prove useful in the
development of next-generation tele-dermatology applications, enhancing remote
consultation capabilities and access to care, especially in underserved areas.
|
[
-0.3360652029514313,
-0.9539648294448853,
0.6164382696151733,
0.07768149673938751,
-0.32656651735305786,
0.329589307308197,
-0.2603224217891693,
-0.9143667817115784,
0.5274567008018494,
0.6872204542160034,
-0.6666110754013062,
-1.0478569269180298,
-0.46885013580322266,
0.06263511627912521,
-0.20271246135234833,
0.4373829960823059,
0.016922304406762123,
0.24823381006717682,
-0.06614324450492859,
-0.2684333026409149,
-0.5069632530212402,
-0.34151849150657654,
-0.6706095933914185,
-0.2846817076206207,
0.327372670173645,
0.500447154045105,
0.7097776532173157,
0.3400311768054962,
0.8757905960083008,
0.3546059727668762,
0.2562255561351776,
0.4519972503185272,
0.35826122760772705,
0.3541734516620636,
-0.11159409582614899,
-0.3180719017982483,
-0.7968025803565979,
-0.041200488805770874,
0.0033622540067881346,
0.815775990486145,
-0.3422081768512726,
0.35219964385032654,
-0.6351293921470642,
0.868704080581665,
-0.3631143271923065,
0.29170989990234375,
-0.3059675693511963,
0.2973383069038391,
-0.1661030501127243,
0.0860312357544899,
-0.19131441414356232,
-0.06153437867760658,
0.22806192934513092,
-0.325959175825119,
0.024151192978024483,
-0.11018170416355133,
0.451692670583725,
0.6277204155921936,
-0.41252994537353516,
0.0269098412245512,
-0.8802165985107422,
0.5642675757408142,
-0.957800567150116,
0.1785917580127716,
0.18655596673488617,
1.1221184730529785,
0.2753656506538391,
-0.5849880576133728,
-0.42204979062080383,
-0.34195950627326965,
0.10745229572057724,
0.10085084289312363,
-0.1236422210931778,
-0.13124369084835052,
0.17944733798503876,
-0.005546679254621267,
-0.3633434474468231,
0.3956899642944336,
-0.20348858833312988,
0.044601790606975555,
0.8571978211402893,
0.20951811969280243,
0.3367765545845032,
0.0005499148392118514,
-0.12439119070768356,
0.10256402939558029,
-0.36099931597709656,
-0.2525216042995453,
-0.11958818882703781,
0.5595861077308655,
-0.05698053911328316,
0.4266161024570465,
-0.2880762815475464,
0.7194584012031555,
0.02305438183248043,
-0.006443108431994915,
0.34849613904953003,
-0.024184726178646088,
-0.32506224513053894,
0.0662759393453598,
0.848516047000885,
0.2582738995552063,
0.24572595953941345,
-0.013607724569737911,
-0.09737894684076309,
0.02699260599911213,
0.4097270667552948,
-0.748868465423584,
0.0800238698720932,
0.4571389853954315,
-0.6023080348968506,
-0.6110783815383911,
0.10595095157623291,
-1.0383657217025757,
-0.6248199343681335,
-0.6828970909118652,
0.1919783055782318,
-0.2730528712272644,
-0.49691063165664673,
-0.05347495526075363,
0.22959697246551514,
-0.0910467654466629,
0.3606325089931488,
-0.5032060742378235,
0.49485111236572266,
0.2381957322359085,
0.5819755792617798,
0.004336892627179623,
0.06954582035541534,
-0.2799394428730011,
-0.012730177491903305,
-0.2887619733810425,
0.5595725178718567,
-0.9333452582359314,
-0.022563816979527473,
0.033382102847099304,
-0.0588742233812809,
-0.37073400616645813,
-0.7235303521156311,
0.2768344283103943,
-0.7522197961807251,
0.09077604115009308,
0.13912555575370789,
-0.1626775711774826,
-0.6710935235023499,
0.21652033925056458,
-0.6293284893035889,
0.8494089841842651,
0.5704507231712341,
-0.2856540083885193,
0.2971026301383972,
-1.140993356704712,
-0.19369517266750336,
0.19771906733512878,
0.16034618020057678,
-0.5305485129356384,
0.011942418292164803,
0.29486188292503357,
0.7286560535430908,
-0.5790441036224365,
0.6717851758003235,
-0.34600767493247986,
-0.09501074999570847,
0.21562783420085907,
-0.07607881724834442,
0.6192398071289062,
0.03357737883925438,
-0.9316568970680237,
0.44048255681991577,
-0.8407982587814331,
0.09505897760391235,
0.12852071225643158,
0.39334601163864136,
-0.19004644453525543,
0.06623855978250504,
0.16284064948558807,
0.5194677710533142,
-0.050153836607933044,
-0.5215521454811096,
0.08452244102954865,
-0.6092716455459595,
0.3936329782009125,
0.2725130319595337,
-0.03042830154299736,
-0.020012017339468002,
-0.28605028986930847,
0.30137744545936584,
0.33686965703964233,
0.43385523557662964,
-0.10892735421657562,
-0.572472333908081,
-0.6454898715019226,
-0.1724247932434082,
0.3054061830043793,
0.7146989703178406,
-0.3637356162071228,
0.6383615136146545,
-0.21534818410873413,
-0.6761711239814758,
-0.3259127736091614,
0.03430907800793648,
0.22027216851711273,
0.4542631506919861,
0.5193291902542114,
-0.3211156129837036,
-0.28599876165390015,
-1.020803689956665,
-0.008373971097171307,
0.29127615690231323,
-0.08586621284484863,
0.7140950560569763,
0.3200368285179138,
-1.0169214010238647,
0.6304723620414734,
-0.30342429876327515,
-0.8352484703063965,
-0.09732671827077866,
-0.0765172615647316,
0.27669456601142883,
0.21811231970787048,
0.5745491981506348,
-0.7435302734375,
-0.6682574152946472,
0.5586472749710083,
-0.8561345338821411,
-0.20109610259532928,
0.21921832859516144,
0.1606004387140274,
0.4124908447265625,
0.43073228001594543,
-0.3396831750869751,
0.5960559844970703,
0.5358781814575195,
-0.46194157004356384,
0.2751171588897705,
-0.41028308868408203,
0.44634413719177246,
-0.8115582466125488,
0.28497302532196045,
0.38780954480171204,
-0.5045760869979858,
-0.38436418771743774,
0.0426151305437088,
-0.05542229861021042,
-0.20261752605438232,
-0.1755596250295639,
0.20520150661468506,
-0.1173606812953949,
-0.12379135191440582,
-0.22703902423381805,
0.0043915337882936,
-0.1425524652004242,
0.3981349766254425,
-0.14952655136585236,
0.32825711369514465,
0.6787509918212891,
-0.4427745044231415,
0.6531065702438354,
0.03828081488609314,
-0.05532020330429077,
0.6665035486221313,
-0.5944403409957886,
0.19849559664726257,
0.14497633278369904,
-0.0038988650776445866,
-0.70230633020401,
-0.3640062212944031,
0.4651169776916504,
-0.13412436842918396,
0.4138612151145935,
-0.07736507803201675,
-0.38743752241134644,
-0.477154016494751,
0.1518782675266266,
0.6032631993293762,
0.5751124620437622,
-0.4128611981868744,
0.9876802563667297,
0.5662145614624023,
-0.3140825927257538,
-0.073282390832901,
-0.34026119112968445,
0.359613835811615,
-0.4940687417984009,
-0.7080506682395935,
0.21312780678272247,
0.2177724391222,
-0.6992546916007996,
-0.4172947108745575,
0.18260206282138824,
-0.38696226477622986,
0.02219734713435173,
0.3977613151073456,
0.4062661826610565,
-0.25104036927223206,
0.0007222603890113533,
0.1053423061966896,
-0.21990123391151428,
0.30434930324554443,
-0.4341229498386383,
0.368419885635376,
-0.1026538759469986,
-0.8330978751182556,
-0.7560132741928101,
0.2887965440750122,
0.9713022708892822,
-0.4026579260826111,
0.42350995540618896,
0.4033256471157074,
-0.47777456045150757,
-0.3032439053058624,
-0.596933126449585,
-0.2119176685810089,
-0.4299466013908386,
-0.013999263755977154,
-0.21555815637111664,
-0.31185245513916016,
0.8151681423187256,
-0.6195212602615356,
-0.14316752552986145,
0.7462064027786255,
0.7269097566604614,
0.17527848482131958,
1.107876181602478,
0.5782960653305054,
0.21147754788398743,
0.23747655749320984,
-0.29454800486564636,
0.22038567066192627,
-0.4083486795425415,
-0.6573540568351746,
-0.27010390162467957,
-0.3889499306678772,
-0.3212741017341614,
-0.6814410090446472,
0.40180695056915283,
-0.7845777869224548,
-0.18534152209758759,
0.23288732767105103,
-0.7280547022819519,
0.17837108671665192,
0.38966941833496094,
0.469229131937027,
0.28438079357147217,
-0.11189836263656616,
-0.13122552633285522,
-0.10701784491539001,
-0.5643089413642883,
-0.5447467565536499,
1.337494134902954,
0.37495750188827515,
0.2563866078853607,
0.005422340705990791,
0.4470306634902954,
0.7312111258506775,
0.6384986042976379,
-0.8750282526016235,
0.25339674949645996,
-0.17538544535636902,
-0.4469911456108093,
-0.28770339488983154,
-0.3298833966255188,
-0.8686352968215942,
0.13821695744991302,
-0.12201721221208572,
-0.7617657780647278,
0.28476691246032715,
-0.24364177882671356,
-0.44739848375320435,
0.23752038180828094,
-0.5116660594940186,
0.9550632834434509,
-0.412895143032074,
-0.23583132028579712,
-0.5972857475280762,
-0.9817777872085571,
0.27619779109954834,
-0.4039069712162018,
0.5810869336128235,
-0.313056081533432,
-0.05483173578977585,
0.8562511801719666,
-0.19867701828479767,
0.9585191011428833,
-0.4127316176891327,
-0.22759297490119934,
-0.061672210693359375,
0.20450003445148468,
-0.11524835228919983,
-0.054061245173215866,
-0.11931109428405762,
0.57730633020401,
0.13435892760753632,
-0.22403858602046967,
-0.5887261629104614,
0.6593127250671387,
-0.6030765771865845,
-0.21076594293117523,
-0.27073490619659424,
-0.4960375130176544,
-0.671003520488739,
0.3454211950302124,
-0.43074992299079895,
0.5871531367301941,
-0.3421343266963959,
-0.3675205409526825,
0.35953012108802795,
-0.16662044823169708,
0.2594119608402252,
0.6207427978515625,
-0.2099093496799469,
-0.37771618366241455,
0.6622572541236877,
-0.09757038205862045,
0.03267894312739372,
0.14885224401950836,
0.25405314564704895,
-0.046974461525678635,
-0.6647446155548096,
-0.5183066725730896,
0.3640449643135071,
-0.5744057893753052,
-0.32884055376052856,
-0.46194663643836975,
-0.13331562280654907,
-0.21978063881397247,
0.15200471878051758,
-0.3349989056587219,
-0.262797474861145,
0.14786696434020996,
0.3812609910964966,
0.1488598883152008,
0.8826009035110474,
0.26129448413848877,
0.3280898332595825,
-0.9893150925636292,
0.3555270731449127,
-0.17636734247207642,
0.4003821015357971,
-0.21746701002120972,
-0.12247548252344131,
-0.32322636246681213,
0.24978113174438477,
-0.10900913923978806,
-0.8061317205429077,
0.8492976427078247,
0.18528905510902405,
0.42659708857536316,
0.5963547229766846,
0.024760626256465912,
0.21717271208763123,
-0.43567323684692383,
0.25596582889556885,
0.09264755249023438,
-0.8243873119354248,
0.7389494180679321,
-0.27402734756469727,
0.00667986273765564,
0.6563493609428406,
0.12809020280838013,
-0.45208993554115295,
-0.2954460382461548,
-0.8153137564659119,
-0.6147517561912537,
0.6365002393722534,
-0.2805916965007782,
-0.09154980629682541,
0.28654745221138,
0.2678288221359253,
0.35087093710899353,
0.21973031759262085,
-0.0857449322938919,
-0.26147696375846863,
0.050343893468379974,
-0.39691826701164246,
-0.11964885145425797,
0.031013863161206245,
-0.5600730180740356,
-0.3922613263130188,
0.503961443901062,
-0.4393653869628906,
0.05250248685479164,
0.2582534849643707,
-0.23199845850467682,
-0.13342750072479248,
-0.07536138594150543,
0.5344491004943848,
1.092052936553955,
-0.07991848886013031,
-0.20113934576511383,
0.1025567501783371,
-0.3478855490684509,
-0.031134219840168953,
0.30526572465896606,
0.21577438712120056,
0.25570210814476013,
0.2615087032318115,
0.4024699330329895,
0.17241911590099335,
-0.8596844673156738,
0.5814380645751953,
-0.12434554100036621,
-0.5046047568321228,
-0.37655359506607056,
-0.18742983043193817,
-0.3113042712211609,
0.37801310420036316,
0.4474775493144989,
0.5851942300796509,
0.19119422137737274,
-0.10326247662305832,
0.3533427119255066,
0.4137909412384033,
-0.7413817048072815,
-0.24771150946617126,
0.37693560123443604,
0.3627541661262512,
-0.5219500660896301,
0.6421683430671692,
0.2070946842432022,
-0.5519057512283325,
0.9305594563484192,
0.056436680257320404,
0.6712585091590881,
-0.4298873841762543,
0.3375130891799927,
0.12114623934030533,
0.17854560911655426,
0.3837166726589203,
0.14162857830524445,
0.1327309012413025,
-0.5031211376190186,
-0.5330143570899963,
-0.4048304557800293,
-0.38284263014793396,
-0.23231500387191772,
-0.313716322183609,
0.2234937846660614,
-0.6240099668502808,
-0.28864842653274536,
0.39128807187080383,
0.16590318083763123,
-0.4764508306980133,
0.31472426652908325,
0.15985359251499176,
1.0624333620071411,
-0.8861531615257263,
0.571021556854248,
0.47006282210350037,
-0.1376279592514038,
-0.7286494970321655,
-0.014789987355470657,
0.19266857206821442,
-0.9569636583328247,
0.9878917932510376,
0.3281964361667633,
-0.0263132955878973,
-0.11860033869743347,
-0.036621659994125366,
-0.6422220468521118,
0.9800010919570923,
0.268634557723999,
-0.5757002830505371,
0.240367591381073,
0.11140670627355576,
0.7540494799613953,
-0.512701153755188,
0.5561181306838989,
0.8245187401771545,
0.8421345949172974,
0.26223108172416687,
-1.3059277534484863,
0.25961756706237793,
-0.19726833701133728,
-0.35191476345062256,
0.42880088090896606,
-0.1735416203737259,
0.4989754259586334,
-0.366146057844162,
-0.22789381444454193,
-0.05371171236038208,
0.1473253071308136,
-0.3548746705055237,
0.7233656644821167,
0.44635629653930664,
0.6032955646514893,
0.7537174820899963,
-0.08761942386627197,
1.030668020248413,
-0.5946590900421143,
0.072854183614254,
0.22363661229610443,
-0.3309524357318878,
0.5086339116096497,
0.08544479310512543,
-0.4121626615524292,
0.8273051381111145,
0.6653788685798645,
0.02522074058651924,
0.10856824368238449,
0.14086894690990448,
-0.326985627412796,
-0.28330889344215393,
-0.1727028340101242,
-0.284205824136734,
0.8298224210739136,
0.5222944617271423,
-0.44613227248191833,
-0.4525558352470398,
0.33678674697875977,
-0.3639375567436218,
0.12284786254167557,
-0.19151054322719574,
1.1233320236206055,
-0.04974640533328056,
-0.34128808975219727,
0.5537993907928467,
0.12872368097305298,
0.39764368534088135,
-0.4703436493873596,
-0.2020670473575592,
0.11242510378360748,
0.5462365746498108,
-0.33288857340812683,
-0.14851431548595428,
0.6645344495773315,
-0.40738123655319214,
0.061632100492715836,
-0.024677954614162445,
0.5369161367416382,
-0.22792814671993256,
-0.8174185156822205,
0.301040381193161,
1.0159882307052612,
0.1831250935792923,
-0.302762508392334,
-0.9795869588851929,
-0.06630988419055939,
-0.3665684163570404,
0.020225895568728447,
0.09130032360553741,
0.45683562755584717,
-0.26291897892951965,
0.7683596611022949,
0.6496222019195557,
0.18698906898498535,
-0.5293799638748169,
0.4917682409286499,
0.71806800365448,
-0.5588557124137878,
-0.1612297147512436,
-0.9509164690971375,
0.25981569290161133,
-0.2832920253276825,
0.17303557693958282,
0.543474018573761,
0.36047863960266113,
0.20109783113002777,
0.11567633599042892,
0.6614069938659668,
0.08606411516666412,
0.5718027353286743,
-0.14896561205387115,
0.5291861891746521,
-0.4553477466106415,
0.32624033093452454,
-0.285505473613739,
-0.8079543709754944,
-0.753577709197998,
0.5467847585678101,
-0.4765067994594574,
0.16351689398288727,
0.6976674199104309,
0.6973230838775635,
-0.17874106764793396,
0.02151787281036377,
0.2912519872188568,
-0.04697871208190918,
0.34098944067955017,
0.5447426438331604,
0.5039817094802856,
-0.23464268445968628,
-0.09184461832046509,
-0.3407968282699585,
-0.6962252259254456,
-0.5274861454963684,
-0.504938006401062,
-0.9018768072128296,
-0.47535648941993713,
-0.20650029182434082,
-0.13533131778240204,
-0.00251733954064548,
0.910652756690979,
1.0697308778762817,
-0.795113742351532,
-0.17809344828128815,
-0.0648684874176979,
0.00031204824335873127,
-0.4988788366317749,
-0.2151699960231781,
0.3657137453556061,
-0.26493996381759644,
-0.8436282873153687,
0.34284937381744385,
0.41995474696159363,
-0.10270751267671585,
-0.5057936906814575,
0.2746453881263733,
0.1758081018924713,
-0.15617488324642181,
0.5924883484840393,
-0.015251610428094864,
-0.5951895117759705,
0.07783645391464233,
0.0938754603266716,
0.01917087659239769,
0.12710803747177124,
0.8375658392906189,
-1.054032325744629,
0.3066953122615814,
-0.20890773832798004,
0.7498762607574463,
0.17270037531852722,
-0.013432675041258335,
0.7150463461875916,
-0.05081077292561531,
0.07636838406324387,
0.7254011631011963,
0.17809617519378662,
0.29128000140190125,
-0.562529444694519,
0.34626954793930054,
0.21132993698120117,
-0.2835482060909271,
-0.45358821749687195,
0.20479616522789001,
-1.1031837463378906,
-0.5036706328392029,
0.933462917804718,
0.10755813121795654,
-0.3208833336830139,
-0.3564431667327881,
-0.4640812873840332,
0.03136206790804863,
-0.21794775128364563,
1.0480644702911377,
0.20398515462875366,
-0.3926295340061188,
-0.11051240563392639,
-0.5511118173599243,
0.3653574585914612,
0.25563010573387146,
-1.121112585067749,
0.0016855649882927537,
0.5829125642776489,
0.1467176228761673,
0.38414570689201355,
0.3304215967655182,
-0.1981469690799713,
0.20306247472763062,
-0.2760241627693176,
-0.09050081670284271,
-0.5492705702781677,
-0.3368982970714569,
-0.22423262894153595,
0.0998581275343895,
-0.23780299723148346,
-0.00757766654714942
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14238v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14238v1
|
Reinforcement Learning from Reflective Feedback (RLRF): Aligning and Improving LLMs via Fine-Grained Self-Reflection
| 2024-03-21T08:57:27 | 2024-03-21T08:57:27 |
Kyungjae Lee, Dasol Hwang, Sunghyun Park, Youngsoo Jang, Moontae Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Despite the promise of RLHF in aligning LLMs with human preferences, it often
leads to superficial alignment, prioritizing stylistic changes over improving
downstream performance of LLMs. Underspecified preferences could obscure
directions to align the models. Lacking exploration restricts identification of
desirable outputs to improve the models. To overcome these challenges, we
propose a novel framework: Reinforcement Learning from Reflective Feedback
(RLRF), which leverages fine-grained feedback based on detailed criteria to
improve the core capabilities of LLMs. RLRF employs a self-reflection mechanism
to systematically explore and refine LLM responses, then fine-tuning the models
via a RL algorithm along with promising responses. Our experiments across
Just-Eval, Factuality, and Mathematical Reasoning demonstrate the efficacy and
transformative potential of RLRF beyond superficial surface-level adjustment.
|
[
-0.3843025863170624,
-0.6649887561798096,
0.6445139646530151,
0.177876815199852,
-0.11460796743631363,
0.3285984396934509,
-0.3458113372325897,
-0.28916987776756287,
0.3264275789260864,
0.6699889898300171,
-1.1282082796096802,
-0.2999670207500458,
-0.43677622079849243,
-0.10115546733140945,
0.06051086634397507,
1.3155641555786133,
-0.14008013904094696,
0.2717825174331665,
-0.09141317754983902,
-0.17136500775814056,
-0.4480297863483429,
0.0025697380769997835,
-0.5089021921157837,
-0.8136369585990906,
0.9281103014945984,
0.6764115691184998,
0.2866832911968231,
0.3731142580509186,
0.5231426358222961,
0.22635701298713684,
0.3862334191799164,
0.6935302019119263,
-0.7027701735496521,
0.32921847701072693,
-0.5702918767929077,
-0.19370920956134796,
-0.05946184694766998,
0.060132045298814774,
0.5049760937690735,
0.2205328345298767,
-0.7263103127479553,
0.3677372634410858,
0.36361363530158997,
1.1833218336105347,
-0.7782514691352844,
0.05552024394273758,
-0.3253583014011383,
0.4530213475227356,
0.16997556388378143,
-0.6221256852149963,
-0.4521089494228363,
-0.3962997794151306,
-0.03242121636867523,
-0.5971442461013794,
0.04379992559552193,
0.1909882128238678,
0.6471198797225952,
0.4838169515132904,
-0.11947266757488251,
-0.05732593312859535,
-0.9365453124046326,
0.8802817463874817,
-0.6091058254241943,
0.35597723722457886,
-0.05237562209367752,
0.32797887921333313,
-0.3450350761413574,
-0.47507256269454956,
-0.07225851714611053,
-0.22785989940166473,
-0.1517983078956604,
0.465268075466156,
0.5424046516418457,
0.15984395146369934,
-0.055864833295345306,
0.27340030670166016,
-0.3137252628803253,
0.19283467531204224,
-0.22497734427452087,
-0.07973192632198334,
0.7565427422523499,
0.3829580545425415,
-0.1106858029961586,
0.04218708723783493,
-0.8013602495193481,
-0.33441105484962463,
-0.5570694804191589,
0.4875558912754059,
0.064996637403965,
0.6565524339675903,
0.18304666876792908,
0.2698207199573517,
-0.23469898104667664,
0.5643672943115234,
0.4040973484516144,
-0.3392150402069092,
-0.10199764370918274,
0.06324000656604767,
-0.12075149267911911,
0.24023833870887756,
0.5546817779541016,
0.5022704005241394,
-0.03288993239402771,
-0.0881839394569397,
-0.7557836771011353,
-0.20472091436386108,
0.5724778175354004,
-0.6406028866767883,
0.010500466451048851,
-0.10952558368444443,
-0.5242543816566467,
-0.5559739470481873,
0.2800443470478058,
-0.7025392651557922,
-0.5047774314880371,
-0.5036907196044922,
0.5886720418930054,
0.00003110888064838946,
-0.25509050488471985,
0.18080729246139526,
0.018353169783949852,
0.237600177526474,
0.5412337183952332,
-0.9805225133895874,
0.4451170265674591,
0.8285356163978577,
0.5443313121795654,
-0.41671526432037354,
-0.3901102542877197,
-0.6500928997993469,
0.1684429943561554,
-0.46647363901138306,
0.8550002574920654,
-0.45890378952026367,
-0.49754732847213745,
0.16471099853515625,
-0.05038037896156311,
0.0938514843583107,
-0.7009996771812439,
0.29974135756492615,
-0.4456652104854584,
0.25070998072624207,
-0.3843662142753601,
-0.34951528906822205,
-0.1466100662946701,
0.525305449962616,
-0.42249441146850586,
1.0238193273544312,
0.05814575031399727,
-0.434912770986557,
0.611936628818512,
-0.5329373478889465,
-0.1722572147846222,
-0.11775735765695572,
-0.23216061294078827,
-0.6469672918319702,
0.2995552122592926,
0.11905043572187424,
0.4335516691207886,
0.18527233600616455,
0.2291937917470932,
-0.6651917099952698,
-0.5287312269210815,
0.32841071486473083,
-0.24869820475578308,
-0.17745661735534668,
0.24358250200748444,
-0.30662134289741516,
0.5407047271728516,
-0.6424252390861511,
0.21694010496139526,
-0.005324549973011017,
-0.3743530511856079,
-0.05327311530709267,
0.2008064091205597,
-0.028179002925753593,
0.18597939610481262,
0.2467426210641861,
-0.4221670925617218,
0.2868872880935669,
-0.37404665350914,
0.26867297291755676,
1.1788119077682495,
0.15610967576503754,
0.6171610951423645,
-0.6520544290542603,
0.5628951787948608,
-0.10426673293113708,
0.32914265990257263,
0.2573733925819397,
0.1892998218536377,
-0.6870826482772827,
-0.1733989417552948,
0.09503322839736938,
0.15694557130336761,
-0.5795001983642578,
-0.16902270913124084,
0.09956009685993195,
-0.09457771480083466,
-0.5096436142921448,
0.39212843775749207,
0.8133328557014465,
0.572514533996582,
0.4625948369503021,
-0.6490572094917297,
-0.5520895719528198,
-0.8374085426330566,
-0.45427408814430237,
-0.06636539846658707,
0.36724308133125305,
0.6123254299163818,
0.2435436099767685,
-0.04940853267908096,
0.852544903755188,
-0.5206446647644043,
-0.6838741898536682,
-0.2625272572040558,
0.3242574632167816,
0.032074227929115295,
0.4237251877784729,
-0.06636212021112442,
-0.48038432002067566,
-0.35289159417152405,
-0.020390301942825317,
-0.4635504484176636,
0.061957377940416336,
-0.2591917812824249,
0.005791202653199434,
0.08588933199644089,
0.3919907808303833,
-0.06544671207666397,
0.2662576138973236,
0.3453080654144287,
-0.23959656059741974,
0.5510928630828857,
-0.35807573795318604,
0.11817194521427155,
-0.32722970843315125,
-0.38849928975105286,
0.13357089459896088,
-0.6515412330627441,
-0.11352210491895676,
-0.03387640416622162,
-0.030023356899619102,
0.31721362471580505,
-0.4455741047859192,
0.6831650137901306,
-0.2525920271873474,
-0.3358079791069031,
-0.5260347127914429,
0.17497530579566956,
0.09813089668750763,
0.7811209559440613,
0.34065693616867065,
0.8839579820632935,
-0.1757444441318512,
-0.6108121871948242,
0.07531550526618958,
0.1259397566318512,
-0.29945823550224304,
0.3975275158882141,
-0.44919443130493164,
-0.05903882533311844,
-0.06695876270532608,
0.3891579806804657,
-0.7693307399749756,
-0.11834969371557236,
0.2812443673610687,
-0.2180415689945221,
0.37034720182418823,
0.0006018995773047209,
0.057608287781476974,
-0.14335981011390686,
-0.4492434859275818,
0.1838330328464508,
0.38414689898490906,
-0.7498748302459717,
0.7533358335494995,
0.1600525677204132,
0.15362662076950073,
-0.8281758427619934,
-0.40771105885505676,
-0.33422979712486267,
-0.1278565376996994,
-0.2565312683582306,
0.29671815037727356,
0.12174949795007706,
-0.12998148798942566,
-0.12940151989459991,
-0.18903310596942902,
0.41485610604286194,
0.23432983458042145,
0.3866567611694336,
0.23561088740825653,
0.04625861719250679,
0.13693536818027496,
-0.20425891876220703,
-0.14440377056598663,
0.12506774067878723,
-0.3617776930332184,
0.3566325306892395,
-0.3774886131286621,
-0.3618491590023041,
-0.2631533741950989,
-0.07405923306941986,
0.10156500339508057,
-0.29318565130233765,
0.3350566327571869,
0.7149801850318909,
0.2801426649093628,
-0.8188943266868591,
-0.5560798645019531,
-0.5998010635375977,
-0.49699124693870544,
0.307891845703125,
-0.1437508463859558,
-1.069301962852478,
0.3080655634403229,
-0.19604763388633728,
0.010520177893340588,
0.0742131769657135,
0.47722500562667847,
-0.3396699130535126,
1.1970914602279663,
0.8069156408309937,
0.14903292059898376,
0.6602494716644287,
-0.20794501900672913,
-0.01951305940747261,
-1.151993989944458,
-0.5490511059761047,
0.07528849691152573,
-0.5822709798812866,
-0.6542515754699707,
-0.20085671544075012,
0.3113264739513397,
-0.1326834112405777,
-0.4532111585140228,
-0.16054584085941315,
-0.8026840686798096,
0.4753878712654114,
0.48577284812927246,
0.7187100052833557,
0.26647257804870605,
-0.3436328172683716,
-0.20665013790130615,
-0.08352438360452652,
-0.5297914743423462,
-0.4305052161216736,
0.8062486052513123,
0.555237889289856,
1.1679099798202515,
-0.03641243651509285,
1.1248372793197632,
0.5196833610534668,
0.5945206880569458,
-0.7507252097129822,
0.5120997428894043,
0.06574759632349014,
-0.4086184501647949,
-0.42470094561576843,
-0.30663198232650757,
-0.5054583549499512,
0.3029061257839203,
-0.262391060590744,
-0.2915027439594269,
0.17225773632526398,
0.39324629306793213,
-0.6855682134628296,
0.1953946202993393,
-0.40259718894958496,
0.529839813709259,
-0.4483458995819092,
-0.9002898335456848,
-0.36760833859443665,
-0.5327286720275879,
0.5442761182785034,
0.2965857684612274,
0.24903638660907745,
-0.14735260605812073,
0.006542340852320194,
0.6501259803771973,
-0.2211676388978958,
0.9285115003585815,
-0.5136740803718567,
-0.23712271451950073,
-0.06381583213806152,
0.2881106734275818,
0.5844398140907288,
0.36534908413887024,
0.3694678843021393,
-0.461386501789093,
0.03326416015625,
-0.24102361500263214,
-1.0014491081237793,
0.5726906061172485,
-0.7159494161605835,
-0.7901098132133484,
-0.4896697998046875,
-0.21614769101142883,
-0.5034586787223816,
-0.005127595271915197,
-0.12768596410751343,
0.2226785272359848,
-0.49306395649909973,
-0.1745828539133072,
1.1080292463302612,
0.11522037535905838,
0.3799801468849182,
0.8129851222038269,
-0.8227986097335815,
-0.5894920229911804,
1.0734331607818604,
-0.2710474729537964,
0.2569213807582855,
0.3468402326107025,
0.33689144253730774,
-0.39687323570251465,
-0.3986479341983795,
-0.2819753587245941,
0.08951720595359802,
-0.5345319509506226,
-0.33288508653640747,
-0.1018504723906517,
-0.0591888464987278,
-0.041340652853250504,
-0.16992685198783875,
-0.4949614405632019,
-0.3351929187774658,
-0.29514938592910767,
-0.19517740607261658,
0.07313590496778488,
1.083690881729126,
-0.36894574761390686,
0.04135885834693909,
-0.5372549891471863,
0.03166325017809868,
0.5602666139602661,
0.5579907894134521,
0.2829098701477051,
-0.49087440967559814,
-0.3253062665462494,
0.13466060161590576,
-0.480258584022522,
-0.23614050447940826,
0.40836501121520996,
0.18935172259807587,
0.3244379758834839,
0.5637578368186951,
-0.05923910439014435,
0.7925615310668945,
-0.6051862835884094,
0.5719839930534363,
0.37716275453567505,
-0.5747179985046387,
0.4775893986225128,
-0.27985498309135437,
-0.06847627460956573,
0.8701093196868896,
0.010824723169207573,
-0.37562295794487,
-0.22970864176750183,
-0.4766433537006378,
-0.48631933331489563,
0.587687075138092,
-0.5772070288658142,
0.0218973346054554,
0.1861385703086853,
0.5702883005142212,
0.15371808409690857,
0.17529253661632538,
-0.8464951515197754,
0.10116134583950043,
-0.32345589995384216,
-0.08913088589906693,
-0.08620034158229828,
-0.169077068567276,
-0.6165998578071594,
-0.2186490297317505,
0.9268313646316528,
-0.37241658568382263,
0.1135408952832222,
0.584760308265686,
-0.07037431746721268,
-0.4159524142742157,
0.255945086479187,
0.9606680870056152,
0.25734373927116394,
-0.3062952160835266,
0.19698895514011383,
0.21674895286560059,
-0.0027223974466323853,
0.3546102046966553,
-0.515114426612854,
0.04254704713821411,
-0.6024038791656494,
0.21038952469825745,
0.6752503514289856,
0.49132052063941956,
-0.6063321828842163,
0.57542484998703,
-0.20249059796333313,
-0.28843846917152405,
-0.4198654294013977,
0.5905535221099854,
-0.2025688737630844,
0.5266507863998413,
0.21701841056346893,
0.01258836593478918,
0.14606401324272156,
-0.5516049861907959,
0.410152792930603,
0.7217360734939575,
-1.0163235664367676,
-0.06127479299902916,
0.37282794713974,
0.09874620288610458,
-0.4293222427368164,
0.2965433895587921,
-0.05972372740507126,
-0.5819124579429626,
0.2550753951072693,
0.4522413909435272,
0.8411262631416321,
0.019307484850287437,
0.6302704215049744,
0.2477695345878601,
-0.17589403688907623,
-0.3528240919113159,
0.09288646280765533,
-0.5437249541282654,
-0.8351492285728455,
-0.478871613740921,
-0.6526574492454529,
-0.5721161961555481,
-0.34292587637901306,
-1.0274920463562012,
-0.07519372552633286,
-0.9458182454109192,
-0.07089895009994507,
-0.37890106439590454,
0.185953751206398,
-0.20089595019817352,
0.25257453322410583,
0.05865699052810669,
0.604843258857727,
-0.6526974439620972,
0.45261260867118835,
0.42518603801727295,
-0.5583798885345459,
-1.001039981842041,
-0.09457973390817642,
-0.13902443647384644,
-1.271164894104004,
1.0622555017471313,
0.021499142050743103,
-0.7772641777992249,
-0.05607675760984421,
-0.8692606687545776,
-0.7210854291915894,
1.0950350761413574,
-0.07692699879407883,
-0.5720785856246948,
0.008047874085605145,
-0.07944417744874954,
0.512018084526062,
-0.4890643358230591,
0.3188115358352661,
0.44323983788490295,
0.5843683481216431,
0.04843677580356598,
-0.5543581247329712,
0.0554945170879364,
0.018717709928750992,
0.2522580623626709,
0.28551799058914185,
-1.1123318672180176,
0.23782634735107422,
-0.34753531217575073,
-0.052043985575437546,
-0.004529465455561876,
0.8764837980270386,
0.4164960980415344,
0.24117207527160645,
0.39056992530822754,
0.7684881687164307,
0.43158552050590515,
-0.0791366696357727,
0.617400050163269,
-0.09349246323108673,
0.4734136760234833,
1.2137455940246582,
-0.43899083137512207,
0.7650163173675537,
0.7057021260261536,
-0.011732162907719612,
1.0177381038665771,
0.7041950821876526,
-0.06534503400325775,
1.1398940086364746,
0.310674250125885,
-0.33366671204566956,
-0.5289482474327087,
-0.15480954945087433,
-0.08480887115001678,
0.2693474292755127,
0.17399577796459198,
-0.15312640368938446,
-0.3447580635547638,
0.15413743257522583,
-0.39950230717658997,
0.5145937204360962,
-0.48375147581100464,
1.2524276971817017,
0.130961075425148,
-1.0096626281738281,
0.3081294000148773,
-0.05161692574620247,
0.8165102601051331,
-0.4662398099899292,
-0.31540244817733765,
-0.2788642346858978,
0.5212503671646118,
-0.5007916688919067,
-0.7363556623458862,
-0.041620634496212006,
-0.5901215672492981,
-0.25033921003341675,
-0.7013568878173828,
0.755571186542511,
-0.4616570472717285,
-0.07608167827129364,
0.4461527466773987,
0.21770991384983063,
-0.46780043840408325,
0.39895662665367126,
-0.8722066283226013,
-0.08021996170282364,
0.015945978462696075,
-0.3180639445781708,
0.6364424824714661,
0.2805821895599365,
0.39320749044418335,
0.9350842237472534,
0.5170098543167114,
0.24636967480182648,
-0.23890554904937744,
0.10652625560760498,
0.7021087408065796,
-0.6633095145225525,
-0.3230651319026947,
-0.6733389496803284,
0.3918316662311554,
0.033016011118888855,
-0.23369300365447998,
0.6544646620750427,
0.33922162652015686,
0.8927769660949707,
-0.08976588398218155,
0.47848495841026306,
0.5322450995445251,
0.7975139021873474,
-0.8528331518173218,
0.3893613815307617,
-0.7210924625396729,
0.2892102003097534,
0.011765861883759499,
-0.5975913405418396,
-0.1480983942747116,
0.8250100016593933,
-0.4149797260761261,
0.042328715324401855,
0.4863031804561615,
0.9701132774353027,
0.12278775870800018,
0.013986499980092049,
0.31876203417778015,
-0.042119696736335754,
0.3572528064250946,
0.48513901233673096,
1.216468334197998,
-0.004760391544550657,
0.03984716907143593,
-0.32801246643066406,
-0.14652051031589508,
-0.25068023800849915,
-0.8141164183616638,
-0.6406012177467346,
-0.41159766912460327,
-0.10667029768228531,
-0.5550873875617981,
0.40969863533973694,
1.315561294555664,
0.7082152366638184,
-0.6403381824493408,
-0.35351642966270447,
-0.3946487605571747,
0.1816156506538391,
-0.41466227173805237,
-0.274921178817749,
0.0506141297519207,
-0.9481860995292664,
-0.17795957624912262,
0.3783876299858093,
0.45052140951156616,
-0.12423108518123627,
-0.7845488786697388,
-0.5704830884933472,
0.02037084847688675,
0.11073524504899979,
0.3107309937477112,
0.47975683212280273,
-0.6727729439735413,
-0.46910861134529114,
-0.07721348851919174,
-0.21491366624832153,
0.21153850853443146,
1.0074752569198608,
-0.9413520693778992,
0.12264095991849899,
0.07115141302347183,
0.5626431107521057,
0.712148129940033,
0.17370854318141937,
0.5401992201805115,
-0.5898516178131104,
-0.27667492628097534,
0.38129422068595886,
0.19582220911979675,
0.09388000518083572,
-0.45452627539634705,
0.3894319236278534,
-0.1314118653535843,
-0.8338242769241333,
-0.851146936416626,
0.4689461886882782,
-0.799189567565918,
-0.3427930176258087,
1.005511999130249,
0.021625200286507607,
-0.39988973736763,
0.26673460006713867,
-0.2633115351200104,
-0.03451637178659439,
-0.46413543820381165,
1.2110471725463867,
0.5018675923347473,
-0.569098949432373,
-0.31628188490867615,
-0.13161064684391022,
0.9545072317123413,
0.7565069794654846,
-0.5269328951835632,
0.07241053879261017,
0.39189648628234863,
0.49977976083755493,
-0.12327086180448532,
0.6882924437522888,
-0.14490145444869995,
0.2925570607185364,
-0.6648279428482056,
0.03760857135057449,
-0.2289835810661316,
-0.6076902747154236,
-0.5181480646133423,
0.079033263027668,
0.42504075169563293,
0.18083322048187256
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14734v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14734v2
|
A Survey of Neural Code Intelligence: Paradigms, Advances and Beyond
| 2024-03-21T08:54:56 | 2024-06-23T14:31:05 |
Qiushi Sun, Zhirui Chen, Fangzhi Xu, Kanzhi Cheng, Chang Ma, Zhangyue Yin, Jianing Wang, Chengcheng Han, Renyu Zhu, Shuai Yuan, Qipeng Guo, Xipeng Qiu, Pengcheng Yin, Xiaoli Li, Fei Yuan, Lingpeng Kong, Xiang Li, Zhiyong Wu
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.PL
|
Neural Code Intelligence -- leveraging deep learning to understand, generate,
and optimize code -- holds immense potential for transformative impacts on the
whole society. Bridging the gap between Natural Language and Programming
Language, this domain has drawn significant attention from researchers in both
research communities over the past few years. This survey presents a systematic
and chronological review of the advancements in code intelligence, encompassing
over 50 representative models and their variants, more than 20 categories of
tasks, and an extensive coverage of over 680 related works. We follow the
historical progression to trace the paradigm shifts across different research
phases (e.g., from modeling code with recurrent neural networks to the era of
Large Language Models). Concurrently, we highlight the major technical
transitions in models, tasks, and evaluations spanning through different
stages. For applications, we also observe a co-evolving shift. It spans from
initial endeavors to tackling specific scenarios, through exploring a diverse
array of tasks during its rapid expansion, to currently focusing on tackling
increasingly complex and varied real-world challenges. Building on our
examination of the developmental trajectories, we further investigate the
emerging synergies between code intelligence and broader machine intelligence,
uncovering new cross-domain opportunities and illustrating the substantial
influence of code intelligence across various domains. Finally, we delve into
both the opportunities and challenges associated with this field, alongside
elucidating our insights on the most promising research directions. An ongoing,
dynamically updated project and resources associated with this survey have been
released at https://github.com/QiushiSun/NCISurvey.
|
[
-0.40891560912132263,
-0.35933297872543335,
0.2659502923488617,
0.13260966539382935,
0.4239819049835205,
0.6815246343612671,
-0.32026270031929016,
-0.633162260055542,
-0.011989666149020195,
0.056292757391929626,
-0.6673647165298462,
-0.50355064868927,
-0.622987687587738,
-0.07966122776269913,
-0.4404289722442627,
0.8684820532798767,
0.35992103815078735,
0.16247598826885223,
-0.41575199365615845,
-0.0122554711997509,
-0.6111147999763489,
-0.7073870897293091,
-0.16699373722076416,
-0.3814032971858978,
0.5435821413993835,
0.1864425241947174,
0.36900028586387634,
0.34119439125061035,
0.5347573161125183,
0.21455758810043335,
-0.03239613398909569,
0.21068023145198822,
-0.1436997503042221,
0.01263453345745802,
0.11979081481695175,
-0.5226460099220276,
-0.6306266188621521,
0.01090066134929657,
0.21313516795635223,
0.9134421944618225,
0.05078298598527908,
0.3907875120639801,
0.011868273839354515,
0.7739795446395874,
-0.6549273133277893,
0.11000289767980576,
-0.5102074146270752,
0.2180343121290207,
0.03707573935389519,
-0.11978082358837128,
-0.2569897174835205,
-0.35529401898384094,
0.08021819591522217,
-0.34433895349502563,
-0.1126474067568779,
-0.2951493263244629,
0.332891047000885,
0.17311729490756989,
-0.3361332416534424,
-0.3775409758090973,
-0.8252753615379333,
0.9665054678916931,
-0.48972412943840027,
0.4583016037940979,
0.11234872788190842,
0.21586675941944122,
0.03977924957871437,
-0.9933132529258728,
-0.2881203889846802,
-0.42984169721603394,
0.408335417509079,
-0.0061798095703125,
-0.18835066258907318,
-0.2146133929491043,
0.22473563253879547,
0.2423364818096161,
-0.5240404605865479,
0.21647658944129944,
-0.6327555179595947,
-0.14930051565170288,
0.7599806785583496,
0.3522321879863739,
0.5415800213813782,
0.22977681457996368,
-0.03330162167549133,
0.11393765360116959,
-0.6750456690788269,
0.16420726478099823,
0.24377907812595367,
0.10147024691104889,
-0.06622530519962311,
0.2751905620098114,
-0.2107369303703308,
0.653119683265686,
-0.25827234983444214,
0.3791065812110901,
0.33908557891845703,
-0.7531200647354126,
-0.2032373696565628,
-0.14878901839256287,
0.5124570727348328,
0.29584193229675293,
0.15478858351707458,
-0.26131671667099,
-0.1450052559375763,
0.1552458554506302,
0.6700919270515442,
-0.5396591424942017,
-0.36219170689582825,
0.10387158393859863,
-0.7720062732696533,
-0.20259740948677063,
-0.07488403469324112,
-0.7404613494873047,
-0.7440714240074158,
-0.6424598693847656,
-0.35561132431030273,
-0.39107221364974976,
-0.5922306180000305,
0.13740208745002747,
-0.12609216570854187,
0.5722683668136597,
0.15029782056808472,
-0.6876267790794373,
0.03125729039311409,
1.1163138151168823,
0.7771019339561462,
0.022095751017332077,
-0.21976469457149506,
0.15170536935329437,
-0.6693097352981567,
-0.5132802128791809,
0.6137813925743103,
-0.6788145303726196,
-0.18224172294139862,
0.18613381683826447,
-0.4262803792953491,
-0.12060355395078659,
-0.5070172548294067,
0.1138601303100586,
-0.9205389618873596,
-0.3110376000404358,
0.015717940405011177,
-0.31528234481811523,
-0.21681974828243256,
0.5318944454193115,
-0.5286088585853577,
0.870104968547821,
0.0562967024743557,
-0.2772797644138336,
0.17414888739585876,
-0.7734772562980652,
-0.409745991230011,
0.0961349606513977,
-0.3972872197628021,
-0.1756916344165802,
0.35143744945526123,
-0.010010157711803913,
0.2868809401988983,
-0.570955216884613,
0.5860711336135864,
-0.24947194755077362,
-0.44413015246391296,
0.44430452585220337,
-0.13315828144550323,
1.0379801988601685,
0.40143364667892456,
-0.4359215497970581,
0.22345490753650665,
-0.7484185099601746,
0.380408376455307,
0.02079099602997303,
0.029368767514824867,
-0.07268724590539932,
0.09503977745771408,
-0.013257833197712898,
0.3658274710178375,
0.27507635951042175,
-0.2466782033443451,
0.3658483624458313,
-0.16147927939891815,
0.965674102306366,
0.3990400731563568,
-0.033061686903238297,
0.7169349789619446,
-0.3680330514907837,
0.6488146781921387,
-0.1760956197977066,
0.5636584758758545,
-0.2545132040977478,
-0.5646796226501465,
-0.5403160452842712,
0.13375024497509003,
0.4485921263694763,
0.5179324150085449,
-0.5469008088111877,
0.43729352951049805,
-0.5404802560806274,
-0.6242823600769043,
-0.3874453902244568,
0.014066971838474274,
0.4012933075428009,
-0.05252605304121971,
0.2203650325536728,
-0.17626884579658508,
-0.7407634854316711,
-0.6945134997367859,
-0.32225391268730164,
-0.12142468243837357,
0.02637684904038906,
0.17945486307144165,
0.5763810276985168,
-0.3821437954902649,
0.6971387267112732,
-0.3847601115703583,
0.18114444613456726,
-0.2535770535469055,
0.08589975535869598,
0.2545311450958252,
0.7927749752998352,
0.3932042717933655,
-0.9442727565765381,
-0.03406943008303642,
0.050154779106378555,
-0.7081367373466492,
0.4246937036514282,
-0.3549981713294983,
-0.10902939736843109,
-0.16414889693260193,
0.8284814357757568,
-0.22006556391716003,
0.40133875608444214,
0.4847016930580139,
-0.13101457059383392,
0.4533034861087799,
0.12359774857759476,
0.26408058404922485,
-0.7724606990814209,
0.3199785351753235,
-0.16982387006282806,
0.45455309748649597,
-0.8109700083732605,
0.45400646328926086,
0.11619435250759125,
0.08448483794927597,
-0.09023639559745789,
0.07696244865655899,
-0.6538493037223816,
-0.18153046071529388,
-0.05506687983870506,
-0.13743628561496735,
-0.21869732439517975,
0.4833361506462097,
-0.3121289312839508,
0.7684414386749268,
0.5120235085487366,
-0.5870386958122253,
0.38007253408432007,
0.15705184638500214,
-0.42058417201042175,
-0.007213626056909561,
-0.40764278173446655,
0.5989294052124023,
0.1937517374753952,
-0.006942391861230135,
-0.6350864768028259,
0.17252957820892334,
0.2743991017341614,
-0.8875206708908081,
0.2021629363298416,
-0.14315153658390045,
-0.4729936718940735,
-0.19958673417568207,
-0.2313283532857895,
0.7626422643661499,
0.660463809967041,
-0.10926954448223114,
0.4872470200061798,
0.44854575395584106,
-0.05016542226076126,
-0.581658661365509,
-0.8674323558807373,
0.5891634821891785,
0.17952702939510345,
-0.45378854870796204,
0.4252963364124298,
-0.2335371971130371,
-0.5718871355056763,
-0.11522139608860016,
-0.12851645052433014,
-0.4577355682849884,
0.2615599036216736,
0.1684376299381256,
0.42177098989486694,
-0.3879757523536682,
-0.006152010057121515,
0.03490827977657318,
0.024053001776337624,
0.5200939774513245,
-0.6566688418388367,
0.6314550638198853,
-0.2786073386669159,
-0.13944479823112488,
-0.029246661812067032,
0.23768332600593567,
0.47250404953956604,
-0.6779025197029114,
0.2552277445793152,
0.37759578227996826,
-0.3214801251888275,
-0.2704066038131714,
-0.20351670682430267,
0.013987134210765362,
-0.32128894329071045,
0.5750298500061035,
-0.0735618993639946,
-0.8532154560089111,
0.3854559659957886,
-0.3066442310810089,
0.17425911128520966,
0.15612109005451202,
0.38851916790008545,
0.11033326387405396,
0.782014787197113,
0.8362634778022766,
-0.06404706835746765,
0.6069067120552063,
-0.6158573627471924,
0.42550936341285706,
-0.8830523490905762,
-0.6205496788024902,
-0.4918958842754364,
-0.4337059557437897,
-0.5151787400245667,
-0.5072991847991943,
0.07821445167064667,
-0.11364804953336716,
-0.22924530506134033,
0.2761029303073883,
-0.6746721863746643,
0.3778858780860901,
0.5484248399734497,
0.031513478606939316,
0.1916772425174713,
-0.31143930554389954,
0.352946013212204,
0.12192384153604507,
-0.8132352828979492,
-0.10357791930437088,
1.2992411851882935,
0.29642587900161743,
0.26072415709495544,
-0.17887842655181885,
0.5218737721443176,
0.612485408782959,
0.3811936378479004,
-0.7056999802589417,
0.4837587773799896,
0.03657208010554314,
-0.6327077746391296,
0.058555468916893005,
-0.26812970638275146,
-0.7074980735778809,
-0.32091423869132996,
-0.08875753730535507,
-0.3531920611858368,
0.45633944869041443,
-0.17173901200294495,
-0.6263698935508728,
0.13829967379570007,
-0.4824603199958801,
0.7168199419975281,
-0.40918228030204773,
-0.18107597529888153,
-0.4419024884700775,
-0.8191565871238708,
0.5064764618873596,
0.16498416662216187,
0.08700235933065414,
-0.05892278254032135,
-0.20029890537261963,
0.36225149035453796,
0.16579926013946533,
0.8717595338821411,
-0.023193251341581345,
-0.02430652268230915,
0.33503758907318115,
-0.04494696855545044,
-0.1926940679550171,
0.12505614757537842,
-0.13030244410037994,
0.6350095272064209,
-0.22825002670288086,
-0.4074656367301941,
-0.6288977861404419,
0.6206218600273132,
-0.5785314440727234,
-0.14893721044063568,
-0.46665024757385254,
-0.726604163646698,
-0.30555230379104614,
0.15199825167655945,
-0.0010272101499140263,
0.854172945022583,
-0.10460067540407181,
0.15169657766819,
0.7496088743209839,
-0.31025147438049316,
0.5689728260040283,
-0.18750162422657013,
-0.10925523191690445,
-0.45522022247314453,
0.9652948379516602,
-0.031170371919870377,
0.031658612191677094,
0.3492138683795929,
-0.3065929114818573,
-0.1720370650291443,
-1.0809544324874878,
-0.37285521626472473,
-0.2135496884584427,
-0.5650805234909058,
-0.37277114391326904,
-0.45099398493766785,
-0.4930652976036072,
-0.5856003761291504,
-0.2446785271167755,
-0.1959514319896698,
-0.1726519763469696,
-0.14482297003269196,
0.21207012236118317,
0.1926697939634323,
1.0402222871780396,
0.26209190487861633,
-0.27703142166137695,
-0.8613231182098389,
0.09581039100885391,
0.04100900888442993,
0.5678612589836121,
0.3010216951370239,
-0.16367019712924957,
-0.3878304958343506,
0.07359808683395386,
0.05030856281518936,
-0.5904846787452698,
0.20749960839748383,
0.026206962764263153,
0.5001751184463501,
0.01362269651144743,
0.05760563910007477,
0.680554211139679,
-0.3755353093147278,
0.9889624118804932,
0.1905711591243744,
-0.6921406984329224,
0.2688450515270233,
-0.30412736535072327,
0.38487422466278076,
0.6113244295120239,
0.2493799328804016,
-0.42457327246665955,
-0.07958941161632538,
-0.436257928609848,
-0.7225979566574097,
0.45374220609664917,
0.105230912566185,
0.3187655806541443,
0.09539999812841415,
0.46082228422164917,
-0.027466243132948875,
0.251291424036026,
-0.3591039478778839,
-0.30719897150993347,
-0.17798176407814026,
-0.14871251583099365,
0.30549392104148865,
0.13840655982494354,
0.03691716492176056,
-0.5199533700942993,
0.30775612592697144,
-0.23195423185825348,
0.5194973349571228,
0.026227086782455444,
-0.336874783039093,
0.5851200819015503,
0.3349064290523529,
0.765713632106781,
0.8869122862815857,
0.2646167278289795,
-0.12602698802947998,
-0.06583080440759659,
-0.614093542098999,
-0.14740683138370514,
0.058457210659980774,
-0.16062615811824799,
-0.45136725902557373,
0.5121604800224304,
0.46682223677635193,
0.28053992986679077,
-0.909007728099823,
0.456956684589386,
-0.23491017520427704,
-0.34391582012176514,
-0.608091413974762,
0.09229198843240738,
-0.10238538682460785,
0.5666977763175964,
0.4444250762462616,
0.6993430852890015,
0.41150957345962524,
-0.5191711187362671,
0.2206689864397049,
0.24371469020843506,
-0.44033053517341614,
-0.26283589005470276,
0.41484978795051575,
0.19099006056785583,
-0.3840285837650299,
0.8948262929916382,
-0.36696457862854004,
-0.4663780927658081,
1.1034624576568604,
0.33763960003852844,
1.1855541467666626,
0.29385343194007874,
0.207610622048378,
0.22728589177131653,
0.3791066110134125,
0.2577410638332367,
0.2522982656955719,
-0.41680237650871277,
-0.5906332731246948,
-0.4724355936050415,
-0.4262547492980957,
-0.0316365510225296,
-0.03467094153165817,
-0.6876046061515808,
-0.20426101982593536,
-0.7057301998138428,
-0.19597265124320984,
0.03169902786612511,
0.05197131261229515,
-0.6364350318908691,
0.012317749671638012,
0.6236029863357544,
1.1633864641189575,
-0.3510130047798157,
0.8465325236320496,
0.9103710055351257,
-0.4586000442504883,
-0.3507006764411926,
0.15127874910831451,
-0.029457155615091324,
-0.8423667550086975,
0.84468013048172,
0.22896906733512878,
-0.19725032150745392,
0.1621977537870407,
-0.7380903959274292,
-0.736865758895874,
1.057430386543274,
-0.07512946426868439,
-0.4228259027004242,
-0.37667837738990784,
-0.08463974297046661,
0.6635124683380127,
-0.5026494860649109,
0.32463112473487854,
0.772783637046814,
0.24724572896957397,
-0.352649062871933,
-0.45884549617767334,
-0.10628233850002289,
-0.9242274165153503,
0.27332890033721924,
0.4427492916584015,
-0.39050862193107605,
0.733610987663269,
-0.31070008873939514,
-0.2397453337907791,
0.36866244673728943,
0.7276018857955933,
-0.041026849299669266,
0.6338372230529785,
0.31557804346084595,
0.07671793550252914,
0.36690008640289307,
-0.05160961300134659,
0.7801833748817444,
-0.6525030136108398,
-0.011701676063239574,
0.7259679436683655,
-0.20218731462955475,
0.5057048201560974,
0.22348730266094208,
-0.24492235481739044,
0.6767980456352234,
0.462594598531723,
-0.35048335790634155,
0.14386019110679626,
0.3214888870716095,
-0.051783692091703415,
-0.2719428837299347,
-0.17962662875652313,
-0.33463674783706665,
0.37613537907600403,
0.43809276819229126,
-0.27112919092178345,
0.019844023510813713,
0.0008238578448072076,
-0.2574196457862854,
0.3071061670780182,
-0.5218033790588379,
0.693112850189209,
0.028214527294039726,
-0.8332947492599487,
0.378073126077652,
-0.1325693577528,
0.8608081936836243,
-0.5706852674484253,
-0.4121571481227875,
-0.2609976828098297,
0.15556219220161438,
-0.17420543730258942,
-0.7072078585624695,
0.3806595504283905,
-0.056871335953474045,
-0.3851528465747833,
-0.5471066832542419,
0.5580325722694397,
-0.13132244348526,
-0.1408325880765915,
0.3851208984851837,
0.5533945560455322,
-0.19210243225097656,
-0.042920686304569244,
-0.8485710024833679,
0.24296444654464722,
0.007806922309100628,
0.3133489191532135,
0.4153155982494354,
0.15008161962032318,
0.0686049535870552,
0.4094078242778778,
0.784076988697052,
-0.07880948483943939,
0.36234980821609497,
-0.010014396160840988,
0.9624711871147156,
-0.9117045402526855,
-0.23280401527881622,
-0.674039363861084,
0.42916953563690186,
-0.24547278881072998,
-0.8084496855735779,
0.5988122820854187,
0.5106141567230225,
0.8606775403022766,
0.0022511023562401533,
0.6940553784370422,
-0.40590718388557434,
-0.09992136061191559,
-0.3899482190608978,
0.9071232676506042,
-0.36657261848449707,
0.28790464997291565,
-0.07243271172046661,
-0.5526836514472961,
-0.5470004677772522,
0.013369260355830193,
-0.35441678762435913,
0.024881931021809578,
0.5189163684844971,
0.6969728469848633,
0.3655441403388977,
0.2370052933692932,
0.17117784917354584,
-0.19755300879478455,
0.10147275030612946,
0.7521858811378479,
1.1890027523040771,
-0.4284258782863617,
0.44429081678390503,
-0.19707167148590088,
-0.13992592692375183,
-0.19132831692695618,
-0.6176137924194336,
-0.6742411851882935,
-0.694251298904419,
-0.3423731327056885,
-0.13983947038650513,
0.2023068517446518,
1.0200153589248657,
0.8054354190826416,
-0.800492525100708,
-0.2195664942264557,
-0.426398366689682,
0.05563664808869362,
-0.6385721564292908,
-0.17566704750061035,
-0.06597137451171875,
-0.6559112668037415,
-0.4966852068901062,
0.5488063097000122,
0.3062896430492401,
-0.4457454979419708,
-0.31850412487983704,
0.017964206635951996,
-0.19745589792728424,
-0.11486071348190308,
0.7022001147270203,
0.5818116664886475,
-0.4527234733104706,
0.17951302230358124,
0.630489706993103,
-0.2924674451351166,
0.12421435117721558,
1.275341272354126,
-0.7632742524147034,
0.21452566981315613,
0.7313024401664734,
1.2036300897598267,
-0.10272634029388428,
-0.5129567384719849,
0.5806570053100586,
-0.5176916718482971,
-0.21460114419460297,
0.7654163837432861,
0.08174607157707214,
0.01120904739946127,
-0.44904378056526184,
0.4525015652179718,
0.23547795414924622,
-0.648858368396759,
-0.9355162978172302,
0.34692150354385376,
-0.7203757166862488,
-0.548395037651062,
0.779630720615387,
0.07501651346683502,
-0.15855081379413605,
-0.35586676001548767,
0.26812615990638733,
0.16697467863559723,
-0.1591039001941681,
0.7190970778465271,
0.35827648639678955,
-0.3903646767139435,
-0.2940892279148102,
-0.7612126469612122,
0.43736860156059265,
0.35504844784736633,
-0.9236841797828674,
0.04764857888221741,
0.5629833340644836,
-0.05865262821316719,
0.34985435009002686,
0.3725005090236664,
-0.22354790568351746,
0.6053792238235474,
0.28313499689102173,
0.31454962491989136,
-0.1934938132762909,
-0.7175368666648865,
-0.7261278033256531,
0.234847754240036,
-0.023914793506264687,
-0.07073836773633957
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14236v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14236v2
|
A Unified Framework for Model Editing
| 2024-03-21T08:54:24 | 2024-04-22T17:56:13 |
Akshat Gupta, Dev Sajnani, Gopala Anumanchipalli
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
We introduce a unifying framework that brings two leading "locate-and-edit"
model editing techniques -- ROME and MEMIT -- under a single conceptual
umbrella, optimizing for the same goal, which we call the
preservation-memorization objective. ROME uses an equality constraint to
perform one edit at a time, whereas MEMIT employs a more flexible least-square
constraint that allows for batched edits. Following the
preservation-memorization objective, we present Equality-constrained Mass Model
Editing algorithm for Transformers or EMMET, a new batched memory-editing
algorithm that uses a closed-form solution for the equality-constrained version
of the preservation-memorization objective. EMMET is a batched-version of ROME
and is able to perform batched-edits up to a batch-size of 10,000 with very
similar performance to MEMIT across multiple dimensions. With EMMET, we unify
and achieve symmetry within the "locate-and-edit" algorithms, allowing
batched-editing using both objectives.
|
[
-0.20211730897426605,
-0.5916557312011719,
0.6834121942520142,
-0.08612055331468582,
0.13703285157680511,
-0.0711788684129715,
-0.0018696269253268838,
0.0053275045938789845,
0.1580314040184021,
0.6346622109413147,
-0.8198670744895935,
-0.550017774105072,
-0.25359776616096497,
0.13950608670711517,
-0.502112865447998,
0.7036705613136292,
-0.4099475145339966,
0.38356345891952515,
-0.18564346432685852,
-0.4603368043899536,
-0.4563857316970825,
-0.7054700255393982,
-0.5024469494819641,
-0.31726130843162537,
0.36069607734680176,
0.5058704018592834,
0.9876922369003296,
1.0357712507247925,
0.653600811958313,
0.3066498339176178,
-0.5172721743583679,
0.3012898862361908,
-0.13495364785194397,
0.1187688335776329,
-0.6220242381095886,
-0.4938444197177887,
-0.9118461012840271,
0.08415074646472931,
0.9462112188339233,
0.5217936635017395,
-0.13884393870830536,
0.42412295937538147,
-0.292845755815506,
0.6434655785560608,
-0.8123255968093872,
-0.6135929226875305,
-0.6240028738975525,
0.20353995263576508,
0.1289156973361969,
-0.19382359087467194,
-0.4549359083175659,
0.13154849410057068,
-0.3999033570289612,
-0.9595159888267517,
0.5717340111732483,
0.19366005063056946,
0.7838887572288513,
0.5212690830230713,
-0.14750760793685913,
0.009516655467450619,
-1.0089654922485352,
0.722085177898407,
-0.39135366678237915,
0.7468566298484802,
-0.13028636574745178,
0.12728175520896912,
-0.10483869910240173,
-0.7288965582847595,
-0.34620946645736694,
0.40119701623916626,
0.06161218509078026,
0.19500590860843658,
-0.24463766813278198,
0.34202834963798523,
0.6957927942276001,
0.38538050651550293,
-0.4132993817329407,
0.2252984344959259,
-0.6400870680809021,
-0.30155760049819946,
0.4382576048374176,
0.4595678150653839,
0.48240625858306885,
-0.11511870473623276,
-0.26943716406822205,
-0.110137939453125,
-0.8501032590866089,
-0.256897896528244,
0.1738044023513794,
0.1290934532880783,
0.21474000811576843,
0.8966692686080933,
0.07618407905101776,
0.5063039660453796,
0.07502198964357376,
-0.11821147799491882,
-0.31937193870544434,
-0.019931970164179802,
-0.71442711353302,
-0.17455895245075226,
0.3319093585014343,
0.5673500895500183,
-0.23247335851192474,
-0.2185121476650238,
-0.4121951758861542,
0.03657300025224686,
0.2708757221698761,
-0.9293151497840881,
-0.05210068076848984,
-0.05015453323721886,
-0.806139349937439,
0.022233178839087486,
0.24321219325065613,
-0.5391072034835815,
-0.08597224950790405,
-0.6050188541412354,
0.6479366421699524,
-0.052089303731918335,
0.22048364579677582,
0.2451402097940445,
-0.5157862305641174,
-0.28828686475753784,
0.8365782499313354,
-1.141698956489563,
0.397403359413147,
0.7679467797279358,
0.8453247547149658,
0.2423015534877777,
-0.5443704128265381,
-0.4608418047428131,
0.6340693831443787,
-0.17501108348369598,
0.5543665289878845,
-0.6494643092155457,
-0.5489059090614319,
-0.37575456500053406,
-0.022184627130627632,
-0.025156402960419655,
-0.38370269536972046,
0.6142289638519287,
-0.39865419268608093,
0.19491682946681976,
-0.5479297041893005,
-0.7343871593475342,
-0.20397387444972992,
0.18369625508785248,
-0.7724083662033081,
1.063672423362732,
0.3383384943008423,
-0.5631870031356812,
0.4903920590877533,
-0.7142662405967712,
-0.12396997213363647,
-0.6001488566398621,
0.03417166694998741,
-0.6279729008674622,
0.4634164273738861,
0.3166002333164215,
0.2886887192726135,
-0.46537381410598755,
0.23394711315631866,
-0.3464077413082123,
-0.3655170202255249,
-0.06223762035369873,
-0.16257160902023315,
0.592860758304596,
0.26518476009368896,
0.03701413795351982,
0.2392675131559372,
-0.6426898837089539,
-0.196299210190773,
-0.1888541579246521,
-0.39115968346595764,
-0.2949502468109131,
0.12714360654354095,
0.11662708222866058,
0.30765798687934875,
0.10544853657484055,
-0.6295409798622131,
0.8856572508811951,
0.12613776326179504,
0.6020872592926025,
0.9263314008712769,
0.02925262227654457,
0.8931851983070374,
-0.5196725130081177,
0.4756777584552765,
-0.0911821648478508,
0.6234323978424072,
-0.3535917401313782,
-0.017480123788118362,
-0.8128093481063843,
-0.37339675426483154,
0.4687294363975525,
0.45698025822639465,
-0.028521131724119186,
-0.1303945630788803,
-0.17247554659843445,
-0.3323131799697876,
-0.6523520946502686,
0.34509986639022827,
0.28653189539909363,
0.2805802524089813,
0.6086973547935486,
-0.1680658459663391,
-0.8274803757667542,
-1.2014731168746948,
-0.4900423288345337,
0.11187700182199478,
0.055131539702415466,
0.017808973789215088,
0.6130329370498657,
-0.4949205219745636,
0.8544606566429138,
-0.5857990384101868,
-0.43426060676574707,
0.11319205164909363,
0.017895039170980453,
-0.012587503530085087,
0.8901298642158508,
0.5385674238204956,
-0.7490423917770386,
-0.25800609588623047,
-0.2332526296377182,
-0.7924460768699646,
-0.2094806283712387,
-0.4799495041370392,
-0.29577356576919556,
0.005712122656404972,
0.8887209892272949,
-0.5151276588439941,
0.7006499767303467,
0.30982038378715515,
-0.27830979228019714,
0.34091717004776,
-0.45362791419029236,
0.6090266704559326,
-1.3718544244766235,
-0.12409890443086624,
-0.4427441954612732,
-0.25866788625717163,
-0.5921730995178223,
0.24128368496894836,
0.5074849724769592,
-0.2670077085494995,
-0.3596946597099304,
0.6047680974006653,
-0.8789610862731934,
-0.32686513662338257,
0.11939453333616257,
0.050606902688741684,
0.3522661030292511,
0.32323023676872253,
-0.36087626218795776,
0.5444160103797913,
0.31088319420814514,
-0.5333711504936218,
-0.17952576279640198,
0.7044689059257507,
0.1291159838438034,
0.8115274906158447,
-0.5596796274185181,
0.2963685393333435,
-0.24874982237815857,
0.04286749288439751,
-0.49704819917678833,
0.029124494642019272,
-0.10884218662977219,
-0.21116706728935242,
0.44451427459716797,
-0.27367061376571655,
-0.6301506757736206,
-0.23753780126571655,
-0.2871537506580353,
0.524501621723175,
0.18553313612937927,
-0.7881883978843689,
0.9240168333053589,
0.20995722711086273,
0.2856559157371521,
-0.7566694617271423,
-0.7686827778816223,
-0.11822156608104706,
-0.2343367487192154,
-0.8281765580177307,
0.5835890173912048,
-0.17446333169937134,
-0.4989711046218872,
0.1937599927186966,
-0.4229830503463745,
-0.11020524054765701,
0.11650490015745163,
0.4931612014770508,
0.5898817777633667,
-0.017811279743909836,
0.1470538079738617,
0.6375625729560852,
-0.3098249137401581,
-0.4179902970790863,
-0.2479567527770996,
0.10454516112804413,
0.15853117406368256,
-0.45761600136756897,
-0.5061622858047485,
0.4351453483104706,
0.9937302470207214,
-0.3248339295387268,
0.4235398471355438,
0.2584969699382782,
-0.5779047608375549,
-0.20208150148391724,
-0.7396594285964966,
-0.2518612742424011,
-0.4623144865036011,
0.3698370158672333,
-0.7758159041404724,
-1.1385383605957031,
0.7514439821243286,
-0.31739482283592224,
0.6062694787979126,
0.6434571146965027,
0.29624414443969727,
-0.13384848833084106,
1.175596833229065,
0.8084339499473572,
0.04386703670024872,
0.4217567443847656,
-0.16841039061546326,
-0.06054629385471344,
-1.306075930595398,
-0.044689614325761795,
-0.673803985118866,
-0.7710637450218201,
-0.15979254245758057,
-0.45908668637275696,
0.3427596688270569,
0.544601559638977,
-0.4567781090736389,
0.5759938359260559,
-0.7010853886604309,
0.573854923248291,
0.46574559807777405,
0.13657070696353912,
0.5073700547218323,
-0.09548068791627884,
-0.36305221915245056,
-0.4174824059009552,
-0.7088472843170166,
-0.5849436521530151,
1.2820104360580444,
0.07628995925188065,
0.9233446717262268,
0.07977704703807831,
0.8700103163719177,
0.29908281564712524,
0.4202460050582886,
-0.42619988322257996,
0.45858535170555115,
-0.24072635173797607,
-1.109166145324707,
-0.2871531844139099,
-0.18017072975635529,
-0.5106662511825562,
0.3836385905742645,
-0.28995463252067566,
-0.8126247525215149,
0.15479250252246857,
0.3920619487762451,
-0.24930807948112488,
1.1566941738128662,
-0.42889153957366943,
0.9503865838050842,
-0.022149117663502693,
-0.3110353350639343,
-0.4706859588623047,
-0.4347380995750427,
0.08428019285202026,
-0.02218393050134182,
0.17102597653865814,
-0.13534042239189148,
-0.1422746330499649,
0.5297158360481262,
-0.6018258333206177,
0.17404308915138245,
-0.03218478336930275,
0.3619241714477539,
0.06399498879909515,
0.5227163434028625,
0.4307485520839691,
0.08110963553190231,
-0.25960853695869446,
-0.045361801981925964,
0.005446714349091053,
-0.08285413682460785,
-1.071144938468933,
0.4976235628128052,
-0.5618860721588135,
-0.5797551274299622,
-0.056709617376327515,
-0.9038416743278503,
0.3110872209072113,
0.16046351194381714,
0.30665627121925354,
0.6650543808937073,
-0.6853850483894348,
0.1709824651479721,
0.3548678755760193,
-0.03319527208805084,
0.5149728059768677,
0.6123287081718445,
-0.4518291652202606,
-0.44289278984069824,
0.4334990084171295,
0.3137260675430298,
0.4382837414741516,
0.7882358431816101,
0.05497981607913971,
0.022892247885465622,
-0.34279829263687134,
-0.6840821504592896,
0.024903345853090286,
-0.8227507472038269,
-0.13638123869895935,
-0.6830132007598877,
0.11569014191627502,
-0.13887928426265717,
-0.9314934611320496,
-0.8630273342132568,
-0.8735724687576294,
-0.30361130833625793,
0.16434265673160553,
0.07248716801404953,
0.7180994749069214,
-0.5864678621292114,
0.5010518431663513,
-0.7748986482620239,
0.3974200487136841,
0.17381031811237335,
0.1983354687690735,
-0.3658500909805298,
-0.7760945558547974,
-0.2585381269454956,
0.08854171633720398,
-0.503105103969574,
-0.9502941370010376,
0.211271271109581,
0.08618731796741486,
0.36365509033203125,
0.38054198026657104,
-0.22242766618728638,
1.1095085144042969,
-0.44724327325820923,
0.24030297994613647,
0.1528940498828888,
-1.3933700323104858,
0.512516438961029,
-0.3837120831012726,
0.19410915672779083,
0.6727417707443237,
-0.14301146566867828,
-0.8571537733078003,
-0.20949313044548035,
-0.8004093766212463,
-0.3519720137119293,
0.9008805751800537,
0.20238202810287476,
-0.07148699462413788,
0.4498467743396759,
0.7101010084152222,
-0.060236528515815735,
0.299091100692749,
-0.49781376123428345,
-0.40103879570961,
0.12247276306152344,
0.06302880495786667,
0.22810456156730652,
-0.38622501492500305,
-0.15607306361198425,
-0.7731983065605164,
0.823218584060669,
0.2739237844944,
0.2865009903907776,
0.44238975644111633,
-0.5432540774345398,
-0.4217394292354584,
0.48117366433143616,
0.685461163520813,
0.8270611763000488,
-0.3728977143764496,
-0.10874329507350922,
0.4176340401172638,
-0.3430706560611725,
0.37297242879867554,
-0.2783282697200775,
-0.9024271965026855,
0.07573466747999191,
-0.1790870875120163,
0.8353596329689026,
0.6879756450653076,
-0.29263541102409363,
0.008463794365525246,
0.0765850841999054,
-0.4966724216938019,
-0.09132344275712967,
0.03897347301244736,
-0.07282163947820663,
0.51666259765625,
0.17609547078609467,
0.5875405669212341,
0.17585919797420502,
-0.3286714553833008,
0.24610301852226257,
0.29892057180404663,
-0.15176130831241608,
-0.22317549586296082,
1.4016772508621216,
-0.31761157512664795,
-0.5760435461997986,
0.9060169458389282,
0.031484249979257584,
-0.5379183292388916,
0.5186567306518555,
0.5013726353645325,
1.0452914237976074,
-0.6482398509979248,
0.10989465564489365,
0.7326695322990417,
0.7216870784759521,
-0.42121753096580505,
0.23898780345916748,
0.16100133955478668,
-0.7384511232376099,
0.03802556172013283,
-0.41789934039115906,
-0.5672295689582825,
-0.2270059734582901,
-0.9249335527420044,
0.6721309423446655,
-0.8172817230224609,
-0.13273318111896515,
0.15440528094768524,
-0.508808970451355,
-0.6235261559486389,
0.29412931203842163,
-0.37775591015815735,
0.7099574208259583,
-0.6897263526916504,
0.5149815082550049,
0.82798832654953,
-0.30659347772598267,
-0.9816493391990662,
-0.68690025806427,
0.45518094301223755,
-0.4331267178058624,
0.09189516305923462,
0.19752004742622375,
0.2771105170249939,
0.10809313505887985,
-0.5388763546943665,
-0.8096961975097656,
1.4759808778762817,
0.7118655443191528,
-0.7492340207099915,
-0.17599175870418549,
-0.1759096384048462,
0.12074685841798782,
-0.42517638206481934,
0.13346755504608154,
0.6257179975509644,
0.6724118590354919,
0.10805290937423706,
-0.8496027588844299,
-0.19066397845745087,
-0.1990344077348709,
-0.1497431993484497,
0.7650237083435059,
-0.7136883735656738,
1.373382806777954,
-0.45970749855041504,
-0.22087635099887848,
0.2514084279537201,
0.44027116894721985,
-0.0818544402718544,
0.24128101766109467,
0.36473143100738525,
1.2210484743118286,
0.7710829973220825,
-0.1824273318052292,
0.6316664814949036,
-0.10442357510328293,
0.6348048448562622,
1.2929033041000366,
0.042412616312503815,
0.7255222201347351,
0.4119111895561218,
-0.08068437874317169,
0.1854414939880371,
0.6354809999465942,
-0.559583306312561,
0.031191566959023476,
-0.13897842168807983,
-0.14802177250385284,
-0.25513628125190735,
0.40036845207214355,
-0.11718481034040451,
0.5208753943443298,
0.06191909685730934,
-0.6927125453948975,
-0.3461197018623352,
-0.15383100509643555,
0.4627442955970764,
0.05881679058074951,
-0.5054793953895569,
0.4193096160888672,
-0.09646371752023697,
-0.5613327026367188,
0.262085884809494,
0.6082301139831543,
0.13927370309829712,
-0.15315283834934235,
-0.00781698152422905,
-0.09069229662418365,
0.2972854673862457,
-0.2458074539899826,
-0.216478168964386,
0.4775487780570984,
-0.17248237133026123,
-0.7436633706092834,
-0.43286365270614624,
0.509675145149231,
-0.4895831346511841,
-0.6437999606132507,
0.25341054797172546,
0.4000011086463928,
-0.01669429987668991,
-0.3363490700721741,
-0.8547101616859436,
0.19015243649482727,
0.07708588987588882,
-0.2641710042953491,
0.12771250307559967,
0.051520153880119324,
-0.17514047026634216,
0.554058849811554,
0.5677098035812378,
-0.27074626088142395,
0.11456973105669022,
0.04237895458936691,
0.7839058637619019,
-0.7087063193321228,
-0.34941163659095764,
-1.091195821762085,
0.7388504147529602,
0.05817635357379913,
-0.4105038046836853,
0.6438136100769043,
0.9656457304954529,
0.7531772255897522,
-0.22790515422821045,
0.5486295223236084,
0.03916541114449501,
0.21287038922309875,
-0.5512052178382874,
0.6224070191383362,
-0.9408347606658936,
-0.016868719831109047,
-0.7612139582633972,
-1.5234736204147339,
-0.44873401522636414,
0.6196093559265137,
-0.050061121582984924,
-0.2672172784805298,
0.9439811706542969,
1.1790224313735962,
-0.33624643087387085,
-0.015699535608291626,
0.4866216778755188,
0.05934784561395645,
0.1073177233338356,
0.5862928628921509,
0.6488882899284363,
-0.7400431036949158,
0.0996599793434143,
-0.3040233850479126,
0.09326190501451492,
0.08277644217014313,
-0.6825948357582092,
-0.9919957518577576,
-0.6828799247741699,
-0.28593310713768005,
-0.0773467868566513,
-0.0176033154129982,
1.0525529384613037,
0.7315686345100403,
-0.5130298733711243,
-0.20470616221427917,
0.04113408923149109,
0.09284605830907822,
-0.10388677567243576,
-0.050345275551080704,
0.4360872805118561,
0.052985336631536484,
-1.0794867277145386,
0.3513294458389282,
0.8484174013137817,
0.1559663563966751,
0.09308886528015137,
-0.296670138835907,
-0.15929433703422546,
0.13654226064682007,
0.30880579352378845,
0.47830337285995483,
-0.5948019623756409,
-0.1340094804763794,
0.14658810198307037,
0.06576304882764816,
0.19649574160575867,
1.1561167240142822,
-0.11488447338342667,
0.9217208623886108,
0.33723652362823486,
0.48045870661735535,
0.6953936815261841,
0.2410009205341339,
0.6456401348114014,
-0.46479332447052,
0.44404685497283936,
-0.050787344574928284,
0.7162825465202332,
0.24127018451690674,
-0.2033447027206421,
0.7472986578941345,
0.3147808015346527,
-0.6327885389328003,
-0.9382492899894714,
0.02200399339199066,
-0.9590020179748535,
-0.16780878603458405,
0.8195694088935852,
0.04139457643032074,
0.037322379648685455,
0.2197936773300171,
-0.42182400822639465,
0.6352474093437195,
-0.038127608597278595,
0.6267998218536377,
0.721309244632721,
0.04424171894788742,
-0.15639778971672058,
-0.6566194891929626,
0.2592235207557678,
0.6126949787139893,
-0.6972398161888123,
-0.16574996709823608,
0.8766571283340454,
0.1978788524866104,
-0.007536533288657665,
0.3909679055213928,
-0.34070658683776855,
0.5807879567146301,
0.018880529329180717,
0.5999858379364014,
-0.4566039443016052,
-0.6559028625488281,
-0.24082393944263458,
0.10340806096792221,
-0.20277178287506104,
0.07811320573091507
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15486v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15486v1
|
Sequence-to-Sequence Language Models for Character and Emotion Detection in Dream Narratives
| 2024-03-21T08:27:49 | 2024-03-21T08:27:49 |
Gustave Cortal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The study of dreams has been central to understanding human
(un)consciousness, cognition, and culture for centuries. Analyzing dreams
quantitatively depends on labor-intensive, manual annotation of dream
narratives. We automate this process through a natural language
sequence-to-sequence generation framework. This paper presents the first study
on character and emotion detection in the English portion of the open DreamBank
corpus of dream narratives. Our results show that language models can
effectively address this complex task. To get insight into prediction
performance, we evaluate the impact of model size, prediction order of
characters, and the consideration of proper names and character traits. We
compare our approach with a large language model using in-context learning. Our
supervised models perform better while having 28 times fewer parameters. Our
model and its generated annotations are made publicly available.
|
[
-0.1925172209739685,
-0.3184652030467987,
0.5546069741249084,
-0.0017845070688053966,
-0.30487117171287537,
-0.003491207491606474,
-0.09487216919660568,
-0.8706796169281006,
0.2128347009420395,
0.8490362763404846,
-0.5393754839897156,
-0.5470479130744934,
-0.3407622277736664,
0.42605412006378174,
-0.23694981634616852,
0.6946180462837219,
-0.09538519382476807,
-0.08667690306901932,
-0.09905243664979935,
0.14376305043697357,
-0.4249853789806366,
-0.6465335488319397,
-0.6039800047874451,
0.1421722024679184,
0.329784631729126,
0.14200404286384583,
0.5229479074478149,
0.3404605984687805,
0.447508841753006,
0.2816667854785919,
0.31290024518966675,
0.11063637584447861,
-0.43664297461509705,
0.45678994059562683,
0.2881011962890625,
-0.43091824650764465,
-0.3027119040489197,
-0.2681517004966736,
0.619864821434021,
0.5106918811798096,
0.23140762746334076,
0.05249405279755592,
0.020159486681222916,
0.844196617603302,
-0.4364489018917084,
0.3966873288154602,
-0.17023034393787384,
0.37678274512290955,
-0.29654988646507263,
-0.10134425014257431,
-0.6041132211685181,
-0.5977164506912231,
-0.0058877430856227875,
-0.08102916926145554,
0.3609679937362671,
0.4047384262084961,
0.7014875411987305,
0.061704423278570175,
-0.513739824295044,
-0.46229666471481323,
-0.49333882331848145,
0.6869091391563416,
-0.601860523223877,
0.2650745213031769,
0.25009530782699585,
0.21142521500587463,
-0.0034091987181454897,
-0.4065145254135132,
-0.5357402563095093,
-0.31027528643608093,
-0.3295658230781555,
0.0566757433116436,
-0.06367694586515427,
0.3452065885066986,
0.3062320053577423,
0.33574172854423523,
-0.739223062992096,
0.0813811868429184,
-0.24881860613822937,
-0.1708160936832428,
1.031361699104309,
0.4756866693496704,
0.31031298637390137,
-0.7192022800445557,
-0.1622745543718338,
-0.09611765295267105,
-0.33504021167755127,
0.09937664866447449,
0.6914730668067932,
0.4704771637916565,
-0.1579407900571823,
0.5442713499069214,
-0.10313935577869415,
0.5331155061721802,
-0.22405947744846344,
0.10361401736736298,
0.16136309504508972,
0.2173173576593399,
-0.2745465338230133,
0.2823648750782013,
0.8073264360427856,
0.31524020433425903,
0.49832549691200256,
-0.11088011413812637,
-0.3570529520511627,
0.16915298998355865,
0.27318477630615234,
-0.7553574442863464,
-0.05326433479785919,
0.3370354473590851,
-0.709089457988739,
-0.4501815140247345,
-0.028674563392996788,
-0.9566939473152161,
-0.7298530340194702,
-0.2631072700023651,
0.11479832977056503,
-0.6019668579101562,
-0.3152846395969391,
0.16802939772605896,
0.08023679256439209,
0.04641878977417946,
0.18585649132728577,
-0.8492026329040527,
0.031543128192424774,
0.4911617934703827,
0.6056684255599976,
-0.1561480462551117,
0.16206344962120056,
-0.0848144069314003,
-0.29433342814445496,
-0.41813647747039795,
0.6089800000190735,
-0.530436635017395,
-0.38639286160469055,
0.1898679882287979,
-0.15456271171569824,
-0.24207328259944916,
-0.12679652869701385,
0.5423065423965454,
-0.31050583720207214,
0.2645289897918701,
-0.1311151385307312,
-0.9377726316452026,
-0.34110864996910095,
-0.18354642391204834,
-0.6883777379989624,
0.46708834171295166,
0.07753410190343857,
-0.5488040447235107,
0.09195172786712646,
-0.7935241460800171,
-0.4751424789428711,
0.26578474044799805,
0.005117719992995262,
-0.21319888532161713,
0.6401686668395996,
0.10121230036020279,
0.830025315284729,
-0.2599722743034363,
0.2853214144706726,
0.008997746743261814,
-0.3529459536075592,
0.29352107644081116,
-0.2380302995443344,
0.5229796767234802,
0.6623792052268982,
0.042595598846673965,
-0.05509341135621071,
-0.6279011964797974,
-0.09130833297967911,
0.3631008267402649,
-0.04228267818689346,
-0.11830724775791168,
0.11685178428888321,
0.26353225111961365,
-0.16436345875263214,
-0.07891759276390076,
-0.4988780915737152,
0.012924772687256336,
-0.36288657784461975,
-0.03271685913205147,
0.4075472056865692,
0.026140566915273666,
0.13652342557907104,
-0.12026732414960861,
0.8741578459739685,
-0.037162769585847855,
-0.21956440806388855,
-0.5977234244346619,
-0.4544171094894409,
-0.5840128064155579,
-0.1996503472328186,
0.1588423103094101,
0.38128048181533813,
-0.4237951934337616,
0.5667449831962585,
0.099402517080307,
-0.2031286209821701,
-0.6336143612861633,
-0.44976240396499634,
0.5360252857208252,
0.33860117197036743,
0.22012123465538025,
-0.38303595781326294,
-0.7744764089584351,
-0.5526217222213745,
-0.5163747668266296,
-0.2942045032978058,
-0.11815103143453598,
0.1466517448425293,
0.310740202665329,
-0.10682127624750137,
1.0126564502716064,
-0.6525312066078186,
-0.1130351722240448,
-0.44275495409965515,
0.5091416835784912,
-0.013103766366839409,
0.43365657329559326,
0.7892040610313416,
-0.8543490171432495,
-0.41093140840530396,
-0.1283414512872696,
-0.9467397928237915,
-0.16965213418006897,
0.045411616563797,
0.10362239181995392,
0.5806097984313965,
0.24034304916858673,
-0.2527768909931183,
0.41804003715515137,
0.4343077540397644,
-0.6129196882247925,
0.5921424627304077,
0.24396978318691254,
0.4528719484806061,
-1.2645394802093506,
0.07268892228603363,
0.251780241727829,
-0.22164471447467804,
-0.7731870412826538,
-0.176785409450531,
0.07801514863967896,
-0.34844207763671875,
-0.26925230026245117,
0.6204110383987427,
-0.4300505816936493,
-0.21250726282596588,
-0.15268397331237793,
-0.12886843085289001,
0.00704698683694005,
0.4899127781391144,
0.6138818264007568,
0.202235147356987,
0.36256057024002075,
-0.30192503333091736,
0.28072333335876465,
0.2447468340396881,
-0.6993723511695862,
0.5771158337593079,
-0.16014932096004486,
0.2716972827911377,
-0.552656352519989,
0.007855992764234543,
-1.0597649812698364,
-0.5319868922233582,
0.07453154772520065,
-0.5452358722686768,
0.4756225049495697,
-0.34912577271461487,
-0.3875681161880493,
-0.4480406939983368,
0.17061558365821838,
0.06124255061149597,
0.7940872311592102,
-0.31045958399772644,
0.5511748790740967,
0.21278636157512665,
-0.2434985190629959,
-0.34182706475257874,
-0.3974403738975525,
0.20654144883155823,
-0.2387227565050125,
-0.5603165626525879,
0.09453457593917847,
-0.026692518964409828,
-0.32934218645095825,
-0.1720789521932602,
0.08345627039670944,
-0.14610639214515686,
-0.0667109340429306,
0.46311697363853455,
0.2803623080253601,
-0.3319961428642273,
0.22837300598621368,
0.14871591329574585,
-0.03164473548531532,
0.1414070427417755,
-0.06773705035448074,
0.37205931544303894,
-0.18178041279315948,
-0.2024194747209549,
-0.28107091784477234,
0.5009658336639404,
0.588603138923645,
-0.23607182502746582,
0.552366316318512,
0.4624811112880707,
-0.6365771889686584,
-0.08340505510568619,
-0.46357592940330505,
-0.026559224352240562,
-0.37925779819488525,
0.4973633885383606,
-0.5217143297195435,
-0.7263750433921814,
0.39898189902305603,
0.05373569205403328,
-0.10566386580467224,
0.49061116576194763,
0.2863387167453766,
-0.4677445888519287,
0.9535332322120667,
0.6219087839126587,
0.06524436175823212,
0.4668084681034088,
-0.03570578619837761,
0.192628413438797,
-0.6164640784263611,
-0.012708327732980251,
-0.4537101984024048,
-0.434345543384552,
-0.260676771402359,
-0.25407129526138306,
0.13679563999176025,
0.0714116320014,
0.009003717452287674,
0.41972100734710693,
-0.26510101556777954,
0.654956042766571,
-0.045653317123651505,
-0.10663881152868271,
0.10500568151473999,
-0.15672920644283295,
0.053866416215896606,
-0.11578280478715897,
-0.1414240300655365,
-0.7549592852592468,
1.014554500579834,
0.34594231843948364,
0.5411452054977417,
-0.02260994352400303,
0.9122406244277954,
0.38273847103118896,
0.21217237412929535,
-0.5134080052375793,
0.5918049812316895,
-0.19317714869976044,
-0.47515127062797546,
-0.26813364028930664,
-0.28541308641433716,
-0.8653550148010254,
0.0706983283162117,
-0.22821302711963654,
-1.111279845237732,
0.20625334978103638,
0.14702345430850983,
-0.6641210317611694,
0.3402860462665558,
-0.8091430068016052,
0.9963498711585999,
-0.14235325157642365,
-0.05214318633079529,
-0.22129712998867035,
-0.8261206746101379,
0.5967179536819458,
-0.14283280074596405,
0.015295789577066898,
-0.25239670276641846,
0.4112113118171692,
0.6151415705680847,
-0.20226626098155975,
0.9750840067863464,
-0.1986323446035385,
0.051219407469034195,
0.5146175622940063,
0.41992804408073425,
0.4738614559173584,
-0.2044205516576767,
-0.42947250604629517,
0.13655655086040497,
-0.11596314609050751,
-0.04619825631380081,
-0.2590457499027252,
0.3613753616809845,
-0.518406867980957,
-0.12773136794567108,
-0.34757286310195923,
-0.6949836611747742,
-0.18668150901794434,
-0.32576698064804077,
0.31155309081077576,
0.34088408946990967,
-0.4829246699810028,
-0.08775267750024796,
0.5197781324386597,
-0.3271309435367584,
0.5943869352340698,
0.4544997811317444,
-0.5392133593559265,
-0.1392146199941635,
0.5586214065551758,
-0.017267722636461258,
0.10594377666711807,
0.5252490639686584,
0.16913171112537384,
-0.30595216155052185,
-0.33194443583488464,
-0.20227892696857452,
0.040592461824417114,
-0.6581307649612427,
-0.15183180570602417,
-0.9175872206687927,
-0.13756048679351807,
-0.4803343415260315,
-0.2308182418346405,
-0.3173448145389557,
-0.21097858250141144,
-0.2606810927391052,
-0.23749572038650513,
0.5250188708305359,
0.7859570384025574,
0.17769509553909302,
0.11101289838552475,
-1.0238577127456665,
0.35786324739456177,
0.032345663756132126,
0.318817138671875,
-0.08310238271951675,
-0.46130451560020447,
-0.15958133339881897,
-0.11020410060882568,
-0.09309232234954834,
-1.0834159851074219,
0.7642019987106323,
0.1759391725063324,
0.015776410698890686,
0.5280197858810425,
0.3460371196269989,
0.43211284279823303,
-0.19166404008865356,
0.7366386651992798,
0.10273021459579468,
-1.014657735824585,
0.6838271617889404,
-0.18842008709907532,
0.03882993385195732,
0.218928262591362,
0.4708991050720215,
-0.9077693819999695,
-0.2321666181087494,
-0.43489670753479004,
-0.5433735251426697,
0.8694331049919128,
0.24878409504890442,
0.14832347631454468,
-0.10676509141921997,
0.3830704689025879,
0.4339335262775421,
0.3289615511894226,
-0.5003651976585388,
0.09993817657232285,
-0.005065594799816608,
-0.6150916814804077,
-0.2396186888217926,
-0.36931079626083374,
0.5104328989982605,
0.07025276869535446,
0.30100855231285095,
-0.3277049958705902,
0.4886263608932495,
-0.0024773639161139727,
-0.3690771758556366,
-0.5709319114685059,
0.05890577286481857,
0.46252763271331787,
0.029486805200576782,
-0.32003113627433777,
-0.2992745339870453,
0.03590225428342819,
-0.33897361159324646,
-0.26468294858932495,
0.03487936034798622,
0.04019349440932274,
0.1289065182209015,
0.38734328746795654,
1.3334035873413086,
0.21964654326438904,
-0.7371880412101746,
0.3765762448310852,
-0.057832021266222,
0.061230238527059555,
-0.3782614767551422,
0.026868410408496857,
-0.03608816862106323,
0.5701041221618652,
0.14406009018421173,
0.2097795009613037,
0.3013957142829895,
-0.6261292099952698,
0.04271698370575905,
0.09700339287519455,
-0.4251739978790283,
-0.43625766038894653,
0.6744672656059265,
0.31700369715690613,
-0.4780665636062622,
0.7434560060501099,
-0.344117671251297,
-0.6741584539413452,
0.9361478686332703,
0.5438014268875122,
1.3223259449005127,
-0.3514863848686218,
0.25141850113868713,
0.5062462091445923,
-0.07781676948070526,
-0.11153197288513184,
0.6516864895820618,
0.16942445933818817,
-0.7764520645141602,
-0.2734133005142212,
-1.031126618385315,
-0.5949313640594482,
-0.1719006448984146,
-0.5867627859115601,
0.4303072690963745,
-0.019874487072229385,
0.04855750501155853,
-0.22455747425556183,
-0.1029483824968338,
-0.7832337021827698,
0.5195801258087158,
0.937247633934021,
0.515907883644104,
-0.9297531247138977,
0.8101052045822144,
0.50440514087677,
-0.4045630693435669,
-0.6568511724472046,
0.02623055875301361,
0.10260622948408127,
-0.6073969006538391,
0.6909330487251282,
0.5809267163276672,
0.2594238221645355,
0.311195433139801,
-0.229156956076622,
-0.6793259382247925,
0.8790643215179443,
0.42075076699256897,
-0.825709342956543,
-0.21861767768859863,
0.27625465393066406,
0.7430539727210999,
-0.6579579710960388,
0.3584168553352356,
0.4557414650917053,
0.27633047103881836,
0.19258973002433777,
-0.6263537406921387,
-0.25798752903938293,
-0.04840574786067009,
0.05558306351304054,
0.48512783646583557,
-0.3032572269439697,
0.6323541402816772,
-0.4779646396636963,
-0.33981236815452576,
0.1570432335138321,
0.9386287927627563,
0.0324765108525753,
0.2990112602710724,
0.4956868588924408,
0.31754952669143677,
0.8316822052001953,
-0.24123282730579376,
1.1830295324325562,
-0.4577454924583435,
0.23710380494594574,
0.8428710103034973,
-0.5099908113479614,
0.7269921898841858,
0.002673788694664836,
-0.2576766312122345,
0.5188860297203064,
0.8129599094390869,
0.13177399337291718,
0.30603086948394775,
0.5159982442855835,
-0.07371260970830917,
-0.1183694526553154,
-0.06593643873929977,
-0.11213600635528564,
0.4410487115383148,
0.3796699345111847,
-0.5139452219009399,
0.20427359640598297,
0.45394468307495117,
-0.06185842305421829,
0.034269314259290695,
-0.3892710506916046,
0.5736360549926758,
0.1695428043603897,
-0.7790094614028931,
0.01935346983373165,
-0.23800057172775269,
0.49456170201301575,
-0.6833915710449219,
0.039207156747579575,
-0.3523808419704437,
-0.007993757724761963,
-0.042987871915102005,
-0.841774046421051,
0.4222474694252014,
0.39365777373313904,
0.06689415127038956,
-0.37222820520401,
0.8219860196113586,
-0.6379504799842834,
-0.5379692316055298,
0.14796018600463867,
0.12345321476459503,
0.49025192856788635,
-0.3874114751815796,
-0.2743585705757141,
0.03372989967465401,
-0.08903177082538605,
-0.4257279634475708,
0.1410469263792038,
0.3978164792060852,
-0.12055685371160507,
0.2932339906692505,
0.17583182454109192,
-0.31194618344306946,
-0.0590507835149765,
0.10678902268409729,
0.06216319277882576,
-0.7717964053153992,
-0.5835468173027039,
-0.7884251475334167,
0.7992892265319824,
0.13216769695281982,
-0.23671649396419525,
0.18081791698932648,
0.37956517934799194,
0.47591766715049744,
-0.4906603991985321,
0.870769739151001,
-0.2879228889942169,
0.29053425788879395,
-0.5137436389923096,
0.7803955078125,
-0.4882625341415405,
-0.18512888252735138,
-0.5254979133605957,
-0.9020285606384277,
-0.2401285469532013,
0.3867095708847046,
-0.033350247889757156,
-0.014204061590135098,
0.7025960087776184,
0.4805009067058563,
0.4496583640575409,
0.37366294860839844,
0.6285008192062378,
0.06861154735088348,
0.05714987590909004,
0.7846911549568176,
0.7109695076942444,
-0.42519283294677734,
0.09534943103790283,
-0.10444959998130798,
0.0187863577157259,
-0.4408668279647827,
-0.9910092353820801,
-0.8872613906860352,
-0.7292417883872986,
-0.5270765423774719,
-0.24954815208911896,
0.06193812936544418,
1.2856049537658691,
0.37677785754203796,
-0.9730445742607117,
-0.3653319776058197,
0.09583015739917755,
-0.06132148206233978,
-0.23992978036403656,
-0.1645260751247406,
0.30111053586006165,
-0.41226083040237427,
-0.8977579474449158,
0.4680846929550171,
0.2942502796649933,
0.3011026084423065,
-0.022903891280293465,
-0.3209737539291382,
0.2561855912208557,
0.3548887073993683,
0.5116967558860779,
0.2558426558971405,
-0.7216002941131592,
-0.39641475677490234,
-0.13942685723304749,
-0.2215348184108734,
0.04164144769310951,
0.7169639468193054,
-0.5958678126335144,
0.606436550617218,
0.4755716323852539,
0.31038060784339905,
0.29123562574386597,
-0.17892399430274963,
0.7749048471450806,
-0.8724427223205566,
-0.0656934529542923,
0.45901215076446533,
0.6764792203903198,
0.1883847862482071,
-0.5665928721427917,
0.7045322060585022,
0.21127019822597504,
-0.3937225043773651,
-0.8214794397354126,
0.37013331055641174,
-0.8332644701004028,
-0.1301734447479248,
0.7822554111480713,
-0.2051467001438141,
0.004666502587497234,
0.12904983758926392,
-0.463225781917572,
0.46648019552230835,
-0.22575221955776215,
0.7389428615570068,
0.5871426463127136,
-0.2174992859363556,
-0.2715184986591339,
-0.4394880533218384,
0.6018518209457397,
0.3016706705093384,
-0.8344831466674805,
0.24613462388515472,
0.5852797031402588,
-0.33210307359695435,
0.05195941403508186,
0.41384145617485046,
0.08880092948675156,
-0.020681869238615036,
-0.061415646225214005,
0.6278330683708191,
0.08054079115390778,
-0.31430745124816895,
-0.383344441652298,
0.35965099930763245,
-0.22619575262069702,
-0.16195735335350037
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14222v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14222v1
|
Large-Scale Label Interpretation Learning for Few-Shot Named Entity Recognition
| 2024-03-21T08:22:44 | 2024-03-21T08:22:44 |
Jonas Golde, Felix Hamborg, Alan Akbik
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Few-shot named entity recognition (NER) detects named entities within text
using only a few annotated examples. One promising line of research is to
leverage natural language descriptions of each entity type: the common label
PER might, for example, be verbalized as ''person entity.'' In an initial label
interpretation learning phase, the model learns to interpret such verbalized
descriptions of entity types. In a subsequent few-shot tagset extension phase,
this model is then given a description of a previously unseen entity type (such
as ''music album'') and optionally a few training examples to perform few-shot
NER for this type. In this paper, we systematically explore the impact of a
strong semantic prior to interpret verbalizations of new entity types by
massively scaling up the number and granularity of entity types used for label
interpretation learning. To this end, we leverage an entity linking benchmark
to create a dataset with orders of magnitude of more distinct entity types and
descriptions as currently used datasets. We find that this increased signal
yields strong results in zero- and few-shot NER in in-domain, cross-domain, and
even cross-lingual settings. Our findings indicate significant potential for
improving few-shot NER through heuristical data-based optimization.
|
[
-0.4752092659473419,
-0.5215163230895996,
0.4393627643585205,
-0.21484339237213135,
-0.20994515717029572,
-0.1931062489748001,
-0.20264914631843567,
-0.8358302712440491,
0.12681975960731506,
0.515408992767334,
-0.4024238586425781,
-0.5814920663833618,
-0.7310802340507507,
0.3178921043872833,
-0.11525679379701614,
1.3505107164382935,
0.11995051056146622,
-0.09642031788825989,
0.09932788461446762,
-0.11525548249483109,
-0.3237473964691162,
0.04290320724248886,
-0.8301659822463989,
-0.6056323647499084,
0.7809272408485413,
0.4631081223487854,
0.5344309210777283,
0.4154873788356781,
0.6929605603218079,
0.17132697999477386,
-0.17663776874542236,
-0.12023276090621948,
-0.689258873462677,
-0.2003200650215149,
-0.10870546847581863,
-0.5407094359397888,
-0.5167402625083923,
-0.1898188441991806,
0.9954811334609985,
0.8111830949783325,
0.20690953731536865,
0.32684993743896484,
-0.10702679306268692,
0.2929462790489197,
-0.7463870644569397,
0.31708237528800964,
-0.9237673282623291,
-0.08105765283107758,
-0.44514888525009155,
-0.14443330466747284,
-0.5797351002693176,
0.03702830523252487,
0.5187970399856567,
-0.8715403079986572,
0.027016960084438324,
0.07944299280643463,
1.1510308980941772,
0.26121294498443604,
-0.49315381050109863,
-0.032318681478500366,
-0.6861338019371033,
0.7340967655181885,
-0.5053069591522217,
0.407978355884552,
0.36151188611984253,
0.5334411263465881,
-0.17165353894233704,
-0.6514300107955933,
-0.5472941994667053,
0.008229400962591171,
-0.06750413030385971,
-0.06975555419921875,
-0.44813409447669983,
0.059845179319381714,
0.5214983224868774,
0.018634580075740814,
-0.33119282126426697,
0.3541789650917053,
-0.2968422770500183,
-0.21570822596549988,
0.4811771810054779,
0.1471010148525238,
0.21139110624790192,
-0.2716681659221649,
-0.5658887028694153,
0.08531536906957626,
-0.6746094822883606,
-0.1472097933292389,
0.2042773962020874,
0.4062988758087158,
0.013728679157793522,
0.45329684019088745,
-0.30457308888435364,
0.7708601951599121,
0.08062472194433212,
-0.43913331627845764,
0.4319627285003662,
-0.15032824873924255,
-0.2384602576494217,
0.36022576689720154,
0.6539787650108337,
0.19699861109256744,
0.335135817527771,
-0.15106473863124847,
-0.33248236775398254,
-0.08728621155023575,
0.07848250865936279,
-1.0190467834472656,
-0.20798978209495544,
-0.20903775095939636,
-0.4677175283432007,
-0.1161215677857399,
-0.1819056272506714,
-0.6312371492385864,
-0.47511571645736694,
-0.3827372193336487,
0.6294158697128296,
-0.5468713045120239,
-0.12136588990688324,
-0.030100498348474503,
-0.13025568425655365,
0.35996729135513306,
0.23861871659755707,
-0.8734191656112671,
0.3411444127559662,
0.7445632219314575,
0.6729081869125366,
-0.07174713164567947,
-0.32305192947387695,
-0.7166163325309753,
0.3837285041809082,
-0.22326232492923737,
1.0335348844528198,
-0.7789868712425232,
-0.23871475458145142,
-0.36593735218048096,
-0.16148622334003448,
0.1461016833782196,
-0.6267288327217102,
0.3827374577522278,
-0.7738597989082336,
-0.419894814491272,
-0.06103285029530525,
-0.7325953841209412,
-0.17674390971660614,
0.26039135456085205,
-0.7534725666046143,
0.6250009536743164,
0.07364999502897263,
-0.7270522117614746,
1.0002033710479736,
-0.4826996624469757,
-0.4170481562614441,
0.3876512348651886,
-0.3809848427772522,
-0.4502742886543274,
0.23714524507522583,
0.09004490822553635,
0.38744112849235535,
-0.32243138551712036,
-0.024206897243857384,
-0.2895335853099823,
-0.3248113691806793,
0.27109596133232117,
-0.25893115997314453,
0.3840315341949463,
-0.08292808383703232,
-0.20969511568546295,
-0.22298137843608856,
-1.0796186923980713,
0.023443710058927536,
-0.012740671634674072,
-0.2932037115097046,
-0.6035533547401428,
-0.29961007833480835,
0.06974440813064575,
0.11995792388916016,
-0.13912780582904816,
-0.398386687040329,
0.1640969067811966,
-0.45635291934013367,
0.03065892681479454,
0.434391051530838,
0.4136231243610382,
0.723812460899353,
0.09626112878322601,
0.5249150991439819,
0.13800840079784393,
-0.0690855011343956,
-0.25723642110824585,
-0.4453405737876892,
-0.4348031282424927,
-0.40775978565216064,
0.4501214027404785,
0.20499300956726074,
-0.7924993634223938,
0.07388225942850113,
-0.7388818860054016,
-0.2990391254425049,
-0.4631865322589874,
0.3420255482196808,
0.3770919740200043,
0.7103211283683777,
0.608451247215271,
-0.30651596188545227,
-0.46689867973327637,
-1.0619783401489258,
-0.27673327922821045,
-0.13688793778419495,
-0.16244380176067352,
0.35753920674324036,
0.8233395218849182,
-0.346760630607605,
1.0857354402542114,
-0.6600688099861145,
-0.6781551241874695,
-0.18280115723609924,
0.4891020357608795,
0.25273397564888,
0.225376695394516,
0.20907218754291534,
-0.7418633699417114,
-0.44953233003616333,
0.0883650854229927,
-0.49037355184555054,
0.07427137345075607,
-0.4713221490383148,
-0.10728569328784943,
-0.12908419966697693,
0.34895989298820496,
-0.3503934442996979,
0.14607736468315125,
0.22985152900218964,
0.02059687115252018,
0.2790307402610779,
0.21748125553131104,
-0.33768871426582336,
-0.8803340196609497,
-0.1251336932182312,
0.29235905408859253,
0.05076507478952408,
-0.5916814804077148,
-0.2531113624572754,
-0.06202147901058197,
0.004715943243354559,
-0.6878951191902161,
0.7055570483207703,
-0.5380997657775879,
-0.3795348107814789,
-0.3651122450828552,
0.2592422664165497,
0.05374232307076454,
0.17043977975845337,
0.32641756534576416,
0.44241753220558167,
0.5969758629798889,
-0.5429524779319763,
0.049768030643463135,
0.2690645754337311,
-0.3972240090370178,
1.0451433658599854,
-0.5421070456504822,
0.09198275208473206,
-0.49261289834976196,
0.5284053683280945,
-0.6633909344673157,
-0.4476233124732971,
-0.011270930990576744,
-0.39022091031074524,
0.633570671081543,
-0.489284873008728,
-0.5116913318634033,
-0.14136841893196106,
0.0516335628926754,
0.41986083984375,
0.11525416374206543,
-0.5834574103355408,
0.6388236880302429,
0.21264925599098206,
0.21773889660835266,
-0.39792704582214355,
-0.801482617855072,
0.12526853382587433,
-0.2124801129102707,
-0.4167313277721405,
0.22885042428970337,
0.3060087263584137,
-0.1427006721496582,
0.17977403104305267,
-0.4854847490787506,
-0.27484259009361267,
0.053650133311748505,
0.18185926973819733,
0.42899224162101746,
-0.38270363211631775,
0.5964394807815552,
-0.1067667230963707,
-0.4471113085746765,
-0.03674430772662163,
-0.5267104506492615,
0.094222791492939,
-0.21042701601982117,
0.11955095082521439,
-0.4581061005592346,
-0.011431198567152023,
0.0015847438480705023,
-0.2337431013584137,
0.8360586166381836,
0.7683764100074768,
-0.5147479176521301,
-0.22999286651611328,
-0.3057800829410553,
-0.21796488761901855,
-0.4016042649745941,
0.21006165444850922,
-0.8076334595680237,
-0.5344372987747192,
0.17114487290382385,
-0.25265395641326904,
-0.21253804862499237,
0.5856640934944153,
0.2689315974712372,
-0.08676211535930634,
0.5540524125099182,
0.4351876378059387,
-0.17757777869701385,
0.4478260576725006,
-0.428386926651001,
0.042811471968889236,
-0.941648542881012,
-0.0662267804145813,
-0.2885447144508362,
-0.583855390548706,
-0.6798769235610962,
-0.45979681611061096,
0.3077884316444397,
0.12483785301446915,
-0.12027610838413239,
0.5091504454612732,
-0.28392457962036133,
0.9062300324440002,
0.2501579225063324,
0.08757387101650238,
0.41457176208496094,
0.001072310726158321,
0.11512717604637146,
-0.14020206034183502,
-0.3801681101322174,
-0.5826910734176636,
1.1040338277816772,
0.4161321818828583,
0.8020443320274353,
0.04572184383869171,
1.1310298442840576,
-0.15123578906059265,
0.5199492573738098,
-1.1478934288024902,
0.32978948950767517,
-0.11709406226873398,
-0.8787835240364075,
-0.3485076129436493,
-0.4371216595172882,
-1.1138511896133423,
0.2820592522621155,
-0.4963097870349884,
-0.9516404271125793,
0.2958604395389557,
-0.04400806501507759,
-0.32211214303970337,
0.10036268830299377,
-0.6963653564453125,
0.9246071577072144,
-0.16882812976837158,
-0.1355617791414261,
0.03805012255907059,
-0.6780475974082947,
0.43891850113868713,
-0.3461366295814514,
0.10853979736566544,
-0.18151195347309113,
-0.3083934783935547,
0.6045470237731934,
0.04516494274139404,
0.8089981079101562,
-0.016293512657284737,
-0.06037387251853943,
0.3326829671859741,
-0.052598986774683,
0.6438031196594238,
0.08517146110534668,
-0.011853684671223164,
0.29161879420280457,
-0.2720945179462433,
-0.5017974972724915,
-0.6107155084609985,
0.5628837943077087,
-0.5844848155975342,
-0.03476876765489578,
-0.10533519834280014,
-0.30865994095802307,
-0.2533929646015167,
0.3524927496910095,
0.5286320447921753,
0.4479840397834778,
-0.22030572593212128,
0.20547610521316528,
0.7487847805023193,
-0.09403063356876373,
0.0905093103647232,
0.47141462564468384,
-0.02266026847064495,
-0.2681366503238678,
1.0168968439102173,
0.18828177452087402,
0.3970157206058502,
0.6725918650627136,
0.08082450181245804,
-0.09577719122171402,
-0.6022962331771851,
-0.2596828043460846,
0.33211836218833923,
-0.8749087452888489,
-0.27732938528060913,
-0.6697108149528503,
0.30126386880874634,
-0.1372389942407608,
-0.06625226885080338,
-0.2181822806596756,
-0.23681141436100006,
-0.39838066697120667,
-0.09377777576446533,
0.3101710081100464,
0.4357270896434784,
0.1660732924938202,
0.6393885612487793,
-0.7375365495681763,
0.6485212445259094,
0.2905738651752472,
0.426145076751709,
-0.113582544028759,
-0.5160022974014282,
-0.18419182300567627,
-0.2680304944515228,
0.028713496401906013,
-0.9524538516998291,
0.12782128155231476,
0.4358021020889282,
0.42976313829421997,
0.6390525102615356,
-0.14448480308055878,
0.7091217041015625,
-0.6104423403739929,
0.3182787597179413,
0.2989291250705719,
-0.7772552967071533,
0.7055206298828125,
-0.21481500566005707,
0.4103335440158844,
0.829586386680603,
0.694240152835846,
-0.44072338938713074,
0.009214678779244423,
-0.6373693346977234,
-0.747976541519165,
0.593869149684906,
0.1239316388964653,
0.059122201055288315,
-0.11984054744243622,
0.2645051181316376,
0.1704077273607254,
-0.034470755606889725,
-0.7646411657333374,
-0.22494302690029144,
0.1928362101316452,
0.04087766632437706,
-0.2736523449420929,
-0.05336581915616989,
-0.040908411145210266,
-0.06988774985074997,
0.7103924751281738,
-0.43203240633010864,
-0.006914502941071987,
-0.05308443680405617,
-0.5204853415489197,
-0.0019372461829334497,
0.6358664035797119,
0.17656752467155457,
0.2895866930484772,
-0.15527252852916718,
0.2247990369796753,
0.380083292722702,
-0.3397669792175293,
-0.014885934069752693,
0.13655254244804382,
-0.3591330945491791,
0.14246761798858643,
0.5444125533103943,
1.134568452835083,
0.6001450419425964,
-0.4177159070968628,
0.36336570978164673,
0.28403395414352417,
0.04751366749405861,
-0.03309085592627525,
-0.1402856558561325,
0.005276086274534464,
0.27864891290664673,
0.2252994179725647,
-0.1996307522058487,
0.3908146023750305,
-0.6207420229911804,
0.3541802763938904,
0.27903300523757935,
-0.4492148458957672,
-0.36661696434020996,
0.4804491102695465,
0.017483051866292953,
0.08900763839483261,
0.5357862114906311,
-0.45736873149871826,
-0.2958002984523773,
0.5307232737541199,
0.5929602384567261,
0.8753779530525208,
0.23790748417377472,
0.3585643470287323,
0.4946870803833008,
0.4047369658946991,
0.04507748410105705,
-0.20015019178390503,
-0.15201759338378906,
-0.8088191747665405,
-0.42065194249153137,
-0.7381901741027832,
-0.3546522855758667,
0.091774120926857,
-0.7179275751113892,
0.4074537754058838,
-0.3638465106487274,
-0.38739901781082153,
0.7453407049179077,
-0.08295726776123047,
-1.012258529663086,
0.17200691998004913,
0.5742175579071045,
0.7052007913589478,
-0.906955897808075,
0.7837918996810913,
0.9480433464050293,
-0.760494589805603,
-0.8837970495223999,
0.11396416276693344,
0.3338435888290405,
-0.5465237498283386,
1.2078806161880493,
0.2915436327457428,
0.010430438444018364,
0.11977747827768326,
-0.44568270444869995,
-0.9597093462944031,
0.9558649063110352,
0.04001589119434357,
-0.7963947057723999,
-0.111232228577137,
0.12264571338891983,
0.733716607093811,
-0.482209175825119,
0.35992974042892456,
0.9579254388809204,
0.5366346836090088,
0.32530727982521057,
-0.8026863932609558,
-0.029901033267378807,
0.27085599303245544,
0.10036326944828033,
0.6204297542572021,
-0.24540653824806213,
0.4869459271430969,
-0.24803604185581207,
-0.21658286452293396,
-0.30804046988487244,
0.6753774285316467,
0.06043271720409393,
0.5199604630470276,
0.5600771307945251,
0.5271762013435364,
0.8982135057449341,
0.05019070580601692,
1.1562200784683228,
0.2710821032524109,
0.39151811599731445,
1.6135889291763306,
-0.36657488346099854,
0.973758339881897,
0.41928187012672424,
-0.20118553936481476,
0.44735804200172424,
0.4426458179950714,
-0.3787095546722412,
0.3166464567184448,
0.2917071580886841,
-0.42923474311828613,
-0.40127888321876526,
-0.37047287821769714,
-0.014217318966984749,
0.6797875165939331,
0.530231773853302,
-0.3248875141143799,
-0.5057357549667358,
0.255331426858902,
-0.15326377749443054,
-0.3748772144317627,
-0.4597439169883728,
1.0176761150360107,
0.31328216195106506,
-0.2137567549943924,
0.5086077451705933,
-0.36751723289489746,
0.6828616857528687,
-0.25805914402008057,
0.03052068129181862,
0.1957647055387497,
0.09215907752513885,
-0.5336776375770569,
-0.6617615222930908,
0.06548872590065002,
0.06493569910526276,
-0.1739899218082428,
0.06984149664640427,
1.0046417713165283,
-0.30613163113594055,
-0.38852399587631226,
0.26617079973220825,
0.22163157165050507,
0.5262565016746521,
-0.14765067398548126,
-0.5857353210449219,
-0.19607721269130707,
-0.3447226285934448,
-0.16999860107898712,
0.3566373288631439,
0.5662702322006226,
-0.20222735404968262,
0.4703143239021301,
0.34551286697387695,
0.07463719695806503,
0.21946163475513458,
0.2533615529537201,
0.694029688835144,
-0.5949369668960571,
-0.21995775401592255,
-0.5684122443199158,
0.28463685512542725,
0.010707342065870762,
-0.350126177072525,
0.42026591300964355,
0.6560466885566711,
1.048061490058899,
0.039669424295425415,
0.48000138998031616,
0.13868629932403564,
0.1869516223669052,
-0.39461448788642883,
0.3047998249530792,
-0.47931408882141113,
0.2149423360824585,
-0.44422486424446106,
-1.1431561708450317,
-0.42418158054351807,
0.3649986684322357,
-0.6291913390159607,
-0.24927747249603271,
0.6441607475280762,
0.5250251889228821,
-0.038281869143247604,
-0.11935261636972427,
0.4014508128166199,
0.21556363999843597,
0.11154333502054214,
0.5145898461341858,
0.7178926467895508,
-0.521142303943634,
0.8579698204994202,
-0.2405383586883545,
0.05889114737510681,
-0.14327004551887512,
-0.8252588510513306,
-0.6839743852615356,
-0.13255029916763306,
-0.6500440239906311,
-0.25481560826301575,
-0.22323422133922577,
0.8626410365104675,
0.514814019203186,
-0.6727060675621033,
0.2982192039489746,
0.14022523164749146,
0.10313473641872406,
0.048472464084625244,
-0.25900566577911377,
0.04679924622178078,
-0.36868491768836975,
-0.8178837895393372,
0.30022305250167847,
0.3642197251319885,
0.1297117918729782,
0.13522574305534363,
0.015513376332819462,
-0.16495288908481598,
-0.09414094686508179,
0.7510119676589966,
0.34977683424949646,
-0.671778678894043,
-0.2489885836839676,
-0.19225414097309113,
-0.09143055975437164,
0.25758498907089233,
0.6020891070365906,
-0.7964456677436829,
0.654939591884613,
0.461911141872406,
0.8470744490623474,
0.8504108786582947,
-0.15631556510925293,
-0.012241094373166561,
-0.9414046406745911,
-0.09721849113702774,
0.26991286873817444,
0.19761739671230316,
0.15504957735538483,
-0.20546740293502808,
0.553277313709259,
0.07665043324232101,
-0.2678135931491852,
-0.6109272837638855,
0.3888320326805115,
-1.067246437072754,
-0.09388525038957596,
1.2915440797805786,
-0.11954402923583984,
-0.23986639082431793,
0.024345001205801964,
0.007416242267936468,
0.13441506028175354,
-0.5696653723716736,
0.228378027677536,
0.6307140588760376,
-0.1374519318342209,
-0.10996571183204651,
-0.5768047571182251,
0.22512087225914001,
0.14558742940425873,
-0.9239193797111511,
-0.35564124584198,
0.7304940819740295,
0.33854761719703674,
0.36105644702911377,
0.5384681224822998,
0.05320921540260315,
0.2814073860645294,
0.1639847308397293,
0.025870993733406067,
0.29265913367271423,
-0.3672124147415161,
-0.6805921792984009,
-0.07721155136823654,
0.22972793877124786,
-0.19261373579502106
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14221v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14221v2
|
Improving the Robustness of Large Language Models via Consistency Alignment
| 2024-03-21T08:21:12 | 2024-03-22T12:34:47 |
Yukun Zhao, Lingyong Yan, Weiwei Sun, Guoliang Xing, Shuaiqiang Wang, Chong Meng, Zhicong Cheng, Zhaochun Ren, Dawei Yin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have shown tremendous success in following user
instructions and generating helpful responses. Nevertheless, their robustness
is still far from optimal, as they may generate significantly inconsistent
responses due to minor changes in the verbalized instructions. Recent
literature has explored this inconsistency issue, highlighting the importance
of continued improvement in the robustness of response generation. However,
systematic analysis and solutions are still lacking. In this paper, we
quantitatively define the inconsistency problem and propose a two-stage
training framework consisting of instruction-augmented supervised fine-tuning
and consistency alignment training. The first stage helps a model generalize on
following instructions via similar instruction augmentations. In the second
stage, we improve the diversity and help the model understand which responses
are more aligned with human expectations by differentiating subtle differences
in similar responses. The training process is accomplished by self-rewards
inferred from the trained model at the first stage without referring to
external human preference resources. We conduct extensive experiments on recent
publicly available LLMs on instruction-following tasks and demonstrate the
effectiveness of our training framework.
|
[
-0.0673578530550003,
-0.575160562992096,
0.4096628725528717,
0.1403445154428482,
0.13608399033546448,
0.07498713582754135,
-0.4124492108821869,
-0.34811779856681824,
-0.09134918451309204,
0.2673104405403137,
-0.6572414040565491,
-0.27978891134262085,
-0.871563196182251,
0.10493653267621994,
-0.21898755431175232,
0.8426275849342346,
-0.20279483497142792,
0.1280374675989151,
-0.12081252038478851,
-0.23085108399391174,
-0.7268449068069458,
-0.19965441524982452,
-0.582492470741272,
-0.2789627015590668,
0.5091212391853333,
0.6255580186843872,
0.7859634757041931,
1.057554841041565,
0.4835631549358368,
0.2781873643398285,
0.11889062821865082,
0.49877220392227173,
-0.5052058100700378,
0.30632779002189636,
-0.23803183436393738,
-0.14921486377716064,
-0.39730602502822876,
-0.22546681761741638,
0.6705014109611511,
0.6956589818000793,
-0.20351235568523407,
0.02338368073105812,
0.7133955955505371,
0.42967790365219116,
-0.6003540754318237,
0.1570294052362442,
-0.6700804233551025,
-0.22187280654907227,
0.08162862807512283,
0.004490659572184086,
-0.3550378382205963,
-0.3195202052593231,
-0.043505895882844925,
-0.5644594430923462,
0.011448945850133896,
-0.23428896069526672,
0.9071105122566223,
0.3300964832305908,
-0.15421344339847565,
-0.38114655017852783,
-0.5503237843513489,
0.7037546038627625,
-0.9763593077659607,
0.5873638987541199,
0.39161136746406555,
-0.01928199641406536,
-0.4064226448535919,
-0.31762635707855225,
-0.4150657653808594,
-0.12032993137836456,
-0.0010020355693995953,
-0.14647434651851654,
0.21105404198169708,
-0.06293443590402603,
0.2564926743507385,
0.01964058354496956,
-0.685280978679657,
0.5407752394676208,
0.09680841118097305,
-0.2566108703613281,
0.5486056804656982,
0.253414124250412,
0.24483448266983032,
0.17314594984054565,
-0.25047242641448975,
-0.35649949312210083,
-0.6443390250205994,
0.37962648272514343,
0.548500657081604,
0.6392050981521606,
-0.3412846028804779,
0.7059386372566223,
-0.18814975023269653,
0.795306921005249,
0.5196263194084167,
-0.4547918736934662,
0.22538572549819946,
-0.3882465958595276,
-0.0933007299900055,
-0.046009764075279236,
0.6928075551986694,
0.11019375920295715,
0.2010686993598938,
-0.1692112535238266,
-0.372571736574173,
-0.007946508005261421,
0.28894978761672974,
-0.7179288268089294,
-0.19477811455726624,
0.3215538561344147,
-0.2599710524082184,
-0.19830751419067383,
0.06038874387741089,
-0.48708856105804443,
-0.35078880190849304,
-0.6562749743461609,
0.38753601908683777,
-0.4401751458644867,
-0.10092391073703766,
0.06733093410730362,
0.5264408588409424,
0.23899558186531067,
0.4138972759246826,
-1.4966151714324951,
0.10608826577663422,
1.028606653213501,
0.56070876121521,
-0.26518723368644714,
-0.37514162063598633,
-0.8804418444633484,
0.23648053407669067,
-0.3621339201927185,
0.655021607875824,
-0.5935463309288025,
-0.08695085346698761,
0.21784421801567078,
-0.02063320390880108,
-0.1540580838918686,
-0.5315465927124023,
0.3264908790588379,
-0.3817242980003357,
0.16740629076957703,
-0.34537172317504883,
-0.8897238969802856,
0.324616014957428,
0.5176848769187927,
-0.28075549006462097,
0.9877500534057617,
0.05461769923567772,
-0.8628858327865601,
0.35948628187179565,
-0.1999305784702301,
-0.2680191993713379,
-0.2101752758026123,
-0.4215719997882843,
-0.5855162739753723,
-0.04498860239982605,
0.2008359432220459,
0.27332785725593567,
0.12195417284965515,
0.2759697437286377,
-0.5002440214157104,
-0.46602606773376465,
0.09609179198741913,
-0.22008545696735382,
0.6505098342895508,
-0.03994736075401306,
-0.47306028008461,
0.2811545729637146,
-0.8180530667304993,
0.22236573696136475,
-0.004417065065354109,
-0.5256994962692261,
-0.11040647327899933,
-0.08356335759162903,
-0.3516330420970917,
0.04484283924102783,
0.49683117866516113,
-0.49464431405067444,
0.419290155172348,
-0.37034013867378235,
0.07737211138010025,
1.0651180744171143,
-0.23607715964317322,
0.5445134043693542,
-0.25991499423980713,
0.35561567544937134,
0.022052275016903877,
0.05122656375169754,
-0.380872905254364,
-0.14202971756458282,
-0.668420135974884,
-0.11967722326517105,
0.20344506204128265,
0.6143965721130371,
-0.4932830333709717,
0.5668443441390991,
-0.28971952199935913,
-0.07405179738998413,
-0.4585033655166626,
0.4976244568824768,
0.4755103886127472,
0.6838725805282593,
0.37619221210479736,
-0.19688057899475098,
-0.628111720085144,
-0.7719479203224182,
-0.3399527668952942,
-0.21316152811050415,
-0.041776642203330994,
-0.0742712914943695,
0.21530935168266296,
-0.3189522325992584,
0.714608907699585,
-0.12942038476467133,
-0.039154794067144394,
0.0734926238656044,
0.12703458964824677,
-0.003965739160776138,
0.7718736529350281,
0.09794671088457108,
-0.44167545437812805,
-0.5853316187858582,
0.19093553721904755,
-0.7188009023666382,
-0.03756503388285637,
-0.10777965933084488,
-0.045921798795461655,
0.27697622776031494,
0.46216776967048645,
-0.18348167836666107,
0.2065141201019287,
0.6297264695167542,
0.1459154337644577,
0.3664514124393463,
-0.03698548302054405,
0.1774309128522873,
-1.1095068454742432,
-0.061595454812049866,
-0.06132475659251213,
-0.2832489013671875,
-0.4909384250640869,
-0.04337817057967186,
0.21254664659500122,
0.21318593621253967,
0.027493631467223167,
0.41264262795448303,
-0.41047799587249756,
0.07470951974391937,
-0.449982225894928,
-0.017526470124721527,
-0.05646131932735443,
0.5277091264724731,
-0.1337864100933075,
0.8330850005149841,
0.4880727529525757,
-0.38099345564842224,
0.25802847743034363,
0.43566781282424927,
-0.15558718144893646,
0.6968792080879211,
-0.7249826192855835,
0.32791998982429504,
-0.1864957958459854,
0.029957549646496773,
-1.2227940559387207,
-0.5794768929481506,
0.4024023115634918,
-0.3900927007198334,
0.859048068523407,
-0.22791358828544617,
-0.42016714811325073,
-0.17585626244544983,
-0.2419622540473938,
0.2094608098268509,
0.3272653818130493,
-0.6118461489677429,
0.524459958076477,
0.0710802972316742,
-0.26578670740127563,
-0.8993425965309143,
-0.4991515576839447,
-0.24614574015140533,
-0.01925146020948887,
-0.5899538397789001,
-0.14673873782157898,
-0.09704543650150299,
-0.037182118743658066,
-0.2420707792043686,
-0.4092032015323639,
0.012086465023458004,
0.16139163076877594,
0.15346968173980713,
0.19098028540611267,
-0.14754194021224976,
0.07658272236585617,
-0.03584223985671997,
0.004943434149026871,
-0.06573663651943207,
-0.47429490089416504,
0.3885994553565979,
0.04994620755314827,
-0.690824568271637,
-0.7175308465957642,
0.32610899209976196,
0.13137832283973694,
-0.2035723328590393,
0.7224928140640259,
0.535578191280365,
-0.2877650856971741,
0.07423234730958939,
-0.5470072627067566,
-0.3422800302505493,
-0.4611033797264099,
0.38306501507759094,
-0.21785645186901093,
-1.092223048210144,
0.45249903202056885,
0.19915974140167236,
0.47048574686050415,
0.04471835121512413,
0.4623621702194214,
-0.2409570962190628,
1.3095022439956665,
0.7690351605415344,
0.060922663658857346,
0.6139966249465942,
0.18782362341880798,
0.13475839793682098,
-0.7656735777854919,
-0.33942097425460815,
-0.5933229923248291,
-0.30798017978668213,
-0.44862180948257446,
0.03896590694785118,
0.16626791656017303,
0.2713448107242584,
-0.5738337635993958,
0.3728529214859009,
-0.36890020966529846,
0.273510605096817,
0.3540209233760834,
0.06299368292093277,
0.14064645767211914,
0.2774880528450012,
-0.12645065784454346,
-0.15950646996498108,
-0.7722626328468323,
-0.5558440089225769,
0.8494813442230225,
0.46925488114356995,
1.121928334236145,
0.10117623955011368,
0.8519157767295837,
-0.1298622190952301,
0.41568201780319214,
-0.51708984375,
0.1987401843070984,
-0.10522474348545074,
-0.19562655687332153,
-0.4028034806251526,
-0.5588072538375854,
-0.928642749786377,
0.08041132986545563,
-0.2629700005054474,
-0.9829198122024536,
0.046737223863601685,
0.4165414571762085,
-0.31070956587791443,
0.05758099630475044,
-0.5560486912727356,
0.9379926323890686,
-0.31153491139411926,
-0.5738967657089233,
0.2743437588214874,
-0.9693102240562439,
0.29238951206207275,
-0.07333178073167801,
0.09691943228244781,
0.0013181373942643404,
0.19362032413482666,
0.3847004175186157,
-0.4124467372894287,
0.8823129534721375,
0.002827225485816598,
-0.49572330713272095,
-0.011186081916093826,
0.0662495493888855,
0.788672149181366,
-0.10573512315750122,
0.10190781205892563,
-0.24560993909835815,
-0.18456681072711945,
-0.6340543031692505,
-0.6813848614692688,
0.722000241279602,
-0.7303860187530518,
-0.6674690842628479,
-0.12500794231891632,
-0.8743711709976196,
-0.5507470369338989,
0.1579274982213974,
0.274515300989151,
0.46714386343955994,
0.026947814971208572,
-0.023915830999612808,
1.0679616928100586,
0.039533328264951706,
0.2785232961177826,
0.357497900724411,
-0.09888044744729996,
-0.4359367787837982,
0.5375606417655945,
0.028667213395237923,
0.5350958108901978,
0.4439840316772461,
-0.04163026437163353,
-0.42196527123451233,
-0.5255029201507568,
-0.6201762557029724,
0.06670019775629044,
-0.5577585697174072,
-0.32404232025146484,
-0.5168472528457642,
-0.03620051220059395,
-0.7622127532958984,
0.0514444075524807,
-0.42976775765419006,
-0.003049259539693594,
-0.3474082350730896,
0.09941403567790985,
0.09967641532421112,
0.7401727437973022,
-0.12273573875427246,
0.3149033188819885,
-0.8578327298164368,
0.09861446917057037,
0.3550959527492523,
0.4130059480667114,
0.06788495928049088,
-0.9284816384315491,
-0.4335072934627533,
0.466910183429718,
-0.41304367780685425,
-0.6772423982620239,
-0.13531211018562317,
0.2236742377281189,
0.4779910147190094,
0.47019052505493164,
-0.19155225157737732,
0.9672558903694153,
-0.5331854820251465,
0.5197811722755432,
0.26389279961586,
-0.7956055998802185,
0.5572696328163147,
-0.3619194030761719,
0.4227096140384674,
0.6353788375854492,
0.2690470218658447,
-0.2901177704334259,
-0.48182329535484314,
-0.4436326324939728,
-0.6842420101165771,
0.5413982272148132,
0.04575904458761215,
0.255060076713562,
-0.11268916726112366,
0.4584440588951111,
0.20772762596607208,
0.08087997883558273,
-0.6171646118164062,
-0.058179039508104324,
-0.14541880786418915,
-0.5853234529495239,
0.10761397331953049,
-0.14593876898288727,
-0.39149177074432373,
0.07556499540805817,
0.7650830745697021,
-0.4376533329486847,
-0.16645567119121552,
-0.03871959447860718,
0.040068332105875015,
-0.41015005111694336,
0.22376763820648193,
0.6388111114501953,
0.7988686561584473,
0.04223904013633728,
0.1956917941570282,
0.059348832815885544,
-0.25437819957733154,
0.3384259343147278,
0.23003727197647095,
-0.13721419870853424,
-0.29393401741981506,
0.49521830677986145,
0.6807562708854675,
0.28950992226600647,
-0.5923341512680054,
0.5926299095153809,
0.0629054605960846,
0.05830301716923714,
0.0002463281562086195,
0.2679436206817627,
0.15852685272693634,
0.3584451377391815,
0.11700111627578735,
0.036794837564229965,
-0.1384056657552719,
-0.44431763887405396,
0.2616443932056427,
0.6849513053894043,
-0.2229553759098053,
-0.14286330342292786,
0.6990995407104492,
-0.16936662793159485,
-0.28451600670814514,
0.5674517154693604,
-0.14056549966335297,
-0.33827996253967285,
0.3477098047733307,
0.603050947189331,
0.5324615240097046,
-0.37197819352149963,
0.07443377375602722,
0.4180759787559509,
0.1427229791879654,
-0.5699940323829651,
0.2439308762550354,
0.0221051387488842,
-0.7482048869132996,
-0.5081085562705994,
-0.44843897223472595,
-0.3603505790233612,
-0.031242720782756805,
-0.8847415447235107,
0.1361600011587143,
-0.4559399485588074,
0.04687940329313278,
-0.19699512422084808,
-0.18165624141693115,
-0.5904595851898193,
0.04914826899766922,
0.0825645923614502,
0.6978663802146912,
-0.7899760007858276,
0.8813145756721497,
0.7256745100021362,
-0.4859544038772583,
-1.4229307174682617,
0.1357784867286682,
-0.009716094471514225,
-0.8251748085021973,
0.40518811345100403,
0.17409338057041168,
-0.09401465952396393,
-0.1752418428659439,
-0.8680800795555115,
-0.9208526611328125,
0.959538459777832,
0.5595102310180664,
-0.8837384581565857,
0.16044428944587708,
0.07825905829668045,
0.5216849446296692,
-0.4673728048801422,
-0.031102469190955162,
0.4184446632862091,
0.17935550212860107,
0.2686913013458252,
-0.9593600034713745,
-0.05637366324663162,
0.024783192202448845,
0.2211361527442932,
0.164728581905365,
-0.5074468851089478,
0.6038094162940979,
-0.24978980422019958,
-0.2387925535440445,
0.5862103700637817,
0.9187846779823303,
0.4806745946407318,
0.16338159143924713,
0.3402274250984192,
0.7513606548309326,
0.9204916954040527,
-0.060083113610744476,
0.7906007170677185,
-0.2388642132282257,
0.5031530857086182,
1.6612962484359741,
-0.3503713011741638,
0.8917181491851807,
0.5317410230636597,
-0.013369252905249596,
0.5144965052604675,
0.695462167263031,
0.0507366880774498,
0.4394790530204773,
0.012030436657369137,
-0.0884142592549324,
-0.33574947714805603,
-0.012269238010048866,
-0.417407751083374,
0.181446373462677,
-0.02428385242819786,
-0.27313634753227234,
-0.1833709329366684,
-0.20053495466709137,
0.036388423293828964,
0.3658309578895569,
-0.14355751872062683,
0.880932092666626,
-0.10130459070205688,
-0.8341083526611328,
0.8221650123596191,
-0.12594084441661835,
0.6011607050895691,
-0.6483669877052307,
-0.13417169451713562,
-0.41855862736701965,
0.2117193192243576,
-0.34416669607162476,
-0.8391878008842468,
0.0754246860742569,
0.0802616998553276,
-0.3987862169742584,
-0.12820197641849518,
0.45421302318573,
-0.7566207647323608,
-0.2777719497680664,
0.10084723681211472,
0.32178983092308044,
-0.0980767086148262,
0.35421085357666016,
-0.6846853494644165,
0.45572879910469055,
0.0663251280784607,
0.05288310721516609,
0.5684133172035217,
0.41562551259994507,
0.05223977565765381,
0.5330720543861389,
0.4128704369068146,
-0.2718333899974823,
0.17771455645561218,
-0.014163914136588573,
0.7329674363136292,
-0.061047088354825974,
-0.28626295924186707,
-0.8203260898590088,
0.5496167540550232,
-0.03773289918899536,
-0.1964469999074936,
0.7421251535415649,
0.4726318418979645,
1.0062843561172485,
0.07265902310609818,
0.5929064750671387,
0.12494567036628723,
0.49011653661727905,
-0.5359267592430115,
0.08751974254846573,
-0.5070611834526062,
0.5235471725463867,
-0.12418001890182495,
-1.1275824308395386,
-0.23317673802375793,
0.7294907569885254,
-0.0756368562579155,
0.1992284208536148,
0.36595025658607483,
0.9204663634300232,
-0.27758777141571045,
-0.12969531118869781,
0.06177325174212456,
0.25553637742996216,
0.2652113139629364,
0.4638378620147705,
0.749268651008606,
-0.40093064308166504,
0.3726367652416229,
-0.020829299464821815,
-0.19819068908691406,
-0.0006534340209327638,
-0.7855502367019653,
-0.6098867654800415,
-0.2781997621059418,
-0.341000497341156,
-0.7007773518562317,
0.30121973156929016,
1.2549430131912231,
0.6677030920982361,
-1.0901519060134888,
-0.24715091288089752,
-0.22045934200286865,
0.013877566903829575,
-0.25777214765548706,
-0.17437845468521118,
0.24075856804847717,
-0.7067449688911438,
-0.6143262386322021,
0.26322707533836365,
0.2829362154006958,
0.28396669030189514,
-0.23528268933296204,
-0.2800840437412262,
-0.12419413775205612,
0.013717942871153355,
0.17608241736888885,
0.594488263130188,
-0.8265478014945984,
-0.7130399346351624,
0.12711971998214722,
-0.5341495871543884,
0.27585992217063904,
0.5085633993148804,
-0.30902525782585144,
0.4748407006263733,
0.31259885430336,
1.0605723857879639,
0.04283621907234192,
0.29773783683776855,
0.4970259666442871,
-0.9109315872192383,
-0.13247662782669067,
0.018792852759361267,
0.31055623292922974,
0.702536940574646,
-0.36356064677238464,
0.37289443612098694,
-0.19462601840496063,
-0.7652349472045898,
-0.6657066941261292,
0.4973503053188324,
-0.9964236617088318,
0.006378346122801304,
1.2640846967697144,
-0.48791325092315674,
-0.0009636919712647796,
0.0413130447268486,
-0.14075855910778046,
0.27211007475852966,
-0.3151988089084625,
0.9230250120162964,
0.8099112510681152,
-0.34172192215919495,
-0.17377139627933502,
-0.1615825593471527,
0.3423977494239807,
0.6076791882514954,
-0.8026428818702698,
0.08723130822181702,
0.5596153736114502,
0.641280472278595,
0.06587984412908554,
0.4069623351097107,
-0.0035897339694201946,
0.17232723534107208,
-0.21564964950084686,
-0.10993652790784836,
0.13153864443302155,
-0.30636799335479736,
-0.548265814781189,
0.05806918069720268,
0.31126198172569275,
-0.2141505926847458
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14733v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14733v1
|
Open Knowledge Base Canonicalization with Multi-task Learning
| 2024-03-21T08:03:46 | 2024-03-21T08:03:46 |
Bingchen Liu, Huang Peng, Weixin Zeng, Xiang Zhao, Shijun Liu, Li Pan
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The construction of large open knowledge bases (OKBs) is integral to many
knowledge-driven applications on the world wide web such as web search.
However, noun phrases and relational phrases in OKBs often suffer from
redundancy and ambiguity, which calls for the investigation on OKB
canonicalization. Current solutions address OKB canonicalization by devising
advanced clustering algorithms and using knowledge graph embedding (KGE) to
further facilitate the canonicalization process. Nevertheless, these works fail
to fully exploit the synergy between clustering and KGE learning, and the
methods designed for these subtasks are sub-optimal. To this end, we put
forward a multi-task learning framework, namely MulCanon, to tackle OKB
canonicalization. In addition, diffusion model is used in the soft clustering
process to improve the noun phrase representations with neighboring
information, which can lead to more accurate representations. MulCanon unifies
the learning objectives of these sub-tasks, and adopts a two-stage multi-task
learning paradigm for training. A thorough experimental study on popular OKB
canonicalization benchmarks validates that MulCanon can achieve competitive
canonicalization results.
|
[
-0.4799244999885559,
-0.9931860566139221,
0.5647931694984436,
0.05785892531275749,
-0.16604965925216675,
-0.10927197337150574,
-0.4933246374130249,
-0.15018710494041443,
0.29888564348220825,
0.22247149050235748,
-0.4177441895008087,
-0.6865584850311279,
-0.5994306206703186,
-0.1395956575870514,
0.10999371856451035,
0.9281662106513977,
-0.048852041363716125,
0.0879899114370346,
-0.2356242537498474,
-0.40917032957077026,
-0.4642903506755829,
-0.4443345367908478,
-0.6809234023094177,
-0.10551556199789047,
0.7258248925209045,
0.4080480933189392,
0.3705599308013916,
0.7058672904968262,
0.1634242683649063,
0.19181424379348755,
0.039361536502838135,
0.4472907781600952,
-0.6212818622589111,
0.23822525143623352,
-0.19941848516464233,
-0.2255277931690216,
-0.2612811028957367,
-0.2569544017314911,
0.5687681436538696,
1.0164623260498047,
-0.3697301745414734,
0.17217345535755157,
0.11593684554100037,
0.797171413898468,
-0.6912923455238342,
0.6405993700027466,
-0.6290460824966431,
-0.13475672900676727,
-0.37713488936424255,
0.20326529443264008,
-0.25224316120147705,
-0.38054654002189636,
0.03911152482032776,
-0.915168285369873,
0.07794944941997528,
-0.02921927161514759,
0.38580986857414246,
0.15524068474769592,
-0.5808894038200378,
-0.3045904338359833,
-0.5487056970596313,
0.799805760383606,
-0.5195429921150208,
0.6603698134422302,
0.013837345875799656,
0.13345682621002197,
-0.3139171600341797,
-0.5020967125892639,
-0.427804559469223,
-0.15613925457000732,
-0.08916378766298294,
-0.0427408330142498,
-0.06947910040616989,
0.042059559375047684,
-0.10887131094932556,
0.11057759076356888,
-0.44901660084724426,
-0.07555150985717773,
-0.4713117182254791,
0.01620558649301529,
0.09067101776599884,
-0.2917034327983856,
-0.1690865457057953,
-0.3458811640739441,
-0.5648878812789917,
0.03197157010436058,
-0.6370482444763184,
0.06883875280618668,
0.33541339635849,
0.6915528178215027,
0.5000658631324768,
0.3999207615852356,
-0.34266141057014465,
0.6349611282348633,
0.2888958752155304,
-0.4353548288345337,
0.40132689476013184,
-0.2910100221633911,
-0.11270485818386078,
0.02794359251856804,
0.7242574095726013,
-0.01743469201028347,
-0.20765037834644318,
-0.6811531782150269,
0.25473225116729736,
-0.1948583424091339,
0.5303971171379089,
-0.5927901864051819,
-0.12320196628570557,
0.37570905685424805,
-0.6844714879989624,
-0.06717199087142944,
0.4280093014240265,
-0.7196175456047058,
-0.2792629897594452,
-0.4395236670970917,
0.3888459801673889,
-0.6091995239257812,
-0.45335811376571655,
-0.1573360115289688,
-0.058231912553310394,
-0.4262744188308716,
0.15691635012626648,
-0.678679883480072,
0.2171153724193573,
0.5605853796005249,
0.6661412715911865,
-0.25645679235458374,
-0.44435301423072815,
-0.25579833984375,
0.4069066345691681,
-0.320589542388916,
0.5663256645202637,
-0.19478005170822144,
-0.19717563688755035,
-0.08409850299358368,
0.017965368926525116,
-0.43508395552635193,
-0.6175177693367004,
0.19837023317813873,
-0.632014274597168,
-0.3547936677932739,
-0.33303529024124146,
-0.5520601868629456,
-0.5139559507369995,
0.37699052691459656,
-0.7470534443855286,
1.1223832368850708,
0.1577185094356537,
-0.49592769145965576,
0.3902614116668701,
-0.9097759127616882,
-0.6156809329986572,
-0.20471137762069702,
-0.21158470213413239,
-0.4149358570575714,
0.03062327578663826,
-0.0029939161613583565,
0.7993894219398499,
0.08462798595428467,
0.3879512548446655,
-0.45232608914375305,
0.23784106969833374,
-0.22211433947086334,
0.3369249403476715,
0.5750491619110107,
0.2703205645084381,
-0.494286447763443,
0.1351190209388733,
-0.5694530606269836,
-0.04750349000096321,
0.045319803059101105,
-0.6249514222145081,
-0.7662575840950012,
0.02332616038620472,
-0.26935502886772156,
0.1954750120639801,
0.2861720323562622,
-0.6693838238716125,
0.239767923951149,
-0.31118637323379517,
0.23285086452960968,
0.6473279595375061,
-0.10078570246696472,
0.727532148361206,
-0.09102306514978409,
0.2546011507511139,
0.26739925146102905,
0.12356223165988922,
-0.03162474185228348,
-0.677945613861084,
-0.4005664587020874,
0.007110354490578175,
0.28949037194252014,
0.4490498900413513,
-0.6652097105979919,
0.5540896058082581,
-0.22630025446414948,
-0.6090123057365417,
-0.2261362224817276,
0.5577642917633057,
0.3934158384799957,
0.3127615451812744,
0.5673462748527527,
-0.1354435831308365,
-0.3864344358444214,
-0.744188666343689,
0.06377279758453369,
0.1551046073436737,
0.38581356406211853,
0.4262174665927887,
0.5479777455329895,
0.06578218191862106,
0.974632978439331,
-0.5263431072235107,
-0.8905903697013855,
-0.1336613893508911,
0.30299052596092224,
0.001550668734125793,
0.6419417262077332,
0.639258086681366,
-1.1077650785446167,
-0.45448726415634155,
0.3766328990459442,
-0.7903336882591248,
0.6185129880905151,
0.2665244936943054,
-0.2591981291770935,
0.17112642526626587,
0.8159694075584412,
-0.6366453170776367,
0.25233539938926697,
0.42570579051971436,
0.12147732079029083,
0.4466429352760315,
-0.16915076971054077,
0.2861792743206024,
-1.1501834392547607,
0.2361554354429245,
-0.12045872956514359,
-0.056984808295965195,
-0.6054167747497559,
0.5132536888122559,
0.2742563784122467,
-0.04497840255498886,
-0.4897979497909546,
0.3262900114059448,
-0.4597517251968384,
0.2938375174999237,
-0.0718204602599144,
0.1797843724489212,
-0.3166719079017639,
0.7667153477668762,
-0.12744253873825073,
0.09716486185789108,
0.496146023273468,
-0.7588212490081787,
0.5845270752906799,
0.049030594527721405,
-0.2742763161659241,
0.7191016674041748,
-0.18391317129135132,
-0.08891241252422333,
-0.2568006217479706,
0.45165255665779114,
-1.0417581796646118,
-0.1793554425239563,
0.28324323892593384,
-0.1013568565249443,
0.301550030708313,
-0.19283002614974976,
-0.7438667416572571,
-0.548671543598175,
-0.2961268424987793,
0.538515031337738,
-0.05412744730710983,
-0.7073950171470642,
0.7942501306533813,
0.4118858575820923,
-0.13440291583538055,
-0.756697416305542,
-0.34712448716163635,
-0.4149848222732544,
-0.012803315185010433,
-0.638169527053833,
0.5252610445022583,
0.032925255596637726,
0.20802272856235504,
0.3342624306678772,
-0.2696493864059448,
-0.06403839588165283,
-0.11320336163043976,
0.21354210376739502,
-0.042598992586135864,
-0.40083715319633484,
0.4770273268222809,
0.34949344396591187,
0.052839040756225586,
-0.29043862223625183,
-0.90508633852005,
0.37837550044059753,
0.1328057050704956,
-0.37880054116249084,
0.0925321877002716,
0.310453325510025,
0.4679080545902252,
-0.29610130190849304,
1.202437400817871,
0.7729449272155762,
-0.641632080078125,
-0.06458087265491486,
-0.6587526798248291,
-0.028233051300048828,
-0.34370431303977966,
0.40765222907066345,
-0.35130178928375244,
-0.9343078136444092,
0.3343408703804016,
-0.506969153881073,
0.246909037232399,
0.40887245535850525,
0.369389146566391,
-0.01713479869067669,
0.7297999262809753,
0.5650556683540344,
-0.11851608008146286,
0.34511685371398926,
-0.3103122413158417,
0.22444607317447662,
-0.624243438243866,
-0.5473926663398743,
-0.4583630859851837,
-0.5151715874671936,
-0.18512770533561707,
-0.3365052342414856,
0.6408478617668152,
0.4609437584877014,
-0.10959850996732712,
0.37986108660697937,
-0.2036745399236679,
0.49965158104896545,
0.7951633334159851,
0.48242297768592834,
0.2289906144142151,
0.06217934191226959,
-0.40711310505867004,
0.37802743911743164,
-0.7274230718612671,
0.0020065486896783113,
1.2971196174621582,
0.006976454984396696,
0.6768994331359863,
0.29833635687828064,
0.7677000761032104,
0.026261234655976295,
0.16840606927871704,
-0.6591153144836426,
0.35424456000328064,
-0.61054527759552,
-0.9215337038040161,
-0.538158655166626,
-0.6476430892944336,
-1.2148902416229248,
0.48057910799980164,
-0.2530350685119629,
-0.6677924990653992,
0.1410161405801773,
0.3080228567123413,
-0.3702278137207031,
0.6632552742958069,
-0.6168358325958252,
1.397365927696228,
0.06513361632823944,
-0.016253609210252762,
-0.4547084867954254,
-0.754586398601532,
0.43111541867256165,
-0.10358966886997223,
0.6510735154151917,
0.22026190161705017,
-0.03360151872038841,
0.7670604586601257,
-0.26647987961769104,
0.8864011168479919,
-0.47257551550865173,
0.009369815699756145,
0.2956673800945282,
-0.07622998207807541,
0.42756137251853943,
-0.06178900599479675,
0.15998388826847076,
-0.0010163201950490475,
-0.12107076495885849,
-0.5533678531646729,
-0.4150102734565735,
0.9018008708953857,
-0.5774683356285095,
-0.16288399696350098,
0.04589317739009857,
-0.4951878488063812,
-0.3005322515964508,
0.3893914520740509,
0.0850973129272461,
0.5092406272888184,
-0.45955967903137207,
0.42608654499053955,
0.8057011365890503,
-0.023033780977129936,
0.1572982370853424,
0.1878502517938614,
-0.3753299117088318,
-0.4483965337276459,
1.096319317817688,
0.19145166873931885,
0.3424401581287384,
0.5562757253646851,
0.3465959131717682,
-0.19774264097213745,
-0.4063713848590851,
-0.6187581419944763,
0.20111802220344543,
-0.7749812602996826,
-0.39389967918395996,
-0.6752282977104187,
0.11723452806472778,
-0.7403180599212646,
0.2102402150630951,
-0.3596048951148987,
-0.48998358845710754,
-0.14515440165996552,
-0.08724133670330048,
0.22991015017032623,
0.916004478931427,
-0.20854102075099945,
0.2524827718734741,
-0.750542938709259,
0.5691707134246826,
0.3071722090244293,
0.2659153342247009,
0.4313007891178131,
0.0823586955666542,
-0.6388705968856812,
-0.09324507415294647,
-0.6767660975456238,
-0.8606968522071838,
-0.3104096055030823,
0.1999076008796692,
0.9332413077354431,
0.6120057106018066,
-0.07854024320840836,
0.511086642742157,
-0.6577162742614746,
0.4244012236595154,
0.4237534999847412,
-0.5558138489723206,
0.5643703937530518,
-0.4173598885536194,
0.17560407519340515,
0.5245294570922852,
0.8363761901855469,
-0.4546792507171631,
-0.46342745423316956,
-0.5414657592773438,
-0.9057573080062866,
0.787784993648529,
0.013481362722814083,
-0.12005253881216049,
-0.1334812343120575,
0.31498032808303833,
0.6170040369033813,
0.5743657350540161,
-0.6994794607162476,
-0.8247241377830505,
-0.12082326412200928,
-0.13155768811702728,
0.037972595542669296,
0.2287464588880539,
-0.11397067457437515,
-0.07807619869709015,
0.8724303245544434,
-0.22785373032093048,
0.21146802604198456,
-0.16811063885688782,
-0.3318035900592804,
-0.20046286284923553,
0.3598230183124542,
0.25359079241752625,
0.6327894926071167,
-0.08699985593557358,
0.12054579704999924,
-0.03284282982349396,
-0.2912091612815857,
-0.028840452432632446,
0.4275449216365814,
-0.027613744139671326,
-0.07933878153562546,
0.032414551824331284,
0.4363090991973877,
0.4791697859764099,
-0.3336136043071747,
0.6255604028701782,
0.46860024333000183,
-0.379631906747818,
0.16620685160160065,
-0.1618097722530365,
0.3336523175239563,
0.3066457211971283,
0.536389172077179,
0.5680078268051147,
-0.0019995286129415035,
-0.6680862307548523,
0.04680877551436424,
0.5506472587585449,
-0.07913275808095932,
0.06949898600578308,
0.5462217926979065,
0.0010281021241098642,
0.30528807640075684,
0.11842994391918182,
-0.5037663578987122,
-0.49707314372062683,
0.47375279664993286,
0.2502637803554535,
0.41236308217048645,
-0.5031670928001404,
0.15763889253139496,
0.47704699635505676,
0.24758780002593994,
-0.3017505705356598,
0.19064928591251373,
-0.1690141260623932,
-0.5934018492698669,
-0.36719122529029846,
-0.5745820999145508,
-0.11393566429615021,
0.04194146767258644,
-0.5378117561340332,
-0.05492905154824257,
-0.28143298625946045,
-0.20642916858196259,
0.003766481764614582,
-0.36749643087387085,
-0.6031461358070374,
0.0834733247756958,
0.016365420073270798,
0.5939832329750061,
-0.6015766263008118,
0.828427255153656,
0.9312813878059387,
-0.4823729693889618,
-0.6629999876022339,
-0.39010897278785706,
-0.0031139736529439688,
-0.510468065738678,
0.6752560138702393,
0.2046961635351181,
0.18161597847938538,
0.11008995771408081,
-0.14194731414318085,
-0.8806482553482056,
1.1990965604782104,
0.2983119487762451,
-0.3231661021709442,
-0.3229413330554962,
-0.06278020143508911,
0.08433748781681061,
-0.32194793224334717,
-0.3148926794528961,
0.15293489396572113,
0.7323217391967773,
-0.20543834567070007,
-1.1210554838180542,
0.06294574588537216,
0.2082129716873169,
-0.13651025295257568,
0.5835887789726257,
-0.6267077922821045,
0.9059971570968628,
-0.23434384167194366,
-0.13283489644527435,
0.29936137795448303,
0.6073183417320251,
-0.05344044789671898,
0.2620833218097687,
0.7521476149559021,
0.796710729598999,
0.8097904920578003,
-0.004048773553222418,
0.715285062789917,
0.05949380248785019,
0.4459775686264038,
0.9555701613426208,
0.11582488566637039,
0.9271092414855957,
0.5198761820793152,
-0.3141080141067505,
0.746065616607666,
0.3008793890476227,
0.26680341362953186,
0.7127699851989746,
0.18772254884243011,
-0.12695157527923584,
-0.12809766829013824,
0.14953523874282837,
-0.4768213927745819,
-0.020870836451649666,
0.3352702260017395,
-0.32664206624031067,
-0.5179873704910278,
0.6031768918037415,
0.030165182426571846,
-0.0027455617673695087,
-0.5320060849189758,
0.7853103876113892,
-0.01574951969087124,
-0.7202117443084717,
0.2316868007183075,
0.2605900168418884,
0.7542917728424072,
-0.8522124886512756,
0.21220147609710693,
0.17853723466396332,
0.3943924605846405,
-0.3342980742454529,
-0.35707876086235046,
0.07720272988080978,
-0.5677388310432434,
-0.3749920725822449,
-0.19717785716056824,
0.757204532623291,
-0.655636727809906,
-0.40524083375930786,
0.56920325756073,
0.8633959293365479,
-0.017858438193798065,
-0.3885429799556732,
-0.5776945352554321,
-0.2842693328857422,
-0.2571498155593872,
-0.14918692409992218,
0.5001552104949951,
0.5852411389350891,
0.1425967961549759,
0.3310406506061554,
0.667314350605011,
-0.14196275174617767,
0.48834094405174255,
0.004357973113656044,
0.8496487140655518,
-0.29265686869621277,
-0.5835685133934021,
-0.581386923789978,
0.2620966136455536,
0.26633337140083313,
-0.045786041766405106,
0.5785442590713501,
0.750176191329956,
1.0563452243804932,
-0.3301144242286682,
0.7583314776420593,
-0.495098739862442,
0.556495726108551,
-0.6493343710899353,
0.6103140115737915,
-0.7900688052177429,
-0.3486614227294922,
-0.4511285722255707,
-1.0841355323791504,
-0.35549744963645935,
0.4818095564842224,
-0.001488804118707776,
0.1689540147781372,
1.0879971981048584,
0.6456958055496216,
-0.5589412450790405,
0.11343754827976227,
0.15110886096954346,
0.12131396681070328,
-0.11562459170818329,
0.4754422903060913,
0.4510994553565979,
-0.3110043704509735,
1.022503137588501,
-0.5936815142631531,
-0.4991772472858429,
-0.15621113777160645,
-0.906456708908081,
-0.9928359985351562,
-0.8246086239814758,
-0.1573900580406189,
-0.24771496653556824,
0.11472688615322113,
0.90440434217453,
1.0676190853118896,
-0.9148826599121094,
-0.30025726556777954,
-0.04865337535738945,
0.16673418879508972,
-0.7129144668579102,
-0.23155812919139862,
0.49837854504585266,
-0.5624276399612427,
-0.38250932097435,
0.5113126635551453,
0.11441447585821152,
-0.3765021860599518,
-0.22739528119564056,
-0.042917873710393906,
-0.5209437012672424,
-0.567731499671936,
0.7674116492271423,
0.2702641785144806,
-0.7861568331718445,
-0.043565258383750916,
-0.006028308067470789,
0.012030372396111488,
0.07292647659778595,
0.9657430052757263,
-0.7134254574775696,
0.3179989457130432,
0.1312919706106186,
0.8217451572418213,
0.5290946960449219,
-0.07318054139614105,
0.16430941224098206,
-1.0958256721496582,
-0.20638467371463776,
-0.3150542974472046,
0.4393499195575714,
0.000562719942536205,
-0.31143149733543396,
0.40858474373817444,
0.49973005056381226,
-0.36809590458869934,
-0.27999159693717957,
0.0773569643497467,
-1.06296968460083,
-0.6348726749420166,
0.9327234625816345,
-0.2647523283958435,
-0.13706578314304352,
-0.35064560174942017,
-0.13378289341926575,
0.24000301957130432,
-0.690565288066864,
0.47150054574012756,
0.7265645265579224,
-0.1934971958398819,
0.4323559105396271,
-0.47416943311691284,
0.07250653952360153,
0.1687324345111847,
-0.8948746919631958,
0.034116312861442566,
0.49743232131004333,
0.2868552803993225,
0.764025866985321,
0.4541796147823334,
0.017842287197709084,
0.426734060049057,
-0.23270924389362335,
0.03778834268450737,
-0.26182106137275696,
-0.5255047678947449,
0.20920366048812866,
0.6646850109100342,
-0.15747299790382385,
-0.2488594353199005
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14208v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14208v1
|
Automatic Annotation of Grammaticality in Child-Caregiver Conversations
| 2024-03-21T08:00:05 | 2024-03-21T08:00:05 |
Mitja Nikolaus, Abhishek Agrawal, Petros Kaklamanis, Alex Warstadt, Abdellah Fourtassi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The acquisition of grammar has been a central question to adjudicate between
theories of language acquisition. In order to conduct faster, more
reproducible, and larger-scale corpus studies on grammaticality in
child-caregiver conversations, tools for automatic annotation can offer an
effective alternative to tedious manual annotation. We propose a coding scheme
for context-dependent grammaticality in child-caregiver conversations and
annotate more than 4,000 utterances from a large corpus of transcribed
conversations. Based on these annotations, we train and evaluate a range of NLP
models. Our results show that fine-tuned Transformer-based models perform best,
achieving human inter-annotation agreement levels.As a first application and
sanity check of this tool, we use the trained models to annotate a corpus
almost two orders of magnitude larger than the manually annotated data and
verify that children's grammaticality shows a steady increase with age.This
work contributes to the growing literature on applying state-of-the-art NLP
methods to help study child language acquisition at scale.
|
[
-0.35567694902420044,
-0.6443281769752502,
0.3438093960285187,
0.3316628634929657,
-0.09408801048994064,
-0.29810211062431335,
-0.42814645171165466,
-0.7820353507995605,
-0.03401102125644684,
0.1491146832704544,
-0.5227535963058472,
-0.34280869364738464,
-0.7846395969390869,
0.26655086874961853,
-0.4312494397163391,
0.7728965878486633,
0.2037450671195984,
-0.01763591170310974,
-0.3791253864765167,
0.08726184070110321,
-0.26933273673057556,
-0.8184124231338501,
-0.790034294128418,
-0.10575732588768005,
0.38183921575546265,
0.40672996640205383,
0.6826040744781494,
0.7575432062149048,
0.585612416267395,
0.28489503264427185,
-0.40203434228897095,
0.29516398906707764,
-0.05660621076822281,
0.32198548316955566,
-0.058371346443891525,
-0.3465355634689331,
-0.621823251247406,
0.060602713376283646,
0.42012500762939453,
0.89846271276474,
-0.0010830963728949428,
0.20363162457942963,
-0.22105959057807922,
0.3239797055721283,
-0.5559647679328918,
0.603314995765686,
-0.5908896327018738,
0.2975631654262543,
0.07425344735383987,
0.021987920626997948,
-0.6221445798873901,
-0.2857483923435211,
0.12304709851741791,
-0.43095579743385315,
0.06082722917199135,
-0.24562038481235504,
0.8756002187728882,
0.1489800065755844,
-0.4325253963470459,
-0.37945592403411865,
-0.7609418630599976,
0.46151942014694214,
-0.7653331756591797,
0.26845550537109375,
1.0015405416488647,
-0.08983445912599564,
-0.05214535817503929,
-0.7972475290298462,
-0.6863886117935181,
-0.3811957538127899,
-0.7076948285102844,
-0.2449541836977005,
-0.14023782312870026,
0.03252401202917099,
0.44731295108795166,
0.21259234845638275,
-0.4701768755912781,
0.030930910259485245,
-0.2625409662723541,
0.1778556853532791,
0.6586960554122925,
-0.07764791697263718,
0.5107468366622925,
-0.4128485918045044,
-0.04177168756723404,
-0.04473560303449631,
-0.3842300772666931,
0.026446662843227386,
0.09539219737052917,
0.3890318274497986,
-0.041612010449171066,
0.5283804535865784,
-0.42152947187423706,
0.6061624884605408,
0.3489859998226166,
0.15109223127365112,
0.20913884043693542,
-0.44742512702941895,
-0.09023046493530273,
-0.1382054090499878,
0.6365943551063538,
0.3857904076576233,
0.7259416580200195,
-0.29305875301361084,
-0.06410610675811768,
0.4839552044868469,
0.35577282309532166,
-0.504952073097229,
-0.3390408158302307,
0.06149822473526001,
-0.10390372574329376,
-0.30129730701446533,
0.09513524174690247,
-0.5952880382537842,
-0.1868182271718979,
-0.4475073516368866,
-0.09180848300457001,
-0.31632277369499207,
-0.13694952428340912,
0.08684331178665161,
0.158527210354805,
0.30014467239379883,
0.10355783998966217,
-1.3800454139709473,
0.2951371967792511,
0.7755593657493591,
0.36651572585105896,
0.012584807351231575,
-0.3503745198249817,
-0.6045119166374207,
-0.11974494904279709,
-0.4620511829853058,
0.9313364028930664,
-0.6558074951171875,
-0.3276470899581909,
0.3550334572792053,
0.28766435384750366,
-0.402254194021225,
-0.3672201633453369,
0.5496128797531128,
-0.4366382658481598,
0.41930294036865234,
0.055980581790208817,
-0.5512885451316833,
0.052521269768476486,
0.2866629958152771,
-0.3960133194923401,
0.920263946056366,
0.20109857618808746,
-0.5123034119606018,
0.8128592371940613,
-0.6734851002693176,
-0.6503587365150452,
0.2172098457813263,
0.012626130133867264,
-0.39375030994415283,
0.16938136518001556,
0.5032309293746948,
0.602776050567627,
0.2980622351169586,
0.5178946852684021,
0.019612818956375122,
-0.05139941722154617,
0.22334623336791992,
-0.4760608375072479,
0.78676837682724,
-0.08650190383195877,
-0.3741473853588104,
-0.023218227550387383,
-0.7167896628379822,
0.1309995949268341,
0.06784526258707047,
-0.3232344090938568,
-0.12924815714359283,
0.13618488609790802,
0.21062447130680084,
0.18378834426403046,
0.15310870110988617,
-0.4788939654827118,
0.4543127417564392,
-0.5451327562332153,
0.5883253216743469,
0.05770913138985634,
-0.033231839537620544,
0.5546939969062805,
-0.3236824870109558,
0.496334969997406,
-0.232644721865654,
0.5274596214294434,
-0.5144683718681335,
-0.31843313574790955,
-0.9401483535766602,
0.013034767471253872,
0.14431670308113098,
0.4532788395881653,
-0.2956116199493408,
0.853258490562439,
-0.3688904345035553,
-0.3621167838573456,
-0.21354131400585175,
0.06016699597239494,
0.5822538733482361,
0.2372724860906601,
0.4498178958892822,
-0.27830085158348083,
-0.6641908288002014,
-0.7584977149963379,
0.09943239390850067,
-0.5814847350120544,
0.18260422348976135,
0.3057669699192047,
0.27760061621665955,
-0.3574088215827942,
0.9878028035163879,
-0.18954923748970032,
-0.050754424184560776,
-0.1389225423336029,
0.2905924618244171,
-0.26365184783935547,
0.7278450727462769,
0.5104990005493164,
-0.8133657574653625,
-0.3255228102207184,
0.031941771507263184,
-0.5414829850196838,
-0.3203301727771759,
-0.10328676551580429,
-0.17051829397678375,
0.5089464783668518,
0.7831955552101135,
-0.8399292230606079,
0.47185689210891724,
0.6652854681015015,
-0.7101041078567505,
0.3176712691783905,
-0.07619794458150864,
-0.04117291420698166,
-0.7783570885658264,
0.2663545608520508,
-0.34868577122688293,
-0.5362764000892639,
-0.7306735515594482,
0.09936556965112686,
0.14714235067367554,
0.2662489414215088,
-0.372266560792923,
0.21819795668125153,
-0.3856518566608429,
0.25131624937057495,
0.0009519331506453454,
0.15370988845825195,
-0.04550034552812576,
0.4865407645702362,
0.17476145923137665,
0.667860746383667,
-0.14300929009914398,
-0.23969151079654694,
0.26906147599220276,
0.4510100185871124,
0.1416512429714203,
0.6631399393081665,
-0.4857715666294098,
0.44992733001708984,
-0.17091971635818481,
0.365988552570343,
-0.9729515910148621,
-0.23984681069850922,
0.15085363388061523,
-0.4367853105068207,
0.38675254583358765,
-0.3823572099208832,
-0.6551644206047058,
-0.14712175726890564,
0.0492299348115921,
0.21097218990325928,
0.20929382741451263,
-0.5678841471672058,
0.5613599419593811,
0.5499066710472107,
-0.43343013525009155,
-0.34342309832572937,
-0.45636528730392456,
0.3342621922492981,
-0.05927769094705582,
-0.6123506426811218,
0.18341811001300812,
0.10157312452793121,
-0.22826926410198212,
-0.15172423422336578,
0.001525448402389884,
-0.35044145584106445,
0.14421924948692322,
0.3383890688419342,
0.36150306463241577,
-0.26198360323905945,
0.32148027420043945,
0.16820667684078217,
-0.2757340669631958,
0.22825157642364502,
-0.15001754462718964,
0.6451529264450073,
-0.4208725094795227,
-0.17884497344493866,
-0.24291551113128662,
0.39758503437042236,
0.6252754926681519,
-0.10007554292678833,
0.45630908012390137,
0.263778954744339,
-0.5551878809928894,
-0.24615415930747986,
-0.6405505537986755,
0.04678590968251228,
-0.39893412590026855,
0.14899496734142303,
-0.20812629163265228,
-0.7273902893066406,
0.36490243673324585,
0.022263476625084877,
0.2624398171901703,
0.5531618595123291,
0.2016463577747345,
-0.23862630128860474,
0.7719284892082214,
0.5266187191009521,
0.08959868550300598,
0.5514726042747498,
-0.19147798418998718,
-0.0657760500907898,
-0.5983967781066895,
-0.26568931341171265,
-0.49668222665786743,
-0.10332687944173813,
-0.3340833783149719,
-0.28108423948287964,
-0.24483351409435272,
0.0060187713243067265,
0.06361294537782669,
0.6351071000099182,
-0.47754189372062683,
0.5023890733718872,
0.29792290925979614,
-0.13022348284721375,
0.5291566252708435,
-0.27266812324523926,
0.163462832570076,
-0.09250152111053467,
-0.6741634607315063,
-0.6973215341567993,
0.6317673325538635,
0.2674485445022583,
0.1329774707555771,
0.049530573189258575,
0.5698195695877075,
0.1692981868982315,
0.5719268321990967,
-0.9107450246810913,
0.4926762282848358,
-0.408063143491745,
-0.48886436223983765,
-0.4305257797241211,
-0.07497306913137436,
-0.9551646709442139,
0.12025386840105057,
-0.44151514768600464,
-0.7072934508323669,
0.4748697876930237,
0.3549730181694031,
-0.43505772948265076,
-0.18729934096336365,
-0.9628742337226868,
1.0351393222808838,
-0.09911032766103745,
-0.005695367697626352,
0.26861050724983215,
-0.7491077184677124,
-0.013274830766022205,
-0.027634084224700928,
0.07784517854452133,
0.17749939858913422,
0.1440182626247406,
0.6408107876777649,
-0.3753499984741211,
1.0088069438934326,
-0.06389174610376358,
-0.19683733582496643,
0.35901373624801636,
0.13087818026542664,
0.43443843722343445,
0.1825874149799347,
0.47850263118743896,
0.06138079613447189,
0.27828866243362427,
-0.1779344528913498,
-0.5389449596405029,
0.382273405790329,
-0.4478072226047516,
-0.3347598612308502,
-0.40930211544036865,
-0.6084756255149841,
-0.29334449768066406,
0.1556239128112793,
0.01136840134859085,
0.19275934994220734,
-0.0883529856801033,
0.2657357454299927,
0.38606926798820496,
0.04109257459640503,
0.638181746006012,
0.2469470351934433,
-0.28334733843803406,
-0.1946440488100052,
0.33608976006507874,
-0.007671695668250322,
0.4700012803077698,
0.16302862763404846,
0.15822266042232513,
-0.11968788504600525,
-0.2082400619983673,
-0.44068264961242676,
0.25171253085136414,
-0.804133951663971,
-0.09161432832479477,
-0.7742767930030823,
-0.3496946692466736,
-0.31861814856529236,
-0.3441714942455292,
-0.3768880367279053,
-0.7113009691238403,
-0.2365671694278717,
-0.34555551409721375,
0.37640926241874695,
0.7233116626739502,
0.05836545675992966,
0.41900694370269775,
-0.6129368543624878,
0.10890989005565643,
0.5448107123374939,
0.0748000219464302,
-0.2530267834663391,
-0.4973931312561035,
-0.10627717524766922,
-0.062110159546136856,
0.07889348268508911,
-0.527631402015686,
0.23865312337875366,
0.39661702513694763,
0.11799725890159607,
0.26318520307540894,
-0.16575811803340912,
0.8155167102813721,
-0.4642299711704254,
0.7470303177833557,
-0.05627414211630821,
-1.1435058116912842,
0.6796934008598328,
-0.4409140348434448,
0.27466288208961487,
0.7381331920623779,
-0.15702518820762634,
-0.8160989880561829,
-0.34878894686698914,
-0.8812711238861084,
-0.9569324254989624,
0.5863310694694519,
-0.0321367084980011,
0.49031510949134827,
-0.25524935126304626,
0.45187491178512573,
0.006331990472972393,
-0.08604410290718079,
-0.5453539490699768,
0.14007753133773804,
0.03411247208714485,
-0.375847727060318,
-0.04937496781349182,
-0.47946158051490784,
-0.08180160820484161,
-0.24148377776145935,
0.3338882327079773,
-0.24121101200580597,
0.06276500970125198,
0.19115889072418213,
-0.41022247076034546,
-0.10700912028551102,
0.26772189140319824,
0.5787609219551086,
0.6777752637863159,
-0.05143201723694801,
0.34088951349258423,
0.2690272331237793,
-0.6542695760726929,
0.011537522077560425,
0.28565502166748047,
-0.128627210855484,
0.06761487573385239,
0.7878673672676086,
0.4825027287006378,
0.404561847448349,
-0.5892916917800903,
0.715509295463562,
-0.21337193250656128,
-0.1580735296010971,
-0.6765344142913818,
0.09961704164743423,
0.29458680748939514,
0.13463817536830902,
-0.002116472227498889,
-0.07144847512245178,
-0.20229387283325195,
-0.48281240463256836,
0.41279083490371704,
0.22425471246242523,
-0.3038583993911743,
-0.24163872003555298,
0.30837348103523254,
0.11597642302513123,
-0.5150448679924011,
0.7088853716850281,
-0.20956987142562866,
-0.4197123944759369,
0.5970664620399475,
0.4229576289653778,
0.9399458765983582,
-0.20959894359111786,
0.21191924810409546,
0.23360656201839447,
0.5330410003662109,
-0.2472417652606964,
0.20723989605903625,
-0.2473338395357132,
-0.6312285661697388,
-0.6300872564315796,
-0.4320131540298462,
-0.3695831894874573,
-0.044434115290641785,
-0.8336611986160278,
0.1536581814289093,
-0.3876548409461975,
-0.3024689853191376,
0.15712779760360718,
-0.24176806211471558,
-0.7189971804618835,
0.34690946340560913,
0.44563326239585876,
0.5583046078681946,
-1.070654273033142,
0.6295032501220703,
0.6991475224494934,
-0.4756968915462494,
-0.6590926051139832,
-0.02492588944733143,
-0.41509997844696045,
-0.6657061576843262,
0.8643965721130371,
0.10269734263420105,
-0.15740929543972015,
-0.010289130732417107,
-0.5513948798179626,
-0.7280175089836121,
0.773927628993988,
0.08511580526828766,
-0.7365058064460754,
-0.21386800706386566,
0.12451215088367462,
0.7178606986999512,
-0.4956298768520355,
0.2708791196346283,
0.7786710262298584,
0.37080711126327515,
-0.15392518043518066,
-1.0364011526107788,
-0.040769997984170914,
-0.5461403727531433,
0.12482082843780518,
-0.044780053198337555,
-0.11583559215068817,
0.46042874455451965,
-0.045237500220537186,
-0.34743770956993103,
-0.05969015508890152,
0.5850740671157837,
-0.12318307161331177,
0.3016144335269928,
0.7143674492835999,
0.21764439344406128,
0.5395910143852234,
-0.10313861072063446,
0.8094980120658875,
-0.41884151101112366,
0.43327489495277405,
1.2836042642593384,
0.29194948077201843,
0.9764025807380676,
0.5705292224884033,
-0.24121670424938202,
0.3594115376472473,
0.18199534714221954,
0.13502058386802673,
-0.06414671987295151,
0.2750873267650604,
-0.1786198616027832,
-0.024379832670092583,
-0.1634058803319931,
0.07698139548301697,
0.578733503818512,
0.6303796768188477,
-0.6082773804664612,
0.15826866030693054,
-0.06717678159475327,
0.5583701133728027,
0.21411249041557312,
0.17631176114082336,
1.0841816663742065,
0.05196351557970047,
-0.9257609844207764,
0.6172280311584473,
-0.2426825612783432,
0.5975484251976013,
-0.3594340980052948,
-0.09319406002759933,
-0.30092617869377136,
-0.04269758611917496,
-0.45459187030792236,
-0.4152092933654785,
0.42650750279426575,
0.3375392556190491,
-0.09872683137655258,
-0.366239458322525,
0.5463870763778687,
-0.6652481555938721,
-0.5562576651573181,
0.22343149781227112,
0.6082842350006104,
-0.030552558600902557,
0.19360975921154022,
-0.22199684381484985,
0.06090443581342697,
-0.4382774531841278,
-0.23561130464076996,
-0.15071985125541687,
0.3408453166484833,
-0.0646027997136116,
0.27030834555625916,
0.7062951326370239,
0.2369965761899948,
0.4140888452529907,
0.28919273614883423,
0.7123923301696777,
-0.4546228349208832,
-0.3272413909435272,
-0.8037606477737427,
0.6489675641059875,
-0.083491250872612,
-0.7276746034622192,
0.36798152327537537,
0.13324007391929626,
1.0461291074752808,
0.0629848912358284,
0.6850100159645081,
-0.23902204632759094,
0.251769483089447,
-0.27584388852119446,
0.4468492269515991,
-0.05416969209909439,
0.0017773043364286423,
-0.2605248987674713,
-0.7115994691848755,
-0.8393396139144897,
1.2811064720153809,
-0.5213308930397034,
-0.03334246203303337,
0.7943195700645447,
0.5516031384468079,
-0.14562182128429413,
0.29137250781059265,
0.06596608459949493,
0.024784047156572342,
0.4512206017971039,
0.4406457543373108,
0.8984249830245972,
-0.34114834666252136,
0.3474087417125702,
-0.5630502104759216,
-0.2615598142147064,
-0.24783241748809814,
-0.8193027377128601,
-0.842721164226532,
-0.47322437167167664,
-0.47473520040512085,
-0.2573906183242798,
0.1707235723733902,
1.2206851243972778,
0.724520742893219,
-0.7119747996330261,
-0.08364307135343552,
-0.3275201618671417,
-0.5194486379623413,
-0.3218572735786438,
-0.14698736369609833,
0.37581732869148254,
-0.7759395837783813,
-0.8589677214622498,
0.43327954411506653,
0.017686014994978905,
-0.07317368686199188,
-0.24492396414279938,
0.3286096751689911,
-0.2731335759162903,
0.013242675922811031,
0.7187232971191406,
0.34587952494621277,
-0.6362278461456299,
-0.5423064231872559,
-0.11459201574325562,
-0.3304448425769806,
0.061070483177900314,
0.7039090991020203,
-0.46227505803108215,
0.5786934494972229,
0.2754688858985901,
0.6440668106079102,
0.450236439704895,
0.23009607195854187,
0.44143009185791016,
-0.7215386033058167,
0.17951641976833344,
0.3773144781589508,
0.2405308187007904,
0.4305543303489685,
-0.4617615044116974,
0.5219024419784546,
0.1364298015832901,
-0.5264019966125488,
-0.6630956530570984,
0.1848023384809494,
-0.8810005187988281,
0.01944889687001705,
1.1745256185531616,
-0.41900894045829773,
0.044996969401836395,
-0.2577427923679352,
-0.29185524582862854,
0.2231970876455307,
-0.28617358207702637,
0.8982852101325989,
0.8151707649230957,
-0.03823130205273628,
-0.12706133723258972,
-0.4332773983478546,
0.6091130971908569,
0.5749466419219971,
-0.9957512021064758,
0.29346343874931335,
0.505146324634552,
-0.033179450780153275,
0.3919072151184082,
0.49916043877601624,
-0.218661829829216,
0.25689011812210083,
0.1336507648229599,
0.015660759061574936,
-0.028872361406683922,
-0.3344367742538452,
-0.4608529210090637,
0.1582634299993515,
0.1019677072763443,
-0.10768530517816544
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14197v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14197v1
|
Context Quality Matters in Training Fusion-in-Decoder for Extractive Open-Domain Question Answering
| 2024-03-21T07:47:57 | 2024-03-21T07:47:57 |
Kosuke Akimoto, Kunihiro Takeoka, Masafumi Oyamada
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Retrieval-augmented generation models augment knowledge encoded in a language
model by providing additional relevant external knowledge (context) during
generation. Although it has been shown that the quantity and quality of context
impact the performance of retrieval-augmented generation models during
inference, limited research explores how these characteristics affect model
training. This paper explores how context quantity and quality during model
training affect the performance of Fusion-in-Decoder (FiD), the
state-of-the-art retrieval-augmented generation model, in extractive
open-domain question answering tasks. Experimental results suggest that FiD
models overfit to context quality during training and show suboptimal
performance when evaluated on different context quality. Through the
experimental results, we also reveal FiD models trained with different context
quality have different cross-attention distribution patterns. Specifically, as
context quality during training increases, FiD models tend to attend more
uniformly to each passage in context. Finally, based on these observations, we
propose a method to mitigate overfitting to specific context quality by
introducing bias to the cross-attention distribution, which we demonstrate to
be effective in improving the performance of FiD models on different context
quality.
|
[
-0.68337082862854,
-0.754945695400238,
0.20379997789859772,
-0.1526697725057602,
-0.3679942488670349,
-0.26572999358177185,
0.08780673891305923,
-0.49052831530570984,
-0.38722631335258484,
0.4980107247829437,
-0.2967095673084259,
0.016018595546483994,
-0.5848026871681213,
0.1386193037033081,
-0.3435005247592926,
0.902439534664154,
-0.2230871021747589,
0.23699387907981873,
-0.8029088973999023,
-0.270099401473999,
-0.6239621043205261,
-0.7472001314163208,
-0.4618235230445862,
-0.17162632942199707,
-0.0935700535774231,
0.1993250846862793,
0.48666784167289734,
0.3501015603542328,
0.3646441400051117,
0.23672492802143097,
-0.1447078138589859,
0.21958328783512115,
-0.7146716117858887,
0.23199234902858734,
-0.5010985732078552,
-0.3199025094509125,
0.034650769084692,
0.0686945766210556,
0.8132880926132202,
0.6021274924278259,
0.06525494903326035,
0.13625742495059967,
0.2972210645675659,
0.3668542504310608,
-0.9470457434654236,
-0.14932756125926971,
-0.507904589176178,
-0.2998475432395935,
0.20839953422546387,
-0.4175744652748108,
-0.5230675935745239,
-0.0702662244439125,
0.44746315479278564,
-0.5291404724121094,
0.6185338497161865,
0.06622014194726944,
0.9987706542015076,
0.31359541416168213,
-0.39790552854537964,
-0.004384929779917002,
-0.7333447933197021,
0.7285379767417908,
-0.5403429865837097,
0.6184375286102295,
0.45838895440101624,
0.18741928040981293,
-0.021519040688872337,
-0.5125525593757629,
-0.5003582835197449,
0.4147513508796692,
-0.24258707463741302,
0.030294589698314667,
0.2990294396877289,
0.07522601634263992,
0.2861359119415283,
0.533234715461731,
-0.3725343644618988,
-0.2981530427932739,
-0.3356381952762604,
0.022413818165659904,
0.5710248947143555,
0.052884791046381,
0.3829416036605835,
0.011623097583651543,
-0.5418623089790344,
-0.31998804211616516,
-0.7238647937774658,
0.4001025855541229,
0.024300115182995796,
0.14564964175224304,
0.14604522287845612,
0.5010720491409302,
-0.44778192043304443,
0.7911152243614197,
0.19774013757705688,
-0.12712545692920685,
0.11262010782957077,
-0.6575008034706116,
-0.4570806920528412,
-0.014106718823313713,
0.24331703782081604,
-0.0017902932595461607,
0.03997598588466644,
-0.32040491700172424,
-0.4370008409023285,
-0.4147051274776459,
0.35088735818862915,
-0.7984166741371155,
0.21838507056236267,
0.2553144693374634,
-0.5490320920944214,
0.16526877880096436,
0.3147405982017517,
-0.39816173911094666,
0.17968367040157318,
-0.32724860310554504,
0.8949348330497742,
-0.752926230430603,
-0.3400940001010895,
0.19136546552181244,
-0.4185695946216583,
0.3490465581417084,
0.07726484537124634,
-0.991988480091095,
0.11689769476652145,
0.6234631538391113,
0.5977736711502075,
-0.19205401837825775,
-0.4022290110588074,
-0.7147979736328125,
0.15718653798103333,
-0.22500091791152954,
0.6487845778465271,
-0.5788277387619019,
-0.39465874433517456,
0.015257635153830051,
0.046157076954841614,
-0.7237693071365356,
-0.6811102628707886,
0.34408262372016907,
-0.9614802002906799,
0.4906133711338043,
-0.5416185855865479,
-0.7369418144226074,
-0.15385288000106812,
0.07071971893310547,
-0.5210951566696167,
0.8047918677330017,
0.6989089846611023,
-0.9187641739845276,
0.8082266449928284,
-0.622846245765686,
-0.47886067628860474,
0.18953639268875122,
-0.004134723916649818,
0.015326146967709064,
0.3266339600086212,
0.38734495639801025,
0.342207670211792,
-0.18720939755439758,
-0.050176169723272324,
0.06858709454536438,
-0.5988451838493347,
0.4285636842250824,
-0.2312021702528,
0.7105906009674072,
0.2926529049873352,
-0.07463149726390839,
-0.02505076676607132,
-0.5884599089622498,
0.0356297492980957,
-0.017131440341472626,
-0.464206725358963,
-0.6989273428916931,
-0.11060871928930283,
-0.12931986153125763,
0.519147515296936,
-0.18848060071468353,
-0.8081854581832886,
-0.2788841128349304,
-0.8019055128097534,
0.20240464806556702,
0.39420315623283386,
0.5920034050941467,
0.6155604720115662,
-0.39238473773002625,
0.384145587682724,
0.17170339822769165,
0.050935931503772736,
-0.16932035982608795,
-0.19563846290111542,
-0.5938283801078796,
-0.19242222607135773,
0.4710509479045868,
0.2831699252128601,
-1.046388864517212,
0.2825683057308197,
-0.20348407328128815,
-0.10402097553014755,
-0.8580230474472046,
-0.04907888174057007,
0.6274197697639465,
0.8070387244224548,
0.3800870180130005,
-0.3186894953250885,
-0.0744175910949707,
-0.6240344047546387,
-0.2245130091905594,
0.27813833951950073,
-0.05003482475876808,
0.3563108742237091,
0.5715029239654541,
0.024475447833538055,
1.437223196029663,
-0.2529984712600708,
-0.12519708275794983,
-0.34193119406700134,
-0.14947019517421722,
-0.2201271504163742,
0.5979970097541809,
0.6118849515914917,
-1.0462111234664917,
-0.3308868110179901,
-0.1256168782711029,
-0.6058670878410339,
0.17476579546928406,
-0.12633004784584045,
-0.5783146023750305,
0.43105801939964294,
0.38751235604286194,
-0.613361656665802,
0.2742663323879242,
0.22961437702178955,
-0.4797595739364624,
0.18315206468105316,
-0.0603996142745018,
0.4717373251914978,
-1.0809133052825928,
0.23833537101745605,
-0.12370054423809052,
0.11708950251340866,
-0.6557254791259766,
0.4720185101032257,
0.17404548823833466,
0.014805653132498264,
-0.804978609085083,
0.5917235016822815,
-0.2369394153356552,
-0.3963809311389923,
-0.22920508682727814,
-0.09188903123140335,
0.4217897951602936,
0.4014948010444641,
0.33990418910980225,
1.1998109817504883,
0.23775674402713776,
-0.6174287796020508,
-0.17868578433990479,
0.4849717617034912,
-0.6016916632652283,
0.552177369594574,
-0.5794234275817871,
-0.10150711238384247,
-0.22250095009803772,
0.009899361059069633,
-1.1290159225463867,
-0.3463631868362427,
-0.061006005853414536,
-0.43380793929100037,
0.5218559503555298,
-0.04072769358754158,
-0.5047293305397034,
-0.04579978436231613,
-0.0023780290503054857,
0.6284064650535583,
0.48391690850257874,
-0.7722728848457336,
0.3791508972644806,
0.17996956408023834,
0.20313569903373718,
-0.5434805154800415,
-0.39704325795173645,
-0.7311971187591553,
-0.0884695053100586,
-0.8769179582595825,
0.3170957565307617,
0.0220164991915226,
-0.008474515751004219,
-0.011470564641058445,
-0.27606096863746643,
-0.16036993265151978,
0.21855489909648895,
0.03961644694209099,
-0.03547632694244385,
-0.30056118965148926,
0.21407169103622437,
0.32028132677078247,
-0.006538854446262121,
0.2195056527853012,
-0.10003919899463654,
0.6376842260360718,
0.2643260955810547,
-0.30801114439964294,
-0.27465739846229553,
0.623433530330658,
0.4768097698688507,
-0.5891343951225281,
1.2682043313980103,
0.4852636456489563,
-0.19115933775901794,
-0.1934000551700592,
-0.39663681387901306,
-0.3987681567668915,
-0.48962169885635376,
0.20429283380508423,
-0.5452619791030884,
-0.8705123662948608,
0.3944013714790344,
0.2134326845407486,
0.06907102465629578,
0.4791496992111206,
0.2903299629688263,
-0.16835157573223114,
1.250422477722168,
0.5673725605010986,
0.18249234557151794,
0.5861883163452148,
-0.49417877197265625,
-0.06112382560968399,
-1.2310081720352173,
-0.3573683500289917,
-0.4512683153152466,
-0.02695285901427269,
-0.16647401452064514,
-0.0783693939447403,
0.4440004825592041,
0.37232324481010437,
-0.3635746240615845,
-0.012282116338610649,
-0.4457011818885803,
0.5277518033981323,
0.614798903465271,
0.29316580295562744,
0.17058917880058289,
0.2905677855014801,
0.1438021957874298,
0.1656264066696167,
-1.0545862913131714,
-0.21757036447525024,
0.9167752265930176,
0.2668002247810364,
0.6261818408966064,
-0.033580128103494644,
0.5961310863494873,
-0.010262110270559788,
0.05149475485086441,
-0.22162343561649323,
0.17669714987277985,
0.1199820339679718,
-0.7844356298446655,
-0.29893922805786133,
-0.43619003891944885,
-0.8290623426437378,
0.4768751561641693,
-0.04745437577366829,
-0.5127593874931335,
0.6276920437812805,
0.050560541450977325,
-0.43264418840408325,
0.07245729863643646,
-0.7698603272438049,
0.9604322910308838,
0.0670696496963501,
-0.28571033477783203,
-0.08227477222681046,
-0.614136815071106,
0.4533527195453644,
0.06610700488090515,
-0.06577474623918533,
0.15810488164424896,
0.1641051173210144,
0.7044254541397095,
-0.36489248275756836,
0.42474302649497986,
-0.14562271535396576,
-0.0510917566716671,
0.5267599821090698,
-0.03302653133869171,
0.3144071102142334,
0.12756825983524323,
-0.1973622590303421,
0.0556940920650959,
0.24085557460784912,
-0.6307118535041809,
-0.5176553726196289,
0.5268967151641846,
-1.056518316268921,
-0.5445955991744995,
-0.1474464386701584,
-0.6231664419174194,
-0.3549867868423462,
-0.0913124531507492,
0.7550534605979919,
0.8418601751327515,
-0.02629169262945652,
0.3832753002643585,
1.0864248275756836,
-0.3326192796230316,
0.3491222858428955,
0.15385250747203827,
0.36801397800445557,
-0.3546599745750427,
0.982975423336029,
0.2505192756652832,
1.057440996170044,
0.29251396656036377,
-0.1433071345090866,
-0.40943512320518494,
-0.39948102831840515,
-0.5605136156082153,
0.05085359141230583,
-1.0879956483840942,
-0.22393056750297546,
-0.8628040552139282,
-0.5092610716819763,
-0.6166771054267883,
-0.14755287766456604,
-0.07996739447116852,
-0.1606379747390747,
-0.5461024641990662,
0.15786664187908173,
0.25102856755256653,
0.14940594136714935,
0.3165434002876282,
0.3707275092601776,
-0.8029758334159851,
0.23321446776390076,
0.30618780851364136,
0.4987907409667969,
0.057392239570617676,
-0.8135588765144348,
-0.46722400188446045,
0.23374170064926147,
-0.0623311810195446,
-0.5794684290885925,
0.35815662145614624,
0.28702014684677124,
0.7175861597061157,
0.262432336807251,
0.278195858001709,
0.43790218234062195,
0.05941221863031387,
0.9172111749649048,
-0.26283469796180725,
-0.6705250144004822,
0.537774920463562,
-0.16226249933242798,
0.6269251108169556,
0.6114990711212158,
0.5281456112861633,
-0.1778743416070938,
-0.2729717493057251,
-0.5395208597183228,
-0.6608654856681824,
1.119985818862915,
0.11939780414104462,
0.17410533130168915,
-0.22090548276901245,
0.3702073395252228,
0.34592142701148987,
0.11984381079673767,
-0.3724870979785919,
0.03008509986102581,
-0.43507876992225647,
0.05480063334107399,
0.05340610817074776,
-0.46455150842666626,
-0.15462489426136017,
-0.2664546072483063,
0.6372051239013672,
-0.04928372800350189,
0.2863893508911133,
0.40283066034317017,
-0.4314810037612915,
-0.3570488691329956,
0.10506661236286163,
0.5682021379470825,
0.7107705473899841,
-0.4437555968761444,
-0.21893402934074402,
0.1730533391237259,
-0.33635857701301575,
0.006344189867377281,
-0.1611049771308899,
-0.3973878026008606,
-0.0538036935031414,
0.36112314462661743,
0.8268362283706665,
0.08168892562389374,
-0.7262871265411377,
0.5136801600456238,
-0.01717023365199566,
-0.19847123324871063,
0.22562959790229797,
0.6277803778648376,
-0.4066372513771057,
0.21022005379199982,
0.6050642728805542,
0.08974669873714447,
0.23437906801700592,
-0.5126209259033203,
0.0878070592880249,
0.5431694388389587,
-0.16179940104484558,
0.015349693596363068,
0.6244609951972961,
0.2726694643497467,
-0.1064993217587471,
0.7626879811286926,
-0.025539103895425797,
-0.4663213789463043,
0.6463690400123596,
0.7853878736495972,
0.6466988325119019,
-0.16124923527240753,
-0.0829896479845047,
0.3693277835845947,
-0.05451790615916252,
-0.035530224442481995,
0.44762346148490906,
-0.24192366003990173,
-0.7332913279533386,
-0.6212971210479736,
-0.7153275609016418,
-0.10167432576417923,
-0.012261002324521542,
-0.785895824432373,
-0.12884657084941864,
-0.04858420789241791,
0.0458412691950798,
-0.39943745732307434,
-0.07946552336215973,
-0.6979185938835144,
0.5444508790969849,
-0.19864216446876526,
0.8426750302314758,
-0.6902328729629517,
0.7305852174758911,
0.43042781949043274,
-0.5657879710197449,
-0.6361141204833984,
-0.0010906978277489543,
-0.6326982378959656,
-0.3029904067516327,
0.6193902492523193,
0.0779436007142067,
0.10491496324539185,
0.386345773935318,
-0.47313302755355835,
-1.2623555660247803,
1.0021811723709106,
0.23843559622764587,
0.06364444643259048,
0.13714462518692017,
0.14957788586616516,
0.4498112201690674,
-0.5623968243598938,
0.32742685079574585,
0.6707373261451721,
-0.054343678057193756,
0.15168343484401703,
-0.832537055015564,
-0.1001056581735611,
-0.11721296608448029,
0.08450111746788025,
0.251055508852005,
-0.49905067682266235,
0.8493973612785339,
-0.13502001762390137,
-0.6193951964378357,
-0.0068724993616342545,
0.5582951903343201,
0.2311089038848877,
0.22865065932273865,
0.28478142619132996,
0.33246684074401855,
0.17698028683662415,
-0.13691911101341248,
1.550414800643921,
-0.2817542254924774,
0.23999205231666565,
0.8673772215843201,
-0.1654563695192337,
0.8637704253196716,
0.45560675859451294,
0.2677016258239746,
0.22224609553813934,
0.8045991659164429,
0.28654032945632935,
0.9666519165039062,
-0.30446359515190125,
-0.1736781895160675,
-0.3146897256374359,
-0.1633421778678894,
-0.6991724371910095,
0.24332140386104584,
0.2769988477230072,
-0.5685775876045227,
-0.218768909573555,
0.4537065923213959,
-0.628870964050293,
0.05774775519967079,
-0.2602703869342804,
0.8833359479904175,
-0.3008003234863281,
-0.9320552945137024,
0.9348627328872681,
-0.1055411621928215,
0.4548267722129822,
-0.23142074048519135,
0.018793746829032898,
-0.5554231405258179,
-0.02117764763534069,
-0.11163806915283203,
-0.7237817049026489,
0.22685672342777252,
-0.4519534111022949,
-0.5705417990684509,
-0.168657585978508,
0.6798925399780273,
-0.5415884852409363,
-0.05772392079234123,
0.04811939597129822,
0.5443766117095947,
-0.022507337853312492,
-0.2863035798072815,
-0.24516014754772186,
0.01677912101149559,
-0.16233575344085693,
-0.4149780869483948,
0.7735925912857056,
0.36961793899536133,
-0.012127007357776165,
0.4844866991043091,
0.6501270532608032,
-0.3685109615325928,
0.18109513819217682,
-0.1600620150566101,
0.9232765436172485,
-0.3222724497318268,
-0.5038192272186279,
-0.5129584074020386,
0.500429093837738,
-0.10725872218608856,
-0.5295923948287964,
0.5994654297828674,
0.4391045570373535,
1.2761268615722656,
-0.22701023519039154,
0.44717592000961304,
-0.020110564306378365,
0.5516124367713928,
-0.5565199255943298,
0.749967098236084,
-0.5320978164672852,
0.11601871252059937,
-0.05545224994421005,
-1.0610910654067993,
0.1708659827709198,
0.35055139660835266,
-0.33593297004699707,
0.1186889261007309,
0.48232924938201904,
0.5684657096862793,
-0.2058240920305252,
0.054784346371889114,
0.4078810513019562,
-0.21854351460933685,
0.22528739273548126,
0.5130597352981567,
0.8133662343025208,
-0.6863894462585449,
0.4357071816921234,
-0.3358103334903717,
0.13600461184978485,
-0.3493875563144684,
-0.23899023234844208,
-0.7865485548973083,
-0.884666383266449,
-0.19170846045017242,
-0.3986532986164093,
-0.045785289257764816,
0.7782423496246338,
0.8410675525665283,
-0.6074577569961548,
0.14658311009407043,
0.06402339786291122,
0.020190399140119553,
-0.2905135452747345,
-0.3297103941440582,
0.4497548043727875,
-0.6724528074264526,
-0.5661589503288269,
0.3341696560382843,
-0.04651675373315811,
0.1268473118543625,
-0.04376189038157463,
-0.17555561661720276,
-0.3950609564781189,
0.16242647171020508,
0.8422775864601135,
0.23658768832683563,
-0.6141324043273926,
-0.4757077097892761,
0.0814819186925888,
-0.34365418553352356,
0.14495782554149628,
0.6917139887809753,
-1.0636836290359497,
0.5673619508743286,
0.7934427261352539,
0.8367249369621277,
0.3577144145965576,
0.6034337878227234,
0.7447914481163025,
-0.9824401140213013,
0.07205864042043686,
0.066819928586483,
0.16108360886573792,
0.1854495257139206,
-0.5376966595649719,
0.5587059855461121,
0.13923108577728271,
-0.5805603265762329,
-0.9213724732398987,
-0.08737120032310486,
-0.42576220631599426,
-0.6038464903831482,
1.3196773529052734,
-0.0753633975982666,
-0.23661738634109497,
-0.2986837923526764,
-0.24446918070316315,
0.18166878819465637,
-0.2573276460170746,
0.591973066329956,
0.7098955512046814,
-0.19930918514728546,
-0.27904045581817627,
-0.4757428467273712,
0.789964497089386,
0.6098734140396118,
-0.5483381152153015,
-0.02474340982735157,
0.4538806974887848,
0.4029168486595154,
0.020396115258336067,
0.3356836140155792,
0.07407935708761215,
0.7126685380935669,
0.025917934253811836,
-0.05546804517507553,
-0.12386083602905273,
-0.27589544653892517,
-0.41104909777641296,
0.49817055463790894,
-0.07472515851259232,
-0.3441535532474518
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15485v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15485v1
|
MOGAM: A Multimodal Object-oriented Graph Attention Model for Depression Detection
| 2024-03-21T07:45:58 | 2024-03-21T07:45:58 |
Junyeop Cha, Seoyun Kim, Dongjae Kim, Eunil Park
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Early detection plays a crucial role in the treatment of depression.
Therefore, numerous studies have focused on social media platforms, where
individuals express their emotions, aiming to achieve early detection of
depression. However, the majority of existing approaches often rely on specific
features, leading to limited scalability across different types of social media
datasets, such as text, images, or videos. To overcome this limitation, we
introduce a Multimodal Object-Oriented Graph Attention Model (MOGAM), which can
be applied to diverse types of data, offering a more scalable and versatile
solution. Furthermore, to ensure that our model can capture authentic symptoms
of depression, we only include vlogs from users with a clinical diagnosis. To
leverage the diverse features of vlogs, we adopt a multimodal approach and
collect additional metadata such as the title, description, and duration of the
vlogs. To effectively aggregate these multimodal features, we employed a
cross-attention mechanism. MOGAM achieved an accuracy of 0.871 and an F1-score
of 0.888. Moreover, to validate the scalability of MOGAM, we evaluated its
performance with a benchmark dataset and achieved comparable results with prior
studies (0.61 F1-score). In conclusion, we believe that the proposed model,
MOGAM, is an effective solution for detecting depression in social media,
offering potential benefits in the early detection and treatment of this mental
health condition.
|
[
-0.430980384349823,
-1.1028450727462769,
0.7300696969032288,
0.3885383903980255,
-0.5528249740600586,
-0.23009315133094788,
-0.04450944811105728,
-0.18461939692497253,
0.4547719359397888,
0.263394832611084,
-0.7891167998313904,
-0.7907087802886963,
-0.8839703798294067,
-0.03215549886226654,
-0.241667702794075,
1.023445963859558,
0.12379327416419983,
-0.1234598383307457,
-0.44895148277282715,
-0.07802972942590714,
-0.24777211248874664,
-0.1936446577310562,
-0.8588847517967224,
-0.13227275013923645,
0.5531957745552063,
0.26236239075660706,
0.5413113832473755,
0.3070004880428314,
0.9195052981376648,
0.2337406873703003,
-0.10668742656707764,
0.3674272298812866,
-0.7763106226921082,
-0.21141035854816437,
-0.011391227133572102,
-0.37149372696876526,
-0.894236147403717,
-0.25162097811698914,
0.21850788593292236,
0.1662137508392334,
-0.09047939628362656,
0.5215440988540649,
-0.14523956179618835,
0.41759002208709717,
-0.7512089014053345,
0.4322308301925659,
-0.32627126574516296,
0.4346247911453247,
-0.15069691836833954,
-0.19379815459251404,
-0.34431442618370056,
-0.0954328179359436,
-0.1778714656829834,
-0.4411756992340088,
0.3213542401790619,
-0.34908902645111084,
0.5760836005210876,
0.4161466956138611,
-0.5606091022491455,
-0.16871047019958496,
-0.3326762318611145,
0.6944827437400818,
-0.6558110117912292,
0.016804467886686325,
0.46370771527290344,
0.33046644926071167,
0.12986744940280914,
-0.4443212151527405,
-0.23410427570343018,
0.04340428486466408,
-0.23848819732666016,
0.2405843734741211,
-0.2380734235048294,
0.01594739407300949,
0.42373090982437134,
0.5352447032928467,
-0.7155201435089111,
-0.3165638744831085,
-0.18875107169151306,
-0.3443606495857239,
0.269998162984848,
0.5008397698402405,
0.4702712893486023,
-0.4870612323284149,
-0.5202522277832031,
0.2749606966972351,
0.03413771837949753,
0.14155106246471405,
0.17682607471942902,
0.12483900040388107,
-0.2704475224018097,
0.754058837890625,
-0.22750556468963623,
0.8983880281448364,
0.07243965566158295,
-0.5823307633399963,
0.2521035075187683,
-0.2915312647819519,
-0.15718074142932892,
0.12403474748134613,
1.0412557125091553,
0.6706658005714417,
-0.0958026871085167,
0.3292664587497711,
0.0780951976776123,
0.7230971455574036,
0.28153854608535767,
-0.8529477119445801,
-0.5108270645141602,
0.44288110733032227,
-0.909770667552948,
-0.37988290190696716,
-0.43810296058654785,
-0.9613549709320068,
-0.5732429027557373,
-0.050360728055238724,
0.2480681985616684,
-0.7567672729492188,
-0.48006078600883484,
0.12438083440065384,
-0.09003599733114243,
-0.5329288244247437,
0.2500024139881134,
-0.7507652640342712,
0.0341312438249588,
0.6103524565696716,
1.2626533508300781,
-0.062194518744945526,
0.1746915727853775,
-0.962285578250885,
0.2629666030406952,
0.15142317116260529,
0.7886642813682556,
-0.5187127590179443,
-0.39861205220222473,
-0.14951293170452118,
0.01505543664097786,
0.01935763843357563,
-0.24465712904930115,
0.5316759347915649,
-0.018041767179965973,
-0.13244692981243134,
0.18930836021900177,
-0.2630614638328552,
-0.022160563617944717,
0.45848092436790466,
-0.8863519430160522,
0.7265061736106873,
0.28672951459884644,
-0.841568112373352,
0.08502157777547836,
-0.695925235748291,
-0.45731523633003235,
-0.025256790220737457,
0.14532685279846191,
-0.43008795380592346,
0.2616386413574219,
0.38416677713394165,
0.6544033288955688,
-0.3264952600002289,
0.07774688303470612,
-0.8672232031822205,
-0.10579175502061844,
0.24989479780197144,
-0.1598781943321228,
0.5414314866065979,
0.2561245560646057,
0.07819652557373047,
-0.033896345645189285,
-0.911504864692688,
0.08096526563167572,
0.007439553737640381,
-0.14162656664848328,
-0.47643396258354187,
-0.0950189158320427,
-0.07339943945407867,
0.27516913414001465,
0.29048070311546326,
-0.4799162447452545,
0.015249276533722878,
0.13716262578964233,
0.38816696405410767,
0.586390495300293,
-0.07639516890048981,
-0.011537984013557434,
0.04573316499590874,
0.8564261198043823,
0.4104984998703003,
0.5284653902053833,
-0.37014442682266235,
-0.5337820053100586,
-0.3291743993759155,
-0.9550103545188904,
-0.05547156557440758,
0.35575756430625916,
-0.3128211200237274,
0.1892211139202118,
-0.019987324252724648,
-0.4902181029319763,
-0.6014047265052795,
0.29251447319984436,
0.6020588278770447,
0.5207895040512085,
0.36608585715293884,
-0.6551662087440491,
-0.43011191487312317,
-0.8139510154724121,
-0.03015110082924366,
0.06311558187007904,
0.10414373129606247,
0.6112901568412781,
0.12321176379919052,
-0.618668258190155,
0.7114441990852356,
-1.0464900732040405,
-0.8584405183792114,
-0.1926320642232895,
0.5736880302429199,
0.27690526843070984,
0.07665622234344482,
0.4734174907207489,
-0.9352401494979858,
-0.5370614528656006,
0.25591275095939636,
-0.9302271604537964,
0.0166992899030447,
0.22531792521476746,
-0.0627259761095047,
-0.2951801121234894,
0.19270578026771545,
-0.7422560453414917,
0.5286200046539307,
0.7379235029220581,
-0.2193298637866974,
0.19132213294506073,
0.16678756475448608,
0.15815840661525726,
-1.09982430934906,
-0.030573325231671333,
0.23518520593643188,
-0.5099008083343506,
-0.3350944519042969,
-0.35491102933883667,
0.07383820414543152,
-0.58060222864151,
-0.41416236758232117,
0.2764040231704712,
-0.1730787307024002,
-0.008367761969566345,
-0.21941478550434113,
0.3368017077445984,
-0.0023762600030750036,
0.4663654863834381,
-0.30563104152679443,
0.39407259225845337,
0.7552356123924255,
-0.5615452527999878,
0.6061601638793945,
0.138711616396904,
-0.23202136158943176,
0.9263021945953369,
-0.5215690732002258,
0.00599944731220603,
-0.3393583595752716,
0.06353124976158142,
-1.5158169269561768,
-0.4617457687854767,
0.48752790689468384,
-0.6835925579071045,
0.03961053863167763,
-0.1187431663274765,
-0.2593621611595154,
-0.36089590191841125,
-0.15646182000637054,
0.6192398071289062,
0.0866074338555336,
-0.025430839508771896,
0.951738715171814,
0.37111154198646545,
-0.20759934186935425,
-0.39260730147361755,
-0.5184217095375061,
-0.2825554311275482,
-0.21177101135253906,
-0.6904322504997253,
0.40171897411346436,
0.07797568291425705,
0.054020386189222336,
0.48106467723846436,
0.020149273797869682,
-0.18944306671619415,
-0.024934368208050728,
0.31549105048179626,
0.14311453700065613,
-0.2163843959569931,
0.39727625250816345,
-0.2269553393125534,
-0.5113924741744995,
-0.03532972186803818,
0.14071550965309143,
0.7897850871086121,
-0.18836815655231476,
-0.3688056766986847,
-0.7503278255462646,
0.4315720200538635,
0.7903996109962463,
-0.3767032325267792,
0.5503798127174377,
0.9489752054214478,
-0.378850519657135,
-0.01951601915061474,
-0.1671086996793747,
-0.04096149653196335,
-0.43191513419151306,
0.37316375970840454,
-0.2613905966281891,
-0.6183205842971802,
0.5552629232406616,
-0.298667311668396,
-0.36169731616973877,
0.09202564507722855,
0.5717489123344421,
-0.01634860411286354,
1.6180869340896606,
0.7122719287872314,
-0.09398707747459412,
0.6967127919197083,
-0.16996176540851593,
0.461142361164093,
-1.112634301185608,
0.037081278860569,
-0.006047059316188097,
-0.5011104345321655,
-0.15845851600170135,
-0.48332977294921875,
0.47410348057746887,
-0.06477972120046616,
0.16044652462005615,
0.16052944958209991,
-0.45499497652053833,
0.22316786646842957,
0.19800816476345062,
0.6603534817695618,
0.2797294855117798,
-0.09747727960348129,
0.3127213716506958,
-0.2665485143661499,
-0.3819596469402313,
-0.28364837169647217,
1.0132683515548706,
0.0024722409434616566,
0.9432603716850281,
0.2120516300201416,
0.5383462905883789,
0.6504393219947815,
0.47723081707954407,
-0.8422282338142395,
0.5717111229896545,
-0.38800278306007385,
-0.556833803653717,
-0.30551815032958984,
-0.5430486798286438,
-0.6959776282310486,
0.2456585317850113,
0.10823825746774673,
-0.789478600025177,
0.013157031498849392,
0.3831653296947479,
-0.5629130601882935,
0.008832254447042942,
-0.9117651581764221,
1.355086326599121,
-0.48016655445098877,
-0.215622678399086,
-0.3484414517879486,
-0.44975876808166504,
0.7330722212791443,
-0.030118264257907867,
0.3293249309062958,
-0.5139025449752808,
0.10510808974504471,
0.2628566324710846,
-0.20265857875347137,
1.0400913953781128,
-0.04850022494792938,
0.06920839101076126,
0.2687559723854065,
-0.007703382056206465,
0.4824656844139099,
0.5152758359909058,
0.2886575758457184,
-0.180411696434021,
-0.2750796377658844,
-0.4422064423561096,
-0.78542560338974,
0.6447444558143616,
-0.6449398398399353,
-0.47886160016059875,
-0.22171077132225037,
-0.639543354511261,
-0.13930295407772064,
0.33514899015426636,
0.016420256346464157,
0.4646424651145935,
-0.14603614807128906,
0.36805084347724915,
0.8916870355606079,
0.034650906920433044,
0.03654643893241882,
0.2306043654680252,
-0.5907263159751892,
-0.5744211673736572,
1.0036455392837524,
-0.15266761183738708,
0.35616791248321533,
0.3275194764137268,
0.22203122079372406,
0.028713678941130638,
-0.0226664487272501,
0.08940722048282623,
0.4052513837814331,
-0.7439476251602173,
-0.25747740268707275,
-1.0137392282485962,
0.2244165688753128,
-0.5392190217971802,
0.14162495732307434,
-0.5387617945671082,
-0.0851266011595726,
-0.5841177701950073,
-0.18073450028896332,
0.4322531223297119,
-0.022229565307497978,
-0.06519469618797302,
0.3468388319015503,
-0.8989651799201965,
0.9703089594841003,
0.4380965530872345,
0.2896046042442322,
0.018632952123880386,
-0.023788226768374443,
-0.1613684445619583,
0.14396582543849945,
-0.4012403190135956,
-0.7684110403060913,
0.4745974540710449,
0.22456638514995575,
0.3145979642868042,
0.8808376789093018,
0.04325472563505173,
0.9986555576324463,
0.029867244884371758,
0.4585171341896057,
0.7112894654273987,
-0.9676744341850281,
0.8251519799232483,
-0.3751325309276581,
0.28027480840682983,
0.2878510057926178,
0.6935980319976807,
-0.7070005536079407,
-0.20873123407363892,
-0.31789201498031616,
-0.8210766315460205,
0.9489749073982239,
0.04118812829256058,
-0.014925269410014153,
-0.1703076809644699,
-0.12598448991775513,
0.05912831053137779,
0.27288469672203064,
-0.8791224956512451,
-0.08907227218151093,
-0.4141092598438263,
-0.48598626255989075,
-0.2722001075744629,
-0.325366348028183,
-0.3729844391345978,
0.015878060832619667,
0.3513879179954529,
-0.3168507516384125,
0.6882815361022949,
0.15966330468654633,
-0.22849757969379425,
-0.2023412436246872,
-0.19390898942947388,
0.35318896174430847,
0.4830999970436096,
-0.4850720167160034,
0.2655685544013977,
-0.34466275572776794,
-0.27098554372787476,
0.11822017282247543,
0.03687195107340813,
0.0311796423047781,
0.2795536518096924,
0.31241753697395325,
1.020461916923523,
0.19346892833709717,
-0.8774155974388123,
0.5536536574363708,
-0.12522175908088684,
0.06855782121419907,
-0.2460193634033203,
0.15490661561489105,
0.3788774907588959,
0.45563840866088867,
-0.037066858261823654,
0.047760799527168274,
0.31471312046051025,
-0.81326824426651,
-0.0033070100471377373,
0.35241618752479553,
-0.7625262141227722,
-0.3536222279071808,
0.5578738451004028,
0.1269017606973648,
-0.6539275050163269,
0.5015084147453308,
-0.20367980003356934,
-0.3225754499435425,
0.7993669509887695,
0.43022865056991577,
0.7740508317947388,
-0.2366061508655548,
0.7655553817749023,
0.1937737911939621,
0.09531808644533157,
0.04187827184796333,
0.4447725713253021,
-0.06184602901339531,
-0.5130864381790161,
-0.15090754628181458,
-0.5353813171386719,
-0.17464524507522583,
0.12975777685642242,
-0.8716979622840881,
0.3769747018814087,
-0.5474284291267395,
-0.7842714190483093,
0.1656949520111084,
-0.6151114702224731,
-0.4757051169872284,
0.39452433586120605,
0.21599261462688446,
0.25795668363571167,
-0.8366835117340088,
0.40002915263175964,
0.9038856625556946,
-0.32557645440101624,
-0.13673239946365356,
-0.08349844068288803,
0.24060943722724915,
-0.6519807577133179,
0.4853227436542511,
0.628140389919281,
-0.17299355566501617,
0.0918753519654274,
-0.2765271067619324,
-1.0202810764312744,
1.0875791311264038,
0.23614323139190674,
-0.2455720603466034,
0.28921735286712646,
0.0006017073756083846,
0.5909615755081177,
-0.5848166942596436,
0.24859780073165894,
0.023215798661112785,
0.2575501799583435,
-0.01291909720748663,
-0.42182257771492004,
-0.13264726102352142,
-0.3682307004928589,
0.12682700157165527,
0.502284586429596,
-0.9994450807571411,
1.275382399559021,
-0.17329543828964233,
-0.3791535794734955,
-0.38328641653060913,
0.3990907073020935,
0.1499921828508377,
0.528727114200592,
0.5751227140426636,
0.8677230477333069,
0.830433189868927,
0.027820538729429245,
1.1419428586959839,
-0.31860285997390747,
0.6773544549942017,
0.906406819820404,
-0.4513245224952698,
0.49890226125717163,
0.3749604821205139,
-0.14827197790145874,
0.4021206498146057,
0.5323530435562134,
0.08339517563581467,
0.8510413765907288,
-0.2446971833705902,
-0.2996039390563965,
-0.7076819539070129,
-0.4658470153808594,
-0.3971712589263916,
0.02206035517156124,
0.4965161681175232,
-0.6313178539276123,
-0.2865159511566162,
0.4043632745742798,
-0.1380203515291214,
-0.2710705101490021,
-0.30345773696899414,
0.5397206544876099,
0.07730621844530106,
-0.3774489760398865,
0.3996603488922119,
-0.1794731318950653,
0.3047655522823334,
-0.6891023516654968,
0.09109112620353699,
-0.21962760388851166,
0.6678040623664856,
-0.1809058040380478,
-0.4681348502635956,
0.18525923788547516,
0.14101678133010864,
-0.4903840720653534,
-0.0018641749629750848,
0.8256747126579285,
-0.21606571972370148,
-0.8124908208847046,
0.5005782246589661,
0.20531776547431946,
0.02577807381749153,
-0.19677583873271942,
-0.5744521021842957,
0.15401680767536163,
0.011026784777641296,
-0.2768062651157379,
0.420806348323822,
0.8574866056442261,
0.07464759796857834,
0.9483204483985901,
0.6125328540802002,
-0.2797233462333679,
0.05754469707608223,
-0.06966537237167358,
0.8427556157112122,
-0.5251255631446838,
-0.45146644115448,
-0.9585241675376892,
0.6676443219184875,
-0.31509897112846375,
-0.5015274882316589,
0.6284346580505371,
0.3481937050819397,
0.6113500595092773,
-0.4054335355758667,
0.8645403981208801,
-0.2997448742389679,
0.4617367684841156,
-0.31744736433029175,
0.15415912866592407,
-0.9731013178825378,
-0.3146553337574005,
-0.45645201206207275,
-0.5857885479927063,
-0.23447555303573608,
0.5886030197143555,
-0.26995018124580383,
-0.2191288322210312,
0.9760743379592896,
0.7045959830284119,
-0.3506719768047333,
-0.18275298178195953,
0.19983424246311188,
0.2682250142097473,
0.32463157176971436,
0.8750753998756409,
0.7733145356178284,
-0.1995536834001541,
0.811039388179779,
-0.33242109417915344,
-0.25101667642593384,
-0.7350053787231445,
-0.7170512676239014,
-1.1191480159759521,
-0.18775047361850739,
-0.39774835109710693,
-0.035640303045511246,
-0.10325447469949722,
0.4904913902282715,
0.3926013112068176,
-0.4671691060066223,
0.08802056312561035,
0.17099758982658386,
0.18189097940921783,
-0.6872594356536865,
-0.24419890344142914,
0.1913491189479828,
-0.16501575708389282,
-0.536514163017273,
-0.12833289802074432,
0.5888546705245972,
-0.2938697040081024,
-0.21870635449886322,
0.11181680858135223,
-0.33208799362182617,
-0.24000504612922668,
0.8235182166099548,
-0.17122961580753326,
-0.6104232668876648,
0.07032237201929092,
-0.012787953019142151,
-0.29258719086647034,
0.12924575805664062,
0.8327998518943787,
-0.4061462879180908,
0.6391767859458923,
0.5962862372398376,
0.4042274057865143,
0.5989090204238892,
0.40515047311782837,
0.21225814521312714,
-0.3860744833946228,
0.3440275192260742,
0.2910436987876892,
0.374092698097229,
0.30987221002578735,
-0.6232545971870422,
0.5109530091285706,
0.46161964535713196,
-0.22659794986248016,
-0.9094480872154236,
0.341158926486969,
-1.1248711347579956,
-0.175912544131279,
0.9066279530525208,
-0.4903518855571747,
-0.5753540992736816,
-0.08177491277456284,
-0.5770279169082642,
0.1521584689617157,
-0.5566655397415161,
1.1984992027282715,
0.9499019980430603,
-0.3659975230693817,
-0.27945730090141296,
-0.4050288498401642,
0.012279840186238289,
0.32397255301475525,
-0.7559571862220764,
0.07002818584442139,
0.6184619069099426,
-0.10393785685300827,
0.4532022774219513,
0.7570180892944336,
-0.025880569592118263,
0.5145230293273926,
0.02027338370680809,
0.03114303946495056,
-0.11447291821241379,
-0.22294765710830688,
0.1270185112953186,
0.5213472247123718,
-0.5851386785507202,
-0.34487059712409973
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15484v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15484v1
|
RakutenAI-7B: Extending Large Language Models for Japanese
| 2024-03-21T06:56:07 | 2024-03-21T06:56:07 |
Rakuten Group, Aaron Levine, Connie Huang, Chenguang Wang, Eduardo Batista, Ewa Szymanska, Hongyi Ding, Hou Wei Chou, Jean-François Pessiot, Johanes Effendi, Justin Chiu, Kai Torben Ohlhus, Karan Chopra, Keiji Shinzato, Koji Murakami, Lee Xiong, Lei Chen, Maki Kubota, Maksim Tkachenko, Miroku Lee, Naoki Takahashi, Prathyusha Jwalapuram, Ryutaro Tatsushima, Saurabh Jain, Sunil Kumar Yadav, Ting Cai, Wei-Te Chen, Yandi Xia, Yuki Nakayama, Yutaka Higashiyama
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We introduce RakutenAI-7B, a suite of Japanese-oriented large language models
that achieve the best performance on the Japanese LM Harness benchmarks among
the open 7B models. Along with the foundation model, we release instruction-
and chat-tuned models, RakutenAI-7B-instruct and RakutenAI-7B-chat
respectively, under the Apache 2.0 license.
|
[
-0.5478247404098511,
-0.8161723017692566,
0.1460675746202469,
0.5201736688613892,
-0.442155659198761,
-0.15084780752658844,
-0.5580348372459412,
-0.8942316174507141,
0.1609368920326233,
1.0005102157592773,
-0.6149439215660095,
-0.27937018871307373,
-0.5198047757148743,
0.04141298308968544,
-0.09361568838357925,
0.5874686241149902,
0.10105564445257187,
-0.05452705919742584,
0.26462703943252563,
-0.09122363477945328,
-0.9135072231292725,
-0.04733990132808685,
-0.7495148777961731,
-0.7596232295036316,
0.7154555916786194,
0.6303760409355164,
1.078664779663086,
0.5873680710792542,
0.7339962124824524,
0.23310644924640656,
-0.04103698581457138,
-0.3025782108306885,
-0.4691762328147888,
0.44090232253074646,
-0.2007288634777069,
-0.9355727434158325,
-0.4559779763221741,
-0.5479642152786255,
0.5641360282897949,
0.5289984941482544,
-0.19944791495800018,
0.0890989899635315,
-0.5318253636360168,
0.697367787361145,
-0.7957546710968018,
0.6291400790214539,
-0.2727154791355133,
-0.2643382251262665,
-0.5432731509208679,
0.02005542442202568,
-0.6649263501167297,
-0.2739807665348053,
-0.1651155948638916,
-0.7558553218841553,
-0.008064892143011093,
-0.017344564199447632,
0.7710748314857483,
0.01649595983326435,
-0.21601828932762146,
-0.31314077973365784,
-0.5733511447906494,
0.6391628384590149,
-0.8715479969978333,
0.40317317843437195,
0.5331553220748901,
0.8677425980567932,
-0.482769638299942,
-0.4857500195503235,
-0.3840676248073578,
-0.270152747631073,
-0.01175761129707098,
0.17391939461231232,
0.12491157650947571,
0.1770392209291458,
0.46401989459991455,
0.6414918303489685,
-0.7137791514396667,
0.5859274864196777,
-0.88414466381073,
0.3565365970134735,
0.7875357270240784,
0.17875929176807404,
0.7029891610145569,
-0.18078136444091797,
0.1097739189863205,
-0.43211111426353455,
-0.9703296422958374,
-0.32469436526298523,
0.5297338962554932,
0.4121237099170685,
-0.2577565014362335,
0.5646135210990906,
-0.5777005553245544,
0.8175413608551025,
-0.31215277314186096,
-0.2485174834728241,
0.12478189170360565,
0.33948543667793274,
-0.2779879570007324,
0.40483415126800537,
0.7499768137931824,
0.24950428307056427,
0.11504019051790237,
-0.010669341310858727,
-0.034592822194099426,
0.44667062163352966,
0.03450603783130646,
-0.8402314782142639,
-0.3337692618370056,
0.04258411005139351,
-0.5930461287498474,
-0.1864590346813202,
-0.02715205028653145,
-0.6417794227600098,
-0.3250706195831299,
-0.051192451268434525,
0.08033227920532227,
-0.4859078824520111,
-0.977790355682373,
0.39730191230773926,
-0.17909906804561615,
0.5878787040710449,
0.2557675540447235,
-0.907438337802887,
0.13598307967185974,
0.9039257168769836,
0.6807212233543396,
-0.018140500411391258,
-0.28820309042930603,
0.19816671311855316,
0.3610268831253052,
-0.5638113021850586,
0.6516505479812622,
-0.94218909740448,
-0.6867761015892029,
0.037856556475162506,
0.3051084876060486,
0.1940915584564209,
-0.37354570627212524,
0.6791558265686035,
-0.5909496545791626,
0.1707122027873993,
-0.1213010773062706,
-0.48321279883384705,
-0.4625561237335205,
-0.045366015285253525,
-0.9816401600837708,
1.1519664525985718,
0.16268053650856018,
-0.6153348088264465,
-0.07467267662286758,
-0.9720125198364258,
-0.4894014894962311,
0.5603932738304138,
0.04250152409076691,
-0.29094359278678894,
0.4148644208908081,
-0.0013515037717297673,
0.472250372171402,
-0.5494612455368042,
0.5009266138076782,
-0.6506697535514832,
-0.4348669648170471,
0.1397291123867035,
-0.28575000166893005,
0.7295325994491577,
0.5606053471565247,
-0.18707025051116943,
0.08405990153551102,
-0.9838823080062866,
-0.20872294902801514,
0.192470982670784,
-0.09590349346399307,
-0.699873149394989,
-0.3356814384460449,
0.26993826031684875,
0.006096149329096079,
0.10353247076272964,
-0.4788352847099304,
0.3312089145183563,
-0.6427512168884277,
0.20660415291786194,
0.5116956830024719,
-0.21757172048091888,
0.38716384768486023,
-0.3233472406864166,
0.85191810131073,
-0.1413438767194748,
0.2137327641248703,
-0.6122466921806335,
-0.8124205470085144,
-0.9226179718971252,
-0.20943695306777954,
0.018890980631113052,
0.21593311429023743,
-0.7603605389595032,
0.43924278020858765,
-0.6272612810134888,
-0.9997854828834534,
-0.5841169357299805,
-0.1843857318162918,
0.5024628639221191,
-0.05638604238629341,
-0.008572331629693508,
-0.186526820063591,
-0.5229086875915527,
-1.1331855058670044,
-0.054493248462677,
-0.0006302630063146353,
0.1993395984172821,
-0.10824255645275116,
0.3415869176387787,
-0.08020679652690887,
0.4626022279262543,
-0.4024414122104645,
0.02231953665614128,
-0.7621949315071106,
-0.118683822453022,
0.5256590247154236,
0.47496578097343445,
0.6146848797798157,
-0.6643133759498596,
-0.8079541325569153,
0.481463760137558,
-0.8041354417800903,
-0.161908358335495,
0.398843377828598,
-0.2736802101135254,
0.1757340133190155,
0.33584627509117126,
-0.7069560289382935,
0.326458603143692,
0.8014690279960632,
-0.20160514116287231,
0.198854461312294,
-0.02267204038798809,
0.23151786625385284,
-1.7481998205184937,
0.19083644449710846,
-0.18719398975372314,
-0.3212719261646271,
-0.6075991988182068,
0.8494323492050171,
0.13869337737560272,
-0.3303009867668152,
-0.2731727361679077,
0.6825191974639893,
-0.8088539242744446,
-0.3669498562812805,
-0.7693278789520264,
0.16511675715446472,
-0.21795140206813812,
0.2278553992509842,
0.14597581326961517,
0.6257383227348328,
0.74888014793396,
-0.49187058210372925,
0.6962204575538635,
0.14540834724903107,
-0.7704342603683472,
0.30594345927238464,
-0.7645435929298401,
-0.03348584845662117,
-0.18418461084365845,
0.3929591476917267,
-0.7048292756080627,
-0.6736679077148438,
0.29173868894577026,
-0.37542054057121277,
0.5065962672233582,
-0.4864710867404938,
-0.38629618287086487,
-0.48073798418045044,
-0.009890612214803696,
0.26611411571502686,
0.6772328019142151,
-0.616014838218689,
0.7555639147758484,
0.25695210695266724,
-0.10838810354471207,
-0.6191695928573608,
-0.6793016791343689,
-0.03961924836039543,
-0.2594706118106842,
-0.5875353217124939,
-0.1486712396144867,
0.06117728352546692,
-0.02822260558605194,
-0.08924378454685211,
0.24936728179454803,
-0.009484048001468182,
0.20047247409820557,
0.735273003578186,
0.279586523771286,
-0.7317469120025635,
-0.33108076453208923,
0.33000314235687256,
-0.09293258935213089,
-0.06187152490019798,
0.3755674660205841,
0.8854643106460571,
0.1609422117471695,
-0.1686411052942276,
-0.4551743268966675,
0.3085702955722809,
0.5382605195045471,
-0.1674126237630844,
0.8855330348014832,
0.3877642750740051,
-0.34309297800064087,
-0.16441507637500763,
-0.6514474749565125,
0.04290594160556793,
-0.5100517868995667,
0.7518974542617798,
-0.8648620247840881,
-1.1137773990631104,
0.7055829167366028,
-0.010860244743525982,
0.19529491662979126,
0.5774271488189697,
0.6154360771179199,
0.46694526076316833,
0.9469055533409119,
0.697969377040863,
-0.2735486328601837,
0.5149289965629578,
0.04218267276883125,
0.07731503248214722,
-0.8268873691558838,
-0.1285340040922165,
-0.7980865240097046,
-0.07188437134027481,
-0.6787399053573608,
-0.3344290554523468,
-0.08318515866994858,
0.2129623144865036,
-0.18217070400714874,
0.6437510251998901,
-0.3052298426628113,
0.8183553218841553,
0.32703617215156555,
-0.10118293017148972,
0.33394166827201843,
-0.146337628364563,
0.42844316363334656,
0.3366692066192627,
-0.8431774377822876,
-0.21918846666812897,
0.9954853653907776,
0.6217122673988342,
1.1860556602478027,
0.5212680101394653,
0.38987627625465393,
-0.12031464278697968,
0.7289896011352539,
-0.7019987106323242,
0.43518736958503723,
-0.1112862229347229,
-1.0934438705444336,
-0.1439536064863205,
-0.3963750898838043,
-0.9970323443412781,
0.2727378308773041,
-0.002692998154088855,
-0.7909085154533386,
-0.12816515564918518,
0.01697843335568905,
0.22466036677360535,
0.24045051634311676,
-0.8396890759468079,
0.8347029089927673,
0.09221458435058594,
0.2555958032608032,
-0.6798213720321655,
-0.4865931570529938,
1.0438530445098877,
0.21833853423595428,
0.2938450276851654,
-0.49364620447158813,
0.35455822944641113,
0.673659086227417,
-0.029500329867005348,
0.8578857183456421,
-0.10214551538228989,
-0.17992083728313446,
0.010320243425667286,
0.1187891960144043,
0.44175633788108826,
0.04356545954942703,
0.16184687614440918,
0.10675832629203796,
0.14310431480407715,
-0.35665538907051086,
-0.7561370134353638,
1.1260863542556763,
-1.139096975326538,
-0.5671808123588562,
-0.26563915610313416,
-0.3370540738105774,
-0.06306331604719162,
0.48952794075012207,
0.10528440028429031,
0.6064531207084656,
-0.10236983001232147,
0.7747869491577148,
0.647451639175415,
-0.47189462184906006,
0.4662173390388489,
0.723640501499176,
-0.8555784225463867,
-0.41854745149612427,
0.6176454424858093,
-0.19461406767368317,
0.44445815682411194,
0.5267618894577026,
0.3275468349456787,
-0.26264718174934387,
-0.26068252325057983,
-0.5918281674385071,
0.412820041179657,
-0.8698869347572327,
-0.3273310661315918,
-0.5317890048027039,
-0.2373851090669632,
-0.5192386507987976,
-0.008920912630856037,
-0.732126772403717,
-0.6104788780212402,
0.318282812833786,
-0.07956844568252563,
0.49900808930397034,
1.068164587020874,
0.41970452666282654,
0.9754714369773865,
-0.9198217391967773,
0.28590095043182373,
-0.32559072971343994,
0.7433563470840454,
0.18841007351875305,
-0.5534062385559082,
-0.46448424458503723,
-0.05074065923690796,
-0.1772191971540451,
-0.6930972933769226,
0.2689947485923767,
0.0966162458062172,
0.6932047009468079,
0.3630715310573578,
-0.05154760554432869,
0.5418111681938171,
-0.2527051568031311,
0.7322845458984375,
0.5494537949562073,
-0.5757349133491516,
0.7161197066307068,
-0.5733572244644165,
0.59343022108078,
0.19671118259429932,
0.5579548478126526,
-0.6608642339706421,
-0.6098036766052246,
-0.5361518263816833,
-0.5755044221878052,
0.885137140750885,
0.0015052958624437451,
0.15859298408031464,
0.0403900146484375,
0.5360269546508789,
0.21744048595428467,
-0.20882555842399597,
-0.6471119523048401,
-0.32072362303733826,
-0.30129510164260864,
-0.44620177149772644,
-0.23039181530475616,
-0.41395100951194763,
0.30678460001945496,
0.2533303499221802,
0.90948086977005,
-0.14088907837867737,
0.04119904339313507,
-0.15125411748886108,
-0.30356043577194214,
-0.22802996635437012,
0.2889896035194397,
0.6214174628257751,
0.8986179232597351,
-0.08009480684995651,
-0.19945967197418213,
-0.18630261719226837,
-0.5640340447425842,
-0.0989418774843216,
-0.09511855244636536,
-0.28006356954574585,
0.0026353984139859676,
0.48243820667266846,
1.4439942836761475,
0.42167720198631287,
-0.536702036857605,
0.11199073493480682,
-0.14430831372737885,
0.15664352476596832,
-0.23891323804855347,
0.43873292207717896,
0.2671254873275757,
0.20538437366485596,
0.009867708198726177,
-0.7464500665664673,
0.06868428736925125,
-0.7230814695358276,
-0.2830212116241455,
0.18085584044456482,
-0.24175460636615753,
-0.4354840815067291,
0.5508556962013245,
0.13041049242019653,
-0.23190632462501526,
0.4523929953575134,
0.5218982696533203,
-0.3405689597129822,
0.3121480941772461,
0.9634413123130798,
0.8944048285484314,
-0.6735005974769592,
-0.08483900129795074,
0.7145219445228577,
0.3094257414340973,
-0.5468697547912598,
0.2789306938648224,
0.12174785137176514,
-0.7731079459190369,
-0.5252876281738281,
-0.7696459889411926,
-0.5101169347763062,
0.19749581813812256,
-1.0006287097930908,
0.4983710050582886,
-0.4418404996395111,
-0.1774870604276657,
0.03746025636792183,
-0.06014981493353844,
-0.282048761844635,
0.2852858603000641,
0.14027883112430573,
1.1060937643051147,
-0.8405231237411499,
1.1985937356948853,
0.8195924758911133,
-0.503531813621521,
-0.8375004529953003,
-0.6871535181999207,
-0.5568110942840576,
-0.8156852722167969,
0.2907668352127075,
0.286547988653183,
0.06963332742452621,
-0.21037286520004272,
-0.4491099417209625,
-0.9358183145523071,
0.9972679018974304,
0.2393757849931717,
-0.8487932682037354,
-0.05216243863105774,
0.10605733841657639,
0.3253115713596344,
-0.21472322940826416,
0.49977827072143555,
0.509391188621521,
0.4098683297634125,
0.0269680954515934,
-1.0367213487625122,
-0.055814266204833984,
-0.5061019062995911,
0.4889969825744629,
0.47320258617401123,
-0.9543941020965576,
0.344191312789917,
0.48522141575813293,
-0.04044672101736069,
0.3828451931476593,
1.0302355289459229,
0.30766817927360535,
-0.1594921201467514,
0.3123030960559845,
0.6314674615859985,
0.21508970856666565,
-0.2694043517112732,
1.1876922845840454,
-0.4771672189235687,
0.2811315953731537,
1.322538137435913,
-0.09072211384773254,
0.9747196435928345,
0.016147024929523468,
-0.06946471333503723,
0.3950522840023041,
0.45665764808654785,
0.11919908970594406,
0.14945179224014282,
-0.07694928348064423,
-0.13099795579910278,
-0.25985485315322876,
0.019968925043940544,
-0.7171862125396729,
0.39746329188346863,
0.5448095798492432,
-0.21484887599945068,
-0.03128357604146004,
-0.03397396206855774,
0.1996976137161255,
-0.025877300649881363,
-0.3972439169883728,
0.70711350440979,
0.3521318733692169,
-0.9744673371315002,
0.5000289678573608,
0.4054931700229645,
0.7037489414215088,
-0.8722947239875793,
0.1447850465774536,
-0.4459071457386017,
0.37282875180244446,
0.010920698754489422,
-0.8769910335540771,
0.35696306824684143,
-0.2390873283147812,
-0.15382646024227142,
0.26170840859413147,
0.9448944330215454,
-0.4043770134449005,
-0.5126633644104004,
0.32174164056777954,
-0.22579547762870789,
0.07449666410684586,
0.1563711166381836,
-0.51938396692276,
0.7045966386795044,
-0.3219009339809418,
-0.3368692100048065,
0.4494251608848572,
0.3578934073448181,
-0.3228127360343933,
0.8688384890556335,
0.5649598836898804,
0.014954120852053165,
0.3878439664840698,
0.4954182803630829,
0.7869906425476074,
-0.6873894333839417,
-0.7514491081237793,
-0.5701624751091003,
0.15087264776229858,
-0.12563733756542206,
-0.22646641731262207,
0.8668779730796814,
0.8288994431495667,
0.8960158228874207,
-0.37542977929115295,
0.8668134808540344,
-0.17531001567840576,
0.5565130710601807,
-0.5491843819618225,
0.7560160756111145,
-0.41003671288490295,
-0.14591331779956818,
-0.2414349913597107,
-1.2639044523239136,
-0.3143292963504791,
0.606253981590271,
-0.0584508515894413,
-0.011371467262506485,
0.4142456352710724,
0.9122560620307922,
-0.37072962522506714,
0.4420190453529358,
0.614532470703125,
0.3648657202720642,
0.6005166172981262,
0.7001800537109375,
1.0666576623916626,
-0.6189061403274536,
0.08951656520366669,
-0.35251671075820923,
-0.3413643538951874,
-0.11228672415018082,
-0.620359480381012,
-1.1323847770690918,
-0.3245428800582886,
-0.18977324664592743,
-0.26133379340171814,
0.10196558386087418,
0.9153485298156738,
0.5037066340446472,
-0.7582674026489258,
-0.5543424487113953,
0.2054903358221054,
-0.07053534686565399,
0.18851275742053986,
-0.28398817777633667,
0.08120977878570557,
-0.258407860994339,
-0.7943915724754333,
0.4818476140499115,
0.3584402799606323,
-0.2572629153728485,
-0.459591805934906,
-0.32448646426200867,
0.06153731420636177,
-0.03695833310484886,
0.5717848539352417,
0.4120922088623047,
-0.8256389498710632,
-0.022656697779893875,
-0.28404244780540466,
0.044011395424604416,
-0.11149543523788452,
0.8032740354537964,
-0.09672857820987701,
0.3448832333087921,
0.6722670197486877,
0.6444817185401917,
0.647881031036377,
-0.29307132959365845,
0.9193546175956726,
-0.2804286777973175,
0.581866979598999,
-0.3105895519256592,
0.45279839634895325,
0.4780847430229187,
-0.0654980018734932,
0.3966705799102783,
0.12920385599136353,
-0.2985837161540985,
-0.8552281856536865,
0.26294463872909546,
-1.1736904382705688,
-0.2270931750535965,
1.3036153316497803,
-0.2718087434768677,
-0.6903535723686218,
0.2007889449596405,
-0.13268382847309113,
0.2359064817428589,
-0.037946682423353195,
0.41549283266067505,
0.7357028722763062,
0.5198895931243896,
-0.7378959655761719,
-0.6781622767448425,
0.31784525513648987,
-0.06262900680303574,
-0.7847358584403992,
0.07307852059602737,
0.41315826773643494,
0.3742816150188446,
-0.05476706475019455,
0.6607792377471924,
-0.3127284646034241,
0.5158037543296814,
-0.07982312887907028,
0.11171292513608932,
-0.04651361331343651,
-0.44787895679473877,
-0.11846689879894257,
0.05187353864312172,
0.5353823900222778,
0.1621720790863037
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14171v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14171v3
|
MMIDR: Teaching Large Language Model to Interpret Multimodal Misinformation via Knowledge Distillation
| 2024-03-21T06:47:28 | 2024-04-08T08:30:06 |
Longzheng Wang, Xiaohan Xu, Lei Zhang, Jiarui Lu, Yongxiu Xu, Hongbo Xu, Minghao Tang, Chuang Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Automatic detection of multimodal misinformation has gained a widespread
attention recently. However, the potential of powerful Large Language Models
(LLMs) for multimodal misinformation detection remains underexplored. Besides,
how to teach LLMs to interpret multimodal misinformation in cost-effective and
accessible way is still an open question. To address that, we propose MMIDR, a
framework designed to teach LLMs in providing fluent and high-quality textual
explanations for their decision-making process of multimodal misinformation. To
convert multimodal misinformation into an appropriate instruction-following
format, we present a data augmentation perspective and pipeline. This pipeline
consists of a visual information processing module and an evidence retrieval
module. Subsequently, we prompt the proprietary LLMs with processed contents to
extract rationales for interpreting the authenticity of multimodal
misinformation. Furthermore, we design an efficient knowledge distillation
approach to distill the capability of proprietary LLMs in explaining multimodal
misinformation into open-source LLMs. To explore several research questions
regarding the performance of LLMs in multimodal misinformation detection tasks,
we construct an instruction-following multimodal misinformation dataset and
conduct comprehensive experiments. The experimental findings reveal that our
MMIDR exhibits sufficient detection performance and possesses the capacity to
provide compelling rationales to support its assessments.
|
[
-0.35376042127609253,
-0.7076359987258911,
0.5550221800804138,
0.08248491585254669,
-0.127688929438591,
0.12495969980955124,
-0.268023282289505,
-0.036532316356897354,
-0.23659124970436096,
0.17558906972408295,
-0.608405590057373,
-0.3216151297092438,
-0.8020307421684265,
0.09292695671319962,
-0.1677340269088745,
0.9054919481277466,
0.00901675596833229,
0.26941001415252686,
-0.411416232585907,
0.07332780212163925,
-0.5436170101165771,
-0.3370114266872406,
-0.4065367877483368,
-0.2743516266345978,
0.6903612613677979,
0.8078536987304688,
0.3920274078845978,
0.6723551750183105,
0.5522216558456421,
0.3601955473423004,
0.1163586750626564,
0.43919849395751953,
-0.5514698624610901,
0.08994155377149582,
-0.1300882250070572,
-0.5408003330230713,
-0.19102221727371216,
0.06268701702356339,
0.53118497133255,
0.4770894944667816,
-0.22839093208312988,
0.12378507107496262,
-0.017979880794882774,
0.5422455668449402,
-0.6973407864570618,
0.306436151266098,
-0.6471381783485413,
-0.1695469319820404,
-0.160928413271904,
-0.3386521339416504,
-0.7669224739074707,
-0.1034027710556984,
0.023584404960274696,
-0.38957276940345764,
0.11022481322288513,
0.08790542185306549,
0.3222701847553253,
0.33600082993507385,
-0.5955132842063904,
-0.6742439866065979,
-0.90308678150177,
0.8603456020355225,
-0.5634275674819946,
0.42864224314689636,
0.3253888487815857,
0.6555726528167725,
-0.01570935919880867,
-0.7130216360092163,
-1.130118489265442,
-0.038222067058086395,
0.06465328484773636,
0.1632440686225891,
-0.19724813103675842,
-0.06214427202939987,
0.2920752763748169,
0.2931375205516815,
-0.6539822816848755,
0.15992774069309235,
-0.4950627088546753,
-0.17032644152641296,
0.2904879152774811,
0.061350516974925995,
0.20961087942123413,
-0.13025246560573578,
-0.5501285195350647,
-0.26131096482276917,
-0.3301508128643036,
-0.3931368887424469,
0.3374658524990082,
-0.03302549943327904,
-0.10363076627254486,
0.6455559134483337,
0.1767345815896988,
0.5526414513587952,
0.2692640423774719,
-0.8663013577461243,
0.3704439401626587,
-0.2560531497001648,
-0.202457457780838,
0.13209198415279388,
0.5624468326568604,
0.6174898147583008,
0.13362804055213928,
0.10434918105602264,
-0.23908308148384094,
0.1119350716471672,
-0.050693050026893616,
-0.963502049446106,
-0.048019006848335266,
0.037205230444669724,
-0.5752536058425903,
-0.04661509022116661,
-0.17780177295207977,
-0.9407788515090942,
-0.453718364238739,
-0.6671574115753174,
0.4228726327419281,
-0.5522434115409851,
-0.4548615515232086,
0.0685979351401329,
-0.42406609654426575,
0.017864834517240524,
0.4189695715904236,
-0.8671419620513916,
-0.23913797736167908,
0.48498496413230896,
0.7349087595939636,
-0.06898930668830872,
-0.2728276550769806,
-0.36135366559028625,
0.44654351472854614,
0.03553245961666107,
0.7590181827545166,
-0.8022341728210449,
-0.1890728920698166,
-0.183462455868721,
-0.052308157086372375,
-0.2752366364002228,
-0.6020719408988953,
0.5052688717842102,
-0.4735763967037201,
0.34251609444618225,
-0.05685189366340637,
-0.533790647983551,
-0.4195932149887085,
0.48923149704933167,
-0.6302798390388489,
0.37322404980659485,
-0.24499844014644623,
-0.9051357507705688,
0.46438491344451904,
-0.6527470946311951,
-0.09040791541337967,
-0.12208259850740433,
-0.1520444005727768,
-0.08742047846317291,
-0.02648499235510826,
0.380467027425766,
0.5040514469146729,
-0.2515997290611267,
0.4372444152832031,
-0.3347789943218231,
-0.0873655304312706,
0.41881582140922546,
-1.249125599861145,
0.512671172618866,
0.5108759999275208,
-0.09178618341684341,
-0.011821103282272816,
-0.8535888195037842,
-0.34600815176963806,
-0.20793262124061584,
-0.4222734570503235,
-0.5598620772361755,
0.015479465015232563,
-0.07356639206409454,
0.2985716760158539,
0.06297334283590317,
-0.3790753483772278,
0.10183177888393402,
0.17937223613262177,
0.22797678411006927,
0.6957957744598389,
-0.16075047850608826,
0.40044575929641724,
-0.2492811530828476,
0.35702139139175415,
0.4127853214740753,
0.14985670149326324,
-0.6563425660133362,
-0.27229902148246765,
-0.7492189407348633,
-0.6662343740463257,
0.1126289963722229,
0.4807497262954712,
-1.2899422645568848,
-0.05474206060171127,
-0.5227877497673035,
-0.20309001207351685,
-0.6706412434577942,
0.1993696540594101,
0.2667628824710846,
0.6077097058296204,
0.3950698673725128,
0.0946832001209259,
-0.6232186555862427,
-0.8391640782356262,
-0.03570728749036789,
-0.04408672824501991,
-0.0024233285803347826,
0.0262815672904253,
0.5616529583930969,
-0.4529174566268921,
0.8070024847984314,
-0.33456388115882874,
-0.3755071461200714,
-0.2724074721336365,
0.5220195651054382,
0.059487856924533844,
0.3410119116306305,
0.4047066569328308,
-1.0400172472000122,
-0.42416834831237793,
-0.054354097694158554,
-0.7577417492866516,
-0.0006450042128562927,
-0.2217044234275818,
0.12096250802278519,
0.035970717668533325,
0.5582985281944275,
-0.5366530418395996,
0.12782418727874756,
0.6528332233428955,
-0.07611396908760071,
0.49348556995391846,
-0.3663395643234253,
0.42454639077186584,
-1.2617909908294678,
-0.061219584196805954,
0.1443338841199875,
0.00028070289408788085,
-0.5421401262283325,
-0.14564763009548187,
0.16316558420658112,
0.2160692662000656,
-0.4043072760105133,
0.30250900983810425,
-0.6991254091262817,
0.14545810222625732,
-0.3691094219684601,
0.1119641661643982,
0.04259656369686127,
0.23084093630313873,
-0.1420605629682541,
0.7721436619758606,
0.22113744914531708,
-0.5280893445014954,
0.6142532825469971,
-0.029356589540839195,
-0.4430505335330963,
0.9200680255889893,
-0.1667337566614151,
-0.1049250140786171,
-0.6154611706733704,
0.1724063903093338,
-1.0689122676849365,
-0.32090505957603455,
0.19205552339553833,
-0.4568687975406647,
0.4898545444011688,
-0.5832889080047607,
-0.6541228890419006,
-0.3501175045967102,
-0.1598082035779953,
0.1631358116865158,
0.26451289653778076,
-0.7617526054382324,
0.6744034886360168,
0.22545087337493896,
-0.09309105575084686,
-0.7750916481018066,
-0.7069888710975647,
0.02092627063393593,
-0.31008070707321167,
-0.5895812511444092,
-0.08072703331708908,
-0.3581642210483551,
-0.434331476688385,
-0.02071187272667885,
0.03287892043590546,
-0.3009822964668274,
-0.11799324303865433,
0.20901238918304443,
0.3003309369087219,
-0.362324982881546,
0.3817636966705322,
0.12410984188318253,
-0.23453126847743988,
0.008338038809597492,
-0.1516193151473999,
0.29334989190101624,
0.2161371409893036,
-0.7270629405975342,
-0.5742479562759399,
0.1409302055835724,
0.9885419607162476,
-0.2298007607460022,
0.8320332765579224,
0.9017975926399231,
-0.2348293513059616,
-0.05929587036371231,
-0.7574589848518372,
-0.13948293030261993,
-0.44969871640205383,
0.3679852783679962,
-0.4139174222946167,
-0.6495907306671143,
0.08721747249364853,
-0.25925031304359436,
-0.049271684139966965,
0.33918285369873047,
0.5213350057601929,
-0.05196628347039223,
1.2549395561218262,
0.5500779747962952,
-0.07157432287931442,
0.42664778232574463,
-0.2692858874797821,
0.09438447654247284,
-0.43797051906585693,
-0.44494715332984924,
-0.3160421848297119,
-0.3527773916721344,
-0.0709359347820282,
-0.8485968112945557,
0.37832438945770264,
-0.03325067460536957,
0.057011738419532776,
-0.4047735929489136,
-0.18984265625476837,
0.7426132559776306,
0.30690300464630127,
-0.12164999544620514,
0.5334908962249756,
0.29308390617370605,
-0.19789689779281616,
-0.27559995651245117,
-0.5501302480697632,
-0.4620554745197296,
1.0081981420516968,
0.5066099762916565,
1.288246512413025,
0.3463824391365051,
0.2585996091365814,
0.31949326395988464,
0.5515227913856506,
-0.7709725499153137,
0.10699552297592163,
-0.10234079509973526,
-0.540282130241394,
0.035208892077207565,
-0.5203843712806702,
-0.48062577843666077,
0.5048639178276062,
-0.2542804777622223,
-0.3363407850265503,
0.17965294420719147,
0.0690564513206482,
-0.0561455674469471,
0.41153767704963684,
-1.0266575813293457,
0.7631064653396606,
-0.35116514563560486,
-0.15195471048355103,
-0.43008244037628174,
-0.4605919420719147,
0.7626407742500305,
-0.06803138554096222,
0.69318687915802,
0.034041158854961395,
0.10931091755628586,
0.47297191619873047,
-0.01175291370600462,
0.9478445649147034,
-0.44492530822753906,
-0.14648579061031342,
0.11737633496522903,
-0.06043080985546112,
0.2892526090145111,
-0.030731406062841415,
-0.03136429935693741,
-0.16269998252391815,
-0.20973530411720276,
0.04561290144920349,
-0.7126411199569702,
0.8142949342727661,
-0.44792333245277405,
-0.5064449310302734,
-0.3490905165672302,
-0.7865663170814514,
0.18775971233844757,
0.15612119436264038,
-0.10403238981962204,
0.5260666012763977,
0.041970327496528625,
0.4358842074871063,
0.9832704067230225,
-0.1021551862359047,
0.4318999648094177,
0.6847438216209412,
-0.2578348219394684,
-0.4491387903690338,
1.0066756010055542,
0.07569483667612076,
0.2866329848766327,
0.573103666305542,
0.08428827673196793,
-0.47567319869995117,
-0.562290608882904,
-0.7803441286087036,
0.17826499044895172,
-0.8911746740341187,
-0.1487424373626709,
-0.7336977124214172,
-0.04109084606170654,
-0.19437679648399353,
0.28134313225746155,
-0.13857503235340118,
-0.11167176067829132,
-0.4585581421852112,
0.03550729528069496,
0.30324265360832214,
0.5733880400657654,
-0.33922749757766724,
0.36416080594062805,
-0.9529963135719299,
0.38432416319847107,
0.37026333808898926,
0.21134428679943085,
0.0753638967871666,
-0.6345151662826538,
-0.20790095627307892,
0.4999968111515045,
-0.28950732946395874,
-0.7343986630439758,
0.49137887358665466,
0.29849517345428467,
0.7059119939804077,
0.8550605773925781,
-0.016495395451784134,
0.9343265295028687,
-0.5142405033111572,
0.3912999629974365,
0.351425439119339,
-0.7538626194000244,
0.32621508836746216,
0.037337031215429306,
0.23625382781028748,
0.22498184442520142,
0.813991129398346,
-0.614996612071991,
-0.18932703137397766,
-0.11581514775753021,
-0.47094014286994934,
0.6439666748046875,
-0.23090167343616486,
0.10858398675918579,
-0.06415506452322006,
0.05136912688612938,
0.3392189145088196,
0.16411229968070984,
-0.6224691867828369,
-0.3494023084640503,
-0.1396518051624298,
-0.49064901471138,
-0.36882713437080383,
-0.6331830620765686,
-0.12632353603839874,
-0.043643753975629807,
0.4868218004703522,
-0.27168819308280945,
0.03823568671941757,
-0.025406867265701294,
-0.6325604915618896,
0.0807330533862114,
0.45036619901657104,
0.7227529883384705,
0.8551185131072998,
-0.08834665268659592,
0.47936731576919556,
-0.10150191932916641,
-0.5308026075363159,
0.17126169800758362,
0.2240990698337555,
0.1041526347398758,
0.1990758180618286,
0.3089712858200073,
0.7217202186584473,
0.037471264600753784,
-0.7723920345306396,
0.7370065450668335,
-0.1934511512517929,
-0.18522916734218597,
-0.23953956365585327,
-0.18721173703670502,
0.2228928506374359,
0.5812928676605225,
0.46303224563598633,
0.04708169400691986,
0.20579461753368378,
-0.5304612517356873,
0.18932639062404633,
0.31233033537864685,
-0.13218054175376892,
-0.18514083325862885,
0.4732382893562317,
0.14659075438976288,
0.27992966771125793,
0.6018843054771423,
-0.11934462189674377,
-0.2896044850349426,
0.3093232214450836,
0.464668333530426,
0.42472097277641296,
-0.3807026445865631,
0.2683282196521759,
0.1987161934375763,
0.3898817002773285,
-0.018387367948889732,
0.047383856028318405,
-0.09120386093854904,
-0.7387886047363281,
-0.6508399248123169,
-0.44092604517936707,
-0.15210863947868347,
0.271202951669693,
-0.4864329993724823,
0.13898013532161713,
-0.2600329518318176,
0.0007722220034338534,
0.3674997091293335,
-0.617629885673523,
-0.39256104826927185,
0.014005061239004135,
0.26930442452430725,
0.8276163935661316,
-0.7491170763969421,
0.7369803786277771,
0.5495831966400146,
-0.5818670988082886,
-0.49176275730133057,
-0.017473332583904266,
0.4505541920661926,
-0.7447338104248047,
1.1022608280181885,
0.23454256355762482,
-0.0636989176273346,
-0.19479092955589294,
-0.6413293480873108,
-0.6626404523849487,
1.2016398906707764,
0.5692228674888611,
-0.7426191568374634,
0.07880035787820816,
0.021884378045797348,
0.38799774646759033,
-0.45144936442375183,
0.5981045961380005,
0.36410757899284363,
0.5215864181518555,
0.5991963148117065,
-0.9043417572975159,
-0.3698008060455322,
-0.08555424213409424,
-0.04980625584721565,
-0.04533800110220909,
-0.19482865929603577,
0.9086690545082092,
-0.30095839500427246,
-0.21207310259342194,
-0.2949807941913605,
0.4850310683250427,
-0.0052325911819934845,
0.596803605556488,
0.42659011483192444,
0.5452250242233276,
0.6617522835731506,
0.026943178847432137,
0.6823188662528992,
-0.0667937695980072,
0.17483392357826233,
1.2263721227645874,
-0.24168217182159424,
0.8551163077354431,
0.6810327172279358,
0.20694372057914734,
0.5891879796981812,
0.41396549344062805,
0.10638728737831116,
0.5689414143562317,
0.03566436842083931,
-0.5054512619972229,
-0.1297157108783722,
-0.09510613977909088,
-0.3228350877761841,
0.4825388789176941,
0.6962301731109619,
-0.581235408782959,
-0.38088172674179077,
0.5060193538665771,
-0.030968669801950455,
0.023391248658299446,
-0.3037768006324768,
0.9005675911903381,
-0.20414350926876068,
-0.3923220932483673,
0.6364043354988098,
0.06378635764122009,
0.8415603637695312,
-0.4393002390861511,
-0.3931312561035156,
-0.129215270280838,
0.5658218860626221,
-0.20901747047901154,
-0.7250084280967712,
0.23016361892223358,
0.06996706873178482,
-0.6229885220527649,
-0.24492332339286804,
0.6763505935668945,
-0.8428491950035095,
-0.44252678751945496,
0.12872353196144104,
0.5983495116233826,
0.2028895765542984,
0.06964138895273209,
-0.5436966419219971,
0.2055211365222931,
0.12092068046331406,
0.1910001039505005,
0.2664385437965393,
0.8949074745178223,
0.1529604196548462,
0.973112940788269,
0.7421254515647888,
-0.22296185791492462,
0.1827613115310669,
0.18229998648166656,
0.9272018074989319,
-0.21448758244514465,
-0.17649368941783905,
-0.9576702117919922,
0.605226993560791,
-0.1314966380596161,
0.25387510657310486,
0.7411817908287048,
0.598405122756958,
0.9528367519378662,
-0.3162347078323364,
0.8799773454666138,
0.043231237679719925,
0.622251570224762,
-0.6567111015319824,
0.7830100059509277,
-0.4886505901813507,
0.3960650563240051,
-0.02654188685119152,
-0.9266650080680847,
-0.17271466553211212,
0.5155460834503174,
-0.28178223967552185,
-0.08274931460618973,
0.5875684022903442,
0.9130266308784485,
-0.39928603172302246,
-0.010853481478989124,
0.40513190627098083,
0.4658243656158447,
0.3735405504703522,
0.2314697653055191,
1.019671082496643,
-0.0943991020321846,
0.7408953309059143,
-0.06406357139348984,
-0.39151281118392944,
-0.2990261912345886,
-0.8438864946365356,
-0.8836239576339722,
-0.5499454140663147,
-0.10138248652219772,
-0.09500748664140701,
0.05752267315983772,
0.9952782392501831,
0.5831258296966553,
-0.5181187391281128,
-0.14747898280620575,
0.36261171102523804,
0.30778950452804565,
0.07648012787103653,
-0.26385146379470825,
-0.029631931334733963,
-0.28944841027259827,
-0.8892892599105835,
0.43217337131500244,
0.28041160106658936,
0.24347703158855438,
-0.45661070942878723,
-0.21866129338741302,
-0.44694840908050537,
-0.10916830599308014,
0.8114102482795715,
-0.11258697509765625,
-0.7193637490272522,
-0.035311877727508545,
-0.28164952993392944,
-0.09178555756807327,
-0.06686823070049286,
0.685828685760498,
-0.4894922375679016,
0.8645033240318298,
0.24176079034805298,
0.6342462301254272,
0.3920832574367523,
-0.2099979817867279,
0.3976701498031616,
-0.6424426436424255,
0.1302960216999054,
-0.03884253278374672,
0.22276435792446136,
0.4477311968803406,
0.00688847666606307,
0.05633288621902466,
0.37092965841293335,
-0.2790962755680084,
-0.7323541045188904,
-0.03042355179786682,
-0.7007175087928772,
-0.3255278170108795,
1.1721138954162598,
-0.20413325726985931,
-0.16662068665027618,
-0.15671797096729279,
-0.5450433492660522,
0.11651287972927094,
-0.43808138370513916,
0.6174132823944092,
0.715259850025177,
0.2999992370605469,
-0.5158647894859314,
-0.622967004776001,
0.18467339873313904,
-0.23663075268268585,
-0.7237141132354736,
0.12289287894964218,
0.9487757086753845,
0.37283894419670105,
0.24236759543418884,
0.2840849459171295,
-0.06293263286352158,
0.2050587683916092,
0.15224765241146088,
0.16543236374855042,
-0.3155056834220886,
-0.4750714600086212,
-0.3216833770275116,
-0.0008356766775250435,
0.034232866019010544,
-0.34493333101272583
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14168v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14168v3
|
M$^3$AV: A Multimodal, Multigenre, and Multipurpose Audio-Visual Academic Lecture Dataset
| 2024-03-21T06:43:59 | 2024-06-04T04:05:09 |
Zhe Chen, Heyang Liu, Wenyi Yu, Guangzhi Sun, Hongcheng Liu, Ji Wu, Chao Zhang, Yu Wang, Yanfeng Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Publishing open-source academic video recordings is an emergent and prevalent
approach to sharing knowledge online. Such videos carry rich multimodal
information including speech, the facial and body movements of the speakers, as
well as the texts and pictures in the slides and possibly even the papers.
Although multiple academic video datasets have been constructed and released,
few of them support both multimodal content recognition and understanding
tasks, which is partially due to the lack of high-quality human annotations. In
this paper, we propose a novel multimodal, multigenre, and multipurpose
audio-visual academic lecture dataset (M$^3$AV), which has almost 367 hours of
videos from five sources covering computer science, mathematics, and medical
and biology topics. With high-quality human annotations of the slide text and
spoken words, in particular high-valued name entities, the dataset can be used
for multiple audio-visual recognition and understanding tasks. Evaluations
performed on contextual speech recognition, speech synthesis, and slide and
script generation tasks demonstrate that the diversity of M$^3$AV makes it a
challenging dataset.
|
[
-0.43570762872695923,
-0.7177401781082153,
0.3880746066570282,
0.13734683394432068,
-0.20932884514331818,
0.03777003288269043,
-0.30937594175338745,
-0.2198314368724823,
0.20197278261184692,
0.13901808857917786,
-0.2874663770198822,
-0.42245763540267944,
-0.597481369972229,
0.07506288588047028,
-0.3236505389213562,
0.8385481834411621,
0.05971520394086838,
0.3556397259235382,
-0.4643384516239166,
-0.46163156628608704,
-0.272989958524704,
-0.2676088213920593,
-0.34740307927131653,
0.031828511506319046,
0.5979927778244019,
0.6627606153488159,
0.4684162139892578,
0.7317495346069336,
0.6323243379592896,
0.3418819010257721,
0.4370588958263397,
0.26775598526000977,
0.0027955302502959967,
-0.16594122350215912,
0.2585636079311371,
-0.026830125600099564,
-0.39908450841903687,
0.047397684305906296,
1.0132135152816772,
0.5423085689544678,
-0.04417392611503601,
0.33253052830696106,
0.00836023036390543,
0.517834484577179,
-0.5425726175308228,
0.43325313925743103,
-0.26864683628082275,
-0.03609106317162514,
-0.52510666847229,
-0.17746153473854065,
-0.4073032736778259,
-0.06507077813148499,
-0.020457111299037933,
-1.0115400552749634,
0.09197144210338593,
-0.08562962710857391,
0.43797537684440613,
0.2229340821504593,
-0.36494821310043335,
0.13616473972797394,
-0.5589444041252136,
0.8232800960540771,
-0.17070427536964417,
0.5671583414077759,
0.3630702793598175,
0.7873365879058838,
0.4553297460079193,
-0.43135079741477966,
-0.7019408941268921,
0.2496325969696045,
0.3289952576160431,
0.010366573929786682,
-0.06503307819366455,
0.11143387854099274,
0.008374263532459736,
0.26845309138298035,
-0.5885061621665955,
-0.05849607288837433,
-0.6884939670562744,
-0.2093183696269989,
0.5728214383125305,
0.030728654935956,
0.25917762517929077,
-0.397967129945755,
-0.22100944817066193,
-0.4309373199939728,
-0.4013545513153076,
0.03303899988532066,
0.406627893447876,
0.13886809349060059,
-0.0489451065659523,
0.7143465876579285,
0.07312753051519394,
0.7585212588310242,
-0.6432440280914307,
-0.6625458002090454,
0.6071343421936035,
-0.39775940775871277,
-0.3204191327095032,
0.15847983956336975,
0.7165391445159912,
0.33185291290283203,
0.1396670639514923,
0.3140002489089966,
0.38024935126304626,
-0.06604969501495361,
0.17738555371761322,
-0.6155780553817749,
-0.37185022234916687,
0.1281486451625824,
-0.3247889280319214,
-0.03836638480424881,
0.06938044726848602,
-0.936292827129364,
-0.2753753960132599,
-0.6146038174629211,
0.645829975605011,
-0.705325186252594,
-0.02725670300424099,
0.03765975311398506,
-0.05463375523686409,
-0.2760881781578064,
0.7874986529350281,
-1.0202456712722778,
0.0796760618686676,
0.397579163312912,
0.8298496603965759,
0.023905474692583084,
-0.471280038356781,
-0.5503509640693665,
0.44532859325408936,
0.11569325625896454,
0.4627592861652374,
-0.6550552845001221,
-0.22138673067092896,
0.05275789275765419,
-0.1189059466123581,
-0.0013749481877312064,
-0.1580154001712799,
0.3895503282546997,
-0.11162736266851425,
0.25056159496307373,
0.20361748337745667,
-0.3585219383239746,
-0.4236917495727539,
0.11501845717430115,
-0.6815779209136963,
0.46521323919296265,
-0.0729450210928917,
-0.6214820146560669,
0.3848993480205536,
-0.8241224884986877,
-0.14571544528007507,
0.24031078815460205,
-0.649560272693634,
-0.361748605966568,
-0.518570601940155,
0.30641305446624756,
0.630944013595581,
-0.07856830954551697,
0.26533252000808716,
-0.1861860752105713,
-0.12252657115459442,
0.16501562297344208,
-0.607907235622406,
0.3809005916118622,
0.21293291449546814,
-0.031139740720391273,
-0.055391017347574234,
-1.3423629999160767,
-0.4456500709056854,
-0.1369294673204422,
-0.3723716735839844,
-0.49153634905815125,
0.17924340069293976,
0.2764293849468231,
0.07968569546937943,
-0.07282113283872604,
-0.812716543674469,
0.24567247927188873,
0.25044673681259155,
0.5009596347808838,
0.6918652057647705,
-0.24536393582820892,
0.11839569360017776,
-0.26582664251327515,
0.34870022535324097,
0.2406497299671173,
0.09764834493398666,
-0.5162113308906555,
-0.6486533284187317,
-0.42097848653793335,
-0.8506432771682739,
-0.14354652166366577,
0.33169981837272644,
-0.823255181312561,
-0.23880887031555176,
-0.28468507528305054,
-0.31065842509269714,
-1.028902292251587,
0.3574327528476715,
0.3734365403652191,
0.5406992435455322,
0.8653815984725952,
0.2405593991279602,
-0.566136360168457,
-1.0674543380737305,
-0.012904820963740349,
-0.17078588902950287,
-0.3924708366394043,
0.6350827217102051,
0.3807549476623535,
-0.3215828239917755,
0.6152801513671875,
-0.437505841255188,
-0.6894189119338989,
0.1769273728132248,
0.6015843152999878,
-0.0629354789853096,
0.4836865961551666,
0.47446903586387634,
-0.6968587040901184,
0.022029034793376923,
-0.02152969129383564,
-0.7565444707870483,
0.30557680130004883,
-0.27595511078834534,
0.15426811575889587,
-0.22021634876728058,
0.19871343672275543,
-0.22256194055080414,
-0.05267740786075592,
0.553497314453125,
-0.06926700472831726,
0.35408371686935425,
-0.01918843761086464,
0.5119055509567261,
-1.086652159690857,
-0.19580675661563873,
0.24158184230327606,
-0.029212409630417824,
-0.33209654688835144,
-0.3667489290237427,
0.028325529769062996,
-0.24832254648208618,
-0.849327802658081,
0.34438544511795044,
-0.09216919541358948,
0.0341574065387249,
0.160197913646698,
0.4788128435611725,
0.026760676875710487,
0.4592021107673645,
-0.0022708990145474672,
0.7340205311775208,
0.7482692003250122,
-0.4594671130180359,
0.3004000782966614,
0.8199776411056519,
-0.37042754888534546,
0.8927201628684998,
-0.250315397977829,
-0.2325638383626938,
-0.23071643710136414,
0.09377098083496094,
-0.5761088728904724,
-0.8311735987663269,
-0.11439359188079834,
-0.5197045207023621,
0.12926112115383148,
-0.1278063803911209,
-0.19171719253063202,
0.03897625580430031,
-0.4816645681858063,
0.707462728023529,
-0.12600108981132507,
-0.6335129737854004,
0.5964480042457581,
0.46375471353530884,
-0.48676633834838867,
-0.780462920665741,
-0.5767579674720764,
0.15100502967834473,
-0.07579974830150604,
-0.8532971739768982,
0.4007415473461151,
-0.1268370896577835,
-0.2882934510707855,
-0.0860741063952446,
0.2490246295928955,
-0.06953029334545135,
-0.34068191051483154,
0.5682063102722168,
0.44358956813812256,
-0.19694623351097107,
0.25484439730644226,
-0.026929480955004692,
0.14746728539466858,
0.018247082829475403,
-0.053397197276353836,
-0.1822301745414734,
-0.3115961253643036,
-0.486469566822052,
-0.5481808185577393,
0.6307790279388428,
0.7289096117019653,
-0.042895909398794174,
0.30862167477607727,
0.8364049792289734,
-0.39362484216690063,
0.23034712672233582,
-0.5243876576423645,
0.03826999291777611,
-0.4060610234737396,
0.44247961044311523,
-0.23095449805259705,
-1.0362215042114258,
-0.04075615480542183,
0.33611974120140076,
0.2950010299682617,
0.5739994049072266,
0.44240647554397583,
-0.24443921446800232,
1.0108965635299683,
0.271153062582016,
0.1578816920518875,
0.49535128474235535,
-0.17375771701335907,
-0.07000131905078888,
-0.8169522881507874,
-0.6427366137504578,
-0.5036150813102722,
-0.2522018551826477,
-0.33222609758377075,
-0.46542084217071533,
0.4898197650909424,
-0.4582134783267975,
-0.20539282262325287,
0.11598290503025055,
-0.3115651607513428,
0.36807507276535034,
0.6376767754554749,
0.1133100837469101,
0.4099089205265045,
0.11938604712486267,
0.04499294236302376,
-0.346132755279541,
-0.20384202897548676,
-0.5887519717216492,
1.1327972412109375,
0.4781537353992462,
0.6838650107383728,
0.5239561796188354,
0.35091444849967957,
0.4397070109844208,
0.10979066789150238,
-0.5704153776168823,
0.4984574019908905,
-0.23735035955905914,
-0.4756004512310028,
-0.3867453634738922,
-0.48818284273147583,
-0.7011066675186157,
0.37891432642936707,
-0.4616769850254059,
-0.741956889629364,
-0.022182879969477654,
0.233859121799469,
-0.2813235819339752,
0.43480339646339417,
-0.6906832456588745,
0.7604813575744629,
-0.12109854817390442,
-0.5273395776748657,
-0.3290911018848419,
-0.7925059199333191,
0.4851926267147064,
-0.11255818605422974,
0.7924619317054749,
-0.10362108051776886,
0.25792229175567627,
1.1417231559753418,
-0.07319243252277374,
0.27778610587120056,
-0.2879510223865509,
0.3616775572299957,
0.3213109076023102,
-0.002085653133690357,
-0.18248111009597778,
0.5917839407920837,
0.29319775104522705,
0.14936310052871704,
0.08878768980503082,
-0.21233786642551422,
-0.11964390426874161,
0.7292530536651611,
-1.0658068656921387,
-0.3840022087097168,
-0.36113137006759644,
-0.5545660257339478,
-0.26134300231933594,
0.16867999732494354,
-0.3260200321674347,
0.7849592566490173,
-0.16086570918560028,
0.7125837206840515,
0.48812007904052734,
-0.07289337366819382,
0.5999180674552917,
0.27492624521255493,
0.06087959557771683,
-0.8699904680252075,
1.341899037361145,
-0.040461402386426926,
-0.07011851668357849,
0.44669049978256226,
-0.06616105139255524,
-0.1432853639125824,
-0.3497098684310913,
-0.6989471912384033,
0.09789057821035385,
-0.7608555555343628,
-0.11306977272033691,
-0.9173945784568787,
0.005684706848114729,
-0.3202998638153076,
-0.2552539110183716,
-0.2572498917579651,
-0.7431451678276062,
-0.6513810157775879,
-0.35463014245033264,
0.3501304090023041,
0.4311522841453552,
-0.35927027463912964,
0.37625738978385925,
-0.9087277054786682,
0.5515467524528503,
0.8549202084541321,
0.2969743609428406,
-0.41447439789772034,
-0.24020689725875854,
-0.3942262828350067,
0.003914545755833387,
-0.6715916395187378,
-0.6764621138572693,
0.3503291606903076,
0.6590676307678223,
0.5123633742332458,
0.7583678364753723,
-0.522470235824585,
0.4844062030315399,
-0.6220242977142334,
0.9335451722145081,
0.45459774136543274,
-0.77982097864151,
0.42423614859580994,
-0.4852255880832672,
-0.06027458235621452,
0.6999972462654114,
0.6080804467201233,
-0.17091844975948334,
-0.13850939273834229,
-0.5917101502418518,
-0.9112176299095154,
0.5720267295837402,
0.3192669451236725,
-0.10951513797044754,
0.19192838668823242,
-0.24406279623508453,
0.3968670070171356,
0.39153149724006653,
-0.6007563471794128,
-0.25869685411453247,
-0.8549225926399231,
-0.2255275547504425,
-0.43356117606163025,
0.04079782962799072,
-0.5519145727157593,
-0.37315642833709717,
0.6460809707641602,
-0.19520382583141327,
0.23911796510219574,
0.010183343663811684,
-0.32830968499183655,
0.13189071416854858,
0.4887387752532959,
0.8292539119720459,
0.47499510645866394,
-0.6371764540672302,
0.32806286215782166,
-0.28761026263237,
-0.7583553791046143,
0.31350627541542053,
0.27468016743659973,
0.4258481562137604,
0.1996283084154129,
0.3160163164138794,
0.686176598072052,
0.26407817006111145,
-0.8314731121063232,
0.5737251043319702,
-0.09598032385110855,
-0.6328455209732056,
-0.46457791328430176,
-0.01865038089454174,
-0.16158820688724518,
0.16824427247047424,
0.5877279043197632,
0.30641990900039673,
0.36492136120796204,
-0.35396257042884827,
0.39890119433403015,
0.11055663973093033,
-0.2845323383808136,
-0.2538260221481323,
1.1930030584335327,
0.34803348779678345,
-0.27260300517082214,
0.48209986090660095,
0.22305217385292053,
0.11716639250516891,
0.17028044164180756,
0.11931881308555603,
0.4135270118713379,
-0.00021157880837563425,
0.3910056948661804,
0.4839089512825012,
0.02925153635442257,
0.09788252413272858,
0.4041074812412262,
-0.2792057693004608,
-0.27335846424102783,
-0.3842940926551819,
-0.5494746565818787,
-0.8414897918701172,
0.13576491177082062,
-0.6185684204101562,
0.3865419924259186,
-0.3078724145889282,
-0.12506313621997833,
0.5919821262359619,
-0.35902830958366394,
-0.5798592567443848,
0.38780277967453003,
0.32242584228515625,
0.6224164366722107,
-0.972689688205719,
0.7432924509048462,
0.6103230714797974,
-0.5939913988113403,
-0.3922490179538727,
-0.7579575181007385,
0.3847968578338623,
-0.4631103277206421,
0.5215606093406677,
0.19849362969398499,
-0.06097399815917015,
-0.15792012214660645,
-0.39301756024360657,
-0.514142632484436,
1.1785701513290405,
0.3618035316467285,
-0.5435903668403625,
0.10722146928310394,
0.13431693613529205,
0.19615106284618378,
-0.38243725895881653,
0.283193975687027,
0.2538706660270691,
0.5546692609786987,
0.19442704319953918,
-0.5446993112564087,
-0.5813067555427551,
-0.4261228144168854,
-0.5248149037361145,
0.12353567779064178,
-0.574444591999054,
0.978976309299469,
-0.15581749379634857,
0.2893262803554535,
-0.49197229743003845,
0.7166649103164673,
0.41738662123680115,
0.4556126892566681,
0.37162819504737854,
0.38971856236457825,
0.5483561754226685,
-0.11814581602811813,
0.5436644554138184,
-0.01456601731479168,
0.058912213891744614,
1.0659650564193726,
0.09139768034219742,
0.8172131776809692,
0.6988391280174255,
-0.1516178697347641,
0.3635772168636322,
0.4302552044391632,
-0.26015445590019226,
0.3913591504096985,
-0.057233940809965134,
-0.46662065386772156,
-0.28468042612075806,
-0.1825382113456726,
-0.4799678921699524,
0.5898047685623169,
0.5909668207168579,
-0.18964821100234985,
0.06332486122846603,
0.4257931113243103,
-0.12206903845071793,
-0.20087410509586334,
-0.2392580807209015,
0.6458947062492371,
-0.1362903118133545,
-0.25340503454208374,
0.12174990773200989,
-0.28578251600265503,
0.45494264364242554,
-0.4306494891643524,
-0.3418455719947815,
0.2631407678127289,
-0.04896337166428566,
-0.3597593307495117,
-0.7559025287628174,
0.027214912697672844,
-0.02335014007985592,
0.02139260619878769,
-0.3481820523738861,
0.12048579752445221,
-0.5638976097106934,
-0.45463067293167114,
-0.058400604873895645,
0.20554307103157043,
0.26758089661598206,
0.2405642718076706,
-0.14975076913833618,
-0.012607613578438759,
-0.21858423948287964,
-0.11806899309158325,
0.36310073733329773,
0.22736147046089172,
0.17048805952072144,
0.6763277649879456,
0.5379865169525146,
-0.0830039456486702,
-0.035973452031612396,
0.22571519017219543,
0.6572840213775635,
-0.39069145917892456,
-0.3626302182674408,
-0.5257605314254761,
0.6225584149360657,
-0.03167261928319931,
-0.45356687903404236,
0.7409765720367432,
0.6116359829902649,
0.9623939990997314,
-0.1362403780221939,
0.9299470782279968,
0.09208599478006363,
0.39052069187164307,
-0.5638129711151123,
0.40985846519470215,
-0.8522306084632874,
-0.01396368257701397,
-0.6808506846427917,
-0.584942638874054,
-0.4971596598625183,
0.6155292987823486,
0.28454455733299255,
-0.15964017808437347,
0.5976508855819702,
0.364145427942276,
-0.18474286794662476,
0.37640491127967834,
0.285017728805542,
-0.06008332967758179,
0.5363276600837708,
0.4396788477897644,
0.5993101596832275,
-0.34054189920425415,
0.7612400650978088,
-0.26098930835723877,
-0.32494956254959106,
-0.5222935080528259,
-0.7128225564956665,
-0.8003299236297607,
-0.9026099443435669,
-0.5236533284187317,
-0.05921103432774544,
-0.12831024825572968,
1.1739239692687988,
0.8534042239189148,
-0.6448692083358765,
-0.03692160174250603,
0.36149486899375916,
-0.14586031436920166,
-0.3147241473197937,
-0.18782134354114532,
0.4755312502384186,
0.17271433770656586,
-0.707241952419281,
0.7195014953613281,
0.48761212825775146,
0.167032852768898,
-0.36004072427749634,
-0.03431393578648567,
-0.5013601779937744,
-0.06428727507591248,
0.7233455777168274,
0.3846581280231476,
-0.4239230155944824,
-0.39513304829597473,
-0.07474736869335175,
0.13650017976760864,
0.3701336979866028,
0.7210846543312073,
-0.4899613559246063,
0.806477427482605,
0.31030434370040894,
0.679169237613678,
0.5602946281433105,
-0.13132008910179138,
0.3706764280796051,
-0.9699833393096924,
0.2633267939090729,
0.3185827136039734,
0.6854971647262573,
0.4945988655090332,
-0.0775008276104927,
0.33285003900527954,
0.1519233137369156,
-0.7470234036445618,
-0.697378933429718,
-0.12203480303287506,
-1.4733421802520752,
-0.048180460929870605,
0.7890477180480957,
-0.11915548890829086,
0.1157645583152771,
-0.0627790242433548,
-0.437280535697937,
0.17933352291584015,
-0.6943655610084534,
0.8531755208969116,
0.7257636189460754,
-0.3326840400695801,
-0.3625503480434418,
-0.9418950080871582,
0.35586631298065186,
0.12185057997703552,
-0.8962239027023315,
-0.10933341085910797,
0.8216820359230042,
-0.1246805489063263,
0.35677778720855713,
0.2731008231639862,
-0.1773902326822281,
0.4361267387866974,
-0.09452936798334122,
0.12093652784824371,
-0.6068314909934998,
-0.867648720741272,
-0.14614230394363403,
0.5267124772071838,
-0.18107131123542786,
-0.6520320773124695
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14731v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14731v1
|
Reversible Jump Attack to Textual Classifiers with Modification Reduction
| 2024-03-21T04:54:31 | 2024-03-21T04:54:31 |
Mingze Ni, Zhensu Sun, Wei Liu
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Recent studies on adversarial examples expose vulnerabilities of natural
language processing (NLP) models. Existing techniques for generating
adversarial examples are typically driven by deterministic hierarchical rules
that are agnostic to the optimal adversarial examples, a strategy that often
results in adversarial samples with a suboptimal balance between magnitudes of
changes and attack successes. To this end, in this research we propose two
algorithms, Reversible Jump Attack (RJA) and Metropolis-Hasting Modification
Reduction (MMR), to generate highly effective adversarial examples and to
improve the imperceptibility of the examples, respectively. RJA utilizes a
novel randomization mechanism to enlarge the search space and efficiently
adapts to a number of perturbed words for adversarial examples. With these
generated adversarial examples, MMR applies the Metropolis-Hasting sampler to
enhance the imperceptibility of adversarial examples. Extensive experiments
demonstrate that RJA-MMR outperforms current state-of-the-art methods in attack
performance, imperceptibility, fluency and grammar correctness.
|
[
-0.45797839760780334,
-1.1277551651000977,
0.2802235782146454,
0.061106037348508835,
-0.005334612913429737,
0.09863777458667755,
0.011777005158364773,
-0.2593826949596405,
0.19892501831054688,
0.6756933331489563,
-0.5244866609573364,
-0.2769939601421356,
-0.7017661929130554,
0.08486444503068924,
-0.6631133556365967,
1.289505958557129,
0.2779632806777954,
-0.3022139370441437,
0.11598160862922668,
-0.07998021692037582,
-0.33043813705444336,
-0.6273535490036011,
-0.9528322815895081,
-0.2884379029273987,
0.5528254508972168,
0.19126789271831512,
1.0671088695526123,
0.67157381772995,
0.5326815247535706,
0.3246764838695526,
-0.37019672989845276,
-0.01480800285935402,
-0.38174891471862793,
0.26881250739097595,
-0.0004764514451380819,
-0.6879891753196716,
-0.2198069989681244,
-0.06782739609479904,
0.5920124650001526,
0.3395130932331085,
-0.006950655952095985,
-0.2874678671360016,
-0.1094389483332634,
0.953449010848999,
-0.8398276567459106,
-0.1688058078289032,
-0.891235888004303,
0.29627716541290283,
-0.2252064049243927,
-0.6408625245094299,
-0.688515841960907,
-0.3349379897117615,
-0.18478591740131378,
-0.5953108668327332,
0.5141786336898804,
-0.26808851957321167,
0.786139726638794,
0.47142767906188965,
-0.1450445055961609,
-0.22219473123550415,
-0.729423999786377,
0.6608778238296509,
-0.9541828632354736,
0.29924798011779785,
0.13080176711082458,
0.3130010664463043,
-0.7361792325973511,
-0.7657175064086914,
-0.538176953792572,
-0.1840009242296219,
0.15949562191963196,
0.2358274757862091,
-0.30828261375427246,
0.07287865877151489,
0.4974602162837982,
0.25582748651504517,
-0.6607280969619751,
0.1343749761581421,
-0.10613121092319489,
-0.03073304146528244,
0.4655364751815796,
0.1941361129283905,
0.4223674535751343,
0.01999577507376671,
-0.13980354368686676,
-0.4399321675300598,
-0.6307500004768372,
0.044605378061532974,
0.7043604254722595,
0.3394683301448822,
0.3573892116546631,
0.5499864816665649,
-0.0705588161945343,
0.7451446652412415,
0.24626217782497406,
-0.002579218242317438,
0.07725100964307785,
-0.11810706555843353,
-0.41546186804771423,
-0.19546176493167877,
0.6142690181732178,
0.19632276892662048,
0.30212733149528503,
-0.21070918440818787,
0.013763819821178913,
0.04416322708129883,
0.6284608244895935,
-0.8613402247428894,
-0.4569035470485687,
0.092563696205616,
-0.40547001361846924,
-0.6390718817710876,
-0.1447754204273224,
-0.8097351789474487,
-0.4256461262702942,
0.13906338810920715,
0.21149888634681702,
-0.6332244277000427,
0.10978692770004272,
0.19483034312725067,
-0.40388160943984985,
0.07074079662561417,
0.3596689999103546,
-0.7690418362617493,
0.3828379511833191,
0.7419182062149048,
0.7225839495658875,
0.09485133737325668,
-0.48168307542800903,
-0.6312287449836731,
-0.05896011367440224,
-0.41501420736312866,
0.6599516272544861,
-0.4771993160247803,
-0.5204611420631409,
-0.07033171504735947,
-0.31340929865837097,
-0.42615219950675964,
-0.44230005145072937,
0.6639934778213501,
-0.9366656541824341,
0.3879404366016388,
0.1787596493959427,
-0.4427492022514343,
-0.5078099370002747,
0.6256408095359802,
-0.715805172920227,
0.9594085812568665,
-0.37179070711135864,
-1.201011300086975,
0.3337896764278412,
-0.7356597781181335,
-0.5879068970680237,
-0.25908151268959045,
0.15066276490688324,
-0.795472264289856,
0.1400385946035385,
0.5823001265525818,
0.3256649971008301,
0.2033718079328537,
-0.16024653613567352,
-0.166155606508255,
-0.40225085616111755,
0.40077540278434753,
-0.6699758768081665,
0.8667486310005188,
0.09244377166032791,
-0.08716852217912674,
0.0810234472155571,
-1.0443007946014404,
-0.0608612559735775,
0.35765665769577026,
-0.5763860940933228,
-0.670505940914154,
0.33113932609558105,
0.09796268492937088,
0.06705620139837265,
0.028818905353546143,
-0.16577021777629852,
0.4319482743740082,
-0.9734025597572327,
0.06521963328123093,
0.5648431777954102,
0.46102336049079895,
0.21462297439575195,
-0.356842041015625,
0.49974679946899414,
-0.05458962917327881,
0.15925279259681702,
-0.14113113284111023,
-0.6006775498390198,
-0.8491911888122559,
-0.47905677556991577,
0.27267923951148987,
0.7985856533050537,
-0.935547411441803,
0.49196088314056396,
-0.2835850119590759,
-0.5585977435112,
-0.4381096065044403,
-0.07334117591381073,
0.3644467890262604,
0.39181336760520935,
0.6382563710212708,
-0.1608218103647232,
-0.6245032548904419,
-0.753149688243866,
-0.8686208128929138,
-0.24722440540790558,
-0.15772321820259094,
-0.2807405889034271,
0.48426297307014465,
-0.4407234489917755,
0.8964766263961792,
-0.5303423404693604,
0.026130957528948784,
-0.24034282565116882,
0.43256065249443054,
0.2902075946331024,
0.38182106614112854,
0.5366159677505493,
-0.8579187989234924,
-0.1985996514558792,
-0.21586160361766815,
-0.34798845648765564,
-0.007773540914058685,
-0.5399061441421509,
0.34647059440612793,
0.035389892756938934,
0.6609418392181396,
-0.28802362084388733,
0.6124326586723328,
0.15841802954673767,
-0.09347204864025116,
0.39886346459388733,
-0.4108220636844635,
0.3241681158542633,
-1.2008411884307861,
-0.20776428282260895,
-0.1918613165616989,
-0.4496300220489502,
-0.9664323925971985,
0.5834877490997314,
-0.0009773329365998507,
0.008452837355434895,
-0.41853806376457214,
0.07246163487434387,
-0.1297507882118225,
0.19721941649913788,
-0.4289635717868805,
-0.05318799987435341,
-0.16741769015789032,
0.35171931982040405,
-0.04642857611179352,
0.6242817640304565,
0.2786726951599121,
-0.8408543467521667,
-0.07889527827501297,
0.1994614154100418,
-0.027059974148869514,
0.25650426745414734,
-0.5450224876403809,
0.22628948092460632,
-0.3901028335094452,
0.38842472434043884,
-0.9846776127815247,
0.15922467410564423,
0.35494348406791687,
-0.7352569699287415,
0.5668409466743469,
-0.34039124846458435,
-0.5457373261451721,
-0.1772821843624115,
-0.7035520076751709,
0.1833607405424118,
0.3008081018924713,
-0.7383763790130615,
0.37316903471946716,
0.08171726018190384,
-0.07607711106538773,
-0.8177701830863953,
-0.9441736340522766,
0.4604520797729492,
-0.1984846144914627,
-0.342548131942749,
0.2461184710264206,
-0.22801540791988373,
-0.055877238512039185,
-0.2513815462589264,
0.23066449165344238,
-0.1087101623415947,
0.5274466872215271,
0.21768546104431152,
0.1575881391763687,
-0.0026485093403607607,
-0.2728356122970581,
0.1637897789478302,
-0.29035618901252747,
0.09367084503173828,
-0.015070379711687565,
0.3726962208747864,
0.09833458065986633,
-0.41467559337615967,
-0.338323712348938,
0.08053917437791824,
0.688518226146698,
0.0762798860669136,
0.7892860770225525,
0.5902766585350037,
-0.4142870306968689,
-0.2718444764614105,
-0.16894471645355225,
-0.09175502508878708,
-0.45895224809646606,
0.531542956829071,
-0.47096696496009827,
-0.8072678446769714,
0.24376894533634186,
0.10313208401203156,
0.475982129573822,
0.40586161613464355,
0.45227760076522827,
0.2760958969593048,
0.9942307472229004,
0.3097277581691742,
-0.18355679512023926,
0.48997193574905396,
-0.12266254425048828,
0.29002222418785095,
-0.7347625494003296,
0.2652190923690796,
-0.7575173377990723,
-0.13383057713508606,
-0.7970247864723206,
-0.3512185215950012,
0.03814429044723511,
-0.117972731590271,
-0.03915828466415405,
0.6907469034194946,
-0.4179331362247467,
0.5289313793182373,
0.3555431663990021,
-0.03132254257798195,
0.258710652589798,
-0.0343780517578125,
-0.2878478169441223,
-0.4092537760734558,
-0.6370208859443665,
-0.29767775535583496,
1.0435824394226074,
0.49198541045188904,
0.6330774426460266,
0.345527708530426,
0.7440060973167419,
0.4888385832309723,
0.34478360414505005,
-0.7752645015716553,
0.6281702518463135,
-0.24183282256126404,
-0.3757213354110718,
-0.1612939089536667,
-0.4886641800403595,
-0.832029402256012,
0.4681330919265747,
-0.49652111530303955,
-0.5851914882659912,
0.07049138098955154,
0.07626903057098389,
0.06192423030734062,
0.6168311238288879,
-0.41096943616867065,
0.39682796597480774,
0.4209092855453491,
-0.0010781441815197468,
-0.2353263795375824,
-0.47020620107650757,
0.38472551107406616,
-0.23445340991020203,
0.42889589071273804,
0.4784981310367584,
0.04337535426020622,
0.7387494444847107,
-0.40699177980422974,
0.7042067646980286,
-0.18328852951526642,
-0.024038756266236305,
0.00756683899089694,
0.37746644020080566,
0.718197762966156,
0.025381190702319145,
0.010930294170975685,
0.020967788994312286,
-0.3879512548446655,
-0.10607792437076569,
-0.7503737211227417,
0.6087809801101685,
-0.4710492789745331,
-0.6196928024291992,
-0.44347208738327026,
-0.5180762410163879,
-0.19137819111347198,
0.059683095663785934,
0.34910258650779724,
0.21555201709270477,
-0.42704570293426514,
0.07385474443435669,
0.6561493873596191,
-0.29969900846481323,
0.587632954120636,
0.552704393863678,
-0.1844494342803955,
-0.6854971647262573,
0.816946268081665,
-0.03412856534123421,
0.18296760320663452,
0.8573580384254456,
0.10258612781763077,
-0.2152067869901657,
-1.030119776725769,
-0.30312055349349976,
-0.02456902712583542,
-0.6492529511451721,
-0.06565654277801514,
-0.6492182612419128,
-0.3423739969730377,
-0.5197174549102783,
-0.41211050748825073,
-0.26257067918777466,
-0.7430205345153809,
-0.24149474501609802,
-0.08392487466335297,
0.22824770212173462,
0.41010233759880066,
-0.06661048531532288,
0.3614269196987152,
-0.7128475308418274,
0.5272016525268555,
0.42284321784973145,
-0.09618949145078659,
-0.05608890950679779,
-0.7998660802841187,
-0.18081650137901306,
-0.10268852859735489,
-0.3049795627593994,
-0.8722192049026489,
0.5815316438674927,
-0.021481245756149292,
0.23333033919334412,
0.3270096778869629,
0.015790292993187904,
0.6744252443313599,
-0.7190420627593994,
0.632969319820404,
0.15763244032859802,
-0.8022922873497009,
0.5848983526229858,
-0.2606630027294159,
0.26508066058158875,
0.6872912645339966,
0.11408805847167969,
-0.3811032474040985,
-0.873458743095398,
-0.636662483215332,
-0.7526506185531616,
0.44293922185897827,
0.5275993943214417,
-0.24012261629104614,
0.010580676607787609,
0.23596815764904022,
-0.11316987872123718,
-0.12822726368904114,
-0.6991241574287415,
-0.47367963194847107,
-0.26132744550704956,
0.033266980201005936,
-0.09463606774806976,
-0.060070279985666275,
0.16057351231575012,
0.11021490395069122,
0.9907740354537964,
0.10521192103624344,
-0.1884521245956421,
0.3691011667251587,
-0.19328461587429047,
0.11329147219657898,
0.7011349201202393,
0.598547637462616,
0.12902820110321045,
-0.3633384108543396,
0.10238102078437805,
0.2978021800518036,
-0.9317964315414429,
0.13792458176612854,
0.2720860540866852,
-0.6853296756744385,
-0.07819109410047531,
0.3338124752044678,
0.4588039219379425,
0.13090309500694275,
-0.36428311467170715,
0.2543315589427948,
-0.5753715634346008,
-0.15269549190998077,
-0.18878595530986786,
0.17538192868232727,
-0.23349905014038086,
0.07951433956623077,
0.27262982726097107,
0.5575737953186035,
0.4055338501930237,
-0.23492108285427094,
0.3053806722164154,
0.5037007331848145,
-0.33064141869544983,
-0.07407081127166748,
0.6987566351890564,
-0.2140812873840332,
-0.5318593382835388,
0.3186512589454651,
0.002799004316329956,
-0.499402791261673,
0.5719291567802429,
0.7620974779129028,
1.0292032957077026,
-0.3962048292160034,
0.06954976916313171,
0.36481839418411255,
0.7729771137237549,
0.027087245136499405,
-0.26080358028411865,
0.025650575757026672,
-0.7698136568069458,
-0.2768227458000183,
-0.306186705827713,
-0.5891270637512207,
0.16903099417686462,
-0.7457148432731628,
0.08716453611850739,
-0.8033847212791443,
-0.05593688040971756,
0.16345886886119843,
-0.1436559557914734,
-0.26722094416618347,
0.39511996507644653,
-0.1955496072769165,
0.9551659822463989,
-0.6901425123214722,
0.7059427499771118,
0.7237954139709473,
-0.2832149565219879,
-0.1036769449710846,
0.40247219800949097,
0.04091764613986015,
-0.46774038672447205,
0.42035913467407227,
0.07291628420352936,
-0.16973967850208282,
-0.13027817010879517,
-0.27827656269073486,
-0.39376100897789,
0.689537763595581,
0.16852723062038422,
-0.4097754955291748,
0.10152514278888702,
-0.024963241070508957,
0.5591521263122559,
0.16516107320785522,
0.17735423147678375,
0.4485119581222534,
0.4613734185695648,
-0.15609028935432434,
-0.41773414611816406,
0.010357530787587166,
-0.2537539303302765,
0.1382116675376892,
0.44815266132354736,
-0.2024419605731964,
0.6706868410110474,
-0.3132506310939789,
-0.40686556696891785,
0.09755196422338486,
0.8074377775192261,
0.34095701575279236,
0.35368579626083374,
0.7264989614486694,
1.0421156883239746,
0.5118786096572876,
0.15342000126838684,
1.0439858436584473,
0.07161912322044373,
0.2425612211227417,
1.1293669939041138,
-0.14469054341316223,
0.9594339728355408,
0.4593670666217804,
-0.33599627017974854,
0.4947592318058014,
0.31658628582954407,
0.07120848447084427,
0.424113005399704,
0.3421214818954468,
-0.21393950283527374,
0.0011326244566589594,
0.4481199085712433,
-0.3996123969554901,
0.22147227823734283,
0.42273926734924316,
-0.24370135366916656,
-0.3672184944152832,
0.012488044798374176,
0.5259646773338318,
0.3598949611186981,
-0.3184828758239746,
0.7240185737609863,
-0.3295786380767822,
-0.424505352973938,
0.6518993973731995,
0.4308929145336151,
0.8165448904037476,
-0.6966071128845215,
-0.15008839964866638,
-0.003976225387305021,
0.34381362795829773,
-0.21968358755111694,
-0.5382940173149109,
0.44661733508110046,
0.08637981861829758,
-0.3413509726524353,
-0.03569261357188225,
0.8048452734947205,
-0.08456030488014221,
-0.4855423867702484,
0.23356226086616516,
0.04943789169192314,
0.023780900985002518,
0.0626847967505455,
-0.7386369705200195,
-0.3066273331642151,
0.07887176424264908,
-0.3703445792198181,
0.48609715700149536,
0.08459622412919998,
0.3543744385242462,
0.7338697910308838,
0.8754297494888306,
0.23886363208293915,
0.00688813766464591,
0.2669897675514221,
0.8090789318084717,
-0.6785510778427124,
-0.5520180463790894,
-0.9333609342575073,
0.23105646669864655,
-0.02807709202170372,
-0.08285177499055862,
0.9824876189231873,
0.6560308337211609,
0.7518119215965271,
-0.09984167665243149,
0.9129197001457214,
0.2401813268661499,
0.5945446491241455,
-0.6528245806694031,
0.767673909664154,
-0.2748628556728363,
0.4291388988494873,
-0.5123215317726135,
-0.6642847061157227,
-0.7276723384857178,
0.5092049241065979,
-0.19638174772262573,
-0.24459686875343323,
0.6575887799263,
0.8887057900428772,
0.16015273332595825,
-0.07179182022809982,
0.485659658908844,
0.3486781418323517,
0.7056154012680054,
0.49204879999160767,
0.670833945274353,
-0.8327872157096863,
0.5968654751777649,
-0.06911901384592056,
-0.2665809392929077,
-0.17675335705280304,
-0.9237121939659119,
-1.103569746017456,
-0.3873997926712036,
-0.4615752398967743,
-0.40185925364494324,
0.4133925437927246,
0.604828417301178,
0.27551698684692383,
-0.7508998513221741,
0.17236489057540894,
-0.4369116425514221,
0.3870241045951843,
-0.31797531247138977,
-0.35524407029151917,
0.22297337651252747,
-0.34975364804267883,
-0.6054556965827942,
0.9321658611297607,
0.2673736810684204,
0.12362246960401535,
-0.10128438472747803,
0.20763204991817474,
-0.36638346314430237,
0.44138115644454956,
0.352660208940506,
0.5983502864837646,
-0.2962113916873932,
-0.26349353790283203,
-0.3556532859802246,
0.08079580962657928,
-0.004875956568866968,
0.8332455158233643,
-0.9648773670196533,
0.42420494556427,
0.6443450450897217,
0.9179737567901611,
0.2319106161594391,
0.04472332447767258,
0.17840297520160675,
-0.7530321478843689,
0.20991763472557068,
0.17014478147029877,
0.3896690309047699,
0.25410541892051697,
-0.2575642168521881,
0.3671036660671234,
0.2930808365345001,
-0.4986633062362671,
-0.7201117873191833,
0.3530976176261902,
-0.8704535961151123,
-0.4593581259250641,
0.8094218969345093,
-0.07304050773382187,
-0.14622065424919128,
-0.2828403413295746,
-0.2539743483066559,
0.17805762588977814,
-0.3112419545650482,
0.978798508644104,
0.4733249247074127,
0.1943274587392807,
0.0975065529346466,
-0.3200508654117584,
0.31797870993614197,
0.2839342951774597,
-0.9137486219406128,
0.1366754025220871,
0.37761765718460083,
0.16955770552158356,
0.3400256037712097,
0.3809411823749542,
-0.23183105885982513,
0.26156386733055115,
0.1448262333869934,
-0.11811282485723495,
-0.14335237443447113,
-0.26557794213294983,
-0.6663098335266113,
0.43404287099838257,
-0.009016684256494045,
-0.30977463722229004
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15482v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15482v1
|
Multi-Level Feedback Generation with Large Language Models for Empowering Novice Peer Counselors
| 2024-03-21T04:23:56 | 2024-03-21T04:23:56 |
Alicja Chaszczewicz, Raj Sanjay Shah, Ryan Louie, Bruce A Arnow, Robert Kraut, Diyi Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.LG
|
Realistic practice and tailored feedback are key processes for training peer
counselors with clinical skills. However, existing mechanisms of providing
feedback largely rely on human supervision. Peer counselors often lack
mechanisms to receive detailed feedback from experienced mentors, making it
difficult for them to support the large number of people with mental health
issues who use peer counseling. Our work aims to leverage large language models
to provide contextualized and multi-level feedback to empower peer counselors,
especially novices, at scale. To achieve this, we co-design with a group of
senior psychotherapy supervisors to develop a multi-level feedback taxonomy,
and then construct a publicly available dataset with comprehensive feedback
annotations of 400 emotional support conversations. We further design a
self-improvement method on top of large language models to enhance the
automatic generation of feedback. Via qualitative and quantitative evaluation
with domain experts, we demonstrate that our method minimizes the risk of
potentially harmful and low-quality feedback generation which is desirable in
such high-stakes scenarios.
|
[
-0.39187362790107727,
-0.6159265041351318,
0.6440877318382263,
0.5157872438430786,
0.24452875554561615,
0.08573487401008606,
-0.268624484539032,
-0.2646312713623047,
0.14397962391376495,
0.2619084119796753,
-0.6803570985794067,
-0.4785076677799225,
-0.6225016713142395,
0.15515519678592682,
-0.08727670460939407,
1.2198140621185303,
0.08784636855125427,
0.4453088045120239,
0.0912405252456665,
0.18911024928092957,
-0.6807583570480347,
-0.4513760805130005,
-0.9719516634941101,
-0.17899470031261444,
0.7009530663490295,
0.6789478063583374,
0.22235415875911713,
-0.08030322939157486,
0.41980451345443726,
0.3377912640571594,
-0.05158495903015137,
0.09937410056591034,
-0.5713444352149963,
0.09631741791963577,
-0.25025901198387146,
-0.24560365080833435,
-1.1113401651382446,
-0.07924862205982208,
0.5032997131347656,
0.7173392176628113,
-0.5454632639884949,
0.35553252696990967,
0.4079741835594177,
0.570178210735321,
-0.5886642932891846,
0.2715786099433899,
-0.3213001489639282,
0.09313642233610153,
0.036181047558784485,
-0.027559883892536163,
-0.641284167766571,
-0.15597665309906006,
0.08979928493499756,
-0.38079047203063965,
0.31204935908317566,
-0.01684863679111004,
0.09160163998603821,
0.11807647347450256,
-0.7005871534347534,
-0.10292269289493561,
-0.7897024154663086,
0.6099925637245178,
-1.0001145601272583,
0.10635882616043091,
0.4672623574733734,
0.3399507701396942,
-0.16991139948368073,
-0.49685099720954895,
-0.1314612179994583,
-0.40582939982414246,
-0.28298547863960266,
0.11653005331754684,
0.01733921281993389,
0.2815490663051605,
0.38882705569267273,
0.11357222497463226,
0.08019901812076569,
-0.012316710315644741,
-0.360942006111145,
-0.033502865582704544,
0.7269423007965088,
0.37187880277633667,
0.0794539749622345,
-0.08893343806266785,
0.14626824855804443,
0.2281321883201599,
-0.40856269001960754,
0.06019708514213562,
0.14707215130329132,
0.26950305700302124,
-0.05290251970291138,
0.4082759618759155,
-0.14352118968963623,
0.40749484300613403,
0.43888744711875916,
-0.4004255533218384,
0.022497860714793205,
-0.28735676407814026,
0.36070388555526733,
0.10454653203487396,
0.7244074940681458,
0.7101398706436157,
-0.05970675125718117,
-0.21785227954387665,
-0.19034476578235626,
-0.2507605254650116,
0.5429642200469971,
-0.7643301486968994,
-0.17738261818885803,
0.20968659222126007,
-0.5743371248245239,
-0.24915039539337158,
-0.1056763231754303,
-1.1031732559204102,
-0.45397692918777466,
-0.3842636048793793,
0.297270268201828,
-0.24367362260818481,
-0.501170814037323,
-0.02653968334197998,
0.06332046538591385,
-0.09176918864250183,
0.5534144639968872,
-0.7493818998336792,
0.4580110013484955,
0.35607045888900757,
0.9343342185020447,
0.041799481958150864,
-0.35236456990242004,
-0.6083072423934937,
0.485512912273407,
-0.13901250064373016,
0.6201720237731934,
-0.5635879635810852,
-0.3536749482154846,
0.05506793409585953,
0.12434635311365128,
0.33891913294792175,
-0.2207542359828949,
0.30885690450668335,
0.1313844472169876,
0.3424847722053528,
-0.3821280002593994,
-0.3736831247806549,
0.5099827647209167,
0.15569402277469635,
-0.16428972780704498,
0.8120875358581543,
0.22934095561504364,
-0.830264151096344,
0.361712783575058,
-0.6638926863670349,
-0.11518684029579163,
0.2294437289237976,
0.07065936923027039,
-0.11466026306152344,
0.3074484169483185,
0.42176246643066406,
0.47450247406959534,
-0.21038953959941864,
0.2751926779747009,
-0.5491979718208313,
-0.07394973188638687,
-0.038594238460063934,
-0.05994705110788345,
0.060875922441482544,
-0.04561718925833702,
-0.4982721507549286,
0.3543320596218109,
-0.7939583659172058,
0.12958981096744537,
-0.14754392206668854,
-0.2841508388519287,
-0.2832549214363098,
-0.2027110606431961,
0.12863345444202423,
0.3421732783317566,
0.02013213559985161,
-0.7876341342926025,
0.29227152466773987,
-0.11079658567905426,
0.4533652067184448,
0.7083019614219666,
0.39457207918167114,
0.24509723484516144,
-0.09549181163311005,
0.6347585320472717,
-0.012356606312096119,
0.25815126299858093,
-0.3795444369316101,
-0.24307101964950562,
-0.5096323490142822,
-0.0518861748278141,
-0.06933575123548508,
0.04849710687994957,
-0.7767466902732849,
0.25230464339256287,
0.04265276715159416,
-0.7021185755729675,
-0.5065961480140686,
0.3491523265838623,
0.5200461745262146,
0.46868523955345154,
0.3918059468269348,
-0.42258644104003906,
-0.39666420221328735,
-0.6579903364181519,
-0.2258167713880539,
-0.006711362395435572,
-0.08205316215753555,
0.11183138936758041,
0.4259464144706726,
-0.25897327065467834,
0.8585183620452881,
-0.5366083383560181,
-0.5789037942886353,
-0.2894749939441681,
0.24280503392219543,
-0.18898603320121765,
0.6493107676506042,
0.3820054829120636,
-0.06498207151889801,
-0.5363025665283203,
-0.2689701020717621,
-0.5427564382553101,
-0.2767011821269989,
-0.09365049004554749,
-0.243058979511261,
-0.40061303973197937,
0.6231530904769897,
-0.02621060237288475,
0.04331511631608009,
0.4744163751602173,
-0.5270189642906189,
0.43607792258262634,
-0.5226020812988281,
0.06284938752651215,
-1.046135663986206,
-0.08043301850557327,
0.3034777343273163,
-0.2061997354030609,
-0.6626582145690918,
-0.1630176305770874,
-0.10859984159469604,
-0.29668018221855164,
-0.14695024490356445,
0.20331710577011108,
-0.37243080139160156,
0.4324192404747009,
-0.28291037678718567,
0.05319909751415253,
-0.3460143208503723,
0.7239829897880554,
0.008558418601751328,
0.34053927659988403,
0.48647767305374146,
-0.19307099282741547,
0.6642557382583618,
0.20816610753536224,
0.045894719660282135,
1.1191080808639526,
-0.9680978655815125,
0.2016490250825882,
-0.18069922924041748,
0.685521125793457,
-0.8004498481750488,
-0.3395051062107086,
0.0075582582503557205,
-0.1087409183382988,
0.34293508529663086,
-0.2156023383140564,
-0.2496795654296875,
-0.57138592004776,
-0.1722440868616104,
0.25398990511894226,
-0.04792889207601547,
-0.13468456268310547,
0.295266330242157,
0.46254199743270874,
-0.5996008515357971,
-0.4372867941856384,
-0.2814900577068329,
0.3324326276779175,
0.05181428790092468,
-0.41070348024368286,
0.029851187020540237,
-0.1935930848121643,
-0.0204843208193779,
-0.24743132293224335,
0.15910474956035614,
0.1252504587173462,
-0.20588667690753937,
0.5394450426101685,
-0.15939265489578247,
0.09107626229524612,
0.31128591299057007,
0.40507134795188904,
-0.3348960280418396,
0.4166317284107208,
-0.11944182962179184,
0.5807427167892456,
-0.7070173025131226,
-0.6216597557067871,
-0.46694687008857727,
0.6910209655761719,
0.5195774435997009,
-0.2617705762386322,
0.7756282091140747,
0.7159273028373718,
-0.31702807545661926,
-0.236159548163414,
-0.7080085873603821,
-0.4537811875343323,
-0.4526275396347046,
0.39420345425605774,
-0.22499661147594452,
-0.9633493423461914,
0.22036616504192352,
-0.17943134903907776,
0.22691358625888824,
-0.04507783427834511,
0.7570005059242249,
0.07346685975790024,
1.4840168952941895,
0.6603025197982788,
0.22559377551078796,
0.37169963121414185,
-0.38246479630470276,
0.15722744166851044,
-0.7789875864982605,
-0.38220977783203125,
-0.3147183656692505,
-0.37079551815986633,
-0.17789225280284882,
-0.0530397891998291,
0.5079460740089417,
-0.03227359056472778,
-0.37702080607414246,
0.1442856341600418,
-0.6364924907684326,
0.10658338665962219,
0.6440173983573914,
0.4317111074924469,
0.2715288996696472,
-0.3442763686180115,
-0.16012080013751984,
-0.4564492404460907,
-0.7018002867698669,
-0.38056790828704834,
1.0350946187973022,
0.5842714309692383,
0.956739068031311,
0.06473905593156815,
0.7896377444267273,
0.1050160825252533,
0.710566520690918,
-0.6643894910812378,
0.35582229495048523,
0.4422876536846161,
-0.49561893939971924,
-0.4061300456523895,
-0.5061725974082947,
-0.6156454682350159,
0.2570618987083435,
-0.24207206070423126,
-0.573341429233551,
0.3323505222797394,
0.2529102861881256,
-0.45377928018569946,
0.0877256914973259,
-0.6314007639884949,
0.7574642300605774,
-0.10828306525945663,
-0.46427372097969055,
-0.428103506565094,
-0.6894238591194153,
0.2660628855228424,
-0.26169106364250183,
0.41027647256851196,
-0.08293482661247253,
0.10853996872901917,
0.691472053527832,
-0.9264405369758606,
1.1424381732940674,
-0.4895423948764801,
-0.5819945335388184,
0.02151014469563961,
0.19604690372943878,
0.24863409996032715,
0.37760764360427856,
0.2494594007730484,
-0.3924526572227478,
0.425776869058609,
-0.4499606192111969,
-0.6310102343559265,
0.5521601438522339,
-0.8186987638473511,
-0.6696375608444214,
0.09102839231491089,
-0.5844426155090332,
-0.6920762658119202,
0.12907984852790833,
0.23309138417243958,
0.5972286462783813,
0.09457412362098694,
0.29190802574157715,
0.09014282375574112,
-0.23728853464126587,
0.22249774634838104,
0.6526675224304199,
-0.24503983557224274,
-0.6557137966156006,
0.7058227062225342,
0.17148059606552124,
0.2704593241214752,
-0.30866745114326477,
0.17742173373699188,
0.002333753276616335,
-0.09110409021377563,
-0.08714203536510468,
0.32218706607818604,
-0.6899597644805908,
-0.16067413985729218,
-0.594517707824707,
0.008749945089221,
-0.7140864729881287,
-0.2434079349040985,
-0.43815672397613525,
-0.304019570350647,
0.26030075550079346,
-0.23591248691082,
0.2081841677427292,
1.0778945684432983,
-0.35186129808425903,
0.6531252264976501,
-1.0106287002563477,
0.05124153196811676,
0.4862464964389801,
0.39913731813430786,
0.6697431206703186,
-0.16461007297039032,
-0.5343140363693237,
0.016403086483478546,
-0.5520460605621338,
-1.1279990673065186,
0.3264862895011902,
0.20725978910923004,
0.362158864736557,
0.5426648259162903,
0.16610148549079895,
0.670488715171814,
-0.516690194606781,
0.7502122521400452,
0.4510886073112488,
-1.14778470993042,
0.9517533779144287,
-0.46100053191185,
0.27662888169288635,
0.6326501369476318,
0.2576039731502533,
-0.7849889993667603,
-0.8064417243003845,
-0.5566499829292297,
-0.8259735703468323,
0.8257086277008057,
-0.07531062513589859,
0.29794055223464966,
0.023572875186800957,
0.597218930721283,
-0.08399587869644165,
0.42458218336105347,
-0.8957436680793762,
-0.04853847995400429,
-0.3781421482563019,
-0.08034826815128326,
0.14054985344409943,
-0.4231601655483246,
-0.5729498863220215,
-0.340373158454895,
0.49487748742103577,
-0.3335307538509369,
0.14763721823692322,
0.2580086886882782,
0.3145463764667511,
-0.6659508347511292,
0.42572709918022156,
0.2312716841697693,
0.7547054290771484,
-0.014382008463144302,
0.17033453285694122,
0.4718945026397705,
-0.341454416513443,
0.45454660058021545,
-0.3287273347377777,
0.19906805455684662,
-0.06687293201684952,
0.5488196611404419,
0.603645920753479,
0.4273107349872589,
-0.28632399439811707,
0.6000804305076599,
-0.24394172430038452,
-0.14044788479804993,
-0.22387520968914032,
0.09960976243019104,
0.015334030613303185,
0.19315506517887115,
0.2769889533519745,
-0.24296967685222626,
0.11964712291955948,
-0.5151312947273254,
0.23102527856826782,
0.257489949464798,
-0.7224680781364441,
-0.35847342014312744,
0.5649517178535461,
0.5046052932739258,
-0.300948828458786,
0.3734460473060608,
0.1397765874862671,
-0.23707416653633118,
0.23715879023075104,
0.6424082517623901,
0.5914974212646484,
-0.33683133125305176,
0.5083798170089722,
0.5303785800933838,
0.1383327841758728,
-0.1721901297569275,
0.10677486658096313,
-0.15372265875339508,
-0.28019484877586365,
-0.5661922097206116,
-0.45911964774131775,
-0.6204892992973328,
-0.1936647742986679,
-1.2477308511734009,
0.14345979690551758,
-0.5534391403198242,
-0.590481698513031,
-0.30135589838027954,
-0.042113397270441055,
-0.36868050694465637,
-0.01937056891620159,
0.04267226904630661,
0.6757404208183289,
-0.726687490940094,
0.5888032913208008,
0.8253511190414429,
-0.5538455843925476,
-0.9497626423835754,
-0.07227730751037598,
0.0982050895690918,
-0.40763765573501587,
0.6955884695053101,
0.12676659226417542,
-0.05435755476355553,
0.07730904221534729,
-0.6442059278488159,
-0.7199555039405823,
1.0024486780166626,
0.38494107127189636,
-0.5192326903343201,
-0.5679320693016052,
0.11869102716445923,
1.0400749444961548,
-0.5138241648674011,
0.5498784780502319,
0.3298328220844269,
0.427443265914917,
0.0230431966483593,
-1.0412776470184326,
0.1271323263645172,
-0.448556125164032,
0.20858214795589447,
-0.10156664997339249,
-0.7957013249397278,
0.5513786673545837,
-0.29788175225257874,
0.07370787858963013,
-0.06436876952648163,
0.6413028836250305,
0.1405920833349228,
-0.04828609526157379,
0.6511770486831665,
0.5017923712730408,
0.5524996519088745,
0.060423437505960464,
0.8208058476448059,
-0.7570070028305054,
0.40787220001220703,
1.3782440423965454,
-0.1537572294473648,
0.6397694945335388,
0.318888396024704,
0.03301452100276947,
0.7084726691246033,
0.37317296862602234,
-0.06139848753809929,
0.19138984382152557,
0.13958513736724854,
-0.21535757184028625,
-0.39022913575172424,
-0.4155583083629608,
-0.5020996332168579,
0.035096462815999985,
0.3502720594406128,
-0.31311774253845215,
-0.14494897425174713,
0.27915409207344055,
-0.005756448023021221,
-0.053234465420246124,
-0.4665091931819916,
0.8467391729354858,
0.37226641178131104,
-0.5875734090805054,
0.2347407042980194,
-0.06307968497276306,
0.37849292159080505,
-0.5448099970817566,
-0.10668525099754333,
-0.1717153787612915,
0.4385378062725067,
-0.5070362687110901,
-0.5481088757514954,
0.018105609342455864,
0.08527928590774536,
0.06102104112505913,
-0.5330501198768616,
0.4860437512397766,
-0.5320363640785217,
-0.45159652829170227,
0.49529576301574707,
0.7280122637748718,
-0.265724241733551,
0.05056251958012581,
-0.5105304718017578,
-0.49589285254478455,
-0.43537643551826477,
-0.3700770139694214,
0.44909265637397766,
0.6025657653808594,
0.15887178480625153,
0.7777682542800903,
0.6187364459037781,
0.600753903388977,
0.0325331836938858,
0.33329951763153076,
0.8940757513046265,
-0.42940959334373474,
-0.31484439969062805,
-0.6054815649986267,
0.3751770853996277,
-0.19407504796981812,
-0.4954265058040619,
1.0543365478515625,
-0.029432572424411774,
0.6469025611877441,
-0.003768743947148323,
0.601796567440033,
-0.021160922944545746,
0.5674251914024353,
0.027786873281002045,
0.527562141418457,
-0.5587639212608337,
0.10291026532649994,
-0.7660083174705505,
-0.9123988151550293,
-0.2086506187915802,
0.382087379693985,
-0.3552100658416748,
0.0874338373541832,
0.5872350335121155,
0.6434996128082275,
0.33349743485450745,
-0.1549665629863739,
0.1432924121618271,
0.4999512732028961,
0.7079237699508667,
0.4981066882610321,
0.9327133297920227,
0.06371212750673294,
0.3968554139137268,
-0.44422200322151184,
-0.3453649580478668,
0.1526840329170227,
-0.6868714690208435,
-0.8424454927444458,
-0.371603786945343,
-0.2693707048892975,
-0.47261208295822144,
-0.27047857642173767,
1.1476584672927856,
0.8674401044845581,
-0.7986380457878113,
-0.2839173674583435,
-0.06171788275241852,
-0.29594019055366516,
-0.11985000967979431,
-0.24298197031021118,
0.05279777944087982,
-0.6774256229400635,
-0.5744759440422058,
0.19392769038677216,
0.2927568256855011,
-0.13135354220867157,
-0.7968658804893494,
-0.12545548379421234,
0.32046592235565186,
-0.28151825070381165,
0.5812897086143494,
-0.17370955646038055,
-0.587016224861145,
-0.20894576609134674,
-0.23851962387561798,
-0.11298757791519165,
-0.08224420249462128,
1.127813458442688,
-0.540360689163208,
0.34477517008781433,
0.22453215718269348,
0.23722855746746063,
0.17456111311912537,
-0.023741507902741432,
1.047070860862732,
-0.7789381742477417,
0.04357375577092171,
0.13997015357017517,
0.5654245615005493,
0.22158628702163696,
-0.48314201831817627,
0.5208858847618103,
0.04012342169880867,
-0.6417086720466614,
-0.8755414485931396,
0.055825747549533844,
-0.5062006711959839,
-0.1195266991853714,
1.0196630954742432,
-0.5977479219436646,
0.2365194708108902,
-0.10741958767175674,
-0.9211711287498474,
0.13902337849140167,
-0.579859733581543,
0.9492713212966919,
0.8257437348365784,
-0.24959078431129456,
-0.49508175253868103,
-0.2099217027425766,
0.5285689234733582,
0.5116187930107117,
-0.8621845245361328,
0.16593553125858307,
0.605073094367981,
0.11097125709056854,
0.2488233894109726,
0.7288747429847717,
-0.06994905322790146,
0.06409332156181335,
-0.05530315265059471,
0.19259139895439148,
0.010205731727182865,
-0.48084700107574463,
-0.3732202649116516,
0.47284698486328125,
0.2136065512895584,
0.7799727916717529
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14119v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14119v3
|
C-TPT: Calibrated Test-Time Prompt Tuning for Vision-Language Models via Text Feature Dispersion
| 2024-03-21T04:08:29 | 2024-03-31T13:36:54 |
Hee Suk Yoon, Eunseop Yoon, Joshua Tian Jin Tee, Mark Hasegawa-Johnson, Yingzhen Li, Chang D. Yoo
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In deep learning, test-time adaptation has gained attention as a method for
model fine-tuning without the need for labeled data. A prime exemplification is
the recently proposed test-time prompt tuning for large-scale vision-language
models such as CLIP. Unfortunately, these prompts have been mainly developed to
improve accuracy, overlooking the importance of calibration, which is a crucial
aspect for quantifying prediction uncertainty. However, traditional calibration
methods rely on substantial amounts of labeled data, making them impractical
for test-time scenarios. To this end, this paper explores calibration during
test-time prompt tuning by leveraging the inherent properties of CLIP. Through
a series of observations, we find that the prompt choice significantly affects
the calibration in CLIP, where the prompts leading to higher text feature
dispersion result in better-calibrated predictions. Introducing the Average
Text Feature Dispersion (ATFD), we establish its relationship with calibration
error and present a novel method, Calibrated Test-time Prompt Tuning (C-TPT),
for optimizing prompts during test-time with enhanced calibration. Through
extensive experiments on different CLIP architectures and datasets, we show
that C-TPT can effectively improve the calibration of test-time prompt tuning
without needing labeled data. The code is publicly accessible at
https://github.com/hee-suk-yoon/C-TPT.
|
[
-0.37125805020332336,
-0.6305649280548096,
0.6602011919021606,
0.2981469929218292,
-0.481138676404953,
0.4710713028907776,
-0.3925206661224365,
-0.13259348273277283,
-0.12322260439395905,
0.07867573946714401,
-0.6725955009460449,
-0.3912166357040405,
-0.5302690863609314,
0.04202566668391228,
-0.07666540890932083,
0.6756138205528259,
-0.09423063695430756,
0.17832781374454498,
0.191789448261261,
-0.0654992163181305,
-0.6632034182548523,
-0.3423120975494385,
-0.47539713978767395,
-0.01831991784274578,
0.38967862725257874,
0.5211865305900574,
0.7595937848091125,
0.7790933847427368,
0.2271842509508133,
0.10572304576635361,
-0.21186408400535583,
0.3095422387123108,
-0.28096556663513184,
-0.18461301922798157,
-0.24019469320774078,
-0.4464004337787628,
-0.17795972526073456,
-0.09884484112262726,
0.7923938035964966,
0.6611927151679993,
0.12640316784381866,
0.0838177427649498,
0.5099373459815979,
0.4066697955131531,
-0.8814095854759216,
0.18358254432678223,
-0.5586268305778503,
0.03330492228269577,
-0.14629554748535156,
-0.6834728717803955,
-0.5207134485244751,
-0.4880690574645996,
0.26053187251091003,
-0.7690361738204956,
0.5616480708122253,
0.259712815284729,
0.703359842300415,
0.5433763265609741,
-0.4256458580493927,
0.02211492881178856,
-0.5560978651046753,
0.9959284663200378,
-0.42818355560302734,
0.31543856859207153,
0.2998347580432892,
0.5482733249664307,
-0.14147250354290009,
-0.019651668146252632,
-0.5016379952430725,
-0.12991243600845337,
0.3236904442310333,
-0.007912141270935535,
0.11486975103616714,
0.256304532289505,
0.48666179180145264,
0.27937135100364685,
-0.4887157678604126,
0.261042982339859,
-0.0411110483109951,
-0.3656851053237915,
0.3075345754623413,
0.18082255125045776,
0.12252279371023178,
0.010885439813137054,
-0.37921929359436035,
-0.7646746635437012,
-0.487911581993103,
0.21889068186283112,
0.19654163718223572,
0.39662966132164,
-0.1680121123790741,
0.492689847946167,
0.3014620542526245,
0.8222522139549255,
0.2918411195278168,
-0.09967992454767227,
0.14130790531635284,
-0.429526686668396,
0.012798655778169632,
0.24899707734584808,
0.5933650135993958,
0.5990092158317566,
0.4478844404220581,
0.2946113049983978,
0.02706233039498329,
0.08462443202733994,
-0.0687335878610611,
-1.0664864778518677,
-0.20747587084770203,
-0.06375954300165176,
-0.11727528274059296,
-0.5160622000694275,
-0.14313910901546478,
-0.9886545538902283,
-0.5332034826278687,
-0.3008726239204407,
0.45892471075057983,
-0.3901887536048889,
-0.10731048136949539,
0.21875636279582977,
-0.43406474590301514,
0.19316427409648895,
0.40271785855293274,
-0.9065955281257629,
0.08853881061077118,
0.4913421869277954,
0.8452772498130798,
-0.3452880084514618,
-0.32209593057632446,
-0.7700561285018921,
-0.11531469970941544,
-0.49404391646385193,
0.6692573428153992,
-0.5476948618888855,
-0.5400534868240356,
-0.11460074782371521,
0.03801124915480614,
-0.27274227142333984,
-0.2775743901729584,
0.30784571170806885,
-0.26837921142578125,
0.08320767432451248,
-0.5310521721839905,
-0.3751045763492584,
-0.05211890488862991,
0.419938325881958,
-0.5239517092704773,
0.9242009520530701,
0.2801080048084259,
-0.5435547232627869,
0.6499456167221069,
-0.4042341709136963,
-0.30365437269210815,
0.07922426611185074,
-0.06164126098155975,
-0.31335556507110596,
0.16042421758174896,
0.7643095850944519,
0.19502805173397064,
-0.2995525002479553,
0.2062511146068573,
-0.7555714249610901,
-0.591123104095459,
0.3736611008644104,
-0.6305590867996216,
0.8134584426879883,
0.032434914261102676,
-0.39668309688568115,
-0.13766390085220337,
-0.6961424350738525,
0.24736382067203522,
-0.12200625240802765,
0.024998003616929054,
-0.22038806974887848,
0.11792009323835373,
0.030131066218018532,
-0.19850985705852509,
-0.09285127371549606,
-0.5790404081344604,
0.20092564821243286,
-0.6535022258758545,
0.6014748215675354,
0.6351423263549805,
0.2659216821193695,
0.38866400718688965,
-0.3432672321796417,
0.6979814171791077,
0.0633673220872879,
0.2507747411727905,
-0.44328537583351135,
-0.28174638748168945,
-0.526042103767395,
-0.11287511140108109,
0.22228728234767914,
0.8204874992370605,
-0.7661409974098206,
0.21827249228954315,
-0.19446894526481628,
-0.4688256084918976,
-0.2241223305463791,
-0.13960504531860352,
0.3860023319721222,
0.88930344581604,
0.35803860425949097,
-0.0698385015130043,
-0.2339784950017929,
-0.5919415354728699,
-0.2920023202896118,
-0.28151988983154297,
-0.20803558826446533,
0.47055110335350037,
0.09321945905685425,
0.40454941987991333,
1.0102216005325317,
-0.8076624274253845,
-0.2461574226617813,
-0.042849741876125336,
-0.07527045160531998,
0.23947729170322418,
0.19638371467590332,
0.8895862102508545,
-0.7802949547767639,
-0.45278725028038025,
-0.5305860638618469,
0.07827787846326828,
-0.4487241804599762,
-0.1056707426905632,
0.1033831238746643,
0.04518526792526245,
0.2286701500415802,
-0.015352771617472172,
0.5236577391624451,
0.622860848903656,
-0.6592916250228882,
0.7404919862747192,
-0.23973269760608673,
0.6098616123199463,
-1.1169755458831787,
-0.11745385080575943,
0.06365523487329483,
-0.3474567234516144,
-0.19013524055480957,
-0.3172336220741272,
0.43548864126205444,
-0.29978591203689575,
-0.6679341197013855,
0.7898149490356445,
-0.14475880563259125,
0.19145750999450684,
-0.38535332679748535,
0.2212933897972107,
0.5808873176574707,
0.3448799252510071,
-0.011358958669006824,
1.1380656957626343,
0.3688091039657593,
-0.8121444582939148,
0.17745867371559143,
0.48566123843193054,
-0.2777543067932129,
0.7156917452812195,
-0.598229169845581,
-0.07573576271533966,
0.17767660319805145,
0.11520502716302872,
-0.9685661792755127,
-0.01944592222571373,
0.27337682247161865,
-0.4405805170536041,
0.4228915572166443,
-0.2505195140838623,
-0.6475170850753784,
-0.32676878571510315,
-0.5125104784965515,
1.0033375024795532,
0.3879031538963318,
-0.7561280131340027,
0.34105774760246277,
0.07553354650735855,
0.10762229561805725,
-0.56248539686203,
-0.8027560710906982,
-0.08518148958683014,
-0.11813186854124069,
-0.36770740151405334,
0.707390308380127,
-0.3369884788990021,
0.24000702798366547,
-0.42501169443130493,
-0.06240198388695717,
-0.1955849677324295,
0.15976347029209137,
0.1943804770708084,
0.38600003719329834,
-0.030065208673477173,
0.3376410901546478,
0.3526521623134613,
-0.058053310960531235,
-0.1014186441898346,
-0.20577482879161835,
0.4934852421283722,
0.1962890625,
-0.32681262493133545,
-0.4522683620452881,
0.10275987535715103,
0.3376111686229706,
-0.18987402319908142,
0.4403327703475952,
0.37028709053993225,
-0.25823456048965454,
-0.4911501407623291,
-0.4087393283843994,
-0.17090052366256714,
-0.5078028440475464,
0.40235984325408936,
-0.29037749767303467,
-0.7483729124069214,
0.361104279756546,
0.0543300025165081,
-0.15848875045776367,
0.4117029905319214,
0.41578951478004456,
-0.15890128910541534,
1.0325971841812134,
0.8796961307525635,
0.03311543166637421,
1.0037952661514282,
0.03532176837325096,
-0.06419126689434052,
-0.7553321123123169,
0.07256234437227249,
-0.625669002532959,
-0.39073875546455383,
-0.4176643192768097,
-0.4610046446323395,
0.4428810179233551,
0.03210759907960892,
-0.45663297176361084,
0.38329654932022095,
-0.6900452971458435,
0.5703814625740051,
0.3561016023159027,
0.4712262451648712,
0.1257198005914688,
-0.1345735341310501,
-0.2302490770816803,
-0.5853270292282104,
-0.38401156663894653,
-0.18818017840385437,
0.8830176591873169,
0.31250593066215515,
0.792482852935791,
-0.39621901512145996,
0.02433711290359497,
0.3306613564491272,
-0.31936097145080566,
-0.8052304983139038,
0.45957592129707336,
-0.35398778319358826,
-0.27842557430267334,
-0.013507834635674953,
-0.2621212303638458,
-0.40443581342697144,
-0.21551233530044556,
-0.14894743263721466,
-0.7344707250595093,
0.4697267413139343,
0.6278392672538757,
-0.5363914966583252,
0.22119742631912231,
-0.8730921149253845,
0.912979781627655,
-0.30129504203796387,
0.009338119998574257,
-0.09719257056713104,
-0.268792062997818,
-0.09917547553777695,
-0.16340413689613342,
-0.19277101755142212,
-0.23977965116500854,
-0.26519346237182617,
0.4863698184490204,
-0.2991611659526825,
0.9546576738357544,
-0.46708762645721436,
-0.0057316976599395275,
0.23735164105892181,
0.26138514280319214,
0.5158443450927734,
0.18826919794082642,
-0.10551080107688904,
-0.03937523066997528,
0.37978488206863403,
-0.16772131621837616,
-0.6104715466499329,
0.37377628684043884,
-0.5611021518707275,
-0.29959291219711304,
-0.3530275821685791,
-0.6048101186752319,
-0.30153295397758484,
0.17850607633590698,
0.4139033257961273,
0.7695924043655396,
-0.09236359596252441,
-0.1370922476053238,
0.7531048655509949,
-0.5138116478919983,
0.6581602096557617,
0.3942122757434845,
-0.15413899719715118,
-0.5331315398216248,
0.9240042567253113,
-0.2082822173833847,
0.4663383364677429,
0.7039240002632141,
0.32235464453697205,
-0.5112566947937012,
-0.5839247107505798,
-0.5668445229530334,
0.10353806614875793,
-0.6202487945556641,
-0.21154747903347015,
-0.31306400895118713,
0.0014377041952684522,
-0.3215658962726593,
-0.35064494609832764,
-0.40035906434059143,
-0.6542669534683228,
-0.7995866537094116,
0.13126838207244873,
0.48560765385627747,
-0.03263341262936592,
0.44514524936676025,
0.560671329498291,
-0.8334174752235413,
0.2033255249261856,
-0.08243968337774277,
0.4223410487174988,
-0.39185991883277893,
-0.7514481544494629,
0.03122812882065773,
0.16836366057395935,
-0.5388869047164917,
-0.9298629760742188,
0.16117580235004425,
0.6486229300498962,
0.0037172874435782433,
0.14856134355068207,
0.41043251752853394,
0.8292500972747803,
-0.39731350541114807,
0.9392040371894836,
0.0023826316464692354,
-1.2037931680679321,
0.8266108632087708,
-0.2862553298473358,
0.7614688873291016,
0.7863340973854065,
-0.10373108834028244,
-0.5422207713127136,
-0.3086416721343994,
-0.07825729995965958,
-0.5403195023536682,
0.6264956593513489,
-0.222075954079628,
0.10616393387317657,
0.22194784879684448,
0.42275238037109375,
0.10863543301820755,
0.17190450429916382,
-0.2635226547718048,
-0.0561465248465538,
-0.4277794063091278,
-0.4841257929801941,
-0.3486563563346863,
-0.3523693084716797,
0.2073001116514206,
-0.2920621931552887,
0.2850571870803833,
-0.5777804851531982,
0.07891937345266342,
0.2971220016479492,
-0.21636056900024414,
-0.10411888360977173,
0.39134469628334045,
0.6522603034973145,
0.7826317548751831,
-0.26106712222099304,
-0.09422611445188522,
0.28349167108535767,
-0.8121795654296875,
0.24048012495040894,
0.3472760319709778,
-0.30151256918907166,
-0.004161833319813013,
0.15291747450828552,
0.9802539348602295,
0.39776426553726196,
-0.6898660659790039,
0.9404619336128235,
-0.11293821781873703,
-0.2518742084503174,
-0.24776141345500946,
0.38447508215904236,
-0.5645319223403931,
0.3104903995990753,
0.6042529940605164,
0.09114523231983185,
0.01355128362774849,
-0.010044711641967297,
0.22435696423053741,
0.26230815052986145,
-0.543318510055542,
-0.3471529483795166,
0.9294579029083252,
0.13249090313911438,
-0.24908842146396637,
0.5925852060317993,
-0.014163040556013584,
-0.7828409671783447,
0.6219134330749512,
0.4004993140697479,
0.981109082698822,
-0.16649997234344482,
0.2967795431613922,
0.4971710443496704,
0.13923892378807068,
0.02602100372314453,
0.3291725814342499,
-0.25725147128105164,
-0.5674422979354858,
-0.6294680237770081,
-0.6404395699501038,
-0.7423475384712219,
-0.1415378749370575,
-0.4804641604423523,
0.7636263370513916,
-0.5385001301765442,
-0.17019395530223846,
-0.051693595945835114,
0.15220120549201965,
-0.712773859500885,
0.14100898802280426,
0.13106873631477356,
1.2945464849472046,
-0.7766063809394836,
0.6455706357955933,
0.403785765171051,
0.2885756492614746,
-0.8005716800689697,
0.04586470499634743,
0.08265615999698639,
-0.6879614591598511,
0.19290469586849213,
0.4458695948123932,
0.05383405461907387,
0.23405562341213226,
-0.361586332321167,
-0.6057030558586121,
1.036103367805481,
0.8021203279495239,
-0.8672434091567993,
-0.1659126728773117,
0.3895585536956787,
0.3981185853481293,
-0.3393419682979584,
0.3073178827762604,
0.48221877217292786,
0.3714476227760315,
0.29433152079582214,
-1.121354103088379,
0.15251663327217102,
0.02360335737466812,
0.15221136808395386,
0.3439289629459381,
-0.5380476713180542,
0.4536267817020416,
-0.4407682418823242,
-0.3369526267051697,
-0.08955318480730057,
0.22394193708896637,
0.39332646131515503,
0.2377403974533081,
0.8478382229804993,
0.20245438814163208,
0.5010055899620056,
-0.3888956606388092,
0.8621805310249329,
-0.2507319152355194,
0.3772849142551422,
1.1407893896102905,
0.008968522772192955,
0.5320760607719421,
0.5694519281387329,
-0.06511314958333969,
0.06743942201137543,
1.0044429302215576,
-0.4670566916465759,
0.7381515502929688,
0.03819279372692108,
-0.08284416049718857,
-0.3773297965526581,
-0.2908672094345093,
-0.26982632279396057,
0.3214125335216522,
0.15986044704914093,
-0.4029565453529358,
-0.26603448390960693,
0.45310094952583313,
-0.29818159341812134,
0.020077809691429138,
-0.26090341806411743,
0.38575491309165955,
0.06970585137605667,
-0.7220733165740967,
0.5022600293159485,
-0.466763973236084,
0.48906487226486206,
-0.2730778753757477,
-0.10480162501335144,
0.17705348134040833,
0.48072248697280884,
0.15159636735916138,
-1.072895884513855,
0.13381554186344147,
-0.13653472065925598,
-0.3322199583053589,
-0.4458046555519104,
0.37690699100494385,
-0.3566185235977173,
-0.4733753800392151,
0.21834039688110352,
0.03845524415373802,
-0.23389066755771637,
-0.36935368180274963,
-0.7091644406318665,
0.18949466943740845,
0.10226631164550781,
-0.35570064187049866,
-0.011229705065488815,
0.1903517097234726,
0.07639419287443161,
0.5980726480484009,
0.23255948722362518,
0.20998860895633698,
0.00905139185488224,
0.1812332272529602,
0.8559792637825012,
-0.7541683316230774,
-0.5770173072814941,
-1.0121463537216187,
0.5256588459014893,
0.22234512865543365,
-0.6391043663024902,
0.32762768864631653,
0.4400824010372162,
0.7317676544189453,
0.12495505064725876,
0.3589818477630615,
-0.012887570075690746,
0.6876183748245239,
-0.5449841618537903,
0.5238063931465149,
-0.5697349905967712,
0.338762491941452,
-0.30350548028945923,
-1.0811268091201782,
-0.3123338520526886,
-0.07621479034423828,
-0.19657187163829803,
-0.04026974365115166,
0.8282108306884766,
0.7814344763755798,
-0.14271730184555054,
-0.016113584861159325,
0.02704123966395855,
-0.013537902384996414,
0.6657878160476685,
0.8885805010795593,
0.5450093150138855,
-0.5462189316749573,
0.9429653882980347,
-0.46747422218322754,
-0.40213248133659363,
-0.21353453397750854,
-1.2268245220184326,
-1.0247316360473633,
-0.6928936839103699,
-0.4720049500465393,
-0.25594228506088257,
-0.059990957379341125,
0.8013607859611511,
0.6388341784477234,
-0.7573258876800537,
0.33917200565338135,
-0.04002649709582329,
-0.02995281107723713,
-0.25978896021842957,
-0.23107053339481354,
0.46549510955810547,
-0.34778496623039246,
-0.8408786058425903,
0.36246591806411743,
0.13847468793392181,
0.5452239513397217,
0.031067360192537308,
0.09536471217870712,
0.4585849940776825,
-0.18326909840106964,
0.171594500541687,
0.17551399767398834,
-0.38366323709487915,
-0.4424009621143341,
0.2761538028717041,
-0.025047725066542625,
0.21809612214565277,
0.7583696246147156,
-0.8951754570007324,
0.8606649041175842,
0.3612097501754761,
0.5734625458717346,
0.5873910188674927,
0.024651192128658295,
0.8570268750190735,
-0.9279235601425171,
0.36819541454315186,
0.47779905796051025,
0.019587721675634384,
0.20057758688926697,
-0.47441744804382324,
0.19567032158374786,
0.24456042051315308,
-0.5796480178833008,
-1.006106972694397,
0.14444656670093536,
-1.146908164024353,
0.0032014071475714445,
0.9023991823196411,
0.03809400647878647,
-0.4118293821811676,
0.07060606777667999,
-0.4150996804237366,
0.35191869735717773,
-0.5300032496452332,
0.7345138192176819,
0.7857315540313721,
0.24866150319576263,
-0.4997693598270416,
-0.39914846420288086,
0.6383053660392761,
0.3488634526729584,
-0.4415868818759918,
0.11730153858661652,
0.28608980774879456,
0.3272973597049713,
-0.14193838834762573,
0.2819875180721283,
0.12659509479999542,
0.613544225692749,
-0.2789386212825775,
-0.3781419098377228,
-0.3882872760295868,
-0.19967347383499146,
-0.41356608271598816,
-0.08792978525161743,
0.08152167499065399,
-0.5840325355529785
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14118v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14118v1
|
From Handcrafted Features to LLMs: A Brief Survey for Machine Translation Quality Estimation
| 2024-03-21T04:07:40 | 2024-03-21T04:07:40 |
Haofei Zhao, Yilun Liu, Shimin Tao, Weibin Meng, Yimeng Chen, Xiang Geng, Chang Su, Min Zhang, Hao Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Machine Translation Quality Estimation (MTQE) is the task of estimating the
quality of machine-translated text in real time without the need for reference
translations, which is of great importance for the development of MT. After two
decades of evolution, QE has yielded a wealth of results. This article provides
a comprehensive overview of QE datasets, annotation methods, shared tasks,
methodologies, challenges, and future research directions. It begins with an
introduction to the background and significance of QE, followed by an
explanation of the concepts and evaluation metrics for word-level QE,
sentence-level QE, document-level QE, and explainable QE. The paper categorizes
the methods developed throughout the history of QE into those based on
handcrafted features, deep learning, and Large Language Models (LLMs), with a
further division of deep learning-based methods into classic deep learning and
those incorporating pre-trained language models (LMs). Additionally, the
article details the advantages and limitations of each method and offers a
straightforward comparison of different approaches. Finally, the paper
discusses the current challenges in QE research and provides an outlook on
future research directions.
|
[
-0.3495621681213379,
-0.4655754268169403,
0.6923742294311523,
-0.2569306790828705,
-0.4281836152076721,
0.3109625279903412,
-0.04328424483537674,
-0.18411654233932495,
0.19508543610572815,
0.7440510392189026,
-0.620430588722229,
-0.5226463079452515,
-1.0343424081802368,
0.1986120045185089,
-0.3231227695941925,
0.8136242032051086,
-0.37386396527290344,
0.2064369022846222,
-0.01933581568300724,
-0.29533714056015015,
-0.3849044442176819,
-0.576536238193512,
-0.28261837363243103,
-0.06658711284399033,
0.4067024886608124,
0.11240393668413162,
0.9001511335372925,
0.7607554793357849,
0.5994566679000854,
0.25683242082595825,
-0.0786871537566185,
0.4415850043296814,
-0.39826759696006775,
0.18523429334163666,
0.02418384701013565,
-0.6132870316505432,
-0.5080076456069946,
0.33713245391845703,
0.4827783405780792,
0.7146639823913574,
0.09499966353178024,
0.42401108145713806,
0.4357495605945587,
0.848220944404602,
-0.4139978885650635,
-0.25898224115371704,
-0.2649311423301697,
0.28408747911453247,
-0.24046587944030762,
-0.196387380361557,
-0.03494368493556976,
-0.39338189363479614,
0.08183107525110245,
-0.26563122868537903,
0.08487309515476227,
0.14694076776504517,
0.8070103526115417,
0.38334840536117554,
-0.5912705659866333,
-0.44404953718185425,
-0.7230753302574158,
1.1501424312591553,
-0.9047716856002808,
0.6709490418434143,
0.40122005343437195,
0.4044586718082428,
-0.2998262941837311,
-0.8234017491340637,
-0.287799209356308,
-0.21228323876857758,
0.11441990733146667,
0.20206552743911743,
0.04845557361841202,
-0.19090613722801208,
-0.02815207466483116,
0.8674798607826233,
-0.6802691221237183,
0.15992552042007446,
-0.045249093323946,
-0.23142603039741516,
0.5882261395454407,
0.0857369601726532,
0.3678399324417114,
-0.21729080379009247,
-0.3573891818523407,
0.07711470872163773,
-0.5704959034919739,
0.09776602685451508,
-0.026198258623480797,
-0.28111520409584045,
0.1815972924232483,
0.6386415362358093,
-0.1475251019001007,
0.359835147857666,
-0.19144655764102936,
-0.4026181101799011,
0.21474473178386688,
-0.5697550177574158,
-0.4271771013736725,
-0.6822461485862732,
1.1907246112823486,
0.36587926745414734,
-0.14787621796131134,
-0.41157203912734985,
-0.5251820683479309,
-0.4622590243816376,
0.08672984689474106,
-0.6300286650657654,
0.20497053861618042,
0.3694643974304199,
-0.6819661855697632,
-0.295174241065979,
0.04372524470090866,
-0.4038701057434082,
-0.2504742443561554,
-0.4301130771636963,
0.23735164105892181,
-0.32429563999176025,
-0.1418515294790268,
-0.27147984504699707,
-0.06620414555072784,
-0.01666799746453762,
0.04980883002281189,
-0.6618732810020447,
0.0853494331240654,
0.6011667251586914,
0.827309787273407,
-0.3943852484226227,
-0.1414424479007721,
-0.46421074867248535,
-0.20827962458133698,
-0.3365733027458191,
0.5916424989700317,
-0.14348526298999786,
-0.5625086426734924,
-0.05753509700298309,
0.28524908423423767,
0.3063949942588806,
-0.6882352232933044,
0.8339245915412903,
-0.540304958820343,
0.4794616103172302,
-0.3173975646495819,
-0.6246274709701538,
-0.4512261748313904,
0.4238627851009369,
-0.5659264326095581,
1.286750078201294,
0.3117474615573883,
-0.6101926565170288,
0.41527223587036133,
-0.37811020016670227,
-0.16744542121887207,
0.004255981184542179,
0.1343650370836258,
-0.4871981739997864,
0.6632656455039978,
0.4109379053115845,
0.4938547611236572,
-0.47144001722335815,
0.4210292398929596,
-0.11104810237884521,
-0.29799795150756836,
0.39982330799102783,
-0.6236734986305237,
0.8268052339553833,
0.5472375154495239,
-0.08086974918842316,
0.24930129945278168,
-0.5025277137756348,
0.09717436879873276,
-0.10499265044927597,
-0.18660563230514526,
-0.10438799858093262,
0.13499832153320312,
-0.13949139416217804,
0.23864883184432983,
0.37225934863090515,
-0.35168707370758057,
0.09060847014188766,
-0.5644745826721191,
0.6198590397834778,
0.11858067661523819,
0.1581849455833435,
0.4691028892993927,
-0.14055277407169342,
0.6306729316711426,
0.07748067378997803,
0.6116923689842224,
0.028659990057349205,
-0.3779849410057068,
-0.4755236506462097,
-0.11220788210630417,
0.7326333522796631,
0.8411669135093689,
-0.8981123566627502,
0.50505131483078,
-0.3140890896320343,
-0.39003950357437134,
-1.08098304271698,
0.4715719521045685,
0.17136208713054657,
-0.12250537425279617,
0.35820797085762024,
-0.4889107942581177,
-0.22077162563800812,
-0.9294499158859253,
-0.29741644859313965,
0.03876880556344986,
-0.49502032995224,
-0.1847044974565506,
0.30137377977371216,
-0.15615898370742798,
0.5569407939910889,
-0.269941508769989,
-0.09859735518693924,
-0.0987260565161705,
0.20484182238578796,
0.2559463381767273,
0.3477659225463867,
0.3583884537220001,
-0.5594174265861511,
-0.3900034725666046,
0.008033298887312412,
-0.9433197379112244,
-0.07588054239749908,
0.13922511041164398,
-0.2196735143661499,
0.0320185087621212,
0.2753438353538513,
-0.3475545048713684,
0.10860650986433029,
0.8521471619606018,
0.22711101174354553,
0.4413396120071411,
-0.0967651903629303,
0.7193090915679932,
-1.3608933687210083,
-0.2675844728946686,
0.0676448717713356,
-0.20573844015598297,
-0.6221067905426025,
0.1328691840171814,
0.14732898771762848,
0.005330673884600401,
-0.41721323132514954,
0.3544522523880005,
-0.611240804195404,
-0.10132955759763718,
-0.6495106220245361,
0.4639992117881775,
0.1870328038930893,
0.26193663477897644,
-0.273315966129303,
0.9138047099113464,
0.18717066943645477,
-0.3170635402202606,
0.46643495559692383,
-0.07661060243844986,
-0.38465258479118347,
0.8015317916870117,
-0.4724474847316742,
0.18995414674282074,
0.0337701216340065,
-0.2753393054008484,
-0.7835553288459778,
0.1918765902519226,
0.47600677609443665,
-0.7262911796569824,
0.4398740231990814,
-0.28182682394981384,
-0.6917983293533325,
-0.46954479813575745,
-0.32197141647338867,
0.25985023379325867,
0.6175032258033752,
-0.20235228538513184,
0.3138527572154999,
0.482104629278183,
-0.17657005786895752,
-0.5012462735176086,
-0.5032029747962952,
0.5556778907775879,
-0.35865703225135803,
-0.5078493356704712,
0.18694663047790527,
0.007099552545696497,
-0.16445232927799225,
-0.036578934639692307,
-0.18752655386924744,
-0.43366748094558716,
0.4669477939605713,
0.09188549220561981,
0.044958941638469696,
-0.38021019101142883,
0.08581966906785965,
0.31976306438446045,
-0.1677151322364807,
-0.002009934512898326,
-0.4436345398426056,
0.05070709437131882,
0.16161829233169556,
-0.2663927674293518,
-0.533515989780426,
0.2262813001871109,
0.3650864362716675,
-0.46452799439430237,
0.5218687653541565,
0.7188748717308044,
-0.2725600600242615,
0.07299870252609253,
-0.6269111633300781,
-0.08047766238451004,
-0.3864758610725403,
0.38187676668167114,
-0.3849557638168335,
-0.9630572199821472,
0.43653687834739685,
-0.29204073548316956,
0.23736605048179626,
0.6891520023345947,
0.24828827381134033,
-0.4840574860572815,
0.9805774092674255,
0.6164742112159729,
-0.008043029345571995,
0.2885596454143524,
-0.18224872648715973,
-0.03189217671751976,
-0.947425901889801,
0.0540359802544117,
-0.5369024872779846,
-0.29992395639419556,
-0.8940061926841736,
-0.6318448781967163,
0.36693075299263,
0.6028319001197815,
0.10240631550550461,
0.341030091047287,
-0.39066049456596375,
0.21024730801582336,
0.5522382855415344,
-0.0774659514427185,
0.5135830044746399,
0.09173484891653061,
0.1654185652732849,
-0.24373823404312134,
-0.45968717336654663,
-0.8896594047546387,
1.0146710872650146,
0.6290199160575867,
0.15191730856895447,
-0.04266630485653877,
0.6478612422943115,
0.38955309987068176,
0.4931633770465851,
-0.8994015455245972,
0.2801662087440491,
-0.23306185007095337,
-0.5658387541770935,
-0.295688271522522,
-0.5166454315185547,
-0.6914176940917969,
0.398192822933197,
-0.29559969902038574,
-0.26357609033584595,
-0.13612182438373566,
0.13270223140716553,
-0.03370216116309166,
0.33470818400382996,
-0.3687303960323334,
0.8161097764968872,
-0.48224103450775146,
-0.14611321687698364,
-0.02372095361351967,
-0.6004612445831299,
0.34276482462882996,
-0.14111123979091644,
0.4218924045562744,
-0.2854142189025879,
-0.12496060878038406,
0.7561582922935486,
-0.35996168851852417,
0.5495958924293518,
-0.07579223066568375,
-0.2691670060157776,
0.4514167308807373,
0.08470344543457031,
0.5591601133346558,
-0.009563079103827477,
-0.24533118307590485,
0.39103588461875916,
0.5683363676071167,
-0.6569584608078003,
-0.7823778390884399,
0.5357540845870972,
-0.5652252435684204,
-0.5812608599662781,
-0.1388372927904129,
-0.3754228949546814,
-0.3191559314727783,
0.28824639320373535,
0.30506327748298645,
0.143697127699852,
-0.478079229593277,
-0.18403637409210205,
0.5150136947631836,
-0.3783627152442932,
0.42016565799713135,
0.31429407000541687,
-0.1540575921535492,
-0.9642395377159119,
1.0298562049865723,
0.39869049191474915,
0.17978067696094513,
0.6031225323677063,
0.02145620994269848,
-0.24198371171951294,
-1.161432147026062,
-0.7538228034973145,
0.3085368275642395,
-0.39990824460983276,
-0.0751955509185791,
-0.2575482130050659,
-0.18233808875083923,
-0.010309359058737755,
0.08436232805252075,
-0.4775722324848175,
-0.519902229309082,
-0.3028984069824219,
-0.011652817018330097,
-0.0622810460627079,
0.9054835438728333,
0.38077056407928467,
0.5226526260375977,
-1.3199260234832764,
0.15926562249660492,
0.09413906931877136,
0.30542564392089844,
-0.3209589719772339,
-0.7108035683631897,
-0.6302193403244019,
0.4564978778362274,
-0.48806068301200867,
-0.8390916585922241,
0.4945598244667053,
-0.2559157907962799,
0.6584991216659546,
0.137152299284935,
0.05418355017900467,
0.24484087526798248,
-0.4548509120941162,
1.0942546129226685,
0.13760590553283691,
-0.8068979382514954,
0.4290497899055481,
0.017817320302128792,
0.16857029497623444,
0.545166015625,
0.3802652955055237,
-0.6761026382446289,
-0.43038251996040344,
-0.42974522709846497,
-0.5756528973579407,
0.02292713150382042,
0.3956735134124756,
0.032895397394895554,
0.03488732874393463,
0.4982210695743561,
0.33744558691978455,
0.4917043149471283,
-0.5064331889152527,
-0.21483005583286285,
-0.19640982151031494,
-0.38744932413101196,
-0.11026237159967422,
-0.48852601647377014,
0.15549315512180328,
0.14845649898052216,
0.8003026247024536,
0.08914906531572342,
-0.046064991503953934,
0.016013698652386665,
-0.49650388956069946,
-0.0700996071100235,
0.6067531108856201,
0.6407018303871155,
0.6548728942871094,
-0.2766144573688507,
0.17991656064987183,
0.4080042541027069,
-0.4021131992340088,
0.2036125659942627,
-0.11937132477760315,
-0.3158588409423828,
0.13853824138641357,
0.34008172154426575,
0.9358665943145752,
-0.3139316141605377,
-0.2558360993862152,
0.37527307868003845,
0.24375472962856293,
-0.30067500472068787,
-0.24757890403270721,
-0.34082236886024475,
-0.10100162774324417,
0.27216583490371704,
0.2860357463359833,
-0.08441808819770813,
0.34360796213150024,
-0.2630571722984314,
-0.060255225747823715,
0.3807016611099243,
-0.9553804993629456,
-0.6100916266441345,
0.6058891415596008,
0.35051798820495605,
-0.3067583739757538,
0.46269527077674866,
-0.10897960513830185,
-0.24712854623794556,
0.25907447934150696,
-0.02451172098517418,
1.0435329675674438,
-0.4234544634819031,
0.046579163521528244,
0.16032809019088745,
0.6543489694595337,
-0.11747706681489944,
0.14444489777088165,
0.2844442129135132,
-0.41174593567848206,
-0.8259047865867615,
-0.7049927711486816,
-0.2719673812389374,
0.1156257763504982,
-0.45671093463897705,
-0.04665272310376167,
0.020287495106458664,
-0.5727701187133789,
-0.3530848026275635,
0.25425827503204346,
-0.7017990946769714,
0.24636846780776978,
-0.07024085521697998,
0.7343190908432007,
-0.7304059863090515,
0.8067530989646912,
0.5933588147163391,
-0.428814560174942,
-0.19173800945281982,
-0.057401735335588455,
0.07907119393348694,
-0.7741584777832031,
0.4924449920654297,
-0.20533818006515503,
-0.12020178139209747,
0.2165132462978363,
-0.2903573215007782,
-0.7628767490386963,
1.054999589920044,
0.012034204788506031,
-0.4897921681404114,
0.032412245869636536,
0.4189731478691101,
0.466935932636261,
-0.17490637302398682,
0.21694666147232056,
0.583491325378418,
0.4351806938648224,
-0.33408957719802856,
-0.876478910446167,
-0.030943281948566437,
0.045113492757081985,
0.4683266282081604,
0.5020318031311035,
-0.30730679631233215,
-0.06246424466371536,
0.16196174919605255,
-0.3346443474292755,
0.11155667155981064,
0.8638607859611511,
-0.20634394884109497,
0.3699372112751007,
0.262751042842865,
0.5028219223022461,
0.5532667636871338,
-0.2766718864440918,
0.8306834697723389,
-0.19614823162555695,
0.2230619192123413,
0.8778586387634277,
0.15551653504371643,
0.9172269105911255,
0.5447188019752502,
-0.5097564458847046,
-0.020098203793168068,
0.8847609758377075,
-0.15583446621894836,
0.2103731632232666,
0.09244352579116821,
-0.12369225174188614,
-0.09155147522687912,
-0.11548156291246414,
-0.20522724092006683,
-0.025444552302360535,
0.30165112018585205,
-0.6375386118888855,
0.155286967754364,
0.24106447398662567,
-0.10898008942604065,
0.060252927243709564,
-0.11555743217468262,
0.9953143000602722,
0.37114688754081726,
-0.4588431417942047,
0.5403223037719727,
0.0326644591987133,
0.49811965227127075,
-0.13662610948085785,
0.08548784255981445,
-0.4572765529155731,
-0.30868664383888245,
-0.08391273021697998,
-1.0187699794769287,
0.38776373863220215,
-0.2423507273197174,
-0.3872447609901428,
-0.2655705213546753,
0.21952170133590698,
-0.44878169894218445,
-0.4910928010940552,
0.022524124011397362,
0.9524168372154236,
0.39650416374206543,
-0.24682027101516724,
-0.6917381286621094,
0.04276088625192642,
0.08264222741127014,
-0.3368235230445862,
0.3750362992286682,
0.7193236351013184,
0.0008812984451651573,
0.5072248578071594,
0.342218816280365,
0.005719998385757208,
0.03408319503068924,
-0.18774722516536713,
0.4288945198059082,
-0.9977505803108215,
0.15017050504684448,
-0.8036450743675232,
0.8260099291801453,
0.007616070099174976,
-0.14615239202976227,
0.7193623781204224,
0.5772037506103516,
0.6420607566833496,
-0.13562928140163422,
0.7693058848381042,
0.4005454182624817,
0.7763845324516296,
-0.6063211560249329,
0.5594669580459595,
-0.7408625483512878,
0.3608259856700897,
0.07539373636245728,
-1.1290040016174316,
-0.3121371269226074,
0.10506267100572586,
-0.14793476462364197,
-0.20208708941936493,
0.8440357446670532,
0.5761606693267822,
-0.08216719329357147,
-0.2448049634695053,
0.5217568874359131,
0.05353768169879913,
0.14700287580490112,
0.13385449349880219,
0.8299183249473572,
-0.8791247010231018,
0.6221652626991272,
-0.24610230326652527,
-0.2382073551416397,
-0.19111409783363342,
-0.7638608813285828,
-0.6691846251487732,
-0.572603702545166,
-0.4347207844257355,
-0.19272005558013916,
0.058350931853055954,
0.8271199464797974,
0.47261548042297363,
-0.9072543978691101,
-0.29912063479423523,
0.22063295543193817,
0.26525601744651794,
-0.5512665510177612,
-0.11107902973890305,
0.4055139422416687,
-0.25965937972068787,
-0.9085713624954224,
0.5182185173034668,
0.4008103609085083,
0.2715020775794983,
-0.10412601381540298,
-0.0006467167404480278,
0.14628727734088898,
-0.0806162878870964,
0.8410534858703613,
0.1634349375963211,
-0.976372480392456,
-0.10091006755828857,
0.1505281776189804,
-0.27206912636756897,
0.2234119325876236,
0.5166056752204895,
-0.2959873080253601,
0.3729812800884247,
0.5624613761901855,
0.5728631019592285,
0.5078112483024597,
-0.13000181317329407,
0.7113726139068604,
-0.43319639563560486,
-0.18364715576171875,
0.09857837855815887,
0.290350079536438,
0.30601274967193604,
-0.05973978713154793,
0.5482549667358398,
0.20714285969734192,
-0.7171098589897156,
-0.7429919838905334,
0.3712305724620819,
-0.943687915802002,
-0.21728652715682983,
0.504786491394043,
-0.2735445499420166,
-0.25842660665512085,
-0.12012216448783875,
-0.22176745533943176,
0.5195935368537903,
0.07130748778581619,
0.6586650013923645,
0.7647889256477356,
0.0872376561164856,
-0.6165587306022644,
-1.2103686332702637,
0.4359118342399597,
0.2695845067501068,
-0.7746596932411194,
-0.13968704640865326,
0.5216569900512695,
0.23841851949691772,
-0.011183458380401134,
0.09427128732204437,
-0.23693175613880157,
-0.10572049766778946,
-0.32686078548431396,
0.30348536372184753,
-0.09888888150453568,
0.06453356146812439,
-0.07060929387807846,
0.2103210985660553,
0.720185399055481,
-0.21465912461280823
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14117v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14117v2
|
A Design Space for Intelligent and Interactive Writing Assistants
| 2024-03-21T04:03:16 | 2024-03-26T12:53:14 |
Mina Lee, Katy Ilonka Gero, John Joon Young Chung, Simon Buckingham Shum, Vipul Raheja, Hua Shen, Subhashini Venugopalan, Thiemo Wambsganss, David Zhou, Emad A. Alghamdi, Tal August, Avinash Bhat, Madiha Zahrah Choksi, Senjuti Dutta, Jin L. C. Guo, Md Naimul Hoque, Yewon Kim, Simon Knight, Seyed Parsa Neshaei, Agnia Sergeyuk, Antonette Shibani, Disha Shrivastava, Lila Shroff, Jessi Stark, Sarah Sterman, Sitong Wang, Antoine Bosselut, Daniel Buschek, Joseph Chee Chang, Sherol Chen, Max Kreminski, Joonsuk Park, Roy Pea, Eugenia H. Rho, Shannon Zejiang Shen, Pao Siangliulue
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.CL
|
In our era of rapid technological advancement, the research landscape for
writing assistants has become increasingly fragmented across various research
communities. We seek to address this challenge by proposing a design space as a
structured way to examine and explore the multidimensional space of intelligent
and interactive writing assistants. Through a large community collaboration, we
explore five aspects of writing assistants: task, user, technology,
interaction, and ecosystem. Within each aspect, we define dimensions (i.e.,
fundamental components of an aspect) and codes (i.e., potential options for
each dimension) by systematically reviewing 115 papers. Our design space aims
to offer researchers and designers a practical tool to navigate, comprehend,
and compare the various possibilities of writing assistants, and aid in the
envisioning and design of new writing assistants.
|
[
-0.6810184121131897,
-0.6069475412368774,
1.0578330755233765,
0.45505648851394653,
0.21317324042320251,
0.5461164116859436,
0.051748380064964294,
-0.7052425742149353,
0.7253895401954651,
0.24538220465183258,
-0.8256894946098328,
-0.3920578062534332,
-0.3473377823829651,
0.3318755328655243,
-0.12155259400606155,
0.6440723538398743,
-0.29334038496017456,
-0.159891739487648,
-0.8070831298828125,
-0.17639285326004028,
-0.6695458292961121,
-0.26150375604629517,
-0.5671215057373047,
0.29036006331443787,
0.8705898523330688,
0.5733820199966431,
0.4755500555038452,
0.41102418303489685,
0.9382150173187256,
0.39952394366264343,
0.04997991770505905,
0.40434399247169495,
0.16909538209438324,
0.16001491248607635,
0.051691167056560516,
-0.007098188158124685,
-0.9771655201911926,
0.2427147775888443,
0.32414379715919495,
0.9147400259971619,
0.17380525171756744,
0.1408754140138626,
0.017243076115846634,
0.4350711405277252,
-0.6774810552597046,
-0.04609541967511177,
0.22617389261722565,
0.2039175033569336,
-0.1881493180990219,
-0.00013745894830208272,
-0.2868672311306,
-0.6342223286628723,
-0.01755867712199688,
-1.1709976196289062,
0.06163482367992401,
0.3635159730911255,
0.22246457636356354,
0.05060136318206787,
-0.2913985550403595,
-0.6139695644378662,
-1.155913233757019,
0.39752107858657837,
-0.12580975890159607,
0.21847869455814362,
0.1781989485025406,
0.14198219776153564,
0.028714599087834358,
-0.6572731137275696,
-1.0825104713439941,
-0.07168810069561005,
-0.09483128786087036,
0.03462798520922661,
-0.19493384659290314,
0.09206287562847137,
0.09170421212911606,
0.29379960894584656,
-0.5269318222999573,
-0.11371814459562302,
-0.3721763789653778,
0.14308689534664154,
0.5873950719833374,
0.31520742177963257,
0.7966560125350952,
0.3646833896636963,
-0.04835548624396324,
-0.0941200777888298,
-0.14748845994472504,
0.05908174067735672,
0.7112358212471008,
0.05763835832476616,
0.2284233570098877,
0.2627132534980774,
-0.11671070754528046,
0.5598191618919373,
-0.14858883619308472,
-0.09505166113376617,
0.1408098191022873,
-0.4645497798919678,
-0.0035922499373555183,
-0.3749082684516907,
0.7650286555290222,
0.37851399183273315,
-0.3919931948184967,
-0.2686614692211151,
-0.09676249325275421,
-0.2409755140542984,
0.7271223664283752,
-0.3112359941005707,
-0.2388972043991089,
0.14874690771102905,
-0.4219459295272827,
-0.5307052135467529,
0.1658134162425995,
-0.7342318892478943,
-0.9038693904876709,
-0.5049136281013489,
0.3180777132511139,
-0.21374310553073883,
-0.31452813744544983,
-0.19471122324466705,
-0.5131126642227173,
-0.300751656293869,
0.5155079364776611,
-0.8525074124336243,
0.606899619102478,
0.45003798604011536,
0.6182220578193665,
-0.12417350709438324,
-0.6722180843353271,
0.2779064178466797,
0.09494061022996902,
-0.1250075399875641,
1.0294804573059082,
-0.7760255932807922,
-0.7105417251586914,
-0.16610226035118103,
-0.4586697518825531,
0.08208994567394257,
-0.20168431103229523,
0.4641546607017517,
-0.22552329301834106,
0.39475491642951965,
-0.3261251449584961,
-0.18817703425884247,
-0.08347539603710175,
0.08363287895917892,
-1.0018800497055054,
0.500537097454071,
0.18684636056423187,
-0.3658908009529114,
0.6600424647331238,
-1.2191166877746582,
-0.4848274886608124,
0.09020888805389404,
-0.17656739056110382,
-0.41714349389076233,
0.18606095016002655,
-0.06502651423215866,
-0.004994466435164213,
0.10133413225412369,
-0.07901779562234879,
-0.28811895847320557,
-0.3115900456905365,
0.5508198142051697,
0.0560651458799839,
0.584477424621582,
0.34602925181388855,
0.044446513056755066,
0.4739130139350891,
-1.0793133974075317,
-0.016822168603539467,
-0.11895478516817093,
-0.573061466217041,
-0.4026867747306824,
-0.11693619936704636,
0.347705602645874,
0.16752129793167114,
0.45297813415527344,
-0.858325719833374,
0.5510300397872925,
0.19511796534061432,
0.3758386969566345,
0.4652692973613739,
-0.10285238176584244,
0.8646153807640076,
-0.3012810945510864,
0.7907238602638245,
-0.25341740250587463,
0.4955945312976837,
0.15990838408470154,
-0.30974000692367554,
-0.7234216332435608,
-0.29986631870269775,
-0.024494722485542297,
0.3973829448223114,
-0.4626002311706543,
0.6922436356544495,
-0.06071687489748001,
-0.43096187710762024,
-0.7440795302391052,
0.10278630256652832,
0.3776386082172394,
0.11997303366661072,
0.2332753688097,
-0.1580769568681717,
-0.3669712543487549,
-0.8725597262382507,
-0.05951673910021782,
0.08108486980199814,
0.05027468129992485,
0.2401553839445114,
0.3269577920436859,
-0.11861318349838257,
0.9145380854606628,
-0.5293059945106506,
-0.6896294355392456,
-0.5763369798660278,
0.18695354461669922,
-0.185517355799675,
0.4034316837787628,
0.7363128066062927,
-0.5734556913375854,
-0.6039395928382874,
-0.08965060859918594,
-0.6934729814529419,
-0.17343275249004364,
-0.24999353289604187,
-0.24493011832237244,
-0.019015435129404068,
0.5899476408958435,
-0.8964752554893494,
0.5342774987220764,
0.2123493105173111,
-0.5159471035003662,
0.154825359582901,
-0.07299397885799408,
0.18737439811229706,
-1.1486321687698364,
0.4232358932495117,
-0.2522168755531311,
0.4389982521533966,
-0.6266549229621887,
0.2807304263114929,
0.09208549559116364,
-0.4662843346595764,
0.15346857905387878,
0.6358634233474731,
-0.6462942957878113,
0.10164040327072144,
-0.36778876185417175,
0.2864943742752075,
0.5940186381340027,
0.7126623392105103,
-0.029592588543891907,
0.6730450391769409,
0.05304475501179695,
0.08715230971574783,
0.0898023322224617,
0.3842560052871704,
-0.15276995301246643,
0.6875430345535278,
-0.5530089139938354,
0.4865063726902008,
-0.09340488910675049,
0.4112803637981415,
-0.982978880405426,
-0.2850412428379059,
-0.039342302829027176,
-0.3936923146247864,
0.10332497954368591,
0.6133326292037964,
-0.5137614011764526,
-0.40229836106300354,
-0.5146983861923218,
0.4872231185436249,
0.031583476811647415,
-0.08237537741661072,
0.8113222122192383,
0.7063875794410706,
-0.457042396068573,
-0.2889622151851654,
-0.6350204348564148,
0.21657763421535492,
-0.12373502552509308,
-0.6610349416732788,
0.25212013721466064,
-0.18382057547569275,
-0.6381310224533081,
0.12535753846168518,
0.36530399322509766,
-0.22095535695552826,
0.0041160075925290585,
0.48302605748176575,
0.016906946897506714,
-0.0006818412221036851,
0.04639624431729317,
0.18866683542728424,
-0.09861277788877487,
0.1366402506828308,
-0.09604430943727493,
0.13954009115695953,
0.1074184700846672,
-0.363640695810318,
-0.521551251411438,
1.0683785676956177,
0.8617932200431824,
-0.34043028950691223,
0.6011475920677185,
0.34970736503601074,
-0.4228919744491577,
-0.25890734791755676,
-0.47568613290786743,
0.3516666293144226,
-0.5360346436500549,
0.10705931484699249,
-0.3560587465763092,
-0.6655150055885315,
0.786609411239624,
0.30452048778533936,
0.5481677651405334,
0.13986656069755554,
0.2510359287261963,
-0.2418866902589798,
0.7732983827590942,
1.2177972793579102,
0.21814966201782227,
0.5320681929588318,
0.10345423221588135,
0.8514273762702942,
-1.1678260564804077,
-0.615749180316925,
-0.49662500619888306,
-0.6846225261688232,
0.0998125672340393,
-0.22863289713859558,
0.4720916748046875,
-0.21040105819702148,
0.025493716821074486,
0.36529678106307983,
-0.9037043452262878,
0.5330261588096619,
0.9218687415122986,
-0.10761794447898865,
0.05851462110877037,
-0.5192565321922302,
-0.09822093695402145,
-0.0926196500658989,
-0.3595885932445526,
-0.653756856918335,
0.6785255670547485,
0.418610155582428,
0.6161908507347107,
0.38907381892204285,
0.6363667249679565,
0.23570369184017181,
0.19485263526439667,
-0.5955069661140442,
0.5047752857208252,
-0.0724889263510704,
-0.36642175912857056,
-0.5695931911468506,
0.31841275095939636,
-0.6896802186965942,
-0.03241468220949173,
-0.19105111062526703,
-0.5888316035270691,
0.6149706840515137,
0.1791863590478897,
-0.8315664529800415,
0.21519748866558075,
-0.7941882014274597,
0.7769774794578552,
-0.11089075356721878,
-0.463923841714859,
-0.08923806250095367,
-0.37376588582992554,
0.12625928223133087,
0.17473214864730835,
0.17112813889980316,
0.06802568584680557,
0.07144147157669067,
0.5290884971618652,
-0.4017404019832611,
0.9310647249221802,
0.09261582791805267,
0.07494305819272995,
0.26461920142173767,
0.31934601068496704,
-0.0797092616558075,
-0.07419877499341965,
-0.1193796768784523,
-0.3817833364009857,
-0.14823946356773376,
-0.12354368716478348,
-0.6436218023300171,
0.7118621468544006,
-0.9141648411750793,
-0.15562546253204346,
-0.43928876519203186,
-0.8487910032272339,
-0.3809169828891754,
0.397797554731369,
0.026368191465735435,
0.5644698739051819,
-0.5051289796829224,
0.08180133998394012,
0.5770140290260315,
-0.16735859215259552,
0.49070531129837036,
0.19119267165660858,
-0.23090703785419464,
-0.23425081372261047,
0.8821061253547668,
0.1378839612007141,
-0.06733431667089462,
0.5107731223106384,
-0.007266433443874121,
-0.2582845687866211,
-0.6048974394798279,
-0.44137853384017944,
-0.3203223943710327,
-0.8065982460975647,
0.164747953414917,
-0.8837226629257202,
-0.17903804779052734,
-0.7220417857170105,
-0.6319781541824341,
0.024793149903416634,
-0.5884968042373657,
-0.5361313819885254,
-0.1818612962961197,
0.21928496658802032,
1.3023136854171753,
0.013145673088729382,
0.305751770734787,
-0.5365444421768188,
0.14495179057121277,
0.3540754020214081,
0.3534334897994995,
0.06860805302858353,
0.09932740777730942,
-0.03463269770145416,
-0.5656136274337769,
-0.49560320377349854,
-0.5436208248138428,
0.2230711430311203,
-0.05788051337003708,
0.7421635985374451,
0.2017173171043396,
-0.1879335194826126,
0.40063703060150146,
-0.40020808577537537,
0.7525256276130676,
0.09486030787229538,
-0.6007593870162964,
0.6570229530334473,
-0.4571010172367096,
0.518119215965271,
0.8959531784057617,
0.1489899754524231,
-0.5858707427978516,
-0.44680240750312805,
-0.6017436981201172,
-0.8415952920913696,
0.32819148898124695,
-0.004734520800411701,
0.05595904961228371,
0.2417227029800415,
0.24302449822425842,
0.3477421700954437,
0.4394437074661255,
-0.6864882111549377,
0.21790586411952972,
-0.22789420187473297,
-0.2730351984500885,
0.4371398985385895,
-0.2299451380968094,
-0.29978877305984497,
-0.110048808157444,
0.21252961456775665,
-0.1664286106824875,
0.553740382194519,
-0.043192457407712936,
0.3258569836616516,
-0.15653526782989502,
0.13827574253082275,
0.8727323412895203,
1.0842293500900269,
0.16540396213531494,
0.17192567884922028,
-0.018017077818512917,
-0.6283565759658813,
-0.10320767015218735,
0.040110308676958084,
-0.09135065227746964,
-0.2595994472503662,
0.6346254944801331,
0.6455557942390442,
-0.05051782354712486,
-0.24148066341876984,
0.37607330083847046,
-0.5018350481987,
-0.4351958930492401,
-0.6692723035812378,
0.3740953207015991,
0.18403016030788422,
0.031174704432487488,
0.08921864628791809,
0.2562970817089081,
0.353484183549881,
-0.7315961122512817,
-0.22216401994228363,
0.2317325919866562,
-0.3859179615974426,
-0.3052339553833008,
0.6955411434173584,
0.859204113483429,
-0.811687707901001,
0.6957582831382751,
-0.33056989312171936,
-0.12089157849550247,
0.6929336786270142,
0.05243055894970894,
1.0839072465896606,
0.21651260554790497,
0.27328720688819885,
-0.10250353813171387,
0.3019057810306549,
0.52671217918396,
0.4710083305835724,
-0.13716402649879456,
-0.2711722254753113,
0.14642460644245148,
-0.7500883340835571,
-0.5910173654556274,
0.06328622251749039,
-0.46466371417045593,
0.16081418097019196,
-0.9248786568641663,
-0.03782966732978821,
0.27573370933532715,
0.0915980413556099,
-0.4541563093662262,
0.07359907031059265,
-0.0008992179646156728,
0.9154282808303833,
-0.5308261513710022,
0.5561054348945618,
1.1136693954467773,
-0.4779551029205322,
-0.4334857761859894,
-0.01972084492444992,
0.3312302529811859,
-0.4228653907775879,
0.10421392321586609,
-0.04329020157456398,
-0.5069131255149841,
-0.41917967796325684,
-0.47357138991355896,
-0.7837818264961243,
1.2251509428024292,
-0.3988737165927887,
-0.357839435338974,
-0.023167574778199196,
0.1934119611978531,
0.9234184622764587,
-0.384333074092865,
0.05082792043685913,
0.3243130147457123,
0.4425971806049347,
-0.2257729023694992,
-0.7902889251708984,
-0.0003911598469130695,
-0.8361905813217163,
-0.05704474821686745,
0.07252410799264908,
-1.1081867218017578,
0.8501343131065369,
-0.0016830929089337587,
0.07035008072853088,
0.4285843074321747,
0.6019726991653442,
0.07668468356132507,
0.31161487102508545,
0.2994915843009949,
0.3747321665287018,
0.7888234257698059,
-0.02104082517325878,
0.7060760855674744,
-0.2568291425704956,
-0.18712730705738068,
0.86805260181427,
-0.4092629849910736,
0.5344697833061218,
0.6273362636566162,
0.03947460278868675,
0.6884077787399292,
0.21400989592075348,
0.3000046908855438,
0.35485681891441345,
0.07359109073877335,
-0.5843964219093323,
0.09251365810632706,
-0.23813991248607635,
0.14249564707279205,
0.06433158367872238,
0.4866083264350891,
-0.04605702683329582,
0.09952224791049957,
0.2608462870121002,
-0.048544157296419144,
0.45996442437171936,
0.2737662196159363,
0.9345099925994873,
-0.07175058126449585,
-0.7627151012420654,
-0.8075961470603943,
-0.05348265916109085,
0.1778632253408432,
-0.5862252116203308,
-0.28276464343070984,
-0.3330310881137848,
0.2122700959444046,
-0.19686296582221985,
-1.4527842998504639,
0.36638399958610535,
-0.3157569169998169,
-0.31106722354888916,
-0.7099499702453613,
0.7313293814659119,
-0.10693096369504929,
-0.6035665273666382,
-0.14603258669376373,
0.4333813786506653,
-0.1747473180294037,
0.39074912667274475,
-0.3689897656440735,
0.4978961646556854,
-0.5196523666381836,
-0.09328275173902512,
0.23832815885543823,
0.9336526393890381,
-0.26624491810798645,
0.6599680185317993,
0.36102816462516785,
-0.2519068419933319,
-0.09070158749818802,
0.17297814786434174,
0.8535484671592712,
-0.37974604964256287,
-0.919696033000946,
-0.4107353389263153,
0.5214727520942688,
-0.3678525388240814,
-1.2674058675765991,
0.48407647013664246,
0.5770353078842163,
0.5250827074050903,
-0.13728542625904083,
1.210328459739685,
-0.5033676624298096,
0.6507768034934998,
-0.1968199759721756,
0.9898821115493774,
-0.5067766308784485,
-0.007290148641914129,
-0.3979678153991699,
-0.7619662880897522,
-0.45902520418167114,
0.7950929403305054,
-0.03148198127746582,
0.13319146633148193,
0.7621868848800659,
0.38772761821746826,
-0.2597658336162567,
0.25353214144706726,
0.10164251923561096,
-0.2840532064437866,
0.6318262815475464,
0.3882472515106201,
0.9300498962402344,
0.2194102257490158,
0.37759608030319214,
-0.7215116024017334,
-0.4057995080947876,
-0.11812611669301987,
-0.7625554800033569,
-1.0912668704986572,
-0.8937014937400818,
-0.19334545731544495,
0.06833550333976746,
-0.2647980749607086,
0.6804900169372559,
0.5037360191345215,
-0.3472048342227936,
-0.22639308869838715,
0.009320268407464027,
0.11337850242853165,
-0.03680715337395668,
-0.20558825135231018,
0.03226913884282112,
0.134078711271286,
-0.7338830232620239,
0.3633585572242737,
0.5878475308418274,
-0.04394717514514923,
-0.9704862833023071,
0.42651328444480896,
-0.07869642972946167,
0.13756133615970612,
0.5654922723770142,
0.38302260637283325,
-0.3915679156780243,
-0.403644323348999,
0.3871888220310211,
-0.37867286801338196,
-0.31046855449676514,
1.1636998653411865,
-0.40488845109939575,
0.3932730555534363,
0.887431800365448,
0.48105254769325256,
-0.30083051323890686,
-0.21791425347328186,
0.8004724979400635,
-0.8393369913101196,
-0.12220486253499985,
0.17274872958660126,
0.21135729551315308,
0.20965109765529633,
-0.7542360424995422,
0.5316426753997803,
0.037195999175310135,
-0.7150856256484985,
-0.5244466066360474,
-0.04233873263001442,
-1.0606848001480103,
-0.47227880358695984,
0.7322750687599182,
0.13252775371074677,
-0.1376735121011734,
-0.29549649357795715,
-0.6121201515197754,
-0.11922512948513031,
-0.3359682261943817,
1.2364606857299805,
1.0253610610961914,
-0.8099361062049866,
-0.11739742010831833,
-0.6809581518173218,
0.5628024339675903,
0.040700338780879974,
-1.2242107391357422,
-0.07287297397851944,
0.5654183030128479,
-0.09244873374700546,
0.7591709494590759,
1.024226427078247,
0.281941294670105,
0.6332157254219055,
0.32080551981925964,
0.2836417257785797,
-0.1563737541437149,
-0.896706223487854,
0.05136650428175926,
0.2146199345588684,
0.19555209577083588,
-0.17738065123558044
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14112v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14112v2
|
Benchmarking Chinese Commonsense Reasoning of LLMs: From Chinese-Specifics to Reasoning-Memorization Correlations
| 2024-03-21T03:52:01 | 2024-04-19T06:57:21 |
Jiaxing Sun, Weiquan Huang, Jiang Wu, Chenya Gu, Wei Li, Songyang Zhang, Hang Yan, Conghui He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce CHARM, the first benchmark for comprehensively and in-depth
evaluating the commonsense reasoning ability of large language models (LLMs) in
Chinese, which covers both globally known and Chinese-specific commonsense. We
evaluated 7 English and 12 Chinese-oriented LLMs on CHARM, employing 5
representative prompt strategies for improving LLMs' reasoning ability, such as
Chain-of-Thought. Our findings indicate that the LLM's language orientation and
the task's domain influence the effectiveness of the prompt strategy, which
enriches previous research findings. We built closely-interconnected reasoning
and memorization tasks, and found that some LLMs struggle with memorizing
Chinese commonsense, affecting their reasoning ability, while others show
differences in reasoning despite similar memorization performance. We also
evaluated the LLMs' memorization-independent reasoning abilities and analyzed
the typical errors. Our study precisely identified the LLMs' strengths and
weaknesses, providing the clear direction for optimization. It can also serve
as a reference for studies in other fields. We will release CHARM at
https://github.com/opendatalab/CHARM .
|
[
-0.1277688592672348,
-0.6629977822303772,
0.6141603589057922,
0.2714943587779999,
-0.1820073425769806,
-0.12516245245933533,
-0.40116289258003235,
-0.02104458585381508,
0.055669430643320084,
0.27248769998550415,
-0.3726116716861725,
-0.6331924200057983,
-0.15221506357192993,
0.3009372651576996,
-0.011808425188064575,
0.5705633759498596,
0.10708649456501007,
0.3775571584701538,
-0.4065183699131012,
-0.17868295311927795,
-0.5382073521614075,
-0.5041078925132751,
-0.7685050368309021,
-0.2997859716415405,
0.6874376535415649,
0.3439139723777771,
0.41782861948013306,
0.5887104868888855,
0.6351200938224792,
0.20560896396636963,
-0.4127982556819916,
0.46655967831611633,
-0.5608348846435547,
-0.004124005790799856,
-0.5620181560516357,
-0.5445809364318848,
-0.6518272161483765,
-0.12495619058609009,
0.634006142616272,
0.48783549666404724,
0.011205745860934258,
0.056303925812244415,
0.04795953258872032,
0.641124427318573,
-0.6240423917770386,
-0.07599523663520813,
-0.9053583741188049,
-0.008445801213383675,
-0.38231751322746277,
-0.3501981794834137,
-0.43014857172966003,
-0.474867582321167,
-0.01708132028579712,
-0.6901415586471558,
0.04174315184354782,
0.35926100611686707,
0.7104854583740234,
0.04020309820771217,
-0.3183612823486328,
-0.10769515484571457,
-0.03270113468170166,
1.0997127294540405,
-0.7570071220397949,
0.27568554878234863,
0.25098493695259094,
0.24348084628582,
-0.45248469710350037,
-0.7028182148933411,
-0.4687708914279938,
-0.502755880355835,
0.0970262736082077,
0.3191669285297394,
0.20098912715911865,
0.008748507127165794,
0.4975457191467285,
0.5430961847305298,
-0.6019040942192078,
0.14712625741958618,
0.022129889577627182,
-0.30956801772117615,
0.8376066088676453,
0.4470355808734894,
0.4249303936958313,
-0.04808492213487625,
-0.5183455348014832,
-0.10638170689344406,
-0.858803927898407,
0.10221225023269653,
0.2045789510011673,
0.5145135521888733,
0.05136772617697716,
0.34364816546440125,
-0.17420606315135956,
0.30617380142211914,
-0.1589818000793457,
-0.3882272243499756,
0.11188456416130066,
-0.39287132024765015,
-0.03897352144122124,
0.010927495546638966,
0.7324868440628052,
0.5103206038475037,
0.2725575268268585,
0.03509491682052612,
-0.3939830958843231,
-0.2316371202468872,
-0.056377485394477844,
-0.5552264451980591,
-0.2667858302593231,
0.24512510001659393,
-0.646054208278656,
-0.035526737570762634,
-0.08449529111385345,
-0.6483047008514404,
-0.7025482654571533,
-0.14208568632602692,
0.3080141842365265,
-0.5014018416404724,
-0.42473849654197693,
0.014913647435605526,
-0.2617867887020111,
0.4451141059398651,
0.4905658960342407,
-0.8527781367301941,
0.32525864243507385,
0.9915454387664795,
0.843841552734375,
-0.5716731548309326,
-0.593826413154602,
-0.7413589358329773,
-0.169814795255661,
-0.4255833625793457,
0.8405886888504028,
-0.3232667148113251,
-0.4034254848957062,
0.15009631216526031,
-0.24724344909191132,
-0.0785587728023529,
-0.8566058874130249,
0.8911473751068115,
-0.1960691511631012,
-0.3365783989429474,
-0.8281936049461365,
-0.7083551287651062,
0.09374041855335236,
0.520973265171051,
-0.7497705221176147,
0.9101024270057678,
-0.1873195618391037,
-0.7268909811973572,
0.20301146805286407,
-0.29399213194847107,
-0.47722187638282776,
0.05171804502606392,
-0.09883828461170197,
-0.11420147866010666,
0.18192267417907715,
0.1387835443019867,
0.3576919734477997,
-0.6705294847488403,
0.20183852314949036,
-0.5781710743904114,
-0.6282012462615967,
0.4900154173374176,
-0.6204545497894287,
0.7849758863449097,
0.3848479390144348,
0.1174946203827858,
0.030336884781718254,
-0.5290308594703674,
-0.011953971348702908,
0.3345525562763214,
0.006954381242394447,
-0.38549184799194336,
0.038138892501592636,
-0.15426209568977356,
-0.04463285580277443,
0.5505977272987366,
-0.17706367373466492,
0.3280896544456482,
-0.05911198630928993,
0.12968358397483826,
0.7619706988334656,
-0.017250346019864082,
0.0424797348678112,
-0.4935052990913391,
0.0053232042118906975,
0.24584737420082092,
0.21195316314697266,
-0.46953627467155457,
-0.2670506238937378,
-0.5988285541534424,
-0.15585775673389435,
0.07139424234628677,
0.6489080190658569,
-0.5930530428886414,
0.221388041973114,
-0.07428945600986481,
-0.3959876596927643,
-0.2386385202407837,
0.24562974274158478,
0.6379849314689636,
0.287092924118042,
0.30364954471588135,
-0.380508691072464,
-0.07870998233556747,
-0.6652584671974182,
-0.7830587029457092,
-0.2554205358028412,
0.2527928650379181,
0.20611359179019928,
0.5263592600822449,
0.28416383266448975,
0.5967625975608826,
-0.4432827830314636,
-0.0916135236620903,
-0.35606229305267334,
0.0023701535537838936,
0.3944265842437744,
0.234757661819458,
0.17803789675235748,
-0.6555761098861694,
-0.41080549359321594,
0.06735116988420486,
-0.6387774348258972,
-0.18226806819438934,
-0.2194928675889969,
-0.18998423218727112,
0.15086928009986877,
0.4837394058704376,
-0.43497857451438904,
0.2115236073732376,
0.06801000237464905,
-0.2232988476753235,
0.9825958609580994,
-0.1658506542444229,
0.14883415400981903,
-0.9038827419281006,
-0.01587233878672123,
0.15082839131355286,
0.2141065001487732,
-0.6800477504730225,
0.0682927668094635,
0.2663613557815552,
0.14561709761619568,
-0.5533129572868347,
1.0156631469726562,
-0.5192945599555969,
-0.09273948520421982,
-0.1669374257326126,
0.4405158758163452,
-0.11793452501296997,
0.5983741879463196,
0.2747012972831726,
0.8790255188941956,
0.49497705698013306,
-0.5983538031578064,
0.5260276794433594,
-0.12750476598739624,
-0.28169503808021545,
0.8893126249313354,
-0.4660666286945343,
-0.011745910160243511,
0.38797780871391296,
-0.04630904272198677,
-0.8917086124420166,
-0.05202765017747879,
-0.11650625616312027,
-0.37110984325408936,
0.12191774696111679,
0.035091500729322433,
-0.8269215822219849,
-0.46935006976127625,
-0.38005414605140686,
0.2429054230451584,
0.48891186714172363,
-0.8335079550743103,
0.3898398280143738,
-0.11313318461179733,
0.15168270468711853,
-0.5743756294250488,
-0.4356129467487335,
-0.07977531105279922,
-0.3608302175998688,
-0.3952772319316864,
0.14335963129997253,
-0.15243948996067047,
-0.5530152320861816,
-0.30074426531791687,
-0.3697046637535095,
-0.17202025651931763,
0.2324485033750534,
-0.2744736969470978,
0.2420201599597931,
-0.13938486576080322,
0.2326551079750061,
-0.0188664048910141,
-0.03620360046625137,
0.23240314424037933,
-0.23067548871040344,
0.4362943470478058,
-0.28977951407432556,
-0.6521784067153931,
-0.33382949233055115,
-0.09135960787534714,
0.36112701892852783,
-0.18954011797904968,
0.46832039952278137,
0.4642986059188843,
-0.24694378674030304,
-0.43648046255111694,
-0.6930233836174011,
-0.32256507873535156,
-0.4956803321838379,
0.3940379321575165,
-0.6178610920906067,
-0.5659061670303345,
0.6588315367698669,
-0.3246002495288849,
0.10824218392372131,
0.21242064237594604,
0.45717528462409973,
0.15210741758346558,
0.7036629915237427,
0.07361947000026703,
-0.4069998860359192,
0.17670992016792297,
0.20375066995620728,
0.10026952624320984,
-0.8300920724868774,
0.006192024797201157,
-0.21985290944576263,
0.0641203224658966,
-0.5960596799850464,
-0.5378506183624268,
0.2843843102455139,
0.36882808804512024,
-0.4771530032157898,
0.10255441069602966,
-0.33399698138237,
0.521152675151825,
0.7349953651428223,
0.059042513370513916,
0.4714325964450836,
-0.29841184616088867,
-0.4192679822444916,
-0.013550187461078167,
-0.505608320236206,
-0.4675155282020569,
1.0646120309829712,
0.25814321637153625,
0.7676316499710083,
-0.0382237583398819,
0.8292134404182434,
0.15272977948188782,
0.04176753759384155,
-0.5139761567115784,
0.9739570021629333,
-0.2097940742969513,
-0.2866593897342682,
-0.18354324996471405,
-0.5725921392440796,
-0.5913025140762329,
0.2865765392780304,
0.09297686815261841,
-0.8400723934173584,
-0.36379507184028625,
0.21536536514759064,
-0.0684831365942955,
0.5789924263954163,
-0.538989245891571,
0.8277115821838379,
-0.6612211465835571,
-0.7265231609344482,
-0.1962885558605194,
-0.34494489431381226,
0.6670734286308289,
0.10820697247982025,
-0.11474286019802094,
-0.24065713584423065,
0.07653183490037918,
0.501587986946106,
-0.2951474189758301,
0.7170113921165466,
-0.012375697493553162,
-0.23066450655460358,
0.37874728441238403,
0.04591800644993782,
0.5826325416564941,
0.062241461127996445,
-0.12469343096017838,
0.14391474425792694,
0.02567991055548191,
-0.3786497712135315,
-0.7280094027519226,
0.712730884552002,
-0.599256157875061,
-0.7956368923187256,
-0.4871913492679596,
-0.529967188835144,
-0.2554595470428467,
0.32607781887054443,
0.04081515222787857,
0.40880921483039856,
-0.4712747633457184,
-0.1974276900291443,
1.0266340970993042,
-0.4466998875141144,
0.32321029901504517,
0.5424620509147644,
-0.20670507848262787,
-0.5741990208625793,
1.1898016929626465,
0.009756461717188358,
0.3626967668533325,
0.7307447791099548,
0.32125431299209595,
-0.3257041275501251,
-0.5318652987480164,
-0.12077227234840393,
0.3755384087562561,
-0.9711645841598511,
-0.009301712736487389,
-0.22385628521442413,
-0.3106509745121002,
-0.3871890902519226,
-0.10584384202957153,
-0.4817497432231903,
-0.14682523906230927,
-0.13556820154190063,
0.23939767479896545,
0.3646596670150757,
0.37233585119247437,
-0.05321475490927696,
-0.15291962027549744,
-0.61311274766922,
0.2998139262199402,
0.35828107595443726,
0.4789627194404602,
0.24895240366458893,
-0.46594810485839844,
-0.2552088499069214,
-0.31065523624420166,
-0.3007735311985016,
-0.6504156589508057,
0.25907963514328003,
-0.3495006561279297,
0.9341691136360168,
0.7385431528091431,
0.3444558084011078,
0.5921698212623596,
-0.30976033210754395,
1.0962796211242676,
0.25566720962524414,
-0.9298056960105896,
0.4788386821746826,
-0.37108927965164185,
0.362559974193573,
0.48020705580711365,
0.05741994455456734,
-0.6261824369430542,
-0.35081636905670166,
-0.4310223162174225,
-0.5883756875991821,
0.42943039536476135,
0.06648681312799454,
-0.1996196061372757,
-0.2917358875274658,
0.1436605602502823,
-0.06189104914665222,
0.08356165885925293,
-0.5783855319023132,
-0.477433979511261,
-0.11780532449483871,
-0.1403273344039917,
0.17890703678131104,
-0.2578820288181305,
-0.11742671579122543,
-0.12769468128681183,
0.5499081015586853,
-0.27637720108032227,
0.31240391731262207,
0.15269242227077484,
-0.08228854835033417,
0.23368841409683228,
0.3355869650840759,
0.683332085609436,
0.4516569972038269,
-0.1432827115058899,
0.19573745131492615,
0.7226150631904602,
-0.49181097745895386,
-0.10740114003419876,
-0.037597332149744034,
0.08926460891962051,
-0.2488558292388916,
0.5084222555160522,
0.5757437944412231,
0.06820353865623474,
-0.9399778842926025,
0.42097869515419006,
0.03053952567279339,
-0.09721674770116806,
-0.2717699110507965,
0.30583035945892334,
0.08666176348924637,
0.3572373390197754,
0.363338440656662,
-0.5009433031082153,
0.053993239998817444,
-0.4291976988315582,
0.06296699494123459,
0.4930627942085266,
-0.05064428597688675,
-0.22771434485912323,
0.5010931491851807,
0.27376651763916016,
-0.1526954025030136,
0.5518309473991394,
-0.45139843225479126,
-0.6366742849349976,
0.6625346541404724,
0.6628475189208984,
1.142194390296936,
-0.09161821007728577,
-0.11593929678201675,
0.6471360325813293,
0.29322484135627747,
-0.3499467074871063,
0.2901933193206787,
-0.14698362350463867,
-0.8300216794013977,
-0.12201022356748581,
-0.15111492574214935,
-0.8548727035522461,
0.13566337525844574,
-0.7248976826667786,
0.3844689726829529,
-0.5215649604797363,
0.06491737067699432,
-0.5515084266662598,
0.7221023440361023,
-0.5276708006858826,
0.07896575331687927,
0.33932480216026306,
1.382137417793274,
-0.6346564888954163,
0.8321381211280823,
0.5818659663200378,
-0.43114039301872253,
-0.8381252288818359,
0.1899847835302353,
0.337307870388031,
-0.9093784093856812,
0.6394734382629395,
0.28488779067993164,
-0.10788856446743011,
-0.33023470640182495,
-0.5629459619522095,
-0.7017771601676941,
1.3676878213882446,
-0.14571629464626312,
-0.7245230674743652,
0.3480340838432312,
-0.0040245456621050835,
0.5007463097572327,
-0.22390304505825043,
0.6925375461578369,
0.737585723400116,
0.5103929042816162,
0.10053959488868713,
-1.0060267448425293,
0.12422924488782883,
-0.42657557129859924,
0.13797640800476074,
-0.12427397817373276,
-1.225258469581604,
0.8428722023963928,
-0.2529478967189789,
-0.20474356412887573,
0.3672151565551758,
0.9182519912719727,
0.9434382915496826,
0.729678213596344,
0.28282633423805237,
0.6221573948860168,
1.1040455102920532,
-0.2072148323059082,
0.8613706231117249,
-0.2603110074996948,
0.025578627362847328,
1.025673508644104,
-0.7600103616714478,
0.7597841620445251,
0.32708311080932617,
-0.25785037875175476,
0.2717139720916748,
0.5406301617622375,
-0.1308799386024475,
0.3672196865081787,
0.4256433844566345,
-0.33099696040153503,
-0.20332953333854675,
-0.26777416467666626,
-0.3379015028476715,
-0.03525514155626297,
0.4277726411819458,
-0.04236704483628273,
0.027516957372426987,
-0.2899879217147827,
0.25530576705932617,
0.16838043928146362,
-0.566027045249939,
0.6812666058540344,
0.21147388219833374,
-0.927169680595398,
0.5267955660820007,
-0.1982899308204651,
0.7025899291038513,
-0.6353700160980225,
0.0652548223733902,
-0.7093827128410339,
0.2594165802001953,
0.0027175061404705048,
-0.9146777987480164,
-0.29816004633903503,
0.00906285922974348,
-0.01483163796365261,
0.05341728776693344,
0.8347873687744141,
-0.4328749477863312,
-0.07096652686595917,
0.3184768557548523,
0.39052602648735046,
0.37836238741874695,
0.07980803400278091,
-0.759244441986084,
0.2154259979724884,
-0.11511000990867615,
-0.2644326090812683,
0.4810429513454437,
0.8459413051605225,
-0.13964742422103882,
0.8570555448532104,
0.6387250423431396,
0.30067160725593567,
-0.1294223815202713,
0.3726631700992584,
0.7945784330368042,
-1.1072839498519897,
-0.23132595419883728,
-0.9146544933319092,
0.2004726529121399,
-0.32743340730667114,
-0.48738908767700195,
1.0552165508270264,
0.5600999593734741,
0.8247427344322205,
0.0683988705277443,
0.7902184128761292,
0.34694501757621765,
0.5032423138618469,
-0.6923002600669861,
0.3935158848762512,
-0.6573092341423035,
0.4136398434638977,
-0.4533228278160095,
-0.834213376045227,
-0.21725982427597046,
0.32201826572418213,
-0.36382007598876953,
0.01094602420926094,
0.9460932016372681,
0.9849790334701538,
0.23719047009944916,
0.05827285721898079,
0.5366191267967224,
-0.03061486966907978,
0.30553510785102844,
0.8511868119239807,
1.1255697011947632,
-0.18378907442092896,
0.4858799874782562,
-0.2112470418214798,
-0.02702810987830162,
-0.2645033597946167,
-1.0049041509628296,
-1.287743330001831,
-0.357028603553772,
-0.2222289890050888,
-0.303406685590744,
0.15733402967453003,
1.1599822044372559,
0.19674108922481537,
-0.6837676167488098,
-0.4205976724624634,
-0.20065048336982727,
0.5548974275588989,
-0.6854972839355469,
-0.2513008713722229,
0.5377753973007202,
-0.7242982387542725,
-0.6740314364433289,
0.27192214131355286,
0.39561328291893005,
-0.11738140136003494,
-0.24413515627384186,
-0.300187349319458,
0.06667834520339966,
0.23835541307926178,
0.42093637585639954,
0.4046914577484131,
-1.012514591217041,
-0.048633258789777756,
0.179229274392128,
-0.36999833583831787,
-0.08107688277959824,
0.9800689816474915,
-0.36801671981811523,
0.5697158575057983,
0.5852864384651184,
0.49683812260627747,
0.0039648269303143024,
-0.002281774301081896,
0.39440011978149414,
-0.36678433418273926,
-0.1710510551929474,
0.007043111138045788,
0.4830566346645355,
0.23133403062820435,
-0.12975095212459564,
0.4969758987426758,
0.3211999535560608,
-0.6659972071647644,
-0.8993748426437378,
0.13461196422576904,
-0.9931681156158447,
-0.2659837305545807,
1.4165949821472168,
-0.2787707448005676,
-0.2612825632095337,
0.01564972475171089,
-0.12422792613506317,
0.12009717524051666,
-0.40529242157936096,
0.522293210029602,
0.721044659614563,
0.050131283700466156,
-0.4038035273551941,
-0.25505924224853516,
0.4959336817264557,
0.6288982033729553,
-0.7641865015029907,
0.2900453507900238,
0.23573219776153564,
0.025776062160730362,
0.027592957019805908,
0.7995857000350952,
0.00695202499628067,
0.5087628960609436,
0.3174532353878021,
-0.026080528274178505,
0.04282255843281746,
-0.3132583498954773,
-0.14411871135234833,
-0.19422079622745514,
0.3336640000343323,
0.0027340224478393793
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14101v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14101v1
|
Text-Enhanced Data-free Approach for Federated Class-Incremental Learning
| 2024-03-21T03:24:01 | 2024-03-21T03:24:01 |
Minh-Tuan Tran, Trung Le, Xuan-May Le, Mehrtash Harandi, Dinh Phung
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Federated Class-Incremental Learning (FCIL) is an underexplored yet pivotal
issue, involving the dynamic addition of new classes in the context of
federated learning. In this field, Data-Free Knowledge Transfer (DFKT) plays a
crucial role in addressing catastrophic forgetting and data privacy problems.
However, prior approaches lack the crucial synergy between DFKT and the model
training phases, causing DFKT to encounter difficulties in generating
high-quality data from a non-anchored latent space of the old task model. In
this paper, we introduce LANDER (Label Text Centered Data-Free Knowledge
Transfer) to address this issue by utilizing label text embeddings (LTE)
produced by pretrained language models. Specifically, during the model training
phase, our approach treats LTE as anchor points and constrains the feature
embeddings of corresponding training samples around them, enriching the
surrounding area with more meaningful information. In the DFKT phase, by using
these LTE anchors, LANDER can synthesize more meaningful samples, thereby
effectively addressing the forgetting problem. Additionally, instead of tightly
constraining embeddings toward the anchor, the Bounding Loss is introduced to
encourage sample embeddings to remain flexible within a defined radius. This
approach preserves the natural differences in sample embeddings and mitigates
the embedding overlap caused by heterogeneous federated settings. Extensive
experiments conducted on CIFAR100, Tiny-ImageNet, and ImageNet demonstrate that
LANDER significantly outperforms previous methods and achieves state-of-the-art
performance in FCIL. The code is available at
https://github.com/tmtuan1307/lander.
|
[
-0.30334749817848206,
-0.4497605562210083,
0.2550024390220642,
0.14442534744739532,
-0.08834763616323471,
0.22085148096084595,
-0.10491541773080826,
-0.12773801386356354,
-0.0394723117351532,
0.45877805352211,
-0.271104633808136,
-0.6179095506668091,
-0.6262926459312439,
-0.3240901827812195,
-0.36754655838012695,
1.2510976791381836,
-0.4520084857940674,
-0.3644314408302307,
-0.4888531267642975,
-0.36792153120040894,
-0.30025216937065125,
-0.5286644697189331,
-0.3592573404312134,
-0.5129190683364868,
0.40547746419906616,
0.5565342307090759,
0.5469546914100647,
0.39914780855178833,
0.4388406574726105,
0.07361342757940292,
0.15448805689811707,
-0.2034030258655548,
-0.6783307790756226,
-0.08963882923126221,
-0.03412031754851341,
-0.37637096643447876,
-0.42839211225509644,
0.13498735427856445,
0.7450419664382935,
0.7413437962532043,
-0.08786080777645111,
-0.1512424349784851,
-0.08522437512874603,
0.866087019443512,
-0.6727267503738403,
0.13305090367794037,
-0.565250039100647,
0.35156166553497314,
-0.0160199124366045,
-0.13780009746551514,
-0.5768923759460449,
-0.3845894932746887,
0.39085716009140015,
-0.8441592454910278,
0.31493833661079407,
-0.23176516592502594,
0.7691104412078857,
0.32775893807411194,
-0.3948940336704254,
-0.35298168659210205,
-0.5105443596839905,
0.6445078253746033,
-0.3221050202846527,
0.7135629653930664,
0.28278470039367676,
0.19650393724441528,
-0.11969951540231705,
-0.6312497854232788,
-0.5642334818840027,
-0.10749652981758118,
-0.16595882177352905,
0.3169623017311096,
0.0446789488196373,
-0.028346272185444832,
0.03443083539605141,
0.5721126198768616,
-0.3409184515476227,
0.08688490837812424,
0.04982681944966316,
-0.11619481444358826,
0.4361908733844757,
-0.39199724793434143,
0.010619644075632095,
0.1761409342288971,
-0.632392942905426,
-0.4022631049156189,
-0.7823336124420166,
0.3011450171470642,
0.07689324766397476,
0.1857699155807495,
-0.24642568826675415,
0.2577793598175049,
-0.19119812548160553,
0.4779854714870453,
0.35580793023109436,
-0.09917620569467545,
0.30804312229156494,
0.12599964439868927,
-0.1929430067539215,
0.10250076651573181,
0.5989521145820618,
0.15286685526371002,
-0.0187761839479208,
-0.590472400188446,
-0.32471752166748047,
-0.3753190338611603,
-0.053407374769449234,
-0.9198700189590454,
-0.3506084978580475,
0.1844010204076767,
-0.17450952529907227,
-0.5141530632972717,
0.209181010723114,
-0.7820108532905579,
-0.22496551275253296,
-0.04905586689710617,
0.5204935669898987,
-0.3797725737094879,
-0.30482611060142517,
-0.2694054841995239,
0.08331531286239624,
0.2841252088546753,
0.3494596779346466,
-0.9200347661972046,
0.3309182822704315,
0.5746833682060242,
0.73346346616745,
-0.13085998594760895,
-0.16605941951274872,
-0.7828251123428345,
0.27376970648765564,
-0.12442243844270706,
0.7639322280883789,
-0.3940157890319824,
-0.3322157561779022,
-0.12438290566205978,
0.1022426038980484,
-0.4148087203502655,
-0.27934107184410095,
0.03909590467810631,
-0.7124678492546082,
0.4036000370979309,
-0.0442037396132946,
-0.8935647010803223,
-0.3110794723033905,
0.2742726802825928,
-0.6780152916908264,
1.057875633239746,
0.2991093397140503,
-0.6622009873390198,
0.42282670736312866,
-0.7962810397148132,
-0.28303876519203186,
0.10957571119070053,
-0.3727835416793823,
-0.6930326819419861,
-0.07690403610467911,
0.28374889492988586,
0.6559818983078003,
0.04949840158224106,
0.7656344771385193,
-0.03323092684149742,
-0.35520464181900024,
0.058812130242586136,
-0.27719786763191223,
0.5346412658691406,
-0.062243856489658356,
-0.6537096500396729,
-0.19723059237003326,
-0.645317018032074,
0.1336999088525772,
0.05577051267027855,
-0.4079142212867737,
-0.45919832587242126,
-0.2066393941640854,
-0.0050661638379096985,
0.15839846432209015,
0.08517829328775406,
-0.5880131125450134,
0.1987212747335434,
-0.3718380033969879,
0.05335655063390732,
0.7140337228775024,
-0.1119929775595665,
0.8435055613517761,
-0.5811538696289062,
0.3024526834487915,
0.22478394210338593,
-0.057133354246616364,
-0.26784345507621765,
-0.1831534206867218,
-0.880648136138916,
-0.19827495515346527,
0.5159781575202942,
0.7118555903434753,
-1.1549817323684692,
0.2049776166677475,
-0.7448881268501282,
-0.5389269590377808,
-0.3991856575012207,
0.09414826333522797,
0.27300554513931274,
0.20712806284427643,
0.4185684621334076,
-0.11480895429849625,
-0.08034083992242813,
-0.4236856698989868,
0.10755259543657303,
0.23007498681545258,
0.0415622852742672,
0.5144687294960022,
0.5872209668159485,
-0.3236325979232788,
1.19761061668396,
-0.30022940039634705,
-0.42098522186279297,
0.06568668782711029,
0.10143117606639862,
-0.08289216458797455,
0.6747710108757019,
0.7495940923690796,
-1.0127685070037842,
-0.5474550724029541,
0.24589964747428894,
-0.8148974776268005,
0.05968159809708595,
-0.22338883578777313,
-0.027837667614221573,
0.3467346131801605,
0.1187281385064125,
-0.20421628654003143,
0.3728586733341217,
0.8414209485054016,
-0.4063710570335388,
0.15123575925827026,
0.02500869892537594,
0.20114076137542725,
-1.0656367540359497,
0.07821795344352722,
-0.27969858050346375,
-0.06816262006759644,
-0.7265045046806335,
-0.1801120936870575,
0.12862245738506317,
-0.22685258090496063,
-0.23331525921821594,
0.5862210392951965,
-0.3130798637866974,
0.01794530637562275,
-0.1737883985042572,
0.0913941040635109,
-0.006635480094701052,
0.4516996741294861,
0.15131527185440063,
0.7740691304206848,
0.42417699098587036,
-0.39469796419143677,
-0.11162931472063065,
0.4307814836502075,
0.04814593121409416,
0.4558454155921936,
-0.30932945013046265,
0.3771125078201294,
-0.22823867201805115,
0.3548075556755066,
-0.7740076780319214,
-0.17929735779762268,
0.0777946338057518,
-0.3935645520687103,
0.2719269394874573,
-0.15146423876285553,
-0.26801905035972595,
-0.12603643536567688,
-0.2611561715602875,
0.26946088671684265,
0.2565135359764099,
-0.9127761125564575,
0.4723987877368927,
0.2748923897743225,
-0.11701827496290207,
-0.5844368934631348,
-0.6102908253669739,
-0.04976149648427963,
-0.022989939898252487,
-0.5609670281410217,
0.680308997631073,
-0.027094826102256775,
0.10718083381652832,
0.037504322826862335,
-0.2228165864944458,
-0.522930920124054,
0.1485072523355484,
0.3011094629764557,
0.0003463196044322103,
-0.2103876769542694,
0.422196626663208,
0.5033649802207947,
-0.17597387731075287,
-0.22690542042255402,
-0.5824519395828247,
0.11620626598596573,
-0.17381909489631653,
-0.20779195427894592,
-0.3295513689517975,
0.4319723844528198,
0.6154191493988037,
-0.09923211485147476,
0.9446947574615479,
0.5907023549079895,
-0.30513718724250793,
-0.2506955564022064,
-0.5724801421165466,
-0.26549261808395386,
-0.4391884207725525,
-0.19340915977954865,
-0.3650556206703186,
-1.5167555809020996,
0.38630974292755127,
-0.2784369885921478,
0.2929162383079529,
0.20149829983711243,
0.0374148003757,
-0.1337522566318512,
0.22294339537620544,
1.0430092811584473,
-0.09569200873374939,
0.5216659307479858,
-0.3781674802303314,
0.2564524710178375,
-0.5402790904045105,
-0.31584712862968445,
0.003507076995447278,
-0.11316657066345215,
-0.5643372535705566,
-0.6159383058547974,
0.06265737861394882,
0.028604276478290558,
-0.06940454244613647,
0.2529481053352356,
-0.509494960308075,
0.36449146270751953,
0.30072206258773804,
0.10457871854305267,
0.29066717624664307,
0.27576079964637756,
-0.3086751103401184,
-0.08100524544715881,
-0.9793261885643005,
-0.287913054227829,
0.9594662189483643,
0.3845770061016083,
0.5637088418006897,
-0.06685280054807663,
0.9639233946800232,
0.3215458393096924,
0.8664027452468872,
-0.6637420654296875,
0.3088969886302948,
-0.37216317653656006,
-0.34930524230003357,
-0.07245936244726181,
-0.5810770392417908,
-0.6318246722221375,
0.21510663628578186,
-0.21092790365219116,
-0.5887704491615295,
0.2839187979698181,
0.16234858334064484,
-0.24213416874408722,
0.5701495409011841,
-0.4617612361907959,
0.580567479133606,
-0.20261569321155548,
-0.45156654715538025,
0.2750014364719391,
-0.5033113956451416,
0.07793895155191422,
-0.2532415986061096,
0.19967135787010193,
-0.09498880058526993,
0.22603125870227814,
0.9830359816551208,
-0.3276638686656952,
0.8092664480209351,
-0.6659145355224609,
-0.25254711508750916,
0.3425173759460449,
-0.2038831263780594,
0.579951822757721,
0.06715104728937149,
-0.027608703821897507,
0.2512415051460266,
-0.26679274439811707,
-0.3771512806415558,
-0.47906288504600525,
0.7689440250396729,
-0.7985687851905823,
-0.18270964920520782,
-0.18746735155582428,
-0.6827979683876038,
-0.20808392763137817,
0.15995019674301147,
0.1728280782699585,
0.5197081565856934,
-0.14199712872505188,
0.4647964537143707,
0.9370627999305725,
-0.32567405700683594,
0.4309917390346527,
0.5953181982040405,
0.023288505151867867,
-0.7140952944755554,
0.9274167418479919,
0.2396336793899536,
0.2744116187095642,
0.8697670102119446,
-0.00853878166526556,
-0.15710031986236572,
-0.4586859345436096,
-0.3059019446372986,
0.10085977613925934,
-0.6689329743385315,
-0.3020951449871063,
-0.8771734237670898,
-0.28969699144363403,
-0.3012292981147766,
-0.7107363939285278,
-0.6183450818061829,
-0.40368106961250305,
-0.15013106167316437,
-0.11790494620800018,
0.6586917042732239,
0.3876285254955292,
0.07367663085460663,
0.8227508664131165,
-0.7287592887878418,
0.04355674609541893,
0.1885976344347,
0.7019787430763245,
-0.01506736408919096,
-0.20467537641525269,
-0.27114883065223694,
0.2571936249732971,
-0.08342193067073822,
-0.4635535776615143,
0.08441580086946487,
0.3320956230163574,
0.5953213572502136,
0.0010898590553551912,
0.09347891807556152,
0.5096494555473328,
-0.28443607687950134,
0.37386539578437805,
0.11246293783187866,
-0.895830512046814,
0.5764767527580261,
-0.4625004827976227,
0.2788914144039154,
0.7584278583526611,
0.3575492799282074,
-0.32198429107666016,
-0.34282973408699036,
-0.69426429271698,
-0.925919234752655,
0.399221807718277,
0.351702481508255,
-0.012289158068597317,
0.1727762520313263,
0.4346838593482971,
0.39316198229789734,
0.24948421120643616,
-1.0436594486236572,
-0.32062891125679016,
-0.3533278703689575,
-0.3634626269340515,
0.1726064234972,
-0.11085086315870285,
0.12957000732421875,
-0.28408071398735046,
0.5983719825744629,
-0.28683745861053467,
0.5584993958473206,
0.3554931581020355,
-0.4919063448905945,
0.02555236406624317,
0.3936176896095276,
0.2831518054008484,
0.21634900569915771,
-0.19772575795650482,
-0.07177682220935822,
0.13202449679374695,
-0.7029892802238464,
0.5071374773979187,
0.6652527451515198,
-0.4626944661140442,
0.01338380016386509,
0.16990447044372559,
0.8520547151565552,
0.5279405117034912,
-0.3055671155452728,
0.7093678712844849,
0.004787174053490162,
-0.5617107152938843,
-0.2849225401878357,
0.0026497237849980593,
-0.27305224537849426,
-0.0018868471961468458,
0.6085547208786011,
0.014175585471093655,
-0.20356744527816772,
0.1307705044746399,
0.7819734811782837,
0.10010384023189545,
-0.6602174043655396,
-0.1677476018667221,
0.6065564751625061,
0.34963539242744446,
0.21819864213466644,
0.5627164840698242,
-0.05766482651233673,
-0.40489429235458374,
0.5367053151130676,
0.5027825832366943,
0.736520528793335,
-0.27149441838264465,
0.4799002408981323,
0.18282900750637054,
0.3148820698261261,
0.0744631215929985,
0.045046787708997726,
-0.39347875118255615,
-0.8934078216552734,
-0.4327487647533417,
-0.5206685066223145,
-0.4090527296066284,
0.054627418518066406,
-0.5673081278800964,
-0.18959690630435944,
-0.4821716248989105,
0.1826118528842926,
-0.276749849319458,
0.09927761554718018,
-0.6780324578285217,
0.2864910662174225,
0.05900620296597481,
0.8468232750892639,
-0.8161265254020691,
0.950823187828064,
0.8212440609931946,
-0.02996089868247509,
-0.8665245175361633,
0.059618737548589706,
-0.18113777041435242,
-0.4259382486343384,
0.43392446637153625,
0.6178867816925049,
0.05259699001908302,
0.6005899310112,
-0.32159551978111267,
-0.7532274127006531,
1.6363104581832886,
0.022550402209162712,
-0.4497833251953125,
0.22374287247657776,
0.281799852848053,
0.18357081711292267,
-0.5416812896728516,
0.049606241285800934,
0.26579540967941284,
0.3410167098045349,
0.21792207658290863,
-0.7330674529075623,
0.1400025188922882,
-0.1309516280889511,
-0.1410742700099945,
0.3641444146633148,
-0.5639588236808777,
0.5929223895072937,
-0.22863921523094177,
-0.21911191940307617,
-0.23153865337371826,
0.6782203316688538,
0.07659100741147995,
0.5802211761474609,
0.606188952922821,
0.7905735373497009,
0.8806469440460205,
-0.19447137415409088,
0.6880843043327332,
-0.017663227394223213,
0.620678722858429,
1.0171042680740356,
-0.2768186926841736,
0.7016674876213074,
0.4894040524959564,
0.05628020688891411,
0.6135926842689514,
0.19163639843463898,
0.0004976241034455597,
0.8411208391189575,
-0.12752696871757507,
-0.6665911078453064,
0.20930537581443787,
-0.07827762514352798,
-0.33301737904548645,
0.5227245688438416,
0.3256434500217438,
-0.3584054708480835,
-0.43173643946647644,
0.49476784467697144,
0.10576558113098145,
-0.0487816259264946,
-0.12809701263904572,
0.9266776442527771,
-0.053852129727602005,
-0.5443651676177979,
0.5220474004745483,
-0.23956656455993652,
0.8283370733261108,
-0.44182288646698,
-0.06069008633494377,
-0.28442636132240295,
0.31364205479621887,
-0.17686675488948822,
-0.5911769866943359,
0.28828638792037964,
-0.02113259956240654,
-0.25574588775634766,
-0.5195570588111877,
0.9164685606956482,
-0.7767689228057861,
-0.2348172664642334,
0.28192007541656494,
0.5798705816268921,
-0.05959996581077576,
-0.000827882147859782,
-0.5288122296333313,
-0.11653020977973938,
0.21616411209106445,
-0.3258180022239685,
0.39525604248046875,
0.3422429859638214,
-0.04011121019721031,
0.6302415728569031,
0.7339646816253662,
-0.4672955870628357,
-0.050339557230472565,
-0.07385282218456268,
1.0275001525878906,
-0.5497866868972778,
-0.4787651002407074,
-0.45560920238494873,
0.6373605132102966,
0.024393226951360703,
-0.00898964237421751,
0.42276421189308167,
0.43603482842445374,
0.8618100881576538,
-0.153153657913208,
0.899137020111084,
-0.4419005513191223,
0.16726428270339966,
-0.41216951608657837,
1.0241904258728027,
-0.3534146845340729,
0.007264026906341314,
-0.18352577090263367,
-0.5840169787406921,
-0.37123534083366394,
0.7379518151283264,
-0.39005038142204285,
-0.12840929627418518,
0.5558668971061707,
0.6090031862258911,
-0.11535811424255371,
0.10235068947076797,
0.2327841967344284,
-0.1665387749671936,
0.3953218460083008,
0.8088440895080566,
0.5519461631774902,
-0.8362122178077698,
0.4588448703289032,
-0.6590039134025574,
-0.5157771110534668,
-0.035178251564502716,
-1.0216245651245117,
-0.8729047179222107,
-0.5808826088905334,
-0.5710544586181641,
0.17191125452518463,
0.1976204663515091,
0.6380701661109924,
0.7264977693557739,
-0.8948618173599243,
0.014329260215163231,
-0.39876729249954224,
0.22130803763866425,
-0.12631866335868835,
-0.3516731262207031,
0.32893216609954834,
-0.051014065742492676,
-0.27358996868133545,
0.302888423204422,
0.13882318139076233,
0.5659717917442322,
0.20821790397167206,
0.025524752214550972,
-0.2298695594072342,
-0.44787999987602234,
0.5610777735710144,
0.09201816469430923,
-0.2345084697008133,
-0.29086291790008545,
0.0019563951063901186,
0.010007835924625397,
0.07799285650253296,
0.7843170762062073,
-1.1288199424743652,
0.34189721941947937,
0.11225949227809906,
1.018567442893982,
0.3480311334133148,
0.007619061041623354,
0.5495058298110962,
-1.1164523363113403,
0.44939228892326355,
0.30145788192749023,
-0.07270985096693039,
0.4708643853664398,
-0.7027750015258789,
0.43271324038505554,
0.30125731229782104,
-0.54912269115448,
-0.4801277816295624,
-0.14649006724357605,
-0.817596971988678,
0.08361998945474625,
0.6630193591117859,
-0.5165402293205261,
0.055351946502923965,
0.11412933468818665,
0.22018703818321228,
0.25456294417381287,
-0.36492541432380676,
0.7296364307403564,
0.6372467875480652,
0.16687074303627014,
-0.41892921924591064,
-0.6211180686950684,
0.4435749351978302,
0.29864510893821716,
-0.994154691696167,
-0.07413002103567123,
0.3818225562572479,
0.3052583932876587,
0.07177725434303284,
0.7358266711235046,
-0.04509427770972252,
0.2915639281272888,
0.04329538345336914,
0.021168772131204605,
-0.17075273394584656,
-0.3958110511302948,
-0.0625685304403305,
0.27826231718063354,
-0.2426847517490387,
-0.19419103860855103
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14074v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14074v1
|
M3: A Multi-Task Mixed-Objective Learning Framework for Open-Domain Multi-Hop Dense Sentence Retrieval
| 2024-03-21T01:52:07 | 2024-03-21T01:52:07 |
Yang Bai, Anthony Colas, Christan Grant, Daisy Zhe Wang
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In recent research, contrastive learning has proven to be a highly effective
method for representation learning and is widely used for dense retrieval.
However, we identify that relying solely on contrastive learning can lead to
suboptimal retrieval performance. On the other hand, despite many retrieval
datasets supporting various learning objectives beyond contrastive learning,
combining them efficiently in multi-task learning scenarios can be challenging.
In this paper, we introduce M3, an advanced recursive Multi-hop dense sentence
retrieval system built upon a novel Multi-task Mixed-objective approach for
dense text representation learning, addressing the aforementioned challenges.
Our approach yields state-of-the-art performance on a large-scale open-domain
fact verification benchmark dataset, FEVER. Code and data are available at:
https://github.com/TonyBY/M3
|
[
-0.11080675572156906,
-0.8418245911598206,
0.6251650452613831,
0.05082187056541443,
-0.33379003405570984,
-0.08067987114191055,
-0.017331836745142937,
-0.19949230551719666,
0.03957423195242882,
0.44020843505859375,
-0.46727505326271057,
-0.5152252912521362,
-0.9464711546897888,
0.27485135197639465,
-0.3059825003147125,
0.951743483543396,
0.057859133929014206,
-0.25416141748428345,
-0.20019526779651642,
-0.3327872157096863,
-0.43520021438598633,
-0.5173062682151794,
-0.5588947534561157,
-0.4233027398586273,
0.4532087743282318,
0.6833078265190125,
0.677101194858551,
0.33064937591552734,
0.6190592646598816,
0.24028001725673676,
0.2276141196489334,
0.813115119934082,
-0.8426230549812317,
0.35825860500335693,
-0.04296821355819702,
-0.05856670066714287,
-0.007622271776199341,
-0.15095099806785583,
0.5494181513786316,
0.5573343634605408,
-0.19537591934204102,
-0.10005522519350052,
0.010036547668278217,
0.7986650466918945,
-1.0577841997146606,
0.2402307540178299,
-0.8067792057991028,
0.22715960443019867,
-0.18014296889305115,
-0.3596086800098419,
-0.6182619333267212,
0.21628452837467194,
0.20705409348011017,
-0.7022839784622192,
-0.04509476572275162,
0.31994855403900146,
0.619594931602478,
0.20053957402706146,
-0.7597230076789856,
-0.35956114530563354,
-0.22589091956615448,
1.0514287948608398,
-0.24696718156337738,
0.5623318552970886,
0.11589988321065903,
0.14559689164161682,
-0.07200496643781662,
-0.7528804540634155,
-0.30023008584976196,
-0.03926612809300423,
-0.2598768174648285,
0.23143425583839417,
-0.2668845057487488,
-0.16331392526626587,
0.09157731384038925,
0.36662763357162476,
-0.5415537357330322,
-0.3878980576992035,
-0.10169514268636703,
-0.20164237916469574,
0.33207038044929504,
0.11875897645950317,
0.09948543459177017,
0.057569582015275955,
-0.6976690292358398,
0.16043022274971008,
-0.5623605847358704,
0.004523816984146833,
-0.02199668623507023,
0.5492335557937622,
0.06237407028675079,
0.6502952575683594,
-0.27852028608322144,
0.6885696053504944,
-0.07163024693727493,
-0.2521921694278717,
0.7029641270637512,
-0.3251553773880005,
-0.2820548117160797,
-0.025853345170617104,
0.9461056590080261,
0.28746747970581055,
-0.009430108591914177,
-0.3769334852695465,
-0.4481876492500305,
-0.541898787021637,
0.45418059825897217,
-1.0870121717453003,
0.10174297541379929,
0.34060898423194885,
-0.5393927693367004,
0.05357625335454941,
0.30406031012535095,
-0.6704490184783936,
-0.3881150186061859,
-0.13356433808803558,
0.6153106689453125,
-0.8744173645973206,
-0.1633961945772171,
0.3587757647037506,
-0.21620053052902222,
-0.0990949422121048,
0.16989703476428986,
-0.6937017440795898,
0.26859867572784424,
0.6299387216567993,
1.0704270601272583,
-0.18232159316539764,
-0.39427709579467773,
-0.8742188215255737,
0.15882998704910278,
-0.18200339376926422,
0.4733823835849762,
-0.6845666170120239,
-0.31227898597717285,
-0.018814725801348686,
-0.28188425302505493,
-0.32371488213539124,
-0.7503859996795654,
0.69407719373703,
-0.6613034605979919,
0.001017174101434648,
-0.024267753586173058,
-0.43605077266693115,
-0.4215365946292877,
0.4152196943759918,
-0.6061608791351318,
1.0157065391540527,
0.1305703967809677,
-1.1450800895690918,
0.12345448136329651,
-0.38129791617393494,
-0.7404069900512695,
-0.2990095913410187,
-0.1433716118335724,
-0.6287075877189636,
-0.1176496148109436,
0.16501565277576447,
0.823120653629303,
-0.20831185579299927,
0.29643285274505615,
-0.21381060779094696,
-0.6925437450408936,
0.010791419073939323,
-0.14333361387252808,
0.7616114616394043,
0.4966878890991211,
-0.24691887199878693,
0.32013049721717834,
-0.7211324572563171,
-0.28108692169189453,
0.15395106375217438,
-0.47605711221694946,
-0.36378639936447144,
0.01155285444110632,
-0.12786996364593506,
-0.006464262958616018,
0.1693640947341919,
-0.7315037846565247,
0.11467914283275604,
0.130539670586586,
0.3173339068889618,
0.2842876613140106,
0.053807634860277176,
0.19076600670814514,
-0.6207782626152039,
0.15644362568855286,
0.585493803024292,
-0.2641363739967346,
-0.4550701379776001,
-0.4100522994995117,
-0.5500501990318298,
-0.5626230835914612,
0.03138751909136772,
0.7643604278564453,
-1.003233790397644,
0.24689671397209167,
-0.12934954464435577,
-0.4105606973171234,
-0.6997785568237305,
0.32926565408706665,
0.4959094226360321,
0.5122495889663696,
0.8626906871795654,
-0.04117099940776825,
-0.7672984600067139,
-0.8945199847221375,
0.004042164888232946,
0.06370393931865692,
0.0517737939953804,
0.5455366373062134,
0.652508556842804,
-0.7390797138214111,
0.6690553426742554,
-0.5743907690048218,
-0.5273115038871765,
-0.5030581951141357,
0.4026396870613098,
0.2906907796859741,
0.4930156469345093,
0.37301045656204224,
-0.9132149815559387,
-0.21725337207317352,
0.11574562638998032,
-0.7317681908607483,
0.12474071979522705,
-0.12600021064281464,
-0.12485235184431076,
0.020047057420015335,
0.7395550012588501,
-0.5694983601570129,
-0.1644463688135147,
0.4734705686569214,
-0.14432013034820557,
0.5247820019721985,
-0.06968820840120316,
0.42510953545570374,
-0.9561446905136108,
0.32790154218673706,
0.0061888620257377625,
-0.46923062205314636,
-0.3539448380470276,
0.33753079175949097,
0.26740574836730957,
-0.03941302001476288,
-0.5111739039421082,
0.22521892189979553,
-0.41484305262565613,
0.055402178317308426,
-0.11634105443954468,
0.14833523333072662,
-0.03712122142314911,
0.35600364208221436,
-0.001408542157150805,
1.0699812173843384,
0.7120601534843445,
-0.8577751517295837,
0.14194446802139282,
-0.033983953297138214,
-0.23537033796310425,
0.5036329627037048,
-0.4953705668449402,
-0.12463557720184326,
-0.39438381791114807,
0.10467074811458588,
-0.7435536980628967,
-0.03615114837884903,
0.24778442084789276,
-0.41055962443351746,
0.14053207635879517,
0.0013335546245798469,
-0.5114505887031555,
0.018868306651711464,
-0.26146844029426575,
0.48079267144203186,
0.21054396033287048,
-0.3524072468280792,
0.5786759257316589,
0.3829474449157715,
0.17981351912021637,
-1.1548376083374023,
-0.4602634906768799,
-0.1853305846452713,
0.039158739149570465,
-0.33800992369651794,
0.638374924659729,
-0.02964145876467228,
-0.33892908692359924,
0.0365876704454422,
-0.07985848933458328,
-0.14798788726329803,
0.18767133355140686,
0.03706378489732742,
-0.06639709323644638,
-0.34664663672447205,
0.15983952581882477,
-0.029651595279574394,
-0.10350292176008224,
-0.2334710955619812,
-0.21064068377017975,
0.31915000081062317,
-0.09246081113815308,
-0.13323330879211426,
-0.05800948664546013,
0.5180367231369019,
0.5185272097587585,
-0.3332728147506714,
0.704275369644165,
1.0095373392105103,
-0.302129864692688,
-0.19696550071239471,
-0.3096361458301544,
-0.022172044962644577,
-0.3678319752216339,
0.47177526354789734,
-0.6862735748291016,
-1.1963844299316406,
-0.00484952749684453,
-0.11205334961414337,
0.18436481058597565,
0.4059920012950897,
0.3594789505004883,
0.0459553487598896,
0.6869564652442932,
0.5938277244567871,
0.0462963692843914,
0.26189175248146057,
-0.14128632843494415,
0.030053716152906418,
-0.8654196858406067,
-0.3672827184200287,
-0.41700732707977295,
-0.08335074037313461,
-0.21647532284259796,
-0.666508674621582,
0.2642430365085602,
0.06857842952013016,
-0.43233197927474976,
0.09548738598823547,
-0.0018292488530278206,
0.37127846479415894,
0.6261550784111023,
0.3701651692390442,
0.4774855673313141,
-0.2216690629720688,
-0.563291609287262,
0.21926842629909515,
-0.5278237462043762,
-0.2586035430431366,
0.9729094505310059,
0.04694676399230957,
0.40660372376441956,
0.42148056626319885,
0.9006778001785278,
0.4199345111846924,
0.14966052770614624,
-0.9594789147377014,
0.4769597351551056,
-0.43370214104652405,
-0.5082867741584778,
-0.11872292309999466,
-0.8769956827163696,
-1.1307719945907593,
0.8648636937141418,
-0.4656978249549866,
-0.4761034846305847,
-0.1366497427225113,
-0.17917965352535248,
-0.38407185673713684,
0.29688265919685364,
-0.6382601857185364,
0.9361097812652588,
0.008713358081877232,
-0.5028069615364075,
-0.27574896812438965,
-0.7029754519462585,
0.5916950702667236,
0.031687185168266296,
0.44251635670661926,
-0.10891196131706238,
-0.2999511659145355,
0.46584954857826233,
-0.11436452716588974,
0.6122848391532898,
-0.14848601818084717,
0.2382979393005371,
0.2136298567056656,
0.21558675169944763,
0.1434108316898346,
0.21499258279800415,
-0.40171360969543457,
-0.06918071955442429,
-0.2518472671508789,
-0.5017839670181274,
-0.2754836082458496,
0.6928953528404236,
-0.8044884204864502,
-0.5061545968055725,
-0.6340724229812622,
-0.757639467716217,
-0.37069761753082275,
0.5850582122802734,
-0.10953843593597412,
0.39633676409721375,
-0.24086631834506989,
0.6564565300941467,
0.8811390995979309,
-0.0023615630343556404,
0.3217659294605255,
0.48369914293289185,
-0.20975592732429504,
-0.48325395584106445,
0.9135041236877441,
-0.21752811968326569,
-0.0930618867278099,
1.0383967161178589,
-0.05289280787110329,
-0.07357075065374374,
-0.885654866695404,
-0.5060650706291199,
0.060839079320430756,
-0.46518853306770325,
-0.47229981422424316,
-1.0398753881454468,
-0.06466852128505707,
-0.37351492047309875,
0.027479149401187897,
-0.23009079694747925,
0.01801862195134163,
-0.4191981852054596,
-0.13277152180671692,
0.06553453207015991,
0.7696905136108398,
-0.08452393114566803,
0.2572394609451294,
-0.9860687255859375,
0.6479261517524719,
0.08711402118206024,
0.36571192741394043,
-0.11680465191602707,
-0.38706499338150024,
-0.347544401884079,
-0.1821594387292862,
-0.4402254521846771,
-0.7364747524261475,
0.3024654984474182,
0.24971003830432892,
0.610328733921051,
0.4790639281272888,
0.2829962372779846,
0.6395307183265686,
-0.5984753966331482,
0.4641023576259613,
0.12417558580636978,
-0.9986171722412109,
0.23480556905269623,
-0.08447621762752533,
0.3598238527774811,
0.7507068514823914,
0.8423705101013184,
-0.5352282524108887,
-0.17809538543224335,
-0.26579663157463074,
-0.8720717430114746,
0.576188325881958,
0.1963108330965042,
-0.070148766040802,
-0.10978155583143234,
0.26217249035835266,
0.5027268528938293,
0.27122363448143005,
-0.6896216869354248,
-0.4648791551589966,
-0.2648964822292328,
-0.413000226020813,
-0.32629212737083435,
-0.34289801120758057,
0.011407961137592793,
0.10563170909881592,
0.8380141854286194,
-0.29662615060806274,
0.15551696717739105,
0.5266706943511963,
-0.4973660111427307,
0.200426384806633,
0.4364486038684845,
0.40017470717430115,
0.47929003834724426,
-0.5959537029266357,
0.44885140657424927,
-0.29893818497657776,
-0.37435072660446167,
0.03539855778217316,
0.3769285976886749,
-0.1662513017654419,
-0.01663743332028389,
0.519515872001648,
0.5882436633110046,
0.5426609516143799,
-1.0187890529632568,
0.6092502474784851,
-0.05417945981025696,
-0.27396053075790405,
0.28816837072372437,
-0.0873866081237793,
0.05450337380170822,
0.2158658802509308,
0.6050443053245544,
0.2829362452030182,
0.6632177829742432,
-0.7541449666023254,
0.7535021901130676,
0.45483043789863586,
-0.45445701479911804,
0.18621180951595306,
0.4319552183151245,
0.3047075867652893,
0.24536995589733124,
0.6448097825050354,
-0.4772936701774597,
-0.33604881167411804,
0.27356576919555664,
0.4958185851573944,
0.5430153608322144,
0.11135278642177582,
0.31690526008605957,
0.6227105259895325,
0.26654717326164246,
-0.08125879615545273,
0.3482120931148529,
-0.13589587807655334,
-0.797127366065979,
-0.24415487051010132,
-0.33932942152023315,
-0.535335898399353,
-0.14684359729290009,
-0.4891797602176666,
0.12770526111125946,
-0.2237178087234497,
-0.04674207419157028,
-0.09805420786142349,
0.10786484181880951,
-0.37895339727401733,
0.2063610702753067,
0.06051601096987724,
0.831149697303772,
-0.5058801174163818,
0.8353238701820374,
0.663847804069519,
-0.5834378600120544,
-0.21740922331809998,
0.11314687132835388,
0.20027881860733032,
-0.844997763633728,
0.5326077938079834,
0.6676039695739746,
-0.4071636497974396,
0.03563850000500679,
-0.049758266657590866,
-0.7477659583091736,
1.0982519388198853,
0.3508261740207672,
-0.4553226828575134,
0.2650407552719116,
-0.35714930295944214,
0.19413693249225616,
-0.6782944798469543,
0.4446437358856201,
0.3200885057449341,
0.21073417365550995,
0.2600022852420807,
-0.65555739402771,
0.119385726749897,
-0.17333248257637024,
-0.3638187050819397,
0.07838692516088486,
-0.6893680095672607,
1.0093920230865479,
-0.748682975769043,
-0.253057599067688,
-0.14597372710704803,
0.8826956152915955,
0.4051082134246826,
0.5260091423988342,
0.4196073114871979,
0.730739176273346,
0.9032554626464844,
-0.04759456589818001,
1.0403547286987305,
-0.17791077494621277,
0.29805275797843933,
1.0519107580184937,
-0.37817832827568054,
1.0893336534500122,
0.5003760457038879,
0.03666534647345543,
0.6861624121665955,
0.5351215600967407,
0.3504642844200134,
0.6770555377006531,
0.09174761921167374,
-0.1740679293870926,
-0.3604893088340759,
-0.16315273940563202,
-0.2330847978591919,
0.18053479492664337,
0.4094284176826477,
-0.29615268111228943,
-0.2414126843214035,
-0.09758755564689636,
0.12506669759750366,
0.06294237077236176,
-0.3743775188922882,
0.7972320318222046,
-0.033522333949804306,
-0.6503002643585205,
0.44087544083595276,
0.15125863254070282,
0.9767125248908997,
-0.5320897698402405,
-0.18764053285121918,
-0.053551606833934784,
0.24377410113811493,
-0.3224546015262604,
-0.8440439701080322,
0.2771231532096863,
-0.32315683364868164,
-0.23428311944007874,
-0.2635453939437866,
0.618321418762207,
-0.5928978323936462,
-0.22203555703163147,
0.44912803173065186,
0.8011330366134644,
-0.1803591549396515,
-0.15792779624462128,
-0.8230511546134949,
0.21295756101608276,
0.044194966554641724,
-0.06740132719278336,
0.19987617433071136,
0.7583701610565186,
0.5585208535194397,
0.7585449814796448,
0.3568352460861206,
-0.2761881351470947,
-0.11835861206054688,
-0.0016978245694190264,
0.6110090017318726,
-0.6165137887001038,
-0.18060147762298584,
-0.8119962215423584,
0.3961881995201111,
0.025149358436465263,
-0.18587826192378998,
0.5542714595794678,
0.8954870104789734,
0.9804046750068665,
-0.08640043437480927,
0.7959712743759155,
-0.060542862862348557,
0.6055690050125122,
-0.7671948671340942,
0.3186609447002411,
-0.7111411094665527,
0.1161707267165184,
0.02352413721382618,
-0.61160808801651,
-0.5983527302742004,
0.646816074848175,
0.06600973755121231,
0.0348772369325161,
1.0683984756469727,
0.5706606507301331,
-0.2784205675125122,
-0.06651101261377335,
0.49711737036705017,
0.17750857770442963,
0.09005886316299438,
0.639551043510437,
0.5177210569381714,
-0.4438900947570801,
0.7533186078071594,
-0.31739774346351624,
-0.14569833874702454,
-0.5368862152099609,
-0.7207393646240234,
-0.8341479897499084,
-0.6922052502632141,
-0.2835962474346161,
-0.1844271719455719,
0.40453609824180603,
1.1521211862564087,
0.7859162092208862,
-0.7512331604957581,
-0.22106732428073883,
0.24410030245780945,
0.35075637698173523,
-0.5655196905136108,
-0.2551996409893036,
0.15987005829811096,
-0.8660050630569458,
-0.7392609715461731,
0.5049391984939575,
0.35325583815574646,
-0.21186505258083344,
0.12617944180965424,
-0.040845490992069244,
-0.626089334487915,
0.02278742752969265,
1.0061770677566528,
-0.013717777095735073,
-0.4243911802768707,
-0.12399214506149292,
-0.22959792613983154,
-0.4219140410423279,
0.25856882333755493,
1.1707290410995483,
-0.8543514013290405,
0.27744847536087036,
0.3747691512107849,
1.145005702972412,
0.34755945205688477,
-0.08477523177862167,
0.379098117351532,
-0.8477082252502441,
-0.11103852093219757,
0.18706274032592773,
0.849396288394928,
0.3662075996398926,
-0.22797581553459167,
0.5073487758636475,
0.3510584235191345,
-0.40044480562210083,
-0.5022993683815002,
0.25785401463508606,
-1.1537548303604126,
-0.4794996976852417,
1.1785261631011963,
-0.2687211334705353,
0.040570978075265884,
-0.40425431728363037,
-0.4061754643917084,
0.036254506558179855,
-0.8817000389099121,
0.5167094469070435,
0.6461287140846252,
-0.24016951024532318,
-0.24665603041648865,
-0.42783117294311523,
0.28105780482292175,
0.40377286076545715,
-0.6644243001937866,
0.07763120532035828,
0.6368990540504456,
0.1265968382358551,
0.16160090267658234,
0.6709776520729065,
-0.021277138963341713,
0.19098004698753357,
0.009922701865434647,
-0.20862598717212677,
-0.3652511537075043,
-0.576948881149292,
0.09550079703330994,
0.7692162990570068,
-0.09885659068822861,
-0.08128487318754196
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14072v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14072v1
|
A Taxonomy of Ambiguity Types for NLP
| 2024-03-21T01:47:22 | 2024-03-21T01:47:22 |
Margaret Y. Li, Alisa Liu, Zhaofeng Wu, Noah A. Smith
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Ambiguity is an critical component of language that allows for more effective
communication between speakers, but is often ignored in NLP. Recent work
suggests that NLP systems may struggle to grasp certain elements of human
language understanding because they may not handle ambiguities at the level
that humans naturally do in communication. Additionally, different types of
ambiguity may serve different purposes and require different approaches for
resolution, and we aim to investigate how language models' abilities vary
across types. We propose a taxonomy of ambiguity types as seen in English to
facilitate NLP analysis. Our taxonomy can help make meaningful splits in
language ambiguity data, allowing for more fine-grained assessments of both
datasets and model performance.
|
[
-0.296498566865921,
-0.8925861716270447,
0.4085691571235657,
0.7435965538024902,
-0.20204704999923706,
0.49838438630104065,
-0.009247515350580215,
-0.9118602871894836,
0.22029785811901093,
0.04363660514354706,
-0.4138987064361572,
-0.12202028185129166,
-1.1866790056228638,
0.3453349173069,
-0.4638734757900238,
0.38875484466552734,
0.008917768485844135,
-0.22839118540287018,
-0.04120999947190285,
-0.41581323742866516,
-0.6329124569892883,
-0.5490128993988037,
-0.7454074025154114,
-0.5254157185554504,
0.7568995356559753,
0.20283664762973785,
1.4851047992706299,
0.3667384684085846,
0.8384485244750977,
0.25186771154403687,
-0.5263621211051941,
0.2285366803407669,
0.02124316245317459,
0.33077284693717957,
-0.37154582142829895,
-0.6502191424369812,
-0.3849707543849945,
-0.19286513328552246,
0.6900768876075745,
1.1326158046722412,
-0.29705122113227844,
0.15929991006851196,
-0.2260778546333313,
0.44613656401634216,
-0.8490061163902283,
-0.09119901061058044,
-0.5891034007072449,
0.27397340536117554,
-0.5718333721160889,
-0.03482170030474663,
-0.13784411549568176,
0.012317150831222534,
0.4136461317539215,
-0.5565459728240967,
-0.14570023119449615,
0.12215571850538254,
1.0638911724090576,
0.5296803712844849,
-0.6599534153938293,
-0.3701300621032715,
-0.7923552393913269,
0.46956175565719604,
-0.8676195740699768,
0.5822274684906006,
0.2196570485830307,
0.1364368200302124,
-0.1396079659461975,
-0.5455012321472168,
-0.4403439462184906,
0.3010634183883667,
-0.31421980261802673,
-0.06483626365661621,
-0.2873477637767792,
0.32164183259010315,
0.21727481484413147,
0.32024577260017395,
-0.5482882261276245,
0.42725831270217896,
-0.31721773743629456,
-0.061996202915906906,
0.4119493067264557,
0.1491919904947281,
0.49709227681159973,
-0.5153160691261292,
-0.07111188769340515,
0.3560795485973358,
-0.47724130749702454,
0.13933420181274414,
0.47526705265045166,
0.31631553173065186,
-0.11305210739374161,
0.6757997274398804,
0.05855967476963997,
1.2253047227859497,
-0.3558233976364136,
0.0658063068985939,
0.02954106032848358,
0.024563228711485863,
-0.23604294657707214,
-0.4242033362388611,
0.47133609652519226,
0.2502197325229645,
-0.22304627299308777,
-0.24178999662399292,
-0.2848006784915924,
0.09743325412273407,
0.17558400332927704,
0.07165279984474182,
0.19859181344509125,
0.36006802320480347,
-0.40557584166526794,
-0.05881071835756302,
-0.10278370976448059,
-0.8117948174476624,
-0.2396947741508484,
-0.3272971212863922,
0.5170022249221802,
-0.37878429889678955,
-0.44433799386024475,
0.573490560054779,
-0.4906386435031891,
0.26805922389030457,
0.1584223508834839,
-1.0732336044311523,
0.4264577329158783,
0.7244860529899597,
0.7348079681396484,
-0.12581557035446167,
-0.2546422481536865,
-0.1009565070271492,
0.027397867292165756,
-0.24833661317825317,
0.4870778024196625,
-1.0732563734054565,
-0.44531214237213135,
0.03387445956468582,
-0.3058926463127136,
-0.29324081540107727,
-0.42240381240844727,
0.5736883878707886,
-0.6238508224487305,
0.2988857328891754,
-0.0027681265491992235,
-0.5525411367416382,
-0.4553675353527069,
-0.010091252624988556,
-0.7195478677749634,
1.1170361042022705,
0.31547635793685913,
-0.8774294257164001,
0.4999580383300781,
-0.6889001727104187,
-0.11388766020536423,
0.5692915320396423,
-0.2923504114151001,
-0.10963478684425354,
0.2874341309070587,
-0.13187691569328308,
0.1352076232433319,
-0.34064653515815735,
0.5314294695854187,
-0.09449785202741623,
-0.23682351410388947,
0.3455178141593933,
-0.1522710919380188,
0.7647662162780762,
0.1891741156578064,
-0.11187604814767838,
-0.08116598427295685,
-0.780231773853302,
0.07495826482772827,
-0.09592163562774658,
-0.186651349067688,
-0.7930598258972168,
0.3748781681060791,
0.0959044024348259,
0.23846951127052307,
0.4611620604991913,
-0.10602055490016937,
0.3669997751712799,
-0.46089667081832886,
0.42454323172569275,
0.3411954641342163,
-0.056415069848299026,
0.4085175395011902,
-0.301506906747818,
0.9239091873168945,
-0.025190332904458046,
0.24365775287151337,
0.34717512130737305,
-1.0364174842834473,
-0.9473180770874023,
0.26574674248695374,
0.6483761072158813,
0.7949050068855286,
-0.6426664590835571,
0.6813027262687683,
0.011999810114502907,
-0.30171632766723633,
-0.8870497941970825,
-0.10371509194374084,
0.39532700181007385,
0.28254708647727966,
0.47328078746795654,
-0.23720890283584595,
-0.6233696937561035,
-1.0004401206970215,
-0.47699764370918274,
-0.20373418927192688,
-0.07485293596982956,
0.12945236265659332,
0.3051292896270752,
-0.393586665391922,
1.1959052085876465,
-0.31678399443626404,
0.09786916524171829,
-0.14548707008361816,
0.5625748634338379,
-0.004273225553333759,
0.22229650616645813,
0.5642318725585938,
-1.1801872253417969,
-0.14704333245754242,
-0.03897431120276451,
-0.36790090799331665,
-0.1746135652065277,
-0.19639582931995392,
0.13548493385314941,
0.04702257737517357,
0.305782288312912,
-0.3984156847000122,
0.3674478232860565,
0.6692754030227661,
-0.3418847620487213,
0.335586816072464,
0.05894186720252037,
-0.15010274946689606,
-0.7736261487007141,
-0.011976751498878002,
-0.1208474412560463,
-0.1091352179646492,
-0.8289278745651245,
0.31021252274513245,
-0.03726261481642723,
0.2696572244167328,
-0.3720608055591583,
0.47161412239074707,
-0.26629766821861267,
-0.060655627399683,
0.22767023742198944,
0.3087129294872284,
0.01916513219475746,
-0.10130323469638824,
0.16827024519443512,
0.3719386160373688,
0.7583581805229187,
-0.6801938414573669,
0.2657069265842438,
0.36072981357574463,
-0.09398968517780304,
0.4434736669063568,
-0.4924565851688385,
-0.07043473422527313,
-0.2766227126121521,
-0.22215190529823303,
-0.770785927772522,
-0.2881479859352112,
0.42014646530151367,
-0.39609864354133606,
0.45234763622283936,
-0.1060674861073494,
-0.3074024021625519,
-0.44146376848220825,
0.2577775716781616,
0.6569453477859497,
0.021422768011689186,
-0.16224977374076843,
0.559558093547821,
0.143936887383461,
-0.04081146419048309,
-1.1402199268341064,
-0.6013420224189758,
0.0906548947095871,
-0.4417746365070343,
-0.7168943285942078,
0.2780230939388275,
0.022906098514795303,
-0.5188705921173096,
0.16876357793807983,
-0.25054579973220825,
-0.3395439088344574,
0.3532705008983612,
0.18165530264377594,
0.03842942789196968,
-0.1873583346605301,
0.4021660089492798,
-0.013114625588059425,
-0.03752986714243889,
-0.10298486053943634,
0.010738191194832325,
0.5524149537086487,
-0.08391250669956207,
-0.4634358286857605,
-0.051764171570539474,
0.6291040182113647,
0.13766372203826904,
-0.2006927877664566,
0.6319647431373596,
0.3894319534301758,
-0.6221084594726562,
0.00799478031694889,
-0.27365782856941223,
0.32194870710372925,
-0.5020801424980164,
0.20239023864269257,
-0.6851460337638855,
-1.15497887134552,
0.9289960861206055,
0.186009019613266,
-0.0181855671107769,
0.6399275064468384,
0.2258891612291336,
-0.07205372303724289,
0.910129725933075,
0.6993760466575623,
0.23003068566322327,
0.20771370828151703,
0.22918172180652618,
0.6000325083732605,
-0.6121200919151306,
-0.17789645493030548,
-0.790152907371521,
-0.34840676188468933,
-0.6255895495414734,
-0.31163811683654785,
-0.12151773273944855,
0.24864080548286438,
0.008780877105891705,
0.27798619866371155,
-0.610765278339386,
0.37710562348365784,
0.42392876744270325,
-0.314985454082489,
0.3613491356372833,
-0.4251703917980194,
0.15921662747859955,
-0.2843339145183563,
-0.6977512836456299,
-0.4577767550945282,
0.7170011401176453,
0.534700334072113,
0.7228666543960571,
0.5795693397521973,
0.4750152826309204,
0.30441272258758545,
-0.2252032607793808,
-1.0824859142303467,
0.16252397000789642,
-0.14052127301692963,
-0.8329463005065918,
-0.34025129675865173,
-0.3877648711204529,
-1.2780791521072388,
0.40427592396736145,
-0.35494929552078247,
-1.0241690874099731,
0.6232793927192688,
-0.007831483148038387,
-0.4612192213535309,
0.29770103096961975,
-0.8539915084838867,
0.8080552220344543,
-0.09518515318632126,
0.41715821623802185,
0.256483256816864,
-0.9964934587478638,
0.4323616921901703,
-0.13944745063781738,
0.3535082936286926,
-0.16001670062541962,
-0.27051183581352234,
0.6979604363441467,
0.007494736462831497,
0.6677514314651489,
0.3334203362464905,
-0.34713202714920044,
0.22826696932315826,
0.38289299607276917,
0.10955069214105606,
-0.01610708050429821,
-0.11888357251882553,
0.3768013119697571,
0.30611225962638855,
-0.40305376052856445,
-0.6679263710975647,
-0.15882952511310577,
-0.6954726576805115,
-0.710159957408905,
-0.4161361753940582,
-0.5762354731559753,
-0.37302809953689575,
0.09392695873975754,
0.5685112476348877,
0.23438891768455505,
0.1296851634979248,
-0.08265688270330429,
0.3334147334098816,
-0.06241520121693611,
0.37380364537239075,
0.531519889831543,
-0.2653024196624756,
0.3923919200897217,
0.688632071018219,
0.43413037061691284,
0.44926416873931885,
0.5808991193771362,
-0.07457997649908066,
-0.31855908036231995,
-0.6835905313491821,
0.1043919175863266,
0.10295391827821732,
-0.8275286555290222,
-0.20773246884346008,
-0.5600674748420715,
-0.5262430310249329,
-0.37778425216674805,
-0.38680824637413025,
-0.08734989911317825,
-0.6084903478622437,
-0.45969828963279724,
-0.08473870903253555,
0.4126347005367279,
0.994221568107605,
-0.26275530457496643,
0.7786771655082703,
-0.7458589673042297,
0.3518540561199188,
0.24783392250537872,
0.6075562238693237,
-0.29794955253601074,
-0.5127784609794617,
0.1593206226825714,
-0.0382702574133873,
0.012526429258286953,
-1.341712474822998,
0.3883151710033417,
0.2929672598838806,
0.647248387336731,
0.47366857528686523,
-0.2020474672317505,
0.6630220413208008,
-0.1972636729478836,
0.939258873462677,
0.1720362901687622,
-1.3082101345062256,
0.37581801414489746,
-0.4072507619857788,
0.1706298291683197,
0.3200497031211853,
0.5566818714141846,
-1.3762950897216797,
-0.7662255764007568,
-0.9560689330101013,
-1.3230221271514893,
0.6028107404708862,
0.0586274191737175,
-0.10303815454244614,
-0.0013087315019220114,
0.6065717339515686,
0.0603959895670414,
0.23110297322273254,
-0.9522104859352112,
-0.6484317183494568,
0.16721875965595245,
0.03291185200214386,
-0.09395471960306168,
-0.387897789478302,
-0.45500147342681885,
-0.05630846321582794,
0.15311835706233978,
0.10639309138059616,
0.1324329823255539,
0.023922618478536606,
-0.2374034821987152,
-0.17972290515899658,
0.5907856225967407,
0.5184076428413391,
0.9113061428070068,
-0.4047904908657074,
0.5239304900169373,
-0.026265162974596024,
-0.4158289134502411,
0.1338859349489212,
-0.030966157093644142,
0.008733728900551796,
0.07869379967451096,
0.4794483184814453,
0.6244421601295471,
0.2522207796573639,
-0.44419294595718384,
0.24980442225933075,
0.0038647360634058714,
-0.11688707023859024,
0.0659998282790184,
0.06856190413236618,
0.04933992400765419,
-0.042686741799116135,
0.31329718232154846,
0.289315402507782,
0.42640501260757446,
-0.3287845551967621,
0.23160560429096222,
0.2242029756307602,
-0.14540965855121613,
-0.11781810969114304,
0.4533211886882782,
0.30250564217567444,
-0.6945164203643799,
0.3219703733921051,
-0.5794062614440918,
-0.5448136329650879,
0.677315354347229,
0.5358837246894836,
0.4675322473049164,
-0.4155474603176117,
0.365286260843277,
-0.1583142727613449,
0.6962882876396179,
0.23454833030700684,
0.4335385859012604,
0.4236167073249817,
-0.9771337509155273,
-0.47598564624786377,
-0.3854270577430725,
-0.718294084072113,
0.08186838775873184,
-0.8363397717475891,
0.2485005408525467,
-0.14360947906970978,
-0.20765092968940735,
0.2921750247478485,
-0.3217945694923401,
-0.47910067439079285,
0.16983918845653534,
0.29194092750549316,
1.136017084121704,
-1.0430570840835571,
0.41118302941322327,
0.7013689279556274,
-0.25738605856895447,
-0.7611287832260132,
-0.19964979588985443,
0.2015928030014038,
-0.6287917494773865,
0.5937172174453735,
-0.19590917229652405,
-0.1684410572052002,
-0.26563379168510437,
-0.3028448522090912,
-1.1458808183670044,
0.6276016235351562,
0.1943628340959549,
-0.3838614821434021,
-0.2931065857410431,
0.3955877721309662,
0.63304603099823,
-0.3768466114997864,
0.4090205430984497,
0.8798952102661133,
0.8798120617866516,
-0.011443758383393288,
-1.1774427890777588,
-0.21392016112804413,
-0.011032736860215664,
0.24876607954502106,
0.4499935507774353,
-0.5242075324058533,
0.9075422286987305,
0.2797543406486511,
-0.4113682806491852,
-0.2108135223388672,
0.2968374788761139,
-0.294210284948349,
0.10355743020772934,
0.5553932785987854,
0.45047542452812195,
1.0351766347885132,
-0.4021810293197632,
0.7462548613548279,
0.09480320662260056,
0.3649323582649231,
1.340575098991394,
0.06590304523706436,
0.8763816356658936,
0.41532787680625916,
-0.4259389042854309,
0.3215149939060211,
1.23006010055542,
0.24733592569828033,
-0.1427270770072937,
0.09722284227609634,
-0.19433370232582092,
-0.40507304668426514,
0.07420600950717926,
-0.5976089239120483,
0.7167194485664368,
1.1587162017822266,
-0.012560161761939526,
-0.4018239676952362,
-0.28788670897483826,
-0.05418103560805321,
-0.03510814160108566,
-0.15803322196006775,
0.38666632771492004,
-0.12182456254959106,
-0.5125234127044678,
0.4545743763446808,
0.09538712352514267,
0.9017978310585022,
-0.6001952290534973,
0.15974584221839905,
0.21085494756698608,
-0.629885733127594,
-0.5992276668548584,
-1.094781517982483,
0.5845001339912415,
-0.5820781588554382,
-0.053713392466306686,
-0.06954134255647659,
0.6377732753753662,
-0.45292267203330994,
-0.2004019021987915,
0.6050715446472168,
0.5771055221557617,
0.2198708951473236,
0.23247750103473663,
-0.9864706993103027,
-0.033985525369644165,
-0.12913210690021515,
0.012746867723762989,
-0.2120939940214157,
0.4691391885280609,
-0.09911808371543884,
0.9181109070777893,
-0.03794432803988457,
0.1631658524274826,
0.6945180296897888,
0.10517461597919464,
0.39978376030921936,
-0.536523163318634,
-0.1254870593547821,
-0.5493510365486145,
0.6094975471496582,
0.04248853027820587,
-0.6397772431373596,
0.4856854975223541,
0.2887423634529114,
0.34497857093811035,
0.1513061225414276,
0.6108278036117554,
-0.4614928066730499,
0.5764414668083191,
-0.43604612350463867,
0.1732524037361145,
-0.6568789482116699,
0.17616935074329376,
-0.3017207086086273,
-0.7076475620269775,
-0.8473970890045166,
0.6039617657661438,
-0.2906424105167389,
-0.12193964421749115,
0.7096742987632751,
0.37797194719314575,
0.027206601575016975,
0.1666972041130066,
0.45279157161712646,
0.15269966423511505,
0.11187534034252167,
0.3243285119533539,
0.9793540239334106,
-0.23995117843151093,
0.19883283972740173,
-0.07627397775650024,
-0.11416274309158325,
-0.37218478322029114,
-0.8434471487998962,
-0.3810824155807495,
-0.9395862221717834,
-0.3553692698478699,
-0.17878872156143188,
-0.0592772513628006,
0.7235867381095886,
0.6872210502624512,
-0.4023799002170563,
-0.18276159465312958,
0.046395640820264816,
0.8137488961219788,
-0.2491740733385086,
-0.27097266912460327,
0.0001599015376996249,
-0.6635727286338806,
-0.8504926562309265,
0.22823898494243622,
0.3227876126766205,
0.3327484130859375,
-0.14367404580116272,
0.2882893681526184,
-0.46282804012298584,
0.29635900259017944,
0.4069927930831909,
0.5669561624526978,
-0.7590801119804382,
-0.5985397100448608,
-0.11197065562009811,
0.12324225902557373,
0.1057232916355133,
0.7596549987792969,
-0.2344714254140854,
0.628986656665802,
0.32248762249946594,
0.5506259799003601,
-0.0662405714392662,
-0.10172139108181,
0.6440507173538208,
-1.1043535470962524,
0.45379024744033813,
0.34540197253227234,
0.39061060547828674,
0.07108184695243835,
-0.6239627599716187,
0.5089806914329529,
0.07105977833271027,
-0.4676159918308258,
-0.6406266689300537,
0.7210587859153748,
-1.1870882511138916,
-0.4298785328865051,
1.1765128374099731,
0.1341250091791153,
0.17879587411880493,
-0.6227819323539734,
0.03699537739157677,
-0.042961228638887405,
-0.26540207862854004,
0.6258028745651245,
1.3075535297393799,
-0.2544967234134674,
-0.14612498879432678,
-0.6074135303497314,
0.7771264314651489,
0.5180821418762207,
-0.5667214393615723,
-0.12908102571964264,
0.14449526369571686,
-0.07288306951522827,
0.5960222482681274,
0.3112698793411255,
-0.05374385416507721,
0.11529161781072617,
-0.19452153146266937,
0.09217803180217743,
0.877497673034668,
-0.21546635031700134,
-0.4910075068473816,
0.16384480893611908,
0.4214555621147156,
0.18056301772594452
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14727v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14727v1
|
Protected group bias and stereotypes in Large Language Models
| 2024-03-21T00:21:38 | 2024-03-21T00:21:38 |
Hadas Kotek, David Q. Sun, Zidi Xiu, Margit Bowler, Christopher Klein
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
As modern Large Language Models (LLMs) shatter many state-of-the-art
benchmarks in a variety of domains, this paper investigates their behavior in
the domains of ethics and fairness, focusing on protected group bias. We
conduct a two-part study: first, we solicit sentence continuations describing
the occupations of individuals from different protected groups, including
gender, sexuality, religion, and race. Second, we have the model generate
stories about individuals who hold different types of occupations. We collect
>10k sentence completions made by a publicly available LLM, which we subject to
human annotation. We find bias across minoritized groups, but in particular in
the domains of gender and sexuality, as well as Western bias, in model
generations. The model not only reflects societal biases, but appears to
amplify them. The model is additionally overly cautious in replies to queries
relating to minoritized groups, providing responses that strongly emphasize
diversity and equity to an extent that other group characteristics are
overshadowed. This suggests that artificially constraining potentially harmful
outputs may itself lead to harm, and should be applied in a careful and
controlled manner.
|
[
-0.23447754979133606,
-0.5739370584487915,
0.5133114457130432,
0.14825578033924103,
0.06280628591775894,
0.03218349069356918,
-0.06925047188997269,
-0.8522654175758362,
-0.03427906334400177,
0.9241741895675659,
-0.40691882371902466,
-0.3749198317527771,
-0.924254298210144,
0.25262537598609924,
-0.196369007229805,
1.1051020622253418,
0.33329710364341736,
0.2853606045246124,
-0.21294009685516357,
-0.08343633264303207,
-0.2650037705898285,
-0.9554412364959717,
-0.40250474214553833,
-0.28717729449272156,
0.37753427028656006,
0.06288762390613556,
0.7791698575019836,
0.7530847787857056,
0.25861644744873047,
0.17615436017513275,
-0.4137968122959137,
-0.12733374536037445,
-0.6614307761192322,
0.2021142989397049,
-0.22543540596961975,
-0.5117486715316772,
-0.487610787153244,
0.47053390741348267,
0.5095487833023071,
0.9640874862670898,
0.13397598266601562,
0.1598963588476181,
0.1174890324473381,
0.49960610270500183,
-0.4865456223487854,
-0.0019972180016338825,
-0.7065618634223938,
0.18794259428977966,
-0.3320733308792114,
0.03455009311437607,
-0.5226098895072937,
-0.5597671866416931,
0.0003216290788259357,
-0.3903370499610901,
0.2196325808763504,
0.2881166636943817,
0.6201468110084534,
-0.08966676890850067,
-0.825079083442688,
-0.18069051206111908,
-0.5727595090866089,
1.0774513483047485,
-0.6545013785362244,
0.19611462950706482,
0.734347939491272,
0.056910187005996704,
-0.17848879098892212,
-0.30078187584877014,
-0.3228920102119446,
-0.3171924650669098,
-0.0753769800066948,
-0.1522464007139206,
0.01945268176496029,
0.30687257647514343,
0.6281240582466125,
0.327226459980011,
-0.20307670533657074,
0.5236630439758301,
-0.5702834129333496,
-0.255441814661026,
0.9616516828536987,
0.17295780777931213,
0.4150562584400177,
-0.25456851720809937,
-0.23889660835266113,
0.10113929212093353,
-1.2171062231063843,
0.10513025522232056,
0.8259186744689941,
0.29061049222946167,
0.045983150601387024,
0.6326738595962524,
-0.13976997137069702,
0.3892934322357178,
-0.1712406575679779,
-0.12319700419902802,
0.1812528371810913,
-0.08283959329128265,
-0.2160361409187317,
0.060836225748062134,
0.5503553748130798,
0.6714067459106445,
0.805553674697876,
-0.1278659999370575,
-0.20972351729869843,
0.14047777652740479,
0.1090712770819664,
-0.6670531630516052,
0.18227192759513855,
-0.060450147837400436,
-0.6919655203819275,
-0.40019112825393677,
-0.0861692726612091,
-0.8643976449966431,
-0.7112375497817993,
-0.17931148409843445,
-0.058024898171424866,
0.17497576773166656,
-0.10541684925556183,
0.22750969231128693,
-0.018395964056253433,
0.06207973510026932,
0.05424191802740097,
-0.983648419380188,
0.3963455855846405,
0.8895657062530518,
0.47137776017189026,
-0.1820906400680542,
0.021003922447562218,
-0.6655429005622864,
0.264492392539978,
-0.1531526893377304,
0.3513906002044678,
-0.9326980113983154,
-0.7421895265579224,
0.29690155386924744,
0.0586513988673687,
0.18303313851356506,
-0.5710349082946777,
0.5833219289779663,
-0.44500064849853516,
0.1576184630393982,
-0.5158796906471252,
-0.4980345666408539,
0.0009108091471716762,
-0.0438636913895607,
-0.5313251614570618,
0.5799201130867004,
-0.2435556799173355,
-0.9527683854103088,
0.6322627067565918,
-0.4377574622631073,
-0.4584050476551056,
-0.08286434412002563,
-0.5806261301040649,
-0.21597249805927277,
0.1292867660522461,
0.0627145767211914,
0.39917242527008057,
-0.22610671818256378,
0.403668612241745,
-0.7531057596206665,
-0.24571245908737183,
0.36174654960632324,
-0.46090736985206604,
0.8633022308349609,
0.15151852369308472,
-0.26138606667518616,
0.23534263670444489,
-0.4941093623638153,
-0.3688742518424988,
0.053820494562387466,
-0.2657167911529541,
-0.6326286792755127,
0.030267605558037758,
0.12781400978565216,
0.4399946928024292,
-0.007668549194931984,
-0.6958146691322327,
0.08073122799396515,
-0.046400465071201324,
0.38837286829948425,
1.3108426332473755,
-0.009697379544377327,
0.4821670353412628,
-0.38150855898857117,
0.5788764953613281,
-0.21024569869041443,
0.4434732496738434,
0.34828248620033264,
-0.4248140752315521,
-0.47612521052360535,
-0.2031591683626175,
0.005050665233284235,
0.4205074608325958,
-0.42449474334716797,
0.24913963675498962,
-0.19890564680099487,
0.00904585886746645,
-0.34562915563583374,
0.03653203696012497,
0.4632538855075836,
0.14805467426776886,
0.023047400638461113,
-0.37812814116477966,
-0.2875312268733978,
-1.3894033432006836,
-0.5537607073783875,
-0.11249982565641403,
-0.11259554326534271,
0.3474594056606293,
0.4239993989467621,
0.029534844681620598,
0.8470085859298706,
-0.45131611824035645,
-0.20327867567539215,
-0.17560610175132751,
-0.2061063051223755,
0.028987189754843712,
0.31037721037864685,
0.6610243320465088,
-0.8473241925239563,
-0.28438642621040344,
-0.3451157808303833,
-0.7152097821235657,
-0.4692923426628113,
0.18804346024990082,
-0.20385044813156128,
0.1320197433233261,
0.6139973402023315,
-0.5686187148094177,
0.34856733679771423,
0.5247988104820251,
-0.6278291344642639,
0.6673950552940369,
0.3767837584018707,
-0.04393080994486809,
-0.8762159943580627,
-0.12835898995399475,
0.19905899465084076,
-0.2686232924461365,
-0.5993702411651611,
0.10406021773815155,
-0.35157933831214905,
0.2787386178970337,
-0.4817296862602234,
0.596766471862793,
-0.3577311933040619,
0.0028465420473366976,
-0.2998770773410797,
0.000017144418961834162,
-0.09911398589611053,
-0.013285116292536259,
-0.0024313824251294136,
0.5508763790130615,
0.5489739775657654,
-0.7358851432800293,
-0.06020086631178856,
0.19955946505069733,
-0.3253307640552521,
0.4094661474227905,
-0.6119217872619629,
0.24865561723709106,
-0.30605679750442505,
0.3594810962677002,
-0.36927899718284607,
-0.47322240471839905,
0.06111350283026695,
-0.1273198276758194,
0.031138494610786438,
-0.22396253049373627,
-0.6317397952079773,
-0.22575192153453827,
-0.435100793838501,
0.5192408561706543,
0.6800618767738342,
-0.2838599681854248,
0.33931270241737366,
0.7816160917282104,
-0.3507673740386963,
-0.8433930277824402,
-0.8158589005470276,
-0.10011324286460876,
-0.5487541556358337,
-0.6170481443405151,
0.011044199578464031,
0.09063491970300674,
-0.8283473253250122,
-0.13973970711231232,
-0.15878120064735413,
0.10305896401405334,
0.15503878891468048,
0.41688644886016846,
0.23750297725200653,
0.24532023072242737,
0.046294309198856354,
0.06845663487911224,
0.3211967647075653,
0.08451656997203827,
0.010320719331502914,
0.524686872959137,
0.10763148963451385,
-0.22152923047542572,
0.13878753781318665,
0.6808873414993286,
0.3960166871547699,
-0.11807602643966675,
0.8451627492904663,
0.12042102217674255,
-0.4407776892185211,
-0.11555526405572891,
-0.5266983509063721,
-0.35677677392959595,
-0.5115952491760254,
0.46061262488365173,
0.011948788538575172,
-1.5658597946166992,
0.47960740327835083,
0.3744809329509735,
0.2630617022514343,
0.24471132457256317,
0.30082136392593384,
0.23700155317783356,
0.9824638962745667,
0.8151768445968628,
-0.2088543325662613,
0.3341551423072815,
0.24530823528766632,
0.2591252326965332,
-0.7059491872787476,
-0.12273748219013214,
-0.5453751087188721,
-0.10788639634847641,
-0.9176763892173767,
-0.14578533172607422,
0.3014930784702301,
0.07970497757196426,
-0.2028300017118454,
-0.1101597249507904,
-0.4145756661891937,
0.5500834584236145,
0.5030892491340637,
-0.04030187800526619,
0.423891544342041,
0.05132177099585533,
0.0927639976143837,
-0.351616770029068,
-0.5100119709968567,
-0.9826571941375732,
1.2512222528457642,
0.6757835745811462,
0.9176145792007446,
0.09811122715473175,
0.5777163505554199,
0.6111445426940918,
0.5452529788017273,
-0.3670288026332855,
0.8227790594100952,
-0.2762758135795593,
-1.1256601810455322,
-0.03006894886493683,
-0.5064515471458435,
-0.8015893697738647,
0.3951306939125061,
-0.19339866936206818,
-1.1404211521148682,
0.3804127871990204,
0.2295645922422409,
-0.08533449470996857,
0.3667401969432831,
-0.42625316977500916,
0.4940047860145569,
-0.20798377692699432,
-0.5488808751106262,
-0.10234977304935455,
-0.6411706209182739,
0.8406484127044678,
-0.17890936136245728,
0.40333718061447144,
-0.46396785974502563,
0.21427257359027863,
0.7789070010185242,
-0.13260594010353088,
1.1270482540130615,
-0.15975765883922577,
-0.27611440420150757,
-0.08996865898370743,
0.08737844973802567,
0.29841387271881104,
0.04477304592728615,
-0.25605857372283936,
0.23425577580928802,
-0.15114352107048035,
-0.4966231882572174,
0.03131918981671333,
0.652521550655365,
-0.6324896216392517,
-1.0235644578933716,
-0.5473035573959351,
-0.6563237905502319,
-0.25800636410713196,
0.1961299479007721,
0.22340480983257294,
0.23754629492759705,
-0.23945352435112,
0.11175055056810379,
0.6999931335449219,
-0.7168547511100769,
0.2363017201423645,
0.39226192235946655,
-0.5381321907043457,
-0.017409756779670715,
0.2827893793582916,
0.1200750395655632,
0.828696608543396,
-0.16877925395965576,
-0.06875008344650269,
-0.2373482882976532,
-0.4845382273197174,
-0.006280108354985714,
0.22796234488487244,
-0.8264808058738708,
0.06282436102628708,
-0.8764667510986328,
-0.16104084253311157,
-0.6514267325401306,
0.0597488209605217,
-0.004953925497829914,
-0.3949131667613983,
0.11947096884250641,
-0.3747938573360443,
0.21517884731292725,
0.9010715484619141,
0.02521314099431038,
0.09930985420942307,
-0.5917278528213501,
0.2734943926334381,
0.28413230180740356,
0.14599721133708954,
-0.16226328909397125,
-0.38012930750846863,
0.1764560341835022,
-0.1611223816871643,
-0.22268545627593994,
-0.5601310133934021,
0.041313786059617996,
-0.047562628984451294,
0.665404736995697,
0.37667542695999146,
0.2673284411430359,
-0.10275228321552277,
-0.6312049031257629,
0.8658245801925659,
0.04049185663461685,
-0.74554443359375,
0.26629188656806946,
-0.5303491353988647,
-0.11422515660524368,
0.3685828447341919,
0.3333195149898529,
-0.7650363445281982,
-0.8394261002540588,
-0.44707655906677246,
-0.9371667504310608,
0.6428198218345642,
0.2544591724872589,
0.5348513722419739,
-0.2727872431278229,
0.18645912408828735,
0.36950695514678955,
0.3827800154685974,
-1.2677706480026245,
-0.19706173241138458,
0.1921871453523636,
-0.04698111116886139,
0.17661654949188232,
-0.6073936820030212,
-0.5285402536392212,
0.1401633620262146,
0.5150191783905029,
0.07506905496120453,
0.12744483351707458,
0.039134569466114044,
-0.12648649513721466,
0.018585940822958946,
0.6386407017707825,
0.5344012379646301,
0.6460024118423462,
0.002954769181087613,
0.16876010596752167,
-0.07176081091165543,
-0.5139088034629822,
0.21599270403385162,
0.166439950466156,
-0.43173614144325256,
-0.24363388121128082,
0.37050166726112366,
0.7572379112243652,
-0.4386201798915863,
-0.5264166593551636,
0.49590668082237244,
0.11338421702384949,
-0.06300884485244751,
-0.19202092289924622,
0.11534755676984787,
-0.1868562549352646,
0.23047584295272827,
0.39706090092658997,
-0.05160174146294594,
0.20744077861309052,
-0.814548134803772,
0.014545799233019352,
0.6783169507980347,
-0.1173555999994278,
-0.09808462113142014,
0.861673891544342,
0.23363187909126282,
-0.10059184581041336,
0.2869861423969269,
-0.05472063273191452,
-0.5754160284996033,
0.6383070349693298,
0.346307635307312,
0.8250476717948914,
-0.01311616413295269,
0.0682155042886734,
-0.012232084758579731,
0.7235164046287537,
-0.17365266382694244,
0.060850467532873154,
0.41556480526924133,
-0.8839349150657654,
-0.3946816027164459,
-0.7250954508781433,
-0.22426553070545197,
0.15259189903736115,
-0.6222694516181946,
-0.20784972608089447,
-0.5165892839431763,
-0.31020015478134155,
-0.21662861108779907,
-0.383430153131485,
-0.44753336906433105,
0.15348723530769348,
0.39156824350357056,
0.8177151083946228,
-1.0303915739059448,
0.64165860414505,
0.31930235028266907,
-0.34505608677864075,
-0.3609420359134674,
0.3830834925174713,
0.10160856693983078,
-0.6908381581306458,
0.8285781145095825,
0.4498059153556824,
-0.07763534784317017,
-0.5543055534362793,
-0.5849580764770508,
-0.49627789855003357,
0.63494473695755,
0.5099261999130249,
-0.682047963142395,
-0.13241761922836304,
0.5101101398468018,
0.4688573181629181,
-0.3864467144012451,
-0.16084054112434387,
0.5917919874191284,
0.33172333240509033,
-0.5257977247238159,
-1.1621867418289185,
0.23302027583122253,
-0.13314975798130035,
0.1779736876487732,
-0.08285768330097198,
-0.7309930920600891,
0.8100137114524841,
0.08360320329666138,
-0.05088215321302414,
-0.16624636948108673,
0.43296560645103455,
0.5223356485366821,
0.24031202495098114,
0.6093171238899231,
0.11458422243595123,
0.7298928499221802,
-0.1716776043176651,
1.3896336555480957,
-0.005118079949170351,
0.046166546642780304,
1.0825474262237549,
-0.5734843015670776,
0.28483760356903076,
0.38554322719573975,
-0.04161282628774643,
0.09161663800477982,
0.6446925401687622,
0.09026429057121277,
0.5024183988571167,
0.5228135585784912,
-0.4986177682876587,
-0.29299867153167725,
-0.560634434223175,
-0.515228271484375,
0.2063291072845459,
0.2801959812641144,
-0.7133558988571167,
0.2058672457933426,
0.03655466064810753,
0.2448156476020813,
0.2899082899093628,
-0.5653795599937439,
0.3774382472038269,
0.5588350296020508,
-0.6141360998153687,
-0.04341178387403488,
0.16618183255195618,
0.9949302077293396,
-0.48914429545402527,
0.19603383541107178,
-0.3030809760093689,
0.18131791055202484,
-0.28004884719848633,
-0.7939310073852539,
0.17836517095565796,
0.19497014582157135,
-0.2841870188713074,
-0.25628137588500977,
0.8633795380592346,
-0.3576439917087555,
-0.4978601634502411,
0.3924637734889984,
0.308788925409317,
0.08361276984214783,
0.12799397110939026,
-0.342963844537735,
0.16719451546669006,
0.01994258537888527,
-0.2051083892583847,
0.3965647518634796,
0.10567402094602585,
-0.48978427052497864,
0.7626826763153076,
0.4299083948135376,
0.15794353187084198,
0.4373685419559479,
0.32244279980659485,
0.7045261263847351,
-0.44756969809532166,
-0.4214614927768707,
-0.9798048138618469,
0.26731541752815247,
-0.45016855001449585,
-0.17530609667301178,
0.7971026301383972,
0.5383492112159729,
0.9044210910797119,
-0.0242093987762928,
1.0298386812210083,
0.13035935163497925,
0.32440438866615295,
-0.8302419185638428,
0.7285516262054443,
-0.31333276629447937,
0.3668830096721649,
-0.3593592643737793,
-1.0361002683639526,
-0.23764246702194214,
0.412717342376709,
-0.607872486114502,
0.4540138840675354,
0.44255197048187256,
0.7138920426368713,
-0.023670407012104988,
0.07124112546443939,
0.2847949266433716,
0.20989924669265747,
0.46240681409835815,
0.3253308832645416,
0.9672482013702393,
0.14315026998519897,
0.2463238686323166,
0.11424623429775238,
-0.15066486597061157,
0.04167192429304123,
-0.8678560256958008,
-0.9948297739028931,
0.09610006213188171,
-0.23931172490119934,
-0.49249058961868286,
0.1021806076169014,
1.0871996879577637,
0.6274493336677551,
-0.6273552179336548,
-0.22399470210075378,
0.2324548214673996,
0.09059028327465057,
0.26239827275276184,
-0.2522859275341034,
-0.05650551989674568,
0.0761910080909729,
-0.8442063927650452,
0.11388849467039108,
0.14737682044506073,
-0.13913649320602417,
-0.42504188418388367,
0.03398844599723816,
0.05549301952123642,
0.2356301248073578,
0.6577787399291992,
0.06336762011051178,
-0.7894110679626465,
-0.5731172561645508,
-0.2423747181892395,
-0.2437555193901062,
-0.28436294198036194,
0.782483696937561,
-0.14531861245632172,
0.05134415999054909,
0.12663723528385162,
0.4503971338272095,
0.05820504575967789,
-0.14674055576324463,
0.8586177229881287,
-0.8144351840019226,
0.2892337143421173,
0.44306641817092896,
0.6118943691253662,
0.49269920587539673,
-0.5374208092689514,
0.5440022945404053,
0.28374624252319336,
-0.6532477140426636,
-0.9879363179206848,
0.7291069030761719,
-0.5936167240142822,
-0.2263006567955017,
1.5055832862854004,
-0.07481624186038971,
0.0848589837551117,
-0.18926553428173065,
-0.16486449539661407,
0.11036115139722824,
-0.4280434548854828,
0.8276382088661194,
0.9197452664375305,
-0.046422239392995834,
-0.09089105576276779,
-0.8692995309829712,
0.6731478571891785,
0.43019238114356995,
-0.8523848652839661,
0.23012381792068481,
0.8773914575576782,
0.5235990285873413,
-0.2531502842903137,
0.7042509913444519,
-0.4022575318813324,
0.03662068396806717,
-0.2681066393852234,
0.023122912272810936,
0.22333994507789612,
-0.07374834269285202,
-0.17726589739322662,
0.16707639396190643,
0.25997427105903625,
0.09257236868143082
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14050v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14050v2
|
Extracting Emotion Phrases from Tweets using BART
| 2024-03-21T00:20:16 | 2024-03-23T14:46:59 |
Mahdi Rezapour
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, stat.AP
|
Sentiment analysis is a natural language processing task that aims to
identify and extract the emotional aspects of a text. However, many existing
sentiment analysis methods primarily classify the overall polarity of a text,
overlooking the specific phrases that convey sentiment. In this paper, we
applied an approach to sentiment analysis based on a question-answering
framework. Our approach leverages the power of Bidirectional Autoregressive
Transformer (BART), a pre-trained sequence-to-sequence model, to extract a
phrase from a given text that amplifies a given sentiment polarity. We create a
natural language question that identifies the specific emotion to extract and
then guide BART to pay attention to the relevant emotional cues in the text. We
use a classifier within BART to predict the start and end positions of the
answer span within the text, which helps to identify the precise boundaries of
the extracted emotion phrase. Our approach offers several advantages over most
sentiment analysis studies, including capturing the complete context and
meaning of the text and extracting precise token spans that highlight the
intended sentiment. We achieved an end loss of 87% and Jaccard score of 0.61.
|
[
-0.4787962734699249,
-0.9486766457557678,
0.37892603874206543,
0.4635898172855377,
-0.7747681140899658,
0.4375108480453491,
-0.03954501077532768,
-0.22312413156032562,
0.6491392254829407,
0.457087904214859,
-0.6390146613121033,
-0.3845418095588684,
-0.7031645178794861,
0.2983304262161255,
-0.25466224551200867,
1.307483434677124,
-0.24316160380840302,
-0.26001811027526855,
-0.09747330099344254,
-0.02591647207736969,
-0.3006633520126343,
-0.3761339783668518,
-0.6032235622406006,
0.23759175837039948,
0.6042261719703674,
0.5043646097183228,
0.480630487203598,
-0.16360682249069214,
0.7900767922401428,
0.2212439924478531,
-0.14542697370052338,
-0.23329991102218628,
-0.42794790863990784,
0.6358342170715332,
-0.10280770808458328,
-0.26615411043167114,
-0.3889617919921875,
0.07870879024267197,
0.384378582239151,
0.3699969947338104,
-0.05719536542892456,
0.39292463660240173,
-0.15649496018886566,
0.7547321915626526,
-0.41373851895332336,
0.24234449863433838,
-0.4097723662853241,
0.2639084756374359,
-0.17616994678974152,
-0.44228869676589966,
-0.1858896166086197,
-0.8926278352737427,
0.33279624581336975,
-0.1600126177072525,
0.20145747065544128,
0.197000190615654,
1.0552096366882324,
0.33368566632270813,
-0.3777376413345337,
-0.19225838780403137,
-0.41134658455848694,
0.7357656359672546,
-0.5860452055931091,
-0.10605902969837189,
0.05102808028459549,
0.3530854284763336,
0.4213213622570038,
-0.5442728996276855,
-0.6309166550636292,
0.2798598110675812,
-0.03711950033903122,
0.5313645005226135,
-0.4369070529937744,
0.1188470870256424,
0.1392655223608017,
0.342655211687088,
-0.6360031366348267,
-0.5953210592269897,
-0.217035174369812,
0.24533848464488983,
0.6875644326210022,
0.16296134889125824,
0.25590890645980835,
-0.6578328013420105,
-0.474528968334198,
-0.25987550616264343,
0.10133706033229828,
0.269853800535202,
0.16451045870780945,
0.3413417339324951,
-0.02777792699635029,
0.5871962308883667,
0.11777272820472717,
-0.03234181925654411,
0.04779232665896416,
0.264483779668808,
0.3415360748767853,
0.19684650003910065,
-0.29724717140197754,
-0.06038772314786911,
0.9747612476348877,
0.535608172416687,
0.47934865951538086,
-0.09592919051647186,
-0.36947229504585266,
-0.14621199667453766,
0.5301122665405273,
-0.7748663425445557,
-0.11706528067588806,
0.3701273202896118,
-0.6611474752426147,
-0.7067607641220093,
0.2995547950267792,
-1.3330187797546387,
-0.22887614369392395,
-0.015478517860174179,
0.31700271368026733,
-0.16077949106693268,
-0.37450262904167175,
-0.18882112205028534,
-0.5290824770927429,
0.3497280478477478,
0.17514169216156006,
-0.580812931060791,
0.21131488680839539,
0.5158066153526306,
0.8800455927848816,
-0.0026458892971277237,
0.40858930349349976,
-0.3654412627220154,
-0.352629154920578,
-0.39621132612228394,
0.6285485625267029,
-0.5756962895393372,
-0.6061119437217712,
0.10166523605585098,
0.10715719312429428,
-0.198504239320755,
-0.17011456191539764,
0.7261821031570435,
-0.8680264949798584,
0.45333775877952576,
-0.4287785589694977,
-0.4800845682621002,
-0.2488841861486435,
0.5024268627166748,
-0.5497472286224365,
1.1559240818023682,
0.22502395510673523,
-1.193212866783142,
-0.08756181597709656,
-1.03152334690094,
-0.6418080925941467,
-0.017760220915079117,
0.329059362411499,
-0.43205201625823975,
0.5302966833114624,
0.36159029603004456,
0.48957520723342896,
-0.40589430928230286,
0.39440858364105225,
-0.5486082434654236,
0.034208476543426514,
0.5368659496307373,
-0.4292448163032532,
0.8579543232917786,
0.2501167953014374,
-0.33809205889701843,
-0.056786347180604935,
-0.221868097782135,
0.057549625635147095,
0.29118606448173523,
-0.06788108497858047,
-0.3807763457298279,
-0.08353019505739212,
0.37511226534843445,
0.336506187915802,
0.2272585779428482,
-0.8641984462738037,
0.10434720665216446,
-0.39784374833106995,
0.028794052079319954,
0.8679888248443604,
0.400469571352005,
0.550751805305481,
0.006695953197777271,
1.0871065855026245,
-0.19232603907585144,
0.21068069338798523,
0.0780140608549118,
-0.45054373145103455,
-0.5695095658302307,
-0.14409807324409485,
-0.033145349472761154,
0.5110958218574524,
-0.5643032193183899,
0.45524370670318604,
-0.23431411385536194,
-0.27830085158348083,
-0.8010851740837097,
-0.28596773743629456,
0.09601093083620071,
0.7253709435462952,
0.4383038878440857,
-0.1433689147233963,
-0.6967689394950867,
-0.6912319660186768,
-0.159171000123024,
-0.5118076801300049,
0.3661419153213501,
0.2174690216779709,
0.24157224595546722,
-0.14598652720451355,
1.3704919815063477,
-0.8192542195320129,
0.14767798781394958,
-0.4161462187767029,
0.6187899112701416,
0.10176222026348114,
0.037146296352148056,
0.4431068003177643,
-0.9263929724693298,
-0.7122284173965454,
-0.12009680271148682,
-0.7775689959526062,
-0.6222624182701111,
-0.09526927769184113,
-0.39381691813468933,
0.14005495607852936,
0.28656598925590515,
-0.5550412535667419,
0.40409672260284424,
0.3190906345844269,
-0.2470628321170807,
0.4578095078468323,
0.5059622526168823,
0.17290835082530975,
-1.2161743640899658,
0.22746609151363373,
0.046780891716480255,
-0.22643424570560455,
-0.5610995888710022,
-0.12942448258399963,
0.024994000792503357,
0.0031157091725617647,
-0.2658381462097168,
0.4867965877056122,
0.043432485312223434,
-0.0005409437580965459,
-0.26761794090270996,
0.10467123240232468,
0.4874641001224518,
0.2641947269439697,
0.07254782319068909,
0.4398941993713379,
0.37195783853530884,
0.02887968346476555,
0.4202905297279358,
0.30357152223587036,
0.1827181577682495,
0.3705214560031891,
-0.5997037887573242,
0.051514316350221634,
-0.4107677638530731,
0.16624325513839722,
-1.3380639553070068,
0.03282589837908745,
0.4372664988040924,
-0.6055637001991272,
0.299893319606781,
-0.06925203651189804,
-0.3370506465435028,
-0.6976042985916138,
-0.473090261220932,
0.15628081560134888,
0.5065405964851379,
-0.22571444511413574,
0.6987124085426331,
0.36777734756469727,
-0.5661874413490295,
-0.6147571206092834,
-0.48114004731178284,
0.20791736245155334,
-0.4715239405632019,
-0.38785314559936523,
-0.14052939414978027,
-0.03714517503976822,
-0.44788551330566406,
0.01844470202922821,
-0.0007155833882279694,
-0.05389026552438736,
0.20775637030601501,
0.11203780025243759,
0.44642049074172974,
-0.2611953318119049,
0.3647927939891815,
0.46447357535362244,
-0.04115234687924385,
0.5858128666877747,
0.2033596634864807,
0.6034887433052063,
-0.457201212644577,
0.07734823226928711,
-0.4635751247406006,
0.4877752959728241,
0.6911077499389648,
-0.216803640127182,
0.5485295653343201,
0.8440021872520447,
-0.1166793629527092,
0.011583058163523674,
-0.49900585412979126,
-0.05533496290445328,
-0.43422356247901917,
0.2790859639644623,
-0.17968139052391052,
-0.5883134603500366,
0.5573266744613647,
-0.01029894594103098,
-0.09956298023462296,
0.49832430481910706,
0.2973857820034027,
-0.7158787846565247,
1.0070523023605347,
0.5028568506240845,
-0.4024365246295929,
0.5164823532104492,
-0.24528534710407257,
0.4850318729877472,
-0.7214149236679077,
-0.04762999340891838,
-0.30682694911956787,
-0.27655819058418274,
-0.49666285514831543,
-0.16405515372753143,
0.23929224908351898,
0.03981354832649231,
-0.22093410789966583,
0.21499639749526978,
-0.34416863322257996,
0.15152135491371155,
0.40918976068496704,
0.043181560933589935,
-0.23796989023685455,
-0.17296919226646423,
0.25618982315063477,
-0.03859124332666397,
-0.1779315173625946,
-0.625581681728363,
0.7147440910339355,
0.7018457055091858,
0.6285281777381897,
0.17291980981826782,
1.013270378112793,
0.4519738256931305,
0.5932608246803284,
-1.0198348760604858,
0.5978057384490967,
-0.055488914251327515,
-0.5843383073806763,
-0.35849690437316895,
-0.4215455651283264,
-0.6636289358139038,
0.10977087914943695,
-0.1620846688747406,
-0.44647982716560364,
0.016403455287218094,
-0.27674487233161926,
-0.06067551672458649,
0.20658273994922638,
-0.5577806830406189,
1.050832986831665,
-0.35500502586364746,
0.07669610530138016,
0.03569552302360535,
-1.0937663316726685,
0.16068866848945618,
-0.06949634850025177,
0.3557378947734833,
-0.349987268447876,
0.04540875926613808,
0.873949408531189,
-0.18875733017921448,
0.8620299696922302,
-0.41527071595191956,
-0.07986529916524887,
0.40934497117996216,
0.23480628430843353,
0.1803366243839264,
0.003686331445351243,
-0.11448114365339279,
-0.03802448883652687,
0.008022223599255085,
-0.3492840826511383,
-0.4835726320743561,
0.150321364402771,
-0.7412735223770142,
-0.33779382705688477,
-0.33461278676986694,
-0.3275064527988434,
-0.23137769103050232,
0.08993444591760635,
0.020645560696721077,
0.30745503306388855,
-0.5365922451019287,
-0.22625257074832916,
0.3874512314796448,
-0.10865461081266403,
0.9291476011276245,
-0.048242129385471344,
-0.13822442293167114,
-0.6276628375053406,
0.761414110660553,
-0.49717947840690613,
0.18728893995285034,
0.6759647130966187,
0.6239330172538757,
-0.46931350231170654,
0.08302440494298935,
-0.328513503074646,
0.2531028687953949,
-0.5696091651916504,
-0.5198891758918762,
-0.6392784118652344,
0.10562676191329956,
-0.684963583946228,
-0.4357520043849945,
-0.32608240842819214,
-0.4911770522594452,
-0.5400253534317017,
-0.15709488093852997,
0.34096845984458923,
0.6495554447174072,
0.05662376433610916,
0.4755657911300659,
-1.0971415042877197,
0.22979961335659027,
0.2094302922487259,
-0.09939642250537872,
-0.1593438982963562,
-0.5823570489883423,
-0.10768720507621765,
-0.13030898571014404,
-0.37954792380332947,
-1.2824777364730835,
1.147244930267334,
0.1445525735616684,
0.048968590795993805,
0.7189611792564392,
0.4940679669380188,
0.6615710258483887,
-0.1797354817390442,
0.8138317465782166,
0.46461111307144165,
-1.124284267425537,
0.8811756372451782,
-0.2598058879375458,
0.05395734682679176,
0.5523617267608643,
0.36321714520454407,
-0.6637281775474548,
-0.6165423393249512,
-0.649020254611969,
-0.9841181635856628,
0.6035451292991638,
0.1117304340004921,
0.33992061018943787,
-0.39039483666419983,
0.25897330045700073,
0.020417096093297005,
0.41418904066085815,
-0.7471290826797485,
-0.2719710171222687,
-0.4200436472892761,
-0.7045740485191345,
0.008910097181797028,
-0.2647745609283447,
-0.09813082218170166,
-0.04738736152648926,
0.4629686176776886,
-0.07394186407327652,
0.45409902930259705,
0.09358836710453033,
-0.20943336188793182,
-0.49315181374549866,
0.34901782870292664,
0.01133807934820652,
-0.05810578539967537,
-0.6631883978843689,
0.014359451830387115,
-0.038206782191991806,
-0.301205039024353,
-0.1714315265417099,
0.23224805295467377,
0.13597427308559418,
0.1958669126033783,
0.35278570652008057,
0.7021437883377075,
-0.07517362385988235,
-0.744208812713623,
0.9268965125083923,
-0.26638251543045044,
-0.08238770812749863,
-0.2520078420639038,
-0.49383100867271423,
-0.16523315012454987,
0.5246036648750305,
0.5349170565605164,
0.1888626664876938,
0.3653309941291809,
-0.5843598246574402,
0.12973655760288239,
0.4912041425704956,
-0.6544786095619202,
-0.536708414554596,
0.4552915692329407,
0.1334449052810669,
-0.1135387197136879,
0.47769802808761597,
-0.31265658140182495,
-1.0847973823547363,
0.7391653656959534,
0.4485795795917511,
1.4997594356536865,
-0.09359591454267502,
0.6541464924812317,
0.23849156498908997,
0.09897326678037643,
0.25118041038513184,
0.5838863253593445,
-0.21906344592571259,
-0.7452471256256104,
-0.3194686770439148,
-0.873656690120697,
-0.5533159971237183,
-0.6266580820083618,
-1.1911040544509888,
0.16757994890213013,
-0.2726174294948578,
-0.31133612990379333,
-0.41411975026130676,
-0.0813208743929863,
-0.4090244174003601,
0.616012454032898,
0.4314536452293396,
0.566486656665802,
-1.3024017810821533,
0.47387680411338806,
0.8414238691329956,
-0.5224511623382568,
-0.7714610695838928,
0.2964029014110565,
-0.3546479642391205,
-0.616027295589447,
0.823631763458252,
0.3620118498802185,
-0.16485494375228882,
-0.05666068568825722,
-0.6825409531593323,
-0.5504105091094971,
0.782836377620697,
-0.037517014890909195,
-0.1659998744726181,
-0.027124037966132164,
0.11325118690729141,
0.8474112749099731,
-0.4513642191886902,
0.5071768164634705,
0.4315057694911957,
0.179168239235878,
0.1546008139848709,
-0.6604275703430176,
0.13995932042598724,
-0.4461829364299774,
-0.18707247078418732,
0.24838551878929138,
-0.33128154277801514,
0.6965651512145996,
-0.15583424270153046,
-0.10898172110319138,
-0.30796557664871216,
0.6067306399345398,
-0.13085830211639404,
0.5114070773124695,
0.6495347023010254,
0.3857437074184418,
0.6381298899650574,
0.052964843809604645,
0.9115491509437561,
-0.2604212462902069,
0.8603517413139343,
0.6220701336860657,
-0.15086545050144196,
1.0693531036376953,
0.5691461563110352,
-0.05478469654917717,
0.8147812485694885,
0.5776098370552063,
0.41150522232055664,
0.7627687454223633,
-0.14203301072120667,
-0.25249767303466797,
-0.1497589498758316,
0.1368490308523178,
0.03324984014034271,
0.4138246178627014,
0.41866108775138855,
-0.3780314028263092,
-0.15631555020809174,
0.3556949496269226,
0.06498593091964722,
-0.3214803636074066,
-0.24642327427864075,
0.8344030380249023,
0.09548743069171906,
-0.5648378729820251,
0.050402864813804626,
-0.2563106119632721,
0.38656821846961975,
-0.09173673391342163,
0.24401165544986725,
-0.3375586271286011,
-0.10669825971126556,
-0.029715178534388542,
-1.0427650213241577,
0.4689815640449524,
0.2168799191713333,
-0.060971952974796295,
-0.5058616995811462,
0.6680803298950195,
-0.33607685565948486,
-0.4172077775001526,
0.3076385259628296,
0.5798594951629639,
0.136477530002594,
-0.232267826795578,
-0.8888428211212158,
-0.21216696500778198,
0.03130204603075981,
-0.6900607347488403,
-0.07773112505674362,
0.794272780418396,
0.422934353351593,
0.49448248744010925,
0.36687153577804565,
-0.0560939759016037,
-0.1583830565214157,
0.32078391313552856,
1.055420160293579,
-0.861676037311554,
-0.4671402871608734,
-0.9756572842597961,
0.6646807193756104,
-0.2776789665222168,
-0.36972057819366455,
0.44766223430633545,
0.24738293886184692,
0.03932199254631996,
-0.006622976623475552,
1.0466203689575195,
-0.31154927611351013,
0.9569884538650513,
0.023526065051555634,
0.40893566608428955,
-0.7272151708602905,
0.2130715399980545,
-0.6705136299133301,
-0.684412956237793,
-0.43693244457244873,
0.858277440071106,
-0.4689231216907501,
-0.29060977697372437,
0.7604107856750488,
0.45036715269088745,
0.14456626772880554,
0.49252820014953613,
-0.10052455961704254,
0.24313439428806305,
0.46887609362602234,
0.026920653879642487,
0.8131794929504395,
-0.3922922611236572,
0.6080893278121948,
-0.39879000186920166,
-0.2344527393579483,
-0.3972269594669342,
-0.7505346536636353,
-0.860977292060852,
-0.3227694630622864,
-0.3225543200969696,
-0.6092949509620667,
-0.2885037362575531,
1.0260285139083862,
-0.002725066617131233,
-0.8299615383148193,
-0.024747474119067192,
-0.08061777055263519,
-0.03880500793457031,
0.0892816111445427,
-0.4244917333126068,
0.6338884830474854,
-0.7389415502548218,
-0.5749967098236084,
-0.06156010925769806,
0.25538620352745056,
-0.10079360753297806,
0.2365572601556778,
0.2173418551683426,
-0.07031062990427017,
0.2745603024959564,
0.6960445046424866,
0.06827956438064575,
-0.33796972036361694,
-0.5268508195877075,
0.44529175758361816,
-0.10157458484172821,
0.050030454993247986,
0.5922530293464661,
-0.4628504812717438,
0.6280547976493835,
0.4972987771034241,
0.4852200150489807,
0.45686769485473633,
0.5616177916526794,
0.4528268873691559,
-0.7575706839561462,
-0.39396366477012634,
0.724510133266449,
0.31040284037590027,
0.27047035098075867,
-0.18939217925071716,
0.2025400847196579,
0.3244672119617462,
-0.6337713003158569,
-0.6673120856285095,
-0.07192862033843994,
-1.53173828125,
-0.2080373615026474,
1.1592917442321777,
-0.0792129784822464,
-0.22431741654872894,
-0.15685254335403442,
-0.4302256405353546,
0.5414972901344299,
-0.6523758172988892,
0.989116370677948,
0.3408290147781372,
-0.1951865702867508,
-0.2281554788351059,
-0.25933489203453064,
0.07701200246810913,
0.45028215646743774,
-0.7558639645576477,
0.01217764150351286,
0.1276618093252182,
0.0963435247540474,
0.002290986943989992,
0.7050178050994873,
-0.05041217803955078,
-0.10617656260728836,
-0.2946619391441345,
0.4658391773700714,
0.5801253318786621,
0.032260142266750336,
-0.46820759773254395,
0.4460819363594055,
-0.2630080282688141,
-0.6002067923545837
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14048v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14048v1
|
The NeurIPS 2023 Machine Learning for Audio Workshop: Affective Audio Benchmarks and Novel Data
| 2024-03-21T00:13:59 | 2024-03-21T00:13:59 |
Alice Baird, Rachel Manzelli, Panagiotis Tzirakis, Chris Gagne, Haoqi Li, Sadie Allen, Sander Dieleman, Brian Kulis, Shrikanth S. Narayanan, Alan Cowen
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
The NeurIPS 2023 Machine Learning for Audio Workshop brings together machine
learning (ML) experts from various audio domains. There are several valuable
audio-driven ML tasks, from speech emotion recognition to audio event
detection, but the community is sparse compared to other ML areas, e.g.,
computer vision or natural language processing. A major limitation with audio
is the available data; with audio being a time-dependent modality, high-quality
data collection is time-consuming and costly, making it challenging for
academic groups to apply their often state-of-the-art strategies to a larger,
more generalizable dataset. In this short white paper, to encourage researchers
with limited access to large-datasets, the organizers first outline several
open-source datasets that are available to the community, and for the duration
of the workshop are making several propriety datasets available. Namely, three
vocal datasets, Hume-Prosody, Hume-VocalBurst, an acted emotional speech
dataset Modulate-Sonata, and an in-game streamer dataset Modulate-Stream. We
outline the current baselines on these datasets but encourage researchers from
across audio to utilize them outside of the initial baseline tasks.
|
[
-0.6679720282554626,
-0.4076058864593506,
0.31858310103416443,
0.3217303454875946,
0.06671945750713348,
-0.25260597467422485,
-0.39300262928009033,
-0.644045352935791,
0.31468522548675537,
0.3296521306037903,
-0.854216456413269,
-0.5514647364616394,
-0.6339627504348755,
-0.04331662505865097,
-0.38037246465682983,
0.8136815428733826,
0.12385903298854828,
0.0549723245203495,
-0.23583340644836426,
-0.6382018327713013,
-0.44763895869255066,
-0.44150298833847046,
-0.7680400609970093,
-0.15713879466056824,
0.6114330291748047,
0.6163288950920105,
0.3898697793483734,
0.14772216975688934,
0.4315740764141083,
0.16591744124889374,
-0.1070762574672699,
-0.08559522777795792,
-0.31652703881263733,
0.5548054575920105,
0.33261147141456604,
-0.3173978924751282,
-0.5285645723342896,
0.019575798884034157,
0.2689521908760071,
0.6305282115936279,
-0.03488227725028992,
0.3788057267665863,
-0.0732572078704834,
0.8094620704650879,
-0.711983859539032,
0.34111839532852173,
-0.5260952115058899,
0.415641188621521,
-0.2947006821632385,
-0.13478796184062958,
-0.33334881067276,
-0.09509531408548355,
0.20101480185985565,
-0.7362626194953918,
0.10248585790395737,
-0.2695954740047455,
0.40640246868133545,
0.8314204216003418,
-0.22672176361083984,
-0.31803378462791443,
-0.7030813694000244,
0.9315487146377563,
-0.7604933977127075,
0.46102651953697205,
0.5675704479217529,
0.3732355237007141,
-0.12408725172281265,
-0.436324805021286,
-0.42292091250419617,
0.1691150963306427,
0.4597092866897583,
0.15050360560417175,
-0.42850255966186523,
-0.141350656747818,
0.376798152923584,
0.3176470994949341,
-0.4705958664417267,
0.3741946518421173,
0.1740081012248993,
0.1843661367893219,
0.709184467792511,
0.3002256453037262,
0.178492471575737,
0.05266975983977318,
0.18595954775810242,
-0.027595937252044678,
-0.5610300898551941,
-0.032032549381256104,
0.4609186053276062,
0.2654041647911072,
-0.26323479413986206,
0.40423470735549927,
-0.23218141496181488,
0.5761647820472717,
0.02086551859974861,
0.17834559082984924,
0.6004923582077026,
-0.13488145172595978,
-0.05427110940217972,
0.11255384981632233,
0.7601308822631836,
0.23328366875648499,
-0.10645218193531036,
0.01496738288551569,
-0.11547324061393738,
-0.111673504114151,
0.04743311554193497,
-0.8259332180023193,
-0.3732476532459259,
0.46014082431793213,
-0.34762126207351685,
-0.08100589364767075,
-0.40395471453666687,
-1.0086891651153564,
-0.6730039119720459,
-0.8550927042961121,
0.40170055627822876,
-0.20484092831611633,
-0.3855314254760742,
-0.29132428765296936,
-0.18855324387550354,
-0.21158313751220703,
0.225479856133461,
-0.9623035192489624,
0.4584379196166992,
0.6183555126190186,
0.7888717651367188,
-0.2502990663051605,
0.11108921468257904,
-0.5848748087882996,
0.010809576138854027,
-0.11882387846708298,
0.4513539671897888,
-0.7048871517181396,
-0.33357110619544983,
-0.2158089280128479,
0.0023125025909394026,
0.23894470930099487,
-0.8391155004501343,
0.7264048457145691,
-0.04267029091715813,
0.22089403867721558,
-0.19875818490982056,
-0.59885573387146,
-0.10253824293613434,
-0.20758089423179626,
-0.75999915599823,
0.8435845971107483,
0.06266467273235321,
-0.654890775680542,
0.583065390586853,
-0.9499067068099976,
-0.3689075708389282,
-0.055605463683605194,
-0.22514188289642334,
-0.7599668502807617,
0.3393791615962982,
0.2986947298049927,
0.5232217907905579,
-0.22874869406223297,
0.3682631850242615,
-0.8158049583435059,
-0.3565635085105896,
0.39520564675331116,
-0.460089772939682,
0.5149131417274475,
0.29720568656921387,
-0.5474728941917419,
0.1484958827495575,
-0.9610103368759155,
-0.3196966052055359,
-0.15991701185703278,
0.05543642118573189,
0.004192583728581667,
0.3671441972255707,
0.5139837861061096,
0.23222149908542633,
-0.1983841508626938,
-0.5824143290519714,
-0.18230950832366943,
-0.14800968766212463,
0.7379067540168762,
0.7147279977798462,
0.03495679423213005,
0.18530432879924774,
-0.002635627519339323,
0.5643414258956909,
0.011729591526091099,
0.21417133510112762,
-0.08265423774719238,
-0.31870102882385254,
-0.6356017589569092,
-0.45017337799072266,
0.24600239098072052,
0.2609420120716095,
-0.08112864196300507,
0.4133247137069702,
0.2435743659734726,
-0.6691117286682129,
-0.8899169564247131,
-0.06258247792720795,
-0.11910218745470047,
0.46125558018684387,
0.5450536608695984,
-0.1521398425102234,
-0.9401782751083374,
-0.7690606117248535,
0.032685212790966034,
0.1835569441318512,
-0.1667141616344452,
0.7576325535774231,
0.15845228731632233,
-0.21742546558380127,
0.8657073378562927,
-0.20568856596946716,
-0.24918478727340698,
0.07906784862279892,
0.3976057767868042,
0.45923832058906555,
0.497599333524704,
0.3927377164363861,
-0.9376087784767151,
-0.393000066280365,
-0.30550146102905273,
-0.7811338901519775,
-0.23199214041233063,
0.1695019155740738,
0.19857141375541687,
0.302537739276886,
0.39067500829696655,
-0.37150371074676514,
0.29638516902923584,
0.9275733828544617,
-0.05643583461642265,
0.22354352474212646,
0.28553447127342224,
0.2599163353443146,
-0.7894321084022522,
0.07499020546674728,
0.0586865060031414,
0.03366320952773094,
-0.5574601292610168,
-0.5036328434944153,
-0.43636494874954224,
-0.5267927050590515,
-0.4858274459838867,
0.33964988589286804,
-0.15052290260791779,
-0.3807153105735779,
-0.44803497195243835,
0.08514372259378433,
-0.3861522972583771,
0.33688434958457947,
0.18014708161354065,
0.4781384766101837,
0.6583878397941589,
-0.4491558074951172,
0.410450279712677,
0.22052320837974548,
-0.18321767449378967,
0.8371655344963074,
-0.684319257736206,
0.37973546981811523,
0.030772536993026733,
0.3155049979686737,
-0.6391376852989197,
-0.43979382514953613,
0.08413198590278625,
-0.5252150297164917,
0.19270870089530945,
-0.2529210150241852,
-0.3283504843711853,
-0.12024282664060593,
0.20976190268993378,
0.5802639126777649,
0.5302997827529907,
-0.5363562703132629,
0.500684380531311,
0.9497762322425842,
-0.27234604954719543,
-0.43389320373535156,
-0.5833792090415955,
0.12827809154987335,
-0.7097792029380798,
-0.3928152918815613,
0.05793775990605354,
-0.1389731913805008,
-0.13754571974277496,
0.23875075578689575,
0.03768661618232727,
-0.2150011509656906,
0.21167650818824768,
0.8613511919975281,
-0.12931391596794128,
-0.08034080266952515,
0.3722864091396332,
-0.2722857892513275,
-0.3598455488681793,
0.15851452946662903,
-0.2542877495288849,
0.3818880617618561,
-0.1024242714047432,
-0.3303654193878174,
-0.5238485336303711,
0.4795666038990021,
0.40061113238334656,
-0.06932525336742401,
0.16797740757465363,
0.937871515750885,
-0.4324283301830292,
-0.15026502311229706,
-0.31126490235328674,
-0.13715030252933502,
-0.40650179982185364,
0.3457397222518921,
-0.17035143077373505,
-1.0927774906158447,
0.3679317831993103,
-0.1432623267173767,
0.05337526276707649,
0.43401899933815,
0.597006618976593,
-0.3862422704696655,
1.2546417713165283,
0.6151650547981262,
-0.31465932726860046,
0.5341475009918213,
-0.13797934353351593,
0.08720660209655762,
-0.7733955979347229,
-0.22723488509655,
-0.6343518495559692,
-0.7260406613349915,
-0.5398917198181152,
-0.2245364934206009,
0.3433398902416229,
-0.3381456136703491,
-0.12204308807849884,
0.39042603969573975,
-0.5008009076118469,
0.359331876039505,
0.54761803150177,
-0.03330908715724945,
-0.14544188976287842,
-0.32537639141082764,
0.41751667857170105,
-0.33460673689842224,
-0.5411521196365356,
-0.08239848911762238,
1.259405493736267,
0.26419857144355774,
0.2647317945957184,
-0.10231682658195496,
0.6695224642753601,
0.28780752420425415,
0.13609209656715393,
-0.8070921897888184,
0.31408172845840454,
-0.053267549723386765,
-0.6944085955619812,
-0.3810022175312042,
-0.5299579501152039,
-0.9928792119026184,
-0.24850571155548096,
-0.27941370010375977,
-0.6143593192100525,
0.36707091331481934,
0.1676121950149536,
0.05416017770767212,
0.17541371285915375,
-0.5375977158546448,
0.8584372997283936,
-0.021803006529808044,
-0.2765519917011261,
-0.2899608314037323,
-0.5514320731163025,
0.0063124471344053745,
-0.30328497290611267,
0.37202343344688416,
-0.6670939922332764,
0.018086427822709084,
0.8383685350418091,
-0.04804977402091026,
0.6118636131286621,
-0.5388349890708923,
0.21367484331130981,
0.32617855072021484,
-0.1115429624915123,
0.18228217959403992,
0.20492324233055115,
-0.2570566236972809,
0.21084599196910858,
-0.12826380133628845,
-0.46243736147880554,
-0.5875703692436218,
0.6846106648445129,
-0.7663421034812927,
-0.05407339334487915,
-0.002263896632939577,
-0.5063222646713257,
-0.6336148977279663,
-0.07360726594924927,
0.15726728737354279,
0.6756170392036438,
-0.3608270287513733,
0.6058408617973328,
0.5904918909072876,
-0.2868049144744873,
0.5350216031074524,
0.3335345387458801,
0.0665845051407814,
-0.5574063658714294,
1.1878941059112549,
0.13872915506362915,
-0.10771432518959045,
0.2083754539489746,
0.13753458857536316,
-0.13924336433410645,
-0.5351937413215637,
-0.09168731421232224,
-0.17880146205425262,
-0.4252617061138153,
-0.026122549548745155,
-0.7016730308532715,
0.306029349565506,
-0.28036537766456604,
-0.017381995916366577,
-0.5197669863700867,
-0.585150420665741,
-0.6003687977790833,
-0.07281197607517242,
0.4443729817867279,
0.5267812609672546,
-0.4487997889518738,
-0.003090774640440941,
-0.6190113425254822,
0.4214334189891815,
0.0973057821393013,
0.24194100499153137,
-0.15271548926830292,
-0.2541830837726593,
-0.44548436999320984,
-0.06782297044992447,
-0.1942385584115982,
-0.8799172043800354,
0.3587855398654938,
0.26191234588623047,
0.48521506786346436,
0.4126550555229187,
0.14786846935749054,
0.49950674176216125,
-0.16137592494487762,
0.7803283929824829,
0.27279791235923767,
-0.9995927810668945,
0.7771220207214355,
-0.498824805021286,
0.15221402049064636,
0.8597539067268372,
0.7808277010917664,
-0.7146536707878113,
-0.28355666995048523,
-0.8450297117233276,
-1.0760380029678345,
0.5361592769622803,
0.22228841483592987,
0.018663419410586357,
0.17872552573680878,
-0.013386006467044353,
0.3166032135486603,
0.45032861828804016,
-0.4329473078250885,
-0.12403272837400436,
-0.29217979311943054,
-0.4694528877735138,
-0.38297727704048157,
0.09435856342315674,
-0.07738737761974335,
-0.3326420187950134,
0.7619554996490479,
-0.16256746649742126,
0.295256108045578,
-0.09810241311788559,
0.189431831240654,
-0.1622954159975052,
0.37749746441841125,
0.22241999208927155,
0.29104089736938477,
-0.39230817556381226,
0.07337480038404465,
0.1990443766117096,
-0.2254715859889984,
0.25259754061698914,
0.022670982405543327,
-0.06599738448858261,
0.048145364969968796,
0.16127312183380127,
1.2067902088165283,
0.35714706778526306,
-0.9077733755111694,
0.37118101119995117,
-0.09484254568815231,
-0.3003453016281128,
-0.5089621543884277,
0.025287818163633347,
0.09685732424259186,
0.32173776626586914,
0.12899023294448853,
0.23267032206058502,
0.5656412839889526,
-0.5197018980979919,
0.39800989627838135,
-0.05241845175623894,
-1.1666176319122314,
-0.3816773593425751,
0.6044329404830933,
0.26914915442466736,
-0.26259881258010864,
0.6153160929679871,
-0.013584207743406296,
-0.13370516896247864,
0.5075418949127197,
0.16737212240695953,
1.1354502439498901,
-0.041451528668403625,
-0.007205479312688112,
0.38264137506484985,
-0.10515455901622772,
0.36399227380752563,
0.23259767889976501,
-0.2395639568567276,
-0.22266611456871033,
-0.46847212314605713,
-0.38693967461586,
-0.9260509610176086,
0.3999570906162262,
-0.7196033596992493,
0.4574318528175354,
-0.35953882336616516,
-0.49164459109306335,
-0.020616304129362106,
-0.014007244259119034,
-0.691215991973877,
0.08824282884597778,
0.2585485875606537,
0.6323013305664062,
-0.9720527529716492,
0.3502631187438965,
0.3580886125564575,
-0.18449753522872925,
-0.6185375452041626,
-0.2005472332239151,
0.33763396739959717,
-0.2915770411491394,
0.3243560791015625,
0.14227358996868134,
0.32844895124435425,
-0.08602338284254074,
-0.6712422370910645,
-0.7086116075515747,
0.7549238801002502,
0.39415243268013,
-0.6275935173034668,
0.09778784215450287,
-0.05806534364819527,
0.592043399810791,
-0.28736624121665955,
0.3278235197067261,
0.5326182842254639,
0.7065280079841614,
0.04965385049581528,
-0.592171847820282,
-0.28022363781929016,
-0.5331804752349854,
-0.743678867816925,
0.40824031829833984,
-0.32782572507858276,
0.5194156169891357,
0.09838174283504486,
0.14559319615364075,
-0.28653931617736816,
0.7609326839447021,
0.13895809650421143,
0.8108447790145874,
0.7263547778129578,
0.7933405637741089,
0.8433964252471924,
-0.33518096804618835,
0.6756733059883118,
0.09885953366756439,
0.041010696440935135,
1.3197697401046753,
-0.19569146633148193,
1.036388635635376,
0.3686530888080597,
-0.22966058552265167,
0.29865390062332153,
0.810471773147583,
-0.38232582807540894,
0.44193997979164124,
0.3582809269428253,
-0.4182763695716858,
-0.2785223126411438,
-0.4948425889015198,
-0.46501559019088745,
0.5444810390472412,
0.35306501388549805,
-0.07163264602422714,
0.22414793074131012,
0.42323246598243713,
-0.11812619119882584,
-0.2864503860473633,
-0.0410907045006752,
0.9439768195152283,
0.13386431336402893,
-0.28425097465515137,
0.14713361859321594,
-0.5511019229888916,
0.47814273834228516,
-0.23501305282115936,
-0.040280550718307495,
0.10317543148994446,
0.01314279343932867,
-0.41652801632881165,
-0.6381999850273132,
0.36975955963134766,
0.09916086494922638,
-0.1590537130832672,
-0.15274053812026978,
0.48465657234191895,
-0.2322966605424881,
-0.12845760583877563,
0.44401419162750244,
0.06344427913427353,
0.29391899704933167,
-0.3773036003112793,
-0.673206627368927,
0.25291064381599426,
-0.3297063708305359,
-0.23143990337848663,
0.32642027735710144,
0.6040417551994324,
0.3110603392124176,
0.4762837588787079,
0.5854780673980713,
0.19700568914413452,
-0.11528271436691284,
0.21273575723171234,
0.5749138593673706,
-0.6056167483329773,
-0.4455495774745941,
-0.3990604877471924,
0.48781779408454895,
-0.06855396926403046,
-0.4331594407558441,
0.7148719429969788,
0.576208233833313,
0.7305277585983276,
0.24149112403392792,
0.7808677554130554,
0.08669554442167282,
0.6392612457275391,
-0.33498114347457886,
0.343970388174057,
-0.6981606483459473,
-0.09085287153720856,
-0.6333625912666321,
-0.8350459933280945,
-0.19593991339206696,
0.10651164501905441,
-0.17290300130844116,
-0.12355628609657288,
0.3131677508354187,
0.4979335367679596,
0.023369736969470978,
0.6913479566574097,
0.20065127313137054,
0.0005363588570617139,
0.3316594958305359,
0.9077346324920654,
1.0246798992156982,
-0.2554360330104828,
0.32931992411613464,
-0.3990720510482788,
-0.11322136223316193,
-0.39920008182525635,
-0.9621379971504211,
-0.5254818201065063,
-0.8962680101394653,
-0.5589664578437805,
-0.03689074143767357,
0.0031849220395088196,
1.0329062938690186,
1.0359866619110107,
-0.9129816293716431,
-0.19458001852035522,
-0.24662554264068604,
0.006133390590548515,
-0.21978053450584412,
-0.21809303760528564,
0.19060726463794708,
-0.1578637957572937,
-0.8084580898284912,
0.7744253277778625,
0.27267158031463623,
0.033011604100465775,
-0.05186789110302925,
-0.29119646549224854,
0.16123871505260468,
-0.12492188066244125,
0.38112086057662964,
0.5015413761138916,
-0.26502469182014465,
-0.06019177660346031,
-0.08905523270368576,
0.3386037051677704,
0.160838782787323,
0.8396998643875122,
-0.6314001679420471,
0.4383251667022705,
0.493623822927475,
0.7623462677001953,
0.8121863007545471,
-0.5683653354644775,
0.5223087072372437,
-0.5229057669639587,
0.13005897402763367,
0.6276575326919556,
0.19313956797122955,
0.35932210087776184,
-0.02675737999379635,
0.7534505724906921,
0.2576606869697571,
-0.7484385371208191,
-0.9835926294326782,
0.016721054911613464,
-1.1567482948303223,
-0.08642592281103134,
0.7762525081634521,
-0.00913658645004034,
0.09308595210313797,
-0.1456601470708847,
-0.12327858805656433,
0.43913403153419495,
-0.5103105902671814,
0.4577397406101227,
0.6873540878295898,
-0.45075714588165283,
-0.24191814661026,
-0.819832980632782,
0.6876028180122375,
0.44915634393692017,
-1.0343780517578125,
0.1619885116815567,
0.6383759379386902,
-0.1788702756166458,
0.025955775752663612,
0.48848116397857666,
-0.2598852813243866,
0.2596195638179779,
0.018422333523631096,
0.0190468430519104,
-0.2262490838766098,
-0.5218039155006409,
-0.6047995090484619,
0.3909943103790283,
-0.14444079995155334,
0.10648344457149506
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14037v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14037v1
|
Ax-to-Grind Urdu: Benchmark Dataset for Urdu Fake News Detection
| 2024-03-20T23:21:35 | 2024-03-20T23:21:35 |
Sheetal Harris, Jinshuo Liu, Hassan Jalil Hadi, Yue Cao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Misinformation can seriously impact society, affecting anything from public
opinion to institutional confidence and the political horizon of a state. Fake
News (FN) proliferation on online websites and Online Social Networks (OSNs)
has increased profusely. Various fact-checking websites include news in English
and barely provide information about FN in regional languages. Thus the Urdu FN
purveyors cannot be discerned using factchecking portals. SOTA approaches for
Fake News Detection (FND) count upon appropriately labelled and large datasets.
FND in regional and resource-constrained languages lags due to the lack of
limited-sized datasets and legitimate lexical resources. The previous datasets
for Urdu FND are limited-sized, domain-restricted, publicly unavailable and not
manually verified where the news is translated from English into Urdu. In this
paper, we curate and contribute the first largest publicly available dataset
for Urdu FND, Ax-to-Grind Urdu, to bridge the identified gaps and limitations
of existing Urdu datasets in the literature. It constitutes 10,083 fake and
real news on fifteen domains collected from leading and authentic Urdu
newspapers and news channel websites in Pakistan and India. FN for the
Ax-to-Grind dataset is collected from websites and crowdsourcing. The dataset
contains news items in Urdu from the year 2017 to the year 2023. Expert
journalists annotated the dataset. We benchmark the dataset with an ensemble
model of mBERT,XLNet, and XLM RoBERTa. The selected models are originally
trained on multilingual large corpora. The results of the proposed model are
based on performance metrics, F1-score, accuracy, precision, recall and MCC
value.
|
[
-0.12563608586788177,
-0.4031120836734772,
0.34267300367355347,
0.6729625463485718,
-0.1626514345407486,
0.18760865926742554,
0.031954504549503326,
-0.18983355164527893,
0.1205534115433693,
0.3889908492565155,
-0.5348641872406006,
-0.5730918645858765,
-0.6926079988479614,
0.5703322291374207,
-0.5830399394035339,
0.7999135255813599,
-0.14380481839179993,
0.07719352096319199,
0.05051199346780777,
-0.3241496682167053,
-0.10763723403215408,
-0.3167671859264374,
-0.42872223258018494,
0.06892021000385284,
0.2312411367893219,
0.5808844566345215,
0.6983621120452881,
0.7530447244644165,
0.27827170491218567,
0.2375280112028122,
0.19247716665267944,
0.5913534164428711,
-0.4515663981437683,
-0.2952727675437927,
-0.1581527292728424,
-0.2926015853881836,
-0.19769056141376495,
-0.07779079675674438,
0.5994457006454468,
0.3815026879310608,
0.03954964503645897,
0.2003837376832962,
-0.2558687925338745,
0.41969621181488037,
-0.5504466891288757,
-0.11697836965322495,
-0.583861768245697,
0.013948863372206688,
-0.6409165263175964,
0.04056942090392113,
-0.32679593563079834,
-0.5435426235198975,
-0.5176244974136353,
-0.4432045519351959,
0.17271816730499268,
0.17338435351848602,
1.0693804025650024,
-0.07779525965452194,
-0.5988238453865051,
-0.2648613750934601,
-0.6999682784080505,
0.8246988654136658,
-0.6801431775093079,
0.6808689832687378,
0.5527947545051575,
0.4297879636287689,
-0.09381161630153656,
-0.5656252503395081,
-0.7802419662475586,
-0.04064004868268967,
0.11195988953113556,
-0.09158127009868622,
-0.2545661926269531,
-0.37396591901779175,
0.15106570720672607,
0.5834395289421082,
-0.7551110982894897,
-0.228545144200325,
-0.44696348905563354,
-0.396306574344635,
0.4016236960887909,
-0.08016441762447357,
0.4956439137458801,
-0.10088004916906357,
-0.3090251088142395,
-0.18116404116153717,
-0.9292194247245789,
-0.2996681332588196,
0.6573536396026611,
0.44470828771591187,
0.0034392205998301506,
0.36589157581329346,
-0.5456215143203735,
0.5884554982185364,
0.08299597352743149,
-0.46843409538269043,
0.541785478591919,
-0.42994359135627747,
-0.04328129068017006,
0.2581617534160614,
0.8057409524917603,
0.19493234157562256,
0.028787799179553986,
-0.2796400487422943,
-0.1936882734298706,
0.23492595553398132,
-0.0010107439011335373,
-0.6711918115615845,
0.061989616602659225,
-0.01579255983233452,
-0.18762071430683136,
-0.21139882504940033,
-0.048462383449077606,
-0.7172884345054626,
-0.24672403931617737,
-0.012788885273039341,
0.3067786991596222,
-0.26954081654548645,
-0.5663490891456604,
-0.19932067394256592,
-0.06941476464271545,
-0.09874384850263596,
0.17854644358158112,
-0.24627366662025452,
0.3625997304916382,
0.5347710847854614,
1.0478994846343994,
0.04214898496866226,
-0.30929645895957947,
-0.41686493158340454,
-0.029862524941563606,
-0.7259842157363892,
1.0249522924423218,
-0.32273295521736145,
0.06529540568590164,
0.08902540057897568,
-0.028920626267790794,
0.06478703022003174,
-0.7693397402763367,
0.7409628629684448,
-0.5088620185852051,
-0.28753793239593506,
-0.322573721408844,
-0.09864678233861923,
-0.18398664891719818,
0.4454074203968048,
-0.7066324949264526,
1.2394715547561646,
0.35693344473838806,
-0.41868799924850464,
0.5500714778900146,
-0.2950683534145355,
-0.5491707921028137,
-0.1673716902732849,
0.06196855381131172,
-0.49058797955513,
-0.15033714473247528,
0.4408649504184723,
0.09263920783996582,
-0.3561060130596161,
0.4067920446395874,
-0.20437748730182648,
-0.2368067502975464,
0.22080007195472717,
-0.4234063923358917,
0.6486423015594482,
0.4094937741756439,
-0.25367793440818787,
-0.26991772651672363,
-0.9183074831962585,
0.00012632732978090644,
-0.21101833879947662,
0.07944747060537338,
-0.21129712462425232,
-0.21746589243412018,
0.18371708691120148,
0.6725692749023438,
-0.2578206956386566,
-0.7068951725959778,
-0.11267835646867752,
-0.6816349625587463,
0.3147414028644562,
0.5435373783111572,
-0.05827874690294266,
0.08130486309528351,
-0.4630216062068939,
0.3606812059879303,
0.3457486033439636,
-0.0946134477853775,
-0.0657970979809761,
-0.10533197969198227,
-0.4502921402454376,
-0.2563058137893677,
0.848070502281189,
0.5032845139503479,
-0.7285922765731812,
-0.07739652693271637,
-0.3867203891277313,
-0.4686373472213745,
-0.6875054240226746,
0.24803726375102997,
0.367557555437088,
0.27169954776763916,
0.2889624834060669,
-0.04277680814266205,
-0.7710518836975098,
-0.8663149476051331,
-0.6358927488327026,
0.24072030186653137,
-0.010915333405137062,
-0.05248227342963219,
0.330249160528183,
0.022297391667962074,
0.9796730875968933,
-0.11182016879320145,
-0.7106424570083618,
-0.3583148717880249,
0.39355796575546265,
0.2643720507621765,
0.12446042895317078,
0.5062167644500732,
-1.1837546825408936,
-0.7692317366600037,
0.005118940025568008,
-0.5333706736564636,
-0.26988041400909424,
0.004733450710773468,
0.041955914348363876,
0.3073568046092987,
0.39273375272750854,
-0.5370901823043823,
0.6764662861824036,
0.5043137669563293,
-0.13480395078659058,
0.48485711216926575,
0.30740612745285034,
0.4878787100315094,
-1.0570473670959473,
-0.04300515353679657,
-0.03487253934144974,
-0.4432666003704071,
-0.5645840167999268,
-0.07883508503437042,
-0.07302679866552353,
-0.1978805810213089,
-0.7140990495681763,
0.7571481466293335,
-0.33242449164390564,
-0.19482195377349854,
-0.2792668044567108,
0.04292447119951248,
-0.11589282751083374,
0.38955965638160706,
-0.09890695661306381,
1.0368292331695557,
0.2449088841676712,
-0.5801146030426025,
0.25594937801361084,
0.25227540731430054,
-0.45950350165367126,
0.18673694133758545,
-0.3523198068141937,
0.11141429096460342,
0.18608257174491882,
0.3015933930873871,
-0.7312789559364319,
-0.2713598310947418,
0.3900279104709625,
-0.7827380895614624,
-0.2640407681465149,
-0.0466156005859375,
-0.7954948544502258,
-0.09220197051763535,
-0.27129268646240234,
0.30792734026908875,
0.20138312876224518,
-0.38582131266593933,
0.5140865445137024,
0.30097776651382446,
-0.10912758857011795,
-0.6953328847885132,
-0.6615942716598511,
0.24495001137256622,
0.17464220523834229,
-0.605729341506958,
0.16846515238285065,
0.14007805287837982,
-0.4211982190608978,
0.141556516289711,
-0.4806602895259857,
-0.4064522087574005,
-0.3531615734100342,
0.2477983981370926,
-0.11898204684257507,
-0.4330671727657318,
0.0651678815484047,
0.17614857852458954,
-0.048403557389974594,
-0.09090209752321243,
0.0037871403619647026,
0.5239275693893433,
0.023152831941843033,
-0.14667300879955292,
-0.20744311809539795,
0.45499828457832336,
0.5675488710403442,
-0.06346959620714188,
0.9219996929168701,
0.5482980012893677,
-0.5575085878372192,
-0.2154179811477661,
-0.5176470279693604,
-0.08309017866849899,
-0.3897652328014374,
0.3530395030975342,
-0.2146468609571457,
-0.2657228410243988,
0.3872109651565552,
-0.515339195728302,
-0.15715771913528442,
0.5747039914131165,
0.4534454345703125,
0.5427904725074768,
1.2471147775650024,
0.4377780854701996,
-0.2942027151584625,
-0.12912334501743317,
-0.26398295164108276,
0.47213760018348694,
-0.2763170599937439,
0.06530524045228958,
-0.4664926826953888,
-0.09790736436843872,
-0.1893293708562851,
-0.4107854664325714,
0.28711363673210144,
-0.05892491340637207,
-0.11857727915048599,
0.11066293716430664,
-0.06774185597896576,
0.5007871389389038,
0.25024285912513733,
0.07939299196004868,
0.3524661660194397,
0.12895195186138153,
-0.09261056035757065,
-0.09245901554822922,
-0.7180087566375732,
-0.3114117681980133,
1.0630347728729248,
0.0565691776573658,
0.2624535858631134,
0.1540755182504654,
0.17475318908691406,
0.6783899068832397,
0.3718308210372925,
-0.39418432116508484,
0.3470275402069092,
-0.32873407006263733,
-0.6556052565574646,
-0.1786382794380188,
-0.48497703671455383,
-0.3559176027774811,
-0.08933334052562714,
-0.15099108219146729,
-0.26332440972328186,
0.31285831332206726,
0.10304328799247742,
-0.3438253104686737,
0.4003560245037079,
-0.35799312591552734,
0.6609124541282654,
-0.006629603914916515,
-0.5120038986206055,
-0.09483993798494339,
-0.42198941111564636,
0.3963826894760132,
-0.1427367776632309,
0.6351595520973206,
-0.2221408188343048,
0.1829737275838852,
0.5543913841247559,
-0.7372936606407166,
0.5702022910118103,
0.03573230654001236,
0.36539608240127563,
0.13673312962055206,
0.008095246739685535,
0.5244799852371216,
0.04290704056620598,
-0.24710087478160858,
0.5740500688552856,
-0.3305857479572296,
-0.3863443434238434,
-0.3467126190662384,
0.736973762512207,
-0.9021754264831543,
-0.28941094875335693,
-0.8137326240539551,
-0.5333566069602966,
-0.32527074217796326,
0.34271594882011414,
0.5304260849952698,
0.6457110047340393,
-0.13961724936962128,
0.17559807002544403,
0.4782819151878357,
0.04877348616719246,
0.050938624888658524,
0.5615502595901489,
-0.2941014766693115,
-0.3382420241832733,
1.1149142980575562,
0.38600850105285645,
-0.001639563008211553,
0.22281454503536224,
-0.0175721924751997,
-0.28581351041793823,
-0.3758930265903473,
-0.8033844232559204,
0.04952307417988777,
-0.509793221950531,
-0.6551465392112732,
-0.6900590658187866,
-0.4924015998840332,
-0.8214407563209534,
0.01956111565232277,
-0.4698006808757782,
-0.19112218916416168,
0.04520034417510033,
-0.05439123138785362,
0.632584810256958,
0.4962378740310669,
-0.42646440863609314,
0.4304576516151428,
-0.6211771368980408,
0.7413856387138367,
-0.0037447409704327583,
0.30371901392936707,
-0.12596875429153442,
-0.38741451501846313,
-0.2931032180786133,
0.5388949513435364,
-0.3255857527256012,
-0.8219935297966003,
0.7790652513504028,
0.48066258430480957,
0.22003905475139618,
0.488900363445282,
0.3612821400165558,
0.6898272037506104,
-0.4571700096130371,
0.48448431491851807,
-0.1544143259525299,
-0.8585020303726196,
0.4213882386684418,
-0.4374118149280548,
0.1391139179468155,
0.5521325469017029,
0.7226582169532776,
-0.6899023652076721,
-0.4235057532787323,
-0.4159072935581207,
-1.009577751159668,
1.0024577379226685,
0.2295936942100525,
-0.09909146279096603,
0.054842814803123474,
0.02694220468401909,
0.39045634865760803,
0.22967885434627533,
-0.8027442693710327,
-0.24190858006477356,
-0.3330742418766022,
-0.34374552965164185,
0.09361566603183746,
-0.2372930943965912,
-0.014965948648750782,
-0.13008442521095276,
0.9513018131256104,
0.12877632677555084,
0.23862428963184357,
0.1806079000234604,
-0.38751792907714844,
-0.3039824962615967,
0.05423976853489876,
0.7020533084869385,
0.916272759437561,
-0.0673428624868393,
-0.07810638844966888,
0.20556855201721191,
-0.5973906517028809,
0.10049460828304291,
-0.07933458685874939,
-0.2130446583032608,
0.3345356285572052,
0.17725436389446259,
0.7006657719612122,
0.20874269306659698,
-0.7451806664466858,
0.5485575795173645,
0.12701095640659332,
-0.43261075019836426,
-0.7407152056694031,
-0.25331270694732666,
-0.20523592829704285,
-0.06398351490497589,
0.7057247161865234,
0.4507712125778198,
0.22373810410499573,
-0.6997369527816772,
0.25838908553123474,
-0.09493106603622437,
-0.30116984248161316,
-0.24961546063423157,
0.3525453507900238,
-0.13626882433891296,
-0.3881842792034149,
0.5983414649963379,
-0.2817378044128418,
-0.7868149876594543,
0.6169323325157166,
0.6465287804603577,
0.37493038177490234,
-0.3544257581233978,
0.4783591032028198,
0.41751766204833984,
0.35356405377388,
-0.5480239391326904,
0.028008289635181427,
0.2663933336734772,
-0.6766961812973022,
-0.5550029277801514,
-0.5960073471069336,
-0.1559818536043167,
0.48962610960006714,
-0.3069446086883545,
0.5097702145576477,
-0.3218096196651459,
0.18884649872779846,
-0.04110651835799217,
0.07477569580078125,
-0.3493073880672455,
0.35185688734054565,
-0.19389797747135162,
1.0538735389709473,
-1.186498999595642,
0.7344894409179688,
0.49054551124572754,
-0.2851288914680481,
-0.8626160621643066,
0.14468583464622498,
0.2616356313228607,
-0.6657307744026184,
0.844166100025177,
0.15075787901878357,
-0.1415407657623291,
-0.042341139167547226,
-0.38133469223976135,
-0.8137219548225403,
0.5278914570808411,
0.3818502426147461,
-0.3067916929721832,
0.13640297949314117,
0.6465905904769897,
0.24049772322177887,
-0.20785187184810638,
0.26026663184165955,
0.18456827104091644,
0.625347912311554,
0.11555124819278717,
-0.7251408696174622,
-0.17162422835826874,
-0.3823896050453186,
-0.3619692325592041,
0.41059252619743347,
-0.7629712224006653,
1.1082221269607544,
0.34687474370002747,
-0.23179422318935394,
0.0053949179127812386,
0.5949569344520569,
0.12386442720890045,
0.7744200229644775,
0.47792500257492065,
0.6281835436820984,
0.1625032126903534,
-0.12888048589229584,
0.736637532711029,
-0.22204618155956268,
0.008371470496058464,
0.6409247517585754,
-0.412361741065979,
0.7448140382766724,
0.11256091296672821,
-0.03987784683704376,
0.4451369345188141,
0.5723015666007996,
0.06480319797992706,
0.6471757292747498,
0.016299111768603325,
-0.11531690508127213,
-0.31317809224128723,
-0.19261275231838226,
-0.49768996238708496,
0.6004905104637146,
0.3689429461956024,
-0.15208590030670166,
-0.6044862270355225,
0.40356767177581787,
0.1889519840478897,
0.4303613007068634,
-0.6060878038406372,
0.5252242088317871,
-0.09280713647603989,
-0.32714930176734924,
0.4880926311016083,
0.18261492252349854,
0.5494470596313477,
-0.7476094961166382,
-0.3722871243953705,
-0.36274030804634094,
0.36894139647483826,
-0.1618749350309372,
-0.1348409205675125,
0.5988782048225403,
0.13888314366340637,
-0.39126214385032654,
-0.18703722953796387,
0.8969569206237793,
-0.4416968524456024,
-0.9057455062866211,
0.04428599774837494,
0.40258127450942993,
0.26663678884506226,
-0.3955215513706207,
-0.33087077736854553,
0.34246933460235596,
-0.11767710000276566,
0.14196757972240448,
0.5905085206031799,
0.5597985982894897,
-0.3416130542755127,
0.5828621983528137,
0.7011505961418152,
0.4199050962924957,
-0.040026646107435226,
-0.46323642134666443,
0.7870959639549255,
-0.3750652074813843,
-0.6880853176116943,
-0.5939914584159851,
-0.08353208005428314,
-0.2674104869365692,
-0.3915424048900604,
1.0280519723892212,
0.8478364944458008,
0.8730462193489075,
-0.032714132219552994,
0.764578104019165,
-0.0022819049190729856,
1.2716342210769653,
-0.40864112973213196,
1.1022439002990723,
-0.647396445274353,
-0.0019066289532929659,
-0.20638583600521088,
-0.6023977398872375,
-0.15792050957679749,
0.5410842895507812,
-0.3003977835178375,
-0.011325918138027191,
0.46469447016716003,
1.0317238569259644,
-0.35180553793907166,
0.13705086708068848,
0.3548567295074463,
0.4222688674926758,
-0.31736576557159424,
0.223221555352211,
0.5424405932426453,
-0.7592385411262512,
0.8011669516563416,
-0.29365405440330505,
-0.04397164657711983,
-0.482848584651947,
-0.7688330411911011,
-0.5813682079315186,
-0.6418275237083435,
-0.2822115123271942,
-0.29377883672714233,
0.45952433347702026,
0.8449046015739441,
0.8549104928970337,
-0.9446966648101807,
-0.24281005561351776,
-0.012562381103634834,
0.3561168313026428,
-0.5548503994941711,
-0.2606567144393921,
0.3588339388370514,
0.17718182504177094,
-0.5759643912315369,
0.3482440114021301,
0.06087753176689148,
-0.46799686551094055,
0.040510620921850204,
0.04137042909860611,
-0.6121915578842163,
0.19381844997406006,
0.45389464497566223,
0.584093451499939,
-0.4466264843940735,
-0.0610695481300354,
0.22438229620456696,
0.08566993474960327,
0.1789669692516327,
0.7611669898033142,
-1.0118587017059326,
-0.0006935768760740757,
0.0714721828699112,
0.3856578767299652,
0.17270654439926147,
-0.18261195719242096,
0.5133342742919922,
-0.9440202116966248,
0.3297300636768341,
0.27224674820899963,
-0.2030179798603058,
0.33624401688575745,
-0.4695923924446106,
0.3871173560619354,
0.3220411241054535,
-0.40020424127578735,
-1.3637624979019165,
0.025760073214769363,
-0.523701548576355,
-0.13192668557167053,
1.1308331489562988,
-0.024857331067323685,
-0.5308237671852112,
-0.5896342396736145,
-0.17489922046661377,
0.35200822353363037,
-0.5097440481185913,
0.7688209414482117,
0.8015578389167786,
0.15999338030815125,
-0.19885462522506714,
-0.6328462362289429,
0.668825626373291,
0.056185849010944366,
-0.4824266731739044,
0.02969975955784321,
0.19584377110004425,
0.2324172556400299,
0.22290778160095215,
0.652103841304779,
-0.10993073880672455,
0.5031441450119019,
0.24489213526248932,
-0.06937994807958603,
-0.44781118631362915,
-0.47229626774787903,
0.1706128716468811,
0.2335302233695984,
-0.24457035958766937,
0.036654096096754074
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14009v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14009v1
|
A New Massive Multilingual Dataset for High-Performance Language Technologies
| 2024-03-20T22:14:39 | 2024-03-20T22:14:39 |
Ona de Gibert, Graeme Nail, Nikolay Arefyev, Marta Bañón, Jelmer van der Linde, Shaoxiong Ji, Jaume Zaragoza-Bernabeu, Mikko Aulamo, Gema Ramírez-Sánchez, Andrey Kutuzov, Sampo Pyysalo, Stephan Oepen, Jörg Tiedemann
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present the HPLT (High Performance Language Technologies) language
resources, a new massive multilingual dataset including both monolingual and
bilingual corpora extracted from CommonCrawl and previously unused web crawls
from the Internet Archive. We describe our methods for data acquisition,
management and processing of large corpora, which rely on open-source software
tools and high-performance computing. Our monolingual collection focuses on
low- to medium-resourced languages and covers 75 languages and a total of ~5.6
trillion word tokens de-duplicated on the document level. Our English-centric
parallel corpus is derived from its monolingual counterpart and covers 18
language pairs and more than 96 million aligned sentence pairs with roughly 1.4
billion English tokens. The HPLT language resources are one of the largest open
text corpora ever released, providing a great resource for language modeling
and machine translation training. We publicly release the corpora, the
software, and the tools used in this work.
|
[
-0.5237410068511963,
-0.7897785305976868,
0.021713126450777054,
0.29502320289611816,
-0.021600842475891113,
0.35159409046173096,
-0.6178221106529236,
-0.26195448637008667,
0.16571377217769623,
0.6576657295227051,
-0.20601020753383636,
-0.27462896704673767,
-0.3524779677391052,
0.22248244285583496,
-0.30301836133003235,
1.0571608543395996,
0.11299299448728561,
-0.11996153742074966,
0.008622080087661743,
-0.5120365023612976,
-0.17343805730342865,
-0.817822277545929,
-0.4772454798221588,
0.10224425047636032,
0.9403262734413147,
0.5903231501579285,
0.8890647292137146,
0.8488501906394958,
0.6636684536933899,
0.271955668926239,
0.04853610694408417,
0.10110548883676529,
-0.5841941237449646,
0.06217201426625252,
-0.388786256313324,
0.11775133013725281,
-0.5935662984848022,
-0.17634670436382294,
0.9853109121322632,
0.7324481010437012,
-0.07626952230930328,
0.3951258361339569,
0.16418564319610596,
0.5731918215751648,
-0.7913810014724731,
0.1638815551996231,
-0.3617243468761444,
0.1053580790758133,
-0.9582914113998413,
-0.1788187325000763,
-0.5366885662078857,
-0.21410927176475525,
-0.1533181071281433,
-0.7792149782180786,
-0.045786596834659576,
0.07037726044654846,
0.3465421795845032,
-0.07343733310699463,
-0.6191710233688354,
-0.12126992642879486,
-0.661914050579071,
1.0170905590057373,
-0.21323607861995697,
0.894021213054657,
0.2937230169773102,
0.40086808800697327,
0.23434311151504517,
-0.7817497849464417,
-0.5341435670852661,
0.17581374943256378,
-0.06154458597302437,
-0.10719817131757736,
0.16506870090961456,
-0.22426283359527588,
0.2330150455236435,
0.47920477390289307,
-0.9902525544166565,
0.2267998456954956,
-0.5349154472351074,
-0.40694907307624817,
0.4338911175727844,
0.06711221486330032,
0.08120802044868469,
-0.02099505625665188,
-0.2728913724422455,
-0.3349536955356598,
-0.6841112971305847,
-0.2157416194677353,
0.29565152525901794,
0.6425468921661377,
-0.12730269134044647,
0.4728969931602478,
-0.003582173027098179,
0.49697771668434143,
-0.5904269218444824,
-0.32614582777023315,
0.5897009968757629,
-0.48335006833076477,
-0.29353466629981995,
0.15731686353683472,
0.8598734736442566,
-0.2001267373561859,
0.23266375064849854,
-0.06266738474369049,
0.016768742352724075,
-0.3595191538333893,
-0.15936075150966644,
-0.8069767951965332,
0.18926140666007996,
0.15866468846797943,
-0.5608495473861694,
-0.15664030611515045,
-0.016424739733338356,
-1.235131859779358,
-0.45876818895339966,
-0.3062606155872345,
0.06848297268152237,
-0.4403674006462097,
-0.6456636786460876,
0.04380697011947632,
-0.17304104566574097,
0.03942959010601044,
-0.1559179425239563,
-0.7513810992240906,
0.3165736198425293,
0.6127616763114929,
0.5450153350830078,
-0.3297223448753357,
-0.8406939506530762,
-0.8724698424339294,
0.15670011937618256,
-0.015231424011290073,
0.39745423197746277,
-0.5806134343147278,
-0.319339781999588,
0.3131415843963623,
0.3712564706802368,
0.008133343420922756,
-0.5281131267547607,
0.7819095849990845,
-0.6611840724945068,
0.2800646722316742,
-0.3131982684135437,
-0.24476665258407593,
-0.04113416746258736,
0.2274261862039566,
-1.0411220788955688,
1.1368763446807861,
0.05321735143661499,
-0.8689236044883728,
0.05544210225343704,
-0.7900981307029724,
-0.6340582370758057,
0.5691068768501282,
-0.10013072192668915,
0.12540920078754425,
-0.12497914582490921,
0.0013009428512305021,
0.06665556132793427,
-0.605383038520813,
0.10280035436153412,
-0.12725695967674255,
-0.3058047294616699,
-0.11712159216403961,
-0.5500209927558899,
1.0461925268173218,
0.6530911326408386,
-0.19614329934120178,
-0.07882071286439896,
-0.9757367968559265,
0.019592683762311935,
0.034545812755823135,
-0.6931617259979248,
-0.1960127353668213,
-0.035315513610839844,
0.756424069404602,
0.4085855185985565,
0.8193812966346741,
-0.7190904021263123,
0.018454404547810555,
0.14080318808555603,
0.18715748190879822,
0.6723433136940002,
-0.5096573829650879,
0.1637526899576187,
-0.004834113176912069,
0.6166288256645203,
0.05027773603796959,
0.21148906648159027,
-0.4079853892326355,
-0.27208641171455383,
-0.48828381299972534,
-0.31521928310394287,
0.3098722994327545,
0.7073615193367004,
-0.5750481486320496,
0.26093390583992004,
-0.37609076499938965,
-0.2912702262401581,
-0.7148489952087402,
0.17969143390655518,
0.37993472814559937,
0.5478775501251221,
0.32705268263816833,
0.013295331969857216,
-0.7038544416427612,
-0.922454833984375,
-0.07604239881038666,
0.030569830909371376,
0.23221322894096375,
0.12019389867782593,
0.12223562598228455,
-0.19255591928958893,
0.525283932685852,
-0.16539664566516876,
-0.02782811038196087,
-0.04751181975007057,
0.41206738352775574,
0.16187924146652222,
0.3480679988861084,
0.26818937063217163,
-1.0027583837509155,
-0.616560161113739,
0.5812777280807495,
-0.8872990012168884,
0.052281901240348816,
0.3412248492240906,
-0.15017254650592804,
0.38869377970695496,
0.45984673500061035,
-0.28355124592781067,
-0.18541878461837769,
0.8447203040122986,
-0.29882383346557617,
0.730792224407196,
-0.3392728567123413,
0.348647803068161,
-1.0555541515350342,
0.5571127533912659,
-0.33180877566337585,
-0.2951643168926239,
-0.3871811330318451,
0.2999485433101654,
0.16639891266822815,
-0.33508750796318054,
-0.8258907198905945,
0.6571845412254333,
-0.3731965720653534,
-0.22547923028469086,
-0.1361803561449051,
0.1696598082780838,
-0.09448641538619995,
0.27770182490348816,
-0.2046961635351181,
1.2003910541534424,
0.6549391150474548,
-0.34342047572135925,
0.645921528339386,
0.1977531909942627,
-0.2677714228630066,
0.4393688440322876,
-0.25730326771736145,
0.2408231794834137,
-0.07473798841238022,
-0.19007128477096558,
-0.37576189637184143,
-0.3389507234096527,
-0.3789404034614563,
-0.058420389890670776,
-0.016455046832561493,
0.048584189265966415,
-0.7985774874687195,
-0.5336042046546936,
-0.17555813491344452,
0.5503582954406738,
0.4767187237739563,
-0.5799286365509033,
0.1937892735004425,
0.7968533635139465,
-0.5176246166229248,
-0.9064036011695862,
-0.7535492181777954,
0.207394078373909,
0.01630537211894989,
-0.5344758629798889,
0.1852714866399765,
-0.38230472803115845,
-0.14656639099121094,
0.11984537541866302,
0.6408815979957581,
-0.5614868998527527,
-0.14660264551639557,
0.016105331480503082,
0.1742132306098938,
-0.46106234192848206,
0.3878680169582367,
-0.3561858832836151,
0.17641276121139526,
-0.28337109088897705,
-0.39742642641067505,
0.8183783888816833,
-0.26043522357940674,
-0.27079877257347107,
0.057636745274066925,
0.584746778011322,
0.9228857159614563,
-0.5871457457542419,
0.7105098366737366,
0.9121994972229004,
-0.33817702531814575,
0.14168694615364075,
-0.4711146056652069,
0.34133729338645935,
-0.4365234076976776,
0.5942426919937134,
-0.3552309274673462,
-1.2056429386138916,
0.45724278688430786,
0.18094204366207123,
0.18634158372879028,
0.41915377974510193,
0.7819958329200745,
0.26188623905181885,
0.9378981590270996,
0.7411127090454102,
-0.5391316413879395,
0.2972579300403595,
0.24268889427185059,
0.032056305557489395,
-0.4258866608142853,
0.0003165407688356936,
-0.5641165971755981,
-0.13128753006458282,
-1.017135500907898,
-0.39866194128990173,
0.28206339478492737,
-0.13761067390441895,
-0.4062586724758148,
0.4572370648384094,
-0.3779434561729431,
0.6491348147392273,
0.7004789710044861,
-0.3220217823982239,
0.4870370924472809,
0.2377394586801529,
-0.2954881191253662,
-0.05928772687911987,
-0.40158453583717346,
-0.3391563296318054,
1.1259517669677734,
0.24995462596416473,
0.265227735042572,
0.1256868541240692,
0.30540427565574646,
0.14934009313583374,
-0.0692065954208374,
-0.5274472832679749,
0.4381372332572937,
-0.6121542453765869,
-0.9047799110412598,
-0.45600494742393494,
-0.6616041660308838,
-0.9946020841598511,
0.10402091592550278,
-0.028211625292897224,
-0.34640198945999146,
-0.06078220158815384,
-0.06216898560523987,
-0.04392112419009209,
0.378769189119339,
-0.4890761971473694,
1.0563724040985107,
-0.3036225736141205,
-0.6951156854629517,
-0.5570979118347168,
-0.35220766067504883,
0.11352439969778061,
-0.49035388231277466,
0.5978633761405945,
0.03598792478442192,
0.10246207565069199,
0.6640697717666626,
-0.23341993987560272,
0.14478404819965363,
-0.18033409118652344,
0.05429855361580849,
0.14177992939949036,
-0.00381484255194664,
0.4475698173046112,
-0.32440418004989624,
-0.6360647082328796,
0.10757675021886826,
-0.09275464713573456,
-0.6222589612007141,
-0.09010422229766846,
0.7889557480812073,
-0.6235191226005554,
0.02846802957355976,
-0.2697228789329529,
-0.8189590573310852,
-0.07190755754709244,
0.6926760077476501,
0.15154986083507538,
0.5905566811561584,
-0.5343714356422424,
0.4840860962867737,
0.3484259843826294,
-0.5140054821968079,
0.5414707660675049,
0.5070614218711853,
-0.31768569350242615,
-0.4872586131095886,
1.234677791595459,
0.16349388659000397,
-0.04647601768374443,
0.33070263266563416,
0.176469624042511,
-0.1849781721830368,
-0.4110446870326996,
-0.3122095763683319,
0.18980161845684052,
-0.42812037467956543,
0.09929157793521881,
-0.4449135661125183,
-0.10725320130586624,
-0.6212772130966187,
0.10429297387599945,
-0.4574476480484009,
-0.4070111811161041,
0.30326226353645325,
0.14887207746505737,
0.2662140130996704,
0.7940365672111511,
-0.15515433251857758,
0.10734648257493973,
-1.077599287033081,
0.1378454715013504,
0.212956964969635,
0.41255319118499756,
-0.4027961790561676,
-0.2517968416213989,
-0.6874536871910095,
0.014235901646316051,
-0.17684975266456604,
-0.4132414758205414,
0.5405044555664062,
0.21121737360954285,
0.4675467014312744,
0.04373815655708313,
-0.2964709401130676,
0.4828452169895172,
-0.6279183030128479,
0.7425163984298706,
0.06752921640872955,
-0.6125792860984802,
0.12383996695280075,
-0.6889494061470032,
0.5068253874778748,
0.7036594152450562,
0.6167862415313721,
-0.8873072266578674,
-0.059434253722429276,
-0.3434908092021942,
-0.5942438244819641,
0.7104048728942871,
-0.05567500367760658,
-0.10243159532546997,
-0.13212941586971283,
-0.1757975071668625,
0.1254500150680542,
0.4866338074207306,
-0.43311890959739685,
-0.19611653685569763,
0.06389288604259491,
-0.23999835550785065,
-0.23057083785533905,
-0.15403355658054352,
-0.008275025524199009,
-0.17539945244789124,
0.7279446721076965,
-0.3060607612133026,
-0.137516587972641,
-0.22309695184230804,
-0.2851084768772125,
-0.19914108514785767,
0.44037461280822754,
0.28191763162612915,
0.7927842140197754,
-0.3097142279148102,
0.23672540485858917,
0.056648802012205124,
-0.747209370136261,
-0.060143232345581055,
0.4138782024383545,
0.1501060426235199,
-0.10236108303070068,
0.10443253070116043,
0.4632871448993683,
0.08879413455724716,
-1.0249724388122559,
0.4799274206161499,
0.11387885361909866,
-0.07588761299848557,
-0.3268386423587799,
-0.6363471746444702,
0.1709422916173935,
0.010179354809224606,
0.27780988812446594,
-0.21296203136444092,
0.17762701213359833,
-0.6559767723083496,
0.5120101571083069,
0.14856866002082825,
-0.12317030876874924,
-0.3562766909599304,
0.41750824451446533,
0.23334167897701263,
-0.2060225009918213,
0.8267800211906433,
-0.3470301926136017,
-0.4727483093738556,
0.2652318477630615,
0.4585043489933014,
0.6020867228507996,
-0.2111624926328659,
0.23339585959911346,
0.5418506860733032,
0.07557650655508041,
-0.008601264096796513,
0.41839125752449036,
0.1726159304380417,
-0.555885374546051,
-0.8014718890190125,
-0.893275797367096,
-0.4127233624458313,
0.3405652940273285,
-0.4816693961620331,
0.48974165320396423,
-0.24227337539196014,
0.16170652210712433,
0.07365723699331284,
0.01401219516992569,
-0.7431818246841431,
-0.018348099663853645,
0.3769606053829193,
0.9550333023071289,
-0.6274641752243042,
1.3061764240264893,
0.7195028066635132,
-0.40108704566955566,
-0.4805195927619934,
-0.39211320877075195,
0.1494777351617813,
-0.6854327321052551,
0.8122732043266296,
-0.10041522234678268,
-0.10069657117128372,
-0.0774349570274353,
-0.1709498167037964,
-0.824007511138916,
0.6934552192687988,
0.6827608942985535,
-0.6256640553474426,
-0.23020391166210175,
0.6761633157730103,
0.3870868384838104,
-0.03577727824449539,
0.2629350423812866,
0.6107291579246521,
0.7070364952087402,
-0.2662367820739746,
-1.2440038919448853,
-0.28754544258117676,
-0.38344040513038635,
-0.4354811906814575,
0.36023464798927307,
-0.705653727054596,
1.2761173248291016,
0.4777602553367615,
-0.08315374702215195,
-0.2569396495819092,
0.2561386525630951,
0.20724469423294067,
-0.1254216581583023,
0.44936439394950867,
0.5993666052818298,
0.9897257089614868,
0.1791832596063614,
0.9916205406188965,
-0.6093599200248718,
0.3637561500072479,
1.1856833696365356,
-0.4228851795196533,
1.098071813583374,
0.326565146446228,
-0.09304308146238327,
0.2617977559566498,
0.18514001369476318,
0.26710009574890137,
0.1825568675994873,
-0.10366857051849365,
-0.4901285469532013,
-0.10505331307649612,
-0.5632384419441223,
-0.27243971824645996,
0.49406155943870544,
0.16406826674938202,
-0.16846852004528046,
-0.35772904753685,
0.28391915559768677,
0.032093387097120285,
0.09826815128326416,
-0.012721673585474491,
0.46422553062438965,
-0.24771225452423096,
-0.6143214106559753,
0.6647995114326477,
-0.23010078072547913,
0.7933433055877686,
-0.40767180919647217,
0.14040489494800568,
-0.07524257898330688,
0.35737234354019165,
-0.05291242152452469,
-0.92082679271698,
0.307616263628006,
0.08802511543035507,
-0.18907375633716583,
-0.5459803938865662,
0.5029390454292297,
-0.6605867147445679,
-0.5645483732223511,
0.6207038164138794,
0.6462500691413879,
0.35275909304618835,
-0.04875107854604721,
-0.6141869425773621,
0.3081720769405365,
-0.32185620069503784,
-0.16727539896965027,
0.4446622431278229,
0.6325647234916687,
0.03230362758040428,
0.22053192555904388,
0.563742458820343,
0.41855543851852417,
0.3070460855960846,
0.20007716119289398,
0.7149437069892883,
-0.6841794848442078,
-0.3347921669483185,
-0.4360719919204712,
0.4521803557872772,
-0.23995402455329895,
-0.44673141837120056,
0.7081083655357361,
1.0999304056167603,
0.9895543456077576,
0.11980988085269928,
0.959972083568573,
-0.13954873383045197,
0.8287329077720642,
-0.08237886428833008,
0.6027353405952454,
-0.6995517611503601,
-0.34148451685905457,
0.04297151416540146,
-0.8029409646987915,
-0.10430703312158585,
0.007104567717760801,
0.15427854657173157,
-0.4158189296722412,
0.8648368120193481,
0.810113251209259,
-0.2907300889492035,
0.1535896360874176,
0.46654272079467773,
0.28264889121055603,
0.23351119458675385,
0.5437101721763611,
0.45873647928237915,
-0.38158902525901794,
0.7656707763671875,
-0.30785730481147766,
-0.2804270386695862,
-0.08858034014701843,
-0.806784451007843,
-0.3557944595813751,
-0.7404882907867432,
0.0588560625910759,
-0.10674821585416794,
0.09053416550159454,
0.9935733675956726,
0.8039186000823975,
-0.9678638577461243,
-0.7580558657646179,
-0.059571024030447006,
-0.16999360918998718,
-0.009362459182739258,
-0.22102566063404083,
0.16210991144180298,
-0.7635604739189148,
-0.7999626994132996,
0.7542632222175598,
0.2712000906467438,
-0.3693249821662903,
-0.3680218458175659,
-0.2626016139984131,
-0.5009135007858276,
-0.33608290553092957,
0.8566578030586243,
0.4362925589084625,
-0.16213372349739075,
-0.09481711685657501,
0.2379797101020813,
-0.35104432702064514,
0.22213594615459442,
0.8324955105781555,
-0.5994452834129333,
0.5855771899223328,
0.8014215230941772,
0.6797509789466858,
0.4256659746170044,
-0.38541361689567566,
0.5641055703163147,
-0.8940049409866333,
0.6621084809303284,
0.20817188918590546,
0.399570107460022,
0.33619946241378784,
-0.18161003291606903,
0.36436089873313904,
0.21617594361305237,
-0.7945026755332947,
-0.8063646554946899,
0.04457820579409599,
-0.743205189704895,
-0.25038427114486694,
0.9583234786987305,
-0.03804384171962738,
-0.26532384753227234,
-0.1196722611784935,
-0.08863002061843872,
0.3980883061885834,
-0.27900075912475586,
0.11491747200489044,
0.8025926947593689,
0.31439948081970215,
-0.18650737404823303,
-0.8895441889762878,
0.5338684916496277,
0.4223172068595886,
-0.8915988802909851,
0.47535431385040283,
0.6266171336174011,
-0.03868216276168823,
0.4814698100090027,
0.604794442653656,
-0.438625305891037,
0.33381080627441406,
-0.08244922757148743,
0.37083831429481506,
-0.08386993408203125,
-0.5248825550079346,
-0.387719064950943,
0.5411698222160339,
0.06462781131267548,
0.028040403500199318
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14006v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14006v1
|
On Prompt Sensitivity of ChatGPT in Affective Computing
| 2024-03-20T22:11:01 | 2024-03-20T22:11:01 |
Mostafa M. Amin, Björn W. Schuller
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent studies have demonstrated the emerging capabilities of foundation
models like ChatGPT in several fields, including affective computing. However,
accessing these emerging capabilities is facilitated through prompt
engineering. Despite the existence of some prompting techniques, the field is
still rapidly evolving and many prompting ideas still require investigation. In
this work, we introduce a method to evaluate and investigate the sensitivity of
the performance of foundation models based on different prompts or generation
parameters. We perform our evaluation on ChatGPT within the scope of affective
computing on three major problems, namely sentiment analysis, toxicity
detection, and sarcasm detection. First, we carry out a sensitivity analysis on
pivotal parameters in auto-regressive text generation, specifically the
temperature parameter $T$ and the top-$p$ parameter in Nucleus sampling,
dictating how conservative or creative the model should be during generation.
Furthermore, we explore the efficacy of several prompting ideas, where we
explore how giving different incentives or structures affect the performance.
Our evaluation takes into consideration performance measures on the affective
computing tasks, and the effectiveness of the model to follow the stated
instructions, hence generating easy-to-parse responses to be smoothly used in
downstream applications.
|
[
-0.6135299205780029,
-1.0784964561462402,
0.276887446641922,
0.6308919191360474,
-0.08503855764865875,
-0.4916055202484131,
-0.2173764407634735,
-0.060371894389390945,
-0.17317771911621094,
-0.03231237083673477,
-0.9986189007759094,
-0.13661696016788483,
-0.49579617381095886,
0.2927515506744385,
-0.24141685664653778,
1.1824983358383179,
0.11926090717315674,
-0.33497145771980286,
0.037106845527887344,
0.2878998816013336,
-0.7884185314178467,
-0.3562391400337219,
-0.8189553022384644,
0.03883221000432968,
0.39604365825653076,
0.515850841999054,
0.7046170234680176,
-0.1192043200135231,
0.6136758327484131,
0.30724918842315674,
-0.27378958463668823,
-0.45037707686424255,
-0.4569598436355591,
0.5638740658760071,
0.04414208605885506,
-0.4477486312389374,
-0.17521272599697113,
-0.2738906741142273,
0.3804584741592407,
0.10319416224956512,
-0.009728722274303436,
0.1614026427268982,
0.2978445291519165,
0.7777685523033142,
-0.5867658257484436,
0.20826080441474915,
-0.6792248487472534,
0.146231546998024,
0.14394663274288177,
-0.24034751951694489,
-0.7019745111465454,
-0.6072384119033813,
0.13603995740413666,
-0.3414812684059143,
0.387717068195343,
-0.1751742959022522,
0.5401798486709595,
0.4883343577384949,
-0.3026232123374939,
-0.5884027481079102,
-0.25460201501846313,
0.5194218754768372,
-0.663871705532074,
0.06508291512727737,
0.004926406778395176,
0.1850447803735733,
-0.14872261881828308,
-0.5471747517585754,
-0.35077568888664246,
-0.5684238076210022,
0.0779896154999733,
0.16047026216983795,
-0.41237419843673706,
0.05552435293793678,
0.5936604738235474,
0.4147237241268158,
-0.5751947164535522,
-0.04955131933093071,
0.13102732598781586,
-0.22455908358097076,
0.2326916754245758,
0.23829303681850433,
0.39805713295936584,
-0.5419374108314514,
-0.3091985881328583,
-0.2826307415962219,
-0.38779085874557495,
0.3516920804977417,
0.3537091612815857,
0.5584447979927063,
-0.12638995051383972,
0.5888806581497192,
-0.27113044261932373,
0.593899667263031,
0.33669281005859375,
0.4857715368270874,
-0.026594901457428932,
-0.2472623586654663,
-0.16985060274600983,
-0.2947639524936676,
0.9027655720710754,
0.3660144805908203,
0.29289403557777405,
0.23521053791046143,
-0.12319201231002808,
0.27345800399780273,
0.41645383834838867,
-1.1706905364990234,
-0.4557719826698303,
0.23342923820018768,
-0.5651438236236572,
-0.657550573348999,
-0.6303198337554932,
-0.9344491362571716,
-0.5927236080169678,
-0.10201872140169144,
0.459395170211792,
-0.6508102416992188,
-0.3172219395637512,
-0.20770855247974396,
-0.08444809168577194,
0.22213588654994965,
0.2010708451271057,
-0.8375172019004822,
0.048913344740867615,
0.5071934461593628,
0.8884050846099854,
-0.24231472611427307,
-0.034970540553331375,
-0.4422054886817932,
-0.5307012796401978,
0.014294466935098171,
0.8131974935531616,
-0.621711790561676,
-0.7067358493804932,
-0.21226488053798676,
-0.33931803703308105,
-0.3907723128795624,
0.02725592441856861,
0.6860849261283875,
-0.43297404050827026,
0.3190646767616272,
-0.5384618639945984,
-0.4110061824321747,
0.07518301159143448,
0.367562472820282,
-0.705803632736206,
0.9663203954696655,
0.14864689111709595,
-1.203486442565918,
0.22614574432373047,
-0.9472002983093262,
-0.42153000831604004,
-0.018286308273673058,
-0.07245034724473953,
-0.2317657470703125,
0.0978672057390213,
0.17328356206417084,
0.48913946747779846,
-0.2153969705104828,
0.2719964385032654,
-0.16258367896080017,
-0.06035718321800232,
0.666715145111084,
-0.6317089200019836,
0.6758538484573364,
0.3319540321826935,
-0.6981374025344849,
0.12078174948692322,
-0.43840983510017395,
0.1185876652598381,
-0.2461896389722824,
-0.09828575700521469,
0.16787070035934448,
-0.07231716066598892,
-0.05825255811214447,
0.4347681701183319,
0.028979865834116936,
-0.3704798221588135,
0.12539823353290558,
-0.21323123574256897,
0.4042859375476837,
0.8866207599639893,
0.4242630898952484,
0.09646569937467575,
-0.18933960795402527,
0.8764833211898804,
-0.06880278140306473,
0.3075672388076782,
-0.40795332193374634,
-0.6495437026023865,
-0.5939363837242126,
-0.2037612348794937,
0.06169429421424866,
0.5922073125839233,
-0.5345321893692017,
-0.011733507737517357,
0.1940518319606781,
-0.6068230271339417,
-0.14211365580558777,
-0.32512587308883667,
0.4619895815849304,
0.8894442915916443,
0.16067540645599365,
-0.11126057803630829,
-0.011927472427487373,
-0.8004155158996582,
-0.41009485721588135,
-0.43976029753685,
0.14155039191246033,
0.8169175982475281,
0.17766864597797394,
0.15455245971679688,
0.9944613575935364,
-0.5969152450561523,
0.47820451855659485,
0.24664194881916046,
0.479259729385376,
0.3786490261554718,
0.418791800737381,
0.7015090584754944,
-0.8527923226356506,
-0.688159704208374,
-0.2372579425573349,
-0.3669302761554718,
-0.5245101451873779,
0.030314389616250992,
-0.19177918136119843,
0.25627389550209045,
0.19309914112091064,
-0.7937823534011841,
0.48163846135139465,
0.23165948688983917,
-0.5382395386695862,
0.718776524066925,
0.4368292987346649,
0.7597590684890747,
-0.9334893226623535,
0.43189767003059387,
-0.017965057864785194,
0.19401194155216217,
-0.7582947015762329,
-0.069099560379982,
0.03686429560184479,
-0.5999784469604492,
-0.465382844209671,
0.36173009872436523,
-0.2069622278213501,
0.26305222511291504,
-0.38927125930786133,
-0.07551496475934982,
-0.2132916897535324,
0.3783729374408722,
0.04129300266504288,
0.8199078440666199,
0.6583086848258972,
-0.8421488404273987,
0.35716044902801514,
0.28435829281806946,
0.14055907726287842,
0.7876030206680298,
-0.8168138265609741,
0.1534450352191925,
-0.02810087613761425,
0.09788064658641815,
-1.3569927215576172,
-0.21952936053276062,
0.48520490527153015,
-0.7345119118690491,
0.18088383972644806,
-0.028232155367732048,
-0.09658881276845932,
-0.3487926423549652,
-0.24872301518917084,
0.2119276076555252,
0.5987387299537659,
-0.2691289186477661,
0.46139100193977356,
-0.24869868159294128,
-0.678909957408905,
-0.4146241247653961,
-0.4368618428707123,
-0.16929127275943756,
-0.5579200983047485,
-0.9131092429161072,
0.1215319037437439,
-0.46618181467056274,
-0.1312253624200821,
-0.1865072250366211,
0.09951066225767136,
0.08292040973901749,
0.35008057951927185,
0.5223386287689209,
0.0644649863243103,
-0.1641869843006134,
0.12423211336135864,
-0.05718134716153145,
-0.1569870114326477,
0.4499829411506653,
0.20557501912117004,
0.49703702330589294,
-0.28682491183280945,
-0.28486061096191406,
-0.2901681959629059,
0.30853700637817383,
0.3188159167766571,
-0.06299377977848053,
0.48174336552619934,
0.6365064978599548,
-0.23237130045890808,
-0.20265629887580872,
-0.41045817732810974,
-0.4824129343032837,
-0.5159441828727722,
0.02188945934176445,
-0.5706626176834106,
-0.777783215045929,
0.7079967260360718,
-0.11174243688583374,
-0.028475631028413773,
0.5371989607810974,
0.8365402221679688,
0.5111882090568542,
1.0346945524215698,
0.4860583543777466,
-0.15531225502490997,
0.6544294357299805,
0.32998570799827576,
0.13516086339950562,
-0.5202342867851257,
-0.1534513533115387,
-0.9686018228530884,
-0.057903874665498734,
-0.5110577344894409,
-0.0013383645564317703,
0.2558504343032837,
-0.034111205488443375,
-0.31774476170539856,
0.08895526081323624,
-0.7031294107437134,
0.1475389003753662,
0.27735471725463867,
0.17905527353286743,
-0.09540898352861404,
-0.18001776933670044,
-0.026463402435183525,
0.08581636846065521,
-0.5567715764045715,
-0.36253622174263,
0.6108208894729614,
0.2487306147813797,
0.6574727892875671,
0.09634631872177124,
0.2818586230278015,
0.4922764003276825,
0.43950796127319336,
-0.6849716305732727,
0.37378817796707153,
0.17522534728050232,
-0.549741268157959,
-0.22181099653244019,
-0.46499916911125183,
-0.5373488664627075,
-0.07135473191738129,
-0.021891584619879723,
-0.9125527739524841,
0.27880749106407166,
0.40958645939826965,
-0.4805411398410797,
-0.1961842030286789,
-1.0879203081130981,
0.9275696277618408,
0.07304954528808594,
-0.48883503675460815,
-0.010931145399808884,
-0.7696495652198792,
0.26092010736465454,
-0.08053552359342575,
0.011611300520598888,
-0.17753174901008606,
0.13346852362155914,
0.43553295731544495,
-0.25637882947921753,
1.0358117818832397,
-0.4278712868690491,
-0.041370369493961334,
0.49049681425094604,
0.48913249373435974,
0.632361888885498,
0.14039385318756104,
-0.6726500391960144,
-0.41587236523628235,
-0.08938108384609222,
-0.2097228765487671,
-0.5133518576622009,
0.8554551601409912,
-0.5541718602180481,
-0.4180079400539398,
-0.05615978315472603,
-0.3870590627193451,
-0.4755907356739044,
0.12717832624912262,
0.7083971500396729,
0.21176466345787048,
-0.44780081510543823,
-0.007918999530375004,
0.6799054145812988,
-0.295678049325943,
0.6769226789474487,
0.4970395267009735,
0.03973231837153435,
0.013396083377301693,
0.7072895765304565,
-0.23628073930740356,
0.303737074136734,
0.087795190513134,
0.46027499437332153,
-0.2189401537179947,
-0.2052469104528427,
-0.527541995048523,
-0.2993830442428589,
-0.7128964066505432,
-0.4178430736064911,
-0.7153157591819763,
-0.03972668573260307,
-0.461463987827301,
-0.34452494978904724,
-0.10686349123716354,
-0.3747101426124573,
-0.738761305809021,
-0.043639469891786575,
0.768241822719574,
0.4422094523906708,
0.13933463394641876,
0.49909818172454834,
-0.4991501271724701,
0.19867359101772308,
0.2184421420097351,
0.36551910638809204,
0.04721207916736603,
-0.47747674584388733,
0.25905749201774597,
-0.06415636837482452,
-0.39667174220085144,
-1.331992745399475,
0.19824913144111633,
0.15464900434017181,
0.39586615562438965,
0.2871209383010864,
0.3460228741168976,
0.17804546654224396,
-0.06869219988584518,
1.018566370010376,
-0.00009234699246007949,
-1.1354414224624634,
0.8841867446899414,
-0.5753353834152222,
0.18624846637248993,
0.6177123785018921,
0.4868226945400238,
-0.4670453369617462,
-0.3258652091026306,
-0.7279118299484253,
-0.7995447516441345,
0.7375527620315552,
0.4313279390335083,
0.30974069237709045,
-0.1943296194076538,
0.5009486675262451,
0.229218989610672,
0.22469444572925568,
-0.6964499354362488,
-0.046053383499383926,
-0.4158518612384796,
-0.14345557987689972,
0.2778881788253784,
-0.35216206312179565,
0.15700075030326843,
0.39032629132270813,
0.6656431555747986,
-0.1780717968940735,
0.312021404504776,
0.200753852725029,
-0.011970472522079945,
-0.0516962893307209,
0.4768507182598114,
0.18636514246463776,
0.1899416148662567,
-0.01883034221827984,
-0.09866901487112045,
0.1427241712808609,
-0.3648529052734375,
0.06263869255781174,
0.19933050870895386,
-0.3272818922996521,
-0.2744375169277191,
0.06971181929111481,
0.9990102648735046,
-0.051948826760053635,
-0.3262684643268585,
0.6734722256660461,
-0.23995941877365112,
0.04611033573746681,
0.1675354242324829,
0.37129420042037964,
-0.2348390370607376,
-0.004993898328393698,
0.07362595945596695,
0.08136533200740814,
0.7085162401199341,
-0.13109509646892548,
0.10603424161672592,
0.3912156820297241,
-0.6167113184928894,
-0.2775736153125763,
0.5265933871269226,
0.2395630180835724,
-0.28008076548576355,
0.7127024531364441,
0.0063733188435435295,
-0.6201784610748291,
0.9421026706695557,
0.7543737888336182,
0.9216840267181396,
-0.6710241436958313,
0.3688278794288635,
0.46621716022491455,
0.20603536069393158,
0.30833443999290466,
0.5401159524917603,
-0.2504854202270508,
-0.4382797181606293,
-0.27715036273002625,
-0.28810980916023254,
-0.5523643493652344,
-0.2344355285167694,
-0.6776422262191772,
0.4075145721435547,
-0.22134383022785187,
-0.5203825831413269,
0.10772533714771271,
-0.1614459902048111,
-0.6522855162620544,
0.43326351046562195,
-0.0478886142373085,
0.9335595369338989,
-1.1263139247894287,
-0.1019885316491127,
0.6891710758209229,
-0.11761769652366638,
-1.0961763858795166,
0.01939467340707779,
0.08247185498476028,
-0.49799078702926636,
0.41714391112327576,
0.3167561888694763,
-0.13076913356781006,
0.11835025250911713,
-0.4419935345649719,
-0.5734632015228271,
0.7066760063171387,
0.34737423062324524,
-0.2584507465362549,
0.44186151027679443,
-0.17023181915283203,
0.6377965807914734,
-0.16838298738002777,
0.9181060791015625,
0.4685938060283661,
0.5221124887466431,
0.212898388504982,
-0.631058931350708,
0.34883183240890503,
-0.800013542175293,
-0.11898437887430191,
0.17424415051937103,
-0.8143710494041443,
0.832046627998352,
-0.07553383708000183,
-0.14412488043308258,
-0.1265111118555069,
0.3912275731563568,
0.28310003876686096,
0.4142338037490845,
0.6244232654571533,
0.07105375081300735,
0.6968458294868469,
-0.054218586534261703,
1.0905046463012695,
-0.6223390102386475,
0.2622361183166504,
0.575652003288269,
-0.2409536987543106,
0.574560284614563,
0.20181581377983093,
-0.09272683411836624,
0.35769331455230713,
0.9267592430114746,
0.1308530867099762,
0.40197911858558655,
0.29974427819252014,
-0.5061538219451904,
0.08674448728561401,
-0.2547799348831177,
-0.5905970931053162,
0.04293201491236687,
0.3803367018699646,
-0.23283101618289948,
0.03147517144680023,
0.27213361859321594,
0.18290819227695465,
-0.3569273352622986,
-0.32041940093040466,
0.7761119604110718,
-0.034651175141334534,
-1.0574830770492554,
0.23430630564689636,
-0.10050790756940842,
0.5139555335044861,
-0.4539778232574463,
0.18278177082538605,
-0.40707632899284363,
-0.23434339463710785,
-0.33579304814338684,
-0.7096254825592041,
0.09735337644815445,
0.40013739466667175,
-0.33624380826950073,
-0.00806095264852047,
1.102962851524353,
0.1383441686630249,
-0.25231239199638367,
-0.027227137237787247,
0.15221603214740753,
0.1325179785490036,
-0.3151327967643738,
-0.7723493576049805,
0.14263193309307098,
0.15593552589416504,
-0.8852444291114807,
-0.014166387729346752,
0.6832515001296997,
-0.06974822282791138,
0.6481900215148926,
0.4962301552295685,
-0.2932293713092804,
0.04383207857608795,
0.02772786282002926,
1.1921180486679077,
-0.5800221562385559,
-0.7362668514251709,
-1.045106291770935,
0.6178649067878723,
0.1073145866394043,
-0.4627961814403534,
0.6549815535545349,
0.24845212697982788,
-0.052771035581827164,
-0.1441384106874466,
0.839381992816925,
-0.45825323462486267,
0.3875265419483185,
-0.4712740480899811,
0.38304051756858826,
0.03977485001087189,
0.11569041758775711,
-0.7885566353797913,
-0.9301556944847107,
-0.0566435270011425,
0.39154544472694397,
-0.4611509144306183,
0.37633466720581055,
0.5805826187133789,
0.8754900097846985,
0.07719158381223679,
0.6319221258163452,
-0.2328912764787674,
0.22587494552135468,
0.22552160918712616,
0.5463704466819763,
1.038967490196228,
0.05843546614050865,
0.3745364546775818,
-0.2961353063583374,
-0.608811616897583,
-0.3038656711578369,
-1.2925266027450562,
-0.6142092943191528,
-0.5475645065307617,
-0.3776351809501648,
-0.5374124646186829,
0.10828745365142822,
0.5590559840202332,
0.3731575906276703,
-0.7659360766410828,
0.3195360600948334,
-0.43084093928337097,
-0.07529686391353607,
0.15362727642059326,
-0.3244774639606476,
0.5377579927444458,
-0.5308421850204468,
-0.3134883642196655,
0.20893904566764832,
-0.03723457083106041,
-0.017912669107317924,
0.04008733481168747,
0.1286633461713791,
0.33370766043663025,
0.22426989674568176,
0.5258951187133789,
0.2861289978027344,
-0.15063521265983582,
-0.2802760601043701,
0.2670709788799286,
-0.20487000048160553,
-0.11582273244857788,
0.8968158960342407,
-0.7481581568717957,
0.26008859276771545,
0.7597609758377075,
0.48897871375083923,
0.44527021050453186,
0.4252987205982208,
0.5570559501647949,
-0.6124861240386963,
-0.01880774460732937,
0.29765069484710693,
0.03505280986428261,
0.3938958942890167,
-0.8832301497459412,
0.3267582058906555,
-0.09030123054981232,
-0.905479371547699,
-0.579115629196167,
0.32639259099960327,
-0.9475399255752563,
-0.211600661277771,
1.2080761194229126,
-0.11248728632926941,
0.05564618483185768,
0.358183890581131,
-0.6687119603157043,
0.291094034910202,
-0.5909111499786377,
0.9390546083450317,
0.7767642140388489,
-0.5521715879440308,
-0.2081756442785263,
-0.46920809149742126,
0.6539628505706787,
0.7263336777687073,
-0.8389031291007996,
0.2250702977180481,
0.8340255618095398,
0.100731261074543,
-0.1279178112745285,
0.8112758994102478,
-0.07881602644920349,
0.38950374722480774,
-0.010204648599028587,
0.10308045148849487,
0.064815953373909,
-0.03100760094821453,
-0.49042758345603943,
0.46682634949684143,
0.26432520151138306,
0.030984940007328987
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14003v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14003v1
|
Multi-Modal Hallucination Control by Visual Information Grounding
| 2024-03-20T22:05:18 | 2024-03-20T22:05:18 |
Alessandro Favero, Luca Zancato, Matthew Trager, Siddharth Choudhary, Pramuditha Perera, Alessandro Achille, Ashwin Swaminathan, Stefano Soatto
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Generative Vision-Language Models (VLMs) are prone to generate
plausible-sounding textual answers that, however, are not always grounded in
the input image. We investigate this phenomenon, usually referred to as
"hallucination" and show that it stems from an excessive reliance on the
language prior. In particular, we show that as more tokens are generated, the
reliance on the visual prompt decreases, and this behavior strongly correlates
with the emergence of hallucinations. To reduce hallucinations, we introduce
Multi-Modal Mutual-Information Decoding (M3ID), a new sampling method for
prompt amplification. M3ID amplifies the influence of the reference image over
the language prior, hence favoring the generation of tokens with higher mutual
information with the visual prompt. M3ID can be applied to any pre-trained
autoregressive VLM at inference time without necessitating further training and
with minimal computational overhead. If training is an option, we show that
M3ID can be paired with Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) to improve the
model's reliance on the prompt image without requiring any labels. Our
empirical findings show that our algorithms maintain the fluency and linguistic
capabilities of pre-trained VLMs while reducing hallucinations by mitigating
visually ungrounded answers. Specifically, for the LLaVA 13B model, M3ID and
M3ID+DPO reduce the percentage of hallucinated objects in captioning tasks by
25% and 28%, respectively, and improve the accuracy on VQA benchmarks such as
POPE by 21% and 24%.
|
[
-0.726875901222229,
-0.7369349002838135,
0.6135593056678772,
0.2540193200111389,
-0.46450886130332947,
-0.3246247172355652,
-0.17606434226036072,
-0.35207265615463257,
0.2945128381252289,
0.44702330231666565,
-0.6350468397140503,
-0.38966232538223267,
-0.6194165349006653,
0.28508031368255615,
-0.036512475460767746,
0.561720073223114,
0.2460043728351593,
0.3825884759426117,
-0.39271068572998047,
-0.1229122132062912,
-0.8057281374931335,
-0.9546619057655334,
-0.30592405796051025,
-0.07201680541038513,
0.6535398364067078,
0.14904233813285828,
0.7614128589630127,
0.35631054639816284,
0.4155472218990326,
0.2949135899543762,
0.11731410026550293,
0.46635156869888306,
-0.4672588109970093,
0.2160690575838089,
0.12606017291545868,
-0.43528515100479126,
-0.1238434687256813,
-0.13852693140506744,
0.22519725561141968,
0.6002975702285767,
-0.0010311888763681054,
-0.23796473443508148,
-0.1882917881011963,
0.549188494682312,
-0.8285349607467651,
0.2400897890329361,
-0.6286584734916687,
0.2206076979637146,
0.2462572306394577,
-0.8256840109825134,
-0.6485045552253723,
-0.04788655787706375,
-0.11170866340398788,
-0.5814247131347656,
0.07365762442350388,
0.24887965619564056,
0.8767312169075012,
0.6553756594657898,
-0.27303004264831543,
-0.23044532537460327,
-0.6348571181297302,
0.6029809713363647,
-0.3220869302749634,
0.5892972946166992,
0.6743342876434326,
0.08193772286176682,
-0.04916277155280113,
-0.3733360469341278,
-0.71854168176651,
-0.5298794507980347,
-0.29517030715942383,
0.14153581857681274,
-0.024221064522862434,
0.2903003692626953,
0.5462607741355896,
0.10131459683179855,
-0.3925710916519165,
-0.1229771226644516,
-0.5658572912216187,
-0.4528837502002716,
0.10030482709407806,
0.25065621733665466,
0.26108765602111816,
-0.3763827085494995,
-0.3738088309764862,
-0.18690279126167297,
-0.5702852606773376,
-0.05762602761387825,
0.026963673532009125,
-0.004303945228457451,
0.29510805010795593,
0.8853380680084229,
-0.17389971017837524,
0.7435712814331055,
0.21945439279079437,
-0.1654731184244156,
0.3601935803890228,
-0.3175479471683502,
-0.2501201331615448,
-0.03885047510266304,
0.5169376730918884,
0.7587796449661255,
0.22752998769283295,
-0.21187053620815277,
-0.2916882634162903,
0.34043386578559875,
0.44795942306518555,
-0.8144309520721436,
-0.1075860857963562,
0.13383200764656067,
-0.6599545478820801,
-0.2719309628009796,
0.21795699000358582,
-0.7099098563194275,
-0.5239432454109192,
-0.7904453277587891,
0.6461058259010315,
-0.46289172768592834,
-0.11304449290037155,
0.07262404263019562,
-0.2644175887107849,
0.30598196387290955,
0.4618014991283417,
-0.7788050174713135,
0.17590093612670898,
0.11661901324987411,
0.963133692741394,
-0.24616123735904694,
-0.5606591701507568,
-0.8644858598709106,
0.20208998024463654,
-0.411736398935318,
0.6670364737510681,
-0.4689854085445404,
-0.326590895652771,
-0.12409408390522003,
0.16683568060398102,
-0.036345914006233215,
-0.6220929622650146,
0.21417611837387085,
-0.5244479775428772,
0.27775436639785767,
-0.5587828755378723,
-0.17043493688106537,
-0.3592867851257324,
-0.0049203005619347095,
-0.8005203604698181,
0.6615351438522339,
-0.24615104496479034,
-0.811438798904419,
0.45859408378601074,
-0.16355569660663605,
-0.32712188363075256,
-0.19635483622550964,
-0.6206684708595276,
-0.04377632588148117,
0.4335947632789612,
0.43521422147750854,
0.47815456986427307,
-0.021805457770824432,
0.47566351294517517,
-0.1475532501935959,
-0.5678027868270874,
0.09478787332773209,
-0.4640820026397705,
0.47717928886413574,
0.23200517892837524,
-0.5630234479904175,
0.5675633549690247,
-0.7985830903053284,
-0.34312549233436584,
0.027383392676711082,
0.06465637683868408,
-0.4585428833961487,
-0.09085395187139511,
-0.05526626482605934,
0.2805362045764923,
0.005106937140226364,
0.044291455298662186,
0.03651004657149315,
-0.049812160432338715,
0.06752029061317444,
0.9129419922828674,
0.004785986617207527,
0.2310306578874588,
-0.5968974828720093,
0.38544633984565735,
0.2755853533744812,
0.17822879552841187,
-0.2339630275964737,
-0.4205264449119568,
-0.8701876401901245,
-0.35218533873558044,
-0.3053536117076874,
0.5295944809913635,
-1.0410574674606323,
0.5589798092842102,
-0.1919279843568802,
-0.006799500435590744,
-0.37667161226272583,
-0.11865243315696716,
0.12973007559776306,
0.5891726613044739,
0.5866256952285767,
-0.23234426975250244,
-0.5138089060783386,
-0.8998996019363403,
0.4428909718990326,
-0.09467913955450058,
-0.003149475436657667,
0.3773587644100189,
0.2402617186307907,
-0.2788102328777313,
0.505011260509491,
-0.32880422472953796,
-0.49764543771743774,
-0.1223258450627327,
0.10259858518838882,
0.0908229649066925,
0.32997503876686096,
0.4155859351158142,
-0.9481016397476196,
-0.021222667768597603,
-0.2674734592437744,
-1.0209882259368896,
-0.1231740266084671,
-0.4559725522994995,
-0.1908622682094574,
0.26917728781700134,
0.6264609098434448,
-0.7891815304756165,
0.5533276200294495,
0.2961806356906891,
-0.42979586124420166,
0.6173582673072815,
-0.33171921968460083,
0.4699357748031616,
-0.8892078399658203,
0.016767069697380066,
-0.3833504617214203,
-0.02298787422478199,
-0.504662811756134,
-0.05865988880395889,
-0.0623934231698513,
-0.026190999895334244,
-0.2566700577735901,
0.30168113112449646,
-0.7092946767807007,
-0.09277446568012238,
-0.40380871295928955,
-0.007346794009208679,
0.05829166620969772,
0.7418082356452942,
0.4431871771812439,
0.8487711548805237,
0.7831823825836182,
-0.7013859152793884,
0.4149089455604553,
0.22958512604236603,
-0.09714234620332718,
0.5321491360664368,
-0.476120263338089,
-0.0009423803421668708,
-0.6748910546302795,
-0.010509663261473179,
-0.996471107006073,
-0.25693458318710327,
0.37873974442481995,
-0.36900967359542847,
0.17357206344604492,
0.2760939598083496,
-0.4137159585952759,
-0.1793941855430603,
-0.3121010363101959,
0.3596627712249756,
0.4606904983520508,
-0.6640118360519409,
0.73957359790802,
0.025238240137696266,
0.1405075192451477,
-0.5896486639976501,
-0.6231575012207031,
0.17501786351203918,
-0.12776662409305573,
-0.4442894160747528,
0.27098605036735535,
-0.4160579442977905,
-0.2894216775894165,
-0.028979262337088585,
-0.18019554018974304,
0.02568386122584343,
-0.0798359140753746,
0.565122127532959,
0.3896700441837311,
-0.1175142303109169,
0.4077748954296112,
0.0819048210978508,
-0.07166671007871628,
0.13332268595695496,
-0.16468355059623718,
0.9453020095825195,
0.004910765215754509,
-0.4463292360305786,
-0.7527949810028076,
0.5300636291503906,
0.883812665939331,
-0.19803275167942047,
0.847291886806488,
0.6022804379463196,
-0.4223772883415222,
0.1531890332698822,
-0.7095167636871338,
-0.7368209958076477,
-0.4167827367782593,
0.18639925122261047,
-0.8611751198768616,
-0.640247106552124,
0.4654123783111572,
0.17396843433380127,
-0.41899386048316956,
0.21980896592140198,
0.6484279632568359,
0.19707483053207397,
1.0303761959075928,
0.4456983804702759,
-0.03702038899064064,
0.5155888795852661,
-0.11951364576816559,
-0.026176953688263893,
-0.5693138837814331,
-0.5151583552360535,
-0.21120944619178772,
-0.06023812294006348,
-0.0996168851852417,
-0.5374500751495361,
0.32199549674987793,
0.2253846526145935,
0.15875877439975739,
-0.09420143812894821,
-0.654144823551178,
0.5010164380073547,
0.7284692525863647,
0.4569716453552246,
0.4059807360172272,
0.21757259964942932,
-0.14103591442108154,
-0.2798634171485901,
-0.5178222060203552,
-0.21643473207950592,
0.934876024723053,
-0.03971173241734505,
0.7646047472953796,
-0.09541970491409302,
0.5392596125602722,
0.3514150381088257,
-0.07301874458789825,
-0.6860572099685669,
0.5684983730316162,
0.32884660363197327,
-0.3163623809814453,
-0.3276779055595398,
-0.3303696811199188,
-0.5086835622787476,
0.5544634461402893,
-0.355325847864151,
-0.6329737901687622,
0.4189296066761017,
0.05010529235005379,
-0.3508863151073456,
0.043947283178567886,
-0.644588828086853,
0.5660110116004944,
-0.1886572241783142,
-0.4742693603038788,
-0.34241679310798645,
-0.6607146263122559,
0.4303792715072632,
0.11148948967456818,
0.10658744722604752,
0.16429905593395233,
0.025899536907672882,
0.3488071858882904,
-0.30028268694877625,
0.8245171904563904,
-0.20149195194244385,
0.010517152957618237,
0.05062286928296089,
-0.041212908923625946,
0.5195648074150085,
0.21050971746444702,
0.2241627722978592,
0.10533048957586288,
-0.20523959398269653,
-0.33980661630630493,
-0.8234037756919861,
0.5956825017929077,
-0.692180335521698,
-0.7783872485160828,
-0.3584175109863281,
-0.42263466119766235,
0.040719661861658096,
0.1288570761680603,
0.6831517219543457,
0.6076570153236389,
0.08367064595222473,
0.22217917442321777,
0.8925512433052063,
-0.2615533173084259,
0.32982057332992554,
-0.047761768102645874,
-0.5015884041786194,
-0.6662736535072327,
0.7361393570899963,
-0.002263349946588278,
0.34281742572784424,
0.38363149762153625,
-0.04706057533621788,
-0.3333914577960968,
-0.5646103620529175,
-0.3752560317516327,
0.31360718607902527,
-0.9658072590827942,
-0.014004523865878582,
-1.019896149635315,
-0.08986169099807739,
-0.4314316213130951,
-0.15278834104537964,
-0.04334297031164169,
-0.18213492631912231,
-0.48770061135292053,
-0.20585229992866516,
0.22681748867034912,
0.39647307991981506,
-0.2711218595504761,
0.08868643641471863,
-0.4550171196460724,
0.8281096816062927,
0.42977768182754517,
0.0853644460439682,
-0.008557228371500969,
-0.341171532869339,
0.1391732394695282,
-0.10796990245580673,
0.21393300592899323,
-1.1701645851135254,
0.3199272155761719,
-0.0285680890083313,
0.5992211699485779,
0.6372769474983215,
0.2270112931728363,
0.861555278301239,
-0.2997715175151825,
0.6833893656730652,
0.4027635157108307,
-0.9331175088882446,
0.5166104435920715,
0.04351850971579552,
0.2497512549161911,
0.5847300887107849,
0.43737947940826416,
-0.38896483182907104,
-0.4072992503643036,
-0.08446738123893738,
-0.5314192771911621,
0.5339581966400146,
0.20007862150669098,
0.17356418073177338,
-0.10795803368091583,
0.044602494686841965,
0.2236085832118988,
0.3255898952484131,
-1.0163105726242065,
-0.2631259262561798,
-0.5575411319732666,
0.09823255985975266,
-0.044950637966394424,
-0.5585945248603821,
-0.42227381467819214,
-0.5658193230628967,
0.30027228593826294,
-0.17974352836608887,
0.32845836877822876,
0.5517954230308533,
-0.37760165333747864,
0.002916597528383136,
-0.09103526175022125,
1.0437778234481812,
0.6883763670921326,
-0.2797831594944,
0.6080891489982605,
-0.024925993755459785,
-0.4391826093196869,
0.22985181212425232,
-0.15624216198921204,
-0.30745166540145874,
0.21045248210430145,
0.26206836104393005,
1.2186585664749146,
-0.16418296098709106,
-0.6090008616447449,
0.6337626576423645,
-0.18705840408802032,
-0.2089681178331375,
-0.21589326858520508,
-0.060018401592969894,
-0.302055299282074,
0.26012280583381653,
0.3645058274269104,
0.29618167877197266,
0.22274646162986755,
-0.3694947063922882,
0.3683795928955078,
0.4241315722465515,
-0.44173794984817505,
-0.26055431365966797,
0.825517475605011,
-0.13451707363128662,
-0.11545892059803009,
0.4498594105243683,
-0.12797504663467407,
-0.3631899058818817,
0.4186635911464691,
0.5931594967842102,
0.8146360516548157,
-0.0808495581150055,
0.32875293493270874,
0.38764625787734985,
0.5318722128868103,
-0.04176865890622139,
0.4091910421848297,
-0.27244505286216736,
-0.7007632255554199,
-0.24840009212493896,
-0.395629346370697,
-0.08719988912343979,
0.3008044362068176,
-0.647574782371521,
0.390816867351532,
-0.49557042121887207,
-0.16519474983215332,
-0.38441726565361023,
-0.5024172067642212,
-0.5425456166267395,
0.14844490587711334,
0.14764559268951416,
0.3941645622253418,
-0.7537104487419128,
0.7620499730110168,
0.3898839056491852,
-0.6879603266716003,
-0.36286652088165283,
0.1118694543838501,
-0.0896575078368187,
-0.5573117136955261,
0.6737784147262573,
0.598786473274231,
-0.32575109601020813,
0.10042167454957962,
-0.5146220922470093,
-0.6603853702545166,
0.8738993406295776,
0.14197608828544617,
-0.3619772791862488,
-0.07328473031520844,
-0.22476299107074738,
0.30982381105422974,
-0.39730003476142883,
0.1606741100549698,
0.2458747923374176,
0.5863615274429321,
0.3356121778488159,
-0.6214733719825745,
0.3282237946987152,
-0.2801090478897095,
0.016196196898818016,
-0.11152906715869904,
-0.3413134515285492,
0.7985404133796692,
-0.49986863136291504,
-0.31824424862861633,
-0.10490130633115768,
0.7368463277816772,
0.3371821939945221,
0.23381923139095306,
0.6552703976631165,
0.3331089913845062,
0.8859825134277344,
0.1630331575870514,
0.8300133347511292,
-0.2942780554294586,
-0.1720743179321289,
1.0083009004592896,
-0.03120441548526287,
0.49608978629112244,
1.058404564857483,
0.20217005908489227,
0.23534110188484192,
0.47880762815475464,
-0.1520427167415619,
0.8755646347999573,
0.11215752363204956,
-0.19895443320274353,
-0.4278757572174072,
-0.2529822885990143,
-0.6475292444229126,
0.21824520826339722,
0.1005752831697464,
-0.3690033257007599,
0.0659928172826767,
0.5476462841033936,
-0.2311374843120575,
0.02969335950911045,
-0.056754786521196365,
0.7971649765968323,
-0.07743287831544876,
-0.6528052687644958,
0.9728906750679016,
-0.3978038728237152,
0.6816421747207642,
-0.3868080675601959,
-0.10163256525993347,
-0.44237324595451355,
-0.2958889305591583,
-0.026202309876680374,
0.03337375819683075,
0.20375363528728485,
-0.35040390491485596,
-0.3856801688671112,
-0.09802904725074768,
0.5473456382751465,
-0.4421986937522888,
-0.3065510392189026,
0.43884918093681335,
0.5367016792297363,
0.2278304249048233,
-0.36682406067848206,
-0.13291986286640167,
0.23357106745243073,
0.017802510410547256,
-0.15612496435642242,
0.083500437438488,
0.5160984992980957,
-0.02883896976709366,
0.55962735414505,
0.6884364485740662,
0.1504344642162323,
0.4455187916755676,
0.3035827577114105,
1.0816013813018799,
-0.772144079208374,
-0.3593687415122986,
-0.8435768485069275,
0.35386425256729126,
-0.16595333814620972,
-0.106458880007267,
0.5710673332214355,
0.41938987374305725,
0.7222638130187988,
-0.5232709646224976,
0.6418808698654175,
0.03270275518298149,
-0.10376906394958496,
-0.9264336228370667,
0.6286466121673584,
-0.7583580613136292,
0.1787511110305786,
-0.20575271546840668,
-1.129086971282959,
-0.49777182936668396,
0.597196102142334,
-0.007957936264574528,
-0.20324257016181946,
1.0234267711639404,
1.0166823863983154,
0.13381442427635193,
-0.25105538964271545,
0.8238458633422852,
-0.09708522260189056,
0.1031079962849617,
0.4001352787017822,
1.1807730197906494,
-0.0718565508723259,
0.41898858547210693,
-0.40223032236099243,
-0.28032681345939636,
-0.3422057628631592,
-0.5359467267990112,
-1.2534756660461426,
-0.7979801893234253,
-0.02877832017838955,
-0.31013810634613037,
0.09530395269393921,
0.8361866474151611,
0.663580060005188,
-0.7456231713294983,
-0.11255723237991333,
-0.182503342628479,
0.14382857084274292,
-0.14489296078681946,
-0.21531903743743896,
0.28989118337631226,
-0.6900069713592529,
-0.6423720121383667,
0.38101160526275635,
0.49740228056907654,
0.44359856843948364,
-0.4851164221763611,
-0.18009315431118011,
0.04446284472942352,
0.054563701152801514,
0.7178731560707092,
-0.20215928554534912,
-1.1354477405548096,
-0.182038813829422,
0.44450369477272034,
-0.2949846088886261,
0.309920072555542,
0.885470986366272,
-0.8097536563873291,
0.7135154008865356,
0.5140737295150757,
0.47884851694107056,
0.272368848323822,
0.13420064747333527,
0.45233526825904846,
-0.25503072142601013,
0.6046489477157593,
-0.0028436107095330954,
0.25333988666534424,
0.20427826046943665,
-0.48424190282821655,
0.24564862251281738,
0.5983324646949768,
-0.201991006731987,
-0.7072552442550659,
0.22972552478313446,
-1.033645510673523,
-0.6038100123405457,
1.1560667753219604,
0.3423653841018677,
-0.1250586211681366,
-0.07369811087846756,
-0.7806223630905151,
0.012370013631880283,
-0.33350828289985657,
1.0322047472000122,
0.8608699440956116,
0.05084613710641861,
-0.5294407606124878,
-0.29535356163978577,
0.7499145269393921,
0.5312972664833069,
-0.8048654198646545,
-0.01746811904013157,
1.1544864177703857,
-0.3453238010406494,
0.2890903353691101,
0.7963851094245911,
0.12084583938121796,
0.24680626392364502,
0.11046656221151352,
0.25761356949806213,
-0.19805358350276947,
-0.9837554097175598,
-0.4964959919452667,
0.4699341356754303,
-0.02808842808008194,
-0.3004980981349945
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14001v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14001v1
|
Evaluating Unsupervised Dimensionality Reduction Methods for Pretrained Sentence Embeddings
| 2024-03-20T21:58:32 | 2024-03-20T21:58:32 |
Gaifan Zhang, Yi Zhou, Danushka Bollegala
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Sentence embeddings produced by Pretrained Language Models (PLMs) have
received wide attention from the NLP community due to their superior
performance when representing texts in numerous downstream applications.
However, the high dimensionality of the sentence embeddings produced by PLMs is
problematic when representing large numbers of sentences in memory- or
compute-constrained devices. As a solution, we evaluate unsupervised
dimensionality reduction methods to reduce the dimensionality of sentence
embeddings produced by PLMs. Our experimental results show that simple methods
such as Principal Component Analysis (PCA) can reduce the dimensionality of
sentence embeddings by almost $50\%$, without incurring a significant loss in
performance in multiple downstream tasks. Surprisingly, reducing the
dimensionality further improves performance over the original high-dimensional
versions for the sentence embeddings produced by some PLMs in some tasks.
|
[
-0.47583675384521484,
-0.5492511987686157,
0.8221076130867004,
0.4037373960018158,
-0.7228147387504578,
-0.060057785362005234,
-0.3400478959083557,
0.22856760025024414,
0.41399386525154114,
0.601033091545105,
-0.4749089479446411,
-0.7338454127311707,
-0.5798529386520386,
-0.1294676512479782,
-0.21257317066192627,
0.6614757776260376,
-0.10782523453235626,
0.04263204708695412,
-0.8706339597702026,
-0.014022942632436752,
-0.5742483139038086,
-0.9168177247047424,
-0.1222696453332901,
-0.015573221258819103,
0.14133864641189575,
0.08036383241415024,
0.2735593616962433,
0.4126637876033783,
0.829910933971405,
0.2859535217285156,
-0.13453856110572815,
0.23944441974163055,
-0.48415711522102356,
-0.11258777230978012,
0.08230146020650864,
-0.4074808657169342,
-0.3350409269332886,
0.4931047260761261,
0.6927089691162109,
1.0878289937973022,
-0.013857434503734112,
0.11595138162374496,
0.10614378750324249,
0.7738958597183228,
-0.8658197522163391,
0.27878880500793457,
-0.2466040551662445,
0.6049485206604004,
-0.2517809271812439,
-0.46918177604675293,
-0.6709655523300171,
-0.29017674922943115,
0.15670561790466309,
-0.5886014103889465,
0.19716781377792358,
-0.17624709010124207,
0.24942895770072937,
0.586779773235321,
-0.5710683465003967,
0.003310796106234193,
-0.9561032652854919,
0.7828323245048523,
-0.50879967212677,
0.3539530634880066,
0.24233053624629974,
-0.23381216824054718,
-0.0786365196108818,
-0.8390778303146362,
-0.5656028985977173,
-0.02025025337934494,
-0.12996335327625275,
0.17963442206382751,
-0.11975500732660294,
0.1362682282924652,
0.3376070559024811,
0.2753147482872009,
-0.6716468334197998,
0.2987779378890991,
-0.2657168507575989,
-0.11766967922449112,
0.4966830611228943,
-0.07173231989145279,
0.22765100002288818,
-0.3037972152233124,
-0.4169546663761139,
-0.40983277559280396,
-0.7176602482795715,
0.0924319177865982,
0.22490455210208893,
0.2677610218524933,
0.14073576033115387,
0.619247555732727,
0.2537005841732025,
0.3611163794994354,
-0.28769105672836304,
-0.009658689610660076,
0.3292219638824463,
-0.2951229214668274,
-0.29073086380958557,
0.05653131753206253,
0.7613207101821899,
0.4755040407180786,
0.16543768346309662,
-0.1419331431388855,
0.1611890345811844,
0.3353370726108551,
0.47889357805252075,
-0.9748143553733826,
-0.39581525325775146,
0.18098808825016022,
-0.9684656262397766,
-0.059860821813344955,
0.3126652240753174,
-0.6877020597457886,
-0.3543449640274048,
-0.24430839717388153,
0.20650611817836761,
-0.404135137796402,
0.2286989837884903,
0.3056437075138092,
0.0032241877634078264,
0.04416023567318916,
0.11940338462591171,
-0.5079408884048462,
0.18872599303722382,
0.5087076425552368,
0.87094646692276,
-0.2518119513988495,
-0.15928438305854797,
-0.8676238656044006,
0.10200432687997818,
-0.413814514875412,
0.7838082909584045,
-0.5410795211791992,
-0.47632700204849243,
0.004119828809052706,
-0.39344966411590576,
-0.40675821900367737,
-0.5694756507873535,
0.6505900025367737,
-0.2776058614253998,
0.3432263433933258,
-0.39193105697631836,
-0.9280083179473877,
-0.06891490519046783,
-0.28161871433258057,
-0.648132860660553,
0.5622266530990601,
-0.3496217727661133,
-0.796008825302124,
0.3822898864746094,
-0.5054706335067749,
-0.5095236897468567,
-0.07837497442960739,
-0.0436512753367424,
-0.5848578810691833,
0.6572427153587341,
0.6514214873313904,
0.6218640804290771,
0.028651732951402664,
-0.0734793022274971,
-0.3761225938796997,
-0.4513958692550659,
0.16914445161819458,
-0.4688597619533539,
0.6710206270217896,
0.1424405574798584,
-0.0234981756657362,
-0.01612352579832077,
-0.9393392205238342,
0.07569532841444016,
-0.021350523456931114,
-0.47026073932647705,
-0.5814105868339539,
0.3199314773082733,
0.03620053827762604,
0.1704287976026535,
0.22242720425128937,
-0.7801374197006226,
0.2202240526676178,
-0.521151065826416,
0.4864080548286438,
0.6184372305870056,
-0.1046309694647789,
0.4752914011478424,
0.22220639884471893,
0.5105822086334229,
0.2349892556667328,
0.05090801790356636,
0.003940328489989042,
-0.3424224853515625,
-0.7897539734840393,
-0.3686995506286621,
0.2483091801404953,
0.4557135999202728,
-0.7145951390266418,
0.8465960621833801,
-0.1795843243598938,
-0.14623907208442688,
-0.3492054343223572,
0.07960141450166702,
0.4180716872215271,
-0.11078369617462158,
0.483558714389801,
-0.5626348257064819,
-0.572380781173706,
-0.7914251089096069,
-0.40274566411972046,
-0.26858294010162354,
-0.337544709444046,
-0.10573349893093109,
0.22565169632434845,
-0.07552038878202438,
0.9970998764038086,
-0.6751672029495239,
-0.5154393911361694,
-0.12267803400754929,
0.4488011598587036,
-0.293098509311676,
0.6836077570915222,
0.671531081199646,
-0.2579028010368347,
-0.429714173078537,
-0.2055797427892685,
-0.5967104434967041,
-0.14040043950080872,
-0.18412427604198456,
0.3158050775527954,
0.13252241909503937,
0.8441067934036255,
-1.007625699043274,
0.807242214679718,
0.6484882235527039,
-0.42611202597618103,
0.16121679544448853,
-0.8318459391593933,
-0.28934213519096375,
-0.9101965427398682,
-0.03518122434616089,
-0.0012792553752660751,
-0.30238258838653564,
-0.4660714566707611,
-0.0754426047205925,
-0.041982363909482956,
-0.3873564600944519,
-0.17574350535869598,
-0.2327079474925995,
-0.602347195148468,
-0.3470208942890167,
-0.174953430891037,
0.3473646938800812,
0.0391717329621315,
0.3183954358100891,
-0.22804789245128632,
0.7526302337646484,
0.25139284133911133,
-0.4782400131225586,
0.17716264724731445,
0.6717749834060669,
-0.4027650058269501,
0.376573771238327,
-0.5733724236488342,
0.382474422454834,
-0.40352270007133484,
0.3401755094528198,
-0.7897531390190125,
0.5031914114952087,
-0.161315456032753,
-0.17680403590202332,
0.1988353580236435,
0.30902811884880066,
-0.6624544262886047,
-0.3817306458950043,
-0.43853577971458435,
0.13095669448375702,
0.34148159623146057,
-0.7420729398727417,
0.5567626357078552,
0.3524181842803955,
-0.18642522394657135,
-0.05493154749274254,
-0.7127537131309509,
0.0782913938164711,
-0.061135292053222656,
-0.400860458612442,
0.6887646317481995,
-0.16578412055969238,
0.09198436886072159,
-0.11978703737258911,
0.01921524666249752,
0.0732475072145462,
-0.0815945565700531,
0.17137712240219116,
-0.05353817716240883,
-0.038629572838544846,
0.27554556727409363,
0.1652756780385971,
-0.28331735730171204,
0.4253932237625122,
-0.1594281792640686,
0.6203192472457886,
-0.010349597781896591,
-0.36262422800064087,
-0.8776152729988098,
0.4413868188858032,
0.43140262365341187,
-0.6676972508430481,
1.0786954164505005,
0.835098147392273,
-0.12596963346004486,
-0.4190947413444519,
-0.4202015995979309,
-0.01427773479372263,
-0.42602992057800293,
0.35311320424079895,
-0.1101989597082138,
-1.0062382221221924,
0.3134913146495819,
-0.2525450885295868,
-0.38710448145866394,
0.20179343223571777,
0.1898125261068344,
-0.20600390434265137,
1.02536141872406,
0.7644050121307373,
-0.10997015982866287,
0.2665736675262451,
-0.2102690041065216,
0.7864360809326172,
-0.4918868839740753,
-0.22305330634117126,
-0.5177538394927979,
-0.3409506380558014,
-0.8531344532966614,
-0.7591286897659302,
0.3971090614795685,
-0.07043801993131638,
0.05260292440652847,
0.01958606392145157,
-0.20360082387924194,
0.48359161615371704,
0.7945075035095215,
-0.011623457074165344,
0.14329443871974945,
0.17133298516273499,
-0.27590039372444153,
-0.31478258967399597,
-0.5427855253219604,
-0.4619500935077667,
1.1606853008270264,
0.4078136086463928,
0.17749878764152527,
-0.017126427963376045,
0.4462769627571106,
0.04426552355289459,
-0.31760281324386597,
-0.5623560547828674,
0.6345484256744385,
-1.028454065322876,
0.15562041103839874,
-0.07186825573444366,
-0.7447757124900818,
-0.6719064116477966,
0.2580784261226654,
-0.35477113723754883,
-0.5959246754646301,
0.3011738657951355,
-0.18529197573661804,
-0.5495441555976868,
0.4820907711982727,
-0.8745113015174866,
0.8266104459762573,
0.036811355501413345,
0.24386481940746307,
-0.4460638165473938,
-0.41743209958076477,
-0.03564394637942314,
-0.17490240931510925,
-0.17443549633026123,
0.2851870357990265,
0.11077388375997543,
1.025070309638977,
-0.9110091924667358,
0.9050216674804688,
-0.4764429032802582,
-0.05522714555263519,
0.1390119045972824,
-0.29350942373275757,
0.4129617512226105,
-0.05115852504968643,
0.5176639556884766,
-0.06960896402597427,
0.04253556579351425,
-0.31693410873413086,
-0.753119170665741,
0.8180750608444214,
-0.7807528972625732,
-0.44208842515945435,
-0.32714784145355225,
-0.5779861807823181,
-0.5579593777656555,
-0.004838021006435156,
0.17123039066791534,
0.3505571484565735,
-0.3254084587097168,
0.7211056351661682,
0.7868215441703796,
-0.6786997318267822,
0.7050533294677734,
0.1760524958372116,
-0.0882648453116417,
-0.22309435904026031,
0.7259694933891296,
0.19646750390529633,
-0.29722660779953003,
0.45501890778541565,
0.03861135244369507,
-0.29593127965927124,
-0.8967825174331665,
0.2922980785369873,
0.23803357779979706,
-0.4032815098762512,
0.08981136232614517,
-0.5203325748443604,
-0.18271484971046448,
-0.4575042426586151,
0.060094110667705536,
-0.7180004715919495,
-0.6276121139526367,
-0.7267482876777649,
-0.32881250977516174,
-0.046891842037439346,
0.7799780964851379,
0.052174363285303116,
0.6132829785346985,
-0.9053148627281189,
0.10501796752214432,
0.5593922138214111,
0.4569454491138458,
-0.30148008465766907,
-0.29941219091415405,
-0.19095449149608612,
-0.3169916868209839,
-0.33951735496520996,
-0.5129812955856323,
0.6205052733421326,
0.23458686470985413,
0.43367886543273926,
0.6316387057304382,
0.18357793986797333,
0.5593969821929932,
-0.6380362510681152,
0.7819564938545227,
0.1687973290681839,
-1.2398711442947388,
0.6839520335197449,
-0.07316622138023376,
0.3186139166355133,
0.31486573815345764,
0.2614918649196625,
0.034746136516332626,
-0.07651232928037643,
-0.38977307081222534,
-0.678128719329834,
0.4079298675060272,
0.6127014756202698,
0.21449828147888184,
0.03193483501672745,
0.43996644020080566,
-0.06188057363033295,
0.3013889789581299,
-0.40545105934143066,
-0.33255812525749207,
-0.21183151006698608,
-0.07845914363861084,
-0.4902799427509308,
-0.7113522887229919,
0.28291618824005127,
-0.31597772240638733,
0.438890278339386,
0.08949868381023407,
0.49271315336227417,
0.010961857624351978,
-0.1699068546295166,
0.05676206946372986,
0.16688814759254456,
0.47677674889564514,
0.6726006269454956,
-0.47844386100769043,
0.2320035845041275,
-0.17775759100914001,
-0.6359994411468506,
-0.03794548660516739,
0.24917937815189362,
-0.07667751610279083,
0.07459080219268799,
0.3603771924972534,
0.9641791582107544,
-0.1367843896150589,
-0.4170578420162201,
0.8280922770500183,
-0.35476288199424744,
0.019752753898501396,
-0.16886098682880402,
-0.41299304366111755,
0.03722548857331276,
0.12877821922302246,
0.013887406326830387,
0.20575669407844543,
-0.09528550505638123,
-0.27322500944137573,
0.08522232621908188,
0.3750608563423157,
-0.3424760699272156,
-0.395137220621109,
0.44256001710891724,
0.2787123918533325,
-0.020678607746958733,
0.9159564971923828,
-0.0731969028711319,
-0.45831912755966187,
0.09970027953386307,
0.4553510546684265,
0.8877549171447754,
-0.41391342878341675,
0.7005934715270996,
0.014407184906303883,
0.5456057190895081,
0.18424580991268158,
0.10465481877326965,
0.23872941732406616,
-0.7922868728637695,
-0.7744397521018982,
-0.633441686630249,
0.006826573982834816,
0.2227022349834442,
-0.8458511829376221,
-0.3407604396343231,
-0.7256376147270203,
-0.21555878221988678,
-0.0836079940199852,
0.11920061707496643,
-0.7020581364631653,
0.16355000436306,
0.1375102698802948,
0.5434582233428955,
-1.0096162557601929,
0.7316113710403442,
0.7939155101776123,
-0.4247284531593323,
-0.35082143545150757,
0.0931888222694397,
-0.3194209337234497,
-0.20088507235050201,
0.83790123462677,
0.267647922039032,
0.09165620058774948,
-0.2218487411737442,
-0.39420008659362793,
-0.6426610946655273,
0.8799269795417786,
0.8065345287322998,
-0.5840439796447754,
0.11304092407226562,
0.6277851462364197,
0.7683812379837036,
-0.45605456829071045,
-0.30758145451545715,
0.6383224725723267,
0.22467613220214844,
-0.30702731013298035,
-0.9062236547470093,
-0.058936573565006256,
-0.369417279958725,
0.6900644898414612,
-0.09079781174659729,
-0.38337308168411255,
1.1315045356750488,
0.12445811182260513,
-0.23889027535915375,
-0.09861280024051666,
0.8466115593910217,
0.13778646290302277,
0.0966666117310524,
0.4123978614807129,
1.0160430669784546,
0.8768372535705566,
0.10482968389987946,
1.0079004764556885,
-0.05038446933031082,
0.45159730315208435,
0.9239891767501831,
-0.3371298313140869,
1.058863639831543,
0.6762268543243408,
-0.4282616674900055,
0.5790413618087769,
0.19968625903129578,
0.26517656445503235,
0.6839556097984314,
0.2576581537723541,
-0.048767488449811935,
-0.3780706822872162,
-0.05409817025065422,
-0.22020097076892853,
0.7858643531799316,
0.0622071772813797,
-0.3556676208972931,
0.04890994355082512,
0.4318307936191559,
-0.004141487181186676,
0.547905683517456,
-0.1863398551940918,
0.6088130474090576,
0.12623214721679688,
-0.15437358617782593,
0.22346419095993042,
0.11524621397256851,
0.5033327341079712,
-0.17625246942043304,
0.13577395677566528,
-0.2989710569381714,
0.6096596717834473,
0.08568424731492996,
-0.1978415548801422,
0.3919876515865326,
-0.08978946506977081,
-0.24895288050174713,
-0.6185927987098694,
0.6405812501907349,
-0.247493714094162,
-0.5574979782104492,
0.39911189675331116,
0.5649529695510864,
0.019935494288802147,
-0.5176221132278442,
-0.28275614976882935,
-0.005769982002675533,
-0.020028483122587204,
-0.18939849734306335,
0.5303025841712952,
0.38867032527923584,
0.38706329464912415,
0.5091320872306824,
0.678985059261322,
0.26653721928596497,
0.0799022763967514,
0.17766915261745453,
1.0027390718460083,
-0.48535725474357605,
-0.7478303909301758,
-0.41522860527038574,
0.21814917027950287,
-0.12403717637062073,
-0.18441423773765564,
0.8361892104148865,
0.5050656795501709,
0.9651044607162476,
-0.4210403561592102,
0.5315209031105042,
0.4686749577522278,
0.5575966835021973,
-0.9816431403160095,
0.7963932156562805,
-0.3018995225429535,
0.6608873605728149,
-0.14948731660842896,
-1.1269960403442383,
-0.4797174334526062,
1.0347223281860352,
-0.4397028684616089,
0.14775554835796356,
1.2635353803634644,
0.40146175026893616,
0.10093945264816284,
0.19760480523109436,
0.30334705114364624,
0.22524748742580414,
0.4382510483264923,
0.3120109438896179,
0.6947008371353149,
-0.42447736859321594,
0.3117244243621826,
-0.529420793056488,
-0.033460583537817,
0.10259328037500381,
-1.0247316360473633,
-1.1596596240997314,
-0.573327898979187,
-0.5577754974365234,
0.2313186526298523,
-0.063409723341465,
0.7404544949531555,
0.5020211338996887,
-0.9299929738044739,
-0.17398415505886078,
-0.1696118265390396,
-0.36149585247039795,
-0.2094176560640335,
-0.12838910520076752,
0.8436371088027954,
-0.3813744783401489,
-0.46292614936828613,
0.6641904711723328,
0.25742557644844055,
-0.038958217948675156,
-0.38453397154808044,
0.2932615876197815,
-0.22722558677196503,
0.002858347026631236,
1.0638545751571655,
-0.2542654871940613,
-0.38144242763519287,
-0.502656102180481,
-0.31651684641838074,
0.30703428387641907,
-0.07108767330646515,
1.2388429641723633,
-0.8240407109260559,
0.4755764603614807,
0.7294305562973022,
0.6963149309158325,
0.4033883512020111,
0.0757230594754219,
0.6268289089202881,
-1.3105286359786987,
0.36481791734695435,
0.05675232410430908,
0.41653865575790405,
0.3577186167240143,
-0.16075770556926727,
0.0495561920106411,
0.339684396982193,
-0.48882976174354553,
-0.665974497795105,
-0.18446838855743408,
-1.104454755783081,
-0.5138958692550659,
0.7777711153030396,
-0.43474671244621277,
-0.0696459636092186,
0.14447788894176483,
0.11141686141490936,
0.10367859899997711,
-0.028857972472906113,
0.6766502857208252,
0.560742199420929,
0.07415583729743958,
-0.25924915075302124,
-0.24733847379684448,
0.4732204079627991,
0.6599642038345337,
-0.9376193881034851,
0.1030893474817276,
0.6064032316207886,
-0.20481634140014648,
0.36315587162971497,
0.4455154836177826,
-0.02889213338494301,
-0.14910434186458588,
-0.22038748860359192,
0.11053622514009476,
-0.09995635598897934,
-0.5678659677505493,
-0.41016247868537903,
0.43703097105026245,
-0.1581389605998993,
-0.4007849097251892
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14725v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14725v2
|
Testing the Limits of Jailbreaking Defenses with the Purple Problem
| 2024-03-20T21:53:56 | 2024-06-24T05:01:06 |
Taeyoun Kim, Suhas Kotha, Aditi Raghunathan
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The rise of "jailbreak" attacks on language models has led to a flurry of
defenses aimed at preventing undesirable responses. We critically examine the
two stages of the defense pipeline: (i) defining what constitutes unsafe
outputs, and (ii) enforcing the definition via methods such as input processing
or fine-tuning. To test the efficacy of existing enforcement mechanisms, we
consider a simple and well-specified definition of unsafe outputs--outputs that
contain the word "purple". Surprisingly, existing fine-tuning and input
defenses fail on this simple problem, casting doubt on whether enforcement
algorithms can be robust for more complicated definitions. We find that real
safety benchmarks similarly test enforcement for a fixed definition. We hope
that future research can lead to effective/fast enforcement as well as high
quality definitions used for enforcement and evaluation.
|
[
-0.5753604769706726,
-1.051807165145874,
0.30917125940322876,
0.1497718095779419,
-0.27730196714401245,
0.19919328391551971,
0.043742671608924866,
-0.40824323892593384,
-0.19001561403274536,
0.5513004064559937,
-0.3678833246231079,
-0.07185275107622147,
-1.0209040641784668,
0.16604827344417572,
-0.654263973236084,
1.2281343936920166,
-0.12818604707717896,
-0.35956788063049316,
0.4512789249420166,
-0.22273854911327362,
-0.751329779624939,
-0.5162198543548584,
-0.2946854829788208,
0.05563870817422867,
0.5001159906387329,
0.6797470450401306,
0.7102189660072327,
0.9640882015228271,
0.6887458562850952,
0.2817753851413727,
0.0038002512883394957,
-0.2841210663318634,
-0.4669168293476105,
0.3260243237018585,
-0.1736479252576828,
-0.3439682722091675,
-0.020123668015003204,
0.1639515459537506,
0.3800837993621826,
0.40476325154304504,
0.10474672168493271,
-0.12151295691728592,
-0.059276033192873,
0.7241341471672058,
-1.258644700050354,
-0.20590011775493622,
-0.8825845718383789,
0.051532283425331116,
-0.4141099750995636,
0.09611572325229645,
-0.5571597814559937,
-0.4569680690765381,
-0.31459176540374756,
-0.1581413596868515,
-0.17319560050964355,
-0.15796317160129547,
1.048311471939087,
0.055480509996414185,
-0.931678056716919,
-0.3409220576286316,
-0.7284930944442749,
0.6296893358230591,
-0.3248254954814911,
0.2356625199317932,
0.5932597517967224,
0.426876962184906,
-0.06375566869974136,
-1.003934383392334,
-0.5451943278312683,
-0.3259618878364563,
0.11484719067811966,
0.09683471918106079,
-0.6798540353775024,
0.47636985778808594,
0.45919284224510193,
0.35169875621795654,
-0.22397571802139282,
-0.007941443473100662,
-1.0733312368392944,
-0.43202412128448486,
0.4746783673763275,
0.14307747781276703,
0.3970640301704407,
-0.2614024877548218,
-0.12870056927204132,
-0.1729685515165329,
-0.6714211106300354,
0.20438094437122345,
0.5942093133926392,
0.47763532400131226,
-0.21257297694683075,
0.6289636492729187,
-0.1838075816631317,
0.16904547810554504,
0.2500147223472595,
0.4004448652267456,
-0.09808804839849472,
-0.4595288932323456,
-0.2796022891998291,
0.04427001625299454,
0.8402522206306458,
0.5329737663269043,
0.5181378722190857,
-0.24133756756782532,
-0.07874919474124908,
0.46021419763565063,
0.6585292220115662,
-1.0736606121063232,
-0.47476762533187866,
0.4551694393157959,
-0.29771003127098083,
-0.8191635608673096,
0.08623720705509186,
-0.6235001087188721,
-0.9503615498542786,
0.34889376163482666,
0.2809279263019562,
-0.4176184833049774,
-0.15269650518894196,
-0.23077711462974548,
-0.34490805864334106,
0.02423863671720028,
-0.4779719114303589,
-1.168914556503296,
0.4369216859340668,
0.7634447813034058,
0.6857448816299438,
0.09661754220724106,
-0.12372632324695587,
-0.7773921489715576,
-0.06670211255550385,
-0.5993395447731018,
0.514610230922699,
-0.281629741191864,
-0.5411756634712219,
-0.1256003975868225,
0.26713696122169495,
0.3688376843929291,
-0.5960802435874939,
0.5851483345031738,
-0.5090821385383606,
-0.41334226727485657,
-0.20984198153018951,
-0.35195425152778625,
0.1397259682416916,
0.20018896460533142,
-0.4637230634689331,
0.5369613766670227,
0.26365357637405396,
-0.8054008483886719,
0.711988091468811,
-0.5168651342391968,
-0.6096247434616089,
-0.10628484189510345,
-0.08017610758543015,
-0.4876343905925751,
0.09088002145290375,
-0.2604230046272278,
0.09065105020999908,
0.24065496027469635,
0.006891608703881502,
-0.6743654012680054,
-0.2838420569896698,
0.17460928857326508,
-0.15282393991947174,
1.033690333366394,
0.5070908665657043,
-0.4290822446346283,
0.14413940906524658,
-0.8148652911186218,
0.09423031657934189,
0.10558422654867172,
-0.4278937876224518,
-0.27236178517341614,
0.08526730537414551,
-0.34264102578163147,
-0.03058781288564205,
-0.0044550360180437565,
-0.728752076625824,
0.044103801250457764,
-0.41089099645614624,
1.0425225496292114,
0.9694821834564209,
-0.0790526494383812,
0.7213063836097717,
0.1226421669125557,
0.6008288264274597,
0.10999313741922379,
0.34315934777259827,
-0.20581640303134918,
-0.1301080733537674,
-0.6560858488082886,
0.09543533623218536,
0.5692613124847412,
0.956092894077301,
-0.27332374453544617,
0.096111960709095,
0.40327197313308716,
-0.6284751296043396,
-0.09453380107879639,
0.02642337791621685,
0.4390646517276764,
0.2919495403766632,
0.17044976353645325,
-0.5657387971878052,
-0.8619276881217957,
-1.1347787380218506,
-0.549043595790863,
-0.22659941017627716,
0.11240612715482712,
0.10030180215835571,
0.59403395652771,
-0.28908342123031616,
0.5923560857772827,
-0.27574464678764343,
0.19588950276374817,
0.028530223295092583,
0.37355008721351624,
0.10919143259525299,
0.6309692859649658,
0.5780507326126099,
-0.5759313106536865,
-0.31418105959892273,
-0.0408218652009964,
-0.7165801525115967,
-0.14587031304836273,
0.2116011083126068,
0.14337961375713348,
-0.08401794731616974,
0.7614211440086365,
-0.34408384561538696,
0.5186708569526672,
0.3508574068546295,
-0.7733829617500305,
0.8983005881309509,
0.02258862368762493,
0.27837979793548584,
-0.4512758255004883,
-0.32615789771080017,
-0.2120564877986908,
-0.039531365036964417,
-0.8566965460777283,
0.621679425239563,
0.4439046084880829,
-0.20698964595794678,
-0.4663139581680298,
0.1578778326511383,
-0.12632432579994202,
0.3009476363658905,
-0.338576078414917,
-0.08635380864143372,
-0.18449313938617706,
0.05415933206677437,
-0.7751575112342834,
0.7357546091079712,
0.5841484069824219,
-0.7198651432991028,
0.49657630920410156,
-0.22445419430732727,
-0.13324669003486633,
0.5079554915428162,
-0.6862338781356812,
0.3810868263244629,
-0.009133187122642994,
-0.061598215252161026,
-1.1949427127838135,
-0.2742234468460083,
0.45076578855514526,
-0.3035499155521393,
0.09795238077640533,
-0.49402230978012085,
-0.3059181869029999,
-0.5289026498794556,
-0.4414074420928955,
0.37128201127052307,
0.5967177152633667,
-0.10190333425998688,
0.2929908037185669,
0.6218754649162292,
-0.16088011860847473,
-0.681365430355072,
-1.019324541091919,
0.22081534564495087,
-0.6057106852531433,
-0.4913713335990906,
0.2638247013092041,
0.10881143808364868,
-0.5647422075271606,
-0.3332199156284332,
-0.2259466052055359,
-0.5203869938850403,
0.6854437589645386,
0.4484694302082062,
-0.11401159316301346,
0.0023829073179513216,
-0.23155012726783752,
0.17106299102306366,
-0.09359867870807648,
0.5708494782447815,
-0.11718534678220749,
0.25332722067832947,
-0.28147274255752563,
-0.13243946433067322,
-0.15967197716236115,
0.42840006947517395,
0.6994174122810364,
-0.010093465447425842,
0.594961941242218,
0.12118376791477203,
-0.3692139983177185,
-0.13136491179466248,
-0.005136020947247744,
-0.4327436089515686,
-0.5655555129051208,
0.43995556235313416,
-0.39416635036468506,
-0.8529785871505737,
0.5200584530830383,
0.0499541200697422,
0.2324477583169937,
0.0958106741309166,
0.4346829056739807,
-0.24194319546222687,
1.0535553693771362,
0.7994470596313477,
0.2016088217496872,
0.4469950497150421,
0.03607447072863579,
0.640116810798645,
-0.3573535084724426,
0.16112937033176422,
-0.7002272009849548,
-0.3493967056274414,
-1.0150926113128662,
0.08319033682346344,
0.005798169877380133,
0.782759964466095,
-0.5542098879814148,
0.7630043029785156,
-0.45565181970596313,
0.6754220724105835,
0.6101045608520508,
0.09254763275384903,
0.11622960865497589,
-0.3774973750114441,
-0.2593080997467041,
-0.1886875480413437,
-0.3284229636192322,
-0.5442792177200317,
1.2078512907028198,
0.477006733417511,
0.3407919108867645,
0.19319245219230652,
0.45157590508461,
0.457955002784729,
0.17753244936466217,
-0.6174299716949463,
0.4793878197669983,
-0.30615028738975525,
-0.7810232043266296,
-0.14223507046699524,
-0.22129832208156586,
-0.9560255408287048,
0.1349237859249115,
-0.17808541655540466,
-1.0110499858856201,
0.18959176540374756,
0.6191233396530151,
-0.34881868958473206,
0.10686099529266357,
-0.9466376304626465,
1.0930982828140259,
-0.3107394874095917,
-0.44715797901153564,
-0.2747863233089447,
-0.4041702449321747,
0.8035487532615662,
0.03752424940466881,
0.29173967242240906,
0.012150846421718597,
0.27204954624176025,
0.6373270750045776,
-0.6656458973884583,
0.5731936097145081,
-0.1404045671224594,
0.02802836149930954,
0.35311436653137207,
0.46801668405532837,
0.4138796329498291,
0.013046834617853165,
0.3856593668460846,
-0.21661688387393951,
0.3702714145183563,
-0.46374213695526123,
-0.4843607246875763,
0.2068902552127838,
-0.36195892095565796,
-0.672569215297699,
-0.3062281012535095,
-0.5366178750991821,
-0.2552271783351898,
0.49424928426742554,
0.5763823986053467,
0.20452168583869934,
-0.06997483223676682,
0.15026968717575073,
0.6892556548118591,
-0.22411826252937317,
0.18367493152618408,
0.4456517696380615,
-0.3579660952091217,
-0.2660875618457794,
0.9479941725730896,
0.30544808506965637,
0.19319669902324677,
-0.30000945925712585,
0.4005560576915741,
-0.09107198566198349,
-1.023412823677063,
-0.3414989411830902,
-0.2157699018716812,
-0.6052654385566711,
-0.05102182924747467,
-0.35956838726997375,
-0.27320513129234314,
-0.6413843631744385,
-0.03194915130734444,
-0.34354478120803833,
-0.6206874847412109,
0.23057644069194794,
-0.23628896474838257,
0.28404974937438965,
0.6449341177940369,
-0.45035725831985474,
0.012397089041769505,
-0.683476448059082,
0.47888877987861633,
0.6139315962791443,
0.43907204270362854,
-0.31773510575294495,
-0.597883939743042,
-0.16569815576076508,
0.006334090139716864,
-0.913032054901123,
-1.2510489225387573,
-0.0991772785782814,
-0.17989017069339752,
0.02796766348183155,
0.7242342233657837,
0.34927481412887573,
0.3496910333633423,
-0.5549612641334534,
0.530572235584259,
0.14321984350681305,
-0.8793243765830994,
0.8398394584655762,
-0.6784483790397644,
0.1536012589931488,
0.686870276927948,
0.08726761490106583,
-0.44998523592948914,
-0.809734046459198,
-0.5586984157562256,
-0.9642965197563171,
0.2852456867694855,
0.37963247299194336,
0.33099713921546936,
-0.17716674506664276,
0.15444272756576538,
-0.3873291313648224,
0.18334682285785675,
-0.6864582300186157,
-0.24490442872047424,
-0.2266334593296051,
0.30715659260749817,
0.4875951409339905,
-0.39666110277175903,
-0.3576302230358124,
-0.13210442662239075,
0.3842456340789795,
0.30676451325416565,
-0.04196858033537865,
-0.2521049976348877,
-0.11135834455490112,
0.07118157297372818,
0.5809720158576965,
0.5160528421401978,
0.4329110383987427,
-0.037714507430791855,
0.10814302414655685,
0.11766141653060913,
-0.7263344526290894,
0.3553363084793091,
-0.002801406430080533,
-0.43072083592414856,
-0.47457581758499146,
0.18941055238246918,
0.5737724304199219,
-0.16627755761146545,
-0.8174794316291809,
0.3550868630409241,
-0.2128651887178421,
-0.2395726591348648,
-0.08909515291452408,
0.43013235926628113,
-0.210571750998497,
0.11166523396968842,
0.01741207204759121,
0.040486495941877365,
0.2716611921787262,
-0.8126832842826843,
0.5059270858764648,
0.5729932188987732,
-0.625272274017334,
-0.03938278928399086,
0.6583502888679504,
0.22540342807769775,
-0.5072922706604004,
0.8370257019996643,
-0.41441914439201355,
-0.5875377058982849,
1.0492684841156006,
0.369365930557251,
0.7972697615623474,
0.09620366990566254,
-0.20476457476615906,
0.27885887026786804,
0.7194026708602905,
0.3022393584251404,
0.33983319997787476,
-0.057933758944272995,
-0.7950776815414429,
-0.269693523645401,
-0.22742407023906708,
-0.3705882728099823,
0.24565470218658447,
-0.7683579325675964,
0.2579270005226135,
-1.0138765573501587,
-0.3100906312465668,
0.045109495520591736,
-0.29149481654167175,
-0.057292480021715164,
0.11421925574541092,
0.11114972829818726,
1.2499195337295532,
-0.8177531361579895,
0.43984073400497437,
0.5487819910049438,
-0.26697367429733276,
-0.682921290397644,
-0.22705864906311035,
0.37118181586265564,
-0.33739596605300903,
0.6625704169273376,
0.2534477412700653,
-0.1115202084183693,
-0.36537739634513855,
-0.5529778599739075,
-0.37051016092300415,
0.3823258578777313,
0.4775742292404175,
-0.7016233801841736,
0.05122273787856102,
0.17925070226192474,
0.2977149784564972,
0.21466004848480225,
-0.051150109618902206,
1.2153078317642212,
0.6144375205039978,
-0.7270281314849854,
-0.823354959487915,
-0.08829978108406067,
-0.3795173466205597,
-0.38235563039779663,
0.6245044469833374,
-0.5166379809379578,
0.8031299114227295,
-0.42231249809265137,
-0.5053152441978455,
0.10001669079065323,
0.6357248425483704,
0.5347602367401123,
0.3382212519645691,
0.5908629298210144,
0.879995584487915,
0.5932076573371887,
-0.5255504250526428,
1.1050100326538086,
-0.25512397289276123,
0.14286524057388306,
0.8308857679367065,
0.09462399035692215,
0.6132749915122986,
0.578095018863678,
-0.318283349275589,
0.38055217266082764,
0.5855535268783569,
-0.23259058594703674,
0.7863000631332397,
0.7449555993080139,
-0.03722929581999779,
0.017399083822965622,
-0.04313403740525246,
-0.22687651216983795,
0.6341849565505981,
0.12737765908241272,
-0.28208738565444946,
-0.09309318661689758,
0.2302124947309494,
0.37874582409858704,
0.2991037368774414,
-0.4660165309906006,
0.5761498212814331,
0.09792419523000717,
-0.6168000102043152,
0.6529884934425354,
0.2775823771953583,
0.5087902545928955,
-0.5392089486122131,
0.017848217859864235,
-0.3019363582134247,
0.4475693106651306,
-0.22425846755504608,
-0.811367392539978,
0.5955597162246704,
0.4059782922267914,
-0.2944447994232178,
-0.12769052386283875,
0.6069090366363525,
0.11441068351268768,
-0.28545600175857544,
0.35580670833587646,
-0.11405976116657257,
-0.049738604575395584,
0.048849958926439285,
-0.6634382605552673,
0.22240111231803894,
-0.2543219029903412,
-0.04555700719356537,
0.38030362129211426,
0.29632583260536194,
-0.09031710773706436,
0.5877593755722046,
0.2841135859489441,
0.26238390803337097,
0.422397255897522,
-0.1754433810710907,
0.6428378224372864,
-0.585732638835907,
-0.8228036165237427,
-1.1449368000030518,
0.5600408315658569,
-0.009207373484969139,
-0.4362022876739502,
0.8599751591682434,
0.27035748958587646,
0.8543813228607178,
0.35992470383644104,
1.0001555681228638,
-0.33868059515953064,
0.17193207144737244,
-0.39112019538879395,
0.7842831015586853,
-0.07426232844591141,
0.03162813186645508,
-0.44195955991744995,
-0.43301740288734436,
0.05105489492416382,
0.49300616979599,
0.033954210579395294,
-0.07099870592355728,
0.8542223572731018,
0.7196663618087769,
-0.13420969247817993,
0.06167414411902428,
0.016406333073973656,
0.7210027575492859,
0.17147968709468842,
0.8149692416191101,
1.0621360540390015,
-0.6599178910255432,
1.01093327999115,
-0.743217945098877,
-0.3314798176288605,
0.24211308360099792,
-1.0330626964569092,
-0.7406362295150757,
-0.3343629837036133,
-0.25116539001464844,
-1.0461314916610718,
0.4834049642086029,
0.10163399577140808,
0.8989690542221069,
-1.3171665668487549,
-0.28331631422042847,
-0.5708988308906555,
0.1318463236093521,
-0.4044382870197296,
-0.2214590609073639,
-0.10502476990222931,
-0.17467288672924042,
-0.3440586030483246,
0.3866237699985504,
0.2854768633842468,
-0.20352214574813843,
-0.18054111301898956,
0.03785932809114456,
0.229511559009552,
0.15939217805862427,
0.37152937054634094,
0.6445499062538147,
-0.47847428917884827,
-0.5257817506790161,
-0.35377806425094604,
-0.1158159151673317,
-0.15395483374595642,
0.9945929646492004,
-0.5942248702049255,
0.45361289381980896,
0.43317633867263794,
0.8652191758155823,
0.01792748272418976,
-0.126382976770401,
0.827451229095459,
-0.45634931325912476,
0.18527363240718842,
0.2523749768733978,
0.29929104447364807,
-0.12083417922258377,
-0.08845242112874985,
0.28280699253082275,
0.24551382660865784,
-0.5560935139656067,
-1.2980921268463135,
0.9196172952651978,
-0.4067976772785187,
-0.5282134413719177,
0.6446968913078308,
-0.09505576640367508,
0.10728423297405243,
-0.338640034198761,
0.06600034236907959,
0.24057002365589142,
-0.2586011588573456,
1.2551242113113403,
1.007275938987732,
-0.035901837050914764,
-0.32766193151474,
-0.6432161927223206,
0.5748809576034546,
0.19509141147136688,
-0.7512920498847961,
0.42159080505371094,
0.25080084800720215,
0.24888336658477783,
0.2266596108675003,
0.3407823443412781,
-0.1936803013086319,
0.906673014163971,
0.03931121155619621,
-0.5764451026916504,
-0.12369000166654587,
-0.3525504767894745,
-0.494536429643631,
0.466596394777298,
0.10335180163383484,
-0.17781879007816315
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15478v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15478v1
|
Integrating Supervised Extractive and Generative Language Models for Suicide Risk Evidence Summarization
| 2024-03-20T21:16:10 | 2024-03-20T21:16:10 |
Rika Tanaka, Yusuke Fukazawa
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We propose a method that integrates supervised extractive and generative
language models for providing supporting evidence of suicide risk in the
CLPsych 2024 shared task. Our approach comprises three steps. Initially, we
construct a BERT-based model for estimating sentence-level suicide risk and
negative sentiment. Next, we precisely identify high suicide risk sentences by
emphasizing elevated probabilities of both suicide risk and negative sentiment.
Finally, we integrate generative summaries using the MentaLLaMa framework and
extractive summaries from identified high suicide risk sentences and a
specialized dictionary of suicidal risk words. SophiaADS, our team, achieved
1st place for highlight extraction and ranked 10th for summary generation, both
based on recall and consistency metrics, respectively.
|
[
-0.3753107190132141,
-0.7504745721817017,
0.8791716694831848,
0.4045623540878296,
-0.014003802090883255,
-0.3836350440979004,
-0.11513538658618927,
-0.3989371955394745,
0.2759263515472412,
0.4085307717323303,
-0.66657954454422,
-0.8890723586082458,
-0.8097155094146729,
0.17189669609069824,
-0.45954370498657227,
1.3071192502975464,
0.21912093460559845,
0.04888814315199852,
-0.11482419073581696,
0.18242581188678741,
-0.42499157786369324,
-0.4979138970375061,
-0.5620731711387634,
0.059750739485025406,
0.6848254799842834,
0.3820149898529053,
0.5819705128669739,
0.019351162016391754,
0.48780420422554016,
0.1888420432806015,
-0.03349406644701958,
-0.2552209496498108,
-0.37601032853126526,
-0.01138402707874775,
-0.09277476370334625,
-0.36424970626831055,
-0.7907075881958008,
0.26032671332359314,
0.24162450432777405,
0.5301358699798584,
-0.30089133977890015,
0.06788311153650284,
0.14496168494224548,
0.46435075998306274,
-0.7345280647277832,
0.15151910483837128,
-0.4147305190563202,
0.07372427731752396,
-0.2259320467710495,
0.0017907508881762624,
-0.5608759522438049,
-0.659482479095459,
0.331643283367157,
-0.45862653851509094,
0.2981073558330536,
-0.5117353796958923,
0.6217489242553711,
0.14500348269939423,
-0.47565603256225586,
-0.5927876234054565,
-0.46865564584732056,
0.9236106872558594,
-0.9570960998535156,
-0.013947095721960068,
0.28407061100006104,
0.12575329840183258,
0.03735695034265518,
-0.7148001790046692,
-0.35213321447372437,
0.0730663388967514,
-0.21952998638153076,
0.49127641320228577,
-0.1681307703256607,
0.3720993995666504,
0.13383030891418457,
0.40296661853790283,
-0.5508451461791992,
0.15923503041267395,
-0.607735276222229,
-0.3767251968383789,
1.0353469848632812,
0.2736087441444397,
0.5272694230079651,
-0.5316692590713501,
-0.40152689814567566,
0.09566134959459305,
-0.6424794793128967,
-0.11052736639976501,
0.41603678464889526,
0.2945820689201355,
-0.26453104615211487,
0.5990431904792786,
-0.2404053509235382,
0.5210842490196228,
-0.21626624464988708,
-0.16823746263980865,
0.44120514392852783,
-0.4279630184173584,
-0.03752739354968071,
0.14933866262435913,
1.1101596355438232,
0.790376603603363,
0.029775764793157578,
0.025604423135519028,
0.08705886453390121,
-0.08283635973930359,
0.3433210551738739,
-0.7640190124511719,
-0.4624044597148895,
0.5445645451545715,
-0.7410834431648254,
-0.4800163805484772,
-0.13167457282543182,
-1.259089708328247,
-0.35425683856010437,
-0.05833429470658302,
0.5668041110038757,
-0.546623945236206,
-0.21287532150745392,
0.08396746218204498,
-0.5309213399887085,
0.018871864303946495,
0.4527582824230194,
-0.6281388998031616,
0.1259184032678604,
0.6401259899139404,
0.9816462397575378,
-0.46634209156036377,
-0.10675995796918869,
-0.29131370782852173,
0.16843871772289276,
0.04184802621603012,
0.9249430298805237,
-0.12576600909233093,
-0.3969678282737732,
0.3127875030040741,
0.039210256189107895,
0.07312656193971634,
-0.3232977092266083,
0.952206552028656,
-0.15121184289455414,
0.6725925207138062,
-0.4743230640888214,
-0.7961737513542175,
-0.46548914909362793,
0.04835059121251106,
-0.7882590889930725,
0.8128622770309448,
0.049073271453380585,
-1.1021703481674194,
0.38903310894966125,
-0.7022044658660889,
-0.5338603258132935,
0.2808678448200226,
0.018811259418725967,
-0.5588982701301575,
-0.02165827713906765,
0.3698975741863251,
0.95270174741745,
0.1377943754196167,
0.37990349531173706,
-0.45008429884910583,
-0.11034274846315384,
0.04023411124944687,
-0.2863122224807739,
1.3327586650848389,
0.1818217933177948,
-0.021436277776956558,
0.1841001808643341,
-0.6556257009506226,
-0.05609701946377754,
0.019300173968076706,
-0.3944167196750641,
-0.4400462210178375,
0.1286630928516388,
0.4401493966579437,
0.37519195675849915,
0.6244930624961853,
-0.672939658164978,
-0.009910151362419128,
-0.30171144008636475,
0.19349044561386108,
0.4291827380657196,
0.6730950474739075,
0.24964411556720734,
-0.17199084162712097,
0.5749022364616394,
-0.21530722081661224,
0.38396841287612915,
0.07369552552700043,
-0.6478103995323181,
-0.3187454044818878,
-0.7989681959152222,
-0.11805036664009094,
0.7742023468017578,
-0.27203571796417236,
0.7355525493621826,
0.035126253962516785,
-0.48647284507751465,
-0.22931015491485596,
-0.0196632519364357,
0.19977359473705292,
0.488351047039032,
0.5375416278839111,
-0.11959131062030792,
-0.9867497682571411,
-1.0226881504058838,
-0.027089152485132217,
-0.181110218167305,
-0.05551634728908539,
-0.31514972448349,
0.4139701724052429,
-0.08799697458744049,
0.9222739338874817,
-0.915202260017395,
-0.37800440192222595,
-0.765956461429596,
0.5256077647209167,
0.4858228862285614,
0.34803053736686707,
0.5470536947250366,
-0.8027557730674744,
-0.48440465331077576,
-0.40253618359565735,
-1.149088740348816,
-0.24058036506175995,
-0.19071312248706818,
-0.08549603819847107,
-0.19939470291137695,
0.51759934425354,
-0.773366391658783,
0.5844844579696655,
0.3658283054828644,
0.04448920860886574,
0.7502939105033875,
-0.09024946391582489,
-0.020465446636080742,
-1.4100964069366455,
0.017160484567284584,
-0.08106037229299545,
-0.19928047060966492,
-0.908254086971283,
-0.12836062908172607,
-0.03340943157672882,
-0.027321279048919678,
-0.33700403571128845,
0.026940088719129562,
-0.2759632468223572,
-0.026423797011375427,
-0.3956426680088043,
0.16709661483764648,
-0.1217852234840393,
0.34829649329185486,
0.1699075549840927,
0.5907062888145447,
0.45181748270988464,
-0.3465127646923065,
0.15765784680843353,
0.41649290919303894,
-0.12734438478946686,
0.48709845542907715,
-0.6279594302177429,
-0.6320526599884033,
-0.2200143039226532,
0.32406309247016907,
-0.8228335976600647,
-0.4525998532772064,
0.021225526928901672,
-0.246299609541893,
-0.018706856295466423,
0.22394056618213654,
-0.38091880083084106,
-0.3373644948005676,
-0.5170531868934631,
0.08353588730096817,
0.5586844086647034,
0.03477924317121506,
0.5814630389213562,
0.6041661500930786,
-0.889876663684845,
-0.46380606293678284,
-0.443549782037735,
0.2815403640270233,
-0.605340301990509,
-0.200211301445961,
0.4372002184391022,
-0.17494286596775055,
-0.17719730734825134,
-0.13997231423854828,
0.3730365037918091,
-0.004430865403264761,
0.2893597185611725,
0.5420873761177063,
0.28079962730407715,
0.09677720069885254,
0.0074096848256886005,
0.27745676040649414,
-0.07197363674640656,
0.31258946657180786,
0.25850504636764526,
0.5649551153182983,
-0.05473586171865463,
-0.0410693921148777,
-0.6999728679656982,
0.9521353840827942,
0.3148346543312073,
-0.013127204030752182,
0.8793891668319702,
0.550353467464447,
-0.514237642288208,
-0.052491914480924606,
-0.39368388056755066,
0.021514078602194786,
-0.34244799613952637,
0.4858343303203583,
0.23348116874694824,
-0.840462327003479,
0.6166290640830994,
-0.0526650995016098,
0.1520141214132309,
0.6709462404251099,
0.9349198937416077,
-0.488770067691803,
1.0532281398773193,
0.8994065523147583,
-0.06112700700759888,
0.4989268481731415,
-0.20584838092327118,
0.22376927733421326,
-0.5940572023391724,
-0.040593817830085754,
-0.24027834832668304,
0.11689666658639908,
-0.32335197925567627,
-0.023738954216241837,
0.8628401160240173,
0.46542710065841675,
0.007927999831736088,
0.6797662377357483,
-0.3942539393901825,
0.17022351920604706,
0.5195077061653137,
0.17943133413791656,
0.3317940831184387,
-0.20765969157218933,
0.22444018721580505,
-0.11406221240758896,
-0.33212465047836304,
-0.5446416139602661,
1.114698052406311,
0.24773620069026947,
0.1933521330356598,
0.19150963425636292,
1.1306248903274536,
0.48070138692855835,
0.6351049542427063,
-0.4716747999191284,
0.6730514168739319,
-0.22051510214805603,
-0.81697678565979,
-0.3150184452533722,
-0.10597318410873413,
-0.5582185983657837,
0.030053840950131416,
-0.05372930318117142,
-1.0272942781448364,
0.17301346361637115,
-0.05169171094894409,
-0.5356313586235046,
-0.33079588413238525,
-0.5732438564300537,
0.6867381930351257,
-0.03620714321732521,
0.28045397996902466,
-0.47444695234298706,
-0.8138406872749329,
0.7824742794036865,
-0.17660588026046753,
0.3548547327518463,
-0.15975767374038696,
0.22003410756587982,
0.9659415483474731,
-0.42795947194099426,
1.0769412517547607,
-0.3101019859313965,
-0.39814674854278564,
0.3834831118583679,
-0.12858279049396515,
0.35139840841293335,
0.07127635926008224,
-0.22596050798892975,
0.0703718289732933,
0.04250514134764671,
-0.41714897751808167,
-0.34972521662712097,
0.2934104800224304,
-0.5772392749786377,
-0.36215728521347046,
-0.3062162697315216,
-0.8498043417930603,
-0.057829950004816055,
0.29182732105255127,
0.5819445848464966,
0.2577877938747406,
-0.47837409377098083,
-0.22689127922058105,
0.4431071877479553,
-0.370542049407959,
0.5887985229492188,
0.2786790430545807,
-0.18001653254032135,
-0.9075996279716492,
0.8310655355453491,
0.027819296345114708,
0.385395884513855,
0.39782097935676575,
0.18475671112537384,
-0.1253644824028015,
-0.7064809799194336,
0.06714781373739243,
0.25014936923980713,
-0.8876767754554749,
-0.23491446673870087,
-1.0614087581634521,
-0.3908989131450653,
-0.6220605373382568,
-0.37181153893470764,
-0.15519440174102783,
-0.40799275040626526,
-0.3135169446468353,
-0.5834817290306091,
0.5074594616889954,
0.7890429496765137,
-0.492450475692749,
0.4520503580570221,
-1.0675240755081177,
0.19634802639484406,
0.010202772915363312,
-0.4666067659854889,
-0.04264326021075249,
-0.18013152480125427,
-0.36914658546447754,
-0.2467668056488037,
-0.3683953583240509,
-1.2171413898468018,
0.5651831030845642,
0.26014938950538635,
0.5380985140800476,
0.7797350883483887,
0.1926947981119156,
0.6439765691757202,
-0.3123932480812073,
1.0634914636611938,
0.4009362757205963,
-0.8587813973426819,
0.804789662361145,
-0.6431869864463806,
0.0448877327144146,
0.8304757475852966,
0.8691431879997253,
-0.4512873589992523,
-0.5601555109024048,
-0.5958476066589355,
-0.832796573638916,
0.44549360871315,
0.2517600953578949,
-0.2085903435945511,
-0.17966614663600922,
0.1435580849647522,
0.3532812297344208,
0.10386918485164642,
-0.7459649443626404,
-0.05438080430030823,
-0.14276495575904846,
-0.7039778232574463,
0.019400257617235184,
-0.47488877177238464,
-0.4186384081840515,
-0.16386650502681732,
0.6929989457130432,
-0.0879531055688858,
0.2949649691581726,
0.06739092618227005,
-0.017811110243201256,
0.1393224447965622,
0.14689208567142487,
0.483866423368454,
0.39231470227241516,
-0.47960129380226135,
0.09369450062513351,
0.26013341546058655,
-0.5053550004959106,
-0.05854426696896553,
0.3081150949001312,
-0.3333231210708618,
-0.09853173792362213,
1.1118931770324707,
0.3950507342815399,
0.061940182000398636,
-0.8535929322242737,
0.9523367285728455,
-0.14868631958961487,
-0.35581183433532715,
-0.6226872205734253,
-0.06823385506868362,
0.14710542559623718,
0.20936109125614166,
0.30083411931991577,
-0.014158702455461025,
0.6654430031776428,
-0.3126940429210663,
0.4884858727455139,
0.39419469237327576,
-0.3500615656375885,
-0.6747799515724182,
0.323090136051178,
0.033572763204574585,
0.18991461396217346,
0.34861865639686584,
-0.05234131962060928,
-0.6696217656135559,
0.4379906952381134,
0.32891249656677246,
1.1187150478363037,
-0.094137042760849,
0.6598974466323853,
0.553995668888092,
0.0033912109211087227,
-0.11879683285951614,
0.6661391258239746,
-0.009847288019955158,
-0.4810183048248291,
-0.4667791426181793,
-0.7300816774368286,
-0.12995705008506775,
-0.06064821034669876,
-1.0589126348495483,
0.21699614822864532,
-0.1659086048603058,
0.04482901468873024,
0.03703024610877037,
-0.19319668412208557,
-0.1663079708814621,
0.22022829949855804,
0.24326148629188538,
0.6903113722801208,
-1.2465063333511353,
0.4356324374675751,
0.31182751059532166,
-0.6202030181884766,
-0.5841476917266846,
0.105705127120018,
0.1292518526315689,
-0.40605461597442627,
0.6821959614753723,
0.43169867992401123,
0.23653918504714966,
-0.13568119704723358,
-0.7167738080024719,
-0.8980676531791687,
1.1015992164611816,
0.18387596309185028,
-0.2263070046901703,
-0.3647327721118927,
0.0488162524998188,
0.6674782633781433,
-0.2975866496562958,
0.09292670339345932,
0.3649272322654724,
0.2897825539112091,
-0.08502154797315598,
-0.5772337913513184,
0.0037506993394345045,
0.004281309433281422,
-0.33531972765922546,
0.08232017606496811,
-0.3441011607646942,
0.885267436504364,
-0.1722731739282608,
-0.5527346730232239,
0.2633759379386902,
0.96824049949646,
0.15886357426643372,
0.2438596785068512,
0.3582971692085266,
0.835014820098877,
0.637676477432251,
0.3057861924171448,
0.8656848073005676,
-0.08111975342035294,
0.5015957951545715,
1.2346858978271484,
-0.3424868881702423,
0.9840307235717773,
0.3638264238834381,
-0.22709020972251892,
0.6663163900375366,
0.511170506477356,
0.18547804653644562,
0.8437451720237732,
-0.15597856044769287,
-0.49363115429878235,
-0.36717095971107483,
-0.140538290143013,
-0.002456619404256344,
0.3083212971687317,
0.6806639432907104,
-0.4854940176010132,
-0.5631206035614014,
0.3643868863582611,
0.18937049806118011,
0.013466733507812023,
-0.016408633440732956,
0.9710574746131897,
0.21027344465255737,
-0.7230569124221802,
0.2374563217163086,
-0.18405303359031677,
0.42466941475868225,
-0.37090083956718445,
-0.19017380475997925,
0.1127239465713501,
0.2161259949207306,
-0.25719329714775085,
-0.9137560725212097,
0.592722475528717,
0.09052036702632904,
-0.3347579538822174,
-0.200986847281456,
0.5394129753112793,
-0.5101245045661926,
-0.6177487969398499,
0.2809820771217346,
0.37068670988082886,
0.21784676611423492,
-0.044143881648778915,
-0.5439956784248352,
-0.23229855298995972,
-0.036866359412670135,
-0.0719398707151413,
0.393916517496109,
0.3158397674560547,
0.010498803108930588,
0.4544999301433563,
0.541939377784729,
0.30952727794647217,
-0.03510494530200958,
0.07132964581251144,
0.7664666175842285,
-0.5747981071472168,
-0.43050941824913025,
-0.917748749256134,
0.5924023985862732,
-0.33516502380371094,
-0.2630266547203064,
0.9320483803749084,
0.5793541669845581,
0.3546120226383209,
-0.16142377257347107,
1.012976050376892,
-0.5620293617248535,
0.6370717883110046,
-0.4710535705089569,
0.7978074550628662,
-0.31462907791137695,
-0.15047280490398407,
-0.4712810814380646,
-0.6557434797286987,
-0.33549872040748596,
0.2831173837184906,
-0.3587423264980316,
-0.42954012751579285,
0.6879881620407104,
0.6363177299499512,
0.31288930773735046,
0.09836315363645554,
0.06167079880833626,
0.2556309103965759,
0.6352753639221191,
0.6285815834999084,
0.6052671074867249,
-0.4721613824367523,
0.2798748314380646,
-0.2926287055015564,
-0.4067774713039398,
-0.20042264461517334,
-1.011649250984192,
-0.891484260559082,
-0.9164852499961853,
-0.40732908248901367,
-0.14972740411758423,
-0.12716089189052582,
0.5794994831085205,
0.3446987271308899,
-1.0016975402832031,
0.011940719559788704,
-0.40250781178474426,
-0.14094220101833344,
-0.3790012300014496,
-0.35653945803642273,
0.654262900352478,
-0.24560818076133728,
-0.5659450888633728,
0.32194334268569946,
0.36828404664993286,
-0.12226537615060806,
-0.3029382526874542,
0.156145378947258,
-0.454447478055954,
-0.2515287697315216,
0.5741739869117737,
-0.005120056681334972,
-0.6780633330345154,
-0.32621583342552185,
-0.47606146335601807,
-0.18508216738700867,
-0.3393305540084839,
0.6216405034065247,
-0.5521942377090454,
0.07667769491672516,
0.7534422278404236,
0.3332468271255493,
0.15755559504032135,
0.1955520510673523,
0.906605064868927,
-0.5828589797019958,
-0.09819772839546204,
0.26176193356513977,
0.32913491129875183,
0.25102657079696655,
-0.7041460871696472,
0.3684478998184204,
0.15568363666534424,
-0.6136250495910645,
-0.8336387276649475,
0.24940742552280426,
-1.1898560523986816,
-0.18690147995948792,
0.7223497033119202,
-0.4502365291118622,
-0.07530198991298676,
-0.19108694791793823,
-0.29587528109550476,
0.3766208589076996,
-0.299272358417511,
0.7742477059364319,
0.6522213220596313,
-0.3241136074066162,
-0.20654232800006866,
-0.6808277368545532,
0.636668860912323,
0.2209482640028,
-1.0199790000915527,
0.23907238245010376,
0.45630645751953125,
0.20880606770515442,
0.34619390964508057,
0.576292097568512,
-0.14960834383964539,
0.34934917092323303,
-0.3216678202152252,
0.4833123981952667,
0.28872549533843994,
-0.23890763521194458,
-0.2951664924621582,
0.5056086778640747,
-0.45774877071380615,
0.1988178938627243
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00027v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00027v3
|
LLMs as Writing Assistants: Exploring Perspectives on Sense of Ownership and Reasoning
| 2024-03-20T21:06:42 | 2024-04-22T08:30:30 |
Azmine Toushik Wasi, Mst Rafia Islam, Raima Islam
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
Sense of ownership in writing confines our investment of thoughts, time, and
contribution, leading to attachment to the output. However, using writing
assistants introduces a mental dilemma, as some content isn't directly our
creation. For instance, we tend to credit Large Language Models (LLMs) more in
creative tasks, even though all tasks are equal for them. Additionally, while
we may not claim complete ownership of LLM-generated content, we freely claim
authorship. We conduct a short survey to examine these issues and understand
underlying cognitive processes in order to gain a better knowledge of
human-computer interaction in writing and improve writing aid systems.
|
[
-0.1747535616159439,
-0.5683226585388184,
1.24459969997406,
0.0810193419456482,
0.07772176712751389,
0.06882638484239578,
-0.20550328493118286,
-0.7372909784317017,
0.2877315878868103,
0.6507038474082947,
-0.5520627498626709,
0.049007315188646317,
-1.0375677347183228,
0.41627031564712524,
-0.11099861562252045,
0.8018202781677246,
-0.379301518201828,
-0.008634370751678944,
-0.8960233330726624,
0.10412576794624329,
-0.4531000256538391,
-0.5532707571983337,
-0.9717431664466858,
-0.16936765611171722,
0.6639438271522522,
0.4691634178161621,
0.40755078196525574,
0.4668785035610199,
0.6867764592170715,
0.3953325152397156,
0.1858157217502594,
0.024831498041749,
-0.15636786818504333,
0.08521712571382523,
-0.22010132670402527,
-0.5948368310928345,
-0.6928589940071106,
0.15966790914535522,
0.36639291048049927,
0.6938588619232178,
-0.061187565326690674,
0.12243588268756866,
0.04959948733448982,
0.6058928370475769,
-0.7739689946174622,
-0.1292557418346405,
-0.4753802716732025,
0.1098405197262764,
0.040914908051490784,
-0.33479005098342896,
-0.45097970962524414,
-0.5266221761703491,
0.2517043352127075,
-0.870794415473938,
-0.030697345733642578,
0.1970432698726654,
0.6645932197570801,
0.3694523870944977,
-0.4516105353832245,
-0.7797666192054749,
-0.7239479422569275,
0.8123258352279663,
-0.7029708027839661,
0.08659865707159042,
0.643238365650177,
-0.14259067177772522,
-0.07970023155212402,
-0.5155487656593323,
-0.9351896047592163,
-0.23026089370250702,
-0.008884778246283531,
0.1727483570575714,
-0.18718183040618896,
0.09076793491840363,
0.3315802216529846,
0.3748255968093872,
-0.1967165321111679,
0.2540508508682251,
-0.3679961562156677,
-0.18300557136535645,
0.7777764797210693,
0.28969940543174744,
0.7341042757034302,
-0.02470935881137848,
-0.37338942289352417,
0.15710805356502533,
-0.6437588334083557,
0.13029955327510834,
0.5930832028388977,
-0.10880797356367111,
0.13147100806236267,
1.0071380138397217,
0.28902119398117065,
0.6707431674003601,
-0.06805682182312012,
-0.38966548442840576,
-0.22297702729701996,
-0.1558433473110199,
-0.49050578474998474,
0.053582482039928436,
0.7322096228599548,
0.529186487197876,
0.7392045259475708,
-0.19114816188812256,
-0.11589325219392776,
-0.03805708512663841,
0.4380840063095093,
-0.21812546253204346,
0.21388261020183563,
0.09415660798549652,
-0.2275938093662262,
-0.19867786765098572,
0.28214970231056213,
-0.09225117415189743,
-0.8827133774757385,
-0.7666025161743164,
0.5478107333183289,
-0.20566308498382568,
-0.2964300811290741,
0.034999147057533264,
-0.538733720779419,
0.3816322982311249,
0.6274914741516113,
-0.9877855181694031,
0.4606586694717407,
0.4811455309391022,
0.5623136162757874,
-0.6270260214805603,
-0.6659893989562988,
-0.15763181447982788,
0.4691520631313324,
-0.38040605187416077,
0.7715111374855042,
-0.282747358083725,
-0.7661300897598267,
-0.026449386030435562,
0.04624692723155022,
-0.2948904037475586,
-0.5417987108230591,
0.1601879596710205,
-0.2765215039253235,
0.33609047532081604,
-0.523303210735321,
-0.7331857085227966,
0.36129170656204224,
0.019023723900318146,
-0.5822440981864929,
0.799308180809021,
0.10170796513557434,
-0.46821242570877075,
0.5035684108734131,
-0.6676236391067505,
-0.5214031934738159,
-0.23933200538158417,
-0.1947060227394104,
0.10536632686853409,
0.3515217900276184,
-0.044234748929739,
0.6629367470741272,
-0.18849411606788635,
0.21207460761070251,
-0.11834497004747391,
-0.12922637164592743,
0.9498920440673828,
-0.11088800430297852,
0.7956425547599792,
0.10565759241580963,
-0.061318330466747284,
0.012828502804040909,
-0.6850007176399231,
-0.4415874481201172,
0.14857998490333557,
-0.41706281900405884,
-0.628250777721405,
-0.18812209367752075,
-0.2850247025489807,
0.08862291276454926,
0.5146703720092773,
-0.5877468585968018,
0.4405101239681244,
0.12297417223453522,
0.21355251967906952,
1.065172791481018,
0.2122851461172104,
0.8131642937660217,
-0.5867651104927063,
0.8737227320671082,
-0.011514977551996708,
-0.0684303268790245,
0.11839969456195831,
-0.3922227621078491,
-0.7759983539581299,
-0.23374563455581665,
-0.23846782743930817,
0.5294044017791748,
-0.4233197867870331,
0.24960066378116608,
0.05998748913407326,
0.0133084487169981,
-0.536149263381958,
0.6361901164054871,
0.37231799960136414,
0.5349963903427124,
-0.0437534898519516,
-0.047124944627285004,
-0.458938330411911,
-0.7898949980735779,
-0.2762470543384552,
-0.11659250408411026,
-0.04422038421034813,
0.36465340852737427,
0.3025069832801819,
0.21639177203178406,
0.720975399017334,
-0.7268844246864319,
-0.47288379073143005,
-0.5625506043434143,
-0.13677877187728882,
-0.15118178725242615,
0.3556940257549286,
0.34369340538978577,
-0.3680106997489929,
-0.42970702052116394,
-0.17991195619106293,
-1.094077467918396,
-0.48942917585372925,
-0.4090653955936432,
-0.1283373385667801,
0.5957385897636414,
0.7987290620803833,
-0.7642412781715393,
0.5009322762489319,
0.31290167570114136,
-0.5699734687805176,
0.5621670484542847,
-0.23333530128002167,
0.07188349217176437,
-1.2186578512191772,
0.042289987206459045,
-0.1311584711074829,
-0.005502935033291578,
-0.23190969228744507,
-0.19484125077724457,
-0.2666398286819458,
0.014883889816701412,
-0.18115444481372833,
0.5665202140808105,
-0.8926546573638916,
-0.3551649749279022,
-0.3961450159549713,
0.46306705474853516,
0.33291563391685486,
0.31458497047424316,
0.3123864233493805,
0.8479400873184204,
0.4155411124229431,
-0.43823450803756714,
0.09481560438871384,
0.029816167429089546,
-0.2609163820743561,
0.7458199262619019,
-0.5833263993263245,
0.055148497223854065,
-0.13404640555381775,
-0.11107303947210312,
-1.0548832416534424,
-0.21293365955352783,
0.05583538860082626,
-0.4836254417896271,
0.37469691038131714,
0.44063878059387207,
-0.416091650724411,
-0.0658322423696518,
-0.18580763041973114,
0.007946014404296875,
0.26037436723709106,
-0.07825112342834473,
0.7446491718292236,
0.5324898362159729,
-0.6041387915611267,
-0.5896359086036682,
-0.961341917514801,
0.17579969763755798,
-0.2368318736553192,
-0.38883453607559204,
0.06762762367725372,
-0.010151227936148643,
-0.7440182566642761,
0.21213962137699127,
0.19072933495044708,
-0.01795477420091629,
0.24364444613456726,
0.5557734966278076,
0.3609170913696289,
-0.039817001670598984,
0.08234695345163345,
0.21532537043094635,
0.02280748263001442,
0.338977187871933,
0.0979023203253746,
0.14353160560131073,
0.337350070476532,
-0.4604831635951996,
-0.6386284828186035,
0.660730242729187,
0.7150402069091797,
-0.02023623138666153,
0.6608762145042419,
0.038620781153440475,
-0.19055040180683136,
-0.110934779047966,
-0.7270166277885437,
0.12115348875522614,
-0.4385245144367218,
-0.0710436999797821,
-0.14329755306243896,
-0.8797189593315125,
0.4041006863117218,
0.28707483410835266,
-0.06063969433307648,
0.5016186833381653,
0.40398064255714417,
-0.43745413422584534,
0.504517674446106,
0.8019892573356628,
-0.009157232940196991,
0.3019385039806366,
-0.23850135505199432,
0.221461683511734,
-1.1702898740768433,
-0.28803807497024536,
-0.4112916886806488,
-0.29643842577934265,
-0.01981945149600506,
-0.09701996296644211,
0.015852531418204308,
0.09254638850688934,
0.042823199182748795,
0.27745485305786133,
-0.6181255578994751,
0.43107476830482483,
0.6668205857276917,
-0.13195805251598358,
0.6902320981025696,
-0.45883098244667053,
0.12681661546230316,
-0.17184557020664215,
-0.4403611719608307,
-0.8702442646026611,
1.0104365348815918,
0.2388402819633484,
0.6820520162582397,
0.24190470576286316,
0.862116277217865,
0.4250924289226532,
0.2863476574420929,
-0.990943431854248,
0.7438005805015564,
0.27918103337287903,
-0.4001387357711792,
-0.41188567876815796,
0.0990782380104065,
-0.8178628087043762,
-0.20868231356143951,
-0.15147055685520172,
-1.0477542877197266,
0.17195135354995728,
0.13781628012657166,
-0.42510977387428284,
0.3461442291736603,
-0.9652829766273499,
0.5470924377441406,
-0.09661669284105301,
-0.4480518698692322,
0.05576663836836815,
-0.5075232982635498,
0.385580837726593,
0.0810321792960167,
0.004022056702524424,
0.047846850007772446,
-0.206433966755867,
0.8008859753608704,
-0.4740983247756958,
1.03357994556427,
0.019489461556077003,
-0.431494802236557,
0.6265459656715393,
0.15913653373718262,
0.24666541814804077,
-0.06517115235328674,
-0.035754308104515076,
-0.4012709856033325,
-0.01035227719694376,
-0.1750461906194687,
-0.558699369430542,
0.8122999668121338,
-0.9888852834701538,
-0.8596721887588501,
-0.6315606236457825,
-0.7093862891197205,
-0.17674049735069275,
0.2070731520652771,
0.3316872715950012,
0.09455863386392593,
-0.3039931654930115,
-0.01604057475924492,
0.5554211735725403,
-0.08035850524902344,
0.6774294376373291,
0.2138984203338623,
-0.3131102919578552,
-0.16496257483959198,
0.6702412366867065,
0.24770894646644592,
0.5001070499420166,
0.21891091763973236,
0.16736774146556854,
-0.21349366009235382,
-0.3554019033908844,
-0.4070967137813568,
0.214170902967453,
-0.6591069102287292,
0.07658624649047852,
-0.8602517247200012,
-0.035517945885658264,
-0.6090836524963379,
-0.7007954120635986,
0.06135353818535805,
-0.6446895003318787,
-0.7305998206138611,
-0.3517206907272339,
0.3689669668674469,
0.9952762722969055,
0.03074217215180397,
0.5242188572883606,
-0.5147772431373596,
0.31090471148490906,
0.496163547039032,
-0.0022625750862061977,
0.20798765122890472,
-0.2578350007534027,
-0.047472476959228516,
-0.47088900208473206,
-0.45308029651641846,
-0.9877870082855225,
0.06709028035402298,
-0.2785770297050476,
0.5131426453590393,
0.4860866069793701,
-0.2889728844165802,
0.3970586359500885,
-0.1986735463142395,
1.2525006532669067,
0.02318696305155754,
-1.1367213726043701,
0.27775418758392334,
-0.3151676058769226,
0.19350986182689667,
0.3960086703300476,
0.34652912616729736,
-0.2623724639415741,
-0.42866307497024536,
-0.6637360453605652,
-0.48631125688552856,
0.4971950054168701,
-0.10679084807634354,
0.03015200048685074,
0.0061585321091115475,
0.3512118458747864,
-0.020233003422617912,
0.39687085151672363,
-0.7790248990058899,
0.11300835013389587,
0.011822860687971115,
0.03735846281051636,
-0.07016931474208832,
-0.43846750259399414,
-0.04553621634840965,
-0.24864402413368225,
0.6067474484443665,
0.007178314961493015,
0.3683568239212036,
0.5424110293388367,
-0.16806593537330627,
-0.26680514216423035,
0.24793291091918945,
0.7915294766426086,
0.849955141544342,
0.1858823001384735,
0.20765234529972076,
0.22503961622714996,
-0.3763098418712616,
0.12432125210762024,
-0.3411240875720978,
0.20638222992420197,
-0.4365823566913605,
0.6300898194313049,
0.5193353295326233,
-0.03938230872154236,
-0.5932410955429077,
0.7272965908050537,
0.010882164351642132,
-0.36641278862953186,
-0.6980028748512268,
0.24063590168952942,
0.6167299747467041,
-0.0013229396427050233,
0.127574160695076,
-0.034998293966054916,
0.08372487872838974,
-0.6095536947250366,
-0.33133596181869507,
0.5361742973327637,
-0.040582817047834396,
-0.18876200914382935,
0.5256944894790649,
0.07262062281370163,
-0.4040873646736145,
0.43385031819343567,
0.1649019569158554,
-0.12642253935337067,
0.846908450126648,
0.7358838319778442,
1.054155945777893,
-0.006174449343234301,
0.07756230235099792,
-0.14419473707675934,
0.2946188449859619,
0.11120680719614029,
0.46082574129104614,
-0.26590168476104736,
-0.847091555595398,
-0.3781834840774536,
-0.3966529965400696,
-0.673427164554596,
0.05456656962633133,
-0.8031908273696899,
0.06760174036026001,
-0.7027357220649719,
-0.11997029185295105,
0.07623108476400375,
-0.015661973506212234,
-0.622355580329895,
0.2474350780248642,
-0.08236631751060486,
0.7544068694114685,
-0.875045657157898,
0.6819530129432678,
0.8758643865585327,
-0.3890852630138397,
-0.878294825553894,
-0.173669695854187,
0.08601474016904831,
-0.7386347651481628,
0.4172416925430298,
-0.07691928744316101,
-0.39159131050109863,
-0.09865428507328033,
-0.6667884588241577,
-0.5849381685256958,
1.314945936203003,
0.1821506917476654,
-0.3019183874130249,
-0.2961062788963318,
0.1655208021402359,
0.5440880060195923,
-0.49544450640678406,
-0.18460211157798767,
0.27547991275787354,
0.5544694662094116,
-0.18111807107925415,
-0.6736904978752136,
0.04593105614185333,
-0.1003662720322609,
-0.07529463618993759,
0.035445686429739,
-0.5969029664993286,
0.7381306886672974,
-0.4963865578174591,
0.19564217329025269,
0.16924847662448883,
0.5493390560150146,
0.15313850343227386,
0.45457133650779724,
0.20829233527183533,
0.4832664430141449,
0.7877255082130432,
0.16401930153369904,
1.2200289964675903,
0.1543300747871399,
-0.3073933720588684,
1.1828047037124634,
-0.5082871317863464,
0.5971827507019043,
1.152203917503357,
-0.07157856225967407,
0.6127408146858215,
0.012448067776858807,
0.2539929747581482,
-0.03318559750914574,
0.19753418862819672,
-0.4785730242729187,
-0.10104573518037796,
-0.34385475516319275,
0.0705634355545044,
0.4025973379611969,
0.28685232996940613,
-0.6845313906669617,
0.41563519835472107,
-0.008825388737022877,
0.22101497650146484,
0.513461709022522,
-0.1851060539484024,
1.2579480409622192,
0.4814951419830322,
-1.0086065530776978,
-0.28062060475349426,
-0.3253128230571747,
0.4675979018211365,
-0.5167317390441895,
0.15542888641357422,
-0.027988670393824577,
0.002482207491993904,
-0.2640867531299591,
-1.1243996620178223,
0.5326311588287354,
0.11721041798591614,
-0.45135536789894104,
-0.5872960090637207,
0.9473620653152466,
-0.22634674608707428,
-0.43578651547431946,
0.12913542985916138,
0.8823952078819275,
0.1747678965330124,
0.18979261815547943,
-0.07244149595499039,
0.07514035701751709,
-0.2909119129180908,
-0.47005072236061096,
0.3932898938655853,
0.6044691205024719,
-0.013584027998149395,
0.5355322957038879,
0.5633991956710815,
0.37801697850227356,
0.12767843902111053,
-0.06883110851049423,
0.5602302551269531,
-0.6696271300315857,
-0.1821712851524353,
-0.9632013440132141,
0.45832595229148865,
-0.25086352229118347,
-0.6818398237228394,
0.8762143850326538,
0.5674079656600952,
0.7219567894935608,
-0.37101346254348755,
1.1855406761169434,
-0.15752960741519928,
0.32937461137771606,
-0.6414024233818054,
0.7928844094276428,
-0.6881491541862488,
0.0007142320391722023,
-0.7483963966369629,
-0.7792232632637024,
-0.2964818477630615,
0.5188742280006409,
-0.3657861053943634,
-0.13095684349536896,
0.6826646327972412,
0.6159032583236694,
0.10088295489549637,
-0.055096585303545,
0.4591139256954193,
-0.19222740828990936,
0.17441542446613312,
0.5846683382987976,
1.1140193939208984,
0.033857233822345734,
0.11274468153715134,
-0.25435879826545715,
-0.11211805045604706,
0.2608693838119507,
-1.2140064239501953,
-0.9132015109062195,
-0.7487802505493164,
-0.25613194704055786,
-0.20876777172088623,
-0.3339037299156189,
0.9110811948776245,
0.1179022341966629,
-0.3176361918449402,
-0.4256989657878876,
-0.08115769922733307,
0.35943982005119324,
-0.03445351868867874,
-0.278543084859848,
0.200198695063591,
-0.15857216715812683,
-0.8446422219276428,
0.06296467781066895,
0.37806329131126404,
0.42560914158821106,
-0.45852038264274597,
0.006136058364063501,
-0.33024337887763977,
0.3821357488632202,
0.5853927135467529,
0.30637332797050476,
-0.7608835101127625,
-0.1108018234372139,
0.3126561641693115,
-0.37198182940483093,
-0.1393546313047409,
1.11942720413208,
-0.37771695852279663,
0.2507559359073639,
0.5430883765220642,
0.6376181244850159,
0.04943074285984039,
-0.010137978009879589,
0.724527895450592,
-0.4669646620750427,
-0.15960577130317688,
0.06931640952825546,
0.4606739282608032,
0.5224325656890869,
-0.8544492721557617,
0.2780075669288635,
0.11894183605909348,
-0.7218079566955566,
-0.6067766547203064,
0.028556203469634056,
-1.2562980651855469,
-0.23946653306484222,
1.2269128561019897,
-0.11126591265201569,
-0.2426784187555313,
0.1439303457736969,
-0.7358556985855103,
0.331305593252182,
-0.3206798732280731,
0.6238096356391907,
1.1296499967575073,
-0.5263120532035828,
-0.3537213206291199,
-0.43948936462402344,
0.6324973702430725,
0.3225173354148865,
-0.9729346632957458,
0.04369324818253517,
0.6398299336433411,
0.29016709327697754,
0.1503644436597824,
1.2175532579421997,
-0.10416261851787567,
0.1894684135913849,
-0.2420312911272049,
0.23539841175079346,
-0.22933544218540192,
-0.5693066716194153,
-0.19972705841064453,
0.17509707808494568,
0.6289717555046082,
0.027363022789359093
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00026v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00026v3
|
Ink and Individuality: Crafting a Personalised Narrative in the Age of LLMs
| 2024-03-20T21:02:16 | 2024-04-22T08:30:28 |
Azmine Toushik Wasi, Raima Islam, Mst Rafia Islam
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Individuality and personalization comprise the distinctive characteristics
that make each writer unique and influence their words in order to effectively
engage readers while conveying authenticity. However, our growing reliance on
LLM-based writing assistants risks compromising our creativity and
individuality over time. We often overlook the negative impacts of this trend
on our creativity and uniqueness, despite the possible consequences. This study
investigates these concerns by performing a brief survey to explore different
perspectives and concepts, as well as trying to understand people's viewpoints,
in conjunction with past studies in the area. Addressing these issues is
essential for improving human-computer interaction systems and enhancing
writing assistants for personalization and individuality.
|
[
-0.3981185257434845,
-0.409585177898407,
0.7943375110626221,
0.11086267977952957,
-0.01030908152461052,
0.4930950105190277,
0.14792513847351074,
-0.8156493306159973,
0.4579349458217621,
0.8403382897377014,
-0.6016169190406799,
-0.3464655578136444,
-0.6096328496932983,
0.5089750289916992,
0.08466113358736038,
0.6576225161552429,
-0.2137668877840042,
-0.26187002658843994,
-0.3906419575214386,
-0.4568699896335602,
-0.473845899105072,
-0.8343831896781921,
-0.6422557830810547,
-0.15190716087818146,
0.9072093963623047,
0.6460949778556824,
0.30307629704475403,
0.6419569849967957,
0.6787946224212646,
0.4090278446674347,
-0.2588297724723816,
0.1821383386850357,
-0.3834642171859741,
0.42449504137039185,
-0.19643084704875946,
-0.6981668472290039,
-0.2832100987434387,
0.35934263467788696,
0.43720170855522156,
0.8547487258911133,
0.43862631916999817,
0.10017798840999603,
0.18564791977405548,
0.7593722939491272,
-0.6021369099617004,
-0.5677741765975952,
-0.3608683943748474,
0.31305715441703796,
-0.46453073620796204,
-0.3126320540904999,
-0.3152426481246948,
-0.3459039330482483,
-0.023211820051074028,
-0.7928507924079895,
0.3102964758872986,
-0.062228716909885406,
0.5293697714805603,
-0.10325214266777039,
-0.38040637969970703,
-0.7350696325302124,
-1.0789034366607666,
0.5480312705039978,
-0.5577912926673889,
-0.2518635094165802,
-0.000057598212151788175,
0.06586676836013794,
-0.037497300654649734,
-0.9555535316467285,
-0.5054548978805542,
-0.026531940326094627,
0.007061864715069532,
0.32030099630355835,
0.2195305973291397,
-0.19590900838375092,
0.09583418071269989,
0.44743645191192627,
-0.04143683984875679,
0.40064552426338196,
-0.09328655153512955,
0.009646464139223099,
0.6328020095825195,
0.6306793689727783,
0.5861937999725342,
0.2800873816013336,
-0.49337124824523926,
0.4896548390388489,
-0.8690668940544128,
0.3959377706050873,
1.1929748058319092,
0.11977594345808029,
0.25753459334373474,
0.4072500169277191,
-0.2363642454147339,
0.21462759375572205,
-0.02646813727915287,
-0.27342939376831055,
-0.1501190960407257,
-0.10937362164258957,
0.2166285514831543,
-0.07962221652269363,
0.6460688710212708,
0.23308701813220978,
0.2822125554084778,
-0.28266191482543945,
-0.10642794519662857,
-0.3973766267299652,
0.37140604853630066,
-0.4539533257484436,
0.22370046377182007,
0.21700938045978546,
-0.17169182002544403,
-0.4787118136882782,
0.47814419865608215,
-0.3969264030456543,
-1.113955020904541,
-0.443625807762146,
0.15869368612766266,
0.0940694808959961,
0.08360914885997772,
-0.1748700886964798,
-0.25605079531669617,
-0.2289700210094452,
0.6954948306083679,
-1.044543981552124,
0.17358572781085968,
0.5229816436767578,
0.4535800516605377,
-0.6450520753860474,
-0.4718196988105774,
0.08669716119766235,
0.4323076903820038,
-0.33959704637527466,
1.1117212772369385,
-0.1698381006717682,
-0.6213853359222412,
-0.020439207553863525,
-0.08202254772186279,
0.3661675453186035,
-0.5958439111709595,
0.43515917658805847,
-0.13201501965522766,
0.25789710879325867,
-0.6864766478538513,
-0.44100421667099,
0.05702117830514908,
0.03835628181695938,
-0.36953723430633545,
0.42669931054115295,
-0.008563284762203693,
-0.8077764511108398,
0.5040386319160461,
-0.4850744903087616,
-0.4530142843723297,
0.3394955098628998,
-0.2174309343099594,
-0.46208760142326355,
0.3354417085647583,
-0.10310119390487671,
0.4822992980480194,
-0.12971623241901398,
-0.21610970795154572,
-0.3344103693962097,
-0.6239460110664368,
0.7520328164100647,
-0.41400256752967834,
0.7238636612892151,
0.16617953777313232,
-0.20641277730464935,
-0.20548054575920105,
-0.795010507106781,
-0.2419521063566208,
-0.02817908488214016,
-0.6675703525543213,
-0.10794637352228165,
-0.2939659059047699,
0.10729621350765228,
-0.009786641225218773,
0.5810678601264954,
-0.7155248522758484,
0.496360719203949,
-0.26812541484832764,
0.34978166222572327,
1.0274887084960938,
0.36525657773017883,
0.394462525844574,
-0.6523976922035217,
0.8101658225059509,
0.20041581988334656,
0.13234040141105652,
-0.5058125257492065,
-0.622474730014801,
-0.5862652063369751,
-0.15273480117321014,
-0.1250966638326645,
0.6204394102096558,
-0.11754155158996582,
0.2603437304496765,
0.14957065880298615,
-0.27878639101982117,
-0.5352962017059326,
0.7231769561767578,
0.2500136196613312,
0.5542112588882446,
-0.22699490189552307,
-0.4709172546863556,
-0.4227580428123474,
-0.9007665514945984,
-0.6420914530754089,
-0.16434834897518158,
0.05556558817625046,
0.27396562695503235,
0.07383087277412415,
-0.09689603745937347,
1.0188870429992676,
-0.47401681542396545,
-0.5086835622787476,
-0.33468514680862427,
0.22133933007717133,
-0.0013200707035139203,
0.44118064641952515,
0.14690233767032623,
-0.5325340628623962,
-0.8496347665786743,
0.036641430109739304,
-0.9129257202148438,
-0.4883352518081665,
-0.6529260873794556,
0.21201997995376587,
0.2880082130432129,
0.08433960378170013,
-0.2808005213737488,
0.771108090877533,
-0.0010887469397857785,
-0.5674540400505066,
0.5943096280097961,
-0.18884330987930298,
0.47628191113471985,
-0.9058595299720764,
0.13792124390602112,
-0.12695057690143585,
0.05096351355314255,
-0.5305308103561401,
-0.1819566935300827,
-0.34443819522857666,
0.03158162534236908,
-0.5882859826087952,
0.7676705718040466,
-0.6893824934959412,
0.013029958121478558,
-0.31728458404541016,
0.13450033962726593,
0.4733193516731262,
0.28554487228393555,
-0.2087143510580063,
0.875055193901062,
-0.03637320548295975,
-0.25427180528640747,
-0.022563377395272255,
0.2906446158885956,
-0.13581238687038422,
0.7677441835403442,
-0.2979782521724701,
0.8617892861366272,
-0.21011069416999817,
-0.44421228766441345,
-1.3016045093536377,
0.07269944250583649,
0.10869061201810837,
-0.4569464325904846,
0.43454861640930176,
0.2865113615989685,
-0.285748690366745,
-0.053208377212285995,
-0.425184965133667,
-0.36281853914260864,
0.2650231719017029,
-0.36442485451698303,
0.6858295202255249,
0.22372058033943176,
-0.4935845136642456,
-0.6121710538864136,
-0.8399361968040466,
0.628574013710022,
-0.49452006816864014,
-0.8068224191665649,
0.2043582797050476,
-0.35413017868995667,
-0.6159769892692566,
-0.15668490529060364,
0.11208650469779968,
-0.0395190492272377,
0.3231367766857147,
0.5067845582962036,
-0.02654867060482502,
-0.1494593620300293,
-0.25202280282974243,
-0.09401383250951767,
-0.2744777202606201,
-0.20543549954891205,
0.2434813231229782,
0.20495064556598663,
0.0732903927564621,
-0.29511186480522156,
-0.8794923424720764,
0.7318043112754822,
0.43042171001434326,
0.05782583728432655,
0.8188009262084961,
0.3827655017375946,
0.28037694096565247,
-0.11635714769363403,
-1.035224437713623,
0.20890064537525177,
-0.5698357820510864,
-0.09622563421726227,
-0.3571995198726654,
-0.7964228987693787,
0.6529527902603149,
-0.10723347216844559,
-0.031994398683309555,
0.27938371896743774,
0.6226534247398376,
-0.6681162118911743,
0.40107184648513794,
0.913658857345581,
0.21818700432777405,
0.5168918967247009,
-0.07431168854236603,
0.0355064794421196,
-1.0582785606384277,
-0.1428150087594986,
-0.08771956712007523,
-0.4825609028339386,
-0.353704035282135,
0.30739009380340576,
0.10243742913007736,
-0.1193680465221405,
-0.03219623491168022,
-0.1106472909450531,
-0.8932743072509766,
0.6309694647789001,
0.5746696591377258,
-0.08361375331878662,
0.7779939770698547,
-0.43438422679901123,
0.03969944268465042,
-0.37723368406295776,
-0.061310794204473495,
-1.1688926219940186,
1.0052777528762817,
0.2323697805404663,
0.6518356800079346,
0.08792360872030258,
0.8541352152824402,
0.5556808114051819,
0.5148230195045471,
-0.3419913649559021,
0.49439963698387146,
-0.1207367554306984,
-0.5504621267318726,
-0.2780987024307251,
0.06382478028535843,
-1.1735285520553589,
0.032553695142269135,
-0.14638091623783112,
-1.1406893730163574,
0.4156336486339569,
0.20030276477336884,
-0.43882185220718384,
0.45649391412734985,
-0.9795816540718079,
0.6014598608016968,
-0.24797868728637695,
-0.632172167301178,
0.3510618209838867,
-0.5441159605979919,
0.1915595382452011,
-0.0649128258228302,
-0.14936795830726624,
-0.37600675225257874,
-0.548782229423523,
0.43674328923225403,
-0.1781807243824005,
1.245808482170105,
0.13153713941574097,
0.030525900423526764,
0.55445396900177,
0.07130076736211777,
0.3017396032810211,
-0.05453800410032272,
0.05405665189027786,
-0.05263934284448624,
0.003636839333921671,
-0.07714255899190903,
-0.39143437147140503,
0.7243287563323975,
-0.9246066212654114,
-1.0818952322006226,
-0.4365382492542267,
-0.5239059329032898,
-0.2721600830554962,
0.17463979125022888,
0.5063931345939636,
0.28111323714256287,
-0.37665170431137085,
-0.2200937420129776,
0.6261065602302551,
-0.2162340134382248,
0.5467352867126465,
0.49382483959198,
-0.16935446858406067,
-0.6072145700454712,
0.7462272644042969,
0.4629218876361847,
0.30953946709632874,
0.2618781328201294,
0.30621111392974854,
-0.03123238869011402,
-0.8376188278198242,
-0.33665114641189575,
0.30180615186691284,
-1.081558108329773,
0.20008888840675354,
-0.738764762878418,
0.08936194330453873,
-0.6302777528762817,
-0.5263527035713196,
-0.046956323087215424,
-0.5186247825622559,
-0.9599027633666992,
0.1645776331424713,
0.024634595960378647,
1.1812952756881714,
0.11712652444839478,
0.36916473507881165,
-0.5216896533966064,
0.17418037354946136,
0.44092702865600586,
0.1591530293226242,
-0.1665174514055252,
-0.24007442593574524,
-0.08952499181032181,
-0.6791787147521973,
-0.6386998891830444,
-0.869513988494873,
0.1256200671195984,
-0.22242186963558197,
0.5275874733924866,
0.5854584574699402,
-0.3750257194042206,
0.2386447787284851,
-0.29827073216438293,
0.9191469550132751,
0.022328026592731476,
-0.7023271918296814,
0.26905372738838196,
-0.49670886993408203,
0.5593749284744263,
0.8040750622749329,
0.2413211166858673,
-0.9273918271064758,
-0.40982678532600403,
-0.5232653617858887,
-0.6593313813209534,
0.4672695994377136,
0.1019781082868576,
0.14331819117069244,
0.3714321553707123,
0.7075449228286743,
0.3862261474132538,
0.32405781745910645,
-0.6389003992080688,
-0.23047016561031342,
0.3289749026298523,
-0.137828528881073,
0.1658335030078888,
-0.51888507604599,
0.0761767327785492,
-0.050942644476890564,
0.3303896188735962,
0.11738468706607819,
0.21790140867233276,
0.3154224753379822,
0.2715088427066803,
-0.06345724314451218,
0.26479247212409973,
0.5527422428131104,
0.8358649015426636,
0.1318780779838562,
0.06800197809934616,
0.2852037250995636,
-0.7597659826278687,
0.5260328650474548,
-0.43081194162368774,
-0.29747089743614197,
-0.28432855010032654,
0.5139981508255005,
0.3619140088558197,
-0.2258695662021637,
-0.4861215353012085,
0.3625694513320923,
-0.06994666159152985,
0.1411665827035904,
-0.7469033002853394,
0.1491149365901947,
0.4008308947086334,
-0.14048945903778076,
0.25058576464653015,
0.221212238073349,
0.13840050995349884,
-0.7512243986129761,
-0.24098537862300873,
0.2960093021392822,
-0.2660893499851227,
-0.47995445132255554,
0.6690958142280579,
0.28866705298423767,
-0.6161024570465088,
0.013407343067228794,
-0.11152375489473343,
-0.09362348169088364,
0.6251116394996643,
0.5505186915397644,
1.1236305236816406,
-0.2502465844154358,
-0.12732696533203125,
-0.267814040184021,
0.3650042414665222,
0.35273104906082153,
0.0917709618806839,
0.031058305874466896,
-0.7631657719612122,
0.09361867606639862,
-0.2878184914588928,
-0.8482942581176758,
-0.16743025183677673,
-0.31236201524734497,
0.4083375930786133,
-0.6788907051086426,
-0.2452034205198288,
-0.08912411332130432,
0.03651750087738037,
-0.7283244729042053,
0.2519263029098511,
0.2729756534099579,
0.3663419187068939,
-0.5645315647125244,
0.5185391902923584,
0.8154584765434265,
-0.39289575815200806,
-0.3025411367416382,
-0.09129691123962402,
0.31000494956970215,
-0.4252243638038635,
0.599158763885498,
0.17179188132286072,
-0.30147501826286316,
-0.21261653304100037,
-0.29009345173835754,
-0.6949494481086731,
1.1263773441314697,
0.21434977650642395,
-0.37088197469711304,
-0.13016952574253082,
0.7946711182594299,
0.6288973093032837,
-0.6361362934112549,
0.008193780668079853,
0.5717330574989319,
0.2486264854669571,
0.07944145798683167,
-0.24718715250492096,
-0.2508417069911957,
-0.22691437602043152,
0.38925984501838684,
-0.034606046974658966,
-0.8030169010162354,
0.7657678723335266,
-0.1884956955909729,
-0.2521434426307678,
0.29042747616767883,
0.5381331443786621,
-0.04991831257939339,
0.42708152532577515,
0.049567706882953644,
0.5226709842681885,
0.7683495283126831,
0.0951976329088211,
1.1061313152313232,
0.02694893442094326,
-0.351291686296463,
1.058038353919983,
-0.33114734292030334,
0.4273635447025299,
0.48530569672584534,
-0.2837449610233307,
0.37886136770248413,
0.2885008752346039,
0.15991775691509247,
0.08573824912309647,
0.09522092342376709,
-0.6983811259269714,
0.17736577987670898,
0.020917249843478203,
0.14889779686927795,
0.2614048421382904,
0.20224712789058685,
-0.2986564338207245,
0.4667857885360718,
0.19682851433753967,
0.14061470329761505,
0.4774685204029083,
-0.027742918580770493,
1.0223901271820068,
0.21078330278396606,
-0.427410364151001,
-0.3449438512325287,
-0.3108395040035248,
0.8194511532783508,
-0.572343647480011,
0.01271964330226183,
-0.3861229121685028,
0.1363063007593155,
-0.27598094940185547,
-0.9717251658439636,
0.32693976163864136,
-0.08474037796258926,
0.007804146036505699,
-0.5472208261489868,
1.1037153005599976,
-0.052710797637701035,
-0.4740312397480011,
-0.16224679350852966,
0.5652593374252319,
-0.02613387443125248,
0.11411686986684799,
-0.32973021268844604,
0.25660136342048645,
-0.1244613453745842,
-0.45694592595100403,
0.32575082778930664,
0.7731391787528992,
0.4568595290184021,
0.6349368691444397,
0.2755013406276703,
0.3495411276817322,
-0.001798113458789885,
-0.23093780875205994,
0.5512608289718628,
-0.7591623067855835,
-0.4447331726551056,
-0.9566255807876587,
0.8326854705810547,
-0.08572488278150558,
-1.136648416519165,
1.0512480735778809,
0.5901493430137634,
0.3567313551902771,
-0.15737412869930267,
0.9128815531730652,
0.41395488381385803,
0.7064171433448792,
-0.2862214744091034,
1.0118507146835327,
-0.39606335759162903,
0.5415692329406738,
-0.357077032327652,
-0.7280601859092712,
-0.23942884802818298,
0.14983899891376495,
-0.2604275345802307,
0.030919257551431656,
0.5462839603424072,
0.4408338963985443,
0.3944753110408783,
0.01598012074828148,
0.5611280202865601,
-0.1871333122253418,
0.3866021931171417,
0.1026822030544281,
1.3451322317123413,
0.18692238628864288,
0.05063490569591522,
-0.5462437272071838,
-0.005384335294365883,
0.0790494978427887,
-1.0132023096084595,
-1.0231000185012817,
-0.7401277422904968,
-0.6143633723258972,
-0.1322113275527954,
-0.10689210146665573,
0.6865987181663513,
0.13371063768863678,
-0.5126653909683228,
-0.2816162705421448,
0.209457665681839,
0.2231609970331192,
0.15284566581249237,
-0.23921649158000946,
-0.06271316856145859,
-0.33211731910705566,
-0.7303833961486816,
-0.0940270647406578,
0.8384746313095093,
0.45333024859428406,
-0.7992423176765442,
0.47671324014663696,
0.07783089578151703,
0.34597036242485046,
0.47281771898269653,
0.4098634421825409,
-0.6662521362304688,
-0.19786810874938965,
-0.040911298245191574,
-0.22218382358551025,
0.8106403350830078,
1.2209807634353638,
-0.599868893623352,
0.6368237733840942,
0.2172539234161377,
0.5244988203048706,
0.388565331697464,
-0.13464921712875366,
0.35696539282798767,
-0.6590796113014221,
-0.03838147222995758,
0.49577629566192627,
0.24763979017734528,
0.7351598739624023,
-1.157051920890808,
0.43609198927879333,
0.6874907612800598,
-0.7317913174629211,
-0.4873308837413788,
0.1370362639427185,
-0.8303637504577637,
-0.18928666412830353,
0.9371449947357178,
-0.23949164152145386,
-0.1609063744544983,
-0.31795111298561096,
-0.5301216840744019,
-0.15137746930122375,
-0.07185537368059158,
0.7547004222869873,
0.9762130379676819,
-0.6676632165908813,
-0.08091028034687042,
-0.38836607336997986,
0.2792186439037323,
-0.0028119783382862806,
-1.1278315782546997,
-0.09510181844234467,
0.13592320680618286,
0.47948330640792847,
0.08131010085344315,
1.2149008512496948,
0.09726041555404663,
-0.03494652733206749,
0.18477287888526917,
0.25395530462265015,
-0.3041972517967224,
-0.30464276671409607,
-0.18189767003059387,
0.2918071150779724,
0.4667728841304779,
0.28743159770965576
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13925v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13925v1
|
Reducing Large Language Model Bias with Emphasis on 'Restricted Industries': Automated Dataset Augmentation and Prejudice Quantification
| 2024-03-20T18:59:18 | 2024-03-20T18:59:18 |
Devam Mondal, Carlo Lipizzi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Despite the growing capabilities of large language models, there exists
concerns about the biases they develop. In this paper, we propose a novel,
automated mechanism for debiasing through specified dataset augmentation in the
lens of bias producers and in the context of 'restricted industries' with
limited data. We additionally create two new additional metrics, the mb-index
and db-index, to quantify bias, considering the idea that bias occurs due to
both intrinsic model architecture and dataset.
|
[
-0.7416189312934875,
-0.7276732921600342,
0.4738849401473999,
0.2278660535812378,
0.25119420886039734,
-0.23097896575927734,
-0.12303036451339722,
-0.5921120643615723,
0.16352413594722748,
0.7981160283088684,
-0.7211399674415588,
-0.43130192160606384,
-0.45676949620246887,
0.033917881548404694,
-0.4609163701534271,
0.8235921859741211,
0.2282017320394516,
0.21479852497577667,
-0.19762973487377167,
-0.17333680391311646,
-0.4278554320335388,
-0.7835772037506104,
-0.18726514279842377,
-0.2795232832431793,
0.37282469868659973,
0.3134163022041321,
0.9859804511070251,
0.7818208932876587,
0.6117814183235168,
0.1990930736064911,
-0.007163165137171745,
-0.039403900504112244,
-0.24237686395645142,
0.031439490616321564,
-0.3142131268978119,
-0.6220420598983765,
-0.45702049136161804,
-0.00180071871727705,
0.716780424118042,
1.200284481048584,
0.4402082860469818,
0.390158474445343,
0.054053205996751785,
0.7560912370681763,
-0.9193878769874573,
0.17647406458854675,
-0.5333438515663147,
0.02611038275063038,
-0.2748962938785553,
0.203853577375412,
-0.4010692238807678,
-0.37613534927368164,
0.0442412905395031,
-0.4695654511451721,
0.26082974672317505,
0.09046826511621475,
0.8342952132225037,
0.4211390018463135,
-0.5958365201950073,
0.03995642438530922,
-0.810314416885376,
1.0332120656967163,
-0.5081629753112793,
0.3811415731906891,
0.6115509271621704,
0.24960288405418396,
0.2783699035644531,
-0.253223180770874,
-0.33529385924339294,
-0.20471231639385223,
-0.14826376736164093,
-0.29660332202911377,
-0.022443503141403198,
0.11719444394111633,
0.5405796766281128,
0.4595046937465668,
-0.21507221460342407,
0.5687915682792664,
-0.4086341857910156,
-0.15099875628948212,
0.741310715675354,
0.24077224731445312,
0.2555355727672577,
0.016854558140039444,
0.07130266726016998,
-0.08640610426664352,
-0.828862190246582,
-0.38826316595077515,
0.9182374477386475,
0.05119248107075691,
0.21212834119796753,
0.7800921201705933,
-0.5744034647941589,
0.6196792721748352,
0.009532139636576176,
0.2898041605949402,
0.586790919303894,
-0.04303468018770218,
-0.3177551329135895,
-0.012146418914198875,
0.4234776198863983,
0.5723564624786377,
0.15133105218410492,
0.21312165260314941,
-0.5080545544624329,
0.46064579486846924,
-0.012292243540287018,
-0.5161953568458557,
-0.10608541965484619,
0.2413921058177948,
-0.3983500003814697,
-0.3498857617378235,
-0.023250235244631767,
-0.9247815012931824,
-0.76790452003479,
-0.13387219607830048,
0.2947057783603668,
0.14837691187858582,
-0.2726464569568634,
-0.07996407896280289,
-0.5363219380378723,
0.1028946042060852,
-0.047897741198539734,
-0.9768961071968079,
0.12519390881061554,
0.7791520357131958,
0.508122444152832,
-0.044857777655124664,
-0.011680234223604202,
-0.2644105851650238,
0.28875023126602173,
-0.5445155501365662,
0.5788108706474304,
-0.9574270248413086,
-0.3502083420753479,
-0.05005841702222824,
-0.012179411947727203,
0.37524762749671936,
-0.9454283118247986,
0.5642967820167542,
-0.5385063290596008,
0.2363446056842804,
-0.31023380160331726,
-0.3999788165092468,
-0.34249529242515564,
0.06483731418848038,
-1.0070558786392212,
0.9697222709655762,
0.3943388760089874,
-0.762191653251648,
0.9477124214172363,
-0.7503507137298584,
-0.42399176955223083,
-0.09994141757488251,
-0.18048588931560516,
-0.10345260053873062,
0.08146776258945465,
0.5942694544792175,
0.05793998762965202,
-0.47932207584381104,
0.4792528450489044,
-0.8586786389350891,
-0.13203853368759155,
0.35693153738975525,
-0.6847792863845825,
1.0177931785583496,
0.28568005561828613,
-0.4419991075992584,
0.0002920249244198203,
-0.7680906653404236,
-0.2694253623485565,
-0.25916430354118347,
-0.19525876641273499,
-0.7686923742294312,
0.05361137166619301,
0.06597934663295746,
0.14313261210918427,
0.1875486522912979,
-0.44772717356681824,
0.10891116410493851,
-0.6931078433990479,
0.21517063677310944,
0.8136003017425537,
0.03373434394598007,
0.747065007686615,
-0.23677092790603638,
0.4712675213813782,
0.23605135083198547,
0.36437052488327026,
-0.09296643733978271,
-0.20534446835517883,
-1.2075847387313843,
-0.3685762882232666,
0.4750910699367523,
0.5659233331680298,
-0.5930954813957214,
0.6916702389717102,
-0.29411745071411133,
-0.16900333762168884,
-0.8825492262840271,
0.07295367866754532,
0.13070720434188843,
0.38844117522239685,
0.21631382405757904,
-0.6273239254951477,
-0.7659590244293213,
-1.4959547519683838,
-0.23028355836868286,
0.184656023979187,
-0.6139763593673706,
0.323691189289093,
0.3589414358139038,
-0.41094785928726196,
1.0912142992019653,
-0.5797318816184998,
-0.39764243364334106,
0.007205603644251823,
0.034569934010505676,
0.2996234893798828,
0.6824482679367065,
0.6372664570808411,
-0.6769320368766785,
-0.4077029526233673,
-0.1518867313861847,
-0.6629924178123474,
-0.6797918081283569,
-0.08837158232927322,
-0.022723250091075897,
0.2572120130062103,
0.2725403904914856,
-0.4095771312713623,
0.4754689037799835,
0.2591278553009033,
-0.1909910887479782,
0.3609687089920044,
0.31427207589149475,
0.06338194012641907,
-0.6488039493560791,
0.054689619690179825,
0.2974874973297119,
-0.08576393872499466,
-0.3992327153682709,
0.08151141554117203,
-0.08173318207263947,
0.05847945064306259,
-0.1123780906200409,
0.46854710578918457,
-0.558680534362793,
-0.17178641259670258,
-0.2942635715007782,
0.05437146872282028,
0.29409828782081604,
0.30892378091812134,
0.06891843676567078,
0.5703592896461487,
0.7634505033493042,
-0.7115700244903564,
0.3875495195388794,
0.2648722231388092,
-0.9382596015930176,
0.6037381887435913,
-0.41993480920791626,
-0.05544591695070267,
-0.3127073049545288,
0.2882170081138611,
-0.6562462449073792,
-0.24005889892578125,
0.13728351891040802,
-0.22200272977352142,
0.07820836454629898,
-0.2446138560771942,
-0.2861217260360718,
-0.5319623351097107,
-0.2682340145111084,
0.34117990732192993,
0.5911640524864197,
-0.39402467012405396,
0.2145535796880722,
0.8634137511253357,
-0.2794330418109894,
-0.9209498763084412,
-1.240250825881958,
0.14215806126594543,
-0.44274547696113586,
-0.5406135320663452,
0.10532397031784058,
0.03469545766711235,
-0.7417386174201965,
-0.004593438934534788,
0.025435199961066246,
-0.4268067181110382,
0.14394786953926086,
0.06708212196826935,
0.28267404437065125,
-0.04481714591383934,
0.08781840652227402,
0.44896915555000305,
-0.015721037983894348,
0.3566272258758545,
-0.3090038597583771,
0.3555425703525543,
0.544243574142456,
-0.40191155672073364,
-0.2842184901237488,
0.4325896203517914,
0.6156526803970337,
-0.1747417449951172,
0.7055417895317078,
0.308536171913147,
-0.1934709995985031,
-0.28210461139678955,
-0.7933695912361145,
-0.2997368574142456,
-0.505955159664154,
0.5237427949905396,
-0.2003929764032364,
-0.8406599164009094,
0.49868011474609375,
0.17443591356277466,
-0.1348806619644165,
0.658150315284729,
0.6226900219917297,
0.5575461387634277,
1.5609151124954224,
0.5740207433700562,
-0.5100441575050354,
0.3757406771183014,
-0.0879984050989151,
0.3456430733203888,
-0.8521379828453064,
0.005822927225381136,
-0.7411057353019714,
-0.3161598742008209,
-0.7078561782836914,
-0.18573927879333496,
0.45731550455093384,
-0.28356897830963135,
-0.34868133068084717,
-0.09151767194271088,
-0.4821006953716278,
0.5573691129684448,
0.8136661648750305,
0.2019803524017334,
0.21609733998775482,
-0.16264694929122925,
-0.09395303577184677,
0.052976980805397034,
-0.5290000438690186,
-0.4713262617588043,
1.1775329113006592,
0.5437188744544983,
0.8275742530822754,
-0.08495903015136719,
0.16203610599040985,
0.6365856528282166,
0.5554912090301514,
-0.815865159034729,
0.42197567224502563,
-0.022997692227363586,
-1.3317519426345825,
-0.3063872456550598,
-0.4671536386013031,
-0.44819897413253784,
0.13494880497455597,
-0.20515182614326477,
-0.6267307996749878,
0.8564522862434387,
0.19507504999637604,
-0.11449617147445679,
0.03722681477665901,
-0.8506410717964172,
0.6135903596878052,
-0.07981205731630325,
-0.635894775390625,
-0.30846670269966125,
-0.38056614995002747,
0.55473792552948,
-0.3234374225139618,
0.46573537588119507,
-0.2767815589904785,
-0.07741685956716537,
0.6650481224060059,
-0.5702744722366333,
0.873657763004303,
-0.46284219622612,
-0.24833504855632782,
0.1962752491235733,
-0.025363530963659286,
0.32943078875541687,
-0.11158271878957748,
-0.4492243528366089,
0.12507954239845276,
-0.22576364874839783,
-0.2773760259151459,
-0.33020904660224915,
0.548931896686554,
-0.539099395275116,
-0.875707745552063,
-0.12626832723617554,
-0.6310281157493591,
-0.514822244644165,
0.2577342092990875,
0.0743500217795372,
0.30611521005630493,
-0.23457996547222137,
0.3261011242866516,
0.4270371198654175,
-0.518875241279602,
0.1529868096113205,
0.528857409954071,
-0.0979529470205307,
-0.3029007017612457,
0.40384459495544434,
0.3135488033294678,
0.24375684559345245,
0.3469874858856201,
0.032914500683546066,
-0.5369501113891602,
-0.4249500632286072,
-0.26958778500556946,
-0.22145293653011322,
-0.8258659839630127,
-0.09965281933546066,
-0.6245267391204834,
-0.000169837279827334,
-0.583723247051239,
0.04892848804593086,
-0.04254768788814545,
-0.769984245300293,
-0.03261933475732803,
-0.3086450397968292,
0.11428513377904892,
0.5325871109962463,
-0.1756724715232849,
0.3849087059497833,
-0.6052026748657227,
0.3191659152507782,
0.2578542232513428,
0.5754035115242004,
0.043218184262514114,
-0.6141817569732666,
-0.5125604867935181,
0.3706626296043396,
-0.11505956202745438,
-0.7302468419075012,
0.6356809139251709,
0.07461950927972794,
0.48200172185897827,
0.6322938799858093,
0.22390145063400269,
0.4739360213279724,
-0.3779304325580597,
0.7356072068214417,
-0.04780072718858719,
-1.2307820320129395,
0.5159850716590881,
-0.46548616886138916,
0.0786043033003807,
0.5599864721298218,
0.538992702960968,
-0.4175475239753723,
-0.6512941122055054,
-0.32021209597587585,
-1.080989122390747,
0.8056387305259705,
-0.15564179420471191,
0.3394692540168762,
-0.06008615344762802,
0.08213260024785995,
0.19556966423988342,
0.40049540996551514,
-0.9079163074493408,
-0.23023909330368042,
0.026617487892508507,
-0.30868345499038696,
0.07228729128837585,
-0.42876169085502625,
-0.25195005536079407,
-0.4389824867248535,
0.8313174843788147,
0.12837666273117065,
-0.07710157334804535,
0.14584609866142273,
-0.4522145390510559,
-0.08528068661689758,
0.3524549603462219,
0.11703438311815262,
0.7582262754440308,
-0.13190238177776337,
-0.05137918144464493,
0.12423917651176453,
-0.33797377347946167,
0.1216038316488266,
0.09689696878194809,
-0.6888075470924377,
-0.03213231638073921,
-0.05887824669480324,
1.0338335037231445,
-0.46296679973602295,
-0.666999340057373,
0.31267061829566956,
0.48391035199165344,
-0.1073753759264946,
-0.25143545866012573,
0.19625800848007202,
-0.33258378505706787,
0.1718548685312271,
0.4892489016056061,
-0.1564655900001526,
0.667199432849884,
-0.45739954710006714,
0.22761042416095734,
0.4532385468482971,
-0.4167170524597168,
-0.020986143499612808,
0.8162228465080261,
0.5011094212532043,
0.17000535130500793,
0.6039535999298096,
-0.052144404500722885,
-0.38687410950660706,
0.809169590473175,
0.24565105140209198,
1.0301216840744019,
-0.23304277658462524,
-0.018069058656692505,
0.29941776394844055,
0.762074887752533,
-0.21417227387428284,
-0.12451601028442383,
0.23058661818504333,
-0.9554948210716248,
-0.5430396199226379,
-0.5261180996894836,
-0.3909299969673157,
0.29339656233787537,
-0.7525471448898315,
0.26874274015426636,
-0.385407954454422,
-0.41485127806663513,
0.21005070209503174,
-0.38662439584732056,
-0.6530358195304871,
0.43253496289253235,
0.3160649538040161,
0.8306616544723511,
-1.0722929239273071,
0.8353728652000427,
0.4843817353248596,
-0.5169355869293213,
-0.2652331590652466,
-0.01755407638847828,
-0.07339170575141907,
-0.8086517453193665,
0.7293412685394287,
0.36882704496383667,
0.22744855284690857,
-0.11123283207416534,
-0.42854419350624084,
-0.7275230884552002,
0.47977739572525024,
0.27259814739227295,
-0.7281376719474792,
0.1587318778038025,
0.45260390639305115,
0.3240874111652374,
-0.345714807510376,
0.31347498297691345,
1.0670069456100464,
0.9049822092056274,
-0.6375899314880371,
-0.9208218455314636,
-0.041721899062395096,
-0.2140199840068817,
0.05703352391719818,
0.30456778407096863,
-0.5371840000152588,
0.597763180732727,
0.32597291469573975,
-0.03566691279411316,
-0.3201603293418884,
0.2350234091281891,
-0.43132543563842773,
0.2733246386051178,
0.6417962312698364,
0.6577787399291992,
0.7503278255462646,
-0.20555567741394043,
0.8427619338035583,
-0.3473628759384155,
0.3494485020637512,
0.9780670404434204,
-0.6858927607536316,
0.31102877855300903,
0.1873323768377304,
-0.25522735714912415,
0.47071030735969543,
0.5740822553634644,
-0.3771926462650299,
0.46804478764533997,
0.2883073389530182,
-0.3903134763240814,
-0.0419115275144577,
-0.47198396921157837,
-0.29742467403411865,
0.5497525930404663,
0.6766030192375183,
-0.6115058064460754,
0.20109640061855316,
0.13399380445480347,
0.0955728217959404,
-0.040688637644052505,
-0.5726906061172485,
0.7776016592979431,
-0.15380528569221497,
-0.7419136166572571,
0.5159783363342285,
0.14640220999717712,
0.833230197429657,
-0.5145025849342346,
0.3425765037536621,
-0.4195711016654968,
0.17732882499694824,
-0.23567257821559906,
-0.6911959648132324,
0.6670746207237244,
0.16029390692710876,
-0.39975088834762573,
-0.13609345257282257,
0.6713256239891052,
-0.45778006315231323,
-0.7209270000457764,
0.14665862917900085,
0.35130906105041504,
-0.07716529816389084,
-0.315019428730011,
-0.5426860451698303,
0.12823356688022614,
0.026310905814170837,
-0.3364220857620239,
0.15320581197738647,
0.336068719625473,
-0.2227308303117752,
0.6694602966308594,
0.33157411217689514,
-0.05506712198257446,
-0.13688822090625763,
0.27226367592811584,
0.8459928035736084,
-0.7099761962890625,
-0.591522216796875,
-0.9479098320007324,
0.27626001834869385,
-0.28063610196113586,
0.1379506140947342,
0.8302929401397705,
0.7548648118972778,
0.9532970786094666,
-0.18666765093803406,
1.2994441986083984,
-0.16136009991168976,
0.6625819802284241,
-0.3614872992038727,
0.8267205357551575,
-0.396202027797699,
0.397802472114563,
-0.26639389991760254,
-1.0889726877212524,
-0.27840399742126465,
0.5306066870689392,
-0.5217354893684387,
0.18614643812179565,
0.5049344897270203,
1.1523029804229736,
-0.0026927448343485594,
-0.3138851225376129,
0.14196699857711792,
0.3697032034397125,
-0.07621567696332932,
0.3525181710720062,
0.6815539598464966,
-0.006509257480502129,
0.27136290073394775,
-0.3760407865047455,
-0.5025730729103088,
-0.15432220697402954,
-0.7323951125144958,
-0.6832423210144043,
-0.30491816997528076,
-0.33604151010513306,
-0.2750798463821411,
-0.06424873322248459,
0.7715638279914856,
0.7622185349464417,
-1.0250831842422485,
-0.2720526158809662,
0.06857641786336899,
0.29426395893096924,
-0.08804386854171753,
-0.3174290955066681,
0.09840614348649979,
-0.26413071155548096,
-1.0964316129684448,
0.2608933746814728,
0.2535803020000458,
-0.1883716881275177,
-0.7254907488822937,
0.3252960443496704,
0.05878462269902229,
0.4232655465602875,
0.501569390296936,
-0.05658871680498123,
-0.327224999666214,
-0.26420265436172485,
-0.2565050721168518,
0.134599968791008,
0.08326003700494766,
0.8612662553787231,
-0.7032598853111267,
0.49006181955337524,
0.5166723728179932,
0.6478313207626343,
0.262282133102417,
-0.013299361802637577,
0.8739751577377319,
-0.8449987173080444,
0.5369919538497925,
0.16724810004234314,
0.2434861958026886,
0.43103986978530884,
-0.4044021666049957,
0.5782892107963562,
0.22443787753582,
-0.4526577591896057,
-1.0805860757827759,
0.45981666445732117,
-0.4662148356437683,
-0.25520655512809753,
1.0514459609985352,
0.2828678488731384,
-0.22374098002910614,
-0.3582440912723541,
-0.1206294447183609,
0.08027581870555878,
-0.32334864139556885,
0.9640923738479614,
0.8188238143920898,
0.27379122376441956,
0.0885058119893074,
-0.5430536270141602,
0.4107648730278015,
0.5210620164871216,
-0.7035010457038879,
0.28440144658088684,
1.225661039352417,
0.08739463984966278,
-0.07510223984718323,
0.4187967777252197,
-0.21148082613945007,
-0.0183697659522295,
0.1568433940410614,
0.15060444176197052,
0.12324429303407669,
-0.1729864478111267,
-0.42508843541145325,
-0.0016330007929354906,
0.28113144636154175,
-0.12761352956295013
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13922v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13922v1
|
Visually Grounded Speech Models have a Mutual Exclusivity Bias
| 2024-03-20T18:49:59 | 2024-03-20T18:49:59 |
Leanne Nortje, Dan Oneaţă, Yevgen Matusevych, Herman Kamper
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, eess.AS
|
When children learn new words, they employ constraints such as the mutual
exclusivity (ME) bias: a novel word is mapped to a novel object rather than a
familiar one. This bias has been studied computationally, but only in models
that use discrete word representations as input, ignoring the high variability
of spoken words. We investigate the ME bias in the context of visually grounded
speech models that learn from natural images and continuous speech audio.
Concretely, we train a model on familiar words and test its ME bias by asking
it to select between a novel and a familiar object when queried with a novel
word. To simulate prior acoustic and visual knowledge, we experiment with
several initialisation strategies using pretrained speech and vision networks.
Our findings reveal the ME bias across the different initialisation approaches,
with a stronger bias in models with more prior (in particular, visual)
knowledge. Additional tests confirm the robustness of our results, even when
different loss functions are considered.
|
[
-0.524258017539978,
-0.6405486464500427,
0.1911715865135193,
-0.10664200782775879,
-0.5327367186546326,
-0.12074034661054611,
-0.18778343498706818,
-0.50582355260849,
-0.04132148250937462,
0.3804682493209839,
-0.5811487436294556,
-0.14974848926067352,
-0.6998603940010071,
-0.3216739892959595,
-0.3896511495113373,
0.72198885679245,
0.12623336911201477,
0.2906022369861603,
-0.5896338224411011,
-0.585465669631958,
-0.511738121509552,
-0.7678809762001038,
-0.19378291070461273,
-0.3750275671482086,
0.3527228832244873,
0.14468538761138916,
0.9203299283981323,
0.43853047490119934,
0.18011771142482758,
0.31103265285491943,
-0.2834419012069702,
-0.1815924495458603,
-0.42173102498054504,
0.2723892629146576,
-0.3893115222454071,
-0.5373970866203308,
0.27526864409446716,
0.3045386075973511,
0.46924254298210144,
0.9039924144744873,
0.010025383904576302,
0.044244762510061264,
0.23945309221744537,
0.5800890326499939,
-0.6401835680007935,
0.33287185430526733,
-0.83199542760849,
0.32915017008781433,
0.10448269546031952,
-0.05352042242884636,
-0.2921389639377594,
-0.09616908431053162,
0.7805432081222534,
-0.678905189037323,
0.38799700140953064,
-0.04259198531508446,
1.2009128332138062,
0.3976404070854187,
-0.3296518325805664,
-0.2163107693195343,
-0.6174353957176208,
0.7565430402755737,
-0.26671916246414185,
0.579506516456604,
0.2139311581850052,
0.37118440866470337,
0.0034239774104207754,
-0.6840854287147522,
-0.7595941424369812,
-0.3274390697479248,
0.06946435570716858,
0.18964172899723053,
-0.09444066137075424,
0.23261313140392303,
0.620535135269165,
0.08500511199235916,
-0.38756152987480164,
-0.16335277259349823,
-0.38976216316223145,
-0.07398881763219833,
0.24001958966255188,
-0.4353492856025696,
0.5695279836654663,
0.012622253969311714,
-0.3937319815158844,
-0.4039344787597656,
-0.6870212554931641,
0.2758687436580658,
0.3861199617385864,
0.135917067527771,
-0.4919246435165405,
0.6574813723564148,
-0.17063815891742706,
0.9466139078140259,
0.05131210759282112,
-0.12391775101423264,
0.34981077909469604,
-0.13251903653144836,
-0.21697284281253815,
0.18756963312625885,
0.3907201886177063,
0.5708327293395996,
0.8194146156311035,
0.10401937365531921,
0.002946164458990097,
0.7463774085044861,
-0.18558333814144135,
-0.3935849964618683,
-0.11640512198209763,
-0.36638304591178894,
-0.43172749876976013,
-0.12135367840528488,
-0.05207338184118271,
-0.5377379655838013,
-0.17699889838695526,
-0.5235556364059448,
0.4352087378501892,
-0.43286222219467163,
-0.24813202023506165,
-0.029862089082598686,
-0.47311699390411377,
0.13822421431541443,
0.11653435230255127,
-0.997933030128479,
0.027946362271904945,
0.3345366418361664,
0.4449092447757721,
0.07596644759178162,
-0.2643924057483673,
-0.6018461585044861,
0.26705482602119446,
-0.37674400210380554,
0.5817645192146301,
-0.8840464949607849,
-0.2359268069267273,
0.04708060249686241,
-0.03513508290052414,
0.13463717699050903,
-0.46309828758239746,
0.31804612278938293,
-0.3880721926689148,
0.4667915105819702,
-0.4392521381378174,
-0.21614795923233032,
-0.3459458351135254,
-0.04998909309506416,
-0.5638957619667053,
0.6669923067092896,
0.056457482278347015,
-0.9013770818710327,
1.3397507667541504,
-0.17135635018348694,
-0.22194263339042664,
-0.40333887934684753,
-1.0346425771713257,
-0.2540101706981659,
0.31311824917793274,
0.27641788125038147,
0.37274107336997986,
-0.00298003270290792,
0.6368763446807861,
-0.48536553978919983,
-0.3481155037879944,
0.062314704060554504,
-0.5754897594451904,
0.4190690219402313,
0.1018499955534935,
-0.6681922078132629,
-0.008133946917951107,
-0.8635820150375366,
-0.24152275919914246,
-0.050079092383384705,
0.019479038193821907,
-0.753350019454956,
0.2563123404979706,
-0.2363799661397934,
0.38438382744789124,
-0.07598605006933212,
-0.5720663070678711,
-0.3596901595592499,
-0.3198423981666565,
0.6106407642364502,
0.8057774305343628,
-0.15690578520298004,
0.5324284434318542,
-0.4799124300479889,
0.303787499666214,
0.5467789173126221,
-0.029253728687763214,
-0.4886058568954468,
-0.5808827877044678,
-0.7436914443969727,
-0.22209532558918,
-0.05935492739081383,
-0.0497361496090889,
-0.8490938544273376,
0.01568259671330452,
-0.3810620903968811,
0.10654216259717941,
-0.16724294424057007,
-0.05132457613945007,
0.47981682419776917,
0.5714571475982666,
0.13674570620059967,
-0.5022681951522827,
-0.4098769724369049,
-1.190191626548767,
-0.2579129934310913,
-0.21759678423404694,
0.06757643073797226,
0.7394385933876038,
0.17021551728248596,
-0.12477069348096848,
1.0647709369659424,
-0.09147301316261292,
-0.17745979130268097,
0.21591386198997498,
0.27103787660598755,
0.20753903687000275,
0.6087524890899658,
0.6632217168807983,
-0.8952522873878479,
-0.3037855923175812,
-0.17204751074314117,
-0.9486402273178101,
0.03141825646162033,
-0.1583426147699356,
-0.03266412019729614,
-0.0030712976586073637,
0.4719594419002533,
-0.19285905361175537,
0.6629809141159058,
0.7143935561180115,
-0.4465467035770416,
0.12047512084245682,
-0.015944577753543854,
-0.09429294615983963,
-0.6243641972541809,
-0.4337165057659149,
0.12126727402210236,
-0.21725355088710785,
-0.24901515245437622,
-0.018109625205397606,
-0.26672276854515076,
-0.08952890336513519,
-0.5750324130058289,
0.4267987310886383,
-0.8653459548950195,
-0.22914712131023407,
-0.051820386201143265,
0.13693535327911377,
0.2693893313407898,
0.45071688294410706,
0.3993539810180664,
0.766430139541626,
0.8138543963432312,
-0.6851455569267273,
0.02157815359532833,
0.11187296360731125,
-0.313047856092453,
0.6634616851806641,
-0.7854956984519958,
0.07911087572574615,
-0.46552374958992004,
-0.08025744557380676,
-1.0452075004577637,
-0.22618989646434784,
-0.05411051958799362,
-0.38512924313545227,
0.5453078746795654,
-0.19603797793388367,
-0.34566110372543335,
-0.2821687161922455,
0.15905015170574188,
0.7187353372573853,
0.5674859285354614,
-0.9446864724159241,
0.410634309053421,
0.588457465171814,
0.05831542983651161,
-0.5573821663856506,
-0.8985921144485474,
-0.14917367696762085,
-0.16129210591316223,
-0.765498161315918,
0.09992338716983795,
0.17422185838222504,
-0.38605329394340515,
0.22688746452331543,
-0.07777293026447296,
-0.21705329418182373,
-0.26661375164985657,
0.7516599893569946,
0.12473699450492859,
-0.0974564254283905,
0.02778146229684353,
0.3071649372577667,
0.06510912626981735,
-0.030976666137576103,
-0.37296831607818604,
0.39792579412460327,
0.09516290575265884,
-0.6572882533073425,
-0.1462331861257553,
0.36998170614242554,
0.6145569086074829,
-0.10489126294851303,
0.36526840925216675,
0.25202906131744385,
-0.4708915948867798,
-0.1509566754102707,
-0.597305417060852,
-0.21357972919940948,
-0.513612687587738,
0.2447253316640854,
-0.4451543390750885,
-1.062565803527832,
0.2913309633731842,
0.3501216769218445,
-0.13259357213974,
-0.0011056462535634637,
0.3973037302494049,
-0.03477224335074425,
0.943492591381073,
0.5796958804130554,
0.01047667395323515,
0.4831385314464569,
-0.13572430610656738,
-0.1632855236530304,
-0.6748591065406799,
-0.3817313015460968,
-0.182803213596344,
-0.3041618764400482,
-0.43463122844696045,
-0.5016969442367554,
0.1953919380903244,
-0.10094316303730011,
-0.196646586060524,
0.0767444372177124,
-0.7120302319526672,
0.476874440908432,
1.037643551826477,
0.21992658078670502,
0.03206462785601616,
0.381439208984375,
-0.7993659377098083,
-0.43524572253227234,
-0.6772898435592651,
-0.31484222412109375,
1.0401283502578735,
0.22672414779663086,
0.7052616477012634,
-0.1813863068819046,
0.45301124453544617,
0.07364944368600845,
0.1434236466884613,
-0.30792587995529175,
0.4116273522377014,
0.07963439077138901,
-0.7812662720680237,
-0.24769531190395355,
-0.07353757321834564,
-0.7186915874481201,
0.38077059388160706,
-0.40113842487335205,
-0.555923581123352,
0.6007182002067566,
0.36572179198265076,
-0.2104841023683548,
0.3012917935848236,
-0.6497427821159363,
0.33458009362220764,
-0.2335100919008255,
-1.0955759286880493,
-0.11274615675210953,
-0.5743234753608704,
0.45229870080947876,
0.0345454066991806,
0.2999618649482727,
-0.07392958551645279,
0.19375242292881012,
0.7740129232406616,
-0.3452456593513489,
0.8393747806549072,
-0.45626991987228394,
0.12445279955863953,
0.5446649193763733,
-0.24865207076072693,
0.26876121759414673,
-0.09150023758411407,
0.2295558899641037,
0.1195143386721611,
-0.04784899950027466,
-0.48303714394569397,
-0.5124046802520752,
0.5809040069580078,
-0.8072270750999451,
-0.5334064364433289,
-0.7234389781951904,
-0.34825870394706726,
-0.2216324359178543,
0.33327019214630127,
0.562262237071991,
0.6445759534835815,
-0.3305298686027527,
0.2802141010761261,
0.6676343083381653,
-0.5491926074028015,
0.33041808009147644,
0.2991160750389099,
-0.4158079922199249,
-0.3841273784637451,
0.6494799852371216,
0.3601321578025818,
0.5392202734947205,
0.1615583896636963,
0.21074947714805603,
-0.25646793842315674,
-0.5408843159675598,
-0.1817944347858429,
-0.037964317947626114,
-0.6828542351722717,
0.3497110903263092,
-0.47484636306762695,
-0.09605758637189865,
-0.13268373906612396,
-0.1889122724533081,
-0.13893462717533112,
-0.46403348445892334,
-0.24203698337078094,
-0.27613213658332825,
0.004976977128535509,
0.5842433571815491,
-0.16515928506851196,
0.3905576765537262,
-0.31699204444885254,
0.5099766254425049,
0.746594250202179,
0.34729868173599243,
-0.10864903032779694,
-0.5412128567695618,
0.03395296633243561,
0.23939521610736847,
-0.04825499281287193,
-0.8241289258003235,
0.268488347530365,
0.48779407143592834,
0.7200493812561035,
0.9739482998847961,
-0.13110554218292236,
0.609702467918396,
-0.6857596039772034,
0.8966522812843323,
0.6410551071166992,
-0.7519676089286804,
0.4793994724750519,
-0.5765587091445923,
0.26954686641693115,
0.7529866695404053,
0.23433056473731995,
-0.28718137741088867,
-0.32664191722869873,
-0.8378227353096008,
-0.5984053015708923,
0.1500258445739746,
-0.01754850707948208,
0.3427799642086029,
-0.15997065603733063,
0.16597792506217957,
0.1846424639225006,
0.5069381594657898,
-0.9101396203041077,
-0.30044224858283997,
-0.43118545413017273,
0.23045946657657623,
-0.11641863733530045,
-0.5558547973632812,
-0.2624640166759491,
-0.39785236120224,
0.26650962233543396,
-0.050121862441301346,
0.3093263804912567,
0.3521246016025543,
-0.2862817049026489,
-0.17272062599658966,
-0.09602256119251251,
0.5237228274345398,
0.4276474714279175,
-0.18505504727363586,
0.34536847472190857,
-0.13776172697544098,
-0.5582086443901062,
0.4127550721168518,
-0.2669925093650818,
-0.5468827486038208,
0.4641103744506836,
0.35985562205314636,
1.0599397420883179,
0.5716041922569275,
-0.6567630767822266,
0.751625657081604,
-0.14074411988258362,
-0.39884817600250244,
-0.41920095682144165,
0.13204160332679749,
-0.10247587412595749,
0.0753513053059578,
0.0690949559211731,
0.34338539838790894,
0.04641863331198692,
-0.6558359861373901,
0.5789294838905334,
0.8661097288131714,
-0.8033851981163025,
-0.3392275869846344,
1.0176993608474731,
-0.032166000455617905,
0.20391255617141724,
0.21455882489681244,
-0.06602269411087036,
-0.5732240080833435,
0.5681421160697937,
0.40860751271247864,
0.8819587826728821,
0.013554609380662441,
0.10799349844455719,
0.3865453898906708,
0.4562649428844452,
0.14568710327148438,
0.3296082615852356,
-0.2197360247373581,
-0.8627396821975708,
-0.10020476579666138,
-0.40374046564102173,
-0.2768460512161255,
0.00454800995066762,
-0.8692992329597473,
0.43355193734169006,
-0.7206938862800598,
-0.23572267591953278,
-0.34510135650634766,
-0.5401721596717834,
-0.7951868176460266,
0.4963592290878296,
0.4812377691268921,
0.6394608020782471,
-1.0375354290008545,
0.7159439325332642,
0.5565441846847534,
-0.2907220423221588,
-0.8930196762084961,
-0.3488050103187561,
-0.027401616796851158,
-0.8881552815437317,
0.6374173164367676,
0.47130268812179565,
-0.0051932428032159805,
-0.15583446621894836,
-0.8614454865455627,
-1.0323072671890259,
0.8394972085952759,
0.29779940843582153,
-0.7325274348258972,
-0.055077213793992996,
0.1443181037902832,
0.3250771760940552,
-0.5242257714271545,
0.41277244687080383,
0.3452024459838867,
0.21643409132957458,
0.31770575046539307,
-0.5805025100708008,
-0.2500881254673004,
-0.4095194637775421,
-0.11296936124563217,
-0.34440815448760986,
-0.5693491697311401,
0.9887218475341797,
-0.1663624346256256,
-0.3950854241847992,
-0.2997095286846161,
0.8509711623191833,
0.35887032747268677,
0.6479794979095459,
0.7231169939041138,
0.6850996613502502,
0.7411834001541138,
-0.16940821707248688,
0.7424946427345276,
-0.37348702549934387,
-0.12570500373840332,
1.5778621435165405,
-0.19249776005744934,
0.6182273626327515,
0.7545614838600159,
-0.0954890325665474,
0.5778810977935791,
0.512423574924469,
0.0953010767698288,
0.8535707592964172,
0.4214969873428345,
-0.3493700921535492,
0.06835078448057175,
-0.33084341883659363,
-0.7239865064620972,
0.368604451417923,
0.2515205442905426,
-0.6114750504493713,
-0.0871879905462265,
0.22664842009544373,
-0.09054916352033615,
0.30097848176956177,
-0.20591166615486145,
0.6551059484481812,
0.2700934410095215,
-0.6794290542602539,
0.6875643730163574,
-0.44921261072158813,
0.716731607913971,
-0.49541139602661133,
0.03541010245680809,
-0.0557798333466053,
-0.14814645051956177,
-0.14495019614696503,
-0.23700833320617676,
0.10260917991399765,
-0.23985280096530914,
-0.30541694164276123,
0.16756287217140198,
0.5933670997619629,
-0.5358532071113586,
-0.4306594729423523,
0.4570598304271698,
0.3085404932498932,
-0.1296825110912323,
-0.030232783406972885,
-0.5505517721176147,
0.11534880101680756,
0.16696926951408386,
0.002504089381545782,
0.23716041445732117,
0.49156635999679565,
-0.01305426750332117,
0.6562370657920837,
0.8165797591209412,
0.37115681171417236,
0.7864124774932861,
-0.0013412934495136142,
0.9948976039886475,
-0.34284910559654236,
-0.7401905059814453,
-0.7132967114448547,
0.3692862391471863,
-0.15652695298194885,
-0.007782423868775368,
0.6683263778686523,
0.3781059682369232,
0.8505515456199646,
-0.00790307205170393,
1.0101127624511719,
0.43343812227249146,
0.32031577825546265,
-0.5700705647468567,
0.7534191608428955,
-0.4018308222293854,
0.076894611120224,
-0.8099803328514099,
-1.0651952028274536,
-0.06506823748350143,
0.8349078297615051,
-0.3455769121646881,
-0.05349168926477432,
0.6314335465431213,
0.6110047101974487,
-0.14124087989330292,
0.2026163786649704,
0.6285056471824646,
-0.02916136384010315,
0.18309202790260315,
0.4614337384700775,
1.1550222635269165,
-0.11508991569280624,
-0.042011212557554245,
-0.4584181606769562,
-0.5449874997138977,
0.21607184410095215,
-0.9456050395965576,
-1.1506997346878052,
-0.4401666522026062,
-0.35324373841285706,
-0.43876123428344727,
0.27817729115486145,
0.8528227806091309,
1.002639889717102,
-0.6180367469787598,
0.03050200082361698,
-0.3304522633552551,
-0.1485300213098526,
0.12383031100034714,
-0.1352965533733368,
0.048760831356048584,
-0.05547032132744789,
-0.7505955100059509,
0.15712109208106995,
0.17122520506381989,
0.37284913659095764,
-0.3195405602455139,
-0.06470046937465668,
-0.17857344448566437,
0.18907268345355988,
0.32074475288391113,
0.389250248670578,
-0.5611798167228699,
-0.5047544240951538,
-0.3346226215362549,
0.14409279823303223,
0.25418218970298767,
0.5711915493011475,
-1.0847569704055786,
1.010545015335083,
0.42844676971435547,
0.3285003900527954,
0.6049081087112427,
-0.005981636233627796,
0.7837402820587158,
-0.4884320795536041,
1.0017095804214478,
0.01485543604940176,
0.5418897867202759,
0.3817428946495056,
-0.10169252753257751,
0.3051128089427948,
0.6088818311691284,
-0.20749609172344208,
-0.8598116636276245,
0.4427925944328308,
-0.7523126006126404,
0.06459520012140274,
0.9940206408500671,
-0.12590080499649048,
-0.23654168844223022,
0.012104172259569168,
-0.09757833927869797,
0.26829442381858826,
-0.14085105061531067,
0.3244560956954956,
0.7124443650245667,
0.4177476763725281,
-0.12405166029930115,
-0.512857973575592,
0.4649483859539032,
0.5783494710922241,
0.054517850279808044,
-0.5209053754806519,
0.6279228329658508,
0.19969674944877625,
0.18302024900913239,
0.40866124629974365,
-0.16830500960350037,
0.16212619841098785,
0.3190211355686188,
0.011361265555024147,
-0.12333396822214127,
-0.46416640281677246,
-0.5596463680267334,
0.16610795259475708,
0.09308509528636932,
-0.42104604840278625
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13903v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13903v1
|
Leveraging Linguistically Enhanced Embeddings for Open Information Extraction
| 2024-03-20T18:18:48 | 2024-03-20T18:18:48 |
Fauzan Farooqui, Thanmay Jayakumar, Pulkit Mathur, Mansi Radke
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Open Information Extraction (OIE) is a structured prediction (SP) task in
Natural Language Processing (NLP) that aims to extract structured $n$-ary
tuples - usually subject-relation-object triples - from free text. The word
embeddings in the input text can be enhanced with linguistic features, usually
Part-of-Speech (PoS) and Syntactic Dependency Parse (SynDP) labels. However,
past enhancement techniques cannot leverage the power of pretrained language
models (PLMs), which themselves have been hardly used for OIE. To bridge this
gap, we are the first to leverage linguistic features with a Seq2Seq PLM for
OIE. We do so by introducing two methods - Weighted Addition and Linearized
Concatenation. Our work can give any neural OIE architecture the key
performance boost from both PLMs and linguistic features in one go. In our
settings, this shows wide improvements of up to 24.9%, 27.3% and 14.9% on
Precision, Recall and F1 scores respectively over the baseline. Beyond this, we
address other important challenges in the field: to reduce compute overheads
with the features, we are the first ones to exploit Semantic Dependency Parse
(SemDP) tags; to address flaws in current datasets, we create a clean synthetic
dataset; finally, we contribute the first known study of OIE behaviour in SP
models.
|
[
-0.4542672634124756,
-0.6434596180915833,
0.3544403910636902,
0.0003074797277804464,
-0.07479585707187653,
-0.23940211534500122,
-0.42716455459594727,
-0.764369547367096,
0.263206422328949,
0.5197200179100037,
-0.17178048193454742,
-0.46738937497138977,
-0.6502185463905334,
-0.12337398529052734,
0.11391802132129669,
0.8151555061340332,
0.02122853323817253,
-0.07071901112794876,
-0.08418432623147964,
-0.35010892152786255,
-0.41679567098617554,
-0.5322597026824951,
-0.2029377669095993,
0.0854877382516861,
0.26069438457489014,
0.32805612683296204,
0.6048465967178345,
0.728679895401001,
0.32248082756996155,
0.17473731935024261,
0.053582485765218735,
0.2464078813791275,
-0.6599364876747131,
0.1320108324289322,
-0.28620055317878723,
-0.5489096641540527,
-0.47689947485923767,
0.23207053542137146,
0.6305341124534607,
0.8837488889694214,
-0.06046633794903755,
0.2918025255203247,
0.20406222343444824,
0.41971632838249207,
-1.0616570711135864,
0.44931715726852417,
-0.6838991641998291,
0.08963317424058914,
-0.3415561616420746,
-0.2646622061729431,
-0.42801597714424133,
-0.32513198256492615,
0.20353838801383972,
-0.7455285787582397,
-0.168499156832695,
-0.12867328524589539,
0.8691956996917725,
0.26938748359680176,
-0.00564225297421217,
-0.31245627999305725,
-0.6538230180740356,
0.7002626061439514,
-0.6646669507026672,
0.64284747838974,
0.23282119631767273,
0.0283244289457798,
-0.17401456832885742,
-0.8837446570396423,
-0.558424711227417,
0.023134609684348106,
-0.05716738477349281,
0.1104472205042839,
-0.12165933102369308,
0.022552451118826866,
0.27399301528930664,
0.4498884379863739,
-0.19111089408397675,
0.1740724742412567,
-0.3321605622768402,
0.04116535186767578,
0.42520132660865784,
-0.3686392605304718,
0.27733364701271057,
-0.01649552769958973,
-0.5427462458610535,
-0.11657445877790451,
-0.5701130032539368,
0.16072045266628265,
0.34701570868492126,
0.4312407672405243,
0.18212075531482697,
1.0118688344955444,
-0.04436745494604111,
0.3277132213115692,
-0.11516784131526947,
0.1433320939540863,
0.46901220083236694,
-0.2559460699558258,
-0.23601657152175903,
0.22538836300373077,
0.7762421369552612,
0.10163255780935287,
0.33160051703453064,
-0.28278204798698425,
-0.22034378349781036,
-0.12202849984169006,
0.07335928082466125,
-0.8209735155105591,
-0.06641553342342377,
0.301868200302124,
-0.5533002018928528,
-0.10866691172122955,
0.5432180762290955,
-0.9811999797821045,
-0.4047866463661194,
-0.16299495100975037,
0.4622930884361267,
-0.8088198900222778,
-0.4250107705593109,
0.4443155825138092,
-0.3981313407421112,
0.12416242808103561,
0.1903209239244461,
-0.6987536549568176,
0.3405793607234955,
0.8593888878822327,
0.8029263019561768,
0.05501200631260872,
-0.07223464548587799,
-0.8940138220787048,
0.21949565410614014,
0.07072761654853821,
0.5136496424674988,
-0.867806077003479,
-0.06560569256544113,
0.06348834186792374,
-0.21143732964992523,
-0.21266232430934906,
-0.46529656648635864,
0.5471343398094177,
-0.4848395586013794,
0.41932570934295654,
-0.003255712566897273,
-0.6814603805541992,
-0.1095675453543663,
-0.04852887988090515,
-0.8401378989219666,
1.3174604177474976,
0.17828625440597534,
-0.904242217540741,
0.29825013875961304,
-1.0628108978271484,
-0.11652995645999908,
0.10901331156492233,
-0.32479730248451233,
-0.13243511319160461,
0.3969652056694031,
0.3075912296772003,
0.2863219380378723,
-0.0784306675195694,
0.04988740012049675,
-0.3916528522968292,
-0.0937223732471466,
-0.03447681665420532,
-0.03299187496304512,
0.7701965570449829,
0.1039167270064354,
-0.24249377846717834,
-0.12804047763347626,
-0.9346042275428772,
0.17123161256313324,
0.24678856134414673,
-0.4187883734703064,
-0.7213068604469299,
0.10186455398797989,
-0.24970440566539764,
0.04730246588587761,
0.30053475499153137,
-0.9836079478263855,
0.3476722538471222,
-0.8115602731704712,
0.3353298008441925,
0.6176182627677917,
-0.013018467463552952,
0.6679598689079285,
0.13373549282550812,
0.24818865954875946,
-0.07070425897836685,
-0.06528433412313461,
-0.2589947283267975,
-0.6563446521759033,
-0.30641651153564453,
-0.5567885637283325,
0.5448167324066162,
0.7640263438224792,
-0.7433521151542664,
0.5628872513771057,
-0.43425336480140686,
-0.23091010749340057,
-0.9500404000282288,
-0.008434552699327469,
0.2717633843421936,
0.3126392960548401,
0.4795248210430145,
-0.2683984041213989,
-0.609992265701294,
-0.6090570092201233,
-0.41151025891304016,
0.05976470932364464,
-0.30471158027648926,
0.1859455108642578,
0.280734121799469,
0.18790531158447266,
1.0756351947784424,
-0.6736122965812683,
-0.4464454650878906,
-0.16769835352897644,
0.11194435507059097,
0.31406983733177185,
0.3865502178668976,
0.5311928391456604,
-0.6929982900619507,
-0.2497551441192627,
-0.051937878131866455,
-0.8180909156799316,
-0.1552874594926834,
0.2762914299964905,
-0.1692935675382614,
0.08726488053798676,
0.5291398167610168,
-0.7186275720596313,
0.6235042214393616,
0.25133398175239563,
-0.44027021527290344,
0.19673247635364532,
-0.04932472109794617,
-0.1399865299463272,
-0.9267744421958923,
0.09978169947862625,
-0.08702094852924347,
-0.06957151740789413,
-0.6575103998184204,
0.1797846406698227,
-0.04818699136376381,
-0.2760353684425354,
-0.4705709218978882,
0.4342309534549713,
-0.6362249255180359,
-0.052034709602594376,
-0.07011442631483078,
0.2564614713191986,
0.08963041007518768,
0.5117902755737305,
0.12235317379236221,
0.5671265125274658,
0.3369143307209015,
-0.43481817841529846,
-0.11257655918598175,
0.3835618793964386,
-0.4138656556606293,
0.19182896614074707,
-0.5095478892326355,
0.3014223277568817,
-0.4001061022281647,
-0.17863979935646057,
-0.6445788145065308,
0.02948048710823059,
0.23348228633403778,
-0.5416432023048401,
0.5331100225448608,
0.11189775913953781,
-0.5415583848953247,
0.030090469866991043,
-0.527349054813385,
0.31679800152778625,
0.3811333477497101,
-0.6926079988479614,
0.6741975545883179,
0.6648130416870117,
-0.3493671715259552,
-0.5427685976028442,
-0.4696212112903595,
-0.13988864421844482,
0.1529574990272522,
-0.7562594413757324,
0.4715751111507416,
0.3221209943294525,
-0.21117301285266876,
0.3897073566913605,
-0.15483355522155762,
0.07341586798429489,
0.27092504501342773,
0.13885942101478577,
0.2254357486963272,
-0.5944985747337341,
0.2386389821767807,
-0.20068660378456116,
-0.00005825972039019689,
-0.10664582997560501,
-0.594792366027832,
0.6270097494125366,
-0.10905656963586807,
-0.1686122566461563,
-0.3185912072658539,
0.5243504047393799,
0.17713120579719543,
-0.7760197520256042,
1.0847285985946655,
0.6927163600921631,
-0.700414776802063,
-0.16499581933021545,
-0.43162551522254944,
-0.05229218304157257,
-0.3729732930660248,
0.41103851795196533,
-0.460928350687027,
-0.9564716815948486,
0.10603348165750504,
-0.16015978157520294,
0.2632955014705658,
0.48601579666137695,
0.0420619398355484,
0.016019945964217186,
0.9808493256568909,
0.8213273882865906,
0.07318153232336044,
0.7038466930389404,
-0.23994548618793488,
0.28774353861808777,
-0.694536566734314,
-0.43040046095848083,
-0.6979007124900818,
-0.20998260378837585,
-0.7052461504936218,
-0.48184141516685486,
0.27045679092407227,
0.5918833613395691,
0.12018421292304993,
0.21554885804653168,
-0.2961883246898651,
0.2273070514202118,
0.7232686281204224,
0.20973770320415497,
0.011159450747072697,
0.09153202921152115,
-0.006203805562108755,
0.09290853887796402,
-0.6116517186164856,
-0.45296159386634827,
1.0900110006332397,
0.6462389230728149,
0.5759909152984619,
0.1527376025915146,
0.7458300590515137,
0.09621382504701614,
-0.049678295850753784,
-0.8135852217674255,
0.5451347231864929,
-0.3694300651550293,
-0.10419721156358719,
-0.34237775206565857,
-0.37410715222358704,
-0.7951446771621704,
0.12007454037666321,
-0.5166735053062439,
-1.0274991989135742,
0.42584478855133057,
-0.1009979397058487,
-0.26580312848091125,
0.3705560863018036,
-0.7936334609985352,
0.6326487064361572,
-0.0893847867846489,
-0.4636278748512268,
-0.002948412438854575,
-0.5609254240989685,
0.009374034591019154,
0.2999289035797119,
0.14643917977809906,
-0.013103201054036617,
-0.3335011899471283,
0.6846179962158203,
-0.4180234670639038,
0.6169549822807312,
-0.6102091670036316,
-0.03775525838136673,
0.24271199107170105,
-0.164484441280365,
0.510688841342926,
-0.18758301436901093,
-0.3342452943325043,
0.4761219918727875,
-0.0946538895368576,
-0.3752269148826599,
-0.6713064312934875,
0.4989776015281677,
-0.6978678703308105,
-0.42009031772613525,
-0.3043096363544464,
-0.2520692050457001,
-0.2555553615093231,
0.2344272881746292,
0.08779171109199524,
0.48661497235298157,
-0.15829141438007355,
0.42730438709259033,
0.7678884267807007,
-0.3821784257888794,
0.3982659876346588,
0.19153332710266113,
-0.1465669721364975,
-0.7288281321525574,
0.933583676815033,
0.1807917207479477,
0.21797427535057068,
0.6242967247962952,
0.348711758852005,
-0.26063743233680725,
-0.6173320412635803,
-0.21868157386779785,
0.22701866924762726,
-0.6096051931381226,
-0.18971076607704163,
-0.8509225845336914,
-0.29554128646850586,
-0.7578649520874023,
0.3045903444290161,
-0.2461727410554886,
-0.7742900252342224,
-0.30539727210998535,
-0.2502579987049103,
-0.0053957197815179825,
0.806626558303833,
-0.04009649157524109,
0.07227447628974915,
-1.0100383758544922,
0.4554515779018402,
-0.23414435982704163,
0.5684917569160461,
-0.34782978892326355,
-0.14310301840305328,
-0.29596829414367676,
-0.02210075780749321,
-0.15944521129131317,
-1.000943899154663,
0.2511955797672272,
0.6797406077384949,
0.8191419243812561,
0.38948315382003784,
0.059850748628377914,
0.5823652744293213,
-0.37911558151245117,
0.7781899571418762,
0.006588764488697052,
-0.7426167130470276,
0.671259880065918,
0.043546173721551895,
0.042644206434488297,
0.5173935890197754,
0.5553439855575562,
0.011175916530191898,
-0.2514304518699646,
-0.5463783144950867,
-0.9692022800445557,
0.8789209127426147,
0.3169286251068115,
-0.278055876493454,
-0.2374730408191681,
0.41063424944877625,
0.39326074719429016,
0.45271027088165283,
-0.5719054937362671,
-0.13637809455394745,
-0.23527783155441284,
-0.49912363290786743,
0.08682983368635178,
-0.4674268960952759,
0.3087480366230011,
0.11464572697877884,
0.7416549324989319,
-0.09285575151443481,
0.37088286876678467,
0.46484506130218506,
-0.3087019920349121,
0.05102727189660072,
0.35118043422698975,
0.11328870803117752,
0.2809150815010071,
-0.49478599429130554,
0.08586476743221283,
-0.225163534283638,
-0.5956401824951172,
-0.5278594493865967,
0.4328460097312927,
-0.21906214952468872,
0.06901020556688309,
0.31379806995391846,
0.9887963533401489,
0.11123258620500565,
-0.5815326571464539,
0.6318159699440002,
0.09366462379693985,
-0.03866571560502052,
-0.18694953620433807,
-0.07695016264915466,
-0.31415843963623047,
0.3182579576969147,
0.139712393283844,
0.13372008502483368,
0.28654345870018005,
-0.7560206651687622,
0.1895454078912735,
0.495413601398468,
-0.4580143690109253,
-0.4205387234687805,
0.5213335752487183,
0.13016849756240845,
-0.2750900387763977,
0.5030845403671265,
-0.02583722583949566,
-0.36140158772468567,
0.2504226565361023,
0.5429587960243225,
0.879063606262207,
-0.20921599864959717,
-0.12418682128190994,
0.3914625346660614,
0.38927996158599854,
0.15619558095932007,
0.6044759750366211,
-0.14277318120002747,
-0.7336146831512451,
-0.3360728621482849,
-0.8823692202568054,
-0.0166245698928833,
0.2292552888393402,
-0.9093585014343262,
0.44797614216804504,
-0.2872714698314667,
-0.001893803128041327,
0.06279610842466354,
-0.13124297559261322,
-0.7979545593261719,
-0.044014718383550644,
0.36906638741493225,
1.3355132341384888,
-0.558720052242279,
0.7686993479728699,
0.8230316042900085,
-0.4567504823207855,
-0.5643042325973511,
-0.032241303473711014,
-0.39431115984916687,
-0.7322542667388916,
0.4272397756576538,
0.5789594650268555,
0.13707749545574188,
-0.02731023170053959,
-0.40235990285873413,
-0.7402191162109375,
0.9958139061927795,
0.4764399528503418,
-0.4070935845375061,
-0.33208924531936646,
0.36433106660842896,
0.2789326310157776,
-0.6134902238845825,
0.3090866506099701,
0.5092192888259888,
0.3805890679359436,
-0.1673291027545929,
-0.7842301726341248,
0.12658680975437164,
-0.4267392158508301,
-0.160785511136055,
0.5668450593948364,
-0.12102789431810379,
0.7509349584579468,
-0.24554744362831116,
-0.5731031894683838,
0.06258200109004974,
0.7609164714813232,
-0.16325286030769348,
0.350272536277771,
0.6827509999275208,
0.797990083694458,
0.9051092267036438,
-0.035588525235652924,
1.0401346683502197,
-0.251433402299881,
0.06584201008081436,
1.4335204362869263,
-0.35620057582855225,
1.2603975534439087,
0.4705878496170044,
0.12028505653142929,
0.5318043828010559,
0.19286812841892242,
0.19629983603954315,
0.5879244804382324,
-0.04486590623855591,
-0.18887504935264587,
0.03294387087225914,
-0.5052186846733093,
-0.35203009843826294,
0.7184902429580688,
0.6424233913421631,
-0.5015826225280762,
-0.19771650433540344,
0.20972740650177002,
-0.10372333228588104,
0.22749026119709015,
-0.2984716296195984,
1.1592235565185547,
-0.13265474140644073,
-0.5816322565078735,
0.17319361865520477,
-0.0590897873044014,
0.48293206095695496,
-0.6957894563674927,
-0.4487574100494385,
0.3333536684513092,
0.18064498901367188,
-0.20456092059612274,
-0.8590744137763977,
0.2732681334018707,
-0.17184728384017944,
-0.07324156910181046,
-0.2925295829772949,
0.9975674152374268,
-0.5337762832641602,
-0.0703314021229744,
0.5984900593757629,
0.4921484589576721,
0.07003161311149597,
-0.36764785647392273,
-0.23658967018127441,
-0.16744351387023926,
0.032583292573690414,
-0.3388601839542389,
0.19585101306438446,
0.6271013617515564,
0.04844740405678749,
0.11810091137886047,
0.6868895292282104,
0.34852632880210876,
0.24064286053180695,
0.04332663491368294,
1.1124677658081055,
-0.6887858510017395,
-0.4500543773174286,
-0.7299774289131165,
0.6491022109985352,
-0.3157327473163605,
-0.10510488599538803,
0.4780113399028778,
0.6541720032691956,
0.9926449656486511,
0.011582598090171814,
0.96990966796875,
-0.2972227931022644,
0.5315889120101929,
-0.8188718557357788,
0.31696411967277527,
-0.43704625964164734,
0.22560326755046844,
0.06710398197174072,
-0.9442647099494934,
0.05550502985715866,
0.18510788679122925,
-0.20501011610031128,
-0.40975072979927063,
0.7475501894950867,
0.5869030952453613,
-0.003256189404055476,
0.35091665387153625,
0.17458857595920563,
0.3486948013305664,
0.24224036931991577,
0.4767810106277466,
0.6676227450370789,
-0.3642364740371704,
0.48855024576187134,
-0.37883439660072327,
-0.5901755690574646,
0.08276262879371643,
-0.9179220795631409,
-0.746097207069397,
-0.38335704803466797,
-0.2130466103553772,
-0.3703368902206421,
0.006044710520654917,
1.0443322658538818,
0.4449123442173004,
-0.8594964742660522,
0.2019885927438736,
-0.04895394295454025,
-0.1314481645822525,
-0.15278466045856476,
-0.28424954414367676,
0.19664537906646729,
-0.3177728056907654,
-0.5674944519996643,
0.6680675745010376,
0.4470736086368561,
-0.17128297686576843,
0.01039078924804926,
0.18138961493968964,
-0.5241090655326843,
0.0354580394923687,
0.580665647983551,
0.21501262485980988,
-0.3658236265182495,
-0.5332799553871155,
0.062105290591716766,
0.1813661903142929,
0.20958611369132996,
0.8300769329071045,
-0.7815869450569153,
0.517174243927002,
0.7105734944343567,
0.8492634892463684,
0.2228248119354248,
0.11459566652774811,
0.6972598433494568,
-0.8567579984664917,
0.22052542865276337,
0.35673463344573975,
0.46762755513191223,
0.13203835487365723,
-0.43697524070739746,
0.6066256761550903,
0.2330479919910431,
-0.19482341408729553,
-0.7765985727310181,
0.194715678691864,
-0.8865793943405151,
-0.12272612005472183,
1.017237901687622,
-0.5181015729904175,
-0.4743780493736267,
-0.018251750618219376,
-0.18562544882297516,
0.34229204058647156,
-0.5057694911956787,
0.3040062189102173,
0.3155553340911865,
0.06775064021348953,
0.08967650681734085,
-0.5214619636535645,
0.20802825689315796,
0.10335489362478256,
-0.7552456855773926,
-0.19628092646598816,
0.37666574120521545,
0.0159468911588192,
0.5340893268585205,
0.402596652507782,
-0.38319242000579834,
0.057402677834033966,
0.04450073093175888,
0.28228119015693665,
-0.44478699564933777,
-0.4215613603591919,
-0.29893988370895386,
0.677470326423645,
-0.024237781763076782,
-0.6310033798217773
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13901v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13901v1
|
Train & Constrain: Phonologically Informed Tongue-Twister Generation from Topics and Paraphrases
| 2024-03-20T18:13:17 | 2024-03-20T18:13:17 |
Tyler Loakman, Chen Tang, Chenghua Lin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Previous work in phonologically and phonetically grounded language generation
has mainly focused on domains such as puns and poetry. In this article, we
present new work on the generation of tongue-twisters - a form of language that
is required to be conditioned on a phoneme level to maximize sound overlap,
whilst maintaining semantic consistency with an input topic and still being
grammatically correct. We present TwisterLister, a pipeline for generating
phonologically informed tongue-twisters from Large Language Models (LLMs) that
we use to generate TwistList 2.0, the largest annotated dataset of
tongue-twisters to date, consisting of 17K+ examples from a combination of
human and LLM authors. Our generation pipeline involves the use of a
phonologically constrained vocabulary alongside LLM prompting to generate
novel, non-derivative tongue-twister examples. We additionally present the
results of automatic and human evaluation of smaller models trained on our
generated dataset to demonstrate the extent to which phonologically motivated
language types can be generated without explicit injection of phonological
knowledge. Additionally, we introduce a Phoneme-Aware Constrained Decoding
module (PACD) that can be integrated into any causal language model and
demonstrate that this method generates good quality tongue-twisters both with
and without fine-tuning the underlying language model. We also design and
implement a range of automatic metrics for the task of tongue-twister
generation that is phonologically motivated and captures the unique essence of
tongue-twisters based on Phonemic Edit Distance (PED).
|
[
-0.2994939684867859,
-0.4788415729999542,
0.3529593348503113,
-0.14535978436470032,
-0.39221906661987305,
-0.08294899016618729,
-0.006566023454070091,
-0.08656767010688782,
0.30634066462516785,
0.8897143006324768,
-0.39003920555114746,
-0.08105780929327011,
-0.4208301603794098,
0.012725571170449257,
-0.4061669111251831,
1.0272797346115112,
0.32169973850250244,
-0.14952236413955688,
0.09436017274856567,
0.23361872136592865,
-0.49168774485588074,
-0.18067581951618195,
-0.31309428811073303,
-0.6651107668876648,
0.33166584372520447,
0.4508519768714905,
0.6254861354827881,
0.7175614237785339,
-0.04052641615271568,
0.27196282148361206,
-0.3132742941379547,
0.057868294417858124,
-0.43317100405693054,
0.406716525554657,
-0.2729993164539337,
-0.4044216275215149,
0.04286394640803337,
-0.06194736436009407,
0.17549069225788116,
0.7593470811843872,
-0.11603033542633057,
-0.14379873871803284,
-0.19249242544174194,
0.3386276364326477,
-0.47026142477989197,
-0.18676427006721497,
-0.9724284410476685,
0.09606417268514633,
-0.3806852102279663,
-0.3320539593696594,
-0.45862072706222534,
-0.5393257141113281,
0.26730987429618835,
-0.5440348386764526,
0.36683204770088196,
-0.06380770355463028,
0.599330723285675,
0.28782734274864197,
-0.5824344158172607,
-0.6769574284553528,
-0.622248649597168,
0.2529187798500061,
-0.4464362561702728,
0.7121337056159973,
0.15105868875980377,
0.19010533392429352,
-0.40139907598495483,
-0.7421183586120605,
-0.6752646565437317,
-0.1792612373828888,
0.1482500582933426,
-0.04492919519543648,
0.19856303930282593,
0.07684825360774994,
0.05791524052619934,
0.4298846423625946,
-0.6600965261459351,
0.12277896702289581,
-0.24822597205638885,
-0.2853291630744934,
0.40555253624916077,
0.07148933410644531,
0.2783198356628418,
-0.46659502387046814,
-0.006277021020650864,
-0.24066953361034393,
-0.649025022983551,
0.013953180983662605,
0.6541949510574341,
-0.0026696568820625544,
0.1845887303352356,
0.8355594873428345,
0.0365120954811573,
0.3473780155181885,
0.6050103306770325,
-0.3483029007911682,
0.1307101547718048,
-0.023262398317456245,
0.13301046192646027,
0.1799222081899643,
0.7565918564796448,
0.2217588871717453,
0.4497237801551819,
-0.5047216415405273,
-0.34015658497810364,
-0.06939780712127686,
0.1688302755355835,
-0.7128580212593079,
-0.5180584192276001,
0.2623809278011322,
0.1464233547449112,
-0.4910981357097626,
0.06960587948560715,
-0.9621957540512085,
-0.7144855856895447,
-0.1141335591673851,
0.22003675997257233,
-0.8037682771682739,
-0.6403487324714661,
0.19723279774188995,
-0.5096874833106995,
0.24726161360740662,
-0.335578054189682,
-0.9759193658828735,
0.12278638780117035,
0.699457049369812,
0.4297848641872406,
-0.0006560590118169785,
-0.5356196761131287,
-0.7018237709999084,
0.14202357828617096,
-0.2741185426712036,
0.5347223281860352,
-0.43199050426483154,
-0.5950663089752197,
0.3525221645832062,
-0.14525938034057617,
0.05074642598628998,
-0.7949063777923584,
0.6266361474990845,
-0.3654601275920868,
0.17499428987503052,
0.17388451099395752,
-0.8033949732780457,
0.06696118414402008,
-0.028582867234945297,
-0.6347752213478088,
0.8974498510360718,
0.18020980060100555,
-0.6727108955383301,
0.6803918480873108,
-0.05920363962650299,
-0.5900920629501343,
0.24737787246704102,
-0.13786917924880981,
-0.40378761291503906,
0.29756084084510803,
0.21667860448360443,
0.2072179764509201,
-0.39127054810523987,
0.8970573544502258,
0.140628844499588,
0.019530577585101128,
0.4792751669883728,
-0.1718488335609436,
0.44798123836517334,
0.1707805097103119,
-0.5959307551383972,
0.06722167879343033,
-0.9490670561790466,
-0.11557832360267639,
-0.008148940280079842,
-0.38704678416252136,
-0.18517832458019257,
-0.2802521288394928,
0.06209546700119972,
0.35344502329826355,
-0.05607612803578377,
-0.42578527331352234,
0.07422935962677002,
-0.5496432185173035,
0.7285211086273193,
0.4062670171260834,
0.4862413704395294,
0.4867880642414093,
-0.2005697637796402,
0.5048323273658752,
0.3497775197029114,
0.10740187764167786,
-0.3341679573059082,
-0.27874529361724854,
-0.8365831971168518,
0.1423739790916443,
0.42185965180397034,
0.40847426652908325,
-0.9683652520179749,
0.6702159643173218,
-0.414334237575531,
-0.5864114761352539,
-0.5197072625160217,
0.1032152771949768,
0.3547813892364502,
0.3519655764102936,
0.19019107520580292,
-0.29283106327056885,
-0.47312089800834656,
-0.6098541021347046,
-0.35964953899383545,
-0.09229137748479843,
0.017822034657001495,
-0.06947579979896545,
0.1951855719089508,
0.12769703567028046,
0.882841944694519,
-0.22035253047943115,
0.26642993092536926,
-0.2757827043533325,
0.2351350039243698,
0.14227207005023956,
0.6390673518180847,
0.13686123490333557,
-0.8316291570663452,
-0.08993876725435257,
-0.11197769641876221,
-0.24143917858600616,
-0.22416925430297852,
-0.25519517064094543,
-0.02545551024377346,
-0.1334785521030426,
0.4563843905925751,
-0.9931416511535645,
-0.025627974420785904,
0.12000872194766998,
-0.48104628920555115,
0.7647542953491211,
0.02470572106540203,
-0.28132471442222595,
-0.8666090965270996,
-0.17900557816028595,
0.16225337982177734,
-0.10665817558765411,
-0.8679993748664856,
-0.14497077465057373,
-0.12210225313901901,
-0.4744874835014343,
-0.4658190906047821,
0.5570580363273621,
-0.33799976110458374,
0.314292311668396,
-0.30214834213256836,
0.15510861575603485,
-0.15063901245594025,
0.44235190749168396,
0.24433255195617676,
0.49643397331237793,
0.6316649913787842,
-0.7441748380661011,
0.15261243283748627,
0.1491367518901825,
-0.061888258904218674,
0.5521258115768433,
-0.5182613730430603,
0.33617594838142395,
0.07910151779651642,
0.16190578043460846,
-0.3658410608768463,
-0.4213668704032898,
0.16933046281337738,
-0.25803810358047485,
0.37068110704421997,
-0.3893490731716156,
-0.2628752291202545,
-0.5069716572761536,
-0.2184114009141922,
0.2611910402774811,
0.8052843809127808,
-0.6348348259925842,
0.42170989513397217,
0.5214430689811707,
0.04330574348568916,
-0.2728296220302582,
-0.5128072500228882,
-0.06730255484580994,
-0.5777106881141663,
-0.5316544771194458,
0.09344707429409027,
0.0692591741681099,
-0.11527293920516968,
-0.20772184431552887,
-0.2935192286968231,
-0.005639152135699987,
-0.3235725462436676,
0.17847061157226562,
-0.32470619678497314,
-0.06781066954135895,
0.17756888270378113,
0.15551696717739105,
-0.07240571826696396,
0.22845900058746338,
-0.9614710211753845,
0.6552533507347107,
0.3034675419330597,
-0.08430081605911255,
-0.264477014541626,
-0.005029136780649424,
0.5518673062324524,
-0.23455549776554108,
0.23518110811710358,
0.7231296896934509,
-0.2743275463581085,
-0.34617701172828674,
-0.7098308801651001,
-0.4158633351325989,
-0.48104965686798096,
0.07228699326515198,
-0.7041370272636414,
-0.7993807792663574,
0.19122517108917236,
-0.422101765871048,
-0.34546807408332825,
0.12433678656816483,
0.5826025605201721,
0.3508570194244385,
0.6119859218597412,
0.44854146242141724,
0.13139380514621735,
0.3050757050514221,
-0.17093375325202942,
0.09438040852546692,
-0.6357431411743164,
-0.2857665717601776,
-0.22257250547409058,
-0.022844476625323296,
-1.012732744216919,
-0.05432165414094925,
0.16926410794258118,
0.225199356675148,
-0.12764349579811096,
0.3067646026611328,
-0.6649472713470459,
0.5263783931732178,
0.6507909297943115,
0.005354715045541525,
-0.05735365301370621,
-0.43900611996650696,
-0.3201090097427368,
0.0758390724658966,
-0.66791832447052,
-0.4044659435749054,
1.0276422500610352,
0.16081540286540985,
0.403399258852005,
-0.012767447158694267,
0.8535667657852173,
-0.020556466653943062,
-0.35042330622673035,
-0.7703241109848022,
0.5081625580787659,
-0.01137896254658699,
-0.36939337849617004,
-0.17592978477478027,
-0.301605224609375,
-0.9724310636520386,
0.012569904327392578,
-0.09554670006036758,
-0.8257870674133301,
0.2479899376630783,
0.08946403861045837,
0.04250834137201309,
0.07488114386796951,
-0.6653082370758057,
0.7066051363945007,
-0.23464137315750122,
-0.35068321228027344,
0.18671312928199768,
-0.5950480103492737,
0.46713367104530334,
-0.06411540508270264,
-0.03035181201994419,
0.02335057593882084,
0.1058732271194458,
0.6237175464630127,
-0.8499676585197449,
0.7287980318069458,
-0.46402299404144287,
-0.1006694957613945,
0.5313349366188049,
0.4133845865726471,
0.6090210676193237,
0.3024154007434845,
-0.05050940811634064,
-0.5027619004249573,
-0.34723973274230957,
-0.09374187141656876,
-0.444808691740036,
0.5944632887840271,
-0.6245886087417603,
-0.7923543453216553,
-0.1306731253862381,
-0.7171114087104797,
-0.3675466775894165,
0.35881438851356506,
0.47728708386421204,
0.46990975737571716,
0.07854854315519333,
-0.1220603659749031,
0.6386855244636536,
0.13512775301933289,
0.2154366821050644,
0.09665868431329727,
-0.19103476405143738,
-0.576630175113678,
1.2205239534378052,
0.054407063871622086,
-0.08844484388828278,
0.4602886140346527,
0.5479295253753662,
-0.4030607342720032,
-0.9084307551383972,
-0.2822759747505188,
0.4235337972640991,
-0.6448832750320435,
0.05323225259780884,
-0.3865852653980255,
-0.09978784620761871,
-0.49177753925323486,
-0.052896302193403244,
-0.07911001890897751,
-0.6115877628326416,
-0.017565635964274406,
-0.2184329777956009,
0.5195359587669373,
0.9562612771987915,
-0.12119701504707336,
0.39588358998298645,
-0.48162877559661865,
0.09190361946821213,
0.4719909429550171,
0.06484492868185043,
-0.3527516722679138,
-0.4272041916847229,
-0.1266191452741623,
-0.3281266391277313,
-0.4629892408847809,
-0.9979808926582336,
0.28500232100486755,
0.21112386882305145,
0.3217678964138031,
0.1449204683303833,
0.11163343489170074,
0.3325137495994568,
-0.5841735005378723,
0.9302910566329956,
0.1994352638721466,
-1.2226262092590332,
0.7842885255813599,
-0.40115422010421753,
0.2734623849391937,
0.35223937034606934,
0.23820453882217407,
-0.464557021856308,
-0.9537246823310852,
-0.9276593327522278,
-0.9523258209228516,
0.37578150629997253,
0.32504886388778687,
-0.07392460852861404,
-0.1516164392232895,
0.7233872413635254,
0.5203142762184143,
0.24514375627040863,
-0.7123122811317444,
0.1202249825000763,
-0.5847447514533997,
-0.3590594530105591,
0.05965721979737282,
-0.1738279014825821,
0.1211029663681984,
-0.02834264747798443,
0.7212795615196228,
-0.1339423805475235,
-0.23503628373146057,
0.204879492521286,
-0.5045890212059021,
0.04008947312831879,
0.23189274966716766,
0.5386384129524231,
0.5914009809494019,
0.12882161140441895,
0.49172893166542053,
-0.05148286372423172,
-0.6903321146965027,
0.3232305645942688,
0.020437009632587433,
-0.30282315611839294,
0.15150918066501617,
0.24507541954517365,
0.9822320938110352,
0.042256150394678116,
-0.642508864402771,
0.1516963690519333,
0.2532702684402466,
-0.08661172538995743,
-0.29687485098838806,
0.21168075501918793,
0.1561926305294037,
0.25770843029022217,
0.16560234129428864,
-0.25527435541152954,
0.15469743311405182,
-0.07992909103631973,
0.5163590312004089,
-0.000021050516807008535,
-0.28773075342178345,
-0.5709810256958008,
0.7796748280525208,
0.44843605160713196,
-0.5984537601470947,
0.49587440490722656,
-0.4633964002132416,
-0.5337608456611633,
0.4223908483982086,
0.6686030626296997,
0.9564918279647827,
-0.29512906074523926,
0.08146100491285324,
0.27334919571876526,
0.3034847378730774,
0.12325606495141983,
0.10865955799818039,
-0.017095346003770828,
-0.7285945415496826,
-0.1679811030626297,
-0.3870379626750946,
-0.36037304997444153,
0.5359170436859131,
-0.41796422004699707,
0.6094376444816589,
-0.3345837891101837,
-0.22943346202373505,
0.17264041304588318,
-0.2095041424036026,
-0.5679696202278137,
0.2923121452331543,
0.1818232238292694,
0.9518511891365051,
-0.626433789730072,
0.9672379493713379,
0.63592529296875,
-0.4952169358730316,
-0.9423596858978271,
0.40446171164512634,
-0.026498161256313324,
-0.5879501104354858,
0.4115544259548187,
0.13132964074611664,
-0.031459908932447433,
0.20430433750152588,
-0.11092773824930191,
-0.2689994275569916,
0.9148515462875366,
0.3527413010597229,
-0.37568557262420654,
-0.07431019097566605,
0.627509355545044,
0.3897073566913605,
-0.20406445860862732,
0.35678309202194214,
1.0389564037322998,
0.39468392729759216,
0.12663333117961884,
-0.8334258794784546,
0.19349071383476257,
-0.2953401803970337,
0.16003891825675964,
0.5258110165596008,
-0.3536411225795746,
0.6234586238861084,
0.0708751380443573,
0.04310401901602745,
-0.00769778760150075,
0.5436274409294128,
0.29199835658073425,
0.06291685253381729,
0.7121265530586243,
0.6221205592155457,
0.7939035296440125,
-0.11754456162452698,
0.7449619770050049,
-0.48719522356987,
0.08115695416927338,
0.8734843730926514,
-0.1797654926776886,
0.38374611735343933,
0.7416133880615234,
0.26865941286087036,
0.13135865330696106,
0.6449344158172607,
0.1645144373178482,
0.4749217927455902,
0.5716978907585144,
-0.11767701804637909,
-0.2033850997686386,
-0.22903962433338165,
-0.023029912263154984,
0.5409821271896362,
0.3070921301841736,
0.04488237202167511,
0.12834203243255615,
0.2142103761434555,
0.19700998067855835,
0.13998451828956604,
-0.18322166800498962,
0.7602269053459167,
-0.03416088595986366,
-0.9317775368690491,
0.6192724108695984,
-0.3732530474662781,
0.800685465335846,
-0.40231600403785706,
0.2875291109085083,
-0.2561013400554657,
-0.009729123674333096,
0.019231876358389854,
-0.9460923075675964,
0.06159359589219093,
0.007190818898379803,
-0.00815071165561676,
0.001251133857294917,
0.9094883799552917,
-0.8028663396835327,
-0.2021993100643158,
-0.01409571710973978,
0.5901286602020264,
0.261473685503006,
0.2680257558822632,
-0.43369272351264954,
-0.0941239520907402,
-0.11123763024806976,
-0.387934148311615,
0.004536504857242107,
1.0975675582885742,
0.0921158567070961,
0.5880283117294312,
0.42428311705589294,
0.20361553132534027,
0.4606022834777832,
0.41290482878685,
0.7212193608283997,
-0.6834385991096497,
-0.6409746408462524,
-0.5117976665496826,
0.627854585647583,
0.07397052645683289,
-0.6542914509773254,
0.3943120241165161,
0.5911183953285217,
0.7576740384101868,
-0.23365920782089233,
0.843349277973175,
0.051220379769802094,
0.2927844524383545,
-0.7949055433273315,
0.44992202520370483,
-0.27306267619132996,
-0.014425590634346008,
0.15255115926265717,
-0.7315452694892883,
-0.0040539647452533245,
0.061122115701436996,
-0.23526689410209656,
-0.016677215695381165,
0.720082700252533,
0.6574353575706482,
-0.11371400952339172,
0.20585817098617554,
0.17378589510917664,
0.05861448869109154,
0.4523431956768036,
0.5948606133460999,
0.8938997983932495,
-0.4020770788192749,
0.7025887966156006,
-0.5582606792449951,
0.14150366187095642,
-0.109493687748909,
-0.6493092179298401,
-0.802425742149353,
-0.8637979030609131,
-0.4150454103946686,
-0.2982045114040375,
0.08458112925291061,
0.8169102072715759,
0.5829672813415527,
-0.5825587511062622,
-0.5310589075088501,
-0.6753970384597778,
0.2529259920120239,
0.009328718297183514,
-0.2914694547653198,
0.01390872523188591,
-0.44383323192596436,
-0.8549433946609497,
0.4169975221157074,
-0.14658083021640778,
0.10576140135526657,
-0.32889777421951294,
-0.28163576126098633,
0.03717336803674698,
0.014833756722509861,
0.27838876843452454,
0.3332476317882538,
-0.6318832039833069,
-0.45807212591171265,
-0.058240775018930435,
0.23062144219875336,
-0.05035500228404999,
1.2571338415145874,
-0.7837654948234558,
0.29034191370010376,
0.3442760705947876,
0.4819977581501007,
0.6280558109283447,
-0.40751320123672485,
0.6396659016609192,
-0.9415355324745178,
0.4011971652507782,
0.4596293866634369,
0.33035552501678467,
0.4092431366443634,
-0.30033376812934875,
0.3849231004714966,
0.3075786530971527,
-0.547655463218689,
-0.8754796385765076,
0.48239246010780334,
-0.7325760722160339,
-0.010462287813425064,
1.2217416763305664,
0.2174561768770218,
-0.24938389658927917,
-0.26805827021598816,
0.046699199825525284,
0.587390661239624,
-0.36326277256011963,
0.4785889685153961,
0.5652762055397034,
-0.1257343888282776,
-0.3965786099433899,
-0.016058718785643578,
0.6248358488082886,
0.23072925209999084,
-0.5729723572731018,
-0.04062947630882263,
0.2231198400259018,
0.22582416236400604,
0.3465020954608917,
0.21151918172836304,
0.13517305254936218,
0.22197432816028595,
0.34453198313713074,
0.34629005193710327,
0.005865622311830521,
-0.311860591173172,
-0.2720399796962738,
0.13555562496185303,
0.37026435136795044,
-0.0021318565122783184
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13804v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13804v1
|
Learning from Models and Data for Visual Grounding
| 2024-03-20T17:59:43 | 2024-03-20T17:59:43 |
Ruozhen He, Paola Cascante-Bonilla, Ziyan Yang, Alexander C. Berg, Vicente Ordonez
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We introduce SynGround, a novel framework that combines data-driven learning
and knowledge transfer from various large-scale pretrained models to enhance
the visual grounding capabilities of a pretrained vision-and-language model.
The knowledge transfer from the models initiates the generation of image
descriptions through an image description generator. These descriptions serve
dual purposes: they act as prompts for synthesizing images through a
text-to-image generator, and as queries for synthesizing text, from which
phrases are extracted using a large language model. Finally, we leverage an
open-vocabulary object detector to generate synthetic bounding boxes for the
synthetic images and texts. We finetune a pretrained vision-and-language model
on this dataset by optimizing a mask-attention consistency objective that
aligns region annotations with gradient-based model explanations. The resulting
model improves the grounding capabilities of an off-the-shelf
vision-and-language model. Particularly, SynGround improves the pointing game
accuracy of ALBEF on the Flickr30k dataset from 79.38% to 87.26%, and on
RefCOCO+ Test A from 69.35% to 79.06% and on RefCOCO+ Test B from 53.77% to
63.67%.
|
[
-0.30490821599960327,
-0.5862327218055725,
0.6230756640434265,
0.03261975198984146,
-0.36489132046699524,
-0.26633012294769287,
-0.17154639959335327,
-0.35091936588287354,
-0.16253826022148132,
0.5145454406738281,
-0.5272064805030823,
-0.8290297985076904,
-0.5181546211242676,
-0.4507574141025543,
-0.3332034945487976,
0.759979784488678,
-0.09759608656167984,
0.05811367556452751,
-0.5687782764434814,
-0.3737028241157532,
-0.6843348145484924,
-0.5616103410720825,
-0.4065400958061218,
-0.1946592777967453,
0.18585018813610077,
0.3651468753814697,
0.7120176553726196,
0.6891970634460449,
0.6567407846450806,
0.18105624616146088,
0.2092759609222412,
-0.18714427947998047,
-0.6683095693588257,
-0.07539694011211395,
-0.5660497546195984,
-0.536509096622467,
-0.04446026310324669,
0.20318472385406494,
0.4821179211139679,
0.5542756915092468,
0.015841014683246613,
0.2037435621023178,
-0.16162219643592834,
0.8771352767944336,
-0.9266438484191895,
0.22576028108596802,
-0.6325783729553223,
0.3086548149585724,
-0.16867896914482117,
-0.26099318265914917,
-0.28488704562187195,
0.059199050068855286,
0.24068857729434967,
-1.1694151163101196,
0.3447052240371704,
0.06898301094770432,
1.2018787860870361,
0.5358679294586182,
-0.053214751183986664,
0.0965433418750763,
-0.3527502119541168,
0.45999661087989807,
-0.2920988202095032,
0.6099610328674316,
0.212340846657753,
0.6623964905738831,
0.11740053445100784,
-0.7915186882019043,
-0.6584049463272095,
-0.08304507285356522,
0.10172875970602036,
0.5218802690505981,
0.04570741578936577,
0.2686947286128998,
0.6599674224853516,
0.2438819706439972,
-0.18519829213619232,
-0.25766023993492126,
-0.3885864019393921,
0.09595945477485657,
0.3957432508468628,
-0.0368293933570385,
0.4274950325489044,
-0.05594203993678093,
-0.46785449981689453,
-0.3825642764568329,
-0.684027910232544,
0.3928329050540924,
0.014821582473814487,
0.05783703178167343,
-0.29629117250442505,
0.6951078772544861,
-0.44053778052330017,
1.0854843854904175,
0.3838445544242859,
-0.13428497314453125,
0.12238634377717972,
-0.1484059989452362,
-0.3207501173019409,
-0.21518057584762573,
0.3306809961795807,
1.1815649271011353,
0.34786465764045715,
-0.25741642713546753,
-0.18315669894218445,
0.36362284421920776,
0.20339669287204742,
-0.7492138147354126,
-0.6222931146621704,
-0.2132810652256012,
-0.6697701811790466,
-0.6236791014671326,
0.3161320686340332,
-0.7521705627441406,
-0.5719565153121948,
-0.7801758646965027,
0.4843105673789978,
-0.4087495803833008,
-0.09082689136266708,
0.14849165081977844,
-0.3617125153541565,
0.4188459813594818,
0.4802480936050415,
-0.6121972799301147,
0.2463425248861313,
0.13845865428447723,
0.6862258315086365,
-0.18299302458763123,
-0.43893516063690186,
-0.6671133637428284,
0.3090800344944,
-0.5419186353683472,
0.6989994049072266,
-0.33157187700271606,
0.13915787637233734,
-0.0994039848446846,
0.10474791377782822,
0.23865267634391785,
-0.5200579762458801,
0.08819446712732315,
-0.3776542842388153,
0.25962015986442566,
-0.2210559993982315,
-0.12340379506349564,
-0.26486825942993164,
0.42341357469558716,
-0.5849481225013733,
0.9836750626564026,
-0.005625897087156773,
-0.9199137687683105,
0.7731561660766602,
-0.3472827970981598,
-0.4605551064014435,
0.07191216200590134,
-0.4339011609554291,
-0.15720140933990479,
0.31433266401290894,
0.4321555197238922,
0.4580010175704956,
-0.14427734911441803,
0.4817740321159363,
-0.23860064148902893,
-0.3323475122451782,
-0.22985100746154785,
0.1407000720500946,
0.3947765529155731,
-0.09584596008062363,
-0.5272369980812073,
0.23024238646030426,
-0.9509578943252563,
0.13444606959819794,
0.20378156006336212,
0.07712260633707047,
-0.1698817014694214,
0.2503221035003662,
0.1224106028676033,
0.6058608889579773,
-0.10447777807712555,
-0.24060113728046417,
-0.32712358236312866,
-0.234357550740242,
0.09972508996725082,
0.5196461081504822,
-0.09784995764493942,
0.6731019616127014,
-0.2638425827026367,
0.5137967467308044,
0.15143708884716034,
-0.05542462691664696,
-0.6053581833839417,
-0.24243150651454926,
-0.8318066596984863,
-0.005066003650426865,
0.1382857859134674,
0.6492121815681458,
-1.0643219947814941,
0.5450631380081177,
-0.21828140318393707,
-0.30814817547798157,
-0.21660062670707703,
-0.05640513077378273,
0.28339874744415283,
0.982598602771759,
0.5512754321098328,
-0.3864772319793701,
-0.5681406855583191,
-0.815829873085022,
0.10608736425638199,
-0.055255476385354996,
0.15361528098583221,
0.47339141368865967,
0.2229987531900406,
-0.07726001739501953,
1.0910179615020752,
-0.3329874575138092,
-0.4801769554615021,
-0.08203353732824326,
-0.20673245191574097,
0.10209625214338303,
0.49729156494140625,
0.6178498268127441,
-0.8618260622024536,
-0.4586006999015808,
-0.017036478966474533,
-1.1751304864883423,
-0.18101873993873596,
-0.1595534384250641,
-0.2905557155609131,
-0.22101815044879913,
0.7547094821929932,
-0.6709575653076172,
0.7357683181762695,
0.46243858337402344,
-0.2664233148097992,
0.5223559737205505,
-0.012436666525900364,
0.1628352403640747,
-0.9122376441955566,
0.3399827480316162,
0.028522443026304245,
-0.299826979637146,
-0.42647790908813477,
0.42521893978118896,
-0.026066618040204048,
-0.6121435761451721,
-0.6066280603408813,
0.45946380496025085,
-0.5995739102363586,
-0.1888800710439682,
-0.3876330554485321,
0.06406055390834808,
0.1662517935037613,
0.26475515961647034,
0.48351073265075684,
0.6792351007461548,
1.2757490873336792,
-0.5873371958732605,
0.4701703190803528,
0.30617645382881165,
-0.449297159910202,
0.6892883777618408,
-0.7581753730773926,
-0.09254702925682068,
-0.3964543640613556,
0.29326558113098145,
-0.7744154334068298,
-0.3880487382411957,
0.16070379316806793,
-0.25237536430358887,
0.06290232390165329,
-0.46263831853866577,
-0.33899056911468506,
-0.3733900785446167,
0.14201591908931732,
0.4546157121658325,
0.7953493595123291,
-0.7765281200408936,
0.6671186685562134,
0.3876493275165558,
0.1867271363735199,
-0.5134573578834534,
-0.5931945443153381,
0.09986309707164764,
-0.2483045756816864,
-0.687552809715271,
0.41982409358024597,
0.3080548048019409,
-0.1797412633895874,
0.011988881975412369,
-0.18704132735729218,
0.20384112000465393,
0.04007744416594505,
0.6058158278465271,
0.1200617253780365,
-0.22655533254146576,
0.2879818379878998,
-0.3100123405456543,
-0.1624956578016281,
0.11402378231287003,
-0.5723764896392822,
0.35414740443229675,
0.08465096354484558,
-0.3295234441757202,
-0.42814069986343384,
0.11329412460327148,
0.4444981813430786,
-0.42175447940826416,
0.5206654071807861,
0.4021008312702179,
-0.508404016494751,
-0.2084903120994568,
-0.47915956377983093,
-0.29094383120536804,
-0.4504934847354889,
0.347244530916214,
-0.6035328507423401,
-0.41911596059799194,
0.47487831115722656,
-0.2611280083656311,
-0.21788421273231506,
0.2629472613334656,
0.21828575432300568,
-0.33171290159225464,
0.8403518795967102,
0.9934442043304443,
0.19475486874580383,
0.7014689445495605,
-0.26379966735839844,
-0.15922899544239044,
-0.4921994209289551,
-0.43527114391326904,
0.28184714913368225,
-0.4820158779621124,
-0.0764264464378357,
-0.7372041344642639,
0.1351865828037262,
0.6071811318397522,
0.028265276923775673,
0.08891093730926514,
-0.3766120672225952,
0.9891409873962402,
0.5358163118362427,
0.6031892895698547,
-0.0705287903547287,
0.40854349732398987,
-0.1971486508846283,
-0.35834619402885437,
-0.7753913998603821,
-0.2686106860637665,
1.1611144542694092,
0.26780450344085693,
0.9160560965538025,
-0.4911235570907593,
0.546761155128479,
0.10431063175201416,
0.2791491150856018,
-0.6523056626319885,
0.571732759475708,
-0.1181749552488327,
-0.4277028441429138,
-0.04671177640557289,
-0.21084797382354736,
-0.3273474872112274,
0.16451965272426605,
-0.6147934198379517,
-0.4594865143299103,
0.16339634358882904,
0.430959016084671,
-0.2790890336036682,
0.325924813747406,
-0.6578395366668701,
1.0446785688400269,
-0.3666059076786041,
-0.7444878816604614,
0.0776151642203331,
-0.8700454831123352,
0.41689491271972656,
0.21005846560001373,
-0.024123311042785645,
0.005255894735455513,
0.3062695562839508,
0.7494349479675293,
-0.11219125241041183,
0.8645472526550293,
-0.483127623796463,
-0.023511577397584915,
0.4116230010986328,
-0.10861743241548538,
0.37704554200172424,
0.07024095952510834,
0.36147138476371765,
0.21391326189041138,
-0.36653247475624084,
-0.33026665449142456,
-0.5655868053436279,
0.3302496671676636,
-0.6824014782905579,
-0.63788902759552,
-0.27822598814964294,
-0.5099391937255859,
-0.19454337656497955,
0.520403265953064,
0.5416194796562195,
0.3948199152946472,
-0.3173561990261078,
0.31705817580223083,
0.6546515226364136,
-0.36639946699142456,
0.005643060896545649,
0.1251964420080185,
-0.5335623025894165,
-0.454198956489563,
0.7670546770095825,
-0.25532305240631104,
0.20988747477531433,
0.356762170791626,
-0.09219657629728317,
-0.11386211216449738,
-0.5927524566650391,
-0.3438659906387329,
-0.045573268085718155,
-1.011135458946228,
-0.3109540641307831,
-0.6109102964401245,
-0.07031401991844177,
-0.1785174310207367,
-0.4193737208843231,
-0.3419482111930847,
-0.1965203583240509,
-0.1998106837272644,
-0.3869013786315918,
0.11461547762155533,
0.5548593997955322,
-0.025347013026475906,
0.7069169878959656,
-0.3978499174118042,
0.6592996716499329,
0.2857820391654968,
0.3628711998462677,
-0.32169950008392334,
-0.3535532057285309,
-0.1627006232738495,
0.1590091735124588,
-0.1359204202890396,
-0.8825104236602783,
0.30424362421035767,
0.20160457491874695,
0.5962342023849487,
0.36164698004722595,
-0.17037221789360046,
0.8772750496864319,
-0.6802681684494019,
0.5872202515602112,
0.7358179688453674,
-0.9008105397224426,
0.9090220332145691,
-0.43708765506744385,
0.3321557343006134,
0.672807514667511,
0.07179997861385345,
-0.34682393074035645,
-0.18526042997837067,
-0.746086061000824,
-0.7452840209007263,
0.8856096863746643,
0.09461254626512527,
-0.14820490777492523,
0.2636852264404297,
0.315952867269516,
-0.1056939885020256,
0.14923007786273956,
-0.8820521235466003,
-0.0034047579392790794,
-0.4836580157279968,
-0.35967740416526794,
-0.3635379672050476,
0.06084296107292175,
-0.4857863783836365,
-0.34287339448928833,
0.18219786882400513,
-0.4100983738899231,
0.06567833572626114,
0.07072945684194565,
-0.6322111487388611,
-0.2577664256095886,
-0.38557925820350647,
0.26581159234046936,
0.8556950092315674,
-0.15169201791286469,
0.42605528235435486,
0.06810881197452545,
-0.2561773955821991,
0.25635695457458496,
0.21415579319000244,
-0.41240036487579346,
0.024543004110455513,
0.3569657802581787,
1.012282133102417,
0.14632797241210938,
-0.7358805537223816,
0.7158069014549255,
0.2413477748632431,
-0.30416661500930786,
-0.01946970634162426,
0.07017284631729126,
-0.1484009027481079,
0.1919616162776947,
0.33273980021476746,
0.43844959139823914,
0.014308932237327099,
-0.38498324155807495,
0.7001205682754517,
0.3267248272895813,
-0.29848572611808777,
-0.45178234577178955,
0.8213823437690735,
0.2302262783050537,
0.27792173624038696,
0.38221603631973267,
0.1803027242422104,
-0.6634988784790039,
0.8656164407730103,
0.6167764067649841,
0.47211527824401855,
0.27622565627098083,
0.30167508125305176,
0.4758298099040985,
0.23187080025672913,
-0.18863674998283386,
0.18161962926387787,
-0.13260619342327118,
-0.821129560470581,
-0.13749943673610687,
-0.3397581875324249,
-0.130761981010437,
0.06706804782152176,
-0.6623833775520325,
0.5288318991661072,
-0.7300854325294495,
-0.19762133061885834,
-0.16806721687316895,
-0.23469915986061096,
-0.9785740375518799,
0.6600660681724548,
0.6427592039108276,
0.7999829053878784,
-1.110684871673584,
0.4862802028656006,
1.124871850013733,
-0.4300522208213806,
-0.5519409775733948,
0.07647813856601715,
-0.40959930419921875,
-0.8095710873603821,
1.1042098999023438,
0.6928933262825012,
0.05164819210767746,
0.3227297067642212,
-0.8738054037094116,
-0.9543191194534302,
1.1939620971679688,
0.31646406650543213,
-0.46407410502433777,
-0.1352601945400238,
-0.15309683978557587,
0.304375559091568,
-0.6972241401672363,
0.1423972100019455,
0.10868246853351593,
0.23313920199871063,
0.18909411132335663,
-0.4836123287677765,
0.013482949696481228,
-0.24276228249073029,
-0.02994038164615631,
-0.16074752807617188,
-0.570280909538269,
0.7269240021705627,
-0.4552519619464874,
-0.5178212523460388,
-0.28910937905311584,
0.6147915720939636,
0.49979105591773987,
0.3830094635486603,
0.49527812004089355,
1.0622222423553467,
0.5062394142150879,
-0.12838934361934662,
0.8717184662818909,
-0.4004906713962555,
0.04068949073553085,
1.2127578258514404,
-0.45870426297187805,
0.5175862908363342,
0.5342384576797485,
0.257997065782547,
0.5476216077804565,
0.44477221369743347,
-0.032283999025821686,
1.0419336557388306,
0.21089817583560944,
0.06477855890989304,
-0.536069929599762,
-0.095851831138134,
-0.5332269668579102,
0.357138991355896,
0.18976886570453644,
-0.5210202932357788,
-0.615092396736145,
0.36382147669792175,
-0.691914975643158,
0.19954171776771545,
-0.29198142886161804,
0.7453547716140747,
-0.05962926894426346,
-0.6449997425079346,
0.4488658308982849,
-0.044033464044332504,
0.401043176651001,
-0.38708508014678955,
-0.29422688484191895,
-0.17431607842445374,
0.387771338224411,
-0.15269769728183746,
-0.6963746547698975,
-0.0443476177752018,
-0.08080486953258514,
-0.414336621761322,
-0.3976648151874542,
1.1068227291107178,
-0.49385571479797363,
-0.35154351592063904,
0.16176776587963104,
0.47599565982818604,
-0.07316497713327408,
-0.19721636176109314,
-0.7431920766830444,
0.03099977970123291,
-0.1031181663274765,
0.02984529919922352,
0.10613691806793213,
0.5981109142303467,
-0.21109549701213837,
0.6533745527267456,
0.8887251615524292,
0.03848135098814964,
0.2355319857597351,
-0.026962626725435257,
1.0845502614974976,
-0.7127606868743896,
-0.8720880746841431,
-0.5411508679389954,
0.678870439529419,
-0.2662853002548218,
-0.18408073484897614,
0.6671652793884277,
0.5377283096313477,
0.8205857276916504,
-0.428226113319397,
0.7551195025444031,
-0.2599959969520569,
-0.03208868205547333,
-0.9526957869529724,
0.6967596411705017,
-0.3886190354824066,
-0.318806916475296,
-0.08337347954511642,
-1.1381772756576538,
-0.2949526011943817,
0.8718485832214355,
-0.3343384563922882,
-0.17827792465686798,
0.7457249760627747,
0.49236682057380676,
-0.4785638153553009,
-0.4643639624118805,
0.5461563467979431,
-0.2287285029888153,
0.15619854629039764,
0.6056214570999146,
1.0150223970413208,
-0.6387693285942078,
0.1476876586675644,
-0.5082680583000183,
-0.4473808705806732,
0.14505606889724731,
-0.924605667591095,
-1.340396523475647,
-0.23651635646820068,
-0.41335397958755493,
-0.352891206741333,
0.3627553880214691,
0.39338207244873047,
1.2706660032272339,
-0.7808910608291626,
-0.11946259438991547,
-0.6406899690628052,
-0.21258290112018585,
-0.11034225672483444,
-0.20110084116458893,
0.25337404012680054,
-0.4656746983528137,
-0.2751244306564331,
0.25335532426834106,
0.021464841440320015,
0.40181848406791687,
0.10531362146139145,
-0.10382784903049469,
-0.08949587494134903,
-0.4331624209880829,
0.561694324016571,
0.19663548469543457,
-0.655534565448761,
-0.12236198782920837,
0.0767674371600151,
-0.08603248745203018,
0.04526049643754959,
0.8043748140335083,
-1.1776089668273926,
0.5880111455917358,
0.3501763641834259,
0.6299525499343872,
0.4351682960987091,
0.5711179375648499,
0.8146975040435791,
-0.9418047070503235,
0.8371407985687256,
0.13077294826507568,
0.2412240356206894,
0.5645483136177063,
-0.2654436230659485,
0.5448670983314514,
0.6328290700912476,
0.032253753393888474,
-0.6480928659439087,
0.11718596518039703,
-0.8190023899078369,
0.024491121992468834,
1.0687562227249146,
-0.1739090085029602,
-0.3426452875137329,
0.399215430021286,
-0.2119273990392685,
0.16320905089378357,
0.055586788803339005,
0.5456299185752869,
0.7143411636352539,
0.47319793701171875,
-0.5709541440010071,
-0.40099209547042847,
0.6978518962860107,
0.5118641257286072,
-0.8583389520645142,
-0.030962679535150528,
0.9065390229225159,
0.25849679112434387,
0.23643085360527039,
0.347013920545578,
0.04534264653921127,
0.5571166276931763,
0.12597306072711945,
0.44680047035217285,
-0.2567571997642517,
-0.807043194770813,
-0.20200510323047638,
0.13679833710193634,
-0.3230243921279907,
-0.4189298450946808
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13802v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13802v2
|
ZigMa: A DiT-style Zigzag Mamba Diffusion Model
| 2024-03-20T17:59:14 | 2024-04-01T17:58:02 |
Vincent Tao Hu, Stefan Andreas Baumann, Ming Gui, Olga Grebenkova, Pingchuan Ma, Johannes Fischer, Björn Ommer
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The diffusion model has long been plagued by scalability and quadratic
complexity issues, especially within transformer-based structures. In this
study, we aim to leverage the long sequence modeling capability of a
State-Space Model called Mamba to extend its applicability to visual data
generation. Firstly, we identify a critical oversight in most current
Mamba-based vision methods, namely the lack of consideration for spatial
continuity in the scan scheme of Mamba. Secondly, building upon this insight,
we introduce a simple, plug-and-play, zero-parameter method named Zigzag Mamba,
which outperforms Mamba-based baselines and demonstrates improved speed and
memory utilization compared to transformer-based baselines. Lastly, we
integrate Zigzag Mamba with the Stochastic Interpolant framework to investigate
the scalability of the model on large-resolution visual datasets, such as
FacesHQ $1024\times 1024$ and UCF101, MultiModal-CelebA-HQ, and MS COCO
$256\times 256$ . Code will be released at https://taohu.me/zigma/
|
[
-0.5047078132629395,
-0.8322670459747314,
0.5952795743942261,
0.33792728185653687,
-0.5007509589195251,
-0.1039382666349411,
0.1927068531513214,
-0.08390030264854431,
0.14206881821155548,
0.18923437595367432,
-0.48069098591804504,
-0.6143948435783386,
-0.6664416790008545,
-0.4367824196815491,
-0.46422079205513,
0.4760283827781677,
0.09697850048542023,
-0.11723369359970093,
-0.17048490047454834,
-0.0549151748418808,
-0.4803047478199005,
-0.25724583864212036,
-0.2476418912410736,
-0.10453324764966965,
0.710919201374054,
0.37490859627723694,
0.8112382292747498,
0.4787748157978058,
0.2502681314945221,
0.17875227332115173,
-0.2749274969100952,
0.13416533172130585,
-0.48436588048934937,
0.039110470563173294,
0.19963084161281586,
-0.33161941170692444,
-0.344984233379364,
-0.2942333519458771,
0.6264783143997192,
0.84466153383255,
-0.6475563645362854,
0.1892014741897583,
-0.014371991157531738,
1.0200750827789307,
-0.6156556606292725,
0.20853622257709503,
-0.2772365212440491,
0.1454671323299408,
-0.24615401029586792,
0.38111287355422974,
-0.2702980935573578,
-0.5499728322029114,
0.08282293379306793,
-0.48706308007240295,
0.17391341924667358,
-0.07811003923416138,
0.8918194770812988,
0.3921430706977844,
-0.5203150510787964,
-0.15508343279361725,
-0.7974600195884705,
0.21425402164459229,
-0.7362648248672485,
0.19149954617023468,
-0.11253102123737335,
0.9274640679359436,
-0.3873204290866852,
-0.7566742300987244,
-0.7662261724472046,
-0.36375969648361206,
0.36017557978630066,
0.26801520586013794,
-0.3235822021961212,
-0.15854038298130035,
0.376665860414505,
0.3769265413284302,
-0.5660538077354431,
-0.1627051830291748,
-0.49122127890586853,
0.3332366645336151,
0.5317689776420593,
0.3219706416130066,
0.23166298866271973,
-0.24433380365371704,
-0.6221655011177063,
-0.010146562941372395,
-0.6301191449165344,
0.2257787585258484,
0.43571195006370544,
0.09481863677501678,
-0.12817224860191345,
0.38692760467529297,
-0.22667349874973297,
1.068320393562317,
0.114386186003685,
-0.11244481801986694,
0.21825054287910461,
-0.32080256938934326,
-0.5216315388679504,
-0.3447501063346863,
0.5956876277923584,
0.4451535940170288,
0.12616513669490814,
0.20036101341247559,
0.21377654373645782,
-0.15126626193523407,
0.5572237372398376,
-0.987850546836853,
-0.6068861484527588,
0.0715426355600357,
-0.5267179012298584,
0.05374946445226669,
-0.043846286833286285,
-1.2735564708709717,
-0.4423927962779999,
-0.027013059705495834,
0.5801434516906738,
-0.42101097106933594,
-0.492730975151062,
0.3840339779853821,
0.144427090883255,
0.014295940287411213,
0.43014344573020935,
-0.6590986847877502,
-0.15020503103733063,
0.0012697428464889526,
1.2995104789733887,
0.026016132906079292,
-0.01545618660748005,
-0.08802184462547302,
0.04514406993985176,
-0.5829519629478455,
0.5775755047798157,
-0.37492525577545166,
-0.778291642665863,
-0.0624634213745594,
-0.01143634133040905,
-0.022987954318523407,
-0.5390724539756775,
-0.022482430562376976,
-0.2757793962955475,
-0.2888195514678955,
-0.3954128324985504,
-0.3517264127731323,
-0.6242349743843079,
-0.2010553777217865,
-0.7470030784606934,
0.7054436206817627,
0.34644588828086853,
-0.19565142691135406,
0.614197313785553,
-0.7554337382316589,
-0.3898128271102905,
0.12168377637863159,
-0.10463809967041016,
-0.8737562894821167,
0.04178542643785477,
-0.04192695394158363,
0.6126192808151245,
-0.12740279734134674,
0.2809414863586426,
-0.4288555681705475,
-0.5481813549995422,
-0.26507195830345154,
-0.11876701563596725,
0.5600776076316833,
0.4627646207809448,
-0.28919458389282227,
0.1758013665676117,
-1.045678734779358,
-0.3931800425052643,
0.30502116680145264,
-0.17372293770313263,
-0.19593249261379242,
0.2846602499485016,
-0.28077688813209534,
0.4302906394004822,
-0.030671415850520134,
-0.3255878686904907,
0.5869332551956177,
0.0689176544547081,
0.3707908093929291,
0.418018102645874,
0.05632016062736511,
0.48241081833839417,
0.009631427936255932,
0.6860580444335938,
0.6790257096290588,
0.3488885760307312,
-0.5195931196212769,
-0.8119975924491882,
-0.5609117746353149,
-0.5927638411521912,
0.019771378487348557,
0.1921270787715912,
-1.001878261566162,
0.24311304092407227,
-0.24089932441711426,
-0.8304348587989807,
0.12198027968406677,
-0.02095709927380085,
-0.13404561579227448,
0.6478649973869324,
0.4027928113937378,
-0.23514863848686218,
-0.10174418985843658,
-0.9474014639854431,
0.6861093640327454,
0.09223823994398117,
-0.05822768062353134,
0.4590625762939453,
0.3348545432090759,
-0.2479456663131714,
0.8254138231277466,
-0.8051111102104187,
-0.037525758147239685,
-0.14726117253303528,
0.17090798914432526,
0.47509464621543884,
0.3459932804107666,
1.15132737159729,
-0.6654598116874695,
-0.36878836154937744,
-0.1947811394929886,
-0.5975825786590576,
-0.055630337446928024,
-0.1611683964729309,
-0.2809460759162903,
-0.17917299270629883,
0.3397655189037323,
-0.4605557322502136,
0.9349187016487122,
0.6190688014030457,
-0.29490822553634644,
0.24284276366233826,
-0.35285288095474243,
0.23352749645709991,
-1.0912809371948242,
0.0682612881064415,
0.299345999956131,
-0.07681158185005188,
-0.881764829158783,
0.036458659917116165,
0.348880797624588,
-0.16675356030464172,
-0.5254284143447876,
0.04296649619936943,
-0.45184603333473206,
-0.09122422337532043,
-0.38531628251075745,
-0.16947612166404724,
-0.10298342257738113,
0.5027694702148438,
-0.26477301120758057,
0.8025477528572083,
0.7868819236755371,
-1.0013980865478516,
0.2714456021785736,
0.04935700073838234,
-0.5616835951805115,
0.5632854104042053,
-0.6598400473594666,
-0.2918320596218109,
-0.39427316188812256,
0.2382993996143341,
-1.5790635347366333,
-0.035762786865234375,
0.3741493821144104,
0.002255867002531886,
0.20091214776039124,
-0.5197461247444153,
-0.4685988128185272,
-0.6087614297866821,
0.10633140802383423,
0.5294890999794006,
0.9439870715141296,
-0.8274245858192444,
0.690224289894104,
0.1591947227716446,
0.022776421159505844,
-0.36453741788864136,
-0.4817295968532562,
0.050272587686777115,
-0.40728357434272766,
-0.8061711192131042,
-0.057530634105205536,
-0.22821281850337982,
-0.012713155709207058,
-0.4589586853981018,
0.13221384584903717,
0.00977054052054882,
0.12792888283729553,
0.5788544416427612,
0.39190876483917236,
-0.29719310998916626,
-0.12076175957918167,
0.12057650834321976,
0.21122416853904724,
-0.11348122358322144,
-0.2064533680677414,
0.606123685836792,
0.07842760533094406,
-0.5452080965042114,
-0.07681352645158768,
0.38293027877807617,
0.6672337651252747,
0.034339144825935364,
0.6680766344070435,
0.3778279721736908,
-0.16344861686229706,
-0.439124196767807,
-0.012408910319209099,
0.534247100353241,
-0.44880250096321106,
0.38377898931503296,
-0.3429853916168213,
-0.4000404477119446,
0.8080105781555176,
-0.43470412492752075,
-0.14304441213607788,
0.27309757471084595,
0.7755634784698486,
-0.1000630334019661,
0.8629316687583923,
0.592690646648407,
0.2028239369392395,
0.7056518197059631,
-0.4082108438014984,
0.3585294485092163,
-0.5967969298362732,
-0.36223092675209045,
0.09008097648620605,
-0.6584203243255615,
-0.066141277551651,
-0.7745062708854675,
0.512304961681366,
0.2836613357067108,
-0.022794315591454506,
0.2687270939350128,
-0.29105761647224426,
0.2829979360103607,
0.3882623314857483,
0.277709037065506,
-0.057071078568696976,
-0.12530356645584106,
-0.11776775866746902,
0.18030227720737457,
-0.8071780204772949,
-0.17523108422756195,
0.8137634992599487,
0.12554743885993958,
0.8956541419029236,
0.29101452231407166,
0.348553329706192,
0.32421544194221497,
0.08619717508554459,
-0.5248180627822876,
0.6815089583396912,
-0.11692219972610474,
-0.08376001566648483,
-0.22688764333724976,
-0.2123321145772934,
-0.8445718288421631,
0.35086846351623535,
0.034870024770498276,
-0.4040933847427368,
0.6705583333969116,
0.292559951543808,
-0.5701833963394165,
0.5764058232307434,
-0.6928299069404602,
0.46456438302993774,
0.2569418251514435,
-0.32684749364852905,
0.1251770406961441,
-0.6009267568588257,
0.6601738333702087,
-0.08065302670001984,
-0.13417558372020721,
-0.24536484479904175,
0.19035913050174713,
0.1361057162284851,
-0.6195152997970581,
0.712558388710022,
-0.5925763845443726,
-0.3075401186943054,
0.6158847212791443,
0.13134095072746277,
0.2840021550655365,
0.03359930217266083,
0.2239166796207428,
0.6585944890975952,
-0.3577834963798523,
-0.5675936341285706,
-0.5750350952148438,
0.4916980266571045,
-0.3224506080150604,
-0.31632333993911743,
-0.12592993676662445,
-0.5280223488807678,
0.1811906397342682,
-0.03467218577861786,
0.39440855383872986,
0.19377194344997406,
0.017754951491951942,
0.1771397441625595,
0.6237523555755615,
-0.16713711619377136,
0.6887826919555664,
0.32373741269111633,
-0.47291702032089233,
0.006580116227269173,
0.7437896132469177,
0.6012672185897827,
0.38206133246421814,
-0.2711786925792694,
0.0036103406455367804,
0.016192112118005753,
-0.690747857093811,
-0.9238862991333008,
-0.1105569452047348,
-0.6175525188446045,
-0.25315913558006287,
-0.2369813472032547,
-0.29606911540031433,
0.07259263843297958,
-0.2007216513156891,
-0.2829863727092743,
-0.1764041632413864,
-0.3705810606479645,
-0.09980043023824692,
0.3158561885356903,
0.7449954748153687,
-0.14551326632499695,
0.5950340628623962,
-0.3451820909976959,
0.413368821144104,
0.3533848822116852,
0.2988702058792114,
0.25395578145980835,
-0.3318735361099243,
-0.5443325638771057,
0.15544119477272034,
-0.11480862647294998,
-0.9466684460639954,
0.47322097420692444,
-0.22392362356185913,
0.5089834332466125,
0.47392410039901733,
-0.303067684173584,
1.046608328819275,
-0.7926662564277649,
1.277340292930603,
0.4249105155467987,
-0.8195093870162964,
0.5773064494132996,
-0.40615394711494446,
0.31684380769729614,
0.040541812777519226,
0.32968562841415405,
-0.07645582407712936,
-0.11831210553646088,
-0.27623432874679565,
-1.1114838123321533,
0.17642511427402496,
0.028467455878853798,
-0.006364648230373859,
-0.1558537483215332,
0.6877592206001282,
0.1893056184053421,
0.17814131081104279,
-0.28284481167793274,
-0.4037054479122162,
-0.718848705291748,
-0.041356343775987625,
-0.16930295526981354,
-0.33466073870658875,
0.04902208223938942,
-0.26631081104278564,
0.11258770525455475,
-0.23390808701515198,
0.19816939532756805,
0.20832565426826477,
-0.0796208530664444,
-0.010782149620354176,
-0.1463184505701065,
1.0516585111618042,
0.8198176622390747,
-0.010120592080056667,
-0.24140319228172302,
-0.15536266565322876,
-0.5434561967849731,
0.3902202844619751,
-0.0768560841679573,
-0.3231126368045807,
0.22094345092773438,
-0.29413729906082153,
0.7667219042778015,
0.035893674939870834,
-0.36991143226623535,
0.7170647978782654,
-0.01777462847530842,
-0.5332663059234619,
-0.12313369661569595,
0.38106033205986023,
0.06256446987390518,
0.60065096616745,
0.4669875204563141,
0.11599354445934296,
0.19305850565433502,
-0.1424580067396164,
0.20943555235862732,
0.3299238085746765,
-0.060115497559309006,
-0.26129838824272156,
1.2091578245162964,
-0.08814123272895813,
-0.019867923110723495,
0.4155426621437073,
-0.10545219480991364,
0.11016982793807983,
0.8403857350349426,
0.375509113073349,
0.6919865012168884,
-0.3064442574977875,
0.14116646349430084,
0.6037732362747192,
-0.1044217199087143,
-0.29106348752975464,
0.33197394013404846,
-0.26252150535583496,
-0.35273653268814087,
-0.06383465230464935,
-0.40951550006866455,
-0.30199113488197327,
-0.15708903968334198,
-0.8591891527175903,
0.10507476329803467,
-0.7056794166564941,
-0.45850351452827454,
-0.14802297949790955,
-0.39353254437446594,
-0.4460636377334595,
0.21844686567783356,
0.5254322290420532,
0.8578332662582397,
-0.8392025828361511,
1.0255845785140991,
0.22207267582416534,
-0.5905225872993469,
-0.5000157356262207,
0.10569034516811371,
-0.13035635650157928,
-0.6956954002380371,
0.6133610606193542,
-0.10099517554044724,
-0.4390474855899811,
-0.12673160433769226,
-0.7152705788612366,
-0.9238724708557129,
1.6372822523117065,
0.1830378919839859,
-1.0158448219299316,
0.016092119738459587,
-0.19347237050533295,
0.4846634566783905,
-0.3285667300224304,
-0.14629290997982025,
0.42178452014923096,
0.23258057236671448,
0.6112060546875,
-0.3527633547782898,
-0.15540345013141632,
-0.2007693499326706,
0.5518068075180054,
0.16560591757297516,
-1.083254337310791,
1.1893113851547241,
-0.519347071647644,
-0.2456379532814026,
0.29105332493782043,
0.9341155290603638,
0.1972118318080902,
0.21202151477336884,
0.5998179316520691,
0.47103777527809143,
0.7860212326049805,
-0.17774102091789246,
0.9150829315185547,
-0.22268399596214294,
0.32527878880500793,
0.8479040265083313,
-0.493160605430603,
0.5478018522262573,
0.37248483300209045,
-0.20470955967903137,
0.8346644639968872,
0.5828203558921814,
-0.37003669142723083,
0.7554530501365662,
0.3867179751396179,
-0.12171849608421326,
-0.07996586710214615,
0.5201638340950012,
-0.3771723508834839,
0.2152538001537323,
0.20568996667861938,
-0.3763144910335541,
-0.24494460225105286,
0.26214587688446045,
-0.04466641694307327,
-0.14096152782440186,
-0.5041810274124146,
0.34950247406959534,
-0.23752030730247498,
-0.18011818826198578,
0.47000420093536377,
-0.30343905091285706,
0.491098552942276,
-0.5622860789299011,
-0.1907452791929245,
-0.5339789986610413,
-0.11223343014717102,
-0.06016990542411804,
-0.7836284041404724,
0.12616866827011108,
-0.24256756901741028,
-0.28058555722236633,
0.1803843379020691,
0.18355374038219452,
-0.4205751121044159,
-0.620472252368927,
0.25980624556541443,
0.3610796332359314,
-0.04033695533871651,
0.10015760362148285,
-0.3283720910549164,
-0.15500737726688385,
-0.04993464797735214,
-0.3647574484348297,
0.3093457818031311,
0.3040413558483124,
0.11813147366046906,
0.8748385906219482,
0.5983211398124695,
-0.005783336237072945,
0.5199451446533203,
0.28799140453338623,
0.8468523025512695,
-0.8066282868385315,
-0.7573240995407104,
-0.9392552971839905,
0.7226811647415161,
0.040959496051073074,
-0.059999365359544754,
0.8025755882263184,
0.3839922249317169,
0.3890819847583771,
-0.28002768754959106,
0.6084855198860168,
0.16629689931869507,
0.18374842405319214,
-0.7386540770530701,
0.835279643535614,
-0.7340181469917297,
0.03782610222697258,
-0.26193967461586,
-0.6704356074333191,
-0.3864436149597168,
0.6400333046913147,
-0.07439260184764862,
0.12303578108549118,
0.25859957933425903,
0.583658754825592,
-0.15895862877368927,
-0.3034217059612274,
0.7835467457771301,
0.19254495203495026,
0.49770158529281616,
0.781868040561676,
0.874474287033081,
-0.3485748767852783,
0.3742036521434784,
-0.05960875377058983,
-0.1091812327504158,
-0.3402468264102936,
-0.7551097869873047,
-0.7885289192199707,
-0.7333407998085022,
-0.3283628225326538,
-0.33885592222213745,
-0.2444307804107666,
0.31640496850013733,
1.0715404748916626,
-0.2599155604839325,
-0.05065329745411873,
0.13758735358715057,
-0.09814754873514175,
-0.18230539560317993,
-0.20041988790035248,
0.028939779847860336,
0.16586127877235413,
-0.7025452256202698,
0.4184940755367279,
0.6852300763130188,
0.4708748161792755,
-0.4454335868358612,
0.11281834542751312,
-0.15375389158725739,
0.38199329376220703,
0.6631991267204285,
0.23878462612628937,
-0.7235236167907715,
-0.22684097290039062,
-0.32468873262405396,
0.03754753619432449,
0.6779425144195557,
0.5981113314628601,
-0.7776182889938354,
0.5392388701438904,
0.43100839853286743,
0.19610999524593353,
0.6698413491249084,
0.29519447684288025,
0.42433682084083557,
-0.44436463713645935,
0.3081861734390259,
-0.232656329870224,
0.7244824767112732,
-0.04444720223546028,
-0.4573782682418823,
0.4507715106010437,
0.10704142600297928,
-0.45044445991516113,
-0.5220436453819275,
0.33333200216293335,
-1.296727180480957,
-0.37480834126472473,
0.9322693347930908,
-0.2380611151456833,
-0.4697346091270447,
0.1172247976064682,
-0.3354659080505371,
0.07454904168844223,
-0.16733042895793915,
0.761488676071167,
0.5530046820640564,
-0.20611082017421722,
-0.2835030257701874,
-0.5642724633216858,
0.1856936812400818,
-0.22246012091636658,
-0.6870241761207581,
-0.12091266363859177,
0.7899811267852783,
0.5757433176040649,
0.24598923325538635,
0.4391442537307739,
0.0039830622263252735,
0.3787209391593933,
0.31575798988342285,
0.17966203391551971,
-0.31273579597473145,
-0.6832697987556458,
-0.7231040596961975,
0.49565932154655457,
-0.41006889939308167,
-0.48230934143066406
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13801v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13801v2
|
Natural Language as Policies: Reasoning for Coordinate-Level Embodied Control with LLMs
| 2024-03-20T17:58:12 | 2024-04-06T04:12:47 |
Yusuke Mikami, Andrew Melnik, Jun Miura, Ville Hautamäki
|
cs.RO
|
cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2.9; I.2.7
|
We demonstrate experimental results with LLMs that address robotics task
planning problems. Recently, LLMs have been applied in robotics task planning,
particularly using a code generation approach that converts complex high-level
instructions into mid-level policy codes. In contrast, our approach acquires
text descriptions of the task and scene objects, then formulates task planning
through natural language reasoning, and outputs coordinate level control
commands, thus reducing the necessity for intermediate representation code as
policies with pre-defined APIs. Our approach is evaluated on a multi-modal
prompt simulation benchmark, demonstrating that our prompt engineering
experiments with natural language reasoning significantly enhance success rates
compared to its absence. Furthermore, our approach illustrates the potential
for natural language descriptions to transfer robotics skills from known tasks
to previously unseen tasks. The project website:
https://natural-language-as-policies.github.io/
|
[
-0.2771237790584564,
-0.9495624899864197,
0.7319626212120056,
0.37414345145225525,
0.11063340306282043,
0.054998040199279785,
-0.1566634476184845,
-0.4761236011981964,
0.02860543690621853,
0.7363709807395935,
-0.9378560185432434,
-0.672160804271698,
-0.26735320687294006,
0.22613295912742615,
-0.08334723114967346,
0.4735730290412903,
-0.3149176239967346,
-0.07168138027191162,
-0.28444409370422363,
0.3298775553703308,
-0.5123758912086487,
-0.39415252208709717,
-0.586021363735199,
-0.4834858775138855,
0.5141146779060364,
0.489348441362381,
0.742763876914978,
0.38976970314979553,
0.6260935068130493,
0.2660291790962219,
-0.11481011658906937,
0.4647863507270813,
0.028339289128780365,
0.09025703370571136,
-0.2540407180786133,
-0.24209244549274445,
-0.3730619251728058,
-0.2831122875213623,
0.523925244808197,
0.8027054667472839,
-0.06846239417791367,
-0.18523839116096497,
0.10959836095571518,
0.6249770522117615,
-0.5451521277427673,
0.4271581768989563,
-0.3100406527519226,
0.3334401845932007,
0.3820044994354248,
-0.30560463666915894,
-0.34910622239112854,
-0.26202207803726196,
0.0377938449382782,
-0.8901239633560181,
-0.08230070769786835,
0.3186025023460388,
0.8427929878234863,
0.37367522716522217,
-0.4140251874923706,
-0.44284507632255554,
-1.0455420017242432,
0.8677566051483154,
-0.6570181250572205,
0.10584685206413269,
0.6764209866523743,
0.35294103622436523,
-0.6238685250282288,
-0.5173741579055786,
-0.8816656470298767,
-0.714989960193634,
-0.16593779623508453,
-0.0012467815540730953,
-0.31763941049575806,
0.7069869637489319,
0.5118022561073303,
0.06059028580784798,
-0.7276909947395325,
0.308849036693573,
-0.13264548778533936,
-0.43156787753105164,
0.7049282193183899,
0.34904322028160095,
0.44214609265327454,
-0.424113929271698,
-0.4872831106185913,
0.06883686035871506,
-0.5816689133644104,
0.2325662076473236,
0.4167999029159546,
0.49956774711608887,
-0.2566758096218109,
0.9450653791427612,
-0.776159942150116,
0.707183301448822,
-0.34881699085235596,
0.034318529069423676,
0.022434145212173462,
-0.5988606214523315,
-0.2578493356704712,
-0.16162459552288055,
0.7303141355514526,
0.4595317840576172,
0.3170172870159149,
-0.2198513150215149,
-0.3043733835220337,
0.0847616046667099,
0.5889942646026611,
-0.45866870880126953,
0.20038962364196777,
0.2579962909221649,
-0.481611430644989,
0.07165408879518509,
-0.3178079128265381,
-0.45015397667884827,
-0.422897070646286,
-0.967484176158905,
0.39565837383270264,
-0.34767529368400574,
0.19687777757644653,
0.5565641522407532,
-0.09405236691236496,
0.32504287362098694,
0.5149348974227905,
-0.8108641505241394,
0.4864596128463745,
0.8097078800201416,
0.6554312705993652,
-0.21479663252830505,
-0.22929950058460236,
-0.1628480851650238,
0.23413176834583282,
-0.33825215697288513,
0.6010111570358276,
-0.3090975284576416,
-0.6348587274551392,
0.37013766169548035,
-0.0030196229927241802,
0.10516642034053802,
-0.3602919578552246,
0.7453545331954956,
-0.12477507442235947,
0.26003631949424744,
-0.08519469946622849,
-0.35075271129608154,
-0.25495561957359314,
0.4597006142139435,
-0.6427530646324158,
1.0596312284469604,
-0.11270446330308914,
-0.2658315598964691,
0.216504767537117,
-1.029330849647522,
-0.8692821264266968,
-0.15160371363162994,
-0.2251361757516861,
-0.00687714759260416,
-0.34946805238723755,
0.09267185628414154,
0.6134878993034363,
-0.26055774092674255,
0.45216104388237,
-0.0367891825735569,
0.0500112883746624,
0.06565141677856445,
-0.20692521333694458,
0.594488799571991,
0.28956013917922974,
-0.2849724590778351,
0.4738152325153351,
-0.5786434412002563,
0.006145240273326635,
0.07653840631246567,
-0.25708475708961487,
0.20576490461826324,
0.4058733582496643,
-0.21078883111476898,
0.05405642092227936,
0.4810771942138672,
-0.48297688364982605,
0.4950703978538513,
-0.49061402678489685,
0.3222291171550751,
0.4133904278278351,
0.1977149248123169,
1.1351978778839111,
-0.41965967416763306,
0.6055446267127991,
-0.6587979197502136,
0.2940676212310791,
-0.08898376673460007,
-0.5891239643096924,
-0.5766468048095703,
0.04743366688489914,
-0.47621381282806396,
0.7535512447357178,
-1.1162720918655396,
0.5105299353599548,
0.12838079035282135,
-0.18635040521621704,
0.1370190978050232,
0.002556157298386097,
0.36878398060798645,
0.6134424805641174,
0.5559039115905762,
-0.045570045709609985,
-0.46970072388648987,
-0.9963375926017761,
-0.04234474524855614,
-0.33599933981895447,
-0.33547550439834595,
0.19385559856891632,
0.5931075215339661,
-0.08954669535160065,
0.9996911883354187,
-0.46228981018066406,
-0.21411405503749847,
-0.5494610667228699,
0.4745050072669983,
0.17336207628250122,
0.5083715915679932,
0.3457450270652771,
-0.5339011549949646,
-0.0007883735233917832,
-0.00752435764297843,
-0.6816898584365845,
-0.09669964760541916,
-0.4342455565929413,
-0.527775764465332,
0.3450620174407959,
0.3561011552810669,
-1.0236752033233643,
0.48507606983184814,
0.3296668827533722,
-0.303492933511734,
0.5616881251335144,
-0.3434734046459198,
0.03484473004937172,
-0.8582169413566589,
-0.09588175266981125,
0.1346329152584076,
-0.0329413115978241,
-0.7599775195121765,
0.013524115085601807,
-0.2622769773006439,
-0.11194037646055222,
-0.429610937833786,
0.584696888923645,
-0.44045290350914,
-0.24090668559074402,
-0.5206442475318909,
0.04629335179924965,
0.02895275689661503,
0.7278773784637451,
0.34540730714797974,
0.6725139617919922,
0.5867241024971008,
-0.9140411615371704,
0.4433237910270691,
0.3063405752182007,
-0.13942256569862366,
0.47962817549705505,
-0.6244474053382874,
-0.15954074263572693,
0.005376518238335848,
0.38518887758255005,
-0.6796582341194153,
-0.41634905338287354,
0.5748862028121948,
-0.3671095371246338,
0.33164289593696594,
-0.07758241146802902,
-0.6331945657730103,
-0.6453119516372681,
-0.06913281232118607,
-0.19700714945793152,
0.5898104906082153,
-0.13350319862365723,
0.7589793801307678,
0.4992351531982422,
-0.004806975834071636,
-0.44768422842025757,
-0.6750739812850952,
0.12495144456624985,
0.033938247710466385,
-0.39101651310920715,
0.5244324207305908,
-0.1451391577720642,
-0.23806552588939667,
-0.10475338250398636,
-0.26028311252593994,
-0.36849841475486755,
0.2441730946302414,
0.2441001981496811,
0.39662718772888184,
-0.03809686750173569,
0.02750222757458687,
0.19983170926570892,
-0.1027408093214035,
0.5073460936546326,
-0.23175230622291565,
0.47925105690956116,
0.12097185105085373,
-0.45134222507476807,
-0.7209900617599487,
0.15171733498573303,
0.1939888596534729,
0.022844932973384857,
0.31689849495887756,
0.1971232295036316,
-0.5742512941360474,
-0.3004206418991089,
-0.05890123173594475,
-0.22530412673950195,
-0.5032413601875305,
0.09522900730371475,
-0.1844712644815445,
-0.741610050201416,
0.2915705442428589,
-0.2724629044532776,
0.30239275097846985,
0.06728342920541763,
0.40501970052719116,
-0.3855544924736023,
0.8770431876182556,
0.5323735475540161,
0.04773157835006714,
0.42790743708610535,
-0.27698662877082825,
0.06686833500862122,
-0.5189454555511475,
-0.4018431007862091,
-0.6903840899467468,
-0.5162116885185242,
-0.4674636721611023,
-0.8398239612579346,
0.02119886502623558,
0.12944449484348297,
-0.5042612552642822,
0.675551176071167,
-0.6118894219398499,
0.36635610461235046,
0.6176410913467407,
-0.01630527526140213,
0.18337437510490417,
-0.2169162631034851,
-0.01081607025116682,
0.14701642096042633,
-0.5450431704521179,
-1.0577335357666016,
0.6655973196029663,
0.12934646010398865,
0.793113648891449,
-0.22397911548614502,
0.620345950126648,
0.37947824597358704,
-0.22310172021389008,
-0.9733675122261047,
0.9454314708709717,
0.2441452294588089,
-0.4419226050376892,
-0.5958014130592346,
-0.3219396770000458,
-1.1275835037231445,
-0.059337250888347626,
-0.3456328511238098,
-0.8090419769287109,
-0.01648208498954773,
0.2465900182723999,
-0.35190510749816895,
0.2770995795726776,
-0.5077367424964905,
0.8809187412261963,
-0.4990234375,
-0.24884222447872162,
-0.19358164072036743,
-0.8839590549468994,
0.07843363285064697,
0.4629044234752655,
0.1380997896194458,
-0.6468363404273987,
-0.21357540786266327,
0.48704662919044495,
-0.1803213506937027,
1.1079912185668945,
-0.26454636454582214,
-0.22114691138267517,
0.5727309584617615,
0.24879541993141174,
0.6279714107513428,
-0.12249511480331421,
0.07841351628303528,
0.047422438859939575,
-0.3343868851661682,
-0.3829781413078308,
-0.6294300556182861,
0.3601360321044922,
-0.5020533204078674,
-0.4363383948802948,
-0.17540305852890015,
-0.8301524519920349,
-0.31384608149528503,
0.1648685783147812,
-0.251827597618103,
0.36948174238204956,
-0.3760077953338623,
-0.07513400167226791,
0.6424638628959656,
-0.556084930896759,
0.618650496006012,
0.44473645091056824,
-0.2666361629962921,
0.06558240950107574,
0.7285078763961792,
-0.25359418988227844,
0.4953409433364868,
0.9577032923698425,
0.131378635764122,
-0.21905748546123505,
-0.579776406288147,
-0.34242045879364014,
-0.18006931245326996,
-0.49859750270843506,
-0.24631056189537048,
-0.42975977063179016,
-0.18755334615707397,
-0.368791401386261,
-0.4765549600124359,
-0.2404555231332779,
-0.5796958804130554,
-0.29781574010849,
-0.03245564550161362,
0.30352288484573364,
0.967157781124115,
0.02193811908364296,
0.34873801469802856,
-0.559729278087616,
0.695094108581543,
0.026863085106015205,
0.1564885824918747,
-0.49072760343551636,
-0.09491266310214996,
0.06686130911111832,
0.23311154544353485,
-0.3964683711528778,
-0.7001859545707703,
0.4828665256500244,
-0.17279775440692902,
0.8080143928527832,
0.07482215762138367,
0.2645304203033447,
0.2975771725177765,
-0.5981108546257019,
0.8760966658592224,
0.1877068281173706,
-0.7211560606956482,
0.7833513021469116,
-0.4293491840362549,
0.48285311460494995,
0.1893668919801712,
0.500372588634491,
-0.3327198028564453,
-0.6274319291114807,
-0.43942537903785706,
-0.7107859253883362,
0.6710523962974548,
0.2960258424282074,
0.19937807321548462,
0.10411853343248367,
0.019608916714787483,
-0.019070986658334732,
0.2600608468055725,
-0.46272480487823486,
-0.2019839882850647,
0.026878975331783295,
-0.20757433772087097,
0.1845628172159195,
-0.15298287570476532,
-0.16747227311134338,
-0.07563744485378265,
0.2915971875190735,
-0.3111112117767334,
0.4833259880542755,
0.07875985652208328,
-0.04778796806931496,
0.13877025246620178,
0.45448529720306396,
0.9376646876335144,
0.4618927836418152,
0.008610368706285954,
0.16036765277385712,
0.21621601283550262,
-0.28168022632598877,
-0.10418257117271423,
0.14124666154384613,
-0.1866701990365982,
-0.12540698051452637,
0.2470862865447998,
0.7332855463027954,
0.560520350933075,
-0.6583117842674255,
0.17532719671726227,
0.24316570162773132,
-0.5078951716423035,
-0.24659432470798492,
0.12415892630815506,
0.01512338686734438,
0.24853764474391937,
0.21427923440933228,
0.1020880714058876,
0.16268327832221985,
-0.3448418378829956,
0.11479755491018295,
0.40460437536239624,
-0.30187252163887024,
-0.2831890285015106,
0.6647788882255554,
0.48805180191993713,
-0.37937596440315247,
0.3273372948169708,
-0.48975974321365356,
-0.37312355637550354,
0.9400755763053894,
0.33890748023986816,
0.7684105038642883,
0.14469729363918304,
0.4652329683303833,
0.5647454261779785,
0.6763766407966614,
-0.06879157572984695,
0.6626020073890686,
-0.22166018187999725,
-0.8687015771865845,
-0.7107042670249939,
-0.3711456060409546,
-0.7058050036430359,
-0.498203843832016,
-0.331369012594223,
0.2638891637325287,
-0.541349470615387,
-0.04621092602610588,
-0.38379788398742676,
-0.05777018144726753,
-0.515289843082428,
-0.131249338388443,
0.5432541370391846,
0.8368083834648132,
-0.5797867178916931,
0.5235251188278198,
0.6717039346694946,
-0.5798617601394653,
-0.7106134295463562,
-0.12341692298650742,
0.044379688799381256,
-0.9667034149169922,
0.8424513339996338,
0.11059726774692535,
-0.2853908836841583,
-0.15275293588638306,
-0.7938566207885742,
-0.7589149475097656,
1.1242005825042725,
0.31120237708091736,
-0.3839302659034729,
-0.29918843507766724,
0.36954396963119507,
0.41653189063072205,
-0.1513507217168808,
-0.03583432361483574,
0.32327285408973694,
0.7003656029701233,
0.3834075629711151,
-1.1847755908966064,
-0.07336913049221039,
0.1437537670135498,
-0.13421525061130524,
0.34701359272003174,
-0.0046476153656840324,
0.4390062391757965,
-0.33298760652542114,
-0.37996238470077515,
0.18036925792694092,
0.8988811373710632,
0.35153549909591675,
0.5633314847946167,
0.23027963936328888,
0.2691931426525116,
0.734818160533905,
-0.21297872066497803,
1.4448668956756592,
-0.28350019454956055,
-0.0077301315031945705,
1.0674326419830322,
-0.6153722405433655,
0.7416279911994934,
0.5047272443771362,
-0.18940076231956482,
0.6170887351036072,
0.2712753713130951,
0.3822566568851471,
0.335493266582489,
0.39488035440444946,
-0.2076873779296875,
-0.22159075736999512,
-0.48569250106811523,
0.020993920043110847,
0.34390610456466675,
0.30197352170944214,
0.13464462757110596,
-0.3740263879299164,
0.24980084598064423,
0.08244272321462631,
0.40325769782066345,
-0.48668086528778076,
0.7085556387901306,
0.11330364644527435,
-0.6548813581466675,
0.15167443454265594,
-0.13959334790706635,
0.5885964035987854,
-0.5904390811920166,
-0.31352803111076355,
0.15334142744541168,
-0.12619724869728088,
-0.04348429664969444,
-1.3607726097106934,
0.48062267899513245,
-0.02475227788090706,
-0.03920397907495499,
-1.0688111782073975,
0.915813684463501,
-0.332876980304718,
-0.08194000273942947,
0.024858655408024788,
0.4473640024662018,
0.10974223166704178,
0.03797001764178276,
-0.8541054725646973,
-0.25276532769203186,
-0.18404075503349304,
-0.2868820130825043,
0.07366019487380981,
0.45061200857162476,
-0.14496220648288727,
1.0951834917068481,
0.6129545569419861,
0.014892037957906723,
0.13981494307518005,
-0.0567195825278759,
0.6962454319000244,
-0.7279020547866821,
-0.403195321559906,
-0.42264795303344727,
0.5064754486083984,
-0.16726695001125336,
-0.1302378624677658,
0.6113606095314026,
0.4815114140510559,
0.8789157271385193,
-0.11841592937707901,
0.5073287487030029,
-0.24940374493598938,
0.45823925733566284,
-0.8663802146911621,
0.35682836174964905,
-0.1936492919921875,
0.03716743364930153,
0.2486720234155655,
-0.5337277054786682,
-0.5060339570045471,
0.678602397441864,
-0.3697701096534729,
-0.16165906190872192,
0.7518190145492554,
0.8349088430404663,
0.31585556268692017,
-0.09714186936616898,
0.3550540804862976,
-0.33964264392852783,
0.2824569642543793,
0.5010400414466858,
1.1535805463790894,
0.18307091295719147,
0.5390986204147339,
-0.36852067708969116,
0.26395297050476074,
0.03848187252879143,
-1.0593458414077759,
-0.6664126515388489,
-0.28860434889793396,
-0.2247467041015625,
-0.005366944707930088,
-0.09177792817354202,
1.1637914180755615,
0.4856729209423065,
-0.576092004776001,
-0.5609900951385498,
-0.6396592855453491,
0.47342973947525024,
-0.06724639236927032,
-0.23723989725112915,
-0.16827745735645294,
-0.722900390625,
-0.771445095539093,
0.7321643829345703,
0.2909412384033203,
0.09687843918800354,
-0.31581851840019226,
-0.5825873017311096,
-0.3283005654811859,
-0.12999169528484344,
0.7561745643615723,
0.6320690512657166,
-0.886630117893219,
-0.27087587118148804,
0.27676066756248474,
-0.5366427302360535,
-0.12857259809970856,
1.021418809890747,
-0.736644983291626,
0.3756866753101349,
0.6787877082824707,
0.626449704170227,
0.12902222573757172,
-0.13311682641506195,
0.9303325414657593,
-0.7420935034751892,
0.22821129858493805,
0.5877354145050049,
0.3572644293308258,
-0.03284173086285591,
-0.08678784221410751,
0.610112726688385,
-0.030420955270528793,
-0.5676182508468628,
-0.6056203842163086,
0.47525766491889954,
-1.4254121780395508,
-0.23731045424938202,
1.3867192268371582,
0.1827445924282074,
-0.1865009069442749,
-0.19822904467582703,
-0.6460352540016174,
0.2151978313922882,
-0.504433274269104,
0.280243843793869,
0.359870582818985,
-0.5258323550224304,
-0.05263184383511543,
-1.1062666177749634,
0.6119135022163391,
0.20641781389713287,
-1.1199737787246704,
0.06717035174369812,
0.6754230260848999,
-0.5179988145828247,
0.12619607150554657,
0.5881491303443909,
0.23970291018486023,
0.11288876086473465,
-0.3044900894165039,
0.6492714881896973,
0.03849675878882408,
-0.3455185890197754,
-0.08217761665582657,
-0.2172224074602127,
0.08636216819286346,
-0.36077573895454407
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13799v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13799v3
|
Reverse Training to Nurse the Reversal Curse
| 2024-03-20T17:55:35 | 2024-05-07T20:35:15 |
Olga Golovneva, Zeyuan Allen-Zhu, Jason Weston, Sainbayar Sukhbaatar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) have a surprising failure: when trained on "A
has a feature B", they do not generalize to "B is a feature of A", which is
termed the Reversal Curse. Even when training with trillions of tokens this
issue still appears due to Zipf's law - hence even if we train on the entire
internet. This work proposes an alternative training scheme, called reverse
training, whereby all words are used twice, doubling the amount of available
tokens. The LLM is trained in both forward and reverse directions by reversing
the training strings while preserving (i.e., not reversing) chosen substrings,
such as entities. We show that data-matched reverse-trained models provide
superior performance to standard models on standard tasks, and compute-matched
reverse-trained models provide far superior performance on reversal tasks,
helping resolve the reversal curse issue.
|
[
0.035032738000154495,
-0.3566364645957947,
0.2155953347682953,
0.21530941128730774,
-0.45769956707954407,
0.0560503825545311,
-0.08398398756980896,
-0.4123454689979553,
0.6562955975532532,
1.0362367630004883,
-0.7188515663146973,
0.03606041893362999,
-0.8983359336853027,
0.36059489846229553,
-0.8059709668159485,
1.2227128744125366,
0.2863098680973053,
0.7034021615982056,
-0.261017769575119,
-0.03532027453184128,
-0.43038997054100037,
-0.6901758909225464,
-0.9328941106796265,
-0.8969146609306335,
0.6790696978569031,
0.40036359429359436,
0.5230570435523987,
0.4821486175060272,
0.4269638955593109,
0.19299128651618958,
0.2750610113143921,
0.04384012147784233,
-1.155672311782837,
-0.026653995737433434,
-0.07912395894527435,
-0.8264680504798889,
-0.13833396136760712,
0.12374859303236008,
0.5223633050918579,
0.9010269045829773,
-0.046314090490341187,
0.06356102973222733,
-0.2415386587381363,
0.9608516097068787,
-0.43220046162605286,
-0.233136847615242,
-0.9017233848571777,
0.10898185521364212,
0.056584037840366364,
-0.43353864550590515,
-0.32036110758781433,
-0.5384113788604736,
0.10242971777915955,
-0.38914066553115845,
0.5495538711547852,
0.14314839243888855,
0.8402296304702759,
0.21918176114559174,
-0.4031558036804199,
-0.05867038667201996,
-0.783672571182251,
0.6929882764816284,
-0.6931276321411133,
0.5419711470603943,
0.3986833691596985,
0.14675647020339966,
-0.2920083999633789,
-0.5239643454551697,
-0.6989546418190002,
-0.1492500603199005,
-0.047747090458869934,
0.19050578773021698,
0.021692657843232155,
-0.09053628146648407,
0.15441399812698364,
0.22339773178100586,
-0.6859433650970459,
0.7169889807701111,
-0.49848973751068115,
-0.0866713747382164,
0.5275449156761169,
0.2942836284637451,
0.424979031085968,
0.3636685609817505,
-0.6690431237220764,
0.05039682239294052,
-1.3261363506317139,
-0.2199830710887909,
0.6026508212089539,
0.44124242663383484,
0.2727561891078949,
0.5238842368125916,
0.08826707303524017,
0.5325316786766052,
-0.09068172425031662,
-0.3569067120552063,
0.39229297637939453,
0.14756248891353607,
-0.4459586441516876,
0.30428552627563477,
0.23027482628822327,
0.3517034649848938,
0.33589687943458557,
-0.5077394247055054,
-0.2515149712562561,
0.05688059329986572,
0.5590836405754089,
-0.8143945932388306,
-0.18757504224777222,
0.0183908361941576,
-0.40160536766052246,
-0.4113105833530426,
-0.05010801553726196,
-0.21994763612747192,
-0.8262900114059448,
-0.34788835048675537,
0.6193240284919739,
-0.23754984140396118,
-0.2906864285469055,
0.31961116194725037,
-0.41836753487586975,
0.3598538339138031,
0.07288073003292084,
-0.8871611952781677,
0.37028202414512634,
0.9868544340133667,
0.682797908782959,
-0.08419999480247498,
-0.5069041848182678,
-0.4118165671825409,
-0.28182747960090637,
-0.3369198441505432,
0.5346962213516235,
-0.5657045841217041,
-0.46319666504859924,
-0.16133412718772888,
0.2436169683933258,
-0.1950574517250061,
-0.5520754456520081,
0.345874547958374,
-0.5184417963027954,
0.23940113186836243,
-0.2812773883342743,
-0.3999725580215454,
-0.38093826174736023,
0.12953193485736847,
-0.4496237635612488,
0.6671801805496216,
-0.061448343098163605,
-0.9007853269577026,
0.43912118673324585,
0.05476255342364311,
-0.6141729950904846,
-0.3715548515319824,
0.07303284853696823,
-1.0381711721420288,
0.39515259861946106,
0.16077692806720734,
0.19484369456768036,
-0.4259451925754547,
0.14896392822265625,
-0.4296550154685974,
-0.8920409679412842,
0.1278267800807953,
-0.6384146809577942,
1.0343080759048462,
-0.22092896699905396,
-0.1808636337518692,
-0.0817158967256546,
-0.8025140762329102,
-0.42317432165145874,
0.3296196162700653,
-0.3563399612903595,
-0.7289949059486389,
-0.23455265164375305,
-0.39775973558425903,
0.23031118512153625,
-0.04668990895152092,
-0.6551451683044434,
0.5941354036331177,
-0.7425333261489868,
0.35365867614746094,
0.7587929964065552,
-0.2997076213359833,
0.3153500258922577,
-0.44715023040771484,
0.5784425735473633,
0.31284087896347046,
-0.0194687582552433,
0.21294185519218445,
-0.6414869427680969,
-0.9006684422492981,
-0.242691770195961,
0.21391035616397858,
0.6707614660263062,
-0.890572190284729,
0.1729050874710083,
-0.5024880766868591,
-0.34766119718551636,
-0.927586019039154,
0.07073792070150375,
0.912132203578949,
0.7802325487136841,
0.42719125747680664,
-0.5976076126098633,
-1.0368852615356445,
-1.0284265279769897,
-0.5325692892074585,
-0.1275213062763214,
0.22891533374786377,
0.206988126039505,
0.6012380719184875,
-0.2448912262916565,
0.6220937967300415,
-0.37649986147880554,
-0.3754909634590149,
-0.2015988528728485,
0.2945569157600403,
0.21696414053440094,
0.5221014022827148,
0.28211501240730286,
-0.8488572239875793,
0.09715151786804199,
-0.5153903961181641,
-0.41099241375923157,
-0.20220424234867096,
-0.34578338265419006,
0.01999554969370365,
0.45890137553215027,
0.5729206204414368,
-0.43680182099342346,
0.5351508855819702,
0.6315566897392273,
-0.22147543728351593,
0.7508760094642639,
-0.1785748153924942,
-0.054464586079120636,
-0.8971261978149414,
0.16600799560546875,
-0.5335153341293335,
-0.22228533029556274,
-0.561032235622406,
0.033584337681531906,
-0.08197972923517227,
0.041601359844207764,
-0.22803208231925964,
0.5786523818969727,
-0.6253437399864197,
-0.5140187740325928,
-0.5311925411224365,
-0.03749586269259453,
0.044038351625204086,
0.30483102798461914,
0.15135303139686584,
0.7777073979377747,
0.6356821060180664,
-0.6072211265563965,
0.42326343059539795,
0.09614574909210205,
-0.007388856261968613,
0.5115172863006592,
-0.18768303096294403,
0.4082808196544647,
-0.2824096381664276,
0.30188271403312683,
-1.1030356884002686,
0.2905471622943878,
0.1295132339000702,
-0.5460118651390076,
0.5832881927490234,
-0.170898899435997,
-0.18633347749710083,
-0.9730304479598999,
-0.42724037170410156,
0.2519402801990509,
0.5339800715446472,
-1.0041043758392334,
0.46844789385795593,
0.08193956315517426,
0.2553507685661316,
-1.2285536527633667,
-1.102065086364746,
0.2696476876735687,
-0.3499588072299957,
-0.31125324964523315,
0.20551583170890808,
0.29778727889060974,
0.11507552117109299,
-0.12147164344787598,
-0.2575593888759613,
0.056285031139850616,
0.36113348603248596,
0.5000262260437012,
0.007338420953601599,
-0.23039136826992035,
0.45586004853248596,
-0.06972919404506683,
-0.21178822219371796,
-0.1157473623752594,
-0.8923430442810059,
0.7776222825050354,
0.21862761676311493,
-0.44251957535743713,
-0.07401283085346222,
0.07963389158248901,
0.32465553283691406,
0.052591823041439056,
0.9470745921134949,
0.45871594548225403,
-0.3507001996040344,
-0.050946690142154694,
-0.7201184630393982,
-0.5520143508911133,
-0.38828223943710327,
0.375386118888855,
-0.22562475502490997,
-0.7252900004386902,
0.5767632126808167,
0.0025570066645741463,
-0.0484842024743557,
0.012925859540700912,
0.44230151176452637,
0.014793815091252327,
0.9484449028968811,
0.857607364654541,
-0.3877563774585724,
0.24146993458271027,
-0.24348612129688263,
0.5065474510192871,
-0.7940071821212769,
-0.09923239052295685,
-0.4517271816730499,
-0.5968244671821594,
-0.47428780794143677,
-0.042553093284368515,
0.19047430157661438,
0.5179280042648315,
-0.12160782516002655,
0.5486247539520264,
-0.3493419587612152,
0.4045645296573639,
0.7470685243606567,
0.4684376120567322,
0.4379529654979706,
-0.2409527748823166,
-0.06666574627161026,
0.2456064522266388,
-0.6327716112136841,
-0.2817854881286621,
1.130698323249817,
0.11206991970539093,
0.7571450471878052,
-0.08294627070426941,
1.215187907218933,
-0.239005446434021,
0.6178938746452332,
-0.8511514663696289,
0.6686559319496155,
-0.5252427458763123,
-0.4472392797470093,
-0.36992427706718445,
-0.5950872898101807,
-1.2013721466064453,
0.3023197650909424,
-0.18923553824424744,
-0.4489721655845642,
0.06370369344949722,
0.3215503394603729,
-0.2491266131401062,
0.7598475813865662,
-0.7329708933830261,
0.4611281454563141,
-0.32837286591529846,
-0.04016788676381111,
-0.2980445325374603,
-0.6493783593177795,
0.4803059697151184,
-0.03911805525422096,
0.014195780269801617,
0.2799963653087616,
0.056938838213682175,
0.623849630355835,
-0.6937882304191589,
1.123040795326233,
-0.09376370906829834,
-0.21178506314754486,
-0.1540720909833908,
0.10869251936674118,
0.5291960835456848,
0.01978897675871849,
0.26868993043899536,
0.02710784785449505,
-0.5469120144844055,
-0.37974783778190613,
-0.5328389406204224,
0.9097590446472168,
-0.7298727035522461,
-0.9435760974884033,
-0.30547499656677246,
-0.2785727381706238,
-0.23172423243522644,
0.2272111177444458,
0.48959261178970337,
0.3676575720310211,
0.06278417259454727,
-0.31328585743904114,
0.5504493713378906,
-0.46514877676963806,
0.274568647146225,
0.8369860053062439,
-0.45955154299736023,
-0.09851475805044174,
1.0617731809616089,
0.22931388020515442,
0.20897836983203888,
0.42553505301475525,
0.43476569652557373,
-0.14530956745147705,
-0.5666608810424805,
-0.3471032977104187,
0.30645251274108887,
-0.48394766449928284,
-0.31767183542251587,
-0.6926663517951965,
-0.2079513669013977,
-0.6056526899337769,
-0.08751824498176575,
-0.3511086404323578,
-0.8016851544380188,
-0.6020976305007935,
-0.3251333236694336,
0.47017794847488403,
0.4826579689979553,
-0.222489133477211,
0.1571691334247589,
-0.5745640993118286,
0.3803342580795288,
0.5206628441810608,
0.5193669199943542,
0.16713188588619232,
-0.9434625506401062,
0.02381209097802639,
-0.08448520302772522,
-0.02907777950167656,
-0.6274561882019043,
0.5012648105621338,
0.06776160001754761,
0.16362743079662323,
0.3763508200645447,
-0.31125831604003906,
0.7743832468986511,
-0.6586386561393738,
0.5557982921600342,
0.5304916501045227,
-0.5583454966545105,
0.07244639843702316,
-0.013217364437878132,
0.08947479724884033,
0.31744590401649475,
0.5496248602867126,
-0.6866337060928345,
-0.4413064122200012,
-0.608359158039093,
-0.8692901134490967,
0.40830305218696594,
-0.10620872676372528,
0.3968961238861084,
-0.04587802290916443,
0.4519979655742645,
0.553291380405426,
0.3520980179309845,
-0.4891846477985382,
-0.2718375623226166,
-0.38805675506591797,
0.16892556846141815,
-0.05811658874154091,
-0.2532520592212677,
-0.059928979724645615,
-0.19196532666683197,
0.9511268734931946,
0.09130050241947174,
0.39625391364097595,
0.10480403155088425,
-0.13873757421970367,
-0.2189214676618576,
0.13407577574253082,
0.8219597339630127,
0.5079012513160706,
-0.02131996862590313,
0.2451678365468979,
0.23645950853824615,
-0.7874108552932739,
0.000312241492792964,
0.047422975301742554,
-0.29910045862197876,
-0.2821626663208008,
0.4708273112773895,
0.9473374485969543,
0.2838064730167389,
-0.28816935420036316,
0.45506659150123596,
0.1013096421957016,
-0.12668901681900024,
-0.5045823454856873,
-0.02255118265748024,
0.37628939747810364,
0.28532034158706665,
0.1626402586698532,
0.030750377103686333,
0.12138378620147705,
-0.6694948077201843,
0.2163238674402237,
0.5394949913024902,
-0.3731605112552643,
-0.20893286168575287,
0.3880685269832611,
0.0758669301867485,
-0.47495022416114807,
0.9957601428031921,
-0.041712164878845215,
-0.8157626986503601,
0.750149667263031,
0.8954552412033081,
0.9770540595054626,
-0.11097045242786407,
0.062159404158592224,
0.15469901263713837,
0.2688489258289337,
-0.49052903056144714,
0.5698027014732361,
0.5571836829185486,
-0.9877299070358276,
-0.26446911692619324,
-0.4068729281425476,
-0.15068455040454865,
0.04648404195904732,
-0.7671278119087219,
0.250554621219635,
-0.3377757966518402,
-0.21895650029182434,
-0.2581915557384491,
-0.3375172019004822,
-0.8079323768615723,
0.20597895979881287,
0.21668678522109985,
0.8340656757354736,
-0.855018138885498,
0.9469389319419861,
0.5874882936477661,
-0.6792083382606506,
-0.5797329545021057,
-0.11784501373767853,
-0.06253243237733841,
-1.456107258796692,
0.9424449801445007,
0.25328901410102844,
-0.38405686616897583,
0.13234807550907135,
-0.8521823287010193,
-0.573779284954071,
1.0124133825302124,
0.3436794877052307,
-0.862497866153717,
-0.20163635909557343,
0.03942541033029556,
0.6775828003883362,
-0.4252126216888428,
0.2595248222351074,
0.6715108156204224,
0.1452520191669464,
-0.26038458943367004,
-1.1159011125564575,
0.09100160002708435,
0.23471178114414215,
0.026554053649306297,
0.27987220883369446,
-0.6621567606925964,
0.7513336539268494,
-0.7492515444755554,
-0.2779999077320099,
0.21702341735363007,
0.18251413106918335,
0.19026081264019012,
0.1822446584701538,
0.43890759348869324,
1.0114861726760864,
0.5959616303443909,
-0.12466703355312347,
1.0052196979522705,
0.19752030074596405,
0.3561021685600281,
1.1985706090927124,
-0.30162039399147034,
0.6685342788696289,
0.7509490847587585,
0.15412969887256622,
0.5686196088790894,
0.1210535317659378,
-0.07911757379770279,
0.4280462861061096,
0.7441368103027344,
0.28622111678123474,
-0.3722606897354126,
0.09222893416881561,
-0.23464618623256683,
0.5432090759277344,
0.18494673073291779,
-0.5726757645606995,
-0.27805429697036743,
0.5779211521148682,
0.11099721491336823,
0.10382518917322159,
-0.6868137121200562,
0.7266408801078796,
0.4904261529445648,
-0.44199082255363464,
0.9448196291923523,
-0.26519015431404114,
0.9309097528457642,
-0.23922820389270782,
-0.20118868350982666,
-0.47067418694496155,
0.32408246397972107,
-0.2901707887649536,
-0.43573951721191406,
0.12935300171375275,
-0.39843428134918213,
-0.07820996642112732,
-0.18992264568805695,
0.8634351491928101,
-0.33263012766838074,
-0.4029203951358795,
0.42650285363197327,
0.18759441375732422,
0.25440070033073425,
0.06783317774534225,
-0.7051296234130859,
-0.30213692784309387,
-0.30206409096717834,
-0.19987992942333221,
0.3904899060726166,
0.16697685420513153,
-0.1109403595328331,
1.0946083068847656,
0.4827263057231903,
0.46769800782203674,
0.1168554276227951,
0.5106419324874878,
0.9025130867958069,
-0.7546063661575317,
-0.41137099266052246,
-0.720243513584137,
0.18247434496879578,
0.20710670948028564,
-0.4885564148426056,
0.6416330337524414,
0.3755180537700653,
0.9484317898750305,
-0.2685229778289795,
0.6265243291854858,
0.5501787066459656,
0.8703057169914246,
-0.7927099466323853,
0.6679440140724182,
-0.4217826724052429,
0.3756881654262543,
-0.1560787707567215,
-0.6615773439407349,
-0.45384716987609863,
0.37419453263282776,
-0.6177359223365784,
-0.012033785693347454,
0.4807506203651428,
0.7943497896194458,
-0.008703905157744884,
0.2792884409427643,
0.32950979471206665,
0.5731846690177917,
0.11689568310976028,
0.7685529589653015,
0.865746796131134,
-0.44703829288482666,
0.5828525424003601,
-0.1027555912733078,
0.018329232931137085,
-0.4869921803474426,
-0.8535224199295044,
-1.0742933750152588,
-0.37818828225135803,
-0.0385364331305027,
-0.6206355094909668,
0.45450687408447266,
0.8318763971328735,
0.47334134578704834,
-0.8700264096260071,
0.08589000254869461,
-0.26961901783943176,
0.2070852816104889,
-0.5812823176383972,
-0.17063289880752563,
0.3299919068813324,
-0.09118028730154037,
-0.11279530078172684,
0.2300824522972107,
0.14717307686805725,
0.1316964030265808,
-0.5681443810462952,
0.11196532100439072,
-0.16585509479045868,
0.08281830698251724,
0.3833984136581421,
0.5130146145820618,
-0.7218793630599976,
-0.5327632427215576,
-0.03690800815820694,
-0.16774879395961761,
0.0005147875635884702,
1.2257906198501587,
-1.1805707216262817,
0.3870416581630707,
0.5699338912963867,
0.7296466827392578,
0.3730365037918091,
-0.05482221022248268,
0.6489605903625488,
-0.6474245190620422,
0.09344297647476196,
0.39947083592414856,
0.41518688201904297,
0.4891088306903839,
-0.4894897937774658,
0.45427677035331726,
0.43773868680000305,
-0.36445873975753784,
-0.9970096349716187,
0.5020655393600464,
-0.40102675557136536,
-0.5332679152488708,
1.0177801847457886,
-0.1674218475818634,
0.060126353055238724,
-0.21560262143611908,
-0.11367979645729065,
0.3946901857852936,
-0.05857808142900467,
1.1438515186309814,
0.410751074552536,
-0.11598706245422363,
-0.13943883776664734,
-0.25456327199935913,
0.49024105072021484,
0.6749001741409302,
-0.17741964757442474,
0.17099587619304657,
0.05106864497065544,
0.584331750869751,
0.10133887827396393,
0.6476120352745056,
-0.3163257837295532,
0.04900592565536499,
-0.14518077671527863,
0.05818691477179527,
-0.2559233009815216,
-0.6391740441322327,
-0.815314769744873,
-0.475830078125,
0.013923965394496918,
-0.04151457920670509
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13786v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13786v2
|
Chain-of-Interaction: Enhancing Large Language Models for Psychiatric Behavior Understanding by Dyadic Contexts
| 2024-03-20T17:47:49 | 2024-03-23T04:02:01 |
Guangzeng Han, Weisi Liu, Xiaolei Huang, Brian Borsari
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Automatic coding patient behaviors is essential to support decision making
for psychotherapists during the motivational interviewing (MI), a collaborative
communication intervention approach to address psychiatric issues, such as
alcohol and drug addiction. While the behavior coding task has rapidly adapted
machine learning to predict patient states during the MI sessions, lacking of
domain-specific knowledge and overlooking patient-therapist interactions are
major challenges in developing and deploying those models in real practice. To
encounter those challenges, we introduce the Chain-of-Interaction (CoI)
prompting method aiming to contextualize large language models (LLMs) for
psychiatric decision support by the dyadic interactions. The CoI prompting
approach systematically breaks down the coding task into three key reasoning
steps, extract patient engagement, learn therapist question strategies, and
integrates dyadic interactions between patients and therapists. This approach
enables large language models to leverage the coding scheme, patient state, and
domain knowledge for patient behavioral coding. Experiments on real-world
datasets can prove the effectiveness and flexibility of our prompting method
with multiple state-of-the-art LLMs over existing prompting baselines. We have
conducted extensive ablation analysis and demonstrate the critical role of
dyadic interactions in applying LLMs for psychotherapy behavior understanding.
|
[
-0.5060174465179443,
-0.7884244918823242,
1.0098636150360107,
0.3463500738143921,
-0.01827387884259224,
0.10726293921470642,
-0.043298181146383286,
-0.11964479088783264,
0.1681869626045227,
0.3510509133338928,
-1.0147833824157715,
-0.3885425329208374,
-0.3545129597187042,
0.09099800884723663,
-0.14514154195785522,
0.8375779390335083,
-0.2573257088661194,
0.2812691628932953,
-0.1377880722284317,
0.10183244198560715,
-0.658173143863678,
-0.8540995717048645,
-0.9351933598518372,
-0.4230218529701233,
0.6794939637184143,
0.2705775201320648,
0.34745708107948303,
0.13223926723003387,
0.39379656314849854,
0.2868945896625519,
0.056959569454193115,
0.16107873618602753,
-0.64475017786026,
0.006180872675031424,
-0.3189893066883087,
-0.13164544105529785,
-0.6539387106895447,
0.03580523282289505,
0.3418941795825958,
1.2308242321014404,
-0.5990432500839233,
-0.08175303041934967,
-0.09786045551300049,
0.5420013070106506,
-0.5679093599319458,
0.05403267592191696,
-0.2324005514383316,
0.07895804196596146,
0.4462900757789612,
-0.36934879422187805,
-0.6838510036468506,
-0.13665035367012024,
0.09664054960012436,
-0.20090481638908386,
-0.1890578269958496,
0.1804187297821045,
0.41030481457710266,
0.255252480506897,
-0.6396079063415527,
-0.5075986385345459,
-0.8040461540222168,
0.41216301918029785,
-0.47926798462867737,
0.42920681834220886,
0.7844725847244263,
-0.13128620386123657,
-0.6193720102310181,
-0.45146942138671875,
-0.8487393260002136,
-0.23823441565036774,
-0.29759731888771057,
-0.10485044121742249,
-0.3901351988315582,
0.5452616810798645,
0.5187965035438538,
0.2368721216917038,
-0.3210074305534363,
0.19391489028930664,
-0.24223196506500244,
0.18018198013305664,
0.6365962028503418,
0.3905889093875885,
0.3996870517730713,
0.02792883850634098,
-0.2103833705186844,
0.1689341813325882,
-0.5160806179046631,
0.1570749133825302,
0.07377642393112183,
-0.09738738089799881,
-0.29206445813179016,
0.30400535464286804,
0.08561712503433228,
0.6830611824989319,
0.6467593908309937,
-0.07834926247596741,
-0.1604955941438675,
-0.19444453716278076,
-0.21673168241977692,
0.2534065544605255,
0.8993722200393677,
0.6257399916648865,
-0.08862259984016418,
-0.0504310205578804,
0.1181471198797226,
0.02395063452422619,
0.49973708391189575,
-0.6202362775802612,
-0.35593536496162415,
0.6555468440055847,
-0.5013294816017151,
-0.18050996959209442,
-0.2180013507604599,
-0.8598434925079346,
-0.3395899534225464,
-0.392704039812088,
0.34010303020477295,
-0.42001989483833313,
-0.3628579080104828,
0.396007776260376,
-0.14313074946403503,
0.0050090220756828785,
0.2672176659107208,
-1.0199719667434692,
0.6645808815956116,
0.5978050231933594,
0.8233451843261719,
-0.02682606317102909,
-0.5161988735198975,
-0.800028920173645,
0.4125894606113434,
-0.40596622228622437,
0.22117166221141815,
-0.4224419891834259,
-0.3475150465965271,
-0.0012047751806676388,
-0.09654579311609268,
-0.12690456211566925,
-0.2983773648738861,
0.05974106118083,
-0.5013697147369385,
0.13069036602973938,
-0.30567261576652527,
-0.5082412362098694,
-0.12657319009304047,
0.3398865759372711,
-0.5291066765785217,
0.5450888872146606,
0.355172723531723,
-0.6230980157852173,
0.2747753858566284,
-0.7011193037033081,
-0.24271617829799652,
0.017420360818505287,
-0.2977856397628784,
-0.09874696284532547,
0.10928171873092651,
0.221208393573761,
0.4686104953289032,
0.13830870389938354,
0.6719815135002136,
-0.34214192628860474,
-0.32099583745002747,
0.5103729963302612,
-0.12486620992422104,
0.6080136299133301,
0.07926272600889206,
0.029870806261897087,
0.1369054764509201,
-0.70801842212677,
-0.3402167558670044,
-0.07959538698196411,
-0.31795284152030945,
-0.4986008107662201,
-0.1330602616071701,
-0.4239131808280945,
0.342165470123291,
-0.0037599646020680666,
-0.29326561093330383,
0.41367512941360474,
-0.07952120900154114,
0.47976595163345337,
0.42558613419532776,
0.5143901705741882,
0.10168462991714478,
-0.17426873743534088,
0.7016322612762451,
0.026594378054142,
0.09251148998737335,
-0.23136773705482483,
-0.07135514914989471,
-0.4342213571071625,
-0.522240936756134,
-0.18449603021144867,
0.38323232531547546,
-0.9775605797767639,
0.5050407648086548,
-0.007267600391060114,
-0.2082589864730835,
-0.2597786784172058,
-0.1128288209438324,
0.4413846433162689,
0.6514211893081665,
0.29653701186180115,
-0.3070767819881439,
-0.9847864508628845,
-0.3968474566936493,
0.039405159652233124,
-0.3803853392601013,
0.11008410155773163,
0.277435839176178,
0.5403602123260498,
-0.35178709030151367,
1.015616774559021,
-0.3467785120010376,
0.15413948893547058,
-0.6262819766998291,
0.29179447889328003,
0.39648863673210144,
0.43522322177886963,
0.16138514876365662,
-0.35707929730415344,
-0.503758430480957,
-0.1713521033525467,
-0.7748461365699768,
0.04183244705200195,
-0.21185652911663055,
-0.17856717109680176,
-0.058249395340681076,
0.6300042271614075,
-0.23303315043449402,
0.3892802596092224,
0.7333034873008728,
-0.38026952743530273,
0.3218332529067993,
-0.4023803174495697,
0.5247224569320679,
-0.7772724032402039,
0.19574370980262756,
0.02816229686141014,
-0.0788223147392273,
-1.1047519445419312,
-0.32057854533195496,
-0.4323790967464447,
-0.2989458739757538,
-0.33073359727859497,
0.23654097318649292,
-0.1786232888698578,
0.20145073533058167,
-0.10040468722581863,
-0.18804261088371277,
-0.053511787205934525,
0.8184815645217896,
0.39794179797172546,
0.7235373854637146,
0.452692449092865,
-0.8279454112052917,
0.3752305507659912,
0.5580801367759705,
-0.019182123243808746,
0.7908991575241089,
-0.49486657977104187,
0.3809744715690613,
-0.14943979680538177,
0.5598118305206299,
-0.9183692336082458,
-0.3137122690677643,
0.573206901550293,
-0.059969909489154816,
0.05328067019581795,
-0.4520590305328369,
-0.17048770189285278,
-0.4698253571987152,
-0.04021187499165535,
0.656058132648468,
0.4817917048931122,
-0.6428624391555786,
0.18463489413261414,
0.42279374599456787,
-0.2629036009311676,
-0.3516296148300171,
-0.31668227910995483,
0.25351643562316895,
-0.3286720812320709,
-0.24445359408855438,
0.21953167021274567,
-0.0928482860326767,
-0.38576802611351013,
-0.5794153809547424,
0.027254607528448105,
-0.1718103587627411,
-0.024624895304441452,
0.14265234768390656,
0.5980085134506226,
0.2996929883956909,
-0.006049028132110834,
0.26983004808425903,
-0.11136218905448914,
0.46911710500717163,
-0.1362646073102951,
0.9079606533050537,
-0.09004517644643784,
-0.3437954783439636,
-0.8602759838104248,
0.5161750912666321,
0.39170148968696594,
-0.01859918236732483,
0.8972033262252808,
0.3506891429424286,
-0.28902512788772583,
0.19652357697486877,
-0.26367563009262085,
-0.2604571580886841,
-0.48957550525665283,
0.2692176401615143,
-0.4273917078971863,
-1.0016067028045654,
0.19063502550125122,
-0.4469294846057892,
-0.5050370693206787,
-0.37909772992134094,
0.6297529935836792,
-0.1405542492866516,
1.5112903118133545,
0.569646418094635,
-0.09330935776233673,
0.48381292819976807,
-0.22351215779781342,
0.5704986453056335,
-0.9717317223548889,
-0.27503475546836853,
-0.11157304793596268,
-0.04917962849140167,
-0.4131423532962799,
-0.3460196256637573,
0.6813656687736511,
0.2518056333065033,
-0.3389398157596588,
0.14514821767807007,
-0.34312382340431213,
0.2024908810853958,
0.058866847306489944,
0.36595314741134644,
0.2839358448982239,
0.09777582436800003,
-0.08210283517837524,
-0.05116685479879379,
-0.8654319643974304,
-0.20593975484371185,
0.5666869878768921,
0.621636688709259,
0.841677188873291,
0.09821344912052155,
0.8483473062515259,
0.2027250975370407,
0.003170961979776621,
-0.8995066285133362,
0.5608031153678894,
0.3211623430252075,
-0.07151009142398834,
-0.12327276170253754,
-0.2794100344181061,
-1.1727997064590454,
0.026521848514676094,
0.004110381007194519,
-1.2619268894195557,
0.5386643409729004,
0.29162153601646423,
-0.6415576338768005,
-0.007500389125198126,
-0.39273321628570557,
0.6875938773155212,
-0.08502590656280518,
-0.44255295395851135,
-0.5371478796005249,
-0.5064213871955872,
0.24448545277118683,
0.26588836312294006,
0.39366862177848816,
0.12954431772232056,
0.007540520280599594,
0.5730626583099365,
-0.6482003927230835,
0.9671637415885925,
-0.21978138387203217,
-0.4756025969982147,
0.10336393117904663,
0.4212665557861328,
0.5655079483985901,
0.126425638794899,
-0.2382355034351349,
-0.044994477182626724,
0.237863227725029,
-0.03849833086133003,
-0.864194929599762,
0.5401601195335388,
-0.5609596967697144,
-0.4951264262199402,
-0.3451956510543823,
-0.5823076963424683,
-0.44944238662719727,
-0.06399350613355637,
-0.037860967218875885,
0.5495603084564209,
-0.21667204797267914,
-0.35653695464134216,
0.7368441224098206,
-0.20128384232521057,
0.05959542095661163,
0.5263837575912476,
-0.37466496229171753,
-0.42403051257133484,
0.9256645441055298,
-0.4428451359272003,
0.148585706949234,
0.15465596318244934,
0.15332934260368347,
-0.12337296456098557,
-0.542098343372345,
-0.0022626793943345547,
0.36118805408477783,
-0.6545059680938721,
0.2855623662471771,
-0.763642430305481,
-0.04419312998652458,
-0.19988524913787842,
-0.3115631341934204,
0.04559209197759628,
0.19616352021694183,
0.12281396985054016,
-0.031535107642412186,
0.3999658226966858,
0.9461966156959534,
0.03745941072702408,
0.3511068522930145,
-1.0080240964889526,
0.16051846742630005,
0.15031196177005768,
0.5703083276748657,
0.29388540983200073,
0.04641677066683769,
-0.49951043725013733,
-0.09944082051515579,
-0.030115820467472076,
-1.217394471168518,
0.49218660593032837,
-0.1436367928981781,
0.391146183013916,
0.2217739224433899,
0.060021206736564636,
0.9299486875534058,
-0.4616544842720032,
0.700014054775238,
0.4567040503025055,
-1.262436032295227,
0.7906887531280518,
-0.5482255220413208,
0.10031457990407944,
0.6421411037445068,
0.9495959877967834,
-1.1275029182434082,
-0.14326044917106628,
-0.5142397880554199,
-0.6956383585929871,
0.9647645354270935,
-0.15735435485839844,
-0.18455341458320618,
-0.29218846559524536,
0.5906761288642883,
0.038508765399456024,
0.5200132131576538,
-0.5649631023406982,
-0.02810877375304699,
0.2369392067193985,
-0.4742348790168762,
0.25193119049072266,
-0.2215220034122467,
-0.5606210827827454,
-0.38587486743927,
0.37164005637168884,
-0.27422183752059937,
0.3782860338687897,
0.4419516623020172,
-0.05767028033733368,
-0.4406064450740814,
0.18576255440711975,
0.3489989638328552,
0.670720100402832,
-0.1949625313282013,
0.08605410903692245,
0.3452824652194977,
-0.288433313369751,
0.33530527353286743,
-0.3305284082889557,
0.4477534294128418,
-0.42397359013557434,
0.2636745572090149,
1.0318527221679688,
-0.07554010301828384,
-0.7796579599380493,
0.3635706305503845,
-0.37791377305984497,
-0.18435107171535492,
-0.19000738859176636,
0.19095048308372498,
-0.28053992986679077,
0.24202990531921387,
-0.11296307295560837,
-0.27010872960090637,
0.43147650361061096,
-0.7846976518630981,
0.23146530985832214,
0.24937278032302856,
-0.5684297680854797,
-0.27175459265708923,
0.016155239194631577,
0.27747195959091187,
-0.5010772943496704,
0.8676812648773193,
-0.2165963053703308,
-0.5697301626205444,
0.28580620884895325,
0.509221076965332,
0.44032374024391174,
-0.07012669742107391,
0.1811995506286621,
0.551058292388916,
-0.3071354925632477,
-0.06528611481189728,
0.41333305835723877,
-0.23170296847820282,
-0.6176751852035522,
-0.6204829216003418,
-0.07727479189634323,
-0.6662163138389587,
0.275991290807724,
-0.9309035539627075,
0.30207493901252747,
-0.5836426615715027,
-0.004075026139616966,
-0.25085166096687317,
-0.16311533749103546,
-0.37485992908477783,
-0.10266721993684769,
0.378602534532547,
0.5649223327636719,
-0.7281982898712158,
0.7449541687965393,
0.8154773116111755,
-0.3575018644332886,
-0.9731982350349426,
0.13042837381362915,
-0.0005359197384677827,
-0.6892803907394409,
0.5740797519683838,
0.008539157919585705,
-0.08670610189437866,
0.14640000462532043,
-0.5765166878700256,
-0.719667375087738,
0.9169753193855286,
0.16568492352962494,
-0.6310400366783142,
-0.11360324919223785,
0.08031248301267624,
0.6897750496864319,
-0.6028276085853577,
0.33700886368751526,
0.917368471622467,
0.2993132472038269,
0.2845294177532196,
-0.955712616443634,
0.4188503324985504,
-0.2481561303138733,
0.04523244500160217,
0.2690916955471039,
-0.38248372077941895,
0.5004534721374512,
-0.24017512798309326,
-0.036444760859012604,
0.04246990755200386,
0.20725765824317932,
0.46084579825401306,
0.3584025800228119,
0.8560919761657715,
0.1885022073984146,
1.0501694679260254,
0.215852290391922,
0.9073305130004883,
-0.44039222598075867,
0.27110934257507324,
0.9816190600395203,
-0.6250772476196289,
0.7202463150024414,
0.8941433429718018,
-0.41642820835113525,
0.9560233950614929,
0.5468262434005737,
-0.050947412848472595,
0.3046296238899231,
0.24896448850631714,
-0.3774131238460541,
-0.2133120447397232,
-0.3581162095069885,
0.00718830619007349,
0.292623907327652,
0.6390687823295593,
-0.12623922526836395,
0.11563578248023987,
0.32115843892097473,
0.10937502980232239,
-0.06841599196195602,
-0.24756336212158203,
1.06696355342865,
0.16555726528167725,
-1.180393099784851,
0.784666895866394,
-0.25258365273475647,
0.3401670753955841,
-0.504160463809967,
-0.24314101040363312,
0.17212863266468048,
0.11026468873023987,
-0.32183486223220825,
-0.693633496761322,
0.31163573265075684,
-0.03670988604426384,
-0.22281424701213837,
-0.3723856806755066,
0.4454044997692108,
-0.8147194385528564,
0.009897039271891117,
0.337462455034256,
0.44681328535079956,
0.1388150006532669,
0.27812862396240234,
-0.6233599185943604,
0.26084381341934204,
-0.17020194232463837,
0.08602491021156311,
0.5399072170257568,
0.1452046036720276,
0.04947730526328087,
0.6319590210914612,
0.6983969211578369,
0.011250592768192291,
-0.5409733057022095,
0.32157737016677856,
0.8555033206939697,
-0.5454103350639343,
-0.6544697284698486,
-0.9362318515777588,
0.47724592685699463,
0.03354231268167496,
0.18219028413295746,
0.4216535985469818,
-0.03149303421378136,
0.3850964307785034,
0.08399920165538788,
0.6755223274230957,
-0.22194965183734894,
0.1753876656293869,
-0.5461537837982178,
0.3037513792514801,
-0.34075209498405457,
0.3047102987766266,
-0.1691996157169342,
-0.23780560493469238,
0.02379312366247177,
0.5979007482528687,
-0.5899253487586975,
0.033144157379865646,
0.8884715437889099,
0.6702428460121155,
0.2970936894416809,
0.08392194658517838,
0.13271664083003998,
0.2827956974506378,
0.4897541105747223,
0.6894197463989258,
1.107723355293274,
-0.143485888838768,
0.12355347722768784,
-0.29600903391838074,
-0.4006194770336151,
-0.10066713392734528,
-0.9211908578872681,
-0.99726802110672,
-0.5148380994796753,
-0.4558529555797577,
-0.6560203433036804,
0.21776480972766876,
1.5236399173736572,
0.6824012398719788,
-0.5047569274902344,
-0.7001824975013733,
-0.3869769871234894,
0.06488610804080963,
-0.6116352081298828,
-0.16957993805408478,
0.06418561935424805,
-0.30930522084236145,
-0.7009488344192505,
0.4964447617530823,
0.47366851568222046,
-0.12330971658229828,
-0.42236417531967163,
-0.3963907063007355,
-0.41343656182289124,
0.03496023640036583,
0.47152063250541687,
0.11461299657821655,
-0.33927279710769653,
-0.06424946337938309,
-0.19204488396644592,
0.05668012425303459,
0.17251138389110565,
1.1933166980743408,
-0.8039487600326538,
0.2633768320083618,
0.3701704442501068,
0.1911468505859375,
0.3015271723270416,
-0.05764276906847954,
1.0806528329849243,
-0.5732774138450623,
0.14800085127353668,
0.1802549511194229,
0.2337321788072586,
0.0913139283657074,
-0.7148193120956421,
0.23789086937904358,
-0.0006608963012695312,
-0.5795409679412842,
-0.8811155557632446,
0.42377474904060364,
-0.8135417103767395,
-0.23547165095806122,
0.9826807379722595,
-0.3637523353099823,
-0.4214080274105072,
-0.4582860469818115,
-0.6022285223007202,
0.18335606157779694,
-0.5108985900878906,
0.7676798701286316,
0.6773982644081116,
-0.6276711821556091,
-0.3999791145324707,
-0.133308544754982,
0.7511229515075684,
0.38204333186149597,
-0.682017982006073,
0.03976908698678017,
0.3810831904411316,
0.05356886610388756,
-0.030574394389986992,
0.9927685856819153,
0.29468563199043274,
0.3348567485809326,
-0.08949559181928635,
0.060787271708250046,
0.06723758578300476,
-0.22216561436653137,
-0.6515032649040222,
-0.14140427112579346,
0.1291535645723343,
0.15644042193889618
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13780v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13780v1
|
Information-Theoretic Distillation for Reference-less Summarization
| 2024-03-20T17:42:08 | 2024-03-20T17:42:08 |
Jaehun Jung, Ximing Lu, Liwei Jiang, Faeze Brahman, Peter West, Pang Wei Koh, Yejin Choi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The current winning recipe for automatic summarization is using proprietary
large-scale language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT as is, or imitation learning
from them as teacher models. While increasingly ubiquitous dependence on such
large-scale language models is convenient, there remains an important question
of whether small-scale models could have achieved competitive results, if we
were to seek an alternative learning method -- that allows for a more
cost-efficient, controllable, yet powerful summarizer. We present InfoSumm, a
novel framework to distill a powerful summarizer based on the
information-theoretic objective for summarization, without relying on either
the LLM's capability or human-written references. To achieve this, we first
propose a novel formulation of the desiderata of summarization (saliency,
faithfulness and brevity) through the lens of mutual information between the
original document and the summary. Based on this formulation, we start off from
Pythia-2.8B as the teacher model, which is not yet capable of summarization,
then self-train the model to optimize for the information-centric measures of
ideal summaries. Distilling from the improved teacher, we arrive at a compact
but powerful summarizer with only 568M parameters that performs competitively
against ChatGPT, without ever relying on ChatGPT's capabilities. Extensive
analysis demonstrates that our approach outperforms in-domain supervised models
in human evaluation, let alone state-of-the-art unsupervised methods, and wins
over ChatGPT in controllable summarization.
|
[
-0.3157584071159363,
-0.5679706931114197,
0.22616314888000488,
0.013047270476818085,
-0.5491918325424194,
-0.018690329045057297,
-0.4946107864379883,
-0.20730595290660858,
0.3371333181858063,
0.18556922674179077,
-0.2563849985599518,
-0.177964985370636,
-0.8080931305885315,
0.014700114727020264,
-0.6056291460990906,
1.310988187789917,
0.08100228756666183,
-0.08461058884859085,
-0.30663004517555237,
-0.04121984541416168,
-0.04817478731274605,
-0.6444352269172668,
-0.2230241745710373,
-0.5265969038009644,
0.5576136708259583,
0.6167570352554321,
0.4655627906322479,
0.6279714703559875,
0.6896883845329285,
0.23721455037593842,
-0.1630183458328247,
0.2383769005537033,
-0.6907994747161865,
-0.1039024069905281,
-0.2708880305290222,
-0.5434041023254395,
-0.3650973439216614,
0.21971483528614044,
0.705798327922821,
0.8858467936515808,
-0.2997303307056427,
0.35129275918006897,
0.42620375752449036,
1.025490164756775,
-0.7748238444328308,
0.49969807267189026,
-0.6145575046539307,
-0.10579518228769302,
0.011903153732419014,
-0.26109522581100464,
-0.34399157762527466,
-0.6180840134620667,
0.3394743800163269,
-0.41441500186920166,
0.35292840003967285,
-0.11155813187360764,
0.7724934220314026,
0.3977803587913513,
-0.28045108914375305,
-0.3826363682746887,
-0.8928137421607971,
0.5330572128295898,
-0.6400359869003296,
-0.05921357870101929,
0.32311320304870605,
0.5013589859008789,
0.04844379052519798,
-0.8568011522293091,
-0.42121878266334534,
-0.12452705204486847,
-0.16590562462806702,
0.40053659677505493,
-0.2760964334011078,
-0.006095099728554487,
0.07216159999370575,
0.5292966961860657,
-0.35682937502861023,
-0.32553359866142273,
-0.5476877093315125,
0.3389979898929596,
0.31228747963905334,
0.026464104652404785,
-0.09337040781974792,
0.0015647471882402897,
-0.4603266417980194,
0.1798093616962433,
-0.6448298692703247,
-0.3730289340019226,
0.08446089923381805,
0.10319805145263672,
-0.020525403320789337,
0.556582510471344,
-0.37086042761802673,
0.4599359333515167,
0.31478849053382874,
-0.2508785128593445,
-0.24820813536643982,
-0.39691802859306335,
-0.12192511558532715,
0.3408196270465851,
0.6827328205108643,
0.4275066554546356,
0.4188980758190155,
-0.23100325465202332,
0.1288100779056549,
-0.02238982915878296,
-0.03439442440867424,
-1.2000551223754883,
-0.775176465511322,
-0.04819619283080101,
-0.28362521529197693,
-0.5738469362258911,
0.1367064267396927,
-0.6215483546257019,
-0.4671128988265991,
-0.41645559668540955,
0.4197555184364319,
-0.4562900960445404,
-0.29361629486083984,
-0.16874690353870392,
-0.3113732933998108,
-0.22393982112407684,
0.3994079828262329,
-1.0595215559005737,
0.5607059001922607,
0.3205881714820862,
1.0017518997192383,
-0.14259521663188934,
-0.41597795486450195,
-0.13601459562778473,
0.29237768054008484,
-0.33184805512428284,
0.6583365797996521,
-0.28013578057289124,
-0.1682681292295456,
-0.5304497480392456,
-0.4322020709514618,
0.1332208812236786,
-0.6658071279525757,
0.14233078062534332,
-0.5256484150886536,
0.2684077322483063,
-0.25551989674568176,
-0.6785785555839539,
-0.5956897735595703,
0.09044497460126877,
-0.6351010799407959,
0.7570145726203918,
0.11696576327085495,
-1.090595006942749,
0.341471791267395,
-0.5061259269714355,
-0.1897464543581009,
-0.15778367221355438,
-0.08182685077190399,
-0.3214791715145111,
0.2684938609600067,
-0.006256851367652416,
0.28880637884140015,
-0.49543267488479614,
0.49794507026672363,
-0.05461477115750313,
-0.5287517309188843,
0.16165097057819366,
-0.6805979609489441,
0.5699883699417114,
0.14113615453243256,
-0.16501131653785706,
-0.17538291215896606,
-0.6168157458305359,
-0.2491382360458374,
0.133234441280365,
-0.39469820261001587,
-0.4399799108505249,
0.011052075773477554,
-0.19731304049491882,
-0.08312836289405823,
0.45929014682769775,
-0.07127691060304642,
0.3290952444076538,
-0.1745942085981369,
0.36499881744384766,
0.5931953191757202,
0.09344522655010223,
0.5519219636917114,
-0.6097257733345032,
0.26500871777534485,
-0.13697057962417603,
-0.07181508839130402,
-0.3348332941532135,
-0.07927583158016205,
-0.6408442854881287,
-0.6748707294464111,
0.5918763279914856,
0.3602854013442993,
-0.5535187721252441,
0.32743582129478455,
-0.500584602355957,
-0.7427831292152405,
-0.2585958242416382,
0.1310352385044098,
0.26459747552871704,
0.6759655475616455,
0.299310564994812,
-0.1451178640127182,
-0.5475046038627625,
-0.6660785675048828,
-0.39416563510894775,
-0.23477698862552643,
0.011544882319867611,
-0.11995751410722733,
0.3702663481235504,
0.21826171875,
1.08888578414917,
-0.617387592792511,
-0.327131062746048,
-0.6728851199150085,
0.186599001288414,
0.5271586775779724,
0.2183963507413864,
0.595251202583313,
-0.8929449915885925,
-0.5906481742858887,
-0.3601061701774597,
-0.8724253177642822,
-0.2684062421321869,
0.10954504460096359,
-0.004215192515403032,
-0.24179694056510925,
0.29859206080436707,
-0.5333847999572754,
0.40509042143821716,
0.20030373334884644,
-0.056236427277326584,
0.6071587800979614,
-0.5383422374725342,
0.1757546067237854,
-1.1745657920837402,
0.3180515766143799,
-0.26263052225112915,
-0.2711639404296875,
-0.5437151193618774,
0.08264338225126266,
0.1966344118118286,
-0.0033754194155335426,
-0.17478759586811066,
0.4266233444213867,
-0.5064679980278015,
0.11852844804525375,
-0.6497472524642944,
0.5286320447921753,
0.13305111229419708,
0.6670175194740295,
0.14551910758018494,
0.4143884479999542,
0.23550738394260406,
-0.8154593706130981,
0.5243054628372192,
0.1027519479393959,
-0.4257396161556244,
0.6631651520729065,
-0.6516218185424805,
-0.37206000089645386,
-0.4940411150455475,
0.32334578037261963,
-0.9368597865104675,
-0.39628469944000244,
0.08478276431560516,
-0.36886221170425415,
0.36762911081314087,
-0.32311663031578064,
-0.4939699172973633,
0.04464665427803993,
-0.42632317543029785,
0.37587302923202515,
0.5845082998275757,
-0.6823744177818298,
0.5631736516952515,
0.3005546033382416,
-0.5150039792060852,
-0.5822435617446899,
-0.6342921257019043,
0.13201607763767242,
-0.36101576685905457,
-0.34229618310928345,
0.3789445161819458,
-0.12037520110607147,
-0.5235508680343628,
0.0915621817111969,
-0.37040039896965027,
-0.24517254531383514,
0.19589769840240479,
0.1059613898396492,
0.4416462481021881,
0.1170831024646759,
0.2643584907054901,
0.0351748950779438,
-0.2536141574382782,
-0.2924763262271881,
-0.3465118706226349,
0.3757154047489166,
0.002252621576189995,
-0.2246289998292923,
-0.3831719160079956,
0.2676945626735687,
0.4780748188495636,
-0.1852426379919052,
0.4968096613883972,
0.13752643764019012,
-0.27134665846824646,
-0.05480307340621948,
-0.44175219535827637,
-0.3913070857524872,
-0.3957132399082184,
0.5207935571670532,
-0.2334025800228119,
-0.360371470451355,
0.2501789331436157,
-0.1473194807767868,
0.29840439558029175,
0.3425803482532501,
0.4752885401248932,
-0.12751628458499908,
0.5849007368087769,
0.5647220015525818,
-0.2692373991012573,
0.6541429758071899,
-0.26897838711738586,
-0.02644100785255432,
-0.5717149376869202,
-0.10591551661491394,
-0.2553510069847107,
-0.4060899615287781,
-0.2611904740333557,
-0.11344688385725021,
0.6624453067779541,
0.34037724137306213,
0.035142067819833755,
0.18285809457302094,
-0.36636441946029663,
0.7912865877151489,
0.6461987495422363,
0.010030636563897133,
0.8016483783721924,
0.046719323843717575,
0.1004917249083519,
0.036174532026052475,
-1.0121904611587524,
-0.49323543906211853,
1.1135410070419312,
0.035155799239873886,
0.9686899185180664,
0.25660136342048645,
0.7656840085983276,
0.22675389051437378,
0.3970554769039154,
-0.7066804766654968,
0.4043828845024109,
-0.10476280748844147,
-0.44686535000801086,
-0.14424417912960052,
-0.605492353439331,
-0.6050221920013428,
0.6992229223251343,
0.043185193091630936,
-0.5417394042015076,
-0.057338617742061615,
0.2992244362831116,
-0.23272636532783508,
0.3403998017311096,
-0.9298869967460632,
0.6212097406387329,
0.08653543889522552,
-0.29650595784187317,
-0.2733590304851532,
-0.5375180840492249,
0.4945172965526581,
-0.09774546325206757,
0.30937203764915466,
-0.07111482322216034,
-0.048761315643787384,
0.6991539597511292,
-0.6873885989189148,
0.6939104199409485,
-0.05089058727025986,
0.12749162316322327,
0.435701459646225,
0.2590237855911255,
0.49903738498687744,
-0.0016972704324871302,
0.049443040043115616,
-0.011950221844017506,
0.08909397572278976,
-0.4642883539199829,
-0.7392347455024719,
0.58869868516922,
-0.47991353273391724,
-0.5743215084075928,
-0.5188238024711609,
-0.4115602672100067,
0.01886569708585739,
0.4019602835178375,
0.5044795870780945,
0.49973589181900024,
-0.21438471972942352,
0.16093125939369202,
0.6005687713623047,
0.4547021687030792,
0.49063682556152344,
0.6695773601531982,
-0.320535272359848,
-0.3883342444896698,
0.9766342043876648,
0.38876408338546753,
0.44986531138420105,
0.560531735420227,
0.4542139172554016,
-0.1974307745695114,
-0.4855853021144867,
-0.29672256112098694,
0.2765936851501465,
-0.7784914374351501,
0.0586811788380146,
-0.5155075192451477,
-0.12730920314788818,
-0.14585942029953003,
0.040287312120199203,
-0.4456290900707245,
-0.7693975567817688,
-0.12854260206222534,
-0.1224507987499237,
0.24574176967144012,
0.6996405124664307,
-0.20808443427085876,
0.3029668629169464,
-0.6380671858787537,
0.3868653476238251,
0.367942750453949,
0.10587839782238007,
-0.051323674619197845,
-0.8353497982025146,
-0.3848939836025238,
0.17280209064483643,
-0.17094020545482635,
-0.7719975113868713,
0.24196752905845642,
0.42268744111061096,
0.2527311146259308,
0.49629831314086914,
0.38085663318634033,
0.6000562310218811,
-0.2950820326805115,
0.437429815530777,
0.16649721562862396,
-0.8167340755462646,
0.34392353892326355,
-0.14622047543525696,
0.4671891927719116,
0.8384771943092346,
0.2819139361381531,
-0.5576185584068298,
-0.4353936016559601,
-0.6411457061767578,
-0.915901243686676,
0.6716070771217346,
0.2979484498500824,
-0.159584641456604,
0.19034335017204285,
0.28811708092689514,
0.23184360563755035,
0.5422388315200806,
-0.5096189975738525,
-0.36448484659194946,
-0.13616915047168732,
-0.4358888864517212,
-0.10173297673463821,
-0.37836018204689026,
-0.046547405421733856,
0.017192617058753967,
0.9284555315971375,
0.03488792106509209,
-0.21681764721870422,
0.19710010290145874,
-0.30930620431900024,
0.35043829679489136,
0.08978702872991562,
0.33956703543663025,
0.7706186175346375,
-0.3377837538719177,
0.6868448853492737,
0.09656994044780731,
-0.6668474674224854,
0.17328964173793793,
0.18730098009109497,
-0.36588531732559204,
0.2726210951805115,
0.3930121958255768,
0.40107783675193787,
0.2862071692943573,
-0.5646666884422302,
0.6104106903076172,
-0.15372522175312042,
-0.014951629564166069,
-0.31719398498535156,
0.09278781712055206,
0.11150985211133957,
0.2470940500497818,
0.4384172856807709,
0.08361860364675522,
0.2224031388759613,
-0.4170740246772766,
0.1939803659915924,
0.04822978377342224,
-0.3640260696411133,
-0.33750563859939575,
0.5812212228775024,
0.006141725927591324,
0.25650206208229065,
0.18246780335903168,
-0.17836356163024902,
-0.2584855556488037,
0.47086259722709656,
0.3173421323299408,
0.6791349649429321,
-0.35887715220451355,
0.11541395634412766,
0.3831368386745453,
0.1907079815864563,
-0.3387977182865143,
0.05429955571889877,
-0.36817029118537903,
-0.3251325786113739,
-0.09771028906106949,
-0.2716284692287445,
-0.5528074502944946,
-0.2619289457798004,
-0.6137484908103943,
0.32905876636505127,
-0.40443843603134155,
0.09030335396528244,
0.17843428254127502,
-0.05956202745437622,
-0.1494860053062439,
0.11679832637310028,
-0.24248160421848297,
0.7496081590652466,
-0.46853378415107727,
0.7728030681610107,
0.396721750497818,
-0.47638025879859924,
-0.5216163396835327,
0.04319491609930992,
-0.055758848786354065,
-0.368003785610199,
0.437750905752182,
0.07702326774597168,
-0.27898073196411133,
0.07107946276664734,
-0.31964680552482605,
-0.7600877285003662,
1.3290770053863525,
0.7313317656517029,
-0.5983892679214478,
-0.37264367938041687,
-0.23596550524234772,
0.24640507996082306,
-0.053674615919589996,
0.43577417731285095,
0.42423176765441895,
0.19398066401481628,
0.39030760526657104,
-0.8619325160980225,
-0.14545758068561554,
-0.2687556743621826,
-0.217037171125412,
0.16512110829353333,
-0.8956105709075928,
0.8885740637779236,
-0.5534209609031677,
-0.40860822796821594,
-0.08443402498960495,
0.48771798610687256,
-0.0722896158695221,
0.09205853939056396,
0.04070880264043808,
0.32643765211105347,
0.9527071714401245,
-0.06953995674848557,
0.8329939842224121,
-0.46552518010139465,
0.45027095079421997,
1.8248002529144287,
0.1075834408402443,
0.48228663206100464,
0.46830540895462036,
-0.24385741353034973,
0.18297439813613892,
0.3722974359989166,
0.1607392430305481,
0.7337672710418701,
0.19336670637130737,
-0.4376237392425537,
0.014288344420492649,
-0.07649383693933487,
-0.358796626329422,
0.529312014579773,
0.032885052263736725,
-0.43205052614212036,
-0.6624035239219666,
-0.32125070691108704,
0.21756137907505035,
0.17564697563648224,
-0.29588782787323,
1.0919480323791504,
0.14601284265518188,
-0.6118836998939514,
0.7152127623558044,
0.15506471693515778,
0.46456772089004517,
-0.7267528772354126,
-0.017533328384160995,
-0.26950615644454956,
0.2778727114200592,
-0.14995254576206207,
-0.1911778450012207,
0.19652524590492249,
0.17649222910404205,
-0.19275248050689697,
0.13246287405490875,
0.5233826041221619,
-0.7261528372764587,
-0.39352133870124817,
-0.1412314474582672,
0.23118247091770172,
0.3091984689235687,
-0.329415887594223,
-0.05161643773317337,
-0.46548154950141907,
-0.1309921145439148,
-0.14392916858196259,
0.2678675949573517,
0.5031355023384094,
0.23279069364070892,
0.5936631560325623,
0.2813340127468109,
0.2465217262506485,
-0.24706658720970154,
-0.1422487199306488,
0.8723452091217041,
-0.5786251425743103,
-0.7467280626296997,
-1.4108457565307617,
0.260156512260437,
-0.2238447219133377,
0.060162633657455444,
0.7920841574668884,
0.7636565566062927,
0.5783270597457886,
0.03751698508858681,
1.1942662000656128,
0.04492371901869774,
0.4768174886703491,
-0.3585645258426666,
0.8120560050010681,
-0.26450788974761963,
0.24475795030593872,
-0.32180511951446533,
-1.0618336200714111,
-0.006171496119350195,
0.5219494700431824,
-0.24749454855918884,
-0.09327557682991028,
0.6190104484558105,
0.36839282512664795,
-0.11734668910503387,
0.1027575135231018,
0.22865894436836243,
0.12079677730798721,
0.19625410437583923,
0.643162727355957,
0.7742757797241211,
-0.3434908092021942,
0.6506880521774292,
-0.2445453405380249,
-0.7062192559242249,
-0.47241631150245667,
-0.9052568674087524,
-1.0382078886032104,
-0.5276845097541809,
-0.29804444313049316,
-0.11278204619884491,
-0.06612227857112885,
1.1153209209442139,
0.5257166624069214,
-0.5206401348114014,
-0.2081792950630188,
-0.11584492027759552,
0.30257076025009155,
-0.18179504573345184,
-0.17113927006721497,
0.40635043382644653,
-0.144048273563385,
-0.8480802774429321,
0.09339306503534317,
0.311950147151947,
0.2561071813106537,
-0.18239693343639374,
0.1463235765695572,
0.13945503532886505,
0.35159212350845337,
0.4468533396720886,
0.022042248398065567,
-0.2568266689777374,
0.18590569496154785,
-0.38555777072906494,
-0.10093015432357788,
0.11629833281040192,
0.728174090385437,
-0.46456414461135864,
0.6062197089195251,
0.3899383842945099,
0.3521946370601654,
0.7235361337661743,
0.2538403570652008,
0.4692193865776062,
-0.6091718673706055,
0.3544984757900238,
0.13256767392158508,
0.29897797107696533,
0.12257575243711472,
-0.09182697534561157,
0.4288507103919983,
0.2991310656070709,
-0.250167578458786,
-0.5891458988189697,
0.28625819087028503,
-0.6204525828361511,
-0.22677312791347504,
1.0119256973266602,
-0.45233872532844543,
-0.20673081278800964,
0.10136740654706955,
-0.4641279876232147,
0.3862534761428833,
-0.3719867169857025,
1.2138092517852783,
0.7353777289390564,
0.08335938304662704,
0.11530719697475433,
-0.16736215353012085,
0.5308927893638611,
0.15646757185459137,
-0.7438433766365051,
0.43961450457572937,
0.6637973785400391,
0.27319732308387756,
0.07645590603351593,
0.797989547252655,
-0.18712759017944336,
0.28971067070961,
0.11561212688684464,
0.06951243430376053,
-0.5174233317375183,
-0.49858254194259644,
-0.1251240223646164,
0.3462870419025421,
0.2787860929965973,
-0.14074018597602844
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13754v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13754v1
|
Different Tokenization Schemes Lead to Comparable Performance in Spanish Number Agreement
| 2024-03-20T17:01:56 | 2024-03-20T17:01:56 |
Catherine Arnett, Pamela D. Rivière, Tyler A. Chang, Sean Trott
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The relationship between language model tokenization and performance is an
open area of research. Here, we investigate how different tokenization schemes
impact number agreement in Spanish plurals. We find that
morphologically-aligned tokenization performs similarly to other tokenization
schemes, even when induced artificially for words that would not be tokenized
that way during training. We then present exploratory analyses demonstrating
that language model embeddings for different plural tokenizations have similar
distributions along the embedding space axis that maximally distinguishes
singular and plural nouns. Our results suggest that morphologically-aligned
tokenization is a viable tokenization approach, and existing models already
generalize some morphological patterns to new items. However, our results
indicate that morphological tokenization is not strictly required for
performance.
|
[
-0.3009040951728821,
-0.3748524785041809,
0.3284911811351776,
0.8648592233657837,
-0.6534046530723572,
0.12782207131385803,
0.03478163480758667,
-0.6002086400985718,
0.5965890288352966,
0.11442263424396515,
0.07400666922330856,
-0.36733901500701904,
-0.6700931787490845,
0.4579601287841797,
-0.20933865010738373,
0.6161165237426758,
0.20553918182849884,
0.5691195726394653,
-0.18478834629058838,
-0.3359844386577606,
-0.5494356155395508,
-0.9117833375930786,
-0.44780731201171875,
-0.15099592506885529,
0.7751940488815308,
-0.10062485188245773,
0.9248756766319275,
0.8648125529289246,
0.8373405933380127,
0.4797065854072571,
-0.1731155812740326,
0.05464688315987587,
-0.0858653113245964,
0.1358686089515686,
-0.16655226051807404,
-0.23967857658863068,
-0.4984991252422333,
-0.2775003910064697,
0.8747251629829407,
0.7430524826049805,
-0.03908630087971687,
-0.2370312511920929,
-0.2846529185771942,
0.31199678778648376,
-0.40495625138282776,
0.0015285916160792112,
-0.7840206027030945,
-0.06854069232940674,
-0.3821813464164734,
0.039732299745082855,
-0.3931061923503876,
-0.5874831676483154,
0.11389042437076569,
-0.38770610094070435,
0.004115030635148287,
0.011229374445974827,
0.7128285765647888,
0.3523443043231964,
-0.3994387984275818,
-0.49498581886291504,
-0.29869046807289124,
0.68436199426651,
-0.8969130516052246,
0.5655693411827087,
0.07787851989269257,
-0.047612275928258896,
-0.048731960356235504,
-0.40581345558166504,
-0.4495915174484253,
-0.08320707827806473,
-0.10676082968711853,
0.026190966367721558,
-0.1702495813369751,
0.25897881388664246,
0.15472476184368134,
0.3625052273273468,
-0.36135467886924744,
0.6888321042060852,
-0.6276148557662964,
-0.06531084328889847,
0.44571346044540405,
0.011391118168830872,
0.4817132353782654,
-0.39261284470558167,
-0.49496424198150635,
0.04797111079096794,
-0.6756134629249573,
0.13099895417690277,
0.5678058862686157,
0.7857241034507751,
0.012995687313377857,
0.8790202736854553,
0.19479243457317352,
0.5538484454154968,
0.014788692817091942,
0.03967450559139252,
0.4100490212440491,
-0.39139077067375183,
-0.1487257182598114,
0.16194415092468262,
0.7540475726127625,
-0.03505144640803337,
0.2705950438976288,
-0.6655243635177612,
-0.3894270360469818,
0.3739326298236847,
0.3366493582725525,
-0.5566632151603699,
0.2819710075855255,
0.15963461995124817,
-0.25288212299346924,
-0.36421671509742737,
0.9666507244110107,
-0.1959204524755478,
-0.1475214660167694,
-0.1406441628932953,
0.39307701587677,
-0.3470921814441681,
-0.3270855247974396,
0.4371086061000824,
-0.4602150022983551,
0.3956071734428406,
0.06853943318128586,
-1.2834796905517578,
0.6641829013824463,
1.34541916847229,
1.1520048379898071,
-0.4247189462184906,
-0.466628760099411,
-0.37791749835014343,
-0.030133407562971115,
-0.6714077591896057,
0.6948657035827637,
-0.6059889197349548,
-0.5298605561256409,
0.07312987744808197,
-0.04776438698172569,
-0.40163230895996094,
-0.6792603135108948,
0.004021036438643932,
-0.6276363730430603,
0.11170917749404907,
-0.2524927258491516,
-0.5324552655220032,
0.020963480696082115,
-0.0872228741645813,
-0.8812842965126038,
1.1527124643325806,
-0.5115724802017212,
-0.46897464990615845,
0.7137316465377808,
-0.6126721501350403,
-0.4513033926486969,
-0.07285458594560623,
-0.21975217759609222,
-0.24313762784004211,
0.6216323375701904,
-0.25253885984420776,
0.4271391034126282,
0.3304469883441925,
0.4803522229194641,
-0.30527520179748535,
-0.5230594873428345,
0.3852209448814392,
-0.2116066962480545,
0.5658811926841736,
-0.19719237089157104,
-0.28941309452056885,
-0.01658918336033821,
-0.5466445088386536,
-0.0808357521891594,
-0.22343286871910095,
-0.413577139377594,
-0.6154539585113525,
-0.2449660450220108,
-0.2259000986814499,
0.2638982832431793,
0.2678210735321045,
-0.5270408391952515,
0.41288238763809204,
-0.8400968909263611,
0.2054227590560913,
0.7657828330993652,
-0.17055225372314453,
0.6621126532554626,
-0.4061220586299896,
0.44084063172340393,
0.07758260518312454,
-0.18367840349674225,
-0.059699226170778275,
-0.669068455696106,
-0.5700826048851013,
-0.4441621005535126,
0.6695065498352051,
0.30201420187950134,
-0.15605773031711578,
0.3382887840270996,
-0.4541338086128235,
-0.2152758240699768,
-0.3784462809562683,
-0.11968003213405609,
0.6055800914764404,
-0.18778803944587708,
0.2693331241607666,
-0.4763506054878235,
-0.8175001740455627,
-0.8735898733139038,
-0.18326963484287262,
-0.3852524757385254,
0.4377124011516571,
-0.005229408387094736,
0.6004083156585693,
0.22656290233135223,
0.9052342772483826,
0.022915605455636978,
-0.11483913660049438,
0.0660896748304367,
0.3210204839706421,
0.29288047552108765,
0.566676914691925,
0.8975119590759277,
-0.5817862749099731,
-0.33568429946899414,
0.3556164503097534,
-0.46114683151245117,
0.0723971426486969,
0.16481555998325348,
-0.026080887764692307,
0.4346756935119629,
0.6075125932693481,
-0.3834998607635498,
0.36906304955482483,
0.7769012451171875,
-0.5465320348739624,
0.15655654668807983,
-0.3378186523914337,
0.02874392457306385,
-1.0251710414886475,
-0.1334509253501892,
-0.10562928020954132,
-0.09048513323068619,
-0.8571661710739136,
-0.2775910794734955,
0.1244785413146019,
0.2128867655992508,
-0.7647855877876282,
0.7816532254219055,
-0.3251097500324249,
-0.4044507145881653,
-0.08465024083852768,
-0.24878518283367157,
-0.049246929585933685,
0.26640620827674866,
0.2675090432167053,
0.908107340335846,
0.3344610631465912,
-0.5958013534545898,
-0.25377362966537476,
0.15226666629314423,
-0.15008416771888733,
0.2374621033668518,
-1.0818513631820679,
0.1492699384689331,
-0.1673859804868698,
0.00036101933801546693,
-1.0858811140060425,
-0.0219251848757267,
0.046395692974328995,
-0.21267558634281158,
-0.07341302186250687,
-0.4185360372066498,
-0.4898735284805298,
-0.13438302278518677,
-0.4610324501991272,
0.6696093678474426,
0.274392694234848,
-0.4393433928489685,
0.39970776438713074,
0.3637300729751587,
-0.06755901873111725,
-0.5396711230278015,
-0.6816104054450989,
-0.0036059145350009203,
-0.505370020866394,
-0.7582878470420837,
0.8130158185958862,
0.26456430554389954,
-0.6640180349349976,
-0.24731865525245667,
-0.09340599924325943,
-0.027842510491609573,
0.12075112760066986,
0.46702253818511963,
0.19953428208827972,
-0.33776572346687317,
0.6027888059616089,
0.07904913276433945,
-0.07825328409671783,
-0.34746313095092773,
-0.30381134152412415,
0.865961492061615,
-0.2155282348394394,
-0.5807670950889587,
-0.408333420753479,
0.3501906991004944,
0.951752781867981,
-0.1758958250284195,
1.0523303747177124,
0.06197049096226692,
-0.6144235134124756,
0.23450742661952972,
-0.6830887198448181,
0.08709017932415009,
-0.5018793940544128,
0.04687105491757393,
-0.8060369491577148,
-0.6534938812255859,
0.9014715552330017,
0.1861490160226822,
0.3953721225261688,
0.4467519223690033,
0.5620201826095581,
-0.0441511906683445,
1.1508381366729736,
0.4427642226219177,
0.3181348741054535,
0.7349797487258911,
-0.23473238945007324,
0.12119970470666885,
-0.4638022780418396,
-0.48991668224334717,
-0.7113988399505615,
-0.31629282236099243,
-0.40110981464385986,
-0.5947696566581726,
-0.12778018414974213,
0.13700638711452484,
-0.1590147167444229,
0.30207106471061707,
-0.07935781031847,
0.5962246060371399,
0.19872915744781494,
-0.402732789516449,
0.41194888949394226,
-0.045219019055366516,
-0.28268179297447205,
-0.3543189465999603,
-0.7222908139228821,
-0.7209485173225403,
0.44944536685943604,
0.3266765773296356,
0.32076212763786316,
0.617988109588623,
1.0224815607070923,
0.28059330582618713,
0.120146743953228,
-0.8451982140541077,
0.22107385098934174,
-0.611003577709198,
-0.12062613666057587,
-0.39472758769989014,
-0.10301750153303146,
-1.3319119215011597,
0.7600511312484741,
-0.03636523336172104,
-0.5237898826599121,
0.659359872341156,
-0.14239053428173065,
-0.17481648921966553,
0.15990692377090454,
-0.8533733487129211,
0.8500815033912659,
-0.4218413531780243,
0.31668731570243835,
0.005252926144748926,
-0.012899859808385372,
-0.00651869410648942,
-0.06163061037659645,
0.18245910108089447,
-0.12054029107093811,
-0.5985514521598816,
1.1556568145751953,
-0.8128348588943481,
1.1017576456069946,
-0.13846474885940552,
-0.3419858515262604,
-0.10627661645412445,
0.03374922275543213,
0.5262470841407776,
-0.1617571860551834,
-0.3422033190727234,
0.2834952175617218,
-0.06366884708404541,
-0.5189334750175476,
-0.657709538936615,
0.6588636636734009,
-0.942265510559082,
-0.5757702589035034,
-0.3482959270477295,
-0.3801999092102051,
-0.18713317811489105,
0.08926136791706085,
0.12199616432189941,
0.4862992465496063,
-0.4477488398551941,
0.1430717408657074,
0.2970357835292816,
0.3145110309123993,
0.6316745281219482,
0.16546866297721863,
-0.37264367938041687,
-0.4247640073299408,
0.8945937156677246,
0.5103806853294373,
0.2933243215084076,
0.11709121614694595,
0.16213932633399963,
-0.5817273259162903,
-0.7466440796852112,
-0.4266190528869629,
0.554070770740509,
-0.44451799988746643,
-0.1207176074385643,
-0.7062556147575378,
0.1766074001789093,
-0.6836314797401428,
-0.3816096782684326,
-0.47476300597190857,
-0.9417107105255127,
-0.2746467590332031,
-0.4227707087993622,
0.5094006061553955,
1.0246665477752686,
-0.0629725456237793,
0.3103916347026825,
-0.5658181309700012,
0.1102055236697197,
0.34277594089508057,
0.34206104278564453,
0.016385862603783607,
-0.7123373746871948,
0.06872294843196869,
-0.13341274857521057,
0.2640022933483124,
-0.9611949920654297,
0.019478846341371536,
0.21954169869422913,
0.5303991436958313,
0.5631752014160156,
-0.45141637325286865,
1.2039122581481934,
-0.46910735964775085,
0.5396233201026917,
0.4124392569065094,
-1.2387354373931885,
0.25514885783195496,
-0.4339456558227539,
0.06120448186993599,
0.5141597390174866,
0.10746922343969345,
-0.8928941488265991,
-0.4802373945713043,
-0.7889060974121094,
-0.865943431854248,
0.5310755372047424,
-0.08435094356536865,
0.6027808785438538,
-0.4421023428440094,
-0.0016347371274605393,
0.39887678623199463,
0.19433404505252838,
-0.5560236573219299,
-0.0834839791059494,
-0.2766517698764801,
-0.002267340896651149,
0.2329549789428711,
-0.03980632126331329,
0.09692318737506866,
-0.1413412094116211,
0.4889596700668335,
0.00900284107774496,
-0.007043561898171902,
-0.24269726872444153,
-0.2797909677028656,
0.30340468883514404,
-0.04334584251046181,
0.7730518579483032,
0.6030055284500122,
0.24804773926734924,
0.154288649559021,
0.1861288994550705,
-0.41374051570892334,
0.38594940304756165,
-0.4078995883464813,
0.045485857874155045,
0.4077773094177246,
0.3374791741371155,
0.7263711094856262,
0.8179466724395752,
-0.41212061047554016,
0.4567432403564453,
0.07063431292772293,
-0.4521995782852173,
0.15590760111808777,
-0.0037487554363906384,
0.10528207570314407,
0.048509083688259125,
0.18040154874324799,
0.11653643101453781,
-0.2599768340587616,
-0.5544968843460083,
0.014134790748357773,
0.5795791149139404,
-0.2756775915622711,
-0.4719213843345642,
0.0659588947892189,
0.10272354632616043,
-0.6851878762245178,
0.3718126714229584,
-0.13050034642219543,
-0.43529728055000305,
0.9051817059516907,
0.7120504975318909,
0.44107764959335327,
-0.043007973581552505,
0.6564257144927979,
0.17956435680389404,
0.11502307653427124,
-0.5241081118583679,
0.41237279772758484,
0.09818510711193085,
-0.9643359780311584,
-0.31830987334251404,
-0.3799861967563629,
-0.3658074736595154,
-0.4382314383983612,
-0.6514374613761902,
0.2538677752017975,
-0.5691051483154297,
-0.39865735173225403,
-0.07014863193035126,
-0.3211357295513153,
-0.6300806403160095,
-0.21456335484981537,
0.06646496802568436,
0.7620700001716614,
-1.0656489133834839,
0.5937484502792358,
0.9687896370887756,
-0.2976623475551605,
-0.7578259706497192,
-0.5440261960029602,
-0.2576001286506653,
-0.9556033611297607,
0.5869412422180176,
-0.0469488687813282,
-0.1842857003211975,
-0.11052990704774857,
0.10898230969905853,
-1.1879643201828003,
0.9466919302940369,
0.2293609231710434,
-0.2818832993507385,
-0.001228171749971807,
0.3829924464225769,
0.757062554359436,
-0.4268482029438019,
-0.12245404720306396,
0.332193523645401,
0.6346475481987,
0.22034023702144623,
-1.039308786392212,
-0.10011322796344757,
-0.48257768154144287,
0.2790437340736389,
0.4402535855770111,
-0.7498337030410767,
0.8801141381263733,
-0.10235648602247238,
-0.6031822562217712,
0.3220621347427368,
0.6512355804443359,
0.4754186272621155,
0.07429765164852142,
0.35415294766426086,
0.7440205216407776,
1.2519842386245728,
-0.3370344638824463,
0.8201411366462708,
-0.034796081483364105,
0.019098617136478424,
0.7483652830123901,
-0.06934300065040588,
0.8127497434616089,
0.9184175133705139,
-0.27940064668655396,
0.5883134007453918,
0.5186569094657898,
-0.0751693993806839,
0.40873226523399353,
0.2604151964187622,
-0.03972388431429863,
-0.10222917050123215,
-0.2946881353855133,
-0.5239307880401611,
0.5267537832260132,
0.27120161056518555,
-0.3370124399662018,
-0.03890414908528328,
0.11293409764766693,
-0.01652141846716404,
0.03539300337433815,
-0.3688754141330719,
0.9762527942657471,
-0.03867068514227867,
-0.753996729850769,
0.3759903013706207,
0.2530912160873413,
0.9898436069488525,
-0.2953314781188965,
0.2515164613723755,
-0.2989484965801239,
-0.3344340920448303,
-0.4018579125404358,
-0.3364492952823639,
0.3795735836029053,
0.0875820592045784,
-0.30903324484825134,
-0.3654806613922119,
0.2762492299079895,
-0.048068903386592865,
-0.5910415053367615,
0.1207406297326088,
0.95703125,
0.37486425042152405,
0.28517797589302063,
-0.32724377512931824,
0.15865349769592285,
-0.406241238117218,
0.12482250481843948,
0.34798863530158997,
0.6374605894088745,
-0.5936877727508545,
0.2956584393978119,
0.7613744139671326,
0.33953145146369934,
0.8975058794021606,
0.7003445029258728,
0.3890415132045746,
-0.5919750928878784,
-0.5955976843833923,
-1.007396936416626,
0.5513178706169128,
-0.0275212861597538,
-0.5038501620292664,
0.6701074838638306,
0.5153346061706543,
0.7540702223777771,
0.030668532475829124,
0.36810874938964844,
0.17234130203723907,
-0.19371958076953888,
-0.4243156313896179,
0.11248496919870377,
-0.19765256345272064,
0.2614203989505768,
-0.22425925731658936,
-1.0580790042877197,
-0.8280895352363586,
0.6811503767967224,
-0.5109191536903381,
-0.07658346742391586,
0.5196495056152344,
0.8087742328643799,
-0.09802629798650742,
-0.08262147754430771,
0.4800622761249542,
-0.03571177273988724,
0.20337232947349548,
-0.25013306736946106,
1.1096458435058594,
-0.35957279801368713,
0.2723180651664734,
-0.08775502443313599,
0.1896391361951828,
-0.07249904423952103,
-0.6621253490447998,
-0.7397779822349548,
-0.5936527848243713,
-0.12108475714921951,
0.05860692262649536,
0.15021885931491852,
0.8430822491645813,
0.7551493048667908,
-0.7560511231422424,
-0.3112049400806427,
-0.2348579317331314,
0.4134773910045624,
-0.13335353136062622,
-0.16647370159626007,
0.28774628043174744,
-0.5044131875038147,
-0.9371469616889954,
0.3230457305908203,
0.48745742440223694,
0.6362672448158264,
-0.2827565670013428,
-0.21751469373703003,
0.06481532007455826,
0.288282185792923,
0.355946809053421,
0.3640216588973999,
-0.9076815247535706,
-0.24747821688652039,
0.30627208948135376,
-0.3152815103530884,
0.4602455794811249,
1.2796509265899658,
-0.8668181896209717,
0.12835194170475006,
0.7379494309425354,
0.3659680485725403,
0.07810719311237335,
0.38545867800712585,
0.5461288094520569,
-0.7698817253112793,
0.43851131200790405,
0.22710682451725006,
0.5619552135467529,
0.11429566890001297,
-0.14786522090435028,
0.2257319539785385,
-0.014423477463424206,
0.0011915540089830756,
-1.0243754386901855,
0.1451534777879715,
-0.9374628663063049,
-0.10772515833377838,
0.996455729007721,
0.16570056974887848,
0.05173550546169281,
-0.4367324411869049,
-0.05430159345269203,
-0.15114708244800568,
-0.5146586298942566,
0.8746451735496521,
0.7740106582641602,
-0.11866409331560135,
0.40581369400024414,
0.21048198640346527,
0.2193581610918045,
0.690746545791626,
-0.5148677229881287,
-0.3479785621166229,
0.03467656299471855,
-0.15222005546092987,
0.36536115407943726,
0.7041381001472473,
-0.36848706007003784,
0.47891271114349365,
-0.18789321184158325,
-0.3698902130126953,
0.01957392692565918,
-0.44344037771224976,
-0.532949686050415,
0.2032930552959442,
0.3448653519153595,
-0.1742018163204193
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13737v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13737v4
|
EthioLLM: Multilingual Large Language Models for Ethiopian Languages with Task Evaluation
| 2024-03-20T16:43:42 | 2024-06-23T12:06:27 |
Atnafu Lambebo Tonja, Israel Abebe Azime, Tadesse Destaw Belay, Mesay Gemeda Yigezu, Moges Ahmed Mehamed, Abinew Ali Ayele, Ebrahim Chekol Jibril, Michael Melese Woldeyohannis, Olga Kolesnikova, Philipp Slusallek, Dietrich Klakow, Shengwu Xiong, Seid Muhie Yimam
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have gained popularity recently due to their
outstanding performance in various downstream Natural Language Processing (NLP)
tasks. However, low-resource languages are still lagging behind current
state-of-the-art (SOTA) developments in the field of NLP due to insufficient
resources to train LLMs. Ethiopian languages exhibit remarkable linguistic
diversity, encompassing a wide array of scripts, and are imbued with profound
religious and cultural significance. This paper introduces EthioLLM --
multilingual large language models for five Ethiopian languages (Amharic,
Ge'ez, Afan Oromo, Somali, and Tigrinya) and English, and Ethiobenchmark -- a
new benchmark dataset for various downstream NLP tasks. We evaluate the
performance of these models across five downstream NLP tasks. We open-source
our multilingual language models, new benchmark datasets for various downstream
tasks, and task-specific fine-tuned language models and discuss the performance
of the models. Our dataset and models are available at the
https://huggingface.co/EthioNLP repository.
|
[
-0.3357533812522888,
-0.8292404413223267,
0.21512354910373688,
0.39765357971191406,
-0.18966446816921234,
0.0027615216095000505,
-0.8595966100692749,
-0.852255642414093,
0.2708841562271118,
0.5398070812225342,
-0.5163695216178894,
-0.46858707070350647,
-0.783268392086029,
0.23689548671245575,
-0.2543419897556305,
0.8910302519798279,
-0.29045936465263367,
0.10779578983783722,
0.06172904372215271,
-0.6020464897155762,
-0.3642273545265198,
-0.47652965784072876,
-0.7050089240074158,
-0.10644800215959549,
0.37865424156188965,
0.48007622361183167,
0.3870532810688019,
0.5789559483528137,
0.21787236630916595,
0.2890459895133972,
-0.038861386477947235,
0.30605220794677734,
-0.22483311593532562,
0.46414095163345337,
-0.016050705686211586,
-0.20785874128341675,
-0.2110622674226761,
-0.2232135385274887,
0.7877189517021179,
0.9805218577384949,
-0.4781278073787689,
0.5737866759300232,
0.15391071140766144,
0.4435877799987793,
-0.5079172253608704,
0.09138614684343338,
-0.6410048604011536,
-0.3568767309188843,
-0.5992063283920288,
0.40720152854919434,
-0.2764213979244232,
-0.36049288511276245,
-0.04794757813215256,
-0.11907987296581268,
-0.10726641863584518,
0.32682326436042786,
0.4949951171875,
0.10163998603820801,
-0.2924536168575287,
-0.27735039591789246,
-0.6336697340011597,
1.1125034093856812,
-0.7532505989074707,
0.514284074306488,
0.4391501247882843,
0.3344811201095581,
0.11849282681941986,
-0.6683454513549805,
-0.4270073175430298,
-0.41516196727752686,
0.20790307223796844,
-0.03213856369256973,
0.20981110632419586,
-0.4260960519313812,
0.2730450928211212,
0.3051322102546692,
-0.3312612473964691,
0.39342746138572693,
-0.15796329081058502,
0.023209795355796814,
0.4836026430130005,
0.34681424498558044,
0.3156684339046478,
0.09199191629886627,
-0.14213739335536957,
0.14501246809959412,
-0.5755724310874939,
-0.1688460111618042,
0.4122674763202667,
0.3547886908054352,
-0.30532416701316833,
0.5195916295051575,
-0.2706770896911621,
0.7665202617645264,
-0.5527648329734802,
-0.09511902183294296,
0.21109037101268768,
-0.1662464290857315,
-0.14161092042922974,
-0.006325370166450739,
0.6546960473060608,
0.07821225374937057,
0.10592268407344818,
0.026591941714286804,
-0.19777752459049225,
-0.09020877629518509,
0.1027456596493721,
-0.7417514324188232,
0.13136446475982666,
0.19794559478759766,
-0.6955652832984924,
0.11127325892448425,
-0.5134947896003723,
-0.7425770163536072,
-0.21046635508537292,
-0.22507384419441223,
0.028627024963498116,
-0.5648858547210693,
-0.25743985176086426,
-0.05288916081190109,
0.37211844325065613,
-0.043856725096702576,
0.4624664783477783,
-1.0331690311431885,
0.6085314154624939,
0.76316237449646,
0.9570572376251221,
-0.3952506184577942,
-0.6239485144615173,
-0.6639320254325867,
0.11633472889661789,
-0.1482982188463211,
0.5104191899299622,
-0.7034726738929749,
-0.023752644658088684,
0.3860614001750946,
0.08462827652692795,
-0.21631157398223877,
-0.618783175945282,
1.162719964981079,
-0.5860057473182678,
-0.22855249047279358,
-0.0038248240016400814,
-0.5602092742919922,
-0.5413437485694885,
0.2659336030483246,
-0.9221215844154358,
1.0169551372528076,
-0.009830116294324398,
-0.355073481798172,
0.05977477878332138,
-0.5407636761665344,
-0.7938258647918701,
0.2165832668542862,
0.11075974255800247,
-0.3551788330078125,
0.3836013674736023,
0.05378005653619766,
0.50608891248703,
-0.912415623664856,
0.3144780099391937,
-0.32921749353408813,
-0.11142665147781372,
-0.035056643187999725,
-0.3512422442436218,
1.0415233373641968,
0.4044135510921478,
-0.31934067606925964,
0.02174658142030239,
-0.8386296033859253,
0.13787291944026947,
0.1443728506565094,
-0.31892165541648865,
-0.4537261128425598,
0.21198251843452454,
0.5078074932098389,
0.19955699145793915,
0.18510623276233673,
-0.5803412199020386,
-0.16560229659080505,
-0.15211239457130432,
0.4620424211025238,
0.44239741563796997,
-0.47931623458862305,
0.03714057803153992,
-0.23388338088989258,
0.324561208486557,
-0.09067577868700027,
0.04013558849692345,
-0.1262587457895279,
-0.6624552011489868,
-0.999819815158844,
-0.23955018818378448,
0.24170808494091034,
0.2598561644554138,
-0.3589656949043274,
0.07873966544866562,
-0.31946876645088196,
-0.5338971614837646,
-0.6891079545021057,
0.05566677451133728,
0.008503852412104607,
0.18699315190315247,
0.501695454120636,
-0.05109342932701111,
-0.26520371437072754,
-1.036836862564087,
-0.5065603852272034,
0.16354021430015564,
-0.04105358570814133,
0.09497712552547455,
0.6635420322418213,
-0.30553025007247925,
0.15394483506679535,
-0.2094297856092453,
-0.4018627405166626,
-0.5589970350265503,
0.17608854174613953,
0.38249391317367554,
0.4863993227481842,
0.549450695514679,
-0.6379501819610596,
-0.7299093008041382,
0.1447620987892151,
-0.3062400221824646,
-0.22334223985671997,
0.23517930507659912,
0.22353895008563995,
0.4837559163570404,
0.16670139133930206,
-0.41561374068260193,
0.022663012146949768,
0.8156254291534424,
0.013661378063261509,
0.5984159111976624,
-0.18158872425556183,
0.3036501705646515,
-0.9727610945701599,
0.2393277883529663,
0.09808201342821121,
-0.33228781819343567,
-0.7798125147819519,
0.3903593122959137,
0.1567237824201584,
-0.023942964151501656,
-0.4889427423477173,
0.6106341481208801,
-0.5433983206748962,
-0.06789300590753555,
-0.08565933257341385,
-0.03171427175402641,
-0.3163744807243347,
0.49137160181999207,
0.30582690238952637,
0.43890124559402466,
0.5093854069709778,
-0.7413063645362854,
0.5004795789718628,
0.24054498970508575,
-0.796432375907898,
0.5604661107063293,
-0.6235061287879944,
0.08318052440881729,
0.15883351862430573,
-0.11744823306798935,
-0.5468083024024963,
-0.36786192655563354,
0.04661675915122032,
0.03881673514842987,
0.5874849557876587,
0.09251823276281357,
-0.6439998149871826,
-0.1123083159327507,
-0.2824421525001526,
0.523901104927063,
0.39173629879951477,
-0.45695266127586365,
0.7464121580123901,
0.5176668167114258,
-0.6028079390525818,
-0.4878820776939392,
-0.6738195419311523,
0.21737968921661377,
-0.19862781465053558,
-0.6072272658348083,
0.3543623685836792,
0.058830637484788895,
-0.2856574058532715,
-0.20117473602294922,
0.1708444207906723,
-0.08293432742357254,
0.30735093355178833,
0.06632351875305176,
0.149735689163208,
-0.015639308840036392,
0.046056751161813736,
0.050808705389499664,
0.046726856380701065,
-0.09415864944458008,
-0.4043925106525421,
0.7695186734199524,
-0.279018759727478,
-0.5703687071800232,
-0.09432941675186157,
0.5888048410415649,
0.11149398982524872,
-0.48822706937789917,
1.1815271377563477,
0.6841613054275513,
-0.7290335893630981,
-0.28180205821990967,
-0.8139351606369019,
0.1026211753487587,
-0.31700828671455383,
0.5754933953285217,
-0.4454623758792877,
-1.0075633525848389,
0.7292401790618896,
-0.29030561447143555,
0.33459657430648804,
0.5580262541770935,
0.9945361614227295,
-0.04039021581411362,
0.7394842505455017,
0.6298532485961914,
-0.0818977952003479,
0.23045243322849274,
-0.07991591095924377,
0.013969090767204762,
-0.9327273368835449,
-0.29984399676322937,
-1.0158565044403076,
-0.3580377995967865,
-0.7484563589096069,
-0.42058899998664856,
0.22912685573101044,
-0.089196115732193,
-0.11497261375188828,
0.4004517197608948,
0.04138919711112976,
0.13349927961826324,
0.5190289616584778,
-0.27214670181274414,
0.4224109351634979,
0.22860243916511536,
-0.27831220626831055,
-0.11317833513021469,
-0.7208045125007629,
-0.7944053411483765,
0.9421665668487549,
0.3046959340572357,
0.6906709671020508,
0.18843774497509003,
0.40245214104652405,
0.22512155771255493,
0.5377826690673828,
-0.7019315361976624,
0.4347737729549408,
-0.33872151374816895,
-0.7410717606544495,
-0.23648980259895325,
-0.3633647859096527,
-0.6286646723747253,
0.24364034831523895,
-0.02746688760817051,
-0.9005226492881775,
-0.11556331068277359,
-0.28124502301216125,
-0.17915284633636475,
0.3991442918777466,
-0.2874918282032013,
0.892898678779602,
-0.35561954975128174,
-0.5060298442840576,
-0.7153117060661316,
-0.6803367137908936,
0.2938464283943176,
-0.46341732144355774,
0.49293550848960876,
-0.32677799463272095,
-0.2157253473997116,
0.8110307455062866,
-0.5311164855957031,
0.488602876663208,
0.13500621914863586,
-0.17780983448028564,
0.19502952694892883,
-0.05336311459541321,
0.47811052203178406,
-0.10172149538993835,
-0.5385738611221313,
0.7264677882194519,
-0.09730829298496246,
-0.3083796501159668,
0.07227997481822968,
1.0298713445663452,
-0.5913755297660828,
-0.33135777711868286,
-0.3138604462146759,
-0.4178352952003479,
-0.23518186807632446,
0.2320852130651474,
0.13196739554405212,
0.5478696227073669,
-0.3347998559474945,
0.216033473610878,
0.283878892660141,
-0.4993053376674652,
0.5914488434791565,
0.5876474976539612,
-0.07307058572769165,
-0.4079423248767853,
0.6688032150268555,
0.19193235039710999,
0.2804372310638428,
0.19414418935775757,
-0.1663222312927246,
-0.32539883255958557,
-0.6982576251029968,
-0.7779046297073364,
0.10537726432085037,
-0.6201844811439514,
-0.08997988700866699,
-0.8671236038208008,
0.0852716937661171,
-0.12878961861133575,
0.24874275922775269,
-0.2768481969833374,
-0.4887736141681671,
0.10177787393331528,
0.2902103662490845,
0.17444965243339539,
0.6236537098884583,
-0.057726435363292694,
0.15114441514015198,
-1.2335282564163208,
0.3609529435634613,
-0.005775369703769684,
0.4750892221927643,
0.21086251735687256,
-0.6044658422470093,
-0.7105059027671814,
0.19608384370803833,
-0.22223222255706787,
-0.6346341967582703,
0.40389013290405273,
0.5625787973403931,
0.6391541957855225,
0.03735949099063873,
-0.12149275839328766,
0.49339723587036133,
-0.9270148277282715,
0.6259775757789612,
0.18541479110717773,
-0.9568363428115845,
0.20667849481105804,
-0.16358596086502075,
0.11281165480613708,
0.5771109461784363,
0.5243963003158569,
-0.9252791404724121,
-0.3518607020378113,
-0.18155504763126373,
-0.7559307813644409,
1.042593002319336,
0.30662208795547485,
0.2547426223754883,
-0.19642983376979828,
0.00869864784181118,
0.5007385015487671,
0.5241144895553589,
-0.5049989223480225,
-0.35553300380706787,
0.11801281571388245,
-0.2551761269569397,
0.010669173672795296,
-0.37489306926727295,
0.05066753923892975,
-0.0365569181740284,
0.823779821395874,
-0.08450144529342651,
0.11665599048137665,
-0.2831590175628662,
-0.49685704708099365,
-0.23199564218521118,
0.3716312646865845,
0.42132145166397095,
0.48731285333633423,
0.00821037869900465,
-0.02158791944384575,
0.4337521195411682,
-0.4753454327583313,
0.21558047831058502,
0.3199957013130188,
-0.2961019277572632,
0.029839416965842247,
0.5132740139961243,
0.8731796741485596,
0.0424937829375267,
-0.6237442493438721,
0.08595865219831467,
0.06257643550634384,
0.22127045691013336,
-0.26770728826522827,
-0.1376737356185913,
0.4289761185646057,
0.11809831857681274,
0.3818086087703705,
0.11978055536746979,
0.24158960580825806,
-0.741553544998169,
-0.22152823209762573,
0.3738495111465454,
-0.16088834404945374,
-0.34994903206825256,
0.8631839156150818,
0.29775822162628174,
-0.22272717952728271,
0.7100374698638916,
0.07326101511716843,
-0.73797607421875,
0.6232116222381592,
0.5298200845718384,
0.9445105791091919,
-0.4431542456150055,
0.04142770916223526,
0.43004971742630005,
0.5267865061759949,
-0.2076384425163269,
0.36709079146385193,
0.05505712330341339,
-0.6545499563217163,
-0.6550500988960266,
-1.012695074081421,
-0.36536890268325806,
0.21610184013843536,
-0.6125009059906006,
0.3098876476287842,
-0.1302337944507599,
-0.23959101736545563,
-0.09290405362844467,
0.08054986596107483,
-0.8886412382125854,
0.2425820231437683,
0.20900371670722961,
0.9657604098320007,
-0.5803443789482117,
0.8239098787307739,
0.8557745218276978,
-0.0417528934776783,
-0.5072831511497498,
0.07293824106454849,
-0.1981937736272812,
-0.7482119798660278,
0.6892945170402527,
0.4129754900932312,
-0.1285640299320221,
0.1369355469942093,
-0.2212882786989212,
-0.5236120223999023,
0.5203637480735779,
0.4725196063518524,
-0.8138943314552307,
0.4095749855041504,
0.39672282338142395,
0.44973379373550415,
-0.3731978237628937,
0.5720654129981995,
0.5048767924308777,
0.6283557415008545,
-0.2464515119791031,
-0.8344072103500366,
0.005522598046809435,
-0.2069602608680725,
0.1652485728263855,
0.3808080852031708,
-0.8473102450370789,
0.6612449884414673,
-0.23899245262145996,
-0.2839341461658478,
0.30221718549728394,
0.6607803702354431,
0.10668051987886429,
0.07644712179899216,
0.479125440120697,
0.5912279486656189,
0.5316159129142761,
-0.1866588443517685,
1.1049096584320068,
-0.5019804239273071,
0.1985783874988556,
1.195862054824829,
-0.7309807538986206,
1.0059081315994263,
0.3574737012386322,
-0.209121972322464,
0.31077566742897034,
0.6493270397186279,
0.1759917438030243,
0.36653196811676025,
0.07267584651708603,
-0.16662289202213287,
-0.34101054072380066,
-0.5452157855033875,
-0.2713507413864136,
0.3189631402492523,
0.39411693811416626,
-0.01235282327979803,
-0.09684062004089355,
-0.08486077934503555,
-0.11233535408973694,
0.0055770231410861015,
-0.3681611120700836,
0.4514560103416443,
0.43587395548820496,
-0.6333919167518616,
0.5688133239746094,
0.4910160303115845,
0.6619246006011963,
-0.6994456648826599,
0.1588723361492157,
-0.08027593791484833,
0.07097934186458588,
-0.10976219922304153,
-0.5311088562011719,
0.5878795981407166,
0.21474722027778625,
0.17129038274288177,
-0.18364645540714264,
0.7475407123565674,
-0.6983763575553894,
-0.5627853274345398,
0.6157090067863464,
0.5362387895584106,
-0.0032703366596251726,
0.04545438662171364,
-0.5083337426185608,
0.2134290337562561,
-0.15447431802749634,
-0.3381868004798889,
0.17703883349895477,
0.2633953094482422,
-0.26549237966537476,
0.7643251419067383,
0.5310864448547363,
0.3217902183532715,
-0.024743689224123955,
0.43424808979034424,
0.4908759891986847,
-0.5704342126846313,
-0.24177022278308868,
-1.0960686206817627,
0.27474769949913025,
-0.14371663331985474,
-0.19787047803401947,
0.9100580811500549,
0.5950536727905273,
0.8772244453430176,
-0.27576789259910583,
0.6759620904922485,
-0.18023443222045898,
0.6749315857887268,
-0.4500315189361572,
0.7087358832359314,
-0.7911851406097412,
0.10019537806510925,
-0.09661322832107544,
-1.3315387964248657,
-0.04627062752842903,
0.4813622534275055,
-0.05967811122536659,
0.12179579585790634,
0.804311215877533,
0.21359649300575256,
-0.09545813500881195,
0.24864497780799866,
0.20452354848384857,
0.25950461626052856,
-0.021818630397319794,
0.45748358964920044,
1.0238687992095947,
-0.35509780049324036,
0.12831147015094757,
-0.2911568880081177,
-0.062023911625146866,
-0.3495073914527893,
-0.9801149964332581,
-0.7576651573181152,
-0.5191556811332703,
-0.3199850618839264,
0.1492680162191391,
-0.23771162331104279,
1.0974881649017334,
0.4958517551422119,
-1.1266472339630127,
-0.5009726881980896,
0.3102666437625885,
-0.030649684369564056,
-0.5539339184761047,
-0.07307897508144379,
0.16297784447669983,
-0.25128868222236633,
-0.9907222986221313,
0.22449567914009094,
0.44293129444122314,
-0.1973259001970291,
-0.10452628880739212,
-0.1266702115535736,
-0.3433137536048889,
-0.1033167615532875,
0.6311184167861938,
-0.17763637006282806,
-0.557133138179779,
0.04062820225954056,
-0.09273131936788559,
-0.10685865581035614,
-0.16239334642887115,
0.5632376670837402,
-0.24927562475204468,
0.14232073724269867,
0.39305150508880615,
0.7228949666023254,
0.6577360033988953,
-0.47118210792541504,
0.608681857585907,
-0.3960290551185608,
0.17076443135738373,
0.23737238347530365,
0.7259799242019653,
0.5111753940582275,
0.12710876762866974,
0.7073409557342529,
-0.08424237370491028,
-0.40071818232536316,
-0.6557890176773071,
0.1782265454530716,
-0.5560128092765808,
0.045929115265607834,
0.9456718564033508,
-0.33008500933647156,
-0.14561814069747925,
-0.19735264778137207,
0.0893457755446434,
0.42576083540916443,
-0.297439306974411,
0.5648257732391357,
0.8810712695121765,
0.5095454454421997,
0.037257615476846695,
-0.9804959893226624,
0.357721209526062,
0.5779137015342712,
-1.134390950202942,
0.12058576196432114,
0.5647432208061218,
0.10394378006458282,
0.1335911899805069,
0.37088313698768616,
0.07644198089838028,
-0.06277930736541748,
-0.3145882785320282,
-0.05160113796591759,
0.09880153089761734,
-0.2904733419418335,
-0.3307788074016571,
0.02541397139430046,
0.15340912342071533,
-0.001665260293520987
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15473v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15473v1
|
Efficient argument classification with compact language models and ChatGPT-4 refinements
| 2024-03-20T16:24:10 | 2024-03-20T16:24:10 |
Marcin Pietron, Rafał Olszowski, Jakub Gomułka
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Argument mining (AM) is defined as the task of automatically identifying and
extracting argumentative components (e.g. premises, claims, etc.) and detecting
the existing relations among them (i.e., support, attack, no relations). Deep
learning models enable us to analyze arguments more efficiently than
traditional methods and extract their semantics. This paper presents
comparative studies between a few deep learning-based models in argument
mining. The work concentrates on argument classification. The research was done
on a wide spectrum of datasets (Args.me, UKP, US2016). The main novelty of this
paper is the ensemble model which is based on BERT architecture and ChatGPT-4
as fine tuning model. The presented results show that BERT+ChatGPT-4
outperforms the rest of the models including other Transformer-based and
LSTM-based models. The observed improvement is, in most cases, greater than
10The presented analysis can provide crucial insights into how the models for
argument classification should be further improved. Additionally, it can help
develop a prompt-based algorithm to eliminate argument classification errors.
|
[
-0.3792831301689148,
-0.8620412945747375,
0.4005035161972046,
-0.22767212986946106,
-0.42655640840530396,
0.036828890442848206,
-0.41939717531204224,
-0.43208611011505127,
-0.5218191146850586,
0.25214794278144836,
-0.4020548164844513,
-0.4196687340736389,
-0.6634310483932495,
0.09217996895313263,
-0.24141956865787506,
0.9543047547340393,
0.03816233202815056,
0.3802216947078705,
-0.03145895525813103,
-0.24586158990859985,
-0.44587478041648865,
-0.6663709282875061,
-1.0706737041473389,
-0.3472248911857605,
0.4434010982513428,
0.43400993943214417,
0.48769646883010864,
0.29319071769714355,
0.3084949851036072,
0.6012022495269775,
-0.005435823928564787,
0.10881514847278595,
0.0345197394490242,
0.36088454723358154,
0.014045854099094868,
-0.4892747402191162,
-0.20995798707008362,
0.0219875555485487,
0.3806568384170532,
0.2511894106864929,
-0.1337868720293045,
-0.2236679345369339,
-0.1466098576784134,
0.3111844062805176,
-0.40164172649383545,
0.26472702622413635,
-0.8313069343566895,
0.0832965299487114,
-0.23382368683815002,
-0.03873685747385025,
-0.48892325162887573,
-0.36946362257003784,
0.4307630658149719,
-0.13185417652130127,
0.29793164134025574,
-0.06126675009727478,
1.1084612607955933,
0.23743677139282227,
-0.06474237143993378,
-0.6947628855705261,
-0.455745130777359,
0.8765943646430969,
-1.2449162006378174,
0.43310168385505676,
-0.3276776671409607,
0.3518608510494232,
-0.05986955389380455,
-1.015730381011963,
-0.5681952834129333,
-0.17296412587165833,
0.009005941450595856,
0.15042325854301453,
-0.575280487537384,
0.30764085054397583,
0.08254101872444153,
0.36009904742240906,
-0.17727282643318176,
0.5966978669166565,
-0.31433168053627014,
-0.30638912320137024,
0.5842087864875793,
-0.06731514632701874,
0.05656209960579872,
-0.5577475428581238,
-0.304985910654068,
-0.2361462414264679,
-0.40408286452293396,
-0.0707845538854599,
0.5393926501274109,
0.210639089345932,
0.054317280650138855,
0.18668092787265778,
-0.05411653220653534,
0.5361873507499695,
0.2450118511915207,
0.22192081809043884,
-0.06824715435504913,
-0.021088501438498497,
-0.33498674631118774,
0.13785098493099213,
0.9721678495407104,
0.12319065630435944,
0.35238274931907654,
0.044744282960891724,
0.08123047649860382,
0.15849250555038452,
0.03165597841143608,
-0.9578464031219482,
-0.5124029517173767,
0.057377323508262634,
-0.8092629909515381,
-0.2827502489089966,
-0.3415237367153168,
-0.8875795006752014,
-0.6446576714515686,
-0.3576614260673523,
-0.04165826365351677,
-0.6675252318382263,
-0.17959687113761902,
0.1552790105342865,
-0.025872092694044113,
0.5161341428756714,
0.5278670191764832,
-0.6946741342544556,
0.39587971568107605,
0.9400427341461182,
0.6501390337944031,
-0.16762292385101318,
0.20180439949035645,
-0.38088706135749817,
-0.5279711484909058,
-0.26464495062828064,
1.4682626724243164,
-0.8959866762161255,
0.03868652880191803,
0.18265625834465027,
-0.187642440199852,
-0.18271175026893616,
-0.6607362627983093,
1.5780696868896484,
-0.5511621832847595,
0.5664815902709961,
-0.11451774090528488,
-1.2142345905303955,
-0.5793056488037109,
0.5731672644615173,
-0.5687926411628723,
0.5516111254692078,
-0.3588046729564667,
-0.4600895643234253,
0.5810685753822327,
-0.8117823004722595,
-0.19023028016090393,
0.40348222851753235,
-0.411611944437027,
-0.5748640894889832,
0.060406915843486786,
0.2851111888885498,
0.8672763109207153,
-0.29694387316703796,
0.16799825429916382,
-0.4144827723503113,
0.0733858272433281,
-0.0031289737671613693,
-0.6596359610557556,
0.5330207943916321,
0.660895824432373,
-0.2793070673942566,
0.24552248418331146,
-0.5471913814544678,
0.1844024658203125,
0.05048275738954544,
-0.3405973017215729,
-0.14290578663349152,
0.47575074434280396,
-0.4615558385848999,
0.16073638200759888,
0.12039772421121597,
-0.6154886484146118,
0.028822001069784164,
-0.5790737867355347,
0.7520521879196167,
0.7988457679748535,
0.04511208087205887,
0.1466992199420929,
0.0375942662358284,
0.2530939280986786,
0.22146879136562347,
-0.2558545470237732,
-0.28779444098472595,
-0.6054182052612305,
-0.9785830974578857,
-0.13551270961761475,
0.7445186376571655,
0.4953664243221283,
-0.1983800083398819,
0.3214260935783386,
-0.21869252622127533,
-0.4026511013507843,
-0.6076486706733704,
-0.10338225215673447,
-0.01748533919453621,
0.2959189713001251,
0.18185587227344513,
0.007882189005613327,
-0.8105279803276062,
-0.8539982438087463,
-0.2968113124370575,
-0.41624200344085693,
0.18669885396957397,
0.6156545281410217,
0.2382255643606186,
-0.22153545916080475,
0.6350528597831726,
-0.19343668222427368,
0.028347134590148926,
-0.2519005537033081,
0.36779218912124634,
0.23911088705062866,
0.26603853702545166,
0.4700767993927002,
-0.5646730661392212,
-0.5809395909309387,
0.3475581407546997,
-0.5675033926963806,
0.022405529394745827,
-0.10375779122114182,
0.2293601632118225,
0.33686354756355286,
0.4418283700942993,
-0.7058826684951782,
0.15432849526405334,
0.042924556881189346,
-0.1865360140800476,
0.442195326089859,
-0.0021857719402760267,
0.06731952726840973,
-1.0628560781478882,
-0.47020798921585083,
-0.003438824787735939,
-0.25189438462257385,
-0.6502147316932678,
0.02833632566034794,
-0.19938525557518005,
-0.10655099153518677,
-0.2470899075269699,
0.2503310441970825,
-0.08847848325967789,
0.4831206500530243,
-0.3259604871273041,
-0.021365204825997353,
-0.24222087860107422,
0.42651069164276123,
0.25173884630203247,
0.16856242716312408,
0.4158160984516144,
-0.3403988480567932,
0.7049365639686584,
0.12336668372154236,
-0.3398812413215637,
0.5818714499473572,
-0.6166583299636841,
0.2601824998855591,
0.2081110179424286,
0.20397284626960754,
-1.0299885272979736,
-0.17480039596557617,
0.24319927394390106,
-0.37473064661026,
0.34973564743995667,
-0.3633577823638916,
-0.39020732045173645,
-0.2300918698310852,
-0.39818745851516724,
-0.1026085838675499,
0.4794006943702698,
-0.8454341888427734,
0.5403780937194824,
0.14490053057670593,
-0.3086957037448883,
-0.5391161441802979,
-0.18334190547466278,
0.18120768666267395,
-0.7234255075454712,
-0.5759230852127075,
0.19792073965072632,
0.08589402586221695,
-0.382559597492218,
0.03771553933620453,
0.09853014349937439,
-0.0736289769411087,
-0.014632178470492363,
0.16888387501239777,
-0.15392637252807617,
-0.5085437893867493,
0.3724082112312317,
-0.14424151182174683,
-0.00418194942176342,
0.18514947593212128,
-0.03274533152580261,
0.6307428479194641,
-0.5457080006599426,
-0.22236086428165436,
-0.41638824343681335,
0.4951033890247345,
0.3044818341732025,
-0.10270913690328598,
0.2486201822757721,
0.6342061161994934,
-0.23311656713485718,
-0.34454360604286194,
-0.8173472881317139,
-0.2600952684879303,
-0.5110994577407837,
0.30624711513519287,
-0.2871807813644409,
-0.822434663772583,
0.44711631536483765,
-0.6520082354545593,
0.553260326385498,
0.6454812288284302,
0.7536314129829407,
-0.08639314770698547,
0.9423697590827942,
-0.001858451752923429,
-0.25318288803100586,
0.4286669194698334,
-0.18739177286624908,
0.5187773108482361,
-0.39098936319351196,
0.011786118149757385,
-0.6720873117446899,
-0.2638627886772156,
-0.6288129091262817,
-0.23251712322235107,
-0.33126381039619446,
-0.08952517062425613,
-0.24682871997356415,
0.24044989049434662,
-0.6670240163803101,
0.2920258641242981,
0.24254703521728516,
-0.2272755652666092,
-0.010986601002514362,
0.04747137054800987,
-0.11732682585716248,
-0.015346917323768139,
-0.8921821117401123,
-0.789814829826355,
0.8389593958854675,
0.6989498734474182,
0.5852580666542053,
0.061876680701971054,
0.7815321087837219,
0.4111979007720947,
0.19390401244163513,
-1.2529196739196777,
0.6815558671951294,
-0.42756709456443787,
-0.46452265977859497,
-0.009698856621980667,
-0.32961562275886536,
-1.1418863534927368,
0.36220213770866394,
-0.3066924214363098,
-0.687017023563385,
0.14763589203357697,
0.07662367820739746,
-0.46403974294662476,
0.6090009212493896,
-1.2523086071014404,
0.9784966111183167,
-0.1969159096479416,
-0.16198848187923431,
-0.2767353653907776,
-0.2827727496623993,
0.29651495814323425,
0.24069103598594666,
-0.020540503785014153,
-0.09277277439832687,
0.5530170202255249,
1.0369027853012085,
-0.4399813711643219,
0.7466615438461304,
-0.30534327030181885,
-0.12954548001289368,
0.6484975218772888,
-0.39548105001449585,
0.420254647731781,
-0.07497673481702805,
-0.26734617352485657,
0.09106641262769699,
0.038624394685029984,
-0.05028209462761879,
-0.625673234462738,
0.7013715505599976,
-0.7845655083656311,
-0.6858116388320923,
-0.3306001126766205,
-0.275838166475296,
0.03682459518313408,
0.049755144864320755,
0.2344253808259964,
0.41105222702026367,
-0.18129870295524597,
0.5494906902313232,
0.6233327388763428,
-0.19676995277404785,
0.774864673614502,
0.385474294424057,
0.5228230357170105,
-0.10464899241924286,
0.6803913712501526,
0.13395260274410248,
-0.3431366980075836,
0.2006244957447052,
0.6073763370513916,
-0.581383228302002,
-0.8169512748718262,
-0.3447561264038086,
-0.17020182311534882,
-0.9740840792655945,
-0.5209489464759827,
-0.7845944166183472,
-0.3870902955532074,
-0.33304670453071594,
0.12046020478010178,
-0.28910738229751587,
-0.4276346266269684,
-0.09557826817035675,
-0.2194749265909195,
0.35108986496925354,
0.5420717000961304,
0.10816649347543716,
0.36334702372550964,
-0.6396512389183044,
-0.1020350307226181,
0.5128322243690491,
0.5440318584442139,
0.12980732321739197,
-0.2270788699388504,
0.1369389146566391,
-0.2047583907842636,
-0.693871796131134,
-0.895470917224884,
0.09278664737939835,
0.44100168347358704,
0.5844822525978088,
0.8066120147705078,
0.23214562237262726,
0.7146711945533752,
-0.6749114394187927,
0.9422554969787598,
0.07649969309568405,
-0.8934057354927063,
0.3325779438018799,
-0.018264980986714363,
-0.10665623098611832,
0.32119596004486084,
0.0858287662267685,
-0.2551487684249878,
0.03531617298722267,
-0.973616898059845,
-0.7417598366737366,
0.5893582701683044,
0.0756741538643837,
0.10513357818126678,
-0.2617321312427521,
0.461972713470459,
0.22509464621543884,
-0.11361521482467651,
-0.8478816747665405,
0.2126387059688568,
-0.2395826131105423,
-0.40494027733802795,
0.31808438897132874,
-0.25691941380500793,
0.023261748254299164,
-0.21035702526569366,
0.5455087423324585,
-0.10017955303192139,
0.4635225832462311,
-0.03750035539269447,
-0.03965746611356735,
0.12868721783161163,
0.7289511561393738,
0.5625150799751282,
-0.08400151878595352,
-0.0711466521024704,
0.23735728859901428,
0.6506744623184204,
-0.06227518245577812,
0.011818996630609035,
0.24359050393104553,
0.2376411408185959,
0.23793210089206696,
0.6076789498329163,
1.0048269033432007,
0.12331372499465942,
-0.5516162514686584,
0.45277678966522217,
-0.2549241781234741,
-0.40811148285865784,
-0.4126611053943634,
0.1839521825313568,
0.14045272767543793,
0.4573413133621216,
-0.08181118220090866,
0.1902708113193512,
0.46774235367774963,
-0.453316867351532,
0.20196671783924103,
0.7963554263114929,
-0.3098371922969818,
-0.24762243032455444,
0.2546183168888092,
0.2886895537376404,
-0.3308325707912445,
0.45886608958244324,
-0.04123901203274727,
-0.7082312107086182,
0.3418509364128113,
0.2979554235935211,
0.8736494183540344,
-0.23875001072883606,
0.041323836892843246,
0.2925254702568054,
-0.1573365330696106,
0.24947763979434967,
0.004349776543676853,
-0.2731914818286896,
-0.9468587636947632,
-0.4082697629928589,
-0.43228811025619507,
-0.43900546431541443,
0.5018271207809448,
-0.37110480666160583,
0.3320654630661011,
-0.4352143108844757,
-0.03116242028772831,
0.514634370803833,
0.5143827199935913,
-0.5823255181312561,
0.07016382366418839,
0.3951602280139923,
0.695662796497345,
-0.7090993523597717,
0.8402478098869324,
0.7540275454521179,
0.1539561003446579,
-0.7128230929374695,
-0.21518972516059875,
-0.20370309054851532,
-0.37418505549430847,
0.5907266736030579,
0.23070162534713745,
-0.08096246421337128,
-0.2974013388156891,
-0.7253507971763611,
-0.1061391532421112,
0.6468744874000549,
0.27704110741615295,
-0.4096505343914032,
0.3233819007873535,
-0.014064357616007328,
0.7264310121536255,
-0.4245845675468445,
0.3930448889732361,
0.5931118130683899,
0.4356882572174072,
0.24625223875045776,
-0.43322914838790894,
-0.08625578135251999,
-0.2040068358182907,
-0.40775564312934875,
0.16268932819366455,
-0.5056541562080383,
0.8276716470718384,
-0.030023755505681038,
-0.3949659764766693,
0.12142208963632584,
0.8635424375534058,
0.2341136485338211,
0.2864558696746826,
0.7568556666374207,
0.6541817784309387,
0.894989013671875,
-0.32815656065940857,
0.839279055595398,
0.00798314344137907,
0.33431679010391235,
1.1325198411941528,
-0.36879950761795044,
0.9241920709609985,
0.06498036533594131,
-0.03620264679193497,
0.9004738330841064,
0.9892734289169312,
-0.3032355010509491,
0.3258321285247803,
0.2936150133609772,
-0.45363903045654297,
-0.5291722416877747,
0.14335621893405914,
-0.2312246710062027,
0.5794810652732849,
0.6286580562591553,
-0.18781892955303192,
-0.6031001806259155,
-0.40951964259147644,
0.2474784255027771,
0.02913975529372692,
-0.1622147560119629,
1.1522541046142578,
0.05128408223390579,
-0.8860646486282349,
0.4997189939022064,
0.09213222563266754,
0.7197168469429016,
-0.42835482954978943,
-0.16923752427101135,
0.012189560569822788,
0.5208019614219666,
-0.29496946930885315,
-0.6562408208847046,
0.09846851974725723,
0.2799629271030426,
0.10337749868631363,
0.15766015648841858,
1.059051752090454,
-0.19418641924858093,
-0.22027556598186493,
0.11521647870540619,
0.2610841989517212,
0.2371527999639511,
0.14674656093120575,
-1.0639094114303589,
-0.1798301786184311,
0.04576263576745987,
-0.16566938161849976,
0.02740674838423729,
0.6049708724021912,
-0.20202410221099854,
0.5177063345909119,
0.5009766221046448,
-0.30420351028442383,
0.29860177636146545,
0.003861412638798356,
0.867624044418335,
-0.42083853483200073,
-0.30147701501846313,
-1.2256910800933838,
0.23744146525859833,
-0.5338728427886963,
-0.08905593305826187,
0.7428693175315857,
0.4910541772842407,
0.3194519877433777,
-0.0942835658788681,
0.7067086696624756,
-0.05286427214741707,
0.5465376377105713,
-0.3934031128883362,
0.28457289934158325,
-0.03630560636520386,
0.2636105418205261,
-0.32419243454933167,
-0.6239756941795349,
-0.4103810489177704,
0.874172568321228,
-0.4577917456626892,
0.06027430668473244,
0.4438655376434326,
0.34872516989707947,
-0.22092393040657043,
0.5457539558410645,
0.12931136786937714,
0.15619389712810516,
0.7600247263908386,
0.6292176246643066,
1.0985031127929688,
-0.48002344369888306,
0.521544873714447,
-0.07106108218431473,
-0.04403453692793846,
-0.25557413697242737,
-1.069008231163025,
-1.0237970352172852,
-0.4706946015357971,
-0.7113938331604004,
-0.037914566695690155,
-0.16666151583194733,
0.9726980924606323,
1.0838829278945923,
-1.2295215129852295,
-0.06267908215522766,
-0.289554238319397,
0.1493629515171051,
-0.05442831292748451,
-0.19856692850589752,
0.6108851432800293,
-0.8722609877586365,
-0.7023810148239136,
0.528783917427063,
-0.04819229245185852,
-0.21204239130020142,
0.20022551715373993,
-0.26183873414993286,
-0.35560908913612366,
0.4951345920562744,
0.7237647771835327,
0.30534985661506653,
-0.9992362856864929,
-0.4485272169113159,
-0.3349519371986389,
0.48327741026878357,
0.3635385036468506,
0.6404726505279541,
-0.7321239113807678,
0.45304521918296814,
0.5171007513999939,
0.7082496881484985,
0.2983652353286743,
0.04917506128549576,
0.44768214225769043,
-0.8495885729789734,
-0.010334554128348827,
0.28840765357017517,
0.815641462802887,
0.4058734178543091,
-0.13913863897323608,
0.43223321437835693,
-0.11623348295688629,
-0.7654904127120972,
-0.6570133566856384,
0.22940747439861298,
-1.0500022172927856,
-0.4193498194217682,
1.0733314752578735,
-0.5830475091934204,
0.11116637289524078,
-0.12365435063838959,
-0.5245886445045471,
0.22195124626159668,
-0.40443453192710876,
0.7597530484199524,
0.9535139203071594,
-0.265183687210083,
-0.5455303192138672,
-0.4183468520641327,
0.6826992630958557,
0.5018325448036194,
-0.8035256266593933,
0.17394812405109406,
0.3767949938774109,
0.17318227887153625,
0.3902989327907562,
0.0018372628837823868,
-0.1890980750322342,
0.03608798608183861,
-0.23632486164569855,
-0.17068298161029816,
0.2513800263404846,
0.14210623502731323,
-0.31653720140457153,
0.7408776879310608,
0.10263998806476593,
-0.42254963517189026
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13681v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13681v1
|
PARAMANU-AYN: An Efficient Novel Generative and Instruction-tuned Language Model for Indian Legal Case Documents
| 2024-03-20T15:39:54 | 2024-03-20T15:39:54 |
Mitodru Niyogi, Arnab Bhattacharya
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
In this paper, we present PARAMANU-AYN, a language model based exclusively on
case documents of the Supreme Court of India, the Constitution of India, and
the Indian Penal Code. The novel Auto Regressive (AR) decoder based model is
pretrained from scratch at a context size of 8192. We evaluated our pretrained
legal model on perplexity metrics. We also instruction-tuned our pretrained
model on a set of 10,763 instructions covering various legal tasks such as
legal reasoning, judgement explanation, legal clause generation, legal
drafting, legal contract drafting, case summarization, constitutional
question-answering, etc. We also evaluated the responses of prompts for
instruction-tuned models by GPT-3.5-Turbo on clarity, relevance, completeness,
and legal reasoning metrics in a scale of 10. Our model can be run on CPU and
achieved 42.46 tokens/sec CPU inference speed. We found that our models,
despite not being pretrained on legal books, various legal contracts, and legal
documents, were able to learn the domain knowledge required for drafting
various legal contracts and legal clauses, and generalize to draft legal
contracts and legal clauses with limited instruction tuning. Hence, we conclude
that for a strong domain-specialized generative language model (such as legal),
very large amounts of data are not required to develop models from scratch. We
believe that this work is the first attempt to make a dedicated generative
legal language model from scratch for Indian Supreme Court jurisdiction or in
legal NLP overall. We plan to release our Paramanu-Ayn model at
https://www.bharatgpts.com.
|
[
0.17030033469200134,
-0.7836563587188721,
0.2659052908420563,
-0.10044343769550323,
-0.6204121112823486,
-0.24667564034461975,
-0.29028600454330444,
0.07208510488271713,
0.01719706505537033,
0.6506966948509216,
-0.2889580726623535,
-0.4180055856704712,
-0.37147262692451477,
0.049174487590789795,
-0.6383033394813538,
0.8992609977722168,
0.3688953220844269,
0.10175138711929321,
-0.20029987394809723,
-0.2103518843650818,
-0.06261380016803741,
-0.6661390662193298,
-0.3385794758796692,
0.2287083864212036,
-0.08006126433610916,
0.1273392140865326,
0.7092956304550171,
1.1300976276397705,
0.4471483528614044,
0.3104652464389801,
-0.10592327266931534,
-0.21038463711738586,
-0.1669776439666748,
-0.0874861404299736,
-0.1392228603363037,
-0.5860223174095154,
-0.4503883719444275,
-0.08615679293870926,
0.6366938948631287,
0.33340170979499817,
-0.7961876392364502,
0.15358972549438477,
-0.27908098697662354,
0.583819568157196,
-0.7340785264968872,
0.2849169969558716,
-0.6585133671760559,
-0.09104132652282715,
-0.300984263420105,
-0.038003869354724884,
-0.5002942681312561,
-0.2495386302471161,
-0.19375312328338623,
-0.9440757036209106,
0.3294225037097931,
0.2736949622631073,
0.9851158857345581,
0.5092693567276001,
-0.43988603353500366,
-0.5782990455627441,
-0.6587059497833252,
0.48975586891174316,
-0.8939158916473389,
0.4513866603374481,
0.2841968834400177,
0.44153183698654175,
0.15857452154159546,
-0.7964494228363037,
-0.6766523718833923,
-0.5167074799537659,
0.025484979152679443,
0.24242061376571655,
-0.12198920547962189,
0.35271647572517395,
0.3185480535030365,
0.3559352159500122,
-0.6710229516029358,
-0.10929667204618454,
-0.34459030628204346,
-0.10278619080781937,
0.4818795621395111,
0.14307866990566254,
0.557574450969696,
-0.4279288947582245,
-0.05457465723156929,
0.09545572102069855,
-0.7049327492713928,
-0.025543197989463806,
0.7326570153236389,
0.15915268659591675,
-0.12867961823940277,
0.596535325050354,
-0.20330111682415009,
1.0196890830993652,
0.11943939328193665,
-0.01339488010853529,
-0.0847976803779602,
-0.26544007658958435,
-0.23910722136497498,
-0.036154717206954956,
0.9736659526824951,
-0.03829484432935715,
0.17252975702285767,
-0.17462588846683502,
-0.19552792608737946,
0.012053987011313438,
0.46402856707572937,
-0.5657264590263367,
-0.20619457960128784,
-0.020209068432450294,
-0.7643619775772095,
-0.1440558284521103,
-0.17047542333602905,
-0.6408830881118774,
-0.34719979763031006,
-0.6561118364334106,
0.11395391821861267,
-0.5584428310394287,
-0.38247066736221313,
0.19989505410194397,
0.24906893074512482,
0.495945543050766,
0.17336004972457886,
-0.9230031371116638,
0.13217537105083466,
0.5926979780197144,
0.31272977590560913,
0.11806338280439377,
-0.0936940610408783,
-0.448915958404541,
0.07038482278585434,
-0.3978826403617859,
0.6906973123550415,
-0.8942749500274658,
-0.27758461236953735,
0.34399959444999695,
-0.1546245962381363,
-0.3231315314769745,
-0.373905211687088,
0.8488874435424805,
-0.47258102893829346,
-0.16956885159015656,
-0.04120630398392677,
-0.68790602684021,
-0.09836098551750183,
0.10615058243274689,
-0.5307899117469788,
0.192502960562706,
-0.037686169147491455,
-0.6881452798843384,
0.4597647190093994,
-0.6198780536651611,
-0.5718510746955872,
0.6145691275596619,
-0.4584476053714752,
-0.44505658745765686,
0.2075822949409485,
0.08337423205375671,
0.19594018161296844,
-0.5139243602752686,
0.5736092329025269,
-0.12921017408370972,
-0.3330276608467102,
-0.2200571894645691,
-0.2031034231185913,
1.0559039115905762,
0.49249234795570374,
-0.03326232731342316,
0.27589669823646545,
-0.9967200756072998,
-0.17577628791332245,
-0.005515078082680702,
-0.5316848158836365,
-0.2319565713405609,
-0.009106487035751343,
0.048426467925310135,
0.14310337603092194,
0.2668226659297943,
-0.6581916213035583,
-0.025396980345249176,
-0.32708486914634705,
0.7180189490318298,
0.31112003326416016,
-0.14304977655410767,
0.4204825162887573,
-0.14631599187850952,
0.9530135989189148,
-0.18776513636112213,
0.24957603216171265,
-0.13116440176963806,
-0.36485224962234497,
-0.8015034794807434,
-0.00264210463501513,
0.7956681847572327,
0.7595840692520142,
-0.5802969336509705,
0.31195396184921265,
-0.2116013616323471,
-0.1607281118631363,
-0.9199656248092651,
0.17283302545547485,
0.6734786629676819,
0.4396766424179077,
0.2100031077861786,
0.23563288152217865,
-0.6333491802215576,
-1.1235976219177246,
-0.5578586459159851,
-0.30443596839904785,
0.29340362548828125,
0.33672377467155457,
0.45250508189201355,
-0.020931126549839973,
0.6485006809234619,
-0.05996828153729439,
-0.05307353287935257,
-0.295331209897995,
0.1874740570783615,
0.045482564717531204,
0.3436718285083771,
0.30218374729156494,
-0.7600976824760437,
-0.5810955166816711,
0.17037968337535858,
-0.9930203557014465,
0.011907409876585007,
-0.22365118563175201,
-0.2372276484966278,
0.2145756334066391,
0.8499492406845093,
-0.8077507615089417,
0.4398204982280731,
0.033758118748664856,
-0.40425580739974976,
0.533113420009613,
-0.4868280589580536,
0.05417768284678459,
-1.1398968696594238,
0.07879307121038437,
0.05333526059985161,
-0.27782317996025085,
-0.6037659049034119,
0.6498690247535706,
0.5225162506103516,
-0.46483370661735535,
-0.6456246972084045,
0.26756295561790466,
-0.3639764189720154,
0.35030972957611084,
-0.2849454879760742,
-0.29268407821655273,
-0.3595398962497711,
0.6334559321403503,
-0.01945561170578003,
0.9933398962020874,
0.5671777129173279,
-0.5936859846115112,
0.22561362385749817,
0.4396931529045105,
-0.24734054505825043,
0.5665115118026733,
-0.5144997239112854,
0.018137691542506218,
-0.31378912925720215,
-0.042419467121362686,
-0.41212037205696106,
-0.26264405250549316,
0.142083078622818,
-0.006501018535345793,
0.39459285140037537,
-0.5326831936836243,
-0.49858930706977844,
-0.26249125599861145,
0.29566293954849243,
0.26249849796295166,
0.5800561904907227,
-0.2099027782678604,
0.9180634021759033,
0.5553685426712036,
-0.026043886318802834,
-0.38453617691993713,
-0.4378710389137268,
0.12556733191013336,
-0.31041219830513,
-0.17382465302944183,
0.16499508917331696,
0.006874532904475927,
-0.17916074395179749,
0.23507101833820343,
0.016776110976934433,
-0.2243320345878601,
-0.3194534182548523,
0.354428768157959,
-0.07091958820819855,
-0.2476014792919159,
0.09395037591457367,
0.3438737094402313,
0.12702089548110962,
0.1799730658531189,
-0.13154906034469604,
0.36187779903411865,
-0.31519314646720886,
-0.21546685695648193,
-0.7244793176651001,
0.3395717442035675,
0.6648337841033936,
-0.39989766478538513,
0.440415620803833,
0.047778066247701645,
-0.389049232006073,
-0.04209423437714577,
-0.5334991812705994,
0.4023692309856415,
-0.4157687723636627,
0.12971745431423187,
-0.6372331976890564,
-0.6587084531784058,
0.39296168088912964,
-0.1582481563091278,
0.014260158874094486,
0.8617739677429199,
0.5699296593666077,
0.27795618772506714,
0.7192875146865845,
0.7019239068031311,
0.044508662074804306,
0.5335913300514221,
-0.2896859645843506,
0.22732281684875488,
-0.5903651118278503,
-0.22686947882175446,
-0.4138931632041931,
0.4029037356376648,
-0.5273914337158203,
-0.014436054974794388,
0.16914314031600952,
0.1554228663444519,
-0.11600350588560104,
0.579338788986206,
-0.3578181564807892,
0.6106701493263245,
0.5400050282478333,
0.18432116508483887,
0.18748916685581207,
-0.21381622552871704,
-0.4407183825969696,
0.2675435543060303,
-0.9407877922058105,
-0.46267372369766235,
1.551222562789917,
-0.01336892694234848,
0.5801861882209778,
-0.05019669979810715,
0.7267807126045227,
0.23039817810058594,
-0.025626694783568382,
-0.6463167667388916,
0.561226487159729,
-0.5444846749305725,
-0.5755022168159485,
-0.11243104189634323,
-0.33422860503196716,
-0.7207728624343872,
0.06989751011133194,
-0.2247493714094162,
-0.1436811238527298,
0.2238713800907135,
0.20030348002910614,
-0.8244330286979675,
0.08249372243881226,
-0.7880929708480835,
0.9384671449661255,
-0.010824134573340416,
-0.44746628403663635,
-0.33584901690483093,
-0.5270968079566956,
0.6035951375961304,
-0.1149473488330841,
0.11002150923013687,
0.023160360753536224,
0.20696935057640076,
0.6979560256004333,
-0.8344783186912537,
0.5346843004226685,
-0.14653171598911285,
0.07468737661838531,
0.6350429654121399,
0.05905858427286148,
0.38651758432388306,
0.30374985933303833,
-0.20972082018852234,
-0.16417738795280457,
0.16981258988380432,
-0.38134297728538513,
-0.6113846302032471,
0.5895625948905945,
-0.6386263370513916,
-0.9150441288948059,
-0.35787197947502136,
-0.7681973576545715,
0.1647203266620636,
0.21678684651851654,
0.34088462591171265,
0.4393864572048187,
0.008126986213028431,
0.2783637046813965,
0.5950153470039368,
-0.18396659195423126,
0.6712494492530823,
0.7240521907806396,
0.18626169860363007,
-0.18676365911960602,
0.9358215928077698,
0.05587676912546158,
-0.3566846549510956,
0.3435814678668976,
0.27120521664619446,
-0.6195486783981323,
-0.5955998301506042,
-0.7648530602455139,
0.23268960416316986,
-0.7805125117301941,
-0.253240168094635,
-0.6524609923362732,
-0.3945121467113495,
-0.46252039074897766,
0.22088077664375305,
-0.414348304271698,
-0.4942165017127991,
-0.15144215524196625,
0.2241988629102707,
0.3285568952560425,
0.814937949180603,
0.24901846051216125,
0.06614074110984802,
-0.5238103866577148,
0.49243101477622986,
0.415781706571579,
0.35002684593200684,
-0.33304843306541443,
-0.8484617471694946,
0.015275898389518261,
-0.01908758282661438,
-0.09817734360694885,
-0.5987809896469116,
0.35332611203193665,
0.39459699392318726,
0.6596912145614624,
0.3121805787086487,
0.11607466638088226,
0.6228934526443481,
-0.8122203946113586,
0.4146823585033417,
-0.07518504559993744,
-0.9781395792961121,
0.7663160562515259,
-0.5481996536254883,
0.14402633905410767,
0.6483542323112488,
0.3475290834903717,
0.03144261986017227,
-0.36458057165145874,
-0.5310176014900208,
-0.6199417114257812,
0.6816108226776123,
0.28849223256111145,
0.3436990976333618,
0.03154692426323891,
0.9744318723678589,
0.05334074795246124,
0.2824459671974182,
-0.49833089113235474,
0.0035231292713433504,
-0.31026723980903625,
-0.2207668125629425,
0.19545745849609375,
-0.3277134299278259,
-0.08870840817689896,
-0.680060863494873,
0.44289377331733704,
0.23265531659126282,
0.16683480143547058,
0.016079774126410484,
-0.5067462921142578,
0.09432196617126465,
0.2533298134803772,
0.789314866065979,
0.8265490531921387,
-0.07449795305728912,
-0.20850999653339386,
-0.0926678478717804,
-0.4618304371833801,
0.2510077655315399,
0.2448255717754364,
-0.31485259532928467,
-0.01547569502145052,
0.12814325094223022,
1.0808624029159546,
0.006734609603881836,
-0.6498898863792419,
0.4639918804168701,
-0.2981039881706238,
-0.42471322417259216,
-0.34679606556892395,
0.069161057472229,
-0.07496336102485657,
0.07526680082082748,
0.10238007456064224,
0.07598607987165451,
0.36619678139686584,
-0.4036402106285095,
0.24789772927761078,
0.20070524513721466,
-0.04535102844238281,
-0.07345626503229141,
1.1931897401809692,
0.27147212624549866,
-0.5564515590667725,
0.611815869808197,
-0.49200770258903503,
-0.22530986368656158,
0.5056175589561462,
0.6213208436965942,
0.7231373190879822,
-0.24312281608581543,
0.11283469200134277,
0.25650373101234436,
0.12098328024148941,
-0.36108481884002686,
0.2818848490715027,
-0.15311527252197266,
-0.23616622388362885,
-0.32100456953048706,
-0.9528902173042297,
-0.34601789712905884,
0.3127663731575012,
-0.6610238552093506,
0.17310769855976105,
-0.708139181137085,
0.054050687700510025,
-0.08686365187168121,
-0.026705730706453323,
-0.5443110466003418,
0.15719301998615265,
-0.28424930572509766,
0.66431725025177,
-0.8592827916145325,
1.1622025966644287,
0.7770305871963501,
-0.597632110118866,
-0.6810186505317688,
0.12197086215019226,
-0.28321555256843567,
-0.5181390643119812,
0.4462970495223999,
-0.10954293608665466,
0.05568322911858559,
0.2744109034538269,
-0.15397322177886963,
-0.5783822536468506,
0.718272864818573,
0.7751507759094238,
-1.0503038167953491,
-0.13319629430770874,
0.14426176249980927,
0.6664635539054871,
-0.3321996331214905,
-0.04060418903827667,
0.7301235198974609,
-0.047224901616573334,
-0.011344684287905693,
-0.6786728501319885,
0.16301897168159485,
-0.8292441368103027,
0.26399561762809753,
0.10558236390352249,
-0.5773493051528931,
0.8970387578010559,
0.1591651737689972,
-0.040423326194286346,
0.07492689788341522,
0.6330965757369995,
0.1678682267665863,
-0.18286317586898804,
0.38027432560920715,
0.9109311103820801,
0.6689573526382446,
0.16056376695632935,
1.3977879285812378,
-0.9837930202484131,
0.10971122980117798,
0.8196216821670532,
-0.17676308751106262,
0.8688016533851624,
0.1492515504360199,
-0.024784591048955917,
0.38524484634399414,
0.3441663384437561,
-0.027369847521185875,
0.41173478960990906,
0.42745712399482727,
-0.3059982359409332,
-0.7010393142700195,
-0.06346306949853897,
-0.3021039366722107,
0.6006171107292175,
0.17789000272750854,
-0.20331159234046936,
-0.06064191088080406,
0.053497135639190674,
-0.31624311208724976,
0.4598122835159302,
-0.25844115018844604,
0.572472333908081,
-0.1075611561536789,
-0.686275839805603,
0.7411495447158813,
0.3221612274646759,
0.43365079164505005,
-0.3604813814163208,
-0.10541980713605881,
-0.4384496510028839,
0.012318267486989498,
0.10109660774469376,
-0.19585877656936646,
0.4013926088809967,
0.2280305176973343,
-0.01790529489517212,
-0.1802709847688675,
0.5509297847747803,
-0.45084068179130554,
-0.824332594871521,
-0.1318044364452362,
0.16722457110881805,
0.16253513097763062,
-0.1303769052028656,
-0.8855447173118591,
0.011542228050529957,
-0.2942153215408325,
-0.16917739808559418,
0.24879761040210724,
0.45182618498802185,
-0.2666163444519043,
0.5605461597442627,
0.3982674479484558,
-0.04363904893398285,
0.5292741656303406,
0.17521406710147858,
0.7555606961250305,
-0.5485870242118835,
-0.6046009063720703,
-0.6988226771354675,
0.36795303225517273,
0.059494126588106155,
-0.4741989076137543,
0.5281215310096741,
0.9083726406097412,
0.6029316186904907,
-0.2575860619544983,
0.8377851247787476,
-0.014257890172302723,
0.2234642505645752,
-0.7781975269317627,
1.058732032775879,
-0.47324132919311523,
0.12151511013507843,
0.2794778645038605,
-0.7225891351699829,
-0.2957925796508789,
0.5816223621368408,
-0.166081503033638,
-0.08743531256914139,
0.6398772597312927,
0.7391296625137329,
-0.3269784152507782,
-0.10718872398138046,
0.38748738169670105,
-0.07933821529150009,
-0.1133546382188797,
0.5378965139389038,
0.5754451751708984,
-0.7105712294578552,
1.0148162841796875,
-0.23557770252227783,
0.001304056029766798,
-0.01901155337691307,
-0.5990786552429199,
-1.0313559770584106,
-0.5349407196044922,
-0.4317623972892761,
-0.1300581991672516,
0.3517196476459503,
0.7028575539588928,
0.6220683455467224,
-0.888293445110321,
-0.4426155984401703,
-0.8690091967582703,
-0.2935221195220947,
0.22227174043655396,
-0.11495310068130493,
0.5424959659576416,
-0.7600399255752563,
-0.6851364970207214,
0.5550482273101807,
0.10275927186012268,
-0.18309107422828674,
0.10596436262130737,
-0.23014940321445465,
-0.5394696593284607,
0.21576881408691406,
0.3586594760417938,
0.46455860137939453,
-0.8863774538040161,
0.23239250481128693,
-0.34278231859207153,
-0.11467176675796509,
0.05239015072584152,
1.1637264490127563,
-0.36560600996017456,
0.6629788875579834,
0.4142898917198181,
0.650019645690918,
0.5200871825218201,
0.10362803190946579,
0.7045935988426208,
-0.5075463652610779,
0.4546028971672058,
0.11555462330579758,
0.4563671350479126,
0.08033061027526855,
-0.4793708920478821,
0.2319658398628235,
0.32722732424736023,
-0.3122994303703308,
-0.7437372803688049,
0.132665753364563,
-0.5846769213676453,
-0.3913353979587555,
1.113128423690796,
-0.346449077129364,
-0.46991705894470215,
0.02263546735048294,
-0.05119916424155235,
0.6902652978897095,
-0.20843249559402466,
0.7843431234359741,
0.6120963096618652,
0.12291330844163895,
-0.400003582239151,
-0.8112643957138062,
0.8075271248817444,
0.513067901134491,
-0.7789938449859619,
0.08627553284168243,
0.21105708181858063,
0.2503884732723236,
-0.09143294394016266,
0.48317840695381165,
-0.2519608736038208,
0.4860830307006836,
0.30378034710884094,
0.07283628731966019,
-0.4584449529647827,
-0.4692082703113556,
-0.7533964514732361,
0.2925265431404114,
-0.04910896718502045,
-0.2513663172721863
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13679v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13679v3
|
RoleInteract: Evaluating the Social Interaction of Role-Playing Agents
| 2024-03-20T15:38:36 | 2024-03-22T00:49:59 |
Hongzhan Chen, Hehong Chen, Ming Yan, Wenshen Xu, Xing Gao, Weizhou Shen, Xiaojun Quan, Chenliang Li, Ji Zhang, Fei Huang, Jingren Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have advanced the development of various AI
conversational agents, including role-playing conversational agents that mimic
diverse characters and human behaviors. While prior research has predominantly
focused on enhancing the conversational capability, role-specific knowledge,
and stylistic attributes of these agents, there has been a noticeable gap in
assessing their social intelligence. In this paper, we introduce RoleInteract,
the first benchmark designed to systematically evaluate the sociality of
role-playing conversational agents at both individual and group levels of
social interactions. The benchmark is constructed from a variety of sources and
covers a wide range of 500 characters and over 6,000 question prompts and
30,800 multi-turn role-playing utterances. We conduct comprehensive evaluations
on this benchmark using mainstream open-source and closed-source LLMs. We find
that agents excelling in individual level does not imply their proficiency in
group level. Moreover, the behavior of individuals may drift as a result of the
influence exerted by other agents within the group. Experimental results on
RoleInteract confirm its significance as a testbed for assessing the social
interaction of role-playing conversational agents. The benchmark is publicly
accessible at https://github.com/X-PLUG/RoleInteract.
|
[
-0.2989722788333893,
-0.6294875741004944,
0.24835477769374847,
0.2922528088092804,
0.07075206935405731,
0.37462958693504333,
-0.21696165204048157,
-0.541081428527832,
0.2094566822052002,
0.21361593902111053,
-0.6062090992927551,
-0.6240379810333252,
-0.5656636357307434,
-0.051016081124544144,
-0.13378868997097015,
0.6798330545425415,
0.5111035704612732,
-0.016943039372563362,
-0.633571207523346,
-0.37446948885917664,
-0.14849615097045898,
-0.409289687871933,
-0.9171690940856934,
-0.37879887223243713,
0.6363401412963867,
0.48826587200164795,
0.6349961757659912,
0.10824239253997803,
0.5798196792602539,
0.4680333137512207,
0.17443233728408813,
0.23458006978034973,
-0.9625518918037415,
0.29635003209114075,
-0.2853371202945709,
-0.24027663469314575,
-0.5953702330589294,
0.40309590101242065,
0.6713799834251404,
0.4110508859157562,
0.10777708888053894,
0.34682324528694153,
0.09134048968553543,
0.2346665859222412,
-0.47134891152381897,
0.6352102160453796,
-0.5857999920845032,
-0.2460385113954544,
-0.19425678253173828,
-0.20916244387626648,
-0.39996686577796936,
-0.5551889538764954,
-0.03282470628619194,
-0.4782130718231201,
-0.17695695161819458,
-0.27550506591796875,
0.27612870931625366,
0.1865747570991516,
-0.3941676616668701,
-0.0306948721408844,
-0.5330623984336853,
0.6080962419509888,
-0.7440283894538879,
0.05749485269188881,
0.5723726153373718,
0.4186157286167145,
-0.21966974437236786,
-0.4734082818031311,
-0.429574579000473,
-0.4786120355129242,
-0.06614214926958084,
0.1629468947649002,
-0.007697403430938721,
0.06431443244218826,
0.31128230690956116,
0.052481912076473236,
-0.4932558834552765,
-0.054765939712524414,
-0.32382795214653015,
0.06137232854962349,
1.045479416847229,
0.11317253112792969,
0.3602636456489563,
-0.020715394988656044,
-0.2101103514432907,
-0.2348000407218933,
-0.4100379943847656,
0.32838472723960876,
0.5276510715484619,
0.037239864468574524,
-0.2555772066116333,
0.5954872369766235,
-0.03387373313307762,
-0.042689621448516846,
-0.17924441397190094,
0.06235664337873459,
0.29009193181991577,
-0.2961790859699249,
0.027485093101859093,
-0.02266341634094715,
0.7864118218421936,
0.5886790156364441,
0.6359995007514954,
-0.21309037506580353,
0.10564945638179779,
0.327782541513443,
0.26293402910232544,
-0.6859190464019775,
0.04405376687645912,
-0.07631507515907288,
-0.3227474093437195,
-0.44585976004600525,
0.12193682789802551,
-0.4757421314716339,
-0.7767588496208191,
0.11028145998716354,
0.3559344708919525,
-0.3754119873046875,
-0.2577728033065796,
-0.4961510896682739,
-0.16205962002277374,
0.47636112570762634,
0.2757250964641571,
-0.5933443903923035,
0.5962008237838745,
1.090816617012024,
0.7278612852096558,
-0.15744274854660034,
-0.6798318028450012,
-0.9676432013511658,
0.07925304770469666,
-0.28916144371032715,
0.801787257194519,
-0.7017847299575806,
-0.5757865309715271,
0.0020580522250384092,
0.10303523391485214,
-0.12783639132976532,
-0.48205626010894775,
0.2610663175582886,
-0.29236364364624023,
-0.4016402065753937,
-0.2083214670419693,
-0.40171101689338684,
0.2836047410964966,
0.4948863983154297,
-0.4196808338165283,
0.8860760927200317,
0.10052983462810516,
-0.3786821663379669,
0.43073180317878723,
-0.6597338318824768,
-0.5793027877807617,
0.6413683295249939,
-0.38870730996131897,
0.06613039970397949,
-0.16723163425922394,
-0.24285411834716797,
0.37223705649375916,
-0.4823901057243347,
0.04996674135327339,
-0.6372726559638977,
-0.7110550403594971,
0.5972046256065369,
-0.33058369159698486,
0.5202423334121704,
-0.07548076659440994,
-0.15085765719413757,
0.38782593607902527,
-0.40258917212486267,
0.0891878753900528,
-0.1136963739991188,
-0.007517973892390728,
-0.5224713683128357,
0.240861177444458,
-0.08420664072036743,
0.06448952108621597,
0.0734606683254242,
-0.48979488015174866,
0.006681140046566725,
-0.037054650485515594,
0.5188595652580261,
0.9907565712928772,
-0.0434204638004303,
0.2957540452480316,
-0.4342252016067505,
0.3810708820819855,
-0.6019230484962463,
0.5696272850036621,
0.19911018013954163,
-0.44371843338012695,
-0.31021422147750854,
-0.4042787551879883,
-0.10929079353809357,
0.3690146505832672,
-0.5379261374473572,
0.4397820234298706,
-0.25490516424179077,
-0.9259568452835083,
-0.4287799000740051,
0.10673786699771881,
0.42327335476875305,
0.034277379512786865,
0.11615347117185593,
-0.5833359360694885,
-0.16294395923614502,
-0.7841705679893494,
-0.5764778256416321,
-0.723800003528595,
0.11701827496290207,
0.7156752347946167,
0.3122692108154297,
-0.49874410033226013,
0.6646096706390381,
0.12434796243906021,
-0.17894722521305084,
-0.27097925543785095,
0.27235499024391174,
-0.18821847438812256,
0.3744420111179352,
0.2327689826488495,
-0.2581775486469269,
-0.7055268883705139,
-0.0014753456925973296,
-0.8217658996582031,
-0.2709539830684662,
0.3616138994693756,
-0.06865671277046204,
0.07561374455690384,
0.7229225635528564,
-0.6979425549507141,
0.542007565498352,
0.6560574769973755,
-0.43929973244667053,
0.27415481209754944,
-0.18209080398082733,
0.5384078621864319,
-0.7426429986953735,
0.3166375160217285,
0.11056432127952576,
-0.21654090285301208,
-0.5709231495857239,
-0.16356825828552246,
-0.18071696162223816,
-0.03444847837090492,
-0.30556604266166687,
0.7158689498901367,
-0.3352261781692505,
-0.5391227006912231,
0.0946914479136467,
0.3376542329788208,
-0.422183632850647,
0.1522977352142334,
-0.4961254596710205,
1.0517137050628662,
0.20201928913593292,
-0.41712725162506104,
0.3336975574493408,
0.18366026878356934,
-0.555224597454071,
0.7754437327384949,
-0.9373595118522644,
0.46862804889678955,
0.026595301926136017,
0.23549096286296844,
-1.1719331741333008,
-0.2310384213924408,
0.1045326292514801,
-0.40449270606040955,
-0.18909704685211182,
-0.24739620089530945,
-0.5770577192306519,
-0.14405182003974915,
-0.48139092326164246,
0.5137092471122742,
0.49082151055336,
-0.2193373590707779,
0.5843400955200195,
0.7766240239143372,
-0.344980388879776,
-0.36452972888946533,
-0.2715461552143097,
0.1923009306192398,
-0.19859156012535095,
-0.9151493906974792,
0.21385042369365692,
-0.4555101692676544,
-0.6048023104667664,
-0.28169745206832886,
0.029429905116558075,
0.128620907664299,
0.12784825265407562,
0.29820480942726135,
0.08737891912460327,
-0.005016126669943333,
0.06497545540332794,
-0.07597173750400543,
-0.10461480170488358,
0.08749445527791977,
0.6464098691940308,
0.7512580752372742,
-0.46216854453086853,
-0.4327448904514313,
-0.30537763237953186,
0.2170168161392212,
0.8546042442321777,
-0.3483818471431732,
0.4630337357521057,
0.34285083413124084,
-0.09787973016500473,
-0.03475725278258324,
-0.7876121997833252,
-0.24009425938129425,
-0.5004408955574036,
0.3562301695346832,
-0.2371479570865631,
-0.7599859237670898,
0.6823229789733887,
-0.16163134574890137,
0.12827469408512115,
0.14523498713970184,
0.14518709480762482,
0.01519640814512968,
0.997697651386261,
0.2606240510940552,
-0.13785003125667572,
0.5327000021934509,
0.0026998145040124655,
-0.0023919781669974327,
-0.6875506043434143,
-0.21102657914161682,
-0.35785433650016785,
-0.3605734407901764,
-0.6709830164909363,
-0.7072629928588867,
0.4283379316329956,
-0.34090593457221985,
-0.3748420476913452,
0.2917671799659729,
0.019785946235060692,
0.575275182723999,
0.32278040051460266,
0.03656696528196335,
0.30090850591659546,
-0.28819766640663147,
0.42882826924324036,
0.17326998710632324,
-0.39042171835899353,
-0.5113421678543091,
0.7313324213027954,
0.41602227091789246,
0.8324060440063477,
0.4580172896385193,
0.7159495949745178,
0.7913161516189575,
0.5791220664978027,
-0.7453290224075317,
1.0517220497131348,
-0.07459990680217743,
-0.2887142300605774,
-0.7346528172492981,
-0.3529893159866333,
-0.9985305666923523,
0.07251805812120438,
-0.3640473186969757,
-0.9408050775527954,
-0.008815514855086803,
-0.11705505847930908,
-0.05506782606244087,
-0.29852986335754395,
-0.7294397354125977,
1.066698431968689,
-0.09548647701740265,
-0.6832404136657715,
-0.5428504347801208,
-0.5838730931282043,
0.13312721252441406,
0.39290082454681396,
0.18495090305805206,
-0.3458729386329651,
0.021079689264297485,
0.4474928677082062,
-0.40786129236221313,
0.9404416680335999,
-0.18739432096481323,
0.17457875609397888,
0.19641053676605225,
0.06937815248966217,
0.5957662463188171,
0.24530358612537384,
-0.22186031937599182,
0.41976916790008545,
0.14527837932109833,
-0.2184029221534729,
-0.5007615089416504,
0.8884062767028809,
-0.9981148838996887,
-0.5922990441322327,
-0.45968931913375854,
-0.4828304946422577,
-0.3278060853481293,
-0.0050442717038095,
-0.22020943462848663,
0.3019498586654663,
-1.0516068935394287,
0.4577138125896454,
0.36591747403144836,
-0.11108878254890442,
0.3124074637889862,
0.5108329057693481,
0.060725267976522446,
-0.35205894708633423,
0.7228211164474487,
-0.053311921656131744,
0.38409724831581116,
-0.030922183766961098,
0.1740397959947586,
-0.16080424189567566,
-0.04078185558319092,
-0.1443486362695694,
0.35308125615119934,
-0.5637657642364502,
0.09576660394668579,
-0.6228655576705933,
-0.33294665813446045,
-0.6903285384178162,
0.09500843286514282,
-0.22600658237934113,
-0.06579584628343582,
0.14427053928375244,
0.06205111742019653,
0.26475316286087036,
0.7617731690406799,
-0.05773388221859932,
0.1592595875263214,
-0.5784671306610107,
-0.025466689839959145,
0.6169009208679199,
0.46819955110549927,
-0.07848893851041794,
-0.18149039149284363,
-0.03193643316626549,
-0.3089337944984436,
0.2327156662940979,
-0.7798358201980591,
0.03780970722436905,
0.22209563851356506,
0.9825138449668884,
0.4611694812774658,
0.006751207169145346,
0.46993517875671387,
-0.3413566052913666,
0.6855320334434509,
-0.05909561365842819,
-0.9369051456451416,
0.33852866291999817,
-0.4120452404022217,
0.2612968385219574,
0.902742862701416,
-0.03997845947742462,
-0.8363257646560669,
-0.35854092240333557,
-0.6981137990951538,
-0.6916341781616211,
0.8163431882858276,
0.32882052659988403,
-0.026835618540644646,
-0.18312948942184448,
0.09643290191888809,
0.026666752994060516,
0.18454480171203613,
-0.37312012910842896,
-0.07302135974168777,
-0.03416459262371063,
-0.16653312742710114,
-0.5809685587882996,
-0.17614640295505524,
-0.32536718249320984,
-0.08012072741985321,
0.45802536606788635,
-0.13809160888195038,
0.011436250060796738,
-0.010575395077466965,
-0.22876591980457306,
-0.13890007138252258,
0.29553428292274475,
0.5144023299217224,
0.6805077195167542,
-0.27622178196907043,
0.2728669047355652,
0.2108299732208252,
-0.417691707611084,
-0.0820111334323883,
0.28440752625465393,
0.22145318984985352,
-0.4822867810726166,
0.43653473258018494,
0.37518683075904846,
0.2632332742214203,
-0.8139804005622864,
0.6338078379631042,
-0.3947809040546417,
-0.008157916367053986,
-0.42758071422576904,
0.36559200286865234,
0.05861391872167587,
0.6357734799385071,
0.14528413116931915,
-0.22149944305419922,
0.18983536958694458,
-1.1207047700881958,
0.1463610976934433,
0.7450957298278809,
-0.5976317524909973,
-0.2148166447877884,
0.214385986328125,
0.5464977622032166,
-0.89256751537323,
0.3439778983592987,
-0.07823531329631805,
-0.18517206609249115,
0.799108624458313,
0.22408679127693176,
1.0473743677139282,
-0.4386470913887024,
0.45810720324516296,
0.16992056369781494,
0.6020569801330566,
0.19073598086833954,
0.045169729739427567,
-0.24223995208740234,
-0.5367909669876099,
-0.15842214226722717,
-0.014931399375200272,
-0.6016736030578613,
0.12019428610801697,
-0.34281691908836365,
0.10510145127773285,
-0.476037859916687,
-0.2088085412979126,
-0.02911555767059326,
0.10941517353057861,
-0.7297218441963196,
-0.23513178527355194,
-0.00015191861893981695,
0.6597325801849365,
-0.664446234703064,
0.6766589283943176,
0.6848976016044617,
-0.3692726790904999,
-0.42834171652793884,
0.17562219500541687,
-0.04994748532772064,
-0.8332019448280334,
0.538502037525177,
0.34067460894584656,
-0.35150617361068726,
0.003066564444452524,
-0.6208761930465698,
-0.5523921251296997,
1.2960631847381592,
0.03050401620566845,
-0.21354326605796814,
0.24275684356689453,
0.3508833050727844,
0.6302160620689392,
-0.5339337587356567,
0.798687219619751,
0.5962284803390503,
0.481559157371521,
0.010112443007528782,
-0.8594608306884766,
0.2106107473373413,
-0.9180612564086914,
-0.01838674768805504,
-0.245365172624588,
-1.0320286750793457,
0.6687884330749512,
0.10205801576375961,
-0.23580577969551086,
0.16688644886016846,
0.44774365425109863,
0.35586658120155334,
0.6268898844718933,
0.9545685052871704,
-0.10699117928743362,
0.6501264572143555,
0.08531057834625244,
0.7602192759513855,
-0.4480896294116974,
-0.028762545436620712,
1.0189629793167114,
-0.8237465620040894,
0.5950223207473755,
0.32564616203308105,
0.13532230257987976,
0.3286302089691162,
0.32810351252555847,
0.164894700050354,
0.353255033493042,
0.39612647891044617,
-0.4259970486164093,
-0.34769347310066223,
-0.18411704897880554,
-0.2976295053958893,
0.4432893395423889,
0.4065271317958832,
0.027409516274929047,
0.08763890713453293,
-0.3529798984527588,
-0.17880399525165558,
0.10286995023488998,
-0.12915077805519104,
0.974031388759613,
0.00785213615745306,
-0.9360898733139038,
-0.020981090143322945,
-0.26237839460372925,
0.5082470178604126,
-0.761292576789856,
-0.3093078136444092,
-0.38566744327545166,
0.38378971815109253,
-0.014237649738788605,
-0.6043177247047424,
-0.11204379051923752,
-0.04318100959062576,
0.27434393763542175,
0.052859220653772354,
0.9130757451057434,
-0.2736493647098541,
-0.02346702665090561,
0.771465003490448,
0.5110158920288086,
0.39570990204811096,
0.0726185068488121,
-0.6324273943901062,
0.27945324778556824,
-0.5676640272140503,
0.01881733350455761,
0.32533544301986694,
0.34641653299331665,
-0.10688905417919159,
0.6214374303817749,
0.5584081411361694,
-0.11610306054353714,
-0.2132926732301712,
0.464988112449646,
0.8493976593017578,
-0.42658084630966187,
-0.37842151522636414,
-0.6686012744903564,
0.5289018750190735,
-0.6478310823440552,
-0.43614789843559265,
0.7827545404434204,
0.4499959349632263,
0.529545783996582,
0.22578515112400055,
0.7931086421012878,
-0.041496794670820236,
0.27282455563545227,
0.08705069869756699,
0.8372869491577148,
-0.382795512676239,
0.30504751205444336,
-0.6788190603256226,
-0.8709632158279419,
0.2631373405456543,
0.6549652814865112,
-0.42888718843460083,
0.19311374425888062,
0.5184656977653503,
0.9337252974510193,
-0.06268658488988876,
0.05313323438167572,
0.578142523765564,
0.1628299206495285,
0.4003267288208008,
0.13226421177387238,
1.2251943349838257,
-0.2374511957168579,
0.4746025502681732,
0.1769600510597229,
-0.7155346274375916,
-0.26194334030151367,
-0.671283483505249,
-1.3927428722381592,
-0.31493011116981506,
-0.20323039591312408,
-0.41979649662971497,
0.375217467546463,
1.176139235496521,
0.5619111061096191,
-0.21581785380840302,
-0.7769556045532227,
0.04575403779745102,
0.03353255242109299,
-0.45486488938331604,
-0.23226021230220795,
-0.1393337994813919,
-0.17901678383350372,
-0.7015369534492493,
0.8208562135696411,
0.33745113015174866,
-0.41579556465148926,
-0.5472676157951355,
-0.297387957572937,
-0.35327133536338806,
0.6008892059326172,
0.8924112319946289,
0.37435126304626465,
-0.40249699354171753,
-0.40542057156562805,
0.14437301456928253,
-0.2843921482563019,
-0.14935064315795898,
0.8078534603118896,
-0.37339848279953003,
0.25668224692344666,
0.47094520926475525,
0.2913966178894043,
0.547093391418457,
0.1200713962316513,
0.4576014280319214,
-0.5176827311515808,
0.0007157615036703646,
0.202198326587677,
-0.02029423974454403,
0.2561435103416443,
-0.28955984115600586,
0.804269015789032,
0.1721586287021637,
-0.8098810315132141,
-0.7330049872398376,
0.08289424329996109,
-1.0948245525360107,
0.12313566356897354,
1.2669649124145508,
-0.20201309025287628,
-0.15663264691829681,
-0.07993928343057632,
-0.08774589747190475,
0.2621532380580902,
-0.7576271295547485,
0.8364481329917908,
0.5687720775604248,
0.00860328134149313,
-0.2697244882583618,
-0.3504810631275177,
0.4139179587364197,
0.2611069977283478,
-1.1573662757873535,
0.2027730792760849,
0.5229263305664062,
0.05482770875096321,
0.12519928812980652,
1.1202529668807983,
-0.10323790460824966,
0.18337787687778473,
-0.06357800960540771,
0.11147015541791916,
0.17626768350601196,
-0.29009369015693665,
0.10165151208639145,
-0.0829923003911972,
0.10695739835500717,
0.12957900762557983
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14720v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14720v1
|
Defending Against Indirect Prompt Injection Attacks With Spotlighting
| 2024-03-20T15:26:23 | 2024-03-20T15:26:23 |
Keegan Hines, Gary Lopez, Matthew Hall, Federico Zarfati, Yonatan Zunger, Emre Kiciman
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs), while powerful, are built and trained to
process a single text input. In common applications, multiple inputs can be
processed by concatenating them together into a single stream of text. However,
the LLM is unable to distinguish which sections of prompt belong to various
input sources. Indirect prompt injection attacks take advantage of this
vulnerability by embedding adversarial instructions into untrusted data being
processed alongside user commands. Often, the LLM will mistake the adversarial
instructions as user commands to be followed, creating a security vulnerability
in the larger system. We introduce spotlighting, a family of prompt engineering
techniques that can be used to improve LLMs' ability to distinguish among
multiple sources of input. The key insight is to utilize transformations of an
input to provide a reliable and continuous signal of its provenance. We
evaluate spotlighting as a defense against indirect prompt injection attacks,
and find that it is a robust defense that has minimal detrimental impact to
underlying NLP tasks. Using GPT-family models, we find that spotlighting
reduces the attack success rate from greater than {50}\% to below {2}\% in our
experiments with minimal impact on task efficacy.
|
[
0.00588561687618494,
-0.9305980801582336,
0.764500081539154,
0.4936675727367401,
0.02440130151808262,
0.2009872943162918,
-0.0014394816244021058,
-0.2758754789829254,
-0.24717679619789124,
0.5736613869667053,
-0.4685855209827423,
-0.43837857246398926,
-0.6708019375801086,
0.2971838116645813,
-0.5868669748306274,
0.7086223363876343,
0.09076564759016037,
0.0762682855129242,
0.15212154388427734,
0.12622562050819397,
-0.6353535056114197,
-0.38669753074645996,
-0.9317138195037842,
0.0990065485239029,
0.7219297289848328,
0.3044843077659607,
0.5947932600975037,
0.5489794015884399,
0.5323961973190308,
0.2729337215423584,
-0.14239145815372467,
0.01960817351937294,
-0.35761767625808716,
0.44931191205978394,
-0.1631249636411667,
-0.583552360534668,
0.11713770031929016,
-0.06022146716713905,
0.5505484342575073,
0.6371387839317322,
0.26255109906196594,
-0.10129822790622711,
0.2577982544898987,
0.25264060497283936,
-0.7704716920852661,
-0.15628397464752197,
-0.7913723587989807,
0.07541727274656296,
-0.3757813274860382,
-0.41389143466949463,
-0.807518482208252,
-0.1516692042350769,
-0.010973464697599411,
-0.19486121833324432,
0.20098328590393066,
0.202960804104805,
0.6448702812194824,
0.2691328823566437,
-0.44298890233039856,
-0.08388181775808334,
-0.6626030802726746,
0.5924097895622253,
-0.5268689393997192,
-0.1745293289422989,
0.23578688502311707,
0.39140504598617554,
-0.45698657631874084,
-0.5443941950798035,
-0.25604963302612305,
-0.4359951615333557,
-0.3328344225883484,
0.06339426338672638,
-0.44037890434265137,
0.3962991535663605,
0.50774747133255,
-0.08108779042959213,
-0.648263692855835,
0.3852141797542572,
0.18904973566532135,
-0.1358669549226761,
0.03379154950380325,
0.1455249786376953,
0.5135767459869385,
-0.30285221338272095,
-0.6915916204452515,
-0.10846342891454697,
-1.1760975122451782,
0.12745237350463867,
0.29470527172088623,
0.5380129814147949,
0.20277491211891174,
0.5278041958808899,
-0.011130841448903084,
0.5631929636001587,
0.2395266443490982,
-0.1890314519405365,
-0.34929654002189636,
-0.6126570701599121,
-0.18130798637866974,
0.05094673112034798,
0.7944265604019165,
0.14302611351013184,
-0.2414335161447525,
-0.26045313477516174,
-0.29224252700805664,
-0.13598762452602386,
0.2023145854473114,
-0.850520670413971,
0.1281524896621704,
0.11362241208553314,
-0.2272186279296875,
-0.5835899710655212,
0.20242875814437866,
-0.749152421951294,
-0.7648766040802002,
0.1704786717891693,
0.32521942257881165,
-0.35787564516067505,
0.3657201826572418,
-0.21732498705387115,
-0.28606462478637695,
0.3187623620033264,
0.23779675364494324,
-0.896207332611084,
0.2751637101173401,
0.6247850060462952,
0.918612003326416,
-0.22260527312755585,
-0.22230225801467896,
-1.0610476732254028,
0.4907720685005188,
-0.11692426353693008,
0.7329452633857727,
-0.45926156640052795,
-0.6584282517433167,
0.16720061004161835,
0.1399734914302826,
-0.0756852850317955,
-0.5440687537193298,
0.4759654104709625,
-0.6819033026695251,
-0.004277525003999472,
-0.20079025626182556,
-0.2681642174720764,
0.18406033515930176,
0.05619009584188461,
-0.6007879376411438,
0.7527671456336975,
-0.04052988067269325,
-0.7273117899894714,
0.15360093116760254,
-0.4844566881656647,
-0.4142359495162964,
0.1952526569366455,
-0.23970715701580048,
-0.214802548289299,
0.17374981939792633,
0.6554210186004639,
0.33645057678222656,
-0.1591445654630661,
0.33022168278694153,
-0.27047911286354065,
-0.3343844413757324,
0.1679171621799469,
-0.4969944953918457,
0.929876446723938,
-0.09690826386213303,
-0.49886655807495117,
0.351514995098114,
-0.5745640993118286,
-0.38093602657318115,
0.04439432546496391,
0.0013502419460564852,
-0.3033156991004944,
-0.1713263839483261,
-0.16641369462013245,
-0.11907168477773666,
0.16538171470165253,
-0.45906269550323486,
0.3722604513168335,
-0.6061380505561829,
0.26065999269485474,
0.9471786618232727,
0.3737639784812927,
0.5826731324195862,
-0.08181878924369812,
0.7281880378723145,
0.12100932747125626,
0.3375948369503021,
-0.669230043888092,
-0.50681072473526,
-0.5057404041290283,
-0.3841768801212311,
0.12735497951507568,
0.9631551504135132,
-1.1033239364624023,
0.3787420392036438,
0.0819329023361206,
-0.33309707045555115,
-0.11923225224018097,
0.2619101405143738,
0.29243385791778564,
0.7716497778892517,
0.33404430747032166,
0.31154248118400574,
-0.4375305473804474,
-0.9263501167297363,
-0.3586786687374115,
-0.11997409909963608,
-0.24319101870059967,
0.1537279635667801,
0.2632357180118561,
-0.29406359791755676,
0.8374675512313843,
-0.5203983783721924,
-0.09201622754335403,
-0.27300119400024414,
0.16379351913928986,
0.439373642206192,
0.5362764596939087,
0.8494574427604675,
-0.5684104561805725,
-0.528285801410675,
-0.10993453115224838,
-0.6887378096580505,
-0.5706136226654053,
-0.49705252051353455,
-0.13416913151741028,
-0.30147504806518555,
0.6693977117538452,
-0.6302418112754822,
0.43895870447158813,
0.3058473467826843,
-0.37694013118743896,
0.5506324172019958,
0.12499521672725677,
0.10309591144323349,
-0.8400728702545166,
-0.08044426143169403,
-0.0028110246639698744,
-0.3817472457885742,
-0.7838859558105469,
0.3441932499408722,
0.18031075596809387,
-0.35936492681503296,
-0.5034583806991577,
0.7038838267326355,
-0.5027845501899719,
0.19379845261573792,
-0.324116587638855,
-0.23703856766223907,
0.08698990195989609,
0.12760917842388153,
-0.2803112864494324,
1.0606237649917603,
0.9101890325546265,
-0.4965125024318695,
0.5639593005180359,
0.018173133954405785,
-0.2537805140018463,
0.4906393587589264,
-0.8545710444450378,
0.233425572514534,
0.14477501809597015,
0.18894101679325104,
-1.0735530853271484,
-0.09129699319601059,
0.48875996470451355,
-0.22978711128234863,
0.5894274115562439,
-0.3163782060146332,
-0.7117508053779602,
-0.18022091686725616,
-0.609523594379425,
0.1610245406627655,
0.408458948135376,
-0.9135175347328186,
0.5295687913894653,
-0.05813445523381233,
-0.5409354567527771,
-0.8157221078872681,
-0.5962740182876587,
0.5549220442771912,
-0.40624967217445374,
-0.8253188729286194,
0.6095196008682251,
0.16578851640224457,
-0.20951591432094574,
-0.2246275395154953,
0.11765487492084503,
-0.028706125915050507,
0.3967280983924866,
0.2992652654647827,
0.4897516369819641,
-0.18044604361057281,
-0.0472908690571785,
0.12542158365249634,
-0.23892070353031158,
0.12180301547050476,
-0.22054751217365265,
0.37407997250556946,
0.3737963140010834,
-0.6542037725448608,
-0.5182175636291504,
0.7530989646911621,
0.3592918813228607,
0.18967005610466003,
0.8618795275688171,
0.3993886709213257,
-0.1659005880355835,
-0.21372179687023163,
-0.5367597341537476,
-0.5145734548568726,
-0.5898122191429138,
0.23692792654037476,
-0.18826515972614288,
-0.6523689031600952,
0.5564638376235962,
-0.1762368232011795,
-0.03346272185444832,
0.12027774751186371,
0.16031987965106964,
-0.10631739348173141,
1.2232017517089844,
0.7519934177398682,
-0.10816609859466553,
0.7365405559539795,
0.17878605425357819,
0.09314757585525513,
-0.675700843334198,
0.09371527284383774,
-0.625407338142395,
-0.08765365928411484,
-0.2245137244462967,
-0.2501298785209656,
0.4822356104850769,
0.023177895694971085,
-0.0028065391816198826,
0.2995409667491913,
-0.3656274080276489,
0.5476245284080505,
0.7403892874717712,
0.161361426115036,
0.1513816863298416,
-0.05322227627038956,
0.058389876037836075,
-0.09470100700855255,
-0.5195706486701965,
-0.6043906211853027,
0.9431885480880737,
0.35011136531829834,
0.974199652671814,
0.05158878490328789,
0.6090371608734131,
0.24393509328365326,
0.22374579310417175,
-0.5523548722267151,
0.6445978283882141,
0.020761696621775627,
-0.1339295357465744,
-0.13883280754089355,
-0.5018476247787476,
-0.9537490606307983,
0.1886330246925354,
0.09998368471860886,
-0.6556195616722107,
0.21411101520061493,
-0.09211694449186325,
-0.5747785568237305,
0.28121432662010193,
-0.9231474995613098,
0.590861439704895,
-0.24032063782215118,
-0.3573059141635895,
0.31300538778305054,
-0.6487135291099548,
0.40308767557144165,
-0.05117800831794739,
-0.032286737114191055,
0.2835087776184082,
-0.07857568562030792,
0.5718047618865967,
-0.36621779203414917,
1.1785824298858643,
-0.3034272789955139,
-0.06359750032424927,
0.08866188675165176,
0.12272430956363678,
0.8903363943099976,
0.4890126585960388,
0.22014549374580383,
-0.1389595866203308,
-0.38573962450027466,
-0.36009830236434937,
-0.785794734954834,
0.7534923553466797,
-0.3781476616859436,
-1.2153739929199219,
-0.4105142056941986,
-0.2969372272491455,
-0.1584549993276596,
0.13818654417991638,
0.30151453614234924,
0.3588750958442688,
-0.24352432787418365,
-0.03763377666473389,
0.8227860331535339,
-0.43729934096336365,
0.6741117238998413,
0.4159452021121979,
-0.15758010745048523,
-0.28506141901016235,
0.597610354423523,
-0.06300993263721466,
0.3686205744743347,
0.47613340616226196,
0.050687383860349655,
-0.08487524092197418,
-0.7611087560653687,
-0.4713205099105835,
0.17639315128326416,
-0.7823330163955688,
-0.4852197766304016,
-0.698573887348175,
-0.020016880705952644,
-0.7196919322013855,
-0.304494172334671,
0.07422369718551636,
-0.25014784932136536,
-0.3443295955657959,
-0.19067439436912537,
0.17173878848552704,
0.49033886194229126,
0.13956451416015625,
0.6227390766143799,
-0.7363814115524292,
0.3488403260707855,
0.6946253180503845,
-0.1528320163488388,
-0.2917240560054779,
-0.5466554164886475,
0.12372571229934692,
-0.2830072045326233,
-0.321416974067688,
-1.2884612083435059,
0.4515799880027771,
-0.08386650681495667,
0.40961286425590515,
0.46721479296684265,
-0.010474479757249355,
0.345804899930954,
-0.8022118806838989,
0.8444925546646118,
0.1406567096710205,
-0.9600620269775391,
0.8776418566703796,
-0.2606719434261322,
0.5830943584442139,
0.5400227904319763,
0.06311294436454773,
-0.4271853268146515,
-0.67022705078125,
-0.27799123525619507,
-0.8494530320167542,
0.5888290405273438,
0.09247676283121109,
0.11191751807928085,
-0.06429875642061234,
0.2415735274553299,
0.0132192587479949,
0.09103334695100784,
-0.6689112186431885,
-0.3302101194858551,
0.012912833131849766,
0.04645057022571564,
0.1906406283378601,
-0.48218879103660583,
-0.47393593192100525,
0.05727222189307213,
0.3957296907901764,
-0.09912826865911484,
0.14475776255130768,
0.019217880442738533,
-0.06417162716388702,
0.2547363042831421,
0.3143226206302643,
0.5185405611991882,
0.25620266795158386,
-0.06728910654783249,
0.5046003460884094,
0.09491922706365585,
-0.48678866028785706,
0.3086467683315277,
0.1777908056974411,
-0.5280011892318726,
0.22936846315860748,
0.5306529402732849,
0.581226646900177,
0.3358127474784851,
-0.4469800591468811,
0.7656880617141724,
-0.08316575735807419,
0.44391053915023804,
-0.0408763661980629,
-0.0013026180677115917,
-0.1216505616903305,
0.004915978293865919,
0.6062827706336975,
0.2974146604537964,
0.2401280254125595,
-0.38461175560951233,
0.021501591429114342,
0.5021659135818481,
-0.3450475335121155,
-0.2732965052127838,
0.4004557430744171,
0.3051605224609375,
-0.08512789011001587,
0.32899904251098633,
-0.052188221365213394,
-0.46157699823379517,
0.8371726870536804,
0.6722849011421204,
1.0617326498031616,
-0.5068883299827576,
0.01073402725160122,
0.2338271588087082,
0.630017101764679,
0.054917752742767334,
-0.17823638021945953,
0.18321992456912994,
-0.4144895672798157,
-0.3817996382713318,
-0.15414880216121674,
-0.5140827894210815,
0.05096879228949547,
-0.3591275215148926,
0.3897991478443146,
-0.5730072259902954,
-0.0645708218216896,
-0.08457347005605698,
-0.6413935422897339,
-0.547015905380249,
-0.35282841324806213,
0.08350023627281189,
0.8892727494239807,
-0.774837076663971,
0.5105019211769104,
0.3357399106025696,
-0.2729417681694031,
-0.3660340905189514,
0.0506790466606617,
0.1756930649280548,
-0.7141073942184448,
0.9918811321258545,
0.45567500591278076,
-0.18361899256706238,
-0.21865864098072052,
-0.8919399976730347,
-0.8263667225837708,
0.829557478427887,
0.5861563682556152,
-0.29560792446136475,
-0.20389848947525024,
0.06165356934070587,
0.07051479816436768,
-0.2877468764781952,
0.3729375898838043,
0.3788702189922333,
0.5519519448280334,
-0.08045803755521774,
-0.6680847406387329,
0.3740752935409546,
0.02988993190228939,
0.15128083527088165,
-0.02325846254825592,
-0.21968767046928406,
0.7018417119979858,
-0.1991536170244217,
-0.7588611245155334,
0.08714666217565536,
0.624243438243866,
0.2293078750371933,
0.1773887574672699,
0.3630911409854889,
0.23591658473014832,
0.6498687267303467,
-0.22246408462524414,
1.2172054052352905,
-0.08833114057779312,
-0.1738886684179306,
1.038924217224121,
-0.49705633521080017,
0.4287159740924835,
0.6577527523040771,
-0.06217436492443085,
0.2484084665775299,
0.18533775210380554,
-0.10070086270570755,
0.735365629196167,
0.10738208144903183,
-0.5138867497444153,
0.10951285064220428,
-0.32315191626548767,
-0.38962322473526,
0.16800713539123535,
0.30686524510383606,
-0.4409298002719879,
-0.3173011541366577,
0.420587420463562,
0.250903844833374,
0.03239285200834274,
-0.23884379863739014,
0.8248365521430969,
0.06684032827615738,
-0.4711456000804901,
0.3063766062259674,
0.012199758552014828,
0.8194433450698853,
-0.8012411594390869,
-0.014817376621067524,
-0.22425858676433563,
-0.13223274052143097,
-0.06831321120262146,
-0.5975773930549622,
0.05635721981525421,
0.07884163409471512,
-0.3377254605293274,
-0.4336588382720947,
0.8196902275085449,
-0.08871107548475266,
-0.25080370903015137,
0.32384198904037476,
0.3230191469192505,
-0.38157474994659424,
-0.19484709203243256,
-0.4785798192024231,
-0.09276270866394043,
-0.09529512375593185,
-0.3563498258590698,
0.408661425113678,
0.29592135548591614,
0.2399868220090866,
0.6730632781982422,
0.7091416716575623,
0.18964093923568726,
0.20260444283485413,
0.3135838210582733,
0.9226612448692322,
-0.7471989989280701,
-0.4366535544395447,
-1.2537901401519775,
0.17606161534786224,
-0.39841604232788086,
-0.0038493822794407606,
1.1311817169189453,
0.3019392490386963,
0.3245585858821869,
-0.13675695657730103,
0.8008444905281067,
0.3676067888736725,
0.39961478114128113,
-0.6592677235603333,
0.4770929217338562,
0.2733563184738159,
0.5461504459381104,
-0.20920006930828094,
-0.7132361531257629,
-0.5508956909179688,
0.03837066888809204,
-0.28817734122276306,
-0.12924495339393616,
0.8300653696060181,
0.9038214087486267,
0.18035809695720673,
-0.07234129309654236,
0.31995055079460144,
0.24482057988643646,
0.7462498545646667,
0.524644672870636,
1.143964409828186,
-0.2047305405139923,
0.534497082233429,
-0.2432711124420166,
-0.5091755390167236,
-0.08118220418691635,
-0.9333354234695435,
-1.010339617729187,
-0.04679155349731445,
-0.22145213186740875,
-0.26297998428344727,
0.1081114411354065,
0.5238038897514343,
0.6068159341812134,
-0.8469581007957458,
0.046662066131830215,
-0.18073828518390656,
0.3523581922054291,
-0.26637741923332214,
-0.3049676716327667,
0.3183085024356842,
-0.6039597392082214,
-0.5982438325881958,
0.9768360257148743,
0.49873027205467224,
0.19091033935546875,
-0.4566258490085602,
0.5525606870651245,
-0.04616004601120949,
0.1003350242972374,
0.3512503504753113,
0.3544684946537018,
-0.7416785955429077,
-0.43459352850914,
0.13606931269168854,
-0.42013677954673767,
-0.06087126210331917,
0.7946507930755615,
-0.9322682023048401,
0.2924576699733734,
0.5064972043037415,
0.9059101343154907,
-0.049218107014894485,
-0.08485183864831924,
0.6914570927619934,
-1.051471471786499,
0.17416119575500488,
0.2603163719177246,
0.5072608590126038,
0.3786109685897827,
-0.7644298076629639,
0.3881610333919525,
0.21132522821426392,
-0.5014821290969849,
-1.0855752229690552,
0.47369512915611267,
-0.9735376238822937,
-0.3140467405319214,
1.1765042543411255,
-0.20469346642494202,
-0.3122756779193878,
-0.21693101525306702,
-0.5016640424728394,
-0.08583572506904602,
-0.5574389696121216,
0.6401851773262024,
0.5713468790054321,
0.0463082529604435,
-0.19746516644954681,
-0.5123672485351562,
0.5976476669311523,
0.605449378490448,
-0.8451682925224304,
0.10240133106708527,
0.2556648254394531,
-0.11811286211013794,
0.3527334928512573,
0.18706420063972473,
-0.050821054726839066,
0.355947881937027,
-0.050484493374824524,
-0.33901599049568176,
-0.029313035309314728,
-0.3698594868183136,
-0.7095677852630615,
0.5344900488853455,
-0.03562504053115845,
-0.19653482735157013
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13666v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13666v1
|
Grounding Spatial Relations in Text-Only Language Models
| 2024-03-20T15:20:30 | 2024-03-20T15:20:30 |
Gorka Azkune, Ander Salaberria, Eneko Agirre
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper shows that text-only Language Models (LM) can learn to ground
spatial relations like "left of" or "below" if they are provided with explicit
location information of objects and they are properly trained to leverage those
locations. We perform experiments on a verbalized version of the Visual Spatial
Reasoning (VSR) dataset, where images are coupled with textual statements which
contain real or fake spatial relations between two objects of the image. We
verbalize the images using an off-the-shelf object detector, adding location
tokens to every object label to represent their bounding boxes in textual form.
Given the small size of VSR, we do not observe any improvement when using
locations, but pretraining the LM over a synthetic dataset automatically
derived by us improves results significantly when using location tokens. We
thus show that locations allow LMs to ground spatial relations, with our
text-only LMs outperforming Vision-and-Language Models and setting the new
state-of-the-art for the VSR dataset. Our analysis show that our text-only LMs
can generalize beyond the relations seen in the synthetic dataset to some
extent, learning also more useful information than that encoded in the spatial
rules we used to create the synthetic dataset itself.
|
[
-0.16579732298851013,
-0.8954386711120605,
1.092238187789917,
-0.0005477536469697952,
-0.30611151456832886,
-0.28335633873939514,
-0.4361858069896698,
-0.5472978353500366,
0.02419121190905571,
0.7486685514450073,
-0.3185935616493225,
-0.800069272518158,
-0.3830951154232025,
-0.1289830207824707,
-0.4156913459300995,
0.6251202821731567,
0.030441736802458763,
-0.005733412690460682,
-0.5647299289703369,
-0.4130883514881134,
-0.4811933636665344,
-0.9415011405944824,
-0.27484768629074097,
-0.4083506762981415,
0.4154700040817261,
0.2621079385280609,
1.0153403282165527,
0.9728162884712219,
0.5185599327087402,
0.3033575415611267,
-0.052449148148298264,
0.15003658831119537,
-0.31820499897003174,
-0.07968593388795853,
-0.39384713768959045,
-0.3710770606994629,
-0.007004015613347292,
-0.06712700426578522,
0.6211098432540894,
0.8810587525367737,
0.15801319479942322,
-0.24408307671546936,
-0.5501710176467896,
0.7008239030838013,
-0.4274151623249054,
0.2945050299167633,
-0.658089280128479,
0.33369889855384827,
-0.0028370171785354614,
-0.24782511591911316,
-0.4335113763809204,
-0.2678702771663666,
0.29046905040740967,
-0.7294798493385315,
0.2760835289955139,
0.10038525611162186,
1.2864974737167358,
0.21861955523490906,
-0.49469730257987976,
-0.040348656475543976,
-0.8549239039421082,
0.6664694547653198,
-0.210675448179245,
0.6575112342834473,
0.7413218021392822,
0.41355714201927185,
0.016335686668753624,
-0.4548214077949524,
-0.5420759916305542,
-0.46684521436691284,
-0.4585491418838501,
0.11327269673347473,
0.07383651286363602,
-0.07390059530735016,
0.5248109102249146,
-0.0447247214615345,
-0.4004066586494446,
-0.2715294361114502,
-0.36424997448921204,
0.30969953536987305,
0.42822936177253723,
-0.25369006395339966,
0.5165714621543884,
-0.16881564259529114,
-0.48078712821006775,
-0.270129919052124,
-0.9208149313926697,
-0.0474361777305603,
-0.22988328337669373,
0.3997495174407959,
-0.0785904973745346,
0.8606637120246887,
0.15256990492343903,
0.6477864384651184,
0.06884776800870895,
0.13535289466381073,
0.21657705307006836,
-0.34890803694725037,
-0.31858253479003906,
-0.07128237932920456,
0.7329260110855103,
0.3097200095653534,
0.6150593757629395,
-0.3215816617012024,
-0.25080567598342896,
0.178057461977005,
0.14122888445854187,
-0.2613907754421234,
-0.3186902105808258,
-0.061891354620456696,
-0.3653796315193176,
-0.18748533725738525,
0.13088226318359375,
-0.24831649661064148,
-0.44764426350593567,
-0.6048873662948608,
0.15129293501377106,
-0.3289833962917328,
-0.4006965160369873,
0.018931463360786438,
-0.13459496200084686,
0.39094167947769165,
0.08599769324064255,
-0.7798047065734863,
0.4156014323234558,
0.5108044147491455,
0.6139454245567322,
0.16359765827655792,
-0.6501210927963257,
-0.340240478515625,
0.33376288414001465,
-0.6176435351371765,
1.1490103006362915,
-0.5786043405532837,
-0.3109450340270996,
0.08401814103126526,
-0.09097782522439957,
0.016524987295269966,
-0.5827353596687317,
0.4328834116458893,
-0.5341586470603943,
0.13089779019355774,
-0.5765694975852966,
-0.283882200717926,
0.07667024433612823,
0.29752305150032043,
-0.6296674609184265,
1.4760030508041382,
-0.1205693855881691,
-0.7735024094581604,
0.4424887001514435,
-0.43376803398132324,
-0.5742893218994141,
-0.20287053287029266,
-0.5660953521728516,
-0.28322485089302063,
0.1993701159954071,
0.44663557410240173,
0.357628732919693,
0.30072447657585144,
0.689185380935669,
-0.3381820321083069,
-0.3911222815513611,
0.2817126214504242,
0.0987187996506691,
0.38350099325180054,
-0.045475710183382034,
-0.282681941986084,
0.16104772686958313,
-0.8921977877616882,
0.04670032486319542,
0.32567286491394043,
-0.10730228573083878,
-0.7124685645103455,
0.40607118606567383,
-0.03999421373009682,
0.38933679461479187,
0.13017778098583221,
-0.36237940192222595,
0.05000218376517296,
-0.5313105583190918,
0.08574826270341873,
0.46923384070396423,
-0.33293160796165466,
1.3024706840515137,
0.06813660264015198,
0.1847628355026245,
0.03856973722577095,
-0.25591012835502625,
-0.3756062388420105,
-0.300094336271286,
-0.7611907124519348,
-0.13179463148117065,
-0.11950656026601791,
0.6814894080162048,
-0.7425803542137146,
0.5898187160491943,
-0.599468469619751,
-0.3661772310733795,
0.07654367387294769,
-0.26394230127334595,
0.4355399012565613,
0.6765311360359192,
0.32845064997673035,
0.2578445374965668,
-0.8796262741088867,
-0.820501446723938,
-0.2541886866092682,
-0.20430535078048706,
0.09090862423181534,
0.5869433283805847,
0.46724098920822144,
-0.06702741980552673,
1.3507376909255981,
-0.5182126760482788,
-0.15572163462638855,
-0.2294112741947174,
-0.22563090920448303,
0.08569913357496262,
0.24576646089553833,
0.6879398226737976,
-0.9217995405197144,
-0.4021773934364319,
0.10882000625133514,
-1.200493335723877,
-0.23961664736270905,
0.00009211049473378807,
-0.35599285364151,
0.12887200713157654,
0.661979615688324,
-0.8737304210662842,
0.65976881980896,
0.43431729078292847,
-0.6466698050498962,
0.3008388578891754,
-0.34951573610305786,
-0.11704010516405106,
-0.7110772728919983,
-0.03103700280189514,
0.14604327082633972,
-0.42515286803245544,
-0.7822390198707581,
0.1614072173833847,
0.06607168912887573,
-0.6680303812026978,
-0.39777734875679016,
0.888479471206665,
-0.5463151335716248,
-0.4542291462421417,
-0.27794596552848816,
0.46628499031066895,
0.059983011335134506,
0.5226724743843079,
0.970757246017456,
0.6324008703231812,
0.5841144323348999,
-0.6407967209815979,
0.0956723615527153,
0.4204888343811035,
-0.2891044616699219,
0.23528699576854706,
-0.6595657467842102,
0.14466509222984314,
-0.48746228218078613,
0.41878148913383484,
-1.0162551403045654,
-0.0019678338430821896,
0.24497383832931519,
-0.3893262445926666,
-0.02447846345603466,
-0.27491065859794617,
-0.5230845808982849,
-0.10508237779140472,
0.09797102957963943,
0.2981070876121521,
0.36606767773628235,
-0.7237216234207153,
0.6220061779022217,
0.3534044623374939,
0.2473207712173462,
-0.46591103076934814,
-1.0805997848510742,
0.13357242941856384,
-0.1380923092365265,
-0.5872600078582764,
0.09272116422653198,
0.20031020045280457,
-0.43481430411338806,
0.25929537415504456,
-0.059625111520290375,
-0.4143916368484497,
0.008003116585314274,
0.4120276868343353,
0.10494579374790192,
-0.2162465751171112,
0.4242425262928009,
-0.3123650550842285,
-0.36475950479507446,
0.06074918806552887,
-0.37609097361564636,
0.259121835231781,
0.013269258663058281,
-0.29624900221824646,
-0.14169451594352722,
0.41559216380119324,
0.4314939081668854,
-0.2521340250968933,
0.969242513179779,
0.018296819180250168,
-0.6766403913497925,
-0.057750582695007324,
-0.29105344414711,
-0.1895972192287445,
-0.4291574954986572,
0.3827224671840668,
-0.7722915410995483,
-0.5723223090171814,
0.39101970195770264,
0.10200148820877075,
-0.22755098342895508,
0.14908352494239807,
0.09794110059738159,
-0.2926942706108093,
0.8729785084724426,
0.8497733473777771,
0.032970789819955826,
0.5077375769615173,
-0.13375341892242432,
0.49335840344429016,
-0.41367557644844055,
-0.40736377239227295,
-0.5323730111122131,
-0.09295248240232468,
-0.37676751613616943,
-0.4986805021762848,
0.09499087929725647,
0.1986859291791916,
-0.2953254282474518,
0.3570827543735504,
-0.3591027855873108,
1.056875467300415,
0.493455708026886,
0.1882440447807312,
0.023400086909532547,
0.5156473517417908,
-0.32044336199760437,
-0.4161008298397064,
-0.7492623925209045,
-0.5216581225395203,
0.6874484419822693,
0.296505331993103,
0.4697982370853424,
-0.19691604375839233,
0.38738811016082764,
-0.06292636692523956,
0.04513745754957199,
-0.7937392592430115,
0.6810004711151123,
-0.27793267369270325,
-0.4186291992664337,
-0.22052012383937836,
-0.4189271926879883,
-0.7928172945976257,
0.46915075182914734,
-0.2382587492465973,
-0.4109898507595062,
0.07270228117704391,
0.08074519038200378,
0.0944235771894455,
0.36714884638786316,
-0.6521207690238953,
0.7959980368614197,
-0.5584971904754639,
-0.30739209055900574,
0.27625343203544617,
-0.636156439781189,
-0.07435286045074463,
0.17571517825126648,
0.46494272351264954,
-0.039362695068120956,
0.1093738004565239,
0.4747468829154968,
-0.3562537133693695,
0.854033350944519,
-0.37825778126716614,
-0.2521457374095917,
0.1821223795413971,
0.059292931109666824,
0.42396342754364014,
-0.12516306340694427,
0.1812705099582672,
0.32449108362197876,
-0.34114354848861694,
-0.41395309567451477,
-0.7969391942024231,
0.6872408390045166,
-0.9330753684043884,
-0.3462884724140167,
-0.5086086392402649,
-0.40767914056777954,
-0.13728871941566467,
0.4614487290382385,
0.24319477379322052,
0.4322517216205597,
-0.19346028566360474,
0.04186460003256798,
0.851664662361145,
-0.20742113888263702,
0.12232547998428345,
0.4427197277545929,
-0.5899298787117004,
-0.40265533328056335,
0.63420170545578,
0.0703669935464859,
-0.18002557754516602,
0.8098021745681763,
0.2435157597064972,
-0.7239876389503479,
-0.11997842788696289,
-0.18773823976516724,
0.4069390296936035,
-0.9658055901527405,
0.09170866012573242,
-0.6797022223472595,
-0.0840635821223259,
-0.18699678778648376,
-0.4893679618835449,
-0.37119239568710327,
-0.4750898480415344,
-0.28971973061561584,
-0.46954312920570374,
0.15126797556877136,
0.6776151061058044,
0.08461245149374008,
0.1289256066083908,
-0.8439021706581116,
0.5152842402458191,
0.0663202553987503,
0.2725900411605835,
-0.29593485593795776,
-0.3687816858291626,
-0.1881115436553955,
0.2155042290687561,
0.19771677255630493,
-0.8432648777961731,
0.26833850145339966,
0.11142116039991379,
0.38355752825737,
0.2672899067401886,
-0.20506002008914948,
1.029374599456787,
-0.8898373246192932,
0.7611392140388489,
0.08179108798503876,
-0.7990747690200806,
0.7571779489517212,
-0.6331884264945984,
0.4042835235595703,
0.26089414954185486,
0.04505937919020653,
-0.4141358435153961,
-0.2675345242023468,
-0.48750755190849304,
-0.7640776634216309,
0.5356318950653076,
0.27354294061660767,
0.3353361189365387,
-0.30763813853263855,
0.601659893989563,
-0.35130637884140015,
0.08708764612674713,
-1.3151180744171143,
-0.3734835684299469,
-0.2518891990184784,
-0.222085639834404,
-0.1937679797410965,
-0.4972075819969177,
-0.23036174476146698,
-0.3972589671611786,
0.3537783920764923,
0.005037675611674786,
0.37545207142829895,
0.39230942726135254,
-0.3341411352157593,
-0.16287443041801453,
0.09784190356731415,
0.5450850129127502,
0.8699308037757874,
0.027713730931282043,
0.5591179132461548,
0.08720964938402176,
0.026896104216575623,
0.308361679315567,
-0.09053027629852295,
-0.4420211613178253,
0.2637234330177307,
0.38606590032577515,
0.8727668523788452,
0.5952860116958618,
-0.6778033971786499,
0.6465770602226257,
0.004496258217841387,
-0.26750847697257996,
-0.43765389919281006,
-0.362813264131546,
-0.014150653034448624,
0.23322251439094543,
0.31019163131713867,
0.21472807228565216,
-0.27892398834228516,
-0.45308825373649597,
0.24588808417320251,
0.3509927988052368,
-0.40031570196151733,
-0.4008401036262512,
0.6655711531639099,
-0.0562555268406868,
-0.06169639527797699,
0.5522202849388123,
-0.027358712628483772,
-0.6613173484802246,
0.6806974411010742,
0.8170017600059509,
0.6453429460525513,
0.2549724876880646,
0.2105206549167633,
0.5295114517211914,
0.43091827630996704,
-0.22667242586612701,
0.18663622438907623,
-0.23243647813796997,
-1.0353972911834717,
-0.4069453477859497,
-0.2567429840564728,
-0.16172826290130615,
0.13109642267227173,
-0.4615788459777832,
0.3917747735977173,
-0.5488125681877136,
-0.07683537900447845,
-0.5513947606086731,
-0.2136712670326233,
-0.45328542590141296,
0.4550584554672241,
0.42749130725860596,
0.8002808690071106,
-1.0426974296569824,
0.7316656112670898,
1.393170714378357,
-0.17779475450515747,
-0.6288745403289795,
-0.2351905107498169,
-0.48125001788139343,
-0.6418003439903259,
1.0143617391586304,
0.29903218150138855,
-0.2244376540184021,
-0.29297935962677,
-0.869196891784668,
-1.0477286577224731,
0.7469791769981384,
0.4368557929992676,
-0.4990011155605316,
-0.009495185688138008,
0.25522443652153015,
0.7668587565422058,
-0.14398761093616486,
0.11235503107309341,
0.26397770643234253,
0.34878408908843994,
0.11526545882225037,
-0.572367787361145,
-0.0635056123137474,
-0.2656065821647644,
0.18578660488128662,
0.2340017706155777,
-0.4094838798046112,
0.65152508020401,
-0.23279999196529388,
-0.5513613224029541,
0.08070382475852966,
0.7517470121383667,
0.6148408055305481,
0.43375468254089355,
0.24356351792812347,
0.9081306457519531,
0.6716831922531128,
-0.26269006729125977,
1.0420219898223877,
-0.03626358136534691,
0.3616380989551544,
1.342885971069336,
-0.4540570378303528,
0.8579227328300476,
0.5221620202064514,
0.14821001887321472,
0.5003564357757568,
0.41887739300727844,
0.04892633482813835,
0.8494910001754761,
0.072054922580719,
-0.03070174902677536,
-0.3492107391357422,
-0.10443759709596634,
-0.38491255044937134,
0.2512211799621582,
0.13812270760536194,
-0.3611741364002228,
-0.39209312200546265,
0.06223281845450401,
0.04477176442742348,
0.6337894797325134,
-0.19816873967647552,
0.802107572555542,
0.07524462789297104,
-0.44666144251823425,
0.4531453251838684,
0.06499341875314713,
0.24116696417331696,
-0.637910783290863,
-0.03761059418320656,
-0.16262121498584747,
0.10975058376789093,
-0.26041659712791443,
-0.7636494040489197,
0.35971611738204956,
0.06622523069381714,
-0.48929110169410706,
-0.5693718194961548,
1.1438065767288208,
-0.6454721689224243,
-0.4872733950614929,
0.4158823788166046,
0.4253275394439697,
0.07740139216184616,
-0.13320182263851166,
-0.46762892603874207,
-0.016091445460915565,
-0.24583075940608978,
-0.1054481714963913,
0.19899806380271912,
0.7657016515731812,
-0.21326680481433868,
0.6811305284500122,
0.9115421772003174,
0.25064799189567566,
0.14842489361763,
0.11208309978246689,
0.7788547277450562,
-0.95720374584198,
-0.5512708425521851,
-0.7997761368751526,
0.37587353587150574,
-0.03292195126414299,
0.18973833322525024,
0.7620104551315308,
0.4467392861843109,
0.8466101288795471,
-0.2684130072593689,
0.8273105025291443,
0.21345503628253937,
0.2341737151145935,
-0.7438684105873108,
0.5378841757774353,
-0.407254695892334,
0.10654666274785995,
-0.03254926577210426,
-1.1237283945083618,
-0.6957027912139893,
1.2506046295166016,
-0.595562219619751,
-0.04781971126794815,
0.9602636694908142,
0.43178242444992065,
-0.1869579553604126,
-0.39537814259529114,
0.5622355341911316,
0.16332541406154633,
0.17571672797203064,
0.4221739172935486,
1.173330545425415,
-0.5748144388198853,
0.33892741799354553,
-0.3364887237548828,
-0.005420016590505838,
0.39179864525794983,
-0.9917734861373901,
-1.1203858852386475,
-0.3817106783390045,
-0.2168719619512558,
-0.1804068386554718,
0.030052248388528824,
0.6568635702133179,
0.7347663640975952,
-0.5743759870529175,
-0.16136449575424194,
-0.42649123072624207,
0.055182818323373795,
0.22670476138591766,
-0.21719704568386078,
0.3417344093322754,
-0.10795523226261139,
-0.5533101558685303,
0.551546573638916,
0.28241926431655884,
0.2918289005756378,
0.11656355857849121,
-0.06451718509197235,
-0.18898019194602966,
-0.010010972619056702,
0.7887095212936401,
0.28960898518562317,
-0.6627753973007202,
-0.45527148246765137,
0.17718258500099182,
-0.31921109557151794,
0.22593067586421967,
0.8892548680305481,
-0.9383373260498047,
0.3246704041957855,
0.34987539052963257,
0.40424877405166626,
0.28628402948379517,
0.16371439397335052,
0.4782470464706421,
-1.174497365951538,
0.678070068359375,
-0.036025747656822205,
0.530859649181366,
0.5291582345962524,
-0.33721888065338135,
0.4040514826774597,
0.2850961685180664,
-0.3927607834339142,
-0.5795289278030396,
0.2739253640174866,
-0.6068079471588135,
-0.1812296062707901,
1.3962665796279907,
-0.06760767847299576,
-0.4135555624961853,
0.14039690792560577,
-0.3335263133049011,
0.12781769037246704,
-0.13135352730751038,
0.5318518877029419,
0.7416658401489258,
0.32265400886535645,
-0.31588318943977356,
-0.20555400848388672,
0.39276787638664246,
0.46516481041908264,
-0.7683855891227722,
0.0025485868100076914,
0.7677841186523438,
0.21896281838417053,
0.18843460083007812,
0.9213464260101318,
-0.09583636373281479,
0.07066001743078232,
-0.18118438124656677,
-0.057522788643836975,
-0.03770192712545395,
-0.6793891191482544,
-0.34166258573532104,
-0.023022806271910667,
-0.11951691657304764,
-0.1103861853480339
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13638v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13638v2
|
Do Not Worry if You Do Not Have Data: Building Pretrained Language Models Using Translationese
| 2024-03-20T14:41:01 | 2024-03-21T04:03:59 |
Meet Doshi, Raj Dabre, Pushpak Bhattacharyya
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we explore the utility of Translationese as synthetic data
created using machine translation for pre-training language models (LMs).
Pre-training requires vast amounts of monolingual data, which is mostly
unavailable for languages other than English. Recently, there has been a
growing interest in using synthetic data to address this data scarcity. We take
the case of English and Indic languages and translate web-crawled monolingual
documents (clean) into the target language. Then, we train language models
containing 28M and 85M parameters on this translationese data (synthetic). We
show that their performance on downstream natural language understanding and
generative tasks is only 3.56% poorer on NLU tasks and 1.51% on NLG tasks than
LMs pre-trained on clean data. Further, we propose the use of lightweight
TinyLMs pre-trained on clean data to filter synthetic data efficiently which
significantly improves the performance of our models. We also find that LMs
trained on synthetic data strongly benefit from extended pretraining on a tiny
fraction (10%) of clean data. We release the data we collected and created as a
part of this work, IndicMonoDoc, the largest collection of monolingual
document-level corpora, which we hope will help bridge the gap between English
and non-English performance for large language models.
|
[
-0.4359467625617981,
-0.40356501936912537,
0.41189733147621155,
0.06885326653718948,
-0.3979528844356537,
0.15334759652614594,
-0.4477846324443817,
-0.506713330745697,
0.4311922490596771,
0.7341218590736389,
-0.7724887728691101,
-0.5781199932098389,
-0.4345667362213135,
0.4677838087081909,
-0.580928385257721,
0.9516358375549316,
-0.03659410774707794,
0.29854369163513184,
-0.21993853151798248,
-0.25360551476478577,
-0.11557912826538086,
-0.4518911838531494,
-0.7456855773925781,
-0.3253061771392822,
0.4050024151802063,
0.36121058464050293,
0.48550108075141907,
0.5776455998420715,
0.12497054040431976,
0.27869826555252075,
0.2878313958644867,
0.39384716749191284,
-0.6349355578422546,
-0.18980643153190613,
-0.14670740067958832,
-0.7055831551551819,
-0.37269866466522217,
0.14196020364761353,
0.4085622727870941,
0.9163315296173096,
0.05581686273217201,
0.2793336510658264,
-0.05969605594873428,
0.5837555527687073,
-0.3756534457206726,
0.022129984572529793,
-0.7891752123832703,
0.22742290794849396,
-0.436554878950119,
-0.10458345711231232,
-0.4119627773761749,
-0.27591127157211304,
-0.15653593838214874,
-0.934248685836792,
0.5303224325180054,
0.18747040629386902,
0.7791654467582703,
0.33922621607780457,
-0.4183036684989929,
-0.1455996185541153,
-0.8479025363922119,
0.8016022443771362,
-0.7695390582084656,
0.4237179458141327,
0.6161913871765137,
0.16421319544315338,
-0.12545588612556458,
-0.813395082950592,
-0.6969825625419617,
-0.2806957960128784,
-0.32034558057785034,
0.24427483975887299,
0.22164396941661835,
-0.03613540902733803,
0.1574387103319168,
0.6071203947067261,
-0.8624352216720581,
0.335296630859375,
-0.6213146448135376,
-0.052416883409023285,
0.5930737257003784,
0.058150727301836014,
0.4340563714504242,
0.09855365753173828,
-0.10122167319059372,
-0.30770450830459595,
-0.9620222449302673,
-0.2893570065498352,
0.5987261533737183,
0.5397367477416992,
-0.3803793489933014,
0.6307660937309265,
0.01780213788151741,
0.5757274627685547,
-0.21908845007419586,
-0.01455007866024971,
0.34687483310699463,
-0.6113550662994385,
-0.1172897219657898,
0.0859828069806099,
1.0289877653121948,
-0.2108696550130844,
0.6172826886177063,
-0.2586955726146698,
-0.2769615650177002,
0.1579490453004837,
0.40093234181404114,
-0.7846097946166992,
-0.21342457830905914,
0.10716573148965836,
-0.17828379571437836,
-0.19860930740833282,
-0.16881293058395386,
-0.6362518668174744,
-0.07651768624782562,
-0.626314103603363,
0.23224733769893646,
-0.4895070195198059,
-0.3313106596469879,
0.15870928764343262,
-0.03546629473567009,
-0.17180600762367249,
0.2193015068769455,
-0.8078650832176208,
0.4178769588470459,
0.2804635465145111,
0.6221497654914856,
-0.11737343668937683,
-0.3165193796157837,
-0.32839101552963257,
-0.03249068185687065,
-0.7320383191108704,
0.459747314453125,
-0.218919038772583,
-0.5816161036491394,
0.04732653498649597,
0.17020148038864136,
-0.1598740667104721,
-0.7580675482749939,
0.41663122177124023,
-0.27622899413108826,
0.3768593966960907,
0.3118574321269989,
-0.5720201730728149,
-0.0003759135433938354,
0.12284445017576218,
-1.0472131967544556,
0.8735653758049011,
0.13031966984272003,
-0.6579580903053284,
0.25806841254234314,
-0.7047404646873474,
-0.8550195097923279,
0.12479047477245331,
-0.05248160660266876,
-0.027702318504452705,
0.35092175006866455,
0.15698513388633728,
-0.0200920719653368,
-0.29159995913505554,
0.1739649623632431,
-0.22658835351467133,
-0.2282107025384903,
0.06136836111545563,
-0.3776545524597168,
0.522104799747467,
0.3557146489620209,
-0.0007108805002644658,
-0.18090775609016418,
-0.8314576148986816,
0.21262384951114655,
0.04742611572146416,
-0.25308164954185486,
-0.5377390384674072,
-0.06955747306346893,
0.12332622706890106,
0.19077107310295105,
0.4384571611881256,
-0.6431448459625244,
0.02785966545343399,
-0.6955768465995789,
0.10702928155660629,
0.5655996203422546,
-0.2920711934566498,
0.512897253036499,
-0.023424644023180008,
0.723076581954956,
0.10681930184364319,
0.02048751339316368,
-0.03808283805847168,
-0.1739097237586975,
-0.8968669176101685,
-0.17916449904441833,
0.48470932245254517,
0.5321956872940063,
-1.1550401449203491,
0.2721179723739624,
-0.5091982483863831,
-0.47086021304130554,
-1.0594313144683838,
0.41954514384269714,
0.3592287003993988,
0.2899439334869385,
0.4778884947299957,
-0.012556669302284718,
-0.9410359859466553,
-0.9793052077293396,
-0.30771970748901367,
0.0798354223370552,
-0.18334659934043884,
-0.12428543716669083,
0.3108559548854828,
-0.37672701478004456,
0.7719462513923645,
-0.26959291100502014,
-0.24008837342262268,
-0.6336169838905334,
0.1814117729663849,
0.30209070444107056,
0.581603467464447,
0.372356653213501,
-0.7402719259262085,
-0.5645672082901001,
0.20404782891273499,
-0.9053154587745667,
0.044838566333055496,
0.06429412215948105,
-0.08491509407758713,
0.1521807163953781,
0.494902640581131,
-0.7662820816040039,
0.22431892156600952,
0.83575838804245,
0.20545339584350586,
0.2798466980457306,
-0.5290067195892334,
-0.13903333246707916,
-1.331175446510315,
0.25425219535827637,
0.06423478573560715,
-0.5164357423782349,
-0.9023721218109131,
-0.17213425040245056,
-0.032164186239242554,
-0.4900548458099365,
-0.6925898790359497,
1.0313955545425415,
-0.32864171266555786,
0.30060094594955444,
-0.25493839383125305,
0.03551173582673073,
-0.04905148968100548,
0.382517009973526,
0.2850230634212494,
0.84974604845047,
0.2605774998664856,
-0.6453368663787842,
-0.18966451287269592,
0.22712528705596924,
-0.4862448275089264,
-0.07511124759912491,
-0.505064845085144,
0.24734501540660858,
-0.2091394066810608,
-0.0643719732761383,
-0.35344818234443665,
-0.16566747426986694,
0.04493328556418419,
-0.44979041814804077,
0.5568650960922241,
-0.02398519217967987,
-0.6218079328536987,
-0.2869338095188141,
-0.02269013784825802,
0.3679911196231842,
0.5406273007392883,
-0.5086206197738647,
0.36593011021614075,
0.44887661933898926,
-0.11645608395338058,
-0.17887051403522491,
-0.6710934638977051,
-0.014281339943408966,
-0.1437412053346634,
-0.2092791050672531,
0.16938795149326324,
-0.019693128764629364,
-0.04953918606042862,
0.18513569235801697,
-0.04888143762946129,
-0.27065789699554443,
0.004480055533349514,
0.06918837130069733,
0.27984529733657837,
-0.16871584951877594,
0.11124545335769653,
0.051120348274707794,
-0.22031068801879883,
-0.14270244538784027,
-0.4182301461696625,
0.5755807161331177,
0.07940713316202164,
-0.004082241095602512,
-0.23995813727378845,
0.27638185024261475,
0.5193185210227966,
-0.3254948854446411,
1.0026780366897583,
0.4758875370025635,
-0.4549565613269806,
-0.3928467333316803,
-0.2115384042263031,
-0.28629109263420105,
-0.45203691720962524,
0.31479912996292114,
-0.3500356674194336,
-0.7097991704940796,
0.106402188539505,
0.027933219447731972,
0.06723612546920776,
0.40154069662094116,
0.2532750964164734,
-0.236140176653862,
1.0690680742263794,
0.8512048721313477,
-0.23648643493652344,
0.35217657685279846,
-0.3082068860530853,
0.42845675349235535,
-0.4675006568431854,
-0.06259262561798096,
-0.5314985513687134,
-0.10043737292289734,
-0.9433000683784485,
-0.3351495563983917,
0.3417772650718689,
-0.008093983866274357,
-0.005863383412361145,
0.6207578182220459,
-0.05224734917283058,
0.293058305978775,
0.47326138615608215,
0.06672565639019012,
0.3139432668685913,
0.1514514535665512,
0.16633494198322296,
-0.2163097858428955,
-0.7807539701461792,
-0.5057520270347595,
1.2413394451141357,
-0.13420464098453522,
0.8818880915641785,
-0.42529937624931335,
0.7311132550239563,
0.17293892800807953,
0.5065568089485168,
-0.5571293830871582,
0.4487360715866089,
-0.7017642855644226,
-0.6889532804489136,
-0.18406465649604797,
-0.7228959798812866,
-1.0485148429870605,
0.23702314496040344,
-0.13649886846542358,
-0.24566568434238434,
-0.08196335285902023,
0.2602815628051758,
0.06004500016570091,
0.28722864389419556,
-0.7411888241767883,
0.9198588132858276,
-0.5633904933929443,
0.009770039469003677,
-0.27683940529823303,
-0.39042192697525024,
0.3833167254924774,
-0.4952155351638794,
0.39772510528564453,
-0.07652486115694046,
0.11115911602973938,
0.6678327918052673,
-0.69642573595047,
0.7384079098701477,
0.025541234761476517,
0.02263302356004715,
0.22195059061050415,
0.026589715853333473,
0.4937642514705658,
-0.1323077529668808,
-0.07669668644666672,
0.3387211859226227,
0.11125002056360245,
-0.38316094875335693,
-0.5725520253181458,
0.5212771892547607,
-0.6977041959762573,
-0.5043637752532959,
-0.23263391852378845,
-0.3328721225261688,
-0.31866148114204407,
0.45851558446884155,
0.5509226322174072,
0.23197072744369507,
-0.2376064658164978,
0.31630465388298035,
0.5163670778274536,
-0.20098310708999634,
0.09541019797325134,
0.6627741456031799,
-0.31301456689834595,
-0.2169012427330017,
1.036176323890686,
0.07440906018018723,
0.21919476985931396,
0.5090129971504211,
-0.07580676674842834,
-0.37971287965774536,
-0.4283168613910675,
-0.5065423846244812,
0.4228159785270691,
-0.2856987714767456,
-0.06253571063280106,
-0.6277570724487305,
-0.29490911960601807,
-0.3585783541202545,
0.17509718239307404,
-0.8775153160095215,
-0.35423359274864197,
-0.2650001645088196,
-0.3468920588493347,
0.07767049223184586,
0.6464450359344482,
0.00993095152080059,
0.15387311577796936,
-0.9177019596099854,
0.46990594267845154,
-0.22656042873859406,
0.02912118472158909,
-0.29255998134613037,
-0.3732200562953949,
-0.5792519450187683,
0.5211695432662964,
0.18636442720890045,
-0.46671363711357117,
0.789595901966095,
0.2783896028995514,
0.5018109679222107,
0.13337045907974243,
0.08998827636241913,
0.7549391388893127,
-0.6487150192260742,
0.49403080344200134,
0.05307857692241669,
-0.7397462725639343,
0.5714483857154846,
-0.13373450934886932,
0.24741284549236298,
0.8964245915412903,
0.6285637617111206,
-0.4639400541782379,
-0.47248512506484985,
-0.5680710673332214,
-0.6541340351104736,
0.7054535746574402,
0.2646055221557617,
0.30650603771209717,
-0.02060747519135475,
0.18789513409137726,
0.20034869015216827,
0.5896366834640503,
-0.7138352990150452,
-0.15872317552566528,
-0.18922677636146545,
-0.5122288465499878,
-0.4757274389266968,
0.16614240407943726,
0.05164913088083267,
-0.3146423101425171,
0.8096539378166199,
-0.10913310199975967,
-0.17754031717777252,
-0.04997161030769348,
-0.34257644414901733,
-0.0320763923227787,
0.033978238701820374,
0.21949736773967743,
0.34633591771125793,
-0.020824512466788292,
0.06033330783247948,
0.20557156205177307,
-0.4707081913948059,
0.31838127970695496,
-0.017830943688750267,
-0.2532415986061096,
0.25897836685180664,
0.39938220381736755,
0.9219310283660889,
0.05268833786249161,
-0.9677997827529907,
0.2136092483997345,
-0.13399218022823334,
0.07704439014196396,
-0.5263449549674988,
-0.0025014940183609724,
-0.021388253197073936,
-0.46968623995780945,
-0.11321451514959335,
0.07594993710517883,
-0.16120408475399017,
-0.6046278476715088,
-0.012904220260679722,
0.21051029860973358,
-0.17372015118598938,
-0.6233340501785278,
0.5963163375854492,
0.0662880688905716,
-0.03217882290482521,
0.8657716512680054,
-0.10897227376699448,
-0.2657177746295929,
0.46519848704338074,
0.6364985108375549,
0.7052440047264099,
-0.28502780199050903,
0.29423636198043823,
0.4210567772388458,
0.543480396270752,
-0.12303938716650009,
0.07974280416965485,
0.06094139814376831,
-0.873091995716095,
-0.41975972056388855,
-0.9200038313865662,
-0.21549350023269653,
0.5691103339195251,
-0.5346865653991699,
0.24700115621089935,
-0.27938079833984375,
0.028081001713871956,
-0.2925916016101837,
-0.03972804173827171,
-1.012114405632019,
0.4966273903846741,
-0.0326341912150383,
0.969369113445282,
-0.9861114621162415,
1.1297334432601929,
0.7436127066612244,
-0.3032338321208954,
-0.7910856008529663,
-0.30124762654304504,
-0.41667503118515015,
-0.6715234518051147,
0.5921218991279602,
0.17937712371349335,
-0.02725299820303917,
0.1685124933719635,
-0.3365269899368286,
-0.7700018882751465,
0.5192905068397522,
0.6579816341400146,
-0.4593087434768677,
-0.04944893717765808,
0.5878610610961914,
0.8405390977859497,
-0.21634459495544434,
-0.22737228870391846,
0.5053478479385376,
0.47432148456573486,
-0.11216194927692413,
-0.6202048063278198,
-0.27153754234313965,
-0.5277596116065979,
-0.02540464699268341,
0.22731222212314606,
-0.20742769539356232,
0.8549522757530212,
0.1480422466993332,
-0.5291517972946167,
0.16747882962226868,
0.3200485110282898,
-0.10748488456010818,
0.06409216672182083,
0.2840859293937683,
0.813042402267456,
0.656738817691803,
-0.042131535708904266,
1.4222688674926758,
-0.3521042764186859,
0.0013724106829613447,
1.3639098405838013,
-0.42194807529449463,
0.7277908325195312,
0.40744951367378235,
-0.15562590956687927,
0.24065876007080078,
0.7110560536384583,
0.398808091878891,
0.53074049949646,
-0.022107362747192383,
-0.42293989658355713,
-0.2381301373243332,
-0.15748867392539978,
-0.2710023820400238,
0.4189591705799103,
0.3282979130744934,
-0.11098726093769073,
-0.20424440503120422,
0.3348287045955658,
0.14923468232154846,
0.11139510571956635,
-0.12238605320453644,
0.7853938937187195,
0.42632296681404114,
-0.7960717082023621,
0.6697923541069031,
-0.005393089726567268,
0.4045182168483734,
-1.0072015523910522,
0.18758560717105865,
-0.6461312770843506,
0.30572009086608887,
-0.14216044545173645,
-0.3612433969974518,
0.33327987790107727,
0.26230332255363464,
-0.2317347377538681,
-0.3748895525932312,
0.566113293170929,
-0.8979408740997314,
-0.7415350079536438,
0.3299601376056671,
0.6498805284500122,
0.28325578570365906,
-0.07387598603963852,
-0.2954820394515991,
-0.23017026484012604,
0.04123270511627197,
-0.1391383409500122,
0.45310723781585693,
0.39435917139053345,
-0.11504075676202774,
0.6117804646492004,
0.9946923851966858,
0.45830875635147095,
0.17051155865192413,
0.07124903053045273,
0.6313432455062866,
-0.45062312483787537,
-0.3823341131210327,
-0.6310698986053467,
0.3180728852748871,
-0.04275962710380554,
-0.06150779500603676,
0.9263060688972473,
0.8074619174003601,
1.2170367240905762,
-0.4850768446922302,
0.970412015914917,
0.2146543711423874,
0.6948865056037903,
-0.7674867510795593,
0.7354893088340759,
-0.7763776183128357,
-0.1295379400253296,
0.39139851927757263,
-0.8207770586013794,
-0.020139703527092934,
0.3043668270111084,
-0.08032920956611633,
-0.038205306977033615,
0.7022666931152344,
0.9022996425628662,
-0.17593605816364288,
-0.1435450166463852,
0.4196394979953766,
0.19264616072177887,
0.22022655606269836,
0.30360427498817444,
0.5979717969894409,
-0.3923923969268799,
0.2905437648296356,
-0.31841304898262024,
0.2462676465511322,
0.19688831269741058,
-0.5313804745674133,
-0.8142015337944031,
-0.4317282438278198,
-0.0597388781607151,
-0.022670701146125793,
-0.11703165620565414,
0.8156551718711853,
0.8608508706092834,
-0.9728288650512695,
-0.44462528824806213,
-0.3817567229270935,
0.016758788377046585,
0.23695528507232666,
-0.13980017602443695,
0.012693215161561966,
-0.6442753672599792,
-0.9759383797645569,
0.9729605913162231,
0.11962085217237473,
0.5047520399093628,
-0.20278431475162506,
-0.20880001783370972,
-0.16451415419578552,
0.06352014094591141,
0.4758736193180084,
0.49667420983314514,
-0.17305099964141846,
0.12645548582077026,
-0.07317215204238892,
-0.1254902482032776,
-0.01890539936721325,
0.8941875696182251,
-0.7994915246963501,
0.5423221588134766,
0.28787028789520264,
0.633064329624176,
0.8015484809875488,
-0.03648017719388008,
0.8481515645980835,
-1.036285638809204,
0.7849078178405762,
0.19196856021881104,
0.3661736249923706,
0.4984273612499237,
-0.16137373447418213,
0.6643162965774536,
0.18270817399024963,
0.052163347601890564,
-0.7949943542480469,
0.051401834934949875,
-0.400625616312027,
-0.20882104337215424,
0.7277419567108154,
-0.08210490643978119,
-0.33172735571861267,
0.21892082691192627,
0.06763084977865219,
0.4253927767276764,
0.10148745775222778,
0.47500497102737427,
0.43250149488449097,
0.3236955404281616,
-0.05983931943774223,
-0.7849921584129333,
0.7561678290367126,
0.40197187662124634,
-1.1718766689300537,
-0.28590908646583557,
0.2647133767604828,
0.12897132337093353,
0.07708321511745453,
0.6919853091239929,
-0.13812357187271118,
-0.15850485861301422,
0.09625419229269028,
0.07730043679475784,
0.011282638646662235,
-0.575495719909668,
-0.1691111922264099,
-0.17783910036087036,
-0.08579462021589279,
-0.29775336384773254
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13592v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13592v2
|
Llama meets EU: Investigating the European Political Spectrum through the Lens of LLMs
| 2024-03-20T13:42:57 | 2024-03-22T13:37:28 |
Ilias Chalkidis, Stephanie Brandl
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Instruction-finetuned Large Language Models inherit clear political leanings
that have been shown to influence downstream task performance. We expand this
line of research beyond the two-party system in the US and audit Llama Chat in
the context of EU politics in various settings to analyze the model's political
knowledge and its ability to reason in context. We adapt, i.e., further
fine-tune, Llama Chat on speeches of individual euro-parties from debates in
the European Parliament to reevaluate its political leaning based on the EUandI
questionnaire. Llama Chat shows considerable knowledge of national parties'
positions and is capable of reasoning in context. The adapted, party-specific,
models are substantially re-aligned towards respective positions which we see
as a starting point for using chat-based LLMs as data-driven conversational
engines to assist research in political science.
|
[
-0.49690255522727966,
-0.5855326652526855,
0.5754934549331665,
-0.06278418004512787,
-0.37251076102256775,
0.44390231370925903,
-0.301668643951416,
-0.45638352632522583,
0.4703352451324463,
0.7199198603630066,
-0.6151020526885986,
-0.47753360867500305,
-0.502061128616333,
0.04341960325837135,
-0.43995383381843567,
0.654893696308136,
0.3470744788646698,
0.20486436784267426,
-0.09193827211856842,
0.005737351719290018,
-0.13336089253425598,
-0.8260014653205872,
-0.3507857918739319,
-0.6183242201805115,
0.44784072041511536,
0.9304748177528381,
0.3115895688533783,
0.4610990285873413,
0.6057698130607605,
0.2982420027256012,
-0.25933966040611267,
0.06958208978176117,
-0.9645597338676453,
0.07055012136697769,
-0.2944970726966858,
-1.1453865766525269,
-0.29883846640586853,
0.20321081578731537,
0.3253575563430786,
0.5910758972167969,
-0.36973726749420166,
0.14728137850761414,
0.22871200740337372,
0.5053901076316833,
-0.4107316732406616,
0.10528465360403061,
-1.1534364223480225,
-0.24082998931407928,
-0.21960264444351196,
-0.652472198009491,
-0.21338704228401184,
0.1066092848777771,
0.1468106210231781,
-0.38561493158340454,
-0.15510837733745575,
-0.11329621821641922,
0.623657763004303,
0.28134897351264954,
-0.8069460988044739,
-0.5460768342018127,
-0.8870392441749573,
0.8196629285812378,
-0.4687694311141968,
0.2648341953754425,
0.23250028491020203,
0.31711649894714355,
-0.5952367186546326,
-0.7727763652801514,
-0.5817219018936157,
0.16029249131679535,
0.4816313087940216,
0.17786593735218048,
-0.37249231338500977,
-0.10592353343963623,
-0.3186466693878174,
0.5668956637382507,
0.09093910455703735,
0.2960497736930847,
-0.6091386675834656,
0.1426943689584732,
0.6276301145553589,
0.3047308921813965,
0.10937996208667755,
-0.02151452749967575,
-0.4298088550567627,
0.02871011383831501,
-0.9633817672729492,
0.06886731088161469,
0.8611332774162292,
0.4521236717700958,
-0.1082734689116478,
0.5617989301681519,
-0.14924992620944977,
0.4878717064857483,
0.07519915699958801,
-0.0024637470487505198,
-0.1363479495048523,
-0.19075508415699005,
-0.028547829017043114,
-0.12374435365200043,
0.512957751750946,
0.5376707315444946,
0.3905712962150574,
0.1493525356054306,
0.15110811591148376,
0.654802143573761,
-0.006946448236703873,
-0.6601409912109375,
-0.14583151042461395,
0.23297782242298126,
-0.46700137853622437,
-0.18614539504051208,
-0.2642612159252167,
-0.8376994132995605,
-0.4673316776752472,
-0.7029126286506653,
-0.1668478101491928,
0.0890837088227272,
-0.40768659114837646,
0.26479747891426086,
0.041495516896247864,
0.4740348756313324,
0.35074880719184875,
-0.6568788886070251,
0.41297319531440735,
1.058882236480713,
0.41875791549682617,
-0.2211558073759079,
0.061277344822883606,
-0.1194712370634079,
-0.0058002290315926075,
-0.4324820637702942,
1.1330617666244507,
-1.0245434045791626,
-0.45221972465515137,
0.10332150012254715,
0.1090465784072876,
0.1878623366355896,
-0.4750017523765564,
0.48001477122306824,
-0.4330708980560303,
0.5154109001159668,
-0.4996560215950012,
-0.7851924300193787,
-0.2720557451248169,
0.3329674005508423,
-0.5380436182022095,
0.9300540089607239,
-0.6698722839355469,
-0.6401049494743347,
0.4706830084323883,
-0.8542986512184143,
0.16500847041606903,
-0.3602616786956787,
-0.4556049406528473,
0.2794428765773773,
-0.06223740428686142,
0.13137201964855194,
0.705933690071106,
-0.1254776418209076,
0.21844090521335602,
-0.39816513657569885,
-0.2980719804763794,
0.20140637457370758,
-0.2053898721933365,
0.8164877891540527,
0.1149018332362175,
-0.09178616106510162,
0.08625293523073196,
-0.9766642451286316,
-0.6025776863098145,
0.03381171450018883,
-0.3428463935852051,
-0.32714173197746277,
0.7297393679618835,
-0.11230894923210144,
0.20684151351451874,
0.3554481267929077,
-0.7547131180763245,
0.14081348478794098,
-0.31782203912734985,
0.8134084343910217,
0.756414532661438,
-0.054085131734609604,
0.41400831937789917,
-0.13663721084594727,
0.4114823341369629,
-0.12428529560565948,
-0.22866885364055634,
0.04790104180574417,
-0.5335822105407715,
-0.9641417860984802,
-0.19342634081840515,
0.18636754155158997,
0.9761247634887695,
-0.43524283170700073,
0.186946302652359,
-0.17039258778095245,
-0.5890735387802124,
-0.37363284826278687,
-0.002508179284632206,
-0.28197747468948364,
0.09188400954008102,
-0.2172316461801529,
-0.14699256420135498,
-0.7834704518318176,
-0.8741686940193176,
-0.20109932124614716,
-0.3900510370731354,
-0.1373090296983719,
0.4555388391017914,
0.6977406144142151,
0.0071454220451414585,
0.7367180585861206,
0.10993707180023193,
-0.15280887484550476,
-0.32263830304145813,
-0.2923509180545807,
0.2796632647514343,
0.13849200308322906,
0.2365448772907257,
-0.35182929039001465,
-0.1502169519662857,
0.19797231256961823,
-0.41334182024002075,
-0.11337267607450485,
0.31980860233306885,
-0.24563021957874298,
-0.00955219380557537,
0.5589348673820496,
-0.03977081552147865,
0.31401991844177246,
0.9993550181388855,
-0.6893216967582703,
-0.26020848751068115,
0.019841298460960388,
0.25201088190078735,
-1.3432611227035522,
-0.1266370415687561,
-0.19979342818260193,
-0.35377180576324463,
-0.6214131116867065,
-0.25085702538490295,
-0.4424677789211273,
0.0697656199336052,
-0.5005751848220825,
0.3246782720088959,
-0.30659741163253784,
-0.25996413826942444,
-0.4308960437774658,
0.31639018654823303,
-0.3128507435321808,
0.26386603713035583,
-0.031042926013469696,
0.8459030985832214,
0.380027174949646,
-0.31954193115234375,
0.020328348502516747,
0.20569609105587006,
-0.4979701638221741,
0.8017430901527405,
-0.4110013544559479,
0.3587566018104553,
0.041298992931842804,
0.3218297064304352,
-1.2590376138687134,
-0.21278105676174164,
0.11858708411455154,
-0.10856122523546219,
0.0008378329803235829,
-0.10246242582798004,
-0.37888917326927185,
-0.023531198501586914,
-0.04113127291202545,
-0.04598234221339226,
0.36753028631210327,
-0.6635026931762695,
0.47484827041625977,
0.9930610656738281,
-0.24896441400051117,
-0.6197685599327087,
-0.41657203435897827,
0.36481690406799316,
-0.5509735941886902,
-0.436819851398468,
0.06730923801660538,
0.25986000895500183,
-0.7631818056106567,
-0.27483049035072327,
0.12599410116672516,
-0.007310774642974138,
0.06381310522556305,
0.18911437690258026,
0.08480063080787659,
-0.16652634739875793,
-0.0031376651022583246,
-0.11461641639471054,
0.03286585956811905,
0.054922085255384445,
0.16546550393104553,
0.588889479637146,
-0.21733061969280243,
-0.36551618576049805,
-0.7397257089614868,
0.4265000522136688,
0.5850031971931458,
0.09002116322517395,
0.3822025656700134,
-0.07786127924919128,
-0.17352524399757385,
-0.07525273412466049,
-0.6095635890960693,
-0.3468587398529053,
-0.4492834806442261,
0.29186099767684937,
-0.26313480734825134,
-1.151194453239441,
0.933524489402771,
-0.4787099361419678,
0.44275689125061035,
0.3724830150604248,
0.9294420480728149,
-0.3486599326133728,
0.6035124063491821,
1.0358892679214478,
-0.13563819229602814,
0.5294721722602844,
-0.18792584538459778,
0.1155042052268982,
-0.4376499652862549,
-0.30485811829566956,
-0.720237672328949,
-0.6572966575622559,
-0.7345762252807617,
-0.5244500041007996,
0.04285786673426628,
-0.19210708141326904,
-0.3838188350200653,
-0.041587524116039276,
-0.4000682830810547,
0.7609549760818481,
0.24011917412281036,
0.01177783403545618,
0.39537644386291504,
0.22489777207374573,
0.2947804629802704,
-0.026871398091316223,
-0.653291642665863,
-1.0800197124481201,
1.2843523025512695,
0.5436327457427979,
0.7729184627532959,
-0.1939498484134674,
0.5084976553916931,
0.01884409785270691,
0.3829437494277954,
-0.5392518043518066,
0.657739520072937,
-0.06251516938209534,
-0.6566043496131897,
-0.1657778024673462,
-0.1828315705060959,
-1.059493899345398,
0.4825490415096283,
-0.07141587138175964,
-0.8946480751037598,
0.41294899582862854,
-0.1004166305065155,
0.06467198580503464,
0.6957197189331055,
-0.182731494307518,
0.4823956787586212,
-0.06636041402816772,
0.16519495844841003,
-0.5070205330848694,
-0.5535349249839783,
0.44659870862960815,
0.4442635774612427,
0.38972750306129456,
-0.6325326561927795,
-0.5260608196258545,
1.0717523097991943,
-0.006706204731017351,
1.228906512260437,
0.027251610532402992,
-0.6078370809555054,
0.2286306917667389,
-0.002100956393405795,
0.0580991730093956,
-0.054191432893276215,
0.002316530328243971,
0.5733513832092285,
0.26509737968444824,
-0.29584312438964844,
-0.057037707418203354,
0.6865412592887878,
-1.0070123672485352,
-0.7449050545692444,
0.017064906656742096,
-0.7660687565803528,
-0.16961494088172913,
-0.23823091387748718,
-0.02801728993654251,
-0.061703652143478394,
-0.5827367305755615,
0.36220526695251465,
0.4062914252281189,
0.20130003988742828,
0.24397985637187958,
0.3609832525253296,
-0.26094725728034973,
-0.2214495986700058,
0.4236477017402649,
0.045343466103076935,
0.1420040726661682,
0.15403571724891663,
-0.01191939041018486,
-0.1936144083738327,
-0.11130663007497787,
-0.15612703561782837,
0.1540452092885971,
-0.813311755657196,
-0.14917773008346558,
-0.30803507566452026,
0.24441269040107727,
0.5541574358940125,
-0.02792845480144024,
-0.5466352105140686,
-0.7167330384254456,
-0.47045934200286865,
-0.17174160480499268,
0.5332674384117126,
1.0133928060531616,
-0.2993946969509125,
0.4911822974681854,
-0.05680559575557709,
0.014714532531797886,
0.23246830701828003,
0.25305697321891785,
-0.589724063873291,
-0.4989827275276184,
0.38120192289352417,
0.08382072299718857,
-0.5667862296104431,
-1.318731665611267,
-0.0411953404545784,
0.2991771399974823,
0.5552355051040649,
0.5025117993354797,
-0.1084543913602829,
0.5431471467018127,
-0.6967023015022278,
1.0168848037719727,
-0.22825895249843597,
-0.7708066701889038,
0.6991432309150696,
-0.3525288701057434,
-0.3310312032699585,
0.42718201875686646,
0.2512838542461395,
-0.23259137570858002,
-0.8496915102005005,
-0.5061371326446533,
-0.6025148630142212,
0.45147794485092163,
0.12743765115737915,
0.5865058898925781,
0.1404847502708435,
0.30615726113319397,
0.1374794989824295,
0.00494476268067956,
-0.4387306571006775,
-0.2616264224052429,
0.3184276521205902,
-0.014391254633665085,
-0.19174104928970337,
-0.28208157420158386,
-0.6814329028129578,
-0.13337790966033936,
0.5030204057693481,
-0.10153910517692566,
0.20092257857322693,
0.1403741091489792,
0.4640529155731201,
-0.3727126121520996,
0.4889984428882599,
0.5077213644981384,
1.0431228876113892,
0.08255987614393234,
0.018679386004805565,
0.29693108797073364,
-0.15095235407352448,
0.19709470868110657,
-0.1352815181016922,
0.3498933017253876,
0.08628714084625244,
0.2501061260700226,
0.5238605737686157,
0.23234501481056213,
-0.524170994758606,
0.1931423395872116,
-0.2491481751203537,
-0.5676523447036743,
-0.13725854456424713,
0.09562966972589493,
0.6157082319259644,
0.5727053880691528,
0.41817808151245117,
-0.2760166525840759,
0.034360576421022415,
-0.9960963129997253,
0.17908267676830292,
0.7200090289115906,
-0.09984365850687027,
-0.24523277580738068,
0.5997574925422668,
0.5916932821273804,
-0.5676019787788391,
0.11972576379776001,
0.4844641089439392,
-0.6613677740097046,
0.606957197189331,
0.31270092725753784,
0.31851789355278015,
-0.5117619037628174,
-0.06655579060316086,
0.025586122646927834,
0.4529128074645996,
0.4332916736602783,
0.9624654054641724,
-0.05756165087223053,
-0.7156259417533875,
-0.5806030631065369,
-0.15809915959835052,
-0.8801462650299072,
0.14855369925498962,
-0.731917142868042,
0.16929571330547333,
-0.09547605365514755,
-0.3214871287345886,
-0.09614863991737366,
0.6579020619392395,
-0.6542335152626038,
-0.31383001804351807,
0.39359092712402344,
1.0443695783615112,
-1.0539896488189697,
0.512218177318573,
0.37134820222854614,
0.4532202482223511,
-0.4255993366241455,
-0.294033408164978,
0.10444812476634979,
-0.9595354199409485,
0.44442814588546753,
-0.021554037928581238,
-0.10704832524061203,
-0.29146456718444824,
-0.9198887348175049,
-0.8438662886619568,
1.1074174642562866,
0.647483766078949,
-0.8467227220535278,
0.23592133820056915,
0.2511143982410431,
0.4595208764076233,
-0.6289643049240112,
-0.09752391278743744,
0.8804066777229309,
0.21252481639385223,
-0.060282766819000244,
-1.0280683040618896,
-0.2678709924221039,
-0.1631792038679123,
-0.406490296125412,
0.1277356892824173,
-0.6570447087287903,
0.611492931842804,
0.20166631042957306,
-0.27042168378829956,
0.009938212111592293,
0.8149968385696411,
0.2620489299297333,
0.25390252470970154,
0.592180073261261,
0.3537372350692749,
0.9672536253929138,
-0.12805913388729095,
0.8247963190078735,
-0.7653252482414246,
0.13642477989196777,
0.8414987921714783,
-0.5604063272476196,
1.3132004737854004,
0.9535619616508484,
-0.3260270953178406,
0.7996782660484314,
0.869590163230896,
0.3510713279247284,
0.32731398940086365,
0.36149585247039795,
-0.10396944731473923,
-0.3720431923866272,
0.03005700185894966,
-0.36772388219833374,
0.8404235243797302,
0.8313631415367126,
-0.04284974932670593,
-0.38416287302970886,
-0.15191397070884705,
-0.00918822456151247,
0.27439719438552856,
-0.35059329867362976,
0.8898117542266846,
0.15367217361927032,
-0.45457127690315247,
0.3478308320045471,
-0.3706989288330078,
0.49115189909935,
-0.10377994924783707,
-0.2468910664319992,
-0.24142080545425415,
0.042727306485176086,
-0.09323902428150177,
-0.9768925905227661,
0.23884780704975128,
0.34085842967033386,
0.11441478133201599,
0.10583161562681198,
0.4543510675430298,
-0.38854843378067017,
-0.5523298382759094,
0.31343764066696167,
0.8387079834938049,
0.5154933333396912,
0.4228660464286804,
-0.679980993270874,
0.283107727766037,
-0.1531488001346588,
-0.5046656131744385,
0.17989951372146606,
0.8579506278038025,
0.09130673855543137,
0.7309079766273499,
0.6131449937820435,
0.023337295278906822,
-0.1417684555053711,
-0.15413396060466766,
0.9586807489395142,
-0.28248804807662964,
-0.5586777329444885,
-0.7702398300170898,
0.29719048738479614,
-0.02968617156147957,
-0.33600080013275146,
0.5363941192626953,
0.3760302662849426,
0.8213720321655273,
0.39982083439826965,
0.4610558748245239,
0.20051003992557526,
0.7187625169754028,
-0.41294366121292114,
0.6808136701583862,
-0.5172267556190491,
0.3184557259082794,
0.08506102114915848,
-0.7471625804901123,
-0.10779375582933426,
0.7696003913879395,
-0.5293761491775513,
-0.3105924427509308,
0.19350749254226685,
0.7824022769927979,
-0.2927715480327606,
0.12679527699947357,
0.2844577729701996,
0.10931618511676788,
0.2065495252609253,
0.5230578780174255,
1.3985861539840698,
0.011929260566830635,
0.6202234625816345,
-0.1401805728673935,
-0.18284454941749573,
0.05018908530473709,
-0.8385733962059021,
-1.182724952697754,
-0.5703105330467224,
-0.03794611245393753,
-0.04905948042869568,
-0.005290267989039421,
0.6698521971702576,
0.6379051804542542,
-0.6944524645805359,
-0.7566099166870117,
0.1518644541501999,
0.058253370225429535,
0.42364564538002014,
-0.17291514575481415,
0.2941702902317047,
-0.20028240978717804,
-0.9317508339881897,
0.31529703736305237,
0.2848544120788574,
-0.30222249031066895,
-0.4957202970981598,
0.24217192828655243,
-0.35065996646881104,
0.6790118217468262,
0.5046457052230835,
0.1538490504026413,
-1.1467705965042114,
-0.34500569105148315,
-0.014521850273013115,
0.014813271351158619,
0.3094741106033325,
0.770601749420166,
-0.5733961462974548,
0.12871333956718445,
0.20774021744728088,
0.4920687675476074,
0.11780586838722229,
-0.18707683682441711,
0.6599754691123962,
-0.3960173726081848,
0.3022982180118561,
0.14621713757514954,
0.41158628463745117,
0.39979931712150574,
-0.15671585500240326,
0.6335342526435852,
-0.2312907576560974,
-0.885590136051178,
-1.0040127038955688,
0.1610969454050064,
-0.9848708510398865,
-0.1913394331932068,
1.1978397369384766,
-0.06274348497390747,
-0.22364875674247742,
-0.1086893081665039,
-0.4126071035861969,
0.1434856504201889,
-0.26866814494132996,
0.7541655898094177,
0.8022789359092712,
-0.1598723828792572,
-0.02219550497829914,
-0.8802802562713623,
0.3825991749763489,
0.2940037250518799,
-0.8959255814552307,
0.038502901792526245,
0.22620385885238647,
0.39875486493110657,
0.03550882637500763,
0.6926974654197693,
0.015445543453097343,
0.13016873598098755,
-0.09681269526481628,
-0.13232403993606567,
0.6530762314796448,
-0.2937164604663849,
-0.32082974910736084,
0.12613777816295624,
-0.283280611038208,
-0.2576596736907959
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13590v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13590v1
|
Teacher-Student Training for Debiasing: General Permutation Debiasing for Large Language Models
| 2024-03-20T13:38:07 | 2024-03-20T13:38:07 |
Adian Liusie, Yassir Fathullah, Mark J. F. Gales
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive zero-shot
capabilities and versatility in NLP tasks, however they sometimes fail to
maintain crucial invariances for specific tasks. One example is permutation
sensitivity, where LLMs' outputs may significantly vary depending on the order
of the input options. While debiasing techniques can mitigate these issues, and
yield better performance and reliability, they often come with a high
computational cost at inference. This paper addresses this inefficiency at
inference time. The aim is to distill the capabilities of a computationally
intensive, debiased, teacher model into a more compact student model. We
explore two variants of student models: one based on pure distillation, and the
other on an error-correction approach for more complex tasks, where the student
corrects a single biased decision from the teacher to achieve a debiased
output. Our approach is general and can be applied to both black-box and
white-box LLMs. Furthermore, we demonstrate that our compact, encoder-only
student models can outperform their larger, biased teacher counterparts,
achieving better results with significantly fewer parameters.
|
[
-0.03506453335285187,
-0.7568402886390686,
0.679390013217926,
0.09495092928409576,
-0.21848942339420319,
0.12788501381874084,
-0.3979823589324951,
-0.09167973697185516,
-0.12058497220277786,
0.4768482446670532,
-0.2688347101211548,
-0.3571338653564453,
-0.8773995637893677,
0.04762331023812294,
-0.6121304631233215,
0.7576348781585693,
0.0665748193860054,
0.5546993613243103,
-0.33955034613609314,
0.02806885354220867,
-0.3914351165294647,
-0.681605339050293,
-0.5200537443161011,
-0.6452562808990479,
0.4340571165084839,
0.8001934289932251,
0.6607980728149414,
0.37873268127441406,
0.4003213346004486,
0.27534806728363037,
-0.11208143830299377,
-0.2398087978363037,
-0.5425524711608887,
0.2353733777999878,
-0.3377154767513275,
-0.5834938287734985,
-0.288341760635376,
0.19979728758335114,
0.5288786888122559,
1.0743385553359985,
-0.1999678760766983,
0.08287040889263153,
0.1941913515329361,
0.3835957944393158,
-0.8874057531356812,
-0.28225138783454895,
-0.9368197321891785,
0.15403766930103302,
0.018620293587446213,
0.359933465719223,
-0.5348758101463318,
-0.27981653809547424,
0.02696719951927662,
-0.3176672160625458,
0.33458495140075684,
-0.3612801134586334,
0.3630818724632263,
0.5732373595237732,
-0.4463719129562378,
-0.10565584152936935,
-0.9452595710754395,
1.2053405046463013,
-0.7993931174278259,
0.37749940156936646,
0.5747756361961365,
0.25238245725631714,
-0.11727036535739899,
-0.5174455046653748,
-0.648322343826294,
0.07693441212177277,
0.11437339335680008,
0.040572647005319595,
-0.021335288882255554,
0.23567092418670654,
0.27591559290885925,
0.2756461203098297,
-0.3642682433128357,
0.2759176194667816,
-0.2534404397010803,
0.25315389037132263,
0.558724582195282,
-0.004168462008237839,
-0.037212736904621124,
-0.022659316658973694,
-0.3206403851509094,
-0.2364048808813095,
-0.5607709288597107,
-0.29069045186042786,
0.6618456840515137,
0.16026638448238373,
-0.11814090609550476,
0.6350758671760559,
-0.0629076212644577,
0.6205597519874573,
0.16629435122013092,
-0.3287683427333832,
0.027077578008174896,
0.12689347565174103,
-0.2987793982028961,
0.17453278601169586,
0.5718701481819153,
0.15796852111816406,
0.37731027603149414,
-0.3397582173347473,
-0.27206286787986755,
0.33015260100364685,
0.271159291267395,
-0.9165259599685669,
-0.35908952355384827,
0.30497655272483826,
-0.14785394072532654,
-0.49389445781707764,
-0.1613820195198059,
-0.8827002644538879,
-0.563438892364502,
-0.47652027010917664,
0.39639970660209656,
-0.12244716286659241,
-0.07383700460195541,
0.413810670375824,
-0.06299258768558502,
-0.14238528907299042,
0.22794264554977417,
-1.030906081199646,
0.38567203283309937,
0.5411685705184937,
0.46626797318458557,
-0.27479881048202515,
-0.3711875081062317,
-0.456590473651886,
0.14890184998512268,
-0.15196099877357483,
0.3858836889266968,
-0.917457640171051,
-0.33268654346466064,
-0.18194369971752167,
-0.47552579641342163,
0.03941420465707779,
-0.6078518629074097,
0.5523924827575684,
-0.35440146923065186,
-0.043896425515413284,
-0.20490287244319916,
-0.45415446162223816,
-0.048958003520965576,
0.15790659189224243,
-0.4945073127746582,
0.9833161234855652,
0.26623985171318054,
-0.8216333389282227,
0.2406957596540451,
-0.2501745820045471,
-0.15094095468521118,
-0.1848803162574768,
-0.28871235251426697,
-0.44550660252571106,
0.2530941665172577,
0.304670512676239,
0.45919397473335266,
-0.40470266342163086,
0.5370983481407166,
-0.5825157165527344,
-0.5673071146011353,
0.38350576162338257,
-0.6038988828659058,
0.9392645955085754,
0.14123132824897766,
-0.2955839931964874,
-0.05617031082510948,
-0.7939121723175049,
-0.26141759753227234,
0.24247634410858154,
-0.33935546875,
-0.4528036415576935,
0.10575151443481445,
-0.059916045516729355,
-0.054627805948257446,
-0.020815033465623856,
-0.6150128245353699,
0.461885541677475,
-0.2725074291229248,
0.5933560729026794,
0.778803288936615,
-0.1426980048418045,
0.6561736464500427,
-0.06291960179805756,
0.5395490527153015,
0.08362795412540436,
0.2411305457353592,
0.23999738693237305,
-0.10521339625120163,
-0.8197681307792664,
-0.3125726282596588,
0.5087579488754272,
0.5013952255249023,
-0.664216160774231,
0.2937808632850647,
-0.09046804159879684,
-0.40876784920692444,
-0.4325720965862274,
0.3839832842350006,
0.33594003319740295,
0.4621644616127014,
0.3565327525138855,
-0.24459746479988098,
-0.6165453791618347,
-0.5349336862564087,
-0.20820832252502441,
0.029778752475976944,
-0.14409786462783813,
-0.2030666470527649,
0.6321412324905396,
-0.32500016689300537,
0.8927799463272095,
-0.706746518611908,
-0.12317070364952087,
-0.2467179000377655,
-0.04102301597595215,
0.15998443961143494,
0.5663077235221863,
0.5640677809715271,
-0.6840290427207947,
-0.5053242444992065,
-0.5796579718589783,
-0.41762858629226685,
-0.11356745660305023,
-0.12204388529062271,
-0.1755923330783844,
0.17335833609104156,
0.4631083607673645,
-0.3671385943889618,
0.41058507561683655,
0.6084272861480713,
-0.26149022579193115,
0.5032201409339905,
-0.10759087651968002,
-0.30888399481773376,
-0.727924108505249,
-0.2848215103149414,
-0.174733966588974,
-0.23263105750083923,
-0.5075953602790833,
-0.029716050252318382,
-0.2088189423084259,
-0.07553237676620483,
-0.1729745715856552,
0.40314939618110657,
-0.37703052163124084,
-0.050586435943841934,
-0.3289982080459595,
0.2097397744655609,
-0.02264985628426075,
0.38882729411125183,
-0.0967080146074295,
0.46025580167770386,
0.5178542137145996,
-0.28105470538139343,
0.45009469985961914,
0.2075536549091339,
-0.38492852449417114,
0.4723849296569824,
-0.7423285245895386,
0.4485239088535309,
-0.23101498186588287,
0.22329644858837128,
-1.060723900794983,
-0.15172071754932404,
0.21609611809253693,
-0.2716425359249115,
0.40784817934036255,
-0.2904704511165619,
-0.542147159576416,
-0.34484824538230896,
-0.3989470303058624,
0.4508838355541229,
0.5051699876785278,
-0.64371657371521,
0.5220333337783813,
0.2846492528915405,
-0.04068995267152786,
-0.9222608804702759,
-0.8825463056564331,
-0.037999819964170456,
-0.06760748475790024,
-0.12834148108959198,
0.3974418342113495,
-0.06358306109905243,
-0.37695640325546265,
0.07597202062606812,
-0.3449275493621826,
-0.26180097460746765,
0.4341476857662201,
0.3318067193031311,
0.25210797786712646,
0.21647073328495026,
0.21707327663898468,
0.14001072943210602,
-0.12657573819160461,
-0.10518405586481094,
-0.3085923492908478,
0.5584983825683594,
0.20559528470039368,
-0.6593074798583984,
-0.007328665349632502,
0.35210204124450684,
0.3227154016494751,
-0.18016596138477325,
0.7590911388397217,
0.1947239488363266,
-0.420752614736557,
-0.5848028659820557,
-0.7385391592979431,
-0.4849243462085724,
-0.4508014917373657,
0.3300631046295166,
-0.2392844259738922,
-0.6508781909942627,
0.34046411514282227,
0.20984917879104614,
0.06012323498725891,
0.060162853449583054,
0.4744751453399658,
0.10839278995990753,
0.8704375624656677,
0.5944006443023682,
-0.2558504641056061,
0.4948602318763733,
-0.30917999148368835,
0.35478848218917847,
-0.48508220911026,
0.06387289613485336,
-0.6895952820777893,
-0.6703977584838867,
-0.2769377529621124,
-0.46654796600341797,
0.23015457391738892,
0.34768441319465637,
-0.637219250202179,
-0.12233231216669083,
-0.6230572462081909,
0.8301767110824585,
0.782372236251831,
0.09013567119836807,
0.39904025197029114,
0.16790567338466644,
0.05929908901453018,
-0.10147954523563385,
-0.7651963233947754,
-0.6331231594085693,
1.4486624002456665,
0.2673546075820923,
1.022412896156311,
0.05212957784533501,
0.7854417562484741,
-0.09986934810876846,
0.24466916918754578,
-0.6461737155914307,
0.5393416285514832,
-0.5896598696708679,
-0.6340919733047485,
-0.4351721704006195,
-0.4299265146255493,
-0.6284787654876709,
0.5321604013442993,
-0.4087967276573181,
-0.6664615869522095,
0.13703553378582,
0.1645107865333557,
-0.2756975293159485,
0.5720059871673584,
-0.6446481347084045,
0.8247190713882446,
-0.16875553131103516,
-0.32010895013809204,
-0.19667330384254456,
-0.501498281955719,
0.2858189344406128,
-0.21585682034492493,
0.06184229999780655,
-0.06359809637069702,
0.06634476035833359,
0.4804777204990387,
-0.2655056416988373,
1.1415917873382568,
-0.3230592906475067,
0.05391313135623932,
0.31231772899627686,
0.1507503241300583,
0.4204806387424469,
0.010947342962026596,
-0.35892748832702637,
0.04742111638188362,
-0.037687480449676514,
-0.5109797716140747,
-0.5187907814979553,
0.6998457908630371,
-0.9843863248825073,
-0.6566686034202576,
-0.2995857894420624,
-0.7566390037536621,
-0.31547465920448303,
-0.05487425997853279,
0.10824277251958847,
0.20470936596393585,
0.08595456928014755,
0.29776427149772644,
0.6049180030822754,
-0.12127379328012466,
0.3886801302433014,
0.44596564769744873,
-0.19947576522827148,
-0.3173808157444,
0.5943040251731873,
0.34249910712242126,
0.3166389465332031,
0.32921168208122253,
0.3908744156360626,
-0.2514280080795288,
-0.6592504978179932,
-0.3093095123767853,
0.10748276859521866,
-0.8968214392662048,
-0.145765483379364,
-0.5782769918441772,
0.13500471413135529,
-0.6354962587356567,
-0.3883957862854004,
-0.37965941429138184,
-0.6358813643455505,
-0.41836050152778625,
-0.2559007704257965,
0.08585391938686371,
0.5595646500587463,
0.22014690935611725,
0.6442325115203857,
-0.522892415523529,
0.32644110918045044,
0.5633248090744019,
0.2510952949523926,
0.1333312690258026,
-0.7256969809532166,
0.03599071875214577,
0.002108705695718527,
-0.6574145555496216,
-0.9858563542366028,
0.20169557631015778,
0.09276099503040314,
0.38932231068611145,
0.3517078757286072,
0.38853538036346436,
0.47005876898765564,
-0.2510260045528412,
0.7209247946739197,
0.18949292600154877,
-1.0523242950439453,
0.14744628965854645,
-0.02222106046974659,
0.11158066987991333,
0.6134322285652161,
0.26484277844429016,
-0.44575393199920654,
-0.5053897500038147,
-0.5368732810020447,
-0.8680932521820068,
0.6209873557090759,
-0.23095190525054932,
0.2899734377861023,
0.16838304698467255,
0.572084903717041,
0.1986185759305954,
0.274982750415802,
-0.8528504371643066,
-0.2749146521091461,
-0.2465144395828247,
-0.5389602184295654,
-0.2838805913925171,
-0.6506420969963074,
-0.08479294180870056,
-0.45972126722335815,
0.7824257612228394,
-0.16064220666885376,
-0.2816186845302582,
0.12147650122642517,
-0.19949418306350708,
-0.03227749094367027,
0.5222726464271545,
0.26876434683799744,
0.6587526798248291,
-0.23204591870307922,
0.5659911632537842,
0.6400772333145142,
-0.5554910898208618,
0.404121994972229,
-0.00898871012032032,
-0.310824453830719,
-0.10609868913888931,
0.24069072306156158,
0.7155548334121704,
0.24442298710346222,
-0.6248162388801575,
0.6243175864219666,
0.15600188076496124,
-0.2715068459510803,
-0.36540499329566956,
0.10207972675561905,
0.18623828887939453,
0.3927405774593353,
0.2602749764919281,
-0.19258885085582733,
0.1043587327003479,
-0.3891453444957733,
-0.17119865119457245,
0.358534574508667,
-0.22870086133480072,
-0.25895586609840393,
0.7806107997894287,
0.17029008269309998,
0.04784879833459854,
0.713398814201355,
-0.16525956988334656,
-0.581588089466095,
0.6267104744911194,
0.759610116481781,
1.124556064605713,
-0.41679954528808594,
0.10098820924758911,
0.3386971950531006,
0.15065810084342957,
-0.31615787744522095,
0.2355881929397583,
0.1597425937652588,
-0.8210775256156921,
-0.5789322257041931,
-0.7555698156356812,
-0.6801872253417969,
0.23170235753059387,
-0.48942244052886963,
0.2647654116153717,
-0.4562199115753174,
-0.052332933992147446,
0.05677942931652069,
0.07860482484102249,
-0.49225401878356934,
0.25498974323272705,
0.1800415813922882,
0.566360354423523,
-0.9917907118797302,
1.0555856227874756,
0.9457014799118042,
-0.11063878983259201,
-0.7646390795707703,
-0.16227518022060394,
-0.11661271005868912,
-0.32892942428588867,
0.814952552318573,
-0.014014672487974167,
-0.04847420006990433,
-0.19988392293453217,
-0.6118771433830261,
-0.4910726547241211,
0.7912410497665405,
0.863490104675293,
-1.0388612747192383,
-0.18227413296699524,
0.36201345920562744,
0.28711575269699097,
-0.15673218667507172,
0.3322102427482605,
0.6943041086196899,
0.28042757511138916,
0.18994514644145966,
-0.5266948342323303,
-0.1158970296382904,
0.2537256181240082,
0.01865914650261402,
0.13347271084785461,
-0.40348726511001587,
1.1817662715911865,
-0.14684085547924042,
0.05554920807480812,
-0.4223564565181732,
0.35994061827659607,
0.0018749302253127098,
0.22407446801662445,
0.7298527956008911,
0.7846497893333435,
0.85646653175354,
0.059834375977516174,
0.8433422446250916,
-0.23001419007778168,
0.40321946144104004,
1.5131583213806152,
-0.3429378271102905,
0.7035589218139648,
0.7198914885520935,
-0.416932612657547,
0.11382973194122314,
0.2630158066749573,
-0.07860006392002106,
0.30284351110458374,
0.39748287200927734,
-0.28490138053894043,
-0.5207074284553528,
0.1425607055425644,
-0.05489778518676758,
0.4380013942718506,
-0.019341131672263145,
-0.20897769927978516,
-0.2830539345741272,
0.17194224894046783,
0.12270544469356537,
0.3360641598701477,
-0.3246687948703766,
0.5561812520027161,
0.1934465765953064,
-0.5239663124084473,
0.60193932056427,
0.14333957433700562,
0.8200141787528992,
-0.42227596044540405,
0.0531197115778923,
-0.16017340123653412,
0.6527757048606873,
-0.29651328921318054,
-0.5724117755889893,
0.3650364577770233,
0.1986600160598755,
-0.38250887393951416,
-0.2537086009979248,
0.7301267981529236,
-0.6622651815414429,
-0.5773304104804993,
0.3139134347438812,
0.16599689424037933,
0.0597899965941906,
-0.23433104157447815,
-0.4474264085292816,
0.19011449813842773,
0.11186442524194717,
-0.33542025089263916,
0.31243896484375,
0.09859735518693924,
-0.01642814837396145,
0.4980010986328125,
0.4228943884372711,
0.20016172528266907,
0.06377696245908737,
0.2223549336194992,
0.7852683663368225,
-0.4678192436695099,
-0.049924336373806,
-1.1534098386764526,
0.2555007040500641,
0.16315209865570068,
-0.26280319690704346,
0.6513547897338867,
0.49817463755607605,
1.1399797201156616,
-0.21204927563667297,
0.8070380687713623,
0.3216142952442169,
0.4880838990211487,
-0.31650903820991516,
0.4649367034435272,
-0.404618501663208,
0.3467623293399811,
-0.24258093535900116,
-1.0188794136047363,
-0.30979233980178833,
0.7211887240409851,
-0.6037179827690125,
-0.2236160784959793,
0.3099741041660309,
0.5993404388427734,
-0.14652229845523834,
0.05201878771185875,
0.36401158571243286,
0.1503096967935562,
0.3325054943561554,
0.7285782098770142,
0.7918744087219238,
-0.2884986400604248,
0.48797523975372314,
-0.6911188960075378,
-0.02026662975549698,
-0.2415931075811386,
-0.8656610250473022,
-1.0664124488830566,
-0.3505322337150574,
-0.41754627227783203,
-0.1414170116186142,
0.022971656173467636,
1.1005101203918457,
0.567581295967102,
-0.7753980755805969,
-0.20511873066425323,
-0.033599551767110825,
0.33099618554115295,
-0.10274901986122131,
-0.09956490248441696,
0.23168964684009552,
-0.4392615258693695,
-1.0840473175048828,
0.11314331740140915,
-0.27474352717399597,
0.2068675011396408,
-0.2736697793006897,
0.09658955782651901,
0.11279092729091644,
0.2835519015789032,
0.48940563201904297,
-0.2042224258184433,
-0.5208112001419067,
-0.2826841473579407,
-0.29122933745384216,
-0.16544342041015625,
-0.009512309916317463,
0.6216650009155273,
-0.5902508497238159,
0.4289218783378601,
0.5015763640403748,
0.6879838705062866,
0.6870911717414856,
-0.01663299649953842,
0.27911001443862915,
-0.8040274381637573,
0.4421086609363556,
0.4360376000404358,
0.2822338342666626,
0.344882071018219,
-0.08399640023708344,
0.6029594540596008,
0.25211992859840393,
-0.6383495330810547,
-1.2381012439727783,
0.2972872257232666,
-0.8033251762390137,
-0.5985819697380066,
1.163372278213501,
-0.18510355055332184,
-0.0794920101761818,
-0.037020180374383926,
-0.3047410845756531,
0.28535839915275574,
-0.10602615773677826,
0.7218673229217529,
0.7865089178085327,
0.375711590051651,
0.07746279984712601,
-0.6388436555862427,
0.1649668663740158,
0.6546636819839478,
-0.47097691893577576,
0.20529411733150482,
0.4666196405887604,
0.46579423546791077,
-0.04578237235546112,
0.38733845949172974,
0.12045931071043015,
-0.12025338411331177,
0.21325737237930298,
0.42876866459846497,
-0.1416744440793991,
-0.4077491760253906,
-0.5079395174980164,
0.24776725471019745,
0.2944866716861725,
-0.20843835175037384
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13588v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13588v1
|
Genetic Auto-prompt Learning for Pre-trained Code Intelligence Language Models
| 2024-03-20T13:37:00 | 2024-03-20T13:37:00 |
Chengzhe Feng, Yanan Sun, Ke Li, Pan Zhou, Jiancheng Lv, Aojun Lu
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL
|
As Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs), a popular approach for code
intelligence, continue to grow in size, the computational cost of their usage
has become prohibitively expensive. Prompt learning, a recent development in
the field of natural language processing, emerges as a potential solution to
address this challenge. In this paper, we investigate the effectiveness of
prompt learning in code intelligence tasks. We unveil its reliance on manually
designed prompts, which often require significant human effort and expertise.
Moreover, we discover existing automatic prompt design methods are very limited
to code intelligence tasks due to factors including gradient dependence, high
computational demands, and limited applicability. To effectively address both
issues, we propose Genetic Auto Prompt (GenAP), which utilizes an elaborate
genetic algorithm to automatically design prompts. With GenAP, non-experts can
effortlessly generate superior prompts compared to meticulously manual-designed
ones. GenAP operates without the need for gradients or additional computational
costs, rendering it gradient-free and cost-effective. Moreover, GenAP supports
both understanding and generation types of code intelligence tasks, exhibiting
great applicability. We conduct GenAP on three popular code intelligence PLMs
with three canonical code intelligence tasks including defect prediction, code
summarization, and code translation. The results suggest that GenAP can
effectively automate the process of designing prompts. Specifically, GenAP
outperforms all other methods across all three tasks (e.g., improving accuracy
by an average of 2.13% for defect prediction). To the best of our knowledge,
GenAP is the first work to automatically design prompts for code intelligence
PLMs.
|
[
-0.4151669144630432,
-0.555539071559906,
0.5276427268981934,
0.2801518142223358,
-0.05793986842036247,
0.5263900756835938,
-0.24387383460998535,
-0.12931837141513824,
0.0747617557644844,
0.045186907052993774,
-0.9565761089324951,
-0.5466485023498535,
-0.2958338260650635,
0.40910857915878296,
0.14707553386688232,
0.6880243420600891,
0.008399042300879955,
-0.07690656930208206,
-0.276907354593277,
0.07490960508584976,
-0.8606100678443909,
-0.5042604207992554,
-0.5214388370513916,
0.19914069771766663,
0.5784521698951721,
0.8966176509857178,
0.38950252532958984,
0.6786179542541504,
0.26026082038879395,
0.33256492018699646,
0.22307972609996796,
0.35209721326828003,
-0.181747704744339,
0.16010795533657074,
0.10918335616588593,
-0.4709218442440033,
-0.1627393215894699,
0.3479369282722473,
0.04000266268849373,
0.5011587738990784,
-0.019205249845981598,
0.1928073912858963,
0.15948744118213654,
0.8422577977180481,
-0.3308011591434479,
0.2836320400238037,
-0.5418980717658997,
0.3096838593482971,
0.030541008338332176,
-0.5583966970443726,
-0.41578051447868347,
-0.7002351880073547,
-0.10730104148387909,
-0.7766444683074951,
0.18612201511859894,
0.22097714245319366,
0.4457077085971832,
0.557637631893158,
-0.006224034819751978,
-0.5399642586708069,
-0.4868237376213074,
0.7363284826278687,
-0.479267418384552,
-0.013322495855391026,
0.3925867974758148,
0.28201955556869507,
-0.25569504499435425,
-0.4961615800857544,
-0.4257998764514923,
-0.6151797771453857,
-0.03146588057279587,
-0.0357680469751358,
-0.0706021636724472,
-0.023351913318037987,
0.503572940826416,
0.13940802216529846,
-0.933408796787262,
0.291653573513031,
-0.3796558678150177,
-0.1735655963420868,
0.5416826009750366,
0.14887401461601257,
0.7963773608207703,
-0.10593122988939285,
-0.3466252386569977,
-0.057080741971731186,
-0.6446225643157959,
0.40992140769958496,
0.2903496026992798,
0.19909706711769104,
-0.0978470966219902,
0.10399110615253448,
-0.30107566714286804,
0.6273132562637329,
0.2550255060195923,
0.1467432975769043,
0.433710515499115,
-0.3129822313785553,
0.07841888070106506,
-0.1902925968170166,
0.8669061660766602,
-0.0037784248124808073,
0.6021258234977722,
-0.14569641649723053,
-0.10261580348014832,
-0.01436315756291151,
0.2428291141986847,
-0.6293075680732727,
-0.46739450097084045,
0.04899846389889717,
-0.6637736558914185,
-0.2163049280643463,
-0.10750140249729156,
-1.0267479419708252,
-0.3687456548213959,
-0.3804658353328705,
0.030192917212843895,
-0.44345661997795105,
0.027762454003095627,
-0.25228801369667053,
0.03401483967900276,
0.2992205321788788,
-0.012274960987269878,
-0.8990893959999084,
-0.2989960014820099,
0.25534746050834656,
0.7476450800895691,
-0.030523624271154404,
-0.5004714131355286,
-0.828277051448822,
-0.34665197134017944,
-0.3318508565425873,
1.0283153057098389,
-0.6566031575202942,
-0.714142918586731,
-0.42143768072128296,
-0.2914901673793793,
-0.28957363963127136,
-0.4702550172805786,
0.3273158669471741,
-0.38957276940345764,
0.31782278418540955,
-0.21160082519054413,
-0.3640420436859131,
-0.030108142644166946,
-0.15329861640930176,
-0.41543567180633545,
0.6590343117713928,
0.23230892419815063,
-0.2862994372844696,
0.3587281405925751,
-0.8119804859161377,
-0.6224151849746704,
0.513673722743988,
-0.5099044442176819,
-0.2079756110906601,
0.06551754474639893,
0.5560678243637085,
0.3064451217651367,
-0.1011984795331955,
0.295360267162323,
-0.1414077877998352,
-0.32485541701316833,
0.18818506598472595,
-0.22733047604560852,
0.928991973400116,
0.4587821662425995,
-0.6668589115142822,
0.2656489312648773,
-0.5665572881698608,
0.10998914390802383,
0.2379593402147293,
-0.0038422688376158476,
-0.1529860496520996,
0.012134485878050327,
-0.7090799808502197,
0.35320428013801575,
0.15159578621387482,
-0.26877912878990173,
0.4544955790042877,
-0.38516226410865784,
0.3153055012226105,
0.7676132321357727,
-0.06401944905519485,
0.8013584613800049,
-0.35296890139579773,
0.9216489195823669,
-0.30466827750205994,
0.5445235967636108,
-0.3499758541584015,
-0.7785397171974182,
-0.3564310073852539,
-0.3640208840370178,
0.162313774228096,
0.9333385825157166,
-0.9989572167396545,
0.6952271461486816,
0.2485286444425583,
-0.41423147916793823,
-0.2401844561100006,
0.470984548330307,
0.4128064513206482,
0.5431252717971802,
0.4285263121128082,
-0.06572947651147842,
-0.4026235044002533,
-0.5709818601608276,
-0.3045780062675476,
-0.1171715185046196,
-0.050368309020996094,
0.36247166991233826,
0.2484264224767685,
-0.1790873259305954,
1.1645619869232178,
-0.5207290053367615,
-0.2344179004430771,
-0.4798266887664795,
0.680156946182251,
0.23154309391975403,
0.6036355495452881,
0.8145389556884766,
-0.5460906028747559,
-0.4635774493217468,
-0.39453041553497314,
-0.831909716129303,
-0.482369989156723,
-0.2981928288936615,
-0.034037213772535324,
0.2153993844985962,
0.6330927014350891,
-0.49546509981155396,
0.4811428189277649,
0.4122011065483093,
-0.36954042315483093,
0.49976053833961487,
-0.4758528470993042,
0.1820032149553299,
-0.8144051432609558,
0.10519672185182571,
-0.08738522976636887,
0.1762857735157013,
-0.6160903573036194,
0.10271509736776352,
0.18365930020809174,
-0.32229116559028625,
-0.3679874837398529,
0.5367812514305115,
-0.6727170944213867,
0.11599326878786087,
-0.2135828584432602,
-0.20267817378044128,
-0.14830996096134186,
0.8152394890785217,
-0.23194532096385956,
1.1873246431350708,
0.445495069026947,
-0.7371721863746643,
0.28368523716926575,
0.34492194652557373,
-0.20625059306621552,
0.3649565279483795,
-0.5570275783538818,
0.32902461290359497,
-0.248931884765625,
0.19849005341529846,
-0.9125228524208069,
-0.023297026753425598,
0.5617047548294067,
-0.896174967288971,
0.2904101312160492,
0.03562384471297264,
-0.38101956248283386,
-0.5990796089172363,
-0.3410632312297821,
0.36631959676742554,
1.027871012687683,
-0.7206240892410278,
0.7122899293899536,
0.11233513802289963,
-0.6065067648887634,
-0.37053608894348145,
-0.3821447491645813,
0.1162305623292923,
-0.06460476666688919,
-0.3670462667942047,
0.05027281120419502,
-0.6418089866638184,
0.059354931116104126,
-0.1905643790960312,
0.1587151736021042,
0.04102342203259468,
0.43120911717414856,
0.3420528471469879,
0.5002828240394592,
-0.01654047891497612,
0.09743376821279526,
-0.029522094875574112,
-0.34693390130996704,
0.1942756026983261,
-0.30656537413597107,
0.6321443319320679,
-0.04266955330967903,
-0.1791602224111557,
-0.41774654388427734,
0.48551273345947266,
0.44164183735847473,
-0.6815627813339233,
0.35372382402420044,
0.2539173662662506,
-0.029617687687277794,
-0.7459424138069153,
-0.29821720719337463,
-0.05313631147146225,
-0.5553566217422485,
-0.02935495413839817,
-0.14694619178771973,
-0.5828250050544739,
0.4126971960067749,
-0.049624208360910416,
0.013811692595481873,
0.28442588448524475,
0.32145047187805176,
-0.34904980659484863,
1.2613420486450195,
0.6639857292175293,
-0.23089314997196198,
0.6190492510795593,
-0.12065762281417847,
0.238858163356781,
-0.26104673743247986,
-0.34804728627204895,
-0.7399970889091492,
-0.2354358434677124,
-0.13371670246124268,
-0.3638547658920288,
0.27048903703689575,
0.009573915041983128,
-0.22337880730628967,
0.15448792278766632,
-0.6397120356559753,
0.6712570786476135,
1.0382848978042603,
0.09933029860258102,
0.03628077358007431,
0.05775078386068344,
-0.12513352930545807,
0.24861524999141693,
-0.8692493438720703,
-0.26976487040519714,
0.8689799904823303,
0.1643485575914383,
0.5461788773536682,
-0.45433706045150757,
0.6653952598571777,
0.40525034070014954,
0.27312329411506653,
-0.6059451699256897,
0.6289637684822083,
-0.19873903691768646,
0.0010771957458928227,
-0.10101625323295593,
-0.7550501227378845,
-0.763665497303009,
-0.5995392203330994,
-0.060662489384412766,
-0.24828939139842987,
0.4369890093803406,
0.34767428040504456,
-0.8692449927330017,
0.10145028680562973,
-0.873060405254364,
0.7814564108848572,
-0.5822353363037109,
0.23785312473773956,
-0.08181433379650116,
-0.8342732191085815,
0.07294219732284546,
-0.10337834805250168,
0.24732287228107452,
-0.013219370506703854,
0.1418188065290451,
0.6894546151161194,
-0.3081384599208832,
0.9152163863182068,
-0.42177051305770874,
0.07294163852930069,
0.2732923626899719,
0.07758786529302597,
0.5080837607383728,
0.05853956565260887,
0.17243435978889465,
-0.032357096672058105,
-0.5440143942832947,
-0.36058735847473145,
-0.5342075824737549,
0.45461922883987427,
-0.6165009140968323,
-0.508751630783081,
-0.33619463443756104,
-0.5395634770393372,
-0.3468967080116272,
0.10859654098749161,
0.5229915976524353,
0.5876301527023315,
0.13487449288368225,
-0.31752917170524597,
0.9407410621643066,
-0.8569570779800415,
0.7147497534751892,
0.5237336754798889,
0.08115603774785995,
-0.3306921124458313,
1.1990152597427368,
-0.13433225452899933,
0.09176439791917801,
0.026638276875019073,
0.18689607083797455,
-0.08831906318664551,
-0.6644827127456665,
-0.6963979005813599,
0.00024567526997998357,
-0.5621912479400635,
-0.4955194294452667,
-0.7113962173461914,
-0.2541000247001648,
-0.39383718371391296,
-0.5158876776695251,
0.15241429209709167,
-0.023480210453271866,
-0.7275370955467224,
-0.04101115092635155,
0.4372937083244324,
0.5903900265693665,
0.001984165282920003,
-0.0126442089676857,
-1.0072963237762451,
0.6137246489524841,
0.6138056516647339,
0.4524270296096802,
-0.16538551449775696,
-0.29482007026672363,
0.14740531146526337,
-0.018861157819628716,
0.025441793724894524,
-0.8948948979377747,
0.5015526413917542,
0.27636080980300903,
0.8363739252090454,
0.14933781325817108,
0.24809116125106812,
0.24004904925823212,
-0.5435484051704407,
0.7753136157989502,
0.0576445497572422,
-0.9281643629074097,
0.7793424725532532,
-0.2638031840324402,
0.5210062861442566,
0.8406450152397156,
0.32802510261535645,
-0.17332208156585693,
-0.554860532283783,
-0.4747481048107147,
-0.5898196697235107,
0.5599302053451538,
-0.12913349270820618,
0.1401880532503128,
-0.26630663871765137,
0.3810591995716095,
0.33974751830101013,
0.06779617816209793,
-0.3323579430580139,
-0.2629243731498718,
-0.27766722440719604,
-0.507163405418396,
0.051442451775074005,
-0.17084139585494995,
0.2514503300189972,
-0.34416934847831726,
0.4794602692127228,
-0.40640947222709656,
0.3633023500442505,
0.13358817994594574,
-0.4279860556125641,
-0.0921998992562294,
0.23345401883125305,
0.7159978747367859,
0.517234206199646,
0.05865928530693054,
-0.18529172241687775,
0.04700324684381485,
-0.39444223046302795,
0.12336156517267227,
0.22506113350391388,
-0.2577233612537384,
-0.11581825464963913,
0.15311579406261444,
0.7052633762359619,
0.01855754666030407,
-0.9227527379989624,
0.6921055912971497,
-0.3365163505077362,
-0.2927904725074768,
-0.19591844081878662,
0.22592879831790924,
-0.2838723659515381,
0.19630993902683258,
0.570260763168335,
0.38411492109298706,
0.08231160044670105,
-0.4363406002521515,
0.38282090425491333,
0.3731582462787628,
0.012742338702082634,
-0.11385056376457214,
0.7663060426712036,
0.49205973744392395,
-0.41085928678512573,
0.9244158267974854,
-0.822765052318573,
-0.9167343378067017,
1.0593215227127075,
0.19675488770008087,
1.0387921333312988,
-0.4447115361690521,
0.6378470063209534,
0.25403931736946106,
0.2869991362094879,
0.052104368805885315,
0.46736589074134827,
-0.14330318570137024,
-0.3336350917816162,
-0.4926012456417084,
-0.4561019539833069,
-0.3250981867313385,
-0.31894218921661377,
-0.20484250783920288,
0.1702818125486374,
-0.7388689517974854,
0.2673202455043793,
-0.536080539226532,
-0.09056338667869568,
-0.6994779109954834,
0.16576828062534332,
0.5413172245025635,
1.083519458770752,
-0.7430498600006104,
0.6462845802307129,
0.5334334969520569,
-0.49612390995025635,
-1.0622341632843018,
0.0021668740082532167,
-0.211320698261261,
-0.8942180275917053,
0.7984675168991089,
0.45155736804008484,
-0.00973251461982727,
0.26879945397377014,
-0.6792958378791809,
-0.6251843571662903,
0.7883747816085815,
0.28815725445747375,
-0.553761899471283,
-0.2900107502937317,
-0.08729209005832672,
0.3388449251651764,
-0.4154527187347412,
0.3247360289096832,
0.4077757000923157,
0.39449599385261536,
-0.07436493784189224,
-0.6037693023681641,
0.10558517277240753,
-0.5720553398132324,
-0.14882077276706696,
0.1258331835269928,
-0.4214332699775696,
0.8490810990333557,
-0.5791237950325012,
-0.5187186598777771,
0.25449657440185547,
0.6621338129043579,
0.3551190197467804,
0.40807023644447327,
0.6583879590034485,
0.10681021958589554,
0.8475876450538635,
0.07187589257955551,
0.9034269452095032,
-0.6918569803237915,
0.07698050141334534,
0.7809514999389648,
-0.16491883993148804,
0.31516602635383606,
0.06462319195270538,
0.13963830471038818,
0.7097411155700684,
0.6504726409912109,
-0.1764223575592041,
0.5390526056289673,
0.15201471745967865,
-0.007693164516240358,
-0.08289775997400284,
0.0253764595836401,
-0.41745835542678833,
0.05613487586379051,
0.22827933728694916,
-0.271757036447525,
0.011811305768787861,
0.4356670677661896,
-0.11974973976612091,
0.22881948947906494,
-0.5646824240684509,
0.8449872136116028,
-0.059487782418727875,
-0.7852468490600586,
0.38383597135543823,
-0.4506070017814636,
0.8512270450592041,
-0.6563394069671631,
-0.12328533828258514,
-0.6536571979522705,
-0.24181292951107025,
-0.11961985379457474,
-0.45597130060195923,
0.056238945573568344,
0.1768006533384323,
-0.1815364509820938,
-0.515687108039856,
0.588527262210846,
-0.3138777017593384,
-0.3488311469554901,
0.21564863622188568,
0.4819587767124176,
-0.26561957597732544,
-0.09383895248174667,
-0.7405236959457397,
-0.3820474445819855,
-0.019587039947509766,
-0.18964843451976776,
0.1228366494178772,
0.20763857662677765,
0.08275414258241653,
0.7293825149536133,
0.6864744424819946,
0.11900459975004196,
0.28041431307792664,
-0.07592608779668808,
0.8298420310020447,
-0.7060295343399048,
-0.7466134428977966,
-0.7305841445922852,
0.3646750748157501,
-0.04159277677536011,
-0.2927367091178894,
0.5315037965774536,
0.13259458541870117,
0.6116027235984802,
-0.2526070773601532,
1.064575433731079,
-0.08134500682353973,
0.5000380873680115,
-0.6997052431106567,
0.500587522983551,
-0.24368922412395477,
0.29120755195617676,
-0.006473534274846315,
-0.6976115107536316,
-0.34880906343460083,
0.41363728046417236,
-0.35745254158973694,
0.22827915847301483,
0.8337723016738892,
0.7445329427719116,
0.3027097284793854,
0.18636880815029144,
0.05471576377749443,
-0.117645263671875,
0.18640433251857758,
0.9404265284538269,
1.176011085510254,
0.2932788133621216,
0.46721482276916504,
-0.2625942826271057,
-0.6509311199188232,
-0.15944762527942657,
-0.7522764801979065,
-1.030253529548645,
-0.37047266960144043,
-0.1931733787059784,
0.04802665114402771,
0.1499256193637848,
1.394439697265625,
0.45650824904441833,
-0.862784743309021,
0.17805439233779907,
-0.38224995136260986,
-0.019928811118006706,
-0.28067630529403687,
-0.17869651317596436,
0.23984335362911224,
-1.005324125289917,
-0.4634456932544708,
0.8414070010185242,
0.3356602191925049,
0.016621246933937073,
-0.1416304111480713,
-0.027372492477297783,
0.12488165497779846,
-0.08768545091152191,
0.2576290965080261,
0.8561931252479553,
-0.2715579569339752,
-0.1656172126531601,
0.326783150434494,
-0.26299887895584106,
0.15579643845558167,
1.1022979021072388,
-1.1924322843551636,
0.22516360878944397,
0.6621642112731934,
0.9814635515213013,
-0.47107380628585815,
0.15915869176387787,
0.8944149613380432,
-0.6704148054122925,
-0.08281166106462479,
0.33372530341148376,
0.28495287895202637,
0.09168171137571335,
-0.749920129776001,
0.3261776566505432,
0.3066116273403168,
-0.7065946459770203,
-0.48949116468429565,
0.39169272780418396,
-0.6654108166694641,
-0.5805104970932007,
1.0364636182785034,
-0.0034013520926237106,
-0.21007263660430908,
-0.27147841453552246,
-0.40024203062057495,
0.18710331618785858,
-0.3634658753871918,
0.717958927154541,
0.10675658285617828,
-0.06586047261953354,
-0.30411064624786377,
-0.4892427325248718,
0.7420728206634521,
0.5818263292312622,
-1.1427757740020752,
-0.0017803757218644023,
0.4571877717971802,
0.03464113920927048,
-0.11985981464385986,
0.5280882120132446,
0.1871843934059143,
0.668740451335907,
-0.43637150526046753,
0.20796528458595276,
-0.4759434163570404,
-0.7030602097511292,
-0.7448107600212097,
0.26087310910224915,
0.05963573232293129,
-0.20653635263442993
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13583v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13583v2
|
CoCoST: Automatic Complex Code Generation with Online Searching and Correctness Testing
| 2024-03-20T13:33:55 | 2024-07-01T09:59:47 |
Xinyi He, Jiaru Zou, Yun Lin, Mengyu Zhou, Shi Han, Zejian Yuan, Dongmei Zhang
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models have revolutionized code generation ability by
converting natural language descriptions into executable code. However,
generating complex code within real-world scenarios remains challenging due to
intricate structures, subtle bugs, understanding of advanced data types, and
lack of supplementary contents. To address these challenges, we introduce the
CoCoST framework, which enhances complex code generation by online searching
for more information with planned queries and correctness testing for code
refinement. Moreover, CoCoST serializes the complex inputs and outputs to
improve comprehension and generates test cases to ensure the adaptability for
real-world applications. CoCoST is validated through rigorous experiments on
the DS-1000 and ClassEval datasets. Experimental results show that CoCoST
substantially improves the quality of complex code generation, highlighting its
potential to enhance the practicality of LLMs in generating complex code.
|
[
-0.6310063004493713,
-1.0806113481521606,
0.23326770961284637,
0.5546987652778625,
-0.0891527533531189,
0.40727517008781433,
-0.4293249845504761,
-0.6050958633422852,
-0.04520617052912712,
0.30880478024482727,
-0.49964287877082825,
-0.6322878003120422,
-0.05357861891388893,
0.36143699288368225,
-0.5990614295005798,
0.8525330424308777,
-0.39543500542640686,
0.028490059077739716,
-0.23217032849788666,
0.30124419927597046,
-0.3228665292263031,
-0.6459264755249023,
-0.49329230189323425,
0.20334719121456146,
0.315028578042984,
0.6566605567932129,
0.48008567094802856,
0.4816156327724457,
0.71209317445755,
0.17654016613960266,
0.40299609303474426,
0.5475906729698181,
-0.5246017575263977,
0.6244617104530334,
-0.004151041153818369,
-0.5019360184669495,
-0.36950331926345825,
-0.5325378179550171,
-0.011268633417785168,
0.4116552770137787,
-0.06560418754816055,
0.20713266730308533,
-0.0893787145614624,
0.4989732801914215,
-0.6951494216918945,
0.3255331516265869,
-0.6782617568969727,
0.27523645758628845,
-0.10568080842494965,
-0.5334258079528809,
-0.1658412516117096,
-0.7872669100761414,
-0.05704941600561142,
-0.3634551167488098,
0.7323346138000488,
0.26454997062683105,
0.7754328846931458,
0.18430329859256744,
-0.41071733832359314,
-0.6939210891723633,
-0.8246217966079712,
0.4069640338420868,
-0.7500504851341248,
0.3385220468044281,
0.2511653006076813,
0.6650898456573486,
-0.3506442904472351,
-0.9778038263320923,
-0.7038982510566711,
-0.6299488544464111,
0.18948398530483246,
0.06821237504482269,
0.32014214992523193,
0.26372653245925903,
0.5023981332778931,
0.5908728837966919,
-0.7013413310050964,
-0.43866440653800964,
-0.42023298144340515,
-0.12620113790035248,
0.780321478843689,
0.23205889761447906,
0.5782565474510193,
0.11723767966032028,
0.1294870674610138,
0.01631343923509121,
-1.0745866298675537,
-0.025626348331570625,
0.5079699754714966,
0.19327136874198914,
0.1968107968568802,
0.8521876335144043,
-0.3483503758907318,
0.8634935617446899,
-0.07298991829156876,
0.0738692581653595,
-0.1462278813123703,
-0.27280962467193604,
-0.27753573656082153,
0.43377572298049927,
0.2738420069217682,
0.24180367588996887,
0.26862043142318726,
-0.07039453834295273,
-0.25286635756492615,
0.28054386377334595,
0.48426949977874756,
-0.8250265717506409,
-0.3543998897075653,
0.41451600193977356,
0.07824539393186569,
-0.6886300444602966,
0.424030601978302,
-0.46334782242774963,
0.04631243273615837,
-0.5007922053337097,
-0.11427613347768784,
-0.28152909874916077,
-0.060853876173496246,
0.32607167959213257,
0.05782610923051834,
0.21556125581264496,
0.2801875174045563,
-0.5295425653457642,
0.2424391210079193,
0.4920126795768738,
0.6157529950141907,
-0.2441914677619934,
-0.03332528844475746,
-0.5550937056541443,
0.12449444830417633,
-0.5107520818710327,
0.7923765182495117,
-0.24435953795909882,
-0.0940634161233902,
0.0985521748661995,
-0.17086485028266907,
0.04581945389509201,
-0.7151733040809631,
0.3292986750602722,
-0.739244818687439,
-0.07852715253829956,
-0.22422859072685242,
-0.5160815715789795,
0.00556178530678153,
0.7726565599441528,
-0.6105378866195679,
1.2160546779632568,
0.32567867636680603,
-0.7950479388237,
0.17397567629814148,
-0.8449062705039978,
-0.7010127902030945,
-0.03437332436442375,
-0.2809333801269531,
-0.7005000114440918,
-0.05872742831707001,
0.11596783995628357,
0.3844522535800934,
-0.38745197653770447,
0.4708809554576874,
-0.39618614315986633,
-0.5213907957077026,
0.23425421118736267,
-0.15866757929325104,
0.37873682379722595,
0.5435765385627747,
-0.8619922995567322,
0.04151812195777893,
-0.8562474250793457,
0.2359183430671692,
0.34575241804122925,
-0.6223958730697632,
0.155588299036026,
0.04118599742650986,
0.1996344029903412,
0.21763673424720764,
-0.0695546343922615,
-0.5347686409950256,
0.4866202771663666,
-0.40780675411224365,
0.4610365331172943,
0.3031250536441803,
0.19872111082077026,
0.020900148898363113,
-0.335612028837204,
0.8308944702148438,
-0.0388311967253685,
0.3736727237701416,
-0.2172975093126297,
-0.2854710519313812,
-1.2195117473602295,
-0.12664596736431122,
0.1864386647939682,
0.7226560711860657,
-0.7220463752746582,
0.49170663952827454,
-0.07655240595340729,
-0.36459988355636597,
-0.36172640323638916,
0.1408085972070694,
0.40353116393089294,
0.17890289425849915,
0.2198818325996399,
-0.2468721717596054,
-0.8683444261550903,
-0.7494697570800781,
-0.15479245781898499,
0.29899126291275024,
-0.017342764884233475,
0.1897510141134262,
0.38321325182914734,
-0.6482427716255188,
1.2394126653671265,
-0.7747816443443298,
0.07159367948770523,
-0.19549685716629028,
-0.05222255736589432,
-0.1976993978023529,
0.44273871183395386,
0.30182480812072754,
-1.0174192190170288,
-0.4327062964439392,
0.08206309378147125,
-0.5949350595474243,
-0.13935719430446625,
-0.16907255351543427,
-0.060774631798267365,
0.049512822180986404,
0.6391423940658569,
-0.23167817294597626,
0.2836219370365143,
0.4833102822303772,
-0.027789369225502014,
0.7868890762329102,
-0.2102261334657669,
0.36744675040245056,
-1.0449721813201904,
0.33093011379241943,
-0.535294771194458,
-0.57912677526474,
-0.3511371910572052,
0.7190473079681396,
0.2358819544315338,
-0.33946701884269714,
-0.5830234885215759,
0.04209279641509056,
-0.5888660550117493,
-0.41113901138305664,
0.08358887583017349,
0.22036662697792053,
0.17414496839046478,
0.29910746216773987,
-0.2527240514755249,
0.9788545370101929,
0.3109472095966339,
-0.8278316855430603,
0.8800060153007507,
-0.2082173377275467,
-0.54912930727005,
0.308726966381073,
-0.5937557816505432,
0.22229626774787903,
-0.010880199261009693,
0.2939341962337494,
-0.7968879342079163,
-0.6721761226654053,
-0.04515276104211807,
-0.16239888966083527,
0.18477141857147217,
0.1085231751203537,
-0.7189023494720459,
-0.5611154437065125,
-0.239958718419075,
0.5749729871749878,
0.08269927650690079,
-0.472247838973999,
0.22695492208003998,
-0.025982270017266273,
-0.11910024285316467,
-0.30191823840141296,
-0.703953742980957,
0.16772553324699402,
0.18611042201519012,
-0.7879096269607544,
0.09807514399290085,
-0.5730723738670349,
-0.2355770319700241,
-0.2342360019683838,
-0.07657267898321152,
-0.1984061747789383,
0.1886095553636551,
0.23534533381462097,
0.1091511994600296,
-0.42071208357810974,
-0.07761634886264801,
0.4252675175666809,
0.1135854497551918,
-0.16348610818386078,
-0.332270085811615,
0.8131992816925049,
-0.2734999656677246,
-0.8312343955039978,
0.0003628426347859204,
0.2236766219139099,
0.5692936778068542,
-0.3894151747226715,
0.16469909250736237,
0.5008998513221741,
-0.4432165324687958,
-0.5745327472686768,
-0.6587083339691162,
0.045428771525621414,
-0.43298831582069397,
0.29880836606025696,
-0.6603013277053833,
-1.0233973264694214,
0.5301375985145569,
-0.34529227018356323,
0.1849355250597,
0.33125683665275574,
0.4608716666698456,
0.2097271829843521,
1.2383073568344116,
0.28508469462394714,
0.5729981064796448,
0.08830395340919495,
-0.44284021854400635,
0.5838790535926819,
-0.5896028280258179,
-0.40669724345207214,
-0.4530112147331238,
0.11862211674451828,
-0.33507996797561646,
-0.5052498579025269,
0.1425507366657257,
0.5059186816215515,
-0.29429686069488525,
0.5825541019439697,
-0.801911473274231,
0.6545217633247375,
0.3329617381095886,
0.16222326457500458,
0.4415358006954193,
-0.03840169683098793,
-0.3281157612800598,
0.11839540302753448,
-0.5838662981987,
-0.48858585953712463,
0.6754615902900696,
-0.08237231522798538,
0.7415581345558167,
0.20941531658172607,
0.4789319634437561,
0.4880554974079132,
0.39046457409858704,
-0.6523406505584717,
0.22247761487960815,
0.3551320433616638,
-0.6909927725791931,
0.18792089819908142,
-0.30200883746147156,
-0.8788503408432007,
-0.1649886965751648,
-0.08733446896076202,
0.004541357979178429,
-0.05093243718147278,
0.4180980324745178,
-0.38814252614974976,
0.10978812724351883,
-0.6100770831108093,
0.6618828177452087,
-0.4757351279258728,
-0.22658313810825348,
-0.01834959350526333,
-0.44822198152542114,
0.6612323522567749,
-0.4109415113925934,
0.2609948217868805,
0.10324722528457642,
0.10015653818845749,
0.19327105581760406,
-0.4505147337913513,
0.6123440265655518,
0.3718530833721161,
-0.1567845344543457,
0.5225078463554382,
0.842549204826355,
0.6178748607635498,
0.3068488836288452,
-0.11598265171051025,
-0.24707181751728058,
-0.0651678815484047,
-0.5171117782592773,
-0.4689580500125885,
1.0525569915771484,
-0.486474871635437,
-0.39059290289878845,
-0.26732388138771057,
-0.3983166813850403,
-0.08773265033960342,
0.42713984847068787,
0.5290809869766235,
0.49487507343292236,
-0.20294219255447388,
0.02213023602962494,
0.847253680229187,
-0.4522366523742676,
-0.04592093452811241,
0.0895872712135315,
-0.4973962604999542,
-0.33891919255256653,
0.9372140765190125,
-0.04974319040775299,
0.509627103805542,
0.42764952778816223,
-0.17103654146194458,
-0.14601558446884155,
-0.2554156184196472,
-0.6101602911949158,
-0.24461819231510162,
-0.7506089806556702,
-0.44784119725227356,
-0.6186729073524475,
-0.24361447989940643,
-0.5677236914634705,
-0.7912963032722473,
-0.3612750172615051,
-0.471363365650177,
-0.16187945008277893,
-0.29943373799324036,
0.142759770154953,
1.010683298110962,
0.4221368730068207,
0.06578182429075241,
-0.9243199825286865,
0.37317678332328796,
0.3600696325302124,
0.4070063531398773,
-0.09182048588991165,
0.2723664939403534,
-0.13725046813488007,
0.20010444521903992,
-0.537133514881134,
-0.6752884387969971,
0.2799004316329956,
0.15165042877197266,
0.2527279555797577,
0.3722001612186432,
0.3389657735824585,
0.8626574277877808,
-0.21734295785427094,
0.862022340297699,
0.12608473002910614,
-1.0737345218658447,
0.5335018038749695,
-0.3463253676891327,
0.18524670600891113,
0.41526538133621216,
0.11636966466903687,
-0.375402569770813,
-0.6106978058815002,
-0.7207751274108887,
-0.922507107257843,
0.4082845449447632,
0.5393677949905396,
-0.16723179817199707,
-0.0708986148238182,
0.5541172027587891,
0.003100136062130332,
0.1968359798192978,
-0.4535125195980072,
-0.026691870763897896,
-0.25636357069015503,
-0.37341174483299255,
0.25251010060310364,
-0.14403457939624786,
0.06127990037202835,
-0.02292751707136631,
0.507377028465271,
-0.2088913768529892,
0.271303653717041,
0.5430969595909119,
-0.3764035105705261,
-0.1891949623823166,
0.2064032256603241,
0.8944347500801086,
0.6471365094184875,
-0.14095459878444672,
0.3153589963912964,
0.39134207367897034,
-0.31566673517227173,
0.070623978972435,
-0.33723968267440796,
-0.09324756264686584,
-0.2689168453216553,
0.417327344417572,
0.49610790610313416,
0.3171127438545227,
-1.1826326847076416,
0.6124390959739685,
-0.3243282735347748,
-0.03881607577204704,
-0.7065209150314331,
0.4792752265930176,
0.16017505526542664,
-0.08289148658514023,
0.25357139110565186,
0.3595297336578369,
0.25283586978912354,
-0.5412489175796509,
0.5094139575958252,
-0.017559435218572617,
-0.4356692433357239,
-0.07710878551006317,
0.679774284362793,
0.1937587410211563,
-0.3002403676509857,
0.6795660853385925,
-0.42695799469947815,
-0.7384529709815979,
0.9024157524108887,
0.7693120837211609,
0.7225461006164551,
-0.0735664963722229,
-0.07952690869569778,
0.4219210147857666,
0.18798048794269562,
-0.1658654808998108,
0.3230953514575958,
-0.2506924569606781,
-0.2888709008693695,
-0.39521628618240356,
-0.7156928181648254,
-0.28385496139526367,
-0.37286582589149475,
-0.5254520177841187,
0.564391016960144,
-0.6901171207427979,
0.07311884313821793,
-0.5401477217674255,
-0.06979788839817047,
-0.6318120956420898,
0.33588340878486633,
-0.12954293191432953,
0.9928140044212341,
-0.3958125412464142,
0.6323503851890564,
0.5195146799087524,
-0.5514627695083618,
-0.8364518284797668,
-0.0986124575138092,
-0.180831640958786,
-0.6299480199813843,
0.5854756832122803,
0.23843950033187866,
-0.1980733424425125,
0.2594462037086487,
-0.7086023092269897,
-0.6851297616958618,
1.2012875080108643,
0.6779764294624329,
-0.9466239213943481,
0.030617160722613335,
0.34466904401779175,
0.4651109278202057,
-0.511035144329071,
0.22916801273822784,
0.30830326676368713,
0.4121756851673126,
0.2793612480163574,
-0.6424166560173035,
0.058625515550374985,
-0.2384050041437149,
0.19833824038505554,
0.1909535825252533,
-0.2733597755432129,
0.75254887342453,
-0.38476330041885376,
-0.3068689703941345,
-0.07374527305364609,
0.21524371206760406,
0.4437381625175476,
0.13668103516101837,
0.3038615882396698,
0.29575252532958984,
0.6795808672904968,
-0.16048729419708252,
1.1871980428695679,
-0.5060053467750549,
0.5646419525146484,
0.8856279253959656,
-0.43963173031806946,
0.6070722341537476,
0.09964939206838608,
0.078070729970932,
0.45558270812034607,
0.9346110820770264,
-0.029729899019002914,
0.06052612140774727,
0.6985498666763306,
-0.3849855363368988,
-0.4082207679748535,
0.13912531733512878,
-0.40973761677742004,
-0.06287519633769989,
0.22114570438861847,
-0.058815184980630875,
-0.17089976370334625,
0.13452477753162384,
0.06778460741043091,
0.07766024768352509,
0.01408865861594677,
0.616054117679596,
0.02889326773583889,
-0.6364938020706177,
0.6037254333496094,
0.22799061238765717,
0.4512121379375458,
-0.5344878435134888,
-0.2559466063976288,
-0.28398388624191284,
0.4719363749027252,
-0.5975074768066406,
-0.38822802901268005,
0.4370836615562439,
0.09177827090024948,
0.0654764175415039,
0.27731290459632874,
0.6121709942817688,
-0.4590032398700714,
-0.5488583445549011,
0.3590480387210846,
0.10844016820192337,
0.03655922785401344,
-0.3050280809402466,
-0.7411271929740906,
0.23506563901901245,
0.24872955679893494,
-0.2355414181947708,
0.058017436414957047,
0.2826167643070221,
-0.20546042919158936,
0.7312464714050293,
1.1422275304794312,
0.15216918289661407,
0.582400918006897,
-0.03993977606296539,
0.9531938433647156,
-0.5968309640884399,
-0.3742525577545166,
-0.5567250847816467,
0.285003125667572,
-0.12703420221805573,
-0.15098045766353607,
0.6481661200523376,
1.074913501739502,
1.2038463354110718,
-0.3698767125606537,
0.9211296439170837,
-0.3173644244670868,
0.06737568974494934,
-0.34935247898101807,
0.5645055770874023,
-0.2746126353740692,
0.3633821904659271,
-0.20425575971603394,
-1.288172721862793,
-0.9080417156219482,
0.5114710927009583,
0.06674788147211075,
-0.31537559628486633,
0.8086678385734558,
1.049942135810852,
-0.5120571851730347,
-0.05992422625422478,
0.32312262058258057,
0.0759412944316864,
0.9380524158477783,
0.40177297592163086,
0.7142665386199951,
-0.5681507587432861,
0.6960798501968384,
-0.2434377819299698,
-0.1701877862215042,
-0.5175642967224121,
-0.693689227104187,
-0.7291012406349182,
-0.3879174292087555,
-0.18127156794071198,
-0.4289793074131012,
0.07130369544029236,
1.3152554035186768,
0.7730664014816284,
-1.0407049655914307,
-0.2733018696308136,
-0.6803701519966125,
-0.11820916831493378,
-0.2049531489610672,
-0.3181755840778351,
0.29973459243774414,
-0.7062016129493713,
-0.5844148993492126,
0.2526533901691437,
0.3632810413837433,
0.018886661157011986,
-0.30939894914627075,
-0.39996102452278137,
0.04536546394228935,
0.18251082301139832,
0.8485826253890991,
0.0904514417052269,
-0.42837536334991455,
-0.0849238783121109,
0.12821878492832184,
-0.4041524827480316,
-0.062370192259550095,
1.3422527313232422,
-0.315018892288208,
0.6917695999145508,
0.5882206559181213,
0.6429113149642944,
0.6262691617012024,
-0.06807953119277954,
0.6443570852279663,
-0.5658234357833862,
-0.0495891273021698,
0.4190628230571747,
0.30664363503456116,
0.3095816373825073,
-0.5325443744659424,
0.4446465075016022,
0.23710443079471588,
-0.47472450137138367,
-0.8337869048118591,
0.4532303512096405,
-1.0489592552185059,
-0.23861902952194214,
1.0346802473068237,
-0.19013579189777374,
-0.21135805547237396,
-0.5478750467300415,
-0.7279826998710632,
0.5180498361587524,
-0.15922148525714874,
0.875006914138794,
0.3802695870399475,
-0.16179998219013214,
0.11043217033147812,
-0.43942612409591675,
0.5892014503479004,
-0.046865109354257584,
-1.1216638088226318,
0.09968661516904831,
0.45624834299087524,
0.49201616644859314,
0.07589461654424667,
0.252699077129364,
-0.15627248585224152,
0.3075910806655884,
-0.12917043268680573,
0.4113982319831848,
-0.29635217785835266,
-0.18165718019008636,
0.13048580288887024,
0.38882651925086975,
0.33134737610816956,
0.39891424775123596
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13578v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13578v1
|
Dynamic Reward Adjustment in Multi-Reward Reinforcement Learning for Counselor Reflection Generation
| 2024-03-20T13:24:41 | 2024-03-20T13:24:41 |
Do June Min, Veronica Perez-Rosas, Kenneth Resnicow, Rada Mihalcea
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In this paper, we study the problem of multi-reward reinforcement learning to
jointly optimize for multiple text qualities for natural language generation.
We focus on the task of counselor reflection generation, where we optimize the
generators to simultaneously improve the fluency, coherence, and reflection
quality of generated counselor responses. We introduce two novel bandit
methods, DynaOpt and C-DynaOpt, which rely on the broad strategy of combining
rewards into a single value and optimizing them simultaneously. Specifically,
we employ non-contextual and contextual multi-arm bandits to dynamically adjust
multiple reward weights during training. Through automatic and manual
evaluations, we show that our proposed techniques, DynaOpt and C-DynaOpt,
outperform existing naive and bandit baselines, showcasing their potential for
enhancing language models.
|
[
-0.3396221697330475,
-0.7442129254341125,
0.4384205639362335,
0.35543856024742126,
-0.15196488797664642,
0.753362238407135,
-0.3965052366256714,
-0.2876948416233063,
0.3540586531162262,
0.27124929428100586,
-0.7411724925041199,
-0.22850248217582703,
-0.8917045593261719,
0.14281709492206573,
0.08133318275213242,
1.4982107877731323,
-0.26847055554389954,
-0.03910493105649948,
0.2715863287448883,
-0.20096707344055176,
-0.8263350129127502,
-0.39683958888053894,
-0.785927951335907,
-0.13739803433418274,
0.8202429413795471,
0.3252963721752167,
0.5634243488311768,
0.18229368329048157,
0.2622871696949005,
0.4192032814025879,
0.14395025372505188,
0.37580063939094543,
-0.6962107419967651,
0.3890568017959595,
-0.1721532642841339,
-0.09796322882175446,
-0.4555574655532837,
0.1914859265089035,
0.7382193207740784,
0.2096475511789322,
-0.4228207468986511,
-0.07273612916469574,
0.36066776514053345,
0.4851459860801697,
-0.8612063527107239,
0.24970132112503052,
-0.7030227184295654,
-0.15847818553447723,
0.06640681624412537,
-0.5553374290466309,
-0.41773536801338196,
-0.6301599740982056,
0.34232833981513977,
-0.8311218023300171,
0.047096364200115204,
-0.16683465242385864,
0.7630097270011902,
0.46789687871932983,
-0.7227849960327148,
-0.5905287265777588,
-0.5982193946838379,
1.1351286172866821,
-0.3992745280265808,
-0.26618289947509766,
-0.03395754098892212,
0.3382822573184967,
-0.3733137547969818,
-0.497393399477005,
-0.31939998269081116,
-0.46601417660713196,
-0.18506358563899994,
0.372836172580719,
0.09450098127126694,
0.2688277065753937,
0.049472250044345856,
0.48411664366722107,
-0.19926555454730988,
-0.03167537972331047,
-0.07442913949489594,
-0.09799019992351532,
0.894723117351532,
0.21082612872123718,
0.13641701638698578,
0.058218490332365036,
-0.5895898938179016,
-0.7557148933410645,
-0.4545283317565918,
0.3941391408443451,
0.7439330220222473,
0.438212126493454,
0.1125737875699997,
0.2537281811237335,
0.1958926022052765,
0.864616334438324,
0.2708703279495239,
-0.671108067035675,
0.0358826220035553,
-0.3230464458465576,
0.19352062046527863,
0.4363913834095001,
0.6683200001716614,
0.15167276561260223,
-0.12319343537092209,
0.019456859678030014,
-0.4619556665420532,
0.0346340537071228,
0.6282321214675903,
-0.4743351936340332,
-0.3487343490123749,
0.018278352916240692,
-0.35737478733062744,
-0.7952063679695129,
-0.037064000964164734,
-1.1343939304351807,
-0.2886853814125061,
-0.4398444890975952,
0.7341009378433228,
-0.30327507853507996,
-0.41040804982185364,
0.0840906947851181,
-0.4705118238925934,
-0.039411067962646484,
0.3333972692489624,
-1.306167721748352,
0.3867252767086029,
0.36563628911972046,
0.6128631234169006,
-0.33033043146133423,
-0.4314596354961395,
-0.9438490271568298,
0.17703744769096375,
-0.017699386924505234,
0.7172533273696899,
-0.4906565546989441,
-0.2273859679698944,
0.09965699911117554,
-0.39331743121147156,
-0.33720940351486206,
-0.2558118999004364,
0.45544612407684326,
-0.27630218863487244,
0.5557865500450134,
-0.1258433610200882,
-0.37413930892944336,
-0.02719244360923767,
0.38576212525367737,
-0.7437057495117188,
1.1431515216827393,
0.5284110307693481,
-0.9081407785415649,
0.5706247091293335,
-0.6358093619346619,
-0.298255056142807,
-0.0240558460354805,
-0.13269396126270294,
-0.41010990738868713,
0.2562794089317322,
0.2197321206331253,
0.08816393464803696,
0.2112547904253006,
0.5679783225059509,
-0.023169614374637604,
-0.6165058016777039,
0.35660237073898315,
-0.622126042842865,
0.504871129989624,
-0.05447004362940788,
-0.45574820041656494,
0.2303173989057541,
-0.7872560620307922,
0.10259967297315598,
0.03666273131966591,
-0.8603124618530273,
-0.18370763957500458,
0.18341758847236633,
0.07344856858253479,
0.15637673437595367,
0.21093271672725677,
-0.41750213503837585,
0.5182988047599792,
-0.5786222219467163,
0.06658840924501419,
1.0007752180099487,
0.11783086508512497,
0.1468861997127533,
-0.33359983563423157,
0.7507148385047913,
-0.3906983733177185,
-0.15638114511966705,
-0.09881936758756638,
0.06870315223932266,
-0.5794104337692261,
-0.7136963605880737,
0.35871458053588867,
0.6109266877174377,
-1.294252872467041,
0.3113187551498413,
0.0313122421503067,
-0.38590240478515625,
-0.4672813415527344,
-0.19271525740623474,
0.6200122237205505,
0.050571512430906296,
0.5836287140846252,
-0.277439147233963,
-0.3840654790401459,
-0.5484138131141663,
-0.8783735632896423,
-0.056501418352127075,
-0.004849843680858612,
0.10746139287948608,
0.367940753698349,
0.24108776450157166,
0.6729546189308167,
-0.8099054098129272,
-0.17352919280529022,
-0.29136261343955994,
0.608302652835846,
0.2716018259525299,
0.3733360469341278,
0.776198148727417,
-0.6877400875091553,
-0.6505371928215027,
-0.48471811413764954,
-0.2114885449409485,
0.1146521046757698,
-0.48680219054222107,
0.055892255157232285,
0.03622005879878998,
0.13278158009052277,
-0.10315828770399094,
0.21251098811626434,
0.8476306796073914,
-0.25510796904563904,
0.6753584146499634,
-0.464513897895813,
0.3057078421115875,
-0.8762288093566895,
-0.25431933999061584,
-0.1459471732378006,
-0.21195289492607117,
-0.6511584520339966,
-0.17496323585510254,
-0.23070251941680908,
0.20230472087860107,
-0.21905517578125,
0.47951218485832214,
-0.4263773262500763,
0.2314901351928711,
-0.56684410572052,
0.3934244215488434,
-0.06823345273733139,
0.8867890238761902,
0.007196035701781511,
0.6868254542350769,
0.5448127388954163,
-0.6318875551223755,
0.7959607839584351,
0.31514665484428406,
-0.20927703380584717,
0.6815369725227356,
-0.46504703164100647,
-0.04713672399520874,
-0.12519557774066925,
0.6346808671951294,
-0.9280502796173096,
-0.20841239392757416,
0.23492693901062012,
-0.29674020409584045,
0.49150457978248596,
0.005219683982431889,
-0.2358846515417099,
-0.18025612831115723,
-0.7136316299438477,
0.33846771717071533,
0.08477140963077545,
-0.8538264036178589,
0.19041167199611664,
0.306763619184494,
-0.39066770672798157,
-0.9195078611373901,
-0.19996345043182373,
0.13479700684547424,
-0.26150575280189514,
-0.28552743792533875,
0.8661566972732544,
0.08443132042884827,
-0.07676979154348373,
-0.09812083840370178,
-0.03194727748632431,
0.24272800981998444,
0.14655925333499908,
-0.24073398113250732,
0.30042847990989685,
0.21643973886966705,
0.3936136066913605,
0.5375367999076843,
-0.3214779198169708,
-0.18530116975307465,
-0.2687796354293823,
0.48494574427604675,
-0.10250238329172134,
-0.19282379746437073,
0.0022750990465283394,
0.3629041314125061,
-0.061081673949956894,
-0.39296799898147583,
0.9839497804641724,
0.770757794380188,
0.0704265758395195,
-0.21657943725585938,
-0.20230479538440704,
-0.29473742842674255,
-0.5350543260574341,
0.2301923930644989,
-0.24661731719970703,
-1.1206457614898682,
0.1577436327934265,
-0.14851625263690948,
0.3806370794773102,
0.2856379747390747,
0.7457615733146667,
0.2167174518108368,
1.3371742963790894,
0.6545829176902771,
0.327292799949646,
0.8582550883293152,
-0.07750723510980606,
0.40891343355178833,
-0.6963556408882141,
-0.09154428541660309,
-0.34839731454849243,
-0.4099472463130951,
-1.1470752954483032,
0.04714512452483177,
0.63047856092453,
0.1618165820837021,
-0.031317390501499176,
0.2866086959838867,
-0.8088042140007019,
0.23635007441043854,
0.7222940921783447,
0.073795847594738,
0.23412638902664185,
-0.14404037594795227,
-0.29271936416625977,
0.015818215906620026,
-0.6484696269035339,
-0.6677441596984863,
0.7573593854904175,
0.06947053968906403,
0.6590729355812073,
0.24438926577568054,
0.9909029006958008,
-0.0005615301197394729,
0.39771899580955505,
-0.614293098449707,
0.1980937421321869,
-0.058562982827425,
-0.4907279312610626,
-0.5167547464370728,
-0.4790678322315216,
-1.038196325302124,
0.611932635307312,
-0.5037394165992737,
-0.8013231754302979,
0.190875843167305,
0.48493942618370056,
-0.48697927594184875,
0.1546820104122162,
-0.35953378677368164,
0.8779182434082031,
-0.523605227470398,
-0.5683595538139343,
-0.4104437828063965,
-0.5092504620552063,
0.5497834086418152,
0.03133242577314377,
-0.07688305526971817,
-0.274619996547699,
0.04544762894511223,
0.438729465007782,
-0.23099678754806519,
0.4724597632884979,
-0.39530107378959656,
-0.3667314052581787,
0.23737365007400513,
-0.007064910139888525,
0.5397172570228577,
0.36451253294944763,
0.01878858171403408,
-0.44005101919174194,
0.38252225518226624,
-0.4710238575935364,
-0.45745038986206055,
0.5490736961364746,
-0.5554736256599426,
-0.27744582295417786,
-0.7342818379402161,
-0.6930969953536987,
-0.2933846414089203,
-0.013804933056235313,
0.19707483053207397,
0.5818458199501038,
-0.5391231179237366,
-0.1840924173593521,
0.45453083515167236,
-0.7755520343780518,
0.5456637740135193,
0.16168363392353058,
0.055979326367378235,
-0.7330697774887085,
1.2002631425857544,
-0.2141212373971939,
0.44319549202919006,
0.27640676498413086,
0.1301710456609726,
-0.3821043074131012,
-0.2157370150089264,
-0.4636996388435364,
0.012447008863091469,
-0.4150940775871277,
-0.2248353511095047,
-0.32837948203086853,
0.10492610186338425,
-0.2942553460597992,
-0.28658655285835266,
-0.3077826499938965,
-0.4225864112377167,
0.03751186653971672,
0.0388421006500721,
0.4327140152454376,
0.7010954022407532,
-0.13923680782318115,
0.6267375349998474,
-0.8366667032241821,
0.3081108331680298,
0.42485249042510986,
0.3606293499469757,
-0.19057509303092957,
-0.11326497793197632,
-0.43129727244377136,
0.3913838863372803,
-0.8550354838371277,
-1.0525031089782715,
0.5906408429145813,
0.07429726421833038,
0.6831876039505005,
0.058645449578762054,
0.0504818931221962,
0.4056755304336548,
-0.3227522671222687,
0.7737423777580261,
0.36132752895355225,
-1.005672812461853,
0.5929276943206787,
-0.5265220403671265,
0.07909071445465088,
0.7377299070358276,
0.01434545312076807,
-0.660033106803894,
-0.6045035719871521,
-0.5961742997169495,
-0.8363415598869324,
1.0634031295776367,
0.20396192371845245,
0.27725011110305786,
0.027224132791161537,
0.25249314308166504,
0.12232454121112823,
0.5029555559158325,
-0.8011054396629333,
0.0773012712597847,
-0.5449993014335632,
-0.5036427974700928,
-0.1234126165509224,
-0.09978701919317245,
-0.41888269782066345,
-0.13873940706253052,
0.6287902593612671,
-0.4620232582092285,
0.3625323176383972,
-0.1671951711177826,
-0.09464412182569504,
-0.00763724884018302,
0.4784780442714691,
0.8529958724975586,
0.6173641085624695,
-0.2835541069507599,
0.06761988252401352,
0.41833382844924927,
-0.3327878713607788,
0.33452147245407104,
0.03255724534392357,
0.14074520766735077,
-0.03563576936721802,
0.4870484471321106,
1.1778595447540283,
0.4737350046634674,
-0.6112002730369568,
0.682375967502594,
-0.3305579721927643,
-0.4474025368690491,
-0.30309921503067017,
0.5098106861114502,
-0.26618802547454834,
0.27763447165489197,
0.21026404201984406,
-0.04146481677889824,
0.04694465920329094,
-0.6017245650291443,
-0.05900001898407936,
0.43781450390815735,
-0.24941878020763397,
-0.007174542639404535,
0.41105347871780396,
0.1701480597257614,
-0.24208243191242218,
0.6050729751586914,
-0.37239205837249756,
-0.619866132736206,
0.3449786603450775,
0.42613109946250916,
0.8641058802604675,
-0.3419141471385956,
0.47635865211486816,
0.5497270822525024,
-0.05268198996782303,
-0.2926902770996094,
0.24989306926727295,
-0.14246349036693573,
-0.7289201617240906,
-0.6297158598899841,
-0.6084131002426147,
-0.6044923663139343,
-0.3259381353855133,
-0.8731825947761536,
0.3865987956523895,
-0.1386469602584839,
-0.10335389524698257,
-0.19745297729969025,
0.25917312502861023,
-0.24901728332042694,
-0.01828954741358757,
-0.0545964352786541,
0.26840740442276,
-0.6415552496910095,
0.7001476883888245,
0.5422287583351135,
-0.4306448996067047,
-0.9502519369125366,
0.09692411124706268,
-0.05901060625910759,
-0.3888748586177826,
0.3982102870941162,
0.10406157374382019,
-0.46296757459640503,
0.04703376814723015,
-0.4463408887386322,
-0.8762915730476379,
1.0268888473510742,
0.34884217381477356,
-0.1977982372045517,
-0.13837793469429016,
-0.2530885338783264,
0.7010462284088135,
-0.31031370162963867,
0.2458905577659607,
0.6192779541015625,
0.7333008050918579,
0.09596165269613266,
-0.9344313740730286,
-0.2577001750469208,
0.09476608037948608,
0.10396921634674072,
0.43174976110458374,
-0.6330631375312805,
0.810217022895813,
-0.015964718535542488,
-0.21805885434150696,
0.007785372901707888,
0.34346073865890503,
0.7495566606521606,
0.06759308278560638,
0.6731327772140503,
0.131788432598114,
0.7723439931869507,
-0.2318858504295349,
0.9789871573448181,
-0.3252113163471222,
0.5318806171417236,
1.1220824718475342,
-0.1880379468202591,
0.4356560707092285,
0.5342728495597839,
-0.001756197540089488,
0.7989743947982788,
0.5966141223907471,
-0.11522480100393295,
0.7423492074012756,
0.5575489401817322,
-0.48024511337280273,
-0.0406753271818161,
0.03580832853913307,
-0.07074622809886932,
0.6993678212165833,
0.19397959113121033,
-0.11988760530948639,
-0.2719959020614624,
0.223318949341774,
0.12074192613363266,
0.43974295258522034,
0.05272087827324867,
0.882636308670044,
-0.1888645440340042,
-1.213916301727295,
0.6841822862625122,
0.4098876118659973,
0.8063298463821411,
-0.5090129375457764,
-0.37144842743873596,
0.028671229258179665,
0.4887411594390869,
-0.06481064110994339,
-0.5674335956573486,
0.13627193868160248,
-0.007630053907632828,
0.26156967878341675,
-0.8406751751899719,
0.5433284044265747,
-0.8010692000389099,
-0.43699154257774353,
0.3000945746898651,
0.23105037212371826,
-0.13723628222942352,
0.11238384246826172,
-0.7591371536254883,
-0.008575476706027985,
-0.1171661838889122,
-0.44084784388542175,
0.3842637538909912,
0.2523503601551056,
0.22293700277805328,
0.3334830403327942,
0.47419020533561707,
0.039614252746105194,
0.025744987651705742,
-0.07395163178443909,
1.0057648420333862,
-0.45238909125328064,
-0.44110217690467834,
-0.8983277082443237,
0.5101178288459778,
-0.20212729275226593,
-0.4440910220146179,
0.7145947217941284,
0.2878876030445099,
0.7738380432128906,
0.11880450695753098,
0.529224693775177,
-0.1309834122657776,
0.6903589963912964,
-0.6321738362312317,
0.23267559707164764,
-0.5557128190994263,
0.042887914925813675,
-0.650895357131958,
-0.9515611529350281,
-0.05198107287287712,
0.9118629693984985,
-0.1370769739151001,
0.18347567319869995,
0.7619195580482483,
0.626524031162262,
0.24868567287921906,
-0.13692989945411682,
-0.006548827048391104,
-0.28956687450408936,
0.657957911491394,
0.754032552242279,
1.0688589811325073,
-0.35400524735450745,
0.5419794321060181,
0.06870827078819275,
-0.2957102954387665,
-0.18279287219047546,
-0.9916337132453918,
-0.5518865585327148,
-0.543904185295105,
-0.1771271675825119,
-0.2529231607913971,
0.0066894241608679295,
0.9995788335800171,
0.4211026430130005,
-0.5095391869544983,
-0.2885478138923645,
0.04319749027490616,
0.267954558134079,
-0.7386409044265747,
-0.2185945063829422,
0.37189027667045593,
-0.761823296546936,
-0.8565561175346375,
0.5397120714187622,
0.3729812502861023,
-0.14081905782222748,
-0.45988860726356506,
-0.37803003191947937,
-0.2664603590965271,
0.3156487047672272,
0.5820789933204651,
-0.13156597316265106,
-0.4477367699146271,
-0.4600695073604584,
-0.23246082663536072,
-0.1796294003725052,
0.009604456834495068,
1.0572264194488525,
-0.7929946184158325,
0.36684730648994446,
0.48234111070632935,
0.2239496409893036,
0.749718427658081,
0.1529892086982727,
0.6864516139030457,
-1.0250089168548584,
0.21307918429374695,
0.3090907633304596,
-0.01250761654227972,
0.11543719470500946,
-0.3012710213661194,
0.3294174373149872,
-0.12858447432518005,
-0.6174322366714478,
-0.9208226203918457,
0.3670496940612793,
-0.7421061992645264,
-0.3745809495449066,
0.728371798992157,
-0.19839270412921906,
0.20700399577617645,
-0.012111340649425983,
-0.5412800312042236,
0.4731796383857727,
-0.2839965522289276,
1.0124431848526,
0.7709987759590149,
-0.38153156638145447,
-0.16141332685947418,
-0.5079323649406433,
0.901249885559082,
0.4061175286769867,
-0.9113369584083557,
0.03158404678106308,
0.5499303936958313,
0.035490721464157104,
0.043999359011650085,
0.6892010569572449,
0.06514513492584229,
0.2266620248556137,
0.04711092263460159,
0.2058398723602295,
0.18799951672554016,
-0.36513352394104004,
-0.35930782556533813,
0.04308256879448891,
0.3053878843784332,
-0.043893277645111084
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13560v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13560v1
|
eRST: A Signaled Graph Theory of Discourse Relations and Organization
| 2024-03-20T12:52:38 | 2024-03-20T12:52:38 |
Amir Zeldes, Tatsuya Aoyama, Yang Janet Liu, Siyao Peng, Debopam Das, Luke Gessler
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this article we present Enhanced Rhetorical Structure Theory (eRST), a new
theoretical framework for computational discourse analysis, based on an
expansion of Rhetorical Structure Theory (RST). The framework encompasses
discourse relation graphs with tree-breaking, nonprojective and concurrent
relations, as well as implicit and explicit signals which give explainable
rationales to our analyses. We survey shortcomings of RST and other existing
frameworks, such as Segmented Discourse Representation Theory (SDRT), the Penn
Discourse Treebank (PDTB) and Discourse Dependencies, and address these using
constructs in the proposed theory. We provide annotation, search and
visualization tools for data, and present and evaluate a freely available
corpus of English annotated according to our framework, encompassing 12 spoken
and written genres with over 200K tokens. Finally, we discuss automatic
parsing, evaluation metrics and applications for data in our framework.
|
[
-0.38461965322494507,
-1.1917093992233276,
0.5756345987319946,
0.06571108847856522,
-0.12331198900938034,
0.2664763629436493,
-0.01740560680627823,
-0.42944684624671936,
0.5862420797348022,
0.10340043157339096,
-0.1501176655292511,
-0.3863583207130432,
-0.3961334824562073,
0.23771819472312927,
-0.5033815503120422,
0.7300751209259033,
0.13480141758918762,
0.0037479551974684,
0.11596821248531342,
-0.1932806819677353,
-0.20394548773765564,
-0.6734727025032043,
-0.838316023349762,
-0.19224083423614502,
0.6655282378196716,
0.12389618158340454,
0.6611291170120239,
0.7763296961784363,
0.3671228587627411,
0.29521554708480835,
-0.28935837745666504,
-0.1089150533080101,
-0.5131934285163879,
0.5362890362739563,
-0.06184645742177963,
-0.11640699207782745,
-0.5735408663749695,
-0.463024377822876,
0.9140814542770386,
1.0884917974472046,
0.00851358287036419,
-0.13922664523124695,
0.19901297986507416,
0.5467112064361572,
-0.10717830806970596,
0.3538973927497864,
-0.2883867621421814,
0.06692642718553543,
-0.2929688096046448,
-0.3737644553184509,
-0.60960853099823,
-0.2204441875219345,
0.30689552426338196,
-0.6557638645172119,
-0.23402287065982819,
0.4741913676261902,
0.9163281917572021,
-0.19289018213748932,
-0.6626551747322083,
-0.14517728984355927,
-0.7039994597434998,
0.23165835440158844,
-0.05398248881101608,
0.5564762949943542,
0.16270539164543152,
0.20711669325828552,
-0.15980544686317444,
-1.1774001121520996,
-0.021065684035420418,
-0.08113989233970642,
-0.28594523668289185,
0.3172002136707306,
-0.2889295518398285,
0.5673430562019348,
0.09266674518585205,
0.28631365299224854,
-0.6326879262924194,
-0.27599239349365234,
-0.2618085443973541,
0.0338367260992527,
0.04775826632976532,
0.10232765972614288,
0.43897294998168945,
-0.43749913573265076,
-0.4497717022895813,
0.3048502802848816,
-0.701716423034668,
-0.21449565887451172,
0.29741424322128296,
0.4405771791934967,
-0.0746181458234787,
0.5578455328941345,
0.42794156074523926,
0.8208327293395996,
-0.1836491972208023,
0.5366679430007935,
-0.13229894638061523,
-0.16030175983905792,
-0.3425414562225342,
0.008035028353333473,
0.7558742761611938,
-0.011743886396288872,
0.26313817501068115,
0.0465124174952507,
0.03742758184671402,
-0.06703498959541321,
0.16673770546913147,
-0.5861715078353882,
-0.5581262707710266,
0.06149136647582054,
-0.49029749631881714,
-0.28903600573539734,
0.25912806391716003,
-0.8735054731369019,
-0.17852535843849182,
-0.2804086208343506,
-0.25291863083839417,
-0.8046872615814209,
-0.5651431679725647,
-0.39829912781715393,
-0.21100206673145294,
0.20685975253582,
0.017276611179113388,
-0.5781177282333374,
0.8364400267601013,
0.9041492938995361,
1.0596903562545776,
-0.1558554619550705,
-0.21883122622966766,
0.021567698568105698,
0.28552576899528503,
-0.3873794972896576,
1.2556884288787842,
-0.9782193303108215,
-0.30259349942207336,
0.09534157812595367,
-0.2314307987689972,
-0.33186325430870056,
0.08722787350416183,
0.7976561784744263,
-0.482547402381897,
0.21583445370197296,
-0.2661474049091339,
-0.8029524087905884,
-0.42296120524406433,
0.48311400413513184,
-0.8763923645019531,
1.139762043952942,
0.2251681685447693,
-0.9274877905845642,
-0.0021985031198710203,
-1.0116426944732666,
-0.6351012587547302,
0.18498875200748444,
-0.5511884093284607,
-0.020074430853128433,
0.00763374287635088,
-0.008558214642107487,
0.22215822339057922,
-0.23872268199920654,
0.4493577182292938,
-0.3145085275173187,
-0.3689880967140198,
0.2487640678882599,
0.01732344552874565,
1.041365146636963,
0.36458203196525574,
0.09604763239622116,
0.299076110124588,
-0.9539949893951416,
0.26879942417144775,
0.028115009889006615,
-0.06771132349967957,
-0.3954724669456482,
0.19303640723228455,
-0.028233516961336136,
-0.2713609039783478,
-0.13994260132312775,
-0.3433511257171631,
-0.0793575569987297,
-0.6737948656082153,
0.7119409441947937,
0.8239875435829163,
0.2769853472709656,
0.2243424504995346,
0.041831664741039276,
0.737842321395874,
-0.3343336284160614,
-0.24664844572544098,
-0.6397541165351868,
-0.33340704441070557,
-0.7603170275688171,
-0.2299925833940506,
0.4022707939147949,
0.4011600911617279,
-0.2500089704990387,
0.36036065220832825,
-0.4082002639770508,
-0.05419829115271568,
-0.04748076573014259,
-0.9541846513748169,
0.2884679436683655,
0.4214889109134674,
0.061111822724342346,
-0.04241087660193443,
-1.155076026916504,
-0.8440229296684265,
-0.3388666808605194,
-0.678896963596344,
0.19818083941936493,
0.11282312124967575,
0.4090329110622406,
0.6277815103530884,
1.0838426351547241,
-0.5641082525253296,
0.10747645050287247,
-0.2337825894355774,
0.2069551795721054,
-0.012683110311627388,
0.07487271726131439,
0.4491490423679352,
-0.5015382170677185,
-0.5329622030258179,
0.19285528361797333,
-0.503390371799469,
-0.1304180771112442,
0.19178242981433868,
-0.04473040625452995,
-0.09824871271848679,
0.4776551127433777,
-0.3086617588996887,
0.2232102006673813,
0.22795438766479492,
-0.4864489436149597,
0.6075242757797241,
0.21186251938343048,
0.09495604038238525,
-1.2585279941558838,
0.214177206158638,
-0.1655842512845993,
-0.4582011103630066,
-0.7812719345092773,
0.23429980874061584,
-0.13516050577163696,
-0.42750370502471924,
-0.15136399865150452,
0.11244363337755203,
-0.5532540678977966,
-0.2759981155395508,
-0.11101717501878738,
0.33790576457977295,
0.034708280116319656,
0.6124216318130493,
0.035688500851392746,
0.4443042278289795,
0.3476253151893616,
-0.40702202916145325,
0.08199747651815414,
0.0441296361386776,
-0.015480290167033672,
1.0071320533752441,
-0.8631201982498169,
0.3884529769420624,
-0.02725638821721077,
0.35260632634162903,
-1.3929868936538696,
-0.18126527965068817,
0.4244326651096344,
-0.524986207485199,
0.3273777961730957,
-0.5865106582641602,
-0.46145984530448914,
-0.20971520245075226,
-0.22022129595279694,
0.3017445504665375,
0.021924469619989395,
-0.23760393261909485,
0.5259459614753723,
0.5754888653755188,
-0.32380005717277527,
-0.4429929554462433,
-0.5273132920265198,
0.1120593473315239,
-0.34341350197792053,
-0.9378328919410706,
0.3107120096683502,
0.41017016768455505,
-0.6016168594360352,
0.21352533996105194,
0.2317318469285965,
-0.3766675889492035,
-0.0688730850815773,
0.2649880051612854,
0.1373787522315979,
-0.43363142013549805,
0.37811174988746643,
0.1483573317527771,
-0.13918638229370117,
0.1155586764216423,
-0.28088733553886414,
0.4114134907722473,
-0.3519822955131531,
-0.35234618186950684,
-0.11904825270175934,
0.4727594256401062,
0.3517575263977051,
0.03142484650015831,
0.32125312089920044,
0.06362676620483398,
-0.46684613823890686,
0.0014194087125360966,
0.024141386151313782,
-0.10038900375366211,
-0.32886171340942383,
0.7096149921417236,
-0.7210261821746826,
-0.9522614479064941,
0.7016395330429077,
-0.24806612730026245,
0.24735789000988007,
0.5377808809280396,
0.26203060150146484,
0.11119168251752853,
0.9366069436073303,
0.6393833160400391,
0.2838488817214966,
0.374102920293808,
0.15702548623085022,
0.21395471692085266,
-0.8608648777008057,
0.1253531277179718,
-0.7361910939216614,
-0.20613867044448853,
-0.31082987785339355,
-0.12912391126155853,
0.15990924835205078,
-0.1200152263045311,
-0.5775260925292969,
0.34550729393959045,
-0.7511178851127625,
0.5028911232948303,
-0.193574920296669,
-0.5454210042953491,
0.4290028512477875,
0.18827909231185913,
-0.45356255769729614,
-0.19577404856681824,
-0.7628316879272461,
-0.6304029226303101,
0.6302689909934998,
0.629813015460968,
0.36875492334365845,
0.08012531697750092,
0.3502931296825409,
0.04095979034900665,
0.20584778487682343,
-0.8774135112762451,
0.657855212688446,
0.32175761461257935,
-0.6353589296340942,
-0.2820279896259308,
-0.22959336638450623,
-1.274256706237793,
0.6228002905845642,
0.3042113482952118,
-0.9107249975204468,
0.2006898820400238,
0.028440799564123154,
-0.30546849966049194,
0.11750531196594238,
-0.7068726420402527,
0.4415753483772278,
-0.0613522082567215,
-0.3655361533164978,
0.16091005504131317,
-0.7149108648300171,
0.2886626720428467,
0.39168399572372437,
0.39160192012786865,
0.16037768125534058,
-0.09764479845762253,
1.1322559118270874,
-0.43204188346862793,
0.9191198348999023,
0.05555896461009979,
0.13490617275238037,
0.5384359955787659,
0.334545761346817,
0.6167525053024292,
-0.09070202708244324,
-0.19536809623241425,
-0.15947338938713074,
0.20200936496257782,
-0.06902693957090378,
-0.5747116804122925,
0.48636114597320557,
-0.5719730257987976,
-0.1263703554868698,
-0.5251176357269287,
-0.16472555696964264,
-0.15234939754009247,
0.40608054399490356,
0.1812559962272644,
0.432557076215744,
-0.8413976430892944,
-0.06285347044467926,
0.1732436716556549,
0.3459678590297699,
0.14905299246311188,
0.278627872467041,
-0.5539095401763916,
-0.7523557543754578,
0.6368545889854431,
0.3623332381248474,
-0.04376821592450142,
0.30293142795562744,
0.1546495258808136,
-0.3472680449485779,
-0.4469447135925293,
-0.1302853375673294,
0.08904510736465454,
-0.8241254687309265,
-0.12110980600118637,
-0.6837839484214783,
-0.29937970638275146,
-0.3746066987514496,
-0.0584992952644825,
-0.29444584250450134,
-0.8638894557952881,
-0.16512270271778107,
-0.6771165132522583,
0.5058703422546387,
1.220744252204895,
0.13607636094093323,
0.39746659994125366,
-0.1671045869588852,
-0.2642567455768585,
-0.34932559728622437,
0.4864697754383087,
0.11752574890851974,
-0.43323230743408203,
-0.09321759641170502,
-0.2771622836589813,
-0.5928280353546143,
-1.384169101715088,
0.2062080353498459,
0.17384135723114014,
0.2695506513118744,
0.5073339939117432,
-0.04096038267016411,
0.9947502613067627,
-0.6094524264335632,
0.7916604280471802,
0.3145582973957062,
-0.8043506145477295,
0.33153313398361206,
-0.6967299580574036,
-0.07396405935287476,
0.43511077761650085,
0.07679826766252518,
-0.7321839928627014,
-0.3569088578224182,
-0.8147702217102051,
-1.108883261680603,
0.5151011943817139,
0.3676391839981079,
-0.21029126644134521,
-0.27212634682655334,
0.17262104153633118,
0.06331093609333038,
-0.10220897942781448,
-0.7769659757614136,
-0.48208174109458923,
-0.1603560596704483,
-0.12637104094028473,
0.5810821652412415,
-0.4840303659439087,
-0.3357439339160919,
-0.31209537386894226,
0.44359561800956726,
0.03479255735874176,
0.46389806270599365,
0.3611903190612793,
0.014429638162255287,
-0.14509306848049164,
0.5279406309127808,
0.4246157109737396,
0.9830899238586426,
0.030928459018468857,
0.5698647499084473,
-0.049806147813797,
-0.1955036222934723,
0.06203242018818855,
0.15757359564304352,
-0.17192092537879944,
-0.02131420187652111,
0.3345336318016052,
0.7626956105232239,
0.5582167506217957,
-0.043690379709005356,
0.13902580738067627,
0.21419265866279602,
-0.2848737835884094,
-0.5283757448196411,
-0.6297433376312256,
0.2754218578338623,
-0.022611558437347412,
0.2686033546924591,
-0.33443722128868103,
0.20875197649002075,
-0.4544115364551544,
0.5727511048316956,
0.2442418336868286,
-0.7235239744186401,
-0.7230589985847473,
0.31417417526245117,
0.4892750680446625,
-0.5878776907920837,
0.32481372356414795,
-0.15581975877285004,
-0.6433072686195374,
0.4351540505886078,
0.7945199608802795,
0.8933305740356445,
-0.05893323943018913,
0.33732861280441284,
0.3317909836769104,
0.40462595224380493,
0.18921539187431335,
0.310179740190506,
0.2144460678100586,
-0.49297380447387695,
-0.7144350409507751,
-0.2914135754108429,
-0.34450381994247437,
0.13517440855503082,
-0.4106783866882324,
0.43896764516830444,
-0.5603715181350708,
-0.22016727924346924,
0.030997276306152344,
-0.130904421210289,
-0.03590070456266403,
-0.46656733751296997,
-0.21027255058288574,
0.5042524337768555,
-0.4957740902900696,
0.38594862818717957,
0.9740815162658691,
-0.25259363651275635,
-0.8938053250312805,
-0.25712692737579346,
0.13310688734054565,
-0.5720754265785217,
0.4957294762134552,
-0.031735893338918686,
-0.28398433327674866,
0.17795270681381226,
-0.22903597354888916,
-0.9340874552726746,
0.8076940774917603,
0.551498293876648,
-0.4775567650794983,
0.01081821322441101,
0.060139261186122894,
0.6198992729187012,
-0.6087060570716858,
0.6579226851463318,
0.4928414821624756,
0.6514761447906494,
0.08858484774827957,
-0.5798335671424866,
0.2383583039045334,
-0.28085610270500183,
-0.1338481605052948,
0.5596933364868164,
-0.43057405948638916,
0.7493358254432678,
0.050849832594394684,
-0.7276526689529419,
0.011149223893880844,
0.7623835802078247,
0.04061298817396164,
0.2214588224887848,
0.2517993748188019,
0.5387333035469055,
0.7739500999450684,
-0.11066647619009018,
0.652944028377533,
-0.46016016602516174,
0.4140472412109375,
1.366350769996643,
-0.37163928151130676,
0.5419043302536011,
0.4105083644390106,
-0.6162925362586975,
0.7493429183959961,
0.816979169845581,
0.22489279508590698,
-0.09253191202878952,
0.4106823801994324,
0.04634804651141167,
0.17303167283535004,
-0.1089584082365036,
-0.5025478601455688,
0.21205580234527588,
0.5658193230628967,
-0.7358745336532593,
-0.39159342646598816,
-0.30740824341773987,
0.15477882325649261,
0.2160777598619461,
0.07131552696228027,
0.7279190421104431,
0.29312464594841003,
-0.48653486371040344,
0.3233684301376343,
-0.08510181307792664,
-0.11217940598726273,
-0.5074748992919922,
-0.17629137635231018,
0.3913072645664215,
-0.3101564347743988,
-0.2679015100002289,
-0.8441551923751831,
0.5828180909156799,
-0.22454826533794403,
0.3100789189338684,
-0.21491655707359314,
1.1902451515197754,
-0.13429947197437286,
-0.419637531042099,
0.2838267385959625,
0.8644567728042603,
0.32710158824920654,
0.1454034149646759,
-0.7486835718154907,
0.2562527060508728,
-0.20453177392482758,
-0.6034517884254456,
0.08220908045768738,
0.6213869452476501,
0.046075738966464996,
0.162932887673378,
0.3733804225921631,
0.006998633034527302,
-0.14837966859340668,
0.10187893360853195,
0.9105810523033142,
-0.7171779274940491,
-0.8355304002761841,
-1.0550899505615234,
0.2525593638420105,
-0.43488919734954834,
-0.09497030079364777,
0.6194125413894653,
0.7831246852874756,
0.298069030046463,
0.5897640585899353,
0.9174846410751343,
-0.4027320444583893,
0.6417385339736938,
-0.1335536688566208,
0.5995968580245972,
0.15626023709774017,
0.2811868488788605,
-0.4760170876979828,
-0.9599409699440002,
-0.35008469223976135,
0.8002080321311951,
-0.3065323531627655,
-0.06525466591119766,
1.312543272972107,
0.3945077657699585,
-0.06147586926817894,
0.5370484590530396,
0.22637702524662018,
0.39766785502433777,
0.3552228510379791,
0.23067812621593475,
0.9632896780967712,
-0.04117023944854736,
0.7003539204597473,
0.07611510157585144,
-0.32733121514320374,
0.22158536314964294,
-0.80837082862854,
-0.747117280960083,
-0.8876236081123352,
-0.21720421314239502,
-0.2292749583721161,
0.33793553709983826,
0.7887705564498901,
0.5324628949165344,
-0.2824236750602722,
-0.5249442458152771,
-0.5566890239715576,
0.3603269159793854,
-0.2236032783985138,
-0.33931204676628113,
0.66671222448349,
-0.26797887682914734,
-0.4144294559955597,
0.37575197219848633,
0.5756869316101074,
-0.04821813106536865,
-0.15473392605781555,
0.14235125482082367,
-0.3855082094669342,
0.1898050308227539,
0.8996859788894653,
0.5090641379356384,
-0.3651047348976135,
-0.6363034248352051,
-0.05418575555086136,
0.3566170632839203,
0.4028455913066864,
1.2735576629638672,
-0.5474493503570557,
0.34628912806510925,
0.5653007626533508,
0.26513049006462097,
0.1085575595498085,
0.15126004815101624,
0.8167876601219177,
-0.7690935730934143,
-0.04728829860687256,
0.5208783149719238,
0.5030605792999268,
0.10653596371412277,
-0.04775918275117874,
0.7858476042747498,
0.30476459860801697,
-0.42538532614707947,
-1.1411808729171753,
0.6501013040542603,
-0.8866991996765137,
-0.28890448808670044,
1.0566356182098389,
-0.20529404282569885,
-0.38643568754196167,
-0.6639032959938049,
-0.3688000440597534,
0.26184675097465515,
-0.717066764831543,
0.31258827447891235,
0.9539628028869629,
-0.5933942198753357,
-0.28397127985954285,
-0.2985510528087616,
0.3749968111515045,
0.3273002803325653,
-0.7337214946746826,
0.504710853099823,
0.5983031392097473,
0.006096288561820984,
0.2068714201450348,
1.0436269044876099,
-0.39330005645751953,
-0.15193341672420502,
0.035771146416664124,
-0.41266438364982605,
-0.19268029928207397,
-0.25636646151542664,
-0.06942033022642136,
0.7036455869674683,
0.208881676197052,
0.18354737758636475
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13537v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13537v1
|
What explains the success of cross-modal fine-tuning with ORCA?
| 2024-03-20T12:14:54 | 2024-03-20T12:14:54 |
Paloma García-de-Herreros, Vagrant Gautam, Philipp Slusallek, Dietrich Klakow, Marius Mosbach
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
ORCA (Shen et al., 2023) is a recent technique for cross-modal fine-tuning,
i.e., applying pre-trained transformer models to modalities beyond their
training data. The technique consists primarily of training an embedder and
fine-tuning the embedder and model. Despite its high performance on a variety
of downstream tasks, we do not understand precisely how each of these
components contribute to ORCA's success. Therefore, we run a series of
ablations and find that embedder training does not help 2D tasks at all,
contrary to what the original paper posits. In 1D tasks, some amount of
embedder training is necessary but more is not better. In 4 out of 6 datasets
we experiment with, it is model fine-tuning that makes the biggest difference.
Through our ablations and baselines, we contribute a better understanding of
the individual components of ORCA.
|
[
-0.7513067722320557,
-0.8892227411270142,
0.27501001954078674,
-0.3251773715019226,
-0.4922754466533661,
0.017307093366980553,
0.04839041084051132,
-0.6681503057479858,
0.07690975815057755,
0.25181567668914795,
-0.543618381023407,
-0.4367658495903015,
-0.7627406716346741,
-0.03550686314702034,
-0.40683820843696594,
1.1104305982589722,
0.0600765235722065,
0.16938772797584534,
0.20486879348754883,
-0.09666929394006729,
-0.6225940585136414,
-0.024041498079895973,
-1.1262753009796143,
-0.39217880368232727,
0.6563563346862793,
0.6664589643478394,
0.863389790058136,
0.9521052241325378,
0.3437182307243347,
0.19543513655662537,
-0.10688035935163498,
0.32683509588241577,
-0.7212260961532593,
-0.2546960115432739,
-0.3268815875053406,
-0.8176847696304321,
-0.18504872918128967,
-0.12540054321289062,
0.36478275060653687,
0.8394186496734619,
0.14806123077869415,
-0.026266375556588173,
0.24016132950782776,
0.5156317949295044,
-0.7885380387306213,
-0.19730357825756073,
-0.5054960250854492,
0.20833279192447662,
-0.5363845825195312,
-0.35854995250701904,
0.027263591066002846,
-0.4758976399898529,
0.05536560341715813,
-0.4903225302696228,
0.5084831714630127,
-0.011774437502026558,
0.6502172350883484,
0.6995407342910767,
-0.8166681528091431,
-0.3354235887527466,
-0.8978095650672913,
0.6739590764045715,
-0.42492467164993286,
0.5980331897735596,
0.31737905740737915,
0.30973517894744873,
-0.06422167271375656,
-0.6691093444824219,
-0.5357350707054138,
0.08260834962129593,
0.024116769433021545,
0.03162899240851402,
0.058065302670001984,
0.018338643014431,
0.47293469309806824,
0.4746946096420288,
-0.38005879521369934,
0.3041095733642578,
-0.5597601532936096,
-0.042968422174453735,
0.4893663227558136,
0.41604670882225037,
0.010776190087199211,
0.21483410894870758,
-0.5189523100852966,
-0.3354179561138153,
-0.77047199010849,
0.6710565090179443,
0.29555898904800415,
0.12442610412836075,
-0.290726900100708,
0.831783652305603,
0.14463317394256592,
0.7564036250114441,
0.4719897508621216,
-0.3140670359134674,
-0.14115425944328308,
-0.493619441986084,
-0.35995757579803467,
0.011439396999776363,
0.28446364402770996,
0.07202503085136414,
-0.014230850152671337,
-0.08283908665180206,
-0.2808527648448944,
0.4468463361263275,
0.562204122543335,
-0.699800968170166,
-0.21221446990966797,
0.0012831443455070257,
-0.6038681268692017,
-0.1851806491613388,
0.060841746628284454,
-0.44441401958465576,
-0.24617311358451843,
-0.32809844613075256,
0.5959585309028625,
-0.45865684747695923,
0.04206551983952522,
0.35435232520103455,
-0.2933284044265747,
0.3632589280605316,
0.23146465420722961,
-1.2038767337799072,
0.27078166604042053,
0.7155085802078247,
0.5694578289985657,
-0.0016801728634163737,
-0.41988393664360046,
-0.21217316389083862,
-0.20082592964172363,
-0.4713851511478424,
0.9584484100341797,
-0.6416782140731812,
-0.5649545192718506,
-0.015748124569654465,
0.06974529474973679,
-0.2050960212945938,
-0.41046664118766785,
0.5622321367263794,
-0.5690355896949768,
-0.07022634893655777,
-0.8934155702590942,
-0.1675555258989334,
-0.4128076136112213,
-0.04540908336639404,
-0.6193904876708984,
0.6898769736289978,
0.06864836812019348,
-0.5222201347351074,
1.0111489295959473,
-0.6102343797683716,
-0.6543166041374207,
-0.4339876174926758,
-0.27756431698799133,
-0.39473575353622437,
0.4805009961128235,
0.21391141414642334,
0.2675113379955292,
-0.3976384401321411,
-0.44277042150497437,
-0.36485934257507324,
-0.41092178225517273,
0.028122125193476677,
-0.2943050265312195,
0.5355836749076843,
0.20753633975982666,
-0.6001371145248413,
-0.073236383497715,
-0.6579784750938416,
-0.3076663017272949,
-0.05867311358451843,
-0.37531778216362,
-0.21298567950725555,
-0.08256097137928009,
0.3342406451702118,
0.3447361886501312,
0.02846715971827507,
-0.8448445200920105,
0.2913513779640198,
-0.29908958077430725,
0.5529972910881042,
0.2874756157398224,
-0.07935820519924164,
0.5457733273506165,
-0.5588973760604858,
0.7178221344947815,
-0.0963105857372284,
0.19248469173908234,
-0.015839625149965286,
-0.3687412142753601,
-0.8317595720291138,
-0.2461441159248352,
0.4685724973678589,
-0.04740238934755325,
-0.5324060320854187,
0.3818897306919098,
-0.008957494981586933,
-0.8334539532661438,
-0.5328145623207092,
0.05783168599009514,
0.3668002188205719,
0.3884407579898834,
0.3288573920726776,
-0.7519910335540771,
-0.3783016800880432,
-0.9301307201385498,
0.13168564438819885,
0.5117737650871277,
0.20452798902988434,
0.0367932990193367,
0.4647759795188904,
-0.004184589255601168,
0.8729307651519775,
-0.0949690118432045,
-0.6521597504615784,
-0.06966613233089447,
0.21084846556186676,
-0.11282510310411453,
0.6684796214103699,
0.6661001443862915,
-0.776346743106842,
-0.28182366490364075,
0.18779975175857544,
-0.5078322291374207,
0.2842940390110016,
-0.25484102964401245,
0.22232306003570557,
0.2745005786418915,
0.8202493190765381,
-0.6048036217689514,
0.708477795124054,
0.6036678552627563,
-0.2587048411369324,
0.12197890877723694,
-0.20669667422771454,
0.10231968760490417,
-0.7229062914848328,
0.1377062201499939,
-0.21686238050460815,
-0.17413467168807983,
-0.3247101902961731,
-0.16483592987060547,
0.16114050149917603,
-0.15746170282363892,
-0.3822031021118164,
0.04561915993690491,
-0.29646506905555725,
-0.26269036531448364,
-0.5331111550331116,
0.008865955285727978,
-0.08938664197921753,
0.444696307182312,
0.060886260122060776,
0.3705064058303833,
0.6412550210952759,
-0.7122926115989685,
0.08615409582853317,
0.39814844727516174,
-0.31255006790161133,
0.8657535314559937,
-0.9279223680496216,
0.05776161700487137,
0.06225769221782684,
0.34148240089416504,
-1.2965048551559448,
-0.04292616620659828,
0.04587967321276665,
-0.37592369318008423,
0.4652132987976074,
0.17737306654453278,
-0.14635421335697174,
-0.10876191407442093,
-0.3083341419696808,
0.8377312421798706,
0.11729642003774643,
-0.7929235696792603,
0.8290349841117859,
0.302112340927124,
0.21615460515022278,
-0.4735235869884491,
-0.8211201429367065,
-0.3126436769962311,
-0.2167620211839676,
-0.7644644379615784,
0.5668849349021912,
0.1764024794101715,
0.31269583106040955,
0.14936251938343048,
-0.5869607329368591,
0.24948129057884216,
0.171103835105896,
0.40080034732818604,
-0.2304689586162567,
-0.27879902720451355,
-0.06109621003270149,
0.39235013723373413,
-0.41359931230545044,
0.07542577385902405,
-0.004225700628012419,
0.5436385869979858,
0.1361347883939743,
-0.8413487672805786,
-0.6367234587669373,
0.17505697906017303,
0.7672390937805176,
-0.33159688115119934,
0.5635820031166077,
0.8058263063430786,
-0.20617154240608215,
-0.14300651848316193,
-0.6132567524909973,
-0.25254181027412415,
-0.43591195344924927,
0.25993287563323975,
-0.6435725092887878,
-0.81745845079422,
0.6790772080421448,
-0.09070393443107605,
0.27561473846435547,
0.4438178837299347,
0.4211822748184204,
-0.08865726739168167,
1.4832137823104858,
1.0850305557250977,
0.003036149777472019,
0.6595363020896912,
-0.45725956559181213,
0.10540344566106796,
-0.8113104701042175,
-0.7141071557998657,
-0.7582871317863464,
-0.8962864875793457,
-0.6026052832603455,
0.039242543280124664,
0.5919773578643799,
0.07392219454050064,
-0.3448035717010498,
0.471629798412323,
-0.39881929755210876,
0.15370260179042816,
0.6408359408378601,
0.21897439658641815,
0.29083511233329773,
-0.19043384492397308,
0.16572453081607819,
0.07713508605957031,
-0.9698366522789001,
-0.24939292669296265,
1.0440268516540527,
0.3951801359653473,
1.3182621002197266,
-0.12054712325334549,
0.30609890818595886,
0.07505971193313599,
-0.2416032999753952,
-0.7987013459205627,
0.09296476095914841,
-0.024206042289733887,
-0.5890912413597107,
-0.360929399728775,
0.027566639706492424,
-1.4639989137649536,
0.041548144072294235,
-0.30456486344337463,
-0.3115103542804718,
0.8608023524284363,
0.06993605941534042,
-0.7413386106491089,
0.15280285477638245,
-0.27925971150398254,
1.1581710577011108,
-0.28753072023391724,
0.015206605195999146,
-0.5825687050819397,
-0.7519837021827698,
0.10649999231100082,
-0.2661171555519104,
-0.1325267255306244,
0.3265380859375,
-0.4211677014827728,
0.523281455039978,
-0.4272405505180359,
0.9559388160705566,
0.05111531913280487,
-0.2888329327106476,
0.015244548209011555,
0.024264996871352196,
0.47484612464904785,
0.2536766827106476,
0.2747332453727722,
0.1851213127374649,
0.11280647665262222,
-0.4435979127883911,
-0.5393272042274475,
0.7332367897033691,
-0.9371401071548462,
-0.30893653631210327,
-0.15500818192958832,
-0.48100781440734863,
-0.04194975271821022,
0.0019669723697006702,
0.5978150367736816,
0.6337785124778748,
-0.07591468095779419,
0.597574770450592,
0.4562264084815979,
0.18488533794879913,
0.36170366406440735,
0.2927047610282898,
0.1539764702320099,
-0.44719579815864563,
0.5597342848777771,
0.1472882330417633,
0.308085173368454,
0.2516394853591919,
-0.17721503973007202,
-0.23085269331932068,
-0.6069972515106201,
-0.41186779737472534,
0.17472808063030243,
-0.5851242542266846,
-0.11868709325790405,
-0.4859447777271271,
-0.08380899578332901,
-0.30975663661956787,
-0.5159133076667786,
-0.6775014400482178,
-0.3487928807735443,
-0.28140825033187866,
0.05679372698068619,
-0.017551112920045853,
1.1081351041793823,
-0.2093478888273239,
0.22628144919872284,
-0.6046432256698608,
0.2573033571243286,
0.5076598525047302,
0.12816502153873444,
0.06011418253183365,
-0.6764530539512634,
-0.6302649974822998,
0.24598506093025208,
-0.5848446488380432,
-0.44374197721481323,
0.05971792712807655,
-0.005290160421282053,
0.5764055848121643,
0.6415660977363586,
-0.1831187903881073,
1.0393216609954834,
-0.0284282099455595,
0.7570412755012512,
-0.03446090593934059,
-1.087421178817749,
0.5133039951324463,
-0.10188335180282593,
0.3776802122592926,
0.5449712872505188,
0.6546706557273865,
-0.20651856064796448,
-0.1500062793493271,
-0.6461654305458069,
-0.661807656288147,
0.8641088604927063,
-0.0068714795634150505,
0.035306092351675034,
0.13467511534690857,
0.3412071168422699,
0.5216853618621826,
0.1558251976966858,
-0.43836039304733276,
-0.40195727348327637,
-0.44972947239875793,
0.43539756536483765,
-0.2651233375072479,
-0.008268496952950954,
-0.13874952495098114,
-0.3300989866256714,
0.6284007430076599,
-0.2790301442146301,
0.006135990377515554,
0.19444453716278076,
-0.09274248778820038,
-0.6700894236564636,
-0.26075229048728943,
0.6785292029380798,
0.6950979828834534,
-0.047993823885917664,
0.017699724063277245,
0.39277514815330505,
-0.30412596464157104,
-0.33344388008117676,
0.09466812759637833,
0.08779408037662506,
-0.17851167917251587,
0.27368950843811035,
0.7014885544776917,
0.4446037709712982,
-0.24624718725681305,
0.21604213118553162,
-0.04879777505993843,
-0.19617018103599548,
-0.03036382608115673,
0.10553605854511261,
-0.12777461111545563,
0.7253057360649109,
0.3414807617664337,
0.5760754346847534,
0.08714576810598373,
-0.6282917857170105,
-0.19199880957603455,
0.6998319625854492,
-0.4810338318347931,
-0.585030198097229,
0.9674837589263916,
0.18987521529197693,
-0.16822946071624756,
0.3236139416694641,
0.33456525206565857,
-0.25783029198646545,
0.7672572731971741,
0.4764978587627411,
0.623828113079071,
-0.18799825012683868,
-0.28295499086380005,
0.18945729732513428,
0.3145599663257599,
0.009652048349380493,
0.3320327699184418,
-0.4538821876049042,
-0.7453994154930115,
-0.3836502730846405,
-0.32795971632003784,
-0.37766504287719727,
0.09786022454500198,
-0.9212449193000793,
0.6505904197692871,
-0.37638014554977417,
-0.27381661534309387,
0.204488143324852,
-0.03685437887907028,
-0.9669632315635681,
0.44112786650657654,
0.22499248385429382,
1.1552563905715942,
-1.0191270112991333,
0.825833797454834,
0.847549557685852,
-0.6205512881278992,
-0.943031907081604,
-0.26989543437957764,
-0.08139792829751968,
-0.6536704301834106,
0.5631768107414246,
-0.09064758569002151,
0.0020037328358739614,
0.18287062644958496,
-0.22566542029380798,
-1.1039297580718994,
1.1816701889038086,
0.4307797849178314,
-0.33378905057907104,
-0.03496754541993141,
0.416986346244812,
0.5448711514472961,
-0.3807709217071533,
0.4523000419139862,
0.6853670477867126,
0.5701136589050293,
0.04201900213956833,
-1.2553188800811768,
0.08327733725309372,
0.031772468239068985,
0.39149996638298035,
0.19872039556503296,
-0.7710268497467041,
0.8263891339302063,
-0.17487573623657227,
-0.21429675817489624,
0.1966969519853592,
0.5731351375579834,
-0.25586193799972534,
0.19582851231098175,
0.6995927095413208,
0.7996426820755005,
0.3253064751625061,
-0.09701041877269745,
1.3221485614776611,
-0.300415962934494,
0.38393160700798035,
0.60941082239151,
0.13349182903766632,
0.4975358843803406,
0.47154515981674194,
0.013702417723834515,
0.3528655767440796,
0.9311193227767944,
-0.023516809567809105,
0.8978856205940247,
-0.2823833227157593,
0.3024487793445587,
-0.5706519484519958,
-0.2569597065448761,
-0.8435245156288147,
0.8646196722984314,
0.32899320125579834,
-0.4688991904258728,
-0.5712037086486816,
0.34911099076271057,
-0.37863773107528687,
-0.1453002244234085,
-0.28467679023742676,
0.7759064435958862,
0.15404930710792542,
-0.6227078437805176,
0.8432746529579163,
-0.14644378423690796,
0.635927140712738,
-0.6097110509872437,
0.038867250084877014,
-0.2543693482875824,
0.253960520029068,
-0.5468735098838806,
-0.5285269021987915,
0.6046638488769531,
-0.5121712684631348,
-0.10350792109966278,
-0.1389479786157608,
0.5738930106163025,
-0.3279294967651367,
0.07930368185043335,
0.10839905589818954,
0.5300657749176025,
-0.00340861058793962,
-0.049445487558841705,
-0.4925738573074341,
0.14013724029064178,
0.014620699919760227,
-0.37882810831069946,
0.36479222774505615,
0.6473320126533508,
0.1016857773065567,
0.40540382266044617,
0.6861332654953003,
-0.17692650854587555,
-0.2058667242527008,
-0.09259109199047089,
1.0425621271133423,
-0.6527169346809387,
-0.24478429555892944,
-0.6324012875556946,
0.5288304090499878,
0.4917910695075989,
-0.7918552160263062,
0.8605063557624817,
0.7028243541717529,
1.2374588251113892,
-0.03007899969816208,
0.4904588460922241,
-0.287411630153656,
0.20139575004577637,
-0.45553576946258545,
0.5090867280960083,
-0.9110124707221985,
0.2053864747285843,
0.15668149292469025,
-1.3283135890960693,
-0.17352965474128723,
0.7258731722831726,
-0.3010329604148865,
0.2543390095233917,
0.8926609754562378,
0.992785632610321,
-0.46163010597229004,
0.39051011204719543,
0.542385995388031,
0.14569124579429626,
0.19924888014793396,
0.48994970321655273,
0.9286174774169922,
-0.5190663933753967,
0.7596060037612915,
-0.39480701088905334,
-0.16772857308387756,
-0.3516010642051697,
-0.5951535105705261,
-1.0399500131607056,
-0.45679834485054016,
-0.13238991796970367,
-0.1832314282655716,
0.015477589331567287,
0.724719762802124,
0.9573467969894409,
-0.7472716569900513,
0.06957109272480011,
-0.2975931167602539,
-0.0972176343202591,
-0.509791374206543,
-0.0676204040646553,
0.21755050122737885,
-0.5055489540100098,
-0.9941090941429138,
0.465179443359375,
0.1276085078716278,
-0.2543591558933258,
-0.3504978120326996,
0.27528172731399536,
0.14684800803661346,
-0.15879027545452118,
0.26994436979293823,
0.515993058681488,
-0.6320424675941467,
-0.5111289024353027,
-0.1718161702156067,
-0.23916763067245483,
0.034003373235464096,
0.865222156047821,
-0.9536200761795044,
0.3300751745700836,
0.543891191482544,
0.808652400970459,
0.9096214175224304,
-0.09973671287298203,
0.54262775182724,
-0.32676976919174194,
-0.1913260519504547,
-0.0007719383575022221,
0.4457361400127411,
0.0011088454630225897,
-0.23006804287433624,
0.5112857818603516,
0.026953404769301414,
-0.8360398411750793,
-0.385701060295105,
0.1348540484905243,
-1.2147493362426758,
-0.04948587343096733,
0.884209930896759,
0.05824030935764313,
-0.005841697566211224,
-0.6076900959014893,
-0.5067993402481079,
0.3753829896450043,
-0.2671404778957367,
1.136020302772522,
0.10520154237747192,
-0.233709916472435,
0.3067295253276825,
-0.1856881082057953,
0.4977192282676697,
0.8635770082473755,
-0.5301656126976013,
-0.4480040669441223,
0.15432672202587128,
0.42955392599105835,
0.5225775241851807,
0.0469929538667202,
-0.09347468614578247,
0.6789326071739197,
0.28151458501815796,
-0.010611130855977535,
-0.4190334975719452,
-0.3074750304222107,
-0.5281628370285034,
0.3706984519958496,
0.06101134046912193,
-0.33611929416656494
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13518v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13518v2
|
Motion Generation from Fine-grained Textual Descriptions
| 2024-03-20T11:38:30 | 2024-03-26T11:16:47 |
Kunhang Li, Yansong Feng
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.RO
|
The task of text2motion is to generate human motion sequences from given
textual descriptions, where the model explores diverse mappings from natural
language instructions to human body movements. While most existing works are
confined to coarse-grained motion descriptions, e.g., "A man squats.",
fine-grained descriptions specifying movements of relevant body parts are
barely explored. Models trained with coarse-grained texts may not be able to
learn mappings from fine-grained motion-related words to motion primitives,
resulting in the failure to generate motions from unseen descriptions. In this
paper, we build a large-scale language-motion dataset specializing in
fine-grained textual descriptions, FineHumanML3D, by feeding GPT-3.5-turbo with
step-by-step instructions with pseudo-code compulsory checks. Accordingly, we
design a new text2motion model, FineMotionDiffuse, making full use of
fine-grained textual information. Our quantitative evaluation shows that
FineMotionDiffuse trained on FineHumanML3D improves FID by a large margin of
0.38, compared with competitive baselines. According to the qualitative
evaluation and case study, our model outperforms MotionDiffuse in generating
spatially or chronologically composite motions, by learning the implicit
mappings from fine-grained descriptions to the corresponding basic motions. We
release our data at https://github.com/KunhangL/finemotiondiffuse.
|
[
0.10871079564094543,
-0.6978346705436707,
0.6961086988449097,
0.03813515231013298,
-0.4717395305633545,
-0.3350859582424164,
0.03322288393974304,
-0.5099127292633057,
0.010175724513828754,
0.6975880265235901,
-0.6201197504997253,
-0.4121784567832947,
-0.5908092856407166,
-0.08582936972379684,
-0.8483965992927551,
1.2043107748031616,
-0.3013947904109955,
0.06369994580745697,
0.11108499765396118,
-0.04927678778767586,
-0.557604193687439,
-0.0636395737528801,
-0.26553165912628174,
-0.7148857712745667,
0.0932144969701767,
0.4148580729961395,
0.7919803261756897,
0.6975751519203186,
0.5660596489906311,
0.22539398074150085,
-0.11092179268598557,
0.17168694734573364,
-0.5522096753120422,
-0.1199508011341095,
-0.2216944545507431,
-0.21746692061424255,
-0.13118673861026764,
-0.29306560754776,
0.5032858848571777,
0.49249202013015747,
-0.18461892008781433,
-0.09457570314407349,
0.2043883502483368,
0.8673937916755676,
-0.5070222616195679,
0.19224584102630615,
0.06131445989012718,
0.2905530631542206,
-0.25228750705718994,
-0.30011406540870667,
0.07658027112483978,
-0.1806587129831314,
0.07444944977760315,
-0.5669124722480774,
0.5071486830711365,
-0.1116812452673912,
0.7469966411590576,
0.2616763412952423,
-0.019278045743703842,
-0.34149637818336487,
-0.9527104496955872,
0.16377925872802734,
-0.34949856996536255,
0.2803584337234497,
0.6250389814376831,
0.37246379256248474,
-0.15551401674747467,
-0.7361627221107483,
-0.5491601824760437,
-0.03139147162437439,
-0.06245448812842369,
-0.0399300716817379,
0.1547214239835739,
-0.022736642509698868,
0.24818821251392365,
0.22594712674617767,
-0.912926971912384,
-0.12581221759319305,
-0.3910594582557678,
-0.12895463407039642,
0.6823435425758362,
0.5429570078849792,
0.2271619290113449,
-0.3793072998523712,
-0.6122016906738281,
-0.33830779790878296,
-0.5503036379814148,
0.10286359488964081,
0.2039342075586319,
0.13452769815921783,
-0.6786075830459595,
0.7674886584281921,
-0.3792502284049988,
0.42040902376174927,
0.31275293231010437,
-0.09227564185857773,
0.09769926965236664,
-0.28224629163742065,
-0.050111621618270874,
0.0463692806661129,
0.9231890439987183,
0.6964587569236755,
0.30221521854400635,
-0.4516945779323578,
-0.2964498698711395,
-0.33711105585098267,
0.03531648591160774,
-1.163880467414856,
-0.30952024459838867,
0.20397718250751495,
-0.35461145639419556,
-0.09561453759670258,
0.3817143738269806,
-1.03494131565094,
-0.7103068232536316,
-0.5467352867126465,
0.42850232124328613,
-0.8382890224456787,
-0.11484752595424652,
0.48733076453208923,
-0.23251460492610931,
0.3680253028869629,
0.33197322487831116,
-1.080880045890808,
0.27392271161079407,
0.9016132354736328,
1.0006656646728516,
-0.07108055055141449,
-0.3447694480419159,
-0.5134289264678955,
0.4061460494995117,
-0.2529450058937073,
0.8300679326057434,
-0.27941474318504333,
-0.3890877962112427,
0.13271819055080414,
-0.044780079275369644,
0.029291929677128792,
-0.3801216185092926,
0.36356326937675476,
-0.13142573833465576,
0.2287609875202179,
0.026138493791222572,
-0.5010772943496704,
-0.3807237148284912,
0.029209472239017487,
-0.515118420124054,
0.7930534482002258,
0.1747516393661499,
-0.742159366607666,
0.22024665772914886,
-0.6682162880897522,
-0.6888203620910645,
-0.0646791160106659,
-0.2727369964122772,
-0.16233159601688385,
0.18790081143379211,
-0.1597364991903305,
0.6460494995117188,
-0.34656259417533875,
0.42461809515953064,
0.20148314535617828,
-0.550721287727356,
-0.04089399799704552,
-0.34159451723098755,
0.3619566559791565,
0.17379672825336456,
-0.4984804391860962,
-0.14440609514713287,
-0.7836301326751709,
-0.43614017963409424,
0.21079209446907043,
-0.3326416611671448,
-0.19291166961193085,
0.2919995188713074,
-0.03069998323917389,
0.06597204506397247,
-0.09790270030498505,
-0.2635890245437622,
0.01941513642668724,
-0.5717079043388367,
0.12902775406837463,
0.4215535819530487,
-0.011588508263230324,
0.7087557315826416,
-0.534218430519104,
0.47499018907546997,
-0.171055406332016,
-0.2529548108577728,
-0.34663596749305725,
-0.45686057209968567,
-0.39623332023620605,
-0.005262731108814478,
0.017315546050667763,
0.4458959102630615,
-0.9567855000495911,
-0.0022857144940644503,
-0.5734483003616333,
-0.3894331157207489,
0.006486380472779274,
-0.01812557689845562,
0.5734207034111023,
0.443657249212265,
0.528078556060791,
-0.017306983470916748,
-0.20683243870735168,
-0.46963801980018616,
0.005308700259774923,
-0.2572341859340668,
-0.5202702283859253,
0.13349969685077667,
0.3141997158527374,
-0.4025322198867798,
0.7568397521972656,
-0.6961801648139954,
-0.29567596316337585,
0.006683250889182091,
0.8274483680725098,
-0.4979347884654999,
0.6030288338661194,
0.7845338582992554,
-0.6505510807037354,
-0.12110813707113266,
0.10346910357475281,
-0.47959163784980774,
-0.26333072781562805,
-0.44945722818374634,
-0.4691486060619354,
0.12347576767206192,
0.49666181206703186,
-0.8361391425132751,
0.27729907631874084,
0.6262131929397583,
-0.704208493232727,
0.4435087740421295,
-0.35118919610977173,
0.10048117488622665,
-1.2409042119979858,
0.3098626732826233,
0.11148330569267273,
-0.31438198685646057,
-0.390960693359375,
0.31831589341163635,
-0.06688055396080017,
-0.10625602304935455,
-0.6593402624130249,
0.6847176551818848,
-0.22850780189037323,
-0.0671868845820427,
-0.44951578974723816,
0.19469505548477173,
0.04594418406486511,
0.6222683191299438,
0.24446292221546173,
0.5228767395019531,
0.3582695722579956,
-0.8843901753425598,
0.0014998059486970305,
0.3151131272315979,
-0.13325747847557068,
0.29262369871139526,
-0.4376952648162842,
0.015564962290227413,
-0.2962082326412201,
0.10217233002185822,
-0.837530791759491,
-0.8722419142723083,
0.3218978941440582,
-0.4198024868965149,
0.577497661113739,
0.010418410412967205,
-0.4251166582107544,
-0.3861550986766815,
-0.42382463812828064,
0.17052127420902252,
0.5445144772529602,
-0.5633335113525391,
0.5064898133277893,
0.15101797878742218,
-0.04314671456813812,
-0.07071687281131744,
-0.9141185283660889,
-0.12404526770114899,
0.0041231755167245865,
-0.5027382969856262,
0.4007513225078583,
0.014674057252705097,
-0.03650788590312004,
-0.32267868518829346,
-0.14595474302768707,
-0.25740471482276917,
0.03208400681614876,
0.3539961278438568,
-0.09244983643293381,
-0.013422103598713875,
-0.0929558053612709,
0.12646520137786865,
-0.1764959692955017,
0.22641633450984955,
-0.14475253224372864,
0.6914215683937073,
0.16203859448432922,
-0.24174340069293976,
-0.7815240621566772,
0.31595471501350403,
0.6562918424606323,
0.3082107603549957,
0.2112935334444046,
1.0230497121810913,
-0.4213224947452545,
0.26589712500572205,
0.1149141862988472,
-0.27277371287345886,
-0.44023212790489197,
0.525381326675415,
-0.10934869945049286,
-0.6572796106338501,
0.2109333574771881,
-0.19113199412822723,
0.08633869141340256,
0.6313455104827881,
0.4002363979816437,
-0.3455940783023834,
0.857088565826416,
0.5970744490623474,
0.2938586175441742,
0.26178044080734253,
-0.49310407042503357,
-0.23491603136062622,
-0.686953067779541,
-0.3602180480957031,
-0.7309767603874207,
-0.6428795456886292,
-0.6515358090400696,
-0.8552046418190002,
-0.23785626888275146,
0.17266874015331268,
-0.4693398177623749,
0.5311217308044434,
-0.20078954100608826,
0.4393121600151062,
0.2416386753320694,
0.1884508728981018,
0.06706301122903824,
0.23308567702770233,
-0.284267783164978,
0.07808229327201843,
-0.3621978163719177,
-0.7081184387207031,
0.7054538130760193,
0.2564295530319214,
0.9563314914703369,
0.35562360286712646,
0.5116653442382812,
0.3705987334251404,
0.23293565213680267,
-0.7840895652770996,
0.7549868822097778,
-0.6240463256835938,
-0.3935984969139099,
-0.20159615576267242,
-0.5033632516860962,
-0.9004086852073669,
0.01655597984790802,
-0.2906750738620758,
-0.571723222732544,
-0.0684860497713089,
0.274200975894928,
-0.522314190864563,
0.2264111340045929,
-0.5432240962982178,
0.5955125689506531,
-0.27920782566070557,
-0.5717116594314575,
-0.06745992600917816,
-0.9238599538803101,
0.5836806893348694,
-0.3084457516670227,
0.14210627973079681,
-0.14511559903621674,
0.14508040249347687,
0.4856971502304077,
-0.615336537361145,
0.7845549583435059,
-0.42078518867492676,
-0.3169768750667572,
0.4444161355495453,
0.38291695713996887,
0.5763410329818726,
-0.11499883234500885,
0.13524681329727173,
0.2296028584241867,
-0.20889699459075928,
-0.11001909524202347,
-0.1088206097483635,
0.5302121043205261,
-0.5164952874183655,
-0.2076926976442337,
-0.0732932984828949,
-0.30335432291030884,
-0.007796481717377901,
0.029842494055628777,
0.4549546539783478,
0.47637462615966797,
-0.27885308861732483,
0.25709453225135803,
0.40538567304611206,
-0.14179815351963043,
0.8236461877822876,
0.44050681591033936,
-0.2725371718406677,
-0.3171311020851135,
0.8768723011016846,
-0.31913843750953674,
0.1301928162574768,
0.7837510108947754,
0.5072784423828125,
-0.4747474491596222,
-0.49037107825279236,
-0.6841927170753479,
-0.006600628606975079,
-0.02448464184999466,
-0.44971734285354614,
-0.5902721285820007,
0.1462857574224472,
-0.13022302091121674,
-0.34840941429138184,
-0.28843870759010315,
-0.5475456118583679,
-0.4208719730377197,
-0.03961094468832016,
0.21571362018585205,
0.5881691575050354,
-0.07239086180925369,
0.6818204522132874,
-1.1200793981552124,
0.8298543095588684,
0.3435722589492798,
0.25689804553985596,
-0.25562217831611633,
-0.6902591586112976,
-0.26967087388038635,
0.5223808288574219,
-0.7701784372329712,
-0.47675520181655884,
0.43667173385620117,
0.4325338304042816,
0.06457779556512833,
0.7342292070388794,
-0.012244537472724915,
0.8839737772941589,
-0.8693055510520935,
1.068122148513794,
0.49597710371017456,
-0.5891181826591492,
0.460524320602417,
-0.5947269797325134,
0.5988088250160217,
0.3845321238040924,
0.2982155978679657,
-0.23466630280017853,
-0.3886359632015228,
-0.30422526597976685,
-0.8973062634468079,
0.9462738037109375,
0.432980477809906,
0.5277494788169861,
-0.12501242756843567,
0.6101037263870239,
0.2666487693786621,
-0.13798466324806213,
-0.4586242437362671,
0.21568354964256287,
-0.21210825443267822,
-0.3942859172821045,
0.04201114922761917,
-0.27104058861732483,
0.08307881653308868,
-0.016735238954424858,
0.40409597754478455,
-0.4315134584903717,
0.4120190143585205,
0.1956789493560791,
-0.30885380506515503,
-0.3658497929573059,
-0.22675827145576477,
0.9823341965675354,
-0.06584729999303818,
-0.08162929862737656,
-0.012618308886885643,
-0.3915276527404785,
-0.8649478554725647,
0.106174997985363,
0.31963905692100525,
-0.37866052985191345,
0.07298482954502106,
0.3639470338821411,
0.9670862555503845,
0.43031781911849976,
-0.7378789782524109,
0.6023605465888977,
-0.08602140843868256,
-0.547637403011322,
0.10861612111330032,
0.3821965157985687,
0.034418102353811264,
0.32829996943473816,
0.20098364353179932,
0.3620469570159912,
0.2784999907016754,
-0.20682191848754883,
0.22519350051879883,
-0.020425919443368912,
-0.26606735587120056,
-0.7021129727363586,
1.114883303642273,
0.37967371940612793,
-0.40348783135414124,
0.38505035638809204,
-0.18860584497451782,
-0.1506650298833847,
0.4687120020389557,
0.4775504171848297,
1.2286412715911865,
-0.15451450645923615,
0.25159531831741333,
0.6789208650588989,
0.028844309970736504,
-0.5485930442810059,
0.2691454291343689,
-0.18743909895420074,
-0.3792484998703003,
-0.5125114321708679,
-0.8612654209136963,
-0.12057431787252426,
0.009510818868875504,
-0.4961871802806854,
0.5401206016540527,
-0.40613728761672974,
-0.10607510060071945,
-0.25707387924194336,
-0.33442652225494385,
-0.5799911618232727,
0.18261177837848663,
0.5239859819412231,
0.8205816745758057,
-0.7436056733131409,
0.520917534828186,
0.8557373881340027,
-0.27931153774261475,
-0.5154255628585815,
0.7024145126342773,
0.07022466510534286,
-0.42623788118362427,
0.409999281167984,
0.5105594992637634,
-0.25012582540512085,
-0.24873937666416168,
-0.48228853940963745,
-0.46640557050704956,
1.2580821514129639,
0.5437571406364441,
-0.535439670085907,
-0.13025560975074768,
0.5309827327728271,
0.576539158821106,
-0.00594807555899024,
-0.07263054698705673,
0.3023572862148285,
0.37803637981414795,
0.3793509602546692,
-0.6562667489051819,
-0.15721525251865387,
0.15748357772827148,
0.11304570734500885,
0.18294455111026764,
-0.8186300992965698,
0.579766035079956,
-0.33141374588012695,
-0.2908271551132202,
0.5941430330276489,
0.5447841882705688,
0.15988877415657043,
0.281416118144989,
0.10723970830440521,
0.49529609084129333,
0.5027113556861877,
-0.14818376302719116,
1.336885690689087,
-0.470053106546402,
0.43595990538597107,
1.3904262781143188,
-0.20382890105247498,
0.726483166217804,
0.2428532838821411,
0.011495478451251984,
0.3601105809211731,
0.3779212236404419,
0.5140848755836487,
0.729857861995697,
0.004149804823100567,
-0.02359025552868843,
-0.07986729592084885,
0.31718242168426514,
-0.0866895392537117,
0.8780953884124756,
0.18546365201473236,
-0.2793753445148468,
-0.6087203025817871,
0.14287115633487701,
0.05631236732006073,
0.193611741065979,
-0.26779404282569885,
0.8209151029586792,
-0.2249344289302826,
-0.5413042306900024,
0.5335259437561035,
0.25370535254478455,
0.5581273436546326,
-0.6119070053100586,
-0.24791274964809418,
-0.5772807598114014,
0.06062989681959152,
0.05704754218459129,
-0.9809184074401855,
0.47068285942077637,
0.37305352091789246,
-0.08993349969387054,
-0.43232831358909607,
0.39858514070510864,
-0.43399778008461,
-0.21870794892311096,
0.07214929163455963,
0.1347842514514923,
0.416181355714798,
-0.06597429513931274,
-0.4296064078807831,
-0.30311018228530884,
0.058897823095321655,
-0.23978473246097565,
0.21417732536792755,
0.8730629682540894,
-0.1555933803319931,
0.4952283799648285,
0.3509540259838104,
-0.3429529070854187,
-0.10852497816085815,
0.025967147201299667,
0.6719714999198914,
-0.6507718563079834,
-0.3583661913871765,
-0.7523388266563416,
0.5274698138237,
0.20179800689220428,
-0.2542897164821625,
0.32764965295791626,
0.7047523856163025,
0.6508921384811401,
-0.2921827733516693,
0.2870282232761383,
-0.3033626973628998,
0.32406648993492126,
-0.896362841129303,
0.813824474811554,
-0.42726248502731323,
0.09072942286729813,
-0.13142624497413635,
-0.744805634021759,
-0.2821353077888489,
0.7613906264305115,
0.3552993834018707,
0.06826476752758026,
0.7013859748840332,
0.6391151547431946,
-0.16645139455795288,
0.017255540937185287,
0.23648452758789062,
0.2623271346092224,
0.22530396282672882,
0.356295108795166,
0.37122586369514465,
-0.6413189172744751,
0.4044433534145355,
-0.18763801455497742,
0.0199922826141119,
-0.4945513904094696,
-0.8689940571784973,
-0.6043557524681091,
-0.4857335090637207,
-0.40189021825790405,
-0.21524681150913239,
-0.030494973063468933,
0.7788774371147156,
0.7980586886405945,
-0.6869462132453918,
-0.0010922260116785765,
-0.5078977346420288,
-0.4287727177143097,
-0.09556526690721512,
-0.2560136616230011,
0.2699514329433441,
-0.10768713802099228,
-0.906375527381897,
0.14106494188308716,
0.08261799812316895,
0.6719276309013367,
-0.12249583750963211,
-0.4992317259311676,
-0.09083729982376099,
-0.09087732434272766,
0.7829271554946899,
0.32824504375457764,
-0.2626439034938812,
-0.45631399750709534,
-0.18565616011619568,
-0.2822454571723938,
-0.15580372512340546,
0.9061485528945923,
-0.6451647877693176,
0.23566366732120514,
0.572477400302887,
0.5279083847999573,
0.5013585686683655,
0.2628801465034485,
0.45656341314315796,
-0.9326602220535278,
0.3713146150112152,
0.029219433665275574,
0.2344738245010376,
0.30470097064971924,
-0.2306414246559143,
0.6731476187705994,
0.3351011276245117,
-0.29803794622421265,
-0.18864737451076508,
-0.074675053358078,
-0.9576229453086853,
-0.2834705114364624,
1.638118028640747,
0.17807453870773315,
-0.26021602749824524,
0.0812525674700737,
-0.6618553996086121,
0.21154285967350006,
-0.2772224247455597,
0.8520535826683044,
0.419141560792923,
-0.15118759870529175,
0.1903650462627411,
-0.590014636516571,
0.49483731389045715,
-0.01913031004369259,
-0.6495499610900879,
0.3849753439426422,
1.0679305791854858,
0.18990492820739746,
0.014322237111628056,
0.5430446863174438,
-0.2365606278181076,
0.2810748517513275,
-0.15229129791259766,
0.19216389954090118,
-0.039842117577791214,
-0.3884302079677582,
-0.15988272428512573,
0.09935198724269867,
-0.34893086552619934,
-0.30268916487693787
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13514v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13514v1
|
How Gender Interacts with Political Values: A Case Study on Czech BERT Models
| 2024-03-20T11:30:45 | 2024-03-20T11:30:45 |
Adnan Al Ali, Jindřich Libovický
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Neural language models, which reach state-of-the-art results on most natural
language processing tasks, are trained on large text corpora that inevitably
contain value-burdened content and often capture undesirable biases, which the
models reflect. This case study focuses on the political biases of pre-trained
encoders in Czech and compares them with a representative value survey. Because
Czech is a gendered language, we also measure how the grammatical gender
coincides with responses to men and women in the survey. We introduce a novel
method for measuring the model's perceived political values. We find that the
models do not assign statement probability following value-driven reasoning,
and there is no systematic difference between feminine and masculine sentences.
We conclude that BERT-sized models do not manifest systematic alignment with
political values and that the biases observed in the models are rather due to
superficial imitation of training data patterns than systematic value beliefs
encoded in the models.
|
[
-0.20739535987377167,
-0.5841034650802612,
0.5793936252593994,
0.056719228625297546,
-0.2238631546497345,
0.06482597440481186,
-0.4041478931903839,
-0.3172699809074402,
0.13496237993240356,
0.49920299649238586,
-0.8184598088264465,
-0.3738614022731781,
-0.7933326959609985,
-0.10633032768964767,
-0.18406935036182404,
0.8547499775886536,
0.47579970955848694,
0.5858222246170044,
-0.21345090866088867,
-0.0007748716743662953,
-0.28863486647605896,
-1.1964784860610962,
0.049596261233091354,
-0.3989531099796295,
0.335916668176651,
-0.014229037798941135,
0.8162993788719177,
0.12423130124807358,
0.36008596420288086,
0.299051970243454,
-0.33051228523254395,
-0.1302909404039383,
-0.4303397536277771,
0.2506990432739258,
-0.11687415838241577,
-0.4705342650413513,
-0.19136017560958862,
0.4304552674293518,
0.45041364431381226,
0.883354902267456,
0.2038619965314865,
0.0612233504652977,
-0.08405230939388275,
0.9671204686164856,
-0.5349116921424866,
0.3771888017654419,
-0.8136619329452515,
-0.04969426989555359,
0.013039066456258297,
0.04832606390118599,
-0.35336071252822876,
-0.9546464085578918,
0.45011019706726074,
-0.06499793380498886,
0.09018810093402863,
0.008261920884251595,
1.0384522676467896,
-0.04107464477419853,
-0.5098163485527039,
-0.5014289021492004,
-0.5783597230911255,
0.9920544028282166,
-0.6446335911750793,
0.2029920220375061,
0.3699972927570343,
0.06475318968296051,
-0.17268532514572144,
0.03869788721203804,
-0.6217839121818542,
-0.28652578592300415,
-0.12219619750976562,
-0.06446441262960434,
-0.16396857798099518,
0.08697571605443954,
-0.017657088115811348,
0.1054319441318512,
-0.19922007620334625,
-0.2443372756242752,
-0.4571291506290436,
0.17396113276481628,
0.4431869387626648,
0.009543821215629578,
0.13928204774856567,
-0.6203039288520813,
-0.17407755553722382,
-0.14614763855934143,
-0.6512409448623657,
0.30371344089508057,
1.2586091756820679,
0.9868751168251038,
0.33329054713249207,
0.719421923160553,
0.3584257662296295,
0.7417861819267273,
0.39179307222366333,
0.47906967997550964,
0.05383835732936859,
-0.464444100856781,
-0.1290908306837082,
0.1974029392004013,
0.5951225161552429,
-0.15110231935977936,
0.7340000867843628,
0.06351786851882935,
-0.08967141062021255,
0.039148733019828796,
0.5304197669029236,
-0.6795554161071777,
0.0007438738248310983,
-0.025789957493543625,
-0.7374141216278076,
-0.5376614928245544,
0.05277630314230919,
-0.7164928913116455,
-0.27251121401786804,
-0.5552946329116821,
0.40895578265190125,
-0.33418095111846924,
-0.4314369261264801,
0.10063543915748596,
-0.39881908893585205,
0.24130965769290924,
0.33043578267097473,
-1.226479411125183,
0.34221434593200684,
0.6804013252258301,
0.2268049418926239,
0.029032757505774498,
0.26496756076812744,
0.002802453236654401,
-0.4717012345790863,
-0.6430007815361023,
0.6092736721038818,
-0.8992598056793213,
-0.10278426855802536,
0.16333870589733124,
-0.14055684208869934,
-0.04174515977501869,
-0.501878023147583,
0.04010224714875221,
-0.5478491187095642,
0.43945828080177307,
-0.7998203635215759,
-0.5240246057510376,
0.0944342166185379,
0.35435929894447327,
-0.6700770258903503,
1.0862417221069336,
0.14374816417694092,
-0.8639533519744873,
0.695270299911499,
-0.5804086923599243,
-0.09275677055120468,
-0.3631724715232849,
-0.6469951272010803,
-0.20176634192466736,
0.15040095150470734,
-0.3482932150363922,
0.28455546498298645,
-0.15775252878665924,
0.5416144728660583,
-0.3883063793182373,
-0.16986480355262756,
0.4965313971042633,
-0.34740620851516724,
1.0909712314605713,
-0.2275220900774002,
-0.3220580518245697,
0.5590865015983582,
-0.6173586249351501,
0.1100950837135315,
-0.11823694407939911,
-0.14343684911727905,
-0.6057103872299194,
0.15865738689899445,
0.2019505351781845,
0.47543901205062866,
0.3671393394470215,
-0.6787869930267334,
0.19858290255069733,
-0.23643669486045837,
0.2959202527999878,
1.152530312538147,
-0.5070688724517822,
0.7816492319107056,
0.09002045542001724,
0.2229011058807373,
-0.1846412569284439,
0.04302694648504257,
0.5274425148963928,
-0.4673245847225189,
-0.3963634967803955,
-0.27038058638572693,
0.6399188041687012,
0.587053120136261,
-0.13054046034812927,
0.7861707806587219,
-0.06795113533735275,
-0.31995174288749695,
-0.5870875120162964,
-0.1948089301586151,
0.012030962854623795,
0.10829788446426392,
0.03257321938872337,
0.20100753009319305,
-0.5412445664405823,
-1.3874019384384155,
-0.3997793197631836,
-0.5608617067337036,
-0.15923279523849487,
0.4240713119506836,
0.7985382676124573,
0.27637356519699097,
1.2294206619262695,
-0.17254453897476196,
0.07167168706655502,
-0.2547476291656494,
0.5933522582054138,
0.1766069084405899,
0.35290074348449707,
0.4996175467967987,
-0.7542285323143005,
0.11006861180067062,
-0.19659754633903503,
-0.4950391352176666,
-0.17844578623771667,
0.17060603201389313,
-0.3564891815185547,
0.3936441242694855,
0.011161747388541698,
-0.3239562213420868,
0.5881145596504211,
0.7817332148551941,
-0.8096358180046082,
0.5222086310386658,
-0.1062171533703804,
0.4320179224014282,
-0.7337338328361511,
0.01312981266528368,
-0.19642136991024017,
-0.27019158005714417,
-0.619328498840332,
-0.4223569333553314,
-0.021418487653136253,
0.1785944104194641,
-0.5570831894874573,
0.1526421755552292,
-0.27613595128059387,
-0.47390493750572205,
-0.3738056421279907,
-0.16488544642925262,
-0.09091750532388687,
0.1651732325553894,
0.2960650324821472,
0.7232275605201721,
-0.11089997738599777,
-0.3179325759410858,
0.18911540508270264,
0.3102225959300995,
-0.328677237033844,
0.6636145114898682,
-0.43545031547546387,
0.14929473400115967,
-0.38980114459991455,
-0.08023648709058762,
-1.194868564605713,
0.2092439979314804,
0.22693006694316864,
-0.597993791103363,
0.02948126569390297,
-0.2939341068267822,
-0.6479807496070862,
-0.07062644511461258,
-0.2439820021390915,
0.2323775589466095,
0.49110186100006104,
-0.32260218262672424,
0.7059869170188904,
0.39367809891700745,
-0.11907658725976944,
-0.6857879757881165,
-0.625822126865387,
-0.16565054655075073,
-0.1061006560921669,
-0.5472472906112671,
0.05867564305663109,
-0.07343050837516785,
-0.4996882975101471,
0.38575074076652527,
0.03693739324808121,
-0.47439801692962646,
-0.21027079224586487,
0.13328862190246582,
0.5102040767669678,
-0.20396390557289124,
0.4157416820526123,
0.10506653785705566,
0.33219364285469055,
0.18290124833583832,
-0.19392774999141693,
0.6797611117362976,
-0.37280920147895813,
-0.1847882866859436,
-0.16268695890903473,
0.46831902861595154,
0.6594169735908508,
0.026698879897594452,
1.109892725944519,
0.11821985989809036,
-0.6318515539169312,
0.19316837191581726,
-0.47008219361305237,
-0.421403169631958,
-0.4052478075027466,
0.27619338035583496,
-0.13938798010349274,
-0.9599606394767761,
0.631653368473053,
0.22881314158439636,
0.09214632213115692,
0.5735152959823608,
0.5436713695526123,
-0.38950780034065247,
1.0068084001541138,
0.5899225473403931,
-0.10974782705307007,
0.5059059262275696,
0.05452202260494232,
0.2795121669769287,
-0.4551033079624176,
-0.22272703051567078,
-0.9520170092582703,
-0.31402525305747986,
-0.8007198572158813,
-0.15232731401920319,
-0.05020236223936081,
-0.3358701467514038,
-0.7734841704368591,
0.19424983859062195,
-0.5279816389083862,
0.1016121432185173,
0.541060209274292,
-0.0073066093027591705,
-0.24421998858451843,
-0.18452641367912292,
0.44672372937202454,
-0.540144145488739,
-0.723491907119751,
-0.7962104082107544,
0.8705860376358032,
0.0539068803191185,
0.8877725601196289,
-0.0959319993853569,
0.2519243359565735,
0.31797218322753906,
0.06505323946475983,
-0.5004940032958984,
0.4312955439090729,
-0.28442004323005676,
-1.0456913709640503,
-0.5907340049743652,
-0.4414733946323395,
-0.9189810752868652,
0.3133816421031952,
-0.5398363471031189,
-0.4887455403804779,
0.6167263984680176,
0.060704994946718216,
-0.050716180354356766,
0.5154310464859009,
-0.0859808549284935,
0.9019049406051636,
-0.4307248294353485,
-0.2456965446472168,
-0.19738543033599854,
-0.6046640872955322,
0.2768169939517975,
0.2470104694366455,
0.13345001637935638,
-0.37902340292930603,
0.21018828451633453,
0.6750633120536804,
-0.11335031688213348,
1.0060203075408936,
-0.12153182178735733,
-0.10435175895690918,
-0.061070140451192856,
-0.1487533450126648,
0.0077798981219530106,
-0.31504377722740173,
-0.1862897425889969,
0.36852121353149414,
0.04255202040076256,
-0.5789489150047302,
-0.2969983220100403,
0.48063328862190247,
-1.0157819986343384,
-0.5769011974334717,
-0.738438606262207,
-0.5603150129318237,
0.32310107350349426,
0.09693761169910431,
0.2004648745059967,
0.14088749885559082,
-0.5490527153015137,
0.3102744519710541,
0.8707242012023926,
-0.4315492808818817,
0.20468203723430634,
0.15853507816791534,
-0.0837317556142807,
-0.27203047275543213,
0.1407385617494583,
0.4231567084789276,
0.5838693976402283,
0.299463152885437,
0.15808957815170288,
-0.22683387994766235,
0.21082182228565216,
-0.4849715530872345,
-0.060175586491823196,
-0.5501453280448914,
-0.026823164895176888,
-0.5165058970451355,
-0.3690081238746643,
-0.26063355803489685,
-0.2417018711566925,
-0.8541483283042908,
-0.42067357897758484,
-0.31043484807014465,
-0.1740460991859436,
0.4970431625843048,
0.821688711643219,
0.1634189337491989,
0.06300792098045349,
-0.23267966508865356,
0.08626813441514969,
0.47848156094551086,
0.26674365997314453,
-0.42561405897140503,
-0.31471434235572815,
0.13513974845409393,
0.1667879968881607,
0.09154250472784042,
-1.4195785522460938,
0.42901986837387085,
-0.30839207768440247,
0.5370141863822937,
0.1564004272222519,
0.12413643300533295,
0.3486344814300537,
-0.6024413108825684,
1.0556272268295288,
-0.20529428124427795,
-1.3836222887039185,
0.6008935570716858,
-0.2755917012691498,
-0.005906681064516306,
0.6099171042442322,
0.054258767515420914,
-0.2677457630634308,
-0.7082467079162598,
-0.5885921716690063,
-0.7361136078834534,
0.5771317481994629,
0.3723461329936981,
0.5791118741035461,
-0.270129531621933,
0.4725602865219116,
0.18319441378116608,
0.7302842140197754,
-0.7031688094139099,
-0.28404611349105835,
-0.5090579390525818,
-0.31779658794403076,
0.2892281115055084,
-0.3521060049533844,
-0.1767134964466095,
-0.3019641935825348,
0.45717620849609375,
-0.04814935475587845,
0.6435917615890503,
0.08339822292327881,
0.015772836282849312,
-0.14786066114902496,
0.5789917707443237,
0.7812390327453613,
0.8424109220504761,
-0.5491129159927368,
0.16829414665699005,
0.01695525273680687,
-0.02916046790778637,
0.33294421434402466,
-0.20179441571235657,
0.04196217283606529,
0.4140804708003998,
0.006300029344856739,
0.7216662764549255,
0.2556614577770233,
-0.3647271990776062,
0.7199305295944214,
-0.11420384794473648,
-0.36044755578041077,
-0.5648595094680786,
-0.3000190854072571,
0.15437032282352448,
0.2283632606267929,
0.4698910117149353,
0.06118030473589897,
0.07149707525968552,
-0.9970971345901489,
-0.11836868524551392,
1.015529751777649,
-0.5138315558433533,
-0.4511081278324127,
0.6089158058166504,
0.1861449033021927,
-0.31292223930358887,
0.7796013951301575,
0.007059471681714058,
-1.1037613153457642,
0.9041816592216492,
0.3469719886779785,
0.7264439463615417,
-0.24112068116664886,
0.10733529925346375,
0.2246817797422409,
0.8905006647109985,
0.14540787041187286,
0.6515268683433533,
0.3590722680091858,
-0.9407086968421936,
-0.4156649708747864,
-0.06952325254678726,
-0.47740638256073,
0.22696582973003387,
-0.8208847641944885,
0.197042778134346,
-0.36831626296043396,
-0.4677252769470215,
-0.09637082368135452,
0.1992345005273819,
-0.7435997724533081,
0.13178445398807526,
0.13795481622219086,
0.7644058465957642,
-1.2666929960250854,
0.6144317388534546,
0.20995743572711945,
-0.2082587480545044,
-0.3132191002368927,
-0.10108494758605957,
-0.008719110861420631,
-0.35791727900505066,
1.1777487993240356,
0.05302954837679863,
-0.2502177059650421,
-0.6030170321464539,
-0.5672059655189514,
-0.6873213648796082,
0.5122730731964111,
0.7457259893417358,
-0.3129284083843231,
0.0905190035700798,
0.09628668427467346,
0.47774064540863037,
-0.5092790722846985,
0.3619876801967621,
0.4113631248474121,
0.8961606025695801,
-0.49925199151039124,
-0.7525092363357544,
-0.23072749376296997,
-0.20034007728099823,
-0.0062096938490867615,
0.23248447477817535,
-0.43332791328430176,
1.1320873498916626,
0.29831889271736145,
0.21320867538452148,
-0.1044628769159317,
0.6664966344833374,
0.14243119955062866,
-0.008508604019880295,
0.6985337138175964,
-0.0507538840174675,
0.8781261444091797,
-0.2583327889442444,
0.7396558523178101,
-0.3286861479282379,
0.14775486290454865,
0.7021890878677368,
-0.43355628848075867,
0.7655619382858276,
0.4478892683982849,
-0.08503954112529755,
0.716046154499054,
0.6354166865348816,
0.08460532873868942,
0.49646487832069397,
0.4243956208229065,
-0.25837332010269165,
-0.3968072831630707,
0.24098674952983856,
-0.37038421630859375,
0.513410747051239,
0.19926860928535461,
-0.5775721669197083,
0.0872739776968956,
-0.07868442684412003,
0.05068806931376457,
0.4129136800765991,
-0.13612714409828186,
0.7105482220649719,
-0.2282942831516266,
-0.20562267303466797,
0.12946712970733643,
-0.2058228850364685,
0.6268780827522278,
-0.6701741218566895,
-0.09361233562231064,
0.2025575041770935,
-0.018806206062436104,
0.07287457585334778,
-0.9035778641700745,
0.43204265832901,
0.1922672539949417,
-0.6951073408126831,
-0.46726682782173157,
0.5435076355934143,
-0.6949585676193237,
-0.511595606803894,
0.390651673078537,
0.5795549750328064,
0.059946365654468536,
-0.023197298869490623,
-0.4229137599468231,
-0.04697799310088158,
-0.13713237643241882,
-0.39381295442581177,
0.42583468556404114,
0.4453086256980896,
-0.06814157962799072,
0.3210408091545105,
0.5216200351715088,
0.19216205179691315,
0.025697704404592514,
0.04619452357292175,
0.7086526155471802,
-0.7627771496772766,
-0.3917306363582611,
-1.083485722541809,
0.24512958526611328,
-0.22060908377170563,
-0.17653827369213104,
0.48549142479896545,
0.6476957201957703,
0.717592179775238,
-0.1557384878396988,
0.8018348813056946,
0.1829300820827484,
0.310774028301239,
-0.3498057425022125,
1.090833067893982,
-0.08394695818424225,
-0.051578588783741,
-0.2512514889240265,
-0.7060137391090393,
-0.01866459660232067,
1.1172541379928589,
-0.5456538200378418,
0.2263665646314621,
0.31661561131477356,
0.3858644366264343,
0.1651889681816101,
0.10405512899160385,
0.2674741744995117,
-0.03316850587725639,
0.10648871958255768,
0.2420872300863266,
1.084410548210144,
-0.07163044810295105,
0.3108430802822113,
-0.012624501250684261,
-0.07640654593706131,
0.002341930055990815,
-1.0505123138427734,
-1.0676809549331665,
-0.6306058764457703,
-0.07280246168375015,
-0.30776578187942505,
0.51407790184021,
1.3396451473236084,
0.9710674285888672,
-0.6144431233406067,
-0.4148700535297394,
-0.00012292616884224117,
0.316598117351532,
-0.00519365631043911,
-0.19709232449531555,
0.36585474014282227,
-0.2835230231285095,
-0.8818870186805725,
-0.16490449011325836,
0.0568934865295887,
-0.28356531262397766,
-0.4009411931037903,
0.23657387495040894,
-0.303031325340271,
0.7742879986763,
0.5677554607391357,
-0.2422531545162201,
-0.9558358192443848,
-0.780643880367279,
0.16123075783252716,
-0.3386583924293518,
0.2708437740802765,
0.8037213683128357,
-0.8326108455657959,
0.42986202239990234,
0.6199573278427124,
0.3724399507045746,
0.0567762665450573,
0.02143808826804161,
0.72578364610672,
-0.6304649710655212,
0.06954875588417053,
0.24839240312576294,
0.22750616073608398,
0.4398242235183716,
-0.5906574130058289,
0.012524979189038277,
0.022044790908694267,
-0.4725336730480194,
-0.8364338874816895,
0.2216629981994629,
-0.7238216996192932,
-0.5726906657218933,
0.9080477356910706,
0.08437290042638779,
-0.24370308220386505,
0.09390930831432343,
-0.30106034874916077,
0.37314605712890625,
-0.3912217617034912,
0.8419303894042969,
1.155008316040039,
0.10687147080898285,
-0.14664767682552338,
-0.9753596186637878,
0.4456852674484253,
0.3048045337200165,
-0.7622300386428833,
0.2784864008426666,
0.4817017614841461,
0.3099474310874939,
0.06968895345926285,
0.46325427293777466,
-0.18545107543468475,
0.2071438431739807,
-0.18444646894931793,
0.513113796710968,
0.22448952496051788,
-0.15554754436016083,
-0.559180736541748,
0.13975612819194794,
-0.20849165320396423,
-0.2893415689468384
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13513v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13513v2
|
What if...?: Thinking Counterfactual Keywords Helps to Mitigate Hallucination in Large Multi-modal Models
| 2024-03-20T11:27:20 | 2024-06-21T06:11:25 |
Junho Kim, Yeon Ju Kim, Yong Man Ro
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
This paper presents a way of enhancing the reliability of Large Multi-modal
Models (LMMs) in addressing hallucination, where the models generate
cross-modal inconsistent responses. Without additional training, we propose
Counterfactual Inception, a novel method that implants counterfactual thinking
into LMMs using self-generated counterfactual keywords. Our method is grounded
in the concept of counterfactual thinking, a cognitive process where human
considers alternative realities, enabling more extensive context exploration.
Bridging the human cognition mechanism into LMMs, we aim for the models to
engage with and generate responses that span a wider contextual scene
understanding, mitigating hallucinatory outputs. We further introduce
Plausibility Verification Process (PVP), a simple yet robust keyword constraint
that effectively filters out sub-optimal keywords to enable the consistent
triggering of counterfactual thinking in the model responses. Comprehensive
analyses across various LMMs, including both open-source and proprietary
models, corroborate that counterfactual thinking significantly reduces
hallucination and helps to broaden contextual understanding based on true
visual clues.
|
[
-0.6824164390563965,
-1.1334223747253418,
0.7517529129981995,
-0.19744129478931427,
-0.48503217101097107,
-0.13713572919368744,
0.05044461786746979,
-0.33867543935775757,
0.13506193459033966,
0.4136449694633484,
-1.0078986883163452,
0.007171517238020897,
-0.3171291947364807,
-0.08061689138412476,
-0.3358282744884491,
0.8060147166252136,
0.21316008269786835,
0.1717863380908966,
-0.5798251628875732,
-0.13341879844665527,
-0.874265730381012,
-0.4558771550655365,
-0.3501623570919037,
-0.24688966572284698,
0.17437659204006195,
0.04978174343705177,
0.6938478946685791,
0.04081728309392929,
0.40678417682647705,
0.3142649531364441,
0.3529219925403595,
0.29232823848724365,
-0.650231122970581,
0.0496620275080204,
-0.5802069306373596,
-0.4239346385002136,
-0.24717821180820465,
0.03507551923394203,
0.35508546233177185,
0.5251585245132446,
0.0024381934199482203,
0.0030941881705075502,
-0.024253802374005318,
0.35850393772125244,
-0.6243789792060852,
-0.02294105291366577,
-1.011740803718567,
0.2552594542503357,
0.4419476091861725,
-0.426772803068161,
-0.3540630340576172,
0.1892952173948288,
0.17081274092197418,
-0.41076987981796265,
0.28139907121658325,
-0.043319977819919586,
0.47381532192230225,
0.43177056312561035,
-0.13603559136390686,
-0.11433398723602295,
-0.7539241909980774,
0.43649017810821533,
-0.4688396751880646,
0.6033787727355957,
0.3540084958076477,
0.08465924859046936,
-0.22086143493652344,
-0.5326855182647705,
-1.028731107711792,
-0.2980903089046478,
-0.07248136401176453,
0.14621613919734955,
0.016654007136821747,
-0.05886661261320114,
0.33380618691444397,
0.20355772972106934,
-0.6316851377487183,
-0.4353361129760742,
-0.25463902950286865,
-0.19294296205043793,
0.45876026153564453,
0.07492829114198685,
0.2675730884075165,
-0.10113072395324707,
-0.40875697135925293,
0.08119410276412964,
-0.6568249464035034,
-0.05025409162044525,
-0.03564436733722687,
0.18160535395145416,
0.06974413990974426,
0.6223938465118408,
-0.07515702396631241,
0.22401779890060425,
0.2648971974849701,
0.04258279502391815,
0.09346182644367218,
-0.7685015201568604,
-0.4593307673931122,
0.09528378397226334,
0.3551293611526489,
0.5934353470802307,
0.051339875906705856,
-0.33354687690734863,
-0.13265027105808258,
0.4271395802497864,
0.7966839671134949,
-0.8260785341262817,
-0.18878386914730072,
0.5575576424598694,
-0.540107011795044,
-0.2650673985481262,
-0.12406304478645325,
-0.5421207547187805,
-0.5285066366195679,
-0.2947341799736023,
1.09866464138031,
-0.5285733342170715,
-0.4449887275695801,
0.13033513724803925,
-0.1158965677022934,
0.11168679594993591,
0.17134353518486023,
-0.478118360042572,
-0.023840995505452156,
0.5914846062660217,
0.6707377433776855,
0.1304541677236557,
-0.5590660572052002,
-0.5429590344429016,
0.010078282095491886,
-0.5677732825279236,
0.7078631520271301,
-0.4839281439781189,
-0.6871216297149658,
-0.22038495540618896,
0.2799854576587677,
-0.09603580832481384,
-0.32791852951049805,
0.311759352684021,
-0.3835381865501404,
0.23459674417972565,
-0.7165710926055908,
-0.5206339955329895,
-0.34132540225982666,
0.5893746018409729,
-0.5124736428260803,
0.7076095938682556,
-0.08559206873178482,
-0.7858363389968872,
0.6900543570518494,
-0.4565877914428711,
-0.24765248596668243,
0.28476935625076294,
-0.6988731026649475,
-0.48497694730758667,
0.4725290834903717,
0.06950162351131439,
0.056340292096138,
-0.2018578201532364,
0.6822111010551453,
-0.4742511808872223,
-0.23285943269729614,
0.4592096209526062,
-0.5761690735816956,
0.5634822249412537,
-0.09998101741075516,
-0.7890615463256836,
0.31055429577827454,
-0.6521026492118835,
-0.05370441451668739,
0.08830346912145615,
0.3994336724281311,
-0.31695660948753357,
-0.04150604456663132,
-0.06948982924222946,
0.4924665093421936,
-0.11797837913036346,
-0.5061401128768921,
0.07880573719739914,
-0.26935023069381714,
0.28816989064216614,
0.6362635493278503,
0.13869555294513702,
0.14041708409786224,
-0.6199447512626648,
0.4004523456096649,
0.2960295081138611,
0.1930263489484787,
-0.38298726081848145,
-0.43550798296928406,
-0.6479207873344421,
-0.20136600732803345,
-0.19546844065189362,
0.5551445484161377,
-1.1346765756607056,
0.33200305700302124,
0.08202840387821198,
-0.3974541127681732,
-0.20722948014736176,
-0.05669365078210831,
0.6024479269981384,
0.8454983830451965,
0.4792283773422241,
-0.32168954610824585,
-0.9106142520904541,
-0.899692177772522,
-0.10776659846305847,
-0.27227073907852173,
0.27474790811538696,
0.24067322909832,
1.0148065090179443,
-0.3112165033817291,
0.9545992016792297,
-0.4118492603302002,
-0.20321029424667358,
-0.18868577480316162,
0.3795282244682312,
-0.18947486579418182,
0.5211174488067627,
0.4427327513694763,
-1.0414687395095825,
0.09234075248241425,
-0.4513671100139618,
-0.8648538589477539,
0.20560091733932495,
-0.6371539831161499,
0.09094598889350891,
0.3662295937538147,
0.8586959838867188,
-0.8601738810539246,
0.785580039024353,
0.16889867186546326,
-0.4715364873409271,
0.6341696381568909,
-0.40998002886772156,
0.2736940383911133,
-0.8570868968963623,
0.20794187486171722,
-0.3080343008041382,
0.21287111937999725,
-0.4107828438282013,
0.07044979184865952,
-0.1610971987247467,
-0.0980599969625473,
-0.45434892177581787,
0.4056282937526703,
-0.24820834398269653,
0.006673323921859264,
-0.33164843916893005,
0.00500161899253726,
-0.10481321066617966,
0.3253045380115509,
0.30436208844184875,
0.8400471210479736,
0.49207359552383423,
-0.4394788444042206,
0.13814273476600647,
0.23101460933685303,
-0.5631924867630005,
1.0156422853469849,
-0.5518506765365601,
0.051169369369745255,
-0.59235018491745,
0.3755391240119934,
-1.2769370079040527,
0.00048205736675299704,
0.19157187640666962,
-0.2624609172344208,
-0.2934483587741852,
0.1158904954791069,
-0.3974660634994507,
-0.30287405848503113,
-0.3437410593032837,
0.38719817996025085,
0.2994180917739868,
-0.47391340136528015,
0.8475426435470581,
0.12442106753587723,
0.26899611949920654,
-0.5491695404052734,
-0.5371127128601074,
0.3006594777107239,
-0.30869707465171814,
-0.3445277810096741,
0.3090481460094452,
-0.5871792435646057,
-0.35649213194847107,
-0.03505929931998253,
-0.24143147468566895,
0.2051277607679367,
0.20705272257328033,
0.4720792770385742,
0.4082093834877014,
-0.05734226480126381,
0.2867940068244934,
-0.07275086641311646,
0.09325522929430008,
0.18078261613845825,
-0.35885995626449585,
0.5286855101585388,
-0.13745728135108948,
-0.47142094373703003,
-0.3174050450325012,
0.4384022355079651,
0.6576265692710876,
-0.024640949442982674,
0.7023794054985046,
0.7443910241127014,
-0.47106578946113586,
-0.33409255743026733,
-0.6491197943687439,
-0.5322969555854797,
-0.4373275339603424,
0.4707421064376831,
-0.8144999146461487,
-0.5080959796905518,
0.5446110367774963,
-0.017918022349476814,
-0.1428295373916626,
0.1957945078611374,
0.6450713276863098,
-0.024311333894729614,
0.822617769241333,
0.6183382272720337,
0.34633690118789673,
0.10533548146486282,
-0.32301169633865356,
0.5187059044837952,
-0.5983302593231201,
-0.610848069190979,
0.11204501986503601,
-0.146918386220932,
-0.33861538767814636,
-0.7326582074165344,
0.4212822914123535,
-0.11672801524400711,
-0.08648406714200974,
0.25737714767456055,
-0.39677807688713074,
0.5640512704849243,
0.3941425383090973,
0.36975181102752686,
0.20278418064117432,
-0.28040727972984314,
-0.31057673692703247,
0.07468622922897339,
-0.43482446670532227,
-0.2327098250389099,
0.9635281562805176,
0.020890023559331894,
0.3908374011516571,
0.09289909154176712,
0.2650473713874817,
0.3231974244117737,
0.20963774621486664,
-0.5711193680763245,
0.7041595578193665,
0.30825087428092957,
-0.9258506298065186,
-0.40982645750045776,
0.013453417457640171,
-0.568095326423645,
0.5386385917663574,
-0.6491705775260925,
-0.7106513381004333,
0.49754294753074646,
0.14682036638259888,
-0.7031036615371704,
0.3407491147518158,
-0.3591255843639374,
0.8869755268096924,
-0.26053908467292786,
-0.5729253888130188,
-0.512932538986206,
-0.6304254531860352,
0.4903542101383209,
-0.30622225999832153,
0.25818076729774475,
0.29649004340171814,
-0.01457098126411438,
0.24890965223312378,
-0.2552366852760315,
1.0220483541488647,
-0.01598619669675827,
-0.23424415290355682,
0.39457306265830994,
0.3330968916416168,
0.3975656032562256,
0.37824273109436035,
0.2754688262939453,
0.20390601456165314,
-0.06666924804449081,
0.05604070797562599,
-0.5719015002250671,
0.6079881191253662,
-0.5656188726425171,
-0.7120085954666138,
-0.3076058626174927,
-0.837503969669342,
-0.22690871357917786,
0.16489426791667938,
0.41781362891197205,
0.4962024986743927,
-0.6299594640731812,
0.286115825176239,
0.867831826210022,
-0.1851484626531601,
0.7351309061050415,
0.42144110798835754,
-0.20259706676006317,
-0.6321899890899658,
0.7075968980789185,
0.2593251168727875,
0.026003016158938408,
0.2306067943572998,
0.1396198272705078,
-0.5017058849334717,
-0.40104302763938904,
-0.4087826907634735,
-0.02236456796526909,
-0.6644579172134399,
0.0006531471153721213,
-0.8851238489151001,
-0.1265851855278015,
-0.4917146563529968,
-0.15992490947246552,
-0.42754045128822327,
-0.291504830121994,
-0.07639385014772415,
-0.12043586373329163,
-0.033350978046655655,
0.2708803713321686,
-0.34015506505966187,
0.024128984659910202,
-0.4242211580276489,
0.7405620217323303,
0.6253425478935242,
0.2120993286371231,
0.2745093107223511,
-0.4863404631614685,
0.0010792186949402094,
0.06000923737883568,
-0.20300111174583435,
-0.5999171733856201,
0.4368303418159485,
0.0857682079076767,
0.6824019551277161,
0.7127596139907837,
0.15861906111240387,
0.7498388290405273,
-0.6389671564102173,
0.7303125262260437,
0.3628219664096832,
-1.1335299015045166,
0.49978113174438477,
-0.20466871559619904,
0.3075343072414398,
0.6870608329772949,
0.5595696568489075,
-0.39043277502059937,
-0.2140384167432785,
-0.7483945488929749,
-0.6772760152816772,
0.2787953019142151,
0.21779108047485352,
0.10240962356328964,
-0.09446682035923004,
0.20653805136680603,
0.43574002385139465,
0.45346739888191223,
-0.9470298290252686,
0.03015005961060524,
-0.6626511812210083,
0.19281087815761566,
-0.3548474609851837,
-0.2953743040561676,
-0.5124874711036682,
-0.3512662649154663,
0.4586906135082245,
-0.0795619860291481,
-0.02888825722038746,
0.5445423126220703,
-0.40315568447113037,
-0.41895171999931335,
0.10015431046485901,
0.9833325743675232,
0.9880455732345581,
-0.39294368028640747,
0.5191793441772461,
0.17216704785823822,
-0.22462214529514313,
0.1684841364622116,
-0.34060099720954895,
-0.29766228795051575,
-0.1515195667743683,
0.32989344000816345,
0.6808454990386963,
0.265013188123703,
-0.7274488806724548,
0.4091454744338989,
-0.02077089063823223,
-0.1642068475484848,
-0.4631066620349884,
-0.007629087194800377,
0.13068921864032745,
0.3630211055278778,
0.42488688230514526,
0.017773523926734924,
0.038715898990631104,
-1.0966764688491821,
0.6769652962684631,
0.6874485611915588,
-0.36832186579704285,
-0.32633763551712036,
0.8261685967445374,
-0.017017971724271774,
-0.459961473941803,
0.4450153112411499,
-0.21034538745880127,
-0.6200628876686096,
0.5476642847061157,
0.6910834312438965,
1.121458649635315,
-0.1957336813211441,
0.167096346616745,
0.4320352375507355,
0.6298003196716309,
-0.006027595605701208,
0.486108660697937,
-0.25594469904899597,
-0.8174102902412415,
-0.34222444891929626,
-0.2810242474079132,
-0.32086145877838135,
0.5079203248023987,
-0.22517243027687073,
0.13447996973991394,
-0.5178541541099548,
-0.23476457595825195,
-0.06151745840907097,
-0.28353655338287354,
-0.4304318130016327,
0.5318736433982849,
0.2900572121143341,
0.5876979231834412,
-1.1671611070632935,
0.6311806440353394,
0.35237300395965576,
-0.7377077341079712,
-0.1587425023317337,
0.19650693237781525,
0.10047297924757004,
-0.699042022228241,
0.8609229922294617,
0.25523459911346436,
-0.36157217621803284,
-0.42452746629714966,
-0.5116280317306519,
-0.7499271631240845,
0.7249330878257751,
0.028519775718450546,
-0.5639574527740479,
0.044173698872327805,
0.1893424540758133,
0.43803471326828003,
-0.5301927328109741,
0.24721121788024902,
0.544194221496582,
0.4601172208786011,
0.36879247426986694,
-0.9553315043449402,
0.5417676568031311,
-0.22692613303661346,
-0.1751725822687149,
-0.25421056151390076,
-0.3847982883453369,
0.8774211406707764,
-0.546687662601471,
-0.06277378648519516,
0.06850626319646835,
0.5105413198471069,
0.24078603088855743,
0.5458886623382568,
0.9335052371025085,
0.8249083161354065,
0.44959935545921326,
0.26582369208335876,
0.6752545237541199,
-0.33098894357681274,
0.0025309280026704073,
1.3346565961837769,
-0.061688706278800964,
0.5779093503952026,
0.6165703535079956,
0.1222328171133995,
0.35084980726242065,
0.3868372142314911,
-0.18392638862133026,
0.7747247219085693,
0.048893798142671585,
-0.23473098874092102,
-0.673246443271637,
-0.11770730465650558,
-0.482413649559021,
0.7067132592201233,
0.27685749530792236,
-0.07319508492946625,
-0.1546262800693512,
0.2568381428718567,
-0.17911238968372345,
0.0395975261926651,
-0.2184009552001953,
0.6252028942108154,
0.037512920796871185,
-0.9457714557647705,
0.53221595287323,
-0.46002665162086487,
0.5603802800178528,
-0.21052290499210358,
-0.23674550652503967,
-0.2772630453109741,
0.18353669345378876,
-0.07740247249603271,
-0.36606594920158386,
0.32387304306030273,
-0.5079787373542786,
-0.1949140429496765,
-0.06700470298528671,
0.4778546690940857,
-0.4650121033191681,
-0.5757943987846375,
0.12097683548927307,
0.495227187871933,
-0.006428843829780817,
-0.16706697642803192,
-0.7112741470336914,
0.16284014284610748,
-0.15949125587940216,
0.22474819421768188,
0.13035115599632263,
0.3491821885108948,
-0.005320833995938301,
0.6544910669326782,
0.6087216734886169,
-0.018108269199728966,
-0.31232988834381104,
0.08022968471050262,
0.8034679293632507,
-0.7203139662742615,
-0.6068624258041382,
-0.9388946294784546,
0.5707352757453918,
-0.13475237786769867,
-0.25839075446128845,
0.7702860236167908,
0.43088093400001526,
0.9184907078742981,
-0.19626860320568085,
0.6578880548477173,
0.05355444923043251,
0.10051857680082321,
-0.2589183449745178,
0.7401995658874512,
-0.7304389476776123,
0.25530576705932617,
-0.5145624876022339,
-0.6978693008422852,
-0.1334214210510254,
0.6367232203483582,
-0.3744204640388489,
0.008915466256439686,
0.9759313464164734,
0.7624225616455078,
0.05078066512942314,
0.1023251861333847,
0.6205259561538696,
0.22052331268787384,
0.19164712727069855,
0.5040439963340759,
0.9881118535995483,
-0.31906408071517944,
0.3802499771118164,
-0.2648192048072815,
-0.0037630791775882244,
-0.2377905249595642,
-0.9857790470123291,
-0.9777815937995911,
-0.8150267004966736,
-0.4191652536392212,
-0.4822979271411896,
0.09950023889541626,
0.7894777059555054,
0.523774266242981,
-0.7263357639312744,
-0.05037746950984001,
-0.3266981840133667,
0.22523599863052368,
-0.19006572663784027,
-0.1815624237060547,
0.3920278549194336,
-0.3305201232433319,
-0.4036834239959717,
0.5003427267074585,
0.4536971151828766,
0.16230173408985138,
-0.5724135041236877,
0.18058983981609344,
-0.3138597011566162,
0.5955777168273926,
0.7208906412124634,
0.12659037113189697,
-0.9304686188697815,
-0.6040562391281128,
-0.07878478616476059,
0.21976761519908905,
0.011791599914431572,
0.9311075210571289,
-1.1232824325561523,
0.7254872918128967,
0.4403000771999359,
0.4239808917045593,
0.17664317786693573,
-0.034244924783706665,
0.49391356110572815,
-0.25433117151260376,
0.3567952513694763,
0.13989132642745972,
0.3358113169670105,
0.08285214751958847,
-0.4223511219024658,
0.455009788274765,
0.5611419081687927,
-0.06258266419172287,
-1.1204185485839844,
0.53574538230896,
-0.8946008682250977,
-0.9263569116592407,
0.7470787763595581,
0.07512123137712479,
0.05540413409471512,
-0.3137587010860443,
-0.15656043589115143,
0.13396817445755005,
0.1430460661649704,
1.4672702550888062,
0.5463767647743225,
-0.16317294538021088,
-0.28985396027565,
-0.18043996393680573,
0.5910859704017639,
0.6419984698295593,
-0.7545821070671082,
0.08021796494722366,
0.5726153254508972,
0.10283443331718445,
0.29552772641181946,
0.5859230756759644,
0.032821621745824814,
0.5009222030639648,
0.48549768328666687,
0.04383304342627525,
-0.037397678941488266,
-0.5114381909370422,
-0.02718276157975197,
0.5336118340492249,
-0.4459209740161896,
-0.11401426792144775
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13485v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13485v4
|
An Entropy-based Text Watermarking Detection Method
| 2024-03-20T10:40:01 | 2024-06-09T06:51:57 |
Yijian Lu, Aiwei Liu, Dianzhi Yu, Jingjing Li, Irwin King
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Text watermarking algorithms for large language models (LLMs) can effectively
identify machine-generated texts by embedding and detecting hidden features in
the text. Although the current text watermarking algorithms perform well in
most high-entropy scenarios, its performance in low-entropy scenarios still
needs to be improved. In this work, we opine that the influence of token
entropy should be fully considered in the watermark detection process, $i.e.$,
the weight of each token during watermark detection should be customized
according to its entropy, rather than setting the weights of all tokens to the
same value as in previous methods. Specifically, we propose
\textbf{E}ntropy-based Text \textbf{W}atermarking \textbf{D}etection
(\textbf{EWD}) that gives higher-entropy tokens higher influence weights during
watermark detection, so as to better reflect the degree of watermarking.
Furthermore, the proposed detection process is training-free and fully
automated. From the experiments, we demonstrate that our EWD can achieve better
detection performance in low-entropy scenarios, and our method is also general
and can be applied to texts with different entropy distributions. Our code and
data is available\footnote{\url{https://github.com/luyijian3/EWD}}.
Additionally, our algorithm could be accessed through MarkLLM
\cite{pan2024markllm}\footnote{\url{https://github.com/THU-BPM/MarkLLM}}.
|
[
0.04939129576086998,
-0.6800178289413452,
0.5453349351882935,
0.23833851516246796,
-0.8130021095275879,
0.17313429713249207,
-0.0562274195253849,
-0.7731075882911682,
0.4607056677341461,
0.4318470060825348,
-0.393177330493927,
-0.6798700094223022,
-0.8602350950241089,
0.3434965908527374,
-0.3375488221645355,
0.5612703561782837,
-0.25519201159477234,
-0.24888621270656586,
0.013223491609096527,
-0.16836000978946686,
0.05279552936553955,
-0.3885485827922821,
-0.6084719300270081,
-0.4414345324039459,
0.3461407721042633,
0.1012803465127945,
0.22998811304569244,
1.0437090396881104,
0.32831451296806335,
0.2873784601688385,
-0.37768563628196716,
0.26576992869377136,
-0.25292807817459106,
0.6192951798439026,
0.17038318514823914,
-0.48862001299858093,
-0.17449700832366943,
-0.13015250861644745,
0.5500767230987549,
-0.2087145894765854,
0.018988244235515594,
0.014755246229469776,
0.07559455186128616,
0.476395845413208,
-0.9279974699020386,
0.048361893743276596,
-0.7945491075515747,
0.28142812848091125,
-0.4750213623046875,
-0.6104245781898499,
-0.38861575722694397,
0.011401066556572914,
-0.3425217866897583,
-0.4388146698474884,
-0.08517549186944962,
0.6104769706726074,
0.8478882908821106,
0.26881322264671326,
-0.1682298630475998,
-0.3375883996486664,
-0.4611641466617584,
0.9708005785942078,
-0.9927823543548584,
0.4086698293685913,
0.5845968723297119,
-0.23549354076385498,
0.04937219247221947,
-0.6494466662406921,
-0.7214885950088501,
0.18686902523040771,
0.36417803168296814,
0.11127029359340668,
-0.22490674257278442,
-0.12469956278800964,
0.29518547654151917,
0.362865149974823,
-0.3944039046764374,
0.24392612278461456,
0.039322733879089355,
-0.4526541829109192,
0.343516081571579,
0.2889504134654999,
0.3208544850349426,
0.06902550905942917,
-0.39968186616897583,
-0.1823471039533615,
-0.4061014950275421,
-0.16358648240566254,
0.512734055519104,
0.19152937829494476,
-0.3984396457672119,
0.5059742331504822,
-0.1992034763097763,
0.7037990689277649,
-0.02755516767501831,
-0.3533884584903717,
0.17376892268657684,
0.12830850481987,
-0.29617932438850403,
0.2695852816104889,
0.798984944820404,
0.1947726607322693,
0.13776281476020813,
-0.1325504630804062,
-0.5151117444038391,
-0.33848080039024353,
-0.19288663566112518,
-1.2086856365203857,
-0.06614817678928375,
0.04530943185091019,
-0.5996293425559998,
-0.6087190508842468,
0.1614951640367508,
-0.6974272131919861,
-0.9113339781761169,
-0.3074497580528259,
0.4146530330181122,
-0.4931970238685608,
-0.105087511241436,
0.08721987158060074,
-0.5945786237716675,
0.22301903367042542,
0.30409979820251465,
-0.7904940247535706,
0.03516731038689613,
0.7895846366882324,
1.125994324684143,
-0.420024573802948,
-0.1081557646393776,
-0.5146681666374207,
0.47918182611465454,
-0.08788035064935684,
0.9161935448646545,
-0.7027217149734497,
0.15367551147937775,
-0.07502003759145737,
-0.1726643294095993,
0.16540318727493286,
-0.3313658833503723,
0.2659485340118408,
-0.6516423225402832,
0.28110209107398987,
-0.10423638671636581,
-0.8291679620742798,
0.17497587203979492,
0.3957248032093048,
-0.9483687281608582,
0.9789882302284241,
-0.17793548107147217,
-1.4309905767440796,
0.4892047643661499,
-0.5121211409568787,
-0.41919636726379395,
0.2016000896692276,
0.14179019629955292,
-0.6126846671104431,
-0.06631409376859665,
0.19367538392543793,
0.45875856280326843,
-0.3640143871307373,
-0.13572481274604797,
-0.4021463990211487,
-0.5234285593032837,
0.15152792632579803,
-0.7896909117698669,
0.7411715388298035,
0.0946701318025589,
-0.6029217839241028,
-0.030678458511829376,
-1.0259979963302612,
0.3201026916503906,
0.1576593816280365,
-0.6307693123817444,
-0.7159209251403809,
-0.15704695880413055,
0.3257112205028534,
-0.19237777590751648,
0.5780593156814575,
-0.5777266025543213,
-0.1100035011768341,
-0.3077560067176819,
0.36111965775489807,
1.0542937517166138,
0.17467638850212097,
0.2218976765871048,
-0.1797325164079666,
0.4579482674598694,
-0.044864337891340256,
-0.124211885035038,
-0.18122315406799316,
-0.7151660323143005,
-0.5039672255516052,
-0.795473575592041,
0.5156872868537903,
0.6891701221466064,
-0.9894716143608093,
0.6397952437400818,
-0.0010486663086339831,
-0.3162103593349457,
-0.13891640305519104,
0.22380851209163666,
0.37036535143852234,
0.10563146322965622,
0.32127946615219116,
-0.24211545288562775,
-0.5924491882324219,
-0.4485958516597748,
-0.771226704120636,
-0.5455250144004822,
-0.058666110038757324,
0.08934442698955536,
0.545428454875946,
0.039182018488645554,
0.8960890769958496,
-0.6053446531295776,
-0.11566383391618729,
0.014447259716689587,
0.4867366850376129,
-0.0564342625439167,
0.3703181743621826,
0.3212766945362091,
-0.6791642904281616,
-0.5494431257247925,
-0.060398682951927185,
-0.6909328699111938,
-0.5309990048408508,
0.11098450422286987,
-0.05589965730905533,
0.46183741092681885,
0.649955153465271,
-0.3202609717845917,
0.7205262780189514,
0.5615870952606201,
-0.49124208092689514,
0.4296794831752777,
-0.21839728951454163,
0.1350705474615097,
-1.0116592645645142,
0.14010900259017944,
0.15276221930980682,
-0.36001309752464294,
-0.4598822295665741,
0.051672596484422684,
0.2322780191898346,
0.10573668032884598,
-0.263660728931427,
0.6544918417930603,
-0.47606417536735535,
0.41799041628837585,
-0.7145299315452576,
-0.35739362239837646,
0.19792798161506653,
0.3586626946926117,
0.016643382608890533,
0.62458336353302,
0.2980755865573883,
-0.35950180888175964,
0.3843517601490021,
-0.39055269956588745,
-0.22255171835422516,
0.8481802940368652,
-0.5540803074836731,
0.3368837535381317,
-0.18744748830795288,
0.1721779853105545,
-0.8594081401824951,
0.17094409465789795,
0.636479914188385,
-0.3053528368473053,
0.4661490023136139,
-0.2814534902572632,
-0.887576162815094,
-0.0034963865764439106,
-0.6628967523574829,
0.2682584226131439,
0.13118067383766174,
-0.4174780249595642,
0.5280457735061646,
0.18177631497383118,
0.07735323905944824,
-0.4868766665458679,
-0.7139973044395447,
0.4899567663669586,
-0.5359494686126709,
-0.33402663469314575,
0.7514553666114807,
-0.026255257427692413,
-0.19162149727344513,
-0.10972049087285995,
-0.30100974440574646,
-0.4019426703453064,
0.17117959260940552,
0.20589527487754822,
0.010399801656603813,
-0.027573686093091965,
0.07583300769329071,
0.013694743625819683,
-0.2142382264137268,
-0.251366525888443,
-0.6451340317726135,
0.629514753818512,
0.16100667417049408,
-0.28196024894714355,
-0.7074177265167236,
0.21364770829677582,
0.6344984173774719,
-0.09618880599737167,
0.9037463068962097,
1.0134438276290894,
-0.7761103510856628,
-0.19560767710208893,
-0.4313119947910309,
-0.2073710709810257,
-0.5440160632133484,
0.0899157002568245,
0.07139506936073303,
-0.9424542188644409,
0.4942232668399811,
0.1378479152917862,
-0.044268447905778885,
0.2638511657714844,
0.5324158072471619,
-0.13554540276527405,
0.38610199093818665,
0.7639551162719727,
-0.48904556035995483,
0.8117058277130127,
0.052476730197668076,
0.3172365427017212,
-0.6659170389175415,
-0.15287035703659058,
-0.6807630062103271,
-0.45132893323898315,
-0.4394141137599945,
-0.5264084339141846,
-0.11034660786390305,
0.12459225207567215,
-0.31855854392051697,
0.3768227994441986,
-0.628024160861969,
0.4121103286743164,
0.6398234963417053,
0.2096836417913437,
0.39845719933509827,
0.26931414008140564,
-0.2763567566871643,
-0.05948616936802864,
-0.3925873637199402,
-0.46919605135917664,
0.7917221784591675,
0.07946763932704926,
0.9622345566749573,
-0.2315054088830948,
1.1545369625091553,
0.6248066425323486,
0.32176274061203003,
-0.6494066715240479,
0.4439184367656708,
0.34438517689704895,
-0.33399975299835205,
-0.597716748714447,
-0.5966461300849915,
-1.0124202966690063,
0.29564809799194336,
-0.07950648665428162,
-0.7853944897651672,
-0.026163747534155846,
-0.14354944229125977,
0.10707800090312958,
0.763813316822052,
-0.5382554531097412,
0.2995540499687195,
-0.14760862290859222,
-0.44939059019088745,
-0.03666994348168373,
-0.2197040617465973,
-0.21623747050762177,
-0.23637691140174866,
0.15746231377124786,
-0.13709495961666107,
-0.4912048876285553,
1.1783695220947266,
-0.49993765354156494,
0.978303074836731,
-0.5657683610916138,
-0.6106750965118408,
0.37154126167297363,
-0.042934320867061615,
0.9071524739265442,
-0.07797611504793167,
-0.34761399030685425,
0.12792691588401794,
-0.08781759440898895,
-0.25798916816711426,
-0.21117883920669556,
0.5388925671577454,
-0.25632160902023315,
-0.47344309091567993,
-0.49776455760002136,
-0.3935784101486206,
0.1359640508890152,
0.502038836479187,
0.332894504070282,
0.190303236246109,
0.2138756960630417,
0.15357504785060883,
0.6520420908927917,
-0.4031749963760376,
0.9002910852432251,
0.47890278697013855,
0.15874691307544708,
-0.7069787383079529,
0.9017990827560425,
0.13914969563484192,
-0.342950701713562,
0.6960166692733765,
0.4008706510066986,
-0.1572984755039215,
-0.6878064274787903,
-0.3928077220916748,
-0.02277328260242939,
-0.6958685517311096,
-0.7285715937614441,
-0.5229879021644592,
-0.14634983241558075,
-0.12153960764408112,
0.05102530121803284,
-0.08185509592294693,
-0.23966734111309052,
-0.53724205493927,
0.16028794646263123,
0.7903978824615479,
0.3143477737903595,
0.11654558032751083,
0.24675992131233215,
-0.5228474736213684,
0.4009086787700653,
0.1855296939611435,
0.6637554168701172,
0.32989081740379333,
-0.6007423400878906,
-0.3885706663131714,
0.011772115714848042,
-0.4763798415660858,
-0.7136344313621521,
0.3662101924419403,
0.3008120059967041,
0.3116104304790497,
0.6920218467712402,
0.3032626807689667,
0.5230927467346191,
-0.46904465556144714,
0.6684529781341553,
0.30799558758735657,
-1.2304214239120483,
0.23823705315589905,
-0.1167016327381134,
0.2776907980442047,
0.31290680170059204,
-0.06229231879115105,
-0.3978550434112549,
-0.7450804710388184,
-0.3578924834728241,
-1.0361601114273071,
0.5152303576469421,
0.487960547208786,
0.21214991807937622,
0.17655545473098755,
0.31448888778686523,
-0.005097400397062302,
0.2641872465610504,
-0.9367796778678894,
-0.28334203362464905,
-0.048986971378326416,
-0.38299623131752014,
0.5812204480171204,
-0.17944607138633728,
0.38100752234458923,
-0.19024579226970673,
0.7634075880050659,
-0.09293055534362793,
0.4075324535369873,
0.23063093423843384,
-0.09760422259569168,
-0.2696039378643036,
0.27763742208480835,
0.5795872807502747,
0.2384062558412552,
-0.015134532004594803,
0.3347051441669464,
0.1502629518508911,
-0.7244361639022827,
0.26073217391967773,
-0.22815851867198944,
-0.19260954856872559,
0.12164871394634247,
0.8374592661857605,
0.5257851481437683,
-0.0654120072722435,
-0.5060471892356873,
0.3927587866783142,
0.0689835250377655,
-0.20617987215518951,
0.07343994081020355,
0.05556030943989754,
0.016074415296316147,
0.36276525259017944,
0.7787781357765198,
-0.17744015157222748,
0.004426470957696438,
-0.17468209564685822,
0.17873981595039368,
0.5219480991363525,
-0.45946577191352844,
-0.3021199107170105,
0.49333852529525757,
-0.12408912926912308,
-0.4709669053554535,
0.12995412945747375,
-0.13908720016479492,
-0.9155463576316833,
0.6984135508537292,
0.7595583200454712,
0.8609945178031921,
-0.1723642498254776,
-0.023909343406558037,
0.06566504389047623,
0.5411416292190552,
-0.2294904738664627,
0.45439815521240234,
-0.32188987731933594,
-0.8027450442314148,
-0.14710547029972076,
-0.6354130506515503,
-0.35182711482048035,
0.14081908762454987,
-0.3774753510951996,
0.2187061458826065,
-0.5982397794723511,
-0.2444722205400467,
-0.06149790808558464,
-0.036097295582294464,
-0.5062959790229797,
0.17462925612926483,
0.4555363357067108,
0.7374048233032227,
-0.6055026054382324,
0.6895623803138733,
0.6022865176200867,
0.42224928736686707,
-0.18102772533893585,
0.5522648096084595,
0.07158554345369339,
-1.0346813201904297,
0.4211421310901642,
0.34908342361450195,
-0.31102830171585083,
0.0584339015185833,
-0.8859074711799622,
-0.7307187914848328,
1.1444252729415894,
0.43967780470848083,
-0.3649831712245941,
0.3674199879169464,
0.06784137338399887,
0.6157980561256409,
-0.0966099351644516,
-0.12538567185401917,
0.008405153639614582,
0.7519990801811218,
-0.2409176379442215,
-0.5146068930625916,
0.38495591282844543,
-0.3309553861618042,
-0.030442697927355766,
0.29813385009765625,
-0.5942657589912415,
0.43129751086235046,
0.04938725382089615,
-0.3276270627975464,
0.20326048135757446,
0.5719432234764099,
0.4706059694290161,
0.6948623061180115,
0.4750894010066986,
0.8404760956764221,
1.0073946714401245,
0.0668540894985199,
0.7918779253959656,
-0.5330348610877991,
0.4210713803768158,
0.6207635998725891,
-0.40433356165885925,
0.8123833537101746,
0.8542112112045288,
-0.16382527351379395,
0.524478018283844,
0.4588349461555481,
-0.314056932926178,
0.7853994965553284,
0.7260571122169495,
-0.263744592666626,
-0.24533580243587494,
-0.16416692733764648,
-0.3951021432876587,
0.20729275047779083,
0.08662284910678864,
-0.6081261038780212,
0.016500651836395264,
-0.1293048858642578,
-0.04746758192777634,
-0.3163612186908722,
-0.25272220373153687,
0.6985493898391724,
0.2932656705379486,
-0.01678570732474327,
0.6298707127571106,
0.7138760089874268,
1.240064024925232,
-0.26457175612449646,
0.12708285450935364,
0.024556618183851242,
-0.16175618767738342,
-0.2189197689294815,
-0.5576269626617432,
0.02186223864555359,
0.27238571643829346,
-0.1451130509376526,
-0.33364546298980713,
1.1235171556472778,
-0.21921515464782715,
-0.4134884476661682,
0.2600092887878418,
0.42644333839416504,
0.01646556332707405,
-0.15035878121852875,
-0.43166106939315796,
0.19415739178657532,
-0.10663288086652756,
-0.29778146743774414,
0.2621341645717621,
0.9167808294296265,
0.04564809799194336,
0.6334410905838013,
0.5680881142616272,
0.17678089439868927,
-0.06423050165176392,
0.04832501336932182,
0.5545334815979004,
-0.6779245734214783,
-0.7670001983642578,
-1.4504457712173462,
-0.06284469366073608,
-0.27376070618629456,
-0.09404831379652023,
0.5924214124679565,
0.6418329477310181,
0.31240659952163696,
0.028558166697621346,
0.7661315202713013,
-0.060926131904125214,
-0.2538524866104126,
-0.7473004460334778,
0.9366034269332886,
-0.5600869059562683,
0.3633701205253601,
-0.6092454791069031,
-1.0050857067108154,
-0.4752238392829895,
0.5270999670028687,
0.15696179866790771,
0.07538093626499176,
0.8079503178596497,
0.6547366380691528,
0.07830697298049927,
0.16893590986728668,
0.3013882637023926,
-0.2994448244571686,
0.23180989921092987,
0.2649663984775543,
0.7669773101806641,
-0.574982225894928,
0.5184979438781738,
-0.004551826044917107,
-0.13345210254192352,
-0.1280958205461502,
-1.2914884090423584,
-0.9931265115737915,
-0.5493576526641846,
-0.6679797768592834,
-0.29213112592697144,
-0.04804341495037079,
0.761324942111969,
0.6050752401351929,
-0.8293062448501587,
0.19234256446361542,
-0.057389337569475174,
0.42049917578697205,
-0.18851308524608612,
-0.26015087962150574,
0.43995407223701477,
0.0597400888800621,
-0.5081802606582642,
0.07445226609706879,
0.5739284157752991,
0.4425290822982788,
0.09293023496866226,
-0.09951723366975784,
0.16225066781044006,
0.35717588663101196,
0.43021515011787415,
-0.053737573325634,
-0.3946419954299927,
-0.2740926742553711,
-0.2526642084121704,
-0.24604526162147522,
0.04271141067147255,
1.0793765783309937,
-0.39770805835723877,
0.0836356058716774,
0.6372911334037781,
0.5537209510803223,
0.48503994941711426,
-0.22384053468704224,
0.1547669917345047,
-0.9449694156646729,
0.19203706085681915,
0.05821242183446884,
0.3741859495639801,
0.4472319185733795,
-0.4827706217765808,
0.19226416945457458,
0.6169084906578064,
-0.0364011749625206,
-1.0539038181304932,
-0.2832809090614319,
-0.6048184037208557,
-0.2913574278354645,
1.1837297677993774,
-0.3746848404407501,
-0.23957601189613342,
-0.3637002110481262,
0.034155674278736115,
0.32627665996551514,
-0.5179902911186218,
1.0522441864013672,
0.9139888286590576,
0.45627233386039734,
-0.22684065997600555,
-0.04134388267993927,
0.26195836067199707,
0.13902495801448822,
-0.7504807114601135,
0.2287929505109787,
-0.09756752848625183,
0.31720614433288574,
-0.055819787085056305,
0.4319296181201935,
-0.12167076766490936,
-0.2010457068681717,
-0.11412440985441208,
0.19650086760520935,
-0.24424298107624054,
-0.06590216606855392,
-0.26668107509613037,
0.13653700053691864,
-0.16207543015480042,
-0.0790996253490448
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15470v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15470v1
|
Vi-Mistral-X: Building a Vietnamese Language Model with Advanced Continual Pre-training
| 2024-03-20T10:14:13 | 2024-03-20T10:14:13 |
James Vo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The advancement of Large Language Models (LLMs) has significantly transformed
the field of natural language processing, although the focus on English-centric
models has created a noticeable research gap for specific languages, including
Vietnamese. To address this issue, this paper presents vi-mistral-x, an
innovative Large Language Model designed expressly for the Vietnamese language.
It utilizes a unique method of continual pre-training, based on the Mistral
architecture, which incorporates grouped-query attention and sliding window
attention techniques. This model, vi-Mistral-X, marks a significant step
forward in improving the understanding and generation of the Vietnamese
language. It introduces an additional phase of continual pre-training,
specifically adapted for Vietnamese, enhancing the model's capability in
understanding complex language nuances and generating accurate, context-aware
Vietnamese text. Through comprehensive testing on various benchmarks,
vi-mistral-x has shown to outperform existing Vietnamese LLMs in several key
areas, including text classification, question answering, and text generation.
Particularly, in the Vietnamese Multitask Language Understanding (VMLU)
benchmark, vi-mistral-x sets a new standard, outperforming other available
models significantly. This paper highlights the critical role of continual
pre-training in advancing language-specific LLMs and opens new avenues for the
development of multilingual models. We aim for vi-mistral-x to not just be an
important asset for processing the Vietnamese language but also to encourage
more advancements in creating large language models for languages that are less
represented.
|
[
-0.19746972620487213,
-0.7504742741584778,
0.6652563214302063,
0.2462853491306305,
-0.3326050639152527,
-0.06775723397731781,
-0.2438000589609146,
-0.23222188651561737,
-0.16143007576465607,
0.7095680236816406,
-0.4296906888484955,
-0.4368891417980194,
-0.6107212901115417,
0.13331422209739685,
-0.5952647924423218,
0.6256074905395508,
-0.29734423756599426,
-0.028514835983514786,
0.015079435892403126,
-0.2580603063106537,
-0.47091346979141235,
-0.9082024097442627,
-0.6602322459220886,
-0.2778809070587158,
0.5538809895515442,
0.1574152708053589,
0.5726249814033508,
0.7827847599983215,
0.29508838057518005,
0.2885757386684418,
0.13833586871623993,
0.04847273975610733,
-0.9072444438934326,
0.048688896000385284,
0.03781260550022125,
-0.6885426640510559,
-0.682610273361206,
-0.09499166160821915,
0.8071139454841614,
0.22834134101867676,
-0.10297970473766327,
0.032982952892780304,
0.04819845035672188,
0.5753428936004639,
-0.65519118309021,
0.08972921222448349,
-0.6514320373535156,
-0.17810383439064026,
-0.31041082739830017,
-0.10859312117099762,
-0.2423171103000641,
-0.16756795346736908,
0.3552649915218353,
-0.6815543174743652,
0.03581730276346207,
-0.5015275478363037,
0.8009122610092163,
0.3818919360637665,
-0.3805626928806305,
0.2203879952430725,
-0.7772775292396545,
0.7348763346672058,
-0.32747596502304077,
0.7341270446777344,
0.15807417035102844,
0.2795451283454895,
0.2122737020254135,
-0.8885473608970642,
-0.4639512002468109,
-0.5442591905593872,
0.2903011441230774,
0.20660455524921417,
-0.36876317858695984,
0.16719955205917358,
-0.19453254342079163,
0.2648457884788513,
-0.7489410042762756,
-0.055341240018606186,
-0.17833304405212402,
0.2325274497270584,
0.30454736948013306,
0.21784384548664093,
0.050441958010196686,
0.2511359453201294,
-0.6904544234275818,
0.13635393977165222,
-0.7528569102287292,
0.03069099597632885,
-0.31412383913993835,
0.11453358083963394,
-0.11063740402460098,
0.3343347907066345,
-0.16515307128429413,
0.8485485911369324,
-0.17129163444042206,
-0.1697191298007965,
0.19704265892505646,
-0.5137249231338501,
-0.39078566431999207,
-0.055973492562770844,
0.5924032926559448,
0.08242141455411911,
0.5106201171875,
0.11401955038309097,
-0.4753580093383789,
0.22683991491794586,
0.2910914719104767,
-0.45457133650779724,
0.03997907415032387,
0.255770206451416,
-0.3229893445968628,
-0.22225596010684967,
0.0766628235578537,
-0.16654735803604126,
0.0013506984105333686,
-0.6632910966873169,
0.5499394536018372,
-0.3083568215370178,
-0.6316211819648743,
0.41278916597366333,
-0.07571782171726227,
0.1345321089029312,
0.6689284443855286,
-0.16800689697265625,
0.2497999519109726,
0.6661053895950317,
1.0042062997817993,
-0.4723757803440094,
-0.6115859746932983,
-0.8033249974250793,
0.2524886727333069,
-0.3407045006752014,
0.751796305179596,
-0.7157287001609802,
-0.5697306394577026,
0.22226016223430634,
0.0069139874540269375,
-0.04698125272989273,
-0.6613094806671143,
0.22375530004501343,
-0.4074728190898895,
0.05749117210507393,
-0.02830188348889351,
-0.37002891302108765,
-0.04039797931909561,
0.3490455448627472,
-0.6341643929481506,
1.0051921606063843,
0.6495959758758545,
-0.6380348205566406,
0.13117659091949463,
-0.3434900641441345,
0.022196559235453606,
0.3457859456539154,
-0.1841910481452942,
-0.22851604223251343,
0.2691068947315216,
-0.05759458988904953,
0.291968435049057,
-0.5578112602233887,
0.22686035931110382,
-0.0873321145772934,
-0.3575419485569,
0.25684821605682373,
-0.5637778043746948,
0.565122663974762,
0.08083274960517883,
-0.5015713572502136,
0.3297489881515503,
-0.7957746386528015,
0.0691356509923935,
0.027090730145573616,
-0.3070276081562042,
-0.5593554377555847,
-0.5381138324737549,
0.23615097999572754,
0.5561992526054382,
0.6067368984222412,
-0.08708984404802322,
0.07248914241790771,
-0.10159941017627716,
0.256685733795166,
0.6820061802864075,
-0.1556842178106308,
0.38620519638061523,
-0.10773823410272598,
0.8971449136734009,
0.12651658058166504,
0.3984183073043823,
-0.7257846593856812,
-0.15801891684532166,
-1.03641939163208,
-0.4610540568828583,
0.041345417499542236,
0.7073207497596741,
-0.9605438113212585,
0.14629803597927094,
-0.35294798016548157,
-0.631830632686615,
-0.5960103273391724,
0.32601678371429443,
0.6781962513923645,
0.24767568707466125,
0.3618382513523102,
-0.16501380503177643,
-0.5222548246383667,
-0.47518399357795715,
-0.10112151503562927,
-0.29498276114463806,
0.27684441208839417,
-0.07205694168806076,
0.2344106286764145,
-0.788495659828186,
0.9312576651573181,
-0.4313308298587799,
-0.24398596584796906,
-0.40321874618530273,
0.0691017359495163,
-0.0483071431517601,
0.09455929696559906,
0.5001333355903625,
-0.8344906568527222,
-0.6713118553161621,
0.45343315601348877,
-0.810554563999176,
-0.16960826516151428,
-0.011842998676002026,
-0.15011368691921234,
0.13245655596256256,
0.8047932982444763,
-0.5739582180976868,
0.40108367800712585,
0.5968026518821716,
-0.1055251806974411,
0.6955543756484985,
-0.37229105830192566,
-0.15569983422756195,
-0.7037278413772583,
0.010272215120494366,
0.1405687779188156,
-0.4628852903842926,
-0.7751376032829285,
0.10376131534576416,
0.10675959289073944,
-0.04846829175949097,
-0.5437219142913818,
0.996571958065033,
-0.46735894680023193,
0.5498782396316528,
-0.6361444592475891,
-0.028403373435139656,
-0.11744324117898941,
0.18283450603485107,
0.4356937110424042,
0.7296435236930847,
0.612352192401886,
-0.7779532074928284,
0.2784653306007385,
-0.34321215748786926,
0.02612896077334881,
0.5762701630592346,
-0.9046992659568787,
-0.06787184625864029,
-0.1537906676530838,
-0.01900758221745491,
-0.634103000164032,
0.2578774094581604,
0.06607513874769211,
-0.21290086209774017,
0.1431981325149536,
-0.05332183837890625,
-0.0977180078625679,
-0.3108850121498108,
-0.11502912640571594,
0.46029242873191833,
0.30897364020347595,
-0.37775421142578125,
0.432584673166275,
0.38317450881004333,
-0.32803770899772644,
-0.47866290807724,
-0.1995149701833725,
0.20888468623161316,
-0.27952226996421814,
-0.34277164936065674,
0.19446605443954468,
-0.026947392150759697,
-0.5254848599433899,
-0.19468563795089722,
-0.05269870534539223,
-0.426644891500473,
-0.0759248435497284,
0.10199104994535446,
0.19669599831104279,
-0.5994377136230469,
0.17225764691829681,
-0.11324451118707657,
-0.5979956388473511,
-0.07263635843992233,
-0.821026086807251,
0.6339207887649536,
-0.04199996963143349,
0.095195472240448,
-0.5496264696121216,
0.3825248181819916,
0.6897703409194946,
-0.6423779129981995,
0.5335756540298462,
0.6352671980857849,
-0.21574629843235016,
-0.02326466143131256,
-0.6683081984519958,
0.16232170164585114,
-0.43885913491249084,
0.6588496565818787,
-0.46581465005874634,
-1.15322744846344,
-0.08875210583209991,
-0.04749886691570282,
0.09804455190896988,
0.16589733958244324,
0.7017101645469666,
0.30468156933784485,
0.8824511170387268,
1.1899840831756592,
-0.36935967206954956,
0.8300657272338867,
-0.029410196468234062,
-0.1782171130180359,
-0.30362963676452637,
0.18452182412147522,
-0.4191773533821106,
0.6182829737663269,
-0.392849862575531,
-0.8193986415863037,
0.3340679407119751,
-0.06050717458128929,
-0.39260581135749817,
0.2347908318042755,
-0.25642603635787964,
0.10108097642660141,
0.39864984154701233,
-0.2448899745941162,
0.3804745376110077,
0.03821156173944473,
0.15570068359375,
0.05247848108410835,
-0.5430892109870911,
-0.582244873046875,
0.9877282977104187,
0.2622416913509369,
0.9286020398139954,
-0.3047928512096405,
0.6898765563964844,
0.19259004294872284,
0.3042730689048767,
-0.3264775574207306,
0.18470194935798645,
-0.1662491410970688,
-0.22919002175331116,
-0.32288286089897156,
-0.4111874997615814,
-1.064731240272522,
0.48659104108810425,
0.23106946051120758,
-0.38819825649261475,
-0.11054658889770508,
0.2140396684408188,
-0.21767103672027588,
-0.18687331676483154,
-0.692073404788971,
0.8771594166755676,
-0.567454993724823,
-0.3245449364185333,
-0.20856647193431854,
-0.35110923647880554,
0.4592631459236145,
-0.4477716386318207,
0.0967039242386818,
0.15398786962032318,
-0.325493186712265,
0.26679742336273193,
-0.44451460242271423,
0.6818342208862305,
-0.12700439989566803,
-0.566910445690155,
0.4589864909648895,
-0.26485753059387207,
0.1536012589931488,
0.5130441188812256,
0.012067612260580063,
0.2123440057039261,
-0.08697935193777084,
-0.33217740058898926,
-0.47728249430656433,
0.5658632516860962,
-1.0019936561584473,
-0.7831722497940063,
-0.40667974948883057,
-0.24403046071529388,
0.20540902018547058,
0.33302462100982666,
0.3557665944099426,
0.19596415758132935,
-0.48410019278526306,
-0.18747374415397644,
0.9571951627731323,
-0.15867583453655243,
-0.06398338824510574,
0.6799050569534302,
-0.6103945970535278,
-0.5866453647613525,
1.1285862922668457,
0.34127119183540344,
0.2821241021156311,
0.8431541919708252,
-0.042837873101234436,
-0.18864214420318604,
-0.06494956463575363,
-0.12539200484752655,
0.4080275595188141,
-0.36881566047668457,
0.07518777996301651,
-1.0118324756622314,
-0.4638400375843048,
-0.41486412286758423,
-0.06837756186723709,
-0.5962038040161133,
-0.08942386507987976,
-0.18886075913906097,
0.0858822911977768,
0.16240572929382324,
0.8552860021591187,
0.04596590995788574,
0.664388120174408,
-1.0679391622543335,
0.5799643397331238,
0.6057435870170593,
-0.07724802196025848,
0.020716849714517593,
-0.5857590436935425,
-0.5338352918624878,
-0.010388797149062157,
-0.17291297018527985,
-0.46109694242477417,
0.43186110258102417,
0.1098906472325325,
0.6797182559967041,
0.6733391880989075,
-0.2540946900844574,
0.6712772846221924,
-0.5477662086486816,
0.6438900828361511,
0.19793376326560974,
-0.9996581077575684,
0.5711809992790222,
-0.37427034974098206,
0.789680540561676,
0.30922576785087585,
0.30550819635391235,
-0.7287471890449524,
-0.4746283292770386,
-0.5201045274734497,
-0.8182860016822815,
0.37063613533973694,
0.2784086763858795,
0.08614200353622437,
0.021134313195943832,
0.5213435888290405,
0.32741406559944153,
0.4168876111507416,
-0.8170896172523499,
-0.2759379744529724,
-0.22222141921520233,
0.1655929684638977,
-0.4620289206504822,
-0.35239556431770325,
0.15011559426784515,
-0.29423582553863525,
0.5119375586509705,
-0.013795584440231323,
0.25918179750442505,
0.030934985727071762,
-0.38379308581352234,
0.1888287216424942,
-0.03917994722723961,
0.7479344606399536,
0.7928638458251953,
0.08052484691143036,
0.1654958873987198,
0.07160774618387222,
-0.7634332776069641,
0.4774062931537628,
0.18361112475395203,
0.22970588505268097,
0.3601972460746765,
0.5024710893630981,
0.7083215117454529,
-0.09593190252780914,
-0.6734260320663452,
0.492561936378479,
-0.48731729388237,
0.15697669982910156,
-0.5779488682746887,
0.22541601955890656,
-0.02191890962421894,
0.08196772634983063,
0.29031437635421753,
-0.13167916238307953,
-0.317193865776062,
-0.17360042035579681,
0.24127434194087982,
0.08368264883756638,
-0.873691737651825,
-0.5316227078437805,
0.6335022449493408,
0.23260699212551117,
-0.09867407381534576,
0.41914647817611694,
-0.01789514161646366,
-0.5826557278633118,
0.36770859360694885,
0.3576272428035736,
0.8886999487876892,
-0.7715949416160583,
0.2621797025203705,
0.23091086745262146,
0.46165940165519714,
-0.357683002948761,
0.5338883996009827,
-0.17423486709594727,
-0.478863000869751,
-0.22769206762313843,
-0.4969022870063782,
-0.10519297420978546,
0.16079860925674438,
-0.7015708684921265,
0.5621129274368286,
-0.15630678832530975,
-0.27819037437438965,
-0.5378689169883728,
-0.18540191650390625,
-0.7788006663322449,
0.4469641149044037,
0.1879694014787674,
0.9514492750167847,
-0.5853517651557922,
1.2072564363479614,
0.751097559928894,
-0.3280273377895355,
-0.236238032579422,
0.0017155001405626535,
0.061289574950933456,
-0.8916372060775757,
0.6402526497840881,
0.3430655598640442,
-0.3537300229072571,
0.11758717149496078,
-0.46803438663482666,
-1.0660451650619507,
0.828819215297699,
0.5709676146507263,
-0.7658349871635437,
-0.07434815168380737,
0.29167065024375916,
0.5241084098815918,
-0.4208558201789856,
0.11340606957674026,
0.8084957003593445,
0.4111400842666626,
-0.3977073132991791,
-0.7916631698608398,
-0.3719410300254822,
-0.43524229526519775,
0.3426675498485565,
0.09877543896436691,
-0.761486291885376,
1.1293044090270996,
-0.07847346365451813,
-0.060898516327142715,
0.2722364664077759,
0.9399542212486267,
0.5068020820617676,
0.09325004369020462,
0.5045585036277771,
0.4152343273162842,
0.8123366236686707,
0.04623238742351532,
0.9656999111175537,
-0.393356055021286,
-0.06097522750496864,
1.2427444458007812,
-0.40275511145591736,
0.832277774810791,
0.3232063353061676,
0.03959500044584274,
0.20608605444431305,
0.4952050447463989,
0.39710888266563416,
0.3623049259185791,
0.14697590470314026,
-0.5078694224357605,
-0.44928422570228577,
-0.20581406354904175,
-0.7540446519851685,
0.4944096505641937,
0.3788035809993744,
-0.13478028774261475,
-0.014116649515926838,
0.32769516110420227,
0.2141120582818985,
-0.09683960676193237,
-0.4071637988090515,
0.5382390022277832,
0.4729579985141754,
-0.5385786294937134,
0.8863952159881592,
-0.09051986783742905,
0.7030823230743408,
-0.893174946308136,
-0.034215159714221954,
-0.2082357108592987,
0.4107877016067505,
0.1489296853542328,
-0.43174752593040466,
-0.26509061455726624,
0.16092750430107117,
-0.36324453353881836,
-0.222089022397995,
0.3851716220378876,
-0.5986921787261963,
-0.5091409683227539,
0.6268497109413147,
0.8479011058807373,
-0.10391415655612946,
-0.5768936276435852,
-0.6711931228637695,
0.3615581691265106,
-0.013376053422689438,
-0.13639159500598907,
0.20843149721622467,
1.0360608100891113,
-0.2282017022371292,
0.6094822883605957,
0.2992546856403351,
0.03685006871819496,
0.1991575062274933,
0.19851908087730408,
0.8991913199424744,
-0.7908130288124084,
-0.7572939991950989,
-0.8060324788093567,
0.548200786113739,
0.18493208289146423,
-0.7191068530082703,
0.6250110268592834,
0.452615886926651,
0.9689398407936096,
-0.02667243219912052,
1.2447668313980103,
0.6135000586509705,
0.23703517019748688,
-0.41720566153526306,
0.7043024301528931,
-0.7903852462768555,
-0.027388663962483406,
-0.36035656929016113,
-1.0144295692443848,
-0.18045279383659363,
0.5350862741470337,
0.05423769727349281,
0.24844004213809967,
0.7681874632835388,
0.5998064875602722,
0.21409031748771667,
-0.40849632024765015,
0.6735510230064392,
0.39569881558418274,
0.4622672498226166,
0.48770105838775635,
1.040483832359314,
-0.2860879898071289,
0.5866115689277649,
0.022697176784276962,
-0.42578408122062683,
-0.09218892455101013,
-0.2742498517036438,
-0.918932318687439,
-0.8107876181602478,
-0.2568782866001129,
-0.09572277963161469,
0.2617582082748413,
0.7243326902389526,
0.6349270343780518,
-0.39048928022384644,
-0.6959620118141174,
-0.08141476660966873,
-0.031913310289382935,
-0.2700241506099701,
-0.16060543060302734,
0.11565441638231277,
-0.6155380010604858,
-0.8295772075653076,
0.291615754365921,
0.851868748664856,
0.164963498711586,
-0.5114595293998718,
-0.2001480907201767,
-0.07385609298944473,
-0.11388063430786133,
0.9369184374809265,
0.1959882229566574,
-0.6287582516670227,
0.15974971652030945,
0.24330563843250275,
-0.407471626996994,
0.1437031477689743,
0.9123046398162842,
-1.0648562908172607,
0.574249267578125,
0.2481430172920227,
0.5304439067840576,
0.35601282119750977,
-0.22529062628746033,
1.0930794477462769,
-0.29011520743370056,
0.3717725872993469,
-0.08179517835378647,
0.2752964198589325,
0.17276741564273834,
-0.28763097524642944,
0.3907361924648285,
0.1483042985200882,
-0.39627569913864136,
-0.7341790199279785,
0.12675273418426514,
-0.6920014023780823,
-0.24364131689071655,
1.2018167972564697,
-0.25005844235420227,
-0.37187981605529785,
-0.49834683537483215,
-0.5043003559112549,
0.2356370985507965,
-0.2839668095111847,
0.5561903715133667,
0.4086152911186218,
0.2253509759902954,
-0.40799492597579956,
-0.4775553345680237,
0.3139946162700653,
0.33662593364715576,
-0.839210033416748,
0.2813360393047333,
0.10356011986732483,
-0.029957031831145287,
-0.01643436960875988,
0.9462795853614807,
-0.013125347904860973,
0.6724187731742859,
-0.08206525444984436,
-0.02922898717224598,
0.3564077615737915,
-0.653136134147644,
-0.528098464012146,
0.05000294744968414,
0.3152412474155426,
0.11455019563436508
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13447v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13447v1
|
HyperLLaVA: Dynamic Visual and Language Expert Tuning for Multimodal Large Language Models
| 2024-03-20T09:42:43 | 2024-03-20T09:42:43 |
Wenqiao Zhang, Tianwei Lin, Jiang Liu, Fangxun Shu, Haoyuan Li, Lei Zhang, He Wanggui, Hao Zhou, Zheqi Lv, Hao Jiang, Juncheng Li, Siliang Tang, Yueting Zhuang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Recent advancements indicate that scaling up Multimodal Large Language Models
(MLLMs) effectively enhances performance on downstream multimodal tasks. The
prevailing MLLM paradigm, \emph{e.g.}, LLaVA, transforms visual features into
text-like tokens using a \emph{static} vision-language mapper, thereby enabling
\emph{static} LLMs to develop the capability to comprehend visual information
through visual instruction tuning. Although promising, the \emph{static} tuning
strategy~\footnote{The static tuning refers to the trained model with static
parameters.} that shares the same parameters may constrain performance across
different downstream multimodal tasks. In light of this, we introduce
HyperLLaVA, which involves adaptive tuning of the projector and LLM parameters,
in conjunction with a dynamic visual expert and language expert, respectively.
These experts are derived from HyperNetworks, which generates adaptive
parameter shifts through visual and language guidance, enabling dynamic
projector and LLM modeling in two-stage training.
Our experiments demonstrate that our solution significantly surpasses LLaVA
on existing MLLM benchmarks, including MME, MMBench, SEED-Bench, and
LLaVA-Bench. ~\footnote{Our project is available on the link
https://github.com/DCDmllm/HyperLLaVA}.
|
[
-0.3185310661792755,
-0.9667174220085144,
0.49991607666015625,
0.29750582575798035,
-0.25572532415390015,
0.2623281180858612,
-0.5070735812187195,
-0.3354136645793915,
0.2045554518699646,
0.6074235439300537,
-0.4560393691062927,
-0.4379856586456299,
-0.5408744215965271,
-0.14693430066108704,
-0.32217472791671753,
0.7078171372413635,
0.08320427685976028,
-0.08735105395317078,
-0.23044030368328094,
-0.21384616196155548,
-0.5603880286216736,
-0.16684143245220184,
-0.536230742931366,
-0.11439692229032516,
0.77348792552948,
0.5479432940483093,
0.7704134583473206,
0.7805020809173584,
0.5181517004966736,
0.40429288148880005,
-0.13302725553512573,
0.5529542565345764,
-0.5254910588264465,
0.5882760882377625,
-0.13024647533893585,
-0.5505073666572571,
-0.6455026268959045,
-0.3176453113555908,
0.738641619682312,
0.1644715815782547,
-0.3034776747226715,
0.29971471428871155,
-0.0668041929602623,
0.7067517638206482,
-0.7472777962684631,
0.31115031242370605,
-0.8678337335586548,
-0.06189268082380295,
-0.43187299370765686,
-0.5856825709342957,
-0.43907442688941956,
-0.25447046756744385,
-0.09055233746767044,
-0.8493004441261292,
0.08359010517597198,
0.24721737205982208,
0.8590352535247803,
0.6301934123039246,
-0.4298015236854553,
0.15285560488700867,
-0.6801400780677795,
0.7149187326431274,
-0.49722427129745483,
0.4208894968032837,
0.25091031193733215,
0.5334151387214661,
-0.19313333928585052,
-0.5699132084846497,
-0.5420680046081543,
-0.28664904832839966,
0.2483634501695633,
0.21892419457435608,
-0.12265297770500183,
0.1139102429151535,
0.3566415309906006,
0.020856520161032677,
-0.5711280107498169,
0.3384499251842499,
-0.1654711365699768,
-0.047174062579870224,
0.37330567836761475,
0.2925972640514374,
0.043828804045915604,
0.17056381702423096,
-0.30470454692840576,
-0.07714159041643143,
-0.7272883653640747,
-0.13784727454185486,
0.22002004086971283,
0.09579554200172424,
-0.11435512453317642,
0.3396487236022949,
-0.33971983194351196,
0.9511914849281311,
0.1586199551820755,
-0.2895808815956116,
0.2675406336784363,
-0.20141296088695526,
-0.3619386851787567,
-0.10900724679231644,
0.34817829728126526,
0.3427160382270813,
0.6459835767745972,
0.18600808084011078,
-0.061078596860170364,
-0.2603450417518616,
0.27625682950019836,
-0.5129037499427795,
-0.30738866329193115,
-0.22155041992664337,
-0.2847329378128052,
-0.4414818286895752,
-0.5037477016448975,
-1.0191110372543335,
-0.7451843619346619,
-0.5923960208892822,
0.2777702510356903,
-0.05990064889192581,
-0.4384218454360962,
-0.013013412244617939,
0.044448260217905045,
0.06415675580501556,
0.7200396656990051,
-1.1050318479537964,
-0.019966555759310722,
0.38744035363197327,
0.6020469665527344,
-0.009852486662566662,
-0.5233396291732788,
-0.8448428511619568,
0.2573138475418091,
-0.3770117163658142,
0.802474856376648,
-0.7363269925117493,
-0.0007613857742398977,
0.2818774878978729,
-0.24452544748783112,
-0.19402043521404266,
-0.5653795003890991,
0.1699168086051941,
-0.6293479204177856,
-0.1720573455095291,
-0.21291358768939972,
-0.20036518573760986,
-0.17156687378883362,
0.22748775780200958,
-0.5181358456611633,
1.0804837942123413,
-0.17200376093387604,
-0.5405371785163879,
0.2865462303161621,
-0.4212937355041504,
-0.16351927816867828,
0.2681695818901062,
-0.2548944652080536,
-0.2612534761428833,
0.37781402468681335,
0.29535090923309326,
0.48527926206588745,
-0.3952726125717163,
0.1092313826084137,
-0.4003075659275055,
-0.3684021532535553,
0.3077237606048584,
-0.5486616492271423,
0.2060769498348236,
0.0261260736733675,
-0.34778109192848206,
0.6517391800880432,
-1.0842986106872559,
-0.05722809582948685,
-0.08675846457481384,
-0.6142628192901611,
-0.35451316833496094,
0.23812103271484375,
0.643222451210022,
0.23116236925125122,
0.3926692008972168,
-0.15276016294956207,
0.19076618552207947,
-0.20855003595352173,
0.09879195690155029,
1.0586848258972168,
-0.25507065653800964,
-0.016008226200938225,
0.08790897578001022,
0.6051421761512756,
-0.2531477212905884,
0.34876346588134766,
-0.10995535552501678,
-0.5490360260009766,
-1.1732701063156128,
-0.425128698348999,
0.08959142118692398,
0.4557327330112457,
-0.9085814356803894,
0.113308846950531,
-0.1529398113489151,
-0.32700225710868835,
-0.5447142124176025,
0.5964792370796204,
0.5265815258026123,
0.4785451889038086,
0.3978571593761444,
0.0017808383563533425,
-0.4750884473323822,
-1.0336838960647583,
-0.030270753428339958,
-0.2269880324602127,
0.35780301690101624,
0.18877488374710083,
0.2996263802051544,
-0.08987760543823242,
0.6506850123405457,
-0.5214895009994507,
-0.2572593688964844,
-0.16360212862491608,
0.2597605586051941,
0.13949307799339294,
0.24822045862674713,
0.5754671692848206,
-0.9405533671379089,
-0.6231040358543396,
0.23874598741531372,
-0.7190181016921997,
-0.146743506193161,
-0.04403805360198021,
-0.15986542403697968,
0.2284277379512787,
0.6924388408660889,
-0.38215509057044983,
0.13978035748004913,
0.9120153188705444,
-0.31021982431411743,
0.7173401117324829,
-0.5298060774803162,
0.025675499811768532,
-1.115872859954834,
-0.03840751573443413,
0.16561172902584076,
-0.4447062909603119,
-0.5327819585800171,
0.4092179536819458,
0.2534172236919403,
0.009754491038620472,
-0.5026844143867493,
0.4032190442085266,
-0.4640754163265228,
0.10257270932197571,
-0.6173775792121887,
0.08963122218847275,
-0.2005140632390976,
0.5510066151618958,
-0.07692977786064148,
0.7492481470108032,
0.8732290863990784,
-0.3659452795982361,
0.910223662853241,
0.024216970428824425,
-0.5079256892204285,
0.7074882984161377,
-0.6731923222541809,
0.10412765294313431,
0.028472958132624626,
0.10720670968294144,
-0.6978550553321838,
-0.18042980134487152,
0.006094553507864475,
-0.16227445006370544,
0.39572638273239136,
-0.257357656955719,
-0.720687985420227,
-0.12467435002326965,
-0.07887487858533859,
0.250853568315506,
0.37878918647766113,
-0.36825066804885864,
0.5865999460220337,
0.25701385736465454,
-0.2224983125925064,
-0.6297426223754883,
-0.4892551898956299,
0.4389430284500122,
-0.18324868381023407,
-0.505479097366333,
0.022116106003522873,
-0.23391877114772797,
-0.2166002094745636,
-0.1262337565422058,
0.1248043105006218,
-0.20411323010921478,
0.1407477706670761,
0.32204699516296387,
0.19702693819999695,
-0.37856629490852356,
0.3363180458545685,
0.1333692967891693,
-0.2917923331260681,
-0.24621354043483734,
-0.19798755645751953,
0.4397224187850952,
-0.18727697432041168,
-0.2783223092556,
-0.4270985722541809,
0.1932111233472824,
1.1018874645233154,
-0.6643981337547302,
0.733792245388031,
0.9705149531364441,
-0.21610267460346222,
-0.000998773379251361,
-0.864274263381958,
0.1080273762345314,
-0.5153166651725769,
0.7835051417350769,
-0.47132518887519836,
-0.8443270921707153,
0.22287899255752563,
-0.16911925375461578,
-0.014760973863303661,
0.13441838324069977,
1.1731802225112915,
-0.15803715586662292,
1.1554484367370605,
0.9860473275184631,
-0.027855174615979195,
0.7187037467956543,
-0.006906711496412754,
-0.19541586935520172,
-0.7837343811988831,
-0.22344836592674255,
-0.26270824670791626,
-0.32581886649131775,
-0.5834229588508606,
-0.6141538619995117,
0.6783033013343811,
-0.18009334802627563,
0.023091157898306847,
0.10343768447637558,
-0.11597177386283875,
0.4337644875049591,
0.5432246327400208,
0.01972215622663498,
0.23508046567440033,
0.05369976535439491,
-0.1398463398218155,
-0.07046809792518616,
-0.6140725612640381,
-0.2957780659198761,
0.9570931792259216,
0.371868759393692,
1.0280731916427612,
0.20766127109527588,
0.22757478058338165,
0.2234984189271927,
-0.05738126486539841,
-0.6678915619850159,
0.691978394985199,
-0.06745626777410507,
-0.5457248091697693,
-0.32263705134391785,
-0.11931483447551727,
-0.7165226936340332,
0.46629950404167175,
-0.6538147330284119,
-0.569739818572998,
0.34102770686149597,
0.5640593767166138,
-0.29190802574157715,
0.061829328536987305,
-0.4934144616127014,
0.5935574173927307,
-0.25318700075149536,
-0.7098058462142944,
-0.8466181755065918,
-0.4072607457637787,
0.07446034252643585,
-0.36167478561401367,
0.04797501862049103,
-0.37669527530670166,
-0.1443432867527008,
0.5542854070663452,
0.037739381194114685,
0.8791022896766663,
-0.2170717418193817,
-0.2084774523973465,
-0.22591611742973328,
0.11584492772817612,
0.6633825898170471,
0.1896539181470871,
-0.05004756897687912,
-0.3058195412158966,
-0.34583988785743713,
-0.5148643851280212,
-0.7551188468933105,
1.107816219329834,
-0.7909037470817566,
-0.7083189487457275,
-0.23580023646354675,
-0.9830854535102844,
-0.3580591082572937,
0.16462107002735138,
-0.2113991528749466,
0.6446295976638794,
0.021193983033299446,
0.49355077743530273,
0.902681291103363,
-0.18205173313617706,
0.3898565173149109,
0.7835623025894165,
-0.2552247643470764,
-0.20486685633659363,
0.9120146036148071,
-0.05390027537941933,
0.11695598810911179,
0.6534838676452637,
0.10332618653774261,
-0.156545028090477,
-0.8082857131958008,
-0.6191602945327759,
0.1179967075586319,
-0.6850253343582153,
0.018772276118397713,
-0.3209347724914551,
0.1690741926431656,
-0.13106797635555267,
-0.06869260966777802,
-0.5510463118553162,
-0.29604148864746094,
-0.31625258922576904,
-0.0009223798988386989,
0.4923786520957947,
0.7052176594734192,
0.307836651802063,
0.1382732391357422,
-0.6047911047935486,
0.21459873020648956,
0.6054649949073792,
0.24365302920341492,
-0.14504829049110413,
-0.4986613690853119,
-0.7686458230018616,
-0.19183790683746338,
-0.15571871399879456,
-0.6332912445068359,
0.32243797183036804,
0.3547635078430176,
0.6486351490020752,
0.4492480456829071,
-0.37710142135620117,
0.8656814098358154,
-0.6533311605453491,
0.5288286209106445,
0.2038957178592682,
-0.7634135484695435,
0.6928964853286743,
-0.46062085032463074,
0.48746100068092346,
0.4768069386482239,
0.1421852558851242,
-0.4561202824115753,
-0.48004674911499023,
0.03664969652891159,
-0.7602975368499756,
0.3310509920120239,
0.10155881196260452,
0.0929315835237503,
0.43608978390693665,
0.2305644452571869,
-0.14332352578639984,
0.1960298866033554,
-0.5053476691246033,
-0.09253088384866714,
-0.12098497152328491,
-0.26262375712394714,
-0.309522420167923,
-0.4015311300754547,
-0.28786492347717285,
-0.4322758913040161,
0.49423208832740784,
-0.38839462399482727,
0.009644744917750359,
-0.20250648260116577,
-0.4258643686771393,
-0.300715833902359,
0.11692683398723602,
1.0551271438598633,
1.1606934070587158,
-0.29805490374565125,
0.17847059667110443,
0.3244086503982544,
-0.283256471157074,
0.09219047427177429,
0.06208395957946777,
0.07629905641078949,
-0.0740305632352829,
0.5717795491218567,
1.1958550214767456,
0.45735299587249756,
-0.7819347977638245,
0.2186061590909958,
-0.0932590439915657,
-0.11628977209329605,
-0.11939403414726257,
0.219970241189003,
0.07072917371988297,
0.5601447224617004,
0.4418301582336426,
0.21434637904167175,
-0.1548006236553192,
-0.38559645414352417,
0.02300950512290001,
0.1561492383480072,
-0.4513584077358246,
-0.3598704934120178,
0.7099853157997131,
0.5240179896354675,
-0.20542936027050018,
0.33988991379737854,
0.3305915892124176,
-0.25061294436454773,
0.4621540606021881,
0.5838512182235718,
0.7454411387443542,
-0.20867012441158295,
0.11497645080089569,
-0.05184593051671982,
0.30795714259147644,
0.15938149392604828,
0.19647690653800964,
0.01968592219054699,
-0.47075825929641724,
-0.6051199436187744,
-0.737388551235199,
-0.41018831729888916,
-0.03773358836770058,
-0.5725964903831482,
0.3130463659763336,
-0.3477874994277954,
-0.09527572989463806,
0.02576826512813568,
-0.19867897033691406,
-0.6218740344047546,
0.11358938366174698,
0.40721553564071655,
0.8837609887123108,
-0.8876510262489319,
1.329342246055603,
1.0241822004318237,
-0.1380290389060974,
-0.3196902871131897,
0.11467064917087555,
0.24429869651794434,
-0.8892608880996704,
0.8222569823265076,
-0.2628829777240753,
-0.3487575650215149,
0.0803893506526947,
-0.17879843711853027,
-0.9913802742958069,
0.9647959470748901,
0.4836929142475128,
-0.9822076559066772,
0.004023945890367031,
-0.1454816609621048,
0.7301791906356812,
-0.19010023772716522,
0.1921921968460083,
0.23402374982833862,
0.7145563960075378,
-0.04278358444571495,
-1.1314231157302856,
-0.052404411137104034,
-0.38916826248168945,
0.23495842516422272,
0.11283687502145767,
-0.7929433584213257,
0.6272751092910767,
0.008363044820725918,
0.35662877559661865,
-0.03196301311254501,
0.8085863590240479,
0.1385725736618042,
0.013363736681640148,
0.6008572578430176,
0.37664172053337097,
0.6869087219238281,
0.16489054262638092,
0.9159752130508423,
-0.5100498199462891,
0.312025785446167,
0.8997936248779297,
-0.24501873552799225,
0.9517598748207092,
0.4965430200099945,
0.1258474588394165,
0.39961308240890503,
0.4883207678794861,
-0.01998305879533291,
0.5419213771820068,
0.08108916878700256,
-0.1270085722208023,
-0.5242209434509277,
-0.0689760148525238,
-0.47390130162239075,
0.732483446598053,
0.3748876452445984,
-0.32128044962882996,
-0.1328318864107132,
0.24704770743846893,
-0.05555135756731033,
0.20565606653690338,
-0.3042047917842865,
0.48507553339004517,
-0.1375388652086258,
-0.5111796855926514,
0.8431487679481506,
0.09018221497535706,
0.6499449610710144,
-0.705538809299469,
0.0036300381179898977,
-0.17449526488780975,
0.3618710935115814,
-0.02024271711707115,
-0.5406140685081482,
-0.041730936616659164,
0.06306136399507523,
-0.3004160523414612,
-0.24815848469734192,
0.5704111456871033,
-0.5422164797782898,
-0.7200285792350769,
0.2889162302017212,
0.4727199077606201,
-0.2247995287179947,
0.06088496744632721,
-0.747342050075531,
0.30298927426338196,
-0.15447314083576202,
-0.36253511905670166,
0.5015848875045776,
0.20461051166057587,
-0.08658087998628616,
0.9284759759902954,
0.5879330039024353,
0.29768314957618713,
0.27414190769195557,
0.4124789237976074,
0.8763359785079956,
-0.4251694977283478,
-0.25182968378067017,
-0.7975716590881348,
0.2971784174442291,
-0.005340235307812691,
-0.5612705945968628,
0.9124351739883423,
0.5283125042915344,
0.47929883003234863,
-0.18996082246303558,
0.4537036716938019,
0.31105098128318787,
0.14661692082881927,
-0.796166718006134,
0.8258946537971497,
-0.9044583439826965,
-0.08457768708467484,
-0.26716089248657227,
-1.0191895961761475,
-0.40264180302619934,
0.328939825296402,
0.012545425444841385,
-0.23098452389240265,
0.6466994881629944,
1.0500258207321167,
-0.07763733714818954,
-0.5216355919837952,
0.5932315587997437,
0.45361509919166565,
0.42662420868873596,
0.46485015749931335,
0.7495905160903931,
0.12848998606204987,
0.5704327821731567,
0.11726287007331848,
-0.3685033619403839,
-0.6561788320541382,
-0.7711954712867737,
-0.8892914056777954,
-0.6454804539680481,
-0.4653490483760834,
0.11432085931301117,
0.5288023948669434,
0.97751784324646,
0.9871647357940674,
-0.5844234228134155,
-0.4480162262916565,
0.20588168501853943,
0.034893523901700974,
-0.4206676483154297,
-0.1568521112203598,
0.2454066276550293,
-0.3963909149169922,
-0.9118760228157043,
0.7452460527420044,
0.6262771487236023,
-0.23760484158992767,
-0.5915754437446594,
-0.0645865872502327,
-0.4168618321418762,
0.24471253156661987,
0.7629963159561157,
0.07449383288621902,
-0.7717548608779907,
-0.19840861856937408,
-0.19016169011592865,
-0.12757360935211182,
-0.04455758258700371,
0.6845971941947937,
-0.6421703100204468,
0.7938084006309509,
0.6100621223449707,
0.4168313145637512,
0.6957679390907288,
-0.32565444707870483,
0.6178680658340454,
-0.700448751449585,
0.383679062128067,
-0.07969662547111511,
0.386457234621048,
0.10049168020486832,
-0.18347978591918945,
0.11080779880285263,
0.29182037711143494,
-0.5119032859802246,
-0.8521729707717896,
0.20522747933864594,
-1.1392490863800049,
-0.14053092896938324,
1.110015869140625,
0.05478110536932945,
-0.0596141517162323,
-0.1087118610739708,
-0.3650709092617035,
0.21892651915550232,
-0.28694868087768555,
0.7918907403945923,
0.5116997957229614,
0.02625558339059353,
-0.467472642660141,
-0.9040142297744751,
0.301471471786499,
0.5404677987098694,
-0.6703028678894043,
0.06732427328824997,
0.3603154718875885,
0.023669952526688576,
0.03782987967133522,
0.27292442321777344,
0.32250168919563293,
0.47646528482437134,
-0.2665516436100006,
0.16833050549030304,
-0.4519976079463959,
-0.6656830906867981,
-0.20777402818202972,
0.14419466257095337,
0.3493014872074127,
-0.2570612132549286
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.