id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17284v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17284v1
|
Common Ground Tracking in Multimodal Dialogue
| 2024-03-26T00:25:01 | 2024-03-26T00:25:01 |
Ibrahim Khebour, Kenneth Lai, Mariah Bradford, Yifan Zhu, Richard Brutti, Christopher Tam, Jingxuan Tu, Benjamin Ibarra, Nathaniel Blanchard, Nikhil Krishnaswamy, James Pustejovsky
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Within Dialogue Modeling research in AI and NLP, considerable attention has
been spent on ``dialogue state tracking'' (DST), which is the ability to update
the representations of the speaker's needs at each turn in the dialogue by
taking into account the past dialogue moves and history. Less studied but just
as important to dialogue modeling, however, is ``common ground tracking''
(CGT), which identifies the shared belief space held by all of the participants
in a task-oriented dialogue: the task-relevant propositions all participants
accept as true. In this paper we present a method for automatically identifying
the current set of shared beliefs and ``questions under discussion'' (QUDs) of
a group with a shared goal. We annotate a dataset of multimodal interactions in
a shared physical space with speech transcriptions, prosodic features,
gestures, actions, and facets of collaboration, and operationalize these
features for use in a deep neural model to predict moves toward construction of
common ground. Model outputs cascade into a set of formal closure rules derived
from situated evidence and belief axioms and update operations. We empirically
assess the contribution of each feature type toward successful construction of
common ground relative to ground truth, establishing a benchmark in this novel,
challenging task.
|
[
-0.7799398303031921,
-0.7239149808883667,
0.859291672706604,
-0.12171164900064468,
-0.29727381467819214,
0.1109348013997078,
-0.14097890257835388,
-0.15142494440078735,
0.28866705298423767,
0.3555145561695099,
-0.6766588091850281,
-0.9649869799613953,
-0.7631351351737976,
-0.417534738779068,
-0.10809555649757385,
0.781868040561676,
-0.1434594839811325,
-0.16302913427352905,
-0.41370877623558044,
-0.6060268878936768,
-0.7647547125816345,
-0.9833323955535889,
-0.061377234756946564,
-0.3126589357852936,
0.5206385254859924,
0.22442522644996643,
0.6842302083969116,
0.0846165120601654,
0.29996854066848755,
0.2831698954105377,
-0.1587262600660324,
0.27183184027671814,
-0.28736159205436707,
0.2331729233264923,
-0.005796017590910196,
-0.2891472578048706,
-0.28173208236694336,
0.1832653284072876,
0.5851953625679016,
0.7904426455497742,
-0.08066794276237488,
-0.006337516475468874,
0.03422459959983826,
0.02932714857161045,
-0.3417869806289673,
0.26318925619125366,
-0.47161710262298584,
0.1578209400177002,
0.14305584132671356,
-0.3824674189090729,
-0.02086356095969677,
-0.5036072134971619,
0.21841521561145782,
-0.6098916530609131,
0.4141453504562378,
-0.12525877356529236,
0.5433681011199951,
0.3552824556827545,
-0.7189173102378845,
-0.4370075464248657,
-0.3958927392959595,
0.71364825963974,
-0.5076155662536621,
0.4171302914619446,
0.3146919012069702,
0.12196069955825806,
-0.14530880749225616,
-0.422672837972641,
-0.6346701979637146,
-0.32371336221694946,
-0.15196073055267334,
0.04006001353263855,
-0.012869652360677719,
0.3472856283187866,
0.45789992809295654,
0.2692590355873108,
-0.278606653213501,
-0.33475956320762634,
-0.2018173187971115,
-0.26464906334877014,
0.280229389667511,
0.18944191932678223,
0.36049869656562805,
-0.04662175476551056,
-0.44526949524879456,
0.15218326449394226,
-0.33752182126045227,
0.027539294213056564,
-0.22316434979438782,
0.14095473289489746,
-0.1771813929080963,
0.4606190621852875,
-0.5367621779441833,
0.5555932521820068,
0.1191539317369461,
0.04801749438047409,
0.25195586681365967,
-0.5445740818977356,
0.025388125330209732,
-0.006011437624692917,
0.5188143253326416,
0.9107642769813538,
0.032898057252168655,
-0.1599753051996231,
-0.0815332755446434,
0.45123371481895447,
0.1315392553806305,
-0.3630020022392273,
-0.029859814792871475,
-0.09687639027833939,
-0.29693612456321716,
0.08474651724100113,
-0.1835503876209259,
-0.41716742515563965,
-0.563338577747345,
-0.7007105946540833,
0.2201654613018036,
-0.4597732722759247,
-0.41246533393859863,
0.18171414732933044,
-0.06932653486728668,
0.06820571422576904,
0.7599031925201416,
-0.633014440536499,
0.5460875034332275,
0.9239031076431274,
1.0727863311767578,
-0.06689424812793732,
-0.32597067952156067,
-0.5132551193237305,
0.08403195440769196,
-0.10664067417383194,
0.6942145824432373,
-0.5624467730522156,
-0.2374379187822342,
-0.07058526575565338,
-0.03443651646375656,
-0.24679170548915863,
-0.09661166369915009,
0.4304918050765991,
-0.21159261465072632,
0.27190524339675903,
-0.6790390610694885,
-0.7435881495475769,
-0.460665225982666,
0.8225712776184082,
-0.4296792447566986,
0.7199531197547913,
-0.3011586666107178,
-0.8301091194152832,
0.5112649202346802,
-0.6416243314743042,
0.023180225864052773,
-0.03597884625196457,
-0.5979486703872681,
-0.08164780586957932,
0.23513871431350708,
0.154605895280838,
0.3173788785934448,
-0.05675223097205162,
0.7657753825187683,
-0.5350605249404907,
-0.42818954586982727,
0.1373146027326584,
-0.6157534718513489,
0.45923951268196106,
0.060141708701848984,
-0.241464301943779,
0.14143019914627075,
-0.5036972761154175,
-0.04552576318383217,
-0.37840110063552856,
0.008556618355214596,
-0.3243521451950073,
0.18494965136051178,
-0.29665982723236084,
0.2724062502384186,
0.34262534976005554,
-0.46538496017456055,
0.3858504891395569,
0.2104821801185608,
0.13001690804958344,
0.6403713226318359,
0.44834306836128235,
0.26339447498321533,
-0.3973771333694458,
0.3761645555496216,
0.10023976117372513,
0.14476975798606873,
-0.12007809430360794,
-0.6778854727745056,
-0.5914488434791565,
-0.18551622331142426,
-0.030462021008133888,
0.20314978063106537,
-0.1556767374277115,
0.31179067492485046,
-0.22693145275115967,
-0.41587918996810913,
-0.30673134326934814,
-0.2255912870168686,
0.3355962932109833,
0.25177016854286194,
0.37643861770629883,
-0.3932483494281769,
-0.22068104147911072,
-0.6203292608261108,
0.047141917049884796,
-0.266337126493454,
0.03476415202021599,
0.3304681181907654,
0.3044244945049286,
-0.05019184574484825,
1.0702260732650757,
-0.6941681504249573,
-0.16623756289482117,
-0.013558448292315006,
0.7392012476921082,
0.020329689607024193,
0.5475603342056274,
0.4688965678215027,
-0.9959855079650879,
-0.46083852648735046,
0.025786273181438446,
-0.8549996614456177,
-0.2345585823059082,
-0.10837165266275406,
-0.01864147186279297,
-0.24310097098350525,
0.5114492177963257,
-0.8807904124259949,
0.6680007576942444,
0.5561570525169373,
-0.4145198464393616,
0.23677335679531097,
0.0773150846362114,
0.7794672250747681,
-1.0055837631225586,
-0.05112950876355171,
-0.015057873912155628,
-0.04938916862010956,
-0.5038496255874634,
-0.0721503347158432,
-0.4253692030906677,
-0.04225188493728638,
-0.33228230476379395,
0.25810807943344116,
-0.36069440841674805,
-0.3634791970252991,
0.014361533336341381,
0.3576541841030121,
-0.11843112111091614,
1.0023237466812134,
0.4230613708496094,
0.7580679059028625,
0.5219123363494873,
-0.5268086791038513,
0.3531993329524994,
0.4476967751979828,
-0.19687700271606445,
0.8155551552772522,
-0.3872755467891693,
0.49444183707237244,
0.04746397212147713,
0.49330195784568787,
-0.9770801663398743,
-0.01170592475682497,
0.33870312571525574,
-0.6246823668479919,
-0.42395779490470886,
-0.5716922283172607,
-0.4933914840221405,
0.13789740204811096,
0.21208103001117706,
0.45866331458091736,
0.23473656177520752,
-0.24194227159023285,
0.8016883730888367,
0.39652910828590393,
-0.18914122879505157,
-0.35758188366889954,
-0.07953503727912903,
0.19270622730255127,
-0.3976888358592987,
-0.7472828030586243,
0.21659359335899353,
-0.12814168632030487,
-0.39576882123947144,
-0.1250075101852417,
-0.24856536090373993,
-0.2509535849094391,
0.24435898661613464,
0.5108868479728699,
-0.16424867510795593,
-0.0802311971783638,
0.16924650967121124,
-0.1416540890932083,
-0.048326149582862854,
0.09079588949680328,
-0.17743495106697083,
0.7008036971092224,
-0.3319251537322998,
-0.6799284815788269,
-0.48097652196884155,
0.7292147874832153,
0.8027731776237488,
-0.24171903729438782,
0.5537398457527161,
0.46090227365493774,
-0.48832541704177856,
0.21601970493793488,
-0.5210543274879456,
0.08076351135969162,
-0.36362379789352417,
0.2686593234539032,
-0.45178738236427307,
-0.9108991026878357,
0.629266619682312,
-0.3597923815250397,
0.08231273293495178,
0.1522279530763626,
0.3626375198364258,
-0.28943073749542236,
1.1212629079818726,
0.5548380613327026,
0.02584035135805607,
0.2670130431652069,
0.13088268041610718,
0.11361678689718246,
-0.7668831944465637,
-0.29419857263565063,
-0.4393098056316376,
-0.3255256116390228,
-0.3219003975391388,
-0.7475838661193848,
0.46258479356765747,
0.30755582451820374,
-0.01069820299744606,
0.351841539144516,
-0.23838508129119873,
0.24679745733737946,
0.8897473216056824,
-0.06780650466680527,
0.36637455224990845,
-0.3954962193965912,
-0.36881062388420105,
-0.18815962970256805,
-0.4679473638534546,
-0.39707881212234497,
0.6957424283027649,
0.16248010098934174,
0.4754089117050171,
0.20035533607006073,
0.8079193830490112,
0.5338271260261536,
0.2272942066192627,
-0.5774085521697998,
0.7813908457756042,
0.1307748705148697,
-0.4285888075828552,
-0.07538913935422897,
-0.168499156832695,
-0.3698437809944153,
0.3105810284614563,
-0.26638656854629517,
-0.8599499464035034,
-0.0421409010887146,
0.19996076822280884,
-0.3220900297164917,
0.17999669909477234,
-0.5296708941459656,
0.9288263320922852,
-0.14734533429145813,
-0.12203159183263779,
-0.7062854170799255,
-0.7167346477508545,
0.10234981775283813,
0.02531367354094982,
-0.08404947072267532,
-0.25639450550079346,
0.5076552629470825,
0.6129188537597656,
-0.0846468135714531,
1.1797077655792236,
-0.6039927005767822,
-0.02704172022640705,
0.4197193384170532,
-0.048652052879333496,
0.3536444306373596,
0.09052151441574097,
0.37618201971054077,
0.3687571585178375,
0.08312789350748062,
-0.12821272015571594,
-0.7173912525177002,
0.5833407044410706,
-0.6181483864784241,
-0.6593912243843079,
-0.5911386609077454,
-0.5211302638053894,
-0.28190743923187256,
0.10088229924440384,
0.04329374060034752,
0.40434643626213074,
-0.6697356104850769,
0.27535736560821533,
0.7188043594360352,
-0.24411673843860626,
0.20808850228786469,
0.38485994935035706,
-0.15599529445171356,
-0.4741675853729248,
0.41782519221305847,
-0.03964930772781372,
0.3325093388557434,
0.20672307908535004,
0.00613015703856945,
-0.47954457998275757,
-0.5103573799133301,
-0.049367472529411316,
-0.01895233802497387,
-0.8972944021224976,
0.05934054031968117,
-0.870926558971405,
-0.1501636654138565,
-0.25736820697784424,
-0.26021334528923035,
-0.14660146832466125,
-0.32994213700294495,
-0.18092462420463562,
-0.12658201158046722,
0.05521944910287857,
0.5013297200202942,
0.012913529761135578,
0.4007585346698761,
-0.9556734561920166,
0.6016671061515808,
0.44066667556762695,
0.34240812063217163,
-0.48950573801994324,
-0.10535138845443726,
-0.22194671630859375,
0.5219376087188721,
-0.381429523229599,
-0.7439947724342346,
0.13164445757865906,
-0.024460233747959137,
0.7263830900192261,
-0.06664010137319565,
0.10879402607679367,
0.7513810396194458,
-0.31876298785209656,
0.9649848937988281,
0.5172085762023926,
-1.1570847034454346,
0.6091955900192261,
-0.4796304702758789,
0.36242958903312683,
0.5831401944160461,
0.1872180998325348,
-1.1205952167510986,
-0.4148772954940796,
-0.5810208320617676,
-0.22985661029815674,
0.4350756108760834,
0.11586332321166992,
-0.19888760149478912,
-0.10408856719732285,
-0.2099137157201767,
-0.13409730792045593,
0.4281427562236786,
-0.6409949064254761,
0.048824917525053024,
-0.24251027405261993,
-0.24619457125663757,
0.014384141191840172,
0.046715207397937775,
-0.5987081527709961,
-0.11129093170166016,
0.12601564824581146,
-0.4618198871612549,
0.30205950140953064,
0.17145320773124695,
-0.24512529373168945,
-0.05927279219031334,
0.37905725836753845,
0.7670004963874817,
0.5127663612365723,
-0.4279765188694,
0.11806239932775497,
0.20132341980934143,
-0.05409520864486694,
0.0791054293513298,
0.08937685936689377,
-0.12378986179828644,
0.1646793633699417,
0.23644128441810608,
0.9217628240585327,
0.17606137692928314,
-0.18516835570335388,
0.6911625862121582,
-0.21386563777923584,
-0.2853766083717346,
-0.3864947557449341,
0.042092110961675644,
0.05362652987241745,
0.6086599230766296,
0.13865523040294647,
0.6503575444221497,
0.12056637555360794,
-0.5685056447982788,
0.559890627861023,
0.4139350354671478,
-0.6558961272239685,
-0.5526053309440613,
0.3759838342666626,
0.3871442675590515,
-0.4030703902244568,
0.4357973337173462,
-0.06377515196800232,
-0.9230523705482483,
0.4491857886314392,
0.08271249383687973,
1.017545461654663,
0.10069683939218521,
0.24802590906620026,
0.26273787021636963,
-0.028233928605914116,
-0.027085766196250916,
0.030073517933487892,
-0.3876393139362335,
-0.9265406727790833,
-0.5333436131477356,
-0.33975842595100403,
-0.5220495462417603,
-0.16960175335407257,
-0.7658756375312805,
0.27876827120780945,
-0.31995442509651184,
-0.2537726163864136,
-0.2438010573387146,
0.04593169689178467,
-0.6657645106315613,
0.39356109499931335,
0.7102199196815491,
0.5783408284187317,
-1.0759589672088623,
0.7399351000785828,
0.44840124249458313,
-0.3966178297996521,
-0.4586685597896576,
0.3908325433731079,
0.2958584725856781,
-0.5671632885932922,
0.6198921203613281,
0.3107675313949585,
-0.45734432339668274,
-0.2745802402496338,
-0.7074532508850098,
-0.8259774446487427,
1.0838508605957031,
0.021632708609104156,
-0.5854411125183105,
-0.19291497766971588,
0.10554920136928558,
0.6711893081665039,
-0.4653612971305847,
0.17621314525604248,
0.26044362783432007,
0.31264588236808777,
0.2665638327598572,
-1.0652649402618408,
-0.10492546111345291,
-0.1074264720082283,
-0.556806743144989,
0.317308634519577,
-0.8917840123176575,
0.6508945822715759,
0.1501207947731018,
-0.20863473415374756,
-0.0910123884677887,
0.6060747504234314,
0.4452092945575714,
0.7585769295692444,
0.8112093806266785,
0.6333885788917542,
0.8178654313087463,
-0.20612283051013947,
0.2869230806827545,
-0.30826687812805176,
0.4722677767276764,
1.3155646324157715,
-0.3816221058368683,
0.5169299840927124,
0.3632872998714447,
0.19842137396335602,
0.31065690517425537,
0.29982924461364746,
0.007721569389104843,
0.7441110014915466,
0.14242622256278992,
-0.42204347252845764,
-0.426000714302063,
-0.3373916447162628,
-0.4699873626232147,
0.5122005939483643,
0.4947831630706787,
-0.05906127393245697,
-0.15719465911388397,
-0.28516894578933716,
-0.11995386332273483,
0.08147309720516205,
-0.15853968262672424,
0.8793264627456665,
0.0014419964281842113,
-1.2333927154541016,
0.39689573645591736,
-0.42317381501197815,
0.432222455739975,
-0.39794206619262695,
-0.5151965022087097,
-0.2825281620025635,
-0.06593059748411179,
0.1998252272605896,
-0.8819259405136108,
0.23460625112056732,
-0.03718806430697441,
-0.03459779545664787,
-0.35861295461654663,
0.2922508716583252,
-0.643928587436676,
-0.02302793599665165,
0.4753867983818054,
0.31962984800338745,
-0.02071317844092846,
-0.11455892026424408,
-0.6548909544944763,
0.22037452459335327,
0.254871666431427,
0.05243305489420891,
0.15236440300941467,
0.7438933849334717,
-0.19664375483989716,
0.6068794131278992,
0.5007064938545227,
-0.05187423527240753,
0.22590626776218414,
0.2178744226694107,
0.9650253057479858,
-0.9284286499023438,
-0.5709785223007202,
-0.32854029536247253,
0.6410646438598633,
-0.2669984996318817,
-0.5169939398765564,
0.47302278876304626,
0.2999666929244995,
0.7081721425056458,
0.38924503326416016,
0.9104045033454895,
-0.14085029065608978,
0.7052820920944214,
-0.6972092390060425,
0.31896209716796875,
-0.3236690163612366,
0.24999777972698212,
-0.443715900182724,
-1.0217167139053345,
-0.06635057181119919,
0.6513944864273071,
-0.17940235137939453,
-0.3356826603412628,
0.8857705593109131,
0.5130069255828857,
-0.20447291433811188,
0.2529093027114868,
0.33757665753364563,
0.019420210272073746,
0.4620075821876526,
0.6475178003311157,
1.3575526475906372,
-0.23079264163970947,
0.36915260553359985,
-0.09165345877408981,
-0.13942945003509521,
0.014788471162319183,
-0.742665708065033,
-0.7563686370849609,
-0.706811249256134,
-0.6088178753852844,
-0.08034749329090118,
0.01691032014787197,
0.9909760355949402,
0.7484356760978699,
-0.63262540102005,
-0.05385811999440193,
-0.2672712206840515,
-0.1764611452817917,
-0.2574852705001831,
-0.14478176832199097,
0.13820195198059082,
-0.08939623087644577,
-0.6129324436187744,
0.4661676585674286,
0.2285187691450119,
-0.03559180721640587,
-0.03206481412053108,
-0.2389759123325348,
-0.4879714548587799,
-0.047824546694755554,
0.07200352102518082,
0.05325881019234657,
-1.012528657913208,
-0.7673659920692444,
-0.0721321851015091,
-0.03939707949757576,
0.227119579911232,
0.8130368590354919,
-0.643383264541626,
0.47660693526268005,
0.2807691991329193,
0.3080510199069977,
0.7481450438499451,
0.3778650760650635,
0.81293123960495,
-0.9380404353141785,
0.03112143464386463,
0.429513156414032,
0.35649171471595764,
0.28364503383636475,
-0.06482689827680588,
0.4576445519924164,
0.5293498635292053,
-0.610307514667511,
-0.5972722768783569,
0.3564019501209259,
-1.1023112535476685,
0.06103401631116867,
0.9271627068519592,
-0.48908260464668274,
0.2802399694919586,
-0.3266521990299225,
-0.37252533435821533,
0.40118348598480225,
-0.41682004928588867,
0.6500728726387024,
1.0991894006729126,
0.10717194527387619,
-0.3683570325374603,
-0.17688488960266113,
0.4147544503211975,
0.35082152485847473,
-0.5314806699752808,
0.19281908869743347,
1.0889447927474976,
0.1686423271894455,
0.49683865904808044,
0.8905912041664124,
0.3516443967819214,
0.05342603847384453,
0.17324373126029968,
-0.09130504727363586,
0.3511620759963989,
-0.5268104076385498,
-0.10464858263731003,
0.27682623267173767,
-0.2009291797876358,
-0.44760367274284363
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17281v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17281v1
|
Automate Knowledge Concept Tagging on Math Questions with LLMs
| 2024-03-26T00:09:38 | 2024-03-26T00:09:38 |
Hang Li, Tianlong Xu, Jiliang Tang, Qingsong Wen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Knowledge concept tagging for questions plays a crucial role in contemporary
intelligent educational applications, including learning progress diagnosis,
practice question recommendations, and course content organization.
Traditionally, these annotations have been conducted manually with help from
pedagogical experts, as the task requires not only a strong semantic
understanding of both question stems and knowledge definitions but also deep
insights into connecting question-solving logic with corresponding knowledge
concepts. In this paper, we explore automating the tagging task using Large
Language Models (LLMs), in response to the inability of prior manual methods to
meet the rapidly growing demand for concept tagging in questions posed by
advanced educational applications. Moreover, the zero/few-shot learning
capability of LLMs makes them well-suited for application in educational
scenarios, which often face challenges in collecting large-scale,
expertise-annotated datasets. By conducting extensive experiments with a
variety of representative LLMs, we demonstrate that LLMs are a promising tool
for concept tagging in math questions. Furthermore, through case studies
examining the results from different LLMs, we draw some empirical conclusions
about the key factors for success in applying LLMs to the automatic concept
tagging task.
|
[
-0.6040570139884949,
-0.9044751524925232,
0.6709458231925964,
-0.27178555727005005,
-0.31169140338897705,
0.27852556109428406,
-0.10800954699516296,
-0.34705138206481934,
0.2075178176164627,
0.41464102268218994,
-0.4187650680541992,
-0.6899828910827637,
-0.5679418444633484,
-0.03117969259619713,
-0.36915645003318787,
0.5837439894676208,
-0.3957286775112152,
0.035095665603876114,
-0.7236688733100891,
0.22231708467006683,
-0.5375982522964478,
-0.47457560896873474,
-0.6213020086288452,
-0.3746861517429352,
0.399292916059494,
0.4575580358505249,
0.32988354563713074,
0.8243672847747803,
0.9137992858886719,
0.23068852722644806,
0.2488379031419754,
0.32784557342529297,
0.060138680040836334,
0.23126383125782013,
-0.12300929427146912,
-0.6194846630096436,
-0.527308464050293,
0.09030399471521378,
0.7746637463569641,
1.1037613153457642,
-0.07748255133628845,
0.3713386654853821,
-0.2324395775794983,
0.30847474932670593,
-0.37255293130874634,
0.3972845673561096,
-0.8390465974807739,
0.08760853111743927,
-0.06774202734231949,
-0.17870302498340607,
-0.0018379377434030175,
-0.35927659273147583,
0.13728298246860504,
-0.5807508230209351,
0.02616555243730545,
-0.10931902378797531,
0.6473692655563354,
0.6155096888542175,
-0.17141586542129517,
-0.5109498500823975,
-0.6045160293579102,
0.73883455991745,
-0.5298806428909302,
0.15801455080509186,
0.531187891960144,
0.355328768491745,
-0.09519495815038681,
-0.45601725578308105,
-0.6262302398681641,
-0.07220613211393356,
-0.05408208817243576,
-0.027078352868556976,
-0.047153208404779434,
-0.08236638456583023,
0.484467476606369,
0.16549479961395264,
-0.35230752825737,
0.2515634000301361,
-0.1545974761247635,
-0.14443662762641907,
0.6678448915481567,
0.3966653347015381,
0.24781392514705658,
-0.16663263738155365,
-0.31792718172073364,
0.06601734459400177,
-0.6854169964790344,
-0.11349962651729584,
0.2116711288690567,
0.2333667278289795,
0.22291049361228943,
0.8698276281356812,
-0.09642788767814636,
1.0682368278503418,
-0.40560394525527954,
-0.3392537236213684,
0.04954656586050987,
-0.21209242939949036,
-0.10784894973039627,
-0.1648564636707306,
0.5278735160827637,
0.2820788621902466,
0.6074174046516418,
-0.010523589327931404,
-0.20706871151924133,
0.36697471141815186,
-0.10246220976114273,
-0.6789944171905518,
-0.30724841356277466,
0.02733885683119297,
0.2501668930053711,
-0.01739087700843811,
-0.21964816749095917,
-0.44292953610420227,
-0.21146424114704132,
-0.5597538352012634,
0.6712973117828369,
-0.3819773495197296,
-0.17493301630020142,
0.24348364770412445,
-0.02270461991429329,
0.37425169348716736,
0.6091756820678711,
-0.6287513971328735,
0.19253969192504883,
0.7393780946731567,
0.5526559352874756,
-0.208693265914917,
-0.021736085414886475,
-0.42104026675224304,
0.16424812376499176,
-0.4921301603317261,
0.9523721933364868,
-0.8105409741401672,
-0.45286035537719727,
-0.1598234325647354,
-0.41852906346321106,
-0.16145358979701996,
-0.5453023314476013,
0.023844650015234947,
-0.6979789137840271,
-0.037674419581890106,
-0.2273799628019333,
-1.203997254371643,
-0.05949347838759422,
0.5496410727500916,
-0.3175567090511322,
0.9062165021896362,
-0.1125001460313797,
-0.3866012990474701,
0.13517963886260986,
-0.6922639012336731,
-0.2972528636455536,
0.3961493670940399,
-0.3602558672428131,
-0.12510386109352112,
-0.0044107395224273205,
0.023207327350974083,
0.8122738599777222,
-0.38861972093582153,
0.3573591113090515,
-0.2045966237783432,
-0.18023088574409485,
0.4503887891769409,
-0.2017633318901062,
0.453515887260437,
-0.049049150198698044,
0.0073604281060397625,
-0.31781792640686035,
-0.5217727422714233,
-0.07137180864810944,
0.46851280331611633,
-0.05794281139969826,
-0.5899202227592468,
0.0026840472128242254,
-0.6001266837120056,
0.1017371192574501,
0.352741003036499,
-0.43891647458076477,
0.5695818066596985,
-0.3663165271282196,
0.10308618098497391,
0.5826632976531982,
0.09713298827409744,
0.4128915071487427,
-0.3889811336994171,
0.6551334857940674,
-0.046261016279459,
-0.29576775431632996,
-0.46873703598976135,
-0.5719708204269409,
-0.821220874786377,
-0.31706514954566956,
0.6037024855613708,
0.6199294328689575,
-0.7711385488510132,
0.533447265625,
-0.1177859902381897,
-0.5098400115966797,
-0.45543187856674194,
0.3838725984096527,
0.10137731581926346,
0.8706781268119812,
0.30528250336647034,
-0.15740227699279785,
-0.14228546619415283,
-0.7902129888534546,
-0.2387154996395111,
-0.11195281893014908,
-0.030142102390527725,
0.43269407749176025,
0.677422821521759,
-0.051060751080513,
1.3761160373687744,
-0.997783899307251,
-0.5962385535240173,
-0.08388667553663254,
0.26258936524391174,
-0.06561072915792465,
0.3846863806247711,
0.34814631938934326,
-0.6066128015518188,
-0.3969806432723999,
-0.37685340642929077,
-0.63829505443573,
-0.2482643574476242,
-0.004585950635373592,
-0.15378499031066895,
0.1277720034122467,
0.49824199080467224,
-0.5795088410377502,
0.34576255083084106,
0.0786937028169632,
0.032997045665979385,
0.3762683868408203,
0.05812827870249748,
-0.39274904131889343,
-1.1657649278640747,
-0.04026700183749199,
0.3371020555496216,
-0.15194736421108246,
-0.3946898281574249,
0.1187506839632988,
0.031402185559272766,
0.02141583152115345,
-0.3946341872215271,
0.7799889445304871,
-0.424938827753067,
-0.1831357181072235,
-0.05992217734456062,
0.5252255797386169,
-0.09196941554546356,
0.320772260427475,
0.2624013125896454,
0.5447631478309631,
0.6423742175102234,
-0.6809875965118408,
0.7283233404159546,
0.08809453994035721,
-0.3336128294467926,
0.531258761882782,
-0.5293434858322144,
0.0443846732378006,
-0.1780700385570526,
0.20834997296333313,
-1.1375664472579956,
-0.31757745146751404,
0.27817487716674805,
-0.6057448983192444,
0.1756027489900589,
-0.3006284534931183,
-0.9880756735801697,
-0.2850019633769989,
-0.19424991309642792,
0.33260294795036316,
0.6065388917922974,
-0.2643563151359558,
0.7508161067962646,
0.5980013012886047,
-0.1887737661600113,
-0.32199162244796753,
-0.46327629685401917,
0.05739309638738632,
-0.2691112160682678,
-0.23210963606834412,
0.18171779811382294,
-0.2981734573841095,
-0.39857053756713867,
0.06504251807928085,
-0.1353919953107834,
-0.058514539152383804,
0.46208593249320984,
0.046339038759469986,
0.6841323375701904,
-0.039252933114767075,
0.5310608744621277,
0.04093186929821968,
-0.3254167437553406,
0.4090457856655121,
-0.4680534601211548,
0.6116201281547546,
0.06586761772632599,
-0.7382876873016357,
-0.14340628683567047,
0.20852312445640564,
0.2744574546813965,
-0.5008820295333862,
0.4093687832355499,
0.3878350257873535,
-0.8363324403762817,
-0.3943210542201996,
-0.6567091345787048,
-0.08104706555604935,
-0.4246112108230591,
0.24314990639686584,
-0.24214471876621246,
-0.9085431098937988,
0.4448194205760956,
-0.33620932698249817,
0.24217163026332855,
0.4406490623950958,
0.5216283798217773,
-0.4608595371246338,
0.8941842317581177,
0.5454713106155396,
-0.0035718439612537622,
0.20398759841918945,
-0.5625516772270203,
0.0608963780105114,
-0.6833080053329468,
-0.1831968128681183,
-0.4511919617652893,
-0.2613992691040039,
-0.2811778783798218,
-0.7922155857086182,
0.48159223794937134,
0.03212197124958038,
-0.04600013047456741,
0.05919242650270462,
-0.3189854323863983,
0.6954222321510315,
0.36016300320625305,
-0.2735852003097534,
0.524963915348053,
0.05373275279998779,
-0.15957000851631165,
-0.015427187085151672,
-0.5918134450912476,
-0.38947364687919617,
1.0111656188964844,
0.33020663261413574,
0.9719945788383484,
-0.1574290245771408,
0.9466432929039001,
-0.06619439274072647,
0.45485150814056396,
-1.3364163637161255,
0.8364566564559937,
-0.06001105532050133,
-0.604304850101471,
-0.412395715713501,
-0.40139690041542053,
-0.5200896263122559,
-0.0008340216591022909,
-0.02635204792022705,
-0.42812010645866394,
-0.1848076432943344,
0.1313788741827011,
-0.5773868560791016,
0.3945837914943695,
-0.5288257598876953,
0.502190113067627,
-0.21425768733024597,
0.023658663034439087,
0.07027475535869598,
-0.44720742106437683,
0.27688974142074585,
-0.5575303435325623,
0.20266254246234894,
-0.40839189291000366,
-0.39641618728637695,
0.9592655301094055,
-0.23743408918380737,
1.0462480783462524,
-0.11285420507192612,
-0.45856791734695435,
0.46836042404174805,
0.25704556703567505,
0.22656717896461487,
0.06393968313932419,
0.3064962327480316,
0.060966573655605316,
-0.10446588695049286,
-0.15877725183963776,
-0.7299132347106934,
0.5894108414649963,
-0.5920975804328918,
-0.8049994707107544,
-0.4671834409236908,
-0.8756313323974609,
-0.5114541053771973,
0.06829199194908142,
-0.2517703175544739,
0.39441174268722534,
0.26724085211753845,
-0.17772279679775238,
1.0495021343231201,
-0.01655174233019352,
0.5203757286071777,
0.6733389496803284,
-0.30993494391441345,
-0.1528424322605133,
1.1296107769012451,
0.5022779107093811,
0.2055443525314331,
0.3637027144432068,
0.09162993729114532,
-0.4231601655483246,
-0.32410356402397156,
-0.48883920907974243,
0.580987274646759,
-0.9196891784667969,
-0.5985860824584961,
-0.8227254152297974,
-0.3506227135658264,
-0.32775938510894775,
-0.26039209961891174,
-0.22928985953330994,
-0.5419095158576965,
-0.3480790853500366,
-0.03791680559515953,
0.5349016189575195,
0.559954047203064,
0.06871724128723145,
0.1658404916524887,
-0.6571117043495178,
0.4275035262107849,
0.6687415838241577,
0.3800770044326782,
-0.11339585483074188,
-0.6146064400672913,
-0.11458928883075714,
0.04781150445342064,
0.0019098944030702114,
-0.6818438172340393,
0.1587582677602768,
0.14982998371124268,
0.3861231207847595,
0.15902554988861084,
0.10745035856962204,
0.6553181409835815,
-0.47980964183807373,
0.49789389967918396,
0.07980278879404068,
-0.9160136580467224,
0.6138630509376526,
-0.2673003375530243,
0.28760749101638794,
0.2368796467781067,
0.7878637313842773,
-0.4477638304233551,
-0.2823413908481598,
-0.48627012968063354,
-0.6914055347442627,
0.5056952238082886,
-0.2190077155828476,
0.38407376408576965,
-0.02027171477675438,
0.5413311123847961,
0.005448724143207073,
0.28397849202156067,
-0.2465788871049881,
-0.441438764333725,
0.2361353635787964,
-0.4012777507305145,
-0.09199617803096771,
-0.028652697801589966,
-0.15953591465950012,
-0.4165264070034027,
0.5199632048606873,
-0.3569902181625366,
0.13526593148708344,
-0.014797006733715534,
-0.3544791638851166,
-0.16955025494098663,
0.1277867555618286,
0.4000062644481659,
0.6608731746673584,
-0.08204720914363861,
0.1293598860502243,
0.372917115688324,
-0.27407416701316833,
0.09202051162719727,
0.3541818857192993,
-0.14947886765003204,
-0.07164022326469421,
0.2830272912979126,
0.351943701505661,
0.014095708727836609,
-0.7497280836105347,
0.41594818234443665,
-0.01741541549563408,
-0.28619328141212463,
-0.5919370651245117,
0.29393744468688965,
0.387050986289978,
0.025766702368855476,
0.5036364793777466,
-0.25159984827041626,
-0.23031246662139893,
-0.31744202971458435,
0.1400303691625595,
0.7837343811988831,
-0.023365212604403496,
-0.1127057746052742,
0.31213101744651794,
0.059163033962249756,
-0.31815776228904724,
0.3954857885837555,
-0.17396658658981323,
-0.6632202863693237,
0.9156635999679565,
0.4880340099334717,
0.5920307636260986,
-0.23058192431926727,
0.12419769912958145,
0.2759847939014435,
0.2961341142654419,
0.09551626443862915,
0.16072742640972137,
-0.22710272669792175,
-0.9280419945716858,
-0.6703984141349792,
-0.7672378420829773,
-0.7574847340583801,
-0.11383061110973358,
-0.5855775475502014,
0.3774263262748718,
-0.5942686796188354,
-0.1268525868654251,
0.18066434562206268,
0.09977634251117706,
-0.8092260360717773,
0.44684067368507385,
0.5535722374916077,
1.0034667253494263,
-0.8322013020515442,
0.9080281257629395,
1.222321629524231,
-0.35603782534599304,
-0.869357705116272,
-0.201737180352211,
-0.1456003338098526,
-1.0255438089370728,
0.8634340763092041,
0.014701691456139088,
-0.09162789583206177,
0.5399835109710693,
-0.6650086641311646,
-1.0148237943649292,
1.0398656129837036,
0.04336719587445259,
-0.5700382590293884,
-0.23636330664157867,
0.4342682659626007,
0.4325498342514038,
-0.5314181447029114,
0.18655166029930115,
0.6088306307792664,
0.36032921075820923,
0.4495489001274109,
-0.7119420766830444,
-0.2149289846420288,
-0.08820884674787521,
-0.19043956696987152,
0.3377479910850525,
-0.3519083857536316,
0.6167314052581787,
-0.21946996450424194,
0.0676584541797638,
-0.30495041608810425,
0.7456328868865967,
0.14367246627807617,
0.32908710837364197,
0.5457133650779724,
0.8134216070175171,
0.6351181268692017,
-0.22732385993003845,
0.614000141620636,
-0.31462493538856506,
0.4148387908935547,
0.9713737964630127,
-0.328130304813385,
0.6834156513214111,
0.2338486611843109,
-0.2047288566827774,
0.22490419447422028,
0.6532802581787109,
-0.3269954323768616,
-0.0496806874871254,
0.4430523216724396,
-0.16533324122428894,
-0.7213608026504517,
-0.3036196827888489,
-0.4157423675060272,
0.527881383895874,
0.8487169742584229,
0.05239332094788551,
-0.388882577419281,
-0.009602043777704239,
0.1463831663131714,
-0.09909834712743759,
-0.4462268352508545,
0.8481240272521973,
0.19817684590816498,
-0.5273210406303406,
0.4126110374927521,
-0.03935673087835312,
0.6934887766838074,
-0.6661815643310547,
-0.2151784896850586,
-0.3097856342792511,
-0.1799851953983307,
-0.05161294341087341,
-0.882422685623169,
0.26012900471687317,
0.18144148588180542,
0.07028858363628387,
-0.06130637601017952,
0.7810801267623901,
-0.54871666431427,
-0.7376025915145874,
0.05473315715789795,
0.9104441404342651,
0.19087806344032288,
0.16778874397277832,
-0.6217255592346191,
-0.06128433719277382,
-0.5146832466125488,
0.03649530187249184,
0.3990009129047394,
0.3181111216545105,
0.04184235259890556,
0.8997377753257751,
0.6649202704429626,
0.08983293920755386,
-0.009153380058705807,
-0.0738026425242424,
1.0275894403457642,
-0.7115486264228821,
-0.1543208807706833,
-0.8560112118721008,
0.4304504990577698,
0.21690168976783752,
-0.004825836978852749,
0.8726090788841248,
0.3754953444004059,
1.044203519821167,
0.13984335958957672,
0.7838420271873474,
0.1384667158126831,
0.5969504714012146,
-0.30934005975723267,
0.5879485607147217,
-0.6459997296333313,
0.40857043862342834,
-0.3270021378993988,
-1.0093594789505005,
-0.6190181374549866,
0.576841413974762,
-0.5296643972396851,
-0.008358254097402096,
0.4623437225818634,
0.4915285110473633,
0.1333748996257782,
-0.20791669189929962,
0.38800662755966187,
-0.08497009426355362,
0.272762268781662,
0.5188379883766174,
0.9444758892059326,
-0.03921908140182495,
0.3346887528896332,
-0.44174060225486755,
-0.16332444548606873,
-0.10997233539819717,
-0.8547801375389099,
-1.134836196899414,
-0.5720372200012207,
-0.6681656241416931,
0.10393236577510834,
-0.330219566822052,
1.2783602476119995,
0.31830891966819763,
-0.6427809000015259,
-0.1984071284532547,
0.29807963967323303,
0.26285654306411743,
0.3372698128223419,
-0.2415752112865448,
0.3593980669975281,
-0.4774015545845032,
-0.7469545602798462,
0.1457163393497467,
0.23866450786590576,
0.2827916741371155,
-0.4735741913318634,
0.5254125595092773,
-0.15411710739135742,
0.20898467302322388,
0.40220314264297485,
-0.0014345579547807574,
-0.5588467121124268,
-0.12168120592832565,
0.2026316076517105,
-0.09167104214429855,
-0.2237614244222641,
0.8001559376716614,
-1.0477488040924072,
0.36359328031539917,
0.2796809673309326,
0.9057375192642212,
0.10375204682350159,
0.06684858351945877,
0.13995063304901123,
-0.6251965165138245,
-0.28343096375465393,
0.46629732847213745,
0.29510578513145447,
0.31322935223579407,
-0.12601204216480255,
0.4199334383010864,
0.5997473001480103,
-0.2226318120956421,
-1.0175938606262207,
0.20460836589336395,
-0.6932604908943176,
-0.11859814822673798,
1.1436359882354736,
-0.2265942245721817,
-0.12142771482467651,
-0.061226487159729004,
0.08973024785518646,
0.18782491981983185,
-0.0316946916282177,
0.6222206354141235,
0.8603569865226746,
-0.038595009595155716,
0.06090341508388519,
-0.6730501651763916,
0.2639714479446411,
0.4386306405067444,
-0.831137478351593,
-0.12198728322982788,
0.4220123887062073,
0.4282488524913788,
0.2556479871273041,
0.3394109904766083,
0.08517400175333023,
0.132273331284523,
-0.4290763735771179,
0.17971418797969818,
-0.2549181878566742,
-0.29542675614356995,
-0.26830628514289856,
0.16524852812290192,
0.07310448586940765,
-0.0990728884935379
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17254v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17254v1
|
A Hybrid Approach To Aspect Based Sentiment Analysis Using Transfer Learning
| 2024-03-25T23:02:33 | 2024-03-25T23:02:33 |
Gaurav Negi, Rajdeep Sarkar, Omnia Zayed, Paul Buitelaar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Aspect-Based Sentiment Analysis (ABSA) aims to identify terms or multiword
expressions (MWEs) on which sentiments are expressed and the sentiment
polarities associated with them. The development of supervised models has been
at the forefront of research in this area. However, training these models
requires the availability of manually annotated datasets which is both
expensive and time-consuming. Furthermore, the available annotated datasets are
tailored to a specific domain, language, and text type. In this work, we
address this notable challenge in current state-of-the-art ABSA research. We
propose a hybrid approach for Aspect Based Sentiment Analysis using transfer
learning. The approach focuses on generating weakly-supervised annotations by
exploiting the strengths of both large language models (LLM) and traditional
syntactic dependencies. We utilise syntactic dependency structures of sentences
to complement the annotations generated by LLMs, as they may overlook
domain-specific aspect terms. Extensive experimentation on multiple datasets is
performed to demonstrate the efficacy of our hybrid method for the tasks of
aspect term extraction and aspect sentiment classification.
Keywords: Aspect Based Sentiment Analysis, Syntactic Parsing, large language
model (LLM)
|
[
-0.4470200538635254,
-0.8383525013923645,
0.5264614224433899,
0.21907246112823486,
-0.43687036633491516,
0.36851170659065247,
-0.15696905553340912,
-0.6943815350532532,
0.6709792613983154,
0.6757991909980774,
-0.564192533493042,
-0.5173217058181763,
-0.4426094889640808,
0.11229048669338226,
-0.09739623218774796,
1.31085205078125,
-0.35061413049697876,
0.04551555961370468,
-0.3335533142089844,
-0.508030891418457,
-0.3987085521221161,
-0.8043326139450073,
-0.34948739409446716,
-0.3598100543022156,
0.24100711941719055,
0.18291661143302917,
0.36218106746673584,
-0.1091495081782341,
0.5104085803031921,
0.2152450680732727,
-0.23673316836357117,
0.18965239822864532,
0.02856409177184105,
0.025036001577973366,
-0.5624476075172424,
-0.44518807530403137,
-0.4712553918361664,
-0.11168262362480164,
0.3547380566596985,
0.945103645324707,
0.27343034744262695,
-0.015454355627298355,
0.09739536046981812,
0.71781325340271,
-0.5366460680961609,
0.3649306893348694,
-0.5515173673629761,
0.013323706574738026,
-0.04532668739557266,
0.11665578931570053,
-0.2595830261707306,
-0.23632709681987762,
0.1624392718076706,
-0.3241526782512665,
0.06478577852249146,
-0.10728494822978973,
0.6540341377258301,
-0.23179076611995697,
-0.45202210545539856,
-0.1078471690416336,
-0.8145122528076172,
0.9009856581687927,
-0.6935046911239624,
0.13727319240570068,
0.09018612653017044,
-0.19256550073623657,
0.1572188436985016,
-0.33516499400138855,
-0.7024481892585754,
0.08632029592990875,
-0.27285662293434143,
0.11602985858917236,
-0.013930873945355415,
0.17385685443878174,
-0.17788080871105194,
0.9606170654296875,
-0.04740326479077339,
0.1675412803888321,
-0.21719510853290558,
-0.30649521946907043,
0.5700722932815552,
0.11725747585296631,
0.1085432842373848,
-0.6200171709060669,
-0.5092519521713257,
0.028845151886343956,
-0.6285116672515869,
0.2478320598602295,
0.2805994749069214,
0.7236957550048828,
-0.44892197847366333,
0.5975610613822937,
-0.27411088347435,
0.5047345161437988,
0.15857845544815063,
-0.17971906065940857,
0.3923898935317993,
-0.5880336165428162,
0.05531111732125282,
-0.1927017867565155,
0.9603469967842102,
0.10144868493080139,
-0.2661483585834503,
-0.07608902454376221,
-0.4023573100566864,
0.127963587641716,
0.20984268188476562,
-0.29337233304977417,
-0.1778523325920105,
0.28706979751586914,
-0.4166007339954376,
-0.38925790786743164,
0.21961960196495056,
-1.0706064701080322,
-0.4514775276184082,
-0.502070426940918,
0.5063508749008179,
-0.45819225907325745,
-0.37345945835113525,
-0.2757572531700134,
0.31592676043510437,
0.3454262912273407,
0.2276802808046341,
-0.6261387467384338,
0.14499780535697937,
0.8104995489120483,
0.9533016681671143,
-0.4490709602832794,
-0.11426112800836563,
-0.34025973081588745,
-0.10378031432628632,
-0.1135215163230896,
1.0612188577651978,
-0.5473756790161133,
-0.47800689935684204,
0.22164323925971985,
0.0590323768556118,
-0.010057179257273674,
-0.5044212937355042,
0.5208497643470764,
-0.23717503249645233,
0.24911083281040192,
-0.05104298144578934,
-0.29430055618286133,
-0.8339023590087891,
0.30064845085144043,
-0.6479369401931763,
1.0857874155044556,
0.4146411418914795,
-0.6906022429466248,
0.12715189158916473,
-0.5261896848678589,
-1.0712053775787354,
-0.20448429882526398,
-0.09000635892152786,
-0.6588862538337708,
0.39742669463157654,
0.33875906467437744,
0.521722674369812,
-0.11881725490093231,
0.24715091288089752,
-0.42028164863586426,
0.32348114252090454,
0.3650114834308624,
0.04940708726644516,
0.38498425483703613,
-0.08675649017095566,
-0.2870296537876129,
0.379995733499527,
-0.5695870518684387,
-0.3753909170627594,
-0.16803224384784698,
-0.046531446278095245,
-0.6511943936347961,
-0.23147156834602356,
0.10656170547008514,
0.36767837405204773,
0.6183996796607971,
-0.6198619604110718,
0.2115265280008316,
-0.46775686740875244,
0.23594261705875397,
0.5982682704925537,
0.2681411802768707,
0.5775315761566162,
-0.19227510690689087,
0.5467985272407532,
0.5143463015556335,
0.21734635531902313,
-0.09350420534610748,
-0.23092854022979736,
-0.9786857962608337,
-0.21221433579921722,
0.16260235011577606,
0.44662824273109436,
-1.0675287246704102,
0.8945354223251343,
-0.04475279897451401,
-0.35700562596321106,
-0.6257669925689697,
0.44463229179382324,
0.2145901471376419,
0.25939738750457764,
0.3614356219768524,
-0.6129273176193237,
-0.47465646266937256,
-1.221516489982605,
0.026050355285406113,
-0.36324283480644226,
0.5563356280326843,
0.14963331818580627,
0.41325047612190247,
0.1015285849571228,
1.0094263553619385,
-0.3006880581378937,
-0.6905105113983154,
-0.9974001049995422,
0.4465835690498352,
0.13510893285274506,
0.2918172776699066,
0.4206489026546478,
-0.8913172483444214,
-0.13716202974319458,
0.3089521527290344,
-0.7520986199378967,
-0.015756085515022278,
-0.24372251331806183,
-0.06471360474824905,
0.2748565673828125,
0.05156087130308151,
-0.5030061602592468,
0.1922665685415268,
0.7446841597557068,
-0.06361609697341919,
0.3740076720714569,
0.2012200504541397,
0.002672107657417655,
-1.5764447450637817,
-0.06388193368911743,
0.47583499550819397,
-0.3701920211315155,
-0.27964287996292114,
0.08597078174352646,
-0.15432652831077576,
-0.06970489025115967,
-0.6436659097671509,
0.3611341118812561,
-0.44326701760292053,
-0.13199181854724884,
-0.613539457321167,
-0.20400184392929077,
0.247568741440773,
0.6366047859191895,
0.35774528980255127,
0.5915005803108215,
0.6764229536056519,
-0.1936069130897522,
0.28085097670555115,
0.034295521676540375,
0.15187157690525055,
0.653576672077179,
-0.2058008313179016,
0.2978758215904236,
0.13865788280963898,
0.35430219769477844,
-0.6601463556289673,
0.08692784607410431,
0.30812308192253113,
0.09650694578886032,
0.3848380446434021,
-0.1604403704404831,
-0.3227338194847107,
-0.05216257646679878,
-0.6691445708274841,
0.2725105285644531,
0.22858424484729767,
-0.3890465497970581,
1.2132006883621216,
0.5310065150260925,
-0.34387853741645813,
-0.30566543340682983,
-0.3238205909729004,
-0.03252080827951431,
-0.288237601518631,
-0.23007036745548248,
0.3524075150489807,
0.4431058168411255,
-0.3582325875759125,
0.1725035458803177,
0.03411881625652313,
0.034210484474897385,
-0.08314871788024902,
0.37612131237983704,
0.4983527362346649,
-0.3740927577018738,
-0.2967240810394287,
0.30931997299194336,
0.005867200903594494,
0.051372554153203964,
0.028147701174020767,
0.44170844554901123,
-0.2977101504802704,
-0.05553499236702919,
-0.5990745425224304,
0.5152493715286255,
0.3907179832458496,
-0.20905949175357819,
0.8858098983764648,
0.32631367444992065,
-0.24203848838806152,
-0.4838857352733612,
-0.3481859564781189,
-0.1330508440732956,
-0.3707549571990967,
0.4903060495853424,
-0.21278534829616547,
-0.7565565705299377,
0.5236746072769165,
-0.1936996728181839,
0.05138983577489853,
0.5475375652313232,
0.44298839569091797,
0.0028644385747611523,
0.3496232330799103,
1.0958888530731201,
-0.5451167821884155,
0.7215623259544373,
-0.34010934829711914,
0.2550773322582245,
-1.0189182758331299,
-0.21017229557037354,
-0.2564225196838379,
-0.29946368932724,
-0.49344587326049805,
-0.27856698632240295,
0.28474485874176025,
0.19474393129348755,
0.3261267840862274,
0.3310723900794983,
-0.11227939277887344,
0.1187770664691925,
0.29488494992256165,
0.3089506924152374,
0.41217440366744995,
-0.07657947391271591,
0.4097507894039154,
0.029184015467762947,
-0.21093985438346863,
-0.34381479024887085,
1.0393567085266113,
0.31564441323280334,
0.6387035250663757,
0.03336379677057266,
0.6536474227905273,
0.4605303406715393,
0.49682876467704773,
-1.1819167137145996,
0.5762516260147095,
-0.5560418963432312,
-0.12032096087932587,
0.26032888889312744,
-0.37299782037734985,
-0.42762258648872375,
0.22233185172080994,
-0.447050541639328,
-0.6421730518341064,
0.19901981949806213,
-0.1494854986667633,
-0.15241165459156036,
0.5558305382728577,
-0.5993735194206238,
0.6015626788139343,
-0.2176460325717926,
-0.36440613865852356,
-0.14282988011837006,
-0.4933612048625946,
0.4598686397075653,
-0.31666797399520874,
0.31546279788017273,
-0.030458468943834305,
0.06224731355905533,
0.8391274809837341,
-0.23919181525707245,
1.257968783378601,
-0.10962430387735367,
-0.06365997344255447,
0.371712863445282,
0.20746466517448425,
0.44424450397491455,
-0.06245652213692665,
0.13768763840198517,
0.5037829279899597,
-0.24144452810287476,
-0.2013358622789383,
-0.5904513001441956,
0.7916976809501648,
-0.7055231332778931,
-0.46214258670806885,
-0.49053075909614563,
-0.4771263897418976,
-0.62241131067276,
-0.09157335758209229,
-0.01385178416967392,
0.2049351930618286,
0.018154487013816833,
-0.21473796665668488,
0.35109302401542664,
-0.134334534406662,
0.39917996525764465,
0.3708759546279907,
-0.3530368208885193,
-0.36943840980529785,
1.0283503532409668,
-0.1565733551979065,
0.2268766462802887,
0.5125849843025208,
0.18564268946647644,
-0.2766597270965576,
-0.8112783432006836,
-0.320902556180954,
0.454345703125,
-0.5262390971183777,
-0.3866603672504425,
-0.46644335985183716,
-0.2517929971218109,
-0.3201950192451477,
-0.16971556842327118,
-0.7081616520881653,
-0.3211100399494171,
-0.24497807025909424,
-0.23249635100364685,
0.7000339031219482,
0.9015015959739685,
0.11948907375335693,
0.3033773899078369,
-0.7600871324539185,
0.30451327562332153,
-0.05450616404414177,
0.0470367856323719,
-0.16885365545749664,
-0.5166963338851929,
-0.044091422110795975,
-0.25770699977874756,
-0.5537722110748291,
-0.8140344023704529,
0.32886046171188354,
0.14655835926532745,
0.2805939018726349,
0.2364261895418167,
0.18111863732337952,
0.1624426692724228,
0.20892180502414703,
1.0869951248168945,
0.3437322676181793,
-1.0155037641525269,
0.7412503361701965,
-0.07447124272584915,
-0.22619275748729706,
0.8139262795448303,
0.3239346146583557,
-0.22654388844966888,
-0.5850787162780762,
-0.5194045305252075,
-1.1391183137893677,
0.6504001617431641,
-0.14002013206481934,
0.21101899445056915,
0.31270915269851685,
0.3770855665206909,
0.7953675389289856,
0.01748768985271454,
-0.9128625392913818,
-0.29817330837249756,
0.0014903771225363016,
-0.5168365240097046,
0.17457450926303864,
0.08499068766832352,
0.07135742902755737,
-0.14745855331420898,
0.9029577374458313,
-0.2852950096130371,
-0.09384459257125854,
0.017003551125526428,
-0.16673295199871063,
0.06124237924814224,
0.45479655265808105,
0.021036848425865173,
0.566740870475769,
-0.049387961626052856,
0.11142667382955551,
0.012015928514301777,
-0.20993146300315857,
0.05337702855467796,
0.26040220260620117,
-0.26704344153404236,
0.004844424314796925,
0.4655613899230957,
0.7837327122688293,
0.06881382316350937,
-0.3524308204650879,
0.7127858996391296,
0.3407083749771118,
-0.043386172503232956,
-0.21814236044883728,
-0.286131888628006,
-0.14019156992435455,
0.191494420170784,
0.2242080122232437,
0.03348289802670479,
0.11881928145885468,
-0.8346872925758362,
0.10309406369924545,
0.37449830770492554,
-0.604793906211853,
-0.8341148495674133,
0.16265328228473663,
0.4933599531650543,
0.038082659244537354,
0.27979087829589844,
-0.08927349746227264,
-0.6267760396003723,
0.3059525787830353,
0.2818182110786438,
1.0637431144714355,
0.15532006323337555,
0.4580564498901367,
-0.034931980073451996,
0.06637707352638245,
-0.06511908024549484,
0.23486009240150452,
0.18653473258018494,
-0.7240393757820129,
-0.6949888467788696,
-0.9808995723724365,
-0.6277804970741272,
0.3135456144809723,
-0.8652034997940063,
0.2635962963104248,
-0.5755990743637085,
-0.024759715422987938,
0.14221152663230896,
-0.1383555382490158,
-0.4304511845111847,
0.031740061938762665,
0.2856357991695404,
0.40910959243774414,
-1.3179692029953003,
0.8034630417823792,
1.1789183616638184,
-0.7980682849884033,
-0.6985597610473633,
0.11465588212013245,
-0.0888480395078659,
-0.596519947052002,
0.3011631667613983,
0.17919401824474335,
-0.07491253316402435,
-0.5382673144340515,
-0.20459909737110138,
-0.2434651404619217,
0.6174083948135376,
0.09651214629411697,
-0.3798636794090271,
0.23196224868297577,
0.18529172241687775,
0.6827412247657776,
-0.4411368668079376,
-0.11593465507030487,
0.48138758540153503,
0.07645312696695328,
-0.042379677295684814,
-0.8728128671646118,
0.1445818990468979,
0.02043597586452961,
-0.10939764976501465,
0.5331294536590576,
-0.8092893362045288,
0.6752790212631226,
0.14354656636714935,
0.0769718661904335,
-0.00165564997587353,
1.2380807399749756,
-0.07109030336141586,
0.4360392391681671,
0.5630460977554321,
0.4894586503505707,
0.14674708247184753,
0.03388459235429764,
0.8566145300865173,
-0.2221984714269638,
0.5580522418022156,
0.9172704219818115,
-0.5027928352355957,
1.1241096258163452,
0.7752320766448975,
-0.4405297636985779,
0.8076953291893005,
0.5307533740997314,
0.33089426159858704,
0.5399230122566223,
-0.26252827048301697,
-0.4934031665325165,
-0.21225766837596893,
-0.5278937816619873,
-0.07474050670862198,
0.41902875900268555,
0.38703855872154236,
-0.5303260087966919,
-0.29512885212898254,
0.286954402923584,
-0.030661433935165405,
0.2417496144771576,
-0.5129265189170837,
1.1532098054885864,
0.4386984407901764,
-0.45753708481788635,
-0.27643802762031555,
-0.005986329168081284,
1.104043960571289,
-0.6830407381057739,
-0.039234478026628494,
-0.5956202745437622,
0.08452865481376648,
-0.39774268865585327,
-1.1244570016860962,
0.5846625566482544,
-0.12350104004144669,
-0.11242341995239258,
-0.07479973882436752,
0.6500319242477417,
-0.27424606680870056,
-0.8519565463066101,
0.37781375646591187,
0.6846158504486084,
-0.06663668155670166,
-0.11262629926204681,
-0.660506546497345,
-0.19834603369235992,
0.10228355973958969,
-0.2773100733757019,
0.6754922866821289,
0.5765771269798279,
-0.21241451799869537,
0.1765538603067398,
0.48783549666404724,
0.48098814487457275,
-0.4429076611995697,
0.04067160189151764,
1.0382397174835205,
-0.8086604475975037,
-0.6882069110870361,
-0.7269311547279358,
0.17706158757209778,
0.1701975017786026,
-0.4459769129753113,
0.4497152864933014,
0.5382351279258728,
0.5922456383705139,
0.12797564268112183,
1.0283271074295044,
-0.28311875462532043,
0.5528295636177063,
-0.7892900705337524,
0.18117548525333405,
-0.4882439076900482,
0.31474950909614563,
-0.2160148024559021,
-1.174682378768921,
-0.1420975625514984,
0.21808719635009766,
-0.6383081674575806,
-0.11039766669273376,
0.7818732261657715,
0.5624867677688599,
-0.25573596358299255,
0.3176589012145996,
-0.10125508159399033,
0.0484670028090477,
0.19780468940734863,
0.5624611377716064,
0.9219256043434143,
-0.08174784481525421,
0.19902171194553375,
-0.913591206073761,
-0.2620052695274353,
0.012589642778038979,
-0.7953686118125916,
-0.7899025082588196,
-0.5592848062515259,
-0.6155729293823242,
-0.4705430865287781,
-0.1572697013616562,
0.9670133590698242,
0.38504403829574585,
-0.9656884670257568,
0.019376209005713463,
0.09464777261018753,
0.03290042653679848,
-0.37718984484672546,
-0.4066740572452545,
0.7000676393508911,
-0.19629216194152832,
-0.5199918746948242,
0.2136395275592804,
0.35458534955978394,
-0.0663905143737793,
-0.5987184047698975,
0.4229813814163208,
-0.16843342781066895,
-0.18371962010860443,
0.6038822531700134,
0.32414481043815613,
-0.5688014030456543,
-0.48061835765838623,
-0.5684594511985779,
0.13346311450004578,
0.3807084560394287,
0.9893407225608826,
-0.6271942853927612,
0.08505615592002869,
0.3463689982891083,
0.7121601700782776,
0.27883702516555786,
0.2858866751194,
0.5028501152992249,
-0.7757167816162109,
0.23194372653961182,
0.2784894108772278,
0.44718822836875916,
0.695919930934906,
-0.5338395833969116,
0.10951140522956848,
0.5156487822532654,
0.03911251947283745,
-0.2974129021167755,
0.19994357228279114,
-1.5496082305908203,
-0.38571715354919434,
1.381307601928711,
-0.29265931248664856,
-0.470470130443573,
-0.1548708826303482,
-0.16300912201404572,
0.014201597310602665,
-0.5305945873260498,
0.6847749948501587,
0.47420573234558105,
-0.5955410599708557,
-0.10827676951885223,
-0.06732910126447678,
0.06557419151067734,
0.4400637447834015,
-1.1867531538009644,
0.11152449250221252,
0.42982035875320435,
0.26894885301589966,
0.27588316798210144,
0.29687848687171936,
-0.13083738088607788,
-0.1766785979270935,
-0.2254403978586197,
0.3226223289966583,
-0.056537069380283356,
-0.19065658748149872,
-0.5127914547920227,
0.3929137587547302,
0.02548407018184662,
-0.35199594497680664
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17246v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17246v1
|
TwoStep: Multi-agent Task Planning using Classical Planners and Large Language Models
| 2024-03-25T22:47:13 | 2024-03-25T22:47:13 |
Ishika Singh, David Traum, Jesse Thomason
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MA, cs.RO
|
Classical planning formulations like the Planning Domain Definition Language
(PDDL) admit action sequences guaranteed to achieve a goal state given an
initial state if any are possible. However, reasoning problems defined in PDDL
do not capture temporal aspects of action taking, for example that two agents
in the domain can execute an action simultaneously if postconditions of each do
not interfere with preconditions of the other. A human expert can decompose a
goal into largely independent constituent parts and assign each agent to one of
these subgoals to take advantage of simultaneous actions for faster execution
of plan steps, each using only single agent planning. By contrast, large
language models (LLMs) used for directly inferring plan steps do not guarantee
execution success, but do leverage commonsense reasoning to assemble action
sequences. We combine the strengths of classical planning and LLMs by
approximating human intuitions for two-agent planning goal decomposition. We
demonstrate that LLM-based goal decomposition leads to faster planning times
than solving multi-agent PDDL problems directly while simultaneously achieving
fewer plan execution steps than a single agent plan alone and preserving
execution success. Additionally, we find that LLM-based approximations of
subgoals can achieve similar multi-agent execution steps than those specified
by human experts. Website and resources at https://glamor-usc.github.io/twostep
|
[
-0.3699466288089752,
-0.6721917390823364,
0.8556473255157471,
0.23379983007907867,
-0.019636601209640503,
0.11657794564962387,
-0.28718098998069763,
-0.321957528591156,
0.10086440294981003,
0.6572288274765015,
-0.8508094549179077,
-0.26860836148262024,
-0.3761187493801117,
-0.3573914170265198,
0.0827377438545227,
0.561265230178833,
-0.08345451951026917,
0.007964720018208027,
-0.038399383425712585,
0.05977776646614075,
-0.22598235309123993,
-0.25145483016967773,
-0.9202209115028381,
-0.6565393805503845,
0.43455326557159424,
0.4877443313598633,
0.7317211031913757,
0.48542559146881104,
0.42642566561698914,
0.21687202155590057,
0.05391791835427284,
0.4497627317905426,
-0.4029074013233185,
0.22275197505950928,
-0.3365960717201233,
-0.18641142547130585,
-0.8286526799201965,
-0.12991119921207428,
0.3263167440891266,
0.6047186255455017,
-0.26497313380241394,
0.06932973861694336,
-0.15352226793766022,
0.6377661824226379,
-0.80159592628479,
0.4690598249435425,
-0.3588257133960724,
-0.030151626095175743,
0.25385338068008423,
-0.2268642634153366,
-0.3557778298854828,
0.19459617137908936,
0.20796707272529602,
-0.45283570885658264,
0.06043969839811325,
-0.24984082579612732,
0.2601528763771057,
0.355849951505661,
-0.4122709631919861,
-0.3058750331401825,
-0.8703870177268982,
0.7918764352798462,
-0.5143862962722778,
0.12341249734163284,
0.40870508551597595,
0.34753745794296265,
-0.4541473388671875,
-0.5635263323783875,
-0.5649321675300598,
-0.021212678402662277,
0.034764476120471954,
-0.12809856235980988,
-0.009883991442620754,
0.24485518038272858,
0.3686293661594391,
-0.38135847449302673,
-0.736788272857666,
0.17017725110054016,
-0.3134396970272064,
0.006483445409685373,
0.8526784181594849,
0.37123367190361023,
-0.007694583386182785,
0.12539860606193542,
-0.7956053018569946,
0.00551157770678401,
-0.6612147092819214,
0.12806066870689392,
0.11166747659444809,
0.31927818059921265,
0.06487412005662918,
0.5346806049346924,
-0.2010098695755005,
0.4356496036052704,
-0.07373789697885513,
-0.38887134194374084,
-0.39560309052467346,
-0.3606182634830475,
-0.1680920422077179,
-0.3210415542125702,
0.4615385830402374,
0.5231612324714661,
0.4131357669830322,
-0.3671095669269562,
-0.3854157030582428,
0.22827893495559692,
0.15326397120952606,
-0.6022963523864746,
-0.1980283558368683,
0.3983898460865021,
-0.2823503315448761,
0.29787296056747437,
-0.26203781366348267,
-0.6022613644599915,
-0.4516719877719879,
-0.5836423635482788,
0.26187360286712646,
-0.2855338454246521,
-0.36874639987945557,
0.12841084599494934,
-0.14055633544921875,
0.4556710124015808,
0.6298913359642029,
-0.7031749486923218,
0.8186401724815369,
1.1013662815093994,
0.6272756457328796,
0.11615056544542313,
-0.7826725244522095,
-0.6424881219863892,
0.3578457534313202,
-0.6081111431121826,
0.9078119397163391,
-0.34491032361984253,
-0.3294667899608612,
0.008330171927809715,
-0.3616299331188202,
-0.10230139642953873,
-0.12693345546722412,
0.28185439109802246,
-0.5832161903381348,
-0.20063228905200958,
-0.7244406342506409,
-0.37369051575660706,
-0.4008444845676422,
0.3272974193096161,
-0.40854066610336304,
0.744778037071228,
-0.045210469514131546,
-0.34707334637641907,
0.5245935916900635,
-0.8770862817764282,
-0.6379908919334412,
-0.09393458068370819,
-0.07847686856985092,
0.10170752555131912,
-0.15066659450531006,
0.010349662974476814,
0.7509698867797852,
-0.6111409068107605,
0.3083239197731018,
-0.2696160078048706,
-0.062476638704538345,
-0.1459784209728241,
0.09049004316329956,
0.79615718126297,
0.20913061499595642,
-0.42331188917160034,
0.2819790244102478,
-0.04571903496980667,
0.12817049026489258,
0.024159464985132217,
-0.23512516915798187,
-0.0476723276078701,
0.4856615960597992,
0.11931798607110977,
0.6112580895423889,
0.33194470405578613,
-0.1587008237838745,
0.5112394690513611,
-0.3237397074699402,
0.33491629362106323,
0.6700941920280457,
-0.10752134025096893,
0.7814441919326782,
-0.6054350137710571,
0.5112971067428589,
-0.4502161145210266,
0.0377105176448822,
0.10536354780197144,
-0.5051683187484741,
-0.583434522151947,
-0.01997224986553192,
-0.2443164885044098,
0.6595216393470764,
-0.7524945139884949,
0.1832587718963623,
-0.24186784029006958,
-0.46411746740341187,
-0.03347373008728027,
0.008381077088415623,
0.6049753427505493,
0.050761058926582336,
0.3403100073337555,
-0.38862401247024536,
-0.28959086537361145,
-0.6621057987213135,
-0.14854320883750916,
-0.3239556550979614,
0.17574839293956757,
-0.11567302793264389,
0.6868040561676025,
0.20896880328655243,
0.8308572173118591,
-0.5262194275856018,
-0.40382903814315796,
-0.7060723304748535,
0.30815157294273376,
-0.1315256804227829,
0.2509334981441498,
0.574557363986969,
-0.861693799495697,
-0.45095282793045044,
-0.1948668658733368,
-0.507764995098114,
0.22102904319763184,
-0.2586102783679962,
-0.08476583659648895,
0.16905716061592102,
0.22137412428855896,
-0.872739851474762,
0.43368685245513916,
0.19562368094921112,
-0.44525668025016785,
0.7786800861358643,
-0.4402235448360443,
0.03675343096256256,
-0.9296917915344238,
0.024067837744951248,
0.09385810792446136,
-0.21778526902198792,
-0.9844270348548889,
0.4538908004760742,
0.02383565530180931,
-0.022359009832143784,
-0.47005799412727356,
0.7916485667228699,
-0.7679072022438049,
-0.6650320887565613,
-0.5747383236885071,
-0.10025955736637115,
-0.29950207471847534,
0.8892508149147034,
0.29614782333374023,
0.6433083415031433,
0.4752572178840637,
-0.7297419905662537,
0.3769873380661011,
0.14725054800510406,
-0.003887318540364504,
0.48757636547088623,
-0.6186970472335815,
0.2246009260416031,
-0.22953999042510986,
0.4495933949947357,
-0.6809987425804138,
-0.3460746109485626,
0.3682814836502075,
-0.18466833233833313,
0.4506351053714752,
-0.22088740766048431,
-0.5482303500175476,
-0.3351514935493469,
-0.4277589023113251,
0.2582551836967468,
0.39990875124931335,
-0.1776539832353592,
0.5524258613586426,
0.5223742127418518,
-0.23054635524749756,
-0.6484230160713196,
-0.7915350794792175,
0.12675847113132477,
0.02409019134938717,
-0.6143384575843811,
0.2550068497657776,
-0.019776033237576485,
-0.5869585871696472,
0.05713854357600212,
-0.1177971214056015,
-0.3163563907146454,
-0.007866681553423405,
0.34846925735473633,
0.05222389101982117,
0.24037247896194458,
-0.06474938243627548,
0.02240719646215439,
-0.3924577534198761,
0.08875155448913574,
-0.22391469776630402,
0.601142942905426,
0.2747472822666168,
-0.44698667526245117,
-0.50456303358078,
0.7701480984687805,
0.9732255339622498,
-0.4616418480873108,
0.5836771726608276,
0.3972882032394409,
-0.5429508090019226,
-0.28844407200813293,
-0.4852945804595947,
-0.1519513875246048,
-0.32452571392059326,
0.15416018664836884,
-0.6543595194816589,
-0.35971954464912415,
0.19461442530155182,
-0.2669876217842102,
0.6624683737754822,
0.23778383433818817,
0.6769537329673767,
0.07421920448541641,
0.8704858422279358,
0.5362410545349121,
0.18693441152572632,
0.08650588989257812,
-0.5710989236831665,
0.04149894416332245,
-0.7835040092468262,
-0.2853426933288574,
-0.501228392124176,
-0.4355316758155823,
-0.07031667232513428,
-0.9075589776039124,
0.31265896558761597,
0.0008061876287683845,
-0.11985058337450027,
0.5246656537055969,
-0.2892518937587738,
0.36056599020957947,
0.6057796478271484,
-0.08014694601297379,
0.2231910228729248,
-0.0921139344573021,
0.1765189915895462,
0.16090081632137299,
-0.649309515953064,
-0.7134315371513367,
1.0008752346038818,
0.08441823720932007,
0.5907013416290283,
0.1751767098903656,
0.7438814043998718,
0.3829305171966553,
-0.20360097289085388,
-0.8592426776885986,
0.848908007144928,
-0.059673208743333817,
-0.7517297863960266,
-0.5846128463745117,
-0.1342906802892685,
-0.8630733489990234,
0.3604206442832947,
-0.1978122740983963,
-1.0112208127975464,
0.3256624937057495,
0.0032984649296849966,
-0.28231003880500793,
0.32942861318588257,
-0.6191350221633911,
0.8269636034965515,
-0.16145949065685272,
-0.35796058177948,
-0.8997728228569031,
-0.8116552829742432,
0.3218671977519989,
0.13055634498596191,
0.2779863476753235,
-0.6725523471832275,
-0.30842357873916626,
0.8127090334892273,
-0.5160104632377625,
0.7254208922386169,
-0.345598429441452,
0.1067017987370491,
0.34179043769836426,
0.17612114548683167,
0.872806191444397,
-0.18041951954364777,
-0.1226077526807785,
-0.39704376459121704,
-0.04171838238835335,
-0.8281653523445129,
-0.45600420236587524,
0.7081842422485352,
-0.5218738913536072,
-0.5906897783279419,
-0.36906254291534424,
-0.7232192158699036,
-0.07486721128225327,
0.024639751762151718,
-0.058619000017642975,
0.6225772500038147,
-0.2462567836046219,
-0.5058649778366089,
0.2264348417520523,
0.2671110928058624,
1.0027964115142822,
0.5326706767082214,
0.05433373153209686,
-0.11745122820138931,
0.34869036078453064,
0.18853968381881714,
0.43275681138038635,
0.5302866101264954,
-0.1338733434677124,
-0.4780820906162262,
-0.6844034790992737,
-0.23660022020339966,
0.28133484721183777,
-0.6796271204948425,
0.09345386177301407,
-0.5563102960586548,
0.18366993963718414,
-0.43925583362579346,
-0.4760502576828003,
-0.4899810254573822,
-0.5610044598579407,
0.11174314469099045,
0.33327436447143555,
-0.045271679759025574,
0.8707637786865234,
-0.40468448400497437,
0.09716172516345978,
-0.39278730750083923,
0.5880614519119263,
0.5230060815811157,
-0.2843233644962311,
-0.03974492847919464,
0.11369584500789642,
-0.032118719071149826,
0.07186314463615417,
-0.28754034638404846,
-1.0320968627929688,
0.4004814028739929,
0.15333008766174316,
0.5400642156600952,
0.4559924304485321,
0.3460421562194824,
0.6082725524902344,
-0.4044967293739319,
0.5366680026054382,
0.2691098749637604,
-0.6975070238113403,
0.5461176633834839,
-0.285282164812088,
0.3482697010040283,
0.3357210159301758,
0.4764038622379303,
-0.3873998522758484,
-0.08874540776014328,
-0.4547833800315857,
-0.5361722707748413,
0.9056352376937866,
0.025818729773163795,
-0.3363242745399475,
0.21669046580791473,
0.1262671947479248,
0.05047444626688957,
0.11841296404600143,
-0.2745656371116638,
-0.31345540285110474,
0.31621837615966797,
0.3822822570800781,
-0.40868258476257324,
-0.5212870836257935,
-0.418891966342926,
0.0563628226518631,
0.5323076844215393,
-0.19247013330459595,
0.4165321886539459,
0.09647612273693085,
-0.15706565976142883,
-0.32502445578575134,
0.5716865658760071,
0.9180735945701599,
1.1600725650787354,
0.058236557990312576,
0.34978824853897095,
0.13860879838466644,
-0.09142641723155975,
0.37189576029777527,
0.2706267535686493,
0.021872080862522125,
-0.44942525029182434,
0.7024371027946472,
0.3098917603492737,
0.2239096760749817,
-0.5859161615371704,
0.32926759123802185,
0.03643948212265968,
-0.3312323987483978,
-0.23401424288749695,
0.014245135709643364,
0.13147349655628204,
0.7506468892097473,
0.49962666630744934,
0.291402131319046,
0.03247067704796791,
-0.683855414390564,
-0.004500583279877901,
0.30429747700691223,
-0.16446563601493835,
-0.47975659370422363,
0.5243386030197144,
0.24442191421985626,
-0.5575196146965027,
0.21431097388267517,
-0.7286961674690247,
-0.506864070892334,
0.7393481731414795,
0.49024698138237,
1.0194224119186401,
-0.2652955949306488,
0.459134042263031,
0.13441120088100433,
0.45147883892059326,
-0.3553689420223236,
0.6960545182228088,
0.005571678280830383,
-0.6351374387741089,
-0.814700722694397,
-0.489047110080719,
-0.2867974042892456,
-0.26864373683929443,
-0.33183297514915466,
0.011831758543848991,
-0.5420941114425659,
-0.10026098042726517,
0.045712169259786606,
0.34780821204185486,
-0.7494349479675293,
-0.06589176505804062,
-0.1777651607990265,
0.7734702825546265,
-0.7081736326217651,
0.8102405071258545,
1.2013945579528809,
-0.190333753824234,
-0.9012712240219116,
0.03433725982904434,
0.33094578981399536,
-0.7173594832420349,
0.5299768447875977,
-0.08412281423807144,
-0.1415962129831314,
-0.04891512542963028,
-0.0325191468000412,
-0.6206476092338562,
1.140774130821228,
0.29752156138420105,
-0.5046632289886475,
-0.4589884579181671,
-0.0973971039056778,
0.2212458848953247,
-0.20412227511405945,
0.0010442062048241496,
0.6294703483581543,
0.7812489867210388,
0.3911290764808655,
-1.1858528852462769,
0.22885499894618988,
0.22182311117649078,
-0.28470465540885925,
0.6628941893577576,
-0.3497844338417053,
0.9459421038627625,
-0.7284724712371826,
-0.22729896008968353,
0.12700995802879333,
0.42830848693847656,
0.0907062292098999,
0.6635419130325317,
0.5706814527511597,
0.642021119594574,
0.5072365403175354,
0.024253400042653084,
0.9641371369361877,
-0.14098140597343445,
0.4766143560409546,
0.9897477030754089,
-0.39854568243026733,
0.7970651984214783,
0.33678683638572693,
-0.4332459270954132,
0.09932122379541397,
0.36453720927238464,
0.5432009696960449,
0.6699387431144714,
-0.08129843324422836,
-0.37650105357170105,
-0.5667489767074585,
-0.1488211452960968,
-0.1101008951663971,
0.6486005783081055,
0.3774859309196472,
0.173059344291687,
-0.5991768836975098,
-0.15278565883636475,
0.3036830425262451,
0.10282628983259201,
-0.40119636058807373,
0.6320028901100159,
0.01168129313737154,
-1.101207971572876,
0.3416453003883362,
0.1509031355381012,
0.19968795776367188,
-0.37902531027793884,
0.04309825226664543,
0.10803752392530441,
0.24774174392223358,
-0.0959763303399086,
-0.8565886616706848,
0.27825918793678284,
-0.25672638416290283,
-0.1385367214679718,
-0.43475762009620667,
0.9038981199264526,
-0.4423326253890991,
-0.07504605501890182,
0.3030705749988556,
0.8318760991096497,
0.11160394549369812,
-0.15656891465187073,
-0.7401540279388428,
-0.43249791860580444,
-0.31135258078575134,
-0.17835991084575653,
0.20862963795661926,
0.1845182329416275,
-0.11762867122888565,
0.8311812877655029,
0.38878875970840454,
0.12119352072477341,
-0.16769608855247498,
-0.364592581987381,
0.7805478572845459,
-0.6145006418228149,
-0.4738472104072571,
-0.8095714449882507,
0.48045048117637634,
0.0303343515843153,
-0.11035994440317154,
0.2777148187160492,
0.38864877820014954,
0.6145517230033875,
-0.01977098360657692,
0.5406448841094971,
-0.15648812055587769,
0.2651781439781189,
-0.5667370557785034,
0.30105212330818176,
-0.51971036195755,
0.1777021586894989,
-0.14725276827812195,
-0.8901136517524719,
-0.17796140909194946,
0.36090028285980225,
-0.474117249250412,
-0.11139488220214844,
0.8126370310783386,
0.762391209602356,
0.10402747988700867,
-0.34987765550613403,
0.42166000604629517,
-0.32184898853302,
0.328654408454895,
1.0320050716400146,
0.8264743089675903,
0.13672614097595215,
0.318167120218277,
-0.28732526302337646,
-0.32268011569976807,
-0.28360486030578613,
-0.5693560838699341,
-1.1356838941574097,
-0.7224305272102356,
-0.13733141124248505,
0.20627743005752563,
0.4363792836666107,
1.2733659744262695,
0.9826613068580627,
-0.4240694046020508,
-0.5390384197235107,
-0.09867588430643082,
0.28120937943458557,
-0.5679817199707031,
-0.12794476747512817,
0.33957210183143616,
-0.36010512709617615,
-0.5855848789215088,
0.7292547821998596,
0.4163261950016022,
-0.19686934351921082,
-0.4065936207771301,
-0.5208683609962463,
-0.4793480932712555,
-0.03089740313589573,
0.5797217488288879,
0.5994546413421631,
-1.064247727394104,
-0.07035864144563675,
-0.11486627161502838,
-0.08717238157987595,
-0.36201441287994385,
1.1353087425231934,
-0.6039448976516724,
0.3409270644187927,
0.5569497346878052,
0.22607047855854034,
0.7063742280006409,
-0.12227518111467361,
0.6002031564712524,
-0.5718196630477905,
0.29270660877227783,
0.25241801142692566,
0.287162721157074,
-0.23937253654003143,
-0.026197999715805054,
0.7243446707725525,
0.06687528640031815,
-0.6919203996658325,
-0.4570838510990143,
0.5610684752464294,
-1.0432608127593994,
-0.5920991897583008,
1.1698706150054932,
-0.20000696182250977,
-0.0017614428652450442,
-0.2919846475124359,
-0.30690765380859375,
0.30078279972076416,
-0.5820032358169556,
0.4498042166233063,
0.3827272951602936,
-0.47159913182258606,
-0.1611243337392807,
-0.4492155611515045,
0.5957812666893005,
0.19337214529514313,
-0.8590599298477173,
0.13256315886974335,
0.7297247648239136,
-0.09668624401092529,
0.22443635761737823,
1.083472490310669,
0.5293936729431152,
0.6585087776184082,
0.19718331098556519,
0.08144409209489822,
-0.20937715470790863,
-0.784256637096405,
0.1402536779642105,
0.4821218252182007,
0.3333103656768799,
-0.14271114766597748
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17245v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17245v1
|
SPLICE: A Singleton-Enhanced PipeLIne for Coreference REsolution
| 2024-03-25T22:46:16 | 2024-03-25T22:46:16 |
Yilun Zhu, Siyao Peng, Sameer Pradhan, Amir Zeldes
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Singleton mentions, i.e.~entities mentioned only once in a text, are
important to how humans understand discourse from a theoretical perspective.
However previous attempts to incorporate their detection in end-to-end neural
coreference resolution for English have been hampered by the lack of singleton
mention spans in the OntoNotes benchmark. This paper addresses this limitation
by combining predicted mentions from existing nested NER systems and features
derived from OntoNotes syntax trees. With this approach, we create a near
approximation of the OntoNotes dataset with all singleton mentions, achieving
~94% recall on a sample of gold singletons. We then propose a two-step neural
mention and coreference resolution system, named SPLICE, and compare its
performance to the end-to-end approach in two scenarios: the OntoNotes test set
and the out-of-domain (OOD) OntoGUM corpus. Results indicate that reconstructed
singleton training yields results comparable to end-to-end systems for
OntoNotes, while improving OOD stability (+1.1 avg. F1). We conduct error
analysis for mention detection and delve into its impact on coreference
clustering, revealing that precision improvements deliver more substantial
benefits than increases in recall for resolving coreference chains.
|
[
-0.5390239357948303,
-0.6385979056358337,
0.394207626581192,
-0.11241356283426285,
-0.5108798146247864,
0.02159534953534603,
-0.7538132667541504,
-0.6170275211334229,
0.5925012230873108,
0.45194268226623535,
-0.21328887343406677,
-0.31245630979537964,
-0.772659182548523,
0.3914473354816437,
-0.4695434868335724,
1.277733564376831,
0.36719098687171936,
-0.3611806631088257,
-0.45115983486175537,
-0.2872588634490967,
-0.15619073808193207,
-0.6648275256156921,
-0.5689526796340942,
-0.2550033628940582,
0.7190720438957214,
0.671608030796051,
0.17791885137557983,
0.6977124214172363,
0.4475288987159729,
0.29017502069473267,
-0.5019639134407043,
0.5334987640380859,
-0.16613776981830597,
0.11654330790042877,
-0.3129315972328186,
-0.4074613153934479,
-0.7164692282676697,
-0.13765789568424225,
0.6010051965713501,
0.6539875268936157,
0.2593478858470917,
0.1577286571264267,
0.004783061798661947,
0.34206974506378174,
-0.5332794189453125,
-0.08771958202123642,
-0.8524211049079895,
-0.021469194442033768,
-0.29634904861450195,
-0.19410297274589539,
-0.40738585591316223,
-0.2750813663005829,
0.5069246888160706,
-0.4414544403553009,
0.38607314229011536,
0.03231881186366081,
1.0316416025161743,
0.09121078997850418,
-0.18191289901733398,
-0.4244122803211212,
-0.3236751854419708,
0.7029415965080261,
-0.755102276802063,
-0.2613648772239685,
0.28912121057510376,
0.015845952555537224,
0.29881057143211365,
-0.8224940299987793,
-0.33057329058647156,
-0.3790953755378723,
-0.5449848771095276,
0.09450898319482803,
-0.0014347904361784458,
0.07642728835344315,
0.1347978413105011,
0.5132095217704773,
-0.18591426312923431,
-0.06298601627349854,
-0.5241795182228088,
-0.07121120393276215,
0.44265246391296387,
-0.35116446018218994,
0.04106550291180611,
-0.3530593514442444,
-0.33333149552345276,
0.5024968385696411,
-0.5452836155891418,
-0.2196701318025589,
-0.12441829591989517,
0.5240542888641357,
0.44667309522628784,
0.2520616948604584,
0.43364155292510986,
0.4382004141807556,
0.6754294633865356,
-0.21015356481075287,
0.0974821075797081,
-0.3424763083457947,
0.06888176500797272,
0.4968020021915436,
0.46289771795272827,
0.4026789367198944,
0.3657841384410858,
-0.5044874548912048,
0.12036546319723129,
0.272814005613327,
0.3422136604785919,
-0.4698498547077179,
-0.1398165374994278,
0.155526801943779,
-0.04522328823804855,
0.015144599601626396,
-0.11090340465307236,
-0.3101515471935272,
-0.34978199005126953,
-0.1576073318719864,
0.2543703317642212,
-0.5550608038902283,
-0.24184513092041016,
0.013815735466778278,
-0.3373173773288727,
-0.26796409487724304,
0.33146804571151733,
-0.7144533395767212,
0.6129875779151917,
0.6817797422409058,
0.8495963215827942,
-0.18453174829483032,
-0.5755723118782043,
-0.2633499205112457,
0.1666327714920044,
-0.10882232338190079,
1.3787809610366821,
-0.10129647701978683,
-0.42758849263191223,
-0.36606693267822266,
-0.1489267796278,
-0.22654840350151062,
-0.7108263969421387,
0.49468591809272766,
0.1294609010219574,
-0.008932354860007763,
-0.15430064499378204,
-0.7559991478919983,
-0.2632449269294739,
0.4975132346153259,
-0.5869350433349609,
1.0477678775787354,
-0.18071769177913666,
-0.872780442237854,
0.22914542257785797,
-0.33813759684562683,
-0.3903822898864746,
0.1370769590139389,
-0.3191725015640259,
-0.29115912318229675,
0.2082415223121643,
0.12405406683683395,
0.6428040862083435,
-0.4071386754512787,
0.4112470746040344,
0.1858556568622589,
-0.3070801794528961,
0.14919255673885345,
0.21991440653800964,
0.37477147579193115,
-0.37396863102912903,
-0.29069983959198,
0.1753440499305725,
-0.7149832844734192,
-0.22042034566402435,
-0.2160693258047104,
0.019346747547388077,
-0.6527628302574158,
-0.23173145949840546,
-0.16276495158672333,
0.09458166360855103,
0.2277221381664276,
-0.8954073190689087,
0.15057151019573212,
-0.3155578374862671,
0.4341283142566681,
0.5282160639762878,
0.1664024293422699,
0.6225257515907288,
-0.26401567459106445,
0.0850057527422905,
0.2590870261192322,
-0.09061584621667862,
-0.6716328859329224,
-0.5065965056419373,
-0.8711712956428528,
-0.2690376341342926,
0.1446920782327652,
0.307701975107193,
-0.1366633027791977,
0.6667476892471313,
-0.5363372564315796,
-0.4957747459411621,
-0.26898714900016785,
-0.01593097485601902,
0.8299431204795837,
0.49175789952278137,
0.4587608277797699,
-0.5308829545974731,
-0.9895631074905396,
-0.8655921816825867,
-0.32805752754211426,
-0.29178228974342346,
0.1340591162443161,
0.5242703557014465,
0.611527144908905,
0.19245892763137817,
1.292551875114441,
-0.4159156382083893,
-0.6085811257362366,
-0.21250896155834198,
0.1249762773513794,
0.30147767066955566,
0.46647343039512634,
0.4621677100658417,
-0.6069055199623108,
-0.4534139633178711,
0.2707342207431793,
-0.6780064702033997,
0.14091402292251587,
-0.16865772008895874,
0.11923696100711823,
-0.07022515684366226,
0.6174607276916504,
-0.5204786062240601,
0.30447840690612793,
0.17143875360488892,
-0.37946242094039917,
0.8004288077354431,
-0.16206541657447815,
-0.15587647259235382,
-1.0918645858764648,
0.23001064360141754,
0.08172916620969772,
-0.3541070222854614,
-0.4685014486312866,
-0.20813661813735962,
0.1196582168340683,
0.2854403853416443,
-0.23535557091236115,
0.38636311888694763,
-0.667625904083252,
-0.06990350782871246,
-0.22745998203754425,
0.5451774001121521,
0.05254523083567619,
0.466776967048645,
0.16656243801116943,
0.7337520122528076,
0.2914571762084961,
-0.6121612191200256,
0.21077607572078705,
0.42989933490753174,
-0.2673496603965759,
0.8595193028450012,
-0.4758991301059723,
0.37068578600883484,
-0.2049708217382431,
0.37206366658210754,
-0.8018761873245239,
0.17852197587490082,
-0.27161967754364014,
-0.7407065629959106,
0.3221668601036072,
-0.1000761166214943,
-0.24389104545116425,
-0.10918695479631424,
-0.21454283595085144,
0.18497203290462494,
0.08158652484416962,
-0.5099910497665405,
0.6922938227653503,
0.655556321144104,
-0.21114186942577362,
-0.423094779253006,
-0.9549068212509155,
0.37002742290496826,
-0.21165890991687775,
-0.3598058819770813,
0.7346618175506592,
0.09155885130167007,
-0.043376412242650986,
0.08305974304676056,
-0.3699905276298523,
-0.24005599319934845,
-0.12640634179115295,
0.38732969760894775,
0.2318667620420456,
-0.26407212018966675,
0.22048825025558472,
-0.17671896517276764,
-0.4436560869216919,
-0.07613380998373032,
-0.5830439925193787,
-0.016460830345749855,
-0.37011438608169556,
0.32310131192207336,
-0.11337390542030334,
0.46107017993927,
0.40101590752601624,
-0.20429328083992004,
0.4864458739757538,
0.19200536608695984,
-0.4938940703868866,
-0.15620030462741852,
-0.7722555994987488,
-0.29263636469841003,
-0.39332324266433716,
0.24231895804405212,
-0.41635918617248535,
-1.042114496231079,
0.4711790978908539,
-0.3530820310115814,
0.3898342251777649,
0.27699869871139526,
0.10191096365451813,
-0.1970432847738266,
0.11562635749578476,
0.40128594636917114,
0.19394628703594208,
0.1367068737745285,
-0.30436667799949646,
0.3664166331291199,
-1.2495197057724,
-0.1424388736486435,
-0.6409003138542175,
-0.16621339321136475,
-0.026420574635267258,
-0.5863421559333801,
0.18551285564899445,
0.3153187930583954,
0.06972844898700714,
0.8875504732131958,
-0.6409353017807007,
0.5643661618232727,
0.34095266461372375,
0.12546783685684204,
0.555855393409729,
0.012783732265233994,
-0.3507329523563385,
-0.22358310222625732,
-0.738612711429596,
-0.4205362796783447,
0.6184738874435425,
0.010389790870249271,
0.013002034276723862,
-0.10280495136976242,
0.6685156226158142,
0.20571719110012054,
0.5124941468238831,
-0.8743544220924377,
0.8500365018844604,
-0.48883673548698425,
-0.7162945866584778,
-0.13435214757919312,
-0.17280586063861847,
-0.6204621195793152,
0.15699473023414612,
0.14276811480522156,
-1.0376865863800049,
0.2709360718727112,
0.1668853610754013,
-0.6880974173545837,
0.5019131302833557,
-0.36825472116470337,
0.39908692240715027,
0.15693967044353485,
-0.224762961268425,
-0.05137995630502701,
-0.7013520002365112,
0.23723486065864563,
0.11092327535152435,
0.10705789923667908,
-0.22051146626472473,
0.020102720707654953,
0.8344568610191345,
-0.36820822954177856,
0.9459966421127319,
0.23631080985069275,
0.08227110654115677,
0.46572476625442505,
-0.12057682126760483,
0.20766973495483398,
-0.0428902842104435,
-0.04347195103764534,
0.3012603223323822,
-0.2048729956150055,
-0.15979978442192078,
-0.5353691577911377,
0.8526928424835205,
-0.46766597032546997,
-0.31614676117897034,
-0.48001787066459656,
-0.43536269664764404,
0.06861107796430588,
0.01106053963303566,
0.5033850073814392,
0.563907265663147,
-0.13985367119312286,
0.18782657384872437,
0.5981593132019043,
0.25502505898475647,
0.4314226508140564,
0.2771417796611786,
-0.0961887463927269,
-0.7221181392669678,
0.5149979591369629,
0.5258641839027405,
0.03524637222290039,
0.12017562240362167,
0.1414211392402649,
-0.15862564742565155,
-0.263739675283432,
-0.46977704763412476,
0.5562582015991211,
-0.8054053783416748,
-0.36734986305236816,
-0.8813194632530212,
-0.13125532865524292,
-0.37728971242904663,
-0.4795507788658142,
-0.7069185972213745,
-0.7354747653007507,
-0.1976502239704132,
-0.38601580262184143,
0.7227088212966919,
0.520763635635376,
-0.16155070066452026,
0.3248794674873352,
-0.7974185943603516,
0.08062733709812164,
0.06427610665559769,
0.15230245888233185,
0.02491551823914051,
-0.7097293138504028,
-0.5369669795036316,
-0.7063995003700256,
0.135680690407753,
-0.6896770000457764,
0.04816363751888275,
0.6979963183403015,
0.20032626390457153,
0.5293763279914856,
0.012611916288733482,
1.0149414539337158,
-0.611986517906189,
0.8956564664840698,
0.288670152425766,
-1.0240122079849243,
0.5130071043968201,
-0.14420750737190247,
0.42386558651924133,
0.871676504611969,
0.19735030829906464,
-0.8567919731140137,
-0.29152312874794006,
-0.7624686360359192,
-1.193238615989685,
0.5184122920036316,
0.09490890055894852,
-0.11812455952167511,
-0.42624351382255554,
0.7344803214073181,
0.236952006816864,
0.17840348184108734,
-0.3858069181442261,
-0.5853022336959839,
0.32462817430496216,
0.3219478130340576,
-0.2472674399614334,
-0.3823937475681305,
-0.00784174632281065,
-0.3116247355937958,
0.6528633236885071,
-0.1302909106016159,
0.23967623710632324,
0.4463295638561249,
-0.2738783657550812,
0.13332700729370117,
0.14294315874576569,
0.18444876372814178,
0.5744616985321045,
-0.297892302274704,
0.489236444234848,
0.2558344900608063,
-0.6152095198631287,
0.07119356840848923,
-0.14608626067638397,
-0.2810424566268921,
0.6149575710296631,
0.35585224628448486,
0.4512990415096283,
0.9076356887817383,
-0.3495538830757141,
0.17633725702762604,
0.13385294377803802,
-0.14559026062488556,
-0.5164430141448975,
-0.2558187246322632,
0.2929631769657135,
-0.17976686358451843,
0.5092790722846985,
0.4237416088581085,
-0.030854206532239914,
-0.5425025820732117,
0.6170576810836792,
-0.18409554660320282,
-0.45970067381858826,
-0.4447878897190094,
-0.024111663922667503,
0.3907845914363861,
-0.2658977806568146,
0.39034655690193176,
-0.11846686899662018,
-0.7680824398994446,
0.543632984161377,
0.7606377005577087,
0.8817405104637146,
-0.3104691505432129,
0.06977322697639465,
0.9036060571670532,
0.2492816299200058,
-0.18035069108009338,
-0.0038229303900152445,
-0.5003079175949097,
-0.8072550892829895,
-0.4280460476875305,
-0.2796419560909271,
-0.4591008126735687,
-0.36397549510002136,
-1.0936548709869385,
0.0834394171833992,
-0.7437825798988342,
-0.4664115011692047,
0.23428112268447876,
-0.03231333941221237,
-0.1760692596435547,
0.2506328225135803,
0.0991152822971344,
0.914783775806427,
-0.5568039417266846,
0.7478480339050293,
0.9347352385520935,
-0.2827279269695282,
-0.5149374604225159,
-0.3411252498626709,
-0.07771502435207367,
0.12972259521484375,
0.25102564692497253,
0.5235664248466492,
-0.3210529386997223,
0.2988344132900238,
-0.24974745512008667,
-0.8963139653205872,
0.9024285674095154,
0.1760070025920868,
-0.356366902589798,
-0.17970162630081177,
-0.278920441865921,
0.2415788471698761,
-0.38681405782699585,
0.6792568564414978,
1.0713211297988892,
0.3597189486026764,
0.03594435378909111,
-1.0799505710601807,
-0.02312653511762619,
-0.4881777763366699,
-0.09713786840438843,
0.2748158574104309,
-0.5343772172927856,
0.800954282283783,
-0.05584951117634773,
-0.5139951109886169,
0.05166323482990265,
0.806134045124054,
0.3721100091934204,
0.35719746351242065,
0.5113465785980225,
0.5910730957984924,
0.7273820638656616,
-0.13369986414909363,
0.7446062564849854,
-0.1305118203163147,
0.4999188780784607,
1.7007898092269897,
-0.2582729160785675,
0.834006130695343,
0.7538416981697083,
-0.046641163527965546,
0.5484476685523987,
0.28453415632247925,
0.249602809548378,
0.15274584293365479,
0.07577373832464218,
-0.4447818398475647,
-0.1023503914475441,
-0.5663930177688599,
-0.26364997029304504,
0.1223122626543045,
0.6617364883422852,
-0.2036123275756836,
-0.4502284526824951,
0.05872984975576401,
0.27636435627937317,
0.454524964094162,
-0.45115914940834045,
0.9027405381202698,
0.3324277698993683,
-0.8786845207214355,
0.4532310664653778,
-0.2401360422372818,
1.0682703256607056,
-0.6305159330368042,
0.10061638057231903,
-0.28538885712623596,
0.40622076392173767,
-0.4553595781326294,
-0.4558095335960388,
0.524491548538208,
0.16379708051681519,
-0.24970288574695587,
-0.15574800968170166,
0.8349449038505554,
-0.4078090488910675,
-0.23794908821582794,
0.5163131952285767,
0.2497943490743637,
0.40249699354171753,
-0.1205899715423584,
-0.4543215036392212,
-0.3343571424484253,
-0.10943452268838882,
0.06149834021925926,
0.08469781279563904,
0.42255526781082153,
0.19564159214496613,
0.2518566846847534,
0.466064989566803,
0.22688910365104675,
0.18200193345546722,
-0.1925349086523056,
0.9160103797912598,
-0.7163596153259277,
-0.6187546849250793,
-0.687006413936615,
0.6045566201210022,
-0.3657929003238678,
-0.7427628636360168,
1.0480784177780151,
0.5400676131248474,
0.7721102237701416,
-0.002750982064753771,
0.7267942428588867,
-0.23091290891170502,
0.7821086645126343,
0.04757443815469742,
0.37303078174591064,
-0.23324117064476013,
0.07066385447978973,
-0.33614975214004517,
-0.6551327705383301,
-0.685671865940094,
0.733004629611969,
-0.2588813602924347,
-0.39023807644844055,
1.1052687168121338,
0.6622068285942078,
-0.09758055955171585,
0.21712735295295715,
0.4447743594646454,
0.3638589084148407,
-0.08273591846227646,
0.44775089621543884,
0.6613042950630188,
-0.6313705444335938,
0.34998637437820435,
-0.26497432589530945,
-0.07631931453943253,
-0.24148890376091003,
-0.8929061889648438,
-0.7098991274833679,
-0.660595178604126,
-0.5157613754272461,
-0.5182213187217712,
0.33424311876296997,
1.0922778844833374,
0.6299005150794983,
-0.7490148544311523,
-0.3807666599750519,
-0.05737791210412979,
-0.2852945625782013,
-0.461915522813797,
-0.08437903225421906,
0.5522858500480652,
-0.32861337065696716,
-0.5618563890457153,
0.5039031505584717,
0.7606244087219238,
-0.5637910962104797,
-0.08582961559295654,
0.18836332857608795,
-0.650579035282135,
0.0513642244040966,
0.5217679142951965,
0.27547913789749146,
-0.6323210597038269,
-0.22090116143226624,
-0.13110888004302979,
-0.09608086198568344,
0.33693698048591614,
1.2514805793762207,
-0.918771505355835,
0.34385451674461365,
0.2681432068347931,
0.5069056153297424,
0.5628669857978821,
0.07537133991718292,
0.4479636549949646,
-0.9083360433578491,
0.3997187912464142,
0.519507884979248,
0.3385862112045288,
0.40764549374580383,
-0.4014218747615814,
0.4431878328323364,
0.21830256283283234,
-0.48138394951820374,
-0.6679795980453491,
0.11946164071559906,
-0.969144880771637,
-0.21195454895496368,
0.8454499840736389,
-0.7994050979614258,
-0.542597234249115,
-0.45367664098739624,
-0.25690415501594543,
0.2877354919910431,
-0.38192304968833923,
0.6837603449821472,
0.505351722240448,
0.10611607134342194,
-0.31849879026412964,
-0.03965102881193161,
0.31646785140037537,
0.6666053533554077,
-0.5836590528488159,
0.14191275835037231,
0.3448222577571869,
0.1593618094921112,
0.8011240363121033,
0.7502779960632324,
-0.05388856306672096,
0.5377877354621887,
0.033232081681489944,
0.23691341280937195,
-0.10884980112314224,
-0.5799853205680847,
-0.2840160131454468,
0.29947447776794434,
-0.07847065478563309,
-0.08498409390449524
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17240v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17240v2
|
The Role of $n$-gram Smoothing in the Age of Neural Networks
| 2024-03-25T22:42:19 | 2024-04-30T20:58:40 |
Luca Malagutti, Andrius Buinovskij, Anej Svete, Clara Meister, Afra Amini, Ryan Cotterell
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
For nearly three decades, language models derived from the $n$-gram
assumption held the state of the art on the task. The key to their success lay
in the application of various smoothing techniques that served to combat
overfitting. However, when neural language models toppled $n$-gram models as
the best performers, $n$-gram smoothing techniques became less relevant.
Indeed, it would hardly be an understatement to suggest that the line of
inquiry into $n$-gram smoothing techniques became dormant. This paper re-opens
the role classical $n$-gram smoothing techniques may play in the age of neural
language models. First, we draw a formal equivalence between label smoothing, a
popular regularization technique for neural language models, and add-$\lambda$
smoothing. Second, we derive a generalized framework for converting any
$n$-gram smoothing technique into a regularizer compatible with neural language
models. Our empirical results find that our novel regularizers are comparable
to and, indeed, sometimes outperform label smoothing on language modeling and
machine translation.
|
[
-0.6772233843803406,
-0.643297553062439,
0.4833141267299652,
0.17663869261741638,
-0.030901392921805382,
-0.24022060632705688,
-0.4052819311618805,
-0.3155907094478607,
0.38135379552841187,
0.26302048563957214,
-0.017685575410723686,
-0.17848695814609528,
-0.829164445400238,
-0.08655531704425812,
-0.5975012183189392,
0.93386310338974,
0.3724696636199951,
0.012644108384847641,
-0.09676989167928696,
0.25058460235595703,
0.10514792799949646,
-0.4172629714012146,
-1.1654877662658691,
-0.8461967706680298,
0.9657766819000244,
-0.16457714140415192,
0.9883202910423279,
0.7749477028846741,
0.23561635613441467,
0.35012200474739075,
-0.31654092669487,
0.19161011278629303,
-0.35113415122032166,
0.014644823968410492,
0.3960893154144287,
-0.5034123659133911,
-0.9068803787231445,
0.20194703340530396,
0.8917436599731445,
0.8874717950820923,
-0.01361945178359747,
-0.24409715831279755,
0.07819131761789322,
1.1407787799835205,
-0.6712758541107178,
0.07118997722864151,
-0.46534863114356995,
-0.12927484512329102,
-0.2602273225784302,
-0.4331130385398865,
-0.3920001983642578,
-0.6311150193214417,
-0.1956818699836731,
-0.6963087320327759,
0.16863813996315002,
-0.27945563197135925,
1.0577839612960815,
0.23261232674121857,
-0.30196914076805115,
0.10933858901262283,
-0.7344458103179932,
0.7054534554481506,
-1.1655676364898682,
0.31549644470214844,
0.7796149849891663,
0.470346599817276,
-0.6970832943916321,
-0.727168619632721,
-0.4470668137073517,
-0.22549982368946075,
0.066182442009449,
-0.04389481246471405,
-0.209076389670372,
0.1577453315258026,
0.2096385508775711,
0.43817490339279175,
-0.10717510432004929,
0.3933284282684326,
-0.37570759654045105,
-0.10472499579191208,
0.4177311956882477,
-0.38058197498321533,
0.21711625158786774,
0.2914956212043762,
-0.06672336161136627,
0.1991003006696701,
-0.6779942512512207,
-0.2052682638168335,
0.510012149810791,
0.46450161933898926,
0.3467676043510437,
0.04493420943617821,
-0.46541544795036316,
1.0482549667358398,
-0.04438099265098572,
-0.07366334646940231,
-0.10667748004198074,
-0.10407049208879471,
-0.3185049295425415,
0.10130710899829865,
0.4877583980560303,
0.5720030665397644,
0.8510779738426208,
-0.47336462140083313,
-0.27561691403388977,
0.13494448363780975,
0.3039376437664032,
-0.7119882106781006,
-0.3115537166595459,
-0.30732592940330505,
-0.445421040058136,
-0.1811729520559311,
-0.1430586725473404,
-0.8691399693489075,
-0.43856295943260193,
-0.365529328584671,
0.18542134761810303,
-0.2001866102218628,
-0.21270421147346497,
0.3528503477573395,
-0.25182604789733887,
0.22636203467845917,
0.18811599910259247,
-1.052090048789978,
0.8623237013816833,
1.1139963865280151,
0.7236769795417786,
0.1748805046081543,
0.036830171942710876,
-0.36275285482406616,
-0.3997495472431183,
-0.7302297949790955,
0.5782443881034851,
-0.708784818649292,
-0.05679917335510254,
0.04547899216413498,
-0.25541654229164124,
-0.14446093142032623,
-0.334285706281662,
0.4864584803581238,
-0.8037434816360474,
0.09167874604463577,
-0.10895136743783951,
-0.6604844927787781,
-0.47606706619262695,
0.3650389611721039,
-0.23542506992816925,
0.8973369598388672,
-0.16958804428577423,
-0.3726643919944763,
0.4401066303253174,
-0.2746404707431793,
-0.23926150798797607,
-0.24732644855976105,
0.043742235749959946,
-0.2262171506881714,
0.4840371608734131,
0.22374829649925232,
0.30611559748649597,
-0.4454820454120636,
0.40606051683425903,
-0.364465594291687,
-0.7559219598770142,
0.4218651056289673,
-0.7779260277748108,
0.6100573539733887,
-0.07965557277202606,
-0.02546648494899273,
-0.32395437359809875,
-0.860641598701477,
0.21822252869606018,
-0.24804693460464478,
-0.5137411952018738,
-0.5350444316864014,
-0.046847935765981674,
0.018711496144533157,
0.29559850692749023,
0.0002766751276794821,
-0.7503523230552673,
0.3390284478664398,
-0.5245872139930725,
0.7374419569969177,
0.37595614790916443,
-0.2253236621618271,
0.5739232301712036,
-0.4614326059818268,
0.3044015169143677,
-0.416038453578949,
0.10079919546842575,
-0.03278247267007828,
-0.9631335735321045,
-1.1563055515289307,
-0.047266241163015366,
0.8845966458320618,
0.06397093832492828,
-0.4353266954421997,
0.12081438302993774,
-0.45366171002388,
-0.6406283974647522,
-0.5940684676170349,
0.020787928253412247,
0.30434170365333557,
0.4057685434818268,
0.5178752541542053,
-0.38864216208457947,
-0.28160011768341064,
-1.0529628992080688,
-0.3472270965576172,
0.04095279052853584,
-0.035990189760923386,
-0.014889262616634369,
-0.1444665491580963,
-0.022502822801470757,
0.701144814491272,
-0.23436370491981506,
-0.15383055806159973,
0.30247801542282104,
0.31499889492988586,
0.18690729141235352,
0.8575425744056702,
0.6297429800033569,
-0.5727949142456055,
-0.17121078073978424,
0.05259035527706146,
-0.4196834862232208,
-0.21054379642009735,
-0.16010430455207825,
0.10333196818828583,
0.38513728976249695,
0.9167430996894836,
-0.16835781931877136,
0.6620071530342102,
0.71112060546875,
-0.01768251322209835,
0.2797296345233917,
-0.6266304850578308,
-0.0005863209953531623,
-0.6241056323051453,
-0.04201815649867058,
0.3185928165912628,
-0.19709521532058716,
-1.032019853591919,
0.1352432370185852,
0.20742163062095642,
0.2020798772573471,
-0.07457142323255539,
0.4877280592918396,
-0.47555434703826904,
-0.14569830894470215,
-0.8104743361473083,
0.265034556388855,
0.1537366807460785,
0.4774295687675476,
-0.39072856307029724,
0.464385062456131,
0.7604497671127319,
-0.896622359752655,
-0.15668292343616486,
-0.25087806582450867,
0.057921893894672394,
0.17290693521499634,
-0.5745595693588257,
0.20029060542583466,
-0.4009382128715515,
0.2914784848690033,
-1.040067195892334,
0.2734420597553253,
0.20306673645973206,
-0.48197630047798157,
0.8416156768798828,
-0.519972562789917,
-0.4167582392692566,
-0.17236793041229248,
-0.1030198335647583,
0.36510592699050903,
0.7913548946380615,
-0.2616788446903229,
0.5892636179924011,
0.0873170867562294,
0.0021556001156568527,
-0.3355635106563568,
-1.013344407081604,
0.4544208347797394,
-0.12579378485679626,
-0.4460139870643616,
0.47037893533706665,
0.3394824266433716,
-0.09876184910535812,
-0.16514497995376587,
-0.32881003618240356,
-0.4719103276729584,
0.2332226037979126,
0.07833827286958694,
0.15947890281677246,
-0.46925321221351624,
0.027535196393728256,
-0.1442313939332962,
-0.7820040583610535,
-0.14818312227725983,
-0.8066456317901611,
0.4707790017127991,
-0.01833922788500786,
-0.06413177400827408,
-0.3093301057815552,
0.05736587196588516,
0.3826751112937927,
-0.17253519594669342,
0.555997908115387,
0.6235284209251404,
-0.4993000030517578,
0.17461590468883514,
-0.8521316051483154,
-0.22633209824562073,
-0.4752187132835388,
-0.007607898209244013,
-0.0269036665558815,
-0.5661736726760864,
0.21051903069019318,
-0.04793960601091385,
0.023085230961441994,
0.3603151738643646,
0.11999054998159409,
0.14997002482414246,
0.8653386831283569,
0.7532697319984436,
0.02055906504392624,
0.6577733755111694,
-0.09700694680213928,
0.4897853434085846,
-1.0533757209777832,
0.052076615393161774,
-0.6892842650413513,
-0.8269020318984985,
-1.0048848390579224,
-0.28241533041000366,
-0.04326213523745537,
0.19201268255710602,
-0.10632671415805817,
0.36431798338890076,
-0.17395992577075958,
0.21167752146720886,
0.639734148979187,
-0.07155821472406387,
0.032175593078136444,
0.06687100976705551,
0.16434209048748016,
-0.08084302395582199,
-0.8127291798591614,
-0.38340553641319275,
0.7650536894798279,
0.3420456349849701,
0.5450669527053833,
-0.1270211786031723,
0.6912208199501038,
-0.14116662740707397,
0.25692299008369446,
-0.8076497316360474,
0.6048825979232788,
-0.6750743389129639,
-0.2987184524536133,
-0.04119924455881119,
-0.35452964901924133,
-0.9912594556808472,
0.24601426720619202,
-0.3050704300403595,
-0.7361232042312622,
0.8306454420089722,
0.27150169014930725,
-0.45651307702064514,
0.36613166332244873,
-0.7498995661735535,
0.5219478607177734,
0.031246086582541466,
-0.2941291034221649,
0.11298049241304398,
-0.5322585701942444,
0.2734859585762024,
-0.12118566036224365,
0.3379906415939331,
-0.27923646569252014,
-0.18930639326572418,
0.5977773666381836,
-0.2402988076210022,
0.6872420907020569,
-0.2494361400604248,
-0.02093040756881237,
-0.07480340451002121,
0.24750027060508728,
0.1065911129117012,
-0.2637866139411926,
-0.21236668527126312,
0.1238623857498169,
-0.2751520276069641,
-0.5856842398643494,
-1.0749716758728027,
1.047804832458496,
-0.38855910301208496,
-0.423745721578598,
-0.214459627866745,
-0.519137978553772,
-0.18179915845394135,
0.349237859249115,
-0.09655135124921799,
0.9720470309257507,
0.23985031247138977,
0.15144267678260803,
0.5342956185340881,
-0.04673811048269272,
0.7682878971099854,
0.29893118143081665,
-0.4427471458911896,
-0.09495504200458527,
1.1694886684417725,
0.5725597739219666,
0.4805006980895996,
0.22147220373153687,
0.3685629963874817,
-0.010168755427002907,
-0.6843097805976868,
-0.08622513711452484,
0.10005170106887817,
-0.517867386341095,
-0.02009052038192749,
-0.6997861862182617,
-0.3089210093021393,
-0.34085527062416077,
-0.12309196591377258,
-0.20026172697544098,
-0.9103541970252991,
-0.01874295435845852,
0.1747247725725174,
0.4418911337852478,
0.5713462233543396,
-0.25212985277175903,
0.49218034744262695,
-0.6089655160903931,
0.2423136681318283,
0.2502938210964203,
0.5603389143943787,
0.13611726462841034,
-0.4965013265609741,
-0.2375774085521698,
0.08047123998403549,
0.06665217131376266,
-0.5053738355636597,
0.34769919514656067,
0.6636760830879211,
0.4858979284763336,
0.56807941198349,
-0.4753384292125702,
0.6737908720970154,
-0.6297619938850403,
0.5210919976234436,
-0.1725701242685318,
-0.5212270617485046,
-0.15644051134586334,
-0.3862250745296478,
0.4034227728843689,
0.40481120347976685,
0.2517191767692566,
-0.9112337827682495,
-0.28403979539871216,
-0.6333128809928894,
-1.1958428621292114,
0.3040127158164978,
0.15275077521800995,
0.1834656447172165,
-0.08973025530576706,
0.5807855129241943,
-0.03502980247139931,
0.2831064760684967,
-0.3608010709285736,
-0.5888699293136597,
-0.2785637378692627,
0.27549293637275696,
-0.5431028604507446,
-0.29970672726631165,
0.2589537501335144,
-0.2181227058172226,
0.7462804317474365,
-0.10205056518316269,
0.2764146625995636,
0.001939430134370923,
0.24986989796161652,
0.12733124196529388,
0.37753036618232727,
0.7078580260276794,
0.35045793652534485,
-0.2855605185031891,
0.2906520366668701,
-0.33492228388786316,
-0.3425147831439972,
0.02064816839993,
0.326992005109787,
-0.7716203331947327,
-0.08547500520944595,
0.01350228302180767,
0.8696454167366028,
0.5670410990715027,
0.03967102989554405,
0.00402591098099947,
-0.12359526753425598,
-0.2979224920272827,
-0.043306585401296616,
0.060759782791137695,
0.11632035672664642,
-0.1818598508834839,
0.13618484139442444,
0.7640981674194336,
0.336101770401001,
-0.4627116322517395,
0.3807136118412018,
0.2220999151468277,
-0.8215715885162354,
-0.12378083169460297,
0.5777142643928528,
-0.2896442413330078,
-0.5534616708755493,
0.4319044351577759,
-0.14134657382965088,
-0.39969462156295776,
0.5097118616104126,
0.5585618019104004,
0.956172525882721,
0.06511110812425613,
0.08621590584516525,
0.33166950941085815,
0.4594193398952484,
-0.34962812066078186,
0.011874130927026272,
0.08821103721857071,
-0.6081850528717041,
-0.5949013829231262,
-0.5497380495071411,
0.2634546458721161,
-0.1571653038263321,
-0.7360239028930664,
-0.316409170627594,
-0.6480787396430969,
-0.6552510857582092,
0.24097563326358795,
-0.32606324553489685,
-0.5233370065689087,
0.24527452886104584,
0.45374366641044617,
1.1663978099822998,
-0.678542971611023,
0.9069586396217346,
0.48442116379737854,
-0.2221444994211197,
-0.3780905306339264,
0.12300081551074982,
0.034933604300022125,
-0.7409945726394653,
0.7237151861190796,
0.2856636941432953,
-0.02694426104426384,
0.21205583214759827,
-0.22825156152248383,
-1.0021998882293701,
0.4045874774456024,
0.26161879301071167,
-0.3414957523345947,
-0.11933162808418274,
-0.14434264600276947,
0.9133712649345398,
-0.14231835305690765,
0.2829625606536865,
1.0603538751602173,
0.7159466743469238,
-0.03531229496002197,
-0.7273331880569458,
-0.10329755395650864,
-0.5498846769332886,
0.23526239395141602,
0.6512422561645508,
-0.3400167226791382,
0.9517403841018677,
0.26942265033721924,
0.05843298137187958,
0.11377717554569244,
0.5809727907180786,
-0.2623264491558075,
0.018581124022603035,
0.2992493212223053,
0.5650622248649597,
0.43043676018714905,
-0.5041077136993408,
1.2359005212783813,
-0.29863956570625305,
-0.13614937663078308,
0.9845181107521057,
0.1623973548412323,
0.7551912069320679,
0.6056981682777405,
0.09643668681383133,
0.3555184304714203,
0.5028168559074402,
0.06310079991817474,
0.4109734296798706,
0.6153184771537781,
0.026876354590058327,
-0.28957507014274597,
-0.18202602863311768,
-0.28955990076065063,
0.30448219180107117,
0.5304984450340271,
-0.08193079382181168,
-0.6204851269721985,
-0.18330861628055573,
0.10307879000902176,
0.40077871084213257,
-0.5264557600021362,
0.6980495452880859,
0.2544565200805664,
-0.5672416687011719,
0.733144998550415,
0.14865002036094666,
0.9476135969161987,
-0.5495944619178772,
-0.10582268238067627,
-0.2683480978012085,
0.11131301522254944,
-0.10498420149087906,
-0.22174373269081116,
0.16523975133895874,
-0.37234270572662354,
-0.013497011736035347,
-0.3246259391307831,
0.8244298696517944,
-0.6223248839378357,
-0.6533640623092651,
0.44795769453048706,
0.2866668403148651,
0.25083091855049133,
-0.07939872145652771,
-0.5401624441146851,
-0.08873994648456573,
-0.4570798873901367,
-0.0647236630320549,
0.45915940403938293,
0.3793315291404724,
0.046579714864492416,
0.7202110290527344,
0.5609943270683289,
0.3761417865753174,
0.6110678911209106,
0.12936724722385406,
0.8247356414794922,
-0.3137385845184326,
-0.293211430311203,
-0.784771740436554,
0.2047225534915924,
-0.006673845928162336,
-0.35204893350601196,
0.9102614521980286,
0.2578928470611572,
0.6419703960418701,
0.3488922119140625,
0.436286598443985,
0.17492403090000153,
0.08273657411336899,
-0.6579251289367676,
0.8080870509147644,
-0.6859114766120911,
-0.17383092641830444,
-0.2338285893201828,
-0.8652558922767639,
-0.6497071981430054,
0.4315880537033081,
-0.5048554539680481,
0.5654239654541016,
0.4477015435695648,
0.9071416258811951,
0.11629879474639893,
-0.008867941796779633,
0.4963799715042114,
0.059828195720911026,
0.2798875570297241,
0.22399769723415375,
0.48984241485595703,
-0.8522709608078003,
0.14002051949501038,
-0.17782250046730042,
-0.07757839560508728,
-0.20310424268245697,
-1.1620732545852661,
-0.5376918315887451,
-0.3748164176940918,
-0.30476200580596924,
-0.24418915808200836,
0.1933731883764267,
0.7257664203643799,
0.7483128905296326,
-0.7550448179244995,
-0.15312983095645905,
-0.2591722309589386,
-0.12544751167297363,
-0.5830447673797607,
-0.13273397088050842,
0.1362200826406479,
-0.5775631666183472,
-0.7109197378158569,
0.7559939622879028,
0.3007529377937317,
0.3350978195667267,
-0.200676828622818,
0.15980051457881927,
-0.39673998951911926,
0.21002408862113953,
0.17761164903640747,
0.5641806125640869,
-0.6126720905303955,
-0.01953127048909664,
-0.02835836634039879,
-0.04440253973007202,
0.3679378628730774,
0.9359518885612488,
-0.847873330116272,
0.7304261326789856,
0.4777015149593353,
0.8917721509933472,
0.36852124333381653,
-0.08822044730186462,
0.9463458061218262,
-0.631358802318573,
0.3747991621494293,
-0.05597788095474243,
0.47108811140060425,
0.5151613354682922,
-0.11596906930208206,
0.23871752619743347,
-0.016044260933995247,
-0.6709420680999756,
-0.4931991398334503,
0.14973248541355133,
-0.5441960692405701,
-0.12150897830724716,
0.8545748591423035,
-0.08869610726833344,
-0.43647292256355286,
-0.24503974616527557,
-0.13535688817501068,
0.29986968636512756,
-0.5186591744422913,
0.7562047839164734,
0.6128100752830505,
0.32117795944213867,
-0.03721991553902626,
-0.9647466540336609,
0.7879318594932556,
0.41619765758514404,
-0.34513017535209656,
-0.069887176156044,
0.31127747893333435,
-0.08384837955236435,
0.38476550579071045,
0.656712532043457,
-0.09116093069314957,
-0.0005665852804668248,
0.0679454579949379,
-0.013277334161102772,
-0.33935827016830444,
-0.5545617341995239,
-0.5903843641281128,
0.018108030781149864,
0.16845157742500305,
-0.1574905514717102
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17220v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17220v1
|
Making Sentence Embeddings Robust to User-Generated Content
| 2024-03-25T21:48:36 | 2024-03-25T21:48:36 |
Lydia Nishimwe, Benoît Sagot, Rachel Bawden
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
NLP models have been known to perform poorly on user-generated content (UGC),
mainly because it presents a lot of lexical variations and deviates from the
standard texts on which most of these models were trained. In this work, we
focus on the robustness of LASER, a sentence embedding model, to UGC data. We
evaluate this robustness by LASER's ability to represent non-standard sentences
and their standard counterparts close to each other in the embedding space.
Inspired by previous works extending LASER to other languages and modalities,
we propose RoLASER, a robust English encoder trained using a teacher-student
approach to reduce the distances between the representations of standard and
UGC sentences. We show that with training only on standard and synthetic
UGC-like data, RoLASER significantly improves LASER's robustness to both
natural and artificial UGC data by achieving up to 2x and 11x better scores. We
also perform a fine-grained analysis on artificial UGC data and find that our
model greatly outperforms LASER on its most challenging UGC phenomena such as
keyboard typos and social media abbreviations. Evaluation on downstream tasks
shows that RoLASER performs comparably to or better than LASER on standard
data, while consistently outperforming it on UGC data.
|
[
-0.1585889756679535,
-0.8591716289520264,
0.28147515654563904,
-0.1449056714773178,
-0.2997952103614807,
0.08046543598175049,
-0.2208651900291443,
-0.42164042592048645,
0.025582822039723396,
0.4289311468601227,
-0.1815178096294403,
-0.6346122026443481,
-0.5352185964584351,
0.3466991186141968,
-0.4726771116256714,
0.8988350033760071,
0.19082647562026978,
0.2754783630371094,
-0.29362356662750244,
-0.09890839457511902,
-0.46346884965896606,
-0.49128642678260803,
-0.322611540555954,
-0.23302683234214783,
0.20628884434700012,
0.10181073844432831,
1.1143579483032227,
0.791258692741394,
0.6864385008811951,
0.15715210139751434,
-0.13440075516700745,
0.4515221416950226,
-0.4666776955127716,
0.3414742648601532,
-0.13401491940021515,
-0.29927384853363037,
0.08156219124794006,
-0.430056631565094,
0.5942714810371399,
0.5875114798545837,
-0.3544975817203522,
-0.35545361042022705,
0.4244175851345062,
0.3698939085006714,
-0.5510456562042236,
-0.20198632776737213,
-0.7378759980201721,
0.3883870840072632,
-0.11194498836994171,
0.01510166097432375,
-0.7734865546226501,
-0.2753724455833435,
0.007500628475099802,
-0.5607272386550903,
0.4323505461215973,
-0.03730342164635658,
1.1946810483932495,
0.4349006116390228,
-0.31194379925727844,
-0.5124860405921936,
-0.7375288009643555,
0.6126682162284851,
-0.7430545687675476,
0.798461377620697,
0.19924966990947723,
0.16067107021808624,
-0.2946184575557709,
-0.8171953558921814,
-0.3431313633918762,
-0.2504207491874695,
-0.16963593661785126,
0.27329710125923157,
-0.16323627531528473,
0.03784596174955368,
0.09046030044555664,
0.14305001497268677,
-0.7235459089279175,
0.11347785592079163,
-0.06005918234586716,
-0.22949546575546265,
0.45524558424949646,
0.28806230425834656,
0.49889665842056274,
-0.4848470687866211,
-0.4738394320011139,
-0.30409690737724304,
-0.8661336898803711,
0.11930259317159653,
0.5427169799804688,
0.4192517101764679,
0.32562288641929626,
0.8262597918510437,
0.027724549174308777,
0.8497296571731567,
-0.07430766522884369,
-0.07294462621212006,
-0.17355775833129883,
-0.43145427107810974,
-0.01947650872170925,
-0.012660414911806583,
0.9781720638275146,
0.43014562129974365,
0.3262653350830078,
-0.26414602994918823,
-0.24653996527194977,
0.10339498519897461,
0.46883493661880493,
-0.8431986570358276,
-0.5077290534973145,
-0.09341304749250412,
-0.36324959993362427,
-0.0652775913476944,
0.40687331557273865,
-0.7990813255310059,
-0.3200121223926544,
0.26714617013931274,
0.14104779064655304,
-0.5136421322822571,
0.38738349080085754,
0.14179058372974396,
-0.011775493621826172,
-0.13870401680469513,
0.05431205779314041,
-1.0779767036437988,
0.10908915102481842,
0.47507572174072266,
0.7873794436454773,
-0.0432526059448719,
-0.22181624174118042,
-0.41775307059288025,
0.1665521264076233,
-0.38263851404190063,
0.8104240894317627,
-0.5948227047920227,
-0.5714284181594849,
0.34633398056030273,
-0.19782237708568573,
-0.059688594192266464,
-0.648785412311554,
0.8580915331840515,
-0.445068895816803,
0.45380720496177673,
-0.009593645110726357,
-0.9840683341026306,
0.20214438438415527,
-0.12127479165792465,
-0.5869102478027344,
1.0011754035949707,
-0.043791137635707855,
-0.7823710441589355,
0.6477512717247009,
-0.40875107049942017,
-0.5323390364646912,
0.10876069962978363,
-0.3122144043445587,
-0.6763526201248169,
0.21575619280338287,
0.3812909722328186,
0.43157586455345154,
0.19628161191940308,
0.28023195266723633,
-0.3269008696079254,
-0.45014190673828125,
0.36421656608581543,
-0.46795761585235596,
0.7719428539276123,
0.2807569205760956,
-0.0879250317811966,
-0.09795249253511429,
-0.6253539323806763,
0.08325948566198349,
0.012777723371982574,
-0.5571602582931519,
-0.2048538774251938,
0.2942379415035248,
0.2660212218761444,
-0.13913318514823914,
0.09588389098644257,
-0.6857683658599854,
0.2368837296962738,
-0.6377456784248352,
0.6306810975074768,
0.5580510497093201,
0.015495591796934605,
0.49550601840019226,
-0.011480518616735935,
0.45835790038108826,
-0.2849588990211487,
-0.09765543788671494,
-0.10438795387744904,
-0.6718961000442505,
-0.49557068943977356,
-0.13157984614372253,
0.37505003809928894,
0.7486104965209961,
-0.8197684288024902,
0.7248257994651794,
-0.19734002649784088,
-0.3339153826236725,
-0.6732881665229797,
0.5109046697616577,
0.398727685213089,
0.5822506546974182,
0.32308080792427063,
-0.3893393874168396,
-0.5996794700622559,
-0.8014569282531738,
-0.352633535861969,
-0.12781985104084015,
-0.4542222321033478,
0.24882929027080536,
0.30043235421180725,
-0.18575263023376465,
1.108023762702942,
-0.5161720514297485,
-0.4324549436569214,
-0.3046824634075165,
0.1733725517988205,
-0.0432627834379673,
0.5077869296073914,
0.07711400836706161,
-0.6717992424964905,
-0.7131133079528809,
-0.23956643044948578,
-1.0348225831985474,
-0.00987121369689703,
-0.607757031917572,
0.1370837688446045,
0.27959346771240234,
0.39937981963157654,
-0.5783021450042725,
0.598078727722168,
0.40730565786361694,
-0.6147936582565308,
0.11309587955474854,
-0.40890443325042725,
-0.024818304926156998,
-1.2390813827514648,
-0.29110050201416016,
0.01214761845767498,
-0.3795449435710907,
-0.5644213557243347,
0.15228424966335297,
-0.0615706592798233,
-0.2838420867919922,
-0.5517621040344238,
0.10781203955411911,
-0.24633130431175232,
-0.16171754896640778,
-0.15583810210227966,
0.34473738074302673,
0.22764040529727936,
0.10805798321962357,
0.2243199348449707,
1.0259952545166016,
0.30955225229263306,
-0.1741883009672165,
0.35705748200416565,
0.5623248219490051,
-0.5940821170806885,
0.36591556668281555,
-1.0530847311019897,
0.26272034645080566,
0.07887177169322968,
0.18461088836193085,
-0.7917686700820923,
-0.23118598759174347,
-0.0750754326581955,
-0.6932018995285034,
0.07809122651815414,
0.19843487441539764,
-0.9185114502906799,
-0.06034824252128601,
-0.125772625207901,
-0.1370200514793396,
0.6217042207717896,
-0.6291475892066956,
0.4854869246482849,
0.20524825155735016,
0.1849851906299591,
-0.27169421315193176,
-0.9046221375465393,
0.3304518163204193,
-0.12204675376415253,
-0.9085858464241028,
0.4436141848564148,
0.20062626898288727,
-0.10857492685317993,
0.3482276201248169,
0.1508529633283615,
-0.2902643084526062,
0.19918502867221832,
0.2418288141489029,
0.19675731658935547,
-0.09095726907253265,
0.11265376955270767,
-0.10835252702236176,
-0.07230755686759949,
-0.24085839092731476,
-0.04774438589811325,
0.37526270747184753,
0.01290197391062975,
-0.4607151746749878,
-0.670872688293457,
0.49796104431152344,
0.07655341923236847,
-0.02227928303182125,
1.0492682456970215,
0.8393437266349792,
-0.34563902020454407,
-0.5475539565086365,
0.08824381977319717,
-0.6095989942550659,
-0.47715771198272705,
0.401824414730072,
-0.10285251587629318,
-1.0872727632522583,
0.4309644103050232,
0.3522883355617523,
0.09145329892635345,
0.08269166946411133,
0.37976011633872986,
-0.4009068012237549,
1.2656357288360596,
0.7137919068336487,
0.22332556545734406,
0.39071202278137207,
0.10402994602918625,
0.5102825164794922,
-0.6417027711868286,
-0.2433805912733078,
-0.4998047947883606,
-0.08159162849187851,
-0.475440114736557,
-0.03740169107913971,
0.14642594754695892,
0.3862847685813904,
0.1857605278491974,
0.6778927445411682,
-0.6503263711929321,
0.5772623419761658,
0.6253082752227783,
0.08003844320774078,
0.14141497015953064,
-0.001969875069335103,
0.002616716315969825,
-0.5819393992424011,
-0.8713037967681885,
-0.8080142140388489,
0.9132154583930969,
0.31552043557167053,
0.9808383584022522,
0.2969590127468109,
0.6654850840568542,
0.49953246116638184,
-0.2392885386943817,
-0.5360666513442993,
0.39216071367263794,
-0.6051850318908691,
-0.6269609928131104,
-0.12028338015079498,
-0.5295767188072205,
-0.8946416974067688,
0.10383588075637817,
-0.5224144458770752,
-0.6048701405525208,
-0.10008446127176285,
0.10932277888059616,
-0.5287279486656189,
0.36222440004348755,
-0.7202539443969727,
0.7728734612464905,
0.027209704741835594,
-0.39072385430336,
0.27467334270477295,
-0.5050957202911377,
-0.1289258897304535,
0.16704623401165009,
-0.019955292344093323,
0.23263101279735565,
-0.03887372463941574,
0.7070721983909607,
-0.42461612820625305,
0.8503024578094482,
-0.14074499905109406,
0.005636908579617739,
0.45045509934425354,
0.0006263022660277784,
0.5429887175559998,
0.2905043363571167,
0.14009015262126923,
-0.05509185045957565,
-0.43149638175964355,
-0.3184206783771515,
-0.8186192512512207,
0.5651816129684448,
-0.6367574334144592,
-0.5008240938186646,
-0.15348288416862488,
-0.5437356233596802,
-0.25346076488494873,
-0.019594913348555565,
0.6791743636131287,
0.6288734674453735,
-0.1252906173467636,
0.6941536664962769,
0.8129626512527466,
-0.22703544795513153,
0.5334309339523315,
0.005605420097708702,
-0.09258226305246353,
-0.5280106663703918,
0.7828263640403748,
0.033394478261470795,
0.26989462971687317,
0.3330860137939453,
0.04835790395736694,
-0.5005714297294617,
-0.5441089272499084,
-0.8736507296562195,
-0.20321029424667358,
-0.7819720506668091,
-0.2230384349822998,
-0.4704567492008209,
-0.23835480213165283,
-0.4688512682914734,
-0.7210363149642944,
-0.3993854820728302,
-0.21991892158985138,
-0.7071648240089417,
-0.2389698177576065,
0.04805804416537285,
0.8258029818534851,
0.07582541555166245,
0.3362937867641449,
-0.8688559532165527,
0.02157878316938877,
0.25113627314567566,
0.08323107659816742,
-0.43183231353759766,
-0.6281223893165588,
-0.2795058488845825,
-0.06349930167198181,
-0.18584680557250977,
-0.8722676634788513,
0.5828260183334351,
0.6854979991912842,
0.544215738773346,
0.5746868848800659,
0.09962407499551773,
0.4455444812774658,
-0.5217617750167847,
1.1471269130706787,
0.055355630815029144,
-0.9109028577804565,
0.5578678250312805,
-0.35312479734420776,
0.3208616077899933,
0.7597272396087646,
0.2633739411830902,
-0.15831829607486725,
-0.6535996198654175,
-0.33999893069267273,
-0.6871320605278015,
0.24192215502262115,
0.28075799345970154,
0.5569936633110046,
-0.023592162877321243,
0.3871888518333435,
-0.08767075091600418,
-0.1417689174413681,
-0.9778714776039124,
-0.05244690179824829,
-0.5300538539886475,
-0.5443816184997559,
0.026832478120923042,
-0.21999040246009827,
0.14236989617347717,
0.17083869874477386,
0.3744092881679535,
0.016021357849240303,
0.18044234812259674,
0.3927144408226013,
-0.2610725462436676,
0.15332576632499695,
0.21148867905139923,
0.49336114525794983,
0.28358444571495056,
-0.35508614778518677,
0.40676677227020264,
0.20706257224082947,
-0.5585203170776367,
0.026331622153520584,
-0.14373785257339478,
-0.610588550567627,
0.24345123767852783,
0.743047297000885,
0.541189432144165,
0.25223347544670105,
-0.9537470936775208,
0.4312151074409485,
-0.10894356667995453,
-0.14349722862243652,
0.10547788441181183,
0.16681000590324402,
0.04665167257189751,
0.00003871300941682421,
0.14436906576156616,
0.11880003660917282,
0.11454842239618301,
-0.40457648038864136,
0.6198776364326477,
0.3306497037410736,
-0.7152112126350403,
-0.25123730301856995,
0.8877508044242859,
0.26609331369400024,
-0.4364575743675232,
0.6789451241493225,
-0.1619788557291031,
-0.6223111152648926,
0.2661930322647095,
0.9728960990905762,
0.6276423335075378,
-0.05296511575579643,
0.23178140819072723,
0.2655600905418396,
0.41959264874458313,
0.13916805386543274,
-0.027915647253394127,
0.1497899889945984,
-0.8257906436920166,
-0.18587560951709747,
-0.4939257800579071,
-0.3795279264450073,
-0.4517465829849243,
-0.8351255655288696,
0.07299814373254776,
-0.7045776844024658,
-0.15167050063610077,
-0.19299381971359253,
-0.057546522468328476,
-0.33617982268333435,
0.029425127431750298,
-0.008257049135863781,
0.756721556186676,
-0.9488266110420227,
1.0719895362854004,
0.6505559086799622,
-0.36335626244544983,
-0.6877634525299072,
-0.1339898258447647,
0.039614152163267136,
-0.6502093076705933,
0.5042371153831482,
0.12823611497879028,
-0.18634235858917236,
-0.1822488158941269,
-0.1901744157075882,
-0.5057016611099243,
1.061521291732788,
0.3983857035636902,
-0.5095622539520264,
0.1167207881808281,
0.35368549823760986,
0.7110331654548645,
-0.43107759952545166,
-0.12072069942951202,
-0.2014952450990677,
0.06469471752643585,
0.09915399551391602,
-0.4757816791534424,
-0.08084302395582199,
-0.03904806077480316,
0.25388896465301514,
0.16124722361564636,
-0.20479987561702728,
0.8833196759223938,
-0.07130097597837448,
-0.6019355654716492,
0.043959904462099075,
0.9655911326408386,
0.017695607617497444,
-0.016044581308960915,
0.26248911023139954,
0.874557375907898,
0.738315224647522,
-0.19347111880779266,
1.0756586790084839,
-0.1414509266614914,
0.41786205768585205,
1.1533656120300293,
-0.3873412311077118,
1.1907060146331787,
0.3420742154121399,
-0.1077100858092308,
0.6755543351173401,
0.3380858898162842,
-0.41780173778533936,
0.8359581232070923,
0.0002984800667036325,
-0.22255924344062805,
-0.36093661189079285,
-0.2907344102859497,
-0.23631609976291656,
0.5743536949157715,
-0.08262531459331512,
-0.43912938237190247,
-0.20971651375293732,
0.18753021955490112,
0.1374058723449707,
0.7176846861839294,
0.0038528330624103546,
0.8987559080123901,
-0.0284056905657053,
-0.42615723609924316,
0.43174174427986145,
0.08048674464225769,
0.9294480681419373,
-0.45842480659484863,
-0.005797460209578276,
-0.25863516330718994,
0.352302610874176,
-0.25704485177993774,
-0.8696576952934265,
0.6769518852233887,
0.3214162588119507,
0.028893280774354935,
-0.3131982386112213,
0.8968091011047363,
-0.43614742159843445,
-0.593654215335846,
0.19565726816654205,
0.26980552077293396,
-0.040843140333890915,
0.3343886733055115,
-0.5166603922843933,
0.16762155294418335,
0.3278462290763855,
-0.029373738914728165,
0.2740815281867981,
0.14058555662631989,
0.5155314207077026,
0.6032708287239075,
0.6164266467094421,
-0.07182833552360535,
0.11433687061071396,
-0.034825436770915985,
0.5129464268684387,
-0.5561688542366028,
-0.27014827728271484,
-1.0344862937927246,
0.4729624390602112,
-0.02400428242981434,
-0.5077064037322998,
1.2682900428771973,
0.5833701491355896,
0.8910892605781555,
0.007325859274715185,
0.48491352796554565,
0.10301762074232101,
0.3144978880882263,
-0.7975499033927917,
0.9394369125366211,
-0.4102747142314911,
0.21375297009944916,
-0.05210902914404869,
-0.9492582082748413,
-0.7380663156509399,
0.9934547543525696,
0.23293358087539673,
-0.2248532474040985,
0.37164393067359924,
0.8723523616790771,
0.14774028956890106,
0.12310563027858734,
0.45129266381263733,
-0.20413416624069214,
0.4928657114505768,
0.6123350858688354,
0.8883662819862366,
-0.2826496362686157,
0.6891523599624634,
-0.2668983042240143,
0.10361871123313904,
-0.2342006415128708,
-0.7701811194419861,
-1.0916783809661865,
-0.5637644529342651,
-0.1406356245279312,
-0.3872665762901306,
0.12605662643909454,
0.7565076351165771,
0.8631064891815186,
-0.7800031304359436,
-0.039295777678489685,
-0.4256669878959656,
0.015021265484392643,
0.02973107621073723,
-0.21141134202480316,
0.35128581523895264,
-0.3233882188796997,
-0.6468413472175598,
0.6025224328041077,
0.02914036624133587,
0.12799091637134552,
-0.41792991757392883,
-0.11782708764076233,
-0.06514579057693481,
0.21212875843048096,
0.34232378005981445,
0.029740547761321068,
-0.7195326089859009,
-0.6476889252662659,
0.3644999563694,
-0.31585028767585754,
0.0510563999414444,
0.4326036274433136,
-0.6760473251342773,
0.5165031552314758,
0.34809404611587524,
0.8719069361686707,
-0.03043978661298752,
0.09090449661016464,
0.5100502371788025,
-0.874891996383667,
-0.11521241813898087,
0.30738797783851624,
0.5357853770256042,
0.6551184058189392,
-0.4601040184497833,
0.48591288924217224,
0.1291346251964569,
-0.7409839034080505,
-0.8622275590896606,
0.3164353370666504,
-0.8335011601448059,
-0.3984147608280182,
0.9995757341384888,
-0.5351616740226746,
-0.05760950595140457,
-0.044404301792383194,
-0.06318534910678864,
0.01796993799507618,
-0.5809271335601807,
0.863123893737793,
0.7978371381759644,
-0.16717007756233215,
-0.18743297457695007,
-0.3154953420162201,
0.5153315663337708,
0.5816715955734253,
-0.7452932596206665,
0.013588416390120983,
0.5268073081970215,
0.13294892013072968,
0.3331320583820343,
0.05925638601183891,
0.08113503456115723,
0.11709343641996384,
0.5139248967170715,
-0.1659817397594452,
-0.34688472747802734,
-0.4966488778591156,
-0.373521625995636,
0.541534960269928,
0.02694202959537506,
-0.10880973190069199
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17216v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17216v1
|
Ontology Completion with Natural Language Inference and Concept Embeddings: An Analysis
| 2024-03-25T21:46:35 | 2024-03-25T21:46:35 |
Na Li, Thomas Bailleux, Zied Bouraoui, Steven Schockaert
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We consider the problem of finding plausible knowledge that is missing from a
given ontology, as a generalisation of the well-studied taxonomy expansion
task. One line of work treats this task as a Natural Language Inference (NLI)
problem, thus relying on the knowledge captured by language models to identify
the missing knowledge. Another line of work uses concept embeddings to identify
what different concepts have in common, taking inspiration from cognitive
models for category based induction. These two approaches are intuitively
complementary, but their effectiveness has not yet been compared. In this
paper, we introduce a benchmark for evaluating ontology completion methods and
thoroughly analyse the strengths and weaknesses of both approaches. We find
that both approaches are indeed complementary, with hybrid strategies achieving
the best overall results. We also find that the task is highly challenging for
Large Language Models, even after fine-tuning.
|
[
-0.5240966081619263,
-0.45807382464408875,
0.6976444125175476,
-0.275115042924881,
0.027368037030100822,
0.4122953414916992,
-0.16661199927330017,
-0.500810444355011,
0.24080359935760498,
0.550875186920166,
-0.6784106492996216,
-0.44409385323524475,
-0.6826515197753906,
0.2545213997364044,
-0.328055202960968,
0.6078897714614868,
0.05924022197723389,
-0.2571016550064087,
-0.5538169145584106,
-0.08445043861865997,
-0.536510705947876,
-0.16634458303451538,
-0.4104440212249756,
-0.6101704835891724,
0.11064917594194412,
0.2552153170108795,
0.6417317986488342,
0.7186945080757141,
0.5992454290390015,
0.17518307268619537,
-0.24282342195510864,
0.43655407428741455,
-0.17792335152626038,
-0.17756745219230652,
-0.374070942401886,
-0.46884623169898987,
-0.21454164385795593,
0.11005207896232605,
0.5025350451469421,
1.3265348672866821,
-0.4010213613510132,
0.015447149984538555,
0.08817775547504425,
0.4039236307144165,
-0.9582940936088562,
-0.002446010708808899,
-0.5321825742721558,
0.41919612884521484,
0.042076289653778076,
-0.1552382856607437,
-0.13732485473155975,
-0.31141796708106995,
0.7927650809288025,
-0.8575083613395691,
0.13721592724323273,
0.16809779405593872,
0.6619719862937927,
0.3594077229499817,
-0.508043646812439,
-0.7011213302612305,
-0.7079375982284546,
1.2141979932785034,
-0.6416471004486084,
0.36921459436416626,
0.5651413202285767,
0.0005790532450191677,
-0.08677402883768082,
-0.617425262928009,
-0.6564527750015259,
-0.17400170862674713,
-0.3253450095653534,
0.31606683135032654,
-0.02194400317966938,
0.279207319021225,
0.3334271013736725,
0.5630496740341187,
-0.4046179950237274,
0.1633327752351761,
-0.09934213757514954,
-0.09540139138698578,
0.2957717180252075,
0.036095358431339264,
0.49189162254333496,
-0.5954329967498779,
-0.316254585981369,
0.008481013588607311,
-0.5443286895751953,
-0.33825957775115967,
0.23784139752388,
0.25660428404808044,
0.05258724093437195,
0.6932113766670227,
-0.2544032633304596,
0.9964965581893921,
-0.3664225935935974,
-0.11714789271354675,
0.393699049949646,
-0.8405811786651611,
-0.05403721705079079,
-0.061925992369651794,
0.5158712863922119,
0.2412276268005371,
0.21466076374053955,
-0.8779216408729553,
-0.012775667943060398,
0.2586056888103485,
0.45479029417037964,
0.1530255228281021,
0.22530904412269592,
0.5917198061943054,
-0.14146040380001068,
0.07125086337327957,
0.13009722530841827,
-0.32990503311157227,
-0.16032402217388153,
-0.3873486816883087,
0.4061996042728424,
-0.6544996500015259,
-0.4106946885585785,
0.1444191187620163,
-0.7353023886680603,
0.64668208360672,
0.2554609775543213,
-0.9174502491950989,
0.41321828961372375,
1.2469329833984375,
0.8236193060874939,
-0.11828084290027618,
-0.00586192449554801,
-0.15360558032989502,
0.3827696740627289,
-0.41145774722099304,
0.8412312865257263,
-0.6520882844924927,
-0.3046163022518158,
0.027356449514627457,
-0.31030187010765076,
-0.11374152451753616,
-0.5128744840621948,
0.6347829103469849,
-0.44013845920562744,
0.29698601365089417,
-0.5681660175323486,
-1.1214288473129272,
-0.2733064293861389,
0.5027307271957397,
-0.5257716774940491,
1.0069515705108643,
0.08129311352968216,
-0.880976676940918,
0.5804882645606995,
-0.6290576457977295,
-0.19427524507045746,
0.17735767364501953,
-0.11493058502674103,
0.10695209354162216,
0.040901534259319305,
-0.39339080452919006,
0.45020660758018494,
-0.7812120318412781,
0.2683904767036438,
-0.3576223850250244,
-0.26346099376678467,
0.03593381866812706,
0.3655763566493988,
0.5510272979736328,
0.05826888978481293,
-0.18400609493255615,
-0.42444905638694763,
-0.9210724234580994,
0.13934342563152313,
-0.0009236882324330509,
0.018113812431693077,
-0.8210669159889221,
0.0980144664645195,
-0.21564264595508575,
-0.025363052263855934,
0.20308297872543335,
-0.8662348389625549,
0.21397745609283447,
-0.6774404048919678,
0.3956780433654785,
0.2057221233844757,
-0.0010087992995977402,
0.7215496301651001,
-0.3707180619239807,
0.31870579719543457,
-0.2919306457042694,
-0.12378126382827759,
0.04722302779555321,
-0.7572029232978821,
-0.7248972654342651,
-0.12776921689510345,
0.7139551639556885,
0.6548782587051392,
-0.7047051191329956,
0.9021087288856506,
-0.4058392643928528,
-0.5224355459213257,
-0.5245857834815979,
0.18488815426826477,
0.5826734900474548,
0.26219162344932556,
0.2663959264755249,
-0.620928943157196,
-0.8012430667877197,
-0.6921899318695068,
-0.19328254461288452,
-0.04569244757294655,
-0.25257349014282227,
0.1456322968006134,
0.5528334975242615,
-0.30612125992774963,
1.2576431035995483,
-0.5056627988815308,
-0.45577090978622437,
-0.19617043435573578,
0.0975988507270813,
0.08755604922771454,
0.4493240714073181,
0.33389195799827576,
-0.8832058310508728,
-0.1310233175754547,
0.17541731894016266,
-1.2171740531921387,
0.27224379777908325,
0.14089837670326233,
-0.05552429333329201,
-0.07056348770856857,
0.2155756652355194,
-0.48709025979042053,
0.5057345628738403,
0.354830265045166,
-0.009225611574947834,
0.10399408638477325,
-0.23701320588588715,
-0.08472966402769089,
-1.0683343410491943,
0.07091996818780899,
-0.045035190880298615,
-0.03559049963951111,
-0.9745064377784729,
0.24772639572620392,
-0.06549815088510513,
0.40941882133483887,
-0.0944482684135437,
0.37184974551200867,
-0.5536434054374695,
-0.10834154486656189,
-0.20429565012454987,
0.6410004496574402,
-0.030058208853006363,
0.14139977097511292,
0.21189260482788086,
0.06972670555114746,
0.5081519484519958,
-0.5686155557632446,
0.2729859948158264,
0.47930413484573364,
-0.24619527161121368,
0.208342045545578,
-0.5335002541542053,
0.056206561625003815,
-0.1757446825504303,
0.12856261432170868,
-1.181234359741211,
-0.22267988324165344,
0.32607191801071167,
-0.22602367401123047,
0.11982651054859161,
-0.10590627044439316,
-0.5528595447540283,
-0.47895732522010803,
-0.31171873211860657,
0.18399423360824585,
0.6020538806915283,
-0.46238380670547485,
0.8060373663902283,
0.29703572392463684,
0.20553657412528992,
-0.7306638956069946,
-0.7335981726646423,
0.15222357213497162,
0.01259196363389492,
-0.3058016300201416,
0.5704421401023865,
0.34742921590805054,
-0.2361287772655487,
0.38420963287353516,
-0.04375685378909111,
0.08476569503545761,
0.21316751837730408,
0.2707689702510834,
0.11146026849746704,
-0.20887070894241333,
0.20296569168567657,
-0.018645796924829483,
-0.20716620981693268,
0.07411138713359833,
-0.3958427906036377,
0.44518300890922546,
0.1801912784576416,
-0.6052205562591553,
-0.33614400029182434,
0.4567628502845764,
0.20243702828884125,
-0.09932835400104523,
0.7762346267700195,
0.2986418306827545,
-0.5372785329818726,
-0.08164647221565247,
-0.7909408211708069,
-0.12257254868745804,
-0.3797530233860016,
0.06600792706012726,
-0.30494701862335205,
-0.6498715877532959,
0.3860328495502472,
-0.04794279485940933,
0.15599370002746582,
0.5183814764022827,
0.10729704797267914,
0.08741962909698486,
0.45479223132133484,
0.7347227334976196,
0.3410978317260742,
0.16447092592716217,
-0.6757030487060547,
0.2848486006259918,
-0.9412015676498413,
-0.3850652575492859,
-0.5865302085876465,
0.05817250907421112,
-0.8108676075935364,
-0.2630128264427185,
-0.09327159076929092,
-0.02916613593697548,
0.29961276054382324,
0.45609328150749207,
-0.3051370680332184,
0.15515895187854767,
0.845137357711792,
0.01905699074268341,
0.7328693866729736,
-0.029470115900039673,
-0.16860204935073853,
0.11982584744691849,
-0.936083197593689,
-0.5742524862289429,
1.3756582736968994,
-0.09674815088510513,
0.25401896238327026,
0.28321313858032227,
0.8332591652870178,
0.1380550116300583,
0.24831530451774597,
-0.8791622519493103,
0.31008797883987427,
-0.2574123740196228,
-0.5887346267700195,
-0.24840769171714783,
-0.3656192421913147,
-0.9412079453468323,
0.1611245572566986,
-0.5829366445541382,
-0.7919469475746155,
0.10627083480358124,
-0.05191028118133545,
-0.5502044558525085,
0.30091434717178345,
-0.7537171244621277,
0.6157383322715759,
0.3160676956176758,
-0.0031969293486326933,
-0.34986963868141174,
-0.6594303846359253,
0.5004082322120667,
-0.3782631754875183,
0.2415371686220169,
-0.14806640148162842,
-0.26536473631858826,
0.8966202139854431,
-0.48004451394081116,
0.8081955313682556,
0.11209669709205627,
-0.21914902329444885,
0.42947572469711304,
-0.5700778961181641,
0.06805040687322617,
-0.19744226336479187,
-0.1733940839767456,
0.09233229607343674,
0.20261161029338837,
-0.48788705468177795,
-0.9867200255393982,
0.4113663136959076,
-0.62806636095047,
-0.6972312331199646,
-0.3449344038963318,
-0.24178461730480194,
-0.4360128939151764,
-0.039738789200782776,
0.29088079929351807,
0.5179397463798523,
-0.19749875366687775,
-0.0761980414390564,
0.6251254081726074,
-0.08958765864372253,
0.394937664270401,
0.32201388478279114,
-0.06715304404497147,
-0.09887626767158508,
0.7895767092704773,
0.43602192401885986,
0.44015535712242126,
0.4545668363571167,
0.022243887186050415,
-0.393997460603714,
-0.29426491260528564,
-0.22694653272628784,
0.249253049492836,
-0.6543706059455872,
0.04676016792654991,
-1.0640078783035278,
-0.4341510832309723,
-0.41614967584609985,
0.02834480255842209,
-0.41650933027267456,
-0.505521297454834,
-0.06674492359161377,
0.10449104011058807,
0.44825828075408936,
0.8930095434188843,
-0.07387696951627731,
0.19215059280395508,
-0.8593431115150452,
0.37268176674842834,
0.39382657408714294,
0.37902507185935974,
0.5164478421211243,
-0.3532698154449463,
0.028698625043034554,
0.18288633227348328,
-0.2617775797843933,
-0.5939756631851196,
-0.1970200091600418,
0.28289592266082764,
0.6718952655792236,
0.5883064866065979,
0.12409156560897827,
0.6216469407081604,
-0.3758048713207245,
0.5446635484695435,
0.32871755957603455,
-0.8243851065635681,
0.6506009697914124,
0.01335990522056818,
0.1488126516342163,
0.37718185782432556,
0.7949525713920593,
-0.559659481048584,
-0.4885150194168091,
-0.8680824041366577,
-0.7202974557876587,
0.4424511194229126,
0.31752973794937134,
0.004774358123540878,
-0.16581563651561737,
0.48553648591041565,
0.21072235703468323,
0.1242208257317543,
-0.1186893954873085,
-0.3852488398551941,
0.1734931766986847,
-0.12340467423200607,
-0.1570548564195633,
-0.18165023624897003,
-0.022513512521982193,
-0.16099736094474792,
0.4123600125312805,
-0.08524004369974136,
0.21149323880672455,
0.18013735115528107,
-0.11180532723665237,
0.1892751008272171,
0.28654736280441284,
0.02170218527317047,
0.6921238303184509,
-0.35918164253234863,
-0.08356596529483795,
0.252704918384552,
-0.283534973859787,
0.06844022125005722,
-0.1911909133195877,
-0.17177437245845795,
-0.04502641037106514,
0.7896929383277893,
0.5007071495056152,
0.21167448163032532,
-0.8204226493835449,
0.44203516840934753,
0.10818420350551605,
-0.2530725300312042,
-0.3538890779018402,
0.21425805985927582,
0.028551684692502022,
-0.06533564627170563,
0.6183596849441528,
0.09092938899993896,
0.35162174701690674,
-0.850647509098053,
0.17310720682144165,
0.6162343621253967,
-0.503057062625885,
-0.2305234968662262,
0.23428986966609955,
-0.12126483023166656,
-0.09623396396636963,
0.48918354511260986,
-0.455461323261261,
-0.6208797097206116,
0.5861005783081055,
0.3437742292881012,
0.6473567485809326,
0.21561285853385925,
0.1917523592710495,
0.26197385787963867,
0.32135140895843506,
-0.2207181602716446,
0.4851081073284149,
-0.07861227542161942,
-1.124077558517456,
-0.8050762414932251,
-0.6557598114013672,
-0.6946733593940735,
-0.4195038080215454,
-0.8846546411514282,
-0.03858203440904617,
-0.36999762058258057,
-0.27260464429855347,
0.21120424568653107,
0.06575071066617966,
-0.6932377219200134,
0.2649461627006531,
0.04480494186282158,
0.9395940899848938,
-1.042040228843689,
0.6199283599853516,
0.8466622233390808,
-0.37366917729377747,
-0.6376916170120239,
0.04504384100437164,
-0.008904426358640194,
-0.5735156536102295,
0.4642547369003296,
-0.01280871033668518,
-0.0055440207943320274,
0.12946093082427979,
-0.03453854098916054,
-1.1171106100082397,
0.9499138593673706,
-0.14345362782478333,
-0.21368056535720825,
-0.07303135842084885,
0.1652873307466507,
0.6055768132209778,
-0.4581775963306427,
0.23479129374027252,
0.872918426990509,
0.5340073704719543,
0.37774211168289185,
-0.8793957233428955,
0.2142161875963211,
0.040446601808071136,
0.26727649569511414,
0.1769677996635437,
-0.21611708402633667,
0.37248629331588745,
-0.2665404975414276,
-0.258463054895401,
0.36003196239471436,
0.6625833511352539,
-0.026132281869649887,
0.24742743372917175,
0.6072441339492798,
0.9131067991256714,
0.8915279507637024,
-0.17264007031917572,
1.1125435829162598,
-0.12138605117797852,
0.46189749240875244,
0.9327710270881653,
-0.3978167772293091,
1.0370240211486816,
0.44509556889533997,
-0.35590940713882446,
0.5431540608406067,
0.6268744468688965,
-0.025764888152480125,
0.6645435690879822,
0.032856158912181854,
-0.022393614053726196,
-0.33672794699668884,
-0.6405738592147827,
-0.532716691493988,
0.6608390808105469,
0.54990553855896,
0.04943709447979927,
-0.17452064156532288,
0.14865434169769287,
-0.43816301226615906,
0.003705374663695693,
-0.08380063623189926,
1.0638128519058228,
0.1689624935388565,
-0.8687288165092468,
0.49166905879974365,
-0.1284530907869339,
0.6890898942947388,
-0.4326816499233246,
0.029801426455378532,
-0.07997017353773117,
-0.1443483978509903,
-0.21773996949195862,
-0.6730578541755676,
0.6040583252906799,
-0.30759549140930176,
-0.25396308302879333,
0.05280710756778717,
0.5224782824516296,
-0.260742723941803,
-0.29869258403778076,
0.6687480807304382,
0.8264555335044861,
-0.18210192024707794,
0.22977061569690704,
-0.24298900365829468,
-0.3469710350036621,
-0.16256500780582428,
0.04834267497062683,
0.014757949858903885,
0.40833115577697754,
0.06836677342653275,
0.8399561643600464,
0.4801488220691681,
-0.056778937578201294,
-0.03291923552751541,
-0.10364751517772675,
0.5500094294548035,
-0.7277164459228516,
-0.12848109006881714,
-0.8017710447311401,
0.12669655680656433,
-0.23847004771232605,
-0.2660629451274872,
0.833568811416626,
0.42686042189598083,
0.801206111907959,
0.02036217227578163,
0.90807044506073,
-0.31568780541419983,
0.6697207689285278,
-0.5824059247970581,
0.37700241804122925,
-0.8382865786552429,
0.27582746744155884,
-0.5659757852554321,
-0.8944283723831177,
-0.4446001648902893,
0.2858388125896454,
-0.2834978699684143,
-0.0798332467675209,
0.9183768033981323,
0.5505034327507019,
-0.14732591807842255,
0.38647088408470154,
0.18723247945308685,
-0.12802797555923462,
-0.40139323472976685,
0.42207062244415283,
1.1357749700546265,
-0.5129489302635193,
0.1527036726474762,
-0.1535179167985916,
-0.35233932733535767,
0.02348482236266136,
-0.708767294883728,
-0.7833777666091919,
-0.520641028881073,
-0.5357904434204102,
-0.3485453426837921,
-0.022409331053495407,
0.984630823135376,
0.5081413388252258,
-0.9134109020233154,
-0.049756523221731186,
-0.0995807945728302,
0.39461469650268555,
-0.21897344291210175,
-0.11405530571937561,
0.21092769503593445,
-0.4565228521823883,
-0.6078157424926758,
0.07350198179483414,
0.3383895754814148,
-0.14398521184921265,
-0.20026813447475433,
0.09185250103473663,
-0.5983140468597412,
0.06157807260751724,
0.44057226181030273,
0.23433056473731995,
-1.114714503288269,
-0.27818435430526733,
-0.08728426694869995,
0.04108810797333717,
-0.05991015583276749,
0.6122055649757385,
-0.7820029258728027,
0.3673606514930725,
0.3330232799053192,
0.8468305468559265,
0.2010233998298645,
-0.1778569221496582,
0.7348676323890686,
-0.6599704623222351,
0.02636118046939373,
-0.14302492141723633,
0.38099852204322815,
0.2977488934993744,
0.08094874024391174,
0.8835552930831909,
0.37541645765304565,
0.19039583206176758,
-0.8002362847328186,
0.1456926017999649,
-0.878609299659729,
-0.21021756529808044,
0.9762391448020935,
-0.14478982985019684,
-0.26992905139923096,
-0.4050787091255188,
0.22528904676437378,
0.29482096433639526,
0.15841317176818848,
0.5772413611412048,
0.7595022916793823,
0.1542430967092514,
0.25451192259788513,
-0.5173189043998718,
0.40873852372169495,
0.5284771919250488,
-0.45045286417007446,
-0.37495702505111694,
-0.07511082291603088,
0.20498964190483093,
0.7569723725318909,
0.39246729016304016,
0.2771095037460327,
0.22800441086292267,
-0.008539588190615177,
0.19026517868041992,
0.6137634515762329,
0.028525184839963913,
0.02089782990515232,
0.2615385949611664,
0.019349975511431694,
0.011694195680320263
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17199v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17199v1
|
Extracting Social Support and Social Isolation Information from Clinical Psychiatry Notes: Comparing a Rule-based NLP System and a Large Language Model
| 2024-03-25T21:19:50 | 2024-03-25T21:19:50 |
Braja Gopal Patra, Lauren A. Lepow, Praneet Kasi Reddy Jagadeesh Kumar, Veer Vekaria, Mohit Manoj Sharma, Prakash Adekkanattu, Brian Fennessy, Gavin Hynes, Isotta Landi, Jorge A. Sanchez-Ruiz, Euijung Ryu, Joanna M. Biernacka, Girish N. Nadkarni, Ardesheer Talati, Myrna Weissman, Mark Olfson, J. John Mann, Alexander W. Charney, Jyotishman Pathak
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Background: Social support (SS) and social isolation (SI) are social
determinants of health (SDOH) associated with psychiatric outcomes. In
electronic health records (EHRs), individual-level SS/SI is typically
documented as narrative clinical notes rather than structured coded data.
Natural language processing (NLP) algorithms can automate the otherwise
labor-intensive process of data extraction.
Data and Methods: Psychiatric encounter notes from Mount Sinai Health System
(MSHS, n=300) and Weill Cornell Medicine (WCM, n=225) were annotated and
established a gold standard corpus. A rule-based system (RBS) involving
lexicons and a large language model (LLM) using FLAN-T5-XL were developed to
identify mentions of SS and SI and their subcategories (e.g., social network,
instrumental support, and loneliness).
Results: For extracting SS/SI, the RBS obtained higher macro-averaged
f-scores than the LLM at both MSHS (0.89 vs. 0.65) and WCM (0.85 vs. 0.82). For
extracting subcategories, the RBS also outperformed the LLM at both MSHS (0.90
vs. 0.62) and WCM (0.82 vs. 0.81).
Discussion and Conclusion: Unexpectedly, the RBS outperformed the LLMs across
all metrics. Intensive review demonstrates that this finding is due to the
divergent approach taken by the RBS and LLM. The RBS were designed and refined
to follow the same specific rules as the gold standard annotations. Conversely,
the LLM were more inclusive with categorization and conformed to common
English-language understanding. Both approaches offer advantages and are made
available open-source for future testing.
|
[
-0.41062161326408386,
-0.7185575366020203,
0.79188472032547,
0.44740113615989685,
-0.24883025884628296,
0.022909801453351974,
-0.27900752425193787,
-0.6884275078773499,
0.718252420425415,
0.4443362355232239,
-0.48525357246398926,
-0.9663072824478149,
-0.8794127106666565,
0.2902221083641052,
-0.21997150778770447,
1.305649757385254,
-0.017241572961211205,
-0.0035973258782178164,
0.028306221589446068,
-0.1172027736902237,
-0.054239869117736816,
-0.587828516960144,
-0.6877164244651794,
-0.18136096000671387,
0.6420698761940002,
0.26259472966194153,
0.569406270980835,
0.4073755443096161,
0.8657234907150269,
0.18096011877059937,
-0.320394366979599,
0.23390716314315796,
-0.25444358587265015,
-0.00914633646607399,
-0.2004382461309433,
0.0030903792940080166,
-0.7523872256278992,
-0.26161134243011475,
0.2675248682498932,
0.6298522353172302,
-0.3905330002307892,
0.3436587154865265,
0.2835164964199066,
0.6706823706626892,
-0.5572777986526489,
0.3686421513557434,
-0.16909685730934143,
0.08186086267232895,
-0.39272114634513855,
-0.043856918811798096,
-0.3401707410812378,
-0.46736904978752136,
0.27107831835746765,
-0.5341664552688599,
0.308185338973999,
-0.06925750523805618,
0.7729365825653076,
-0.15234433114528656,
-0.10229112207889557,
-0.33504974842071533,
-0.7178804874420166,
0.4848769009113312,
-0.7940232157707214,
0.09284012019634247,
0.5733438730239868,
0.18732251226902008,
-0.22930504381656647,
-0.41870585083961487,
-0.26560887694358826,
-0.08095656335353851,
-0.3169073462486267,
0.04368695616722107,
-0.14154189825057983,
0.24146899580955505,
0.49597248435020447,
0.40451958775520325,
-0.49794498085975647,
-0.05888251215219498,
-0.7877113819122314,
-0.029235146939754486,
0.9541311860084534,
0.27744510769844055,
0.3964861333370209,
-0.5630398392677307,
0.03301544114947319,
0.17174585163593292,
-0.3109116852283478,
0.14637982845306396,
-0.10258012264966965,
0.2706362009048462,
-0.39897823333740234,
0.7557603120803833,
-0.20507104694843292,
0.042722053825855255,
-0.22458037734031677,
-0.2637619376182556,
0.38493824005126953,
-0.17902515828609467,
0.09634692221879959,
0.1839345097541809,
1.084526777267456,
0.5560656785964966,
0.3058294951915741,
-0.30669745802879333,
-0.22154563665390015,
0.3499554395675659,
0.09403306990861893,
-0.2586807608604431,
-0.2106146514415741,
0.08287552744150162,
-0.9297021627426147,
-0.0801786407828331,
0.1594168245792389,
-1.0486810207366943,
-0.581169843673706,
-0.28923290967941284,
0.1912565529346466,
-0.4617001414299011,
-0.5069639086723328,
0.05399805307388306,
-0.37873074412345886,
0.2553263306617737,
0.4475995600223541,
-0.8983550071716309,
0.9165741205215454,
0.7596026062965393,
1.2968931198120117,
-0.5078135132789612,
0.03365502506494522,
-0.5819118022918701,
0.0841694176197052,
-0.09473448246717453,
0.6387801170349121,
-0.3193007707595825,
-0.4387650787830353,
0.05489020794630051,
0.3853685259819031,
-0.2370598167181015,
-0.5858155488967896,
0.5673942565917969,
-0.025827929377555847,
0.18035230040550232,
-0.41884952783584595,
-0.3853500485420227,
0.20711037516593933,
-0.15660840272903442,
-0.632424533367157,
0.942716121673584,
0.35848477482795715,
-0.8023828864097595,
0.14553172886371613,
-0.6190642714500427,
-0.44235384464263916,
0.23760239779949188,
-0.3100317716598511,
-0.18960753083229065,
0.08408717066049576,
0.13566796481609344,
0.4718880355358124,
-0.28016626834869385,
0.2613799273967743,
-0.7360005974769592,
-0.4128037691116333,
0.05163540691137314,
-0.1131318137049675,
0.8076140880584717,
0.05878157168626785,
-0.5312384366989136,
-0.18330885469913483,
-0.9556684494018555,
-0.3616599440574646,
0.2432851344347,
-0.26221907138824463,
-0.706667423248291,
0.22088146209716797,
0.1064755916595459,
0.4071996212005615,
-0.09335611760616302,
-0.7105081081390381,
-0.23147979378700256,
-0.3498587906360626,
0.16942042112350464,
0.6240407228469849,
0.2137279212474823,
0.138022318482399,
-0.3498777151107788,
0.622774600982666,
-0.10072494298219681,
0.17746317386627197,
0.17014314234256744,
-0.5619141459465027,
-0.24312551319599152,
-0.39168110489845276,
0.07409529387950897,
0.7035745978355408,
-0.3137914538383484,
0.5702010989189148,
-0.10734221339225769,
-0.21161611378192902,
-0.7381468415260315,
0.07909633964300156,
0.25507858395576477,
0.2575596272945404,
0.6180607080459595,
-0.5160624384880066,
-0.6948562264442444,
-0.7800140976905823,
-0.03963005542755127,
-0.009286019951105118,
-0.05476099252700806,
0.2563791871070862,
0.35888946056365967,
-0.30506253242492676,
0.6999648213386536,
-0.5571789741516113,
-0.47504469752311707,
-0.5310112237930298,
-0.08970477432012558,
0.14338675141334534,
0.24770760536193848,
0.24184447526931763,
-0.2607380151748657,
-0.4562799334526062,
0.09495297074317932,
-0.8515673279762268,
-0.3517298400402069,
0.26892757415771484,
-0.01881350763142109,
0.29401862621307373,
0.42320340871810913,
-0.7273874878883362,
0.7551053166389465,
0.32690495252609253,
-0.33923816680908203,
0.5151561498641968,
-0.1594303548336029,
-0.1763751357793808,
-1.0769115686416626,
0.01521951612085104,
0.5307347178459167,
-0.10959567874670029,
-0.5162495374679565,
-0.42656007409095764,
-0.1821136176586151,
-0.005822374951094389,
-0.021408336237072945,
0.23987668752670288,
-0.37287867069244385,
0.05620935931801796,
0.035585321485996246,
0.40453773736953735,
-0.013022143393754959,
0.2538430988788605,
0.2379671186208725,
0.09924139827489853,
0.3620232939720154,
-0.3968846797943115,
0.1572919487953186,
0.11428267508745193,
-0.1973029524087906,
0.39385494589805603,
-0.718621551990509,
-0.15039440989494324,
-0.3137837052345276,
0.09148383140563965,
-1.0448808670043945,
-0.18891389667987823,
0.37481147050857544,
-0.24416238069534302,
-0.010569688864052296,
0.0906062051653862,
-0.31010526418685913,
-0.11885718256235123,
-0.4142586588859558,
-0.08423931151628494,
0.45104560256004333,
-0.00653625326231122,
0.3571212887763977,
0.6552624106407166,
-0.7400825023651123,
-0.2048129439353943,
-0.39574721455574036,
0.008953367359936237,
-0.37616294622421265,
-0.2234136462211609,
0.3547843098640442,
0.06955397874116898,
-0.730297863483429,
0.012272334657609463,
-0.047808270901441574,
0.132234588265419,
0.1292750984430313,
0.40456509590148926,
0.5166853666305542,
-0.3238717019557953,
-0.007796230725944042,
0.20038630068302155,
-0.000376961863366887,
0.5157114267349243,
0.48329591751098633,
0.551671028137207,
-0.12509484589099884,
-0.17945241928100586,
-0.6155897378921509,
0.7553435564041138,
0.6716252565383911,
-0.05674588680267334,
0.9147971272468567,
0.415667325258255,
-0.4862744212150574,
-0.13488957285881042,
-0.5067324042320251,
-0.1179439052939415,
-0.3696628212928772,
0.11228322982788086,
-0.040984801948070526,
-0.6535550951957703,
0.4741579294204712,
0.20160812139511108,
0.11950133740901947,
0.4343297779560089,
0.1296604573726654,
-0.07198039442300797,
1.309800624847412,
0.6040749549865723,
-0.26770174503326416,
0.43978041410446167,
0.06082313507795334,
0.28947991132736206,
-0.8679680228233337,
-0.27178245782852173,
-0.5346696972846985,
-0.04231182113289833,
-0.8025930523872375,
0.09031401574611664,
0.36025601625442505,
-0.05875706672668457,
0.07867845892906189,
0.059085000306367874,
-0.42409467697143555,
0.029077868908643723,
0.14530278742313385,
0.5872710347175598,
0.20657797157764435,
0.14434285461902618,
-0.07186316698789597,
-0.29675182700157166,
-0.4754771292209625,
-0.5290685296058655,
1.0545849800109863,
0.5587239861488342,
0.5108023285865784,
0.30807745456695557,
0.8772379755973816,
0.5773745179176331,
0.5222548246383667,
-0.5274338722229004,
0.6914302110671997,
-0.44519370794296265,
-0.2787073254585266,
-0.1887919306755066,
-0.42245563864707947,
-0.7941338419914246,
0.22963400185108185,
-0.32212570309638977,
-1.164538860321045,
0.23660002648830414,
-0.28023362159729004,
-0.6165565848350525,
0.051125168800354004,
-0.8269811272621155,
0.637230396270752,
-0.01753690280020237,
-0.24461619555950165,
-0.07582595944404602,
-0.7988746166229248,
0.3882202208042145,
-0.06616099923849106,
0.46161743998527527,
-0.25121429562568665,
0.2361830621957779,
0.9344446659088135,
-0.42213740944862366,
0.7006456255912781,
-0.145573690533638,
0.009193191304802895,
-0.01604716293513775,
0.0548129566013813,
0.2870549261569977,
0.082401342689991,
-0.25015875697135925,
0.17608632147312164,
0.5937238335609436,
-0.059356968849897385,
-0.5589370131492615,
0.5459564924240112,
-0.8017831444740295,
-0.6560747623443604,
-0.5515415072441101,
-0.39079129695892334,
0.07964986562728882,
0.0923992171883583,
0.06442653387784958,
0.6515236496925354,
0.026807785034179688,
0.29079562425613403,
0.5681446194648743,
-0.3229871094226837,
0.3212711215019226,
0.6003771424293518,
-0.2355668842792511,
-0.750697910785675,
0.6043271422386169,
0.2894201874732971,
0.27020594477653503,
0.07417509704828262,
0.45918211340904236,
-0.18364927172660828,
-0.22912023961544037,
-0.1859131157398224,
0.9028538465499878,
-0.4708349406719208,
0.22724011540412903,
-0.9579556584358215,
-0.48241347074508667,
-0.9378635287284851,
0.04842142388224602,
0.03720230981707573,
-0.4352656602859497,
-0.12112158536911011,
-0.2333972305059433,
0.4387296438217163,
0.9673901796340942,
-0.12382609397172928,
-0.02115684561431408,
-0.9359195828437805,
0.4656310975551605,
-0.3966609239578247,
0.3608347773551941,
-0.033224280923604965,
-0.24928875267505646,
-0.20458032190799713,
-0.259374737739563,
-0.05861274152994156,
-1.235491156578064,
0.41102340817451477,
0.09836971759796143,
0.5225396156311035,
0.6128602623939514,
0.3042437732219696,
0.9122061133384705,
-0.32941487431526184,
0.817158043384552,
0.11350826174020767,
-0.7997445464134216,
0.6456938982009888,
-0.3383786380290985,
0.09932312369346619,
0.676585853099823,
0.6026634573936462,
-0.7583300471305847,
-0.6344080567359924,
-0.7859820127487183,
-1.0818737745285034,
1.013443112373352,
-0.050882380455732346,
-0.4694773554801941,
-0.33549031615257263,
0.6391370296478271,
-0.09592713415622711,
0.23892338573932648,
-0.7390088438987732,
-0.40490248799324036,
0.31480616331100464,
-0.5669501423835754,
-0.4280511736869812,
-0.4500269591808319,
-0.22585952281951904,
-0.33959171175956726,
0.3931681215763092,
0.13426269590854645,
0.21409156918525696,
0.6307612657546997,
0.19070859253406525,
-0.27511224150657654,
0.2604731619358063,
0.4104970693588257,
0.634934663772583,
-0.37332186102867126,
0.3311289846897125,
0.10243622958660126,
-0.7238725423812866,
-0.12841324508190155,
0.2647051513195038,
-0.2342841476202011,
0.39146196842193604,
0.37001997232437134,
0.5087293982505798,
0.050948597490787506,
-0.714460551738739,
0.49165841937065125,
-0.28690531849861145,
-0.26173195242881775,
-0.537851870059967,
0.11954965442419052,
-0.07132618874311447,
0.1648053079843521,
0.04438149183988571,
-0.2868592143058777,
0.1640225648880005,
-0.4667331576347351,
0.21510040760040283,
0.42917945981025696,
-0.5419498682022095,
-0.5247765779495239,
0.2880796790122986,
-0.25496596097946167,
-0.7217565178871155,
0.2441125512123108,
-0.10070385783910751,
-0.10160181671380997,
0.4510017931461334,
0.6758130192756653,
0.8099977970123291,
-0.19257648289203644,
0.4515420198440552,
0.31545135378837585,
0.4431595206260681,
-0.34228992462158203,
0.39017051458358765,
-0.2754800617694855,
-0.4088529348373413,
-0.054742611944675446,
-0.4790799915790558,
-0.40628689527511597,
0.32572364807128906,
-1.1161162853240967,
0.3069581091403961,
-0.6569748520851135,
-0.1763024926185608,
-0.03729674220085144,
0.10128229856491089,
-0.3003530502319336,
0.03628058731555939,
0.2246779054403305,
0.7617791891098022,
-1.0139108896255493,
0.42640310525894165,
0.9389191269874573,
-0.35655319690704346,
-0.8918128609657288,
0.03289298713207245,
0.32620736956596375,
-0.08134077489376068,
0.13923676311969757,
0.2660408318042755,
-0.032641541212797165,
-0.3817363381385803,
-0.21212543547153473,
-0.8935786485671997,
0.9613770842552185,
0.08350957185029984,
-0.4040064513683319,
-0.05243675783276558,
0.2388806939125061,
0.8282200694084167,
-0.3957423269748688,
0.3903026580810547,
0.8319580554962158,
0.12382391840219498,
-0.19635573029518127,
-0.9002572298049927,
0.17858317494392395,
-0.5964713096618652,
-0.3130224049091339,
0.2655423581600189,
-0.5154368877410889,
0.5641483068466187,
0.03547003120183945,
-0.2825339436531067,
-0.2022918462753296,
0.24306324124336243,
0.6211246252059937,
0.8331941962242126,
0.5825017690658569,
0.4120895266532898,
0.8384353518486023,
0.15357351303100586,
0.7324508428573608,
-0.21776899695396423,
0.08871298283338547,
0.9887735247612,
-0.8190177083015442,
0.8201751112937927,
0.5259056091308594,
-0.12783631682395935,
0.7950878739356995,
0.5531011819839478,
0.4082319438457489,
0.4316753149032593,
-0.005415783729404211,
-0.4335736632347107,
0.22531481087207794,
-0.18296752870082855,
-0.26764601469039917,
0.04627900570631027,
0.6447039842605591,
-0.6640259027481079,
-0.15149186551570892,
-0.23899908363819122,
0.1927003115415573,
-0.04989615082740784,
-0.11669376492500305,
1.084114909172058,
0.4124339818954468,
-0.6809312105178833,
0.2152670919895172,
0.002366124652326107,
0.30611470341682434,
-0.8842670917510986,
-0.13050134479999542,
-0.18169865012168884,
0.4153677225112915,
-0.5100296139717102,
-0.42884334921836853,
0.49303215742111206,
0.317328542470932,
-0.24437789618968964,
-0.13794101774692535,
0.7706307172775269,
-0.24388636648654938,
-0.5443255305290222,
0.7008938789367676,
0.4946996867656708,
0.25423869490623474,
0.32210612297058105,
-0.5522663593292236,
-0.07595466077327728,
-0.04939592257142067,
-0.18382497131824493,
0.5332123637199402,
0.6317617297172546,
-0.26323604583740234,
0.4504978358745575,
0.5765231847763062,
0.8530973196029663,
0.01891053281724453,
0.2818053960800171,
0.7748351097106934,
-0.7540127635002136,
-0.5453319549560547,
-1.0289196968078613,
0.14667627215385437,
-0.36442795395851135,
-0.3331802785396576,
0.9585877656936646,
0.42815083265304565,
0.38219931721687317,
0.2937926650047302,
0.8286962509155273,
-0.20793336629867554,
0.8281346559524536,
-0.22307099401950836,
0.46221843361854553,
-0.5463616251945496,
0.43936699628829956,
-0.8591693639755249,
-0.6374242305755615,
-0.3665548861026764,
0.545364260673523,
-0.5819931626319885,
-0.42410531640052795,
0.8944555521011353,
0.8840217590332031,
0.044803135097026825,
0.2559565305709839,
-0.06932557374238968,
0.020976237952709198,
0.400799959897995,
0.3925604820251465,
0.6887053847312927,
-0.18064802885055542,
0.17495228350162506,
-0.45341023802757263,
-0.42593613266944885,
0.12869784235954285,
-0.4480745494365692,
-0.6549381613731384,
-0.18657666444778442,
-0.346834659576416,
-0.7401896119117737,
0.12068472802639008,
1.441049575805664,
0.19910882413387299,
-0.7953180074691772,
-0.47378844022750854,
0.1092015951871872,
0.16956284642219543,
-0.5723150372505188,
-0.3430383503437042,
0.44798803329467773,
-0.08662750571966171,
-0.1503896564245224,
0.13643571734428406,
0.3657134175300598,
-0.29266202449798584,
-0.35118862986564636,
0.027705077081918716,
-0.21666762232780457,
-0.20769952237606049,
0.5968185067176819,
0.0765276551246643,
-0.44888558983802795,
-0.130398228764534,
0.14550146460533142,
-0.29522639513015747,
-0.009012325666844845,
0.611287534236908,
-0.28660282492637634,
0.16514533758163452,
0.4407050907611847,
0.3466503918170929,
0.11302009224891663,
0.28338712453842163,
0.4797426462173462,
-0.2120158076286316,
-0.12573108077049255,
0.03358402103185654,
0.4738720655441284,
0.13703739643096924,
-0.6446229219436646,
0.3827275037765503,
0.5273440480232239,
-0.4651985764503479,
-0.8629701137542725,
-0.19740064442157745,
-0.8968858122825623,
0.002909567207098007,
1.441262125968933,
-0.28301098942756653,
-0.551962673664093,
-0.6657688617706299,
-0.31289398670196533,
0.11429112404584885,
-0.5986511707305908,
1.0914021730422974,
0.7391172647476196,
-0.25185641646385193,
-0.3552356958389282,
-0.7343952655792236,
0.46710777282714844,
0.26454100012779236,
-0.6222168803215027,
0.002803197829052806,
0.4640771746635437,
0.27551373839378357,
0.17010155320167542,
1.0716359615325928,
-0.4833187460899353,
0.2628025412559509,
-0.3976718783378601,
0.083524189889431,
0.4094465374946594,
-0.15151184797286987,
-0.6204941868782043,
0.42891210317611694,
-0.12495066970586777,
-0.04026912897825241
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17196v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17196v1
|
GPT-4 Understands Discourse at Least as Well as Humans Do
| 2024-03-25T21:17:14 | 2024-03-25T21:17:14 |
Thomas Shultz, Jamie Wise, Ardavan Salehi Nobandegani
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We test whether a leading AI system GPT-4 understands discourse as well as
humans do, using a standardized test of discourse comprehension. Participants
are presented with brief stories and then answer eight yes/no questions probing
their comprehension of the story. The questions are formatted to assess the
separate impacts of directness (stated vs. implied) and salience (main idea vs.
details). GPT-4 performs slightly, but not statistically significantly, better
than humans given the very high level of human performance. Both GPT-4 and
humans exhibit a strong ability to make inferences about information that is
not explicitly stated in a story, a critical test of understanding.
|
[
-0.5580849051475525,
-0.8739485740661621,
1.0196800231933594,
0.13891862332820892,
-0.27963143587112427,
0.24252133071422577,
0.03995866701006889,
-0.7636097073554993,
-0.21375717222690582,
0.021493712440133095,
-0.3352549076080322,
-0.2505561411380768,
-0.5419757962226868,
0.5182828903198242,
-0.056505657732486725,
1.2764849662780762,
-0.07168973237276077,
0.09592568129301071,
-0.11419446766376495,
0.05876734480261803,
-0.3785960078239441,
-0.6713042855262756,
-0.7612131834030151,
-0.552834689617157,
0.48935654759407043,
0.2808650732040405,
0.7257899045944214,
0.2278362512588501,
0.5388687252998352,
0.3367479741573334,
-0.05048634484410286,
-0.3441976308822632,
-0.3178046643733978,
0.008288372308015823,
-0.33568957448005676,
-0.5429365634918213,
-0.2878764569759369,
0.28416121006011963,
0.6104647517204285,
0.5614981651306152,
0.11587083339691162,
0.19814877212047577,
0.2454102337360382,
0.1674337536096573,
-0.18843644857406616,
0.4093358516693115,
-0.29716143012046814,
0.16123363375663757,
-0.13083525002002716,
-0.054864611476659775,
-0.2798239588737488,
-0.47032007575035095,
0.48133790493011475,
-0.8880083560943604,
0.3885749578475952,
0.028926212340593338,
1.1057026386260986,
0.29324549436569214,
-0.7554048895835876,
-0.12009776383638382,
-0.44696947932243347,
0.3760874569416046,
-0.4353121221065521,
0.23093588650226593,
0.5988149046897888,
0.17731526494026184,
0.1825263351202011,
-0.9281386733055115,
-0.7424257397651672,
-0.27926450967788696,
-0.3734205663204193,
0.44857409596443176,
0.09508351236581802,
0.42441797256469727,
0.5523868799209595,
0.4984108507633209,
-1.0164964199066162,
-0.19798140227794647,
-0.6070510149002075,
-0.2698744535446167,
0.4459478259086609,
-0.04513316601514816,
0.3455561399459839,
-0.32597577571868896,
-0.42277997732162476,
0.22156643867492676,
-0.34542542695999146,
0.19279760122299194,
0.2943396270275116,
-0.22121182084083557,
0.12166466563940048,
0.2634148597717285,
0.013650363311171532,
0.5033827424049377,
0.1762467920780182,
0.06808575242757797,
0.24781756103038788,
-0.7246529459953308,
-0.30796948075294495,
-0.04891080781817436,
0.6554202437400818,
0.29180535674095154,
0.2458227276802063,
-0.1823156625032425,
-0.03432349115610123,
0.3321189880371094,
0.3574829399585724,
-0.7395104169845581,
-0.328538715839386,
-0.1253834068775177,
-0.2858221232891083,
-0.1350104659795761,
-0.17838367819786072,
-0.4988405406475067,
-0.26831749081611633,
-0.3586415648460388,
0.49990350008010864,
-0.661978542804718,
-0.1129118949174881,
0.1694200038909912,
-0.623298168182373,
0.9296902418136597,
0.4435594081878662,
-1.0784368515014648,
0.7066560387611389,
0.7182276248931885,
0.9422313570976257,
-0.36507731676101685,
-0.43042007088661194,
-0.3921850323677063,
-0.01614920236170292,
-0.3129359483718872,
1.1638929843902588,
-0.4565156400203705,
-0.3859216868877411,
-0.500373363494873,
-0.1660124510526657,
-0.2563891112804413,
-0.36645832657814026,
0.8966348171234131,
-0.4449099600315094,
0.455284059047699,
-0.770748496055603,
-0.517295777797699,
-0.4437768757343292,
0.7155642509460449,
-0.45579057931900024,
0.8481435179710388,
0.3089316487312317,
-1.0108990669250488,
0.4926137328147888,
-1.014045000076294,
-0.532255232334137,
0.2679896056652069,
-0.5337187051773071,
-0.1495891958475113,
-0.1226009950041771,
0.3156594932079315,
0.1757192760705948,
-0.19672994315624237,
0.279866099357605,
0.15860296785831451,
-0.6774700880050659,
0.20800665020942688,
-0.43776607513427734,
0.4785102307796478,
-0.09326615184545517,
-0.6479905247688293,
0.07395638525485992,
-0.30930495262145996,
0.13544368743896484,
0.10198134183883667,
-0.3605666160583496,
0.01982966437935829,
-0.33635449409484863,
-0.38876235485076904,
0.11136038601398468,
0.07877249270677567,
-0.6394596099853516,
0.36391445994377136,
-0.4592921733856201,
0.6242839694023132,
0.7034359574317932,
0.4115334153175354,
0.387432336807251,
-0.4678727090358734,
0.8217350244522095,
-0.12913036346435547,
0.03888077288866043,
-0.2193106859922409,
-1.0208524465560913,
-0.5121572613716125,
0.005390206817537546,
0.2515721619129181,
0.8337289690971375,
-1.0329526662826538,
-0.05181628465652466,
-0.01838243193924427,
-0.15441665053367615,
-0.4200240969657898,
-0.31337448954582214,
0.4452880024909973,
0.7728002667427063,
0.27308234572410583,
-0.43065759539604187,
-0.3937695622444153,
-0.8985950350761414,
-0.3226179778575897,
-0.4847019910812378,
-0.24915260076522827,
0.2975039780139923,
0.7220990657806396,
0.06627710908651352,
0.7161866426467896,
-0.46871817111968994,
0.15063989162445068,
-0.28679394721984863,
0.5795754790306091,
0.08539522439241409,
0.08501080423593521,
0.3966100215911865,
-0.8769652247428894,
-0.44618579745292664,
0.07082539051771164,
-0.9149208068847656,
-0.028194651007652283,
-0.09152495861053467,
0.10874281823635101,
-0.10042563080787659,
-0.06529142707586288,
-0.7537451386451721,
0.622769296169281,
0.34044596552848816,
-0.7094759345054626,
0.738736629486084,
-0.28844353556632996,
0.360171914100647,
-0.5228655934333801,
0.11380235105752945,
-0.14185693860054016,
-0.356153666973114,
-0.6382813453674316,
-0.14882920682430267,
-0.013658169656991959,
-0.21135790646076202,
-0.19639217853546143,
0.28997576236724854,
-0.48875367641448975,
-0.657662570476532,
0.13356004655361176,
0.25841161608695984,
0.28953543305397034,
0.5927014946937561,
-0.015253146179020405,
1.3033941984176636,
0.4721529185771942,
-0.5223167538642883,
0.188496395945549,
0.3906509280204773,
-0.2672670781612396,
0.8727660775184631,
-0.9580783247947693,
0.6313378810882568,
-0.21047712862491608,
0.275086373090744,
-1.1846708059310913,
-0.3983093202114105,
0.26226112246513367,
-0.6262995600700378,
-0.03561237081885338,
0.15097171068191528,
-0.3037154972553253,
-0.47651156783103943,
-0.21080023050308228,
0.29493752121925354,
0.4048255681991577,
-0.13284315168857574,
0.6269519925117493,
0.2566818296909332,
-0.46539050340652466,
-0.42642465233802795,
-0.7193130850791931,
0.29867634177207947,
-0.29917970299720764,
-0.6496574878692627,
0.3013555407524109,
-0.24445928633213043,
-0.3181048333644867,
-0.22590968012809753,
0.13537850975990295,
-0.49971574544906616,
0.0017790040001273155,
0.19123640656471252,
0.08181774616241455,
-0.3446977734565735,
0.08303721249103546,
-0.06397253274917603,
-0.20838560163974762,
0.15343719720840454,
-0.07887241244316101,
0.359040230512619,
-0.5887725353240967,
-0.3254232704639435,
-0.7810461521148682,
0.2841746509075165,
0.45372676849365234,
-0.25082388520240784,
0.14371822774410248,
0.5863763093948364,
-0.05846436694264412,
0.4856499135494232,
-0.287880539894104,
-0.3664911985397339,
-0.4812330901622772,
0.2505408823490143,
-0.8199340105056763,
-0.8414006233215332,
0.5118675231933594,
0.04221881926059723,
0.028575347736477852,
0.45761480927467346,
0.37410300970077515,
-0.057923488318920135,
0.9472734332084656,
0.2211400270462036,
-0.015342344529926777,
-0.10125243663787842,
-0.17466920614242554,
0.16582395136356354,
-0.6643495559692383,
-0.00009734006016515195,
-0.4952825605869293,
-0.434271901845932,
-0.3991878628730774,
-0.3894576132297516,
0.3690143823623657,
-0.24475987255573273,
-0.5971754193305969,
-0.03894777595996857,
-0.7146895527839661,
0.6916555762290955,
0.592786431312561,
-0.000009556480108585674,
0.6851713061332703,
-0.5436442494392395,
0.009080336429178715,
-0.23771660029888153,
-0.18676184117794037,
-0.7910366654396057,
0.8429197669029236,
0.40088558197021484,
0.3309181034564972,
0.28378504514694214,
0.5733146667480469,
0.21718455851078033,
0.4104321599006653,
-0.7952079176902771,
0.4915149509906769,
0.3309464752674103,
-0.795019805431366,
-0.35329777002334595,
-0.20423391461372375,
-1.1117862462997437,
0.3829169273376465,
0.13439255952835083,
-0.6398550271987915,
-0.05365868657827377,
-0.016403188928961754,
-0.6323934197425842,
0.11061020195484161,
-1.05198073387146,
0.9018061757087708,
-0.35466474294662476,
-0.03932441398501396,
0.10037301480770111,
-0.9011964201927185,
0.35754141211509705,
-0.012597236782312393,
0.14254048466682434,
0.05894770100712776,
-0.3580325245857239,
0.7942045331001282,
0.19709908962249756,
0.7450135946273804,
-0.26393643021583557,
0.17958810925483704,
0.4206829071044922,
-0.0540321059525013,
0.174187570810318,
0.2737681567668915,
-0.19537581503391266,
0.11402182281017303,
-0.06784030795097351,
-0.4048939347267151,
-0.7084351778030396,
0.229786679148674,
-1.1048251390457153,
-0.7550345659255981,
-0.721316933631897,
-0.4644574224948883,
-0.15677763521671295,
0.24071840941905975,
0.3713797628879547,
-0.016832979395985603,
-0.599257230758667,
-0.3110063970088959,
0.5605171918869019,
-0.19625253975391388,
0.2332180291414261,
0.49243098497390747,
-0.14856338500976562,
-0.22393286228179932,
0.4031747877597809,
0.07321563363075256,
0.27455809712409973,
0.1634301096200943,
0.37842026352882385,
-0.40000203251838684,
-0.6332840919494629,
-0.7010405659675598,
0.36344560980796814,
-0.6233770847320557,
0.12857535481452942,
-0.7197765707969666,
-0.27675893902778625,
-0.22106675803661346,
-0.04357453063130379,
0.07550939917564392,
-0.2017640769481659,
-0.16738064587116241,
-0.6677550673484802,
0.18432991206645966,
1.403873085975647,
-0.01225133053958416,
0.1256532520055771,
-0.4954427182674408,
0.4046526551246643,
0.7305840253829956,
0.06611655652523041,
-0.4324969947338104,
-0.5617378950119019,
0.3093683123588562,
-0.11921902745962143,
-0.7678824067115784,
-1.020888328552246,
0.03132402524352074,
0.17830587923526764,
0.3776622712612152,
0.34567925333976746,
-0.16505217552185059,
0.5943389534950256,
-0.8589837551116943,
1.3160449266433716,
-0.08307529240846634,
-1.2071598768234253,
0.42866596579551697,
-0.5892723798751831,
0.4308146834373474,
0.6094309687614441,
0.5585314631462097,
-0.5047687292098999,
-0.34878188371658325,
-0.7481376528739929,
-0.2680744528770447,
0.6313097476959229,
0.5441077947616577,
0.11337725073099136,
-0.00936002004891634,
0.6667156219482422,
0.24310247600078583,
0.12311887741088867,
-0.7964266538619995,
0.09031584113836288,
-0.40942174196243286,
0.17118245363235474,
-0.14257654547691345,
-0.12418873608112335,
-0.022027887403964996,
-0.5031248927116394,
0.15446321666240692,
-0.07206769287586212,
0.6483489274978638,
0.3541065752506256,
0.22695785760879517,
0.11687829345464706,
0.3898599147796631,
0.6808347105979919,
0.9671032428741455,
-0.1356833130121231,
0.4311525821685791,
0.4262688159942627,
-0.8252591490745544,
0.48212119936943054,
0.19497478008270264,
0.03504673391580582,
-0.0893353745341301,
0.45328959822654724,
0.732842743396759,
0.12598656117916107,
-0.33039018511772156,
0.7064216136932373,
-0.6561221480369568,
-0.6948035955429077,
-0.12683320045471191,
0.13545405864715576,
0.20843695104122162,
0.11137121170759201,
0.40149229764938354,
0.0009674765169620514,
0.5030201077461243,
-0.8097214698791504,
0.5241574645042419,
-0.025906775146722794,
-0.19972479343414307,
-0.6924070715904236,
0.5956873297691345,
0.32199782133102417,
-0.5173301696777344,
0.5370045304298401,
-0.5872426629066467,
-0.940932035446167,
0.5813972353935242,
0.6170517206192017,
0.4982007145881653,
-0.3687186539173126,
0.48283442854881287,
0.23643657565116882,
0.4771234393119812,
-0.013180771842598915,
0.6575837135314941,
-0.12566769123077393,
-0.7420936226844788,
-0.7413322925567627,
-0.11773961037397385,
-0.7736260890960693,
0.1318000704050064,
-0.6806527376174927,
-0.13338015973567963,
-0.3410555422306061,
-0.28000813722610474,
0.19868262112140656,
0.14084647595882416,
-0.8016159534454346,
0.27666938304901123,
-0.07128067314624786,
0.5503907203674316,
-0.803052544593811,
0.6049001216888428,
0.6757568717002869,
-0.5859790444374084,
-1.0863265991210938,
0.40038302540779114,
-0.09010825306177139,
-0.7802315950393677,
0.8507893681526184,
0.383305162191391,
0.10789553076028824,
0.2652437686920166,
-0.4301750659942627,
-0.8731014132499695,
1.1240593194961548,
0.5334855914115906,
-0.25435003638267517,
-0.24219012260437012,
0.015478978864848614,
0.6062930226325989,
0.13134464621543884,
0.5182989835739136,
0.8256253600120544,
0.8588833808898926,
0.09906620532274246,
-1.3789585828781128,
-0.020579565316438675,
-0.005269975867122412,
-0.2323876917362213,
0.02079087868332863,
-0.45997098088264465,
0.9678575992584229,
-0.2666786015033722,
-0.2587735950946808,
-0.22778262197971344,
0.5480988025665283,
0.09196925908327103,
0.6811326742172241,
0.5312522053718567,
0.42271292209625244,
1.2342302799224854,
-0.19730399549007416,
1.3738919496536255,
0.07769005000591278,
0.14357653260231018,
1.0511739253997803,
-0.5182093381881714,
0.5221461057662964,
0.12190509587526321,
-0.328147828578949,
0.6983217000961304,
0.7969438433647156,
0.5054132342338562,
0.40969356894493103,
0.28483110666275024,
-0.32973986864089966,
0.030485739931464195,
0.21103012561798096,
-0.34716910123825073,
0.6937884092330933,
0.22250759601593018,
-0.03576374053955078,
-0.1034323051571846,
0.13180525600910187,
0.005313631147146225,
0.005038455128669739,
-0.17741349339485168,
1.049340844154358,
0.10933651030063629,
-1.1862847805023193,
0.6184793710708618,
-0.2510710656642914,
0.33248358964920044,
-0.33256274461746216,
-0.056832585483789444,
-0.1269296109676361,
-0.01767481490969658,
0.036162376403808594,
-1.2441959381103516,
0.5094630122184753,
0.04097927734255791,
-0.012860964052379131,
-0.19683749973773956,
0.7641091346740723,
-0.06682706624269485,
-0.006395141128450632,
0.08612982928752899,
0.537140965461731,
0.6169984340667725,
-0.22693924605846405,
-0.7116765975952148,
-0.0805266797542572,
0.07231327891349792,
-0.2403998225927353,
0.15865471959114075,
0.6086652874946594,
0.035152267664670944,
0.41438886523246765,
0.25197818875312805,
-0.13617472350597382,
-0.2136295884847641,
0.11173822730779648,
0.9638990163803101,
-0.7458778023719788,
-0.6703460216522217,
-0.9780188798904419,
0.40942275524139404,
-0.4722127318382263,
-0.3556661009788513,
0.79945307970047,
0.5724625587463379,
0.3741495609283447,
0.24817566573619843,
1.0086536407470703,
0.25295671820640564,
0.49217209219932556,
-0.24805927276611328,
0.3916758894920349,
0.12274442613124847,
-0.27260079979896545,
-0.33714982867240906,
-0.6711062788963318,
-0.20436547696590424,
1.0009316205978394,
-0.7252442836761475,
0.14802111685276031,
1.1946214437484741,
0.22709503769874573,
-0.015547843649983406,
0.6678235530853271,
0.4475182592868805,
0.25365307927131653,
0.4541073143482208,
0.6906604766845703,
1.1129074096679688,
-0.150673508644104,
0.4863895773887634,
0.2430724799633026,
-0.5194920301437378,
0.45383694767951965,
-0.5951319336891174,
-1.0782897472381592,
-0.4467160999774933,
-0.0570455826818943,
0.009499011561274529,
0.22786501049995422,
0.1963936984539032,
0.6565868258476257,
-0.3203973174095154,
0.06329848617315292,
-0.15191516280174255,
-0.07913435250520706,
-0.11099693179130554,
-0.2546479105949402,
0.4079890549182892,
-0.27868640422821045,
-0.5272045731544495,
0.24137648940086365,
0.4364272356033325,
-0.02996371127665043,
-0.18596956133842468,
-0.14332427084445953,
-0.1770859658718109,
0.16218018531799316,
0.5228345394134521,
-0.056875456124544144,
-0.5758622288703918,
-0.7691641449928284,
0.052706897258758545,
0.011911623179912567,
0.2931560277938843,
0.9196679592132568,
-0.8029577732086182,
0.3774711787700653,
0.37038812041282654,
0.7088204622268677,
0.7177140116691589,
0.4288891553878784,
0.7285066843032837,
-0.5961549282073975,
0.16015490889549255,
0.6762637495994568,
0.17201575636863708,
0.4148796796798706,
-0.6783375144004822,
0.7160404324531555,
0.3041735291481018,
-1.2230507135391235,
-0.3349686861038208,
0.26114460825920105,
-0.7806269526481628,
-0.14154565334320068,
0.911058247089386,
-0.37622693181037903,
-0.05213721841573715,
-0.7791752219200134,
-0.7658194899559021,
0.12767373025417328,
-0.4748413860797882,
0.6303023099899292,
0.8768981695175171,
-0.5338846445083618,
-0.20290310680866241,
-1.017254114151001,
0.7090179920196533,
0.23476141691207886,
-1.0575146675109863,
-0.36047226190567017,
0.3013269901275635,
0.34992823004722595,
0.07091168314218521,
1.3179889917373657,
0.1709567755460739,
0.3615233898162842,
-0.1438494771718979,
-0.22108082473278046,
0.32581546902656555,
0.03399920463562012,
-0.08615051209926605,
0.15224091708660126,
0.1714814454317093,
-0.2383071631193161
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11619v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11619v1
|
Advancing Speech Translation: A Corpus of Mandarin-English Conversational Telephone Speech
| 2024-03-25T21:08:06 | 2024-03-25T21:08:06 |
Shannon Wotherspoon, William Hartmann, Matthew Snover
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD
|
This paper introduces a set of English translations for a 123-hour subset of
the CallHome Mandarin Chinese data and the HKUST Mandarin Telephone Speech data
for the task of speech translation. Paired source-language speech and
target-language text is essential for training end-to-end speech translation
systems and can provide substantial performance improvements for cascaded
systems as well, relative to training on more widely available text data sets.
We demonstrate that fine-tuning a general-purpose translation model to our
Mandarin-English conversational telephone speech training set improves
target-domain BLEU by more than 8 points, highlighting the importance of
matched training data.
|
[
0.35772940516471863,
-0.5665746927261353,
-0.0464809387922287,
0.2647072970867157,
-0.5078442096710205,
0.1767769753932953,
-0.512603759765625,
-0.5386840105056763,
-0.3043789267539978,
0.5681224465370178,
-0.21016792953014374,
-0.2887248694896698,
-0.2949712872505188,
0.03549494966864586,
-0.5574753880500793,
0.8714959621429443,
0.2732885479927063,
0.5800312161445618,
0.24691452085971832,
-0.19751162827014923,
-0.882283091545105,
-0.3069702386856079,
-0.9283820390701294,
-0.363465815782547,
0.3547583520412445,
0.5584683418273926,
1.0422574281692505,
0.6608586311340332,
0.49505239725112915,
0.11267587542533875,
-0.029967397451400757,
-0.025106949731707573,
-0.35185834765434265,
0.13322973251342773,
-0.29600146412849426,
-0.5988073348999023,
-0.6037224531173706,
-0.08444187045097351,
0.8018265962600708,
0.7984840869903564,
-0.07731316983699799,
0.23028472065925598,
0.07721994817256927,
0.6197376847267151,
-0.1698351800441742,
0.20102104544639587,
-0.839325487613678,
-0.10225171595811844,
-0.3215256929397583,
-0.3596317172050476,
-0.691096842288971,
-0.1566821187734604,
0.21516276895999908,
-0.3978673219680786,
0.314860463142395,
0.19487592577934265,
0.6939358115196228,
0.3672146499156952,
-0.4432677924633026,
-0.022635558620095253,
-0.748166561126709,
0.8463600873947144,
-0.5935307145118713,
0.7092125415802002,
0.40906721353530884,
0.2834347188472748,
0.062070950865745544,
-0.6251492500305176,
-0.16632848978042603,
-0.32094722986221313,
-0.1464078724384308,
0.30558377504348755,
-0.08867361396551132,
0.22045959532260895,
0.10009206086397171,
0.27559512853622437,
-0.6941112875938416,
-0.03611009567975998,
-0.6031206250190735,
0.06972141563892365,
0.9450833797454834,
-0.08145353198051453,
0.4494912922382355,
-0.08129941672086716,
0.09400615096092224,
-0.1036042869091034,
-0.6081375479698181,
0.09855709969997406,
-0.03288838639855385,
0.8327564597129822,
-0.3227027952671051,
0.5039587020874023,
-0.018395427614450455,
1.0058666467666626,
-0.2089330554008484,
0.028970109298825264,
0.36259788274765015,
-0.5482056736946106,
-0.24537783861160278,
0.6838180422782898,
0.41027629375457764,
0.3287771940231323,
0.43564772605895996,
-0.3510143756866455,
-0.07562128454446793,
-0.23835724592208862,
0.14452603459358215,
-0.5479743480682373,
0.022143065929412842,
0.29325437545776367,
-0.30453455448150635,
-0.12470807135105133,
-0.1002405509352684,
-0.20978085696697235,
0.24526283144950867,
-0.5253255367279053,
0.21025744080543518,
-0.3148169219493866,
-0.03308474272489548,
0.04418464004993439,
-0.2706732749938965,
0.5820930004119873,
0.27195560932159424,
-0.8860758543014526,
0.18255428969860077,
0.6577829122543335,
1.0606085062026978,
-0.22777359187602997,
-0.10859169811010361,
-0.844027578830719,
0.43037867546081543,
-0.8703845739364624,
0.39629921317100525,
-0.5982356667518616,
-0.4703594446182251,
0.2010781168937683,
0.17029277980327606,
-0.23245829343795776,
-0.619235634803772,
0.832356333732605,
-0.3435506224632263,
0.3218526840209961,
0.04243385046720505,
-0.4099799692630768,
0.013287759386003017,
-0.2769017517566681,
-0.4186486005783081,
0.8977712988853455,
0.19599051773548126,
-0.304502010345459,
0.2653917372226715,
-0.6017478108406067,
-0.8581394553184509,
0.2695870101451874,
0.10612824559211731,
-0.19412711262702942,
-0.1082366332411766,
0.3389769494533539,
0.5737832188606262,
-0.30151984095573425,
0.21393808722496033,
0.2155413031578064,
-0.36179086565971375,
0.12915807962417603,
-0.2482747733592987,
0.9413592219352722,
0.47704777121543884,
-0.23041316866874695,
-0.03707049414515495,
-0.5797871351242065,
-0.06321980804204941,
-0.018816165626049042,
-0.3760209083557129,
-0.2991997003555298,
0.08648919314146042,
0.34512174129486084,
0.009112518280744553,
0.5115694999694824,
-0.5225108861923218,
-0.14504459500312805,
-0.403900146484375,
0.5301783084869385,
0.34686240553855896,
-0.2825421988964081,
0.4795769155025482,
-0.37354138493537903,
0.356880247592926,
0.13618920743465424,
-0.17542764544487,
-0.443402498960495,
-0.6953113675117493,
-0.49339473247528076,
0.31208789348602295,
0.4944269359111786,
1.1003649234771729,
-0.44520166516304016,
0.345080703496933,
-0.6071076989173889,
-0.35048750042915344,
-0.8825061917304993,
0.05760630592703819,
0.4714008569717407,
0.5789574384689331,
0.6296434998512268,
-0.026486514136195183,
-0.48038625717163086,
-0.9081997275352478,
-0.1988724321126938,
-0.11110307276248932,
-0.17827127873897552,
0.2841131389141083,
-0.22242464125156403,
0.17779892683029175,
0.63016676902771,
-0.16889145970344543,
-0.3808666169643402,
-0.3285985589027405,
-0.2857002019882202,
0.3080848157405853,
0.5352683067321777,
0.43879610300064087,
-1.1174031496047974,
-0.9455606937408447,
0.5504340529441833,
-0.4229153096675873,
-0.22659897804260254,
-0.14433488249778748,
-0.07608512043952942,
0.06839621812105179,
0.542312502861023,
-0.09113800525665283,
0.19188129901885986,
0.6900061368942261,
-0.07226153463125229,
0.24206961691379547,
-0.03594633564352989,
0.38040557503700256,
-1.606940746307373,
0.08610730618238449,
-0.11351966857910156,
-0.527759313583374,
-0.9884402751922607,
-0.15487128496170044,
0.01733555644750595,
-0.4243241846561432,
-0.4307856559753418,
0.45391252636909485,
-0.34007418155670166,
-0.22994770109653473,
-0.3112959861755371,
0.4049532115459442,
-0.22524172067642212,
0.11781290918588638,
0.3469747304916382,
1.1967781782150269,
0.6508736610412598,
-0.47868776321411133,
0.4770750403404236,
0.6309831142425537,
-0.07738489657640457,
0.5477964878082275,
-0.6733624339103699,
0.22394432127475739,
0.31707412004470825,
0.11887729167938232,
-0.9180878400802612,
-0.10307464003562927,
-0.008237915113568306,
-0.7869806289672852,
0.305308997631073,
-0.07606419175863266,
0.04903309792280197,
-0.023046735674142838,
0.12288381159305573,
0.327318400144577,
0.5797843933105469,
-0.5318934321403503,
-0.11863190680742264,
0.31696778535842896,
-0.5228208303451538,
-0.5911076068878174,
-0.7446628212928772,
0.42641720175743103,
-0.006726715248078108,
-0.6126682758331299,
0.7934948205947876,
0.17632335424423218,
-0.17341865599155426,
-0.09989193826913834,
0.17258280515670776,
-0.24221938848495483,
-0.3153253495693207,
-0.0703529417514801,
0.07006308436393738,
-0.46502649784088135,
0.2886624336242676,
0.1247682049870491,
0.18444667756557465,
0.022004032507538795,
-0.3484499752521515,
0.5443269610404968,
0.3331931233406067,
0.12437556684017181,
-0.35880783200263977,
0.49297964572906494,
0.20089876651763916,
-0.03263331204652786,
0.3928937017917633,
0.5660008788108826,
-0.3567439317703247,
-0.048582952469587326,
-0.31582754850387573,
0.06629601866006851,
-0.40814876556396484,
0.5395642518997192,
-0.6424702405929565,
-0.6821293830871582,
0.29768499732017517,
0.29783445596694946,
0.43617627024650574,
0.2557819187641144,
0.38847482204437256,
0.0662626400589943,
1.0217857360839844,
0.44617849588394165,
-0.6337974071502686,
0.7360531687736511,
0.07584234327077866,
0.06738737970590591,
-0.7470477223396301,
0.135725200176239,
-0.5620745420455933,
-0.13274987041950226,
-0.46396663784980774,
-0.47178998589515686,
0.15313971042633057,
0.16184528172016144,
0.08526816964149475,
0.80527263879776,
-0.5117220878601074,
0.2361416518688202,
0.559839129447937,
0.19744375348091125,
0.3461121916770935,
0.060563430190086365,
0.26161545515060425,
-0.050302669405937195,
-0.6374485492706299,
-0.37227296829223633,
0.9054268598556519,
0.33920732140541077,
0.36448025703430176,
0.07239620387554169,
0.44629696011543274,
0.3225055932998657,
-0.06812579184770584,
-0.6657978892326355,
0.3437182605266571,
-0.46694645285606384,
-0.511979877948761,
-0.5384724736213684,
-0.433838814496994,
-1.1643354892730713,
0.0996423289179802,
0.12566880881786346,
-0.531635046005249,
0.08942879736423492,
0.18845854699611664,
-0.11863616853952408,
-0.01477221492677927,
-0.6689916253089905,
0.6756004691123962,
-0.1822642683982849,
-0.11999853700399399,
-0.709492564201355,
-0.7196977138519287,
0.05286489054560661,
-0.08170749992132187,
0.08281197398900986,
-0.10084232687950134,
0.004892537835985422,
0.8151353597640991,
-0.10001242905855179,
0.43538516759872437,
-0.12933501601219177,
-0.22203639149665833,
0.20403113961219788,
-0.2757191061973572,
0.2764703631401062,
-0.05278078839182854,
-0.1071147620677948,
0.27343812584877014,
-0.12129219621419907,
-0.5821683406829834,
-0.4091183543205261,
0.1737549751996994,
-0.6695153713226318,
-0.5122306942939758,
-0.0741855725646019,
-0.6820062398910522,
-0.2562029957771301,
0.047875091433525085,
0.32132160663604736,
0.474495530128479,
-0.38403069972991943,
0.37078678607940674,
0.3544900417327881,
-0.04202292487025261,
0.4645353853702545,
0.43618327379226685,
-0.019596688449382782,
-0.4362007677555084,
0.7423045635223389,
0.13809624314308167,
0.5260359644889832,
0.7255594730377197,
-0.03811230883002281,
-0.38210928440093994,
-0.6633177995681763,
-0.7257168292999268,
0.09925499558448792,
-0.397415429353714,
-0.06354732811450958,
-0.4241756200790405,
-0.5514643788337708,
-0.9170357584953308,
-0.25234344601631165,
-0.12132707983255386,
-0.5032620429992676,
-0.22424837946891785,
-0.11902622133493423,
0.3422369658946991,
0.4927699863910675,
-0.1575007140636444,
0.6063268184661865,
-0.9352303743362427,
0.33894532918930054,
0.20016492903232574,
-0.29919323325157166,
-0.40930667519569397,
-1.1884130239486694,
-0.8060582280158997,
0.3791102170944214,
-0.006918173748999834,
-0.8939575552940369,
0.45925670862197876,
0.5051937103271484,
0.48818355798721313,
0.05164175480604172,
-0.2164260745048523,
0.8410729765892029,
-0.9660040736198425,
0.8801155090332031,
0.10127673298120499,
-0.9079704284667969,
0.9051427841186523,
-0.5337311625480652,
0.3203338086605072,
0.30791813135147095,
0.290020614862442,
-0.9905515313148499,
-0.25965961813926697,
-0.5703270435333252,
-0.6824198961257935,
0.7253656387329102,
0.20995312929153442,
0.1659279614686966,
0.19650259613990784,
0.31356585025787354,
-0.4001537561416626,
0.19570791721343994,
-0.4101656377315521,
-0.11304068565368652,
-0.08025141060352325,
-0.1871110051870346,
-0.43846213817596436,
0.07495712488889694,
-0.12020231783390045,
-0.4712556302547455,
0.6955002546310425,
-0.15039339661598206,
0.24071873724460602,
0.24853600561618805,
-0.18733066320419312,
-0.2715856432914734,
0.4264828562736511,
0.5913760662078857,
0.378755122423172,
-0.43113505840301514,
-0.3479019105434418,
0.38758528232574463,
-0.6163362264633179,
0.2579384446144104,
0.3706628382205963,
-0.03899528458714485,
0.23068536818027496,
0.48025763034820557,
0.9490620493888855,
0.22270798683166504,
-0.5116523504257202,
0.4264541566371918,
0.23041272163391113,
-0.0805496871471405,
-0.3016599416732788,
0.11852545291185379,
0.08579964190721512,
-0.01848522201180458,
0.6122767329216003,
-0.15374284982681274,
0.15831241011619568,
-0.5646939873695374,
0.5458770394325256,
0.13289353251457214,
-0.6500194072723389,
-0.2216876745223999,
0.6944007873535156,
0.5017071962356567,
-0.6831963062286377,
0.3544817268848419,
0.10020789504051208,
-0.3798808157444,
0.38427627086639404,
0.8029929399490356,
1.0105869770050049,
-0.7613080143928528,
0.1559412032365799,
0.33468177914619446,
0.139677494764328,
-0.00964479148387909,
0.20766033232212067,
-0.12820766866207123,
-0.7108643054962158,
-0.7255924940109253,
-0.4764055609703064,
-0.6490340828895569,
-0.02172483317553997,
-0.880003809928894,
0.423946738243103,
0.11988719552755356,
0.09853771328926086,
-0.08332908153533936,
-0.16645626723766327,
-0.2150099277496338,
0.35958167910575867,
0.20915834605693817,
0.9167309999465942,
-0.619020938873291,
1.0989047288894653,
0.6837776303291321,
-0.06517212837934494,
-0.8462212085723877,
-0.1235218197107315,
-0.4279490113258362,
-0.7735912799835205,
0.6790566444396973,
-0.024301376193761826,
-0.04720715805888176,
0.3933895528316498,
-0.44756019115448,
-0.7405781745910645,
0.9545950293540955,
0.4259392023086548,
-0.8954216837882996,
-0.14203453063964844,
0.518784761428833,
0.4066838026046753,
-0.5179277062416077,
0.016286538913846016,
0.7921416759490967,
0.2001696228981018,
-0.17075441777706146,
-1.4914510250091553,
-0.3288484215736389,
-0.07877984642982483,
-0.06653978675603867,
0.05852707102894783,
-0.7667238116264343,
0.6495782136917114,
0.04995390772819519,
-0.2483736127614975,
-0.10902658104896545,
0.7954099178314209,
-0.18110229074954987,
0.047285936772823334,
0.4569750428199768,
0.33349335193634033,
0.5362656116485596,
-0.07462999224662781,
0.6430631875991821,
-0.5378621220588684,
0.028477536514401436,
1.2636663913726807,
-0.27950072288513184,
1.2341259717941284,
0.09354881197214127,
-0.3091543912887573,
0.09552189707756042,
0.7562447190284729,
0.25560662150382996,
0.44755819439888,
-0.0926918312907219,
-0.4227239191532135,
-0.12184837460517883,
-0.3515566289424896,
-0.47824180126190186,
0.5373337268829346,
0.6078805327415466,
-0.3596363365650177,
-0.10553915053606033,
0.06101420149207115,
-0.16429489850997925,
0.14498765766620636,
-0.2897918224334717,
0.7309553027153015,
0.2794470191001892,
-0.6719234585762024,
0.8196665644645691,
-0.10063394159078598,
0.5352082848548889,
-0.4108908176422119,
-0.13122138381004333,
-0.11505578458309174,
-0.005621625110507011,
-0.23812276124954224,
-0.5447311997413635,
0.3480314314365387,
-0.07863403856754303,
0.06839447468519211,
-0.23955437541007996,
0.5367642641067505,
-0.8754360675811768,
-0.2811835706233978,
0.35636574029922485,
0.4179270267486572,
0.38707801699638367,
-0.013126211240887642,
-1.0096863508224487,
-0.30315566062927246,
0.29133760929107666,
-0.017960943281650543,
0.032498881220817566,
0.24434536695480347,
-0.023965727537870407,
0.4705132246017456,
0.638909101486206,
0.46700185537338257,
0.2932857871055603,
0.2260507494211197,
0.5276954174041748,
-0.7350695133209229,
-0.42845475673675537,
-0.5829816460609436,
0.3669912815093994,
-0.24609024822711945,
-0.43229612708091736,
0.5283381938934326,
0.8939932584762573,
0.9718950986862183,
0.08353804796934128,
0.9641969203948975,
0.0010295145912095904,
0.794057309627533,
-0.5540220737457275,
0.47483906149864197,
-0.23159143328666687,
-0.290968656539917,
-0.17582930624485016,
-1.0855921506881714,
-0.21772858500480652,
0.6389501690864563,
-0.28389474749565125,
-0.3637044131755829,
0.6242746114730835,
0.8706891536712646,
-0.08810777217149734,
0.0629836693406105,
0.6749047040939331,
-0.05205710232257843,
0.3612670600414276,
0.4927084147930145,
0.47404077649116516,
-0.8258204460144043,
0.5764684677124023,
-0.11257236450910568,
-0.0917116329073906,
-0.07959984242916107,
-0.39262866973876953,
-0.7489382028579712,
-0.8119572401046753,
-0.3263246715068817,
-0.2762078046798706,
0.44866693019866943,
0.804032564163208,
0.8002719879150391,
-1.0369906425476074,
-0.7268360257148743,
0.034002635627985,
-0.23495513200759888,
-0.44755819439888,
-0.22542649507522583,
0.2815837264060974,
-0.8289339542388916,
-1.1499693393707275,
0.8801281452178955,
0.13457971811294556,
0.23507387936115265,
0.0005665686330758035,
-0.24850167334079742,
-0.20947633683681488,
-0.03408088535070419,
0.6232200264930725,
0.27740412950515747,
-0.4983595609664917,
-0.33024147152900696,
0.018875714391469955,
-0.10658112168312073,
0.3227348029613495,
0.8277187347412109,
-0.43397125601768494,
0.17693360149860382,
0.28620031476020813,
0.7836955189704895,
0.35600021481513977,
0.22575269639492035,
1.0290589332580566,
-1.0449694395065308,
0.5810254812240601,
0.268877774477005,
0.34017473459243774,
0.5249785780906677,
-0.44059979915618896,
0.7731794714927673,
0.04912031441926956,
-0.7439298629760742,
-0.8364789485931396,
0.07507524639368057,
-1.0859181880950928,
-0.029361367225646973,
1.1408153772354126,
-0.12976118922233582,
-0.13008913397789001,
-0.347380131483078,
-0.4190192222595215,
0.5287825465202332,
-0.5918488502502441,
0.20356997847557068,
0.6682862043380737,
-0.04015694931149483,
-0.31329965591430664,
-0.7488883137702942,
0.6833052635192871,
0.6789654493331909,
-0.45576339960098267,
0.1965404897928238,
0.4521687924861908,
-0.11906954646110535,
0.26103296875953674,
0.6860271692276001,
0.029514329507946968,
0.3920435309410095,
0.02645426243543625,
-0.222355917096138,
0.41275620460510254,
-0.2701503038406372,
-0.4191521406173706,
-0.27359387278556824,
0.1602996587753296,
-0.563106119632721
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17169v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17169v3
|
QuanTemp: A real-world open-domain benchmark for fact-checking numerical claims
| 2024-03-25T20:36:03 | 2024-05-01T06:27:24 |
Venktesh V, Abhijit Anand, Avishek Anand, Vinay Setty
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Automated fact checking has gained immense interest to tackle the growing
misinformation in the digital era. Existing systems primarily focus on
synthetic claims on Wikipedia, and noteworthy progress has also been made on
real-world claims. In this work, we release QuanTemp, a diverse, multi-domain
dataset focused exclusively on numerical claims, encompassing temporal,
statistical and diverse aspects with fine-grained metadata and an evidence
collection without leakage. This addresses the challenge of verifying
real-world numerical claims, which are complex and often lack precise
information, not addressed by existing works that mainly focus on synthetic
claims. We evaluate and quantify the limitations of existing solutions for the
task of verifying numerical claims. We also evaluate claim decomposition based
methods, numerical understanding based models and our best baselines achieves a
macro-F1 of 58.32. This demonstrates that QuanTemp serves as a challenging
evaluation set for numerical claim verification.
|
[
-0.7088302969932556,
-0.4498955011367798,
0.4160151779651642,
0.44689562916755676,
-0.09004499018192291,
0.16710451245307922,
-0.04743143171072006,
-0.5794476270675659,
-0.04094437509775162,
0.18124903738498688,
-0.3821808695793152,
-0.47499921917915344,
-0.4686691164970398,
0.2967545986175537,
-0.2185097634792328,
0.9702324271202087,
-0.013922556303441525,
-0.177574023604393,
-0.6445881724357605,
-0.33815839886665344,
-0.10689117014408112,
-0.6392425894737244,
-0.36924245953559875,
-0.018636886030435562,
0.2934078574180603,
0.21483111381530762,
0.35022151470184326,
0.26706433296203613,
0.6447939276695251,
0.2953615188598633,
0.19096501171588898,
0.5809991359710693,
-0.04525241628289223,
0.016116321086883545,
-0.1559457629919052,
-0.2611382305622101,
-0.4999794661998749,
0.045452721416950226,
0.7256314754486084,
0.2669833302497864,
-0.34148547053337097,
0.7049183249473572,
-0.37319597601890564,
0.31218254566192627,
-1.2891390323638916,
0.2512461841106415,
-0.7008634209632874,
0.3980823755264282,
-0.10593631863594055,
0.052329935133457184,
-0.38695114850997925,
-0.7337957620620728,
-0.03608923405408859,
-0.5975843667984009,
0.4701046943664551,
-0.024298302829265594,
0.9191198945045471,
0.5292288064956665,
-0.796753466129303,
0.057774219661951065,
-0.819063127040863,
0.5921618938446045,
-0.6132268309593201,
0.28209394216537476,
0.22243434190750122,
0.7210267782211304,
0.27877065539360046,
-1.0086681842803955,
-0.6558313965797424,
0.08853738754987717,
0.025034461170434952,
0.11519066244363785,
-0.4611254334449768,
-0.09815685451030731,
0.7941644191741943,
0.35586702823638916,
-0.7554237842559814,
-0.262597918510437,
-0.36716997623443604,
-0.6463826298713684,
0.5878746509552002,
-0.03550922870635986,
0.26458343863487244,
-0.11137986183166504,
-0.39314091205596924,
-0.22575099766254425,
-0.7752240896224976,
-0.13046424090862274,
0.11048232764005661,
-0.03537769988179207,
-0.3679702579975128,
0.6140690445899963,
-0.344076007604599,
0.6365563869476318,
-0.5201292634010315,
-0.019470175728201866,
-0.040243931114673615,
-0.23471182584762573,
-0.303105890750885,
0.17735177278518677,
0.7178739309310913,
0.3030589818954468,
0.220526322722435,
-0.06312724202871323,
0.022595683112740517,
0.17332032322883606,
0.2583910822868347,
-1.1382837295532227,
0.1170249879360199,
0.20592539012432098,
-0.15193548798561096,
-0.21922430396080017,
0.5252520442008972,
-0.6370329260826111,
-0.20323500037193298,
-0.10319970548152924,
0.19936153292655945,
-0.23385563492774963,
-0.2769588828086853,
0.13877321779727936,
-0.33279258012771606,
-0.3203287124633789,
0.2267681211233139,
-0.3088926672935486,
0.4514410197734833,
0.9520993828773499,
0.9775380492210388,
0.12359870970249176,
0.12795180082321167,
-0.5708968639373779,
-0.06302358210086823,
-0.43407589197158813,
1.2731375694274902,
-0.1930006593465805,
-0.11326801031827927,
-0.051107361912727356,
-0.3115445673465729,
0.16141660511493683,
-1.0117506980895996,
0.9100005030632019,
-0.5716363787651062,
-0.09756625443696976,
-0.2996559739112854,
-0.429614394903183,
-0.10076068341732025,
0.449701189994812,
-0.9461605548858643,
1.0770440101623535,
0.22583995759487152,
-0.761577308177948,
0.43922221660614014,
-0.533315122127533,
0.022426895797252655,
-0.04904431477189064,
-0.21243198215961456,
-0.5735839605331421,
0.3923053741455078,
-0.023312147706747055,
-0.10721273720264435,
-0.6424763798713684,
0.37670403718948364,
-0.651781439781189,
0.019768068566918373,
0.3925287425518036,
-0.5471416115760803,
0.9188794493675232,
0.2286662459373474,
-0.3555447459220886,
-0.39861810207366943,
-1.0943042039871216,
0.39633840322494507,
-0.014278922230005264,
-0.02837972901761532,
-0.5115856528282166,
-0.19924317300319672,
-0.28235429525375366,
0.4267693758010864,
0.10642199963331223,
-0.9798195362091064,
0.42276594042778015,
-0.03101765736937523,
0.17833296954631805,
0.4629625976085663,
0.16155385971069336,
-0.3840169906616211,
-0.44874054193496704,
0.48296576738357544,
0.1404104381799698,
-0.03342951834201813,
0.125961571931839,
-0.21327726542949677,
-0.3052990138530731,
-0.27638891339302063,
1.10872220993042,
0.6199983358383179,
-0.7760704755783081,
0.011478623375296593,
-0.45048660039901733,
-0.40086787939071655,
-0.18703188002109528,
-0.5527938604354858,
0.26837748289108276,
0.6764910817146301,
0.3979673385620117,
0.023544443771243095,
-0.6967063546180725,
-0.9917017221450806,
-0.5469319820404053,
-0.3585890531539917,
-0.44173702597618103,
0.1663730889558792,
0.6057837605476379,
0.10763794928789139,
1.1536529064178467,
-0.9876614212989807,
-0.07593590021133423,
0.6296421885490417,
0.5851453542709351,
-0.0550149604678154,
0.2824673652648926,
0.7252453565597534,
-0.8222277164459229,
-0.5146104097366333,
-0.22546717524528503,
-0.9551244378089905,
-0.2851799726486206,
-0.060303542762994766,
0.2160479873418808,
-0.018604649230837822,
0.21081827580928802,
-0.8636330962181091,
0.4514080584049225,
0.5157284140586853,
-0.3329424560070038,
0.8190397024154663,
-0.17735055088996887,
0.43661659955978394,
-0.48004451394081116,
0.11470795422792435,
0.3743586242198944,
-0.3617629408836365,
-0.16405507922172546,
0.1570332646369934,
0.32009273767471313,
-0.15509949624538422,
-0.5671200156211853,
0.5607311725616455,
-0.014541598036885262,
-0.13523636758327484,
-0.031242433935403824,
-0.18243049085140228,
0.0046300990507006645,
0.4013964533805847,
-0.05404325947165489,
0.7941526770591736,
0.14690835773944855,
-0.657006561756134,
0.48938900232315063,
0.06819739937782288,
-0.38919731974601746,
1.0426584482192993,
-0.7736004590988159,
-0.14071626961231232,
0.11844702810049057,
0.5561572313308716,
-0.6167199611663818,
-0.1090840995311737,
0.013747217133641243,
-0.514202356338501,
-0.209610253572464,
-0.28573694825172424,
-0.6993584036827087,
-0.3283524811267853,
-0.3448112905025482,
0.6550493240356445,
0.21552586555480957,
-0.6057174205780029,
0.6342484951019287,
0.494064062833786,
-0.3972548842430115,
-0.5766228437423706,
-0.3804316818714142,
0.33876779675483704,
-0.12056897580623627,
-0.467284232378006,
0.7043037414550781,
-0.03871684893965721,
-0.8826723694801331,
-0.0739925429224968,
-0.5292435884475708,
-0.5037119388580322,
-0.09300176054239273,
0.23312972486019135,
-0.06551560759544373,
-0.3640996813774109,
-0.016580047085881233,
0.17309966683387756,
-0.32884925603866577,
0.5061202049255371,
-0.358396053314209,
0.01879117637872696,
-0.08694897592067719,
-0.5175191164016724,
-0.1296229064464569,
0.28483110666275024,
0.6416283249855042,
-0.25080057978630066,
0.4024982154369354,
0.42414766550064087,
-0.8965489268302917,
-0.37117961049079895,
-0.5602257251739502,
0.010519211180508137,
-0.3656551241874695,
-0.08490077406167984,
-0.4842095971107483,
-0.4853226840496063,
0.4100775122642517,
-0.6061745285987854,
0.43804848194122314,
1.049352765083313,
0.1019512340426445,
0.02128724940121174,
0.9529345631599426,
0.3326635956764221,
0.42421722412109375,
-0.11117200553417206,
-0.29251834750175476,
-0.01905687525868416,
-0.39515918493270874,
-0.2699775695800781,
-0.9850535988807678,
-0.06729067116975784,
-0.3899620771408081,
-0.3497718274593353,
0.6581347584724426,
-0.193470299243927,
-0.3880637288093567,
0.15848231315612793,
-0.2820472717285156,
0.47934117913246155,
0.5067649483680725,
0.1709754467010498,
0.6389296054840088,
0.12166233360767365,
-0.014200321398675442,
-0.43717634677886963,
-0.5713659524917603,
-0.27509838342666626,
0.8719397187232971,
0.04655667021870613,
0.2586137652397156,
0.38597652316093445,
0.33475080132484436,
0.9803650379180908,
0.3981158435344696,
-0.32344040274620056,
0.4781593978404999,
-0.23135782778263092,
-0.6366220116615295,
-0.1276790350675583,
-0.8493645787239075,
-0.5240740180015564,
0.49331188201904297,
-0.2655136287212372,
-0.20032429695129395,
0.258142352104187,
0.23776434361934662,
-0.5676408410072327,
0.5052735805511475,
-0.18690802156925201,
0.7876406908035278,
-0.1668122410774231,
-0.20981286466121674,
-0.508169949054718,
-0.41111916303634644,
0.6928876042366028,
-0.20771537721157074,
0.314267098903656,
-0.286270409822464,
-0.11763269454240799,
0.5256980657577515,
-1.009182095527649,
0.721711277961731,
-0.46986520290374756,
-0.5267330408096313,
0.6167342066764832,
0.26095137000083923,
0.3215792775154114,
0.3000701665878296,
-0.14641377329826355,
0.4109685719013214,
0.49076828360557556,
-0.29803556203842163,
-0.5892245769500732,
0.4059780538082123,
-0.5472133755683899,
-0.0047035436145961285,
-0.8621774911880493,
-0.10728833079338074,
-0.3125659227371216,
0.1317490190267563,
0.19632674753665924,
0.7722361087799072,
-0.5835524797439575,
0.22829082608222961,
0.8725672364234924,
-0.27186906337738037,
0.24903862178325653,
0.670839250087738,
0.14694558084011078,
-0.7434136271476746,
1.0252041816711426,
0.1638484001159668,
-0.07177472114562988,
0.37786245346069336,
0.2111215442419052,
-0.43879127502441406,
-0.13139548897743225,
-0.5022070407867432,
0.08176268637180328,
-0.5708242654800415,
-0.6968973875045776,
-0.553383469581604,
-0.22655224800109863,
-0.29622113704681396,
0.3529580533504486,
-0.309832900762558,
-1.08692467212677,
0.3056029677391052,
0.04600716009736061,
0.17957597970962524,
0.461701899766922,
-0.44559913873672485,
-0.08290272206068039,
-0.9356099367141724,
1.044508457183838,
0.5316737294197083,
0.5132692456245422,
-0.2648853361606598,
-0.2641972601413727,
-0.29027876257896423,
0.3265730142593384,
-0.3746033012866974,
-0.3625941276550293,
0.14783303439617157,
0.4003237187862396,
0.34740209579467773,
0.20975375175476074,
0.713927149772644,
0.540258526802063,
-0.4682561457157135,
0.7065473198890686,
-0.07654109597206116,
-0.8278993964195251,
0.34002912044525146,
-0.00021228250989224762,
0.14588235318660736,
0.45217064023017883,
0.6836392283439636,
-0.4814893901348114,
-0.15872398018836975,
-1.1878262758255005,
-0.43238598108291626,
0.2953118681907654,
-0.031107671558856964,
-0.4843270480632782,
0.04125768318772316,
0.3019763231277466,
0.009799998253583908,
0.15550562739372253,
-0.4219488501548767,
-0.08335411548614502,
-0.13840389251708984,
-0.06214749068021774,
0.43949201703071594,
-0.06550364941358566,
-0.5164625644683838,
-0.013616243377327919,
0.5948296189308167,
-0.3744731545448303,
0.15016013383865356,
0.19416028261184692,
-0.2853572964668274,
-0.006393762305378914,
0.08766632527112961,
0.9900342226028442,
0.8299931883811951,
-0.1800493597984314,
0.5614193677902222,
0.33843448758125305,
-0.6617596745491028,
0.3561018705368042,
0.156686931848526,
-0.28000548481941223,
0.4231259524822235,
0.40942102670669556,
0.2553074061870575,
0.3587527275085449,
-0.7148984670639038,
0.5173559784889221,
-0.4974549114704132,
-0.38841643929481506,
-0.4589135944843292,
-0.09884155541658401,
-0.3837125599384308,
0.02462804690003395,
0.49804094433784485,
0.4028970003128052,
0.1674601137638092,
-0.22144325077533722,
0.4411064386367798,
0.2189982533454895,
0.022915005683898926,
-0.35005223751068115,
0.7858926057815552,
-0.017971577122807503,
0.06480572372674942,
0.5956649780273438,
-0.06390377879142761,
-0.29878097772598267,
0.995679497718811,
0.28454944491386414,
0.826866865158081,
0.07093988358974457,
0.45571306347846985,
0.6243544816970825,
0.15088197588920593,
-0.0790020078420639,
0.13880634307861328,
-0.27370887994766235,
-0.3593437969684601,
-0.5080530643463135,
-0.4136096239089966,
-0.8277457356452942,
0.012818087823688984,
-0.6338863372802734,
0.14637917280197144,
-0.7320095300674438,
-0.521389365196228,
0.2019680291414261,
0.1412651240825653,
-0.44140753149986267,
0.4037117660045624,
0.023330122232437134,
1.1190191507339478,
-0.9247438907623291,
0.30983972549438477,
0.37279194593429565,
-0.2601253390312195,
-0.05932553857564926,
-0.033167995512485504,
0.2863311767578125,
-0.6082903742790222,
0.7456101179122925,
-0.20248804986476898,
-0.2709328830242157,
-0.0352790541946888,
-0.8126198053359985,
-0.5801931023597717,
0.5521090030670166,
0.7110562920570374,
-0.21548737585544586,
-0.015701839700341225,
0.3638291358947754,
0.43244317173957825,
0.18356044590473175,
0.1433592140674591,
0.06685679405927658,
0.5616391897201538,
0.14019468426704407,
-0.7683972120285034,
0.12501685321331024,
-0.052586719393730164,
-0.3066234886646271,
0.17020225524902344,
-0.7938355803489685,
0.7638508677482605,
-0.22137044370174408,
-0.29632821679115295,
-0.19150257110595703,
0.8967603445053101,
0.49997666478157043,
0.5197025537490845,
0.6555633544921875,
0.8577626943588257,
0.6689545512199402,
-0.352385014295578,
0.9174445271492004,
-0.46329399943351746,
0.36256280541419983,
0.9968904852867126,
-0.29218780994415283,
0.724709153175354,
-0.12722010910511017,
-0.592839777469635,
0.5756590962409973,
0.6747826337814331,
-0.1666429191827774,
0.1367553025484085,
0.362926185131073,
-0.6940561532974243,
-0.305646687746048,
-0.3699875473976135,
-0.4774843454360962,
0.19979190826416016,
0.4234425723552704,
0.4354417622089386,
-0.5742955803871155,
-0.31304359436035156,
-0.0650106742978096,
-0.11072482168674469,
-0.055112581700086594,
0.735937237739563,
0.056875430047512054,
-0.852985680103302,
0.6918200850486755,
0.253473699092865,
0.32678601145744324,
-0.6979215145111084,
-0.49626317620277405,
-0.12016880512237549,
0.2063186913728714,
-0.4725908041000366,
-0.507608950138092,
0.47475093603134155,
0.25653332471847534,
-0.09255627542734146,
-0.1802370548248291,
0.6625397205352783,
-0.18871314823627472,
-0.2413390576839447,
-0.5272226929664612,
0.33053064346313477,
-0.013473321683704853,
-0.6104793548583984,
-0.5001449584960938,
-0.07583769410848618,
-0.2950313687324524,
0.19646824896335602,
0.21470454335212708,
0.9648957848548889,
-0.38893812894821167,
0.5237228870391846,
0.6042609214782715,
0.18972189724445343,
-0.2116648554801941,
0.06137440353631973,
0.5009249448776245,
-0.606544554233551,
-0.3007039427757263,
-0.7134479880332947,
0.3558553457260132,
-0.3118170201778412,
-0.17023716866970062,
0.7582073211669922,
0.9448156356811523,
0.6320145130157471,
-0.10639520734548569,
0.8962914347648621,
-0.13635657727718353,
0.47992897033691406,
-0.41738131642341614,
0.41493943333625793,
-0.25738760828971863,
-0.11549744009971619,
-0.07547327131032944,
-0.7967968583106995,
-0.5719992518424988,
0.3788873255252838,
0.264764666557312,
-0.2780270278453827,
0.6560970544815063,
0.18140122294425964,
-0.2534978687763214,
0.19461682438850403,
0.1571127027273178,
0.05810030549764633,
0.288176029920578,
0.22420842945575714,
0.7619664669036865,
-0.4803033173084259,
0.5761765837669373,
-0.2669037878513336,
-0.2551057040691376,
-0.16454479098320007,
-1.2329752445220947,
-0.33238643407821655,
-0.3818863034248352,
-0.7978845834732056,
-0.5772558450698853,
-0.4505923092365265,
0.7356764674186707,
0.665314793586731,
-1.006946086883545,
-0.02112174965441227,
0.2207195907831192,
0.12128715217113495,
-0.46154624223709106,
-0.17395180463790894,
0.3110923767089844,
0.07097064703702927,
-0.35807234048843384,
0.12360991537570953,
0.2855827212333679,
0.3531641960144043,
-0.27991431951522827,
0.3417038321495056,
0.0795520469546318,
0.13141672313213348,
0.823728621006012,
0.9001896977424622,
-0.20205368101596832,
-0.1419786512851715,
-0.13673049211502075,
-0.15135706961154938,
0.0749841034412384,
1.2281358242034912,
-0.9001864194869995,
0.03520765155553818,
0.5863954424858093,
0.8076566457748413,
0.7249630689620972,
0.2333798110485077,
0.5838311910629272,
-0.9864486455917358,
-0.01960718259215355,
0.3031628727912903,
0.2534398138523102,
0.005749652627855539,
0.033702731132507324,
0.7456842660903931,
0.6087377667427063,
-0.2934499979019165,
-1.1490390300750732,
0.040774207562208176,
-0.8338683843612671,
-0.2502232789993286,
0.46858125925064087,
-0.2055928111076355,
-0.03573368489742279,
-0.008480947464704514,
0.07621949911117554,
0.0665617436170578,
0.019261736422777176,
1.0577038526535034,
0.6926503777503967,
-0.029742717742919922,
0.21395336091518402,
-0.6172583699226379,
0.4701889455318451,
-0.0015724989352747798,
-1.0902211666107178,
0.394972026348114,
0.8513233661651611,
0.19038726389408112,
0.32743003964424133,
0.462964802980423,
-0.24001647531986237,
0.3290155827999115,
0.3222828209400177,
0.16263142228126526,
-0.14970910549163818,
-0.5141267776489258,
-0.051203496754169464,
0.5799737572669983,
-0.27030789852142334,
-0.053224291652441025
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17158v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17158v1
|
Reflecting the Male Gaze: Quantifying Female Objectification in 19th and 20th Century Novels
| 2024-03-25T20:16:14 | 2024-03-25T20:16:14 |
Kexin Luo, Yue Mao, Bei Zhang, Sophie Hao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Inspired by the concept of the male gaze (Mulvey, 1975) in literature and
media studies, this paper proposes a framework for analyzing gender bias in
terms of female objectification: the extent to which a text portrays female
individuals as objects of visual pleasure. Our framework measures female
objectification along two axes. First, we compute an agency bias score that
indicates whether male entities are more likely to appear in the text as
grammatical agents than female entities. Next, by analyzing the word embedding
space induced by a text (Caliskan et al., 2017), we compute an appearance bias
score that indicates whether female entities are more closely associated with
appearance-related words than male entities. Applying our framework to 19th and
20th century novels reveals evidence of female objectification in literature:
we find that novels written from a male perspective systematically objectify
female characters, while novels written from a female perspective do not
exhibit statistically significant objectification of any gender.
|
[
-0.04307306185364723,
-0.6312282681465149,
0.5431159138679504,
0.20805315673351288,
0.20286814868450165,
-0.32719817757606506,
0.2135845273733139,
-0.43569397926330566,
0.21490810811519623,
0.6398048400878906,
-0.7293523550033569,
-0.22761797904968262,
-0.3349815905094147,
0.3062642812728882,
-0.423203706741333,
0.5327495336532593,
0.07211016863584518,
0.1491338312625885,
-0.646090030670166,
0.02775801159441471,
-0.3601723909378052,
-0.36489981412887573,
-0.02418309636414051,
-0.23536714911460876,
0.45891430974006653,
-0.35356006026268005,
0.6669604182243347,
0.2498219907283783,
0.49685776233673096,
0.2787989675998688,
0.07016052305698395,
0.26937443017959595,
-0.8037881851196289,
0.0938551276922226,
-0.07348532229661942,
-0.7939215898513794,
-0.1032993271946907,
0.41606855392456055,
0.5211749076843262,
0.600705087184906,
0.38026905059814453,
0.09233610332012177,
0.22015905380249023,
0.844584047794342,
-0.6909786462783813,
0.09785886853933334,
-0.12955528497695923,
0.181069016456604,
-0.13965977728366852,
-0.2953835725784302,
-0.6979940533638,
-0.30839186906814575,
0.3246549665927887,
-0.2825676202774048,
0.4907667338848114,
0.28964221477508545,
0.9693106412887573,
-0.1005554273724556,
-0.5044585466384888,
-0.20059289038181305,
-0.6941393613815308,
1.1813868284225464,
-0.180882066488266,
0.30728796124458313,
0.27178171277046204,
-0.015168332494795322,
0.12873415648937225,
-0.10100995749235153,
-0.25772932171821594,
-0.47079822421073914,
-0.4651486277580261,
-0.12179196625947952,
-0.15357275307178497,
-0.3777993619441986,
0.4126489758491516,
0.43249446153640747,
-0.3879384398460388,
-0.8735650181770325,
-0.2991124987602234,
0.0767359733581543,
0.6762909889221191,
0.07765752077102661,
0.5172094106674194,
-0.27080878615379333,
-0.5280444025993347,
0.21368475258350372,
-0.5362837910652161,
0.1197909340262413,
0.824543833732605,
0.38556385040283203,
0.26703593134880066,
0.5661922097206116,
0.23274172842502594,
0.37144899368286133,
0.33266177773475647,
0.06279334425926208,
0.12274127453565598,
-0.19760751724243164,
-0.07927394658327103,
0.0005746911629103124,
0.5475295186042786,
0.799737811088562,
0.23570990562438965,
-0.18274205923080444,
0.049816232174634933,
0.17429357767105103,
1.0900415182113647,
-0.5970395803451538,
0.09649612754583359,
-0.24890781939029694,
-0.8221286535263062,
-0.550348699092865,
0.2899205982685089,
-0.6825382113456726,
-0.8678432703018188,
-0.0881175696849823,
0.15894068777561188,
-0.1905308961868286,
-0.2806239128112793,
-0.2932209372520447,
-0.5980545878410339,
0.3416762948036194,
0.23690208792686462,
-1.2151848077774048,
0.08053817600011826,
0.6066008806228638,
0.49011939764022827,
-0.039033763110637665,
-0.19764339923858643,
0.08544651418924332,
0.15667563676834106,
-0.8872913718223572,
0.6305616497993469,
-0.5853555202484131,
-0.2774033844470978,
0.3175016939640045,
0.31035909056663513,
-0.21907223761081696,
-0.16973750293254852,
0.5274567604064941,
-0.07019098103046417,
0.3440982401371002,
-0.49650838971138,
-0.23869626224040985,
-0.39104950428009033,
0.3744881749153137,
-0.7197301983833313,
1.248471975326538,
0.29471662640571594,
-0.7874084711074829,
0.5860278606414795,
-0.05551433563232422,
-0.11526522785425186,
-0.29241400957107544,
-0.5163466930389404,
-0.37853744626045227,
0.18365417420864105,
0.0740007534623146,
0.24847234785556793,
-0.3815038204193115,
0.056248586624860764,
-0.3014008104801178,
-0.2780900001525879,
0.2737816870212555,
0.03307356685400009,
0.5284304022789001,
-0.2433774471282959,
-0.4440774917602539,
-0.09783708304166794,
-0.04109446704387665,
-0.3909244239330292,
0.03995531424880028,
0.014448034577071667,
-0.9242305159568787,
0.04854987934231758,
0.3938004672527313,
-0.32083672285079956,
0.2300819456577301,
-0.6346378922462463,
0.045372650027275085,
-0.1435798853635788,
0.266045480966568,
0.37167659401893616,
-0.1248294860124588,
0.7924920320510864,
-0.443882554769516,
0.40542715787887573,
-0.15203958749771118,
0.10236646234989166,
-0.31479668617248535,
-0.36631226539611816,
-0.560975193977356,
0.1649516373872757,
0.015401103533804417,
0.12996479868888855,
-0.47978636622428894,
0.22450411319732666,
0.05538001284003258,
-0.27076828479766846,
-0.1299791783094406,
-0.10218992829322815,
0.6114329695701599,
0.15031667053699493,
-0.05325237661600113,
-0.1284242570400238,
-0.38549017906188965,
-1.2971714735031128,
-0.8499782681465149,
-0.28771957755088806,
0.0526982806622982,
0.5523298978805542,
0.4835849702358246,
-0.2981637120246887,
0.7722720503807068,
-0.8599651455879211,
-0.7907654047012329,
-0.19073078036308289,
-0.023834720253944397,
-0.10529007762670517,
0.5571069717407227,
1.1503790616989136,
-0.8839962482452393,
-0.05152830854058266,
-0.04047632962465286,
-0.9649665355682373,
0.14377287030220032,
0.11053838580846786,
-0.633629322052002,
0.0013482861686497927,
0.6673771142959595,
-0.31219062209129333,
0.6409099102020264,
0.1084812581539154,
-0.7820898294448853,
0.7520878314971924,
0.16148477792739868,
0.6805123686790466,
-0.6273592114448547,
0.14830763638019562,
0.5610083937644958,
-0.16413360834121704,
-0.6627665162086487,
0.2662152945995331,
0.09160026162862778,
0.01135590672492981,
-0.2894377112388611,
0.7035512328147888,
-0.7306178212165833,
0.04425058886408806,
0.07225669175386429,
0.244350403547287,
0.553063154220581,
0.3081021308898926,
0.18888135254383087,
0.43876391649246216,
0.032620884478092194,
-0.4112327992916107,
-0.0971813052892685,
0.37030738592147827,
-0.21706289052963257,
0.7943311333656311,
-0.34839221835136414,
0.006377254147082567,
-0.5038513541221619,
-0.02996906451880932,
-1.3582428693771362,
-0.19086463749408722,
0.35022616386413574,
-0.2560023367404938,
0.19088433682918549,
-0.06415542215108871,
0.22936849296092987,
-0.264464795589447,
-0.606760561466217,
0.5888987183570862,
0.071771539747715,
-0.2748403251171112,
1.0269973278045654,
0.2868591248989105,
0.17229361832141876,
-0.7871013283729553,
-0.9108487963676453,
-0.2305597960948944,
-0.19590157270431519,
-0.2551117241382599,
0.24729658663272858,
0.07719845324754715,
-0.6269874572753906,
-0.18941296637058258,
-0.06129744276404381,
-0.13589097559452057,
-0.35826224088668823,
0.31576627492904663,
0.3352910578250885,
0.03519205003976822,
-0.014735016971826553,
0.10259813070297241,
0.2859043776988983,
0.20216478407382965,
0.10832969099283218,
0.13563908636569977,
0.17931856215000153,
-0.08310370147228241,
-0.2599512040615082,
0.5068106055259705,
0.4678620398044586,
-0.0035786249209195375,
0.46616503596305847,
0.5040488839149475,
-0.5055490136146545,
-0.2108161598443985,
-0.3914630711078644,
-0.3027046024799347,
-0.36464762687683105,
0.48569488525390625,
-0.7483429908752441,
-0.4218691885471344,
0.3885914087295532,
0.36892110109329224,
0.007671094033867121,
0.47334012389183044,
0.2335536628961563,
-0.1482638418674469,
0.9912921786308289,
1.0313587188720703,
-0.0819157212972641,
0.7788572907447815,
-0.4263465106487274,
0.11057738214731216,
-1.1866217851638794,
-0.24468763172626495,
-0.6976400017738342,
-0.3561497628688812,
-0.25160282850265503,
-0.411369264125824,
-0.11555927246809006,
-0.278739869594574,
-0.06379923224449158,
0.31317058205604553,
-0.6366481781005859,
0.4765996038913727,
0.5260517597198486,
0.49206238985061646,
0.2733612060546875,
-0.22863079607486725,
0.1885906457901001,
-0.35357865691185,
-0.3086922764778137,
-0.868845522403717,
1.2443451881408691,
0.48139140009880066,
0.6643113493919373,
0.449354350566864,
0.3008260726928711,
0.8851373195648193,
0.35637882351875305,
-0.6502622365951538,
0.6007673740386963,
-0.23847870528697968,
-1.0530067682266235,
-0.23240070044994354,
-0.08129353821277618,
-0.7775404453277588,
0.44367414712905884,
0.06571069359779358,
-0.8289956450462341,
1.0080971717834473,
0.03274693712592125,
-0.08868903666734695,
-0.06399756669998169,
-0.30869731307029724,
1.024376392364502,
0.12074283510446548,
-0.958262026309967,
-0.19079464673995972,
0.017636673524975777,
0.7280671000480652,
0.6045830845832825,
0.02259715087711811,
-0.25433769822120667,
-0.3550093173980713,
0.6598408818244934,
-0.20986057817935944,
0.9731625318527222,
-0.2826191782951355,
-0.5484693050384521,
0.060936249792575836,
0.40409424901008606,
0.10823391377925873,
-0.012128976173698902,
-0.07368075102567673,
0.019595839083194733,
0.13468626141548157,
-0.5460343360900879,
-0.3917461633682251,
0.4909942150115967,
-0.5062938928604126,
-0.560676097869873,
-0.5820701122283936,
-0.7934790849685669,
-0.0216976385563612,
0.26098740100860596,
0.14077316224575043,
0.9441505670547485,
-0.7942538857460022,
-0.21470381319522858,
0.5795632600784302,
0.05002748966217041,
0.35610777139663696,
-0.03277159482240677,
-0.8452903628349304,
-0.014627470634877682,
0.5936213731765747,
0.0049775876104831696,
0.2922382056713104,
0.6907172799110413,
-0.02499694935977459,
-0.48874610662460327,
-0.15359243750572205,
-0.5676847696304321,
0.44115686416625977,
-0.6757034659385681,
0.30707070231437683,
-0.46427538990974426,
0.20454595983028412,
-0.2763393819332123,
-0.13723379373550415,
-0.13309530913829803,
0.05315566435456276,
-0.46502652764320374,
0.22603489458560944,
0.0764589011669159,
0.6122349500656128,
0.8755514621734619,
0.1696799397468567,
-0.34073686599731445,
0.33595380187034607,
0.29528066515922546,
0.22942155599594116,
0.08429405838251114,
-0.43346306681632996,
-0.24348491430282593,
-0.17339639365673065,
-0.2708449959754944,
-0.8586647510528564,
0.5587776303291321,
0.23628804087638855,
0.35161298513412476,
0.9419780373573303,
0.10887382924556732,
0.3519757390022278,
-0.4107644557952881,
0.9239400625228882,
0.1280764788389206,
-0.7726210951805115,
0.3087804615497589,
-0.8782798647880554,
0.18637995421886444,
0.6646080613136292,
0.34498709440231323,
-0.49736881256103516,
-0.6117767095565796,
-0.3341587781906128,
-0.27430805563926697,
0.7862336039543152,
0.07448678463697433,
0.4528433680534363,
0.11236316710710526,
0.3580510914325714,
0.34640634059906006,
0.6283749938011169,
-0.915201723575592,
-0.40129196643829346,
-0.07123015075922012,
-0.34365731477737427,
-0.42306429147720337,
-0.3645921051502228,
-0.3319469690322876,
-0.017639141529798508,
0.43379977345466614,
-0.3587562143802643,
0.7731592059135437,
0.5588584542274475,
-0.4285069406032562,
-0.05893101543188095,
-0.1118217408657074,
0.45993858575820923,
0.8212213516235352,
-0.3645339906215668,
0.07201850414276123,
-0.5320289731025696,
-0.8341027498245239,
0.13607405126094818,
-0.19196265935897827,
-0.7506011128425598,
0.48045650124549866,
0.5385708212852478,
0.8396390676498413,
0.43730247020721436,
-0.5717435479164124,
0.4705754816532135,
0.07963171601295471,
-0.3273783028125763,
-0.37049931287765503,
0.0990770012140274,
-0.07625383883714676,
0.6058543920516968,
0.6923468112945557,
0.18697305023670197,
0.5141203999519348,
-1.083701729774475,
-0.32297974824905396,
0.6626898050308228,
-0.8510327935218811,
-0.11978244036436081,
0.7584971785545349,
0.26026174426078796,
-0.21572765707969666,
-0.012912547215819359,
-0.05534004047513008,
-0.5236797332763672,
0.6617116332054138,
0.30379417538642883,
1.1380040645599365,
-0.16055536270141602,
0.38226500153541565,
0.500874936580658,
0.5141893029212952,
-0.053975608199834824,
0.25753527879714966,
0.10401447117328644,
-0.676347553730011,
0.35502466559410095,
-0.508079469203949,
-0.1811901479959488,
-0.39787670969963074,
-0.44288432598114014,
0.10183504223823547,
-0.14969132840633392,
-0.3298368453979492,
0.25190189480781555,
-0.2328084260225296,
-0.1014653816819191,
0.08425208926200867,
0.1751125156879425,
0.629030704498291,
-0.8785492777824402,
0.1196678876876831,
0.8472155332565308,
-0.5297146439552307,
-0.2724699079990387,
0.36718448996543884,
0.2379034161567688,
-0.10507991164922714,
0.4200139343738556,
0.5858484506607056,
-0.2215234339237213,
-0.12144587934017181,
-0.2306797355413437,
-0.7544520497322083,
0.8306530117988586,
0.1934027075767517,
-0.4067807197570801,
-0.3599942922592163,
0.10606450587511063,
0.3815729320049286,
-0.7962571978569031,
0.6843234896659851,
0.6408487558364868,
0.6092237830162048,
-0.5887380838394165,
-0.5815791487693787,
-0.000016447209418402053,
-0.47454559803009033,
0.3538784384727478,
0.38521814346313477,
-0.8530944585800171,
0.6888712644577026,
-0.11161817610263824,
-0.09705501794815063,
0.2724701762199402,
0.7590410709381104,
-0.06981728225946426,
0.6049516797065735,
0.43331706523895264,
0.2455713003873825,
0.40894052386283875,
-0.5068321228027344,
0.968149721622467,
0.27113571763038635,
0.24872952699661255,
0.517349123954773,
-0.16094158589839935,
0.4122280478477478,
0.621747612953186,
-0.7240403294563293,
0.6606817245483398,
0.5555122494697571,
-0.08016076683998108,
0.48251116275787354,
0.04791492223739624,
-0.2111196666955948,
0.013787808828055859,
-0.2909524738788605,
-0.17453394830226898,
0.3959609568119049,
-0.1441224068403244,
-0.9518930912017822,
0.2755335569381714,
0.4441911280155182,
-0.07618740200996399,
0.5597698092460632,
-0.6055927276611328,
0.6131426095962524,
0.22668372094631195,
-0.6801435947418213,
0.24652038514614105,
-0.1930103898048401,
0.49838787317276,
-0.4575648009777069,
0.020043067634105682,
-0.1561778038740158,
0.4958063066005707,
-0.3289996087551117,
-0.21507519483566284,
0.07601908594369888,
-0.21274089813232422,
-1.0291669368743896,
-0.05542122945189476,
0.7707311511039734,
-0.6345313787460327,
-0.8200728297233582,
0.18592210114002228,
0.23553340137004852,
0.3166050910949707,
-0.18803103268146515,
-0.38769108057022095,
0.12918797135353088,
0.24790599942207336,
-0.4857529103755951,
0.358478307723999,
0.2730662524700165,
-0.10659562796354294,
0.6077660918235779,
0.10289277881383896,
-0.2824610471725464,
-0.049705903977155685,
0.3704303503036499,
0.2671986222267151,
-0.7037862539291382,
-0.5163763761520386,
-0.6729139089584351,
0.5109456777572632,
-0.16533324122428894,
-0.4003380835056305,
0.9383516907691956,
0.5871288180351257,
0.14072436094284058,
-0.5860691070556641,
0.5801753997802734,
-0.2710864841938019,
0.5211793780326843,
-0.07583867758512497,
0.9661206603050232,
-0.6489395499229431,
-0.03359368443489075,
-0.7778022885322571,
-1.2530964612960815,
0.11108241230249405,
0.571308970451355,
-0.609574019908905,
0.3240680396556854,
0.7485316395759583,
0.7844903469085693,
0.126723974943161,
0.27301010489463806,
0.24035866558551788,
-0.11300580203533173,
-0.25490251183509827,
0.062302496284246445,
1.0139609575271606,
-0.7906973361968994,
0.16949030756950378,
0.09698040783405304,
-0.29004132747650146,
-0.5539355278015137,
-0.6845312118530273,
-1.1724395751953125,
-0.6920062899589539,
-0.48326364159584045,
-0.07316167652606964,
0.1600906252861023,
0.3364863097667694,
0.7265556454658508,
-0.2669822573661804,
-0.3337171673774719,
0.08313827216625214,
0.10136056691408157,
-0.7258254289627075,
-0.3042948246002197,
0.32070037722587585,
-0.2542251944541931,
-1.2845522165298462,
0.00437419768422842,
-0.006056993268430233,
-0.40117770433425903,
-0.9829457998275757,
0.13311024010181427,
-0.27136263251304626,
0.32376059889793396,
0.6198445558547974,
-0.4714926481246948,
-0.8396450877189636,
-0.12204649299383163,
0.07827067375183105,
-0.11839797347784042,
0.12117443978786469,
0.9677439332008362,
-0.6479803323745728,
0.5183641910552979,
0.45606523752212524,
0.11934264749288559,
0.3565356135368347,
0.24209459125995636,
0.873349130153656,
-0.7737588882446289,
0.12294403463602066,
0.11104031652212143,
0.18537499010562897,
0.30265429615974426,
-0.829409658908844,
0.5085769295692444,
0.4141051173210144,
-0.4535646438598633,
-1.113131046295166,
0.3639782667160034,
-0.8941190242767334,
-0.4197651147842407,
0.8557552695274353,
-0.11967270076274872,
-0.5915669202804565,
-0.17758481204509735,
-0.573958158493042,
-0.15518635511398315,
-0.5876699686050415,
0.5918946266174316,
0.9196528792381287,
-0.1756143420934677,
-0.43556809425354004,
-0.8420952558517456,
0.5538161396980286,
0.39184483885765076,
-0.7488632798194885,
0.43675369024276733,
0.7073007225990295,
-0.2039128839969635,
0.4390049874782562,
0.2597784101963043,
-0.10546649247407913,
0.26345008611679077,
0.4553482234477997,
0.30462780594825745,
0.10084255039691925,
-0.3532097637653351,
0.06930889934301376,
0.35123708844184875,
-0.3015499413013458,
-0.09819691628217697
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17155v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17155v1
|
Task-Agnostic Detector for Insertion-Based Backdoor Attacks
| 2024-03-25T20:12:02 | 2024-03-25T20:12:02 |
Weimin Lyu, Xiao Lin, Songzhu Zheng, Lu Pang, Haibin Ling, Susmit Jha, Chao Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR
|
Textual backdoor attacks pose significant security threats. Current detection
approaches, typically relying on intermediate feature representation or
reconstructing potential triggers, are task-specific and less effective beyond
sentence classification, struggling with tasks like question answering and
named entity recognition. We introduce TABDet (Task-Agnostic Backdoor
Detector), a pioneering task-agnostic method for backdoor detection. TABDet
leverages final layer logits combined with an efficient pooling technique,
enabling unified logit representation across three prominent NLP tasks. TABDet
can jointly learn from diverse task-specific models, demonstrating superior
detection efficacy over traditional task-specific methods.
|
[
-0.043603766709566116,
-0.6694908142089844,
0.5509227514266968,
0.11972077935934067,
-0.054226309061050415,
0.2739506959915161,
0.09934207051992416,
-0.38687875866889954,
0.14661164581775665,
0.6949188113212585,
-0.5718964338302612,
-0.8218671083450317,
-0.3858039677143097,
-0.025660334154963493,
-0.6153408885002136,
1.0627487897872925,
0.12834836542606354,
-0.5099306702613831,
0.16043001413345337,
0.09527470171451569,
-0.9493069052696228,
-0.6402500867843628,
-0.5851610898971558,
-0.0935693234205246,
0.4569576680660248,
0.20581603050231934,
0.33699601888656616,
0.16738246381282806,
0.4798763692378998,
0.1671970933675766,
0.4714565575122833,
-0.15447604656219482,
0.03809652104973793,
0.34524592757225037,
-0.4250476062297821,
-0.7389620542526245,
-0.41294384002685547,
-0.20582199096679688,
0.35988232493400574,
-0.036099258810281754,
-0.2668261229991913,
0.30762308835983276,
-0.14928090572357178,
0.31360533833503723,
-0.8428740501403809,
-0.16247326135635376,
-1.0244430303573608,
0.16472889482975006,
-0.44693252444267273,
-0.3413584232330322,
-0.6534212231636047,
0.021649446338415146,
-0.2482176274061203,
-0.014077992178499699,
0.6007400155067444,
0.13250648975372314,
0.5747949481010437,
0.14813007414340973,
-0.3246064782142639,
-0.23672981560230255,
-0.42765113711357117,
0.26854804158210754,
-0.5095392465591431,
0.875971794128418,
0.24838176369667053,
0.3114493191242218,
-0.40509629249572754,
-0.8142144680023193,
-0.6640329957008362,
-0.4351038336753845,
-0.24420912563800812,
-0.2466890811920166,
-0.298175185918808,
0.22812452912330627,
0.10071001946926117,
0.5097567439079285,
-1.1723047494888306,
0.24229079484939575,
0.14445285499095917,
-0.2904186546802521,
0.29802992939949036,
0.21095959842205048,
0.6184358596801758,
-0.28689685463905334,
-0.4672006070613861,
-0.08782853931188583,
-0.5984325408935547,
0.30641621351242065,
0.3690389394760132,
0.3247653841972351,
0.24585846066474915,
0.5035565495491028,
0.16065044701099396,
0.6408426761627197,
0.4348750114440918,
0.12632881104946136,
0.2118881791830063,
-0.1311745047569275,
-0.26939138770103455,
0.06732559204101562,
0.49358779191970825,
-0.06585491448640823,
-0.4597982168197632,
-0.6566393375396729,
-0.4679596424102783,
0.443600594997406,
0.6944130659103394,
-0.6617984175682068,
-0.38490599393844604,
0.5650582313537598,
-0.2433662712574005,
-0.4371694028377533,
0.20675607025623322,
-0.5274949669837952,
-0.3731200397014618,
0.4251471161842346,
0.4305490553379059,
-0.3277987837791443,
-0.09541264921426773,
0.030723318457603455,
-0.3415044844150543,
0.43604031205177307,
0.13728263974189758,
-0.6412699222564697,
0.673973798751831,
0.9057576656341553,
0.870052695274353,
-0.4506785273551941,
-0.27626872062683105,
-1.0333092212677002,
0.32469886541366577,
-0.1386869251728058,
0.8749438524246216,
-0.2820911109447479,
-0.2501269578933716,
-0.26585420966148376,
0.2904651165008545,
-0.16364337503910065,
-0.38633841276168823,
0.4919684827327728,
-0.8194047212600708,
0.15922501683235168,
0.17096279561519623,
-0.3287545442581177,
-0.4624221920967102,
0.5815469622612,
-0.7158951759338379,
1.3380526304244995,
0.26653724908828735,
-0.7202403545379639,
0.40424084663391113,
-0.7899720668792725,
-0.6238507628440857,
0.28888073563575745,
-0.1222170814871788,
-0.4913703501224518,
0.13253864645957947,
0.13630962371826172,
0.6125208139419556,
0.16524551808834076,
0.16562049090862274,
-0.03795317932963371,
-0.19313526153564453,
0.2020748406648636,
-0.35106855630874634,
0.8846350908279419,
-0.14037658274173737,
-0.6929080486297607,
-0.08930116891860962,
-0.5235276818275452,
-0.06768222898244858,
-0.14332911372184753,
-0.036364488303661346,
-0.4370936155319214,
-0.33116626739501953,
0.13621458411216736,
0.11581896990537643,
0.3941420912742615,
-1.2098770141601562,
0.07471693307161331,
-0.38046473264694214,
-0.1262616217136383,
0.7902922630310059,
0.043038032948970795,
0.1610163301229477,
-0.09781047701835632,
0.6167737245559692,
0.014064569026231766,
0.12385734915733337,
-0.31702715158462524,
-0.5165694952011108,
-0.21727125346660614,
-0.5503591299057007,
0.12579886615276337,
1.2164198160171509,
-0.7243668437004089,
0.5757501721382141,
-0.04367413371801376,
-0.5046226978302002,
0.03861100599169731,
0.2575663924217224,
0.5877736806869507,
0.325986385345459,
0.35709837079048157,
-0.3691214323043823,
-0.3781719207763672,
-0.8316268920898438,
-0.5636079907417297,
-0.14192359149456024,
-0.17317914962768555,
0.1111912727355957,
0.7355158925056458,
-0.39462894201278687,
0.6905921101570129,
-0.7360230088233948,
-0.3987122178077698,
-0.16946862637996674,
0.1192559227347374,
0.43727436661720276,
0.55684494972229,
0.5526266098022461,
-0.9689180850982666,
-0.7574348449707031,
0.3407849073410034,
-0.6572614312171936,
0.011814459227025509,
-0.08149884641170502,
0.2049272060394287,
0.09264598786830902,
0.43149304389953613,
-0.7536735534667969,
0.7647656202316284,
0.6388583779335022,
-0.46162959933280945,
0.4389662444591522,
-0.05897804722189903,
0.18207883834838867,
-1.0270708799362183,
0.09061981737613678,
-0.13789790868759155,
-0.6466177701950073,
-0.9410944581031799,
0.4113742709159851,
0.3188911974430084,
-0.3101634681224823,
-0.2042919397354126,
0.6147515177726746,
-0.5248296856880188,
-0.3016614317893982,
-0.17511580884456635,
-0.018555747345089912,
0.02284921705722809,
0.764390230178833,
-0.1592903733253479,
0.8075509667396545,
0.3607267141342163,
-0.29810968041419983,
0.7019228339195251,
0.29731228947639465,
0.11098398268222809,
0.6386224627494812,
-0.48332229256629944,
0.45917922258377075,
0.2489883005619049,
0.6972180604934692,
-1.2934662103652954,
-0.10662373900413513,
0.7568680047988892,
-0.6646397709846497,
0.5517557859420776,
-0.030750444158911705,
-0.5181500315666199,
-0.6288947463035583,
-0.6798315644264221,
0.34625673294067383,
0.23608553409576416,
-0.5533977150917053,
0.8486045598983765,
0.2220509946346283,
-0.12662842869758606,
-0.813422679901123,
-0.7878516912460327,
0.22165802121162415,
0.03770388662815094,
-0.48316460847854614,
0.48777681589126587,
0.2619888186454773,
0.20607376098632812,
0.04293345659971237,
-0.6391006708145142,
-0.3909038305282593,
0.23220372200012207,
0.4968336522579193,
0.1472252458333969,
-0.28145018219947815,
-0.07430839538574219,
0.02925809472799301,
-0.1878732293844223,
-0.10346848517656326,
-0.7076054215431213,
0.5421608090400696,
-0.21826772391796112,
-0.6073457598686218,
-0.5221543312072754,
0.6157662868499756,
0.3978864550590515,
-0.4335725009441376,
0.4104176461696625,
0.7506127953529358,
-0.5311675071716309,
-0.39901161193847656,
-0.7752304077148438,
-0.37978053092956543,
-0.5070182681083679,
0.2291017770767212,
-0.5005391836166382,
-0.876969039440155,
0.6283917427062988,
0.2134072482585907,
0.3823595643043518,
0.003879902185872197,
0.31275132298469543,
0.019627630710601807,
0.5037981867790222,
0.6506738066673279,
0.19376112520694733,
0.3346303701400757,
-0.08435055613517761,
0.41770756244659424,
-0.8655640482902527,
-0.09235356748104095,
-0.4011595845222473,
-0.22876445949077606,
-0.45373204350471497,
-0.3063560426235199,
0.17620711028575897,
-0.4320252537727356,
0.24934113025665283,
0.864355742931366,
-0.718569278717041,
0.1785535365343094,
0.42361342906951904,
0.8249173164367676,
0.33474165201187134,
-0.3827281892299652,
0.06813082098960876,
0.36518701910972595,
-0.5540554523468018,
-0.1365528702735901,
1.2968041896820068,
0.3766937851905823,
0.7307791709899902,
0.07275550812482834,
0.9754320979118347,
0.781122088432312,
0.34985801577568054,
-0.5152462720870972,
0.6836329698562622,
-0.42366257309913635,
-1.0210230350494385,
-0.5564711689949036,
0.16130657494068146,
-1.061320185661316,
0.06234370917081833,
0.14065812528133392,
-1.3360259532928467,
0.44814786314964294,
0.25460758805274963,
-0.5037153959274292,
0.6601744890213013,
-0.6842308640480042,
0.9787594676017761,
-0.013483285903930664,
-0.05957627296447754,
0.015337948687374592,
-0.556742787361145,
0.4608120024204254,
-0.22917725145816803,
-0.05687261372804642,
-0.062121305614709854,
-0.09062768518924713,
0.580784261226654,
-0.32433488965034485,
0.9914588928222656,
-0.33028414845466614,
-0.25832685828208923,
0.23112978041172028,
0.36716386675834656,
0.7800990343093872,
0.3090702295303345,
0.38364043831825256,
0.056873489171266556,
-0.1179431825876236,
-0.3555437922477722,
-0.7696199417114258,
0.4584881365299225,
0.04719293862581253,
-1.070501685142517,
-0.4281803369522095,
-0.6183709502220154,
-0.08639637380838394,
0.016572464257478714,
0.3053419291973114,
0.5529080629348755,
-0.011430371552705765,
0.2552650570869446,
0.8338664770126343,
-0.17409177124500275,
0.3560173213481903,
0.2378363162279129,
-0.21479156613349915,
-0.20159652829170227,
0.9485935568809509,
-0.2597372829914093,
-0.03876764699816704,
0.8563937544822693,
0.02070043794810772,
-0.37115800380706787,
-0.4750944674015045,
-0.39482343196868896,
-0.0248502716422081,
-0.5254088640213013,
-0.5255107879638672,
-0.9670372605323792,
-0.37946099042892456,
-0.19216163456439972,
-0.3724193572998047,
-0.3406352698802948,
-0.24890142679214478,
0.24611744284629822,
-0.12459825724363327,
0.44043493270874023,
0.17375515401363373,
-0.1807098686695099,
0.5361703634262085,
-0.8601759076118469,
0.8627067804336548,
0.6159762144088745,
0.31785258650779724,
-0.08931158483028412,
-0.25410735607147217,
-0.1863655298948288,
-0.24559162557125092,
-0.24378065764904022,
-1.2673088312149048,
0.16508467495441437,
-0.024233639240264893,
0.6431731581687927,
0.004142714664340019,
0.10878816246986389,
0.08035099506378174,
-0.5957186222076416,
0.8011059165000916,
0.15931926667690277,
-1.0528368949890137,
0.6108097434043884,
-0.2651844024658203,
0.038862697780132294,
0.4844571650028229,
0.06870368123054504,
-0.4412151873111725,
-0.7043750882148743,
-0.5831156373023987,
-0.5307199954986572,
0.49621662497520447,
0.20315837860107422,
0.08226118236780167,
0.3071064054965973,
0.25759610533714294,
0.5220314860343933,
0.4456610083580017,
-0.9226847887039185,
0.0005193790420889854,
-0.30301007628440857,
-0.05192963406443596,
0.13330861926078796,
0.06900516897439957,
0.07316967844963074,
0.025983599945902824,
0.29352059960365295,
0.21029610931873322,
0.5791602730751038,
0.2612253725528717,
-0.5454089641571045,
0.08032535761594772,
0.41076338291168213,
0.3534700870513916,
0.25511839985847473,
-0.3525579571723938,
0.06880054622888565,
0.34107697010040283,
-1.1035293340682983,
0.5698596239089966,
0.3643893897533417,
-0.17059138417243958,
0.3415621221065521,
0.3151901364326477,
0.4687242805957794,
0.2535528838634491,
-0.19872865080833435,
0.9315647482872009,
0.0840010866522789,
-0.06553395837545395,
-0.2348182201385498,
0.19094181060791016,
-0.6042112708091736,
0.6564632058143616,
0.6567074656486511,
0.02566133439540863,
0.5697776079177856,
-0.4891459345817566,
0.7900047898292542,
0.6734830141067505,
-0.3829253315925598,
-0.4473012685775757,
0.4946194589138031,
0.16005505621433258,
-0.5380984544754028,
0.32214856147766113,
-0.08233816921710968,
-0.9177947044372559,
0.4485839605331421,
0.605720579624176,
1.5331568717956543,
-0.9122292995452881,
0.4148431420326233,
-0.27381816506385803,
0.7617515325546265,
0.20397183299064636,
0.3471926152706146,
-0.4001196324825287,
-0.8202056288719177,
-0.15833242237567902,
-0.32739412784576416,
-0.3764227628707886,
0.18191450834274292,
-0.5630128979682922,
0.16736914217472076,
-0.5329881906509399,
-0.15393656492233276,
-0.1420259326696396,
-0.24864338338375092,
-0.6381008625030518,
0.12187542766332626,
-0.13835954666137695,
0.8387720584869385,
-0.7984835505485535,
0.6395724415779114,
0.6471054553985596,
0.03331655636429787,
-0.46164223551750183,
0.3641646206378937,
-0.17810973525047302,
-0.8771367073059082,
0.6907437443733215,
0.38563165068626404,
-0.14111967384815216,
0.06074398383498192,
-0.3346565067768097,
-0.3512912392616272,
0.8577227592468262,
0.06361827999353409,
-0.22865693271160126,
-0.571433961391449,
-0.27043238282203674,
0.15159711241722107,
-0.08241776376962662,
-0.20719774067401886,
0.207481250166893,
0.5780357718467712,
-0.3038490116596222,
-0.9593758583068848,
0.5325749516487122,
-0.1300904005765915,
-0.07210099697113037,
0.473503977060318,
-0.17537614703178406,
0.9714231491088867,
0.13108810782432556,
-0.41453492641448975,
-0.22941023111343384,
0.5831260681152344,
0.3270505666732788,
0.6979764699935913,
0.5973387360572815,
0.549408495426178,
0.47880059480667114,
0.10024384409189224,
0.6898341774940491,
-0.24806250631809235,
-0.027767715975642204,
1.0617014169692993,
-0.27510055899620056,
0.5624938607215881,
0.285970538854599,
-0.050984252244234085,
0.7506932020187378,
0.31185412406921387,
-0.387378990650177,
0.5949600338935852,
0.09906454384326935,
-0.33854052424430847,
-0.028047975152730942,
0.2448326051235199,
-0.434126615524292,
0.5625312924385071,
0.4975619614124298,
-0.06412015855312347,
-0.5852599740028381,
0.4785144627094269,
0.010830914601683617,
-0.02122565545141697,
-0.4988061785697937,
0.42124900221824646,
-0.07741474360227585,
-0.3775729238986969,
0.4349115788936615,
-0.11109371483325958,
0.7153773903846741,
-0.6558964252471924,
-0.05518018454313278,
0.1234130859375,
0.1749105602502823,
-0.3665025532245636,
-1.0298305749893188,
0.3666057884693146,
0.12830282747745514,
0.07965684682130814,
-0.13813109695911407,
1.2209227085113525,
-0.16484035551548004,
0.03148297220468521,
0.12690997123718262,
0.4528062045574188,
-0.17664994299411774,
-0.4408714473247528,
-0.36809706687927246,
-0.19140736758708954,
0.019150368869304657,
-0.3254965543746948,
0.0043207514099776745,
0.6378493309020996,
-0.031051374971866608,
0.597788393497467,
0.9136092066764832,
-0.1809847056865692,
0.1870175153017044,
-0.5379747748374939,
0.9986674785614014,
-0.645995557308197,
-0.8240073919296265,
-0.9564246535301208,
0.702109694480896,
-0.1509593427181244,
-0.13781127333641052,
0.9095248579978943,
0.6016853451728821,
0.6016117930412292,
-0.18976743519306183,
0.6876312494277954,
0.033641986548900604,
0.4342409670352936,
-0.406319797039032,
0.37346452474594116,
-0.2901458740234375,
0.12362216413021088,
-0.6180088520050049,
-0.9034752249717712,
-0.38246530294418335,
0.2290123552083969,
-0.22953422367572784,
-0.307720422744751,
0.9886929392814636,
0.7417779564857483,
-0.21567250788211823,
0.02555461786687374,
0.5066567063331604,
0.036982323974370956,
0.41633057594299316,
0.6127809882164001,
0.6622093319892883,
-0.4456935524940491,
0.5363549590110779,
0.03032076172530651,
-0.4443435072898865,
-0.3784182667732239,
-0.7726569771766663,
-1.2806458473205566,
-0.6099463105201721,
0.06055323779582977,
-0.2427828311920166,
0.470272421836853,
0.44148579239845276,
0.47467041015625,
-0.9104390144348145,
-0.09130799025297165,
-0.2087152600288391,
0.2969767153263092,
-0.3470771014690399,
-0.263073205947876,
0.24751703441143036,
-0.14370866119861603,
-0.01989082805812359,
0.19289441406726837,
0.6439440250396729,
-0.21633575856685638,
-0.2059340626001358,
0.46340659260749817,
-0.30889376997947693,
-0.009042697958648205,
0.42604660987854004,
0.6198468208312988,
-0.7808667421340942,
-0.40413302183151245,
0.14806407690048218,
-0.12117163091897964,
-0.07232438772916794,
0.7905505895614624,
-0.8289133310317993,
-0.10792553424835205,
0.43446454405784607,
0.9950803518295288,
0.5077918171882629,
-0.28826430439949036,
0.5974935293197632,
-1.0118529796600342,
0.3994104266166687,
0.4099164307117462,
-0.02579246275126934,
-0.0023104227147996426,
-0.8699630498886108,
0.47105205059051514,
0.40548497438430786,
-0.31327155232429504,
-1.2290198802947998,
0.5163493156433105,
-0.9505582451820374,
-0.33560022711753845,
0.5473435521125793,
-0.3672386407852173,
-0.45123451948165894,
-0.4456581771373749,
-0.028995150700211525,
-0.063997782766819,
-0.6621182560920715,
0.538091242313385,
0.45361045002937317,
-0.16153883934020996,
-0.26663434505462646,
-0.5019983649253845,
0.3591637909412384,
-0.08246832340955734,
-0.7958577275276184,
0.08093972504138947,
0.05606597289443016,
0.06051396206021309,
0.38797518610954285,
0.6305095553398132,
0.10902401059865952,
0.6959449648857117,
0.22901377081871033,
0.026423590257763863,
-0.18163619935512543,
-0.571475088596344,
-0.054574526846408844,
0.2719835638999939,
-0.336187481880188,
-0.6139164566993713
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17146v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17146v1
|
Outcome-Constrained Large Language Models for Countering Hate Speech
| 2024-03-25T19:44:06 | 2024-03-25T19:44:06 |
Lingzi Hong, Pengcheng Luo, Eduardo Blanco, Xiaoying Song
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Counterspeech that challenges or responds to hate speech has been seen as an
alternative to mitigate the negative impact of hate speech and foster
productive online communications. Research endeavors have been directed to
using language models for the automatic generation of counterspeech to assist
efforts in combating online hate. Existing research focuses on the generation
of counterspeech with certain linguistic attributes, such as being polite,
informative, and intent-driven. However, it remains unclear what impact the
counterspeech might have in an online environment. We first explore methods
that utilize large language models (LLM) to generate counterspeech constrained
by potential conversation outcomes. We build two conversation outcome
classifiers that predict the incivility level and the hater reentry behavior
following replies to hate with Reddit data, then propose four methods to
incorporate the desired outcomes, i.e., low conversation incivility and
non-hateful hater reentry, into the text generation process, including Prompt
with Instructions, Prompt and Select, LLM finetune, and LLM transformer
reinforcement learning (TRL). Evaluation results show effective strategies to
generate outcome-constrained counterspeech and the linguistic characteristics
of texts generated by different methods.
|
[
-0.5600141882896423,
-1.090623140335083,
0.3805394470691681,
0.10931208729743958,
-0.10053406655788422,
0.018081920221447945,
-0.27314555644989014,
-0.5343506932258606,
0.5190860629081726,
0.5489946007728577,
-0.7042754888534546,
-0.08290273696184158,
-0.546604573726654,
0.17208801209926605,
-0.5190368294715881,
1.2468805313110352,
0.19657306373119354,
0.08047402650117874,
-0.044334691017866135,
0.003668575081974268,
-0.4513237476348877,
-0.8569661378860474,
-0.7622141242027283,
-0.4293051064014435,
0.6264792680740356,
0.42847946286201477,
0.5090739130973816,
0.33309850096702576,
0.4974324703216553,
0.27586930990219116,
0.11496783792972565,
-0.14922986924648285,
-0.8801622986793518,
0.3475978970527649,
-0.13049861788749695,
-0.15766501426696777,
-0.04547387734055519,
0.008679667487740517,
0.392551064491272,
0.20152242481708527,
-0.3641018867492676,
0.03716980293393135,
-0.06995474547147751,
0.047814443707466125,
-0.4661511778831482,
-0.1895408034324646,
-0.871922492980957,
0.18858933448791504,
-0.1387343853712082,
0.0946473777294159,
-0.4959142804145813,
-0.4784633219242096,
-0.10931167006492615,
-0.34549760818481445,
0.09314022958278656,
0.0028550196439027786,
0.4120545983314514,
0.1197485625743866,
-0.27643853425979614,
-0.5918867588043213,
-0.7911574840545654,
0.9523078203201294,
-1.0717923641204834,
0.49185317754745483,
0.45834675431251526,
0.22317726910114288,
-0.24440206587314606,
-0.42828813195228577,
-0.8226195573806763,
-0.4080345630645752,
-0.1126294657588005,
0.12557847797870636,
-0.28170979022979736,
0.012405762448906898,
0.3645903468132019,
0.13470226526260376,
-0.4405631422996521,
0.4554177224636078,
-0.20247283577919006,
-0.011971079744398594,
0.6939413547515869,
0.48802629113197327,
0.08118262887001038,
-0.18604730069637299,
-0.28516075015068054,
0.14766062796115875,
-0.5502408742904663,
-0.12480466067790985,
0.6803920865058899,
0.5141963958740234,
-0.05415504798293114,
0.6334232687950134,
-0.2475888729095459,
0.5517080426216125,
0.13441400229930878,
-0.29607364535331726,
-0.011507617309689522,
0.0022021401673555374,
0.12704375386238098,
-0.04873266816139221,
0.8076188564300537,
0.2399030476808548,
0.4996167719364166,
0.013364971615374088,
-0.21534298360347748,
0.4815690815448761,
0.6297458410263062,
-1.0231269598007202,
-0.005194717086851597,
0.10404808819293976,
-0.33981117606163025,
-0.5431278944015503,
-0.3849557936191559,
-1.0126835107803345,
-0.5220162868499756,
-0.16467557847499847,
0.2427171915769577,
-0.2664806544780731,
-0.24153907597064972,
-0.46037405729293823,
-0.1462465226650238,
-0.019628973677754402,
0.28842833638191223,
-0.7973575592041016,
0.6285020709037781,
0.48674315214157104,
0.6274011731147766,
-0.4688876271247864,
-0.10761590301990509,
-0.7884288430213928,
-0.14263081550598145,
-0.2661845088005066,
0.5298027396202087,
-0.7361636757850647,
-0.48653528094291687,
0.2639874517917633,
-0.40680280327796936,
0.3257351815700531,
-0.37162768840789795,
0.5827732086181641,
-0.5927403569221497,
0.22032563388347626,
0.0774594321846962,
-0.6347020268440247,
0.017711203545331955,
0.40883108973503113,
-0.4896615743637085,
0.6539668440818787,
0.030767973512411118,
-0.7985424399375916,
0.05489644035696983,
-0.38975876569747925,
-0.7499125003814697,
0.16382676362991333,
-0.18640205264091492,
-0.66849684715271,
0.308150976896286,
-0.26863959431648254,
0.24072515964508057,
-0.26657962799072266,
0.2070721536874771,
-0.3288678824901581,
0.00711457384750247,
0.48167070746421814,
-0.2998615503311157,
0.46720772981643677,
0.4180976450443268,
-0.5366176962852478,
0.1328478306531906,
-0.5413700342178345,
-0.0795179158449173,
0.3912025988101959,
-0.33145761489868164,
-0.23896782100200653,
0.2697652280330658,
0.20631740987300873,
0.25462761521339417,
-0.18823711574077606,
-0.8652428984642029,
-0.3019685745239258,
-0.3895263671875,
0.3085123598575592,
0.8305855393409729,
0.018973184749484062,
-0.043049294501543045,
-0.41270509362220764,
0.6076127290725708,
-0.22866052389144897,
0.13734424114227295,
0.2562272250652313,
-0.5431702733039856,
-0.661263108253479,
0.05460096895694733,
-0.16669026017189026,
0.4283432364463806,
-0.7606574892997742,
0.015163499861955643,
0.033914003521203995,
-0.5702486634254456,
-0.24202094972133636,
-0.21660062670707703,
0.7582581639289856,
0.6376710534095764,
0.3424524962902069,
-0.4057806432247162,
-0.8692290186882019,
-0.8320261240005493,
-0.28820091485977173,
-0.24807709455490112,
0.09015011042356491,
0.33010271191596985,
0.277121365070343,
-0.07111268490552902,
0.7475500702857971,
-0.4828750789165497,
0.025196654722094536,
-0.3983965218067169,
0.3476281464099884,
-0.0960087850689888,
0.20844270288944244,
0.27633392810821533,
-0.8424351811408997,
-0.7061519622802734,
-0.4808262288570404,
-0.20581305027008057,
-0.30875346064567566,
0.019937705248594284,
0.1885751336812973,
0.3278111517429352,
0.3534637987613678,
-0.45092111825942993,
0.5789530277252197,
0.6242268681526184,
-0.24605996906757355,
0.7475770115852356,
0.48792752623558044,
0.4422444701194763,
-0.8628895878791809,
-0.1937098503112793,
-0.030748242512345314,
-0.3447267413139343,
-1.1859917640686035,
0.1609659492969513,
-0.4798879623413086,
-0.3113074004650116,
-0.6750101447105408,
0.5610599517822266,
0.1255500316619873,
0.22356534004211426,
-0.46386536955833435,
0.10315319150686264,
-0.45062488317489624,
0.4004606008529663,
0.5372146368026733,
0.5408768653869629,
-0.23673024773597717,
-0.7196153402328491,
0.2522023916244507,
0.4034043848514557,
-0.2997725009918213,
0.8030940890312195,
-0.5292475819587708,
0.09094466269016266,
0.04412892833352089,
0.21705493330955505,
-0.7901352643966675,
-0.054552190005779266,
0.28309375047683716,
-0.6484765410423279,
-0.010254651308059692,
-0.08945474028587341,
-0.13720503449440002,
-0.4181981086730957,
-0.2330179363489151,
0.4846126139163971,
0.6231754422187805,
-0.3236357271671295,
0.47930029034614563,
0.6549162864685059,
-0.34198522567749023,
-0.33885711431503296,
-0.7661502361297607,
0.07934042811393738,
-0.31815046072006226,
-0.1423114836215973,
0.2999056875705719,
-0.45026952028274536,
-0.6676148772239685,
-0.39457616209983826,
0.4633914530277252,
0.046459365636110306,
-0.010331621393561363,
0.3369775712490082,
-0.018004368990659714,
0.11709543317556381,
0.07036954909563065,
-0.3827156126499176,
0.12948259711265564,
0.18829013407230377,
0.02048133686184883,
0.9005216956138611,
0.2392992079257965,
-0.14853866398334503,
-0.0977879986166954,
0.6509509682655334,
0.2700272798538208,
0.064326211810112,
0.8547143340110779,
0.46766525506973267,
-0.30265673995018005,
-0.327386736869812,
-0.7450245022773743,
-0.4648013114929199,
-0.42669156193733215,
0.4282674491405487,
-0.20689193904399872,
-1.1003941297531128,
0.39753568172454834,
0.29635974764823914,
0.2806473672389984,
0.32080456614494324,
0.8557676672935486,
0.005209759343415499,
0.9686843752861023,
0.46691182255744934,
0.24729998409748077,
0.5450387001037598,
0.5425868630409241,
0.30723950266838074,
-0.42225906252861023,
0.06621026992797852,
-0.6437883973121643,
-0.16570104658603668,
-0.5783100128173828,
-0.2411864548921585,
0.19737926125526428,
-0.28874316811561584,
-0.41351649165153503,
0.3946257531642914,
-0.4389137029647827,
0.11708585172891617,
0.5165897011756897,
-0.06340909749269485,
0.1382478028535843,
0.2299971580505371,
0.05252986028790474,
-0.5365689396858215,
-0.6703013181686401,
-0.04107477515935898,
0.9286600351333618,
0.26315563917160034,
0.6371574401855469,
0.37130945920944214,
0.49786874651908875,
0.4703834056854248,
0.6592345237731934,
-0.7257729172706604,
0.5995957255363464,
-0.08509940654039383,
-0.616898775100708,
-0.2674782872200012,
-0.8128334283828735,
-0.7212511897087097,
-0.09039925038814545,
-0.4150083065032959,
-0.7035532593727112,
-0.34136253595352173,
0.3502764403820038,
-0.14883047342300415,
0.368573397397995,
-0.38199567794799805,
0.6149858832359314,
-0.2799871563911438,
-0.31621718406677246,
-0.5260230302810669,
-0.36714914441108704,
0.45979487895965576,
-0.2393876165151596,
0.5079509615898132,
0.05284978449344635,
0.21332213282585144,
0.6825074553489685,
-0.3912331759929657,
1.04897940158844,
-0.10049960762262344,
-0.1424991488456726,
0.4183189570903778,
0.4427053928375244,
0.8206519484519958,
-0.36020299792289734,
-0.21317452192306519,
0.2755283713340759,
-0.4093928337097168,
-0.02458938956260681,
-0.23905102908611298,
0.6996995210647583,
-0.5264414548873901,
-0.5946614742279053,
-0.08434328436851501,
-0.45234203338623047,
-0.27560827136039734,
0.12807869911193848,
0.30588361620903015,
0.21196100115776062,
-0.5416093468666077,
-0.13569514453411102,
0.6460264325141907,
-0.573216438293457,
0.26648518443107605,
0.8502785563468933,
-0.4686601758003235,
-0.501998782157898,
1.1110939979553223,
0.18520912528038025,
0.4607641100883484,
0.33608219027519226,
0.5122673511505127,
-0.25387972593307495,
-0.43171319365501404,
-0.20397627353668213,
0.013347920961678028,
-0.5660039186477661,
-0.34537601470947266,
-0.7696548104286194,
-0.36445969343185425,
-0.5581513047218323,
-0.2838726043701172,
-0.3275962471961975,
-0.4169778823852539,
-0.060782745480537415,
0.029677901417016983,
0.533304750919342,
1.0671255588531494,
-0.2892267107963562,
0.5000323057174683,
-0.3990148603916168,
0.5157887935638428,
0.4100722074508667,
0.35782742500305176,
0.11894863098859787,
-0.871591329574585,
-0.1802198886871338,
0.003315952606499195,
-0.10347609221935272,
-1.0799530744552612,
0.46588197350502014,
-0.12931405007839203,
0.3514888882637024,
0.05729612708091736,
0.41650667786598206,
0.45074012875556946,
-0.8008595705032349,
0.6234432458877563,
0.439620703458786,
-0.5964214205741882,
0.561346173286438,
-0.34017980098724365,
0.13747219741344452,
0.1889709085226059,
0.45650288462638855,
-0.853614866733551,
-0.8040151596069336,
-0.7990214824676514,
-0.6704177856445312,
0.4787687659263611,
0.28465983271598816,
0.3875560164451599,
-0.43894609808921814,
0.004320891108363867,
0.13783636689186096,
0.382968544960022,
-1.0636852979660034,
-0.17691850662231445,
-0.3306027948856354,
-0.226225346326828,
0.06836932897567749,
-0.5188319087028503,
-0.17096292972564697,
0.026472177356481552,
0.8210498690605164,
0.19645941257476807,
0.05975838750600815,
-0.2063797265291214,
-0.024648014456033707,
-0.2363012433052063,
0.3970102369785309,
0.7038297653198242,
0.31013399362564087,
0.13651414215564728,
0.12299471348524094,
0.3616194427013397,
-0.3446751534938812,
0.059969279915094376,
-0.05178756266832352,
-0.503200888633728,
0.009659473784267902,
0.10317094624042511,
0.6501267552375793,
0.10380195826292038,
-0.7571886777877808,
0.44573837518692017,
-0.0936722606420517,
-0.1311458796262741,
-0.6220667958259583,
-0.06272892653942108,
0.021893225610256195,
0.15485554933547974,
0.045217156410217285,
-0.46869584918022156,
-0.041706833988428116,
-0.28255197405815125,
0.3901844918727875,
0.6335659027099609,
-0.3634425401687622,
-0.06332851201295853,
0.6143920421600342,
0.3119109570980072,
-0.7638846039772034,
0.6165409088134766,
-0.3674094080924988,
-0.7198056578636169,
0.39730504155158997,
0.8185915946960449,
0.6529848575592041,
-0.47474852204322815,
0.3900819420814514,
0.611918568611145,
0.21695835888385773,
0.3074064552783966,
0.044541649520397186,
0.14726266264915466,
-0.7494335174560547,
-0.27663737535476685,
-0.8937242031097412,
-0.49844324588775635,
0.4227447211742401,
-0.16191159188747406,
0.14320263266563416,
-0.6795865893363953,
-0.15154977142810822,
-0.051018521189689636,
-0.138788640499115,
-0.5622828602790833,
0.19771122932434082,
0.37692520022392273,
0.5344066619873047,
-0.7772765159606934,
0.4021373987197876,
0.24923673272132874,
-0.37562933564186096,
-0.5916675329208374,
-0.1346290111541748,
0.3788856565952301,
-0.8159494996070862,
0.5941764712333679,
0.05899612233042717,
-0.39140328764915466,
0.04391084983944893,
-0.570539653301239,
-0.5980968475341797,
0.14009131491184235,
-0.014455544762313366,
-0.7358074188232422,
0.4638723134994507,
0.49111002683639526,
0.6427326202392578,
-0.4565546214580536,
0.32239335775375366,
0.3125307559967041,
0.3103013336658478,
0.07116648554801941,
-0.7829844355583191,
0.16861438751220703,
-0.0866791382431984,
-0.0943623036146164,
0.3117060363292694,
-0.654395580291748,
0.8670549392700195,
-0.04920896515250206,
-0.3170401453971863,
-0.05002479627728462,
0.4981251060962677,
0.1520887017250061,
-0.10779035091400146,
0.5709940195083618,
0.9301389455795288,
0.15565381944179535,
0.2001563310623169,
0.9142103791236877,
0.04764629155397415,
0.026182495057582855,
1.2421220541000366,
-0.23211336135864258,
0.9204735159873962,
0.3623037040233612,
-0.14231570065021515,
0.5869503021240234,
0.17410224676132202,
0.09830321371555328,
0.17061112821102142,
0.6824362874031067,
-0.4968487024307251,
-0.2241981476545334,
-0.666371762752533,
-0.11131627857685089,
0.5324620604515076,
0.4162904918193817,
-0.1507977396249771,
-0.1796838939189911,
0.1397685557603836,
0.191171333193779,
0.5692493915557861,
-0.2605016529560089,
0.9738979935646057,
-0.059597261250019073,
-0.7598598003387451,
0.387313574552536,
0.22750619053840637,
0.8365552425384521,
-0.5977418422698975,
-0.12565889954566956,
-0.14174894988536835,
0.15648889541625977,
-0.1607191115617752,
-0.7284666299819946,
0.4611107409000397,
0.36396992206573486,
-0.22633305191993713,
-0.19382444024085999,
0.7003214359283447,
-0.5487560629844666,
-0.4525018036365509,
0.2703589200973511,
0.23381149768829346,
0.16684578359127045,
0.01467549055814743,
-0.6816863417625427,
0.29650217294692993,
0.045479804277420044,
-0.28375619649887085,
0.5419489145278931,
0.005296818912029266,
-0.046015553176403046,
0.6480087637901306,
0.5564888715744019,
0.1880999356508255,
-0.12872326374053955,
0.16519728302955627,
0.7602139115333557,
-0.48286202549934387,
-0.5559610724449158,
-0.780214250087738,
0.3882753849029541,
-0.163551464676857,
-0.21250934898853302,
0.6517707109451294,
0.46218836307525635,
1.0004630088806152,
0.08350551873445511,
0.8875638842582703,
-0.3518698215484619,
1.1040699481964111,
-0.23459388315677643,
0.48839133977890015,
-0.3913876712322235,
-0.0483861081302166,
-0.35607147216796875,
-0.620975136756897,
-0.20645421743392944,
0.5928691029548645,
-0.3850112557411194,
-0.08846069127321243,
0.3491348922252655,
0.7989315986633301,
0.11801628023386002,
-0.03475605696439743,
0.44084352254867554,
0.3032345473766327,
0.521228551864624,
0.4817794859409332,
0.8566964864730835,
-0.1780914068222046,
0.8177580833435059,
-0.147426038980484,
-0.17336289584636688,
-0.09253468364477158,
-0.6701122522354126,
-0.8862022161483765,
-0.3582770824432373,
-0.1493474394083023,
-0.5409590005874634,
0.10333448648452759,
0.823632538318634,
0.3761914074420929,
-0.8839167356491089,
-0.42025476694107056,
-0.039299361407756805,
0.17762726545333862,
0.12096025794744492,
-0.29936760663986206,
-0.33657965064048767,
-0.30414268374443054,
-0.6266418099403381,
0.25379467010498047,
0.010784758254885674,
-0.12078417092561722,
-0.23928408324718475,
-0.33469435572624207,
-0.33369722962379456,
0.3875024616718292,
0.7546634078025818,
0.5441991686820984,
-0.7375960946083069,
-0.38461968302726746,
-0.2483692169189453,
-0.1790217161178589,
-0.13566838204860687,
1.0053770542144775,
-0.7403420209884644,
0.35688409209251404,
0.3051845133304596,
0.6518223285675049,
0.38199880719184875,
0.0496387779712677,
0.6738952398300171,
-0.8215847015380859,
0.08797749876976013,
0.6160359978675842,
0.008169826120138168,
0.2901386618614197,
-0.20183244347572327,
0.3376300632953644,
0.19146199524402618,
-0.5471299290657043,
-0.794095516204834,
0.8202832937240601,
-0.2378721535205841,
-0.48489150404930115,
1.154301643371582,
0.20325522124767303,
0.2787865698337555,
-0.24377958476543427,
0.019138213247060776,
0.30694580078125,
-0.4282947778701782,
0.8731576204299927,
0.5457404255867004,
-0.1859389692544937,
-0.4851628541946411,
-0.40463486313819885,
0.6668049693107605,
0.4177952706813812,
-0.9390442371368408,
0.30321982502937317,
0.7919058203697205,
-0.07842941582202911,
0.19952410459518433,
0.6383350491523743,
0.09921707212924957,
0.13348811864852905,
0.09883740544319153,
0.1958884596824646,
0.15418218076229095,
-0.21721921861171722,
-0.049971505999565125,
0.18449623882770538,
0.0002848978328984231,
0.4505806267261505
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17143v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17143v2
|
Guided Distant Supervision for Multilingual Relation Extraction Data: Adapting to a New Language
| 2024-03-25T19:40:26 | 2024-03-27T15:15:16 |
Alistair Plum, Tharindu Ranasinghe, Christoph Purschke
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Relation extraction is essential for extracting and understanding
biographical information in the context of digital humanities and related
subjects. There is a growing interest in the community to build datasets
capable of training machine learning models to extract relationships. However,
annotating such datasets can be expensive and time-consuming, in addition to
being limited to English. This paper applies guided distant supervision to
create a large biographical relationship extraction dataset for German. Our
dataset, composed of more than 80,000 instances for nine relationship types, is
the largest biographical German relationship extraction dataset. We also create
a manually annotated dataset with 2000 instances to evaluate the models and
release it together with the dataset compiled using guided distant supervision.
We train several state-of-the-art machine learning models on the automatically
created dataset and release them as well. Furthermore, we experiment with
multilingual and cross-lingual experiments that could benefit many low-resource
languages.
|
[
-0.5063551068305969,
-0.7866435647010803,
0.5478165745735168,
0.25249946117401123,
-0.029848793521523476,
-0.3283771276473999,
-0.4444678723812103,
-0.6895707845687866,
0.18131501972675323,
0.6413542628288269,
-0.8549343943595886,
-0.5890798568725586,
-0.6446772813796997,
0.23698818683624268,
0.023393526673316956,
1.1582075357437134,
-0.056723032146692276,
0.28966856002807617,
-0.24834327399730682,
-0.37220537662506104,
-0.33494850993156433,
-0.7178028225898743,
-0.5802193284034729,
-0.08878500014543533,
0.8864980936050415,
0.31339260935783386,
0.5258183479309082,
0.6599540114402771,
0.5893552303314209,
0.2457604706287384,
-0.0166896004229784,
0.36080288887023926,
-0.44857850670814514,
0.3104872405529022,
-0.2900446653366089,
-0.17502254247665405,
-0.48206469416618347,
0.02239505760371685,
0.7668972611427307,
1.1491055488586426,
0.3142297565937042,
0.42521020770072937,
-0.24628905951976776,
0.9540053606033325,
-0.45337679982185364,
0.6104949116706848,
-0.2844584882259369,
0.07687511295080185,
-0.45000356435775757,
0.026455096900463104,
-0.3749292492866516,
-0.586970329284668,
0.2808983325958252,
-0.5328867435455322,
0.2353249192237854,
-0.19770251214504242,
0.7244855165481567,
-0.011837159283459187,
-0.8026559948921204,
-0.18764641880989075,
-1.053997278213501,
0.583563506603241,
-0.18363864719867706,
0.7987250089645386,
0.654814600944519,
0.5699131488800049,
-0.19232824444770813,
-0.6353357434272766,
-0.04285827651619911,
-0.32708823680877686,
-0.2881894111633301,
-0.021242106333374977,
-0.07183326780796051,
-0.34999698400497437,
0.403360515832901,
0.22053338587284088,
-0.31502053141593933,
-0.0011926721781492233,
-0.555295467376709,
-0.06272005289793015,
0.8177449107170105,
0.049045100808143616,
0.008395048789680004,
-0.0844859704375267,
0.07648913562297821,
0.10482442378997803,
-0.8668842911720276,
-0.3826741576194763,
0.4294164776802063,
0.4018346965312958,
-0.061156027019023895,
0.38263842463493347,
-0.381126344203949,
0.7953351736068726,
0.12446711212396622,
-0.053150519728660583,
0.33764946460723877,
-0.3705887794494629,
0.2230796217918396,
-0.014221835881471634,
0.8904237747192383,
0.24344126880168915,
0.8726845979690552,
-0.4386332631111145,
0.27909016609191895,
-0.488817036151886,
0.021484246477484703,
-0.7626595497131348,
-0.5909019112586975,
-0.04505468159914017,
-0.5256338119506836,
-0.07556678354740143,
0.2538232207298279,
-0.8581181168556213,
-0.2555012106895447,
-0.41022998094558716,
-0.1691053807735443,
-0.46647560596466064,
-0.4342119097709656,
-0.3380798399448395,
0.017726438120007515,
0.020155949518084526,
0.1697453409433365,
-1.0267246961593628,
-0.10934017598628998,
0.5745625495910645,
0.7324444651603699,
-0.18249094486236572,
-0.5500051975250244,
-1.0799096822738647,
0.5557914972305298,
-0.19840385019779205,
0.5980473756790161,
-0.5687251687049866,
-0.3789514899253845,
0.2671626806259155,
0.4935609996318817,
0.1080055758357048,
-0.5380023121833801,
0.2858413755893707,
-0.7472343444824219,
0.5541107654571533,
-0.1315707564353943,
-0.5311999917030334,
-0.11158972233533859,
-0.06333373486995697,
-0.9626412987709045,
0.8711471557617188,
0.4310618042945862,
-0.6338965892791748,
0.329937219619751,
-0.5015284419059753,
-0.6389566659927368,
0.05479183793067932,
-0.07350917160511017,
-0.39911890029907227,
-0.1829574853181839,
0.35044118762016296,
0.8836419582366943,
-0.044480156153440475,
0.6161325573921204,
-0.7035768032073975,
0.056954275816679,
-0.12366412580013275,
-0.030173620209097862,
1.086997389793396,
0.14570635557174683,
-0.07174950838088989,
-0.17273065447807312,
-1.0205893516540527,
-0.4153210520744324,
0.05498311668634415,
-0.25045549869537354,
-0.7756669521331787,
-0.12839512526988983,
0.05037285387516022,
0.2893090844154358,
0.28227099776268005,
-0.344539999961853,
0.258455365896225,
-0.244889497756958,
-0.10251666605472565,
0.5415221452713013,
0.43491777777671814,
0.5673635005950928,
0.12759506702423096,
0.6147912740707397,
-0.19161157310009003,
-0.0024382472038269043,
-0.22223441302776337,
-0.2113993912935257,
-0.4184369444847107,
-0.21222369372844696,
0.2957898676395416,
0.6586123108863831,
-0.7204150557518005,
0.798571765422821,
-0.5143756866455078,
-0.5127688050270081,
-0.22264237701892853,
0.4232698380947113,
0.29974204301834106,
0.6330910325050354,
0.3033343255519867,
-0.06597595661878586,
-0.5107257962226868,
-0.9747256636619568,
-0.16500133275985718,
0.02759910561144352,
-0.1623624712228775,
0.336139440536499,
0.3952096104621887,
-0.44214022159576416,
0.9380534291267395,
-0.8224797248840332,
-0.5104669332504272,
0.13000625371932983,
-0.0806305930018425,
0.043134696781635284,
0.5019232630729675,
0.7893049716949463,
-0.9462580680847168,
-0.622734785079956,
0.36201784014701843,
-1.370073914527893,
-0.017200401052832603,
-0.12272898852825165,
-0.6896005868911743,
-0.11449389904737473,
0.5499170422554016,
-0.39741769433021545,
-0.047911278903484344,
0.44746240973472595,
-0.25099846720695496,
0.6271198987960815,
-0.1733746975660324,
-0.2211816906929016,
-1.386823058128357,
0.2206854373216629,
0.27145713567733765,
-0.4520837664604187,
-0.6308954954147339,
0.03887954354286194,
0.1439877152442932,
0.11530084162950516,
-0.3635045886039734,
0.5791216492652893,
-0.8481948971748352,
0.07547834515571594,
0.0588587261736393,
0.13738013803958893,
-0.21339277923107147,
0.47639885544776917,
0.25100064277648926,
0.3416798710823059,
0.6035348176956177,
-0.5336920619010925,
0.8495175838470459,
0.6715586185455322,
-0.02034335769712925,
0.8456932902336121,
0.0009880195138975978,
0.08803018182516098,
-0.16985972225666046,
0.19188040494918823,
-0.3821254372596741,
-0.5104452967643738,
0.3748527765274048,
-0.11781544238328934,
0.42771515250205994,
-0.31723201274871826,
-0.4422910511493683,
-0.05385260283946991,
-0.15903808176517487,
0.053753260523080826,
0.20160898566246033,
-0.7914958596229553,
0.7635968327522278,
0.5107003450393677,
-0.550807535648346,
-0.3087591230869293,
-0.5341047048568726,
0.047478027641773224,
-0.5518735647201538,
-0.5820812582969666,
0.19442443549633026,
0.16281776130199432,
-0.5493333339691162,
0.10285333544015884,
0.18466123938560486,
-0.5765508413314819,
-0.0006298459484241903,
0.4893820285797119,
0.37590888142585754,
-0.09943651407957077,
0.21487019956111908,
0.2236947864294052,
-0.19241110980510712,
0.334112286567688,
0.08267965912818909,
0.05405772477388382,
0.2594309151172638,
-0.04114978760480881,
-0.16673977673053741,
0.6691439151763916,
0.2747839391231537,
-0.22104594111442566,
0.7412609457969666,
0.8271004557609558,
-0.3727925717830658,
-0.023297876119613647,
-0.5261573195457458,
-0.20482401549816132,
-0.3958131968975067,
0.4619385302066803,
-0.6423599123954773,
-0.8297354578971863,
0.4755001664161682,
-0.42207804322242737,
0.1300709992647171,
0.5922115445137024,
0.403962105512619,
0.04676587134599686,
0.5775508880615234,
0.998630940914154,
-0.45773109793663025,
0.6431701183319092,
-0.0459417924284935,
-0.20815409719944,
-0.5949962735176086,
-0.19732840359210968,
-0.23545493185520172,
0.27610647678375244,
-0.8727529048919678,
0.04900359734892845,
0.28978243470191956,
0.07500000298023224,
-0.02683197520673275,
0.5436434149742126,
-0.20956894755363464,
0.3163214325904846,
0.5813744068145752,
0.06867058575153351,
0.5514403581619263,
0.2395358681678772,
0.3384888172149658,
-0.20825053751468658,
-0.21599657833576202,
-0.5095660090446472,
1.0113458633422852,
0.09920008480548859,
0.25094807147979736,
0.12449699640274048,
0.9400377869606018,
0.13906879723072052,
0.486438512802124,
-0.6673083901405334,
0.22965770959854126,
-0.170810729265213,
-0.7408848404884338,
-0.3081744313240051,
-0.7326021790504456,
-1.0703140497207642,
0.035349320620298386,
-0.06915795803070068,
-0.674646258354187,
0.07966604083776474,
0.09777569025754929,
-0.13806229829788208,
-0.05747131630778313,
-0.679777204990387,
0.8559442162513733,
-0.23011893033981323,
-0.4662805199623108,
-0.04474847391247749,
-1.1916128396987915,
0.5511231422424316,
-0.5839201211929321,
0.2750612199306488,
0.026171313598752022,
0.39339497685432434,
0.771116316318512,
-0.15352986752986908,
0.6616772413253784,
-0.2641751766204834,
-0.2730844020843506,
-0.1559535712003708,
0.1836172342300415,
0.5753328800201416,
-0.02044816128909588,
-0.2548062801361084,
0.3471654951572418,
0.1571497619152069,
-0.16412033140659332,
-0.4803886413574219,
0.743107795715332,
-0.305375874042511,
-0.43598854541778564,
-0.20430931448936462,
-0.5984632968902588,
-0.5020896196365356,
0.3433269262313843,
-0.10801590979099274,
0.24803319573402405,
-0.4796159267425537,
-0.015274601988494396,
0.234126016497612,
-0.19222936034202576,
0.31638938188552856,
0.4520251452922821,
-0.39341142773628235,
-0.5133286118507385,
0.964072048664093,
0.17477810382843018,
0.13290853798389435,
0.19100718200206757,
-0.02105620503425598,
-0.22112783789634705,
0.1042943000793457,
-0.6508158445358276,
0.6329886317253113,
-0.6375157833099365,
0.162582129240036,
-0.6585759520530701,
-0.030279867351055145,
-0.31611934304237366,
0.060731347650289536,
-0.09274157881736755,
-0.405906617641449,
-0.315906822681427,
-0.21209268271923065,
0.5721588134765625,
0.8823164701461792,
-0.20715034008026123,
0.18572641909122467,
-1.169767141342163,
0.5021917819976807,
0.11331912875175476,
0.26379451155662537,
-0.15573355555534363,
-0.13125771284103394,
-0.4502256512641907,
-0.2293928563594818,
-0.14082811772823334,
-1.1018128395080566,
0.30591484904289246,
0.3626483082771301,
0.3663876950740814,
0.6151496767997742,
-0.1264992207288742,
0.915224015712738,
-0.7634570002555847,
0.4143230617046356,
-0.11297023296356201,
-0.4422321319580078,
0.5408758521080017,
-0.6806595921516418,
0.03140057623386383,
0.6637507677078247,
0.7643248438835144,
-0.55389004945755,
-0.374047189950943,
-0.6274732351303101,
-0.6917849779129028,
0.8873576521873474,
-0.008450665511190891,
0.21221813559532166,
0.20086772739887238,
0.6307791471481323,
0.48728394508361816,
0.10673239827156067,
-0.6658236384391785,
-0.5459073185920715,
0.4113851487636566,
-0.1481052041053772,
-0.16964967548847198,
-0.12895908951759338,
-0.03960094228386879,
-0.35886868834495544,
0.7770361304283142,
0.13531306385993958,
-0.023063724860548973,
-0.10522638261318207,
-0.07511579990386963,
-0.03266307711601257,
-0.27497443556785583,
0.13581030070781708,
0.7531332969665527,
-0.21948477625846863,
-0.0790804922580719,
0.15811719000339508,
-0.23312605917453766,
-0.014918049797415733,
0.7130167484283447,
-0.07843741029500961,
0.3502195477485657,
0.682214081287384,
0.4393192231655121,
-0.19581709802150726,
-0.31023550033569336,
0.4060131311416626,
0.14216172695159912,
-0.18044832348823547,
-0.6825902462005615,
-0.14497052133083344,
0.3441635072231293,
0.3158990144729614,
0.39132824540138245,
-0.42482709884643555,
-0.07256767898797989,
-0.36378875374794006,
0.580138087272644,
0.43687424063682556,
-0.3867882192134857,
-0.3318383991718292,
0.6888588666915894,
0.13515907526016235,
-0.27774977684020996,
0.6639618873596191,
-0.15662340819835663,
-0.2458954155445099,
0.2423844188451767,
0.23736977577209473,
0.7437567114830017,
-0.2541210353374481,
0.18147650361061096,
0.4815698266029358,
-0.10678958147764206,
-0.015283575281500816,
-0.20574785768985748,
-0.2964547574520111,
-0.4131786823272705,
-0.5929263234138489,
-0.43213629722595215,
-0.3653123676776886,
0.07318124920129776,
-0.9127949476242065,
0.3127651810646057,
-0.034116845577955246,
0.07579335570335388,
0.14905445277690887,
-0.15013879537582397,
-0.5699930191040039,
0.05723901093006134,
0.09541603922843933,
0.47604668140411377,
-1.0300123691558838,
1.1173208951950073,
0.47706952691078186,
-0.41058266162872314,
-0.623091995716095,
0.02375212498009205,
-0.14737242460250854,
-0.4617367088794708,
1.1000727415084839,
0.22074618935585022,
-0.06699354946613312,
0.20073789358139038,
-0.2147168517112732,
-0.7616104483604431,
0.8935210108757019,
0.7503824830055237,
-0.604134738445282,
-0.1958131492137909,
0.044657107442617416,
0.5415298342704773,
-0.31317734718322754,
-0.027751751244068146,
0.6341135501861572,
0.5221685767173767,
-0.26604393124580383,
-0.7303060293197632,
0.0023411212023347616,
-0.1340608149766922,
-0.2768431007862091,
0.46213701367378235,
-0.5413094758987427,
0.36368808150291443,
0.08832553774118423,
-0.20586656033992767,
-0.0313696451485157,
0.815445065498352,
0.06712749600410461,
0.23647218942642212,
0.30833205580711365,
0.09933710098266602,
0.7270243763923645,
0.047863781452178955,
0.9055407047271729,
-0.4023840129375458,
0.2455790936946869,
1.461658000946045,
-0.4998801350593567,
0.5293874740600586,
0.5539493560791016,
-0.22092801332473755,
0.6577357053756714,
0.7557993531227112,
-0.40380939841270447,
0.43959739804267883,
-0.18183772265911102,
-0.4319806396961212,
0.0011559923877939582,
-0.2573627531528473,
-0.37551602721214294,
0.3239203691482544,
0.015283147804439068,
-0.9053822755813599,
-0.2776299715042114,
0.06291291117668152,
0.32253944873809814,
0.07817723602056503,
0.008660388179123402,
0.8942343592643738,
0.09876755625009537,
-0.6930593252182007,
0.1383260041475296,
-0.14121590554714203,
0.2729194462299347,
-0.6977319717407227,
-0.21500864624977112,
-0.179806649684906,
0.16438424587249756,
-0.33235132694244385,
-0.41798925399780273,
0.42187729477882385,
0.11157554388046265,
-0.2211333066225052,
-0.1373354196548462,
0.47529637813568115,
-0.74806809425354,
-0.7872886657714844,
0.5966084599494934,
1.0308339595794678,
0.45362305641174316,
-0.2088870257139206,
-0.4040740132331848,
-0.48869502544403076,
0.13834214210510254,
-0.41770139336586,
0.3434509038925171,
0.6103150844573975,
-0.27624788880348206,
0.41653427481651306,
0.8099867701530457,
0.5270476341247559,
0.021580813452601433,
0.10366369038820267,
0.8602336049079895,
-0.814644455909729,
-0.27190709114074707,
-1.2302916049957275,
0.27403712272644043,
-0.2640783488750458,
-0.15386132895946503,
1.149395227432251,
0.6969857811927795,
0.9079909920692444,
-0.13762280344963074,
0.8892032504081726,
-0.08154194056987762,
0.460611492395401,
-0.2770748436450958,
0.4771149158477783,
-0.34275588393211365,
-0.20370382070541382,
-0.45866239070892334,
-1.144811749458313,
-0.5952873826026917,
0.48172885179519653,
-0.4746743440628052,
0.01942426525056362,
0.6140365600585938,
0.6047537922859192,
-0.2617253363132477,
-0.13432367146015167,
0.12716032564640045,
-0.21700823307037354,
0.2916814386844635,
0.44368356466293335,
0.6422333717346191,
-0.0795150101184845,
0.49992480874061584,
-0.7407582402229309,
-0.19520922005176544,
0.1781930774450302,
-0.9759212136268616,
-1.1219279766082764,
-0.6678581237792969,
-0.39113831520080566,
-0.2561250925064087,
-0.09923432022333145,
0.829844057559967,
0.7248314023017883,
-0.6487943530082703,
-0.19353079795837402,
0.07204943895339966,
-0.058230288326740265,
-0.20117445290088654,
-0.2632398307323456,
0.7228529453277588,
0.03915233910083771,
-0.9706123471260071,
0.42222318053245544,
0.0671866312623024,
-0.007998953573405743,
-0.417855829000473,
-0.022671667858958244,
-0.24569936096668243,
-0.8611204624176025,
0.6205693483352661,
0.224935382604599,
-0.3924524188041687,
-0.1690291464328766,
-0.34442368149757385,
0.015533375553786755,
0.13089558482170105,
0.5308897495269775,
-0.4313472509384155,
0.5812222361564636,
0.09155462682247162,
0.6810961961746216,
0.7740722298622131,
0.3182293176651001,
0.8644911646842957,
-1.0666477680206299,
0.2636556029319763,
-0.11980597674846649,
0.3578340411186218,
0.5249903202056885,
-0.8376020193099976,
0.8409043550491333,
0.14860503375530243,
-0.5214661359786987,
-0.6702932715415955,
0.34663596749305725,
-0.757905900478363,
-0.09728959202766418,
1.366168737411499,
-0.43553054332733154,
-0.062681183218956,
-0.3180919587612152,
-0.29404065012931824,
0.6150557398796082,
-0.2910796105861664,
0.662678599357605,
0.8529706001281738,
-0.21572765707969666,
0.11760762333869934,
-0.774526834487915,
0.4326022267341614,
0.1359553188085556,
-0.8734233975410461,
0.4228774607181549,
0.907974898815155,
0.262260764837265,
0.2230527102947235,
0.3058899939060211,
-0.005434129387140274,
0.11518949270248413,
-0.3359648883342743,
0.030522050336003304,
-0.24960878491401672,
-0.2150028645992279,
-0.398313045501709,
0.2565120458602905,
-0.04195887967944145,
-0.16426360607147217
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17141v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17141v2
|
MetaAligner: Towards Generalizable Multi-Objective Alignment of Language Models
| 2024-03-25T19:28:10 | 2024-05-06T14:17:41 |
Kailai Yang, Zhiwei Liu, Qianqian Xie, Jimin Huang, Tianlin Zhang, Sophia Ananiadou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) aim to tackle
heterogeneous human expectations and values via multi-objective preference
alignment. However, existing methods are parameter-adherent to the policy
model, leading to two key limitations: (1) the high-cost repetition of their
alignment algorithms for each new target model; (2) they cannot expand to
unseen objectives due to their static alignment objectives. In this work, we
propose Meta-Objective Aligner (MetaAligner), a model that performs conditional
weak-to-strong correction for weak responses to approach strong responses.
MetaAligner is the first policy-agnostic and generalizable method for
multi-objective preference alignment, which enables plug-and-play alignment by
decoupling parameter updates from the policy models and facilitates zero-shot
preference alignment for unseen objectives via in-context learning.
Experimental results show that MetaAligner achieves significant and balanced
improvements in multi-objective alignments on 10 state-of-the-art policy
models, and outperforms previous alignment methods with down to 15.71x less GPU
training hours. The model also effectively aligns unseen objectives, marking
the first step towards generalizable multi-objective preference alignment.
|
[
-0.22106847167015076,
-0.4430503845214844,
0.4944571256637573,
-0.01678837276995182,
0.020897485315799713,
-0.08904477953910828,
-0.5614311099052429,
0.08111698180437088,
0.08177140355110168,
0.5058029294013977,
-0.6551897525787354,
-0.44650793075561523,
-0.6003896594047546,
-0.047733716666698456,
0.08963348716497421,
1.2624530792236328,
-0.16218841075897217,
-0.0637907087802887,
0.027210094034671783,
-0.4245508909225464,
-0.5344305634498596,
-0.20443232357501984,
-0.33473652601242065,
-0.5897350311279297,
0.6326289772987366,
0.4708733856678009,
1.1073423624038696,
0.4459886848926544,
0.7531207799911499,
0.2875112295150757,
0.10996221005916595,
0.1887555569410324,
-0.3559797406196594,
-0.15310604870319366,
-0.5874007344245911,
-0.04128413647413254,
-0.8053848147392273,
0.053029853850603104,
0.5689409375190735,
0.42358770966529846,
-0.34103646874427795,
0.23758159577846527,
0.3555971682071686,
0.43798893690109253,
-1.04531991481781,
-0.21136616170406342,
-0.6004933714866638,
-0.1525464504957199,
-0.009565218351781368,
0.09217152744531631,
-0.2838441729545593,
-0.16875247657299042,
0.17906725406646729,
-0.4401191771030426,
0.047661781311035156,
-0.07509297132492065,
1.0826178789138794,
0.4250184893608093,
-0.5408741235733032,
-0.08821546286344528,
-0.844978392124176,
1.1866273880004883,
-0.616722822189331,
0.42031624913215637,
0.07671957463026047,
0.3732750713825226,
0.0920637771487236,
-0.19412556290626526,
-0.6375449895858765,
0.1664503663778305,
-0.2730801999568939,
0.1317984163761139,
-0.08023779094219208,
0.3307874798774719,
-0.1699257791042328,
0.11752673983573914,
-0.7319397330284119,
-0.09222668409347534,
-0.16261038184165955,
-0.22333665192127228,
0.4522627294063568,
0.24210934340953827,
0.18195250630378723,
-0.12480996549129486,
-0.20179486274719238,
0.04885951429605484,
-0.35275474190711975,
-0.07921437174081802,
0.23507259786128998,
0.6049785614013672,
-0.17597363889217377,
0.8086832165718079,
-0.300378680229187,
0.8627678751945496,
0.6406115889549255,
-0.4785397946834564,
0.358297735452652,
-0.4095246195793152,
-0.12641817331314087,
0.08875617384910583,
0.9236343502998352,
0.582802951335907,
0.04874444007873535,
-0.23907659947872162,
-0.13789494335651398,
0.09059452265501022,
0.2384302318096161,
-0.7064580321311951,
0.21848081052303314,
0.24292005598545074,
-0.32129502296447754,
-0.1743755340576172,
-0.15541888773441315,
-0.7393525838851929,
-0.12125520408153534,
-0.6376513242721558,
0.5256319046020508,
-0.0641384869813919,
-0.1676640659570694,
0.41791197657585144,
0.18653984367847443,
0.46527713537216187,
0.13360317051410675,
-1.0496339797973633,
0.08325684070587158,
0.7669731974601746,
0.687598705291748,
-0.07062314450740814,
-0.550700843334198,
-0.47609224915504456,
0.4998938739299774,
-0.08818765729665756,
0.5191050171852112,
-0.8694761395454407,
-0.004745911806821823,
-0.144297793507576,
0.057520005851984024,
-0.31208884716033936,
-0.014807133004069328,
0.6351536512374878,
-0.28301185369491577,
0.6200317144393921,
-0.09588243812322617,
-0.09330384433269501,
-0.0363977812230587,
0.5869279503822327,
-0.3481467664241791,
0.7983070015907288,
0.15758365392684937,
-0.6224889159202576,
0.46844133734703064,
-0.6180227398872375,
-0.27234452962875366,
-0.4196923077106476,
-0.05115043744444847,
-0.5618000626564026,
0.14443129301071167,
0.2547881603240967,
0.22244682908058167,
-0.44242629408836365,
0.8324885964393616,
-0.47842180728912354,
-0.2997867465019226,
0.01542950700968504,
-0.3860800862312317,
0.4529130458831787,
0.1833249032497406,
-0.5284052491188049,
0.3267558813095093,
-0.5382001399993896,
0.07336151599884033,
-0.15965715050697327,
-0.33578482270240784,
-0.2658885717391968,
0.22040392458438873,
-0.18357515335083008,
0.3978659212589264,
0.5075779557228088,
-0.3936081826686859,
0.3874570429325104,
-0.2364879548549652,
0.22128456830978394,
0.7957618832588196,
-0.6211407780647278,
0.9099664092063904,
-0.19485682249069214,
0.3948833644390106,
-0.30722489953041077,
0.29319509863853455,
0.17130085825920105,
-0.005214350763708353,
-0.7356614470481873,
-0.6351804137229919,
0.4375426769256592,
0.6431229114532471,
-0.1550838053226471,
0.5214862823486328,
-0.6512316465377808,
-0.15675479173660278,
-0.8827412724494934,
0.393218994140625,
0.6844951510429382,
0.6816120743751526,
0.5733593106269836,
0.10117893666028976,
-0.396132230758667,
-1.025638461112976,
-0.4312041699886322,
-0.1460820585489273,
0.1085185632109642,
0.5027002096176147,
0.18598201870918274,
-0.5442330837249756,
1.0142308473587036,
-0.6524634957313538,
-0.557650089263916,
-0.3189150393009186,
0.11758439987897873,
0.4061025381088257,
0.38625335693359375,
0.4719526171684265,
-0.5627666115760803,
-0.6645034551620483,
0.13761942088603973,
-0.6754867434501648,
-0.24847400188446045,
0.18222573399543762,
-0.22527314722537994,
-0.01846706122159958,
0.22050970792770386,
-0.5310105681419373,
-0.07655712962150574,
0.9084209203720093,
-0.14417245984077454,
0.21248264610767365,
0.013526760041713715,
0.28162169456481934,
-1.1508041620254517,
0.23500864207744598,
-0.18712341785430908,
-0.12067665159702301,
-0.7336663007736206,
-0.018412252888083458,
0.20183783769607544,
-0.21408632397651672,
-0.4887710511684418,
0.7684345245361328,
-0.3699846863746643,
0.3051450550556183,
-0.3492980897426605,
-0.07016105204820633,
0.07478195428848267,
0.41872313618659973,
0.12422341853380203,
0.8217877149581909,
0.5696098208427429,
-0.5626242160797119,
-0.06375358998775482,
0.26071810722351074,
0.3142235577106476,
0.9304221868515015,
-0.7279472351074219,
0.10210826992988586,
-0.43806639313697815,
0.10050548613071442,
-0.6897196173667908,
-0.2223433256149292,
0.5565066933631897,
-0.12630516290664673,
0.35556650161743164,
-0.3243202567100525,
0.10120663046836853,
-0.2512715756893158,
-0.31862106919288635,
0.5538195371627808,
0.0968993753194809,
-0.499310702085495,
1.239441156387329,
0.17180070281028748,
-0.0386013388633728,
-1.169340968132019,
-0.40624383091926575,
0.03806524723768234,
-0.347772479057312,
-0.44941020011901855,
0.5079061985015869,
-0.0692947655916214,
-0.062237996608018875,
0.18375180661678314,
0.002274339087307453,
0.17127768695354462,
-0.0669456273317337,
0.05836171656847,
0.3822569251060486,
-0.2505244314670563,
0.08833986520767212,
0.09750701487064362,
-0.42112067341804504,
-0.4965059757232666,
-0.35516357421875,
0.47837620973587036,
-0.3314175605773926,
-0.44199779629707336,
-0.2845814526081085,
0.20286507904529572,
0.5571046471595764,
-0.5395954251289368,
0.6972694396972656,
0.4531012177467346,
-0.25740060210227966,
0.23155426979064941,
-0.7508299946784973,
0.008512311615049839,
-0.5172672867774963,
0.34716829657554626,
-0.5021060109138489,
-0.8572177886962891,
0.031240586191415787,
-0.007016479969024658,
0.14529143273830414,
0.4421877861022949,
0.22532479465007782,
0.056165967136621475,
1.3041582107543945,
0.648898184299469,
-0.5198440551757812,
0.2772737741470337,
0.18927587568759918,
0.4260888397693634,
-1.0550397634506226,
0.046342335641384125,
-0.40241530537605286,
-0.5366460084915161,
-0.3383825421333313,
-0.1809363067150116,
0.2670835554599762,
0.15639516711235046,
-0.45878320932388306,
0.43310922384262085,
-0.6560866832733154,
0.6974329948425293,
0.2875041961669922,
-0.004374366719275713,
0.05588102340698242,
-0.24460871517658234,
-0.03358960524201393,
-0.0757509395480156,
-0.41325342655181885,
-0.640917956829071,
1.3263192176818848,
-0.012313509359955788,
0.9802324771881104,
0.3438875675201416,
0.7468751668930054,
-0.028288040310144424,
0.5055862665176392,
-0.5467768311500549,
0.3624197244644165,
-0.3800708055496216,
-0.86821049451828,
-0.361875057220459,
-0.30160030722618103,
-0.6769211292266846,
0.5368356704711914,
-0.47730281949043274,
-0.6756297945976257,
0.28005167841911316,
0.5640991926193237,
-0.28353145718574524,
0.19103585183620453,
-0.5323044657707214,
1.1244239807128906,
-0.6473363041877747,
-0.6077668070793152,
0.07907935231924057,
-0.6256936192512512,
0.5199145674705505,
-0.08070600777864456,
0.2212735116481781,
-0.4168740212917328,
-0.03444498032331467,
0.18808649480342865,
0.0015506638446822762,
0.7267714738845825,
-0.2114073485136032,
0.02078809030354023,
-0.03995356336236,
-0.20936164259910583,
0.5825313329696655,
-0.15679889917373657,
-0.25150439143180847,
0.054488882422447205,
-0.41397783160209656,
-0.24127276241779327,
-0.4175323247909546,
0.611949622631073,
-0.6757977604866028,
-0.6892023682594299,
-0.5839433073997498,
-0.6965644955635071,
-0.08504508435726166,
0.4474053382873535,
0.02157966047525406,
0.1804213523864746,
-0.5950590372085571,
0.03136998042464256,
0.48221105337142944,
-0.035968124866485596,
0.2935752868652344,
0.8820533156394958,
-0.18815883994102478,
-0.7278439402580261,
1.0221271514892578,
-0.27360445261001587,
0.3335410952568054,
0.5675430297851562,
0.2852747142314911,
-0.2986554503440857,
-0.20057009160518646,
-0.37775957584381104,
0.3430205285549164,
-0.3006810247898102,
-0.3433387577533722,
-0.7160208821296692,
0.01629832573235035,
-0.39475980401039124,
-0.5930843353271484,
-0.5771266222000122,
-0.13064366579055786,
-0.34806516766548157,
0.10478545725345612,
-0.12559151649475098,
0.06479480117559433,
-0.2788327634334564,
0.5959759950637817,
-0.4788567125797272,
0.48515403270721436,
0.47226622700691223,
0.4106775224208832,
-0.551760196685791,
-0.35384801030158997,
0.06745128333568573,
0.2340245544910431,
-0.584282398223877,
-0.45154204964637756,
0.09963779896497726,
0.6002070903778076,
0.42244407534599304,
0.8445160388946533,
-0.055047959089279175,
0.9438171982765198,
-0.720366358757019,
0.34777429699897766,
0.39212411642074585,
-1.1651362180709839,
0.3329674005508423,
-0.2636319696903229,
0.4220801293849945,
1.0201143026351929,
0.13423505425453186,
-0.5229093432426453,
-0.3063172996044159,
-0.1421005129814148,
-0.5544064044952393,
0.6196824312210083,
-0.2076752483844757,
0.354397714138031,
-0.012622201815247536,
0.2829613983631134,
-0.11619164049625397,
0.28634414076805115,
-0.7566807866096497,
-0.15483438968658447,
-0.3542226552963257,
-0.6036613583564758,
-0.6144572496414185,
-0.143804132938385,
-0.23178505897521973,
-0.09759244322776794,
0.7178106904029846,
-0.5462545156478882,
-0.0018210499547421932,
-0.12254317849874496,
-0.48935467004776,
-0.052136845886707306,
0.8290969133377075,
0.8941487669944763,
0.6186784505844116,
-0.45729127526283264,
0.34211838245391846,
0.29655003547668457,
-0.09561987966299057,
0.5242864489555359,
0.2570541203022003,
-0.4012293517589569,
-0.23385167121887207,
0.001353991450741887,
0.7680045366287231,
0.4341484308242798,
-0.45321714878082275,
0.8146175146102905,
-0.08512892574071884,
-0.27409765124320984,
0.1986873596906662,
0.13261185586452484,
0.11901762336492538,
0.20052288472652435,
-0.013059656135737896,
0.14011575281620026,
0.16908884048461914,
-0.39630159735679626,
0.00243937480263412,
1.0081678628921509,
-0.6211545467376709,
-0.38152050971984863,
1.0148952007293701,
0.16970375180244446,
0.01581968367099762,
0.371123731136322,
-0.21927665174007416,
-0.6529577374458313,
0.003530789166688919,
0.6728861927986145,
0.9003149271011353,
-0.5890030860900879,
0.3987536132335663,
0.3970256745815277,
0.5237218141555786,
-0.28159642219543457,
0.20523661375045776,
0.30820903182029724,
-0.8992229700088501,
-0.3114021122455597,
-0.5299853682518005,
-0.39416584372520447,
-0.0362563282251358,
-0.6815945506095886,
0.4552828073501587,
-0.22863291203975677,
-0.4411928951740265,
-0.2254171073436737,
-0.3477751612663269,
-0.7058201432228088,
0.1687537133693695,
-0.16481873393058777,
0.20295226573944092,
-0.9151409864425659,
0.4359824061393738,
0.4606986343860626,
-0.2748285233974457,
-0.517517626285553,
-0.06450411677360535,
0.24905449151992798,
-0.7410365343093872,
0.2683773338794708,
0.16383914649486542,
-0.4082189202308655,
-0.0934322401881218,
-0.3500290513038635,
-1.0938527584075928,
1.016811490058899,
0.7411240935325623,
-0.6229739785194397,
-0.08204224705696106,
0.33948272466659546,
0.25733959674835205,
-0.4973556101322174,
0.2823241651058197,
0.44882211089134216,
0.7346369624137878,
-0.11069371551275253,
-0.917734682559967,
0.013746369630098343,
0.06326805055141449,
-0.20238831639289856,
0.6807453036308289,
-0.8452582359313965,
0.7862653732299805,
-0.3754209578037262,
-0.08650987595319748,
-0.16439224779605865,
0.5767706036567688,
0.09810410439968109,
0.19101126492023468,
0.4278477132320404,
0.8499414324760437,
0.7225820422172546,
-0.06506464630365372,
0.6881511807441711,
-0.5459598898887634,
0.42782777547836304,
1.3721383810043335,
-0.7044106721878052,
0.5792281627655029,
0.4623885154724121,
0.17654965817928314,
0.3505517542362213,
0.1819443702697754,
-0.07454804331064224,
0.7878697514533997,
-0.12247500568628311,
-0.21609054505825043,
-0.30440953373908997,
-0.2046537697315216,
-0.3686080574989319,
0.42082321643829346,
-0.06511004269123077,
-0.24860872328281403,
-0.22229263186454773,
0.012391629628837109,
0.1944301873445511,
-0.19728708267211914,
-0.28242045640945435,
0.8753840327262878,
-0.230128213763237,
-0.9184311032295227,
0.5281457901000977,
0.2550671398639679,
0.852386474609375,
-0.6584658622741699,
0.20235128700733185,
0.05556507781147957,
0.607489287853241,
-0.24271082878112793,
-0.449030339717865,
0.20969918370246887,
-0.017823752015829086,
-0.48238345980644226,
-0.17774301767349243,
0.707547128200531,
-0.8924946188926697,
-0.6356766819953918,
0.2467217594385147,
0.22955696284770966,
-0.30403491854667664,
0.0044530536979436874,
-0.7759408950805664,
0.04732135683298111,
-0.09378566592931747,
0.003978892229497433,
0.29194527864456177,
0.032577451318502426,
0.09275214374065399,
0.5021353363990784,
0.3215242922306061,
-0.1544719636440277,
-0.09067339450120926,
-0.088836669921875,
0.6993602514266968,
-0.5127477645874023,
-0.05148494988679886,
-0.9392792582511902,
0.6888615489006042,
0.10865302383899689,
-0.4364267587661743,
0.5016611814498901,
0.7143813967704773,
0.6478549838066101,
0.045200034976005554,
0.756908655166626,
0.06793823093175888,
0.3240191340446472,
-0.47585564851760864,
0.403238981962204,
-0.6699842810630798,
-0.036395203322172165,
-0.36857011914253235,
-1.2273417711257935,
-0.37643957138061523,
0.5740602612495422,
-0.47821033000946045,
-0.13728727400302887,
0.6687950491905212,
1.1003153324127197,
-0.5737826228141785,
-0.5660334825515747,
0.029337799176573753,
-0.41557633876800537,
0.26663488149642944,
0.49874788522720337,
0.5516818165779114,
-0.2412116974592209,
0.6210690140724182,
-0.029118908569216728,
-0.2555256187915802,
-0.22138042747974396,
-0.9694828987121582,
-0.9118779897689819,
-0.16694284975528717,
-0.3379210829734802,
-0.19131682813167572,
0.41249245405197144,
1.044250249862671,
0.5715466737747192,
-0.9252827167510986,
-0.2552858293056488,
0.27955198287963867,
0.28666725754737854,
-0.2975594103336334,
-0.18209584057331085,
0.3631110191345215,
-0.4950268268585205,
-0.8057280778884888,
0.25731828808784485,
0.2830352485179901,
-0.08068899065256119,
0.21050362288951874,
-0.5637453198432922,
-0.14772282540798187,
0.3134533166885376,
0.30734607577323914,
0.42289870977401733,
-0.7847133874893188,
-0.3464318513870239,
0.08606097102165222,
-0.33285921812057495,
0.2277805358171463,
0.6381959319114685,
-0.27485191822052,
0.358237624168396,
0.21243871748447418,
0.5619574189186096,
0.23734314739704132,
0.22290600836277008,
0.7001658082008362,
-0.44342514872550964,
-0.14777304232120514,
-0.13100780546665192,
0.34363675117492676,
0.3094683587551117,
-0.08173881471157074,
0.33249330520629883,
-0.3131336569786072,
-0.4988662898540497,
-0.7439766526222229,
0.2089107185602188,
-0.7184845209121704,
-0.06020714342594147,
1.1204625368118286,
0.29012221097946167,
-0.01465766690671444,
0.18110358715057373,
-0.311776340007782,
0.10092159360647202,
-0.4425734877586365,
0.613545835018158,
0.6053625345230103,
0.11954184621572495,
-0.1665647178888321,
-0.12349389493465424,
0.2963160276412964,
0.43317946791648865,
-0.6590882539749146,
0.02609558217227459,
0.5322601199150085,
0.4187401235103607,
0.14791983366012573,
0.6855884194374084,
-0.02003626711666584,
0.07191555202007294,
-0.6137248873710632,
0.40807926654815674,
0.16015119850635529,
-0.5815038084983826,
-0.4052286148071289,
0.05280710756778717,
0.0024166512303054333,
-0.16828817129135132
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17135v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17135v1
|
Exploring the Generalization of Cancer Clinical Trial Eligibility Classifiers Across Diseases
| 2024-03-25T19:17:59 | 2024-03-25T19:17:59 |
Yumeng Yang, Ashley Gilliam, Ethan B Ludmir, Kirk Roberts
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, q-bio.QM
|
Clinical trials are pivotal in medical research, and NLP can enhance their
success, with application in recruitment. This study aims to evaluate the
generalizability of eligibility classification across a broad spectrum of
clinical trials. Starting with phase 3 cancer trials, annotated with seven
eligibility exclusions, then to determine how well models can generalize to
non-cancer and non-phase 3 trials. To assess this, we have compiled eligibility
criteria data for five types of trials: (1) additional phase 3 cancer trials,
(2) phase 1 and 2 cancer trials, (3) heart disease trials, (4) type 2 diabetes
trials, and (5) observational trials for any disease, comprising 2,490
annotated eligibility criteria across seven exclusion types. Our results show
that models trained on the extensive cancer dataset can effectively handle
criteria commonly found in non-cancer trials, such as autoimmune diseases.
However, they struggle with criteria disproportionately prevalent in cancer
trials, like prior malignancy. We also experiment with few-shot learning,
demonstrating that a limited number of disease-specific examples can partially
overcome this performance gap. We are releasing this new dataset of annotated
eligibility statements to promote the development of cross-disease
generalization in clinical trial classification.
|
[
0.24193093180656433,
-0.18399101495742798,
0.6331629753112793,
0.1024441197514534,
-0.10635796189308167,
-0.17337928712368011,
0.0016113653546199203,
-0.5044010877609253,
0.11424625664949417,
0.5484453439712524,
-0.08264263719320297,
-0.8869867324829102,
-1.0691412687301636,
0.3095203936100006,
-0.4885757863521576,
1.2124450206756592,
-0.021585097536444664,
0.2738440930843353,
-0.07817632704973221,
-0.22551685571670532,
-0.41069456934928894,
-0.42557772994041443,
-0.5372269749641418,
-0.27682727575302124,
0.8356930017471313,
0.3887166380882263,
0.3112628161907196,
0.5047480463981628,
0.8577663898468018,
0.14589333534240723,
0.13318830728530884,
-0.0211732629686594,
-0.4913887083530426,
0.07699760049581528,
-0.12485106289386749,
-0.80817711353302,
-0.26556190848350525,
0.4802762269973755,
0.02179870940744877,
0.82732754945755,
-0.2877432405948639,
-0.02117493748664856,
0.0068916818127036095,
0.30852216482162476,
-0.6177765727043152,
0.059536468237638474,
-0.6061285734176636,
0.5102290511131287,
-0.34361791610717773,
-0.2628884017467499,
-0.32087719440460205,
-0.7446101307868958,
0.2824243903160095,
-0.8821628093719482,
0.85990971326828,
-0.0729779601097107,
0.7884490489959717,
-0.1461474597454071,
-0.8099011778831482,
-0.7536889910697937,
-0.5447964668273926,
0.47817739844322205,
-0.40399137139320374,
-0.11531762033700943,
0.6570948958396912,
0.8639703392982483,
-0.21014375984668732,
-0.9119325280189514,
0.12382901459932327,
-0.26493632793426514,
-0.1404128223657608,
0.3463687300682068,
0.0050775944255292416,
0.6311205625534058,
0.2845591902732849,
0.7975826263427734,
-0.8847211599349976,
0.2547674775123596,
-0.639314591884613,
-0.40898841619491577,
0.7246926426887512,
0.2369028627872467,
0.5326371788978577,
-0.10726551711559296,
-0.09822430461645126,
0.2659291923046112,
-0.676200807094574,
0.3297889232635498,
-0.15448008477687836,
0.43932947516441345,
-0.027141433209180832,
0.9108545780181885,
-0.43234455585479736,
0.6739059686660767,
-0.09173112362623215,
0.25476980209350586,
0.08838723599910736,
-0.45553338527679443,
-0.15912936627864838,
0.0569753535091877,
0.624984622001648,
0.4527747631072998,
0.05210747569799423,
-0.3847271800041199,
0.11472412943840027,
0.09853878617286682,
0.3975483179092407,
-0.4837280809879303,
-0.2980787456035614,
0.4438713788986206,
-0.8827002644538879,
-0.21223682165145874,
0.03484383225440979,
-0.4078069031238556,
-0.5853819847106934,
0.27987757325172424,
0.5721946358680725,
-0.3517974317073822,
-0.02160072699189186,
0.4233829975128174,
-0.5875274538993835,
0.22115366160869598,
0.3110004961490631,
-0.8422157764434814,
0.1205020323395729,
0.6510024666786194,
0.6229709386825562,
0.1198452040553093,
-0.0857454463839531,
-0.735575795173645,
0.2216603308916092,
-0.10525236278772354,
0.44067421555519104,
-0.9078983664512634,
-0.4630805552005768,
0.0029478666838258505,
0.17925259470939636,
-0.6934729218482971,
-0.3627298176288605,
0.7156442999839783,
-0.37446221709251404,
0.5359005331993103,
-0.25106990337371826,
-0.6787163615226746,
-0.2706931531429291,
0.15935742855072021,
-0.46037110686302185,
0.11730366200208664,
0.35295259952545166,
-0.4998331367969513,
1.056481957435608,
-0.6598331332206726,
-0.16665849089622498,
0.3842598795890808,
-0.21301232278347015,
-0.5584474205970764,
0.5197431445121765,
-0.0699310377240181,
0.42722252011299133,
-0.5146626234054565,
0.2509094476699829,
-0.4209151864051819,
-0.16849027574062347,
-0.21673154830932617,
0.2519797384738922,
0.3439933955669403,
0.35609865188598633,
-0.3168042004108429,
-0.14236226677894592,
-0.569525957107544,
0.0035976481158286333,
-0.0651000365614891,
-0.22757406532764435,
-0.39172348380088806,
0.02281537652015686,
-0.12741105258464813,
0.2187463492155075,
-0.16414985060691833,
-0.7300711274147034,
0.3731807768344879,
-0.500322163105011,
0.20553140342235565,
0.21829135715961456,
-0.024008765816688538,
0.04398161545395851,
-0.2555917501449585,
0.7727364301681519,
0.008253868669271469,
0.5973094701766968,
0.2914377450942993,
-1.0232313871383667,
-0.5367152094841003,
-0.30323776602745056,
0.7341727018356323,
0.4753497838973999,
-0.5890064239501953,
0.412961483001709,
-0.14298312366008759,
-0.19117145240306854,
-0.398628830909729,
-0.18800537288188934,
0.5557699799537659,
0.2759927213191986,
0.3160311281681061,
-0.6125633120536804,
-0.5174813866615295,
-0.9667268991470337,
-0.08110959082841873,
-0.15258388221263885,
-0.21051841974258423,
0.380888432264328,
0.560457170009613,
-0.08593277633190155,
0.7690891027450562,
-0.27408871054649353,
-0.774755597114563,
-0.3014543354511261,
0.11649958789348602,
0.19512899219989777,
0.40638968348503113,
0.5644746422767639,
-0.7733274698257446,
-0.2540586590766907,
0.3042812645435333,
-0.797835111618042,
-0.23694747686386108,
-0.09051134437322617,
0.18074092268943787,
-0.4717480540275574,
0.0818023756146431,
-0.1767139434814453,
0.9663977026939392,
0.5748284459114075,
-0.40407833456993103,
-0.2846493422985077,
-0.10873554646968842,
0.3453924059867859,
-0.5385772585868835,
0.31207162141799927,
0.14498569071292877,
-0.3110615909099579,
-0.6199156641960144,
-0.278076708316803,
0.023276807740330696,
0.029529623687267303,
-0.10402732342481613,
0.11077345907688141,
-0.20518343150615692,
0.048642680048942566,
-0.19577962160110474,
-0.2083323448896408,
-0.029357731342315674,
-0.2188955694437027,
0.06926809996366501,
0.03606012836098671,
0.4448431730270386,
-0.8048723936080933,
0.06394749134778976,
0.0874049961566925,
-0.24372029304504395,
0.2171953320503235,
-0.6350083947181702,
-0.28951480984687805,
-0.23270750045776367,
0.4339948296546936,
-0.8248064517974854,
-0.4377320110797882,
0.24048757553100586,
-0.5689127445220947,
-0.14834168553352356,
-0.3391951620578766,
0.0717020034790039,
-0.6887655854225159,
0.12703077495098114,
0.48219624161720276,
0.3754146695137024,
-0.022082997485995293,
0.5598779916763306,
0.18496279418468475,
-0.044376689940690994,
-0.5481013059616089,
-0.8270696401596069,
-0.26573675870895386,
-0.46787726879119873,
-0.06955178827047348,
0.16743025183677673,
0.34118354320526123,
0.205234557390213,
-0.11361080408096313,
0.19341373443603516,
-0.235807865858078,
-0.049946848303079605,
0.39622989296913147,
-0.17640113830566406,
0.07838703691959381,
-0.07606063038110733,
0.053229570388793945,
0.07795081287622452,
-0.14089849591255188,
0.033739496022462845,
0.3447810709476471,
0.5626177787780762,
-0.7289888858795166,
-0.4627701938152313,
0.5742810368537903,
0.0351688414812088,
0.03169947490096092,
0.20458047091960907,
0.38361260294914246,
-0.4895251989364624,
0.026235206052660942,
-0.5051957368850708,
0.030009062960743904,
-0.3420614004135132,
0.2542663812637329,
-0.3790666162967682,
-1.1486753225326538,
0.6343874335289001,
0.25672072172164917,
0.46850475668907166,
0.8199566006660461,
0.6744112372398376,
0.22696582973003387,
1.0067371129989624,
0.47086837887763977,
0.27522188425064087,
-0.21149660646915436,
-0.0032657638657838106,
-0.0643092542886734,
-0.7068865299224854,
-0.38252896070480347,
-0.5007595419883728,
-0.4148000180721283,
-0.4668411612510681,
-0.47437965869903564,
0.5180042386054993,
-0.042309392243623734,
0.1611945778131485,
0.2373761385679245,
-0.8743479251861572,
0.4932432770729065,
0.1929059624671936,
0.3267972469329834,
0.23384369909763336,
-0.25213518738746643,
-0.23788030445575714,
-0.16341641545295715,
-0.8748530745506287,
-0.03951045870780945,
1.8842054605484009,
0.43275055289268494,
0.05220452696084976,
0.26014047861099243,
1.0380784273147583,
0.6528487801551819,
0.7083758115768433,
-0.4809253513813019,
-0.09419875591993332,
-0.6731279492378235,
-0.9451321363449097,
-0.042005755007267,
-0.7031593322753906,
-1.5066697597503662,
0.14576828479766846,
-0.12044059485197067,
-0.48890420794487,
0.5688799619674683,
0.032512348145246506,
-0.8747404217720032,
0.037003882229328156,
-0.5845836400985718,
0.8321805596351624,
-0.21336014568805695,
0.34914031624794006,
-0.06785216927528381,
-0.7478996515274048,
0.6856998205184937,
-0.010725333355367184,
0.13054989278316498,
-0.38755831122398376,
0.03028430975973606,
0.5764426589012146,
-0.22888101637363434,
0.7452813386917114,
-0.320896178483963,
0.4354323446750641,
-0.022534098476171494,
-0.2232884168624878,
0.077384814620018,
0.2105926275253296,
-0.08139920979738235,
0.14205633103847504,
0.12663066387176514,
-0.5863929986953735,
-0.31024599075317383,
0.2611679136753082,
-0.6116309762001038,
-0.2037162333726883,
-0.6794771552085876,
-0.369483083486557,
-0.2886412441730499,
0.1917104870080948,
0.4170064926147461,
0.16511081159114838,
-0.5007063150405884,
0.16213853657245636,
0.4368802309036255,
-0.4245048761367798,
-0.07515040040016174,
0.7366297841072083,
-0.4100355803966522,
-0.3854413330554962,
0.6865674257278442,
-0.06627241522073746,
0.3769998848438263,
0.4774869978427887,
0.15548020601272583,
-0.24372819066047668,
-1.1636854410171509,
-0.027280030772089958,
-0.14173732697963715,
-0.4654383063316345,
-0.1262231022119522,
-0.7017145156860352,
-0.2679947316646576,
-0.5810505151748657,
0.03605145588517189,
0.01789155974984169,
-0.36349982023239136,
-0.16737663745880127,
0.24258510768413544,
0.06792927533388138,
0.7613614797592163,
-0.18509329855442047,
0.2909163236618042,
-0.696330726146698,
0.6258660554885864,
0.37432053685188293,
0.21285904943943024,
-0.3458309769630432,
-0.8271565437316895,
-0.1534671187400818,
-0.15895390510559082,
-0.11505024880170822,
-0.5195745825767517,
0.11806010454893112,
0.6120535731315613,
0.8936117887496948,
0.4362376034259796,
-0.05649513751268387,
0.5693925619125366,
-0.17467142641544342,
0.5907870531082153,
0.5123716592788696,
-0.5652672052383423,
0.6748437285423279,
-0.43364566564559937,
-0.13444846868515015,
0.9417397379875183,
0.6247358918190002,
-0.7325598001480103,
-0.4257388114929199,
-0.5786802172660828,
-0.5405529141426086,
0.8210875391960144,
0.539356529712677,
-0.2725234031677246,
-0.04273007810115814,
0.7317488789558411,
0.360544353723526,
0.05845947936177254,
-0.5679810047149658,
0.016195353120565414,
-0.06584498286247253,
-0.26458972692489624,
-0.1540793478488922,
-0.16456806659698486,
-0.7789216041564941,
-0.12322942912578583,
0.16787965595722198,
-0.06309707462787628,
0.18805989623069763,
0.46732255816459656,
-0.13486000895500183,
0.17359015345573425,
0.20048756897449493,
0.3833429515361786,
0.533937394618988,
-0.4660663306713104,
-0.10941434651613235,
0.048715732991695404,
-0.6915296316146851,
-0.017380952835083008,
0.2297418862581253,
-0.0447959266602993,
-0.08107363432645798,
0.4653836488723755,
0.4437817633152008,
0.008063873276114464,
-0.4641599655151367,
0.6150129437446594,
-0.44104355573654175,
-0.5117007493972778,
0.1563698947429657,
0.37081456184387207,
-0.36448678374290466,
0.0786856934428215,
0.08783829212188721,
-0.30403852462768555,
0.7126725912094116,
-0.38802582025527954,
0.3590543568134308,
0.6503372192382812,
-0.5576518774032593,
-0.1164725124835968,
0.8782081007957458,
0.5257152318954468,
0.10219651460647583,
0.4865441620349884,
-0.06708694249391556,
0.14574486017227173,
0.7659270763397217,
0.37239497900009155,
0.8138515949249268,
-0.1777651160955429,
0.38830846548080444,
0.34479475021362305,
0.33118048310279846,
-0.18709900975227356,
0.18706433475017548,
0.33195069432258606,
-0.40724945068359375,
-0.22494499385356903,
-0.5599090456962585,
-0.6405665278434753,
-0.0011401245137676597,
-0.571071207523346,
0.34503239393234253,
-0.6538493037223816,
-0.4627126455307007,
0.4254664480686188,
-0.25991007685661316,
-0.5370654463768005,
0.43174126744270325,
0.41262295842170715,
0.6341533064842224,
-1.0656660795211792,
0.7364338040351868,
0.4647906422615051,
-0.33352214097976685,
-0.3681880831718445,
-0.4040229022502899,
0.2415398210287094,
-0.8046752214431763,
0.3239991068840027,
0.3381732702255249,
0.596904456615448,
-0.3395165503025055,
-0.2235497087240219,
-0.7543732523918152,
1.2261642217636108,
0.12002760171890259,
-0.6405417919158936,
-0.2672933042049408,
0.41320687532424927,
0.4459203779697418,
-0.76058030128479,
0.3674457371234894,
0.6020653247833252,
0.38525882363319397,
0.3380934000015259,
-1.3628137111663818,
-0.3154813051223755,
-0.11625880748033524,
0.16661864519119263,
-0.14726591110229492,
-0.4706190228462219,
0.5667723417282104,
-0.07788683474063873,
-0.0740254670381546,
0.39964449405670166,
0.2041616439819336,
0.3760735094547272,
1.0163215398788452,
0.4894568920135498,
0.6748472452163696,
0.7250931262969971,
-0.4567562937736511,
1.118158221244812,
-0.07407380640506744,
0.40110209584236145,
0.5576695203781128,
-0.31389814615249634,
-0.08653286099433899,
-0.1335485726594925,
-0.40397909283638,
0.09733568876981735,
0.7947240471839905,
0.0835045874118805,
0.4542258679866791,
0.20904681086540222,
-0.012543540447950363,
-0.5931734442710876,
-0.043342895805835724,
-0.6986939311027527,
0.43149179220199585,
0.44692736864089966,
-0.8383050560951233,
-0.3335396945476532,
0.1844683438539505,
-0.3439004123210907,
-0.2636711001396179,
-0.17913317680358887,
0.5712841153144836,
0.13252736628055573,
-0.36953669786453247,
0.41772082448005676,
0.013823125511407852,
0.43870270252227783,
-1.02410089969635,
0.023924445733428,
0.11385826021432877,
0.19796577095985413,
-0.5648269653320312,
-0.5311939716339111,
0.1746671050786972,
-0.14881476759910583,
-0.199893519282341,
0.4682421088218689,
0.5630715489387512,
-0.18345190584659576,
-0.7194317579269409,
0.16716644167900085,
0.19319960474967957,
0.33993884921073914,
0.2025422602891922,
-0.8256590366363525,
-0.02838495559990406,
0.10062209516763687,
0.005740338005125523,
0.48579198122024536,
0.4216236472129822,
-0.0693567618727684,
0.4852674603462219,
0.5261951684951782,
0.36540475487709045,
-0.046129848808050156,
0.06456145644187927,
0.5130030512809753,
-0.794724702835083,
-0.11006738990545273,
-0.6057127714157104,
0.23552843928337097,
-0.06194562837481499,
-0.8545636534690857,
0.8091229796409607,
0.793590784072876,
-0.04133585840463638,
0.3393057882785797,
0.8475311398506165,
-0.23190927505493164,
0.6266607642173767,
-0.4695046842098236,
0.5800273418426514,
-0.7018335461616516,
0.07152571529150009,
-0.004866901319473982,
-0.44946718215942383,
-0.7478781938552856,
0.16701136529445648,
-0.6677762269973755,
0.23865103721618652,
0.5398104786872864,
0.34653958678245544,
-0.09911515563726425,
0.16680258512496948,
0.3145969808101654,
-0.02296193689107895,
0.5501371026039124,
1.1537662744522095,
0.3801921606063843,
-0.6121349930763245,
0.14587461948394775,
-0.10766539722681046,
-0.5620734095573425,
-0.38529202342033386,
-0.45883306860923767,
-0.7205790281295776,
-0.31532999873161316,
-0.2936275005340576,
-0.40469393134117126,
0.4540979564189911,
0.5648031234741211,
0.8884819149971008,
-0.9290953278541565,
-0.035108715295791626,
0.08634486049413681,
0.010449208319187164,
-0.17719577252864838,
-0.11913448572158813,
0.20464080572128296,
-0.37099167704582214,
-0.5914657115936279,
0.29158782958984375,
0.3483678698539734,
-0.18336987495422363,
0.29733461141586304,
0.006566629745066166,
-0.2207634150981903,
-0.16676065325737,
0.35479244589805603,
0.8043607473373413,
-0.4173985719680786,
-0.04285309836268425,
-0.29407843947410583,
-0.17510806024074554,
-0.02176237665116787,
0.9552909731864929,
-0.5908952355384827,
0.7649195790290833,
0.15693220496177673,
0.4007759392261505,
0.3272797465324402,
0.08251314610242844,
0.6148934364318848,
-0.13271325826644897,
0.10933208465576172,
0.6586272716522217,
0.1517215371131897,
-0.16497519612312317,
-0.24305757880210876,
0.5829408764839172,
0.29882070422172546,
-0.9490517377853394,
-0.7818683385848999,
0.16154658794403076,
-1.0166817903518677,
0.0368494838476181,
1.1191929578781128,
-0.17236465215682983,
0.1287190169095993,
-0.8081910610198975,
0.181731179356575,
0.007648102939128876,
-0.21286825835704803,
0.9779003262519836,
0.4138098359107971,
-0.6575537323951721,
0.09012369811534882,
-0.6972911953926086,
0.8694849610328674,
0.46596062183380127,
-0.7259619832038879,
0.01370382122695446,
0.613055408000946,
0.3599206805229187,
-0.13864849507808685,
1.0926622152328491,
-0.4272511899471283,
0.763442873954773,
-0.49787411093711853,
0.284385085105896,
0.34263551235198975,
-0.053032003343105316,
-0.3276936411857605,
0.22501255571842194,
0.03129812330007553,
-0.14306548237800598
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17125v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17125v1
|
The Strong Pull of Prior Knowledge in Large Language Models and Its Impact on Emotion Recognition
| 2024-03-25T19:07:32 | 2024-03-25T19:07:32 |
Georgios Chochlakis, Alexandros Potamianos, Kristina Lerman, Shrikanth Narayanan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In-context Learning (ICL) has emerged as a powerful paradigm for performing
natural language tasks with Large Language Models (LLM) without updating the
models' parameters, in contrast to the traditional gradient-based finetuning.
The promise of ICL is that the LLM can adapt to perform the present task at a
competitive or state-of-the-art level at a fraction of the cost. The ability of
LLMs to perform tasks in this few-shot manner relies on their background
knowledge of the task (or task priors). However, recent work has found that,
unlike traditional learning, LLMs are unable to fully integrate information
from demonstrations that contrast task priors. This can lead to performance
saturation at suboptimal levels, especially for subjective tasks such as
emotion recognition, where the mapping from text to emotions can differ widely
due to variability in human annotations. In this work, we design experiments
and propose measurements to explicitly quantify the consistency of proxies of
LLM priors and their pull on the posteriors. We show that LLMs have strong yet
inconsistent priors in emotion recognition that ossify their predictions. We
also find that the larger the model, the stronger these effects become. Our
results suggest that caution is needed when using ICL with larger LLMs for
affect-centered tasks outside their pre-training domain and when interpreting
ICL results.
|
[
-0.4978308379650116,
-0.31757667660713196,
0.7198231220245361,
0.04615781456232071,
-0.22994983196258545,
-0.27707377076148987,
-0.4343092441558838,
-0.5925008654594421,
-0.24301162362098694,
0.24910064041614532,
-0.36506223678588867,
-0.5083627700805664,
-0.6897867321968079,
0.1468525379896164,
-0.14645585417747498,
1.0450247526168823,
-0.3111230731010437,
-0.13312387466430664,
-0.2870479226112366,
-0.1398807317018509,
-0.16066253185272217,
-0.8175150752067566,
-0.35190242528915405,
-0.6102718114852905,
0.4535432457923889,
0.4464551508426666,
0.35627466440200806,
-0.10740268975496292,
0.5290804505348206,
0.22126029431819916,
-0.15899737179279327,
-0.0330662727355957,
-0.5488945841789246,
0.09340612590312958,
-0.1360967755317688,
-0.5479758381843567,
-0.13964499533176422,
0.2027948647737503,
0.6669813394546509,
0.36353904008865356,
0.04227795451879501,
-0.26440614461898804,
0.1962447166442871,
0.8279666900634766,
-0.9871321320533752,
0.06667657941579819,
-0.6941487193107605,
0.2622741460800171,
-0.18822520971298218,
0.02993563935160637,
-0.40546050667762756,
-0.18471916019916534,
0.5673710107803345,
-0.2031269520521164,
-0.22493940591812134,
-0.030777763575315475,
0.9091168642044067,
0.3980599343776703,
-0.6097041368484497,
-0.3822736442089081,
-0.6285555958747864,
0.6539061069488525,
-1.0143675804138184,
0.4439035952091217,
0.5126098990440369,
-0.0004722781013697386,
-0.11353512108325958,
-0.4871906340122223,
-0.7818273305892944,
-0.49287793040275574,
-0.189265638589859,
0.14497503638267517,
-0.2923254072666168,
0.1323402374982834,
0.5804831385612488,
0.38184964656829834,
-0.13791857659816742,
0.30058786273002625,
0.048011861741542816,
0.16890962421894073,
0.47793257236480713,
0.15276555716991425,
0.19596314430236816,
0.12704451382160187,
-0.539374828338623,
-0.01111634261906147,
-0.9928711652755737,
0.4897547662258148,
0.16578182578086853,
0.11388716101646423,
-0.3484455347061157,
0.32286494970321655,
-0.13498805463314056,
0.2404569387435913,
0.3585267663002014,
-0.03299439325928688,
0.2562110722064972,
0.27342551946640015,
-0.42275452613830566,
0.14708968997001648,
0.7983666062355042,
0.14237599074840546,
0.33652156591415405,
0.09144943207502365,
-0.2339658886194229,
-0.06648126244544983,
0.19054433703422546,
-0.8364949822425842,
-0.03961591422557831,
0.1672227829694748,
-0.2962431311607361,
0.3027209937572479,
0.13082954287528992,
-0.6509466171264648,
-0.7024549245834351,
-0.5469970703125,
0.518656313419342,
-0.4332699477672577,
-0.3360429108142853,
-0.17171843349933624,
0.21715082228183746,
0.08007127046585083,
0.3347450792789459,
-0.7444127798080444,
0.34484395384788513,
0.49733737111091614,
0.7454001903533936,
-0.3616195619106293,
-0.31773385405540466,
-0.4428372383117676,
-0.19305649399757385,
-0.3347204029560089,
0.42717719078063965,
-0.4225224256515503,
-0.15237438678741455,
0.20328855514526367,
-0.006629630457609892,
-0.057160135358572006,
-0.5925478339195251,
0.6140466928482056,
-0.43436816334724426,
-0.2651606798171997,
-0.402405709028244,
-0.6307595372200012,
-0.13185229897499084,
0.19876576960086823,
-0.38033968210220337,
0.792020320892334,
0.021616872400045395,
-0.8259097337722778,
0.39814913272857666,
-0.23165707290172577,
-0.5240254998207092,
-0.12130601704120636,
-0.12149670720100403,
-0.3443320095539093,
0.6193045973777771,
-0.08542703837156296,
0.7323728203773499,
-0.20530034601688385,
0.2029530555009842,
-0.5302169322967529,
-0.5961766839027405,
0.45980730652809143,
-0.2671504318714142,
0.38372939825057983,
0.02446749061346054,
-0.6743087768554688,
-0.013740907423198223,
-0.596528947353363,
-0.40547123551368713,
-0.1968328207731247,
-0.33483177423477173,
-0.6093975901603699,
0.1451316624879837,
-0.3844060003757477,
0.5931785702705383,
0.12127577513456345,
-0.5090693235397339,
0.07242967933416367,
-0.47068145871162415,
-0.0150759844109416,
0.924393355846405,
-0.4697248637676239,
0.5078194737434387,
0.14360886812210083,
0.3466634452342987,
0.32662755250930786,
-0.2582736015319824,
-0.13113099336624146,
0.14011666178703308,
-0.8546953201293945,
-0.16192524135112762,
-0.1452108770608902,
0.3157999515533447,
-0.3391101360321045,
0.2860366404056549,
-0.04381489381194115,
-0.5083431601524353,
-0.3380613327026367,
0.2163688689470291,
0.42138853669166565,
0.6993772983551025,
0.2276713103055954,
-0.3140439987182617,
-0.4426478445529938,
-0.7424879670143127,
-0.18347737193107605,
-0.14447666704654694,
0.11366768181324005,
0.4599083662033081,
0.5059747099876404,
-0.1718141734600067,
0.8004891276359558,
-0.21031013131141663,
-0.27884894609451294,
-0.08460196852684021,
0.4957524538040161,
0.17569886147975922,
0.42173081636428833,
0.334751695394516,
-0.7375762462615967,
-0.6386593580245972,
0.10775402933359146,
-0.7721211314201355,
-0.1534271389245987,
0.053455159068107605,
-0.027421321719884872,
0.4459230899810791,
0.5904524326324463,
-0.5743628144264221,
0.5295906662940979,
0.6467043161392212,
-0.18226173520088196,
0.5046894550323486,
-0.23005986213684082,
0.16243712604045868,
-0.5327519178390503,
-0.07603015750646591,
0.4850746989250183,
0.10235422104597092,
-0.6353229284286499,
-0.32465195655822754,
0.34810569882392883,
0.1972947120666504,
-0.6505058407783508,
0.6812111735343933,
-0.4849976897239685,
-0.09908013045787811,
-0.3730459213256836,
0.04483211040496826,
-0.3170320987701416,
0.5016987323760986,
0.3906300365924835,
0.6143410801887512,
0.5948049426078796,
-0.6642943620681763,
-0.0072545502334833145,
-0.09887039661407471,
-0.4222498834133148,
0.9134289622306824,
-0.39309176802635193,
0.3012406527996063,
-0.3075343072414398,
0.24567465484142303,
-0.9764502048492432,
-0.22651737928390503,
-0.002194369910284877,
0.03028671257197857,
0.629630982875824,
-0.018006013706326485,
-0.27351507544517517,
-0.1566937267780304,
-0.05404006689786911,
0.2490779012441635,
0.6839379072189331,
-0.6649909615516663,
0.7806955575942993,
0.04887644201517105,
-0.17454469203948975,
-0.46180498600006104,
-0.6508232355117798,
-0.03589215129613876,
-0.4314529299736023,
-0.25003308057785034,
0.1841651052236557,
-0.16788074374198914,
-0.48643890023231506,
-0.36666229367256165,
-0.20117996633052826,
-0.09575391560792923,
0.11559144407510757,
0.6797229647636414,
0.033264514058828354,
-0.1821250468492508,
0.43463873863220215,
-0.04307187721133232,
0.04983014240860939,
0.11495395004749298,
0.028801612555980682,
0.16100500524044037,
-0.29045942425727844,
-0.34884411096572876,
-0.6697207689285278,
0.2370627075433731,
0.7539250254631042,
-0.17603395879268646,
0.7204984426498413,
0.5324059128761292,
-0.4863954484462738,
-0.11013443022966385,
-0.5934982299804688,
-0.09964759647846222,
-0.4265480637550354,
0.27059900760650635,
-0.3444174826145172,
-0.9692403674125671,
0.43791353702545166,
-0.22665412724018097,
-0.3373676836490631,
0.39567509293556213,
0.48741376399993896,
-0.3278067708015442,
1.0350239276885986,
0.6719056367874146,
-0.21439625322818756,
0.7350469827651978,
0.2439848929643631,
0.13834498822689056,
-1.071825385093689,
-0.05757706239819527,
-0.48268523812294006,
-0.4114440679550171,
-0.10170501470565796,
0.17357461154460907,
0.20672644674777985,
0.26181918382644653,
-0.5045784711837769,
-0.18768608570098877,
-0.017205335199832916,
0.29248252511024475,
0.3780733048915863,
0.12406883388757706,
-0.017777396366000175,
-0.17936810851097107,
0.0928780734539032,
-0.3018241226673126,
-0.21586354076862335,
-0.41590943932533264,
0.8135703802108765,
0.2619304358959198,
0.7768985629081726,
-0.141163170337677,
0.4967309534549713,
-0.056616976857185364,
0.8041680455207825,
-0.6429925560951233,
0.2841149866580963,
-0.16485868394374847,
-0.23223862051963806,
0.002216385444626212,
-0.28672394156455994,
-0.7023503184318542,
0.2171144336462021,
-0.2298174351453781,
-1.1677671670913696,
0.2290264219045639,
0.3057122528553009,
-0.21533450484275818,
0.19000020623207092,
-0.7305511832237244,
0.8901793956756592,
-0.3446061909198761,
-0.4330225884914398,
-0.03955136612057686,
-0.7115393877029419,
0.3775867223739624,
-0.1221824586391449,
0.15399572253227234,
-0.1752609759569168,
0.19069182872772217,
0.41888856887817383,
-0.3591665029525757,
1.0446069240570068,
-0.15623116493225098,
-0.22275952994823456,
0.1458573043346405,
0.16109372675418854,
0.7812365293502808,
-0.23944292962551117,
-0.18615683913230896,
0.011856053955852985,
-0.38027074933052063,
-0.060938555747270584,
-0.6105054616928101,
0.7522246837615967,
-0.6785045862197876,
-0.6722203493118286,
-0.29442575573921204,
-0.5972423553466797,
-0.33795517683029175,
0.05068298056721687,
0.41319307684898376,
0.28842946887016296,
0.03396771848201752,
0.36116549372673035,
0.765828013420105,
-0.07964032888412476,
0.3180443346500397,
0.5515354871749878,
0.16045880317687988,
-0.0750073716044426,
0.6387694478034973,
0.17847727239131927,
0.39061352610588074,
0.3693397343158722,
0.23608048260211945,
-0.19502289593219757,
-0.5703126788139343,
0.1074712797999382,
0.0761362612247467,
-0.8513612747192383,
-0.1623021364212036,
-0.5936591625213623,
0.1782199889421463,
-0.25908413529396057,
-0.3834719657897949,
-0.29011213779449463,
0.3002106547355652,
-0.5671519637107849,
-0.22740447521209717,
0.19757498800754547,
0.724008321762085,
0.017928602173924446,
0.29927778244018555,
-0.6390013098716736,
-0.021417971700429916,
0.3561745285987854,
0.3516482710838318,
0.20510581135749817,
-0.5370318293571472,
-0.4024845361709595,
0.026957791298627853,
-0.24328653514385223,
-0.8755218386650085,
0.3866567611694336,
0.28882429003715515,
0.35504937171936035,
0.5928592085838318,
0.18457207083702087,
0.6061006188392639,
-0.3605589270591736,
0.7937044501304626,
0.16432343423366547,
-1.3421329259872437,
0.48263901472091675,
-0.1171359047293663,
0.4487076699733734,
0.5437217950820923,
0.731763482093811,
-0.37282899022102356,
-0.48390233516693115,
-0.5779115557670593,
-0.8417780995368958,
0.8095066547393799,
-0.07134240120649338,
0.1805243343114853,
0.02054451033473015,
0.4261409640312195,
0.003992848563939333,
0.2553379237651825,
-0.8040865063667297,
-0.010080077685415745,
0.02744106948375702,
-0.4818207025527954,
-0.33146223425865173,
-0.3827710747718811,
0.1347559094429016,
-0.2372177392244339,
0.4262852072715759,
-0.11074226349592209,
-0.07862221449613571,
0.4585988223552704,
-0.2876097857952118,
-0.323026567697525,
0.23653995990753174,
0.6136248707771301,
0.3515828847885132,
-0.3266378939151764,
0.5114511847496033,
0.4467407763004303,
-0.21245834231376648,
0.04555715247988701,
0.049969688057899475,
0.17778454720973969,
-0.22851300239562988,
0.47050994634628296,
1.0609186887741089,
0.4328732490539551,
-0.8993316888809204,
0.6669845581054688,
0.13134720921516418,
0.09690871834754944,
-0.1529335081577301,
-0.08055483549833298,
-0.1061784103512764,
0.5032057166099548,
0.3750916123390198,
-0.0346623994410038,
0.024815233424305916,
-0.6575250625610352,
0.11644069850444794,
0.4572640061378479,
-0.9496747851371765,
-0.5028272271156311,
0.3448171615600586,
-0.19568604230880737,
-0.14438989758491516,
0.513985276222229,
-0.07189308106899261,
-0.7399777173995972,
0.6210513710975647,
0.5641025900840759,
0.8318997025489807,
-0.34662124514579773,
-0.20950835943222046,
0.20876510441303253,
-0.0018244985258206725,
-0.3473432958126068,
0.012195254676043987,
-0.1207764595746994,
-0.7180340886116028,
-0.2455846667289734,
-0.38158106803894043,
-0.4687557518482208,
-0.07041620463132858,
-0.5375215411186218,
0.2613378167152405,
-0.38078680634498596,
-0.07594633102416992,
-0.44460242986679077,
-0.1756848692893982,
-0.9141623973846436,
0.5165440440177917,
0.507826030254364,
0.7205588221549988,
-0.8103923797607422,
0.6988966464996338,
0.7166282534599304,
-0.2802531123161316,
-0.9009701609611511,
0.1503784954547882,
0.14183251559734344,
-0.25552505254745483,
1.0075318813323975,
0.3862411081790924,
-0.06498106569051743,
-0.14031292498111725,
-0.6929566860198975,
-0.7788519859313965,
0.8922315835952759,
0.5120550394058228,
-0.6595352292060852,
0.1886959820985794,
-0.23898011445999146,
0.8343104720115662,
-0.5705128312110901,
0.4660000503063202,
0.3357435166835785,
0.28010016679763794,
0.19792500138282776,
-0.8122157454490662,
0.06187032163143158,
-0.04422751069068909,
-0.3231358230113983,
0.22970691323280334,
-0.4857177734375,
1.0153625011444092,
-0.17950810492038727,
-0.26272591948509216,
-0.26732802391052246,
0.8141080737113953,
0.2526354491710663,
0.42118796706199646,
0.49194538593292236,
0.4711431562900543,
0.7307381629943848,
-0.12669645249843597,
1.3114173412322998,
-0.06567685306072235,
0.3559093773365021,
1.1235283613204956,
-0.6921195387840271,
1.12444007396698,
0.5175512433052063,
-0.05930183082818985,
0.5311465859413147,
0.5821807384490967,
0.4357057511806488,
0.5231730937957764,
0.2099119871854782,
-0.19845159351825714,
-0.30451783537864685,
-0.2267872542142868,
-0.20496879518032074,
0.1987566500902176,
0.3436361253261566,
-0.4358297884464264,
0.08178775012493134,
0.15746191143989563,
0.21690663695335388,
-0.0548737533390522,
-0.5097082257270813,
0.7453132271766663,
0.4486173689365387,
-0.6780788898468018,
0.5843867659568787,
-0.6228178143501282,
0.9201331734657288,
-0.6243224740028381,
0.03313539922237396,
-0.16670091450214386,
0.2609366178512573,
-0.33819252252578735,
-0.7910204529762268,
0.10076861828565598,
0.01629846729338169,
-0.008981223218142986,
-0.09830930083990097,
0.7573035359382629,
-0.5536621809005737,
-0.1434699296951294,
0.4472500681877136,
0.17634886503219604,
0.01646905206143856,
-0.26961347460746765,
-0.19353750348091125,
0.18284668028354645,
-0.34175699949264526,
-0.5160794258117676,
0.5888622403144836,
0.7005125880241394,
0.20105358958244324,
0.5197688341140747,
0.3173939287662506,
0.010061195120215416,
-0.19117732346057892,
-0.0912407711148262,
0.709682047367096,
-0.4540709853172302,
-0.32357439398765564,
-1.0694749355316162,
0.8122987151145935,
0.07608874142169952,
-0.5657925009727478,
0.5443207621574402,
0.015250482596457005,
0.8414629101753235,
0.08724769204854965,
0.6167249083518982,
0.29283735156059265,
0.07335031777620316,
-0.6235657334327698,
0.4481721818447113,
-0.9188661575317383,
-0.08843597769737244,
-0.7634469270706177,
-0.6336208581924438,
-0.2980585992336273,
0.5769729018211365,
-0.6019662618637085,
-0.14779160916805267,
0.7079948782920837,
0.3358849585056305,
0.04672917351126671,
0.037024665623903275,
0.321980744600296,
0.45893940329551697,
0.20689496397972107,
0.8086711168289185,
0.9840238094329834,
0.05247535556554794,
0.12217742949724197,
-0.20102530717849731,
-0.2206348180770874,
-0.30876171588897705,
-1.1248714923858643,
-0.8925849795341492,
-0.5946781039237976,
-0.32733121514320374,
-0.16942843794822693,
0.0462481826543808,
1.1205772161483765,
0.5903090834617615,
-0.6715258359909058,
-0.08471032232046127,
-0.034450650215148926,
0.14762549102306366,
-0.18658627569675446,
-0.17812465131282806,
0.34764599800109863,
-0.318782240152359,
-0.7628382444381714,
0.16095811128616333,
0.4989055097103119,
0.21798597276210785,
0.08261552453041077,
-0.2599884569644928,
0.019891655072569847,
-0.05717543885111809,
0.643628716468811,
0.38890498876571655,
-0.7731161713600159,
-0.3843374252319336,
-0.35873162746429443,
-0.3223707675933838,
0.26421189308166504,
0.7807680368423462,
-0.7059868574142456,
0.31528332829475403,
0.44142669439315796,
0.65745609998703,
0.44562995433807373,
-0.15767811238765717,
0.6419022083282471,
-0.6256185173988342,
0.10050409287214279,
0.1666036993265152,
0.7209889888763428,
0.35386496782302856,
-0.46881747245788574,
0.29944223165512085,
-0.12230715155601501,
-0.5660954117774963,
-0.6981564164161682,
0.34745943546295166,
-0.7696248292922974,
-0.05989353731274605,
1.1352354288101196,
-0.5657885670661926,
0.007223292253911495,
0.22496913373470306,
-0.3774222135543823,
0.12459772080183029,
-0.5074082016944885,
0.651610791683197,
0.954403817653656,
-0.22027145326137543,
-0.4176020920276642,
-0.24933017790317535,
0.6445910930633545,
0.5343223810195923,
-0.7291420698165894,
0.15656709671020508,
0.4901485741138458,
-0.07076755911111832,
0.05630084127187729,
0.5598591566085815,
0.13751907646656036,
0.05076178163290024,
-0.44572076201438904,
0.18366603553295135,
0.21731746196746826,
-0.22072359919548035,
-0.6422432661056519,
0.33972910046577454,
0.1451774686574936,
0.4360451400279999
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17124v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17124v2
|
Grounding Language Plans in Demonstrations Through Counterfactual Perturbations
| 2024-03-25T19:04:59 | 2024-04-29T04:34:52 |
Yanwei Wang, Tsun-Hsuan Wang, Jiayuan Mao, Michael Hagenow, Julie Shah
|
cs.RO
|
cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Grounding the common-sense reasoning of Large Language Models (LLMs) in
physical domains remains a pivotal yet unsolved problem for embodied AI.
Whereas prior works have focused on leveraging LLMs directly for planning in
symbolic spaces, this work uses LLMs to guide the search of task structures and
constraints implicit in multi-step demonstrations. Specifically, we borrow from
manipulation planning literature the concept of mode families, which group
robot configurations by specific motion constraints, to serve as an abstraction
layer between the high-level language representations of an LLM and the
low-level physical trajectories of a robot. By replaying a few human
demonstrations with synthetic perturbations, we generate coverage over the
demonstrations' state space with additional successful executions as well as
counterfactuals that fail the task. Our explanation-based learning framework
trains an end-to-end differentiable neural network to predict successful
trajectories from failures and as a by-product learns classifiers that ground
low-level states and images in mode families without dense labeling. The
learned grounding classifiers can further be used to translate language plans
into reactive policies in the physical domain in an interpretable manner. We
show our approach improves the interpretability and reactivity of imitation
learning through 2D navigation and simulated and real robot manipulation tasks.
Website: https://yanweiw.github.io/glide
|
[
-0.19310325384140015,
-0.853291392326355,
0.7897865772247314,
0.10752035677433014,
-0.14913013577461243,
-0.14178511500358582,
0.011113443411886692,
0.1927470564842224,
0.31096577644348145,
0.6044012308120728,
-0.8691771626472473,
-0.5075117349624634,
-0.5512505769729614,
-0.3063852787017822,
-0.3758573532104492,
0.6784033179283142,
-0.41386622190475464,
-0.20224550366401672,
-0.09481155127286911,
-0.002638741862028837,
-0.35083770751953125,
-0.4942701458930969,
-0.3076810836791992,
-0.8370850086212158,
0.36369460821151733,
0.4389757215976715,
0.74590003490448,
0.48640692234039307,
-0.2600255310535431,
0.3454486131668091,
0.05544509366154671,
0.47158312797546387,
-0.5258371829986572,
0.11916384845972061,
-0.10807603597640991,
-0.500397264957428,
-0.142058864235878,
0.013215210288763046,
0.43933579325675964,
0.7666344046592712,
-0.05606506019830704,
-0.4777172803878784,
-0.18943116068840027,
0.5408523678779602,
-0.5036254525184631,
0.4009130001068115,
-0.4666402041912079,
0.3813532590866089,
0.47526922821998596,
-0.411456823348999,
-0.5155618190765381,
0.17966707050800323,
-0.17587518692016602,
-0.7365084886550903,
0.02205926552414894,
-0.11325037479400635,
0.8504253625869751,
0.5064659714698792,
-0.30048123002052307,
0.03889388218522072,
-0.9284427165985107,
0.7210144996643066,
-0.30077028274536133,
0.4864838123321533,
0.3817267417907715,
0.3216642141342163,
-0.6939270496368408,
-0.5520918965339661,
-0.7916247248649597,
-0.2903578579425812,
-0.23440618813037872,
0.20888496935367584,
-0.16409419476985931,
0.35206112265586853,
0.4264683425426483,
-0.06153243035078049,
-0.4631185829639435,
0.042761147022247314,
-0.054428908973932266,
-0.1584303081035614,
0.35393357276916504,
0.18893097341060638,
0.41817906498908997,
0.0945034921169281,
-0.35109055042266846,
-0.19458967447280884,
-0.91921466588974,
0.12948967516422272,
0.22188904881477356,
0.11138622462749481,
-0.33381351828575134,
0.6052079796791077,
-0.3301452100276947,
0.6197313070297241,
0.2739938497543335,
0.0866636261343956,
-0.022223539650440216,
0.018092820420861244,
-0.36047613620758057,
-0.11980481445789337,
0.543125569820404,
0.37434297800064087,
0.15074682235717773,
-0.332321435213089,
-0.2665058970451355,
0.13722671568393707,
0.36140307784080505,
-0.6055687665939331,
-0.057894155383110046,
0.19298234581947327,
-0.3996351659297943,
-0.05685750022530556,
-0.12478242069482803,
-0.6385270953178406,
-0.5010219216346741,
-0.6786230802536011,
0.5629290342330933,
-0.38752445578575134,
-0.08099236339330673,
0.436496376991272,
-0.1602904349565506,
0.24473382532596588,
0.5056390762329102,
-0.7042830586433411,
0.3185679018497467,
0.6918184161186218,
0.6744906306266785,
0.26684513688087463,
-0.5831543803215027,
-0.6790891885757446,
0.4089912474155426,
-0.4652382731437683,
0.6586235761642456,
-0.5066413283348083,
-0.47895461320877075,
0.10491590201854706,
0.07595518976449966,
-0.22705614566802979,
-0.33735838532447815,
0.1433601826429367,
-0.36993950605392456,
0.14323507249355316,
-0.14130526781082153,
-0.3721678853034973,
-0.5659021735191345,
0.4138807952404022,
-0.431942880153656,
0.5891952514648438,
0.024082355201244354,
-0.3500741124153137,
0.34089016914367676,
-0.5597736239433289,
-0.7895839810371399,
-0.33092746138572693,
-0.5520544648170471,
-0.2764292061328888,
0.014060278423130512,
0.18122482299804688,
0.7147549390792847,
0.04425975680351257,
0.34014570713043213,
-0.02281978726387024,
-0.5503941178321838,
-0.07757258415222168,
-0.350055992603302,
0.4910648763179779,
-0.14917448163032532,
-0.846244752407074,
0.6976850032806396,
-0.6290876269340515,
-0.3094528317451477,
0.10981158167123795,
-0.16370326280593872,
-0.08946957439184189,
0.41232535243034363,
-0.38875719904899597,
0.44321611523628235,
0.062107231467962265,
-0.07833772897720337,
0.23723793029785156,
-0.5888214111328125,
0.34062081575393677,
0.6702004075050354,
0.06825773417949677,
0.5627686977386475,
-0.4929095208644867,
0.6871401071548462,
0.030331015586853027,
0.11429264396429062,
-0.34347042441368103,
-0.2730914354324341,
-0.7698226571083069,
-0.04400773346424103,
-0.4860817492008209,
0.40507063269615173,
-0.8689919114112854,
0.4230828285217285,
-0.23131288588047028,
-0.27544891834259033,
0.05547306686639786,
0.054373156279325485,
0.5480613112449646,
0.6382269859313965,
0.5739876627922058,
0.13076820969581604,
-0.5105164051055908,
-0.9263929128646851,
0.06354596465826035,
-0.22576144337654114,
-0.02792944945394993,
0.2460089772939682,
0.3851887583732605,
-0.3437958359718323,
0.7227615118026733,
-0.11920183897018433,
-0.08406088501214981,
-0.4621700942516327,
0.4109058082103729,
0.09192319959402084,
0.3499726355075836,
0.500274658203125,
-0.9796527624130249,
-0.11921500414609909,
-0.02582387812435627,
-0.6695199012756348,
0.09907684475183487,
-0.57023686170578,
-0.17047637701034546,
0.2227221131324768,
0.5557676553726196,
-0.7480485439300537,
0.5104359984397888,
0.4730156660079956,
-0.3086656630039215,
0.5296651124954224,
-0.2325182557106018,
0.07127595692873001,
-0.7709494829177856,
-0.19775912165641785,
-0.08754271268844604,
-0.13708887994289398,
-0.521579921245575,
0.3244321346282959,
-0.26647424697875977,
0.09632600843906403,
-0.4968555271625519,
0.5505472421646118,
-0.35232609510421753,
-0.20014868676662445,
-0.3035086393356323,
0.1721906214952469,
-0.011284925043582916,
0.8092601299285889,
0.4245060682296753,
0.6482112407684326,
0.6530979871749878,
-0.7481619119644165,
0.030897248536348343,
0.08663037419319153,
0.12831097841262817,
0.20929944515228271,
-0.5654078125953674,
0.1659764051437378,
-0.1636960208415985,
0.6425203680992126,
-0.9561306238174438,
-0.21791480481624603,
0.39256179332733154,
-0.16643692553043365,
0.19984714686870575,
-0.5255557298660278,
-0.363578736782074,
-0.008740161545574665,
-0.1631520539522171,
-0.06882959604263306,
0.6046676635742188,
-0.6425620913505554,
1.128551721572876,
0.23597227036952972,
0.5624316930770874,
-0.6002959609031677,
-0.49902206659317017,
-0.040626149624586105,
-0.24373139441013336,
-0.4496837556362152,
0.3420390188694,
-0.02158123254776001,
-0.3968487083911896,
-0.34056639671325684,
-0.308409720659256,
0.1006312370300293,
0.3011392056941986,
0.800349235534668,
0.015641847625374794,
-0.1556321531534195,
-0.1436402052640915,
0.42823123931884766,
-0.18027034401893616,
0.3378101885318756,
-0.23030304908752441,
0.853337824344635,
-0.10061607509851456,
-0.4249577224254608,
-0.4609898626804352,
0.1788840889930725,
0.6896867752075195,
0.20562255382537842,
0.5610944032669067,
0.2200477421283722,
-0.37453213334083557,
-0.2824728488922119,
-0.08048375695943832,
-0.25400662422180176,
-0.48426276445388794,
0.21597205102443695,
-0.6138414144515991,
-0.3953187167644501,
0.46094852685928345,
-0.45038437843322754,
0.2307765781879425,
0.20984911918640137,
0.45160341262817383,
-0.16921637952327728,
0.92873615026474,
0.5576195120811462,
-0.00029479063232429326,
0.337234765291214,
-0.5817543864250183,
-0.0759149119257927,
-0.4672914743423462,
-0.29388874769210815,
-0.24703119695186615,
-0.6586065888404846,
-0.17979584634304047,
-0.8056917190551758,
0.2918682396411896,
0.253280371427536,
-0.42144298553466797,
0.34042778611183167,
-0.11051786690950394,
0.4860503077507019,
0.34012678265571594,
0.24689745903015137,
0.0795033797621727,
0.23291969299316406,
-0.369097501039505,
0.072658471763134,
-0.6124438047409058,
-0.7446344494819641,
0.6343523859977722,
0.12929381430149078,
0.6498284339904785,
-0.10149392485618591,
0.7963159084320068,
-0.08530750125646591,
0.31487956643104553,
-0.899922251701355,
0.7828238010406494,
-0.3726370930671692,
-0.20279522240161896,
-0.4403877854347229,
-0.16011139750480652,
-0.8221774697303772,
0.29190805554389954,
-0.1777503937482834,
-0.6269149780273438,
0.09601400047540665,
0.40080714225769043,
-0.07165838778018951,
0.37694770097732544,
-0.4549269676208496,
0.7248976230621338,
-0.3607215881347656,
-0.46674343943595886,
-0.6498720049858093,
-0.7745605111122131,
0.19668449461460114,
0.37860700488090515,
0.33003488183021545,
0.16023968160152435,
0.10972260683774948,
0.3241586983203888,
-0.21121463179588318,
1.2356888055801392,
-0.44366976618766785,
-0.19331252574920654,
0.17313790321350098,
0.6611620783805847,
0.5739196538925171,
-0.11781113594770432,
-0.01863710768520832,
0.16324478387832642,
-0.5560599565505981,
-0.19132046401500702,
-0.8771821856498718,
0.635468065738678,
-0.7184115648269653,
-0.6963648200035095,
0.13935959339141846,
-0.5569999814033508,
-0.384353369474411,
0.12582401931285858,
0.11882810294628143,
0.4627193212509155,
-0.08236166089773178,
0.10425470769405365,
0.790136456489563,
-0.2695993483066559,
0.3251669704914093,
0.4290766417980194,
-0.3488704264163971,
0.132920503616333,
0.7865233421325684,
-0.18511906266212463,
0.2364744395017624,
0.8979176878929138,
0.48003441095352173,
-0.20465373992919922,
-0.4647679030895233,
-0.6747631430625916,
-0.024549776688218117,
-0.784643292427063,
0.20877550542354584,
-0.7101948857307434,
-0.006845212075859308,
-0.1206575334072113,
-0.5602145195007324,
-0.2549667954444885,
-0.5180491805076599,
-0.22442397475242615,
-0.3437027335166931,
0.04830944910645485,
0.765985369682312,
0.03640720620751381,
0.4099121391773224,
-0.4034624695777893,
0.6311198472976685,
0.21708203852176666,
0.019609389826655388,
-0.1383214145898819,
-0.5135751366615295,
0.0962163582444191,
0.25623416900634766,
-0.3095531761646271,
-0.6817914843559265,
0.3064934313297272,
0.0431942380964756,
0.7672601342201233,
0.4281066954135895,
-0.008372555486857891,
0.9182538986206055,
-0.6199690103530884,
0.7816356420516968,
0.14710786938667297,
-0.8901289701461792,
0.7740586996078491,
-0.34505194425582886,
-0.0023055155761539936,
0.10447932034730911,
0.696726381778717,
-0.4985058009624481,
-0.36794811487197876,
-0.61295485496521,
-0.9087779521942139,
0.38315296173095703,
-0.10615048557519913,
0.3380889594554901,
0.16387854516506195,
0.48269417881965637,
0.19397269189357758,
0.1387818157672882,
-0.7170518636703491,
-0.4236335754394531,
-0.43523311614990234,
-0.06564486771821976,
-0.1385815590620041,
-0.0431271530687809,
-0.44990503787994385,
-0.06423729658126831,
0.5117223262786865,
-0.37959611415863037,
0.1263408213853836,
0.1725631058216095,
-0.2941312789916992,
-0.35045722126960754,
0.08110587298870087,
1.0080984830856323,
0.47273606061935425,
0.20948006212711334,
0.34659048914909363,
-0.13625545799732208,
-0.040598101913928986,
0.21996738016605377,
-0.0037838080897927284,
-0.28963157534599304,
-0.12256242334842682,
0.4631655812263489,
0.8849924206733704,
0.4362007975578308,
-0.687677264213562,
0.22061121463775635,
0.16032324731349945,
-0.4802848696708679,
-0.28073248267173767,
0.2759841978549957,
-0.0918387770652771,
0.2778230607509613,
0.1727408915758133,
-0.0010666990419849753,
0.0025831880047917366,
-0.5666723847389221,
0.31064021587371826,
0.3417624831199646,
-0.4429363012313843,
-0.582425057888031,
0.6323069930076599,
-0.04618607088923454,
-0.4298723340034485,
0.4199431538581848,
-0.06785976141691208,
-0.7769004702568054,
0.6643090844154358,
0.4788496196269989,
0.7681559324264526,
0.09939643740653992,
0.4047621488571167,
0.22761116921901703,
0.3188681900501251,
-0.11755076050758362,
0.37802639603614807,
-0.13753412663936615,
-0.9682860374450684,
-0.5256689190864563,
-0.21854086220264435,
-0.3201228976249695,
0.22491131722927094,
-0.16860796511173248,
0.3390362560749054,
-0.7620110511779785,
0.47324103116989136,
-0.4151734709739685,
-0.3286859393119812,
-0.3548748195171356,
0.1285664290189743,
0.11494164168834686,
0.6655122637748718,
-1.042887568473816,
0.6471532583236694,
0.9214039444923401,
-0.5297696590423584,
-0.9362776875495911,
0.2442840337753296,
-0.0043645924888551235,
-0.9062131643295288,
0.9798074960708618,
0.1342802345752716,
-0.6935977339744568,
-0.25079476833343506,
-0.7388762831687927,
-0.41539451479911804,
0.7743369936943054,
0.49655330181121826,
-0.550420343875885,
-0.030091455206274986,
-0.1542920470237732,
0.571382999420166,
-0.2255164086818695,
0.022383296862244606,
0.17567890882492065,
0.5855385065078735,
0.15730957686901093,
-0.6392779350280762,
0.1729128658771515,
0.04221121966838837,
-0.511182427406311,
0.152296245098114,
-0.6299812197685242,
0.5432689189910889,
-0.2861781120300293,
-0.11214042454957962,
-0.028880301862955093,
0.5241384506225586,
0.5677101016044617,
0.477861225605011,
0.8359886407852173,
0.5116511583328247,
0.2546854317188263,
0.07676472514867783,
1.0869442224502563,
-0.1705164760351181,
-0.020496578887104988,
1.0656085014343262,
-0.3128338158130646,
0.6854102611541748,
0.6868711113929749,
0.0022244732826948166,
0.8163803219795227,
0.35071587562561035,
0.5317363142967224,
0.41966021060943604,
0.3534504473209381,
-0.06027332693338394,
-0.5783597230911255,
0.1294657588005066,
0.10088249295949936,
0.3922921419143677,
0.6516750454902649,
-0.1257750242948532,
-0.3723742961883545,
0.02933943271636963,
0.020655183121562004,
0.554153561592102,
-0.20737691223621368,
0.504214346408844,
-0.12865310907363892,
-0.6047181487083435,
0.5581041574478149,
-0.14764855802059174,
0.40668344497680664,
-0.47311457991600037,
-0.6121099591255188,
-0.27904120087623596,
-0.06301140040159225,
-0.11534877866506577,
-0.5839656591415405,
0.27300330996513367,
-0.4912508428096771,
-0.10880231112241745,
-0.7401756644248962,
0.5456882119178772,
-0.24753619730472565,
0.018165811896324158,
0.38031598925590515,
0.3309286832809448,
0.2696860134601593,
0.06041787192225456,
-0.6356682181358337,
-0.11400921642780304,
-0.12621958553791046,
-0.31240636110305786,
0.3915438950061798,
0.4092120826244354,
-0.30620473623275757,
0.860314130783081,
0.34864065051078796,
-0.12234008312225342,
0.08945559710264206,
0.20184054970741272,
0.9309608936309814,
-0.450192928314209,
-0.4158461093902588,
-0.6031334400177002,
0.5529060363769531,
0.2793895900249481,
-0.04459761455655098,
0.39208367466926575,
0.40298908948898315,
0.8481814861297607,
-0.09747026115655899,
0.45772314071655273,
0.028918256983160973,
0.1361382007598877,
-0.9399735331535339,
0.5242971777915955,
-0.6085954308509827,
0.21776068210601807,
0.06039823591709137,
-0.5035735964775085,
-0.34679049253463745,
1.0060094594955444,
-0.34344083070755005,
-0.022068599238991737,
0.42753365635871887,
0.7282738089561462,
-0.18301290273666382,
-0.32477185130119324,
0.6496921181678772,
0.3513478934764862,
0.5074191093444824,
0.3785317838191986,
0.9438579678535461,
-0.17412619292736053,
0.2758261561393738,
-0.5319868326187134,
-0.06906473636627197,
-0.11734979599714279,
-0.9396276473999023,
-0.8084032535552979,
-0.6046562194824219,
-0.2915274202823639,
-0.23724952340126038,
0.18879516422748566,
1.1131693124771118,
0.9684021472930908,
-0.6117058992385864,
-0.3905908167362213,
-0.5371411442756653,
0.4238310754299164,
-0.4360886514186859,
-0.22128504514694214,
0.13797158002853394,
-0.3727778196334839,
-0.7216945290565491,
1.0595788955688477,
0.19246631860733032,
0.06191104277968407,
-0.35544613003730774,
-0.4521957337856293,
-0.20665393769741058,
-0.15756572782993317,
0.6678680181503296,
0.4471096694469452,
-0.9143166542053223,
-0.33514484763145447,
-0.08055485785007477,
0.1475299894809723,
-0.04932579770684242,
1.1230871677398682,
-0.9933722019195557,
0.2524610161781311,
0.27507543563842773,
0.49141716957092285,
0.4505034387111664,
-0.14202672243118286,
0.7641136050224304,
-0.8898331522941589,
0.4364778697490692,
0.13278470933437347,
0.5541536808013916,
-0.15354323387145996,
-0.37520790100097656,
0.4622722566127777,
0.23325814306735992,
-0.19643451273441315,
-0.5436175465583801,
0.47436726093292236,
-0.918460488319397,
-0.4335922300815582,
1.3111680746078491,
-0.25413262844085693,
-0.14797905087471008,
-0.16918238997459412,
-0.33884385228157043,
0.2910699248313904,
-0.2281138151884079,
0.8713294267654419,
0.46952110528945923,
-0.3717218339443207,
-0.2920542061328888,
-0.3725646734237671,
0.2768293619155884,
0.3846210241317749,
-0.6721445322036743,
0.11475595831871033,
0.7803246378898621,
0.045307669788599014,
0.24994021654129028,
0.34028390049934387,
0.041739217936992645,
0.28100645542144775,
-0.15829886496067047,
0.13358300924301147,
-0.1719026416540146,
-0.6932112574577332,
-0.474317729473114,
0.0683637335896492,
-0.11198592185974121,
-0.11904441565275192
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17104v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17104v2
|
Attribute First, then Generate: Locally-attributable Grounded Text Generation
| 2024-03-25T18:41:47 | 2024-04-01T17:57:40 |
Aviv Slobodkin, Eran Hirsch, Arie Cattan, Tal Schuster, Ido Dagan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent efforts to address hallucinations in Large Language Models (LLMs) have
focused on attributed text generation, which supplements generated texts with
citations of supporting sources for post-generation fact-checking and
corrections. Yet, these citations often point to entire documents or
paragraphs, burdening users with extensive verification work. In this paper, we
introduce a locally-attributable text generation approach, prioritizing concise
attributions. Our method, named ``Attribute First, then Generate'', breaks down
the conventional end-to-end generation process into three intuitive steps:
content selection, sentence planning, and sequential sentence generation. By
initially identifying relevant source segments (``select first'') and then
conditioning the generation process on them (``then generate''), we ensure
these segments also act as the output's fine-grained attributions (``select''
becomes ``attribute''). Tested on Multi-document Summarization and Long-form
Question-answering, our method not only yields more concise citations than the
baselines but also maintains - and in some cases enhances - both generation
quality and attribution accuracy. Furthermore, it significantly reduces the
time required for fact verification by human assessors.
|
[
-0.22592078149318695,
-0.718863308429718,
0.9286043047904968,
0.08717574924230576,
-0.23684296011924744,
-0.015465022064745426,
-0.1468576043844223,
-0.24943558871746063,
0.15538093447685242,
0.6342615485191345,
-0.6710753440856934,
-0.13045664131641388,
-0.21148036420345306,
0.15808497369289398,
-0.3444616198539734,
1.1558235883712769,
0.011547057889401913,
-0.5799703598022461,
-0.6881491541862488,
0.03880498185753822,
-0.1530705690383911,
-0.673068106174469,
-0.7403303384780884,
-0.4486302435398102,
0.799895167350769,
0.6853334903717041,
0.6642346382141113,
0.5617293119430542,
0.4068053066730499,
0.32472071051597595,
0.07927887886762619,
0.5244060754776001,
-0.3961612284183502,
0.35061129927635193,
-0.11572697013616562,
-0.2296803593635559,
-0.3431163430213928,
-0.07941598445177078,
0.5043723583221436,
0.42206916213035583,
0.15120266377925873,
0.40554484724998474,
-0.04404236003756523,
0.44952791929244995,
-0.7781578302383423,
-0.3508418798446655,
-0.9504904747009277,
-0.28558865189552307,
-0.31239911913871765,
-0.5258291959762573,
-0.5359847545623779,
-0.7346516251564026,
-0.051713477820158005,
-0.3071330189704895,
0.47682520747184753,
0.09748609364032745,
0.8630804419517517,
0.16761788725852966,
-0.5666745901107788,
-0.15371035039424896,
-0.34742000699043274,
0.7989267706871033,
-0.47361916303634644,
0.05164973810315132,
0.375560462474823,
-0.0892055556178093,
-0.16959738731384277,
-0.9390487670898438,
-0.5857256650924683,
-0.3412169814109802,
-0.45330822467803955,
-0.13996213674545288,
-0.04351420700550079,
-0.32984113693237305,
0.2403165102005005,
0.32710033655166626,
-0.3857659697532654,
-0.09008728712797165,
-0.25879696011543274,
-0.3928759694099426,
0.7409847974777222,
0.046984873712062836,
-0.1881357878446579,
-0.4884309768676758,
-0.2088766098022461,
-0.12391933798789978,
-1.2338026762008667,
-0.14718277752399445,
0.27544859051704407,
0.3120631277561188,
0.3098495900630951,
0.7948150038719177,
-0.26805731654167175,
0.3114236891269684,
0.2990436255931854,
-0.2237882912158966,
0.09993810206651688,
-0.6127254366874695,
-0.01298378687351942,
0.48347237706184387,
0.896757960319519,
0.19075600802898407,
0.09698878228664398,
-0.18169784545898438,
-0.15027764439582825,
-0.0861876904964447,
0.3949528634548187,
-0.9999043941497803,
-0.21044179797172546,
0.1873490959405899,
-0.2783571481704712,
-0.802092969417572,
-0.1157427653670311,
-0.2335992008447647,
-0.5649189352989197,
-0.4437377452850342,
0.1347348541021347,
-0.3189167082309723,
-0.03823237493634224,
-0.49371102452278137,
0.4525505304336548,
0.06691340357065201,
0.04168808460235596,
-0.561880350112915,
-0.03770855814218521,
0.4024043083190918,
0.8232430219650269,
-0.26687201857566833,
-0.22069141268730164,
-0.9145838618278503,
0.40287211537361145,
-0.2364981770515442,
1.0416582822799683,
-0.15514162182807922,
-0.0685916543006897,
0.11846699565649033,
-0.3613067865371704,
0.6204157471656799,
-0.4431030750274658,
0.644226610660553,
-0.32191693782806396,
0.2348448485136032,
-0.44786718487739563,
-0.27134737372398376,
0.3079098165035248,
0.01845550164580345,
-0.48762935400009155,
1.3182412385940552,
0.12531396746635437,
-0.9517797827720642,
0.5883411169052124,
-0.33624550700187683,
-0.9341256618499756,
-0.11583752185106277,
-0.22904908657073975,
-0.5744653940200806,
0.40786653757095337,
0.2749047875404358,
0.7703505754470825,
-0.4482899606227875,
0.6215015053749084,
0.07294384390115738,
0.368574857711792,
0.31198373436927795,
-0.19860301911830902,
0.4138118028640747,
0.3606868088245392,
-0.27196139097213745,
0.4060649573802948,
-1.213407278060913,
0.1734345555305481,
0.1873219907283783,
-0.20894771814346313,
-0.3325018286705017,
0.3592328131198883,
0.05089147016406059,
0.12809818983078003,
0.1041022390127182,
-0.3909786641597748,
-0.06726552546024323,
-0.24190768599510193,
0.3638869822025299,
0.8261362314224243,
0.3212197721004486,
0.5536277294158936,
-0.26014503836631775,
0.14145943522453308,
0.00595400296151638,
-0.2675442099571228,
-0.4928779602050781,
-0.051235396414995193,
-0.8356029987335205,
-0.2371637225151062,
-0.22484327852725983,
0.33492398262023926,
-0.8107411861419678,
0.675926923751831,
-0.467217355966568,
-0.6402407288551331,
-0.15244132280349731,
0.040825001895427704,
0.4437483251094818,
0.613060712814331,
0.19522413611412048,
0.03400561958551407,
-0.5583669543266296,
-0.8465520739555359,
-0.20964083075523376,
-0.43906235694885254,
-0.2757467031478882,
0.08092042058706284,
0.41059988737106323,
0.019832972437143326,
1.1958495378494263,
-0.8933932781219482,
-0.2322743535041809,
-0.3053971529006958,
0.6083667278289795,
-0.147841215133667,
0.4796237349510193,
0.43363258242607117,
-0.5793388485908508,
-0.3462853729724884,
-0.0885467380285263,
-0.5571678280830383,
-0.5502036809921265,
-0.5183411240577698,
-0.42245686054229736,
0.22006458044052124,
0.5727713108062744,
-0.6850209832191467,
0.04188920557498932,
-0.03991086408495903,
-0.41989460587501526,
0.3416489362716675,
-0.028187641873955727,
0.1249532476067543,
-1.2532767057418823,
0.12752148509025574,
-0.30609241127967834,
-0.5000472664833069,
-0.4339900016784668,
0.2054433822631836,
-0.13960209488868713,
-0.16761556267738342,
-0.2929171919822693,
0.4095337688922882,
-0.625140368938446,
0.03364824131131172,
-0.20670682191848755,
0.1903068572282791,
0.16776993870735168,
0.2532251477241516,
-0.006966497749090195,
0.8430358171463013,
0.21720388531684875,
-0.674572765827179,
0.22202907502651215,
0.2257695198059082,
-0.41147005558013916,
0.6359496116638184,
-0.4688229262828827,
0.27886655926704407,
-0.19660431146621704,
0.10859455913305283,
-0.7833731174468994,
-0.3448638916015625,
-0.15584270656108856,
-0.3887116312980652,
0.2112715095281601,
0.471813440322876,
-0.6267514824867249,
-0.12531763315200806,
-0.4559466242790222,
0.3564450740814209,
0.28840145468711853,
-0.46265479922294617,
0.6557437777519226,
0.2728360891342163,
-0.39330893754959106,
0.004729387816041708,
-0.5134283900260925,
0.016041403636336327,
-0.20021821558475494,
-0.7276275753974915,
0.44309109449386597,
0.05478082597255707,
-0.32072585821151733,
-0.19776733219623566,
0.028488777577877045,
-0.005835911259055138,
0.25702476501464844,
0.041663073003292084,
-0.1088833138346672,
-0.3037589490413666,
-0.07118771970272064,
0.12978863716125488,
-0.09639807790517807,
0.07811568677425385,
0.005549700930714607,
0.3119756877422333,
0.19344186782836914,
-0.21579904854297638,
-0.05855005234479904,
0.6696174740791321,
0.4540344774723053,
-0.46738943457603455,
0.5878164172172546,
0.4387173354625702,
-0.19530555605888367,
-0.16309377551078796,
-0.5861710906028748,
-0.4458129405975342,
-0.4577532410621643,
0.3412654399871826,
-0.37702828645706177,
-0.6684135794639587,
0.5520118474960327,
0.07368161529302597,
0.30886057019233704,
0.4678935110569,
0.7486992478370667,
0.09592834115028381,
0.6762558221817017,
0.5674440264701843,
0.005823231767863035,
0.4520024061203003,
0.22243069112300873,
0.4946646988391876,
-0.3943271338939667,
-0.11694391071796417,
-0.6558896899223328,
0.0017288062954321504,
-0.2647296190261841,
-0.3584720194339752,
0.27936863899230957,
0.025266317650675774,
-0.2939629852771759,
0.2044062465429306,
-0.5053302049636841,
0.5268450975418091,
0.6050974130630493,
0.08096472173929214,
0.25765883922576904,
0.34247076511383057,
0.07346777617931366,
-0.3271244764328003,
-0.4321441650390625,
-0.5429218411445618,
1.0474642515182495,
-0.05399330332875252,
0.5825327634811401,
0.190766841173172,
0.8595086336135864,
0.28641587495803833,
0.7280197143554688,
-0.4936176538467407,
0.6099281311035156,
0.18730008602142334,
-0.3405165374279022,
-0.10201936960220337,
-0.359041303396225,
-0.6477615833282471,
0.07150808721780777,
-0.3383967876434326,
-0.6865339875221252,
-0.1940172165632248,
0.240846186876297,
-0.5443377494812012,
-0.04830522835254669,
-0.576030969619751,
0.5403410792350769,
-0.1716182380914688,
-0.776624321937561,
-0.0029839256312698126,
-0.5175645351409912,
0.5527197122573853,
-0.38909730315208435,
0.1448541134595871,
0.1325163096189499,
0.2550542950630188,
0.39945587515830994,
-0.43612000346183777,
0.46061962842941284,
0.02371239848434925,
-0.3815690875053406,
0.5225479602813721,
0.2736970782279968,
0.8590309619903564,
0.09912141412496567,
-0.07613024115562439,
-0.37775948643684387,
-0.5596780180931091,
0.06823956221342087,
-0.516937255859375,
0.6705895066261292,
-0.44051793217658997,
-0.5307918787002563,
-0.4332062602043152,
-0.3181930482387543,
-0.017467031255364418,
0.29119938611984253,
0.6046857833862305,
0.551977276802063,
-0.09056219458580017,
0.3931230306625366,
0.6958870887756348,
-0.15113487839698792,
0.1973029375076294,
0.2702535390853882,
-0.21979402005672455,
-0.6699162721633911,
0.9654038548469543,
-0.06246862933039665,
0.3575999140739441,
0.33050426840782166,
0.06912145018577576,
-0.2532977759838104,
-0.39044055342674255,
-0.06929254531860352,
0.06857439875602722,
-0.7709105610847473,
-0.6182119250297546,
-0.737578272819519,
-0.18149840831756592,
-0.5507405996322632,
-0.6587498188018799,
-0.3897550702095032,
-0.29126715660095215,
-0.3676583468914032,
-0.22956719994544983,
0.3608010709285736,
0.43270087242126465,
0.05130508542060852,
0.49915575981140137,
-0.5464868545532227,
0.6839901208877563,
0.12318277359008789,
-0.14549219608306885,
-0.12512820959091187,
-0.3964223861694336,
-0.16085372865200043,
-0.2380010038614273,
-0.6486694812774658,
-0.8201107382774353,
0.09422582387924194,
0.4706979990005493,
0.4089990556240082,
0.42361268401145935,
0.34587353467941284,
0.7249723076820374,
-0.7250878214836121,
0.9655212163925171,
0.20502430200576782,
-0.8170474767684937,
0.8177489042282104,
-0.13588596880435944,
0.06664777547121048,
0.7131229639053345,
0.004161877557635307,
0.06499278545379639,
-0.8915832042694092,
-0.6752233505249023,
-1.3453009128570557,
0.6435117721557617,
0.6533410549163818,
0.15536034107208252,
-0.19863565266132355,
0.4427875280380249,
-0.00987793318927288,
0.31706514954566956,
-0.9242053627967834,
-0.2890188694000244,
-0.13632383942604065,
-0.21718177199363708,
-0.10267050564289093,
-0.5766792297363281,
-0.07956745475530624,
-0.22289912402629852,
0.7798713445663452,
-0.3641199469566345,
0.24061749875545502,
0.4084775447845459,
-0.35597217082977295,
-0.16136415302753448,
0.2608804404735565,
0.742850661277771,
0.6808330416679382,
-0.0610615573823452,
0.46830886602401733,
-0.053391240537166595,
-0.1904543936252594,
0.2502022087574005,
-0.17859585583209991,
-0.5844355225563049,
0.16046899557113647,
0.5376338958740234,
0.6537209153175354,
0.28907686471939087,
-0.2724047005176544,
0.4718468189239502,
0.32166048884391785,
-0.1295301467180252,
-0.29052573442459106,
-0.05550907179713249,
-0.3203521966934204,
0.1395990550518036,
0.5733317136764526,
-0.09282360970973969,
0.0013965561520308256,
-0.5735920667648315,
0.46975719928741455,
0.38179993629455566,
0.31908440589904785,
-0.18148362636566162,
0.9214761853218079,
0.21062903106212616,
0.1553349643945694,
0.36756742000579834,
-0.19849200546741486,
-0.5220227837562561,
0.2472233921289444,
0.6771801114082336,
1.19770348072052,
-0.0344785675406456,
0.3149169087409973,
0.704078733921051,
0.3234449326992035,
0.0547739677131176,
0.13021433353424072,
-0.14955969154834747,
-0.5652890801429749,
-0.46933138370513916,
-0.7716894149780273,
-0.0671013668179512,
0.1651897132396698,
-0.47521737217903137,
0.34700149297714233,
-0.3151629865169525,
-0.19005145132541656,
0.12208956480026245,
0.010776515118777752,
-0.2527088522911072,
0.22004854679107666,
0.26105326414108276,
0.6056501269340515,
-0.8370754718780518,
0.6739643812179565,
0.6377807855606079,
-0.5900631546974182,
-0.8029714226722717,
0.1825011968612671,
-0.16842792928218842,
-0.41530928015708923,
0.5541292428970337,
0.1696130633354187,
-0.22541020810604095,
0.23943480849266052,
-0.7158065438270569,
-0.9829309582710266,
1.1234633922576904,
0.5850985646247864,
0.02804276905953884,
0.05934758484363556,
0.014102564193308353,
0.3256685137748718,
-0.4087955057621002,
0.22236773371696472,
0.48478302359580994,
0.3725530803203583,
0.35517457127571106,
-0.3727757930755615,
0.5333099365234375,
-0.03048044629395008,
0.029471194371581078,
0.07113895565271378,
-0.3874255418777466,
0.8623130321502686,
-0.35686439275741577,
-0.3213699162006378,
0.027171030640602112,
1.2236652374267578,
0.548822283744812,
-0.026943763718008995,
0.33298853039741516,
0.2506592869758606,
0.9684896469116211,
-0.0712692141532898,
0.9695634841918945,
-0.1908724159002304,
-0.046833790838718414,
1.3726965188980103,
-0.3864750266075134,
0.7702414989471436,
0.7891453504562378,
-0.09758037328720093,
0.5792290568351746,
0.5060675740242004,
0.05760436877608299,
0.8343180418014526,
0.2607344388961792,
-0.29245150089263916,
-0.2788574695587158,
-0.35539379715919495,
-0.376465767621994,
0.15696847438812256,
-0.23717504739761353,
-0.389630526304245,
-0.294767290353775,
-0.13558417558670044,
0.3280412554740906,
0.2523522675037384,
-0.2364371418952942,
0.8796380758285522,
-0.05413893237709999,
-1.0522193908691406,
0.505760133266449,
0.1125866174697876,
0.4041232168674469,
-0.7156664133071899,
0.11962419748306274,
-0.5241689682006836,
0.2393939048051834,
-0.4205358624458313,
-0.7142765522003174,
0.3729707896709442,
0.3937125504016876,
-0.5421705842018127,
-0.6506602168083191,
0.8811479210853577,
-0.5367802381515503,
-0.643061101436615,
-0.3153690695762634,
0.17843474447727203,
0.04421890899538994,
-0.41329291462898254,
-0.03172293305397034,
-0.1702834516763687,
0.1201469749212265,
-0.6746960878372192,
0.15949982404708862,
0.7057071328163147,
-0.37539103627204895,
0.45886027812957764,
0.879428505897522,
0.12884050607681274,
0.14679352939128876,
-0.04232652485370636,
1.040487289428711,
-0.4617851972579956,
-0.5267481803894043,
-0.9408536553382874,
0.9281296730041504,
-0.2184349149465561,
-0.23984180390834808,
0.6509330868721008,
0.708088219165802,
0.5919556617736816,
0.10480381548404694,
0.6878697872161865,
-0.4599978029727936,
0.2623627185821533,
-0.7034375071525574,
0.7881990075111389,
-0.7123497128486633,
0.017013808712363243,
-0.4006158113479614,
-1.011333703994751,
-0.46328988671302795,
0.8617122769355774,
0.11551032960414886,
-0.3277439773082733,
0.9527813792228699,
0.7695605158805847,
0.03588666021823883,
-0.42900609970092773,
-0.05388529971241951,
0.1844826340675354,
0.4876336455345154,
0.39456748962402344,
0.6336315870285034,
-0.34264224767684937,
0.4020936191082001,
-0.18451076745986938,
0.03683719411492348,
0.05881502851843834,
-1.3497977256774902,
-0.7496525645256042,
-0.5120757818222046,
-0.4726106524467468,
-0.4400234818458557,
-0.6222707033157349,
0.8983044028282166,
0.34689584374427795,
-0.8270516991615295,
0.1987263411283493,
-0.23000706732273102,
0.26938188076019287,
0.1104298084974289,
-0.1939021646976471,
0.3594188094139099,
-0.5291693210601807,
-0.27935972809791565,
0.1726580411195755,
-0.08409150689840317,
-0.14966976642608643,
-0.35207420587539673,
-0.12976858019828796,
-0.08119990676641464,
0.08207020163536072,
0.9142248630523682,
-0.12397430092096329,
-0.6985829472541809,
-0.4715386629104614,
-0.14349955320358276,
-0.37198108434677124,
0.07373125106096268,
1.1799323558807373,
-0.8903752565383911,
0.054430801421403885,
0.394832968711853,
0.5129348039627075,
0.14965613186359406,
0.1326412707567215,
0.7157293558120728,
-1.2745180130004883,
0.18303588032722473,
0.07372542470693588,
0.07926109433174133,
0.4730692207813263,
-0.5432036519050598,
0.37847331166267395,
0.10345454514026642,
-0.49669936299324036,
-1.1874011754989624,
0.3036966919898987,
-0.7702013254165649,
0.05446949601173401,
1.2031692266464233,
-0.11016347259283066,
-0.00898547563701868,
0.20567984879016876,
-0.36842775344848633,
0.3687921464443207,
-0.22882413864135742,
0.5937881469726562,
0.5615524649620056,
0.1740831881761551,
-0.1791565865278244,
-0.15274035930633545,
0.7685896158218384,
0.31456881761550903,
-1.0335208177566528,
0.528382420539856,
0.901271641254425,
-0.08742844313383102,
0.4069758653640747,
0.8641273975372314,
0.20793551206588745,
-0.06523388624191284,
-0.083048976957798,
0.09085704386234283,
-0.13288727402687073,
-0.4307591915130615,
0.26358217000961304,
0.30674174427986145,
0.13948464393615723,
0.21812106668949127
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19710v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19710v1
|
STRUM-LLM: Attributed and Structured Contrastive Summarization
| 2024-03-25T18:32:44 | 2024-03-25T18:32:44 |
Beliz Gunel, James B. Wendt, Jing Xie, Yichao Zhou, Nguyen Vo, Zachary Fisher, Sandeep Tata
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Users often struggle with decision-making between two options (A vs B), as it
usually requires time-consuming research across multiple web pages. We propose
STRUM-LLM that addresses this challenge by generating attributed, structured,
and helpful contrastive summaries that highlight key differences between the
two options. STRUM-LLM identifies helpful contrast: the specific attributes
along which the two options differ significantly and which are most likely to
influence the user's decision. Our technique is domain-agnostic, and does not
require any human-labeled data or fixed attribute list as supervision.
STRUM-LLM attributes all extractions back to the input sources along with
textual evidence, and it does not have a limit on the length of input sources
that it can process. STRUM-LLM Distilled has 100x more throughput than the
models with comparable performance while being 10x smaller. In this paper, we
provide extensive evaluations for our method and lay out future directions for
our currently deployed system.
|
[
-0.17432630062103271,
-0.5247266888618469,
0.5202277898788452,
0.8016549348831177,
-0.5461830496788025,
0.32084617018699646,
-0.1647108942270279,
-0.6182535886764526,
0.4532390832901001,
0.06190694496035576,
-0.6339442133903503,
-0.5647082924842834,
-0.532331645488739,
0.32480090856552124,
-0.3203398883342743,
1.282467246055603,
-0.20402757823467255,
0.030603958293795586,
-0.49890661239624023,
-0.11875541508197784,
-0.2782681882381439,
-0.13045884668827057,
-0.8082471489906311,
-0.6246291399002075,
0.7224820256233215,
0.5424190759658813,
0.6197224855422974,
0.6489033699035645,
0.8880188465118408,
0.29883435368537903,
-0.1937655806541443,
0.2674185335636139,
-0.56989586353302,
0.36263829469680786,
-0.4690825641155243,
-0.3774718642234802,
-0.7648628354072571,
0.2777184844017029,
0.22003862261772156,
0.4887118935585022,
-0.3696807324886322,
0.5896292328834534,
0.2995966076850891,
0.515350341796875,
-0.5355956554412842,
-0.12469077110290527,
-0.5197420716285706,
0.05574439465999603,
-0.18010669946670532,
-0.2945058345794678,
-0.315860778093338,
-0.38611456751823425,
-0.023491423577070236,
-0.7741518616676331,
0.2303933948278427,
0.12153211236000061,
0.710128903388977,
0.33373382687568665,
-0.5281073451042175,
-0.39119651913642883,
-0.7217000126838684,
0.864759087562561,
-0.8249058127403259,
-0.08042916655540466,
0.3649832010269165,
0.42079001665115356,
0.15328598022460938,
-0.9170077443122864,
-0.33585262298583984,
-0.21538260579109192,
-0.5051184892654419,
0.6498071551322937,
-0.0386444553732872,
-0.0754198431968689,
0.12791703641414642,
0.6084046363830566,
-0.5911896228790283,
0.4230671525001526,
-0.45883727073669434,
0.12700031697750092,
0.9502701759338379,
0.4521794617176056,
-0.024892184883356094,
-0.23534367978572845,
-0.4896683990955353,
0.23408500850200653,
-0.656134307384491,
-0.14603465795516968,
0.38463759422302246,
0.2713944613933563,
-0.32342609763145447,
0.5714848041534424,
-0.22579054534435272,
0.5085684061050415,
0.16287434101104736,
-0.6984208226203918,
0.12999847531318665,
-0.4511885344982147,
-0.32679110765457153,
-0.03258566930890083,
0.5907784700393677,
0.9998181462287903,
-0.2134188860654831,
-0.08782178908586502,
-0.12627486884593964,
0.002134507056325674,
0.09176196157932281,
-0.8525386452674866,
-0.3627670407295227,
0.3032895624637604,
-0.7963318824768066,
-0.45909395813941956,
0.023123614490032196,
-0.7157058119773865,
-0.6310057044029236,
-0.4408247470855713,
0.20631423592567444,
-0.1336687207221985,
-0.2025044858455658,
-0.30619731545448303,
-0.7459620237350464,
0.11131704598665237,
0.7276248335838318,
-0.5732951164245605,
0.42987850308418274,
0.5316590666770935,
1.0351219177246094,
-0.7186698913574219,
-0.02666100114583969,
-0.35952162742614746,
0.316036194562912,
0.19774428009986877,
0.9137095212936401,
-0.5446873903274536,
-0.5229602456092834,
-0.193899467587471,
-0.3432454466819763,
0.2803366184234619,
-0.7107834815979004,
0.2791782021522522,
-0.29426735639572144,
0.09791963547468185,
-0.11790450662374496,
-0.4142782688140869,
-0.07431022822856903,
0.2551049292087555,
-0.8653954267501831,
1.1407884359359741,
0.15378375351428986,
-0.7828357219696045,
0.31595128774642944,
-0.32921913266181946,
-0.7909682393074036,
0.01739225536584854,
-0.08357660472393036,
-0.6172835826873779,
0.3211295008659363,
-0.10416702181100845,
0.09878389537334442,
-0.5389084815979004,
0.06504582613706589,
-0.32963424921035767,
-0.28349927067756653,
0.23009318113327026,
0.12906202673912048,
0.7380228638648987,
0.4495379328727722,
-0.1993270218372345,
0.18296046555042267,
-0.924500048160553,
-0.18166764080524445,
0.08401509374380112,
-0.4447181522846222,
-0.4167643189430237,
0.21610839664936066,
-0.053270015865564346,
0.21469402313232422,
0.24565204977989197,
-0.08485724776983261,
0.13608986139297485,
-0.11885268241167068,
0.4055028259754181,
0.647033154964447,
-0.14233748614788055,
0.48772212862968445,
-0.5158793330192566,
0.6245609521865845,
0.0807248055934906,
-0.03083871118724346,
-0.05644528567790985,
-0.020869309082627296,
-0.7022879123687744,
-0.47857293486595154,
0.3153551518917084,
0.5894961357116699,
-0.8053402900695801,
-0.032185375690460205,
0.02501719631254673,
-0.5239800214767456,
-0.5500966310501099,
0.2173004001379013,
0.5534141659736633,
0.8435978889465332,
0.674453616142273,
-0.21798977255821228,
-0.7426164150238037,
-1.1093584299087524,
-0.3955690562725067,
-0.1435048133134842,
-0.4851842224597931,
0.4839314818382263,
0.4130041003227234,
0.10718921571969986,
0.8664729595184326,
-0.974369466304779,
-0.34872081875801086,
-0.6544772386550903,
0.4457802176475525,
0.08418795466423035,
0.2074824720621109,
0.3535820245742798,
-0.9333676695823669,
-0.7177245020866394,
-0.18361130356788635,
-0.6721311807632446,
-0.5411790013313293,
-0.1520911455154419,
0.08446561545133591,
-0.04208837449550629,
0.31974342465400696,
-0.5567226409912109,
0.5646030306816101,
0.22021563351154327,
0.03727949038147926,
0.6903548240661621,
-0.08339382708072662,
0.24457570910453796,
-1.20158851146698,
0.2466038465499878,
0.14350609481334686,
-0.22532862424850464,
-0.48063966631889343,
0.08711203932762146,
-0.0748521164059639,
0.2799822688102722,
-0.3753192722797394,
0.12376554310321808,
-0.4767827093601227,
-0.19186356663703918,
-0.13261139392852783,
0.531425952911377,
0.18308095633983612,
0.29359039664268494,
0.15148046612739563,
0.6798169612884521,
-0.03520360589027405,
-0.7203308343887329,
0.4750917851924896,
0.35946986079216003,
-0.054473668336868286,
0.850929856300354,
-0.8281269073486328,
0.03417043387889862,
0.03005269728600979,
0.3287787437438965,
-1.1167181730270386,
-0.11728934943675995,
0.11593833565711975,
-0.2660420536994934,
0.13708579540252686,
-0.02526254951953888,
-0.1552494764328003,
-0.2821040153503418,
-0.9292392134666443,
0.42080333828926086,
0.2632722556591034,
-0.3117135465145111,
0.6630458235740662,
0.4521181285381317,
-0.6734668612480164,
-0.29139673709869385,
-0.7665388584136963,
0.11771601438522339,
-0.6329270601272583,
-0.5028432607650757,
0.8049258589744568,
-0.15041837096214294,
-0.7611711025238037,
-0.1432805359363556,
-0.33409199118614197,
-0.19562353193759918,
0.3009447753429413,
0.2923947870731354,
0.34517839550971985,
-0.06873772293329239,
0.04132169485092163,
0.03787626326084137,
-0.11764911562204361,
-0.2725096642971039,
0.1524091213941574,
0.08150463551282883,
0.2753867208957672,
0.11403229087591171,
-0.2494448721408844,
0.6561198234558105,
-0.1803441047668457,
-0.09445012360811234,
0.22490748763084412,
0.09635584056377411,
0.027736399322748184,
-0.4113693833351135,
-0.446850448846817,
-0.023226698860526085,
-0.4400567412376404,
0.1646421253681183,
-0.14489738643169403,
-0.6579355001449585,
0.5800626873970032,
-0.2793847918510437,
0.24093854427337646,
0.42528489232063293,
0.3635022044181824,
-0.7282366156578064,
0.7119311690330505,
0.5347090363502502,
0.1239793598651886,
0.4788321554660797,
0.17509111762046814,
-0.12007805705070496,
-0.5735431909561157,
-0.1820809692144394,
-0.6644037365913391,
-0.8863363862037659,
-0.3773566484451294,
-0.07455432415008545,
0.266675740480423,
0.06892988085746765,
0.01467884797602892,
0.26806774735450745,
-0.4252842366695404,
0.5756581425666809,
0.6428388357162476,
0.24958568811416626,
0.6219062805175781,
-0.22456243634223938,
0.18717364966869354,
-0.0601845383644104,
-0.31937476992607117,
-0.3926093280315399,
0.9248223900794983,
-0.14793692529201508,
0.8007976412773132,
0.2991819381713867,
0.7602245211601257,
0.5048215985298157,
0.5524543523788452,
-0.7578287720680237,
0.578301727771759,
-0.22111032903194427,
-0.3257189989089966,
-0.1748313456773758,
-0.5002111196517944,
-0.7598032355308533,
0.4244154393672943,
-0.34817174077033997,
-0.35551056265830994,
-0.24255196750164032,
0.4751999080181122,
-0.454988569021225,
-0.05483265221118927,
-0.5287066698074341,
0.4182053506374359,
-0.2427331954240799,
-0.5675898194313049,
-0.2924017906188965,
-1.00896155834198,
0.4631883502006531,
0.24699369072914124,
0.18345732986927032,
0.0551847480237484,
-0.1134440079331398,
0.6649234890937805,
-0.482543021440506,
0.6283256411552429,
-0.02023864910006523,
0.000003633455889939796,
0.14619514346122742,
-0.00975794717669487,
0.5159662365913391,
-0.09756477177143097,
-0.07701073586940765,
-0.13828764855861664,
-0.3842483460903168,
-0.001436847378499806,
-0.4803558886051178,
0.462748259305954,
-0.31339147686958313,
-0.8158454895019531,
-0.41054192185401917,
-0.5734079480171204,
-0.09586421400308609,
0.06879261136054993,
0.2221328318119049,
0.1588730812072754,
-0.364984393119812,
0.09935487806797028,
0.3662239909172058,
-0.06330371648073196,
0.691484808921814,
0.6777671575546265,
-0.12817953526973724,
-0.5736173987388611,
0.6766672730445862,
0.12472031265497208,
0.16278290748596191,
0.45140349864959717,
0.20475170016288757,
-0.2992789149284363,
-0.9109396934509277,
-0.28669416904449463,
0.19120344519615173,
-0.44571030139923096,
-0.7022253274917603,
-0.12482870370149612,
0.0335039347410202,
-0.32965874671936035,
-0.3440530300140381,
0.03342204913496971,
-0.8454765677452087,
-0.34579622745513916,
-0.6954861879348755,
0.2513653039932251,
0.7001324892044067,
-0.1705504059791565,
0.5825517773628235,
-0.5561901330947876,
0.709287703037262,
0.22657042741775513,
0.08795354515314102,
-0.038398802280426025,
-0.4780488610267639,
-0.22939330339431763,
-0.11669928580522537,
-0.6135271191596985,
-0.8667808175086975,
0.34349045157432556,
0.32117852568626404,
0.4366934597492218,
0.45686039328575134,
0.33518749475479126,
1.2084910869598389,
-0.41901886463165283,
0.8523730635643005,
0.48366138339042664,
-0.816689133644104,
0.6614497900009155,
-0.010536921210587025,
-0.03546873852610588,
0.9194750189781189,
0.4220300018787384,
-0.19168679416179657,
-0.6247420310974121,
-0.38942116498947144,
-1.1492544412612915,
0.7550050020217896,
0.12133686989545822,
-0.3619166314601898,
0.24982205033302307,
0.16453321278095245,
0.371919184923172,
0.4822887182235718,
-0.781664252281189,
-0.400393009185791,
-0.2844659686088562,
-0.27361711859703064,
-0.16411077976226807,
-0.34990227222442627,
-0.31676873564720154,
-0.21417587995529175,
0.4146362245082855,
0.08577403426170349,
-0.37576454877853394,
0.22033803164958954,
-0.56983882188797,
0.19968579709529877,
0.25805383920669556,
0.6082767248153687,
1.004497766494751,
-0.19575545191764832,
0.76964271068573,
0.41661614179611206,
-0.22162626683712006,
-0.06158621609210968,
0.20609404146671295,
-0.37150588631629944,
-0.041420768946409225,
0.5562586784362793,
0.39844396710395813,
0.5384135246276855,
-0.38445141911506653,
0.43178266286849976,
0.1728287786245346,
-0.390886515378952,
-0.18289987742900848,
-0.05521202087402344,
0.4085538387298584,
0.3682909607887268,
0.3295767605304718,
-0.38981714844703674,
0.5054564476013184,
-0.44153040647506714,
0.09130997955799103,
0.2394329160451889,
0.0037985118106007576,
-0.31194165349006653,
0.5707424283027649,
0.6304408311843872,
-0.32129350304603577,
0.5192828178405762,
-0.02933146059513092,
-0.2107355296611786,
0.5769578218460083,
0.6986337900161743,
0.7313646078109741,
-0.4315401017665863,
0.3560108244419098,
0.23564252257347107,
0.05739765986800194,
0.02806311473250389,
0.15657207369804382,
-0.3274645209312439,
-0.23618178069591522,
-0.01539948396384716,
-0.49224868416786194,
-0.5064190030097961,
-0.08183535933494568,
-1.0584102869033813,
0.1542077660560608,
-0.36219969391822815,
-0.19199508428573608,
0.20894362032413483,
0.11018305271863937,
-0.25971248745918274,
0.2209262102842331,
-0.2718818187713623,
1.0155091285705566,
-0.7640275359153748,
0.4479096233844757,
0.45612579584121704,
-0.6227792501449585,
-0.3932865560054779,
-0.243924081325531,
0.27308329939842224,
-0.5030212998390198,
0.5665056705474854,
0.07608507573604584,
-0.4712325930595398,
-0.2557629644870758,
-0.56065833568573,
-0.2298310250043869,
1.6545982360839844,
0.3317766487598419,
-0.3543534576892853,
-0.16419710218906403,
0.06777125597000122,
0.45521044731140137,
-0.3670198321342468,
0.3607880473136902,
0.6044421195983887,
0.6010876893997192,
0.39295122027397156,
-0.8394413590431213,
0.08860421180725098,
-0.23196084797382355,
-0.05447360500693321,
0.010872316546738148,
-0.7467540502548218,
0.9989061951637268,
-0.19232752919197083,
-0.604113757610321,
-0.09162656217813492,
0.6960480213165283,
0.31199997663497925,
0.7867096662521362,
0.3576590418815613,
0.5442436337471008,
0.6923738121986389,
0.07382799685001373,
0.6213949918746948,
0.025114115327596664,
0.10364511609077454,
1.6783698797225952,
-0.6480238437652588,
0.8631327152252197,
0.7668040990829468,
-0.3506380617618561,
0.562677264213562,
0.5582960247993469,
-0.11267699301242828,
0.5462613701820374,
0.3305840790271759,
-0.28129488229751587,
-0.2985399067401886,
-0.1796027272939682,
-0.3963366746902466,
0.33236533403396606,
0.045653942972421646,
-0.4619790315628052,
-0.3868732154369354,
-0.6303755044937134,
0.17718438804149628,
0.2934219539165497,
-0.5661295652389526,
1.170298457145691,
0.4299910068511963,
-0.7984765768051147,
-0.04975501447916031,
0.10994552820920944,
0.6331484913825989,
-0.8843715190887451,
-0.1592428833246231,
-0.5895041227340698,
0.031661614775657654,
-0.6864575147628784,
-0.5663688778877258,
0.4792121350765228,
0.25681760907173157,
-0.29751718044281006,
-0.5719104409217834,
0.8149824142456055,
-0.4920130968093872,
-0.25933539867401123,
0.2926371991634369,
0.46299639344215393,
-0.05731065943837166,
0.20302538573741913,
-0.3599780797958374,
-0.06408526748418808,
-0.06133759766817093,
-0.21348276734352112,
0.39497673511505127,
0.16125358641147614,
0.07213159650564194,
0.4782094955444336,
0.395339697599411,
0.11506347358226776,
-0.49803751707077026,
-0.06929357349872589,
0.950770378112793,
-0.879431962966919,
-0.6898999214172363,
-1.1162062883377075,
0.6923415064811707,
-0.6915546655654907,
-0.30728429555892944,
1.146533489227295,
0.9683179259300232,
0.565268337726593,
0.0182794202119112,
0.8139760494232178,
0.04809067025780678,
0.589431643486023,
-0.5154298543930054,
0.4631362855434418,
-0.6584500074386597,
0.32705947756767273,
-0.17953598499298096,
-0.499178946018219,
-0.42582833766937256,
0.6335854530334473,
-0.00018610026745591313,
-0.1901344209909439,
0.8084645867347717,
0.5781946778297424,
0.022411640733480453,
0.061035238206386566,
-0.24424801766872406,
0.15548978745937347,
0.07254840433597565,
0.588316023349762,
0.9176379442214966,
0.09665761142969131,
0.7442344427108765,
0.03246307000517845,
-0.45477551221847534,
-0.41759854555130005,
-1.2023091316223145,
-0.775153636932373,
-0.2762168049812317,
-0.40069663524627686,
-0.18976430594921112,
-0.14469556510448456,
0.7546497583389282,
0.34425270557403564,
-0.681023895740509,
-0.4875514805316925,
0.24842523038387299,
0.521548330783844,
-0.45866310596466064,
-0.16059207916259766,
0.19320999085903168,
-0.1024184450507164,
-0.40290477871894836,
0.3370828330516815,
0.44230419397354126,
-0.03291340544819832,
0.16994652152061462,
-0.03995151072740555,
-0.0511583536863327,
0.16783864796161652,
0.7492072582244873,
0.03803158178925514,
-0.3161468207836151,
-0.13225027918815613,
-0.22153449058532715,
-0.1778651773929596,
0.22269418835639954,
1.0700485706329346,
-0.40459132194519043,
-0.11490418761968613,
0.6475085020065308,
0.17503365874290466,
0.9002484083175659,
0.4760379493236542,
0.6635841727256775,
-0.8723511695861816,
-0.12396827340126038,
0.2297617495059967,
0.22612988948822021,
0.12410607188940048,
-0.014076394028961658,
0.6946792006492615,
0.12105222046375275,
-0.2001192271709442,
-0.8612029552459717,
0.4721081852912903,
-1.1844353675842285,
-0.39863622188568115,
1.1583489179611206,
-0.3183221220970154,
0.23325543105602264,
-0.2062748819589615,
-0.32309532165527344,
0.17545266449451447,
-0.16514433920383453,
1.054333209991455,
0.6511462330818176,
-0.3708772361278534,
0.0648316815495491,
0.1245880052447319,
0.6781933903694153,
0.005721637047827244,
-0.9400861263275146,
0.18233096599578857,
0.8089384436607361,
0.18942098319530487,
-0.03220176696777344,
0.7624520063400269,
0.16672049462795258,
0.11996185779571533,
0.15543417632579803,
-0.22104710340499878,
-0.5270916223526001,
-0.2735139727592468,
-0.1831791251897812,
0.5712685585021973,
-0.09478845447301865,
-0.002026775386184454
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16995v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16995v1
|
Language Rectified Flow: Advancing Diffusion Language Generation with Probabilistic Flows
| 2024-03-25T17:58:22 | 2024-03-25T17:58:22 |
Shujian Zhang, Lemeng Wu, Chengyue Gong, Xingchao Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, stat.ML
|
Recent works have demonstrated success in controlling sentence attributes
($e.g.$, sentiment) and structure ($e.g.$, syntactic structure) based on the
diffusion language model. A key component that drives theimpressive performance
for generating high-quality samples from noise is iteratively denoise for
thousands of steps. While beneficial, the complexity of starting from the noise
and the learning steps has limited its implementation to many NLP real-world
applications. This paper proposes Language Rectified Flow ({\ours}). Our method
is based on the reformulation of the standard probabilistic flow models.
Language rectified flow learns (neural) ordinary differential equation models
to transport between the source distribution and the target distribution, hence
providing a unified and effective solution to generative modeling and domain
transfer. From the source distribution, our language rectified flow yields fast
simulation and effectively decreases the inference time. Experiments on three
challenging fine-grained control tasks and multiple high-quality text editing
show that our method consistently outperforms its baselines. Extensive
experiments and ablation studies demonstrate that our method can be general,
effective, and beneficial for many NLP tasks.
|
[
-0.1046842560172081,
-0.9847503304481506,
0.37088578939437866,
0.18237879872322083,
-0.17828480899333954,
0.1767459660768509,
-0.29013144969940186,
-0.11872381716966629,
0.10676540434360504,
0.818340539932251,
-0.6223495602607727,
-0.4644695222377777,
-0.6191602945327759,
-0.019179796800017357,
-0.825707197189331,
1.0638718605041504,
-0.0019770569633692503,
-0.18246698379516602,
0.030729513615369797,
0.18402616679668427,
-0.13206332921981812,
-0.22440259158611298,
-1.1381317377090454,
-0.62816321849823,
0.49254465103149414,
-0.015094363130629063,
0.6973859667778015,
0.3099531829357147,
0.36102744936943054,
0.34299007058143616,
-0.4083500802516937,
-0.051336392760276794,
-0.3748215436935425,
0.44212520122528076,
-0.11399956047534943,
-0.2326422482728958,
-0.17611537873744965,
-0.14214712381362915,
0.700185239315033,
0.8760044574737549,
-0.7346052527427673,
-0.19193559885025024,
0.1331530064344406,
1.004845142364502,
-0.620658278465271,
0.08722998201847076,
-0.4410589933395386,
0.03032994456589222,
-0.2432422637939453,
-0.06006212532520294,
-0.4065645635128021,
-0.5689702033996582,
-0.036035843193531036,
-0.3380177319049835,
0.4228976368904114,
-0.3997836410999298,
0.5411697626113892,
0.3859235942363739,
-0.11082214117050171,
-0.22795093059539795,
-1.1047917604446411,
0.6110305190086365,
-0.748845100402832,
0.3283389210700989,
0.06811299920082092,
0.2786101996898651,
-0.3608139455318451,
-1.166197657585144,
-0.5610350370407104,
0.05896678939461708,
0.2580414116382599,
0.11321850121021271,
-0.4417365491390228,
-0.038480617105960846,
-0.17391212284564972,
0.23213094472885132,
-0.5069459676742554,
-0.11322148144245148,
-0.4008353650569916,
-0.21592198312282562,
0.7085710763931274,
0.002359265461564064,
0.2206754833459854,
0.2040098011493683,
0.08662261068820953,
-0.0646156296133995,
-0.6792831420898438,
-0.11693572998046875,
0.3813837170600891,
0.34707990288734436,
0.11490204930305481,
0.28293532133102417,
-0.3797057271003723,
0.8144786953926086,
-0.08829045295715332,
-0.19425028562545776,
0.3758043050765991,
-0.08684569597244263,
-0.3137292265892029,
-0.16304436326026917,
0.6197067499160767,
0.007645180448889732,
0.35879048705101013,
-0.1881502866744995,
-0.16577255725860596,
-0.32146692276000977,
0.39411455392837524,
-0.8128390312194824,
-0.487498015165329,
0.37239792943000793,
-0.29803818464279175,
-0.3323071002960205,
-0.33408620953559875,
-0.6295439600944519,
-0.32355526089668274,
-0.22134093940258026,
0.08612961322069168,
-0.530831515789032,
-0.7573246955871582,
0.25718823075294495,
-0.0715998187661171,
-0.16004563868045807,
0.4624021053314209,
-0.6797999143600464,
0.12898948788642883,
0.6185035109519958,
0.8145679831504822,
-0.04912586882710457,
-0.023637915030121803,
-0.5778998136520386,
-0.03273854777216911,
-0.3369848132133484,
0.8944224715232849,
-0.5279226303100586,
-0.11012554913759232,
0.13706856966018677,
-0.25854864716529846,
0.13605758547782898,
-0.7983854413032532,
0.4756396412849426,
-0.5839850902557373,
0.1093640848994255,
0.23309007287025452,
-0.5835974812507629,
-0.2785096764564514,
0.017337286844849586,
-0.6766674518585205,
0.6058600544929504,
0.15764044225215912,
-0.5828555226325989,
0.0688399001955986,
-0.5075164437294006,
-0.5102821588516235,
0.1396772265434265,
0.2815088629722595,
-0.4174495041370392,
0.04155413433909416,
-0.15325725078582764,
0.3572775721549988,
-0.09741062670946121,
0.3578419089317322,
0.07490254193544388,
0.012557726353406906,
0.23055671155452728,
-0.7042726874351501,
0.7462900876998901,
0.5978085994720459,
-0.005351049359887838,
0.09249967336654663,
-0.9515318274497986,
-0.06960476189851761,
0.0020249721128493547,
-0.464100182056427,
-0.10077114403247833,
0.10089660435914993,
-0.005291434470564127,
0.022225020453333855,
-0.15663915872573853,
-0.5230912566184998,
-0.041058558970689774,
-0.6176888346672058,
0.6844668388366699,
0.5134602189064026,
0.26611900329589844,
0.6236507892608643,
-0.05022381618618965,
0.6592304706573486,
0.3077352046966553,
-0.1643596887588501,
0.08990458399057388,
-0.6102339625358582,
-0.5639157891273499,
-0.31824079155921936,
0.3182907700538635,
0.45162233710289,
-0.8367390036582947,
0.2071613073348999,
0.11279361695051193,
-0.3751662075519562,
-0.6767386198043823,
0.36491814255714417,
0.1517082005739212,
0.6333539485931396,
0.30775609612464905,
-0.16035059094429016,
-0.30157190561294556,
-0.5704879760742188,
0.02339167520403862,
-0.25223949551582336,
-0.1751769483089447,
-0.2903194725513458,
0.0501280315220356,
-0.21542802453041077,
0.7763519287109375,
-0.7018413543701172,
-0.11632746458053589,
-0.577379047870636,
0.6571769118309021,
0.012794483453035355,
0.5580214858055115,
0.2819598317146301,
-0.6801613569259644,
-0.29735592007637024,
-0.26722514629364014,
-0.19718101620674133,
-0.5316122174263,
-0.2315928339958191,
-0.2966035306453705,
0.44009363651275635,
0.6921203136444092,
-0.4724322557449341,
0.19087302684783936,
0.8172703981399536,
-0.277744323015213,
0.3485912084579468,
-0.3652513921260834,
-0.0562097541987896,
-1.1297966241836548,
-0.007233981508761644,
0.09493028372526169,
-0.38169100880622864,
-0.7595933079719543,
0.10994124412536621,
-0.23436301946640015,
-0.13076479732990265,
-0.5470793843269348,
0.33172860741615295,
-0.3384295701980591,
0.32519590854644775,
-0.5617533922195435,
0.2234402894973755,
0.0012111944379284978,
0.2744832932949066,
0.20043553411960602,
0.4883980453014374,
0.530963659286499,
-0.8027677536010742,
0.492864727973938,
-0.13512994349002838,
-0.15703855454921722,
0.4750990569591522,
-0.46264585852622986,
-0.12012986093759537,
-0.4577721655368805,
0.21362464129924774,
-1.1313475370407104,
0.1419273316860199,
0.14087501168251038,
-0.2432796061038971,
0.45429250597953796,
-0.12154770642518997,
-0.3537997901439667,
-0.07241346687078476,
0.09650241583585739,
0.1471225768327713,
0.839820921421051,
-0.45777589082717896,
0.4498703181743622,
0.35990792512893677,
-0.39896291494369507,
-0.48219358921051025,
-0.6859188079833984,
0.09493663161993027,
0.004781173542141914,
-0.48887768387794495,
0.36293384432792664,
-0.096938356757164,
-0.3400135040283203,
0.12335454672574997,
0.17177583277225494,
-0.3497415781021118,
0.13998322188854218,
0.04436488822102547,
-0.23903027176856995,
0.028445271775126457,
0.3096427619457245,
0.26751241087913513,
-0.0706687867641449,
-0.09053827077150345,
-0.17510510981082916,
0.6290416717529297,
0.22159190475940704,
-0.11825352907180786,
-0.5271201729774475,
0.3278241753578186,
0.25193318724632263,
-0.1600576490163803,
0.6679016351699829,
0.7998067736625671,
-0.31929701566696167,
-0.4045192301273346,
-0.2024727612733841,
-0.17539438605308533,
-0.42944595217704773,
0.41802534461021423,
-0.3825988173484802,
-0.9872864484786987,
0.3597978353500366,
-0.2239864319562912,
0.243284672498703,
0.36055469512939453,
0.4904946982860565,
-0.19157841801643372,
0.7916275858879089,
0.6211830377578735,
0.12727992236614227,
0.5286127328872681,
-0.3316686451435089,
0.24905334413051605,
-0.6205692887306213,
0.025819644331932068,
-0.5991193056106567,
-0.40199902653694153,
-0.560097336769104,
-0.45573291182518005,
-0.1475180983543396,
0.4316866397857666,
0.0646209791302681,
0.317627876996994,
-0.4473874270915985,
0.20105783641338348,
0.5154007077217102,
-0.11440500617027283,
0.34291359782218933,
0.04655523970723152,
-0.05053233727812767,
-0.10789699852466583,
-0.5857483148574829,
-0.2926870882511139,
0.7724080681800842,
0.32880163192749023,
0.7604094743728638,
0.20152302086353302,
0.9375019073486328,
0.3117668330669403,
0.5993567705154419,
-0.5266501903533936,
0.563050389289856,
-0.35152629017829895,
-0.23486538231372833,
-0.2723749876022339,
-0.6480849981307983,
-1.136173129081726,
0.14726872742176056,
-0.20357532799243927,
-0.4113102853298187,
-0.033425576984882355,
0.24608679115772247,
-0.26680833101272583,
0.3964311182498932,
-0.6822944283485413,
0.6414994597434998,
0.5298216938972473,
-0.30512353777885437,
-0.3747931718826294,
-0.2418055683374405,
0.41776296496391296,
0.028999822214245796,
0.205637127161026,
-0.03463679552078247,
0.16930505633354187,
0.39845848083496094,
-0.580460786819458,
0.7883952856063843,
-0.29023510217666626,
-0.5346789956092834,
0.6141635775566101,
0.25705888867378235,
0.37700486183166504,
-0.044213052839040756,
0.06679912656545639,
0.08186734467744827,
-0.31527435779571533,
-0.16597986221313477,
-0.7775731682777405,
0.7163393497467041,
-0.35491833090782166,
-0.535112738609314,
-0.033003780990839005,
-0.37189731001853943,
0.08328933268785477,
0.07713453471660614,
0.22972212731838226,
0.3528830409049988,
-0.12522165477275848,
0.04843616113066673,
0.5595890283584595,
-0.20415359735488892,
0.7118823528289795,
0.4876229465007782,
-0.22432807087898254,
-0.4240165948867798,
0.7527912855148315,
0.04180224612355232,
0.37745919823646545,
0.45992010831832886,
0.03738883510231972,
-0.3651695251464844,
-0.7539655566215515,
-0.31382328271865845,
0.281425803899765,
-0.4242786467075348,
-0.29679280519485474,
-0.6388715505599976,
-0.5418252348899841,
-0.5198237895965576,
-0.1342919021844864,
-0.5655152797698975,
-0.6741482615470886,
-0.26672330498695374,
-0.0344398058950901,
0.34373942017555237,
0.5897195339202881,
-0.32642999291419983,
0.3565829396247864,
-0.8364524245262146,
0.29590484499931335,
0.3687724769115448,
0.31287166476249695,
-0.12424121052026749,
-0.6661630272865295,
-0.09092220664024353,
0.004507485777139664,
-0.47814059257507324,
-0.7696189284324646,
0.7371624112129211,
0.3892695903778076,
0.3039087951183319,
0.26700109243392944,
-0.022282743826508522,
0.5232675671577454,
-0.6764552593231201,
0.7879661321640015,
0.1575484722852707,
-0.7975234985351562,
0.6563552618026733,
0.24330541491508484,
0.3031298518180847,
0.18571530282497406,
0.05607503280043602,
-0.5247756838798523,
-1.0249717235565186,
-0.693627119064331,
-0.8725265860557556,
0.23975913226604462,
0.38013944029808044,
0.3098803758621216,
-0.3531475067138672,
0.7064598202705383,
-0.14473512768745422,
0.338891863822937,
-0.519257664680481,
-0.1572120487689972,
-0.07717794179916382,
-0.3956356942653656,
-0.11202193796634674,
-0.18799905478954315,
0.08351361006498337,
0.06369875371456146,
0.6259540915489197,
0.16261222958564758,
0.1537621021270752,
0.2508992552757263,
0.007364275399595499,
-0.19466601312160492,
0.446559339761734,
0.7322941422462463,
0.3033161163330078,
-0.22806279361248016,
0.16049249470233917,
-0.41929933428764343,
-0.6819260120391846,
0.21472981572151184,
-0.00683442922309041,
-0.5643996596336365,
0.2990107834339142,
0.2589138448238373,
0.6150400638580322,
-0.10083134472370148,
-0.628818929195404,
0.26591184735298157,
-0.0667617991566658,
-0.35991811752319336,
-0.24920034408569336,
0.38457080721855164,
0.33354270458221436,
0.3863256275653839,
0.16079318523406982,
0.38879165053367615,
0.44285663962364197,
-0.37020617723464966,
0.2657865881919861,
0.45996174216270447,
-0.2414158582687378,
-0.38087666034698486,
0.7176720499992371,
0.45812785625457764,
-0.4215013384819031,
0.6939446330070496,
-0.5041326284408569,
-0.15529552102088928,
0.2045745849609375,
0.6099771857261658,
1.181213617324829,
-0.12205097824335098,
0.5889564752578735,
0.6737492084503174,
0.07289188355207443,
-0.3978848159313202,
0.277210533618927,
0.0585494339466095,
-1.0308079719543457,
-0.9787701964378357,
-0.7070567011833191,
-0.15167762339115143,
0.18016712367534637,
-0.49675145745277405,
-0.1878720223903656,
-0.38215452432632446,
-0.289119690656662,
-0.14542797207832336,
-0.21631070971488953,
-0.1408224105834961,
0.22242772579193115,
0.13725727796554565,
0.8482049107551575,
-0.8981632590293884,
0.9083703756332397,
0.6386256217956543,
-0.4583803415298462,
-0.4290083348751068,
0.17702986299991608,
-0.1660069227218628,
-0.40657588839530945,
0.8254093527793884,
-0.24648559093475342,
-0.29129552841186523,
0.39603447914123535,
-0.5685957074165344,
-0.6526570320129395,
0.7974916100502014,
0.5099552869796753,
-0.47198286652565,
0.2600736618041992,
-0.19457872211933136,
0.767296552658081,
-0.2775561511516571,
-0.2003374844789505,
0.5908767580986023,
0.1741068959236145,
0.3940609395503998,
-0.5333385467529297,
-0.11949414759874344,
-0.17800703644752502,
0.256430447101593,
0.3489871025085449,
-0.25558018684387207,
0.6644040942192078,
-0.3909909129142761,
-0.4738934636116028,
0.030554750934243202,
0.8934730887413025,
0.2894999384880066,
0.04541483148932457,
0.4752824902534485,
0.797989010810852,
0.7267128825187683,
-0.1229667216539383,
0.7375485301017761,
-0.11614857614040375,
0.06886641681194305,
1.1156389713287354,
-0.1932516098022461,
1.207044243812561,
0.5316674709320068,
-0.29937073588371277,
0.8087756633758545,
0.21598738431930542,
0.5473541021347046,
0.7343301177024841,
0.5108305811882019,
-0.4913350045681,
-0.09096718579530716,
0.04087738320231438,
0.0018381894333288074,
0.26492130756378174,
0.21676279604434967,
-0.29957467317581177,
-0.35838884115219116,
0.07303473353385925,
0.036007001996040344,
0.4421968460083008,
-0.25257638096809387,
0.7976438999176025,
-0.13367503881454468,
-0.5951313972473145,
0.5982740521430969,
0.08546236157417297,
0.7509768605232239,
-0.4110223650932312,
-0.16651679575443268,
-0.5521239042282104,
0.11745091527700424,
-0.03760277107357979,
-0.9965347051620483,
0.719613254070282,
0.0188114196062088,
-0.0860900953412056,
-0.6397733688354492,
0.5808802247047424,
-0.817609429359436,
-0.3782854974269867,
0.09411417692899704,
0.35021448135375977,
0.39428794384002686,
-0.15404130518436432,
-0.6151484251022339,
-0.21282093226909637,
0.15416590869426727,
-0.3690277636051178,
0.18905706703662872,
0.5889057517051697,
0.38956373929977417,
0.8877345323562622,
0.49284473061561584,
0.6665858030319214,
0.052677400410175323,
0.6215567588806152,
0.42982256412506104,
-0.39816704392433167,
-0.23577013611793518,
-0.7070698738098145,
0.6854785680770874,
-0.05574202910065651,
-0.23536892235279083,
0.1572696715593338,
0.19937892258167267,
0.7422226071357727,
-0.05743957683444023,
0.5610683560371399,
0.06685740500688553,
0.7916648387908936,
-0.792819619178772,
0.8043839931488037,
-0.4168841242790222,
0.2031674087047577,
-0.2096579521894455,
-0.6822472214698792,
-0.5094574093818665,
0.7172857522964478,
0.253840833902359,
-0.06793282181024551,
0.5716537833213806,
0.7955349087715149,
0.3111439645290375,
-0.3610641062259674,
0.3455100953578949,
0.1748345047235489,
0.40833091735839844,
0.4915827512741089,
0.5171067118644714,
-0.4126993715763092,
0.522700309753418,
-0.3388095200061798,
-0.21383674442768097,
-0.028583863750100136,
-0.9875562191009521,
-0.3136408030986786,
-0.7137854695320129,
-0.9014987945556641,
-0.40169212222099304,
-0.06324826925992966,
0.56548011302948,
0.522121250629425,
-0.7526760697364807,
-0.0881870687007904,
-0.7029287219047546,
0.263727068901062,
-0.633990466594696,
-0.27227360010147095,
0.05807068943977356,
-0.7639972567558289,
-0.9604369401931763,
0.24386633932590485,
0.3485244810581207,
0.11196193844079971,
-0.41723835468292236,
-0.06813681870698929,
-0.04895171523094177,
0.03948160633444786,
0.6500821709632874,
0.30576157569885254,
-0.463891863822937,
-0.08869440108537674,
-0.25406527519226074,
-0.2067829668521881,
-0.20728975534439087,
0.8144190907478333,
-0.5632719397544861,
0.36269569396972656,
0.7962139248847961,
0.6158250570297241,
0.20971527695655823,
-0.012902495451271534,
0.751415491104126,
-1.0466512441635132,
0.20268873870372772,
0.19783999025821686,
0.3224731683731079,
0.3877250850200653,
-0.12344252318143845,
0.46264731884002686,
0.32091665267944336,
-0.49042221903800964,
-0.5887905359268188,
0.34137094020843506,
-0.6914359331130981,
-0.5300448536872864,
1.2008945941925049,
-0.19402742385864258,
-0.14807835221290588,
-0.1423056274652481,
-0.20016096532344818,
0.4158623516559601,
-0.3575991690158844,
0.8157843947410583,
0.5835497379302979,
-0.20252208411693573,
-0.6048507690429688,
-0.2402532398700714,
0.7275104522705078,
0.24389763176441193,
-0.6795427203178406,
0.3189570903778076,
0.7031558156013489,
0.4080182909965515,
0.2830272912979126,
0.9302778244018555,
-0.2084602266550064,
-0.020306948572397232,
-0.14337706565856934,
0.4306570291519165,
0.2195087969303131,
-0.28012391924858093,
-0.43324509263038635,
0.3626352846622467,
0.15255911648273468,
-0.1018548235297203
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16984v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16984v2
|
Modelling Commonsense Commonalities with Multi-Facet Concept Embeddings
| 2024-03-25T17:44:45 | 2024-06-04T21:36:42 |
Hanane Kteich, Na Li, Usashi Chatterjee, Zied Bouraoui, Steven Schockaert
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Concept embeddings offer a practical and efficient mechanism for injecting
commonsense knowledge into downstream tasks. Their core purpose is often not to
predict the commonsense properties of concepts themselves, but rather to
identify commonalities, i.e.\ sets of concepts which share some property of
interest. Such commonalities are the basis for inductive generalisation, hence
high-quality concept embeddings can make learning easier and more robust.
Unfortunately, standard embeddings primarily reflect basic taxonomic
categories, making them unsuitable for finding commonalities that refer to more
specific aspects (e.g.\ the colour of objects or the materials they are made
of). In this paper, we address this limitation by explicitly modelling the
different facets of interest when learning concept embeddings. We show that
this leads to embeddings which capture a more diverse range of commonsense
properties, and consistently improves results in downstream tasks such as
ultra-fine entity typing and ontology completion.
|
[
-0.5464339256286621,
-0.38452959060668945,
0.4908829629421234,
-0.06909377872943878,
-0.41350507736206055,
-0.015131357125937939,
-0.05902688205242157,
-0.2641095221042633,
0.3539540469646454,
0.3390985131263733,
-0.22305244207382202,
-0.4767697751522064,
-0.5771722197532654,
-0.056081097573041916,
0.04110446572303772,
0.96733558177948,
0.15021221339702606,
-0.09446043521165848,
-0.5504993796348572,
-0.518090009689331,
-0.3514453172683716,
-0.5537129044532776,
-0.15090897679328918,
-0.2866493761539459,
0.6566910743713379,
0.34334638714790344,
0.6428877711296082,
0.48371151089668274,
0.3041844069957733,
0.22420023381710052,
-0.2842279076576233,
0.339579701423645,
-0.3917774558067322,
0.04908168315887451,
-0.5701135396957397,
-0.36968347430229187,
-0.13675421476364136,
0.39034852385520935,
0.16622689366340637,
1.1865507364273071,
-0.2723509669303894,
-0.10332351177930832,
0.30128902196884155,
0.334068238735199,
-0.7939352989196777,
0.3945978879928589,
-0.5367516279220581,
0.17237046360969543,
-0.048143170773983,
-0.31593239307403564,
-0.16074353456497192,
0.034425873309373856,
0.29101917147636414,
-0.9765806198120117,
0.3669370412826538,
-0.08247458189725876,
0.8190336227416992,
0.3076828718185425,
-0.4443802833557129,
-0.4875355660915375,
-0.46819448471069336,
0.944858729839325,
-0.4085840582847595,
0.462319940328598,
0.09512878209352493,
0.228908509016037,
0.1447969675064087,
-0.6834077835083008,
-0.6243460178375244,
0.016902022063732147,
-0.4309349060058594,
0.28612521290779114,
0.010478381998836994,
0.17540882527828217,
0.08662603795528412,
0.40224120020866394,
-0.13077154755592346,
-0.02875063382089138,
-0.12130973488092422,
-0.029381975531578064,
0.3322395086288452,
0.042896196246147156,
0.281795859336853,
-0.4781249463558197,
-0.559146523475647,
0.04942530021071434,
-0.8724517226219177,
-0.1290678083896637,
0.2973060607910156,
0.6355620622634888,
-0.08626312762498856,
0.5309579372406006,
-0.3343442380428314,
0.5833783745765686,
-0.016063297167420387,
-0.10743594169616699,
0.4643462598323822,
-0.40969619154930115,
0.10432153940200806,
-0.26223224401474,
0.2354668825864792,
0.24126949906349182,
0.3232288956642151,
-0.21897821128368378,
-0.18819990754127502,
0.17418450117111206,
0.18895651400089264,
-0.5498031973838806,
-0.43318983912467957,
0.46061769127845764,
-0.13987955451011658,
-0.41452986001968384,
-0.01770990714430809,
-0.5718669295310974,
-0.3896946609020233,
-0.5823924541473389,
0.5424257516860962,
-0.3435061573982239,
-0.5221522450447083,
0.09245848655700684,
-0.3878174424171448,
0.25218409299850464,
0.5728981494903564,
-0.8244938254356384,
0.22857120633125305,
0.887511134147644,
0.8212411999702454,
0.04093698412179947,
-0.3537786602973938,
-0.46040254831314087,
0.3986489474773407,
-0.020365150645375252,
0.8643678426742554,
-0.9826148748397827,
-0.2315613329410553,
-0.07299958169460297,
-0.23843185603618622,
-0.17546086013317108,
-0.6866929531097412,
0.07961641997098923,
-0.41234856843948364,
-0.2874620854854584,
-0.5376250743865967,
-0.6547701954841614,
-0.24928788840770721,
0.19433334469795227,
-0.9080801606178284,
0.5305735468864441,
0.06337575614452362,
-0.9326531291007996,
0.6199614405632019,
-0.9919450879096985,
-0.3323157727718353,
0.11976943165063858,
-0.3739725649356842,
-0.17466594278812408,
0.18315565586090088,
0.1476060301065445,
1.0332598686218262,
-0.03724583238363266,
0.3560827672481537,
-0.6179801821708679,
-0.06631103903055191,
0.14592427015304565,
-0.14382433891296387,
0.5231108069419861,
0.3292344808578491,
-0.012443327344954014,
-0.19953827559947968,
-0.22481988370418549,
-0.5059611201286316,
-0.20595978200435638,
0.06746092438697815,
-0.8667477965354919,
-0.02761300466954708,
0.10156038403511047,
0.2631216049194336,
-0.0627421885728836,
-0.6645686626434326,
0.08246202021837234,
0.022982243448495865,
0.6895644664764404,
0.5883253812789917,
-0.002405015751719475,
0.6473477482795715,
-0.3931429088115692,
0.08940934389829636,
0.6491138339042664,
-0.11266931891441345,
0.0702025294303894,
-0.6576683521270752,
-0.27574893832206726,
-0.7590376734733582,
0.5428863167762756,
0.37088143825531006,
-0.6203715801239014,
0.27752915024757385,
-0.3061122000217438,
-0.3491179645061493,
-0.3794713318347931,
0.16031883656978607,
0.3066850006580353,
0.1773485392332077,
0.21141290664672852,
-0.5334694981575012,
-0.07078859210014343,
-0.7175825238227844,
-0.2188352346420288,
0.12166741490364075,
0.027392227202653885,
0.5332960486412048,
0.6735746264457703,
-0.07405001670122147,
1.2397466897964478,
-0.6596493124961853,
-0.4066774547100067,
-0.20297031104564667,
0.3836265802383423,
-0.04387230426073074,
0.652729868888855,
0.4305655062198639,
-1.3878090381622314,
-0.14804773032665253,
-0.006016236264258623,
-0.9111179113388062,
0.25196126103401184,
-0.20518821477890015,
0.0018776239594444633,
-0.09283743053674698,
0.5111419558525085,
-0.7509177327156067,
0.27597707509994507,
0.27292096614837646,
-0.12884733080863953,
0.10938673466444016,
-0.014448790811002254,
-0.25510790944099426,
-1.0892729759216309,
0.005685191601514816,
0.1871078908443451,
-0.028802908957004547,
-0.5052199363708496,
0.6293476819992065,
0.08146011829376221,
-0.2766011953353882,
-0.7925980091094971,
0.7304178476333618,
-0.44631510972976685,
-0.2838718593120575,
0.2943958342075348,
0.3184625208377838,
0.2510297894477844,
0.6445280313491821,
0.22843505442142487,
0.5218630433082581,
0.4196476340293884,
-0.8434597849845886,
0.09838800132274628,
0.1753510683774948,
-0.016249610111117363,
1.0944015979766846,
-0.629717230796814,
-0.2534750998020172,
-0.2540687322616577,
0.2576020658016205,
-0.796160101890564,
-0.3037610352039337,
0.02989131025969982,
-0.306560218334198,
0.4152718186378479,
-0.3576916754245758,
-0.509105384349823,
-0.05465729162096977,
-0.3400349020957947,
0.40328890085220337,
0.0852055773139,
-0.8752173781394958,
0.9658435583114624,
0.4987506568431854,
-0.2399820238351822,
-0.5977645516395569,
-0.5542079210281372,
-0.29575347900390625,
-0.390792578458786,
-0.4674532413482666,
0.47265419363975525,
0.08671990782022476,
-0.046855129301548004,
0.35579994320869446,
-0.18195773661136627,
-0.013026957400143147,
0.3747425973415375,
0.19641436636447906,
0.01619269698858261,
0.06105194613337517,
0.4802955090999603,
0.2124830186367035,
-0.07738850265741348,
-0.31647789478302,
-0.36766695976257324,
0.5339695811271667,
-0.17971600592136383,
-0.6575067043304443,
-0.2201252430677414,
0.6454967856407166,
0.5924369096755981,
-0.38144639134407043,
0.6553882956504822,
0.5449258685112,
-0.6167219877243042,
-0.3471645712852478,
-0.36833688616752625,
-0.22050483524799347,
-0.46891313791275024,
0.5097354650497437,
-0.668769359588623,
-0.930162250995636,
0.7058014273643494,
-0.2989889681339264,
0.12253216654062271,
0.45553165674209595,
0.1537853479385376,
-0.3472713232040405,
0.6264061331748962,
0.6747586131095886,
0.33065468072891235,
0.09863785654306412,
-0.5587494373321533,
0.3777710199356079,
-1.2551171779632568,
-0.4025748670101166,
-0.33643198013305664,
-0.1792861521244049,
-1.0541566610336304,
-0.5027720928192139,
0.16765901446342468,
0.25746846199035645,
-0.03615887463092804,
0.21433456242084503,
-0.49969419836997986,
0.5390855073928833,
0.6069104075431824,
0.24071604013442993,
0.3445044755935669,
0.09680843353271484,
-0.3613898754119873,
0.0911121517419815,
-0.7533127665519714,
-0.6046220660209656,
1.1976667642593384,
0.32708287239074707,
0.7669044733047485,
0.205115407705307,
1.1830506324768066,
0.13430510461330414,
0.519630491733551,
-0.8874723315238953,
0.22071628272533417,
-0.7132571339607239,
-0.747536301612854,
-0.2676011919975281,
-0.4381211996078491,
-0.7261808514595032,
0.4261408746242523,
-0.02539631351828575,
-0.40218082070350647,
0.6734936833381653,
0.2823658883571625,
-0.5250494480133057,
0.686553418636322,
-0.6740744709968567,
0.7519404888153076,
0.2892875671386719,
-0.25955262780189514,
-0.3183199167251587,
-0.20366927981376648,
0.2998197674751282,
-0.08608879894018173,
0.20540037751197815,
-0.13314731419086456,
-0.18513932824134827,
0.7158967852592468,
-0.1554088443517685,
1.3124040365219116,
-0.2547836899757385,
-0.03141006827354431,
0.2993771433830261,
-0.28522658348083496,
0.09032582491636276,
0.28251224756240845,
0.20868366956710815,
0.16484825313091278,
-0.07383329421281815,
-0.8505699634552002,
-0.6882891058921814,
0.6499744057655334,
-0.867789626121521,
-0.6019207239151001,
-0.5514309406280518,
-0.4077378213405609,
-0.23129431903362274,
-0.23459571599960327,
0.1502247005701065,
0.6503477096557617,
-0.27340567111968994,
0.11554189771413803,
1.0645090341567993,
-0.20032447576522827,
0.2861480414867401,
0.0820087119936943,
0.3165932297706604,
-0.19195117056369781,
1.2258809804916382,
0.2865408957004547,
0.3831484019756317,
0.40722501277923584,
0.11560467630624771,
-0.40636762976646423,
-0.3476219177246094,
-0.2925482392311096,
0.15980398654937744,
-0.9180281162261963,
-0.35990241169929504,
-1.057464838027954,
-0.26180869340896606,
-0.2888701558113098,
-0.392518013715744,
-0.32869812846183777,
-0.8022360801696777,
-0.3832845389842987,
-0.08270268887281418,
0.5308065414428711,
0.9443358182907104,
-0.5121670365333557,
0.08061999827623367,
-0.693922221660614,
0.40533849596977234,
1.0783278942108154,
0.47360897064208984,
0.18719519674777985,
-0.35388919711112976,
0.006661196239292622,
0.10279875248670578,
-0.4001396596431732,
-0.6679933071136475,
0.08202742040157318,
0.35547927021980286,
0.9358725547790527,
0.385564923286438,
0.11053632944822311,
0.4305158257484436,
-0.273118793964386,
0.5973688960075378,
0.11082077026367188,
-0.9264533519744873,
0.4802934229373932,
-0.3023345470428467,
-0.19862782955169678,
0.44903266429901123,
0.7886536121368408,
-0.6076856851577759,
-0.194490447640419,
-0.8211455345153809,
-0.9108943939208984,
0.21756801009178162,
0.06409896910190582,
0.41032999753952026,
-0.11405716836452484,
0.15507499873638153,
0.30600762367248535,
0.24316218495368958,
-0.5619558691978455,
-0.15736138820648193,
-0.6135726571083069,
-0.25219741463661194,
0.06311838328838348,
-0.06746257096529007,
-0.3516404926776886,
-0.11418963968753815,
0.356698602437973,
-0.3021254241466522,
0.41382157802581787,
0.05294859781861305,
-0.42409631609916687,
0.40447998046875,
0.34573715925216675,
0.4394139349460602,
0.37718045711517334,
-0.33375367522239685,
0.26695767045021057,
0.01062821689993143,
-0.47775962948799133,
0.0018253718735650182,
0.3358508050441742,
-0.027329837903380394,
0.0022712666541337967,
0.3211125433444977,
0.4804379940032959,
0.41249868273735046,
-0.1988511085510254,
0.5845621228218079,
0.31008410453796387,
0.07653947919607162,
-0.042902447283267975,
0.07120569050312042,
0.41758033633232117,
0.1777484267950058,
0.18155013024806976,
0.2059411108493805,
0.21552811563014984,
-0.7970027923583984,
0.4959464967250824,
0.46407246589660645,
-0.21299634873867035,
-0.261579304933548,
0.22574357688426971,
0.703750491142273,
0.20564359426498413,
0.5024246573448181,
-0.5079463124275208,
-0.6197422742843628,
0.5865263342857361,
0.29314395785331726,
0.8504958748817444,
-0.07977631688117981,
0.4275788366794586,
0.3387404680252075,
-0.022598983719944954,
0.0899420753121376,
0.24358722567558289,
-0.23803645372390747,
-1.0342013835906982,
-0.22632622718811035,
-0.8346548676490784,
-0.7343287467956543,
-0.14666180312633514,
-0.7259939312934875,
0.012512830086052418,
-0.5049256086349487,
0.11951261758804321,
0.3195742964744568,
-0.043635524809360504,
-1.0672065019607544,
0.24537502229213715,
0.14068561792373657,
0.8061582446098328,
-1.37595534324646,
0.6327581405639648,
0.8058580160140991,
-0.7716348171234131,
-0.6911681294441223,
-0.1314408779144287,
0.023685161024332047,
-0.639009416103363,
0.762961745262146,
0.24092954397201538,
0.12679307162761688,
-0.05409424751996994,
-0.6581660509109497,
-0.9541048407554626,
1.2162796258926392,
-0.23422926664352417,
-0.4599972367286682,
-0.07358259707689285,
0.303101122379303,
0.22583860158920288,
-0.8195326924324036,
0.12747062742710114,
0.3425596058368683,
0.22121833264827728,
0.29366207122802734,
-0.6183854937553406,
0.12518706917762756,
-0.22147154808044434,
0.15703168511390686,
-0.0026642309967428446,
-0.516574501991272,
1.0023053884506226,
-0.3428818881511688,
-0.20911365747451782,
-0.25081920623779297,
0.6033995151519775,
0.6350976824760437,
0.3505244851112366,
0.5113127827644348,
1.1136354207992554,
0.9063174724578857,
-0.24669569730758667,
0.9517728686332703,
-0.02038603089749813,
0.3968248665332794,
1.0582422018051147,
-0.25057727098464966,
0.9406186938285828,
0.49413958191871643,
-0.029998190701007843,
0.4750666618347168,
0.6064454317092896,
-0.03474193066358566,
0.8566296696662903,
0.21463459730148315,
-0.22473102807998657,
-0.3315434455871582,
-0.32454442977905273,
-0.42498278617858887,
0.43421241641044617,
0.8052175641059875,
0.02034803293645382,
-0.29700320959091187,
0.013173019513487816,
-0.06339600682258606,
0.09844882041215897,
-0.2986549735069275,
0.6907051205635071,
0.3076959550380707,
-0.23590248823165894,
0.274858683347702,
-0.21653981506824493,
1.2116883993148804,
-0.10909596085548401,
-0.214480921626091,
-0.4092956781387329,
-0.15386255085468292,
-0.19764302670955658,
-1.0253709554672241,
0.27396127581596375,
-0.37729281187057495,
-0.05428798496723175,
-0.1738623082637787,
0.4821615219116211,
-0.39726340770721436,
-0.31963497400283813,
0.21447381377220154,
0.6506938338279724,
0.032676540315151215,
-0.07409655302762985,
-0.51042240858078,
-0.4242953658103943,
-0.28973522782325745,
-0.03543354198336601,
0.24137362837791443,
0.8914823532104492,
0.035382237285375595,
0.552242636680603,
0.6558734178543091,
-0.015437594614923,
-0.1801443248987198,
0.08884452283382416,
0.9823337197303772,
-0.8746601939201355,
-0.5338236093521118,
-0.29305124282836914,
0.6614629626274109,
-0.15609797835350037,
-0.4624440670013428,
0.21729782223701477,
0.2785068154335022,
1.2103980779647827,
-0.030230939388275146,
0.8098282217979431,
0.011915391311049461,
0.37357667088508606,
-0.5852197408676147,
0.8198521733283997,
-0.7358805537223816,
0.32806214690208435,
-0.44660115242004395,
-0.8751727938652039,
-0.3872196674346924,
0.6609854698181152,
-0.06524334102869034,
0.2110113501548767,
0.5211960077285767,
0.7755222320556641,
-0.4992743134498596,
0.174346461892128,
0.4282931685447693,
-0.16204889118671417,
0.17567163705825806,
0.4271443486213684,
0.9933211803436279,
-0.09195432811975479,
0.1435839980840683,
-0.5304532051086426,
-0.19696177542209625,
-0.18327020108699799,
-0.8665730357170105,
-0.8497278690338135,
-0.6408424973487854,
-0.4280276596546173,
0.12101303040981293,
-0.024473732337355614,
0.8340421915054321,
0.8076516389846802,
-0.901557445526123,
0.14451758563518524,
-0.03289763629436493,
0.15396487712860107,
-0.07258244603872299,
-0.21728099882602692,
0.37248873710632324,
-0.45899057388305664,
-0.5382380485534668,
-0.4195025563240051,
0.2897332012653351,
0.151748925447464,
-0.24182893335819244,
-0.0257555041462183,
-0.26166245341300964,
0.21633405983448029,
0.720641016960144,
0.11064843833446503,
-0.9196525812149048,
-0.31203848123550415,
-0.1300772726535797,
-0.08787422627210617,
0.05088704824447632,
0.68896484375,
-0.9182506799697876,
0.10216332226991653,
0.2586685121059418,
0.6023984551429749,
0.3126174509525299,
-0.35691937804222107,
0.36686450242996216,
-0.8721119165420532,
0.06345292925834656,
0.26970627903938293,
0.41054046154022217,
0.7227521538734436,
-0.25549769401550293,
0.6532710194587708,
0.41027289628982544,
0.0465606227517128,
-0.6331402063369751,
0.48462215065956116,
-0.9373891353607178,
-0.42362546920776367,
0.8895226716995239,
-0.34155213832855225,
-0.03596687689423561,
-0.25613266229629517,
0.38773050904273987,
0.3460133969783783,
-0.36536020040512085,
0.62912517786026,
0.5017738938331604,
0.038156166672706604,
-0.046686068177223206,
-0.23925872147083282,
0.49300751090049744,
0.38990896940231323,
-0.7555230855941772,
0.05398596450686455,
0.13847830891609192,
0.5332517623901367,
0.637104332447052,
0.1487579196691513,
-0.16572719812393188,
0.3929065763950348,
0.017274904996156693,
-0.15578404068946838,
0.053173478692770004,
-0.5040733814239502,
-0.21046815812587738,
0.15833257138729095,
-0.006427275016903877,
-0.18985861539840698
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16977v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16977v1
|
A comparison of Human, GPT-3.5, and GPT-4 Performance in a University-Level Coding Course
| 2024-03-25T17:41:02 | 2024-03-25T17:41:02 |
Will Yeadon, Alex Peach, Craig P. Testrow
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This study evaluates the performance of ChatGPT variants, GPT-3.5 and GPT-4,
both with and without prompt engineering, against solely student work and a
mixed category containing both student and GPT-4 contributions in
university-level physics coding assignments using the Python language.
Comparing 50 student submissions to 50 AI-generated submissions across
different categories, and marked blindly by three independent markers, we
amassed $n = 300$ data points. Students averaged 91.9% (SE:0.4), surpassing the
highest performing AI submission category, GPT-4 with prompt engineering, which
scored 81.1% (SE:0.8) - a statistically significant difference (p = $2.482
\times 10^{-10}$). Prompt engineering significantly improved scores for both
GPT-4 (p = $1.661 \times 10^{-4}$) and GPT-3.5 (p = $4.967 \times 10^{-9}$).
Additionally, the blinded markers were tasked with guessing the authorship of
the submissions on a four-point Likert scale from `Definitely AI' to
`Definitely Human'. They accurately identified the authorship, with 92.1% of
the work categorized as 'Definitely Human' being human-authored. Simplifying
this to a binary `AI' or `Human' categorization resulted in an average accuracy
rate of 85.3%. These findings suggest that while AI-generated work closely
approaches the quality of university students' work, it often remains
detectable by human evaluators.
|
[
-0.11988072842359543,
-0.6059995889663696,
0.5579149723052979,
0.18395303189754486,
0.3534572720527649,
0.5597484707832336,
-0.04530647024512291,
-0.5357995629310608,
-0.25596383213996887,
-0.22972582280635834,
-0.06352106481790543,
-0.27067118883132935,
-0.25060245394706726,
0.7165110111236572,
-0.29164159297943115,
0.9818053245544434,
-0.07912296056747437,
0.062364015728235245,
-0.3706488311290741,
0.40903833508491516,
-0.5930488705635071,
-0.6076780557632446,
-0.6720313429832458,
-0.502024233341217,
0.46172431111335754,
0.2484581470489502,
0.6382127404212952,
0.29988372325897217,
0.701981246471405,
0.2879246771335602,
0.133126899600029,
-0.5268985033035278,
-0.2234572023153305,
-0.5445945262908936,
-0.20174206793308258,
-0.38185322284698486,
-0.46993839740753174,
0.5671051144599915,
0.47121483087539673,
0.41942083835601807,
-0.16876177489757538,
0.12156829982995987,
0.1609935462474823,
0.6956701874732971,
-0.2777460217475891,
0.19957295060157776,
-0.13841956853866577,
0.11692959815263748,
-0.17825698852539062,
-0.428526908159256,
-0.6006482243537903,
-0.44170868396759033,
-0.0293178241699934,
-0.778226912021637,
0.5348864793777466,
0.045042674988508224,
0.8065788149833679,
0.11139610409736633,
-0.19302381575107574,
-0.2253408581018448,
-0.421098530292511,
0.621728777885437,
-0.4768649637699127,
0.33806511759757996,
0.3289695382118225,
0.009216075763106346,
-0.18537847697734833,
-0.6378335952758789,
-0.48966848850250244,
-0.4395642578601837,
0.04067191109061241,
0.45742860436439514,
-0.17800526320934296,
0.439638614654541,
0.5515734553337097,
0.6092972159385681,
-1.1296147108078003,
0.22198761999607086,
-0.8454205989837646,
-0.5367698669433594,
0.7931106686592102,
-0.12606912851333618,
0.5617008805274963,
-0.23300297558307648,
0.06700368225574493,
-0.210013747215271,
-0.7973439693450928,
0.27351295948028564,
0.8845674395561218,
0.004786067642271519,
-0.09466856718063354,
0.7536947727203369,
-0.47786229848861694,
0.5119181275367737,
-0.0025926718953996897,
0.036082711070775986,
0.32705384492874146,
-0.3474522829055786,
0.0424874909222126,
-0.008717716671526432,
1.116522192955017,
0.3574927747249603,
0.40674176812171936,
-0.24787309765815735,
-0.08722050487995148,
0.41342681646347046,
0.32476547360420227,
-0.6628010272979736,
-0.8394663333892822,
-0.01582380384206772,
-0.3199678957462311,
-0.15844200551509857,
0.09489759057760239,
-0.417594313621521,
-0.25834745168685913,
-0.2722577154636383,
0.5915830135345459,
-0.2878853976726532,
-0.07325082272291183,
0.12356216460466385,
-0.29423534870147705,
0.2606162428855896,
0.398041695356369,
-0.8020626306533813,
0.22445371747016907,
0.6244068741798401,
0.9856406450271606,
-0.23781433701515198,
-0.7431526780128479,
-0.31470319628715515,
-0.26275309920310974,
-0.2588067650794983,
0.6948873400688171,
-0.4149733781814575,
-0.43397822976112366,
-0.4353495240211487,
-0.5409476161003113,
-0.05470211058855057,
-0.3212835192680359,
0.5161498188972473,
-0.3966265916824341,
0.5686956644058228,
-0.015723491087555885,
-0.6289306879043579,
0.025309890508651733,
-0.1751718372106552,
-0.4346769452095032,
1.117513656616211,
0.477095365524292,
-0.5302680134773254,
0.5050585269927979,
-0.9843705892562866,
-0.17152835428714752,
0.3189631700515747,
-0.4562199115753174,
-0.2421981394290924,
-0.2695775330066681,
-0.11762373894453049,
0.42870739102363586,
0.012692904099822044,
0.20678041875362396,
0.044577665627002716,
-0.8826526999473572,
0.47974464297294617,
-0.27179786562919617,
0.7301510572433472,
0.19096139073371887,
-0.5733882188796997,
0.020547835156321526,
-0.6435175538063049,
0.06465151160955429,
-0.08936061710119247,
-0.6106453537940979,
0.22660641372203827,
-0.18810077011585236,
-0.2560245394706726,
0.21355658769607544,
-0.05162854865193367,
-0.7975274920463562,
0.522004246711731,
-0.23915301263332367,
0.5319663882255554,
0.8236777186393738,
-0.13422797620296478,
0.39235690236091614,
-0.40421152114868164,
0.6978912949562073,
-0.4392199218273163,
-0.08729926496744156,
0.19563861191272736,
-1.1662814617156982,
-0.4226337969303131,
-0.1380842626094818,
0.2541680932044983,
0.6247942447662354,
-0.7833425998687744,
0.12453802675008774,
0.02481158636510372,
-0.522019624710083,
-0.523613452911377,
0.15790393948554993,
0.6219789385795593,
0.5056514739990234,
0.43374624848365784,
-0.1712472140789032,
-0.31125712394714355,
-0.7780061364173889,
-0.720288097858429,
-0.650127649307251,
-0.6565179824829102,
0.07829901576042175,
0.6261441111564636,
-0.12895116209983826,
0.9776081442832947,
-0.49034157395362854,
-0.06380151212215424,
-0.045469317585229874,
0.506032407283783,
0.4635861814022064,
0.8778100609779358,
0.4311255216598511,
-0.4523622393608093,
-0.5767117738723755,
-0.03536156192421913,
-0.7329466342926025,
-0.1768806278705597,
-0.1611330509185791,
0.022800477221608162,
0.25153568387031555,
0.21829530596733093,
-0.594062864780426,
0.5874816179275513,
0.2652575671672821,
-0.7218707799911499,
0.9684669375419617,
-0.41896629333496094,
0.571360170841217,
-0.5741686224937439,
0.06396720558404922,
0.32799211144447327,
-0.07516553997993469,
-0.44516098499298096,
0.10904337465763092,
0.29355350136756897,
-0.3034551739692688,
-0.3774264454841614,
0.15008701384067535,
-0.410627156496048,
-0.04262586683034897,
0.034506022930145264,
-0.06365277618169785,
-0.2006457895040512,
0.6448236703872681,
-0.14435523748397827,
1.1303380727767944,
0.5213997960090637,
-0.3696499168872833,
0.4971444010734558,
0.02032165229320526,
-0.23007358610630035,
0.4504685401916504,
-0.8816782832145691,
0.5562378168106079,
0.3082965910434723,
0.22815555334091187,
-0.7725902795791626,
-0.44142282009124756,
0.20001617074012756,
-1.0261117219924927,
0.07840274274349213,
0.04909377545118332,
-0.5924868583679199,
-0.6630903482437134,
-0.451921284198761,
0.6510051488876343,
0.8419426679611206,
-0.15058313310146332,
0.1280992031097412,
-0.1848340630531311,
-0.2871434688568115,
-0.2278602570295334,
-0.6954068541526794,
0.08942157030105591,
-0.027521084994077682,
-0.476659893989563,
0.17033198475837708,
-0.31390729546546936,
-0.06981123983860016,
-0.07053320109844208,
0.05643979087471962,
0.013630851171910763,
0.2726162075996399,
0.14781424403190613,
0.33873894810676575,
-0.20350347459316254,
-0.42641910910606384,
-0.3767898976802826,
-0.25751206278800964,
0.2697717845439911,
-0.037085533142089844,
0.2942782938480377,
-0.46089717745780945,
-0.4431212544441223,
-0.9008873105049133,
0.17311416566371918,
0.10273758322000504,
0.14437231421470642,
0.23041127622127533,
0.5331668257713318,
-0.24225273728370667,
0.2363302856683731,
-0.4391596019268036,
-0.1126786321401596,
-0.5776995420455933,
0.32232123613357544,
-0.55306476354599,
-1.0545127391815186,
0.32084745168685913,
0.4909995198249817,
-0.06367030739784241,
0.6127001047134399,
0.30701693892478943,
-0.26348787546157837,
1.0762938261032104,
0.559697151184082,
-0.30625295639038086,
0.30036789178848267,
-0.2788568139076233,
0.3254299461841583,
-0.6964123845100403,
-0.25233373045921326,
-0.8170694708824158,
-0.20858769118785858,
-0.7720043659210205,
-0.14758449792861938,
0.3816066384315491,
0.24767564237117767,
-0.46365389227867126,
0.5131030678749084,
-1.0408564805984497,
0.8312551975250244,
0.8286685347557068,
0.045444555580616,
0.4072166383266449,
-0.14647895097732544,
0.2598350942134857,
-0.06235217675566673,
-0.8261403441429138,
-0.5613059997558594,
1.344562292098999,
0.31646040081977844,
0.7269073724746704,
0.3954358398914337,
0.6849624514579773,
0.664888858795166,
0.36929774284362793,
-0.5256051421165466,
0.4572218954563141,
0.2884213328361511,
-0.43156543374061584,
-0.32129940390586853,
-0.838340163230896,
-1.0418645143508911,
-0.031066901981830597,
0.030700594186782837,
-1.0088014602661133,
-0.24909250438213348,
0.05517249554395676,
-0.4403177797794342,
0.27527809143066406,
-1.0684773921966553,
0.9627743363380432,
-0.017281683161854744,
-0.2601553797721863,
-0.17846925556659698,
-0.5379801392555237,
0.13223393261432648,
-0.1857755184173584,
0.21853217482566833,
0.05888020247220993,
0.20807889103889465,
1.149686336517334,
-0.2075871378183365,
0.6219717264175415,
-0.05092350021004677,
-0.017929527908563614,
0.4593883156776428,
0.12932473421096802,
0.11735867708921432,
0.34804803133010864,
-0.22880443930625916,
0.20488879084587097,
0.029644928872585297,
-0.7121905088424683,
-0.43733254075050354,
0.5983846783638,
-1.3155111074447632,
-0.4772568643093109,
-0.7955344915390015,
-0.5006850361824036,
0.019840367138385773,
0.14164990186691284,
0.5609803199768066,
0.6851736307144165,
0.1296262890100479,
0.04529178515076637,
0.29432380199432373,
-0.3066658079624176,
0.602263867855072,
0.4340534210205078,
0.026650646701455116,
-0.3183819353580475,
1.1674282550811768,
-0.03734796494245529,
0.15874820947647095,
0.2627597451210022,
0.19113942980766296,
-0.2961154580116272,
-0.4294254779815674,
-0.667030930519104,
0.13990440964698792,
-0.4976150095462799,
-0.2544083297252655,
-0.5602140426635742,
-0.22193121910095215,
-0.6547756195068359,
-0.6337176561355591,
-0.16392438113689423,
-0.19519810378551483,
-0.36838299036026,
0.08840256184339523,
0.08677773177623749,
1.0647406578063965,
-0.05854462459683418,
0.07893483340740204,
-0.6036344766616821,
0.273324191570282,
0.26909786462783813,
0.5957241654396057,
-0.3510420322418213,
-0.46011215448379517,
-0.15555785596370697,
0.10055739432573318,
-0.7011239528656006,
-0.782281756401062,
-0.13806387782096863,
0.2240094095468521,
0.6426867246627808,
0.08934400230646133,
-0.07065264135599136,
0.46356201171875,
-0.22865986824035645,
1.3307628631591797,
0.4779339134693146,
-1.192550539970398,
0.6240049004554749,
-0.4612198770046234,
0.3486970365047455,
0.4459643065929413,
0.39114904403686523,
-0.4888981282711029,
-0.7054159641265869,
-0.7751203775405884,
-0.4212226867675781,
0.9569952487945557,
0.7776156663894653,
-0.11800984293222427,
0.21216192841529846,
0.5315183997154236,
0.06933493912220001,
0.06136801093816757,
-0.9480251669883728,
-0.16562899947166443,
-0.2832131087779999,
-0.1357528269290924,
-0.305014431476593,
0.08870796114206314,
0.24991701543331146,
-0.4335613548755646,
0.516472578048706,
-0.1707262098789215,
0.5911088585853577,
0.4202722907066345,
-0.013559386134147644,
0.13417257368564606,
0.2920844256877899,
0.6744174361228943,
0.9511304497718811,
-0.28210797905921936,
0.09861147403717041,
-0.08117484301328659,
-0.8628543615341187,
0.2910303473472595,
-0.012357187457382679,
-0.07440198957920074,
-0.1515197902917862,
0.5788903832435608,
0.1993173211812973,
-0.19337281584739685,
-0.5824874639511108,
0.6626063585281372,
-0.18552769720554352,
-0.4433031678199768,
-0.07363976538181305,
0.37836477160453796,
-0.4493742287158966,
0.005439557135105133,
0.4978293478488922,
0.3251710534095764,
0.5187079310417175,
-0.5605943202972412,
0.09494839608669281,
-0.10816601663827896,
0.0427057258784771,
-0.7354545593261719,
1.0504765510559082,
0.39366310834884644,
-0.5169969201087952,
0.662800669670105,
-0.5249771475791931,
-0.6008089184761047,
0.794515073299408,
0.5570409893989563,
0.8729222416877747,
-0.17156115174293518,
0.3557291626930237,
0.7415210008621216,
0.19622613489627838,
-0.22590066492557526,
0.3334312438964844,
-0.2146221101284027,
-0.35100406408309937,
-0.5724079012870789,
-0.3707766532897949,
-0.7691262364387512,
-0.17634350061416626,
-0.5520642399787903,
0.18386751413345337,
-0.28173911571502686,
0.06451351195573807,
-0.12071346491575241,
0.3004103899002075,
-0.7409531474113464,
0.05820750817656517,
0.061275191605091095,
0.6805735230445862,
-0.7493336200714111,
0.5543862581253052,
1.0917034149169922,
-0.4576859474182129,
-1.192441701889038,
-0.23935739696025848,
0.1115887463092804,
-0.2661497890949249,
0.4390382468700409,
0.28279396891593933,
0.005647259298712015,
0.2900848984718323,
-0.49316295981407166,
-0.6791886687278748,
0.986668050289154,
0.20468847453594208,
-0.2260299026966095,
-0.0038552205078303814,
0.32317209243774414,
0.6673694849014282,
0.26944679021835327,
0.8024510741233826,
0.4672465920448303,
0.1382044404745102,
-0.20015975832939148,
-1.4055933952331543,
-0.12401828914880753,
-0.43178078532218933,
-0.26828229427337646,
0.07528216391801834,
-0.6837735772132874,
0.9517645835876465,
-0.09818814694881439,
-0.21862727403640747,
0.21149109303951263,
0.6080998182296753,
0.573908805847168,
0.6370598673820496,
0.13759712874889374,
0.24808400869369507,
0.8468437790870667,
-0.27374786138534546,
1.132140040397644,
-0.25253456830978394,
0.6433305144309998,
0.49020639061927795,
-0.0575479231774807,
0.5152398943901062,
0.34985190629959106,
-0.8277592062950134,
0.3982149660587311,
0.7530032396316528,
-0.07484491169452667,
0.28377214074134827,
0.45314139127731323,
-0.056282348930835724,
0.0570223331451416,
0.3712897300720215,
-0.7024804949760437,
0.21149244904518127,
-0.18277353048324585,
0.35508793592453003,
0.13996265828609467,
0.06404072791337967,
0.06594031304121017,
-0.056677818298339844,
-0.3191491961479187,
0.5729820728302002,
0.014165526255965233,
-0.8665356040000916,
0.485615998506546,
0.004053790587931871,
0.8931704759597778,
-0.23623797297477722,
-0.13406223058700562,
-0.22613215446472168,
-0.021673571318387985,
-0.5795220732688904,
-1.1630276441574097,
-0.007165457122027874,
0.5390326380729675,
-0.018261810764670372,
-0.4798493981361389,
0.40755191445350647,
-0.08340653032064438,
-0.2701326608657837,
-0.30217769742012024,
0.15617169439792633,
0.6335591673851013,
-0.03142254054546356,
-0.4016492962837219,
-0.23426958918571472,
0.12159721553325653,
-0.247560054063797,
0.19403865933418274,
0.30734387040138245,
0.08357241004705429,
0.6643791794776917,
0.6649129986763,
-0.050938330590724945,
0.1377863734960556,
-0.0598905049264431,
0.763368546962738,
-0.8134647607803345,
-0.7389620542526245,
-0.8833158016204834,
0.3811226189136505,
0.03466536104679108,
-0.6614606976509094,
0.91484534740448,
1.035498023033142,
1.2472859621047974,
-0.14258426427841187,
0.7202680706977844,
-0.30209824442863464,
0.14037708938121796,
-0.5861281156539917,
0.5932528972625732,
-0.26248377561569214,
0.2834104001522064,
-0.8121495842933655,
-1.0438084602355957,
-0.27935341000556946,
0.6106023788452148,
-0.17365755140781403,
0.19080457091331482,
0.7952001094818115,
0.4825180172920227,
0.13052353262901306,
0.03022725321352482,
0.28477370738983154,
-0.23815086483955383,
0.7967314720153809,
0.8607177138328552,
1.2790933847427368,
-0.40844905376434326,
0.38687291741371155,
-0.5512765645980835,
-0.46450912952423096,
-0.12798498570919037,
-0.5881375074386597,
-0.9123263955116272,
-0.37240099906921387,
-0.7138513922691345,
-0.36059850454330444,
-0.19561852514743805,
0.687828540802002,
0.5414541363716125,
-0.6705760359764099,
-0.1495707631111145,
-0.25708717107772827,
-0.10107067972421646,
-0.22069333493709564,
-0.26495856046676636,
0.42287907004356384,
-0.23991139233112335,
-0.5519561767578125,
0.38524001836776733,
-0.05566476285457611,
0.052500225603580475,
-0.03312409296631813,
-0.5276387333869934,
0.14993412792682648,
-0.28306230902671814,
0.5363205075263977,
0.26998868584632874,
-0.717526912689209,
-0.5352163910865784,
0.11520496010780334,
-0.37834903597831726,
0.1597268432378769,
0.6945453882217407,
-0.8834767937660217,
0.2580689489841461,
0.6227906942367554,
0.562732458114624,
0.16685906052589417,
0.34547752141952515,
0.41287559270858765,
-0.5730518102645874,
0.02299981564283371,
0.38591548800468445,
0.31910887360572815,
0.23746968805789948,
-0.6636010408401489,
0.7627424597740173,
0.6311856508255005,
-1.253476858139038,
-0.7307301163673401,
-0.22621072828769684,
-1.1542946100234985,
-0.05655505508184433,
1.06156325340271,
-0.1304139494895935,
0.1560106873512268,
-0.15455245971679688,
-0.5209640264511108,
0.12232007086277008,
-0.6090758442878723,
0.9180306196212769,
0.6530782580375671,
-0.7262288331985474,
0.12856820225715637,
-0.7973859906196594,
0.5701613426208496,
0.5029314160346985,
-0.7771041989326477,
-0.5283381938934326,
0.5811967253684998,
0.21118609607219696,
0.1700407713651657,
0.9750986695289612,
0.10791949927806854,
0.7721208930015564,
0.19197997450828552,
0.46132516860961914,
-0.11792862415313721,
-0.09928078204393387,
-0.26503634452819824,
0.1586296558380127,
0.1558810919523239,
-0.17167286574840546
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16973v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16973v3
|
VoiceCraft: Zero-Shot Speech Editing and Text-to-Speech in the Wild
| 2024-03-25T17:38:32 | 2024-06-14T00:29:46 |
Puyuan Peng, Po-Yao Huang, Shang-Wen Li, Abdelrahman Mohamed, David Harwath
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD
|
We introduce VoiceCraft, a token infilling neural codec language model, that
achieves state-of-the-art performance on both speech editing and zero-shot
text-to-speech (TTS) on audiobooks, internet videos, and podcasts. VoiceCraft
employs a Transformer decoder architecture and introduces a token rearrangement
procedure that combines causal masking and delayed stacking to enable
generation within an existing sequence. On speech editing tasks, VoiceCraft
produces edited speech that is nearly indistinguishable from unedited
recordings in terms of naturalness, as evaluated by humans; for zero-shot TTS,
our model outperforms prior SotA models including VALLE and the popular
commercial model XTTS-v2. Crucially, the models are evaluated on challenging
and realistic datasets, that consist of diverse accents, speaking styles,
recording conditions, and background noise and music, and our model performs
consistently well compared to other models and real recordings. In particular,
for speech editing evaluation, we introduce a high quality, challenging, and
realistic dataset named RealEdit. We encourage readers to listen to the demos
at https://jasonppy.github.io/VoiceCraft_web.
|
[
-0.04385184496641159,
-0.8982344269752502,
0.28237688541412354,
0.134730264544487,
-0.08536048233509064,
0.4322483539581299,
-0.3099857270717621,
-0.5034201741218567,
0.17947059869766235,
0.6584144830703735,
-0.70772784948349,
-0.6005123853683472,
-0.3607895076274872,
0.03736719489097595,
-0.6771052479743958,
0.9489870071411133,
0.42802760004997253,
0.057816825807094574,
-0.18648606538772583,
-0.06203972175717354,
-0.686890721321106,
-0.6483592987060547,
-0.6995229721069336,
-0.24644802510738373,
0.4024125039577484,
0.28214189410209656,
0.8337229490280151,
0.8114765882492065,
0.045885033905506134,
0.24947433173656464,
-0.46222373843193054,
0.0220754686743021,
-0.425068199634552,
0.2261222004890442,
-0.17326630651950836,
-0.4425802528858185,
-0.7142455577850342,
0.05445650592446327,
0.39551082253456116,
0.4301920533180237,
-0.1557929366827011,
0.47530290484428406,
-0.23872210085391998,
0.08846499025821686,
-0.41194695234298706,
-0.28052905201911926,
-0.9378235936164856,
0.21910826861858368,
-0.20491652190685272,
-0.08466322720050812,
-0.4036346971988678,
-0.13391661643981934,
0.13839173316955566,
-0.6598747372627258,
0.5349987745285034,
-0.06203152611851692,
0.4136476516723633,
0.3386126458644867,
-0.026041554287075996,
0.00872072298079729,
-0.8742662072181702,
0.5722136497497559,
-0.8634480237960815,
0.3977101445198059,
0.23542436957359314,
0.23069354891777039,
-0.19620664417743683,
-0.9783157706260681,
-1.007710576057434,
0.12523260712623596,
0.44198790192604065,
0.15523487329483032,
-0.41934332251548767,
0.3760776221752167,
0.41386446356773376,
0.32067087292671204,
-0.6829953789710999,
0.23596982657909393,
-0.21504154801368713,
-0.11562488973140717,
0.5379787683486938,
0.1052786260843277,
0.49064770340919495,
-0.24044553935527802,
0.11333002895116806,
-0.1632247269153595,
-0.5278162956237793,
0.06297921389341354,
0.6425597071647644,
0.5877744555473328,
-0.011229041032493114,
0.6414075493812561,
0.05121278762817383,
0.9888011813163757,
-0.0133266756311059,
-0.12595219910144806,
0.05293680727481842,
0.03419308736920357,
-0.5702886581420898,
0.5293030738830566,
0.5789523124694824,
0.31987130641937256,
0.14514166116714478,
-0.3102053999900818,
0.019852427765727043,
-0.02037760056555271,
0.3399774730205536,
-0.7638030648231506,
-0.09223958849906921,
0.4628051221370697,
-0.5813000202178955,
-0.7478399872779846,
-0.2399364709854126,
-0.5983409881591797,
-0.631126880645752,
-0.2397303283214569,
0.5373802185058594,
-0.10237542539834976,
-0.5432220697402954,
0.24208521842956543,
-0.5234439969062805,
-0.07419724762439728,
0.18298694491386414,
-0.8433563709259033,
0.4478553235530853,
0.7845141291618347,
1.0237246751785278,
-0.3777316212654114,
-0.3436976373195648,
-0.6854205131530762,
-0.14071784913539886,
-0.39243245124816895,
0.7640959620475769,
-0.6370254158973694,
-0.8169957399368286,
-0.0947846919298172,
-0.10340725630521774,
0.24874188005924225,
-0.6857203841209412,
0.5447235703468323,
-0.26524361968040466,
0.16873517632484436,
0.20590654015541077,
-0.5920870304107666,
-0.04124698415398598,
0.12688004970550537,
-0.5594469904899597,
1.043581247329712,
-0.08019502460956573,
-0.2439609318971634,
0.20878811180591583,
-0.8773342967033386,
-0.30761462450027466,
-0.07863085716962814,
0.21788501739501953,
-0.27510514855384827,
0.35893967747688293,
-0.004573140759021044,
0.32105058431625366,
-0.23032133281230927,
0.4244624972343445,
-0.1251308023929596,
-0.4642401337623596,
0.3898712992668152,
-0.8675801753997803,
0.6519643664360046,
0.25299233198165894,
-0.2692963778972626,
0.4503079354763031,
-0.9943944811820984,
0.2616810202598572,
-0.024698542430996895,
-0.03014373779296875,
0.08783271163702011,
-0.012464025057852268,
0.45475900173187256,
0.2782919704914093,
-0.3506004214286804,
-0.9746391177177429,
0.32358843088150024,
-0.6148657202720642,
0.7755982875823975,
0.5110200047492981,
-0.0474247969686985,
0.24347859621047974,
-0.26385191082954407,
0.6051483750343323,
-0.12265808135271072,
0.25915637612342834,
-0.41045716404914856,
-0.7323890328407288,
-0.38950592279434204,
-0.11974320560693741,
0.5136908888816833,
0.7171179056167603,
-0.5369058847427368,
0.11219191551208496,
-0.29148972034454346,
-0.7215683460235596,
-0.8330128192901611,
-0.3240809738636017,
0.36668160557746887,
0.637667179107666,
0.5067311525344849,
-0.20467814803123474,
-0.6400888562202454,
-0.44707608222961426,
-0.6805708408355713,
-0.08977952599525452,
-0.24945467710494995,
0.15525156259536743,
0.03871708735823631,
0.028938284143805504,
1.1477051973342896,
-0.19725608825683594,
-0.07422881573438644,
-0.3252466320991516,
0.24384894967079163,
0.25567206740379333,
0.58708655834198,
0.4100217819213867,
-0.5182309150695801,
-0.4181439280509949,
-0.0689489096403122,
-0.35694366693496704,
-0.1907060295343399,
-0.28480416536331177,
0.15241864323616028,
-0.0544947050511837,
0.4290033280849457,
-0.6979970932006836,
0.711391806602478,
0.6655551195144653,
-0.3885543942451477,
0.5957557559013367,
-0.06657415628433228,
0.14712747931480408,
-1.0394469499588013,
-0.055384717881679535,
-0.39688947796821594,
-0.4960111975669861,
-0.9428508877754211,
-0.20279647409915924,
-0.270102858543396,
-0.6019441485404968,
-0.8391473293304443,
0.5332025289535522,
-0.046031404286623,
-0.15012282133102417,
-0.30194276571273804,
0.08805439621210098,
-0.02757980115711689,
0.4506603181362152,
0.08600399643182755,
1.0389196872711182,
0.5513059496879578,
-0.0887574777007103,
0.5774112343788147,
0.3614245653152466,
-0.10037965327501297,
0.48099130392074585,
-0.8803199529647827,
0.49109092354774475,
0.03372009098529816,
0.21805481612682343,
-0.7546141147613525,
0.04377621412277222,
-0.012031881138682365,
-0.8273493647575378,
0.29818466305732727,
-0.2850155234336853,
-0.47296613454818726,
-0.11951732635498047,
-0.2331792414188385,
0.2622584104537964,
0.5303940176963806,
-0.6414225101470947,
0.578087329864502,
0.3604741096496582,
-0.2354503571987152,
-0.3783591091632843,
-0.9750967621803284,
0.654604971408844,
0.034375980496406555,
-0.4027974307537079,
0.7907031178474426,
-0.16896651685237885,
-0.15544584393501282,
0.1711495965719223,
-0.1649404913187027,
-0.24902762472629547,
-0.2562093734741211,
0.5428961515426636,
0.22123752534389496,
-0.16819995641708374,
0.012867841869592667,
0.11197667568922043,
-0.08175402134656906,
-0.1712392419576645,
-0.5855802893638611,
0.35733696818351746,
0.15654706954956055,
-0.2604670226573944,
-0.6570426225662231,
0.3737848401069641,
0.7084759473800659,
-0.10722783207893372,
0.26539817452430725,
0.36943793296813965,
-0.383866548538208,
-0.11613120883703232,
-0.6291304230690002,
0.03298564255237579,
-0.44692063331604004,
0.36938920617103577,
-0.30913734436035156,
-1.0107944011688232,
0.4933876395225525,
-0.1666496992111206,
0.19574543833732605,
0.2928668260574341,
0.2859741747379303,
-0.061741042882204056,
1.1267142295837402,
0.4539855420589447,
0.08916133642196655,
0.592974841594696,
-0.32344502210617065,
0.005291422829031944,
-0.5116736888885498,
-0.09424308687448502,
-0.5350836515426636,
-0.44899222254753113,
-0.5116376280784607,
-0.537790060043335,
0.16495925188064575,
-0.26940467953681946,
-0.02877810411155224,
0.42566195130348206,
-0.7966828346252441,
0.8846960663795471,
0.5191236138343811,
-0.014547694474458694,
0.2509976327419281,
0.036100585013628006,
-0.022328173741698265,
-0.2222888320684433,
-0.8266081213951111,
-0.37842893600463867,
1.2185310125350952,
0.2121499627828598,
0.32961001992225647,
-0.07654834538698196,
0.4289489984512329,
0.5597527623176575,
0.15455064177513123,
-0.7792931199073792,
0.29493075609207153,
-0.31161990761756897,
-0.8091756701469421,
-0.3956730365753174,
-0.03743003308773041,
-0.532119870185852,
0.08943824470043182,
-0.37574654817581177,
-0.7106246948242188,
0.08916952461004257,
0.2276736944913864,
-0.6552034020423889,
0.7576355934143066,
-0.6095200777053833,
0.9234670996665955,
-0.07257331907749176,
-0.4249840974807739,
-0.21023330092430115,
-0.6579809784889221,
0.08820103853940964,
0.2592719495296478,
0.008728875778615475,
0.047476086765527725,
0.280517578125,
0.5247012376785278,
-0.4806693494319916,
0.8478369116783142,
-0.3635966181755066,
0.2918758988380432,
0.5760936141014099,
0.3801875710487366,
0.2570669651031494,
0.019330661743879318,
-0.235191211104393,
0.5326249599456787,
0.39053481817245483,
-0.03841982036828995,
-0.8514913320541382,
0.6346209049224854,
-0.7784208059310913,
-0.3963807225227356,
-0.35430559515953064,
-0.2026643306016922,
-0.3036420941352844,
0.2662539780139923,
0.2776997685432434,
0.7768387198448181,
-0.48227789998054504,
0.2778509259223938,
0.6289554238319397,
-0.5033472180366516,
0.6597989797592163,
0.26917216181755066,
-0.30558130145072937,
-0.6745246648788452,
0.9073069095611572,
0.11915596574544907,
0.1826290339231491,
0.07831471413373947,
0.1490357220172882,
-0.21151553094387054,
-0.5761198401451111,
-0.8291943073272705,
-0.09384628385305405,
-0.43359270691871643,
-0.27621644735336304,
-0.6733461022377014,
-0.3458336889743805,
-0.37899768352508545,
-0.11158442497253418,
-0.7050398588180542,
-0.7298320531845093,
-0.4462842047214508,
-0.2731459438800812,
0.37905219197273254,
0.8456267714500427,
-0.06922570616006851,
0.5884727835655212,
-0.7320740818977356,
0.5499340295791626,
0.43538743257522583,
0.4720515012741089,
-0.11140034347772598,
-0.6910330057144165,
0.03566237539052963,
0.10604292899370193,
-0.19886159896850586,
-0.8570894002914429,
0.4644390940666199,
0.3156906068325043,
0.16784615814685822,
-0.09636042267084122,
-0.14513207972049713,
1.0984925031661987,
-0.6950883865356445,
1.3266751766204834,
0.19939970970153809,
-1.2755903005599976,
0.33434900641441345,
-0.22952426970005035,
0.39991992712020874,
0.41700559854507446,
-0.3260263204574585,
-1.0573209524154663,
-0.21579129993915558,
-0.7322044968605042,
-0.5039316415786743,
0.7294172644615173,
0.29638218879699707,
0.49090340733528137,
0.05770871788263321,
0.4592350721359253,
0.18833591043949127,
0.3690395653247833,
-0.31417277455329895,
-0.23011907935142517,
-0.7276764512062073,
-0.20162810385227203,
0.11352282762527466,
-0.41858139634132385,
0.18354646861553192,
-0.4639236330986023,
0.5718590617179871,
0.03243406116962433,
0.29859012365341187,
0.38845014572143555,
0.0075647043995559216,
-0.25288712978363037,
0.24704518914222717,
0.844070553779602,
0.30192694067955017,
-0.13812577724456787,
0.017288224771618843,
0.3547069728374481,
-0.752291738986969,
-0.02685350738465786,
-0.186404287815094,
-0.10479553788900375,
0.34347784519195557,
0.29023006558418274,
1.1281797885894775,
0.22383365035057068,
-0.6459611654281616,
0.5501730442047119,
-0.3206523656845093,
-0.4061811864376068,
-0.27001485228538513,
0.08401425182819366,
-0.04237953573465347,
0.1053750067949295,
0.06706153601408005,
0.4567827880382538,
0.15107184648513794,
-0.31703251600265503,
0.03671951964497566,
0.1542942225933075,
-0.4716230630874634,
-0.5441935062408447,
1.0799936056137085,
0.2607509195804596,
-0.8969340920448303,
0.6250404715538025,
0.03230900689959526,
-0.29505258798599243,
0.40524572134017944,
0.818579912185669,
1.4690744876861572,
-0.049277614802122116,
0.19904115796089172,
0.19812074303627014,
0.16103902459144592,
0.07194720208644867,
0.304671049118042,
-0.28700950741767883,
-0.46682649850845337,
-0.6583077311515808,
-0.5470762848854065,
-0.6547362208366394,
0.21825852990150452,
-0.3865276873111725,
0.3891844153404236,
-0.574241578578949,
-0.36588844656944275,
0.13395652174949646,
-0.42718595266342163,
-0.5531215667724609,
0.25734370946884155,
0.13644558191299438,
1.0758918523788452,
-0.507814347743988,
0.8472909927368164,
0.2936302125453949,
-0.09058470278978348,
-0.8383805155754089,
0.006056707818061113,
0.21750780940055847,
-0.40020763874053955,
0.321889191865921,
-0.0017761371564120054,
-0.27364274859428406,
0.4520607888698578,
-0.7048622965812683,
-0.7453885078430176,
0.9309316277503967,
0.48469024896621704,
-0.5375452637672424,
-0.026252523064613342,
0.3024536371231079,
0.5990039706230164,
-0.11271419376134872,
0.30875617265701294,
0.579765260219574,
0.21130983531475067,
0.24686214327812195,
-1.1504318714141846,
-0.6220369338989258,
-0.30249813199043274,
0.07889895141124725,
-0.24382267892360687,
-0.37653112411499023,
0.5549440979957581,
0.07739425450563431,
-0.10840339958667755,
0.11171625554561615,
0.4571077525615692,
-0.05213350057601929,
0.3634970784187317,
0.39964255690574646,
0.5864266157150269,
0.608441174030304,
-0.07130975276231766,
0.7165055871009827,
-0.29402706027030945,
-0.005046525038778782,
1.2726898193359375,
-0.18879620730876923,
0.8980182409286499,
0.3331894874572754,
-0.16307269036769867,
0.36273014545440674,
0.4631466567516327,
0.1331550031900406,
0.2961405813694,
0.20484672486782074,
-0.4548652172088623,
-0.11444580554962158,
-0.28722700476646423,
-0.17588241398334503,
0.8535784482955933,
0.1292661875486374,
0.03747217729687691,
0.18712972104549408,
0.2112286239862442,
0.11131598055362701,
0.12422465533018112,
-0.13911190629005432,
0.909585177898407,
-0.2788088619709015,
-0.4917908310890198,
0.3746136426925659,
0.1576342135667801,
0.7118203043937683,
-0.5364295244216919,
-0.28912392258644104,
-0.0056822882033884525,
-0.21518801152706146,
-0.34771692752838135,
-0.710175633430481,
0.5903711318969727,
0.6221511363983154,
-0.2884252071380615,
-0.6208575963973999,
0.7683545351028442,
-0.3895381987094879,
-0.3306136429309845,
-0.025674626231193542,
0.24862156808376312,
0.14148768782615662,
-0.36005446314811707,
-0.6633015871047974,
0.2920635938644409,
-0.13409481942653656,
-0.2724013924598694,
-0.017059465870261192,
0.2607380449771881,
0.09802456945180893,
0.19980479776859283,
1.1259516477584839,
0.45655468106269836,
0.17703032493591309,
0.31803351640701294,
0.5953176021575928,
-0.6645834445953369,
-0.6269704699516296,
-0.8627461194992065,
0.75309818983078,
-0.2576555907726288,
-0.48306575417518616,
0.5728117823600769,
0.6607426404953003,
0.866582453250885,
-0.1661979705095291,
0.8776431679725647,
0.06213632598519325,
0.6543090343475342,
-0.23605601489543915,
0.8483625650405884,
-0.33948439359664917,
-0.1522800624370575,
-0.3679059147834778,
-0.7989400625228882,
-0.693956196308136,
0.2741541266441345,
0.09627501666545868,
-0.3181188404560089,
0.3444823622703552,
0.9345014691352844,
0.025380127131938934,
0.3462086617946625,
0.7588430643081665,
0.14182719588279724,
0.4224242568016052,
-0.04725941643118858,
0.7629643678665161,
-0.5479854941368103,
0.5428293347358704,
-0.25041741132736206,
-0.11802941560745239,
0.15081574022769928,
-0.9736732840538025,
-0.8048996329307556,
-0.41083240509033203,
-0.25503304600715637,
-0.21435312926769257,
0.16169990599155426,
1.1980023384094238,
0.8782261610031128,
-0.7918563485145569,
-0.3709540069103241,
-0.2486133724451065,
0.024163315072655678,
-0.37556344270706177,
-0.17445234954357147,
-0.04891926795244217,
0.06015155836939812,
-0.8546920418739319,
0.8747621774673462,
0.6180460453033447,
0.09642305970191956,
-0.17641492187976837,
0.03456379100680351,
0.1325397491455078,
0.25761666893959045,
0.601911723613739,
0.4210992753505707,
-0.8288689851760864,
-0.19785526394844055,
0.2789248526096344,
0.225723534822464,
0.011043652892112732,
1.0373069047927856,
-0.9311439394950867,
1.066057562828064,
0.41788050532341003,
0.6387592554092407,
0.5960143208503723,
0.014307337813079357,
0.42828574776649475,
-0.9152073860168457,
0.40370887517929077,
0.3799342215061188,
-0.21741177141666412,
0.32542985677719116,
-0.3132593333721161,
0.23003539443016052,
0.33316636085510254,
-0.5642104744911194,
-1.0936574935913086,
-0.027284102514386177,
-0.8359383344650269,
-0.09160107374191284,
0.866277277469635,
0.0823645293712616,
-0.23283614218235016,
0.010862128809094429,
-0.5183117389678955,
0.6147037744522095,
-0.09640717506408691,
0.6116421222686768,
0.5706137418746948,
-0.11322200298309326,
-0.1699649840593338,
-0.7717524170875549,
0.666767954826355,
0.2602129876613617,
-0.515009343624115,
0.226596862077713,
0.49320799112319946,
0.22896631062030792,
-0.1219782829284668,
0.41164734959602356,
-0.12909428775310516,
0.3387918770313263,
0.2296309471130371,
0.3811054527759552,
-0.5983085632324219,
-0.3964675962924957,
-0.7238746881484985,
0.11793495714664459,
-0.11772125214338303,
-0.3266591429710388
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16971v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16971v2
|
AIOS: LLM Agent Operating System
| 2024-03-25T17:32:23 | 2024-03-26T02:35:07 |
Kai Mei, Zelong Li, Shuyuan Xu, Ruosong Ye, Yingqiang Ge, Yongfeng Zhang
|
cs.OS
|
cs.OS, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The integration and deployment of large language model (LLM)-based
intelligent agents have been fraught with challenges that compromise their
efficiency and efficacy. Among these issues are sub-optimal scheduling and
resource allocation of agent requests over the LLM, the difficulties in
maintaining context during interactions between agent and LLM, and the
complexities inherent in integrating heterogeneous agents with different
capabilities and specializations. The rapid increase of agent quantity and
complexity further exacerbates these issues, often leading to bottlenecks and
sub-optimal utilization of resources. Inspired by these challenges, this paper
presents AIOS, an LLM agent operating system, which embeds large language model
into operating systems (OS) as the brain of the OS, enabling an operating
system "with soul" -- an important step towards AGI. Specifically, AIOS is
designed to optimize resource allocation, facilitate context switch across
agents, enable concurrent execution of agents, provide tool service for agents,
and maintain access control for agents. We present the architecture of such an
operating system, outline the core challenges it aims to resolve, and provide
the basic design and implementation of the AIOS. Our experiments on concurrent
execution of multiple agents demonstrate the reliability and efficiency of our
AIOS modules. Through this, we aim to not only improve the performance and
efficiency of LLM agents but also to pioneer for better development and
deployment of the AIOS ecosystem in the future. The project is open-source at
https://github.com/agiresearch/AIOS.
|
[
-0.3003982901573181,
-0.3344646692276001,
0.6798548102378845,
0.19013671576976776,
-0.024008221924304962,
0.4042685627937317,
-0.10786281526088715,
-0.5634437799453735,
0.17528481781482697,
0.5289850831031799,
-0.5105900764465332,
-0.18707115948200226,
-0.6322756409645081,
0.1372450441122055,
-0.1505660116672516,
0.8321101069450378,
0.16294491291046143,
-0.01119003165513277,
-0.373244971036911,
-0.10958770662546158,
-0.4144376516342163,
-0.13923758268356323,
-0.9267007112503052,
-0.4924110472202301,
-0.0684797391295433,
0.3591269552707672,
0.9317688345909119,
0.9523662328720093,
0.5485699772834778,
0.5406831502914429,
0.27843189239501953,
0.08711029589176178,
-0.07194894552230835,
0.30982285737991333,
-0.27881425619125366,
-0.3625716269016266,
-0.7736761569976807,
-0.05074341967701912,
0.7831575870513916,
0.1812395453453064,
-0.2215014547109604,
-0.14212660491466522,
-0.15317226946353912,
0.41537749767303467,
-0.5347082614898682,
0.018896091729402542,
-0.7266750931739807,
0.11427106708288193,
-0.148481547832489,
-0.2763370871543884,
-0.07736711204051971,
-0.10811129957437515,
0.18058612942695618,
-0.7992740273475647,
-0.5204219818115234,
0.08558530360460281,
0.38988903164863586,
0.6170796751976013,
-0.2894420027732849,
-0.5417995452880859,
-0.5078393220901489,
1.0004926919937134,
-0.5621800422668457,
0.2593356966972351,
-0.013090410269796848,
0.2718198299407959,
-0.12944845855236053,
-0.4133835732936859,
-0.6367931962013245,
-0.4064875543117523,
0.07722380757331848,
-0.061852119863033295,
0.0786786675453186,
0.24931924045085907,
-0.22402767837047577,
0.26920464634895325,
-0.29686594009399414,
0.17825867235660553,
0.02145138569176197,
-0.2600385844707489,
0.5754602551460266,
0.3922584354877472,
0.6217854619026184,
0.3924209177494049,
-0.41268083453178406,
0.17128178477287292,
-0.40854522585868835,
-0.07431376725435257,
0.5214633941650391,
0.2657061815261841,
-0.07301691919565201,
0.4631648659706116,
-0.23519982397556305,
0.5538878440856934,
-0.28184446692466736,
-0.4190278649330139,
0.2262769192457199,
0.09098093211650848,
-0.06314396858215332,
-0.07486043125391006,
0.7128115892410278,
0.25320154428482056,
0.3214879333972931,
-0.5848755240440369,
-0.512758195400238,
0.3035973012447357,
0.5089008808135986,
-0.6285480260848999,
0.5025416016578674,
0.4255402982234955,
-0.20211975276470184,
-0.24121244251728058,
-0.28318893909454346,
-0.27776870131492615,
-0.231376513838768,
-0.2112385332584381,
0.13147811591625214,
-0.5718762278556824,
-0.08440249413251877,
-0.2207428514957428,
-0.10215014964342117,
0.13328731060028076,
0.5774113535881042,
-0.7843093276023865,
0.6300250291824341,
0.8453401327133179,
0.8853687047958374,
-0.3908546268939972,
-0.5304532647132874,
-0.5778195858001709,
0.45429033041000366,
-0.13805104792118073,
0.6591722965240479,
-0.6543869972229004,
-0.5049183964729309,
-0.27285751700401306,
0.01210387796163559,
0.10373161733150482,
-0.4112946689128876,
0.13710996508598328,
-0.5821093320846558,
-0.05641799420118332,
-0.05499116703867912,
-0.45965227484703064,
0.024424439296126366,
0.42046216130256653,
-0.16367585957050323,
0.6324939131736755,
0.05600251257419586,
-0.09557072073221207,
-0.19113127887248993,
-1.0581344366073608,
-0.4704935550689697,
0.4009940028190613,
-0.3471161723136902,
0.08362281322479248,
0.03150862455368042,
-0.38562604784965515,
0.1450747400522232,
-0.699454128742218,
0.10433206707239151,
-0.18169841170310974,
-0.4071531891822815,
0.13864873349666595,
-0.11889021098613739,
0.6701421737670898,
0.6909682154655457,
-0.2050526887178421,
0.027879755944013596,
-0.3409511148929596,
0.0889543816447258,
0.31420063972473145,
-0.15899750590324402,
-0.3413296043872833,
0.3828771710395813,
-0.11092322319746017,
-0.21681922674179077,
0.6976107358932495,
-0.5424392819404602,
0.7353067994117737,
-0.18796035647392273,
0.4487590193748474,
0.8978638648986816,
-0.5333770513534546,
0.7167450189590454,
-0.11461091041564941,
0.4324920177459717,
-0.11655715852975845,
0.626815915107727,
0.029276695102453232,
-0.3265451490879059,
-0.350961834192276,
-0.3085888922214508,
-0.4969625174999237,
0.9587832093238831,
-0.7348046898841858,
0.27835485339164734,
-0.09502925723791122,
-0.2223285585641861,
-0.3582136929035187,
0.33042508363723755,
0.49793699383735657,
0.4524399936199188,
0.03185658156871796,
-0.29861709475517273,
-0.05418771132826805,
-1.1133909225463867,
0.10216566920280457,
-0.26899558305740356,
0.05242619663476944,
0.44129684567451477,
0.4712228775024414,
-0.6790747046470642,
1.0315474271774292,
-0.3093692362308502,
-0.28963160514831543,
0.1479741483926773,
-0.2695262134075165,
-0.001896774279884994,
0.518234372138977,
0.6636025905609131,
-0.7378301024436951,
-0.42446544766426086,
0.3904401659965515,
-1.065508484840393,
-0.295470267534256,
0.3450874090194702,
-0.06549499928951263,
0.2690742015838623,
0.3632979393005371,
-0.5595198273658752,
-0.14982175827026367,
0.5515590310096741,
-0.34727585315704346,
0.32609689235687256,
-0.3337976336479187,
0.15576903522014618,
-0.9643407464027405,
0.09744998067617416,
-0.44580206274986267,
-0.15032927691936493,
-0.45017096400260925,
0.37882402539253235,
-0.24558667838573456,
-0.22295469045639038,
-0.3805108964443207,
0.8974757194519043,
-0.38144659996032715,
-0.46291473507881165,
-0.6665809750556946,
0.051095932722091675,
-0.03183084726333618,
0.14742213487625122,
-0.20536953210830688,
1.2540847063064575,
0.7654390931129456,
-0.6685853004455566,
0.7404791712760925,
0.04665331169962883,
0.15213236212730408,
0.7594135403633118,
-0.6264088749885559,
0.2562134861946106,
-0.021689867600798607,
0.10964807868003845,
-0.5166608095169067,
-0.22955350577831268,
0.4094460904598236,
-0.1717955321073532,
0.10496099293231964,
0.10244022309780121,
-0.3405844569206238,
-0.222100168466568,
-0.2694171965122223,
0.43451714515686035,
0.3295270800590515,
-0.2956717610359192,
0.9243443012237549,
0.6946572065353394,
-0.15295301377773285,
-1.0119037628173828,
-0.45794135332107544,
0.3770642578601837,
-0.09469877183437347,
-0.7272116541862488,
0.3560779392719269,
-0.18912671506404877,
-0.6507670283317566,
0.5389729142189026,
0.22551329433918,
0.1733545958995819,
0.32896214723587036,
0.22447581589221954,
0.02602420002222061,
-0.15850448608398438,
0.26661935448646545,
0.16223818063735962,
-0.23780457675457,
-0.22915995121002197,
-0.5491212606430054,
0.3532140851020813,
-0.6288468837738037,
-0.37288331985473633,
-0.5572874546051025,
0.6030863523483276,
1.0884491205215454,
-0.2282518744468689,
0.5383046269416809,
0.06436562538146973,
-0.2428782433271408,
-0.21551364660263062,
-0.6288481950759888,
-0.06671205908060074,
-0.5248241424560547,
0.400496244430542,
-0.48934146761894226,
-0.6857545375823975,
0.7672924995422363,
-0.2585427463054657,
0.28118467330932617,
0.23391440510749817,
0.45030781626701355,
-0.16818542778491974,
0.8359959125518799,
0.7165634632110596,
-0.29295235872268677,
0.6751812696456909,
-0.20638687908649445,
-0.0721554160118103,
-0.9585707783699036,
-0.1280582845211029,
-0.18474239110946655,
-0.27053332328796387,
-0.22504299879074097,
-0.322197288274765,
0.5160830020904541,
-0.20035269856452942,
-0.3451639711856842,
-0.0666736587882042,
-0.7310294508934021,
0.4648280739784241,
0.48513728380203247,
-0.3666231036186218,
0.31668591499328613,
-0.20744860172271729,
0.16864116489887238,
0.5859200954437256,
-0.35452523827552795,
-0.7761539220809937,
0.7349684834480286,
0.4537643492221832,
0.7994341254234314,
0.24321569502353668,
0.5640730857849121,
0.8877314925193787,
0.3161250054836273,
-0.8819798827171326,
0.7886988520622253,
-0.33859527111053467,
-0.5145848393440247,
-0.7136031985282898,
-0.10836730897426605,
-0.8112438917160034,
0.3051750957965851,
0.13753221929073334,
-1.0031501054763794,
0.08574026823043823,
0.11823456734418869,
-0.25996947288513184,
0.22563275694847107,
-0.8377404808998108,
0.5272186994552612,
-0.553795337677002,
-0.42292118072509766,
-0.36076080799102783,
-0.6528269648551941,
0.07407506555318832,
0.17025874555110931,
0.20900844037532806,
-0.3312928378582001,
-0.4495577812194824,
0.3756023347377777,
-0.8120432496070862,
0.46479254961013794,
-0.19699561595916748,
-0.15584862232208252,
0.594796359539032,
-0.1464492231607437,
0.8473039865493774,
0.019354986026883125,
-0.3237122893333435,
0.1271970123052597,
-0.22100111842155457,
-0.2540595531463623,
-0.469128280878067,
0.8960298299789429,
-1.0449860095977783,
-0.6308505535125732,
-0.44874703884124756,
-0.8479089736938477,
0.04445626586675644,
0.0800388976931572,
-0.04782160744071007,
0.17913366854190826,
-0.1578059047460556,
-0.03910529240965843,
0.4993661940097809,
-0.2942434847354889,
0.5323405265808105,
0.6044589877128601,
-0.15735073387622833,
-0.3224866986274719,
0.9816427230834961,
0.1478467434644699,
0.27389177680015564,
0.14101167023181915,
-0.03113614208996296,
-0.10556342452764511,
-0.544523298740387,
-0.6552780270576477,
0.08843347430229187,
-0.5181288719177246,
-0.1025203987956047,
-0.7247195243835449,
-0.17922671139240265,
-0.6184002161026001,
-0.43221330642700195,
-0.6870223879814148,
0.09181082993745804,
-0.2430095672607422,
0.45003247261047363,
0.3677702248096466,
0.6900216341018677,
-0.049234285950660706,
0.7577046155929565,
-0.43852004408836365,
0.3901202082633972,
0.4204196333885193,
0.5693164467811584,
0.02158927544951439,
-0.10338959842920303,
-0.36893200874328613,
-0.1320963054895401,
-0.2776058614253998,
-0.8972890377044678,
0.30504754185676575,
0.0974622592329979,
0.6869290471076965,
0.5253015160560608,
-0.24867048859596252,
0.2085421234369278,
-0.4445226192474365,
0.4169645309448242,
-0.08489140123128891,
-1.0365209579467773,
0.5162965059280396,
-0.4332197606563568,
0.1919470727443695,
0.576038658618927,
0.019735943526029587,
-0.5476896166801453,
-0.4923073947429657,
-0.20905278623104095,
-0.8212990760803223,
1.0289047956466675,
0.07429224997758865,
-0.03956476226449013,
0.13865798711776733,
0.5212836265563965,
-0.04891638085246086,
0.44956833124160767,
-0.5606133937835693,
-0.07757282257080078,
-0.056411031633615494,
-0.14786748588085175,
0.02515103854238987,
0.058251239359378815,
-0.18898160755634308,
0.15523460507392883,
0.9649918079376221,
-0.49644553661346436,
0.3521408140659332,
0.1293620765209198,
-0.1447209268808365,
-0.2414868026971817,
0.2184070348739624,
0.5202919244766235,
0.30517852306365967,
-0.1749073565006256,
0.10047423839569092,
0.24389323592185974,
-0.6129934787750244,
0.25257569551467896,
-0.04979284480214119,
-0.4380154013633728,
-0.6241146326065063,
0.12525570392608643,
0.8786414861679077,
-0.5083312392234802,
-0.9262225031852722,
0.19389031827449799,
0.03744238242506981,
0.3648360073566437,
-0.5136280655860901,
0.3590579330921173,
-0.0009263533283956349,
0.8598782420158386,
0.8031442165374756,
-0.18190521001815796,
0.4438264071941376,
-0.9830837249755859,
-0.16195283830165863,
0.883843719959259,
-0.030777478590607643,
-0.0850946307182312,
0.455856591463089,
0.48531121015548706,
-0.5894386172294617,
0.6082033514976501,
-0.37153375148773193,
-0.6188995242118835,
0.9129036068916321,
0.40167489647865295,
1.0998412370681763,
-0.39569976925849915,
0.017032086849212646,
-0.3998968303203583,
0.6712631583213806,
-0.03624532371759415,
0.40592023730278015,
-0.09556005895137787,
-0.7541345953941345,
-0.19018588960170746,
-0.8091731071472168,
-0.648494303226471,
-0.0424782857298851,
0.009139451198279858,
0.03857191279530525,
-0.4396803677082062,
-0.30397334694862366,
-0.5627312660217285,
0.09456227719783783,
-0.27940115332603455,
0.3938828110694885,
0.4446631073951721,
0.6165403127670288,
-0.6804375052452087,
0.8372796177864075,
1.037719964981079,
0.09928737580776215,
-0.21232746541500092,
-0.10819853097200394,
0.0004953955649398267,
-1.0586137771606445,
0.5682273507118225,
-0.07285318523645401,
-0.4957503378391266,
0.1260872781276703,
-0.3966275453567505,
-1.1049916744232178,
1.24476158618927,
0.5580353140830994,
-0.45310866832733154,
-0.0041935034096241,
0.19584716856479645,
0.42356476187705994,
-0.6503764390945435,
0.30493730306625366,
0.11969136446714401,
0.6554281115531921,
-0.00105435645673424,
-0.8629930019378662,
0.056952863931655884,
-0.39243197441101074,
0.03100663051009178,
0.15681150555610657,
-1.0690032243728638,
0.8786804676055908,
-0.37196794152259827,
-0.0949188843369484,
0.1389024257659912,
0.5131120085716248,
0.19205710291862488,
0.5113328099250793,
0.7969894409179688,
0.6316080093383789,
0.6417006850242615,
-0.07472171634435654,
1.1968129873275757,
-0.5993077158927917,
0.015541753731667995,
0.7892260551452637,
-0.5204333066940308,
0.3000792860984802,
0.5373013615608215,
-0.04838108271360397,
0.234121635556221,
0.3607290983200073,
0.18047009408473969,
0.4799986481666565,
0.0371914803981781,
-0.4924488365650177,
-0.11204013973474503,
-0.5395731925964355,
-0.4316413700580597,
0.40059173107147217,
0.5068358182907104,
-0.026962174102663994,
-0.01885860413312912,
0.2438669502735138,
-0.20192699134349823,
-0.2588363587856293,
-0.19143006205558777,
0.6852396130561829,
0.08199002593755722,
-0.6506840586662292,
-0.09760718047618866,
-0.011034657247364521,
0.7078986763954163,
-0.9755285978317261,
0.20470209419727325,
-0.13692526519298553,
0.24987277388572693,
-0.06337489187717438,
-0.5979282855987549,
0.356600821018219,
-0.05930629372596741,
-0.23077911138534546,
-0.4081066846847534,
0.7940542101860046,
-0.08411574363708496,
-0.10691515356302261,
0.658260703086853,
0.3154338002204895,
0.18352444469928741,
0.015627136453986168,
-0.7003509402275085,
0.48435917496681213,
-0.4938798248767853,
-0.4317035973072052,
0.3415915369987488,
0.5582384467124939,
-0.1402050405740738,
1.0242232084274292,
0.4069146513938904,
0.0032338087912648916,
-0.15684184432029724,
-0.3824949264526367,
0.6723085641860962,
-0.43864905834198,
-0.6406908631324768,
-0.9303515553474426,
0.22920916974544525,
-0.01924656145274639,
-0.20784029364585876,
0.3898037075996399,
0.555921196937561,
0.3558017611503601,
0.01854068599641323,
0.8456870317459106,
-0.2646884620189667,
-0.03033074550330639,
-0.23439037799835205,
0.7368245124816895,
-1.0575190782546997,
0.28051674365997314,
-0.14875027537345886,
-0.8151996731758118,
0.16633105278015137,
0.3577130138874054,
-0.12963083386421204,
0.10461194068193436,
0.40053024888038635,
0.6116200685501099,
0.07477102428674698,
-0.27201321721076965,
0.33390530943870544,
0.27935096621513367,
0.17538680136203766,
0.46692797541618347,
0.8046842217445374,
-0.19650889933109283,
0.0988389253616333,
-0.15560932457447052,
-0.3434455990791321,
-0.4527343511581421,
-0.7054597735404968,
-0.29201629757881165,
-0.5764439105987549,
-0.2696866989135742,
0.012236444279551506,
0.4414866268634796,
1.0019944906234741,
0.6513665318489075,
-0.5496906638145447,
-0.7422598600387573,
-0.03877999633550644,
0.43308135867118835,
-0.06486882269382477,
-0.19852590560913086,
-0.15167289972305298,
-0.44344282150268555,
-1.1076655387878418,
0.6009188294410706,
0.7981502413749695,
0.04301939532160759,
-0.3272308111190796,
-0.4940175712108612,
-0.17129524052143097,
0.20519718527793884,
0.6624529361724854,
0.47205352783203125,
-0.6948360800743103,
-0.1697247177362442,
0.10018771141767502,
-0.532961905002594,
-0.31945499777793884,
0.5773678421974182,
-0.6078050136566162,
0.23314784467220306,
0.3416987359523773,
0.8945560455322266,
-0.13930289447307587,
-0.2993032932281494,
0.5390118956565857,
-0.45048603415489197,
0.26096248626708984,
0.3352968096733093,
0.26385271549224854,
0.11866471916437149,
-0.7567341923713684,
0.6020141243934631,
0.4040847718715668,
-0.42593130469322205,
-0.85540771484375,
0.31001046299934387,
-1.1640148162841797,
-0.49034127593040466,
0.8479539155960083,
0.21535556018352509,
-0.3143669068813324,
-0.014670115895569324,
-0.0352812260389328,
0.3229801654815674,
-0.6738125085830688,
0.7316046357154846,
0.6024645566940308,
-0.414345920085907,
0.2009471356868744,
-0.4318844974040985,
0.08460845798254013,
0.41428497433662415,
-1.0720748901367188,
-0.11761849373579025,
0.42577221989631653,
0.06265304982662201,
0.46562817692756653,
1.0303243398666382,
0.08910367637872696,
-0.014818216674029827,
-0.04699794203042984,
0.5239307880401611,
-0.1759505420923233,
-0.5450357794761658,
0.056134507060050964,
0.2690470218658447,
-0.031125327572226524,
-0.2845539152622223
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16968v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16968v1
|
Evaluating Shortest Edit Script Methods for Contextual Lemmatization
| 2024-03-25T17:28:24 | 2024-03-25T17:28:24 |
Olia Toporkov, Rodrigo Agerri
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Modern contextual lemmatizers often rely on automatically induced Shortest
Edit Scripts (SES), namely, the number of edit operations to transform a word
form into its lemma. In fact, different methods of computing SES have been
proposed as an integral component in the architecture of several
state-of-the-art contextual lemmatizers currently available. However, previous
work has not investigated the direct impact of SES in the final lemmatization
performance. In this paper we address this issue by focusing on lemmatization
as a token classification task where the only input that the model receives is
the word-label pairs in context, where the labels correspond to previously
induced SES. Thus, by modifying in our lemmatization system only the SES labels
that the model needs to learn, we may then objectively conclude which SES
representation produces the best lemmatization results. We experiment with
seven languages of different morphological complexity, namely, English,
Spanish, Basque, Russian, Czech, Turkish and Polish, using multilingual and
language-specific pre-trained masked language encoder-only models as a backbone
to build our lemmatizers. Comprehensive experimental results, both in- and
out-of-domain, indicate that computing the casing and edit operations
separately is beneficial overall, but much more clearly for languages with
high-inflected morphology. Notably, multilingual pre-trained language models
consistently outperform their language-specific counterparts in every
evaluation setting.
|
[
-0.3791698217391968,
-0.7511945366859436,
0.5489455461502075,
0.14432570338249207,
-0.44273999333381653,
-0.1689746230840683,
-0.42668208479881287,
-0.299651175737381,
0.1899978518486023,
0.26070791482925415,
-0.4352894723415375,
-0.6572083234786987,
-0.7254994511604309,
0.5107018351554871,
-0.16396564245224,
0.7315442562103271,
-0.03009146638214588,
0.2736348807811737,
-0.13477405905723572,
-0.18001340329647064,
-0.18383561074733734,
-0.639497697353363,
-0.3783269226551056,
0.11473287642002106,
0.48712700605392456,
0.23310120403766632,
0.6436601281166077,
0.7675462961196899,
0.28107950091362,
0.39099302887916565,
-0.38690608739852905,
0.07779200375080109,
0.05209580063819885,
0.019761623814702034,
-0.2972249388694763,
-0.2741549015045166,
-0.3567875325679779,
-0.2337375283241272,
0.572712242603302,
1.0293229818344116,
0.20811517536640167,
0.15207181870937347,
0.0752057433128357,
0.3872162401676178,
-0.969937264919281,
-0.10325594991445541,
-0.5743842720985413,
0.13537149131298065,
-0.460685670375824,
-0.013206235133111477,
-0.49344101548194885,
-0.10690192133188248,
0.1465080827474594,
-0.4111372232437134,
0.12768276035785675,
-0.12540321052074432,
0.37412911653518677,
0.342958003282547,
-0.4391527473926544,
-0.42789262533187866,
-0.3460237979888916,
0.596634030342102,
-0.7374983429908752,
0.6965292096138,
0.2916162610054016,
0.12878632545471191,
-0.05101851746439934,
-0.7376384735107422,
-0.517584502696991,
-0.10908184945583344,
-0.2425040304660797,
0.11532339453697205,
-0.12068937718868256,
0.37882310152053833,
0.4123400151729584,
0.057760316878557205,
-0.33402949571609497,
0.4685039222240448,
-0.3704456090927124,
-0.5051515102386475,
0.2807016670703888,
-0.016997726634144783,
0.29346609115600586,
-0.35343223810195923,
0.015481369569897652,
0.19865472614765167,
-0.5860643982887268,
0.053047072142362595,
0.3170621991157532,
0.2755749225616455,
0.17022250592708588,
0.7390848994255066,
-0.2494305968284607,
0.7900805473327637,
-0.02921028435230255,
-0.21505461633205414,
0.11176528036594391,
-0.3460320830345154,
-0.3270207643508911,
0.12444209307432175,
0.4924871027469635,
0.22666659951210022,
-0.025179423391819,
-0.11794564127922058,
-0.3027406632900238,
0.07371266186237335,
-0.06057170778512955,
-0.9479343295097351,
0.13757026195526123,
-0.018441583961248398,
-0.2439897209405899,
0.0175072830170393,
-0.18918058276176453,
-0.5755478143692017,
-0.22973859310150146,
-0.27748405933380127,
0.587253749370575,
-0.46961119771003723,
0.20593416690826416,
0.16568899154663086,
-0.034343522042036057,
0.030214823782444,
0.5293878316879272,
-0.7528258562088013,
0.36205607652664185,
0.5857707262039185,
0.9803887009620667,
-0.2584603428840637,
-0.2882072925567627,
-0.8122993111610413,
0.015559783205389977,
-0.4841131865978241,
0.6257003545761108,
-0.5950283408164978,
-0.5200225710868835,
0.11388736963272095,
0.16224874556064606,
-0.40406090021133423,
-0.4541085362434387,
0.4133026599884033,
-0.4351619780063629,
0.19800429046154022,
-0.0753081813454628,
-0.8636587858200073,
0.1830120086669922,
-0.08218163996934891,
-0.49629947543144226,
0.8040876984596252,
-0.015445956028997898,
-0.7209124565124512,
0.3536548912525177,
-0.816591739654541,
-0.5766746401786804,
-0.08809854835271835,
0.18539461493492126,
-0.26342952251434326,
0.2865743935108185,
0.37157362699508667,
0.5150671005249023,
0.1515875905752182,
0.03337927907705307,
-0.1554577797651291,
-0.4245110750198364,
0.22987213730812073,
-0.3772980570793152,
0.5231136679649353,
0.05729682371020317,
-0.4420383870601654,
0.19027964770793915,
-0.5525683164596558,
-0.15615303814411163,
-0.13872572779655457,
-0.29810622334480286,
-0.5660174489021301,
-0.26536619663238525,
-0.06122396141290665,
0.2192179411649704,
0.1456131488084793,
-0.6143982410430908,
0.06786138564348221,
-0.5167171955108643,
0.33205080032348633,
0.9570135474205017,
0.10623607784509659,
0.6072501540184021,
0.21849292516708374,
0.40487736463546753,
-0.014169915579259396,
0.18536561727523804,
-0.4571729898452759,
-0.29580554366111755,
-1.0195332765579224,
-0.4345966577529907,
0.755565345287323,
0.31248578429222107,
-0.743596613407135,
0.326185941696167,
-0.15479885041713715,
-0.3546241521835327,
-0.35633885860443115,
0.11668122559785843,
0.6345605850219727,
0.47493794560432434,
0.25071486830711365,
-0.4369647204875946,
-0.5050591826438904,
-0.9724405407905579,
-0.41929516196250916,
0.05881212651729584,
0.19162455201148987,
0.026205597445368767,
0.7004920244216919,
-0.3617912232875824,
0.9483960270881653,
-0.340105801820755,
-0.21505886316299438,
-0.21117736399173737,
-0.06463583558797836,
-0.06321422755718231,
0.42362985014915466,
0.6593940854072571,
-0.35374608635902405,
-0.4575572609901428,
-0.0573984794318676,
-0.3285999000072479,
-0.44170334935188293,
0.16020137071609497,
-0.046159882098436356,
0.5745697617530823,
0.7152281999588013,
-0.5111366510391235,
0.7156538367271423,
0.2669825553894043,
-0.15239748358726501,
0.6888095736503601,
-0.2765008509159088,
-0.0022105458192527294,
-0.8497490286827087,
-0.05707128345966339,
-0.15381161868572235,
-0.236525297164917,
-0.7260259985923767,
-0.022674541920423508,
0.14601373672485352,
0.0980837494134903,
-0.896470308303833,
0.8913943767547607,
-0.43938761949539185,
-0.472072035074234,
-0.07985929399728775,
0.16537439823150635,
-0.04506509378552437,
0.6600325703620911,
0.04881801828742027,
0.8762325048446655,
0.4203576445579529,
-0.6622336506843567,
-0.09692007303237915,
0.07381173223257065,
-0.5159044861793518,
0.5234495997428894,
-0.4319184720516205,
0.34452706575393677,
-0.17802190780639648,
0.1838531494140625,
-0.6374838948249817,
-0.32381772994995117,
0.04073687642812729,
-0.18406470119953156,
0.09928473085165024,
-0.44295236468315125,
-0.7088773250579834,
-0.0465015284717083,
-0.2680320739746094,
0.2482004165649414,
0.3807324469089508,
-0.6521422863006592,
0.39989587664604187,
0.2730239927768707,
-0.21627792716026306,
-0.5966715812683105,
-0.5091919302940369,
-0.09959715604782104,
-0.3107791841030121,
-0.36340638995170593,
0.4551178514957428,
-0.15804530680179596,
-0.355515718460083,
-0.05672257021069527,
-0.3279353082180023,
-0.11223653703927994,
0.10450523346662521,
0.06150176003575325,
-0.037964433431625366,
-0.016551287844777107,
0.0814654678106308,
0.5362141132354736,
-0.10387011617422104,
-0.2727160155773163,
-0.2728899121284485,
0.5646077990531921,
-0.17025521397590637,
-0.6033927798271179,
-0.4458131492137909,
0.15437938272953033,
0.5130764245986938,
-0.2331322431564331,
0.5799052715301514,
0.6310679316520691,
-0.46568402647972107,
-0.09738870710134506,
-0.5072675347328186,
0.12982432544231415,
-0.45787104964256287,
0.4831826388835907,
-0.6382307410240173,
-1.0270140171051025,
0.6824917793273926,
-0.3127681314945221,
-0.06419232487678528,
0.4484262466430664,
0.4885733425617218,
0.09793513268232346,
1.09519624710083,
0.4525395631790161,
0.29829519987106323,
0.6384837627410889,
-0.25266051292419434,
-0.07292438298463821,
-0.9288903474807739,
-0.09584666043519974,
-0.49083811044692993,
-0.0321040004491806,
-0.3680582046508789,
-0.5388604998588562,
0.5961475968360901,
0.30949848890304565,
0.11760487407445908,
0.3739432990550995,
-0.17382469773292542,
0.7540971636772156,
0.2680685818195343,
-0.049490705132484436,
0.07644419372081757,
-0.062220990657806396,
-0.5344256162643433,
-0.16044971346855164,
-0.7085845470428467,
-0.539770245552063,
0.9039667248725891,
0.16994866728782654,
0.43814077973365784,
0.12733720242977142,
0.8557614684104919,
0.2350253462791443,
0.15659315884113312,
-0.8333798050880432,
0.6157429814338684,
-0.2398131936788559,
-0.08732055127620697,
-0.3671621084213257,
-0.015790477395057678,
-0.9269856214523315,
0.7407232522964478,
0.048528216779232025,
-0.8777729868888855,
0.24896080791950226,
0.015742167830467224,
-0.33340248465538025,
0.1622219681739807,
-0.8530778288841248,
0.9692836999893188,
-0.13673444092273712,
-0.4435618221759796,
-0.22230878472328186,
-0.539339005947113,
0.1421407014131546,
-0.2609129846096039,
0.5403088927268982,
0.09051679819822311,
-0.1962222456932068,
0.9909234642982483,
-0.8204525113105774,
0.9035147428512573,
-0.26419389247894287,
0.04166463017463684,
0.20083878934383392,
0.26083773374557495,
0.34928733110427856,
0.07888080179691315,
-0.02695709839463234,
0.252148300409317,
0.1732916384935379,
-0.29041966795921326,
-0.6769353747367859,
0.5435668230056763,
-0.5244941711425781,
-0.6945180892944336,
-0.37748658657073975,
-0.06359755992889404,
-0.15905877947807312,
0.406665563583374,
0.4095546007156372,
0.6148983836174011,
-0.31987252831459045,
0.006090288981795311,
0.33923155069351196,
-0.25057706236839294,
0.7671597003936768,
0.3670652508735657,
-0.2174479216337204,
-0.4490194320678711,
0.6023536920547485,
0.3627702593803406,
0.23607057332992554,
0.17845748364925385,
0.24444249272346497,
-0.3074866831302643,
-0.6595340371131897,
-0.7275194525718689,
0.16247344017028809,
-1.116841197013855,
-0.18797825276851654,
-0.819198489189148,
-0.12436029314994812,
-0.45759502053260803,
-0.388579785823822,
-0.3848532438278198,
-0.6628311276435852,
-0.20953597128391266,
-0.18727998435497284,
0.07104387879371643,
0.6455263495445251,
-0.2079901248216629,
0.44559258222579956,
-0.6233206987380981,
0.05420057475566864,
0.40250200033187866,
0.2603265047073364,
-0.2774370014667511,
-0.435646116733551,
-0.4850359261035919,
-0.16244983673095703,
-0.020021438598632812,
-1.0105162858963013,
0.29577866196632385,
0.396842360496521,
0.5159225463867188,
0.22131463885307312,
-0.14786674082279205,
1.0608383417129517,
-0.7006402015686035,
0.765961766242981,
-0.0785461813211441,
-1.5179344415664673,
0.5241477489471436,
-0.033194828778505325,
0.31406742334365845,
0.5428418517112732,
-0.010030512697994709,
-0.6321749687194824,
-0.2447131872177124,
-0.47038838267326355,
-0.7085078358650208,
0.9010626673698425,
0.24414193630218506,
0.16912449896335602,
-0.19000229239463806,
0.3149833083152771,
0.3122926652431488,
0.2118229866027832,
-0.2985312342643738,
-0.05917496979236603,
-0.05893147364258766,
-0.05967622250318527,
0.0070844246074557304,
-0.32099828124046326,
0.29883643984794617,
-0.30055734515190125,
0.42853352427482605,
-0.22458568215370178,
0.09354840964078903,
0.2678159475326538,
-0.7711986303329468,
0.1098347008228302,
0.4714124798774719,
0.8759124875068665,
0.618636965751648,
-0.030605729669332504,
0.3873549997806549,
0.5719220638275146,
-0.3310912549495697,
-0.10405116528272629,
-0.21313509345054626,
-0.15259379148483276,
0.412091463804245,
0.602543830871582,
1.051403522491455,
0.4060370922088623,
-0.72330641746521,
0.7322171330451965,
0.03192271292209625,
0.03897553309798241,
-0.1707119643688202,
-0.07972416281700134,
-0.2755134403705597,
-0.060588207095861435,
0.0785994753241539,
0.2786823511123657,
0.3670608103275299,
-0.3264666199684143,
0.1947227418422699,
0.35215580463409424,
-0.20407624542713165,
-0.5555121302604675,
0.286773681640625,
0.05915176495909691,
-0.4130991995334625,
0.15415270626544952,
-0.15469156205654144,
-0.8985044360160828,
0.5502037405967712,
0.5927146673202515,
0.9386269450187683,
-0.40090399980545044,
0.049776721745729446,
0.3544744551181793,
0.2908046245574951,
0.17107507586479187,
-0.17018987238407135,
-0.3116726875305176,
-0.5386170744895935,
-0.5292242169380188,
-0.7517596483230591,
-0.5100330710411072,
-0.031585246324539185,
-0.4148467779159546,
0.4650578498840332,
-0.4719648063182831,
-0.15745605528354645,
0.07506878674030304,
-0.33204352855682373,
-0.7571603655815125,
0.1753431111574173,
-0.00923600047826767,
0.8732956647872925,
-0.6869471669197083,
0.7181628346443176,
0.6974138617515564,
-0.054645977914333344,
-0.3461513817310333,
0.0072674318216741085,
0.0033664258662611246,
-0.613029956817627,
0.7743740081787109,
0.3472626805305481,
-0.32147282361984253,
0.09082207083702087,
-0.3249934911727905,
-0.8742552995681763,
0.7542040348052979,
0.4011566638946533,
-0.24427452683448792,
0.10868999361991882,
0.1794857233762741,
0.6711974143981934,
-0.3943922221660614,
0.32532352209091187,
0.6906859278678894,
0.4013749957084656,
-0.02670031413435936,
-1.2084381580352783,
-0.2056557983160019,
-0.2952236831188202,
0.12535788118839264,
-0.009906688705086708,
-0.31136414408683777,
0.6506259441375732,
-0.1578800529241562,
-0.44430655241012573,
0.12857216596603394,
0.47300291061401367,
-0.004580545239150524,
0.24981972575187683,
0.5622391104698181,
0.3803228735923767,
0.5091269612312317,
-0.044459085911512375,
0.9200762510299683,
-0.22873830795288086,
0.16893401741981506,
0.8076040744781494,
-0.11437004059553146,
0.7388745546340942,
0.5525558590888977,
-0.06254392862319946,
0.40986713767051697,
0.8051944375038147,
0.5058080554008484,
0.524494469165802,
0.10792567580938339,
-0.08934316039085388,
-0.14915180206298828,
-0.2603986859321594,
-0.16152840852737427,
0.5057191848754883,
0.44555574655532837,
-0.1330803483724594,
-0.11321216076612473,
0.29103851318359375,
0.2680341899394989,
-0.03883349895477295,
-0.32147571444511414,
0.975074052810669,
-0.07078732550144196,
-0.6003245711326599,
0.4941239356994629,
0.43288323283195496,
0.7807045578956604,
-0.4603124260902405,
0.18373432755470276,
-0.3697910010814667,
-0.009191860444843769,
-0.155808687210083,
-0.504338800907135,
0.4514343738555908,
0.18683429062366486,
0.14113561809062958,
-0.12093213200569153,
0.600655198097229,
-0.3667345345020294,
-0.39738211035728455,
0.19511207938194275,
0.5203413963317871,
0.17077353596687317,
0.2246595025062561,
-0.4889949560165405,
0.20025332272052765,
-0.3049873411655426,
-0.266792356967926,
0.3662336468696594,
0.3165108859539032,
-0.3634099066257477,
0.4221850335597992,
0.8015570044517517,
0.03162616491317749,
0.36257341504096985,
0.2429002970457077,
0.6883195638656616,
-0.46301907300949097,
-0.7394105792045593,
-1.0597485303878784,
0.4084499776363373,
-0.04335525259375572,
-0.16886310279369354,
0.7632120847702026,
0.7300136685371399,
1.0505001544952393,
-0.25795331597328186,
0.6549645066261292,
0.16831819713115692,
0.12301361560821533,
-0.8655243515968323,
0.3134707510471344,
-0.5921826958656311,
0.1505015790462494,
-0.6183204650878906,
-1.093058705329895,
-0.643867552280426,
0.5152083039283752,
-0.47297346591949463,
-0.11378826200962067,
0.8786700963973999,
0.7026603817939758,
0.020578579977154732,
-0.3415486216545105,
0.5012699365615845,
-0.011857107281684875,
0.0363822802901268,
0.2584989666938782,
0.8703568577766418,
-0.33079954981803894,
0.14985501766204834,
-0.47413715720176697,
-0.035502295941114426,
-0.3072972595691681,
-0.6769044995307922,
-0.9735987782478333,
-0.652525782585144,
-0.32052382826805115,
-0.16283728182315826,
0.04858481511473656,
1.0641775131225586,
0.5677027702331543,
-0.6736146211624146,
-0.10269726067781448,
0.1414165496826172,
0.3696088492870331,
-0.0953463613986969,
-0.14627191424369812,
0.7287169694900513,
-0.4526946246623993,
-1.1330324411392212,
0.5309825539588928,
0.6377710103988647,
0.17027755081653595,
-0.03394713252782822,
-0.19165317714214325,
0.19567695260047913,
0.2962654232978821,
0.8114331364631653,
0.036893703043460846,
-0.9485878348350525,
-0.3616568446159363,
0.15850409865379333,
-0.1861175298690796,
-0.08540806919336319,
0.91253262758255,
-0.5830011963844299,
0.7108439803123474,
0.40444913506507874,
0.5690874457359314,
0.4522415101528168,
-0.24120134115219116,
0.1800643801689148,
-1.018347144126892,
0.46536552906036377,
-0.07182455062866211,
0.6893013119697571,
0.41457217931747437,
-0.1552070826292038,
0.4818978011608124,
0.3329147398471832,
-0.16726651787757874,
-1.0807465314865112,
0.29789918661117554,
-0.678706169128418,
-0.3366466164588928,
1.1380494832992554,
-0.1530042141675949,
-0.41541287302970886,
-0.1530548632144928,
-0.4607381522655487,
0.32863569259643555,
-0.0347989946603775,
0.31192439794540405,
0.553856372833252,
-0.11609335988759995,
-0.11616690456867218,
-0.2041117399930954,
0.618476927280426,
0.4425790011882782,
-0.5451676845550537,
-0.09862016886472702,
0.5374540686607361,
0.32081714272499084,
0.14849643409252167,
0.7053649425506592,
-0.05609830841422081,
0.18520845472812653,
-0.25244539976119995,
0.023420732468366623,
-0.11543554067611694,
-0.28198763728141785,
-0.613715648651123,
0.06487617641687393,
-0.018122199922800064,
-0.07094994187355042
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00051v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00051v1
|
Deja vu: Contrastive Historical Modeling with Prefix-tuning for Temporal Knowledge Graph Reasoning
| 2024-03-25T17:25:40 | 2024-03-25T17:25:40 |
Miao Peng, Ben Liu, Wenjie Xu, Zihao Jiang, Jiahui Zhu, Min Peng
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Temporal Knowledge Graph Reasoning (TKGR) is the task of inferring missing
facts for incomplete TKGs in complex scenarios (e.g., transductive and
inductive settings), which has been gaining increasing attention. Recently, to
mitigate dependence on structured connections in TKGs, text-based methods have
been developed to utilize rich linguistic information from entity descriptions.
However, suffering from the enormous parameters and inflexibility of
pre-trained language models, existing text-based methods struggle to balance
the textual knowledge and temporal information with computationally expensive
purpose-built training strategies. To tap the potential of text-based models
for TKGR in various complex scenarios, we propose ChapTER, a Contrastive
historical modeling framework with prefix-tuning for TEmporal Reasoning.
ChapTER feeds history-contextualized text into the pseudo-Siamese encoders to
strike a textual-temporal balance via contrastive estimation between queries
and candidates. By introducing virtual time prefix tokens, it applies a
prefix-based tuning method to facilitate the frozen PLM capable for TKGR tasks
under different settings. We evaluate ChapTER on four transductive and three
few-shot inductive TKGR benchmarks, and experimental results demonstrate that
ChapTER achieves superior performance compared to competitive baselines with
only 0.17% tuned parameters. We conduct thorough analysis to verify the
effectiveness, flexibility and efficiency of ChapTER.
|
[
-0.31105634570121765,
-0.7557814121246338,
0.5025969743728638,
-0.20482981204986572,
-0.6210836172103882,
0.2777233421802521,
0.012409386225044727,
-0.3006681799888611,
-0.05989762768149376,
0.41645804047584534,
-0.6946266293525696,
-0.7284597158432007,
-0.2561867833137512,
0.10398878902196884,
0.11283385753631592,
0.7136533856391907,
-0.2103670984506607,
-0.17075273394584656,
-0.12642012536525726,
-0.12177838385105133,
-0.5505433678627014,
-0.35888728499412537,
-0.565777599811554,
-0.9913013577461243,
0.16413386166095734,
0.3694765865802765,
0.7304888367652893,
0.8630113005638123,
0.0032011668663471937,
0.18253324925899506,
-0.3257129490375519,
0.26782262325286865,
-0.5085059404373169,
0.1550222933292389,
-0.2468690276145935,
-0.2451166808605194,
-0.4409180283546448,
-0.31195327639579773,
0.4753607213497162,
0.7642775177955627,
0.07956454157829285,
-0.17294032871723175,
0.02708316408097744,
0.4040752351284027,
-0.5218948721885681,
0.4797602891921997,
-0.7343897223472595,
0.16366760432720184,
-0.13761159777641296,
-0.4826168119907379,
-0.21212247014045715,
-0.2385154664516449,
0.143900066614151,
-0.8519885540008545,
0.42116913199424744,
0.0694359689950943,
1.042762041091919,
0.4498251676559448,
-0.7671980857849121,
0.01422743871808052,
-0.7763308882713318,
0.8358014225959778,
-0.8719711899757385,
0.5916873812675476,
0.5738573670387268,
0.34336066246032715,
-0.12055595219135284,
-1.0526260137557983,
-0.6019986271858215,
-0.19799940288066864,
-0.3878070116043091,
0.16271443665027618,
0.17545396089553833,
0.13974528014659882,
0.3798830807209015,
0.3395121991634369,
-0.7316588163375854,
0.22602829337120056,
0.022250685840845108,
-0.07415539771318436,
0.19568827748298645,
0.6313070058822632,
0.023290017619729042,
-0.21997715532779694,
-0.22912481427192688,
-0.11174025386571884,
-0.5217183232307434,
-0.17470520734786987,
0.3451261520385742,
0.20396015048027039,
-0.17068149149417877,
0.4067542850971222,
-0.37079763412475586,
0.9960112571716309,
0.023192409425973892,
-0.22270655632019043,
0.07695460319519043,
-0.5047823190689087,
-0.14450502395629883,
0.1295127123594284,
0.4775475859642029,
0.6514772772789001,
0.26607832312583923,
-0.4827881455421448,
0.03472071513533592,
0.12862534821033478,
0.2559053897857666,
-0.8809430003166199,
-0.3599536716938019,
-0.11693045496940613,
-0.3711562752723694,
-0.16446737945079803,
-0.4592198431491852,
-0.9145577549934387,
-0.1658012866973877,
-0.4998753070831299,
0.24951134622097015,
-0.6113549470901489,
-0.24608072638511658,
0.11411064863204956,
-0.21326997876167297,
0.14018242061138153,
0.2671903073787689,
-0.7363355159759521,
0.19372829794883728,
0.6966557502746582,
0.7329885959625244,
0.0754520371556282,
-0.05934780091047287,
-0.3047281801700592,
0.4638122022151947,
-0.3486795723438263,
0.521237850189209,
-0.8847079277038574,
-0.7533729672431946,
-0.1570136696100235,
-0.008642161265015602,
-0.002782081952318549,
-0.4044628441333771,
0.5636239647865295,
-0.6846755743026733,
0.021428415551781654,
-0.14864127337932587,
-0.7745007872581482,
-0.158083975315094,
0.447540283203125,
-0.5459417700767517,
1.0566691160202026,
0.14534299075603485,
-0.8648395538330078,
0.5310755372047424,
-0.15706638991832733,
-0.35905206203460693,
0.18878526985645294,
-0.06649475544691086,
-0.5703698992729187,
-0.38710469007492065,
0.3144562244415283,
0.0559244379401207,
-0.3138921856880188,
0.47908326983451843,
-0.4784342050552368,
-0.2267122119665146,
-0.2686089873313904,
-0.03995233029127121,
0.6805038452148438,
0.321353018283844,
-0.34901875257492065,
-0.17524155974388123,
-0.729267954826355,
-0.010740399360656738,
0.07503984868526459,
-0.06773291528224945,
-0.734122633934021,
0.02774197608232498,
-0.25328272581100464,
-0.02035101316869259,
-0.05367300286889076,
-0.3213692605495453,
0.44293802976608276,
-0.5722251534461975,
0.4922771453857422,
0.26723065972328186,
0.20308518409729004,
0.3746327757835388,
-0.22225168347358704,
0.4084818661212921,
0.1854114532470703,
0.03957250341773033,
-0.4581247866153717,
-0.19652725756168365,
-0.6595070362091064,
0.09467536956071854,
0.46433332562446594,
0.45939400792121887,
-1.2413074970245361,
0.25662723183631897,
-0.4639529585838318,
-0.3837079405784607,
-0.03587882220745087,
-0.27612680196762085,
0.3277139365673065,
1.2457250356674194,
0.4458865821361542,
0.053972307592630386,
-0.5405182242393494,
-0.8686275482177734,
-0.32662078738212585,
-0.4070001244544983,
-0.020520402118563652,
0.46370095014572144,
0.4603494703769684,
0.06823865324258804,
0.9913638234138489,
-0.7368367314338684,
0.012006809934973717,
0.11799731105566025,
0.5393103957176208,
0.06056976318359375,
0.38437095284461975,
0.5356767177581787,
-0.9378624558448792,
-0.2387615293264389,
0.08166102319955826,
-0.7165735363960266,
-0.27267879247665405,
0.11160148680210114,
-0.09048189967870712,
0.27126067876815796,
0.7861236333847046,
-0.2929259240627289,
0.3940482437610626,
0.0887172594666481,
-0.5507799983024597,
0.4186888337135315,
-0.05636157467961311,
0.36707741022109985,
-1.1881189346313477,
0.14069679379463196,
-0.08596204221248627,
-0.28887662291526794,
-0.52113938331604,
-0.1624993234872818,
0.1864338219165802,
-0.17805904150009155,
-0.11471720039844513,
1.0889078378677368,
-0.2137795090675354,
0.4066193699836731,
-0.1727709174156189,
-0.022252624854445457,
-0.054626356810331345,
0.5269937515258789,
0.17653484642505646,
0.38614338636398315,
0.058754194527864456,
-0.6502790451049805,
0.10358379781246185,
0.15871281921863556,
-0.1864665299654007,
0.503363311290741,
-0.4424266815185547,
0.17860294878482819,
-0.09220226854085922,
0.1750817745923996,
-0.9356988668441772,
-0.044642288237810135,
0.32224753499031067,
-0.2575148642063141,
0.783701479434967,
-0.5467177629470825,
-0.5769395232200623,
-0.23672261834144592,
0.03673833608627319,
0.6704506278038025,
0.5597689747810364,
-0.5059411525726318,
0.8868790864944458,
0.0558476597070694,
-0.13966025412082672,
-0.6777676343917847,
-0.46286454796791077,
0.08687492460012436,
-0.3874801695346832,
-0.3669787645339966,
0.7446915507316589,
0.06992135941982269,
-0.31471535563468933,
0.3801507353782654,
-0.4786219894886017,
-0.1723843514919281,
0.04959900304675102,
0.08467518538236618,
0.1677648276090622,
-0.24929706752300262,
0.4502426087856293,
0.2088005542755127,
-0.248048335313797,
-0.43950986862182617,
-0.7158721685409546,
0.4575929045677185,
-0.02886803075671196,
-0.10607662051916122,
0.15965449810028076,
0.010500242002308369,
0.19530723989009857,
0.05788419023156166,
0.6685423851013184,
0.28891468048095703,
-0.3144564628601074,
-0.17848412692546844,
-0.6594327092170715,
-0.18095439672470093,
-0.40387898683547974,
0.15924061834812164,
-0.3315044045448303,
-0.9420453906059265,
0.5223387479782104,
-0.3908919394016266,
-0.04011869430541992,
0.5449512004852295,
0.40231284499168396,
-0.026828158646821976,
0.46015986800193787,
0.38548627495765686,
0.16233810782432556,
0.5222542881965637,
-0.06975654512643814,
-0.17109814286231995,
-0.2948899567127228,
-0.5824281573295593,
-0.6918638944625854,
-0.2723800837993622,
-0.7112992405891418,
-0.05091648921370506,
0.5469560027122498,
0.3838215470314026,
-0.6451752185821533,
-0.0014901868999004364,
-0.15363307297229767,
0.49689406156539917,
0.3011402487754822,
0.20556047558784485,
0.5714550614356995,
-0.17374131083488464,
-0.32965874671936035,
-0.30036431550979614,
-0.7560763955116272,
-0.39424675703048706,
0.7617607712745667,
-0.18281535804271698,
0.8037427067756653,
-0.2519944906234741,
0.3769051432609558,
0.2625278830528259,
-0.044362545013427734,
-0.6929244995117188,
0.43585503101348877,
-0.28161218762397766,
-0.3976071774959564,
-0.23078866302967072,
-0.6202375292778015,
-0.9206613302230835,
0.07069365680217743,
-0.02761167660355568,
-0.5545534491539001,
0.025590170174837112,
0.36131182312965393,
0.08247236907482147,
0.48816028237342834,
-0.6214815378189087,
1.0958731174468994,
-0.001391325844451785,
-0.30555441975593567,
-0.12190153449773788,
-0.9479048848152161,
0.17405590415000916,
0.07857342064380646,
-0.17877112329006195,
0.038030873984098434,
-0.2301485389471054,
0.3837871849536896,
-0.46670567989349365,
1.000758171081543,
-0.06501724570989609,
0.27642640471458435,
0.07357025146484375,
0.43661046028137207,
0.5772112011909485,
-0.0834391787648201,
-0.10552367568016052,
0.30939966440200806,
-0.019269531592726707,
-0.3990190327167511,
-0.7146044969558716,
0.6982274055480957,
-0.6153118014335632,
-0.6523316502571106,
-0.11025789380073547,
-0.628859281539917,
-0.27903831005096436,
0.2739933133125305,
0.27251434326171875,
0.6779481172561646,
-0.26551124453544617,
0.06886700540781021,
0.6206660270690918,
-0.14558593928813934,
0.601243793964386,
0.6325046420097351,
0.044374313205480576,
-0.34882059693336487,
0.5441902875900269,
0.22301584482192993,
0.0039007042068988085,
0.9440370798110962,
0.24971577525138855,
-0.3970220983028412,
-0.4013328552246094,
-0.40000611543655396,
0.3025156557559967,
-0.7295274138450623,
-0.3400154709815979,
-0.805949330329895,
-0.07263887673616409,
-0.18794368207454681,
-0.15081779658794403,
-0.16964004933834076,
-0.7423920631408691,
-0.42729392647743225,
-0.02230401150882244,
0.4505990445613861,
0.4060302972793579,
0.2628462016582489,
0.22452270984649658,
-0.7029561996459961,
0.420339435338974,
0.20105217397212982,
0.5436250567436218,
0.12258800119161606,
-0.39393067359924316,
-0.19081328809261322,
-0.3445238769054413,
-0.503807544708252,
-0.8113422393798828,
0.23865345120429993,
0.12112551182508469,
0.5857588052749634,
0.05707230418920517,
0.36890020966529846,
0.6698749661445618,
-0.5060520768165588,
0.8620743155479431,
-0.13778415322303772,
-0.9150869250297546,
0.5249686241149902,
-0.44215846061706543,
0.4812535047531128,
0.2645684778690338,
0.4713246524333954,
-0.5325019359588623,
-0.3073752224445343,
-0.7014548778533936,
-0.9989703297615051,
0.8257853984832764,
0.2075808197259903,
-0.34188419580459595,
0.05603615194559097,
0.6668605804443359,
0.46642759442329407,
0.2324233055114746,
-0.43884867429733276,
-0.3571878671646118,
-0.5942127704620361,
-0.213987797498703,
-0.11179842799901962,
-0.23839561641216278,
0.10337385535240173,
-0.025123819708824158,
0.601097583770752,
-0.14326977729797363,
-0.26414433121681213,
0.03195123001933098,
-0.05180725082755089,
0.032293371856212616,
0.42853811383247375,
0.4556458592414856,
0.8179183602333069,
-0.1615244597196579,
0.3454532325267792,
0.32673656940460205,
-0.1600089967250824,
0.07829609513282776,
0.4267822504043579,
-0.32983145117759705,
0.182015061378479,
0.5785652995109558,
0.9898601174354553,
0.3029196560382843,
-0.18622025847434998,
-0.06076133996248245,
0.16879025101661682,
-0.09323973953723907,
0.07000480592250824,
-0.12442054599523544,
0.14778149127960205,
0.502221405506134,
0.2215275764465332,
-0.41687870025634766,
-0.06221611797809601,
-0.14540980756282806,
-0.10202214121818542,
0.2214031219482422,
-0.2238989621400833,
-0.21530582010746002,
0.7638821601867676,
0.16193869709968567,
-0.2524948716163635,
0.8343484401702881,
-0.18887683749198914,
-0.5241239070892334,
0.7437143921852112,
0.40451478958129883,
0.8678369522094727,
-0.20579516887664795,
-0.08641231805086136,
0.4983631670475006,
0.21876344084739685,
-0.05574895441532135,
0.09924312680959702,
-0.2868114113807678,
-0.4635452330112457,
-0.3679991662502289,
-0.47206756472587585,
-0.3163701295852661,
0.35177409648895264,
-0.4156300127506256,
0.3442741334438324,
0.026940513402223587,
-0.3151329755783081,
-0.06863816827535629,
0.07600249350070953,
-0.7867933511734009,
0.15209414064884186,
-0.09023686498403549,
0.8642074465751648,
-0.8318106532096863,
0.6898988485336304,
0.5574164986610413,
-0.18821486830711365,
-0.5156705379486084,
0.2609013617038727,
-0.06635124981403351,
-0.508508026599884,
0.9829543828964233,
-0.35693350434303284,
-0.18973815441131592,
0.03667685389518738,
-0.42889171838760376,
-0.297895610332489,
1.1591829061508179,
0.5691292881965637,
-0.5559890866279602,
-0.25792333483695984,
0.018893560394644737,
0.7323282957077026,
-0.04281055927276611,
0.09420072287321091,
0.5040489435195923,
0.3982008099555969,
0.3778981566429138,
-0.991689145565033,
0.027120092883706093,
-0.09260839968919754,
0.13807076215744019,
0.6495828628540039,
-0.4791613817214966,
0.7246297597885132,
0.06959092617034912,
-0.3694133460521698,
0.048147011548280716,
0.4353311359882355,
0.10919936001300812,
0.8394166231155396,
0.3864991366863251,
0.8537092208862305,
0.5246216654777527,
-0.2641471028327942,
1.1557539701461792,
-0.19250606000423431,
0.28635069727897644,
1.2843958139419556,
-0.23810924589633942,
0.08916488289833069,
0.3381843566894531,
0.007010302506387234,
0.3390534818172455,
0.7737072706222534,
0.03886329010128975,
0.7215180397033691,
-0.09854114055633545,
-0.18552549183368683,
-0.5376498699188232,
-0.38170453906059265,
-0.5599152445793152,
0.09304814785718918,
0.28768396377563477,
-0.301849365234375,
-0.607181191444397,
-0.16415049135684967,
0.10208439081907272,
0.007833865471184254,
-0.46989360451698303,
0.8688697218894958,
0.22204431891441345,
-0.6694555282592773,
0.5148236155509949,
-0.1277807205915451,
0.12084542959928513,
-0.7854917049407959,
-0.3777492642402649,
-0.4977250397205353,
0.1199491024017334,
0.04296443238854408,
-0.7885954976081848,
0.22054648399353027,
-0.09477243572473526,
-0.2534269690513611,
-0.17570216953754425,
0.7316386699676514,
-0.4467249810695648,
-0.24632258713245392,
0.22862792015075684,
0.4801974594593048,
-0.16090965270996094,
0.37243080139160156,
-0.3736354112625122,
-0.23136156797409058,
-0.29624587297439575,
-0.22474879026412964,
0.0924970954656601,
0.7897077202796936,
-0.38105034828186035,
0.6344646215438843,
0.0019571788143366575,
-0.10437231510877609,
-0.3467463254928589,
0.22646190226078033,
0.8995605111122131,
-0.9306572079658508,
-0.9320598244667053,
-1.1331621408462524,
0.19241531193256378,
0.11529850959777832,
-0.2068369835615158,
0.48804089426994324,
0.6720143556594849,
1.006023645401001,
0.03073708340525627,
0.51865154504776,
0.24027825891971588,
0.5251663327217102,
-0.9604752063751221,
0.5257381200790405,
-0.7717187404632568,
0.28879961371421814,
-0.13455046713352203,
-0.5493289232254028,
-0.2570508122444153,
-0.1441282480955124,
-0.34166571497917175,
0.31347155570983887,
0.7347078919410706,
0.6884535551071167,
-0.14405997097492218,
0.23083798587322235,
0.29963186383247375,
0.3018903434276581,
0.22779518365859985,
0.6138911247253418,
0.8995843529701233,
-0.08908548206090927,
0.7784337997436523,
-0.07026110589504242,
0.20177926123142242,
-0.27112704515457153,
-1.3157718181610107,
-1.1053987741470337,
-0.7667559385299683,
-0.3619893193244934,
-0.4763304591178894,
0.41004374623298645,
0.8246371150016785,
0.5103265643119812,
-0.5153608322143555,
0.014707925729453564,
0.10343675315380096,
0.24177893996238708,
-0.08686352521181107,
-0.2059299349784851,
0.4995940029621124,
-0.2620902359485626,
-0.5648826956748962,
0.23069117963314056,
0.10172687470912933,
0.2916296422481537,
0.35323357582092285,
-0.024309879168868065,
0.16576746106147766,
-0.3371160924434662,
0.301733136177063,
0.3063925504684448,
-0.6709833145141602,
-0.2540050446987152,
-0.23876558244228363,
-0.06726038455963135,
0.21733999252319336,
1.2956234216690063,
-1.0373986959457397,
0.8997049331665039,
0.6500726342201233,
0.5454233884811401,
1.2989321947097778,
-0.001093252212740481,
0.6252879500389099,
-0.9331343770027161,
0.1974421739578247,
0.42952972650527954,
0.19901077449321747,
0.31811976432800293,
-0.21223942935466766,
0.7835509777069092,
0.515614926815033,
-0.3382755219936371,
-0.6345241069793701,
0.30695268511772156,
-0.8620217442512512,
-0.6470987796783447,
0.9695815443992615,
0.026621509343385696,
0.09702623635530472,
-0.4338848292827606,
0.053285542875528336,
0.9039969444274902,
-0.2744102478027344,
0.9362908601760864,
0.8366920948028564,
-0.13866879045963287,
-0.13109609484672546,
-0.45978814363479614,
0.5616903305053711,
0.14798831939697266,
-0.7467422485351562,
-0.03983813151717186,
0.5130868554115295,
0.16585007309913635,
-0.19034598767757416,
0.3993227481842041,
-0.10009346157312393,
-0.015288054011762142,
0.26827555894851685,
-0.22535932064056396,
-0.67933589220047,
-0.166298046708107,
-0.29299232363700867,
0.2184404879808426,
-0.17498475313186646,
0.07678297907114029
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19709v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19709v1
|
Hierarchical Recurrent Adapters for Efficient Multi-Task Adaptation of Large Speech Models
| 2024-03-25T17:21:56 | 2024-03-25T17:21:56 |
Tsendsuren Munkhdalai, Youzheng Chen, Khe Chai Sim, Fadi Biadsy, Tara Sainath, Pedro Moreno Mengibar
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.NE
|
Parameter efficient adaptation methods have become a key mechanism to train
large pre-trained models for downstream tasks. However, their per-task
parameter overhead is considered still high when the number of downstream tasks
to adapt for is large. We introduce an adapter module that has a better
efficiency in large scale multi-task adaptation scenario. Our adapter is
hierarchical in terms of how the adapter parameters are allocated. The adapter
consists of a single shared controller network and multiple task-level adapter
heads to reduce the per-task parameter overhead without performance regression
on downstream tasks. The adapter is also recurrent so the entire adapter
parameters are reused across different layers of the pre-trained model. Our
Hierarchical Recurrent Adapter (HRA) outperforms the previous adapter-based
approaches as well as full model fine-tuning baseline in both single and
multi-task adaptation settings when evaluated on automatic speech recognition
tasks.
|
[
-0.21218758821487427,
-0.5270180702209473,
0.27102068066596985,
0.3835139572620392,
-0.3472118675708771,
-0.30582955479621887,
-0.10059192031621933,
-0.15735094249248505,
-0.19677549600601196,
0.23181626200675964,
-0.5709620714187622,
-0.1509794443845749,
-0.615636944770813,
-0.16102083027362823,
0.004733814857900143,
0.8439070582389832,
0.13494062423706055,
-0.2540481388568878,
0.002708260901272297,
-0.2066134810447693,
-0.753068208694458,
-0.4893246293067932,
-1.1000339984893799,
-0.4017779529094696,
0.7516957521438599,
0.3089941143989563,
0.1734665036201477,
0.6436301469802856,
0.5036231279373169,
0.364692360162735,
0.012558933347463608,
0.02769298665225506,
-0.4934377074241638,
0.2201351821422577,
-0.28647321462631226,
-0.21416890621185303,
-0.7651867270469666,
-0.4746454954147339,
1.013351321220398,
0.46448850631713867,
-0.5491184592247009,
0.5001211762428284,
0.2962777614593506,
0.8196834325790405,
-0.8203006386756897,
0.2509189248085022,
-0.7301522493362427,
-0.0979103296995163,
-0.05292504280805588,
-0.4585335850715637,
-0.3088473081588745,
0.01426939107477665,
0.30013754963874817,
-0.8546234965324402,
-0.08195018023252487,
-0.0979631096124649,
0.2711515426635742,
0.518263041973114,
-0.16872061789035797,
0.23046189546585083,
-1.0032416582107544,
0.7280710339546204,
-0.6970218420028687,
0.47785595059394836,
-0.025877758860588074,
0.35568422079086304,
-0.17267262935638428,
-0.6859491467475891,
-0.37654972076416016,
-0.18068301677703857,
0.2029634565114975,
0.20721706748008728,
-0.6740514039993286,
0.19224974513053894,
0.22944438457489014,
0.004023011773824692,
-0.488181471824646,
0.23536336421966553,
-0.15709500014781952,
-0.12216290086507797,
0.1645078808069229,
-0.03115096129477024,
0.05290752649307251,
0.121856190264225,
-0.11423224955797195,
0.09152213484048843,
-0.3608209192752838,
0.012693074531853199,
0.07712622731924057,
0.6509798169136047,
-0.0758720263838768,
-0.05311315506696701,
-0.1437160223722458,
0.9866887927055359,
0.5086900591850281,
-0.38165271282196045,
0.24763716757297516,
-0.41681012511253357,
-0.3017100393772125,
0.10703258961439133,
0.34478506445884705,
-0.0004025789094157517,
0.24125193059444427,
-0.03017466701567173,
-0.000024858087272150442,
-0.2682860791683197,
0.5754461884498596,
-0.8297439217567444,
-0.25546085834503174,
0.021342450752854347,
-0.4845350980758667,
0.19224178791046143,
-0.32859334349632263,
-0.6410260200500488,
-0.1847981959581375,
-0.5013819336891174,
0.7102590203285217,
-0.01243830006569624,
-0.25589367747306824,
0.10168083012104034,
-0.09885569661855698,
0.1974668949842453,
0.430125892162323,
-0.8973855972290039,
0.5231393575668335,
0.49273285269737244,
1.0172233581542969,
-0.32494720816612244,
-0.5991183519363403,
-0.9359031319618225,
0.2914939224720001,
-0.23095126450061798,
0.7062496542930603,
-0.2834368050098419,
-0.09742867201566696,
-0.31230226159095764,
0.2051941156387329,
-0.5574228763580322,
-0.6705848574638367,
0.4258459806442261,
-0.23647791147232056,
-0.14156870543956757,
0.008508211001753807,
-0.057107098400592804,
-0.17758630216121674,
-0.1623862236738205,
-0.6185425519943237,
0.6607586741447449,
-0.03520157188177109,
-0.4832119643688202,
0.3576562702655792,
-0.8813290596008301,
-0.5294033885002136,
0.0061899153515696526,
0.22307410836219788,
-0.4345916211605072,
0.19538843631744385,
0.32617300748825073,
0.482778936624527,
-0.29405662417411804,
0.2004251778125763,
-0.18777531385421753,
-0.3462028503417969,
-0.23246797919273376,
-0.4599912762641907,
0.4297280013561249,
0.0658179447054863,
-0.16844221949577332,
0.644897997379303,
-0.774964451789856,
-0.2742617428302765,
-0.2676001489162445,
-0.64776611328125,
-0.33932626247406006,
0.0486278161406517,
0.30258429050445557,
0.31341317296028137,
0.14185796678066254,
-0.39036303758621216,
-0.12560997903347015,
0.056548018008470535,
0.5918758511543274,
0.8440432548522949,
-0.034377481788396835,
0.4082470238208771,
-0.675409734249115,
0.36957094073295593,
0.2752854824066162,
0.053707417100667953,
0.010903843678534031,
-0.27049222588539124,
-0.6208754181861877,
-0.6000548005104065,
0.10630868375301361,
0.42488157749176025,
-0.3363877832889557,
0.6755145192146301,
-0.49669933319091797,
-0.7071465849876404,
-0.5540084838867188,
0.09328925609588623,
0.2709296643733978,
0.4939945638179779,
0.3182775378227234,
-0.24538595974445343,
-0.6199111342430115,
-0.7851247787475586,
-0.29855555295944214,
-0.01898839883506298,
-0.25437048077583313,
0.3551933765411377,
0.48236989974975586,
-0.14956524968147278,
0.5511889457702637,
-0.14714261889457703,
-0.4327285587787628,
-0.17827989161014557,
0.04526788741350174,
0.4520154893398285,
0.7218217849731445,
0.588431715965271,
-0.518387496471405,
-0.21456897258758545,
0.20995526015758514,
-0.1282002329826355,
0.09276020526885986,
-0.39683961868286133,
-0.18562771379947662,
0.048968229442834854,
0.23647122085094452,
-0.2906559109687805,
0.010024741291999817,
0.8830699324607849,
-0.09846009314060211,
0.3372263014316559,
-0.4782869219779968,
0.05668213218450546,
-1.2103891372680664,
0.34435325860977173,
0.10909835249185562,
-0.2707309126853943,
-0.9105154871940613,
-0.21923035383224487,
-0.13126973807811737,
-0.10138557106256485,
-0.22443775832653046,
0.2331557720899582,
-0.19596189260482788,
-0.18184207379817963,
-0.38365864753723145,
-0.09892605245113373,
-0.2725585997104645,
0.8039625287055969,
-0.035877775400877,
0.8189830183982849,
0.8354082107543945,
-0.7432278394699097,
0.3739228844642639,
0.02776603028178215,
-0.3193536102771759,
0.572550892829895,
-0.7017520666122437,
0.2326100468635559,
-0.07285703718662262,
0.5100914239883423,
-1.006864070892334,
0.04093295335769653,
0.02834388054907322,
-0.055963922291994095,
0.12772220373153687,
-0.2055044323205948,
-0.0903889387845993,
-0.13742347061634064,
-0.1267305612564087,
0.6345295906066895,
0.32138240337371826,
-0.746668815612793,
1.0195740461349487,
0.48174118995666504,
-0.41756439208984375,
-0.4094410836696625,
-0.6549196839332581,
-0.09383202344179153,
-0.3232598602771759,
-0.21017740666866302,
0.48188289999961853,
-0.07272286713123322,
0.34505578875541687,
-0.28776270151138306,
-0.5739678144454956,
-0.3160661458969116,
0.009654507972300053,
0.4007588028907776,
0.06992485374212265,
-0.5475912690162659,
0.06288385391235352,
0.12002494186162949,
-0.046574875712394714,
-0.11714321374893188,
-0.5752667188644409,
0.47255441546440125,
0.01004744041711092,
-0.08340887725353241,
-1.0949392318725586,
0.4182034432888031,
1.0929114818572998,
0.07581787556409836,
0.6312912106513977,
0.5602161884307861,
-0.5216485857963562,
-0.0019879795145243406,
-0.5431059002876282,
0.07623132318258286,
-0.4146301746368408,
0.9646970629692078,
-0.5187681913375854,
-0.7618446946144104,
0.38877785205841064,
-0.1410210132598877,
0.24988925457000732,
0.28022128343582153,
0.4560261368751526,
0.1555035263299942,
0.6517244577407837,
0.42883047461509705,
-0.6222543716430664,
0.8066124320030212,
0.18407201766967773,
0.013227264396846294,
-1.0208208560943604,
0.12278773635625839,
-0.7266409993171692,
-0.4033116400241852,
-0.5512816905975342,
-0.48438760638237,
0.3685217499732971,
-0.1456012725830078,
-0.5884336233139038,
0.3934439420700073,
-0.43135660886764526,
0.08139009028673172,
0.6685457229614258,
0.3559342324733734,
0.1303694248199463,
-0.023745805025100708,
0.585228443145752,
0.31106308102607727,
-1.0419405698776245,
-0.046867094933986664,
0.6727444529533386,
0.4129021167755127,
0.575996994972229,
0.14365331828594208,
0.3307684659957886,
0.1921946406364441,
0.01264782715588808,
-0.7978002429008484,
0.2783864438533783,
-0.6027072668075562,
-0.39631718397140503,
-0.5464266538619995,
-0.4840298891067505,
-0.9251627326011658,
0.39406484365463257,
-0.29870694875717163,
-0.6571381092071533,
0.5222121477127075,
0.5623024106025696,
-0.754541277885437,
0.2861017882823944,
-0.5757863521575928,
0.7992885112762451,
0.11399518698453903,
-0.10032723844051361,
-0.5572837591171265,
-0.33120954036712646,
-0.1699729710817337,
-0.4215209484100342,
0.07171660661697388,
0.06383009999990463,
0.07792475819587708,
1.1244932413101196,
0.26462897658348083,
0.8085215091705322,
-0.5311646461486816,
0.05245240032672882,
0.1209687739610672,
-0.30570781230926514,
0.60537189245224,
-0.36736661195755005,
-0.29024994373321533,
0.1527673602104187,
0.06862709671258926,
-0.5130811333656311,
-0.5961247682571411,
0.6853818893432617,
-0.8535469174385071,
-0.5835105180740356,
-0.1845128834247589,
-1.1272799968719482,
-0.31401899456977844,
0.11772476881742477,
-0.11238404363393784,
0.7974239587783813,
-0.04587806388735771,
0.49479445815086365,
0.19875729084014893,
-0.22389023005962372,
0.3370737135410309,
0.27721476554870605,
0.28518378734588623,
-0.4670035243034363,
0.8183430433273315,
0.0623699314892292,
0.49787816405296326,
0.48320573568344116,
0.31926584243774414,
-0.11450124531984329,
-0.8376344442367554,
-0.274486243724823,
0.04356276988983154,
-0.2523437440395355,
-0.14900103211402893,
-0.33220744132995605,
-0.36725762486457825,
-0.4886312484741211,
0.11062189936637878,
-0.3623533248901367,
-0.2779271900653839,
-0.3484078347682953,
0.19193698465824127,
0.26251357793807983,
0.4365593492984772,
0.018515510484576225,
0.7465001344680786,
-0.6294734477996826,
0.8625583648681641,
0.7753465175628662,
0.27578622102737427,
0.24325715005397797,
-1.1563773155212402,
-0.26081210374832153,
-0.13197240233421326,
-0.1297178417444229,
-0.3916357755661011,
0.15850476920604706,
0.6766176819801331,
0.5753158330917358,
0.22226053476333618,
-0.08032003790140152,
1.3339768648147583,
-0.851143479347229,
0.2937345504760742,
0.19096273183822632,
-0.9636185169219971,
0.2145676165819168,
-0.4392055571079254,
0.9366124272346497,
0.3811633288860321,
0.14353929460048676,
-0.29610374569892883,
-0.024300362914800644,
0.030518319457769394,
-0.7963656187057495,
0.867670476436615,
-0.03673221170902252,
0.18607169389724731,
0.5718100070953369,
0.5787188410758972,
0.04297083243727684,
-0.026835979893803596,
-0.45505645871162415,
-0.23244407773017883,
-0.3059467375278473,
-0.040967583656311035,
-0.25065937638282776,
-0.2836318016052246,
-0.03254471346735954,
-0.45300644636154175,
0.6501443982124329,
-0.205062597990036,
0.2584095299243927,
0.05579649284482002,
0.07985613495111465,
-0.31518346071243286,
0.5770686268806458,
0.7070227861404419,
0.8714215755462646,
-0.21738943457603455,
0.008083464577794075,
0.626859724521637,
-0.5379058718681335,
0.13298752903938293,
0.2594127357006073,
0.3366044759750366,
-0.08169527351856232,
0.456064909696579,
1.170875072479248,
0.48942962288856506,
-0.2013876885175705,
0.08840378373861313,
0.10458452999591827,
-0.36152899265289307,
-0.1431448757648468,
0.1288687288761139,
0.253055602312088,
0.42357513308525085,
0.34894001483917236,
0.5373937487602234,
0.14594818651676178,
-0.6122843027114868,
0.27095118165016174,
0.15130943059921265,
-0.2823513448238373,
-0.2534838318824768,
0.28052327036857605,
0.41453397274017334,
-0.4244311451911926,
0.27590513229370117,
0.4802248775959015,
-0.1458134651184082,
0.34336555004119873,
0.8766964673995972,
0.9277360439300537,
-0.8749452233314514,
-0.2862710654735565,
0.5046411156654358,
0.04466428980231285,
-0.08395661413669586,
0.052081987261772156,
-0.2125399112701416,
-0.5234281420707703,
-0.6518792510032654,
-0.6385661363601685,
-0.13921710848808289,
0.22458980977535248,
-0.9777997732162476,
-0.10357058793306351,
-0.2899388372898102,
-0.22679166495800018,
0.24382540583610535,
-0.3300842344760895,
-0.4154786467552185,
0.061333175748586655,
0.19409909844398499,
0.8420740365982056,
-0.6548236608505249,
1.2386627197265625,
0.5811392664909363,
0.34361332654953003,
-0.5903379321098328,
0.13558727502822876,
-0.14298133552074432,
-0.6427907943725586,
0.3748246431350708,
-0.029164692386984825,
-0.6270231604576111,
0.1846119910478592,
0.22598311305046082,
-0.8629003167152405,
1.1810948848724365,
0.5163395404815674,
-1.2056310176849365,
-0.22103171050548553,
-0.21310123801231384,
0.4076305329799652,
-0.4855285882949829,
-0.17009404301643372,
0.722038745880127,
0.4271673858165741,
0.07345087081193924,
-1.4411545991897583,
0.12579718232154846,
-0.1179327666759491,
0.2734414041042328,
0.08739177137613297,
-0.18398171663284302,
0.6301688551902771,
-0.15239526331424713,
0.046086594462394714,
0.19462241232395172,
0.6904104948043823,
0.42580220103263855,
0.16006305813789368,
1.122583270072937,
0.12456102669239044,
0.6574360132217407,
0.21420767903327942,
0.7110881805419922,
-0.18274010717868805,
0.14471499621868134,
1.4371814727783203,
-0.12176792323589325,
1.1607577800750732,
0.5371155142784119,
-0.08272477239370346,
0.49286118149757385,
0.152338907122612,
0.2762816846370697,
0.6317852735519409,
0.40872517228126526,
-0.1681801676750183,
-0.45243844389915466,
-0.1533302217721939,
-0.3183382749557495,
0.5093157291412354,
0.16766710579395294,
-0.13716138899326324,
-0.10784780234098434,
0.16375485062599182,
-0.28624629974365234,
-0.17837552726268768,
-0.729443371295929,
0.9995839595794678,
0.01747337356209755,
-0.6710860133171082,
0.5250158309936523,
-0.40626171231269836,
0.6291083097457886,
-0.6917834281921387,
-0.0031721326522529125,
0.29481807351112366,
0.5821093320846558,
-0.24519360065460205,
-0.3838547468185425,
0.2759219706058502,
-0.04533477500081062,
-0.44428130984306335,
-0.043695203959941864,
0.5038387775421143,
-0.5148203372955322,
-0.34339040517807007,
0.4087507724761963,
0.3992234170436859,
-0.14476671814918518,
-0.38478824496269226,
-0.6492041349411011,
-0.12375933676958084,
-0.21592861413955688,
-0.13115379214286804,
0.4214443266391754,
0.2585146427154541,
0.3062050938606262,
0.5156202912330627,
0.7432180643081665,
0.3424576222896576,
0.13424766063690186,
0.337790846824646,
0.8540818691253662,
-0.6284540891647339,
-0.5280976891517639,
-0.6423394083976746,
0.35245320200920105,
0.19800888001918793,
-0.2781767249107361,
0.5073052048683167,
0.31449058651924133,
0.5002425909042358,
-0.15664607286453247,
0.6713107824325562,
0.27943164110183716,
0.44725120067596436,
-0.33752742409706116,
0.7693825960159302,
-0.5935503840446472,
-0.0403427891433239,
-0.3999330401420593,
-0.7616599798202515,
-0.4596828520298004,
0.6427475810050964,
-0.0609896257519722,
0.23983383178710938,
0.4897218346595764,
0.6648000478744507,
-0.18826952576637268,
-0.1832837015390396,
0.4604469835758209,
0.3308597505092621,
0.16846846044063568,
0.7192923426628113,
0.6221126914024353,
-0.3606719970703125,
0.5289751291275024,
-0.2538345456123352,
-0.40242159366607666,
0.011473656632006168,
-0.8008023500442505,
-0.7249572277069092,
-0.7277379035949707,
-0.3686533570289612,
0.015671957284212112,
0.4940944314002991,
0.9954553246498108,
1.3087635040283203,
-1.0683280229568481,
-0.6269293427467346,
-0.11469041556119919,
-0.24748295545578003,
-0.645085334777832,
-0.1527545154094696,
0.43415138125419617,
-0.27117469906806946,
-0.7116893529891968,
0.4481334388256073,
0.30229127407073975,
-0.40843990445137024,
0.29525429010391235,
-0.07732514292001724,
-0.1932838410139084,
-0.041334010660648346,
0.6653554439544678,
0.12787604331970215,
-0.715485692024231,
-0.5211654305458069,
-0.3654157519340515,
0.3018902838230133,
0.11875896900892258,
0.9630651473999023,
-0.6619004607200623,
0.4160160720348358,
0.35091108083724976,
0.7377486824989319,
0.3543042838573456,
0.0708339512348175,
0.7306589484214783,
-0.44870996475219727,
0.0982971116900444,
0.01941509172320366,
0.3726969361305237,
0.02655237540602684,
-0.09980069845914841,
-0.08757661283016205,
-0.06887171417474747,
-0.891709566116333,
-0.6866241097450256,
-0.020613007247447968,
-1.448955774307251,
-0.24047207832336426,
0.983935534954071,
-0.25750496983528137,
-0.059882793575525284,
-0.3237115144729614,
-0.28943178057670593,
0.46603313088417053,
-0.5344873070716858,
0.6787572503089905,
0.3150944113731384,
-0.19722506403923035,
-0.19128669798374176,
-0.5147978663444519,
0.26157060265541077,
0.34145882725715637,
-1.0303393602371216,
0.2995229959487915,
0.18864554166793823,
0.3959662914276123,
0.2266896367073059,
0.47678160667419434,
0.2518657147884369,
0.5773643255233765,
-0.1493082344532013,
-0.08711905777454376,
-0.049098383635282516,
-0.519522488117218,
-0.7142489552497864,
0.22742094099521637,
0.13239449262619019,
-0.7655428647994995
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16952v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16952v1
|
Data Mixing Laws: Optimizing Data Mixtures by Predicting Language Modeling Performance
| 2024-03-25T17:14:00 | 2024-03-25T17:14:00 |
Jiasheng Ye, Peiju Liu, Tianxiang Sun, Yunhua Zhou, Jun Zhan, Xipeng Qiu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Pretraining data of large language models composes multiple domains (e.g.,
web texts, academic papers, codes), whose mixture proportions crucially impact
the competence of outcome models. While existing endeavors rely on heuristics
or qualitative strategies to tune the proportions, we discover the quantitative
predictability of model performance regarding the mixture proportions in
function forms, which we refer to as the data mixing laws. Fitting such
functions on sample mixtures unveils model performance on unseen mixtures
before actual runs, thus guiding the selection of an ideal data mixture.
Furthermore, we propose nested use of the scaling laws of training steps, model
sizes, and our data mixing law to enable predicting the performance of large
models trained on massive data under various mixtures with only small-scale
training. Moreover, experimental results verify that our method effectively
optimizes the training mixture of a 1B model trained for 100B tokens in
RedPajama, reaching a performance comparable to the one trained for 48% more
steps on the default mixture. Extending the application of data mixing laws to
continual training accurately predicts the critical mixture proportion that
avoids catastrophic forgetting and outlooks the potential for dynamic data
schedules
|
[
-0.349906861782074,
-0.6341875195503235,
0.3840691149234772,
0.620366096496582,
-0.21391946077346802,
0.2511875629425049,
-0.1708734929561615,
-0.43605485558509827,
-0.0042642815969884396,
0.6850592494010925,
-0.4796658158302307,
-0.20587682723999023,
-0.7494708895683289,
-0.2880156338214874,
-0.7725285291671753,
0.5980117321014404,
0.07852235436439514,
0.37517049908638,
-0.5702861547470093,
0.054889533668756485,
-0.5081823468208313,
-0.7236688733100891,
-0.26400020718574524,
-0.4959062337875366,
0.27152377367019653,
0.28816142678260803,
0.5669991970062256,
0.7480056881904602,
0.27586767077445984,
0.1993921846151352,
0.029973428696393967,
-0.13261005282402039,
-0.7210675477981567,
0.11653558909893036,
0.018824584782123566,
-0.7769470810890198,
-0.05878584831953049,
-0.11128158867359161,
0.6790223717689514,
0.8422932624816895,
-0.6217554807662964,
-0.19674448668956757,
-0.03633761405944824,
0.6419088244438171,
-0.6957657337188721,
0.28498750925064087,
-0.7725042104721069,
0.13550078868865967,
-0.2575282156467438,
-0.3095438480377197,
-0.37664151191711426,
-0.3149784207344055,
0.03584976866841316,
-0.5570324063301086,
0.11423131078481674,
0.3947228193283081,
0.5483693480491638,
0.28319457173347473,
-0.2747407853603363,
-0.2011079043149948,
-0.7391806244850159,
0.9685305953025818,
-0.833675742149353,
0.5280289053916931,
0.47934743762016296,
0.5013535022735596,
-0.24411988258361816,
-0.58432936668396,
-0.8463377952575684,
0.007854713127017021,
0.07688696682453156,
-0.0706658735871315,
-0.12337936460971832,
0.0353848896920681,
0.08640100061893463,
0.3535791337490082,
-0.659563422203064,
0.10781905055046082,
-0.3570539355278015,
0.09001710265874863,
0.5350655317306519,
0.4774690866470337,
0.3928687572479248,
0.6166524291038513,
0.24043835699558258,
-0.24111303687095642,
-0.5900629162788391,
-0.32057422399520874,
0.3277603089809418,
0.4842047393321991,
-0.21294112503528595,
0.6039969325065613,
-0.12199690192937851,
0.6912001371383667,
0.008104145526885986,
-0.36853256821632385,
0.17943130433559418,
-0.5437583923339844,
-0.1529192477464676,
-0.07444776594638824,
0.5778209567070007,
0.16787105798721313,
0.6976209878921509,
-0.2961463928222656,
-0.30862993001937866,
0.04154248908162117,
0.4133365750312805,
-0.8986895680427551,
-0.4157143831253052,
0.10875573754310608,
-0.22007982432842255,
-0.3274056911468506,
-0.07654522359371185,
-0.5415585041046143,
-0.46522608399391174,
-0.8383199572563171,
0.41518744826316833,
-0.4332409203052521,
-0.4500158131122589,
0.5336132049560547,
0.05155224725604057,
-0.0859958603978157,
0.08299962431192398,
-1.077918291091919,
0.7078053951263428,
0.9340959787368774,
0.6343883872032166,
-0.08721457421779633,
-0.45222207903862,
-0.2733496129512787,
-0.018177516758441925,
-0.4474729597568512,
0.2765604555606842,
-0.503908097743988,
-0.41575905680656433,
0.1261708289384842,
-0.35124361515045166,
-0.33795344829559326,
-0.8629592657089233,
-0.07062139362096786,
-0.5994066596031189,
-0.00647036824375391,
0.11377640068531036,
-0.7859378457069397,
-0.0030131996609270573,
-0.0989188477396965,
-0.7871167659759521,
0.9753135442733765,
0.22644054889678955,
-0.7679107785224915,
0.7320761680603027,
-0.24936936795711517,
-0.8561325073242188,
-0.17079612612724304,
0.025080695748329163,
-0.47042983770370483,
0.27434489130973816,
-0.13495108485221863,
0.5449942350387573,
-0.23423898220062256,
0.33717960119247437,
-0.4673178791999817,
-0.28212258219718933,
0.19470873475074768,
-0.025431416928768158,
0.735481858253479,
0.2774355709552765,
-0.08387253433465958,
0.0877179205417633,
-0.6949931979179382,
-0.1360228955745697,
0.20148226618766785,
-0.18475331366062164,
-0.30799371004104614,
0.17979641258716583,
0.21345767378807068,
0.2015630304813385,
0.03272038325667381,
-0.1719893515110016,
-0.20404483377933502,
-0.044913824647665024,
0.09184484928846359,
0.5261614322662354,
-0.004456644877791405,
0.4770351052284241,
-0.4326370060443878,
0.7314162254333496,
0.3291836977005005,
0.10361380875110626,
0.14118613302707672,
-0.5006795525550842,
-0.6160895824432373,
-0.13849033415317535,
0.5006340146064758,
0.398945689201355,
-0.599166750907898,
0.6003937721252441,
-0.3113173842430115,
-0.6769237518310547,
-0.4085754454135895,
0.2280074805021286,
0.029231980443000793,
0.22838732600212097,
0.2212481051683426,
-0.44414427876472473,
-0.9799984097480774,
-0.4181104004383087,
-0.18073247373104095,
-0.22399811446666718,
0.30687230825424194,
0.21186815202236176,
0.5193270444869995,
-0.3177238404750824,
1.0307937860488892,
-0.3585672974586487,
0.2883119583129883,
-0.4687046408653259,
0.1972433179616928,
0.2474570870399475,
0.5969898700714111,
0.6962729692459106,
-0.7667421102523804,
-0.7046566605567932,
0.1413431167602539,
-0.4884834289550781,
-0.06334928423166275,
0.07534437626600266,
0.005212392192333937,
-0.0944376289844513,
0.43057677149772644,
-0.3020533323287964,
0.056818604469299316,
0.7051424980163574,
-0.13084882497787476,
0.6114344000816345,
-0.1880728006362915,
-0.09192109107971191,
-0.8015772104263306,
-0.09615223109722137,
0.2125079482793808,
-0.3585222363471985,
-0.6916760206222534,
-0.1383286565542221,
0.06866135448217392,
0.11499293148517609,
-0.3610672354698181,
0.45959773659706116,
-0.14084231853485107,
-0.018908362835645676,
-0.3561403155326843,
-0.49995362758636475,
-0.21812178194522858,
0.06245575472712517,
0.018046561628580093,
0.9613727331161499,
0.716780960559845,
-0.7530641555786133,
0.23087896406650543,
-0.17874391376972198,
-0.6026290059089661,
0.18908338248729706,
-0.6125814318656921,
-0.3171473443508148,
-0.028240026906132698,
0.13507258892059326,
-0.79777991771698,
-0.26831677556037903,
-0.2583419382572174,
-0.29436302185058594,
0.4224315881729126,
-0.1392851024866104,
-0.771287202835083,
-0.26298949122428894,
0.16668996214866638,
0.4853249490261078,
0.7303177118301392,
-0.3758618235588074,
0.6417577266693115,
0.6580226421356201,
-0.07373466342687607,
-0.5351241230964661,
-0.6880162358283997,
-0.1375291794538498,
-0.4280274212360382,
-0.5796419382095337,
0.1807943880558014,
-0.3214937746524811,
-0.383798748254776,
-0.2477792352437973,
-0.02878277376294136,
-0.5263923406600952,
0.2823650538921356,
0.1288760006427765,
0.14404770731925964,
-0.24294915795326233,
-0.44633036851882935,
-0.03833657503128052,
0.13027212023735046,
0.19047275185585022,
-0.4433411657810211,
0.8516605496406555,
0.22314171493053436,
-0.15316452085971832,
-0.16447420418262482,
0.06950010359287262,
0.6959706544876099,
0.1394672691822052,
1.0739470720291138,
0.45132988691329956,
-0.4830090403556824,
-0.18441782891750336,
-0.4653007984161377,
-0.13692614436149597,
-0.40756717324256897,
0.3694334924221039,
-0.3274511694908142,
-0.591903805732727,
0.5837509632110596,
0.20750649273395538,
-0.08134710043668747,
0.15548057854175568,
0.7113109827041626,
0.04704684764146805,
1.0163061618804932,
0.7768586277961731,
-0.51938796043396,
0.8369051218032837,
-0.014528247527778149,
0.2225361317396164,
-0.13550300896167755,
-0.0984657034277916,
-0.5252991318702698,
-0.07720889896154404,
-0.6094983816146851,
-0.48996078968048096,
0.11000511795282364,
0.014240835793316364,
-0.043907295912504196,
0.31029269099235535,
0.12406612187623978,
0.8893938064575195,
0.42084357142448425,
-0.13278226554393768,
0.19668419659137726,
0.22892539203166962,
-0.04493597149848938,
-0.09507919102907181,
-0.8792610168457031,
0.007720672991126776,
1.304979681968689,
0.39857515692710876,
0.9205507636070251,
-0.13996654748916626,
0.7874670624732971,
0.22298380732536316,
0.17733539640903473,
-0.672990620136261,
0.3239169716835022,
-0.13491596281528473,
-0.595715343952179,
0.062232933938503265,
-0.8612756729125977,
-0.957317054271698,
0.2876076102256775,
-0.1805497705936432,
-0.3757355511188507,
-0.052086010575294495,
0.0704810619354248,
-0.15362593531608582,
0.12931156158447266,
-0.6841728091239929,
0.5947388410568237,
-0.21034960448741913,
-0.08528904616832733,
-0.46848443150520325,
-0.6570382118225098,
0.2359953671693802,
-0.5267958045005798,
0.37373799085617065,
0.037406690418720245,
0.18638673424720764,
0.7171644568443298,
-0.27782517671585083,
0.7859656810760498,
-0.04364964738488197,
-0.065537229180336,
0.16300709545612335,
0.06152068078517914,
0.28158828616142273,
-0.30582383275032043,
0.09705289453268051,
0.22140279412269592,
0.0778777152299881,
-0.6120580434799194,
-0.4869120419025421,
0.4223365783691406,
-0.7942138314247131,
-0.06577357649803162,
-0.050541605800390244,
-0.619785726070404,
-0.371305912733078,
0.2797098159790039,
0.2753373384475708,
0.11903605610132217,
-0.04530312120914459,
0.43464282155036926,
0.7957578301429749,
0.21860606968402863,
0.1442468911409378,
0.43137478828430176,
-0.3560161590576172,
-0.30872759222984314,
1.2786222696304321,
0.19032108783721924,
0.2936491370201111,
0.2810860574245453,
0.27434486150741577,
-0.2965628206729889,
-0.9242225885391235,
-0.08594761788845062,
0.16754378378391266,
-0.4418281614780426,
0.08875821530818939,
-0.6637932062149048,
-0.039201196283102036,
-0.39633166790008545,
-0.09831512719392776,
-0.5084165334701538,
-0.42593812942504883,
-0.1352473348379135,
0.10900496691465378,
0.012930854223668575,
0.6818084120750427,
0.02859804779291153,
0.49477407336235046,
-0.6150155067443848,
0.10928018391132355,
0.06300736218690872,
0.46856260299682617,
-0.036890994757413864,
-0.5073657631874084,
-0.49194902181625366,
0.08253934979438782,
0.06045703589916229,
-0.4247322678565979,
0.4677394926548004,
0.035526346415281296,
0.6625454425811768,
0.2019592821598053,
-0.36208778619766235,
0.6504788994789124,
-0.338479220867157,
0.48738881945610046,
0.35104191303253174,
-0.7426257729530334,
0.2615906298160553,
-0.3861408531665802,
-0.14019234478473663,
0.6571283936500549,
0.2613869309425354,
-0.4039112329483032,
-0.4752211272716522,
-0.7082708477973938,
-0.9319216012954712,
0.5904314517974854,
0.27015525102615356,
0.22384381294250488,
0.29773247241973877,
0.20323337614536285,
0.306246817111969,
0.5734449625015259,
-0.7024615406990051,
-0.29067572951316833,
0.06061571463942528,
-0.6382630467414856,
-0.1348029524087906,
0.027700595557689667,
-0.01573566533625126,
-0.5179115533828735,
0.7502645254135132,
0.01655624993145466,
-0.07663094252347946,
-0.7778270840644836,
-0.10380095988512039,
-0.11290013045072556,
-0.27544474601745605,
0.6368693113327026,
0.9792243242263794,
-0.19066110253334045,
-0.16197814047336578,
-0.16405850648880005,
-0.7421607971191406,
0.2122495323419571,
0.06691912561655045,
-0.02186097577214241,
-0.07617736607789993,
0.21285593509674072,
0.6605666875839233,
0.07135894149541855,
-0.924267590045929,
0.4353911578655243,
-0.3031695485115051,
-0.2876686453819275,
-0.23034952580928802,
0.5361090302467346,
0.12351416796445847,
0.142565056681633,
0.26723676919937134,
-0.0642494410276413,
0.04588562995195389,
-0.4256863594055176,
0.3282252252101898,
0.03218350559473038,
-0.07979177683591843,
-0.17824992537498474,
0.55666583776474,
-0.12848114967346191,
0.09569881856441498,
0.4759281575679779,
0.048929739743471146,
-0.31184694170951843,
0.7776466012001038,
0.6674773693084717,
0.5266552567481995,
-0.3517296612262726,
-0.23832039535045624,
0.18870072066783905,
0.1309492439031601,
-0.4935181438922882,
0.16991938650608063,
0.16826795041561127,
-0.8679104447364807,
-0.41827866435050964,
-0.6117637157440186,
-0.5508323311805725,
0.10671836882829666,
-0.606583833694458,
0.14474911987781525,
-0.5447356700897217,
0.027803467586636543,
0.019663743674755096,
0.004267227835953236,
-0.6835583448410034,
0.5866902470588684,
0.19067668914794922,
0.7923221588134766,
-1.0621041059494019,
0.7551566362380981,
0.4885985851287842,
-0.196031853556633,
-0.6072797179222107,
0.03968540206551552,
0.0164771880954504,
-0.7404382228851318,
0.17559349536895752,
-0.003689065808430314,
0.12009178102016449,
0.0015190679114311934,
-0.4888571798801422,
-0.7669991850852966,
0.7297554612159729,
0.43018364906311035,
-0.5083900094032288,
0.3003566563129425,
0.29126060009002686,
0.44673144817352295,
-0.6738159656524658,
0.012156440876424313,
0.9451490640640259,
0.24787452816963196,
0.3542548716068268,
-0.8445759415626526,
-0.31013408303260803,
-0.3229706585407257,
-0.21294477581977844,
0.22620120644569397,
-0.22459284961223602,
0.8533768653869629,
0.012898063287138939,
-0.09119878709316254,
-0.16586174070835114,
0.6872584819793701,
0.41758620738983154,
0.3767740726470947,
0.5198050737380981,
0.6689693331718445,
0.8267813920974731,
-0.18833331763744354,
1.2711542844772339,
-0.4603494107723236,
0.2882577180862427,
1.1642738580703735,
-0.37058714032173157,
0.7389332056045532,
0.4414226710796356,
-0.5714302659034729,
0.40819400548934937,
0.7023422122001648,
0.1323155015707016,
0.740892231464386,
0.30808404088020325,
-0.27893882989883423,
-0.08545765280723572,
-0.0640813335776329,
-0.34531068801879883,
0.21906235814094543,
0.33562034368515015,
-0.2605235278606415,
0.09680715948343277,
-0.1979689598083496,
-0.05126265063881874,
-0.05611368268728256,
0.007540823891758919,
0.7642461061477661,
-0.12526045739650726,
-0.5032016634941101,
0.6728094816207886,
-0.04756173491477966,
0.6331837773323059,
-0.49322909116744995,
0.2908461391925812,
-0.22687216103076935,
0.17332854866981506,
0.022468388080596924,
-0.886213481426239,
0.2901526391506195,
-0.3127673864364624,
-0.26582372188568115,
-0.05877010151743889,
0.4020377993583679,
-0.6047384738922119,
-0.3618937134742737,
0.28729474544525146,
0.4275849163532257,
0.0021728333085775375,
-0.16577701270580292,
-0.6886420845985413,
0.08534669876098633,
-0.012565736658871174,
-0.09527165442705154,
0.6158320307731628,
0.49632173776626587,
0.2561374604701996,
0.7839213609695435,
0.6048779487609863,
0.4103045165538788,
0.4585355520248413,
0.2734859585762024,
0.8774203062057495,
-0.4919237494468689,
-0.8844307661056519,
-0.8202313780784607,
0.4233540892601013,
-0.09881271421909332,
-0.07015252113342285,
0.3830517828464508,
0.8188910484313965,
0.9332314729690552,
0.032402899116277695,
0.9467609524726868,
0.21112754940986633,
0.2544157803058624,
-0.5254048705101013,
0.5688660740852356,
-0.63605135679245,
-0.025304457172751427,
-0.014767049811780453,
-1.0430063009262085,
-0.2822771370410919,
0.5033107399940491,
-0.1961563229560852,
0.2631293535232544,
0.40996548533439636,
0.7692980766296387,
-0.3829791247844696,
0.26288214325904846,
0.3106762170791626,
-0.03910522162914276,
0.27387139201164246,
0.2782442271709442,
0.5062442421913147,
-0.24333488941192627,
0.0680314302444458,
-0.37063828110694885,
-0.04721704125404358,
-0.4380322992801666,
-0.6321923732757568,
-0.6596755981445312,
-0.4818074107170105,
-0.3584102392196655,
-0.32711151242256165,
-0.20444254577159882,
0.6935515999794006,
1.1364749670028687,
-0.8830670714378357,
-0.6454756259918213,
-0.46594613790512085,
-0.053483862429857254,
-0.18442852795124054,
-0.2556574046611786,
-0.3337058126926422,
-0.38090696930885315,
-0.622850775718689,
0.392118364572525,
0.031045643612742424,
0.5630896687507629,
-0.18622645735740662,
-0.2960681617259979,
-0.043319087475538254,
0.419056236743927,
0.4827594757080078,
0.16646797955036163,
-0.3589545488357544,
0.4518083333969116,
-0.35222911834716797,
-0.36343392729759216,
-0.03161866217851639,
1.0434902906417847,
-0.3093753159046173,
0.5673163533210754,
0.5376495122909546,
0.8571275472640991,
0.7157760262489319,
-0.05251745507121086,
0.8738165497779846,
-0.9018257260322571,
0.22933468222618103,
0.3463781177997589,
0.5592483282089233,
0.2914394438266754,
-0.2316945195198059,
0.6347412467002869,
0.22027160227298737,
-0.3765221834182739,
-0.7662797570228577,
-0.13616323471069336,
-0.8155720829963684,
-0.35334712266921997,
0.97572261095047,
0.026833081617951393,
-0.27474260330200195,
-0.16579768061637878,
0.0842195525765419,
0.16403572261333466,
-0.2496827244758606,
0.7704793214797974,
0.9038089513778687,
-0.0063351718708872795,
-0.20716741681098938,
-0.9423486590385437,
0.4261319935321808,
0.6825788617134094,
-0.9152711629867554,
0.2328224778175354,
0.4508007764816284,
0.35760971903800964,
-0.05352330207824707,
0.4339325428009033,
-0.10951878130435944,
0.07326427847146988,
0.15914812684059143,
-0.10556585341691971,
0.25946879386901855,
-0.5144225358963013,
-0.14243671298027039,
0.019616635516285896,
0.09551095962524414,
0.1335693746805191
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16950v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16950v2
|
Aligning with Human Judgement: The Role of Pairwise Preference in Large Language Model Evaluators
| 2024-03-25T17:11:28 | 2024-03-26T02:28:42 |
Yinhong Liu, Han Zhou, Zhijiang Guo, Ehsan Shareghi, Ivan Vulić, Anna Korhonen, Nigel Collier
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated promising capabilities as
automatic evaluators in assessing the quality of generated natural language.
However, LLMs still exhibit biases in evaluation and often struggle to generate
coherent evaluations that align with human assessments. In this work, we first
conduct a systematic study of the misalignment between LLM evaluators and human
judgement, revealing that existing calibration methods aimed at mitigating
biases are insufficient for effectively aligning LLM evaluators. Inspired by
the use of preference data in RLHF, we formulate the evaluation as a ranking
problem and introduce Pairwise-preference Search (PairS), an uncertainty-guided
search method that employs LLMs to conduct pairwise comparisons and efficiently
ranks candidate texts. PairS achieves state-of-the-art performance on
representative evaluation tasks and demonstrates significant improvements over
direct scoring. Furthermore, we provide insights into the role of pairwise
preference in quantifying the transitivity of LLMs and demonstrate how PairS
benefits from calibration.
|
[
-0.28633826971054077,
-0.4454571604728699,
0.7902291417121887,
0.07364574819803238,
-0.15807676315307617,
0.16006019711494446,
-0.5040727853775024,
-0.41965657472610474,
0.07725740969181061,
0.4708975553512573,
-0.06471985578536987,
-0.3131920099258423,
-0.601821780204773,
0.0029034202452749014,
-0.1182166188955307,
0.7925204634666443,
-0.12506012618541718,
0.2867698669433594,
-0.5625666379928589,
-0.2686120271682739,
-0.5012520551681519,
-0.5992186069488525,
-0.5974346399307251,
-0.7993176579475403,
0.6546720862388611,
0.3723328411579132,
1.136368989944458,
0.5207290649414062,
0.6664008498191833,
0.208735853433609,
0.13705703616142273,
0.08223122358322144,
-0.5483627319335938,
0.2946068048477173,
-0.1397244781255722,
-0.26717495918273926,
-0.30005359649658203,
0.1928001344203949,
0.7396339774131775,
0.7493890523910522,
-0.20428012311458588,
0.10136505961418152,
-0.0005625848425552249,
1.002578854560852,
-0.5789044499397278,
-0.0467483289539814,
-0.35304778814315796,
-0.045019958168268204,
-0.2668055295944214,
-0.2644093632698059,
-0.40443742275238037,
-0.6287528872489929,
0.4463629424571991,
-0.32295891642570496,
0.06934113055467606,
0.5136727094650269,
0.682737410068512,
0.28126949071884155,
-0.5325884819030762,
-0.05165741592645645,
-0.5003321766853333,
1.0242140293121338,
-0.7611028552055359,
0.6595756411552429,
0.33898642659187317,
0.1685861200094223,
-0.20722177624702454,
-0.21056745946407318,
-0.2757391333580017,
-0.16650627553462982,
-0.09811602532863617,
-0.08702993392944336,
0.16664397716522217,
0.18112695217132568,
-0.14532563090324402,
0.3649735748767853,
-0.7571743130683899,
0.48740819096565247,
-0.14452455937862396,
-0.3578237295150757,
0.9755983948707581,
0.11107613146305084,
0.16950282454490662,
-0.3392958343029022,
-0.40096697211265564,
-0.2817828059196472,
-0.5738749504089355,
0.11735688894987106,
0.7574735879898071,
0.3468968868255615,
0.12395939230918884,
0.5124897956848145,
0.031125878915190697,
0.9023550152778625,
-0.0069569554179906845,
0.0287170447409153,
0.0636596828699112,
-0.22074158489704132,
-0.14510653913021088,
0.19807153940200806,
1.1103899478912354,
0.7592194080352783,
0.2828930914402008,
-0.2284495085477829,
-0.48840051889419556,
0.12751208245754242,
0.4037255644798279,
-0.5806630253791809,
-0.17305344343185425,
0.17775726318359375,
-0.5012136697769165,
-0.5322619080543518,
0.1466297209262848,
-0.8524876832962036,
-0.4893772006034851,
-0.5289442539215088,
0.4861912429332733,
0.009801272302865982,
-0.18659739196300507,
0.17835156619548798,
-0.0943884626030922,
0.18760494887828827,
0.1454264521598816,
-1.0343501567840576,
0.463959664106369,
0.8881980180740356,
0.45413675904273987,
-0.38052961230278015,
-0.296630859375,
-0.5785353183746338,
-0.12352515757083893,
-0.5258564949035645,
0.7796313166618347,
-0.5711023807525635,
-0.41960951685905457,
-0.010519513860344887,
-0.49617722630500793,
0.09888260066509247,
-0.5251747965812683,
0.9465999007225037,
-0.6975803971290588,
0.4122028648853302,
-0.46294987201690674,
-0.581308126449585,
-0.043898098170757294,
0.10055957734584808,
-0.5905321836471558,
1.348813772201538,
0.037884801626205444,
-0.8049264550209045,
0.4061613976955414,
-0.2742682695388794,
-0.2729993760585785,
0.013888062909245491,
-0.3092118501663208,
-0.3215996325016022,
0.044344060122966766,
0.24520756304264069,
0.4135702848434448,
-0.6006768345832825,
0.6027079224586487,
-0.41013115644454956,
-0.5447555184364319,
0.23206062614917755,
-0.424447238445282,
0.5832048654556274,
0.09128548949956894,
-0.13697895407676697,
0.34105873107910156,
-0.2861064076423645,
0.054319117218256,
0.10200630873441696,
-0.3955352008342743,
-0.6691269278526306,
0.20197845995426178,
0.21795223653316498,
-0.05612606182694435,
0.3578333258628845,
-0.24203360080718994,
0.11926928907632828,
-0.604081928730011,
0.33647051453590393,
1.0605361461639404,
-0.2049829065799713,
0.7603840231895447,
-0.5086715221405029,
0.428487092256546,
-0.368669718503952,
0.19582930207252502,
0.4425572454929352,
-0.44278040528297424,
-0.6511664390563965,
0.32348886132240295,
0.4964560270309448,
0.3750360310077667,
-0.2513502240180969,
0.6793370246887207,
-0.41198140382766724,
-0.4586969017982483,
-0.7594859004020691,
0.443635493516922,
0.5249937772750854,
0.4051915109157562,
0.0593351349234581,
-0.3086540997028351,
-0.558017373085022,
-1.1479415893554688,
-0.38848069310188293,
-0.39032647013664246,
0.14759401977062225,
0.2743673324584961,
0.12171266973018646,
-0.030568940564990044,
1.0865026712417603,
-0.43469470739364624,
0.014785194769501686,
-0.17679248750209808,
0.0034354645758867264,
0.0783122256398201,
0.31117793917655945,
0.3533371090888977,
-0.9002697467803955,
-0.3030701279640198,
-0.1698622703552246,
-0.535381019115448,
-0.262201189994812,
0.283197283744812,
-0.4174424111843109,
0.2687782049179077,
0.2810112535953522,
-0.3305076062679291,
0.09876977652311325,
0.842313826084137,
-0.1803925335407257,
0.45946434140205383,
-0.17130468785762787,
0.22265206277370453,
-0.827945351600647,
0.05856557562947273,
0.24747176468372345,
-0.43764764070510864,
-0.36269626021385193,
0.14291392266750336,
0.07965470850467682,
0.3040247857570648,
-0.12797673046588898,
0.795472264289856,
-0.4175907075405121,
-0.23725782334804535,
-0.03303581103682518,
0.654306173324585,
0.2672080099582672,
0.08315880596637726,
-0.027026589959859848,
0.7991414070129395,
0.1856621354818344,
-0.3943360149860382,
0.4211882948875427,
0.20496131479740143,
-0.47563740611076355,
0.5517401695251465,
-0.4347453713417053,
0.45188072323799133,
-0.04765228554606438,
0.22070756554603577,
-1.0608887672424316,
-0.09129183739423752,
0.11054295301437378,
-0.3375556468963623,
0.376632958650589,
0.024394217878580093,
-0.4456349015235901,
-0.4047221541404724,
-0.6172908544540405,
0.6556040644645691,
0.359655499458313,
-0.5299181342124939,
0.26266181468963623,
0.5465365052223206,
-0.03108949027955532,
-0.6520818471908569,
-0.5611150860786438,
0.09057755023241043,
-0.30059120059013367,
-0.6608538627624512,
0.43324270844459534,
-0.0923115536570549,
-0.627899169921875,
-0.11718592792749405,
-0.3169670104980469,
0.34697893261909485,
0.08243827521800995,
0.2523680329322815,
0.6401185393333435,
-0.13800522685050964,
0.24677437543869019,
-0.23802317678928375,
-0.23189446330070496,
0.042655352503061295,
-0.12435148656368256,
0.5758753418922424,
-0.0947006419301033,
-0.4098350703716278,
-0.07390681654214859,
0.18739765882492065,
0.3741133213043213,
-0.2391739934682846,
0.3667110204696655,
0.3493053913116455,
-0.23821061849594116,
-0.013799776323139668,
-1.0591684579849243,
-0.19755616784095764,
-0.44066354632377625,
0.14641620218753815,
-0.06860721111297607,
-0.8855381011962891,
0.13831603527069092,
0.34495922923088074,
-0.04290632903575897,
0.43007439374923706,
0.44602519273757935,
-0.026298200711607933,
1.0447431802749634,
0.5235066413879395,
-0.471852570772171,
0.26563560962677,
0.27421295642852783,
0.4573771059513092,
-1.0563150644302368,
-0.0348343588411808,
-0.61186683177948,
-0.5020784735679626,
-0.5516331791877747,
-0.27465689182281494,
0.4453769326210022,
0.10747093707323074,
-0.24661913514137268,
0.11464805901050568,
-0.5442370176315308,
0.5560532212257385,
0.5730610489845276,
0.2519066631793976,
0.24769583344459534,
-0.23695585131645203,
-0.22417575120925903,
-0.19185587763786316,
-0.5669677257537842,
-0.8270794153213501,
1.341644525527954,
0.3187284767627716,
0.7026797533035278,
0.10170332342386246,
0.8165749311447144,
0.22866545617580414,
0.2377415895462036,
-0.9338921904563904,
0.4765465259552002,
-0.03727319464087486,
-0.4876917898654938,
-0.47345659136772156,
-0.4672383964061737,
-0.7831254601478577,
0.18364426493644714,
-0.2349713295698166,
-0.7720292806625366,
-0.12588907778263092,
0.04043274745345116,
-0.4693242311477661,
0.1182406023144722,
-0.7760135531425476,
0.8834818601608276,
-0.5375828742980957,
-0.535382866859436,
-0.33059990406036377,
-0.7616224884986877,
0.40415772795677185,
-0.0880851075053215,
0.2433008998632431,
-0.11066149175167084,
0.034259725362062454,
1.0083889961242676,
-0.08522608876228333,
0.4881077706813812,
0.06231943145394325,
-0.23769967257976532,
-0.07925797998905182,
0.20022471249103546,
0.35101649165153503,
0.022116363048553467,
-0.5964019298553467,
0.06334004551172256,
0.0062078433111310005,
-0.23777863383293152,
-0.5647161602973938,
0.9707825183868408,
-0.7082637548446655,
-0.9450576305389404,
-0.4465886354446411,
-0.4645661413669586,
-0.3669818937778473,
0.1714385747909546,
0.03421163558959961,
0.2538602650165558,
-0.30413469672203064,
-0.01927957497537136,
0.5225902795791626,
-0.062252845615148544,
0.34433436393737793,
0.13337501883506775,
-0.6217095851898193,
-0.3959614336490631,
0.7578875422477722,
-0.18003734946250916,
0.4301917850971222,
0.5928435921669006,
0.5385376214981079,
-0.5209980607032776,
-0.43640395998954773,
-0.41958409547805786,
0.317325621843338,
-0.69541996717453,
-0.18816787004470825,
-0.22727712988853455,
-0.0739758312702179,
-0.4824470281600952,
-0.2225668877363205,
-0.19896043837070465,
-0.2101515382528305,
-0.1121932715177536,
-0.11792200058698654,
0.18689173460006714,
0.834961473941803,
0.17816925048828125,
0.05900208652019501,
-0.6562856435775757,
0.13452006876468658,
0.49849292635917664,
0.4696153998374939,
-0.021194661036133766,
-0.4962776005268097,
-0.075992152094841,
-0.05190245807170868,
-0.21408970654010773,
-0.7149195075035095,
0.22838212549686432,
-0.2123108059167862,
0.603013277053833,
0.34413912892341614,
0.165103942155838,
0.6565245389938354,
-0.22942252457141876,
0.7177942395210266,
0.060126934200525284,
-0.9934152364730835,
0.3177187442779541,
-0.27025681734085083,
-0.011800777167081833,
0.7669918537139893,
0.15941354632377625,
-0.6613714098930359,
0.01115791592746973,
-0.32813361287117004,
-0.6033039689064026,
0.7960711717605591,
0.05783497169613838,
-0.11909782141447067,
0.426078200340271,
0.2602245509624481,
0.0004411221598275006,
0.15684859454631805,
-0.48752647638320923,
-0.25253480672836304,
0.18584950268268585,
-0.36967945098876953,
-0.45859864354133606,
-0.3273126482963562,
-0.295193076133728,
-0.20619431138038635,
0.6944382190704346,
-0.06313063949346542,
0.025550605729222298,
0.13338913023471832,
0.01714397221803665,
-0.49452847242355347,
0.3120959997177124,
0.40593644976615906,
0.5888422131538391,
-0.4071984887123108,
0.23692183196544647,
-0.0669197291135788,
-0.11422900855541229,
0.14657048881053925,
0.08775979280471802,
-0.18155166506767273,
-0.2350495606660843,
0.16632090508937836,
0.778205156326294,
0.6073184609413147,
-0.5797600746154785,
0.7468323707580566,
-0.05054432526230812,
0.0660412535071373,
-0.0855654627084732,
-0.021080050617456436,
0.25847679376602173,
0.15652433037757874,
0.22409792244434357,
0.035655707120895386,
0.08519170433282852,
-0.35932204127311707,
-0.07071433216333389,
0.7064553499221802,
-0.35742899775505066,
-0.08052089810371399,
0.45832177996635437,
0.2696794867515564,
-0.6843217611312866,
0.5657851099967957,
-0.048083871603012085,
-0.7957775592803955,
0.4555825889110565,
0.27141374349594116,
0.7675443291664124,
-0.24621936678886414,
0.04782846197485924,
0.16809387505054474,
0.2258964627981186,
-0.3995398283004761,
-0.02419893816113472,
-0.13293559849262238,
-1.0235003232955933,
-0.14174140989780426,
-0.7671843767166138,
-0.6420175433158875,
-0.19308632612228394,
-0.7089748978614807,
0.547852098941803,
-0.14588791131973267,
-0.20807629823684692,
-0.05473051220178604,
0.11871116608381271,
-0.6278454065322876,
0.00793267972767353,
0.2526499927043915,
0.6396891474723816,
-0.6546550393104553,
0.8276321291923523,
0.6553354859352112,
-0.22550690174102783,
-0.9287129044532776,
0.07167059928178787,
0.09510257095098495,
-0.893648087978363,
0.613724946975708,
0.23503074049949646,
-0.20765608549118042,
-0.06573189049959183,
-0.2527051568031311,
-0.758033275604248,
0.9404411911964417,
0.38442766666412354,
-0.7317870855331421,
-0.19760246574878693,
0.004316445905715227,
0.4367057681083679,
-0.12959538400173187,
0.4007384181022644,
0.6999876499176025,
0.7818593382835388,
-0.2861591577529907,
-1.1926615238189697,
0.020131560042500496,
-0.006102984305471182,
0.09065572917461395,
0.5506910681724548,
-0.8023244738578796,
0.4679979979991913,
-0.08669167011976242,
-0.03885025158524513,
-0.10776297748088837,
0.2247197926044464,
0.26337289810180664,
0.2923392951488495,
0.5742714405059814,
0.5634303092956543,
0.7373344302177429,
-0.09639030694961548,
0.962776243686676,
-0.2557941675186157,
0.3074275255203247,
0.9456366896629333,
-0.5777662396430969,
1.0764073133468628,
0.8058323860168457,
-0.41769224405288696,
0.35802018642425537,
0.7317816019058228,
0.24993282556533813,
0.22937439382076263,
0.26651403307914734,
-0.20955398678779602,
-0.6219251155853271,
-0.1051478385925293,
-0.13837961852550507,
0.3885447680950165,
0.0836075022816658,
-0.27896416187286377,
-0.05332662910223007,
-0.4271167814731598,
-0.17289498448371887,
0.4085998237133026,
-0.09278403967618942,
0.5506451725959778,
0.20425593852996826,
-1.0193312168121338,
0.374660462141037,
0.07219468802213669,
0.8249668478965759,
-0.3711554706096649,
0.19097013771533966,
-0.0708695501089096,
0.008327293209731579,
-0.3579291105270386,
-1.0027457475662231,
0.08044225722551346,
-0.24486997723579407,
-0.1257813721895218,
-0.4525512158870697,
0.6651515960693359,
-0.31460678577423096,
-0.3889395296573639,
0.5537633299827576,
0.4200546443462372,
0.001962886191904545,
-0.04874015599489212,
-0.5555826425552368,
0.2479631006717682,
-0.0020015116315335035,
-0.28125354647636414,
0.4461768865585327,
-0.05016981437802315,
-0.1722772866487503,
0.5735429525375366,
0.652916431427002,
0.15875467658042908,
-0.18155981600284576,
0.24343454837799072,
0.5782642364501953,
-0.6217260956764221,
-0.21614611148834229,
-1.0092319250106812,
0.09411003440618515,
0.08018387109041214,
-0.29137077927589417,
0.6293383836746216,
0.7389832139015198,
0.7310655117034912,
0.3048897981643677,
0.6452980041503906,
0.3306492865085602,
0.41994139552116394,
-0.6082491278648376,
0.7149573564529419,
-0.41025450825691223,
0.377655029296875,
-0.29389306902885437,
-1.179317593574524,
-0.3491855263710022,
0.6430741548538208,
-0.5386527180671692,
0.02623155154287815,
0.5799645185470581,
0.9103195667266846,
0.04511019587516785,
0.09727972000837326,
0.2860623002052307,
-0.16860733926296234,
0.3358096182346344,
0.5744304656982422,
0.7808604836463928,
-0.525715708732605,
0.22182895243167877,
-0.2461816370487213,
-0.08867305517196655,
-0.2629430592060089,
-1.0939160585403442,
-0.760219395160675,
-0.5417895913124084,
-0.048179157078266144,
-0.1651872992515564,
0.017260689288377762,
1.3786969184875488,
0.6851633191108704,
-0.6105628609657288,
-0.6132509708404541,
-0.0033384282141923904,
0.40026772022247314,
0.0869961604475975,
-0.26863861083984375,
0.33753281831741333,
-0.19383080303668976,
-0.7960459589958191,
0.38752657175064087,
0.3301893472671509,
-0.12691117823123932,
-0.6557809114456177,
-0.430219829082489,
-0.18532785773277283,
-0.12460941821336746,
0.3044014573097229,
-0.12084615975618362,
-0.9344434142112732,
-0.42688024044036865,
-0.14073646068572998,
-0.38107290863990784,
0.25236448645591736,
0.7850481271743774,
-0.8193049430847168,
0.4966609477996826,
0.6015809774398804,
0.6970109343528748,
0.22636482119560242,
0.1259966343641281,
0.9341740012168884,
-0.45470696687698364,
-0.16744540631771088,
0.28120604157447815,
0.3292410671710968,
0.6006686687469482,
-0.2995325028896332,
0.4551840126514435,
0.0013922525104135275,
-1.032773494720459,
-0.9479817748069763,
-0.010574406012892723,
-1.1255388259887695,
0.019034493714571,
1.3064498901367188,
0.2556525468826294,
-0.03285691514611244,
0.09378387778997421,
-0.35192927718162537,
0.216352641582489,
-0.601760983467102,
0.7127177119255066,
0.9915977120399475,
-0.006860583089292049,
0.030385587364435196,
-0.41575315594673157,
0.35815078020095825,
0.6784870028495789,
-0.4983600676059723,
0.030127961188554764,
0.38721078634262085,
0.1999044120311737,
0.11089786887168884,
0.457065224647522,
0.06350118666887283,
-0.10163407772779465,
-0.48329785466194153,
-0.0017868897411972284,
0.2279859185218811,
0.007317433133721352,
-0.5527061820030212,
-0.0739171952009201,
0.4997541606426239,
0.08632400631904602
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16941v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16941v1
|
SPACE-IDEAS: A Dataset for Salient Information Detection in Space Innovation
| 2024-03-25T17:04:02 | 2024-03-25T17:04:02 |
Andrés García-Silva, Cristian Berrío, José Manuel Gómez-Pérez
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DL
|
Detecting salient parts in text using natural language processing has been
widely used to mitigate the effects of information overflow. Nevertheless, most
of the datasets available for this task are derived mainly from academic
publications. We introduce SPACE-IDEAS, a dataset for salient information
detection from innovation ideas related to the Space domain. The text in
SPACE-IDEAS varies greatly and includes informal, technical, academic and
business-oriented writing styles. In addition to a manually annotated dataset
we release an extended version that is annotated using a large generative
language model. We train different sentence and sequential sentence
classifiers, and show that the automatically annotated dataset can be leveraged
using multitask learning to train better classifiers.
|
[
-0.4287799298763275,
-0.6364589333534241,
0.9535547494888306,
0.13443642854690552,
-0.37091273069381714,
0.11378787457942963,
-0.21749040484428406,
-0.5663728713989258,
0.4908554255962372,
0.29565414786338806,
-0.6336690187454224,
-0.5767017006874084,
-0.3622678518295288,
-0.07664082944393158,
-0.4602019190788269,
1.033464789390564,
0.026694336906075478,
-0.4263429045677185,
-0.5065715312957764,
0.10649705678224564,
-0.6346573829650879,
-0.3401252329349518,
-0.2153833657503128,
0.27898138761520386,
0.5185681581497192,
0.6423867344856262,
0.32829001545906067,
0.4310717284679413,
0.7365335822105408,
0.19794094562530518,
0.11885980516672134,
0.2515958845615387,
-0.0444103442132473,
0.006093173287808895,
0.008454196155071259,
-0.3792196810245514,
0.1329135298728943,
-0.14933058619499207,
0.6178818941116333,
0.563470721244812,
0.1529899537563324,
0.12180598080158234,
-0.29196950793266296,
0.691506028175354,
-0.6553459763526917,
0.38572368025779724,
-0.2936249077320099,
0.22469839453697205,
-0.5582019686698914,
-0.11573874205350876,
-0.11718664318323135,
-0.5127296447753906,
-0.013745099306106567,
-0.7075873613357544,
0.2949436604976654,
0.36663728952407837,
0.8251298666000366,
0.37323784828186035,
0.27754175662994385,
-0.7032294273376465,
-0.6178818345069885,
0.7161958813667297,
-0.3234257400035858,
0.18676221370697021,
0.017721574753522873,
0.19315676391124725,
0.023574840277433395,
-0.4811335504055023,
-0.9354156851768494,
-0.10940646380186081,
-0.05533439666032791,
0.07746218889951706,
-0.2649761140346527,
-0.2737928032875061,
0.18988844752311707,
0.2105969935655594,
-0.6595693826675415,
-0.21780537068843842,
-0.44232064485549927,
0.3257252871990204,
0.5384658575057983,
-0.16887317597866058,
-0.050304852426052094,
-0.38966599106788635,
-0.43782997131347656,
-0.02669372409582138,
-0.5369143486022949,
-0.0040679508820176125,
0.40443384647369385,
0.2665574848651886,
0.11749926954507828,
0.6742070913314819,
-0.3654656410217285,
0.5803571939468384,
-0.015926234424114227,
0.5179353952407837,
0.4144872725009918,
-0.512157142162323,
-0.012112359516322613,
0.03333762660622597,
0.6108211278915405,
0.1888565719127655,
-0.06232384592294693,
-0.3505614101886749,
0.005989610217511654,
0.17125071585178375,
0.2568598687648773,
-0.5604798197746277,
-0.32327359914779663,
0.3023996651172638,
-0.24953478574752808,
-0.12992972135543823,
0.6687292456626892,
-0.5730851888656616,
-0.6562478542327881,
-0.19309954345226288,
0.029484305530786514,
-0.49844178557395935,
-0.08635149896144867,
0.2959049344062805,
-0.6788603067398071,
-0.2577337920665741,
0.22610759735107422,
-0.8980457186698914,
0.05727729573845863,
0.8119957447052002,
0.8515965342521667,
-0.09207119792699814,
-0.2177884876728058,
0.05422506853938103,
0.05357417091727257,
-0.19230733811855316,
1.4053009748458862,
-0.702135443687439,
-0.2543502748012543,
-0.26207977533340454,
-0.09596053510904312,
0.04063846543431282,
-0.36359333992004395,
0.7591070532798767,
-0.38162869215011597,
0.3109050989151001,
-0.42420029640197754,
-0.6569473743438721,
-0.11466517299413681,
0.03374870494008064,
-0.8283735513687134,
0.9675054550170898,
0.13085000216960907,
-0.9384540915489197,
1.0037178993225098,
-1.4486647844314575,
-0.6038781404495239,
0.4477618932723999,
-0.3248392641544342,
-0.6651853919029236,
0.1857452094554901,
0.12602980434894562,
0.3315461277961731,
0.006603963207453489,
0.3449246883392334,
-0.008874057792127132,
-0.24384289979934692,
0.5903009176254272,
0.1524733304977417,
0.10665293037891388,
0.2913505733013153,
-0.4189896583557129,
0.25503185391426086,
-0.7694332599639893,
0.029368460178375244,
0.18193171918392181,
-0.28985893726348877,
-0.5798870921134949,
-0.18478384613990784,
0.1781366914510727,
0.04613236337900162,
0.13367502391338348,
-0.7984287142753601,
0.30004802346229553,
-0.13536222279071808,
0.18626676499843597,
0.3516043424606323,
0.45672065019607544,
0.2803671956062317,
-0.29428771138191223,
0.30128881335258484,
0.028665445744991302,
0.22669845819473267,
-0.2406855970621109,
-0.717758297920227,
-0.7008371949195862,
-0.31983816623687744,
0.008062358945608139,
0.17847467958927155,
-0.6972929835319519,
0.7849213480949402,
-0.03902524709701538,
-0.44052258133888245,
-0.6637507081031799,
-0.13259196281433105,
0.09312400221824646,
0.2902429699897766,
0.29877275228500366,
-0.12012133002281189,
-0.6942517161369324,
-0.9420934319496155,
-0.6974927186965942,
0.08075264096260071,
0.055154021829366684,
0.2938145697116852,
0.7006145715713501,
-0.19851207733154297,
1.0720696449279785,
-0.9439115524291992,
-0.12807315587997437,
-0.14829586446285248,
0.5480971336364746,
0.2498539388179779,
0.4200690984725952,
0.45970577001571655,
-1.3216164112091064,
-0.19330812990665436,
-0.2847736179828644,
-0.52983158826828,
-0.002780711045488715,
-0.18048568069934845,
-0.13839079439640045,
-0.19276981055736542,
0.4657839834690094,
-0.768947422504425,
0.2309810221195221,
-0.05528884381055832,
-0.530103862285614,
0.3893233835697174,
0.33534368872642517,
0.4343758225440979,
-1.170485258102417,
0.31280383467674255,
0.30903685092926025,
0.24867098033428192,
-0.5262126326560974,
-0.3775195777416229,
0.07158022373914719,
-0.12420327216386795,
-0.28787341713905334,
0.5530555248260498,
-0.26557788252830505,
0.10875224322080612,
-0.5903270840644836,
0.2781488001346588,
0.29434096813201904,
0.23349972069263458,
0.38818448781967163,
0.5395252108573914,
0.11336355656385422,
-0.3935677409172058,
0.623680591583252,
0.3974994421005249,
-0.6535535454750061,
0.4302850663661957,
-0.1354585736989975,
0.1731289029121399,
-0.5018429756164551,
0.14020250737667084,
-1.034860610961914,
-0.5780614614486694,
0.16783303022384644,
-0.29271140694618225,
-0.23369115591049194,
0.07671518623828888,
-0.887656033039093,
-0.7309684753417969,
-0.5013502836227417,
-0.00585856381803751,
-0.08633752167224884,
-0.625002920627594,
-0.17208153009414673,
0.5964548587799072,
-0.5821037292480469,
-0.5883985161781311,
-0.5509212613105774,
0.17465980350971222,
-0.42254525423049927,
-0.31863436102867126,
0.5342410206794739,
-0.03966258838772774,
-0.08943358063697815,
0.5459502339363098,
0.41466453671455383,
-0.2125176191329956,
0.06858690083026886,
0.6060091853141785,
0.37070348858833313,
0.05193734169006348,
0.5073732733726501,
-0.19433721899986267,
-0.03826699033379555,
-0.07221242040395737,
-0.5791330933570862,
0.3303872346878052,
-0.30566856265068054,
-0.2838101089000702,
-0.2922382056713104,
0.3388679325580597,
0.39089271426200867,
0.19166968762874603,
0.5059605836868286,
0.7775338292121887,
-0.552596926689148,
-0.2583327293395996,
-0.48769402503967285,
-0.006436523050069809,
-0.39956873655319214,
0.6545915603637695,
-0.09712044149637222,
-0.6612212061882019,
0.06200845539569855,
-0.2479945719242096,
0.24193556606769562,
0.4712051749229431,
0.2468402087688446,
-0.38119032979011536,
0.3337561786174774,
1.2781697511672974,
-0.0022415691055357456,
0.8966670036315918,
-0.34694766998291016,
0.47126802802085876,
-0.7818501591682434,
-0.4095485508441925,
-0.4675846993923187,
-0.34419021010398865,
-0.025356292724609375,
-0.4714789390563965,
0.034514736384153366,
-0.10188837349414825,
0.24025072157382965,
0.5337497591972351,
-0.6382519006729126,
0.7480467557907104,
0.6841447353363037,
-0.21572397649288177,
0.1228390783071518,
-0.017270969226956367,
0.24997767806053162,
-0.11447398364543915,
-0.8198240399360657,
-0.7174873352050781,
0.8166375756263733,
0.24518072605133057,
0.757961630821228,
-0.15343700349330902,
0.4096970856189728,
0.4545561969280243,
0.4407499432563782,
-0.8417945504188538,
0.2863011658191681,
-0.2449548989534378,
-0.38017594814300537,
-0.2051534503698349,
-0.3870847225189209,
-0.5308821797370911,
-0.24488340318202972,
-0.15996339917182922,
-0.45311474800109863,
0.44625553488731384,
-0.033564306795597076,
-0.8064367771148682,
0.18234896659851074,
-0.9970664381980896,
0.6916212439537048,
-0.28172585368156433,
-0.15025722980499268,
-0.035215187817811966,
-0.46221891045570374,
0.049543410539627075,
-0.22555659711360931,
0.15976391732692719,
-0.0507945716381073,
0.3048921227455139,
1.0133873224258423,
0.20455463230609894,
0.8095452785491943,
-0.28693774342536926,
0.11542179435491562,
0.4422650635242462,
-0.4749739170074463,
0.13738444447517395,
0.08705434948205948,
0.028731483966112137,
-0.08809272199869156,
-0.5689734816551208,
-0.0998675748705864,
-0.47122400999069214,
0.5511263012886047,
-0.4144230782985687,
-0.27432385087013245,
-0.2879665195941925,
-0.8215736746788025,
-0.14355254173278809,
0.09519568085670471,
0.4305685758590698,
-0.10376063734292984,
-0.3674912750720978,
0.16435039043426514,
0.2847294211387634,
-0.06221054121851921,
0.49905622005462646,
0.2278507649898529,
0.1943296194076538,
-0.2214396744966507,
0.7898256182670593,
0.07249067723751068,
-0.0644603744149208,
0.45321381092071533,
-0.03598656877875328,
-0.5840786099433899,
-0.25645822286605835,
-0.45429080724716187,
0.0643816739320755,
-0.8359176516532898,
-0.11035403609275818,
-0.7230261564254761,
-0.1863396316766739,
-0.2507651746273041,
-0.3169492781162262,
-0.24668394029140472,
-0.8494239449501038,
-0.27601170539855957,
-0.13088339567184448,
0.43717485666275024,
0.9941625595092773,
0.10645598918199539,
0.16207915544509888,
-0.466426283121109,
0.2711067795753479,
-0.04635382443666458,
0.18854166567325592,
-0.23987670242786407,
-0.0943855568766594,
-0.7182245850563049,
-0.22720161080360413,
-0.43388113379478455,
-0.27225959300994873,
0.27375417947769165,
0.12100787460803986,
0.4677274823188782,
0.47425737977027893,
-0.36088696122169495,
0.2838252782821655,
-0.30112695693969727,
0.8113203048706055,
0.3852459192276001,
-0.6239490509033203,
0.9452037215232849,
0.0644480437040329,
0.5214431285858154,
0.5106057524681091,
0.4584536552429199,
-0.8059042096138,
-0.33103299140930176,
-0.7044587731361389,
-0.8340092301368713,
0.4044124484062195,
0.15665516257286072,
-0.2077651172876358,
0.06365914642810822,
0.2808217704296112,
0.49852368235588074,
0.8377078175544739,
-0.7673748135566711,
0.20782682299613953,
-0.2482694387435913,
-0.5600402355194092,
0.35646551847457886,
0.02288598008453846,
-0.21229369938373566,
0.2126147300004959,
0.6079269051551819,
-0.08506229519844055,
0.42090511322021484,
-0.005705373361706734,
0.051670096814632416,
-0.12476655095815659,
0.6087560057640076,
0.5082494616508484,
0.4829026758670807,
-0.13004641234874725,
0.27314504981040955,
-0.21975669264793396,
-0.6528723239898682,
-0.018952105194330215,
0.3263508677482605,
-0.30626675486564636,
0.3234544098377228,
0.11797357350587845,
0.8209824562072754,
0.17226454615592957,
-0.5941178798675537,
0.43674713373184204,
-0.11488480865955353,
-0.009288951754570007,
-0.18849170207977295,
0.254184365272522,
0.05468747019767761,
0.4102991819381714,
0.5057543516159058,
0.6393299698829651,
0.3467268943786621,
-0.6300382018089294,
0.21527957916259766,
0.18075419962406158,
-0.31284332275390625,
-0.5058635473251343,
0.45030125975608826,
0.18821801245212555,
-0.010405309498310089,
0.11717985570430756,
-0.41350337862968445,
-0.5216478109359741,
0.7136142253875732,
0.4515886902809143,
0.8676646947860718,
0.3156574070453644,
0.29396331310272217,
0.04459312558174133,
0.16097085177898407,
0.005766357760876417,
0.5357840061187744,
-0.15169966220855713,
-0.6540096402168274,
-0.08666156232357025,
-0.43815097212791443,
-0.35578641295433044,
0.31545522809028625,
-0.05564197152853012,
0.3852931261062622,
-0.4871833920478821,
-0.5339584946632385,
0.4673154354095459,
0.02569076232612133,
-0.6802822351455688,
0.10570098459720612,
0.33064794540405273,
0.49652382731437683,
-0.9432576298713684,
0.44853612780570984,
0.9485372304916382,
-0.4215115010738373,
-0.02447713166475296,
0.21769841015338898,
-0.1830645054578781,
-0.2823026776313782,
1.0620341300964355,
0.2863222062587738,
-0.2603483498096466,
-0.29986515641212463,
-0.6550376415252686,
-0.9015220999717712,
0.7931305766105652,
0.01370942685753107,
-0.6872103214263916,
-0.053391970694065094,
0.0770779699087143,
0.2642304599285126,
-0.7449389696121216,
-0.25906115770339966,
0.2905564308166504,
0.6189016103744507,
-0.03328164666891098,
-0.4780285954475403,
-0.18294616043567657,
-0.4891992211341858,
-0.21393191814422607,
0.24998904764652252,
-0.6823750138282776,
0.8276492953300476,
-0.6154692769050598,
-0.44031697511672974,
0.04441400244832039,
0.5139946937561035,
0.44542139768600464,
0.4413701295852661,
0.5541417598724365,
0.558954119682312,
1.0612311363220215,
-0.2570016086101532,
0.6569047570228577,
-0.1713712513446808,
0.18505261838436127,
0.8849278092384338,
-0.28592434525489807,
0.6434523463249207,
0.51234370470047,
0.2394963800907135,
0.565127432346344,
0.42800721526145935,
-0.579643189907074,
0.9305607676506042,
0.13938306272029877,
-0.2750483751296997,
0.5357851386070251,
-0.4661194384098053,
-0.2815200388431549,
0.049034785479307175,
0.6737670302391052,
-0.24960081279277802,
0.07622947543859482,
0.3006422221660614,
-0.015756547451019287,
-0.04976880922913551,
0.142660990357399,
0.7232411503791809,
-0.04731304198503494,
-0.47449618577957153,
0.020454436540603638,
0.004498336464166641,
0.788161039352417,
-0.25975245237350464,
-0.2346762865781784,
0.20644710958003998,
0.09102638810873032,
-0.42381688952445984,
-1.1651065349578857,
0.20815728604793549,
0.28194552659988403,
-0.4423830509185791,
-0.08999668061733246,
0.9222607016563416,
-0.47599196434020996,
-0.42874425649642944,
-0.1063367947936058,
0.20959937572479248,
0.10576164722442627,
-0.23978719115257263,
-0.5497308969497681,
-0.24336351454257965,
-0.22438478469848633,
0.07657885551452637,
-0.35882675647735596,
0.7008293867111206,
0.05984175577759743,
0.3505912125110626,
0.6570313572883606,
0.3652290105819702,
-0.09806663542985916,
0.310379296541214,
1.062952995300293,
-0.946023166179657,
-1.135309100151062,
-0.6197385787963867,
0.39961373805999756,
-0.6660405993461609,
-0.5318975448608398,
0.7792105674743652,
0.853328287601471,
0.6617876291275024,
-0.4455156922340393,
1.327027678489685,
-0.26756832003593445,
0.6687883734703064,
-0.4761258065700531,
0.5928833484649658,
-0.034219007939100266,
0.23730862140655518,
-0.37542301416397095,
-0.8122309446334839,
-0.3067389130592346,
0.5738125443458557,
-0.49016427993774414,
0.06049143150448799,
0.9301221370697021,
0.38919517397880554,
-0.14220549166202545,
0.39648982882499695,
-0.032523974776268005,
-0.10683875530958176,
0.36811119318008423,
0.49515411257743835,
1.2098740339279175,
-0.25314486026763916,
0.2330939769744873,
-0.1365826427936554,
-0.3331257104873657,
-0.5576215386390686,
-0.6688854694366455,
-0.6980217695236206,
-0.9058067798614502,
-0.514804482460022,
0.11988690495491028,
0.038749583065509796,
0.7451475262641907,
0.9100278615951538,
-0.8200469613075256,
0.10355477780103683,
-0.29791373014450073,
-0.038151826709508896,
-0.06133013963699341,
-0.3108592927455902,
0.5161884427070618,
-0.40111443400382996,
-0.25285953283309937,
0.6040608286857605,
0.6802497506141663,
0.11352657526731491,
-0.11397227644920349,
0.4831309914588928,
-0.38120776414871216,
0.016109859570860863,
0.5221434235572815,
0.2968828082084656,
-0.32494696974754333,
-0.3657228946685791,
0.14230084419250488,
-0.0229495819658041,
0.14637413620948792,
1.0483696460723877,
-0.6359118819236755,
0.27438998222351074,
0.16116242110729218,
0.6698406338691711,
0.2533848285675049,
0.14371617138385773,
0.13152071833610535,
-1.3503926992416382,
0.5458701848983765,
0.5087124705314636,
0.3004907965660095,
0.759063184261322,
-0.7647596001625061,
0.4278174936771393,
0.41059455275535583,
-0.36872994899749756,
-0.44687071442604065,
0.04964355006814003,
-0.5257747769355774,
-0.5274415612220764,
0.7917136549949646,
-0.044624440371990204,
-0.4264712929725647,
-0.4192374348640442,
-0.4049557149410248,
-0.07698444277048111,
-0.6783727407455444,
1.2771438360214233,
0.7806867957115173,
-0.3879193961620331,
0.24326489865779877,
-0.4619574546813965,
0.8183539509773254,
0.2122357189655304,
-1.4366793632507324,
0.24791313707828522,
0.4083642363548279,
-0.08303654938936234,
0.9125571250915527,
0.5292331576347351,
-0.019526856020092964,
0.31932714581489563,
0.04406026005744934,
0.24328739941120148,
0.09169595688581467,
-0.6585162281990051,
0.1754472702741623,
0.2725293040275574,
0.010474609211087227,
-0.42395177483558655
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16915v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16915v3
|
Coarse-Tuning for Ad-hoc Document Retrieval Using Pre-trained Language Models
| 2024-03-25T16:32:50 | 2024-03-27T01:53:36 |
Atsushi Keyaki, Ribeka Keyaki
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Fine-tuning in information retrieval systems using pre-trained language
models (PLM-based IR) requires learning query representations and
query-document relations, in addition to downstream task-specific learning.
This study introduces coarse-tuning as an intermediate learning stage that
bridges pre-training and fine-tuning. By learning query representations and
query-document relations in coarse-tuning, we aim to reduce the load of
fine-tuning and improve the learning effect of downstream IR tasks. We propose
Query-Document Pair Prediction (QDPP) for coarse-tuning, which predicts the
appropriateness of query-document pairs. Evaluation experiments show that the
proposed method significantly improves MRR and/or nDCG@5 in four ad-hoc
document retrieval datasets. Furthermore, the results of the query prediction
task suggested that coarse-tuning facilitated learning of query representation
and query-document relations.
|
[
-0.5915688276290894,
-0.6304327249526978,
0.45762088894844055,
-0.49102821946144104,
-0.5355522632598877,
-0.14774927496910095,
-0.33648720383644104,
-0.37023672461509705,
0.0463634692132473,
0.4884051978588104,
-0.5054634213447571,
-0.5454588532447815,
-0.5919908881187439,
-0.09925626218318939,
-0.14934562146663666,
0.8503572940826416,
0.2296200841665268,
0.20292985439300537,
-0.23790475726127625,
-0.17147065699100494,
-0.20077408850193024,
-0.2754506766796112,
-0.7096578478813171,
-0.29890698194503784,
0.5501950979232788,
0.47775813937187195,
0.6623470783233643,
0.9502431154251099,
0.5945414900779724,
0.2525714933872223,
0.2671082615852356,
0.5220828652381897,
-0.6031090617179871,
0.3058035373687744,
-0.35513049364089966,
-0.5588955283164978,
-0.2543577551841736,
0.3166866898536682,
0.5984811186790466,
0.7060167193412781,
-0.29545095562934875,
0.09978421032428741,
0.17720584571361542,
0.8464164137840271,
-0.6088602542877197,
0.3192906975746155,
-1.1695619821548462,
-0.3251156806945801,
-0.3846331536769867,
-0.8222554326057434,
-0.34399670362472534,
-0.24101200699806213,
-0.18858271837234497,
-0.7710090279579163,
0.6162190437316895,
0.5588476061820984,
1.137624979019165,
0.13925080001354218,
-0.381695419549942,
-0.32794302701950073,
-0.5155042409896851,
0.5253297090530396,
-0.5531601905822754,
0.4906308054924011,
1.0669472217559814,
0.10482291877269745,
-0.27990812063217163,
-0.715876579284668,
-0.3812122046947479,
-0.185334712266922,
-0.25389546155929565,
-0.06622330844402313,
0.43353644013404846,
0.4224129021167755,
0.0851508378982544,
0.47710561752319336,
-0.6439348459243774,
0.1180286630988121,
-0.34072431921958923,
0.02599375881254673,
0.45152726769447327,
0.057716209441423416,
-0.16534540057182312,
0.09072162955999374,
-0.08358951658010483,
-0.10737878084182739,
-0.5056001543998718,
-0.18847593665122986,
0.3781200051307678,
0.7129940390586853,
0.17427891492843628,
0.22493217885494232,
-0.45977461338043213,
0.9218775033950806,
0.35810232162475586,
0.17134463787078857,
0.023181414231657982,
-0.5110870003700256,
-0.03151342272758484,
-0.20097540318965912,
0.630451500415802,
0.1430332362651825,
0.1869053691625595,
-0.45542460680007935,
-0.41040506958961487,
-0.14816133677959442,
0.32491809129714966,
-0.6955764889717102,
-0.4031165838241577,
-0.1835985630750656,
-0.42702728509902954,
-0.1673092097043991,
0.2983704209327698,
-0.31167542934417725,
-0.17943249642848969,
-0.8052381277084351,
0.6263983249664307,
-0.6448413133621216,
0.06852739304304123,
0.14199793338775635,
0.15401925146579742,
0.23074080049991608,
0.33814752101898193,
-0.8298072218894958,
0.671460747718811,
0.572943925857544,
0.6143691539764404,
0.16321416199207306,
-0.4010379910469055,
-0.9776608943939209,
0.23034566640853882,
-0.07339978963136673,
1.1465457677841187,
-0.7796299457550049,
-0.4597471058368683,
-0.07879368960857391,
-0.047949887812137604,
-0.3615860044956207,
-0.5851253271102905,
0.7520222067832947,
-0.9138003587722778,
0.016014525666832924,
-0.13524655997753143,
-0.5692322254180908,
0.0965697392821312,
0.1397145837545395,
-0.6419781446456909,
1.1766712665557861,
0.09773113578557968,
-0.7784891724586487,
0.30762597918510437,
-0.16233178973197937,
-0.7747230529785156,
-0.04466607794165611,
-0.19659243524074554,
-0.3565874397754669,
0.1682184338569641,
0.18081189692020416,
0.45051082968711853,
-0.35702237486839294,
0.0032927461434155703,
-0.3500112295150757,
-0.5642939805984497,
-0.4623396694660187,
0.11779475957155228,
-0.011981791816651821,
0.24708499014377594,
0.065217025578022,
-0.11028570681810379,
-0.8473182916641235,
0.1588854044675827,
-0.10297266393899918,
-0.5499329566955566,
-0.5668097138404846,
0.1723974049091339,
-0.1459350436925888,
0.2812522053718567,
0.2969740331172943,
-0.28177905082702637,
0.16576968133449554,
-0.6416652798652649,
0.23116497695446014,
0.6896746158599854,
-0.105226069688797,
0.8357464671134949,
-0.5815356969833374,
0.3037690818309784,
-0.06367358565330505,
-0.05510862544178963,
-0.3436473608016968,
-0.05610531568527222,
-0.6416998505592346,
0.30210062861442566,
0.41403019428253174,
0.2529255747795105,
-0.7254422903060913,
0.15460310876369476,
-0.15709231793880463,
-0.37496277689933777,
-0.5663470029830933,
0.3328118622303009,
0.5757308602333069,
0.6301494240760803,
0.4868016242980957,
-0.20010942220687866,
-0.3417131006717682,
-0.41675329208374023,
-0.4992702901363373,
-0.1836027354001999,
0.0007772439857944846,
0.7776064276695251,
0.187051460146904,
0.02838342823088169,
0.6361668109893799,
-0.6994279623031616,
-0.7303881049156189,
0.24661248922348022,
0.6962745785713196,
-0.05285034328699112,
0.5593047738075256,
0.24716979265213013,
-1.0756597518920898,
-0.5531946420669556,
-0.08215590566396713,
-0.005597787909209728,
0.04989083483815193,
0.2630798816680908,
-0.20389139652252197,
0.1442873328924179,
0.7593342661857605,
-0.4439557194709778,
0.14453189074993134,
0.06405308842658997,
-0.1577237993478775,
0.5932939648628235,
-0.6314834356307983,
0.3384774327278137,
-0.783359944820404,
0.06283021718263626,
0.09244470298290253,
-0.3440837860107422,
-0.17532336711883545,
0.13043168187141418,
0.35990044474601746,
-0.27710166573524475,
-0.11070674657821655,
0.5538840293884277,
-0.5513781905174255,
0.04360966384410858,
-0.2207249253988266,
0.19402562081813812,
0.3138631284236908,
0.41293972730636597,
0.05285029113292694,
0.8300167918205261,
0.4542745351791382,
-0.8298764228820801,
-0.1270577609539032,
0.0060561723075807095,
-0.2055162489414215,
0.48025256395339966,
-0.4784325063228607,
0.3715924620628357,
-0.2709938883781433,
0.008793031796813011,
-0.872814416885376,
-0.13925735652446747,
-0.3467417061328888,
-0.6138877868652344,
0.812292754650116,
-0.41596487164497375,
-0.7921221256256104,
-0.1770322024822235,
-0.405701220035553,
0.23863863945007324,
0.0620264895260334,
-0.3193100392818451,
0.4694684147834778,
0.3089318573474884,
-0.13133998215198517,
-0.1912110447883606,
0.042788855731487274,
-0.37850403785705566,
0.11136159300804138,
-0.43018388748168945,
0.7255648374557495,
0.15167619287967682,
0.18341895937919617,
-0.09504350274801254,
-0.3838163912296295,
-0.2677547037601471,
-0.03964638337492943,
0.06945744156837463,
-0.08552905172109604,
-0.17062337696552277,
0.2946520447731018,
0.015342004597187042,
-0.10338172316551208,
-0.23790308833122253,
-0.46794408559799194,
0.5282968282699585,
-0.1558210849761963,
-0.1988316774368286,
0.04544579237699509,
0.1407201886177063,
0.35971909761428833,
-0.6578162312507629,
0.6769561767578125,
0.6910052299499512,
-0.15521210432052612,
-0.130637988448143,
-0.778596818447113,
-0.45986074209213257,
-0.5044522285461426,
0.12462956458330154,
-0.5432064533233643,
-0.7911394834518433,
0.4316389262676239,
-0.3390481173992157,
-0.32165205478668213,
0.22329328954219818,
0.029556989669799805,
-0.4046691954135895,
1.172415018081665,
0.8462185263633728,
-0.04081832990050316,
0.6094348430633545,
-0.30524834990501404,
-0.16616177558898926,
-0.8057423830032349,
-0.26913169026374817,
-0.9664515852928162,
-0.27643945813179016,
-0.5770699381828308,
-0.4485275447368622,
0.3254736363887787,
0.4177098870277405,
-0.420653373003006,
0.1946466565132141,
-0.18517354130744934,
0.43694397807121277,
0.7430710196495056,
0.3879115581512451,
0.4171812832355499,
-0.035063084214925766,
-0.23103390634059906,
0.04576754942536354,
-0.5865848660469055,
-0.20547741651535034,
0.9993016719818115,
-0.2784852087497711,
1.0101189613342285,
-0.3217720687389374,
0.5789490342140198,
0.08319173753261566,
-0.3537645637989044,
-0.6620568037033081,
0.3256215751171112,
-0.5247673988342285,
-0.2161235809326172,
-0.18162758648395538,
-0.4586049020290375,
-0.9440248608589172,
0.2028675675392151,
-0.30629128217697144,
-0.42552053928375244,
0.1567542850971222,
0.14959383010864258,
-0.25073903799057007,
-0.022050220519304276,
-0.49113237857818604,
0.6059901714324951,
-0.03440301865339279,
-0.4218900203704834,
-0.5302824974060059,
-0.8955844044685364,
-0.04121510311961174,
-0.07893206924200058,
0.3386921286582947,
-0.20893630385398865,
0.03938871994614601,
0.5972486138343811,
-0.14843571186065674,
0.37399497628211975,
-0.16285677254199982,
0.2504405081272125,
-0.05661579221487045,
0.21251429617404938,
0.8233138918876648,
0.23854652047157288,
-0.6290835738182068,
-0.31503191590309143,
-0.02860962599515915,
-0.3815643787384033,
-0.5054259300231934,
0.8370386362075806,
-0.7077721357345581,
-0.620144248008728,
-0.23177212476730347,
-0.540092408657074,
-0.42777326703071594,
0.531786322593689,
0.29281651973724365,
0.7197387218475342,
-0.06471966207027435,
0.36523619294166565,
1.031389832496643,
0.17750217020511627,
0.07748819142580032,
1.1891964673995972,
0.20758278667926788,
0.017118168994784355,
0.763103187084198,
0.14611166715621948,
0.012237517163157463,
0.743516206741333,
-0.003796600503847003,
-0.49629783630371094,
-0.8739773631095886,
0.09315342456102371,
0.35018858313560486,
-0.3968307375907898,
-0.47977304458618164,
-0.606683611869812,
-0.008953295648097992,
-0.5749446153640747,
-0.01613524742424488,
-0.2585488557815552,
-0.16287274658679962,
-0.6502417922019958,
0.23592683672904968,
0.2627837061882019,
0.3764174282550812,
0.05194263532757759,
0.4345296621322632,
-0.8672524094581604,
0.496416836977005,
-0.02247820794582367,
0.874079704284668,
-0.22508837282657623,
-0.8379393815994263,
-0.6209107041358948,
-0.0672062560915947,
-0.387310266494751,
-0.2500719130039215,
0.20597781240940094,
0.9825590252876282,
0.42596638202667236,
0.4156001806259155,
0.5783987045288086,
0.7929518818855286,
-0.7693586349487305,
0.22273680567741394,
-0.30900663137435913,
-0.345894992351532,
1.0872241258621216,
-0.6554330587387085,
0.21876224875450134,
1.0910539627075195,
0.6157654523849487,
0.04232042655348778,
-0.48267093300819397,
-0.4435841739177704,
-0.8870584964752197,
1.0632842779159546,
-0.06275481730699539,
0.09787092357873917,
0.02912498451769352,
0.6558148860931396,
0.23180149495601654,
0.24802501499652863,
-0.17504370212554932,
-0.20352564752101898,
0.027474913746118546,
0.08660510927438736,
-0.15830859541893005,
-0.18647505342960358,
0.08208917081356049,
-0.31617844104766846,
0.6396821737289429,
-0.29488199949264526,
-0.024902183562517166,
0.033530671149492264,
-0.19332389533519745,
-0.4639269709587097,
0.042228780686855316,
0.07809596508741379,
0.6887620687484741,
-0.7395925521850586,
0.20774877071380615,
-0.22696886956691742,
-0.4623137414455414,
-0.06860528886318207,
0.611920177936554,
0.22289180755615234,
-0.027893470600247383,
0.003666576463729143,
0.6926299333572388,
0.5467575788497925,
-0.42533984780311584,
0.3964046239852905,
-0.2983963191509247,
-0.07130183279514313,
0.1840459704399109,
0.1795811504125595,
-0.08483225107192993,
0.029042595997452736,
0.4378434717655182,
0.11528963595628738,
0.33846524357795715,
-0.44107627868652344,
0.442624032497406,
0.5984345078468323,
-0.25979387760162354,
-0.25595229864120483,
0.8921718001365662,
0.1764276623725891,
-0.21711762249469757,
0.6501325368881226,
-0.2961856722831726,
0.013047690503299236,
0.38129106163978577,
0.47594162821769714,
0.31157198548316956,
-0.2772241532802582,
-0.015484352596104145,
0.3388856053352356,
-0.02406264841556549,
-0.16511565446853638,
0.29453930258750916,
-0.44988152384757996,
-0.45686984062194824,
-0.2124912142753601,
-1.0429108142852783,
-0.18563812971115112,
0.11025836318731308,
-1.0281790494918823,
0.6656488180160522,
-0.27040979266166687,
-0.05607868731021881,
0.10993597656488419,
0.5592067241668701,
-0.767697811126709,
0.38085636496543884,
-0.10166381299495697,
1.0321139097213745,
-0.5510993599891663,
1.288063883781433,
0.9359737038612366,
-0.36918818950653076,
-0.7753211855888367,
0.14376679062843323,
-0.4684934914112091,
-0.6530707478523254,
0.6826550960540771,
0.01280863955616951,
-0.25026634335517883,
0.5265185236930847,
-0.23735572397708893,
-0.8905388116836548,
0.9927010536193848,
0.44599607586860657,
-0.6126736402511597,
-0.20777955651283264,
-0.1792401671409607,
0.35535940527915955,
-0.07933243364095688,
0.24759669601917267,
0.40409430861473083,
0.12832041084766388,
0.19865311682224274,
-1.0389404296875,
-0.12365156412124634,
-0.2537030875682831,
0.15642116963863373,
0.4728526771068573,
-0.5598920583724976,
0.7861229181289673,
-0.08735696971416473,
-0.2205440104007721,
0.007757906801998615,
0.590602457523346,
-0.016458742320537567,
0.37589535117149353,
0.2110000103712082,
0.5821170806884766,
0.7725883722305298,
-0.04463827237486839,
0.977715790271759,
-0.653263509273529,
0.37268346548080444,
1.4022018909454346,
-0.22126337885856628,
0.9577374458312988,
0.33777672052383423,
-0.19136840105056763,
0.20421618223190308,
0.6720372438430786,
0.4499940276145935,
0.9093180298805237,
-0.13534915447235107,
-0.22087077796459198,
-0.29522380232810974,
-0.09277458488941193,
-0.5659082531929016,
0.4019887447357178,
0.620298445224762,
-0.1827555149793625,
-0.4360972046852112,
-0.02979678101837635,
-0.25316426157951355,
0.33312419056892395,
-0.6691182851791382,
0.9558300375938416,
0.14885908365249634,
-0.6509494185447693,
0.68358314037323,
0.22164486348628998,
0.756068229675293,
-0.653992772102356,
0.10021596401929855,
-0.3304860293865204,
0.1568130999803543,
-0.16708683967590332,
-0.5096971392631531,
0.16108857095241547,
-0.6143734455108643,
-0.4829380214214325,
-0.08143603801727295,
1.2098547220230103,
-0.5704638957977295,
-0.15967275202274323,
0.2802110016345978,
0.2833770215511322,
-0.11375157535076141,
-0.37224283814430237,
-0.707042932510376,
-0.24488326907157898,
-0.364522784948349,
-0.3214593529701233,
0.8805356621742249,
0.6527608036994934,
0.13197851181030273,
0.5048747062683105,
0.6694592237472534,
0.18556003272533417,
0.002655948279425502,
0.07353893667459488,
1.2717524766921997,
-0.4148772358894348,
-0.6059072017669678,
-0.5398389101028442,
-0.011499976739287376,
0.3419245779514313,
0.13629040122032166,
0.5119057893753052,
0.6720135807991028,
0.8834421634674072,
0.05782528221607208,
0.5086024403572083,
0.11637391895055771,
0.5743306279182434,
-0.6924723982810974,
0.7492398619651794,
-0.5939981341362,
0.1786823272705078,
0.04525172337889671,
-0.7762212753295898,
-0.11614036560058594,
0.42417314648628235,
-0.3633793890476227,
0.04975859075784683,
0.5119766592979431,
1.0473690032958984,
-0.3947606682777405,
-0.2353815883398056,
0.2612210512161255,
0.10415744036436081,
-0.1719008982181549,
0.29352867603302,
0.29567044973373413,
-0.6050701141357422,
0.6224887371063232,
-0.2570827901363373,
-0.10282361507415771,
-0.49748989939689636,
-0.7114202380180359,
-0.6650423407554626,
-0.8003939986228943,
-0.12950028479099274,
-0.30647850036621094,
0.43463820219039917,
0.6211726069450378,
0.7589443922042847,
-0.6173895597457886,
-0.002369499998167157,
-0.12049484997987747,
0.09443172812461853,
0.031228743493556976,
-0.1902657002210617,
0.43701693415641785,
-1.0290322303771973,
-0.5454328656196594,
0.33155393600463867,
0.2706892788410187,
-0.23224474489688873,
0.2520979344844818,
-0.11409130692481995,
-0.6134278774261475,
-0.1438584327697754,
0.45495709776878357,
0.30982527136802673,
-0.28662392497062683,
0.08297433704137802,
-0.1476280242204666,
-0.17183127999305725,
0.15807276964187622,
0.8942134380340576,
-1.0467162132263184,
0.5322911143302917,
0.4660639464855194,
0.31880393624305725,
0.7602266669273376,
0.3173610270023346,
0.643993079662323,
-1.1395056247711182,
0.32724785804748535,
0.4092933237552643,
0.12832389771938324,
0.03154832124710083,
-0.530788004398346,
0.3311862647533417,
0.04728735238313675,
-0.7364418506622314,
-0.6422259211540222,
0.05258917808532715,
-0.6403169631958008,
-0.16999810934066772,
1.0186326503753662,
-0.19910041987895966,
0.09820268303155899,
-0.3746764063835144,
-0.20198173820972443,
0.3738226890563965,
-0.47552937269210815,
0.7533612847328186,
0.31244173645973206,
-0.15816327929496765,
-0.15367890894412994,
-0.5936846733093262,
0.7139226198196411,
0.26242339611053467,
-0.4198805093765259,
-0.052795398980379105,
0.2617904245853424,
0.034153927117586136,
-0.27223309874534607,
0.9047342538833618,
-0.17045898735523224,
0.1988798826932907,
-0.3281303346157074,
-0.427570641040802,
-0.31771260499954224,
-0.19623799622058868,
-0.03161396458745003,
0.031310051679611206,
0.540128231048584,
-0.1356123387813568
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16913v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16913v1
|
New Intent Discovery with Attracting and Dispersing Prototype
| 2024-03-25T16:31:55 | 2024-03-25T16:31:55 |
Shun Zhang, Jian Yang, Jiaqi Bai, Chaoran Yan, Tongliang Li, Zhao Yan, Zhoujun Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
New Intent Discovery (NID) aims to recognize known and infer new intent
categories with the help of limited labeled and large-scale unlabeled data. The
task is addressed as a feature-clustering problem and recent studies augment
instance representation. However, existing methods fail to capture
cluster-friendly representations, since they show less capability to
effectively control and coordinate within-cluster and between-cluster
distances. Tailored to the NID problem, we propose a Robust and Adaptive
Prototypical learning (RAP) framework for globally distinct decision boundaries
for both known and new intent categories. Specifically, a robust prototypical
attracting learning (RPAL) method is designed to compel instances to gravitate
toward their corresponding prototype, achieving greater within-cluster
compactness. To attain larger between-cluster separation, another adaptive
prototypical dispersing learning (APDL) method is devised to maximize the
between-cluster distance from the prototype-to-prototype perspective.
Experimental results evaluated on three challenging benchmarks (CLINC, BANKING,
and StackOverflow) of our method with better cluster-friendly representation
demonstrate that RAP brings in substantial improvements over the current
state-of-the-art methods (even large language model) by a large margin (average
+5.5% improvement).
|
[
-0.2917479872703552,
-0.8490577340126038,
0.7623030543327332,
0.3079947233200073,
-0.29129713773727417,
0.36163330078125,
-0.21024423837661743,
-0.25128504633903503,
0.36804860830307007,
0.015171147882938385,
-0.2967695891857147,
-0.8805355429649353,
-0.7592946290969849,
-0.3040825426578522,
-0.483242928981781,
0.906004786491394,
0.09146919846534729,
-0.6400841474533081,
-0.2717822790145874,
-0.04142605885863304,
-0.28886905312538147,
-0.3099513649940491,
-0.5751060843467712,
0.06671111285686493,
0.32561829686164856,
0.7976934909820557,
0.2735079228878021,
0.31410229206085205,
0.471188485622406,
0.11352556198835373,
-0.31543540954589844,
0.23529665172100067,
-0.37606576085090637,
-0.131226047873497,
-0.07771635800600052,
-0.36056679487228394,
-0.5011895298957825,
0.13672737777233124,
0.8036420345306396,
0.8302919864654541,
-0.4383038878440857,
0.07129664719104767,
0.04925103485584259,
0.6690740585327148,
-0.7503542900085449,
0.22381046414375305,
-0.6588439345359802,
0.03517904877662659,
-0.34380048513412476,
-0.11253047734498978,
-0.7860007882118225,
-0.18358244001865387,
0.5817469954490662,
-0.624381959438324,
0.3392057418823242,
0.021543264389038086,
0.5547110438346863,
-0.24936898052692413,
-0.17847281694412231,
-0.48391902446746826,
-0.8354831337928772,
0.731807291507721,
-0.31476789712905884,
0.2920345366001129,
0.16580651700496674,
0.4642840623855591,
-0.37239769101142883,
-0.8043701648712158,
-0.17909865081310272,
-0.17407365143299103,
0.03136922046542168,
-0.047960229218006134,
-0.37882235646247864,
-0.23636607825756073,
-0.03538846969604492,
0.24782153964042664,
-0.2774469554424286,
0.07437002658843994,
-0.26738473773002625,
-0.1791103333234787,
0.4977705180644989,
-0.31121310591697693,
0.18610374629497528,
0.1490514874458313,
-0.65894615650177,
-0.23465359210968018,
-0.4682319164276123,
0.6870479583740234,
0.1263153851032257,
0.5715925693511963,
-0.21953755617141724,
0.22352968156337738,
0.0027244267985224724,
0.5976791977882385,
0.5245505571365356,
-0.20984645187854767,
0.448805570602417,
0.06100102886557579,
0.11678549647331238,
0.3373623192310333,
0.5738882422447205,
0.34968167543411255,
-0.13129755854606628,
-0.29886728525161743,
0.0562627948820591,
-0.1664002686738968,
0.32164254784584045,
-0.38357263803482056,
-0.07298501580953598,
0.05198471620678902,
-0.6685338616371155,
-0.302677720785141,
0.30367767810821533,
-0.7188931107521057,
-0.17990407347679138,
0.19068311154842377,
0.4139980971813202,
-0.5795612931251526,
-0.48861947655677795,
0.20795968174934387,
-0.2674272656440735,
0.35587459802627563,
0.299776166677475,
-1.193444848060608,
0.45970526337623596,
0.6058351993560791,
1.2108962535858154,
-0.49108126759529114,
-0.2116023600101471,
-0.49329209327697754,
0.26116055250167847,
-0.2589322328567505,
1.1804941892623901,
-0.6251853704452515,
-0.4861234128475189,
-0.427601158618927,
-0.25197547674179077,
-0.13467778265476227,
-0.637053906917572,
0.49154308438301086,
-0.30064043402671814,
0.00915137305855751,
0.03704455867409706,
-0.4181417226791382,
-0.37682244181632996,
0.190914124250412,
-0.42641058564186096,
0.8765968084335327,
0.4925595223903656,
-0.5735992193222046,
0.8438020348548889,
-0.9213172793388367,
-0.40783289074897766,
0.03339333087205887,
-0.15726226568222046,
-0.555831789970398,
0.4174754321575165,
0.020251763984560966,
0.47726649045944214,
0.21103757619857788,
0.2214321494102478,
-0.2910159230232239,
-0.3291222155094147,
0.13750924170017242,
-0.16050271689891815,
0.4321404695510864,
-0.07808704674243927,
-0.4513837993144989,
0.46408188343048096,
-0.8353646993637085,
-0.33459722995758057,
-0.008115882985293865,
-0.047852739691734314,
-0.5148561596870422,
0.28513577580451965,
-0.26666346192359924,
0.015114432200789452,
0.16884297132492065,
-0.5568059682846069,
0.33216872811317444,
0.02102269046008587,
0.3020381033420563,
0.8090682029724121,
0.0736415833234787,
0.7253319025039673,
-0.2585640251636505,
0.43019288778305054,
0.3048018515110016,
0.47195935249328613,
0.2442355901002884,
-0.733485996723175,
-0.13999581336975098,
-0.24223899841308594,
0.21283285319805145,
0.14138907194137573,
-0.3134530186653137,
0.3598509728908539,
-0.05475645884871483,
-0.4323839843273163,
-0.1647782325744629,
0.012399191968142986,
-0.05660013109445572,
0.431866854429245,
0.4642094671726227,
-0.6105535626411438,
-0.43406742811203003,
-0.6168244481086731,
0.15704971551895142,
-0.3607000708580017,
0.07018126547336578,
0.5771117806434631,
-0.026502685621380806,
-0.25570717453956604,
1.20621919631958,
-0.528561532497406,
-0.743890643119812,
-0.5583100914955139,
0.18292780220508575,
0.31147298216819763,
0.17496876418590546,
0.8621005415916443,
-1.129422903060913,
-0.8182558417320251,
0.13092243671417236,
-0.2584224045276642,
0.06749405711889267,
-0.08918272703886032,
-0.09541438519954681,
-0.40132981538772583,
0.8383882641792297,
-0.05303727835416794,
0.5387870669364929,
0.4701632559299469,
-0.40425220131874084,
0.6569799780845642,
-0.07918893545866013,
-0.2957497835159302,
-0.9700950384140015,
-0.054449401795864105,
0.16347192227840424,
0.09797847270965576,
-0.6470398902893066,
-0.43963462114334106,
0.02438955567777157,
0.24661344289779663,
-0.6502097845077515,
0.48579710721969604,
-0.2623540461063385,
-0.18029244244098663,
-0.39902064204216003,
0.17558631300926208,
-0.20469772815704346,
0.2247888296842575,
0.27417048811912537,
0.6201803684234619,
0.9886207580566406,
-0.9082870483398438,
-0.021921740844845772,
0.4483780860900879,
-0.49976885318756104,
0.4928942918777466,
-0.31614238023757935,
-0.2234041392803192,
-0.3719353973865509,
0.2717988193035126,
-1.0645053386688232,
-0.20047102868556976,
0.1031838059425354,
-0.5786839723587036,
0.16050466895103455,
-0.400847852230072,
0.11079056560993195,
-0.22405843436717987,
-0.30908381938934326,
0.49210044741630554,
0.7038072347640991,
-0.7287571430206299,
0.8258156776428223,
0.25089389085769653,
-0.12405460327863693,
-0.49725663661956787,
-0.17155975103378296,
-0.10183105617761612,
-0.47921016812324524,
-0.2157917320728302,
0.7448474764823914,
0.20396089553833008,
-0.030330060049891472,
0.02508147992193699,
0.05337752401828766,
-0.0183237474411726,
0.23389440774917603,
0.1495257019996643,
0.11721368134021759,
-0.013473132625222206,
0.0643620416522026,
-0.035211231559515,
-0.26758620142936707,
0.05311797186732292,
-0.23602260649204254,
0.48317551612854004,
0.08995198458433151,
-0.29310357570648193,
-0.30284249782562256,
0.32761460542678833,
0.9127602577209473,
-0.24555225670337677,
0.7345725297927856,
1.0051223039627075,
-0.05326865240931511,
-0.5376982092857361,
-0.2382548749446869,
-0.19450609385967255,
-0.43932458758354187,
0.294958233833313,
-0.32653746008872986,
-0.9345013499259949,
0.4966014623641968,
-0.49430689215660095,
0.3918992578983307,
0.11904975026845932,
0.2544298470020294,
0.08480281382799149,
0.9770609140396118,
1.1165282726287842,
0.029986409470438957,
0.8386200070381165,
-0.33150336146354675,
0.4587131142616272,
-1.541730284690857,
-0.44725340604782104,
-0.09381818771362305,
-0.6842015981674194,
-0.3096351623535156,
-0.3849646747112274,
0.5491467714309692,
0.16732148826122284,
0.48844730854034424,
0.17060025036334991,
-0.5494285821914673,
0.1613367646932602,
0.6016502380371094,
0.048039209097623825,
0.1444811224937439,
0.04703792557120323,
-0.5329539775848389,
0.04759449511766434,
-0.6649750471115112,
-0.25493186712265015,
1.4461556673049927,
0.16168363392353058,
0.6212019324302673,
0.5158160328865051,
0.7796614766120911,
0.24346788227558136,
0.5357396602630615,
-0.8814669847488403,
0.43962714076042175,
-0.5895465016365051,
-0.271347314119339,
-0.18028277158737183,
-0.291549414396286,
-0.9516618251800537,
0.05696351081132889,
-0.25375840067863464,
-1.0280689001083374,
0.596901535987854,
0.1250113546848297,
-0.6222302317619324,
0.5756650567054749,
-0.6568312048912048,
0.6638848185539246,
-0.19412635266780853,
-0.2925158143043518,
0.1395501047372818,
-0.38075849413871765,
0.3586674928665161,
0.0494612380862236,
0.26493021845817566,
-0.4502318203449249,
0.08911848068237305,
0.669437825679779,
0.19289694726467133,
0.7420200705528259,
-0.5445065498352051,
-0.1097428947687149,
0.3820044696331024,
-0.18506808578968048,
0.46595528721809387,
0.03711428865790367,
-0.05258520320057869,
-0.4039185047149658,
-0.5693473219871521,
-0.2922859787940979,
-0.6384371519088745,
0.39346736669540405,
-0.4832996726036072,
-0.35264626145362854,
-0.1271747350692749,
-0.4368649125099182,
-0.1564699113368988,
0.24993352591991425,
0.4000605642795563,
0.479262113571167,
-0.468417227268219,
0.41563984751701355,
0.7901887893676758,
-0.059409238398075104,
0.49889251589775085,
0.6009048819541931,
-0.304716020822525,
-0.012446003966033459,
0.903228223323822,
-0.2660231292247772,
0.4750640392303467,
0.371441513299942,
0.4846456050872803,
-0.7269799113273621,
-1.0302791595458984,
-0.19942528009414673,
-0.09276765584945679,
-0.1903323531150818,
0.14660173654556274,
-0.7157780528068542,
-0.15065693855285645,
-0.5739176273345947,
-0.2942964732646942,
-0.4147789478302002,
-0.09159453213214874,
-0.3280835449695587,
0.05603250861167908,
0.35011449456214905,
0.5717684626579285,
-0.27313023805618286,
0.4624324440956116,
-0.40258166193962097,
0.4069159924983978,
0.5068553686141968,
0.7024520039558411,
0.12320233136415482,
-0.50450599193573,
-0.07052364945411682,
-0.21245044469833374,
-0.27359452843666077,
-0.4467945992946625,
0.13402611017227173,
0.48773863911628723,
0.8095243573188782,
0.8431570529937744,
0.2632865011692047,
0.3350401520729065,
-0.30416691303253174,
0.39504826068878174,
0.10961050540208817,
-0.43049362301826477,
0.8319488167762756,
-0.1677331179380417,
0.13035646080970764,
0.7204782366752625,
0.5889731645584106,
-0.5296968221664429,
-0.14659379422664642,
-0.8882794380187988,
-0.9175146818161011,
0.5467410683631897,
-0.12929706275463104,
-0.04760611429810524,
-0.3123273253440857,
0.6401910185813904,
0.21372950077056885,
-0.055553462356328964,
-0.7954671382904053,
-0.3247383236885071,
0.08785859495401382,
-0.1932249665260315,
-0.09262377768754959,
-0.23404327034950256,
0.2288532257080078,
-0.17417514324188232,
0.5806440114974976,
-0.2744976580142975,
0.33016854524612427,
0.25863319635391235,
0.11250481009483337,
0.2281452715396881,
0.3888041377067566,
0.43989232182502747,
0.4344552755355835,
-0.6522108316421509,
0.23347961902618408,
-0.31281423568725586,
-0.9626728296279907,
0.5008331537246704,
-0.05296558514237404,
-0.3531639575958252,
0.0349796861410141,
-0.0017204944742843509,
0.6762222051620483,
0.24993403255939484,
-0.6758869886398315,
0.6785188317298889,
-0.27538636326789856,
-0.5917693972587585,
-0.1471187025308609,
0.3982200622558594,
-0.22341081500053406,
0.020557826384902,
0.6352575421333313,
0.16931720077991486,
0.20929211378097534,
-0.7015976905822754,
0.44370588660240173,
0.6144430041313171,
-0.7536314129829407,
-0.4345472455024719,
0.3066154420375824,
0.1124473437666893,
-0.15589851140975952,
0.5149291753768921,
-0.8111082315444946,
-0.4372561275959015,
0.38479387760162354,
0.7941429018974304,
0.9330440163612366,
-0.2829379737377167,
0.6171407103538513,
0.36847400665283203,
-0.005913108121603727,
-0.22938185930252075,
0.024885036051273346,
-0.33058494329452515,
-0.9421420693397522,
-0.3058052659034729,
-0.5679472088813782,
-0.4633592367172241,
0.041628237813711166,
-0.8008458614349365,
0.21226142346858978,
-0.7527796626091003,
-0.26046040654182434,
0.057558897882699966,
-0.20970916748046875,
-0.07718048244714737,
-0.292936772108078,
-0.188942089676857,
0.6414533257484436,
-1.0439797639846802,
0.6078250408172607,
0.9882698655128479,
0.3104608356952667,
-0.7018345594406128,
-0.05807201564311981,
0.08554735034704208,
-0.6134949922561646,
0.19265438616275787,
0.23621486127376556,
0.02354152873158455,
0.2865872085094452,
-0.15687823295593262,
-1.0959690809249878,
1.140866994857788,
-0.1292857974767685,
-0.40448197722435,
0.036599718034267426,
-0.17326030135154724,
0.18997551500797272,
-0.7952781319618225,
-0.028475051745772362,
0.6790636777877808,
0.3553112745285034,
0.5222292542457581,
-0.5476417541503906,
-0.3010083734989166,
-0.1948428452014923,
-0.2977024018764496,
0.5086320042610168,
-0.5124579668045044,
0.8011119961738586,
-0.5845680832862854,
-0.4276583194732666,
-0.13971136510372162,
0.5827488899230957,
0.4512569010257721,
0.4127044081687927,
0.7288293838500977,
0.6226978898048401,
0.5407075881958008,
-0.09426548331975937,
0.5015696287155151,
0.06443618983030319,
0.13420365750789642,
1.092738389968872,
-0.300908625125885,
0.8900838494300842,
0.41932761669158936,
-0.3762011229991913,
1.1353546380996704,
0.47745853662490845,
0.08660340309143066,
0.8944522738456726,
0.008676164783537388,
-0.4609135687351227,
0.08431451767683029,
-0.19159245491027832,
-0.12060735374689102,
0.6566234230995178,
0.7619953751564026,
-0.19434066116809845,
-0.4060533344745636,
0.281937837600708,
-0.57502681016922,
0.18518687784671783,
-0.22843524813652039,
1.0052160024642944,
-0.31722351908683777,
-0.4451846778392792,
-0.02667517028748989,
-0.03211285173892975,
0.965040385723114,
-0.5501091480255127,
-0.09486441314220428,
-0.015719342976808548,
0.17616696655750275,
-0.2692781984806061,
-0.5698269009590149,
0.10177136212587357,
-0.36097252368927,
-0.36254701018333435,
0.006648639217019081,
0.5950016379356384,
-0.2992708086967468,
-0.5202312469482422,
0.2644231617450714,
0.23808930814266205,
-0.0296897254884243,
0.0856073722243309,
-0.5380309820175171,
0.03038949705660343,
0.06800508499145508,
0.4293578565120697,
0.36144357919692993,
0.4204716980457306,
-0.24357832968235016,
0.5879632830619812,
0.774752140045166,
0.20560291409492493,
0.07155539095401764,
0.19877251982688904,
0.52693772315979,
-0.5087345838546753,
-0.8208737969398499,
-0.6137772798538208,
0.16313661634922028,
-0.04479757696390152,
-0.21533280611038208,
0.7413568496704102,
0.4886612594127655,
0.6572396159172058,
0.23425918817520142,
0.5400802493095398,
-0.3876754343509674,
0.7126178741455078,
-0.25162050127983093,
0.16812582314014435,
-0.16830584406852722,
0.3593060374259949,
-0.37634706497192383,
-1.1590173244476318,
-0.2332455813884735,
0.7537222504615784,
-0.302482545375824,
0.09952666610479355,
0.41786593198776245,
0.39461326599121094,
-0.37970075011253357,
-0.23440398275852203,
0.04787319898605347,
0.090165875852108,
0.5856176018714905,
0.8657039403915405,
0.9615137577056885,
-0.16669109463691711,
0.22394877672195435,
-0.3184542655944824,
-0.8245037794113159,
-0.45712119340896606,
-0.9084067940711975,
-0.5552139282226562,
-0.57941734790802,
-0.39915382862091064,
0.3000631034374237,
-0.20522214472293854,
0.6481608748435974,
0.982006311416626,
-0.5912476778030396,
-0.16742785274982452,
-0.4809409976005554,
0.27780288457870483,
-0.7121747136116028,
-0.2986137866973877,
0.573577344417572,
-0.4777008891105652,
-0.3759530782699585,
0.40549182891845703,
0.5904302000999451,
0.5486891865730286,
-0.2079867124557495,
0.09017137438058853,
-0.4695815443992615,
-0.3254033923149109,
0.7897791266441345,
0.36027243733406067,
-0.35723376274108887,
-0.37274637818336487,
0.02307780273258686,
0.4100677967071533,
0.1750790774822235,
0.8966479897499084,
-0.9761353731155396,
0.3728601336479187,
-0.05442984774708748,
0.24464251101016998,
0.36108237504959106,
0.20388881862163544,
0.2952527403831482,
-0.9504356384277344,
0.31134799122810364,
0.21165339648723602,
-0.06681681424379349,
0.06437861919403076,
-0.398077130317688,
0.23017866909503937,
0.05599593371152878,
-0.2000790536403656,
-0.535846471786499,
0.18617163598537445,
-1.1807738542556763,
-0.30900368094444275,
0.8496224880218506,
-0.028156151995062828,
-0.37131842970848083,
-0.5309890508651733,
-0.09957472234964371,
-0.2987622618675232,
-0.5077962875366211,
1.0426770448684692,
0.3801953196525574,
-0.6210505366325378,
-0.16463226079940796,
-0.13799837231636047,
0.7071797847747803,
0.1953294277191162,
-0.6252318024635315,
0.19143414497375488,
0.16603167355060577,
0.27784183621406555,
0.3963172137737274,
0.6564496755599976,
-0.4753809869289398,
0.6812766790390015,
-0.23621875047683716,
-0.1804494559764862,
0.01306021586060524,
-0.7496265769004822,
0.11218461394309998,
0.3239893317222595,
0.429050475358963,
-0.20098547637462616
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16909v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16909v1
|
Towards Algorithmic Fidelity: Mental Health Representation across Demographics in Synthetic vs. Human-generated Data
| 2024-03-25T16:21:25 | 2024-03-25T16:21:25 |
Shinka Mori, Oana Ignat, Andrew Lee, Rada Mihalcea
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Synthetic data generation has the potential to impact applications and
domains with scarce data. However, before such data is used for sensitive tasks
such as mental health, we need an understanding of how different demographics
are represented in it. In our paper, we analyze the potential of producing
synthetic data using GPT-3 by exploring the various stressors it attributes to
different race and gender combinations, to provide insight for future
researchers looking into using LLMs for data generation. Using GPT-3, we
develop HEADROOM, a synthetic dataset of 3,120 posts about
depression-triggering stressors, by controlling for race, gender, and time
frame (before and after COVID-19). Using this dataset, we conduct semantic and
lexical analyses to (1) identify the predominant stressors for each demographic
group; and (2) compare our synthetic data to a human-generated dataset. We
present the procedures to generate queries to develop depression data using
GPT-3, and conduct analyzes to uncover the types of stressors it assigns to
demographic groups, which could be used to test the limitations of LLMs for
synthetic data generation for depression data. Our findings show that synthetic
data mimics some of the human-generated data distribution for the predominant
depression stressors across diverse demographics.
|
[
-0.5539323091506958,
-0.803325355052948,
0.9024209976196289,
0.2105693221092224,
0.049176186323165894,
0.2445824146270752,
0.01299660000950098,
-0.5954601168632507,
0.2682670056819916,
0.20407751202583313,
-0.9184974431991577,
-0.445406049489975,
-0.4251701831817627,
0.4895487129688263,
-0.19345346093177795,
1.1719862222671509,
-0.10185182094573975,
0.16710159182548523,
-0.36721307039260864,
0.24814598262310028,
-0.3505691885948181,
-1.017238974571228,
-0.7270033955574036,
-0.4793872833251953,
0.38816574215888977,
0.2792755663394928,
0.9898341298103333,
0.4367033839225769,
0.5519948601722717,
0.17971347272396088,
0.2761068046092987,
0.027570690959692,
-0.6939935684204102,
0.017832083627581596,
-0.065467968583107,
-0.24009938538074493,
-0.44382646679878235,
0.04696856066584587,
0.09447851032018661,
0.4828348457813263,
-0.12489873170852661,
0.3830392062664032,
-0.03275449201464653,
0.5543333888053894,
-0.3596838712692261,
0.05385991185903549,
-0.7429830431938171,
0.18832670152187347,
-0.3404417932033539,
-0.263739675283432,
0.07890517264604568,
-0.5240964293479919,
-0.12302972376346588,
-0.5457687377929688,
0.6932860016822815,
-0.13843674957752228,
0.46393051743507385,
0.5998935699462891,
-0.4221903383731842,
-0.12603537738323212,
-1.0420924425125122,
0.29478219151496887,
-0.3592465817928314,
0.03435102105140686,
0.5343969464302063,
0.40959927439689636,
-0.4351452887058258,
-0.4888135492801666,
-0.5522190928459167,
-0.01895950920879841,
-0.06628894805908203,
0.1502131074666977,
0.06795147806406021,
-0.1980203092098236,
0.42117398977279663,
0.6260465383529663,
-0.7948288917541504,
-0.3065277934074402,
-0.7739163637161255,
-0.27720439434051514,
1.0319713354110718,
0.5613248944282532,
0.5437844395637512,
-0.12177876383066177,
0.00996587984263897,
-0.033055324107408524,
-0.63480144739151,
-0.2620496153831482,
0.4156374931335449,
0.3211507797241211,
-0.11233334988355637,
0.9647690653800964,
0.08560693264007568,
0.2021150290966034,
0.11373896896839142,
-0.09196974337100983,
0.27297770977020264,
-0.4248473048210144,
-0.025283772498369217,
0.28585371375083923,
0.8008829355239868,
0.5595839023590088,
0.20707610249519348,
-0.07562270760536194,
-0.10285326093435287,
0.37405094504356384,
0.7374909520149231,
-0.6094027161598206,
-0.2394685447216034,
0.26906710863113403,
-0.31280019879341125,
-0.1350376456975937,
0.022213973104953766,
-0.7195948958396912,
-0.46443116664886475,
-0.5448026061058044,
0.06373780220746994,
-0.5425294041633606,
-0.1927696168422699,
0.08416936546564102,
-0.161261186003685,
0.013748922385275364,
0.10800162702798843,
-0.6970922350883484,
0.5500884056091309,
0.7225632071495056,
0.963606059551239,
-0.46835723519325256,
0.197451651096344,
0.08725646883249283,
0.20844729244709015,
-0.36111435294151306,
0.46364185214042664,
-0.4167323112487793,
-0.6804912090301514,
-0.3023565709590912,
-0.2879512906074524,
0.13231317698955536,
-0.817171573638916,
0.4919831454753876,
-0.1143675372004509,
0.2278233915567398,
-0.40605103969573975,
-0.19311000406742096,
0.16273339092731476,
0.019334878772497177,
-0.8550370335578918,
1.2558294534683228,
0.6609442234039307,
-0.9050260186195374,
0.5061621069908142,
-0.4903164505958557,
-0.17359216511249542,
0.10370013117790222,
-0.5813581943511963,
-0.5533483624458313,
0.1886606216430664,
0.2007325142621994,
0.213070347905159,
-0.15150316059589386,
0.30766820907592773,
-0.7112330198287964,
-0.5920109152793884,
0.394544392824173,
-0.06297903507947922,
0.568025529384613,
0.1878109723329544,
-0.18686389923095703,
-0.11662396043539047,
-0.669872522354126,
-0.22846050560474396,
0.11288823932409286,
0.16578993201255798,
-0.2674795091152191,
0.10727554559707642,
0.09387567639350891,
0.44779887795448303,
-0.0691409781575203,
-0.6038988828659058,
-0.001728826784528792,
0.06045563519001007,
0.3582324683666229,
0.6008153557777405,
0.4433555603027344,
-0.022350968793034554,
-0.7081425189971924,
0.8034586310386658,
-0.07145727425813675,
0.18938975036144257,
0.4380251467227936,
-0.6066085696220398,
0.09728971868753433,
-0.44476553797721863,
-0.12948179244995117,
0.8517683148384094,
-0.6669783592224121,
0.391082763671875,
-0.3231606185436249,
-0.5418290495872498,
-0.3696315586566925,
-0.15964068472385406,
-0.09819944202899933,
0.41235479712486267,
0.4291202425956726,
-0.1837371289730072,
-0.8259880542755127,
-1.0428268909454346,
-0.1588045209646225,
-0.16756704449653625,
-0.46550309658050537,
0.37948474287986755,
0.5383341908454895,
-0.5977762341499329,
0.969257116317749,
-0.6995530128479004,
-0.07100864499807358,
0.03843778744339943,
0.24452956020832062,
0.14188088476657867,
0.6612339615821838,
0.4445084035396576,
-0.4434445798397064,
-0.23784078657627106,
-0.2101207971572876,
-0.7898750305175781,
-0.08536708354949951,
-0.17801038920879364,
-0.4086926579475403,
-0.1016460433602333,
0.3134189248085022,
-0.7357035875320435,
0.4354563355445862,
0.43602198362350464,
-0.16478288173675537,
0.6024932265281677,
-0.051071491092443466,
0.06329366564750671,
-1.1394920349121094,
0.140333890914917,
0.12178832292556763,
-0.08533542603254318,
-0.4701991081237793,
-0.2096961885690689,
-0.24543897807598114,
-0.6096510887145996,
-0.0605994276702404,
0.2068646252155304,
-0.09136834740638733,
-0.009793196804821491,
0.06158025562763214,
-0.28734540939331055,
-0.21128886938095093,
0.012130032293498516,
-0.15694689750671387,
1.0826524496078491,
0.11692693084478378,
-0.16735081374645233,
0.343783974647522,
0.2329348772764206,
0.0719362124800682,
0.7427036166191101,
-0.7954557538032532,
0.3839242160320282,
-0.28161337971687317,
0.5679826736450195,
-0.8558005690574646,
-0.7510061264038086,
0.5029388666152954,
-0.43936359882354736,
-0.08643901348114014,
0.28156960010528564,
-0.5717108249664307,
-0.6452071666717529,
-0.48109593987464905,
0.8334159255027771,
0.5900474786758423,
0.12254782021045685,
0.2684187889099121,
0.6326153874397278,
-0.4543761909008026,
0.10688865184783936,
-0.8050596714019775,
0.14881595969200134,
-0.7279981970787048,
-0.6427359580993652,
0.8438884019851685,
-0.05023074895143509,
-0.47518157958984375,
0.07486297190189362,
-0.14271347224712372,
-0.16262702643871307,
-0.06046214699745178,
0.42379966378211975,
0.35282647609710693,
0.09574173390865326,
0.09142950177192688,
-0.25159451365470886,
0.07438161969184875,
0.3827318251132965,
0.003961203154176474,
0.3369741439819336,
0.187691330909729,
-0.2852661907672882,
-0.39734694361686707,
0.6224406361579895,
0.4339447319507599,
0.24227648973464966,
0.5833813548088074,
0.587878942489624,
-0.7129368782043457,
-0.009879722259938717,
-0.35645371675491333,
-0.2182776927947998,
-0.4058954119682312,
0.022080592811107635,
-0.3930983543395996,
-0.9229402542114258,
0.7475113272666931,
0.12894582748413086,
-0.1532602459192276,
0.42496633529663086,
0.726978063583374,
0.01887134276330471,
1.1742182970046997,
0.37523365020751953,
0.1073080450296402,
0.1478796899318695,
0.04802977666258812,
0.15221519768238068,
-0.6457884311676025,
-0.17922280728816986,
-0.3256075978279114,
-0.3917914032936096,
-0.894871175289154,
-0.6283197402954102,
0.8059331178665161,
-0.2832581400871277,
-0.49370574951171875,
-0.0988781526684761,
-0.6374844908714294,
0.10589959472417831,
0.42138782143592834,
0.45625925064086914,
0.12634994089603424,
0.08497605472803116,
0.23643098771572113,
-0.359524130821228,
-0.2138190120458603,
-0.5133472084999084,
1.2512333393096924,
0.24268193542957306,
0.7938929796218872,
-0.1462414711713791,
0.8822057843208313,
0.4806115925312042,
0.4146052300930023,
-0.38440370559692383,
0.16640426218509674,
-0.10876165330410004,
-0.8136002421379089,
-0.0955715999007225,
-0.5806786417961121,
-0.858961284160614,
-0.21708710491657257,
0.008473294787108898,
-0.6367000341415405,
0.38916850090026855,
0.1606111228466034,
-0.6637537479400635,
-0.06273394823074341,
-0.514955997467041,
0.5249786376953125,
-0.19502267241477966,
-0.20397381484508514,
-0.16309836506843567,
-0.43628793954849243,
0.8318793773651123,
-0.6637519001960754,
0.22176818549633026,
-0.47603240609169006,
-0.0007565319538116455,
0.5853484272956848,
-0.5470054745674133,
0.6602901220321655,
0.02504652924835682,
-0.11791516840457916,
0.2627055048942566,
0.17439186573028564,
0.16987809538841248,
0.45599815249443054,
-0.31265750527381897,
0.16910730302333832,
0.30699506402015686,
-0.4709584414958954,
-0.7455450892448425,
0.5098527073860168,
-1.0438079833984375,
-0.6591517329216003,
-0.6154714822769165,
-0.6815366744995117,
-0.4676721394062042,
-0.18305771052837372,
0.12456785142421722,
0.11559343338012695,
-0.28583580255508423,
-0.10942260175943375,
0.1555648297071457,
-0.3482741713523865,
-0.16948488354682922,
-0.10788007825613022,
-0.008388048969209194,
-0.8319934010505676,
0.7221032977104187,
0.19943930208683014,
0.06216207146644592,
-0.19349312782287598,
-0.00955179613083601,
-0.12372845411300659,
-0.12826590240001678,
-0.05483516305685043,
0.43967100977897644,
-0.2724878787994385,
-0.2331557720899582,
-0.3213713765144348,
-0.38734060525894165,
-0.317658007144928,
-0.20580951869487762,
-0.28635886311531067,
-0.3194374144077301,
-0.2993863523006439,
-0.27294397354125977,
0.4413841664791107,
0.7695799469947815,
-0.2632751762866974,
0.12847645580768585,
-0.5170943737030029,
0.780332624912262,
0.23454998433589935,
0.32368528842926025,
-0.3854863941669464,
0.12156012654304504,
0.009719892404973507,
0.3536454439163208,
-0.40999653935432434,
-1.0561203956604004,
0.38470661640167236,
0.1547231674194336,
0.4520319998264313,
0.1351199448108673,
0.3654440641403198,
0.8957579731941223,
-0.36660537123680115,
0.9223060607910156,
-0.12586349248886108,
-0.7693686485290527,
0.4290982186794281,
-0.5749385356903076,
0.09007816016674042,
0.9392196536064148,
0.617018461227417,
-0.6196128726005554,
-0.33923065662384033,
-0.8036892414093018,
-0.7659896016120911,
0.6788769364356995,
0.5472120642662048,
0.10302498936653137,
-0.19134478271007538,
0.8726670145988464,
0.31231197714805603,
-0.050117377191782,
-0.43777793645858765,
-0.08352112025022507,
-0.35759851336479187,
-0.42666277289390564,
-0.011289860121905804,
-0.181328684091568,
-0.4353425204753876,
-0.3887951970100403,
0.33972039818763733,
-0.06265825778245926,
0.6035248637199402,
0.41238266229629517,
0.3874503970146179,
-0.27909785509109497,
-0.09488041698932648,
0.47702860832214355,
0.6472446322441101,
-0.5954936146736145,
0.3110591769218445,
0.07636117190122604,
-0.5190904140472412,
0.4796312749385834,
0.16421160101890564,
-0.20249764621257782,
-0.06871689856052399,
0.3513065576553345,
0.6118279695510864,
-0.2986277937889099,
-0.5885413885116577,
-0.0166697409003973,
-0.296090304851532,
-0.2277449518442154,
-0.5614864826202393,
0.15127204358577728,
-0.05575180798768997,
0.14515025913715363,
0.26712098717689514,
-0.07286743819713593,
0.25581619143486023,
-0.7337484955787659,
0.50550776720047,
0.4618171155452728,
-0.10133219510316849,
-0.6162974834442139,
0.8728397488594055,
0.07624416053295135,
-0.21305401623249054,
0.9116305112838745,
-0.002499269088730216,
-0.23337233066558838,
0.5647321343421936,
0.5115290880203247,
0.9089801907539368,
-0.20654064416885376,
0.38326117396354675,
0.49515578150749207,
0.19549354910850525,
-0.03989502415060997,
0.6392579078674316,
0.22235162556171417,
-0.5979873538017273,
-0.39259207248687744,
-0.43065837025642395,
-0.4501720070838928,
0.34558331966400146,
-0.8922035694122314,
0.2397937774658203,
-0.3562203347682953,
-0.7633273005485535,
-0.34452375769615173,
-0.08795744925737381,
-0.8010075092315674,
0.23230516910552979,
0.5487225651741028,
0.6960157752037048,
-1.0158138275146484,
0.3673432469367981,
0.6420818567276001,
-0.0878196433186531,
-0.5130300521850586,
0.47405603528022766,
0.19752304255962372,
-0.6652291417121887,
0.3980940580368042,
0.22717413306236267,
0.21168723702430725,
-0.18133544921875,
-0.3636491298675537,
-1.0343106985092163,
1.065791368484497,
0.683220386505127,
-0.2178041636943817,
-0.1276639848947525,
0.6587629914283752,
0.8320773243904114,
-0.31291115283966064,
0.039916664361953735,
0.8144447803497314,
0.5043608546257019,
0.12446926534175873,
-0.7843973636627197,
0.32206135988235474,
-0.38103994727134705,
0.4094890058040619,
-0.20311854779720306,
-0.2749091684818268,
0.9236719608306885,
-0.09456003457307816,
-0.48697608709335327,
-0.2679622769355774,
0.3650834262371063,
0.7281655669212341,
0.377903550863266,
0.3568037152290344,
0.6443297266960144,
0.7576987743377686,
-0.04369138181209564,
1.3788928985595703,
-0.3292029798030853,
0.268873929977417,
1.0073639154434204,
-0.4716311991214752,
0.38847610354423523,
0.35461118817329407,
-0.598019540309906,
0.3264996409416199,
1.2716909646987915,
0.05719834193587303,
0.2667035460472107,
0.5174177885055542,
-0.3299309313297272,
-0.0588296614587307,
-0.10511769354343414,
-0.5377709269523621,
0.2836240231990814,
0.4198874235153198,
-0.2613220512866974,
-0.22556090354919434,
-0.11676458269357681,
0.11943728476762772,
-0.24468263983726501,
0.03234921768307686,
0.738330602645874,
0.23673605918884277,
-0.5031067728996277,
0.720001757144928,
-0.011669773608446121,
0.29280325770378113,
-0.31815609335899353,
-0.05312858894467354,
-0.35060158371925354,
-0.02517782710492611,
-0.24527494609355927,
-0.7447528839111328,
0.8491026163101196,
-0.09912749379873276,
-0.17213767766952515,
-0.12239498645067215,
0.48549380898475647,
-0.36422333121299744,
-0.9089343547821045,
0.07692292332649231,
0.6864578723907471,
0.0732472613453865,
-0.44284364581108093,
-0.4291767179965973,
0.23211555182933807,
-0.27639105916023254,
-0.14002195000648499,
0.2360973358154297,
0.4724234342575073,
-0.37492606043815613,
0.4435322880744934,
0.5225907564163208,
0.5244575142860413,
-0.0885869562625885,
-0.2838529050350189,
0.7027725577354431,
-0.7773369550704956,
-0.3183523118495941,
-1.0917177200317383,
0.2038186937570572,
-0.06666985899209976,
-0.18342022597789764,
0.5834084749221802,
0.5078439712524414,
0.717284619808197,
-0.10859113186597824,
1.044562816619873,
-0.02591218426823616,
0.26713281869888306,
-0.11872204393148422,
0.30296123027801514,
-0.2979356050491333,
-0.1682189702987671,
-0.2378349006175995,
-0.9269856214523315,
-0.4163745641708374,
0.36643433570861816,
-0.46993309259414673,
0.009336290881037712,
0.5524359941482544,
0.8412803411483765,
-0.023618577048182487,
-0.011832110583782196,
-0.21784408390522003,
-0.09730230271816254,
0.5572959184646606,
0.5432794094085693,
0.6886032223701477,
-0.0951930582523346,
0.0802740603685379,
-0.44519028067588806,
-0.07769694924354553,
0.044349219650030136,
-0.6533117890357971,
-0.5278488993644714,
-0.5756711959838867,
-0.31511035561561584,
-0.34026581048965454,
0.055289242416620255,
1.036745548248291,
0.5450725555419922,
-0.756545901298523,
-0.1973608285188675,
-0.01961212418973446,
-0.16432304680347443,
-0.2736777663230896,
-0.27730098366737366,
0.2705226242542267,
-0.05778328329324722,
-0.46828123927116394,
0.057759061455726624,
0.05464904382824898,
0.1985998898744583,
-0.37471237778663635,
0.018872911110520363,
0.37293410301208496,
0.17814016342163086,
0.4672098457813263,
-0.03954377770423889,
-0.5916121602058411,
-0.3813721239566803,
-0.31984373927116394,
-0.15216074883937836,
0.023364074528217316,
1.0872128009796143,
-0.8583043217658997,
0.11189883202314377,
0.4290784001350403,
0.6149436831474304,
0.21999891102313995,
0.5702437162399292,
0.9626306891441345,
-0.7654207348823547,
-0.14646309614181519,
0.2690895199775696,
0.17468351125717163,
0.5193185210227966,
-1.0006624460220337,
0.7922304272651672,
0.376566082239151,
-0.5379021167755127,
-0.8939909934997559,
-0.0662500262260437,
-0.7636549472808838,
-0.1095336377620697,
1.0567796230316162,
0.3062646985054016,
-0.03493831306695938,
-0.2514227330684662,
-0.371394544839859,
0.2725493311882019,
-0.4246331751346588,
1.4137181043624878,
0.6874516010284424,
-0.8178836107254028,
-0.03875511884689331,
-0.8139119148254395,
0.8060444593429565,
-0.08426439017057419,
-0.9912251234054565,
0.005098756868392229,
0.5995990633964539,
0.20920002460479736,
0.010065143927931786,
0.8470630049705505,
-0.28347668051719666,
0.23605357110500336,
-0.08001760393381119,
0.07199134677648544,
0.040295179933309555,
0.09718160331249237,
-0.07381688058376312,
0.23349320888519287,
-0.3314761519432068,
0.21529030799865723
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16899v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16899v1
|
State Space Models as Foundation Models: A Control Theoretic Overview
| 2024-03-25T16:10:47 | 2024-03-25T16:10:47 |
Carmen Amo Alonso, Jerome Sieber, Melanie N. Zeilinger
|
eess.SY
|
eess.SY, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SY
|
In recent years, there has been a growing interest in integrating linear
state-space models (SSM) in deep neural network architectures of foundation
models. This is exemplified by the recent success of Mamba, showing better
performance than the state-of-the-art Transformer architectures in language
tasks. Foundation models, like e.g. GPT-4, aim to encode sequential data into a
latent space in order to learn a compressed representation of the data. The
same goal has been pursued by control theorists using SSMs to efficiently model
dynamical systems. Therefore, SSMs can be naturally connected to deep sequence
modeling, offering the opportunity to create synergies between the
corresponding research areas. This paper is intended as a gentle introduction
to SSM-based architectures for control theorists and summarizes the latest
research developments. It provides a systematic review of the most successful
SSM proposals and highlights their main features from a control theoretic
perspective. Additionally, we present a comparative analysis of these models,
evaluating their performance on a standardized benchmark designed for assessing
a model's efficiency at learning long sequences.
|
[
-0.1478356122970581,
-0.643371045589447,
0.5152060985565186,
0.15582863986492157,
-0.07716739177703857,
0.19952979683876038,
-0.0025758298579603434,
-0.15472592413425446,
0.24133455753326416,
0.2596348226070404,
-0.35696637630462646,
-0.12873563170433044,
-0.6123877167701721,
-0.28298574686050415,
-0.7760234475135803,
0.403302937746048,
-0.571612536907196,
0.08237820118665695,
-0.07806237041950226,
0.15787284076213837,
-0.38155391812324524,
-0.537278950214386,
-0.14675623178482056,
-0.5270339250564575,
0.17085425555706024,
-0.26973310112953186,
0.8383659720420837,
0.3955100178718567,
0.4658558964729309,
0.33056843280792236,
-0.36334913969039917,
-0.09368930011987686,
-0.4078058898448944,
-0.0026878956705331802,
-0.23977160453796387,
-0.5110485553741455,
-0.24565120041370392,
0.07478843629360199,
1.0182148218154907,
1.1161521673202515,
-0.44394052028656006,
-0.3855329155921936,
0.00875126663595438,
0.6895870566368103,
-0.6227766275405884,
0.1640828549861908,
-0.20815561711788177,
0.46884793043136597,
0.222727969288826,
-0.001761734951287508,
-0.2256845086812973,
-0.7184463143348694,
0.09353971481323242,
-0.32469892501831055,
-0.12052444368600845,
-0.27152132987976074,
0.6792324185371399,
0.4158351421356201,
-0.5527587532997131,
-0.2055235654115677,
-1.182107925415039,
0.6473142504692078,
-0.7197220921516418,
0.5157579779624939,
-0.03201316297054291,
0.34608736634254456,
-0.6433181166648865,
-0.6621655821800232,
-0.4834030270576477,
-0.25521528720855713,
-0.07501837611198425,
0.1536821573972702,
-0.09425708651542664,
0.11345737427473068,
0.06371073424816132,
0.5173021554946899,
-0.37741726636886597,
0.22455736994743347,
-0.5333461761474609,
-0.1365894228219986,
0.34759262204170227,
0.4502112865447998,
-0.011034168303012848,
-0.08444608002901077,
-0.6477800011634827,
0.15427473187446594,
-0.788649320602417,
0.2516324818134308,
-0.014845391735434532,
0.19595980644226074,
-0.20566695928573608,
0.6372717618942261,
-0.19417347013950348,
0.7545639276504517,
0.1267663687467575,
0.09056513011455536,
-0.2538573443889618,
-0.2794468402862549,
-0.4675655961036682,
-0.3373442590236664,
0.5436551570892334,
-0.12488751113414764,
0.08614541590213776,
-0.37407737970352173,
-0.17913734912872314,
0.5688498616218567,
0.5945540070533752,
-0.7489823698997498,
-0.22374072670936584,
0.04101066291332245,
-0.5386283993721008,
-0.3049401342868805,
0.14056535065174103,
-0.4634249210357666,
-0.4845341444015503,
-0.7767999172210693,
0.3308165967464447,
-0.37133491039276123,
-0.5419918298721313,
0.27769145369529724,
0.2417791187763214,
0.582362711429596,
0.2344781756401062,
-0.5973405838012695,
0.8589372634887695,
0.6901922225952148,
0.8987109661102295,
-0.692732572555542,
-0.09174257516860962,
0.11237803101539612,
-0.06372402608394623,
-0.8872323036193848,
0.1336774230003357,
-0.4792361855506897,
-0.5402921438217163,
0.021044079214334488,
-0.11443634331226349,
-0.09049474447965622,
-0.21206195652484894,
-0.10619284957647324,
-0.8576912879943848,
-0.00196050014346838,
-0.07777434587478638,
-0.8266932368278503,
-0.19909046590328217,
0.0007194965146481991,
-0.6804428696632385,
0.7698408961296082,
0.14492039382457733,
-0.10819358378648758,
0.2503563463687897,
-0.5968852639198303,
-0.7602754831314087,
-0.19967475533485413,
-0.3890094757080078,
-0.11090204864740372,
0.32284098863601685,
-0.44158101081848145,
0.7989171743392944,
-0.12445534020662308,
0.621471643447876,
-0.24950219690799713,
-0.49524614214897156,
0.2654861807823181,
-0.17313191294670105,
0.30209648609161377,
0.46597862243652344,
-0.44292932748794556,
0.11259244382381439,
-0.6884942650794983,
0.08076009154319763,
-0.014198406599462032,
-0.5013697743415833,
-0.18663805723190308,
0.41863304376602173,
-0.34330323338508606,
0.5047838687896729,
-0.0035809327382594347,
-0.025908559560775757,
0.17967520654201508,
-0.3290829658508301,
0.7046152353286743,
0.5550598502159119,
-0.09974062442779541,
0.9568511843681335,
0.049750473350286484,
0.6598013639450073,
0.07796190679073334,
-0.10324583947658539,
-0.21418748795986176,
0.09303601086139679,
-0.5611628890037537,
0.04724658653140068,
0.26309219002723694,
0.40031006932258606,
-0.47655507922172546,
0.5730355978012085,
-0.07985449582338333,
-0.42164313793182373,
0.010266722179949284,
-0.15786831080913544,
0.19464454054832458,
0.24110285937786102,
0.34202438592910767,
-0.2824300229549408,
-0.15458771586418152,
-0.7250896692276001,
0.15909142792224884,
0.3492310345172882,
0.5088369250297546,
0.21637468039989471,
0.6404314041137695,
0.16031157970428467,
0.8561328053474426,
-0.2705283761024475,
0.1772831678390503,
-0.012765634804964066,
-0.3027157783508301,
0.40051913261413574,
0.9019272327423096,
0.5192742943763733,
-1.046566128730774,
0.11395823210477829,
-0.29619890451431274,
-0.8255496621131897,
0.516573429107666,
0.1802617460489273,
-0.015085838735103607,
-0.12489301711320877,
0.5211101174354553,
-0.8988069891929626,
0.7251343727111816,
0.45785877108573914,
-0.3340780436992645,
0.3916478753089905,
0.06755241751670837,
0.05893672630190849,
-1.0852084159851074,
0.14284351468086243,
-0.10679660737514496,
0.04411275312304497,
-0.7404922246932983,
0.4911770224571228,
0.2104887068271637,
-0.2911103367805481,
-0.4633609354496002,
0.22456270456314087,
-0.4462289810180664,
-0.6394409537315369,
-0.4422508478164673,
-0.22206628322601318,
-0.2119210809469223,
0.7019569873809814,
0.11733271181583405,
0.5004578232765198,
0.5377137064933777,
-0.9777838587760925,
0.2364402711391449,
-0.0295509472489357,
-0.5394720435142517,
0.23371760547161102,
-0.5612514019012451,
-0.11586521565914154,
-0.009435522370040417,
0.5840865969657898,
-0.9961864948272705,
-0.08008638769388199,
0.10790655016899109,
-0.11782435327768326,
0.5893803238868713,
-0.22031012177467346,
-0.15671147406101227,
-0.40771937370300293,
0.2565208375453949,
0.15987573564052582,
0.5752241015434265,
-0.18766628205776215,
0.8350986242294312,
0.31198665499687195,
0.08643853664398193,
-0.6307176351547241,
-0.8767346739768982,
-0.20705603063106537,
-0.12513208389282227,
-0.16978631913661957,
0.37183693051338196,
0.02945603057742119,
-0.10690227895975113,
0.16065891087055206,
-0.4906257092952728,
-0.09840714186429977,
0.5855007767677307,
0.6362870335578918,
0.13479280471801758,
-0.4729310870170593,
0.07255897670984268,
0.18098220229148865,
-0.02118578925728798,
0.0301883015781641,
-0.7361076474189758,
0.6189066767692566,
-0.5633434653282166,
-0.38743191957473755,
-0.5641741752624512,
0.11545798927545547,
0.5156898498535156,
-0.2246527522802353,
0.6758811473846436,
-0.11850586533546448,
-0.6575612425804138,
-0.18195727467536926,
-0.1307491511106491,
-0.23780670762062073,
-0.45135998725891113,
0.18856339156627655,
-0.5964221358299255,
-1.1446824073791504,
0.5452588796615601,
-0.5022099614143372,
-0.0334501676261425,
0.30543163418769836,
0.6001827120780945,
-0.36124369502067566,
0.5473185777664185,
0.8921604752540588,
-0.4070573151111603,
0.474514365196228,
-0.7173745632171631,
-0.06500927358865738,
-0.5617811679840088,
-0.2657283544540405,
-0.48569491505622864,
-0.8009869456291199,
-0.31490617990493774,
-0.5314549207687378,
-0.1729225069284439,
0.6116815805435181,
-0.5707646012306213,
0.48721832036972046,
-0.20662672817707062,
0.40954333543777466,
0.011207261122763157,
-0.10493044555187225,
-0.10757818818092346,
-0.18696095049381256,
-0.5374023914337158,
0.14142905175685883,
-0.9482165575027466,
-0.48054492473602295,
0.673475980758667,
0.3664597272872925,
1.075493574142456,
0.23664797842502594,
0.39008283615112305,
0.2268984317779541,
0.00752249313518405,
-0.6314020156860352,
0.38631701469421387,
-0.20128124952316284,
-0.5405224561691284,
-0.35586217045783997,
-0.26985636353492737,
-0.752976655960083,
0.3878802955150604,
-0.01989000104367733,
-0.6705235838890076,
0.5488293766975403,
0.29493486881256104,
-0.7178528904914856,
0.42708292603492737,
-0.3870164155960083,
0.5992618799209595,
-0.36075925827026367,
-0.30974000692367554,
-0.39352646470069885,
-0.673607587814331,
0.358457088470459,
0.08027388155460358,
-0.14161215722560883,
-0.1359412670135498,
-0.018540220335125923,
0.36938542127609253,
-0.32890966534614563,
0.9719419479370117,
-0.4157223105430603,
-0.0919305682182312,
0.20460397005081177,
0.5058256983757019,
0.3238431215286255,
-0.15756642818450928,
-0.10177228599786758,
0.039806120097637177,
-0.1502787470817566,
-0.43318915367126465,
-0.5275557637214661,
0.8549991250038147,
-0.8522934913635254,
-0.2383052110671997,
-0.21243704855442047,
-0.21432222425937653,
-0.29027625918388367,
0.26161423325538635,
-0.10852034389972687,
0.5269719362258911,
-0.237416073679924,
0.5714517831802368,
0.7854174971580505,
-0.010377170518040657,
0.575870931148529,
0.5527116656303406,
-0.2968672215938568,
-0.03658803179860115,
0.2309514433145523,
0.11340811848640442,
0.1994566172361374,
0.6202375292778015,
-0.010017487220466137,
-0.2838916778564453,
-0.6083076596260071,
-0.24458901584148407,
-0.19139984250068665,
-0.7483510375022888,
-0.1329730898141861,
-0.22866655886173248,
-0.42925649881362915,
-0.19902127981185913,
-0.3034680485725403,
-0.5278903245925903,
-0.5430343747138977,
-0.23939065635204315,
-0.43566128611564636,
0.11944829672574997,
1.067183256149292,
0.14959774911403656,
0.5937094688415527,
-0.14305855333805084,
0.287009060382843,
0.014979471452534199,
0.6341387629508972,
0.20257896184921265,
-0.3009625971317291,
-0.239793062210083,
-0.13866466283798218,
-0.1410115361213684,
-0.8936024308204651,
0.058412473648786545,
-0.004901521373540163,
0.7027560472488403,
0.18031339347362518,
-0.3595263957977295,
0.6326619982719421,
-0.6018409729003906,
0.9003763794898987,
0.24853424727916718,
-0.8881058096885681,
0.5753490924835205,
0.03143080323934555,
0.12177322059869766,
0.11962626874446869,
0.6631522178649902,
-0.23398707807064056,
0.00003880225631291978,
-0.48052629828453064,
-0.5497276186943054,
0.4654926061630249,
-0.05050923675298691,
0.15345242619514465,
0.37433749437332153,
0.76109379529953,
0.02678079344332218,
0.5388032793998718,
-0.4425657093524933,
-0.08083484321832657,
-0.5231060981750488,
-0.0734725072979927,
-0.19087550044059753,
-0.017043890431523323,
-0.10187165439128876,
0.1336914449930191,
0.37269121408462524,
-0.21755735576152802,
0.36821120977401733,
0.09553810954093933,
-0.325273722410202,
-0.30639222264289856,
0.20103609561920166,
0.7534670233726501,
0.9233012795448303,
0.223798930644989,
0.08734846115112305,
-0.01065100822597742,
-0.09782169759273529,
0.6367170214653015,
0.19931793212890625,
-0.3626261055469513,
-0.38850709795951843,
0.07470104843378067,
1.1589245796203613,
0.7904309034347534,
0.21162128448486328,
0.41427043080329895,
0.41920530796051025,
-0.1798609495162964,
-0.4017047882080078,
0.4267894923686981,
0.12033229321241379,
0.5034635663032532,
0.30072593688964844,
0.3750710189342499,
-0.018430572003126144,
-0.22629159688949585,
0.1913926899433136,
0.347853422164917,
-0.4735676348209381,
-0.4663931131362915,
0.8063964247703552,
0.1439320296049118,
-0.08214601874351501,
0.5020824670791626,
0.46452975273132324,
-0.4494025707244873,
0.9494485855102539,
0.4521614909172058,
0.5680754780769348,
-0.13463932275772095,
-0.04443160071969032,
0.10626011341810226,
0.3255884647369385,
-0.20231890678405762,
0.5109379291534424,
-0.23271630704402924,
-1.1428253650665283,
-0.7606983184814453,
-0.7916666269302368,
-0.27671894431114197,
0.3638843595981598,
-0.6800627112388611,
-0.1811029314994812,
-1.0000683069229126,
-0.33414793014526367,
-0.06623769551515579,
0.19737479090690613,
-0.7073119282722473,
0.3354804515838623,
0.3874804377555847,
1.481964111328125,
-0.911641538143158,
1.017021656036377,
0.6068925261497498,
-0.27002856135368347,
-1.1025406122207642,
-0.36348482966423035,
0.010176464915275574,
-0.44317904114723206,
0.5700774788856506,
-0.1006581038236618,
-0.33530718088150024,
0.03783304989337921,
-0.6081870794296265,
-1.1176210641860962,
1.3713873624801636,
0.03935636207461357,
-0.6940504312515259,
-0.17728039622306824,
-0.19238150119781494,
0.5272228121757507,
-0.4055819511413574,
-0.28493863344192505,
0.638573408126831,
0.2809348702430725,
-0.14375561475753784,
-0.515284538269043,
-0.11080744862556458,
-0.17153099179267883,
0.40970778465270996,
0.5730663537979126,
-0.7299103736877441,
0.7603325247764587,
-0.056331567466259,
-0.1218561977148056,
0.5481331944465637,
1.0960229635238647,
0.3897741138935089,
-0.11645695567131042,
0.37586915493011475,
0.5051795840263367,
0.6856328248977661,
-0.38785502314567566,
1.1430412530899048,
-0.5156233906745911,
0.2603578269481659,
0.9409752488136292,
-0.7082179188728333,
0.7619577646255493,
0.3727935254573822,
-0.4304094612598419,
0.6267907619476318,
0.5531100630760193,
-0.07191476970911026,
0.6236761808395386,
0.49137893319129944,
0.363358736038208,
0.012694393284618855,
0.5942491888999939,
-0.4269151985645294,
0.10822243988513947,
0.6341584920883179,
-0.3025214374065399,
0.09803786873817444,
0.005476250778883696,
-0.1425820142030716,
0.11398200690746307,
-0.48530787229537964,
0.5460066199302673,
0.4116608500480652,
-0.5108374953269958,
0.15801113843917847,
0.11931553483009338,
0.40430572628974915,
-0.9032921195030212,
0.08496925979852676,
-0.3995346426963806,
0.23088623583316803,
-0.08483120799064636,
-0.6561468243598938,
0.12686142325401306,
-0.1969834566116333,
-0.40994852781295776,
-0.3000667095184326,
0.9683611392974854,
-0.3718581795692444,
0.011699266731739044,
0.3482695519924164,
0.43490442633628845,
0.1659427136182785,
0.40962618589401245,
-0.7868610620498657,
-0.007059615105390549,
-0.5610821843147278,
-0.4108297526836395,
-0.03762964531779289,
0.01329508051276207,
-0.36751654744148254,
0.6263054013252258,
0.5896575450897217,
0.24237781763076782,
0.4300591051578522,
-0.13681639730930328,
0.7296053767204285,
-0.9907270669937134,
-0.9139842391014099,
-0.6223989129066467,
0.34044453501701355,
0.2535056471824646,
-0.12959712743759155,
0.26218181848526,
0.3863455057144165,
0.7450706362724304,
-0.09088432788848877,
0.7341798543930054,
-0.28135985136032104,
0.3375304639339447,
-0.8312472701072693,
0.7854108810424805,
-0.33592337369918823,
-0.1490548551082611,
-0.09253023564815521,
-0.7302186489105225,
-0.07224710285663605,
0.542300820350647,
-0.2481754720211029,
0.2710567116737366,
0.38841161131858826,
0.5311059951782227,
-0.09015268087387085,
0.15380774438381195,
0.32412439584732056,
0.3360891044139862,
0.19708557426929474,
0.7115412354469299,
1.4026962518692017,
-0.2665805518627167,
-0.0159984789788723,
-0.2154504805803299,
0.048547979444265366,
-0.2727331221103668,
-0.9616042971611023,
-0.4545532763004303,
-0.45542487502098083,
0.0508376844227314,
-0.21965104341506958,
-0.06911057978868484,
0.7296695709228516,
1.1033077239990234,
-1.1778342723846436,
-0.408901572227478,
-0.33363786339759827,
0.07099201530218124,
-0.2530130445957184,
-0.1373559832572937,
0.3850356638431549,
-0.09910506010055542,
-0.35031020641326904,
0.9465699195861816,
0.319816917181015,
0.30146315693855286,
-0.6495106220245361,
-0.4825752079486847,
-0.11658066511154175,
0.000668069813400507,
0.4919324219226837,
0.44717514514923096,
-0.9510048031806946,
0.07230070978403091,
0.06881914287805557,
-0.32147401571273804,
-0.09620598703622818,
1.2673819065093994,
-0.9371227025985718,
0.11483878642320633,
0.3336833417415619,
0.9358704090118408,
0.49691617488861084,
-0.10338329523801804,
0.6408177018165588,
-0.725439727306366,
0.2308458685874939,
0.26491284370422363,
0.6460703611373901,
0.21024693548679352,
-0.2638980448246002,
0.6210107803344727,
0.26359355449676514,
-0.2501273453235626,
-0.5372069478034973,
0.344126433134079,
-0.8071709871292114,
-0.5534020066261292,
0.7154618501663208,
-0.20264515280723572,
-0.07980381697416306,
0.5182474255561829,
0.25632280111312866,
0.3324440121650696,
-0.13270851969718933,
0.4287233054637909,
0.7763324975967407,
-0.13262352347373962,
-0.1745494157075882,
-0.35827386379241943,
0.5729304552078247,
0.32211053371429443,
-0.6880003809928894,
-0.33976152539253235,
0.5034522414207458,
0.25207793712615967,
0.2979097366333008,
0.4212307333946228,
-0.22286595404148102,
0.36644887924194336,
-0.4377117156982422,
0.026927676051855087,
-0.042936477810144424,
-0.8133925795555115,
-0.9646672010421753,
0.35080260038375854,
-0.3764154016971588,
-0.05444672331213951
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16865v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16865v2
|
Encoding of lexical tone in self-supervised models of spoken language
| 2024-03-25T15:28:38 | 2024-04-03T12:59:20 |
Gaofei Shen, Michaela Watkins, Afra Alishahi, Arianna Bisazza, Grzegorz Chrupała
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, eess.AS
|
Interpretability research has shown that self-supervised Spoken Language
Models (SLMs) encode a wide variety of features in human speech from the
acoustic, phonetic, phonological, syntactic and semantic levels, to speaker
characteristics. The bulk of prior research on representations of phonology has
focused on segmental features such as phonemes; the encoding of suprasegmental
phonology (such as tone and stress patterns) in SLMs is not yet well
understood. Tone is a suprasegmental feature that is present in more than half
of the world's languages. This paper aims to analyze the tone encoding
capabilities of SLMs, using Mandarin and Vietnamese as case studies. We show
that SLMs encode lexical tone to a significant degree even when they are
trained on data from non-tonal languages. We further find that SLMs behave
similarly to native and non-native human participants in tone and consonant
perception studies, but they do not follow the same developmental trajectory.
|
[
-0.17758427560329437,
-0.22189871966838837,
0.45347005128860474,
0.2871842384338379,
-0.3326163589954376,
-0.24764321744441986,
-0.19112615287303925,
-0.3709636926651001,
0.36094024777412415,
0.9355352520942688,
-0.3116251826286316,
-0.598110020160675,
-0.10112783312797546,
0.31696799397468567,
-0.5182857513427734,
0.9016043543815613,
0.2629927098751068,
0.2897462844848633,
0.016628118231892586,
-0.4043651521205902,
-0.19857525825500488,
-1.1313315629959106,
-0.08310531824827194,
-0.3449956476688385,
-0.12864109873771667,
0.12722724676132202,
0.6358256936073303,
0.5712394714355469,
0.3240237236022949,
0.15669922530651093,
-0.3498450815677643,
-0.07422016561031342,
-0.36095812916755676,
0.09157970547676086,
-0.04300420358777046,
-0.41191425919532776,
-0.21892580389976501,
0.06556647270917892,
0.6668339371681213,
0.6713484525680542,
-0.2692714035511017,
0.058523159474134445,
0.19742894172668457,
0.7160537242889404,
-0.24951261281967163,
0.27310189604759216,
-0.5073953866958618,
-0.003668541321530938,
-0.05006337910890579,
-0.2831784188747406,
-0.5093255043029785,
-0.19121943414211273,
0.16400493681430817,
-0.3527936339378357,
0.2806023955345154,
-0.2865794599056244,
0.7623952031135559,
0.2917855679988861,
-0.42688220739364624,
-0.5494097471237183,
-0.7038636803627014,
0.5991433262825012,
-0.7824907898902893,
0.4129270613193512,
0.4518061876296997,
-0.024176307022571564,
-0.0728929340839386,
-0.29991838335990906,
-0.03884560614824295,
-0.5004688501358032,
-0.3967997431755066,
0.3110233545303345,
0.011882028542459011,
0.50990229845047,
0.1415635198354721,
0.5592350959777832,
-0.7486993670463562,
0.16078458726406097,
-0.5021575093269348,
-0.29291656613349915,
0.8512293696403503,
0.07595980912446976,
0.21526193618774414,
-0.6775076389312744,
-0.46943190693855286,
0.07133444398641586,
-0.41312745213508606,
0.02646559104323387,
0.11584261804819107,
0.6724956631660461,
-0.39931562542915344,
0.43969282507896423,
-0.11622826755046844,
0.7121561765670776,
-0.2320566475391388,
-0.507933497428894,
0.29263973236083984,
-0.38436582684516907,
-0.06164904311299324,
0.4257892072200775,
0.5987075567245483,
0.1464146375656128,
0.6723154783248901,
0.0522170215845108,
-0.4505198001861572,
0.1239185705780983,
0.06239737197756767,
-0.4554808735847473,
-0.14258356392383575,
0.06511206924915314,
-0.6176295876502991,
0.1264333426952362,
0.15052065253257751,
-0.5388513803482056,
-0.39431026577949524,
-0.3775486946105957,
0.34188735485076904,
-0.5287293195724487,
-0.5141618847846985,
0.19090260565280914,
0.002949385205283761,
0.4271737337112427,
-0.11244232952594757,
-0.9459858536720276,
0.43008729815483093,
0.6214976906776428,
0.9615554213523865,
-0.21416226029396057,
-0.27990272641181946,
-0.10274669528007507,
-0.2519785463809967,
-0.42555180191993713,
0.42196595668792725,
-0.47084951400756836,
-0.8238719701766968,
0.17936573922634125,
0.0809815376996994,
-0.194442018866539,
-0.8466784954071045,
0.39769747853279114,
-0.2822389006614685,
-0.26452088356018066,
-0.21076948940753937,
-0.6848506927490234,
-0.07733671367168427,
-0.19699738919734955,
-0.471914142370224,
0.9301250576972961,
0.41927072405815125,
-0.5581340789794922,
0.31816428899765015,
-0.2286675125360489,
-0.4915277659893036,
-0.013050850480794907,
-0.30286431312561035,
-0.26008734107017517,
0.582285463809967,
0.2255559265613556,
0.2159433513879776,
0.031048759818077087,
0.25004342198371887,
-0.034384921193122864,
-0.5141914486885071,
0.37322407960891724,
-0.18092931807041168,
0.6893185377120972,
0.47370943427085876,
-0.1530054360628128,
0.07721743732690811,
-0.859769880771637,
-0.008494431152939796,
0.23228958249092102,
-0.25208398699760437,
-0.3807474970817566,
-0.3852379620075226,
-0.04490859806537628,
0.29252931475639343,
0.33444663882255554,
-0.27492547035217285,
0.03073151223361492,
-0.33803677558898926,
0.6472711563110352,
0.3963625431060791,
0.2752991318702698,
0.4094775915145874,
-0.14870162308216095,
0.5492079854011536,
0.44553229212760925,
-0.08803046494722366,
-0.6222758889198303,
-0.28271397948265076,
-0.8837718367576599,
-0.014390907250344753,
0.03751418739557266,
0.42913761734962463,
-0.32097017765045166,
0.060131024569272995,
0.19966429471969604,
-0.3472035825252533,
-0.7424741983413696,
0.18415118753910065,
0.5366740226745605,
0.44197577238082886,
0.41679421067237854,
-0.5368012189865112,
-0.5540310144424438,
-0.8788855075836182,
-0.3824310898780823,
-0.49601808190345764,
-0.0926208347082138,
0.39330413937568665,
0.1317799985408783,
-0.07751952111721039,
1.0239698886871338,
-0.14792364835739136,
-0.39622434973716736,
-0.3179091215133667,
0.3278858959674835,
0.18225552141666412,
0.3459838628768921,
0.48739156126976013,
-0.6588780283927917,
-0.10482080280780792,
-0.19960808753967285,
-0.6144294142723083,
-0.5760257244110107,
-0.2641266882419586,
0.4939649701118469,
0.4435872733592987,
0.706123411655426,
-0.2084978073835373,
0.28943681716918945,
0.7065476775169373,
-0.2962810695171356,
0.7867109179496765,
-0.5329606533050537,
-0.12324193865060806,
-0.5918776392936707,
-0.3439759910106659,
0.2742263972759247,
-0.09391292929649353,
-0.9397366642951965,
-0.2637674808502197,
0.16326642036437988,
-0.3509467542171478,
-0.33366653323173523,
0.2936316728591919,
-0.649144172668457,
-0.6855412721633911,
-0.481107234954834,
0.20536643266677856,
0.02886648289859295,
0.5262287855148315,
0.40492916107177734,
0.7795398831367493,
0.5452303290367126,
-0.6473333239555359,
0.03197966516017914,
-0.1445649415254593,
-0.3155483305454254,
0.591357946395874,
-0.656419575214386,
0.2135162502527237,
-0.23372149467468262,
-0.01901867240667343,
-0.7144049406051636,
0.05775780603289604,
-0.22147570550441742,
-0.2550777792930603,
0.056659650057554245,
-0.3452802300453186,
-0.37910738587379456,
-0.15920978784561157,
0.26005861163139343,
0.40203800797462463,
0.7641516923904419,
-0.449459046125412,
0.2328253984451294,
0.5984721183776855,
0.22480285167694092,
0.06617157906293869,
-0.7248725295066833,
-0.165900319814682,
-0.5416869521141052,
-0.15139776468276978,
0.07184343039989471,
0.3605726361274719,
-0.40991780161857605,
-0.1632731556892395,
-0.19590967893600464,
-0.15149284899234772,
-0.029944591224193573,
0.4263330399990082,
0.01057728473097086,
-0.5049246549606323,
0.3221316337585449,
-0.5187993049621582,
-0.12652766704559326,
0.18339034914970398,
-0.6666762828826904,
0.5596280694007874,
-0.29943984746932983,
-0.3557925522327423,
-0.674759566783905,
0.09481588751077652,
0.5190198421478271,
-0.4573339819908142,
0.5517578125,
0.5331737399101257,
-0.14631128311157227,
-0.15372230112552643,
-0.4217330813407898,
-0.2561763525009155,
-0.45683521032333374,
0.33695659041404724,
-0.46808645129203796,
-1.0514476299285889,
0.657687246799469,
-0.0010617495281621814,
-0.4654952883720398,
0.25761517882347107,
0.5112888216972351,
-0.12266591191291809,
1.0123445987701416,
0.45889073610305786,
-0.2589300274848938,
0.5054885745048523,
-0.03289363533258438,
-0.24072033166885376,
-0.6950659155845642,
-0.08561019599437714,
-0.5020173192024231,
0.02859085611999035,
-1.0673216581344604,
-0.457050085067749,
0.3249134123325348,
-0.01619996316730976,
-0.11958855390548706,
0.22399276494979858,
-0.6412767767906189,
0.2824564576148987,
0.5873630046844482,
-0.20187675952911377,
0.20802107453346252,
-0.18802833557128906,
-0.13105294108390808,
-0.36296185851097107,
-0.6696913838386536,
-0.5707606673240662,
0.6750169396400452,
0.4016781449317932,
1.0979865789413452,
-0.33751824498176575,
0.944282591342926,
0.2055302858352661,
-0.3273937702178955,
-0.8089928030967712,
0.4730047881603241,
-0.3023216128349304,
-0.45985090732574463,
-0.34234216809272766,
-0.5180845260620117,
-0.8788202404975891,
0.3813228905200958,
0.0038259467110037804,
-0.7771453261375427,
0.4669552743434906,
0.191595196723938,
-0.17011405527591705,
-0.017643006518483162,
-0.5818575024604797,
0.7458333969116211,
-0.4824475944042206,
0.3274242579936981,
-0.04778052866458893,
-0.5097243189811707,
0.21206672489643097,
0.13702280819416046,
0.3523947596549988,
-0.34081605076789856,
0.2656954228878021,
0.7421160340309143,
-0.29593610763549805,
0.9143343567848206,
-0.3017292320728302,
-0.21680843830108643,
0.6916741728782654,
0.18722297251224518,
0.04079213738441467,
0.08433790504932404,
0.012753160670399666,
0.2994040250778198,
0.13962242007255554,
-0.3353630602359772,
-0.46215981245040894,
0.40319570899009705,
-0.9572482109069824,
-0.8123871684074402,
-0.4391622841358185,
-0.628326416015625,
-0.07950662076473236,
0.05933288857340813,
0.19747449457645416,
0.4539620280265808,
-0.1793636679649353,
-0.20020709931850433,
0.4812634289264679,
-0.08615507185459137,
0.3208540380001068,
0.4313628375530243,
-0.5274125337600708,
-0.07634402066469193,
1.0847879648208618,
0.4518914222717285,
0.5398960709571838,
0.0888671800494194,
0.42480260133743286,
-0.32894420623779297,
-0.632391631603241,
-0.18159739673137665,
0.39590156078338623,
-0.7771978974342346,
0.22022360563278198,
-0.44925689697265625,
-0.6779717206954956,
-0.534514844417572,
0.09635970741510391,
-0.4781394600868225,
-0.44613489508628845,
-0.49822166562080383,
0.06712653487920761,
0.26500141620635986,
0.9940401911735535,
-0.259417325258255,
0.40763112902641296,
-0.9085986018180847,
0.3374776840209961,
0.40608182549476624,
0.06069636717438698,
-0.11765845865011215,
-0.9717867374420166,
-0.4687962234020233,
-0.019511984661221504,
0.14065685868263245,
-1.1404966115951538,
0.7264302372932434,
0.3464854657649994,
0.46249261498451233,
0.5592265129089355,
0.16886688768863678,
0.7373393177986145,
-0.19102896749973297,
0.6233276724815369,
-0.3109098970890045,
-1.2110074758529663,
0.8207547068595886,
-0.19967027008533478,
0.6493314504623413,
0.4865023195743561,
0.09365609288215637,
-0.8132062554359436,
-0.49283233284950256,
-0.6112074255943298,
-0.46106839179992676,
0.8769642114639282,
0.199662446975708,
0.07930674403905869,
0.09469930082559586,
0.5499367713928223,
0.03554052859544754,
0.03664645180106163,
-0.6671274900436401,
-0.05579587444663048,
-0.5761277675628662,
0.009520106017589569,
-0.31354525685310364,
-0.5814969539642334,
-0.029125940054655075,
0.12354795634746552,
0.08655202388763428,
-0.09840833395719528,
-0.11006012558937073,
0.5620160698890686,
-0.44513705372810364,
0.19797036051750183,
0.34099292755126953,
0.7006539106369019,
0.3844764828681946,
-0.3085492253303528,
0.5205920934677124,
0.22276794910430908,
-0.39697811007499695,
0.43192166090011597,
-0.22387957572937012,
-0.13202868402004242,
0.2679966986179352,
0.5908365249633789,
0.9470510482788086,
0.2169649451971054,
-0.46701711416244507,
0.09504949301481247,
0.15043887495994568,
0.11770834773778915,
-0.24755032360553741,
0.18569397926330566,
0.011535217985510826,
0.07010909914970398,
0.26827386021614075,
-0.48545923829078674,
0.13725534081459045,
-0.6658951640129089,
0.19435670971870422,
0.15146367251873016,
-0.7927007675170898,
-0.660724401473999,
0.4458552300930023,
0.14228375256061554,
-0.3680221140384674,
0.6683579683303833,
-0.33942028880119324,
-0.631820797920227,
0.6474942564964294,
0.9075120687484741,
0.7657727599143982,
-0.45765459537506104,
0.21815337240695953,
0.5069092512130737,
0.562852680683136,
0.008177943527698517,
0.39298370480537415,
-0.14594359695911407,
-0.8563821315765381,
0.08361702412366867,
-0.8823174834251404,
-0.48840755224227905,
0.017402715981006622,
-1.178329586982727,
0.20026732981204987,
-0.3570106625556946,
-0.2263365089893341,
-0.28282231092453003,
-0.2776773273944855,
-0.39193230867385864,
0.35748836398124695,
0.6424677968025208,
0.5860999822616577,
-1.004152536392212,
0.9159241914749146,
0.6477644443511963,
-0.20887579023838043,
-0.8688240647315979,
-0.06209193170070648,
0.22062310576438904,
-1.1000287532806396,
0.6040574312210083,
0.4253002405166626,
-0.15003347396850586,
0.07216472178697586,
-0.08685513585805893,
-0.8871209621429443,
0.7252403497695923,
0.47174757719039917,
-0.399544894695282,
0.1400269865989685,
0.7885235548019409,
0.7740298509597778,
-0.6659525036811829,
0.054110921919345856,
1.1065640449523926,
0.25013014674186707,
0.13310964405536652,
-1.0660288333892822,
-0.15829846262931824,
0.07903963327407837,
0.3952096700668335,
-0.15513882040977478,
-0.7725622057914734,
0.9263577461242676,
-0.15899518132209778,
-0.4847468137741089,
-0.3317655622959137,
0.8581469655036926,
0.4173705279827118,
0.10993194580078125,
0.4747750461101532,
0.3841281533241272,
0.6838048100471497,
-0.08688340336084366,
0.6873935461044312,
-0.5483312010765076,
0.43350815773010254,
0.9674763679504395,
-0.24046961963176727,
0.39598551392555237,
0.2544513940811157,
-0.14135706424713135,
0.3302420377731323,
0.8295828700065613,
-0.052790407091379166,
0.3592393398284912,
0.23064716160297394,
0.06190213933587074,
-0.3583376109600067,
-0.43351250886917114,
-0.35781916975975037,
1.090794563293457,
0.5376549363136292,
-0.3528912663459778,
0.044504567980766296,
-0.040688976645469666,
-0.019069742411375046,
0.20881721377372742,
-0.6463808417320251,
0.8470708131790161,
0.5449215173721313,
-0.49170878529548645,
0.8292063474655151,
-0.36380040645599365,
0.5364031791687012,
-0.418175607919693,
0.1612464189529419,
-0.4023738205432892,
-0.06290806084871292,
-0.28280362486839294,
-0.7107574939727783,
0.24109266698360443,
-0.12274494767189026,
0.06751607358455658,
-0.2839840054512024,
0.6084506511688232,
-0.5242873430252075,
-0.44480934739112854,
0.5635854601860046,
0.5518573522567749,
0.45366787910461426,
-0.028681335970759392,
-0.5476195812225342,
0.1009242832660675,
-0.15267978608608246,
-0.15943609178066254,
0.1680184304714203,
0.5058798789978027,
-0.04243133217096329,
0.5906668901443481,
0.31015852093696594,
0.3683314621448517,
0.2417256236076355,
0.49942561984062195,
0.5513322353363037,
-1.193342685699463,
-0.7770669460296631,
-0.9001644253730774,
0.10237715393304825,
0.4094308614730835,
-0.34596896171569824,
0.7936485409736633,
0.30943477153778076,
0.8581947684288025,
0.06070106849074364,
0.5164493322372437,
0.651009738445282,
0.10217700898647308,
-0.7448763251304626,
0.703942596912384,
-0.428982138633728,
-0.01724966987967491,
-0.0819791704416275,
-0.8602953553199768,
-0.12012593448162079,
0.5311579704284668,
-0.10757998377084732,
0.23481670022010803,
0.4170272946357727,
0.6321881413459778,
0.33142516016960144,
0.21785365045070648,
0.6219145655632019,
0.3275790512561798,
-0.010810469277203083,
0.28107956051826477,
0.8269874453544617,
0.2166343480348587,
0.4683251678943634,
-0.4006613492965698,
-0.005044197663664818,
-0.41443175077438354,
-0.3535271883010864,
-0.9940475225448608,
-0.6973287463188171,
-0.15365681052207947,
-0.3268034756183624,
-0.1227593794465065,
0.7972621917724609,
0.6412913203239441,
-1.045225977897644,
-0.8369550704956055,
0.10076900571584702,
0.06398609280586243,
-0.26820752024650574,
-0.19180667400360107,
0.39983421564102173,
-0.5053121447563171,
-0.5996132493019104,
0.4920724332332611,
0.4810078740119934,
0.4196561276912689,
-0.5747069716453552,
-0.060158900916576385,
0.10594207793474197,
0.09994171559810638,
0.19954408705234528,
0.43681302666664124,
-0.8116098046302795,
-0.0757710412144661,
0.08357439935207367,
-0.41368567943573,
0.5086154937744141,
1.0632884502410889,
-0.9011550545692444,
0.6956226229667664,
0.26002243161201477,
0.19868794083595276,
0.4849483370780945,
0.08081280440092087,
0.506626546382904,
-0.6675770878791809,
0.59307461977005,
0.3981192708015442,
0.5972928404808044,
0.5302514433860779,
-0.13768154382705688,
0.5019769668579102,
0.17444755136966705,
-0.5320260524749756,
-0.8195857405662537,
0.33164381980895996,
-0.778043270111084,
0.07806477695703506,
1.1432188749313354,
-0.2848450839519501,
-0.28638017177581787,
-0.23753046989440918,
0.003912255167961121,
0.41758203506469727,
-0.16095811128616333,
0.6621164679527283,
0.5479991436004639,
-0.3957548439502716,
-0.3648409843444824,
-0.34506359696388245,
0.5802819728851318,
0.6750611662864685,
-0.4207130968570709,
0.22872775793075562,
0.17814545333385468,
-0.11879688501358032,
0.2956753373146057,
0.5194977521896362,
-0.008675764314830303,
0.2241416722536087,
0.31807905435562134,
0.05318356305360794,
0.19504305720329285,
-0.27405181527137756,
-1.023668646812439,
-0.016425393521785736,
0.39089933037757874,
-0.005881671328097582
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16854v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16854v3
|
An Expert is Worth One Token: Synergizing Multiple Expert LLMs as Generalist via Expert Token Routing
| 2024-03-25T15:17:05 | 2024-06-11T15:12:09 |
Ziwei Chai, Guoyin Wang, Jing Su, Tianjie Zhang, Xuanwen Huang, Xuwu Wang, Jingjing Xu, Jianbo Yuan, Hongxia Yang, Fei Wu, Yang Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We present Expert-Token-Routing, a unified generalist framework that
facilitates seamless integration of multiple expert LLMs. Our framework
represents expert LLMs as special expert tokens within the vocabulary of a meta
LLM. The meta LLM can route to an expert LLM like generating new tokens.
Expert-Token-Routing not only supports learning the implicit expertise of
expert LLMs from existing instruction dataset but also allows for dynamic
extension of new expert LLMs in a plug-and-play manner. It also conceals the
detailed collaboration process from the user's perspective, facilitating
interaction as though it were a singular LLM. Our framework outperforms various
existing multi-LLM collaboration paradigms across benchmarks that incorporate
six diverse expert domains, demonstrating effectiveness and robustness in
building generalist LLM system via synergizing multiple expert LLMs.
|
[
-0.4264737069606781,
-0.6639255285263062,
0.6997223496437073,
0.0848182812333107,
-0.270315945148468,
0.4290767312049866,
-0.0917128250002861,
-0.29478949308395386,
0.7945520281791687,
0.4616241753101349,
-0.5986325144767761,
-0.6309804320335388,
-0.4911324083805084,
-0.17295075953006744,
-0.37948310375213623,
0.7768293619155884,
0.22503767907619476,
0.4120965301990509,
-0.3239765167236328,
-0.32238733768463135,
-0.5594085454940796,
-0.5707213282585144,
-0.932548999786377,
-0.14886654913425446,
0.7818228006362915,
0.5196240544319153,
0.627606987953186,
0.5309144854545593,
0.493674099445343,
0.4252384901046753,
0.11438468843698502,
0.265732079744339,
-0.04341290146112442,
0.15914414823055267,
-0.658659040927887,
-0.45903053879737854,
-0.9629591703414917,
-0.03751203790307045,
0.21558180451393127,
0.8372661471366882,
-0.24894797801971436,
0.12250039726495743,
0.028638500720262527,
0.6536868810653687,
-0.38321492075920105,
-0.13378746807575226,
-0.7161466479301453,
-0.02746904268860817,
-0.35232773423194885,
-0.07725787162780762,
-0.18098105490207672,
-0.0651024580001831,
0.2893860340118408,
-0.8616009950637817,
0.3956870138645172,
0.27004870772361755,
0.09725917130708694,
0.4202400743961334,
-0.24782295525074005,
-0.16775304079055786,
-0.4492734968662262,
0.5139137506484985,
-0.43182915449142456,
0.2373761534690857,
-0.26902446150779724,
0.5066686868667603,
-0.08873122185468674,
-1.0833431482315063,
-0.36901769042015076,
0.42769700288772583,
0.104777991771698,
0.14822515845298767,
-0.12165877968072891,
0.4554153382778168,
-0.3298967480659485,
0.16108426451683044,
-0.20432732999324799,
0.2568904757499695,
-0.17838136851787567,
-0.15221403539180756,
0.5599806904792786,
0.2711327373981476,
0.09846901893615723,
0.3014192283153534,
-0.6938807964324951,
0.4668012857437134,
-0.40755075216293335,
-0.16306500136852264,
0.5891535878181458,
0.20772230625152588,
0.028388608247041702,
0.05392682924866676,
-0.10885157436132431,
0.7188892364501953,
0.2497895359992981,
-0.30696901679039,
0.23112984001636505,
-0.5130302906036377,
-0.06389670819044113,
0.021767282858490944,
0.777783989906311,
0.18671095371246338,
0.1271767020225525,
-0.8254134058952332,
0.11266922205686569,
-0.37741589546203613,
0.33080196380615234,
-0.442213773727417,
-0.39114394783973694,
0.05359894782304764,
-0.2899268865585327,
-0.2514478862285614,
0.41153812408447266,
-0.9485399127006531,
-0.3746878206729889,
-0.35450446605682373,
0.49094218015670776,
0.11851909756660461,
-0.6417344212532043,
0.2836579382419586,
-0.3136211037635803,
-0.2199745923280716,
0.4928971827030182,
-0.9869263768196106,
0.7569887638092041,
0.9086180329322815,
0.8002878427505493,
-0.3132677674293518,
-0.6066765785217285,
-0.43376633524894714,
0.44405269622802734,
-0.2682250440120697,
0.8668791651725769,
-0.6708232164382935,
-0.4911697208881378,
-0.12089932709932327,
-0.29691338539123535,
-0.21632862091064453,
-0.2720896005630493,
0.43731555342674255,
-0.5962005853652954,
0.26694175601005554,
-0.48004910349845886,
-0.5050574541091919,
-0.36259925365448,
0.2116638422012329,
-0.645271897315979,
0.6481159329414368,
-0.08140838891267776,
-0.6905336380004883,
0.46138280630111694,
-0.9244824647903442,
-0.23082472383975983,
0.38001006841659546,
-0.5602233409881592,
0.2196732759475708,
0.02240356244146824,
0.1639108955860138,
0.3748094141483307,
-0.2947280704975128,
0.21415096521377563,
-0.42405515909194946,
-0.33257344365119934,
-0.029912294819951057,
-0.3705449402332306,
0.37817004323005676,
-0.06432930380105972,
-0.3049578070640564,
0.13923627138137817,
-0.6501513123512268,
-0.002457234775647521,
-0.2999976575374603,
-0.5412196516990662,
-0.1530849039554596,
0.09817017614841461,
-0.23893389105796814,
0.17273367941379547,
0.4352135956287384,
-0.3552556037902832,
0.6285936832427979,
-0.33749398589134216,
0.26247143745422363,
1.1972806453704834,
0.11924207955598831,
0.696198046207428,
-0.2546178102493286,
0.45363980531692505,
0.0647716075181961,
0.1471540778875351,
-0.2508052885532379,
-0.7559974789619446,
-1.0669984817504883,
-0.48182734847068787,
0.3389333486557007,
0.36438095569610596,
-0.5059694647789001,
0.25765225291252136,
-0.21880963444709778,
-0.20179222524166107,
-0.9345237612724304,
0.3445560932159424,
0.32921847701072693,
0.5676583051681519,
0.6452160477638245,
-0.4931674599647522,
-0.45511549711227417,
-0.8862102031707764,
-0.5839304327964783,
-0.02127358317375183,
0.045496728271245956,
0.17132018506526947,
0.1392558366060257,
-0.35140323638916016,
1.3015722036361694,
-0.3143818974494934,
-0.5531705617904663,
-0.023059168830513954,
0.2121136337518692,
0.23547503352165222,
0.5945478677749634,
0.5856058597564697,
-0.7885454297065735,
-0.5796610713005066,
-0.07928132265806198,
-0.7677507996559143,
0.1765924096107483,
0.09442855417728424,
-0.3129574656486511,
0.07629185169935226,
0.4359194040298462,
-0.5600118637084961,
0.3478117883205414,
0.1888190358877182,
-0.4383280277252197,
0.48692360520362854,
-0.07751253247261047,
0.2878699004650116,
-1.1884431838989258,
-0.02165607176721096,
-0.3357590436935425,
-0.03965362161397934,
-0.7838078141212463,
0.16515791416168213,
-0.5794180035591125,
0.289492130279541,
-0.35345304012298584,
0.8825428485870361,
-0.25247302651405334,
-0.2282230406999588,
0.01914471574127674,
0.03837662562727928,
-0.03534093126654625,
0.763959527015686,
-0.31191912293434143,
0.7127107977867126,
0.9362545609474182,
-0.4909459948539734,
0.6401819586753845,
0.009155692532658577,
0.32114148139953613,
0.9981390237808228,
-0.6772274971008301,
0.5072187781333923,
0.2509530782699585,
-0.011044392362236977,
-0.9850947260856628,
-0.17904967069625854,
0.5637286901473999,
-0.3885575234889984,
0.23279106616973877,
-0.35336288809776306,
-0.5822111964225769,
-0.3195912837982178,
0.017140042036771774,
0.2862131595611572,
0.10232566297054291,
-0.5680078864097595,
1.2269582748413086,
0.08414892852306366,
-0.28520527482032776,
-0.7969760298728943,
-0.7509289979934692,
0.45646655559539795,
-0.04114886000752449,
-0.7253490090370178,
0.4408144950866699,
-0.3141677677631378,
-0.2287420630455017,
0.2808232307434082,
-0.2918088436126709,
-0.1426163613796234,
0.3715905547142029,
0.28128933906555176,
-0.05962740257382393,
-0.053013138473033905,
0.35030803084373474,
0.10447308421134949,
-0.5189976692199707,
0.2483321875333786,
-0.773527979850769,
0.2737993001937866,
-0.13952107727527618,
-1.0847374200820923,
-0.3621549606323242,
0.6623902916908264,
0.7911828756332397,
-0.09820889681577682,
0.5717031359672546,
0.7863277792930603,
-0.2960217297077179,
0.021375179290771484,
-1.0102410316467285,
-0.010899407789111137,
-0.5309646725654602,
0.27229437232017517,
-0.4392950236797333,
-0.9736695289611816,
0.6647220849990845,
-0.300249844789505,
0.22943107783794403,
0.5119478106498718,
0.3647507429122925,
0.11903035640716553,
1.0967119932174683,
0.7877716422080994,
-0.39275047183036804,
-0.01970209740102291,
-0.1590244621038437,
0.2414333075284958,
-0.49986740946769714,
-0.6793240904808044,
-0.4041242301464081,
-0.36602872610092163,
-0.10928117483854294,
-0.49796605110168457,
0.4735661745071411,
0.20030514895915985,
-0.4241429567337036,
-0.30195704102516174,
-0.6242139935493469,
0.5001831650733948,
0.8368209004402161,
0.12094222754240036,
0.46621614694595337,
0.00821939017623663,
-0.678831160068512,
0.38339802622795105,
-0.9757561683654785,
-0.4948338270187378,
1.093228816986084,
0.3428526222705841,
0.6962366104125977,
0.15137603878974915,
0.7425586581230164,
0.48528483510017395,
0.26622462272644043,
-0.629275918006897,
0.7555542588233948,
0.05077556148171425,
-0.5813509821891785,
-0.22679366171360016,
-0.26378369331359863,
-0.45326223969459534,
0.2587355673313141,
-0.21161936223506927,
-0.6148371696472168,
0.10114039480686188,
0.10389892756938934,
-0.34860241413116455,
0.8439300060272217,
-0.5812752842903137,
0.7268362045288086,
-0.36922088265419006,
-0.47120189666748047,
-0.5772661566734314,
-0.6512171030044556,
0.12951193749904633,
-0.17160461843013763,
0.3255581855773926,
0.11514188349246979,
-0.5089277625083923,
0.9385146498680115,
-0.38979658484458923,
0.8559522032737732,
-0.25248557329177856,
0.3406178057193756,
0.20069734752178192,
0.11598361283540726,
0.31893083453178406,
0.07479813694953918,
-0.2592698633670807,
0.2068215161561966,
-0.7007548809051514,
-0.557197093963623,
-0.4160154461860657,
0.768852949142456,
-0.9050769209861755,
-0.8538964986801147,
0.00031566672259941697,
-0.28760483860969543,
-0.2998479902744293,
0.4055163860321045,
0.12552382051944733,
0.5210375189781189,
-0.2143823653459549,
-0.31113293766975403,
0.7168330550193787,
0.3312302827835083,
0.4653744697570801,
0.6151654124259949,
0.25175556540489197,
-0.8663803339004517,
0.7130608558654785,
0.14325609803199768,
-0.010986670851707458,
0.3136237561702728,
-0.04079238325357437,
-0.25329262018203735,
-0.7668501734733582,
-0.5123282670974731,
-0.16965140402317047,
-0.968379557132721,
-0.2546437084674835,
-0.9819971323013306,
0.14647601544857025,
-0.2161695659160614,
-0.6418269872665405,
-0.4069948196411133,
-0.4039321839809418,
-0.5466644763946533,
-0.39255979657173157,
0.5349440574645996,
0.9149673581123352,
-0.2267034500837326,
0.35878586769104004,
-0.7899616360664368,
0.03227703645825386,
1.0878829956054688,
0.5836302638053894,
0.36647793650627136,
-0.23258262872695923,
-0.5327810645103455,
-0.08232870697975159,
-0.30358028411865234,
-0.7394250631332397,
-0.1657358556985855,
0.12415271997451782,
1.2636739015579224,
0.92630934715271,
-0.25709104537963867,
0.715447187423706,
-0.5550980567932129,
0.832714855670929,
0.7610490918159485,
-1.1487741470336914,
0.2066224366426468,
-0.35513025522232056,
-0.05723341926932335,
0.7783861756324768,
0.3294666111469269,
-0.38848239183425903,
-0.4017207622528076,
-0.763131856918335,
-0.9122432470321655,
0.4046614468097687,
-0.36091578006744385,
0.027063068002462387,
-0.12411868572235107,
0.35468432307243347,
0.2358601987361908,
0.5910588502883911,
-0.3909499943256378,
-0.5557069182395935,
-0.22377833724021912,
-0.05408673360943794,
0.2685236930847168,
-0.18775589764118195,
-0.6019867658615112,
-0.1552899330854416,
0.28152674436569214,
-0.3515780568122864,
0.4322271943092346,
0.08651410043239594,
0.1007748618721962,
-0.25214681029319763,
0.26524943113327026,
0.27622556686401367,
0.9811088442802429,
0.02483096905052662,
0.37333500385284424,
0.644829273223877,
-0.049447160214185715,
0.1678336262702942,
0.029906481504440308,
0.38276275992393494,
-0.017567746341228485,
0.5808496475219727,
0.4900584816932678,
0.6533025503158569,
-0.004729326814413071,
0.6126629710197449,
0.1204548254609108,
-0.5710898637771606,
-0.04494946822524071,
0.22033999860286713,
0.2909231185913086,
0.3904881477355957,
0.8549419641494751,
0.6307602524757385,
0.10587187856435776,
-0.12928153574466705,
0.4332352876663208,
0.3753983676433563,
-0.2815566956996918,
-0.5051601529121399,
0.8825903534889221,
0.8837849497795105,
-0.5608875155448914,
0.09827620536088943,
-0.289956271648407,
-0.7853561639785767,
0.36991962790489197,
-0.060406021773815155,
1.0893733501434326,
-0.09672021865844727,
0.05105271190404892,
0.1942032128572464,
0.04416124150156975,
-0.06776026636362076,
-0.05553887039422989,
-0.00050749332876876,
-0.46559178829193115,
-0.45350271463394165,
-0.2652741074562073,
-0.8061138987541199,
-0.5885589718818665,
-0.669465184211731,
0.10499757528305054,
-0.42677128314971924,
-0.1439792960882187,
-0.24863079190254211,
0.09398792684078217,
-1.0556142330169678,
-0.06493504345417023,
-0.0668492391705513,
1.1034988164901733,
-0.6899630427360535,
0.5139483213424683,
1.0936930179595947,
-0.3578237295150757,
-0.605907678604126,
-0.355175644159317,
-0.006968912202864885,
-0.8245860934257507,
0.6393888592720032,
-0.015442630276083946,
-0.36000388860702515,
0.0007397226872853935,
-0.5783093571662903,
-0.5601036548614502,
1.3958014249801636,
0.06039572134613991,
-0.635094165802002,
-0.24595989286899567,
0.18178045749664307,
0.37841135263442993,
-0.6757582426071167,
0.4761594831943512,
0.3013513684272766,
0.4785166382789612,
0.16777199506759644,
-0.7956382632255554,
0.01253424771130085,
-0.037169452756643295,
-0.44103503227233887,
0.007588688284158707,
-1.0405727624893188,
0.875013530254364,
-0.2951894700527191,
-0.049668993800878525,
-0.011543480679392815,
0.5492741465568542,
0.03329727426171303,
0.37377873063087463,
0.6604005694389343,
0.9392791390419006,
0.9648575186729431,
0.212675079703331,
0.296195387840271,
-0.7110996246337891,
0.04210842773318291,
0.8787533640861511,
0.014601955190300941,
0.3564055860042572,
0.4765334129333496,
-0.05433302000164986,
0.8219540119171143,
0.5002157688140869,
0.13856402039527893,
0.5662538409233093,
0.0716513991355896,
-0.5182085633277893,
-0.6081080436706543,
-0.05681636556982994,
-0.6072037220001221,
-0.010576168075203896,
0.19989079236984253,
-0.1315990388393402,
-0.31293895840644836,
-0.23756136000156403,
0.3119436800479889,
-0.08005734533071518,
-0.5348562598228455,
0.8357879519462585,
0.04281212016940117,
-0.4609425365924835,
-0.06129266321659088,
0.015352120622992516,
0.849242091178894,
-0.6846991777420044,
-0.05816081166267395,
-0.18128374218940735,
0.020014770328998566,
-0.40657201409339905,
-0.5838935375213623,
-0.08053135126829147,
-0.2312040776014328,
-0.35880792140960693,
-0.23716358840465546,
0.8349400162696838,
-0.4371902048587799,
-0.3360568881034851,
0.5406445264816284,
1.0684127807617188,
-0.01634797640144825,
0.039180755615234375,
-0.7924403548240662,
-0.44559475779533386,
-0.24727508425712585,
-0.12080907821655273,
0.44860896468162537,
0.7628719806671143,
0.5931304097175598,
0.7732438445091248,
0.6910551190376282,
0.09818490594625473,
-0.09090778976678848,
0.22860155999660492,
1.2489649057388306,
-0.49134883284568787,
-0.6335475444793701,
-0.7863787412643433,
0.7215133309364319,
-0.09986826032400131,
-0.3999261260032654,
0.7156246304512024,
0.36299756169319153,
0.8168696165084839,
0.1922130286693573,
0.9368818402290344,
0.33879438042640686,
0.5261663198471069,
-0.28766313195228577,
0.5310160517692566,
-0.522788405418396,
0.47248271107673645,
-0.34778285026550293,
-0.546977698802948,
-0.10115047544240952,
0.19049738347530365,
-0.011081712320446968,
0.010831068269908428,
0.42067140340805054,
0.6577693223953247,
0.042303990572690964,
-0.07383599877357483,
0.18126587569713593,
-0.21615543961524963,
0.37479984760284424,
0.43363451957702637,
0.6778315901756287,
-0.031578101217746735,
0.5411650538444519,
0.07074739784002304,
-0.2902058959007263,
-0.20879080891609192,
-0.8494932055473328,
-1.1191869974136353,
-0.17319074273109436,
-0.2011181265115738,
0.10715433955192566,
0.18184059858322144,
1.164444923400879,
1.1542426347732544,
-0.4852445125579834,
-0.07678484916687012,
-0.3457081615924835,
0.6704970002174377,
-0.3353424370288849,
-0.22206589579582214,
0.24722006916999817,
-0.5353965759277344,
-0.4486261010169983,
0.4322807490825653,
0.4655214846134186,
-0.10911744832992554,
-0.7183709144592285,
-0.3085397481918335,
0.012712758034467697,
0.0152672054246068,
0.27198198437690735,
0.034154728055000305,
-0.6762098073959351,
-0.3659488558769226,
0.10079702734947205,
0.09985493868589401,
-0.03895672410726547,
0.8544913530349731,
-0.8233751058578491,
0.6612569689750671,
0.42236971855163574,
0.7448244094848633,
-0.0664079338312149,
0.05257023125886917,
0.5180837512016296,
-0.7780837416648865,
-0.08775103092193604,
0.20848532021045685,
0.32623007893562317,
0.06192724034190178,
-0.3110065460205078,
0.7066190838813782,
0.6605471968650818,
-0.7134984731674194,
-0.5338965654373169,
0.0917847752571106,
-0.8887871503829956,
-0.14479342103004456,
0.9013002514839172,
-0.36034834384918213,
0.3668895959854126,
-0.5587360858917236,
0.07523411512374878,
-0.053040798753499985,
-0.5885472893714905,
0.4393792450428009,
0.7299472689628601,
-0.11876119673252106,
0.07095873355865479,
-0.33006054162979126,
0.2690804898738861,
0.2505094110965729,
-0.6657599210739136,
-0.44009241461753845,
0.04567883536219597,
0.37054339051246643,
0.3077746629714966,
0.8926287293434143,
0.34834641218185425,
0.22189776599407196,
0.11667749285697937,
0.2578698694705963,
-0.6993561387062073,
-0.805014431476593,
0.0064179678447544575,
0.3151553273200989,
0.0973273515701294,
-0.4318268299102783
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16852v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16852v2
|
Towards Explainability in Legal Outcome Prediction Models
| 2024-03-25T15:15:41 | 2024-04-16T03:53:28 |
Josef Valvoda, Ryan Cotterell
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Current legal outcome prediction models - a staple of legal NLP - do not
explain their reasoning. However, to employ these models in the real world,
human legal actors need to be able to understand the model's decisions. In the
case of common law, legal practitioners reason towards the outcome of a case by
referring to past case law, known as precedent. We contend that precedent is,
therefore, a natural way of facilitating explainability for legal NLP models.
In this paper, we contribute a novel method for identifying the precedent
employed by legal outcome prediction models. Furthermore, by developing a
taxonomy of legal precedent, we are able to compare human judges and neural
models with respect to the different types of precedent they rely on. We find
that while the models learn to predict outcomes reasonably well, their use of
precedent is unlike that of human judges.
|
[
-0.19308169186115265,
-0.3324195146560669,
1.030576229095459,
-0.0657799243927002,
-0.6327434778213501,
-0.28089848160743713,
-0.05461454018950462,
-0.4648199677467346,
0.2399301677942276,
0.6123558282852173,
-0.43504074215888977,
-0.5859858989715576,
-0.39318305253982544,
-0.15369431674480438,
-0.5774950981140137,
0.69833904504776,
0.25423693656921387,
0.21340139210224152,
-0.5587321519851685,
-0.261699378490448,
-0.48620763421058655,
-0.7182068824768066,
-0.6080949902534485,
-0.6462211608886719,
0.4332194924354553,
-0.06543371826410294,
0.837153971195221,
0.6543145775794983,
0.20236395299434662,
0.2666747570037842,
-0.2815684676170349,
-0.4492437243461609,
-0.043028589338064194,
-0.28622278571128845,
-0.3071049451828003,
-0.7272546291351318,
-0.38459599018096924,
-0.1503637731075287,
0.25432324409484863,
0.7292595505714417,
-0.3846072256565094,
-0.29058995842933655,
-0.449738472700119,
0.6382691860198975,
-0.5528626441955566,
0.10107090324163437,
-0.6473615765571594,
0.430921733379364,
-0.10318994522094727,
-0.44461801648139954,
-0.4829696714878082,
-0.44962719082832336,
0.1401744782924652,
-0.83531653881073,
0.3052569627761841,
0.09354358166456223,
0.5237559676170349,
0.06579134613275528,
-0.41016948223114014,
-0.30416396260261536,
-0.6061345934867859,
0.3061215579509735,
-1.0796988010406494,
0.2120399922132492,
0.14614520967006683,
0.9210526347160339,
-0.1876625120639801,
-0.9293556213378906,
-0.9512965679168701,
-0.3831658959388733,
-0.31336283683776855,
0.38554832339286804,
0.019618501886725426,
0.21579937636852264,
0.21789439022541046,
-0.04145389050245285,
-0.5561180710792542,
0.4464707374572754,
-0.22043846547603607,
-0.08918187022209167,
0.4358177185058594,
0.19307273626327515,
0.20177315175533295,
-0.4473359286785126,
-0.16879361867904663,
0.5580317378044128,
-0.7067622542381287,
0.4905829429626465,
0.4256271421909332,
0.4980451762676239,
0.056507110595703125,
0.2860874831676483,
-0.2300124317407608,
0.7583758234977722,
-0.20215703547000885,
0.07840031385421753,
-0.17184709012508392,
0.24407798051834106,
-0.2036445140838623,
0.3591592609882355,
0.40278616547584534,
0.35986217856407166,
0.3043588101863861,
-0.17154936492443085,
-0.032459329813718796,
-0.17874115705490112,
0.5097893476486206,
-0.4368613064289093,
0.16538406908512115,
0.36755692958831787,
-0.798581600189209,
-0.40335002541542053,
0.16490699350833893,
-0.714455246925354,
-0.7619560360908508,
-0.31945687532424927,
0.3637312948703766,
-0.2672690153121948,
-0.19833435118198395,
0.3900919556617737,
-0.32138791680336,
0.46805429458618164,
0.4884018898010254,
-0.6045755743980408,
0.5301872491836548,
1.143982172012329,
0.5557641983032227,
0.12637199461460114,
-0.19304031133651733,
-0.5339902639389038,
-0.053832318633794785,
-0.40733882784843445,
0.5786063075065613,
-0.4777382016181946,
-0.22138245403766632,
0.20945018529891968,
-0.10138094425201416,
0.1970096230506897,
-0.40614432096481323,
0.8122748732566833,
-0.5519529581069946,
-0.17295394837856293,
-0.11558590084314346,
-0.585440456867218,
-0.5091820359230042,
0.05456293001770973,
-0.4874253571033478,
0.007697795517742634,
-0.2794579565525055,
-0.7519462704658508,
1.1881680488586426,
-0.5595182180404663,
-0.6736859679222107,
0.26523923873901367,
-0.3580701947212219,
-0.5598416328430176,
0.34519433975219727,
-0.0235414057970047,
0.4906066358089447,
-0.1890559047460556,
1.0635122060775757,
-0.580685019493103,
-0.4086643159389496,
0.07894192636013031,
-0.27218014001846313,
0.8362458348274231,
0.21251176297664642,
-0.1132349967956543,
0.11805042624473572,
-0.7476350665092468,
-0.2618260681629181,
0.03252154588699341,
0.06812304258346558,
-0.3354136049747467,
0.4981153607368469,
-0.28132563829421997,
0.510144829750061,
-0.09976672381162643,
-0.13523724675178528,
-0.027517469599843025,
-0.306099534034729,
0.5330419540405273,
0.8703816533088684,
-0.08550407737493515,
0.3211038112640381,
-0.4158213436603546,
0.6016700863838196,
0.0133826257660985,
0.2270817905664444,
0.0805644541978836,
-0.6907038688659668,
-0.4772951304912567,
0.1421675980091095,
0.4315055310726166,
0.21307343244552612,
-0.15995651483535767,
0.18287301063537598,
-0.4339064359664917,
-0.3157484531402588,
-0.23144064843654633,
-0.4156348705291748,
0.283105731010437,
0.6407766342163086,
0.2021215409040451,
-0.32683664560317993,
-0.8748959302902222,
-0.968250036239624,
-0.9397306442260742,
-0.5279788970947266,
0.16027425229549408,
0.5618116855621338,
0.6530335545539856,
0.28838276863098145,
1.058660626411438,
0.035405583679676056,
0.14229190349578857,
-0.43364131450653076,
0.30215370655059814,
0.7245810031890869,
0.16548095643520355,
0.3872663676738739,
-1.0200339555740356,
-0.05158129706978798,
0.2039819359779358,
-0.868546187877655,
0.2617567181587219,
-0.5331646800041199,
0.17177492380142212,
-0.05010806769132614,
0.6582680344581604,
-0.4204942584037781,
0.9655882120132446,
-0.500812292098999,
-0.636677086353302,
0.8908202052116394,
-0.3436921536922455,
-0.02907055988907814,
-0.5116192102432251,
-0.028577880933880806,
-0.0792929157614708,
-0.41130247712135315,
-0.6714537143707275,
0.03532857075333595,
-0.04597068205475807,
0.03368034586310387,
-0.609264612197876,
0.6253830790519714,
-0.09835139662027359,
-0.48699602484703064,
0.05820761248469353,
-0.02024899236857891,
-0.043720994144678116,
0.1438194066286087,
0.4150029420852661,
0.24169042706489563,
0.5373668074607849,
-0.6635878086090088,
0.06728501617908478,
0.14939145743846893,
-0.31836554408073425,
0.5950421094894409,
-0.6631352305412292,
-0.37419888377189636,
-0.3639417886734009,
0.27147960662841797,
-0.5328256487846375,
-0.4494338631629944,
-0.03753181919455528,
-0.42991968989372253,
0.11736327409744263,
-0.726561427116394,
-0.28122445940971375,
-0.7397143840789795,
0.18987272679805756,
-0.031721699982881546,
0.5843871235847473,
-0.5731936693191528,
0.9140248894691467,
0.15794135630130768,
0.07096779346466064,
-0.6597617864608765,
-0.5563334226608276,
0.13293786346912384,
-0.8224778175354004,
-0.24672718346118927,
0.35338589549064636,
0.268878310918808,
-0.5729436874389648,
0.07750540971755981,
-0.20202895998954773,
-0.27017098665237427,
0.5015888810157776,
0.6628666520118713,
0.11442616581916809,
-0.3426268398761749,
0.5294064283370972,
-0.021632324904203415,
-0.007474706508219242,
0.45699211955070496,
-0.21523115038871765,
0.26110437512397766,
0.18111491203308105,
-0.3448709547519684,
-0.5783318281173706,
0.30932819843292236,
0.47878748178482056,
0.057387761771678925,
0.6368894577026367,
-0.07856697589159012,
-0.506184458732605,
-0.20438514649868011,
-0.28210872411727905,
0.08704058825969696,
-0.35336992144584656,
0.13032886385917664,
-0.5439116358757019,
-0.3918318450450897,
0.7924646139144897,
0.024498192593455315,
-0.02451244741678238,
0.6185373663902283,
0.41938528418540955,
0.06776919960975647,
0.5658007860183716,
0.4057847857475281,
0.08912262320518494,
0.12067317962646484,
0.22039462625980377,
0.3140796720981598,
-0.2751314342021942,
-0.2774832844734192,
-0.454120934009552,
0.13068529963493347,
-0.5436034202575684,
-0.050166431814432144,
-0.13476090133190155,
0.29962074756622314,
-0.17043578624725342,
0.4835863411426544,
-0.3007297217845917,
0.5419600605964661,
0.5121241211891174,
-0.01875169761478901,
0.42587006092071533,
-0.561208188533783,
-0.4432196617126465,
0.253389835357666,
-0.7089177966117859,
-0.7094709873199463,
1.1421416997909546,
0.11841432750225067,
0.3148372769355774,
0.056710030883550644,
1.1250492334365845,
0.2583102881908417,
0.09445244818925858,
-0.658004105091095,
0.4805201590061188,
-0.2214486300945282,
-0.6679869890213013,
-0.107203908264637,
-0.12307993322610855,
-0.9563626646995544,
0.2155732959508896,
-0.5106217861175537,
-1.043385624885559,
0.3287801146507263,
0.016705304384231567,
-0.9150565266609192,
0.29369527101516724,
-0.2582297921180725,
0.8380612134933472,
-0.20939555764198303,
-0.3584417998790741,
-0.19147546589374542,
-0.8596025109291077,
0.44104763865470886,
-0.08541495352983475,
0.6004437804222107,
-0.07181333750486374,
0.4161759614944458,
0.8860302567481995,
-0.6661444306373596,
0.6446934342384338,
-0.18502886593341827,
0.3786343038082123,
0.2846410870552063,
0.04448537155985832,
0.4246353507041931,
0.32092106342315674,
-0.32674482464790344,
-0.35500749945640564,
-0.05727031081914902,
-0.1570667326450348,
-0.7826778888702393,
0.6560598611831665,
-0.39049792289733887,
-0.7331382632255554,
-0.40967246890068054,
-0.2894945740699768,
-0.01585911586880684,
0.07980923354625702,
0.2016739547252655,
0.36780691146850586,
-0.3750423491001129,
-0.18445797264575958,
0.03509357571601868,
-0.31254687905311584,
0.6167380809783936,
0.7201853394508362,
-0.18043406307697296,
0.1267385631799698,
0.5390252470970154,
0.33447250723838806,
-0.3300601840019226,
0.1188330203294754,
0.5015639662742615,
-0.5085656642913818,
-0.8182347416877747,
0.10961808264255524,
-0.1414332091808319,
-0.9978910684585571,
0.21520036458969116,
-0.5434838533401489,
-0.12566520273685455,
-0.28234657645225525,
-0.5016686916351318,
-0.04885457828640938,
-0.6203113198280334,
-0.2495560497045517,
-0.26728469133377075,
0.26876741647720337,
0.8200816512107849,
-0.030049612745642662,
0.21174146234989166,
-0.2212575227022171,
0.5354391932487488,
0.5641456842422485,
0.47639456391334534,
-0.00937459897249937,
-0.8017953634262085,
0.2409379780292511,
-0.4417947232723236,
0.03101952001452446,
-0.8249878883361816,
0.43175774812698364,
0.17901581525802612,
0.8879641890525818,
0.5947622060775757,
0.19638612866401672,
0.7704527378082275,
-0.6618226170539856,
0.642421305179596,
0.27569225430488586,
-1.01606285572052,
0.9029408693313599,
-0.19137969613075256,
-0.2888804078102112,
0.5632848739624023,
0.2941727936267853,
-0.43621116876602173,
-0.07055162638425827,
-1.0503031015396118,
-1.0194354057312012,
0.4949585497379303,
0.09925799071788788,
-0.07356405258178711,
-0.12397251278162003,
0.7343232035636902,
0.6222290396690369,
0.17612522840499878,
-0.7956082820892334,
0.07599980384111404,
-0.25294172763824463,
0.3475537896156311,
-0.18061938881874084,
-0.06475666910409927,
-0.012262335047125816,
-0.3480997383594513,
0.47018179297447205,
0.06830631196498871,
0.12261398881673813,
0.10267578065395355,
-0.23884598910808563,
0.23618611693382263,
0.48590490221977234,
0.6748135089874268,
1.1341081857681274,
-0.4677797555923462,
0.20945845544338226,
-0.08070433139801025,
0.14319252967834473,
0.02678772434592247,
0.1411673128604889,
-0.01969527266919613,
0.19278256595134735,
0.6881242990493774,
0.7434553503990173,
0.17733022570610046,
-0.43996375799179077,
0.5216904282569885,
-0.043574023991823196,
-0.3011576533317566,
-0.7822961807250977,
-0.03708091005682945,
0.17749245464801788,
0.29558685421943665,
0.30274897813796997,
0.17710654437541962,
0.5509809255599976,
-0.82634037733078,
0.5991553664207458,
0.2838454246520996,
-0.726969301700592,
-0.1669347584247589,
0.961229681968689,
0.056482478976249695,
-0.490725040435791,
0.27912402153015137,
-0.19017179310321808,
-0.36790192127227783,
1.1465919017791748,
0.5133915543556213,
0.5321130752563477,
0.33679166436195374,
0.3028247058391571,
0.430286705493927,
-0.12538883090019226,
-0.36168771982192993,
0.14552639424800873,
0.1853584349155426,
-0.5356495976448059,
-0.33634358644485474,
-0.47086456418037415,
-0.36862945556640625,
0.04375223442912102,
-1.0609147548675537,
0.24387139081954956,
-0.5429523587226868,
-0.14425747096538544,
0.6229862570762634,
-0.3371534049510956,
-0.7342978715896606,
0.34699177742004395,
0.13518588244915009,
1.0165374279022217,
-1.0879485607147217,
0.7956690192222595,
0.3082016408443451,
-0.5361939668655396,
-0.5133653283119202,
0.13115538656711578,
0.13711589574813843,
-0.7130044102668762,
0.623646080493927,
0.42170387506484985,
0.15786676108837128,
-0.39304134249687195,
-0.41160476207733154,
-0.04148330166935921,
0.9847355484962463,
0.1173754408955574,
-0.4912116527557373,
-0.1410026252269745,
-0.097586989402771,
0.6707150936126709,
-0.49259495735168457,
0.22591152787208557,
0.6831262111663818,
0.4705992341041565,
0.17359955608844757,
-0.4830174744129181,
0.1545013189315796,
-0.16324663162231445,
0.010626017116010189,
-0.03700858727097511,
0.2084449827671051,
0.6517928838729858,
-0.618191123008728,
-0.08014380931854248,
0.09376061707735062,
0.5768267512321472,
0.27331510186195374,
0.7324388027191162,
0.41073837876319885,
0.5128932595252991,
0.810933530330658,
-0.2865585684776306,
1.519201636314392,
0.1772320419549942,
0.31749483942985535,
1.4665619134902954,
-0.2879292666912079,
0.7182096838951111,
0.6811093688011169,
-0.2524494528770447,
0.6260858774185181,
0.645028293132782,
0.1460583359003067,
0.5739535093307495,
0.5687525272369385,
0.07638321071863174,
-0.855129063129425,
0.10236052423715591,
-0.050767894834280014,
0.4926934540271759,
0.13593095541000366,
-0.5092526078224182,
-0.2288580983877182,
-0.285014271736145,
-0.4085765779018402,
0.5455167293548584,
-0.6333975195884705,
0.7654585838317871,
0.13210615515708923,
-0.668958842754364,
0.25858643651008606,
-0.3357539474964142,
0.19557461142539978,
-0.2673507332801819,
-0.13289083540439606,
-0.041384320706129074,
-0.08529456704854965,
-0.18006731569766998,
-1.044456958770752,
0.4273744225502014,
-0.4035877287387848,
-0.11967071145772934,
0.3310273289680481,
0.36786752939224243,
0.14783698320388794,
-0.40039846301078796,
0.4800947308540344,
0.4779423475265503,
0.20325137674808502,
0.04341331496834755,
-0.7386386394500732,
-0.6592459678649902,
-0.4382621645927429,
-0.03618720546364784,
0.1308075189590454,
0.6310702562332153,
-0.4015437662601471,
1.0373975038528442,
0.3144097328186035,
0.23056146502494812,
-0.0024744223337620497,
0.08339937031269073,
0.5042554140090942,
-0.9412470459938049,
-0.702715277671814,
-0.9898484349250793,
0.6747592091560364,
-0.2678372263908386,
-0.3484039902687073,
0.17614249885082245,
0.343152791261673,
0.19582952558994293,
-0.03745194151997566,
0.7397109270095825,
-0.08271612972021103,
0.41739621758461,
-0.7863500118255615,
0.6400881409645081,
-0.5982214212417603,
0.27397796511650085,
-0.16040000319480896,
-0.1493142694234848,
-0.618914008140564,
0.5550310015678406,
-0.470122754573822,
-0.13814975321292877,
0.5595967173576355,
0.33538931608200073,
-0.2387843281030655,
-0.009377561509609222,
0.7071473002433777,
0.10197463631629944,
-0.04686247929930687,
0.42817971110343933,
0.7706423997879028,
0.04673066735267639,
0.4542762041091919,
-0.15416738390922546,
0.1984209418296814,
-0.5213736891746521,
-1.1078803539276123,
-0.9647206664085388,
-0.42882102727890015,
0.04760323464870453,
-0.1361248940229416,
0.4715416431427002,
0.5026992559432983,
0.6485244631767273,
-0.9814326167106628,
0.0037423730827867985,
-0.728008508682251,
0.4907416105270386,
-0.3816410005092621,
-0.13199378550052643,
0.35322919487953186,
-0.306912899017334,
-0.14584361016750336,
0.22991397976875305,
0.19292820990085602,
-0.08524545282125473,
0.4185143709182739,
-0.18219906091690063,
-0.1833837926387787,
0.276381254196167,
0.1313645839691162,
0.5043339729309082,
-1.3792670965194702,
-0.3587193489074707,
-0.7940412759780884,
0.3786351978778839,
0.2791408598423004,
0.9085067510604858,
-0.8942928910255432,
0.7451217770576477,
0.22667482495307922,
0.11901696771383286,
0.4276978373527527,
-0.10980994254350662,
0.9833470582962036,
-0.3329240381717682,
0.23108850419521332,
0.34124648571014404,
0.8839535117149353,
-0.07400696724653244,
-0.45954495668411255,
0.6396294236183167,
-0.16891837120056152,
-0.2640414834022522,
-0.49538031220436096,
0.46608632802963257,
-0.9988458156585693,
-0.5468608736991882,
0.5507358312606812,
-0.5396486520767212,
-0.2353321760892868,
-0.5459226965904236,
0.26955488324165344,
0.2596060335636139,
-0.2554183006286621,
0.8586224317550659,
0.4062296450138092,
0.10686236619949341,
-0.20668379962444305,
-0.9144845604896545,
0.6408920884132385,
0.1727936714887619,
-0.6120793223381042,
0.10267320275306702,
0.259332537651062,
0.20553334057331085,
0.11621022969484329,
0.4630400836467743,
-0.3260652422904968,
0.6626333594322205,
-0.0448821596801281,
0.06346077471971512,
-0.043159034103155136,
-0.2587868273258209,
-0.6664130091667175,
0.18059268593788147,
0.07617932558059692,
0.3393845558166504
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16851v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16851v1
|
Can ChatGPT predict article retraction based on Twitter mentions?
| 2024-03-25T15:15:09 | 2024-03-25T15:15:09 |
Er-Te Zheng, Hui-Zhen Fu, Zhichao Fang
|
cs.DL
|
cs.DL, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Detecting problematic research articles timely is a vital task. This study
explores whether Twitter mentions of retracted articles can signal potential
problems with the articles prior to retraction, thereby playing a role in
predicting future retraction of problematic articles. A dataset comprising
3,505 retracted articles and their associated Twitter mentions is analyzed,
alongside 3,505 non-retracted articles with similar characteristics obtained
using the Coarsened Exact Matching method. The effectiveness of Twitter
mentions in predicting article retraction is evaluated by four prediction
methods, including manual labelling, keyword identification, machine learning
models, and ChatGPT. Manual labelling results indicate that there are indeed
retracted articles with their Twitter mentions containing recognizable evidence
signaling problems before retraction, although they represent only a limited
share of all retracted articles with Twitter mention data (approximately 16%).
Using the manual labelling results as the baseline, ChatGPT demonstrates
superior performance compared to other methods, implying its potential in
assisting human judgment for predicting article retraction. This study uncovers
both the potential and limitation of social media events as an early warning
system for article retraction, shedding light on a potential application of
generative artificial intelligence in promoting research integrity.
|
[
-0.0743725448846817,
-0.9426490664482117,
0.4435325562953949,
0.07264071702957153,
-0.3832419812679291,
0.5427159070968628,
-0.11045094579458237,
-0.6505020260810852,
0.4946073293685913,
0.21185174584388733,
-0.6460809707641602,
-0.0786050483584404,
-0.9848716855049133,
0.023641319945454597,
-1.1642138957977295,
1.13658607006073,
-0.15700393915176392,
-0.5613774061203003,
0.29360291361808777,
0.2016284018754959,
-0.3825514018535614,
-0.18106885254383087,
-1.0054670572280884,
-0.42554038763046265,
1.0933334827423096,
0.13430123031139374,
0.5233860611915588,
0.37984997034072876,
0.9188053011894226,
0.2670729458332062,
0.07752708345651627,
-0.10788966715335846,
-0.7411285638809204,
-0.011710884049534798,
0.0030335455667227507,
-0.3533366024494171,
-0.12659986317157745,
0.07914061099290848,
0.48247620463371277,
0.35811254382133484,
-0.2947864532470703,
0.1633332520723343,
0.3715384602546692,
0.6062932014465332,
-0.11900051683187485,
-0.09995605051517487,
-0.9125064015388489,
0.2728397250175476,
-0.14421026408672333,
-0.40232229232788086,
-0.27344387769699097,
-0.8664237856864929,
0.33861133456230164,
-0.5433149933815002,
0.604888379573822,
0.18986931443214417,
1.246290922164917,
0.19402827322483063,
-0.22045664489269257,
-0.10662887245416641,
-0.8831060528755188,
0.5370147228240967,
-0.5310831665992737,
0.1703978031873703,
0.265330046415329,
0.5101664066314697,
-0.16849035024642944,
-0.9691887497901917,
-0.4807446002960205,
-0.1835019439458847,
-0.07222972810268402,
0.006334905978292227,
-0.3987692594528198,
-0.6503391861915588,
0.2315961718559265,
0.04764712229371071,
-0.32774630188941956,
-0.20930281281471252,
-0.6441628336906433,
-0.3675110340118408,
0.5561450123786926,
-0.1830921769142151,
0.3347339630126953,
-0.03532757610082626,
-0.49873924255371094,
0.31211429834365845,
-1.0280416011810303,
-0.466230183839798,
0.30740949511528015,
-0.02603350766003132,
-0.013280542567372322,
0.4771844148635864,
0.1115729883313179,
0.04021766409277916,
-0.003311491571366787,
0.24663671851158142,
0.28227660059928894,
-0.37970638275146484,
0.01988908089697361,
0.11431477218866348,
0.9819698929786682,
0.3756459653377533,
0.23673056066036224,
-0.5368041396141052,
-0.3021996021270752,
-0.2861177921295166,
0.453429251909256,
-0.41152098774909973,
-0.36326760053634644,
-0.042711291462183,
-0.5390808582305908,
-0.49900582432746887,
0.06819625198841095,
-0.6412911415100098,
-0.578804075717926,
0.04101087898015976,
0.6264255046844482,
-0.6973173022270203,
-0.44849893450737,
-0.263195276260376,
-0.18937554955482483,
0.1752072274684906,
0.6147238612174988,
-0.2396087348461151,
-0.10202635824680328,
0.9045183658599854,
1.1448357105255127,
-0.4537981152534485,
-0.24544581770896912,
-0.2241954207420349,
0.19383306801319122,
-0.3650266230106354,
0.9808850288391113,
-0.17055223882198334,
-0.1414511650800705,
0.03636949136853218,
0.31203967332839966,
-0.012439422309398651,
-0.05747874081134796,
1.0457178354263306,
-0.5245625376701355,
-0.06921227276325226,
-0.3521415591239929,
-0.4091031849384308,
-0.14828899502754211,
0.3687724471092224,
-0.8181772232055664,
0.405849426984787,
-0.08962251991033554,
-1.0168519020080566,
0.3744295835494995,
-0.06148970127105713,
-0.5099999904632568,
-0.0701550543308258,
0.09625019133090973,
-0.8620672821998596,
-0.13978976011276245,
0.1668732762336731,
0.17407095432281494,
-0.06629002839326859,
0.4720754027366638,
-0.2955069839954376,
-0.3959510326385498,
0.4190080761909485,
-0.606574535369873,
0.7590126395225525,
0.3604625463485718,
-0.3169797360897064,
0.05341687798500061,
-0.43959754705429077,
-0.4440929591655731,
0.18571241199970245,
-0.3651449978351593,
-0.07336944341659546,
0.08581609278917313,
-0.0449889674782753,
-0.01666443981230259,
-0.17496193945407867,
-0.667979896068573,
0.08669324964284897,
-0.05288638547062874,
0.5308483242988586,
0.7378577589988708,
0.42170828580856323,
0.16856186091899872,
-0.6528552174568176,
0.44119763374328613,
-0.21504805982112885,
-0.07757262885570526,
0.09577605873346329,
-0.6705964803695679,
-0.7592841386795044,
0.05045933276414871,
0.42137062549591064,
0.5936392545700073,
-0.9334367513656616,
0.2729857265949249,
-0.46660488843917847,
-0.7232565879821777,
-0.3715389668941498,
-0.10332851111888885,
0.31692931056022644,
0.6362860202789307,
0.06526659429073334,
-0.05425378680229187,
-0.8634968996047974,
-0.7574687004089355,
-0.9022012948989868,
-0.40198081731796265,
-0.1001567393541336,
-0.041772134602069855,
0.40399935841560364,
0.014637753367424011,
0.9175456166267395,
-0.3425002098083496,
-0.2780594527721405,
-0.12681633234024048,
0.8337961435317993,
0.11757711321115494,
0.35242030024528503,
0.2539059519767761,
-1.0073285102844238,
-0.3805561661720276,
-0.1282135546207428,
-0.8716204166412354,
-0.07179232686758041,
-0.3653479814529419,
-0.042434196919202805,
0.14191287755966187,
0.6996164321899414,
-0.6451361775398254,
0.5535165667533875,
-0.00894164852797985,
-0.18969757854938507,
0.7302932143211365,
0.2892477512359619,
0.26080322265625,
-1.0448650121688843,
0.18723537027835846,
0.14458082616329193,
-0.2719923257827759,
-0.476779967546463,
-0.6469449996948242,
-0.16755862534046173,
0.0718701183795929,
-0.37896817922592163,
0.13050760328769684,
-0.38932421803474426,
0.16808782517910004,
-0.2177092432975769,
-0.02394147589802742,
-0.3003227114677429,
-0.22099316120147705,
0.22004011273384094,
0.6025615334510803,
0.06524834781885147,
-0.34824422001838684,
0.1570046991109848,
0.15550535917282104,
-0.46584269404411316,
-0.1626627892255783,
-0.6655982136726379,
0.026491669937968254,
-0.019250884652137756,
0.16559985280036926,
-1.2363988161087036,
0.08218373358249664,
0.5061575174331665,
-0.9724485278129578,
0.26086747646331787,
-0.2823532223701477,
-0.3021029531955719,
-0.39565783739089966,
-0.34097984433174133,
0.068201944231987,
0.4146278500556946,
0.025897981598973274,
0.3109439015388489,
0.28397810459136963,
-0.5696254968643188,
-0.5146316289901733,
-0.6097198128700256,
0.372038334608078,
-0.33855995535850525,
-0.3834393620491028,
0.36861327290534973,
0.18156905472278595,
0.0065709748305380344,
0.48560354113578796,
-0.026012444868683815,
-0.012930931523442268,
0.1845577508211136,
0.24691501259803772,
0.24393658339977264,
0.10469628870487213,
0.3342455327510834,
-0.1490028351545334,
-0.21004809439182281,
0.3612405061721802,
0.25400668382644653,
0.3283921480178833,
-0.11345665156841278,
-0.4250580072402954,
-0.16913145780563354,
0.19503119587898254,
0.11952029913663864,
0.010693801566958427,
0.7157552242279053,
1.2977731227874756,
-0.6811610460281372,
0.4223991632461548,
-0.7228136658668518,
-0.39241668581962585,
-0.3720611333847046,
0.32892346382141113,
0.21816721558570862,
-0.7008736729621887,
0.6020165085792542,
0.012348197400569916,
0.24007193744182587,
0.706616997718811,
0.37809982895851135,
-0.31689921021461487,
0.5247966051101685,
0.6237689256668091,
-0.29893720149993896,
0.6355106830596924,
-0.1463644802570343,
0.5694615244865417,
-0.6813828945159912,
-0.17976264655590057,
-0.7496128082275391,
-0.2969297468662262,
-0.7582937479019165,
-0.0034079672768712044,
0.0539732351899147,
-0.08117400854825974,
0.027123747393488884,
0.4653775990009308,
-0.4482342302799225,
0.2571108639240265,
0.550692081451416,
0.22777317464351654,
0.38704079389572144,
0.3809106945991516,
0.3994287848472595,
-0.062055595219135284,
-0.6242045760154724,
-0.5552971959114075,
0.9783935546875,
0.21130405366420746,
0.7494532465934753,
-0.02141946740448475,
0.803224503993988,
0.7818053364753723,
0.9381365776062012,
-0.5991377234458923,
0.3163274824619293,
0.4661618769168854,
-0.5328640341758728,
-0.34360548853874207,
-0.3862098157405853,
-1.0954347848892212,
-0.1228584498167038,
-0.3447571396827698,
-0.8112342357635498,
0.20756271481513977,
-0.2879790663719177,
-0.3770533800125122,
0.528656542301178,
-0.8269096612930298,
0.1055280864238739,
0.13795413076877594,
-0.40677088499069214,
-0.1844055950641632,
-0.6000238656997681,
0.4605749249458313,
-0.2782149612903595,
0.2858545184135437,
-0.4669385850429535,
0.0510542206466198,
1.11103093624115,
-0.09816739708185196,
0.8636153936386108,
0.12037428468465805,
0.08699557185173035,
0.5933672785758972,
0.2562926113605499,
0.4139764606952667,
0.24269603192806244,
0.072467140853405,
0.08711212128400803,
0.04042423516511917,
-0.12729522585868835,
0.0021175858564674854,
0.7963302731513977,
-0.7021629214286804,
-0.716834306716919,
-0.6285462975502014,
-0.12790678441524506,
-0.13545286655426025,
0.3876296281814575,
0.5249071717262268,
-0.22977283596992493,
-0.23317396640777588,
0.12933529913425446,
0.5062776207923889,
-0.09261908382177353,
0.7435426712036133,
0.5095347762107849,
0.02925225906074047,
-0.3749067485332489,
1.0165437459945679,
0.29665109515190125,
-0.23332072794437408,
0.29932981729507446,
0.1455869972705841,
-0.046285223215818405,
-0.7701424956321716,
0.08944850414991379,
0.10729178786277771,
-0.260231614112854,
-0.583936333656311,
-0.5808693766593933,
-0.42575645446777344,
-0.454216331243515,
-0.15162551403045654,
-0.38316109776496887,
-0.4385243356227875,
-0.3329226076602936,
-0.3398864269256592,
0.2791529595851898,
0.5379672646522522,
-0.026096723973751068,
0.23759259283542633,
-1.0695481300354004,
0.4073697030544281,
0.015449096448719501,
0.455152690410614,
0.13005927205085754,
-0.49207356572151184,
-0.17855487763881683,
0.008362535387277603,
-0.6190143823623657,
-0.8724930882453918,
0.6041299700737,
0.23030991852283478,
0.49351468682289124,
0.5040633082389832,
0.21492838859558105,
0.26698610186576843,
-0.43258652091026306,
0.5786100029945374,
0.4124850332736969,
-0.3834768533706665,
0.5866274237632751,
-0.6823791861534119,
-0.19843968749046326,
0.1491207778453827,
0.732988715171814,
-0.6744901537895203,
-0.5729463696479797,
-0.7726713418960571,
-0.9665396809577942,
0.4516174793243408,
0.44313833117485046,
0.020114416256546974,
-0.23832622170448303,
0.32239940762519836,
0.4557737410068512,
0.3159812390804291,
-0.7895289659500122,
-0.02648082748055458,
0.15805350244045258,
0.3449610769748688,
0.020256754010915756,
-0.599456250667572,
-0.2211373895406723,
-0.13920047879219055,
0.7676175832748413,
0.3269156813621521,
0.605696976184845,
0.3869979977607727,
-0.206798255443573,
-0.27029314637184143,
0.15230043232440948,
0.28469905257225037,
0.9072297215461731,
-0.5349278450012207,
-0.16276605427265167,
-0.29328256845474243,
-0.5129295587539673,
-0.02198437787592411,
0.25246280431747437,
-0.36102867126464844,
0.14640158414840698,
0.6178049445152283,
0.18289287388324738,
0.14855527877807617,
-0.14949390292167664,
0.26746344566345215,
-0.15487609803676605,
-0.301188588142395,
-0.7344550490379333,
-0.40209275484085083,
0.2982643246650696,
0.17755329608917236,
0.84036785364151,
0.1198020949959755,
0.2776924967765808,
-0.4458344578742981,
0.6379261612892151,
0.15758420526981354,
-0.6074294447898865,
-0.5651976466178894,
0.6619435548782349,
0.2501859962940216,
-0.39283835887908936,
0.641164243221283,
0.09629148989915848,
-0.4306485652923584,
0.675355851650238,
0.33177778124809265,
1.065122127532959,
-0.22963093221187592,
0.25648143887519836,
0.36622151732444763,
0.6477522253990173,
0.005277764517813921,
0.011686992831528187,
0.4643504023551941,
-0.8236087560653687,
-0.4254114329814911,
-0.3157060742378235,
-0.0768417939543724,
-0.014116762205958366,
-0.49161675572395325,
0.31729212403297424,
-0.24792400002479553,
-0.541692316532135,
0.2127988189458847,
-0.11740393936634064,
-0.46073171496391296,
-0.16478827595710754,
0.1342647820711136,
0.8125187754631042,
-1.0984749794006348,
0.585483729839325,
0.412349671125412,
-0.48915719985961914,
-0.5750389099121094,
0.17269641160964966,
0.2653235197067261,
-0.440403550863266,
0.2283051311969757,
0.14670459926128387,
-0.22643227875232697,
-0.1429811716079712,
-0.5835695266723633,
-0.7825399041175842,
1.0642664432525635,
0.5879539251327515,
-0.5013014674186707,
0.1116868332028389,
-0.15433315932750702,
0.38678306341171265,
-0.13973717391490936,
0.03141195327043533,
0.5411279201507568,
0.25616928935050964,
0.37534576654434204,
-0.9610635042190552,
0.15682336688041687,
-0.2184334695339203,
-0.38994187116622925,
0.267291396856308,
-0.5974113941192627,
0.6469042897224426,
-0.33337312936782837,
-0.4279056489467621,
0.004135455470532179,
0.42628031969070435,
-0.12935969233512878,
0.6430632472038269,
0.3626282215118408,
0.3466475307941437,
0.41441822052001953,
-0.43174952268600464,
0.9511374831199646,
0.1946738213300705,
0.5005603432655334,
0.7931680083274841,
0.011672016233205795,
0.7571699619293213,
0.8100573420524597,
-0.21226806938648224,
0.26437458395957947,
0.7461734414100647,
0.06998290121555328,
0.5896437764167786,
-0.10389348864555359,
-0.150375634431839,
-0.1984267681837082,
-0.28437915444374084,
-0.665876567363739,
0.0440543107688427,
0.6207062602043152,
-0.5355696082115173,
-0.4646724760532379,
-0.09905031323432922,
0.31712806224823,
-0.2309247851371765,
-0.1478808969259262,
0.7970606684684753,
0.13104766607284546,
-0.7982342839241028,
0.5441691279411316,
-0.3164832592010498,
0.4555639326572418,
-0.41542866826057434,
-0.25155124068260193,
-0.2998259365558624,
0.19709686934947968,
-0.2669845223426819,
-0.9679007530212402,
0.7302775979042053,
-0.4074358344078064,
0.18749360740184784,
-0.24162648618221283,
1.3784581422805786,
-0.16096805036067963,
-0.5099025964736938,
0.1296158879995346,
0.8170411586761475,
-0.06085474416613579,
-0.20175017416477203,
-0.8818568587303162,
-0.03485812246799469,
0.3402051329612732,
-0.38275837898254395,
0.34708172082901,
0.5324656367301941,
-0.11891967803239822,
1.2166203260421753,
0.6482198238372803,
0.22815808653831482,
0.11483548581600189,
-0.20171673595905304,
1.0356385707855225,
-0.48601850867271423,
-0.19624806940555573,
-0.7862715721130371,
0.12774798274040222,
-0.1678513139486313,
0.10036000609397888,
0.6074039340019226,
0.4203769862651825,
0.3146202564239502,
-0.1378539353609085,
0.9929139018058777,
-0.3477952778339386,
0.9401577711105347,
-0.2848571836948395,
0.86334627866745,
-0.31666332483291626,
0.5005967617034912,
-0.40466320514678955,
-0.5401888489723206,
-0.23103338479995728,
0.27306169271469116,
-0.6108570694923401,
-0.05632742494344711,
0.7403863668441772,
0.39145153760910034,
0.0009527461952529848,
0.08592956513166428,
-0.10960650444030762,
0.05218588933348656,
0.6132517457008362,
0.3502811789512634,
0.7669515609741211,
-0.21173173189163208,
0.9962431192398071,
-0.3302192687988281,
-0.05704361945390701,
-0.6671220660209656,
-1.0576218366622925,
-0.5415928959846497,
-0.6715362668037415,
-0.5509759783744812,
-0.5400309562683105,
0.5380683541297913,
0.43364468216896057,
0.22296753525733948,
-0.7444760203361511,
0.2845803499221802,
0.052057016640901566,
0.3423614203929901,
-0.30068108439445496,
-0.27758926153182983,
0.6551601886749268,
-0.21206550300121307,
-0.25549641251564026,
-0.2667020857334137,
-0.04473108425736427,
0.021279649809002876,
0.24593161046504974,
0.44466695189476013,
-0.6040271520614624,
-0.3222484588623047,
0.48559337854385376,
0.5136187672615051,
-0.4933305084705353,
-0.7377058267593384,
-0.08708355575799942,
0.005897747352719307,
-0.06667651236057281,
0.9239950776100159,
-0.9100981950759888,
0.000155020592501387,
0.45205390453338623,
0.47575995326042175,
0.5550203919410706,
0.28688573837280273,
0.7358282804489136,
-0.522655189037323,
0.010847017168998718,
0.5226976871490479,
0.5007664561271667,
0.2511172592639923,
-0.3304291367530823,
0.705939769744873,
0.5149638056755066,
-0.49670982360839844,
-0.638564944267273,
-0.022142071276903152,
-0.6840740442276001,
0.20088490843772888,
1.0622633695602417,
-0.4495912194252014,
-0.35645344853401184,
-0.2014596164226532,
-0.23701980710029602,
0.554531991481781,
-0.5487057566642761,
1.482843041419983,
0.924139678478241,
-0.04106917977333069,
-0.7194013595581055,
-0.818886935710907,
0.46786385774612427,
0.27191162109375,
-0.4376915991306305,
0.24712605774402618,
0.24901820719242096,
0.34766027331352234,
0.2148309051990509,
0.6171351075172424,
-0.26936033368110657,
0.3619909882545471,
-0.049658626317977905,
-0.17505022883415222,
-0.08703580498695374,
0.016028767451643944,
0.3082607090473175,
0.05750439316034317,
0.2213977873325348,
-0.2400892674922943
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16820v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16820v1
|
Cross-lingual Contextualized Phrase Retrieval
| 2024-03-25T14:46:51 | 2024-03-25T14:46:51 |
Huayang Li, Deng Cai, Zhi Qu, Qu Cui, Hidetaka Kamigaito, Lemao Liu, Taro Watanabe
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Phrase-level dense retrieval has shown many appealing characteristics in
downstream NLP tasks by leveraging the fine-grained information that phrases
offer. In our work, we propose a new task formulation of dense retrieval,
cross-lingual contextualized phrase retrieval, which aims to augment
cross-lingual applications by addressing polysemy using context information.
However, the lack of specific training data and models are the primary
challenges to achieve our goal. As a result, we extract pairs of cross-lingual
phrases using word alignment information automatically induced from parallel
sentences. Subsequently, we train our Cross-lingual Contextualized Phrase
Retriever (CCPR) using contrastive learning, which encourages the hidden
representations of phrases with similar contexts and semantics to align
closely. Comprehensive experiments on both the cross-lingual phrase retrieval
task and a downstream task, i.e, machine translation, demonstrate the
effectiveness of CCPR. On the phrase retrieval task, CCPR surpasses baselines
by a significant margin, achieving a top-1 accuracy that is at least 13 points
higher. When utilizing CCPR to augment the large-language-model-based
translator, it achieves average gains of 0.7 and 1.5 in BERTScore for
translations from X=>En and vice versa, respectively, on WMT16 dataset. Our
code and data are available at \url{https://github.com/ghrua/ccpr_release}.
|
[
-0.32944008708000183,
-0.6368821859359741,
0.32387015223503113,
0.2893366515636444,
-0.3760073781013489,
0.08918454498052597,
-0.42716488242149353,
-0.437050998210907,
0.28926903009414673,
0.5110623240470886,
-0.23496410250663757,
-0.3719017505645752,
-0.6597973704338074,
-0.009416853077709675,
-0.45544669032096863,
0.7294209003448486,
0.09292962402105331,
0.39253944158554077,
-0.12945181131362915,
-0.04519449919462204,
-0.5583240389823914,
-0.6422064304351807,
-0.41415640711784363,
-0.35408955812454224,
0.6335826516151428,
0.5429518818855286,
0.7728516459465027,
0.38874608278274536,
0.48062631487846375,
0.23344138264656067,
-0.34933024644851685,
0.0608690045773983,
-0.6803678870201111,
-0.04370983690023422,
-0.5190394520759583,
-0.3339425027370453,
-0.10777344554662704,
-0.15168818831443787,
0.5525412559509277,
0.972936749458313,
0.07052849978208542,
-0.20923180878162384,
0.259972482919693,
0.48490238189697266,
-0.7390421628952026,
-0.10978730767965317,
-0.8274528384208679,
0.3911999762058258,
-0.20152968168258667,
-0.3575144410133362,
-0.4058937728404999,
0.10395065695047379,
0.48014330863952637,
-0.49133846163749695,
0.21461667120456696,
0.23896659910678864,
0.8145381212234497,
0.05960448086261749,
-0.42899417877197266,
-0.2607012391090393,
-0.26762908697128296,
1.0486243963241577,
-0.5052952170372009,
0.5610951781272888,
0.142488494515419,
0.20103171467781067,
0.24441410601139069,
-0.9567769765853882,
-0.3483315110206604,
-0.18441222608089447,
-0.36473533511161804,
0.19524070620536804,
0.03213876485824585,
-0.20059263706207275,
0.1668507307767868,
0.6035604476928711,
-0.6448919773101807,
0.009229987859725952,
-0.21648350358009338,
-0.08146951347589493,
0.49264052510261536,
0.1496819257736206,
0.5573896765708923,
-0.2508876323699951,
-0.7978869080543518,
-0.1225932314991951,
-0.6117861270904541,
-0.08312162011861801,
-0.007210752926766872,
0.4957484006881714,
-0.2217869907617569,
0.7900499701499939,
-0.2946716248989105,
0.6055808067321777,
0.09244534373283386,
0.224594846367836,
0.32331612706184387,
-0.7083120346069336,
-0.11222349107265472,
0.31709402799606323,
0.6994962096214294,
0.3861425817012787,
0.09411071240901947,
-0.5074381232261658,
-0.30071109533309937,
-0.29170575737953186,
0.17858996987342834,
-0.7600271105766296,
0.0030240798369050026,
-0.04711760953068733,
-0.4535995423793793,
0.07702617347240448,
0.14681635797023773,
-0.7583146691322327,
-0.004160124342888594,
-0.5774123072624207,
0.3517638146877289,
-0.5219357013702393,
-0.06756322085857391,
0.24147213995456696,
-0.2990834414958954,
0.5034435391426086,
-0.01797407679259777,
-0.7827696204185486,
0.33635830879211426,
0.8006948828697205,
0.8862924575805664,
-0.4976550340652466,
-0.2970937490463257,
-0.6080564856529236,
0.24474799633026123,
-0.3779046833515167,
0.37483489513397217,
-0.6649064421653748,
-0.4343678653240204,
-0.08289777487516403,
0.08781269937753677,
-0.3029724061489105,
-0.7592628002166748,
0.5628067255020142,
-0.5220420360565186,
0.3249334394931793,
-0.5332455039024353,
-0.4746665060520172,
0.055973026901483536,
0.2895756661891937,
-0.5646052360534668,
0.8880335688591003,
-0.11149924993515015,
-1.0332623720169067,
0.10468479990959167,
-0.17218247056007385,
-0.521615207195282,
0.044120948761701584,
-0.11698093265295029,
-0.05294293910264969,
0.2817360758781433,
0.31379473209381104,
0.4082791209220886,
-0.31660160422325134,
0.23837843537330627,
-0.25431346893310547,
-0.5356912612915039,
-0.05066034197807312,
-0.2269098460674286,
0.8310849070549011,
0.2811754047870636,
-0.3796951174736023,
-0.08049570769071579,
-0.20255199074745178,
0.13149048388004303,
-0.08928046375513077,
-0.19279152154922485,
-0.6755608916282654,
-0.15795643627643585,
0.2592930793762207,
0.4741305112838745,
0.49643459916114807,
-0.6121656894683838,
-0.03132537379860878,
-0.39651742577552795,
0.04192950576543808,
0.2998378276824951,
-0.26539209485054016,
0.5780656337738037,
-0.16481317579746246,
0.44407156109809875,
0.11006902903318405,
-0.11502581089735031,
0.09597772359848022,
-0.21626591682434082,
-0.45878922939300537,
-0.15225794911384583,
0.3362632989883423,
0.7487846612930298,
-1.0156632661819458,
0.504321813583374,
-0.4665917456150055,
-0.3762672543525696,
-0.29479116201400757,
0.36406436562538147,
0.7078407406806946,
0.6213193535804749,
0.7413257956504822,
-0.42120155692100525,
-0.5652061104774475,
-0.7861514091491699,
-0.29202571511268616,
0.4787828326225281,
0.04538777843117714,
0.40603891015052795,
0.2542918026447296,
-0.26143673062324524,
0.8645050525665283,
-0.608299195766449,
-0.376497745513916,
-0.6529485583305359,
0.37996530532836914,
-0.06453815847635269,
0.6006265878677368,
0.4900420904159546,
-1.2250386476516724,
-0.8078808188438416,
0.26705604791641235,
-0.5214117169380188,
-0.3221690058708191,
0.050190214067697525,
-0.29396262764930725,
-0.05304815620183945,
0.8521919846534729,
-0.5202499032020569,
0.010307125747203827,
0.6761435866355896,
-0.27127841114997864,
0.4732761085033417,
-0.078803151845932,
0.054115671664476395,
-1.2677010297775269,
0.3601108491420746,
-0.06346181035041809,
-0.16388991475105286,
-0.41678401827812195,
0.17583662271499634,
0.06526845693588257,
-0.1142461746931076,
-0.678799569606781,
0.6712123155593872,
-0.5865114331245422,
-0.2867066562175751,
-0.3459300994873047,
0.4210652709007263,
0.05231379717588425,
0.3531450927257538,
0.37442871928215027,
0.9228529334068298,
0.3322314918041229,
-0.3652731776237488,
0.2361414134502411,
0.14215081930160522,
-0.28137990832328796,
0.5895476341247559,
-0.7405798435211182,
-0.12396086752414703,
-0.0776122435927391,
0.21679845452308655,
-0.7635858058929443,
0.09424342960119247,
-0.07559256255626678,
-0.34031179547309875,
0.3750201165676117,
-0.010131675750017166,
-0.4247022271156311,
0.10828052461147308,
-0.0009616529569029808,
0.6302159428596497,
0.25398391485214233,
-0.638989269733429,
0.3903900384902954,
0.43221861124038696,
-0.31065869331359863,
-0.875358521938324,
-0.7125043272972107,
0.22353628277778625,
-0.09257665276527405,
-0.3510168790817261,
0.8544839024543762,
0.10201222449541092,
-0.15185455977916718,
0.09298884123563766,
-0.20063738524913788,
-0.11454339325428009,
-0.19337107241153717,
-0.38985979557037354,
0.12940625846385956,
-0.16112031042575836,
-0.0545729324221611,
-0.08193971961736679,
-0.13456526398658752,
-0.042989104986190796,
-0.2731027901172638,
0.7623622417449951,
-0.1365772783756256,
-0.10202071070671082,
0.08248694986104965,
0.5490845441818237,
0.11465812474489212,
-0.39367449283599854,
0.4766532778739929,
1.1340911388397217,
-0.1966463327407837,
-0.022418254986405373,
-0.3366500735282898,
-0.05448484048247337,
-0.40537792444229126,
0.4132395386695862,
-0.5650256276130676,
-1.0667030811309814,
0.375851571559906,
0.0667588859796524,
-0.279960572719574,
0.23836007714271545,
0.42020007967948914,
0.19613291323184967,
1.1218081712722778,
0.5809345841407776,
-0.20694467425346375,
0.5520058274269104,
-0.23014847934246063,
0.11507998406887054,
-1.0042366981506348,
-0.2269718050956726,
-0.46003708243370056,
-0.39646148681640625,
-0.542217493057251,
-0.7709928154945374,
0.21039539575576782,
0.2891090512275696,
0.10109715908765793,
0.528209388256073,
-0.315807968378067,
0.32333511114120483,
0.5129905343055725,
0.1632702499628067,
0.17558883130550385,
-0.085277259349823,
-0.6608651280403137,
-0.3432474136352539,
-0.6996532082557678,
0.05355406552553177,
0.6517573595046997,
-0.1262776404619217,
0.8095079064369202,
0.09636722505092621,
0.6783004403114319,
0.02960357815027237,
-0.05393358692526817,
-0.7712797522544861,
0.6593145132064819,
-0.6009019613265991,
-0.37495988607406616,
-0.03645749390125275,
-0.6757936477661133,
-0.9983590841293335,
0.5729407072067261,
-0.06109261512756348,
-0.5521494746208191,
0.29568395018577576,
-0.03766337409615517,
0.020073601976037025,
0.05547066405415535,
-0.6420990228652954,
1.2239891290664673,
-0.616244375705719,
-0.5847012996673584,
-0.3962973952293396,
-0.8863641619682312,
0.28660228848457336,
-0.038194358348846436,
-0.17617633938789368,
0.05068527162075043,
-0.37062013149261475,
0.2490350902080536,
-0.18152989447116852,
0.7224454283714294,
-0.07707363367080688,
-0.02868417650461197,
-0.036696143448352814,
-0.14105966687202454,
0.2101898193359375,
-0.08547231554985046,
-0.010168342851102352,
0.14498570561408997,
-0.10004328936338425,
-0.5188600420951843,
-0.6670924425125122,
0.9973001480102539,
-0.5158725380897522,
-0.4979964792728424,
-0.3863159418106079,
-0.8311898112297058,
-0.14877814054489136,
0.3917326331138611,
0.20808173716068268,
0.3407035768032074,
-0.12936045229434967,
0.6608233451843262,
0.8224520683288574,
-0.476529598236084,
0.24856677651405334,
0.33237341046333313,
-0.1446235477924347,
-0.5289716720581055,
0.8922618627548218,
-0.11061249673366547,
0.4553183615207672,
1.1141631603240967,
0.23226134479045868,
-0.48285722732543945,
-0.29066377878189087,
-0.20631016790866852,
0.1771782785654068,
-0.48574915528297424,
-0.102609783411026,
-0.6547160744667053,
-0.1285194456577301,
-0.6295820474624634,
-0.3242158591747284,
-0.26446762681007385,
-0.4688929319381714,
-0.13614732027053833,
0.16469863057136536,
-0.1975107043981552,
0.18092092871665955,
-0.0852716863155365,
0.14820128679275513,
-0.8407643437385559,
0.44572916626930237,
0.07741932570934296,
0.1291963756084442,
-0.24344013631343842,
-0.47143369913101196,
-0.32864049077033997,
-0.08864722400903702,
-0.09490814805030823,
-0.5607209205627441,
0.7251957654953003,
0.12969917058944702,
0.6483640074729919,
0.17406176030635834,
0.06697571277618408,
0.9516713619232178,
-0.5313422083854675,
0.7009644508361816,
0.18454833328723907,
-1.011817216873169,
0.4402838349342346,
-0.06779727339744568,
0.5466917753219604,
0.605641782283783,
0.7491922378540039,
-0.7084403038024902,
-0.0503598228096962,
-0.3762330412864685,
-1.2002235651016235,
0.5613691806793213,
-0.10143853724002838,
0.20078949630260468,
-0.06778937578201294,
0.07949146628379822,
-0.123491570353508,
0.23434340953826904,
-0.7031071186065674,
0.029466567561030388,
-0.1278126984834671,
-0.35998204350471497,
-0.35051462054252625,
-0.21700918674468994,
0.010878579691052437,
-0.2230936884880066,
0.6235650181770325,
-0.29972243309020996,
0.03722900524735451,
0.3900892734527588,
-0.38634446263313293,
0.22067168354988098,
0.37636882066726685,
0.31067630648612976,
0.4926251769065857,
-0.13398772478103638,
0.27627378702163696,
0.18077439069747925,
-0.21064653992652893,
-0.2591750919818878,
0.4503336548805237,
-0.21773406863212585,
0.1802709996700287,
0.14205364882946014,
0.5233049392700195,
0.7014431953430176,
-0.9839577078819275,
0.7178902626037598,
0.14085417985916138,
0.06422124803066254,
-0.1847415715456009,
-0.24662010371685028,
0.06917701661586761,
0.11489011347293854,
0.2799761891365051,
-0.28496190905570984,
0.37838831543922424,
-0.4767346978187561,
0.553960919380188,
0.7669469714164734,
-0.6233164668083191,
-0.06708257645368576,
0.6092856526374817,
-0.024709852412343025,
0.1588941216468811,
0.5042075514793396,
-0.06751430034637451,
-0.6907633543014526,
0.24589577317237854,
0.7207396030426025,
0.7530073523521423,
-0.06591802090406418,
0.0054726614616811275,
0.2861465811729431,
0.07123696058988571,
-0.17033414542675018,
0.2544150948524475,
-0.31092238426208496,
-0.6609475612640381,
-0.6116869449615479,
-0.6211391687393188,
-0.36790457367897034,
-0.18824172019958496,
-0.7347906231880188,
0.3521532416343689,
-0.0019231109181419015,
0.165787935256958,
-0.26287809014320374,
0.14572730660438538,
-0.3720944821834564,
0.2693854868412018,
0.1858942210674286,
1.045594573020935,
-0.5633786916732788,
0.9503370523452759,
0.7851298451423645,
-0.4090419113636017,
-0.668785035610199,
0.039560526609420776,
-0.17048272490501404,
-0.7263883352279663,
0.8276767730712891,
0.22472123801708221,
-0.18241095542907715,
0.004635300021618605,
-0.2544748783111572,
-0.8659849166870117,
1.0534147024154663,
0.27770906686782837,
-0.6135920882225037,
-0.26475754380226135,
0.35538655519485474,
0.620124340057373,
-0.4659634530544281,
0.10057052224874496,
0.27865976095199585,
0.2695218622684479,
0.14747686684131622,
-0.9076768159866333,
0.09526728838682175,
-0.26891961693763733,
0.3448754549026489,
0.07527848333120346,
-0.5239525437355042,
0.8526486754417419,
0.03946835175156593,
-0.04160326346755028,
0.11501120030879974,
0.6598429083824158,
0.12488898634910583,
0.13849619030952454,
0.5637228488922119,
0.8128196597099304,
0.15289214253425598,
-0.11542018502950668,
1.0686079263687134,
-0.6045746803283691,
0.30454716086387634,
1.288399338722229,
-0.2843405604362488,
1.0398342609405518,
0.7332316040992737,
0.4450242817401886,
0.40896138548851013,
0.408598393201828,
0.1282472014427185,
0.6843790411949158,
-0.06223785877227783,
-0.20823542773723602,
-0.28524741530418396,
-0.37348610162734985,
-0.20366115868091583,
0.38564780354499817,
0.4016267955303192,
-0.49332624673843384,
-0.24549075961112976,
0.06470805406570435,
-0.15120479464530945,
0.2090051919221878,
-0.24966560304164886,
0.6798279285430908,
0.39138561487197876,
-0.8730710744857788,
0.5876946449279785,
-0.0050050015561282635,
0.7807215452194214,
-0.5251244306564331,
-0.006214173045009375,
-0.2100057154893875,
0.38968876004219055,
-0.1373286247253418,
-0.7134826183319092,
0.44961339235305786,
-0.23642098903656006,
0.11450617015361786,
-0.5288994908332825,
0.7038259506225586,
-0.9716752767562866,
-0.28541916608810425,
0.7087616324424744,
0.5752909183502197,
-0.023693792521953583,
0.045619748532772064,
-1.053463101387024,
0.039178043603897095,
-0.047366928309202194,
0.03772342950105667,
0.4103708863258362,
0.6036466956138611,
0.041526563465595245,
0.3486374616622925,
0.4477420151233673,
0.22590234875679016,
0.08347825706005096,
0.24585631489753723,
0.8160259127616882,
-0.7125349640846252,
-0.44162315130233765,
-0.5163629651069641,
0.2510988414287567,
-0.21664516627788544,
-0.19773618876934052,
0.839897096157074,
0.927444577217102,
1.3273210525512695,
0.03332670032978058,
0.4996553957462311,
-0.2708216607570648,
0.600006103515625,
-0.6113741397857666,
0.2473175972700119,
-0.9241527915000916,
0.28481003642082214,
-0.32209476828575134,
-0.924565315246582,
-0.17708967626094818,
0.32669752836227417,
-0.3616439998149872,
-0.10211649537086487,
0.7637504935264587,
0.8365797400474548,
-0.5185325741767883,
-0.15681587159633636,
0.23478567600250244,
-0.020656153559684753,
-0.01630452461540699,
0.6270424127578735,
0.588433027267456,
-0.3378394842147827,
0.8288440704345703,
-0.483096182346344,
0.0799325555562973,
-0.29334840178489685,
-0.6548291444778442,
-0.5618368983268738,
-0.39051881432533264,
-0.021021151915192604,
-0.18928615748882294,
0.2140253633260727,
0.8011226058006287,
0.6085923910140991,
-0.7371883392333984,
-0.4232715964317322,
-0.11141175776720047,
0.07690456509590149,
-0.43770021200180054,
-0.3178352117538452,
0.09817219525575638,
-0.8961046934127808,
-1.0786391496658325,
0.507020890712738,
0.05543597787618637,
-0.12354640662670135,
-0.10161812603473663,
-0.14967718720436096,
-0.5366420745849609,
-0.21171577274799347,
0.740408718585968,
0.11941841244697571,
-0.5869612693786621,
-0.251564621925354,
0.1334894895553589,
-0.5288253426551819,
-0.025306692346930504,
1.0882935523986816,
-0.5062211155891418,
0.3204917013645172,
0.8250799775123596,
1.0742663145065308,
0.5714089274406433,
0.22703464329242706,
0.8191002607345581,
-0.9253420233726501,
0.1769123673439026,
0.24069689214229584,
0.47745823860168457,
0.5342384576797485,
-0.23986023664474487,
0.6015428304672241,
0.3236742615699768,
-0.3994777798652649,
-0.552943229675293,
0.21166320145130157,
-1.1470896005630493,
-0.4481176435947418,
1.125922441482544,
-0.21510078012943268,
-0.06567069888114929,
-0.02658766321837902,
-0.2176417112350464,
0.14294397830963135,
-0.08763828128576279,
0.5034753084182739,
0.4818708598613739,
-0.052783410996198654,
-0.28921061754226685,
-0.35948896408081055,
0.3614122271537781,
0.925324559211731,
-0.6009290218353271,
-0.0888114869594574,
0.5365875959396362,
0.1345442235469818,
0.296756386756897,
0.3934226632118225,
-0.3390735387802124,
0.2148079127073288,
-0.14519935846328735,
-0.014074145816266537,
0.315471887588501,
-0.20511727035045624,
-0.23804408311843872,
0.21942628920078278,
-0.3017873167991638,
0.039088524878025055
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16804v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16804v1
|
TEI2GO: A Multilingual Approach for Fast Temporal Expression Identification
| 2024-03-25T14:23:03 | 2024-03-25T14:23:03 |
Hugo Sousa, Ricardo Campos, Alípio Jorge
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Temporal expression identification is crucial for understanding texts written
in natural language. Although highly effective systems such as HeidelTime
exist, their limited runtime performance hampers adoption in large-scale
applications and production environments. In this paper, we introduce the
TEI2GO models, matching HeidelTime's effectiveness but with significantly
improved runtime, supporting six languages, and achieving state-of-the-art
results in four of them. To train the TEI2GO models, we used a combination of
manually annotated reference corpus and developed ``Professor HeidelTime'', a
comprehensive weakly labeled corpus of news texts annotated with HeidelTime.
This corpus comprises a total of $138,069$ documents (over six languages) with
$1,050,921$ temporal expressions, the largest open-source annotated dataset for
temporal expression identification to date. By describing how the models were
produced, we aim to encourage the research community to further explore,
refine, and extend the set of models to additional languages and domains. Code,
annotations, and models are openly available for community exploration and use.
The models are conveniently on HuggingFace for seamless integration and
application.
|
[
0.1762259304523468,
-0.6455659866333008,
0.5568296313285828,
0.4196287989616394,
-0.18297526240348816,
0.362474262714386,
-0.3756263554096222,
-0.9050970077514648,
-0.11065582185983658,
0.03978251293301582,
-0.34809476137161255,
-0.32313910126686096,
-0.7857306003570557,
-0.10925304144620895,
-0.44390782713890076,
0.7543337345123291,
-0.10809975862503052,
-0.03774486109614372,
0.054005421698093414,
-0.33453962206840515,
0.16810768842697144,
-0.17372064292430878,
-0.5225077867507935,
-0.5625420212745667,
0.6709746718406677,
0.12366091459989548,
0.3656903803348541,
0.5356549620628357,
0.14723648130893707,
0.24529294669628143,
-0.2563938498497009,
0.03037072718143463,
-0.2409379780292511,
-0.11922968178987503,
-0.16920404136180878,
-0.11224769055843353,
-0.2138732671737671,
0.23151662945747375,
0.5587395429611206,
0.5803775191307068,
-0.15493673086166382,
0.4184073209762573,
-0.3697706460952759,
0.264817476272583,
-0.6252672076225281,
0.2730863690376282,
-0.3191148638725281,
0.0806519165635109,
-0.6119973659515381,
0.023871542885899544,
-0.26060953736305237,
-0.39995890855789185,
0.1650402843952179,
-0.6795861721038818,
-0.003383262548595667,
-0.1985960453748703,
1.1863231658935547,
-0.06650431454181671,
-0.7869884371757507,
0.024842839688062668,
-0.7261091470718384,
0.4943605959415436,
-0.8962923884391785,
0.49485325813293457,
0.06471095234155655,
0.40622588992118835,
0.1646944284439087,
-0.8751440048217773,
-0.5228524208068848,
-0.03903178870677948,
-0.25445520877838135,
0.20374588668346405,
0.18715038895606995,
-0.4864395260810852,
0.38664233684539795,
0.23515598475933075,
-0.6629515290260315,
0.22754614055156708,
-0.6117648482322693,
-0.20640021562576294,
0.37640637159347534,
-0.06548202782869339,
0.24618986248970032,
-0.18487830460071564,
-0.6975608468055725,
0.2630337178707123,
-0.391293466091156,
-0.02371307834982872,
0.4906466603279114,
0.14784251153469086,
-0.2920922636985779,
0.33115845918655396,
-0.35409510135650635,
0.28980928659439087,
-0.2852939963340759,
-0.19370800256729126,
0.2501778304576874,
-0.05662995204329491,
0.01833416521549225,
-0.08225568383932114,
1.0592613220214844,
0.24686463177204132,
0.3925032913684845,
-0.3703954517841339,
-0.2397059053182602,
0.10355501621961594,
-0.003542534075677395,
-1.0065284967422485,
0.09116944670677185,
0.20948131382465363,
-0.2198144495487213,
-0.18969807028770447,
0.023997189477086067,
-1.119063377380371,
-0.394735187292099,
-0.1234702616930008,
0.31551557779312134,
-0.4561053514480591,
-0.7048228979110718,
-0.24565164744853973,
-0.2367587685585022,
0.07113449275493622,
0.08477049320936203,
-0.5004685521125793,
0.16314806044101715,
0.7406248450279236,
0.9080290794372559,
-0.12769196927547455,
-0.337993860244751,
-0.7345194220542908,
0.29072457551956177,
-0.4685301184654236,
0.5941243171691895,
-0.6236072182655334,
-0.18966759741306305,
0.16093802452087402,
0.062381304800510406,
-0.2251638025045395,
-0.271990031003952,
0.4982181787490845,
-0.9456884860992432,
0.8005769848823547,
0.12682205438613892,
-0.48596686124801636,
-0.1500159204006195,
0.17525945603847504,
-0.9248548150062561,
1.3176119327545166,
0.612852931022644,
-0.608776330947876,
0.09583097696304321,
-0.8754690289497375,
-0.5200451612472534,
0.2845821678638458,
0.20432008802890778,
-0.4391498267650604,
0.33879736065864563,
-0.0511874258518219,
0.015143018215894699,
-0.631298303604126,
0.4871777892112732,
-0.05646171048283577,
-0.05994773283600807,
0.09466125071048737,
-0.2750786244869232,
0.9951445460319519,
0.4801357686519623,
-0.4180474877357483,
-0.031253691762685776,
-0.7152562141418457,
0.11309639364480972,
0.215653657913208,
-0.3067910969257355,
-0.24233324825763702,
-0.08367935568094254,
0.4875517785549164,
0.28339722752571106,
0.4658939242362976,
-0.6822266578674316,
0.08434301614761353,
-0.14103659987449646,
0.5780051946640015,
0.45742958784103394,
-0.03331194072961807,
0.2605268359184265,
0.061521850526332855,
0.4744434654712677,
0.12333033978939056,
0.34463655948638916,
-0.3775905966758728,
-0.4951893389225006,
-0.2524091303348541,
-0.09477957338094711,
0.5232403874397278,
0.7951947450637817,
-0.6590099334716797,
-0.15973860025405884,
-0.5043259859085083,
-0.5043501853942871,
-0.3884982168674469,
0.0746530294418335,
0.5595317482948303,
0.7350330948829651,
0.3597690761089325,
0.05117975175380707,
-0.18842574954032898,
-0.9591387510299683,
-0.5177778601646423,
-0.2884853184223175,
-0.022715600207448006,
0.199874147772789,
0.33048000931739807,
-0.3604496717453003,
0.7271985411643982,
-0.22299276292324066,
-0.006128714419901371,
0.03816547617316246,
0.5932045578956604,
0.10256262123584747,
0.1755155622959137,
0.784392774105072,
-0.824572741985321,
-0.5119129419326782,
0.19610467553138733,
-0.6540970802307129,
-0.5821422338485718,
-0.10930252075195312,
-0.1276450902223587,
0.5146995186805725,
0.45929792523384094,
-0.3671897351741791,
0.3341296315193176,
0.6402536034584045,
-0.6372271776199341,
0.09216146171092987,
0.016631856560707092,
0.2055262178182602,
-1.1903938055038452,
0.3026418685913086,
0.27687641978263855,
-0.4751144349575043,
-0.5776508450508118,
0.45491787791252136,
0.3445477783679962,
-0.22227667272090912,
-0.6916134357452393,
1.0497328042984009,
-0.5345593094825745,
-0.041672855615615845,
-0.04573693126440048,
0.015282157808542252,
0.05975934490561485,
0.42281123995780945,
0.06983830034732819,
0.8042601943016052,
0.11483444273471832,
-0.30281755328178406,
0.1598811149597168,
-0.08831166476011276,
-0.4650648832321167,
0.4120051860809326,
-0.7948821783065796,
0.26541441679000854,
-0.033475637435913086,
-0.11882752180099487,
-0.6329724192619324,
-0.45429205894470215,
0.14261212944984436,
-0.46796563267707825,
0.4108498692512512,
-0.4477737843990326,
-0.5977261066436768,
-0.14438779652118683,
-0.1919918656349182,
0.3430970013141632,
0.48706474900245667,
-0.7636051774024963,
1.1882376670837402,
0.25038066506385803,
-0.051862336695194244,
-0.44584164023399353,
-0.49706509709358215,
0.34037214517593384,
-0.3549309968948364,
-0.44769129157066345,
0.6837579011917114,
0.040249597281217575,
-0.2421506643295288,
0.003919521812349558,
-0.020257962867617607,
-0.2866680324077606,
0.2968728244304657,
-0.007088415790349245,
0.25669655203819275,
-0.09549881517887115,
0.13880391418933868,
0.09781696647405624,
-0.3160152733325958,
-0.23657582700252533,
-0.21350416541099548,
0.40004420280456543,
-0.0104207843542099,
0.12100957334041595,
-0.5468807220458984,
0.830690860748291,
0.7314509153366089,
-0.5052998661994934,
0.4835156202316284,
1.3482908010482788,
-0.7336820960044861,
0.3014533519744873,
-0.46093830466270447,
0.07741009443998337,
-0.4256042242050171,
0.19310425221920013,
-0.34767550230026245,
-0.6821475625038147,
0.3228487968444824,
-0.29356417059898376,
0.29559051990509033,
0.6860692501068115,
0.5637246370315552,
-0.028905723243951797,
0.667970597743988,
0.5557659268379211,
0.025306392461061478,
0.7793127298355103,
0.017892012372612953,
0.0031786637846380472,
-0.7726877927780151,
-0.3509410321712494,
-0.5360177755355835,
-0.3254315257072449,
-0.6193680167198181,
-0.2685619592666626,
0.5387119650840759,
0.08712565898895264,
-0.2968457341194153,
0.24173083901405334,
-0.22001706063747406,
0.38334593176841736,
0.7203809022903442,
0.00938198808580637,
0.04894091188907623,
-0.0045114438980817795,
0.16454310715198517,
0.005611659027636051,
-0.41835886240005493,
-0.5407577157020569,
0.6245193481445312,
0.31916651129722595,
0.45257434248924255,
0.6902362704277039,
0.45918822288513184,
0.3355697691440582,
0.529612123966217,
-0.5333210229873657,
0.341478556394577,
-0.30771464109420776,
-0.8135746121406555,
0.06901944428682327,
-0.44506844878196716,
-0.7123232483863831,
-0.21577274799346924,
-0.21954300999641418,
-1.1543536186218262,
-0.08450157940387726,
-0.06462478637695312,
-0.3940252363681793,
0.050969261676073074,
-1.0510146617889404,
1.0366100072860718,
-0.5025386214256287,
-0.7537988424301147,
-0.17970037460327148,
-0.6214345693588257,
0.072136290371418,
0.07300107926130295,
0.24712151288986206,
-0.456567645072937,
-0.31282559037208557,
0.923380434513092,
-0.26478809118270874,
0.8635983467102051,
-0.34188932180404663,
-0.008801320567727089,
0.3308899700641632,
0.06479834020137787,
0.42771434783935547,
0.3815595507621765,
-0.17649605870246887,
0.5923585891723633,
0.29312020540237427,
-0.6289606690406799,
-0.29965490102767944,
0.9228823781013489,
-0.7988163232803345,
-0.37512126564979553,
-0.4291296601295471,
-0.25341013073921204,
-0.12779870629310608,
0.3781589865684509,
0.31589755415916443,
0.6526238918304443,
-0.03236578404903412,
-0.1579214483499527,
0.34144869446754456,
-0.17178238928318024,
0.8749465942382812,
0.6115780472755432,
-0.15810617804527283,
-0.48327988386154175,
0.7236897945404053,
-0.01823410391807556,
0.11226111650466919,
0.540324330329895,
0.49859800934791565,
-0.36883366107940674,
-0.046077363193035126,
-0.6976451277732849,
0.28118661046028137,
-0.35755598545074463,
-0.04643190652132034,
-0.819718599319458,
0.15716592967510223,
-0.5676730275154114,
0.28409069776535034,
-0.3189451992511749,
-0.7783220410346985,
-0.3028487265110016,
0.06438641995191574,
0.622523307800293,
0.37732112407684326,
0.17762239277362823,
0.6279888153076172,
-1.0348597764968872,
0.5071414113044739,
0.1519130915403366,
0.5740259885787964,
-0.5659447908401489,
-0.41918841004371643,
-0.37857645750045776,
-0.3086465895175934,
0.015268390066921711,
-1.2997937202453613,
0.38649672269821167,
0.5628670454025269,
0.3282051980495453,
0.22518736124038696,
-0.11464685201644897,
0.4194641411304474,
-0.6435753107070923,
0.882235586643219,
-0.1015118882060051,
-1.0594903230667114,
0.37660080194473267,
-0.3006109595298767,
0.3567381501197815,
0.24578355252742767,
0.6117362976074219,
-0.7624626755714417,
0.12080179154872894,
-0.5385512113571167,
-1.0352582931518555,
0.6499111652374268,
-0.15754801034927368,
0.1264570653438568,
-0.06007417291402817,
0.6196688413619995,
0.20570224523544312,
0.10436391830444336,
-0.48084545135498047,
0.2317456752061844,
-0.14693620800971985,
-0.4583737254142761,
0.1632131189107895,
-0.50342857837677,
-0.20194457471370697,
0.2025439739227295,
0.7650508284568787,
-0.5049622058868408,
0.5447415709495544,
-0.0697908028960228,
-0.3379073441028595,
-0.18153266608715057,
0.20338758826255798,
0.43388810753822327,
0.46116217970848083,
-0.058209411799907684,
-0.019672941416502,
-0.17280113697052002,
-0.024508312344551086,
-0.2619147300720215,
0.5177740454673767,
-0.18595623970031738,
0.24001799523830414,
0.5581836104393005,
0.8452891707420349,
-0.04988906905055046,
-0.7235382199287415,
0.4319832921028137,
-0.08029678463935852,
0.14582037925720215,
-0.6174187064170837,
-0.05662018060684204,
0.22031059861183167,
0.6603211760520935,
0.33547139167785645,
-0.3658636808395386,
0.26280978322029114,
-0.5799334645271301,
-0.1244162917137146,
0.10271267592906952,
-0.3080959618091583,
-0.5714375376701355,
1.0037014484405518,
0.17824748158454895,
-0.647122323513031,
0.7827414274215698,
-0.23534061014652252,
-0.8480249047279358,
0.640235424041748,
0.31565913558006287,
1.0654196739196777,
-0.3171534538269043,
0.011689308099448681,
0.585468053817749,
0.21814009547233582,
-0.014207271859049797,
0.46349039673805237,
0.06337471306324005,
-0.46059471368789673,
-0.4520508944988251,
-0.40720877051353455,
-0.24145178496837616,
-0.01496680174022913,
-0.5766894817352295,
0.28477832674980164,
-0.3560201823711395,
-0.41559749841690063,
0.2435711771249771,
-0.0177131500095129,
-0.7314170002937317,
0.07393984496593475,
0.3430158197879791,
1.0165855884552002,
-1.028816819190979,
0.8335840702056885,
0.8670421838760376,
-0.30760613083839417,
-0.23454757034778595,
0.12472297251224518,
0.23188699781894684,
-0.461424857378006,
0.5303001403808594,
0.3237878978252411,
0.1168263629078865,
-0.001823347294703126,
-0.25757625699043274,
-0.634739100933075,
1.136041522026062,
0.19126032292842865,
-0.7236977815628052,
-0.23835298418998718,
-0.20923781394958496,
0.6031304001808167,
-0.15026035904884338,
0.6131740212440491,
0.450862318277359,
0.628626823425293,
-0.15239675343036652,
-0.8786120414733887,
-0.13683180510997772,
-0.5101441740989685,
0.04400279000401497,
0.5066063404083252,
-0.904026448726654,
0.6969085931777954,
-0.33605799078941345,
-0.5180419087409973,
0.25343888998031616,
0.6281248927116394,
-0.29207074642181396,
0.5753157734870911,
0.491208553314209,
0.38913974165916443,
0.7040848731994629,
-0.46178144216537476,
1.1235430240631104,
-0.6212367415428162,
0.4327268600463867,
1.1560815572738647,
-0.29543590545654297,
0.7174996733665466,
0.4398218095302582,
0.13324615359306335,
0.5215725302696228,
0.634270191192627,
0.3367794454097748,
0.3414599299430847,
-0.29939985275268555,
-0.4370211064815521,
-0.23327088356018066,
-0.33497828245162964,
-0.03476712852716446,
0.19921930134296417,
0.5657975673675537,
-0.13364943861961365,
-0.23239080607891083,
-0.0706864669919014,
0.36925947666168213,
0.11740393936634064,
0.25390496850013733,
0.7165392637252808,
-0.2308688461780548,
-0.5043002367019653,
0.2431515008211136,
0.3520115911960602,
0.4935738444328308,
-0.5960214734077454,
0.10514704138040543,
-0.350158154964447,
0.15057528018951416,
-0.056447599083185196,
-0.656872034072876,
0.37511298060417175,
0.2631579041481018,
-0.0098020751029253,
-0.19728489220142365,
0.3872266709804535,
-0.6535601019859314,
-0.5204039216041565,
0.4057849049568176,
0.5708431005477905,
-0.1217484325170517,
0.15691128373146057,
-0.6095295548439026,
0.07119545340538025,
-0.31336528062820435,
-0.6341151595115662,
-0.024214092642068863,
0.5756233930587769,
-0.7923446297645569,
0.22081218659877777,
0.34531110525131226,
-0.1602793186903,
-0.015938255935907364,
0.2647441625595093,
0.5032849311828613,
-0.7523753643035889,
-0.3063127100467682,
-0.6558741331100464,
0.4838305115699768,
-0.3176736831665039,
-0.5286172032356262,
0.10074404627084732,
0.6042409539222717,
0.5834869146347046,
0.15714073181152344,
0.6881591081619263,
-0.3170304000377655,
0.7374077439308167,
-0.5647321343421936,
0.4414707124233246,
-0.6991561651229858,
0.16648516058921814,
0.07795291393995285,
-0.5707770586013794,
-0.20534557104110718,
0.11257068812847137,
-0.11862336099147797,
0.18957848846912384,
0.63264399766922,
0.5082536935806274,
-0.18039067089557648,
-0.2942947745323181,
0.02287217229604721,
0.21288129687309265,
0.7200498580932617,
0.7898052334785461,
0.6580635905265808,
-0.588496208190918,
0.2982492446899414,
-0.4869210124015808,
-0.35291823744773865,
-0.2785698175430298,
-1.25972318649292,
-0.8160711526870728,
-0.61714768409729,
-0.6736591458320618,
-0.3462127447128296,
0.30959227681159973,
1.165826678276062,
0.6931637525558472,
-0.48872387409210205,
0.03558832034468651,
0.5519070029258728,
-0.2037528157234192,
-0.31119289994239807,
-0.22337974607944489,
0.34010881185531616,
0.0506243035197258,
-1.2183464765548706,
0.4347884953022003,
0.18048864603042603,
-0.1255957931280136,
0.014959601685404778,
0.07041410356760025,
-0.26168838143348694,
0.1423356682062149,
0.6548126339912415,
0.493145614862442,
-0.5265804529190063,
-0.345141738653183,
0.20415425300598145,
-0.13674549758434296,
-0.12586359679698944,
0.8682766556739807,
-0.8780778050422668,
0.4210827052593231,
0.6438168287277222,
0.7715395092964172,
0.6087504029273987,
-0.11659538745880127,
0.2900601923465729,
-0.8180676698684692,
0.2727910876274109,
0.044515855610370636,
0.5334654450416565,
0.5393145084381104,
-0.3477576673030853,
0.9196507334709167,
0.5836751461029053,
-0.02372130937874317,
-0.5049214363098145,
0.31506094336509705,
-0.9228707551956177,
-0.3100351095199585,
1.304260015487671,
-0.123345285654068,
-0.45998650789260864,
0.2953917682170868,
0.025925898924469948,
0.38372018933296204,
-0.5327939987182617,
0.7886977195739746,
0.5302590131759644,
0.30595916509628296,
-0.3442939817905426,
-0.7355939149856567,
0.004321245476603508,
0.08824730664491653,
-0.9053716063499451,
-0.13347260653972626,
0.6447598934173584,
0.32247862219810486,
0.2955557703971863,
0.4645198583602905,
-0.4360102117061615,
0.39857885241508484,
-0.3693954348564148,
0.15764698386192322,
-0.2797408998012543,
-0.4633592665195465,
-0.09513454884290695,
0.1759064942598343,
-0.0259065181016922,
0.04263368621468544
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16792v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16792v3
|
Iterative Refinement of Project-Level Code Context for Precise Code Generation with Compiler Feedback
| 2024-03-25T14:07:27 | 2024-06-11T02:38:20 |
Zhangqian Bi, Yao Wan, Zheng Wang, Hongyu Zhang, Batu Guan, Fangxin Lu, Zili Zhang, Yulei Sui, Hai Jin, Xuanhua Shi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SE
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown remarkable progress in automated code
generation. Yet, LLM-generated code may contain errors in API usage, class,
data structure, or missing project-specific information. As much of this
project-specific context cannot fit into the prompts of LLMs, we must find ways
to allow the model to explore the project-level code context. We present
CoCoGen, a new code generation approach that uses compiler feedback to improve
the LLM-generated code. CoCoGen first leverages static analysis to identify
mismatches between the generated code and the project's context. It then
iteratively aligns and fixes the identified errors using information extracted
from the code repository. We integrate CoCoGen with two representative LLMs,
i.e., GPT-3.5-Turbo and Code Llama (13B), and apply it to Python code
generation. Experimental results show that CoCoGen significantly improves the
vanilla LLMs by over 80% in generating code dependent on the project context
and consistently outperforms the existing retrieval-based code generation
baselines.
|
[
-0.3132893741130829,
-0.4848440885543823,
0.31550833582878113,
0.522198498249054,
-0.14498166739940643,
0.29832783341407776,
-0.6144454479217529,
-0.30944958329200745,
-0.008000521920621395,
0.4919503927230835,
-0.4656509757041931,
-0.8036473989486694,
-0.24140679836273193,
0.3023695945739746,
-0.4072088897228241,
0.7899833917617798,
-0.34090757369995117,
-0.21081197261810303,
-0.45968323945999146,
0.24622386693954468,
-0.5891618132591248,
-0.49471840262413025,
-0.1299269199371338,
-0.20971661806106567,
0.3176218569278717,
0.8096175193786621,
0.02480158396065235,
0.4616634249687195,
0.3097471594810486,
0.26655083894729614,
0.02917754091322422,
0.25729426741600037,
-0.5908230543136597,
0.1474325805902481,
0.05381115898489952,
-0.3050778806209564,
-0.18870100378990173,
-0.32208019495010376,
0.4506271779537201,
0.4244880676269531,
-0.15079805254936218,
0.32982438802719116,
0.30570822954177856,
0.5002214312553406,
-0.7371946573257446,
0.437229722738266,
-0.6681954860687256,
-0.015403962694108486,
-0.04683050513267517,
-0.6569597721099854,
-0.45728129148483276,
-0.5032318234443665,
-0.10205020010471344,
-0.30020755529403687,
0.5400306582450867,
-0.09978705644607544,
0.6115394234657288,
0.38903379440307617,
-0.03257663547992706,
-0.4014178216457367,
-0.5603486895561218,
0.8757196664810181,
-0.8412603735923767,
0.013944044709205627,
-0.033099714666604996,
0.015996765345335007,
-0.3616617023944855,
-0.9310379028320312,
-0.3435549736022949,
-0.6772925853729248,
-0.013582090847194195,
-0.1647854894399643,
0.06782069057226181,
-0.08672116696834564,
0.2947692275047302,
0.4197625517845154,
-0.43563342094421387,
-0.04171881079673767,
-0.6317225694656372,
-0.23335051536560059,
0.607935905456543,
0.12375420331954956,
0.13090933859348297,
-0.12303956598043442,
-0.16580012440681458,
0.09383531659841537,
-1.1396164894104004,
-0.15450918674468994,
0.30655136704444885,
0.36273643374443054,
0.1155906692147255,
0.538948655128479,
-0.29884597659111023,
0.7642252445220947,
0.01837398111820221,
0.10307753086090088,
0.30594322085380554,
-0.3083462715148926,
-0.05848135054111481,
0.40181851387023926,
0.5605993270874023,
0.468156099319458,
0.1736861765384674,
-0.030057379975914955,
-0.19503480195999146,
0.2982788383960724,
0.46962669491767883,
-0.9231593608856201,
-0.2562250792980194,
0.4561990797519684,
-0.1958467662334442,
-0.6236231923103333,
0.04520362988114357,
-0.47058621048927307,
-0.2644808888435364,
-0.3191252648830414,
-0.298047810792923,
-0.09605073183774948,
-0.1516648828983307,
0.01750051975250244,
-0.05808427184820175,
0.2562362253665924,
0.3497529625892639,
-0.6191350221633911,
-0.04178018122911453,
0.6653252840042114,
0.6736315488815308,
-0.06425989419221878,
-0.10109531134366989,
-0.6174423098564148,
0.10167636722326279,
-0.5693501830101013,
0.7800957560539246,
-0.5276670455932617,
-0.4587080478668213,
0.21854211390018463,
-0.29724177718162537,
0.25421905517578125,
-0.8568477034568787,
0.13708548247814178,
-0.2877751886844635,
-0.027166521176695824,
-0.27123838663101196,
-0.4148114323616028,
0.23663541674613953,
0.3698884844779968,
-0.3262486755847931,
1.0847066640853882,
0.2993803322315216,
-0.7808130383491516,
0.5282648801803589,
-0.5414544939994812,
-0.3978919982910156,
0.13076257705688477,
-0.39966532588005066,
-0.4189223051071167,
0.3793520927429199,
0.14738331735134125,
0.0990118458867073,
-0.44100111722946167,
0.4534401595592499,
-0.23544101417064667,
-0.5281729102134705,
0.11977662146091461,
-0.07537247985601425,
0.4974263906478882,
0.42180100083351135,
-0.4769272804260254,
0.3755427300930023,
-0.8335080146789551,
0.3207143545150757,
-0.05970210209488869,
-0.679462730884552,
0.2381618320941925,
0.13985194265842438,
0.05561454966664314,
0.17707133293151855,
0.2873725891113281,
-0.4696749150753021,
0.5261753797531128,
-0.258432000875473,
0.5659942626953125,
0.5952414870262146,
0.02340180054306984,
0.22425119578838348,
-0.1394672393798828,
0.4839637279510498,
-0.12364184111356735,
-0.06466323137283325,
-0.3351868689060211,
-0.3930021822452545,
-0.8587753176689148,
-0.10002178698778152,
0.25435173511505127,
0.3005123436450958,
-0.5785341858863831,
0.36521056294441223,
-0.05278845876455307,
-0.13963983952999115,
-0.11390013992786407,
0.5178918838500977,
0.30119073390960693,
0.4558289349079132,
0.12201691418886185,
-0.5588825345039368,
-0.8048386573791504,
-0.665662944316864,
0.024550355970859528,
-0.31824150681495667,
0.009854467585682869,
0.2718208432197571,
0.34254780411720276,
-0.6074488759040833,
1.2182183265686035,
-0.5672197937965393,
0.1607537716627121,
-0.1984739452600479,
0.23544685542583466,
0.14726707339286804,
0.6789576411247253,
0.39600682258605957,
-0.4824252128601074,
-0.28747713565826416,
0.018088867887854576,
-0.3504873216152191,
-0.6224954128265381,
0.011792747303843498,
-0.04321455582976341,
0.07980475574731827,
0.7817683219909668,
-0.1455831229686737,
0.2580493092536926,
0.4761553108692169,
-0.0032516815699636936,
0.6585800647735596,
-0.17627651989459991,
-0.05607426539063454,
-0.9965008497238159,
0.4456295073032379,
-0.2864713966846466,
-0.18030448257923126,
-0.41604191064834595,
0.42838960886001587,
0.25097525119781494,
-0.13253578543663025,
-0.4434615969657898,
0.3435063362121582,
-0.5035302042961121,
-0.07285115867853165,
-0.47018224000930786,
0.043994929641485214,
-0.04725638031959534,
0.30284780263900757,
0.09772065281867981,
0.8496336936950684,
0.5774492621421814,
-0.6555790305137634,
0.44730183482170105,
-0.14911893010139465,
-0.43699321150779724,
0.16095824539661407,
-0.5532307028770447,
0.4078886806964874,
0.09081745147705078,
0.3745869994163513,
-0.891582727432251,
-0.480142742395401,
0.12425221502780914,
-0.3468715250492096,
0.3812178671360016,
-0.14087817072868347,
-0.5973951816558838,
-0.5750056505203247,
-0.39697450399398804,
0.4429503083229065,
0.4619552791118622,
-0.5847921371459961,
0.21275459229946136,
-0.027310261502861977,
-0.14134733378887177,
-0.6731427311897278,
-0.6212034225463867,
0.2512799799442291,
0.0356639139354229,
-0.5719215869903564,
0.24366247653961182,
-0.26883795857429504,
-0.27215316891670227,
-0.15636953711509705,
-0.3748272657394409,
-0.06608004122972488,
0.09642883390188217,
0.23374702036380768,
0.20063644647598267,
-0.24256078898906708,
-0.14842820167541504,
0.019269052892923355,
-0.10460729151964188,
-0.02385982871055603,
-0.5161661505699158,
0.8022352457046509,
-0.2711063325405121,
-0.318151593208313,
-0.10318000614643097,
0.11637275665998459,
0.4711854159832001,
-0.40056100487709045,
0.2671182453632355,
0.31795382499694824,
-0.23004472255706787,
-0.5413280129432678,
-0.5534858107566833,
0.044274091720581055,
-0.4790547788143158,
0.2746688425540924,
-0.26516222953796387,
-0.9653082489967346,
0.5094163417816162,
-0.4093913733959198,
0.2180934101343155,
0.25566011667251587,
0.9326636791229248,
0.3566558361053467,
0.978969395160675,
0.8762632012367249,
-0.08807304501533508,
0.4425986409187317,
-0.4694087505340576,
0.22796282172203064,
-0.6985025405883789,
-0.2662392556667328,
-0.6934190392494202,
0.044129714369773865,
-0.5492280721664429,
-0.5697901844978333,
0.039912622421979904,
0.3735557198524475,
-0.03591563180088997,
0.6510440707206726,
-0.6790115833282471,
0.5952280163764954,
0.5167173743247986,
-0.11404547095298767,
0.19246628880500793,
0.016763022169470787,
-0.3304872214794159,
0.43386346101760864,
-0.8281030058860779,
-0.4820203185081482,
0.9299473166465759,
0.13016051054000854,
0.8600410223007202,
-0.0985506922006607,
1.0163379907608032,
0.09878475964069366,
0.8589535355567932,
-0.5095409750938416,
0.3136979043483734,
0.20309679210186005,
-0.31787222623825073,
0.2131543755531311,
-0.6380527019500732,
-0.6161474585533142,
-0.13406461477279663,
0.2484590709209442,
-0.7384553551673889,
0.2254607230424881,
0.4377240538597107,
-0.3518613278865814,
-0.1743880659341812,
-0.5780730843544006,
0.7318491339683533,
-0.003716162871569395,
-0.515072226524353,
-0.18146084249019623,
-0.3111330270767212,
0.3812435269355774,
-0.22280706465244293,
0.04023247957229614,
-0.004984879866242409,
0.10585552453994751,
0.1212000921368599,
-0.7421483397483826,
0.7741002440452576,
-0.044194385409355164,
-0.6193273663520813,
0.7675925493240356,
0.17412827908992767,
0.5108017921447754,
0.33703672885894775,
-0.11928078532218933,
-0.01152116246521473,
-0.28505629301071167,
-0.3788051903247833,
-0.4119550883769989,
1.0714948177337646,
-0.4038035571575165,
-0.673291027545929,
-0.1917889416217804,
-0.6990334391593933,
-0.1941429078578949,
0.21901394426822662,
0.5623377561569214,
0.5052451491355896,
-0.029702918604016304,
0.14978744089603424,
0.36553773283958435,
-0.5045788884162903,
0.31935954093933105,
0.3467191755771637,
-0.31514182686805725,
-0.2911537289619446,
0.887090802192688,
-0.3710312247276306,
0.09075751900672913,
0.10367538779973984,
0.05046582967042923,
-0.1596072018146515,
-0.4340464770793915,
-0.5216208100318909,
0.023925570771098137,
-0.6660470366477966,
-0.3923886716365814,
-0.13579358160495758,
-0.15629349648952484,
-0.4302203953266144,
-0.46521785855293274,
-0.4236626625061035,
-0.2721312344074249,
-0.28222277760505676,
0.04800483211874962,
-0.019103772938251495,
0.8221082091331482,
0.12545882165431976,
0.09187361598014832,
-0.7792273163795471,
0.018509745597839355,
0.07033859938383102,
0.44292330741882324,
-0.26062488555908203,
-0.07098297774791718,
-0.26840588450431824,
-0.14274592697620392,
-0.42016592621803284,
-0.6846697926521301,
0.28849974274635315,
0.005496741272509098,
0.3458747863769531,
0.29120373725891113,
0.03208278864622116,
0.7965733408927917,
-0.4889306426048279,
0.9465022087097168,
0.16732271015644073,
-1.1061497926712036,
0.6636877655982971,
-0.17517346143722534,
0.494042307138443,
0.46087419986724854,
-0.23241212964057922,
-0.42626872658729553,
-0.8022949695587158,
-0.4343157708644867,
-0.9913062453269958,
0.6099366545677185,
0.3575271964073181,
0.1890038698911667,
-0.18435896933078766,
0.6114492416381836,
-0.094792440533638,
0.4480346441268921,
-0.6472551226615906,
0.07254138588905334,
-0.18095144629478455,
-0.19839482009410858,
0.015022999607026577,
-0.1888296753168106,
-0.1628248244524002,
-0.05759050324559212,
0.34850645065307617,
-0.44573408365249634,
0.3732069432735443,
0.1713840365409851,
-0.27439188957214355,
-0.4645068943500519,
0.21671012043952942,
0.8419469594955444,
1.1019213199615479,
-0.24589233100414276,
0.14707830548286438,
0.14492666721343994,
-0.1689039170742035,
0.0833575427532196,
-0.18219520151615143,
-0.06049361824989319,
-0.024533860385417938,
0.4968146085739136,
0.4238421320915222,
-0.0176484826952219,
-0.9991542100906372,
0.5526370406150818,
-0.009031266905367374,
-0.16979660093784332,
-0.25584036111831665,
0.3487798571586609,
-0.13686521351337433,
0.15965576469898224,
0.24556243419647217,
0.0978250801563263,
0.0812670961022377,
-0.5486050844192505,
0.40991899371147156,
0.2689475417137146,
-0.3116992115974426,
-0.01420644298195839,
0.6471790075302124,
0.3509213328361511,
-0.019617261365056038,
0.7108563780784607,
-0.1443217396736145,
-0.7144787311553955,
0.8628023266792297,
0.7712069153785706,
1.0228679180145264,
0.011808379553258419,
0.07396513968706131,
0.53191739320755,
0.23120523989200592,
-0.1440262496471405,
0.3075702488422394,
-0.448131799697876,
-0.39704397320747375,
-0.790462076663971,
-0.6137419939041138,
-0.3644472360610962,
-0.05055323988199234,
-0.4724532961845398,
0.512986421585083,
-0.7344695925712585,
0.028862662613391876,
-0.6533136963844299,
-0.057073477655649185,
-0.4131586253643036,
0.09982441365718842,
0.31048348546028137,
1.029300570487976,
-0.5320471525192261,
0.8205171227455139,
0.6125535368919373,
-0.28464919328689575,
-0.7785465121269226,
0.31951820850372314,
-0.06447377055883408,
-0.6319282650947571,
0.8049625754356384,
0.44848769903182983,
-0.1229315772652626,
-0.14098674058914185,
-0.8368309140205383,
-0.7958649396896362,
0.9915443658828735,
0.46911999583244324,
-0.8748325109481812,
0.1494140625,
0.1278826743364334,
0.5931750535964966,
-0.5117170810699463,
0.11663653701543808,
0.46844401955604553,
0.22691307961940765,
0.14038196206092834,
-0.8420061469078064,
0.050313569605350494,
-0.47473469376564026,
0.4730885922908783,
0.09896454960107803,
-0.5586943030357361,
0.6742712259292603,
-0.42532896995544434,
-0.1629868745803833,
0.3770487308502197,
0.5967172980308533,
0.5753746628761292,
0.04910389706492424,
0.20183514058589935,
0.3507062792778015,
0.696181058883667,
-0.1006387248635292,
1.163709044456482,
-0.9131973385810852,
0.6220738291740417,
0.9753535985946655,
-0.30775389075279236,
0.5926593542098999,
0.39359474182128906,
0.278296560049057,
0.5653370022773743,
0.6845578551292419,
-0.04630453884601593,
0.4844306707382202,
0.7826570272445679,
-0.24907736480236053,
0.04148444905877113,
0.06386245787143707,
-0.5629238486289978,
0.11060085892677307,
0.17515869438648224,
-0.3567938804626465,
-0.11433212459087372,
-0.17439119517803192,
0.02126825787127018,
-0.2511696219444275,
-0.21928131580352783,
0.4527758061885834,
0.02197771705687046,
-0.7864762544631958,
0.900473415851593,
0.2208857238292694,
0.4568939208984375,
-0.36482107639312744,
-0.25916948914527893,
-0.5016112327575684,
0.45885035395622253,
-0.4209526777267456,
-0.38931742310523987,
0.2466246336698532,
0.44552862644195557,
-0.030017806217074394,
-0.15230797231197357,
0.6346624493598938,
-0.4409118592739105,
-0.38824835419654846,
0.18907959759235382,
-0.01677991822361946,
-0.10139467567205429,
-0.06482628732919693,
-0.4881823658943176,
0.4613364040851593,
0.19907069206237793,
-0.14377883076667786,
-0.029498793184757233,
0.1931966096162796,
-0.06844498962163925,
0.5526489615440369,
0.637747049331665,
0.10498058050870895,
0.24352550506591797,
0.16924554109573364,
1.1594159603118896,
-0.5323447585105896,
-0.3008041977882385,
-0.6797422170639038,
0.4345485270023346,
-0.0689852386713028,
-0.3089003264904022,
0.6631602048873901,
0.7192574143409729,
1.1031267642974854,
-0.14548861980438232,
0.8683313727378845,
-0.27491798996925354,
-0.05148858204483986,
-0.4260879456996918,
0.31443050503730774,
-0.46066898107528687,
0.8053051233291626,
-0.5185866951942444,
-1.4739899635314941,
-0.5388363003730774,
0.6388533115386963,
-0.14848235249519348,
0.02249961346387863,
0.569085419178009,
1.0567606687545776,
0.06038346886634827,
-0.26722246408462524,
-0.11823038011789322,
0.20020298659801483,
0.6433573365211487,
0.5482580661773682,
1.0706580877304077,
-0.14316628873348236,
0.559296190738678,
-0.2831636071205139,
-0.3336373567581177,
-0.4445532262325287,
-0.9941331148147583,
-0.5873135924339294,
-0.26106569170951843,
-0.5714612603187561,
-0.6039003729820251,
-0.15907835960388184,
0.9688767194747925,
0.6867382526397705,
-0.9259231090545654,
-0.5590575933456421,
-0.6438141465187073,
-0.11606919020414352,
-0.0929303839802742,
-0.268959105014801,
0.11614734679460526,
-0.8839131593704224,
-0.6741785407066345,
0.4565238654613495,
0.37117108702659607,
-0.4524809420108795,
-0.33669692277908325,
-0.33877795934677124,
0.40231019258499146,
0.0737716406583786,
0.5407068133354187,
0.39448174834251404,
-0.6426548957824707,
-0.2936156988143921,
-0.03736255317926407,
-0.22053368389606476,
0.20885200798511505,
1.3972445726394653,
-0.6332824230194092,
0.5855563879013062,
0.6409936547279358,
0.32269492745399475,
0.4810493290424347,
0.04652328044176102,
0.7663971781730652,
-1.087977647781372,
0.125369593501091,
0.11761513352394104,
0.35912689566612244,
0.24124804139137268,
-0.2998446524143219,
0.40301185846328735,
0.17047464847564697,
-0.548848032951355,
-0.9074358940124512,
0.2400921881198883,
-0.7179328203201294,
-0.4342353940010071,
1.2441359758377075,
0.009617391042411327,
-0.2619847059249878,
0.10078079998493195,
-0.5177345275878906,
0.18930761516094208,
-0.23125234246253967,
0.9480976462364197,
0.5431052446365356,
-0.09723307192325592,
-0.1009025126695633,
-0.22119902074337006,
0.4646846055984497,
0.19257852435112,
-0.8195677399635315,
0.340593159198761,
0.7850168943405151,
0.43679168820381165,
0.457528680562973,
0.5996001958847046,
-0.2794632613658905,
0.4512823224067688,
0.03435901552438736,
0.3309382200241089,
-0.04348393902182579,
-0.5308162569999695,
-0.1536986380815506,
0.22655640542507172,
0.3904186189174652,
0.06753724813461304
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16777v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16777v1
|
Can Machine Translation Bridge Multilingual Pretraining and Cross-lingual Transfer Learning?
| 2024-03-25T13:53:04 | 2024-03-25T13:53:04 |
Shaoxiong Ji, Timothee Mickus, Vincent Segonne, Jörg Tiedemann
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multilingual pretraining and fine-tuning have remarkably succeeded in various
natural language processing tasks. Transferring representations from one
language to another is especially crucial for cross-lingual learning. One can
expect machine translation objectives to be well suited to fostering such
capabilities, as they involve the explicit alignment of semantically equivalent
sentences from different languages. This paper investigates the potential
benefits of employing machine translation as a continued training objective to
enhance language representation learning, bridging multilingual pretraining and
cross-lingual applications. We study this question through two lenses: a
quantitative evaluation of the performance of existing models and an analysis
of their latent representations. Our results show that, contrary to
expectations, machine translation as the continued training fails to enhance
cross-lingual representation learning in multiple cross-lingual natural
language understanding tasks. We conclude that explicit sentence-level
alignment in the cross-lingual scenario is detrimental to cross-lingual
transfer pretraining, which has important implications for future cross-lingual
transfer studies. We furthermore provide evidence through similarity measures
and investigation of parameters that this lack of positive influence is due to
output separability -- which we argue is of use for machine translation but
detrimental elsewhere.
|
[
-0.40193283557891846,
-0.4249061346054077,
0.4052363932132721,
0.41591987013816833,
-0.3017289638519287,
0.11087172478437424,
-0.2430380880832672,
-0.5360510349273682,
-0.08377109467983246,
0.41068941354751587,
-0.3758828043937683,
0.052941273897886276,
-0.7820549011230469,
0.4130851626396179,
-0.3078322410583496,
0.8742169737815857,
-0.4877333641052246,
0.3841974139213562,
-0.2465001493692398,
-0.08007173240184784,
-0.8419968485832214,
-0.7030432820320129,
-0.5293786525726318,
-0.5501320958137512,
0.6758870482444763,
0.17298713326454163,
0.5678984522819519,
0.44488391280174255,
0.568524956703186,
0.3079880475997925,
0.5527500510215759,
0.05826328694820404,
-0.43703600764274597,
0.012374366633594036,
-0.10324673354625702,
-0.6635828614234924,
-0.1617344319820404,
0.24326227605342865,
1.1316719055175781,
1.23165762424469,
0.4094037115573883,
-0.25311213731765747,
0.2635689377784729,
0.6534591913223267,
-0.4370168447494507,
-0.009166056290268898,
-0.47221654653549194,
0.35414159297943115,
0.01128285564482212,
-0.12011391669511795,
-0.39026758074760437,
-0.04391581937670708,
0.19221539795398712,
-0.7456062436103821,
-0.13633710145950317,
0.2000277191400528,
0.9595856666564941,
0.38505998253822327,
-0.6418704390525818,
-0.24900376796722412,
-0.54158616065979,
0.8192234039306641,
-0.40477365255355835,
0.7506974339485168,
0.34495434165000916,
0.35901525616645813,
0.2696765661239624,
-0.43758144974708557,
-0.2840835750102997,
-0.18483731150627136,
-0.5607137680053711,
0.29250577092170715,
-0.052577730268239975,
-0.13057319819927216,
0.18338415026664734,
0.27913549542427063,
-0.7839611768722534,
0.16488301753997803,
-0.3073958158493042,
-0.22524985671043396,
0.35492199659347534,
-0.10980569571256638,
0.6501514911651611,
0.04997715353965759,
-0.6351305246353149,
-0.14326883852481842,
-0.5904519557952881,
0.05404234305024147,
0.3863498568534851,
0.3606228530406952,
-0.17093294858932495,
0.4227113425731659,
0.2476292997598648,
0.6206707954406738,
-0.09938641637563705,
0.1177220493555069,
0.33846163749694824,
-0.7113149166107178,
0.004915580619126558,
0.22493404150009155,
0.6450896263122559,
0.23763439059257507,
0.5138658285140991,
-0.4742945730686188,
-0.12415222078561783,
-0.09448913484811783,
0.29576605558395386,
-0.6518571376800537,
0.06317276507616043,
-0.1595468521118164,
-0.3617282211780548,
0.2262573540210724,
0.2719686031341553,
-0.24577704071998596,
0.19229252636432648,
-0.5288785696029663,
0.38554689288139343,
-0.438711941242218,
-0.32386207580566406,
0.1609700471162796,
-0.02270003966987133,
0.21509964764118195,
0.06310892105102539,
-0.9536793828010559,
0.2653774917125702,
0.6601461172103882,
0.71174556016922,
-0.44395047426223755,
-0.8019818663597107,
-0.6177366375923157,
0.20490331947803497,
-0.5479299426078796,
0.3248557150363922,
-0.4557562470436096,
-0.15909866988658905,
-0.06017757207155228,
0.37256115674972534,
-0.5786038637161255,
-0.49702274799346924,
0.11392969638109207,
-0.5478062629699707,
0.44358253479003906,
-0.3535762131214142,
-0.32640311121940613,
-0.23711907863616943,
0.20602653920650482,
-0.7586105465888977,
0.6262611150741577,
-0.023475177586078644,
-0.5337406396865845,
0.43543678522109985,
-0.2850925624370575,
-0.798164427280426,
-0.29610323905944824,
0.0905168280005455,
-0.22267961502075195,
0.04941296949982643,
0.18063005805015564,
0.3717383146286011,
0.007448786403983831,
0.24469639360904694,
-0.17471179366111755,
-0.3721873164176941,
0.18846772611141205,
-0.45417407155036926,
0.731092631816864,
0.209712952375412,
-0.3355218172073364,
-0.0888623371720314,
-0.26408571004867554,
-0.18477122485637665,
-0.14580309391021729,
-0.25700265169143677,
-0.4313250780105591,
-0.6012670993804932,
-0.05355893820524216,
0.4910662770271301,
0.4176320731639862,
-0.2551608979701996,
-0.04803052172064781,
-0.44277673959732056,
0.01984602026641369,
0.47659552097320557,
-0.32329174876213074,
0.967403769493103,
-0.2305835336446762,
0.7648276686668396,
0.21842139959335327,
-0.29360848665237427,
-0.28527408838272095,
-0.19476093351840973,
-0.6264318823814392,
-0.053884051740169525,
0.6078824996948242,
0.7472726106643677,
-0.8161894083023071,
0.19308070838451385,
-0.3454720079898834,
-0.0342862606048584,
-0.6908032298088074,
0.3167327344417572,
0.6160750985145569,
0.4567074477672577,
0.40325894951820374,
-0.5061975717544556,
-0.7194675803184509,
-0.7907548546791077,
-0.4950289726257324,
0.10552600771188736,
0.14434973895549774,
-0.14320386946201324,
0.4442702829837799,
-0.2254449427127838,
0.46778449416160583,
0.09472730755805969,
-0.3356909453868866,
-0.21625076234340668,
0.2453288584947586,
-0.1539289504289627,
0.5822307467460632,
0.7015067934989929,
-0.8848392963409424,
-0.7819124460220337,
0.5671724677085876,
-0.9066377282142639,
-0.16532449424266815,
-0.4244379997253418,
-0.25694188475608826,
0.2986002266407013,
0.45906195044517517,
-0.41987571120262146,
0.0058550299145281315,
0.7920480966567993,
-0.09579196572303772,
0.317975252866745,
-0.3987586498260498,
0.4350200593471527,
-0.9693820476531982,
0.28347715735435486,
-0.36741459369659424,
-0.45568737387657166,
-0.6258811950683594,
-0.12246401607990265,
-0.007959622889757156,
-0.18399862945079803,
-0.34368348121643066,
0.5375533103942871,
-0.5768847465515137,
-0.44294142723083496,
-0.23601219058036804,
0.2922448515892029,
0.10993591696023941,
0.26498618721961975,
0.22167091071605682,
0.782728910446167,
0.3794071078300476,
-0.375206857919693,
0.11792406439781189,
0.06212390214204788,
-0.007364809978753328,
0.5323788523674011,
-0.4738212525844574,
0.12472664564847946,
0.004625329747796059,
0.06550033390522003,
-0.7003718614578247,
0.07074041664600372,
0.45334771275520325,
-0.5904223918914795,
0.5941194891929626,
0.049589041620492935,
-0.20392268896102905,
0.0640178695321083,
0.031534343957901,
0.5113579034805298,
0.299757182598114,
-0.31128689646720886,
0.317373663187027,
0.05823122709989548,
-0.18600033223628998,
-0.6885061860084534,
-0.9547810554504395,
0.0704733282327652,
-0.24697603285312653,
-0.5294175744056702,
0.4168882668018341,
0.22991761565208435,
-0.029413044452667236,
0.1382959485054016,
0.006389537826180458,
0.09680291265249252,
0.06993082165718079,
-0.007485531270503998,
0.1807684451341629,
-0.34528717398643494,
0.09243399649858475,
0.07560659199953079,
-0.4539415240287781,
0.0633954331278801,
-0.5432674288749695,
0.37097108364105225,
-0.1477936953306198,
-0.4979257881641388,
-0.1904364377260208,
0.671515166759491,
0.3247903883457184,
-0.477334201335907,
0.76861172914505,
0.9580737352371216,
-0.3325691819190979,
0.28556695580482483,
-0.1401011198759079,
-0.08163711428642273,
-0.3465685546398163,
0.4954131245613098,
-0.7186900973320007,
-0.9300048351287842,
0.37009352445602417,
-0.10476585477590561,
-0.014773128554224968,
0.43251559138298035,
0.32706770300865173,
-0.3084052503108978,
1.0736346244812012,
0.774790346622467,
-0.11318083107471466,
0.5950131416320801,
0.0560244545340538,
0.2282894104719162,
-0.5743538737297058,
-0.016808928921818733,
-0.4676927924156189,
-0.3497163653373718,
-0.6282899379730225,
-0.22695128619670868,
0.005976904649287462,
0.33852800726890564,
-0.19128800928592682,
0.5789958834648132,
0.036844223737716675,
0.13863499462604523,
0.3962470293045044,
-0.25316035747528076,
0.25786352157592773,
0.23028865456581116,
-0.2571992874145508,
-0.3416658341884613,
-0.7548537254333496,
-0.5024059414863586,
0.7421263456344604,
0.1841210126876831,
0.43965137004852295,
-0.13094274699687958,
0.768177330493927,
0.04660290852189064,
0.1600593626499176,
-0.4285428524017334,
0.15691225230693817,
-0.42977485060691833,
-0.3952887952327728,
-0.3025375008583069,
-0.6991111040115356,
-1.1088130474090576,
0.5243468880653381,
-0.19781872630119324,
-0.34858062863349915,
0.007179017178714275,
0.006863693706691265,
0.15337100625038147,
0.17153207957744598,
-0.8166620135307312,
1.3250149488449097,
-0.7974626421928406,
-0.2487548291683197,
-0.26708000898361206,
-0.9164835810661316,
0.1327207088470459,
-0.390438973903656,
0.23767752945423126,
0.24049554765224457,
-0.014362338930368423,
0.5640122890472412,
-0.07299184054136276,
0.6074853539466858,
-0.09871484339237213,
-0.03472800925374031,
-0.17446373403072357,
-0.1624898463487625,
0.10121850669384003,
-0.2565065026283264,
0.1673557162284851,
0.15828552842140198,
0.10146500915288925,
-0.5339291095733643,
-0.8698909282684326,
0.4057047367095947,
-0.880504310131073,
-0.5510876774787903,
-0.3408755362033844,
-0.7027127146720886,
-0.1989051103591919,
0.5314966440200806,
0.2738887369632721,
-0.01744759827852249,
-0.041045237332582474,
0.1574896275997162,
0.4215247929096222,
-0.0892229750752449,
0.14381176233291626,
0.19518423080444336,
-0.4770725667476654,
-0.3125380575656891,
1.1559944152832031,
0.09063900262117386,
0.5545529127120972,
0.7065590620040894,
-0.07976217567920685,
-0.29958391189575195,
-0.398242324590683,
-0.5740465521812439,
0.26496997475624084,
-0.6227756142616272,
0.24163700640201569,
-0.5760217905044556,
0.026347683742642403,
-0.5590301752090454,
-0.26842936873435974,
-0.1757706254720688,
-0.268515020608902,
-0.27500689029693604,
-0.0650949627161026,
-0.2942119240760803,
0.4666310250759125,
-0.36740413308143616,
0.2306888848543167,
-0.9537158608436584,
0.4183416962623596,
0.20591232180595398,
0.02771024964749813,
-0.3123852610588074,
-0.49351391196250916,
-0.5362658500671387,
0.298321932554245,
-0.029604990035295486,
-0.66432124376297,
0.25796547532081604,
0.2736993730068207,
0.792281985282898,
0.11692897230386734,
-0.2248474508523941,
0.8858787417411804,
-0.5223582983016968,
0.41756585240364075,
0.4398578703403473,
-0.8533065319061279,
0.20605960488319397,
0.061821214854717255,
0.3713737428188324,
0.6012792587280273,
0.8612958788871765,
-0.7873117327690125,
-0.22355350852012634,
-0.11401861160993576,
-0.5230339169502258,
0.6061528921127319,
-0.015520834363996983,
0.15319177508354187,
0.269579142332077,
0.11040250211954117,
0.3292185366153717,
0.16899794340133667,
-0.7283787727355957,
0.06030650436878204,
-0.31692826747894287,
-0.09652639925479889,
-0.49349430203437805,
0.12199404835700989,
0.14170365035533905,
-0.12964129447937012,
0.4885713458061218,
-0.13093039393424988,
0.07749736309051514,
-0.05810876563191414,
-0.687595546245575,
-0.0685185119509697,
0.18263505399227142,
0.33746588230133057,
0.41748741269111633,
0.15034759044647217,
0.1804100126028061,
0.2781440317630768,
-0.2928893268108368,
0.26477086544036865,
0.38748064637184143,
0.0426521934568882,
0.11186069995164871,
0.7035986185073853,
0.882156491279602,
0.4026676416397095,
-0.3291977643966675,
0.23862729966640472,
0.07999341934919357,
-0.1344127357006073,
0.043181102722883224,
-0.33196958899497986,
0.142264261841774,
0.10227575898170471,
0.1343729943037033,
0.17354460060596466,
-0.07717695832252502,
-0.8470776677131653,
0.270282506942749,
0.36763277649879456,
-0.6201796531677246,
-0.3386034369468689,
0.6043657660484314,
-0.0025595168117433786,
-0.09589138627052307,
0.7417238354682922,
0.009277175180613995,
-0.8133106231689453,
0.3774879276752472,
0.6583755016326904,
0.6325238347053528,
-0.30063876509666443,
-0.019206326454877853,
0.15960121154785156,
0.5327632427215576,
0.00716010294854641,
-0.11855221539735794,
-0.21380533277988434,
-0.6779942512512207,
-0.657745897769928,
-0.5060995221138,
-0.08984069526195526,
-0.6078306436538696,
-0.6212852597236633,
0.23564422130584717,
0.2175431251525879,
-0.06194397062063217,
-0.3274987041950226,
-0.026280490681529045,
-0.7389941215515137,
0.18398542702198029,
0.3354080021381378,
0.4330454468727112,
-0.9320507645606995,
0.8386818170547485,
0.8839500546455383,
-0.615784764289856,
-0.6395957469940186,
-0.17062965035438538,
-0.4397822618484497,
-0.592968761920929,
0.9261309504508972,
0.37439078092575073,
-0.348765105009079,
-0.08508528023958206,
0.1288653016090393,
-0.5113215446472168,
0.8303194642066956,
0.813104510307312,
-0.5325965285301208,
-0.3387126624584198,
0.7302589416503906,
0.4227607250213623,
-0.6019474864006042,
0.0378168448805809,
0.467599093914032,
0.5711252093315125,
-0.12914837896823883,
-1.0852454900741577,
0.013267716392874718,
-0.18664534389972687,
0.05519840493798256,
0.08191485702991486,
-0.19593776762485504,
0.7287034392356873,
-0.03778476640582085,
-0.3343243896961212,
-0.1627090722322464,
0.6092723608016968,
-0.07190413028001785,
0.22709409892559052,
0.47248584032058716,
0.5402295589447021,
0.5435258746147156,
-0.1543763428926468,
0.9603655934333801,
-0.28292256593704224,
0.08322615176439285,
1.050739049911499,
-0.2396830916404724,
0.6766273379325867,
0.6131411790847778,
-0.07235590368509293,
0.3091283440589905,
0.7949309945106506,
0.34009942412376404,
0.5934880971908569,
-0.06406658887863159,
0.056544508785009384,
-0.3833882510662079,
0.0507756844162941,
-0.64180988073349,
0.2763859033584595,
0.16581940650939941,
-0.4402484893798828,
-0.18422742187976837,
0.37492793798446655,
-0.18045830726623535,
0.11866528540849686,
-0.07211670279502869,
0.5997134447097778,
0.48920780420303345,
-0.8913699984550476,
0.6407520771026611,
-0.3207506537437439,
0.6064257025718689,
-0.608894944190979,
-0.1933501958847046,
-0.1308022439479828,
0.0392044261097908,
-0.23631851375102997,
-0.5561927556991577,
0.6245795488357544,
-0.2166278064250946,
-0.10262278467416763,
-0.8730021119117737,
0.7731394171714783,
-0.7106161713600159,
-0.29524725675582886,
0.5979152321815491,
0.7865954637527466,
0.42191416025161743,
0.020976264029741287,
-0.7269145250320435,
0.030181052163243294,
0.028449654579162598,
-0.00867969635874033,
0.5002333521842957,
0.5448899269104004,
-0.10741540044546127,
0.3609132468700409,
0.5792116522789001,
0.08576758950948715,
0.31503087282180786,
0.16276520490646362,
0.4565746784210205,
-0.49501532316207886,
-0.3750336170196533,
-0.7203235626220703,
0.3114249110221863,
0.20089484751224518,
-0.24909622967243195,
0.7571693658828735,
0.608594536781311,
1.3103442192077637,
-0.06259169429540634,
0.6830421686172485,
0.16779500246047974,
0.09696681052446365,
-0.6698271632194519,
0.6742547154426575,
-0.7706621885299683,
-0.14806246757507324,
-0.03038124553859234,
-0.9653745889663696,
-0.2855287194252014,
0.5532547235488892,
-0.5958610773086548,
0.07326225936412811,
0.8412240743637085,
0.4366644620895386,
-0.19144198298454285,
-0.1772015541791916,
0.5027185082435608,
-0.28549012541770935,
-0.021441347897052765,
0.7065095901489258,
0.8603432774543762,
-0.3774162232875824,
0.7162624597549438,
-0.11686895042657852,
0.06620347499847412,
-0.05177706480026245,
-0.613850474357605,
-0.8666267395019531,
-0.669049859046936,
-0.14026173949241638,
0.008615742437541485,
0.2861979305744171,
0.504706084728241,
0.6944262981414795,
-0.707709014415741,
-0.3336043357849121,
-0.02104540914297104,
0.13258305191993713,
-0.3119949400424957,
-0.11113451421260834,
0.10040506720542908,
-0.8273276090621948,
-0.8149091005325317,
0.2221784144639969,
0.21776244044303894,
0.1552446186542511,
-0.40421241521835327,
-0.4021812677383423,
-0.3174132704734802,
-0.6212087869644165,
0.664415180683136,
0.25942322611808777,
-0.5071992874145508,
-0.2341039627790451,
0.35600215196609497,
-0.3441382944583893,
0.08374729007482529,
0.8046715259552002,
-0.6418774127960205,
0.5030768513679504,
0.49393364787101746,
1.2446520328521729,
0.6841716766357422,
-0.22298665344715118,
1.0194594860076904,
-0.5199753046035767,
0.09243342280387878,
0.04396868124604225,
0.31297630071640015,
0.49921950697898865,
-0.13971267640590668,
0.36505869030952454,
0.16761046648025513,
-0.292121559381485,
-0.5230737328529358,
0.3010038733482361,
-0.47500571608543396,
-0.1322411596775055,
0.7339372038841248,
-0.468911737203598,
-0.15560118854045868,
-0.1171862781047821,
-0.04749787226319313,
0.6723748445510864,
0.16183272004127502,
0.13827672600746155,
0.9430524706840515,
0.04908804967999458,
-0.315017431974411,
-0.7954957485198975,
0.0460488460958004,
0.824434220790863,
-0.7005518674850464,
-0.2623905837535858,
0.20299896597862244,
0.054747674614191055,
0.28451862931251526,
0.35831618309020996,
-0.17977190017700195,
0.283359169960022,
0.010377109982073307,
-0.11827123165130615,
0.17867594957351685,
-0.4279497563838959,
-0.4528583586215973,
-0.09805808216333389,
0.052820440381765366,
-0.3956153690814972
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16771v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16771v2
|
Synthetic Data Generation and Joint Learning for Robust Code-Mixed Translation
| 2024-03-25T13:50:11 | 2024-04-29T20:45:53 |
Kartik Kartik, Sanjana Soni, Anoop Kunchukuttan, Tanmoy Chakraborty, Md Shad Akhtar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The widespread online communication in a modern multilingual world has
provided opportunities to blend more than one language (aka code-mixed
language) in a single utterance. This has resulted a formidable challenge for
the computational models due to the scarcity of annotated data and presence of
noise. A potential solution to mitigate the data scarcity problem in
low-resource setup is to leverage existing data in resource-rich language
through translation. In this paper, we tackle the problem of code-mixed
(Hinglish and Bengalish) to English machine translation. First, we
synthetically develop HINMIX, a parallel corpus of Hinglish to English, with
~4.2M sentence pairs. Subsequently, we propose RCMT, a robust perturbation
based joint-training model that learns to handle noise in the real-world
code-mixed text by parameter sharing across clean and noisy words. Further, we
show the adaptability of RCMT in a zero-shot setup for Bengalish to English
translation. Our evaluation and comprehensive analyses qualitatively and
quantitatively demonstrate the superiority of RCMT over state-of-the-art
code-mixed and robust translation methods.
|
[
-0.23632922768592834,
-0.8343988060951233,
0.19967232644557953,
0.32879048585891724,
-0.4171387851238251,
0.5159468650817871,
-0.5073500871658325,
-0.5677850842475891,
0.2776395380496979,
0.6330534815788269,
-0.33589059114456177,
-0.4789154827594757,
-0.44144031405448914,
0.366962730884552,
-0.1780298799276352,
1.181437373161316,
-0.2874547243118286,
0.22396035492420197,
0.010843571275472641,
-0.4159851372241974,
-0.6732827425003052,
-0.5814143419265747,
-0.0981145054101944,
-0.05979790538549423,
0.5265275239944458,
0.428920716047287,
0.7768293619155884,
0.814541220664978,
0.4001871645450592,
0.2117587774991989,
0.16162405908107758,
0.6271237134933472,
-0.4892033636569977,
0.48663565516471863,
0.01993168145418167,
-0.4519272446632385,
-0.31671059131622314,
-0.24916216731071472,
0.47303488850593567,
0.7177388668060303,
0.1417222023010254,
0.1263546198606491,
0.18599873781204224,
0.20923513174057007,
-0.6073991656303406,
0.18188095092773438,
-0.7957063317298889,
0.03466985002160072,
-0.14966119825839996,
-0.3190077543258667,
-0.2842720150947571,
-0.1690395623445511,
-0.4701429009437561,
-0.6877573728561401,
-0.01250915415585041,
0.20526018738746643,
0.7994465827941895,
0.4436546266078949,
-0.40017253160476685,
-0.19119325280189514,
-0.8663977980613708,
1.0614198446273804,
-0.6042724847793579,
0.3655455410480499,
0.3675568997859955,
0.28199729323387146,
-0.2335391789674759,
-0.5813098549842834,
-0.5919825434684753,
-0.04692784324288368,
-0.1643800288438797,
0.23878182470798492,
0.2645082175731659,
-0.0872029960155487,
0.08324161916971207,
0.30753663182258606,
-0.7422570586204529,
0.05859832465648651,
-0.41541120409965515,
-0.36519309878349304,
0.48802319169044495,
0.13983270525932312,
0.47489431500434875,
-0.284237802028656,
-0.48912331461906433,
-0.20167912542819977,
-0.5347943902015686,
-0.2937069237232208,
0.5282531380653381,
0.6254792213439941,
-0.5423589944839478,
0.49085527658462524,
-0.009787474758923054,
0.59979248046875,
-0.163455992937088,
-0.28927740454673767,
0.30542677640914917,
-0.755566418170929,
-0.04371340572834015,
0.06596684455871582,
0.9621625542640686,
-0.027766017243266106,
0.18172724545001984,
-0.08950448781251907,
-0.41154539585113525,
0.19099123775959015,
0.11061859130859375,
-0.6353167295455933,
-0.1341656893491745,
0.23164479434490204,
-0.3097628355026245,
-0.4112613797187805,
-0.22517308592796326,
-0.939356803894043,
-0.06170448288321495,
-0.2813437581062317,
0.3689972162246704,
-0.3017277121543884,
-0.43096885085105896,
0.09417024254798889,
0.28069618344306946,
-0.18014006316661835,
0.056534625589847565,
-0.5811386704444885,
0.1295466423034668,
0.2464534491300583,
0.6933459639549255,
-0.32417696714401245,
-0.4990762770175934,
-0.384520560503006,
0.2502134144306183,
-0.2928691506385803,
0.46163997054100037,
-0.3649187386035919,
-0.15709376335144043,
0.08779638260602951,
-0.2660925090312958,
-0.09122638404369354,
-0.7573172450065613,
0.32981881499290466,
-0.43430641293525696,
0.03563949838280678,
0.41861093044281006,
-0.06009124591946602,
0.19871939718723297,
0.3839227557182312,
-0.5495622754096985,
1.0120537281036377,
0.2788212299346924,
-0.9815971851348877,
0.237931489944458,
-0.3893739879131317,
-0.8647869825363159,
0.15504267811775208,
-0.2469884604215622,
-0.736469566822052,
-0.04951412230730057,
0.31049075722694397,
0.27914321422576904,
-0.08992523699998856,
0.28916603326797485,
-0.27298980951309204,
-0.5209699869155884,
0.5026289820671082,
-0.5478627681732178,
0.6687909364700317,
0.5989084243774414,
-0.04288358986377716,
0.11645252257585526,
-0.8572852611541748,
0.12345302104949951,
0.07539767026901245,
-0.45706504583358765,
-0.30889466404914856,
-0.2802930176258087,
0.49237295985221863,
0.330922931432724,
0.16944539546966553,
-0.41773539781570435,
0.18306167423725128,
-0.3942195773124695,
0.4085782468318939,
0.31515735387802124,
0.23786187171936035,
0.30462130904197693,
-0.3996606767177582,
0.731244683265686,
0.22277723252773285,
0.057037729769945145,
-0.3390178084373474,
-0.3973805904388428,
-0.4933604300022125,
-0.6485731601715088,
0.49590447545051575,
0.6236657500267029,
-1.0589463710784912,
0.20163093507289886,
-0.23527713119983673,
-0.015719419345259666,
-1.0267056226730347,
0.3128378093242645,
0.3256111145019531,
0.12999142706394196,
0.6916149854660034,
-0.234704852104187,
-0.871673583984375,
-0.6886681318283081,
-0.12891019880771637,
0.03563125431537628,
0.009883617050945759,
0.08795171231031418,
0.26698100566864014,
-0.42972928285598755,
0.5962382555007935,
-0.14874102175235748,
-0.05095672607421875,
-0.5111815929412842,
0.24642834067344666,
0.06662578135728836,
0.693299412727356,
0.14799410104751587,
-0.9353917241096497,
-0.6763142943382263,
0.28301718831062317,
-0.6121492981910706,
-0.25473806262016296,
-0.5530946254730225,
-0.1361415833234787,
0.19624796509742737,
0.4016723334789276,
-0.45746907591819763,
0.2983650267124176,
0.7813329696655273,
0.31643807888031006,
0.5368180274963379,
-0.27075284719467163,
0.35074979066848755,
-1.6418304443359375,
0.04435696080327034,
-0.28998973965644836,
-0.3785937428474426,
-0.344056099653244,
0.3705327808856964,
0.034360628575086594,
-0.2929999530315399,
-0.611423134803772,
0.34909898042678833,
-0.5155730247497559,
0.11639587581157684,
-0.3469952642917633,
0.008967100642621517,
-0.23894356191158295,
0.6590923070907593,
-0.18133559823036194,
0.809360682964325,
0.28492477536201477,
-0.4620215594768524,
0.21184077858924866,
0.26716649532318115,
-0.028012385591864586,
0.1827818900346756,
-0.2563832998275757,
0.13587316870689392,
0.22986909747123718,
0.13250456750392914,
-0.6867130994796753,
-0.5491586327552795,
0.3171836733818054,
-0.6543027758598328,
0.5029777884483337,
-0.2644385099411011,
-0.6490341424942017,
-0.10058997571468353,
-0.07128551602363586,
0.7536051869392395,
0.6176409721374512,
-0.4601318836212158,
0.05905692279338837,
0.36384692788124084,
-0.04742220789194107,
-0.3944665193557739,
-0.9165486097335815,
0.221035435795784,
-0.06757748872041702,
-0.4041498601436615,
0.30794641375541687,
0.045070577412843704,
-0.08931431919336319,
0.017223061993718147,
-0.17121833562850952,
-0.5173254609107971,
-0.09300313889980316,
0.21604642271995544,
0.39980223774909973,
-0.15368737280368805,
-0.27257513999938965,
0.14885951578617096,
-0.1357201188802719,
-0.19399482011795044,
-0.4115132689476013,
0.5202774405479431,
0.22715431451797485,
-0.27709466218948364,
-0.21720394492149353,
0.6358794569969177,
0.6183517575263977,
-0.30572643876075745,
0.7320564389228821,
0.7284098863601685,
-0.38727304339408875,
-0.5678120255470276,
-0.10451407730579376,
-0.2160937786102295,
-0.41184383630752563,
0.49658700823783875,
-0.4668785035610199,
-0.9495279788970947,
0.3976443111896515,
-0.10834001004695892,
-0.16323579847812653,
0.08472344279289246,
0.7753303647041321,
-0.12202496826648712,
1.1314642429351807,
0.6145895719528198,
0.11331240087747574,
0.22398507595062256,
0.0848086029291153,
0.6209791302680969,
-0.2681794762611389,
0.09880262613296509,
-0.4333118200302124,
-0.2974780797958374,
-1.2167794704437256,
-0.3819770812988281,
0.47229933738708496,
0.2656918168067932,
0.05553245171904564,
0.6803276538848877,
-0.4119969308376312,
0.2393958568572998,
0.42373862862586975,
0.18299807608127594,
0.3856565058231354,
0.25799617171287537,
-0.2873399257659912,
-0.24197377264499664,
-0.9474515914916992,
-0.24062934517860413,
1.0571529865264893,
0.05431777611374855,
0.7536067366600037,
-0.22424623370170593,
0.8373759984970093,
-0.02604018524289131,
0.04148830473423004,
-0.4813529849052429,
0.43870770931243896,
0.02290482074022293,
-0.5093474388122559,
0.08014120161533356,
-0.8678671717643738,
-0.8532119393348694,
0.1357811689376831,
-0.5214087963104248,
-0.1279737502336502,
-0.22931669652462006,
0.19436991214752197,
-0.11970046907663345,
0.2866246700286865,
-0.6114698052406311,
0.7369568347930908,
-0.24589850008487701,
-0.7222217917442322,
-0.37018468976020813,
-0.8297722935676575,
0.4071740508079529,
-0.49692782759666443,
0.3898767828941345,
0.25420060753822327,
0.05810526758432388,
0.3154205083847046,
-0.21598415076732635,
0.7443245649337769,
0.23012030124664307,
0.1426590234041214,
0.30878743529319763,
0.22478188574314117,
0.4274711608886719,
0.038028791546821594,
0.18189425766468048,
0.4106268882751465,
0.09873131662607193,
-0.7102486491203308,
-0.5652296543121338,
0.6048600077629089,
-0.6505874395370483,
-0.018554652109742165,
-0.3758450448513031,
-1.0871946811676025,
-0.3475949466228485,
0.25321701169013977,
0.3230489194393158,
0.008196292445063591,
0.28005990386009216,
0.13793745636940002,
0.37216922640800476,
-0.536271333694458,
0.20853079855442047,
0.4241369068622589,
-0.22557759284973145,
-0.7329321503639221,
1.0371637344360352,
0.060181282460689545,
0.3642892837524414,
0.3936421871185303,
0.05240733548998833,
0.04913517087697983,
-0.6773673295974731,
-0.6497224569320679,
0.14179688692092896,
-0.22649312019348145,
-0.3674025535583496,
-0.560165524482727,
-0.3098544180393219,
-0.33396589756011963,
-0.3027578890323639,
-0.5278608202934265,
-0.33782467246055603,
0.1559569388628006,
0.1980484277009964,
0.1287394016981125,
0.618046224117279,
-0.06990283727645874,
0.03844870626926422,
-1.0131810903549194,
0.3296595811843872,
-0.20428569614887238,
0.305804044008255,
-0.4038521349430084,
-0.2608787417411804,
-0.7451710104942322,
0.26366087794303894,
-0.1864631325006485,
-0.8126450777053833,
0.6732491850852966,
-0.27160170674324036,
0.29955753684043884,
-0.20065683126449585,
0.39589422941207886,
0.7297877073287964,
-0.2705080211162567,
0.5609358549118042,
0.1781955510377884,
-0.48870590329170227,
0.3158860504627228,
-0.5846234560012817,
0.2246057093143463,
0.5521754622459412,
0.37766072154045105,
-0.35003456473350525,
-0.6798227429389954,
-0.3945416510105133,
-0.8831032514572144,
0.3778844475746155,
0.3056411147117615,
0.029117846861481667,
0.1430494338274002,
0.1691877245903015,
0.3210112154483795,
0.3100145161151886,
-0.8372567892074585,
-0.009699461050331593,
-0.12247414886951447,
-0.6225295662879944,
0.3438081741333008,
0.03821215406060219,
0.17368613183498383,
-0.22479242086410522,
0.5135595798492432,
-0.09073130041360855,
0.12968091666698456,
-0.1405724138021469,
-0.2693757116794586,
-0.2860621511936188,
0.46383991837501526,
0.31062278151512146,
0.23358207941055298,
-0.15812458097934723,
0.15403501689434052,
0.06952012330293655,
-0.586491048336029,
0.14777471125125885,
-0.009628352709114552,
-0.39415785670280457,
-0.03492966666817665,
0.47068044543266296,
0.5825705528259277,
0.36249101161956787,
-0.734439492225647,
0.36264944076538086,
0.29065799713134766,
-0.18878735601902008,
0.12828490138053894,
-0.12593403458595276,
-0.12636885046958923,
-0.06033733859658241,
-0.03753160312771797,
0.535574734210968,
-0.15737289190292358,
-0.46419116854667664,
0.45286065340042114,
0.05441617593169212,
-0.17712078988552094,
-0.3880177140235901,
0.7317684292793274,
0.2764636278152466,
-0.2464846819639206,
0.5182562470436096,
-0.3910328447818756,
-0.5903379321098328,
0.26342910528182983,
0.8690692782402039,
0.8639986515045166,
-0.06927692890167236,
0.01572033204138279,
0.3310023844242096,
0.32860687375068665,
0.03766980767250061,
0.34092339873313904,
-0.24545976519584656,
-0.5328089594841003,
-0.8071421980857849,
-0.7770674228668213,
-0.42171889543533325,
0.2265280783176422,
-0.6290901899337769,
0.34047240018844604,
-0.21161817014217377,
0.21470777690410614,
-0.5225306749343872,
0.028082262724637985,
-0.45125892758369446,
-0.05397498607635498,
-0.1957525908946991,
0.3723244071006775,
-0.8331746459007263,
1.2207900285720825,
0.7408148050308228,
-0.6231059432029724,
-0.8271166682243347,
0.33923712372779846,
-0.2550216317176819,
-0.6312023401260376,
0.3216731548309326,
-0.003332884283736348,
0.1200956329703331,
-0.0323319137096405,
-0.4661807417869568,
-0.40602296590805054,
0.5633460283279419,
0.5330856442451477,
-0.4541907012462616,
0.28913524746894836,
0.5446160435676575,
0.6290178894996643,
-0.13770431280136108,
-0.10147284716367722,
0.16820713877677917,
0.4211207926273346,
-0.016985710710287094,
-0.9286975860595703,
-0.17200778424739838,
-0.2145387828350067,
-0.14928758144378662,
0.39326390624046326,
-0.37617596983909607,
0.7304365038871765,
-0.04799634963274002,
-0.27814605832099915,
-0.004678803961724043,
0.5067276358604431,
0.13281258940696716,
0.2715038061141968,
0.22382763028144836,
0.2983909845352173,
0.282047301530838,
0.1519327014684677,
0.9271889328956604,
-0.5415921807289124,
0.21993990242481232,
1.087791085243225,
-0.4072455167770386,
0.9460517764091492,
0.7283276319503784,
-0.1527015119791031,
0.03277561068534851,
0.4458538889884949,
0.19621755182743073,
0.4351300299167633,
0.167170450091362,
-0.3614642918109894,
-0.22225415706634521,
-0.23418858647346497,
-0.10547437518835068,
0.42862334847450256,
0.12608522176742554,
0.033923178911209106,
-0.14353621006011963,
0.21712349355220795,
-0.0892072319984436,
0.6650131940841675,
0.057264167815446854,
0.5736903548240662,
0.08738812059164047,
-0.5735892653465271,
0.7829024195671082,
0.1747545748949051,
0.9632756114006042,
-0.5230681896209717,
-0.30622854828834534,
-0.3291395306587219,
0.31552183628082275,
-0.17745153605937958,
-0.5090254545211792,
0.6107348203659058,
0.0948193371295929,
-0.15981420874595642,
-0.5319650173187256,
0.6525269150733948,
-0.955962061882019,
-0.4503985345363617,
0.36040419340133667,
0.5313028693199158,
0.022789349779486656,
0.3277395963668823,
-0.5446539521217346,
0.3468025326728821,
0.07358589768409729,
0.1961447149515152,
0.6465129852294922,
0.3252175450325012,
-0.0649210661649704,
0.33932197093963623,
0.708044707775116,
0.5091824531555176,
0.2390267550945282,
-0.24566620588302612,
0.6245695948600769,
-0.3729735314846039,
-0.49458736181259155,
-0.4858616888523102,
0.38082292675971985,
0.17983148992061615,
-0.2548587918281555,
0.8397354483604431,
0.6521113514900208,
1.3557677268981934,
-0.12950892746448517,
0.9810366630554199,
0.08872769773006439,
0.5801002979278564,
-0.5372567772865295,
0.8166672587394714,
-0.5138663649559021,
0.2739091217517853,
-0.01793373003602028,
-0.8582653999328613,
-0.5651921629905701,
0.48554399609565735,
0.16463449597358704,
-0.112510547041893,
0.7057164311408997,
1.1672497987747192,
-0.33718955516815186,
-0.19489485025405884,
0.539142906665802,
0.24177886545658112,
-0.009068392217159271,
0.6642630100250244,
0.6295087933540344,
-0.614667534828186,
0.9007391929626465,
-0.3274587094783783,
0.008996118791401386,
-0.11507459729909897,
-0.6154181361198425,
-0.6940412521362305,
-0.5676783323287964,
-0.3958735466003418,
-0.6721864938735962,
0.29500386118888855,
1.2072778940200806,
0.8018336296081543,
-1.0109471082687378,
-0.3573112189769745,
-0.19184786081314087,
0.04347182810306549,
-0.41872403025627136,
-0.18047496676445007,
0.07259216904640198,
-0.5509724020957947,
-0.7987314462661743,
0.6240819096565247,
0.32469281554222107,
0.12777984142303467,
-0.18459951877593994,
-0.25906217098236084,
-0.2480791062116623,
0.046315040439367294,
0.29128792881965637,
0.20049670338630676,
-0.2580629289150238,
-0.1000104621052742,
-0.041600435972213745,
-0.520799458026886,
0.1769908219575882,
0.9036920070648193,
-0.6402775645256042,
0.5540897250175476,
0.5377071499824524,
1.022812008857727,
0.558685839176178,
-0.24863295257091522,
0.6729296445846558,
-1.068324327468872,
0.5108685493469238,
0.3250505030155182,
0.047793712466955185,
0.38010576367378235,
-0.1965133249759674,
0.38442763686180115,
0.493904173374176,
-0.39882951974868774,
-1.0547815561294556,
0.19572797417640686,
-0.9176725149154663,
-0.2727932929992676,
1.1246508359909058,
-0.004822727758437395,
-0.2688263952732086,
-0.3083573281764984,
-0.1968177706003189,
0.6673400402069092,
-0.08820123225450516,
0.6426337957382202,
0.34304702281951904,
0.2127998322248459,
-0.12170962989330292,
-0.7648985385894775,
0.2681172788143158,
0.5023216605186462,
-0.680285632610321,
-0.09768635779619217,
0.3480374813079834,
0.058122143149375916,
-0.08121822774410248,
0.19495315849781036,
-0.1850881427526474,
0.07262064516544342,
0.33343440294265747,
0.2671722173690796,
-0.3157709538936615,
-0.3411653935909271,
-0.23307572305202484,
0.2725234031677246,
-0.10842518508434296,
-0.506775975227356
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16702v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16702v1
|
ProCQA: A Large-scale Community-based Programming Question Answering Dataset for Code Search
| 2024-03-25T12:34:33 | 2024-03-25T12:34:33 |
Zehan Li, Jianfei Zhang, Chuantao Yin, Yuanxin Ouyang, Wenge Rong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.SE
|
Retrieval-based code question answering seeks to match user queries in
natural language to relevant code snippets. Previous approaches typically rely
on pretraining models using crafted bi-modal and uni-modal datasets to align
text and code representations. In this paper, we introduce ProCQA, a
large-scale programming question answering dataset extracted from the
StackOverflow community, offering naturally structured mixed-modal QA pairs. To
validate its effectiveness, we propose a modality-agnostic contrastive
pre-training approach to improve the alignment of text and code representations
of current code language models. Compared to previous models that primarily
employ bimodal and unimodal pairs extracted from CodeSearchNet for
pre-training, our model exhibits significant performance improvements across a
wide range of code retrieval benchmarks.
|
[
-0.40122270584106445,
-0.40787363052368164,
0.30301859974861145,
-0.058647993952035904,
-0.28833410143852234,
0.49609294533729553,
0.033603888005018234,
-0.15834036469459534,
0.3190063238143921,
0.32519662380218506,
-0.5256579518318176,
-0.3442603647708893,
-0.20813782513141632,
0.03481582924723625,
-0.3680843412876129,
0.7968317866325378,
-0.06884418427944183,
0.3295861482620239,
-0.34509438276290894,
-0.16352736949920654,
-0.4904603660106659,
-0.6432948112487793,
-0.20397217571735382,
0.2372148334980011,
0.4277709722518921,
0.3414411246776581,
1.0186100006103516,
0.27513280510902405,
0.5740499496459961,
0.22354212403297424,
0.2570769786834717,
0.02016507089138031,
-0.47816669940948486,
-0.07399775087833405,
0.02962665818631649,
-0.3855927884578705,
-0.08185463398694992,
0.007997372187674046,
0.16503781080245972,
0.5586252808570862,
-0.16796377301216125,
0.309928297996521,
-0.14789825677871704,
0.45205581188201904,
-0.7524123191833496,
-0.1250220537185669,
-0.5566480755805969,
-0.3231390416622162,
-0.091751329600811,
-0.31843385100364685,
-0.14233452081680298,
-0.735512912273407,
-0.12204718589782715,
-0.661194384098053,
0.0015113340923562646,
0.058608654886484146,
0.7198708653450012,
0.2630351781845093,
-0.5289673805236816,
-0.45306164026260376,
-0.4156207740306854,
0.7271080017089844,
-0.7807652354240417,
0.3473653197288513,
0.3740907311439514,
0.352807879447937,
0.01145190093666315,
-0.7819535732269287,
-0.8818788528442383,
0.0647934302687645,
-0.14146272838115692,
0.3025161027908325,
0.04456302523612976,
0.13034974038600922,
-0.05070149153470993,
0.7790101766586304,
-0.9335151314735413,
-0.17836856842041016,
-0.46745073795318604,
-0.1611114889383316,
0.3395211696624756,
0.00714991707354784,
0.4551442861557007,
-0.07186383008956909,
-0.1896592378616333,
0.11182957887649536,
-0.6194086670875549,
0.22953234612941742,
0.33575427532196045,
0.09716010093688965,
0.024381432682275772,
0.39243751764297485,
-0.10419416427612305,
0.9495898485183716,
-0.16695308685302734,
0.25545862317085266,
0.3585396111011505,
-0.6971951723098755,
-0.216683492064476,
-0.3275884687900543,
0.5254696607589722,
0.3019251823425293,
0.2692762613296509,
-0.37869954109191895,
-0.10338063538074493,
0.15317413210868835,
0.6180866360664368,
-0.6841644644737244,
-0.5960042476654053,
0.3592294454574585,
-0.5559747815132141,
-0.35745835304260254,
0.3444795310497284,
-0.4372656047344208,
-0.13848912715911865,
-0.5174794793128967,
0.5869388580322266,
0.007715814281255007,
-0.2746339440345764,
0.1647321879863739,
0.09881176054477692,
0.43775737285614014,
0.06255578249692917,
-0.5218310356140137,
0.12666474282741547,
0.5184542536735535,
0.49912798404693604,
0.06574547290802002,
0.08760496973991394,
-0.7008643746376038,
-0.2827869951725006,
-0.42174381017684937,
0.5958638787269592,
-1.0950748920440674,
-0.20610558986663818,
0.06970130652189255,
0.05993054062128067,
-0.018573803827166557,
-0.765518844127655,
0.2226850688457489,
-1.246704339981079,
0.28520429134368896,
-0.2405979335308075,
-0.27553895115852356,
0.05381886661052704,
0.35453808307647705,
-0.6743844151496887,
1.1950408220291138,
0.43133601546287537,
-0.9197255373001099,
-0.0052915094420313835,
-0.38337400555610657,
-0.19828882813453674,
-0.022378744557499886,
-0.50750732421875,
-0.16261246800422668,
-0.000995081732980907,
0.35774269700050354,
0.13479024171829224,
-0.36193156242370605,
0.3512285351753235,
-0.085310198366642,
-0.7626155614852905,
0.37659668922424316,
-0.02925405278801918,
0.7134763598442078,
0.5053394436836243,
-0.09534057229757309,
0.15288172662258148,
-0.5303283929824829,
0.3853723704814911,
-0.23044335842132568,
-0.5515887141227722,
-0.38704636693000793,
-0.1170056164264679,
-0.14778314530849457,
0.5092405676841736,
0.2719610929489136,
-0.5145598649978638,
0.2732791006565094,
-0.4276135563850403,
0.49514275789260864,
0.5017201900482178,
-0.016231141984462738,
0.4547695219516754,
-0.23426765203475952,
0.8431451320648193,
0.15560708940029144,
0.30987322330474854,
-0.1409994661808014,
-0.12618790566921234,
-0.4036879539489746,
-0.30494505167007446,
0.47015079855918884,
0.5828536152839661,
-1.3246132135391235,
0.37185218930244446,
-0.06702692061662674,
-0.37978607416152954,
-0.7717850208282471,
0.18275398015975952,
0.6714017391204834,
0.4275266230106354,
0.5886247754096985,
-0.5589741468429565,
-0.7217123508453369,
-0.8546565771102905,
-0.053294118493795395,
-0.14778512716293335,
-0.33893561363220215,
0.34242966771125793,
0.32705944776535034,
-0.27156445384025574,
1.0083317756652832,
-0.7575424909591675,
0.1885407269001007,
-0.12555545568466187,
0.12241795659065247,
0.4014270603656769,
0.5686991810798645,
0.3131994605064392,
-1.1192349195480347,
-0.4218044877052307,
-0.3898976147174835,
-0.3602626919746399,
-0.2220694124698639,
-0.0396309457719326,
-0.377940833568573,
-0.27930593490600586,
0.7618177533149719,
-0.11670421808958054,
0.26447510719299316,
0.8741499185562134,
-0.24166111648082733,
0.7632559537887573,
0.040592044591903687,
0.5598216652870178,
-1.4238337278366089,
0.4644719362258911,
-0.5485443472862244,
-0.25233355164527893,
-0.441331148147583,
0.3749503493309021,
0.3019465208053589,
-0.2012597918510437,
-0.44483962655067444,
0.24572819471359253,
-0.45387282967567444,
-0.2822316288948059,
-0.14611434936523438,
0.2799122929573059,
0.16141094267368317,
0.576788067817688,
0.1542888730764389,
1.3635848760604858,
0.5850620865821838,
-0.4520663022994995,
0.35573041439056396,
0.33858585357666016,
-0.41594547033309937,
0.30214524269104004,
-0.9189603328704834,
0.38700106739997864,
-0.05115429311990738,
0.29810020327568054,
-1.2237528562545776,
0.023575477302074432,
-0.07054243236780167,
-0.6164379119873047,
-0.059064555913209915,
-0.14631767570972443,
-0.3766281008720398,
-0.4540582299232483,
-0.36229103803634644,
0.9458876252174377,
0.4246329665184021,
-0.5104086995124817,
0.18185308575630188,
0.1890118569135666,
-0.19149987399578094,
-0.733744740486145,
-0.4919752776622772,
-0.13623276352882385,
0.2857856750488281,
-0.3692951798439026,
0.2557315528392792,
-0.3718802034854889,
-0.05970071256160736,
-0.27970248460769653,
-0.3232260048389435,
-0.4904036521911621,
0.135454460978508,
0.1148807480931282,
0.4410252571105957,
-0.2811378836631775,
0.1728527843952179,
-0.2898693382740021,
-0.1090250164270401,
-0.1380324512720108,
-0.3355647921562195,
0.6048027276992798,
-0.08785338699817657,
-0.32163065671920776,
0.003253461793065071,
0.4820617735385895,
0.3411017954349518,
-0.7390497922897339,
0.655819833278656,
0.25544577836990356,
-0.16550776362419128,
0.16012972593307495,
-0.4340875446796417,
-0.10340631008148193,
-0.47897690534591675,
0.3421633541584015,
-0.06380821019411087,
-1.1769981384277344,
0.5547517538070679,
-0.08525558561086655,
0.05067093297839165,
-0.14354735612869263,
0.43842294812202454,
-0.2727005183696747,
0.8556323051452637,
0.47600695490837097,
-0.11484624445438385,
0.36386415362358093,
0.030865557491779327,
0.41217124462127686,
-0.6353366374969482,
-0.21930135786533356,
-0.7922651767730713,
-0.35737621784210205,
-0.24584941565990448,
-0.8123886585235596,
0.22602322697639465,
0.40132877230644226,
-0.5271615386009216,
0.5571218132972717,
-0.5992542505264282,
0.7394869327545166,
0.5965142250061035,
0.2918867766857147,
0.2618428170681,
-0.36290106177330017,
0.04578564316034317,
-0.01398896798491478,
-0.5008810758590698,
-0.3153579831123352,
0.970743715763092,
-0.0878065824508667,
0.7294236421585083,
0.311234712600708,
0.43136388063430786,
0.1757085919380188,
0.24877482652664185,
-0.35893693566322327,
0.2668713331222534,
-0.15104462206363678,
-0.7549976706504822,
-0.03981072083115578,
-0.6102906465530396,
-0.7424095869064331,
-0.09228450804948807,
-0.2549261152744293,
-0.3409903645515442,
0.36979731917381287,
0.2366291731595993,
-0.5099859237670898,
-0.05608562007546425,
-0.5573424696922302,
1.1330233812332153,
-0.43322041630744934,
-0.0407976396381855,
-0.024177266284823418,
-0.7702414393424988,
0.14863018691539764,
-0.1149497926235199,
0.24071310460567474,
0.3849838376045227,
-0.032314494252204895,
0.5882201790809631,
-0.36733633279800415,
0.5561032295227051,
-0.10632587224245071,
0.019180791452527046,
0.43140655755996704,
0.3472300171852112,
0.24635352194309235,
0.24040521681308746,
-0.015059184283018112,
-0.16214588284492493,
0.269362211227417,
-0.8532661199569702,
-0.6624608039855957,
0.4773673415184021,
-0.8804790377616882,
-0.2880195379257202,
-0.05482977256178856,
-0.31787943840026855,
-0.48071691393852234,
0.18137367069721222,
0.17868337035179138,
0.8889955878257751,
-0.015971792861819267,
0.5281442999839783,
0.8372715711593628,
-0.39996135234832764,
0.21737100183963776,
0.44922876358032227,
-0.18683840334415436,
-0.3860074281692505,
0.7022743225097656,
-0.3778693974018097,
0.3977203071117401,
0.5518880486488342,
-0.31962576508522034,
-0.31677699089050293,
-0.5297002196311951,
-0.22477923333644867,
0.00680728442966938,
-0.5923272967338562,
-0.5026394724845886,
-0.46933984756469727,
-0.12304855138063431,
-0.4068829119205475,
-0.5163315534591675,
-0.28246384859085083,
-0.09435170143842697,
-0.11584869027137756,
0.036193639039993286,
0.07708878815174103,
0.3410020172595978,
0.41634440422058105,
0.26587408781051636,
-0.8840456604957581,
0.5817195773124695,
0.5324360132217407,
0.6489397883415222,
-0.20416106283664703,
-0.546512246131897,
-0.2834661602973938,
0.03678399324417114,
-0.09316562861204147,
-0.9883789420127869,
0.10600682348012924,
0.0622626394033432,
0.6252512335777283,
0.08468391001224518,
0.3557564616203308,
0.556011438369751,
-0.03527945280075073,
0.9460790157318115,
0.39784613251686096,
-0.8674389719963074,
0.5257532000541687,
-0.25195083022117615,
0.626205325126648,
1.2665159702301025,
0.6551998853683472,
-0.6165043711662292,
-0.15102583169937134,
-0.28856953978538513,
-0.6886261105537415,
0.45024943351745605,
0.30125635862350464,
0.1744891256093979,
-0.2133791297674179,
0.48391684889793396,
0.059798795729875565,
0.4578971564769745,
-0.8623159527778625,
0.026475941762328148,
-0.5247908234596252,
-0.5773522853851318,
0.09460780024528503,
-0.07491813600063324,
-0.02218526042997837,
-0.23108629882335663,
0.4234950542449951,
-0.5096225738525391,
0.3762369751930237,
0.16405221819877625,
-0.4044899344444275,
0.23688271641731262,
0.30817222595214844,
0.17198821902275085,
0.8019104599952698,
-0.05050472915172577,
0.27573099732398987,
-0.027406353503465652,
-0.5400009751319885,
0.03409339115023613,
-0.024912359192967415,
0.1530703902244568,
-0.3340027332305908,
0.2793709635734558,
0.16115280985832214,
0.3223283290863037,
-1.1370444297790527,
0.9645254015922546,
-0.2438051849603653,
-0.20705009996891022,
-0.11349856108427048,
0.018918955698609352,
0.2879026532173157,
0.202566459774971,
0.36433714628219604,
-0.004928034730255604,
0.15991541743278503,
-0.6610604524612427,
0.33636024594306946,
0.2451033741235733,
-0.3371923267841339,
-0.1695963442325592,
0.6076960563659668,
0.4178706407546997,
-0.14865952730178833,
0.9169792532920837,
-0.0745009332895279,
-0.6864988207817078,
0.7434195280075073,
0.2355240434408188,
0.514465868473053,
-0.019624678418040276,
0.2374027669429779,
0.4720174968242645,
0.051622871309518814,
0.12050702422857285,
0.5662734508514404,
-0.3466690182685852,
-0.5836202502250671,
-0.46231910586357117,
-0.5958079099655151,
-0.2281842678785324,
-0.12169729173183441,
-0.6011934876441956,
0.23368440568447113,
-0.3905157148838043,
0.2984713912010193,
-0.45283448696136475,
0.11217357218265533,
-0.6320430636405945,
0.3878943920135498,
0.08067624270915985,
1.0679128170013428,
-0.7601603269577026,
0.9339100122451782,
0.8221295475959778,
-0.6993852257728577,
-1.0356340408325195,
0.14070752263069153,
-0.29879888892173767,
-0.6299829483032227,
0.37738174200057983,
0.11109624803066254,
-0.07126463949680328,
0.0989917442202568,
-0.9272459149360657,
-0.8324682712554932,
1.1318265199661255,
0.20687098801136017,
-0.4757314920425415,
-0.04039759561419487,
0.03913647308945656,
0.6401377320289612,
-0.45242369174957275,
0.5922407507896423,
0.31655192375183105,
0.15126235783100128,
0.1505478173494339,
-0.8852661848068237,
0.024801215156912804,
-0.6046623587608337,
0.06253562867641449,
0.0458228662610054,
-0.4715810716152191,
0.7051131129264832,
0.04977494478225708,
-0.06721053272485733,
0.0023813447915017605,
0.572300136089325,
0.1370263397693634,
0.11488949507474899,
0.43022483587265015,
0.14541494846343994,
0.6270594000816345,
0.0468783862888813,
0.7575027942657471,
-0.509559690952301,
0.17115724086761475,
1.069831132888794,
-0.14363573491573334,
0.9137901067733765,
0.40267547965049744,
-0.1961936354637146,
0.7345064282417297,
0.7456183433532715,
0.21974867582321167,
0.593158483505249,
0.39373505115509033,
-0.059008609503507614,
-0.6671735644340515,
0.21160916984081268,
-0.43511050939559937,
0.25022968649864197,
-0.07126016169786453,
-0.2319496124982834,
-0.19576996564865112,
-0.24436944723129272,
-0.16025368869304657,
0.5710508823394775,
-0.248594269156456,
0.6640427112579346,
-0.14925478398799896,
-0.7763458490371704,
0.6941908597946167,
-0.174446240067482,
0.8870536684989929,
-0.6378655433654785,
0.0738372802734375,
-0.6121166944503784,
-0.04476682469248772,
-0.32679635286331177,
-0.7152740955352783,
0.3565332591533661,
0.05878879502415657,
-0.2665006220340729,
0.03577245771884918,
0.4073520004749298,
-0.5132831335067749,
-0.14149674773216248,
0.18783412873744965,
0.32699593901634216,
0.05416189134120941,
-0.0963260754942894,
-0.9103291034698486,
-0.09757576882839203,
-0.030147232115268707,
0.04377027601003647,
0.3570333421230316,
0.1770649254322052,
-0.04976442828774452,
0.36530712246894836,
0.5182632803916931,
-0.37739554047584534,
-0.0506734699010849,
-0.013554850593209267,
1.2703677415847778,
-0.5049474239349365,
-0.5852322578430176,
-0.19046467542648315,
0.5265268683433533,
0.010947705246508121,
-0.3457545340061188,
0.3328559994697571,
0.7283068895339966,
0.8911214470863342,
-0.04504064843058586,
0.578494668006897,
-0.2543395161628723,
0.5588348507881165,
-0.43375304341316223,
0.38496389985084534,
-0.5709700584411621,
0.3500497341156006,
-0.1832094043493271,
-1.0020126104354858,
-0.22584088146686554,
0.37079599499702454,
-0.339310884475708,
0.19477660953998566,
0.5261372923851013,
1.3051626682281494,
-0.16137342154979706,
-0.07167050987482071,
0.24370023608207703,
-0.029804348945617676,
0.20465010404586792,
0.8341294527053833,
0.7556812167167664,
-0.4552742540836334,
0.9063257575035095,
0.17980992794036865,
-0.2749797999858856,
-0.1982589215040207,
-0.7040992975234985,
-0.6992245316505432,
-0.6614001989364624,
-0.263929545879364,
-0.37960970401763916,
0.14575839042663574,
0.9611415266990662,
0.7764148116111755,
-0.9600450396537781,
0.12779471278190613,
-0.05851106345653534,
-0.29289814829826355,
-0.22917766869068146,
-0.17353403568267822,
0.30557960271835327,
-0.19483354687690735,
-0.36181288957595825,
0.33342236280441284,
0.016599973663687706,
-0.40792304277420044,
-0.18927393853664398,
-0.24264994263648987,
-0.49126869440078735,
0.24354729056358337,
0.29046010971069336,
0.4473642408847809,
-0.16711045801639557,
-0.27230989933013916,
0.4608604907989502,
-0.47797301411628723,
0.15695923566818237,
1.0766533613204956,
-0.9883192777633667,
0.48354867100715637,
0.7103193402290344,
0.9597892761230469,
0.06806784868240356,
0.4089162051677704,
0.6684769988059998,
-1.0246081352233887,
-0.10480863600969315,
0.3570155203342438,
-0.005152824800461531,
0.11200664192438126,
-0.30305030941963196,
0.42750611901283264,
0.057243987917900085,
-0.6837092638015747,
-0.5182138085365295,
0.31285709142684937,
-0.9550016522407532,
-0.6672950387001038,
0.9679241180419922,
-0.20502428710460663,
0.016444707289338112,
-0.6466137766838074,
-0.40444067120552063,
0.12278583645820618,
-0.07036299258470535,
0.635977029800415,
0.3363127112388611,
0.12769261002540588,
-0.2545577883720398,
-0.49597370624542236,
0.3735150098800659,
0.456241637468338,
-0.8302302956581116,
0.15326283872127533,
0.6779540181159973,
0.12172708660364151,
-0.05351729318499565,
0.8860807418823242,
-0.4489879012107849,
0.6484344005584717,
-0.11205623298883438,
0.3097996115684509,
-0.1480594426393509,
-0.12092170119285583,
-0.21744844317436218,
0.16388551890850067,
0.11934734135866165,
-0.10684416443109512
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16685v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16685v2
|
ToXCL: A Unified Framework for Toxic Speech Detection and Explanation
| 2024-03-25T12:21:38 | 2024-05-20T04:06:00 |
Nhat M. Hoang, Xuan Long Do, Duc Anh Do, Duc Anh Vu, Luu Anh Tuan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
The proliferation of online toxic speech is a pertinent problem posing
threats to demographic groups. While explicit toxic speech contains offensive
lexical signals, implicit one consists of coded or indirect language.
Therefore, it is crucial for models not only to detect implicit toxic speech
but also to explain its toxicity. This draws a unique need for unified
frameworks that can effectively detect and explain implicit toxic speech. Prior
works mainly formulated the task of toxic speech detection and explanation as a
text generation problem. Nonetheless, models trained using this strategy can be
prone to suffer from the consequent error propagation problem. Moreover, our
experiments reveal that the detection results of such models are much lower
than those that focus only on the detection task. To bridge these gaps, we
introduce ToXCL, a unified framework for the detection and explanation of
implicit toxic speech. Our model consists of three modules: a (i) Target Group
Generator to generate the targeted demographic group(s) of a given post; an
(ii) Encoder-Decoder Model in which the encoder focuses on detecting implicit
toxic speech and is boosted by a (iii) Teacher Classifier via knowledge
distillation, and the decoder generates the necessary explanation. ToXCL
achieves new state-of-the-art effectiveness, and outperforms baselines
significantly.
|
[
-0.051509395241737366,
-0.5981729626655579,
0.897406280040741,
0.3975519835948944,
-0.08588835597038269,
-0.09307580441236496,
-0.2550528943538666,
-0.23320582509040833,
-0.7177554368972778,
0.6594316959381104,
-0.692462682723999,
-0.9840092062950134,
-0.6884193420410156,
0.032508112490177155,
-0.780360221862793,
1.2895233631134033,
0.35445156693458557,
-0.06102777272462845,
-0.24053353071212769,
-0.03710494935512543,
-0.26695603132247925,
-0.4771772027015686,
-0.8444130420684814,
-0.40643203258514404,
0.6667400598526001,
0.5440089702606201,
0.42806267738342285,
0.6906421184539795,
-0.17662233114242554,
0.38533928990364075,
-0.27441421151161194,
-0.1910708248615265,
-0.7846144437789917,
0.14704680442810059,
-0.4596027731895447,
-0.5220894813537598,
-0.29429760575294495,
-0.4408857524394989,
0.4737797677516937,
0.6417427659034729,
-0.20784972608089447,
0.16270630061626434,
-0.05275469273328781,
0.48392200469970703,
-0.7521487474441528,
0.06458258628845215,
-0.5589197874069214,
0.07305548340082169,
-0.21024425327777863,
-0.2814933657646179,
-0.685051441192627,
-0.2133210152387619,
-0.0028248834423720837,
-0.6481350660324097,
0.1307222992181778,
-0.1407824009656906,
-0.027611419558525085,
0.38139277696609497,
-0.8031060099601746,
-0.5015900731086731,
-0.9494496583938599,
0.6065087914466858,
-0.5749874114990234,
0.26937365531921387,
0.002372595015913248,
0.24363483488559723,
-0.1047898605465889,
-0.8801829218864441,
-0.6969184875488281,
-0.0073120612651109695,
0.021411392837762833,
0.18744227290153503,
-0.4454197883605957,
0.26647448539733887,
0.006790619343519211,
0.024200929328799248,
-0.742928147315979,
0.056537844240665436,
-0.2968253791332245,
-0.34818312525749207,
0.5682528614997864,
-0.024758396670222282,
0.5496053695678711,
0.00856297928839922,
-0.6039462089538574,
0.09309574216604233,
-0.4421229660511017,
-0.09342482686042786,
0.39076945185661316,
0.3521519601345062,
-0.005865098908543587,
0.16658760607242584,
-0.002541104331612587,
0.33792924880981445,
-0.07417715340852737,
-0.012330746278166771,
-0.015979155898094177,
-0.14919568598270416,
0.1068832129240036,
0.8756459951400757,
0.6123673319816589,
0.17378142476081848,
0.30052363872528076,
-0.11015146225690842,
-0.03766828030347824,
0.5596694946289062,
0.012851129285991192,
-0.8167858719825745,
-0.15020053088665009,
0.2861827611923218,
-0.4063960313796997,
-0.5425876379013062,
-0.38170114159584045,
-0.9950968623161316,
-0.36710265278816223,
-0.19259901344776154,
0.29547199606895447,
0.04667682573199272,
-0.778893768787384,
0.24591605365276337,
-0.3484247922897339,
-0.3830091953277588,
0.04205616936087608,
-0.6853476762771606,
0.6295881867408752,
0.6290521621704102,
0.5024684071540833,
-0.4022938013076782,
0.2182909995317459,
-0.5132865309715271,
0.4852452874183655,
-0.10019180178642273,
0.9608129262924194,
-0.7457383871078491,
-0.5648629665374756,
0.09118311107158661,
-0.23896488547325134,
0.18878422677516937,
-0.4961574375629425,
0.8624154925346375,
-0.2545585036277771,
0.5869423151016235,
-0.03774113580584526,
-0.23573563992977142,
-0.42035308480262756,
-0.13263532519340515,
-0.21596108376979828,
0.8710914850234985,
-0.08610940724611282,
-0.7301035523414612,
0.15137729048728943,
-0.9765316843986511,
-0.1145625114440918,
0.050643082708120346,
0.28190547227859497,
-0.43679580092430115,
0.16919323801994324,
0.05047941207885742,
0.0044334265403449535,
-0.2788878083229065,
0.46194908022880554,
-0.45536360144615173,
-0.38310524821281433,
0.17931342124938965,
-0.7392104268074036,
1.0323173999786377,
0.48608946800231934,
-0.4288228154182434,
0.4657999575138092,
-0.7679598927497864,
0.1815105378627777,
0.19728122651576996,
-0.27832692861557007,
-0.5555494427680969,
0.3241361677646637,
0.3820885717868805,
0.39092111587524414,
-0.19020983576774597,
-0.4572516679763794,
-0.6237896680831909,
-0.11241981387138367,
0.6140518188476562,
0.7905831933021545,
0.14318439364433289,
0.12189716100692749,
-0.19622834026813507,
0.33358484506607056,
0.06837853044271469,
0.3625735342502594,
-0.18218596279621124,
-0.26059380173683167,
-0.3723732531070709,
-0.22229500114917755,
-0.10453243553638458,
0.5322996377944946,
-0.5225900411605835,
0.18123334646224976,
-0.3859196603298187,
-0.2015681266784668,
-0.046025220304727554,
-0.10420352220535278,
0.6614087820053101,
0.794865071773529,
0.42434799671173096,
0.023741640150547028,
-0.49326029419898987,
-0.606698751449585,
-0.32225173711776733,
-0.3677036762237549,
-0.050545915961265564,
0.04923735558986664,
0.3878282904624939,
-0.28186944127082825,
0.9772322773933411,
-0.22982804477214813,
-0.1472771018743515,
-0.020293129608035088,
0.1040324792265892,
-0.21177984774112701,
0.33256709575653076,
0.573012113571167,
-0.9535440802574158,
-0.4301396310329437,
-0.16961777210235596,
-0.5963353514671326,
-0.6485447883605957,
0.21595481038093567,
-0.12395637482404709,
-0.11216557025909424,
0.6932079195976257,
0.2750334143638611,
0.15953975915908813,
0.7044075131416321,
-0.41288208961486816,
0.40949779748916626,
-0.10950691252946854,
-0.14577601850032806,
-0.8739920258522034,
-0.01698320172727108,
0.055975835770368576,
-0.385730504989624,
-1.0199867486953735,
-0.19238708913326263,
-0.22396989166736603,
-0.3547002673149109,
-0.9143810272216797,
0.3551393151283264,
-0.20327283442020416,
0.2867027223110199,
-0.2965928614139557,
0.3678058683872223,
-0.11316946893930435,
0.6136837005615234,
0.04099564626812935,
0.6786917448043823,
0.5180620551109314,
-0.6432705521583557,
0.34808841347694397,
0.2683390974998474,
0.16786043345928192,
0.7219406366348267,
-0.616752028465271,
0.12198758125305176,
-0.37077346444129944,
0.3466769754886627,
-1.3293005228042603,
-0.012780356220901012,
0.4170583188533783,
-0.44282129406929016,
0.12946687638759613,
-0.2460496574640274,
-0.5694904923439026,
-0.37725141644477844,
-0.07085311412811279,
0.8411252498626709,
0.46580109000205994,
-0.8154125809669495,
0.4466750919818878,
0.5264108180999756,
-0.1837315857410431,
-0.4340878129005432,
-0.595092236995697,
-0.09237343817949295,
-0.5292029976844788,
-0.6799446940422058,
0.2159954011440277,
-0.28236308693885803,
-0.2477155476808548,
0.05769209563732147,
-0.4375149607658386,
-0.4013281762599945,
0.060467466711997986,
0.28354084491729736,
0.033238764852285385,
-0.23662211000919342,
0.34507760405540466,
0.2727375328540802,
-0.3424457013607025,
0.6959089636802673,
-0.4069063067436218,
0.3054259121417999,
-0.007568405009806156,
-0.13043852150440216,
-0.3835447132587433,
0.6517471671104431,
0.7242593169212341,
-0.06445616483688354,
0.27846625447273254,
0.3486446142196655,
-0.20329774916172028,
-0.45951247215270996,
-0.1069587841629982,
-0.08966457843780518,
-0.5373127460479736,
0.4260665774345398,
0.1773792803287506,
-0.7114372253417969,
0.40562382340431213,
-0.6347395181655884,
-0.23146803677082062,
0.46229270100593567,
0.45259854197502136,
0.31247562170028687,
1.5689045190811157,
0.6047946214675903,
0.14403335750102997,
0.32706353068351746,
0.3565950095653534,
-0.036012109369039536,
-0.46788910031318665,
-0.3535498082637787,
-0.7074653506278992,
0.2566247284412384,
-0.40843459963798523,
-0.15296676754951477,
0.6903365850448608,
-0.41585463285446167,
-0.6734735369682312,
-0.2956714332103729,
-0.9131645560264587,
0.5771669149398804,
0.12041018903255463,
-0.01148368138819933,
0.4993517994880676,
0.24756228923797607,
-0.19002199172973633,
0.11121449619531631,
-0.7623746991157532,
-0.5234925746917725,
0.9406680464744568,
0.4210250675678253,
0.48479968309402466,
0.18056395649909973,
0.3663172125816345,
0.4990038275718689,
0.5177726149559021,
-0.3272685408592224,
0.5709741711616516,
-0.4577474296092987,
-1.190894365310669,
-0.00715288333594799,
-0.3834974467754364,
-0.6648778319358826,
0.3364831209182739,
-0.24218177795410156,
-0.7060351371765137,
0.12996990978717804,
0.3151027262210846,
-0.3016935884952545,
0.23308134078979492,
-0.6620427966117859,
0.8809111714363098,
-0.48512002825737,
-0.5478327870368958,
-0.20591813325881958,
-0.6673126816749573,
0.7652105689048767,
-0.23512707650661469,
0.5946385264396667,
-0.21732914447784424,
-0.02964269556105137,
0.652462363243103,
-0.3724267780780792,
0.9549857974052429,
-0.25263917446136475,
-0.4833488464355469,
0.2745872139930725,
-0.23185376822948456,
0.18597184121608734,
0.17263323068618774,
-0.272644966840744,
0.3457232713699341,
0.00995554681867361,
-0.11893613636493683,
-0.4717092216014862,
0.5242351293563843,
-0.539875328540802,
-0.5367459058761597,
-0.38472288846969604,
-0.4428105652332306,
-0.04629048332571983,
0.2005947083234787,
0.3758266270160675,
0.4185541272163391,
-0.1453753411769867,
-0.06005045026540756,
0.9612694978713989,
-0.5982157588005066,
0.18209727108478546,
0.6170814037322998,
-0.40113091468811035,
-0.23033908009529114,
1.1147817373275757,
-0.45778778195381165,
0.4658348560333252,
0.15510541200637817,
0.3569701015949249,
-0.5906404256820679,
-0.4405766427516937,
-0.11636778712272644,
0.24318355321884155,
-0.8838908076286316,
0.03942510485649109,
-0.5645526051521301,
-0.1292060762643814,
-0.2505771815776825,
0.17389392852783203,
-0.31762754917144775,
-0.016680650413036346,
-0.38814300298690796,
0.09716035425662994,
0.18359914422035217,
0.8471508622169495,
-0.28709912300109863,
0.5033737421035767,
-0.5748071670532227,
0.3153522312641144,
0.4793989062309265,
0.3562396764755249,
-0.13330404460430145,
-0.4756236672401428,
0.3924955725669861,
0.3511109948158264,
-0.31030088663101196,
-1.132063627243042,
0.3612307906150818,
0.3130897581577301,
0.501139223575592,
0.6828970313072205,
0.4041078984737396,
0.6012295484542847,
-0.4520636200904846,
0.6063275933265686,
0.22289589047431946,
-1.3195855617523193,
0.7243150472640991,
-0.3778603971004486,
-0.10603936016559601,
0.2898046374320984,
0.5114831924438477,
-0.8936956524848938,
-0.5477286577224731,
-0.4778369665145874,
-0.9769786596298218,
0.7642123699188232,
0.23815160989761353,
0.1957448571920395,
0.022776715457439423,
0.2307613044977188,
0.17004546523094177,
0.1229877695441246,
-0.8552082180976868,
-0.537015974521637,
-0.3058760166168213,
-0.25491049885749817,
0.016090132296085358,
-0.5954908728599548,
-0.5323776006698608,
-0.16073285043239594,
0.528942346572876,
-0.010394721291959286,
0.4585607051849365,
0.03525461256504059,
-0.17282883822917938,
-0.4800945520401001,
0.5145673751831055,
0.8229255676269531,
0.5021040439605713,
-0.007692435290664434,
0.3321130871772766,
0.21261319518089294,
-0.3097979426383972,
0.29818248748779297,
0.016538100317120552,
0.02288859337568283,
0.07462775707244873,
0.3241383135318756,
0.740403413772583,
0.3706147074699402,
-0.8307628035545349,
0.7250027060508728,
-0.18009544909000397,
-0.4180077314376831,
-0.5632463097572327,
0.3245358169078827,
-0.02391214855015278,
0.13269740343093872,
0.3935474455356598,
0.023001955822110176,
0.3788222074508667,
-0.7319868803024292,
0.29091015458106995,
0.2766280174255371,
-0.6116844415664673,
-0.36199435591697693,
1.0633597373962402,
0.2766460180282593,
-0.028479451313614845,
0.44022637605667114,
0.06944851577281952,
-0.8564242720603943,
0.3420121967792511,
0.8295512795448303,
0.5029129385948181,
-0.32337266206741333,
0.41289955377578735,
0.14468713104724884,
-0.13830415904521942,
0.11275438964366913,
0.1769571304321289,
-0.15328864753246307,
-0.5229945182800293,
-0.27152219414711,
-0.340852826833725,
-0.18042553961277008,
0.1053515076637268,
-0.6207078099250793,
-0.059130020439624786,
-0.26886823773384094,
0.17772336304187775,
0.12678971886634827,
-0.42325475811958313,
-0.08327838778495789,
0.01417354866862297,
0.5333038568496704,
0.6178291440010071,
-1.2473152875900269,
0.4572484493255615,
0.359710693359375,
-0.12681163847446442,
-0.6227954030036926,
-0.017884809523820877,
0.43554258346557617,
-0.8089357614517212,
0.9223401546478271,
0.08996935188770294,
-0.14994974434375763,
0.28433212637901306,
-0.7908896207809448,
-0.7651325464248657,
0.7467227578163147,
0.5938100218772888,
-0.37249451875686646,
-0.04051504284143448,
0.3167087435722351,
0.6332527995109558,
-0.2745314836502075,
0.23391446471214294,
0.38052916526794434,
0.8181396722793579,
0.33992481231689453,
-0.6465069651603699,
0.2285301238298416,
-0.26640674471855164,
0.16105365753173828,
-0.04757720232009888,
-0.15741576254367828,
0.7178711295127869,
-0.19287031888961792,
-0.7088991403579712,
-0.256013959646225,
0.4468843638896942,
0.22477827966213226,
0.6894741058349609,
0.7751850485801697,
0.16176819801330566,
0.7086375951766968,
-0.1476011425256729,
0.8870010375976562,
-0.07301653921604156,
0.06055931746959686,
1.0350706577301025,
-0.27534395456314087,
0.4841654896736145,
0.04236669838428497,
0.09099436551332474,
0.6382609605789185,
0.5439613461494446,
0.18492209911346436,
0.60893714427948,
0.46576833724975586,
-0.7796261310577393,
-0.3282228112220764,
-0.48419296741485596,
-0.4224148988723755,
0.4127098023891449,
0.6764330267906189,
-0.3225991129875183,
-0.7308427095413208,
0.5020520091056824,
0.07802033424377441,
0.42221859097480774,
-0.5463564991950989,
0.8347278237342834,
-0.040582578629255295,
-0.5870863199234009,
0.7167749404907227,
-0.19656041264533997,
0.5721219778060913,
-0.5281181335449219,
-0.06440723687410355,
0.2210729867219925,
0.44159629940986633,
-0.2516080439090729,
-0.6393486261367798,
0.3849428594112396,
-0.02329707331955433,
-0.08174525946378708,
-0.5228539109230042,
0.7603487968444824,
-0.7615155577659607,
-0.14926230907440186,
0.5775716304779053,
0.21404564380645752,
0.2452848106622696,
-0.36646711826324463,
-0.7339361310005188,
0.16392798721790314,
0.010138166137039661,
0.23703405261039734,
0.04263889044523239,
0.6495721936225891,
-0.1995975226163864,
0.5535174608230591,
0.8766608834266663,
0.08704371005296707,
0.1687570959329605,
-0.11740227788686752,
0.8948620557785034,
-0.11304745078086853,
-0.43006834387779236,
-0.7576526403427124,
0.6953638792037964,
-0.005756855010986328,
-0.1222735345363617,
0.439217746257782,
0.41283032298088074,
0.766071617603302,
0.10842982679605484,
0.8888846635818481,
0.366599977016449,
0.4536036550998688,
-0.2870050072669983,
0.934941291809082,
-0.6199709177017212,
0.22949601709842682,
-0.1781362146139145,
-0.8399044275283813,
-0.4091680943965912,
0.36780667304992676,
-0.08263073116540909,
-0.043077945709228516,
0.8993658423423767,
0.7809150218963623,
0.07350428402423859,
0.2165655493736267,
0.23119644820690155,
0.4955076575279236,
0.5130648016929626,
0.6381358504295349,
0.8586148619651794,
-0.13616269826889038,
1.0575612783432007,
-0.09615491330623627,
-0.18130572140216827,
-0.11003464460372925,
-1.0462158918380737,
-0.7472972869873047,
-0.6736075282096863,
-0.40177884697914124,
-0.2906511723995209,
0.42157042026519775,
0.7662899494171143,
0.6734722256660461,
-0.6773766875267029,
-0.13931863009929657,
-0.2401900440454483,
0.36201316118240356,
-0.2391919493675232,
-0.1877460479736328,
-0.02003299444913864,
-0.2466164380311966,
-0.7641385793685913,
0.4180572032928467,
0.20615176856517792,
-0.12852558493614197,
-0.0071824826300144196,
-0.1005813255906105,
-0.01769263669848442,
0.07278003543615341,
0.7654396295547485,
0.5207149386405945,
-0.6411779522895813,
-0.3790493607521057,
-0.309352844953537,
-0.01533129345625639,
-0.14577920734882355,
0.762263298034668,
-0.52174973487854,
0.5743513703346252,
0.29793787002563477,
0.19041095674037933,
0.31040528416633606,
-0.08488292247056961,
0.5529031157493591,
-0.7532176375389099,
0.06222754716873169,
0.31085145473480225,
0.007649362087249756,
0.20087698101997375,
-0.43374311923980713,
0.3873177468776703,
0.2854137718677521,
-0.44012922048568726,
-1.0930395126342773,
0.22383151948451996,
-1.088119387626648,
-0.6071518063545227,
1.3419699668884277,
0.037834543734788895,
-0.41039860248565674,
-0.5775290131568909,
-0.30082160234451294,
0.6922327876091003,
-0.5778278112411499,
0.6989074945449829,
0.2846442759037018,
0.15407459437847137,
-0.06658145785331726,
-0.529721200466156,
0.5282384753227234,
0.19822807610034943,
-0.8862788677215576,
0.3015629053115845,
0.49683475494384766,
0.6263866424560547,
0.293638676404953,
0.385375440120697,
-0.2967856228351593,
0.4449329972267151,
-0.17006251215934753,
0.08906775712966919,
-0.33547601103782654,
-0.22099310159683228,
-0.35528793931007385,
0.39855441451072693,
-0.4179905951023102,
-0.08564072102308273
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16668v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16668v1
|
Who is bragging more online? A large scale analysis of bragging in social media
| 2024-03-25T12:07:21 | 2024-03-25T12:07:21 |
Mali Jin, Daniel Preoţiuc-Pietro, A. Seza Doğruöz, Nikolaos Aletras
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SI
|
Bragging is the act of uttering statements that are likely to be positively
viewed by others and it is extensively employed in human communication with the
aim to build a positive self-image of oneself. Social media is a natural
platform for users to employ bragging in order to gain admiration, respect,
attention and followers from their audiences. Yet, little is known about the
scale of bragging online and its characteristics. This paper employs
computational sociolinguistics methods to conduct the first large scale study
of bragging behavior on Twitter (U.S.) by focusing on its overall prevalence,
temporal dynamics and impact of demographic factors. Our study shows that the
prevalence of bragging decreases over time within the same population of users.
In addition, younger, more educated and popular users in the U.S. are more
likely to brag. Finally, we conduct an extensive linguistics analysis to unveil
specific bragging themes associated with different user traits.
|
[
-0.509326696395874,
-0.9999856352806091,
0.027890022844076157,
0.8798388838768005,
-0.06949859112501144,
0.5840587615966797,
-0.3423703908920288,
-0.6220365762710571,
0.7402145862579346,
-0.377849280834198,
-0.40387189388275146,
-0.3155891001224518,
-0.9675045013427734,
-0.1263214498758316,
-0.33462005853652954,
0.8887844085693359,
0.10679595172405243,
-0.11248863488435745,
-0.209068164229393,
0.283549964427948,
-0.5510173439979553,
-0.7015385031700134,
-0.6551798582077026,
0.052615974098443985,
0.8761574625968933,
0.26375123858451843,
0.4054563343524933,
0.37202000617980957,
0.45309561491012573,
0.257266640663147,
-0.05535774677991867,
-0.17071418464183807,
-1.2278228998184204,
-0.0035111154429614544,
-0.4026186168193817,
-0.5319438576698303,
-0.41787633299827576,
0.019962076097726822,
0.5189765691757202,
0.3467765748500824,
0.07579922676086426,
0.6356486678123474,
0.28893524408340454,
0.660631537437439,
-0.557623565196991,
0.13869863748550415,
-0.5167628526687622,
-0.06192576140165329,
-0.40841159224510193,
-0.39366188645362854,
0.2209629863500595,
-1.0433425903320312,
0.021672241389751434,
-0.49496206641197205,
0.24419556558132172,
-0.16234737634658813,
0.7043311595916748,
-0.36838385462760925,
-0.6821956634521484,
-0.14773161709308624,
-0.5522212982177734,
0.7037343978881836,
-0.23568473756313324,
0.5991815328598022,
0.6351911425590515,
0.24158281087875366,
0.21389390528202057,
-0.43367671966552734,
-0.1111202985048294,
-0.018462935462594032,
-0.04708828032016754,
0.026821432635188103,
-0.4373766779899597,
-0.1404038965702057,
-0.10517022758722305,
0.40266889333724976,
-0.5333097577095032,
-0.01676373928785324,
-0.6579430103302002,
-0.1699342280626297,
0.6662487387657166,
-0.28113868832588196,
0.3810121417045593,
-0.2011244148015976,
-0.5471814870834351,
0.05418749526143074,
-0.24114790558815002,
0.39389199018478394,
0.40542733669281006,
0.21196423470973969,
-0.0031988383270800114,
0.6200532913208008,
-0.10401956737041473,
0.12977838516235352,
0.24642060697078705,
-0.2515537142753601,
0.07240424305200577,
-0.10550092905759811,
0.12969203293323517,
0.3594181537628174,
0.5928208231925964,
0.880847692489624,
0.8670307993888855,
-0.10118789970874786,
0.07971398532390594,
0.19037286937236786,
0.28897950053215027,
-0.7204586267471313,
0.23034541308879852,
0.021325189620256424,
-0.5220959782600403,
-0.10834237933158875,
0.38191986083984375,
-0.6040453910827637,
-0.5061292052268982,
-0.010122003965079784,
0.19989584386348724,
-0.3494304418563843,
-0.336209774017334,
-0.2548363208770752,
-0.3407403230667114,
0.1348107010126114,
0.02152901142835617,
-0.6583869457244873,
0.4681519865989685,
0.9997367262840271,
1.0505363941192627,
-0.043562788516283035,
-0.29180753231048584,
-0.41211098432540894,
0.12463533878326416,
-0.6961446404457092,
0.9140779972076416,
-0.14558467268943787,
-0.34295108914375305,
0.032101821154356,
-0.011198483407497406,
-0.0852532610297203,
-0.14117147028446198,
0.6592056751251221,
-0.7234364151954651,
-0.5096832513809204,
-0.619580864906311,
-0.6972848176956177,
0.03553460165858269,
0.24686968326568604,
-0.2643480896949768,
0.7015977501869202,
0.03558087721467018,
-0.5162270665168762,
0.7048371434211731,
-0.2744632661342621,
-0.5013426542282104,
0.3489222228527069,
0.11946296691894531,
-0.1474246382713318,
0.47252392768859863,
0.0676778107881546,
0.6597843170166016,
0.06525897979736328,
-0.006423638667911291,
-0.3534277677536011,
-0.354755163192749,
0.5595273375511169,
-0.020557129755616188,
0.2662104070186615,
0.2794005870819092,
-0.17287883162498474,
-0.27199769020080566,
0.3015512228012085,
0.0003039725706912577,
-0.11283305287361145,
-0.09090997278690338,
-0.4110438823699951,
0.08182995766401291,
-0.1778334528207779,
0.1601499319076538,
0.40800702571868896,
-0.8142728805541992,
0.22259977459907532,
-0.2072296142578125,
0.3176043629646301,
0.6890817284584045,
0.5020325779914856,
0.047784872353076935,
-0.6230254173278809,
0.44919222593307495,
-0.4246644079685211,
0.09391313791275024,
0.4495469331741333,
-0.5253747701644897,
0.18811245262622833,
-0.43615636229515076,
0.18858230113983154,
0.4605323076248169,
-0.18123723566532135,
0.2484787404537201,
-0.8454535007476807,
-0.716425359249115,
-0.15824435651302338,
0.26467329263687134,
0.33694988489151,
-0.28558528423309326,
-0.13642780482769012,
0.2141479253768921,
-0.511174738407135,
-1.0966538190841675,
-0.9867947697639465,
-0.48024848103523254,
-0.05203257128596306,
0.13901926577091217,
0.15955191850662231,
0.17913371324539185,
0.8022138476371765,
-0.7369463443756104,
-0.8786906003952026,
-0.3644488453865051,
0.4333344101905823,
-0.19214697182178497,
0.04086785018444061,
0.715938925743103,
-0.9982879757881165,
-0.7651330232620239,
0.2406661957502365,
-0.7635945677757263,
0.06699727475643158,
-0.058679983019828796,
-0.12827737629413605,
0.1588672697544098,
0.6375482678413391,
-0.21810156106948853,
0.27651405334472656,
0.49890995025634766,
-0.47473618388175964,
0.42507338523864746,
0.07502732425928116,
0.5999196767807007,
-0.5677520036697388,
-0.457152396440506,
0.8245190978050232,
-0.16535590589046478,
-0.4367799162864685,
0.015592635609209538,
-0.20754487812519073,
0.403646856546402,
-0.17310933768749237,
0.11992008984088898,
-0.5934138894081116,
-0.050870928913354874,
-0.11460757255554199,
0.16500890254974365,
-0.31662657856941223,
0.1190217137336731,
-0.15203000605106354,
0.4285796582698822,
0.8544928431510925,
-0.5577111840248108,
0.33291879296302795,
0.05122513696551323,
-0.36600449681282043,
0.8851706981658936,
-0.7741075754165649,
-0.11245046555995941,
-0.2445291429758072,
0.355479896068573,
-1.3670971393585205,
-0.5575656890869141,
-0.3573051989078522,
-1.0167614221572876,
0.08928362280130386,
-0.23638056218624115,
-0.4872778058052063,
-0.7931941151618958,
-0.6862412691116333,
0.18245893716812134,
0.43043646216392517,
-0.2861481308937073,
0.25084617733955383,
0.9033504128456116,
-0.48963284492492676,
-0.19468148052692413,
-0.9448193311691284,
0.23275278508663177,
-0.40709155797958374,
-0.8711293339729309,
0.49854326248168945,
0.272121399641037,
-0.4051887094974518,
-0.30422356724739075,
-0.13868607580661774,
-0.12945155799388885,
-0.0887562707066536,
0.11201716959476471,
0.03511784225702286,
-0.07468000799417496,
0.2504425644874573,
-0.10716615617275238,
0.3002699613571167,
0.13602431118488312,
-0.11510053277015686,
0.7843748927116394,
-0.7658610939979553,
-0.19423910975456238,
-0.6950996518135071,
0.413708359003067,
0.3388744294643402,
-0.007150295190513134,
1.125530481338501,
0.7319161891937256,
-0.314969927072525,
-0.10284142196178436,
-0.7681217193603516,
-0.2160637080669403,
-0.4276195764541626,
0.5149285197257996,
-0.3225260376930237,
-0.8378965258598328,
0.599132239818573,
0.009237638674676418,
-0.06586519628763199,
0.2919251024723053,
0.3424656391143799,
-0.30423781275749207,
1.0092207193374634,
0.6673681139945984,
-0.025802642107009888,
0.24603404104709625,
-0.09880875051021576,
0.04788476228713989,
-0.4052372872829437,
-0.07675912231206894,
-0.3055853843688965,
-0.8556268811225891,
-0.9555942416191101,
-0.28441229462623596,
0.3881068527698517,
0.11758656799793243,
0.07109514623880386,
0.30248355865478516,
-0.52191561460495,
0.5074917078018188,
0.0814172774553299,
0.256548672914505,
0.301248699426651,
0.02785360999405384,
0.716460645198822,
-0.3796865940093994,
-0.32833132147789,
-0.342034250497818,
0.6082503795623779,
0.2642838954925537,
0.843362033367157,
0.5475962162017822,
0.5899088978767395,
0.7870246767997742,
0.39478039741516113,
-0.9837765693664551,
0.6015345454216003,
-0.23654615879058838,
-0.7221826910972595,
-0.3008929491043091,
-0.6134324073791504,
-0.9884488582611084,
-0.2568112909793854,
-0.3084268867969513,
-1.0574564933776855,
0.16041867434978485,
0.3738289177417755,
-0.3421037197113037,
0.561155378818512,
-0.7417278289794922,
0.5430968403816223,
-0.3080398440361023,
-0.36222508549690247,
-0.30990859866142273,
-0.7592006921768188,
0.5457059144973755,
-0.1315547227859497,
0.5334355235099792,
-0.12158713489770889,
-0.06998713314533234,
0.6591455936431885,
0.058156173676252365,
0.9554621577262878,
-0.24648819863796234,
-0.03312531113624573,
0.3760966956615448,
0.1256180703639984,
0.35871270298957825,
-0.1496596485376358,
0.11341254413127899,
0.1286948323249817,
0.19626863300800323,
-0.4580892026424408,
-0.26398950815200806,
1.0351784229278564,
-0.8427419066429138,
-0.237404003739357,
-0.21076031029224396,
0.1685357391834259,
-0.1968206912279129,
-0.35577014088630676,
0.36936143040657043,
0.4150189757347107,
-0.7970091700553894,
0.27407750487327576,
0.4141416549682617,
-0.04065093770623207,
0.15410305559635162,
-0.2265290766954422,
-0.5639039278030396,
-0.17065145075321198,
1.5839946269989014,
0.6414101123809814,
0.2025199830532074,
0.16522035002708435,
0.3611316680908203,
-0.43315210938453674,
0.01948716677725315,
0.06421837955713272,
0.662416398525238,
-0.2874917984008789,
0.0904773622751236,
-0.5126606225967407,
-0.12504391372203827,
-0.8741699457168579,
-0.480251282453537,
-0.3588325083255768,
-0.49623531103134155,
0.13538683950901031,
-0.19666333496570587,
0.4528917670249939,
0.9907472133636475,
-0.3574075400829315,
0.611762285232544,
-0.5996456146240234,
0.3315114676952362,
0.5817151069641113,
0.6179143786430359,
0.12215594202280045,
-0.3258587121963501,
0.01712576486170292,
-0.025978848338127136,
-0.22966375946998596,
-0.8918730616569519,
0.24146580696105957,
0.6548678278923035,
0.6975941061973572,
0.7678713798522949,
-0.006192696280777454,
0.5971232056617737,
0.23233334720134735,
0.8059922456741333,
-0.0217041727155447,
-0.7669446468353271,
0.15974654257297516,
-0.6716671586036682,
-0.007903361693024635,
0.457550972700119,
0.4920707643032074,
-1.0939213037490845,
-0.3023456633090973,
-0.5118691921234131,
-0.7992069721221924,
0.26901328563690186,
0.1390232890844345,
0.3335866332054138,
-0.2207867056131363,
0.16850148141384125,
0.06408084183931351,
0.272068589925766,
-0.6639189720153809,
-0.44951140880584717,
-0.14217156171798706,
0.3786070942878723,
0.0002066738234134391,
-0.30073434114456177,
0.006519253831356764,
-0.42064595222473145,
0.6059057712554932,
0.03618433699011803,
0.30330607295036316,
-0.05619323253631592,
-0.2356199026107788,
-0.22695986926555634,
0.2091962695121765,
0.25666406750679016,
0.7434547543525696,
-0.35767456889152527,
0.11873505264520645,
0.14040729403495789,
-0.49232250452041626,
-0.1418471336364746,
-0.23533640801906586,
0.2588735818862915,
-0.0748857855796814,
0.21598798036575317,
0.48112472891807556,
0.3299214541912079,
-0.21050989627838135,
0.7131064534187317,
-0.06431853026151657,
-0.510161280632019,
-0.4630914032459259,
-0.42251136898994446,
0.461609423160553,
-0.04937964677810669,
0.7995718717575073,
0.08928524702787399,
-0.02521362528204918,
-0.7712554335594177,
0.17328326404094696,
0.5012000799179077,
-0.5694679021835327,
-0.4625636339187622,
0.7104913592338562,
0.028825543820858,
-0.292094349861145,
-0.0037033306434750557,
-0.43081778287887573,
-0.5590023398399353,
0.3869817852973938,
0.45548006892204285,
0.708097517490387,
-0.03912780061364174,
0.694247305393219,
0.5141538977622986,
0.21196284890174866,
-0.02388700284063816,
0.02287212945520878,
0.056080643087625504,
-0.38651612401008606,
-0.3460364043712616,
-0.8229158520698547,
0.16499896347522736,
-0.4833063781261444,
-0.729412853717804,
0.43642306327819824,
-0.3509802222251892,
-0.7880823612213135,
0.06973353773355484,
-0.1492047756910324,
-0.38401204347610474,
0.06728256493806839,
0.401154100894928,
0.3916724622249603,
-0.7144116759300232,
-0.02078111469745636,
0.8384135961532593,
-0.06655190140008926,
-0.6958349943161011,
0.36225271224975586,
0.6058129072189331,
-0.6421681046485901,
0.8150416612625122,
0.20800626277923584,
-0.47586849331855774,
0.22673442959785461,
-0.6528666615486145,
-0.6416705846786499,
0.6608292460441589,
0.09698151051998138,
0.06259511411190033,
-0.039341188967227936,
0.21412554383277893,
0.7498533129692078,
-0.07176081091165543,
0.04122235253453255,
0.5453878045082092,
0.3856847584247589,
0.3915785551071167,
-0.9772088527679443,
-0.2068892866373062,
-0.018888460472226143,
0.052075035870075226,
0.187565416097641,
-1.0150526762008667,
0.8704501986503601,
-0.1995122879743576,
-0.6921237707138062,
-0.31777456402778625,
0.9170311689376831,
-0.015153972432017326,
0.11009731888771057,
0.5593942999839783,
0.17645972967147827,
0.6506403684616089,
-0.06779486685991287,
0.7942830324172974,
-0.2267618328332901,
0.301016241312027,
0.5415747761726379,
0.1799306869506836,
0.6364239454269409,
-0.041721832007169724,
-0.3577190637588501,
0.6690459251403809,
0.5467835068702698,
0.15432938933372498,
-0.07215791940689087,
0.3865080773830414,
-0.1626848578453064,
-0.27181774377822876,
-0.20346735417842865,
-0.4905106723308563,
0.7268280386924744,
0.35590848326683044,
-0.27592724561691284,
-0.2755739390850067,
0.15233203768730164,
0.36634811758995056,
0.3141147196292877,
-0.7610839605331421,
0.8961871862411499,
-0.021535031497478485,
-0.5372701287269592,
0.47678956389427185,
-0.27173131704330444,
1.0018253326416016,
-0.6874082088470459,
0.35479456186294556,
-0.019540537148714066,
0.3087444305419922,
-0.5656347274780273,
-0.8819003105163574,
0.368228942155838,
0.13213492929935455,
0.13434584438800812,
-0.3737947642803192,
0.7288017272949219,
-0.02273453027009964,
-0.5704490542411804,
0.6026464104652405,
0.7965724468231201,
0.5435847640037537,
-0.45997923612594604,
-0.13608703017234802,
-0.45976778864860535,
-0.18316659331321716,
-0.20447148382663727,
0.40853676199913025,
0.4228978455066681,
-0.26230624318122864,
0.8103019595146179,
0.6339942216873169,
0.2949317991733551,
0.3973512053489685,
0.20367088913917542,
0.7223809957504272,
-0.3567982614040375,
-0.6682720184326172,
-1.1345916986465454,
0.10054317861795425,
-0.4668062627315521,
-0.4479227662086487,
1.445847988128662,
0.6641184687614441,
0.40480557084083557,
-0.004468039609491825,
0.6012457609176636,
-0.39921021461486816,
0.6715167760848999,
0.3610449731349945,
0.9886491894721985,
-0.5944474935531616,
-0.10155872255563736,
-0.6045992374420166,
-0.7960889339447021,
0.08834360539913177,
0.16927021741867065,
-0.42743104696273804,
0.012614739127457142,
0.1123729795217514,
0.49898773431777954,
0.24750927090644836,
0.23192943632602692,
0.37522196769714355,
0.3033205270767212,
-0.01192608941346407,
-0.23803183436393738,
0.7903338074684143,
0.2809458374977112,
0.5352436304092407,
-0.11336399614810944,
-0.7622608542442322,
-0.21155361831188202,
-0.5524046421051025,
-0.886353611946106,
-0.42732226848602295,
-0.25657007098197937,
-0.2807622253894806,
-0.0689835324883461,
1.0665204524993896,
0.61093670129776,
-0.5079947710037231,
-0.4861065447330475,
0.2106497883796692,
0.18655118346214294,
-0.5500440001487732,
-0.3719180226325989,
-0.04354783520102501,
-0.22913914918899536,
-0.43807509541511536,
-0.11749445647001266,
0.05112437158823013,
-0.30488526821136475,
-0.328567773103714,
0.5015906691551208,
-0.5269823670387268,
0.391292005777359,
0.8163560032844543,
0.5504190325737,
-0.30369043350219727,
-0.28945404291152954,
0.4730232357978821,
-0.06762835383415222,
0.10636764019727707,
0.6027209758758545,
-0.36905643343925476,
0.22999411821365356,
0.6513192057609558,
0.0914459154009819,
0.6101616024971008,
0.7862453460693359,
0.4079212248325348,
-0.9173152446746826,
-0.5359582901000977,
-0.027997009456157684,
-0.1971299797296524,
0.4268459975719452,
-0.5281963348388672,
0.17020024359226227,
0.5250982046127319,
-0.7716876268386841,
-0.6075396537780762,
-0.1927005648612976,
-0.875035285949707,
-0.24220693111419678,
1.1288142204284668,
0.23604056239128113,
-0.2052769660949707,
-0.10599539428949356,
-0.1971607506275177,
0.2996934652328491,
-0.7911344766616821,
0.948716938495636,
0.8017765283584595,
-0.31727322936058044,
0.2945796549320221,
-0.42357170581817627,
0.40781673789024353,
-0.20220625400543213,
-0.743420422077179,
0.16708797216415405,
0.37109246850013733,
0.2856850028038025,
0.402944952249527,
0.41170045733451843,
0.28452521562576294,
-0.13305355608463287,
0.04285499081015587,
-0.16049398481845856,
0.4141884744167328,
-0.15382862091064453,
0.19303959608078003,
0.5158624053001404,
-0.3138117492198944,
0.04454047232866287
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16662v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16662v2
|
RU22Fact: Optimizing Evidence for Multilingual Explainable Fact-Checking on Russia-Ukraine Conflict
| 2024-03-25T11:56:29 | 2024-03-26T07:13:15 |
Yirong Zeng, Xiao Ding, Yi Zhao, Xiangyu Li, Jie Zhang, Chao Yao, Ting Liu, Bing Qin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Fact-checking is the task of verifying the factuality of a given claim by
examining the available evidence. High-quality evidence plays a vital role in
enhancing fact-checking systems and facilitating the generation of explanations
that are understandable to humans. However, the provision of both sufficient
and relevant evidence for explainable fact-checking systems poses a challenge.
To tackle this challenge, we propose a method based on a Large Language Model
to automatically retrieve and summarize evidence from the Web. Furthermore, we
construct RU22Fact, a novel multilingual explainable fact-checking dataset on
the Russia-Ukraine conflict in 2022 of 16K samples, each containing real-world
claims, optimized evidence, and referenced explanation. To establish a baseline
for our dataset, we also develop an end-to-end explainable fact-checking system
to verify claims and generate explanations. Experimental results demonstrate
the prospect of optimized evidence in increasing fact-checking performance and
also indicate the possibility of further progress in the end-to-end claim
verification and explanation generation tasks.
|
[
-0.4198041260242462,
-0.6077569127082825,
0.6583200097084045,
0.18488767743110657,
-0.40814152359962463,
0.022297179326415062,
-0.0006722849793732166,
-0.4815993905067444,
-0.20857477188110352,
0.088373102247715,
-0.5596028566360474,
-0.3202263414859772,
-0.5971832871437073,
0.36097562313079834,
-0.3478088080883026,
1.1093822717666626,
-0.1987227499485016,
0.418254017829895,
-0.17885270714759827,
-0.28932592272758484,
-0.0264236181974411,
-0.3891555368900299,
-0.27767592668533325,
-0.44230473041534424,
0.34375062584877014,
0.8007429838180542,
0.3550509214401245,
0.709838330745697,
0.5454080700874329,
0.4680693745613098,
0.2800053358078003,
0.16123364865779877,
-0.3510628044605255,
0.06078016012907028,
-0.2962867319583893,
-0.5739009976387024,
-0.37142905592918396,
-0.1222853884100914,
0.5295937061309814,
0.32466885447502136,
-0.41244617104530334,
0.370254248380661,
-0.3201605975627899,
0.3484765291213989,
-0.516247570514679,
-0.14891169965267181,
-0.5625541806221008,
-0.077799953520298,
0.09699554741382599,
-0.1916949599981308,
-0.2783462405204773,
-0.42014461755752563,
0.189203679561615,
-0.7237293720245361,
0.4473787248134613,
0.0015241153305396438,
1.2691017389297485,
-0.20772936940193176,
-0.5839298963546753,
-0.2812785804271698,
-0.3810729682445526,
0.6256536841392517,
-0.5503155589103699,
0.5031815767288208,
0.2930200397968292,
0.11708104610443115,
-0.11774283647537231,
-0.4693673551082611,
-0.5879458785057068,
0.02481224574148655,
-0.2570926547050476,
0.3669421374797821,
-0.36277663707733154,
-0.3487502336502075,
0.2143767923116684,
0.05541117489337921,
-0.8514190912246704,
-0.09814433753490448,
-0.04770512878894806,
-0.6598366498947144,
0.43689200282096863,
-0.08784833550453186,
0.40863823890686035,
-0.2916572690010071,
-0.25689488649368286,
0.12794645130634308,
-0.7076565623283386,
0.0743812620639801,
0.6548612713813782,
0.056323494762182236,
-0.2939768135547638,
0.6052302718162537,
-0.6744166612625122,
0.5621732473373413,
-0.057348012924194336,
-0.37704479694366455,
-0.21069107949733734,
-0.7222967147827148,
-0.05857406556606293,
0.14331121742725372,
0.6209316849708557,
0.6064358353614807,
-0.16457752883434296,
-0.16820164024829865,
0.09160508215427399,
0.3390137553215027,
-0.07751157879829407,
-1.212600588798523,
-0.056383803486824036,
0.4338799715042114,
-0.4643595814704895,
-0.27857059240341187,
-0.017880573868751526,
-1.3068394660949707,
-0.28464606404304504,
-0.2521655559539795,
0.5864325761795044,
-0.1771010309457779,
-0.2617075443267822,
0.27230843901634216,
-0.23364265263080597,
-0.26230430603027344,
0.43390554189682007,
-0.4343271255493164,
-0.045219723135232925,
0.4562910497188568,
0.6455785632133484,
0.11850082129240036,
-0.17631179094314575,
-0.9632460474967957,
-0.17573557794094086,
-0.39167311787605286,
1.0722119808197021,
-0.38474833965301514,
0.05943726375699043,
0.2290002554655075,
0.2330065369606018,
0.6574531197547913,
-0.32087865471839905,
0.781586229801178,
-0.5627827644348145,
0.4465377628803253,
-0.46870750188827515,
-0.31843453645706177,
-0.14943790435791016,
0.2912678122520447,
-0.5611906051635742,
0.7638705968856812,
-0.4089035987854004,
-0.7997857928276062,
0.7724188566207886,
-0.7489339709281921,
-0.5485766530036926,
0.15721657872200012,
0.038243964314460754,
-0.554900050163269,
-0.11368913948535919,
0.12935927510261536,
0.4004344642162323,
-0.3075529932975769,
0.5742608308792114,
-0.20511510968208313,
0.1783396303653717,
0.4066985249519348,
-0.17027011513710022,
0.7355457544326782,
0.19890858232975006,
-0.5131153464317322,
0.10041294246912003,
-0.9871100783348083,
-0.27314823865890503,
0.26138219237327576,
-0.9175401329994202,
-0.09427864849567413,
0.2821519076824188,
-0.1254199594259262,
0.15483757853507996,
0.44022268056869507,
-0.877047061920166,
-0.020856212824583054,
-0.06275337934494019,
0.21361097693443298,
0.30840951204299927,
-0.0043581328354775906,
0.24531684815883636,
-0.24145810306072235,
0.4306383430957794,
0.13198448717594147,
0.1758134365081787,
-0.5503653883934021,
-0.10611895471811295,
-0.9952166080474854,
-0.03362726420164108,
0.34170278906822205,
0.5888161659240723,
-0.6487368941307068,
0.27258533239364624,
-0.194151371717453,
-0.3299126923084259,
-0.430249959230423,
-0.16290417313575745,
0.2645120620727539,
0.5626312494277954,
0.3969745934009552,
0.20158308744430542,
-0.8151805996894836,
-1.0629985332489014,
-0.34993791580200195,
-0.3239579200744629,
0.30965113639831543,
-0.014784346334636211,
0.7000724673271179,
0.14788848161697388,
0.8669010996818542,
-0.4099139869213104,
0.2038966715335846,
-0.13016706705093384,
0.4945267140865326,
-0.033475883305072784,
0.31651052832603455,
0.19183947145938873,
-0.992698609828949,
-0.40153273940086365,
0.25686490535736084,
-0.7994996905326843,
-0.1638738512992859,
-0.35630419850349426,
-0.1463877409696579,
0.45607247948646545,
0.3586832582950592,
-0.4780498445034027,
0.3760901391506195,
0.4415911138057709,
-0.6106851100921631,
0.7415867447853088,
-0.31652888655662537,
0.5312361121177673,
-0.9587923884391785,
0.31078040599823,
0.045709144324064255,
-0.621171772480011,
-0.5316070914268494,
0.20688492059707642,
0.3384057879447937,
-0.06400924921035767,
-0.11396858841180801,
0.08100070059299469,
-0.4519718289375305,
0.08792556077241898,
-0.28605401515960693,
0.21051445603370667,
0.07918078452348709,
0.15647739171981812,
-0.06549826264381409,
0.7859039306640625,
0.5516557097434998,
-0.45900148153305054,
0.3278921842575073,
0.16957904398441315,
-0.6754549145698547,
0.5822001099586487,
-0.3136371970176697,
-0.45205146074295044,
-0.12401624023914337,
0.1805478036403656,
-1.0696676969528198,
-0.548706591129303,
-0.10046789050102234,
-0.5567206144332886,
-0.04743548855185509,
-0.6020590662956238,
-0.403240442276001,
0.026124093681573868,
0.1323121041059494,
0.015948409214615822,
0.32826775312423706,
-0.685005247592926,
0.8100779056549072,
0.3723466098308563,
-0.36621081829071045,
-0.9238560199737549,
-0.2982940673828125,
0.5762598514556885,
-0.5551483035087585,
-0.54669588804245,
0.23966291546821594,
-0.17898975312709808,
-0.48088258504867554,
0.0025229796301573515,
-0.2508937418460846,
-0.12650837004184723,
0.049698732793331146,
0.031955376267433167,
0.13634584844112396,
-0.2649371922016144,
0.19010981917381287,
-0.29338663816452026,
-0.1614309400320053,
0.28146257996559143,
-0.00866114255040884,
0.34739410877227783,
-0.16627608239650726,
-0.2730898857116699,
-0.6083793640136719,
0.7039816379547119,
0.7674466371536255,
-0.28644806146621704,
0.5806416869163513,
0.7081630825996399,
-0.3116942048072815,
-0.08953574299812317,
-0.8078504800796509,
-0.36311259865760803,
-0.41015148162841797,
0.5614644289016724,
-0.2546039819717407,
-0.7139624357223511,
0.8396470546722412,
-0.46467530727386475,
0.13323234021663666,
0.4690391719341278,
0.5083139538764954,
0.01680375076830387,
0.9834399819374084,
0.5827154517173767,
0.1719362437725067,
0.23513975739479065,
0.0351024754345417,
0.353089302778244,
-0.16367866098880768,
-0.4470584988594055,
-0.8363085389137268,
0.19245226681232452,
-0.3333195447921753,
-0.01332792080938816,
0.20864605903625488,
-0.016164790838956833,
0.07320444285869598,
0.12770482897758484,
0.005049755331128836,
0.5533897876739502,
0.3447463810443878,
-0.001665821997448802,
0.4402075707912445,
0.0808793306350708,
-0.2828875482082367,
-0.03790479898452759,
-0.7949960827827454,
-0.25196409225463867,
0.7081118226051331,
0.061994027346372604,
0.5742800831794739,
0.6484113931655884,
0.3698486089706421,
0.17142514884471893,
0.13842624425888062,
-0.6234405040740967,
0.47952038049697876,
0.17149677872657776,
-0.8836054801940918,
-0.17063599824905396,
-0.475991815328598,
-0.969706118106842,
0.2570452392101288,
-0.6890828609466553,
-0.6576880812644958,
0.128499835729599,
0.39849853515625,
-0.18065142631530762,
0.04788608476519585,
-0.6481993198394775,
0.7515736222267151,
-0.3011341094970703,
-0.6045501828193665,
-0.7228009104728699,
-0.49106577038764954,
0.4469881057739258,
-0.18484604358673096,
0.49985745549201965,
0.11340577900409698,
0.10180456191301346,
0.6487425565719604,
-0.5674735903739929,
0.46905994415283203,
-0.17011208832263947,
-0.27289441227912903,
-0.07958608865737915,
0.1933460831642151,
0.6799114346504211,
0.38272207975387573,
0.10983235388994217,
-0.16563114523887634,
-0.09205548465251923,
-0.3748348355293274,
-0.4310225546360016,
0.5731344223022461,
-0.5940112471580505,
-0.5830570459365845,
-0.5545337200164795,
-0.3453497886657715,
0.12517286837100983,
0.23022066056728363,
0.33452215790748596,
0.9262147545814514,
-0.454166978597641,
0.37426042556762695,
0.7923787832260132,
-0.2803822159767151,
0.5509716868400574,
1.2355895042419434,
-0.2904833257198334,
-0.22971242666244507,
1.053941249847412,
0.1715656816959381,
-0.00326488702557981,
0.6078758239746094,
0.4850749373435974,
-0.41397935152053833,
-0.7493583559989929,
-0.7399404644966125,
-0.01734558306634426,
-0.8339313864707947,
-0.3205382823944092,
-0.6701777577400208,
0.4467760920524597,
-0.05238707736134529,
0.19835852086544037,
-0.2755798399448395,
-0.3072739541530609,
0.15966662764549255,
0.02224687486886978,
0.3752274513244629,
0.8273425102233887,
-0.5058591961860657,
0.24659432470798492,
-0.5167425274848938,
0.6940409541130066,
0.3458682894706726,
0.4155678451061249,
-0.2647571265697479,
-0.5713418126106262,
-0.7134439945220947,
0.0516129806637764,
-0.08840449899435043,
-1.184959053993225,
0.06400745362043381,
0.12554416060447693,
0.4107457101345062,
0.5183961391448975,
0.04823513701558113,
0.8556181192398071,
-0.5253251791000366,
0.7008262872695923,
0.131238654255867,
-0.9191301465034485,
0.4382385313510895,
-0.49985626339912415,
0.16857345402240753,
0.31380826234817505,
0.5423114895820618,
-0.3740997314453125,
0.09186446666717529,
-0.6675987243652344,
-0.700701117515564,
0.8018202781677246,
0.02262386493384838,
-0.38749274611473083,
0.31776899099349976,
0.23842570185661316,
0.2927357852458954,
-0.0837312787771225,
-0.6964476704597473,
-0.161362886428833,
-0.3001704514026642,
-0.13432027399539948,
0.1472715139389038,
-0.2873901426792145,
-0.6268039345741272,
-0.03935319557785988,
0.9909389615058899,
-0.3216158151626587,
0.16039247810840607,
0.319343239068985,
-0.4966592788696289,
-0.45532575249671936,
0.5137583017349243,
0.9293211102485657,
1.1366591453552246,
0.04327685758471489,
0.3924531638622284,
0.38353052735328674,
-0.5079931616783142,
0.21401704847812653,
0.27094700932502747,
-0.12049368023872375,
0.20402857661247253,
0.3417570888996124,
0.45082852244377136,
0.018027298152446747,
-0.9670324325561523,
0.689574658870697,
-0.36889415979385376,
-0.38042452931404114,
-0.31034085154533386,
-0.25807827711105347,
0.2162804901599884,
0.2532115876674652,
0.5864731669425964,
0.0031024222262203693,
0.1844967156648636,
-0.5330795645713806,
0.28692251443862915,
0.5179416537284851,
0.2321612536907196,
-0.35649722814559937,
0.11010189354419708,
0.2180788815021515,
-0.17751041054725647,
0.12472433596849442,
-0.21752405166625977,
-0.7199639678001404,
0.5402570366859436,
0.3282747268676758,
0.31780391931533813,
-0.20293019711971283,
0.5046148300170898,
0.5960477590560913,
0.360946923494339,
0.057475652545690536,
0.4630333483219147,
0.21638628840446472,
-0.625238299369812,
-1.0010454654693604,
-0.3121336102485657,
-0.3067924976348877,
0.6734136939048767,
-0.7926118969917297,
0.15124934911727905,
-0.22268211841583252,
0.05505383759737015,
0.45675423741340637,
0.08908705413341522,
-0.6349796056747437,
0.3593822121620178,
-0.19167263805866241,
0.6241002082824707,
-0.9678870439529419,
0.2695048153400421,
0.4409935474395752,
-0.12561734020709991,
-0.38613566756248474,
-0.07311920076608658,
0.2422143667936325,
-0.7391877174377441,
0.606200098991394,
0.055856335908174515,
-0.26988494396209717,
-0.30311667919158936,
-0.6771268844604492,
-0.9086384773254395,
0.561118483543396,
0.6277469396591187,
-0.4363659620285034,
0.4958203136920929,
0.02687930501997471,
0.2714080512523651,
-0.21054360270500183,
0.1695888191461563,
0.3944533169269562,
0.7886691093444824,
-0.4063618779182434,
-0.5657709240913391,
0.194560244679451,
-0.4299969971179962,
-0.9208294749259949,
0.34867069125175476,
-0.7047761082649231,
0.31667831540107727,
-0.33832648396492004,
-0.3974338173866272,
0.06389465928077698,
0.4929990768432617,
-0.16521835327148438,
0.1072869822382927,
0.5237622857093811,
0.6906646490097046,
0.5942736864089966,
-0.2534855604171753,
0.6524200439453125,
-0.42095303535461426,
0.28266680240631104,
1.0125901699066162,
0.03985580429434776,
0.7650004029273987,
0.4593666195869446,
-0.14938095211982727,
0.8003959655761719,
0.6007425785064697,
-0.20791296660900116,
0.30850866436958313,
-0.07180684059858322,
-0.49369698762893677,
-0.7270187139511108,
-0.4236449599266052,
-0.03454182296991348,
0.7232697606086731,
0.3652019202709198,
-0.0009540721657685935,
-0.580647885799408,
-0.14864879846572876,
0.32205677032470703,
-0.05581514164805412,
0.18355518579483032,
1.1609519720077515,
-0.6168855428695679,
-1.235163688659668,
0.40159615874290466,
0.2557876706123352,
0.2502973675727844,
-0.8329088091850281,
-0.2837066948413849,
-0.08239179104566574,
0.12180187553167343,
-0.3595643639564514,
-0.7418894171714783,
-0.03857846185564995,
0.46921899914741516,
-0.26164737343788147,
-0.054508861154317856,
0.6169440746307373,
-0.6901223659515381,
-0.1978289783000946,
0.15910761058330536,
0.597117006778717,
0.2031627893447876,
0.08531101047992706,
-0.5835275650024414,
0.09334444999694824,
0.09995251893997192,
-0.2317555844783783,
0.37836316227912903,
0.7032949328422546,
0.1382492631673813,
0.7282559275627136,
0.8938133120536804,
0.0827258825302124,
-0.1819240301847458,
0.010758795775473118,
0.7081144452095032,
-0.194556325674057,
-0.6086028814315796,
-1.0181214809417725,
0.7974856495857239,
-0.21069630980491638,
-0.20811882615089417,
0.7522929906845093,
0.9134687781333923,
0.33507922291755676,
0.15277859568595886,
1.178289771080017,
-0.1673273742198944,
0.48846176266670227,
-0.5270313620567322,
0.7606198787689209,
-0.6547834277153015,
-0.5012720227241516,
0.10390865057706833,
-0.38283005356788635,
-0.07440265268087387,
0.5997447967529297,
0.22536499798297882,
-0.2350805550813675,
0.9783130884170532,
0.8336239457130432,
-0.24828307330608368,
0.09149443358182907,
0.12222757935523987,
0.47828346490859985,
0.21096301078796387,
0.14559045433998108,
0.7621363401412964,
-0.2702314257621765,
0.8511524796485901,
-0.1255752444267273,
-0.3399425148963928,
-0.36908644437789917,
-1.425613284111023,
-0.8755318522453308,
-0.824165940284729,
-0.3277669847011566,
-0.5180740356445312,
-0.058491066098213196,
0.6429582834243774,
0.8835440278053284,
-0.7608880400657654,
-0.1163526102900505,
-0.1905261129140854,
0.09314054995775223,
0.16420578956604004,
-0.085450679063797,
0.3265810012817383,
-0.15865616500377655,
-0.4394627809524536,
0.5452550053596497,
0.05182712525129318,
0.0705675557255745,
-0.27553513646125793,
-0.16928523778915405,
-0.5156548619270325,
0.023260748013854027,
0.4609895348548889,
0.2644772231578827,
-0.8796417713165283,
-0.3134559690952301,
-0.11762173473834991,
0.46699953079223633,
0.06671129167079926,
1.035524606704712,
-0.41336098313331604,
0.6746904850006104,
0.6107222437858582,
0.6379950642585754,
0.5388034582138062,
0.11885840445756912,
0.5571019649505615,
-0.4716590940952301,
-0.019834062084555626,
-0.28914061188697815,
0.7544567584991455,
0.5960360169410706,
-0.3082859516143799,
0.26159337162971497,
0.27117034792900085,
-0.618037223815918,
-0.7717674374580383,
0.39144328236579895,
-0.8985176086425781,
-0.37279006838798523,
0.9138862490653992,
-0.38296690583229065,
0.17437613010406494,
-0.636703372001648,
-0.05239503085613251,
0.4949265420436859,
-0.5966095328330994,
1.0633900165557861,
1.1864434480667114,
0.16975471377372742,
-0.1976788341999054,
-0.6152198910713196,
0.7296401262283325,
0.5613623261451721,
-1.2506186962127686,
0.569865345954895,
0.6315563917160034,
0.4801546633243561,
0.3686026930809021,
-0.21162645518779755,
0.20535461604595184,
0.5367580652236938,
0.07215867936611176,
0.028939280658960342,
0.01769706979393959,
-0.5218047499656677,
-0.2876879572868347,
0.33907127380371094,
-0.3304513394832611,
0.20330747961997986
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16655v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16655v1
|
Grammatical vs Spelling Error Correction: An Investigation into the Responsiveness of Transformer-based Language Models using BART and MarianMT
| 2024-03-25T11:45:21 | 2024-03-25T11:45:21 |
Rohit Raju, Peeta Basa Pati, SA Gandheesh, Gayatri Sanjana Sannala, Suriya KS
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Text continues to remain a relevant form of representation for information.
Text documents are created either in digital native platforms or through the
conversion of other media files such as images and speech. While the digital
native text is invariably obtained through physical or virtual keyboards,
technologies such as OCR and speech recognition are utilized to transform the
images and speech signals into text content. All these variety of mechanisms of
text generation also introduce errors into the captured text.
This project aims at analyzing different kinds of error that occurs in text
documents. The work employs two of the advanced deep neural network-based
language models, namely, BART and MarianMT, to rectify the anomalies present in
the text. Transfer learning of these models with available dataset is performed
to finetune their capacity for error correction. A comparative study is
conducted to investigate the effectiveness of these models in handling each of
the defined error categories. It is observed that while both models can bring
down the erroneous sentences by 20+%, BART can handle spelling errors far
better (24.6%) than grammatical errors (8.8%).
|
[
0.3051226735115051,
-1.0901433229446411,
0.5331400632858276,
0.22937045991420746,
0.3692593276500702,
0.2867349684238434,
-0.4129559099674225,
-0.406438946723938,
-0.050488077104091644,
0.5329051613807678,
-0.34485942125320435,
-0.21405260264873505,
-0.6401185393333435,
0.43386310338974,
-0.46346449851989746,
0.6710523962974548,
-0.2910114526748657,
0.3488140106201172,
-0.24493883550167084,
0.08516830205917358,
-0.7438697814941406,
-0.7811119556427002,
-0.8175926208496094,
0.06716151535511017,
0.48447731137275696,
0.31739744544029236,
0.710899293422699,
0.29502204060554504,
0.9230276942253113,
0.3979123830795288,
-0.1395300328731537,
0.25601282715797424,
-0.2532239556312561,
0.3811171352863312,
-0.29087504744529724,
-0.7483677864074707,
-0.6797460913658142,
-0.23563982546329498,
0.6119087338447571,
0.7347500324249268,
-0.07991497963666916,
-0.02797250635921955,
-0.06191089004278183,
0.8237408399581909,
-0.40771961212158203,
0.1845051646232605,
-0.6463125348091125,
0.030798276886343956,
-0.2189847230911255,
0.13764968514442444,
-0.7023544907569885,
-0.6801189184188843,
0.03120691515505314,
-0.7373989224433899,
0.4571145474910736,
0.005946984048932791,
0.7868243455886841,
0.40633830428123474,
-0.3361071050167084,
-0.6205801367759705,
-1.0802927017211914,
0.5711901187896729,
-0.855873167514801,
0.3461269736289978,
0.4912404716014862,
0.05730340629816055,
-0.25791454315185547,
-0.8857908844947815,
-0.8230659365653992,
-0.006318394560366869,
-0.05477910861372948,
0.18789739906787872,
-0.3019256591796875,
0.21964584290981293,
0.25085562467575073,
0.3978005051612854,
-0.5714903473854065,
0.2225285768508911,
-0.3848262131214142,
-0.16409149765968323,
0.392355740070343,
0.22417286038398743,
0.4522216320037842,
-0.2956385314464569,
0.22219139337539673,
-0.37498775124549866,
-0.3194236159324646,
-0.015378577634692192,
0.3627667725086212,
0.5225546360015869,
0.08587022870779037,
0.7804348468780518,
0.1014491468667984,
0.47366955876350403,
0.1199699342250824,
-0.05658269301056862,
0.10663042217493057,
-0.41334018111228943,
-0.4830962121486664,
0.03429236635565758,
0.7280759811401367,
0.20596355199813843,
0.3084186613559723,
0.036249127238988876,
-0.16496410965919495,
0.23049230873584747,
0.5415822863578796,
-0.24188350141048431,
-0.21505126357078552,
-0.12436957657337189,
-0.4366232454776764,
-0.3840078115463257,
0.07101926952600479,
-0.691348135471344,
-0.4818505346775055,
-0.5410611033439636,
0.47682371735572815,
-0.3914955258369446,
-0.10535025596618652,
0.21458153426647186,
0.12747687101364136,
-0.37239736318588257,
0.5206277966499329,
-0.8988962769508362,
0.2974782884120941,
0.2954038679599762,
0.5671160221099854,
0.12262433767318726,
-0.10232944786548615,
-0.1137678250670433,
-0.1854182630777359,
-0.4014793932437897,
0.7409467101097107,
-0.10566474497318268,
-0.2530907690525055,
0.15159901976585388,
0.15018083155155182,
-0.6265292167663574,
-0.3864269256591797,
0.8059287071228027,
-0.6113343834877014,
0.6491122245788574,
-0.27212047576904297,
-0.622796893119812,
-0.4474339187145233,
0.30083563923835754,
-1.0835093259811401,
1.3563693761825562,
0.22236472368240356,
-0.743877649307251,
-0.03790386766195297,
-0.7729641795158386,
-0.4693676233291626,
-0.0986124724149704,
0.26560497283935547,
-0.5901525616645813,
0.2983402907848358,
0.2973475456237793,
0.41225647926330566,
-0.14438346028327942,
0.28680676221847534,
-0.008108592592179775,
-0.1590806543827057,
0.5532641410827637,
-0.747941255569458,
0.6247456073760986,
-0.04361134022474289,
-0.37778419256210327,
0.011384055018424988,
-1.076100468635559,
-0.09299929440021515,
0.19258268177509308,
-0.7858860492706299,
-0.36289986968040466,
-0.02039065770804882,
0.39140912890434265,
0.10716085880994797,
0.1302548199892044,
-0.5671110153198242,
0.3734000027179718,
-0.31559520959854126,
0.5361366868019104,
0.4830845594406128,
-0.2973548173904419,
0.5796087384223938,
-0.21759136021137238,
0.5541836619377136,
-0.14795619249343872,
0.08063822239637375,
-0.2791612148284912,
-0.39419323205947876,
-0.974061131477356,
0.13117116689682007,
0.7579355835914612,
0.7677110433578491,
-0.9381160736083984,
0.2744252383708954,
-0.40027549862861633,
-0.2873007655143738,
-0.8497118353843689,
-0.1406514197587967,
0.3683862090110779,
0.7454965114593506,
0.3505222201347351,
-0.1192888393998146,
-0.728982150554657,
-0.4717083275318146,
-0.2379562109708786,
-0.42645731568336487,
0.4072471559047699,
0.14153867959976196,
0.27608251571655273,
-0.36288315057754517,
0.9234223961830139,
-0.11253554373979568,
-0.33083587884902954,
-0.2407698631286621,
0.09050393849611282,
0.08941786736249924,
0.3300887942314148,
0.5247740149497986,
-0.8303428292274475,
-0.5491185188293457,
0.11554772406816483,
-0.8036971688270569,
-0.19657300412654877,
-0.21936115622520447,
0.286761075258255,
0.892669141292572,
0.49079814553260803,
-0.32427263259887695,
0.6263131499290466,
0.5510955452919006,
-0.3767380118370056,
0.7375591397285461,
-0.5197080969810486,
0.3686123192310333,
-1.0386543273925781,
0.023045752197504044,
-0.1432589739561081,
-0.38317930698394775,
-0.7187209725379944,
0.10136052221059799,
0.4108397364616394,
0.08041500300168991,
-0.41988781094551086,
0.1575959175825119,
-0.38534626364707947,
0.12774725258350372,
-0.2807970941066742,
-0.07759293168783188,
0.24907708168029785,
0.2387852966785431,
-0.12841686606407166,
0.7298582196235657,
0.11162229627370834,
-0.4632027745246887,
0.4919392466545105,
0.29754501581192017,
-0.017991818487644196,
0.6023043394088745,
-0.39657777547836304,
0.041822757571935654,
-0.28451088070869446,
0.15587563812732697,
-1.1746329069137573,
-0.3288620114326477,
0.3698408007621765,
-0.5266379714012146,
0.6677671074867249,
0.18985511362552643,
-0.8237765431404114,
-0.5649289488792419,
0.0032612949144095182,
0.26730185747146606,
0.21759378910064697,
-0.40044987201690674,
0.5522749423980713,
0.043407849967479706,
-0.3922090232372284,
-0.4504871070384979,
-0.9203859567642212,
0.3027634024620056,
0.1609879434108734,
-0.658221960067749,
0.1549525409936905,
-0.014798203483223915,
-0.11136852204799652,
0.319235235452652,
0.24971938133239746,
-0.1092965304851532,
0.12899625301361084,
0.262771338224411,
0.4278472065925598,
-0.45969071984291077,
0.44234031438827515,
0.16971448063850403,
0.06297677010297775,
-0.10677240043878555,
-0.05083838477730751,
0.32360079884529114,
-0.20825284719467163,
-0.37924519181251526,
-0.5343501567840576,
0.21886907517910004,
0.7600681781768799,
-0.051665615290403366,
0.9009036421775818,
0.4130997359752655,
-0.5244178771972656,
0.21931326389312744,
-0.8668456077575684,
0.06902305781841278,
-0.38126808404922485,
0.40285003185272217,
-0.1820017546415329,
-0.6974894404411316,
0.5396943688392639,
0.057443827390670776,
-0.2010226547718048,
0.7819808125495911,
0.30333030223846436,
-0.3856336772441864,
0.6552391648292542,
0.7491543292999268,
-0.03788730129599571,
0.3922678530216217,
-0.14451755583286285,
0.35199475288391113,
-0.5943316221237183,
-0.24501435458660126,
-0.7185539603233337,
-0.2719125747680664,
-0.4040059447288513,
-0.3626520335674286,
0.07702329009771347,
0.04239758849143982,
-0.013217356987297535,
0.594316303730011,
-0.4135894775390625,
0.14895671606063843,
0.8105946183204651,
-0.02842995524406433,
0.45691218972206116,
0.4135146141052246,
-0.3809882402420044,
-0.5426405072212219,
-0.8414889574050903,
-0.6062889099121094,
1.027955412864685,
0.5077626705169678,
0.7042614221572876,
0.012845383025705814,
0.20911559462547302,
0.2819414436817169,
0.11954209208488464,
-0.8043222427368164,
0.2825063467025757,
-0.5060902833938599,
-0.5551934242248535,
-0.3255316913127899,
-0.31790268421173096,
-0.7820094227790833,
-0.018781302496790886,
-0.5691207647323608,
-0.33784666657447815,
0.34574317932128906,
0.18209010362625122,
-0.17693698406219482,
0.6339821815490723,
-0.7337202429771423,
0.7389982342720032,
-0.1612243354320526,
-0.14585715532302856,
-0.020481808111071587,
-0.7226940393447876,
-0.03225225210189819,
-0.17736957967281342,
0.32207077741622925,
0.26198557019233704,
0.2988012433052063,
0.544691264629364,
-0.36878225207328796,
0.9387304186820984,
0.18082930147647858,
-0.17334304749965668,
0.25139275193214417,
0.1185275986790657,
0.37282636761665344,
-0.6297407746315002,
-0.4184245467185974,
0.05328119546175003,
-0.13181032240390778,
0.044875066727399826,
-0.5169533491134644,
0.2548518478870392,
-0.7153767347335815,
-0.01752331852912903,
-0.417911171913147,
-0.4872860908508301,
0.10786889493465424,
0.27428168058395386,
0.44997861981391907,
0.5762038230895996,
-0.351349413394928,
0.08496121317148209,
0.5665871500968933,
-0.19029073417186737,
0.670293390750885,
0.5591408610343933,
-0.13891862332820892,
-0.5425679683685303,
0.7621450424194336,
0.2887301445007324,
0.09534471482038498,
0.5032052397727966,
-0.016477908939123154,
-0.3352642357349396,
-0.39430901408195496,
-0.5889611840248108,
0.3015667498111725,
-0.7262711524963379,
-0.24761193990707397,
-0.5699150562286377,
-0.3463398814201355,
-0.533524751663208,
-0.0303056463599205,
-0.4022620618343353,
-0.7194725871086121,
-0.5893415808677673,
-0.08647559583187103,
0.2666007876396179,
0.9709285497665405,
0.057779405266046524,
0.5926315784454346,
-0.9414382576942444,
-0.03295923396945,
-0.08084175735712051,
0.35672640800476074,
-0.10350289195775986,
-0.5310573577880859,
-0.24740467965602875,
0.11700752377510071,
-0.5254777073860168,
-0.9879017472267151,
0.47951433062553406,
0.25311389565467834,
0.23248648643493652,
-0.016666987910866737,
-0.23208312690258026,
0.601804256439209,
-0.5476372241973877,
0.8685552477836609,
0.1857236623764038,
-1.0038996934890747,
0.6796954870223999,
-0.3221741318702698,
0.1184588149189949,
0.5361359715461731,
0.11714480072259903,
-0.922265887260437,
-0.46778604388237,
-0.6762849688529968,
-0.6699197888374329,
0.8128388524055481,
0.24382147192955017,
0.042937494814395905,
-0.08619207888841629,
0.5789755582809448,
0.16225455701351166,
0.15673784911632538,
-0.8711649775505066,
-0.1478903591632843,
-0.012731825932860374,
-0.6468810439109802,
-0.04241572692990303,
-0.48056501150131226,
0.4095456898212433,
-0.027738774195313454,
0.902938187122345,
0.03336602821946144,
0.16197426617145538,
0.4213297963142395,
-0.5271313190460205,
-0.26724594831466675,
0.3828747570514679,
0.8242896795272827,
0.41529005765914917,
0.020246321335434914,
0.07393604516983032,
0.0823315903544426,
-0.8775537610054016,
0.2300359606742859,
0.013688556849956512,
-0.2587938904762268,
0.41389402747154236,
0.33400943875312805,
0.8308993577957153,
0.29820066690444946,
-0.48076242208480835,
0.4396611154079437,
-0.3128516972064972,
-0.3565690219402313,
-0.2224423587322235,
-0.3635771870613098,
-0.054194893687963486,
0.010625332593917847,
0.26692643761634827,
0.566265344619751,
0.15974214673042297,
-0.3548404276371002,
-0.343558132648468,
0.02497328631579876,
-0.3101681172847748,
-0.29243919253349304,
0.7328220009803772,
0.20396806299686432,
-0.5297102332115173,
0.7658038139343262,
0.06138700619339943,
-0.6160688400268555,
0.5917358994483948,
0.6576077938079834,
0.595975935459137,
-0.5350294709205627,
0.3342287540435791,
0.33416008949279785,
0.5305919647216797,
-0.41695454716682434,
0.10151112079620361,
0.5487583875656128,
-0.7836213111877441,
-0.5709788203239441,
-0.35425058007240295,
-0.38325703144073486,
0.07316280156373978,
-0.5839242339134216,
0.04233384132385254,
-0.27351298928260803,
-0.5407857298851013,
-0.2082616090774536,
-0.22562909126281738,
-0.6040470600128174,
0.3886314928531647,
0.07140626013278961,
0.5797128677368164,
-0.9131768345832825,
0.4424813389778137,
1.0899813175201416,
-0.3465225100517273,
-0.9408307075500488,
-0.2762164771556854,
-0.17879712581634521,
-0.5430710911750793,
0.6735135316848755,
-0.09056544303894043,
0.17758527398109436,
-0.11419147253036499,
-0.07224015891551971,
-0.7873555421829224,
0.8108503818511963,
0.494620144367218,
-0.9499313235282898,
-0.278603196144104,
0.42759281396865845,
0.7741177678108215,
0.1514963060617447,
0.3599209785461426,
0.37019580602645874,
0.448332279920578,
-0.09975282847881317,
-1.3893070220947266,
-0.16159145534038544,
-0.23410442471504211,
0.3394332826137543,
0.19327348470687866,
-0.1818869709968567,
0.7699325680732727,
-0.05698786675930023,
-0.12808723747730255,
0.29473066329956055,
0.4629700183868408,
-0.22670511901378632,
0.3785874843597412,
0.2650046944618225,
0.7308791875839233,
1.1312607526779175,
-0.20648998022079468,
0.8731546401977539,
0.10670128464698792,
0.48122960329055786,
1.0506718158721924,
-0.045059654861688614,
1.1167771816253662,
0.37300175428390503,
-0.350117951631546,
0.6454813480377197,
0.4866229295730591,
0.09542281180620193,
0.19675949215888977,
-0.023593002930283546,
-0.14427027106285095,
0.18281731009483337,
0.21317806839942932,
-0.3015737533569336,
0.3128732144832611,
0.5101320743560791,
-0.6771968603134155,
0.030037643387913704,
0.40929436683654785,
-0.03364132344722748,
0.5708705186843872,
-0.4595731496810913,
0.7486950755119324,
-0.14953583478927612,
-0.6215643882751465,
0.11795123666524887,
0.3902672827243805,
0.6700001955032349,
0.0007259083213284612,
0.14654500782489777,
-0.10112756490707397,
0.5798603296279907,
-0.22996602952480316,
-0.5441876649856567,
0.44224053621292114,
0.11475623399019241,
-0.6212940812110901,
-0.29847586154937744,
1.145134687423706,
-0.4803191125392914,
-0.9345359802246094,
0.04774824529886246,
0.3784780204296112,
0.01678776927292347,
-0.09864741563796997,
-0.5980684161186218,
0.09831137210130692,
-0.1312074065208435,
0.15880133211612701,
-0.19328691065311432,
0.36681097745895386,
-0.09336447715759277,
0.34712567925453186,
0.41159433126449585,
0.17339922487735748,
0.4866134226322174,
0.25306618213653564,
0.43814799189567566,
-0.34752753376960754,
-0.4790581464767456,
-0.7818646430969238,
0.701824426651001,
0.06879754364490509,
-0.06841849535703659,
0.7143470048904419,
0.4651162624359131,
0.6622428894042969,
-0.5654340386390686,
0.7877705693244934,
0.14343126118183136,
0.7738712430000305,
-0.5996948480606079,
0.7632604837417603,
-0.27166762948036194,
0.07566221058368683,
-0.43572720885276794,
-0.9743075370788574,
-0.6524521708488464,
0.7115389108657837,
-0.30065566301345825,
-0.28292855620384216,
0.9135600328445435,
0.6299040913581848,
-0.017466658726334572,
0.19325582683086395,
0.1339750587940216,
0.23556213080883026,
0.17730148136615753,
0.4070080816745758,
0.7769860029220581,
-1.009338140487671,
0.39744770526885986,
-0.023268485441803932,
-0.048642147332429886,
-0.5407535433769226,
-0.7236185669898987,
-0.620356559753418,
-0.6637977957725525,
-0.5575941205024719,
-0.5736697316169739,
0.23366306722164154,
0.744270384311676,
0.35205966234207153,
-0.762252688407898,
0.0033957252744585276,
-0.3716282546520233,
0.06309420615434647,
-0.11096958816051483,
-0.2691396176815033,
0.3748091757297516,
-0.47160348296165466,
-0.7974732518196106,
0.212686687707901,
0.11109323054552078,
0.3639388680458069,
0.029443439096212387,
0.14864522218704224,
-0.039764296263456345,
0.0312380101531744,
0.6411298513412476,
0.2272452414035797,
-0.6739341616630554,
-0.12075385451316833,
0.3960098326206207,
-0.4893953502178192,
0.15679363906383514,
0.6366994976997375,
-0.6356711387634277,
0.7013681530952454,
0.5352661609649658,
0.7705773115158081,
0.2454780638217926,
-0.21649543941020966,
0.5841113924980164,
-0.6512271761894226,
-0.15074121952056885,
0.062484610825777054,
0.31340619921684265,
0.6925435662269592,
-0.5796634554862976,
0.4686641991138458,
0.48931410908699036,
-0.6620791554450989,
-0.7020959854125977,
-0.2353762537240982,
-1.0249050855636597,
-0.10321453958749771,
0.9534038305282593,
-0.1621631234884262,
-0.195628821849823,
0.025216292589902878,
-0.7174053192138672,
0.43864068388938904,
-0.05778399482369423,
0.7560407519340515,
0.9454887509346008,
0.21459336578845978,
-0.14989951252937317,
-0.5093430876731873,
0.2458982914686203,
0.5616120100021362,
-0.6638034582138062,
-0.2161867916584015,
0.4609315097332001,
0.20798873901367188,
0.42676252126693726,
0.4443342089653015,
-0.17103584110736847,
0.5067201256752014,
-0.12176163494586945,
0.22857101261615753,
-0.0828673467040062,
-0.2726033627986908,
-0.6956493854522705,
0.15289127826690674,
-0.03242303431034088,
-0.272544264793396
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16630v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16630v1
|
A comparative analysis of embedding models for patent similarity
| 2024-03-25T11:20:23 | 2024-03-25T11:20:23 |
Grazia Sveva Ascione, Valerio Sterzi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
This paper makes two contributions to the field of text-based patent
similarity. First, it compares the performance of different kinds of
patent-specific pretrained embedding models, namely static word embeddings
(such as word2vec and doc2vec models) and contextual word embeddings (such as
transformers based models), on the task of patent similarity calculation.
Second, it compares specifically the performance of Sentence Transformers
(SBERT) architectures with different training phases on the patent similarity
task. To assess the models' performance, we use information about patent
interferences, a phenomenon in which two or more patent claims belonging to
different patent applications are proven to be overlapping by patent examiners.
Therefore, we use these interferences cases as a proxy for maximum similarity
between two patents, treating them as ground-truth to evaluate the performance
of the different embedding models. Our results point out that, first, Patent
SBERT-adapt-ub, the domain adaptation of the pretrained Sentence Transformer
architecture proposed in this research, outperforms the current
state-of-the-art in patent similarity. Second, they show that, in some cases,
large static models performances are still comparable to contextual ones when
trained on extensive data; thus, we believe that the superiority in the
performance of contextual embeddings may not be related to the actual
architecture but rather to the way the training phase is performed.
|
[
0.005687186028808355,
-0.43261852860450745,
0.47917506098747253,
0.3008798062801361,
-0.29926005005836487,
0.06994839757680893,
0.029892288148403168,
-0.42247605323791504,
0.04930123686790466,
0.5508942604064941,
0.06523057073354721,
-0.378449022769928,
-0.7236149311065674,
-0.08170536160469055,
-0.438723087310791,
0.5732848644256592,
-0.31343913078308105,
0.13318702578544617,
-0.6268301010131836,
-0.10529902577400208,
-0.49865803122520447,
-0.46386927366256714,
0.11601052433252335,
-0.44516390562057495,
-0.08134755492210388,
-0.1847405880689621,
0.4181041419506073,
0.4265540540218353,
0.5273394584655762,
0.3618314862251282,
-0.2911387085914612,
-0.09793848544359207,
-0.2718835175037384,
-0.01925700344145298,
-0.38674965500831604,
-0.48018530011177063,
-0.011144990101456642,
0.14001497626304626,
0.24763567745685577,
0.45514824986457825,
0.0286118034273386,
0.02816106379032135,
0.36505407094955444,
0.10588071495294571,
-0.469346284866333,
0.11292370408773422,
-0.7885331511497498,
0.4600658714771271,
0.2677507996559143,
-0.29108014702796936,
-0.5250247716903687,
-0.39589837193489075,
0.6004947423934937,
-0.45220091938972473,
0.6197425127029419,
0.49300065636634827,
1.1971557140350342,
0.2585206627845764,
-0.27869170904159546,
-0.30777376890182495,
-0.40483689308166504,
0.620732307434082,
-0.7011914253234863,
0.27909108996391296,
-0.11654233187437057,
-0.1555328369140625,
-0.0707334354519844,
-1.0620988607406616,
-0.6987828016281128,
-0.4842698276042938,
-0.25199541449546814,
0.079705148935318,
-0.41847169399261475,
0.024182263761758804,
0.34674137830734253,
0.08048741519451141,
-0.7281654477119446,
0.15720410645008087,
-0.499103844165802,
-0.050046104937791824,
0.05593939498066902,
-0.15674501657485962,
0.0768178328871727,
-0.30539172887802124,
-0.8718427419662476,
-0.3179224133491516,
-0.8746489882469177,
-0.04804205521941185,
0.18136434257030487,
0.0469694584608078,
-0.02587665617465973,
0.5628973841667175,
-0.05048329383134842,
0.46176716685295105,
0.1366530805826187,
0.21032892167568207,
0.5563507676124573,
-0.0940592885017395,
-0.38053569197654724,
0.24972759187221527,
0.6869891285896301,
0.3859049677848816,
0.263591468334198,
-0.5712313055992126,
-0.04399801418185234,
-0.20957063138484955,
0.5680577754974365,
-0.7821031808853149,
-0.05613536760210991,
-0.17669899761676788,
-0.7402992844581604,
-0.13194552063941956,
0.40230464935302734,
-0.42636850476264954,
-0.3485155701637268,
-0.41819581389427185,
1.0401002168655396,
-0.20309695601463318,
0.11346983909606934,
0.09883616864681244,
-0.6026238203048706,
0.42359670996665955,
-0.27668020129203796,
-0.676741898059845,
0.41896867752075195,
1.2580537796020508,
1.0317063331604004,
-0.10810059309005737,
-0.5326345562934875,
-0.03531574085354805,
-0.11550598591566086,
-0.41478851437568665,
0.8816589713096619,
-0.4775274991989136,
-0.5798728466033936,
0.03541380912065506,
0.06295817345380783,
-0.385464072227478,
-0.9532377123832703,
0.5462020635604858,
-0.704108476638794,
0.19120435416698456,
-0.26158928871154785,
-0.7991517186164856,
-0.2613595128059387,
0.07444806396961212,
-0.42867448925971985,
0.7290414571762085,
-0.06959007680416107,
-0.9548256993293762,
0.7810335159301758,
-0.538070797920227,
-0.449221134185791,
-0.09731803834438324,
-0.07032214105129242,
-0.4937366247177124,
0.28518036007881165,
-0.2045586109161377,
0.6013126373291016,
-0.39298245310783386,
0.2184806764125824,
-0.3749591112136841,
-0.47538653016090393,
0.2856139838695526,
-0.11422485113143921,
0.5613191723823547,
0.2162548154592514,
-0.5790356993675232,
0.10527025163173676,
-0.609790563583374,
-0.0686207041144371,
-0.08006411790847778,
0.25900572538375854,
-0.7098724842071533,
0.0634540244936943,
-0.16749465465545654,
0.2459360510110855,
0.18261031806468964,
-0.8175018429756165,
0.06759707629680634,
-0.4827524423599243,
0.5549914836883545,
0.6286750435829163,
-0.11148831993341446,
0.3266199231147766,
-0.49704769253730774,
0.29483485221862793,
0.10051488131284714,
0.022695239633321762,
-0.2038843333721161,
-0.5074378252029419,
-0.5269947052001953,
-0.23353411257266998,
0.8051570057868958,
0.46910086274147034,
-0.19846469163894653,
0.504082202911377,
-0.7645184397697449,
-0.44236671924591064,
-0.6395798921585083,
-0.2782417833805084,
0.5119814276695251,
0.5445481538772583,
0.43285104632377625,
-0.7675870060920715,
-0.4549899697303772,
-1.144470453262329,
-0.6031098961830139,
0.08365023881196976,
-0.010127993300557137,
0.5294662714004517,
0.6223893165588379,
0.0610988512635231,
0.976262629032135,
-0.550832986831665,
-0.14233259856700897,
0.24477462470531464,
0.44838282465934753,
0.25239992141723633,
0.5676045417785645,
0.7029083371162415,
-0.6260616779327393,
-0.8223171234130859,
0.1525106281042099,
-0.6590663194656372,
-0.06988979130983353,
-0.08267312496900558,
0.2675016522407532,
-0.041265904903411865,
0.6775192618370056,
-0.6676610708236694,
0.553689181804657,
0.33105212450027466,
-0.4703359305858612,
0.36797571182250977,
-0.5193424224853516,
0.3660045862197876,
-1.1562069654464722,
0.22084766626358032,
-0.30193978548049927,
-0.08010894060134888,
-0.5826371312141418,
0.029308205470442772,
0.20597222447395325,
-0.1477372646331787,
-0.5327131152153015,
0.4589732587337494,
-0.503311276435852,
-0.26250994205474854,
-0.3813541531562805,
0.1548645943403244,
0.19023701548576355,
0.15845170617103577,
-0.36101770401000977,
1.1106288433074951,
0.4934263825416565,
-0.34566324949264526,
0.19389615952968597,
0.48295727372169495,
-0.7930015325546265,
0.2956702411174774,
-1.0287623405456543,
0.19346687197685242,
0.08473202586174011,
0.09809175133705139,
-0.8318788409233093,
0.3910839557647705,
-0.039376065135002136,
-0.18984417617321014,
0.32604652643203735,
0.06511730700731277,
-0.46152403950691223,
-0.5273200869560242,
-0.563052773475647,
0.09782198816537857,
0.7251095771789551,
-0.8282302021980286,
0.5684014558792114,
0.03621159866452217,
-0.40542736649513245,
-0.7445195913314819,
-0.9159257411956787,
0.077872633934021,
-0.4171857535839081,
-0.6085667014122009,
1.2835149765014648,
0.29707440733909607,
0.030972430482506752,
0.6659150123596191,
0.07490859925746918,
-0.17629365622997284,
-0.12830482423305511,
0.493872731924057,
0.1422295868396759,
-0.521214485168457,
0.030375171452760696,
0.19336485862731934,
-0.11635153740644455,
-0.06564666330814362,
-0.2760181128978729,
0.36268743872642517,
0.2971375584602356,
-0.39654070138931274,
-0.4230197072029114,
0.10891695320606232,
0.4150276482105255,
-0.01753194071352482,
0.9061429500579834,
0.12316220253705978,
-0.1886097490787506,
-0.08469688147306442,
-0.6144567131996155,
0.1296818107366562,
-0.47520866990089417,
0.3337692320346832,
-0.6808542609214783,
-0.9336068630218506,
0.3275027275085449,
-0.3033992052078247,
-0.1994241327047348,
0.5604667067527771,
0.4621041417121887,
0.22454123198986053,
0.36048927903175354,
0.8687150478363037,
-0.23674072325229645,
0.3231896460056305,
-0.16768337786197662,
0.6034282445907593,
-0.8666239380836487,
-0.40071603655815125,
-0.7048940062522888,
-0.2222730815410614,
-0.3749772310256958,
-0.565386950969696,
-0.19490393996238708,
0.026384569704532623,
-0.3393809497356415,
0.9135143756866455,
-0.5363564491271973,
0.44968047738075256,
0.636557936668396,
-0.21270187199115753,
0.050542425364255905,
0.25008612871170044,
-0.5923628211021423,
-0.11166205257177353,
-0.5624644756317139,
-0.5857577919960022,
1.2618052959442139,
0.1759868562221527,
0.6764472126960754,
-0.24025313556194305,
0.4258474111557007,
0.5031399130821228,
0.14359302818775177,
-0.5664671063423157,
0.1871052235364914,
-0.46959808468818665,
-0.3084814250469208,
0.1914888322353363,
-0.1360907256603241,
-0.8135337829589844,
0.40521299839019775,
-0.32372725009918213,
-0.7600188851356506,
0.5373690128326416,
-0.1468529999256134,
-0.3240053355693817,
0.22337684035301208,
-0.979223370552063,
0.8684087991714478,
-0.16214849054813385,
-0.2774544656276703,
-0.5819770097732544,
-0.3499012589454651,
-0.1288793534040451,
-0.27567780017852783,
-0.19040420651435852,
0.28751465678215027,
0.14891280233860016,
0.9646404981613159,
-0.21495196223258972,
0.6533194780349731,
-0.08123564720153809,
0.19346201419830322,
0.24104410409927368,
-0.36230039596557617,
0.17106181383132935,
-0.5851154923439026,
-0.2412150651216507,
0.05228549987077713,
0.0776389017701149,
-0.017303019762039185,
-0.6663697957992554,
0.869952917098999,
-0.5500613451004028,
-0.7224677205085754,
-0.444667786359787,
-0.17769047617912292,
-0.0035903893876820803,
0.19409732520580292,
0.30739742517471313,
0.4886908233165741,
-0.4894929528236389,
0.5093402862548828,
0.2908799350261688,
-0.36888575553894043,
0.3719000816345215,
0.48175761103630066,
0.3282153308391571,
-0.15594297647476196,
0.6628281474113464,
0.07018284499645233,
-0.13018254935741425,
0.657930850982666,
0.08566856384277344,
-0.511777400970459,
-0.44352880120277405,
-0.03301665559411049,
0.1811733990907669,
-0.6046261191368103,
-0.2748980224132538,
-0.9199629426002502,
-0.36493995785713196,
-0.43748122453689575,
-0.16306927800178528,
-0.3078685998916626,
-0.43493005633354187,
-0.32979097962379456,
-0.24134935438632965,
0.236207976937294,
0.9073930978775024,
0.011832774616777897,
0.2009594440460205,
-0.5964719653129578,
0.31186240911483765,
0.403387188911438,
0.527802586555481,
0.2077157199382782,
-0.8730362057685852,
-0.14476580917835236,
-0.16661334037780762,
-0.7416878342628479,
-0.5367538332939148,
0.0468875914812088,
0.3883475959300995,
0.6410093903541565,
0.454704612493515,
-0.1335662603378296,
0.7319701313972473,
-1.0516493320465088,
0.8529984354972839,
0.1020408645272255,
-1.2587817907333374,
0.047715283930301666,
0.3963218033313751,
-0.45034265518188477,
0.46107131242752075,
0.4824843406677246,
-0.13825060427188873,
0.09026051312685013,
-0.7713837623596191,
-0.801349937915802,
0.5059903264045715,
0.023708874359726906,
0.5825955271720886,
0.26010167598724365,
0.4705248475074768,
0.265445739030838,
0.2083510160446167,
-0.4754093587398529,
-0.018059050664305687,
-0.21670693159103394,
-0.28757765889167786,
0.14614121615886688,
-0.3152291476726532,
0.03905282914638519,
-0.10053277760744095,
0.4878341555595398,
0.38843655586242676,
0.5974062085151672,
0.2313990741968155,
-0.16030901670455933,
0.3848985731601715,
0.3261987268924713,
0.638778030872345,
0.42472243309020996,
-0.08496057242155075,
0.31419944763183594,
0.40925753116607666,
-0.5045142769813538,
0.1401505023241043,
0.35458651185035706,
-0.004016671795397997,
0.13162873685359955,
0.5532004237174988,
1.006128191947937,
0.3823513686656952,
-0.6460545659065247,
0.8101517558097839,
0.09886255860328674,
-0.382855623960495,
0.2921610474586487,
0.05286640673875809,
-0.018493186682462692,
0.5496441721916199,
0.16893911361694336,
0.14993323385715485,
0.3203299939632416,
-0.4764891266822815,
0.541692316532135,
0.4691925644874573,
-0.5375986695289612,
-0.35024186968803406,
0.5395568013191223,
0.0321643203496933,
-0.5098206996917725,
0.18723826110363007,
0.034639835357666016,
-1.027669906616211,
0.7820210456848145,
0.8162308931350708,
1.019385814666748,
0.08211644738912582,
-0.06091388687491417,
0.1297593116760254,
0.17045366764068604,
-0.3244195580482483,
-0.16719631850719452,
-0.10573940724134445,
-0.4787478744983673,
-0.12494082003831863,
-0.2435566633939743,
-0.37387529015541077,
-0.10397440195083618,
-0.48173800110816956,
0.2694043815135956,
-0.3183469772338867,
-0.2678890824317932,
0.005800263956189156,
-0.17516036331653595,
-0.6539968848228455,
0.019871626049280167,
-0.3470414876937866,
0.8636711835861206,
-0.8240628242492676,
0.7546576261520386,
0.495476096868515,
-0.014050384983420372,
-0.6341028213500977,
0.23702360689640045,
-0.40927544236183167,
-0.4663292467594147,
0.8997098803520203,
0.34112706780433655,
-0.09171915799379349,
-0.22540666162967682,
-0.00411610770970583,
-0.5385090112686157,
1.278701901435852,
0.08347541838884354,
-0.40191009640693665,
0.10059459507465363,
0.2161189764738083,
0.6058845520019531,
-0.6066127419471741,
0.15332268178462982,
0.30809342861175537,
-0.026209106668829918,
-0.18780578672885895,
-0.9860973358154297,
0.13511872291564941,
-0.19438433647155762,
0.21348188817501068,
-0.2103271186351776,
-0.4056008756160736,
0.730872631072998,
0.02480200119316578,
-0.295807808637619,
0.4104653000831604,
0.3974746763706207,
0.0023774050641804934,
0.25991106033325195,
0.2881838083267212,
0.7770453095436096,
0.41511639952659607,
-0.010359104722738266,
0.8491454720497131,
-0.6383275985717773,
0.7632374167442322,
1.163540244102478,
-0.6018467545509338,
1.1100859642028809,
0.30685460567474365,
-0.279697448015213,
0.48466169834136963,
0.05385808274149895,
-0.6318677663803101,
0.9094763994216919,
0.27684882283210754,
0.16357110440731049,
0.39570164680480957,
-0.10778822004795074,
-0.7286284565925598,
0.27435383200645447,
-0.1069241613149643,
-0.7336764335632324,
-0.007941721938550472,
-0.06890904903411865,
-0.29232120513916016,
0.1695232391357422,
0.3849658966064453,
0.7011586427688599,
0.23728898167610168,
-0.507614016532898,
0.358445942401886,
0.30113720893859863,
0.8923816680908203,
-0.3039550185203552,
0.16454029083251953,
0.11516601592302322,
0.14113295078277588,
0.11842473596334457,
-0.5956687927246094,
0.3819492757320404,
0.2807359993457794,
-0.18392544984817505,
-0.14818918704986572,
0.630551815032959,
-0.06115100532770157,
-0.07471486926078796,
0.5403578877449036,
0.10094327479600906,
-0.07778018712997437,
0.2057299017906189,
-0.6327933073043823,
-0.17013974487781525,
-0.2291797250509262,
-0.069039486348629,
0.024467915296554565,
0.2827065587043762,
0.21550942957401276,
0.49596619606018066,
0.3696277141571045,
0.09696350246667862,
0.4108583927154541,
0.07933935523033142,
0.7478905320167542,
-0.715026319026947,
-0.4792356491088867,
-0.713453471660614,
0.1723860502243042,
-0.2637908160686493,
-0.42386043071746826,
0.6010665893554688,
0.8154367208480835,
0.5935843586921692,
-0.5283370614051819,
0.43894168734550476,
0.06487276405096054,
0.5520032048225403,
-0.6080119013786316,
0.705001711845398,
-0.4691084623336792,
0.154281347990036,
-0.3134998083114624,
-1.139084815979004,
-0.2564316987991333,
0.7362299561500549,
-0.3533785343170166,
-0.0832241028547287,
0.9561659693717957,
1.016261100769043,
-0.5673336982727051,
0.10273834317922592,
0.12791237235069275,
0.24309107661247253,
0.2744521200656891,
0.25989508628845215,
0.8792622685432434,
-0.6399180293083191,
0.08118613064289093,
-0.009124650619924068,
-0.07452556490898132,
-0.2917686402797699,
-0.9298655390739441,
-0.8248563408851624,
-0.6901355981826782,
-0.23825547099113464,
-0.0221985075622797,
0.14223310351371765,
0.7616633772850037,
0.6756259202957153,
-0.8534117341041565,
0.09847976267337799,
-0.05854425206780434,
-0.12817451357841492,
0.05274466425180435,
-0.19023969769477844,
0.7195631265640259,
-0.15295255184173584,
-0.38799524307250977,
0.24276594817638397,
0.281634122133255,
0.12974825501441956,
0.2038782238960266,
0.19131691753864288,
0.05754804238677025,
0.3702043890953064,
0.664314329624176,
0.01714857667684555,
-0.7825106382369995,
-0.4363752007484436,
-0.015924682840704918,
-0.21286776661872864,
0.1318196803331375,
1.0559477806091309,
-0.7878626585006714,
0.49251267313957214,
0.6776544451713562,
0.9026383757591248,
0.47188135981559753,
0.12132026255130768,
0.3040013313293457,
-0.4211215376853943,
0.5574008226394653,
-0.06314092129468918,
0.4393790066242218,
0.2769860625267029,
-0.08523987978696823,
0.20708522200584412,
0.03921150788664818,
-0.44213658571243286,
-0.6444199681282043,
-0.03719262033700943,
-0.9342538714408875,
-0.4742888808250427,
0.8817102313041687,
-0.48483991622924805,
0.06456581503152847,
0.005928231403231621,
-0.1094517782330513,
0.2551995813846588,
0.061867907643318176,
1.000464677810669,
0.704321026802063,
0.19442018866539001,
0.41832074522972107,
-0.18798667192459106,
0.22553643584251404,
0.5495280623435974,
-0.33044928312301636,
-0.28229430317878723,
-0.1938214749097824,
0.4375123381614685,
0.40099313855171204,
0.13681307435035706,
-0.2630307972431183,
-0.04041802138090134,
0.281596839427948,
-0.004501123446971178,
-0.12330148369073868,
-0.2721010744571686,
-0.48262497782707214,
0.38192546367645264,
0.08300870656967163,
-0.34744793176651
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16614v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16614v1
|
Semantically Enriched Cross-Lingual Sentence Embeddings for Crisis-related Social Media Texts
| 2024-03-25T10:44:38 | 2024-03-25T10:44:38 |
Rabindra Lamsal, Maria Rodriguez Read, Shanika Karunasekera
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Tasks such as semantic search and clustering on crisis-related social media
texts enhance our comprehension of crisis discourse, aiding decision-making and
targeted interventions. Pre-trained language models have advanced performance
in crisis informatics, but their contextual embeddings lack semantic
meaningfulness. Although the CrisisTransformers family includes a sentence
encoder to address the semanticity issue, it remains monolingual, processing
only English texts. Furthermore, employing separate models for different
languages leads to embeddings in distinct vector spaces, introducing challenges
when comparing semantic similarities between multi-lingual texts. Therefore, we
propose multi-lingual sentence encoders (CT-XLMR-SE and CT-mBERT-SE) that embed
crisis-related social media texts for over 50 languages, such that texts with
similar meanings are in close proximity within the same vector space,
irrespective of language diversity. Results in sentence encoding and sentence
matching tasks are promising, suggesting these models could serve as robust
baselines when embedding multi-lingual crisis-related social media texts. The
models are publicly available at: https://huggingface.co/crisistransformers.
|
[
-0.12301228195428848,
-0.5033044219017029,
0.4298696517944336,
0.6959776282310486,
-0.3173847198486328,
0.46481019258499146,
-0.21739359200000763,
-0.4270572066307068,
0.5417824387550354,
0.18704107403755188,
-0.6603164672851562,
-0.47186827659606934,
-0.6949881911277771,
0.43608930706977844,
-0.44904664158821106,
0.7984622716903687,
-0.18958374857902527,
0.08789289742708206,
0.013266283087432384,
-0.05152921751141548,
-0.28631868958473206,
-0.352979451417923,
-0.36503440141677856,
0.42042192816734314,
0.6812551021575928,
0.5461856722831726,
0.8890181183815002,
0.24117511510849,
0.484344482421875,
0.3257240653038025,
-0.10482525080442429,
0.1431507170200348,
-0.8875334858894348,
0.1371316760778427,
-0.14082303643226624,
0.08239218592643738,
-0.005774199031293392,
-0.4362025856971741,
0.4013209640979767,
0.36969441175460815,
-0.0516512431204319,
-0.24755859375,
0.1950557678937912,
0.225630521774292,
-0.6875026822090149,
0.07395380735397339,
-0.47265350818634033,
0.07269851863384247,
0.29218167066574097,
-0.3193838894367218,
-0.2460005283355713,
-0.2604360580444336,
0.23273371160030365,
-0.7141674160957336,
0.03661258518695831,
0.028233034536242485,
0.8046560883522034,
0.11884916573762894,
-0.6956398487091064,
-0.3238338232040405,
-0.6658672094345093,
0.4545731246471405,
-0.31132441759109497,
0.44556838274002075,
-0.012831040658056736,
0.11729752272367477,
0.12593746185302734,
-0.7182456254959106,
-0.4152497947216034,
0.32890719175338745,
-0.12119846045970917,
0.33567026257514954,
-0.2827722430229187,
0.0518401674926281,
-0.17579346895217896,
0.0639878660440445,
-0.6103439331054688,
0.003711041761562228,
-0.37679818272590637,
-0.23935112357139587,
0.4701804220676422,
0.19213631749153137,
0.6474590301513672,
-0.6866328120231628,
-0.6504707932472229,
-0.12748922407627106,
-0.6841809749603271,
-0.13127745687961578,
0.23553234338760376,
0.4889259338378906,
-0.49690723419189453,
0.5470255613327026,
-0.04082217812538147,
0.2980484962463379,
-0.3901327848434448,
-0.0030691898427903652,
0.18992440402507782,
-0.6036174893379211,
-0.09029226005077362,
0.2859606444835663,
0.824297308921814,
0.6262785196304321,
0.2891637086868286,
-0.24963444471359253,
-0.061540387570858,
0.1009620875120163,
0.41030094027519226,
-0.9655176997184753,
0.20258165895938873,
0.12722148001194,
-0.33548876643180847,
-0.13621151447296143,
0.19751645624637604,
-0.7011999487876892,
-0.3585762083530426,
0.029270991683006287,
0.4540541172027588,
-0.5129256844520569,
-0.17660842835903168,
0.4180780351161957,
-0.4493803083896637,
-0.07583793252706528,
-0.06772415339946747,
-0.3702963590621948,
-0.07363531738519669,
0.6561870574951172,
0.9373323321342468,
0.25048696994781494,
-0.21861697733402252,
-0.2946189045906067,
0.2563159763813019,
-0.17484459280967712,
0.7502150535583496,
-0.7459031343460083,
-0.4325897693634033,
0.5559443235397339,
0.3181419372558594,
-0.07039619237184525,
-0.19769681990146637,
1.0193887948989868,
-0.3623230755329132,
-0.006091774441301823,
-0.5524358153343201,
-0.40383628010749817,
-0.0885830745100975,
0.21194639801979065,
-0.5852722525596619,
0.8301589488983154,
-0.05273948609828949,
-1.0128276348114014,
0.34888124465942383,
-0.5343611240386963,
-0.6600273251533508,
-0.028138449415564537,
-0.09236300736665726,
-0.1918153017759323,
0.0200913418084383,
0.5475111603736877,
0.9255245923995972,
-0.24620559811592102,
0.16396580636501312,
-0.5327814817428589,
-0.33751094341278076,
0.12337398529052734,
-0.18337894976139069,
0.5217095017433167,
0.08388058841228485,
-0.061711788177490234,
0.1993175595998764,
-0.529424250125885,
-0.1983574777841568,
0.20816266536712646,
-0.19952701032161713,
-0.7130807042121887,
-0.030334437265992165,
0.7164610624313354,
0.48889586329460144,
0.1410604864358902,
-0.7437543869018555,
-0.18045836687088013,
-0.3013262152671814,
0.5900142192840576,
0.38098767399787903,
0.15263457596302032,
0.3780770003795624,
-0.328454852104187,
0.4356350898742676,
0.39144882559776306,
0.09430617094039917,
-0.40792953968048096,
-0.3149171769618988,
-0.5376825332641602,
-0.2244260609149933,
-0.16337372362613678,
0.9183483719825745,
-1.1026027202606201,
0.3414108455181122,
-0.46849319338798523,
-0.4383403956890106,
-0.6223062872886658,
-0.11548791080713272,
0.19373545050621033,
0.10878968983888626,
0.4659353196620941,
0.1413438469171524,
-0.7989954352378845,
-0.9325054287910461,
-0.3556065261363983,
0.07456399500370026,
0.15118540823459625,
0.15239515900611877,
0.4287738800048828,
-0.30543431639671326,
0.7443255186080933,
-0.2250407338142395,
-0.13240209221839905,
-0.6629423499107361,
0.1688048541545868,
-0.3152880370616913,
0.005416458006948233,
0.56905198097229,
-1.1209357976913452,
-0.5704407691955566,
0.034992899745702744,
-0.6516580581665039,
-0.03826601430773735,
-0.36428526043891907,
-0.15576334297657013,
0.05438556522130966,
0.565858781337738,
-0.4403555393218994,
0.27382564544677734,
0.6119163632392883,
-0.6198559403419495,
0.06155339255928993,
-0.09407705813646317,
0.49442633986473083,
-1.6425471305847168,
-0.264827162027359,
0.05900125205516815,
-0.30568617582321167,
-0.7627870440483093,
-0.10349562019109726,
0.1751735806465149,
-0.22990399599075317,
-0.6466321349143982,
0.3984379768371582,
-0.5795466303825378,
0.06598799675703049,
-0.04188762232661247,
0.5967968702316284,
-0.15605048835277557,
0.007302308455109596,
0.03723938390612602,
0.41968682408332825,
0.7137556076049805,
-0.06995244324207306,
0.24059565365314484,
0.34363168478012085,
-0.43044090270996094,
0.5226225256919861,
-0.7170066237449646,
-0.3138843774795532,
-0.47480490803718567,
0.3004939556121826,
-0.8605908155441284,
-0.19593632221221924,
0.20191630721092224,
-0.12127702683210373,
0.11435006558895111,
0.09762515127658844,
-0.6559274196624756,
-0.29982617497444153,
-0.33750149607658386,
0.3907288610935211,
0.10816022008657455,
-0.3155837953090668,
0.47286421060562134,
0.5305353403091431,
-0.2985992431640625,
-0.6536955237388611,
-0.7800742387771606,
0.35507261753082275,
-0.2849096655845642,
-0.8533774614334106,
0.4735963046550751,
0.16082708537578583,
0.034929923713207245,
0.34874552488327026,
0.22880567610263824,
-0.06627929955720901,
0.01901666820049286,
0.2764366567134857,
0.29924869537353516,
-0.25259217619895935,
0.33619368076324463,
0.2935565114021301,
0.07091391086578369,
-0.11308013647794724,
-0.16593441367149353,
0.497815877199173,
-0.06993408501148224,
-0.17307811975479126,
-0.0488537922501564,
1.0034217834472656,
0.44554921984672546,
-0.07914897799491882,
1.092113733291626,
0.6342582106590271,
-0.5993517637252808,
-0.03131791576743126,
-0.4629008173942566,
-0.06701371818780899,
-0.42800459265708923,
0.4793396294116974,
-0.07441455870866776,
-1.450873851776123,
0.6361278295516968,
0.1525367945432663,
-0.08713483065366745,
0.32292312383651733,
0.5255956649780273,
0.25157430768013,
0.7668312788009644,
0.6626073122024536,
-0.26216429471969604,
0.2638188600540161,
-0.027790222316980362,
0.5857452154159546,
-0.19378703832626343,
0.01900220476090908,
-0.3492562174797058,
-0.1381896436214447,
-0.6014416217803955,
-0.5588724613189697,
0.5228118300437927,
-0.07613351941108704,
-0.2070009410381317,
0.40458717942237854,
-0.3256261944770813,
0.4666688144207001,
0.03651312366127968,
-0.00823894515633583,
0.1159767359495163,
0.010186286643147469,
0.06276100873947144,
-0.16919830441474915,
-1.05262291431427,
-0.39317265152931213,
0.2893727719783783,
0.26777178049087524,
0.66646808385849,
-0.004938270431011915,
0.7348968386650085,
-0.06092581897974014,
0.10604233294725418,
-0.5317155718803406,
0.2809502184391022,
-0.29432421922683716,
-0.43739891052246094,
-0.07406426221132278,
-0.42473024129867554,
-0.8653945922851562,
0.16098149120807648,
-0.3323701024055481,
-0.6281424164772034,
0.32598796486854553,
-0.295531302690506,
-0.6155783534049988,
0.05222078040242195,
-0.4325474798679352,
1.2074640989303589,
-0.1275666505098343,
0.20855098962783813,
-0.40598949790000916,
-0.7066857218742371,
0.14829182624816895,
-0.13028034567832947,
0.52992844581604,
-0.01631290838122368,
-0.2630605101585388,
0.5085467100143433,
-0.37735822796821594,
1.07638418674469,
0.21532702445983887,
-0.022476965561509132,
0.26527565717697144,
-0.2402479499578476,
0.33981019258499146,
0.11831362545490265,
0.2930183410644531,
-0.0350649394094944,
0.2488235980272293,
-0.369465708732605,
-0.3758046329021454,
0.6716030836105347,
-0.6496779322624207,
-0.2437436431646347,
-0.15395024418830872,
-0.643036425113678,
-0.14899185299873352,
0.05851969122886658,
0.45882755517959595,
0.6379746794700623,
-0.49942338466644287,
0.33784055709838867,
0.3097175657749176,
-0.4784923195838928,
0.6656463146209717,
0.2613728940486908,
-0.06352607160806656,
-0.42757007479667664,
0.7392585277557373,
0.09015808254480362,
0.1314271241426468,
0.747227132320404,
0.025820888578891754,
-0.10266336053609848,
0.13597038388252258,
-0.30177041888237,
0.2229546457529068,
-0.9367495179176331,
-0.41702795028686523,
-1.0832464694976807,
-0.2514355480670929,
-0.49061280488967896,
-0.6324424147605896,
-0.2836381494998932,
-0.34535425901412964,
-0.2668919265270233,
-0.3427797257900238,
0.5626364946365356,
0.5998652577400208,
-0.34800171852111816,
0.19678743183612823,
-1.285223364830017,
0.3069491982460022,
-0.40595197677612305,
0.10553322732448578,
-0.18577603995800018,
-0.20173338055610657,
-0.41343367099761963,
0.0045380303636193275,
0.04874742031097412,
-1.2103017568588257,
0.4455883204936981,
0.36330750584602356,
0.15004749596118927,
0.4504268169403076,
0.358412504196167,
0.793871283531189,
-0.81305992603302,
0.6807289123535156,
0.15966998040676117,
-0.8812999129295349,
0.48942190408706665,
-0.4214015007019043,
0.1667337268590927,
0.38005349040031433,
0.9311379194259644,
-1.0051583051681519,
-0.710017204284668,
-0.22336256504058838,
-0.9744018316268921,
0.454912930727005,
0.15999823808670044,
0.7106533646583557,
-0.4636956751346588,
0.070290207862854,
-0.1350526213645935,
-0.10146822035312653,
-0.645392119884491,
-0.13397452235221863,
-0.3672870993614197,
-0.35093438625335693,
-0.0467081218957901,
-0.5025532245635986,
0.0691007673740387,
0.03304004296660423,
0.44547656178474426,
0.05190779268741608,
0.14314581453800201,
0.3805096447467804,
-0.09833366423845291,
-0.09962020069360733,
0.45196476578712463,
0.2930446267127991,
0.12545154988765717,
0.24675361812114716,
0.008357470855116844,
0.19034992158412933,
-0.3709668815135956,
0.17420102655887604,
0.3600651025772095,
-0.08591244369745255,
0.2397157996892929,
0.4507995843887329,
0.6894522905349731,
1.1397066116333008,
-0.8591747879981995,
0.7347058057785034,
-0.23024484515190125,
0.09077171981334686,
-0.28859779238700867,
-0.4443584382534027,
0.3990441858768463,
0.510495126247406,
0.30048668384552,
-0.3101781904697418,
0.3590540289878845,
-0.7332078218460083,
0.26997336745262146,
0.33994996547698975,
-0.3977275788784027,
-0.20360755920410156,
0.3701619803905487,
0.15861155092716217,
-0.020551202818751335,
0.13313154876232147,
-0.26235678791999817,
-0.8800939917564392,
0.33226436376571655,
0.5700556039810181,
0.9716421365737915,
-0.38274064660072327,
0.5823020339012146,
0.32425543665885925,
0.5245651006698608,
-0.3463088870048523,
0.6658076643943787,
0.27503669261932373,
-0.8296329379081726,
-0.47093233466148376,
-0.5058897137641907,
-0.053076859563589096,
-0.2919531464576721,
-0.594218909740448,
0.4156131446361542,
-0.09515926241874695,
0.08205866068601608,
-0.25090861320495605,
-0.5338514447212219,
-0.6964020133018494,
0.06130494922399521,
0.12465332448482513,
0.9893556833267212,
-0.9162541627883911,
0.3452490568161011,
0.7017845511436462,
-0.14089472591876984,
-0.8402422070503235,
-0.10604064166545868,
-0.07591834664344788,
-0.359010249376297,
0.33647510409355164,
0.47391846776008606,
0.08906204253435135,
-0.2952133119106293,
-0.19212999939918518,
-0.9318459630012512,
0.8326382637023926,
0.49583491683006287,
-0.609556257724762,
-0.30637142062187195,
0.5811691880226135,
0.600299596786499,
-0.6257267594337463,
-0.027280496433377266,
0.1469862312078476,
0.3055229187011719,
0.020802615210413933,
-0.7414370775222778,
0.22987328469753265,
-0.3824828863143921,
-0.011650817468762398,
0.22348512709140778,
-0.39778411388397217,
0.5536797642707825,
-0.07230723649263382,
-0.5719999074935913,
-0.16061967611312866,
0.7832905054092407,
-0.23168912529945374,
0.17158721387386322,
0.3716047406196594,
0.43811407685279846,
0.36116063594818115,
-0.06206469237804413,
1.2771316766738892,
-0.668199896812439,
0.24602387845516205,
0.8817106485366821,
-0.12616142630577087,
0.9963963627815247,
0.036020755767822266,
0.48231202363967896,
0.577233612537384,
0.5973754525184631,
0.18471120297908783,
0.5042691230773926,
-0.1440557837486267,
-0.2850814163684845,
-0.4469214379787445,
-0.27642905712127686,
-0.09987369179725647,
0.4504144489765167,
0.467205673456192,
-0.531603991985321,
-0.43523845076560974,
0.29435697197914124,
0.1297207921743393,
0.048339515924453735,
-0.27570921182632446,
0.551224946975708,
0.3069676160812378,
-0.31740978360176086,
0.26148781180381775,
0.10634905844926834,
0.6530636548995972,
-0.30622419714927673,
0.33992451429367065,
0.041219938546419144,
-0.05023421719670296,
-0.09613418579101562,
-0.6214284896850586,
0.7515259981155396,
0.09398950636386871,
-0.013438519090414047,
-0.33656731247901917,
0.8665513396263123,
-0.7829198241233826,
-0.800652265548706,
0.7336216568946838,
0.7956147193908691,
-0.2222539484500885,
-0.19332411885261536,
-0.5224400162696838,
0.22528831660747528,
-0.432878702878952,
-0.12434348464012146,
0.09925718605518341,
0.8828635811805725,
0.16220423579216003,
0.45561814308166504,
0.20682291686534882,
-0.14784947037696838,
0.04449585825204849,
0.3143882155418396,
0.9705583453178406,
-0.6212835907936096,
-0.7751401662826538,
-0.8650957942008972,
0.5637074708938599,
-0.17135821282863617,
-0.3629249930381775,
0.7484441995620728,
0.5494642853736877,
0.8474981784820557,
-0.013743492774665356,
0.8229133486747742,
-0.008619490079581738,
0.4813394248485565,
-0.4378979802131653,
0.7954778671264648,
-0.7295599579811096,
-0.08975566178560257,
-0.5546910762786865,
-0.6394137740135193,
-0.19956496357917786,
0.40463122725486755,
-0.16814634203910828,
-0.21308457851409912,
0.5824616551399231,
0.8828525543212891,
-0.2480032593011856,
0.21829476952552795,
0.22084027528762817,
0.18978635966777802,
-0.040577806532382965,
0.6341760754585266,
1.0320932865142822,
-0.3326420783996582,
0.7867006659507751,
-0.16275140643119812,
0.051023468375205994,
-0.2172660380601883,
-0.9217103719711304,
-1.0953623056411743,
-0.9326404333114624,
-0.20803722739219666,
-0.16452030837535858,
0.06696536391973495,
1.0190495252609253,
0.24215856194496155,
-0.5004316568374634,
0.08574111759662628,
0.16225382685661316,
0.08629046380519867,
0.12339109182357788,
-0.21064883470535278,
0.08473576605319977,
-0.2843368351459503,
-0.4184372127056122,
0.4788074195384979,
0.5900773406028748,
-0.010129442438483238,
-0.24446368217468262,
0.10608693212270737,
-0.1338452398777008,
0.44932159781455994,
0.758868396282196,
-0.23983831703662872,
-0.651539146900177,
-0.5575035810470581,
0.2534998059272766,
-0.30073848366737366,
-0.12584230303764343,
1.0914150476455688,
-0.4232960045337677,
0.010755930095911026,
0.558275043964386,
0.9287954568862915,
-0.06766483932733536,
-0.22950425744056702,
0.47179871797561646,
-0.7678356766700745,
0.20446866750717163,
0.1589268445968628,
0.7025081515312195,
0.8152276277542114,
-0.49766379594802856,
0.3614347577095032,
0.10444535315036774,
-0.276933878660202,
-0.7895731329917908,
0.14168104529380798,
-0.8644485473632812,
-0.40330770611763,
1.335776448249817,
-0.2687861919403076,
-0.023402977734804153,
-0.11199603974819183,
-0.1279705911874771,
0.4090876877307892,
-0.42885661125183105,
0.8024057149887085,
0.7936711311340332,
0.5238121747970581,
-0.43430978059768677,
-0.38229992985725403,
0.40498098731040955,
0.32021859288215637,
-0.8875375986099243,
-0.010096542537212372,
0.3774607181549072,
-0.06585310399532318,
0.2857723534107208,
0.30252546072006226,
0.05803157016634941,
0.33979806303977966,
-0.08870504051446915,
-0.31508344411849976,
0.16598430275917053,
-0.3484977185726166,
-0.2389446645975113,
0.28634822368621826,
-0.6846877932548523,
0.2878175377845764
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16609v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16609v1
|
Conversational Grounding: Annotation and Analysis of Grounding Acts and Grounding Units
| 2024-03-25T10:39:18 | 2024-03-25T10:39:18 |
Biswesh Mohapatra, Seemab Hassan, Laurent Romary, Justine Cassell
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Successful conversations often rest on common understanding, where all
parties are on the same page about the information being shared. This process,
known as conversational grounding, is crucial for building trustworthy dialog
systems that can accurately keep track of and recall the shared information.
The proficiencies of an agent in grounding the conveyed information
significantly contribute to building a reliable dialog system. Despite recent
advancements in dialog systems, there exists a noticeable deficit in their
grounding capabilities. Traum provided a framework for conversational grounding
introducing Grounding Acts and Grounding Units, but substantial progress,
especially in the realm of Large Language Models, remains lacking. To bridge
this gap, we present the annotation of two dialog corpora employing Grounding
Acts, Grounding Units, and a measure of their degree of grounding. We discuss
our key findings during the annotation and also provide a baseline model to
test the performance of current Language Models in categorizing the grounding
acts of the dialogs. Our work aims to provide a useful resource for further
research in making conversations with machines better understood and more
reliable in natural day-to-day collaborative dialogs.
|
[
-0.4577179253101349,
-1.170411467552185,
0.551925003528595,
0.146256685256958,
-0.1504182368516922,
0.12536892294883728,
-0.03464832529425621,
-0.31123408675193787,
0.09907514601945877,
0.7433972954750061,
-0.27244898676872253,
-0.5517762303352356,
-0.4695504307746887,
-0.2005935162305832,
-0.20876675844192505,
0.7936740517616272,
0.22527630627155304,
-0.0005829032161273062,
-0.6195876598358154,
-0.6744231581687927,
-1.16497802734375,
-1.0436203479766846,
-0.6053506731987,
-0.7482618093490601,
0.08867266029119492,
0.3088044822216034,
1.012975811958313,
0.2157054990530014,
0.4177175760269165,
0.3485027551651001,
-0.23562604188919067,
-0.022434692829847336,
-0.5936439633369446,
0.3295346200466156,
0.042610686272382736,
-0.48509669303894043,
-0.4313276410102844,
0.25486868619918823,
0.5687544941902161,
1.1737667322158813,
0.06951496005058289,
-0.27230751514434814,
-0.18377341330051422,
0.5615105032920837,
-0.24950672686100006,
0.3409252464771271,
-0.45423245429992676,
0.21530817449092865,
0.35791119933128357,
-0.5773974657058716,
-0.623073160648346,
-0.4228935241699219,
0.13499681651592255,
-0.5675478577613831,
0.06909650564193726,
0.10654641687870026,
0.8458741903305054,
0.3523731529712677,
-0.2920511066913605,
-0.4444100558757782,
-0.4736504852771759,
0.4747495949268341,
-0.4319608807563782,
0.345734179019928,
0.6535053253173828,
-0.00014461461978498846,
-0.06122400984168053,
-0.43641865253448486,
-0.2711888253688812,
-0.7914596199989319,
-0.3795512020587921,
0.025751993060112,
0.01248636282980442,
0.3853178918361664,
0.48198145627975464,
0.4439341425895691,
-0.05854213982820511,
-0.2387152463197708,
-0.29658108949661255,
-0.2183104306459427,
0.089572012424469,
-0.02079130709171295,
0.5402470827102661,
-0.024734044447541237,
-0.3077054023742676,
-0.04639297351241112,
-0.5116553902626038,
-0.06155017763376236,
0.1597854346036911,
0.19914838671684265,
-0.3130985498428345,
0.5200530290603638,
-0.21112997829914093,
0.550153911113739,
0.1839924305677414,
-0.03744877874851227,
0.28762978315353394,
0.0005456488579511642,
-0.5425671339035034,
0.2230333387851715,
0.48287442326545715,
0.7987126708030701,
0.22228533029556274,
-0.40539565682411194,
0.05333597958087921,
0.1971074789762497,
0.3604336380958557,
-0.5979939103126526,
-0.16530808806419373,
0.13764916360378265,
-0.31882601976394653,
-0.6613132953643799,
0.13144837319850922,
-0.2007758766412735,
-0.5911511182785034,
-0.7723720073699951,
0.23905712366104126,
-0.4568060636520386,
-0.31392890214920044,
-0.21779511868953705,
-0.22911852598190308,
-0.06092270463705063,
0.333605021238327,
-0.6525730490684509,
0.6370177268981934,
0.7400074005126953,
0.8871362209320068,
0.314480721950531,
-0.16321104764938354,
-0.738844633102417,
-0.022086048498749733,
-0.5185636281967163,
0.5817033052444458,
-0.4750490188598633,
-0.39548957347869873,
0.19733937084674835,
0.22531214356422424,
-0.04449234530329704,
-0.45474421977996826,
0.7260728478431702,
-0.6112194657325745,
0.22311776876449585,
-0.4926674962043762,
-0.555555522441864,
-0.5349648594856262,
0.5166969895362854,
-0.5243080258369446,
0.867758572101593,
0.07702546566724777,
-0.8414646983146667,
0.13856758177280426,
-0.7103576064109802,
-0.376778781414032,
0.2513146996498108,
-0.3225795030593872,
0.07549841701984406,
0.22931888699531555,
-0.24359643459320068,
0.5459783673286438,
-0.12433177977800369,
0.48986709117889404,
-0.1611979752779007,
-0.3191903531551361,
0.38469329476356506,
-0.25632041692733765,
0.718939483165741,
-0.1542046070098877,
-0.39340266585350037,
0.08172588795423508,
-0.7372447848320007,
0.005378281231969595,
-0.1134897917509079,
-0.04148970916867256,
-0.4602198302745819,
0.0054972171783447266,
-0.09823671728372574,
0.1287432312965393,
0.12917721271514893,
-0.02020830102264881,
-0.06068652495741844,
-0.2721630930900574,
0.5221992135047913,
0.36845239996910095,
0.2924938499927521,
0.583977460861206,
-0.3349705636501312,
0.12342165410518646,
0.07834527641534805,
-0.2927680015563965,
-0.5850527286529541,
-0.3769143223762512,
-1.009338617324829,
0.09442274272441864,
0.1750582754611969,
0.6297221183776855,
-0.2975374162197113,
0.6683438420295715,
-0.21146398782730103,
-0.35127153992652893,
-0.21050295233726501,
-0.16593694686889648,
0.3530915677547455,
0.6631978154182434,
0.30298200249671936,
-0.4166567623615265,
-0.5218932032585144,
-0.8803362846374512,
0.2880594730377197,
-0.5846925973892212,
-0.002461889060214162,
0.289937824010849,
0.006108168978244066,
-0.3251281976699829,
1.0712392330169678,
-0.21625792980194092,
-0.06417064368724823,
-0.017304737120866776,
0.7202589511871338,
-0.27226337790489197,
0.6519688367843628,
0.47712162137031555,
-0.7498545050621033,
-0.10927218198776245,
0.10537485033273697,
-1.2453643083572388,
-0.4672306180000305,
-0.22095873951911926,
-0.2612791061401367,
0.06722529232501984,
0.6717959642410278,
-0.7944889664649963,
0.37102097272872925,
0.3824513256549835,
-0.34654030203819275,
0.2466515451669693,
-0.23522619903087616,
0.5705778002738953,
-0.554166316986084,
0.00682700565084815,
-0.2635108530521393,
-0.47829800844192505,
-0.9492374062538147,
-0.006570214405655861,
-0.3136841356754303,
-0.06041650101542473,
-0.22160346806049347,
0.1109602078795433,
-0.3704075515270233,
-0.17641699314117432,
-0.33639025688171387,
0.4353125989437103,
0.10132306814193726,
0.4652062952518463,
0.12474562972784042,
0.8477217555046082,
0.5173628926277161,
-0.7103440165519714,
0.07765065878629684,
0.4354342818260193,
0.29734867811203003,
0.8673407435417175,
-0.6227449178695679,
0.5335521697998047,
-0.23762084543704987,
0.2923014163970947,
-0.9040422439575195,
-0.12707965075969696,
0.36446553468704224,
-0.4441790282726288,
-0.14193694293498993,
-0.43181678652763367,
-0.4602668881416321,
0.19810180366039276,
0.10665421187877655,
0.14644548296928406,
0.3751661777496338,
-0.23569242656230927,
0.6562663316726685,
0.7465117573738098,
-0.01739431545138359,
-0.06768900901079178,
-0.34701311588287354,
0.37879258394241333,
-0.48305651545524597,
-0.950606644153595,
0.0825204998254776,
-0.10632172971963882,
-0.8180649876594543,
-0.4437795877456665,
-0.035799115896224976,
-0.15678471326828003,
0.46993303298950195,
0.881100594997406,
0.02857155352830887,
-0.26535847783088684,
0.26660698652267456,
-0.3322577178478241,
-0.40162259340286255,
0.29264071583747864,
-0.16842783987522125,
0.8619171977043152,
-0.4174203872680664,
-0.2339472472667694,
-0.5941259860992432,
0.36243942379951477,
0.854646623134613,
0.07165409624576569,
0.8049991726875305,
0.339495450258255,
-0.6041589975357056,
0.45651501417160034,
-0.8065913319587708,
-0.08422224223613739,
-0.4275210499763489,
-0.13453762233257294,
-0.4733331799507141,
-0.6953276991844177,
0.5637645721435547,
-0.12413335591554642,
0.01890181377530098,
0.4191504120826721,
0.40933957695961,
-0.15080609917640686,
0.783551812171936,
0.7674522995948792,
-0.12183964252471924,
0.3285137712955475,
-0.09665682911872864,
0.19342771172523499,
-0.5183132290840149,
-0.12406642735004425,
-0.477897971868515,
0.17742957174777985,
-0.42785242199897766,
-0.5542001724243164,
-0.12607336044311523,
0.34721726179122925,
0.050311341881752014,
0.14428281784057617,
-0.33386602997779846,
0.3723784387111664,
0.4473637044429779,
-0.17594146728515625,
0.24637703597545624,
0.03758266940712929,
-0.1131383553147316,
-0.06202011927962303,
-0.1377284973859787,
-1.1990784406661987,
0.43602874875068665,
0.583587646484375,
0.15887224674224854,
-0.17541661858558655,
0.3199118375778198,
0.5887701511383057,
0.3898727595806122,
-0.6362169981002808,
0.5860887765884399,
0.36087915301322937,
-0.3794597387313843,
-0.2387455850839615,
-0.2831524610519409,
-0.529175341129303,
0.388247013092041,
-0.06416462361812592,
-0.8238863945007324,
-0.15385815501213074,
-0.026499861851334572,
-0.1629611849784851,
0.005934538319706917,
-0.7671205997467041,
0.8578658699989319,
-0.014315181411802769,
-0.20246575772762299,
-0.404217928647995,
-0.8864141702651978,
0.1961451768875122,
0.3644687831401825,
0.2904401421546936,
-0.3305243253707886,
0.47021883726119995,
0.8550112843513489,
-0.1784142106771469,
0.9444409608840942,
-0.41363993287086487,
-0.17244166135787964,
0.5605138540267944,
0.03693537041544914,
0.17840906977653503,
0.09684991836547852,
0.02493283897638321,
0.3918665647506714,
-0.10349537432193756,
-0.3285893201828003,
-0.4620909094810486,
0.39068230986595154,
-0.7076461911201477,
-0.5644192099571228,
-0.2847069799900055,
-0.42189642786979675,
-0.23572880029678345,
0.15263642370700836,
-0.08355628699064255,
0.6142382025718689,
-0.6657787561416626,
0.41092655062675476,
0.829057514667511,
0.16506631672382355,
0.19938074052333832,
0.37256163358688354,
-0.1895509511232376,
-0.47743430733680725,
0.6462957859039307,
-0.015177713707089424,
0.326407790184021,
0.37055110931396484,
-0.03756466135382652,
0.06254834681749344,
-0.379276305437088,
-0.11074826866388321,
-0.05825800821185112,
-0.9638540148735046,
0.07200112193822861,
-1.0739822387695312,
-0.19388510286808014,
-0.31392791867256165,
-0.38297104835510254,
-0.019459614530205727,
-0.5696589946746826,
-0.3657326400279999,
-0.5722885131835938,
0.04777800291776657,
0.5956485867500305,
-0.010966223664581776,
0.6888589859008789,
-0.7613744139671326,
0.3610747158527374,
0.2206495702266693,
-0.16320981085300446,
-0.20105896890163422,
-0.20031346380710602,
-0.11034300923347473,
0.29543063044548035,
-0.39178672432899475,
-0.9235415458679199,
-0.020504165440797806,
-0.17227669060230255,
0.5022905468940735,
0.40923547744750977,
-0.04319785162806511,
0.7713786959648132,
-0.4807119369506836,
0.9106312990188599,
0.3937826156616211,
-1.1120100021362305,
0.5524383783340454,
-0.46236205101013184,
-0.1262502670288086,
0.8536468744277954,
-0.18605074286460876,
-1.0579313039779663,
-0.5968264937400818,
-1.0130958557128906,
-0.720389187335968,
0.59919273853302,
0.5333472490310669,
0.2920109033584595,
-0.07629062235355377,
0.15476900339126587,
0.0384119376540184,
0.299490362405777,
-0.576937735080719,
-0.28066009283065796,
-0.14916382730007172,
-0.011582726612687111,
-0.056750234216451645,
-0.39070430397987366,
-0.6984781622886658,
0.1289459615945816,
0.4813753068447113,
-0.19103828072547913,
0.25686219334602356,
0.07717769593000412,
-0.5888869166374207,
-0.3115695118904114,
0.2792286276817322,
0.8916001319885254,
0.6613589525222778,
-0.3719898462295532,
0.4508349299430847,
0.3005704879760742,
-0.36712217330932617,
0.25555872917175293,
-0.018847661092877388,
-0.14213618636131287,
0.13278037309646606,
0.25730952620506287,
1.0181406736373901,
0.4150303602218628,
-0.5133859515190125,
0.373352587223053,
-0.09610013663768768,
-0.012873035855591297,
-0.46358373761177063,
0.0705326646566391,
0.026446111500263214,
0.005603006109595299,
0.4488992393016815,
0.08320118486881256,
0.0005600100848823786,
-0.6947027444839478,
0.37652215361595154,
0.20268644392490387,
-0.6634625792503357,
-0.43781065940856934,
0.2755682170391083,
0.4330691695213318,
-0.5290570855140686,
0.40526455640792847,
-0.23732776939868927,
-0.8259475231170654,
0.6162809729576111,
0.34985458850860596,
0.8878223896026611,
0.10319990664720535,
0.337409108877182,
0.10029032081365585,
0.414028525352478,
-0.11826330423355103,
-0.29539749026298523,
-0.19253520667552948,
-0.73235684633255,
0.14445222914218903,
-0.07803705334663391,
-0.6744553446769714,
0.1392442286014557,
-0.474874347448349,
0.23279879987239838,
-0.5595332980155945,
-0.2493208646774292,
-0.15801632404327393,
0.22681409120559692,
-0.5755007266998291,
0.5472591519355774,
0.41540956497192383,
0.6026397943496704,
-1.14409339427948,
0.16631311178207397,
0.8958122134208679,
-0.5167251229286194,
-0.4773258566856384,
0.09339453279972076,
-0.1207306981086731,
-0.5801220536231995,
0.7113183736801147,
0.6394116878509521,
-0.1693810075521469,
-0.150534525513649,
-0.5197897553443909,
-0.5749127268791199,
1.0633065700531006,
0.1523597687482834,
-0.055245596915483475,
0.0449417419731617,
0.30762627720832825,
0.5977849364280701,
-0.7037652134895325,
0.6064357161521912,
0.6178581714630127,
0.4956611096858978,
0.0475500226020813,
-0.8528493642807007,
0.1816655546426773,
-0.08347243815660477,
-0.21315135061740875,
-0.06164412200450897,
-0.7764628529548645,
0.6076199412345886,
0.40853333473205566,
-0.35009685158729553,
-0.09536688774824142,
0.7013849020004272,
0.3976893723011017,
0.7578245401382446,
0.7225943207740784,
0.6970943212509155,
1.0455963611602783,
-0.248859703540802,
0.47200319170951843,
-0.47566208243370056,
0.18217256665229797,
0.8952392935752869,
-0.3744801878929138,
0.4353601932525635,
0.27433502674102783,
0.2299051433801651,
0.47462427616119385,
0.31653261184692383,
0.3186205327510834,
0.23566961288452148,
0.11253407597541809,
-0.23487380146980286,
-0.2700085937976837,
-0.2728528082370758,
-0.4232284426689148,
0.22835439443588257,
0.5453000664710999,
-0.20892910659313202,
-0.15119168162345886,
-0.010156264528632164,
0.14333279430866241,
0.011165929026901722,
-0.04481321573257446,
0.923949122428894,
0.0626809298992157,
-0.7572169303894043,
0.48619577288627625,
-0.057055018842220306,
0.09987284243106842,
-0.08359485119581223,
-0.1558835804462433,
-0.20461256802082062,
-0.329276442527771,
-0.19780980050563812,
-0.3773864805698395,
0.11842603981494904,
-0.02904529497027397,
-0.18904061615467072,
-0.419013112783432,
0.9245004057884216,
-0.1542346179485321,
-0.03624000772833824,
0.25726258754730225,
0.3722411096096039,
0.3783697485923767,
0.03618716076016426,
-0.4230104088783264,
0.42219796776771545,
-0.12118077278137207,
0.013343890197575092,
-0.036799296736717224,
0.7078816294670105,
-0.12200550734996796,
0.5140094757080078,
0.6435003280639648,
-0.33907270431518555,
0.08023256063461304,
0.3912481963634491,
0.7876773476600647,
-0.7283860445022583,
-0.5683746933937073,
-0.5193862915039062,
0.9012502431869507,
-0.42966794967651367,
-0.09621745347976685,
0.4922383725643158,
0.41568660736083984,
0.23007240891456604,
0.2969432771205902,
0.8513708114624023,
-0.15091493725776672,
0.22115294635295868,
-0.6482191681861877,
0.5618042945861816,
0.10980731248855591,
0.22951869666576385,
-0.09923035651445389,
-0.814152717590332,
-0.1353747844696045,
0.998824954032898,
-0.26995334029197693,
-0.18046705424785614,
0.8309723734855652,
0.42430537939071655,
0.05357852205634117,
0.32136526703834534,
0.6044453978538513,
0.2812482416629791,
0.46880561113357544,
0.03395849093794823,
1.2276904582977295,
-0.5092974901199341,
0.08876100927591324,
-0.1958775669336319,
-0.26302608847618103,
-0.4445425570011139,
-0.728588879108429,
-1.277961015701294,
-0.4893662631511688,
-0.579567551612854,
-0.4140337109565735,
0.1248793676495552,
0.9922904372215271,
0.8836885094642639,
-0.7082279324531555,
-0.136403426527977,
-0.5013025999069214,
0.010160856880247593,
0.081369549036026,
-0.26049166917800903,
-0.057630520313978195,
-0.6553972959518433,
-0.3695102334022522,
0.4649495780467987,
0.3200821280479431,
0.17407654225826263,
-0.16832223534584045,
-0.15600012242794037,
0.005989555735141039,
0.19543203711509705,
0.5534282326698303,
0.22207699716091156,
-0.7109903693199158,
-0.5689235329627991,
-0.2595978379249573,
-0.2662256062030792,
0.39313387870788574,
0.8736938834190369,
-0.8517571687698364,
0.05334336310625076,
0.24797336757183075,
0.498392790555954,
0.0759480893611908,
0.4575617015361786,
0.6576675772666931,
-0.8938496112823486,
0.5569311380386353,
0.24282856285572052,
0.24862150847911835,
0.8092426061630249,
-0.4016139507293701,
0.6352329254150391,
0.3322737216949463,
-0.63117915391922,
-0.9460489749908447,
-0.015423417091369629,
-1.1522265672683716,
0.25499841570854187,
1.0861272811889648,
-0.19112971425056458,
0.15654900670051575,
-0.23794981837272644,
-0.6110596060752869,
0.4312243163585663,
-0.4130558371543884,
0.7172289490699768,
1.1815866231918335,
0.3689671456813812,
-0.19212692975997925,
-0.7040467858314514,
0.2530047297477722,
0.48346251249313354,
-0.9697514772415161,
0.35311904549598694,
0.8251045346260071,
0.020892759785056114,
0.7807753682136536,
0.8848668932914734,
0.313914030790329,
0.06949833780527115,
0.07887133210897446,
-0.15514320135116577,
0.32036691904067993,
-0.3423207402229309,
-0.2701311707496643,
0.5713140368461609,
0.07806774228811264,
-0.16576218605041504
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16592v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16592v1
|
TrustAI at SemEval-2024 Task 8: A Comprehensive Analysis of Multi-domain Machine Generated Text Detection Techniques
| 2024-03-25T10:09:03 | 2024-03-25T10:09:03 |
Ashok Urlana, Aditya Saibewar, Bala Mallikarjunarao Garlapati, Charaka Vinayak Kumar, Ajeet Kumar Singh, Srinivasa Rao Chalamala
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
The Large Language Models (LLMs) exhibit remarkable ability to generate
fluent content across a wide spectrum of user queries. However, this capability
has raised concerns regarding misinformation and personal information leakage.
In this paper, we present our methods for the SemEval2024 Task8, aiming to
detect machine-generated text across various domains in both mono-lingual and
multi-lingual contexts. Our study comprehensively analyzes various methods to
detect machine-generated text, including statistical, neural, and pre-trained
model approaches. We also detail our experimental setup and perform a in-depth
error analysis to evaluate the effectiveness of these methods. Our methods
obtain an accuracy of 86.9\% on the test set of subtask-A mono and 83.7\% for
subtask-B. Furthermore, we also highlight the challenges and essential factors
for consideration in future studies.
|
[
-0.4068872630596161,
-0.9445515871047974,
0.4554067850112915,
0.1842387616634369,
-0.2491455376148224,
0.08683072775602341,
-0.00919606164097786,
-0.5507485270500183,
-0.024263136088848114,
0.6303938627243042,
-0.8141223788261414,
-0.5896914601325989,
-0.7799510955810547,
0.5280925631523132,
-0.2985492944717407,
0.7031399607658386,
-0.4412115216255188,
-0.1155867651104927,
-0.29107192158699036,
-0.12500853836536407,
-0.5475776791572571,
-0.8062083721160889,
-0.646243155002594,
-0.10848242789506912,
0.41620010137557983,
0.46413615345954895,
-0.036884576082229614,
0.0647118091583252,
0.5102845430374146,
0.25389331579208374,
0.12049006670713425,
0.7401418089866638,
-0.3112788498401642,
0.3077355921268463,
-0.15266786515712738,
-0.25479742884635925,
-0.3076493740081787,
-0.14205656945705414,
0.470866322517395,
0.2104487270116806,
0.2461673617362976,
0.2511672079563141,
0.28296369314193726,
0.28112390637397766,
-0.6929834485054016,
-0.04408853128552437,
-0.8063781261444092,
0.06544419378042221,
-0.6737126708030701,
-0.4574817717075348,
-0.6543428897857666,
0.0893285721540451,
-0.04519025981426239,
-0.3886518180370331,
0.20452778041362762,
0.22550390660762787,
0.8936111927032471,
0.1919647753238678,
-0.8177642226219177,
-0.5868660807609558,
-0.35751083493232727,
1.0273120403289795,
-0.7887136340141296,
0.3304188549518585,
0.4828488230705261,
0.10858161747455597,
-0.13505083322525024,
-0.5568031668663025,
-0.5650695562362671,
0.13200634717941284,
-0.02717779017984867,
0.04409720376133919,
-0.005107584875077009,
-0.30163443088531494,
0.28934258222579956,
0.08009117096662521,
-0.6487178802490234,
0.12447004020214081,
-0.03789808973670006,
-0.5655355453491211,
0.5775232315063477,
0.1506824642419815,
0.6216705441474915,
-0.29584816098213196,
-0.515167236328125,
0.10981322824954987,
-0.7538056969642639,
-0.19474263489246368,
0.53031986951828,
0.05788015201687813,
-0.06294284015893936,
0.47711411118507385,
-0.18893124163150787,
0.39935699105262756,
-0.24021382629871368,
-0.3270590007305145,
0.29751157760620117,
-0.7392098307609558,
-0.11769569665193558,
-0.11829514056444168,
1.0352774858474731,
0.06707627326250076,
0.46165961027145386,
0.08512533456087112,
-0.265191912651062,
-0.09211838990449905,
0.2231813669204712,
-0.7221035957336426,
0.14015208184719086,
0.06789389252662659,
-0.43132948875427246,
-0.4611414968967438,
-0.15161339938640594,
-0.6903050541877747,
-0.5209797620773315,
-0.2726110816001892,
0.38625815510749817,
-0.47693416476249695,
-0.19755053520202637,
-0.08543118089437485,
0.05637063458561897,
0.13989229500293732,
0.4140540659427643,
-0.5890254378318787,
-0.026665551587939262,
0.5234297513961792,
0.46487918496131897,
-0.6935115456581116,
-0.48026371002197266,
-0.4483831822872162,
0.05380898714065552,
-0.19649623334407806,
0.8893365263938904,
-0.27429893612861633,
-0.2277977019548416,
0.16387076675891876,
0.29498371481895447,
-0.29081156849861145,
-0.5802962183952332,
0.8363755941390991,
-0.6210238337516785,
0.09990206360816956,
-0.33283334970474243,
-0.6308218240737915,
-0.24353086948394775,
0.4476315677165985,
-0.6799973845481873,
1.0358836650848389,
-0.14095163345336914,
-1.0306190252304077,
0.3306705951690674,
-0.5154998898506165,
-0.7159056663513184,
0.034551896154880524,
-0.15808485448360443,
-0.6136984825134277,
-0.10851691663265228,
0.43991023302078247,
0.74387127161026,
-0.24667997658252716,
0.3978077471256256,
-0.17486438155174255,
-0.11803296953439713,
0.45231306552886963,
-0.776090145111084,
0.6789610385894775,
0.30676281452178955,
-0.6779289841651917,
-0.017012428492307663,
-0.48751041293144226,
-0.017740925773978233,
0.13826081156730652,
-0.11752067506313324,
-0.476301908493042,
-0.3628121614456177,
0.11405422538518906,
0.10164090245962143,
0.6004351377487183,
-0.595703661441803,
-0.2509460151195526,
0.007121996022760868,
0.05909521132707596,
0.742079496383667,
0.3551478385925293,
0.08495719730854034,
-0.07279086112976074,
0.755325973033905,
0.43047288060188293,
-0.07330060005187988,
-0.638058602809906,
-0.5715947151184082,
-0.6957198977470398,
-0.17202645540237427,
0.5037245154380798,
0.6232243776321411,
-0.8533991575241089,
0.2452915906906128,
-0.08538199216127396,
-0.3246780037879944,
-0.1718505620956421,
0.19370535016059875,
0.4836616516113281,
0.35771164298057556,
0.19859319925308228,
-0.09821341931819916,
-0.7415794730186462,
-0.9894681572914124,
-0.46998125314712524,
0.2078312486410141,
0.31962287425994873,
0.3348795175552368,
0.8687732219696045,
-0.6157406568527222,
0.47156423330307007,
-0.27241280674934387,
-0.033814892172813416,
-0.14187607169151306,
0.4516427218914032,
-0.2692233920097351,
0.37690499424934387,
0.47966817021369934,
-0.7886826992034912,
-0.6537070274353027,
0.033017948269844055,
-1.1244374513626099,
-0.28086793422698975,
-0.08345269411802292,
-0.2024349868297577,
0.633137047290802,
0.3785417079925537,
-0.4189108610153198,
0.44689956307411194,
0.5523889660835266,
-0.2511320114135742,
0.5390191674232483,
0.0751999020576477,
0.5559975504875183,
-1.3587390184402466,
0.011293577030301094,
0.18297012150287628,
-0.42478740215301514,
-0.6148137450218201,
0.16254980862140656,
0.23193973302841187,
-0.007613570429384708,
-0.3588477671146393,
0.5760701298713684,
-0.4804803133010864,
0.12182705104351044,
-0.4237242639064789,
0.0030589415691792965,
0.08797311037778854,
0.2639744281768799,
-0.1163833811879158,
1.034554123878479,
0.29212507605552673,
-0.5854346752166748,
0.02159993350505829,
0.020133696496486664,
-0.34771728515625,
0.5540879368782043,
-0.42957615852355957,
0.36693641543388367,
0.029460417106747627,
0.04683206230401993,
-1.0342082977294922,
-0.3076563775539398,
0.26829275488853455,
-0.6706516742706299,
0.208802729845047,
0.11598307639360428,
-0.7088064551353455,
-0.041053954511880875,
-0.1794722080230713,
0.3541339933872223,
0.14990246295928955,
-0.46177902817726135,
0.4830263555049896,
0.787653923034668,
-0.30009424686431885,
-0.7122272253036499,
-0.6575422883033752,
0.21271546185016632,
-0.3417782485485077,
-0.8874839544296265,
0.2145414650440216,
-0.01904040016233921,
-0.21719321608543396,
-0.2789817452430725,
-0.1767105758190155,
-0.27091801166534424,
0.2584703862667084,
0.14504584670066833,
0.15295591950416565,
-0.1721149981021881,
-0.3573276996612549,
0.3405401408672333,
-0.0037214779295027256,
0.15151561796665192,
-0.13758930563926697,
0.5654735565185547,
0.040791139006614685,
-0.43211492896080017,
-0.5257174372673035,
0.5322760939598083,
0.5485988259315491,
-0.4538869261741638,
0.5978552103042603,
0.9017761945724487,
-0.5661156177520752,
-0.5037363767623901,
-0.5534279346466064,
-0.02678389847278595,
-0.45999979972839355,
0.24120232462882996,
-0.5535455346107483,
-1.1200966835021973,
0.49072569608688354,
-0.228208988904953,
-0.07659962773323059,
0.4749728739261627,
0.7058345079421997,
-0.038187406957149506,
0.9954947829246521,
0.5828000903129578,
-0.0850968137383461,
0.04016996920108795,
-0.038176700472831726,
0.36820757389068604,
-0.5758860111236572,
-0.33264264464378357,
-0.6164286732673645,
0.06337845325469971,
-0.5870748162269592,
-0.5265700221061707,
0.3724491596221924,
-0.2329084426164627,
0.02185475081205368,
0.44536951184272766,
-0.16874000430107117,
0.15624220669269562,
0.5833786129951477,
-0.103465236723423,
0.2492944449186325,
0.16412901878356934,
-0.296005517244339,
-0.10751555860042572,
-0.3030974566936493,
-0.660598874092102,
1.0252444744110107,
0.3848857581615448,
0.5755673050880432,
-0.01563231460750103,
0.863061785697937,
0.48878213763237,
0.023992938920855522,
-0.5208860635757446,
0.5039021372795105,
-0.18494614958763123,
-0.6513552665710449,
-0.1833791881799698,
-0.3001324236392975,
-0.8241397142410278,
0.26193201541900635,
-0.003985023591667414,
-0.5295885801315308,
-0.08589774370193481,
-0.0670158714056015,
-0.019693873822689056,
0.027046088129281998,
-0.5520907044410706,
0.9412262439727783,
-0.2420775592327118,
-0.14697349071502686,
-0.03855537995696068,
-0.3402763307094574,
0.4404934346675873,
-0.5676499605178833,
0.2634016275405884,
-0.1525837630033493,
-0.09904653578996658,
0.7297286987304688,
0.027943706139922142,
0.8233057856559753,
-0.03957093134522438,
-0.40966975688934326,
0.5978052616119385,
0.17984405159950256,
0.701744019985199,
0.04506950452923775,
-0.02917664870619774,
0.3446785807609558,
-0.07943713665008545,
-0.199812650680542,
-0.13215447962284088,
0.6519536972045898,
-0.5919229388237,
-0.19597285985946655,
-0.3295600116252899,
-0.4328301250934601,
-0.2726770043373108,
0.45383524894714355,
0.5819706320762634,
0.45970913767814636,
-0.22440382838249207,
0.20534002780914307,
0.9365006685256958,
-0.41571342945098877,
0.3257778286933899,
0.41079282760620117,
-0.013892773538827896,
-0.27365756034851074,
0.8182776570320129,
-0.057550493627786636,
-0.1492210328578949,
0.4052581191062927,
0.014998003840446472,
-0.23634088039398193,
-0.6266601085662842,
-0.4740569293498993,
0.1217806339263916,
-0.7481756210327148,
-0.31759876012802124,
-0.797535240650177,
-0.2419588714838028,
-0.6693359613418579,
0.14953330159187317,
-0.17089693248271942,
0.004383235704153776,
-0.23529453575611115,
-0.0531088225543499,
-0.12060728669166565,
0.5529437065124512,
0.40830907225608826,
0.20330870151519775,
-0.9695046544075012,
0.3760424554347992,
-0.07367269694805145,
-0.3220202922821045,
-0.3010714650154114,
-0.5308827757835388,
-0.24344566464424133,
0.07902588695287704,
-0.2450796216726303,
-0.7984604835510254,
0.504486083984375,
-0.05942052975296974,
0.724714994430542,
0.17851939797401428,
0.024169018492102623,
0.40980303287506104,
-0.6336429119110107,
0.8955869674682617,
-0.10940523445606232,
-0.9558832049369812,
0.6320996880531311,
-0.5047644972801208,
0.3053884506225586,
0.4839414060115814,
0.5821179151535034,
-0.46292659640312195,
-0.4049099087715149,
-0.44500863552093506,
-0.6325235962867737,
0.504869282245636,
0.3508525788784027,
0.19436469674110413,
0.1217794269323349,
0.1868947297334671,
0.27933788299560547,
0.3077293336391449,
-0.5845072269439697,
-0.24583351612091064,
0.2117794007062912,
-0.3887539803981781,
0.14002525806427002,
-0.3892141878604889,
0.09447947144508362,
0.25695499777793884,
0.7775991559028625,
-0.2082134187221527,
0.20936906337738037,
0.05455060303211212,
-0.3749701678752899,
0.05008235573768616,
0.3211134374141693,
0.8474217057228088,
0.6497721076011658,
0.3201224207878113,
0.26145365834236145,
0.28291258215904236,
-0.5425907373428345,
0.05844886600971222,
0.0033289489801973104,
-0.27763062715530396,
0.2196153700351715,
0.5145856142044067,
0.7124719023704529,
-0.06675631552934647,
-0.6419697403907776,
0.5988295674324036,
-0.14680056273937225,
-0.23159749805927277,
-0.5135756134986877,
-0.19943799078464508,
-0.04858317971229553,
0.010365523397922516,
0.1506197452545166,
0.22195392847061157,
0.41757702827453613,
-0.3622017502784729,
0.40648654103279114,
0.3914850950241089,
-0.27429497241973877,
-0.46032655239105225,
0.4961628019809723,
0.2616024315357208,
0.03178230673074722,
0.3266420364379883,
-0.34166648983955383,
-0.7645552158355713,
0.6822338104248047,
0.5471445918083191,
0.9552367925643921,
-0.18526987731456757,
0.2231190800666809,
0.239812433719635,
0.4564025402069092,
0.07533557713031769,
0.36122044920921326,
0.04920763894915581,
-1.0635244846343994,
-0.5528132319450378,
-0.5548049807548523,
-0.38594260811805725,
0.42237043380737305,
-0.2894950807094574,
0.29462164640426636,
0.024334298446774483,
-0.155242919921875,
0.06138318032026291,
0.10513832420110703,
-0.6124842762947083,
0.18506430089473724,
0.38608264923095703,
0.7922847270965576,
-0.7539721727371216,
0.6965704560279846,
0.8898510336875916,
-0.06646965444087982,
-0.784260094165802,
0.1903105080127716,
0.3978227972984314,
-0.7554858326911926,
0.6840108036994934,
0.3470502197742462,
-0.4578315317630768,
-0.21849772334098816,
-0.5861560702323914,
-0.6226789951324463,
1.002329707145691,
0.09208501130342484,
-0.3354845345020294,
0.18623943626880646,
0.4246024787425995,
0.3749745190143585,
-0.4517984390258789,
0.015562430955469608,
0.42749011516571045,
0.5138909816741943,
-0.23669955134391785,
-1.004362940788269,
0.10201731324195862,
-0.2850487530231476,
-0.036146752536296844,
0.05593372881412506,
-0.5611339807510376,
0.7573283314704895,
0.2516801059246063,
-0.15200744569301605,
0.1233072355389595,
0.6107248663902283,
0.4251095652580261,
0.5929496884346008,
0.4635193943977356,
0.4962906241416931,
0.8695379495620728,
0.18010978400707245,
0.7987579107284546,
-0.42731162905693054,
0.3384835720062256,
0.9002902507781982,
-0.5770077705383301,
0.5958783626556396,
0.21402260661125183,
0.1958947330713272,
0.41146770119667053,
0.7004448771476746,
0.13916966319084167,
0.3249932825565338,
0.06220494955778122,
-0.4287351965904236,
-0.30048269033432007,
-0.2162436842918396,
-0.14449673891067505,
0.5193908214569092,
0.37291184067726135,
-0.40386438369750977,
-0.05683806911110878,
0.23443946242332458,
0.27994126081466675,
0.018354369327425957,
-0.1283235251903534,
0.5957184433937073,
0.2949015200138092,
-0.9262330532073975,
0.19358505308628082,
0.3611493706703186,
0.9873366355895996,
-0.4051561951637268,
0.06012924388051033,
-0.14469003677368164,
0.3612886369228363,
-0.017058400437235832,
-0.5195280313491821,
0.27172496914863586,
0.26054322719573975,
0.03421007841825485,
-0.3817157447338104,
1.523711919784546,
-0.36510762572288513,
-0.31584128737449646,
0.1489570587873459,
0.7331679463386536,
0.14886167645454407,
-0.30669093132019043,
-0.6925356388092041,
0.3101435601711273,
0.20563532412052155,
-0.1482614129781723,
0.2332625389099121,
0.7052599191665649,
-0.17322911322116852,
0.40262237191200256,
0.36550334095954895,
-0.29086703062057495,
0.2805812954902649,
0.07276228070259094,
0.4511576294898987,
-0.42027461528778076,
-0.27161940932273865,
-0.7903924584388733,
0.32048434019088745,
-0.2411983162164688,
-0.37468451261520386,
1.1901755332946777,
0.6625850796699524,
0.9543650150299072,
-0.3538554310798645,
1.1167328357696533,
0.10646674036979675,
0.607606053352356,
-0.6608791351318359,
0.5907859802246094,
-0.5835144519805908,
0.16272054612636566,
-0.26791438460350037,
-0.7064647078514099,
0.021961865946650505,
0.3715134263038635,
-0.0755542740225792,
-0.02462160959839821,
0.9924286603927612,
0.7013492584228516,
-0.01962372288107872,
0.15585710108280182,
0.34554237127304077,
-0.15718822181224823,
0.20700453221797943,
0.32170549035072327,
1.0251785516738892,
-0.6653830409049988,
0.4652132987976074,
-0.2628554403781891,
0.06730879098176956,
-0.13994094729423523,
-0.7019688487052917,
-1.134622573852539,
-0.6096217036247253,
-0.4560354948043823,
-0.20258185267448425,
-0.06338649243116379,
0.4384680986404419,
0.7914915680885315,
-1.0605605840682983,
-0.19604407250881195,
0.08042716979980469,
0.06460648775100708,
0.1627238541841507,
-0.23302721977233887,
0.13823455572128296,
-0.5028191208839417,
-0.8960754871368408,
0.4872318208217621,
0.14395056664943695,
-0.11715831607580185,
-0.30140310525894165,
0.11135564744472504,
-0.18452942371368408,
0.21452373266220093,
0.7639143466949463,
-0.2098836749792099,
-0.4882897734642029,
-0.29957476258277893,
0.2999071776866913,
-0.2943309545516968,
-0.2065923810005188,
0.9418157935142517,
-0.27194544672966003,
0.12139113992452621,
0.8387451171875,
0.8258309364318848,
0.4239640235900879,
0.06205301731824875,
0.47474053502082825,
-0.8914375901222229,
-0.16761615872383118,
0.11326488107442856,
0.5232369303703308,
0.3572833240032196,
-0.5333531498908997,
0.545609712600708,
0.34957367181777954,
-0.7118477821350098,
-0.7893404364585876,
0.24152226746082306,
-0.8107224106788635,
-0.3155381977558136,
1.281367540359497,
-0.3946499824523926,
-0.2735108435153961,
-0.2893514633178711,
-0.15916801989078522,
0.252778559923172,
-0.18106800317764282,
0.17849725484848022,
0.8544599413871765,
-0.015518156811594963,
-0.1569439321756363,
-0.7707099318504333,
0.4186381697654724,
0.2912971079349518,
-1.1702337265014648,
-0.25187546014785767,
0.5157504677772522,
0.3882445693016052,
0.2916244864463806,
0.7018468976020813,
-0.18552634119987488,
0.043430790305137634,
-0.08994005620479584,
-0.018383894115686417,
0.09541721642017365,
-0.5771599411964417,
-0.1628589630126953,
0.25847265124320984,
-0.1674213707447052,
-0.14365114271640778
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16584v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16584v2
|
Can Large Language Models (or Humans) Disentangle Text?
| 2024-03-25T09:51:54 | 2024-05-03T14:04:19 |
Nicolas Audinet de Pieuchon, Adel Daoud, Connor Thomas Jerzak, Moa Johansson, Richard Johansson
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, 68T50, I.2.7; H.1.2
|
We investigate the potential of large language models (LLMs) to disentangle
text variables--to remove the textual traces of an undesired forbidden variable
in a task sometimes known as text distillation and closely related to the
fairness in AI and causal inference literature. We employ a range of various
LLM approaches in an attempt to disentangle text by identifying and removing
information about a target variable while preserving other relevant signals. We
show that in the strong test of removing sentiment, the statistical association
between the processed text and sentiment is still detectable to machine
learning classifiers post-LLM-disentanglement. Furthermore, we find that human
annotators also struggle to disentangle sentiment while preserving other
semantic content. This suggests there may be limited separability between
concept variables in some text contexts, highlighting limitations of methods
relying on text-level transformations and also raising questions about the
robustness of disentanglement methods that achieve statistical independence in
representation space.
|
[
-0.26160815358161926,
-1.0800549983978271,
0.8883211612701416,
0.09621332585811615,
-0.483979195356369,
0.2505073845386505,
-0.4550527036190033,
-0.5389671325683594,
-0.04421998932957649,
0.5610995292663574,
-0.5983321666717529,
-0.254207581281662,
-1.0000649690628052,
0.18396171927452087,
-0.7736283540725708,
1.051536202430725,
-0.11178956180810928,
-0.038259319961071014,
-0.4528657793998718,
-0.04258468374609947,
-0.28884410858154297,
-0.7238158583641052,
-0.48211848735809326,
-0.6802553534507751,
0.690136194229126,
-0.01251862570643425,
0.7275004386901855,
0.7053300142288208,
0.7731539011001587,
0.40826916694641113,
-0.529310405254364,
-0.01703023351728916,
-0.4826100170612335,
0.34564098715782166,
-0.4472379684448242,
-0.7545701861381531,
-0.24498029053211212,
0.36221742630004883,
0.6932229995727539,
0.8861840963363647,
0.03884131461381912,
-0.16049201786518097,
0.2836243212223053,
0.845176637172699,
-0.30958789587020874,
0.18494917452335358,
-0.6264516711235046,
0.009646865539252758,
-0.1890433430671692,
0.1978512406349182,
-0.5419567823410034,
-0.1901150792837143,
-0.0544104166328907,
-0.015321983024477959,
0.16919788718223572,
-0.020387526601552963,
1.101623296737671,
0.5702815651893616,
-0.6254744529724121,
-0.26405417919158936,
-1.115838885307312,
1.0199686288833618,
-0.5202291011810303,
0.07013069093227386,
0.7481780648231506,
0.03274088352918625,
-0.025349536910653114,
-0.29212266206741333,
-0.8095631003379822,
0.011470799334347248,
-0.17494574189186096,
-0.00646045571193099,
-0.2441413551568985,
-0.0783197209239006,
0.3426193594932556,
0.25595465302467346,
-0.3152296543121338,
0.22833675146102905,
-0.21254661679267883,
-0.10747864842414856,
0.7784069776535034,
0.1965538114309311,
0.5173540711402893,
-0.4162856340408325,
-0.2599382996559143,
0.012826082296669483,
-0.5369872450828552,
-0.2158818244934082,
0.28408488631248474,
0.16578298807144165,
0.10762326419353485,
0.66197669506073,
0.21988224983215332,
0.3095972239971161,
-0.04880344495177269,
-0.26300227642059326,
0.19837966561317444,
0.05495229363441467,
-0.2939576208591461,
-0.017395172268152237,
1.1383689641952515,
0.20106233656406403,
0.1389211118221283,
-0.2494737207889557,
-0.36996960639953613,
0.23994453251361847,
0.030616452917456627,
-0.5290611386299133,
-0.13882766664028168,
0.14108748733997345,
-0.7126609086990356,
-0.3472719192504883,
-0.06773073971271515,
-0.7061852812767029,
-0.8601202368736267,
-0.3351030647754669,
0.3367403745651245,
-0.13595183193683624,
-0.5409481525421143,
0.147696390748024,
-0.2582564055919647,
0.29683032631874084,
0.22735808789730072,
-1.075778603553772,
0.27456381916999817,
0.7989006042480469,
0.6738007664680481,
-0.10586933046579361,
-0.17727510631084442,
-0.21771161258220673,
-0.031165074557065964,
-0.31826674938201904,
0.22316443920135498,
-0.6545665264129639,
-0.3257846236228943,
-0.27406230568885803,
0.06762730330228806,
0.1621166169643402,
-0.5997292399406433,
0.1852038949728012,
-0.6349397301673889,
0.19930703938007355,
-0.28043273091316223,
-0.7631740570068359,
-0.21616604924201965,
0.16248109936714172,
-1.0440409183502197,
0.45653998851776123,
-0.14465706050395966,
-0.804739236831665,
0.20050838589668274,
-0.013918322511017323,
-0.44871819019317627,
-0.39267417788505554,
-0.3677234947681427,
-0.4708870053291321,
0.35995787382125854,
-0.10810866951942444,
0.4370058476924896,
-0.6178213357925415,
0.5003901124000549,
-0.44672873616218567,
-0.34805864095687866,
0.6424735188484192,
-1.039744257926941,
0.9141886830329895,
0.2065017968416214,
-0.44594481587409973,
-0.24255195260047913,
-0.7622859477996826,
-0.5481745600700378,
0.1541372686624527,
-0.3857521414756775,
-0.6781091690063477,
0.33613336086273193,
-0.038612447679042816,
0.26873907446861267,
0.266297847032547,
-0.7173613905906677,
0.15472251176834106,
-0.32892367243766785,
0.5974785685539246,
0.9367508292198181,
-0.27058467268943787,
0.5996249318122864,
-0.030080163851380348,
0.2762032151222229,
0.39030176401138306,
-0.27020058035850525,
0.17906196415424347,
-0.3146725594997406,
-0.7442960739135742,
-0.6706996560096741,
0.29170331358909607,
0.43823567032814026,
-0.6687255501747131,
0.5665649771690369,
-0.04931505396962166,
-0.14316435158252716,
-0.5253256559371948,
0.16972917318344116,
0.4285934567451477,
0.37326496839523315,
0.04937377944588661,
-0.0016527974512428045,
-0.23710227012634277,
-0.8072552680969238,
-0.5074176788330078,
-0.3496485650539398,
-0.233491912484169,
-0.15325480699539185,
0.517877459526062,
-0.3460196554660797,
1.1042284965515137,
-0.6401731967926025,
-0.21930164098739624,
-0.20273292064666748,
0.3521244525909424,
0.09032857418060303,
0.2585063576698303,
0.33454129099845886,
-1.1444557905197144,
-0.21447382867336273,
-0.1792980432510376,
-1.150802731513977,
0.012367635034024715,
-0.23113298416137695,
0.19248968362808228,
0.12037353217601776,
0.779427170753479,
-0.7612581849098206,
0.614530086517334,
0.3449188768863678,
-0.47887474298477173,
0.1311635673046112,
-0.3768705129623413,
0.09516517072916031,
-1.0184279680252075,
-0.13780049979686737,
0.3710077702999115,
-0.43270358443260193,
-0.4917050004005432,
-0.12790542840957642,
0.053530678153038025,
0.15739713609218597,
-0.2764189541339874,
0.39340639114379883,
-0.3530460298061371,
0.3693605959415436,
-0.5656983852386475,
0.19884248077869415,
0.25459975004196167,
0.21465431153774261,
0.08803105354309082,
0.16335223615169525,
0.3542393743991852,
-0.3456014394760132,
0.23480118811130524,
0.31033098697662354,
-0.22184786200523376,
0.40453198552131653,
-0.5280542969703674,
-0.07374806702136993,
-0.7365200519561768,
0.18200352787971497,
-1.1954773664474487,
-0.2358739972114563,
0.2537417709827423,
-0.26961785554885864,
0.21584701538085938,
0.11898654699325562,
-0.6146681308746338,
-0.09852226823568344,
-0.2171899825334549,
0.37323400378227234,
0.704932689666748,
-0.6237348318099976,
0.5530511140823364,
0.5512584447860718,
-0.06944916397333145,
-0.48947155475616455,
-1.190745234489441,
0.12502598762512207,
-0.6268022656440735,
-0.16320976614952087,
0.17848119139671326,
-0.008557436987757683,
-0.6666145324707031,
0.11260320991277695,
0.011559013277292252,
-0.4224860370159149,
0.2891325056552887,
0.49954482913017273,
0.45975956320762634,
0.2787795662879944,
0.6853857636451721,
0.11796682327985764,
-0.008626606315374374,
0.3953127861022949,
0.045716263353824615,
0.34779736399650574,
0.08063171058893204,
-0.39955228567123413,
-0.5258840918540955,
0.3895992934703827,
0.6029977798461914,
-0.16384349763393402,
1.1264573335647583,
0.6307719349861145,
-0.5621510148048401,
-0.04446287453174591,
-0.38018661737442017,
0.02169090509414673,
-0.5156641006469727,
0.47347792983055115,
-0.24303758144378662,
-1.2238423824310303,
0.4787776470184326,
-0.1172255203127861,
-0.12057756632566452,
0.5013538002967834,
0.464878112077713,
-0.3292102813720703,
1.222854495048523,
0.8206112384796143,
-0.5334576368331909,
0.3305395543575287,
0.12942661345005035,
0.5178236365318298,
-0.6844564080238342,
-0.026417633518576622,
-0.6794368624687195,
-0.2777348458766937,
-0.8818118572235107,
-0.15795239806175232,
-0.07182759791612625,
0.32012423872947693,
-0.19643494486808777,
-0.1331813484430313,
-0.45775192975997925,
0.7002072930335999,
0.2639327645301819,
0.27823978662490845,
0.35408735275268555,
-0.0942978635430336,
0.268408864736557,
-0.214626744389534,
-0.07411208003759384,
-0.7108383774757385,
0.8983153104782104,
0.561790943145752,
0.8397932648658752,
0.07371868193149567,
1.0292338132858276,
0.33275845646858215,
0.28616008162498474,
-0.6613052487373352,
0.5923709869384766,
-0.5167302489280701,
-0.6639091372489929,
-0.43694445490837097,
-0.8629130125045776,
-0.832542896270752,
0.3452364504337311,
-0.3175261914730072,
-1.0764868259429932,
-0.12761765718460083,
-0.02318599447607994,
0.17497797310352325,
0.659780740737915,
-0.6573470830917358,
0.5976248383522034,
-0.05713249742984772,
-0.36382582783699036,
-0.11182164400815964,
-0.5134665369987488,
0.5345789194107056,
-0.3973240852355957,
0.4754410982131958,
-0.30728450417518616,
0.17323993146419525,
0.7798301577568054,
-0.34511101245880127,
1.1471056938171387,
-0.07377015799283981,
-0.4336577355861664,
0.37530115246772766,
0.06487900018692017,
0.30537834763526917,
-0.038996078073978424,
-0.05372776463627815,
0.23937281966209412,
-0.12254784256219864,
-0.2033795267343521,
-0.3801078498363495,
0.6025900840759277,
-0.8682595491409302,
-0.7442125678062439,
-0.35260921716690063,
-0.5013980865478516,
0.03510107472538948,
0.33219578862190247,
0.05306660756468773,
0.22379064559936523,
-0.2543903589248657,
0.2609061300754547,
0.8631901741027832,
-0.4363541901111603,
0.7453720569610596,
0.27043673396110535,
-0.18134044110774994,
-0.06242186948657036,
1.1203182935714722,
-0.2290439009666443,
0.14953593909740448,
0.6142373085021973,
0.3892728388309479,
-0.41249027848243713,
-0.35238775610923767,
0.12512969970703125,
0.32761502265930176,
-0.7761266231536865,
0.16305816173553467,
-0.33598214387893677,
-0.20931126177310944,
-0.0631815493106842,
0.07128462195396423,
-0.3137655258178711,
-0.2411726415157318,
-0.7300631403923035,
-0.14915072917938232,
0.24206897616386414,
0.9435161352157593,
0.0007711420767009258,
0.31589922308921814,
-0.9170870184898376,
0.48042628169059753,
0.3147495687007904,
0.237619549036026,
-0.06390755623579025,
-0.2992076575756073,
-0.0241545420140028,
0.10958946496248245,
-0.026276426389813423,
-0.7188617587089539,
0.48910728096961975,
-0.15704159438610077,
0.13947468996047974,
0.43430039286613464,
0.1760377287864685,
0.3199642300605774,
-0.5858342051506042,
0.8686048984527588,
0.6591718792915344,
-1.1689273118972778,
0.30829918384552,
-0.4070039391517639,
0.4281955659389496,
0.3843424320220947,
0.46736493706703186,
-0.5739757418632507,
-0.8531796336174011,
-0.2417747676372528,
-0.923078179359436,
0.5647251009941101,
-0.010572455823421478,
0.2501870393753052,
-0.29816290736198425,
0.605941653251648,
0.16184361279010773,
0.3215429186820984,
-0.8977692127227783,
-0.17930521070957184,
0.2791628837585449,
-0.7082802653312683,
-0.32361018657684326,
-0.3628690838813782,
-0.1799798309803009,
-0.06780140101909637,
0.161363884806633,
0.31471359729766846,
0.068709596991539,
-0.025041423738002777,
-0.27504298090934753,
0.013904927298426628,
0.30738553404808044,
0.21955470740795135,
0.47008833289146423,
0.07688934355974197,
0.434324711561203,
-0.2926758825778961,
-0.5764920711517334,
0.5319021940231323,
-0.10129847377538681,
-0.08707152307033539,
-0.20713603496551514,
0.533470630645752,
0.4687674939632416,
-0.24022842943668365,
-0.6041640043258667,
0.501230001449585,
-0.5246109366416931,
-0.4293116629123688,
0.006293644197285175,
0.07939520478248596,
0.3615475296974182,
0.41903945803642273,
0.2525676190853119,
0.023506222292780876,
-0.1476721465587616,
-0.6080603003501892,
0.15122950077056885,
0.38762912154197693,
-0.6034227013587952,
-0.32706114649772644,
0.8969112634658813,
0.09006362408399582,
-0.29306527972221375,
0.6292251944541931,
-0.10288050770759583,
-0.3169754147529602,
0.5937278866767883,
0.18796305358409882,
0.9614154696464539,
-0.0328906886279583,
0.3167670965194702,
-0.07871539890766144,
0.31482240557670593,
-0.4101380407810211,
-0.12462157756090164,
0.28459399938583374,
-0.861265242099762,
-0.47289758920669556,
-0.5750669836997986,
-0.07090896368026733,
0.0619545504450798,
-0.7518520951271057,
-0.102089062333107,
-0.35133376717567444,
-0.33500033617019653,
0.3676677346229553,
-0.21847203373908997,
-0.6142358183860779,
0.32669585943222046,
0.35183995962142944,
0.2201349288225174,
-1.0224990844726562,
0.7824661731719971,
0.42040541768074036,
-0.4482947289943695,
-0.5478336811065674,
0.33868980407714844,
0.27202755212783813,
-0.1539820283651352,
0.7970243096351624,
0.10573573410511017,
-0.2575538754463196,
-0.4176759421825409,
-0.6618804335594177,
-0.4566810429096222,
0.6601327657699585,
0.556281566619873,
-0.7617876529693604,
0.06497903913259506,
0.48795703053474426,
0.6493724584579468,
0.10256753861904144,
0.16982953250408173,
0.7302950024604797,
0.3479374647140503,
-0.32034626603126526,
-0.8070561289787292,
0.14576885104179382,
0.020002830773591995,
-0.058872003108263016,
0.30640938878059387,
-0.8571688532829285,
1.2214272022247314,
0.20010258257389069,
-0.14889603853225708,
-0.13253197073936462,
0.6711979508399963,
-0.05253133177757263,
0.1430450677871704,
0.6811589598655701,
0.32093581557273865,
0.9409615993499756,
-0.14767272770404816,
0.5836551189422607,
0.0241374671459198,
0.5988243222236633,
1.0260120630264282,
-0.4596915543079376,
0.7209500074386597,
0.6424746513366699,
-0.054062262177467346,
0.34761399030685425,
0.32465067505836487,
0.3910660147666931,
0.6149754524230957,
0.17633144557476044,
-0.5299073457717896,
-0.3468714654445648,
0.2139682024717331,
0.1613312065601349,
0.7810651659965515,
0.27739882469177246,
-0.5766414403915405,
-0.08143260329961777,
0.3011200726032257,
0.11247337609529495,
0.3649362325668335,
-0.19400495290756226,
0.8602181673049927,
0.24022319912910461,
-0.5458970665931702,
0.4170893728733063,
0.13549743592739105,
0.5563390851020813,
-0.46142926812171936,
0.020531756803393364,
-0.16514252126216888,
0.5887489914894104,
-0.09813759475946426,
-0.8656526207923889,
0.4078301191329956,
0.17510731518268585,
-0.40838316082954407,
-0.4558706283569336,
0.8328033089637756,
-0.6294867992401123,
-0.43972209095954895,
0.47884032130241394,
0.5149426460266113,
0.0540136955678463,
0.022348657250404358,
-0.3828098177909851,
0.3002302646636963,
0.11150899529457092,
-0.5073127746582031,
0.6505351066589355,
0.7334134578704834,
0.13930527865886688,
0.7265814542770386,
0.15935444831848145,
0.08047200739383698,
-0.29128313064575195,
0.10210029780864716,
1.0221108198165894,
-1.011584758758545,
-0.23804369568824768,
-1.4789681434631348,
0.3040214478969574,
-0.0861380472779274,
0.037341710180044174,
0.7828753590583801,
0.15831881761550903,
0.5691585540771484,
0.08584614098072052,
0.9169656038284302,
0.034619275480508804,
0.32699054479599,
-0.3925255835056305,
1.0075539350509644,
-0.5656003355979919,
0.4018937349319458,
-0.4825822114944458,
-0.7201721668243408,
-0.2740494906902313,
0.5090036988258362,
-0.2180115133523941,
-0.09304387122392654,
0.7370132803916931,
0.44509127736091614,
0.17357558012008667,
0.12508337199687958,
0.38260096311569214,
0.22138331830501556,
0.6822521686553955,
0.46488237380981445,
1.0436569452285767,
-0.17482541501522064,
0.436189204454422,
0.1357160359621048,
-0.42760947346687317,
0.023829946294426918,
-0.7942678332328796,
-1.2255051136016846,
-0.5420105457305908,
-0.39977508783340454,
-0.1830107420682907,
-0.13217449188232422,
0.47624582052230835,
0.24190664291381836,
-0.3122580051422119,
-0.11856046319007874,
-0.10594314336776733,
0.46151793003082275,
-0.042918767780065536,
-0.1904638260602951,
0.36326268315315247,
-0.1439896523952484,
-0.9271771311759949,
-0.0025256825610995293,
0.2889910340309143,
0.036096155643463135,
-0.5467950105667114,
0.31742215156555176,
0.002815560670569539,
0.21069161593914032,
0.6995196342468262,
-0.08431650698184967,
-0.5628038048744202,
-0.6530146598815918,
-0.32991814613342285,
-0.3485014736652374,
-0.11147788912057877,
0.6019742488861084,
-0.4930259883403778,
0.5102987885475159,
0.5588521957397461,
0.5643652677536011,
0.3854191303253174,
-0.11541390419006348,
0.4182054400444031,
-0.8449210524559021,
0.4892471134662628,
0.11011061072349548,
0.3636590540409088,
0.19447974860668182,
-0.34090471267700195,
0.06652596592903137,
0.06949406117200851,
-0.5000960826873779,
-0.8152235150337219,
0.2293783575296402,
-0.6600023508071899,
-0.6697427034378052,
1.148370385169983,
-0.16775238513946533,
-0.6655217409133911,
0.042734574526548386,
-0.04782534018158913,
0.34444260597229004,
-0.036364175379276276,
1.0050156116485596,
1.0781919956207275,
0.07863869518041611,
-0.046218033879995346,
-0.3629459738731384,
0.38929057121276855,
0.23685790598392487,
-0.8788543343544006,
0.42346879839897156,
0.611440122127533,
0.24286210536956787,
0.04565884545445442,
0.7156155705451965,
-0.20682142674922943,
-0.2577531635761261,
0.10842765122652054,
-0.06380313634872437,
0.39698442816734314,
-0.3159386217594147,
-0.5072829127311707,
0.165978342294693,
0.1917065680027008,
-0.3131728768348694
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16571v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16571v1
|
NSINA: A News Corpus for Sinhala
| 2024-03-25T09:36:51 | 2024-03-25T09:36:51 |
Hansi Hettiarachchi, Damith Premasiri, Lasitha Uyangodage, Tharindu Ranasinghe
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The introduction of large language models (LLMs) has advanced natural
language processing (NLP), but their effectiveness is largely dependent on
pre-training resources. This is especially evident in low-resource languages,
such as Sinhala, which face two primary challenges: the lack of substantial
training data and limited benchmarking datasets. In response, this study
introduces NSINA, a comprehensive news corpus of over 500,000 articles from
popular Sinhala news websites, along with three NLP tasks: news media
identification, news category prediction, and news headline generation. The
release of NSINA aims to provide a solution to challenges in adapting LLMs to
Sinhala, offering valuable resources and benchmarks for improving NLP in the
Sinhala language. NSINA is the largest news corpus for Sinhala, available up to
date.
|
[
-0.13059808313846588,
-0.373360276222229,
0.3065149486064911,
0.3293432295322418,
-0.538434624671936,
0.14200448989868164,
-0.316511869430542,
-0.5066362023353577,
0.6085222363471985,
0.6842712759971619,
-0.37933778762817383,
-0.4041616916656494,
-0.5018079280853271,
0.47266092896461487,
-0.7608302235603333,
0.8907402753829956,
-0.09011902660131454,
0.10879720002412796,
-0.2639574706554413,
-0.1171647384762764,
-0.5536074638366699,
-0.5037539005279541,
-0.6549309492111206,
0.06348807364702225,
0.5047832727432251,
0.3862878084182739,
0.35363662242889404,
0.342739075422287,
0.5524432063102722,
0.2016836702823639,
-0.07321662455797195,
0.2648821771144867,
-0.35249316692352295,
0.17390033602714539,
-0.12211823463439941,
-0.8938071727752686,
-0.2913650870323181,
-0.2550196647644043,
0.7967392206192017,
0.6376709938049316,
-0.1299981325864792,
0.2769087553024292,
-0.24306683242321014,
0.6855674982070923,
-0.6082257628440857,
-0.3354366421699524,
-0.627981960773468,
-0.03460923582315445,
-0.6843291521072388,
-0.2637922465801239,
-0.28728336095809937,
-0.5119238495826721,
-0.39326512813568115,
-0.49991267919540405,
-0.05483826994895935,
0.0886530727148056,
0.9509525299072266,
0.7407464981079102,
-0.46082910895347595,
-0.4122471809387207,
-0.4967784583568573,
0.9706387519836426,
-0.7570338845252991,
0.5228245854377747,
0.5920386910438538,
0.2713676691055298,
-0.07399793714284897,
-0.6002410054206848,
-0.3400014042854309,
-0.12738843262195587,
0.02105501852929592,
-0.30509406328201294,
-0.23751649260520935,
-0.2684057354927063,
0.18618719279766083,
0.1672811359167099,
-0.48717427253723145,
0.13789129257202148,
-0.5737054347991943,
0.07935978472232819,
0.5610539317131042,
0.12060806900262833,
0.44421082735061646,
-0.5555804967880249,
-0.34144577383995056,
0.3995925784111023,
-0.7967070937156677,
-0.5003571510314941,
0.514060914516449,
0.30862361192703247,
-0.3110279440879822,
0.4703071117401123,
-0.45451462268829346,
0.9308314919471741,
-0.25475820899009705,
-0.4513853192329407,
0.2603115141391754,
-0.27638405561447144,
-0.30616840720176697,
0.5499706268310547,
0.5689108967781067,
0.2906379699707031,
-0.08482953161001205,
-0.012153323739767075,
0.028723739087581635,
0.04226912185549736,
0.5010741949081421,
-0.7695691585540771,
0.4265255033969879,
0.27216336131095886,
-0.5809082984924316,
-0.4753393530845642,
-0.5356264710426331,
-0.9632547497749329,
-0.2847951054573059,
-0.6091986298561096,
-0.17716945707798004,
-0.12139168381690979,
-0.34039929509162903,
-0.08186154812574387,
-0.0488756000995636,
0.26206353306770325,
0.47385546565055847,
-0.8663488626480103,
0.30906781554222107,
0.6316876411437988,
0.8990519642829895,
-0.3896556496620178,
-0.23482367396354675,
-0.5490695834159851,
-0.10376406461000443,
-0.6403963565826416,
0.9246355295181274,
-0.4457831084728241,
-0.14132212102413177,
-0.21403145790100098,
-0.10277312248945236,
0.03948628902435303,
-0.5958578586578369,
0.8677303791046143,
-0.5431877970695496,
-0.15455643832683563,
-0.22358600795269012,
-0.19794254004955292,
-0.3492077887058258,
0.2577081322669983,
-0.6964197754859924,
0.7995371222496033,
0.3333151638507843,
-0.7060984373092651,
-0.08615164458751678,
-0.5060126781463623,
-0.46779391169548035,
-0.008258864283561707,
0.025968361645936966,
-0.05452593415975571,
0.45837780833244324,
0.16478131711483002,
0.23948562145233154,
-0.7550373673439026,
0.755693256855011,
-0.058889709413051605,
-0.12960956990718842,
0.27451643347740173,
-0.6338005065917969,
0.9410067796707153,
0.3328537940979004,
-0.03234482556581497,
0.08039754629135132,
-0.896308183670044,
-0.2092469185590744,
-0.19630686938762665,
-0.24489794671535492,
-0.5276906490325928,
-0.2922796607017517,
0.33856937289237976,
0.18475443124771118,
0.37142905592918396,
-0.47475355863571167,
0.04212784394621849,
-0.3805658519268036,
0.3131425082683563,
0.4707290232181549,
-0.08323856443166733,
0.1387842297554016,
-0.19050754606723785,
0.7250827550888062,
-0.24395492672920227,
0.246090829372406,
0.10239886492490768,
-0.2557618021965027,
-0.7282505631446838,
0.0027698881458491087,
0.6982086896896362,
0.2721175253391266,
-0.7651505470275879,
-0.12051675468683243,
-0.19562947750091553,
-0.44936230778694153,
-0.7999095916748047,
0.5288974046707153,
0.2109823077917099,
0.4024287462234497,
0.2462216317653656,
-0.39226874709129333,
-1.0865709781646729,
-0.8745990991592407,
0.0568833127617836,
0.05911451578140259,
0.37107792496681213,
0.22854843735694885,
0.3151927888393402,
-0.2758510410785675,
0.8498989343643188,
-0.22773069143295288,
-0.3469689190387726,
-0.4618231952190399,
0.15033453702926636,
0.38037216663360596,
-0.01925416849553585,
0.6783817410469055,
-1.2057868242263794,
-0.42046815156936646,
0.04468834400177002,
-0.9735074639320374,
-0.3969787359237671,
-0.13227961957454681,
-0.3799785375595093,
0.5870199203491211,
0.5439056158065796,
-0.4880359470844269,
0.44846346974372864,
0.8283292651176453,
0.05230806767940521,
0.6368823647499084,
0.27885130047798157,
-0.06695759296417236,
-1.3780180215835571,
0.33181217312812805,
-0.41544342041015625,
-0.4010152518749237,
-0.7566764950752258,
0.003607674967497587,
-0.10574499517679214,
-0.18047747015953064,
-0.8784657120704651,
0.957211971282959,
-0.2563682496547699,
-0.35610881447792053,
-0.7163625955581665,
0.20045538246631622,
-0.11488515138626099,
0.26017093658447266,
0.2782421410083771,
0.8169043660163879,
0.4437685012817383,
-0.7518611550331116,
0.298833429813385,
0.29114460945129395,
-0.3054875135421753,
0.7600457072257996,
-0.5376530289649963,
-0.31781092286109924,
-0.2736941874027252,
0.2318597435951233,
-0.3739495873451233,
-0.5136768221855164,
-0.09727939963340759,
-0.3814397156238556,
0.14485178887844086,
0.1756901890039444,
-0.1239498108625412,
-0.16203290224075317,
-0.2793065905570984,
0.45082393288612366,
0.07836146652698517,
-0.5137849450111389,
0.6334325671195984,
0.6362438797950745,
-0.3692396283149719,
-0.9539386630058289,
-0.6797060966491699,
0.4791852533817291,
-0.29686710238456726,
0.03862475976347923,
0.30074000358581543,
-0.012981200590729713,
-0.4002692401409149,
0.315912127494812,
0.04543367028236389,
-0.334354966878891,
0.32303905487060547,
0.4694983661174774,
0.3163618743419647,
-0.4116525650024414,
0.296644926071167,
0.12872789800167084,
-0.19322046637535095,
-0.23270124197006226,
0.18168702721595764,
0.9629632234573364,
0.014200971461832523,
-0.10013698041439056,
-0.6687697768211365,
0.31211012601852417,
0.5202209949493408,
-0.2772682011127472,
0.6591812968254089,
0.5840062499046326,
-0.4682231545448303,
-0.19827184081077576,
-0.48279884457588196,
0.25831338763237,
-0.3363051116466522,
0.2770499885082245,
-0.07174926996231079,
-0.6756389141082764,
0.115009605884552,
-0.2146768718957901,
0.023923182860016823,
0.6658471822738647,
0.6295977234840393,
0.23838166892528534,
0.40881210565567017,
0.6229422092437744,
-0.5481555461883545,
0.2441108375787735,
-0.1807287633419037,
0.08216769248247147,
-1.2566882371902466,
-0.05073988437652588,
-0.6646758317947388,
-0.442378968000412,
-0.3434883952140808,
-0.451096773147583,
0.0005223948392085731,
0.15949060022830963,
-0.019265800714492798,
0.3823709487915039,
-0.25036051869392395,
0.42628762125968933,
0.6249139904975891,
-0.3291987180709839,
0.5262176394462585,
-0.12736624479293823,
0.35633736848831177,
0.1271592080593109,
-0.5972078442573547,
-0.38086390495300293,
1.326921820640564,
0.07720021903514862,
0.8359791040420532,
0.2940741777420044,
0.8414086103439331,
0.15564493834972382,
0.4941727817058563,
-0.7919096350669861,
0.402847558259964,
-0.4536454677581787,
-0.6635228395462036,
-0.08901271224021912,
-0.39121049642562866,
-0.9944281578063965,
-0.028374861925840378,
0.0053423200733959675,
-0.40851375460624695,
0.3701688349246979,
-0.5253714323043823,
-0.5258757472038269,
0.29361453652381897,
-0.04795948788523674,
0.3197622299194336,
-0.6075953841209412,
-0.06231814995408058,
-0.25159919261932373,
-0.3876735270023346,
0.7471280694007874,
-0.4592105448246002,
0.3837984502315521,
-0.39240115880966187,
-0.28507134318351746,
0.8322968482971191,
-0.12127722054719925,
1.0488777160644531,
0.19343675673007965,
0.11315556615591049,
0.30470362305641174,
-0.22373908758163452,
-0.15039804577827454,
0.29542315006256104,
-0.2641644775867462,
0.3523992598056793,
-0.2377777248620987,
-0.12821196019649506,
-0.2414102405309677,
0.9171580672264099,
-0.8793288469314575,
-0.2597607970237732,
-0.6808534860610962,
-0.5887309312820435,
-0.04048626497387886,
0.40147408843040466,
0.017468735575675964,
0.5878919959068298,
-0.20227299630641937,
0.5797094106674194,
0.3200201094150543,
-0.3376302421092987,
0.6620980501174927,
0.41576769948005676,
-0.5106593370437622,
-0.596854031085968,
0.7901014685630798,
0.04691634699702263,
0.006181325763463974,
0.5444608330726624,
-0.07786577194929123,
-0.34368962049484253,
-0.5029206275939941,
-0.658298909664154,
0.41205790638923645,
-0.434146523475647,
-0.6737186908721924,
-0.678966760635376,
-0.4864625334739685,
-0.23278144001960754,
-0.17184291779994965,
-0.41728082299232483,
-0.5488278269767761,
-0.555094838142395,
0.01983041875064373,
0.24626296758651733,
0.867800772190094,
0.013721896335482597,
0.37494444847106934,
-0.7230268120765686,
0.7556479573249817,
0.292411208152771,
0.296986848115921,
-0.034449927508831024,
-0.3878364861011505,
-0.1485358029603958,
0.038248755037784576,
-0.25105997920036316,
-0.7595900893211365,
0.8051782846450806,
0.2256513237953186,
0.47052109241485596,
0.14397253096103668,
0.08606972545385361,
0.6516243815422058,
-0.3376298248767853,
0.8399755954742432,
0.16819927096366882,
-0.8712052702903748,
0.7992511987686157,
-0.19420744478702545,
0.2046283334493637,
0.8870260119438171,
0.6867058277130127,
-0.5754367709159851,
-0.13242459297180176,
-0.5493608713150024,
-0.6496815085411072,
0.7455888390541077,
-0.0256987102329731,
0.34290042519569397,
-0.025256460532546043,
0.3726111352443695,
0.14540299773216248,
0.6442787647247314,
-0.5877822041511536,
0.00011720215115929022,
0.03360440582036972,
-0.31398898363113403,
0.0008055896032601595,
-0.4281429648399353,
0.050491396337747574,
-0.06300781667232513,
0.8415456414222717,
-0.1839282065629959,
0.13202150166034698,
0.050098955631256104,
-0.33448708057403564,
-0.19818860292434692,
0.23624345660209656,
0.7597832083702087,
0.6102051138877869,
-0.15993177890777588,
-0.01575491577386856,
0.3264526128768921,
-0.5604776740074158,
0.057500116527080536,
-0.05555599182844162,
-0.4690171182155609,
0.4955076277256012,
0.500379741191864,
1.2884297370910645,
0.5324324369430542,
-1.0078003406524658,
0.31804224848747253,
-0.29569706320762634,
-0.05744091793894768,
-0.3741277754306793,
0.06318573653697968,
0.06511382013559341,
0.038931138813495636,
0.42408260703086853,
0.014998647384345531,
0.21250388026237488,
-0.7654600739479065,
0.17614495754241943,
0.16749559342861176,
-0.29032614827156067,
-0.04099782556295395,
0.6155312061309814,
0.034722473472356796,
-0.3011389970779419,
0.5917477011680603,
-0.10318300873041153,
-0.501062273979187,
0.6599088311195374,
0.6524453163146973,
0.7374330759048462,
-0.4933896064758301,
0.6500758528709412,
0.5398552417755127,
0.1965850442647934,
-0.27724209427833557,
0.3040802776813507,
0.1584503948688507,
-0.4824874997138977,
-0.47022581100463867,
-1.5042668581008911,
-0.5847617387771606,
0.12182784080505371,
-0.5555769801139832,
0.6262585520744324,
-0.435481458902359,
-0.13970227539539337,
-0.127876877784729,
0.26802629232406616,
-0.30547404289245605,
0.23638907074928284,
0.2721075713634491,
0.8635618090629578,
-0.6629769206047058,
0.9217016100883484,
0.4537064731121063,
-0.30439630150794983,
-0.6660081148147583,
-0.09113890677690506,
0.01631615310907364,
-0.581496000289917,
0.6596759557723999,
0.22268803417682648,
0.19596071541309357,
-0.18980403244495392,
-0.20166292786598206,
-1.2195625305175781,
0.9714327454566956,
0.651329755783081,
-0.6365628242492676,
-0.09521569311618805,
0.21678896248340607,
0.46636268496513367,
-0.5638368725776672,
0.15947945415973663,
0.4014205038547516,
0.6067000031471252,
-0.08279615640640259,
-1.0278730392456055,
-0.17390359938144684,
-0.24379903078079224,
0.0454118549823761,
0.28366467356681824,
-0.7767353057861328,
0.9275506734848022,
0.15773269534111023,
-0.09782586246728897,
0.2006303369998932,
0.6973653435707092,
0.04797815531492233,
0.39369356632232666,
0.21232390403747559,
0.6494167447090149,
0.9766920208930969,
0.16725395619869232,
1.2843232154846191,
-0.2528243064880371,
-0.04808063805103302,
1.380255937576294,
-0.25537776947021484,
1.3020559549331665,
0.2932276427745819,
-0.15085245668888092,
0.7005188465118408,
0.4771434962749481,
0.35518741607666016,
0.37300366163253784,
-0.005976146552711725,
-0.2039661556482315,
-0.012992776930332184,
-0.9815043807029724,
-0.3785424530506134,
0.8963034749031067,
0.4752488434314728,
-0.18223567306995392,
-0.5239266753196716,
0.3096092641353607,
-0.12473050504922867,
0.08156469464302063,
-0.610409140586853,
0.5905096530914307,
0.3499981760978699,
-0.47857770323753357,
0.787121057510376,
0.11981164664030075,
0.7739579081535339,
-0.6081690788269043,
0.0448492132127285,
-0.28921395540237427,
-0.21521241962909698,
-0.3230787515640259,
-0.3783751428127289,
0.8713249564170837,
0.26449912786483765,
-0.02135186456143856,
0.0797290951013565,
0.9611871242523193,
-0.42980191111564636,
-0.6910691261291504,
0.1818000078201294,
0.32036635279655457,
0.2730732262134552,
0.016659431159496307,
-0.3576100766658783,
0.5218695998191833,
0.015939680859446526,
0.030227918177843094,
0.49306315183639526,
0.03366070240736008,
-0.34610310196876526,
0.4450035095214844,
0.8258730173110962,
0.4034709334373474,
0.025766542181372643,
0.18674680590629578,
0.6868036389350891,
-0.6727325916290283,
-0.2537083923816681,
-0.6261091828346252,
0.08785563707351685,
-0.287672758102417,
-0.5618039965629578,
0.6129769682884216,
0.587245523929596,
0.40738335251808167,
0.07864060252904892,
0.659415066242218,
-0.06278914958238602,
0.5506564974784851,
-0.6207395792007446,
0.5952501893043518,
-0.8285888433456421,
0.024449599906802177,
0.13181772828102112,
-0.9288300275802612,
-0.5053138136863708,
0.46918967366218567,
-0.07310456782579422,
-0.3911948800086975,
0.7636343240737915,
0.5438551306724548,
-0.04895728826522827,
0.3260374069213867,
0.19830626249313354,
0.2616657614707947,
-0.06940619647502899,
0.5799288153648376,
0.6101247072219849,
-0.38405951857566833,
0.0717197135090828,
-0.3765755891799927,
0.03625141456723213,
-0.5126354098320007,
-0.8759200572967529,
-0.8737601041793823,
-0.6955462694168091,
-0.012653440237045288,
0.17492583394050598,
0.000544696522410959,
0.958254873752594,
0.5935325026512146,
-0.815004825592041,
-0.4133296608924866,
-0.0029965785797685385,
0.4423847794532776,
0.09443116933107376,
-0.18777886033058167,
0.3646160364151001,
-0.4885999262332916,
-0.9569876194000244,
0.6452738046646118,
0.20657193660736084,
-0.3052019774913788,
-0.474098801612854,
0.052841316908597946,
-0.5293793678283691,
0.08660929650068283,
0.5441279411315918,
0.3839801847934723,
-0.5749991536140442,
0.14763841032981873,
-0.09883900731801987,
-0.14979135990142822,
-0.08822892606258392,
0.4900509715080261,
-0.7758235335350037,
0.06455303728580475,
0.3955717086791992,
0.9776879549026489,
0.383694052696228,
-0.12583814561367035,
0.3691774010658264,
-0.7744932770729065,
0.47264301776885986,
0.280592143535614,
0.12226413190364838,
0.5280916094779968,
-0.5673116445541382,
0.7899095416069031,
-0.01241241954267025,
-0.25182318687438965,
-1.3023786544799805,
-0.10703688859939575,
-0.9892406463623047,
-0.2522258460521698,
1.1379014253616333,
0.4239201545715332,
-0.8887712955474854,
-0.13364028930664062,
-0.23707689344882965,
0.12953779101371765,
-0.20730918645858765,
0.4768451750278473,
0.668595016002655,
0.18501760065555573,
-0.16147111356258392,
-1.1999058723449707,
0.5124979019165039,
0.3394758105278015,
-1.2253124713897705,
-0.02166726626455784,
0.31779178977012634,
0.09968128800392151,
0.4576184153556824,
0.9053802490234375,
0.012358814477920532,
0.44772017002105713,
-0.06727216392755508,
-0.024390365928411484,
0.07374628633260727,
-0.9258294105529785,
-0.4173750579357147,
0.25762230157852173,
0.06672560423612595,
0.1278257966041565
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16554v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16554v2
|
PE: A Poincare Explanation Method for Fast Text Hierarchy Generation
| 2024-03-25T09:04:14 | 2024-06-12T11:17:47 |
Qian Chen, Dongyang Li, Xiaofeng He, Hongzhao Li, Hongyu Yi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The black-box nature of deep learning models in NLP hinders their widespread
application. The research focus has shifted to Hierarchical Attribution (HA)
for its ability to model feature interactions. Recent works model
non-contiguous combinations with a time-costly greedy search in Eculidean
spaces, neglecting underlying linguistic information in feature
representations. In this work, we introduce a novel method, namely Poincare
Explanation (PE), for modeling feature interactions with hyperbolic spaces in a
time efficient manner. Specifically, we take building text hierarchies as
finding spanning trees in hyperbolic spaces. First we project the embeddings
into hyperbolic spaces to elicit inherit semantic and syntax hierarchical
structures. Then we propose a simple yet effective strategy to calculate
Shapley score. Finally we build the the hierarchy with proving the constructing
process in the projected space could be viewed as building a minimum spanning
tree and introduce a time efficient building algorithm. Experimental results
demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach.
|
[
-0.1864968240261078,
-1.0850942134857178,
0.6448405981063843,
0.33349668979644775,
-0.09066952764987946,
-0.1295829862356186,
0.0931321457028389,
-0.27229851484298706,
0.344838947057724,
0.07940226048231125,
-0.4269341826438904,
-0.5125357508659363,
-0.4042840301990509,
-0.4587406814098358,
-0.20133249461650848,
1.1223129034042358,
-0.30975520610809326,
-1.0511177778244019,
-0.0459640808403492,
0.2795584499835968,
0.2622829079627991,
-0.5840927362442017,
-0.3769891560077667,
-0.2768569886684418,
0.608144998550415,
-0.033995017409324646,
1.1590696573257446,
1.0251556634902954,
0.3144996762275696,
0.33556246757507324,
-0.43628573417663574,
0.14827948808670044,
-0.4195864200592041,
-0.01068735308945179,
-0.04755726456642151,
0.04631204530596733,
-0.6044476628303528,
-0.13533487915992737,
0.6850185394287109,
1.0719455480575562,
-0.17700231075286865,
-0.06466417014598846,
0.24889300763607025,
0.22906064987182617,
-0.9412865042686462,
0.19463635981082916,
-0.60591721534729,
0.2665824592113495,
-0.23568765819072723,
-0.8135154843330383,
-0.061264052987098694,
-0.22377347946166992,
0.4538862407207489,
-0.6874343752861023,
0.34904083609580994,
0.11120284348726273,
1.2253855466842651,
0.21676571667194366,
-0.19515100121498108,
-0.19534869492053986,
-0.4833832383155823,
0.8869010806083679,
-0.3490631580352783,
0.04428502544760704,
0.3523528277873993,
0.0596928745508194,
-0.07986216247081757,
-0.546339213848114,
-0.5777081251144409,
0.010200112126767635,
-0.09696637839078903,
0.04073439911007881,
-0.044654011726379395,
-0.042683057487010956,
0.00019310131028760225,
0.653847336769104,
-0.1528308391571045,
0.0247342512011528,
-0.03760768845677376,
0.02019587904214859,
0.4360876977443695,
0.03806137293577194,
0.17675752937793732,
-0.6447299718856812,
-0.44426578283309937,
0.06577768921852112,
-0.59434574842453,
0.15173573791980743,
0.610345721244812,
0.21311838924884796,
-0.01841590367257595,
0.5481136441230774,
0.4400658905506134,
0.21121478080749512,
0.08640444278717041,
0.09105950593948364,
0.1300550103187561,
-0.3345504701137543,
-0.23098644614219666,
0.2262454479932785,
0.8044072985649109,
0.15345637500286102,
0.011406431905925274,
-0.07887069135904312,
0.0540473572909832,
0.08054226636886597,
0.23111866414546967,
-0.9008689522743225,
-0.40638265013694763,
0.2959906756877899,
-0.49246665835380554,
-0.6871017217636108,
-0.12924103438854218,
-0.734910249710083,
-0.38212481141090393,
0.2216421216726303,
0.08362887799739838,
-0.4334305226802826,
-0.5975619554519653,
0.38221997022628784,
0.008330797776579857,
0.17691625654697418,
0.20510558784008026,
-0.8910107016563416,
0.408702552318573,
0.6160897612571716,
0.8128026723861694,
0.010688398033380508,
-0.5455937385559082,
-0.6124162077903748,
0.45990926027297974,
-0.33943042159080505,
0.7319386601448059,
-0.633516252040863,
-0.10466592758893967,
0.1392049342393875,
-0.33972403407096863,
-0.06106516346335411,
-0.4806271493434906,
0.435676246881485,
-0.1368512511253357,
0.44754841923713684,
0.11087458580732346,
-0.4502469301223755,
0.03245748579502106,
0.02805403620004654,
-0.556592583656311,
1.1899513006210327,
0.23574548959732056,
-1.0932573080062866,
0.2919958829879761,
-0.7549241781234741,
-0.6012365221977234,
0.21750594675540924,
-0.006144878454506397,
-0.7912777662277222,
0.14691489934921265,
0.36266183853149414,
0.572783350944519,
-0.07204069942235947,
0.3638370633125305,
-0.21884627640247345,
-0.04744551330804825,
-0.09997411072254181,
-0.13982655107975006,
0.7914180159568787,
0.030477428808808327,
-0.6312103271484375,
-0.19861078262329102,
-0.30083632469177246,
0.01400745939463377,
0.24330021440982819,
-0.40588122606277466,
-0.6410124897956848,
0.5260604619979858,
-0.002238968852907419,
0.08139359205961227,
0.13900181651115417,
-0.466106116771698,
0.0853666290640831,
-0.5807711482048035,
0.42903557419776917,
0.4395906925201416,
0.2981175184249878,
0.3532886505126953,
-0.13054659962654114,
0.2745569348335266,
0.11869347095489502,
0.11083713173866272,
-0.2203826606273651,
-0.4979522228240967,
-0.22248020768165588,
-0.2184755653142929,
-0.09614713490009308,
0.35206955671310425,
-0.7193528413772583,
0.7113721966743469,
-0.2349272072315216,
-0.2925540804862976,
-0.5490455627441406,
0.2606760263442993,
0.6008713245391846,
0.35199248790740967,
0.27238473296165466,
-0.1646358221769333,
-0.3347531259059906,
-0.7982305288314819,
-0.3189013600349426,
-0.39481887221336365,
0.05000228062272072,
0.30003201961517334,
0.6535909175872803,
0.0768471509218216,
0.7416344881057739,
-0.5890195965766907,
-0.08440135419368744,
-0.1059328019618988,
0.14700832962989807,
0.12100148946046829,
0.36530789732933044,
0.7140184044837952,
-0.9252129793167114,
-0.2021058201789856,
0.06574118882417679,
-0.6426973342895508,
0.11187456548213959,
0.02313368022441864,
-0.21393975615501404,
-0.2994391918182373,
0.41819825768470764,
-0.3791775703430176,
0.3776472806930542,
0.5342170000076294,
-0.47346243262290955,
0.4104522466659546,
-0.08555933088064194,
0.11325116455554962,
-1.0025707483291626,
-0.10168039053678513,
0.3639463484287262,
-0.16389313340187073,
-0.4363926351070404,
0.14537549018859863,
-0.2659096419811249,
-0.30438515543937683,
-0.6650614142417908,
0.4060278534889221,
-0.45958566665649414,
0.18055342137813568,
0.04647579789161682,
0.35301485657691956,
-0.09708339720964432,
0.77585369348526,
0.03287186473608017,
0.2196546047925949,
0.6724376082420349,
-0.6978753209114075,
0.15038830041885376,
0.2060614973306656,
-0.3177676796913147,
0.5228348970413208,
-0.8452078700065613,
-0.22858171164989471,
-0.2677909731864929,
0.07388564199209213,
-1.1358987092971802,
-0.16699543595314026,
0.09277947247028351,
-0.24284105002880096,
0.0029224574100226164,
-0.2977272868156433,
-0.7744125127792358,
-0.4027952551841736,
-0.5109303593635559,
0.7368040680885315,
0.4756752550601959,
-0.8590099215507507,
0.4349132180213928,
0.6270011067390442,
-0.13944777846336365,
-0.22401703894138336,
-0.41380420327186584,
-0.12874680757522583,
-0.4022315442562103,
-0.6953564882278442,
0.8557032346725464,
0.22573387622833252,
-0.35916411876678467,
0.2899729311466217,
-0.038371384143829346,
-0.1602121889591217,
0.31685420870780945,
0.26713812351226807,
0.09801264852285385,
-0.4187348783016205,
-0.018097158521413803,
0.27972134947776794,
0.0026428273413330317,
-0.05098245292901993,
-0.3740585744380951,
0.33834776282310486,
-0.19943015277385712,
-0.12555815279483795,
-0.7240151762962341,
0.40159061551094055,
0.5359041690826416,
-0.3316870629787445,
0.8684449195861816,
0.1571030169725418,
-0.6059130430221558,
-0.45976021885871887,
0.012454697862267494,
0.007115896325558424,
-0.43011319637298584,
0.5684224963188171,
-0.35137975215911865,
-0.6543177366256714,
0.38692358136177063,
-0.25264811515808105,
0.330419659614563,
0.8242542147636414,
0.8295067548751831,
-0.12192563712596893,
0.9752014875411987,
0.6994999647140503,
0.08078957349061966,
0.6238319277763367,
-0.26430782675743103,
0.5030946135520935,
-0.5604144930839539,
-0.2415943443775177,
-0.5301088690757751,
-0.4053906500339508,
-0.5138334631919861,
-0.38396042585372925,
0.3752819299697876,
0.22798992693424225,
-0.11358240991830826,
0.5337194204330444,
-0.619581937789917,
0.6912010908126831,
0.11444737017154694,
0.0514274500310421,
0.2659100294113159,
0.31867074966430664,
-0.059599269181489944,
-0.11279036104679108,
-0.7806065082550049,
-0.2649233043193817,
0.5104413032531738,
0.6100397109985352,
0.716815710067749,
0.11617159843444824,
0.8079417943954468,
-0.0208868607878685,
0.303657203912735,
-0.6672431230545044,
0.17708726227283478,
-0.474963515996933,
-0.4028315842151642,
-0.4131678342819214,
-0.4405079185962677,
-0.9994930028915405,
0.21729575097560883,
-0.2647923529148102,
-0.7203733921051025,
0.09539128094911575,
0.18562830984592438,
-0.5148066282272339,
0.6203486919403076,
-0.6863815784454346,
0.7864075303077698,
-0.2309999018907547,
-0.6202284097671509,
-0.07082649320363998,
-0.25623998045921326,
0.33323782682418823,
0.2574651539325714,
0.0819055512547493,
0.0014832313172519207,
-0.12957730889320374,
0.8836140632629395,
-0.7320273518562317,
0.7989091873168945,
-0.4208413064479828,
-0.37366679310798645,
0.3555506467819214,
0.3880283832550049,
0.318136066198349,
-0.18476326763629913,
0.0016939983470365405,
-0.10229013115167618,
-0.19310599565505981,
-0.5541000366210938,
-0.6604406833648682,
0.7701597213745117,
-0.8079380989074707,
-0.15565888583660126,
-0.017922932282090187,
-0.5693296790122986,
0.002284880494698882,
-0.251350462436676,
0.2767485976219177,
0.4966726005077362,
0.03242596611380577,
0.213087797164917,
0.7309697270393372,
-0.16887272894382477,
0.43710237741470337,
-0.17075462639331818,
-0.16912123560905457,
-0.05705951526761055,
0.8040912747383118,
-0.07157138735055923,
-0.08680054545402527,
0.6399110555648804,
0.5344946980476379,
-0.2601906657218933,
-0.4924543797969818,
0.015324724838137627,
0.4220927655696869,
-0.16538697481155396,
0.09231650829315186,
-0.718657374382019,
-0.286965012550354,
0.1064218282699585,
-0.47895029187202454,
-0.4628811180591583,
-0.4859354496002197,
0.1693948209285736,
-0.09559188038110733,
0.1081487312912941,
0.6915794610977173,
0.6182295680046082,
0.5412207841873169,
-0.3883630931377411,
0.3486582338809967,
0.281979501247406,
0.4974750578403473,
0.2643711268901825,
-0.319417804479599,
-0.32566770911216736,
-0.3988894522190094,
-0.6167669296264648,
-0.8933655619621277,
0.21650594472885132,
0.3375588357448578,
0.5455552339553833,
0.2962712347507477,
-0.21847182512283325,
0.7457599639892578,
-0.45240136981010437,
0.7438147068023682,
0.2650185823440552,
-1.086243748664856,
0.8820521235466003,
-0.4318900406360626,
-0.06888555735349655,
0.18699344992637634,
0.6407383680343628,
-0.20462153851985931,
-0.5881146192550659,
-1.1549289226531982,
-1.1099032163619995,
0.1841880977153778,
0.4647466242313385,
-0.025218447670340538,
-0.1391814947128296,
0.6595926880836487,
0.16939769685268402,
0.09721346944570541,
-0.6538713574409485,
-0.26030710339546204,
-0.27171456813812256,
-0.2752494812011719,
0.07475409656763077,
-0.14581166207790375,
-0.014229491353034973,
-0.26210400462150574,
0.3841978907585144,
-0.10601289570331573,
0.07493582367897034,
0.32625293731689453,
-0.132686585187912,
-0.216328427195549,
0.1369086503982544,
0.10060179978609085,
0.5642004609107971,
-0.09502722322940826,
0.44283661246299744,
-0.3262139558792114,
-0.1401810646057129,
-0.10890370607376099,
0.2331734597682953,
0.21028664708137512,
0.17333178222179413,
0.6735484004020691,
0.6115107536315918,
0.5046132206916809,
-0.0855448842048645,
0.7263227105140686,
0.27479028701782227,
-0.559913158416748,
0.34665897488594055,
-0.07694089412689209,
0.07709166407585144,
0.16148275136947632,
0.3478485941886902,
-0.32834646105766296,
0.0038310284726321697,
-0.7006841897964478,
0.29147499799728394,
0.18697816133499146,
-0.33415791392326355,
-0.4408414363861084,
0.8005765080451965,
0.21702776849269867,
-0.14042140543460846,
0.47326257824897766,
-0.013662056997418404,
-0.5814734101295471,
0.5776143074035645,
0.38789108395576477,
0.8588100075721741,
-0.19340485334396362,
0.5160843729972839,
0.276643306016922,
0.05262313038110733,
0.08097155392169952,
0.13894279301166534,
-0.2388554960489273,
-0.7519140243530273,
-0.6024963855743408,
-0.7527561187744141,
-0.343573659658432,
0.06325136125087738,
-0.22582755982875824,
-0.024382209405303,
-0.7075920701026917,
0.021306123584508896,
0.6718268990516663,
0.10937592387199402,
-0.43676644563674927,
-0.14177921414375305,
0.05141257867217064,
0.5443065762519836,
-1.1256308555603027,
0.47225654125213623,
0.7495574355125427,
-0.296573668718338,
-0.7379237413406372,
0.2306104451417923,
-0.06444243341684341,
-0.8093339204788208,
0.5418476462364197,
-0.19748325645923615,
-0.1054578498005867,
-0.038537707179784775,
-0.6801362633705139,
-0.23776452243328094,
0.758082926273346,
0.3327009975910187,
-0.335873544216156,
-0.40621498227119446,
-0.2849884033203125,
0.7214637994766235,
-0.38929471373558044,
-0.1709124892950058,
0.3488573729991913,
0.3477596640586853,
0.04233737289905548,
-0.6028323173522949,
0.18587525188922882,
-0.49745258688926697,
0.017685119062662125,
0.5838251113891602,
-0.13368090987205505,
0.9213480949401855,
-0.3368961811065674,
-0.3243735432624817,
0.0660616084933281,
0.6660008430480957,
0.3389378786087036,
0.08123601227998734,
0.7155433893203735,
0.5061718821525574,
0.8667312860488892,
-0.051989417523145676,
1.5521560907363892,
-0.1090988889336586,
0.6379736065864563,
0.7687510848045349,
0.09455307573080063,
0.7263413667678833,
0.6034273505210876,
-0.29225683212280273,
0.8272790312767029,
0.6031206846237183,
0.160750150680542,
0.45829135179519653,
0.44169843196868896,
-0.11344102025032043,
-0.22449587285518646,
-0.2055167853832245,
-0.1730731874704361,
0.2369726449251175,
0.1890515834093094,
-0.3718276023864746,
-0.5618575215339661,
-0.24800166487693787,
0.2911193072795868,
0.2476762980222702,
-0.35175952315330505,
0.5449685454368591,
-0.054978787899017334,
-0.566142201423645,
0.5608388185501099,
-0.058549027889966965,
0.61395263671875,
-0.4582359194755554,
0.02194206975400448,
0.13961242139339447,
0.30593669414520264,
-0.5229501128196716,
-1.2064876556396484,
0.2722392976284027,
-0.13592179119586945,
-0.36250677704811096,
-0.5119056105613708,
0.4007793962955475,
-0.7299317717552185,
-0.3850935697555542,
0.20151935517787933,
0.653850793838501,
0.2502356469631195,
-0.2888602614402771,
-0.6526201963424683,
-0.4051503837108612,
-0.30224236845970154,
-0.1780177652835846,
-0.011507613584399223,
0.9115750193595886,
-0.3348880708217621,
0.1870834231376648,
0.45387002825737,
0.305614709854126,
-0.023851439356803894,
0.04084208235144615,
0.7631598711013794,
-0.550505518913269,
-0.7834936380386353,
-0.941044270992279,
0.5270440578460693,
0.08041366934776306,
-0.44100767374038696,
0.583536684513092,
0.5399971604347229,
0.44476136565208435,
0.18356461822986603,
0.5938820838928223,
-0.1715010106563568,
0.16424058377742767,
-0.4349316656589508,
0.5776980519294739,
-0.6399389505386353,
0.06271559745073318,
-0.6343453526496887,
-1.1143547296524048,
-0.4794650673866272,
0.5601640343666077,
-0.28456202149391174,
-0.016563646495342255,
1.104359745979309,
0.43110793828964233,
-0.2747027575969696,
-0.06515885889530182,
0.07033766061067581,
0.40656378865242004,
0.43802645802497864,
0.9599993824958801,
0.8578290939331055,
-0.34514620900154114,
0.5341426134109497,
-0.2966907024383545,
-0.6186469793319702,
-0.0649111196398735,
-1.0982341766357422,
-0.8457565903663635,
-0.7184801697731018,
-0.6571319699287415,
-0.4192611277103424,
0.05236738175153732,
0.39042553305625916,
0.7713183164596558,
-0.5858551859855652,
-0.07464459538459778,
0.04897240549325943,
0.42410340905189514,
-0.4551883041858673,
-0.2736877202987671,
0.8464451432228088,
-0.15901805460453033,
-0.6197423338890076,
0.029079202562570572,
0.44676312804222107,
-0.19156531989574432,
-0.19322779774665833,
-0.14943119883537292,
-0.2955004572868347,
-0.16019606590270996,
0.5655024647712708,
0.20538559556007385,
-0.34679341316223145,
-0.29876255989074707,
-0.2749052345752716,
-0.07951947301626205,
0.19730262458324432,
1.2166600227355957,
-0.7551941871643066,
0.09021460264921188,
0.6140909790992737,
0.6644861698150635,
0.5443277955055237,
0.017623750492930412,
0.3897128701210022,
-0.8662847280502319,
-0.04276653379201889,
0.07114311307668686,
0.2848750054836273,
0.31488198041915894,
-0.3983078598976135,
0.2008514553308487,
0.4846843183040619,
-0.1726958155632019,
-0.5041221380233765,
0.18605858087539673,
-0.7610610723495483,
-0.2947358191013336,
0.7863078117370605,
0.03242633119225502,
-0.6909998655319214,
-0.1434158831834793,
-0.0834273248910904,
-0.0009850380010902882,
-0.19862127304077148,
0.8394429683685303,
0.5273922681808472,
-0.17495664954185486,
-0.061743129044771194,
-0.12549813091754913,
0.6035916805267334,
0.3135018050670624,
-0.9692474603652954,
0.329870343208313,
0.11227752268314362,
-0.03959043696522713,
0.499909371137619,
0.5107580423355103,
-0.49688586592674255,
0.35421469807624817,
0.08593320846557617,
-0.1429888904094696,
-0.2039424031972885,
-0.6127240061759949,
0.02705306187272072,
0.6634511351585388,
-0.25992298126220703,
-0.15315236151218414
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16543v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16543v1
|
Efficient Information Extraction in Few-Shot Relation Classification through Contrastive Representation Learning
| 2024-03-25T08:36:06 | 2024-03-25T08:36:06 |
Philipp Borchert, Jochen De Weerdt, Marie-Francine Moens
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Differentiating relationships between entity pairs with limited labeled
instances poses a significant challenge in few-shot relation classification.
Representations of textual data extract rich information spanning the domain,
entities, and relations. In this paper, we introduce a novel approach to
enhance information extraction combining multiple sentence representations and
contrastive learning. While representations in relation classification are
commonly extracted using entity marker tokens, we argue that substantial
information within the internal model representations remains untapped. To
address this, we propose aligning multiple sentence representations, such as
the [CLS] token, the [MASK] token used in prompting, and entity marker tokens.
Our method employs contrastive learning to extract complementary discriminative
information from these individual representations. This is particularly
relevant in low-resource settings where information is scarce. Leveraging
multiple sentence representations is especially effective in distilling
discriminative information for relation classification when additional
information, like relation descriptions, are not available. We validate the
adaptability of our approach, maintaining robust performance in scenarios that
include relation descriptions, and showcasing its flexibility to adapt to
different resource constraints.
|
[
-0.1607004702091217,
-0.4201458990573883,
0.48835641145706177,
-0.05474960058927536,
-0.329228013753891,
-0.06626040488481522,
-0.06289775669574738,
-0.6205331087112427,
0.22742871940135956,
0.3041294813156128,
-0.4690413773059845,
-0.22925348579883575,
-0.5540614128112793,
0.07697708159685135,
0.14592032134532928,
0.9771860241889954,
0.1045784205198288,
0.21295367181301117,
-0.1796654611825943,
-0.38577303290367126,
-0.7240535020828247,
-0.4621356427669525,
-0.5941996574401855,
-0.4067493975162506,
0.4395161271095276,
0.5496300458908081,
0.41682347655296326,
0.6688297390937805,
0.6749082803726196,
0.3021668791770935,
0.15896135568618774,
0.43555748462677,
-0.3909856081008911,
0.345012903213501,
-0.07891537249088287,
-0.3789060413837433,
0.03240290656685829,
-0.08504761010408401,
0.6668364405632019,
0.7663060426712036,
0.10343955457210541,
0.08463349938392639,
0.24028418958187103,
0.21242991089820862,
-0.8372998833656311,
0.5498047471046448,
-0.8464354872703552,
0.0014152732910588384,
-0.33850815892219543,
-0.2090088129043579,
-0.46422067284584045,
0.1271803081035614,
0.16456085443496704,
-0.8311392068862915,
-0.029767489060759544,
0.2546970248222351,
1.08860182762146,
0.16382211446762085,
-0.5443853139877319,
-0.3547881245613098,
-0.560996413230896,
0.7416718602180481,
-0.3606540858745575,
0.2607176601886749,
0.14847245812416077,
0.38228365778923035,
0.10492072999477386,
-0.8411497473716736,
-0.6451007723808289,
0.04239611700177193,
-0.5257524847984314,
0.08213630318641663,
-0.11036057770252228,
0.05418623238801956,
0.2895282804965973,
0.29136019945144653,
-0.10430233180522919,
0.25926026701927185,
-0.16857276856899261,
-0.13084013760089874,
0.2041938751935959,
0.3345768451690674,
0.13762523233890533,
-0.45138314366340637,
-0.7776907086372375,
-0.058032311499118805,
-0.6403809785842896,
-0.08622803539037704,
0.10455065965652466,
0.8024964928627014,
-0.20935450494289398,
0.6635351777076721,
0.12442899495363235,
0.48424017429351807,
0.23241184651851654,
-0.19346831738948822,
0.38248011469841003,
-0.47492164373397827,
-0.0942278578877449,
0.05155341327190399,
0.8178174495697021,
0.3972851037979126,
-0.1271502673625946,
-0.020631134510040283,
-0.12028762698173523,
0.0008901784312911332,
0.09169411659240723,
-0.8756052851676941,
-0.09630308300256729,
-0.023789621889591217,
-0.6399902701377869,
0.022953186184167862,
0.41817784309387207,
-1.1401641368865967,
-0.605978786945343,
-0.12407790869474411,
0.18096686899662018,
-0.46389904618263245,
-0.25002631545066833,
-0.42111387848854065,
-0.42189493775367737,
0.2584247291088104,
0.18212732672691345,
-1.168912649154663,
0.483214408159256,
0.49352455139160156,
0.9426308274269104,
-0.22306028008460999,
-0.0756567046046257,
-0.8175323605537415,
0.4090745747089386,
-0.0156632699072361,
0.6265090703964233,
-0.8275676965713501,
-0.22290118038654327,
0.3471534252166748,
-0.20002807676792145,
0.04551493003964424,
-0.5343231558799744,
0.34922605752944946,
-0.43074509501457214,
0.2915564477443695,
-0.32016825675964355,
-0.813183605670929,
0.0034361411817371845,
0.12964966893196106,
-1.0029699802398682,
0.882437527179718,
0.40783044695854187,
-1.1023294925689697,
0.5123467445373535,
-0.5623486638069153,
-0.21592578291893005,
0.3265683352947235,
-0.5715473890304565,
-0.5150592923164368,
-0.08358509838581085,
0.4561461806297302,
0.5497252941131592,
-0.0245377030223608,
-0.20367221534252167,
-0.2840845286846161,
-0.24918213486671448,
0.14868058264255524,
-0.02166421338915825,
0.6432362794876099,
0.25144287943840027,
-0.13646896183490753,
-0.006907009519636631,
-0.8010310530662537,
-0.40710458159446716,
0.11988033354282379,
-0.2826091945171356,
-0.5677992701530457,
-0.4497206509113312,
0.04328576847910881,
0.19285504519939423,
0.22029778361320496,
-0.4221498370170593,
0.28253814578056335,
-0.4029982388019562,
0.08096791058778763,
0.6846355199813843,
0.3627084195613861,
0.7437573075294495,
-0.15123465657234192,
0.49738791584968567,
0.673489511013031,
-0.45617422461509705,
-0.5989436507225037,
-0.2995492219924927,
-0.7137529253959656,
-0.3671758770942688,
0.318895548582077,
0.4168317914009094,
-1.0835938453674316,
0.2954501807689667,
-0.2939717769622803,
0.02585562691092491,
-0.7103609442710876,
0.26685601472854614,
0.4796164333820343,
0.8510114550590515,
0.5934022068977356,
-0.124179407954216,
-0.7440364956855774,
-0.6615749001502991,
-0.1601402908563614,
-0.3166733682155609,
0.08799558132886887,
0.2859976291656494,
0.4287574887275696,
0.029592882841825485,
0.7223954200744629,
-0.5392383933067322,
-0.527099072933197,
-0.2755732238292694,
0.4227570593357086,
0.12569314241409302,
0.5047070384025574,
0.5474928617477417,
-0.7834078669548035,
-0.3646904528141022,
0.15522675216197968,
-0.8228893280029297,
0.2159396857023239,
-0.4301184415817261,
-0.28726351261138916,
-0.21789167821407318,
0.41643214225769043,
-0.6567257642745972,
0.24921391904354095,
0.03112928941845894,
-0.17074699699878693,
0.23310665786266327,
0.1320776790380478,
0.06805068999528885,
-1.089728593826294,
-0.17477485537528992,
0.18295179307460785,
-0.33230122923851013,
-0.5059444904327393,
0.12466920167207718,
-0.0369269885122776,
0.06280188262462616,
-0.3627687692642212,
0.6374993920326233,
-0.7594336867332458,
-0.06821458786725998,
0.015411493368446827,
0.49139249324798584,
0.021112101152539253,
0.38115495443344116,
0.09219841659069061,
0.7031400799751282,
0.4634275436401367,
-0.5766487121582031,
0.35073453187942505,
0.5570558905601501,
0.04139465466141701,
0.9196360111236572,
-0.14925239980220795,
0.17340229451656342,
-0.28196966648101807,
0.07995246350765228,
-0.9551658034324646,
-0.2927720248699188,
0.4424114525318146,
-0.24134685099124908,
0.49361729621887207,
-0.1964535266160965,
-0.3914775848388672,
-0.09575286507606506,
-0.49674317240715027,
0.2468973845243454,
0.3038828670978546,
-0.8449708223342896,
0.7638728618621826,
0.3618316352367401,
-0.03980914130806923,
-0.6472924947738647,
-0.7353659868240356,
-0.25049373507499695,
-0.5362035036087036,
-0.07920540124177933,
0.6350036263465881,
0.46078893542289734,
-0.25435671210289,
0.351487934589386,
-0.0890168845653534,
-0.3917441666126251,
-0.05903751403093338,
0.26667097210884094,
0.4703574776649475,
-0.4774007797241211,
0.6851922273635864,
-0.23699551820755005,
0.014033526182174683,
-0.1870218813419342,
-0.0369357131421566,
0.36319226026535034,
0.10867474973201752,
-0.12641268968582153,
-0.4993671476840973,
0.537693440914154,
-0.0005377752240747213,
0.017857061699032784,
0.9649637341499329,
0.702731728553772,
-0.7338489890098572,
-0.012980811297893524,
-0.35001447796821594,
-0.24591928720474243,
-0.38990551233291626,
0.25707313418388367,
-0.7208613157272339,
-0.7962232232093811,
0.587522029876709,
-0.22653330862522125,
-0.029078764840960503,
0.6346055269241333,
0.0956917256116867,
0.00897479709237814,
0.6599152684211731,
0.7535897493362427,
-0.15266723930835724,
0.6382004022598267,
-0.015906793996691704,
0.05220460146665573,
-0.9625416398048401,
-0.3726789653301239,
-0.6317418217658997,
-0.08112962543964386,
-0.5241830348968506,
0.008748799562454224,
0.048015665262937546,
0.4693056344985962,
-0.17766083776950836,
0.521487295627594,
-0.45314183831214905,
0.331709623336792,
0.4362964332103729,
0.4677620530128479,
0.27633729577064514,
-0.010224876925349236,
-0.2464817762374878,
-0.4108907878398895,
-0.6112118363380432,
-0.6138095259666443,
0.8443266153335571,
0.19522307813167572,
0.5537307858467102,
0.1686764806509018,
1.0767172574996948,
-0.2588997185230255,
0.36501413583755493,
-0.8168772459030151,
0.14643488824367523,
-0.22604073584079742,
-0.4242438077926636,
-0.05271697789430618,
-0.5930376648902893,
-1.0416570901870728,
0.2575311064720154,
-0.6113288402557373,
-1.0323961973190308,
0.2344004064798355,
-0.01815936528146267,
-0.5801437497138977,
0.026057835668325424,
-0.8243483304977417,
0.7854769229888916,
-0.1284043937921524,
-0.3163938522338867,
0.023961009457707405,
-0.7873320579528809,
0.2682620584964752,
0.056169699877500534,
-0.00266201957128942,
0.14807476103305817,
-0.22317339479923248,
0.8082754611968994,
-0.1940346658229828,
0.8670185208320618,
-0.1458704173564911,
0.2931596040725708,
0.2524980902671814,
-0.16489140689373016,
0.35742834210395813,
-0.025399792939424515,
-0.17988987267017365,
-0.22912108898162842,
-0.2124212384223938,
-0.30630409717559814,
-0.767224907875061,
0.44107088446617126,
-0.5005055665969849,
-0.2993737459182739,
-0.3745865225791931,
-0.26380595564842224,
-0.3780268430709839,
0.22963440418243408,
0.23304450511932373,
0.21581219136714935,
-0.31670132279396057,
-0.059614397585392,
0.21086068451404572,
0.0339759923517704,
0.6101586818695068,
-0.0893230214715004,
-0.07048545777797699,
-0.5546014308929443,
0.6568946242332458,
-0.13246504962444305,
0.038025181740522385,
0.5658966302871704,
0.09447980672121048,
-0.521121084690094,
-0.20994040369987488,
-0.15218904614448547,
0.3924448490142822,
-1.1210196018218994,
-0.5917377471923828,
-0.49289247393608093,
-0.07357487082481384,
-0.4904158413410187,
0.10347805172204971,
0.13111546635627747,
-0.3851657807826996,
-0.7601187229156494,
-0.3907005190849304,
0.14058223366737366,
0.7766448259353638,
0.038100045174360275,
0.6725589036941528,
-0.8629030585289001,
0.6710612773895264,
0.3747335374355316,
-0.10255315154790878,
-0.04338818043470383,
-0.25250205397605896,
-0.050335004925727844,
-0.2853211462497711,
-0.470436692237854,
-1.2532881498336792,
0.023467637598514557,
0.46440333127975464,
0.7011497020721436,
0.7680774331092834,
0.03946293517947197,
1.119226098060608,
-0.37294134497642517,
0.8595117926597595,
0.7489293217658997,
-0.8795771598815918,
0.5416855812072754,
0.2515466809272766,
0.1548106074333191,
0.681522011756897,
0.5376480221748352,
-0.20686641335487366,
-0.14658436179161072,
-0.8011862635612488,
-0.6697567701339722,
0.6261664032936096,
0.1704212725162506,
0.3840734362602234,
-0.28215348720550537,
0.44596680998802185,
0.24045684933662415,
0.20838607847690582,
-0.9096749424934387,
-0.28127753734588623,
-0.15740041434764862,
-0.5660867094993591,
0.39353030920028687,
-0.4160762429237366,
-0.14222988486289978,
0.011763648129999638,
0.3926951289176941,
-0.2019958198070526,
0.3862174153327942,
0.0637144222855568,
-0.12751708924770355,
0.09874971956014633,
0.29833605885505676,
0.03149930387735367,
0.5220056176185608,
0.11865616589784622,
0.5895953178405762,
0.2997226119041443,
-0.0874631404876709,
-0.07611609995365143,
0.2987058162689209,
0.08738614618778229,
0.2548474967479706,
0.7677412629127502,
0.7814471125602722,
0.211342453956604,
-0.19451425969600677,
0.759585976600647,
0.17708317935466766,
0.2550824284553528,
0.17541028559207916,
-0.19167651236057281,
0.04848751425743103,
0.3802614212036133,
0.24023665487766266,
-0.16289442777633667,
0.21960625052452087,
-0.7615562677383423,
0.47150713205337524,
0.5110077261924744,
-0.5769738554954529,
-0.02138553187251091,
0.5426439046859741,
0.31339892745018005,
0.048414237797260284,
0.7159104347229004,
-0.22812195122241974,
-0.42082542181015015,
0.21059001982212067,
0.5893991589546204,
0.6487796306610107,
-0.069574274122715,
0.19841258227825165,
0.7362045049667358,
-0.08750897645950317,
-0.0025746142491698265,
-0.01655651442706585,
-0.2107917219400406,
-0.8474795818328857,
-0.1496429294347763,
-0.3217649757862091,
-0.2244742214679718,
0.07566637545824051,
-0.7767934203147888,
0.5577040910720825,
-0.3486599028110504,
-0.24166008830070496,
0.3601148724555969,
-0.029345618560910225,
-0.8373434543609619,
-0.028835933655500412,
0.18634402751922607,
0.3577140271663666,
-0.8056830167770386,
0.6526220440864563,
0.5307252407073975,
-1.0656436681747437,
-0.9116528034210205,
-0.007809226866811514,
-0.06321868300437927,
-0.7767171263694763,
1.059863805770874,
0.557528018951416,
-0.18009687960147858,
-0.3507278263568878,
-0.5238579511642456,
-0.25793999433517456,
0.865792453289032,
0.7281118631362915,
-0.5776000618934631,
-0.16911840438842773,
-0.10214100778102875,
0.37842994928359985,
-0.9387825727462769,
0.329876571893692,
0.3755575716495514,
0.2368103712797165,
0.2527209222316742,
-0.5813002586364746,
0.2855352461338043,
0.023702163249254227,
0.08203914016485214,
-0.018738849088549614,
-0.3111364245414734,
0.6288617849349976,
-0.14946502447128296,
-0.6836059093475342,
0.039911918342113495,
0.9037743806838989,
0.26120537519454956,
0.2292783409357071,
0.5200673341751099,
0.26445043087005615,
1.1157472133636475,
-0.10788745433092117,
0.6436580419540405,
0.0459538996219635,
0.28869572281837463,
1.5533452033996582,
-0.38443759083747864,
0.8649407625198364,
0.7531640529632568,
0.004561471752822399,
0.7722029685974121,
0.5555732846260071,
-0.06603676080703735,
0.6163806319236755,
0.07281164824962616,
-0.3314798176288605,
-0.15160493552684784,
-0.36462274193763733,
-0.1887812614440918,
0.4881131947040558,
0.2852226197719574,
-0.49789050221443176,
-0.21682500839233398,
-0.10802644491195679,
-0.006545994896441698,
0.246694877743721,
-0.19008313119411469,
1.2376978397369385,
0.24257752299308777,
-0.5883071422576904,
0.2537385821342468,
-0.38538315892219543,
0.5058565735816956,
-0.2547280490398407,
-0.7015112638473511,
-0.005654423031955957,
0.003025925252586603,
-0.3654348850250244,
-0.6604409217834473,
0.054028842598199844,
-0.12839928269386292,
-0.04049012437462807,
-0.07900842279195786,
0.7762264013290405,
-0.6773241758346558,
-0.22216805815696716,
0.2728901207447052,
0.42944544553756714,
-0.025345012545585632,
0.22615644335746765,
-0.535586416721344,
-0.27545881271362305,
-0.20847462117671967,
0.2149539291858673,
-0.017416762188076973,
0.8362308740615845,
0.16511984169483185,
0.2773002088069916,
0.25002622604370117,
0.1461798995733261,
0.04114295542240143,
0.1950087994337082,
0.9866065382957458,
-0.7742867469787598,
-0.6308035254478455,
-1.088918685913086,
0.6002151370048523,
-0.5893248319625854,
-0.43166255950927734,
0.6158697605133057,
0.3446454107761383,
0.6367937326431274,
0.0010162140242755413,
0.5697376728057861,
0.13939426839351654,
0.34265705943107605,
-0.8633221983909607,
-0.08041737973690033,
-0.08470550179481506,
0.2518262267112732,
-0.3115966022014618,
-0.9180564284324646,
-0.4491015672683716,
0.7386065125465393,
0.1625944823026657,
-0.060763366520404816,
1.1090140342712402,
0.38068312406539917,
-0.04520832374691963,
-0.08573509007692337,
0.15360842645168304,
-0.10028567910194397,
0.12362097203731537,
0.5885521173477173,
0.9129570722579956,
-0.49635836482048035,
0.7447370290756226,
-0.19838768243789673,
-0.03315137326717377,
-0.10763069987297058,
-0.8850756287574768,
-1.0901377201080322,
-0.6707079410552979,
-0.49740633368492126,
-0.36958497762680054,
-0.1888067126274109,
0.9665815830230713,
0.8902974724769592,
-0.7479504346847534,
0.04051633179187775,
-0.01915406808257103,
0.24140356481075287,
-0.31357541680336,
-0.2502034902572632,
0.3502707779407501,
-0.6589331030845642,
-0.5188993811607361,
0.12405433505773544,
0.2775248885154724,
0.25961920619010925,
0.018384896218776703,
-0.06728696078062057,
-0.2864742577075958,
-0.33180102705955505,
0.3822375535964966,
-0.018404750153422356,
-0.6323197484016418,
-0.36591413617134094,
-0.3102818429470062,
-0.2528505027294159,
0.5081305503845215,
0.9053612947463989,
-0.6302323341369629,
0.5451505780220032,
0.28933021426200867,
0.8355610966682434,
0.7233580350875854,
0.23567301034927368,
0.3814808428287506,
-1.3842742443084717,
0.2931998074054718,
0.22784633934497833,
0.504696249961853,
0.7073050141334534,
-0.6568188667297363,
0.5234386324882507,
0.019331052899360657,
-0.04779323190450668,
-0.48227497935295105,
0.5078412294387817,
-1.079473853111267,
-0.09949661046266556,
1.0451593399047852,
-0.47610029578208923,
-0.010209915228188038,
-0.0993737205862999,
-0.3617759943008423,
0.45252934098243713,
-0.5417996048927307,
0.5014086961746216,
0.8892865180969238,
-0.3529752492904663,
-0.46653100848197937,
-0.08334794640541077,
0.3647807240486145,
-0.0013696304522454739,
-1.1092190742492676,
-0.1313687562942505,
0.5424810647964478,
-0.14839878678321838,
0.5339589715003967,
0.6639301180839539,
-0.18083126842975616,
-0.06049688905477524,
0.2251083105802536,
-0.27287188172340393,
0.1721394956111908,
-0.11372068524360657,
-0.40422606468200684,
0.3497824966907501,
0.13813841342926025,
-0.5734649300575256
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16527v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16527v1
|
Hallucination Detection in Foundation Models for Decision-Making: A Flexible Definition and Review of the State of the Art
| 2024-03-25T08:11:02 | 2024-03-25T08:11:02 |
Neeloy Chakraborty, Melkior Ornik, Katherine Driggs-Campbell
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.RO
|
Autonomous systems are soon to be ubiquitous, from manufacturing autonomy to
agricultural field robots, and from health care assistants to the entertainment
industry. The majority of these systems are developed with modular
sub-components for decision-making, planning, and control that may be
hand-engineered or learning-based. While these existing approaches have been
shown to perform well under the situations they were specifically designed for,
they can perform especially poorly in rare, out-of-distribution scenarios that
will undoubtedly arise at test-time. The rise of foundation models trained on
multiple tasks with impressively large datasets from a variety of fields has
led researchers to believe that these models may provide common sense reasoning
that existing planners are missing. Researchers posit that this common sense
reasoning will bridge the gap between algorithm development and deployment to
out-of-distribution tasks, like how humans adapt to unexpected scenarios. Large
language models have already penetrated the robotics and autonomous systems
domains as researchers are scrambling to showcase their potential use cases in
deployment. While this application direction is very promising empirically,
foundation models are known to hallucinate and generate decisions that may
sound reasonable, but are in fact poor. We argue there is a need to step back
and simultaneously design systems that can quantify the certainty of a model's
decision, and detect when it may be hallucinating. In this work, we discuss the
current use cases of foundation models for decision-making tasks, provide a
general definition for hallucinations with examples, discuss existing
approaches to hallucination detection and mitigation with a focus on decision
problems, and explore areas for further research in this exciting field.
|
[
-0.6361937522888184,
-0.7341543436050415,
0.8612369894981384,
0.283806711435318,
-0.015570420771837234,
-0.4299664795398712,
0.1011832058429718,
-0.6324851512908936,
0.37308216094970703,
0.6406974196434021,
-0.7747461199760437,
-0.29997482895851135,
-0.5287269949913025,
0.06740038096904755,
-0.653316855430603,
0.46978604793548584,
-0.004092654678970575,
-0.06803853064775467,
-0.2489296942949295,
0.009586057625710964,
-0.839172899723053,
-0.5457648038864136,
-0.2920474708080292,
-0.5616632103919983,
-0.3221398890018463,
0.12775596976280212,
0.801474928855896,
0.22692827880382538,
0.46067169308662415,
0.26288798451423645,
-0.08023873716592789,
-0.023150742053985596,
-0.22662214934825897,
0.14978952705860138,
-0.21943698823451996,
-0.1284767985343933,
-0.3606996238231659,
-0.20648245513439178,
0.18301615118980408,
1.1237235069274902,
-0.20891617238521576,
-0.3695146441459656,
-0.20164676010608673,
0.7801571488380432,
-0.8534592986106873,
0.08728540688753128,
-0.5070531368255615,
0.4501696527004242,
0.3704273998737335,
-0.035032253712415695,
-0.56307452917099,
-0.22921529412269592,
0.27534645795822144,
-0.3582953214645386,
0.41699057817459106,
-0.04942626133561134,
0.4401295483112335,
0.8050855994224548,
-0.11201994866132736,
-0.6816367506980896,
-0.9868845343589783,
0.6254146099090576,
-0.2994658946990967,
0.6599934101104736,
0.5650984048843384,
0.48499786853790283,
-0.5197696089744568,
-0.41496554017066956,
-0.5932335257530212,
-0.3710189163684845,
-0.15470251441001892,
-0.14678509533405304,
-0.2579857110977173,
0.19912447035312653,
0.0859285295009613,
0.1838756501674652,
-0.5447553992271423,
0.07084059715270996,
-0.23837262392044067,
-0.2673436403274536,
0.5994592308998108,
0.14496412873268127,
-0.1260082721710205,
-0.41993799805641174,
-0.35327795147895813,
0.07345598191022873,
-0.3635445833206177,
-0.15531325340270996,
0.2604283094406128,
0.3304697275161743,
0.18868142366409302,
0.5613770484924316,
-0.621690034866333,
0.8487018346786499,
0.2545112371444702,
0.19760097563266754,
-0.0015389486216008663,
-0.208952859044075,
-0.5865626931190491,
0.11666961014270782,
0.29961809515953064,
0.35980483889579773,
0.4331115484237671,
-0.29682013392448425,
-0.5012574791908264,
0.5406898260116577,
0.5467025637626648,
-0.5160863399505615,
-0.46146783232688904,
0.31115180253982544,
-0.6098446249961853,
-0.4192102551460266,
0.12979143857955933,
-0.804369330406189,
-0.8353776931762695,
-0.39161214232444763,
0.5147016048431396,
-0.27190133929252625,
-0.541259229183197,
0.8036866784095764,
-0.07356610149145126,
-0.006085331551730633,
0.22636517882347107,
-0.8578195571899414,
0.48575666546821594,
0.42822265625,
0.7125276923179626,
-0.47736290097236633,
-0.275945782661438,
-0.2827770411968231,
-0.17563676834106445,
-0.46373069286346436,
0.9547204375267029,
-0.1766941398382187,
-0.5773392915725708,
-0.23351630568504333,
0.17585496604442596,
-0.025388913229107857,
-0.8660077452659607,
0.3112906217575073,
-0.003868677420541644,
-0.39178702235221863,
-0.19737949967384338,
-0.16848692297935486,
-0.48883554339408875,
0.10923497378826141,
-0.7461564540863037,
0.5224488973617554,
0.2123648226261139,
-0.2251265048980713,
0.7316162586212158,
-0.5160030126571655,
-0.5520543456077576,
-0.03934955224394798,
-0.520546019077301,
-0.3834664225578308,
0.26298150420188904,
0.03885069862008095,
0.8423717021942139,
-0.10385403037071228,
0.5066405534744263,
-0.2905392646789551,
-0.4233092963695526,
0.20262446999549866,
-0.21406863629817963,
0.7023427486419678,
0.1639033854007721,
-0.8187873959541321,
0.17546500265598297,
-0.7785789370536804,
-0.2955677807331085,
-0.09602868556976318,
0.24043330550193787,
-0.13330958783626556,
0.31026527285575867,
-0.1743411123752594,
0.0778442844748497,
-0.1926259547472,
-0.037932440638542175,
-0.27265745401382446,
-0.08884663134813309,
0.14803466200828552,
0.7451257705688477,
0.08962759375572205,
0.5784716010093689,
-0.41982582211494446,
0.41979989409446716,
-0.03797818347811699,
0.40119630098342896,
0.22376598417758942,
-0.4780261218547821,
-0.7453424334526062,
-0.16974076628684998,
-0.21046629548072815,
0.36251047253608704,
-0.4026716351509094,
0.7519855499267578,
0.15406817197799683,
-0.20022636651992798,
-0.1961301863193512,
-0.29982778429985046,
-0.14387233555316925,
0.4950142800807953,
0.4634934365749359,
-0.19137291610240936,
-0.561318039894104,
-0.7491773962974548,
0.20655566453933716,
-0.12776589393615723,
0.2626327872276306,
0.12408385425806046,
0.9137985706329346,
-0.4603145718574524,
1.0365664958953857,
-0.3441123962402344,
-0.48260533809661865,
-0.21569570899009705,
0.06949105858802795,
-0.07188446819782257,
0.4754476249217987,
0.6187171936035156,
-1.1400281190872192,
0.2659669518470764,
0.1230916976928711,
-1.167142391204834,
0.1695205122232437,
-0.32190731167793274,
0.07812665402889252,
0.3622075915336609,
0.3470665216445923,
-0.779568612575531,
1.015959620475769,
0.27209004759788513,
-0.3886662423610687,
0.7692329287528992,
-0.03485766798257828,
0.11830262839794159,
-0.446988970041275,
0.026720745489001274,
-0.22583042085170746,
0.21038509905338287,
-0.6769387722015381,
0.08549122512340546,
-0.3476461172103882,
0.16740022599697113,
-0.1642259955406189,
0.27427175641059875,
-0.36703452467918396,
-0.5571685433387756,
-0.4564662277698517,
-0.09309756010770798,
-0.278841108083725,
0.23986436426639557,
0.44195908308029175,
0.49110734462738037,
0.4800299406051636,
-1.017764925956726,
0.3551190197467804,
0.20094965398311615,
-0.4948837161064148,
0.6168479919433594,
-0.3975331485271454,
-0.22489556670188904,
-0.18277527391910553,
0.33189037442207336,
-0.5917310118675232,
-0.5319597125053406,
0.449948787689209,
-0.4125068783760071,
-0.3001438081264496,
0.322849303483963,
-0.22037358582019806,
-0.336353600025177,
0.037796031683683395,
0.11020390689373016,
0.1854480355978012,
-0.5409983396530151,
0.8727087378501892,
0.46027371287345886,
0.4025534689426422,
-0.6428143978118896,
-0.9091706871986389,
-0.23485203087329865,
-0.17814244329929352,
-0.6528120636940002,
0.26524850726127625,
-0.17651496827602386,
-0.5848509669303894,
0.05982322618365288,
-0.4682997763156891,
-0.15978337824344635,
0.5290706753730774,
0.5868467092514038,
-0.027231400832533836,
-0.0003001459699589759,
0.13642758131027222,
0.18345946073532104,
-0.23297904431819916,
0.2728707492351532,
-0.23703289031982422,
0.581552267074585,
-0.32205966114997864,
-0.5909562110900879,
-0.38037464022636414,
0.49599945545196533,
0.8110454082489014,
0.01859191246330738,
0.5867538452148438,
0.18920069932937622,
-1.0416553020477295,
-0.49691030383110046,
-0.5569582581520081,
-0.5836650729179382,
-0.3939609229564667,
0.24074524641036987,
-0.526893675327301,
-0.30137044191360474,
0.6001914143562317,
-0.22317886352539062,
-0.26275357604026794,
0.24179382622241974,
0.5092523694038391,
0.17048625648021698,
0.9814472198486328,
0.8214847445487976,
0.2749929428100586,
-0.05044155940413475,
-0.42758944630622864,
0.4654479920864105,
-0.26932063698768616,
-0.4745279550552368,
-0.4443042576313019,
-0.22209635376930237,
-0.4373675584793091,
-0.1596345752477646,
0.051609113812446594,
0.24081993103027344,
0.01733596995472908,
0.22109085321426392,
-0.9028725028038025,
0.41187766194343567,
0.1615927368402481,
0.18196454644203186,
0.4197174906730652,
-0.24340501427650452,
0.05398446321487427,
0.35032331943511963,
-0.5215206742286682,
-0.5278441905975342,
0.7123602628707886,
-0.03051970712840557,
0.5412979125976562,
-0.15847669541835785,
0.6976094841957092,
0.4761076271533966,
-0.015972403809428215,
-0.8539825677871704,
0.5877372622489929,
0.18868441879749298,
-0.5385642647743225,
-0.45703184604644775,
-0.0522250160574913,
-0.7743499875068665,
0.23918619751930237,
-0.30159324407577515,
-0.8016813397407532,
0.9448923468589783,
-0.12754717469215393,
-0.7565491199493408,
0.2497393637895584,
-0.5811358094215393,
0.8500320911407471,
-0.07385161519050598,
0.10681166499853134,
-0.2891494333744049,
-0.5110417008399963,
0.47935521602630615,
-0.23683123290538788,
0.14170564711093903,
0.03517017140984535,
0.37022343277931213,
0.5137252807617188,
-0.06081072986125946,
0.735956609249115,
-0.17636042833328247,
0.08437187969684601,
0.3167053461074829,
0.18767064809799194,
0.48763608932495117,
0.008138404227793217,
-0.3197866678237915,
-0.08413136750459671,
-0.08895736187696457,
-0.11894815415143967,
-0.5198431611061096,
0.5520331263542175,
-0.4837622344493866,
-0.4319829046726227,
-0.5514742136001587,
-0.47221678495407104,
-0.0016052790451794863,
-0.0016200325917452574,
0.5720153450965881,
0.030718116089701653,
-0.3805029094219208,
0.28673413395881653,
0.8182220458984375,
0.03536197170615196,
0.3297218382358551,
0.18531394004821777,
-0.4427269995212555,
-0.041376449167728424,
0.7633429169654846,
0.18156439065933228,
0.06409010291099548,
-0.08909707516431808,
0.04131355136632919,
-0.2344396710395813,
-0.9089030623435974,
-0.12566038966178894,
0.020573057234287262,
-0.9117052555084229,
-0.06393105536699295,
-0.7503075003623962,
-0.1705397516489029,
-0.3780020475387573,
-0.5090877413749695,
-0.32955431938171387,
-0.3393085300922394,
-0.471555233001709,
-0.4042719900608063,
0.11922004073858261,
0.8923658728599548,
-0.30696824193000793,
0.24738651514053345,
0.015723370015621185,
0.5629928112030029,
0.3092666268348694,
0.14990414679050446,
0.11173679679632187,
-0.017394626513123512,
-0.002162857446819544,
0.0001644139993004501,
-0.19193324446678162,
-0.8684503436088562,
0.2901775538921356,
-0.38707607984542847,
0.7079210877418518,
0.5273890495300293,
0.4447164535522461,
0.47233590483665466,
0.1388157457113266,
0.5313673615455627,
-0.0019784027244895697,
-0.8503085970878601,
0.6342654824256897,
0.007146312389522791,
-0.22882221639156342,
0.5850339531898499,
0.5056009292602539,
-0.15612006187438965,
-0.1201767846941948,
-0.5067922472953796,
-0.48159244656562805,
0.5829485058784485,
0.17004646360874176,
-0.3101326823234558,
-0.14113473892211914,
0.21495109796524048,
0.5364076495170593,
0.3082144558429718,
-0.7720634937286377,
0.0665617436170578,
-0.28890639543533325,
0.14508536458015442,
0.16681891679763794,
0.13282901048660278,
-0.024940425530076027,
-0.25428101420402527,
0.3912504315376282,
-0.13084881007671356,
0.25535309314727783,
0.23849764466285706,
-0.31229427456855774,
-0.3706016540527344,
-0.09384513646364212,
0.6652697920799255,
0.7266750931739807,
-0.32831674814224243,
-0.0025748068001121283,
0.1143476739525795,
-0.29229071736335754,
0.2434239387512207,
0.09997964650392532,
-0.39476996660232544,
-0.05650433525443077,
-0.014311610721051693,
0.7353433966636658,
0.21281786262989044,
-0.6342567801475525,
0.4334767460823059,
0.24857811629772186,
-0.359982430934906,
-0.6977212429046631,
0.15094272792339325,
-0.31972986459732056,
0.5333938598632812,
0.40037405490875244,
0.654897928237915,
0.4718925654888153,
-0.6661653518676758,
0.41244828701019287,
0.4434981644153595,
-0.35602566599845886,
-0.2504611015319824,
0.45012620091438293,
0.16778850555419922,
-0.5338834524154663,
0.6078540682792664,
-0.36683472990989685,
-0.4263685345649719,
0.8020877242088318,
0.3215475380420685,
1.1519482135772705,
-0.2543560862541199,
0.4318171441555023,
-0.041314661502838135,
0.5857719779014587,
-0.5747376084327698,
0.23974570631980896,
-0.15774747729301453,
-0.9200780987739563,
-0.11875449866056442,
-0.6075827479362488,
-0.3201495409011841,
0.3856084942817688,
-0.6705965399742126,
0.3555642068386078,
-0.5833114981651306,
-0.2869020700454712,
-0.25796836614608765,
-0.15559077262878418,
-0.5779680013656616,
0.4122627377510071,
0.00860685110092163,
0.6666338443756104,
-1.0282002687454224,
0.3640718460083008,
0.3471960723400116,
-0.24402375519275665,
-0.23155251145362854,
0.11309287697076797,
0.01314615923911333,
-0.3225501775741577,
0.42964211106300354,
0.47028085589408875,
-0.5405658483505249,
-0.14490188658237457,
-0.35013025999069214,
-0.526012122631073,
1.1567343473434448,
0.23282264173030853,
-0.18169952929019928,
-0.31013843417167664,
-0.01410109456628561,
0.3259160816669464,
-0.5718986392021179,
-0.09506687521934509,
0.9876434803009033,
0.7183408141136169,
0.07933180034160614,
-0.7285878658294678,
0.10333425551652908,
0.16604825854301453,
-0.3117939531803131,
0.21172690391540527,
-0.2701013386249542,
0.8775033950805664,
-0.3955800235271454,
-0.32714614272117615,
0.29856032133102417,
0.5685257315635681,
0.4876440167427063,
0.7430158257484436,
0.6734927892684937,
0.37704718112945557,
0.9418807625770569,
-0.14287275075912476,
0.8114839196205139,
0.017913026735186577,
0.021772807464003563,
0.7006606459617615,
-0.42405787110328674,
0.6343103647232056,
0.5091673731803894,
0.1872841715812683,
0.35647839307785034,
0.6572765111923218,
0.06635928153991699,
0.7055479288101196,
0.14389221370220184,
-0.14396822452545166,
-0.5456415414810181,
-0.09312734007835388,
-0.4165900945663452,
0.5673450827598572,
0.6374868154525757,
-0.15644471347332,
-0.05723848566412926,
0.3401497006416321,
-0.5239028334617615,
0.13948173820972443,
-0.060436274856328964,
0.43646183609962463,
0.023581422865390778,
-0.7965714931488037,
0.5460376739501953,
-0.3013676404953003,
0.5449632406234741,
-0.27706897258758545,
-0.1548565775156021,
-0.21131077408790588,
0.2968496084213257,
-0.33859989047050476,
-0.4370060861110687,
0.6016383767127991,
-0.3975527584552765,
-0.32865095138549805,
-0.12799373269081116,
0.6414794325828552,
0.20278924703598022,
-0.28353333473205566,
0.7240052223205566,
0.6121258735656738,
0.3115987777709961,
-0.38807621598243713,
-0.4537368714809418,
0.2812544107437134,
-0.09762398898601532,
-0.02831444889307022,
0.1213579848408699,
0.43473759293556213,
-0.31813719868659973,
0.9050750732421875,
0.3595845103263855,
0.07128691673278809,
0.05123477056622505,
-0.15142537653446198,
0.5667465329170227,
-0.5821278095245361,
-0.5842651128768921,
-0.4929584264755249,
0.2919052839279175,
-0.0014303759671747684,
-0.2220519632101059,
0.16979998350143433,
0.13945244252681732,
0.9304613471031189,
-0.12899050116539001,
0.7102261185646057,
-0.03547460213303566,
0.0625247210264206,
-0.5665537118911743,
0.7503113150596619,
-0.4306652247905731,
0.16124464571475983,
-0.2965121567249298,
-0.887545645236969,
-0.4230385720729828,
1.1863608360290527,
-0.24207577109336853,
0.04841580614447594,
0.8403169512748718,
0.8685489296913147,
-0.020205430686473846,
0.4791755974292755,
0.4172940254211426,
-0.028787342831492424,
0.01652669347822666,
0.472562313079834,
1.0194395780563354,
-0.1839907169342041,
0.38921526074409485,
-0.4433022439479828,
-0.3155719041824341,
-0.5811445116996765,
-0.7749975323677063,
-0.8854656219482422,
-0.9232119917869568,
-0.13943886756896973,
-0.14066432416439056,
0.2478000521659851,
0.7637161612510681,
0.8480682969093323,
-0.9693626165390015,
-0.3686515986919403,
-0.7292813658714294,
0.3366096317768097,
-0.6286889910697937,
-0.20457711815834045,
0.14021386206150055,
-0.08003871142864227,
-0.30085864663124084,
0.6538596749305725,
0.25473108887672424,
0.45795413851737976,
-0.49088966846466064,
-0.3891671895980835,
-0.08193963021039963,
-0.053241338580846786,
0.5257897973060608,
0.19631968438625336,
-1.0923517942428589,
-0.2275998741388321,
0.1758776158094406,
0.2044096440076828,
-0.21838898956775665,
0.8005390763282776,
-1.1423927545547485,
0.4107688069343567,
0.3830523192882538,
0.5544699430465698,
0.3228616416454315,
-0.2923194169998169,
0.515861988067627,
-0.1179615929722786,
0.2588436007499695,
0.5180167555809021,
0.30600184202194214,
0.3432129919528961,
-0.5606062412261963,
0.775886595249176,
0.33754029870033264,
-0.4693412780761719,
-1.1002596616744995,
0.31814390420913696,
-0.7399042248725891,
-0.5891822576522827,
0.6669469475746155,
0.38642099499702454,
-0.0216386578977108,
-0.4619220793247223,
0.04275460168719292,
0.07980033755302429,
-0.1513526290655136,
1.2951916456222534,
0.8165516257286072,
-0.36154040694236755,
0.02306862361729145,
-0.6122277975082397,
0.6808097958564758,
0.41801348328590393,
-0.7768262624740601,
0.24578922986984253,
0.6245856881141663,
-0.37247326970100403,
0.5166007876396179,
0.5928245186805725,
0.3161531388759613,
0.6755618453025818,
0.1160314604640007,
-0.01589072495698929,
0.15540169179439545,
-0.9733337163925171,
-0.42420247197151184,
0.21461087465286255,
-0.1881348192691803,
-0.18156525492668152
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16516v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16516v2
|
Visually Guided Generative Text-Layout Pre-training for Document Intelligence
| 2024-03-25T08:00:43 | 2024-03-27T12:32:31 |
Zhiming Mao, Haoli Bai, Lu Hou, Jiansheng Wei, Xin Jiang, Qun Liu, Kam-Fai Wong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Prior study shows that pre-training techniques can boost the performance of
visual document understanding (VDU), which typically requires models to gain
abilities to perceive and reason both document texts and layouts (e.g.,
locations of texts and table-cells). To this end, we propose visually guided
generative text-layout pre-training, named ViTLP. Given a document image, the
model optimizes hierarchical language and layout modeling objectives to
generate the interleaved text and layout sequence. In addition, to address the
limitation of processing long documents by Transformers, we introduce a
straightforward yet effective multi-segment generative pre-training scheme,
facilitating ViTLP to process word-intensive documents of any length. ViTLP can
function as a native OCR model to localize and recognize texts of document
images. Besides, ViTLP can be effectively applied to various downstream VDU
tasks. Extensive experiments show that ViTLP achieves competitive performance
over existing baselines on benchmark VDU tasks, including information
extraction, document classification, and document question answering.
|
[
-0.40709248185157776,
-0.5978360176086426,
0.7114843726158142,
0.1497044563293457,
-0.4773671329021454,
0.028337374329566956,
0.010343966074287891,
-0.41538864374160767,
-0.030329106375575066,
0.47304829955101013,
-0.6610080003738403,
-0.6823628544807434,
-0.519537627696991,
-0.034362174570560455,
-0.6074570417404175,
0.6343581080436707,
-0.0412261001765728,
0.07776466012001038,
-0.48300066590309143,
0.10318028181791306,
-0.46668577194213867,
-0.5284883379936218,
-0.12727484107017517,
-0.011777334846556187,
0.5194932818412781,
0.493990421295166,
0.37328973412513733,
0.6213106513023376,
0.7752298712730408,
0.4187927842140198,
0.01927722804248333,
0.20281273126602173,
-0.22805890440940857,
0.04027444124221802,
0.056315828114748,
-0.40513765811920166,
-0.4802868962287903,
-0.11934833973646164,
0.7008762359619141,
0.34445643424987793,
0.07454172521829605,
-0.12417712062597275,
0.15097488462924957,
0.6639057993888855,
-0.6088663935661316,
0.09013374149799347,
-0.4260721504688263,
0.3095928132534027,
-0.27170875668525696,
-0.5634093880653381,
-0.5913177132606506,
-0.4673846960067749,
0.23178119957447052,
-0.7488829493522644,
0.49511751532554626,
-0.017513997852802277,
1.0075632333755493,
0.17681315541267395,
-0.20095276832580566,
-0.1656871885061264,
-0.6782888174057007,
0.3364054560661316,
-0.3146838843822479,
0.562810480594635,
0.20255112648010254,
0.11413953453302383,
0.21076272428035736,
-1.2445157766342163,
-0.5881003737449646,
0.15583787858486176,
-0.19751089811325073,
0.44360390305519104,
0.1926525980234146,
0.2158462256193161,
0.5627848505973816,
0.6183585524559021,
-0.8519778251647949,
0.04498680308461189,
-0.3986963629722595,
-0.09354101866483688,
0.13337020576000214,
-0.0052347853779792786,
0.6303868293762207,
0.08338930457830429,
-0.49758195877075195,
-0.3431682586669922,
-0.2965162992477417,
-0.10998640954494476,
0.12779094278812408,
-0.13332772254943848,
0.020097067579627037,
0.5971744656562805,
-0.13909390568733215,
0.8161177635192871,
-0.3227614164352417,
-0.08460337668657303,
0.2264484167098999,
-0.5106675624847412,
-0.426873117685318,
0.14937780797481537,
0.4806302785873413,
0.09409548342227936,
0.37078016996383667,
0.05146463215351105,
-0.05722552910447121,
0.07036153972148895,
0.5788933038711548,
-1.0041215419769287,
-0.17978772521018982,
-0.16062317788600922,
-0.4403493404388428,
-0.17157861590385437,
0.07500101625919342,
-0.7353553175926208,
-0.3234720528125763,
-0.44962024688720703,
0.4622821509838104,
-0.8348373174667358,
0.025062229484319687,
0.22393456101417542,
-0.46729910373687744,
0.6188256740570068,
0.585576593875885,
-1.0340909957885742,
0.08798795938491821,
0.43626150488853455,
0.9754413962364197,
-0.017249302938580513,
-0.5438117980957031,
-0.6752313375473022,
0.18669502437114716,
-0.1602603942155838,
1.0900418758392334,
-0.3529053032398224,
-0.6715879440307617,
0.21060435473918915,
-0.15759214758872986,
-0.21976929903030396,
-0.23589174449443817,
0.6525367498397827,
-0.4484998881816864,
0.43430274724960327,
-0.20962944626808167,
-0.30848056077957153,
0.21245279908180237,
0.3590700328350067,
-0.7144028544425964,
0.6601288318634033,
0.2728465795516968,
-1.0115704536437988,
0.5646302103996277,
-0.565031886100769,
-0.6198861598968506,
0.3276423215866089,
-0.4138509929180145,
-0.6042761206626892,
0.244340717792511,
0.5791542530059814,
0.2254798263311386,
0.1382422000169754,
-0.36848774552345276,
-0.05287636071443558,
-0.3472821116447449,
-0.21803343296051025,
-0.41550779342651367,
0.5372619032859802,
0.11947520822286606,
-0.046418193727731705,
0.34643426537513733,
-0.5466055274009705,
0.23192882537841797,
0.13495051860809326,
-0.44807353615760803,
-0.3974390923976898,
-0.1919872909784317,
0.21224316954612732,
-0.00778686860576272,
0.311222642660141,
-0.2178286910057068,
0.5171171426773071,
-0.33363696932792664,
0.06756075471639633,
0.6005966663360596,
-0.3441591262817383,
0.5812073945999146,
-0.11911001056432724,
0.5024864673614502,
-0.13378146290779114,
0.3836694359779358,
-0.6013760566711426,
-0.48579415678977966,
-0.7431889772415161,
-0.3464072644710541,
0.32387223839759827,
0.5064502358436584,
-1.0496379137039185,
0.3031001091003418,
-0.3901001214981079,
-0.34142205119132996,
-0.047508131712675095,
0.06701074540615082,
0.5736520886421204,
0.651917040348053,
0.43084242939949036,
-0.6345325112342834,
-0.3700389862060547,
-0.6330317258834839,
-0.15185001492500305,
-0.06639601290225983,
0.21860620379447937,
-0.115225650370121,
0.3477344810962677,
-0.20634478330612183,
0.7103530764579773,
-0.7160124182701111,
-0.7342066764831543,
-0.4762534201145172,
0.5777778625488281,
-0.032570965588092804,
0.3475649654865265,
0.5323851704597473,
-1.120451807975769,
-0.6948646306991577,
0.19115762412548065,
-0.6792146563529968,
-0.023668518289923668,
-0.03817891702055931,
-0.24456048011779785,
0.1451730877161026,
0.7812485098838806,
-0.6257723569869995,
0.9018892049789429,
0.24753040075302124,
-0.3359152674674988,
0.581096351146698,
-0.7116575241088867,
0.0899796187877655,
-0.978512704372406,
-0.14657370746135712,
-0.01861700974404812,
-0.17615213990211487,
-0.6071122288703918,
0.07265462726354599,
0.4641551673412323,
-0.22930528223514557,
-0.39141303300857544,
0.38980013132095337,
-0.784239649772644,
-0.36219003796577454,
-0.12168152630329132,
-0.12733933329582214,
0.2552788257598877,
0.4344315826892853,
0.5337128043174744,
0.8866937160491943,
0.15291351079940796,
-0.3603404760360718,
-0.02927282452583313,
0.48228076100349426,
-0.7404587864875793,
0.7523832321166992,
-0.4004436433315277,
-0.01176247838884592,
-0.3467768132686615,
-0.11310265213251114,
-0.9289200901985168,
-0.15369413793087006,
-0.23551806807518005,
-0.44019773602485657,
0.5406161546707153,
-0.022069647908210754,
-0.4678165018558502,
-0.4456939101219177,
-0.23631268739700317,
0.39385786652565,
0.55842125415802,
-0.6323613524436951,
0.7825455069541931,
0.05434825271368027,
-0.22629299759864807,
-0.4914860725402832,
-0.641008734703064,
-0.10307543724775314,
-0.005259993020445108,
-0.6083973050117493,
0.7232014536857605,
-0.01956523023545742,
0.21672086417675018,
-0.18243646621704102,
-0.02537030167877674,
-0.1965714991092682,
-0.0003306231228634715,
0.3000202178955078,
-0.012001864612102509,
-0.2210976928472519,
0.10894270241260529,
-0.03138144686818123,
-0.19830194115638733,
-0.17743463814258575,
-0.31959331035614014,
0.8557480573654175,
-0.2760127782821655,
-0.6139351725578308,
-0.23780006170272827,
0.4380966126918793,
0.5613671541213989,
-0.7569571137428284,
0.40288397669792175,
0.8532211184501648,
-0.15413345396518707,
-0.2284715473651886,
-0.36281928420066833,
0.10995451360940933,
-0.4972330629825592,
0.509804904460907,
-0.38698866963386536,
-0.4351133108139038,
0.0001575036149006337,
-0.16891001164913177,
0.11535708606243134,
0.27378007769584656,
0.3847557604312897,
-0.35715022683143616,
0.9498149156570435,
1.0046252012252808,
0.1375986784696579,
1.0371713638305664,
-0.42362889647483826,
0.11012895405292511,
-0.5867289304733276,
-0.3000359535217285,
-0.5957608819007874,
-0.07183966040611267,
-0.07094816863536835,
-0.5275591015815735,
0.37067657709121704,
0.07218824326992035,
0.041744332760572433,
0.17848388850688934,
-0.62042236328125,
0.6228675246238708,
1.0039323568344116,
0.13783185184001923,
0.24734169244766235,
0.278982937335968,
-0.24368895590305328,
-0.10752447694540024,
-0.604364812374115,
-0.26131218671798706,
0.76332026720047,
0.07930722832679749,
0.7509839534759521,
-0.20775997638702393,
0.7958084940910339,
0.2788637578487396,
0.2308032363653183,
-0.7260544896125793,
0.4887561798095703,
-0.2500932514667511,
-0.010735351592302322,
-0.4150013029575348,
0.011975483037531376,
-0.8194934129714966,
0.06340020149946213,
-0.28880736231803894,
-0.6565837860107422,
0.12653467059135437,
0.13378019630908966,
-0.18803031742572784,
0.17793357372283936,
-1.0282000303268433,
1.0835307836532593,
-0.6393932700157166,
-0.14083822071552277,
-0.009255597367882729,
-0.3740842640399933,
0.12403380870819092,
0.044271070510149,
-0.10277178883552551,
0.451159805059433,
0.34395861625671387,
0.5023782849311829,
-0.7016603946685791,
0.4737234115600586,
-0.0838615894317627,
0.12590231001377106,
0.08557886630296707,
-0.30952680110931396,
0.2909965217113495,
-0.23422583937644958,
0.16241095960140228,
-0.13801699876785278,
-0.12672337889671326,
-0.3723503351211548,
-0.6071411371231079,
0.37985846400260925,
-0.7374357581138611,
-0.6642411351203918,
-0.4133864939212799,
-0.32336631417274475,
-0.03881353139877319,
0.6589963436126709,
0.6703472137451172,
0.6529727578163147,
-0.3797479271888733,
0.3369140028953552,
1.1101421117782593,
-0.3043275475502014,
0.4902699887752533,
0.0008758649346418679,
-0.38482046127319336,
-0.26028648018836975,
0.8792626857757568,
-0.007740420754998922,
0.07830240577459335,
0.7781577110290527,
0.009288324043154716,
-0.4909854829311371,
-0.8008691072463989,
-0.39414504170417786,
0.01779318042099476,
-0.800319254398346,
0.17397214472293854,
-0.7014191746711731,
-0.5650144219398499,
-0.3442717492580414,
-0.40277478098869324,
-0.1419185847043991,
0.0379205122590065,
-0.36468392610549927,
-0.047241080552339554,
-0.03709062933921814,
0.5590178370475769,
0.2658540904521942,
0.5699024796485901,
-0.7249913215637207,
0.6721850633621216,
0.7013291120529175,
0.3062436282634735,
-0.24981652200222015,
-0.36799871921539307,
-0.2795952260494232,
-0.337725967168808,
-0.3979705572128296,
-0.7492223978042603,
0.5103917717933655,
0.10219573974609375,
0.5279556512832642,
0.43319761753082275,
-0.10056348145008087,
0.6404635906219482,
-0.5509893298149109,
0.5098715424537659,
0.363070547580719,
-0.7362585663795471,
0.7821735143661499,
-0.30669477581977844,
0.7261062264442444,
0.44763925671577454,
0.32109788060188293,
-0.029421864077448845,
-0.059612490236759186,
-0.3907766044139862,
-0.7317345142364502,
0.6319394707679749,
0.24461883306503296,
-0.09459499269723892,
0.3264051675796509,
0.04784063994884491,
-0.14973118901252747,
0.18092241883277893,
-0.7295420169830322,
0.26143038272857666,
-0.5143725275993347,
-0.22551706433296204,
0.00850443821400404,
-0.5235887765884399,
-0.0314125120639801,
-0.36590948700904846,
0.2645787298679352,
-0.2931146025657654,
0.4537915289402008,
0.4297389090061188,
-0.4519994258880615,
0.34327244758605957,
0.18716734647750854,
0.8233312964439392,
0.6147342324256897,
-0.2623556852340698,
0.02275031805038452,
-0.16668590903282166,
-0.9615505933761597,
-0.061860449612140656,
0.21809664368629456,
-0.11721345782279968,
0.0584268681704998,
0.5821207761764526,
0.8254142999649048,
-0.2721858322620392,
-0.4015955328941345,
0.7675297260284424,
-0.6167333126068115,
-0.48876476287841797,
-0.31309208273887634,
0.11017128080129623,
-0.04342866688966751,
0.19236591458320618,
0.26784974336624146,
-0.16489402949810028,
-0.040943387895822525,
-0.4469689428806305,
0.13225294649600983,
0.38383948802948,
-0.6206308007240295,
0.06020254269242287,
0.7072986364364624,
0.2030685544013977,
-0.5424171686172485,
0.8655082583427429,
0.1409478634595871,
-0.5184380412101746,
0.7733381390571594,
0.5138107538223267,
0.8863146901130676,
0.03477667272090912,
0.41025853157043457,
0.09726390987634659,
0.41782206296920776,
-0.02165934070944786,
0.48959439992904663,
-0.4419257938861847,
-0.5513390898704529,
-0.3118663728237152,
-0.6852383017539978,
-0.25958606600761414,
0.08649013191461563,
-0.4891447424888611,
0.4051746428012848,
-0.6283451318740845,
-0.0709051787853241,
0.017211532220244408,
-0.15574420988559723,
-0.7970884442329407,
0.5591372847557068,
0.3688748776912689,
0.9627604484558105,
-0.4441717863082886,
1.1573302745819092,
0.5670709609985352,
-0.5072997212409973,
-0.4998704493045807,
0.26384714245796204,
-0.26530465483665466,
-0.7638779282569885,
0.6673924922943115,
0.5793502926826477,
-0.17089945077896118,
0.16277800500392914,
-0.4240291118621826,
-0.44830814003944397,
1.124756932258606,
0.04351749271154404,
-0.5869907736778259,
-0.39171671867370605,
0.19013124704360962,
0.6487849950790405,
-0.1594376415014267,
0.32962092757225037,
0.1570255309343338,
0.38476818799972534,
0.00016211005277000368,
-0.49105459451675415,
-0.36593398451805115,
-0.4757298529148102,
0.2189638912677765,
0.12765748798847198,
-0.3669045865535736,
0.786112368106842,
-0.168291375041008,
-0.24688801169395447,
0.30636876821517944,
0.8114860653877258,
0.08418866246938705,
0.29500633478164673,
0.5188376903533936,
0.7072528600692749,
0.6368035078048706,
-0.23741069436073303,
1.1128873825073242,
-0.15554434061050415,
-0.19578562676906586,
1.1335395574569702,
-0.082908496260643,
0.5653274655342102,
0.37846389412879944,
0.12927405536174774,
0.5247604250907898,
0.40235450863838196,
0.1510179191827774,
0.7385141253471375,
-0.11480803042650223,
-0.19175627827644348,
-0.21722954511642456,
-0.04041973128914833,
-0.5976840257644653,
0.32415831089019775,
0.5440477728843689,
-0.5384705662727356,
-0.17922435700893402,
-0.01127748191356659,
-0.4459228515625,
0.22533182799816132,
-0.3460962474346161,
0.7901362180709839,
0.006119849160313606,
-0.6134971380233765,
0.2825109660625458,
-0.1666698306798935,
0.49590587615966797,
-0.8228813409805298,
-0.03451869264245033,
-0.293367475271225,
0.2163049280643463,
-0.10827061533927917,
-0.8681336045265198,
0.037973906844854355,
-0.17855452001094818,
-0.3734321892261505,
-0.6937447190284729,
0.9839365482330322,
-0.2502542734146118,
-0.3877057135105133,
0.14228735864162445,
0.4265231788158417,
-0.1838872730731964,
-0.28389471769332886,
-0.48597896099090576,
-0.09013845026493073,
-0.005229002796113491,
-0.17920373380184174,
0.5178899765014648,
0.581230640411377,
-0.12327608466148376,
0.2921311855316162,
0.6319018006324768,
-0.08179783076047897,
0.10772226750850677,
0.40453529357910156,
0.8467215299606323,
-0.6488553285598755,
-0.742070198059082,
-0.7311105132102966,
0.566269040107727,
-0.4284107983112335,
-0.32456567883491516,
0.5136291980743408,
0.577071487903595,
0.912948727607727,
-0.34992948174476624,
0.80818772315979,
0.23787634074687958,
0.044822681695222855,
-0.8446385860443115,
0.8198538422584534,
-0.823502779006958,
-0.16373488306999207,
-0.5502416491508484,
-0.9190669059753418,
-0.29040834307670593,
0.48085713386535645,
-0.44826599955558777,
-0.171909898519516,
0.9091290831565857,
0.5831629037857056,
-0.2181115597486496,
-0.11639660596847534,
0.43610188364982605,
-0.24056802690029144,
0.3998360335826874,
0.4385796785354614,
0.9640948176383972,
-0.15676873922348022,
0.6200834512710571,
-0.17510820925235748,
-0.08257301151752472,
-0.30222758650779724,
-0.8459368944168091,
-1.0868421792984009,
-0.7688552737236023,
-0.00253234407864511,
-0.08420371264219284,
-0.08547685295343399,
0.14411798119544983,
0.7651774883270264,
-0.1482943296432495,
0.0018482804298400879,
-0.36320552229881287,
0.3276568055152893,
-0.04538244381546974,
-0.16062016785144806,
0.376651406288147,
-0.3859940767288208,
-0.6506327390670776,
0.1820831000804901,
0.6444690227508545,
0.4642479419708252,
-0.14751996099948883,
0.05296102911233902,
-0.24669159948825836,
-0.1510416567325592,
0.6149150133132935,
0.5165479183197021,
-0.2967664897441864,
0.042148131877183914,
-0.1324480026960373,
-0.38772091269493103,
0.3223315477371216,
0.9187482595443726,
-0.6339501142501831,
0.6656906604766846,
0.9748945236206055,
0.6937633156776428,
0.7317177057266235,
0.20325885713100433,
0.6206342577934265,
-0.7782548666000366,
0.4808005392551422,
-0.03639848902821541,
0.4950055181980133,
0.23274818062782288,
-0.38082632422447205,
0.4589013159275055,
0.16764122247695923,
-0.30621805787086487,
-0.6754209995269775,
0.2875170111656189,
-0.9810412526130676,
-0.4255642294883728,
0.7946905493736267,
-0.07773882895708084,
-0.4043712615966797,
0.058487147092819214,
-0.6643732786178589,
0.13995257019996643,
0.041180528700351715,
0.5804224014282227,
0.3462260365486145,
0.07945115119218826,
-0.47705861926078796,
-0.24141377210617065,
0.6739310622215271,
0.38695332407951355,
-1.1263575553894043,
-0.3594212234020233,
0.40383732318878174,
-0.34257686138153076,
0.3960343301296234,
1.0519747734069824,
-0.07102000713348389,
0.3664079010486603,
0.15460588037967682,
0.18863283097743988,
-0.14136777818202972,
-0.8217602968215942,
0.04195793718099594,
0.25852805376052856,
0.113736592233181,
-0.3110339641571045
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16512v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16512v5
|
LLMs Are Few-Shot In-Context Low-Resource Language Learners
| 2024-03-25T07:55:29 | 2024-06-25T11:54:23 |
Samuel Cahyawijaya, Holy Lovenia, Pascale Fung
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In-context learning (ICL) empowers large language models (LLMs) to perform
diverse tasks in underrepresented languages using only short in-context
information, offering a crucial avenue for narrowing the gap between
high-resource and low-resource languages. Nonetheless, there is only a handful
of works explored ICL for low-resource languages with most of them focusing on
relatively high-resource languages, such as French and Spanish. In this work,
we extensively study ICL and its cross-lingual variation (X-ICL) on 25
low-resource and 7 relatively higher-resource languages. Our study not only
assesses the effectiveness of ICL with LLMs in low-resource languages but also
identifies the shortcomings of in-context label alignment, and introduces a
more effective alternative: query alignment. Moreover, we provide valuable
insights into various facets of ICL for low-resource languages. Our study
concludes the significance of few-shot in-context information on enhancing the
low-resource understanding quality of LLMs through semantically relevant
information by closing the language gap in the target language and aligning the
semantics between the targeted low-resource and the high-resource language that
the model is proficient in. Our work highlights the importance of advancing ICL
research, particularly for low-resource languages. Our code is publicly
released at https://github.com/SamuelCahyawijaya/in-context-alignment
|
[
-0.3749438524246216,
-0.3910079300403595,
0.4117261469364166,
-0.10238628089427948,
-0.12218300998210907,
0.464698851108551,
-0.2570774257183075,
-0.6114205718040466,
-0.19873261451721191,
0.2283921092748642,
-0.5840831995010376,
-0.6276291012763977,
-0.4367697834968567,
0.17096920311450958,
-0.09956220537424088,
0.9078417420387268,
-0.08695187419652939,
0.2594749331474304,
-0.21179209649562836,
-0.42733150720596313,
-0.24874824285507202,
-0.3495621085166931,
-0.43975722789764404,
-0.4686141908168793,
0.677108883857727,
0.8441230058670044,
0.5152521729469299,
0.6413306593894958,
0.572441577911377,
0.09472601115703583,
-0.30854693055152893,
0.2457844763994217,
-0.8704841136932373,
-0.284988135099411,
-0.3049286901950836,
-0.45607253909111023,
-0.1473941057920456,
-0.17638973891735077,
0.8639875650405884,
0.9250844717025757,
0.14597249031066895,
0.16417883336544037,
0.4678238332271576,
0.7812182903289795,
-0.7929697036743164,
-0.0684487596154213,
-0.8048945665359497,
0.049465030431747437,
-0.5768412947654724,
0.05161324515938759,
-0.31002944707870483,
-0.0667407289147377,
0.26549243927001953,
-0.4451083838939667,
-0.18988817930221558,
0.3499121367931366,
0.8373203277587891,
0.44440409541130066,
-0.5160885453224182,
-0.15590547025203705,
-0.4628784656524658,
1.0689635276794434,
-0.7745445966720581,
0.6028526425361633,
0.41474035382270813,
0.25802162289619446,
-0.02927320823073387,
-0.4738888740539551,
-0.4223109781742096,
-0.05829640105366707,
-0.3315213620662689,
-0.1389099657535553,
-0.04583938792347908,
-0.03752707690000534,
0.17601391673088074,
0.11531651020050049,
-0.4386042654514313,
0.6571664810180664,
-0.13063770532608032,
-0.00014827221457380801,
0.2925189733505249,
0.312255322933197,
0.34713539481163025,
-0.13936847448349,
-0.5394851565361023,
0.17763102054595947,
-1.2806329727172852,
0.31547144055366516,
0.09697610884904861,
0.7602059245109558,
-0.499864786863327,
0.4908541440963745,
-0.07643312960863113,
0.8872342109680176,
-0.16201098263263702,
-0.5071321725845337,
-0.01745794713497162,
-0.4971608817577362,
-0.21320582926273346,
0.29636791348457336,
0.683395266532898,
0.18152733147144318,
-0.11728738248348236,
-0.16875678300857544,
-0.147355854511261,
-0.3606792092323303,
-0.406861811876297,
-0.7150267362594604,
0.3130294978618622,
-0.1654915064573288,
-0.3635324537754059,
0.09223224222660065,
-0.19563482701778412,
-0.4861590564250946,
-0.16868267953395844,
-0.23619970679283142,
0.10901613533496857,
-0.38564783334732056,
0.05763501673936844,
-0.15647530555725098,
0.3548872768878937,
0.45957231521606445,
0.2791224420070648,
-0.8303695917129517,
0.3197396397590637,
0.6177095174789429,
0.8210958242416382,
-0.5427660942077637,
-0.28525781631469727,
-0.48908835649490356,
0.27891770005226135,
-0.2775178849697113,
0.4336533546447754,
-0.6168743371963501,
-0.42210713028907776,
-0.02662792056798935,
-0.054217398166656494,
-0.05102841556072235,
-0.5739958882331848,
0.3377251923084259,
-0.5599609613418579,
0.0415041409432888,
-0.5386945009231567,
-0.6106237173080444,
-0.0053410339169204235,
0.40143531560897827,
-0.43422362208366394,
0.9700654745101929,
0.1139804944396019,
-0.6589159369468689,
0.5113806128501892,
-0.3068559467792511,
-0.2634298503398895,
0.12173595279455185,
-0.5137125849723816,
-0.14995695650577545,
0.04853029549121857,
0.020930057391524315,
0.11291597038507462,
-0.5530332326889038,
-0.11213590949773788,
-0.030089976266026497,
-0.515653133392334,
0.43799251317977905,
-0.4280463755130768,
0.7603147625923157,
0.16022376716136932,
-0.3505450189113617,
-0.25061601400375366,
-0.5065248012542725,
0.21399351954460144,
-0.08292848616838455,
-0.5236260294914246,
-0.4183329641819,
-0.2400607317686081,
0.10100352019071579,
0.4665357172489166,
0.21316547691822052,
-0.5148239135742188,
0.1970706284046173,
-0.5658836960792542,
0.08136425167322159,
0.4596695899963379,
-0.31698909401893616,
0.6607739925384521,
-0.2255261242389679,
0.592490553855896,
0.05991310253739357,
-0.06063632294535637,
-0.09417011588811874,
-0.16355018317699432,
-0.5057796239852905,
-0.3666759729385376,
0.3442380726337433,
0.5291234850883484,
-0.6865016222000122,
-0.11678885668516159,
-0.21423719823360443,
-0.23158089816570282,
-0.7000673413276672,
0.5278818011283875,
0.9275698065757751,
0.7336688041687012,
0.34053799510002136,
-0.15898212790489197,
-0.42647629976272583,
-0.8871504068374634,
-0.2146432250738144,
-0.1022544801235199,
0.28518110513687134,
0.5116913914680481,
0.3034992516040802,
-0.13540086150169373,
0.9956352114677429,
-0.24633264541625977,
-0.40688449144363403,
-0.4485413432121277,
-0.33594638109207153,
0.08510905504226685,
0.3940552771091461,
0.5809829235076904,
-0.6019741296768188,
-1.0556105375289917,
0.2420339733362198,
-0.6070361137390137,
-0.08335677534341812,
0.3316522240638733,
-0.23151731491088867,
0.40456780791282654,
0.5200027823448181,
-0.237603098154068,
0.22214049100875854,
0.5568660497665405,
-0.03958546742796898,
-0.054022762924432755,
0.038836151361465454,
-0.04909396544098854,
-0.7541541457176208,
-0.10126817971467972,
0.09673509001731873,
-0.12584801018238068,
-0.4994742274284363,
-0.17768841981887817,
0.2541552782058716,
-0.05053247883915901,
-1.0053631067276,
0.9194797873497009,
-0.608242392539978,
-0.026645982638001442,
-0.26524221897125244,
0.3450033962726593,
-0.029811307787895203,
0.3728981912136078,
-0.01298841554671526,
0.8351674675941467,
0.4667282700538635,
-0.4446922242641449,
-0.332863450050354,
0.058464787900447845,
-0.5122387409210205,
0.5450586676597595,
-0.15861876308918,
-0.013933422043919563,
-0.17877443134784698,
-0.012791207060217857,
-0.9466303586959839,
-0.08953985571861267,
0.41194021701812744,
-0.006434284150600433,
0.6842821836471558,
-0.3026214838027954,
-0.39485079050064087,
0.23263029754161835,
-0.08705226331949234,
0.9001405835151672,
0.33659660816192627,
-0.7595821022987366,
0.14330224692821503,
0.4258640706539154,
0.13795675337314606,
-0.8341574668884277,
-0.8652884364128113,
-0.05453597381711006,
-0.33307337760925293,
-0.4578979015350342,
0.575495183467865,
-0.06380879133939743,
-0.5611168742179871,
0.007678184658288956,
-0.07030293345451355,
0.005467255599796772,
-0.01387250516563654,
-0.0826154574751854,
0.17366430163383484,
-0.4683307111263275,
0.2618039846420288,
-0.15557821094989777,
-0.07630783319473267,
-0.44043833017349243,
-0.30632027983665466,
0.3276366591453552,
-0.28068768978118896,
-0.6183118224143982,
-0.42243826389312744,
0.36671245098114014,
0.3348518908023834,
-0.06832003593444824,
0.7653736472129822,
0.24642746150493622,
-0.3659765124320984,
-0.16707436740398407,
-0.3601413667201996,
0.05041157826781273,
-0.3962792456150055,
0.2855566442012787,
-0.30951809883117676,
-0.9465739130973816,
0.43775179982185364,
0.01542000100016594,
-0.11223118007183075,
0.23970776796340942,
0.38267791271209717,
-0.3382681608200073,
0.9685081243515015,
0.9482730031013489,
-0.28973284363746643,
0.5201841592788696,
-0.24517935514450073,
0.2606777548789978,
-0.9198057651519775,
-0.22551396489143372,
-0.46686217188835144,
-0.4231205880641937,
-0.6339902281761169,
-0.305178701877594,
0.39454251527786255,
0.18183481693267822,
-0.18938536942005157,
0.07548993080854416,
-0.18539151549339294,
0.7908159494400024,
0.36793678998947144,
0.06443711370229721,
0.45039984583854675,
-0.05711620673537254,
-0.11820129305124283,
-0.4646012783050537,
-0.9522953629493713,
-0.6079280376434326,
0.7225562334060669,
0.03813865780830383,
1.101798176765442,
0.3120615780353546,
0.8379610776901245,
-0.054685212671756744,
0.16554591059684753,
-0.8974992036819458,
0.28830230236053467,
-0.291167289018631,
-0.5115188360214233,
-0.35022348165512085,
-0.08450879901647568,
-0.85015469789505,
0.4655604660511017,
0.06826360523700714,
-0.7481479644775391,
0.2883167862892151,
0.17530466616153717,
-0.4511973261833191,
0.41382119059562683,
-0.6500955820083618,
0.8632397651672363,
-0.8437272310256958,
-0.6620192527770996,
0.040430013090372086,
-0.784417986869812,
0.3333781361579895,
-0.32263147830963135,
0.31235337257385254,
-0.2306419163942337,
-0.45305949449539185,
0.35911235213279724,
-0.4574067294597626,
1.2074501514434814,
0.1758527010679245,
-0.12302330881357193,
0.2966814637184143,
-0.04971306025981903,
0.47587302327156067,
0.03712080419063568,
-0.08929509669542313,
0.10206490010023117,
-0.06950804591178894,
-0.5704028010368347,
-0.38073694705963135,
0.8196579217910767,
-0.6769200563430786,
-0.5961657166481018,
-0.44133126735687256,
-0.6408175230026245,
-0.1302078813314438,
0.09441536664962769,
0.4770728051662445,
0.21847671270370483,
-0.17292417585849762,
0.1908605694770813,
0.7195468544960022,
-0.1932738721370697,
0.5521846413612366,
0.7425898313522339,
0.0006306792492978275,
-0.12518271803855896,
0.8095460534095764,
0.4255770444869995,
0.48947620391845703,
0.707457959651947,
0.09941914677619934,
-0.1516033262014389,
-0.47682926058769226,
-0.4731036126613617,
0.27249306440353394,
-0.8762430548667908,
-0.4096071124076843,
-0.3898695707321167,
0.010704300366342068,
-0.11152777820825577,
-0.4803248345851898,
-0.3475620150566101,
-0.25181910395622253,
-0.3662247955799103,
0.22741377353668213,
0.03900402411818504,
0.44516605138778687,
0.15541908144950867,
0.48376041650772095,
-0.7479560971260071,
-0.08754301071166992,
-0.017609210684895515,
0.17449951171875,
0.06054236739873886,
-0.6161822080612183,
-0.6157839894294739,
-0.11036684364080429,
-0.18026313185691833,
-0.6250096559524536,
0.27363935112953186,
0.35133522748947144,
0.778810977935791,
0.3793327808380127,
0.006794004235416651,
0.8295890688896179,
-0.37044188380241394,
0.6916385889053345,
0.17704574763774872,
-0.9279789328575134,
0.44087204337120056,
0.014416608959436417,
0.6454713940620422,
0.7654212713241577,
0.5203821659088135,
-0.6573419570922852,
-0.2856089472770691,
-0.4042121469974518,
-0.8648909330368042,
0.9890332221984863,
-0.04930863156914711,
-0.048259440809488297,
-0.03418508917093277,
0.254853218793869,
0.16174578666687012,
0.08627407997846603,
-0.8398883938789368,
-0.3800559639930725,
0.25399917364120483,
-0.25746428966522217,
0.0657249242067337,
-0.3324108421802521,
-0.24268485605716705,
-0.17171716690063477,
0.7658036947250366,
-0.3939480185508728,
-0.3583180606365204,
-0.09183477610349655,
-0.37715280055999756,
-0.32047098875045776,
0.36245718598365784,
0.4800818860530853,
0.7309029698371887,
-0.07679809629917145,
0.1821083277463913,
0.5407466292381287,
-0.05001412332057953,
0.2802495062351227,
-0.05175497755408287,
-0.2735171914100647,
-0.169670969247818,
0.48297709226608276,
0.6634942293167114,
0.6645431518554688,
-0.8711313605308533,
0.44344499707221985,
0.08282666653394699,
0.41984686255455017,
-0.008397095836699009,
-0.04560409113764763,
0.06953141838312149,
0.3990355134010315,
0.16851218044757843,
-0.16294600069522858,
-0.165941521525383,
-0.5642222166061401,
-0.07329750061035156,
0.7087411284446716,
-0.6201585531234741,
-0.15745708346366882,
0.4454958438873291,
0.02829759009182453,
-0.174726203083992,
0.5851835608482361,
-0.23591306805610657,
-0.22557230293750763,
0.5185973048210144,
0.7042673230171204,
0.5821033716201782,
0.18412446975708008,
-0.13562805950641632,
0.19387850165367126,
0.3262542188167572,
0.046383775770664215,
0.10282403975725174,
-0.2475130409002304,
-0.7422437071800232,
-0.4142608642578125,
-0.4581468999385834,
-0.5879445672035217,
-0.1028003841638565,
-0.4706172049045563,
0.5056392550468445,
-0.16873571276664734,
-0.04705580696463585,
-0.35007959604263306,
0.013512803241610527,
-0.7560597062110901,
-0.01069506537169218,
0.2248985767364502,
0.8460775017738342,
-0.6991251111030579,
1.0877971649169922,
0.7080861926078796,
-0.5135290026664734,
-0.6745859384536743,
0.10446886718273163,
0.3213917016983032,
-0.7958203554153442,
1.2417298555374146,
-0.08638908714056015,
-0.41744160652160645,
0.08098244667053223,
-0.5599066019058228,
-1.2870149612426758,
1.1197949647903442,
0.615065336227417,
-0.7367529273033142,
0.016892272979021072,
0.37681296467781067,
0.4473631978034973,
-0.6196249723434448,
0.07343737781047821,
0.4691401422023773,
0.2869209051132202,
0.1669369637966156,
-0.833999514579773,
-0.17605100572109222,
0.13788987696170807,
0.1978486031293869,
0.30344605445861816,
-0.9118032455444336,
0.6004809737205505,
-0.32641470432281494,
-0.34721797704696655,
0.06087363883852959,
0.5961015224456787,
0.36255261301994324,
0.382758766412735,
0.22150854766368866,
0.3885470926761627,
0.8634520173072815,
-0.1370423436164856,
0.980044960975647,
-0.420855849981308,
0.2101910263299942,
1.289270281791687,
-0.5431041717529297,
0.7124531269073486,
0.8267274498939514,
-0.07370216399431229,
0.1896682232618332,
0.822456955909729,
0.3937375843524933,
0.6057910919189453,
0.09101615101099014,
-0.47195228934288025,
-0.2656081020832062,
-0.5537827014923096,
-0.2653883993625641,
0.40619441866874695,
0.4816005527973175,
-0.2674250900745392,
-0.3317214250564575,
0.11682827770709991,
0.007851757109165192,
0.04007590189576149,
-0.2224627137184143,
0.7772183418273926,
0.34703338146209717,
-0.43798545002937317,
0.8001716136932373,
-0.20363536477088928,
0.7255427837371826,
-0.5410531163215637,
0.08166635036468506,
-0.3688112199306488,
0.15120123326778412,
-0.4194287955760956,
-0.807793915271759,
0.0737757459282875,
0.10365782678127289,
-0.26761704683303833,
-0.21228596568107605,
0.5873888731002808,
-0.6100161075592041,
-0.23093342781066895,
0.543817400932312,
0.7805303335189819,
0.18784679472446442,
0.492954820394516,
-0.6743480563163757,
0.1905878782272339,
0.04122587665915489,
0.10864859074354172,
0.6967705488204956,
0.5434051752090454,
-0.21590735018253326,
0.6005699038505554,
0.20135030150413513,
0.11521666496992111,
0.11305566877126694,
0.10524283349514008,
0.6797570586204529,
-0.6305975914001465,
-0.2834538519382477,
-1.0014472007751465,
0.5052745342254639,
0.21592625975608826,
-0.4345727562904358,
0.7686597108840942,
0.7752217650413513,
1.5416936874389648,
0.19357018172740936,
0.7149315476417542,
0.13689126074314117,
0.2569325268268585,
-0.6790347695350647,
0.38309231400489807,
-0.8971375226974487,
0.5565611720085144,
-0.172146275639534,
-0.7405447959899902,
-0.4350299537181854,
0.20544421672821045,
-0.25661003589630127,
-0.23144641518592834,
0.6586160659790039,
0.9073331356048584,
-0.20678304135799408,
-0.5368086099624634,
0.5988601446151733,
-0.19684046506881714,
0.12206994742155075,
0.4431218206882477,
0.92149817943573,
-0.30187326669692993,
0.7744887471199036,
-0.5433088541030884,
-0.006537139881402254,
-0.3219060003757477,
-0.9024160504341125,
-0.6862449049949646,
-0.3834574520587921,
-0.4415822923183441,
-0.2155734747648239,
0.0750366747379303,
1.3259812593460083,
0.6007164716720581,
-0.6423476934432983,
-0.6804885268211365,
0.28423312306404114,
0.5639976263046265,
-0.08407549560070038,
-0.18688684701919556,
0.32468098402023315,
-0.5850261449813843,
-0.9496192932128906,
0.5639466047286987,
0.5732869505882263,
0.21284116804599762,
-0.1480477899312973,
-0.4283601939678192,
-0.3533828854560852,
-0.3217824101448059,
0.6258765459060669,
0.700340747833252,
-0.9759933352470398,
0.010176874697208405,
0.03675078600645065,
-0.6878401637077332,
0.3778005838394165,
0.752494215965271,
-0.6711226105690002,
0.44237416982650757,
0.6236791014671326,
0.8246212601661682,
0.43365949392318726,
-0.20098832249641418,
0.33224061131477356,
-0.930864155292511,
0.298766165971756,
0.1389988213777542,
0.4741038680076599,
0.49845409393310547,
-0.37544992566108704,
0.5739875435829163,
0.01535066682845354,
-0.4299983084201813,
-0.8590121269226074,
0.368681937456131,
-0.6574049592018127,
-0.16809476912021637,
1.0535029172897339,
0.11317387223243713,
-0.24119925498962402,
0.07102695852518082,
-0.19293761253356934,
0.22988159954547882,
-0.3491806089878082,
0.4755210876464844,
0.6402937173843384,
-0.4887319505214691,
-0.20478062331676483,
-0.49050578474998474,
0.6039051413536072,
0.4337928891181946,
-0.6272865533828735,
-0.24663159251213074,
0.293907105922699,
0.06280907988548279,
0.004226322751492262,
0.6270286440849304,
-0.13060331344604492,
-0.02179378643631935,
-0.559807300567627,
-0.043475206941366196,
0.448901891708374,
-0.12781091034412384,
-0.44189417362213135,
-0.10232188552618027,
0.49365919828414917,
-0.03994767740368843
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16504v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16504v1
|
LARA: Linguistic-Adaptive Retrieval-Augmented LLMs for Multi-Turn Intent Classification
| 2024-03-25T07:38:40 | 2024-03-25T07:38:40 |
Liu Junhua, Tan Yong Keat, Fu Bin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Following the significant achievements of large language models (LLMs),
researchers have employed in-context learning for text classification tasks.
However, these studies focused on monolingual, single-turn classification
tasks. In this paper, we introduce LARA (Linguistic-Adaptive
Retrieval-Augmented Language Models), designed to enhance accuracy in
multi-turn classification tasks across six languages, accommodating numerous
intents in chatbot interactions. Multi-turn intent classification is notably
challenging due to the complexity and evolving nature of conversational
contexts. LARA tackles these issues by combining a fine-tuned smaller model
with a retrieval-augmented mechanism, integrated within the architecture of
LLMs. This integration allows LARA to dynamically utilize past dialogues and
relevant intents, thereby improving the understanding of the context.
Furthermore, our adaptive retrieval techniques bolster the cross-lingual
capabilities of LLMs without extensive retraining and fine-tune. Comprehensive
experiments demonstrate that LARA achieves state-of-the-art performance on
multi-turn intent classification tasks, enhancing the average accuracy by 3.67%
compared to existing methods.
|
[
0.03447314351797104,
-0.9376593828201294,
0.6081032752990723,
0.3742024600505829,
-0.2342296838760376,
0.4273211359977722,
-0.4144970178604126,
-0.36383363604545593,
0.577702522277832,
0.7993535995483398,
-0.5332446098327637,
-0.5665472149848938,
-0.6498481631278992,
0.08236223459243774,
-0.4331456124782562,
0.8533360958099365,
0.06675978749990463,
0.021841445937752724,
0.027473457157611847,
-0.32950863242149353,
-0.668535053730011,
-0.5314510464668274,
-0.7257266044616699,
-0.1024322435259819,
0.6702955961227417,
0.5810463428497314,
0.461112380027771,
0.041838765144348145,
0.37881630659103394,
0.3489484488964081,
0.1794837862253189,
0.7886069416999817,
-0.4914947748184204,
0.4582187533378601,
0.11268079280853271,
-0.5120461583137512,
-0.599494457244873,
-0.15264391899108887,
0.6926764249801636,
0.5212810635566711,
-0.36555370688438416,
0.07896262407302856,
0.013088933192193508,
0.5535497665405273,
-0.8181739449501038,
0.43431127071380615,
-0.9051058292388916,
-0.278547078371048,
-0.3916102349758148,
-0.5227298736572266,
-1.0455238819122314,
-0.26676663756370544,
0.22102780640125275,
-0.6768970489501953,
-0.11064938455820084,
0.23627935349941254,
0.2165248543024063,
0.08045028150081635,
-0.34333646297454834,
-0.5909081697463989,
-0.6250135898590088,
1.0644140243530273,
-0.4664263129234314,
0.516099750995636,
0.27052685618400574,
0.2710518538951874,
-0.12205451726913452,
-0.8564654588699341,
-0.6187668442726135,
0.15440483391284943,
-0.07834608852863312,
-0.10867545753717422,
-0.03278035297989845,
0.07652567327022552,
-0.004341520369052887,
0.07980676740407944,
-0.37259477376937866,
0.05170690640807152,
-0.2578578591346741,
-0.15130817890167236,
0.6209321618080139,
0.2201506793498993,
0.6139068603515625,
-0.11625461280345917,
-0.431373655796051,
0.012995034456253052,
-0.5803478956222534,
0.034559983760118484,
-0.007465960457921028,
0.8628217577934265,
0.028170377016067505,
0.47716283798217773,
-0.27061858773231506,
0.7253097891807556,
0.042696595191955566,
-0.3481019139289856,
0.405347615480423,
-0.2125696837902069,
-0.24341140687465668,
0.23401862382888794,
0.9676693081855774,
0.16918060183525085,
0.13725191354751587,
-0.09800702333450317,
0.13365472853183746,
-0.2614680230617523,
0.28953078389167786,
-0.4448625147342682,
-0.046151626855134964,
0.09560689330101013,
-0.0674566999077797,
-0.05086609348654747,
-0.2116706222295761,
-0.698693037033081,
-0.27298256754875183,
-0.07478521019220352,
0.41399356722831726,
-0.4142040014266968,
-0.2718954384326935,
0.4931717813014984,
0.27431052923202515,
0.3977378010749817,
0.5562975406646729,
-0.9268619418144226,
0.33542168140411377,
0.674831748008728,
0.9569309949874878,
-0.594097375869751,
-0.7182253003120422,
-0.9771983623504639,
0.27236077189445496,
-0.2806449234485626,
0.7526233196258545,
-0.6947429180145264,
-0.1606467217206955,
0.3415617346763611,
-0.08838162571191788,
-0.2608187794685364,
-0.1580120027065277,
0.5933931469917297,
-0.9916908740997314,
0.41499340534210205,
-0.14065800607204437,
-0.25176382064819336,
-0.6601807475090027,
0.35734209418296814,
-0.5294370055198669,
1.074215054512024,
-0.025637013837695122,
-0.5151066780090332,
0.37656500935554504,
-0.9164272546768188,
-0.6782599091529846,
0.30320239067077637,
0.2217264026403427,
-0.3084560036659241,
-0.11072245240211487,
0.1722225546836853,
0.49341389536857605,
-0.33561158180236816,
0.18705850839614868,
-0.25789496302604675,
-0.32198551297187805,
0.329755574464798,
-0.6511069536209106,
0.7204135060310364,
-0.1552797108888626,
0.08019956946372986,
0.6523112058639526,
-0.4943145513534546,
0.18066902458667755,
-0.2033049464225769,
-0.28744885325431824,
-0.5606516003608704,
0.06748759001493454,
0.16315244138240814,
0.18251095712184906,
0.20656001567840576,
-0.5079481601715088,
0.26945775747299194,
-0.3613709509372711,
0.3418262302875519,
0.5023611783981323,
-0.09939312189817429,
0.6776743531227112,
-0.22314079105854034,
0.29061686992645264,
-0.14216367900371552,
0.374493807554245,
-0.1622317135334015,
-0.7282520532608032,
-0.824038565158844,
-0.5601111054420471,
0.18834088742733002,
0.6301308870315552,
-0.9739800691604614,
0.10573380440473557,
-0.6444965600967407,
-0.277263343334198,
-0.6522731781005859,
0.3430834114551544,
0.2694317400455475,
0.31369704008102417,
0.6426584720611572,
-0.3995850682258606,
-0.4001300632953644,
-0.4408414959907532,
-0.3522278368473053,
-0.31523674726486206,
0.17697888612747192,
0.34901607036590576,
0.08131295442581177,
-0.42144396901130676,
0.8478805422782898,
-0.5120214223861694,
-0.3847730755805969,
-0.39209049940109253,
0.21801483631134033,
-0.002700593788176775,
0.07151835411787033,
0.3270769715309143,
-1.1216137409210205,
-0.8056089878082275,
-0.05791992321610451,
-0.688306450843811,
-0.0008735277224332094,
0.14040441811084747,
-0.20479489862918854,
0.2794455885887146,
0.21850383281707764,
-0.7178836464881897,
0.1142907589673996,
0.3154347538948059,
-0.06779786944389343,
0.23391710221767426,
-0.18136624991893768,
0.32274287939071655,
-0.7752109169960022,
-0.46859651803970337,
-0.22742842137813568,
-0.30623674392700195,
-0.8713113069534302,
-0.076514832675457,
0.10420916974544525,
0.25951331853866577,
-0.8298789858818054,
0.7579547762870789,
-0.42920130491256714,
0.03731120750308037,
-0.3849411606788635,
0.30491891503334045,
0.017484338954091072,
0.5661749243736267,
0.27429836988449097,
0.8028518557548523,
0.6025753617286682,
-0.9173386693000793,
0.3747169077396393,
0.3389277756214142,
-0.21782833337783813,
0.6852678656578064,
-0.15291480720043182,
0.45713314414024353,
0.0031467066146433353,
0.05043967440724373,
-1.0409103631973267,
-0.44343867897987366,
0.2478497475385666,
-0.44939762353897095,
0.2789463400840759,
-0.22798331081867218,
-0.3857184648513794,
0.1001334935426712,
-0.5386531352996826,
0.4630413353443146,
0.3573564887046814,
-0.8623680472373962,
1.1685034036636353,
0.6521317958831787,
-0.22173307836055756,
-0.7459312081336975,
-0.6605247259140015,
0.008802290074527264,
-0.35443758964538574,
-0.4652886688709259,
0.29319268465042114,
-0.10114341974258423,
-0.010047980584204197,
-0.48968490958213806,
0.18748071789741516,
-0.15894074738025665,
-0.1823565512895584,
0.06996653974056244,
0.28018346428871155,
0.00447014719247818,
0.22677811980247498,
0.15941797196865082,
-0.07850934565067291,
-0.13152828812599182,
-0.16015323996543884,
0.7925134897232056,
-0.0020655703265219927,
-0.4097509980201721,
-0.2344532310962677,
0.27553361654281616,
0.9410998821258545,
-0.33178797364234924,
0.6856984496116638,
0.5592281222343445,
-0.2772864103317261,
-0.1958315670490265,
-0.706986665725708,
-0.0060957144014537334,
-0.500251293182373,
0.28880858421325684,
-0.5107077956199646,
-0.9821556806564331,
0.4585932791233063,
-0.10647114366292953,
0.10270097106695175,
0.2172040343284607,
0.6007900834083557,
-0.019883278757333755,
0.9377351403236389,
0.6125596761703491,
-0.03534698486328125,
0.7043306827545166,
0.016293546184897423,
0.1553100198507309,
-1.1350860595703125,
-0.38907015323638916,
-0.29156941175460815,
-0.11826889961957932,
-0.6653255820274353,
-0.6104896068572998,
0.3445999026298523,
-0.19131143391132355,
-0.2854937016963959,
0.26659446954727173,
-0.48793625831604004,
0.27865394949913025,
0.4762634336948395,
0.3704380691051483,
0.7065641283988953,
-0.030738381668925285,
0.45881542563438416,
-0.07016810774803162,
-0.7186150550842285,
-0.36749011278152466,
1.0673929452896118,
0.053479649126529694,
0.908690869808197,
0.4024121165275574,
0.47476449608802795,
0.37224191427230835,
0.6529090404510498,
-0.909331202507019,
0.529793381690979,
-0.06903578341007233,
-0.48155677318573,
-0.37703531980514526,
-0.3860836923122406,
-0.8469969034194946,
0.27871498465538025,
-0.23025771975517273,
-0.7136200070381165,
-0.028713738545775414,
-0.10012700408697128,
-0.19308510422706604,
0.15918540954589844,
-0.7545559406280518,
0.7124345898628235,
-0.5938652157783508,
-0.32889750599861145,
-0.18447506427764893,
-0.3802488446235657,
0.31243231892585754,
-0.08006279170513153,
0.3267683684825897,
-0.13019128143787384,
-0.23725979030132294,
0.7015792727470398,
0.1145222932100296,
0.9166322946548462,
-0.12731772661209106,
0.032267335802316666,
0.4306270182132721,
0.08465706557035446,
0.5056896209716797,
0.18636159598827362,
-0.06726184487342834,
-0.038286346942186356,
-0.21562103927135468,
-0.26959875226020813,
-0.7225722670555115,
0.8626965284347534,
-0.45550310611724854,
-0.3396085500717163,
-0.5479367971420288,
-0.5660445094108582,
-0.33161041140556335,
0.3769688904285431,
0.02271369658410549,
0.2906641662120819,
-0.1566077321767807,
0.09123609960079193,
0.7908381223678589,
-0.157799631357193,
0.2730448544025421,
0.8741404414176941,
-0.5950815677642822,
-0.21752946078777313,
0.8493896722793579,
0.010221041738986969,
0.2592543065547943,
0.6113283634185791,
-0.0181815717369318,
-0.5601142048835754,
-0.6848211288452148,
-0.5283364653587341,
0.10584988445043564,
-0.7490003705024719,
-0.42942094802856445,
-0.8700796365737915,
-0.049430932849645615,
-0.0829126387834549,
-0.005662840791046619,
-0.420038104057312,
-0.15367700159549713,
-0.2100357711315155,
0.10221894830465317,
0.8123997449874878,
0.6479175686836243,
0.49279817938804626,
0.5303572416305542,
-0.649839460849762,
0.2571881413459778,
0.3495391011238098,
0.6085646152496338,
-0.2567408084869385,
-0.6690305471420288,
0.15746323764324188,
0.025370066985487938,
0.007769481278955936,
-0.8569293022155762,
0.3987172544002533,
0.3448927402496338,
0.3918965458869934,
-0.13062869012355804,
0.14189590513706207,
0.5730509161949158,
-0.5964527726173401,
0.548109233379364,
0.1712583601474762,
-0.916281521320343,
0.4728778004646301,
-0.19284625351428986,
0.24804452061653137,
0.7122058272361755,
0.38842377066612244,
-0.5870084166526794,
-0.0399283729493618,
-0.2503392994403839,
-0.785818874835968,
0.7661866545677185,
-0.15882743895053864,
0.4138621985912323,
-0.06800859421491623,
0.5507997274398804,
0.14911474287509918,
0.13042901456356049,
-0.6933556199073792,
-0.11914670467376709,
0.20312334597110748,
-0.5463161468505859,
0.051352787762880325,
-0.2218993902206421,
0.19167962670326233,
-0.17273855209350586,
0.708153247833252,
-0.496155321598053,
0.10379861295223236,
-0.0768887996673584,
-0.6029016971588135,
0.1349932700395584,
0.23834842443466187,
0.37648695707321167,
0.5424591898918152,
0.005466870032250881,
-0.006455959286540747,
0.6494519710540771,
-0.642681360244751,
0.012851137667894363,
-0.08187312632799149,
-0.3450419008731842,
-0.037521131336688995,
0.21371544897556305,
0.8355915546417236,
0.5865408778190613,
-0.6507811546325684,
0.35782673954963684,
-0.3647782504558563,
0.30844345688819885,
-0.34788209199905396,
0.2543133795261383,
-0.14304350316524506,
0.2386389672756195,
0.46206915378570557,
0.10079698264598846,
0.38713186979293823,
-0.6938349008560181,
0.07602210342884064,
0.5363577008247375,
-0.6576473116874695,
-0.20725980401039124,
0.24754023551940918,
0.1806558519601822,
-0.8085023164749146,
0.6112504601478577,
-0.27728602290153503,
-0.6674907207489014,
-0.20502780377864838,
0.43515947461128235,
0.8500106930732727,
-0.37133440375328064,
0.19136519730091095,
0.26868805289268494,
0.12491246312856674,
-0.3777981400489807,
0.4241972863674164,
0.020573478192090988,
-0.8929625153541565,
-0.6723843216896057,
-0.650913655757904,
-0.6741253733634949,
-0.16611310839653015,
-0.4674415588378906,
0.46450096368789673,
-0.09447862207889557,
-0.13594432175159454,
0.026332052424550056,
-0.1053953766822815,
-0.4435855746269226,
-0.13266122341156006,
-0.18116119503974915,
0.7211462259292603,
-0.6922463178634644,
0.893303394317627,
0.6710875630378723,
-0.23500314354896545,
-0.35619446635246277,
-0.13438056409358978,
-0.1501789391040802,
-0.5723192691802979,
0.23820719122886658,
0.05959908291697502,
-0.728916347026825,
0.08384831994771957,
-0.42500436305999756,
-0.8270121812820435,
0.9425560832023621,
0.36682993173599243,
-0.2697012424468994,
0.025647876784205437,
0.010912983678281307,
0.5794854164123535,
-0.6121509671211243,
0.39551153779029846,
0.44268599152565,
0.3220166265964508,
0.022681552916765213,
-1.074703574180603,
-0.21994057297706604,
-0.05560962110757828,
-0.16011518239974976,
0.3451277017593384,
-0.7315667271614075,
0.5363485217094421,
-0.200109601020813,
-0.1553598940372467,
-0.15573501586914062,
0.8542324304580688,
0.3621034324169159,
0.44644829630851746,
0.47520166635513306,
-0.0941358283162117,
0.9200728535652161,
-0.22492220997810364,
1.0195361375808716,
-0.18788141012191772,
0.3279789090156555,
1.1224148273468018,
-0.5056642889976501,
1.149173617362976,
0.44548219442367554,
-0.13406400382518768,
0.7438888549804688,
0.3311734199523926,
0.6581421494483948,
0.5941509008407593,
-0.27935129404067993,
-0.46006107330322266,
-0.21231719851493835,
-0.004006967879831791,
0.1878170669078827,
0.761063814163208,
0.8299053311347961,
0.11963367462158203,
0.18481962382793427,
0.40199145674705505,
-0.21634699404239655,
0.22047843039035797,
-0.31608641147613525,
0.9241982698440552,
-0.15438967943191528,
-0.7742213606834412,
0.21945315599441528,
-0.015364778228104115,
1.1329238414764404,
-0.655326783657074,
-0.10255397111177444,
0.08818709850311279,
0.4507502317428589,
-0.19764134287834167,
-0.97640061378479,
0.273649662733078,
-0.10432429611682892,
-0.292561411857605,
-0.147118479013443,
1.0304914712905884,
-0.7035057544708252,
-0.41322430968284607,
0.6187596321105957,
0.5247983932495117,
-0.017611680552363396,
-0.16963791847229004,
-0.6833552718162537,
0.41483670473098755,
-0.23359130322933197,
-0.03580091521143913,
0.2542670965194702,
0.28313180804252625,
-0.19635143876075745,
0.9504678845405579,
0.5309444665908813,
-0.1709875762462616,
0.23914343118667603,
0.10134205967187881,
0.5836726427078247,
-0.441072940826416,
-0.35318660736083984,
-0.7944084405899048,
0.256263792514801,
-0.0748470351099968,
-0.3071819543838501,
0.7825766801834106,
0.581475019454956,
0.827455461025238,
0.06191445514559746,
0.5530175566673279,
0.07554899901151657,
0.735887885093689,
-0.618594765663147,
0.37250086665153503,
-0.3174629509449005,
0.471265584230423,
-0.1475340723991394,
-0.7543346285820007,
-0.4441128671169281,
0.6598052382469177,
-0.4277075529098511,
0.2872627377510071,
0.41620030999183655,
0.5202879905700684,
-0.3243780732154846,
0.16821208596229553,
0.05901302769780159,
-0.018108172342181206,
0.2850712835788727,
0.5234944224357605,
0.7722253799438477,
-0.6133072972297668,
0.4817068576812744,
-0.005933074280619621,
-0.3056178689002991,
-0.35720494389533997,
-0.5838623642921448,
-0.8223798871040344,
-0.8318378925323486,
-0.26485660672187805,
-0.24967294931411743,
0.10108586400747299,
0.995057225227356,
0.795094907283783,
-0.7886616587638855,
-0.36314326524734497,
0.35475954413414,
0.4088077247142792,
-0.1605902910232544,
-0.22089070081710815,
0.35267046093940735,
-0.5784822106361389,
-0.9240524768829346,
0.5244843363761902,
0.6546404957771301,
-0.35055866837501526,
-0.2646912932395935,
-0.29657605290412903,
-0.6905229091644287,
0.022520286962389946,
1.0857495069503784,
0.2409268617630005,
-0.6717251539230347,
-0.48020270466804504,
0.4621999263763428,
-0.18011373281478882,
0.28791284561157227,
0.6634117364883423,
-0.6560822129249573,
0.5967723727226257,
0.4539845883846283,
0.6084502339363098,
0.8382689952850342,
-0.06366006284952164,
0.3544902205467224,
-0.7785943150520325,
0.025531893596053123,
0.2700747847557068,
0.24582824110984802,
0.6205684542655945,
-0.37663453817367554,
0.42608147859573364,
-0.12551860511302948,
-0.38928934931755066,
-0.9113462567329407,
0.17577232420444489,
-1.2102934122085571,
-0.03426669165492058,
1.0822079181671143,
0.12537972629070282,
-0.3170827031135559,
-0.43682408332824707,
-0.35035622119903564,
0.27393537759780884,
-0.4104543626308441,
0.6762345433235168,
0.6658424735069275,
-0.38081303238868713,
-0.3340282142162323,
-0.6516788601875305,
0.5671473741531372,
0.2539587616920471,
-0.8002980351448059,
0.2387693226337433,
0.15088008344173431,
0.28009724617004395,
0.5171346664428711,
0.9549319744110107,
-0.12605911493301392,
0.4048622250556946,
-0.5387811064720154,
-0.058030687272548676,
0.24935951828956604,
-0.5908005833625793,
-0.1631201058626175,
0.1659160703420639,
0.26891833543777466,
-0.06918231397867203
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16483v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16483v1
|
Automatic Construction of a Large-Scale Corpus for Geoparsing Using Wikipedia Hyperlinks
| 2024-03-25T07:08:13 | 2024-03-25T07:08:13 |
Keyaki Ohno, Hirotaka Kameko, Keisuke Shirai, Taichi Nishimura, Shinsuke Mori
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Geoparsing is the task of estimating the latitude and longitude (coordinates)
of location expressions in texts. Geoparsing must deal with the ambiguity of
the expressions that indicate multiple locations with the same notation. For
evaluating geoparsing systems, several corpora have been proposed in previous
work. However, these corpora are small-scale and suffer from the coverage of
location expressions on general domains. In this paper, we propose Wikipedia
Hyperlink-based Location Linking (WHLL), a novel method to construct a
large-scale corpus for geoparsing from Wikipedia articles. WHLL leverages
hyperlinks in Wikipedia to annotate multiple location expressions with
coordinates. With this method, we constructed the WHLL corpus, a new
large-scale corpus for geoparsing. The WHLL corpus consists of 1.3M articles,
each containing about 7.8 unique location expressions. 45.6% of location
expressions are ambiguous and refer to more than one location with the same
notation. In each article, location expressions of the article title and those
hyperlinks to other articles are assigned with coordinates. By utilizing
hyperlinks, we can accurately assign location expressions with coordinates even
with ambiguous location expressions in the texts. Experimental results show
that there remains room for improvement by disambiguating location expressions.
|
[
-0.7963036298751831,
-1.0747942924499512,
0.8751413822174072,
0.09968019276857376,
-0.33474019169807434,
-0.196532741189003,
-0.45085859298706055,
-0.6217563152313232,
0.3843132257461548,
-0.2173956036567688,
-0.508400022983551,
-0.8460192680358887,
-0.3373410701751709,
0.3310040533542633,
-0.4955863356590271,
0.9869844913482666,
-0.0026332801207900047,
-0.22488729655742645,
-0.2998065948486328,
-0.14967772364616394,
-0.028005024418234825,
-0.5180452466011047,
-0.06845894455909729,
0.3698984682559967,
0.8849523067474365,
0.387227863073349,
1.0558054447174072,
0.7758498787879944,
0.6117557883262634,
0.38071557879447937,
-0.14386463165283203,
0.2989354431629181,
-0.22115977108478546,
0.06219205632805824,
-0.6845628023147583,
0.14523105323314667,
-0.05321459472179413,
-0.09926819056272507,
0.9799296855926514,
0.9857326149940491,
-0.039314813911914825,
0.5799074769020081,
-0.08110307157039642,
0.3497377336025238,
-0.9623631238937378,
-0.03008148819208145,
-0.4255601763725281,
-0.015161733143031597,
-0.4016191065311432,
0.05363021790981293,
0.033320918679237366,
-0.6606314778327942,
0.2318841814994812,
-0.6684153079986572,
0.4483323097229004,
0.3396700620651245,
0.87205970287323,
0.03128611668944359,
0.0665784403681755,
-0.1762658953666687,
-0.6725855469703674,
0.5815172791481018,
-0.45441824197769165,
0.5937648415565491,
0.36733680963516235,
0.3288916349411011,
-0.16109924018383026,
-0.510882556438446,
-0.834739625453949,
0.021019458770751953,
-0.441921204328537,
-0.34194958209991455,
0.029273204505443573,
-0.32639941573143005,
0.6444175839424133,
-0.04191252216696739,
-0.46173912286758423,
-0.09894229471683502,
-0.624212920665741,
-0.2518746852874756,
0.349756121635437,
-0.030427031219005585,
0.20435094833374023,
-0.6819614768028259,
-0.38661912083625793,
0.016237422823905945,
-0.5598412156105042,
-0.002824799856171012,
0.4122651219367981,
0.3875734806060791,
-0.13675457239151,
0.7766721248626709,
-0.4900074005126953,
0.7408812642097473,
0.12118057161569595,
-0.29863911867141724,
0.2559150457382202,
0.15478967130184174,
-0.19093365967273712,
0.5461208820343018,
0.9352183938026428,
0.38783755898475647,
0.046702537685632706,
-0.19320254027843475,
0.24583084881305695,
-0.3832050859928131,
0.1835658997297287,
-0.4661654233932495,
-0.10474000126123428,
0.2773645222187042,
-0.37064337730407715,
-0.20208704471588135,
0.26605963706970215,
-0.881385087966919,
-0.2751580774784088,
-0.1718762069940567,
0.005088210105895996,
-0.32042190432548523,
0.15402476489543915,
-0.21926023066043854,
-0.12136621028184891,
-0.027005499228835106,
0.06425736844539642,
-0.9573094248771667,
-0.3728422522544861,
0.6783549189567566,
0.8245875835418701,
0.01690935716032982,
-0.8985215425491333,
-0.549697995185852,
0.5721554160118103,
-0.17511694133281708,
0.9924950003623962,
-0.430763840675354,
-0.35644567012786865,
0.35853907465934753,
0.04732302203774452,
0.386148601770401,
-0.2424493432044983,
0.7862670421600342,
-0.8465255498886108,
0.09501423686742783,
-0.43913009762763977,
-0.32213595509529114,
-0.09470907598733902,
0.3335825800895691,
-0.8573272824287415,
1.2187867164611816,
0.12671126425266266,
-1.0182844400405884,
0.07078578323125839,
-0.6584985256195068,
-0.5745033621788025,
0.19256293773651123,
0.31062424182891846,
-0.12412158399820328,
0.05839162319898605,
0.40377742052078247,
0.07562470436096191,
-0.18608048558235168,
0.5772485136985779,
-0.4753115475177765,
-0.3761352002620697,
0.23913659155368805,
-0.3079833686351776,
0.7132903337478638,
0.06125634163618088,
-0.3067225217819214,
-0.06770148128271103,
-0.559377908706665,
0.19049596786499023,
-0.2502060532569885,
-0.36183682084083557,
-0.5294410586357117,
0.05571959912776947,
0.13081558048725128,
0.06995370984077454,
0.9594080448150635,
-0.6507280468940735,
-0.07483336329460144,
-0.32910120487213135,
-0.21505239605903625,
0.4686897099018097,
-0.1004280224442482,
0.544625461101532,
0.2644089460372925,
0.11518560349941254,
-0.32722896337509155,
0.3943119943141937,
0.13589954376220703,
-0.4973208010196686,
-0.46961361169815063,
0.05580203980207443,
0.19558094441890717,
0.36691829562187195,
-0.6480754613876343,
0.7821117043495178,
-0.6676172018051147,
-0.7961537837982178,
-0.3383289873600006,
0.036027900874614716,
0.12012407183647156,
1.0150797367095947,
0.8144534230232239,
0.2873590290546417,
-0.5072057247161865,
-0.7652246356010437,
0.1311391443014145,
-0.33627402782440186,
-0.14742650091648102,
-0.06181523576378822,
0.31217479705810547,
0.07389382272958755,
1.1565966606140137,
-0.9488965272903442,
-0.027350477874279022,
0.2575622797012329,
0.008734873495995998,
-0.05834781378507614,
0.20708459615707397,
0.4726415276527405,
-0.9818034768104553,
-0.7575713992118835,
-0.07908140867948532,
-0.8802927732467651,
-0.15714244544506073,
0.4152390956878662,
-0.7194015979766846,
-0.10157528519630432,
0.5554030537605286,
-0.8676499128341675,
0.29597198963165283,
0.4329787492752075,
-0.28349146246910095,
0.8458115458488464,
-0.43590402603149414,
0.11593697965145111,
-0.8480921983718872,
0.3568040132522583,
-0.07162027806043625,
-0.20440414547920227,
-0.11647346615791321,
0.18516813218593597,
0.20743022859096527,
-0.31617048382759094,
-0.5966846942901611,
0.24902179837226868,
-0.21381765604019165,
-0.2505970597267151,
-0.18288522958755493,
0.5186841487884521,
-0.05822088196873665,
0.33016130328178406,
0.08376763015985489,
0.5155422687530518,
0.5157517194747925,
-0.37264731526374817,
0.8883002400398254,
0.34136947989463806,
-0.260399729013443,
0.7137132883071899,
-0.2771662473678589,
-0.15502923727035522,
-0.23104578256607056,
0.41383516788482666,
-0.8251023888587952,
-0.2631136178970337,
0.14001962542533875,
-0.2707709074020386,
-0.15281200408935547,
-0.22908943891525269,
-0.5498945713043213,
-0.5297316908836365,
-0.32360944151878357,
0.5007694363594055,
0.13331542909145355,
-0.8118820786476135,
0.259781152009964,
0.4270981550216675,
-0.43168532848358154,
-0.7468128204345703,
-0.25211530923843384,
0.22742734849452972,
-0.3730011284351349,
-0.40448176860809326,
0.5263286232948303,
-0.10600817203521729,
-0.007158082444220781,
0.539655864238739,
0.19181662797927856,
-0.2553776800632477,
-0.1460554152727127,
0.29819488525390625,
0.4959392547607422,
-0.20011189579963684,
0.09394237399101257,
-0.01969054713845253,
-0.25256118178367615,
0.15543541312217712,
-0.6235267519950867,
0.5250663161277771,
0.09618808329105377,
-0.4020015001296997,
-0.4911684989929199,
0.704974889755249,
0.6119515299797058,
-0.48367562890052795,
0.7304447293281555,
0.907461404800415,
-0.3972253203392029,
0.11538970470428467,
-0.5450068116188049,
0.29634854197502136,
-0.47783613204956055,
0.17739874124526978,
-0.08217623829841614,
-0.7192018032073975,
0.321347713470459,
-0.1399545967578888,
-0.26107293367385864,
0.7736358046531677,
0.4035957157611847,
-0.39228355884552,
0.38215744495391846,
0.6069134473800659,
-0.5270411968231201,
0.22168861329555511,
0.1109694093465805,
0.5841361880302429,
-0.6333977580070496,
-0.2862046957015991,
-0.8022539019584656,
-0.5894685387611389,
-0.8580204844474792,
-0.49209171533584595,
0.4469112753868103,
0.19403451681137085,
-0.38669514656066895,
0.4150162935256958,
-0.37016674876213074,
0.7444767951965332,
0.8200578093528748,
0.013210182078182697,
0.1937197595834732,
0.48049184679985046,
-0.34865114092826843,
0.05231822654604912,
-0.38947445154190063,
-0.2716746926307678,
0.7796232104301453,
-0.1691615879535675,
0.5269951820373535,
0.35079634189605713,
0.48170411586761475,
0.3456241190433502,
0.23532254993915558,
-0.5945093631744385,
0.42622247338294983,
-0.015812180936336517,
-0.6387059092521667,
-0.7234269380569458,
-0.24961628019809723,
-0.7319669127464294,
0.0008189249783754349,
-0.3700040578842163,
-0.659234881401062,
0.010690026916563511,
-0.17370404303073883,
-0.47731828689575195,
0.4598334729671478,
-0.5482260584831238,
0.6785505414009094,
-0.08766341954469681,
-0.576303243637085,
-0.01848851889371872,
-0.6870598793029785,
-0.19539055228233337,
-0.034292127937078476,
0.3350464105606079,
-0.11387456953525543,
0.19958168268203735,
0.306455135345459,
-0.3693115711212158,
0.5272552967071533,
-0.46643728017807007,
-0.318819522857666,
0.5600235462188721,
-0.0428667813539505,
0.3184061050415039,
0.28153669834136963,
-0.07579849660396576,
0.5534434914588928,
-0.2748149633407593,
-0.35932040214538574,
-0.5730540752410889,
1.1852339506149292,
-0.5467285513877869,
-0.3914676308631897,
-0.1734391748905182,
-0.6438345313072205,
-0.21261657774448395,
0.4731684923171997,
0.24482546746730804,
0.3644047975540161,
-0.1304854154586792,
-0.09186886250972748,
0.4307277202606201,
-0.38050487637519836,
0.6576279997825623,
0.38258013129234314,
0.06538048386573792,
-0.39246803522109985,
0.6696334481239319,
-0.07597151398658752,
-0.3165837526321411,
0.5358870625495911,
0.20644539594650269,
-0.8106896281242371,
-0.17566347122192383,
-0.5965561866760254,
0.17098850011825562,
-0.5418254733085632,
-0.46144697070121765,
-0.43402090668678284,
-0.03322355076670647,
-0.40442585945129395,
-0.598254919052124,
-0.0963234156370163,
-0.36808496713638306,
0.28966766595840454,
-0.1308719366788864,
0.21528874337673187,
0.49040454626083374,
-0.29867035150527954,
0.05193502455949783,
-0.7576135396957397,
0.47136804461479187,
0.14143583178520203,
0.38026681542396545,
0.04383419454097748,
0.1544753611087799,
-0.5892583727836609,
0.1619231253862381,
-0.12189577519893646,
-0.8175236582756042,
0.15752802789211273,
-0.2541483938694,
0.2405449002981186,
0.4218041002750397,
0.2226439118385315,
0.9649344682693481,
-1.1315066814422607,
0.8649026155471802,
0.28199470043182373,
-0.7431371212005615,
0.5071336627006531,
-0.2814509868621826,
0.27641916275024414,
0.36065587401390076,
0.6556156277656555,
-0.5118458271026611,
-0.40815603733062744,
-0.45379066467285156,
-0.744226336479187,
0.20206302404403687,
-0.07743410021066666,
0.1137714758515358,
-0.3165241479873657,
0.3890030086040497,
-0.22229480743408203,
-0.14701808989048004,
-0.4285160303115845,
-0.43081915378570557,
0.046971432864665985,
-0.2247614860534668,
-0.0959865003824234,
-0.48940637707710266,
-0.30360567569732666,
-0.35757339000701904,
0.4542151093482971,
0.002351621864363551,
0.09188225865364075,
0.5039687156677246,
-0.4081893265247345,
-0.15759128332138062,
0.19818539917469025,
0.3592325747013092,
0.851446807384491,
-0.12358387559652328,
0.48806947469711304,
0.4041289985179901,
-0.44533389806747437,
0.07460764050483704,
0.5422621369361877,
-0.4096897840499878,
0.4578903019428253,
0.20664657652378082,
0.11285389959812164,
0.2969515919685364,
-0.543479323387146,
0.4862009584903717,
0.4110567271709442,
0.49267420172691345,
-0.3636969327926636,
-0.2679276466369629,
0.3737105429172516,
0.3773183226585388,
0.43854063749313354,
-0.1829470694065094,
0.2140687257051468,
-0.1784147173166275,
0.1200423538684845,
0.23214282095432281,
-0.16858918964862823,
-0.06620310246944427,
0.7201957702636719,
-0.05007707327604294,
-0.11866100877523422,
0.8211319446563721,
-0.44722965359687805,
-0.6038692593574524,
0.37171441316604614,
0.5702522993087769,
0.5649497509002686,
-0.35284170508384705,
0.2894568145275116,
0.8124815821647644,
0.10551178455352783,
0.24099677801132202,
-0.10939374566078186,
-0.12470585852861404,
-0.36657893657684326,
-0.4388381838798523,
-0.9932599663734436,
-0.2541011869907379,
-0.2634791135787964,
-0.6201843023300171,
0.4005293846130371,
-0.2243848443031311,
-0.11438123136758804,
0.12950736284255981,
-0.1716582477092743,
-0.6181395053863525,
0.2486572265625,
0.3382718861103058,
0.8145440816879272,
-0.6653664112091064,
0.7303579449653625,
0.8899635672569275,
-0.041468847543001175,
-0.49635663628578186,
0.21028602123260498,
-0.1270664483308792,
-0.23858346045017242,
0.6645472049713135,
-0.04918069392442703,
-0.26728013157844543,
-0.18858864903450012,
-0.5367183089256287,
-1.0384621620178223,
1.0070185661315918,
0.19422000646591187,
-0.346262663602829,
-0.28483831882476807,
0.5503559112548828,
0.5461698770523071,
0.029548121616244316,
-0.0850725919008255,
0.062014129012823105,
0.49421438574790955,
-0.3430951237678528,
-1.0456799268722534,
0.20956161618232727,
0.22665749490261078,
-0.09991265833377838,
0.4122586250305176,
-0.39211222529411316,
0.6490744352340698,
-0.4137667417526245,
-0.02502148412168026,
0.16381557285785675,
0.6783736944198608,
0.003389206249266863,
0.1796901822090149,
0.4630696475505829,
0.7576746940612793,
0.9435364603996277,
0.05399215966463089,
0.8978057503700256,
-0.5136941075325012,
0.9073961973190308,
1.299344778060913,
-0.1001378670334816,
1.2082264423370361,
0.35401833057403564,
-0.21368929743766785,
0.6999639868736267,
0.34659212827682495,
-0.21832087635993958,
0.6006501913070679,
-0.03914801403880119,
-0.6526170969009399,
0.08238321542739868,
-0.2563384771347046,
-0.43632519245147705,
0.5309346318244934,
0.36841148138046265,
-0.2381725311279297,
-1.0655601024627686,
-0.09337624907493591,
0.16838815808296204,
-0.046423908323049545,
-0.21529141068458557,
0.3613070249557495,
-0.40481382608413696,
-0.5224003791809082,
0.252776563167572,
0.34760338068008423,
0.3094053268432617,
-0.7668859958648682,
0.09993287920951843,
-0.08017945289611816,
-0.28299471735954285,
-0.3296715021133423,
-0.8614988327026367,
0.4394523799419403,
0.4575362801551819,
-0.3878021240234375,
-0.027915097773075104,
0.6831310987472534,
-0.5525270700454712,
-0.558416485786438,
0.04940217733383179,
0.3116165101528168,
0.11589010804891586,
-0.17543469369411469,
-0.22780169546604156,
-0.21838729083538055,
-0.14011737704277039,
0.00929920095950365,
0.17417484521865845,
0.8322601914405823,
-0.16090275347232819,
0.22379735112190247,
1.1589957475662231,
0.11477579176425934,
-0.005555758718401194,
-0.34964287281036377,
0.766543447971344,
-0.9829790592193604,
-0.7625858783721924,
-0.9407618045806885,
0.2015102505683899,
-0.3335454761981964,
-0.16384100914001465,
0.7677884697914124,
1.061868667602539,
0.7493438124656677,
-0.11725059896707535,
0.7164809107780457,
-0.46058666706085205,
0.33911675214767456,
-0.12871292233467102,
0.7740812301635742,
-0.22983577847480774,
-0.24303963780403137,
-0.28458255529403687,
-1.2328314781188965,
-0.31204795837402344,
0.6491583585739136,
-0.34905222058296204,
-0.5222182273864746,
0.8743657469749451,
0.5866086483001709,
-0.30645713210105896,
-0.13228203356266022,
0.2598223090171814,
-0.1162460520863533,
0.11851734668016434,
0.3539760708808899,
0.709930419921875,
-0.016877273097634315,
0.6414918899536133,
-0.69955974817276,
-0.030226193368434906,
-0.06201242655515671,
-1.0127074718475342,
-0.309491902589798,
-0.6738216280937195,
-0.12335864454507828,
-0.34484320878982544,
-0.27262210845947266,
0.6693623065948486,
0.5293217897415161,
-0.5725629329681396,
0.09855999797582626,
0.5058915615081787,
0.382510781288147,
0.1293894350528717,
-0.2525581419467926,
1.0033303499221802,
-0.37832900881767273,
-1.0545521974563599,
0.3054161071777344,
0.37764012813568115,
-0.23818127810955048,
-0.34709879755973816,
0.26847875118255615,
-0.2573091983795166,
-0.6258992552757263,
0.8213474154472351,
0.23876459896564484,
-0.4568244516849518,
-0.5190668702125549,
-0.17318940162658691,
-0.28208065032958984,
-0.13715022802352905,
0.6884649991989136,
-0.666269063949585,
0.384947270154953,
0.4087604582309723,
0.49200329184532166,
0.2229955792427063,
0.4524604380130768,
0.01603292115032673,
-0.7731085419654846,
0.28905022144317627,
-0.29567068815231323,
0.3383331298828125,
0.5082157254219055,
-0.536251425743103,
0.19525544345378876,
0.26835981011390686,
-0.38955581188201904,
-0.23972930014133453,
-0.0012664794921875,
-0.8578686118125916,
-0.1460701823234558,
1.1576173305511475,
-0.20583361387252808,
-0.32400888204574585,
0.007424982264637947,
-0.10433295369148254,
0.2150958776473999,
-0.21179631352424622,
1.0218982696533203,
0.7614590525627136,
0.15486064553260803,
0.5663892030715942,
-0.5975584983825684,
0.4141741693019867,
-0.009782310575246811,
-0.711557149887085,
-0.08863800764083862,
0.9336260557174683,
0.4167273938655853,
0.8105015158653259,
0.1824987530708313,
-0.060347072780132294,
0.11342672258615494,
-0.06646940112113953,
-0.01798679307103157,
0.019794775173068047,
-0.31636640429496765,
0.25135982036590576,
0.6181836128234863,
-0.1880682408809662,
-0.3011186420917511
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16463v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16463v1
|
Few-shot Named Entity Recognition via Superposition Concept Discrimination
| 2024-03-25T06:45:09 | 2024-03-25T06:45:09 |
Jiawei Chen, Hongyu Lin, Xianpei Han, Yaojie Lu, Shanshan Jiang, Bin Dong, Le Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Few-shot NER aims to identify entities of target types with only limited
number of illustrative instances. Unfortunately, few-shot NER is severely
challenged by the intrinsic precise generalization problem, i.e., it is hard to
accurately determine the desired target type due to the ambiguity stemming from
information deficiency. In this paper, we propose Superposition Concept
Discriminator (SuperCD), which resolves the above challenge via an active
learning paradigm. Specifically, a concept extractor is first introduced to
identify superposition concepts from illustrative instances, with each concept
corresponding to a possible generalization boundary. Then a superposition
instance retriever is applied to retrieve corresponding instances of these
superposition concepts from large-scale text corpus. Finally, annotators are
asked to annotate the retrieved instances and these annotated instances
together with original illustrative instances are used to learn FS-NER models.
To this end, we learn a universal concept extractor and superposition instance
retriever using a large-scale openly available knowledge bases. Experiments
show that SuperCD can effectively identify superposition concepts from
illustrative instances, retrieve superposition instances from large-scale
corpus, and significantly improve the few-shot NER performance with minimal
additional efforts.
|
[
-0.2846018970012665,
-0.934727132320404,
0.5666351914405823,
-0.374024897813797,
-0.1531553864479065,
0.14125314354896545,
0.046756379306316376,
-0.6425255537033081,
0.2577561140060425,
0.31244075298309326,
-0.17093771696090698,
-0.11338653415441513,
-0.6714909672737122,
0.24396201968193054,
-0.4395156502723694,
0.9899418354034424,
0.06754888594150543,
-0.08746612817049026,
-0.09762484580278397,
0.18734169006347656,
-0.07388283312320709,
-0.21363942325115204,
-0.5630234479904175,
-0.2926566004753113,
0.2918936014175415,
0.41333863139152527,
0.3930661082267761,
0.47807955741882324,
0.6877278089523315,
0.3651695251464844,
-0.39914169907569885,
0.2914436161518097,
-0.3574303984642029,
0.0847453847527504,
-0.2135574221611023,
-0.6590587496757507,
-0.005471126176416874,
-0.41306790709495544,
0.6789771318435669,
0.10278815776109695,
-0.023126810789108276,
-0.08858432620763779,
-0.25870418548583984,
0.38706842064857483,
-1.1295658349990845,
0.24476507306098938,
-0.7937124371528625,
0.17615371942520142,
-0.39571014046669006,
0.04633844271302223,
-0.2792603373527527,
-0.03043670393526554,
0.4084453284740448,
-1.070984959602356,
0.6272490620613098,
-0.2415674775838852,
1.0969291925430298,
0.27023908495903015,
-0.2451937049627304,
-0.17950840294361115,
-0.906426191329956,
0.6948427557945251,
-0.23564068973064423,
0.3663029968738556,
0.2448515146970749,
0.6344457268714905,
-0.12923486530780792,
-0.5117213129997253,
-1.0819047689437866,
0.30975204706192017,
0.014978193677961826,
0.06884492933750153,
-0.4576161205768585,
-0.1459183692932129,
0.44033747911453247,
0.24486970901489258,
-0.3279428780078888,
0.040389638394117355,
-0.3107036054134369,
-0.289628267288208,
0.49922406673431396,
0.10106054693460464,
0.07897178828716278,
-0.3088615834712982,
-0.2687877416610718,
0.16332340240478516,
-0.5218749642372131,
-0.409202516078949,
0.01683768443763256,
0.3202633261680603,
0.07527242600917816,
0.4741430878639221,
-0.2549220025539398,
0.7741532325744629,
0.5198495984077454,
-0.3920576870441437,
0.23186859488487244,
-0.14968498051166534,
-0.20720040798187256,
0.21848855912685394,
0.45563504099845886,
-0.07790198177099228,
0.07873187959194183,
-0.022184036672115326,
-0.3441081643104553,
0.21999485790729523,
0.17859263718128204,
-0.7483121156692505,
-0.19903427362442017,
-0.01055109966546297,
-0.13827106356620789,
-0.013609915971755981,
0.06467200070619583,
-0.7392144203186035,
-0.533133864402771,
-0.22833676636219025,
0.5663384795188904,
-0.6019535660743713,
-0.28056371212005615,
-0.19228076934814453,
-0.21703648567199707,
0.19197557866573334,
0.2908397912979126,
-0.8864059448242188,
0.11751296371221542,
0.658244788646698,
0.8042919039726257,
-0.30759483575820923,
-0.04616793990135193,
-0.5083467364311218,
0.5891367197036743,
-0.1926044523715973,
1.275211215019226,
-0.7584546804428101,
-0.26117780804634094,
-0.2860773801803589,
-0.11903919279575348,
0.07931457459926605,
-0.593605101108551,
0.11503469944000244,
-0.7995675206184387,
-0.26446571946144104,
0.11798007041215897,
-1.0134412050247192,
-0.2894752025604248,
0.3473016023635864,
-0.7996541261672974,
0.7778646349906921,
-0.08395271003246307,
-1.0180556774139404,
0.7666959762573242,
-0.460541307926178,
-0.38282105326652527,
0.5665684938430786,
-0.6191350817680359,
-0.5965048670768738,
0.2234382927417755,
0.06514215469360352,
0.604229211807251,
-0.08323585987091064,
0.01619691587984562,
0.05858225375413895,
-0.42684629559516907,
0.11520441621541977,
-0.06527549773454666,
0.38271576166152954,
0.059337861835956573,
-0.2989983558654785,
-0.0293898768723011,
-1.099551796913147,
-0.24246014654636383,
0.2736731469631195,
-0.2555318772792816,
-0.7626384496688843,
-0.20687156915664673,
0.2075541913509369,
0.1933290660381317,
0.015583154745399952,
-0.7390878200531006,
0.265261173248291,
-0.26066669821739197,
0.2703726291656494,
0.578298032283783,
0.374956339597702,
0.5931665301322937,
-0.045584142208099365,
0.5503152012825012,
0.2779465317726135,
-0.2437472641468048,
0.044018588960170746,
-0.21694457530975342,
-0.7141116857528687,
-0.7014675140380859,
0.4550640285015106,
0.555996835231781,
-1.109073519706726,
0.4598022699356079,
-0.22235175967216492,
-0.5120239853858948,
-0.20907898247241974,
0.16015857458114624,
0.5468645691871643,
0.22272062301635742,
0.604759156703949,
-0.1167958602309227,
-0.6625321507453918,
-0.7228900790214539,
0.19181451201438904,
-0.1280323714017868,
0.13837574422359467,
0.19857904314994812,
0.8017982244491577,
-0.11336257308721542,
1.2215936183929443,
-0.8343474268913269,
-0.7920475006103516,
-0.5126208066940308,
0.21955503523349762,
0.12461742758750916,
0.4152456223964691,
0.17946548759937286,
-0.984902024269104,
-0.3880041539669037,
-0.14060641825199127,
-0.7892604470252991,
0.3296773433685303,
-0.30918988585472107,
-0.09717287868261337,
0.021805359050631523,
0.6330855488777161,
-0.6303351521492004,
0.46205633878707886,
-0.034569233655929565,
0.12469206750392914,
0.5435358285903931,
-0.07101878523826599,
-0.4485883414745331,
-0.7739741802215576,
-0.170013889670372,
0.10207948833703995,
0.15895584225654602,
-0.6026020646095276,
0.3370291292667389,
0.23686859011650085,
0.1903332769870758,
-0.866899847984314,
0.5490124821662903,
-0.4888852834701538,
-0.02018488384783268,
-0.29190587997436523,
0.027547288686037064,
-0.17513670027256012,
0.04619188606739044,
0.4798547327518463,
0.6151507496833801,
0.7981851100921631,
-1.064758062362671,
0.15276582539081573,
0.4416135251522064,
-0.4863852560520172,
0.9629418253898621,
-0.4963633716106415,
0.36892828345298767,
-0.40891408920288086,
0.5641140341758728,
-0.7208730578422546,
-0.25668013095855713,
0.013986054807901382,
-0.1541767716407776,
0.5081624388694763,
-0.3529583215713501,
-0.490566223859787,
-0.28003886342048645,
0.09942183643579483,
0.4032460153102875,
-0.21987329423427582,
-0.5660410523414612,
0.7107790112495422,
0.4605022370815277,
0.2588842511177063,
-0.5432062745094299,
-0.8112460374832153,
-0.20756462216377258,
0.024439312517642975,
-0.17567181587219238,
0.628183901309967,
0.10683990269899368,
0.11905807256698608,
-0.049863867461681366,
-0.32902923226356506,
-0.16831691563129425,
-0.11945614218711853,
0.3205985128879547,
0.16407108306884766,
-0.18524466454982758,
0.2529354393482208,
0.019987815991044044,
-0.5736428499221802,
-0.4951170086860657,
-0.19350628554821014,
0.2967168390750885,
0.19398832321166992,
-0.2918311655521393,
-0.6223475933074951,
0.24417555332183838,
0.19808168709278107,
-0.30773451924324036,
0.5453434586524963,
0.48046520352363586,
-0.7742024660110474,
-0.2841741144657135,
-0.6256740093231201,
-0.08024156093597412,
-0.41031038761138916,
0.2529556155204773,
-0.7379832863807678,
-0.900098443031311,
0.2480023354291916,
0.007239644881337881,
-0.12777699530124664,
0.3689565360546112,
0.22867730259895325,
0.3048118054866791,
0.970608651638031,
0.5895243883132935,
-0.08766759932041168,
0.5727046728134155,
-0.8484857082366943,
0.06606678664684296,
-0.8165215253829956,
-0.053184859454631805,
-0.3100542426109314,
-0.42819133400917053,
-0.3045898973941803,
-0.3597373068332672,
0.2502397894859314,
0.2769675552845001,
-0.07900923490524292,
0.5044332146644592,
-0.5234495997428894,
0.9890807271003723,
0.5726630687713623,
0.20753221213817596,
0.4022809863090515,
-0.0844537615776062,
-0.45481622219085693,
-0.20593993365764618,
-0.3542267382144928,
-0.4705878496170044,
0.9976776242256165,
-0.023913966491818428,
0.6647027730941772,
0.2770446538925171,
1.2366670370101929,
-0.011113161221146584,
0.17822465300559998,
-1.1094061136245728,
0.7715132832527161,
-0.37964296340942383,
-1.087935447692871,
-0.24270392954349518,
-0.3732680380344391,
-0.8819613456726074,
0.09622633457183838,
-0.5687642097473145,
-0.7000700235366821,
0.5089585185050964,
-0.19663101434707642,
-0.8186794519424438,
0.17217953503131866,
-0.4760199785232544,
0.5785335898399353,
0.015610352158546448,
-0.28994011878967285,
-0.10823269188404083,
-0.5091615915298462,
0.29121920466423035,
-0.17974214255809784,
0.0593179427087307,
0.11024739593267441,
0.21318477392196655,
0.7481396198272705,
-0.1414557844400406,
0.5834189653396606,
-0.3479789197444916,
0.054626114666461945,
0.2954276502132416,
0.25592195987701416,
0.4486369788646698,
-0.007438142318278551,
-0.17992711067199707,
0.07070833444595337,
-0.33829137682914734,
-0.23566415905952454,
-0.5888983011245728,
0.40435004234313965,
-0.6926628947257996,
-0.48644453287124634,
-0.42784640192985535,
-0.23378854990005493,
0.18542242050170898,
0.5440457463264465,
0.5214815735816956,
0.0906657874584198,
-0.41091302037239075,
0.023332970216870308,
0.6552919149398804,
0.017977934330701828,
0.45809775590896606,
0.8360794186592102,
-0.06416023522615433,
-0.2095821052789688,
1.2424285411834717,
0.34250277280807495,
0.15301373600959778,
0.7694329023361206,
-0.07129725813865662,
-0.1331382542848587,
-0.6236332654953003,
-0.3377833068370819,
0.27082040905952454,
-0.5846346020698547,
-0.7231231927871704,
-0.847116231918335,
-0.33880481123924255,
-0.1739271730184555,
-0.2824573516845703,
-0.3418148159980774,
-0.46009933948516846,
-0.5797038674354553,
-0.4717543125152588,
0.30909913778305054,
0.492110937833786,
-0.18908534944057465,
0.5555891990661621,
-0.6868922710418701,
0.9516627788543701,
0.7313901782035828,
-0.06858225911855698,
-0.09269485622644424,
-0.41549545526504517,
-0.014085326343774796,
-0.27041733264923096,
-0.5778231024742126,
-0.6823841333389282,
0.11586842685937881,
0.500636637210846,
0.6494914293289185,
0.9865727424621582,
0.04330760985612869,
0.7022256255149841,
-0.5168147683143616,
0.5006284713745117,
0.26199156045913696,
-1.0317403078079224,
0.7745481133460999,
0.1883092075586319,
0.1346050649881363,
0.6169992685317993,
0.5169149041175842,
-0.12684309482574463,
-0.34896138310432434,
-0.7420815825462341,
-0.7477749586105347,
0.893774688243866,
0.14434970915317535,
-0.08711957186460495,
-0.4586808681488037,
0.1362730860710144,
0.18264837563037872,
-0.318340927362442,
-0.44977572560310364,
-0.37475651502609253,
0.024314021691679955,
0.051790978759527206,
0.11939448863267899,
-0.06469101458787918,
0.08190246671438217,
-0.013813434168696404,
0.8511289358139038,
-0.1856423318386078,
0.37652620673179626,
0.1871868520975113,
-0.5730769634246826,
-0.24323433637619019,
0.4641954302787781,
0.21935823559761047,
0.41447949409484863,
-0.11358077079057693,
0.5167454481124878,
0.07907702028751373,
-0.5191142559051514,
0.4408833384513855,
0.34406721591949463,
-0.693433403968811,
0.1693270057439804,
0.2809140384197235,
0.5435603857040405,
0.29576390981674194,
-0.3314686119556427,
0.6228405237197876,
0.17676737904548645,
-0.04339400678873062,
-0.04506358131766319,
0.45141083002090454,
-0.045700110495090485,
0.5391892194747925,
0.6801406145095825,
0.0034810935612767935,
0.23555748164653778,
-0.3109642267227173,
0.5095961093902588,
0.40643182396888733,
-0.5206904411315918,
-0.18780042231082916,
0.6904305219650269,
0.10297049582004547,
-0.14410410821437836,
0.49215981364250183,
-0.6611074209213257,
-0.702944278717041,
0.7669351100921631,
0.8878859877586365,
0.7286917567253113,
-0.4207773506641388,
0.4661306142807007,
0.3493439257144928,
-0.08055758476257324,
-0.3741942048072815,
0.3440065383911133,
-0.14202070236206055,
-1.2590086460113525,
-0.23315516114234924,
-0.5178804397583008,
-0.42420533299446106,
0.06456545740365982,
-0.5890401601791382,
0.5291811227798462,
-0.8358563184738159,
-0.22389021515846252,
0.6978247761726379,
0.01627674326300621,
-0.7512066960334778,
0.1918758600950241,
0.3711000978946686,
0.6289717555046082,
-0.7520970702171326,
0.7935699820518494,
1.0290199518203735,
-0.7725514769554138,
-0.5734160542488098,
0.0010111004812642932,
0.3483915328979492,
-0.6193065643310547,
0.9129676818847656,
0.284106969833374,
-0.1199384480714798,
0.3747935891151428,
-0.6662036776542664,
-0.6706512570381165,
1.0509097576141357,
0.23650117218494415,
-0.6680183410644531,
0.0740058496594429,
-0.19033512473106384,
0.48972088098526,
-0.3521176278591156,
0.5133357644081116,
0.5492655634880066,
0.38932397961616516,
0.3275410830974579,
-0.6281350255012512,
0.021094778552651405,
0.033111218363046646,
-0.008458568714559078,
0.37245771288871765,
-0.5480082631111145,
0.574923038482666,
-0.5498960018157959,
-0.41247981786727905,
-0.14928364753723145,
0.9631953239440918,
0.67606520652771,
0.4601065516471863,
0.6842617988586426,
0.7361862063407898,
0.658204972743988,
0.17900776863098145,
0.5461813807487488,
0.09858240187168121,
0.4731040894985199,
1.1147726774215698,
-0.48867279291152954,
0.9331226348876953,
0.3425918221473694,
-0.3221699893474579,
0.4588492512702942,
0.10888557136058807,
-0.0794922336935997,
0.7156716585159302,
0.2533274292945862,
-0.4351631999015808,
-0.446039080619812,
-0.21417856216430664,
-0.39053091406822205,
0.74679034948349,
0.7983936071395874,
-0.26117831468582153,
-0.2203255444765091,
-0.047471415251493454,
-0.24892933666706085,
-0.2884041368961334,
-0.23492467403411865,
1.1122747659683228,
-0.03898525610566139,
-0.02997569739818573,
0.5236782431602478,
-0.026287125423550606,
0.9762812852859497,
-0.446037232875824,
-0.312787264585495,
-0.13060566782951355,
0.3398433327674866,
-0.502364993095398,
-0.480576753616333,
0.056349121034145355,
0.012880967929959297,
-0.25366538763046265,
0.24276097118854523,
0.7940250635147095,
-0.20932632684707642,
-0.5740375518798828,
0.1518060266971588,
0.368617981672287,
0.22640268504619598,
-0.20943328738212585,
-0.5387985706329346,
-0.34013184905052185,
-0.2785731554031372,
-0.009865518659353256,
0.18167611956596375,
0.7175562381744385,
-0.04738135263323784,
0.38739052414894104,
0.6541563868522644,
0.040080197155475616,
-0.08168799430131912,
0.009799305349588394,
0.8271937370300293,
-0.777880847454071,
-0.6455439329147339,
-0.6260011196136475,
0.17322227358818054,
0.13990285992622375,
-0.4074142873287201,
0.4215323328971863,
0.7879974842071533,
0.921237587928772,
-0.11625266075134277,
0.7832820415496826,
-0.2418360412120819,
0.6720623970031738,
-0.4309743344783783,
0.4821438193321228,
-0.34711530804634094,
0.20707792043685913,
-0.8286441564559937,
-1.1577945947647095,
-0.773220419883728,
1.0552083253860474,
-0.28965944051742554,
-0.44955727458000183,
0.5679739117622375,
0.7848000526428223,
-0.4111331105232239,
0.11734234541654587,
0.2729067802429199,
0.35797014832496643,
0.26027148962020874,
0.6213647723197937,
1.057446837425232,
-0.37640735507011414,
0.7313860654830933,
-0.3115242123603821,
-0.1618395745754242,
-0.37133678793907166,
-0.7359843254089355,
-0.4895654618740082,
-0.24771982431411743,
-0.7805263996124268,
0.005194404628127813,
0.06650488078594208,
0.8073514103889465,
0.792240560054779,
-1.185512661933899,
0.2856646180152893,
-0.44898706674575806,
0.5191791653633118,
-0.42357680201530457,
-0.3233225643634796,
0.39879342913627625,
0.14387531578540802,
-0.6728019118309021,
0.4730963408946991,
0.32798561453819275,
0.06783567368984222,
0.04702594131231308,
0.06937708705663681,
-0.5294569730758667,
-0.2131708264350891,
0.40302804112434387,
0.4180293679237366,
-0.5555247664451599,
-0.4484424591064453,
-0.16146130859851837,
-0.016997922211885452,
-0.10604192316532135,
0.8488200306892395,
-0.9653944373130798,
0.5751596689224243,
0.5100436210632324,
0.7548328042030334,
0.6505781412124634,
-0.1771666556596756,
-0.09823259711265564,
-0.7981820106506348,
-0.017657505348324776,
0.07369591295719147,
0.2951471209526062,
0.1621631383895874,
-0.36174219846725464,
0.49805694818496704,
0.5102585554122925,
-0.18927311897277832,
-0.5188058018684387,
0.253478080034256,
-0.8581106662750244,
-0.20415830612182617,
1.1355496644973755,
-0.29582589864730835,
0.1080937460064888,
-0.5749881863594055,
-0.23592481017112732,
0.369198739528656,
-0.6117101311683655,
0.7135818600654602,
0.5275822281837463,
-0.3512429893016815,
-0.17339470982551575,
-0.024209965020418167,
0.05089954659342766,
0.15135732293128967,
-0.7337571978569031,
-0.18152771890163422,
0.6231923699378967,
0.1427682489156723,
0.702820897102356,
0.5188207626342773,
0.1620911806821823,
0.2616094648838043,
-0.06129010394215584,
0.13533365726470947,
0.062028102576732635,
-0.5897155404090881,
-0.20193831622600555,
0.13994653522968292,
-0.4254186749458313,
-0.32782912254333496
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16447v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16447v1
|
A Study on How Attention Scores in the BERT Model are Aware of Lexical Categories in Syntactic and Semantic Tasks on the GLUE Benchmark
| 2024-03-25T06:18:18 | 2024-03-25T06:18:18 |
Dongjun Jang, Sungjoo Byun, Hyopil Shin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This study examines whether the attention scores between tokens in the BERT
model significantly vary based on lexical categories during the fine-tuning
process for downstream tasks. Drawing inspiration from the notion that in human
language processing, syntactic and semantic information is parsed differently,
we categorize tokens in sentences according to their lexical categories and
focus on changes in attention scores among these categories. Our hypothesis
posits that in downstream tasks that prioritize semantic information, attention
scores centered on content words are enhanced, while in cases emphasizing
syntactic information, attention scores centered on function words are
intensified. Through experimentation conducted on six tasks from the GLUE
benchmark dataset, we substantiate our hypothesis regarding the fine-tuning
process. Furthermore, our additional investigations reveal the presence of BERT
layers that consistently assign more bias to specific lexical categories,
irrespective of the task, highlighting the existence of task-agnostic lexical
category preferences.
|
[
-0.44057103991508484,
-0.9312106966972351,
0.48928186297416687,
0.23133584856987,
-0.05453061684966087,
-0.21180196106433868,
-0.483562171459198,
-0.6019644141197205,
0.28804147243499756,
0.14457203447818756,
-0.6076479554176331,
-0.3009275794029236,
-0.8385515213012695,
-0.06480856984853745,
-0.2493128925561905,
1.2835220098495483,
0.14909474551677704,
-0.15563932061195374,
-0.25886863470077515,
0.017430204898118973,
-0.5775030255317688,
-0.45298975706100464,
-0.35966840386390686,
-0.05199120193719864,
0.9923646450042725,
0.21149353682994843,
0.9074121713638306,
0.8445743322372437,
0.9355026483535767,
0.20429161190986633,
-0.2567196488380432,
-0.19092462956905365,
-0.4221799075603485,
0.07285619527101517,
-0.662128210067749,
-0.7737405300140381,
-0.22058488428592682,
0.05618888884782791,
0.5896731615066528,
0.9130725264549255,
0.14971323311328888,
0.7115339040756226,
0.3446981608867645,
0.7273524403572083,
-0.8222134709358215,
0.32153090834617615,
-0.9947778582572937,
-0.3317866027355194,
-0.2500508725643158,
-0.13219620287418365,
-0.44764411449432373,
0.0695481076836586,
0.4956989288330078,
-0.400391548871994,
0.7173087000846863,
0.08852101117372513,
1.0613515377044678,
0.6654406785964966,
-0.13362406194210052,
-0.13213667273521423,
-0.4176386892795563,
0.9337524175643921,
-0.3908427655696869,
0.299599826335907,
0.3120974600315094,
-0.2545492649078369,
-0.05779290199279785,
-0.5510067939758301,
-0.03899085149168968,
-0.07150356471538544,
0.06583330035209656,
-0.0068572284653782845,
-0.0959494560956955,
0.167448490858078,
0.28357401490211487,
0.25499799847602844,
-0.3769078850746155,
-0.12690693140029907,
-0.2467576116323471,
-0.31229761242866516,
0.34220626950263977,
0.09957369416952133,
0.19941313564777374,
-0.0013369092484936118,
-0.5832992792129517,
-0.21617119014263153,
-0.2954913079738617,
0.3872658908367157,
0.1815965473651886,
0.6161397695541382,
0.19927042722702026,
0.6417714357376099,
-0.23211771249771118,
0.9744166135787964,
0.3085579574108124,
0.1833661049604416,
0.10198082029819489,
-0.37266767024993896,
-0.46794965863227844,
0.4017702341079712,
0.18604548275470734,
0.350728303194046,
0.3148192763328552,
-0.2812737822532654,
-0.05971287190914154,
0.5080386400222778,
0.7467370629310608,
-0.23172792792320251,
-0.3172665536403656,
0.15284347534179688,
-0.4533140957355499,
0.07024956494569778,
-0.12291224300861359,
-0.10337914526462555,
-0.18062129616737366,
-0.6553741693496704,
0.6846683025360107,
-0.43185415863990784,
0.1307649463415146,
0.09149345755577087,
-0.27170467376708984,
0.18878886103630066,
0.404606431722641,
-1.1473997831344604,
0.33278220891952515,
0.8943284153938293,
0.5125336050987244,
-0.29000481963157654,
-0.28272780776023865,
-0.5098350048065186,
0.19171108305454254,
-0.3318997323513031,
1.1299090385437012,
-0.7535812854766846,
0.3199673593044281,
-0.22938336431980133,
0.13124901056289673,
-0.5945323705673218,
-0.5770169496536255,
0.4233890771865845,
-0.3974204957485199,
-0.15647675096988678,
-0.6823312640190125,
-0.8057557344436646,
-0.2728176414966583,
0.05530862510204315,
-0.4984615743160248,
1.0906299352645874,
0.1075097918510437,
-0.8660882711410522,
0.8811877369880676,
-0.2847754955291748,
-0.4233821928501129,
-0.11096162348985672,
0.11639060825109482,
0.15776389837265015,
0.5188784599304199,
0.0026503887493163347,
0.527895987033844,
-0.09800202399492264,
0.18362540006637573,
-0.3980483114719391,
-0.3602456748485565,
0.20365409553050995,
0.1340261697769165,
0.35434645414352417,
0.0015486708143725991,
-0.38873642683029175,
0.26942792534828186,
-0.42014655470848083,
0.13187938928604126,
-0.30184444785118103,
-0.4414161741733551,
-0.5235631465911865,
0.21368861198425293,
-0.05557621270418167,
0.3121148347854614,
0.5391331315040588,
-0.7278688549995422,
0.1893669068813324,
-0.46279025077819824,
0.19170887768268585,
0.870469868183136,
0.037174880504608154,
0.3117344379425049,
-0.4410337507724762,
-0.0773746520280838,
0.10368955880403519,
0.11467146873474121,
0.06848513334989548,
-0.7894189357757568,
-1.0925393104553223,
-0.14910659193992615,
0.5102381110191345,
0.22629861533641815,
-0.06070737913250923,
0.4937427043914795,
-0.05127590149641037,
-0.3400227725505829,
-0.9572252631187439,
0.19808641076087952,
0.38641828298568726,
0.3822454512119293,
0.22098520398139954,
-0.6227778792381287,
-0.11865721642971039,
-1.3064908981323242,
-0.4710371494293213,
-0.04471712186932564,
0.06599561870098114,
0.4347309172153473,
0.2208981066942215,
0.21961195766925812,
1.083378553390503,
-0.6705819964408875,
-0.6861270070075989,
-0.11179905384778976,
0.28882211446762085,
0.25882425904273987,
0.2640745937824249,
0.5496020317077637,
-0.6272748708724976,
-0.48881977796554565,
-0.19761595129966736,
-0.020466774702072144,
-0.06252500414848328,
-0.16985735297203064,
-0.3714309632778168,
0.3865525722503662,
0.47987857460975647,
-0.4340578019618988,
0.30853205919265747,
0.2846209704875946,
-0.6438151597976685,
0.2823886275291443,
-0.17547672986984253,
-0.20931316912174225,
-0.6295133233070374,
0.1716492474079132,
-0.030753035098314285,
0.03954152390360832,
-0.44798216223716736,
0.17227299511432648,
0.056846559047698975,
0.3301195204257965,
-0.40934431552886963,
0.34734615683555603,
-0.2337784320116043,
-0.4181074798107147,
-0.1314593255519867,
0.1705397665500641,
-0.03145800530910492,
1.000677227973938,
0.11306034028530121,
0.5806649923324585,
0.564624547958374,
-0.6205055117607117,
-0.014933440834283829,
0.0900263711810112,
-0.6227597594261169,
-0.043027788400650024,
-0.6808217763900757,
0.04950420558452606,
-0.2728891968727112,
-0.3243168294429779,
-1.594528317451477,
-0.21830947697162628,
-0.2400057166814804,
-0.4247865676879883,
0.37280407547950745,
0.3335628807544708,
-0.9970259666442871,
-0.06594876199960709,
-0.2327151596546173,
0.05534413829445839,
0.35933151841163635,
-0.1015995442867279,
0.19585846364498138,
0.47741544246673584,
-0.19813232123851776,
-0.3078738749027252,
-0.6017272472381592,
-0.39903298020362854,
-0.014758710749447346,
-0.5197256803512573,
0.422966867685318,
-0.04661823436617851,
-0.09724044799804688,
0.13990157842636108,
-0.4556479752063751,
-0.16326454281806946,
0.21351847052574158,
0.21138250827789307,
0.04923906922340393,
-0.05241016298532486,
0.5338819622993469,
-0.07518184930086136,
0.21143735945224762,
0.2329849749803543,
-0.12395015358924866,
0.5177481770515442,
-0.04565536603331566,
-0.04701539874076843,
-0.05970710143446922,
0.052895545959472656,
0.4025247097015381,
-0.24005037546157837,
0.8029148578643799,
0.7854601740837097,
-0.1361416131258011,
-0.07886138558387756,
-0.7090939879417419,
-0.24453449249267578,
-0.3973635733127594,
0.2465878427028656,
-0.20874419808387756,
-0.9537897706031799,
0.6486947536468506,
0.3021249771118164,
0.08204571902751923,
0.5949913859367371,
0.8611793518066406,
-0.3055010437965393,
1.0623124837875366,
0.6574828028678894,
-0.14750240743160248,
0.5253639817237854,
0.15223811566829681,
0.03592245280742645,
-1.0777515172958374,
0.18928883969783783,
-0.5639119744300842,
-0.8354185819625854,
-0.6674519777297974,
-0.2516719102859497,
0.27741512656211853,
0.06044985353946686,
-0.1990278661251068,
0.4901290833950043,
-0.823054313659668,
0.36309167742729187,
0.7330858111381531,
0.32261770963668823,
-0.08224018663167953,
-0.15351729094982147,
-0.2601128816604614,
-0.17895905673503876,
-0.715913712978363,
-0.15175260603427887,
0.8300251364707947,
0.3911912739276886,
0.6535448431968689,
-0.0025733395013958216,
0.4312055706977844,
0.27831801772117615,
0.00771512882784009,
-0.7951286435127258,
0.5155115723609924,
-0.39967459440231323,
-1.0976303815841675,
-0.29040589928627014,
0.32483530044555664,
-1.0302348136901855,
0.09048891067504883,
0.09684485197067261,
-1.2830957174301147,
0.3136836588382721,
0.04786378890275955,
-0.3892002999782562,
-0.1880783587694168,
-1.1393368244171143,
1.0463223457336426,
0.20162279903888702,
-0.5864461064338684,
-0.5080704092979431,
-0.9173547029495239,
-0.035768602043390274,
-0.1493801474571228,
-0.18056511878967285,
-0.7243524193763733,
-0.10579706728458405,
0.7595072984695435,
0.008359973318874836,
1.134351372718811,
0.01196549367159605,
-0.17992357909679413,
0.33980947732925415,
0.02358429506421089,
0.24326524138450623,
-0.24765588343143463,
0.05955592170357704,
-0.010059494525194168,
-0.07426009327173233,
-0.4041690230369568,
-0.3893502950668335,
0.6738014221191406,
-0.6487033367156982,
-0.8838092088699341,
-0.20746257901191711,
-0.940883219242096,
-0.41069650650024414,
0.1718316227197647,
0.1520724594593048,
0.3517322242259979,
0.4316593110561371,
0.291534960269928,
0.7334102988243103,
-0.009322470985352993,
0.3924899697303772,
0.38280224800109863,
0.35489797592163086,
0.3896229565143585,
0.7331231236457825,
0.233811154961586,
0.5156069993972778,
0.652813196182251,
-0.004713757894933224,
-0.1749448925256729,
-0.06980287283658981,
0.14501047134399414,
0.2260698676109314,
-0.7374194264411926,
-0.06526864320039749,
-0.5407042503356934,
-0.07120371609926224,
-0.31076735258102417,
-0.16891220211982727,
-0.341632217168808,
-0.4741562008857727,
-0.348177969455719,
0.2824094593524933,
0.3424335718154907,
0.4237639307975769,
0.3741966485977173,
-0.14618556201457977,
-0.7154145240783691,
0.21868114173412323,
0.27576664090156555,
0.6322595477104187,
0.17660515010356903,
-0.47023800015449524,
-0.37365058064460754,
-0.17553019523620605,
-0.28559038043022156,
-0.3091343641281128,
0.0003698054060805589,
0.40579450130462646,
0.644326388835907,
0.27770596742630005,
0.06877349317073822,
0.6137174367904663,
-0.4649313986301422,
0.8903999924659729,
-0.1392943263053894,
-0.9740622043609619,
0.7317416667938232,
-0.6380889415740967,
0.914007842540741,
0.6004312038421631,
0.2203376740217209,
-0.10137102752923965,
-1.0135666131973267,
-0.6787784695625305,
-0.6842527389526367,
1.0729514360427856,
0.21373677253723145,
0.054929450154304504,
-0.31937724351882935,
0.060067806392908096,
0.11606114357709885,
0.3060654401779175,
-0.568560779094696,
-0.07309242337942123,
0.3783499598503113,
-0.09355225414037704,
-0.024111920967698097,
-0.2984025180339813,
-0.005912634078413248,
-0.2995714247226715,
0.24598555266857147,
-0.030581345781683922,
0.6071953177452087,
0.4208766222000122,
-0.12437370419502258,
-0.16245950758457184,
0.2774617373943329,
0.5603227019309998,
0.5815332531929016,
-0.5847419500350952,
0.011101970449090004,
-0.03513715788722038,
-0.5442748665809631,
-0.3022461533546448,
-0.15151333808898926,
0.23982135951519012,
0.011264231987297535,
0.687117874622345,
0.9476333856582642,
0.6969109773635864,
-0.6087023019790649,
0.2885873019695282,
0.27143341302871704,
-0.23657667636871338,
0.25315141677856445,
0.6089827418327332,
0.0544220432639122,
0.2720564305782318,
0.09872584789991379,
0.1748511791229248,
0.32177799940109253,
-0.720003604888916,
0.18048398196697235,
0.37856775522232056,
-0.6067860722541809,
-0.24599674344062805,
0.6406165361404419,
-0.060679834336042404,
0.20523200929164886,
0.3342965543270111,
0.08026470243930817,
-0.3073583245277405,
0.8211115598678589,
0.47834843397140503,
0.8102124333381653,
-0.17528976500034332,
-0.18155702948570251,
0.27568596601486206,
0.25070592761039734,
0.2677483856678009,
0.3423532247543335,
-0.3791595697402954,
-0.7381557822227478,
-0.4993993937969208,
-0.8797432780265808,
-0.1437208503484726,
-0.18284709751605988,
-0.9391809701919556,
0.2117861658334732,
-0.2825530469417572,
-0.5817835330963135,
0.6734470129013062,
-0.173939511179924,
-0.7272764444351196,
0.4341067373752594,
0.3970947861671448,
0.9041210412979126,
-0.4786878526210785,
0.8294271230697632,
1.062406301498413,
0.010609281249344349,
-0.8644524216651917,
0.26203447580337524,
-0.2889920175075531,
-0.8219097852706909,
1.0524322986602783,
0.2378227561712265,
0.1927257627248764,
0.05448705703020096,
-0.19077862799167633,
-1.4497692584991455,
0.5812864899635315,
0.330117404460907,
-0.3558155298233032,
-0.29843369126319885,
0.0750717744231224,
0.8178290724754333,
-0.19850300252437592,
-0.014683292247354984,
0.6053361296653748,
0.2895050644874573,
-0.17046518623828888,
-1.2191251516342163,
-0.1072460487484932,
-0.09459954500198364,
0.16128745675086975,
0.5481876134872437,
-0.8108261227607727,
0.8950657844543457,
-0.20185662806034088,
-0.23206007480621338,
-0.2706909477710724,
0.15044483542442322,
-0.14920909702777863,
-0.1538083255290985,
0.5480573773384094,
0.5018093585968018,
0.23414252698421478,
-0.28334254026412964,
1.0985246896743774,
-0.43857982754707336,
0.4950122535228729,
1.092856526374817,
-0.3008686900138855,
0.8550376892089844,
0.5900530815124512,
-0.2647862434387207,
0.500192403793335,
0.6889514327049255,
-0.18450826406478882,
0.9450531005859375,
0.17875465750694275,
0.15539582073688507,
-0.3727721571922302,
-0.5552979707717896,
0.06534359604120255,
0.6506710052490234,
0.494072288274765,
-0.4457733631134033,
-0.34735676646232605,
0.047773782163858414,
-0.31534087657928467,
-0.1921374499797821,
-0.6331896185874939,
1.0692805051803589,
-0.234660804271698,
-1.071378231048584,
0.6424651741981506,
-0.2760652005672455,
0.14569325745105743,
-0.5644558072090149,
0.18469227850437164,
0.3005830943584442,
0.4863240420818329,
-0.09109019488096237,
-1.1549410820007324,
0.3163910508155823,
-0.31151556968688965,
-0.5514691472053528,
-0.061376966536045074,
0.8700082302093506,
-0.39457404613494873,
-0.1997806578874588,
0.3493252694606781,
0.03529463708400726,
-0.051813557744026184,
-0.020844686776399612,
-0.6152975559234619,
0.1515968292951584,
0.029780087992548943,
-0.42977654933929443,
0.5148628950119019,
0.243875190615654,
-0.05756480246782303,
0.5102754235267639,
0.4336298108100891,
-0.04875148832798004,
0.2792811095714569,
0.15008927881717682,
0.802862286567688,
-0.49757739901542664,
-0.6895855665206909,
-0.6869763135910034,
0.4712294936180115,
0.15471439063549042,
-0.5541939735412598,
0.7691904902458191,
0.30807846784591675,
0.8799014687538147,
-0.45119592547416687,
0.3237000107765198,
-0.040309879928827286,
0.7358731031417847,
-0.42676854133605957,
0.459220290184021,
-0.6682776212692261,
-0.22913916409015656,
-0.5688871741294861,
-1.1803996562957764,
-0.20073077082633972,
0.404854953289032,
-0.3457927703857422,
-0.22253048419952393,
0.8690001368522644,
0.3931785225868225,
0.11560574173927307,
-0.14038875699043274,
0.1491674780845642,
0.040751148015260696,
-0.2287779152393341,
0.755072832107544,
0.3434053659439087,
-0.1535925716161728,
0.10271379351615906,
-0.17276382446289062,
0.019417056813836098,
-0.464218407869339,
-0.6541399955749512,
-0.9602888822555542,
-0.7777289748191833,
-0.39314770698547363,
0.10703406482934952,
0.05515068769454956,
0.7977723479270935,
0.6035498380661011,
-0.8620567917823792,
-0.010075349360704422,
-0.16899193823337555,
-0.06382414698600769,
-0.3908178210258484,
-0.3421999216079712,
0.46918076276779175,
-1.249266266822815,
-0.77879798412323,
-0.23198147118091583,
0.5519303679466248,
-0.3476118743419647,
0.1374211311340332,
0.6631225347518921,
-0.5544430613517761,
0.18982282280921936,
0.559511661529541,
-0.26563194394111633,
-1.0794520378112793,
-0.5630452632904053,
0.22211743891239166,
-0.40720081329345703,
0.11461394280195236,
0.6815894842147827,
-0.7729904651641846,
0.6815440058708191,
0.5148987174034119,
0.5466288328170776,
0.22262097895145416,
0.020788397639989853,
0.5157185792922974,
-1.0704314708709717,
0.2344541847705841,
0.060152191668748856,
0.23368212580680847,
-0.10784202814102173,
-0.5972048044204712,
0.5248100757598877,
-0.041224636137485504,
-0.6248953342437744,
-0.6305301189422607,
-0.011144150979816914,
-1.207460641860962,
-0.35169467329978943,
0.9948294162750244,
-0.02970711700618267,
-0.3423875868320465,
-0.004280041437596083,
-0.23852035403251648,
0.2197847217321396,
-0.4281107783317566,
0.9006185531616211,
1.364176630973816,
-0.4318107068538666,
0.13294577598571777,
-0.3839011788368225,
0.6887485384941101,
0.9035797715187073,
-0.4192826449871063,
0.35522642731666565,
0.14483188092708588,
0.11856763064861298,
0.5542440414428711,
0.20396871864795685,
0.1733034998178482,
0.46912798285484314,
-0.2911742627620697,
-0.07745517790317535,
0.5505191087722778,
-0.3768026828765869,
-0.01889478787779808,
0.06315009295940399,
0.21524755656719208,
-0.20178739726543427
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16446v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16446v1
|
Towards Automatic Evaluation for LLMs' Clinical Capabilities: Metric, Data, and Algorithm
| 2024-03-25T06:17:54 | 2024-03-25T06:17:54 |
Lei Liu, Xiaoyan Yang, Fangzhou Li, Chenfei Chi, Yue Shen, Shiwei Lyu Ming Zhang, Xiaowei Ma, Xiangguo Lyu, Liya Ma, Zhiqiang Zhang, Wei Xue, Yiran Huang, Jinjie Gu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) are gaining increasing interests to improve
clinical efficiency for medical diagnosis, owing to their unprecedented
performance in modelling natural language. Ensuring the safe and reliable
clinical applications, the evaluation of LLMs indeed becomes critical for
better mitigating the potential risks, e.g., hallucinations. However, current
evaluation methods heavily rely on labor-intensive human participation to
achieve human-preferred judgements. To overcome this challenge, we propose an
automatic evaluation paradigm tailored to assess the LLMs' capabilities in
delivering clinical services, e.g., disease diagnosis and treatment. The
evaluation paradigm contains three basic elements: metric, data, and algorithm.
Specifically, inspired by professional clinical practice pathways, we formulate
a LLM-specific clinical pathway (LCP) to define the clinical capabilities that
a doctor agent should possess. Then, Standardized Patients (SPs) from the
medical education are introduced as the guideline for collecting medical data
for evaluation, which can well ensure the completeness of the evaluation
procedure. Leveraging these steps, we develop a multi-agent framework to
simulate the interactive environment between SPs and a doctor agent, which is
equipped with a Retrieval-Augmented Evaluation (RAE) to determine whether the
behaviors of a doctor agent are in accordance with LCP. The above paradigm can
be extended to any similar clinical scenarios to automatically evaluate the
LLMs' medical capabilities. Applying such paradigm, we construct an evaluation
benchmark in the field of urology, including a LCP, a SPs dataset, and an
automated RAE. Extensive experiments are conducted to demonstrate the
effectiveness of the proposed approach, providing more insights for LLMs' safe
and reliable deployments in clinical practice.
|
[
-0.13839007914066315,
-0.6282307505607605,
1.033944845199585,
0.16313733160495758,
-0.2149258255958557,
0.09527585655450821,
-0.4724285900592804,
-0.5077587366104126,
0.1858038753271103,
0.5199612379074097,
-0.4271276295185089,
-0.6492308378219604,
-0.7430550456047058,
0.4838863015174866,
-0.18431442975997925,
0.6726881861686707,
-0.06297241151332855,
0.5398139953613281,
-0.495149701833725,
-0.21382366120815277,
-0.6899347901344299,
-0.14390690624713898,
-0.6791335344314575,
-0.5014263391494751,
0.19930489361286163,
0.15153846144676208,
0.8399696946144104,
0.6485165357589722,
0.8555980324745178,
0.4001104533672333,
0.39186328649520874,
0.40145382285118103,
-0.11437518894672394,
0.35089242458343506,
-0.1821412891149521,
-0.18054290115833282,
-0.7319787740707397,
-0.05450756102800369,
0.6836189031600952,
0.8668080568313599,
-0.18479906022548676,
0.027749760076403618,
-0.00482194684445858,
0.5710652470588684,
-0.37339404225349426,
0.1273558884859085,
-0.3444673717021942,
0.16394896805286407,
0.19677966833114624,
-0.4849693179130554,
-0.29059016704559326,
-0.473664253950119,
0.13140104711055756,
-0.39043739438056946,
0.10372753441333771,
-0.0903836116194725,
0.5562139749526978,
0.32923856377601624,
-0.34246960282325745,
-0.420178085565567,
-0.6002359986305237,
0.5036500096321106,
-0.4014206826686859,
0.48906826972961426,
0.2747010588645935,
0.7771233320236206,
-0.22923749685287476,
-0.6417427062988281,
-0.18777228891849518,
-0.8400527834892273,
-0.270582377910614,
-0.043399810791015625,
0.02999253012239933,
0.2719080150127411,
0.047772493213415146,
0.23164883255958557,
-0.6148398518562317,
0.22168605029582977,
-0.15104255080223083,
-0.2069416493177414,
0.9250245690345764,
0.6516357660293579,
0.35616493225097656,
-0.2258262187242508,
-0.2946951687335968,
0.1360318511724472,
-0.4313780963420868,
-0.40361201763153076,
-0.1964827924966812,
0.2225460410118103,
0.044853389263153076,
0.5832081437110901,
-0.1625586450099945,
0.561964750289917,
-0.12317481637001038,
-0.3137628436088562,
0.31609663367271423,
-0.39196115732192993,
-0.08442740887403488,
-0.14212624728679657,
1.0000720024108887,
0.44384706020355225,
0.08276977390050888,
-0.4984883964061737,
-0.34864503145217896,
0.23558400571346283,
0.6208707094192505,
-0.5798409581184387,
0.09600433707237244,
0.5319557785987854,
-0.5309954881668091,
-0.3498341143131256,
-0.24384768307209015,
-0.7578933835029602,
-0.6990348100662231,
-0.5090743899345398,
0.5724623203277588,
-0.5655049085617065,
-0.05500226467847824,
0.34567609429359436,
0.29892316460609436,
-0.0656147301197052,
0.4470286965370178,
-0.47441184520721436,
0.776745080947876,
0.6688706874847412,
0.7033596634864807,
-0.49234798550605774,
-0.2181374877691269,
-0.6726295351982117,
-0.005386270582675934,
-0.18501430749893188,
0.7360719442367554,
-0.6141823530197144,
-0.4260636270046234,
-0.048244453966617584,
0.06548161804676056,
-0.2650638222694397,
-0.7862624526023865,
0.44348785281181335,
-0.1877988576889038,
-0.14455929398536682,
0.014396501705050468,
-0.69004887342453,
0.06298462301492691,
0.33062925934791565,
-0.5294272303581238,
0.6307469010353088,
0.3384118378162384,
-0.2853564918041229,
0.5568732619285583,
-0.9914129376411438,
-0.33043617010116577,
0.38283005356788635,
-0.37988272309303284,
-0.39731618762016296,
-0.17194610834121704,
0.24610720574855804,
0.527722954750061,
-0.6069304943084717,
0.38269200921058655,
-0.15911643207073212,
-0.42479607462882996,
0.2160092443227768,
-0.1758863925933838,
0.6871522068977356,
0.10796549171209335,
-0.3558701276779175,
0.3056406080722809,
-0.6911056637763977,
0.10593908280134201,
0.02603149227797985,
-0.13258907198905945,
-0.006714904215186834,
0.03525344654917717,
-0.25616374611854553,
0.056455887854099274,
0.17936979234218597,
-0.3313045799732208,
0.2165800780057907,
-0.39780429005622864,
0.062487803399562836,
0.5785022974014282,
0.18608759343624115,
0.2690749168395996,
-0.5616567730903625,
0.9079757928848267,
-0.35081255435943604,
0.5874316096305847,
0.19880710542201996,
-0.4016386568546295,
-0.4532378315925598,
-0.5525753498077393,
0.12503710389137268,
0.5886874198913574,
-0.5509411096572876,
0.8303266763687134,
-0.4113723635673523,
-0.5570499897003174,
-0.7269064784049988,
0.3030596375465393,
0.4311496615409851,
0.375865638256073,
0.3096522092819214,
-0.4800632894039154,
-0.3767114281654358,
-0.755513608455658,
-0.06634286791086197,
-0.315742164850235,
-0.1182304173707962,
0.5605968832969666,
0.4725378751754761,
-0.7283814549446106,
0.6821692585945129,
-0.28064796328544617,
-0.6196539998054504,
-0.3917486369609833,
-0.1864110380411148,
0.22051599621772766,
0.29051241278648376,
0.2629028260707855,
-0.37950554490089417,
-0.19421406090259552,
0.0020883262623101473,
-1.069881558418274,
-0.44273483753204346,
-0.11147534102201462,
-0.10536948591470718,
-0.03144100308418274,
0.2559313178062439,
-0.41487282514572144,
0.47438591718673706,
0.2198924422264099,
-0.365201473236084,
0.6398060321807861,
-0.6123589277267456,
0.2678145468235016,
-0.517749547958374,
0.10172060132026672,
-0.054608333855867386,
-0.3431937098503113,
-0.38672858476638794,
0.25712624192237854,
-0.06103960797190666,
0.04135207086801529,
-0.13800646364688873,
0.7358775734901428,
-0.34903061389923096,
-0.3014675974845886,
-0.10658221691846848,
0.36409249901771545,
0.028660280629992485,
0.047002751380205154,
0.07423554360866547,
0.4946145713329315,
0.6530758142471313,
-0.6015815734863281,
0.6130291223526001,
0.06309223920106888,
-0.2322205901145935,
0.7887780070304871,
-0.5718763470649719,
0.0729498565196991,
0.054724741727113724,
0.20486858487129211,
-0.60206139087677,
-0.025048794224858284,
0.32866159081459045,
-0.3349112272262573,
0.09561606496572495,
-0.0860043317079544,
-0.7559744715690613,
-0.3478822410106659,
-0.182411327958107,
0.30666354298591614,
0.3701765239238739,
-0.1047702357172966,
0.6770703792572021,
0.30966633558273315,
-0.02825581282377243,
-0.32590869069099426,
-0.1206774041056633,
0.33871015906333923,
-0.11020821332931519,
-0.5888110399246216,
0.19094794988632202,
-0.06547893583774567,
-0.3089127540588379,
-0.13960909843444824,
0.207795187830925,
0.14238466322422028,
0.2589825689792633,
0.4053211510181427,
0.5114597082138062,
-0.062492381781339645,
0.2514239549636841,
0.16917723417282104,
-0.3436540961265564,
0.23954260349273682,
0.03379054740071297,
0.5452116131782532,
-0.3056483268737793,
-0.9038512110710144,
-0.535552978515625,
0.16335509717464447,
0.5405485033988953,
-0.15174022316932678,
0.36691251397132874,
0.648107647895813,
-0.5497472882270813,
-0.09602679312229156,
-0.5597164034843445,
-0.46654027700424194,
-0.3926490843296051,
0.4851069450378418,
-0.25318413972854614,
-0.30549633502960205,
0.4077054262161255,
-0.10954426974058151,
0.0678805261850357,
0.2932233512401581,
0.8435927629470825,
0.04793941229581833,
1.0766352415084839,
0.3385361433029175,
0.3005709648132324,
-0.2634243667125702,
-0.26416152715682983,
0.19288910925388336,
-0.8560155034065247,
-0.45805010199546814,
-0.342803418636322,
0.006269439123570919,
-0.3795737028121948,
-0.645793080329895,
0.8726359009742737,
-0.17319528758525848,
0.06132075935602188,
0.13459567725658417,
-0.5365452170372009,
0.11430136114358902,
-0.12245681881904602,
0.3648175895214081,
0.5284422039985657,
-0.18686747550964355,
-0.4856242835521698,
0.022036852315068245,
-0.5609723925590515,
-0.8270438313484192,
1.3682173490524292,
0.5719864368438721,
0.4837499260902405,
-0.06662467122077942,
0.8134727478027344,
0.6342138648033142,
0.6696208715438843,
-1.0234403610229492,
0.7820886969566345,
-0.00397087074816227,
-0.4228561520576477,
-0.4091663658618927,
-0.24864953756332397,
-1.0867093801498413,
0.3188021183013916,
-0.35439544916152954,
-0.6705603003501892,
-0.20620784163475037,
-0.2109277993440628,
-0.534325897693634,
0.009640972130000591,
-0.3804493844509125,
0.6816163659095764,
-0.4452206492424011,
-0.2841087877750397,
-0.4380112588405609,
-0.6604819297790527,
0.030920283868908882,
-0.2705913186073303,
0.2153719961643219,
-0.18014605343341827,
-0.29027625918388367,
0.6161433458328247,
-0.37608957290649414,
0.5816541314125061,
-0.2860761284828186,
-0.03293399140238762,
-0.13335548341274261,
0.24315503239631653,
0.21637481451034546,
0.3475435972213745,
-0.2427143156528473,
0.019712867215275764,
0.26399731636047363,
-0.16454823315143585,
-0.846736490726471,
0.3509090840816498,
-0.6465787887573242,
-0.4581966698169708,
-0.2709234058856964,
-0.459059476852417,
-0.7047274708747864,
0.10262501984834671,
-0.14654192328453064,
0.4447236657142639,
-0.4023515582084656,
-0.2789652347564697,
0.3136577308177948,
-0.37450477480888367,
-0.11768466234207153,
0.8808202147483826,
-0.3718654215335846,
-0.25929713249206543,
0.6424580216407776,
-0.16860559582710266,
0.12962466478347778,
0.0022856355644762516,
0.2859582006931305,
-0.6207863688468933,
-0.9406778812408447,
-0.5539765954017639,
0.5435000061988831,
-0.8352934718132019,
-0.11844083666801453,
-0.6099292635917664,
-0.29531967639923096,
-0.2674103081226349,
-0.1891045719385147,
-0.23439793288707733,
0.1951274871826172,
-0.07273107767105103,
0.12215445935726166,
0.17388831079006195,
0.7588753700256348,
0.004234197549521923,
-0.047151293605566025,
-0.772797167301178,
0.42258062958717346,
0.006276965141296387,
0.4377281665802002,
-0.09163159132003784,
-0.4881630837917328,
-0.26020675897598267,
-0.16115042567253113,
-0.2525055706501007,
-0.650492250919342,
0.36875665187835693,
0.12011291831731796,
0.8011146783828735,
0.6136365532875061,
0.029329098761081696,
0.57744961977005,
-0.5584949254989624,
0.33849236369132996,
0.10351637750864029,
-0.6906031370162964,
0.5245426893234253,
-0.10546144098043442,
-0.2347593456506729,
0.6891393065452576,
0.2660621404647827,
-0.48168525099754333,
-0.6134432554244995,
-0.4991799294948578,
-0.5726514458656311,
0.4156303405761719,
0.12433964759111404,
-0.14018045365810394,
-0.1420128494501114,
0.3687019348144531,
0.33639079332351685,
0.0040670898742973804,
-0.31613317131996155,
-0.12056242674589157,
0.4097801148891449,
-0.38324519991874695,
-0.06834795325994492,
0.11272772401571274,
-0.4556752145290375,
-0.2839112877845764,
0.3115648627281189,
-0.22903266549110413,
0.4847317934036255,
0.42479172348976135,
-0.3526139259338379,
-0.06254298239946365,
0.17942368984222412,
0.2531765401363373,
1.0789648294448853,
-0.2703012228012085,
-0.11379073560237885,
0.15428799390792847,
-0.5883625745773315,
0.3213061988353729,
0.18319013714790344,
0.20268243551254272,
0.13008524477481842,
0.5789243578910828,
0.4354396462440491,
-0.012747944332659245,
-1.0302797555923462,
0.7035424113273621,
-0.07175017148256302,
-0.08762213587760925,
-0.42481374740600586,
0.09164807200431824,
-0.34791722893714905,
0.29958194494247437,
0.2577895522117615,
-0.0747513547539711,
0.375046968460083,
-0.3794260621070862,
0.5448371171951294,
0.4454669952392578,
-0.4550932049751282,
-0.13014934957027435,
0.4165692627429962,
0.13465486466884613,
-0.3480580151081085,
0.4816572368144989,
-0.2541504204273224,
-0.19104181230068207,
0.745668888092041,
0.3403528928756714,
0.8592310547828674,
-0.11329767107963562,
0.3053697943687439,
0.09318426251411438,
0.27516528964042664,
0.0755516067147255,
0.14773665368556976,
0.20045100152492523,
-0.5560756921768188,
-0.3688414692878723,
-0.5987997055053711,
-0.37460243701934814,
0.11959387362003326,
-0.7240517735481262,
0.5736284852027893,
-0.597321093082428,
-0.35668009519577026,
-0.032681334763765335,
0.3270469605922699,
-0.725972592830658,
0.2432960569858551,
0.08065648376941681,
0.7450180649757385,
-0.7080451250076294,
0.7237005233764648,
0.6316565871238708,
-0.19231104850769043,
-0.4948858618736267,
-0.17506296932697296,
0.03937254846096039,
-1.0743447542190552,
0.5809165239334106,
0.14953456819057465,
-0.23096075654029846,
-0.3994837999343872,
-0.034366101026535034,
-0.3354022204875946,
1.1566789150238037,
0.25881874561309814,
-0.4769192934036255,
0.021090053021907806,
0.2808742821216583,
0.9011069536209106,
-0.7864383459091187,
0.5756998658180237,
0.8115503787994385,
0.48659995198249817,
-0.18351024389266968,
-1.2747712135314941,
0.4511336386203766,
-0.18182140588760376,
-0.12235914915800095,
-0.013842808082699776,
-0.2044604867696762,
0.2510289251804352,
-0.43479007482528687,
-0.059094153344631195,
0.26215600967407227,
0.06253678351640701,
0.47926774621009827,
0.4391712248325348,
0.6415154933929443,
0.3937499523162842,
0.775219202041626,
0.13799414038658142,
1.1198616027832031,
-0.4827086925506592,
0.1792955994606018,
0.6579904556274414,
-0.6091353297233582,
0.47927021980285645,
0.26265063881874084,
-0.4315728545188904,
0.34487369656562805,
0.4243732988834381,
-0.23272328078746796,
0.10976212471723557,
0.39026302099227905,
-0.31015655398368835,
-0.26313507556915283,
-0.17019832134246826,
-0.25252071022987366,
0.6227362155914307,
0.46508631110191345,
-0.6022922992706299,
-0.18059459328651428,
0.05261508747935295,
-0.08935582637786865,
0.12531660497188568,
-0.15976649522781372,
0.787937581539154,
-0.006121054757386446,
-0.589260995388031,
0.7756542563438416,
0.05080046132206917,
0.14004653692245483,
-0.5875178575515747,
-0.17114394903182983,
-0.03060317039489746,
0.14246074855327606,
-0.2944905757904053,
-0.5271958708763123,
0.186595156788826,
-0.07210779190063477,
0.24346934258937836,
-0.03702976182103157,
0.5939411520957947,
-0.018523337319493294,
-0.5709363222122192,
0.5053908228874207,
0.6938082575798035,
0.4780355989933014,
0.2404709756374359,
-0.973662257194519,
0.04035307466983795,
-0.4590492248535156,
0.11987452954053879,
0.32927989959716797,
0.27131378650665283,
-0.2288941740989685,
1.0342129468917847,
0.4161088168621063,
0.606657862663269,
-0.3328653573989868,
0.5699810981750488,
0.7781253457069397,
-0.3752898871898651,
-0.27454784512519836,
-0.8146675825119019,
0.1979878693819046,
-0.0264605525881052,
0.14783883094787598,
0.331572562456131,
0.43760859966278076,
0.16225680708885193,
0.19715255498886108,
0.727141797542572,
0.04395374283194542,
0.4671953022480011,
-0.4557434916496277,
0.7791697382926941,
-0.560770571231842,
0.6044546961784363,
-0.3374079465866089,
-0.6818877458572388,
-0.3770991563796997,
0.5915481448173523,
-0.375349760055542,
0.17858034372329712,
0.8601315021514893,
0.6940828561782837,
0.1656392216682434,
-0.17924249172210693,
0.4572775959968567,
0.08176060765981674,
0.31099602580070496,
0.5898702144622803,
0.7353180050849915,
-0.3322516679763794,
0.18715259432792664,
-0.1420018970966339,
-0.4715803265571594,
-0.31812018156051636,
-0.6418304443359375,
-0.8134057521820068,
-0.36454930901527405,
-0.33107486367225647,
-0.3580450415611267,
0.2815907299518585,
1.1928565502166748,
0.7287194728851318,
-0.5288158655166626,
-0.39014431834220886,
0.2079741209745407,
-0.02075604535639286,
-0.3933490216732025,
-0.18354928493499756,
0.6068789958953857,
-0.45455604791641235,
-0.5162603259086609,
0.4384829103946686,
0.5912352800369263,
-0.16816852986812592,
-0.6167532801628113,
-0.28443780541419983,
0.23487652838230133,
-0.10874196887016296,
0.5035629272460938,
-0.1789960265159607,
-0.665594220161438,
-0.10133305937051773,
-0.03215532749891281,
-0.18930257856845856,
0.17773930728435516,
0.7454811930656433,
-0.9888062477111816,
0.5108487606048584,
-0.06382964551448822,
0.7461763024330139,
-0.10234735161066055,
-0.12262047827243805,
0.6680731773376465,
-0.011823400855064392,
-0.14383766055107117,
0.7810198664665222,
0.3190387189388275,
0.1574757993221283,
-0.4271334409713745,
0.5349112749099731,
0.2158304899930954,
-0.468225359916687,
-0.8959296941757202,
0.0034160984214395285,
-0.7671968340873718,
-0.12057577818632126,
1.2078074216842651,
-0.2409876435995102,
0.005026266444474459,
-0.6175938248634338,
-0.06338369846343994,
0.15533053874969482,
-0.14435307681560516,
1.0369952917099,
0.23557154834270477,
-0.4388580620288849,
0.19809962809085846,
-0.7970967888832092,
0.582598865032196,
0.4121483564376831,
-0.8771690130233765,
-0.18292859196662903,
0.4340979754924774,
0.46042579412460327,
-0.03225760906934738,
0.8785771727561951,
-0.585983395576477,
0.4857783019542694,
-0.35169026255607605,
-0.07570724189281464,
-0.09600622206926346,
-0.40928971767425537,
-0.38251087069511414,
-0.09961620718240738,
0.1328970342874527,
-0.0816100463271141
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16444v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16444v1
|
KIT-19: A Comprehensive Korean Instruction Toolkit on 19 Tasks for Fine-Tuning Korean Large Language Models
| 2024-03-25T06:15:21 | 2024-03-25T06:15:21 |
Dongjun Jang, Sungjoo Byun, Hyemi Jo, Hyopil Shin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Instruction Tuning on Large Language Models is an essential process for model
to function well and achieve high performance in specific tasks. Accordingly,
in mainstream languages such as English, instruction-based datasets are being
constructed and made publicly available. In the case of Korean, publicly
available models and datasets all rely on using the output of ChatGPT or
translating datasets built in English. In this paper, We introduce
\textit{KIT-19} as an instruction dataset for the development of LLM in Korean.
\textit{KIT-19} is a dataset created in an instruction format, comprising 19
existing open-source datasets for Korean NLP tasks. In this paper, we train a
Korean Pretrained LLM using \textit{KIT-19} to demonstrate its effectiveness.
The experimental results show that the model trained on \textit{KIT-19}
significantly outperforms existing Korean LLMs. Based on the its quality and
empirical results, this paper proposes that \textit{KIT-19} has the potential
to make a substantial contribution to the future improvement of Korean LLMs'
performance.
|
[
-0.176968514919281,
-0.7002466917037964,
0.2570312023162842,
0.4594946503639221,
-0.28721147775650024,
0.2849752604961395,
-0.4776100218296051,
-0.03136887401342392,
0.019907217472791672,
0.6757318377494812,
-0.7298353910446167,
-0.8762847185134888,
-0.32032468914985657,
0.040512003004550934,
-0.030630484223365784,
0.823415219783783,
-0.1135503500699997,
0.48707664012908936,
-0.13203807175159454,
0.42483264207839966,
-0.6645366549491882,
-0.04851101338863373,
-0.632745623588562,
-0.509703516960144,
0.27155572175979614,
0.5858175158500671,
0.42696380615234375,
0.9471269845962524,
0.6444070935249329,
0.33576440811157227,
0.04940691962838173,
0.3468875288963318,
-0.5725009441375732,
0.15951421856880188,
-0.19692134857177734,
-0.6465932130813599,
-0.8252593874931335,
0.03445646911859512,
0.5630979537963867,
0.4322330355644226,
0.025981750339269638,
0.3084608316421509,
0.004860222805291414,
0.6673497557640076,
-0.21666869521141052,
0.29066669940948486,
-0.63539719581604,
0.030820701271295547,
-0.32263675332069397,
-0.2999534606933594,
-0.4566960036754608,
-0.15880054235458374,
-0.2385319173336029,
-0.7718648910522461,
0.06506440788507462,
-0.11449448764324188,
0.8505167961120605,
0.38357114791870117,
-0.42896783351898193,
-0.4776008725166321,
-0.5497323274612427,
0.82258540391922,
-0.8705904483795166,
0.4543529748916626,
0.6297537088394165,
0.49942725896835327,
-0.3938301205635071,
-0.5728508830070496,
-0.015027962625026703,
-0.2744413912296295,
0.10186125338077545,
0.20680278539657593,
0.5046929121017456,
0.41147860884666443,
0.0835033729672432,
0.4604513645172119,
-0.607268214225769,
0.442421019077301,
-0.4397413432598114,
-0.17642122507095337,
0.9334561228752136,
0.22123269736766815,
0.3018181324005127,
-0.36445870995521545,
-0.2942359745502472,
0.05513686686754227,
-0.811799168586731,
-0.419898122549057,
0.5290278196334839,
0.38700273633003235,
-0.3420810103416443,
0.671090304851532,
-0.672003448009491,
0.5515959858894348,
0.21424072980880737,
-0.6379002332687378,
0.32405799627304077,
-0.400134414434433,
-0.3371363878250122,
0.018214043229818344,
0.5420085787773132,
0.34718504548072815,
0.563676118850708,
-0.2528228163719177,
-0.46216028928756714,
-0.22574220597743988,
0.345165491104126,
-0.6254097819328308,
-0.4293260872364044,
-0.16204111278057098,
-0.4565586447715759,
-0.4320245385169983,
-0.04030488803982735,
-0.7081855535507202,
-0.3703632056713104,
-0.7657146453857422,
0.48510053753852844,
-0.00019913911819458008,
-0.05706245079636574,
0.20429521799087524,
0.26594749093055725,
0.17635668814182281,
0.3186919689178467,
-0.5891823768615723,
0.21137502789497375,
0.7237268090248108,
0.617081344127655,
-0.26129183173179626,
-0.29318806529045105,
-0.3415369391441345,
-0.026352474465966225,
-0.8016905188560486,
0.5639469027519226,
-0.4264729619026184,
-0.23961295187473297,
-0.07657590508460999,
0.5581777691841125,
-0.15721413493156433,
-0.7983943223953247,
0.17263263463974,
-0.4407486319541931,
0.10144217312335968,
-0.026934290304780006,
-0.6423499584197998,
0.00044994009658694267,
0.15876668691635132,
-0.5264179706573486,
1.3187894821166992,
0.17343418300151825,
-0.15096339583396912,
0.20375880599021912,
-0.7594744563102722,
-0.38001251220703125,
0.3925296664237976,
-0.054604820907115936,
-0.20039190351963043,
0.039716143161058426,
0.09109830856323242,
0.805213987827301,
-0.20492880046367645,
0.40568894147872925,
-0.10023012012243271,
-0.3635990619659424,
-0.13874398171901703,
-0.41887131333351135,
0.67743980884552,
0.05352875217795372,
-0.40751174092292786,
0.04965062439441681,
-1.0401114225387573,
0.19735127687454224,
0.031983062624931335,
-0.6448312997817993,
-0.2646191120147705,
-0.5425037741661072,
-0.2835748791694641,
0.3240199685096741,
0.48494017124176025,
-0.3864406645298004,
0.19745586812496185,
-0.43957680463790894,
-0.07934264093637466,
0.9013504385948181,
-0.0860968604683876,
0.772331953048706,
-0.18682876229286194,
1.0143649578094482,
-0.44979700446128845,
0.20910543203353882,
-0.3763188421726227,
-0.5171264410018921,
-0.8008451461791992,
-0.2146127074956894,
0.4379711151123047,
0.7623420357704163,
-0.8038597106933594,
0.40989965200424194,
-0.13153398036956787,
-0.5784456729888916,
-0.6919677257537842,
0.4736129641532898,
0.6685858964920044,
0.42271310091018677,
0.12633559107780457,
0.16397760808467865,
-0.6570185422897339,
-0.812612771987915,
0.2265128642320633,
0.22593922913074493,
-0.1836920827627182,
0.3398633897304535,
0.3884257972240448,
-0.15425756573677063,
0.29639875888824463,
-0.35872429609298706,
0.039947230368852615,
-0.2354855239391327,
-0.17842882871627808,
0.2946929335594177,
0.4356226921081543,
0.11735469847917557,
-0.33653873205184937,
-0.7802724242210388,
0.385780394077301,
-0.7439286112785339,
-0.3965268135070801,
-0.12155870348215103,
-0.4165131151676178,
0.16635552048683167,
0.8700414896011353,
-0.3806043267250061,
0.40603551268577576,
0.5506821274757385,
-0.26370057463645935,
0.80182945728302,
-0.169651061296463,
0.058819808065891266,
-1.373813509941101,
-0.22208431363105774,
-0.33859434723854065,
-0.33952730894088745,
-0.5636790990829468,
0.2559807300567627,
0.10206501185894012,
-0.08589013665914536,
-0.48243194818496704,
0.9028108716011047,
-0.318667471408844,
-0.011510171927511692,
-0.47139763832092285,
-0.09456012398004532,
-0.08479751646518707,
0.24831053614616394,
-0.20019154250621796,
0.9196297526359558,
0.14517205953598022,
-0.7556539177894592,
0.6009281277656555,
0.2171522080898285,
-0.4392540454864502,
0.5895578265190125,
-0.4386887550354004,
0.14301173388957977,
0.055817145854234695,
-0.03277887403964996,
-0.6505914926528931,
-0.653570294380188,
0.32706448435783386,
-0.10558163374662399,
0.6006818413734436,
-0.0927659273147583,
-0.2761709690093994,
-0.2661829888820648,
-0.2911401093006134,
-0.2790754735469818,
0.3695409595966339,
-0.5559589862823486,
0.45747342705726624,
0.137252539396286,
-0.14843837916851044,
-0.7402552366256714,
-0.7069092392921448,
-0.06330074369907379,
-0.18157093226909637,
-0.502871036529541,
0.4993164837360382,
-0.1631188839673996,
-0.16888666152954102,
-0.05679556727409363,
-0.2516231834888458,
-0.11957930028438568,
0.10523725301027298,
0.28758668899536133,
0.21327456831932068,
-0.4080900251865387,
0.39320507645606995,
0.14529800415039062,
-0.21576733887195587,
0.03743169456720352,
0.07617155462503433,
0.8367352485656738,
0.12442910671234131,
-0.26960206031799316,
-0.49977919459342957,
-0.16432233154773712,
0.16216623783111572,
0.19507713615894318,
0.4879205822944641,
0.6446429491043091,
-0.24920281767845154,
-0.5764825940132141,
-0.49592894315719604,
-0.20455020666122437,
-0.6254577040672302,
0.8202968835830688,
-0.46299466490745544,
-0.5902274250984192,
0.5036823749542236,
-0.4863343834877014,
-0.07209968566894531,
0.19545337557792664,
0.5144157409667969,
-0.1445382833480835,
0.713034987449646,
0.4423339366912842,
-0.005165495909750462,
0.4686030149459839,
-0.31873059272766113,
0.08658932894468307,
-0.7484492659568787,
-0.5335034132003784,
-0.3683922290802002,
-0.5760526657104492,
-0.568150520324707,
-0.5766730308532715,
-0.10399392992258072,
0.32542580366134644,
-0.538172721862793,
0.2695075273513794,
-0.26867955923080444,
0.95470130443573,
0.6900486946105957,
0.2384071797132492,
0.1975342035293579,
-0.16242603957653046,
-0.10010886937379837,
0.02564239129424095,
-0.853043794631958,
-0.7093436121940613,
1.395967721939087,
0.12910620868206024,
0.9768574237823486,
-0.5969564318656921,
0.894216001033783,
0.056792788207530975,
-0.12148002535104752,
-0.8165309429168701,
0.7914417386054993,
-0.40091127157211304,
-0.5621594786643982,
-0.31764036417007446,
-0.3374793827533722,
-0.7965553998947144,
-0.4815378487110138,
0.2551070749759674,
-0.4390189051628113,
-0.13613036274909973,
-0.013241978362202644,
0.05572133511304855,
0.03525938466191292,
-0.8365020751953125,
0.9350845813751221,
-0.42527535557746887,
0.12492617964744568,
0.03879287838935852,
-0.47072505950927734,
0.3704218864440918,
-0.23818711936473846,
-0.04659181088209152,
-0.24032904207706451,
-0.1996316760778427,
0.6995892524719238,
-0.20829430222511292,
0.9025141596794128,
-0.2569219470024109,
-0.2470451146364212,
0.0897417739033699,
-0.08239202946424484,
0.5535418391227722,
0.23337601125240326,
0.029736362397670746,
-0.196820467710495,
-0.2112337052822113,
-0.4504713714122772,
-0.6102020144462585,
0.7988860607147217,
-0.6844498515129089,
-0.43156886100769043,
0.1957951933145523,
-0.7984144687652588,
-0.05958138406276703,
0.18228960037231445,
0.21570166945457458,
0.34842851758003235,
0.032190918922424316,
0.36175650358200073,
0.8490990400314331,
-0.4876158535480499,
0.3676413893699646,
0.49687522649765015,
-0.5721049904823303,
-0.5520550608634949,
1.0677237510681152,
0.3514687120914459,
0.6511821150779724,
0.38194897770881653,
0.1240447387099266,
-0.11631215363740921,
-0.4254245162010193,
-0.5048754811286926,
0.16535836458206177,
-0.9115612506866455,
-0.5252848267555237,
-0.21390165388584137,
-0.5744377970695496,
-0.011403022333979607,
-0.3368353843688965,
-0.6201514601707458,
-0.4248047173023224,
-0.18216517567634583,
-0.19808292388916016,
0.3540266752243042,
0.8815959095954895,
0.03687775880098343,
0.763730525970459,
-0.37291568517684937,
0.3100067377090454,
0.4127471148967743,
0.4542318284511566,
-0.1617162674665451,
-0.4918825328350067,
-0.5181530117988586,
0.19862598180770874,
-0.25327691435813904,
-0.5850406289100647,
0.16220547258853912,
0.4083845019340515,
0.5640112161636353,
0.30042392015457153,
-0.034942589700222015,
0.6204023957252502,
-0.39757296442985535,
0.5808643698692322,
-0.4592016339302063,
-0.6426757574081421,
0.4729037284851074,
-0.45421671867370605,
0.7257503867149353,
0.4847008287906647,
0.39231806993484497,
-0.5480945110321045,
-0.18168680369853973,
-0.4675156772136688,
-0.5033556222915649,
0.9901964068412781,
-0.2507287859916687,
0.3679686486721039,
0.14727473258972168,
0.4473622739315033,
0.34388941526412964,
0.2892484962940216,
-0.4900396764278412,
-0.22492635250091553,
-0.008583693765103817,
-0.49417439103126526,
0.11700545996427536,
-0.15210995078086853,
0.06377516686916351,
-0.19486702978610992,
1.0204685926437378,
-0.06969425827264786,
0.3287334144115448,
-0.5337594747543335,
0.004620139487087727,
0.03690179064869881,
0.05465676635503769,
0.4539903700351715,
0.7540995478630066,
-0.005495290271937847,
0.010165633633732796,
0.38423359394073486,
-0.8818598985671997,
0.3319079279899597,
-0.04051131010055542,
-0.3431015610694885,
0.08246717602014542,
0.3633505403995514,
0.8522561192512512,
0.5035355091094971,
-0.5684679746627808,
0.19885659217834473,
0.35494303703308105,
-0.14333632588386536,
0.08979854732751846,
0.13741450011730194,
0.40655744075775146,
0.2924066185951233,
0.08905093371868134,
-0.3765939772129059,
-0.15853706002235413,
-0.18875592947006226,
0.20867815613746643,
0.2913336455821991,
-0.20212498307228088,
-0.3846585750579834,
0.3015184998512268,
0.1571791023015976,
-0.663618266582489,
0.4097048044204712,
-0.5897417068481445,
-0.48504677414894104,
0.8634912371635437,
0.7216356992721558,
0.6672745943069458,
-0.78692227602005,
0.810129702091217,
0.35547488927841187,
0.4261311888694763,
-0.2094496339559555,
0.6924868822097778,
0.3563300371170044,
-0.4012381136417389,
-0.957266628742218,
-0.8088424205780029,
-0.07469803094863892,
0.7747431993484497,
-0.3557828962802887,
0.7155943512916565,
-0.3708551228046417,
0.2953561544418335,
-0.3024960458278656,
0.20450663566589355,
-0.7186226844787598,
0.41458022594451904,
-0.14841629564762115,
0.7502415180206299,
-0.7266020774841309,
0.7179014086723328,
0.7217790484428406,
0.08787337690591812,
-0.8373437523841858,
-0.3020003139972687,
0.03431083261966705,
-1.0763858556747437,
0.6323033571243286,
0.11240138113498688,
0.32380521297454834,
0.14865106344223022,
-0.5149330496788025,
-1.028502345085144,
1.0596795082092285,
0.46140745282173157,
-0.7947205305099487,
-0.1130908951163292,
0.48465436697006226,
0.3583108186721802,
-0.47960248589515686,
-0.1454688012599945,
0.3752730190753937,
0.4252050518989563,
-0.20267561078071594,
-1.0433902740478516,
-0.12000104784965515,
-0.20530566573143005,
-0.08925419300794601,
0.24125026166439056,
-0.44605207443237305,
0.5385634303092957,
0.33053386211395264,
0.03883734345436096,
0.26128387451171875,
0.09882545471191406,
0.2264275997877121,
0.5317837595939636,
0.038382284343242645,
0.5540467500686646,
0.8973276615142822,
-0.0012632748112082481,
0.684320867061615,
-0.31003931164741516,
-0.0369807630777359,
1.4238561391830444,
0.1598966270685196,
0.6357676386833191,
0.11487799137830734,
-0.19783715903759003,
0.03702208772301674,
0.6952365040779114,
0.021904287859797478,
0.5689957737922668,
0.27757886052131653,
-0.20858901739120483,
-0.29451823234558105,
-0.13746292889118195,
-0.3431745171546936,
0.6761378049850464,
0.2516673505306244,
-0.5256900191307068,
-0.2262943834066391,
0.2835485339164734,
0.30203425884246826,
0.09532144665718079,
-0.5813363790512085,
0.8055799007415771,
0.13970249891281128,
-0.1700659692287445,
0.5253216624259949,
-0.0730748400092125,
0.6350477933883667,
-0.6626484394073486,
-0.007654161192476749,
-0.2981683611869812,
0.13313733041286469,
-0.1829160451889038,
-0.464866578578949,
0.14469555020332336,
-0.06535673141479492,
-0.24848046898841858,
-0.15285637974739075,
0.9531189799308777,
-0.5213152766227722,
-0.660760760307312,
0.06801289319992065,
0.5298510193824768,
0.24811455607414246,
0.024317258968949318,
-0.6483370065689087,
-0.07449046522378922,
0.1054970994591713,
-0.29186826944351196,
0.5451778769493103,
0.5979251265525818,
-0.15755441784858704,
0.6088162064552307,
0.3838229477405548,
0.22446663677692413,
0.4358656704425812,
-0.030434023588895798,
0.7097434997558594,
-0.3079557418823242,
-0.13178852200508118,
-0.7371202707290649,
0.4500691294670105,
-0.15565621852874756,
-0.5451713800430298,
0.9091921448707581,
0.5954126715660095,
1.242302417755127,
-0.36045607924461365,
0.6967398524284363,
0.18364186584949493,
0.44361603260040283,
-0.6863354444503784,
0.7237643599510193,
-0.24722594022750854,
0.20130829513072968,
-0.05500447377562523,
-1.254136562347412,
-0.0507424995303154,
0.6012442111968994,
-0.34472227096557617,
0.14744170010089874,
0.516567587852478,
1.1066622734069824,
-0.1622665822505951,
-0.11712381988763809,
0.3179454803466797,
0.048778701573610306,
0.05232876166701317,
0.13709768652915955,
0.7672284841537476,
-0.40622398257255554,
0.41425108909606934,
-0.8106611371040344,
-0.041651636362075806,
-0.06260863691568375,
-0.8074216842651367,
-1.2096073627471924,
-0.45919930934906006,
-0.26328787207603455,
-0.01864297315478325,
0.31291717290878296,
1.031604528427124,
0.7511443495750427,
-0.8063576817512512,
-0.31582552194595337,
-0.2696322202682495,
-0.014924587681889534,
-0.041863150894641876,
-0.19758203625679016,
0.3432323932647705,
-0.7907194495201111,
-0.7911662459373474,
0.8770855665206909,
0.19179819524288177,
0.11751693487167358,
-0.302906334400177,
-0.47884687781333923,
-0.25656893849372864,
0.003158701816573739,
0.41407132148742676,
-0.15456491708755493,
-0.5043842792510986,
0.20141145586967468,
0.45579445362091064,
0.06353600323200226,
0.0018702205270528793,
0.4187089800834656,
-0.462957501411438,
0.6836891174316406,
0.409906804561615,
0.8897457718849182,
0.38241562247276306,
-0.19273261725902557,
0.8080685138702393,
-1.1037639379501343,
0.04119274392724037,
0.09988853335380554,
-0.162704735994339,
0.3677075207233429,
-0.3706899583339691,
0.8969693779945374,
0.004114788956940174,
-0.8775355815887451,
-0.8951423168182373,
0.0766550675034523,
-0.4717332720756531,
-0.11954627931118011,
1.2373595237731934,
-0.14026111364364624,
-0.18264758586883545,
-0.05804020166397095,
-0.494329035282135,
0.27734148502349854,
-0.239561527967453,
0.7781320810317993,
0.9124172329902649,
0.308008074760437,
-0.047509729862213135,
-1.1371665000915527,
0.6362295150756836,
0.08257272839546204,
-1.0792791843414307,
-0.06552499532699585,
0.025033801794052124,
0.04378227889537811,
-0.10430904477834702,
0.18221154808998108,
0.07657618820667267,
0.38457512855529785,
0.0032827453687787056,
-0.09127426147460938,
-0.32874026894569397,
-0.6037395596504211,
-0.1883353292942047,
-0.24727582931518555,
-0.0756315141916275,
-0.2959802746772766
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16443v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16443v1
|
CodeS: Natural Language to Code Repository via Multi-Layer Sketch
| 2024-03-25T06:09:55 | 2024-03-25T06:09:55 |
Daoguang Zan, Ailun Yu, Wei Liu, Dong Chen, Bo Shen, Wei Li, Yafen Yao, Yongshun Gong, Xiaolin Chen, Bei Guan, Zhiguang Yang, Yongji Wang, Qianxiang Wang, Lizhen Cui
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SE
|
The impressive performance of large language models (LLMs) on code-related
tasks has shown the potential of fully automated software development. In light
of this, we introduce a new software engineering task, namely Natural Language
to code Repository (NL2Repo). This task aims to generate an entire code
repository from its natural language requirements. To address this task, we
propose a simple yet effective framework CodeS, which decomposes NL2Repo into
multiple sub-tasks by a multi-layer sketch. Specifically, CodeS includes three
modules: RepoSketcher, FileSketcher, and SketchFiller. RepoSketcher first
generates a repository's directory structure for given requirements;
FileSketcher then generates a file sketch for each file in the generated
structure; SketchFiller finally fills in the details for each function in the
generated file sketch. To rigorously assess CodeS on the NL2Repo task, we carry
out evaluations through both automated benchmarking and manual feedback
analysis. For benchmark-based evaluation, we craft a repository-oriented
benchmark, SketchEval, and design an evaluation metric, SketchBLEU. For
feedback-based evaluation, we develop a VSCode plugin for CodeS and engage 30
participants in conducting empirical studies. Extensive experiments prove the
effectiveness and practicality of CodeS on the NL2Repo task.
|
[
-0.2603507936000824,
-0.226904034614563,
0.14834798872470856,
0.6503440737724304,
-0.07626177370548248,
0.1178315132856369,
-0.06228158622980118,
-0.7284595370292664,
0.18603451550006866,
1.0076619386672974,
-0.3585983216762543,
-0.36031806468963623,
-0.08976063132286072,
0.327857106924057,
-0.5196465849876404,
0.743350088596344,
-0.26187440752983093,
-0.23864752054214478,
-0.15275852382183075,
0.047546111047267914,
-0.5256097912788391,
-0.3105177581310272,
-0.5011780261993408,
-0.294447124004364,
0.24089477956295013,
0.4919600486755371,
0.18206506967544556,
0.3193734884262085,
0.4111953675746918,
0.3444739282131195,
0.1723972111940384,
0.14192433655261993,
-0.3593822121620178,
0.06880130618810654,
-0.023643821477890015,
-0.45954596996307373,
-0.3177950382232666,
-0.1413624882698059,
0.17551465332508087,
0.2712658941745758,
-0.014142509549856186,
0.31585896015167236,
0.0804353803396225,
1.0621984004974365,
-0.47182103991508484,
0.39540010690689087,
-0.30050691962242126,
0.15627972781658173,
0.2328816056251526,
-0.34172242879867554,
-0.6302801966667175,
-0.5680668950080872,
-0.04472341388463974,
-0.649692714214325,
0.15171100199222565,
0.059640903025865555,
0.6239742636680603,
0.18787015974521637,
-0.16003938019275665,
-0.5890482664108276,
-0.5184290409088135,
0.6207649111747742,
-0.8452233076095581,
0.053254857659339905,
0.26458001136779785,
0.4769718647003174,
-0.13727320730686188,
-0.9049015641212463,
-0.5356300473213196,
-0.5461662411689758,
-0.21860644221305847,
-0.02497604861855507,
0.009014863520860672,
0.00852990709245205,
0.33243587613105774,
0.46877381205558777,
-0.6788259744644165,
0.050401512533426285,
-0.40292441844940186,
-0.38434112071990967,
0.6995570659637451,
-0.08481676876544952,
0.5846243500709534,
-0.5770163536071777,
-0.4453302323818207,
0.06615101546049118,
-0.4478108584880829,
-0.0720330998301506,
0.5771908760070801,
0.42004793882369995,
-0.2793060541152954,
0.7958181500434875,
-0.37242811918258667,
0.39150598645210266,
-0.2943126857280731,
0.033850543200969696,
0.3433534801006317,
-0.39562252163887024,
-0.21338574588298798,
-0.08922656625509262,
0.6322457790374756,
0.27922874689102173,
0.3753938674926758,
-0.35275977849960327,
-0.38162264227867126,
0.17944787442684174,
0.6178126335144043,
-0.7475431561470032,
-0.4906047284603119,
0.4387015402317047,
-0.44583600759506226,
-0.5591719746589661,
-0.007580172270536423,
-0.6079785227775574,
-0.35629501938819885,
-0.5532358288764954,
0.15896296501159668,
-0.2402902990579605,
-0.35505932569503784,
0.17257601022720337,
-0.45939698815345764,
0.17998215556144714,
0.3884495794773102,
-0.5624361038208008,
0.4046701490879059,
0.6573213934898376,
0.8674528002738953,
-0.04415804520249367,
-0.29178741574287415,
-0.5767336487770081,
0.24176332354545593,
-0.3208150565624237,
0.8501240611076355,
-0.111591637134552,
-0.20714277029037476,
-0.0379430316388607,
-0.15629352629184723,
0.31689324975013733,
-0.5936610102653503,
0.2528612017631531,
-0.22359660267829895,
0.20308221876621246,
-0.013890125788748264,
-0.5341768860816956,
-0.025752274319529533,
0.2880031168460846,
-0.9846109747886658,
1.2265244722366333,
0.4749943017959595,
-0.7270779609680176,
-0.02958269603550434,
-0.9989592432975769,
-0.5489351749420166,
0.3518621325492859,
-0.29422250390052795,
-0.10108786821365356,
-0.027528271079063416,
-0.05961480364203453,
0.3612811267375946,
-0.3417784571647644,
0.33510446548461914,
-0.009011341258883476,
-0.42962902784347534,
-0.016451118513941765,
0.11770502477884293,
1.0407328605651855,
0.1191868856549263,
-0.5612961649894714,
0.12579265236854553,
-0.8577229976654053,
0.2831215560436249,
0.11468693614006042,
-0.5960184335708618,
-0.06320890784263611,
-0.15195396542549133,
0.4796411693096161,
0.20616139471530914,
-0.0987468734383583,
-0.42046505212783813,
0.3062017858028412,
-0.46802476048469543,
0.7035088539123535,
0.5470260381698608,
-0.07181081175804138,
0.7473034262657166,
-0.3517020642757416,
0.4767824709415436,
-0.4979794919490814,
0.04938395693898201,
-0.1350427269935608,
-0.5179441571235657,
-0.6040992140769958,
-0.11838995665311813,
0.019654305651783943,
0.609552800655365,
-1.0185154676437378,
0.4157199561595917,
-0.14902052283287048,
-0.3250601589679718,
-0.13760851323604584,
0.4618319571018219,
0.546983540058136,
0.378648042678833,
0.31760671734809875,
-0.5593305826187134,
-0.6287131309509277,
-0.9114691615104675,
-0.07721836119890213,
-0.3027772903442383,
-0.38157397508621216,
0.1702171117067337,
0.5648667216300964,
-0.4105149805545807,
1.0186606645584106,
-0.37255239486694336,
-0.40314584970474243,
-0.4635799527168274,
0.48640525341033936,
-0.059530291706323624,
0.609033465385437,
0.801607608795166,
-0.6059609651565552,
-0.2187499850988388,
0.019917072728276253,
-0.6069389581680298,
-0.286886990070343,
-0.2625952959060669,
-0.25809285044670105,
0.35182061791419983,
0.4242056906223297,
-0.6128488183021545,
0.16459061205387115,
0.5088372230529785,
0.07191924750804901,
0.7204952239990234,
-0.05648837611079216,
-0.006852952763438225,
-0.971693217754364,
0.522855818271637,
-0.07223591208457947,
-0.08256543427705765,
-0.49550268054008484,
0.5730786919593811,
0.21268245577812195,
-0.26768866181373596,
-0.3583102524280548,
0.6937510967254639,
-0.4717373549938202,
-0.3000772297382355,
-0.2625815272331238,
0.011189380660653114,
0.3398960828781128,
0.6742011308670044,
-0.04389417916536331,
0.6228988170623779,
0.18915455043315887,
-0.3927015960216522,
0.4836021065711975,
0.06147577986121178,
-0.6209316253662109,
0.21918566524982452,
-0.8101592063903809,
0.5549820065498352,
0.06430471688508987,
0.4030613899230957,
-0.8351545333862305,
-0.3197304308414459,
0.05341801792383194,
-0.4021826684474945,
0.3467230498790741,
-0.4185441732406616,
-0.8717197179794312,
-0.4565475881099701,
-0.5560168027877808,
-0.05992157757282257,
0.3084036111831665,
-0.2656182646751404,
0.537458598613739,
0.43911999464035034,
-0.15792620182037354,
-0.4787505865097046,
-0.7827515006065369,
0.34947893023490906,
0.3460220992565155,
-0.509632408618927,
0.2932664453983307,
-0.14422687888145447,
-0.15601418912410736,
0.10526018589735031,
-0.29021748900413513,
-0.40457338094711304,
-0.029921535402536392,
0.29747119545936584,
0.15187197923660278,
-0.17953550815582275,
-0.08475042879581451,
0.10122667998075485,
-0.41813623905181885,
0.2422654926776886,
-0.3945201337337494,
0.4341675043106079,
0.012639617547392845,
-0.3236940801143646,
-0.23488053679466248,
0.3188669979572296,
0.47385215759277344,
-0.20957531034946442,
-0.13074031472206116,
0.399373859167099,
-0.4281819760799408,
-0.6808813810348511,
-0.5125157237052917,
0.1125660240650177,
-0.47651493549346924,
0.2706232964992523,
-0.35160499811172485,
-0.9983784556388855,
0.49314790964126587,
-0.24961084127426147,
0.42867282032966614,
0.16175377368927002,
0.3532639741897583,
-0.04062243551015854,
0.48929089307785034,
0.8684305548667908,
0.012068063020706177,
0.2932800352573395,
-0.474470317363739,
0.27594906091690063,
-0.6850172281265259,
-0.23701798915863037,
-0.9305021166801453,
-0.27443671226501465,
-0.20901428163051605,
-0.6557828783988953,
-0.14558568596839905,
0.3322511315345764,
-0.14695297181606293,
0.805081307888031,
-0.7350404858589172,
0.795059859752655,
0.44515523314476013,
-0.17902930080890656,
0.13745270669460297,
-0.108261838555336,
-0.2428392469882965,
0.23240962624549866,
-0.5738616585731506,
-0.6219579577445984,
0.8011887073516846,
0.2942969501018524,
0.633595883846283,
0.05928173288702965,
0.966948390007019,
0.33354848623275757,
0.3627089262008667,
-0.8166680932044983,
0.5502995848655701,
-0.07335716485977173,
-0.4973582327365875,
-0.24498455226421356,
-0.5374495983123779,
-0.43989405035972595,
-0.0351879820227623,
0.03134453669190407,
-0.5721288323402405,
-0.013305582106113434,
0.1905018836259842,
-0.04119687154889107,
0.04785996675491333,
-0.9754902124404907,
0.9253492951393127,
-0.2667107880115509,
-0.21059826016426086,
0.0052653104066848755,
-0.7310567498207092,
0.411346971988678,
0.04432430863380432,
0.28272733092308044,
-0.08081645518541336,
0.14266416430473328,
0.5363951921463013,
-0.43249109387397766,
0.7859001755714417,
-0.25202831625938416,
-0.19298599660396576,
0.34466224908828735,
0.3695125877857208,
0.4852167069911957,
0.32424524426460266,
-0.1982050985097885,
-0.1510823369026184,
0.008671234361827374,
-0.3635729253292084,
-0.6625213027000427,
0.6592443585395813,
-0.4329592287540436,
0.023723216727375984,
0.0017742229392752051,
-0.4455534815788269,
-0.04361293092370033,
0.4430325925350189,
0.00975075177848339,
0.7611711025238037,
0.043268151581287384,
0.0017646350897848606,
0.40988391637802124,
-0.6907772421836853,
0.39830437302589417,
0.2758525311946869,
-0.3436834216117859,
-0.4033920466899872,
0.7094921469688416,
-0.2583857774734497,
0.27720144391059875,
0.6702190041542053,
0.13026951253414154,
-0.21349994838237762,
-0.4998084008693695,
-0.7039657831192017,
-0.010320945642888546,
-0.8991546034812927,
-0.4694044888019562,
-0.40571799874305725,
-0.2682897746562958,
-0.4492456018924713,
-0.38090449571609497,
-0.5173302292823792,
-0.46820104122161865,
0.16037766635417938,
0.07699748128652573,
0.3078892230987549,
1.0754224061965942,
0.18717966973781586,
-0.29839712381362915,
-0.8231587409973145,
0.7012789249420166,
0.26566049456596375,
0.6764708757400513,
0.058740682899951935,
-0.03775787353515625,
-0.11281038820743561,
-0.15483388304710388,
0.015027642250061035,
-0.5562905669212341,
0.28675374388694763,
-0.12067525833845139,
0.5870855450630188,
-0.08816280961036682,
0.19926221668720245,
0.5603393912315369,
-0.572735607624054,
0.5596141815185547,
0.3526187241077423,
-0.9507858157157898,
0.7726925611495972,
-0.11985818296670914,
0.34888941049575806,
0.6953758597373962,
-0.07371021062135696,
-0.32041075825691223,
-0.8813389539718628,
-0.18508613109588623,
-0.9995383620262146,
0.6397380232810974,
0.42595362663269043,
0.3406795263290405,
0.12087278813123703,
0.3692014515399933,
0.1171339601278305,
0.15797346830368042,
-0.8438560366630554,
-0.12370643764734268,
-0.3305402994155884,
0.004273824393749237,
0.2738344669342041,
-0.19658009707927704,
-0.13697808980941772,
-0.13435538113117218,
0.2710590362548828,
-0.45927974581718445,
0.45691484212875366,
0.05185185745358467,
-0.3319358229637146,
-0.02712385356426239,
0.30510351061820984,
0.7826226949691772,
0.7893568873405457,
-0.29047057032585144,
0.030960869044065475,
-0.2513751685619354,
-0.5554664134979248,
-0.07785990089178085,
0.05793393775820732,
-0.06940639764070511,
0.16103070974349976,
0.589446485042572,
0.4875199794769287,
0.5625878572463989,
-0.696020245552063,
0.4387474060058594,
-0.08636528253555298,
-0.47699618339538574,
-0.34934014081954956,
0.10544802248477936,
0.25955966114997864,
0.07044925540685654,
0.3811068534851074,
0.33077117800712585,
0.2513335049152374,
-0.5367206931114197,
0.3676786720752716,
-0.010462826117873192,
-0.26052314043045044,
-0.05687643587589264,
0.460211843252182,
0.6114282011985779,
-0.4749220609664917,
0.5584918260574341,
-0.5469453930854797,
-0.6058359742164612,
1.0072736740112305,
0.4991995096206665,
1.1418659687042236,
0.3520936369895935,
0.31264743208885193,
0.44223421812057495,
0.5988527536392212,
-0.20984677970409393,
0.36999133229255676,
-0.13523100316524506,
-0.39284491539001465,
-0.9971245527267456,
-0.5756150484085083,
-0.41095679998397827,
0.0334681011736393,
-0.6370009779930115,
0.391723096370697,
-0.5906452536582947,
0.3347814083099365,
0.024607552215456963,
0.0511474572122097,
-0.4292888939380646,
-0.21115505695343018,
0.06760622560977936,
1.1503902673721313,
-0.5826494097709656,
0.969241738319397,
0.8740785717964172,
-0.4683808386325836,
-0.9233250617980957,
-0.16486944258213043,
0.21240177750587463,
-0.5113725066184998,
0.7184228897094727,
0.5344305634498596,
-0.09234786778688431,
-0.0859152302145958,
-0.5350844264030457,
-0.5646727085113525,
0.9427880644798279,
0.5634542107582092,
-0.4605330228805542,
-0.003908457234501839,
0.0456697978079319,
0.5435791015625,
-0.2554788887500763,
0.2213444709777832,
0.1937149465084076,
0.30778393149375916,
0.05241775885224342,
-1.0434391498565674,
0.03202776983380318,
-0.872115433216095,
0.160873144865036,
0.33767104148864746,
-0.060657475143671036,
0.47370681166648865,
-0.3303785026073456,
-0.27885299921035767,
0.09179215878248215,
0.13290216028690338,
0.3327016532421112,
0.1188611164689064,
0.3463461995124817,
0.4821450710296631,
0.4571702480316162,
0.07045931369066238,
1.3161048889160156,
-0.4394320249557495,
0.34289661049842834,
1.298836350440979,
-0.4666655361652374,
0.8582064509391785,
0.5366284847259521,
-0.2719351351261139,
0.5129033923149109,
0.12505485117435455,
0.05459601804614067,
0.29844963550567627,
0.6947382688522339,
0.3011137843132019,
0.19913128018379211,
0.07462219893932343,
-0.2763819992542267,
0.06287090480327606,
-0.12570658326148987,
0.02420785464346409,
-0.2003389596939087,
-0.19121971726417542,
-0.21380993723869324,
0.10489211231470108,
0.12449727207422256,
0.7366095185279846,
0.11178445816040039,
-0.3634941279888153,
0.26336681842803955,
0.1855856031179428,
0.5769284963607788,
-0.6067133545875549,
-0.3735417425632477,
-0.34530577063560486,
0.03756564110517502,
-0.35007819533348083,
-0.7936693429946899,
0.5042828321456909,
0.1695539802312851,
-0.0524078793823719,
-0.6663966178894043,
0.7044408917427063,
-0.08381301909685135,
-0.35934045910835266,
0.5024166703224182,
0.1854705959558487,
-0.06807743012905121,
-0.03299850597977638,
-0.7996056079864502,
0.014083929359912872,
-0.05142231285572052,
-0.278980553150177,
0.2430652529001236,
0.44504231214523315,
0.09074755758047104,
0.7338241934776306,
0.8607221841812134,
0.05110377073287964,
0.0051760002970695496,
0.6361895799636841,
0.9402373433113098,
-0.4603300392627716,
-0.5594632625579834,
-0.3491263687610626,
0.7430424690246582,
-0.28074294328689575,
-0.43127211928367615,
0.5569375157356262,
0.8434170484542847,
0.9973514676094055,
-0.17157545685768127,
0.7351345419883728,
-0.47312700748443604,
0.46507132053375244,
-0.586211621761322,
0.8192759156227112,
-0.3013763427734375,
0.42402446269989014,
-0.5149677991867065,
-1.063640832901001,
-0.4586524963378906,
0.7618998289108276,
0.26584962010383606,
-0.23035307228565216,
0.7991177439689636,
0.750309407711029,
0.1030605211853981,
0.12481458485126495,
-0.26134419441223145,
-0.14745445549488068,
0.3636046051979065,
0.5840675234794617,
0.7932540774345398,
-0.5103781223297119,
0.5083784461021423,
-0.6664583683013916,
-0.09759172797203064,
-0.08237814158201218,
-1.0530198812484741,
-0.8746511936187744,
-0.4560437798500061,
-0.3915558159351349,
-0.21608424186706543,
-0.337581068277359,
0.8763517141342163,
0.6527395844459534,
-0.9594650864601135,
-0.6013321876525879,
-0.42663851380348206,
0.16816307604312897,
-0.2500804364681244,
-0.3197673261165619,
0.0970940962433815,
-0.5725188255310059,
-0.43587395548820496,
0.22620201110839844,
0.7964058518409729,
-0.07394801080226898,
-0.4283822178840637,
-0.42277321219444275,
0.008130582980811596,
-0.4013182818889618,
0.7706030607223511,
0.18571940064430237,
-0.64317786693573,
-0.2043410688638687,
0.20186100900173187,
-0.5096063017845154,
-0.14441145956516266,
1.2394099235534668,
-0.5801785588264465,
0.5314759612083435,
0.6907690167427063,
0.7653036713600159,
0.3311941623687744,
-0.26823118329048157,
0.6660609245300293,
-0.8449233174324036,
0.15888270735740662,
0.38014864921569824,
0.18420080840587616,
0.11692605912685394,
-0.18700991570949554,
0.8872338533401489,
0.00907567422837019,
-0.30266785621643066,
-1.0704454183578491,
0.048783235251903534,
-1.1578526496887207,
-0.4038768410682678,
1.1081976890563965,
-0.0002684796927496791,
0.1086544543504715,
-0.4949551224708557,
-0.2868999242782593,
-0.03195706009864807,
-0.18727083504199982,
0.6906786561012268,
0.4259974956512451,
-0.11579997092485428,
-0.28899627923965454,
-1.1155182123184204,
0.5147590041160583,
-0.02198118530213833,
-1.1343305110931396,
0.04013455659151077,
0.49180567264556885,
0.21336261928081512,
0.37566518783569336,
0.8847973942756653,
-0.19086170196533203,
0.40707966685295105,
0.0898074060678482,
0.41322359442710876,
-0.26970648765563965,
-0.3230590224266052,
-0.06472906470298767,
0.18619731068611145,
0.09154300391674042,
0.23553013801574707
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16442v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16442v1
|
If CLIP Could Talk: Understanding Vision-Language Model Representations Through Their Preferred Concept Descriptions
| 2024-03-25T06:05:50 | 2024-03-25T06:05:50 |
Reza Esfandiarpoor, Cristina Menghini, Stephen H. Bach
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
Recent works often assume that Vision-Language Model (VLM) representations
are based on visual attributes like shape. However, it is unclear to what
extent VLMs prioritize this information to represent concepts. We propose
Extract and Explore (EX2), a novel approach to characterize important textual
features for VLMs. EX2 uses reinforcement learning to align a large language
model with VLM preferences and generates descriptions that incorporate the
important features for the VLM. Then, we inspect the descriptions to identify
the features that contribute to VLM representations. We find that spurious
descriptions have a major role in VLM representations despite providing no
helpful information, e.g., Click to enlarge photo of CONCEPT. More importantly,
among informative descriptions, VLMs rely significantly on non-visual
attributes like habitat to represent visual concepts. Also, our analysis
reveals that different VLMs prioritize different attributes in their
representations. Overall, we show that VLMs do not simply match images to scene
descriptions and that non-visual or even spurious descriptions significantly
influence their representations.
|
[
-0.45616579055786133,
-0.5412182211875916,
0.8776558041572571,
0.05134953558444977,
-0.38203608989715576,
0.07914712280035019,
-0.1528107225894928,
-0.770783543586731,
0.39214181900024414,
0.623223602771759,
-0.43785732984542847,
-0.20658613741397858,
-0.6601805090904236,
-0.17559941112995148,
-0.614017903804779,
0.8541544079780579,
-0.018627453595399857,
-0.06201593577861786,
-0.4097650349140167,
-0.1449786275625229,
-0.7331370115280151,
-0.5622587203979492,
-0.4005959630012512,
-0.02106795459985733,
0.3565126359462738,
0.0618673637509346,
0.7127377986907959,
0.8008179664611816,
0.517399787902832,
0.2628704905509949,
-0.3169204890727997,
0.111470527946949,
-0.5040850043296814,
-0.06178576126694679,
-0.20446805655956268,
-0.5083669424057007,
-0.16734102368354797,
0.05058479681611061,
0.6965585350990295,
0.4798491299152374,
0.15268367528915405,
0.08869176357984543,
0.05498075112700462,
0.26153063774108887,
-0.37389761209487915,
0.519607663154602,
-0.6964069604873657,
-0.04109102860093117,
-0.14668522775173187,
-0.34208598732948303,
-0.36925697326660156,
0.13489291071891785,
0.7565054297447205,
-0.6051045656204224,
0.12077532708644867,
0.41866767406463623,
1.3101695775985718,
0.17614208161830902,
-0.24495083093643188,
-0.10270239412784576,
-0.6242489218711853,
0.7632012367248535,
-0.2724820077419281,
0.19835691154003143,
0.24564827978610992,
0.38589492440223694,
0.1288893222808838,
-0.6651345491409302,
-0.7069752216339111,
-0.15202417969703674,
-0.43742120265960693,
-0.12792326509952545,
-0.30613160133361816,
-0.0011388766579329967,
0.35662490129470825,
0.21525099873542786,
-0.24036245048046112,
0.015811478719115257,
-0.6986477375030518,
-0.336500346660614,
0.72029048204422,
0.3287354111671448,
0.42051082849502563,
-0.4829784631729126,
-0.9152694940567017,
-0.6021503210067749,
-0.5038074254989624,
0.5183308124542236,
-0.0331413559615612,
0.22604498267173767,
0.013776072300970554,
0.7747595906257629,
-0.02730228751897812,
0.6638205647468567,
-0.2936849594116211,
-0.035809535533189774,
0.258333683013916,
-0.2764350473880768,
-0.1737450659275055,
0.01972486637532711,
0.5734758377075195,
0.7354525923728943,
0.12332411855459213,
-0.03726503252983093,
-0.23894082009792328,
-0.10450701415538788,
0.47924885153770447,
-0.7517507672309875,
-0.17713116109371185,
0.0506582073867321,
-0.5958436727523804,
-0.44127514958381653,
0.2890409231185913,
-0.8523722887039185,
-0.39427313208580017,
-0.25182461738586426,
0.4425271153450012,
-0.4330216646194458,
-0.3341886103153229,
0.006714858580380678,
-0.5419909358024597,
0.5350974202156067,
0.38143447041511536,
-0.8518072962760925,
0.258394330739975,
0.5212087631225586,
0.9065040349960327,
-0.5597431659698486,
-0.3572924733161926,
-0.37055936455726624,
0.1586558222770691,
-0.4058653712272644,
0.941601574420929,
-0.6325151324272156,
-0.5054231882095337,
-0.026123804971575737,
0.24299511313438416,
0.16200214624404907,
-0.3665101230144501,
0.42804378271102905,
-0.2622833549976349,
0.14737087488174438,
-0.46857768297195435,
-0.43605396151542664,
-0.425578773021698,
0.061484795063734055,
-0.8790395855903625,
0.983066737651825,
0.2518463432788849,
-0.7806669473648071,
0.5866898894309998,
-0.5841917991638184,
0.0018591461703181267,
0.2217581868171692,
-0.6641790866851807,
-0.29615095257759094,
0.2804252505302429,
0.24522536993026733,
0.26801660656929016,
0.11498201638460159,
0.09248041361570358,
-0.2702917456626892,
-0.1831139326095581,
0.4926993250846863,
-0.139137864112854,
0.3813720643520355,
-0.06097232550382614,
-0.26101088523864746,
0.4478524625301361,
-0.6056234836578369,
0.22957871854305267,
0.3683370053768158,
0.03235211595892906,
-0.6864534020423889,
0.4117286205291748,
0.065443255007267,
0.04553459584712982,
0.16481530666351318,
-0.42811939120292664,
0.14996741712093353,
-0.4068710207939148,
0.36079156398773193,
0.8084448575973511,
0.012099322862923145,
0.4214774966239929,
-0.1780424267053604,
0.46676093339920044,
-0.07098007202148438,
0.25777292251586914,
-0.34887051582336426,
-0.3796955645084381,
-0.9875917434692383,
-0.3774643540382385,
-0.09384886175394058,
0.2968524694442749,
-0.9642176032066345,
-0.16141174733638763,
-0.22940470278263092,
-0.16342408955097198,
-0.4725591540336609,
-0.22410160303115845,
0.4593483507633209,
0.37034186720848083,
0.38331395387649536,
-0.38021746277809143,
-0.7019945979118347,
-1.2067242860794067,
0.00004642079511540942,
-0.40035685896873474,
0.0892387181520462,
0.5541831254959106,
0.3522707521915436,
0.14828087389469147,
1.3355830907821655,
-0.6861850023269653,
-0.17035286128520966,
-0.4168809652328491,
-0.16914108395576477,
-0.1158798411488533,
-0.06431067734956741,
0.7545124292373657,
-1.2258111238479614,
-0.15087303519248962,
-0.11586271226406097,
-0.5496370196342468,
0.057210154831409454,
-0.040475983172655106,
-0.26422318816185,
-0.16570740938186646,
0.4666427969932556,
-0.4635980427265167,
0.9045728445053101,
0.226695716381073,
-0.502583920955658,
0.3951384127140045,
-0.15930579602718353,
-0.21064095199108124,
-0.5985133647918701,
-0.12009009718894958,
-0.09976769983768463,
-0.26620611548423767,
-0.3194010257720947,
0.13187989592552185,
-0.021249031648039818,
-0.18384908139705658,
-0.6150575876235962,
0.7207428812980652,
-0.5076210498809814,
-0.30767741799354553,
-0.32864028215408325,
0.2913893163204193,
0.2863790690898895,
0.47789108753204346,
0.8069548010826111,
0.7712021470069885,
0.656578540802002,
-0.6304945945739746,
-0.014920778572559357,
0.4771588146686554,
-0.4202216863632202,
0.29866477847099304,
-0.6989998817443848,
-0.037755366414785385,
-0.0783933624625206,
-0.032697249203920364,
-0.7268041372299194,
-0.08114942908287048,
0.12678533792495728,
-0.3576602041721344,
0.2578843832015991,
-0.11578558385372162,
-0.248120978474617,
-0.3615204989910126,
-0.4986768960952759,
0.00972011312842369,
0.5020695924758911,
-0.47011637687683105,
0.45110681653022766,
0.6240415573120117,
-0.005703826434910297,
-0.44234421849250793,
-0.3716260492801666,
-0.02309603989124298,
-0.31267207860946655,
-0.34368717670440674,
0.41993317008018494,
0.16411414742469788,
-0.16824480891227722,
0.2569904029369354,
-0.07467559725046158,
-0.10068042576313019,
0.07301107048988342,
0.5115057229995728,
0.5724415183067322,
-0.19645246863365173,
0.19774873554706573,
-0.14699573814868927,
-0.033838894218206406,
0.016987377777695656,
-0.34011247754096985,
0.42725321650505066,
-0.25557205080986023,
-0.2528439164161682,
0.11351737380027771,
0.5418354868888855,
0.49646514654159546,
-0.4429972469806671,
0.4418890178203583,
0.5186106562614441,
0.009971179999411106,
-0.2508242428302765,
-0.06697697192430496,
-0.06564085930585861,
-0.43178263306617737,
0.7004725337028503,
-0.3071766793727875,
-0.8804013729095459,
0.21652235090732574,
0.12205659598112106,
0.0764014720916748,
0.5539318919181824,
0.3522195816040039,
-0.4648869037628174,
0.9075299501419067,
1.317894458770752,
0.32755792140960693,
0.7226898074150085,
-0.2802678644657135,
0.21810702979564667,
-0.9834519624710083,
-0.6470977067947388,
-0.20385165512561798,
-0.19822952151298523,
-0.3385722041130066,
-0.6790015697479248,
0.3523922860622406,
0.09672919660806656,
0.2955726087093353,
0.5211898684501648,
-0.5985652208328247,
0.49789032340049744,
0.38562923669815063,
-0.040367092937231064,
-0.01734624058008194,
0.07455090433359146,
-0.1674371212720871,
-0.17201492190361023,
-0.5604186654090881,
-0.7999643087387085,
0.9338881373405457,
0.42684561014175415,
0.6811655759811401,
-0.022801654413342476,
0.3569314181804657,
0.1987931728363037,
-0.054576002061367035,
-0.8990296721458435,
0.616578221321106,
-0.08173048496246338,
-0.34958165884017944,
-0.39231961965560913,
0.09218145161867142,
-0.869055449962616,
0.4733661413192749,
-0.239576518535614,
-1.0082696676254272,
0.4465431272983551,
0.1127849593758583,
-0.4089256525039673,
0.16036882996559143,
-0.5837574601173401,
0.7058935165405273,
-0.5445572733879089,
-0.048170655965805054,
-0.1268259733915329,
-0.5279489755630493,
0.18476563692092896,
0.22796599566936493,
0.09701471775770187,
-0.0627051368355751,
-0.190662682056427,
0.7342939376831055,
-0.3070813715457916,
0.8256245255470276,
0.06961299479007721,
0.16650210320949554,
0.5068041682243347,
0.14201970398426056,
0.16755083203315735,
-0.17962944507598877,
0.4351494312286377,
0.19207563996315002,
0.26717400550842285,
-0.20861287415027618,
-0.813570499420166,
0.12120848149061203,
-0.5897833704948425,
-0.6295693516731262,
-0.2823600471019745,
-0.24484631419181824,
-0.14924100041389465,
0.0409095324575901,
0.33977386355400085,
0.48009786009788513,
-0.2123030126094818,
0.05468745157122612,
0.737248957157135,
-0.4402350187301636,
0.4800049066543579,
0.4054644703865051,
-0.7373177409172058,
-0.07287277281284332,
1.1603244543075562,
-0.09871015697717667,
0.31359103322029114,
0.48995065689086914,
0.14754718542099,
-0.4479932487010956,
-0.6045148372650146,
-0.41145190596580505,
-0.020727990195155144,
-0.8272372484207153,
0.04042322561144829,
-0.7083194851875305,
-0.35905376076698303,
0.030518732964992523,
0.17888864874839783,
-0.2848241329193115,
-0.37096622586250305,
-0.4375508725643158,
-0.42799603939056396,
0.5480008125305176,
0.8339528441429138,
0.17713220417499542,
0.21185080707073212,
-0.63547283411026,
0.20829002559185028,
0.5304971933364868,
0.09757781773805618,
0.10042028874158859,
-0.4263944923877716,
-0.23148487508296967,
-0.2710648477077484,
-0.29509690403938293,
-0.9613410234451294,
0.5434681177139282,
0.2817715108394623,
0.8095828890800476,
0.5942265391349792,
-0.05179871991276741,
0.6686251163482666,
-0.627170205116272,
0.9831931591033936,
0.21507038176059723,
-0.8908074498176575,
0.8045685291290283,
0.02418847754597664,
-0.23056571185588837,
0.2690563499927521,
0.2740205228328705,
-0.3704480528831482,
-0.4327255189418793,
-0.6672669649124146,
-0.9394822120666504,
0.8111617565155029,
0.19622963666915894,
0.4172152280807495,
-0.043671444058418274,
-0.030917251482605934,
0.18900568783283234,
0.11632668226957321,
-0.8889300227165222,
-0.058501970022916794,
-0.5141227841377258,
0.09368912875652313,
0.15344439446926117,
-0.6212090253829956,
-0.13264743983745575,
-0.08263371884822845,
0.002164718694984913,
-0.07302818447351456,
0.5199196338653564,
0.3944878876209259,
-0.23633860051631927,
0.3645232915878296,
0.1353675276041031,
0.6834959387779236,
0.5183666944503784,
-0.16774392127990723,
0.4340750575065613,
-0.0532560832798481,
-0.37664535641670227,
-0.17282836139202118,
-0.3041762113571167,
-0.18520595133304596,
0.33622387051582336,
0.7445476055145264,
1.3625391721725464,
0.302969366312027,
-1.0109071731567383,
0.7521220445632935,
-0.06387221813201904,
0.009635412134230137,
-0.11959857493638992,
0.3647647500038147,
-0.18035587668418884,
0.3484855890274048,
0.3446216881275177,
0.06607505679130554,
0.23959894478321075,
-0.7419757843017578,
0.29625898599624634,
0.46958255767822266,
-0.7255656719207764,
-0.43528807163238525,
0.4346030652523041,
0.11609649658203125,
-0.27652066946029663,
0.2998114228248596,
-0.14750687777996063,
-0.9755164384841919,
0.5246406197547913,
0.24233923852443695,
0.6047248244285583,
0.28823623061180115,
0.38640740513801575,
0.1959698498249054,
0.3185334801673889,
0.19912594556808472,
0.15624861419200897,
-0.25807809829711914,
-0.6466085314750671,
-0.26798710227012634,
-0.5552624464035034,
-0.35667720437049866,
-0.015899699181318283,
-0.8075097799301147,
0.4214596152305603,
-0.3576134741306305,
-0.1691092997789383,
-0.11243361979722977,
-0.36228039860725403,
-0.6833652257919312,
-0.07596053183078766,
0.5195394158363342,
0.7691911458969116,
-0.7820878028869629,
0.8097950220108032,
0.48547717928886414,
-0.5907725691795349,
-0.9373638033866882,
-0.10153985768556595,
-0.16546092927455902,
-0.9354650974273682,
0.9859215617179871,
0.0920521542429924,
-0.08660924434661865,
-0.44570648670196533,
-0.6999192237854004,
-1.0726258754730225,
1.0201915502548218,
0.401126891374588,
-0.4457050859928131,
-0.1489463746547699,
-0.21476247906684875,
0.5594967007637024,
-0.5520886182785034,
0.33342111110687256,
0.3100612461566925,
0.2533183991909027,
0.27158594131469727,
-1.0390903949737549,
-0.12190800160169601,
-0.1316414773464203,
0.30135539174079895,
-0.09108035266399384,
-0.5596377849578857,
0.881930410861969,
-0.5639259815216064,
-0.644715428352356,
0.010717405006289482,
0.6583038568496704,
0.003974331077188253,
0.15436503291130066,
0.42853131890296936,
-0.0745784193277359,
0.6613205075263977,
0.035188522189855576,
1.3890453577041626,
0.15677359700202942,
0.3022795617580414,
1.2655922174453735,
-0.10214442014694214,
1.0345616340637207,
0.6763145327568054,
-0.1639823466539383,
0.44516444206237793,
0.6862138509750366,
-0.06725948303937912,
0.8484918475151062,
0.1157112866640091,
0.2504952847957611,
-0.24357131123542786,
-0.13860376179218292,
-0.25359559059143066,
0.8241116404533386,
0.29183638095855713,
-0.573720395565033,
-0.264897882938385,
0.18273389339447021,
-0.3842424750328064,
-0.1317153126001358,
-0.12678515911102295,
0.8532640933990479,
0.09486863017082214,
-0.49390318989753723,
0.4165864884853363,
-0.19586299359798431,
0.35550183057785034,
-0.5744033455848694,
-0.49821195006370544,
-0.01749872975051403,
-0.3363252282142639,
0.013938233256340027,
-1.1209560632705688,
0.3533273935317993,
0.02543376013636589,
-0.3138381838798523,
-0.4467581808567047,
0.6805214285850525,
-0.4938144385814667,
-0.2700751721858978,
0.33683547377586365,
0.3034679889678955,
0.4575474262237549,
0.0033871696796268225,
-0.5009831786155701,
0.3012044131755829,
0.3473741412162781,
-0.01219392754137516,
0.2963383197784424,
0.544720470905304,
-0.49371209740638733,
0.7282461524009705,
0.43667253851890564,
0.30915626883506775,
0.12458976358175278,
-0.18335144221782684,
0.8839044570922852,
-0.5757842659950256,
-0.4744332432746887,
-0.9117370247840881,
0.5566026568412781,
-0.36123326420783997,
-0.26799964904785156,
0.6473842263221741,
0.3945930004119873,
0.7802457809448242,
-0.12452538311481476,
0.6487366557121277,
-0.09793353825807571,
0.3534909188747406,
-0.8850528001785278,
0.5164546370506287,
-0.48913782835006714,
0.27350765466690063,
-0.20948545634746552,
-0.9216850996017456,
0.3296278715133667,
0.8112461566925049,
-0.24373529851436615,
-0.44072017073631287,
0.9231092929840088,
0.32727402448654175,
0.13659748435020447,
-0.16619107127189636,
0.49174508452415466,
0.02130497433245182,
0.3437665104866028,
0.4649158716201782,
1.1415743827819824,
-0.0012044587638229132,
0.805830717086792,
-0.04247625172138214,
-0.10238747298717499,
-0.20715439319610596,
-0.9275089502334595,
-0.830177903175354,
-0.8850792050361633,
-0.27752256393432617,
-0.03571096435189247,
-0.4224657416343689,
0.5627776980400085,
1.032300353050232,
-0.5144399404525757,
-0.06370942294597626,
0.3825456202030182,
0.2721050977706909,
-0.13414137065410614,
-0.21526870131492615,
0.5805789232254028,
-0.10645291954278946,
-0.5509920716285706,
0.33817777037620544,
0.6186875700950623,
0.3070584833621979,
-0.45607948303222656,
-0.019164402037858963,
0.5327414274215698,
0.04770912602543831,
0.7597988247871399,
0.22308482229709625,
-1.0416879653930664,
-0.5972679257392883,
0.05802520364522934,
-0.07948250323534012,
0.25843968987464905,
1.0373443365097046,
-1.0527868270874023,
0.7395339608192444,
0.09565125405788422,
0.4525541067123413,
0.673299252986908,
-0.2607024312019348,
0.6150269508361816,
-0.5835522413253784,
0.33189424872398376,
0.23506654798984528,
0.31910672783851624,
0.2596898674964905,
-0.31438395380973816,
0.24952788650989532,
0.14336860179901123,
0.2183622419834137,
-0.8198668956756592,
0.32234612107276917,
-1.4547659158706665,
-0.3245866894721985,
1.1699280738830566,
-0.3150157630443573,
-0.4135378897190094,
0.09351818263530731,
-0.6987596750259399,
-0.25953543186187744,
-0.3064139485359192,
0.510193943977356,
0.828397810459137,
-0.1642875075340271,
-0.48326459527015686,
-0.7468459010124207,
0.6592802405357361,
0.03970780968666077,
-0.4921465218067169,
0.02608143351972103,
0.3271521329879761,
0.12933509051799774,
0.16485756635665894,
0.5848714709281921,
-0.21761341392993927,
0.0446586012840271,
-0.015384772792458534,
-0.09564939141273499,
-0.25935080647468567,
-0.3540908694267273,
-0.022724665701389313,
0.01638592965900898,
0.22736585140228271,
-0.47797203063964844
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16437v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16437v2
|
Reasoning Runtime Behavior of a Program with LLM: How Far Are We?
| 2024-03-25T05:37:16 | 2024-07-03T04:10:43 |
Junkai Chen, Zhiyuan Pan, Xing Hu, Zhenhao Li, Ge Li, Xin Xia
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL
|
Large language models for code (i.e., code LLMs) have shown strong code
understanding and generation capabilities. To evaluate the capabilities of code
LLMs in various aspects, many benchmarks have been proposed (e.g., HumanEval
and ClassEval). Code reasoning is one of the most essential abilities of code
LLMs, but existing benchmarks for code reasoning are not sufficient. Typically,
they focus on predicting the input and output of a program, ignoring the
evaluation of the intermediate behavior during program execution, as well as
the logical consistency (e.g., the model should not give the correct output if
the prediction of execution path is wrong) when performing the reasoning. To
address these problems, in this paper, we propose a framework, namely REval,
for evaluating code reasoning abilities and consistency of code LLMs with
program execution. We utilize existing code benchmarks and adapt them to new
benchmarks within our framework. A large-scale empirical study is conducted and
most LLMs show unsatisfactory performance on both Runtime Behavior Reasoning
(i.e., an average accuracy of 44.4%) and Incremental Consistency Evaluation
(i.e., an average IC score of 10.3). Evaluation results of current code LLMs
reflect the urgent need for the community to strengthen the code reasoning
capability of code LLMs. Our code, data, and \newname leaderboard are available
at https://r-eval.github.io.
|
[
-0.20000125467777252,
-0.49845463037490845,
0.5888502597808838,
0.33472415804862976,
-0.11483380943536758,
0.254647821187973,
-0.46261247992515564,
-0.48205962777137756,
-0.19634132087230682,
0.5420102477073669,
-0.40855616331100464,
-0.7081412076950073,
-0.3460325300693512,
0.07640063762664795,
-0.21280398964881897,
0.7646231651306152,
-0.28388750553131104,
0.015287204645574093,
-0.6353702545166016,
-0.23630653321743011,
-0.5350418090820312,
-0.48694056272506714,
-0.23869578540325165,
-0.6092483997344971,
0.2060774564743042,
0.4595697224140167,
0.5202339887619019,
0.4807608723640442,
0.5562224388122559,
0.2485475391149521,
0.14553499221801758,
0.08882033824920654,
-0.5111208558082581,
0.39091065526008606,
-0.2643914818763733,
-0.5850532650947571,
-0.3903747498989105,
-0.08106109499931335,
0.4843370020389557,
0.47940176725387573,
-0.20706035196781158,
0.30262959003448486,
-0.1503656506538391,
0.7668015360832214,
-0.47965022921562195,
0.07792433351278305,
-0.5143621563911438,
-0.0958234891295433,
0.1392316073179245,
-0.44721853733062744,
-0.357369065284729,
-0.714993953704834,
-0.3320882022380829,
-0.20594017207622528,
-0.10580809414386749,
-0.04447193443775177,
0.48760125041007996,
0.2528628706932068,
-0.021858641877770424,
-0.3743818402290344,
-0.7316832542419434,
0.8342065811157227,
-0.8815178871154785,
0.5791710615158081,
0.09990353137254715,
0.20911167562007904,
-0.3776445686817169,
-0.6270706653594971,
-0.42913880944252014,
-0.48421818017959595,
0.24483303725719452,
-0.043619554489851,
-0.11308182775974274,
-0.004667567554861307,
0.4506072402000427,
0.3602057695388794,
-0.5805261135101318,
0.04868699610233307,
-0.11123257130384445,
-0.046604692935943604,
0.5617579817771912,
0.47481080889701843,
-0.036191198974847794,
0.22561527788639069,
-0.4649803638458252,
0.053417664021253586,
-0.7446510791778564,
0.10735443234443665,
0.39680659770965576,
-0.011182199232280254,
-0.039106108248233795,
0.5464605689048767,
-0.2533697783946991,
0.44358834624290466,
-0.182053342461586,
-0.02281837910413742,
0.26136982440948486,
-0.4139474928379059,
-0.2892586886882782,
-0.29631736874580383,
0.5317621827125549,
0.496833860874176,
0.5452702045440674,
-0.29744991660118103,
-0.4726453721523285,
0.33881962299346924,
0.4782916307449341,
-0.800388753414154,
-0.24326762557029724,
0.2641669809818268,
-0.5307660698890686,
-0.28208234906196594,
0.054221272468566895,
-0.6622215509414673,
-0.39243805408477783,
-0.43110090494155884,
0.13544467091560364,
-0.5041098594665527,
-0.23218218982219696,
0.17051643133163452,
0.232667475938797,
0.5050889253616333,
0.3712014853954315,
-0.3649238049983978,
0.1650686115026474,
0.9862316846847534,
0.5510863661766052,
-0.3987973928451538,
-0.34500956535339355,
-0.5561943054199219,
-0.17168934643268585,
-0.48772886395454407,
0.6080548763275146,
-0.7463449835777283,
-0.31889769434928894,
-0.09723742306232452,
-0.15257203578948975,
-0.09077990800142288,
-0.6793850660324097,
0.24120889604091644,
-0.7892048358917236,
-0.35122403502464294,
-0.004274351987987757,
-0.7385127544403076,
-0.10036931186914444,
0.4917679727077484,
-0.2250983864068985,
0.9139724373817444,
-0.04438559338450432,
-0.4460882544517517,
0.18910036981105804,
-0.324404239654541,
-0.5047792792320251,
-0.23370212316513062,
-0.3887156844139099,
-0.3564233183860779,
0.1990203857421875,
-0.008640175685286522,
0.044747982174158096,
-0.2958422601222992,
0.40787893533706665,
-0.42438289523124695,
-0.7776854634284973,
0.6068114042282104,
-0.5986772775650024,
0.48051923513412476,
0.30776822566986084,
-0.27162012457847595,
0.19492414593696594,
-0.5472510457038879,
0.5202576518058777,
-0.10832332074642181,
-0.5454602837562561,
0.15537376701831818,
0.024824654683470726,
-0.45878392457962036,
0.09190484881401062,
0.46855083107948303,
-0.2478371560573578,
0.47150516510009766,
-0.16023880243301392,
0.24049709737300873,
0.8478960394859314,
0.06629148870706558,
0.2984108030796051,
-0.38394248485565186,
0.9367081522941589,
-0.1370561122894287,
0.3109176754951477,
-0.189702570438385,
-0.35381367802619934,
-0.6410189270973206,
-0.030242832377552986,
0.015540133230388165,
0.5693216919898987,
-0.4851248562335968,
0.2586917579174042,
-0.14370042085647583,
-0.4236850440502167,
-0.05612992122769356,
0.21734920144081116,
0.7688623070716858,
0.26507270336151123,
0.25266316533088684,
-0.0806424617767334,
-0.642580509185791,
-0.7361680269241333,
-0.5863868594169617,
-0.6340265870094299,
0.23930363357067108,
0.19092144072055817,
0.5071320533752441,
-0.4312351942062378,
0.7952109575271606,
-0.42046216130256653,
0.3358675241470337,
-0.34842437505722046,
0.03795589506626129,
0.5303900837898254,
0.5021507143974304,
0.005330640822649002,
-0.4391852617263794,
0.004438506439328194,
-0.1608201414346695,
-0.8181124329566956,
-0.4615548253059387,
-0.10112220793962479,
-0.1577494889497757,
0.3563665449619293,
0.784722626209259,
-0.11942356079816818,
0.48015886545181274,
0.6126006245613098,
-0.16073179244995117,
0.7786142826080322,
-0.18439769744873047,
0.24685826897621155,
-0.5541964769363403,
0.2259909063577652,
-0.16606996953487396,
-0.23983407020568848,
-0.2475547045469284,
0.33591678738594055,
-0.03257258981466293,
0.08669067919254303,
-0.18156185746192932,
0.30690065026283264,
-0.38829517364501953,
-0.48123466968536377,
-0.32141345739364624,
-0.18423320353031158,
0.19694942235946655,
0.42451396584510803,
0.191646546125412,
1.0063449144363403,
0.393777072429657,
-0.5384930968284607,
0.4509694576263428,
-0.33262577652931213,
-0.3887641429901123,
0.4429455101490021,
-0.7468074560165405,
0.27460354566574097,
0.30295637249946594,
0.17144480347633362,
-0.8050605654716492,
0.1714337170124054,
0.05672632157802582,
-0.5156026482582092,
0.2660369277000427,
-0.3342409133911133,
-0.4507789611816406,
-0.2864995300769806,
-0.24493582546710968,
0.4625679850578308,
0.5663135051727295,
-0.5604159832000732,
0.39339277148246765,
0.03506062179803848,
0.2061532735824585,
-0.5605888962745667,
-0.49348005652427673,
0.13695977628231049,
-0.13530802726745605,
-0.6311654448509216,
0.08974220603704453,
-0.2876250445842743,
-0.48651251196861267,
-0.2017117738723755,
-0.34642964601516724,
-0.014665615744888783,
-0.009506793692708015,
0.44156110286712646,
0.31030935049057007,
-0.2838674485683441,
0.13418565690517426,
-0.34235870838165283,
-0.23820458352565765,
0.3014358580112457,
-0.12059836834669113,
0.36907222867012024,
-0.7681456804275513,
-0.7608050107955933,
-0.14038795232772827,
-0.08811666071414948,
0.6566576361656189,
-0.10739161819219589,
0.4600220322608948,
0.14213034510612488,
-0.1293402910232544,
-0.15562283992767334,
-0.602837860584259,
-0.012698444537818432,
-0.416310578584671,
0.25228607654571533,
-0.45066145062446594,
-0.6662454605102539,
0.7386347651481628,
-0.2637936472892761,
0.022815119475126266,
-0.1321554034948349,
0.5512005090713501,
0.10452647507190704,
0.8047499656677246,
0.42617538571357727,
0.11185857653617859,
0.1863376498222351,
-0.14582763612270355,
0.1677805781364441,
-0.879540741443634,
-0.47087275981903076,
-0.3460405468940735,
-0.11353439837694168,
-0.44134822487831116,
-0.636370837688446,
0.08204658329486847,
0.49232274293899536,
-0.2932765781879425,
0.38143113255500793,
-0.5187520384788513,
0.49295857548713684,
0.31479907035827637,
-0.12145044654607773,
0.5218270421028137,
-0.33390992879867554,
-0.2004813700914383,
0.14827361702919006,
-0.46339288353919983,
-0.7930912971496582,
0.9178476929664612,
0.4542548954486847,
1.2073156833648682,
0.11955886334180832,
0.7877911329269409,
0.3421710431575775,
0.49334660172462463,
-0.634308397769928,
0.6940750479698181,
0.2955050468444824,
-0.23129183053970337,
-0.05622483044862747,
-0.5728152394294739,
-0.6086347103118896,
0.03298270329833031,
0.22496247291564941,
-0.6378253698348999,
0.06598424166440964,
0.0710994303226471,
-0.03596791625022888,
0.19596007466316223,
-0.5844239592552185,
0.7818182706832886,
-0.31072184443473816,
-0.6527336239814758,
-0.13189798593521118,
-0.4280896484851837,
0.45627349615097046,
0.08580232411623001,
0.10941793024539948,
-0.10756304115056992,
-0.06167052686214447,
0.37393632531166077,
-0.6349038481712341,
0.6162427067756653,
-0.04870505630970001,
-0.318380743265152,
0.431416779756546,
0.3371524512767792,
0.5452666878700256,
0.4694291055202484,
-0.34022778272628784,
0.3638240396976471,
0.17680631577968597,
-0.02435261756181717,
-0.5875377058982849,
0.9319267868995667,
-0.4241960346698761,
-0.5527887940406799,
-0.436271995306015,
-0.4326125681400299,
-0.23941734433174133,
-0.027497656643390656,
0.11132780462503433,
0.48147276043891907,
-0.06093336641788483,
-0.011264953762292862,
0.6379640102386475,
-0.34600475430488586,
0.29428836703300476,
0.6960828304290771,
-0.6748403906822205,
-0.19942575693130493,
0.7214793562889099,
-0.28972288966178894,
0.19547972083091736,
0.16430841386318207,
0.034490395337343216,
-0.3943693935871124,
-0.6265048980712891,
-0.387403279542923,
0.050547339022159576,
-0.7333192825317383,
-0.37809911370277405,
-0.12320469319820404,
-0.18003959953784943,
-0.13566076755523682,
-0.22745774686336517,
-0.5486885905265808,
-0.05979235842823982,
-0.053631044924259186,
0.25143134593963623,
0.3145671784877777,
0.7700566053390503,
0.1078045442700386,
-0.3864421248435974,
-0.7059459686279297,
0.1666414886713028,
-0.03954119607806206,
0.7415168285369873,
-0.06878781318664551,
-0.6281799077987671,
-0.1668599396944046,
-0.04897015914320946,
-0.16665780544281006,
-0.5581995844841003,
-0.07026731222867966,
-0.16511733829975128,
0.5877311825752258,
0.1690441220998764,
0.16103488206863403,
0.596709132194519,
-0.2638704478740692,
0.48774412274360657,
0.11042021214962006,
-0.9060735106468201,
0.5930120944976807,
-0.1316051334142685,
0.40388327836990356,
0.6846631765365601,
-0.2753199636936188,
-0.3951559066772461,
-0.4950096607208252,
-0.4252062737941742,
-0.3300698697566986,
0.45701223611831665,
0.20002047717571259,
-0.012107020244002342,
-0.18271538615226746,
0.3705595135688782,
0.017974967136979103,
0.15863488614559174,
-0.6119027733802795,
0.03814641758799553,
-0.021730300039052963,
0.07545776665210724,
0.2588879466056824,
-0.041014164686203,
0.05295684561133385,
-0.2216557413339615,
0.41683828830718994,
-0.22725197672843933,
0.21730414032936096,
-0.038346465677022934,
-0.0659848302602768,
-0.1352643370628357,
0.21860355138778687,
0.7734284996986389,
1.1045701503753662,
-0.17942063510417938,
0.26839327812194824,
0.09029047191143036,
-0.3694473206996918,
0.14853985607624054,
-0.12448570877313614,
0.1022886261343956,
-0.32488030195236206,
0.5978239178657532,
0.2765229046344757,
0.18728068470954895,
-1.1243606805801392,
0.6830881237983704,
-0.08377629518508911,
-0.11278069764375687,
-0.5015654563903809,
0.3864361643791199,
0.24098068475723267,
0.5535387992858887,
0.08053489029407501,
0.1849956065416336,
-0.17872613668441772,
-0.48146259784698486,
0.2566834092140198,
0.41002053022384644,
-0.19973881542682648,
-0.26949697732925415,
0.4389345645904541,
0.15418466925621033,
-0.2914072871208191,
0.7990729212760925,
-0.26511791348457336,
-0.6384232640266418,
0.9233908653259277,
0.5638798475265503,
0.7494642734527588,
0.05791787803173065,
-0.10242269188165665,
0.28627878427505493,
0.363618940114975,
-0.020133676007390022,
0.5368146300315857,
0.11119355261325836,
-0.7166853547096252,
-0.6259344816207886,
-0.7597294449806213,
-0.44873347878456116,
0.04946520924568176,
-0.5264608263969421,
0.30629777908325195,
-0.6126581430435181,
0.04086175560951233,
-0.5492889285087585,
-0.030461888760328293,
-0.4226745367050171,
0.06664695590734482,
0.07670951634645462,
0.9549055695533752,
-0.48964107036590576,
0.9060063362121582,
0.8835446238517761,
-0.37682950496673584,
-0.7131962180137634,
0.11432062834501266,
-0.24949496984481812,
-0.8837220668792725,
0.7254984378814697,
0.20533695816993713,
-0.447584331035614,
-0.32244738936424255,
-0.4800797402858734,
-0.6616501808166504,
0.9147726893424988,
0.43205076456069946,
-0.6956913471221924,
0.3322693705558777,
-0.06431538611650467,
0.5809102058410645,
-0.49445080757141113,
0.2214074283838272,
0.5105803608894348,
0.5014773011207581,
0.2419814169406891,
-0.5537175536155701,
0.06371355056762695,
-0.26580217480659485,
0.15415599942207336,
0.24761882424354553,
-0.44345930218696594,
0.6584314107894897,
-0.6808858513832092,
-0.04433419555425644,
0.2107095867395401,
0.5011804103851318,
0.7351858615875244,
0.5989698767662048,
0.2052677720785141,
0.6133199334144592,
0.5503907203674316,
0.003066508797928691,
1.0638164281845093,
-0.5295836925506592,
0.28419843316078186,
1.1499027013778687,
-0.5020544528961182,
0.7638919949531555,
0.4934656023979187,
-0.4512845277786255,
0.6539109349250793,
0.32566267251968384,
0.03228423744440079,
0.25145044922828674,
0.6200805306434631,
-0.20480191707611084,
-0.4803762137889862,
0.1417541652917862,
-0.41551241278648376,
0.3940204381942749,
0.15663109719753265,
-0.33977216482162476,
0.025013955309987068,
-0.41795584559440613,
-0.057711537927389145,
0.37860456109046936,
-0.08127716183662415,
0.36264973878860474,
0.12535302340984344,
-0.7981097102165222,
0.7238382697105408,
0.10439219325780869,
0.43610692024230957,
-0.28353622555732727,
-0.43375542759895325,
-0.5262117981910706,
0.4041390120983124,
-0.32001546025276184,
-0.9865339994430542,
0.49173450469970703,
0.16936375200748444,
-0.31235644221305847,
-0.04557843506336212,
0.7019137144088745,
-0.10139767825603485,
-0.24479378759860992,
0.31716489791870117,
0.4762130081653595,
0.33767446875572205,
0.2030731439590454,
-0.7084771394729614,
0.5190423130989075,
0.06389360129833221,
-0.23437966406345367,
0.32776129245758057,
0.3711771070957184,
-0.029570747166872025,
0.8817922472953796,
0.6327325701713562,
0.015510888770222664,
0.017859844490885735,
0.2577727138996124,
0.9012296795845032,
-0.5248365998268127,
-0.11662734299898148,
-0.9932845234870911,
0.057050514966249466,
0.10663070529699326,
-0.27561983466148376,
0.7051020860671997,
0.7803742289543152,
0.5895543098449707,
0.1416066288948059,
0.5460235476493835,
0.09849710017442703,
0.26013386249542236,
-0.686623215675354,
0.14275851845741272,
-0.24903318285942078,
0.9278180003166199,
-0.2397582232952118,
-1.2087535858154297,
-0.1267630159854889,
0.6506247520446777,
-0.42476141452789307,
0.4053659737110138,
0.6334315538406372,
0.9517491459846497,
0.07616375386714935,
0.1410544067621231,
0.2823335826396942,
0.04003472253680229,
0.4047471880912781,
0.7667101621627808,
1.118059754371643,
-0.1243956908583641,
0.5610780119895935,
-0.028213147073984146,
-0.24785369634628296,
-0.2636168599128723,
-1.2290422916412354,
-0.5916062593460083,
0.07381787896156311,
-0.46282586455345154,
-0.5962752103805542,
0.18557162582874298,
0.7308605909347534,
0.3821006715297699,
-0.5755003690719604,
-0.36591771245002747,
-0.6631614565849304,
0.32441067695617676,
-0.29544228315353394,
-0.2811943292617798,
-0.04954061284661293,
-0.48821112513542175,
-0.3552742898464203,
0.45950016379356384,
0.44197991490364075,
-0.4775495231151581,
-0.4104284644126892,
-0.6216487884521484,
-0.035812195390462875,
0.1631035953760147,
0.33268484473228455,
0.47611919045448303,
-0.6756525039672852,
-0.49738743901252747,
0.06000342220067978,
-0.28498929738998413,
0.040824443101882935,
0.8920335173606873,
-0.8568335771560669,
0.36875057220458984,
0.5757585763931274,
0.555764377117157,
0.15672820806503296,
0.20061030983924866,
0.5855004191398621,
-0.5164010524749756,
-0.43456801772117615,
0.2787049412727356,
0.32600027322769165,
0.12121937423944473,
-0.1715914011001587,
0.7697802186012268,
0.19307197630405426,
-0.860027551651001,
-0.7962380647659302,
0.3910646140575409,
-0.7055981755256653,
-0.23089903593063354,
1.3172080516815186,
-0.3181639313697815,
0.0032802254427224398,
-0.08421214669942856,
0.11127138882875443,
0.14859172701835632,
-0.302141934633255,
0.4043252170085907,
0.4867982268333435,
-0.5965611934661865,
-0.2609582543373108,
-0.4564010202884674,
0.16298910975456238,
0.25116077065467834,
-0.7284867763519287,
0.4579726755619049,
0.6483450531959534,
0.42863795161247253,
0.016862517222762108,
0.6228418946266174,
-0.40353628993034363,
0.2654222249984741,
-0.04248182475566864,
0.3261794149875641,
-0.2434154599905014,
-0.2802775204181671,
-0.3666497766971588,
-0.07894831895828247,
0.3838048279285431,
-0.08951473236083984
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16435v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16435v1
|
InstUPR : Instruction-based Unsupervised Passage Reranking with Large Language Models
| 2024-03-25T05:31:22 | 2024-03-25T05:31:22 |
Chao-Wei Huang, Yun-Nung Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
This paper introduces InstUPR, an unsupervised passage reranking method based
on large language models (LLMs). Different from existing approaches that rely
on extensive training with query-document pairs or retrieval-specific
instructions, our method leverages the instruction-following capabilities of
instruction-tuned LLMs for passage reranking without any additional
fine-tuning. To achieve this, we introduce a soft score aggregation technique
and employ pairwise reranking for unsupervised passage reranking. Experiments
on the BEIR benchmark demonstrate that InstUPR outperforms unsupervised
baselines as well as an instruction-tuned reranker, highlighting its
effectiveness and superiority. Source code to reproduce all experiments is
open-sourced at https://github.com/MiuLab/InstUPR
|
[
-0.00008709221583558246,
-0.632102906703949,
0.4852677583694458,
0.32201460003852844,
-0.3865113854408264,
0.4543485641479492,
-0.5509379506111145,
0.05281015858054161,
-0.014770685695111752,
0.6054869890213013,
-0.14814022183418274,
-0.7643383145332336,
-0.4928876757621765,
-0.06666015833616257,
-0.624775230884552,
0.9711791276931763,
0.4984927177429199,
0.45871996879577637,
-0.5924833416938782,
-0.08213227987289429,
-0.179576575756073,
-0.4027397334575653,
-0.39104795455932617,
-0.533018946647644,
0.37248486280441284,
0.9627052545547485,
0.36092475056648254,
0.4298173487186432,
0.7207561135292053,
0.3090277910232544,
-0.42151010036468506,
0.06522280722856522,
-0.46675753593444824,
0.24816164374351501,
-0.30339598655700684,
-0.4691629409790039,
-0.18106810748577118,
-0.17986957728862762,
1.092374563217163,
0.8758072257041931,
-0.3494787812232971,
0.1233205571770668,
0.4620385766029358,
0.5793649554252625,
-0.5589245557785034,
0.001400772132910788,
-0.6478269100189209,
-0.1224755123257637,
-0.4483474791049957,
-0.24362611770629883,
-0.9401868581771851,
-0.6034501194953918,
-0.010160306468605995,
-0.2280731201171875,
0.28001633286476135,
0.0993000864982605,
0.25149470567703247,
0.13000890612602234,
-0.5670965313911438,
0.011774465441703796,
-0.14029423892498016,
0.8761930465698242,
-0.6699378490447998,
0.6637654900550842,
0.06058821082115173,
0.09675848484039307,
-0.31755393743515015,
-1.0403194427490234,
-0.22258883714675903,
-0.3565016984939575,
0.10354090481996536,
-0.09346269816160202,
0.2100585401058197,
0.0578291192650795,
-0.14834816753864288,
0.43231239914894104,
-0.616138756275177,
0.43733108043670654,
-0.32790935039520264,
0.08973771333694458,
0.7027878165245056,
0.03651073947548866,
0.18508045375347137,
0.16498203575611115,
-0.4335823953151703,
-0.1946476399898529,
-1.000326156616211,
-0.009102623909711838,
0.21624618768692017,
0.3746686279773712,
-0.09274663776159286,
0.628305196762085,
-0.252694308757782,
0.7198789715766907,
0.10326747596263885,
0.19506895542144775,
0.46435680985450745,
0.031232234090566635,
-0.09994573891162872,
0.19994723796844482,
0.7095739841461182,
0.23683315515518188,
0.3105299472808838,
-0.6281972527503967,
-0.4041344225406647,
-0.3647595942020416,
0.17932364344596863,
-0.9465051889419556,
-0.3206968307495117,
-0.19248659908771515,
-0.41228288412094116,
-0.25954291224479675,
0.27022308111190796,
-1.1097570657730103,
-0.07655984163284302,
-0.16526615619659424,
0.4529949426651001,
-0.24583619832992554,
-0.07248776406049728,
-0.07015527039766312,
-0.0036074607633054256,
0.6368321180343628,
0.1085236668586731,
-0.9023051261901855,
0.4959510266780853,
1.1213709115982056,
0.9141377806663513,
-0.4159682095050812,
-0.4968093931674957,
-0.8899545669555664,
0.058304402977228165,
-0.2851765751838684,
0.8171421885490417,
-1.01168954372406,
-0.5555175542831421,
0.20735707879066467,
0.14920592308044434,
-0.09578754752874374,
-0.5988486409187317,
0.712622344493866,
-0.6974262595176697,
0.13138334453105927,
0.01350770890712738,
-1.0902031660079956,
-0.03273819386959076,
-0.08818427473306656,
-0.2941529154777527,
1.0351265668869019,
0.12424051016569138,
-0.38811084628105164,
0.003214667085558176,
-0.6564623713493347,
-0.6298488974571228,
0.2762736976146698,
-0.008793792687356472,
-0.25095272064208984,
0.2619132101535797,
0.23549577593803406,
0.417812317609787,
-0.15660659968852997,
0.022891921922564507,
-0.2927984297275543,
-0.7685139179229736,
0.3416452705860138,
-0.4559984505176544,
0.7675094604492188,
0.1614372432231903,
-0.11358781903982162,
0.20986714959144592,
-0.2934488356113434,
0.38983291387557983,
-0.04378436878323555,
-0.5926901698112488,
-0.5298002362251282,
-0.1344558596611023,
-0.032952435314655304,
-0.23948898911476135,
0.3294822573661804,
-0.7743737697601318,
0.6573777794837952,
-0.5924921035766602,
0.47635412216186523,
0.849734902381897,
0.13293831050395966,
0.686776876449585,
0.09913694113492966,
0.4746411442756653,
-0.28374627232551575,
0.24007894098758698,
0.1169837936758995,
-0.4555605351924896,
-0.8231093287467957,
-0.02133166417479515,
0.753940999507904,
0.6102814674377441,
-0.6519055366516113,
0.3069846034049988,
-0.4435907006263733,
-0.5745337009429932,
-0.6898699998855591,
0.4174453914165497,
0.9165486097335815,
0.3701770305633545,
0.4916977882385254,
-0.03386073559522629,
0.04682859033346176,
-0.6967131495475769,
-0.20518839359283447,
0.1536703109741211,
-0.010436796583235264,
-0.24419845640659332,
0.4719626307487488,
-0.14912281930446625,
0.3251895606517792,
-0.9338162541389465,
-0.437598317861557,
-0.509856104850769,
0.11509594321250916,
0.2953263819217682,
0.6108617782592773,
0.19003179669380188,
-0.7360699772834778,
-0.6203641891479492,
-0.348315954208374,
-0.41903844475746155,
-0.18688374757766724,
0.4368637800216675,
-0.24526797235012054,
0.2563973367214203,
1.2038767337799072,
-0.29704469442367554,
0.13836073875427246,
0.4005289673805237,
-0.2434566169977188,
0.17914724349975586,
-0.5047353506088257,
-0.02953292988240719,
-0.9845340251922607,
-0.3930964469909668,
0.13382208347320557,
-0.26271137595176697,
-0.17486168444156647,
0.5029129981994629,
0.26145559549331665,
-0.04959513992071152,
-0.47135064005851746,
0.38884562253952026,
-0.6865244507789612,
-0.17918698489665985,
-0.19113972783088684,
0.08773604035377502,
-0.2615898847579956,
0.5276607871055603,
-0.13395944237709045,
0.9232553839683533,
0.5576887726783752,
-0.5376797914505005,
0.23182056844234467,
0.3335059583187103,
-0.758607029914856,
0.5112776160240173,
-0.753903865814209,
0.4474986791610718,
-0.02776249870657921,
0.21471825242042542,
-1.0442728996276855,
0.01900753565132618,
-0.05959608778357506,
-0.3248225450515747,
0.8522284626960754,
-0.6371000409126282,
-0.5025275945663452,
0.046512823551893234,
-0.36895138025283813,
0.48628854751586914,
0.457474023103714,
-0.7864999175071716,
0.1285121589899063,
0.4797728657722473,
-0.3245577812194824,
-0.42663952708244324,
-0.6904447078704834,
0.015540692955255508,
-0.1829841583967209,
-0.2811250388622284,
0.5716626644134521,
-0.15303809940814972,
-0.2782124876976013,
0.016028985381126404,
0.19788607954978943,
-0.1160445362329483,
-0.3140168786048889,
0.12682275474071503,
-0.08269532024860382,
-0.18967671692371368,
0.32696351408958435,
0.20498670637607574,
-0.18262116611003876,
0.09499749541282654,
-0.1017501950263977,
0.4844302237033844,
-0.3169589042663574,
-0.5321088433265686,
-0.2946866452693939,
0.5342199802398682,
0.5666895508766174,
-0.5529014468193054,
0.5226905941963196,
0.2766575217247009,
-0.0456443652510643,
-0.4895961880683899,
-0.3523169457912445,
-0.2330307513475418,
-0.5052533745765686,
0.3231014311313629,
-0.1838350147008896,
-0.7835935354232788,
0.0025199253577739,
-0.16993658244609833,
0.2954171597957611,
0.15981121361255646,
0.3170197904109955,
-0.29791098833084106,
1.0329694747924805,
0.7337847948074341,
-0.33038032054901123,
0.6043341159820557,
-0.34582269191741943,
-0.11365637928247452,
-1.0931860208511353,
-0.34972861409187317,
-0.6685965061187744,
-0.4702284634113312,
-0.8002943992614746,
-0.36006203293800354,
0.5998411774635315,
-0.23431967198848724,
-0.4771100878715515,
-0.3158400058746338,
-0.6334709525108337,
0.880582332611084,
1.080043077468872,
0.316820353269577,
0.26685187220573425,
0.029077662155032158,
-0.09432706236839294,
0.017411986365914345,
-0.7536731362342834,
-0.18210788071155548,
1.4262135028839111,
-0.011847172863781452,
1.0737454891204834,
0.48746564984321594,
0.8125761151313782,
0.537177324295044,
0.5794826149940491,
-0.7062250375747681,
0.7733343839645386,
-0.536575198173523,
-0.1826411932706833,
-0.4739154279232025,
-0.44244757294654846,
-0.9861390590667725,
0.45038527250289917,
-0.04010622575879097,
-0.5829092860221863,
-0.08064151555299759,
-0.17733849585056305,
-0.1447231024503708,
0.2407032549381256,
-0.81511390209198,
0.7574688792228699,
-0.34936410188674927,
-0.311557412147522,
-0.36323484778404236,
-0.6748828887939453,
0.33740341663360596,
0.20393726229667664,
-0.1408507376909256,
0.42167678475379944,
-0.11173880100250244,
0.8666515350341797,
-0.5529988408088684,
0.7101204991340637,
-0.10384800285100937,
0.21328425407409668,
0.164951890707016,
-0.011553996242582798,
0.47784727811813354,
0.1740245223045349,
-0.10659347474575043,
0.01733703538775444,
-0.18814069032669067,
-0.24619601666927338,
-0.6430270671844482,
1.2093130350112915,
-0.6265318989753723,
-0.6097419857978821,
-0.542016863822937,
-0.21638868749141693,
-0.27101001143455505,
0.12016145884990692,
0.41462936997413635,
0.8360480070114136,
-0.03536168858408928,
0.7144341468811035,
1.1934223175048828,
-0.07718544453382492,
0.4402082860469818,
0.7703938484191895,
-0.19782310724258423,
-0.5538727045059204,
0.9906892776489258,
0.1620047688484192,
0.16420426964759827,
0.9866493344306946,
0.28475120663642883,
-0.9527297019958496,
-0.7216710448265076,
-0.3551110625267029,
0.4283510148525238,
-0.6545935273170471,
-0.34247034788131714,
-0.19942964613437653,
-0.3362919092178345,
-0.4778638482093811,
-0.21294383704662323,
-0.29644373059272766,
-0.06095999479293823,
-0.1099487766623497,
-0.20087166130542755,
0.37760138511657715,
0.737277626991272,
-0.06020523980259895,
0.27852025628089905,
-0.6029377579689026,
0.20945920050144196,
0.27876317501068115,
0.6801003813743591,
-0.0962921604514122,
-1.0583194494247437,
-0.24286934733390808,
-0.1133003905415535,
-0.21024109423160553,
-0.849979817867279,
0.11007663607597351,
0.23154231905937195,
0.7548630833625793,
0.34795159101486206,
0.24415969848632812,
0.5198063850402832,
-0.4623294174671173,
0.3401361405849457,
-0.1935286968946457,
-0.7747775316238403,
0.3806579113006592,
0.00661055650562048,
0.3523224890232086,
0.7558150291442871,
0.0032782936468720436,
-0.2511967420578003,
-0.3432936668395996,
-0.42924636602401733,
-0.923205554485321,
0.41678839921951294,
-0.3001730144023895,
0.283242404460907,
0.18231771886348724,
0.3942268490791321,
-0.1399460881948471,
0.01725788600742817,
-0.5830497741699219,
-0.23584142327308655,
0.05838140845298767,
-0.3922080993652344,
-0.43919837474823,
-0.6175535917282104,
0.20673862099647522,
-0.3970753252506256,
0.8214831948280334,
0.03668275475502014,
-0.07007796317338943,
0.10753932595252991,
-0.30141186714172363,
0.02533213421702385,
0.4977447986602783,
0.4004982113838196,
0.5843368768692017,
-0.4034123718738556,
-0.00091244449140504,
0.16594313085079193,
-0.5678426027297974,
0.20142486691474915,
0.1125727966427803,
-0.498440146446228,
-0.06167616695165634,
0.3577398657798767,
0.2411436289548874,
0.7017967104911804,
-0.6123760938644409,
0.7096309065818787,
-0.01197543554008007,
-0.0684589222073555,
-0.5051926374435425,
0.058883972465991974,
0.03885892778635025,
0.4309498369693756,
0.21884095668792725,
-0.6654133796691895,
0.11451751738786697,
-0.3484148681163788,
0.3053153157234192,
0.5320682525634766,
-0.594296395778656,
-0.01873520389199257,
0.6631404161453247,
0.516819417476654,
-0.5422675013542175,
1.1306535005569458,
-0.2668171226978302,
-0.2971537411212921,
0.2868940532207489,
0.6621148586273193,
0.8408125042915344,
-0.4728221595287323,
0.20513831079006195,
0.06818095594644547,
0.5330862998962402,
-0.1748190075159073,
0.3021262586116791,
-0.016353797167539597,
-0.3762925863265991,
-0.4510703384876251,
-0.49719274044036865,
-0.7159057259559631,
0.3462122976779938,
-0.8437080979347229,
0.0762571468949318,
-0.28966450691223145,
0.338907927274704,
-0.21599739789962769,
0.1333361715078354,
-0.39515969157218933,
0.08859995007514954,
-0.09313786029815674,
1.2357460260391235,
-0.5791404843330383,
0.8804740309715271,
0.8882660865783691,
-0.4011072814464569,
-0.5012171864509583,
0.3996303677558899,
-0.2014320343732834,
-0.5748147964477539,
0.44375261664390564,
0.06381655484437943,
-0.2981768250465393,
0.3706667721271515,
-0.6265518069267273,
-0.7898727655410767,
0.8362524509429932,
0.4107270836830139,
-0.725101113319397,
0.24570445716381073,
-0.00048405409324914217,
0.31971314549446106,
-0.15516948699951172,
0.11529497057199478,
0.28225186467170715,
0.24290265142917633,
-0.059805043041706085,
-0.46359747648239136,
-0.20107823610305786,
-0.09743969887495041,
-0.23282425105571747,
0.45895373821258545,
-0.8269686102867126,
0.5777305364608765,
-0.401530385017395,
0.013951856642961502,
0.166058748960495,
1.0490130186080933,
0.12839850783348083,
0.38867634534835815,
0.591659426689148,
0.7648410797119141,
0.6217553019523621,
-0.019039997830986977,
0.7777504920959473,
-0.1553008109331131,
0.08823201060295105,
1.3337692022323608,
-0.24495455622673035,
1.2207088470458984,
0.4092724621295929,
-0.07938139140605927,
0.6735000610351562,
0.4393816590309143,
0.13544751703739166,
0.7109008431434631,
0.34350746870040894,
-0.3681265413761139,
-0.42406710982322693,
-0.07785504311323166,
-0.46261927485466003,
0.7632801532745361,
0.34219250082969666,
-0.38271647691726685,
-0.2139005810022354,
-0.1526920199394226,
0.05447214096784592,
0.29312363266944885,
-0.6309114098548889,
0.7727068066596985,
0.27157190442085266,
-0.745304524898529,
0.35784345865249634,
0.08682487905025482,
0.7559075355529785,
-0.6792349219322205,
-0.290090948343277,
-0.5461978912353516,
0.5557655096054077,
0.06622946262359619,
-1.2637947797775269,
-0.2038220465183258,
0.10850038379430771,
0.02564404159784317,
-0.3288160562515259,
0.40385696291923523,
-0.5579870939254761,
-0.7681086659431458,
0.18842102587223053,
0.5543744564056396,
0.3055379092693329,
-0.13032464683055878,
-0.4911614954471588,
-0.28155240416526794,
-0.014461886137723923,
-0.3354606330394745,
0.6557999849319458,
0.5822494626045227,
-0.31911543011665344,
0.92204749584198,
0.613509476184845,
-0.18971435725688934,
-0.027270831167697906,
0.4889160096645355,
0.740002453327179,
-0.7183139324188232,
-0.5245490074157715,
-0.800167977809906,
0.144697368144989,
-0.06485162675380707,
-0.48329296708106995,
0.6508987545967102,
0.8967676758766174,
1.013927936553955,
0.07109177112579346,
0.49543464183807373,
0.5490362048149109,
0.7296230792999268,
-0.7102289199829102,
0.7024363875389099,
-0.758131206035614,
0.23925799131393433,
-0.21625959873199463,
-0.8799656629562378,
-0.2606213688850403,
0.19445110857486725,
-0.1388150155544281,
-0.02027350291609764,
0.3747568130493164,
1.042913556098938,
-0.36328941583633423,
-0.3920351266860962,
0.144695445895195,
0.1049768403172493,
0.029077809303998947,
0.5612156391143799,
0.8766435980796814,
0.11920703947544098,
0.7311486601829529,
-0.27956461906433105,
-0.19549128413200378,
-0.5421241521835327,
-0.684651792049408,
-0.6993181705474854,
-0.5071476101875305,
-0.3486267626285553,
-0.08663175255060196,
0.20867176353931427,
0.7828245162963867,
0.41942521929740906,
-0.6336498260498047,
-0.2948295474052429,
0.08885344117879868,
0.5432778000831604,
-0.3757179081439972,
-0.26739948987960815,
0.5969319939613342,
-0.41211456060409546,
-0.8327593207359314,
0.8008556365966797,
0.09296650439500809,
-0.04334622621536255,
-0.40010878443717957,
-0.07350386679172516,
-0.19548606872558594,
-0.08555982261896133,
0.4934593141078949,
0.27738121151924133,
-0.4825345575809479,
-0.046401917934417725,
-0.12327370047569275,
-0.13753627240657806,
-0.14059726893901825,
0.7358399033546448,
-0.6432809829711914,
0.13248944282531738,
0.5873009562492371,
0.45402079820632935,
0.377773642539978,
0.21514728665351868,
0.35852399468421936,
-0.9343430995941162,
-0.0008491136250086129,
0.2157537341117859,
0.4749249219894409,
0.4306120276451111,
-0.18941831588745117,
0.6609225869178772,
0.03928065672516823,
-0.7757658958435059,
-1.0091239213943481,
-0.00045208464143797755,
-0.914269745349884,
-0.33141300082206726,
1.335301160812378,
0.03862324357032776,
-0.06255782395601273,
-0.001213745679706335,
0.1072700023651123,
0.1250874400138855,
-0.5788772702217102,
0.6665710210800171,
0.1501191407442093,
0.06657206267118454,
-0.30361634492874146,
-0.4014459550380707,
0.1829252690076828,
0.28040340542793274,
-0.6407133340835571,
0.003138274885714054,
0.2838447093963623,
0.5231796503067017,
-0.3433242440223694,
0.5229694247245789,
-0.06632880866527557,
-0.008530107326805592,
-0.30243366956710815,
-0.043745823204517365,
-0.1888340264558792,
-0.41689378023147583,
-0.41567620635032654,
0.20965100824832916,
0.15234166383743286,
-0.6222443580627441
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16432v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16432v3
|
$\textit{LinkPrompt}$: Natural and Universal Adversarial Attacks on Prompt-based Language Models
| 2024-03-25T05:27:35 | 2024-04-09T13:05:49 |
Yue Xu, Wenjie Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Prompt-based learning is a new language model training paradigm that adapts
the Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs) to downstream tasks, which revitalizes
the performance benchmarks across various natural language processing (NLP)
tasks. Instead of using a fixed prompt template to fine-tune the model, some
research demonstrates the effectiveness of searching for the prompt via
optimization. Such prompt optimization process of prompt-based learning on PLMs
also gives insight into generating adversarial prompts to mislead the model,
raising concerns about the adversarial vulnerability of this paradigm. Recent
studies have shown that universal adversarial triggers (UATs) can be generated
to alter not only the predictions of the target PLMs but also the prediction of
corresponding Prompt-based Fine-tuning Models (PFMs) under the prompt-based
learning paradigm. However, UATs found in previous works are often unreadable
tokens or characters and can be easily distinguished from natural texts with
adaptive defenses. In this work, we consider the naturalness of the UATs and
develop $\textit{LinkPrompt}$, an adversarial attack algorithm to generate UATs
by a gradient-based beam search algorithm that not only effectively attacks the
target PLMs and PFMs but also maintains the naturalness among the trigger
tokens. Extensive results demonstrate the effectiveness of
$\textit{LinkPrompt}$, as well as the transferability of UATs generated by
$\textit{LinkPrompt}$ to open-sourced Large Language Model (LLM) Llama2 and
API-accessed LLM GPT-3.5-turbo. The resource is available at
$\href{https://github.com/SavannahXu79/LinkPrompt}{https://github.com/SavannahXu79/LinkPrompt}$.
|
[
-0.4707469046115875,
-1.1916701793670654,
0.15916207432746887,
-0.08170605450868607,
-0.26212644577026367,
-0.23246647417545319,
-0.01581615023314953,
-0.28476259112358093,
-0.1297861635684967,
0.284918874502182,
-0.7680830359458923,
-0.402085542678833,
-0.47445300221443176,
0.2820555865764618,
-0.3501195013523102,
1.148163080215454,
0.17856159806251526,
0.148257777094841,
0.4500683546066284,
-0.2915748059749603,
-0.5333417057991028,
-0.36268502473831177,
-1.0323498249053955,
0.1419440507888794,
0.4809170365333557,
-0.1882157176733017,
0.9218900203704834,
0.3894292712211609,
0.5840056538581848,
0.25508785247802734,
-0.10218358784914017,
-0.024573910981416702,
-0.3408324122428894,
0.3773004710674286,
-0.20985004305839539,
-0.35273638367652893,
-0.1566053032875061,
0.21164384484291077,
0.5880764126777649,
0.5274212956428528,
0.1623663455247879,
-0.05486861988902092,
0.20987774431705475,
0.5551942586898804,
-0.452493280172348,
-0.20196300745010376,
-0.9984297156333923,
-0.05924439802765846,
-0.2294265478849411,
-0.38229137659072876,
-0.48007041215896606,
-0.3585261106491089,
-0.05990222841501236,
-0.4882083833217621,
0.49892231822013855,
0.3389623761177063,
0.7787898778915405,
0.3815227448940277,
-0.43326136469841003,
-0.49942347407341003,
-0.1358405500650406,
0.39325404167175293,
-0.4046531915664673,
0.1292238086462021,
-0.005770121235400438,
0.24226954579353333,
-0.7850944995880127,
-0.6264868378639221,
-0.349373996257782,
-0.49269813299179077,
0.03099832497537136,
-0.12432342022657394,
-0.6645851731300354,
0.21210074424743652,
0.4511433243751526,
0.22549577057361603,
-0.9361503720283508,
0.20084120333194733,
-0.12041167169809341,
-0.3284463584423065,
0.2663086950778961,
0.16795198619365692,
0.6925464272499084,
-0.3036049008369446,
-0.6860305070877075,
0.15416140854358673,
-1.1449856758117676,
0.35435524582862854,
0.5389276146888733,
0.5466973781585693,
-0.13695836067199707,
0.22411035001277924,
-0.17629380524158478,
0.9280146360397339,
0.08965831995010376,
0.3239600658416748,
-0.24192309379577637,
-0.3071989119052887,
-0.24758009612560272,
-0.04788490757346153,
1.1786969900131226,
-0.0803498849272728,
0.2610433101654053,
-0.33771568536758423,
-0.14411476254463196,
0.06756538152694702,
0.3158113658428192,
-0.4888269603252411,
-0.2892382740974426,
-0.08759833872318268,
-0.284057080745697,
-0.38435113430023193,
0.09177494049072266,
-0.48976436257362366,
-0.38637852668762207,
-0.15654322504997253,
0.5147647261619568,
-0.535551905632019,
0.049947984516620636,
-0.03796875476837158,
0.15982209146022797,
-0.10056465119123459,
0.20914122462272644,
-0.7000848054885864,
-0.025072911754250526,
0.578969419002533,
0.8577660322189331,
0.020148515701293945,
-0.3923526406288147,
-1.0515246391296387,
-0.25383639335632324,
-0.10071022808551788,
0.7413752675056458,
-0.3762550354003906,
-0.42737987637519836,
0.22970376908779144,
0.017985500395298004,
-0.2640816867351532,
-0.287376344203949,
0.7226799130439758,
-0.7619501948356628,
0.29950472712516785,
-0.4379761517047882,
-0.32874616980552673,
-0.026018593460321426,
0.12373089790344238,
-0.916513979434967,
0.8374617695808411,
-0.16220562160015106,
-0.9364082217216492,
0.12197141349315643,
-0.8493685722351074,
-0.5003729462623596,
-0.001717880368232727,
-0.0017056703800335526,
-0.1789712905883789,
0.023801535367965698,
0.2654205560684204,
0.33348727226257324,
-0.48790863156318665,
0.2639787495136261,
-0.34063348174095154,
-0.3172402083873749,
0.36014893651008606,
-0.6995604038238525,
1.2323991060256958,
0.363189697265625,
-0.5768707394599915,
0.38315349817276,
-0.612917423248291,
-0.3403904438018799,
0.2818657457828522,
-0.21247228980064392,
-0.2552310824394226,
-0.24331198632717133,
-0.3969026505947113,
0.1452944576740265,
0.1989092230796814,
-0.3593895435333252,
0.4273728132247925,
-0.5984174609184265,
0.08806169778108597,
0.8519728779792786,
0.27170467376708984,
0.4001022279262543,
-0.18475933372974396,
0.5961182713508606,
-0.2687627673149109,
0.4940436780452728,
-0.358289510011673,
-0.6386903524398804,
-0.5124934315681458,
-0.1865118443965912,
-0.0476715974509716,
0.519807755947113,
-1.059362769126892,
0.30785930156707764,
0.3207622170448303,
-0.3031412363052368,
-0.41614848375320435,
0.1617031842470169,
0.622709333896637,
0.6044414639472961,
0.401378333568573,
0.0570751391351223,
-0.4923107326030731,
-0.457732230424881,
-0.5437186360359192,
-0.20178380608558655,
-0.08309663087129593,
-0.1835426390171051,
0.3133343756198883,
-0.008805163204669952,
0.7145600318908691,
-0.3290606439113617,
-0.030687477439641953,
-0.06815288215875626,
0.459847092628479,
0.22622010111808777,
0.28173089027404785,
0.751181960105896,
-0.7830345630645752,
-0.3826557695865631,
-0.4645572900772095,
-0.7517275810241699,
-0.3274616599082947,
-0.1953495591878891,
-0.04759174585342407,
0.1754031628370285,
0.4760452210903168,
-0.6758540272712708,
0.3612123131752014,
0.4356151819229126,
-0.7007312178611755,
0.8259775638580322,
-0.01827612891793251,
0.19404104351997375,
-1.119486927986145,
0.11952266842126846,
0.26125141978263855,
0.08598435670137405,
-0.5950050950050354,
0.5734338164329529,
-0.03842029348015785,
-0.3586118519306183,
-0.680934727191925,
0.679938554763794,
-0.4655110538005829,
0.1968240886926651,
-0.3219901919364929,
0.07440328598022461,
-0.19999611377716064,
0.41965627670288086,
-0.40740448236465454,
1.0457617044448853,
0.709345281124115,
-0.7634453773498535,
0.8171067237854004,
0.1682032197713852,
0.13483762741088867,
0.8105065822601318,
-0.5877710580825806,
0.09617569297552109,
0.08418843895196915,
0.19034643471240997,
-0.9235147833824158,
0.1814899891614914,
0.5554252862930298,
-0.6610264778137207,
0.3577631413936615,
-0.04209766164422035,
-0.41976290941238403,
-0.1961902678012848,
-0.5643600225448608,
0.023675909265875816,
0.40599605441093445,
-0.8278676271438599,
0.11616677045822144,
-0.0974571630358696,
-0.18548548221588135,
-0.627726137638092,
-0.05655670911073685,
0.41745349764823914,
-0.2071048468351364,
-0.5020501613616943,
0.006387779023498297,
-0.19854684174060822,
-0.10912191867828369,
0.05775097385048866,
0.10798802226781845,
0.22782136499881744,
0.4072970151901245,
0.25816798210144043,
0.4221968650817871,
-0.24241934716701508,
0.028525933623313904,
-0.25546297430992126,
-0.3084475100040436,
0.33988672494888306,
-0.21113871037960052,
0.5619266629219055,
-0.17368561029434204,
-0.6192190051078796,
-0.48488396406173706,
0.2041231244802475,
0.37369853258132935,
-0.16689634323120117,
0.641011118888855,
0.863205075263977,
-0.2348768711090088,
-0.32359668612480164,
-0.30767685174942017,
-0.37129485607147217,
-0.5076921582221985,
0.22302575409412384,
-0.3819502890110016,
-0.8778135776519775,
0.5677236914634705,
-0.12762467563152313,
-0.13265018165111542,
0.6419615745544434,
0.40359044075012207,
0.05910522863268852,
0.9664125442504883,
0.3012242913246155,
-0.3235641121864319,
0.4426918029785156,
-0.19409391283988953,
0.05381753668189049,
-0.9263032674789429,
-0.2380785495042801,
-0.7221639156341553,
-0.11492760479450226,
-0.4379201829433441,
-0.14417815208435059,
0.33626750111579895,
0.19078882038593292,
-0.39390578866004944,
0.5087891817092896,
-0.2530280649662018,
0.26880544424057007,
0.9129608273506165,
-0.0799076110124588,
0.10116692632436752,
0.08692920207977295,
-0.5528929233551025,
-0.08062504976987839,
-0.7141408920288086,
-0.23788920044898987,
1.162606120109558,
0.11250381916761398,
0.7270389199256897,
0.08019249141216278,
0.4229355454444885,
0.5703570246696472,
-0.00407523475587368,
-0.5141297578811646,
0.6205152869224548,
-0.09974519163370132,
-0.48076632618904114,
-0.10158458352088928,
-0.524222731590271,
-1.09975004196167,
-0.12928147614002228,
-0.21249669790267944,
-0.7818773984909058,
-0.04794866591691971,
0.0036165970377624035,
-0.24727636575698853,
0.672209620475769,
-0.4217345118522644,
0.8003064393997192,
-0.224028080701828,
-0.37778693437576294,
0.0803074836730957,
-0.6937428712844849,
0.24835793673992157,
-0.08125070482492447,
0.06233571469783783,
0.03927601873874664,
0.17814454436302185,
0.576399028301239,
-0.16347528994083405,
0.945386528968811,
-0.21358998119831085,
-0.08036825805902481,
0.3564777374267578,
0.4506514072418213,
0.8995163440704346,
0.06929509341716766,
0.003849626984447241,
0.019453736022114754,
-0.5006502866744995,
-0.489365816116333,
-0.6769816279411316,
0.802498996257782,
-0.5094893574714661,
-0.7431638240814209,
-0.40210914611816406,
-0.5067277550697327,
-0.10748337209224701,
0.017925729975104332,
0.5366184115409851,
0.680474042892456,
-0.3669312000274658,
-0.011147355660796165,
0.8030627965927124,
-0.3187789022922516,
0.6080338358879089,
0.7088187336921692,
0.2006199061870575,
-0.43817058205604553,
0.9076504111289978,
-0.3101333975791931,
0.30306050181388855,
0.38017910718917847,
-0.004334923345595598,
-0.47674939036369324,
-0.6598048806190491,
-0.42652666568756104,
0.06873660534620285,
-0.7533649206161499,
-0.48525482416152954,
-0.2921234667301178,
-0.1614433228969574,
-0.4469418525695801,
-0.3723534047603607,
-0.003714358899742365,
-0.03042803704738617,
-0.5465648174285889,
0.1502508670091629,
0.40801718831062317,
0.6967065930366516,
-0.14627663791179657,
0.2984640896320343,
-0.8152036070823669,
0.49473273754119873,
0.27630695700645447,
0.18492749333381653,
-0.3097952604293823,
-0.5625909566879272,
-0.11067473143339157,
0.04043542966246605,
-0.43229299783706665,
-1.144970178604126,
0.23424756526947021,
-0.024971790611743927,
0.7634949684143066,
0.5769760608673096,
0.4323027729988098,
0.09645798057317734,
-0.24024784564971924,
0.8336434364318848,
0.4421216547489166,
-0.7326569557189941,
0.6976711750030518,
-0.46849048137664795,
0.2998068630695343,
0.49375277757644653,
0.5962308645248413,
-0.3545689880847931,
-0.46894875168800354,
-0.6589683294296265,
-0.5582866072654724,
0.6987497210502625,
0.1644921898841858,
-0.06765860319137573,
-0.14880023896694183,
0.33060574531555176,
-0.07206299901008606,
-0.03126933053135872,
-0.7305570244789124,
-0.5459070205688477,
-0.08710967004299164,
-0.32008394598960876,
0.17626042664051056,
-0.2809574007987976,
-0.025900796055793762,
-0.004359056241810322,
0.6997539401054382,
-0.08701899647712708,
0.14617781341075897,
0.05114171653985977,
-0.16066785156726837,
-0.1750604510307312,
0.3602178990840912,
0.3013189733028412,
0.18002985417842865,
-0.10649944841861725,
0.18487316370010376,
0.15581175684928894,
-0.47802114486694336,
0.3434063792228699,
0.288520485162735,
-0.3732655644416809,
-0.005776458885520697,
0.5274072885513306,
1.0533796548843384,
0.4426422417163849,
-0.4326624274253845,
0.4362284541130066,
-0.12258918583393097,
-0.011877465061843395,
0.15270231664180756,
0.276685506105423,
-0.3288639187812805,
0.2544037401676178,
0.4769284427165985,
0.319202721118927,
0.21641811728477478,
-0.42963746190071106,
0.3161783218383789,
0.7786408066749573,
-0.6041080355644226,
-0.5620477795600891,
0.8770632743835449,
0.32486531138420105,
-0.46699389815330505,
0.3189253807067871,
-0.5946706533432007,
-0.7360809445381165,
0.47139063477516174,
0.7166998386383057,
1.1187188625335693,
-0.5127788782119751,
0.34286537766456604,
0.3170364499092102,
0.45833322405815125,
0.1947401463985443,
-0.006678570993244648,
0.10854188352823257,
-0.37760767340660095,
-0.19205400347709656,
-0.6179913878440857,
-0.19512023031711578,
0.25757917761802673,
-0.5123307108879089,
0.3890635669231415,
-0.5874140858650208,
0.05707418546080589,
-0.16090278327465057,
0.0814410075545311,
-0.4459993243217468,
0.15466487407684326,
0.0038526803255081177,
0.7953816652297974,
-0.9662449955940247,
0.7859160304069519,
0.8072270750999451,
-0.575881838798523,
-0.7077636122703552,
0.15688379108905792,
0.43931204080581665,
-0.8234148621559143,
0.8612625002861023,
-0.13078181445598602,
-0.07335899770259857,
0.12352608889341354,
-0.2660749852657318,
-0.6835631728172302,
0.7211397886276245,
0.7055457830429077,
-0.22625447809696198,
-0.24463489651679993,
0.12180785089731216,
0.23815849423408508,
-0.12545937299728394,
0.07186288386583328,
0.39012423157691956,
0.19694066047668457,
0.12032751739025116,
-0.7175735831260681,
0.510168194770813,
-0.4074586033821106,
-0.18434226512908936,
0.30857226252555847,
-0.2941591143608093,
0.9445059895515442,
-0.23995567858219147,
-0.28371188044548035,
0.051366329193115234,
0.31254735589027405,
0.2289845496416092,
0.27094513177871704,
0.2628031373023987,
0.6545194387435913,
0.38702917098999023,
-0.09783464670181274,
1.0923361778259277,
-0.3755447268486023,
0.32671988010406494,
0.8528935313224792,
0.05348159000277519,
0.4991985559463501,
0.21906934678554535,
-0.42503008246421814,
0.24133464694023132,
0.5391671061515808,
-0.06960558891296387,
0.46208202838897705,
0.06130673736333847,
-0.44111841917037964,
0.09450776129961014,
-0.20345185697078705,
-0.5587840676307678,
0.2570262849330902,
0.07283536344766617,
-0.19572196900844574,
-0.4695053696632385,
0.07454034686088562,
0.31394487619400024,
0.20776310563087463,
-0.2949671149253845,
0.7702555656433105,
0.023449914529919624,
-0.4375836253166199,
0.80218505859375,
-0.04991864413022995,
0.8680776953697205,
-0.880667507648468,
0.14883315563201904,
-0.16733171045780182,
-0.18826302886009216,
0.03386816009879112,
-0.41217172145843506,
0.08938470482826233,
0.22447998821735382,
0.0074476320296525955,
0.1092129647731781,
0.7965736985206604,
-0.018979106098413467,
-0.3194904923439026,
0.3649299144744873,
0.18621057271957397,
-0.26596134901046753,
-0.396582692861557,
-1.045307993888855,
0.008626851253211498,
0.15505294501781464,
-0.4225207567214966,
0.4902196526527405,
0.3916678726673126,
0.17214368283748627,
0.6319058537483215,
0.9736620783805847,
0.4173654615879059,
0.01870141364634037,
0.03390871360898018,
0.8466610312461853,
-0.5769187808036804,
-0.5034322738647461,
-1.029847264289856,
0.23421233892440796,
0.02280205301940441,
-0.3412973880767822,
0.8530542850494385,
0.3646395802497864,
0.5843194723129272,
0.04409829154610634,
0.6607450246810913,
0.1139410212635994,
0.3621726334095001,
-0.9121106266975403,
0.7430810332298279,
-0.39966803789138794,
0.4268585443496704,
-0.35055679082870483,
-0.7496373653411865,
-0.2828032672405243,
0.05067390576004982,
-0.31033703684806824,
-0.04937802255153656,
0.9939215183258057,
0.7636091113090515,
0.11881126463413239,
0.11351759731769562,
0.2333313226699829,
0.06083435192704201,
0.41048556566238403,
0.6567376255989075,
0.6846747398376465,
-0.35269710421562195,
0.6326696276664734,
0.009604777209460735,
-0.1129128709435463,
-0.361795037984848,
-0.7789863348007202,
-0.9500436782836914,
-0.6980794072151184,
-0.3186788558959961,
-0.27850353717803955,
0.3821861147880554,
0.9272973537445068,
0.26239728927612305,
-0.8469386696815491,
0.19041483104228973,
-0.36345407366752625,
0.03766070678830147,
0.1748499870300293,
-0.22828513383865356,
0.5909091830253601,
-0.7313909530639648,
-0.46206438541412354,
0.6087668538093567,
0.16753917932510376,
0.23055404424667358,
-0.21832633018493652,
-0.20041154325008392,
-0.37944653630256653,
-0.08680154383182526,
0.21085737645626068,
0.6190798282623291,
-0.8090248107910156,
-0.0775751993060112,
-0.06282341480255127,
-0.10753574967384338,
-0.3000341057777405,
0.795798659324646,
-0.8147792816162109,
0.35558179020881653,
0.36106812953948975,
0.7456417679786682,
-0.3288981318473816,
-0.11119651049375534,
0.6186074614524841,
-0.7544143199920654,
0.43484723567962646,
-0.031853411346673965,
0.6220474243164062,
0.3340776264667511,
-0.585946798324585,
0.34135302901268005,
0.6042959094047546,
-0.2724609673023224,
-0.7961881756782532,
0.5796611309051514,
-0.6992791891098022,
-0.5503552556037903,
1.1206724643707275,
-0.3408564627170563,
-0.1361682116985321,
-0.05778242647647858,
-0.43065619468688965,
0.5706018209457397,
-0.3580995202064514,
0.7372925877571106,
0.192106693983078,
0.1390458047389984,
0.17632393538951874,
-0.5413855314254761,
0.7534775733947754,
0.34981080889701843,
-0.603954553604126,
-0.10854711383581161,
0.4162777066230774,
0.05486757308244705,
-0.06697556376457214,
0.1707296073436737,
0.15294361114501953,
0.4827609956264496,
0.09697654098272324,
-0.11586630344390869,
-0.5682365894317627,
-0.3729362487792969,
-0.6185706257820129,
0.46507027745246887,
0.06570121645927429,
-0.2916184961795807
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16396v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16396v1
|
Is There a One-Model-Fits-All Approach to Information Extraction? Revisiting Task Definition Biases
| 2024-03-25T03:19:20 | 2024-03-25T03:19:20 |
Wenhao Huang, Qianyu He, Zhixu Li, Jiaqing Liang, Yanghua Xiao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Definition bias is a negative phenomenon that can mislead models. Definition
bias in information extraction appears not only across datasets from different
domains but also within datasets sharing the same domain. We identify two types
of definition bias in IE: bias among information extraction datasets and bias
between information extraction datasets and instruction tuning datasets. To
systematically investigate definition bias, we conduct three probing
experiments to quantitatively analyze it and discover the limitations of
unified information extraction and large language models in solving definition
bias. To mitigate definition bias in information extraction, we propose a
multi-stage framework consisting of definition bias measurement, bias-aware
fine-tuning, and task-specific bias mitigation. Experimental results
demonstrate the effectiveness of our framework in addressing definition bias.
Resources of this paper can be found at
https://github.com/EZ-hwh/definition-bias
|
[
-0.7133582234382629,
-1.0266541242599487,
0.2932468056678772,
0.11006762087345123,
-0.1628195196390152,
-0.3573450744152069,
-0.08783591538667679,
-0.4174966812133789,
0.07973881810903549,
0.4188065230846405,
-0.872423529624939,
-0.1655714511871338,
-0.8013817071914673,
-0.02320312336087227,
-0.5329062938690186,
1.1799564361572266,
-0.07126712799072266,
0.18113994598388672,
-0.19715474545955658,
-0.0911201760172844,
-0.6513526439666748,
-0.17491261661052704,
-0.21764281392097473,
-0.3204801678657532,
0.4422146677970886,
0.3935486376285553,
0.40797996520996094,
1.0338119268417358,
0.4394659698009491,
0.0517311692237854,
0.14838388562202454,
-0.08973319083452225,
-0.29238611459732056,
0.1422257125377655,
-0.4850939214229584,
-0.25844916701316833,
-0.2042868286371231,
0.4241931736469269,
0.36437085270881653,
0.6097217202186584,
-0.022162409499287605,
0.8011115193367004,
0.11037103831768036,
0.4980272948741913,
-1.0635895729064941,
0.08354190737009048,
-0.8567104935646057,
-0.06216450035572052,
-0.38136693835258484,
-0.2999524772167206,
-0.2513144016265869,
-0.19504179060459137,
0.4897318184375763,
-0.6884329319000244,
0.5726250410079956,
-0.07796316593885422,
1.020815134048462,
0.3154931366443634,
-0.24966342747211456,
-0.37966006994247437,
-0.6163788437843323,
0.8823143839836121,
-0.5124013423919678,
0.3552407920360565,
0.053742919117212296,
0.21136942505836487,
0.19628044962882996,
-0.3551536798477173,
-0.49947553873062134,
0.5317047834396362,
0.142150416970253,
-0.18224647641181946,
-0.12052474915981293,
0.03800816833972931,
0.6290455460548401,
0.05924168974161148,
-0.21865302324295044,
0.023654500022530556,
-0.516240656375885,
-0.11834939569234848,
0.39742404222488403,
-0.23275859653949738,
0.10144700109958649,
-0.23414503037929535,
-0.4699786305427551,
0.039806168526411057,
-0.8967323899269104,
-0.3156009018421173,
0.39048057794570923,
0.49652400612831116,
0.2337900847196579,
0.4402787387371063,
-0.10616685450077057,
0.5352014303207397,
0.1945911943912506,
0.14549687504768372,
0.035201843827962875,
-0.3294074833393097,
-0.5864258408546448,
-0.07559829950332642,
0.3703390657901764,
0.13774234056472778,
0.46360859274864197,
-0.3578060567378998,
-0.07418172061443329,
0.05365840345621109,
0.47993162274360657,
-0.8085356950759888,
0.03265363723039627,
0.08048688620328903,
-0.49905917048454285,
-0.5062440633773804,
0.2836543321609497,
-1.2518495321273804,
-0.7760746479034424,
-0.5374612212181091,
0.7906635999679565,
-0.01139808725565672,
-0.39830535650253296,
-0.07217349857091904,
-0.4511739909648895,
0.21146628260612488,
0.05649634450674057,
-0.640434980392456,
0.29850444197654724,
0.4049931764602661,
0.4295883774757385,
-0.4004521667957306,
-0.03702886775135994,
-0.30879753828048706,
0.04709016904234886,
-0.306686669588089,
0.6400779485702515,
-0.4960683286190033,
-0.05915546417236328,
-0.026488294824957848,
-0.1570647805929184,
-0.14138498902320862,
-0.656317412853241,
0.6238511800765991,
-0.4411553740501404,
0.25763005018234253,
-0.6563905477523804,
-0.5337520241737366,
-0.29672104120254517,
0.18375588953495026,
-0.8643049001693726,
0.9898505806922913,
0.20798346400260925,
-1.207435131072998,
0.8497653603553772,
-0.861827552318573,
-0.4271702170372009,
-0.3507131040096283,
-0.427946537733078,
-0.4072885811328888,
0.06494372338056564,
0.2233123481273651,
0.28775346279144287,
-0.7003046274185181,
0.3610491156578064,
-0.22244776785373688,
-0.24399372935295105,
-0.15793892741203308,
-0.31399405002593994,
0.9952489137649536,
0.186072438955307,
-0.6207669377326965,
-0.16652481257915497,
-0.7439890503883362,
0.15697677433490753,
0.18778195977210999,
-0.25463229417800903,
-0.29359254240989685,
0.17264734208583832,
0.018532361835241318,
0.6028726100921631,
0.1516299843788147,
-0.6241238713264465,
0.3666750192642212,
-0.07647343724966049,
0.1996394246816635,
0.8889542818069458,
0.07106324285268784,
0.49709975719451904,
-0.1956474930047989,
0.35059595108032227,
0.32910898327827454,
0.08893101662397385,
-0.08417754620313644,
0.02789558842778206,
-0.7629833817481995,
-0.2820502519607544,
0.4934501349925995,
0.5094162225723267,
-0.38611871004104614,
0.2661929130554199,
-0.2231958955526352,
-0.1438501626253128,
-0.7619805932044983,
0.2085287719964981,
0.3541441559791565,
0.664646565914154,
0.3858828544616699,
-0.21971164643764496,
-0.9469252228736877,
-1.1534943580627441,
-0.6855183243751526,
0.19834667444229126,
-0.2713792324066162,
0.040408965200185776,
0.43121010065078735,
-0.2049015462398529,
1.177722692489624,
-0.25274956226348877,
-0.4248281717300415,
-0.1965784728527069,
0.3266987204551697,
0.012705575674772263,
0.35418611764907837,
0.24360229074954987,
-1.0161558389663696,
-0.12977559864521027,
-0.33590513467788696,
-0.8294572830200195,
-0.1771189570426941,
-0.11499367654323578,
-0.13569921255111694,
-0.13957247138023376,
0.19477644562721252,
-0.7109512090682983,
0.7842477560043335,
-0.09107843786478043,
-0.07675205171108246,
0.6227399110794067,
0.3762493133544922,
0.010443274863064289,
-0.9057994484901428,
0.13737531006336212,
0.42767322063446045,
0.13402296602725983,
-0.8141685724258423,
0.315673291683197,
0.23824603855609894,
0.41255125403404236,
-0.20182381570339203,
0.28520888090133667,
-0.40711402893066406,
-0.16553226113319397,
-0.26197198033332825,
0.23715612292289734,
0.4285472333431244,
0.2982822358608246,
-0.22586478292942047,
0.6764208674430847,
0.6075680255889893,
-0.9325413107872009,
0.17294682562351227,
0.30411332845687866,
-0.2383902668952942,
0.6091371178627014,
-0.43322011828422546,
0.18752366304397583,
-0.4316541850566864,
-0.00038817524909973145,
-0.7507822513580322,
0.026322759687900543,
0.27616989612579346,
-0.27473756670951843,
0.49732187390327454,
-0.020753271877765656,
-0.39787858724594116,
-0.3122625946998596,
-0.32764309644699097,
0.24301999807357788,
0.13554875552654266,
-0.6395581960678101,
0.4363453984260559,
0.5719105005264282,
-0.008058936335146427,
-0.7857112884521484,
-0.5186107754707336,
-0.271872878074646,
-0.4952163100242615,
-0.46936163306236267,
0.2701883912086487,
-0.01661774329841137,
-0.5368281602859497,
-0.36641061305999756,
-0.7010060548782349,
-0.39881107211112976,
0.16449692845344543,
0.1523021012544632,
0.3430381119251251,
-0.06114886701107025,
0.37424930930137634,
-0.037102166563272476,
0.3897606432437897,
0.19724033772945404,
-0.4361826777458191,
0.3722550570964813,
0.5066787600517273,
-0.2849231958389282,
-0.36452716588974,
0.36103567481040955,
0.43439266085624695,
-0.1813340187072754,
0.28416958451271057,
0.5483547449111938,
-0.602954089641571,
-0.01150981243699789,
-0.9260523319244385,
-0.3086327910423279,
-0.3511080741882324,
0.4006419777870178,
-0.4736248850822449,
-0.2326887547969818,
0.3285415470600128,
-0.1878024786710739,
0.3951245844364166,
0.5518853664398193,
0.210286483168602,
0.11127381771802902,
1.1183733940124512,
1.0059565305709839,
-0.244431272149086,
0.4026947617530823,
-0.055785126984119415,
0.31396108865737915,
-0.991554856300354,
0.09111825376749039,
-0.7508711218833923,
-0.20598967373371124,
-0.42886239290237427,
0.06822779774665833,
0.1486547291278839,
0.25494539737701416,
-0.17107507586479187,
0.1833154261112213,
-0.5474109053611755,
0.29914596676826477,
0.48422133922576904,
0.08858327567577362,
-0.024971352890133858,
0.12290812283754349,
0.0015874834498390555,
-0.09218606352806091,
-0.5411329865455627,
-0.49645093083381653,
1.5523436069488525,
0.17396941781044006,
0.5819658637046814,
-0.2041391283273697,
0.4237973988056183,
0.403878390789032,
0.1322244107723236,
-0.6257407665252686,
-0.03255467861890793,
0.22611477971076965,
-1.106124758720398,
-0.39140650629997253,
-0.2756579518318176,
-0.587408721446991,
0.4011635482311249,
-0.2939212918281555,
-1.0676140785217285,
0.37880823016166687,
0.006771747954189777,
-0.04238289222121239,
0.357593834400177,
-0.6009050607681274,
0.817791223526001,
0.09588412940502167,
-0.5799738764762878,
0.18538767099380493,
-0.5779514908790588,
0.33940237760543823,
-0.3716599643230438,
0.6033223867416382,
-0.07890820503234863,
0.4138392210006714,
1.0573006868362427,
0.37638792395591736,
0.5515888929367065,
-0.3316914737224579,
-0.05722365528345108,
0.3689821660518646,
0.31834492087364197,
0.5481215119361877,
-0.2578834891319275,
-0.30758896470069885,
0.15947873890399933,
0.3050350546836853,
-0.5316826105117798,
-0.5840672254562378,
0.16816750168800354,
-0.5338416695594788,
-0.44339144229888916,
-0.06287942826747894,
-0.4775369465351105,
-0.19400209188461304,
0.38782045245170593,
0.4926561713218689,
0.26082876324653625,
-0.3468066453933716,
-0.23210085928440094,
0.8993788957595825,
-0.02927321381866932,
0.25730445981025696,
0.5443390011787415,
0.10546592622995377,
0.35224997997283936,
0.7735585570335388,
0.16884295642375946,
0.2610687017440796,
0.1284751445055008,
0.14424994587898254,
-0.010960989631712437,
-0.21194186806678772,
-0.42308399081230164,
-0.16764838993549347,
-0.8269834518432617,
-0.0998787134885788,
-0.52140873670578,
-0.23461535573005676,
-0.6041716933250427,
0.4479910433292389,
-0.28231576085090637,
-0.4258265793323517,
-0.37516874074935913,
-0.220676451921463,
-0.2405215948820114,
0.9384363889694214,
0.04969598725438118,
0.3298661410808563,
-0.39566439390182495,
0.5004092454910278,
0.04130961745977402,
0.06495378911495209,
-0.1627640575170517,
-0.38328802585601807,
-0.26944562792778015,
0.2618454694747925,
-0.5958471894264221,
-1.0328221321105957,
0.2908546030521393,
0.21658852696418762,
0.5449069142341614,
0.6888312697410583,
-0.22810879349708557,
0.5466522574424744,
-0.3993220329284668,
0.6862404942512512,
-0.022667478770017624,
-1.0143195390701294,
0.5945228934288025,
-0.1509820818901062,
0.20317743718624115,
0.5579308867454529,
0.5123558640480042,
-0.43032410740852356,
0.04081261157989502,
-0.7470487952232361,
-0.7434661388397217,
0.6492408514022827,
-0.0991261899471283,
-0.19370950758457184,
0.0016340831061825156,
0.5727492570877075,
0.5595659017562866,
0.6303354501724243,
-0.6858181357383728,
-0.36383092403411865,
0.1002783328294754,
-0.12409244477748871,
0.26336392760276794,
-0.3159862756729126,
-0.25447118282318115,
-0.11847192794084549,
0.7183544635772705,
-0.11774837970733643,
0.3307523727416992,
0.2514342963695526,
-0.5359426140785217,
-0.498289555311203,
0.5493670105934143,
0.16747084259986877,
1.2793464660644531,
-0.05463733151555061,
0.14911627769470215,
-0.12030841410160065,
-0.44957467913627625,
-0.21775195002555847,
0.11030130833387375,
-0.4939066767692566,
0.10964794456958771,
0.14797565340995789,
0.2946144640445709,
-0.014046377502381802,
-0.40286314487457275,
0.6778149008750916,
0.15001057088375092,
-0.18004585802555084,
0.03037797100841999,
-0.12881886959075928,
-0.46075204014778137,
0.04289152845740318,
0.5401544570922852,
0.045561596751213074,
0.46598899364471436,
-0.42526233196258545,
0.41278648376464844,
0.7179129719734192,
-0.5919724702835083,
-0.2528400123119354,
0.5290722250938416,
-0.05200217291712761,
0.1227206438779831,
0.527376115322113,
-0.0938972756266594,
-0.528099775314331,
0.684918999671936,
0.44029757380485535,
0.8105195164680481,
-0.12577487528324127,
0.21078188717365265,
0.3893902897834778,
0.4275207221508026,
-0.07621734589338303,
0.17390944063663483,
-0.049668651074171066,
-0.8181416988372803,
-0.39497649669647217,
-0.4591274857521057,
0.09112522006034851,
0.3716679811477661,
-1.0096017122268677,
0.43494272232055664,
-0.23962770402431488,
0.05784633010625839,
0.41403692960739136,
-0.026063093915581703,
-1.023405909538269,
0.21781866252422333,
-0.04637646675109863,
0.9004417061805725,
-0.9064136147499084,
0.7462321519851685,
0.3411523103713989,
-0.5967419743537903,
-0.5430015325546265,
0.017770392820239067,
0.2747379243373871,
-0.5874750018119812,
0.7077381610870361,
0.292155385017395,
0.32435494661331177,
-0.1658191680908203,
-0.7811806201934814,
-0.968359112739563,
0.9448413848876953,
0.1116522029042244,
-0.42297807335853577,
-0.4357078969478607,
-0.06376855820417404,
0.017757244408130646,
-0.6030341982841492,
0.20427511632442474,
1.1305235624313354,
0.5213801860809326,
-0.26955923438072205,
-1.0840359926223755,
0.07966967672109604,
0.018217729404568672,
-0.35385891795158386,
0.20049935579299927,
0.05059369280934334,
1.0397874116897583,
-0.10054966807365417,
-0.4302814304828644,
-0.2788054943084717,
0.031107814982533455,
-0.35335680842399597,
0.24494753777980804,
0.41203880310058594,
0.4898883104324341,
0.7610422968864441,
-0.020805414766073227,
0.6044950485229492,
-0.08005886524915695,
0.2843778431415558,
1.1341172456741333,
-0.2958238422870636,
0.22614970803260803,
0.7263877391815186,
-0.02999512106180191,
0.20124977827072144,
0.7316843271255493,
0.12102563679218292,
0.4347049295902252,
0.4151703417301178,
0.02261453866958618,
-0.036524005234241486,
-0.12707597017288208,
-0.1787165105342865,
0.37973740696907043,
0.5389623641967773,
-0.5150217413902283,
-0.3854047954082489,
-0.0943269208073616,
0.06236166134476662,
-0.3196328580379486,
-0.3585704267024994,
0.8673950433731079,
-0.33265402913093567,
-0.6888946294784546,
0.34252962470054626,
0.028168581426143646,
0.5547430515289307,
-0.3655904531478882,
-0.15801435708999634,
0.1671023964881897,
-0.057066161185503006,
-0.30704694986343384,
-0.303305059671402,
0.09376733005046844,
-0.11344073712825775,
-0.5226088166236877,
-0.03478703275322914,
0.8512106537818909,
-0.35982152819633484,
-0.2153564989566803,
0.13393783569335938,
0.8688398003578186,
-0.02346375398337841,
-0.4900210499763489,
-0.6028932332992554,
0.022883597761392593,
0.23745021224021912,
-0.19993576407432556,
0.389172226190567,
0.2997134327888489,
-0.04941622167825699,
0.37124279141426086,
0.22274774312973022,
0.23389647901058197,
0.444721519947052,
-0.061268389225006104,
0.7525710463523865,
-0.3976163864135742,
-0.2507842779159546,
-0.8499366044998169,
0.2769104838371277,
-0.2975549101829529,
-0.1916775107383728,
0.633102536201477,
0.5568198561668396,
0.8270841240882874,
0.2142840176820755,
1.2930482625961304,
-0.2720949351787567,
0.7839320302009583,
-0.18189112842082977,
0.2263236790895462,
-0.41178324818611145,
0.136198028922081,
-0.513610303401947,
-1.1523098945617676,
0.04803186282515526,
0.6222922205924988,
-0.14453597366809845,
-0.044382672756910324,
0.5938372611999512,
0.5140983462333679,
-0.16760554909706116,
0.3401813507080078,
-0.1348472684621811,
0.19779381155967712,
0.23917007446289062,
0.14864632487297058,
0.3823743164539337,
-0.607009768486023,
0.24443267285823822,
-0.09566020220518112,
-0.3712269067764282,
0.01525646448135376,
-0.742926299571991,
-0.6188660264015198,
-0.5322306156158447,
-0.2225506603717804,
-0.23738066852092743,
0.17109161615371704,
0.8041659593582153,
0.8876953125,
-0.6833104491233826,
-0.03384295478463173,
-0.10640295594930649,
0.4887230098247528,
-0.26090380549430847,
-0.3300481140613556,
0.2276151031255722,
-0.3946806788444519,
-0.4669216275215149,
0.1272599995136261,
0.01759287342429161,
-0.17243288457393646,
-0.2691395580768585,
0.4614103138446808,
-0.6302213072776794,
0.2248965948820114,
0.2806663513183594,
0.2761653661727905,
-0.5462284088134766,
-0.4553214907646179,
-0.18476556241512299,
0.0014401364605873823,
0.4099833369255066,
0.9765296578407288,
-0.4759475886821747,
0.6933649778366089,
0.18400178849697113,
0.5862329602241516,
0.5414709448814392,
0.1458698958158493,
0.5118191242218018,
-1.0039550065994263,
0.0000865298934513703,
-0.1393444538116455,
0.06121166795492172,
0.15348173677921295,
-0.47707831859588623,
0.5622221231460571,
0.036868851631879807,
-0.42834731936454773,
-0.5785765051841736,
0.5570003390312195,
-0.5296531915664673,
-0.5008206963539124,
1.1687499284744263,
0.11473198980093002,
-0.15785780549049377,
-0.056004442274570465,
-0.14467978477478027,
0.5807351469993591,
-0.06342220306396484,
1.1163537502288818,
1.0121022462844849,
-0.18526077270507812,
0.19549761712551117,
-0.9771413207054138,
0.5588556528091431,
0.04872075095772743,
-0.6483665704727173,
0.2828793227672577,
0.5263444185256958,
0.6050958037376404,
0.3302764594554901,
0.2730374038219452,
-0.257323682308197,
0.14647068083286285,
-0.3506104350090027,
0.5425790548324585,
0.18441516160964966,
-0.4583660364151001,
-0.2507559657096863,
0.10869681090116501,
-0.1953248381614685,
-0.26644912362098694
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16394v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16394v1
|
Skews in the Phenomenon Space Hinder Generalization in Text-to-Image Generation
| 2024-03-25T03:18:39 | 2024-03-25T03:18:39 |
Yingshan Chang, Yasi Zhang, Zhiyuan Fang, Yingnian Wu, Yonatan Bisk, Feng Gao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The literature on text-to-image generation is plagued by issues of faithfully
composing entities with relations. But there lacks a formal understanding of
how entity-relation compositions can be effectively learned. Moreover, the
underlying phenomenon space that meaningfully reflects the problem structure is
not well-defined, leading to an arms race for larger quantities of data in the
hope that generalization emerges out of large-scale pretraining. We hypothesize
that the underlying phenomenological coverage has not been proportionally
scaled up, leading to a skew of the presented phenomenon which harms
generalization. We introduce statistical metrics that quantify both the
linguistic and visual skew of a dataset for relational learning, and show that
generalization failures of text-to-image generation are a direct result of
incomplete or unbalanced phenomenological coverage. We first perform
experiments in a synthetic domain and demonstrate that systematically
controlled metrics are strongly predictive of generalization performance. Then
we move to natural images and show that simple distribution perturbations in
light of our theories boost generalization without enlarging the absolute data
size. This work informs an important direction towards quality-enhancing the
data diversity or balance orthogonal to scaling up the absolute size. Our
discussions point out important open questions on 1) Evaluation of generated
entity-relation compositions, and 2) Better models for reasoning with abstract
relations.
|
[
-0.38825398683547974,
-0.6113430261611938,
0.6787447333335876,
0.31274327635765076,
-0.4498363435268402,
0.02168223261833191,
-0.09356255829334259,
-0.4397885203361511,
0.24478866159915924,
0.4980091452598572,
-0.3921448886394501,
-0.3984604775905609,
-0.6734258532524109,
-0.14767184853553772,
-0.34169965982437134,
1.221861720085144,
0.03932515159249306,
-0.22290873527526855,
-0.5424155592918396,
-0.31639397144317627,
-0.38782569766044617,
-0.48660987615585327,
-0.21497680246829987,
-0.26320499181747437,
0.45674553513526917,
0.2589050531387329,
1.0781680345535278,
0.7779951691627502,
0.5774931311607361,
0.2584790885448456,
0.14605003595352173,
0.08844082802534103,
-0.5734556317329407,
0.3758223056793213,
-0.135310098528862,
-0.7376609444618225,
-0.2066688984632492,
-0.1693510115146637,
0.8797537684440613,
1.185080647468567,
-0.07861685752868652,
0.046490516513586044,
-0.16245636343955994,
0.9108949303627014,
-0.6402949690818787,
-0.011177187785506248,
-0.799501359462738,
0.11911506205797195,
-0.2244889736175537,
-0.028164248913526535,
-0.17996911704540253,
-0.03619377315044403,
0.4170771539211273,
-0.9997242093086243,
0.7004328370094299,
0.1941722184419632,
0.8244463801383972,
0.1828148066997528,
-0.5216001868247986,
-0.4913097321987152,
-1.0805184841156006,
0.7879025340080261,
-0.3620360791683197,
0.16707564890384674,
0.32515278458595276,
0.1288006752729416,
-0.1240164041519165,
-0.6173716187477112,
-0.5159394145011902,
-0.10025865584611893,
-0.03750012069940567,
0.03796714171767235,
-0.11694709956645966,
-0.03313815966248512,
0.42267000675201416,
0.5710687041282654,
-0.48772066831588745,
-0.2855508029460907,
-0.41636160016059875,
-0.07246359437704086,
0.6142681837081909,
0.28130796551704407,
0.4612998962402344,
0.0036085257306694984,
-0.14920760691165924,
-0.37394991517066956,
-0.7566750049591064,
-0.2085469365119934,
0.5639199018478394,
-0.09572772681713104,
-0.0671457052230835,
0.712027907371521,
0.11283168941736221,
0.39212626218795776,
0.23307135701179504,
0.15885978937149048,
0.2512805163860321,
-0.3019770681858063,
-0.11298386752605438,
-0.3481765687465668,
0.9217346906661987,
0.41790086030960083,
0.32914605736732483,
-0.29709354043006897,
-0.012546409852802753,
0.3033429980278015,
0.3085089921951294,
-0.7894437909126282,
-0.45030176639556885,
-0.04398927092552185,
-0.24511465430259705,
-0.28498634696006775,
0.22717270255088806,
-0.930884063243866,
-0.14907002449035645,
-0.3513234853744507,
0.262593150138855,
-0.3427748680114746,
-0.39758235216140747,
-0.20991525053977966,
-0.34461814165115356,
-0.1607455313205719,
0.10534585267305374,
-0.9245921969413757,
0.09449337422847748,
0.332805335521698,
0.7125634551048279,
-0.2856988310813904,
-0.14634113013744354,
0.16076646745204926,
0.28951355814933777,
-0.8079079389572144,
0.737488329410553,
-0.40802985429763794,
-0.4556959271430969,
-0.020791037008166313,
-0.20927956700325012,
0.13399526476860046,
-0.627537727355957,
-0.050736915320158005,
-0.27498915791511536,
0.2440655529499054,
-0.19103626906871796,
-0.3638364374637604,
0.33647021651268005,
-0.052560754120349884,
-0.6087020039558411,
0.8656699061393738,
0.1431802362203598,
-1.0025347471237183,
0.8258360624313354,
-0.19966153800487518,
-0.5717369914054871,
-0.09645861387252808,
-0.5625814199447632,
-0.7722861766815186,
0.6133286356925964,
0.12086118012666702,
0.34871765971183777,
-0.23011845350265503,
0.3398798406124115,
-0.3128948211669922,
-0.23770785331726074,
0.2853895127773285,
-0.019404398277401924,
0.2538963258266449,
0.185511976480484,
-0.3543684780597687,
-0.3225356340408325,
-0.9654312133789062,
-0.07631680369377136,
0.4240260720252991,
0.016799554228782654,
-0.7821316719055176,
0.2764388918876648,
-0.10728675127029419,
0.05330841243267059,
-0.09013782441616058,
-0.2702498435974121,
0.12957243621349335,
-0.47272008657455444,
0.2342255562543869,
0.5113556981086731,
0.274932324886322,
1.1033692359924316,
-0.02986675128340721,
0.311441570520401,
0.5697630643844604,
-0.11017129570245743,
-0.36765432357788086,
-0.4371257722377777,
-0.6684487462043762,
0.038362566381692886,
0.08590327203273773,
0.2024552971124649,
-1.1845171451568604,
0.01871177740395069,
-0.5239995121955872,
-0.36387455463409424,
-0.21958167850971222,
0.23773778975009918,
0.3799090087413788,
0.3667067587375641,
0.3271678388118744,
-0.6003044843673706,
-0.15963122248649597,
-0.9953902363777161,
-0.4346122741699219,
-0.19933560490608215,
-0.3514444828033447,
0.19313250482082367,
0.40090715885162354,
-0.1628655046224594,
0.8941162824630737,
-0.5576867461204529,
-0.292039692401886,
0.012505828402936459,
0.30189821124076843,
-0.0031095484737306833,
0.5690528154373169,
0.8494886159896851,
-0.859704315662384,
-0.40870043635368347,
-0.048304878175258636,
-0.8900307416915894,
0.12340623885393143,
-0.28098422288894653,
-0.17745012044906616,
0.16220757365226746,
0.2657304108142853,
-0.8329775929450989,
0.5903668999671936,
0.20434688031673431,
-0.25779595971107483,
0.3340763449668884,
-0.1814507097005844,
-0.0617859810590744,
-1.0428210496902466,
-0.22480624914169312,
0.3910643458366394,
0.09397192299365997,
-0.7552477121353149,
0.03672526776790619,
-0.14485754072666168,
-0.1507112681865692,
-0.022808454930782318,
0.18969179689884186,
-0.5237867832183838,
-0.32486554980278015,
-0.2825790047645569,
0.015718862414360046,
-0.07041078805923462,
0.43582212924957275,
0.17473067343235016,
0.43525415658950806,
0.6601541638374329,
-0.7026160955429077,
-0.031068982556462288,
0.11970971524715424,
-0.02874106355011463,
0.9490975737571716,
-0.6342667937278748,
0.11768969893455505,
-0.4772021472454071,
0.257138192653656,
-1.0100679397583008,
-0.5167260766029358,
0.2933892011642456,
-0.496113657951355,
0.40142515301704407,
-0.04361933469772339,
-0.4843583106994629,
-0.30702507495880127,
-0.12327644228935242,
0.5834825038909912,
0.5742359757423401,
-0.35120925307273865,
0.42928194999694824,
0.24443915486335754,
0.043504051864147186,
-0.5005596876144409,
-0.9332226514816284,
-0.1381697803735733,
-0.24158726632595062,
-0.612604558467865,
0.2029145509004593,
0.25211867690086365,
-0.2928803265094757,
0.1387147605419159,
-0.3729236125946045,
-0.08595170825719833,
-0.3182908594608307,
0.40957266092300415,
0.23233741521835327,
-0.34542420506477356,
0.3660292327404022,
0.23876862227916718,
0.13820065557956696,
0.41836318373680115,
-0.5279439091682434,
0.16121213138103485,
0.2734828591346741,
-0.23661629855632782,
-0.09835983067750931,
0.32853156328201294,
0.3872949182987213,
0.2013459950685501,
0.7525182366371155,
0.304056853055954,
-0.3394145667552948,
-0.32450926303863525,
-0.2767013609409332,
-0.03789957985281944,
-0.45807021856307983,
0.495028018951416,
-0.2503297030925751,
-0.6229873895645142,
0.3791210353374481,
-0.06187060847878456,
0.15275059640407562,
0.6941004991531372,
0.3521144986152649,
-0.4377742111682892,
1.0314652919769287,
0.6798261404037476,
0.14909373223781586,
0.38125312328338623,
-0.402316689491272,
0.214017853140831,
-0.503115713596344,
-0.22714205086231232,
-0.4025527536869049,
-0.3719160556793213,
-0.787799596786499,
-0.27565431594848633,
0.2368008941411972,
-0.03391618654131889,
-0.2595821022987366,
0.15978942811489105,
-0.620426595211029,
0.40634915232658386,
0.2675951421260834,
0.1656622439622879,
0.3476170301437378,
0.6111850738525391,
0.03609466552734375,
-0.46181175112724304,
-0.6368986368179321,
-0.2351447343826294,
1.392142415046692,
0.1485188901424408,
0.842647910118103,
-0.21120919287204742,
0.5646964311599731,
0.17015843093395233,
0.46801504492759705,
-0.4409301280975342,
0.38404980301856995,
-0.17761889100074768,
-0.5271282196044922,
-0.38914209604263306,
-0.7636634707450867,
-0.9946578145027161,
0.3206835091114044,
-0.309051513671875,
-0.3700844347476959,
0.5924056768417358,
0.6443989276885986,
0.34629738330841064,
0.27175042033195496,
-0.6750807762145996,
0.5055795311927795,
-0.12087595462799072,
-0.340025931596756,
-0.10831418633460999,
-0.6866388916969299,
0.39571595191955566,
-0.12409363687038422,
0.3301467001438141,
0.011651698499917984,
-0.005813493859022856,
0.46930092573165894,
-0.43482401967048645,
0.759578287601471,
-0.31572991609573364,
0.07909248769283295,
0.2709707021713257,
0.05605905503034592,
0.2144198715686798,
0.10752607882022858,
0.43596696853637695,
-0.018079157918691635,
-0.21235059201717377,
-0.721183717250824,
-0.762100338935852,
0.4356124699115753,
-0.9542363882064819,
-0.3881309926509857,
-0.16585507988929749,
-0.6104592084884644,
-0.47784966230392456,
-0.01851695403456688,
0.9843835234642029,
0.12202547490596771,
-0.2570328712463379,
0.17498275637626648,
0.791205644607544,
-0.22959743440151215,
-0.06923287361860275,
-0.11217471957206726,
-0.3275178372859955,
-0.3765169680118561,
1.1267826557159424,
0.23581698536872864,
0.6438415050506592,
0.12440615147352219,
-0.12494929134845734,
0.009132572449743748,
-0.414190411567688,
-0.3228270709514618,
0.33142903447151184,
-0.7174702286720276,
-0.08564037084579468,
-0.5879202485084534,
-0.0021355675999075174,
-0.19414380192756653,
0.03511796146631241,
-0.30549341440200806,
-0.48431771993637085,
-0.3925562798976898,
0.0526108518242836,
0.06953296065330505,
0.7857712507247925,
0.21955040097236633,
0.6797558665275574,
-0.14512397348880768,
0.48846644163131714,
0.19009900093078613,
0.13222619891166687,
0.21743923425674438,
-0.4618804454803467,
-0.22922921180725098,
0.20459701120853424,
-0.7299953699111938,
-0.8380335569381714,
0.15973541140556335,
0.5017037391662598,
0.30120423436164856,
0.4626760482788086,
-0.2582712173461914,
0.6203323602676392,
-0.5104442834854126,
0.7308661341667175,
0.6768752932548523,
-0.640795886516571,
0.6367843151092529,
-0.34493640065193176,
0.2432112842798233,
0.2834039330482483,
0.5014084577560425,
-0.24965429306030273,
-0.7971580624580383,
-0.8705299496650696,
-1.0170592069625854,
0.30224719643592834,
0.3038163185119629,
0.526301920413971,
0.008850539103150368,
0.6743676066398621,
-0.02155594900250435,
0.3548361659049988,
-0.8540509343147278,
-0.3849697411060333,
-0.7506952285766602,
-0.11568084359169006,
-0.15729974210262299,
-0.10624993592500687,
0.0757555365562439,
-0.11823166161775589,
0.34326663613319397,
-0.09279152005910873,
0.318805992603302,
0.37108922004699707,
-0.23160220682621002,
-0.4883241355419159,
0.1377805769443512,
0.3813090920448303,
0.7068303227424622,
0.25773724913597107,
0.1029721200466156,
-0.25227633118629456,
-0.7342779040336609,
0.3217647969722748,
-0.26587820053100586,
-0.34591588377952576,
0.19249989092350006,
0.41191309690475464,
0.9566901922225952,
0.14253655076026917,
-0.1521960347890854,
0.4166407287120819,
0.18878783285617828,
-0.6278637051582336,
-0.115601547062397,
0.146155446767807,
0.028709247708320618,
-0.054223690181970596,
0.753828763961792,
0.1892128735780716,
0.09192042797803879,
-0.6754252910614014,
-0.04006922245025635,
0.45811641216278076,
-0.12679490447044373,
-0.5971187353134155,
0.7176271080970764,
-0.12122023105621338,
0.03290613740682602,
0.6500189304351807,
-0.04760449007153511,
-0.16545279324054718,
0.9440064430236816,
0.6552688479423523,
0.43187907338142395,
-0.09326780587434769,
0.38323014974594116,
0.3030719757080078,
0.4239843189716339,
-0.23358063399791718,
-0.11257360130548477,
0.14680510759353638,
-0.7889607548713684,
-0.31015491485595703,
-0.2939315140247345,
-0.25420472025871277,
0.1207175999879837,
-0.601385235786438,
-0.10791429877281189,
-0.6395363211631775,
-0.5029834508895874,
0.1236966922879219,
-0.32378578186035156,
-0.7809423804283142,
0.355816513299942,
-0.10263144969940186,
0.3965025544166565,
-1.0964714288711548,
0.48376378417015076,
0.91993647813797,
-0.43564537167549133,
-0.6818510293960571,
0.24150080978870392,
-0.3428427278995514,
-0.4190398156642914,
0.5870519280433655,
0.057676006108522415,
0.3758169710636139,
-0.223593607544899,
-0.877562940120697,
-0.659782886505127,
0.9390403628349304,
0.40609267354011536,
-0.5380479097366333,
-0.32394298911094666,
0.6361662745475769,
0.9376615881919861,
-0.46929800510406494,
-0.23737378418445587,
0.4174312949180603,
0.23033669590950012,
0.36044925451278687,
-0.317023903131485,
-0.077806256711483,
-0.08558822423219681,
0.4864519238471985,
0.3945257067680359,
-0.3644258975982666,
0.6282923817634583,
-0.25487035512924194,
-0.3243524432182312,
-0.01856876164674759,
0.7441552877426147,
0.18679475784301758,
0.685879111289978,
0.35683006048202515,
0.7386929392814636,
0.2951284646987915,
-0.22800402343273163,
1.1013939380645752,
0.27327871322631836,
0.3355548083782196,
0.9227278828620911,
-0.04178537800908089,
0.39501774311065674,
0.8001713156700134,
-0.3366846740245819,
0.3767557144165039,
0.4235648810863495,
-0.14273522794246674,
0.4746541976928711,
0.2708262503147125,
0.0005415444611571729,
-0.08118342608213425,
0.2090967893600464,
-0.4100528955459595,
-0.02473711036145687,
0.6801864504814148,
-0.5752661824226379,
-0.09415571391582489,
0.14049093425273895,
-0.4018375277519226,
0.3170373737812042,
-0.3408470153808594,
0.6546574234962463,
0.21595150232315063,
-0.5576278567314148,
0.2007671296596527,
-0.471695214509964,
0.6317675709724426,
-0.30227330327033997,
0.06243811547756195,
-0.3645833730697632,
-0.0440065972507,
-0.35338303446769714,
-0.7184877991676331,
0.4094022512435913,
-0.3549582064151764,
-0.48064279556274414,
0.167471244931221,
0.8511229753494263,
-0.4393433630466461,
-0.603469967842102,
-0.0037073891144245863,
0.46755024790763855,
0.08361482620239258,
-0.019259285181760788,
-0.38509681820869446,
-0.20098049938678741,
-0.10643640160560608,
-0.3404267132282257,
0.5930778980255127,
0.8729645609855652,
-0.26518791913986206,
0.4077970087528229,
0.5715994834899902,
0.2689738869667053,
0.2838284373283386,
-0.24907474219799042,
0.8277857303619385,
-0.31339794397354126,
-0.3622714579105377,
-0.6346080899238586,
0.4249070882797241,
-0.15097185969352722,
-0.2735808789730072,
0.383455753326416,
0.3550412058830261,
0.8827674984931946,
-0.3972342312335968,
0.754905104637146,
-0.07152702659368515,
0.1746479570865631,
-0.27771684527397156,
0.5910694003105164,
-0.5845724940299988,
0.134926438331604,
-0.4691161513328552,
-1.2689988613128662,
-0.33087724447250366,
0.4949066638946533,
-0.38682499527931213,
0.05919729545712471,
0.4899621605873108,
0.46128663420677185,
-0.2579125165939331,
-0.21040447056293488,
0.4031407833099365,
0.09894035011529922,
0.11026299744844437,
0.346944123506546,
0.841482937335968,
-0.41212302446365356,
0.5620563626289368,
-0.23605838418006897,
-0.2256717085838318,
0.13615171611309052,
-0.7222225069999695,
-0.9925282597541809,
-0.8043391108512878,
-0.30637362599372864,
-0.2829938232898712,
0.10007797181606293,
0.37497007846832275,
0.6565585136413574,
-0.5297895669937134,
-0.04551161825656891,
-0.437289834022522,
-0.007116064429283142,
0.12155720591545105,
-0.25293198227882385,
0.1721208542585373,
-0.45771679282188416,
-0.4911944568157196,
-0.4375567138195038,
0.281963050365448,
0.2821246087551117,
-0.20900925993919373,
0.0471353679895401,
0.376495897769928,
0.034402187913656235,
0.41814884543418884,
0.4427640736103058,
-0.517482578754425,
0.07566551864147186,
-0.038296449929475784,
-0.1091921254992485,
0.27778732776641846,
1.1078343391418457,
-0.5521150827407837,
0.21402762830257416,
0.2607349753379822,
0.5569856762886047,
0.5219062566757202,
-0.030075808987021446,
0.6773301362991333,
-1.0986543893814087,
0.4246603846549988,
0.07285048067569733,
0.07130036503076553,
0.30569350719451904,
-0.5490443110466003,
0.4270747900009155,
0.6654329299926758,
-0.5559607148170471,
-0.7205185890197754,
0.3974110186100006,
-0.5601914525032043,
-0.2485176920890808,
0.7487818598747253,
0.029377328231930733,
-0.1969890296459198,
0.17265968024730682,
0.09376423060894012,
0.16508400440216064,
-0.2666374146938324,
0.7725943922996521,
0.7836759686470032,
-0.0383622944355011,
-0.08967389911413193,
-0.5775555372238159,
0.42618441581726074,
0.5888578295707703,
-0.8006383180618286,
-0.21791264414787292,
0.7612500190734863,
0.4207907021045685,
0.4838414490222931,
0.44507676362991333,
-0.11987360566854477,
0.4328453540802002,
-0.010287807323038578,
-0.09402727335691452,
0.3722306489944458,
-0.3107134997844696,
-0.03609354421496391,
0.10083203762769699,
-0.0008069858886301517,
0.0654120147228241
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16393v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16393v1
|
Concurrent Linguistic Error Detection (CLED) for Large Language Models
| 2024-03-25T03:17:27 | 2024-03-25T03:17:27 |
Jinhua Zhu, Javier Conde, Zhen Gao, Pedro Reviriego, Shanshan Liu, Fabrizio Lombardi
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The wide adoption of Large language models (LLMs) makes their dependability a
pressing concern. Detection of errors is the first step to mitigating their
impact on a system and thus, efficient error detection for LLMs is an important
issue. In many settings, the LLM is considered as a black box with no access to
the internal nodes; this prevents the use of many error detection schemes that
need access to the model's internal nodes. An interesting observation is that
the output of LLMs in error-free operation should be valid and normal text.
Therefore, when the text is not valid or differs significantly from normal
text, it is likely that there is an error. Based on this observation we propose
to perform Concurrent Linguistic Error Detection (CLED); this scheme extracts
some linguistic features of the text generated by the LLM and feeds them to a
concurrent classifier that detects errors. Since the proposed error detection
mechanism only relies on the outputs of the model, then it can be used on LLMs
in which there is no access to the internal nodes. The proposed CLED scheme has
been evaluated on the T5 model when used for news summarization and on the
OPUS-MT model when used for translation. In both cases, the same set of
linguistic features has been used for error detection to illustrate the
applicability of the proposed scheme beyond a specific case. The results show
that CLED can detect most of the errors at a low overhead penalty. The use of
the concurrent classifier also enables a trade-off between error detection
effectiveness and its associated overhead, so providing flexibility to a
designer.
|
[
-0.15090011060237885,
-0.6283237934112549,
0.6477121114730835,
0.36335137486457825,
-0.5666834712028503,
-0.08311539143323898,
-0.6267024874687195,
-0.4330640137195587,
-0.13389363884925842,
0.5906426310539246,
-0.41875195503234863,
-0.6640720367431641,
-0.7261752486228943,
0.22831037640571594,
-0.5359163880348206,
0.7283151745796204,
-0.29652372002601624,
0.030914759263396263,
-0.155659481883049,
-0.4212370216846466,
-0.7747800946235657,
-0.708338737487793,
-0.5761539340019226,
-0.21859610080718994,
0.265401154756546,
0.46049419045448303,
0.3047902286052704,
0.47512590885162354,
0.39237308502197266,
0.3113383948802948,
-0.022349810227751732,
0.4762328267097473,
-0.4828726053237915,
0.21207335591316223,
-0.29623809456825256,
-0.5246822834014893,
-0.4492756426334381,
-0.3961339294910431,
0.859085202217102,
0.4038397967815399,
0.008583287708461285,
-0.054431792348623276,
0.18770714104175568,
0.7007752656936646,
-0.43122202157974243,
0.2936473786830902,
-0.7753802537918091,
-0.11133919656276703,
-0.6567927002906799,
-0.02529776468873024,
-0.460943341255188,
-0.2504602074623108,
-0.043837111443281174,
-0.2729162275791168,
0.05043259263038635,
0.05759216099977493,
0.6394428014755249,
0.3310486674308777,
-0.1571025848388672,
-0.4569767415523529,
-0.5911375284194946,
0.9559287428855896,
-1.0547277927398682,
0.36217284202575684,
-0.2549606263637543,
-0.04039716720581055,
-0.28138285875320435,
-0.31975826621055603,
-0.8488086462020874,
-0.011596820317208767,
-0.21322199702262878,
0.028992127627134323,
0.02677021734416485,
0.10944970697164536,
0.22630895674228668,
0.2999308109283447,
-0.5152465105056763,
0.4502626955509186,
-0.08493871241807938,
-0.1642618477344513,
0.48837703466415405,
0.16922174394130707,
0.41452306509017944,
0.10121648013591766,
-0.23987255990505219,
0.120183564722538,
-0.5823858380317688,
-0.26588407158851624,
0.07515758275985718,
0.20204950869083405,
-0.5182437896728516,
0.3425365686416626,
-0.16198262572288513,
0.6633641123771667,
-0.14616072177886963,
-0.2624730169773102,
0.1907937377691269,
-0.3719528913497925,
-0.045296479016542435,
0.13165193796157837,
0.7503826022148132,
0.35209569334983826,
0.5028473138809204,
-0.05110473930835724,
-0.6027435064315796,
0.23306146264076233,
-0.13039495050907135,
-0.4298449158668518,
0.010061549954116344,
0.4473995864391327,
-0.2415892630815506,
-0.22550465166568756,
0.02350044995546341,
-0.8021261096000671,
-0.37290245294570923,
-0.0876699909567833,
0.07746095955371857,
-0.3008939027786255,
-0.3430884778499603,
0.16665610671043396,
-0.02368650771677494,
-0.1567455232143402,
0.31305184960365295,
-0.6917079091072083,
0.21122702956199646,
0.7057167887687683,
0.9764924645423889,
-0.7433570623397827,
-0.33716413378715515,
-0.4874300956726074,
0.2821490466594696,
-0.2299354374408722,
0.7936950325965881,
-0.2683681547641754,
-0.2838810086250305,
-0.03853454813361168,
-0.037241123616695404,
-0.1032763198018074,
-0.5252345204353333,
0.5701152682304382,
-0.34646880626678467,
-0.2644954323768616,
-0.1299847662448883,
-0.8160250186920166,
-0.24368149042129517,
0.2207643836736679,
-0.6895129680633545,
0.6343005299568176,
0.007131831720471382,
-0.9521219730377197,
0.2819114029407501,
-0.6953129768371582,
-0.2894696295261383,
0.1505623459815979,
-0.2011541873216629,
-0.7126071453094482,
0.09980600327253342,
0.11695994436740875,
0.2535138428211212,
-0.11130505800247192,
0.46163347363471985,
-0.4808400869369507,
-0.3996712565422058,
0.35896894335746765,
-0.40542513132095337,
0.6521829962730408,
0.06970173120498657,
-0.4155538082122803,
0.05046696588397026,
-0.8506947755813599,
0.08328979462385178,
0.16936224699020386,
-0.5170891880989075,
-0.4121820330619812,
0.2518884837627411,
0.021512143313884735,
-0.06480664014816284,
0.3410692811012268,
-0.5741716027259827,
0.07539686560630798,
-0.3207429051399231,
0.19690324366092682,
0.703051745891571,
0.11278530210256577,
0.3074573874473572,
-0.40734022855758667,
0.15539464354515076,
0.42254045605659485,
-0.13592581450939178,
-0.2148187905550003,
-0.3412107527256012,
-0.90238356590271,
-0.2108757495880127,
0.3816406726837158,
0.7467080354690552,
-0.7594262361526489,
0.4822453558444977,
-0.1329406499862671,
-0.2860598862171173,
-0.1533823311328888,
0.46515485644340515,
0.5567317008972168,
0.13420547544956207,
-0.007112784311175346,
-0.27654483914375305,
-0.7402517795562744,
-0.47037652134895325,
-0.4500349462032318,
0.024799246340990067,
0.4239203929901123,
-0.014514065347611904,
0.5146459341049194,
-0.17291869223117828,
0.9031096696853638,
-0.2667904794216156,
-0.3188014626502991,
-0.41811349987983704,
0.062292736023664474,
0.37661463022232056,
0.6344918012619019,
0.3996647298336029,
-0.6518070697784424,
-0.5841439366340637,
0.16312120854854584,
-0.89582759141922,
-0.705923318862915,
-0.06311724334955215,
0.12020576745271683,
0.5536220073699951,
0.3395838439464569,
-0.5027888417243958,
0.2281331717967987,
0.8073084354400635,
0.131984680891037,
0.7492471933364868,
-0.20136839151382446,
-0.11889364570379257,
-0.8308714628219604,
-0.12590956687927246,
-0.11869393289089203,
-0.45881953835487366,
-0.7661436796188354,
0.07612314075231552,
0.11256296932697296,
0.28315725922584534,
-0.4472654461860657,
0.5767509341239929,
-0.5636669397354126,
-0.23993074893951416,
-0.4673522710800171,
0.3844331204891205,
-0.10284585505723953,
0.3058571219444275,
0.18742682039737701,
0.685276210308075,
0.43712204694747925,
-0.6254788041114807,
0.30533546209335327,
-0.11573928594589233,
-0.33428749442100525,
0.6150298714637756,
-0.5946125984191895,
0.1551734209060669,
-0.25390490889549255,
0.12469177693128586,
-0.8384780883789062,
-0.25393831729888916,
0.24306634068489075,
-0.3035329580307007,
0.21121534705162048,
0.010140358470380306,
-0.6804431080818176,
-0.30431658029556274,
-0.2252010703086853,
0.4163617491722107,
0.23466919362545013,
-0.6528238654136658,
0.32854220271110535,
0.4293743073940277,
0.0639500692486763,
-0.5362148880958557,
-0.71822589635849,
-0.1520092636346817,
-0.058147452771663666,
-0.8241355419158936,
-0.09038998186588287,
-0.05642293021082878,
-0.2600277364253998,
0.10727837681770325,
-0.1570873260498047,
-0.15712152421474457,
0.3559020459651947,
0.14355023205280304,
0.13743600249290466,
-0.31917640566825867,
0.18482361733913422,
-0.08551226556301117,
-0.10007315129041672,
-0.2765359878540039,
-0.481010764837265,
0.6452506184577942,
-0.12247535586357117,
-0.4844416081905365,
-0.5860299468040466,
0.3073853552341461,
0.7774526476860046,
-0.3085053563117981,
0.7259792685508728,
0.37348562479019165,
-0.4892825782299042,
-0.6724225282669067,
-0.7464249730110168,
-0.025592699646949768,
-0.43535417318344116,
0.29160746932029724,
-0.06513237953186035,
-0.8725886344909668,
0.5899836421012878,
0.1155037134885788,
0.21050451695919037,
0.2553536295890808,
0.7183632850646973,
0.014132648706436157,
0.6826044321060181,
0.7248039245605469,
-0.08301856368780136,
0.4260110855102539,
0.11443661153316498,
0.20780494809150696,
-0.6183363795280457,
0.1336655467748642,
-0.4059704840183258,
-0.19359199702739716,
-0.437646746635437,
-0.30334484577178955,
0.5532220005989075,
0.15441904962062836,
0.1016470417380333,
0.1384781301021576,
-0.3776587247848511,
0.535978376865387,
0.5267252922058105,
-0.0014800912467762828,
0.656943678855896,
-0.08073008805513382,
-0.26620322465896606,
-0.0292578786611557,
-0.479667067527771,
-0.38256216049194336,
0.7153604030609131,
0.2319817841053009,
0.6743807792663574,
0.04005175456404686,
0.8608052730560303,
0.32256871461868286,
0.4620673656463623,
-0.5833076238632202,
0.6362875699996948,
-0.49052226543426514,
-0.34616661071777344,
-0.23876091837882996,
-0.43810275197029114,
-0.4795156717300415,
0.40887877345085144,
-0.12279123067855835,
-0.9040215611457825,
0.21429236233234406,
0.39350906014442444,
-0.13705264031887054,
0.69941645860672,
-0.770553708076477,
0.8764983415603638,
-0.26101920008659363,
-0.17653341591358185,
-0.15364931523799896,
-0.32664981484413147,
0.8233820796012878,
-0.46997976303100586,
0.2227419912815094,
-0.08587178587913513,
0.09558948129415512,
0.5755382776260376,
-0.4853224456310272,
0.985757052898407,
-0.17199692130088806,
0.016488157212734222,
0.20393799245357513,
0.10808832943439484,
0.7486551403999329,
-0.03957450017333031,
-0.10131102055311203,
0.1860627681016922,
0.006485000718384981,
-0.08957096189260483,
-0.20687220990657806,
0.7018846869468689,
-0.5377559065818787,
-0.6277045607566833,
-0.6135715842247009,
-0.9424404501914978,
-0.07742329686880112,
0.4377414286136627,
0.062231358140707016,
0.335819810628891,
0.0938950702548027,
0.10514302551746368,
0.48142072558403015,
-0.31596681475639343,
0.6169309616088867,
0.8309664726257324,
-0.20076481997966766,
-0.15954017639160156,
0.8818501830101013,
0.06730334460735321,
0.5095916390419006,
0.18820534646511078,
0.1619231253862381,
-0.09325205534696579,
-1.0517727136611938,
-0.38870689272880554,
0.5377920866012573,
-0.7283316254615784,
-0.11329033225774765,
-0.5436872839927673,
-0.31281620264053345,
-0.20034323632717133,
-0.0007737533887848258,
-0.36583325266838074,
-0.12154433131217957,
-0.252007395029068,
0.16854317486286163,
0.04916361719369888,
0.754220187664032,
0.13880832493305206,
0.4292973577976227,
-1.2378536462783813,
0.00690116873010993,
-0.1912616491317749,
0.3379901051521301,
0.0037265566643327475,
-0.18899452686309814,
-0.22396960854530334,
0.04462306573987007,
-0.3089914917945862,
-0.817200243473053,
0.42416366934776306,
0.18347330391407013,
0.5272465944290161,
0.2242017537355423,
0.16846869885921478,
0.44052016735076904,
-0.46510985493659973,
0.6228311657905579,
0.12620234489440918,
-1.190900206565857,
0.24668003618717194,
-0.21952472627162933,
0.4195544421672821,
0.28421005606651306,
0.02971765026450157,
-0.7499035596847534,
-0.8152549266815186,
-0.263320654630661,
-0.49382004141807556,
0.846180260181427,
-0.05275930091738701,
-0.378071665763855,
-0.11477303504943848,
0.113784059882164,
0.04792938753962517,
0.3528122007846832,
-0.9693982601165771,
-0.015812018886208534,
0.30038028955459595,
-0.2953338027000427,
0.2532258629798889,
-0.4196609854698181,
0.15214376151561737,
0.2579077184200287,
0.6951394081115723,
-0.07704842835664749,
-0.057479988783597946,
0.25722870230674744,
-0.41553062200546265,
-0.08855147659778595,
0.5229940414428711,
0.6979407668113708,
0.7576285004615784,
-0.02297026664018631,
0.12409313768148422,
0.30521848797798157,
-0.2718909680843353,
-0.0775265172123909,
-0.32744112610816956,
-0.38734641671180725,
0.31762632727622986,
0.1893676519393921,
0.5880900025367737,
0.18116073310375214,
-0.9917406439781189,
0.6402638554573059,
0.29443836212158203,
0.025575609877705574,
-0.3727227747440338,
-0.19751934707164764,
0.17259004712104797,
0.28837987780570984,
-0.03416656702756882,
0.11054130643606186,
-0.07062140107154846,
-0.4102555811405182,
0.42077934741973877,
0.4130527079105377,
0.044735684990882874,
-0.2270185351371765,
0.5040300488471985,
0.2527765929698944,
-0.03259442001581192,
0.2910092771053314,
-0.4768504798412323,
-0.9429870247840881,
0.6715114712715149,
0.7538195848464966,
0.820647120475769,
-0.14920936524868011,
-0.013426984660327435,
0.03952823206782341,
0.29606392979621887,
-0.3669225573539734,
0.2661156952381134,
0.4434523582458496,
-1.0574557781219482,
-0.4484250247478485,
-0.6196828484535217,
-0.5223815441131592,
0.04813230782747269,
-0.17929793894290924,
0.5441475510597229,
-0.5220302939414978,
0.21562251448631287,
-0.2787921726703644,
-0.41495174169540405,
-0.18164345622062683,
-0.008823907002806664,
0.37935054302215576,
0.7347250580787659,
-0.6119449734687805,
0.9585700631141663,
0.46327871084213257,
0.09210408478975296,
-0.6550915241241455,
-0.00495807034894824,
0.20931725203990936,
-0.7082089781761169,
0.7516549229621887,
0.1650673747062683,
-0.05236859619617462,
-0.15981213748455048,
-0.2932576835155487,
-0.6498144268989563,
0.9321209788322449,
0.25887271761894226,
-0.9040772318840027,
0.004937112797051668,
0.18811187148094177,
0.3545254170894623,
-0.4202255606651306,
0.0679236650466919,
0.6059030294418335,
0.5241298079490662,
-0.10833868384361267,
-1.153427004814148,
0.12016911059617996,
0.23038412630558014,
-0.041479289531707764,
0.5128197073936462,
-0.6583506464958191,
1.0835843086242676,
-0.044732801616191864,
-0.5714582204818726,
0.135189488530159,
0.5402767658233643,
0.33566972613334656,
0.45560160279273987,
0.899703860282898,
0.6815234422683716,
0.9103557467460632,
-0.26989656686782837,
0.9460014700889587,
-0.4697422385215759,
0.49924325942993164,
1.0036791563034058,
-0.49549758434295654,
0.8707753419876099,
0.27253302931785583,
0.024185312911868095,
0.1941639930009842,
0.168331578373909,
-0.10439867526292801,
0.3480128347873688,
0.29471272230148315,
-0.45636090636253357,
-0.09419043362140656,
-0.0629149079322815,
-0.1549716293811798,
0.16529875993728638,
0.7119351029396057,
-0.22078242897987366,
-0.5208088755607605,
0.04852176085114479,
0.18109440803527832,
0.12481428682804108,
-0.4375927150249481,
0.5246703624725342,
0.3285965323448181,
-0.6818686723709106,
0.6104121208190918,
0.0849742591381073,
1.0154039859771729,
-0.4411497712135315,
0.02028663270175457,
-0.1759701669216156,
0.5649721026420593,
-0.40292102098464966,
-0.6306345462799072,
0.4886832535266876,
0.08715954422950745,
-0.23514720797538757,
0.022931937128305435,
0.9109768867492676,
-0.8210320472717285,
-0.31069955229759216,
0.37926894426345825,
0.487616628408432,
0.1619451344013214,
0.064585380256176,
-0.4562898278236389,
0.6669596433639526,
0.022760413587093353,
0.3058615028858185,
0.09556661546230316,
0.4312792420387268,
-0.22902806103229523,
0.6412650346755981,
0.5271561145782471,
0.3326629400253296,
0.2797769010066986,
0.028358113020658493,
0.7907862663269043,
-0.38210952281951904,
-0.6508936882019043,
-0.9446816444396973,
0.32420170307159424,
-0.28250807523727417,
0.04597873613238335,
0.6186065673828125,
0.3294382095336914,
0.923674464225769,
-0.1508806049823761,
1.030822992324829,
0.0029740966856479645,
0.6874492168426514,
-0.7544418573379517,
0.5722200870513916,
-0.4696315824985504,
0.8322426080703735,
-0.08291816711425781,
-0.8131566047668457,
-0.3842068016529083,
0.15365974605083466,
-0.31993985176086426,
-0.2947643995285034,
1.1682742834091187,
0.8338040709495544,
-0.018047720193862915,
0.18113602697849274,
0.3536610007286072,
0.46795493364334106,
0.3916453719139099,
0.7020121216773987,
0.5536736845970154,
-0.09166008234024048,
0.5437325239181519,
-0.21232257783412933,
-0.22207270562648773,
-0.13083690404891968,
-0.9398549199104309,
-0.9899998903274536,
-0.31752490997314453,
-0.28986096382141113,
-0.3435606062412262,
0.43019968271255493,
0.9425821304321289,
0.33900561928749084,
-1.0595675706863403,
-0.42968785762786865,
-0.12687449157238007,
0.4808145761489868,
-0.1899145543575287,
-0.24086086452007294,
0.08068575710058212,
-0.6929069757461548,
-0.9731348156929016,
0.2074020504951477,
0.3468441069126129,
-0.08897636830806732,
-0.12401781231164932,
0.1174112930893898,
-0.05679841339588165,
-0.14072392880916595,
0.32220134139060974,
0.2423599809408188,
-0.7316263318061829,
-0.5597947835922241,
-0.32659924030303955,
-0.06705384701490402,
0.03292914107441902,
0.9224022626876831,
-0.1862202137708664,
0.38248440623283386,
0.7891041040420532,
0.9147000312805176,
0.13468456268310547,
-0.09294187277555466,
0.6782736778259277,
-0.8668195009231567,
0.2799585163593292,
0.017204387113451958,
0.641560971736908,
0.3274262845516205,
-0.26364919543266296,
0.31020352244377136,
0.713186502456665,
-0.686327338218689,
-0.8819728493690491,
0.22511881589889526,
-1.3406871557235718,
-0.07160259038209915,
1.1479759216308594,
-0.48045825958251953,
-0.4955150783061981,
-0.3961891829967499,
-0.19807708263397217,
0.056666046380996704,
-0.42927128076553345,
0.4165615737438202,
0.9356188774108887,
0.299703985452652,
-0.34928616881370544,
-0.6806153655052185,
0.3400754928588867,
0.33634454011917114,
-0.7268534302711487,
0.11164196580648422,
0.3467721939086914,
0.5194666981697083,
0.19637250900268555,
0.5131772756576538,
-0.19571632146835327,
0.3589315414428711,
-0.3239095211029053,
0.08508658409118652,
-0.021027972921729088,
-0.02883748523890972,
-0.3029712438583374,
0.08967125415802002,
0.05380316451191902,
-0.3458890914916992
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16385v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16385v2
|
Synthesize Step-by-Step: Tools, Templates and LLMs as Data Generators for Reasoning-Based Chart VQA
| 2024-03-25T03:02:27 | 2024-03-28T16:45:44 |
Zhuowan Li, Bhavan Jasani, Peng Tang, Shabnam Ghadar
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Understanding data visualizations like charts and plots requires reasoning
about both visual elements and numerics. Although strong in extractive
questions, current chart visual question answering (chart VQA) models suffer on
complex reasoning questions. In this work, we address the lack of reasoning
ability by data augmentation. We leverage Large Language Models (LLMs), which
have shown to have strong reasoning ability, as an automatic data annotator
that generates question-answer annotations for chart images. The key innovation
in our method lies in the Synthesize Step-by-Step strategy: our LLM-based data
generator learns to decompose the complex question into step-by-step
sub-questions (rationales), which are then used to derive the final answer
using external tools, i.e. Python. This step-wise generation procedure is
trained on synthetic data generated using a template-based QA generation
pipeline. Experimental results highlight the significance of the proposed
step-by-step generation. By training with the LLM-augmented data (LAMENDA), we
significantly enhance the chart VQA models, achieving the state-of-the-art
accuracy on the ChartQA and PlotQA datasets. In particular, our approach
improves the accuracy of the previous state-of-the-art approach from 38% to 54%
on the human-written questions in the ChartQA dataset, which needs strong
reasoning. We hope our work underscores the potential of synthetic data and
encourages further exploration of data augmentation using LLMs for
reasoning-heavy tasks.
|
[
-0.4769936501979828,
-0.8303594589233398,
0.809755265712738,
-0.21721841394901276,
-0.3303746283054352,
0.2985017001628876,
0.20222674310207367,
-0.4218008518218994,
0.13157615065574646,
0.8548258543014526,
-0.6944103240966797,
-0.6754243969917297,
-0.1951032131910324,
0.13827021420001984,
-0.3753947913646698,
0.6166258454322815,
-0.2192915976047516,
0.19401051104068756,
-0.3084314167499542,
-0.016746317967772484,
-0.5757518410682678,
-0.40607091784477234,
-0.5364323854446411,
-0.17933028936386108,
0.4703812301158905,
0.6341955065727234,
0.675844132900238,
0.6574431657791138,
0.16083885729312897,
0.29798585176467896,
0.16971059143543243,
0.6247650980949402,
-0.617719292640686,
0.49066248536109924,
-0.040952444076538086,
-0.4783097505569458,
-0.5268357992172241,
-0.1107216402888298,
0.09229478985071182,
0.7270561456680298,
0.4528152644634247,
0.39786630868911743,
-0.31245461106300354,
0.7179015874862671,
-0.3235548734664917,
0.6923407316207886,
-0.5374671816825867,
-0.07499772310256958,
0.0658029243350029,
-0.2675708532333374,
-0.36984550952911377,
-0.49149444699287415,
-0.07097604125738144,
-0.890027642250061,
0.026370735839009285,
0.1259884238243103,
0.5971844792366028,
0.30730393528938293,
-0.7850642800331116,
-0.15739615261554718,
-0.7139977812767029,
0.5054277777671814,
-0.5418342351913452,
0.24199531972408295,
0.1773097664117813,
0.7385038137435913,
-0.2389959990978241,
-1.2222862243652344,
-0.6573454141616821,
-0.12941645085811615,
0.09832349419593811,
0.28375375270843506,
0.017706969752907753,
-0.194270059466362,
0.4888060986995697,
0.2199501395225525,
-0.49441084265708923,
-0.08378543704748154,
-0.6385003328323364,
-0.15862902998924255,
0.9884828329086304,
0.5099974870681763,
0.48296675086021423,
-0.40984204411506653,
-0.2895336449146271,
-0.3125327229499817,
-0.9615094661712646,
0.0032752794213593006,
0.21329234540462494,
0.21040372550487518,
0.1584336757659912,
0.8965673446655273,
-0.4318450391292572,
0.5341097712516785,
0.09924051910638809,
0.06256216019392014,
0.30470654368400574,
-0.37101104855537415,
-0.12092357128858566,
0.11451779305934906,
0.6532986760139465,
0.44174498319625854,
0.3604341149330139,
0.17273660004138947,
-0.19732321798801422,
-0.05206714943051338,
0.34637853503227234,
-0.6466870307922363,
-0.5016728639602661,
0.45478999614715576,
0.08968289941549301,
-0.32159557938575745,
-0.19825126230716705,
-0.3185453414916992,
-0.7046270966529846,
-0.6916079521179199,
0.4627467095851898,
-0.5234516859054565,
0.035307880491018295,
-0.01010468602180481,
-0.0892978087067604,
0.22922447323799133,
0.7275741100311279,
-0.39136093854904175,
-0.07810182124376297,
0.636339545249939,
0.2466263622045517,
0.051796264946460724,
-0.09980780631303787,
-0.6933483481407166,
0.20617987215518951,
-0.8282485008239746,
0.8129175901412964,
-0.2045450359582901,
-0.19963721930980682,
-0.11868693679571152,
0.014431857503950596,
0.21072667837142944,
-0.49686703085899353,
0.4550340175628662,
-0.531415581703186,
0.1665789783000946,
-0.4203747808933258,
-0.7238063812255859,
-0.3392447233200073,
0.25141283869743347,
-0.8839077949523926,
0.9391118288040161,
0.2997925579547882,
-0.6885409951210022,
0.3890322148799896,
-0.48809367418289185,
-0.3248969614505768,
0.26710245013237,
-0.5098069906234741,
-0.339006632566452,
-0.2706630825996399,
0.8752971291542053,
0.33398374915122986,
-0.45674940943717957,
-0.09078741818666458,
-0.12345912307500839,
-0.3587925136089325,
0.49328064918518066,
-0.142429918050766,
0.7043589353561401,
0.22098863124847412,
-0.3756448030471802,
0.4062579870223999,
-0.7922028303146362,
0.27393314242362976,
0.2973501980304718,
-0.21390008926391602,
0.06765566021203995,
-0.07561871409416199,
0.07837534695863724,
0.1861666589975357,
0.06668036431074142,
-0.275322824716568,
0.2591237425804138,
-0.36856573820114136,
0.32679852843284607,
0.6640214920043945,
0.3345795273780823,
0.21262498199939728,
-0.2787019908428192,
0.6781193614006042,
0.12230119854211807,
0.03913858160376549,
-0.3047856390476227,
-0.6071485280990601,
-0.8180638551712036,
-0.3171813488006592,
0.29121193289756775,
0.5247207880020142,
-1.134291410446167,
0.2244439423084259,
-0.48331737518310547,
-0.796207845211029,
-0.41672423481941223,
0.21859526634216309,
0.016462529078125954,
0.877234160900116,
0.4080621898174286,
-0.22379164397716522,
-0.7290806770324707,
-0.7549275159835815,
0.23419812321662903,
-0.2102382630109787,
-0.08129587769508362,
-0.04716069623827934,
0.36808109283447266,
-0.14270034432411194,
0.7987086772918701,
-0.6125375032424927,
0.24847528338432312,
-0.6619297862052917,
0.09492166340351105,
0.15591959655284882,
0.307696670293808,
0.49161669611930847,
-0.7690576910972595,
-0.36478617787361145,
-0.1870861053466797,
-0.7981211543083191,
-0.19385430216789246,
-0.41208571195602417,
-0.44286245107650757,
0.003116947365924716,
0.6182909607887268,
-0.6370031237602234,
0.6012846827507019,
0.012350684963166714,
-0.3369717597961426,
0.6702339053153992,
0.07689271867275238,
0.26993298530578613,
-1.0739151239395142,
-0.12017177790403366,
-0.04488592594861984,
-0.2349446415901184,
-0.7690805792808533,
0.08465638011693954,
0.028457125648856163,
-0.32508912682533264,
-0.3335005044937134,
0.5309765338897705,
-0.32034286856651306,
-0.0034786586184054613,
-0.19409583508968353,
0.06278547644615173,
0.16655109822750092,
0.3834080398082733,
0.14669735729694366,
0.6903261542320251,
0.5513924956321716,
-0.4044758677482605,
0.6710650324821472,
0.4756079614162445,
-0.36283114552497864,
0.44460734724998474,
-0.6595613956451416,
0.1991211473941803,
-0.22085893154144287,
0.3960646390914917,
-1.260522484779358,
-0.3944377601146698,
0.462106317281723,
-0.32401642203330994,
0.09609585255384445,
-0.2876266539096832,
-0.5998193025588989,
-0.458487331867218,
-0.1680341511964798,
0.21435494720935822,
0.5734374523162842,
-0.6180633902549744,
0.6058961749076843,
0.21492479741573334,
-0.32983696460723877,
-0.27816811203956604,
-0.6001471877098083,
0.2144763171672821,
-0.2347744256258011,
-0.8055875897407532,
-0.11675389856100082,
-0.13269536197185516,
-0.2584921717643738,
-0.30633220076560974,
-0.0704222023487091,
-0.06840579956769943,
-0.12682314217090607,
0.40701496601104736,
0.4306442439556122,
-0.12810982763767242,
0.0928012803196907,
0.07935081422328949,
-0.3197267949581146,
0.31195369362831116,
-0.19789904356002808,
0.3247130513191223,
0.18935905396938324,
-0.7110611200332642,
-0.3587844967842102,
0.18606990575790405,
0.6951425671577454,
-0.2765597701072693,
0.2481812685728073,
0.6227088570594788,
-0.19404444098472595,
-0.17333801090717316,
-0.30777519941329956,
-0.14254754781723022,
-0.4969545602798462,
0.17246708273887634,
-0.3497718274593353,
-0.44775769114494324,
0.3666127026081085,
-0.1362506002187729,
0.19634540379047394,
0.3402896225452423,
0.6212228536605835,
-0.3246991038322449,
1.136252760887146,
-0.1749955713748932,
0.27258071303367615,
0.19690126180648804,
-0.5820171236991882,
0.1916889101266861,
-0.5103370547294617,
-0.15887556970119476,
-0.05860474333167076,
-0.32880523800849915,
-0.524772584438324,
-0.6944002509117126,
0.7497138381004333,
-0.08582182228565216,
-0.499132364988327,
-0.0666082426905632,
-0.4507533609867096,
0.13115495443344116,
0.6646870374679565,
0.3066886067390442,
0.17394617199897766,
-0.027222346514463425,
0.17700770497322083,
-0.11117534339427948,
-0.583283543586731,
-0.5339921116828918,
1.5046199560165405,
0.08630278706550598,
0.6985723376274109,
-0.20653030276298523,
0.7098351120948792,
0.07475316524505615,
0.22837722301483154,
-0.6934545040130615,
0.6544036269187927,
0.406035453081131,
-0.40161576867103577,
-0.4103761911392212,
-0.3982326090335846,
-0.8787350654602051,
0.14594683051109314,
-0.49373021721839905,
-0.458489328622818,
-0.06584323942661285,
0.2527211606502533,
0.04820890352129936,
0.07738517224788666,
-0.8359661102294922,
0.8078777194023132,
-0.3997243642807007,
-0.23562589287757874,
0.10315129160881042,
-0.5101923942565918,
0.517834484577179,
-0.09812140464782715,
0.14643090963363647,
0.15960024297237396,
0.17875276505947113,
0.3682107925415039,
-0.7408698797225952,
0.6795222759246826,
-0.06051502376794815,
-0.18454106152057648,
0.7714316844940186,
0.1321674883365631,
0.7428438663482666,
0.04064960777759552,
0.025075649842619896,
-0.33590784668922424,
-0.20107761025428772,
-0.6123985052108765,
-0.8977527618408203,
0.3988601863384247,
-0.48544275760650635,
-0.7022308111190796,
-0.11989791691303253,
-0.7273148894309998,
-0.4549108147621155,
-0.0028502708300948143,
-0.07262533903121948,
0.559731125831604,
0.30560988187789917,
0.09640906006097794,
0.3703308403491974,
-0.19300107657909393,
-0.18931731581687927,
0.03615959361195564,
-0.48834896087646484,
-0.7079052329063416,
0.8081022500991821,
0.23780107498168945,
0.24998612701892853,
0.09521286189556122,
0.03579796850681305,
-0.4336647689342499,
-0.6070394515991211,
-0.6400136351585388,
0.05461719259619713,
-1.0339875221252441,
-0.006164443679153919,
-0.28235673904418945,
-0.29231032729148865,
-0.34869325160980225,
-0.11407507210969925,
-0.09938553720712662,
-0.8307653069496155,
-0.22353944182395935,
-0.48046258091926575,
0.7226862907409668,
0.674953281879425,
-0.04066478833556175,
-0.06866854429244995,
-0.5739005208015442,
0.7263956069946289,
0.6303166151046753,
-0.32408595085144043,
-0.07081807404756546,
-0.1238417699933052,
-0.24258747696876526,
0.13148652017116547,
-0.35907235741615295,
-0.9687416553497314,
0.31138700246810913,
-0.37912365794181824,
0.34556013345718384,
0.018289020285010338,
0.06924958527088165,
0.7510366439819336,
-0.20662380754947662,
0.8619132041931152,
0.20273903012275696,
-0.7169660925865173,
0.5644294619560242,
-0.33321070671081543,
0.3686942756175995,
0.1146991029381752,
0.2793177366256714,
-0.14533516764640808,
-0.6168382167816162,
-0.5287942290306091,
-1.214638590812683,
0.36738118529319763,
0.3753263056278229,
-0.07961856573820114,
0.2087124139070511,
0.41876134276390076,
0.11591852456331253,
0.20181185007095337,
-0.42496395111083984,
-0.34392595291137695,
-0.5551445484161377,
-0.4448965787887573,
-0.09859316051006317,
0.12130402028560638,
-0.18788941204547882,
-0.6286395192146301,
0.545245349407196,
-0.43619322776794434,
-0.19578711688518524,
0.1976870894432068,
-0.046795785427093506,
-0.07155550271272659,
0.14626674354076385,
0.045022424310445786,
0.9650128483772278,
0.033262211829423904,
0.17943075299263,
0.12662561237812042,
-0.35605692863464355,
0.09619767963886261,
0.23767141997814178,
-0.43306222558021545,
-0.15945252776145935,
0.547315239906311,
0.7788266539573669,
0.0071924226358532906,
-1.062827229499817,
0.15248985588550568,
-0.021319905295968056,
-0.21662753820419312,
-0.3318151831626892,
0.28624165058135986,
0.5388381481170654,
0.4892326295375824,
0.6023941040039062,
-0.3480603098869324,
0.042202532291412354,
-0.4571259617805481,
0.2757226824760437,
0.19133752584457397,
-0.09037657082080841,
-0.02942102588713169,
0.9016172289848328,
-0.04394958168268204,
0.006052751559764147,
0.617700457572937,
-0.07144629955291748,
-0.3965177536010742,
0.7443121671676636,
0.23016956448554993,
0.3992789387702942,
0.2269095480442047,
0.44739148020744324,
0.4653032124042511,
0.2036171555519104,
0.41971710324287415,
0.9359685778617859,
0.13814029097557068,
-0.2947448194026947,
-0.6184288263320923,
-0.0719711035490036,
-0.5930756330490112,
0.33664196729660034,
-0.4714469611644745,
0.20677895843982697,
-0.4232460856437683,
-0.1003987118601799,
0.018394913524389267,
0.00731821171939373,
-0.8161500692367554,
0.6060904860496521,
0.23671437799930573,
0.6973909735679626,
-0.6533262133598328,
0.40348729491233826,
0.7028271555900574,
-0.8155180215835571,
-1.1269721984863281,
-0.14197248220443726,
-0.13100303709506989,
-0.7041147351264954,
0.7559043765068054,
-0.05660080164670944,
0.3426630198955536,
-0.08716291934251785,
-0.8690492510795593,
-0.6945789456367493,
1.2985453605651855,
0.5383642911911011,
-0.33892908692359924,
0.24321457743644714,
0.49527719616889954,
0.7141539454460144,
-0.42227134108543396,
0.22682520747184753,
0.37230533361434937,
0.6305378675460815,
0.4563002288341522,
-0.48493826389312744,
0.3821837902069092,
-0.26632750034332275,
-0.1414627581834793,
-0.1401519477367401,
-0.11060354858636856,
0.8362229466438293,
-0.34947723150253296,
-0.10731299221515656,
-0.0441618487238884,
0.7427549958229065,
0.5791155695915222,
0.4834141433238983,
0.42816004157066345,
0.49078240990638733,
0.7673384547233582,
-0.09823513776063919,
0.9658104181289673,
-0.22482211887836456,
-0.03584231808781624,
1.17449951171875,
-0.19558167457580566,
0.6275381445884705,
0.46122267842292786,
0.01392571721225977,
0.6091267466545105,
0.642772376537323,
0.1762704998254776,
0.20293128490447998,
0.3628007471561432,
0.09937990456819534,
-0.650185763835907,
0.083278127014637,
-0.21952477097511292,
0.28994330763816833,
0.3462957441806793,
-0.3359566628932953,
-0.17923538386821747,
-0.21274055540561676,
-0.17857834696769714,
0.07506641000509262,
-0.25918057560920715,
0.5620009899139404,
-0.015459660440683365,
-0.39974111318588257,
0.8891127109527588,
-0.44944465160369873,
-0.3239195942878723,
-0.38637322187423706,
-0.28039252758026123,
-0.15413187444210052,
-0.3565223217010498,
-0.06741728633642197,
-1.1322364807128906,
-0.14293529093265533,
0.020119421184062958,
0.2275005429983139,
-0.17382843792438507,
0.5379372835159302,
-0.37598922848701477,
-0.7630040049552917,
-0.24267920851707458,
0.9305225014686584,
-0.010295058600604534,
0.018959056586027145,
-0.5927891731262207,
-0.06919433176517487,
0.09482905268669128,
-0.3639645278453827,
-0.017328238114714622,
0.6319378614425659,
-0.2178819328546524,
0.9509800672531128,
0.7894802689552307,
0.06873821467161179,
0.14762523770332336,
0.24984262883663177,
1.0564181804656982,
-0.5966630578041077,
-0.4645569324493408,
-0.22605040669441223,
0.8875142931938171,
-0.20066899061203003,
0.013315968215465546,
0.6430051922798157,
0.5683028101921082,
0.5856783986091614,
-0.18127121031284332,
1.1166774034500122,
0.2425127625465393,
0.5420582890510559,
-0.711758017539978,
0.5211340188980103,
-0.5917733311653137,
0.21542051434516907,
-0.28841865062713623,
-0.7245195508003235,
-0.020949261263012886,
0.2645179033279419,
-0.44368985295295715,
-0.20108065009117126,
0.5845836997032166,
0.8372983336448669,
-0.13354599475860596,
-0.022956112399697304,
-0.025218354538083076,
0.2202347218990326,
0.541655421257019,
0.5790130496025085,
0.8861289024353027,
-0.44921496510505676,
0.7426422834396362,
-0.30540886521339417,
0.09658975899219513,
-0.014676336199045181,
-0.5942896008491516,
-0.7735828757286072,
-0.7440434694290161,
-0.4733346402645111,
-0.4607740342617035,
-0.2776763141155243,
0.7573263049125671,
0.38608524203300476,
-0.6598702669143677,
-0.04442809522151947,
-0.13135552406311035,
0.22375096380710602,
-0.23109598457813263,
-0.2885124683380127,
0.6275036931037903,
-0.13669492304325104,
-0.6709914803504944,
0.5513071417808533,
0.10197455435991287,
0.3039751648902893,
-0.4430157542228699,
-0.18029052019119263,
0.14180442690849304,
0.27181199193000793,
0.4825424551963806,
0.21751749515533447,
-0.47737839818000793,
-0.43890705704689026,
-0.11744046211242676,
0.008052371442317963,
0.24906180799007416,
0.5834466218948364,
-0.9047043919563293,
0.8003964424133301,
0.6198839545249939,
0.4900650680065155,
0.7582792043685913,
0.2544110119342804,
0.7053097486495972,
-0.4305536448955536,
-0.07927871495485306,
0.20061251521110535,
0.40199893712997437,
0.49652230739593506,
-0.2116955667734146,
0.6653782725334167,
-0.0010114784818142653,
-0.18985441327095032,
-0.8121872544288635,
0.4278472065925598,
-1.0986913442611694,
-0.2454790323972702,
0.9869726896286011,
0.04638904705643654,
-0.3428311049938202,
-0.1298675388097763,
-0.7327104806900024,
0.39078179001808167,
-0.21076491475105286,
0.8175107836723328,
0.3156419098377228,
-0.46106579899787903,
-0.09323529899120331,
-0.4062637686729431,
0.37422242760658264,
0.0018091914243996143,
-1.2245959043502808,
-0.060724399983882904,
0.987913191318512,
0.23154236376285553,
0.12699249386787415,
0.5022834539413452,
0.0710330531001091,
0.47103118896484375,
0.20194584131240845,
-0.23130258917808533,
-0.31911784410476685,
-0.034674204885959625,
0.26010945439338684,
0.21885235607624054,
0.19080910086631775,
-0.027377592399716377
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08656v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08656v1
|
Linear Cross-document Event Coreference Resolution with X-AMR
| 2024-03-25T02:49:06 | 2024-03-25T02:49:06 |
Shafiuddin Rehan Ahmed, George Arthur Baker, Evi Judge, Michael Regan, Kristin Wright-Bettner, Martha Palmer, James H. Martin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Event Coreference Resolution (ECR) as a pairwise mention classification task
is expensive both for automated systems and manual annotations. The task's
quadratic difficulty is exacerbated when using Large Language Models (LLMs),
making prompt engineering for ECR prohibitively costly. In this work, we
propose a graphical representation of events, X-AMR, anchored around individual
mentions using a \textbf{cross}-document version of \textbf{A}bstract
\textbf{M}eaning \textbf{R}epresentation. We then linearize the ECR with a
novel multi-hop coreference algorithm over the event graphs. The event graphs
simplify ECR, making it a) LLM cost-effective, b) compositional and
interpretable, and c) easily annotated. For a fair assessment, we first enrich
an existing ECR benchmark dataset with these event graphs using an
annotator-friendly tool we introduce. Then, we employ GPT-4, the newest LLM by
OpenAI, for these annotations. Finally, using the ECR algorithm, we assess
GPT-4 against humans and analyze its limitations. Through this research, we aim
to advance the state-of-the-art for efficient ECR and shed light on the
potential shortcomings of current LLMs at this task. Code and annotations:
\url{https://github.com/ahmeshaf/gpt_coref}
|
[
-0.6439096331596375,
-0.398287296295166,
0.6137621998786926,
-0.2604924738407135,
-0.3102794289588928,
0.18700185418128967,
-0.6262233853340149,
-0.9585740566253662,
0.2018434852361679,
0.23044531047344208,
-0.35565829277038574,
-0.5473631024360657,
-0.5918901562690735,
0.2820172905921936,
-0.24254009127616882,
1.1639007329940796,
-0.3684838116168976,
-0.36599621176719666,
-0.07057558000087738,
-0.3576355576515198,
0.07524681836366653,
-1.06584632396698,
-0.7105146050453186,
-0.5663760304450989,
0.663906455039978,
0.29946327209472656,
0.5615870952606201,
0.6755778789520264,
0.4128274619579315,
0.30550283193588257,
-0.07605458796024323,
0.1604946106672287,
-0.22916245460510254,
0.027027752250432968,
-0.07250458002090454,
-0.29079100489616394,
-0.6137052178382874,
0.06539767235517502,
0.539141058921814,
0.38891252875328064,
0.2991221845149994,
0.06525041162967682,
0.11700636893510818,
0.1470007747411728,
-0.38138896226882935,
0.4378848373889923,
-0.5096220970153809,
-0.229955792427063,
-0.5069425702095032,
-0.3360862135887146,
-0.2797183096408844,
0.029913023114204407,
0.14793848991394043,
-0.6604893803596497,
0.479053258895874,
0.3708258271217346,
1.037445306777954,
-0.0895058885216713,
-0.14370879530906677,
-0.5042964220046997,
-0.6782530546188354,
0.7169955372810364,
-0.38925811648368835,
0.28219130635261536,
0.16917797923088074,
0.15809425711631775,
0.16073761880397797,
-0.7732493877410889,
-0.7070372700691223,
-0.13205187022686005,
-0.23129001259803772,
-0.17567560076713562,
-0.5703193545341492,
0.2245425134897232,
0.5052375793457031,
0.19368629157543182,
-0.5338510870933533,
0.18312928080558777,
-0.2239319086074829,
-0.2984611392021179,
0.37913548946380615,
0.22278062999248505,
0.21972565352916718,
-0.1957234889268875,
-0.21262097358703613,
0.05235890671610832,
-0.6359599232673645,
-0.009441309608519077,
0.19331689178943634,
0.3022785484790802,
-0.1175425723195076,
0.44200587272644043,
-0.13187478482723236,
0.32679444551467896,
0.403982549905777,
0.021943334490060806,
0.3747042715549469,
-0.5880928635597229,
0.2843092381954193,
0.06645284593105316,
0.8110663294792175,
0.580402135848999,
0.2526310086250305,
-0.28514185547828674,
-0.09703214466571808,
0.25019991397857666,
-0.05958053469657898,
-0.8849212527275085,
-0.29017218947410583,
0.11393482238054276,
-0.21270978450775146,
-0.05259718373417854,
-0.27416014671325684,
-0.6442480683326721,
-0.40537115931510925,
-0.3500881493091583,
0.2547205984592438,
-0.30904871225357056,
0.2516154646873474,
-0.3746703863143921,
-0.11644144356250763,
0.18395107984542847,
0.6011415719985962,
-0.5613898038864136,
0.344176709651947,
0.6057884693145752,
1.0179767608642578,
0.15121588110923767,
-0.21414591372013092,
-0.6912087798118591,
0.10579624027013779,
0.20606356859207153,
0.9731056094169617,
-0.6242649555206299,
-0.5013412237167358,
-0.1975141018629074,
-0.19797773659229279,
0.19946645200252533,
-0.2992105185985565,
0.9222827553749084,
-0.2934619188308716,
-0.10130995512008667,
-0.5788351893424988,
-0.5777103900909424,
0.03795527666807175,
0.46586164832115173,
-0.5545887351036072,
0.7499405145645142,
-0.21407553553581238,
-1.0301417112350464,
0.3467133939266205,
-0.5554521679878235,
-0.18049286305904388,
0.26768651604652405,
-0.703046441078186,
-0.42779138684272766,
-0.34268084168434143,
0.5169612765312195,
0.5449789762496948,
-0.41492554545402527,
-0.11616310477256775,
-0.35015609860420227,
-0.09356015920639038,
0.2557746469974518,
0.16488003730773926,
0.34107956290245056,
-0.2248457670211792,
-0.4391220510005951,
0.45031917095184326,
-0.8497546315193176,
-0.19329336285591125,
-0.07446617633104324,
-0.04736030474305153,
-0.6199800968170166,
0.07356156408786774,
0.12627893686294556,
0.4686693251132965,
0.2059677094221115,
-0.8411601185798645,
0.2558765113353729,
-0.005090764723718166,
0.468910813331604,
0.6733030676841736,
-0.08576847612857819,
0.43649446964263916,
-0.2623459994792938,
0.27296268939971924,
-0.030861923471093178,
-0.005930814892053604,
-0.43393537402153015,
-0.6343681812286377,
-0.7819995880126953,
-0.30406367778778076,
0.013816933147609234,
0.45544105768203735,
-0.5466786623001099,
0.4898165464401245,
-0.43726298213005066,
-0.3965267837047577,
-0.21072803437709808,
0.09315868467092514,
0.5502631664276123,
0.5878134965896606,
0.5126373171806335,
-0.11214254051446915,
-0.8969528079032898,
-0.7680795788764954,
0.12137916684150696,
-0.4156310558319092,
-0.06796064227819443,
0.3416290879249573,
0.5906961560249329,
-0.10442359000444412,
0.9904747009277344,
-0.36184656620025635,
-0.4367119371891022,
-0.18779371678829193,
0.6580670475959778,
0.03834572061896324,
0.32545503973960876,
0.5204511284828186,
-0.4686216115951538,
-0.3862038254737854,
0.26422661542892456,
-0.5007389783859253,
-0.43930840492248535,
-0.18032896518707275,
-0.03892219066619873,
0.16483135521411896,
0.3742506802082062,
-0.40040022134780884,
0.5854276418685913,
0.46089428663253784,
-0.3625124990940094,
0.731887698173523,
-0.17507149279117584,
0.1904982626438141,
-0.7323969602584839,
0.28544092178344727,
0.25418537855148315,
-0.41010257601737976,
-0.5256614685058594,
-0.23053492605686188,
0.18846099078655243,
-0.06866127252578735,
0.10341957211494446,
0.6703708171844482,
-0.6962741017341614,
0.08031371980905533,
-0.440485417842865,
0.511447548866272,
-0.10275763273239136,
0.5516982078552246,
0.3203132748603821,
0.4651743769645691,
0.29081135988235474,
-0.515994131565094,
0.34534752368927,
0.36751729249954224,
0.013140344060957432,
0.8750759959220886,
-0.59262615442276,
0.3417613208293915,
-0.0032245006877928972,
0.5898162126541138,
-0.748583197593689,
0.13477616012096405,
0.40971192717552185,
-0.47391432523727417,
0.2482442855834961,
-0.3089820146560669,
-0.436076283454895,
-0.37117013335227966,
-0.36806678771972656,
0.37738853693008423,
0.394525408744812,
-0.7534990310668945,
0.791424036026001,
0.24888157844543457,
-0.340755820274353,
-0.3940170705318451,
-0.42411261796951294,
0.35446983575820923,
-0.0017607512418180704,
-0.6890312433242798,
0.6513267159461975,
-0.07113587856292725,
-0.08877202868461609,
0.09697660803794861,
-0.09084457159042358,
0.24691729247570038,
-0.4937155842781067,
0.500323474407196,
0.3610972464084625,
0.004183338023722172,
-0.1467597335577011,
-0.187702015042305,
-0.5677346587181091,
0.05888698622584343,
-0.31329721212387085,
0.32932519912719727,
-0.33655574917793274,
-0.3970411419868469,
-0.3355937600135803,
0.5089297294616699,
0.300679087638855,
-0.28922030329704285,
0.3575499653816223,
0.652229905128479,
-0.4958339035511017,
-0.09007687121629715,
-0.7236712574958801,
0.007501503452658653,
-0.3705759048461914,
0.3117885887622833,
-0.5788975358009338,
-0.9046560525894165,
0.801341712474823,
0.09489542245864868,
0.2892155349254608,
0.21172872185707092,
0.6357395052909851,
0.12211280316114426,
0.8815875053405762,
0.3724541962146759,
0.03256544843316078,
0.3948829770088196,
-0.14285965263843536,
0.13829044997692108,
-1.1154909133911133,
-0.09233778715133667,
-0.9084383249282837,
-0.35571029782295227,
-0.3024674952030182,
-0.7153094410896301,
0.33909544348716736,
0.014666056260466576,
0.009918521158397198,
0.41152292490005493,
-0.24427345395088196,
0.3525691330432892,
0.5872584581375122,
0.12496091425418854,
0.5659810304641724,
-0.30992257595062256,
-0.14149110019207,
-0.13830715417861938,
-0.4302278161048889,
-0.5629525780677795,
0.815115213394165,
0.209734708070755,
0.8369250893592834,
-0.11116596311330795,
0.8414803743362427,
0.11798063665628433,
0.5292965769767761,
-0.697105884552002,
0.5392672419548035,
-0.03075779601931572,
-0.4073464274406433,
-0.1319492757320404,
-0.5130856037139893,
-0.8347231149673462,
0.1414262354373932,
-0.08311031013727188,
-1.0553159713745117,
0.49627649784088135,
0.34050384163856506,
-0.3019557297229767,
0.6239178776741028,
-0.3328118622303009,
0.6287115216255188,
-0.12566165626049042,
-0.24809414148330688,
-0.14210353791713715,
-0.6431284546852112,
0.009985552169382572,
-0.12380766868591309,
0.30909204483032227,
-0.18389655649662018,
-0.20760461688041687,
0.9759538769721985,
-0.4294882118701935,
0.9731313586235046,
-0.06634636223316193,
0.14851756393909454,
0.29463842511177063,
-0.180098757147789,
0.9295132756233215,
-0.16148200631141663,
-0.029618149623274803,
0.2820659875869751,
-0.17784123122692108,
-0.3533861041069031,
-0.544746458530426,
0.7576026916503906,
-0.8073063492774963,
-0.35897207260131836,
-0.4306929409503937,
-0.3155782222747803,
-0.008326241746544838,
0.006447820458561182,
0.39780813455581665,
0.7329745888710022,
-0.2714870572090149,
-0.16823254525661469,
0.24690456688404083,
0.04944927617907524,
0.5466152429580688,
0.3650960922241211,
-0.21111832559108734,
-0.6506054997444153,
0.6067944765090942,
0.40529435873031616,
-0.025494124740362167,
0.43815329670906067,
0.1355612576007843,
-0.4089537262916565,
-0.5991862416267395,
-0.4924235939979553,
0.4523681402206421,
-0.9359239339828491,
-0.24876870214939117,
-0.8980531096458435,
0.11329378932714462,
-0.28531819581985474,
-0.5005105137825012,
-0.07786907255649567,
-0.5238814949989319,
-0.21622565388679504,
-0.1584518998861313,
0.3551311194896698,
0.4967586398124695,
-0.29747474193573,
0.25615209341049194,
-0.822912871837616,
0.041819699108600616,
0.06675440073013306,
0.18349263072013855,
0.000016817790310597047,
-0.4762375056743622,
-0.37350451946258545,
-0.4272376000881195,
-0.24176637828350067,
-0.8028348684310913,
0.1254795789718628,
0.31043246388435364,
0.5552828907966614,
0.48599952459335327,
0.4075670838356018,
0.8238736391067505,
-0.5573813319206238,
0.512712836265564,
0.4980705976486206,
-1.1918885707855225,
0.3974553048610687,
-0.16544780135154724,
0.19444750249385834,
0.3230656683444977,
0.4254981279373169,
-0.8072550892829895,
-0.4470060467720032,
-0.6666180491447449,
-1.078249216079712,
0.6906246542930603,
0.2872331738471985,
-0.22328975796699524,
-0.20129793882369995,
0.4587474465370178,
-0.004069708287715912,
-0.20587483048439026,
-0.4913623034954071,
-0.4308190643787384,
0.0729372650384903,
0.031118744984269142,
-0.15686416625976562,
-0.21526511013507843,
-0.07801351696252823,
-0.014114017598330975,
0.7720385193824768,
-0.2345658242702484,
0.3086688816547394,
0.46473437547683716,
-0.2584797143936157,
-0.24103765189647675,
0.4664975106716156,
0.3268563449382782,
0.5250503420829773,
-0.1872783750295639,
0.5014277696609497,
0.18651241064071655,
-0.29691123962402344,
0.2293684482574463,
0.52631014585495,
-0.1676575094461441,
0.1680384874343872,
0.452763170003891,
0.7746039032936096,
0.4480665624141693,
-0.39814695715904236,
0.495333731174469,
-0.11341831833124161,
-0.066774383187294,
-0.28541016578674316,
-0.3107629418373108,
-0.05094466358423233,
0.3362168073654175,
0.5875784158706665,
0.004121460486203432,
0.060660671442747116,
-0.2732433080673218,
0.42413997650146484,
0.21400776505470276,
-0.3691244423389435,
-0.667008101940155,
0.5878931879997253,
0.7526464462280273,
0.009505078196525574,
0.44922277331352234,
-0.4905748963356018,
-0.7980697751045227,
0.2281738519668579,
0.34258097410202026,
0.8795188665390015,
-0.12163126468658447,
-0.06614861637353897,
0.6399254202842712,
0.37777912616729736,
0.2554001808166504,
0.03857983276247978,
-0.194527268409729,
-0.8542372584342957,
-0.6203860640525818,
-0.4350215792655945,
-0.8329535126686096,
-0.094300776720047,
-0.5297735333442688,
0.4285038411617279,
-0.5783635377883911,
-0.45197683572769165,
0.37521135807037354,
0.09730201214551926,
-0.7121409177780151,
-0.109446682035923,
0.6174687147140503,
0.7218857407569885,
-0.7734930515289307,
0.7852562069892883,
0.982244074344635,
-0.5895190834999084,
-0.40693289041519165,
-0.3105543851852417,
0.14965662360191345,
-0.4511992037296295,
0.5712686777114868,
0.2237602323293686,
-0.09166811406612396,
0.003655970562249422,
-0.13542138040065765,
-0.62375408411026,
1.0035555362701416,
0.0737098902463913,
-0.9575942754745483,
-0.33291134238243103,
-0.11635072529315948,
0.25211015343666077,
-0.35740533471107483,
0.5233874917030334,
0.40163737535476685,
0.5744033455848694,
0.10496870428323746,
-1.2522543668746948,
0.45912203192710876,
-0.3282775282859802,
-0.12054961919784546,
0.5417137145996094,
-0.42556601762771606,
0.6608736515045166,
-0.450382798910141,
-0.41783881187438965,
0.04707878455519676,
0.9082990884780884,
0.19117861986160278,
0.450284868478775,
0.6076154112815857,
0.48360100388526917,
0.8837271332740784,
-0.20076242089271545,
0.8616757988929749,
-0.3185950517654419,
0.47669166326522827,
1.2723586559295654,
-0.4560202956199646,
0.7106375694274902,
0.4819895625114441,
-0.2888076901435852,
0.33823302388191223,
0.3291645646095276,
0.07208514958620071,
-0.07790262997150421,
0.2668544352054596,
-0.5608281493186951,
-0.32619988918304443,
0.05189211666584015,
-0.23784016072750092,
-0.012637229636311531,
0.48425063490867615,
-0.360584557056427,
-0.6248970627784729,
0.1639813333749771,
0.3538361191749573,
-0.14377355575561523,
-0.410724937915802,
0.5437731146812439,
0.08640918135643005,
-0.2559821903705597,
0.2971894443035126,
0.06196478754281998,
0.9094640016555786,
-0.5388939380645752,
0.04522296041250229,
0.1194148063659668,
0.3526931703090668,
-0.2263633757829666,
-0.7459072470664978,
0.27177298069000244,
0.24362869560718536,
-0.26151517033576965,
-0.0398072823882103,
0.7755140662193298,
-0.3654058277606964,
-0.29827016592025757,
0.6552878022193909,
0.42222535610198975,
0.1392480581998825,
-0.27001073956489563,
-0.5797612071037292,
0.3391079008579254,
-0.07552608847618103,
-0.2110181599855423,
0.2872781455516815,
0.4271458685398102,
-0.36877721548080444,
0.5002931952476501,
0.5412107706069946,
0.019155094400048256,
0.1660027801990509,
0.08918917924165726,
1.0090582370758057,
-0.8639106750488281,
-0.5770530700683594,
-0.7000117301940918,
0.2550307810306549,
-0.19562792778015137,
-0.3424820303916931,
0.4906071126461029,
0.5182456374168396,
0.8106797933578491,
0.3608736991882324,
1.116071105003357,
-0.38118067383766174,
0.5643980503082275,
-0.1834949553012848,
0.23311969637870789,
-0.00440617511048913,
0.1245778501033783,
-0.419453501701355,
-0.6692585945129395,
-0.578473687171936,
0.45426812767982483,
-0.5960965752601624,
-0.04523348808288574,
0.7155835628509521,
0.7733933925628662,
-0.027998650446534157,
0.009619259275496006,
0.43564167618751526,
0.285305380821228,
0.5526880025863647,
0.5701290965080261,
0.8739358186721802,
-0.14158156514167786,
1.0103691816329956,
-0.53652024269104,
-0.6005343794822693,
-0.34467652440071106,
-1.0951977968215942,
-0.8992050290107727,
-0.7055642008781433,
-0.8804539442062378,
-0.45058542490005493,
0.15987564623355865,
1.3488141298294067,
0.704060971736908,
-0.8233962655067444,
-0.0870126411318779,
0.3065034747123718,
-0.23027771711349487,
-0.139164000749588,
-0.11547234654426575,
0.5166528820991516,
-0.38722503185272217,
-0.7592244148254395,
0.05131016671657562,
0.19074779748916626,
-0.11567117273807526,
-0.05685633420944214,
-0.1922067403793335,
-0.08811210840940475,
-0.14440585672855377,
0.6434939503669739,
0.41363343596458435,
-0.74922776222229,
-0.6097874045372009,
-0.33936628699302673,
-0.029120417311787605,
0.25514358282089233,
1.1832765340805054,
-0.650934100151062,
0.3133699297904968,
0.5160908699035645,
0.5189765691757202,
0.6765308380126953,
0.03988252952694893,
0.3142331838607788,
-0.8231337070465088,
-0.19462719559669495,
0.1473376303911209,
0.7240386605262756,
0.30547860264778137,
-0.35682764649391174,
0.3137013614177704,
0.42822349071502686,
-0.6721228957176208,
-0.4513615667819977,
0.05739624425768852,
-1.4245455265045166,
0.209939107298851,
0.9762081503868103,
-0.4760300815105438,
-0.29429543018341064,
-0.4885872006416321,
-0.5101737976074219,
0.2174501270055771,
-0.7337716221809387,
0.4725266098976135,
0.6674418449401855,
-0.6743109226226807,
-0.4883172810077667,
-0.006848318036645651,
0.11479036509990692,
-0.14748147130012512,
-0.6664918661117554,
0.3548086881637573,
0.6847372055053711,
0.23013319075107574,
0.5724708437919617,
0.7942219972610474,
-0.1776210069656372,
0.21414317190647125,
0.09330198168754578,
0.655203640460968,
-0.1920901983976364,
-0.02347961813211441,
-0.26391321420669556,
0.15073572099208832,
0.20769500732421875,
-0.052190277725458145
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16345v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16345v1
|
Enhanced Facet Generation with LLM Editing
| 2024-03-25T00:43:44 | 2024-03-25T00:43:44 |
Joosung Lee, Jinhong Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
In information retrieval, facet identification of a user query is an
important task. If a search service can recognize the facets of a user's query,
it has the potential to offer users a much broader range of search results.
Previous studies can enhance facet prediction by leveraging retrieved documents
and related queries obtained through a search engine. However, there are
challenges in extending it to other applications when a search engine operates
as part of the model. First, search engines are constantly updated. Therefore,
additional information may change during training and test, which may reduce
performance. The second challenge is that public search engines cannot search
for internal documents. Therefore, a separate search system needs to be built
to incorporate documents from private domains within the company. We propose
two strategies that focus on a framework that can predict facets by taking only
queries as input without a search engine. The first strategy is multi-task
learning to predict SERP. By leveraging SERP as a target instead of a source,
the proposed model deeply understands queries without relying on external
modules. The second strategy is to enhance the facets by combining Large
Language Model (LLM) and the small model. Overall performance improves when
small model and LLM are combined rather than facet generation individually.
|
[
-0.4799957871437073,
-0.5159010887145996,
0.7189350724220276,
0.25487521290779114,
-0.0407089926302433,
0.14653953909873962,
-0.11626166105270386,
-0.5754925608634949,
0.22789156436920166,
0.9216024279594421,
-0.9273691177368164,
-0.23257659375667572,
-0.4356235861778259,
0.009245532564818859,
-0.05822058767080307,
1.0206496715545654,
0.3331869840621948,
0.16565059125423431,
-0.3075847923755646,
-0.03681033104658127,
-0.4609445333480835,
-0.4800770878791809,
-0.8083213567733765,
-0.13984708487987518,
0.3409116864204407,
0.27352166175842285,
0.4733928442001343,
0.40424227714538574,
0.4624699652194977,
0.2780781388282776,
-0.08747410774230957,
0.4753803014755249,
-0.3468076288700104,
0.5300958156585693,
-0.3855454921722412,
-0.41433805227279663,
-0.4298456907272339,
-0.15005627274513245,
0.4756375253200531,
0.734290599822998,
-0.014912093058228493,
-0.20669806003570557,
0.24419468641281128,
0.8709052801132202,
-0.5685666799545288,
0.19135722517967224,
-0.9190648198127747,
-0.043440740555524826,
-0.43789517879486084,
-0.2540348172187805,
-0.3284413516521454,
-0.11011522263288498,
0.016112463548779488,
-0.4534825086593628,
0.31727442145347595,
0.05110640823841095,
0.5435003042221069,
0.11978904902935028,
-0.3380770683288574,
-0.11494263261556625,
-0.5673215389251709,
0.3935898244380951,
-0.47773584723472595,
0.4267115294933319,
0.44704657793045044,
0.4409765303134918,
-0.394345760345459,
-0.6682411432266235,
-0.4320906400680542,
-0.1099575012922287,
-0.08817774802446365,
0.30281972885131836,
0.04607264697551727,
0.024302981793880463,
0.29793044924736023,
0.29303285479545593,
-0.47255316376686096,
0.07534202933311462,
-0.22339880466461182,
-0.07365278154611588,
0.5352563261985779,
0.015392346307635307,
0.02385076694190502,
-0.47574272751808167,
-0.21205154061317444,
-0.05712344869971275,
-0.9036186933517456,
0.02278187684714794,
0.2553892433643341,
0.4248739778995514,
0.39226680994033813,
0.669507622718811,
-0.5121036171913147,
0.4408639669418335,
0.46104249358177185,
0.022547027096152306,
0.02538473531603813,
-0.009537510573863983,
-0.30062568187713623,
-0.16557615995407104,
0.47493842244148254,
0.23240907490253448,
-0.11149406433105469,
-0.2770507335662842,
-0.5179063677787781,
-0.2864982485771179,
0.32992205023765564,
-0.9541780352592468,
-0.24394071102142334,
0.14680619537830353,
-0.20193691551685333,
-0.45685693621635437,
0.168064683675766,
-0.8426134586334229,
-0.9282047748565674,
-0.3425397276878357,
0.5283156633377075,
-0.3974149823188782,
0.05572604015469551,
-0.2919348478317261,
-0.030131498351693153,
0.015907378867268562,
0.7074791193008423,
-0.7237849831581116,
0.3102351129055023,
0.6048154234886169,
0.7138159871101379,
-0.14362464845180511,
-0.2600184679031372,
-0.8545882105827332,
0.437263548374176,
-0.044295087456703186,
0.9909210205078125,
-0.5689833164215088,
-0.44765955209732056,
0.12634176015853882,
0.12089037895202637,
-0.07365364581346512,
-0.6126741766929626,
0.3633798658847809,
-0.9526402950286865,
0.35975381731987,
-0.4569789469242096,
-0.40388035774230957,
-0.1964217722415924,
0.06090471148490906,
-0.8717502355575562,
1.0793038606643677,
0.2334313541650772,
-0.7742213010787964,
0.3008803129196167,
-0.8154953122138977,
-0.6339051127433777,
0.39614880084991455,
-0.37292009592056274,
-0.5046482682228088,
0.42351341247558594,
0.6761389970779419,
0.6073917150497437,
-0.14465446770191193,
0.23216520249843597,
-0.19784483313560486,
0.04799874871969223,
0.0663580447435379,
0.09619317948818207,
0.5715482831001282,
-0.006032910197973251,
-0.3220806121826172,
0.12553159892559052,
-0.6139020919799805,
-0.06193755567073822,
0.10344371944665909,
-0.2777501940727234,
-0.31917381286621094,
0.12706243991851807,
0.09556058794260025,
0.24510546028614044,
0.4514562487602234,
-0.4056294560432434,
0.32685431838035583,
-0.5039020776748657,
0.07803487032651901,
0.997090756893158,
0.19119302928447723,
0.40466809272766113,
-0.4517284333705902,
0.6032344102859497,
-0.04378237575292587,
-0.03690064325928688,
-0.10136228799819946,
-0.7164605259895325,
-0.6014723181724548,
-0.2506486177444458,
0.1924043893814087,
0.5824167132377625,
-0.9018024802207947,
0.12508703768253326,
-0.3319784998893738,
-0.2862211763858795,
-0.4088415801525116,
0.2551535964012146,
0.12213846296072006,
0.41991961002349854,
0.3226592242717743,
-0.3810540735721588,
-0.6987543702125549,
-0.7714674472808838,
-0.5414764881134033,
0.1836061030626297,
-0.27368560433387756,
0.8210684061050415,
0.35086241364479065,
-0.20732314884662628,
0.9971013069152832,
-0.6299354434013367,
-0.5221836566925049,
-0.2666071951389313,
0.13796517252922058,
0.042305827140808105,
0.2929147183895111,
0.30904048681259155,
-1.0229648351669312,
-0.6867018342018127,
0.17887893319129944,
-0.565319299697876,
-0.3057788908481598,
-0.1230539008975029,
-0.13828006386756897,
0.029984990134835243,
0.2727096676826477,
-0.5787158608436584,
0.4444497525691986,
0.36373984813690186,
-0.029273126274347305,
0.5031864643096924,
-0.16050776839256287,
0.1973097026348114,
-1.0666764974594116,
-0.09825224429368973,
0.09270580857992172,
-0.3927987813949585,
-0.6001717448234558,
0.24295347929000854,
0.33895987272262573,
-0.5746945142745972,
-0.30329471826553345,
0.6099688410758972,
-0.5060981512069702,
-0.42499977350234985,
-0.5341577529907227,
0.14700168371200562,
0.01700085960328579,
0.4469568729400635,
0.132395401597023,
1.181915283203125,
0.3060249984264374,
-0.6098805069923401,
0.17884786427021027,
0.36264804005622864,
-0.17993725836277008,
0.6330215930938721,
-0.3872756361961365,
0.2732217609882355,
-0.09192559123039246,
0.3750954866409302,
-0.7605913281440735,
-0.5509230494499207,
-0.2384335845708847,
-0.34518101811408997,
0.33114802837371826,
-0.16263064742088318,
-0.6105555295944214,
-0.09493841230869293,
-0.5552523136138916,
-0.17701317369937897,
0.32661592960357666,
-0.7370380759239197,
0.7698870301246643,
0.38295498490333557,
-0.5299649834632874,
-0.1927686631679535,
-0.4818778932094574,
0.3367574214935303,
-0.08591991662979126,
-0.953827440738678,
0.7645546197891235,
-0.06318136304616928,
0.1003742590546608,
-0.13630257546901703,
-0.059000033885240555,
-0.03693127632141113,
0.10082276910543442,
0.4238072335720062,
0.16729119420051575,
-0.10990472137928009,
0.025711767375469208,
0.21017850935459137,
0.044547416269779205,
-0.2938694953918457,
-0.33714503049850464,
0.4441920518875122,
0.09469456225633621,
-0.30258074402809143,
-0.4161839485168457,
0.5427713394165039,
0.5915516018867493,
-0.5529422163963318,
0.7053321003913879,
0.482281893491745,
-0.5307168960571289,
-0.2966471314430237,
-0.8015972375869751,
-0.2126355767250061,
-0.5173686742782593,
0.1964661031961441,
-0.6196700930595398,
-0.8329177498817444,
0.5818153023719788,
-0.5458556413650513,
-0.284786581993103,
0.567980170249939,
0.5112605094909668,
-0.12031477689743042,
1.3289642333984375,
1.0881589651107788,
0.09555806964635849,
0.6242954134941101,
-0.15065030753612518,
0.08321882784366608,
-1.2598659992218018,
-0.2210160195827484,
-0.3292269706726074,
-0.21008680760860443,
-1.0693018436431885,
-0.3104499280452728,
0.5135228037834167,
0.05969223752617836,
0.05261347070336342,
0.4203003942966461,
-0.5382765531539917,
0.2646366357803345,
0.6308483481407166,
0.5791113376617432,
0.1995745450258255,
0.23085227608680725,
-0.15632390975952148,
-0.23912912607192993,
-0.324502557516098,
-0.21009880304336548,
1.106127142906189,
0.023846540600061417,
0.5674200057983398,
0.2569877505302429,
0.846120297908783,
0.2915630340576172,
0.24492043256759644,
-0.5458275675773621,
0.4052871763706207,
-0.4806312918663025,
-0.5482186675071716,
-0.1135467141866684,
-0.2846754491329193,
-0.6690239906311035,
0.3623930811882019,
-0.08651194721460342,
-0.8396998643875122,
0.3031575381755829,
-0.08059002459049225,
-0.37643319368362427,
-0.011824623681604862,
-0.49098148941993713,
0.5597636103630066,
-0.23299826681613922,
-0.5847291350364685,
-0.01989506185054779,
-0.3174871802330017,
0.1900813728570938,
-0.34790492057800293,
0.18953709304332733,
0.3072863817214966,
-0.07242708653211594,
0.6634626388549805,
-0.3149496614933014,
0.8513733148574829,
-0.2600706219673157,
0.2536180913448334,
-0.1188034936785698,
0.1678754985332489,
0.946252703666687,
0.08366574347019196,
-0.2173459380865097,
-0.3850841522216797,
-0.2572396397590637,
-0.2953220307826996,
-0.6675010323524475,
0.7490398287773132,
-0.608276903629303,
-0.8722679615020752,
-0.3229171633720398,
-0.44759461283683777,
-0.46869957447052,
0.37824440002441406,
0.15261736512184143,
0.021614816039800644,
-0.03217821195721626,
0.4159797132015228,
0.7803260684013367,
-0.22467365860939026,
0.1608707308769226,
0.4160022735595703,
-0.3521375358104706,
-0.407968133687973,
0.7140824794769287,
0.06103017181158066,
0.05276131629943848,
0.4403378367424011,
0.3756137192249298,
-0.1866416335105896,
-0.6796098351478577,
-0.23996926844120026,
0.15351277589797974,
-0.7115589380264282,
-0.2937908172607422,
-0.7204004526138306,
-0.3102553188800812,
-0.8382905125617981,
-0.1026579961180687,
-0.17296084761619568,
-0.3683014214038849,
-0.16445282101631165,
0.1705944985151291,
0.34081462025642395,
0.8149083256721497,
-0.10077347606420517,
0.6210724115371704,
-0.5400381088256836,
0.46322429180145264,
0.5703514814376831,
0.281024307012558,
-0.24228237569332123,
-0.4305887222290039,
-0.24882103502750397,
-0.05052536353468895,
-0.4642522633075714,
-1.1086450815200806,
0.5935689806938171,
0.3285229504108429,
0.5669931769371033,
0.13634607195854187,
-0.11315982788801193,
0.7257267236709595,
-0.6590700745582581,
0.7425824999809265,
-0.1720302850008011,
-0.826237678527832,
1.0149964094161987,
-0.483083575963974,
0.22431053221225739,
0.7148451805114746,
0.31723302602767944,
-0.5318633913993835,
-0.290823370218277,
-0.7086502313613892,
-0.8145111799240112,
0.8742294311523438,
0.29600438475608826,
-0.13721993565559387,
0.35231781005859375,
0.48770588636398315,
0.2720396816730499,
0.49096864461898804,
-0.6587151288986206,
0.2125435769557953,
-0.16362951695919037,
0.030963126569986343,
0.1943090409040451,
-0.1348949372768402,
0.07166633009910583,
-0.12485489994287491,
0.7407470941543579,
-0.2941935062408447,
0.23281903564929962,
0.11027061194181442,
-0.27789613604545593,
-0.15257081389427185,
-0.10275091975927353,
0.4822466969490051,
0.6979990601539612,
-0.4939013719558716,
-0.08829166740179062,
0.03901175037026405,
-0.5513878464698792,
-0.43366739153862,
0.14930106699466705,
-0.2324574738740921,
-0.0934792086482048,
0.05710380896925926,
0.7991203665733337,
0.08761292695999146,
-0.37225914001464844,
0.6664021611213684,
0.08239693194627762,
0.14792472124099731,
-0.3800065815448761,
-0.02000693790614605,
0.060112737119197845,
0.49449536204338074,
0.5690864324569702,
0.005970175378024578,
0.13422535359859467,
-0.45233893394470215,
0.4248355031013489,
0.47658979892730713,
-0.16016419231891632,
-0.15637098252773285,
0.7012916803359985,
0.20550402998924255,
-0.4039153456687927,
0.4049261510372162,
-0.24616843461990356,
-0.7683188915252686,
0.4845852255821228,
0.3934479057788849,
1.2170441150665283,
-0.5329349637031555,
-0.02243979088962078,
0.07002038508653641,
0.3014504313468933,
0.003983447328209877,
0.12435765564441681,
-0.08502040803432465,
-0.5098991990089417,
-0.4391708970069885,
-0.7637438178062439,
-0.501665472984314,
0.5885902643203735,
-0.4746392071247101,
0.30257245898246765,
-0.6731428503990173,
0.034219011664390564,
0.26629215478897095,
0.3633372187614441,
-0.9389024972915649,
0.3665054440498352,
0.08433850109577179,
0.5528098344802856,
-0.712812066078186,
0.8988046050071716,
0.7444742918014526,
-0.6192821860313416,
-0.2906777262687683,
0.20365585386753082,
0.08371442556381226,
-0.8543874025344849,
0.8761220574378967,
0.33597391843795776,
-0.08697471767663956,
-0.1136578842997551,
-0.4302038550376892,
-0.7380037307739258,
1.1991862058639526,
0.23445162177085876,
-0.3850727081298828,
-0.24470967054367065,
-0.02481386810541153,
0.2123233824968338,
-0.7582199573516846,
0.09827323257923126,
0.24247956275939941,
0.3888515532016754,
0.18361203372478485,
-0.8416410684585571,
0.2027946412563324,
0.0637153834104538,
0.32870885729789734,
-0.1044192761182785,
-0.35012611746788025,
1.027472734451294,
0.1865457147359848,
-0.18164950609207153,
-0.03386683017015457,
0.6475306749343872,
0.19784657657146454,
0.2583017945289612,
0.32125401496887207,
0.3598468005657196,
0.6489399671554565,
0.30543214082717896,
1.0730631351470947,
-0.23365986347198486,
0.2615293860435486,
1.2283549308776855,
-0.4818592369556427,
0.9542163014411926,
0.41901397705078125,
-0.17438092827796936,
0.17707723379135132,
0.7329285144805908,
-0.034276511520147324,
0.7960655689239502,
-0.14003288745880127,
-0.3322930932044983,
-0.2330237627029419,
0.00910466630011797,
-0.3447399437427521,
0.5043175220489502,
0.4400944709777832,
-0.3941804766654968,
-0.26094233989715576,
0.0924370214343071,
0.03784524276852608,
0.1445724219083786,
-0.08617693930864334,
0.9728233218193054,
-0.11339457333087921,
-0.5318242311477661,
0.15076391398906708,
0.27842241525650024,
0.7235792875289917,
-0.4429231286048889,
0.09656872600317001,
-0.352209210395813,
0.13649094104766846,
-0.2969299852848053,
-0.5223220586776733,
0.20487821102142334,
-0.09869272261857986,
-0.25305497646331787,
-0.41623231768608093,
1.052960991859436,
-0.2897348999977112,
-0.6125587224960327,
0.30494165420532227,
0.6874495148658752,
0.04093760997056961,
-0.7962470650672913,
-0.7696623206138611,
-0.16224858164787292,
0.21818169951438904,
-0.42268258333206177,
0.740359902381897,
0.5095381736755371,
-0.016307983547449112,
0.3927999436855316,
0.8006781935691833,
0.27964672446250916,
0.06414052098989487,
-0.01724116876721382,
1.0831613540649414,
-0.6516017317771912,
-0.632655680179596,
-0.4579980671405792,
0.4279302656650543,
-0.35318708419799805,
0.09662245959043503,
0.5637679100036621,
0.5075944066047668,
0.7304532527923584,
-0.08954056352376938,
1.078645944595337,
0.06974787265062332,
0.6964013576507568,
-0.601606011390686,
0.7484762668609619,
-0.7316962480545044,
0.3215595483779907,
-0.22309747338294983,
-1.0719010829925537,
-0.06970670819282532,
0.5712289214134216,
-0.3753127455711365,
0.20847901701927185,
0.7704913020133972,
0.9105647802352905,
-0.18470489978790283,
-0.03756454959511757,
0.39430394768714905,
-0.013627361506223679,
0.5083792209625244,
0.39222627878189087,
0.3939168453216553,
-0.3864644765853882,
0.1777171939611435,
-0.5780395269393921,
-0.4156920611858368,
-0.5478454828262329,
-0.8488849401473999,
-0.7599355578422546,
-0.6453903913497925,
-0.18218694627285004,
-0.15510666370391846,
0.20114333927631378,
0.4281903803348541,
0.6286875605583191,
-0.7143428325653076,
-0.14438065886497498,
-0.0228327177464962,
-0.06541290134191513,
-0.17052386701107025,
-0.22885343432426453,
0.462557852268219,
-0.43530330061912537,
-0.6026405096054077,
0.7010831236839294,
0.3394947052001953,
-0.1583612859249115,
-0.3338332176208496,
0.2133805900812149,
-0.3018513023853302,
0.1023871898651123,
0.8008406758308411,
0.13402938842773438,
-0.7244519591331482,
-0.25904595851898193,
0.06202610954642296,
0.061212990432977676,
0.14908981323242188,
0.8075177669525146,
-0.9403953552246094,
0.47651660442352295,
0.4666699767112732,
0.9394781589508057,
0.8809457421302795,
0.09783148020505905,
0.5511009097099304,
-0.9851188063621521,
0.028723156079649925,
0.2370898425579071,
0.06673773378133774,
0.6527765393257141,
-0.9119654893875122,
0.43691444396972656,
0.29451417922973633,
-0.374235063791275,
-0.6134530901908875,
0.4258652329444885,
-0.8286632895469666,
-0.34929323196411133,
0.9009257555007935,
0.05017895624041557,
-0.25229570269584656,
0.22849325835704803,
-0.11265210807323456,
0.1833791732788086,
-0.4738277494907379,
0.720355212688446,
0.5556670427322388,
-0.47745025157928467,
-0.22596223652362823,
-1.0356979370117188,
0.5209311246871948,
0.2008693963289261,
-0.8765122890472412,
-0.03500216454267502,
0.4081480801105499,
0.14491432905197144,
0.14989466965198517,
0.479424387216568,
-0.06980641186237335,
0.2844761610031128,
-0.2881929874420166,
-0.04617495462298393,
-0.08972325176000595,
-0.31603193283081055,
-0.3180437386035919,
0.34459438920021057,
0.09272076189517975,
-0.11563880741596222
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08655v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08655v1
|
Transformer-based Joint Modelling for Automatic Essay Scoring and Off-Topic Detection
| 2024-03-24T21:44:14 | 2024-03-24T21:44:14 |
Sourya Dipta Das, Yash Vadi, Kuldeep Yadav
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Automated Essay Scoring (AES) systems are widely popular in the market as
they constitute a cost-effective and time-effective option for grading systems.
Nevertheless, many studies have demonstrated that the AES system fails to
assign lower grades to irrelevant responses. Thus, detecting the off-topic
response in automated essay scoring is crucial in practical tasks where
candidates write unrelated text responses to the given task in the question. In
this paper, we are proposing an unsupervised technique that jointly scores
essays and detects off-topic essays. The proposed Automated Open Essay Scoring
(AOES) model uses a novel topic regularization module (TRM), which can be
attached on top of a transformer model, and is trained using a proposed hybrid
loss function. After training, the AOES model is further used to calculate the
Mahalanobis distance score for off-topic essay detection. Our proposed method
outperforms the baseline we created and earlier conventional methods on two
essay-scoring datasets in off-topic detection as well as on-topic scoring.
Experimental evaluation results on different adversarial strategies also show
how the suggested method is robust for detecting possible human-level
perturbations.
|
[
-0.5933167934417725,
-1.0298919677734375,
0.5650089383125305,
-0.11321753263473511,
-0.12538929283618927,
0.09358873963356018,
-0.15468177199363708,
-0.09773052483797073,
0.4394376575946808,
0.5905945897102356,
-0.3716425597667694,
-0.5935031175613403,
-0.6186094284057617,
-0.014746901579201221,
-0.5175065994262695,
1.0083650350570679,
-0.26809728145599365,
-0.17498937249183655,
-0.5917640328407288,
-0.20557670295238495,
-0.4617273807525635,
-0.0762367770075798,
-0.609732449054718,
-0.1606750190258026,
0.2952951192855835,
0.40565091371536255,
0.0846550241112709,
0.32245931029319763,
0.8328757882118225,
0.36516517400741577,
0.14284132421016693,
0.15140178799629211,
-0.15670493245124817,
0.15799768269062042,
-0.2914906144142151,
-0.7799248695373535,
-0.3044377863407135,
0.24520595371723175,
0.59324711561203,
0.5223138928413391,
0.08939673751592636,
0.27036723494529724,
0.06100762262940407,
0.37971195578575134,
-0.7037312984466553,
-0.015272513031959534,
-0.5779982209205627,
0.1659592241048813,
-0.22653795778751373,
-0.26231834292411804,
-0.6498178243637085,
-0.2099875658750534,
-0.07206977903842926,
-0.58590167760849,
0.27146676182746887,
0.23184330761432648,
0.8373346924781799,
0.3523958921432495,
-0.39349547028541565,
-0.14843057096004486,
-0.7196367979049683,
0.8953463435173035,
-0.1443127691745758,
-0.06340210139751434,
0.1872275322675705,
0.2716790735721588,
0.03796270489692688,
-0.4866219460964203,
-0.5102800726890564,
0.03067583590745926,
-0.3472868502140045,
0.4235132336616516,
-0.44979411363601685,
0.17117147147655487,
0.025616837665438652,
0.49532079696655273,
-0.7040867209434509,
0.025091618299484253,
-0.14897814393043518,
-0.1603614240884781,
0.5209038257598877,
0.3205984830856323,
0.21722613275051117,
-0.21017859876155853,
-0.30455121397972107,
0.005778325255960226,
-0.3085494041442871,
0.42831286787986755,
0.6402387619018555,
0.31973686814308167,
-0.02608085423707962,
0.5162929892539978,
0.18055441975593567,
0.6218948364257812,
0.43634527921676636,
0.08071447163820267,
-0.22627180814743042,
0.06243721395730972,
0.050441209226846695,
-0.10580147802829742,
0.8448532223701477,
0.3186480700969696,
-0.13233207166194916,
-0.40094831585884094,
-0.17488190531730652,
0.6841031312942505,
0.5541457533836365,
-0.4209911525249481,
-0.16652071475982666,
-0.1625252515077591,
-0.7839106917381287,
-0.5828419923782349,
0.38619813323020935,
-1.050981044769287,
-0.2598862946033478,
-0.15190261602401733,
0.9157602787017822,
-0.0796201303601265,
-0.018610890954732895,
-0.12458471208810806,
-0.06624807417392731,
-0.045096028596162796,
0.12279852479696274,
-0.40033477544784546,
0.6751452088356018,
0.23521044850349426,
0.7736772894859314,
-0.6182706952095032,
-0.17032501101493835,
-0.5903491973876953,
-0.11066301167011261,
-0.40188270807266235,
1.0987523794174194,
-0.7481067180633545,
-0.43333879113197327,
-0.08654467761516571,
0.07836640626192093,
-0.25113627314567566,
-0.29631292819976807,
0.9350967407226562,
-0.5988989472389221,
0.7593771815299988,
-0.034720130264759064,
-0.7371079325675964,
-0.1462707370519638,
0.4118014872074127,
-0.6236184239387512,
1.1781961917877197,
0.10440076887607574,
-1.0349578857421875,
0.1249416172504425,
-1.1369340419769287,
-0.3389997184276581,
-0.2535054087638855,
-0.051425106823444366,
-0.8978441953659058,
0.03570902347564697,
0.09661681205034256,
0.2820146977901459,
-0.4285344183444977,
0.3440886437892914,
-0.16177250444889069,
-0.7497564554214478,
-0.014011436142027378,
-0.4678969383239746,
0.31773385405540466,
-0.18630032241344452,
-0.44711607694625854,
0.27477410435676575,
-0.7370080947875977,
-0.08985323458909988,
0.050473134964704514,
-0.13195005059242249,
-0.6124037504196167,
-0.3148695230484009,
0.05061490461230278,
0.2726942002773285,
0.06991200149059296,
-0.8308039903640747,
0.10429218411445618,
-0.4095974564552307,
0.09502975642681122,
0.6106663942337036,
0.23960262537002563,
0.44012579321861267,
-0.6226279139518738,
0.6154907941818237,
0.09190019220113754,
0.02737768180668354,
-0.18464361131191254,
-0.8146176338195801,
-0.7958747148513794,
-0.2960880696773529,
0.38522088527679443,
0.5849992632865906,
-0.6765486598014832,
1.0180904865264893,
0.0722581073641777,
-0.49259570240974426,
-0.47705742716789246,
-0.43010076880455017,
0.36047112941741943,
0.5711443424224854,
0.6673563122749329,
-0.17150664329528809,
-0.436849981546402,
-0.5346778035163879,
-0.47984322905540466,
-0.23578934371471405,
-0.16407036781311035,
0.009579134173691273,
0.5320845246315002,
0.1743539422750473,
1.2846746444702148,
-1.0073809623718262,
-0.7710472345352173,
-0.08562316745519638,
0.7174064517021179,
-0.1925746202468872,
0.35545310378074646,
0.47751477360725403,
-0.9466842412948608,
-0.5899697542190552,
-0.39582526683807373,
-0.561472475528717,
-0.2615860104560852,
0.04877229779958725,
-0.03383549302816391,
0.09415038675069809,
0.5115727782249451,
-0.6431818604469299,
0.954180121421814,
0.11419839411973953,
-0.4587138593196869,
0.3275001347064972,
-0.23874391615390778,
0.6086584329605103,
-1.2346359491348267,
0.2012302726507187,
0.3711807429790497,
-0.031926143914461136,
-0.4815323054790497,
-0.07579458504915237,
-0.1401975005865097,
-0.23409318923950195,
-0.1345934122800827,
0.5138537883758545,
-0.004112302791327238,
0.06122405081987381,
-0.599083423614502,
-0.06690475344657898,
0.4629218578338623,
0.6503726840019226,
0.030792975798249245,
0.4895738959312439,
0.5306766033172607,
-0.2594766318798065,
0.3016386032104492,
0.2075684815645218,
-0.08085164427757263,
0.8019415140151978,
-0.4082893133163452,
0.08248762786388397,
-0.1357310265302658,
0.42071250081062317,
-1.2883341312408447,
0.07682689279317856,
0.20756395161151886,
-0.6025821566581726,
0.36319369077682495,
-0.06120412051677704,
-0.010378748178482056,
-0.30200618505477905,
-0.668397068977356,
0.21017669141292572,
0.4198785424232483,
-0.480219304561615,
0.8882871866226196,
0.4662850499153137,
0.055735379457473755,
-0.24128353595733643,
-0.45155075192451477,
-0.05561814084649086,
-0.5821367502212524,
-0.5266032218933105,
0.8794568181037903,
0.13290128111839294,
-0.251630961894989,
0.38159456849098206,
0.06340237706899643,
-0.2873041033744812,
-0.07288042455911636,
0.3619457185268402,
0.4235612750053406,
-0.29576364159584045,
0.09567569196224213,
0.22618678212165833,
-0.32134634256362915,
0.20452649891376495,
-0.5484928488731384,
0.10479129105806351,
0.11183394491672516,
-0.5146692991256714,
-0.42509588599205017,
0.7460564970970154,
0.7539046406745911,
-0.25400155782699585,
0.881344735622406,
0.7477421164512634,
-0.6586276292800903,
-0.24167823791503906,
-0.4882710874080658,
-0.3684515357017517,
-0.43102025985717773,
0.16692526638507843,
-0.17234009504318237,
-0.6968120336532593,
0.5172832608222961,
-0.1131679117679596,
-0.13661710917949677,
0.8562675714492798,
0.49759429693222046,
-0.1699371337890625,
0.8761926293373108,
0.7921579480171204,
-0.22128121554851532,
0.217247873544693,
-0.33189404010772705,
0.6759218573570251,
-0.4303757846355438,
-0.21190200746059418,
-0.8256374597549438,
-0.2537345886230469,
-0.6618471741676331,
-0.25754278898239136,
0.6370510458946228,
-0.14765489101409912,
0.25737932324409485,
0.15764209628105164,
-0.5563873648643494,
0.5398086905479431,
0.470888614654541,
0.04625055938959122,
0.27803489565849304,
-0.07386412471532822,
-0.29448023438453674,
-0.019382096827030182,
-0.3633493185043335,
-0.5122545957565308,
1.1066087484359741,
0.14733392000198364,
0.5425830483436584,
-0.1460549384355545,
0.4575108289718628,
0.867321252822876,
0.2863761782646179,
-0.5441867113113403,
0.5358139872550964,
-0.42036372423171997,
-0.471114844083786,
-0.5904703140258789,
-0.5021705031394958,
-0.5841609239578247,
0.06858838349580765,
-0.19254076480865479,
-0.7558674216270447,
-0.11467140913009644,
-0.14014644920825958,
-0.550069272518158,
0.7659782767295837,
-0.39380672574043274,
0.8632664084434509,
0.2772902250289917,
-0.5315535068511963,
-0.07340126484632492,
-0.5235954523086548,
0.1203337013721466,
-0.29879656434059143,
0.0650847852230072,
0.2392239272594452,
0.18755143880844116,
1.2418184280395508,
-0.20249561965465546,
0.6838372945785522,
-0.34646475315093994,
0.02720732055604458,
0.5827745199203491,
-0.19456271827220917,
0.38050591945648193,
0.06695402413606644,
-0.010985393077135086,
0.1842176914215088,
-0.28150665760040283,
-0.12031839787960052,
-0.7686505317687988,
0.8378469944000244,
-0.7143200039863586,
-0.5258849859237671,
-0.528771698474884,
-0.43679940700531006,
-0.15706589818000793,
0.052167993038892746,
0.5720580816268921,
0.32696524262428284,
-0.23282165825366974,
-0.052105680108070374,
0.6797857880592346,
-0.13695208728313446,
0.4963248670101166,
0.7809136509895325,
0.1900184005498886,
-0.18065698444843292,
0.9908322095870972,
0.048479367047548294,
-0.4585355818271637,
0.7004618644714355,
0.3432721495628357,
-0.576296865940094,
-0.23691801726818085,
-0.43927884101867676,
-0.04480385780334473,
-0.625225841999054,
-0.3720971345901489,
-0.8012548685073853,
-0.06977931410074234,
-0.4172992408275604,
-0.4032800495624542,
-0.33008646965026855,
-0.3919556140899658,
-0.3335826098918915,
-0.01271857600659132,
0.2482975870370865,
0.5598371028900146,
-0.04019938409328461,
0.07040520012378693,
-0.6640207171440125,
0.42073512077331543,
0.0857965424656868,
0.5068929195404053,
-0.11441489309072495,
-0.9332067370414734,
-0.026203975081443787,
-0.3084666132926941,
-0.7698337435722351,
-0.5448106527328491,
0.096688412129879,
0.02605779469013214,
0.3687951862812042,
0.6147335767745972,
0.43952181935310364,
0.3073268532752991,
-0.19472424685955048,
0.665206253528595,
-0.04828847944736481,
-1.0336112976074219,
0.5838022232055664,
-0.22971214354038239,
-0.040067192167043686,
0.5510883331298828,
0.6765138506889343,
-0.3263188600540161,
-0.5112369060516357,
-0.37747591733932495,
-0.5677063465118408,
0.9965371489524841,
0.35738635063171387,
-0.05100015550851822,
0.18627670407295227,
0.3403988480567932,
0.2714015543460846,
-0.039197590202093124,
-0.7194103002548218,
-0.29579058289527893,
-0.07019786536693573,
-0.45372721552848816,
0.15383265912532806,
0.1786164492368698,
0.17294560372829437,
-0.20257018506526947,
0.9119463562965393,
-0.018048347905278206,
0.4149819314479828,
-0.0719083771109581,
0.2244289368391037,
-0.6840071082115173,
0.1777159571647644,
0.33869969844818115,
-0.03266281262040138,
-0.2678324580192566,
-0.06136997044086456,
0.179976224899292,
-0.5091183185577393,
0.6109420657157898,
0.2921425998210907,
-0.274942547082901,
0.047894153743982315,
0.443355917930603,
0.4400152266025543,
-0.04809429496526718,
-0.41501036286354065,
0.7595541477203369,
-0.4092620611190796,
-0.11792246252298355,
-0.3106118440628052,
-0.03387638181447983,
-0.29863595962524414,
-0.16234004497528076,
0.27456897497177124,
0.5506170988082886,
0.17523068189620972,
-0.31306174397468567,
0.44126322865486145,
0.24619530141353607,
-0.6643233299255371,
-0.3620498776435852,
0.6126373410224915,
0.24334675073623657,
-0.37092697620391846,
0.17452359199523926,
-0.4383067786693573,
-0.6544498205184937,
0.7487213015556335,
0.3530691862106323,
0.8993558287620544,
-0.5535670518875122,
0.18907999992370605,
0.15339985489845276,
0.17330196499824524,
-0.0747804269194603,
0.0963081493973732,
0.06400121003389359,
-0.38630780577659607,
-0.17118822038173676,
-0.7658106684684753,
-0.46038392186164856,
0.3251568675041199,
-0.8162582516670227,
0.7380902171134949,
-0.03246450424194336,
-0.11798708140850067,
0.0709662213921547,
0.11857225000858307,
-0.11542137712240219,
0.593084990978241,
-0.14989574253559113,
0.5032256245613098,
-1.3427016735076904,
0.5754294395446777,
1.010210633277893,
-0.17635928094387054,
-0.43109437823295593,
0.5115069150924683,
-0.039652176201343536,
-0.00801737979054451,
0.3096289038658142,
0.3962668478488922,
-0.28884759545326233,
-0.017659394070506096,
0.39192792773246765,
-0.6697496771812439,
0.7668110728263855,
0.03418832644820213,
-0.18920883536338806,
-0.18723495304584503,
0.4567617177963257,
0.5808156728744507,
-0.23697489500045776,
0.7989480495452881,
0.298124223947525,
0.5242392420768738,
-0.140357106924057,
-0.5524331331253052,
-0.1515101194381714,
-0.2061622142791748,
-0.4517614245414734,
0.7579322457313538,
-0.7113555073738098,
0.8817318081855774,
0.2741253674030304,
0.06251631677150726,
-0.02900637872517109,
0.366041362285614,
-0.35127827525138855,
0.852203369140625,
0.6794924736022949,
0.8224030137062073,
0.35251349210739136,
-0.2248658984899521,
0.5684283375740051,
-0.3620765209197998,
0.49796950817108154,
0.47645002603530884,
-0.4820905923843384,
0.4883013069629669,
0.17265324294567108,
-0.1970372200012207,
0.4144918918609619,
0.32784149050712585,
-0.10884194821119308,
0.6870991587638855,
0.2508286237716675,
-0.2626730501651764,
-0.2668546140193939,
-0.33202600479125977,
-0.08424699306488037,
1.0212379693984985,
0.2542557120323181,
-0.3231707215309143,
-0.3929218649864197,
0.39801719784736633,
-0.27391576766967773,
0.5435666441917419,
-0.2161344587802887,
0.6033732295036316,
-0.09588846564292908,
-1.1615535020828247,
0.1116165816783905,
0.7465133666992188,
0.7418878674507141,
-0.5081833004951477,
-0.14882692694664001,
-0.19507232308387756,
0.38182908296585083,
-0.060496751219034195,
-0.44785913825035095,
0.7422518134117126,
0.27386459708213806,
-0.4845516085624695,
-0.007931417785584927,
1.0542272329330444,
-0.3220711350440979,
-0.6763442158699036,
0.45939433574676514,
0.34947067499160767,
-0.28246399760246277,
-0.08270694315433502,
-0.445211797952652,
-0.16701386868953705,
-0.40273886919021606,
-0.2383173406124115,
0.348098486661911,
0.36421650648117065,
-0.4007202982902527,
0.2556053400039673,
0.38047170639038086,
-0.3567012846469879,
-0.5021394491195679,
-0.1526738554239273,
0.8351856470108032,
-0.3083529770374298,
-0.9916544556617737,
-0.8423610329627991,
0.17840628325939178,
-0.023822437971830368,
-0.31135591864585876,
0.7029061913490295,
0.5522467494010925,
0.6499451398849487,
0.04094316065311432,
0.7442103624343872,
0.17334137856960297,
0.8394706845283508,
-0.40126490592956543,
0.8346050381660461,
-0.6475281715393066,
0.19688528776168823,
-0.671630322933197,
-0.8714090585708618,
-0.3527872860431671,
0.4044190049171448,
-0.5279053449630737,
0.07410208135843277,
0.8886797428131104,
0.8242011666297913,
-0.26243817806243896,
0.43715548515319824,
0.48579278588294983,
-0.27644267678260803,
0.14062583446502686,
0.48715683817863464,
1.0296742916107178,
-0.5648375153541565,
0.7396876215934753,
-0.24664482474327087,
-0.35900747776031494,
-0.13269254565238953,
-0.6041674613952637,
-1.3470284938812256,
-0.6524979472160339,
-0.6105364561080933,
0.08284022659063339,
0.04358133301138878,
0.6552015542984009,
0.4414796233177185,
-0.9511405825614929,
0.15557853877544403,
-0.17395056784152985,
-0.14062020182609558,
-0.021682381629943848,
-0.34271156787872314,
0.6648316979408264,
0.10769041627645493,
-0.41768938302993774,
0.3025674521923065,
0.6073447465896606,
-0.2291915863752365,
-0.4023483991622925,
0.2401418685913086,
-0.27932852506637573,
0.45461955666542053,
0.1052386462688446,
-0.22090600430965424,
-0.5301589965820312,
-0.22094598412513733,
0.11010900884866714,
0.12964917719364166,
-0.015611537732183933,
1.056039571762085,
-0.7757683992385864,
-0.01808529905974865,
0.36437633633613586,
0.5284010767936707,
0.1034805029630661,
0.159939244389534,
0.04948921501636505,
-0.8103432655334473,
0.012228022329509258,
0.32603588700294495,
0.3274126648902893,
0.2760915756225586,
-0.6907147765159607,
0.04095768928527832,
0.6064532399177551,
-0.520877480506897,
-0.6711500287055969,
-0.15358470380306244,
-0.38682740926742554,
-0.3712305426597595,
0.41032612323760986,
-0.6288817524909973,
-0.03520219027996063,
-0.4582238495349884,
-0.10147376358509064,
0.4716026186943054,
-0.26943108439445496,
1.4302797317504883,
0.5286114811897278,
-0.0777478888630867,
0.3081453740596771,
0.1581384390592575,
0.22610421478748322,
0.565949559211731,
-1.161831259727478,
-0.33298149704933167,
-0.0710543543100357,
-0.08886177092790604,
0.5876370668411255,
0.32577353715896606,
0.08545306324958801,
0.42968788743019104,
-0.046149417757987976,
-0.1510840803384781,
-0.02946893870830536,
-0.621870756149292,
-0.2374446988105774,
0.7201338410377502,
-0.4675140976905823,
-0.4934651255607605
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16303v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16303v3
|
Large Language Models in Biomedical and Health Informatics: A Bibliometric Review
| 2024-03-24T21:29:39 | 2024-04-23T23:13:24 |
Huizi Yu, Lizhou Fan, Lingyao Li, Jiayan Zhou, Zihui Ma, Lu Xian, Wenyue Hua, Sijia He, Mingyu Jin, Yongfeng Zhang, Ashvin Gandhi, Xin Ma
|
cs.DL
|
cs.DL, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have rapidly become important tools in
Biomedical and Health Informatics (BHI), enabling new ways to analyze data,
treat patients, and conduct research. This bibliometric review aims to provide
a panoramic view of how LLMs have been used in BHI by examining research
articles and collaboration networks from 2022 to 2023. It further explores how
LLMs can improve Natural Language Processing (NLP) applications in various BHI
areas like medical diagnosis, patient engagement, electronic health record
management, and personalized medicine. To do this, our bibliometric review
identifies key trends, maps out research networks, and highlights major
developments in this fast-moving field. Lastly, it discusses the ethical
concerns and practical challenges of using LLMs in BHI, such as data privacy
and reliable medical recommendations. Looking ahead, we consider how LLMs could
further transform biomedical research as well as healthcare delivery and
patient outcomes. This bibliometric review serves as a resource for
stakeholders in healthcare, including researchers, clinicians, and
policymakers, to understand the current state and future potential of LLMs in
BHI.
|
[
-0.07583317160606384,
-0.6227309703826904,
0.6600654125213623,
0.23275893926620483,
-0.0953437015414238,
0.14952562749385834,
-0.359729528427124,
-1.0848231315612793,
0.18970878422260284,
0.7157725095748901,
-0.253591388463974,
-0.37775498628616333,
-0.7261055707931519,
0.30212077498435974,
-0.5056667923927307,
0.8823773860931396,
0.1546299010515213,
0.4972690939903259,
-0.3765738308429718,
-0.06377357244491577,
-0.20570962131023407,
-0.6000118851661682,
-0.43733373284339905,
-0.7689746022224426,
0.957451581954956,
0.039834413677453995,
0.9892263412475586,
0.6002286076545715,
0.9102048873901367,
0.22990773618221283,
-0.4853495955467224,
0.0029998780228197575,
-0.5105071663856506,
0.30433568358421326,
-0.23525379598140717,
-0.30333369970321655,
-0.5408127903938293,
-0.30822569131851196,
0.6877814531326294,
1.3362265825271606,
-0.011672754772007465,
0.2344106137752533,
-0.1121782660484314,
0.8916223049163818,
-0.15223529934883118,
0.16727615892887115,
-0.16147756576538086,
0.09726760536432266,
-0.39465582370758057,
-0.2567979395389557,
-0.34619489312171936,
-0.37129634618759155,
0.3307722806930542,
-0.06604772806167603,
-0.2785884439945221,
0.34121015667915344,
0.5221779942512512,
0.14335612952709198,
-0.5429968237876892,
-0.32268503308296204,
-1.0181632041931152,
0.8177023530006409,
-0.8432028293609619,
0.7971196174621582,
0.28111305832862854,
0.2135343849658966,
-0.4381871223449707,
-0.9208980202674866,
-0.2965858280658722,
-0.1469220370054245,
0.04964638501405716,
-0.05624935403466225,
-0.36873602867126465,
0.12807750701904297,
0.16605480015277863,
0.4494747519493103,
-0.6936511993408203,
0.5095574259757996,
-0.6106617450714111,
0.016150174662470818,
0.7743625044822693,
0.4306180477142334,
0.3440631330013275,
-0.2533080279827118,
-0.07943370938301086,
0.25310951471328735,
-1.0705242156982422,
-0.2703826129436493,
-0.054943740367889404,
0.17818233370780945,
-0.024050302803516388,
0.7189557552337646,
-0.1288076937198639,
0.7009339928627014,
-0.4287461042404175,
-0.3746820390224457,
0.48900076746940613,
-0.506752610206604,
-0.524075448513031,
0.1021612137556076,
0.9309353828430176,
0.38032102584838867,
-0.015174382366240025,
-0.2808021008968353,
0.19213974475860596,
-0.24165482819080353,
0.19025972485542297,
-0.9470193386077881,
0.007723547052592039,
0.7042949795722961,
-0.9317346215248108,
0.002504653763025999,
-0.1753440946340561,
-0.7208217978477478,
-0.6195103526115417,
-0.4217965006828308,
-0.23781555891036987,
-0.469294011592865,
-0.19206230342388153,
0.37994644045829773,
0.1529799848794937,
0.07725837826728821,
0.2358604222536087,
-0.6744070053100586,
0.2278928905725479,
0.9056895971298218,
0.978843629360199,
-0.02324446104466915,
-0.26034823060035706,
-0.09498530626296997,
0.3534674644470215,
-0.4600904881954193,
0.539290726184845,
-0.30482789874076843,
-0.611836314201355,
0.35158446431159973,
0.12394274771213531,
0.17403988540172577,
-0.5539386868476868,
0.20981140434741974,
-0.45144057273864746,
-0.0751219391822815,
-0.5082900524139404,
-0.560878336429596,
-0.1421113759279251,
0.2828078866004944,
-0.8611077070236206,
0.3679690957069397,
-0.2386651188135147,
-0.9113982915878296,
0.14478550851345062,
-0.6706730127334595,
-0.5921977162361145,
0.4412933886051178,
0.04423564299941063,
-0.43988925218582153,
0.021664869040250778,
-0.16130410134792328,
0.6346277594566345,
-0.781646192073822,
0.44224974513053894,
-0.4717417061328888,
-0.23488782346248627,
0.4424463212490082,
-0.03056737780570984,
1.0449800491333008,
0.25568148493766785,
0.06682351976633072,
0.342357873916626,
-0.6645234227180481,
-0.1607682853937149,
-0.052703484892845154,
-0.19193708896636963,
-0.36572811007499695,
0.38126546144485474,
0.297372430562973,
0.02175898104906082,
0.4051205515861511,
-0.5335535407066345,
-0.047747641801834106,
-0.7436195015907288,
0.5951817631721497,
0.27872544527053833,
0.14082832634449005,
0.35160523653030396,
-0.29914143681526184,
0.33784401416778564,
-0.20277366042137146,
0.5401476621627808,
-0.030717013403773308,
-0.6425912380218506,
-0.10966822504997253,
-0.24082861840724945,
0.38237422704696655,
0.47389206290245056,
-0.3708440065383911,
0.5162510871887207,
-0.23544389009475708,
-0.6870802044868469,
-0.5810571312904358,
0.02817402221262455,
0.09447407722473145,
0.3762897253036499,
0.2853452265262604,
-0.16736629605293274,
-0.5707817673683167,
-0.8720400333404541,
-0.04020776227116585,
-0.30605679750442505,
0.03805120289325714,
0.1839650720357895,
0.48760566115379333,
-0.9326593279838562,
0.6009235382080078,
-0.021907148882746696,
-0.13827483355998993,
-0.38748934864997864,
-0.08439682424068451,
0.1724768728017807,
0.11300715059041977,
0.23139339685440063,
-0.827731728553772,
-0.2590310573577881,
0.3505624830722809,
-0.9578433036804199,
-0.0873369425535202,
0.3641226887702942,
0.03878122568130493,
0.054962433874607086,
0.3581467866897583,
-0.5721089243888855,
0.22840356826782227,
0.7342650890350342,
-0.320896178483963,
0.3877260088920593,
-0.12481754273176193,
-0.06098253279924393,
-1.0243897438049316,
0.3705919682979584,
0.04809824004769325,
-0.23016302287578583,
-0.5683726072311401,
-0.008882090449333191,
-0.07589808851480484,
0.004443306475877762,
-0.04872560873627663,
0.6180113554000854,
-0.5617555379867554,
-0.12465458363294601,
-0.4253745377063751,
-0.3032042682170868,
-0.12798136472702026,
-0.5508912205696106,
-0.16064171493053436,
0.23382315039634705,
0.5572839975357056,
-0.3594350516796112,
0.5535874962806702,
0.5454629063606262,
-0.5170300006866455,
0.4771054685115814,
-0.8425167202949524,
-0.10616136342287064,
-0.1698649674654007,
0.4020649492740631,
-0.5622768402099609,
-0.34503597021102905,
0.04779182747006416,
-0.3064972758293152,
0.227313831448555,
0.13398601114749908,
-1.0116243362426758,
-0.5866836309432983,
-0.2529177665710449,
0.14898671209812164,
0.3535516560077667,
-0.29100915789604187,
0.2892393171787262,
0.7448826432228088,
-0.4437360465526581,
-0.36600828170776367,
-0.9699654579162598,
0.4353528618812561,
0.09048794209957123,
-0.4686037302017212,
0.33311888575553894,
-0.1611848920583725,
-0.6401583552360535,
0.1391250491142273,
0.2888292372226715,
0.009098636917769909,
0.06408382952213287,
0.3633354604244232,
0.47834402322769165,
-0.04615894705057144,
0.36189788579940796,
-0.08510305732488632,
0.1278594732284546,
0.26437023282051086,
-0.05774877220392227,
0.5416938662528992,
0.06374165415763855,
-0.15667685866355896,
-0.3189482092857361,
0.668846845626831,
0.5538903474807739,
-0.33843427896499634,
0.8561708927154541,
0.4941374361515045,
-0.4956907629966736,
0.33161216974258423,
-0.5095089077949524,
-0.13709372282028198,
-0.3012683391571045,
0.6666511297225952,
0.3865354359149933,
-1.1678863763809204,
0.37729158997535706,
-0.19028812646865845,
0.2008999139070511,
0.08970201015472412,
1.094475507736206,
-0.05997354909777641,
0.8334340453147888,
0.7723047137260437,
-0.22406913340091705,
0.2125578075647354,
0.04526806250214577,
0.5527703762054443,
-0.9221310019493103,
-0.607076108455658,
-0.5599740743637085,
-0.17101749777793884,
-0.923780620098114,
-0.272359699010849,
0.5728246569633484,
-0.3111244738101959,
-0.22612321376800537,
-0.2209862768650055,
-0.2081173211336136,
0.060347188264131546,
0.2157808542251587,
0.041971947997808456,
0.41890037059783936,
-0.19412176311016083,
0.16532078385353088,
0.02099742740392685,
-0.570774495601654,
-0.5312882661819458,
1.1296477317810059,
0.6883295178413391,
0.7968904972076416,
0.13864897191524506,
0.5944506525993347,
0.02689116634428501,
0.4386686384677887,
-0.8502156734466553,
0.37549930810928345,
-0.17852945625782013,
-0.8551227450370789,
-0.43954816460609436,
-0.5022788643836975,
-1.2942414283752441,
-0.03921383246779442,
-0.2684966027736664,
-0.7964974641799927,
0.09178769588470459,
-0.0755242332816124,
-0.17350374162197113,
0.3754359483718872,
-0.3039126992225647,
0.5735451579093933,
-0.4207352101802826,
-0.5071080327033997,
-0.2842896282672882,
-0.9437904357910156,
0.30798831582069397,
-0.05537709221243858,
0.37236830592155457,
-0.12367036193609238,
-0.055921755731105804,
0.652364194393158,
-0.14890755712985992,
0.6840983033180237,
0.2361786663532257,
-0.04576924070715904,
-0.08932572603225708,
-0.028864094987511635,
0.08469359576702118,
0.0017314143478870392,
-0.30157965421676636,
0.5732011198997498,
0.37249985337257385,
-0.25768133997917175,
-0.1626501977443695,
0.8030930757522583,
-0.5233927369117737,
-0.4256226420402527,
-0.5868629813194275,
-0.6789893507957458,
-0.4993967115879059,
0.37919485569000244,
0.01648227870464325,
0.37238839268684387,
-0.29844406247138977,
0.44700103998184204,
0.7888439297676086,
-0.36213746666908264,
0.27418196201324463,
0.3801861107349396,
-0.4414359927177429,
-0.24484652280807495,
0.6552125215530396,
0.23820433020591736,
-0.05239398032426834,
0.38214972615242004,
0.34426048398017883,
-0.31958335638046265,
-0.9225926399230957,
-0.17169500887393951,
0.7162983417510986,
-0.5338395237922668,
-0.1635458916425705,
-0.6288306713104248,
-0.29831433296203613,
-0.46764346957206726,
0.10962887853384018,
-0.15290005505084991,
0.17296946048736572,
-0.25115057826042175,
-0.02377539686858654,
0.42094677686691284,
1.1497421264648438,
-0.007354511879384518,
0.11283312737941742,
-0.8581673502922058,
0.132757768034935,
-0.05611897632479668,
0.5404313802719116,
0.04130208492279053,
-0.1228988766670227,
-0.4973399341106415,
-0.30512726306915283,
0.09970897436141968,
-0.9987367987632751,
0.5171276330947876,
-0.17196080088615417,
0.45544132590293884,
0.14160889387130737,
-0.39445051550865173,
0.31804338097572327,
-0.9012439846992493,
0.7414351105690002,
0.4299476146697998,
-0.5601076483726501,
0.2546372711658478,
-0.3535139858722687,
0.33392342925071716,
0.40554550290107727,
0.7582619190216064,
-0.8572475910186768,
0.07915827631950378,
-0.3142652213573456,
-0.985487699508667,
0.19838033616542816,
-0.21246400475502014,
-0.010122875683009624,
0.07324230670928955,
0.12957395613193512,
0.06901391595602036,
0.3657681941986084,
-0.493217796087265,
-0.23170681297779083,
0.18405106663703918,
-0.3267905116081238,
-0.05447080358862877,
-0.5380476713180542,
-0.2971995770931244,
-0.0960954800248146,
0.5480419397354126,
0.015708154067397118,
0.32582420110702515,
0.1778312474489212,
0.20728735625743866,
-0.3091360926628113,
0.4539347290992737,
0.0974637046456337,
0.836317777633667,
-0.21422071754932404,
-0.04979320615530014,
-0.16280502080917358,
-0.2967856824398041,
-0.2031146138906479,
0.2811238467693329,
-0.1957143396139145,
0.053048040717840195,
0.5164714455604553,
0.5812315344810486,
0.31117376685142517,
-0.87758469581604,
0.37266966700553894,
0.21687066555023193,
-0.11343956738710403,
-0.24103416502475739,
-0.33105921745300293,
0.41039255261421204,
0.4431895613670349,
0.059987232089042664,
-0.29038670659065247,
0.4642418324947357,
-0.6863493323326111,
-0.1867147833108902,
0.5649486780166626,
-0.2261844426393509,
-0.31713801622390747,
0.4171416163444519,
0.14066997170448303,
-0.3413284718990326,
0.2283940464258194,
0.23609685897827148,
-0.047207560390233994,
0.13248960673809052,
0.4743289649486542,
0.3787849247455597,
-0.2919488847255707,
0.060691576451063156,
0.08268706500530243,
0.35133934020996094,
-0.4339037239551544,
0.23707081377506256,
0.42848172783851624,
-0.5034269094467163,
-0.763629138469696,
-0.6378520727157593,
-0.8211095333099365,
0.3899495005607605,
-0.42780593037605286,
0.16330407559871674,
-0.451309472322464,
-0.2103724330663681,
0.33921754360198975,
0.12951429188251495,
-0.5884124636650085,
0.21576403081417084,
0.3742589056491852,
0.7469310164451599,
-0.490206778049469,
0.8679624199867249,
0.7664477229118347,
-0.24894438683986664,
-0.48697996139526367,
-0.07636937499046326,
0.12570664286613464,
-0.40458768606185913,
0.4872283637523651,
-0.16448722779750824,
0.07231874018907547,
-0.3572905957698822,
-0.7091679573059082,
-0.8481375575065613,
1.0104455947875977,
0.313606858253479,
-0.9496455192565918,
-0.3104088306427002,
0.10975885391235352,
0.8569911122322083,
-0.1861778050661087,
0.04948129877448082,
0.4533975124359131,
0.5732859373092651,
-0.09442545473575592,
-1.125342845916748,
-0.08855383098125458,
-0.1454901397228241,
0.10512068122625351,
0.0527513287961483,
-0.7696397304534912,
0.7565362453460693,
-0.006148903165012598,
0.21068571507930756,
0.23522667586803436,
0.4973701536655426,
0.2861817479133606,
0.5715819001197815,
0.02371925860643387,
0.2797221839427948,
0.9299866557121277,
0.2080528438091278,
1.3447620868682861,
-0.20908445119857788,
0.19196881353855133,
0.6703565716743469,
-1.0165873765945435,
0.7784844040870667,
0.601959228515625,
-0.3836299777030945,
0.5008721947669983,
0.5468252301216125,
0.002969356719404459,
0.04108568653464317,
0.2072972059249878,
-0.16573776304721832,
-0.09089762717485428,
-0.3155711889266968,
-0.46855077147483826,
0.33052000403404236,
0.6419454216957092,
-0.5042287111282349,
0.12279557436704636,
0.20412205159664154,
0.2218494564294815,
0.18336549401283264,
-0.3799563944339752,
0.5893528461456299,
0.2813255786895752,
-0.24298687279224396,
0.2242315411567688,
0.12247855961322784,
0.4694063365459442,
-0.7330594062805176,
0.07953046262264252,
0.15195143222808838,
-0.05049514025449753,
-0.3823696970939636,
-0.7571955919265747,
0.42416274547576904,
0.03502817824482918,
-0.38978317379951477,
-0.11258091777563095,
0.8788759112358093,
-0.25436264276504517,
-0.5897853970527649,
0.6580878496170044,
0.6093204021453857,
0.09204213321208954,
0.3544714152812958,
-0.6311724185943604,
0.47162777185440063,
-0.11219395697116852,
-0.35937923192977905,
0.4762072265148163,
0.3552490174770355,
-0.07323702424764633,
0.738736629486084,
0.7730367183685303,
0.661857008934021,
-0.1965235471725464,
0.11113302409648895,
0.6266869306564331,
-0.8822183609008789,
-0.19044680893421173,
-0.8761374950408936,
0.02643876150250435,
-0.15466025471687317,
-0.0672682672739029,
0.6384971141815186,
0.46089231967926025,
0.43197739124298096,
0.22400066256523132,
1.0115447044372559,
0.030505346134305,
0.9395767450332642,
-0.44584396481513977,
0.8221931457519531,
-0.5373910069465637,
0.12526534497737885,
-0.0981716513633728,
-0.5303810238838196,
-0.7271647453308105,
0.49066829681396484,
-0.47916048765182495,
0.025979984551668167,
0.767310619354248,
0.511681079864502,
0.24135249853134155,
0.21510349214076996,
0.46620815992355347,
0.5401767492294312,
0.41063782572746277,
0.3025972843170166,
0.6153836250305176,
-0.10030434280633926,
-0.0181938037276268,
-0.011018415912985802,
-0.0713912844657898,
-0.5101786851882935,
-0.823869526386261,
-0.9132432341575623,
-0.40741223096847534,
-0.21095559000968933,
-0.37060263752937317,
0.25769978761672974,
1.1036510467529297,
0.713045597076416,
-0.6725932359695435,
-0.42150482535362244,
0.20076493918895721,
0.15043745934963226,
-0.03283161669969559,
-0.15323273837566376,
0.15299275517463684,
0.054165229201316833,
-0.6125603318214417,
0.45281052589416504,
0.75906902551651,
-0.1483575999736786,
-0.7027097940444946,
-0.02129843458533287,
-0.2478320449590683,
0.0034206556156277657,
0.8388187885284424,
0.29055649042129517,
-0.7018038630485535,
0.09466832131147385,
0.06231943145394325,
-0.3116609752178192,
-0.11408109217882156,
0.795474112033844,
-0.43542546033859253,
0.3757484555244446,
0.4299951493740082,
0.8172256350517273,
0.18903273344039917,
-0.4584435224533081,
0.3079047203063965,
-0.004415896721184254,
0.11871210485696793,
0.5537857413291931,
0.5754102468490601,
0.7406274080276489,
-0.32812488079071045,
0.48709046840667725,
0.12313205003738403,
-0.9531158208847046,
-1.100257158279419,
0.16968558728694916,
-1.1695280075073242,
-0.2981989085674286,
1.3810690641403198,
0.14573833346366882,
-0.5608471035957336,
-0.34384578466415405,
-0.03391725569963455,
0.1479928195476532,
-0.10777287930250168,
0.7320898771286011,
0.49597102403640747,
-0.21298520267009735,
-0.02107267640531063,
-0.8558239936828613,
0.2961543798446655,
0.25730493664741516,
-1.1235712766647339,
0.13999846577644348,
0.49793341755867004,
0.11023791134357452,
0.016892991960048676,
0.6855642795562744,
-0.5521215796470642,
0.17895744740962982,
-0.6493275165557861,
0.12189735472202301,
0.07708197087049484,
-0.20385468006134033,
-0.3608914911746979,
-0.06082086265087128,
0.2951207160949707,
0.4754510521888733
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16295v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16295v1
|
LexDrafter: Terminology Drafting for Legislative Documents using Retrieval Augmented Generation
| 2024-03-24T21:02:35 | 2024-03-24T21:02:35 |
Ashish Chouhan, Michael Gertz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the increase in legislative documents at the EU, the number of new terms
and their definitions is increasing as well. As per the Joint Practical Guide
of the European Parliament, the Council and the Commission, terms used in legal
documents shall be consistent, and identical concepts shall be expressed
without departing from their meaning in ordinary, legal, or technical language.
Thus, while drafting a new legislative document, having a framework that
provides insights about existing definitions and helps define new terms based
on a document's context will support such harmonized legal definitions across
different regulations and thus avoid ambiguities. In this paper, we present
LexDrafter, a framework that assists in drafting Definitions articles for
legislative documents using retrieval augmented generation (RAG) and existing
term definitions present in different legislative documents. For this,
definition elements are built by extracting definitions from existing
documents. Using definition elements and RAG, a Definitions article can be
suggested on demand for a legislative document that is being drafted. We
demonstrate and evaluate the functionality of LexDrafter using a collection of
EU documents from the energy domain. The code for LexDrafter framework is
available at https://github.com/achouhan93/LexDrafter.
|
[
-0.4936198890209198,
-0.5455091595649719,
0.4576917588710785,
0.12586036324501038,
-0.7053034901618958,
0.39585965871810913,
0.15989048779010773,
-0.45708510279655457,
0.8093752264976501,
0.7556357383728027,
-0.25385111570358276,
-0.220358744263649,
-0.49140042066574097,
0.33615925908088684,
-0.5030623078346252,
0.6481603980064392,
-0.44624054431915283,
-0.24549810588359833,
-0.20754948258399963,
-0.18130220472812653,
-0.37004324793815613,
-0.16685493290424347,
-0.4912780523300171,
-0.664796769618988,
0.498491108417511,
-0.1804097294807434,
0.5009064674377441,
0.8171280026435852,
0.5383829474449158,
0.3988945484161377,
-0.21048897504806519,
0.06998612731695175,
-0.19439411163330078,
0.2636794447898865,
-0.34695741534233093,
-0.2774844467639923,
-0.5507528781890869,
-0.20724500715732574,
0.8236657977104187,
0.17037270963191986,
-0.287854939699173,
0.3437539339065552,
-0.05882491171360016,
0.6319725513458252,
-0.8076310753822327,
0.11522495746612549,
-0.9351494312286377,
-0.03569941595196724,
-0.3046016991138458,
-0.6237669587135315,
-0.12580454349517822,
-0.3079291582107544,
-0.2273314744234085,
-0.7377423644065857,
0.30113986134529114,
0.26494520902633667,
1.2282915115356445,
0.3821053206920624,
-0.10357792675495148,
-0.5152626037597656,
-0.4075635075569153,
-0.021290477365255356,
-0.46409887075424194,
0.517729640007019,
-0.048426102846860886,
0.46019914746284485,
0.22712592780590057,
-1.233504056930542,
-0.7912479043006897,
-0.12045124918222427,
-0.2818932831287384,
0.20261558890342712,
-0.2567952275276184,
0.3015846610069275,
0.41842034459114075,
0.2841326594352722,
-0.45317408442497253,
-0.08103344589471817,
-0.4533582925796509,
-0.4973430633544922,
0.6677125096321106,
0.06441681832075119,
0.20834985375404358,
-0.47474098205566406,
-0.6821356415748596,
-0.02792496420443058,
-0.9313547611236572,
-0.25299328565597534,
0.7304078340530396,
0.32808390259742737,
-0.05728713050484657,
0.8666306138038635,
0.21279536187648773,
0.4493311047554016,
0.06991977244615555,
0.4584541916847229,
0.543502688407898,
-0.3976095914840698,
-0.26788124442100525,
0.34206947684288025,
0.2658446431159973,
0.2890569567680359,
-0.5980227589607239,
-0.1368827223777771,
-0.6351311206817627,
-0.2718524932861328,
0.3617709279060364,
-0.9572955965995789,
0.05851319059729576,
0.1151181012392044,
-0.4777599573135376,
0.018204089254140854,
0.38174042105674744,
-0.8769294619560242,
-0.4111279249191284,
-0.6896072626113892,
0.10844564437866211,
-0.29060283303260803,
-0.4687177836894989,
0.045398861169815063,
-0.8939119577407837,
0.4013461172580719,
-0.011559727601706982,
-0.6584190130233765,
0.08666238188743591,
0.841938853263855,
0.7703108787536621,
0.03220238536596298,
0.18510623276233673,
-0.7291329503059387,
0.125675767660141,
-0.10043404251337051,
0.9920879006385803,
-0.5544955730438232,
-0.7944531440734863,
0.1536959856748581,
0.17245042324066162,
0.025986384600400925,
-0.42068490386009216,
0.48827654123306274,
-0.5582061409950256,
-0.1586519479751587,
-0.11950809508562088,
-0.8953972458839417,
0.03514990955591202,
0.02386597916483879,
-0.9414589405059814,
0.8403933644294739,
0.35011717677116394,
-0.6972031593322754,
0.7720184326171875,
-0.9149707555770874,
-0.25318649411201477,
0.8819901943206787,
-0.48093611001968384,
-0.34666821360588074,
0.28313618898391724,
-0.3751969039440155,
0.10377148538827896,
0.06150138005614281,
0.16811159253120422,
0.11854289472103119,
-0.07047763466835022,
-0.3082472085952759,
0.12873739004135132,
0.8626459240913391,
0.5973294377326965,
-0.09919143468141556,
0.30039215087890625,
-0.7148558497428894,
0.05957354977726936,
-0.24984434247016907,
-0.5822868347167969,
-0.5734208822250366,
-0.12798714637756348,
0.5204380750656128,
0.08987066149711609,
0.5042980313301086,
-0.7114821076393127,
-0.10928720235824585,
-0.47082844376564026,
0.24560105800628662,
0.3652321398258209,
0.25317302346229553,
0.36647194623947144,
-0.6052609086036682,
0.7839910984039307,
-0.4992940127849579,
-0.3584243357181549,
-0.12495017796754837,
-0.1126975566148758,
-0.6124659180641174,
-0.08143472671508789,
0.6203034520149231,
0.5808501839637756,
-1.1963131427764893,
0.7830967307090759,
-0.25376051664352417,
-0.5604227185249329,
-0.5306794047355652,
0.059645578265190125,
0.3788348138332367,
0.0881110206246376,
0.21947820484638214,
0.15266117453575134,
-1.0411473512649536,
-0.759972870349884,
-0.33940163254737854,
-0.19851350784301758,
-0.019504934549331665,
0.2725569009780884,
0.584846019744873,
-0.12195532768964767,
0.9236397743225098,
-0.09902758151292801,
-0.13341127336025238,
-0.47133687138557434,
0.6796202063560486,
-0.1439497321844101,
0.20670707523822784,
0.5955379605293274,
-1.103337287902832,
-0.40421774983406067,
0.11143533140420914,
-0.4211733937263489,
-0.2676777243614197,
-0.6116369366645813,
-0.08389981091022491,
0.28888869285583496,
0.864187479019165,
-0.41672006249427795,
0.343294233083725,
0.22956091165542603,
-0.6211442351341248,
0.5481042265892029,
-0.38023868203163147,
-0.2854005694389343,
-1.4343724250793457,
0.4980233609676361,
-0.13072769343852997,
-0.21313492953777313,
-0.2539212703704834,
0.7146233320236206,
0.2596483826637268,
0.11026985198259354,
-0.7186325788497925,
1.0254287719726562,
-0.4874430000782013,
-0.016397424042224884,
-0.24067716300487518,
0.3679859936237335,
0.1344321072101593,
-0.32080426812171936,
-0.015349868685007095,
1.081404209136963,
0.27003374695777893,
-0.4026409983634949,
0.48954883217811584,
0.5307096838951111,
-0.28054049611091614,
0.4295756220817566,
-0.499407559633255,
-0.06371597945690155,
-0.18427258729934692,
-0.008321626111865044,
-0.4513973593711853,
-0.09443545341491699,
-0.1580084264278412,
-0.18473903834819794,
0.5556334257125854,
0.1543412208557129,
-0.5960444808006287,
-0.5207079648971558,
-0.27637940645217896,
-0.20786598324775696,
0.1978776603937149,
-0.3661593794822693,
1.13683021068573,
0.6480279564857483,
-0.18109917640686035,
-0.5719658732414246,
-0.4164491295814514,
0.12279634922742844,
-0.18929043412208557,
-0.3760707974433899,
0.7263603210449219,
-0.02314666099846363,
-0.5639459490776062,
0.31303274631500244,
-0.3582077622413635,
0.05661731958389282,
-0.027260741218924522,
0.41817349195480347,
0.34863540530204773,
-0.0830293670296669,
0.29698145389556885,
0.28702014684677124,
0.0058110058307647705,
0.12883126735687256,
0.2076350897550583,
0.5587637424468994,
0.01197085902094841,
-0.04320323094725609,
-0.045395489782094955,
0.3012244701385498,
0.24410299956798553,
-0.1622087061405182,
0.3122257590293884,
0.5663389563560486,
-0.10470444709062576,
-0.31849443912506104,
-0.5478736758232117,
0.12930800020694733,
-0.5284804701805115,
0.0959404706954956,
-0.6305826902389526,
-0.9902307987213135,
0.6068773865699768,
-0.3366629183292389,
0.5617993474006653,
0.6819133162498474,
0.44656383991241455,
0.18633857369422913,
0.29598426818847656,
0.9686427116394043,
0.31279972195625305,
0.5451356768608093,
-0.17065440118312836,
0.23977862298488617,
-0.8333049416542053,
-0.18397760391235352,
-0.8186691403388977,
-0.11724761873483658,
-0.6686995625495911,
-0.2129022181034088,
0.1289498209953308,
-0.11234673112630844,
0.19617784023284912,
0.8025799989700317,
-0.48211869597435,
0.5981220006942749,
0.2132861614227295,
-0.29661688208580017,
0.06856542080640793,
-0.0631508156657219,
-0.46690866351127625,
0.3910404443740845,
-0.3211871087551117,
-0.6801496148109436,
0.7599115371704102,
0.03813966363668442,
0.36396661400794983,
-0.2493516504764557,
1.2063592672348022,
0.3402467668056488,
0.3061724603176117,
-0.851280689239502,
0.5563682913780212,
-0.1754382699728012,
-0.6635199189186096,
-0.28738540410995483,
-0.4601157307624817,
-1.0386617183685303,
0.16738049685955048,
-0.3701832890510559,
-0.35073545575141907,
0.37463676929473877,
-0.09765950590372086,
-0.5600548982620239,
0.5042695999145508,
-0.22169849276542664,
0.5234783291816711,
0.034720756113529205,
-0.2075490802526474,
-0.2112082988023758,
-0.29756462574005127,
0.07312798500061035,
-0.4216117858886719,
-0.02160957083106041,
-0.33858153223991394,
-0.22454476356506348,
0.62567138671875,
-0.37053006887435913,
0.18957558274269104,
-0.3753732442855835,
-0.28184276819229126,
0.6008634567260742,
-0.0647958442568779,
0.17693611979484558,
0.11368650943040848,
-0.5212619304656982,
-0.09899915754795074,
0.40705645084381104,
0.022165244445204735,
-0.36882683634757996,
0.22343748807907104,
-0.16155245900154114,
-0.4426526427268982,
-0.16226541996002197,
-0.5217416286468506,
0.1823507398366928,
0.5681007504463196,
0.48505276441574097,
0.4615728259086609,
-0.44965681433677673,
0.19401830434799194,
0.2363126575946808,
-0.03140835836529732,
0.521730363368988,
0.4710979461669922,
-0.30885934829711914,
-0.09137865900993347,
0.807525634765625,
0.06862898916006088,
-0.2470199167728424,
0.49204906821250916,
-0.028912581503391266,
-0.8206146955490112,
-0.5820143222808838,
-0.21443982422351837,
0.0808391273021698,
-0.6728789210319519,
-0.4648139774799347,
-0.2273930311203003,
-0.5571831464767456,
-0.1492936909198761,
-0.29104065895080566,
0.071651890873909,
-0.6147406697273254,
-0.037750519812107086,
-0.2711161673069,
0.24782924354076385,
0.5516555905342102,
-0.21707798540592194,
0.060124803334474564,
-0.8373680114746094,
0.4283922016620636,
0.12802214920520782,
0.4526335895061493,
-0.6709761619567871,
-0.1802719235420227,
0.08332916349172592,
-0.09437671303749084,
-0.4113336503505707,
-0.43219634890556335,
0.4019929766654968,
0.23816706240177155,
0.7471235990524292,
0.2940174341201782,
0.06174786016345024,
0.5994715690612793,
-0.6140405535697937,
0.644216001033783,
0.2904092073440552,
-0.9624655842781067,
0.47157320380210876,
-0.21243080496788025,
0.18224291503429413,
0.7497426271438599,
0.14166606962680817,
-0.37422117590904236,
-0.5986116528511047,
-0.6028194427490234,
-1.0191329717636108,
0.05342518538236618,
0.19371367990970612,
0.6394960880279541,
-0.12319405376911163,
0.607329785823822,
0.22810740768909454,
0.20489579439163208,
-0.2251274436712265,
-0.08588681370019913,
-0.10846170783042908,
0.16751554608345032,
0.3018982410430908,
-0.08158136159181595,
-0.20492416620254517,
-0.12265735864639282,
0.8350266814231873,
-0.06114306300878525,
0.3428346812725067,
0.039738573133945465,
-0.052321527153253555,
-0.26164889335632324,
0.6223031282424927,
0.514419436454773,
0.927390992641449,
-0.4182562828063965,
0.11211496591567993,
-0.11148232966661453,
-0.6736611723899841,
-0.09320797026157379,
0.62244713306427,
-0.4162347614765167,
0.6832718849182129,
-0.005778772756457329,
0.749502956867218,
0.13123074173927307,
-0.7815002202987671,
0.1934327483177185,
-0.1347578465938568,
-0.8781768083572388,
-0.47125694155693054,
0.053069256246089935,
0.013120995834469795,
0.21787814795970917,
0.28418779373168945,
0.11966563016176224,
0.1721109300851822,
-0.3708542585372925,
0.611578643321991,
0.4792702794075012,
-0.043346140533685684,
0.04115869104862213,
0.6860287189483643,
0.2510688602924347,
-0.32731643319129944,
0.17142720520496368,
-0.5858956575393677,
-0.22021052241325378,
0.6249719858169556,
0.418935626745224,
0.9899990558624268,
0.07091061025857925,
0.24608096480369568,
0.42389678955078125,
-0.001161767984740436,
0.1063697412610054,
0.637644350528717,
-0.13076409697532654,
-0.6859152317047119,
-0.2824758291244507,
-0.9948895573616028,
-0.3945428133010864,
-0.017638618126511574,
-0.8357406854629517,
0.42978471517562866,
-0.48361170291900635,
-0.5048233866691589,
0.388029545545578,
0.15551280975341797,
-0.4821558892726898,
-0.5624876022338867,
0.3186626732349396,
1.466845154762268,
-0.4325793385505676,
0.7157135009765625,
0.9288076758384705,
-0.4491157531738281,
-0.8119875192642212,
-0.11465528607368469,
-0.016336096450686455,
-0.6953374147415161,
0.5099142789840698,
-0.05053176358342171,
-0.2732059359550476,
0.07886308431625366,
-0.21017807722091675,
-0.7579196691513062,
1.28582763671875,
0.15017294883728027,
-0.6866255402565002,
-0.28631019592285156,
0.05596417561173439,
0.4331919550895691,
-0.2316894829273224,
-0.2526664137840271,
0.6516621112823486,
0.7293872237205505,
0.4685308635234833,
-0.9670201539993286,
0.16531085968017578,
-0.7033480405807495,
0.06848673522472382,
0.4703413248062134,
0.01958777941763401,
0.45292288064956665,
0.23232142627239227,
-0.5712058544158936,
0.3732692003250122,
0.4664458632469177,
0.22176989912986755,
0.30522462725639343,
0.48168542981147766,
0.5765725374221802,
0.8573622703552246,
-0.11774595826864243,
0.8369669914245605,
-0.8049418926239014,
0.24113231897354126,
1.1730494499206543,
-0.632876455783844,
0.984707236289978,
0.6073979139328003,
0.1163700670003891,
0.5192567706108093,
0.24693559110164642,
-0.39534851908683777,
0.3233642280101776,
0.21324996650218964,
-0.37758731842041016,
-0.061267875134944916,
-0.1586422324180603,
-0.33302000164985657,
0.3893080949783325,
0.5419297814369202,
-0.3686443865299225,
-0.8343830108642578,
-0.031799834221601486,
-0.12518003582954407,
0.24360774457454681,
-0.4347630739212036,
0.9258430004119873,
0.032458435744047165,
-0.5940238833427429,
0.6098431348800659,
-0.0068670231848955154,
0.4070812463760376,
-0.44184914231300354,
-0.19754035770893097,
0.0034365705214440823,
-0.11091623455286026,
-0.18494917452335358,
-0.9416366219520569,
0.82321697473526,
0.06222192198038101,
0.2119365781545639,
-0.6122467517852783,
0.6824518442153931,
-0.2334342747926712,
-0.4553305208683014,
0.19689348340034485,
0.772255003452301,
0.15976044535636902,
0.22316063940525055,
-0.9559205174446106,
-0.008959105238318443,
-0.28286516666412354,
0.10433068871498108,
0.033615246415138245,
0.37618017196655273,
0.28904902935028076,
0.21063517034053802,
0.3498339354991913,
0.44719216227531433,
0.07825016975402832,
0.11294813454151154,
1.0244287252426147,
-0.1428767293691635,
-0.6564046740531921,
-0.5467334389686584,
0.5145100355148315,
-0.32054081559181213,
-0.24266061186790466,
0.6075769066810608,
1.0423583984375,
0.6791191101074219,
0.1275521069765091,
0.8267869353294373,
-0.5311890840530396,
0.4240885376930237,
-0.7267981767654419,
0.9989848732948303,
-0.5100008845329285,
0.1852284073829651,
0.10094524919986725,
-1.0865066051483154,
-0.3027559816837311,
0.41669079661369324,
-0.07584206759929657,
-0.3989165127277374,
0.7060753107070923,
0.7333264946937561,
-0.04223866015672684,
0.10230863839387894,
0.21747595071792603,
-0.11286736279726028,
0.08513544499874115,
-0.1421235352754593,
0.4364897310733795,
-0.02120235003530979,
0.26209530234336853,
-0.03535674139857292,
0.23385757207870483,
-0.03241858631372452,
-0.9088156819343567,
-0.7814229130744934,
-0.8472458124160767,
-0.1027449294924736,
-0.19325195252895355,
0.04306621849536896,
1.2178207635879517,
0.39516085386276245,
-0.624805748462677,
-0.29973432421684265,
-0.3947216272354126,
0.1746976673603058,
-0.01569925807416439,
-0.24139223992824554,
0.4274199306964874,
-0.6951028108596802,
-0.39307212829589844,
0.23211944103240967,
0.10412304848432541,
0.015681374818086624,
0.013039099983870983,
0.0557195283472538,
-0.08667895942926407,
0.364271342754364,
0.43362003564834595,
0.44571569561958313,
-0.6806558966636658,
-0.08463146537542343,
-0.48785513639450073,
0.03575048968195915,
0.1537034958600998,
1.1354265213012695,
-0.7236711382865906,
0.5506976246833801,
0.6013526916503906,
0.6986210346221924,
0.4491758346557617,
0.11466105282306671,
0.26872164011001587,
-0.9196822047233582,
0.14494222402572632,
0.25821542739868164,
0.7622485756874084,
0.08198755234479904,
-0.3816109001636505,
0.5607776045799255,
-0.010912002064287663,
-0.17089682817459106,
-0.5978396534919739,
0.03174646198749542,
-0.98123699426651,
-0.3234250843524933,
0.9482228755950928,
0.030037548393011093,
-0.2083211988210678,
-0.20466823875904083,
-0.2936829626560211,
0.41444212198257446,
-0.42048463225364685,
0.8742384314537048,
0.4715350866317749,
-0.01343873143196106,
-0.1621840000152588,
-0.719031810760498,
0.7333369255065918,
-0.2608887255191803,
-1.0047273635864258,
0.2400716096162796,
0.5426510572433472,
0.13738086819648743,
0.5450399518013,
0.5263909101486206,
-0.16942428052425385,
0.3746331036090851,
0.2051638662815094,
0.16765770316123962,
-0.38496875762939453,
-0.0015035697724670172,
-0.3722591698169708,
0.20311424136161804,
-0.30148860812187195,
0.24908848106861115
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16265v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16265v1
|
Connecting the Dots: Inferring Patent Phrase Similarity with Retrieved Phrase Graphs
| 2024-03-24T18:59:38 | 2024-03-24T18:59:38 |
Zhuoyi Peng, Yi Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We study the patent phrase similarity inference task, which measures the
semantic similarity between two patent phrases. As patent documents employ
legal and highly technical language, existing semantic textual similarity
methods that use localized contextual information do not perform satisfactorily
in inferring patent phrase similarity. To address this, we introduce a
graph-augmented approach to amplify the global contextual information of the
patent phrases. For each patent phrase, we construct a phrase graph that links
to its focal patents and a list of patents that are either cited by or cite
these focal patents. The augmented phrase embedding is then derived from
combining its localized contextual embedding with its global embedding within
the phrase graph. We further propose a self-supervised learning objective that
capitalizes on the retrieved topology to refine both the contextualized
embedding and the graph parameters in an end-to-end manner. Experimental
results from a unique patent phrase similarity dataset demonstrate that our
approach significantly enhances the representation of patent phrases, resulting
in marked improvements in similarity inference in a self-supervised fashion.
Substantial improvements are also observed in the supervised setting,
underscoring the potential benefits of leveraging retrieved phrase graph
augmentation.
|
[
-0.038747306913137436,
-0.7232521176338196,
0.6855323314666748,
0.2301435023546219,
-0.33464425802230835,
0.4204329550266266,
0.29215213656425476,
-0.5511812567710876,
0.7375645637512207,
0.8184322714805603,
-0.23882654309272766,
-0.6362011432647705,
-0.4810698628425598,
0.07190057635307312,
-0.284537672996521,
0.5476164817810059,
0.06742885708808899,
-0.1592281609773636,
-0.6363573670387268,
0.056702498346567154,
-0.3654554784297943,
-0.5024504065513611,
-0.1757015734910965,
-0.3895712196826935,
0.3817046880722046,
0.42048847675323486,
0.32745519280433655,
0.7582297325134277,
0.37370964884757996,
0.36246517300605774,
-0.21119612455368042,
0.30913275480270386,
-0.2537505626678467,
0.133317232131958,
-0.06185780465602875,
-0.26027804613113403,
-0.17290805280208588,
0.15017364919185638,
0.3534536063671112,
1.061276912689209,
0.3804287016391754,
-0.02082516811788082,
0.41228926181793213,
0.28956159949302673,
-0.2996213734149933,
0.23167097568511963,
-0.7850863337516785,
0.3042072653770447,
-0.06504273414611816,
-0.554714560508728,
-0.3591303825378418,
-0.3442690074443817,
0.18774233758449554,
-0.9178745150566101,
0.5369152426719666,
0.4719867408275604,
1.176527976989746,
-0.003538310993462801,
-0.49728044867515564,
-0.2779269516468048,
-0.11387193202972412,
0.3764159679412842,
-0.36479315161705017,
-0.03142502158880234,
0.34240901470184326,
-0.22012799978256226,
-0.43331918120384216,
-1.4923127889633179,
-0.5366620421409607,
-0.42007747292518616,
-0.24459829926490784,
-0.001716830302029848,
-0.20981097221374512,
-0.00595129607245326,
0.23687832057476044,
0.06194129213690758,
-0.6628280878067017,
-0.005012589041143656,
-0.44544950127601624,
-0.24871838092803955,
0.18131104111671448,
-0.326522558927536,
0.18185967206954956,
-0.5248421430587769,
-0.7503561973571777,
0.01388173084706068,
-0.9237827658653259,
-0.13299565017223358,
0.14772716164588928,
0.5028009414672852,
0.26923373341560364,
0.5850996971130371,
-0.3762268126010895,
0.6823094487190247,
0.31956395506858826,
0.2538880705833435,
0.6347115635871887,
-0.37441349029541016,
-0.2684154510498047,
0.43324241042137146,
0.5917553305625916,
0.3809974193572998,
0.17674516141414642,
-0.6034297347068787,
0.23103447258472443,
-0.5268736481666565,
0.16404329240322113,
-0.7406976222991943,
-0.3989872932434082,
0.024948081001639366,
-0.521507740020752,
0.012421769089996815,
0.20078958570957184,
-0.5819520950317383,
-0.6279588341712952,
-0.5379964113235474,
0.7592514753341675,
-0.267122745513916,
0.24069668352603912,
-0.1387835144996643,
-0.68644118309021,
0.13934031128883362,
-0.22936779260635376,
-0.7988013625144958,
0.10940304398536682,
1.0722984075546265,
1.1128333806991577,
0.1218976303935051,
-0.4633990526199341,
-0.44602930545806885,
0.5086339712142944,
-0.5209295749664307,
1.0751841068267822,
-0.5219182968139648,
-0.8718954920768738,
-0.2727867662906647,
0.23016363382339478,
-0.29225829243659973,
-0.8043490648269653,
0.3640308976173401,
-0.5179187655448914,
0.20326298475265503,
-0.234316885471344,
-0.9061024785041809,
0.06659240275621414,
0.2279428094625473,
-0.4373529553413391,
0.7895257472991943,
-0.15712548792362213,
-0.9502241611480713,
0.8545027375221252,
-0.5765991806983948,
-0.6946414113044739,
0.07628083974123001,
-0.3319350481033325,
-0.5430850982666016,
0.024165363982319832,
0.24794591963291168,
0.35670530796051025,
0.08679889142513275,
-0.05069664493203163,
-0.7432926297187805,
-0.000036079465644434094,
0.12160655856132507,
0.28012731671333313,
0.9305196404457092,
0.20081548392772675,
-0.1019878163933754,
0.1395062357187271,
-0.8492277264595032,
-0.04953960329294205,
-0.09453505277633667,
0.21298867464065552,
-0.7840448021888733,
-0.09924853593111038,
-0.6372119188308716,
0.018564322963356972,
0.46377265453338623,
-0.9127923846244812,
0.02480577863752842,
-0.49885985255241394,
0.39200881123542786,
0.7631961107254028,
0.4810009002685547,
0.3198624551296234,
-0.012943149544298649,
0.3162586987018585,
-0.2216586023569107,
0.07513636350631714,
-0.1643872857093811,
-0.7029169201850891,
-0.46114400029182434,
-0.49919891357421875,
0.4262154698371887,
0.29943251609802246,
-0.6168670058250427,
0.5620712041854858,
-0.5724381804466248,
-0.2811453342437744,
-0.2571634352207184,
0.10940935462713242,
0.25947463512420654,
1.1451669931411743,
0.28233516216278076,
-0.3621039092540741,
-0.31785523891448975,
-0.8763003349304199,
-0.5523350834846497,
0.07860735803842545,
-0.15418212115764618,
0.6011790037155151,
0.3740154802799225,
0.15295563638210297,
1.3127738237380981,
-0.874299943447113,
-0.5156542658805847,
0.36285820603370667,
0.5678460001945496,
0.44947075843811035,
0.41524216532707214,
0.6255040168762207,
-0.7155433297157288,
-0.8484196662902832,
0.44268643856048584,
-0.7434783577919006,
-0.015380863100290298,
0.07753492891788483,
0.046437982469797134,
-0.44839775562286377,
1.0409481525421143,
-0.5088137984275818,
0.38309240341186523,
-0.008184797130525112,
-0.563948929309845,
0.18357707560062408,
-0.6572672724723816,
0.29464206099510193,
-1.2456340789794922,
0.22413896024227142,
-0.2967875301837921,
-0.15858712792396545,
-0.31355053186416626,
-0.08130434155464172,
0.08349260687828064,
-0.38598063588142395,
-0.28730112314224243,
0.5705732703208923,
-0.688002347946167,
-0.3034556806087494,
-0.4276581406593323,
0.45167216658592224,
0.5023711323738098,
0.11947222799062729,
-0.39792126417160034,
1.0547794103622437,
0.7716959118843079,
-0.47295498847961426,
0.5161734819412231,
0.34295853972435,
-0.38929739594459534,
0.5326686501502991,
-0.7922884821891785,
0.0885050818324089,
-0.032257936894893646,
0.0607660710811615,
-1.0175471305847168,
-0.04463904723525047,
-0.08394630253314972,
-0.5568637251853943,
0.34476467967033386,
-0.32725954055786133,
-0.6753435134887695,
-0.4796707332134247,
-0.24003902077674866,
-0.02862556092441082,
0.2220020592212677,
-0.9084569215774536,
0.5398746728897095,
0.49284595251083374,
-0.4197222590446472,
-0.4640175402164459,
-0.7559953331947327,
0.5020190477371216,
-0.6045061349868774,
-0.638447105884552,
0.8069997429847717,
0.4547105133533478,
0.11439571529626846,
0.34120258688926697,
0.20631103217601776,
-0.3013213872909546,
0.024626921862363815,
0.40587544441223145,
-0.06731446832418442,
-0.18055513501167297,
0.5686537027359009,
0.058091141283512115,
-0.4115627110004425,
-0.06258047372102737,
-0.979626476764679,
0.2166624814271927,
0.3365667760372162,
-0.30683228373527527,
0.06269239634275436,
0.2786361277103424,
0.04929487034678459,
-0.20194466412067413,
0.2135591208934784,
0.3686898946762085,
-0.14736101031303406,
-0.14217503368854523,
-0.15454711019992828,
-0.0031737766694277525,
-0.5332561731338501,
0.1136736124753952,
-0.7374945878982544,
-0.9780381917953491,
0.5031806826591492,
-0.5701055526733398,
-0.5528838634490967,
0.5319780111312866,
0.17453280091285706,
-0.10824300348758698,
0.44347602128982544,
0.6601012349128723,
-0.03644940257072449,
0.48279157280921936,
-0.305787056684494,
0.7047973871231079,
-0.711541473865509,
-0.31976571679115295,
-0.7015402913093567,
-0.09942703694105148,
-0.45443403720855713,
-0.6499453783035278,
0.2955452799797058,
0.15242812037467957,
-0.13861282169818878,
0.5375347137451172,
-0.6950829029083252,
0.5555137395858765,
0.9492142796516418,
0.12108651548624039,
0.21758247911930084,
0.5834929347038269,
-0.7930660247802734,
0.013365532271564007,
-0.4832531809806824,
-0.2695253789424896,
1.1713472604751587,
-0.05844465643167496,
0.6292154788970947,
-0.37550896406173706,
0.8437297940254211,
0.6153386831283569,
-0.23694965243339539,
-0.46310320496559143,
0.4519771337509155,
-0.3511659801006317,
-0.28910958766937256,
-0.033891137689352036,
-0.25658032298088074,
-1.3109978437423706,
0.06661970913410187,
0.014530770480632782,
-1.0069334506988525,
0.6929755210876465,
0.16573655605316162,
-0.2638870179653168,
-0.08157042413949966,
-0.9706171751022339,
1.0949615240097046,
-0.2480977177619934,
-0.4448395073413849,
-0.43938830494880676,
-0.5911652445793152,
-0.17995049059391022,
-0.12654022872447968,
-0.11003881692886353,
0.04402177408337593,
0.16811734437942505,
0.6901731491088867,
-0.7215577363967896,
0.9306467175483704,
-0.036799509078264236,
0.1583770364522934,
0.4950313866138458,
-0.33299770951271057,
0.16501565277576447,
-0.3541840612888336,
-0.11617854237556458,
-0.08728338778018951,
-0.23207128047943115,
-0.49544477462768555,
-0.6697362661361694,
1.1702159643173218,
-0.27906882762908936,
-0.5698568820953369,
-0.34687718749046326,
-0.248259037733078,
-0.12122298777103424,
0.6481552124023438,
0.08411223441362381,
0.637813925743103,
-0.0550583191215992,
0.037901926785707474,
0.22961552441120148,
-0.03452306613326073,
0.3846808671951294,
0.20131437480449677,
-0.04464685544371605,
-0.6455384492874146,
1.2175521850585938,
0.20561692118644714,
0.0786450207233429,
0.5663901567459106,
0.1900409311056137,
-0.7309001684188843,
-0.37605366110801697,
-0.12460220605134964,
0.21017783880233765,
-0.8820876479148865,
-0.12096594274044037,
-0.6778726577758789,
0.0034688101150095463,
-0.7495592832565308,
-0.0572822205722332,
0.10918255895376205,
-0.8144553899765015,
-0.42096278071403503,
-0.40671873092651367,
0.7517649531364441,
0.6307324171066284,
-0.32320237159729004,
0.12451055645942688,
-0.5210740566253662,
0.417659193277359,
0.5201060175895691,
0.44255784153938293,
-0.22711239755153656,
-0.3795989751815796,
-0.3091996908187866,
-0.07852697372436523,
-0.5080033540725708,
-0.4787422716617584,
0.22603657841682434,
0.5510910749435425,
0.617770254611969,
0.4432312548160553,
0.10344898700714111,
0.9905757904052734,
-0.7372094988822937,
0.7433221936225891,
0.14167653024196625,
-0.8195257782936096,
0.8111903071403503,
-0.018731143325567245,
-0.2997277081012726,
0.274888277053833,
0.30615171790122986,
0.1079787164926529,
-0.2582821249961853,
-0.8013620972633362,
-1.009642481803894,
0.1693328469991684,
-0.12341636419296265,
0.2989029586315155,
-0.37468650937080383,
0.4653487205505371,
-0.09277038276195526,
0.09426901489496231,
-0.4455101788043976,
-0.04375466704368591,
-0.12997403740882874,
-0.1499997228384018,
0.2705186903476715,
0.13105161488056183,
-0.3022159934043884,
0.027979034930467606,
0.4957200884819031,
-0.2983442544937134,
0.280446320772171,
0.6443604230880737,
-0.00657103443518281,
0.3373570144176483,
-0.16502806544303894,
0.20814841985702515,
0.7729460597038269,
-0.18150272965431213,
0.40511560440063477,
-0.13133679330348969,
-0.3179062008857727,
-0.22083774209022522,
0.7776774168014526,
-0.16273760795593262,
0.28303489089012146,
0.3626178801059723,
0.5816793441772461,
0.15119792520999908,
-0.513841450214386,
0.4983641505241394,
0.23053598403930664,
-0.059520382434129715,
0.11986558139324188,
-0.24586772918701172,
0.05518080294132233,
0.3734208345413208,
0.5139395594596863,
-0.12151314318180084,
0.5333773493766785,
-0.44310760498046875,
0.8185197114944458,
0.5453494191169739,
-0.5494424104690552,
0.0730973333120346,
0.5870845317840576,
0.15333420038223267,
-0.15651145577430725,
0.11294743418693542,
-0.15901851654052734,
-0.5038948059082031,
0.811223030090332,
0.7462426424026489,
1.013160228729248,
0.2819473445415497,
0.15350733697414398,
0.25981953740119934,
-0.10334417223930359,
0.32764294743537903,
-0.11664949357509613,
-0.46485814452171326,
-0.31667354702949524,
-0.2835266590118408,
-0.1536380648612976,
-0.3421773612499237,
-0.6338931322097778,
-0.20007777214050293,
0.1581609696149826,
-0.2802911102771759,
-0.41306132078170776,
0.06400655955076218,
0.10460498183965683,
-0.2671888768672943,
0.15349984169006348,
-0.21882280707359314,
0.5590854287147522,
-0.7150933146476746,
0.7880389094352722,
0.5584813952445984,
-0.5622488260269165,
-0.5183343887329102,
-0.0607047863304615,
-0.31144624948501587,
-0.9002166986465454,
1.0007271766662598,
0.17097745835781097,
-0.17320606112480164,
0.050021812319755554,
-0.3791259527206421,
-0.9064632058143616,
1.3053908348083496,
0.1343540996313095,
-0.08517596870660782,
0.2048020213842392,
0.29955410957336426,
0.4625818133354187,
-0.49529680609703064,
-0.1795557290315628,
0.17373433709144592,
-0.06609873473644257,
0.28878337144851685,
-0.828464925289154,
0.06411575525999069,
-0.20795221626758575,
-0.1319328099489212,
-0.06261973083019257,
-0.2133329063653946,
0.6862211227416992,
-0.3211500644683838,
-0.25162723660469055,
0.22732983529567719,
0.809863269329071,
0.21009044349193573,
0.6412498950958252,
0.2635725140571594,
0.7723613381385803,
0.9324061870574951,
0.1446947604417801,
1.0093430280685425,
-0.8270258903503418,
0.5675672292709351,
1.4466708898544312,
-0.3123142719268799,
0.8208457827568054,
0.4701826870441437,
-0.03329099714756012,
0.42907220125198364,
0.5190197825431824,
-0.31089454889297485,
0.6782919764518738,
0.11838462948799133,
-0.19440047442913055,
0.05724888667464256,
-0.582472026348114,
-0.49717292189598083,
0.0011224327608942986,
0.32794222235679626,
-0.7178311347961426,
-0.23496630787849426,
-0.08078697323799133,
-0.08253085613250732,
0.20966312289237976,
0.10130851715803146,
0.8381527662277222,
0.32740095257759094,
-0.396858811378479,
0.398889422416687,
-0.38071712851524353,
0.05112083628773689,
-0.3100806176662445,
-0.10097037255764008,
-0.11107950657606125,
0.21670210361480713,
-0.020630300045013428,
-0.9441955089569092,
0.15738342702388763,
-0.13388144969940186,
-0.1181056946516037,
-0.2075365036725998,
0.8135086894035339,
-0.2874021828174591,
-0.5931634306907654,
0.5092592239379883,
0.1537836641073227,
0.17781250178813934,
0.07940604537725449,
-0.6095728278160095,
-0.6435846090316772,
-0.14083115756511688,
0.3395596444606781,
0.13699620962142944,
0.8939018845558167,
0.09496572613716125,
0.6615603566169739,
0.5851122736930847,
0.16555027663707733,
0.41112446784973145,
0.24655456840991974,
1.0224473476409912,
-0.6448177099227905,
-0.7827262878417969,
-0.41431379318237305,
0.17277659475803375,
-0.7228819131851196,
-0.35353347659111023,
1.0055718421936035,
0.8587221503257751,
0.4953075647354126,
-0.19242940843105316,
0.700036883354187,
-0.04266471043229103,
0.8126001358032227,
-0.5540580153465271,
0.4486277997493744,
-0.5097457766532898,
0.13370460271835327,
-0.32735058665275574,
-0.6652234196662903,
-0.5953555703163147,
0.49213165044784546,
-0.41197073459625244,
-0.14818017184734344,
0.6206364631652832,
1.0903010368347168,
-0.36530691385269165,
-0.30077192187309265,
0.09054521471261978,
0.36824601888656616,
0.4388172924518585,
-0.1139780730009079,
0.5090076923370361,
-0.3867533206939697,
0.4151466190814972,
-0.26901665329933167,
-0.07865215092897415,
-0.11004982888698578,
-1.146457314491272,
-0.5578625798225403,
-0.4116034507751465,
-0.5190086960792542,
-0.3963089883327484,
0.1306149661540985,
0.6925051212310791,
0.6714873313903809,
-0.679495096206665,
-0.04016590863466263,
-0.3233034610748291,
0.36663681268692017,
-0.010617939755320549,
-0.2624945640563965,
0.9996474385261536,
-0.7269761562347412,
-0.4482479393482208,
0.522144615650177,
0.5900375843048096,
-0.09866172820329666,
0.2632427215576172,
0.27032700181007385,
-0.30593252182006836,
-0.1389072984457016,
0.7013514637947083,
0.5227672457695007,
-0.6709775924682617,
-0.48301568627357483,
0.08176825195550919,
0.07500766217708588,
0.23163333535194397,
1.0075956583023071,
-1.0280418395996094,
0.9714180827140808,
0.791987955570221,
0.8074913620948792,
0.6113443970680237,
0.36109659075737,
0.5679280161857605,
-0.9358908534049988,
0.17488990724086761,
-0.12593357264995575,
0.5468272566795349,
0.45731911063194275,
-0.22945043444633484,
0.3970688581466675,
0.36642947793006897,
-0.5879669785499573,
-0.37318500876426697,
0.10693782567977905,
-1.147387146949768,
-0.42217764258384705,
0.6908707022666931,
-0.5725638270378113,
-0.17993564903736115,
-0.32282131910324097,
-0.12938053905963898,
0.10261484235525131,
-0.04777438938617706,
0.8040657639503479,
0.2216016948223114,
-0.26950058341026306,
0.24367637932300568,
-0.06479024887084961,
0.23069585859775543,
0.15779614448547363,
-0.5930972695350647,
-0.09679917991161346,
0.4034597873687744,
0.267834335565567,
0.555971622467041,
0.5512027144432068,
-0.16486895084381104,
-0.09634462743997574,
0.38446810841560364,
-0.045302003622055054,
-0.029972782358527184,
-0.12237310409545898,
-0.02841581404209137,
0.39321404695510864,
0.17316892743110657,
-0.6687044501304626
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16248v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16248v2
|
Large Language Models Offer an Alternative to the Traditional Approach of Topic Modelling
| 2024-03-24T17:39:51 | 2024-03-26T17:46:26 |
Yida Mu, Chun Dong, Kalina Bontcheva, Xingyi Song
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Topic modelling, as a well-established unsupervised technique, has found
extensive use in automatically detecting significant topics within a corpus of
documents. However, classic topic modelling approaches (e.g., LDA) have certain
drawbacks, such as the lack of semantic understanding and the presence of
overlapping topics. In this work, we investigate the untapped potential of
large language models (LLMs) as an alternative for uncovering the underlying
topics within extensive text corpora. To this end, we introduce a framework
that prompts LLMs to generate topics from a given set of documents and
establish evaluation protocols to assess the clustering efficacy of LLMs. Our
findings indicate that LLMs with appropriate prompts can stand out as a viable
alternative, capable of generating relevant topic titles and adhering to human
guidelines to refine and merge topics. Through in-depth experiments and
evaluation, we summarise the advantages and constraints of employing LLMs in
topic extraction.
|
[
-0.48589494824409485,
-0.8577917218208313,
1.1185301542282104,
-0.08594129979610443,
-0.37374481558799744,
0.04380868375301361,
-0.6527659296989441,
-0.03397241607308388,
0.3172185719013214,
0.7131075263023376,
-0.45750704407691956,
-0.5293028950691223,
-0.7197837829589844,
0.009750080294907093,
-0.9426091909408569,
0.6957044005393982,
0.040753234177827835,
-0.2139328271150589,
-0.28175508975982666,
0.3426438868045807,
-0.5382493734359741,
-0.42454370856285095,
-0.43109607696533203,
-0.3596106469631195,
0.7235080599784851,
0.5093324780464172,
0.3513358533382416,
0.4952828288078308,
0.5502278208732605,
0.26516857743263245,
-0.517799973487854,
0.15853194892406464,
-0.4694632291793823,
0.13469967246055603,
-0.35288259387016296,
-0.31975504755973816,
-0.05152048170566559,
0.16149543225765228,
0.8438398838043213,
1.0569195747375488,
-0.15120360255241394,
-0.13705484569072723,
-0.15548241138458252,
0.5111517310142517,
-0.3334871232509613,
-0.17832252383232117,
-0.958428144454956,
-0.12160568684339523,
-0.1763298362493515,
-0.30751803517341614,
-0.33975085616111755,
0.04047958180308342,
0.3339957296848297,
0.04425591602921486,
0.08305420726537704,
-0.10061628371477127,
0.6752181649208069,
-0.08470086753368378,
-0.463452011346817,
-0.6475241184234619,
-0.7149155735969543,
0.7976108193397522,
-0.6791436076164246,
0.19431638717651367,
0.1715451329946518,
0.06547923386096954,
-0.28829246759414673,
-0.532213568687439,
-0.48832443356513977,
-0.2358589768409729,
-0.08393202722072601,
-0.13885806500911713,
-0.2612302601337433,
-0.3095865547657013,
0.11295382678508759,
0.46005779504776,
-0.5684622526168823,
0.5503973364830017,
-0.26982200145721436,
0.13123346865177155,
0.3666704297065735,
0.24928328394889832,
0.3908020257949829,
-0.3514355719089508,
-0.167542964220047,
0.269171804189682,
-0.9863027930259705,
-0.20538608729839325,
0.434550940990448,
0.44474509358406067,
0.055092040449380875,
0.7979965806007385,
0.02193984016776085,
0.800305187702179,
-0.028867142274975777,
-0.2065429389476776,
-0.1488325446844101,
-0.05466903746128082,
0.04608609154820442,
-0.12125322967767715,
0.5779677033424377,
0.06795714795589447,
-0.12303317338228226,
-0.43632495403289795,
-0.17898452281951904,
0.07022368162870407,
0.24070796370506287,
-0.8773406744003296,
0.1453162431716919,
0.5840268731117249,
-0.5407639145851135,
-0.2727683484554291,
0.11645381897687912,
-0.8978114128112793,
-0.44626688957214355,
-0.4307834804058075,
0.017556175589561462,
-0.16657991707324982,
-0.3815825283527374,
0.1411108374595642,
-0.23246197402477264,
0.33041760325431824,
0.4268542528152466,
-0.9528688788414001,
-0.0002438668889226392,
1.1861308813095093,
0.8334760665893555,
-0.8459542989730835,
-0.1231684461236,
-0.3915823698043823,
0.10141588747501373,
-0.739155113697052,
0.8559142351150513,
-0.8736555576324463,
-0.5559284687042236,
0.1013069897890091,
0.14376333355903625,
0.35354936122894287,
-0.584826648235321,
0.33503207564353943,
-0.6703032851219177,
0.20993240177631378,
-0.10615789145231247,
-0.7192209362983704,
0.16553159058094025,
0.21086850762367249,
-0.5774155855178833,
0.7372602224349976,
-0.09814789146184921,
-0.7342337369918823,
0.2489469200372696,
-0.6578039526939392,
-0.18119056522846222,
-0.11763478815555573,
-0.30229708552360535,
-0.05723113939166069,
0.1966114640235901,
0.15587423741817474,
0.703345000743866,
-0.7735329866409302,
0.8886919021606445,
-0.2509421408176422,
-0.26887083053588867,
0.45802220702171326,
-0.5123344659805298,
0.3760582506656647,
0.29542475938796997,
-0.08325245976448059,
0.4150027334690094,
-0.5530164837837219,
-0.48418545722961426,
-0.014031510800123215,
-0.2294902354478836,
-0.5409581661224365,
0.005730877630412579,
-0.12841899693012238,
0.12431225925683975,
0.4326017200946808,
-0.38044703006744385,
0.18842655420303345,
-0.4066735506057739,
0.591927707195282,
0.6359961628913879,
0.027715902775526047,
0.5417860746383667,
-0.1462555080652237,
0.4402313828468323,
-0.03689553588628769,
-0.4523940682411194,
-0.5254513621330261,
-0.47602516412734985,
-0.6363857388496399,
-0.6075167059898376,
0.5271301865577698,
0.21323628723621368,
-0.5257045030593872,
0.7710131406784058,
-0.16247114539146423,
-0.707748532295227,
-0.1060212105512619,
0.16996876895427704,
-0.038922734558582306,
0.14472638070583344,
-0.13611774146556854,
-0.14512501657009125,
-0.3462931513786316,
-0.7803245782852173,
0.07146059721708298,
0.08250078558921814,
-0.23808546364307404,
0.12242969870567322,
0.5385864973068237,
-0.27927207946777344,
1.2660738229751587,
-0.6243699193000793,
0.15365900099277496,
-0.3837502598762512,
0.3741682469844818,
0.4448903799057007,
0.36248326301574707,
0.15531618893146515,
-0.9774438738822937,
-0.2116025984287262,
0.08743280172348022,
-0.8598273992538452,
-0.08962646871805191,
-0.14520998299121857,
-0.10953274369239807,
-0.11739535629749298,
0.8320081830024719,
-0.88108891248703,
0.18190191686153412,
0.3924387991428375,
-0.14227762818336487,
0.44938352704048157,
-0.275189608335495,
0.005786694586277008,
-1.1849483251571655,
0.24262312054634094,
0.07454946637153625,
-0.1907908320426941,
-0.5134688019752502,
0.2052375227212906,
0.03873854875564575,
-0.8696856498718262,
-0.3345511555671692,
0.8179215788841248,
-0.5995011925697327,
-0.3384799659252167,
-0.7165137529373169,
0.528346061706543,
-0.14296387135982513,
-0.049375612288713455,
0.34850576519966125,
0.712941586971283,
0.7495696544647217,
-0.5193759202957153,
0.298794150352478,
0.166795015335083,
-0.3456372916698456,
0.07261298596858978,
-0.6456932425498962,
-0.055700697004795074,
-0.3022285997867584,
0.20582979917526245,
-1.1171001195907593,
-0.17071065306663513,
-0.2912346422672272,
-0.14038130640983582,
0.5133959650993347,
-0.16480745375156403,
-0.43579649925231934,
-0.552841305732727,
-0.30476877093315125,
-0.11039277166128159,
0.5385701060295105,
-0.5831883549690247,
0.4180986285209656,
0.6004756689071655,
-0.6286485195159912,
-0.42571523785591125,
-0.22496789693832397,
0.36406582593917847,
-0.7930424213409424,
-0.44523656368255615,
0.3969751298427582,
-0.058700673282146454,
-0.4675816297531128,
0.0023984271101653576,
0.21877650916576385,
0.06509235501289368,
0.2908707559108734,
0.2685706615447998,
0.2354651838541031,
-0.2340347319841385,
0.3849698007106781,
0.002435593865811825,
-0.2350369542837143,
-0.14162899553775787,
-0.24427352845668793,
0.8690106272697449,
0.14424432814121246,
-0.4461851418018341,
-0.19268669188022614,
0.6941520571708679,
0.5959764122962952,
-0.47018590569496155,
0.5872928500175476,
0.29795461893081665,
-0.5312407612800598,
-0.20484425127506256,
-0.5583125352859497,
-0.2977408766746521,
-0.4372307062149048,
0.4088762104511261,
-0.06564909219741821,
-1.2805262804031372,
0.4137481451034546,
-0.5712944269180298,
-0.028613291680812836,
0.4400908350944519,
0.7886204123497009,
0.11575783044099808,
0.5667301416397095,
0.8600555062294006,
-0.04246891662478447,
0.4177744388580322,
-0.06243205815553665,
0.3661258816719055,
-0.6716641187667847,
0.042210813611745834,
-0.7052868008613586,
0.16833853721618652,
-0.594717800617218,
-0.6895907521247864,
0.13181039690971375,
0.21742534637451172,
0.080085389316082,
0.14531157910823822,
-0.17434021830558777,
0.4558735489845276,
0.2379988580942154,
-0.17975370585918427,
0.2828337252140045,
0.19126729667186737,
0.26898592710494995,
0.10857781022787094,
-0.5613151788711548,
-1.044976830482483,
0.9697153568267822,
0.4896003007888794,
0.6804932355880737,
-0.06972536444664001,
0.6542611718177795,
0.2816314399242401,
0.44490644335746765,
-0.7794817090034485,
0.6157671213150024,
-0.45985111594200134,
-0.5453052520751953,
-0.764363706111908,
-0.3656373918056488,
-1.0760999917984009,
0.4747386872768402,
-0.29230979084968567,
-0.9283181428909302,
0.15377318859100342,
-0.4219675362110138,
-0.3187190294265747,
0.4131997525691986,
-0.340027391910553,
0.7360987663269043,
-0.06369046121835709,
-0.2581411898136139,
-0.23708570003509521,
-0.08010918647050858,
0.34903499484062195,
-0.7318088412284851,
0.24664773046970367,
-0.15308840572834015,
-0.06586164236068726,
0.8146158456802368,
-0.2562016546726227,
0.9770922064781189,
0.24148628115653992,
-0.6824770569801331,
0.41320666670799255,
-0.21954642236232758,
0.3158179521560669,
0.10353342443704605,
-0.35377368330955505,
-0.06058409810066223,
-0.41428864002227783,
-0.11962546408176422,
-0.4361470639705658,
1.0307929515838623,
-0.4627252519130707,
-0.9572170376777649,
-0.22054928541183472,
-0.570684015750885,
-0.28132981061935425,
0.28673896193504333,
-0.23115606606006622,
0.5250040292739868,
-0.4363957643508911,
0.29856887459754944,
0.6702566742897034,
-0.736239492893219,
0.588311493396759,
0.7588674426078796,
-0.5151622295379639,
0.0028129182755947113,
0.9270484447479248,
-0.2055065780878067,
0.010714657604694366,
0.4902638792991638,
0.3360866904258728,
-0.25251516699790955,
-0.6642264127731323,
-0.30986806750297546,
0.4263973832130432,
-0.6809279322624207,
0.036315761506557465,
-0.8151708841323853,
-0.04918995127081871,
-0.3092927038669586,
-0.25563761591911316,
-0.29633283615112305,
-0.04727626219391823,
-0.48116838932037354,
-0.21113288402557373,
0.3936643898487091,
0.7307363152503967,
-0.25161808729171753,
0.5178595185279846,
-0.6960507035255432,
0.37384867668151855,
0.39014869928359985,
0.05118566378951073,
0.12891407310962677,
-0.5661487579345703,
0.17040236294269562,
-0.23711231350898743,
-0.1025504544377327,
-0.8133062124252319,
0.630429744720459,
-0.32728832960128784,
0.588789165019989,
0.4729212522506714,
-0.13999897241592407,
0.2892395555973053,
-0.6942281126976013,
0.8252326846122742,
0.3051737844944,
-0.8665333390235901,
0.544482409954071,
-0.6375221014022827,
0.14291277527809143,
0.3176096975803375,
0.7366451025009155,
-0.48991769552230835,
-0.2898658514022827,
-0.47436219453811646,
-0.9780018329620361,
0.3719078600406647,
0.05515270680189133,
0.3291613459587097,
-0.26185616850852966,
0.33322831988334656,
0.3165763020515442,
0.41599082946777344,
-0.47071903944015503,
-0.02743125706911087,
0.48638811707496643,
0.12265083193778992,
-0.2896924614906311,
-0.5966999530792236,
-0.03344055265188217,
0.10604371875524521,
0.5231561660766602,
-0.007403501775115728,
0.20876169204711914,
-0.16965781152248383,
0.08381564915180206,
-0.19851338863372803,
0.5947569012641907,
0.4285760819911957,
1.0467787981033325,
-0.23335184156894684,
0.1854175329208374,
-0.03442366421222687,
0.19076520204544067,
0.008054851554334164,
0.10967060923576355,
-0.1203903928399086,
0.14368201792240143,
0.39859724044799805,
0.5269595980644226,
0.13206230103969574,
-0.9363328814506531,
0.4557654559612274,
0.018441352993249893,
-0.06859597563743591,
-0.20638705790042877,
-0.32401007413864136,
0.6462497115135193,
0.21275915205478668,
0.45938849449157715,
-0.7049152851104736,
-0.0336495004594326,
-1.0310932397842407,
0.4360100030899048,
0.6048310399055481,
-0.3959033191204071,
0.15108324587345123,
0.23994791507720947,
0.14006762206554413,
-0.28363725543022156,
0.340170294046402,
-0.11143091320991516,
-0.4645139276981354,
0.8501260876655579,
0.5435352325439453,
0.37383970618247986,
0.01688462123274803,
0.40854641795158386,
0.07819909602403641,
0.13092879951000214,
-0.20526757836341858,
0.04872285947203636,
0.37272512912750244,
-0.5559697151184082,
-0.6061738729476929,
-0.7257463932037354,
-0.4384075999259949,
0.38523849844932556,
-0.43762364983558655,
0.3556537330150604,
-0.04939347133040428,
0.07266928255558014,
0.3166446387767792,
-0.12682302296161652,
-0.15667739510536194,
0.07922012358903885,
0.24918562173843384,
0.8979191184043884,
-0.8444468379020691,
0.740925669670105,
0.5451663136482239,
-0.11267174780368805,
-0.3172568380832672,
0.17348669469356537,
-0.3809664845466614,
-0.4746817946434021,
0.6381187438964844,
0.2023548036813736,
0.24671868979930878,
-0.27636799216270447,
-0.44510164856910706,
-0.8714016079902649,
0.9314408302307129,
0.17517521977424622,
-0.7130666375160217,
-0.1498458981513977,
0.1045926883816719,
0.5466302633285522,
-0.5097900629043579,
0.1671145111322403,
0.3637365400791168,
0.4537886083126068,
0.21253058314323425,
-0.6214751601219177,
0.031674668192863464,
0.03424448147416115,
-0.07646153122186661,
0.39011678099632263,
-0.3825749456882477,
0.9961218237876892,
-0.039451614022254944,
0.028069790452718735,
0.31235840916633606,
0.7895220518112183,
0.23556657135486603,
0.18784010410308838,
0.4627719223499298,
0.15453475713729858,
0.87586510181427,
0.10822758078575134,
0.9408126473426819,
-0.223642498254776,
0.24855022132396698,
0.9205869436264038,
-0.6308349967002869,
0.7966757416725159,
0.4742879569530487,
0.09831376373767853,
0.17623834311962128,
0.7095937132835388,
0.008831995539367199,
0.5410011410713196,
0.5052131414413452,
-0.03685940057039261,
-0.5572229027748108,
-0.2006608098745346,
-0.4499122202396393,
0.5473180413246155,
0.6929724216461182,
-0.45008403062820435,
-0.4555206298828125,
0.09978210180997849,
-0.13384321331977844,
0.21911299228668213,
-0.37644141912460327,
0.673287034034729,
0.2351435273885727,
-0.6306199431419373,
0.2730262875556946,
0.28210151195526123,
0.856052041053772,
-0.6540866494178772,
-0.10439473390579224,
-0.22152262926101685,
-0.18663829565048218,
0.16150136291980743,
-0.6368797421455383,
0.2553068697452545,
0.3255344033241272,
-0.2016688734292984,
-0.1463615596294403,
1.027058720588684,
-0.5378413200378418,
-0.5805084705352783,
0.2986907958984375,
0.6740210652351379,
0.3370574712753296,
-0.14198662340641022,
-0.39223718643188477,
-0.013784234412014484,
-0.08203116804361343,
-0.06469278782606125,
0.6100881099700928,
0.884734034538269,
-0.22308804094791412,
0.6107170581817627,
0.6135472059249878,
0.09984767436981201,
-0.540132462978363,
-0.11081035435199738,
0.9982635378837585,
-0.8333392143249512,
-0.4843936264514923,
-0.8752687573432922,
0.16362270712852478,
-0.19209520518779755,
-0.08230504393577576,
0.6970483660697937,
0.49295151233673096,
0.26346567273139954,
-0.02953050471842289,
0.8039022088050842,
0.1867278516292572,
0.721279501914978,
-0.724590003490448,
0.623879611492157,
-0.7168897986412048,
0.5601584315299988,
-0.44042226672172546,
-0.7776526808738708,
-0.08384495228528976,
0.44272831082344055,
-0.489356130361557,
-0.18283173441886902,
0.6514191031455994,
0.7904242873191833,
-0.13941876590251923,
0.11936281621456146,
0.6359879970550537,
0.056852079927921295,
0.37616580724716187,
0.2338593304157257,
1.2147494554519653,
0.3144863545894623,
0.15788526833057404,
0.02514905296266079,
-0.35967394709587097,
-0.19760027527809143,
-1.1076340675354004,
-1.278056025505066,
-0.5727538466453552,
-0.1558699905872345,
0.051359448581933975,
0.09627038240432739,
0.6910454034805298,
0.4953973889350891,
-0.6952583193778992,
-0.28507474064826965,
0.13320279121398926,
0.3077540695667267,
0.351895272731781,
-0.13408400118350983,
0.565189003944397,
-0.221114382147789,
-0.6135619878768921,
0.665718138217926,
0.20169781148433685,
-0.014254319481551647,
-0.5736298561096191,
0.32033807039260864,
-0.19954952597618103,
0.14535091817378998,
0.6899282932281494,
0.05100412666797638,
-0.6487758159637451,
0.05150315910577774,
-0.16548219323158264,
-0.04699643701314926,
-0.16881239414215088,
1.1534918546676636,
-0.4323364794254303,
-0.16090163588523865,
0.3403262495994568,
0.8337761163711548,
0.5171319246292114,
-0.01243710145354271,
0.745965838432312,
-0.4032576382160187,
0.24071455001831055,
-0.08323068916797638,
0.556200385093689,
0.5040128827095032,
-0.1882263869047165,
0.4215654134750366,
-0.08583247661590576,
-0.22158870100975037,
-1.0003551244735718,
0.1796271950006485,
-0.877646267414093,
-0.9440388679504395,
1.5833349227905273,
-0.07526452839374542,
-0.19514288008213043,
0.011278577148914337,
-0.3067208230495453,
-0.05795641243457794,
-0.37580689787864685,
0.746247410774231,
0.6816498637199402,
0.3620756268501282,
0.017304589971899986,
-0.4823288321495056,
0.07750783115625381,
0.28480154275894165,
-1.0519828796386719,
0.4218214750289917,
0.5489354729652405,
0.12375500053167343,
0.37663334608078003,
0.5533945560455322,
-0.24423497915267944,
-0.18306967616081238,
-0.35894063115119934,
-0.11615558713674545,
0.3236044943332672,
-0.5250634551048279,
-0.4648495018482208,
0.4153393507003784,
0.2821390628814697,
0.4636021554470062
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16247v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16247v1
|
Improving Sequence-to-Sequence Models for Abstractive Text Summarization Using Meta Heuristic Approaches
| 2024-03-24T17:39:36 | 2024-03-24T17:39:36 |
Aditya Saxena, Ashutosh Ranjan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.NE
|
As human society transitions into the information age, reduction in our
attention span is a contingency, and people who spend time reading lengthy news
articles are decreasing rapidly and the need for succinct information is higher
than ever before. Therefore, it is essential to provide a quick overview of
important news by concisely summarizing the top news article and the most
intuitive headline. When humans try to make summaries, they extract the
essential information from the source and add useful phrases and grammatical
annotations from the original extract. Humans have a unique ability to create
abstractions. However, automatic summarization is a complicated problem to
solve. The use of sequence-to-sequence (seq2seq) models for neural abstractive
text summarization has been ascending as far as prevalence. Numerous innovative
strategies have been proposed to develop the current seq2seq models further,
permitting them to handle different issues like saliency, familiarity, and
human lucidness and create excellent synopses. In this article, we aimed toward
enhancing the present architectures and models for abstractive text
summarization. The modifications have been aimed at fine-tuning
hyper-parameters, attempting specific encoder-decoder combinations. We examined
many experiments on an extensively used CNN/DailyMail dataset to check the
effectiveness of various models.
|
[
-0.3560691475868225,
-0.6431989669799805,
0.38011184334754944,
0.2633671164512634,
-0.48707115650177,
-0.03984437137842178,
-0.10739564150571823,
-0.4000462591648102,
0.15783476829528809,
0.23395435512065887,
-0.29683005809783936,
-0.43148866295814514,
-0.6224662661552429,
0.3584200441837311,
-0.5810401439666748,
1.0557522773742676,
0.21821993589401245,
-0.26541396975517273,
-0.28294381499290466,
-0.11296860128641129,
-0.1420764923095703,
-0.4125153720378876,
-0.4517515003681183,
-0.13012844324111938,
0.2601509988307953,
0.4676307439804077,
0.5757518410682678,
0.6295595169067383,
0.33199819922447205,
0.20574034750461578,
-0.3885084092617035,
0.15893417596817017,
-0.2604673206806183,
0.007151031866669655,
-0.13254621624946594,
-0.12149203568696976,
-0.5779879689216614,
-0.23465687036514282,
0.49097195267677307,
0.7834326028823853,
-0.02621312439441681,
0.40047726035118103,
0.3085474669933319,
0.8666433095932007,
-0.7528784871101379,
-0.034049928188323975,
-0.3495432138442993,
0.08102946728467941,
0.06799142062664032,
-0.31251513957977295,
-0.296878844499588,
-0.3989643454551697,
0.2618478536605835,
-0.3954203724861145,
0.21433290839195251,
-0.24967236816883087,
0.5567222237586975,
0.30106911063194275,
-0.5168355703353882,
-0.12372444570064545,
-0.6959671378135681,
0.3335953652858734,
-1.0866996049880981,
0.12628641724586487,
0.21381109952926636,
0.1009315773844719,
0.22934164106845856,
-0.6115779876708984,
-0.23175404965877533,
-0.022297263145446777,
-0.1262132227420807,
0.2400933802127838,
0.07717785984277725,
-0.0077582839876413345,
0.24442128837108612,
0.07096688449382782,
-0.6129503846168518,
-0.14342454075813293,
-0.5126993060112,
0.020377224311232567,
0.7445374131202698,
0.4033120274543762,
0.10457644611597061,
-0.35221707820892334,
-0.13564898073673248,
0.335350900888443,
-0.4347322881221771,
0.06670746952295303,
0.3384546637535095,
-0.0013550407020375133,
0.04985432326793671,
0.507892906665802,
-0.6088642477989197,
0.6976085305213928,
0.21992263197898865,
0.11868739873170853,
0.25262248516082764,
-0.5701342225074768,
-0.06215144321322441,
0.07524604350328445,
0.5974686145782471,
0.7676532864570618,
0.26735925674438477,
-0.18509438633918762,
-0.15181612968444824,
-0.07867858558893204,
0.14413495361804962,
-0.8638709783554077,
-0.020546238869428635,
0.3539291024208069,
-0.7196376323699951,
-0.43499425053596497,
-0.09524085372686386,
-0.9040169715881348,
-0.13995423913002014,
-0.44118818640708923,
0.38664817810058594,
-0.2966221570968628,
-0.1479133814573288,
0.2409140169620514,
-0.33580482006073,
0.0902523398399353,
0.23403245210647583,
-0.9747565984725952,
0.276265025138855,
0.49344754219055176,
0.875022292137146,
-0.2287982702255249,
-0.09465529769659042,
-0.20238326489925385,
0.3345896899700165,
-0.19380241632461548,
0.7282968163490295,
-0.43770840764045715,
-0.17034272849559784,
-0.2012586146593094,
-0.2833276689052582,
-0.10122669488191605,
-0.2260490357875824,
0.5029121041297913,
-0.5198848247528076,
0.32752832770347595,
-0.16206182539463043,
-0.49373430013656616,
-0.3648819327354431,
0.4318851828575134,
-0.6258633136749268,
0.6588957905769348,
-0.17473071813583374,
-0.903579592704773,
-0.17628833651542664,
-0.8032492399215698,
-0.8973151445388794,
-0.3323007822036743,
0.15816688537597656,
-0.48801788687705994,
0.41935381293296814,
0.47728127241134644,
0.4502617120742798,
-0.1343936175107956,
0.30283865332603455,
0.14705131947994232,
-0.36827459931373596,
0.060734935104846954,
-0.3169953227043152,
0.5407853722572327,
0.17268379032611847,
-0.25519272685050964,
0.24035266041755676,
-0.8050201535224915,
0.054456111043691635,
-0.05167343094944954,
-0.3390904366970062,
-0.4053744375705719,
0.14032027125358582,
0.06682365387678146,
0.24775226414203644,
0.21272586286067963,
0.00996609590947628,
-0.09761986881494522,
-0.6096798777580261,
0.7873965501785278,
0.323032021522522,
0.3619316816329956,
0.5707790851593018,
-0.3338238596916199,
0.2591543197631836,
0.13362626731395721,
0.07433078438043594,
-0.860072910785675,
-0.3091302216053009,
-0.41925108432769775,
0.005444368813186884,
0.5197950601577759,
0.7699218988418579,
-0.42611828446388245,
0.45942506194114685,
-0.3437988758087158,
-0.2522487938404083,
-0.15542900562286377,
-0.21578258275985718,
0.25328874588012695,
0.4790267050266266,
0.4130687713623047,
-0.3795619308948517,
-0.6300897598266602,
-0.665349006652832,
-0.4666472375392914,
0.24017535150051117,
-0.11093594878911972,
0.02471136674284935,
0.4297754168510437,
-0.1704639345407486,
0.7859963178634644,
-0.40993669629096985,
0.04448894411325455,
-0.369755357503891,
0.3245478570461273,
0.30733954906463623,
0.47877493500709534,
0.22466595470905304,
-0.795386791229248,
-0.1948203444480896,
-0.4707711637020111,
-0.7226680517196655,
0.10405737906694412,
-0.22288863360881805,
-0.010825187899172306,
0.21682780981063843,
0.7826864719390869,
-0.7064299583435059,
0.6571673154830933,
0.10555773973464966,
-0.3768138289451599,
0.5945336222648621,
-0.196557879447937,
0.10696283727884293,
-1.4194514751434326,
0.3179952800273895,
0.051841795444488525,
-0.2366524487733841,
-0.6226602792739868,
0.1384425014257431,
0.10672954469919205,
-0.1145758256316185,
-0.2317183017730713,
0.31430476903915405,
-0.5719407200813293,
-0.3248426020145416,
-0.38115811347961426,
-0.11223883181810379,
0.004433424677699804,
0.5538512468338013,
0.016281049698591232,
0.5407844185829163,
0.12789121270179749,
-0.8598595857620239,
-0.017479190602898598,
0.2617757320404053,
-0.14310985803604126,
0.18352888524532318,
-1.0619738101959229,
-0.14139103889465332,
-0.6021826267242432,
0.4360191226005554,
-1.1230189800262451,
-0.3293200433254242,
0.1929396092891693,
-0.5370836853981018,
0.11229348927736282,
0.1422082483768463,
-0.30681103467941284,
-0.1154823824763298,
-0.6085307002067566,
0.8171778321266174,
0.6505779027938843,
-0.08915716409683228,
0.6358678936958313,
0.15991443395614624,
-0.46272164583206177,
-0.5489170551300049,
-0.5111939311027527,
0.500067412853241,
-0.03829196095466614,
-0.5815820693969727,
0.7578082084655762,
0.043379105627536774,
-0.09999926388263702,
0.21766334772109985,
-0.10888558626174927,
0.05416332557797432,
0.07439479976892471,
-0.0012863407609984279,
0.1706324964761734,
-0.1610228270292282,
0.051475513726472855,
0.2473604828119278,
-0.37223953008651733,
0.023486685007810593,
-0.3519553244113922,
0.31813710927963257,
0.01870708540081978,
0.07242831587791443,
-0.6399325132369995,
0.5796234607696533,
0.6952679753303528,
-0.5491077899932861,
0.43731260299682617,
0.5265503525733948,
-0.5795086622238159,
0.29351332783699036,
-0.3191714286804199,
-0.49668627977371216,
-0.3247285485267639,
0.7114589214324951,
-0.1955796629190445,
-0.5813716650009155,
0.49735888838768005,
-0.20378343760967255,
0.19937776029109955,
0.4021104574203491,
0.49838685989379883,
-0.2208268940448761,
1.1101435422897339,
0.4567963778972626,
-0.09258296340703964,
0.42949825525283813,
-0.30765101313591003,
-0.12953276932239532,
-0.9240471124649048,
-0.06379768997430801,
-0.1985955387353897,
-0.4661889374256134,
-0.2338375449180603,
-0.1453908234834671,
0.4316180348396301,
-0.02908191829919815,
-0.055367160588502884,
0.2688860297203064,
-0.3973558843135834,
0.734348475933075,
0.4252137541770935,
0.19519218802452087,
0.5077138543128967,
0.05243030562996864,
0.06740887463092804,
0.14438872039318085,
-0.7396742701530457,
-0.45519015192985535,
1.0362329483032227,
0.33150774240493774,
0.5203928351402283,
0.07544311136007309,
0.566293478012085,
0.3734598457813263,
-0.11749634891748428,
-0.620340883731842,
0.5435043573379517,
-0.33412352204322815,
-0.35058802366256714,
-0.4492783546447754,
-0.19651226699352264,
-0.7283374071121216,
0.09897911548614502,
-0.1831289380788803,
-0.45766308903694153,
0.27037954330444336,
0.30217015743255615,
-0.8354074954986572,
-0.16789942979812622,
-0.34433111548423767,
0.8653567433357239,
0.025452198460698128,
-0.29571688175201416,
-0.2693882882595062,
-1.0465213060379028,
0.4784435033798218,
0.3645547032356262,
0.18204617500305176,
-0.021669136360287666,
-0.36815178394317627,
0.5806543231010437,
-0.269466757774353,
0.8945304155349731,
0.15026602149009705,
0.022095076739788055,
0.2150992453098297,
-0.19410128891468048,
0.49272775650024414,
0.1116470918059349,
0.040794145315885544,
-0.03153679519891739,
-0.26655223965644836,
-0.4565158486366272,
-0.5343127250671387,
0.2091643214225769,
-0.5954738259315491,
-0.3781202733516693,
-0.26817330718040466,
-0.4854506552219391,
-0.045614056289196014,
0.01471257209777832,
0.6832877993583679,
0.7571612596511841,
-0.2042020559310913,
-0.11919405311346054,
0.7980741262435913,
0.004841940011829138,
0.8176834583282471,
0.15070490539073944,
0.11500074714422226,
-0.6923425793647766,
0.614173412322998,
0.08224911242723465,
0.18202774226665497,
0.4053595960140228,
-0.0040820869617164135,
-0.2422400265932083,
-0.7671974897384644,
-0.461186021566391,
0.042054615914821625,
-0.6263887286186218,
-0.1899840086698532,
-0.8351183533668518,
-0.44462621212005615,
-0.5359634757041931,
-0.02299460768699646,
-0.02449597790837288,
-0.9123867154121399,
-0.4466274380683899,
-0.06619983166456223,
0.08083880692720413,
0.43102240562438965,
0.04293261840939522,
0.09712254256010056,
-1.1330218315124512,
0.5679259896278381,
0.26557037234306335,
0.07055722177028656,
0.08772339671850204,
-0.7070445418357849,
-0.31985145807266235,
-0.0502559095621109,
-0.2369159460067749,
-1.0361641645431519,
0.3748312294483185,
0.4104323387145996,
0.2993113100528717,
0.2275688797235489,
0.10092558711767197,
0.4553462266921997,
-0.6020665764808655,
0.5150882601737976,
0.03878781199455261,
-0.8780818581581116,
0.5381758809089661,
-0.49816450476646423,
0.6458730697631836,
0.5697996616363525,
0.3694444000720978,
-0.5961297750473022,
-0.15953221917152405,
-0.40389296412467957,
-1.1356247663497925,
0.420172780752182,
0.31171277165412903,
0.258391797542572,
0.04250971972942352,
0.6273635029792786,
0.038020774722099304,
0.25801974534988403,
-0.4039236009120941,
0.06750314682722092,
-0.4179909825325012,
-0.6962242126464844,
-0.10908321291208267,
-0.5211221575737,
0.10991106927394867,
-0.2470700591802597,
0.6078082919120789,
-0.15480290353298187,
0.20226959884166718,
0.3179519474506378,
-0.3179634213447571,
0.0772147998213768,
0.3889845907688141,
1.0341558456420898,
0.677942156791687,
-0.040121033787727356,
0.14272911846637726,
0.11517956107854843,
-0.4178856909275055,
0.1257370412349701,
0.216940239071846,
-0.4832189381122589,
0.1452549397945404,
0.30126702785491943,
0.6337486505508423,
0.38495901226997375,
-0.6575502157211304,
0.5674170255661011,
0.0350392684340477,
-0.2549034655094147,
-0.36430445313453674,
-0.01952528953552246,
0.19470934569835663,
0.3584231436252594,
0.4383486211299896,
0.47985148429870605,
0.7639795541763306,
-0.5625333786010742,
0.19930855929851532,
0.14598454535007477,
-0.11072558164596558,
-0.48965537548065186,
0.7823652029037476,
0.6430627703666687,
-0.2684668004512787,
0.3922310173511505,
-0.2917865216732025,
-0.573738694190979,
0.7531866431236267,
0.5603174567222595,
1.1201575994491577,
-0.10820210725069046,
0.10310982167720795,
0.6738656759262085,
0.26775601506233215,
-0.463452011346817,
0.23965005576610565,
-0.12722431123256683,
-0.40881624817848206,
-0.5994806289672852,
-0.19085846841335297,
-0.15729933977127075,
-0.15630492568016052,
-0.5494075417518616,
0.1991005837917328,
-0.2721947133541107,
-0.16730113327503204,
-0.011565806344151497,
-0.3993498980998993,
-0.19900020956993103,
0.049956489354372025,
0.052656449377536774,
0.9898770451545715,
-0.7013831734657288,
0.2605080306529999,
0.6177911162376404,
-0.30367690324783325,
-0.07061026245355606,
0.42321866750717163,
-0.16693706810474396,
-0.2828197479248047,
0.32862231135368347,
0.3619794249534607,
0.3179740607738495,
0.3876430094242096,
-0.3225178122520447,
-0.7515319585800171,
1.1136868000030518,
0.013912567868828773,
-0.6812819242477417,
-0.4990050196647644,
0.04883836582303047,
0.3608165383338928,
-0.3228042721748352,
0.20399907231330872,
0.5859845280647278,
0.3592044413089752,
0.1636800318956375,
-0.5859431028366089,
0.1363154500722885,
-0.4162363111972809,
0.17102093994617462,
0.3578953444957733,
-0.4569188058376312,
0.8485651016235352,
-0.7128005623817444,
-0.08250238746404648,
0.18364886939525604,
0.7287663817405701,
0.11221080273389816,
0.6599317789077759,
0.27476319670677185,
0.7282935976982117,
0.33039379119873047,
0.26631730794906616,
0.7461023926734924,
-0.43089357018470764,
0.11327256262302399,
1.3210712671279907,
0.046557869762182236,
0.8361876010894775,
0.2493606060743332,
0.21763719618320465,
0.3160723149776459,
0.6287633776664734,
0.10865449905395508,
0.7042250037193298,
-0.01545779313892126,
-0.19354090094566345,
-0.13983838260173798,
0.20334845781326294,
-0.2879299521446228,
0.30025091767311096,
0.41369161009788513,
-0.5745108127593994,
-0.3356580138206482,
0.08485396206378937,
-0.1266498565673828,
0.1515320986509323,
-0.42717882990837097,
1.1677135229110718,
-0.03352334722876549,
-0.7888813614845276,
0.37773942947387695,
0.3412841558456421,
0.7017049789428711,
-0.13630850613117218,
0.05547332018613815,
-0.25263625383377075,
0.0011722010094672441,
-0.33494052290916443,
-0.3637303113937378,
0.4607488811016083,
-0.038672346621751785,
-0.4084154963493347,
0.19330544769763947,
0.8793001174926758,
-0.6672757863998413,
-0.5169374346733093,
-0.3394336998462677,
0.551406741142273,
-0.12670449912548065,
-0.32216277718544006,
-0.48118993639945984,
-0.20707003772258759,
-0.2583447992801666,
-0.23673418164253235,
0.0217676293104887,
0.30736273527145386,
-0.025029566138982773,
0.24378807842731476,
0.44240981340408325,
-0.26452308893203735,
-0.11212820559740067,
0.04657959192991257,
0.5977493524551392,
-0.9846358299255371,
-0.8165419697761536,
-1.1867374181747437,
0.7073134183883667,
-0.25507059693336487,
-0.24427036941051483,
0.456245481967926,
0.6395599246025085,
0.22909483313560486,
-0.24182941019535065,
0.8922032713890076,
0.13879571855068207,
0.3403819799423218,
-0.5747518539428711,
0.5924821496009827,
-0.29040461778640747,
0.20449219644069672,
-0.21078823506832123,
-0.9103932976722717,
-0.2773248851299286,
0.42254573106765747,
-0.0177440382540226,
0.09270592778921127,
0.5771694779396057,
0.49113035202026367,
0.028443433344364166,
0.21692827343940735,
0.09060230851173401,
0.011430798098444939,
-0.06158134713768959,
0.7436121702194214,
0.7627114057540894,
-0.7256287932395935,
0.5565401315689087,
0.03062940575182438,
-0.13441972434520721,
-0.7920324802398682,
-1.0421667098999023,
-0.9081001281738281,
-0.6612447500228882,
-0.460052490234375,
-0.14027424156665802,
0.46262049674987793,
1.0777323246002197,
0.6273916363716125,
-0.5854373574256897,
-0.0038592838682234287,
-0.3754632771015167,
0.05760720744729042,
-0.3025149405002594,
-0.16481924057006836,
0.3509243130683899,
-0.4663255512714386,
-0.510597288608551,
-0.07256926596164703,
0.2989485263824463,
0.4033673107624054,
0.007478900719434023,
0.0867714136838913,
-0.0005746242241002619,
0.2680452764034271,
0.8526087403297424,
0.34173017740249634,
-0.4236145317554474,
0.00048708272515796125,
0.18173064291477203,
-0.2140900194644928,
-0.008226840756833553,
0.8470091223716736,
-0.8012369275093079,
-0.04313089698553085,
0.8314191102981567,
0.838410496711731,
0.3508260250091553,
0.2972775995731354,
0.5274285674095154,
-0.697561502456665,
-0.03520209342241287,
0.24380238354206085,
0.11259829998016357,
0.20701754093170166,
-0.37294280529022217,
0.540006697177887,
0.1724155843257904,
-0.4045662581920624,
-0.5569296479225159,
0.09095626324415207,
-0.6644930243492126,
-0.39137768745422363,
1.0243686437606812,
0.23782317340373993,
-0.2804064154624939,
-0.07778336852788925,
-0.24181199073791504,
0.23771487176418304,
-0.3452202379703522,
1.0457863807678223,
0.4622941315174103,
-0.19893679022789001,
-0.3363027572631836,
-0.32717466354370117,
0.6517781615257263,
0.30656057596206665,
-1.1628059148788452,
0.06379904597997665,
0.44592151045799255,
0.2761344909667969,
0.09121948480606079,
0.6199756860733032,
-0.10750862210988998,
0.7626970410346985,
-0.2518298029899597,
-0.08024634420871735,
-0.30912062525749207,
-0.4660203754901886,
-0.43665066361427307,
0.31610774993896484,
-0.36917275190353394,
-0.2957741320133209
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16204v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16204v1
|
SQL-Encoder: Improving NL2SQL In-Context Learning Through a Context-Aware Encoder
| 2024-03-24T15:57:24 | 2024-03-24T15:57:24 |
Mohammadreza Pourreza, Davood Rafiei, Yuxi Feng, Raymond Li, Zhenan Fan, Weiwei Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.DB, cs.HC
|
Detecting structural similarity between queries is essential for selecting
examples in in-context learning models. However, assessing structural
similarity based solely on the natural language expressions of queries, without
considering SQL queries, presents a significant challenge. This paper explores
the significance of this similarity metric and proposes a model for accurately
estimating it. To achieve this, we leverage a dataset comprising 170k question
pairs, meticulously curated to train a similarity prediction model. Our
comprehensive evaluation demonstrates that the proposed model adeptly captures
the structural similarity between questions, as evidenced by improvements in
Kendall-Tau distance and precision@k metrics. Notably, our model outperforms
strong competitive embedding models from OpenAI and Cohere. Furthermore,
compared to these competitive models, our proposed encoder enhances the
downstream performance of NL2SQL models in 1-shot in-context learning scenarios
by 1-2\% for GPT-3.5-turbo, 4-8\% for CodeLlama-7B, and 2-3\% for
CodeLlama-13B.
|
[
-0.06052883341908455,
-0.7853301763534546,
0.20628990232944489,
-0.019056912511587143,
-0.4104534983634949,
-0.1195852980017662,
0.0034037616569548845,
-0.37045180797576904,
0.3084212839603424,
0.476411372423172,
-0.2287457138299942,
-0.4462692141532898,
-0.2874296009540558,
0.16310474276542664,
-0.5530862212181091,
0.5394569635391235,
0.19409917294979095,
0.3377552032470703,
-0.5783615708351135,
-0.24086391925811768,
-0.499846875667572,
-0.4735395312309265,
-0.7171922326087952,
0.006875016260892153,
-0.07920471578836441,
-0.13771604001522064,
0.37373974919319153,
0.43734678626060486,
0.3860227167606354,
0.15544961392879486,
-0.3746875822544098,
0.26286470890045166,
-0.6368352770805359,
0.3375786542892456,
-0.291642427444458,
-0.6978071331977844,
-0.11659498512744904,
-0.42628979682922363,
0.6564276814460754,
0.8797241449356079,
-0.24497148394584656,
0.3122326731681824,
0.5784350633621216,
0.9020054340362549,
-0.3630378842353821,
0.18038862943649292,
-1.0425969362258911,
0.34897610545158386,
-0.02121128886938095,
-0.05372459068894386,
-0.318115770816803,
-0.6539425253868103,
0.0960245430469513,
-0.3969396650791168,
0.20660069584846497,
0.37066999077796936,
0.8045545816421509,
0.42849552631378174,
-0.5806767344474792,
-0.23345328867435455,
-0.11532065272331238,
0.40980181097984314,
-0.4952912926673889,
0.677494466304779,
0.4984261989593506,
0.41086214780807495,
-0.25370877981185913,
-0.4146673381328583,
-0.4584783613681793,
0.07374744862318039,
-0.31755557656288147,
0.16691496968269348,
0.09144734591245651,
-0.127092644572258,
0.21825458109378815,
0.2343001812696457,
-0.9854463934898376,
-0.06609693169593811,
-0.41183391213417053,
0.043702367693185806,
0.25212839245796204,
0.22029539942741394,
-0.1172991693019867,
-0.32067805528640747,
-0.36725765466690063,
0.038772474974393845,
-0.8178145289421082,
0.21760866045951843,
0.10810933262109756,
0.3402114510536194,
0.001570435706526041,
0.47982197999954224,
-0.19129903614521027,
0.8179675936698914,
0.09277725219726562,
0.24480684101581573,
0.289499968290329,
-0.24406754970550537,
-0.2104155719280243,
0.13978800177574158,
0.5071963667869568,
0.5540431141853333,
0.15467919409275055,
-0.4199817478656769,
-0.02811574377119541,
-0.04619884863495827,
0.4224124252796173,
-0.7909078001976013,
-0.11749118566513062,
0.16190922260284424,
-0.41961243748664856,
0.10153598338365555,
0.22434842586517334,
-0.6091603636741638,
-0.2659073770046234,
-0.318771094083786,
0.26009899377822876,
-0.5211905241012573,
-0.10558075457811356,
-0.022843169048428535,
-0.22982558608055115,
0.6728366017341614,
0.01053382083773613,
-0.6312307715415955,
0.3912777602672577,
0.8841894865036011,
0.8803799152374268,
-0.3621452748775482,
0.1067349836230278,
-0.3245845139026642,
0.21272090077400208,
-0.5164170861244202,
0.5598209500312805,
-0.5926740169525146,
-0.26463526487350464,
0.007767840754240751,
0.060944560915231705,
-0.1213572770357132,
-0.7444318532943726,
0.16537001729011536,
-0.7227733135223389,
0.20114420354366302,
-0.47772493958473206,
-0.9159419536590576,
-0.06698011606931686,
0.7225104570388794,
-0.6851022243499756,
1.445508599281311,
0.310798317193985,
-0.6441769599914551,
0.6450694799423218,
-0.501417875289917,
-0.2688332498073578,
0.23030424118041992,
-0.3202823996543884,
-0.4415901303291321,
0.05170457437634468,
0.08210692554712296,
0.2923544645309448,
-0.34146958589553833,
0.318515807390213,
-0.34348028898239136,
-0.6820945143699646,
0.20157234370708466,
0.0895397737622261,
0.7021054625511169,
0.024881945922970772,
-0.08207173645496368,
-0.014098657295107841,
-0.48165205121040344,
0.16151411831378937,
0.029026782140135765,
-0.34488484263420105,
-0.6166456937789917,
-0.13240426778793335,
-0.2036004662513733,
0.07028231769800186,
-0.029263827949762344,
-0.6233973503112793,
-0.17045417428016663,
-0.9412034749984741,
0.31767359375953674,
0.33008018136024475,
0.16691471636295319,
0.6670412421226501,
-0.04392683133482933,
0.4369295835494995,
-0.04945645108819008,
-0.03277995064854622,
0.12032437324523926,
-0.4091581404209137,
-0.3124937415122986,
0.030467823147773743,
0.29081323742866516,
0.4102376699447632,
-0.5758242607116699,
0.5349708795547485,
-0.4943632483482361,
-0.46243688464164734,
-0.4655741751194,
0.034117989242076874,
0.52745121717453,
0.7770273685455322,
0.6825355291366577,
-0.49638572335243225,
-0.6709774136543274,
-0.8184167742729187,
-0.7087702751159668,
-0.006369411014020443,
-0.32591500878334045,
0.4067747890949249,
0.5454090237617493,
0.12409782409667969,
0.981411337852478,
-0.4212324321269989,
-0.5100420117378235,
-0.00107725546695292,
-0.4088824391365051,
0.08925053477287292,
0.5911622643470764,
0.6564609408378601,
-0.6267189979553223,
-0.8573443293571472,
-0.10874608904123306,
-0.9871883988380432,
0.4350025951862335,
0.2979937195777893,
-0.17443373799324036,
0.2466048300266266,
0.7261953949928284,
-0.4794658422470093,
0.27666136622428894,
0.08616824448108673,
-0.3430728316307068,
0.1822998821735382,
0.10989624261856079,
0.08299022912979126,
-1.370868444442749,
-0.0995318740606308,
-0.09895908087491989,
0.06181946024298668,
-0.37409281730651855,
0.22440750896930695,
0.3651588559150696,
-0.18255338072776794,
-0.34464365243911743,
0.5325417518615723,
-0.37027421593666077,
-0.3167859613895416,
0.2817114293575287,
0.12989503145217896,
0.11873015016317368,
0.4805178940296173,
-0.0054894317872822285,
0.7847515344619751,
0.5848143696784973,
-0.41615554690361023,
0.11985591799020767,
0.5174612998962402,
-0.7022657990455627,
0.7635549902915955,
-0.834002673625946,
0.329157292842865,
-0.20058004558086395,
0.44028905034065247,
-0.9816835522651672,
-0.16924455761909485,
-0.03835903853178024,
-0.511856734752655,
0.1087355837225914,
-0.4640255570411682,
-0.39683589339256287,
-0.24855461716651917,
-0.3655484914779663,
0.33112820982933044,
0.42215386033058167,
-0.6607018709182739,
0.6550101637840271,
0.3781171143054962,
0.006853053811937571,
-0.5999079346656799,
-0.9001237154006958,
-0.10009631514549255,
-0.3066330850124359,
-0.3344477415084839,
0.5233467221260071,
0.3505082428455353,
0.12482760846614838,
0.15411406755447388,
-0.2940771281719208,
-0.3126334249973297,
0.02896207384765148,
0.3271481990814209,
0.03999074175953865,
-0.4163438677787781,
0.4750473201274872,
0.4187418222427368,
0.3153236210346222,
0.23960764706134796,
-0.5099685192108154,
0.5088759064674377,
-0.32848867774009705,
-0.28749486804008484,
-0.0428318977355957,
0.22193972766399384,
0.09017403423786163,
-0.405765563249588,
0.9125499129295349,
0.43938854336738586,
-0.586090087890625,
-0.07480094581842422,
-0.44359955191612244,
-0.4584357738494873,
-0.48801568150520325,
0.6871813535690308,
-0.5873450040817261,
-1.0732779502868652,
0.4459095299243927,
0.0019181875977665186,
-0.312749981880188,
0.2545188069343567,
0.09008640050888062,
-0.30215078592300415,
0.7185543179512024,
0.3076784908771515,
0.054740242660045624,
0.28385618329048157,
-0.32437339425086975,
0.15681757032871246,
-0.9158821105957031,
-0.8194631338119507,
-0.5373571515083313,
-0.277614563703537,
-0.34219756722450256,
-0.5515235066413879,
0.3668149411678314,
0.17012420296669006,
-0.5262642502784729,
0.6627047061920166,
-0.4858150780200958,
0.8322132229804993,
0.17448464035987854,
0.16517594456672668,
-0.11844722926616669,
0.338154673576355,
-0.21839338541030884,
-0.1871415674686432,
-0.7241144776344299,
-0.16245923936367035,
0.9752349853515625,
0.009915795177221298,
0.4747731685638428,
0.34142500162124634,
0.657153308391571,
0.13538578152656555,
-0.013541658408939838,
-0.6179145574569702,
0.48847049474716187,
-0.10593359172344208,
-0.5972582101821899,
-0.2863054573535919,
-0.4482998549938202,
-0.7831149101257324,
0.23159082233905792,
-0.22298936545848846,
-0.4139464497566223,
0.2142498940229416,
-0.11102298647165298,
-0.27728331089019775,
0.07179728895425797,
-0.42067813873291016,
0.9495570659637451,
-0.0771462693810463,
-0.3736312985420227,
-0.10919079184532166,
-0.6334922313690186,
-0.07357519865036011,
-0.0688532218337059,
-0.11651135981082916,
0.03931741416454315,
-0.14450529217720032,
0.8034917712211609,
-0.046128254383802414,
0.6086843013763428,
-0.44207850098609924,
0.2608541250228882,
0.36132603883743286,
0.34405118227005005,
0.17459054291248322,
0.028395961970090866,
-0.48751240968704224,
0.10952507704496384,
0.18286556005477905,
-0.39556509256362915,
-0.795133650302887,
0.5595250129699707,
-0.2669884264469147,
-0.2082892656326294,
-0.10375398397445679,
-0.18320854008197784,
-0.2522544860839844,
-0.1157212108373642,
0.13205187022686005,
0.6579399108886719,
-0.34421417117118835,
0.6854844689369202,
0.5575569272041321,
-0.03123786859214306,
0.17929492890834808,
0.3430223762989044,
0.02973482944071293,
-0.08632570505142212,
0.5620182156562805,
0.04591377452015877,
-0.07912169396877289,
0.6097712516784668,
-0.022122051566839218,
-0.8066930174827576,
-0.3913058042526245,
-0.4024624526500702,
-0.05394253134727478,
-0.7016808390617371,
-0.6855382323265076,
-0.6920419931411743,
-0.09736258536577225,
-0.2935451865196228,
-0.16049239039421082,
-0.2808704376220703,
-0.3372488021850586,
-0.13207712769508362,
-0.3623087704181671,
0.44784054160118103,
0.5102761387825012,
0.6139863133430481,
0.06988292932510376,
-0.45299428701400757,
-0.14112825691699982,
0.18525010347366333,
0.6018607020378113,
0.0602237731218338,
-0.8705514073371887,
-0.252041757106781,
-0.007582083810120821,
-0.07649669051170349,
-0.86920565366745,
0.3707287907600403,
0.8353858590126038,
0.5451766848564148,
0.1846388727426529,
0.08606250584125519,
0.7542343139648438,
-0.46189194917678833,
0.842820405960083,
-0.0737968310713768,
-0.7150441408157349,
0.7262774109840393,
0.12444725632667542,
0.17550455033779144,
0.9585492014884949,
0.7730032205581665,
-0.1948436051607132,
-0.16407695412635803,
-0.1027427539229393,
-0.6188125014305115,
0.3904482424259186,
-0.08255302160978317,
0.2471938580274582,
-0.48267948627471924,
0.767037034034729,
0.0723513662815094,
-0.007011812645941973,
-0.6195865869522095,
0.12637342512607574,
-0.3284982144832611,
-0.49227502942085266,
0.3808485269546509,
-0.16591256856918335,
0.1661309152841568,
-0.5130084156990051,
0.3195890188217163,
-0.48973309993743896,
0.3291068375110626,
0.15841104090213776,
-0.40456873178482056,
0.11877795308828354,
0.1615578979253769,
0.03264767304062843,
0.385360985994339,
-0.4185412526130676,
0.035269416868686676,
0.8146725296974182,
-0.2696371376514435,
-0.15662182867527008,
-0.0047125122509896755,
-0.11881102621555328,
-0.07792408019304276,
0.22151252627372742,
0.6233919262886047,
0.38981106877326965,
-0.8125420212745667,
0.5614227652549744,
-0.13939033448696136,
-0.023355957120656967,
-0.2706931233406067,
-0.042987506836652756,
0.23062168061733246,
0.2633180022239685,
0.21391956508159637,
-0.014329618774354458,
0.42816847562789917,
-0.589242696762085,
0.24263721704483032,
0.617255687713623,
-0.983493983745575,
-0.17218799889087677,
0.6398503184318542,
0.03448246791958809,
-0.3805306553840637,
0.8129114508628845,
-0.38756072521209717,
-0.7876200675964355,
0.7032896280288696,
0.7034708261489868,
0.5074160695075989,
-0.258154034614563,
-0.2570405900478363,
0.9489823579788208,
0.0771811306476593,
-0.09651798754930496,
0.504595935344696,
-0.20739950239658356,
-0.6427834630012512,
-0.013971906155347824,
-0.8792160153388977,
-0.17963838577270508,
-0.3794787526130676,
-0.9872803092002869,
0.13253167271614075,
-0.31173306703567505,
0.0770905390381813,
-0.37842506170272827,
-0.05871915444731712,
-0.6627301573753357,
0.1420327126979828,
-0.28451213240623474,
0.8805242776870728,
-0.6802628636360168,
1.0186705589294434,
0.6460757851600647,
-0.33495959639549255,
-0.7114647030830383,
-0.17926393449306488,
-0.09894652664661407,
-0.43282151222229004,
0.5002294182777405,
0.4548845589160919,
-0.00553479976952076,
-0.1423696130514145,
-0.14716005325317383,
-0.6496354341506958,
1.3701845407485962,
0.39560505747795105,
-0.525886058807373,
-0.07355620712041855,
0.27670732140541077,
0.7916120290756226,
-0.7095434665679932,
0.35456836223602295,
0.7192712426185608,
-0.12477374821901321,
-0.18967200815677643,
-0.666037917137146,
0.18538616597652435,
-0.25539156794548035,
0.14105932414531708,
0.21099403500556946,
-0.26119109988212585,
0.5210427045822144,
-0.09990010410547256,
-0.1732083261013031,
-0.08388669788837433,
0.6167043447494507,
0.1423138827085495,
0.2882435619831085,
0.36378735303878784,
0.39021918177604675,
0.7730589509010315,
-0.13492333889007568,
1.0592960119247437,
-0.32531726360321045,
0.337912917137146,
1.4678573608398438,
-0.4148949384689331,
1.2720131874084473,
0.3512764275074005,
-0.34220460057258606,
0.5849031805992126,
0.5306864380836487,
-0.17589986324310303,
0.5357399582862854,
0.08250586688518524,
0.19771808385849,
0.0276911873370409,
-0.08379024267196655,
-0.6213982701301575,
0.5959774255752563,
0.5323636531829834,
-0.42402681708335876,
-0.024321621283888817,
-0.26313304901123047,
-0.35477790236473083,
0.5098795294761658,
0.014569840393960476,
1.1010396480560303,
0.15880165994167328,
-0.5053999423980713,
0.6454067826271057,
-0.2233714610338211,
0.7151278257369995,
-0.4637930691242218,
0.03244210034608841,
-0.5575364828109741,
0.02132182940840721,
-0.056547414511442184,
-0.7522028088569641,
0.8735102415084839,
-0.09828553348779678,
0.02155701257288456,
0.15464597940444946,
0.5537782907485962,
-0.7734432220458984,
-0.1363341063261032,
0.577812910079956,
0.3403896987438202,
0.16751398146152496,
-0.45830899477005005,
-0.8617539405822754,
-0.2028966248035431,
-0.26063957810401917,
0.2250598669052124,
0.3694780468940735,
0.24308572709560394,
0.04508516937494278,
0.372570276260376,
0.32535043358802795,
-0.3135069012641907,
0.1181284487247467,
0.19908396899700165,
0.6337490081787109,
-0.5658334493637085,
-0.6013107895851135,
-0.6653120517730713,
-0.02972864732146263,
-0.3626870810985565,
-0.2955997586250305,
0.6729406714439392,
1.0842499732971191,
0.9530175924301147,
-0.30915072560310364,
0.1686573028564453,
0.12302936613559723,
0.4997350573539734,
-0.4632159173488617,
0.8854155540466309,
-0.6031349301338196,
0.2847663462162018,
0.0020464383997023106,
-1.3121851682662964,
-0.22751536965370178,
0.660301923751831,
-0.13772070407867432,
-0.1292838603258133,
0.6592255234718323,
1.2735108137130737,
-0.13413822650909424,
0.19470952451229095,
0.2077302783727646,
0.15180078148841858,
0.016201822087168694,
0.6075520515441895,
0.6776322722434998,
-0.696639358997345,
0.5032312273979187,
0.01673666201531887,
0.16775985062122345,
-0.14393667876720428,
-0.5130494832992554,
-1.0131844282150269,
-0.7822937965393066,
-0.22382621467113495,
-0.4242803156375885,
0.3460027873516083,
1.050079345703125,
0.637996256351471,
-0.9243423342704773,
-0.24670802056789398,
-0.03697272390127182,
-0.04254968464374542,
-0.3842000961303711,
-0.2262478768825531,
0.6731688976287842,
-0.1676841378211975,
-0.2259511500597,
0.4887428283691406,
0.2433650940656662,
-0.18533876538276672,
0.11310781538486481,
-0.13449546694755554,
-0.265043705701828,
0.2041940987110138,
0.8531976342201233,
-0.022425904870033264,
-0.8305957317352295,
-0.2978600859642029,
0.087137371301651,
-0.13887467980384827,
0.051778148859739304,
0.3998449146747589,
-0.9469762444496155,
0.3409404754638672,
0.4761904776096344,
0.9564806222915649,
0.7198663353919983,
0.0527409128844738,
0.2085680067539215,
-1.1986995935440063,
0.10984411090612411,
0.3129997253417969,
0.28158363699913025,
0.5456467270851135,
-0.4590066969394684,
0.8385049104690552,
-0.05472057685256004,
-0.13734452426433563,
-0.8390896916389465,
0.23030047118663788,
-0.8950401544570923,
-0.13274963200092316,
0.9065617918968201,
-0.14391368627548218,
-0.2461768090724945,
-0.36963382363319397,
0.10186056047677994,
0.14010998606681824,
-0.13068097829818726,
0.6895820498466492,
0.054161518812179565,
0.1390308290719986,
0.065053790807724,
-0.2430041879415512,
0.6160823702812195,
0.5521830320358276,
-0.6307187080383301,
-0.22732661664485931,
0.11100076138973236,
0.4063001573085785,
-0.1671987920999527,
0.26702919602394104,
-0.3770619034767151,
0.15155774354934692,
0.14816297590732574,
-0.1982380747795105,
-0.1156226173043251,
-0.1496594399213791,
-0.40177738666534424,
0.5456053018569946,
-0.2912420332431793,
0.008107122033834457
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16187v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16187v2
|
ALoRA: Allocating Low-Rank Adaptation for Fine-tuning Large Language Models
| 2024-03-24T15:09:55 | 2024-04-15T13:25:05 |
Zequan Liu, Jiawen Lyn, Wei Zhu, Xing Tian, Yvette Graham
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) is widely studied for its
effectiveness and efficiency in the era of large language models. Low-rank
adaptation (LoRA) has demonstrated commendable performance as a popular and
representative method. However, it is implemented with a fixed intrinsic rank
that might not be the ideal setting for the downstream tasks. Recognizing the
need for more flexible downstream task adaptation, we extend the methodology of
LoRA to an innovative approach we call allocating low-rank adaptation (ALoRA)
that enables dynamic adjustments to the intrinsic rank during the adaptation
process. First, we propose a novel method, AB-LoRA, that can effectively
estimate the importance score of each LoRA rank. Second, guided by AB-LoRA, we
gradually prune abundant and negatively impacting LoRA ranks and allocate the
pruned LoRA budgets to important Transformer modules needing higher ranks. We
have conducted experiments on various tasks, and the experimental results
demonstrate that our ALoRA method can outperform the recent baselines with
comparable tunable parameters.
|
[
-0.4261952340602875,
-0.884221613407135,
0.44219186902046204,
0.08972595632076263,
-0.10322112590074539,
0.041677240282297134,
-0.4461985230445862,
-0.3398219347000122,
0.1081896498799324,
0.3673751950263977,
-0.4073551893234253,
-0.2728833556175232,
-0.6235619187355042,
-0.10933429002761841,
-0.3071793019771576,
1.1082801818847656,
0.031019091606140137,
-0.5611879229545593,
0.33510512113571167,
-0.3157188296318054,
-0.5176581144332886,
-0.012571643106639385,
-0.8503310084342957,
-0.22470428049564362,
0.9102058410644531,
0.8682714700698853,
0.9247398972511292,
0.8389480710029602,
0.6094914674758911,
0.2405574470758438,
-0.08021294325590134,
0.07743075489997864,
-0.5983490943908691,
0.18409186601638794,
-0.525216817855835,
-0.5601003170013428,
-0.8746381998062134,
-0.2169700562953949,
0.825167179107666,
0.7906594276428223,
-0.19594453275203705,
0.38420024514198303,
0.0904296264052391,
0.7722275257110596,
-1.019482970237732,
-0.16707676649093628,
-1.1356240510940552,
-0.25355735421180725,
-0.33297619223594666,
-0.2893114984035492,
-0.40883833169937134,
-0.2741318941116333,
0.020319344475865364,
-0.8199161887168884,
-0.1613018661737442,
0.09196958690881729,
0.8318315148353577,
0.7504986524581909,
-0.15653984248638153,
-0.061250507831573486,
-0.9992327094078064,
0.780041515827179,
-0.5432119965553284,
0.30454328656196594,
0.3490850329399109,
0.24915015697479248,
0.18952874839305878,
-0.3284098505973816,
-0.24504061043262482,
-0.07908441871404648,
0.2650161683559418,
-0.020752310752868652,
-0.4498572051525116,
-0.035137295722961426,
0.0057721794582903385,
0.33345112204551697,
-0.1124853566288948,
0.511326253414154,
-0.4039989411830902,
0.0653529092669487,
0.3684225082397461,
-0.1855282485485077,
-0.07149311155080795,
0.2417910397052765,
-0.05391161888837814,
-0.38102883100509644,
-0.8480526804924011,
0.06141739711165428,
0.45363834500312805,
0.5788055658340454,
0.008217201568186283,
0.3190760910511017,
-0.280518114566803,
0.48313698172569275,
0.5202305912971497,
-0.09248543530702591,
0.10486304759979248,
0.0894273892045021,
-0.34096360206604004,
0.19525562226772308,
0.30326905846595764,
0.024271676316857338,
0.07058526575565338,
-0.03239748254418373,
-0.22615879774093628,
0.06874019652605057,
0.23556318879127502,
-0.6782255172729492,
-0.27532488107681274,
0.012477432377636433,
-0.4625207483768463,
-0.25483089685440063,
-0.27173152565956116,
-0.9935517311096191,
-0.3778110444545746,
-0.2753910720348358,
0.9443758726119995,
-0.22299423813819885,
-0.15402932465076447,
0.09165297448635101,
0.3378528356552124,
0.38779693841934204,
0.603730320930481,
-1.2428127527236938,
0.4342421889305115,
0.5148775577545166,
0.6925148367881775,
-0.3824400007724762,
-0.4624231457710266,
-1.0130051374435425,
0.27563875913619995,
-0.19841238856315613,
0.9856217503547668,
-0.4740193784236908,
-0.07358498871326447,
-0.21985046565532684,
0.1038319393992424,
-0.4584105312824249,
-0.7170596718788147,
0.7847679257392883,
-0.5225663781166077,
-0.1282811313867569,
-0.023600103333592415,
0.046035584062337875,
0.08601474016904831,
-0.18559060990810394,
-0.7163503766059875,
1.0732362270355225,
0.37283048033714294,
-0.39617979526519775,
0.126857191324234,
-1.0764293670654297,
-0.6383898854255676,
-0.23139280080795288,
0.41522470116615295,
-0.4367322325706482,
0.34954115748405457,
0.26373496651649475,
0.21161943674087524,
-0.3687651753425598,
-0.22759799659252167,
-0.1927717626094818,
-0.4570294916629791,
0.026122961193323135,
-0.428252637386322,
0.434234082698822,
0.33410170674324036,
-0.37000536918640137,
0.39880383014678955,
-0.6518222093582153,
-0.13669364154338837,
-0.20066063106060028,
-0.3740786910057068,
-0.45127663016319275,
0.04772361367940903,
0.061855748295784,
-0.17364703118801117,
0.3002350628376007,
-0.1744018793106079,
0.49485287070274353,
-0.4973568320274353,
0.6340203881263733,
1.1069326400756836,
-0.232587993144989,
0.9028641581535339,
-0.2779572010040283,
0.4714087247848511,
-0.2775193750858307,
0.42298465967178345,
0.21843646466732025,
-0.1963978111743927,
-1.3059883117675781,
-0.42305025458335876,
0.5744256377220154,
0.5305737257003784,
-0.6362787485122681,
0.6067524552345276,
-0.45221146941185,
-0.6220974326133728,
-0.7847727537155151,
0.22388683259487152,
0.023335246369242668,
0.18847818672657013,
0.4631554186344147,
-0.08509854227304459,
-0.20018906891345978,
-1.0826698541641235,
0.034984663128852844,
-0.2734966576099396,
0.0756688341498375,
0.04888357222080231,
0.40580153465270996,
-0.1997399926185608,
0.8077049851417542,
-0.5965694189071655,
-0.5493211150169373,
-0.12222310155630112,
0.2304886281490326,
0.5020011067390442,
0.48408111929893494,
0.6641557812690735,
-0.511189877986908,
-0.5028160810470581,
0.2671539783477783,
-0.10448113083839417,
-0.2849956750869751,
-0.1870439648628235,
-0.5622413754463196,
0.18120437860488892,
0.5115180611610413,
-0.3987204134464264,
0.1079912930727005,
0.964422881603241,
-0.3657505512237549,
0.013115196488797665,
-0.3741908073425293,
0.06596212089061737,
-0.8594727516174316,
0.17012238502502441,
-0.30134209990501404,
-0.2625373601913452,
-0.39712515473365784,
0.1444665491580963,
0.08350835740566254,
-0.09605094790458679,
-0.47042545676231384,
0.6088965535163879,
-0.2325560301542282,
0.0478847399353981,
-0.4191519021987915,
-0.20859962701797485,
-0.1327327936887741,
0.6954112648963928,
-0.3274441361427307,
0.9494826793670654,
0.5954557061195374,
-0.6728312373161316,
-0.00666829152032733,
0.19177024066448212,
-0.47439196705818176,
0.5849542021751404,
-0.4326052963733673,
0.1557030975818634,
-0.010089659132063389,
-0.1051362007856369,
-0.7157441973686218,
-0.0900862067937851,
0.19765938818454742,
0.10216118395328522,
0.1289345771074295,
-0.24847333133220673,
-0.21763505041599274,
0.19359993934631348,
-0.26807406544685364,
0.4800774157047272,
0.6533592343330383,
-0.6788332462310791,
0.8097096681594849,
0.49139702320098877,
-0.5170210599899292,
-0.21763357520103455,
-0.2801843285560608,
-0.1295548379421234,
-0.6738932728767395,
-0.2828454375267029,
0.7961100935935974,
-0.2673923671245575,
-0.23747189342975616,
0.05532371997833252,
-0.1483466625213623,
0.0472852922976017,
0.5289709568023682,
0.15688110888004303,
0.034121811389923096,
-0.3198276162147522,
-0.02211049199104309,
0.38808223605155945,
-0.17445416748523712,
-0.41814956068992615,
-0.0049618263728916645,
0.4181618094444275,
-0.23305611312389374,
-0.4386141002178192,
-0.2455780804157257,
0.2582853138446808,
0.8665348887443542,
-0.20993152260780334,
0.7718943953514099,
0.571046769618988,
-0.28049829602241516,
-0.4298979938030243,
-0.41040149331092834,
-0.06811609864234924,
-0.5135411024093628,
0.48634788393974304,
-0.324922651052475,
-0.8744099736213684,
0.5346370339393616,
-0.3173469305038452,
0.1123003140091896,
0.7155700922012329,
0.6137000322341919,
-0.09141077101230621,
0.8696317672729492,
1.0172852277755737,
-0.21581614017486572,
0.7653282284736633,
-0.056965094059705734,
0.37531551718711853,
-0.8572357296943665,
0.371616929769516,
-0.7096126675605774,
-0.7020221948623657,
-0.5974749326705933,
-0.41984570026397705,
0.7429359555244446,
0.36684921383857727,
-0.31648167967796326,
0.369731605052948,
-0.39002227783203125,
0.4875585436820984,
0.561241090297699,
0.021360894665122032,
0.43787050247192383,
0.06845381110906601,
0.49262136220932007,
0.1960037499666214,
-0.5046854615211487,
-0.1832149624824524,
0.9123513102531433,
0.4310573637485504,
0.8777700066566467,
0.4537765681743622,
0.3905388116836548,
0.5940474271774292,
0.41159215569496155,
-0.9872994422912598,
0.32861050963401794,
-0.46991387009620667,
-0.3570826053619385,
-0.7611532211303711,
-0.18219973146915436,
-0.9711173176765442,
0.1688433736562729,
-0.18704064190387726,
-0.673911452293396,
0.47479090094566345,
0.2748498320579529,
-0.8560952544212341,
0.07123073190450668,
-0.6878625154495239,
0.6420398354530334,
-0.2277715504169464,
-0.3772870898246765,
-0.5672173500061035,
-0.23769471049308777,
-0.07260046899318695,
-0.5079757571220398,
0.3084595203399658,
-0.38189753890037537,
0.010555836372077465,
0.8795324563980103,
-0.11269178986549377,
0.7116652727127075,
-0.18331725895404816,
-0.3930724859237671,
-0.0636894628405571,
-0.0005192787502892315,
0.7046516537666321,
0.00912972167134285,
-0.5200431942939758,
-0.1315312534570694,
-0.008921610191464424,
-0.48500898480415344,
-0.5685781240463257,
0.924473762512207,
-1.0307374000549316,
-0.6236143708229065,
-0.29350584745407104,
-0.6754118204116821,
-0.38446030020713806,
0.08675801008939743,
0.08069759607315063,
0.10947798937559128,
-0.160797119140625,
0.3850927948951721,
0.6512110233306885,
-0.25801244378089905,
0.5162508487701416,
0.34949618577957153,
0.07036846876144409,
-0.2613007128238678,
0.9943341016769409,
0.034542016685009,
0.2608031928539276,
0.5574462413787842,
0.22298015654087067,
0.017759008333086967,
-0.6816500425338745,
-0.5078888535499573,
0.07049211859703064,
-0.7207616567611694,
-0.2780340909957886,
-0.11992345750331879,
-0.12545499205589294,
-0.10848173499107361,
-0.35356590151786804,
-0.7578331828117371,
-0.6066744923591614,
-0.10890579223632812,
0.19542379677295685,
0.618790864944458,
0.4297739863395691,
0.0090755270794034,
0.7425225973129272,
-0.5160380601882935,
0.39823073148727417,
0.484655499458313,
0.4047510325908661,
0.00015836187230888754,
-0.8968737721443176,
-0.5143499970436096,
-0.1130957081913948,
-0.33315369486808777,
-0.5214186310768127,
0.2943594753742218,
0.7284919023513794,
0.6164641976356506,
0.1564393788576126,
0.2351841926574707,
0.8305268883705139,
-0.6051747798919678,
0.244026318192482,
-0.1864905059337616,
-1.114961862564087,
0.5577093958854675,
-0.5302168130874634,
0.34094011783599854,
0.8952466249465942,
-0.09937100857496262,
-0.24413420259952545,
-0.027597542852163315,
-0.11618797481060028,
-1.1239687204360962,
0.6793645024299622,
0.18141061067581177,
0.28443872928619385,
0.36138293147087097,
0.3709266185760498,
0.2875235974788666,
-0.09096740186214447,
-0.709159791469574,
-0.08990342170000076,
0.03838339075446129,
-0.2815876603126526,
0.0478215329349041,
-0.021216249093413353,
-0.238224595785141,
-0.5462574362754822,
0.9339213371276855,
-0.47810426354408264,
0.3266158103942871,
-0.1697472780942917,
-0.32704949378967285,
-0.47402331233024597,
0.5793463587760925,
0.4004453420639038,
0.8992246985435486,
-0.3563128113746643,
0.10401247441768646,
0.4968813359737396,
-0.26947563886642456,
0.09561901539564133,
0.15605150163173676,
-0.2539202868938446,
-0.3808380365371704,
0.2080909013748169,
1.0891101360321045,
0.4826512038707733,
-0.5756893754005432,
0.21638436615467072,
0.2112886905670166,
-0.229087695479393,
-0.1530316025018692,
0.3271339237689972,
-0.12195169180631638,
0.35026270151138306,
0.5848298668861389,
0.2335946261882782,
-0.11911025643348694,
-0.7342168092727661,
-0.11756467819213867,
0.17073112726211548,
-0.24438123404979706,
-0.3570019006729126,
0.4747242033481598,
0.4591801166534424,
-0.15500923991203308,
0.36784031987190247,
0.007560989819467068,
-0.12338056415319443,
0.330578476190567,
0.43891286849975586,
0.75693678855896,
-0.49005165696144104,
0.2282962203025818,
0.12441976368427277,
0.28846511244773865,
-0.18825288116931915,
0.08693091571331024,
0.243899405002594,
-0.6212734580039978,
-0.6134396195411682,
-1.0354505777359009,
-0.5134025812149048,
0.24994824826717377,
-0.676788866519928,
0.44664859771728516,
-0.45413368940353394,
-0.026428434997797012,
0.09952668100595474,
-0.23855014145374298,
-0.5049181580543518,
-0.16317787766456604,
0.16584715247154236,
0.814331591129303,
-1.1006958484649658,
1.1916791200637817,
0.6918274164199829,
-0.030687352642416954,
-0.4641020894050598,
0.2335365265607834,
-0.4324360489845276,
-0.8103421330451965,
0.41072988510131836,
-0.3198702335357666,
-0.3676493465900421,
0.43097585439682007,
-0.11338657140731812,
-1.285666584968567,
1.1596038341522217,
0.7572367787361145,
-0.4854165315628052,
-0.19174157083034515,
-0.021823426708579063,
0.43988633155822754,
-0.1700332909822464,
-0.029520517215132713,
0.6253382563591003,
0.7259629964828491,
-0.12391345202922821,
-1.203350305557251,
-0.09252750873565674,
-0.17113372683525085,
-0.10949695855379105,
0.46639278531074524,
-0.7564074397087097,
1.0009695291519165,
0.06974615901708603,
0.010274414904415607,
0.3394375145435333,
0.5848369598388672,
0.10512624680995941,
-0.04618788883090019,
1.0241167545318604,
0.3138698637485504,
0.7973354458808899,
-0.044666070491075516,
0.6377133131027222,
-0.22153782844543457,
0.30771559476852417,
0.8594105243682861,
-0.41015464067459106,
1.2090119123458862,
0.6777620911598206,
-0.1639050394296646,
0.5493383407592773,
0.5102824568748474,
0.1016191765666008,
0.993867039680481,
-0.07935763895511627,
0.06186598911881447,
-0.42813995480537415,
-0.24792669713497162,
-0.376321017742157,
0.6670499444007874,
0.44326257705688477,
-0.14781221747398376,
-0.20284569263458252,
0.15339282155036926,
-0.0776156634092331,
-0.09183813631534576,
-0.6196272969245911,
0.550665020942688,
-0.09647168219089508,
-0.8213111162185669,
0.8609991669654846,
0.17531678080558777,
0.6283414363861084,
-0.48306819796562195,
0.04569186270236969,
-0.18730616569519043,
0.5501744151115417,
-0.0278487429022789,
-0.3637450337409973,
0.2574080526828766,
-0.04744315147399902,
-0.3829496204853058,
-0.43438562750816345,
0.5872502326965332,
-0.22999508678913116,
-0.6298559904098511,
0.36598441004753113,
0.5743877291679382,
-0.235917329788208,
-0.19782908260822296,
-0.5419425368309021,
0.35767337679862976,
-0.1818811446428299,
-0.3727525770664215,
0.7057321667671204,
0.25501829385757446,
-0.44482600688934326,
0.440403014421463,
0.616995096206665,
0.132795512676239,
-0.19487741589546204,
0.1746286153793335,
0.8963045477867126,
-0.46010029315948486,
-0.5020447969436646,
-0.6715807318687439,
0.27610093355178833,
0.30663055181503296,
-0.3015092611312866,
0.3956249952316284,
0.25235000252723694,
0.6201419234275818,
-0.058589573949575424,
0.69254070520401,
-0.09868241101503372,
0.4270966351032257,
-0.7341402173042297,
0.7587510943412781,
-0.7314777970314026,
0.3187010884284973,
-0.26807889342308044,
-1.3296575546264648,
-0.18060949444770813,
0.7739250063896179,
-0.2905053198337555,
-0.22527259588241577,
0.728740930557251,
0.7217577695846558,
-0.43300044536590576,
-0.3053308129310608,
0.23895563185214996,
0.45746034383773804,
0.07447181642055511,
0.6816316246986389,
0.7410999536514282,
-0.42580145597457886,
0.5934826135635376,
-0.16122300922870636,
-0.3908050060272217,
-0.40906578302383423,
-1.034617304801941,
-0.5201526880264282,
-0.5291222333908081,
-0.3918192386627197,
0.07970691472291946,
0.3551885485649109,
0.903276264667511,
0.9418044090270996,
-0.9548746347427368,
-0.2960078716278076,
0.2010134905576706,
0.00977051630616188,
-0.564207136631012,
-0.13742145895957947,
0.6140544414520264,
0.01621236465871334,
-1.0329768657684326,
0.6326513886451721,
0.3322533667087555,
-0.4544663727283478,
-0.10612114518880844,
-0.11791002005338669,
-0.16185638308525085,
0.038984280079603195,
0.7137823104858398,
0.30753931403160095,
-0.6476852297782898,
-0.6675662398338318,
0.044632915407419205,
0.12527790665626526,
0.12403950840234756,
0.5624600052833557,
-0.70524662733078,
-0.23324532806873322,
0.40559956431388855,
0.6756374835968018,
0.3884473443031311,
0.015706393867731094,
0.5125450491905212,
-0.5904719233512878,
0.09712269902229309,
-0.0056890579871833324,
0.3159630000591278,
0.2094307541847229,
-0.21232230961322784,
0.5767424702644348,
-0.18160748481750488,
-0.5841509103775024,
-0.9554042816162109,
0.20349790155887604,
-1.3531162738800049,
-0.3339138329029083,
1.1658746004104614,
0.25282788276672363,
-0.15097439289093018,
0.03645874932408333,
-0.33047276735305786,
0.17997299134731293,
-0.4882374703884125,
1.020064353942871,
0.40861639380455017,
-0.1352996677160263,
-0.2746345102787018,
-0.5703873038291931,
0.42566806077957153,
0.6871275901794434,
-1.0249733924865723,
0.20557641983032227,
0.061755333095788956,
0.07586207985877991,
0.24307331442832947,
0.4230858385562897,
0.2815227806568146,
0.17968696355819702,
-0.6686388254165649,
-0.15867358446121216,
0.17077042162418365,
-0.4957290589809418,
-0.3491271138191223,
0.2295307070016861,
0.7323809266090393,
0.03979659825563431
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16176v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16176v1
|
Subspace Defense: Discarding Adversarial Perturbations by Learning a Subspace for Clean Signals
| 2024-03-24T14:35:44 | 2024-03-24T14:35:44 |
Rui Zheng, Yuhao Zhou, Zhiheng Xi, Tao Gui, Qi Zhang, Xuanjing Huang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR
|
Deep neural networks (DNNs) are notoriously vulnerable to adversarial attacks
that place carefully crafted perturbations on normal examples to fool DNNs. To
better understand such attacks, a characterization of the features carried by
adversarial examples is needed. In this paper, we tackle this challenge by
inspecting the subspaces of sample features through spectral analysis. We first
empirically show that the features of either clean signals or adversarial
perturbations are redundant and span in low-dimensional linear subspaces
respectively with minimal overlap, and the classical low-dimensional subspace
projection can suppress perturbation features out of the subspace of clean
signals. This makes it possible for DNNs to learn a subspace where only
features of clean signals exist while those of perturbations are discarded,
which can facilitate the distinction of adversarial examples. To prevent the
residual perturbations that is inevitable in subspace learning, we propose an
independence criterion to disentangle clean signals from perturbations.
Experimental results show that the proposed strategy enables the model to
inherently suppress adversaries, which not only boosts model robustness but
also motivates new directions of effective adversarial defense.
|
[
-0.5405539274215698,
-0.6807774901390076,
0.21137093007564545,
-0.2947681248188019,
-0.32239794731140137,
0.3432821035385132,
0.029536612331867218,
-0.03818296641111374,
0.2736213207244873,
0.6971287727355957,
-0.5660616159439087,
-0.5322635769844055,
-0.6591534614562988,
-0.3176800608634949,
-0.6091780662536621,
0.9199263453483582,
0.29314568638801575,
-0.116336889564991,
-0.015310432761907578,
0.12446200102567673,
-0.4156631529331207,
-0.48397552967071533,
-0.4270707964897156,
-0.018196815624833107,
0.5647186040878296,
0.17731928825378418,
0.6468684673309326,
0.5416800379753113,
0.539671778678894,
0.374475359916687,
-0.45280733704566956,
0.13204601407051086,
-0.7774216532707214,
0.27580055594444275,
0.14289018511772156,
-0.5926445722579956,
-0.1900709718465805,
0.11864729970693588,
0.5248317122459412,
0.8620539903640747,
0.19903448224067688,
-0.04856853932142258,
0.12435721606016159,
0.6628718376159668,
-0.6520654559135437,
-0.2557445168495178,
-0.8537594676017761,
0.5748239755630493,
-0.4546484053134918,
-0.01240680180490017,
-0.19217725098133087,
-0.2291739284992218,
-0.24879731237888336,
-0.4455723464488983,
0.3751724362373352,
-0.6466474533081055,
0.9847123622894287,
0.48281246423721313,
-0.4121321141719818,
0.29940280318260193,
-0.9163826107978821,
0.6126591563224792,
-0.30941110849380493,
0.17736290395259857,
0.2869853377342224,
0.4328823387622833,
-0.4277034103870392,
-0.7439233660697937,
-0.38433367013931274,
-0.3652576208114624,
-0.012450420297682285,
0.13207893073558807,
-0.5832315683364868,
0.1387510895729065,
0.24784451723098755,
0.2511332929134369,
-0.23212897777557373,
0.1419457495212555,
-0.51714026927948,
-0.41521206498146057,
0.4898388087749481,
0.007631206884980202,
0.20726877450942993,
-0.14481636881828308,
-0.9796848297119141,
-0.42693179845809937,
-0.9025285840034485,
0.17589831352233887,
0.8219832181930542,
0.041537076234817505,
0.18967340886592865,
0.1629270613193512,
0.08328723162412643,
0.2622656524181366,
0.15951505303382874,
0.19202004373073578,
-0.029005615040659904,
-0.08197283744812012,
-0.13735538721084595,
-0.06708104908466339,
0.6420426964759827,
-0.2828834354877472,
-0.07498520612716675,
-0.3239200711250305,
-0.4506949782371521,
0.19037288427352905,
0.5251733064651489,
-0.3985280692577362,
-0.8522627353668213,
-0.04224328696727753,
-0.5943284034729004,
-0.7167187929153442,
0.026053912937641144,
-0.8677490949630737,
-0.8133789896965027,
-0.40542858839035034,
0.38620835542678833,
-0.2547285556793213,
-0.23878420889377594,
-0.06063620001077652,
-0.2736271321773529,
-0.2945868968963623,
0.11624918133020401,
-0.6417310237884521,
0.6389303207397461,
0.7092523574829102,
0.20304982364177704,
0.19673879444599152,
-0.10924884676933289,
-0.39179861545562744,
-0.6019144654273987,
-0.44251251220703125,
0.3363893926143646,
-0.10340087115764618,
-0.21074220538139343,
-0.27578893303871155,
-0.37542471289634705,
0.24661827087402344,
-0.5655359029769897,
0.3818490207195282,
-0.7675724625587463,
-0.24859164655208588,
-0.5706155300140381,
-0.275339812040329,
-0.5090062618255615,
0.12223204970359802,
-0.8265870809555054,
0.36149224638938904,
0.0015345200663432479,
-0.5311941504478455,
0.4750693142414093,
-0.40548375248908997,
-0.35454061627388,
0.10230366140604019,
-0.2913302779197693,
-0.6598219871520996,
0.3832075595855713,
0.22284643352031708,
0.2837545573711395,
0.39968112111091614,
-0.07540477067232132,
-0.6797736883163452,
-0.4462849199771881,
0.40708449482917786,
-0.714897871017456,
1.1075173616409302,
0.6789104342460632,
-0.4853765666484833,
0.20883220434188843,
-1.0369917154312134,
-0.13602164387702942,
0.0762460008263588,
-0.035241156816482544,
-0.33924874663352966,
0.28347247838974,
-0.4199085235595703,
0.029819078743457794,
-0.02235906943678856,
-0.6190891861915588,
0.19452941417694092,
-0.22593335807323456,
0.22847576439380646,
0.8682927489280701,
0.3205548822879791,
0.1302497386932373,
-0.14035868644714355,
0.5170187950134277,
0.15156182646751404,
0.3981781601905823,
0.23975397646427155,
-0.04740287736058235,
-0.7484926581382751,
-0.8172584772109985,
0.4102601408958435,
0.20332291722297668,
-0.7974193096160889,
0.4897081255912781,
0.057001743465662,
-0.3406846225261688,
-0.23908331990242004,
0.38684219121932983,
0.4959355294704437,
0.23826979100704193,
0.3502257168292999,
-0.2709023356437683,
-0.8902169466018677,
-0.865750789642334,
0.1252327710390091,
0.09126594662666321,
0.17839831113815308,
-0.11935599893331528,
0.4599635601043701,
0.29664328694343567,
0.5788215398788452,
-0.34665414690971375,
-0.2567303776741028,
-0.01621282286942005,
-0.3342345058917999,
-0.02023988775908947,
0.30723583698272705,
0.7533820271492004,
-0.8638781309127808,
0.009811530821025372,
-0.30843672156333923,
-0.8442224860191345,
0.20819909870624542,
0.07601609081029892,
-0.10427837073802948,
-0.7472969889640808,
0.7850806713104248,
-0.26126447319984436,
0.7123318314552307,
0.18806184828281403,
-0.3257592022418976,
0.3701508343219757,
0.01107893604785204,
-0.21111692488193512,
-0.5334189534187317,
0.18756596744060516,
-0.09639506042003632,
-0.3766002058982849,
-0.8495868444442749,
0.37166810035705566,
-0.23294444382190704,
-0.38007012009620667,
-0.4244876801967621,
-0.09897498786449432,
-0.20281760394573212,
0.07267029583454132,
-0.2528194189071655,
-0.025273647159337997,
0.3232431709766388,
0.3528798222541809,
-0.35539954900741577,
0.3088657259941101,
0.3368249237537384,
-0.6884740591049194,
0.33041808009147644,
0.3991205394268036,
-0.09448711574077606,
0.09157410264015198,
-0.5558463931083679,
0.19630937278270721,
-0.18342749774456024,
0.14634045958518982,
-1.227203369140625,
0.3627643287181854,
0.40195807814598083,
-0.4413929581642151,
0.4752880930900574,
-0.2601703405380249,
0.06244760751724243,
-0.2356184870004654,
-0.28542768955230713,
0.2732517421245575,
0.6204828023910522,
-0.7905201315879822,
0.05509801208972931,
0.27788016200065613,
0.3857082724571228,
-0.9293110966682434,
-0.6337399482727051,
0.0520373210310936,
-0.33425357937812805,
-0.24329203367233276,
0.04785393550992012,
0.44724881649017334,
-0.446738600730896,
0.10937809199094772,
-0.10272721201181412,
0.06559491902589798,
0.9684690237045288,
0.4308905303478241,
0.26058876514434814,
-0.14595621824264526,
0.03344065696001053,
-0.2571905851364136,
-0.19801805913448334,
0.30341070890426636,
-0.5780961513519287,
0.4055213928222656,
0.17276880145072937,
-0.6765456199645996,
-0.3585064113140106,
0.2247389853000641,
0.5459086894989014,
-0.39474377036094666,
0.1898709535598755,
0.6107156872749329,
-0.4089469015598297,
-0.5410531163215637,
-0.23608925938606262,
-0.4160838723182678,
-0.5389569997787476,
0.6163986325263977,
-0.24662457406520844,
-0.34387853741645813,
0.7449999451637268,
0.0321822389960289,
-0.19118426740169525,
0.40994006395339966,
0.07533571869134903,
-0.17649835348129272,
0.47571659088134766,
0.32991114258766174,
-0.2786000072956085,
0.4617609679698944,
-0.633311927318573,
0.2764911949634552,
-0.6639633178710938,
-0.032285336405038834,
-0.3001430034637451,
-0.8684965968132019,
-0.3594183623790741,
-0.061519555747509,
0.4279576539993286,
0.3405444324016571,
-0.39537513256073,
0.1918809711933136,
-0.6561952233314514,
0.45411548018455505,
0.4921245574951172,
0.5468355417251587,
-0.3117300868034363,
0.1921273171901703,
-0.2400239259004593,
-0.11372475326061249,
-0.5296269059181213,
-0.2400881052017212,
0.9686169028282166,
0.7268816828727722,
0.6255978345870972,
0.2543713450431824,
1.1259732246398926,
0.49299341440200806,
-0.2544529438018799,
-0.4493727385997772,
0.6727218627929688,
-0.7385565638542175,
-0.4517226219177246,
-0.05483532324433327,
-0.5303332805633545,
-1.0345333814620972,
0.32428786158561707,
-0.30580636858940125,
-0.7383346557617188,
0.8547397255897522,
0.28095027804374695,
-0.56414794921875,
0.7294577360153198,
-0.37831637263298035,
0.5286142826080322,
-0.29463279247283936,
-0.33159661293029785,
-0.12398114800453186,
-0.3451804518699646,
0.46350201964378357,
0.3918939530849457,
-0.2998967468738556,
0.058600012212991714,
0.3063110411167145,
0.3851037919521332,
-0.3010038733482361,
1.1832014322280884,
-0.6722640991210938,
-0.019751178100705147,
0.531476616859436,
0.44173723459243774,
0.18223926424980164,
-0.0010116123594343662,
0.3114399015903473,
0.12350683659315109,
-0.40316328406333923,
-0.339365690946579,
-0.43053367733955383,
0.508202850818634,
-0.7918484210968018,
-0.47947293519973755,
-0.11404052376747131,
-0.14291542768478394,
-0.14903274178504944,
0.18563058972358704,
0.5001619458198547,
0.5816044807434082,
-0.27862221002578735,
0.21531091630458832,
1.057206392288208,
-0.0954553559422493,
0.6400841474533081,
0.10303714871406555,
-0.04713313654065132,
-0.35307881236076355,
1.1382850408554077,
-0.015342175960540771,
0.44161221385002136,
0.25415241718292236,
0.1122768223285675,
-0.24902349710464478,
-1.0271304845809937,
-0.06978549808263779,
-0.501842200756073,
-0.9399189949035645,
-0.26404255628585815,
-0.08145177364349365,
-0.20727698504924774,
-0.03420420363545418,
0.2754533588886261,
-0.4412357807159424,
-0.39640888571739197,
-0.19816745817661285,
-0.17928043007850647,
-0.029924003407359123,
0.9147055745124817,
-0.1762908399105072,
-0.05172305554151535,
-0.5370723009109497,
0.4142608046531677,
0.5795546770095825,
0.07669594138860703,
0.14958781003952026,
-0.24458785355091095,
0.0833316221833229,
0.13420625030994415,
-0.6821048259735107,
-0.8099696636199951,
0.21715867519378662,
-0.09227735549211502,
0.7428485751152039,
0.7506293058395386,
0.15149611234664917,
0.25561320781707764,
-0.0671091079711914,
0.8913105130195618,
0.18970675766468048,
-1.0868644714355469,
0.34949666261672974,
-0.45959892868995667,
-0.12040691077709198,
0.5370559692382812,
0.011436253786087036,
-0.09118729829788208,
-0.2632976770401001,
-0.7324835658073425,
-0.6781845092773438,
0.15769949555397034,
0.08558747917413712,
-0.07827738672494888,
0.08068664371967316,
0.4333733916282654,
-0.17335519194602966,
0.34001362323760986,
-0.5525079369544983,
-0.30902430415153503,
-0.5271278023719788,
-0.14747938513755798,
0.09685742855072021,
-0.1314523071050644,
-0.6927929520606995,
0.0687631368637085,
0.20916609466075897,
0.17796169221401215,
0.2856026887893677,
0.332712858915329,
-0.026891712099313736,
0.20178523659706116,
0.08309629559516907,
0.5890209674835205,
0.25977641344070435,
-0.04067349061369896,
0.43372562527656555,
0.11591070890426636,
-0.6262468099594116,
0.5296463966369629,
0.14810845255851746,
-0.23598814010620117,
-0.26546603441238403,
0.4535481035709381,
0.7732526659965515,
-0.13170184195041656,
-0.01985188014805317,
0.6916458606719971,
-0.08666788041591644,
-0.5144059658050537,
-0.20290109515190125,
0.12417597323656082,
-0.4407983422279358,
0.26735228300094604,
0.2722841799259186,
0.8155751824378967,
0.21723291277885437,
-0.23653988540172577,
0.38131183385849,
0.5550454258918762,
-0.8063229322433472,
-0.4051620066165924,
0.6980350017547607,
0.08512957394123077,
0.13128963112831116,
0.4702194333076477,
-0.3116472661495209,
-0.968891978263855,
0.929137110710144,
0.01890416629612446,
1.0264346599578857,
0.057464927434921265,
-0.04461526498198509,
-0.11203289031982422,
0.41378068923950195,
0.36841881275177,
0.07123108208179474,
0.03665603697299957,
-0.6125628352165222,
-0.14805231988430023,
-0.2682726979255676,
0.10172604024410248,
0.4453781545162201,
-0.6781425476074219,
0.06917709112167358,
-1.0128182172775269,
-0.06303683668375015,
0.2623932957649231,
0.1362895518541336,
-0.534093976020813,
0.2690398395061493,
0.676985502243042,
0.5583356022834778,
-0.9179136157035828,
0.5318366289138794,
0.3827475309371948,
-0.29062023758888245,
-0.8456207513809204,
-0.056369513273239136,
0.5054705142974854,
-0.36897000670433044,
0.9425125122070312,
-0.37234175205230713,
-0.339153915643692,
-0.5537397861480713,
-0.4123214781284332,
-0.7652655839920044,
0.6224094033241272,
0.5995117425918579,
-0.30363741517066956,
0.49839362502098083,
-0.09664391726255417,
0.4924250841140747,
0.17416106164455414,
-0.04440944269299507,
0.25237739086151123,
0.34336167573928833,
-0.3672679364681244,
-0.38293805718421936,
0.18593820929527283,
-0.3581591546535492,
-0.1204230859875679,
0.2566239535808563,
-0.778167724609375,
1.2478632926940918,
-0.033755384385585785,
-0.33049502968788147,
0.07373511791229248,
0.5952428579330444,
-0.3601647913455963,
0.06994897872209549,
0.8190966248512268,
0.6810707449913025,
0.6491516828536987,
-0.20922406017780304,
0.8651094436645508,
-0.09556765854358673,
0.3167268931865692,
0.7344476580619812,
-0.02606053091585636,
0.5518192648887634,
0.22413726150989532,
-0.20829516649246216,
0.22136817872524261,
0.23189757764339447,
-0.4346867799758911,
0.6248169541358948,
0.7394371032714844,
-0.25322961807250977,
-0.1479492485523224,
0.41799071431159973,
-0.36282047629356384,
1.0472652912139893,
0.27495574951171875,
-0.20101448893547058,
-0.24087896943092346,
0.24916505813598633,
0.0022845182102173567,
0.6040768623352051,
-0.23822496831417084,
0.7264174222946167,
-0.20837879180908203,
-0.4181581139564514,
0.8488299250602722,
-0.45957493782043457,
0.30471497774124146,
-0.7955300807952881,
-0.23211748898029327,
-0.1683329939842224,
0.8093559145927429,
-0.3657032549381256,
-0.14105215668678284,
0.22573989629745483,
-0.44422265887260437,
-0.31487566232681274,
-0.0013461642665788531,
0.8730915784835815,
-0.22667086124420166,
-0.10469139367341995,
0.4472224712371826,
-0.0221408698707819,
-0.3392053246498108,
0.24073567986488342,
-0.29233700037002563,
-0.0313623882830143,
0.23007890582084656,
0.03012808971107006,
0.4169008135795593,
0.09659458696842194,
0.2970024347305298,
0.5302634239196777,
0.6067936420440674,
0.303166002035141,
0.07327036559581757,
-0.004026549402624369,
1.111589789390564,
-0.1802845448255539,
-0.4416474997997284,
-0.8087234497070312,
0.4158940017223358,
-0.15008343756198883,
-0.4314676523208618,
0.9202633500099182,
0.1963585466146469,
0.4383891522884369,
0.0038194963708519936,
0.7421771883964539,
0.22829905152320862,
0.4083966612815857,
-0.5264493227005005,
1.0465443134307861,
-0.2747206687927246,
0.7391106486320496,
-0.17695435881614685,
-0.31996336579322815,
-0.13167807459831238,
0.4394342601299286,
-0.022000741213560104,
0.06742899864912033,
0.33300700783729553,
0.5802087783813477,
-0.20492134988307953,
0.05785297229886055,
0.2729929983615875,
0.17739948630332947,
0.7441949844360352,
0.5423063635826111,
1.1308693885803223,
-0.5428957939147949,
0.44320598244667053,
-0.5201242566108704,
-0.2241957038640976,
0.061005719006061554,
-0.7730473279953003,
-0.850446343421936,
-0.2796383798122406,
-0.23509114980697632,
-0.6162957549095154,
0.2705501317977905,
0.47375690937042236,
0.9071149826049805,
-0.9460287094116211,
0.08671493083238602,
-0.036223120987415314,
0.21478280425071716,
-0.6765556335449219,
-0.16231726109981537,
0.36672866344451904,
-0.3969908356666565,
-0.26878562569618225,
0.9057508707046509,
-0.08957824110984802,
0.009240557439625263,
-0.6924256086349487,
0.4637296497821808,
-0.024251174181699753,
-0.2278173416852951,
0.04627746716141701,
0.5046367049217224,
-0.5510495901107788,
-0.4598000943660736,
-0.17305028438568115,
-0.15695232152938843,
-0.2664848268032074,
0.7353304624557495,
-0.7403505444526672,
0.5652280449867249,
0.512856662273407,
0.6498399376869202,
0.09315317124128342,
-0.15436019003391266,
0.46047618985176086,
-1.1786625385284424,
0.42398175597190857,
0.48778247833251953,
0.47413721680641174,
0.053343627601861954,
-0.6331746578216553,
0.0666574016213417,
0.1955811083316803,
-0.3802751898765564,
-0.6930452585220337,
0.26623809337615967,
-0.6911908984184265,
-0.4860851466655731,
0.7757531404495239,
-0.46632084250450134,
-0.14277862012386322,
-0.10622941702604294,
-0.08178871870040894,
0.13092736899852753,
0.058823924511671066,
0.7843461632728577,
0.3493494391441345,
0.19252249598503113,
0.22774659097194672,
-0.20366068184375763,
0.7957389950752258,
0.4067804515361786,
-0.36231502890586853,
0.05249316990375519,
0.2587035000324249,
0.31045207381248474,
0.5243099331855774,
0.003140365704894066,
-0.10027819126844406,
0.43540242314338684,
0.6188352108001709,
-0.14329177141189575,
-0.6627808809280396,
-0.5372620224952698,
-0.7596501708030701,
0.6047857403755188,
-0.040735214948654175,
-1.1314690113067627
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16167v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16167v3
|
Exploiting Semantic Reconstruction to Mitigate Hallucinations in Vision-Language Models
| 2024-03-24T14:21:06 | 2024-05-05T05:46:45 |
Minchan Kim, Minyeong Kim, Junik Bae, Suhwan Choi, Sungkyung Kim, Buru Chang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Hallucinations in vision-language models pose a significant challenge to
their reliability, particularly in the generation of long captions. Current
methods fall short of accurately identifying and mitigating these
hallucinations. To address this issue, we introduce ESREAL, a novel
unsupervised learning framework designed to suppress the generation of
hallucinations through accurate localization and penalization of hallucinated
tokens. Initially, ESREAL creates a reconstructed image based on the generated
caption and aligns its corresponding regions with those of the original image.
This semantic reconstruction aids in identifying both the presence and type of
token-level hallucinations within the generated caption. Subsequently, ESREAL
computes token-level hallucination scores by assessing the semantic similarity
of aligned regions based on the type of hallucination. Finally, ESREAL employs
a proximal policy optimization algorithm, where it selectively penalizes
hallucinated tokens according to their token-level hallucination scores. Our
framework notably reduces hallucinations in LLaVA, InstructBLIP, and mPLUG-Owl2
by 32.81%, 27.08%, and 7.46% on the CHAIR metric. This improvement is achieved
solely through signals derived from the image itself, without the need for any
image-text pairs.
|
[
-0.4436374008655548,
-0.6204449534416199,
0.5147343873977661,
0.007229846902191639,
-0.4219159185886383,
-0.15589429438114166,
-0.3558334708213806,
-0.39396435022354126,
0.6389972567558289,
1.1501227617263794,
-0.46673384308815,
-0.6439896821975708,
-0.31595128774642944,
0.1324462592601776,
-0.4761926233768463,
0.853641152381897,
0.27815183997154236,
-0.0068564568646252155,
-0.4062870144844055,
-0.02854648046195507,
-0.35195887088775635,
-0.3936085104942322,
-0.37040966749191284,
-0.21316130459308624,
0.10893908143043518,
0.12168310582637787,
0.6053358912467957,
0.28308841586112976,
0.4740704894065857,
0.2833968698978424,
0.09450564533472061,
0.5083088874816895,
-0.48929262161254883,
0.07824403792619705,
-0.052303534001111984,
-0.034939881414175034,
-0.0541372075676918,
-0.5864320993423462,
0.47580626606941223,
0.7428037524223328,
-0.43955257534980774,
-0.19842292368412018,
-0.007213518489152193,
0.80287104845047,
-0.69507896900177,
0.2428140491247177,
-0.8256978988647461,
0.4031158983707428,
0.161545529961586,
-0.5152403116226196,
-0.6765931844711304,
0.03201206400990486,
0.019516596570611,
-0.793049693107605,
0.3678120970726013,
0.20150886476039886,
0.9706413149833679,
0.659168004989624,
-0.10984078049659729,
-0.14240460097789764,
-0.5275993943214417,
0.7421396970748901,
-0.46052810549736023,
0.3217119574546814,
0.35806921124458313,
0.3543427288532257,
-0.5144596099853516,
-0.47824811935424805,
-0.4355253577232361,
-0.13760420680046082,
-0.2901003658771515,
0.13877813518047333,
-0.2900766134262085,
0.3104441463947296,
0.3133755028247833,
-0.011918910779058933,
-0.7066484093666077,
0.050463564693927765,
-0.7219641804695129,
-0.7928550243377686,
0.31540894508361816,
0.03215431049466133,
0.3223293721675873,
-0.3075020909309387,
-0.6005221009254456,
-0.14659705758094788,
-0.6737098097801208,
-0.34929773211479187,
0.4113991856575012,
0.35722583532333374,
0.46444079279899597,
0.6197922825813293,
-0.31975191831588745,
0.740804135799408,
-0.24430790543556213,
-0.19237519800662994,
0.41281113028526306,
0.10162758827209473,
-0.17587073147296906,
0.27481314539909363,
0.2740364670753479,
0.7768656611442566,
0.35126423835754395,
-0.5703603625297546,
-0.3908308446407318,
0.623394787311554,
0.6177619695663452,
-0.6514730453491211,
-0.30479371547698975,
0.17265501618385315,
-0.2931482493877411,
-0.40573301911354065,
0.16087216138839722,
-1.1498814821243286,
-0.7196436524391174,
-0.397796094417572,
0.6077650189399719,
-0.32618245482444763,
-0.2158132791519165,
0.6111643314361572,
-0.15173809230327606,
0.4879465699195862,
0.3276306390762329,
-0.746588408946991,
0.5365506410598755,
0.45414265990257263,
0.6890268325805664,
-0.5216832756996155,
-0.3744986653327942,
-0.7406842708587646,
0.1521224081516266,
-0.36845237016677856,
0.9407114386558533,
-0.3356306254863739,
-0.19396492838859558,
0.17711982131004333,
0.12082340568304062,
0.12809966504573822,
-0.7723082900047302,
0.1728467494249344,
-0.22558419406414032,
-0.048718493431806564,
-0.0625954195857048,
-0.40599703788757324,
-0.3630536198616028,
0.19322222471237183,
-0.7018020153045654,
0.7421873807907104,
-0.12046869099140167,
-0.6160328984260559,
0.34246575832366943,
-0.29516106843948364,
-0.5316393971443176,
0.004933182615786791,
-0.4066823720932007,
-0.5187070965766907,
0.4224577248096466,
0.5313908457756042,
0.34767675399780273,
0.055075205862522125,
0.23141898214817047,
0.13152222335338593,
-0.6432064175605774,
-0.17841924726963043,
-0.19343002140522003,
0.470604807138443,
0.060282498598098755,
-0.5881809592247009,
0.35076072812080383,
-1.037556767463684,
-0.17581810057163239,
0.08854638040065765,
0.16249458491802216,
-0.33038192987442017,
0.08296576142311096,
0.19516216218471527,
-0.04953450709581375,
-0.26584675908088684,
-0.5531117916107178,
-0.15492239594459534,
-0.6864768862724304,
0.1157713308930397,
0.822144091129303,
0.12981607019901276,
0.483407199382782,
-0.19945435225963593,
0.44469529390335083,
0.16388557851314545,
0.1884525567293167,
-0.042926136404275894,
-0.2699224352836609,
-0.9444531798362732,
-0.402615487575531,
-0.4055272042751312,
0.20726977288722992,
-1.0375418663024902,
0.4225004315376282,
-0.11009795218706131,
-0.32823580503463745,
-0.2804707884788513,
-0.25068315863609314,
0.3682222366333008,
0.6026660203933716,
0.5768577456474304,
-0.3938785195350647,
-0.5301092267036438,
-1.0138452053070068,
-0.03213013708591461,
-0.09206905215978622,
0.0048899282701313496,
0.0908803939819336,
0.6100965142250061,
-0.2318476289510727,
0.7369505167007446,
-0.4934791326522827,
-0.9264024496078491,
-0.12048731744289398,
-0.10051289200782776,
-0.24835535883903503,
0.4402548670768738,
0.5908960700035095,
-0.8269952535629272,
-0.07213454693555832,
-0.11785003542900085,
-0.7091222405433655,
-0.19846542179584503,
-0.5610978603363037,
-0.10012774914503098,
0.5997133851051331,
0.6145692467689514,
-0.5700089335441589,
0.8312674760818481,
0.4573579728603363,
-0.5302758812904358,
0.5351433753967285,
-0.2943509519100189,
0.02098596654832363,
-0.8318703174591064,
-0.11563999205827713,
-0.5369020700454712,
-0.15828169882297516,
-0.37922048568725586,
0.06007342413067818,
-0.254089891910553,
-0.24083290994167328,
-0.4498811364173889,
0.41915419697761536,
-0.5274546146392822,
-0.4648614823818207,
-0.18002542853355408,
0.3961244225502014,
0.10620398074388504,
0.7380945086479187,
0.3797679841518402,
0.5245516300201416,
0.9815642833709717,
-0.2833324074745178,
0.27203720808029175,
0.2418069690465927,
-0.6205881834030151,
0.46972528100013733,
-0.44761285185813904,
0.12841984629631042,
-0.5000442862510681,
0.04234090447425842,
-0.9240503311157227,
-0.24562706053256989,
0.3369525969028473,
-0.35116347670555115,
0.10919434577226639,
0.2509317100048065,
-0.4229162037372589,
-0.06526725739240646,
-0.3431362509727478,
0.1124625951051712,
0.41735661029815674,
-0.7559280395507812,
1.100417137145996,
0.36125388741493225,
0.3993571996688843,
-0.7260359525680542,
-0.6729252338409424,
0.07342872768640518,
-0.18720105290412903,
-0.16381584107875824,
0.4705435633659363,
0.10744483023881912,
-0.11758843064308167,
0.2568284869194031,
-0.1886809766292572,
0.3549521565437317,
-0.014856449328362942,
0.4005768597126007,
0.20015738904476166,
0.15734954178333282,
0.13083083927631378,
0.07287180423736572,
-0.29197004437446594,
0.011116858571767807,
-0.3246849477291107,
0.7804142832756042,
-0.20611338317394257,
-0.5252844095230103,
-0.47135838866233826,
0.31957563757896423,
0.6651404500007629,
-0.3263525366783142,
0.7498393654823303,
0.5250391364097595,
-0.772641658782959,
-0.5257212519645691,
-0.5956498980522156,
-0.7236723899841309,
-0.43649327754974365,
0.7776173949241638,
-0.3732365369796753,
-0.5661687254905701,
0.6339852809906006,
0.048921942710876465,
-0.20708118379116058,
0.15983958542346954,
0.40577688813209534,
0.24214841425418854,
0.8675175309181213,
0.45409414172172546,
0.21790370345115662,
0.24814411997795105,
-0.24723246693611145,
0.2612992823123932,
-0.6890420913696289,
-0.540926456451416,
-0.14997844398021698,
-0.0002784174866974354,
-0.3970686197280884,
-0.3103172481060028,
0.2135026752948761,
-0.2965424954891205,
0.07709281146526337,
0.3230830729007721,
-0.6982690095901489,
0.7927640676498413,
0.41124776005744934,
0.23721657693386078,
0.08405294269323349,
0.4548606872558594,
-0.025966381654143333,
-0.18045517802238464,
-0.44434404373168945,
-0.4052189886569977,
0.7666933536529541,
-0.02571059949696064,
0.6166629791259766,
-0.039847567677497864,
0.9448193907737732,
0.32544127106666565,
-0.051842253655195236,
-0.8129004836082458,
0.7920534610748291,
0.022621165961027145,
-0.30055704712867737,
-0.398209810256958,
-0.4112301766872406,
-0.7029196619987488,
0.576511025428772,
-0.3504754602909088,
-1.0008134841918945,
0.16069239377975464,
-0.04655156657099724,
-0.3820875585079193,
0.5018051862716675,
-0.46888142824172974,
0.714637041091919,
-0.08173545449972153,
-0.17232725024223328,
-0.3210647404193878,
-0.5540844798088074,
-0.02357461489737034,
-0.11621849983930588,
0.14989767968654633,
-0.05348072201013565,
0.21992214024066925,
0.6653011441230774,
-0.231658473610878,
1.0415416955947876,
-0.3079061508178711,
0.21945348381996155,
0.30065086483955383,
0.25927311182022095,
0.5313971042633057,
-0.183546245098114,
0.4038831293582916,
0.09652502834796906,
0.052520859986543655,
-0.4273533821105957,
-0.7652897834777832,
0.5804531574249268,
-0.635226845741272,
-0.49385732412338257,
-0.46337080001831055,
-0.4845656156539917,
-0.20043662190437317,
0.07498066127300262,
0.3323274850845337,
0.6116969585418701,
-0.08514221757650375,
0.1936519294977188,
0.5319638252258301,
-0.6697189807891846,
0.1272328495979309,
0.24080133438110352,
-0.6379759311676025,
-0.49964669346809387,
0.9897202849388123,
0.016322780400514603,
0.13947677612304688,
0.10981129854917526,
0.05555722489953041,
-0.15866303443908691,
-0.6079703569412231,
-0.16487577557563782,
0.3466818332672119,
-0.9953401684761047,
-0.4355071187019348,
-0.5249154567718506,
-0.06029059737920761,
-0.38024553656578064,
-0.3357692360877991,
-0.6214657425880432,
-0.2957713305950165,
-0.22063063085079193,
-0.3798351585865021,
0.20920252799987793,
0.6115609407424927,
-0.1431409865617752,
0.01996075175702572,
-0.18868380784988403,
0.3737080991268158,
0.04122096672654152,
0.192430317401886,
0.019703999161720276,
-0.5304952263832092,
0.09594544768333435,
-0.36569374799728394,
0.18094505369663239,
-0.6724414825439453,
0.7204070091247559,
0.22318914532661438,
0.47312766313552856,
0.5549187064170837,
0.4342014193534851,
0.7352953553199768,
-0.5260025262832642,
0.6966214776039124,
0.37286463379859924,
-0.8237114548683167,
0.6013817191123962,
0.31171485781669617,
-0.009582717902958393,
0.44667869806289673,
-0.10738185793161392,
-0.3577510714530945,
-0.637361466884613,
-0.3617878556251526,
-1.0085631608963013,
0.4541996717453003,
0.23133625090122223,
0.32592979073524475,
-0.11432833224534988,
0.3691065311431885,
0.13382865488529205,
0.07107279449701309,
-0.6418192982673645,
0.09369593858718872,
-0.21614347398281097,
-0.15132200717926025,
0.20062404870986938,
-0.2584296762943268,
-0.2212202101945877,
-0.2698601186275482,
0.6401109099388123,
-0.24484547972679138,
0.20725983381271362,
0.2786921560764313,
-0.26750800013542175,
0.011649983003735542,
-0.29155248403549194,
0.7613000869750977,
0.4982883930206299,
-0.24707955121994019,
0.4372875690460205,
0.023762626573443413,
-0.4600808024406433,
-0.26886603236198425,
-0.16950500011444092,
-0.4647672474384308,
0.12604911625385284,
0.3830591142177582,
1.0091338157653809,
0.09315381944179535,
-1.0121842622756958,
0.6444295048713684,
-0.019602322950959206,
-0.17412346601486206,
-0.6258808970451355,
-0.09127428382635117,
-0.4141308069229126,
0.3597440719604492,
0.17818398773670197,
0.336404025554657,
0.21882787346839905,
-0.32949796319007874,
0.45908409357070923,
0.2261863499879837,
-0.550764799118042,
-0.32768362760543823,
0.6512168049812317,
-0.10257526487112045,
-0.3038075566291809,
0.7428305745124817,
-0.16603945195674896,
-0.7044748663902283,
0.6662600636482239,
0.7944355607032776,
0.8578072190284729,
0.2161754071712494,
0.5230786204338074,
0.4561295211315155,
0.34041205048561096,
-0.14345881342887878,
0.18799175322055817,
-0.14039094746112823,
-1.0311050415039062,
-0.13332499563694,
-0.8547255992889404,
-0.053788576275110245,
-0.05533194914460182,
-0.8086730241775513,
0.19046466052532196,
-0.20779745280742645,
-0.0009473444661125541,
-0.30372774600982666,
-0.31090298295021057,
-0.4610558748245239,
0.035613466054201126,
0.22239772975444794,
0.4129524528980255,
-0.9732517600059509,
0.6292117834091187,
0.3491697311401367,
-0.5805558562278748,
-0.4388643205165863,
0.0304388590157032,
-0.05843089148402214,
-0.6913098096847534,
0.27668508887290955,
0.535872220993042,
-0.5455061793327332,
0.08225365728139877,
-0.348291277885437,
-0.506916344165802,
0.8680334091186523,
0.4257916212081909,
-0.4546627998352051,
0.07263458520174026,
0.1200895681977272,
0.6510019898414612,
-0.34931713342666626,
-0.46613645553588867,
0.4590986967086792,
0.2755986452102661,
0.16575615108013153,
-0.49746230244636536,
0.16884557902812958,
0.0549330934882164,
0.07051810622215271,
0.08827944099903107,
-0.2905985414981842,
0.09613951295614243,
-0.5624709129333496,
-0.374565064907074,
0.19166912138462067,
0.56800377368927,
0.1473488211631775,
0.1303747296333313,
0.655659019947052,
0.5157214403152466,
0.7895543575286865,
-0.07748907059431076,
0.8622788786888123,
-0.18358395993709564,
0.32932159304618835,
1.0488905906677246,
-0.338705837726593,
0.7689555883407593,
1.2252336740493774,
0.30921313166618347,
0.2326463758945465,
0.3263052701950073,
-0.20430953800678253,
0.9604750275611877,
0.3442831039428711,
-0.0016871036496013403,
-0.3436111509799957,
-0.32852914929389954,
-0.030205944553017616,
0.671876072883606,
0.18090446293354034,
-0.17658662796020508,
-0.06528449058532715,
0.6073205471038818,
-0.16150180995464325,
0.47155648469924927,
-0.11512025445699692,
0.8248194456100464,
-0.14889656007289886,
-0.5800520777702332,
0.4941655695438385,
-0.41535452008247375,
0.43749693036079407,
-0.31848016381263733,
-0.2710748314857483,
-0.4058265686035156,
0.20574209094047546,
-0.1538565754890442,
-0.2709050178527832,
0.6947968006134033,
-0.23953427374362946,
0.25081729888916016,
0.04524736851453781,
0.6691235303878784,
-0.4511186182498932,
-0.3989940285682678,
0.6919697523117065,
0.15093402564525604,
0.49004730582237244,
-0.18259315192699432,
-0.22461450099945068,
0.24346359074115753,
0.06422483175992966,
-0.2698613703250885,
0.1262209266424179,
0.359971821308136,
0.015055350959300995,
0.41607317328453064,
0.45753607153892517,
0.4136221408843994,
-0.08056255429983139,
0.47135990858078003,
0.8772240281105042,
-0.41152068972587585,
-0.2918437719345093,
-0.6300799250602722,
0.41868487000465393,
-0.18132121860980988,
-0.16235454380512238,
0.3297765254974365,
0.52775639295578,
1.1448463201522827,
-0.444784015417099,
0.24239233136177063,
0.14037010073661804,
0.08347667753696442,
-0.6974704265594482,
0.9281315207481384,
-0.8577167391777039,
0.31878241896629333,
-0.20476838946342468,
-1.077386498451233,
-0.8997042775154114,
0.9605192542076111,
-0.09688033908605576,
-0.3998960852622986,
0.5859717726707458,
1.4744783639907837,
0.20647597312927246,
-0.5184908509254456,
0.8171122074127197,
0.05039883032441139,
0.09454607963562012,
0.37641945481300354,
0.8732612133026123,
-0.3948531150817871,
0.661851704120636,
-0.3425846993923187,
-0.12756839394569397,
-0.14154352247714996,
-0.592289388179779,
-1.0243334770202637,
-0.8466919660568237,
-0.33939099311828613,
-0.40920788049697876,
0.15613572299480438,
0.9296766519546509,
0.5253174304962158,
-1.0015945434570312,
0.11516924202442169,
-0.2123909890651703,
-0.07545331865549088,
-0.32278478145599365,
-0.222366601228714,
0.7429469227790833,
-0.4655698835849762,
-0.5659480094909668,
0.17127829790115356,
0.6847394108772278,
0.014073366299271584,
-0.4766210615634918,
-0.28608208894729614,
0.33657222986221313,
0.2932067811489105,
0.6550636887550354,
-0.06106513738632202,
-1.0727723836898804,
-0.6755180954933167,
0.10125869512557983,
-0.06301020085811615,
0.06557894498109818,
0.5681737065315247,
-0.8473010063171387,
0.8869983553886414,
0.1738271266222,
0.6686099171638489,
0.4709693491458893,
-0.25000205636024475,
0.19383546710014343,
-0.5816144347190857,
0.655100405216217,
0.2808595299720764,
0.4449460804462433,
0.5428223013877869,
-0.28919142484664917,
0.6465094685554504,
0.40376022458076477,
-0.16978363692760468,
-1.0850493907928467,
0.430165559053421,
-0.9786621928215027,
-0.45133304595947266,
1.2015116214752197,
0.11148808896541595,
-0.39476311206817627,
0.07632290571928024,
-0.5604425072669983,
0.10410134494304657,
0.025986310094594955,
1.3322272300720215,
0.45562243461608887,
0.037091296166181564,
-0.08588863909244537,
-0.32294195890426636,
0.6909047365188599,
0.4982994496822357,
-0.6748626232147217,
0.0689675509929657,
0.693989098072052,
-0.12556232511997223,
0.20466361939907074,
0.3490547239780426,
-0.29986894130706787,
0.1866151988506317,
0.22370083630084991,
0.25987932085990906,
-0.10160265862941742,
-0.8821418285369873,
-0.2708055078983307,
0.15023072063922882,
-0.24224331974983215,
-0.34544652700424194
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16158v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16158v1
|
Korean Bio-Medical Corpus (KBMC) for Medical Named Entity Recognition
| 2024-03-24T13:51:05 | 2024-03-24T13:51:05 |
Sungjoo Byun, Jiseung Hong, Sumin Park, Dongjun Jang, Jean Seo, Minseok Kim, Chaeyoung Oh, Hyopil Shin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Named Entity Recognition (NER) plays a pivotal role in medical Natural
Language Processing (NLP). Yet, there has not been an open-source medical NER
dataset specifically for the Korean language. To address this, we utilized
ChatGPT to assist in constructing the KBMC (Korean Bio-Medical Corpus), which
we are now presenting to the public. With the KBMC dataset, we noticed an
impressive 20% increase in medical NER performance compared to models trained
on general Korean NER datasets. This research underscores the significant
benefits and importance of using specialized tools and datasets, like ChatGPT,
to enhance language processing in specialized fields such as healthcare.
|
[
-0.25867241621017456,
-0.3514978289604187,
0.6915233135223389,
0.0815466120839119,
-0.24315792322158813,
0.36584848165512085,
-0.18183566629886627,
-0.5183454751968384,
0.4503128230571747,
0.6358989477157593,
-0.04318179562687874,
-0.7723716497421265,
-0.6250028014183044,
0.26062461733818054,
0.06447196751832962,
1.0489248037338257,
0.16408874094486237,
0.6098623275756836,
-0.012448699213564396,
-0.22933173179626465,
-0.3503889739513397,
-0.6770090460777283,
-1.1126134395599365,
-0.29301881790161133,
0.6702264547348022,
0.3634234368801117,
0.7304698824882507,
0.5682075023651123,
0.9230673909187317,
0.2082269787788391,
-0.03181019797921181,
-0.02114289440214634,
-0.18103012442588806,
0.23982997238636017,
-0.07682247459888458,
-0.24517476558685303,
-0.5649500489234924,
-0.32356661558151245,
0.7254602313041687,
0.8720679879188538,
-0.0016361610032618046,
-0.058101553469896317,
-0.21897274255752563,
0.9584481120109558,
-0.3082290291786194,
0.5102306008338928,
-0.39719879627227783,
0.24576717615127563,
-0.15772299468517303,
-0.17240124940872192,
-0.2678776979446411,
-0.49153223633766174,
0.3762616813182831,
-0.5018438100814819,
0.23567381501197815,
-0.24885976314544678,
0.7995375990867615,
0.1457100212574005,
-0.6294077038764954,
-0.49352124333381653,
-0.5806748270988464,
0.21065041422843933,
-0.4495700001716614,
0.7644974589347839,
0.449812650680542,
0.5691307187080383,
-0.3577613830566406,
-1.0234806537628174,
-0.23591601848602295,
-0.4050053060054779,
-0.1819346398115158,
0.318555623292923,
-0.18332022428512573,
0.3368588984012604,
0.1892039030790329,
0.16955479979515076,
-0.5374169945716858,
0.004622372332960367,
-0.7974688410758972,
-0.37625518441200256,
0.412378191947937,
0.2530037462711334,
0.702265739440918,
-0.5192776918411255,
-0.11576448380947113,
0.12889887392520905,
-0.7081027030944824,
-0.12863583862781525,
0.02257615327835083,
0.3440615236759186,
0.09275545924901962,
0.6756805777549744,
-0.2862291634082794,
0.5289558172225952,
-0.04824931174516678,
-0.2660999894142151,
0.48495712876319885,
-0.07623381912708282,
-0.3240222930908203,
0.6686750650405884,
0.8081232309341431,
0.385138601064682,
0.20705534517765045,
-0.40096333622932434,
0.10364644229412079,
0.07222610712051392,
0.39523589611053467,
-1.0315438508987427,
-0.7830743193626404,
0.1533685028553009,
-0.7379547953605652,
-0.36563822627067566,
-0.06785061955451965,
-0.8644793033599854,
-0.5449680089950562,
-0.3756231367588043,
0.17867089807987213,
-0.46928030252456665,
-0.2653347849845886,
-0.11381558328866959,
-0.06654521077871323,
0.09026312828063965,
0.05267755687236786,
-0.5402418375015259,
0.44071072340011597,
0.469062864780426,
0.8809033036231995,
-0.19794732332229614,
0.26634615659713745,
-0.275716632604599,
0.04477890208363533,
-0.49401232600212097,
0.9035912156105042,
-0.5443651080131531,
-0.4558515250682831,
-0.33674269914627075,
0.3370831310749054,
-0.23278380930423737,
-0.8675873875617981,
0.466114342212677,
-0.5134175419807434,
-0.16396349668502808,
-0.24937325716018677,
-0.5924021601676941,
-0.20219732820987701,
0.10088666528463364,
-0.7993729710578918,
0.6689131855964661,
0.20958128571510315,
-0.7398749589920044,
0.46107929944992065,
-0.8218401074409485,
-0.4283687174320221,
0.5657221674919128,
-0.5381404757499695,
-0.4408971965312958,
-0.05832517519593239,
0.2198399007320404,
0.5794751048088074,
-0.045790769159793854,
0.4408309757709503,
-0.13434143364429474,
-0.010376568883657455,
0.41076329350471497,
-0.1618504375219345,
0.5749596953392029,
0.27686622738838196,
0.042500220239162445,
-0.1480579823255539,
-1.025702714920044,
0.2822563946247101,
-0.09806298464536667,
-0.5719516277313232,
-0.43907245993614197,
0.025752613320946693,
0.09153097122907639,
0.30445805191993713,
-0.08855652064085007,
-0.67485511302948,
0.03769923746585846,
-0.5411771535873413,
0.48211026191711426,
0.1405729502439499,
0.26576676964759827,
0.38986313343048096,
-0.05598105862736702,
0.7501296401023865,
0.060516394674777985,
-0.29946133494377136,
-0.050422247499227524,
-0.733016848564148,
-0.4161837697029114,
-0.5781843066215515,
0.630148708820343,
0.7326551675796509,
-0.7080575227737427,
0.01412187609821558,
-0.25172337889671326,
-0.7867559790611267,
-0.9578456282615662,
-0.4594481289386749,
0.3750844895839691,
0.9676530957221985,
0.42149001359939575,
0.03357560187578201,
-0.9192750453948975,
-1.1285701990127563,
-0.16962482035160065,
-0.04514516517519951,
-0.2729286849498749,
0.7118122577667236,
0.28629690408706665,
-0.45309150218963623,
0.927560567855835,
-0.5536207556724548,
-0.061711858958005905,
-0.22841039299964905,
-0.0731220692396164,
0.4264424741268158,
0.38054168224334717,
0.2778016924858093,
-0.9033984541893005,
-0.8904217481613159,
0.3507640063762665,
-0.6332160234451294,
-0.4022005796432495,
0.1699296534061432,
-0.14809930324554443,
0.1392333060503006,
0.6829283833503723,
-0.5301740765571594,
0.5119919776916504,
0.47144076228141785,
-0.4284532070159912,
0.6091804504394531,
-0.15220294892787933,
0.4361432194709778,
-1.464922547340393,
0.3082502484321594,
-0.4785747528076172,
-0.45790955424308777,
-0.7996575832366943,
-0.17561089992523193,
0.31568634510040283,
-0.3565555512905121,
-0.3729475736618042,
0.5444015860557556,
-0.5643240213394165,
0.03201960772275925,
-0.42225363850593567,
-0.0909339040517807,
-0.36326834559440613,
0.07886839658021927,
0.3039509356021881,
0.6785770058631897,
0.5313093066215515,
-0.8290479183197021,
0.19368231296539307,
0.35980528593063354,
-0.32628417015075684,
0.7213753461837769,
-0.8262205123901367,
0.022159771993756294,
-0.23679181933403015,
0.06875786930322647,
-0.7226170897483826,
-0.602387547492981,
0.46199482679367065,
-0.6589388251304626,
0.43049824237823486,
-0.4981510043144226,
-0.3484095335006714,
-0.23765166103839874,
0.21145300567150116,
0.19637930393218994,
0.5557419657707214,
-0.45347359776496887,
0.3091637194156647,
0.8029002547264099,
-0.32786160707473755,
-0.3074337840080261,
-0.7599477767944336,
0.08167889714241028,
0.01467748824506998,
-0.33399996161460876,
0.6367733478546143,
0.2567031979560852,
0.07621163874864578,
0.21418510377407074,
-0.30769771337509155,
-0.43277159333229065,
-0.22620123624801636,
0.5079832077026367,
0.4664589762687683,
-0.5565140247344971,
0.4712480306625366,
0.0014164912281557918,
-0.38712939620018005,
-0.014115262776613235,
-0.0503775030374527,
0.6091060042381287,
-0.027659080922603607,
-0.2100965678691864,
-0.01391700841486454,
0.18585558235645294,
0.3489431142807007,
0.09437324851751328,
0.8813462257385254,
0.5650436282157898,
-0.6842916011810303,
0.4715352952480316,
-0.43752390146255493,
0.12808243930339813,
-0.4389326572418213,
0.6831272840499878,
-0.15715888142585754,
-1.1376144886016846,
0.46860551834106445,
-0.11984679847955704,
-0.4260237514972687,
0.5079101920127869,
0.6847102046012878,
0.009798703715205193,
0.9825732111930847,
0.2869155704975128,
-0.03479201719164848,
0.021070515736937523,
0.3629341423511505,
0.427021861076355,
-0.9829557538032532,
-0.4100709855556488,
-0.4044792652130127,
-0.340186208486557,
-1.1076385974884033,
-0.4273567497730255,
0.4393559694290161,
0.01441749557852745,
-0.15095242857933044,
0.5324634909629822,
-0.6831820607185364,
0.5389181971549988,
0.3102857172489166,
0.2869498133659363,
0.25858578085899353,
-0.09875049442052841,
-0.3964954912662506,
-0.2366665005683899,
-0.5795260071754456,
-0.5995054244995117,
1.027842402458191,
0.11112606525421143,
0.4550495743751526,
-0.15925410389900208,
0.6525031924247742,
-0.16066181659698486,
0.3111051321029663,
-0.7029228210449219,
0.5541526079177856,
-0.29924702644348145,
-0.5447183847427368,
0.07240866869688034,
-0.5856034159660339,
-1.4217280149459839,
-0.01658046804368496,
-0.09223224222660065,
-0.6953084468841553,
0.15312698483467102,
0.037997838109731674,
-0.37587589025497437,
0.2173233926296234,
-0.6702752113342285,
0.7546505928039551,
0.16074645519256592,
0.5138934254646301,
0.12701523303985596,
-0.7505366206169128,
0.1992313116788864,
-0.20664726197719574,
-0.15702901780605316,
-0.189300999045372,
-0.20585277676582336,
0.7505843639373779,
-0.4206324517726898,
0.42236894369125366,
-0.15071460604667664,
0.5766563415527344,
0.14210334420204163,
-0.12531431019306183,
0.14735352993011475,
0.47598934173583984,
0.23514880239963531,
0.3495478928089142,
0.09168574213981628,
-0.12705443799495697,
-0.24943208694458008,
0.65547114610672,
-0.4296293556690216,
-0.055003758519887924,
-0.5029305219650269,
-0.4201732277870178,
-0.33960357308387756,
0.44348466396331787,
0.39612191915512085,
0.1678885817527771,
-0.3402138948440552,
0.4046091139316559,
0.6224470734596252,
-0.6857283115386963,
0.04364017769694328,
0.6959406137466431,
-0.4532091021537781,
-0.9014257192611694,
0.7880483269691467,
0.2971610724925995,
0.22999054193496704,
0.5184022188186646,
0.023657651618123055,
-0.0029274371918290854,
-0.3153493106365204,
-0.2788398563861847,
0.16437561810016632,
-0.5655966997146606,
-0.41998761892318726,
-1.3142422437667847,
-0.8682205677032471,
-0.5229693055152893,
-0.08850961178541183,
-0.29384079575538635,
-0.49676254391670227,
-0.05931055173277855,
-0.12761381268501282,
0.6647025942802429,
0.5320266485214233,
0.08311252295970917,
0.46994709968566895,
-1.0272531509399414,
0.5060913562774658,
-0.08333601802587509,
0.5762779116630554,
-0.36095428466796875,
-0.022769298404455185,
-0.07264053821563721,
-0.08479553461074829,
-0.022895323112607002,
-1.1387498378753662,
0.6478101015090942,
0.06545240432024002,
0.631644070148468,
0.21318702399730682,
-0.38124367594718933,
0.6980584859848022,
-0.8733320832252502,
0.5364199280738831,
0.034817636013031006,
-0.273643434047699,
0.48842179775238037,
-0.21091169118881226,
0.5701797008514404,
0.6370552778244019,
0.7071453928947449,
-1.1840624809265137,
-0.13467425107955933,
-0.6997542381286621,
-0.9051373600959778,
0.5959043502807617,
0.23364408314228058,
-0.18244804441928864,
-0.4075061082839966,
0.2843882143497467,
0.06472551077604294,
0.3020012676715851,
-0.29084888100624084,
-0.2709146738052368,
0.20950116217136383,
-0.3666253387928009,
0.15122506022453308,
-0.26186680793762207,
0.4777158796787262,
-0.19765515625476837,
0.6791629791259766,
0.0376434251666069,
0.7037100195884705,
0.5433122515678406,
-0.09870042651891708,
0.2860724627971649,
0.2685460150241852,
0.32243627309799194,
0.17364424467086792,
-0.018136775121092796,
-0.0007035586168058217,
0.15081532299518585,
-1.1414432525634766,
-0.09758300334215164,
0.29614362120628357,
-0.16198597848415375,
0.42968985438346863,
0.07158484309911728,
0.7089352607727051,
0.4253941774368286,
-0.7760040163993835,
0.06036259979009628,
-0.044232141226530075,
-0.1662740707397461,
-0.14291326701641083,
-0.0758437067270279,
0.5101271271705627,
0.17126452922821045,
-0.04687793180346489,
0.13369470834732056,
0.3443191945552826,
-0.09096477180719376,
0.3554978370666504,
0.2130136787891388,
-0.6035982370376587,
-0.134811669588089,
0.4970911741256714,
-0.35779470205307007,
-0.27343055605888367,
1.0664798021316528,
-0.15695931017398834,
-0.62650066614151,
0.8271535038948059,
0.6712968945503235,
0.7804813385009766,
-0.4021517038345337,
0.37004798650741577,
0.6957488656044006,
0.1337483823299408,
0.024241220206022263,
0.4940025806427002,
0.18374328315258026,
-0.5888239145278931,
-0.3613094687461853,
-0.6833034753799438,
-0.34218263626098633,
0.25267308950424194,
-0.5553521513938904,
0.558372437953949,
-0.3617122769355774,
-0.34630295634269714,
0.3599169850349426,
-0.2235134243965149,
-0.6852478384971619,
0.24248415231704712,
0.04289429634809494,
0.6934412121772766,
-0.21733471751213074,
0.6963906288146973,
0.9210976362228394,
-0.3375309705734253,
-0.8473309278488159,
-0.3300818204879761,
-0.09404581785202026,
-0.8712560534477234,
0.7293203473091125,
0.25370240211486816,
0.5186198353767395,
-0.041526373475790024,
-0.19869175553321838,
-1.070818305015564,
1.0219131708145142,
0.20682393014431,
-0.6981044411659241,
0.03584244102239609,
0.41059577465057373,
0.7454041242599487,
-0.3380078971385956,
0.05636540427803993,
0.4443960189819336,
0.3866834044456482,
-0.16074709594249725,
-1.0056774616241455,
-0.029441876336932182,
-0.3042934536933899,
-0.08498334884643555,
0.7669918537139893,
-0.2185610681772232,
0.4957902431488037,
-0.13752970099449158,
-0.21199999749660492,
-0.1583394557237625,
0.2937692105770111,
0.4577462673187256,
0.6105565428733826,
0.21924224495887756,
0.4532451927661896,
0.988822340965271,
0.011689215898513794,
0.8343886137008667,
-0.27332577109336853,
0.08443857729434967,
1.161514163017273,
-0.17274528741836548,
0.6346995234489441,
0.22731107473373413,
-0.3335902988910675,
0.20065541565418243,
0.5821689963340759,
-0.16899165511131287,
0.5614197254180908,
0.20111367106437683,
-0.4055640697479248,
0.08816034346818924,
-0.06013122946023941,
-0.502231776714325,
0.35989975929260254,
0.4419596791267395,
-0.823409914970398,
-0.15698307752609253,
0.2512366473674774,
0.34185025095939636,
-0.34095364809036255,
-0.54825359582901,
0.8859468698501587,
0.3419559895992279,
-0.4213870167732239,
-0.015288763679564,
-0.2273840308189392,
0.39816585183143616,
-0.593144953250885,
-0.11735105514526367,
0.21351458132266998,
0.09899595379829407,
-0.3032711446285248,
-0.7261728644371033,
0.615923285484314,
-0.02830522693693638,
-0.29671669006347656,
0.2107713520526886,
1.427107572555542,
-0.6190044283866882,
-0.683290958404541,
0.08017272502183914,
0.44873595237731934,
0.6507537961006165,
-0.13353292644023895,
-0.4236662685871124,
-0.5010005235671997,
-0.18741531670093536,
0.0025076596066355705,
0.513231098651886,
0.4516661465167999,
-0.04299541562795639,
0.4886171221733093,
0.7961453795433044,
0.396560400724411,
0.07963810861110687,
0.04378867149353027,
0.638849675655365,
-0.8015358448028564,
-0.4299711287021637,
-0.9500162601470947,
0.07555118948221207,
-0.21773982048034668,
-0.24173277616500854,
0.46858638525009155,
0.8275853991508484,
0.6903014779090881,
-0.4138578474521637,
0.7445780634880066,
-0.2598731517791748,
0.850595235824585,
-0.30860140919685364,
1.3258345127105713,
-0.07292778789997101,
-0.2583469748497009,
-0.4025617837905884,
-0.5455211997032166,
-0.5309068560600281,
0.5658336877822876,
-0.07276102900505066,
0.0023661267478019,
0.7586032748222351,
0.8162550330162048,
-0.01081833615899086,
0.10409658402204514,
0.49559909105300903,
0.22238346934318542,
0.10141976922750473,
0.5051443576812744,
0.409462034702301,
-0.3646523356437683,
0.42577072978019714,
-0.39149317145347595,
0.06993645429611206,
-0.025939125567674637,
-0.9390524625778198,
-0.8556672930717468,
-0.4129188060760498,
-0.41453656554222107,
-0.4448862075805664,
0.21052800118923187,
1.1899248361587524,
0.5973295569419861,
-1.0338151454925537,
0.3267451226711273,
-0.18441903591156006,
-0.29625755548477173,
-0.1285751461982727,
-0.2779250741004944,
0.5792186260223389,
-0.3474702835083008,
-0.3879293203353882,
0.4980386197566986,
0.48251864314079285,
-0.03766760602593422,
0.30842432379722595,
-0.09675218909978867,
-0.03166227787733078,
-0.17882443964481354,
0.5415002703666687,
0.3155716359615326,
-0.25677651166915894,
0.08208654820919037,
0.2994750738143921,
-0.41737350821495056,
0.3514572083950043,
0.872391402721405,
-0.9805976152420044,
0.4464259147644043,
0.500401496887207,
1.0256258249282837,
0.19034062325954437,
-0.3847864270210266,
0.5550239086151123,
-0.3657163679599762,
-0.33208373188972473,
0.46750229597091675,
0.28104397654533386,
0.2934461832046509,
-0.5955324769020081,
0.8286969661712646,
0.28924548625946045,
-0.9248156547546387,
-0.7278921008110046,
-0.09655526280403137,
-1.1447830200195312,
0.05679551139473915,
0.9188518524169922,
0.0170076172798872,
-0.14279629290103912,
-0.4550932049751282,
-0.6463619470596313,
0.507689356803894,
-0.46513938903808594,
0.5467168688774109,
0.79254150390625,
-0.3101736605167389,
0.03823606297373772,
-1.2023048400878906,
0.5677270293235779,
0.02831488475203514,
-0.9806875586509705,
-0.33476337790489197,
0.18241098523139954,
0.5352916121482849,
-0.05875043570995331,
1.0344635248184204,
-0.5729900598526001,
0.44748303294181824,
-0.062385816127061844,
0.08345022052526474,
0.173716202378273,
-0.13114550709724426,
-0.1369353085756302,
0.047405462712049484,
-0.3093506097793579,
-0.2733944058418274
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16142v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16142v1
|
What Happens to a Dataset Transformed by a Projection-based Concept Removal Method?
| 2024-03-24T13:28:27 | 2024-03-24T13:28:27 |
Richard Johansson
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We investigate the behavior of methods that use linear projections to remove
information about a concept from a language representation, and we consider the
question of what happens to a dataset transformed by such a method. A
theoretical analysis and experiments on real-world and synthetic data show that
these methods inject strong statistical dependencies into the transformed
datasets. After applying such a method, the representation space is highly
structured: in the transformed space, an instance tends to be located near
instances of the opposite label. As a consequence, the original labeling can in
some cases be reconstructed by applying an anti-clustering method.
|
[
-0.4668331742286682,
-0.9871566891670227,
0.3607903718948364,
-0.23176413774490356,
-0.36893048882484436,
0.1623515635728836,
-0.08615747839212418,
-0.6403417587280273,
0.6750512719154358,
0.5892170667648315,
-0.17386648058891296,
-0.22458238899707794,
-0.5039884448051453,
-0.44749438762664795,
-1.0164241790771484,
1.0940500497817993,
-0.14824621379375458,
-0.06396597623825073,
-0.309434711933136,
0.07316797971725464,
-0.3951224684715271,
-0.738178551197052,
0.05724135786294937,
-0.3601101040840149,
0.25259700417518616,
0.3788166046142578,
0.804637610912323,
1.159574031829834,
0.7688141465187073,
0.283080518245697,
-0.22340677678585052,
-0.18947838246822357,
-0.9026564359664917,
0.017347153276205063,
-0.2046915888786316,
-0.7223170399665833,
-0.022531671449542046,
0.45562997460365295,
0.803213357925415,
1.3060762882232666,
-0.19058160483837128,
-0.02233847603201866,
0.1365620344877243,
0.40459850430488586,
-0.5934540629386902,
0.1933623105287552,
-0.770828127861023,
0.23416654765605927,
-0.2365032434463501,
-0.33291107416152954,
-0.3314727544784546,
-0.3982202112674713,
0.20368331670761108,
-0.5759749412536621,
0.6909219026565552,
-0.029839754104614258,
0.8613618016242981,
0.007559348829090595,
-0.4310564398765564,
-0.3884428143501282,
-1.4245470762252808,
0.8333298563957214,
-0.08704426884651184,
0.10797423869371414,
0.24100488424301147,
0.2408231943845749,
-0.34703880548477173,
-0.5637090802192688,
-0.6229334473609924,
0.28031614422798157,
-0.2508603632450104,
0.05369336158037186,
0.08375393599271774,
-0.05518457666039467,
0.6001852750778198,
0.4196813106536865,
-0.44714727997779846,
-0.17919887602329254,
-0.8916063904762268,
-0.1154436394572258,
0.5202680230140686,
-0.1411178857088089,
0.20441493391990662,
-0.4056914448738098,
-0.39817655086517334,
-0.2140394151210785,
-1.0546633005142212,
-0.576308012008667,
0.0985337644815445,
0.44362717866897583,
0.4234262704849243,
0.7520914077758789,
0.13666844367980957,
0.6173587441444397,
-0.06280078738927841,
-0.05233410745859146,
0.48773685097694397,
-0.0031060287728905678,
-0.3011890649795532,
0.28046509623527527,
0.28270193934440613,
0.29021862149238586,
0.25567859411239624,
-0.19472067058086395,
-0.24031595885753632,
0.5628670454025269,
0.2995736598968506,
-0.3852316439151764,
-0.23920424282550812,
-0.02536514215171337,
-0.4991276264190674,
-0.2293109893798828,
0.1353829801082611,
-0.5319878458976746,
-0.45040014386177063,
-0.4910096824169159,
0.5093324780464172,
-0.4798424243927002,
-0.3190358579158783,
-0.145178884267807,
-0.11676909774541855,
0.1969471424818039,
0.2925778031349182,
-0.5886335372924805,
0.34076619148254395,
0.5812148451805115,
0.5183566808700562,
-0.24914515018463135,
0.36969277262687683,
-0.2875244617462158,
0.24007557332515717,
-0.7858973145484924,
0.6705524325370789,
-0.6981930732727051,
-0.6088895797729492,
-0.02940165065228939,
-0.005643331911414862,
-0.05669233575463295,
-1.0227539539337158,
0.23360396921634674,
-0.3786219358444214,
0.23513586819171906,
-0.39949771761894226,
-0.9576824903488159,
-0.1892017424106598,
0.023528585210442543,
-0.6141010522842407,
0.6792437434196472,
-0.08641696721315384,
-0.49339529871940613,
0.44641363620758057,
-0.36667972803115845,
-0.4056451618671417,
-0.007480980828404427,
-0.218354731798172,
-0.14058350026607513,
0.38179391622543335,
-0.24899107217788696,
0.3323885500431061,
0.0184551402926445,
0.11532596498727798,
-0.12198193371295929,
-0.4352545142173767,
0.1484055072069168,
-0.16410239040851593,
0.4666252136230469,
0.42346495389938354,
-0.01801208406686783,
-0.10897001624107361,
-1.242258071899414,
-0.05481531098484993,
0.29581841826438904,
0.09157904982566833,
-0.9959828853607178,
0.4731026887893677,
-0.016949592158198357,
0.34195953607559204,
-0.099912129342556,
-0.9601767659187317,
0.30812034010887146,
-0.6147512197494507,
0.3031715154647827,
0.5548597574234009,
0.38453564047813416,
0.6776885390281677,
0.023867668583989143,
0.32327619194984436,
0.39730939269065857,
-0.07230257242918015,
0.022925155237317085,
-0.489524245262146,
-0.8270131945610046,
-0.08376877754926682,
0.11772509664297104,
0.5056898593902588,
-1.1071897745132446,
0.1830248385667801,
-0.23944400250911713,
-0.4040733277797699,
-0.19107921421527863,
-0.1504300981760025,
0.30120915174484253,
0.5809237957000732,
0.3592774569988251,
-0.24731004238128662,
-0.796066403388977,
-1.0384547710418701,
-0.09886594116687775,
-0.27827218174934387,
-0.05877862498164177,
-0.27985838055610657,
0.6260913014411926,
-0.05309402570128441,
1.1052535772323608,
-0.915083646774292,
-0.28875112533569336,
-0.07124243676662445,
0.10937561839818954,
0.2650679051876068,
0.7802987098693848,
0.6102325916290283,
-1.0253158807754517,
-0.2756046950817108,
-0.40292108058929443,
-0.8378572463989258,
0.1755470335483551,
-0.2681311070919037,
0.12487290054559708,
-0.021284034475684166,
0.6830523014068604,
-0.37539610266685486,
0.9119201898574829,
0.30483707785606384,
-0.017536409199237823,
0.553661048412323,
-0.08639742434024811,
-0.06648407131433487,
-1.0707533359527588,
-0.047243881970644,
0.2331434190273285,
-0.05863016098737717,
-0.981799840927124,
0.08116684854030609,
-0.17612463235855103,
-0.11189906299114227,
-0.38698768615722656,
0.21606874465942383,
-0.1813308447599411,
-0.336221843957901,
-0.2253572791814804,
0.1601584404706955,
-0.06349601596593857,
0.20027771592140198,
0.2376926988363266,
0.5682483911514282,
0.2234870195388794,
-0.5399139523506165,
0.2026159018278122,
0.3911921977996826,
-0.4105960428714752,
0.49777930974960327,
-0.46424365043640137,
0.27191224694252014,
-0.5657252073287964,
0.06813988834619522,
-1.2695344686508179,
0.13885590434074402,
0.4173699915409088,
-0.1488337516784668,
0.1928529292345047,
-0.06553934514522552,
-0.6306515336036682,
-0.22104723751544952,
-0.02874648943543434,
0.2457016259431839,
0.4185573160648346,
-0.4866500794887543,
0.09552539885044098,
0.5152225494384766,
0.059065885841846466,
-0.27555400133132935,
-0.8995552062988281,
0.10704193264245987,
-0.4637957513332367,
-0.18649914860725403,
0.5993083119392395,
0.06533525884151459,
-0.6662721037864685,
0.3189776539802551,
-0.034672968089580536,
-0.18826748430728912,
-0.16447286307811737,
0.26207810640335083,
0.24689875543117523,
0.06333233416080475,
0.3666348457336426,
0.09414493292570114,
-0.1096378043293953,
0.13181109726428986,
0.05925411358475685,
0.4619491696357727,
0.3199743330478668,
-0.289516419172287,
-0.17931734025478363,
0.6021209359169006,
0.2736802101135254,
-0.049043506383895874,
1.039386510848999,
0.30811771750450134,
-0.6052260994911194,
-0.07952127605676651,
-0.1705668568611145,
-0.10747049748897552,
-0.4401208460330963,
0.6188408732414246,
-0.5704408884048462,
-0.25284478068351746,
0.6226859092712402,
0.06470739096403122,
0.09388086199760437,
0.4983552098274231,
0.4594621956348419,
-0.5383144021034241,
1.0328326225280762,
0.5345823764801025,
0.13750579953193665,
0.6783376336097717,
-0.6247252821922302,
0.45454204082489014,
-0.6742098331451416,
-0.3215174376964569,
-0.6088383793830872,
-0.2680812180042267,
-0.5353966951370239,
-0.4919302761554718,
0.37810400128364563,
0.1649487316608429,
0.3460107743740082,
0.518115758895874,
-0.49855318665504456,
0.353659451007843,
0.36423587799072266,
0.13325953483581543,
0.18802575767040253,
0.2418222725391388,
0.151020810008049,
-0.3712734282016754,
-0.47683727741241455,
-0.373342365026474,
0.9956139922142029,
0.14156927168369293,
0.6096028685569763,
-0.10900125652551651,
0.900748074054718,
0.3269404470920563,
0.4420852065086365,
-0.9292223453521729,
0.728848934173584,
-0.21376743912696838,
-0.5101010203361511,
-0.2621116638183594,
-0.5210641026496887,
-0.974824070930481,
0.44544264674186707,
-0.3156214654445648,
-0.7044387459754944,
0.5905295014381409,
0.21547262370586395,
0.31426161527633667,
0.49902480840682983,
-0.9231619834899902,
0.03096720203757286,
0.25769925117492676,
-0.18809756636619568,
-0.6830143332481384,
-0.29320627450942993,
0.020537272095680237,
-0.2411089986562729,
0.38369593024253845,
0.20628158748149872,
0.612634539604187,
1.1519203186035156,
-0.533436119556427,
0.7612606287002563,
-0.6564416885375977,
-0.43472006916999817,
0.38707488775253296,
0.3160124719142914,
0.34773537516593933,
-0.4661834239959717,
-0.10353441536426544,
0.1222948357462883,
0.16739675402641296,
-0.40574580430984497,
-0.8052824139595032,
0.3253895342350006,
-0.6031973958015442,
-0.6647549867630005,
-0.3801679313182831,
-0.6552302241325378,
-0.373161256313324,
-0.07466195523738861,
0.13410773873329163,
0.6184732913970947,
-0.4653884768486023,
0.09269922971725464,
0.3960501551628113,
-0.5037534236907959,
0.03501427546143532,
0.17280597984790802,
-0.3889164924621582,
0.17234691977500916,
1.0349968671798706,
0.701783299446106,
0.4535174071788788,
0.2992759943008423,
-0.17073777318000793,
-0.08530080318450928,
-0.46671828627586365,
0.11113337427377701,
0.23824097216129303,
-0.8876948356628418,
0.15654714405536652,
-0.0727703794836998,
-0.3538426458835602,
-0.3403419852256775,
-0.06750849634408951,
-0.4715736508369446,
-0.9354486465454102,
-0.13118380308151245,
-0.3112342059612274,
-0.1558501273393631,
0.7933212518692017,
-0.22794252634048462,
0.27325868606567383,
-0.49140411615371704,
0.4095679819583893,
0.08539971709251404,
0.04544222354888916,
-0.15521720051765442,
-0.4080740213394165,
-0.5147988200187683,
0.3336496651172638,
0.015462108887732029,
-0.62480229139328,
0.5854259729385376,
0.22378063201904297,
0.5260118842124939,
0.47992128133773804,
-0.143083393573761,
0.8046659827232361,
-0.5361928939819336,
0.5164651870727539,
0.14779573678970337,
-0.807352602481842,
0.5162527561187744,
-0.31196561455726624,
0.06776871532201767,
-0.10110429674386978,
0.26788005232810974,
-0.7428076863288879,
-0.3552793562412262,
-0.4735642969608307,
-0.6000072956085205,
0.4289170801639557,
0.2386879026889801,
0.05335555598139763,
-0.17030256986618042,
0.8756462931632996,
0.06982852518558502,
0.14692221581935883,
-0.15653645992279053,
-0.5524600744247437,
-0.28647884726524353,
-0.033392008394002914,
-0.4284490942955017,
-0.5148341059684753,
-0.06206328421831131,
-0.25455182790756226,
0.3791482150554657,
0.15492910146713257,
0.7878926992416382,
0.032843928784132004,
-0.33451393246650696,
-0.14489249885082245,
0.12260615825653076,
0.2850179672241211,
0.7710027098655701,
-0.2726845443248749,
0.18159937858581543,
-0.3146580755710602,
-0.33093148469924927,
0.1831618696451187,
-0.157948300242424,
-0.37508752942085266,
-0.0464797206223011,
0.41178348660469055,
0.5753177404403687,
-0.1641456037759781,
-0.22290244698524475,
0.04036976769566536,
0.22333018481731415,
-0.19150002300739288,
-0.25226616859436035,
0.07310541719198227,
-0.27541857957839966,
-0.24875733256340027,
0.681294322013855,
0.32280245423316956,
0.3397175669670105,
-0.9736360907554626,
0.44498565793037415,
0.21347302198410034,
-0.471092164516449,
-0.6291646361351013,
0.32746532559394836,
-0.226206436753273,
-0.11332603543996811,
0.46926918625831604,
0.08733176440000534,
-0.5034490823745728,
0.6510437726974487,
0.8256441354751587,
0.4430256187915802,
-0.5115434527397156,
0.6303434371948242,
0.21117934584617615,
0.13072393834590912,
0.09473924338817596,
0.1554928570985794,
0.3177740275859833,
-1.2420083284378052,
-0.5595547556877136,
-0.22291244566440582,
-0.26202085614204407,
0.007690375205129385,
-0.945368766784668,
-0.1236351951956749,
-0.3576309084892273,
-0.045370448380708694,
0.3724731206893921,
-0.18006101250648499,
-0.38148313760757446,
0.4654497504234314,
0.31391072273254395,
0.47883349657058716,
-1.2301992177963257,
1.0904051065444946,
0.7860052585601807,
-0.23267552256584167,
-0.5537136793136597,
0.04724815860390663,
0.2665967345237732,
-0.7507014870643616,
0.7692664265632629,
-0.26404449343681335,
-0.14639323949813843,
-0.1929638683795929,
-0.7825057506561279,
-1.1224607229232788,
0.22235560417175293,
0.469728022813797,
-0.45630308985710144,
-0.030397091060876846,
0.48679837584495544,
0.9249621629714966,
-0.14179006218910217,
-0.29073449969291687,
0.360731840133667,
0.21389402449131012,
0.21181344985961914,
-0.8649020195007324,
-0.08027257770299911,
-0.2040807455778122,
0.09034313261508942,
0.2767322063446045,
-0.2967170774936676,
0.9015026092529297,
0.12498824298381805,
-0.4144446849822998,
-0.11326571553945541,
0.6058273315429688,
-0.05598951503634453,
-0.1408233642578125,
0.8586031794548035,
0.25906896591186523,
0.7176389694213867,
-0.17982521653175354,
0.7703973650932312,
-0.06435239315032959,
0.6618698835372925,
0.7640321850776672,
-0.47489944100379944,
0.7374675273895264,
0.88091641664505,
-0.0785261020064354,
0.774046003818512,
0.2633589804172516,
0.05627920851111412,
0.6624273061752319,
0.28760212659835815,
0.19530263543128967,
0.08597401529550552,
-0.27471330761909485,
-0.3184374272823334,
0.837720513343811,
0.977436363697052,
-0.24719320237636566,
-0.10141590982675552,
0.3729679584503174,
-0.1039125844836235,
0.2628403604030609,
-0.19927027821540833,
0.5863202810287476,
0.1473274976015091,
-0.35515618324279785,
0.7302858829498291,
-0.12005697190761566,
0.1157580241560936,
-0.3914199769496918,
-0.2992474138736725,
-0.045503608882427216,
0.5659863352775574,
-0.3493345081806183,
-0.6672200560569763,
0.836556613445282,
-0.5216977000236511,
-0.2570859491825104,
-0.4288932979106903,
0.6978091597557068,
-0.5069654583930969,
-0.44482287764549255,
0.3716218173503876,
0.5445126295089722,
0.19638364017009735,
0.24941956996917725,
-0.4353989064693451,
-0.01853022351861,
0.22691373527050018,
-0.32527539134025574,
0.40240564942359924,
0.059425871819257736,
-0.3603895604610443,
0.5788642764091492,
0.4550749659538269,
0.48428836464881897,
-0.17642028629779816,
-0.0010310326470062137,
0.8721424341201782,
-0.5585123896598816,
-0.5878735184669495,
-0.3174033761024475,
0.0201114472001791,
-0.23645901679992676,
0.2562376856803894,
0.7911967635154724,
0.6709293723106384,
0.8112316727638245,
-0.017334701493382454,
0.801277220249176,
-0.29922598600387573,
0.9173821806907654,
-0.41179391741752625,
0.4867052435874939,
-0.4381580054759979,
0.4203236699104309,
-0.8334903120994568,
-1.2387315034866333,
-0.5081802010536194,
0.7881764769554138,
-0.6652302742004395,
-0.2509253919124603,
0.7168768048286438,
0.7073427438735962,
-0.036850232630968094,
-0.06232259050011635,
0.34140825271606445,
0.564293622970581,
0.5365031361579895,
0.10821771621704102,
0.6982852816581726,
-0.3632587790489197,
0.39031821489334106,
-0.39371246099472046,
-0.30058303475379944,
0.17443488538265228,
-0.2436925321817398,
-0.4375245273113251,
-1.0295906066894531,
-0.6135058999061584,
-0.404599130153656,
0.16914604604244232,
0.7908586859703064,
0.742477297782898,
-1.1173185110092163,
-0.2255527377128601,
0.2264576554298401,
-0.10643173009157181,
-0.2632240355014801,
-0.2951388359069824,
0.8061650395393372,
0.018481291830539703,
-0.7830238938331604,
0.4691143035888672,
0.16486193239688873,
-0.11866682767868042,
-0.3418734073638916,
0.44484320282936096,
-0.14935995638370514,
-0.038441117852926254,
0.6594492793083191,
0.21836671233177185,
-0.26155325770378113,
-0.8184716701507568,
-0.2776648700237274,
0.08620589226484299,
0.38452431559562683,
0.9102559685707092,
-1.144228458404541,
0.6009087562561035,
0.6293908357620239,
0.05115325748920441,
0.7626245617866516,
0.1972229927778244,
0.774135410785675,
-0.9940096139907837,
0.7402861714363098,
-0.025183508172631264,
0.29928120970726013,
0.014723594300448895,
-0.2313784509897232,
0.5106738209724426,
0.5753968358039856,
-0.0002632089890539646,
-0.9507198929786682,
0.3472360670566559,
-0.5633355379104614,
-0.47108861804008484,
1.0388559103012085,
-0.0026891224551945925,
-0.20845484733581543,
-0.30804765224456787,
-0.123403400182724,
0.2667025923728943,
-0.12226758897304535,
0.9520187377929688,
0.4584601819515228,
-0.10179346054792404,
-0.030442431569099426,
-0.1248200535774231,
0.21252185106277466,
0.22595885396003723,
-0.5033362507820129,
-0.15871794521808624,
0.6148169636726379,
0.21385106444358826,
0.5613684058189392,
0.366635799407959,
-0.2840421795845032,
-0.35546404123306274,
-0.06912805885076523,
0.25581294298171997,
0.31183895468711853,
-0.3221874237060547,
-0.14761580526828766,
0.46416670083999634,
-0.3669927418231964,
-0.3047301769256592
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16139v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16139v1
|
A Little Leak Will Sink a Great Ship: Survey of Transparency for Large Language Models from Start to Finish
| 2024-03-24T13:21:58 | 2024-03-24T13:21:58 |
Masahiro Kaneko, Timothy Baldwin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are trained on massive web-crawled corpora. This
poses risks of leakage, including personal information, copyrighted texts, and
benchmark datasets. Such leakage leads to undermining human trust in AI due to
potential unauthorized generation of content or overestimation of performance.
We establish the following three criteria concerning the leakage issues: (1)
leakage rate: the proportion of leaked data in training data, (2) output rate:
the ease of generating leaked data, and (3) detection rate: the detection
performance of leaked versus non-leaked data. Despite the leakage rate being
the origin of data leakage issues, it is not understood how it affects the
output rate and detection rate. In this paper, we conduct an experimental
survey to elucidate the relationship between the leakage rate and both the
output rate and detection rate for personal information, copyrighted texts, and
benchmark data. Additionally, we propose a self-detection approach that uses
few-shot learning in which LLMs detect whether instances are present or absent
in their training data, in contrast to previous methods that do not employ
explicit learning. To explore the ease of generating leaked information, we
create a dataset of prompts designed to elicit personal information,
copyrighted text, and benchmarks from LLMs. Our experiments reveal that LLMs
produce leaked information in most cases despite less such data in their
training set. This indicates even small amounts of leaked data can greatly
affect outputs. Our self-detection method showed superior performance compared
to existing detection methods.
|
[
-0.5258925557136536,
-0.5432054996490479,
0.8206691145896912,
0.0009049925720319152,
-0.28782597184181213,
-0.06386616826057434,
-0.12712405622005463,
-0.7512993216514587,
-0.09958960115909576,
0.5673284530639648,
-0.4662669897079468,
-0.3780989646911621,
-0.9626840949058533,
-0.1858898252248764,
-0.6675041913986206,
1.012625813484192,
0.21305201947689056,
-0.05487814545631409,
-0.08957827091217041,
0.09961257129907608,
-0.36917561292648315,
-0.5174003839492798,
-0.7548587918281555,
-0.2844536304473877,
0.31729477643966675,
0.527335524559021,
0.3548479378223419,
0.7852218151092529,
0.24444147944450378,
0.2501543164253235,
-0.17632269859313965,
-0.15616244077682495,
-0.8013261556625366,
0.21483080089092255,
-0.37126651406288147,
-0.7201843857765198,
-0.06670280545949936,
-0.03290684148669243,
0.43950673937797546,
0.252096951007843,
-0.09887045621871948,
0.4557228088378906,
0.3370506763458252,
0.9223390817642212,
-0.7817862033843994,
0.3630296289920807,
-0.7766295075416565,
-0.019750673323869705,
-0.6082983016967773,
-0.1634901463985443,
-0.5179399251937866,
-0.08561453968286514,
-0.050036218017339706,
-0.33898797631263733,
0.2553388178348541,
0.08322275429964066,
0.6649752855300903,
0.406036913394928,
-0.15208330750465393,
-0.6076118350028992,
-0.6567773222923279,
0.8300610780715942,
-0.6488742232322693,
0.24519987404346466,
0.3665047585964203,
0.3327735662460327,
-0.03085148148238659,
-0.4930042028427124,
-0.6040230393409729,
-0.08309106528759003,
-0.017493389546871185,
0.038228582590818405,
-0.4320128560066223,
-0.3043297231197357,
0.21120181679725647,
0.2849513292312622,
-0.5794082283973694,
0.20634908974170685,
-0.2904563248157501,
-0.37888771295547485,
0.8910859823226929,
0.1272287368774414,
0.24615710973739624,
-0.13889449834823608,
-0.4564482271671295,
-0.42305436730384827,
-0.9777072668075562,
-0.2498548924922943,
0.9307081699371338,
0.302109956741333,
-0.3535909354686737,
0.4469505548477173,
-0.0434483103454113,
0.321307897567749,
-0.18908973038196564,
0.05406278744339943,
0.08791442215442657,
-0.36628258228302,
-0.06121496856212616,
0.12775926291942596,
1.0830128192901611,
-0.16584771871566772,
0.4930863380432129,
0.11311102658510208,
-0.25841769576072693,
-0.16240742802619934,
0.05879710614681244,
-0.7355398535728455,
-0.12242825329303741,
0.25425803661346436,
-0.36052799224853516,
-0.39079564809799194,
0.08870694786310196,
-0.558907151222229,
-0.6188022494316101,
-0.10763047635555267,
0.38263386487960815,
-0.3255787193775177,
-0.2654532194137573,
-0.029081135988235474,
-0.1016521155834198,
0.03588871657848358,
0.1972905546426773,
-0.8420259356498718,
0.19643783569335938,
0.7830492258071899,
0.7863453030586243,
-0.3334572911262512,
-0.24034839868545532,
-0.5387200117111206,
0.19999228417873383,
-0.3217836618423462,
0.7831818461418152,
-0.13720548152923584,
-0.22407744824886322,
0.1825203150510788,
-0.22182302176952362,
0.39667582511901855,
-0.5223666429519653,
0.4058956801891327,
-0.37410998344421387,
0.08774994313716888,
-0.16906042397022247,
-0.6276667714118958,
0.20881067216396332,
0.20660346746444702,
-0.7733457088470459,
0.6005215048789978,
-0.16424323618412018,
-1.0368376970291138,
0.303181529045105,
-0.5607797503471375,
-0.1527356654405594,
0.041417527943849564,
-0.4453991651535034,
-0.5903120636940002,
-0.027318039909005165,
0.07821974158287048,
0.7904501557350159,
0.012780788354575634,
0.2893708050251007,
-0.1375555843114853,
-0.4763358235359192,
0.45566993951797485,
-0.6581539511680603,
0.8518596887588501,
0.20408062636852264,
-0.3557647466659546,
-0.31773996353149414,
-0.46678879857063293,
-0.12997294962406158,
0.10282112658023834,
-0.4840547740459442,
-0.3750898540019989,
-0.19658805429935455,
-0.10874577611684799,
0.0747009739279747,
0.14193879067897797,
-0.5758348703384399,
0.17867055535316467,
-0.36727309226989746,
0.2084416300058365,
0.955693781375885,
0.16773106157779694,
0.4874737858772278,
-0.3291415274143219,
0.5231348276138306,
0.24670542776584625,
0.12334024906158447,
-0.33393537998199463,
-0.693934440612793,
-0.7237797379493713,
-0.19908423721790314,
0.38477250933647156,
0.24869205057621002,
-0.4952503442764282,
0.15107525885105133,
-0.40199869871139526,
-0.5732870101928711,
-0.5789164900779724,
0.4073196351528168,
0.597129225730896,
0.11251433193683624,
0.12274573743343353,
-0.24372991919517517,
-0.23121421039104462,
-0.9189429879188538,
-0.7090568542480469,
-0.4318183958530426,
-0.2638861835002899,
0.5495011210441589,
0.6381347179412842,
0.11152476072311401,
0.8234658241271973,
-0.538918137550354,
-0.6152074337005615,
-0.21548502147197723,
0.4603008031845093,
0.02400684915482998,
0.47759631276130676,
0.19538746774196625,
-0.44405844807624817,
-0.6590223908424377,
-0.37585973739624023,
-0.7355143427848816,
0.12327075749635696,
-0.07956158369779587,
0.00495868781581521,
0.4162801206111908,
0.5433456301689148,
-0.5620037913322449,
0.19187842309474945,
0.8231833577156067,
-0.31759053468704224,
0.3777633011341095,
-0.09742359817028046,
-0.31653696298599243,
-0.8433374762535095,
0.07956978678703308,
-0.21824899315834045,
-0.3861158490180969,
-0.34044867753982544,
0.03532649949193001,
0.23174886405467987,
-0.1092582643032074,
-0.7696729302406311,
0.5886368751525879,
-0.7368963360786438,
-0.20893411338329315,
-0.22920885682106018,
0.20661911368370056,
-0.047478292137384415,
0.13315464556217194,
-0.21202483773231506,
0.7355177402496338,
0.5846192240715027,
-0.6764842867851257,
-0.06234804540872574,
0.1726318895816803,
-0.4630613625049591,
0.1889951229095459,
-0.4506883919239044,
0.46363183856010437,
-0.3221704363822937,
0.1761218011379242,
-1.016726016998291,
-0.1626444011926651,
0.24384436011314392,
-0.6273557543754578,
0.6715594530105591,
-0.47908785939216614,
-0.5359070301055908,
0.0553133524954319,
-0.5208802223205566,
0.03972872719168663,
0.374301016330719,
-0.5478925704956055,
0.047655295580625534,
0.35281088948249817,
-0.10991305112838745,
-0.8755512833595276,
-1.215141773223877,
0.1596575379371643,
-0.06695124506950378,
-0.6406298279762268,
0.2609422504901886,
-0.1776910126209259,
0.016595227643847466,
0.0034119472838938236,
-0.02255668118596077,
-0.129181906580925,
0.21101559698581696,
0.37103506922721863,
0.16436614096164703,
-0.15470671653747559,
0.08884411305189133,
-0.13234451413154602,
-0.17418523132801056,
0.27042195200920105,
-0.07853583246469498,
0.6818106174468994,
-0.17304331064224243,
-0.43992435932159424,
-0.5408969521522522,
0.21970245242118835,
0.40238362550735474,
0.06241018697619438,
0.9630802273750305,
0.5141720175743103,
-0.22776484489440918,
-0.5112300515174866,
-0.5827349424362183,
-0.3405856788158417,
-0.49120229482650757,
0.112883061170578,
-0.1274278312921524,
-0.6928790807723999,
0.38996732234954834,
0.13319461047649384,
-0.09942816942930222,
0.25045958161354065,
0.48898041248321533,
-0.04732579365372658,
0.6425787210464478,
1.1042048931121826,
-0.44625502824783325,
0.35881415009498596,
-0.4700199365615845,
0.25954964756965637,
-0.5318006277084351,
-0.12570472061634064,
-0.5995640158653259,
-0.20263616740703583,
-0.7488959431648254,
-0.328481525182724,
0.16865286231040955,
0.09189081937074661,
-0.1626926213502884,
0.16872626543045044,
-0.37643712759017944,
0.8218593001365662,
0.4054512083530426,
-0.13795961439609528,
0.7144172787666321,
-0.04499007761478424,
0.18531839549541473,
0.019256724044680595,
-0.49572592973709106,
-0.572488009929657,
1.37986421585083,
0.6162551641464233,
1.0584495067596436,
0.25300681591033936,
1.051042914390564,
0.38223686814308167,
0.27000370621681213,
-0.7544406652450562,
0.2804934084415436,
0.0021877733524888754,
-0.8943719863891602,
-0.5193136930465698,
-0.34647437930107117,
-0.9815760850906372,
-0.024879105389118195,
-0.09754049777984619,
-0.629069447517395,
0.32992127537727356,
0.33994388580322266,
-0.1398557424545288,
0.09408622235059738,
-0.501061201095581,
0.6252090334892273,
-0.10465351492166519,
-0.5001476407051086,
-0.02946997433900833,
-0.41651490330696106,
0.8229171633720398,
-0.38994136452674866,
0.21801894903182983,
-0.19926661252975464,
-0.2423115223646164,
0.7911787033081055,
-0.05351768061518669,
0.9171950817108154,
-0.0980459451675415,
-0.1073099821805954,
0.2259020209312439,
0.47213974595069885,
0.8139375448226929,
0.18720832467079163,
-0.09804198890924454,
0.47486069798469543,
-0.25618135929107666,
-0.25047069787979126,
-0.31367748975753784,
0.5553005933761597,
-0.7227460145950317,
-0.36084237694740295,
-0.6059079766273499,
-0.17210552096366882,
-0.18185555934906006,
0.13090312480926514,
0.7150377035140991,
-0.02580108493566513,
-0.0162266306579113,
0.10076712816953659,
0.7898475527763367,
-0.14217084646224976,
0.632387101650238,
0.7999063730239868,
-0.07363075017929077,
0.22218476235866547,
0.8806928396224976,
0.04450332373380661,
0.3891766667366028,
0.009212604723870754,
0.4176086485385895,
-0.30469435453414917,
-0.8189414143562317,
-0.47123047709465027,
0.5198392868041992,
-0.5593706369400024,
-0.5122405886650085,
-0.40728652477264404,
-0.43401646614074707,
-0.1850050836801529,
0.24480979144573212,
-0.863590657711029,
-0.19387096166610718,
-0.24983984231948853,
-0.02758578024804592,
0.13481250405311584,
1.0866535902023315,
-0.08879455178976059,
0.3552725911140442,
-0.77707439661026,
0.12483641505241394,
0.21321941912174225,
0.22686509788036346,
0.09828152507543564,
-0.5948712825775146,
-0.1372685730457306,
-0.09179014712572098,
-0.44945552945137024,
-0.6903156638145447,
0.43300485610961914,
0.12815330922603607,
0.5260674953460693,
0.6212748289108276,
0.11405237019062042,
0.2957894802093506,
-0.37056300044059753,
0.8963415622711182,
0.18185804784297943,
-1.019229769706726,
0.5193620920181274,
-0.2475351244211197,
0.0954509750008583,
0.5856342911720276,
0.6706888675689697,
-0.312755286693573,
-0.668196976184845,
-0.7396875619888306,
-0.6996036767959595,
0.8010085225105286,
0.28032609820365906,
0.4029223918914795,
0.2453516125679016,
0.04068644717335701,
0.19752538204193115,
0.4789629578590393,
-0.7706484198570251,
-0.4959414601325989,
0.13211573660373688,
0.04509004205465317,
-0.007799988612532616,
-0.43332797288894653,
-0.07224626839160919,
0.16997505724430084,
0.5875180959701538,
-0.13902246952056885,
0.26665621995925903,
0.176627978682518,
-0.3118768036365509,
-0.05694723129272461,
0.5225127339363098,
0.38292160630226135,
0.6360387802124023,
-0.005859408061951399,
0.22312623262405396,
-0.20641091465950012,
-0.6451417803764343,
0.23629941046237946,
-0.366402268409729,
-0.2129003405570984,
0.005414241924881935,
0.5574710965156555,
0.445208340883255,
-0.08527275919914246,
-0.663730263710022,
1.0970078706741333,
-0.05204154551029205,
0.04218105226755142,
-0.4168911874294281,
0.17560821771621704,
0.28803595900535583,
0.09259281307458878,
0.2904849946498871,
-0.04965439438819885,
0.2342633605003357,
-0.8685269951820374,
0.12583886086940765,
0.4616847336292267,
-0.2507590055465698,
-0.18490146100521088,
0.4314814805984497,
-0.10358120501041412,
-0.03542536497116089,
0.5862722992897034,
-0.2932673990726471,
-0.4923311173915863,
0.21034663915634155,
0.5041680335998535,
0.6677677035331726,
-0.344575971364975,
0.2647115886211395,
0.17775915563106537,
0.4980226159095764,
-0.24334771931171417,
0.2151268869638443,
0.06906673312187195,
-0.7293233871459961,
-0.39370182156562805,
-0.51052325963974,
-0.35340720415115356,
0.6422539353370667,
-0.6246042251586914,
0.12553338706493378,
-0.3630184829235077,
-0.057814858853816986,
-0.12383783608675003,
-0.013203408569097519,
-0.762963593006134,
-0.2293827086687088,
0.5874975323677063,
0.850102961063385,
-0.9879282712936401,
0.6036826968193054,
-0.0047765690833330154,
-0.4529462456703186,
-0.7275536060333252,
0.1504703164100647,
0.17503605782985687,
-0.7870059609413147,
0.7339959144592285,
0.11269308626651764,
0.0049539776518940926,
-0.16988877952098846,
-0.9275016188621521,
-1.069846272468567,
1.009189486503601,
0.8458876609802246,
-0.8287048935890198,
-0.00716327503323555,
0.44348272681236267,
0.3962000906467438,
-0.1946353018283844,
0.11537761241197586,
0.7556314468383789,
0.4828450083732605,
-0.3460398018360138,
-0.7553903460502625,
0.15945671498775482,
0.1084979996085167,
-0.061881426721811295,
-0.08321945369243622,
-0.646641194820404,
0.9866772890090942,
-0.07788609713315964,
-0.37887370586395264,
-0.1575303077697754,
0.3552013337612152,
0.2568153440952301,
0.38709014654159546,
0.3918951749801636,
0.43725839257240295,
0.8087944388389587,
0.10431423783302307,
1.2438750267028809,
-0.09446821361780167,
0.25955191254615784,
1.0909353494644165,
-0.017888594418764114,
1.076781988143921,
0.43944406509399414,
-0.03787644952535629,
0.2807735502719879,
0.23065470159053802,
-0.09174907207489014,
0.43025290966033936,
0.48884665966033936,
-0.0876329317688942,
0.08439218252897263,
-0.12933267652988434,
-0.25478458404541016,
0.4930057227611542,
0.25139883160591125,
-0.5034381747245789,
-0.16006909310817719,
-0.06630487740039825,
0.398227334022522,
0.01087930053472519,
-0.13461807370185852,
0.8103066086769104,
0.33826085925102234,
-0.4465860426425934,
0.593631386756897,
-0.09648475795984268,
0.7267301082611084,
-0.4909655451774597,
0.0022471367847174406,
-0.36104995012283325,
0.07802131026983261,
-0.44398072361946106,
-0.976681113243103,
0.11379940807819366,
0.2180348038673401,
0.013456895016133785,
-0.23653258383274078,
0.7659062147140503,
-0.327393114566803,
-0.07021573185920715,
0.40397191047668457,
0.8212700486183167,
0.52264004945755,
-0.5770163536071777,
-0.5003268122673035,
0.550231397151947,
-0.06977725774049759,
-0.3674924373626709,
0.5168412327766418,
0.1459359973669052,
0.2365310788154602,
0.8442886471748352,
0.6905160546302795,
0.39740678668022156,
0.3141492009162903,
-0.05594891309738159,
0.7795988321304321,
-0.5320031046867371,
-0.4405847489833832,
-0.9681844711303711,
0.4329981207847595,
-0.2258346527814865,
-0.11314112693071365,
0.8194541931152344,
0.7422942519187927,
0.8654139041900635,
-0.12840178608894348,
0.9511436820030212,
0.3968363106250763,
0.4149319529533386,
-0.691973865032196,
1.1749740839004517,
-0.2725772559642792,
0.49887847900390625,
-0.13395321369171143,
-0.9716442227363586,
0.18246102333068848,
0.24884086847305298,
-0.048101358115673065,
-0.18016520142555237,
0.8398877382278442,
0.5573011636734009,
-0.28872495889663696,
-0.029223347082734108,
0.40325090289115906,
0.49259936809539795,
0.4171810448169708,
0.5478101968765259,
0.903838038444519,
-0.5372584462165833,
0.8473533987998962,
-0.4351363182067871,
0.10513907670974731,
-0.27072674036026,
-1.0047122240066528,
-0.7846635580062866,
-0.4234241247177124,
-0.342530220746994,
-0.18510819971561432,
0.06374826282262802,
0.08875416964292526,
0.852435827255249,
-0.6370671987533569,
-0.1784633845090866,
-0.1720162034034729,
0.07904905825853348,
0.17631885409355164,
-0.2384321242570877,
0.3411584496498108,
-0.20641475915908813,
-0.8246329426765442,
0.5418582558631897,
-0.08520832657814026,
0.25975632667541504,
-0.715563952922821,
0.08533242344856262,
0.17576093971729279,
0.09091749042272568,
0.4080282747745514,
0.321574330329895,
-0.35620710253715515,
-0.15816451609134674,
-0.43708017468452454,
-0.2833671271800995,
-0.15098866820335388,
0.6582112908363342,
-0.7319780588150024,
0.20881788432598114,
0.5301292538642883,
0.7359352111816406,
0.9341205358505249,
0.030106443911790848,
0.3451009690761566,
-1.0289340019226074,
0.054550204426050186,
0.3035888373851776,
0.1710764467716217,
0.45381563901901245,
-0.6341318488121033,
0.4544174373149872,
-0.11386284977197647,
-0.5366528630256653,
-0.9771397709846497,
0.14053381979465485,
-0.6839882731437683,
-0.27432504296302795,
1.0272260904312134,
-0.27473974227905273,
-0.38367462158203125,
-0.22240930795669556,
0.17603467404842377,
0.08376222848892212,
-0.6338710188865662,
0.6657543778419495,
0.7848483920097351,
-0.16365046799182892,
0.18818895518779755,
-0.9600666165351868,
0.655474841594696,
0.05640210583806038,
-0.8176932334899902,
0.2731066942214966,
0.3727617859840393,
0.6085563898086548,
0.3242698907852173,
0.5546185970306396,
-0.14968624711036682,
-0.005208367481827736,
0.03296768665313721,
-0.09342557191848755,
-0.2611926794052124,
-0.5832700729370117,
-0.6203685998916626,
0.14356406033039093,
0.21880671381950378,
-0.12815247476100922
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16129v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16129v1
|
A Survey on Lexical Ambiguity Detection and Word Sense Disambiguation
| 2024-03-24T12:58:48 | 2024-03-24T12:58:48 |
Miuru Abeysiriwardana, Deshan Sumanathilaka
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper explores techniques that focus on understanding and resolving
ambiguity in language within the field of natural language processing (NLP),
highlighting the complexity of linguistic phenomena such as polysemy and
homonymy and their implications for computational models. Focusing extensively
on Word Sense Disambiguation (WSD), it outlines diverse approaches ranging from
deep learning techniques to leveraging lexical resources and knowledge graphs
like WordNet. The paper introduces cutting-edge methodologies like word sense
extension (WSE) and neuromyotonic approaches, enhancing disambiguation accuracy
by predicting new word senses. It examines specific applications in biomedical
disambiguation and language specific optimisation and discusses the
significance of cognitive metaphors in discourse analysis. The research
identifies persistent challenges in the field, such as the scarcity of sense
annotated corpora and the complexity of informal clinical texts. It concludes
by suggesting future directions, including using large language models, visual
WSD, and multilingual WSD systems, emphasising the ongoing evolution in
addressing lexical complexities in NLP. This thinking perspective highlights
the advancement in this field to enable computers to understand language more
accurately.
|
[
-0.4981148838996887,
-0.7685136795043945,
0.9885044097900391,
0.10631223767995834,
-0.24417397379875183,
0.2624303102493286,
-0.25503382086753845,
-0.6920137405395508,
0.007625103462487459,
-0.30727630853652954,
-0.5107723474502563,
-0.30029961466789246,
-1.1859866380691528,
0.32666921615600586,
-0.10705487430095673,
0.14286865293979645,
-0.007828553207218647,
0.16629824042320251,
-0.3722248375415802,
-0.5655640363693237,
-0.44079047441482544,
-0.39447665214538574,
-0.4064408540725708,
-0.5612025260925293,
0.5817776918411255,
-0.14283055067062378,
1.0981550216674805,
0.299311101436615,
0.5417300462722778,
0.3387870490550995,
-0.6131612062454224,
0.3951279819011688,
0.10580488294363022,
0.026137303560972214,
-0.5203027725219727,
-0.3003663420677185,
-0.13370618224143982,
-0.2735337018966675,
0.12273264676332474,
1.4412845373153687,
-0.1131206750869751,
-0.19779238104820251,
-0.08022631704807281,
0.7085875272750854,
-0.9009618759155273,
-0.09115753322839737,
-0.605622410774231,
0.10029706358909607,
-0.1659466028213501,
0.19893129169940948,
0.04728041961789131,
0.02867109514772892,
0.22178243100643158,
-0.6408229470252991,
-0.08584664762020111,
0.09106187522411346,
0.9416460990905762,
0.5977703332901001,
-0.3644864559173584,
-0.6555991172790527,
-0.40492329001426697,
0.7127565145492554,
-0.7419748306274414,
0.8075700402259827,
0.47585415840148926,
0.14361153542995453,
-0.3113594949245453,
-0.6997504830360413,
-0.9213457107543945,
0.05745582655072212,
0.0773581862449646,
0.008221686817705631,
-0.5121142268180847,
0.3949039578437805,
0.261567085981369,
0.3026377856731415,
-0.5981414914131165,
0.31352826952934265,
-0.3260479271411896,
-0.3560210168361664,
0.30276721715927124,
-0.04665633663535118,
0.3180064558982849,
-0.3225788176059723,
-0.17121590673923492,
0.06524734944105148,
-0.14530304074287415,
-0.21529531478881836,
0.1939648985862732,
0.07688044011592865,
0.10645604878664017,
0.4597817659378052,
0.10685909539461136,
1.1658750772476196,
-0.45829418301582336,
0.020825516432523727,
0.34512555599212646,
-0.3436157703399658,
-0.28897035121917725,
-0.09958431869745255,
0.5217042565345764,
0.1718055009841919,
0.08729423582553864,
-0.1074809655547142,
0.013338140211999416,
0.4851548373699188,
0.2226659655570984,
-0.18744328618049622,
-0.017180411145091057,
0.3848326802253723,
-0.21905310451984406,
0.0636971965432167,
-0.184581458568573,
-0.5502383708953857,
-0.6009765267372131,
-0.759960949420929,
0.3272097706794739,
-0.8976635336875916,
-0.3451349139213562,
0.6116840243339539,
-0.6000286936759949,
0.022853704169392586,
0.20059560239315033,
-0.6650316119194031,
0.2304905503988266,
0.6284710168838501,
0.7091119885444641,
-0.0767611414194107,
-0.23013770580291748,
0.07793990522623062,
0.04978092759847641,
-0.3205597400665283,
0.5486627221107483,
-0.4637719988822937,
-0.24415720999240875,
-0.23178642988204956,
-0.29858851432800293,
0.07729482650756836,
-0.5553570985794067,
0.3245508074760437,
-0.3900931477546692,
0.191298246383667,
-0.2449835240840912,
-0.6858597993850708,
-0.2415591925382614,
0.32726845145225525,
-0.4886744022369385,
0.9889741539955139,
0.31418126821517944,
-0.7431860566139221,
0.528823971748352,
-0.6444204449653625,
-0.21122561395168304,
0.3685756325721741,
-0.24421998858451843,
0.18627409636974335,
0.5434783101081848,
0.10812626034021378,
0.08398008346557617,
-0.24764873087406158,
0.4475971758365631,
-0.22481335699558258,
-0.2161284238100052,
0.15796135365962982,
-0.15726275742053986,
0.8053175210952759,
0.3810808062553406,
-0.1139766052365303,
-0.11876614391803741,
-0.7127070426940918,
0.1703157275915146,
0.08321745693683624,
0.16418038308620453,
-0.868699312210083,
-0.09501633793115616,
0.011223389767110348,
0.2387511283159256,
0.44579678773880005,
-0.4643344581127167,
0.09862066060304642,
-0.690202534198761,
0.637668788433075,
0.2688573896884918,
-0.388459175825119,
0.15949945151805878,
0.12241216748952866,
0.5523130893707275,
0.309714138507843,
0.21124006807804108,
0.2148325890302658,
-0.6037350296974182,
-0.49954724311828613,
-0.04656338691711426,
0.598710298538208,
0.4666365087032318,
-0.9184961318969727,
0.642970085144043,
0.02697206288576126,
-0.37873607873916626,
-0.7972474694252014,
-0.06494958698749542,
0.19213174283504486,
0.48025599122047424,
0.5706060528755188,
-0.269832044839859,
-0.5046043992042542,
-0.8091462850570679,
-0.47462543845176697,
-0.44418981671333313,
-0.07182864099740982,
0.006137752439826727,
0.44857534766197205,
-0.6855401992797852,
1.1025887727737427,
-0.5997982621192932,
0.07543003559112549,
-0.05905739217996597,
0.2872958183288574,
0.09693315625190735,
-0.00362688978202641,
0.4695242941379547,
-1.161711573600769,
0.11174125224351883,
-0.05749298632144928,
-0.6860834360122681,
-0.12630821764469147,
0.20783036947250366,
0.1918220967054367,
-0.017584141343832016,
0.6399582624435425,
-0.3743898272514343,
0.5781320929527283,
0.6184806823730469,
-0.24601922929286957,
0.44878220558166504,
-0.31947997212409973,
-0.07295126467943192,
-0.986679196357727,
0.08826086670160294,
-0.1302971988916397,
-0.1466999351978302,
-0.6354086399078369,
0.18349340558052063,
0.11665131896734238,
0.09278672933578491,
-0.3383283317089081,
0.5708405375480652,
-0.6423048377037048,
0.11743088066577911,
-0.39235469698905945,
0.5865015387535095,
0.22980211675167084,
0.01446441002190113,
-0.07713697850704193,
0.4124216139316559,
0.6120490431785583,
-0.6509093642234802,
0.48604315519332886,
0.22228027880191803,
-0.1995909959077835,
0.5322893857955933,
-0.487976610660553,
-0.14876514673233032,
-0.5562288165092468,
-0.40285053849220276,
-1.062214732170105,
-0.1062094196677208,
0.37868818640708923,
-0.6354725360870361,
0.168442502617836,
0.35794565081596375,
-0.40604734420776367,
-0.668329119682312,
0.008280029520392418,
0.7661004066467285,
0.17393825948238373,
-0.3840235471725464,
0.14107303321361542,
0.49989229440689087,
0.24020275473594666,
-0.6761049628257751,
-0.8059138655662537,
0.2589118778705597,
-0.12070877850055695,
-0.402448832988739,
0.4393359422683716,
0.05679239705204964,
-0.6185975670814514,
-0.0355151891708374,
-0.2333015650510788,
-0.26412010192871094,
0.2863317131996155,
0.1354389637708664,
0.20684698224067688,
0.1463739573955536,
0.5980629920959473,
0.22324712574481964,
-0.12133180350065231,
-0.08102356642484665,
-0.351429283618927,
0.5237051248550415,
-0.16989554464817047,
-0.48716384172439575,
0.14585202932357788,
0.47757112979888916,
0.3826553523540497,
-0.08238080888986588,
0.6145157217979431,
0.7688286900520325,
-0.8394932746887207,
0.07754885405302048,
-0.343656063079834,
-0.13676954805850983,
-0.45418381690979004,
0.3298403024673462,
-0.4240606129169464,
-1.031323790550232,
0.4706364870071411,
-0.5178921222686768,
-0.3248130679130554,
0.3846837878227234,
0.3928200304508209,
-0.10513334721326828,
0.8131057620048523,
0.6410041451454163,
0.006504040211439133,
0.11048275232315063,
0.16948236525058746,
0.6635257005691528,
-0.7076385617256165,
0.08409661054611206,
-0.45210519433021545,
-0.34663155674934387,
-0.5742385387420654,
-0.6055458784103394,
0.5589823722839355,
0.41205596923828125,
0.22817079722881317,
0.2913471758365631,
-0.7262080311775208,
0.2953096032142639,
0.07889757305383682,
-0.11711768805980682,
0.42321017384529114,
-0.16495133936405182,
-0.4683348536491394,
-0.26647207140922546,
-0.7375625371932983,
-0.383414626121521,
0.4925265312194824,
0.18500614166259766,
0.3470180928707123,
0.18739670515060425,
0.4939143657684326,
0.18174871802330017,
-0.18739689886569977,
-1.0085409879684448,
0.33723190426826477,
0.13226595520973206,
-0.3307648301124573,
-0.3422994315624237,
-0.3456115126609802,
-1.357587218284607,
0.41705068945884705,
-0.22110645473003387,
-0.8721551299095154,
0.42518508434295654,
0.02115008980035782,
-0.2936643958091736,
0.2749621570110321,
-0.6081308722496033,
0.7082613706588745,
0.0406079962849617,
-0.1627172976732254,
-0.06879793107509613,
-0.7899011969566345,
0.2189446985721588,
0.0025977077893912792,
0.510166347026825,
-0.315026193857193,
-0.35956573486328125,
0.23462848365306854,
-0.2578898072242737,
0.40482768416404724,
-0.03579327091574669,
-0.48344653844833374,
0.21399946510791779,
0.06856873631477356,
-0.1725751906633377,
-0.07244838774204254,
-0.43632060289382935,
0.7302404046058655,
0.35213011503219604,
-0.3585512340068817,
-0.4728390872478485,
0.23740552365779877,
-0.31762993335723877,
-0.43295249342918396,
-0.7359323501586914,
-0.6596627235412598,
-0.6187176704406738,
0.29816877841949463,
0.32394638657569885,
0.14871326088905334,
-0.14943890273571014,
-0.48659926652908325,
0.5488153100013733,
-0.3627530634403229,
0.508804976940155,
0.21205827593803406,
-0.05249088257551193,
0.116026870906353,
0.6803778409957886,
-0.04665651172399521,
0.12599807977676392,
0.181558758020401,
0.2669476270675659,
-0.5156394243240356,
-0.6766542792320251,
-0.35953280329704285,
0.37810128927230835,
-0.4634515941143036,
-0.25938135385513306,
-0.380315363407135,
-0.14154621958732605,
-0.5114431381225586,
-0.13077189028263092,
-0.02576877735555172,
-0.24906125664710999,
-0.24390755593776703,
0.015063033439218998,
0.5583484172821045,
0.5931745171546936,
-0.277064710855484,
0.2717277705669403,
-0.5999171137809753,
0.5792645812034607,
-0.12486264854669571,
0.4799111783504486,
-0.19265830516815186,
-0.1943451315164566,
0.0329129695892334,
0.25083497166633606,
-0.1320461928844452,
-1.3387048244476318,
0.426069974899292,
0.14490702748298645,
0.37933453917503357,
0.3327576220035553,
-0.033385246992111206,
0.8545487523078918,
-0.2771327495574951,
0.7746235132217407,
0.4886070787906647,
-1.1806678771972656,
0.6034825444221497,
-0.22248812019824982,
0.6142736673355103,
0.6404644250869751,
0.6271870136260986,
-1.1267799139022827,
-0.3007439970970154,
-0.5988442897796631,
-1.046898365020752,
0.20653022825717926,
-0.023050427436828613,
-0.1205521821975708,
-0.20354332029819489,
0.5961931347846985,
0.13591504096984863,
0.48253944516181946,
-0.2134905904531479,
-0.19336295127868652,
0.41142788529396057,
-0.4564518928527832,
-0.068214550614357,
0.019160686060786247,
-0.017762240022420883,
-0.5109376311302185,
0.1521328240633011,
-0.39130502939224243,
0.07029058784246445,
0.3045516908168793,
-0.33415475487709045,
0.2613806426525116,
0.31241461634635925,
0.4174765646457672,
1.0652966499328613,
0.2078552395105362,
0.2982257604598999,
0.2905876040458679,
-0.479615181684494,
0.03865504637360573,
-0.12632136046886444,
0.1478593647480011,
0.2976352572441101,
0.2226155549287796,
0.50794917345047,
0.06190795451402664,
-1.0071815252304077,
0.468923956155777,
0.028337860479950905,
-0.27774810791015625,
-0.1376577615737915,
-0.14285658299922943,
0.22663907706737518,
-0.014174290932714939,
0.13254888355731964,
0.1273668259382248,
0.5202699899673462,
-0.5016183257102966,
0.117904432117939,
0.5037333965301514,
-0.4203338027000427,
0.044153377413749695,
0.4927356243133545,
-0.31047651171684265,
-0.12185177952051163,
0.44759491086006165,
-0.4523589313030243,
-0.4448952376842499,
0.5110994577407837,
0.3668196499347687,
0.3834194839000702,
-0.18015669286251068,
0.03351305425167084,
0.09518182277679443,
0.34974852204322815,
0.09011688828468323,
0.6026750206947327,
-0.09771162271499634,
-0.8965147733688354,
-0.20198886096477509,
-0.670114278793335,
-0.4891667664051056,
0.021848304197192192,
-0.8066564798355103,
0.19962862133979797,
-0.29983046650886536,
-0.46684369444847107,
0.4629398584365845,
-0.21476291120052338,
-0.450399786233902,
0.16931147873401642,
0.4386354684829712,
0.8828380107879639,
-0.6741170287132263,
0.6800510883331299,
0.9106260538101196,
0.05853009968996048,
-0.6378722786903381,
-0.07444870471954346,
0.25549694895744324,
-0.7144052386283875,
0.29851844906806946,
-0.04619313403964043,
-0.2818286716938019,
-0.1515427976846695,
-0.4237824082374573,
-0.44936931133270264,
0.6304814219474792,
0.4429764449596405,
-0.6468468904495239,
0.06259791553020477,
0.3048061728477478,
0.7618593573570251,
0.3026256859302521,
0.22649361193180084,
0.966200053691864,
0.7571154832839966,
0.046421293169260025,
-1.0065804719924927,
-0.15727637708187103,
-0.25525227189064026,
0.22486340999603271,
0.6239522695541382,
-0.19276757538318634,
0.6218708157539368,
-0.12910829484462738,
-0.2207207828760147,
-0.07355201244354248,
0.6187677383422852,
0.022885015234351158,
0.46642717719078064,
0.725317656993866,
0.7285323143005371,
1.1650410890579224,
-0.3139735162258148,
0.7301856875419617,
-0.07701189070940018,
0.12876226007938385,
0.7477421760559082,
-0.1775597631931305,
0.44542258977890015,
1.0044549703598022,
-0.40430375933647156,
0.3748705983161926,
0.8449830412864685,
0.2314952164888382,
0.03293929994106293,
0.6492814421653748,
-0.4461650550365448,
-0.07492624223232269,
-0.25438347458839417,
-0.36077290773391724,
0.6034559607505798,
0.988325297832489,
0.12309420853853226,
-0.39855241775512695,
0.32972830533981323,
-0.09009901434183121,
0.43404239416122437,
-0.2733434736728668,
0.8119035363197327,
0.1902640163898468,
-0.5169411897659302,
0.6439036726951599,
0.225482776761055,
0.8786575198173523,
-0.7024407386779785,
0.12547603249549866,
0.10338472574949265,
-0.020342150703072548,
-0.1585851013660431,
-0.5818905830383301,
0.578055202960968,
-0.39226534962654114,
-0.15983319282531738,
0.006089231465011835,
0.9028142094612122,
-0.46828070282936096,
-0.3402307331562042,
0.5373321175575256,
0.9327155351638794,
0.25668567419052124,
-0.04354563355445862,
-0.8560116291046143,
0.12570780515670776,
-0.20331984758377075,
0.3188019394874573,
0.22880566120147705,
0.6472121477127075,
-0.18658410012722015,
0.49860507249832153,
0.27600163221359253,
0.29013344645500183,
0.14162753522396088,
0.19404074549674988,
0.6787744760513306,
-0.7014844417572021,
-0.37522032856941223,
-0.9109255075454712,
-0.045061398297548294,
-0.06573639065027237,
-0.5729085803031921,
0.49912509322166443,
0.1317814290523529,
0.8490161299705505,
0.07475237548351288,
0.49255552887916565,
-0.30968037247657776,
0.17491458356380463,
-0.1499062180519104,
0.4037612974643707,
-0.9302710890769958,
-0.04141473025083542,
-0.5018534064292908,
-0.37460049986839294,
-0.6123338937759399,
0.7816106081008911,
-0.25455087423324585,
-0.10923831164836884,
0.7519671320915222,
0.6342604756355286,
-0.1010204404592514,
0.25590449571609497,
0.36545059084892273,
-0.16105344891548157,
-0.18263602256774902,
0.6052259206771851,
0.6650808453559875,
-0.45544764399528503,
-0.10614917427301407,
-0.0792694166302681,
-0.20680713653564453,
-0.05687795951962471,
-0.9281022548675537,
-0.3716212511062622,
-0.9465421438217163,
-0.30316638946533203,
-0.16901051998138428,
0.061207473278045654,
0.7745669484138489,
0.5909141898155212,
-0.4498118758201599,
-0.0560004748404026,
-0.20137248933315277,
0.46087321639060974,
-0.5428353548049927,
-0.23088271915912628,
0.2339920997619629,
-0.6427322626113892,
-0.9067908525466919,
0.42757153511047363,
0.5153505206108093,
-0.08182736486196518,
-0.14494407176971436,
0.12170079350471497,
-0.45629024505615234,
0.0554981529712677,
0.6455211043357849,
0.28461533784866333,
-0.7206252813339233,
-0.15973758697509766,
-0.20348359644412994,
-0.14196890592575073,
-0.11203239113092422,
0.6618797779083252,
-0.7714666128158569,
0.5604455471038818,
0.5176227688789368,
0.7474364638328552,
0.039649058133363724,
-0.1287834644317627,
0.37604469060897827,
-0.6211519241333008,
0.5466451048851013,
0.4796575903892517,
0.28792041540145874,
0.23870904743671417,
-0.30055561661720276,
0.48735108971595764,
0.38615882396698,
0.07325592637062073,
-0.8898217082023621,
0.465609610080719,
-1.0648258924484253,
-0.7940388321876526,
0.8813338875770569,
0.24558745324611664,
-0.3860262334346771,
-0.5274654626846313,
-0.11583607643842697,
0.26682913303375244,
0.15997809171676636,
0.7438252568244934,
0.9294151067733765,
-0.2533585727214813,
0.004862389527261257,
-0.5742129683494568,
0.5420367121696472,
0.8071804046630859,
-0.7240402102470398,
-0.109146848320961,
0.43109333515167236,
-0.11503023654222488,
0.34670525789260864,
0.252538800239563,
-0.2735064923763275,
0.16780105233192444,
-0.18122024834156036,
0.22610218822956085,
0.09042777121067047,
-0.059319641441106796,
-0.617150604724884,
0.08834239840507507,
0.07969963550567627,
-0.13455086946487427
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16127v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16127v2
|
WangchanLion and WangchanX MRC Eval
| 2024-03-24T12:49:30 | 2024-04-23T12:31:30 |
Wannaphong Phatthiyaphaibun, Surapon Nonesung, Patomporn Payoungkhamdee, Peerat Limkonchotiwat, Can Udomcharoenchaikit, Jitkapat Sawatphol, Chompakorn Chaksangchaichot, Ekapol Chuangsuwanich, Sarana Nutanong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This technical report describes the development of WangchanLion, an
instruction fine-tuned model focusing on Machine Reading Comprehension (MRC) in
the Thai language. Our model is based on SEA-LION and a collection of
instruction following datasets. To promote open research and reproducibility,
we publicly release all training data, code, and the final model weights under
the Apache-2 license. To assess the contextual understanding capability, we
conducted extensive experimental studies using two Thai MRC datasets, XQuAD and
Iapp_wiki_qa_squad. Experimental results demonstrate the model's ability to
comprehend the context and produce an answer faithful to the reference one in
0-shot and 1-shot settings. In addition, our evaluation goes beyond the
traditional MRC. We propose a new evaluation scheme assessing the answer's
correctness, helpfulness, conciseness, and contextuality. Our code is available
publicly at https://github.com/vistec-AI/WangchanLion.
|
[
-0.21488259732723236,
-0.6679561138153076,
0.18224239349365234,
0.3191770911216736,
-0.340558260679245,
-0.10014680027961731,
-0.07019539177417755,
-0.5024696588516235,
-0.20646601915359497,
0.39920759201049805,
-0.6671634912490845,
-0.3784005343914032,
-0.34006866812705994,
0.4667007029056549,
-0.21023859083652496,
0.8395451307296753,
-0.33463355898857117,
0.2290697544813156,
0.152973011136055,
-0.29137754440307617,
-0.6399827599525452,
-0.1663883477449417,
-0.46491700410842896,
-0.3036957085132599,
0.7207478880882263,
1.0883203744888306,
0.504519522190094,
0.6389292478561401,
0.8959964513778687,
0.1614018976688385,
-0.11986401677131653,
0.13239839673042297,
-0.427209734916687,
0.0623745322227478,
-0.288127064704895,
-0.4642089605331421,
-0.4992825984954834,
-0.00996474176645279,
0.45286503434181213,
0.7835003137588501,
-0.23407194018363953,
0.20791341364383698,
0.17060141265392303,
0.9270231127738953,
-0.7775825262069702,
0.26654231548309326,
-0.12184020131826401,
0.49119868874549866,
0.1344636082649231,
-0.5217493772506714,
-0.770063042640686,
-0.2752222418785095,
0.528240978717804,
-0.8936240077018738,
0.05926088988780975,
0.1070462092757225,
0.8163257241249084,
-0.00884978286921978,
-0.5288700461387634,
-0.5909782648086548,
-0.24127647280693054,
0.8863668441772461,
-0.5043006539344788,
0.38211506605148315,
0.9607691168785095,
0.45709550380706787,
0.32284051179885864,
-0.7997804284095764,
-0.5555864572525024,
-0.3681674003601074,
-0.12437570840120316,
0.19819986820220947,
0.06909491121768951,
0.018426477909088135,
-0.0943915992975235,
0.511673629283905,
-0.774204671382904,
-0.12881572544574738,
-0.8362834453582764,
-0.07363381236791611,
0.4240817725658417,
0.25283533334732056,
0.0837026983499527,
-0.6851798892021179,
-0.21596825122833252,
-0.24662016332149506,
-0.4838956594467163,
0.04114244133234024,
0.2399308830499649,
0.2392328828573227,
-0.21064746379852295,
0.7403016090393066,
-0.46126192808151245,
0.5605201721191406,
0.08132948726415634,
-0.0363583080470562,
0.11942236870527267,
-0.3827289938926697,
-0.4782058000564575,
0.008353311568498611,
0.5051968097686768,
0.5194486379623413,
0.3860720694065094,
0.028595637530088425,
-0.2000785768032074,
-0.8334161639213562,
0.37429147958755493,
-0.9564709663391113,
-0.5693312287330627,
0.22971993684768677,
-0.7464999556541443,
-0.8228334784507751,
0.4562070965766907,
-0.7316121459007263,
-0.32828637957572937,
-0.3452771306037903,
0.41372251510620117,
-0.5657726526260376,
-0.36560961604118347,
0.06072356179356575,
-0.05945294350385666,
0.5025680661201477,
0.0652436912059784,
-0.9548726677894592,
0.11304982751607895,
0.4019882082939148,
1.0637284517288208,
-0.28034287691116333,
-0.5460772514343262,
-0.294613778591156,
0.018588081002235413,
-0.42655739188194275,
0.7137898206710815,
-0.3940883278846741,
-0.6876263618469238,
0.047219451516866684,
0.4699106216430664,
-0.015343580394983292,
-0.5571993589401245,
0.47403350472450256,
-0.886512041091919,
0.5703126192092896,
-0.15474577248096466,
-0.20589381456375122,
-0.7524264454841614,
0.33455395698547363,
-0.6600719094276428,
0.717899739742279,
0.3794546127319336,
-0.9946140646934509,
0.2533453106880188,
-0.8210676312446594,
-0.8436788320541382,
-0.3807424008846283,
0.44903481006622314,
-0.4239981472492218,
-0.15036842226982117,
0.14153115451335907,
0.39298683404922485,
-0.27145883440971375,
0.07310294359922409,
-0.23494698107242584,
-0.3009899854660034,
0.34309425950050354,
-0.6934613585472107,
1.0428951978683472,
0.6219649910926819,
-0.38058048486709595,
0.4141484498977661,
-0.7635283470153809,
0.16211946308612823,
0.008402144536376,
-0.3228047788143158,
-0.12166082113981247,
-0.25570744276046753,
0.1014409065246582,
-0.015399076044559479,
-0.018322132527828217,
-0.018867021426558495,
0.16082599759101868,
-0.1725529581308365,
0.310135155916214,
0.7617082595825195,
0.08716164529323578,
0.41240182518959045,
-0.009116320870816708,
0.7932665348052979,
0.11158224940299988,
0.07551709562540054,
-0.7217751741409302,
-0.17321231961250305,
-0.8499521613121033,
-0.2440587729215622,
0.46319079399108887,
0.8219976425170898,
-0.8015996813774109,
0.18892988562583923,
0.07748456299304962,
-0.3644126057624817,
-0.2663128972053528,
-0.1429879367351532,
0.31696999073028564,
0.887209951877594,
0.3402579724788666,
-0.16370892524719238,
-0.612603485584259,
-0.6293957233428955,
0.075730100274086,
-0.224822998046875,
-0.021548671647906303,
0.41458091139793396,
0.5617918372154236,
-0.17075885832309723,
0.5261446237564087,
-0.6735517978668213,
-0.0023934298660606146,
-0.38547199964523315,
0.19756180047988892,
0.03116852417588234,
0.5207496881484985,
0.07135329395532608,
-0.48440787196159363,
-0.6308070421218872,
0.37658071517944336,
-0.9999897480010986,
-0.12820951640605927,
0.05541696771979332,
-0.20007358491420746,
0.2210293710231781,
0.5025990009307861,
-0.23343157768249512,
0.5228424668312073,
0.5100517272949219,
-0.3131239116191864,
0.9031047224998474,
-0.4197565019130707,
0.8446767330169678,
-1.0814685821533203,
0.4340624213218689,
-0.18639253079891205,
-0.24816903471946716,
-0.4375319182872772,
0.4320168197154999,
0.37381380796432495,
-0.16456972062587738,
-0.40064647793769836,
0.3583614230155945,
-0.4390682578086853,
0.2179938554763794,
-0.26746928691864014,
0.29784905910491943,
0.12393559515476227,
0.3929240107536316,
0.07261542230844498,
1.032178521156311,
0.48335716128349304,
-0.7782802581787109,
0.4766649007797241,
-0.05995378643274307,
-0.3037887215614319,
0.5732444524765015,
-1.0286260843276978,
0.1534872055053711,
0.20342645049095154,
-0.012763630598783493,
-0.9920477271080017,
-0.6162341833114624,
0.5496236085891724,
-0.35764461755752563,
0.42973506450653076,
0.27779337763786316,
-0.38505658507347107,
-0.3977632224559784,
-0.4072084426879883,
0.5930070281028748,
0.23746350407600403,
-0.5895373821258545,
0.27384549379348755,
0.26115870475769043,
0.02945595234632492,
-0.7346922755241394,
-1.1794275045394897,
-0.3032079339027405,
-0.13156166672706604,
-0.46727144718170166,
-0.24145756661891937,
0.12898068130016327,
-0.08911071717739105,
-0.1472405344247818,
-0.03817398473620415,
-0.7471866607666016,
-0.18608815968036652,
0.03171931952238083,
0.3479546904563904,
-0.5175905227661133,
0.09836453199386597,
0.036287419497966766,
-0.23374038934707642,
0.011964064091444016,
-0.3329874277114868,
0.23164181411266327,
-0.015373796224594116,
-0.24259595572948456,
-0.8757314085960388,
0.020590579137206078,
0.5166649222373962,
-0.28254014253616333,
0.7662579417228699,
0.4827048182487488,
-0.22217600047588348,
-0.0495988093316555,
0.024098258465528488,
-0.2298671305179596,
-0.5194921493530273,
0.6312748789787292,
-0.6271951198577881,
-0.510259747505188,
0.5392245054244995,
0.20392176508903503,
-0.06953421235084534,
0.46480536460876465,
0.4247448444366455,
0.00955043826252222,
0.9066831469535828,
0.8258995413780212,
-0.009177764877676964,
0.2615661025047302,
-0.21106378734111786,
0.13584724068641663,
-0.6856828927993774,
-0.385786235332489,
-0.3337811827659607,
-0.07056965678930283,
-0.3098730444908142,
-0.4736897051334381,
-0.027729876339435577,
0.27986347675323486,
-0.11805234104394913,
0.4637223780155182,
-0.6517579555511475,
0.5968607068061829,
0.39192596077919006,
0.0993543267250061,
0.5761620402336121,
-0.06330490857362747,
-0.44466015696525574,
-0.0829935222864151,
-0.6024397611618042,
-0.5902388095855713,
1.2152353525161743,
0.4042680859565735,
0.8474963903427124,
0.021236775442957878,
-0.045620985329151154,
0.29020267724990845,
0.2843081057071686,
-0.8502151966094971,
0.39754727482795715,
0.27708184719085693,
-0.8376756310462952,
-0.2950305938720703,
-0.4433933198451996,
-0.9086499214172363,
0.308645635843277,
0.5401204228401184,
-0.4100220203399658,
-0.006167975720018148,
0.035856712609529495,
-0.2582290470600128,
0.26378539204597473,
-1.0619020462036133,
1.212624430656433,
0.07445622235536575,
-0.11744119226932526,
-0.7736240029335022,
-0.6561567783355713,
0.8172840476036072,
-0.06336621195077896,
-0.19399936497211456,
0.21450629830360413,
-0.09632905572652817,
0.5850245356559753,
-0.522941529750824,
0.5451569557189941,
-0.06020605191588402,
-0.16486267745494843,
0.5265571475028992,
0.10675595700740814,
0.020598789677023888,
0.21313612163066864,
-0.37728822231292725,
-0.0168402548879385,
0.34301871061325073,
-0.5528066158294678,
-0.5016536116600037,
0.4284035265445709,
-0.697060763835907,
-0.14348207414150238,
-0.5365891456604004,
-0.5550870299339294,
0.063828244805336,
0.3811320960521698,
0.14977271854877472,
0.46440207958221436,
-0.2742806077003479,
0.20268377661705017,
0.7625953555107117,
-0.2908964455127716,
0.14461380243301392,
0.8197277188301086,
-0.5145448446273804,
-0.6182177066802979,
0.9218789339065552,
-0.08612892031669617,
0.36547040939331055,
0.4499357342720032,
0.15862952172756195,
-0.07758348435163498,
-0.1793065071105957,
-0.49278390407562256,
0.07094351947307587,
-0.995153546333313,
-0.18546128273010254,
-0.21368703246116638,
-0.22199085354804993,
-0.14713652431964874,
0.0653313547372818,
-0.04457153007388115,
-0.493617445230484,
-0.4461568593978882,
-0.10325241833925247,
0.1717323660850525,
1.0825871229171753,
-0.23487703502178192,
0.39789190888404846,
-0.4018891155719757,
0.3954268991947174,
0.17308156192302704,
0.4534294903278351,
0.22722308337688446,
-0.9943810105323792,
-0.5637189149856567,
-0.04159244894981384,
-0.5808516144752502,
-0.8831537365913391,
0.07846779376268387,
-0.045765046030282974,
0.10914924740791321,
0.8244374394416809,
0.038175903260707855,
0.8247750401496887,
-0.6931231617927551,
0.6511044502258301,
-0.007701035588979721,
-0.9797545075416565,
0.6462904214859009,
-0.12058314681053162,
0.5022760629653931,
0.5647821426391602,
0.3790357708930969,
-0.811020016670227,
-0.19300034642219543,
-0.12298526614904404,
-0.3221103250980377,
0.9365454912185669,
-0.10822184383869171,
-0.08214613795280457,
0.21304230391979218,
0.40367746353149414,
0.2632633149623871,
0.029012205079197884,
-0.4610000550746918,
-0.3022349178791046,
-0.3636811673641205,
-0.28462040424346924,
0.20307837426662445,
-0.35757699608802795,
0.11507689952850342,
-0.58064204454422,
0.6520753502845764,
0.009842131286859512,
0.05089651048183441,
0.5294660329818726,
-0.364867627620697,
-0.23609505593776703,
-0.02618418075144291,
1.1472892761230469,
0.9960601925849915,
-0.07643759995698929,
0.2308311015367508,
0.3141622543334961,
-0.8926688432693481,
-0.035014618188142776,
0.01449834369122982,
-0.0031817981507629156,
-0.0980239287018776,
0.6266582012176514,
0.4542502760887146,
0.225346177816391,
-0.8498923778533936,
0.2673010528087616,
-0.08026481419801712,
-0.289992094039917,
-0.014781415462493896,
-0.07074301689863205,
-0.11712931841611862,
0.0953478142619133,
0.34712448716163635,
0.12499276548624039,
0.1885494887828827,
-0.3461543917655945,
0.4266306459903717,
-0.025194989517331123,
-0.6601212620735168,
-0.5035015940666199,
0.6862714290618896,
0.2353643923997879,
-0.13828223943710327,
0.6248985528945923,
-0.45439010858535767,
-0.5468708276748657,
0.3984609842300415,
0.3967374265193939,
0.9148358702659607,
-0.3332270681858063,
0.36440691351890564,
0.6307412385940552,
0.49050435423851013,
0.21664699912071228,
0.27332720160484314,
-0.2554721534252167,
-0.2574174404144287,
-0.38992586731910706,
-0.0410366989672184,
-0.6244359612464905,
0.0017294746357947588,
-0.7038838267326355,
0.3373928368091583,
-0.4608403444290161,
0.29632312059402466,
-0.33320534229278564,
0.24258865416049957,
-0.17375800013542175,
0.11849094927310944,
-0.4065901041030884,
1.1065232753753662,
-0.3087851405143738,
1.0051034688949585,
0.42325830459594727,
-0.7338370084762573,
-0.9670761227607727,
0.31971317529678345,
-0.03934966027736664,
-0.8921948671340942,
0.7565093040466309,
0.26647794246673584,
-0.22998516261577606,
-0.22336088120937347,
-0.4724007248878479,
-0.3784036934375763,
1.186280608177185,
0.07460775226354599,
-0.2088938057422638,
0.15856079757213593,
0.12595443427562714,
0.31207075715065,
-0.11615844070911407,
0.42922136187553406,
0.5500948429107666,
0.582755446434021,
-0.12885531783103943,
-0.9542558193206787,
-0.11747882515192032,
-0.0387364886701107,
-0.307624876499176,
-0.44660454988479614,
-0.5974687337875366,
0.570131242275238,
-0.5802507996559143,
-0.14989936351776123,
0.40074434876441956,
0.980559766292572,
0.22332723438739777,
0.3082607388496399,
0.27473026514053345,
0.2414950728416443,
0.9894020557403564,
0.22236290574073792,
1.1950416564941406,
-0.3622925579547882,
0.45285072922706604,
0.930690348148346,
0.004107550717890263,
0.9943414926528931,
0.41290682554244995,
-0.24595345556735992,
0.6041557192802429,
0.9624142646789551,
0.24995605647563934,
0.7733443379402161,
0.07347693294286728,
-0.14972171187400818,
0.3152398467063904,
0.09573758393526077,
-0.3485373556613922,
0.16945520043373108,
-0.1805790811777115,
-0.33272600173950195,
0.04615563526749611,
0.20159299671649933,
-0.09186491370201111,
-0.1825828105211258,
-0.2386973798274994,
0.40741732716560364,
0.10685155540704727,
-0.7588709592819214,
0.7761148810386658,
0.2405817061662674,
0.4466390311717987,
-0.55294269323349,
0.02274584211409092,
-0.23748260736465454,
0.4558751881122589,
-0.2956688106060028,
-1.114727258682251,
0.33315742015838623,
0.1042959988117218,
-0.4320199489593506,
0.10787559300661087,
0.5692198276519775,
-0.44116032123565674,
-0.43892204761505127,
-0.1983930468559265,
0.22926972806453705,
0.3420506417751312,
0.20773009955883026,
-0.6976051926612854,
0.021218055859208107,
0.3186819851398468,
-0.3384459912776947,
-0.18886391818523407,
0.7755712270736694,
0.26829156279563904,
0.8770309686660767,
0.28391435742378235,
-0.049025315791368484,
0.02881479263305664,
0.19694024324417114,
0.5178767442703247,
-0.7071249485015869,
-0.36658725142478943,
-0.6204981207847595,
0.5966653823852539,
-0.06423118710517883,
-0.710864245891571,
0.7931675314903259,
0.6443096399307251,
0.7049071192741394,
-0.25557440519332886,
0.5186591744422913,
0.06297270953655243,
0.4987352192401886,
-0.40544483065605164,
0.9475569725036621,
-0.5543844103813171,
0.16900844871997833,
-0.1084352508187294,
-0.5367007255554199,
-0.41815945506095886,
0.9376344084739685,
-0.2738476097583771,
0.07518253475427628,
1.1886593103408813,
0.8619170188903809,
-0.32056984305381775,
0.3441278040409088,
0.28494006395339966,
-0.09517639875411987,
0.15312549471855164,
0.3029516935348511,
0.8155260682106018,
-0.6845061779022217,
0.8405998945236206,
-0.5106095671653748,
-0.109077587723732,
-0.3094255030155182,
-0.5738043785095215,
-1.1378979682922363,
-0.6319919228553772,
-0.22522494196891785,
-0.3243104815483093,
-0.01984589733183384,
0.5611015558242798,
0.7833487391471863,
-1.203972578048706,
-0.37537145614624023,
-0.3102763891220093,
0.5149876475334167,
-0.2503408193588257,
-0.3724047839641571,
0.5191971063613892,
-0.7189624905586243,
-0.6326717138290405,
0.13891296088695526,
0.3803406059741974,
-0.19287985563278198,
-0.56242436170578,
-0.49389803409576416,
-0.06827104836702347,
-0.08776824176311493,
0.6996796727180481,
0.34369537234306335,
-0.6649684906005859,
-0.16389673948287964,
0.5355237722396851,
-0.5100017786026001,
0.11896812915802002,
0.8776183128356934,
-0.4275088608264923,
0.6820955872535706,
0.6077890992164612,
0.6258643865585327,
0.158866748213768,
-0.1704862266778946,
0.8121318221092224,
-0.3635493218898773,
0.34644103050231934,
-0.06471288204193115,
0.12050550431013107,
0.22814100980758667,
0.023275019600987434,
0.6400585174560547,
0.15106774866580963,
-0.7688391804695129,
-0.9640448689460754,
-0.0906522125005722,
-0.6829656362533569,
-0.3762435019016266,
0.8393363952636719,
-0.21440470218658447,
-0.2808612287044525,
0.029277002438902855,
-0.6063489317893982,
0.3342759609222412,
0.01478085108101368,
0.6020101308822632,
0.8997132778167725,
0.0678810328245163,
-0.46835967898368835,
-0.9481920599937439,
0.277587354183197,
0.5637321472167969,
-0.8190449476242065,
0.07018192112445831,
0.1453569084405899,
0.2209303081035614,
-0.1175878569483757,
0.32518890500068665,
-0.08756392449140549,
0.6396382451057434,
0.15362679958343506,
-0.09241792559623718,
0.1290319412946701,
-0.2553499639034271,
-0.5203312635421753,
0.053048275411129,
0.08920491486787796,
-0.414314329624176
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16099v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16099v2
|
A Multi-Label Dataset of French Fake News: Human and Machine Insights
| 2024-03-24T11:29:55 | 2024-04-11T09:58:17 |
Benjamin Icard, François Maine, Morgane Casanova, Géraud Faye, Julien Chanson, Guillaume Gadek, Ghislain Atemezing, François Bancilhon, Paul Égré
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We present a corpus of 100 documents, OBSINFOX, selected from 17 sources of
French press considered unreliable by expert agencies, annotated using 11
labels by 8 annotators. By collecting more labels than usual, by more
annotators than is typically done, we can identify features that humans
consider as characteristic of fake news, and compare them to the predictions of
automated classifiers. We present a topic and genre analysis using Gate Cloud,
indicative of the prevalence of satire-like text in the corpus. We then use the
subjectivity analyzer VAGO, and a neural version of it, to clarify the link
between ascriptions of the label Subjective and ascriptions of the label Fake
News. The annotated dataset is available online at the following url:
https://github.com/obs-info/obsinfox
Keywords: Fake News, Multi-Labels, Subjectivity, Vagueness, Detail, Opinion,
Exaggeration, French Press
|
[
-0.5235843658447266,
-0.7921761274337769,
0.46108973026275635,
0.4261888265609741,
-0.010579468682408333,
0.2307550460100174,
-0.10318944603204727,
-0.4188239574432373,
0.3201078176498413,
0.7010394930839539,
-0.20923876762390137,
-0.32149913907051086,
-0.6791104078292847,
0.12272569537162781,
-0.6026284098625183,
1.1873655319213867,
0.07113876938819885,
0.13578997552394867,
-0.0272902213037014,
-0.29518017172813416,
0.026961414143443108,
-0.8129960894584656,
-0.3692263066768646,
-0.19358648359775543,
0.7516040802001953,
0.2544494867324829,
0.554899275302887,
0.44230926036834717,
-0.03306448459625244,
0.22313016653060913,
0.15132860839366913,
0.1762872040271759,
-0.38437309861183167,
-0.33898472785949707,
-0.4243643283843994,
-0.2794586718082428,
-0.3168756067752838,
0.35370028018951416,
0.38735681772232056,
0.41940242052078247,
0.1906328648328781,
0.32630905508995056,
0.027528591454029083,
0.42381787300109863,
-0.6010233163833618,
-0.10137701034545898,
-0.4119865596294403,
-0.22697992622852325,
-0.284970223903656,
0.031544554978609085,
-0.38887473940849304,
-0.167920783162117,
-0.07250706106424332,
-0.6017825603485107,
0.6617351770401001,
0.015396279282867908,
1.0904827117919922,
0.23197633028030396,
-0.652256965637207,
-0.2073676735162735,
-0.6973510980606079,
0.4657721519470215,
-0.29144424200057983,
0.5662348866462708,
0.24352648854255676,
0.29825228452682495,
0.07316023856401443,
-0.6557833552360535,
-0.7148240208625793,
-0.09096405655145645,
-0.06223681941628456,
0.20027312636375427,
-0.27524682879447937,
-0.42450565099716187,
0.30756810307502747,
0.06452370434999466,
-0.5769706964492798,
0.0010264178272336721,
-0.6742250323295593,
-0.6400106549263,
0.6186360716819763,
-0.5843147039413452,
0.2467886507511139,
-0.22260282933712006,
-0.5604561567306519,
0.004137836396694183,
-0.4287124276161194,
0.07316987216472626,
0.6510534286499023,
0.07049494236707687,
0.059180207550525665,
0.4730997085571289,
-0.5276383757591248,
0.7884020805358887,
-0.19899021089076996,
-0.03291524946689606,
0.7151985764503479,
-0.008618091233074665,
-0.064687080681324,
0.5184661149978638,
1.0113849639892578,
0.2879675328731537,
0.32126176357269287,
-0.17036867141723633,
-0.18031203746795654,
0.43152427673339844,
0.6463377475738525,
-0.43200719356536865,
-0.25226742029190063,
0.18438133597373962,
-0.25433167815208435,
-0.4541064500808716,
0.6273261308670044,
-0.7374584078788757,
-0.5342037081718445,
-0.42863619327545166,
0.5090664029121399,
-0.19252954423427582,
-0.007549666799604893,
-0.08555255085229874,
-0.5837671756744385,
-0.23469579219818115,
0.48549237847328186,
0.12409010529518127,
0.10442624986171722,
0.36271366477012634,
0.5627672076225281,
0.14026890695095062,
-0.1896144449710846,
-0.6053097248077393,
-0.014445527456700802,
-0.10002054274082184,
1.0142524242401123,
-0.3542635142803192,
-0.0339704304933548,
-0.13124990463256836,
0.38730329275131226,
0.28320634365081787,
-0.2688549757003784,
0.9660730361938477,
-0.4260118305683136,
0.18935760855674744,
-0.4109821319580078,
-0.20437563955783844,
-0.6008371710777283,
0.2765543758869171,
-1.0826749801635742,
0.9191385507583618,
0.05260522663593292,
-0.6522595286369324,
0.21279080212116241,
-0.4108366072177887,
-0.43035247921943665,
-0.21692779660224915,
-0.24747373163700104,
-0.3027367889881134,
0.23203015327453613,
0.44603317975997925,
0.40059950947761536,
-0.13158254325389862,
0.4158604145050049,
-0.3867180049419403,
-0.09193138778209686,
0.7981419563293457,
-0.5538658499717712,
0.7623447179794312,
0.14335694909095764,
-0.3645545244216919,
-0.1867750734090805,
-0.7894232273101807,
-0.26256510615348816,
-0.03927364572882652,
-0.03618741035461426,
-0.43000558018684387,
-0.2024252861738205,
0.23930329084396362,
0.6291099190711975,
0.0007361003663390875,
-0.8805904984474182,
0.03559244051575661,
-0.09625616669654846,
0.427585631608963,
0.5667818188667297,
0.2006082534790039,
0.06690947711467743,
-0.41524815559387207,
0.2345007359981537,
0.24660111963748932,
0.358664333820343,
-0.13394315540790558,
-0.573989987373352,
-0.7386435866355896,
-0.17847979068756104,
0.513901948928833,
0.7720739245414734,
-0.7535773515701294,
0.24808460474014282,
-0.2396949827671051,
-0.4687609076499939,
-0.6249836087226868,
0.14425435662269592,
0.4708537757396698,
0.5899435877799988,
0.44126656651496887,
-0.14526639878749847,
-0.20293381810188293,
-1.4920872449874878,
-0.8061234354972839,
0.1998501420021057,
0.09190010279417038,
0.016848832368850708,
0.6111668348312378,
-0.23663203418254852,
1.0201187133789062,
-0.4315642714500427,
-0.37837129831314087,
0.29331573843955994,
0.7075209617614746,
0.03506963700056076,
0.1155843436717987,
0.6540513038635254,
-1.2875730991363525,
-0.3270054757595062,
-0.11282435059547424,
-0.5269659161567688,
-0.10838164389133453,
-0.08197063952684402,
0.07136738300323486,
0.3396843373775482,
0.4346771836280823,
-0.18970508873462677,
0.44204410910606384,
0.3969811797142029,
-0.24331240355968475,
0.5252488255500793,
0.08506698906421661,
0.4099409580230713,
-0.829193651676178,
-0.02611672133207321,
0.4742339849472046,
-0.24438908696174622,
-0.5548678040504456,
-0.5290008783340454,
0.2520275413990021,
-0.06063264235854149,
-0.7740412354469299,
0.8124883770942688,
-0.41459769010543823,
0.3444793224334717,
-0.3206377327442169,
0.3082534968852997,
0.4009210169315338,
0.26414039731025696,
0.11388827860355377,
0.32025429606437683,
0.4107181429862976,
-0.48266562819480896,
0.5316991209983826,
-0.03742507845163345,
-0.1551407128572464,
0.5457223057746887,
-0.4886171519756317,
0.11568980664014816,
-0.40059375762939453,
0.6302390098571777,
-0.7815130352973938,
-0.5653776526451111,
0.5383851528167725,
-0.7718151807785034,
-0.14129842817783356,
0.08552423864603043,
-0.7712768912315369,
-0.4923075735569,
-0.24282361567020416,
0.10950339585542679,
0.013087156228721142,
-0.3411577343940735,
0.4415762424468994,
0.43163591623306274,
0.04523622617125511,
-0.7453156113624573,
-0.899379312992096,
0.061997219920158386,
0.008049938827753067,
-0.3250432312488556,
0.26538628339767456,
0.2602261006832123,
-0.35815906524658203,
0.475012868642807,
-0.18172496557235718,
-0.24818365275859833,
-0.26890304684638977,
0.39303264021873474,
-0.08178150653839111,
-0.08172281831502914,
0.3792188763618469,
0.11341145634651184,
0.07084807753562927,
-0.0059597427025437355,
-0.4264806807041168,
0.0334242582321167,
-0.3162469267845154,
-0.01235980074852705,
-0.4225597083568573,
0.2839708924293518,
0.4345057010650635,
-0.206708163022995,
0.8603483438491821,
0.7770458459854126,
-0.6188877820968628,
-0.45997777581214905,
-0.7457271218299866,
-0.24488216638565063,
-0.3226052522659302,
0.034859731793403625,
-0.2957111895084381,
-0.4888255000114441,
0.36832544207572937,
0.005285074468702078,
-0.21052023768424988,
0.7965406775474548,
0.30014967918395996,
-0.041479919105768204,
0.5300198197364807,
0.5064682960510254,
-0.17383825778961182,
0.007283925078809261,
-0.21059133112430573,
0.1479053795337677,
-0.25937533378601074,
-0.32684484124183655,
-0.666907548904419,
-0.31467965245246887,
-0.33539870381355286,
-0.48736441135406494,
0.2452712208032608,
0.21260540187358856,
-0.07893010228872299,
0.26692482829093933,
-0.6971278786659241,
0.41560277342796326,
0.7212512493133545,
0.1481824368238449,
0.44244521856307983,
0.3291561007499695,
0.3370446264743805,
0.06411388516426086,
-0.6039937734603882,
-0.7114404439926147,
0.8846205472946167,
0.3008171617984772,
0.44330450892448425,
0.006563352886587381,
0.261048287153244,
0.6727056503295898,
0.9314601421356201,
-0.5412355065345764,
0.10981771349906921,
-0.24579159915447235,
-1.041394829750061,
-0.03454585373401642,
-0.38432547450065613,
-0.540145754814148,
0.17278529703617096,
-0.2115481048822403,
-0.9073787927627563,
0.4883812963962555,
0.19393877685070038,
-0.4496600329875946,
0.1686754822731018,
-0.65448397397995,
0.8369357585906982,
-0.5314256548881531,
-0.14316175878047943,
0.14055898785591125,
-0.5470836758613586,
0.49600541591644287,
-0.523948073387146,
0.6488581895828247,
-0.10265475511550903,
-0.2336817979812622,
0.7984362244606018,
-0.0640011802315712,
1.00923490524292,
0.2119857519865036,
0.08446110785007477,
0.32303720712661743,
-0.2391880601644516,
0.12529057264328003,
0.21674925088882446,
-0.06486149877309799,
0.6715318560600281,
-0.10616917908191681,
-0.4220091998577118,
-0.43155860900878906,
0.8234221339225769,
-1.0437827110290527,
-0.16622871160507202,
-0.7255540490150452,
-0.171282559633255,
-0.26403185725212097,
0.19852475821971893,
0.772334098815918,
0.548961877822876,
-0.30042028427124023,
0.21450567245483398,
0.5206037759780884,
-0.333543986082077,
0.22953806817531586,
0.5043085813522339,
-0.2209842950105667,
-0.6257503032684326,
1.2721807956695557,
0.5440441966056824,
-0.07434223592281342,
0.403896689414978,
0.13813386857509613,
-0.42694365978240967,
0.2771187424659729,
-0.5140377879142761,
0.4377060830593109,
-0.6023298501968384,
-0.10826244950294495,
-1.0143420696258545,
-0.4404284656047821,
-0.5605117082595825,
-0.022257568314671516,
-0.5102662444114685,
-0.39420926570892334,
-0.36096838116645813,
-0.13548733294010162,
0.21736754477024078,
0.7143263220787048,
0.025592898949980736,
0.47717738151550293,
-0.8417156934738159,
0.756245493888855,
-0.006492134183645248,
0.15629976987838745,
-0.5851607322692871,
-0.33642634749412537,
-0.09796816855669022,
0.3718966543674469,
-0.4725046753883362,
-1.373329520225525,
0.2543853521347046,
-0.11468201875686646,
0.6474074721336365,
0.5470501184463501,
0.38101810216903687,
-0.153239905834198,
-0.1585659682750702,
0.6654685735702515,
0.15587249398231506,
-0.9886391162872314,
0.5395152568817139,
-0.5490395426750183,
-0.05280636250972748,
0.4424692690372467,
0.9142639636993408,
-0.45392274856567383,
-0.3638353645801544,
-1.0340086221694946,
-0.6751816868782043,
0.6923662424087524,
0.34781768918037415,
-0.19012197852134705,
0.1606689840555191,
0.20916736125946045,
0.42133739590644836,
0.6469863057136536,
-1.0015203952789307,
-0.5695533752441406,
-0.5140413045883179,
-0.11323463916778564,
-0.35510486364364624,
-0.1463267058134079,
-0.4249115586280823,
-0.09346115589141846,
0.8952142596244812,
-0.07525293529033661,
0.12409791350364685,
0.2938641309738159,
-0.19371701776981354,
0.19147205352783203,
0.23069247603416443,
0.7705692648887634,
0.7954027652740479,
-0.054142262786626816,
0.3562786877155304,
-0.3516521751880646,
-0.3347170948982239,
0.20421724021434784,
0.3000558316707611,
-0.4400222897529602,
0.4633062779903412,
0.2869110405445099,
0.9477227926254272,
-0.15495890378952026,
-0.5582773685455322,
0.4955615699291229,
0.11914568394422531,
-0.36425262689590454,
-0.5085781812667847,
-0.14710432291030884,
-0.0627446174621582,
-0.03161029890179634,
0.4761022925376892,
0.3847653567790985,
0.222361221909523,
-0.6679442524909973,
0.41609272360801697,
-0.021580928936600685,
-0.8222454786300659,
-0.35733485221862793,
0.630375325679779,
0.307960569858551,
-0.38507574796676636,
0.3611053228378296,
-0.34566330909729004,
-0.6920751333236694,
0.6779786348342896,
0.062124766409397125,
0.7017031908035278,
-0.2542637586593628,
0.8981174230575562,
0.2058618813753128,
0.8812305331230164,
-0.3784991204738617,
-0.04303688928484917,
0.4838745892047882,
-0.8240969777107239,
-0.32606884837150574,
-0.6467271447181702,
0.055546049028635025,
0.5536478757858276,
-0.4591160714626312,
0.35893750190734863,
-0.11623693257570267,
-0.2705962359905243,
0.3331618905067444,
-0.3764802813529968,
-0.6564931273460388,
0.48586803674697876,
0.23951956629753113,
0.8314481973648071,
-1.1364152431488037,
0.7615793943405151,
1.0057363510131836,
-0.34466132521629333,
-0.4517427086830139,
0.28174006938934326,
0.4340875744819641,
-0.09322917461395264,
0.5705395340919495,
0.4262492060661316,
0.061912842094898224,
-0.10558240860700607,
-0.5317830443382263,
-0.6720532178878784,
0.3951965868473053,
0.42506828904151917,
-0.7928902506828308,
0.3697405755519867,
0.28804996609687805,
0.39924123883247375,
-0.25855621695518494,
0.041516661643981934,
0.25945717096328735,
0.7997381687164307,
-0.35393020510673523,
-0.6819289326667786,
-0.007726878393441439,
-0.14076285064220428,
-0.4865660071372986,
0.1429273784160614,
-0.9254782795906067,
0.7419573068618774,
0.15910230576992035,
-0.08712026476860046,
-0.6297376155853271,
0.6177637577056885,
-0.29064902663230896,
0.7372111082077026,
0.5825760364532471,
0.6579168438911438,
0.7174530625343323,
-0.26171398162841797,
1.0863001346588135,
-0.14849992096424103,
0.34959954023361206,
1.2263766527175903,
0.1423875093460083,
0.5008898973464966,
0.15214763581752777,
0.3233271539211273,
0.4758128225803375,
0.6349059343338013,
-0.040541209280490875,
0.19535599648952484,
0.19987478852272034,
-0.10821902751922607,
-0.2593105435371399,
-0.18561312556266785,
-0.20860518515110016,
0.40627607703208923,
0.5426010489463806,
-0.5328501462936401,
-0.34625476598739624,
0.585963249206543,
0.06807676702737808,
0.14284561574459076,
-0.30384957790374756,
0.3501685559749603,
0.320856511592865,
-0.5278444290161133,
0.2504062354564667,
0.2745608389377594,
0.23095303773880005,
-0.15374352037906647,
0.0366649329662323,
0.09491848200559616,
0.08477658778429031,
-0.20901323854923248,
-0.6615606546401978,
0.12423325330018997,
-0.14803554117679596,
-0.534638524055481,
-0.17825663089752197,
0.7684400081634521,
-0.30392804741859436,
-0.722372829914093,
0.3284229040145874,
0.6911936402320862,
0.0399714857339859,
-0.7796605229377747,
-0.7266387343406677,
0.14858968555927277,
-0.09212645888328552,
-0.4354264736175537,
0.02606457844376564,
0.5398122668266296,
-0.4184045195579529,
0.4454258680343628,
0.5032256841659546,
-0.02953842654824257,
0.15574310719966888,
-0.07185620814561844,
0.7352762222290039,
-0.70404052734375,
-0.41925010085105896,
-0.6054059863090515,
0.528024435043335,
-0.5181542634963989,
-0.6274130344390869,
0.8388771414756775,
0.6934692859649658,
0.8590455651283264,
-0.19694919884204865,
1.1388660669326782,
-0.07218226045370102,
0.5808742642402649,
-0.30725955963134766,
0.7755070924758911,
-0.736139178276062,
-0.11821259558200836,
-0.10391721874475479,
-1.0445493459701538,
-0.07815103232860565,
0.11592891067266464,
-0.3248361647129059,
-0.13997851312160492,
0.766796350479126,
0.7361602783203125,
-0.35010331869125366,
0.09184392541646957,
0.09242226183414459,
0.5198183059692383,
-0.06785566359758377,
-0.057937465608119965,
0.9160230755805969,
-0.26233747601509094,
0.4420397877693176,
-0.6267574429512024,
-0.36592361330986023,
-0.37667983770370483,
-0.7026310563087463,
-0.8316871523857117,
-0.7660396695137024,
-0.7358863949775696,
-0.6083806157112122,
0.13928161561489105,
0.3195837736129761,
0.7221071124076843,
-0.7277904748916626,
0.2997777462005615,
0.18351714313030243,
0.1562531739473343,
-0.2928510904312134,
-0.36099594831466675,
0.3328510820865631,
0.026617461815476418,
-0.778982937335968,
0.0765736773610115,
0.2788172960281372,
-0.24396568536758423,
-0.397005558013916,
0.24117717146873474,
-0.06618607044219971,
0.3059947192668915,
0.5029494166374207,
0.38212326169013977,
-0.9468910694122314,
-0.2974473536014557,
-0.17289969325065613,
-0.31623005867004395,
-0.27769461274147034,
0.9034345746040344,
-0.9422326683998108,
0.5117560625076294,
0.472465455532074,
0.44291096925735474,
0.2569809556007385,
0.4056939482688904,
0.31351345777511597,
-1.0178552865982056,
0.34063583612442017,
0.20644308626651764,
0.04329613223671913,
0.2610609531402588,
-0.5006523132324219,
0.35347557067871094,
0.721161425113678,
-0.18843568861484528,
-0.7669402360916138,
0.03753358870744705,
-1.157299518585205,
-0.7366181015968323,
1.3269106149673462,
0.1404673159122467,
-0.6071212291717529,
-0.40673497319221497,
-0.1758965253829956,
0.0848926454782486,
-0.6554978489875793,
0.5519446730613708,
0.8343362212181091,
-0.03227982670068741,
-0.07270999252796173,
-1.0658702850341797,
0.5093808770179749,
-0.1389763057231903,
-0.746087372303009,
-0.5003632307052612,
0.6928401589393616,
0.3110492527484894,
0.6750587224960327,
0.5036145448684692,
0.13979078829288483,
0.021407730877399445,
0.11281241476535797,
0.28133389353752136,
-0.06618917733430862,
-0.8549524545669556,
0.057920653373003006,
0.39997443556785583,
-0.6845541596412659,
-0.1563657522201538
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16087v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16087v1
|
LLMs as Compiler for Arabic Programming Language
| 2024-03-24T10:57:08 | 2024-03-24T10:57:08 |
Serry Sibaee, Omar Najar, Lahouri Ghouti, Anis Koubaa
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In this paper we introduce APL (Arabic Programming Language) that uses Large
language models (LLM) as semi-compiler to covert Arabic text code to python
code then run the code. Designing a full pipeline from the structure of the APL
text then a prompt (using prompt engineering) then running the prodcued python
code using PyRunner. This project has a three parts first python library, a
playground with simple interface and this research paper.
|
[
-0.15427619218826294,
-0.5081092715263367,
0.38886409997940063,
0.10943250358104706,
0.009320667013525963,
0.14378038048744202,
-0.11492473632097244,
-0.04626397788524628,
-0.3438870310783386,
0.4122958779335022,
-0.34572452306747437,
-0.5758005380630493,
-0.4384746849536896,
0.3676159679889679,
-0.5836027264595032,
1.17173433303833,
-0.5271754860877991,
-0.18887294828891754,
0.1386304497718811,
0.24177725613117218,
0.25071972608566284,
-0.5722011923789978,
-0.467955619096756,
-0.23261404037475586,
0.1741965413093567,
0.40655517578125,
0.8686326742172241,
0.769725501537323,
0.2525983452796936,
0.37232494354248047,
-0.12779897451400757,
-0.17117656767368317,
-0.01666165702044964,
0.17739979922771454,
-0.04561563581228256,
-0.386921226978302,
0.11261728405952454,
-0.2890249490737915,
0.5527289509773254,
0.3261767029762268,
-0.11487147212028503,
0.39850279688835144,
-0.3090766370296478,
0.8739532828330994,
-0.744339108467102,
0.1632230132818222,
-0.07382912933826447,
-0.014917277731001377,
-0.2282203733921051,
0.1351267695426941,
-0.2890906035900116,
-0.5894114971160889,
-0.029378708451986313,
-0.07208172231912613,
-0.24607102572917938,
0.14032390713691711,
0.4133283197879791,
0.48911112546920776,
-0.691889762878418,
-0.8889675736427307,
-0.726931631565094,
0.9140783548355103,
-0.8541454672813416,
0.016802014783024788,
0.030489511787891388,
0.3963776230812073,
-0.1904413104057312,
-1.3890743255615234,
-0.7278850078582764,
-0.27611568570137024,
0.17895790934562683,
-0.2105322778224945,
-0.07109303027391434,
0.32721927762031555,
0.2645544707775116,
0.6303074955940247,
-0.3665422797203064,
-0.24264360964298248,
-0.5209107398986816,
-0.3335200548171997,
0.8280104994773865,
0.2688921093940735,
0.8537411093711853,
0.11046545207500458,
-0.035324227064847946,
0.25675761699676514,
-0.9540261030197144,
-0.11576105654239655,
0.32995760440826416,
0.08980946987867355,
-0.2612396776676178,
0.9356187582015991,
-0.1327821910381317,
1.0000892877578735,
-0.5997083187103271,
-0.4316974878311157,
-0.04222676530480385,
-0.10584083944559097,
-0.11014725267887115,
0.31369754672050476,
0.6204075217247009,
0.20686279237270355,
0.4891923666000366,
0.07696609199047089,
-0.25639721751213074,
0.2611228823661804,
0.01350114680826664,
-1.0565682649612427,
-0.5752785205841064,
0.43110358715057373,
-0.5903595685958862,
0.01057988777756691,
0.018593819811940193,
-0.26264822483062744,
-0.28716304898262024,
-0.06987714022397995,
0.15909625589847565,
-0.20354002714157104,
-0.10079219937324524,
-0.012748456560075283,
-0.033232830464839935,
0.22591008245944977,
0.32701241970062256,
-0.3339422941207886,
0.14522212743759155,
0.5422080755233765,
0.9516581296920776,
0.008984892629086971,
-0.5511599183082581,
-0.36028724908828735,
0.31288984417915344,
-0.21385036408901215,
0.471830815076828,
-0.5171988010406494,
-0.29320332407951355,
0.459309458732605,
-0.33482933044433594,
0.16229000687599182,
-0.3928927183151245,
0.6124879121780396,
-0.6887038350105286,
-0.03166164830327034,
0.5531624555587769,
-0.6992053389549255,
-0.37156328558921814,
-0.18037183582782745,
-0.551537275314331,
0.9291266798973083,
0.21871055662631989,
-0.8101036548614502,
-0.16855500638484955,
-0.7301186919212341,
-0.542827844619751,
-0.08054828643798828,
-0.16499337553977966,
-0.5354911684989929,
0.09904800355434418,
0.052218012511730194,
0.04826254025101662,
-0.1882222294807434,
0.14134830236434937,
0.324140727519989,
-0.6034311652183533,
0.4974825084209442,
-0.02384793385863304,
0.6852088570594788,
0.7445284724235535,
-0.1913679987192154,
0.32864558696746826,
-0.6463340520858765,
0.010190212167799473,
-0.3485962748527527,
-0.9681403040885925,
0.33217158913612366,
0.2668222188949585,
0.38541045784950256,
0.5318540334701538,
0.596733033657074,
-0.5817425847053528,
0.3894471526145935,
-0.41673925518989563,
0.6630327701568604,
0.6453565359115601,
-0.14620615541934967,
0.28999215364456177,
-0.4686468839645386,
0.6036838293075562,
-0.2978813648223877,
-0.38028252124786377,
-0.27977967262268066,
-0.7052611708641052,
-0.9442331790924072,
-0.4291015863418579,
0.11567466706037521,
0.6051416993141174,
-0.6588291525840759,
0.2528024911880493,
0.24942722916603088,
-0.29609593749046326,
-0.5614305138587952,
0.4307313561439514,
0.34236717224121094,
-0.008756010793149471,
0.027786871418356895,
0.40924856066703796,
-0.9082546234130859,
-0.7622619271278381,
-0.3163577616214752,
-0.5165629982948303,
-0.011198467575013638,
-0.009001828730106354,
0.571999192237854,
-0.2534075975418091,
0.9368743300437927,
-0.39714404940605164,
0.02976934239268303,
-0.8969300389289856,
-0.028156958520412445,
0.9368032217025757,
0.419537752866745,
0.03888244181871414,
-0.5782541036605835,
-1.1074873208999634,
0.12745091319084167,
-0.31377455592155457,
-0.5926730632781982,
0.19369688630104065,
0.13272005319595337,
0.3743855059146881,
0.4610920548439026,
-0.692158579826355,
0.8360276818275452,
0.7509011030197144,
-0.48408034443855286,
0.8572680950164795,
-0.0752744972705841,
-0.1393401175737381,
-0.9580637216567993,
0.07592160999774933,
-0.21710564196109772,
-0.14322234690189362,
-0.6165189743041992,
0.31268009543418884,
0.07891550660133362,
-0.32796353101730347,
-0.8996995687484741,
0.6568920612335205,
-0.5599764585494995,
-0.07693307846784592,
-0.5769326686859131,
-0.6588080525398254,
-0.4011502265930176,
0.0422208234667778,
0.21709805727005005,
1.4688714742660522,
0.7445228099822998,
-0.782957911491394,
0.8007611632347107,
0.13822191953659058,
-0.5079330801963806,
-0.3505197763442993,
-0.6015501022338867,
0.2970932722091675,
0.15353679656982422,
0.19519785046577454,
-1.120525598526001,
-0.17990145087242126,
-0.006144666112959385,
-0.25655025243759155,
0.12505501508712769,
-0.33661988377571106,
-0.6092456579208374,
-0.5480988025665283,
-0.3664509952068329,
0.3910624384880066,
0.8345392942428589,
-0.46786826848983765,
0.4539490044116974,
0.04614526405930519,
-0.14833246171474457,
-0.31445473432540894,
-0.6258860230445862,
0.060812972486019135,
-0.25009921193122864,
-0.6285600066184998,
0.2843170464038849,
-0.11330227553844452,
-0.4008931517601013,
-0.1617831289768219,
-0.18167391419410706,
-0.07086172699928284,
-0.14548185467720032,
0.2369650900363922,
0.2543090581893921,
-0.2581932246685028,
-0.4034573435783386,
-0.015466690994799137,
-0.209023579955101,
0.0926956981420517,
-0.2435440868139267,
0.7537542581558228,
-0.21055001020431519,
-0.36569875478744507,
-1.0184775590896606,
0.34681856632232666,
0.651945173740387,
0.0681656077504158,
0.9244930744171143,
0.053045596927404404,
-0.2186085432767868,
-0.04738607257604599,
-0.35558560490608215,
0.39330336451530457,
-0.5902683734893799,
0.4269007444381714,
-0.4222712814807892,
-0.8380775451660156,
0.38040491938591003,
-0.5478171706199646,
0.005330631509423256,
0.19453182816505432,
1.2066644430160522,
0.12707938253879547,
1.1057238578796387,
0.6148800253868103,
-0.40666499733924866,
0.28586453199386597,
-0.2560589611530304,
0.29836082458496094,
-0.8124778270721436,
-0.12162762135267258,
-0.6804837584495544,
-0.24235473573207855,
-0.31411755084991455,
-0.2932214140892029,
0.3546540141105652,
0.30680009722709656,
-0.871832549571991,
0.15021806955337524,
-0.5225264430046082,
0.6731275916099548,
0.40418192744255066,
-0.2974526584148407,
0.3231614828109741,
0.022228699177503586,
-0.29136234521865845,
0.0867990255355835,
-0.5205474495887756,
-1.0125977993011475,
1.2859339714050293,
0.38146066665649414,
1.1911005973815918,
0.2583281397819519,
1.0035932064056396,
0.4533580243587494,
0.29328790307044983,
-0.9187813401222229,
0.45293062925338745,
0.12995325028896332,
-0.7059664130210876,
-0.05869947373867035,
-0.13582025468349457,
-0.5121399760246277,
0.007769584655761719,
0.48788484930992126,
-0.9319891333580017,
-0.27190855145454407,
-0.14835773408412933,
-0.33148130774497986,
0.37940794229507446,
-0.7655841112136841,
0.8012081980705261,
-0.24146388471126556,
-0.17023436725139618,
-0.04013274237513542,
-0.540010392665863,
0.1391560435295105,
0.18855887651443481,
0.2889990210533142,
0.12657500803470612,
-0.45330244302749634,
0.804259181022644,
-0.8213209509849548,
0.6041768789291382,
0.06330020725727081,
-0.08242868632078171,
0.6289637684822083,
0.31250113248825073,
0.5175685882568359,
0.2081948220729828,
-0.35978710651397705,
-0.055639926344156265,
-0.0860658586025238,
-0.31552109122276306,
-0.29721227288246155,
0.694744348526001,
-1.2317936420440674,
-0.6073429584503174,
-0.9261001348495483,
-0.714614748954773,
0.24205780029296875,
0.1506877988576889,
0.037574224174022675,
0.022325962781906128,
0.09015902131795883,
-0.2550075352191925,
0.11489514261484146,
-0.3533117473125458,
0.7401307225227356,
0.5784153342247009,
-0.6304097771644592,
-0.5498911142349243,
0.6575576066970825,
-0.33012980222702026,
-0.013400380499660969,
0.39451664686203003,
0.03352295979857445,
-0.3632591962814331,
-0.9195184111595154,
-0.5499180555343628,
0.2609381079673767,
-0.6526495814323425,
-0.3920215368270874,
-0.36190688610076904,
-0.6125392317771912,
-0.23302030563354492,
-0.47562962770462036,
-0.3412683308124542,
-0.5694409012794495,
-0.24385404586791992,
0.20986272394657135,
0.42377468943595886,
1.087364673614502,
0.09811746329069138,
0.6543942093849182,
-0.6377362608909607,
0.2625032663345337,
0.29293563961982727,
-0.0899682492017746,
-0.17704114317893982,
-0.4406576156616211,
-0.40863850712776184,
-0.07826808094978333,
-0.5295495986938477,
-1.007311224937439,
0.6711934804916382,
0.5486863851547241,
0.47648701071739197,
0.4114343822002411,
0.09921661019325256,
0.34140440821647644,
-0.6097673773765564,
0.9245904684066772,
0.1572665572166443,
-1.1884607076644897,
0.7683956623077393,
0.18497499823570251,
0.2070920467376709,
0.1358974575996399,
0.3577629327774048,
-0.6730338335037231,
-0.38113003969192505,
-0.1391317993402481,
-0.6739298105239868,
0.959381639957428,
0.48264938592910767,
0.08309029042720795,
-0.05260005220770836,
0.3560481667518616,
-0.012265997007489204,
0.20418518781661987,
-0.6168515086174011,
-0.6093204021453857,
-0.20017315447330475,
-0.27786460518836975,
-0.02328408509492874,
-0.46880629658699036,
0.024769950658082962,
-0.5461768507957458,
0.5588579773902893,
0.06653768569231033,
0.3236016631126404,
0.04588526114821434,
-0.3622050881385803,
0.09800554811954498,
0.4185958206653595,
0.25343087315559387,
0.8239195346832275,
-0.173155277967453,
0.3126934766769409,
-0.04599438235163689,
-0.5137102603912354,
0.5535185933113098,
-0.03431614115834236,
-0.17045758664608002,
-0.1581691950559616,
0.3896903693675995,
0.36894017457962036,
-0.5009515285491943,
-0.8954583406448364,
0.2750132083892822,
0.2065138816833496,
0.18111492693424225,
-0.40054792165756226,
0.1258442997932434,
0.4195828139781952,
0.31567052006721497,
0.7375158071517944,
-0.3905571699142456,
0.23840662837028503,
-0.6326696872711182,
0.18960553407669067,
0.0777069628238678,
0.060440853238105774,
-0.23726874589920044,
0.6896396279335022,
0.2397872358560562,
-0.667073667049408,
0.7525931000709534,
-0.09215065836906433,
-1.006498098373413,
0.7189581990242004,
1.2224013805389404,
0.629097044467926,
-0.46700507402420044,
0.006414433475583792,
0.1874052733182907,
0.15352381765842438,
0.10676582902669907,
0.6839673519134521,
-0.07051459699869156,
-0.5774995684623718,
-0.7055624723434448,
-0.9717538356781006,
-0.6244888305664062,
-0.11613719165325165,
-0.1017199456691742,
0.35224705934524536,
-0.8011562824249268,
0.14286306500434875,
-0.3791802227497101,
0.14154914021492004,
-0.21696680784225464,
0.116371750831604,
0.3440048396587372,
1.0836368799209595,
-0.7579056024551392,
1.351364254951477,
1.46244478225708,
-0.24585114419460297,
-0.6460627317428589,
-0.06236811727285385,
0.11927779018878937,
-0.8497765064239502,
1.1058225631713867,
0.27835968136787415,
0.09012758731842041,
0.23805604875087738,
-0.5012063980102539,
-0.7304977774620056,
0.8932953476905823,
0.281523734331131,
-0.34640029072761536,
0.11698920279741287,
0.33609920740127563,
0.25085732340812683,
-0.638189971446991,
0.5016988515853882,
0.5788277387619019,
0.2549717128276825,
0.2941665053367615,
-1.0153961181640625,
0.0048899282701313496,
-0.48369452357292175,
0.4949340522289276,
0.2438955008983612,
-0.5194063782691956,
1.234380841255188,
-0.27053266763687134,
-0.17283783853054047,
0.5383186936378479,
0.845576822757721,
0.5291532874107361,
0.19206205010414124,
-0.24022933840751648,
0.45851197838783264,
0.374499648809433,
0.2249043732881546,
0.9963089823722839,
-0.8286285400390625,
0.4302183985710144,
0.5373510718345642,
-0.3238663077354431,
0.7403957843780518,
0.6580321788787842,
-0.8973571062088013,
0.7059291005134583,
0.494825154542923,
0.45148131251335144,
0.4851149320602417,
0.5099993944168091,
-0.7846038341522217,
-0.05203986540436745,
0.07043837010860443,
-0.4954136312007904,
0.16767659783363342,
0.5810776948928833,
-0.3902846574783325,
-0.2553566098213196,
-0.32875508069992065,
0.12274152785539627,
-0.034956660121679306,
-0.32265040278434753,
0.5195153951644897,
0.26920342445373535,
-0.28201916813850403,
0.7099775075912476,
0.45354753732681274,
0.8398081064224243,
-0.4946611225605011,
-0.0620826855301857,
-0.22923661768436432,
0.3357067108154297,
-0.43185850977897644,
-0.9165194630622864,
0.6487139463424683,
0.18953411281108856,
-0.03317675366997719,
0.11569583415985107,
0.760242760181427,
-0.18804433941841125,
-0.6498543620109558,
-0.15987072885036469,
0.2938382029533386,
0.44418179988861084,
-0.10201770812273026,
-0.7744325995445251,
0.3359900712966919,
0.2093905806541443,
-0.25139540433883667,
0.178304523229599,
0.38877618312835693,
0.1538357436656952,
1.080167293548584,
0.786754310131073,
0.31113067269325256,
0.31089532375335693,
-0.3754131495952606,
1.1915740966796875,
-0.8092488646507263,
-0.49543869495391846,
-1.2572413682937622,
0.40004903078079224,
0.24330803751945496,
0.008551279082894325,
0.873640775680542,
0.998883843421936,
0.5426877737045288,
-0.29047873616218567,
1.0894296169281006,
-0.3775240182876587,
0.3768268823623657,
-0.455263614654541,
0.9352816343307495,
-0.1405937671661377,
0.36066585779190063,
-0.15680347383022308,
-1.1269514560699463,
-0.3666529655456543,
1.2284636497497559,
-0.13919256627559662,
-0.10207486152648926,
0.9126281142234802,
0.8232449293136597,
0.16349805891513824,
-0.34763985872268677,
0.202535018324852,
-0.06968221068382263,
0.26455163955688477,
1.0053834915161133,
1.3696168661117554,
-0.2587345540523529,
0.6636570692062378,
-0.35112902522087097,
-0.3581708073616028,
-0.09279695898294449,
-0.9033860564231873,
-1.1924906969070435,
-0.12413045018911362,
-0.551750898361206,
-0.6796700954437256,
0.11169760674238205,
0.9449829459190369,
0.3695720136165619,
-1.082463026046753,
-0.8753231763839722,
-0.26489904522895813,
0.4787698984146118,
0.15767863392829895,
-0.17354832589626312,
0.46687862277030945,
-0.20341895520687103,
-0.7495633363723755,
0.0492367297410965,
0.2758762836456299,
-0.18409720063209534,
-0.27875015139579773,
-0.6483960747718811,
-0.3159789443016052,
-0.19339506328105927,
0.27427080273628235,
0.5581463575363159,
-0.6814928650856018,
0.18832717835903168,
-0.582878828048706,
-0.010162566788494587,
0.04287904500961304,
0.9799007773399353,
-0.6695972681045532,
0.1351156383752823,
0.5270053148269653,
0.5875775814056396,
0.4989781677722931,
-0.1783168464899063,
0.6983081102371216,
-0.3481478989124298,
0.42805686593055725,
0.13070692121982574,
0.3190365433692932,
0.16633270680904388,
-0.2912832498550415,
0.2648032009601593,
0.03240112587809563,
-0.8551721572875977,
-0.6738360524177551,
0.44868403673171997,
-0.47835853695869446,
-0.17852865159511566,
1.3464274406433105,
-0.34944459795951843,
-0.3763335347175598,
-0.4681455194950104,
-0.8097168207168579,
0.35114410519599915,
-0.5131340026855469,
0.6336787343025208,
0.8049086332321167,
-0.40816211700439453,
-0.4008933901786804,
-0.39396774768829346,
0.5660148859024048,
0.12414378672838211,
-0.44960594177246094,
-0.3432573974132538,
0.41380852460861206,
0.23716923594474792,
0.036328379064798355,
0.5657306909561157,
-0.0183078832924366,
0.3932129144668579,
-0.04803970828652382,
0.2916560471057892,
-0.251273512840271,
-0.17296668887138367,
-0.11491302400827408,
0.026515642181038857,
0.5877013802528381,
-0.18763814866542816
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16084v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16084v1
|
Argument Quality Assessment in the Age of Instruction-Following Large Language Models
| 2024-03-24T10:43:21 | 2024-03-24T10:43:21 |
Henning Wachsmuth, Gabriella Lapesa, Elena Cabrio, Anne Lauscher, Joonsuk Park, Eva Maria Vecchi, Serena Villata, Timon Ziegenbein
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The computational treatment of arguments on controversial issues has been
subject to extensive NLP research, due to its envisioned impact on opinion
formation, decision making, writing education, and the like. A critical task in
any such application is the assessment of an argument's quality - but it is
also particularly challenging. In this position paper, we start from a brief
survey of argument quality research, where we identify the diversity of quality
notions and the subjectiveness of their perception as the main hurdles towards
substantial progress on argument quality assessment. We argue that the
capabilities of instruction-following large language models (LLMs) to leverage
knowledge across contexts enable a much more reliable assessment. Rather than
just fine-tuning LLMs towards leaderboard chasing on assessment tasks, they
need to be instructed systematically with argumentation theories and scenarios
as well as with ways to solve argument-related problems. We discuss the
real-world opportunities and ethical issues emerging thereby.
|
[
-0.33592793345451355,
-0.9866066575050354,
0.6610821485519409,
-0.039514731615781784,
-0.1179489865899086,
0.2208341658115387,
-0.05573232099413872,
-0.328566312789917,
-0.3398808240890503,
0.23816287517547607,
-0.2746621370315552,
-0.22740627825260162,
-0.8125258684158325,
-0.22783243656158447,
-0.31775417923927307,
0.8206081986427307,
-0.14949773252010345,
0.3350629508495331,
-0.4160567820072174,
-0.26843422651290894,
-0.5078279972076416,
-0.5543312430381775,
-0.9153902530670166,
-0.256325364112854,
0.4960480034351349,
0.4129491150379181,
0.5798900723457336,
0.49728652834892273,
0.3203059434890747,
0.3920719623565674,
-0.2859000265598297,
-0.049106549471616745,
-0.3626084625720978,
0.3213314414024353,
-0.4484309256076813,
-0.13962168991565704,
-0.3375420868396759,
0.25554361939430237,
0.7819464206695557,
0.9536236524581909,
-0.18954768776893616,
0.05422654002904892,
-0.03259234502911568,
0.8019276261329651,
-0.5063759088516235,
-0.25709444284439087,
-0.5718046426773071,
0.22778518497943878,
0.056128814816474915,
-0.06861292570829391,
-0.3979949653148651,
-0.5458469986915588,
0.5403119325637817,
-0.16257892549037933,
-0.2873024046421051,
-0.03752293810248375,
1.005164384841919,
0.04340295493602753,
-0.413146048784256,
-0.6111264824867249,
-0.7070797681808472,
0.9279841780662537,
-0.983736515045166,
0.30875518918037415,
0.0711045190691948,
0.26483452320098877,
-0.26277947425842285,
-0.991238534450531,
-0.2634982168674469,
-0.2661774158477783,
0.5035926699638367,
0.07108411937952042,
-0.23646345734596252,
0.018068844452500343,
0.15279296040534973,
0.37278228998184204,
-0.26309776306152344,
0.4670366942882538,
-0.35017234086990356,
0.008029632270336151,
0.6810139417648315,
0.1689901351928711,
0.2044009417295456,
-0.23460933566093445,
-0.3375726640224457,
-0.04337112978100777,
-0.62563157081604,
0.18783365190029144,
0.6329914331436157,
-0.0687314048409462,
0.2950475215911865,
0.34813618659973145,
0.13819268345832825,
0.8056387305259705,
0.13064008951187134,
0.13772115111351013,
-0.3398526906967163,
-0.15314611792564392,
-0.2739955186843872,
-0.10268577933311462,
0.7918500304222107,
0.21574272215366364,
0.10763389617204666,
0.19447937607765198,
0.02065211720764637,
-0.1333528459072113,
0.47043105959892273,
-0.8428094387054443,
-0.08295264840126038,
0.4220389127731323,
-0.49143826961517334,
-0.1652664989233017,
-0.06964239478111267,
-1.1770051717758179,
-0.4146307706832886,
-0.4121383726596832,
0.2288690060377121,
-0.3090476095676422,
-0.11741065979003906,
0.12005985528230667,
0.18464887142181396,
0.3576526343822479,
0.44365936517715454,
-0.8816046118736267,
0.2949637770652771,
1.0110434293746948,
0.4711757302284241,
-0.3658216595649719,
-0.07173215597867966,
-0.4560147523880005,
-0.32513684034347534,
-0.8552982807159424,
1.089918613433838,
-0.8594335913658142,
-0.3347797691822052,
0.010191917419433594,
-0.0739864856004715,
-0.004878131207078695,
-0.6672936081886292,
0.9546844959259033,
-0.5123152136802673,
0.5338834524154663,
-0.3213660717010498,
-1.0896104574203491,
-0.3836916983127594,
0.44116172194480896,
-0.31380316615104675,
0.8224378824234009,
0.07509029656648636,
-0.33225613832473755,
0.3719877302646637,
-0.7570561170578003,
-0.24691198766231537,
0.2182861715555191,
-0.14963583648204803,
-0.21599042415618896,
0.2779368758201599,
0.07642067223787308,
0.5416935086250305,
-0.30886656045913696,
0.42385634779930115,
-0.19861336052417755,
-0.1074085459113121,
0.37384024262428284,
-0.6873031854629517,
0.6999680995941162,
0.09202545136213303,
-0.35875293612480164,
0.06716396659612656,
-0.5105249285697937,
0.3251306116580963,
0.030532127246260643,
-0.18910065293312073,
-0.3031487464904785,
0.42310401797294617,
-0.4747273623943329,
0.15062937140464783,
0.17224813997745514,
-0.32494956254959106,
0.1519419550895691,
-0.5110092759132385,
0.6346068382263184,
0.8969171643257141,
0.16123473644256592,
0.178807333111763,
-0.19802412390708923,
0.6207592487335205,
-0.25489166378974915,
0.3944894075393677,
0.032110217958688736,
-0.5881433486938477,
-0.7574612498283386,
0.3257966935634613,
0.6350268721580505,
0.34905827045440674,
-0.27978411316871643,
0.19550566375255585,
0.025443458929657936,
-0.5836927890777588,
-0.4854678213596344,
0.15242840349674225,
0.10403106361627579,
0.31466567516326904,
0.2562595009803772,
-0.1964857429265976,
-0.27651920914649963,
-0.6762979626655579,
-0.26897433400154114,
-0.4561387896537781,
0.3105250895023346,
0.2979026436805725,
0.44488033652305603,
0.043961625546216965,
0.7963880300521851,
-0.1342448741197586,
0.19075477123260498,
-0.1432843953371048,
0.27175024151802063,
0.01441550999879837,
0.6383275985717773,
0.2949777841567993,
-0.5522976517677307,
-0.3295420706272125,
-0.18377412855625153,
-0.6259364485740662,
-0.10810358822345734,
-0.1748686283826828,
-0.18176355957984924,
0.14043520390987396,
0.46893933415412903,
-0.2764967978000641,
-0.12277791649103165,
0.5385137796401978,
-0.3088783025741577,
0.7662947177886963,
0.016171710565686226,
0.2375771403312683,
-0.8871239423751831,
-0.23756586015224457,
0.08680974692106247,
0.0797371044754982,
-0.574019193649292,
0.2425825148820877,
-0.423808753490448,
-0.19282566010951996,
-0.4770192801952362,
0.5334330797195435,
-0.2289767861366272,
0.2848321497440338,
-0.4102210998535156,
0.14334186911582947,
0.14091211557388306,
-0.0042565870098769665,
-0.05873815715312958,
0.6341995000839233,
0.34646716713905334,
-0.27935361862182617,
0.31841129064559937,
-0.1720786839723587,
-0.5497322678565979,
0.9132572412490845,
-0.6470010876655579,
0.3503682017326355,
0.13639575242996216,
0.035409145057201385,
-0.735861599445343,
-0.13824382424354553,
0.17004890739917755,
-0.2670116424560547,
0.29692819714546204,
-0.32036662101745605,
-0.11839283257722855,
-0.2565571665763855,
-0.28950366377830505,
0.24710698425769806,
0.5131064057350159,
-0.5287627577781677,
0.6268179416656494,
0.38474637269973755,
-0.4182926118373871,
-1.0160843133926392,
-0.24862432479858398,
0.391745924949646,
-0.42767348885536194,
-0.4980520009994507,
0.18148696422576904,
-0.1300494521856308,
-0.6802083849906921,
0.06294091045856476,
-0.12853558361530304,
-0.3736339807510376,
0.21164698898792267,
0.19935199618339539,
0.1488763689994812,
-0.5056816935539246,
0.12857171893119812,
0.34165191650390625,
-0.06982691586017609,
0.44915634393692017,
-0.11798258125782013,
0.2944919466972351,
-0.28902968764305115,
-0.5532253980636597,
-0.2265593558549881,
0.6324495077133179,
0.48836588859558105,
0.019900359213352203,
0.40502670407295227,
0.36409690976142883,
-0.3706924319267273,
-0.3852488398551941,
-0.7160729765892029,
-0.056702326983213425,
-0.47204506397247314,
0.39278531074523926,
0.014326206408441067,
-0.9890527129173279,
0.13421429693698883,
-0.35085082054138184,
0.49785155057907104,
0.5266702771186829,
0.43334901332855225,
-0.3794005215167999,
0.9254701137542725,
0.19367408752441406,
0.22882463037967682,
0.30861756205558777,
-0.2683624029159546,
0.4534964859485626,
-0.85216224193573,
0.0689624547958374,
-0.5803346633911133,
-0.23062460124492645,
-0.17986896634101868,
-0.5535321831703186,
-0.004547830671072006,
0.2505263090133667,
-0.3579263389110565,
-0.30508458614349365,
-0.5522920489311218,
0.5705594420433044,
0.21898990869522095,
-0.25715363025665283,
0.08837881684303284,
-0.10235881805419922,
0.03633520007133484,
-0.39123889803886414,
-0.6904417276382446,
-1.0759880542755127,
0.6262609362602234,
0.6475932598114014,
0.5289826989173889,
-0.09061155468225479,
0.529022216796875,
0.4157119691371918,
0.5804295539855957,
-1.1008341312408447,
0.7255192399024963,
-0.26602670550346375,
-0.6142488718032837,
-0.18586479127407074,
-0.48107871413230896,
-0.9374245405197144,
0.2609412372112274,
-0.17484605312347412,
-0.7431187629699707,
0.19294753670692444,
0.10041142255067825,
-0.4260391891002655,
0.4597771465778351,
-0.6584640741348267,
1.077818751335144,
-0.4261780083179474,
-0.6650567054748535,
-0.1778244525194168,
-0.3183223009109497,
0.4382326602935791,
0.1816558837890625,
0.14776180684566498,
-0.1983911097049713,
0.21037961542606354,
1.2697572708129883,
-0.2252471148967743,
0.6436998844146729,
-0.17557615041732788,
-0.4272182583808899,
0.8573350310325623,
0.14922387897968292,
-0.015261314809322357,
-0.15502528846263885,
-0.079871267080307,
0.016286678612232208,
0.2821062505245209,
-0.21636000275611877,
-0.7121533155441284,
0.6951901912689209,
-0.6656277179718018,
-1.0254509449005127,
-0.41906026005744934,
-0.298566997051239,
-0.2945302426815033,
-0.1936948150396347,
-0.09921297430992126,
0.4863301217556,
-0.2692970037460327,
0.3138844668865204,
0.715939462184906,
-0.3357747793197632,
0.2837948501110077,
0.24778564274311066,
0.018169596791267395,
-0.37184712290763855,
1.2503374814987183,
0.42771053314208984,
0.20097501575946808,
-0.197202667593956,
0.690920352935791,
-0.4910685420036316,
-0.8134559392929077,
-0.6912541389465332,
0.03350519761443138,
-1.1880640983581543,
-0.1451694518327713,
-0.5267579555511475,
-0.26476454734802246,
0.005835284478962421,
-0.3813326358795166,
-0.6713674068450928,
-0.28801876306533813,
-0.38736194372177124,
-0.08585372567176819,
-0.022896086797118187,
0.7638372778892517,
0.1512242704629898,
0.10400178283452988,
-0.6837975382804871,
-0.12395501136779785,
0.7216066122055054,
0.3125438392162323,
0.32231631875038147,
-0.7568626403808594,
0.09298374503850937,
0.029133550822734833,
-0.6608006954193115,
-0.7873947024345398,
-0.068930484354496,
0.036351270973682404,
0.5769855380058289,
0.6100032329559326,
-0.001814341521821916,
0.5476573705673218,
-0.3649543821811676,
1.332253098487854,
0.01533511746674776,
-1.0427714586257935,
0.30512696504592896,
0.06376587599515915,
-0.05815090239048004,
0.4862044155597687,
0.5559723377227783,
-0.4467943608760834,
-0.24462741613388062,
-0.6508792638778687,
-0.7987518906593323,
0.29496142268180847,
-0.36568382382392883,
0.34830307960510254,
-0.08809000253677368,
0.4828033745288849,
0.18117685616016388,
-0.1218474805355072,
-0.6822361946105957,
0.30751195549964905,
-0.2604103684425354,
-0.21130380034446716,
0.41203033924102783,
-0.5135232210159302,
-0.3613227605819702,
-0.3652585744857788,
0.5274839997291565,
-0.08014095574617386,
0.1349397599697113,
-0.04784637317061424,
0.19464538991451263,
-0.08815117925405502,
0.7317506670951843,
0.7551500201225281,
1.0485916137695312,
0.1437578648328781,
0.121212437748909,
0.3090240955352783,
-0.23608383536338806,
0.5058939456939697,
-0.09365004301071167,
0.006505904719233513,
-0.19891591370105743,
0.5302426218986511,
0.7120421528816223,
0.0016151058953255415,
-0.6627922058105469,
0.43957236409187317,
0.09398658573627472,
-0.35166558623313904,
-0.11352048814296722,
0.2573696970939636,
0.20202982425689697,
0.2655136287212372,
0.3026680052280426,
-0.24813231825828552,
-0.07264631986618042,
-0.5944207906723022,
0.006424999330192804,
0.47636711597442627,
-0.6922623515129089,
-0.05943859741091728,
0.36416542530059814,
0.20120257139205933,
-0.39186713099479675,
0.436214417219162,
0.08539631217718124,
-0.6023704409599304,
0.7697622776031494,
0.3920975923538208,
0.7366069555282593,
-0.31692251563072205,
0.20143142342567444,
0.3000626564025879,
0.2755087614059448,
-0.2317662388086319,
0.12466719001531601,
0.23712551593780518,
-0.6285709142684937,
-0.7639576196670532,
-0.43851882219314575,
-0.9466228485107422,
0.3127637505531311,
-0.4153205156326294,
-0.11298561841249466,
-0.7432746887207031,
-0.2916867733001709,
-0.09048047661781311,
0.15407299995422363,
-0.11062001436948776,
0.22738468647003174,
0.058572158217430115,
0.6892812848091125,
-0.7743332386016846,
0.40268459916114807,
0.8007136583328247,
-0.02121100202202797,
-0.4983255863189697,
-0.004415908828377724,
-0.253204882144928,
-0.30876225233078003,
0.6606841087341309,
-0.014645828865468502,
-0.2626717686653137,
-0.18684834241867065,
-0.8444170355796814,
-0.3705873191356659,
0.4040278494358063,
0.3815866708755493,
-0.4346770942211151,
0.10822749137878418,
-0.2446078509092331,
0.7164390087127686,
-0.4113151431083679,
0.19890518486499786,
0.444132000207901,
0.5474578738212585,
-0.08243914693593979,
-0.20955903828144073,
-0.12637698650360107,
-0.02467777580022812,
-0.1915736049413681,
-0.23166713118553162,
-0.4671555757522583,
0.634354829788208,
-0.16335290670394897,
-0.22821569442749023,
-0.09308239072561264,
1.0415526628494263,
0.1743917465209961,
0.3523123860359192,
0.4099326729774475,
0.36001479625701904,
0.5085732340812683,
-0.17998236417770386,
0.866289496421814,
-0.07461263984441757,
0.19644087553024292,
0.9861667156219482,
-0.3339029550552368,
1.0248850584030151,
0.44644203782081604,
-0.22412794828414917,
0.6905202269554138,
0.8850302696228027,
-0.03176837041974068,
-0.12280205637216568,
0.46137237548828125,
-0.14997908473014832,
-0.46023479104042053,
-0.24403458833694458,
-0.2900967597961426,
0.532881498336792,
0.7194721102714539,
-0.15779830515384674,
-0.12802940607070923,
-0.1645730584859848,
0.10031982511281967,
0.47635748982429504,
-0.14459165930747986,
0.6536426544189453,
0.0512135773897171,
-0.8039937019348145,
0.5377004146575928,
0.09402253478765488,
0.5016114711761475,
-0.4062492847442627,
-0.3953036963939667,
-0.09710394591093063,
-0.3078068792819977,
-0.021138746291399002,
-1.0737625360488892,
0.22956611216068268,
0.1758957803249359,
0.10575450956821442,
0.007681789342314005,
0.561175525188446,
-0.06998927891254425,
-0.3663027882575989,
0.21095697581768036,
0.604835569858551,
0.0779377669095993,
0.4207191467285156,
-0.9682978987693787,
0.3587818443775177,
-0.3632613718509674,
-0.4432545602321625,
0.3148210048675537,
0.36933937668800354,
-0.02825758419930935,
0.6435664892196655,
0.5027657151222229,
0.16651158034801483,
0.18137918412685394,
-0.022650593891739845,
0.6196503043174744,
-0.33872494101524353,
-0.03012029081583023,
-0.9580754041671753,
0.426797091960907,
-0.23031337559223175,
-0.5397828221321106,
0.43071964383125305,
0.10744170844554901,
0.5047894716262817,
0.3080671727657318,
0.4195748567581177,
0.04734618961811066,
0.3493098020553589,
-0.6132997274398804,
0.6964988708496094,
-0.48661938309669495,
0.02151390165090561,
-0.4509904980659485,
-0.9013153910636902,
-0.21390335261821747,
0.8643474578857422,
-0.39098507165908813,
0.18056043982505798,
0.7974411249160767,
0.27261266112327576,
-0.07736654579639435,
0.3037189543247223,
0.26147758960723877,
0.10268178582191467,
0.526101291179657,
0.48092541098594666,
1.4437534809112549,
-0.38836005330085754,
0.22730493545532227,
-0.0788230150938034,
-0.14012280106544495,
-0.0765460729598999,
-1.1173914670944214,
-0.8149635791778564,
-0.5348291397094727,
-0.6341052055358887,
-0.4758506715297699,
0.12242156267166138,
1.1328877210617065,
0.5599960684776306,
-0.8083460330963135,
-0.35352787375450134,
0.24880890548229218,
0.3586902618408203,
-0.38004013895988464,
-0.23764032125473022,
0.6495816707611084,
-0.42384663224220276,
-0.7360806465148926,
0.5918869972229004,
0.16316670179367065,
-0.1588810384273529,
-0.4958394169807434,
0.009190392680466175,
-0.30439215898513794,
0.5694111585617065,
0.8652888536453247,
0.492862731218338,
-0.7903704047203064,
-0.5763710141181946,
-0.36470794677734375,
-0.020662181079387665,
0.20884472131729126,
0.7962603569030762,
-0.20310597121715546,
0.6162528991699219,
0.31166067719459534,
1.217291235923767,
-0.18151216208934784,
0.08498736470937729,
0.5144948363304138,
-0.17628009617328644,
-0.33243778347969055,
0.5750307440757751,
0.3655222952365875,
0.4847199618816376,
0.013763372786343098,
0.30848029255867004,
0.17507076263427734,
-0.7121466994285583,
-1.0290465354919434,
0.06427153944969177,
-0.8787912726402283,
-0.4308154284954071,
1.1103386878967285,
-0.4585498869419098,
-0.14172233641147614,
-0.09131848067045212,
-0.2535151243209839,
-0.12831944227218628,
-0.22403232753276825,
1.0463595390319824,
1.1243754625320435,
-0.13229280710220337,
-0.3645115792751312,
-0.8677647113800049,
0.43595898151397705,
0.8534114360809326,
-1.0428622961044312,
0.24213770031929016,
0.509983479976654,
0.09585046768188477,
0.2477777898311615,
0.196586012840271,
-0.30418381094932556,
0.27350202202796936,
0.0038320571184158325,
-0.1771322637796402,
0.16665710508823395,
-0.47680798172950745,
-0.3853134214878082,
0.6203624606132507,
0.45374640822410583,
0.13025330007076263
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07954v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07954v1
|
An efficient domain-independent approach for supervised keyphrase extraction and ranking
| 2024-03-24T08:33:27 | 2024-03-24T08:33:27 |
Sriraghavendra Ramaswamy
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.LG, H.3.1; I.2.7
|
We present a supervised learning approach for automatic extraction of
keyphrases from single documents. Our solution uses simple to compute
statistical and positional features of candidate phrases and does not rely on
any external knowledge base or on pre-trained language models or word
embeddings. The ranking component of our proposed solution is a fairly
lightweight ensemble model. Evaluation on benchmark datasets shows that our
approach achieves significantly higher accuracy than several state-of-the-art
baseline models, including all deep learning-based unsupervised models compared
with, and is competitive with some supervised deep learning-based models too.
Despite the supervised nature of our solution, the fact that does not rely on
any corpus of "golden" keywords or any external knowledge corpus means that our
solution bears the advantages of unsupervised solutions to a fair extent.
|
[
0.1569780856370926,
-0.37440502643585205,
0.5516186952590942,
0.1730428785085678,
-0.48754191398620605,
0.1932094246149063,
-0.2922126352787018,
0.11183813214302063,
0.2050885558128357,
0.9055696725845337,
-0.21642377972602844,
-0.9175282716751099,
-0.9643785357475281,
0.23164817690849304,
-0.695953905582428,
0.923015296459198,
0.38378995656967163,
0.052974432706832886,
-0.2630770206451416,
-0.029188701882958412,
0.026066094636917114,
-0.5287840366363525,
-0.26447099447250366,
-0.01803392358124256,
0.24869434535503387,
0.4604867100715637,
0.41125771403312683,
0.7138009071350098,
1.0689502954483032,
0.273019403219223,
0.011758645065128803,
0.07915331423282623,
-0.1627120077610016,
0.5592236518859863,
-0.20494283735752106,
-0.2591516077518463,
-0.2215745747089386,
0.2599342167377472,
0.30062568187713623,
0.8128555417060852,
0.10370499640703201,
-0.059898775070905685,
0.24239879846572876,
0.6755633354187012,
-0.5903030633926392,
0.2077423632144928,
-1.0929594039916992,
-0.03328562155365944,
-0.47885724902153015,
-0.28676050901412964,
-0.428946852684021,
-0.4281354546546936,
0.17839926481246948,
-0.7358130216598511,
0.544925332069397,
-0.15499313175678253,
0.48499175906181335,
0.17506299912929535,
-0.42267051339149475,
-0.4471502900123596,
-0.003285688115283847,
0.7170457243919373,
-0.4668855667114258,
0.21774598956108093,
0.26375752687454224,
0.02645145356655121,
-0.05649757385253906,
-1.2104520797729492,
-0.10892076045274734,
-0.02479040063917637,
-0.0611187219619751,
0.27867695689201355,
0.18898481130599976,
0.244669571518898,
-0.21151579916477203,
0.2096133828163147,
-0.7053024768829346,
-0.025494897738099098,
-0.42640450596809387,
-0.03759745880961418,
0.7981997728347778,
-0.21565105020999908,
0.07646244019269943,
-0.5283176302909851,
-0.15618914365768433,
-0.30315127968788147,
-0.4014875292778015,
0.012795166112482548,
0.12444163113832474,
0.8253642320632935,
0.2959013879299164,
0.5392500758171082,
-0.4270763397216797,
0.1395268738269806,
0.19461502134799957,
-0.091639444231987,
0.20178133249282837,
-0.18835461139678955,
-0.04376639425754547,
0.24854488670825958,
0.9533794522285461,
0.10380933433771133,
0.40143436193466187,
-0.9289284944534302,
-0.1407105028629303,
0.03335876017808914,
0.47520628571510315,
-0.8023644685745239,
-0.7617242336273193,
0.2721877098083496,
-0.5486426949501038,
-0.8506317734718323,
0.385477215051651,
-1.0102936029434204,
-0.23335979878902435,
0.056385353207588196,
0.6301583051681519,
-0.47521981596946716,
0.2021554559469223,
-0.24283577501773834,
-0.7352455854415894,
-0.20840714871883392,
0.008778170682489872,
-0.7853496074676514,
0.3262246251106262,
0.7976608872413635,
0.8573228120803833,
-0.8321791291236877,
-0.10236749053001404,
-0.40175536274909973,
0.07227262109518051,
-0.4165422022342682,
0.7013920545578003,
-0.7831575274467468,
-0.7309607267379761,
0.1119748204946518,
0.26179108023643494,
-0.36344388127326965,
-0.5983160734176636,
1.1384906768798828,
-0.7549108266830444,
0.18657605350017548,
0.10697624087333679,
-0.907404363155365,
-0.13815559446811676,
-0.17408260703086853,
-0.6162682771682739,
0.7623051404953003,
-0.1525878608226776,
-0.7798495888710022,
0.40540435910224915,
-0.8868829607963562,
-0.7994894981384277,
0.39407166838645935,
-0.12421169131994247,
-0.40042364597320557,
0.29539766907691956,
0.5352920889854431,
0.5082232356071472,
0.06821082532405853,
0.17992453277111053,
-0.2928547263145447,
-0.20049244165420532,
0.07936077564954758,
-0.26476019620895386,
0.9730491042137146,
0.3842630982398987,
-0.30023059248924255,
-0.2037723958492279,
-0.6898797154426575,
0.5018648505210876,
0.30109795928001404,
-0.26738888025283813,
-0.7731281518936157,
-0.00799642875790596,
0.20558519661426544,
-0.14607007801532745,
0.48725399374961853,
-0.551016628742218,
0.46162667870521545,
-0.39183488488197327,
0.24826905131340027,
0.7178525328636169,
0.46543997526168823,
0.6784169673919678,
0.014079329557716846,
0.4866243898868561,
-0.25447559356689453,
-0.11673004925251007,
0.12470279633998871,
-0.43745237588882446,
-0.20015442371368408,
-0.8301451206207275,
0.6917082071304321,
0.608299195766449,
-0.3770395517349243,
0.5343295931816101,
-0.5236610770225525,
-0.44088980555534363,
-0.5478017330169678,
0.5659394264221191,
0.2419489324092865,
0.2356836199760437,
0.35177484154701233,
-0.3542800545692444,
-0.29536259174346924,
-0.6093809604644775,
-0.40636277198791504,
0.1358797401189804,
-0.00783324521034956,
-0.11556663364171982,
0.6406905055046082,
0.017725368961691856,
1.0006457567214966,
-0.6970536112785339,
-0.6472470164299011,
-0.20299825072288513,
0.4681835174560547,
0.2830481231212616,
0.44125282764434814,
0.18009009957313538,
-1.2416694164276123,
-0.6581571698188782,
-0.07790112495422363,
-1.1612167358398438,
-0.3160932958126068,
0.16707272827625275,
0.0060248104855418205,
-0.27102550864219666,
0.5460205674171448,
-0.5876851081848145,
0.141227588057518,
0.09829138964414597,
0.20080868899822235,
-0.13134238123893738,
-0.21920783817768097,
0.23892688751220703,
-1.0035334825515747,
0.26299548149108887,
0.09236480295658112,
0.2669658958911896,
-0.618285059928894,
0.364400714635849,
0.38496920466423035,
-0.2717715799808502,
-0.19964252412319183,
0.46614667773246765,
-0.26763805747032166,
0.25244706869125366,
-0.3157292604446411,
0.3735704720020294,
0.029771562665700912,
0.35418280959129333,
0.4686942994594574,
0.6958091855049133,
0.5232686996459961,
-0.5447052121162415,
0.12962129712104797,
0.42997878789901733,
-0.1930059790611267,
0.2624930739402771,
-0.6721029877662659,
0.10634434223175049,
0.07133946567773819,
-0.06363832950592041,
-0.8434188961982727,
-0.192448690533638,
-0.17179086804389954,
-0.6509450078010559,
0.3458649218082428,
-0.37358391284942627,
-0.5227190256118774,
-0.13051427900791168,
-0.45862099528312683,
-0.11841045320034027,
0.40790194272994995,
-0.5472665429115295,
0.12318319827318192,
0.7084566354751587,
-0.5643540024757385,
-0.3586573600769043,
-0.224165678024292,
0.24174226820468903,
-0.47606807947158813,
-0.4980901777744293,
0.643065869808197,
0.25846245884895325,
-0.3185165524482727,
-0.06776712089776993,
-0.19072507321834564,
-0.6169630289077759,
0.4841316342353821,
0.37867510318756104,
0.08739755302667618,
0.089814193546772,
0.3397633731365204,
0.20339304208755493,
-0.10596748441457748,
-0.2788175642490387,
-0.36854657530784607,
0.08487553149461746,
0.16320417821407318,
-0.10359134525060654,
-0.42978930473327637,
0.6845453381538391,
0.8328705430030823,
-0.5399319529533386,
0.29971542954444885,
0.3056724965572357,
-0.4111001193523407,
-0.10052791237831116,
-0.05884404480457306,
-0.22324126958847046,
-0.4762689173221588,
0.19018685817718506,
-0.3802368640899658,
-0.3784027397632599,
0.1672581285238266,
-0.15186059474945068,
0.22506900131702423,
0.6853532195091248,
0.3374346196651459,
-0.2571220397949219,
1.2780526876449585,
0.6437075734138489,
-0.21531467139720917,
0.2425464242696762,
-0.16646091639995575,
0.3351224958896637,
-0.4303922653198242,
-0.07851553708314896,
-0.7916231751441956,
0.020160675048828125,
-0.8208689093589783,
-0.019846638664603233,
0.4321892261505127,
0.2562166750431061,
0.05197342485189438,
0.4352157413959503,
-0.9385300874710083,
0.08150481432676315,
0.7238329648971558,
-0.020162733271718025,
0.35543128848075867,
0.06837071478366852,
-0.32017824053764343,
-0.10033263266086578,
-0.5382575988769531,
-0.6636998653411865,
1.7151342630386353,
-0.11074572801589966,
0.9332861304283142,
0.05369490012526512,
1.3358556032180786,
0.7394553422927856,
0.094694584608078,
-0.5886229872703552,
0.39591410756111145,
-0.5111580491065979,
-0.8006990551948547,
-0.38424843549728394,
-0.26113197207450867,
-1.2339123487472534,
0.5289751291275024,
-0.254140704870224,
-0.8313848972320557,
0.0077438512817025185,
-0.3990796208381653,
-0.4097648561000824,
-0.29001832008361816,
-0.6535570025444031,
1.0139678716659546,
-0.4173038601875305,
-0.158920556306839,
0.12989889085292816,
-0.679320216178894,
0.2157791405916214,
-0.4136509299278259,
0.27686062455177307,
0.19900767505168915,
-0.0782788023352623,
1.2179386615753174,
-0.30439773201942444,
0.3900608420372009,
-0.12683524191379547,
0.24590517580509186,
0.17605063319206238,
-0.24217157065868378,
0.5923423767089844,
-0.024722332134842873,
-0.08537310361862183,
-0.14829429984092712,
0.25716128945350647,
-0.12369322031736374,
-0.4961833655834198,
0.7081090807914734,
-0.5634499788284302,
-0.3404547870159149,
-0.41917499899864197,
-0.39363256096839905,
-0.2806577980518341,
0.39980119466781616,
0.6765264868736267,
0.1803818941116333,
-0.1826779991388321,
0.6782777309417725,
0.8847799301147461,
0.2697381377220154,
0.40845897793769836,
0.33069005608558655,
-0.00874505378305912,
-0.4232584238052368,
0.7242538928985596,
0.23072439432144165,
-0.1715211570262909,
0.7080792784690857,
0.30774828791618347,
-0.3467206656932831,
-0.6676235198974609,
-0.10303963720798492,
-0.06415920704603195,
-0.8249789476394653,
-0.020465653389692307,
-1.047917127609253,
-0.22229239344596863,
-1.2315564155578613,
-0.23991627991199493,
-0.32061636447906494,
-0.7465543150901794,
-0.05548761785030365,
-0.09110613912343979,
0.3420678675174713,
0.15500275790691376,
0.020761609077453613,
0.4477229118347168,
-1.0716911554336548,
0.5548421740531921,
0.3576146960258484,
-0.2540907859802246,
-0.44350138306617737,
-0.6907603740692139,
-0.2278469204902649,
-0.3843916654586792,
-0.2853490114212036,
-0.895552396774292,
0.6067302823066711,
0.5693691372871399,
0.978603720664978,
0.5796899795532227,
0.5328056812286377,
0.35692763328552246,
-0.42899295687675476,
0.8080983757972717,
-0.19672012329101562,
-0.6482363343238831,
0.7641724348068237,
-0.20398622751235962,
0.13157808780670166,
1.2760387659072876,
0.5415707230567932,
-0.05519059672951698,
-0.623269259929657,
-0.7713684439659119,
-0.8718580603599548,
0.3089934289455414,
0.37417811155319214,
-0.04183289781212807,
-0.28399860858917236,
0.0586596243083477,
0.19377735257148743,
0.30572324991226196,
-0.5377593040466309,
-0.23416244983673096,
-0.12608760595321655,
-0.6175172328948975,
0.019986510276794434,
0.2666093707084656,
-0.17138347029685974,
-0.09451040625572205,
0.9652187824249268,
-0.25614720582962036,
-0.048760004341602325,
0.2574100196361542,
-0.5316391587257385,
0.10607217997312546,
0.21334199607372284,
-0.0047158896923065186,
0.27899646759033203,
-0.5694438219070435,
0.12867404520511627,
-0.21991944313049316,
-0.6627666354179382,
-0.03943747282028198,
0.37771084904670715,
-0.1648857593536377,
0.3606404662132263,
0.5241388082504272,
-0.18180479109287262,
0.4598601460456848,
-0.7475085258483887,
0.9339809417724609,
0.0012958926381543279,
-0.2758190631866455,
-0.06419181078672409,
-0.15966252982616425,
-0.07317621260881424,
0.2710295021533966,
0.8361805081367493,
-0.012923258356750011,
0.4565211236476898,
-0.4719896614551544,
0.786527693271637,
0.7018919587135315,
-0.2306666076183319,
0.019685382023453712,
0.6421622633934021,
0.19376027584075928,
-0.27668502926826477,
0.532120406627655,
0.007606341037899256,
-0.7447099685668945,
0.4259519577026367,
0.22238880395889282,
1.090624213218689,
-0.08238648623228073,
0.17795324325561523,
0.13631205260753632,
0.2714565098285675,
-0.10965730994939804,
-0.17620742321014404,
-0.35922902822494507,
-0.60308837890625,
0.23858152329921722,
-0.6075631380081177,
-0.4089933931827545,
-0.08479386568069458,
-0.7392516732215881,
0.005744585767388344,
-0.18042799830436707,
-0.2040708065032959,
0.34035301208496094,
0.48188602924346924,
-0.49954167008399963,
0.3291114270687103,
-0.047833699733018875,
0.8691294193267822,
-0.8673530220985413,
1.0462907552719116,
0.416275292634964,
-0.5924766063690186,
-0.1906893253326416,
0.14253199100494385,
-0.12984783947467804,
-0.7720373868942261,
0.8186593651771545,
0.16284137964248657,
0.06970387697219849,
-0.08300218731164932,
-0.5186676979064941,
-0.7517644762992859,
0.9926422238349915,
-0.07487096637487411,
-0.09725092351436615,
-0.3508191704750061,
-0.21392840147018433,
0.29571080207824707,
-0.302763432264328,
-0.25383639335632324,
0.24781575798988342,
0.2761802673339844,
-0.1337701976299286,
-0.7078518271446228,
-0.27517566084861755,
-0.3553224205970764,
-0.26103726029396057,
-0.024946561083197594,
-0.24797651171684265,
0.5574880838394165,
0.11158974468708038,
-0.3072546124458313,
0.26984360814094543,
0.7240578532218933,
0.033960793167352676,
0.2605529725551605,
0.25224563479423523,
0.6134081482887268,
0.8370062708854675,
0.2864733636379242,
0.8508275747299194,
-0.7999498248100281,
0.4890676438808441,
1.0307215452194214,
-0.32489657402038574,
0.878909707069397,
0.5070106387138367,
-0.03980735316872597,
0.013550098985433578,
0.5353186726570129,
0.08683205395936966,
1.4062016010284424,
-0.11274164915084839,
-0.21496330201625824,
-0.5418891906738281,
0.27185067534446716,
-0.28800666332244873,
0.7812538743019104,
0.22341635823249817,
-0.8235615491867065,
-0.37324854731559753,
-0.004248431883752346,
-0.11362998187541962,
0.24679410457611084,
-0.1293690949678421,
0.80776447057724,
0.3112512528896332,
-0.8029630184173584,
0.10672333091497421,
0.07037436217069626,
0.5782820582389832,
-0.7967559099197388,
0.15277281403541565,
-0.07249433547258377,
0.3500603139400482,
-0.1688699573278427,
-0.5807849764823914,
-0.12129869312047958,
0.3336787521839142,
-0.12310639768838882,
-0.37493637204170227,
0.7727504372596741,
-0.2696075737476349,
-0.7588717937469482,
0.056477200239896774,
0.6539744138717651,
0.22194021940231323,
-0.3726889491081238,
-0.5334910750389099,
-0.5174102783203125,
-0.16467423737049103,
-0.325652539730072,
0.5645146369934082,
0.4963320791721344,
0.10771211236715317,
0.25269815325737,
0.5200077295303345,
0.02628282830119133,
0.16040194034576416,
-0.22921723127365112,
0.4363095760345459,
-0.4316392242908478,
-0.4747666120529175,
-0.6585696339607239,
0.18428102135658264,
-0.5298281311988831,
-0.2202700525522232,
0.9411698579788208,
0.6283788681030273,
0.36015716195106506,
-0.025907959789037704,
1.1785579919815063,
0.1977124661207199,
0.6289858818054199,
-0.4916035830974579,
0.8962563872337341,
-0.514050304889679,
-0.0939779132604599,
-0.462643027305603,
-0.8220387697219849,
-0.3746402859687805,
0.7769200801849365,
-0.17912235856056213,
-0.3208824098110199,
0.754037618637085,
0.7570827603340149,
0.07031618803739548,
0.08263340592384338,
0.26940008997917175,
-0.38093963265419006,
0.18883803486824036,
0.06866252422332764,
0.08171990513801575,
-0.45513609051704407,
0.49689406156539917,
-0.4383551776409149,
-0.31036582589149475,
-0.3608921468257904,
-0.6890278458595276,
-0.5079313516616821,
-0.6627457141876221,
-0.4977845251560211,
0.07650330662727356,
0.18589673936367035,
0.9944196343421936,
0.6141110062599182,
-0.9033876657485962,
0.0967937558889389,
0.03811757639050484,
0.33848705887794495,
-0.4975667893886566,
-0.2983251214027405,
0.7443537712097168,
-0.7421842813491821,
-0.718442976474762,
0.7902060151100159,
0.2270222008228302,
-0.4522589147090912,
0.306206613779068,
0.2866477072238922,
-0.3557935059070587,
0.1832076758146286,
0.3882516026496887,
0.12066331505775452,
-0.3505932092666626,
-0.2660583257675171,
0.0946616530418396,
-0.46236467361450195,
-0.01320068072527647,
0.5870516896247864,
-0.6183517575263977,
0.40052416920661926,
0.554887056350708,
0.8275078535079956,
0.2873591184616089,
0.19998952746391296,
0.32299134135246277,
-0.6526888608932495,
-0.1916038542985916,
0.24003781378269196,
0.33885660767555237,
0.07467854022979736,
-0.2692610025405884,
0.6410098075866699,
0.5705727934837341,
-0.4253513813018799,
-0.6873936057090759,
-0.2675415277481079,
-1.16390860080719,
-0.4075230062007904,
0.9777132868766785,
-0.3071049153804779,
-0.12025545537471771,
0.01197661180049181,
0.22930622100830078,
0.25960004329681396,
-0.30607709288597107,
0.8772428035736084,
0.42119383811950684,
0.1367630660533905,
0.08378573507070541,
-0.3535816967487335,
0.28648021817207336,
0.1346845179796219,
-0.5153518915176392,
-0.08898521959781647,
0.11110787838697433,
0.32027193903923035,
0.3839433491230011,
0.580244779586792,
-0.36292320489883423,
0.09662576019763947,
0.05575587600469589,
-0.0245494581758976,
0.18916131556034088,
-0.3354450464248657,
-0.3572799861431122,
0.9482649564743042,
-0.007288825698196888,
-0.5821282863616943
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16056v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16056v3
|
Qibo: A Large Language Model for Traditional Chinese Medicine
| 2024-03-24T07:48:05 | 2024-06-22T05:43:53 |
Heyi Zhang, Xin Wang, Zhaopeng Meng, Zhe Chen, Pengwei Zhuang, Yongzhe Jia, Dawei Xu, Wenbin Guo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) has made significant progress in a number of
professional fields, including medicine, law, and finance. However, in
traditional Chinese medicine (TCM), there are challenges such as the essential
differences between theory and modern medicine, the lack of specialized corpus
resources, and the fact that relying only on supervised fine-tuning may lead to
overconfident predictions. To address these challenges, we propose a two-stage
training approach that combines continuous pre-training and supervised
fine-tuning. A notable contribution of our study is the processing of a 2GB
corpus dedicated to TCM, constructing pre-training and instruction fine-tuning
datasets for TCM, respectively. In addition, we have developed Qibo-Benchmark,
a tool that evaluates the performance of LLM in the TCM on multiple dimensions,
including subjective, objective, and three TCM NLP tasks. The medical LLM
trained with our pipeline, named $\textbf{Qibo}$, exhibits significant
performance boosts. Compared to the baselines, the average subjective win rate
is 63%, the average objective accuracy improved by 23% to 58%, and the Rouge-L
scores for the three TCM NLP tasks are 0.72, 0.61, and 0.55. Finally, we
propose a pipline to apply Qibo to TCM consultation and demonstrate the model
performance through the case study.
|
[
0.1840299367904663,
-0.6872060894966125,
0.5022253394126892,
-0.0017423221142962575,
-0.4934207499027252,
0.05349058657884598,
-0.6116737723350525,
-0.4108196794986725,
0.128743514418602,
0.5472220182418823,
-0.22518891096115112,
-0.6665102243423462,
-0.4761057496070862,
-0.06257686764001846,
0.01565660536289215,
0.8690328598022461,
0.0787997767329216,
0.8987248539924622,
0.3004080057144165,
0.10356628894805908,
-0.506565511226654,
-0.20927415788173676,
-0.9859185814857483,
-0.6801690459251404,
0.5602095723152161,
0.2733774781227112,
0.6095576286315918,
0.6790844202041626,
0.4176395535469055,
0.11120916157960892,
-0.12645883858203888,
0.4236983060836792,
-0.3910013735294342,
-0.009312569163739681,
-0.25486046075820923,
-0.6025599837303162,
-0.60801762342453,
0.07656005769968033,
0.7335077524185181,
0.6824398040771484,
-0.6117408871650696,
0.02430715598165989,
0.04628927260637283,
0.6947439908981323,
-0.33899831771850586,
-0.025211749598383904,
-0.6532018184661865,
0.1691206693649292,
-0.2111310362815857,
-0.3516015112400055,
-0.36236998438835144,
-0.35679659247398376,
-0.062416188418865204,
-0.5520166754722595,
0.0825403556227684,
0.09178796410560608,
1.09255850315094,
0.1327880322933197,
-0.49028831720352173,
-0.07455148547887802,
-0.48714888095855713,
0.5164502263069153,
-1.0682947635650635,
0.11430512368679047,
0.2991923689842224,
0.3405090570449829,
-0.499651163816452,
-0.8516258597373962,
-0.45184609293937683,
-0.5024912357330322,
-0.03068426623940468,
0.3274662494659424,
0.32367104291915894,
0.4651210904121399,
0.3242568075656891,
0.3706200122833252,
-0.5115671157836914,
0.3824237883090973,
-0.33126363158226013,
0.11824806034564972,
0.5420693159103394,
0.36107251048088074,
0.2561573386192322,
-0.03635711222887039,
-0.3144104778766632,
0.06591033190488815,
-0.7545023560523987,
0.06774666905403137,
-0.2721419036388397,
0.2697306275367737,
0.03403375297784805,
0.1486419141292572,
-0.3469181954860687,
0.8814419507980347,
0.16272561252117157,
-0.5467721223831177,
-0.01365850493311882,
-0.2315836250782013,
-0.4484638571739197,
0.08970865607261658,
0.9767318367958069,
0.2210085093975067,
-0.004059367347508669,
-0.05589616671204567,
-0.15820010006427765,
-0.2104351669549942,
0.3560071885585785,
-0.9825248122215271,
-0.40061113238334656,
0.5173022150993347,
-0.6566033959388733,
-0.21017427742481232,
-0.08163636922836304,
-0.15374472737312317,
-0.5647017955780029,
-0.47375890612602234,
0.2356242835521698,
-0.741107702255249,
-0.2901783883571625,
0.26261788606643677,
0.15129482746124268,
0.3440200686454773,
0.4629642963409424,
-0.868395209312439,
0.2984464466571808,
0.9501655101776123,
1.0536072254180908,
0.07020270824432373,
-0.15324559807777405,
-0.7444526553153992,
0.3321591317653656,
-0.7927725315093994,
0.692215085029602,
-0.39366278052330017,
-0.3462507724761963,
-0.08534001559019089,
-0.10274191200733185,
0.13925525546073914,
-0.7605109810829163,
0.5176189541816711,
-0.016454210504889488,
-0.00944417342543602,
-0.2851353883743286,
-0.5284923911094666,
0.007480451371520758,
0.28524720668792725,
-0.3916209638118744,
0.7275344729423523,
0.3346483111381531,
-0.5598396062850952,
0.5326049327850342,
-0.5051712393760681,
-0.6201223134994507,
0.37170520424842834,
-0.14558929204940796,
-0.335860013961792,
0.08268341422080994,
0.024161571636795998,
0.5414928197860718,
-0.6536918878555298,
0.592501699924469,
-0.28490495681762695,
-0.5370635390281677,
0.10255224257707596,
0.02828006073832512,
0.944071352481842,
0.30096763372421265,
-0.10767849534749985,
0.1997227519750595,
-0.8389182686805725,
0.15881571173667908,
-0.1199427917599678,
-0.36074498295783997,
-0.35826346278190613,
0.09715914726257324,
-0.032056644558906555,
0.2868272662162781,
0.12173254042863846,
-0.3930278420448303,
0.4796038866043091,
-0.5775178670883179,
0.5925231575965881,
0.41898220777511597,
-0.3110860288143158,
-0.10038723051548004,
-0.3797750473022461,
0.2561935484409332,
0.12481928616762161,
0.2126258909702301,
-0.08725423365831375,
-0.25534379482269287,
-0.5776971578598022,
-0.3895651400089264,
0.45755910873413086,
0.36326462030410767,
-0.7985503673553467,
0.44174012541770935,
-0.17115122079849243,
-0.7437167763710022,
-0.7929644584655762,
0.29149943590164185,
0.26515352725982666,
0.7662332057952881,
0.3598695397377014,
-0.5343340039253235,
-0.08160001039505005,
-0.6848597526550293,
-0.06291268765926361,
-0.3659053146839142,
-0.33730843663215637,
0.04978781193494797,
0.15405048429965973,
-0.3174327313899994,
0.5564996600151062,
-0.4585293233394623,
-0.7029375433921814,
-0.28840985894203186,
0.3152042627334595,
0.35725006461143494,
0.4110857844352722,
0.3884888291358948,
-0.5063067674636841,
-0.5422313809394836,
0.45469966530799866,
-0.4474101662635803,
-0.2918255627155304,
-0.2986880838871002,
-0.14336250722408295,
0.2641444802284241,
0.29739174246788025,
-0.36850401759147644,
-0.014418629929423332,
0.6293120980262756,
-0.06972290575504303,
0.5750035643577576,
-0.634894609451294,
0.060329776257276535,
-1.218400239944458,
0.18211506307125092,
0.06641117483377457,
-0.16648966073989868,
-0.7337824106216431,
0.08457757532596588,
0.49622976779937744,
0.19242297112941742,
-0.27423518896102905,
0.43676209449768066,
-0.5097044110298157,
0.4861426055431366,
-0.5806218385696411,
0.12850318849086761,
-0.14894486963748932,
0.28110095858573914,
0.46329158544540405,
0.2032325714826584,
0.5020791292190552,
-0.5820353031158447,
0.7083508968353271,
-0.07358700782060623,
-0.4819272458553314,
0.6514776945114136,
-0.7379144430160522,
0.02691524103283882,
0.19497334957122803,
0.3785092234611511,
-0.7181018590927124,
-0.23991014063358307,
0.19217604398727417,
-0.2611110806465149,
0.7605397701263428,
0.15470853447914124,
-0.5824468731880188,
-0.3903299570083618,
-0.24976198375225067,
0.011834690347313881,
0.41584649682044983,
-0.2862841784954071,
0.581997275352478,
0.06973633915185928,
-0.11430522799491882,
-0.5529062747955322,
-0.5008047223091125,
0.2044065296649933,
0.00928057637065649,
-0.5078639388084412,
0.34720832109451294,
0.1385568529367447,
0.04890059307217598,
-0.2833804786205292,
0.00793923158198595,
-0.08865576237440109,
0.27494803071022034,
0.11004437506198883,
0.28425467014312744,
-0.24968087673187256,
0.3056229054927826,
0.3291000425815582,
-0.03934108093380928,
0.14882400631904602,
-0.34407925605773926,
0.4469767212867737,
0.22505509853363037,
-0.11916371434926987,
-0.4901566207408905,
-0.02932862564921379,
0.12017940729856491,
-0.30227410793304443,
0.8651435375213623,
0.6557070016860962,
-0.45497918128967285,
-0.3216070234775543,
-0.6329112648963928,
-0.11933916807174683,
-0.39157015085220337,
0.5747465491294861,
-0.17147690057754517,
-0.5663002729415894,
0.16148145496845245,
-0.1970616728067398,
0.2008618414402008,
0.0642586350440979,
0.8674740195274353,
-0.005421802401542664,
0.7470422387123108,
0.4699612855911255,
-0.061646703630685806,
0.40718260407447815,
0.02049277350306511,
0.1319718360900879,
-0.7990803122520447,
-0.26284846663475037,
-0.27069786190986633,
-0.2022583931684494,
-0.6192952394485474,
-0.4022637903690338,
0.35489484667778015,
0.16840264201164246,
-0.19066588580608368,
0.2617509663105011,
-0.3049491345882416,
0.15635736286640167,
0.6455177068710327,
0.44081956148147583,
0.2486485093832016,
-0.4257045388221741,
-0.015831012278795242,
0.2619189918041229,
-0.7470802664756775,
-0.4684341549873352,
1.1819390058517456,
0.5447713732719421,
0.8772755265235901,
-0.14749859273433685,
0.6308767795562744,
-0.25388315320014954,
0.5490912795066833,
-0.9105918407440186,
0.3286977708339691,
-0.4048105776309967,
-0.6011430025100708,
-0.3430221974849701,
-0.49014049768447876,
-0.8546380400657654,
0.33008521795272827,
-0.41977572441101074,
-0.3759918808937073,
-0.3115048408508301,
0.22642464935779572,
-0.9277400970458984,
0.29997798800468445,
-0.5882821083068848,
0.8024455904960632,
-0.5448285341262817,
-0.5000598430633545,
-0.3736768662929535,
-0.9666615128517151,
0.5850220322608948,
-0.3314165472984314,
0.027004269883036613,
-0.1150338351726532,
0.010230532847344875,
0.5449037551879883,
-0.28808483481407166,
0.6004052758216858,
-0.07476957142353058,
-0.20169483125209808,
-0.0377364456653595,
0.02269679866731167,
0.1998881995677948,
0.30553942918777466,
0.010377413593232632,
0.3214642405509949,
0.5478936433792114,
-0.5774868130683899,
-0.41681134700775146,
0.4227682054042816,
-0.6518210172653198,
-0.7064015865325928,
-0.596382200717926,
-0.5222817063331604,
-0.35651957988739014,
0.3425011932849884,
0.13017146289348602,
0.23525436222553253,
-0.35802406072616577,
0.24734088778495789,
0.5285013318061829,
-0.6813783049583435,
-0.07740505784749985,
0.9397081136703491,
-0.03802221268415451,
-0.18772730231285095,
0.5054478049278259,
0.2230452001094818,
0.47526878118515015,
0.4855119585990906,
0.4900714159011841,
-0.056320346891880035,
-0.849892795085907,
-0.18673233687877655,
0.41206592321395874,
-0.26087653636932373,
-0.22195777297019958,
-0.4790820777416229,
-0.47880247235298157,
-0.5838238000869751,
0.18689870834350586,
-0.21823638677597046,
0.2781934142112732,
-0.26145052909851074,
0.10820596665143967,
-0.004361493978649378,
0.5444655418395996,
-0.167253315448761,
0.4692852199077606,
-0.816332221031189,
0.5837053060531616,
0.1302115023136139,
0.474055677652359,
-0.02307833917438984,
-0.5996979475021362,
-0.7301629185676575,
0.25311020016670227,
-0.5094927549362183,
-0.550222635269165,
0.5899192690849304,
0.11822102218866348,
0.4164544641971588,
0.9240093231201172,
0.09235025942325592,
0.8060769438743591,
-0.7159162759780884,
0.7765015959739685,
0.46956586837768555,
-0.7111324071884155,
0.5940687656402588,
-0.2537659704685211,
0.1985340416431427,
0.37130096554756165,
0.25185468792915344,
-0.8352911472320557,
-0.5312243103981018,
-0.21827934682369232,
-0.6857670545578003,
0.8448220491409302,
-0.3144190013408661,
0.051060423254966736,
-0.03145429864525795,
0.5125792026519775,
0.0927007719874382,
0.18248429894447327,
-0.5228355526924133,
-0.151651993393898,
0.07249129563570023,
-0.14158551394939423,
-0.14263319969177246,
-0.3793627917766571,
-0.30097636580467224,
-0.3516899645328522,
0.7109538912773132,
-0.2390740066766739,
-0.15233579277992249,
0.12935735285282135,
0.12170033901929855,
-0.31466856598854065,
0.17722883820533752,
0.47180941700935364,
1.0093088150024414,
-0.32687273621559143,
-0.21477268636226654,
0.1621285080909729,
-0.6291528344154358,
-0.0748031884431839,
0.13765084743499756,
0.06793470680713654,
0.12072055041790009,
0.46197354793548584,
0.6891948580741882,
-0.004840347450226545,
-0.7632219195365906,
0.32963788509368896,
0.11475865542888641,
-0.16826702654361725,
-0.3239898085594177,
0.19957934319972992,
0.20981459319591522,
0.24355283379554749,
0.306925892829895,
-0.5385197401046753,
0.14624229073524475,
-0.7879473567008972,
-0.038645192980766296,
0.5320093631744385,
-0.3223259150981903,
-0.07767581939697266,
0.7779598236083984,
0.13726720213890076,
-0.08185780793428421,
0.5418920516967773,
0.1356479376554489,
-0.2880474030971527,
0.45354127883911133,
0.4631379246711731,
0.5865913033485413,
-0.4401124119758606,
0.2326870709657669,
0.48557889461517334,
0.21148158609867096,
-0.6345762610435486,
-0.012082013301551342,
0.17230702936649323,
-0.5342743992805481,
-0.4447765350341797,
-0.5708115696907043,
-0.5566814541816711,
0.24255605041980743,
-0.8553692698478699,
0.7170000672340393,
-0.6393973231315613,
-0.16112816333770752,
-0.002366953529417515,
0.43352988362312317,
-0.33475926518440247,
0.4846538007259369,
0.35580915212631226,
1.0087316036224365,
-0.24530552327632904,
1.5197548866271973,
0.5459589958190918,
-0.2577689290046692,
-0.9865809082984924,
-0.023749209940433502,
-0.13180899620056152,
-0.9360111951828003,
0.6423926949501038,
0.07491739094257355,
0.05195850133895874,
-0.3350931406021118,
-0.6075890064239502,
-0.4955332577228546,
1.3077410459518433,
0.4510650038719177,
-1.1453659534454346,
-0.2709144055843353,
-0.16319629549980164,
0.8367316722869873,
-0.15034683048725128,
0.4425275921821594,
0.7614007592201233,
0.04603182524442673,
0.042908571660518646,
-1.167170524597168,
0.01980476826429367,
0.06364724785089493,
0.16321521997451782,
0.07487674802541733,
-1.0341697931289673,
0.9681936502456665,
-0.26527640223503113,
-0.24540647864341736,
0.3621976375579834,
0.5335692167282104,
0.3849879503250122,
0.27327775955200195,
0.22887635231018066,
0.26678556203842163,
0.9408130049705505,
-0.2786910831928253,
0.9235754013061523,
-0.6329307556152344,
0.24098004400730133,
1.1169154644012451,
-0.5826302170753479,
0.8837813138961792,
0.34761545062065125,
-0.16972635686397552,
0.4333384931087494,
0.9169787764549255,
-0.029478251934051514,
0.33033323287963867,
0.38669562339782715,
-0.09148307889699936,
-0.32513678073883057,
-0.05602176859974861,
-0.5515080094337463,
0.20387201011180878,
0.3545302450656891,
-0.38131651282310486,
0.21621327102184296,
-0.15849389135837555,
0.13997280597686768,
0.14907218515872955,
-0.4992160201072693,
0.7183728218078613,
0.5076651573181152,
-0.5390483736991882,
0.6937547326087952,
0.18005041778087616,
0.6812527775764465,
-1.0664249658584595,
-0.021211419254541397,
-0.3549286425113678,
0.16258680820465088,
-0.272531121969223,
-0.4916418492794037,
-0.12255088984966278,
-0.2845688760280609,
0.222314715385437,
-0.0767289251089096,
0.3062148094177246,
-0.6542366147041321,
-0.5613352060317993,
0.3053814470767975,
0.08417989313602448,
0.04259122163057327,
0.0765429213643074,
-0.5131547451019287,
-0.34928280115127563,
-0.2434411197900772,
-0.19574716687202454,
0.4237270653247833,
0.7456442713737488,
0.0111932922154665,
0.7696093320846558,
0.5547187924385071,
0.8676880598068237,
-0.47067341208457947,
0.11127115786075592,
0.8013119101524353,
-0.9851966500282288,
-0.5411392450332642,
-0.913904070854187,
0.06855639815330505,
-0.043191730976104736,
-0.24442210793495178,
0.3528548777103424,
0.3844323754310608,
0.8071849942207336,
0.08507224172353745,
0.6852636337280273,
0.14040271937847137,
0.7106108069419861,
-0.8212606310844421,
0.9560276865959167,
-0.7856572866439819,
0.1776895374059677,
-0.254882276058197,
-0.5939472317695618,
-0.35854876041412354,
0.6130777597427368,
-0.1534118950366974,
-0.11675028502941132,
0.8010514974594116,
0.5795981884002686,
0.4009702205657959,
-0.29078033566474915,
0.5663295388221741,
0.4409101605415344,
0.2914135158061981,
1.0784337520599365,
0.6489569544792175,
-0.10545720160007477,
0.24828743934631348,
-0.22973884642124176,
-0.2637661099433899,
-0.22875761985778809,
-0.6858870983123779,
-1.0229333639144897,
-0.2320409119129181,
-0.2788960933685303,
-0.4820360243320465,
0.11011632531881332,
1.3576630353927612,
0.5307700634002686,
-0.8725044131278992,
-0.5208173990249634,
0.4273764193058014,
-0.199990913271904,
-0.5473671555519104,
-0.0853695198893547,
0.44034090638160706,
-0.3617742955684662,
-0.6842784881591797,
-0.03839438036084175,
0.4005659222602844,
-0.18063299357891083,
-0.20361444354057312,
-0.08295094966888428,
0.013312004506587982,
-0.12488043308258057,
0.5748476386070251,
0.04130145162343979,
-0.9024559259414673,
-0.07436931133270264,
-0.038088735193014145,
-0.4633723497390747,
0.1723167896270752,
0.8320721983909607,
-0.6749687194824219,
0.6064454317092896,
0.13086633384227753,
0.5193405151367188,
0.30462783575057983,
0.06366843730211258,
0.8064630627632141,
-0.07073304802179337,
0.13271263241767883,
0.2295396775007248,
0.3545362055301666,
0.12086588889360428,
-0.29678985476493835,
0.5183204412460327,
0.012627780437469482,
-0.3007340431213379,
-0.8432634472846985,
-0.15767671167850494,
-1.0691635608673096,
-0.637458324432373,
1.383259892463684,
-0.21986360847949982,
-0.1094159260392189,
-0.07782455533742905,
-0.6896051168441772,
0.5637907385826111,
-0.3167274296283722,
1.0693315267562866,
0.7960689663887024,
0.08840485662221909,
-0.05543036386370659,
-0.6170557141304016,
0.48272112011909485,
0.37430718541145325,
-0.6817006468772888,
-0.06599589437246323,
0.45533907413482666,
0.4704989194869995,
-0.13330627977848053,
0.8410285115242004,
-0.0919833555817604,
0.3525528907775879,
-0.24232490360736847,
0.16777829825878143,
-0.1465885192155838,
-0.03279181569814682,
-0.3589971661567688,
-0.0067856209352612495,
0.4102906286716461,
-0.008140208199620247
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16038v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16038v2
|
Monotonic Paraphrasing Improves Generalization of Language Model Prompting
| 2024-03-24T06:49:07 | 2024-04-18T05:22:01 |
Qin Liu, Fei Wang, Nan Xu, Tianyi Yan, Tao Meng, Muhao Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Performance of large language models (LLMs) may vary with different prompts
or instructions of even the same task. One commonly recognized factor for this
phenomenon is the model's familiarity with the given prompt or instruction,
which is typically estimated by its perplexity. However, finding the prompt
with the lowest perplexity is challenging, given the enormous space of possible
prompting phrases. In this paper, we propose monotonic paraphrasing (MonoPara),
an end-to-end decoding strategy that paraphrases given prompts or instructions
into their lower perplexity counterparts based on an ensemble of a paraphrase
LM for prompt (or instruction) rewriting, and a target LM (i.e. the prompt or
instruction executor) that constrains the generation for lower perplexity. The
ensemble decoding process can efficiently paraphrase the original prompt
without altering its semantic meaning, while monotonically decreasing the
perplexity of each generation as calculated by the target LM. We explore in
detail both greedy and search-based decoding as two alternative decoding
schemes of MonoPara. Notably, MonoPara does not require any training and can
monotonically lower the perplexity of the paraphrased prompt or instruction,
leading to improved performance of zero-shot LM prompting as evaluated on a
wide selection of tasks. In addition, MonoPara is also shown to effectively
improve LMs' generalization on perturbed and unseen task instructions.
|
[
-0.3599519729614258,
-0.8013506531715393,
0.4404672384262085,
0.3874278664588928,
-0.6012877821922302,
-0.21751970052719116,
-0.4115404188632965,
0.21626845002174377,
0.12915335595607758,
0.5742274522781372,
-0.6467484831809998,
-0.6423540711402893,
-0.464890718460083,
0.4223195016384125,
-0.31381115317344666,
0.9917622208595276,
0.1292458027601242,
-0.21900245547294617,
-0.37792322039604187,
-0.22532768547534943,
-0.10296417027711868,
-0.5385808348655701,
-0.8811778426170349,
-0.2620978355407715,
0.7895949482917786,
0.6250553131103516,
0.6292548775672913,
0.6820459365844727,
0.0800614133477211,
0.30356788635253906,
-0.4206802546977997,
-0.13285762071609497,
-0.525955080986023,
0.3381786346435547,
-0.05374891683459282,
-0.435210645198822,
-0.13931582868099213,
-0.291749507188797,
0.7423319220542908,
0.8673851490020752,
-0.21785122156143188,
0.12890313565731049,
0.526156485080719,
0.5415858030319214,
-0.6875895857810974,
0.18326058983802795,
-0.5743069648742676,
0.15718545019626617,
-0.06586460769176483,
-0.6606120467185974,
-0.4790010154247284,
-0.14845380187034607,
0.40800705552101135,
-0.6429046988487244,
0.30844131112098694,
-0.2090984284877777,
0.4228399097919464,
0.25444236397743225,
0.11209524422883987,
-0.33584165573120117,
-0.20217587053775787,
0.9940683841705322,
-0.7660858035087585,
-0.019615402445197105,
0.16265788674354553,
0.039496079087257385,
0.058773502707481384,
-0.41452306509017944,
-0.3134755790233612,
-0.24729199707508087,
0.03066348470747471,
-0.03205055743455887,
-0.12324053049087524,
0.20896779000759125,
0.24138548970222473,
0.14388522505760193,
-0.5008690357208252,
-0.13525110483169556,
-0.28726038336753845,
-0.21192242205142975,
0.08222077041864395,
0.20491427183151245,
0.056278396397829056,
-0.3597176671028137,
-0.6009044051170349,
-0.21879662573337555,
-0.4975210428237915,
0.383223295211792,
0.2278057038784027,
0.4668406546115875,
0.013057147152721882,
0.1443631649017334,
-0.38986214995384216,
0.6078087687492371,
-0.027278101071715355,
-0.034954462200403214,
0.12802916765213013,
-0.5294409394264221,
-0.17357514798641205,
0.038097139447927475,
0.7312698364257812,
0.3206291198730469,
0.30403685569763184,
-0.136400043964386,
-0.03004683367908001,
-0.09964266419410706,
-0.15273161232471466,
-0.5268676280975342,
-0.08729570358991623,
-0.17080995440483093,
-0.4927101135253906,
-0.19219784438610077,
-0.15568847954273224,
-1.2714189291000366,
-0.19561491906642914,
-0.2807852625846863,
0.26134222745895386,
-0.6933503746986389,
0.22795692086219788,
0.3485338091850281,
-0.4224882423877716,
0.40161868929862976,
0.30367815494537354,
-0.9202728867530823,
0.3403201103210449,
0.5102640390396118,
1.0008411407470703,
0.09658853709697723,
-0.7294768691062927,
-0.6292726397514343,
0.13549047708511353,
-0.27329057455062866,
0.7477448582649231,
-0.7258980870246887,
-0.5476489663124084,
-0.1977853775024414,
-0.4149255156517029,
-0.16991744935512543,
-0.5332360863685608,
0.6347073316574097,
-0.14947602152824402,
0.03583841025829315,
-0.3476867973804474,
-0.3671799302101135,
-0.08382128179073334,
0.1488257646560669,
-0.43586331605911255,
0.4727529287338257,
-0.0985746681690216,
-0.5119494199752808,
0.2880059480667114,
-0.505437970161438,
-0.4387333393096924,
0.003304490353912115,
-0.2411843240261078,
-0.015448390506207943,
0.39469268918037415,
0.553347647190094,
0.19970612227916718,
-0.4136708974838257,
-0.1620803326368332,
-0.10010239481925964,
-0.3905757963657379,
-0.17277036607265472,
-0.7352723479270935,
0.5831525921821594,
0.345369428396225,
-0.1016683354973793,
0.11089009046554565,
-0.4700417220592499,
0.07876235991716385,
0.10240115970373154,
-0.3731512129306793,
-0.545886754989624,
-0.07305243611335754,
-0.6022560596466064,
-0.010686376132071018,
0.3752274513244629,
-0.20667582750320435,
0.13071879744529724,
-0.2624629735946655,
0.319455623626709,
0.8258090019226074,
0.2624000608921051,
0.5342918038368225,
-0.4946249723434448,
0.8076915144920349,
-0.0617481954395771,
0.14422568678855896,
-0.8217020630836487,
-0.44975969195365906,
-0.5611437559127808,
-0.30479201674461365,
0.017966529354453087,
0.5623558163642883,
-0.7404628396034241,
0.05730327591300011,
-0.26115864515304565,
-0.16504383087158203,
-0.7486754059791565,
0.4290742874145508,
0.6408981084823608,
0.8621329069137573,
0.6950658559799194,
0.21055647730827332,
-0.3394710123538971,
-0.7855108380317688,
-0.3088112771511078,
0.06881359219551086,
0.01204037107527256,
-0.07366325706243515,
-0.01817455142736435,
0.31671828031539917,
0.5862862467765808,
-0.19966396689414978,
0.10759422928094864,
-0.48169127106666565,
0.476413756608963,
0.44391345977783203,
0.37986478209495544,
0.22330841422080994,
-0.6091524958610535,
-0.5854710340499878,
-0.2736293077468872,
-0.7796343564987183,
-0.15412665903568268,
-0.24466708302497864,
0.045159172266721725,
-0.04403962194919586,
0.529958188533783,
-0.6892130374908447,
0.26574018597602844,
0.13386331498622894,
-0.10137004405260086,
0.6215476989746094,
-0.48886826634407043,
0.2487805038690567,
-0.9188345670700073,
0.010927893221378326,
-0.111042819917202,
-0.04110994189977646,
-0.5509631037712097,
0.339931845664978,
-0.06030918285250664,
-0.23466572165489197,
-0.35073259472846985,
0.4113099277019501,
-0.7171108722686768,
0.40873807668685913,
-0.2660708427429199,
-0.03959687054157257,
-0.06840592622756958,
0.5162927508354187,
0.07939737290143967,
0.8487319946289062,
0.9991284012794495,
-0.8772121071815491,
0.2688632607460022,
0.3500971496105194,
-0.26891952753067017,
0.3779200315475464,
-0.571969747543335,
0.21034911274909973,
-0.4700647294521332,
0.079703688621521,
-1.025588035583496,
0.04296480864286423,
0.0513729564845562,
-0.49739959836006165,
0.1614987701177597,
-0.2363423854112625,
-0.32719579339027405,
-0.11521156877279282,
-0.7217878699302673,
0.5336567759513855,
0.7199642658233643,
-0.4520438015460968,
0.009225699119269848,
-0.23030593991279602,
-0.5658340454101562,
-0.5991668105125427,
-0.6071130037307739,
0.3259836435317993,
-0.39650148153305054,
-0.5320203900337219,
-0.0026956747751682997,
-0.08470842987298965,
-0.07954295724630356,
-0.4431282579898834,
-0.277952641248703,
0.1335882991552353,
-0.11176304519176483,
-0.3896818459033966,
0.10761070996522903,
-0.3655201196670532,
0.020607158541679382,
0.27969303727149963,
-0.3494044840335846,
0.0387808233499527,
-0.33133554458618164,
0.7913059592247009,
0.07944777607917786,
-0.048001546412706375,
-0.43474632501602173,
0.556746244430542,
0.6364092230796814,
-0.19407528638839722,
0.6204961538314819,
0.046195872128009796,
-0.00916171632707119,
-0.2946453094482422,
-0.17005395889282227,
-0.31911396980285645,
-0.46046385169029236,
0.07183898985385895,
-0.5919723510742188,
-0.6070803999900818,
0.5013781189918518,
0.00500733545050025,
-0.013440090231597424,
-0.06087536737322807,
0.24348241090774536,
0.2215193808078766,
0.988406240940094,
0.23353177309036255,
-0.2267143577337265,
0.3240213692188263,
-0.12131847441196442,
-0.09382615983486176,
-0.6730243563652039,
-0.0025273023638874292,
-0.5305292010307312,
-0.4234919548034668,
-0.16254913806915283,
-0.45037588477134705,
0.5382226705551147,
0.2667895257472992,
0.20118305087089539,
0.33012962341308594,
-0.4209858179092407,
0.6714649796485901,
0.8717727661132812,
0.3618898093700409,
0.3429828882217407,
0.28763511776924133,
-0.3752577006816864,
0.13874077796936035,
-0.920475959777832,
-0.47783055901527405,
1.0702016353607178,
0.09262488782405853,
0.8733899593353271,
-0.15880422294139862,
1.1162383556365967,
0.013620106503367424,
-0.29656797647476196,
-0.5416170358657837,
0.9244613647460938,
-0.16802401840686798,
-0.18839558959007263,
-0.6761487722396851,
-0.6272304058074951,
-0.9657323956489563,
0.18217824399471283,
0.18689221143722534,
-0.768036425113678,
0.1959356963634491,
0.37076622247695923,
-0.7282114624977112,
0.10377829521894455,
-0.5202277898788452,
0.9533258080482483,
0.22278766334056854,
-0.23840495944023132,
-0.1377786546945572,
-0.7214071750640869,
0.007817452773451805,
0.11034291982650757,
0.09688283503055573,
0.16137224435806274,
-0.4402692914009094,
0.5334988832473755,
-0.5033283829689026,
0.5816066861152649,
-0.3247511088848114,
-0.11606646329164505,
0.332378089427948,
0.14175119996070862,
0.6923437118530273,
0.0650404840707779,
-0.45099571347236633,
-0.21150639653205872,
-0.04787837713956833,
-0.8216699361801147,
-0.6578343510627747,
0.7051454186439514,
-0.20345409214496613,
-0.821584939956665,
0.03604057803750038,
-0.7737447619438171,
-0.2612265646457672,
0.06655395030975342,
0.8495686650276184,
0.5649693012237549,
0.17306798696517944,
0.33166706562042236,
0.9986996054649353,
-0.18947362899780273,
0.4722623825073242,
0.08614817261695862,
0.005336419679224491,
-0.3377712070941925,
0.85150545835495,
-0.036986615508794785,
0.4227055311203003,
0.6034279465675354,
0.44103461503982544,
-0.29759180545806885,
-0.7655946016311646,
-0.34712958335876465,
0.10853485018014908,
-0.824772834777832,
-0.015211464837193489,
-0.5491613745689392,
0.22430622577667236,
-0.6572215557098389,
-0.2959222197532654,
0.059046849608421326,
-0.2058386355638504,
-0.1384737193584442,
-0.07503736764192581,
0.1714802384376526,
0.07392638176679611,
0.08580699563026428,
0.25288593769073486,
-0.8318665623664856,
0.17965272068977356,
0.43778106570243835,
-0.09309809654951096,
0.06336137652397156,
-0.8609088659286499,
0.06255104392766953,
0.08391978591680527,
0.05236199498176575,
-0.9337888360023499,
0.1962888538837433,
0.2158578485250473,
0.5319414734840393,
0.4374903440475464,
0.27784866094589233,
0.9221044778823853,
-0.43739384412765503,
0.5822853446006775,
0.24152401089668274,
-1.1258752346038818,
0.39728662371635437,
-0.49319201707839966,
0.8449762463569641,
0.8732207417488098,
0.2825346291065216,
-0.4660198986530304,
-0.5926428437232971,
-0.2804000973701477,
-0.8333476781845093,
0.6197717189788818,
0.0302120391279459,
0.6141224503517151,
-0.2709302306175232,
0.27879253029823303,
0.3094007670879364,
0.3333929181098938,
-0.6074367761611938,
-0.21314312517642975,
-0.018699603155255318,
-0.24444763362407684,
-0.13028495013713837,
-0.1950717270374298,
-0.02195233851671219,
-0.32969027757644653,
0.35635480284690857,
-0.14218489825725555,
0.2292291522026062,
0.3744153380393982,
-0.12433422356843948,
-0.1770438402891159,
0.5262614488601685,
0.6898495554924011,
0.5614122152328491,
0.05107930302619934,
0.3361121416091919,
0.4620771110057831,
0.13380593061447144,
0.16353446245193481,
-0.0047951024025678635,
-0.2741467356681824,
0.24494415521621704,
0.5756731629371643,
0.8698971271514893,
0.4880804717540741,
-0.7203487157821655,
0.28514328598976135,
0.2960954010486603,
-0.23875072598457336,
0.14686699211597443,
0.03018186427652836,
-0.005567262414842844,
0.22161760926246643,
0.49154919385910034,
-0.2005171775817871,
0.2504575848579407,
-0.5224697589874268,
0.26278769969940186,
0.3458850085735321,
0.08769407868385315,
-0.11840534955263138,
0.4460213780403137,
-0.07790590822696686,
-0.20442084968090057,
0.43313997983932495,
-0.25613459944725037,
-0.2945289611816406,
0.5113035440444946,
0.6668784618377686,
0.7874583601951599,
-0.4674258232116699,
0.34693044424057007,
0.26675665378570557,
0.19663438200950623,
-0.1368030458688736,
0.32237687706947327,
-0.500312089920044,
-0.3385978043079376,
-0.2948800325393677,
-0.6351293921470642,
-0.41611453890800476,
0.16475698351860046,
-0.7075417041778564,
0.4043441116809845,
-0.6147484183311462,
0.30499085783958435,
-0.12752781808376312,
-0.6752446889877319,
-0.08769601583480835,
-0.03765850141644478,
0.25591084361076355,
1.1537644863128662,
-0.2897551357746124,
0.6247222423553467,
0.8409153819084167,
-0.43662935495376587,
-0.6627033948898315,
0.28457510471343994,
-0.053201884031295776,
-0.8459558486938477,
0.14303550124168396,
0.2236621379852295,
-0.1648872196674347,
0.26898375153541565,
-0.5811640024185181,
-0.5023527145385742,
0.9162819981575012,
0.5936052203178406,
-0.557313084602356,
-0.6054515242576599,
0.09059814363718033,
0.4785369336605072,
-0.2393539994955063,
-0.011909455060958862,
0.35280606150627136,
0.4155164062976837,
0.2247946858406067,
-0.7271981835365295,
0.2218037098646164,
-0.09129247814416885,
0.004429154563695192,
0.3615165650844574,
-0.41683703660964966,
1.1489830017089844,
-0.20856618881225586,
-0.169338196516037,
0.4730952978134155,
0.44523143768310547,
0.21849244832992554,
0.4155206084251404,
0.414501428604126,
0.578154444694519,
0.5216359496116638,
0.4006718397140503,
1.0311164855957031,
-0.49046453833580017,
0.3262249231338501,
1.1015675067901611,
0.0208198893815279,
0.6283183097839355,
0.7669156789779663,
-0.018553005531430244,
0.25906136631965637,
0.27028554677963257,
0.3698482811450958,
0.6195518374443054,
0.23758414387702942,
-0.6085387468338013,
-0.4732995927333832,
0.18701030313968658,
-0.21098370850086212,
0.08710286766290665,
0.2225932627916336,
-0.45283740758895874,
-0.9441696405410767,
0.4265308678150177,
0.21168062090873718,
0.2673003673553467,
-0.5031041502952576,
0.8989594578742981,
0.17277726531028748,
-0.9727706909179688,
1.2800830602645874,
-0.2880111038684845,
0.7291839718818665,
-0.7940948009490967,
0.041724834591150284,
-0.4974030554294586,
0.002422240562736988,
-0.017704203724861145,
-0.517172634601593,
0.09784606844186783,
0.06956084817647934,
-0.2434869408607483,
-0.36574992537498474,
0.44822317361831665,
-0.6554961800575256,
-0.20928016304969788,
0.44445663690567017,
0.43268972635269165,
0.215132936835289,
-0.35211166739463806,
-0.8343632221221924,
-0.18899202346801758,
0.05374661833047867,
-0.30690282583236694,
0.38966262340545654,
0.6145316362380981,
0.17657555639743805,
0.717077374458313,
0.5255494117736816,
0.030869364738464355,
0.322171688079834,
-0.14493328332901,
0.8227483630180359,
-0.685868501663208,
-0.5104336142539978,
-1.1650660037994385,
0.22150561213493347,
0.007936875335872173,
-0.46266359090805054,
0.8478161692619324,
0.3069230318069458,
0.6194939613342285,
-0.23512616753578186,
0.7108843326568604,
0.22689728438854218,
0.47435107827186584,
-0.620406448841095,
0.2509663999080658,
-0.44066447019577026,
0.3859221935272217,
-0.2671322524547577,
-0.8538222312927246,
-0.04693008214235306,
0.4959362745285034,
-0.24771146476268768,
-0.14604772627353668,
0.6802546977996826,
0.9096580743789673,
-0.09641730785369873,
0.018725920468568802,
0.6552397608757019,
-0.07665853947401047,
-0.2524920105934143,
0.6397480964660645,
0.667129397392273,
0.004704941995441914,
0.9362583160400391,
-0.21631190180778503,
-0.4693203270435333,
0.07500603049993515,
-0.594890832901001,
-0.7419470548629761,
-0.27447381615638733,
-0.11657360941171646,
-0.07258515805006027,
0.24593046307563782,
1.0207523107528687,
0.3432196378707886,
-0.7092372179031372,
-0.490456223487854,
-0.6079881191253662,
0.1779707968235016,
-0.4511881172657013,
-0.2097548246383667,
-0.07643570750951767,
-1.145322561264038,
-0.8163769841194153,
0.7108429074287415,
0.36167898774147034,
-0.18649640679359436,
0.043898239731788635,
-0.2542535662651062,
-0.3674602508544922,
0.4207349121570587,
0.37977346777915955,
0.47475188970565796,
-0.4489291310310364,
-0.061934035271406174,
0.10615723580121994,
0.03357149288058281,
0.11572593450546265,
0.735301673412323,
-0.6171463131904602,
0.4307241439819336,
0.6999137997627258,
0.5246821641921997,
0.10823909938335419,
0.16799911856651306,
0.6060759425163269,
-0.8415451049804688,
0.16815482079982758,
0.2274019718170166,
0.30092906951904297,
0.09242437779903412,
-0.0746527761220932,
0.09242468327283859,
0.32796740531921387,
-0.3467431962490082,
-0.7227287888526917,
0.2490810751914978,
-0.7223333716392517,
-0.5489779710769653,
1.0911281108856201,
-0.4606976807117462,
-0.3221750259399414,
-0.02744315192103386,
-0.33302339911460876,
0.1320929378271103,
-0.5689936280250549,
0.6527072787284851,
0.893713653087616,
-0.03802269697189331,
-0.4874948263168335,
-0.18408901989459991,
0.3517753481864929,
1.1090848445892334,
-0.5712693333625793,
0.2680838406085968,
0.22184832394123077,
0.19625647366046906,
0.21538177132606506,
0.4726387560367584,
-0.02007392980158329,
0.6084672808647156,
0.032766830176115036,
-0.23822113871574402,
-0.11925089359283447,
-0.3375430405139923,
-0.7190259099006653,
0.3526778519153595,
0.006351717747747898,
-0.4213126599788666
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.