id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18336v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18336v1
|
A Dataset for Pharmacovigilance in German, French, and Japanese: Annotating Adverse Drug Reactions across Languages
| 2024-03-27T08:21:01 | 2024-03-27T08:21:01 |
Lisa Raithel, Hui-Syuan Yeh, Shuntaro Yada, Cyril Grouin, Thomas Lavergne, Aurélie Névéol, Patrick Paroubek, Philippe Thomas, Tomohiro Nishiyama, Sebastian Möller, Eiji Aramaki, Yuji Matsumoto, Roland Roller, Pierre Zweigenbaum
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
User-generated data sources have gained significance in uncovering Adverse
Drug Reactions (ADRs), with an increasing number of discussions occurring in
the digital world. However, the existing clinical corpora predominantly revolve
around scientific articles in English. This work presents a multilingual corpus
of texts concerning ADRs gathered from diverse sources, including patient fora,
social media, and clinical reports in German, French, and Japanese. Our corpus
contains annotations covering 12 entity types, four attribute types, and 13
relation types. It contributes to the development of real-world multilingual
language models for healthcare. We provide statistics to highlight certain
challenges associated with the corpus and conduct preliminary experiments
resulting in strong baselines for extracting entities and relations between
these entities, both within and across languages.
|
[
-0.01734253764152527,
-0.5336805582046509,
0.684355616569519,
0.2498195469379425,
0.0449981689453125,
-0.12270330637693405,
-0.16243720054626465,
-0.797666609287262,
0.49341094493865967,
0.5957422256469727,
-0.3444456160068512,
-0.6774459481239319,
-0.7772620916366577,
0.521012008190155,
-0.07375124096870422,
1.2125524282455444,
-0.35291787981987,
0.5092470049858093,
0.21495835483074188,
-0.49491098523139954,
-0.14071300625801086,
-0.9902800917625427,
-0.6398799419403076,
-0.18025001883506775,
1.1924203634262085,
0.1946624517440796,
0.43597412109375,
-0.012979887425899506,
1.039831280708313,
0.22465179860591888,
0.4573003947734833,
0.011980007402598858,
-0.0908963531255722,
0.34865644574165344,
-0.2940438687801361,
-0.27384310960769653,
-0.5010318160057068,
-0.4114329218864441,
0.3873021602630615,
0.509440541267395,
-0.05316520482301712,
-0.0669432282447815,
-0.4633600115776062,
0.5192252993583679,
-0.7991724610328674,
0.28394198417663574,
-0.21046403050422668,
0.05671405419707298,
-0.16159456968307495,
-0.04880129545927048,
-0.30314671993255615,
-0.32075265049934387,
0.37291520833969116,
-0.7824207544326782,
0.0226727407425642,
-0.10618697106838226,
0.7394651770591736,
-0.048283398151397705,
-0.7892658710479736,
-0.675766110420227,
-0.5175865292549133,
0.4177396297454834,
-0.3179674744606018,
0.6126722097396851,
0.29091641306877136,
0.28697991371154785,
-0.09023097157478333,
-0.8588919639587402,
-0.4835575520992279,
0.04365941882133484,
-0.3908698260784149,
0.03060094080865383,
-0.1495829075574875,
-0.1682337373495102,
0.06466664373874664,
0.28685030341148376,
-0.5539951920509338,
-0.028248494490981102,
-0.5525733232498169,
-0.43916305899620056,
0.5056822896003723,
0.2751776874065399,
0.5567729473114014,
-0.1097588762640953,
-0.19352151453495026,
-0.1186421811580658,
-0.7458012104034424,
-0.3560717701911926,
0.1560850441455841,
0.4437462389469147,
-0.4789023995399475,
0.6014470458030701,
0.3097221255302429,
0.46040743589401245,
-0.4562704861164093,
-0.1958095282316208,
0.5721422433853149,
-0.5507099628448486,
0.04738694056868553,
0.24583816528320312,
1.191918969154358,
0.7009984254837036,
0.4508640468120575,
-0.052065134048461914,
-0.011121487244963646,
0.27810046076774597,
0.19606637954711914,
-0.8995947241783142,
-0.7258524298667908,
0.4296312928199768,
-0.11870801448822021,
-0.13313724100589752,
-0.018012462183833122,
-1.0361775159835815,
-0.5022556781768799,
0.01736031286418438,
0.1249808520078659,
-0.5263108611106873,
-0.28937211632728577,
0.1765681356191635,
-0.09324128180742264,
-0.006524443160742521,
-0.13537919521331787,
-0.6829043030738831,
0.2805820107460022,
0.2711913287639618,
0.6021271347999573,
-0.24215495586395264,
-0.3325265049934387,
-0.30063894391059875,
0.1811058670282364,
-0.39217236638069153,
1.0379315614700317,
-0.1910918951034546,
-0.5395022034645081,
0.4645683467388153,
0.4934924840927124,
-0.19708703458309174,
-0.4092012345790863,
0.7103826999664307,
-0.33626610040664673,
0.2837922275066376,
-0.22994376718997955,
-0.2461998462677002,
-0.1747886687517166,
-0.17781737446784973,
-0.6941592693328857,
0.47247692942619324,
-0.04206978157162666,
-0.8650543093681335,
0.46778351068496704,
-0.6986826658248901,
-0.9830890893936157,
0.08623983711004257,
-0.12154712527990341,
-0.6070813536643982,
0.09765835851430893,
0.17494040727615356,
0.2523837685585022,
-0.052210770547389984,
0.35821399092674255,
-0.31533315777778625,
0.12459442764520645,
0.5302214622497559,
0.06151816248893738,
0.7264403700828552,
0.2735224962234497,
0.12245810776948929,
0.06209609657526016,
-1.1076183319091797,
-0.4652160108089447,
0.1621011346578598,
-0.37772056460380554,
-0.6979455947875977,
0.03965827077627182,
0.7705445289611816,
0.4584326148033142,
-0.015062695369124413,
-0.5053408741950989,
-0.18194420635700226,
-0.41032445430755615,
0.22035670280456543,
0.2420348972082138,
0.7797115445137024,
0.01095819752663374,
0.06481703370809555,
0.16701318323612213,
0.29050034284591675,
0.14079023897647858,
-0.3396908640861511,
-0.41510409116744995,
-0.5439550876617432,
-0.2795047163963318,
0.029549825936555862,
0.8009939193725586,
-0.6956726908683777,
0.4287089705467224,
-0.2843221426010132,
-0.10086537152528763,
-0.6857739686965942,
-0.01860405132174492,
0.578521192073822,
0.6563662886619568,
0.4240521490573883,
-0.17603345215320587,
-0.566853940486908,
-0.9549527168273926,
-0.26738813519477844,
-0.3339954614639282,
-0.05208202078938484,
0.16496802866458893,
0.5118146538734436,
-0.6189908981323242,
0.12088236212730408,
-0.6297106146812439,
-0.39336827397346497,
-0.07228370010852814,
-0.06415942311286926,
-0.22639067471027374,
0.24383936822414398,
0.7288066744804382,
-0.6978147029876709,
-0.44994932413101196,
0.24088706076145172,
-0.9422987699508667,
-0.25905779004096985,
-0.06735393404960632,
-0.15600861608982086,
0.22542612254619598,
0.41920116543769836,
-0.2756352424621582,
0.09095834195613861,
0.5515440106391907,
-0.12263486534357071,
0.05268637835979462,
-0.05490799620747566,
0.30208271741867065,
-1.4191864728927612,
0.24688708782196045,
0.6055443286895752,
0.08646015077829361,
-0.9400344491004944,
-0.1633915901184082,
0.11324316263198853,
-0.10735934972763062,
-0.7184802293777466,
0.7526204586029053,
-0.2967558801174164,
0.46070095896720886,
0.17473752796649933,
-0.07905810326337814,
0.21985271573066711,
0.05489176884293556,
0.4086149036884308,
0.4698196351528168,
0.6052749752998352,
-0.5737033486366272,
0.3447239100933075,
0.47050046920776367,
-0.23075634241104126,
0.7169885635375977,
-0.45400601625442505,
-0.33539777994155884,
-0.24217407405376434,
0.01613379642367363,
-0.7343026995658875,
-0.7441540360450745,
0.46935468912124634,
-0.22704587876796722,
0.2954333424568176,
-0.18999366462230682,
-0.48852425813674927,
-0.4244987368583679,
-0.06329437345266342,
0.00429875310510397,
0.01757862977683544,
-0.15430855751037598,
0.2598235607147217,
0.9934380650520325,
-0.590022623538971,
-0.3544601500034332,
-0.8658973574638367,
0.21844972670078278,
-0.34154242277145386,
-0.20981521904468536,
-0.1828860491514206,
-0.0028410684317350388,
-0.5244535803794861,
-0.09265507757663727,
0.30669036507606506,
-0.2733801305294037,
-0.16407810151576996,
0.15048108994960785,
0.5134874582290649,
-0.1909990757703781,
0.40312469005584717,
-0.12104041874408722,
-0.04142620414495468,
0.2492847889661789,
0.15591473877429962,
0.12316084653139114,
-0.016596907749772072,
-0.13828787207603455,
-0.18597175180912018,
0.7174745202064514,
0.6199259757995605,
-0.06134204566478729,
0.6691941618919373,
0.4420509934425354,
-0.603438138961792,
0.326630562543869,
-0.21935637295246124,
-0.3348374664783478,
-0.32823681831359863,
0.4641917943954468,
-0.4241599142551422,
-0.43863987922668457,
0.8057746887207031,
0.273307204246521,
0.05159938707947731,
0.34780725836753845,
0.9786865711212158,
0.05288198962807655,
0.7371299862861633,
0.467622846364975,
-0.028992770239710808,
0.1821831911802292,
0.23340146243572235,
0.41789624094963074,
-0.39336276054382324,
-0.28592073917388916,
-0.2854628264904022,
0.22281165421009064,
-0.856046736240387,
-0.1126609817147255,
0.799555242061615,
-0.48316290974617004,
-0.3224090337753296,
0.3441475033760071,
-0.32042619585990906,
0.17641237378120422,
-0.016031047329306602,
-0.11490103602409363,
0.3187604546546936,
0.26019495725631714,
-0.014907418750226498,
-0.31627321243286133,
-0.5748725533485413,
-0.3611573278903961,
1.0363229513168335,
0.3896632790565491,
0.698571503162384,
0.3357296288013458,
0.2820182144641876,
-0.13583087921142578,
0.4466227889060974,
-0.6428930759429932,
0.01929311454296112,
-0.36701467633247375,
-0.7474660873413086,
0.3110820949077606,
-0.38653695583343506,
-0.9621579647064209,
0.18874098360538483,
-0.2997048795223236,
-0.6762554049491882,
0.3418465554714203,
-0.1944013386964798,
-0.49396607279777527,
-0.21246789395809174,
-1.0340576171875,
0.9375099539756775,
-0.26219111680984497,
-0.2165795862674713,
0.26525649428367615,
-0.9551601409912109,
0.27233946323394775,
-0.4249120354652405,
0.5194892287254333,
-0.14723244309425354,
-0.03621616214513779,
0.6046453714370728,
-0.40066760778427124,
0.8101488351821899,
0.27132469415664673,
-0.29991257190704346,
0.2278200387954712,
-0.02529437467455864,
0.06270807236433029,
0.18246732652187347,
0.26892244815826416,
0.19325794279575348,
0.05793803185224533,
-0.2545601725578308,
0.011307843029499054,
1.0113316774368286,
-0.6475592851638794,
0.07620849460363388,
-0.5748699903488159,
-0.4112280309200287,
-0.300284206867218,
0.4703567922115326,
0.3707997500896454,
0.48520949482917786,
-0.396094411611557,
-0.43165862560272217,
0.46110600233078003,
-0.4670720100402832,
0.16420456767082214,
1.1704518795013428,
-0.16469508409500122,
-0.5075622200965881,
0.7716079950332642,
0.15407584607601166,
-0.024816207587718964,
0.32182732224464417,
-0.03457288444042206,
-0.407538503408432,
-0.0781315416097641,
-0.4845973253250122,
0.39359524846076965,
-0.8542725443840027,
-0.09411558508872986,
-0.9989980459213257,
-0.016272034496068954,
-0.6453762650489807,
0.016386037692427635,
-0.1915867179632187,
-0.3454205095767975,
0.026090122759342194,
-0.4390468895435333,
0.6631704568862915,
0.8687086701393127,
0.04174797609448433,
0.11533296853303909,
-0.9624577760696411,
0.34966906905174255,
-0.055012937635183334,
0.4631677269935608,
-0.442129909992218,
0.06711574643850327,
-0.25359976291656494,
-0.3130681812763214,
-0.0892336294054985,
-1.1891217231750488,
0.3842915892601013,
0.23455391824245453,
0.44218918681144714,
0.22010892629623413,
-0.018478943035006523,
0.4185199737548828,
-0.6140744686126709,
0.5760896801948547,
0.17120498418807983,
-0.2680864930152893,
0.6474299430847168,
-0.6029472947120667,
-0.033104997128248215,
0.7062838673591614,
0.9033203721046448,
-0.9021234512329102,
-0.41198796033859253,
-0.33670955896377563,
-1.1784147024154663,
0.3974897563457489,
-0.10922763496637344,
0.009446609765291214,
-0.48689669370651245,
0.03717261180281639,
0.05599819868803024,
-0.08104704320430756,
-0.6209345459938049,
-0.5748515725135803,
0.0766819640994072,
-0.40759697556495667,
-0.441222220659256,
0.0005989655037410557,
-0.46569526195526123,
0.19557569921016693,
0.8249618411064148,
-0.03997764363884926,
-0.13282644748687744,
0.391497939825058,
-0.21090157330036163,
-0.2802777886390686,
0.4075528681278229,
0.5042595267295837,
0.5915796160697937,
-0.2447948157787323,
0.41213932633399963,
-0.24209678173065186,
-0.9016661047935486,
0.1973511129617691,
0.6442866325378418,
0.057431552559137344,
0.02439154125750065,
0.4502609968185425,
0.5146107077598572,
0.24755944311618805,
-0.8926435708999634,
0.2450363039970398,
-0.19274817407131195,
0.23877865076065063,
-0.3599811792373657,
-0.5225041508674622,
-0.035295240581035614,
-0.07155196368694305,
0.22765666246414185,
-0.08438371866941452,
0.3751753270626068,
-0.5336032509803772,
0.6937998533248901,
-0.18761061131954193,
-0.541668713092804,
-0.4389115869998932,
0.49091556668281555,
0.2823021709918976,
0.05659044161438942,
0.1806481033563614,
0.11788780242204666,
-0.309221088886261,
0.22781577706336975,
0.32889029383659363,
0.5977333188056946,
-0.3999519646167755,
0.1717732548713684,
0.5372613668441772,
0.04061755910515785,
0.1752031296491623,
0.28399619460105896,
0.8753136396408081,
-0.668354868888855,
-0.24529826641082764,
-0.4738234579563141,
-0.30195802450180054,
0.20116008818149567,
-0.5747413635253906,
0.44673630595207214,
-0.20236773788928986,
-0.3422299027442932,
0.6802334189414978,
-0.2825108766555786,
-0.3739508092403412,
0.001253500347957015,
0.1559358686208725,
0.4666452705860138,
-1.2156437635421753,
0.7325159311294556,
1.2011682987213135,
-0.6370067596435547,
-0.39327216148376465,
-0.006085295230150223,
0.290921688079834,
-0.6651819944381714,
0.4782005846500397,
-0.14088749885559082,
0.22766219079494476,
-0.5303671360015869,
0.059668730944395065,
-0.46915438771247864,
0.2645517885684967,
-0.04921870678663254,
-0.5352988243103027,
0.1140781119465828,
0.30541303753852844,
0.9037061929702759,
-0.43239182233810425,
0.018964974209666252,
0.6958569288253784,
0.3084873855113983,
-0.38548752665519714,
-0.748928964138031,
-0.12150377780199051,
-0.5562090873718262,
-0.29365992546081543,
0.2586885392665863,
-0.359868586063385,
0.8274629712104797,
-0.20102353394031525,
-0.15522365272045135,
-0.4544246792793274,
0.08183547109365463,
0.11655299365520477,
0.20858882367610931,
-0.09635112434625626,
0.40154197812080383,
0.35609108209609985,
-0.06307099014520645,
1.262840747833252,
-0.5620208978652954,
0.12676924467086792,
0.9720368981361389,
-0.6016358733177185,
0.7780304551124573,
0.49939197301864624,
-0.14969931542873383,
0.7035983204841614,
0.6468012928962708,
0.1301734298467636,
0.7050155997276306,
-0.06508296728134155,
-0.5230885744094849,
0.16716116666793823,
-0.28769156336784363,
-0.28767862915992737,
0.02780255116522312,
0.9465303421020508,
-0.27246251702308655,
-0.2860758304595947,
0.3881164789199829,
0.320069819688797,
0.19960010051727295,
-0.11883221566677094,
1.073131799697876,
0.3080948293209076,
-0.7191183567047119,
0.4612814784049988,
-0.14945489168167114,
0.15940378606319427,
-0.5381644368171692,
0.1020536869764328,
-0.08898016065359116,
0.6153631210327148,
-0.3225117325782776,
-0.8590705394744873,
0.381591260433197,
0.1280357390642166,
-0.24662348628044128,
0.5102456212043762,
0.5684676766395569,
-0.6771352291107178,
-0.8122565746307373,
0.6153319478034973,
0.45084935426712036,
0.10937043279409409,
0.339435875415802,
-0.7082453370094299,
0.09149755537509918,
-0.1605108678340912,
-0.2199290543794632,
0.4290667772293091,
0.5470151305198669,
-0.45668429136276245,
0.33341777324676514,
0.45077887177467346,
0.33407336473464966,
0.11273621022701263,
0.4810120165348053,
0.6958598494529724,
-0.17102153599262238,
-0.352496862411499,
-0.5292701721191406,
0.5227201581001282,
-0.053878892213106155,
-0.2681795358657837,
0.6984250545501709,
0.7029733061790466,
0.47581392526626587,
-0.30415594577789307,
1.133785367012024,
0.06900656968355179,
0.7066125869750977,
-0.21252204477787018,
0.5888863801956177,
-0.28260812163352966,
0.02032257802784443,
-0.144825279712677,
-0.577416718006134,
-0.8269743323326111,
0.4970581829547882,
-0.3726450502872467,
-0.2378186285495758,
0.6688244938850403,
0.5182209014892578,
0.12626704573631287,
-0.2762293219566345,
0.0036049315240234137,
0.32912275195121765,
0.3061303198337555,
0.8557353019714355,
0.3564111590385437,
-0.86363285779953,
0.22789713740348816,
-0.41013818979263306,
0.10244753211736679,
-0.12609289586544037,
-0.5834540724754333,
-0.9218891859054565,
-0.6060944199562073,
-0.4192081689834595,
-0.6507107615470886,
0.29197975993156433,
0.9824347496032715,
0.11884336173534393,
-1.4033135175704956,
0.15921327471733093,
0.22983179986476898,
-0.03565284237265587,
0.14388462901115417,
-0.2343818098306656,
0.42016592621803284,
-0.23365262150764465,
-0.5698549151420593,
0.16351082921028137,
0.4227651357650757,
0.3867608606815338,
-0.11666121333837509,
-0.01285513211041689,
-0.2417113333940506,
-0.026311349123716354,
0.5771247744560242,
0.49341481924057007,
-0.3781096935272217,
-0.06441338360309601,
-0.007501440122723579,
-0.5160752534866333,
0.03638071194291115,
0.8632234930992126,
-0.15440765023231506,
0.6534919738769531,
0.36399033665657043,
0.10585799068212509,
0.28301897644996643,
-0.26799577474594116,
0.6899029016494751,
-0.7935567498207092,
0.4130302369594574,
0.24012364447116852,
0.5646895170211792,
0.7149343490600586,
-0.32051345705986023,
0.5637784600257874,
0.16237874329090118,
-0.3424640893936157,
-0.6513165235519409,
0.1868155151605606,
-0.6047298908233643,
-0.3068319261074066,
1.0565818548202515,
-0.36844876408576965,
-0.18667906522750854,
-0.40470343828201294,
-0.1477605253458023,
0.022008219733834267,
-0.42295923829078674,
0.5909388661384583,
0.7241803407669067,
-0.11952606588602066,
-0.09561265259981155,
-0.9920738935470581,
0.8346654772758484,
-0.09074380248785019,
-0.8063316345214844,
0.40896010398864746,
0.6763370037078857,
0.2717663645744324,
0.4223299026489258,
0.9600626230239868,
-0.5451393127441406,
0.26848217844963074,
-0.040980350226163864,
0.3188270628452301,
0.46622154116630554,
-0.3533473014831543,
-0.22853203117847443,
-0.12886112928390503,
-0.12328261882066727,
0.1805139034986496
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18327v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18327v1
|
Can LLMs Converse Formally? Automatically Assessing LLMs in Translating and Interpreting Formal Specifications
| 2024-03-27T08:08:00 | 2024-03-27T08:08:00 |
Rushang Karia, Daksh Dobhal, Daniel Bramblett, Pulkit Verma, Siddharth Srivastava
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Stakeholders often describe system requirements using natural language which
are then converted to formal syntax by a domain-expert leading to increased
design costs. This paper assesses the capabilities of Large Language Models
(LLMs) in converting between natural language descriptions and formal
specifications. Existing work has evaluated the capabilities of LLMs in
generating formal syntax such as source code but such experiments are typically
hand-crafted and use problems that are likely to be in the training set of
LLMs, and often require human-annotated datasets. We propose an approach that
can use two copies of an LLM in conjunction with an off-the-shelf verifier to
automatically evaluate its translation abilities without any additional human
input. Our approach generates formal syntax using language grammars to
automatically generate a dataset. We conduct an empirical evaluation to measure
the accuracy of this translation task and show that SOTA LLMs cannot adequately
solve this task, limiting their current utility in the design of complex
systems.
|
[
-0.29291191697120667,
-0.6210578083992004,
0.8022594451904297,
0.4027823507785797,
-0.16338306665420532,
0.12093720585107803,
-0.4471573233604431,
-0.9647212624549866,
-0.30163419246673584,
0.6814880967140198,
-0.44356098771095276,
-0.2900427281856537,
-0.42693933844566345,
0.40943068265914917,
-0.5357668995857239,
0.6267569065093994,
-0.5818917155265808,
0.10514611005783081,
-0.2931206524372101,
0.3379065990447998,
-0.26731643080711365,
-0.5175924301147461,
-0.2277373969554901,
-0.24019278585910797,
-0.1600928008556366,
0.3647073805332184,
0.612094521522522,
0.3034338653087616,
0.7323882579803467,
0.39996370673179626,
0.22058604657649994,
0.6403466463088989,
-0.3362399935722351,
-0.0015342660481110215,
-0.0352570042014122,
-0.344035267829895,
-0.5263543725013733,
-0.051512543112039566,
0.7719939947128296,
0.7278838753700256,
0.15109530091285706,
0.46800342202186584,
0.2577458620071411,
0.35628408193588257,
-0.4117773473262787,
0.5349041819572449,
-0.5983513593673706,
0.06590917706489563,
-0.0167201217263937,
-0.2627483010292053,
-0.6162141561508179,
-0.5282837152481079,
0.10585548728704453,
-0.5268858671188354,
-0.22607900202274323,
0.14369215071201324,
1.1669687032699585,
0.3130335211753845,
-0.18057429790496826,
-0.40675827860832214,
-1.090714693069458,
0.700770914554596,
-0.8792345523834229,
0.3403036892414093,
0.3584614396095276,
0.5053243041038513,
-0.39250293374061584,
-0.7138568758964539,
-0.6250749826431274,
-0.7622401118278503,
-0.3162184953689575,
-0.16825464367866516,
-0.1721707582473755,
0.07985047250986099,
0.29974624514579773,
0.32479968667030334,
-0.2593635320663452,
0.024254994466900826,
-0.44519856572151184,
-0.1908784955739975,
0.9855048060417175,
0.1640831083059311,
0.33265846967697144,
-0.2664979100227356,
-0.39605268836021423,
0.3401870131492615,
-0.49192431569099426,
-0.30969294905662537,
0.23287071287631989,
0.3314625918865204,
0.0018591892439872026,
0.6781928539276123,
-0.2746221423149109,
0.6322433948516846,
-0.10357736051082611,
-0.10662177205085754,
0.04034822806715965,
-0.7854793071746826,
-0.49037283658981323,
-0.1673138588666916,
0.9387133121490479,
0.3342650532722473,
0.49082571268081665,
-0.299615740776062,
-0.6044117212295532,
0.013723676092922688,
0.3094314932823181,
-0.5468765497207642,
0.09029613435268402,
0.08979031443595886,
-0.05781824141740799,
-0.13761770725250244,
-0.011899425648152828,
-0.5401037931442261,
-0.07570236176252365,
-0.7458208799362183,
0.34210801124572754,
-0.0637054517865181,
0.0452752485871315,
0.3653714656829834,
0.26166853308677673,
0.3723776638507843,
0.2253979593515396,
-0.6326280236244202,
0.5787841081619263,
0.5676772594451904,
0.6471105813980103,
0.14709992706775665,
-0.132719948887825,
-0.29690980911254883,
0.1898191273212433,
-0.6753501892089844,
0.6681720614433289,
-0.23281823098659515,
-0.38699620962142944,
0.15719273686408997,
-0.07785847038030624,
0.06541579961776733,
-0.48626774549484253,
0.5461689829826355,
-0.4948146343231201,
0.006091039627790451,
0.04960133880376816,
-0.32738739252090454,
0.37578490376472473,
0.2797793745994568,
-0.44517606496810913,
1.0298439264297485,
0.07131300121545792,
-0.3915333151817322,
0.3386015295982361,
-0.49277836084365845,
-0.48473483324050903,
0.33554062247276306,
-0.442769855260849,
-0.1685720980167389,
-0.015431654639542103,
-0.011769695207476616,
0.5900541543960571,
-0.5524476170539856,
0.6927823424339294,
-0.2031175196170807,
-0.10886994749307632,
0.43096724152565,
-0.11321412026882172,
0.34952566027641296,
0.2778904438018799,
-0.42538368701934814,
0.14612457156181335,
-0.8637878894805908,
0.0471954271197319,
0.006445797625929117,
-0.46546706557273865,
-0.1195477843284607,
0.09078299254179001,
-0.035093147307634354,
0.31832846999168396,
0.49897050857543945,
-0.2586742341518402,
0.31062912940979004,
-0.4182552397251129,
0.5312373042106628,
0.5537391901016235,
-0.20856554806232452,
0.5766772627830505,
-0.10498267412185669,
0.4734153151512146,
-0.7450281977653503,
0.09077044576406479,
0.23355956375598907,
-0.26097312569618225,
-0.9468913078308105,
-0.3415547013282776,
0.19862160086631775,
0.49913865327835083,
-0.5792547464370728,
0.7296010255813599,
-0.5413252115249634,
-0.3791389763355255,
-0.43754473328590393,
0.34937283396720886,
0.5182018876075745,
0.19126449525356293,
0.25528499484062195,
-0.07897105813026428,
-0.7855250835418701,
-1.0179381370544434,
-0.07824179530143738,
-0.2921462059020996,
-0.3081198036670685,
0.39675623178482056,
0.5240619778633118,
-0.3031477630138397,
0.9435797929763794,
-0.24642665684223175,
-0.22306835651397705,
-0.3515858054161072,
0.236163929104805,
-0.148412823677063,
0.23569896817207336,
0.19822385907173157,
-0.34457722306251526,
-0.2934221029281616,
0.27901995182037354,
-0.9030581116676331,
-0.47639015316963196,
-0.3548339605331421,
-0.19720113277435303,
0.37053656578063965,
0.7309631109237671,
-0.4919067621231079,
0.32115256786346436,
0.47973355650901794,
-0.19048002362251282,
0.7278982400894165,
-0.3478315472602844,
0.1968184858560562,
-0.7892279624938965,
0.2578628361225128,
-0.024767931550741196,
-0.43724143505096436,
-0.5338927507400513,
0.38137954473495483,
-0.022652702406048775,
0.006688338704407215,
-0.2873423993587494,
0.5432488918304443,
-0.5779362320899963,
-0.3208325505256653,
0.018309829756617546,
0.27506935596466064,
0.05514393001794815,
0.17398691177368164,
0.0402831993997097,
0.5577287673950195,
0.3034988045692444,
-0.786452054977417,
0.5131173133850098,
0.38400229811668396,
-0.6665124297142029,
0.6290737390518188,
-0.6177030205726624,
0.118172787129879,
0.12778109312057495,
0.30284491181373596,
-1.057213544845581,
-0.44646862149238586,
0.29051414132118225,
-0.11692862957715988,
0.36626505851745605,
-0.21269787847995758,
-0.8320435285568237,
-0.22127968072891235,
0.0601782388985157,
0.012743490748107433,
0.3976489007472992,
-0.2402449995279312,
0.5843924283981323,
0.2434360831975937,
-0.28975966572761536,
-0.11672725528478622,
-0.9877992868423462,
0.6288954615592957,
0.16449899971485138,
-0.926155686378479,
0.2146049439907074,
0.06982036679983139,
-0.48554158210754395,
-0.09710080921649933,
-0.0850217193365097,
-0.09410156309604645,
0.2780393660068512,
0.23061195015907288,
0.5600139498710632,
-0.2750611901283264,
0.1364583820104599,
-0.02377915009856224,
-0.14290349185466766,
0.3452599346637726,
-0.41525211930274963,
0.2734755873680115,
-0.2083626389503479,
-0.5339562892913818,
-0.6649330854415894,
0.1464986801147461,
0.7936593294143677,
-0.29414796829223633,
0.4277236759662628,
0.16745050251483917,
-0.34683841466903687,
-0.35581865906715393,
-0.5912361145019531,
0.02209005504846573,
-0.45025691390037537,
0.3353446424007416,
-0.5845773816108704,
-0.5261011123657227,
0.2979001998901367,
-0.2003963738679886,
0.33835846185684204,
0.4444967210292816,
0.4574357271194458,
0.003978013526648283,
0.8603367209434509,
0.4109727740287781,
0.12994922697544098,
0.0839228555560112,
-0.09551504254341125,
0.22355952858924866,
-0.34947457909584045,
-0.35381442308425903,
-0.6638677716255188,
-0.3055967688560486,
-0.33900272846221924,
-0.34085845947265625,
0.2054632604122162,
-0.07890377938747406,
-0.0649842843413353,
0.3393648862838745,
-0.2684252858161926,
0.3554660677909851,
0.12569276988506317,
-0.08766595274209976,
0.5158178806304932,
0.06351535767316818,
-0.027152862399816513,
0.051075585186481476,
-0.23728801310062408,
-1.2117886543273926,
0.7211769223213196,
0.4761293828487396,
0.7014661431312561,
0.08566927164793015,
0.4691661298274994,
0.19491679966449738,
0.31625670194625854,
-0.9320675730705261,
0.8482145667076111,
-0.01854647323489189,
-0.39482349157333374,
-0.43636488914489746,
-0.4254196584224701,
-0.6311695575714111,
-0.13845592737197876,
-0.2309226095676422,
-0.42274209856987,
0.020902374759316444,
0.026148872449994087,
-0.29773733019828796,
0.0969732403755188,
-0.4993418753147125,
0.7006128430366516,
-0.4455122649669647,
-0.2206488996744156,
-0.0532723143696785,
-0.49589186906814575,
0.5199899673461914,
-0.4355165362358093,
0.5744824409484863,
-0.18049000203609467,
-0.16583073139190674,
0.6622815132141113,
-0.418779194355011,
0.9775150418281555,
0.08262569457292557,
-0.5931568741798401,
0.17391952872276306,
0.3597952723503113,
0.5538218021392822,
-0.08757335692644119,
-0.3127608001232147,
0.06074226647615433,
0.16115081310272217,
-0.3226979672908783,
-0.6895182728767395,
0.43293890357017517,
-0.7329453229904175,
-0.48291143774986267,
-0.22382664680480957,
-0.30211102962493896,
-0.327691912651062,
0.13412591814994812,
-0.006330688949674368,
0.14693298935890198,
-0.3982803523540497,
-0.18244174122810364,
0.2791372239589691,
0.17251278460025787,
0.05655273422598839,
0.5161936283111572,
-0.4034203886985779,
-0.16652695834636688,
0.5734621286392212,
0.14477390050888062,
0.6625693440437317,
0.1529327780008316,
0.19646066427230835,
-0.34829816222190857,
-0.6738402843475342,
-0.6253632307052612,
0.14295560121536255,
-0.8046676516532898,
0.09699129313230515,
-0.31837475299835205,
-0.33083000779151917,
-0.3066232204437256,
-0.2002415955066681,
-0.23178578913211823,
-0.34603479504585266,
-0.33669233322143555,
-0.11572866141796112,
0.11414700001478195,
1.0926592350006104,
0.1725347936153412,
0.024873385205864906,
-0.886990487575531,
0.2781585156917572,
0.42293211817741394,
0.33868587017059326,
-0.4847467839717865,
-0.8470720648765564,
-0.019181571900844574,
-0.03998558223247528,
0.01361923012882471,
-0.6662173271179199,
0.38652199506759644,
0.15729321539402008,
0.5139236450195312,
0.14984244108200073,
0.12194748967885971,
0.800870954990387,
-0.703778862953186,
0.6274935007095337,
-0.08249689638614655,
-1.1735557317733765,
0.44996270537376404,
0.049241017550230026,
-0.0669201985001564,
0.6360841393470764,
0.4374205470085144,
-0.39452433586120605,
-0.5610688328742981,
-0.37052977085113525,
-0.6367273926734924,
0.5921690464019775,
0.12132866680622101,
0.3185836374759674,
0.1736486405134201,
0.4558430314064026,
-0.1462189257144928,
0.04073118045926094,
-0.39955228567123413,
0.003961944952607155,
0.27800753712654114,
-0.20074491202831268,
-0.06488640606403351,
-0.38557589054107666,
-0.2017039954662323,
-0.044444236904382706,
0.508744478225708,
-0.04457347095012665,
-0.08996524661779404,
0.13346457481384277,
-0.1436290442943573,
-0.1385832577943802,
0.5269085168838501,
0.554441511631012,
0.7927817106246948,
-0.0538400374352932,
0.32272157073020935,
0.39810675382614136,
-0.05835888534784317,
0.23062346875667572,
0.005672927014529705,
-0.2288389950990677,
0.154082253575325,
0.3885200321674347,
0.5399690270423889,
0.6040882468223572,
-0.6263371706008911,
0.389182448387146,
-0.06892411410808563,
-0.4997369945049286,
-0.2678382992744446,
-0.15293236076831818,
0.1124231293797493,
0.15785987675189972,
0.12900565564632416,
-0.013610276393592358,
0.033896010369062424,
-0.5256431698799133,
0.2904326319694519,
0.3960096836090088,
-0.3041893541812897,
-0.3421001136302948,
0.2580885589122772,
0.4383993446826935,
-0.4356488883495331,
0.3353186547756195,
-0.35249242186546326,
-0.270234078168869,
0.27351129055023193,
0.41931962966918945,
0.8180449604988098,
-0.21338233351707458,
-0.0082839485257864,
0.2099764347076416,
0.5526107549667358,
-0.3258163332939148,
0.3284698724746704,
-0.04159420356154442,
-0.4737216532230377,
-0.7713398933410645,
-0.6951582431793213,
-0.5786215662956238,
0.04790559411048889,
-0.525080680847168,
0.5725064277648926,
-0.622675359249115,
-0.10707486420869827,
0.03524821251630783,
-0.10416676849126816,
-0.5772366523742676,
-0.09228499233722687,
0.3109724521636963,
0.7643826603889465,
-0.9276966452598572,
0.46946895122528076,
0.618354856967926,
-0.42350462079048157,
-0.6953040361404419,
-0.25710222125053406,
-0.3242242634296417,
-0.7655876278877258,
0.9150170087814331,
-0.172201007604599,
-0.4118777811527252,
-0.10159488767385483,
-0.717640221118927,
-0.6175107955932617,
0.7497243285179138,
0.7400264143943787,
-0.7782622575759888,
-0.1684691607952118,
0.4631365239620209,
0.547884464263916,
-0.15621578693389893,
0.13064250349998474,
0.8366224765777588,
0.7458805441856384,
0.14770060777664185,
-1.4695467948913574,
0.2116978019475937,
-0.0898560956120491,
-0.21906155347824097,
0.056623876094818115,
-0.1667017638683319,
0.3835449516773224,
-0.0058932797983288765,
-0.6711277365684509,
0.1009795144200325,
0.5873358845710754,
0.11639580875635147,
0.09114306420087814,
0.3875499665737152,
0.007040968630462885,
0.9121071696281433,
0.13224077224731445,
0.9422710537910461,
-0.4716278612613678,
0.17651404440402985,
1.092894196510315,
-0.5283823609352112,
1.0501470565795898,
0.4041343927383423,
-0.4057110846042633,
0.4838297665119171,
0.377012699842453,
-0.010478890500962734,
-0.10931558907032013,
0.6631189584732056,
-0.2554171085357666,
-0.5772066712379456,
-0.08804430812597275,
-0.17264753580093384,
0.4112417995929718,
0.3773193955421448,
-0.27507874369621277,
-0.08640013635158539,
-0.37767523527145386,
-0.058627188205718994,
0.32796528935432434,
-0.0389380119740963,
0.8558057546615601,
0.2796599566936493,
-0.5750938653945923,
0.7961776852607727,
0.09863808006048203,
0.4240238666534424,
-0.5945400595664978,
0.050479594618082047,
0.016667531803250313,
0.0920061394572258,
-0.4957877993583679,
-0.7274263501167297,
0.5387277603149414,
0.21679368615150452,
0.21752646565437317,
-0.38518422842025757,
0.502821683883667,
-0.30406245589256287,
-0.84185391664505,
0.2174822837114334,
0.44336238503456116,
0.48095986247062683,
0.15144167840480804,
-0.5060153007507324,
0.07031060010194778,
-0.23636700212955475,
0.004438488744199276,
0.13246381282806396,
0.5723947286605835,
-0.121047742664814,
0.7634652256965637,
0.555584728717804,
0.28063806891441345,
0.07490982860326767,
0.07400228828191757,
0.7812819480895996,
-0.35727107524871826,
-0.355474591255188,
-0.9458491802215576,
0.3127097189426422,
0.13700932264328003,
0.03573479503393173,
0.6722363233566284,
0.3998163044452667,
0.7539134621620178,
-0.03913503140211105,
1.0885647535324097,
0.20247608423233032,
-0.015099707059562206,
-0.7010312676429749,
0.5725343823432922,
-0.3388715088367462,
0.46721553802490234,
-0.03996332362294197,
-0.6638752818107605,
-0.4091787338256836,
0.6069981455802917,
-0.581662654876709,
-0.2232692837715149,
0.6070199012756348,
0.7416346669197083,
-0.1377144157886505,
-0.11371190845966339,
0.3969637155532837,
0.21992166340351105,
0.4341048002243042,
0.5158613920211792,
1.12260103225708,
-0.11971957236528397,
0.7904862761497498,
0.1899985671043396,
-0.35922062397003174,
-0.31774774193763733,
-1.0406968593597412,
-0.7858283519744873,
-0.33667296171188354,
-0.45331647992134094,
-0.3663097023963928,
-0.07253643870353699,
1.0024975538253784,
0.6549001932144165,
-0.772233784198761,
-0.4850708246231079,
-0.012833804823458195,
-0.14147228002548218,
0.18613293766975403,
-0.11074793338775635,
0.08315681666135788,
-0.6906888484954834,
-0.7426524758338928,
0.5926514863967896,
0.26877856254577637,
0.11421044915914536,
-0.8637188076972961,
-0.2079319804906845,
0.06998200714588165,
0.2741037607192993,
0.5748522281646729,
0.15039797127246857,
-0.8644995093345642,
-0.28973597288131714,
0.007912220433354378,
-0.5334790945053101,
-0.1119178831577301,
0.6199263334274292,
-0.5224300622940063,
0.35601305961608887,
0.5703919529914856,
0.7307298183441162,
0.3101363480091095,
-0.1844375729560852,
0.780318558216095,
-0.6758467555046082,
-0.36905694007873535,
0.06178651750087738,
0.41150933504104614,
0.20573052763938904,
-0.1587284356355667,
0.2766650319099426,
0.04357263445854187,
-0.5289226174354553,
-0.8748095035552979,
0.32801178097724915,
-0.7862358093261719,
-0.050252851098775864,
1.4576175212860107,
-0.24317561089992523,
-0.2427147477865219,
-0.5418331623077393,
-0.3549267649650574,
0.11500056833028793,
-0.10463028401136398,
0.5792790055274963,
0.6148926615715027,
0.20972636342048645,
0.30120590329170227,
-0.751015841960907,
0.5076362490653992,
0.10938813537359238,
-0.9975183606147766,
0.3076726496219635,
0.41581931710243225,
0.16372963786125183,
0.3912164866924286,
0.5120221972465515,
-0.008616464212536812,
0.07542861253023148,
-0.1781814992427826,
0.40721696615219116,
-0.05491425096988678,
-0.16947253048419952,
-0.267219215631485,
-0.019850291311740875,
0.44966691732406616,
-0.09992911666631699
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18314v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18314v3
|
Chinese Offensive Language Detection:Current Status and Future Directions
| 2024-03-27T07:34:44 | 2024-03-29T18:48:35 |
Yunze Xiao, Houda Bouamor, Wajdi Zaghouani
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Despite the considerable efforts being made to monitor and regulate
user-generated content on social media platforms, the pervasiveness of
offensive language, such as hate speech or cyberbullying, in the digital space
remains a significant challenge. Given the importance of maintaining a
civilized and respectful online environment, there is an urgent and growing
need for automatic systems capable of detecting offensive speech in real time.
However, developing effective systems for processing languages such as Chinese
presents a significant challenge, owing to the language's complex and nuanced
nature, which makes it difficult to process automatically. This paper provides
a comprehensive overview of offensive language detection in Chinese, examining
current benchmarks and approaches and highlighting specific models and tools
for addressing the unique challenges of detecting offensive language in this
complex language. The primary objective of this survey is to explore the
existing techniques and identify potential avenues for further research that
can address the cultural and linguistic complexities of Chinese.
|
[
-0.18949435651302338,
-1.2162251472473145,
-0.047402799129486084,
0.4680350422859192,
-0.22109287977218628,
0.30934903025627136,
-0.29725420475006104,
-0.9814472198486328,
-0.06943680346012115,
0.23162706196308136,
-0.23160208761692047,
-0.4187423288822174,
-0.6466106176376343,
0.07070504128932953,
-0.6593336462974548,
0.6412616968154907,
0.13314670324325562,
-0.03226215019822121,
0.723642885684967,
-0.18677079677581787,
-0.28973060846328735,
-0.6154540181159973,
-0.9854689240455627,
-0.10539119690656662,
0.3539454936981201,
0.1524757295846939,
0.5819051861763,
0.510294497013092,
0.6965031623840332,
0.39399418234825134,
-0.20110063254833221,
0.22618772089481354,
-0.08286189287900925,
0.2866085171699524,
-0.06708291918039322,
-0.22190363705158234,
-0.39715445041656494,
-0.33539268374443054,
0.5250282287597656,
0.14092375338077545,
0.05340681970119476,
-0.07851087301969528,
-0.22564665973186493,
0.24511338770389557,
-0.8798749446868896,
-0.158219575881958,
-0.5666447281837463,
0.28408244252204895,
-0.7205976247787476,
0.09946047514677048,
-0.14981581270694733,
-0.28979143500328064,
0.013401046395301819,
-0.30780383944511414,
-0.07141334563493729,
-0.3084045350551605,
0.5320128798484802,
-0.14133311808109283,
-0.3397389352321625,
-0.5853359699249268,
-0.6572903990745544,
0.5976099967956543,
-1.0373460054397583,
0.31152084469795227,
0.3473823666572571,
0.45464667677879333,
0.18612736463546753,
-0.8359958529472351,
-0.7307688593864441,
-0.3761744499206543,
0.10020118951797485,
0.0029636321123689413,
-0.4769822061061859,
0.01746808923780918,
0.0018177647143602371,
0.300420343875885,
-0.4735288918018341,
0.5947242975234985,
0.09485629200935364,
-0.3541262745857239,
0.9050946235656738,
0.22052820026874542,
1.0754777193069458,
-0.1633731573820114,
-0.13389739394187927,
0.26650622487068176,
-0.29196998476982117,
0.05564260855317116,
0.5150119662284851,
0.43063291907310486,
-0.047620274126529694,
-0.06550852209329605,
-0.4018963873386383,
0.6682165861129761,
-0.10519535094499588,
0.053691815584897995,
0.18110348284244537,
-0.37317323684692383,
-0.06407848745584488,
0.15913133323192596,
0.9341573715209961,
0.32457074522972107,
0.2698323428630829,
0.17059297859668732,
-0.569876492023468,
0.294940710067749,
0.12946321070194244,
-0.4381043016910553,
-0.32332471013069153,
0.38208523392677307,
-0.25110477209091187,
-0.4950096309185028,
-0.12170100212097168,
-0.542549192905426,
-0.8027089238166809,
0.1326196938753128,
-0.09369931370019913,
-0.3415125012397766,
-0.8304896354675293,
-0.13859370350837708,
-0.2593228816986084,
0.4552931785583496,
0.28478139638900757,
-0.7790409326553345,
0.07161270827054977,
0.5776787400245667,
0.7374952435493469,
-0.38240283727645874,
-0.05278151482343674,
-0.4425206780433655,
0.04588328301906586,
-0.35018104314804077,
0.6793970465660095,
-0.5979033708572388,
0.04858717322349548,
0.4353606104850769,
0.17068348824977875,
0.3574157953262329,
-0.8299077153205872,
0.852664589881897,
-0.468519926071167,
0.02821355313062668,
-0.22443270683288574,
0.1066112220287323,
-0.1294528841972351,
0.569579541683197,
-0.36585670709609985,
0.9306536316871643,
-0.07734868675470352,
-0.8777482509613037,
0.09503509104251862,
-0.7365067601203918,
-0.8910412788391113,
0.48653414845466614,
0.13856548070907593,
-0.586727499961853,
-0.29137855768203735,
0.11785773187875748,
0.37691640853881836,
-0.0992387905716896,
0.23698951303958893,
-0.3219650089740753,
-0.44527360796928406,
0.10574819892644882,
-0.5291074514389038,
1.1192094087600708,
0.6834703087806702,
-0.7547343969345093,
0.30612581968307495,
-0.3305771052837372,
-0.19192703068256378,
0.7464626431465149,
-0.2918258011341095,
-0.40650931000709534,
0.30455198884010315,
0.49015751481056213,
0.1300617754459381,
0.40900537371635437,
-0.7287936806678772,
-0.3446207046508789,
-0.20508265495300293,
0.5131555795669556,
0.6306467652320862,
-0.3230951130390167,
-0.03766900673508644,
0.03909439221024513,
0.5671592950820923,
0.2591570019721985,
0.30408579111099243,
-0.13208620250225067,
-0.3568600118160248,
-0.4958806037902832,
0.25867292284965515,
-0.12442111223936081,
1.1109790802001953,
-0.7985190749168396,
0.28857293725013733,
0.11916690319776535,
-0.5894638299942017,
-0.3652898967266083,
0.026459775865077972,
0.6266236305236816,
0.05675371736288071,
0.19027715921401978,
-0.22049424052238464,
-0.5428302884101868,
-0.626747190952301,
-0.5411307215690613,
-0.400547593832016,
0.08935445547103882,
0.1714494824409485,
0.006918005179613829,
0.04296090826392174,
0.3109080493450165,
-0.2629444897174835,
-0.27018478512763977,
-0.48514002561569214,
0.28474292159080505,
-0.2009303867816925,
0.27194005250930786,
0.8006026744842529,
-1.2243330478668213,
-0.9522779583930969,
0.4357859194278717,
-0.8809069991111755,
-0.6300028562545776,
0.28102606534957886,
0.4339369833469391,
0.0770634338259697,
0.5897002816200256,
0.11304707825183868,
0.15141785144805908,
0.5789563059806824,
-0.15578806400299072,
0.7077003121376038,
0.3637677729129791,
0.4453262686729431,
-0.5189337134361267,
-0.20211981236934662,
0.3077761232852936,
-0.1733063906431198,
-1.3000110387802124,
0.4590320289134979,
-0.005774234887212515,
0.11385354399681091,
-0.8196163773536682,
0.40444815158843994,
-0.37323933839797974,
0.23126351833343506,
-0.4312911033630371,
0.43507400155067444,
-0.55495685338974,
0.24795342981815338,
0.20837467908859253,
0.3863844871520996,
0.30890992283821106,
-0.5934928059577942,
0.8542847037315369,
-0.21741735935211182,
-0.21367128193378448,
0.5491006970405579,
-0.40124595165252686,
-0.12361959367990494,
-0.07488644868135452,
0.013940691947937012,
-1.1607776880264282,
-0.09354712814092636,
0.7739431262016296,
-0.6277438402175903,
0.17380519211292267,
-0.019041340798139572,
-0.3584931790828705,
-0.41184747219085693,
-0.33797234296798706,
0.5287990570068359,
0.18331940472126007,
-0.32099634408950806,
0.23842941224575043,
0.7834664583206177,
-0.23839114606380463,
-0.9773826003074646,
-0.7838955521583557,
0.3517382740974426,
-0.3154173493385315,
-0.5172151327133179,
0.2004721313714981,
0.07300341874361038,
-0.6119570732116699,
-0.2883010506629944,
0.23499146103858948,
-0.38282787799835205,
0.46188947558403015,
-0.2426459938287735,
-0.057608526200056076,
-0.37571388483047485,
-0.2785666584968567,
-0.15655189752578735,
0.3781020939350128,
0.18176589906215668,
-0.027768565341830254,
0.49786141514778137,
-0.14653803408145905,
-0.27202340960502625,
-0.6457388401031494,
0.1409238576889038,
0.5939677357673645,
-0.41461876034736633,
0.14412473142147064,
1.031618356704712,
-0.6532530188560486,
-0.19237570464611053,
-0.3692222237586975,
0.023683927953243256,
-0.5118359923362732,
0.6508499383926392,
-0.018159259110689163,
-0.6713646054267883,
0.44606685638427734,
0.15915296971797943,
0.30281588435173035,
0.22239995002746582,
0.671911895275116,
0.23686735332012177,
1.1047393083572388,
0.20300640165805817,
-0.34274017810821533,
0.8332247734069824,
0.42098140716552734,
0.4766874611377716,
-0.4675739109516144,
0.1027228832244873,
-0.4646123945713043,
-0.08004961907863617,
-0.7246625423431396,
0.04107265919446945,
0.010348578914999962,
-0.38715043663978577,
-0.1309550255537033,
0.47422632575035095,
-0.6448731422424316,
0.30602481961250305,
0.05346684902906418,
-0.021800626069307327,
0.19995254278182983,
-0.30631378293037415,
0.11218928545713425,
0.07275751978158951,
-0.37387382984161377,
-0.3402242660522461,
0.3195188641548157,
0.4966168701648712,
0.314897745847702,
0.3795568346977234,
-0.09719312191009521,
0.6922664642333984,
0.2762798070907593,
-0.6474701166152954,
0.4621674418449402,
-0.541473388671875,
-0.8707535266876221,
-0.5035383105278015,
-0.13919025659561157,
-0.7789574265480042,
0.44239410758018494,
-0.14408278465270996,
-0.731149435043335,
0.028918400406837463,
0.12381152808666229,
-0.22904224693775177,
0.7834991216659546,
-0.5543209314346313,
0.8245986104011536,
-0.501089334487915,
-0.5324214696884155,
0.0623321570456028,
-0.49806228280067444,
0.8017754554748535,
-0.15196819603443146,
0.47508537769317627,
-0.24111346900463104,
0.07683474570512772,
0.48402339220046997,
0.04265156015753746,
0.941655158996582,
-0.3258720636367798,
-0.5460488796234131,
0.4450436234474182,
0.01503246370702982,
0.3165503144264221,
-0.4754156172275543,
-0.037258196622133255,
0.2148713618516922,
-0.16486716270446777,
-0.31105926632881165,
-0.0627298429608345,
0.3174034655094147,
-0.24309571087360382,
-0.5085656046867371,
-0.38366198539733887,
-0.32422691583633423,
0.25897911190986633,
0.4595862030982971,
0.29516980051994324,
0.05859101936221123,
-0.38205403089523315,
-0.0909728929400444,
0.5717605948448181,
-0.7655412554740906,
0.523545503616333,
0.602111279964447,
-0.36268237233161926,
0.09013517946004868,
1.1085795164108276,
0.216620534658432,
0.07677926123142242,
0.36593320965766907,
0.07185328006744385,
-0.10265570133924484,
-0.8722704648971558,
-0.36475175619125366,
-0.09861331433057785,
-0.48818734288215637,
0.19054438173770905,
-0.7388753294944763,
-0.45914390683174133,
-0.6280431747436523,
0.020613621920347214,
-0.3360859155654907,
0.030426910147070885,
-0.08036097884178162,
0.19508850574493408,
-0.10838229954242706,
0.7568122148513794,
-0.12175250798463821,
0.5059328079223633,
-0.6595227122306824,
0.4930529296398163,
0.1750253587961197,
0.3080003261566162,
0.19862380623817444,
-0.7387632727622986,
-0.1968623846769333,
0.1373373121023178,
-0.3812655806541443,
-0.7450345158576965,
0.4955127537250519,
-0.1072358712553978,
0.6024794578552246,
0.7895854115486145,
0.4328659772872925,
0.44509851932525635,
-0.23601408302783966,
0.841982901096344,
-0.04285477474331856,
-0.6472305655479431,
0.67465740442276,
-0.48334646224975586,
0.1985427439212799,
-0.12850233912467957,
0.3925648331642151,
-1.0767613649368286,
-0.5400199294090271,
-0.20427440106868744,
-0.6757568717002869,
0.7797272205352783,
0.1272674947977066,
0.3523905873298645,
-0.09326406568288803,
-0.29056084156036377,
-0.3612198531627655,
-0.06770473718643188,
-0.86822509765625,
-0.39912083745002747,
-0.19691267609596252,
0.11451850086450577,
0.3055979311466217,
-0.11190799623727798,
0.27334052324295044,
-0.00935924518853426,
0.4460768699645996,
0.18582645058631897,
0.14055298268795013,
-0.22541001439094543,
-0.1702733039855957,
-0.1327880471944809,
0.20471784472465515,
0.5419068336486816,
0.34879133105278015,
-0.04344974458217621,
-0.07593793421983719,
0.35422664880752563,
-0.5555664300918579,
-0.004689909052103758,
-0.15702949464321136,
-0.16916371881961823,
0.07972396165132523,
0.27894333004951477,
0.4489153325557709,
-0.07416687160730362,
-0.9459702372550964,
0.8355028629302979,
-0.029676545411348343,
-0.014691163785755634,
-0.6965406537055969,
0.15804435312747955,
-0.02100917138159275,
0.10613136738538742,
0.3169291019439697,
-0.32140442728996277,
0.376234769821167,
-0.5906777381896973,
0.2608962059020996,
0.5112369656562805,
-0.6836414337158203,
-0.3345373868942261,
0.6961714029312134,
0.30091702938079834,
-0.5384520888328552,
0.4607711434364319,
-0.2344270944595337,
-1.0760239362716675,
0.652352511882782,
0.6949129104614258,
0.8984845280647278,
-0.6847034692764282,
0.09396448731422424,
0.2993270456790924,
0.4595055878162384,
0.2491576075553894,
0.15699753165245056,
0.02166711911559105,
-1.1380561590194702,
0.07934501767158508,
-0.3070060908794403,
-0.338043749332428,
0.32106807827949524,
-0.3463265895843506,
0.381120502948761,
-0.9123430848121643,
-0.18850594758987427,
0.17288751900196075,
-0.18224991858005524,
-0.03924168646335602,
0.32590028643608093,
0.9517068862915039,
0.710211992263794,
-0.8381607532501221,
0.6522951722145081,
0.7373457551002502,
-0.3251166343688965,
-0.12768563628196716,
-0.08104801923036575,
0.51999831199646,
-0.8720747828483582,
0.5421584248542786,
0.12996233999729156,
-0.29168421030044556,
-0.1848340481519699,
-0.657477855682373,
-0.09427597373723984,
0.48483383655548096,
-0.04638081043958664,
-0.18973354995250702,
0.07115881145000458,
0.13970324397087097,
0.7431815266609192,
-0.009902614168822765,
0.1552312821149826,
0.8312233686447144,
0.5592977404594421,
-0.17180725932121277,
-0.8653780221939087,
-0.006323437672108412,
-0.5174899697303772,
-0.26621395349502563,
0.26798033714294434,
-0.9083494544029236,
0.9721453785896301,
0.2855360507965088,
-0.6525889039039612,
-0.25150245428085327,
0.591804563999176,
0.10178940743207932,
0.5743060111999512,
0.5107074975967407,
0.1128103956580162,
0.33259764313697815,
-0.23408746719360352,
0.5624369978904724,
0.0011832237942144275,
-0.18539173901081085,
0.6419853568077087,
-0.18890435993671417,
0.5947206616401672,
-0.1880970597267151,
-0.34067201614379883,
0.5000591278076172,
0.7145819664001465,
-0.18060140311717987,
-0.11701895296573639,
0.2969992160797119,
-0.42598462104797363,
-0.20151080191135406,
-0.7159463763237,
-0.30816423892974854,
0.6262217164039612,
0.858601987361908,
-0.24621883034706116,
-0.1773287057876587,
-0.1381950080394745,
0.2633616626262665,
0.41114139556884766,
-0.44383516907691956,
0.6767318248748779,
-0.12659597396850586,
-0.32016393542289734,
0.5143178105354309,
0.3461357653141022,
1.336475133895874,
-0.7058579325675964,
0.021825479343533516,
-0.0307129118591547,
-0.020340310409665108,
-0.34503063559532166,
-0.870271623134613,
0.24152737855911255,
0.2623605728149414,
0.4067032039165497,
-0.0142006054520607,
0.8746050596237183,
-0.32500481605529785,
0.0751282349228859,
0.6008347868919373,
0.02128567174077034,
0.22833582758903503,
-0.15743914246559143,
-0.9477525949478149,
0.14392966032028198,
0.10729032754898071,
-0.021030647680163383,
0.14586730301380157,
0.5050569772720337,
-0.31308162212371826,
0.8173299431800842,
0.6467409133911133,
0.25738874077796936,
0.2671343982219696,
-0.05675866827368736,
0.5176935195922852,
-0.6412680745124817,
-0.4793223440647125,
-0.8212293386459351,
0.22832810878753662,
-0.1636386513710022,
-0.27291029691696167,
0.6996512413024902,
0.1896476149559021,
1.1206773519515991,
0.204750657081604,
1.1655738353729248,
-0.2970375418663025,
0.3810842037200928,
0.021871335804462433,
0.8135804533958435,
-0.6120225191116333,
0.1763131320476532,
-0.7387740015983582,
-0.5740400552749634,
-0.6107618808746338,
0.3216366767883301,
-0.14959336817264557,
-0.12491659075021744,
0.22762352228164673,
0.6039426922798157,
0.09378926455974579,
0.11310204863548279,
0.4965984523296356,
0.15102647244930267,
0.5177966952323914,
0.41735538840293884,
0.9638541340827942,
-0.4280799329280853,
0.681239664554596,
-0.25977444648742676,
-0.23415309190750122,
-0.34061720967292786,
-0.6667760014533997,
-0.6140663027763367,
-0.36319154500961304,
-0.23500721156597137,
-0.06354564428329468,
0.22745679318904877,
0.6910639405250549,
0.31771859526634216,
-1.3448848724365234,
-0.42412227392196655,
0.3561825156211853,
0.2234155535697937,
-0.29617661237716675,
-0.24116241931915283,
0.11212297528982162,
-0.29915693402290344,
-1.15458345413208,
0.09942499548196793,
0.34312570095062256,
0.013016635552048683,
-0.1304842084646225,
0.12086454778909683,
-0.6563645005226135,
-0.12250888347625732,
0.977443516254425,
0.6882866024971008,
-0.7923957705497742,
-0.30690449476242065,
-0.02029811032116413,
-0.24735890328884125,
-0.11799975484609604,
0.5655801296234131,
-0.1251315027475357,
0.6087265610694885,
0.760011613368988,
0.969692051410675,
-0.14565390348434448,
0.10257487744092941,
0.44759759306907654,
-0.3586771488189697,
0.015652047470211983,
0.2227933257818222,
0.10824677348136902,
0.43775883316993713,
-0.43686559796333313,
0.3988284170627594,
0.509539783000946,
-0.4177827537059784,
-0.8098011016845703,
0.31283849477767944,
-0.49337252974510193,
-0.6678363680839539,
0.859678328037262,
-0.25860124826431274,
0.04395155981183052,
-0.8187827467918396,
-0.21342627704143524,
0.6643078923225403,
-0.244040384888649,
0.631005585193634,
0.7537925839424133,
0.03569759428501129,
-0.22463470697402954,
-0.4681767523288727,
0.4950103461742401,
0.3238203525543213,
-0.5341508388519287,
0.4894341230392456,
0.39400020241737366,
-0.08141817152500153,
0.128835991024971,
0.5161610245704651,
-0.20802529156208038,
0.39344578981399536,
-0.09467864781618118,
-0.09264346212148666,
0.3182855248451233,
0.03505440428853035,
-0.17335882782936096,
0.16606593132019043,
-0.08704773336648941,
-0.20658595860004425
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18295v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18295v1
|
Dual Instruction Tuning with Large Language Models for Mathematical Reasoning
| 2024-03-27T06:43:58 | 2024-03-27T06:43:58 |
Yongwei Zhou, Tiejun Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent advancements highlight the success of instruction tuning with large
language models (LLMs) utilizing Chain-of-Thought (CoT) data for mathematical
reasoning tasks. Despite the fine-tuned LLMs, challenges persist, such as
incorrect, missing, and redundant steps in CoT generation leading to
inaccuracies in answer predictions. To alleviate this problem, we propose a
dual instruction tuning strategy to meticulously model mathematical reasoning
from both forward and reverse directions. This involves introducing the
Intermediate Reasoning State Prediction task (forward reasoning) and the
Instruction Reconstruction task (reverse reasoning) to enhance the LLMs'
understanding and execution of instructions. Training instances for these tasks
are constructed based on existing mathematical instruction tuning datasets.
Subsequently, LLMs undergo multi-task fine-tuning using both existing
mathematical instructions and the newly created data. Comprehensive experiments
validate the effectiveness and domain generalization of the dual instruction
tuning strategy across various mathematical reasoning tasks.
|
[
-0.20756584405899048,
-0.9819422364234924,
0.5874390602111816,
0.04127880930900574,
-0.4208637475967407,
0.09954078495502472,
-0.5210200548171997,
-0.1715812236070633,
-0.12056868523359299,
0.8734195828437805,
-0.9677579998970032,
-0.5705466866493225,
-0.5559180378913879,
-0.07567672431468964,
-0.005386523902416229,
0.8097662925720215,
-0.2373073399066925,
0.3233294188976288,
-0.33735910058021545,
0.12033770233392715,
-0.8809238076210022,
-0.4892292618751526,
-0.8154297471046448,
-0.40671226382255554,
0.38532596826553345,
0.6522392630577087,
0.7560960650444031,
0.5861589908599854,
0.17376215755939484,
0.2426096796989441,
0.282800555229187,
0.7449166178703308,
-0.5730187296867371,
0.12016047537326813,
-0.4812777638435364,
-0.6769360303878784,
-0.3751334249973297,
-0.09904550760984421,
0.6034499406814575,
0.5116066336631775,
-0.2386508584022522,
0.09469650685787201,
-0.1571246087551117,
0.756284773349762,
-0.6180461049079895,
0.07697302848100662,
-0.8330986499786377,
-0.10356593132019043,
0.041242193430662155,
-0.3953259587287903,
-0.44802722334861755,
-0.3626129925251007,
-0.17862221598625183,
-0.42214512825012207,
0.32261037826538086,
0.007588621228933334,
0.34229975938796997,
0.17068301141262054,
-0.5276188850402832,
-0.3317185938358307,
-0.7995219826698303,
1.0675766468048096,
-0.6098510026931763,
0.34510672092437744,
0.2865484654903412,
0.2504918575286865,
-0.17081506550312042,
-0.2619423270225525,
-0.3289058804512024,
-0.07980259507894516,
0.02623089775443077,
-0.06469804793596268,
0.05082068592309952,
-0.04856142774224281,
0.4227326214313507,
0.19441676139831543,
-0.487825870513916,
0.13672994077205658,
-0.16053885221481323,
-0.14332501590251923,
0.9391894340515137,
0.4250165820121765,
0.19401876628398895,
0.5719074010848999,
-0.26188817620277405,
-0.19952116906642914,
-0.9091125726699829,
-0.12051565200090408,
0.5332958102226257,
0.46299391984939575,
0.015339705161750317,
0.5718841552734375,
-0.015643330290913582,
0.9190521240234375,
0.06562142074108124,
0.0512545071542263,
-0.14224773645401,
-0.334117591381073,
-0.2625333070755005,
0.15243802964687347,
0.34315571188926697,
0.07776279747486115,
0.4051300883293152,
-0.14279071986675262,
-0.4103744328022003,
0.390347957611084,
0.44557830691337585,
-0.6762076020240784,
-0.3501160442829132,
-0.14871913194656372,
0.08532022684812546,
-0.02211908996105194,
-0.08026915043592453,
-0.8556845188140869,
-0.15023426711559296,
-0.97995924949646,
0.4879566729068756,
-0.30556586384773254,
-0.1273164600133896,
0.4495681822299957,
0.18898892402648926,
0.03548485040664673,
0.42053505778312683,
-1.0653173923492432,
0.3942510187625885,
1.1386096477508545,
0.5304737687110901,
0.15211184322834015,
-0.20275098085403442,
-0.7949538230895996,
0.1358119398355484,
-0.5315422415733337,
0.8248732089996338,
-0.9206106066703796,
-0.2838982939720154,
-0.02610442228615284,
-0.046978846192359924,
-0.3858356475830078,
-0.4378204643726349,
0.4747740924358368,
-0.6696935892105103,
0.01308226678520441,
-0.3056836426258087,
-0.5318399667739868,
-0.2104642242193222,
0.19024378061294556,
-0.4002007842063904,
0.8284400701522827,
-0.1228746846318245,
-0.3787185847759247,
-0.074717216193676,
-0.3740469515323639,
-0.77972412109375,
-0.4554250240325928,
-0.14817841351032257,
-0.6090511083602905,
0.39663559198379517,
0.4788977801799774,
0.14827562868595123,
-0.528588593006134,
0.11124221980571747,
-0.3984575569629669,
-0.5156843066215515,
0.08339881151914597,
-0.6175249218940735,
0.5723661780357361,
-0.1058625653386116,
-0.24642904102802277,
0.21386311948299408,
-0.5596457123756409,
0.23961804807186127,
0.17585131525993347,
0.08763740956783295,
-0.26070860028266907,
0.03752759471535683,
-0.7474814057350159,
0.15725716948509216,
0.31481117010116577,
-0.3932782709598541,
0.4362798035144806,
-0.5714566111564636,
0.3412095904350281,
0.872585654258728,
-0.08407262712717056,
0.27664637565612793,
-0.2669656574726105,
0.6323174238204956,
0.10193365067243576,
-0.11396649479866028,
-0.06270405650138855,
-0.5654872059822083,
-0.778712272644043,
0.12452958524227142,
0.09341263025999069,
0.7584258317947388,
-0.71779865026474,
0.40284404158592224,
-0.020639145746827126,
-0.17934492230415344,
-0.44865256547927856,
0.20162896811962128,
0.747958779335022,
0.5553743243217468,
0.5145565867424011,
0.2771444022655487,
-0.4912087023258209,
-0.7749152779579163,
-0.6028991937637329,
0.25134599208831787,
0.14095625281333923,
0.3224397897720337,
0.4961259663105011,
0.06804949045181274,
0.3504265546798706,
-0.7458937764167786,
0.012697187252342701,
0.08859982341527939,
0.22192026674747467,
0.2447228580713272,
0.3030625879764557,
-0.030512133613228798,
-0.6985197067260742,
-0.27717360854148865,
-0.11675585806369781,
-0.47772809863090515,
0.11309141665697098,
-0.10817752778530121,
-0.5280783772468567,
0.2739543318748474,
0.3558075726032257,
-0.2855420410633087,
0.5458918213844299,
0.35800421237945557,
-0.36874160170555115,
0.6531784534454346,
-0.45662787556648254,
0.19181494414806366,
-0.745427131652832,
-0.36372819542884827,
-0.020671401172876358,
-0.019355440512299538,
-0.2801768183708191,
0.040211062878370285,
0.28414666652679443,
-0.1030987873673439,
0.11338470876216888,
0.2999928295612335,
-0.5859710574150085,
0.005954907275736332,
-0.4473314583301544,
0.043122995644807816,
0.10310947149991989,
0.46966552734375,
0.1372474879026413,
0.9804874658584595,
0.6673837900161743,
-0.622131884098053,
0.6272996068000793,
-0.13921919465065002,
-0.27806076407432556,
0.3868698477745056,
-0.592797577381134,
0.5075445771217346,
-0.08616296947002411,
0.17552658915519714,
-0.932495653629303,
0.15910127758979797,
0.05671962350606918,
-0.10097149759531021,
0.5926153063774109,
-0.12568950653076172,
-0.5410301089286804,
-0.645237922668457,
-0.08394653350114822,
0.4693232774734497,
0.4001063406467438,
-0.7027860879898071,
0.6658356785774231,
0.1068800538778305,
-0.13113689422607422,
-0.661768913269043,
-0.5167893171310425,
-0.26711851358413696,
-0.10827983915805817,
-0.7252855896949768,
0.2857216000556946,
0.04359195753931999,
-0.03229166567325592,
-0.10333458334207535,
-0.3642282783985138,
0.15961703658103943,
-0.08856675773859024,
-0.0036779928486794233,
0.4513053297996521,
-0.42341309785842896,
0.4756779968738556,
0.6620347499847412,
-0.3233254849910736,
0.25939828157424927,
-0.681208074092865,
0.5802705883979797,
-0.07099321484565735,
-0.5667845010757446,
-0.36676502227783203,
0.2994295060634613,
0.28338000178337097,
-0.43156370520591736,
0.7972629070281982,
0.3700354993343353,
-0.3693474233150482,
-0.5491881966590881,
-0.43090471625328064,
-0.5209546089172363,
-0.4019121825695038,
0.2944886088371277,
-0.6687806844711304,
-0.5485222339630127,
0.18998663127422333,
-0.3689318299293518,
0.34379681944847107,
0.23663780093193054,
0.584940493106842,
0.14916929602622986,
1.3647485971450806,
0.4425625205039978,
0.18538987636566162,
0.16588757932186127,
-0.4141060411930084,
0.39108726382255554,
-0.8288679122924805,
-0.044696953147649765,
-0.4946702718734741,
-0.5031489133834839,
-0.17824693024158478,
-0.4520026743412018,
0.3676488399505615,
0.370089054107666,
-0.36072221398353577,
0.3110792338848114,
-0.5344914793968201,
0.7576457262039185,
0.5580007433891296,
0.38590291142463684,
0.3143172860145569,
0.13216981291770935,
-0.328138142824173,
0.07801797240972519,
-0.492664635181427,
-0.5407148003578186,
1.2530006170272827,
-0.09773828834295273,
0.8601564168930054,
0.0023443135432899,
0.5831688642501831,
-0.23495765030384064,
0.07486717402935028,
-0.4860711693763733,
0.4762513339519501,
-0.649930477142334,
-0.49092400074005127,
-0.3259969651699066,
-0.6162764430046082,
-0.6656206846237183,
0.3053476810455322,
-0.09963826090097427,
-0.612708568572998,
-0.362102746963501,
0.5000949501991272,
-0.29297488927841187,
0.4188106954097748,
-0.8334160447120667,
0.8877365589141846,
-0.48913872241973877,
-0.5134187340736389,
-0.8528172969818115,
-0.4714503586292267,
0.5165469646453857,
0.08795848488807678,
0.085078664124012,
-0.13439038395881653,
-0.03877653181552887,
0.3735889792442322,
-0.3877686858177185,
0.8607211709022522,
-0.11763501167297363,
-0.5131077766418457,
0.2752261757850647,
0.18738999962806702,
0.6889209747314453,
0.4666350483894348,
-0.14705738425254822,
0.06404753774404526,
0.011100707575678825,
-0.3528535068035126,
-0.9271953105926514,
1.1283241510391235,
-0.7842692732810974,
-0.9221937656402588,
-0.17550088465213776,
-0.8043209314346313,
-0.562395453453064,
0.03588264435529709,
0.08047986775636673,
0.6969484090805054,
0.1536552906036377,
-0.36219456791877747,
0.8871835470199585,
-0.045562148094177246,
0.008465728722512722,
0.40880513191223145,
-0.017132088541984558,
-0.494241863489151,
0.8414539694786072,
-0.17274132370948792,
0.381717711687088,
0.7522695064544678,
0.32452499866485596,
-0.5641158819198608,
-0.19273504614830017,
-0.7055147886276245,
0.4052061140537262,
-0.4698537588119507,
-0.3526808023452759,
-0.13022902607917786,
-0.186014786362648,
-0.42606088519096375,
-0.08995699882507324,
-0.4437737464904785,
-0.38656601309776306,
-0.35616767406463623,
0.2019467055797577,
0.37468087673187256,
0.41365349292755127,
0.168081134557724,
-0.0912368893623352,
-0.6175959706306458,
0.5807047486305237,
0.5082438588142395,
0.5149852633476257,
0.08510580658912659,
-0.6437563300132751,
-0.1527225524187088,
0.7608225345611572,
-0.4429585933685303,
-0.3921658396720886,
0.07183072715997696,
0.09316540509462357,
0.2754269540309906,
0.20400510728359222,
-0.05980049818754196,
0.941493570804596,
-0.6629180908203125,
0.24466024339199066,
0.12318216264247894,
-0.852228045463562,
0.7182987332344055,
0.07544160634279251,
0.43210652470588684,
0.19353431463241577,
0.32926979660987854,
-0.06377130001783371,
0.01080832164734602,
-0.1595730185508728,
-0.23962561786174774,
0.730746328830719,
-0.13654018938541412,
0.15613031387329102,
0.13267676532268524,
0.34220266342163086,
0.32392585277557373,
0.08719532191753387,
0.063882015645504,
-0.09138518571853638,
-0.04708037152886391,
-0.21141399443149567,
-0.3161669075489044,
-0.02133796364068985,
-0.36759552359580994,
-0.4661635458469391,
0.8542559742927551,
-0.15511086583137512,
0.25999927520751953,
-0.2651347517967224,
0.11030662059783936,
-0.5276482701301575,
0.24493816494941711,
0.8780193328857422,
0.940650999546051,
0.06745894998311996,
0.18200403451919556,
0.12135613709688187,
-0.33070144057273865,
-0.006659210659563541,
0.21321073174476624,
0.011923518031835556,
-0.3222174644470215,
0.19835245609283447,
1.0922976732254028,
0.4687102735042572,
-0.5610041618347168,
0.15898726880550385,
-0.031168505549430847,
-0.25584232807159424,
-0.32622289657592773,
0.35017862915992737,
0.26749223470687866,
0.26503443717956543,
-0.05370158329606056,
0.2586505711078644,
-0.3942898213863373,
-0.46886736154556274,
-0.046127013862133026,
0.6823521852493286,
0.00708324508741498,
-0.3251112401485443,
0.47743842005729675,
0.01272483542561531,
-0.3593749701976776,
0.948631227016449,
-0.0729876235127449,
-0.4241977334022522,
0.7223749160766602,
0.9951696395874023,
0.7139366865158081,
-0.029919372871518135,
0.031193459406495094,
0.37740421295166016,
0.11005418747663498,
-0.11655918508768082,
0.5438572764396667,
-0.07170428335666656,
-0.8279576897621155,
-0.6371462941169739,
-0.6024802923202515,
-0.2942109704017639,
-0.1113438531756401,
-0.7687313556671143,
0.5045790076255798,
-0.4164527654647827,
0.10387488454580307,
0.11740118265151978,
0.12391418218612671,
-0.5579909682273865,
0.12432969361543655,
0.2636053264141083,
0.793883204460144,
-0.5725598931312561,
1.1231260299682617,
0.7321916818618774,
-0.055187076330184937,
-0.7205337285995483,
-0.12621182203292847,
-0.03085312247276306,
-1.1918206214904785,
0.30187681317329407,
0.10473623126745224,
-0.7008872628211975,
0.10092618316411972,
-0.4455794095993042,
-0.6943210363388062,
0.9682841897010803,
0.5919233560562134,
-1.025773048400879,
-0.08925330638885498,
0.08488909155130386,
0.4121764302253723,
-0.39735689759254456,
-0.001044871867634356,
0.592570960521698,
0.2365863025188446,
0.4770033657550812,
-0.6773197650909424,
-0.04364050552248955,
0.11722185462713242,
0.04844342917203903,
0.9128955006599426,
-0.6099696159362793,
0.887561023235321,
-0.6698634624481201,
-0.2435869574546814,
0.18623888492584229,
0.630520224571228,
0.5170662999153137,
0.44687315821647644,
0.46791625022888184,
0.8690318465232849,
0.73471999168396,
-0.10912889242172241,
0.7621970772743225,
-0.33510011434555054,
0.21233481168746948,
1.221271276473999,
-0.39237236976623535,
0.8198500871658325,
0.22765210270881653,
-0.14959213137626648,
0.7199797630310059,
0.2577609121799469,
0.10942082107067108,
0.3992474377155304,
0.3815454840660095,
-0.2654520869255066,
-0.6687349677085876,
0.30831652879714966,
-0.5059713125228882,
0.3149738311767578,
0.7690467834472656,
-0.2353229969739914,
-0.16791345179080963,
-0.057912226766347885,
-0.0739097148180008,
0.473920077085495,
-0.5867782831192017,
0.540040135383606,
0.1460801213979721,
-1.0004684925079346,
0.836493194103241,
0.09068536758422852,
0.2858528196811676,
-0.4913105368614197,
-0.3945847451686859,
-0.05556654930114746,
0.572197437286377,
0.05371727794408798,
-0.8154674172401428,
0.3279377818107605,
-0.10390221327543259,
-0.20172211527824402,
-0.2131456881761551,
0.5999667048454285,
-0.6167762279510498,
-0.8433583378791809,
0.08274371922016144,
0.20899446308612823,
-0.13912110030651093,
-0.16753628849983215,
-0.7317475080490112,
0.05521424487233162,
-0.0009881947189569473,
0.10863115638494492,
0.35504910349845886,
0.6253257393836975,
-0.16173012554645538,
0.59930020570755,
0.5653184652328491,
0.11894359439611435,
0.07963815331459045,
0.30783557891845703,
0.9518248438835144,
-0.7880749702453613,
-0.4677015244960785,
-0.9095228314399719,
0.23620158433914185,
0.006376567762345076,
-0.46682149171829224,
0.5400617718696594,
0.5535850524902344,
0.8449583649635315,
-0.16784317791461945,
0.3711783289909363,
0.5196918845176697,
0.5988418459892273,
-0.9382760524749756,
0.09716901183128357,
-0.4373070299625397,
0.36910998821258545,
0.09223774820566177,
-0.8200045824050903,
-0.2489362210035324,
0.4087196886539459,
-0.7948464751243591,
0.1062353327870369,
0.7091690301895142,
0.9749665856361389,
-0.3058684766292572,
0.626624584197998,
0.1762406975030899,
0.08325182646512985,
-0.010181404650211334,
1.0986073017120361,
0.7549694776535034,
-0.3207569718360901,
0.3603699505329132,
-0.49588507413864136,
-0.2956606149673462,
-0.054956354200839996,
-0.6554875373840332,
-1.1243970394134521,
-0.1947549283504486,
-0.32344987988471985,
-0.23069234192371368,
0.22461667656898499,
0.6642377972602844,
0.5930131077766418,
-1.0472795963287354,
-0.25500956177711487,
-0.4510543644428253,
0.1943657249212265,
-0.5392847061157227,
-0.19463998079299927,
0.3407301902770996,
-0.5868956446647644,
-0.5014538168907166,
0.40533745288848877,
0.38814815878868103,
-0.34257829189300537,
-0.22493025660514832,
-0.04365459084510803,
-0.2599560618400574,
0.2120475322008133,
0.4972279667854309,
0.15403950214385986,
-0.8621933460235596,
-0.1743708699941635,
0.017592119053006172,
0.047895487397909164,
-0.1182892844080925,
1.2254822254180908,
-0.6658858060836792,
0.555191159248352,
0.23174980282783508,
0.5392528772354126,
0.564879298210144,
0.17442935705184937,
0.7781983017921448,
-0.557246208190918,
-0.06034577265381813,
0.27281492948532104,
0.14091791212558746,
0.03336784616112709,
-0.4535810351371765,
0.2592688798904419,
0.12702997028827667,
-0.6150290966033936,
-0.6592968702316284,
0.47236236929893494,
-0.5407254099845886,
-0.4322764277458191,
0.8204002976417542,
-0.05462156608700752,
0.01659432426095009,
0.25278332829475403,
-0.22733721137046814,
0.36745738983154297,
-0.19778363406658173,
0.7524887323379517,
0.5716173052787781,
-0.42827892303466797,
-0.11279677599668503,
-0.33043551445007324,
0.16390207409858704,
0.6032631397247314,
-0.5871086120605469,
0.31683555245399475,
0.42563724517822266,
0.04739401116967201,
-0.11617537587881088,
-0.07573500275611877,
-0.04110028222203255,
0.3308950960636139,
0.1339097023010254,
-0.4476306140422821,
-0.243093803524971,
-0.6397690773010254,
-0.29879090189933777,
-0.15819808840751648,
-0.16561368107795715,
-0.21971724927425385
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18286v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18286v1
|
Few-Shot Recalibration of Language Models
| 2024-03-27T06:25:40 | 2024-03-27T06:25:40 |
Xiang Lisa Li, Urvashi Khandelwal, Kelvin Guu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Recent work has uncovered promising ways to extract well-calibrated
confidence estimates from language models (LMs), where the model's confidence
score reflects how likely it is to be correct. However, while LMs may appear
well-calibrated over broad distributions, this often hides significant
miscalibration within narrower slices (e.g., systemic over-confidence in math
can balance out systemic under-confidence in history, yielding perfect
calibration in aggregate). To attain well-calibrated confidence estimates for
any slice of a distribution, we propose a new framework for few-shot
slice-specific recalibration. Specifically, we train a recalibration model that
takes in a few unlabeled examples from any given slice and predicts a curve
that remaps confidence scores to be more accurate for that slice. Our trained
model can recalibrate for arbitrary new slices, without using any labeled data
from that slice. This enables us to identify domain-specific confidence
thresholds above which the LM's predictions can be trusted, and below which it
should abstain. Experiments show that our few-shot recalibrator consistently
outperforms existing calibration methods, for instance improving calibration
error for PaLM2-Large on MMLU by 16%, as compared to temperature scaling.
|
[
-0.2462819665670395,
-0.46930065751075745,
0.5040972828865051,
-0.28770923614501953,
-0.15807700157165527,
0.02764476276934147,
-0.1941494196653366,
-0.2687017023563385,
0.19973823428153992,
0.39250969886779785,
-0.41192010045051575,
-0.6959779858589172,
-0.614086389541626,
-0.17596261203289032,
-0.45221850275993347,
0.9246895909309387,
0.1986970752477646,
0.09563371539115906,
0.11195015907287598,
-0.16339527070522308,
0.0011545545421540737,
-0.14746646583080292,
-0.3462139666080475,
-0.7513334155082703,
0.5298044085502625,
0.49427714943885803,
0.6691262722015381,
0.2109634131193161,
0.43006500601768494,
0.14146912097930908,
0.05477065220475197,
0.2103770524263382,
-0.7272603511810303,
-0.12004787474870682,
-0.1124563217163086,
-0.6472294926643372,
-0.29996970295906067,
0.018225422129034996,
0.7465707659721375,
0.8045264482498169,
-0.21640649437904358,
0.19645267724990845,
0.24650292098522186,
0.7304932475090027,
-1.1613410711288452,
-0.031785931438207626,
-0.8339380621910095,
-0.07994501292705536,
-0.12203975766897202,
-0.16125498712062836,
-0.7131432294845581,
-0.7986763715744019,
0.06029603257775307,
-0.4242967963218689,
0.16846929490566254,
-0.32850077748298645,
0.790661096572876,
0.19525331258773804,
-0.33346688747406006,
0.3146421015262604,
-0.8436419367790222,
1.0270118713378906,
-0.6590055823326111,
0.31121107935905457,
0.6382378339767456,
0.6322272419929504,
-0.18780814111232758,
-0.5319803953170776,
-0.16975203156471252,
0.08036942780017853,
0.22771604359149933,
-0.019227463752031326,
-0.17544665932655334,
-0.09716129302978516,
0.02639385126531124,
0.1025114357471466,
-0.4240230321884155,
0.0209723562002182,
-0.2621254026889801,
-0.28313952684402466,
0.6299746632575989,
0.0363864041864872,
-0.20670896768569946,
0.126643568277359,
-0.26409193873405457,
-0.21906410157680511,
-1.0188250541687012,
-0.02533593587577343,
0.28544387221336365,
0.6200464963912964,
-0.08686646819114685,
0.4444548785686493,
-0.08243094384670258,
0.8460911512374878,
0.15079191327095032,
-0.5190597176551819,
0.4957844913005829,
-0.09809298068284988,
-0.2984754145145416,
-0.17494799196720123,
0.5714629292488098,
0.2953560948371887,
0.6152224540710449,
0.11443089693784714,
-0.11056415736675262,
-0.07881604135036469,
0.2892490327358246,
-0.6180145740509033,
-0.5040753483772278,
0.0794706791639328,
-0.001765514723956585,
-0.29765257239341736,
0.015400455333292484,
-0.5112293362617493,
-0.3823831081390381,
0.07327937334775925,
0.30385318398475647,
-0.5055662393569946,
-0.22531400620937347,
-0.009565459564328194,
-0.07136055827140808,
0.329782634973526,
0.34691229462623596,
-0.9945792555809021,
0.1487625539302826,
0.7273309230804443,
0.5905365347862244,
-0.029675886034965515,
-0.35836583375930786,
-0.4090847373008728,
-0.03173802047967911,
-0.6491218209266663,
0.7763587832450867,
-0.7405749559402466,
-0.3486112654209137,
0.13077770173549652,
-0.10595604032278061,
-0.10335346311330795,
-0.3210783004760742,
0.36452218890190125,
-0.42596927285194397,
-0.13533321022987366,
-0.04506148025393486,
-0.7413474321365356,
-0.16154061257839203,
0.7825023531913757,
-0.49666059017181396,
0.9743585586547852,
0.3020196259021759,
-0.6143826842308044,
0.4495543837547302,
0.11100131273269653,
-0.1383970081806183,
-0.1049877405166626,
-0.33235979080200195,
-0.5029680728912354,
0.17838004231452942,
0.13173559308052063,
0.22398988902568817,
-0.17516523599624634,
-0.1589418649673462,
-0.6687449812889099,
-0.4921732544898987,
0.40079987049102783,
-0.7650283575057983,
0.5860816240310669,
-0.018469881266355515,
0.19161830842494965,
-0.3883896470069885,
-0.7520148158073425,
0.6684618592262268,
-0.3037905693054199,
-0.3213747441768646,
-0.19771814346313477,
-0.38607698678970337,
-0.0769156962633133,
-0.17243044078350067,
0.14780540764331818,
-0.718497097492218,
0.2325395941734314,
-0.7853311896324158,
0.09686456620693207,
0.47176453471183777,
0.15645325183868408,
0.6154804229736328,
-0.3907625675201416,
0.6907861828804016,
-0.03529863804578781,
-0.04121526703238487,
-0.3225615620613098,
-0.6089270710945129,
-0.4052722454071045,
-0.4172624945640564,
0.5081837177276611,
0.5905781388282776,
-0.49934908747673035,
0.435516357421875,
-0.3588508069515228,
-0.7948071956634521,
-0.5938482880592346,
0.35692691802978516,
0.5198559761047363,
0.5150270462036133,
0.31293970346450806,
-0.47061070799827576,
-0.32521724700927734,
-0.855234682559967,
-0.2568322718143463,
-0.22853800654411316,
-0.11521109938621521,
0.1534290909767151,
0.381947785615921,
-0.07758471369743347,
1.3449236154556274,
-0.6340033411979675,
-0.2965904772281647,
-0.2503666281700134,
0.1746768206357956,
0.24608203768730164,
0.4481799602508545,
0.49013084173202515,
-0.39696916937828064,
-0.5784483551979065,
-0.048632267862558365,
-0.21538014709949493,
0.12126420438289642,
0.03671776503324509,
-0.03790606930851936,
0.051586855202913284,
0.13581214845180511,
-0.3306392729282379,
0.4645441174507141,
0.7582831978797913,
0.25018635392189026,
0.384273499250412,
-0.20881067216396332,
0.19824238121509552,
-0.9868168234825134,
0.0571478046476841,
0.14731329679489136,
-0.5906916260719299,
-0.6327210664749146,
0.014726538211107254,
0.26273179054260254,
0.21036532521247864,
-0.6961818337440491,
0.5488352179527283,
-0.10824636369943619,
-0.09147515147924423,
-0.40205860137939453,
0.2884086072444916,
0.18910321593284607,
0.3263949155807495,
0.11300434917211533,
0.39620810747146606,
0.5390860438346863,
-0.46722105145454407,
0.00030734253232367337,
0.024035494774580002,
-0.3875286877155304,
0.6158278584480286,
-0.5041082501411438,
0.13074366748332977,
-0.11698795109987259,
0.35462871193885803,
-1.2578585147857666,
-0.10839671641588211,
0.03347725793719292,
-0.5086793303489685,
0.4330288767814636,
-0.6957606077194214,
-0.10110530257225037,
-0.08581775426864624,
-0.4015922248363495,
0.6247904300689697,
0.5545437932014465,
-0.3910149931907654,
0.49572989344596863,
0.4728807806968689,
0.26250752806663513,
-0.7392600774765015,
-1.082925796508789,
-0.44272276759147644,
0.06244591623544693,
-0.4168787896633148,
0.19659990072250366,
0.041524309664964676,
0.022870581597089767,
-0.3881634473800659,
-0.11725557595491409,
-0.4086013436317444,
-0.003579001175239682,
0.32271453738212585,
0.21061770617961884,
-0.11147049069404602,
0.1930135041475296,
0.06607651710510254,
-0.412820041179657,
-0.3303229510784149,
-0.14834007620811462,
0.48152509331703186,
-0.009584405459463596,
-0.6496721506118774,
-0.26153770089149475,
-0.017931340262293816,
0.20684894919395447,
-0.07822936028242111,
0.5142354965209961,
0.5708922147750854,
-0.7021299004554749,
-0.12387014925479889,
-0.5379019975662231,
-0.40447136759757996,
-0.4520142376422882,
0.26640933752059937,
-0.5537445545196533,
-0.7745541334152222,
0.28699979186058044,
-0.05997254326939583,
0.3622421324253082,
0.3316898047924042,
0.562000572681427,
-0.08500503748655319,
0.939527690410614,
0.7660086154937744,
-0.2970435619354248,
0.30488884449005127,
-0.18467378616333008,
0.1353318989276886,
-0.7084983587265015,
0.12127412855625153,
-0.5819084644317627,
-0.34112316370010376,
-0.5548720359802246,
-0.46597182750701904,
0.21852339804172516,
0.032744213938713074,
-0.35195454955101013,
0.42092567682266235,
-0.2349879890680313,
0.897138237953186,
0.42385274171829224,
0.06465117633342743,
0.09704890847206116,
0.04663084074854851,
-0.16153748333454132,
-0.20503923296928406,
-0.6337680816650391,
-0.7212277054786682,
1.316790223121643,
0.540895938873291,
1.1160101890563965,
0.039751362055540085,
1.1646263599395752,
0.1277182400226593,
0.6823432445526123,
-0.6948643922805786,
0.1567419320344925,
-0.38810476660728455,
-0.8229382634162903,
-0.2658438980579376,
-0.40840965509414673,
-0.8985735177993774,
0.26492974162101746,
-0.26142239570617676,
-0.9446384310722351,
0.3565913438796997,
0.5095143914222717,
-0.8768309354782104,
0.02975406125187874,
-0.8219149708747864,
0.7557251453399658,
0.15046106278896332,
-0.2953835725784302,
0.04136083647608757,
-0.4461917579174042,
0.4470314681529999,
-0.19460582733154297,
0.16176585853099823,
-0.4615398347377777,
0.11576958745718002,
0.3686123192310333,
-0.15810446441173553,
1.2915866374969482,
-0.12802478671073914,
-0.07927367091178894,
0.40218278765678406,
0.4026933014392853,
0.39179086685180664,
-0.02884840965270996,
-0.2879825830459595,
0.049091190099716187,
0.41919803619384766,
-0.43383145332336426,
-0.6386058926582336,
0.7623681426048279,
-0.6877869367599487,
-0.3289656639099121,
-0.257352739572525,
-0.29105114936828613,
-0.512508749961853,
0.1102154552936554,
0.4055052101612091,
0.15526634454727173,
-0.4794897139072418,
0.18446286022663116,
0.47481197118759155,
0.15442350506782532,
0.11771160364151001,
0.44277745485305786,
-0.25116583704948425,
-0.37197136878967285,
0.6824321150779724,
-0.03686394542455673,
0.5464702248573303,
0.4141615629196167,
0.08882878720760345,
-0.19261202216148376,
-0.1976436972618103,
-0.24609743058681488,
0.227851003408432,
-0.8660155534744263,
-0.49580931663513184,
0.018894705921411514,
-0.2613966763019562,
-0.46928393840789795,
-0.19510038197040558,
-0.8163138628005981,
-0.6508234739303589,
-0.28959640860557556,
-0.2986764907836914,
0.1431901901960373,
0.44205164909362793,
0.005752297583967447,
0.4543352723121643,
-0.8327068090438843,
0.032359976321458817,
0.07301988452672958,
0.22940397262573242,
-0.35184377431869507,
-0.9470885396003723,
-0.12108159065246582,
0.43420013785362244,
-0.4101148247718811,
-0.8429970741271973,
0.510701060295105,
0.44909828901290894,
0.41342175006866455,
0.48952415585517883,
-0.11785481870174408,
0.938218355178833,
-0.6558259725570679,
0.6428690552711487,
0.3891838788986206,
-0.8622969388961792,
0.4245586395263672,
0.31076139211654663,
0.5226012468338013,
1.0569705963134766,
0.3209397792816162,
-0.492721825838089,
-0.5396267771720886,
-0.5038220286369324,
-0.4617796242237091,
0.43823498487472534,
-0.08101754635572433,
0.4427819550037384,
-0.10215754806995392,
0.46839985251426697,
0.14811000227928162,
-0.025419918820261955,
-0.7290598154067993,
-0.20855745673179626,
-0.17376674711704254,
-0.5545369982719421,
-0.3095816373825073,
-0.2907082438468933,
-0.40282928943634033,
0.11545239388942719,
0.6128847599029541,
-0.475211501121521,
-0.008874990977346897,
-0.02049284242093563,
-0.09705080091953278,
-0.3393009603023529,
0.4191994071006775,
0.49567702412605286,
0.7191702723503113,
-0.2628577649593353,
0.3071955144405365,
0.2005777359008789,
-0.42210206389427185,
0.24668776988983154,
-0.09896820038557053,
-0.41459429264068604,
0.028453517705202103,
0.39269331097602844,
0.575568675994873,
0.4933483600616455,
-0.4659157395362854,
0.7113496661186218,
0.20843540132045746,
-0.23117221891880035,
-0.37960439920425415,
0.3099258542060852,
-0.061332687735557556,
0.338871568441391,
0.28194716572761536,
0.139120951294899,
-0.054316435009241104,
-0.34637847542762756,
0.4577365815639496,
0.5980787873268127,
-0.5462336540222168,
-0.29067063331604004,
0.267984539270401,
0.1559409350156784,
-0.16356800496578217,
0.5964928269386292,
-0.14808323979377747,
-0.30011555552482605,
0.35998931527137756,
0.6031863689422607,
0.8395460844039917,
-0.2665778696537018,
0.3118898868560791,
0.6733074188232422,
0.546596884727478,
-0.30653396248817444,
0.22013697028160095,
0.15911804139614105,
-1.2459553480148315,
-0.22719700634479523,
-0.5579078197479248,
-0.5477680563926697,
-0.3116591274738312,
-0.7075360417366028,
0.19518499076366425,
-0.6267304420471191,
-0.6361145973205566,
-0.1852721869945526,
-0.03613723814487457,
-0.6940888166427612,
0.26652994751930237,
0.31414127349853516,
1.0422743558883667,
-1.1062043905258179,
1.1966568231582642,
0.2951520085334778,
-0.29908138513565063,
-0.7284511923789978,
-0.11035915464162827,
0.21987831592559814,
-1.040683627128601,
0.2816186845302582,
0.06874355673789978,
-0.4255819320678711,
0.03728557750582695,
-0.4374794661998749,
-0.951245903968811,
1.2205135822296143,
0.7115544080734253,
-0.8976212739944458,
0.13098405301570892,
0.25800007581710815,
0.6428585052490234,
-0.5622265338897705,
0.49069273471832275,
0.7820557355880737,
0.22195793688297272,
0.43024513125419617,
-0.8653098344802856,
-0.407749742269516,
0.13796502351760864,
-0.01115733664482832,
0.29164183139801025,
-0.27383390069007874,
0.6073840260505676,
-0.37305912375450134,
-0.15098316967487335,
0.1872549206018448,
0.5304968953132629,
0.576824426651001,
0.14221295714378357,
0.311594158411026,
0.4726356267929077,
0.8728142976760864,
-0.1866854876279831,
1.1862833499908447,
-0.4406093955039978,
0.6109870672225952,
1.4190171957015991,
-0.2870817482471466,
1.3300502300262451,
0.6130834817886353,
-0.16253836452960968,
0.5339858531951904,
0.5656159520149231,
0.20313727855682373,
0.5435577034950256,
-0.005395942833274603,
-0.20387808978557587,
-0.562670886516571,
0.28003063797950745,
-0.18265528976917267,
0.29404518008232117,
0.39899322390556335,
-0.44467905163764954,
-0.3576555550098419,
-0.08804647624492645,
-0.04815032705664635,
-0.04046713188290596,
-0.2256978303194046,
0.3951519727706909,
0.36867156624794006,
-0.587554931640625,
0.7422515153884888,
0.21734203398227692,
0.41550666093826294,
-0.755918562412262,
0.15004204213619232,
-0.38282981514930725,
0.45890921354293823,
-0.36645931005477905,
-0.8914805054664612,
0.21677282452583313,
0.0067953853867948055,
0.12978217005729675,
0.09785058349370956,
0.5577030777931213,
-0.7687962055206299,
-0.6024752855300903,
-0.06580609828233719,
0.48711448907852173,
0.19764402508735657,
0.08748873323202133,
-0.725631594657898,
0.11181198805570602,
0.005397259257733822,
-0.24241457879543304,
0.16879937052726746,
0.11664839088916779,
0.24783435463905334,
0.6791286468505859,
0.2903209924697876,
0.018126273527741432,
0.12029635906219482,
0.3923572897911072,
0.5049195885658264,
-0.5117451548576355,
-0.24577081203460693,
-0.8316639065742493,
0.5177165269851685,
0.16936948895454407,
-0.47637197375297546,
0.5825392007827759,
0.41526392102241516,
0.843845546245575,
0.07863472402095795,
0.5338216423988342,
0.45063167810440063,
0.5460050702095032,
-0.45323750376701355,
0.47960513830184937,
-0.5473814606666565,
0.36633923649787903,
-0.30038025975227356,
-0.9049909114837646,
-0.7662023901939392,
1.002741813659668,
-0.4685646891593933,
0.21327829360961914,
0.5773813128471375,
1.0273693799972534,
-0.10795583575963974,
-0.20821025967597961,
0.6258758306503296,
-0.0008056499646045268,
0.24179509282112122,
0.7043960094451904,
0.4280489683151245,
-0.5222770571708679,
0.49230527877807617,
-0.3216113746166229,
-0.21982555091381073,
-0.2026725858449936,
-0.8905209302902222,
-0.5840756297111511,
-0.35404545068740845,
-0.5144934058189392,
-0.27578094601631165,
0.01567903347313404,
0.9495272636413574,
0.8815653920173645,
-0.8581953644752502,
-0.19186976552009583,
0.13943320512771606,
0.04405823349952698,
-0.10897324979305267,
-0.16790340840816498,
0.002802106784656644,
-0.18980474770069122,
-0.7448297142982483,
0.4009430706501007,
0.4394649565219879,
0.16027477383613586,
-0.3771568238735199,
-0.18879356980323792,
-0.013137921690940857,
0.3999824821949005,
0.3352283835411072,
0.6031308174133301,
-0.6267054677009583,
-0.5965101718902588,
-0.27223625779151917,
-0.5131862759590149,
0.2282761037349701,
0.6313863396644592,
-0.8203334808349609,
0.48765134811401367,
0.29661449790000916,
0.7155318260192871,
0.6399123072624207,
-0.002204989781603217,
0.4449748396873474,
-1.2188471555709839,
0.13526862859725952,
0.25599178671836853,
0.4057691991329193,
0.36040130257606506,
0.13660122454166412,
0.4131292402744293,
-0.12612459063529968,
-0.3074665665626526,
-0.8427540063858032,
0.4952106177806854,
-0.7438199520111084,
-0.01885153166949749,
1.16354501247406,
-0.4698926508426666,
-0.4297221601009369,
0.11731115728616714,
-0.027475597336888313,
-0.07614658772945404,
-0.26734262704849243,
0.7344147562980652,
0.6827420592308044,
0.11966133117675781,
-0.38877418637275696,
0.07741855829954147,
0.41238754987716675,
0.4786887466907501,
-0.6301797032356262,
0.09186480194330215,
0.5064194202423096,
0.5747365951538086,
0.30981069803237915,
0.8456651568412781,
-0.13645979762077332,
0.4767920672893524,
-0.04315166175365448,
-0.09247405081987381,
0.41095128655433655,
-0.4024840295314789,
-0.5708860158920288,
0.28846079111099243,
0.5800146460533142,
-0.2022411972284317
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18277v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18277v1
|
BlendX: Complex Multi-Intent Detection with Blended Patterns
| 2024-03-27T06:13:04 | 2024-03-27T06:13:04 |
Yejin Yoon, Jungyeon Lee, Kangsan Kim, Chanhee Park, Taeuk Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Task-oriented dialogue (TOD) systems are commonly designed with the
presumption that each utterance represents a single intent. However, this
assumption may not accurately reflect real-world situations, where users
frequently express multiple intents within a single utterance. While there is
an emerging interest in multi-intent detection (MID), existing in-domain
datasets such as MixATIS and MixSNIPS have limitations in their formulation. To
address these issues, we present BlendX, a suite of refined datasets featuring
more diverse patterns than their predecessors, elevating both its complexity
and diversity. For dataset construction, we utilize both rule-based heuristics
as well as a generative tool -- OpenAI's ChatGPT -- which is augmented with a
similarity-driven strategy for utterance selection. To ensure the quality of
the proposed datasets, we also introduce three novel metrics that assess the
statistical properties of an utterance related to word count, conjunction use,
and pronoun usage. Extensive experiments on BlendX reveal that state-of-the-art
MID models struggle with the challenges posed by the new datasets, highlighting
the need to reexamine the current state of the MID field. The dataset is
available at https://github.com/HYU-NLP/BlendX.
|
[
-0.2444736361503601,
-0.7249142527580261,
0.6694999933242798,
0.4522646367549896,
-0.182693213224411,
0.012644021771848202,
-0.20345136523246765,
-0.09799835830926895,
0.1278906613588333,
0.5789161324501038,
-0.8389927744865417,
-0.5429856181144714,
-0.6581011414527893,
-0.013563468120992184,
-0.40530237555503845,
0.8878284096717834,
-0.029992220923304558,
-0.14800000190734863,
-0.13481111824512482,
-0.41552338004112244,
-0.7951148748397827,
-0.24545100331306458,
-0.6677516102790833,
-0.24053889513015747,
0.21111351251602173,
0.8155844211578369,
0.659199059009552,
0.027409663423895836,
0.11154798418283463,
0.23343661427497864,
0.11298788338899612,
0.5000531673431396,
-0.4509512782096863,
0.48089906573295593,
0.44815537333488464,
-0.35081031918525696,
-0.46237829327583313,
0.057939015328884125,
0.4231390953063965,
0.7171494364738464,
-0.2118379771709442,
-0.10056854039430618,
0.17969714105129242,
0.23827160894870758,
-0.6753489971160889,
0.1730482429265976,
-0.3458172678947449,
-0.012735935859382153,
-0.37544313073158264,
-0.08610368520021439,
-0.3114235997200012,
-0.008746632374823093,
0.3834572732448578,
-0.6799022555351257,
0.017429567873477936,
0.2915880084037781,
0.3441298007965088,
0.1349252462387085,
-0.44822344183921814,
-0.4000852704048157,
-0.8505053520202637,
1.081721544265747,
-0.8324205875396729,
0.6007102727890015,
0.2063295692205429,
0.42195358872413635,
-0.4374305307865143,
-0.5635265707969666,
-0.8152551651000977,
0.0808008685708046,
-0.048914019018411636,
0.22978350520133972,
-0.14606280624866486,
-0.03552234545350075,
0.12115693092346191,
0.49350813031196594,
-0.7899770140647888,
-0.23266065120697021,
0.17878103256225586,
-0.15384145081043243,
0.3464624583721161,
0.3305879831314087,
0.4767864942550659,
0.20398405194282532,
-0.48264509439468384,
-0.20489025115966797,
-0.4294690191745758,
0.0191422700881958,
0.24561797082424164,
0.22122707962989807,
-0.3346787393093109,
0.6012004613876343,
-0.346941202878952,
0.6899826526641846,
-0.12959006428718567,
-0.26898202300071716,
0.17022202908992767,
-0.7921969294548035,
-0.2369888573884964,
0.031642649322748184,
0.8529887795448303,
0.19201575219631195,
0.22188201546669006,
-0.16179746389389038,
-0.19826510548591614,
0.001962395617738366,
-0.03149149939417839,
-0.5442475080490112,
-0.1426754593849182,
0.4515834450721741,
-0.44029492139816284,
0.06001049280166626,
-0.1327323168516159,
-0.46764126420021057,
-0.24622704088687897,
-0.6512514352798462,
0.27142807841300964,
-0.4512244164943695,
-0.3718089759349823,
0.5892279744148254,
-0.386579692363739,
0.4319581985473633,
0.4761417508125305,
-0.4031394422054291,
0.5497004985809326,
0.802851676940918,
0.8163800835609436,
-0.3903236389160156,
-0.29716989398002625,
-0.5053477883338928,
0.05030755326151848,
-0.12140495330095291,
0.8413636088371277,
-0.8813225626945496,
-0.4940478205680847,
-0.21941566467285156,
-0.3116537034511566,
-0.16026915609836578,
-0.6080355644226074,
0.8314478993415833,
-0.12859156727790833,
0.4987277388572693,
-0.027436500415205956,
-0.41415950655937195,
-0.27841898798942566,
0.4070471227169037,
-0.5171244144439697,
0.9413689374923706,
0.1559699922800064,
-0.4373290240764618,
0.6300161480903625,
-0.7711641192436218,
-0.605170726776123,
0.02789648063480854,
-0.2715841829776764,
-0.44286635518074036,
0.058711327612400055,
0.08654407411813736,
0.3340270221233368,
-0.4000413417816162,
0.37391233444213867,
-0.4103813171386719,
-0.08839763700962067,
0.4123217463493347,
-0.7271062135696411,
0.5850669741630554,
0.20167171955108643,
-0.1087757796049118,
0.434152215719223,
-0.7143709063529968,
-0.0034929567482322454,
-0.11922471970319748,
-0.08701193332672119,
-0.4992104470729828,
0.14694972336292267,
0.23055072128772736,
0.32754677534103394,
-0.03329947590827942,
-0.7771778106689453,
0.10113818198442459,
0.006295640487223864,
0.112838514149189,
0.5320569276809692,
-0.0656815692782402,
0.22709941864013672,
-0.44440963864326477,
0.4946998953819275,
0.3901385962963104,
0.47127851843833923,
-0.22429469227790833,
-0.9643068313598633,
-0.6144222617149353,
-0.5270562171936035,
0.06719358265399933,
0.631699800491333,
-0.7009273171424866,
0.38338321447372437,
-0.3613658845424652,
-0.09458647668361664,
-0.3241095244884491,
-0.06622336804866791,
0.4270121455192566,
0.04561635106801987,
0.21934574842453003,
-0.5307506918907166,
-0.30817604064941406,
-0.6984202265739441,
-0.37027838826179504,
0.36050233244895935,
-0.048634011298418045,
0.6461954712867737,
0.14608554542064667,
-0.2967013418674469,
1.1591886281967163,
-0.7076916098594666,
-0.41102275252342224,
-0.22536392509937286,
0.2474145144224167,
0.2759769856929779,
0.3431745767593384,
0.5600430965423584,
-1.0168485641479492,
-0.6030083894729614,
0.054998259991407394,
-0.5071017146110535,
0.0865153819322586,
-0.09787982702255249,
-0.20715351402759552,
-0.4893471300601959,
0.2786686420440674,
-0.5773187279701233,
0.4425964951515198,
0.5601680874824524,
-0.46150869131088257,
0.715234100818634,
0.044477880001068115,
0.3685740828514099,
-1.1320351362228394,
-0.2572140693664551,
0.022030211985111237,
-0.24165630340576172,
-0.9415705800056458,
-0.4779920279979706,
-0.39257287979125977,
-0.10098595917224884,
-0.4109667241573334,
0.6700411438941956,
-0.3275299668312073,
-0.01715528778731823,
-0.2804870307445526,
-0.19345523416996002,
-0.004432844929397106,
0.6060725450515747,
-0.04975654184818268,
0.9489558339118958,
0.679571270942688,
-0.7351619005203247,
0.19932030141353607,
0.44129908084869385,
-0.413377970457077,
0.7289204001426697,
-0.5661828517913818,
0.1689397692680359,
-0.06665466725826263,
0.37415754795074463,
-1.1630222797393799,
-0.4141777455806732,
0.43030601739883423,
-0.27696526050567627,
0.02402946725487709,
-0.14369377493858337,
-0.47106537222862244,
0.07191034406423569,
-0.21882189810276031,
0.8883863091468811,
0.19587236642837524,
-0.40935978293418884,
0.7871503233909607,
0.4204149544239044,
-0.35666000843048096,
-0.6287397146224976,
-0.2712034285068512,
0.1083119735121727,
-0.22547180950641632,
-0.6925369501113892,
0.30764806270599365,
-0.2121669501066208,
-0.09213025122880936,
-0.19780035316944122,
-0.285247266292572,
-0.209899440407753,
-0.013190208934247494,
0.19830594956874847,
0.024435140192508698,
-0.2032037377357483,
-0.2765235900878906,
0.18019112944602966,
-0.008713624440133572,
-0.1826610416173935,
-0.5173936486244202,
0.7470371127128601,
0.18962077796459198,
-0.4877433478832245,
-0.3964386582374573,
0.7298367023468018,
0.8942886590957642,
-0.13852986693382263,
0.26735568046569824,
0.642672061920166,
-0.2444177269935608,
-0.3579641878604889,
-0.24331805109977722,
-0.14075186848640442,
-0.4146682024002075,
-0.08443228900432587,
-0.6733775734901428,
-0.819949746131897,
0.5455806255340576,
-0.27801746129989624,
0.341812402009964,
-0.07925722002983093,
0.4218141734600067,
0.11010101437568665,
1.093780517578125,
0.2638835310935974,
0.11176466941833496,
0.5926258563995361,
-0.1834544986486435,
0.5342680215835571,
-0.9536075592041016,
-0.09944529086351395,
-0.3729016184806824,
-0.3312552571296692,
-0.3349149525165558,
-0.4694536626338959,
0.4903393089771271,
-0.4228106737136841,
0.09692897647619247,
0.25182464718818665,
-0.20678512752056122,
0.36775505542755127,
0.7072606682777405,
0.19175659120082855,
0.438221275806427,
-0.13237395882606506,
0.08327104896306992,
0.1591351181268692,
-0.7073625922203064,
-0.3033812940120697,
1.2051217555999756,
-0.13046479225158691,
0.8271318674087524,
0.425961434841156,
0.42309653759002686,
0.3602175712585449,
-0.045579537749290466,
-0.9523491263389587,
0.5252426862716675,
-0.3780553936958313,
-0.4400990903377533,
-0.2348528951406479,
-0.37340933084487915,
-1.186393141746521,
0.3020293414592743,
-0.15689463913440704,
-0.43673771619796753,
0.4095030426979065,
0.027374645695090294,
-0.31853246688842773,
-0.045580387115478516,
-0.7577285766601562,
0.9193341135978699,
-0.19632530212402344,
-0.11430221050977707,
-0.13116802275180817,
-0.40347108244895935,
0.5001764893531799,
0.09108933806419373,
0.17128725349903107,
-0.413118839263916,
0.2873612940311432,
0.46697211265563965,
-0.1138622835278511,
0.8222067952156067,
-0.013962047174572945,
-0.1876489520072937,
0.32098615169525146,
0.004435436800122261,
0.2903534173965454,
-0.01554021704941988,
0.26363518834114075,
0.025502806529402733,
-0.02364370785653591,
-0.3417477607727051,
-0.465520977973938,
0.5621643662452698,
-0.444863498210907,
-0.18539124727249146,
-0.38368889689445496,
-0.6501830816268921,
-0.37282490730285645,
0.3162258565425873,
0.16823524236679077,
0.7054252624511719,
-0.3877220153808594,
0.16225479543209076,
0.6983290314674377,
-0.020779550075531006,
0.220123752951622,
0.22287489473819733,
-0.053629811853170395,
-0.09331464022397995,
0.9815903902053833,
-0.21104519069194794,
0.2939690351486206,
0.11272036284208298,
0.2206452339887619,
-0.3367815911769867,
-0.5846523642539978,
-0.4293561577796936,
-0.08820366114377975,
-0.3455614149570465,
0.020961960777640343,
-0.502083420753479,
0.08806779235601425,
-0.4047452211380005,
0.1642507016658783,
-0.20663948357105255,
-0.26898565888404846,
-0.09792089462280273,
0.5269063115119934,
0.07034780085086823,
0.57649165391922,
0.45075035095214844,
0.6150972247123718,
-0.7746856808662415,
0.7168375253677368,
0.40025007724761963,
0.5478582382202148,
-0.3429701328277588,
-0.21124859154224396,
-0.006483723875135183,
0.2759614884853363,
-0.24568653106689453,
-0.5801770091056824,
0.30333489179611206,
0.37336063385009766,
0.6682317852973938,
0.5000855326652527,
0.11727587878704071,
0.38743025064468384,
-0.30832359194755554,
0.5694139003753662,
0.27141642570495605,
-0.7692483067512512,
0.48086339235305786,
-0.45208874344825745,
0.4133472740650177,
0.4778008460998535,
0.237816721200943,
-0.8122254014015198,
-0.32820799946784973,
-0.5599978566169739,
-0.6061622500419617,
0.8752254843711853,
0.5793864130973816,
-0.12876638770103455,
0.14135098457336426,
0.016769029200077057,
0.488884299993515,
0.18930411338806152,
-0.33077487349510193,
-0.27092573046684265,
0.025782737880945206,
-0.637421727180481,
0.009917506948113441,
-0.002778251888230443,
-0.3332342207431793,
0.1326196938753128,
0.41305166482925415,
-0.35317161679267883,
0.28551939129829407,
0.03033853881061077,
-0.09248699247837067,
0.44890111684799194,
0.5907478332519531,
0.5843591094017029,
0.3600543141365051,
-0.12474403530359268,
-0.06303011626005173,
-0.3804195523262024,
-0.7569248676300049,
0.1467314511537552,
0.05468495935201645,
-0.19176921248435974,
0.06677542626857758,
0.033828604966402054,
0.8467327356338501,
0.28165021538734436,
-0.7624817490577698,
0.5672227740287781,
-0.4401458203792572,
-0.1009271889925003,
-0.20779681205749512,
0.381935715675354,
-0.5757066011428833,
0.05549464747309685,
-0.03979262337088585,
0.5145885944366455,
0.7119465470314026,
-0.7652919292449951,
0.20388108491897583,
0.4006865620613098,
-0.490302175283432,
-0.31052058935165405,
0.23541639745235443,
0.40052375197410583,
-0.21323660016059875,
0.5613733530044556,
-0.43534862995147705,
-0.4094911813735962,
0.47060734033584595,
0.29783162474632263,
1.1227601766586304,
-0.11587011814117432,
0.05640733614563942,
0.03936106711626053,
-0.05542398989200592,
-0.09100184589624405,
0.5775089263916016,
-0.44230255484580994,
-1.103625774383545,
-0.47410327196121216,
-0.344725638628006,
-0.5984364151954651,
0.05026047304272652,
-0.479724258184433,
0.24331779778003693,
-0.10577482730150223,
-0.1959374099969864,
0.16476041078567505,
-0.4589257836341858,
-0.5724931359291077,
0.09401769191026688,
-0.010683482512831688,
0.38330209255218506,
-0.7440562844276428,
0.7422450184822083,
0.6352427005767822,
0.11067359894514084,
-0.3389163315296173,
0.23748378455638885,
0.3466218113899231,
-0.598495602607727,
0.1782299280166626,
0.22874857485294342,
-0.3383259177207947,
-0.08893835544586182,
-0.3524797558784485,
-0.59067702293396,
0.8314149975776672,
-0.06279905885457993,
-0.32658010721206665,
0.12120962142944336,
0.1627802699804306,
0.013335938565433025,
-0.5318853855133057,
0.2696639895439148,
0.864978551864624,
0.5343902111053467,
0.09300980716943741,
-0.9694949388504028,
-0.1354784071445465,
-0.12533684074878693,
-0.4243870973587036,
0.43728533387184143,
-0.42282918095588684,
0.7152256369590759,
-0.0871506929397583,
-0.46411949396133423,
-0.08486098796129227,
0.23900966346263885,
0.39433735609054565,
0.7059652805328369,
0.8237380385398865,
0.6657992005348206,
0.3698795735836029,
-0.45880013704299927,
0.7473101019859314,
-0.029762957245111465,
0.0074954405426979065,
1.194578766822815,
-0.4032781720161438,
0.521273672580719,
0.1961773782968521,
-0.13803638517856598,
0.4024636447429657,
0.4112057089805603,
0.3841129541397095,
0.5343378782272339,
-0.08788198232650757,
-0.5409640073776245,
-0.3628707230091095,
-0.2867230772972107,
0.11424051970243454,
0.8207939267158508,
0.8704777956008911,
0.23863673210144043,
-0.09666728973388672,
0.1996348351240158,
-0.06823361665010452,
-0.22796010971069336,
-0.010614755563437939,
1.098261833190918,
0.012638159096240997,
-0.8091952204704285,
0.16785278916358948,
-0.4251580238342285,
0.8248841762542725,
-0.662756085395813,
-0.2854316234588623,
-0.12321874499320984,
0.1943046897649765,
-0.09518718719482422,
-1.1580452919006348,
0.04119274765253067,
-0.38961565494537354,
-0.14033254981040955,
-0.14456140995025635,
0.6444526314735413,
-0.5971226096153259,
0.06632343679666519,
0.08970814943313599,
0.5839884877204895,
0.048604127019643784,
-0.3368900418281555,
-0.6880804300308228,
0.024340767413377762,
0.09063314646482468,
0.11244039237499237,
0.010133828036487103,
0.657298743724823,
-0.14052262902259827,
0.6530666947364807,
0.8567789793014526,
-0.13114701211452484,
0.30479156970977783,
0.44475752115249634,
0.6507471799850464,
-0.4610539376735687,
-0.5055277347564697,
-0.390267014503479,
0.43956273794174194,
-0.32935672998428345,
-0.6197472810745239,
0.7156842947006226,
0.725238561630249,
0.81825852394104,
-0.004448496736586094,
0.8625221848487854,
-0.04884985461831093,
0.36750227212905884,
-0.517475426197052,
0.02597171626985073,
-0.49093857407569885,
0.18364712595939636,
-0.07512382417917252,
-0.9460073113441467,
-0.22388231754302979,
0.21899083256721497,
0.015485289506614208,
0.10560525208711624,
0.4123952388763428,
0.5589267611503601,
-0.656086802482605,
0.38200560212135315,
0.2533029615879059,
-0.04110890254378319,
0.47776684165000916,
0.4671626091003418,
1.004276990890503,
-0.3604360818862915,
0.46517831087112427,
-0.03909609466791153,
-0.43059688806533813,
-0.36776575446128845,
-0.45840901136398315,
-0.4773896038532257,
-0.698853611946106,
-0.3203909695148468,
-0.02990761771798134,
-0.19370223581790924,
0.6276224851608276,
1.1026614904403687,
-0.8361855745315552,
-0.3478606939315796,
-0.1843910962343216,
0.1342514157295227,
-0.570543646812439,
-0.25369811058044434,
-0.008749397471547127,
-0.49157974123954773,
-0.8885191679000854,
0.5270400047302246,
0.5571043491363525,
0.21056345105171204,
0.1026119515299797,
-0.1148824617266655,
-0.20437093079090118,
0.2356254905462265,
0.9530206322669983,
0.12619648873806,
-0.6238808631896973,
-0.042589373886585236,
0.16713552176952362,
0.12180908769369125,
0.13162554800510406,
1.2172815799713135,
-0.5491236448287964,
0.7135518193244934,
0.6035414338111877,
0.3948611617088318,
0.47143465280532837,
-0.14471301436424255,
0.6711959838867188,
-0.9702420234680176,
0.04039132222533226,
0.4019063413143158,
0.4376758635044098,
0.12295804172754288,
-0.19985711574554443,
0.3715779185295105,
0.08758332580327988,
-0.534338116645813,
-0.5413803458213806,
0.5287333130836487,
-1.503398060798645,
-0.326901912689209,
0.9967350363731384,
0.02205100655555725,
0.025779498741030693,
-0.8186976313591003,
-0.5291758179664612,
-0.13949072360992432,
-0.6481109261512756,
0.2834528386592865,
0.6710753440856934,
-0.45261114835739136,
-0.04850960522890091,
-0.5320780277252197,
0.5845226645469666,
0.5006895065307617,
-0.871405303478241,
0.25131314992904663,
0.6425521373748779,
0.02759414352476597,
0.14805711805820465,
0.5827049016952515,
0.06809408962726593,
0.3616209924221039,
0.04405886307358742,
-0.156803697347641,
0.2924658954143524,
-0.5879880785942078,
0.10674604773521423,
-0.06140383332967758,
-0.177703395485878,
-0.5418967008590698
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18276v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18276v2
|
RankMamba: Benchmarking Mamba's Document Ranking Performance in the Era of Transformers
| 2024-03-27T06:07:05 | 2024-04-07T06:44:28 |
Zhichao Xu
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Transformer structure has achieved great success in multiple applied machine
learning communities, such as natural language processing (NLP), computer
vision (CV) and information retrieval (IR). Transformer architecture's core
mechanism -- attention requires $O(n^2)$ time complexity in training and $O(n)$
time complexity in inference. Many works have been proposed to improve the
attention mechanism's scalability, such as Flash Attention and Multi-query
Attention. A different line of work aims to design new mechanisms to replace
attention. Recently, a notable model structure -- Mamba, which is based on
state space models, has achieved transformer-equivalent performance in multiple
sequence modeling tasks.
In this work, we examine \mamba's efficacy through the lens of a classical IR
task -- document ranking. A reranker model takes a query and a document as
input, and predicts a scalar relevance score. This task demands the language
model's ability to comprehend lengthy contextual inputs and to capture the
interaction between query and document tokens. We find that (1) Mamba models
achieve competitive performance compared to transformer-based models with the
same training recipe; (2) but also have a lower training throughput in
comparison to efficient transformer implementations such as flash attention. We
hope this study can serve as a starting point to explore Mamba models in other
classical IR tasks. Our code implementation and trained checkpoints are made
public to facilitate reproducibility
(https://github.com/zhichaoxu-shufe/RankMamba).
|
[
-0.532004177570343,
-0.4049563705921173,
0.37349605560302734,
0.11619537323713303,
-0.07883225381374359,
0.1533372700214386,
-0.03484406694769859,
-0.08123386651277542,
0.3423830270767212,
0.44549497961997986,
-0.251196950674057,
-0.26470616459846497,
-1.0238507986068726,
0.0584898367524147,
-0.5464499592781067,
0.7255915999412537,
0.08568387478590012,
-0.17660701274871826,
-0.2709551453590393,
-0.37325018644332886,
-0.3673599362373352,
-0.521938145160675,
-0.5450882315635681,
-0.40883803367614746,
0.7929058074951172,
0.5088717937469482,
0.77388995885849,
0.4969158470630646,
0.9452147483825684,
0.2871497571468353,
-0.21463926136493683,
-0.03087712451815605,
-0.7662977576255798,
0.3027430772781372,
0.10783781856298447,
-0.5971037745475769,
-0.41771069169044495,
0.13174329698085785,
0.8761278986930847,
0.7524703741073608,
-0.14906758069992065,
0.2911927402019501,
0.04999135062098503,
0.8178789019584656,
-0.874825656414032,
0.27883240580558777,
-0.5204801559448242,
0.034052036702632904,
-0.23997122049331665,
-0.20283345878124237,
-0.8038970232009888,
-0.48512211441993713,
-0.18422211706638336,
-0.502220630645752,
0.13715119659900665,
0.1508285105228424,
1.138138771057129,
0.5266722440719604,
-0.4689059853553772,
-0.04804343357682228,
-0.5865892767906189,
0.654770016670227,
-0.31855300068855286,
0.4168824553489685,
0.41606616973876953,
0.9075038433074951,
0.011212246492505074,
-0.7230819463729858,
-0.3694092929363251,
-0.35971567034721375,
-0.06652441620826721,
0.41223886609077454,
-0.20782040059566498,
-0.3374168872833252,
0.42007651925086975,
0.6572995185852051,
-0.37437382340431213,
0.08710166811943054,
-0.32668906450271606,
0.07541461288928986,
0.22421656548976898,
0.07953396439552307,
-0.18503627181053162,
-0.33004647493362427,
-0.13719339668750763,
-0.49299857020378113,
-0.5011218786239624,
0.273945689201355,
0.3494894802570343,
0.04086760804057121,
0.3582456409931183,
0.6931219696998596,
-0.22535739839076996,
0.7385320067405701,
0.1260560154914856,
-0.214375838637352,
0.21011990308761597,
0.022928478196263313,
-0.21410883963108063,
-0.1267201155424118,
0.5508356690406799,
0.24684473872184753,
-0.09053807705640793,
-0.29691654443740845,
-0.14618496596813202,
-0.15089541673660278,
1.0091052055358887,
-0.8737276792526245,
-0.036338385194540024,
-0.09333197772502899,
-0.688079297542572,
-0.36777958273887634,
0.16500495374202728,
-0.907072126865387,
-0.34076374769210815,
-0.14089606702327728,
0.7026150226593018,
-0.40853890776634216,
-0.07473877817392349,
-0.23940543830394745,
0.07155313342809677,
0.43313437700271606,
0.05527244508266449,
-0.9224963784217834,
0.1925925463438034,
0.6870070099830627,
0.9862446784973145,
-0.18723085522651672,
-0.3038801848888397,
-0.505771815776825,
0.02619648538529873,
-0.4240667521953583,
0.9601387977600098,
-0.8807019591331482,
-0.6450100541114807,
-0.16516444087028503,
0.03491324558854103,
-0.3369467258453369,
-0.6630131006240845,
0.8398739099502563,
-0.6202977299690247,
-0.035980988293886185,
-0.12677602469921112,
-0.5474267601966858,
-0.212699294090271,
0.1906397044658661,
-0.7478423714637756,
1.3129585981369019,
0.21596881747245789,
-0.493648499250412,
0.4368335008621216,
-0.770841121673584,
-0.6216223239898682,
-0.23558197915554047,
0.19788557291030884,
-0.7482683658599854,
0.0005236614961177111,
0.24220651388168335,
0.5350122451782227,
-0.5185934901237488,
0.18306982517242432,
-0.11660154163837433,
-0.7091459631919861,
-0.0008489368483424187,
-0.08717264980077744,
0.26644858717918396,
0.2903767228126526,
-0.4505983889102936,
0.15031100809574127,
-0.9009298086166382,
-0.1916409432888031,
0.3306910991668701,
-0.4341062605381012,
-0.16862836480140686,
-0.02572137862443924,
-0.21542221307754517,
0.10894253104925156,
-0.048450905829668045,
-0.2519567608833313,
0.4980761706829071,
-0.2562696039676666,
0.29676303267478943,
0.4036574065685272,
-0.05490824580192566,
0.6039372086524963,
-0.2576393485069275,
0.6338952779769897,
0.009892378933727741,
0.38627418875694275,
-0.544708788394928,
-0.5715811848640442,
-1.10914945602417,
-0.14511093497276306,
0.5904794335365295,
0.22001376748085022,
-0.5745425820350647,
0.45343637466430664,
-0.6160961389541626,
-0.9770991206169128,
-0.8352857232093811,
-0.1772545725107193,
0.23890799283981323,
0.5594085454940796,
0.5500104427337646,
-0.34283676743507385,
-0.2213181108236313,
-1.1750726699829102,
-0.04198481887578964,
0.13892152905464172,
-0.286801278591156,
0.4883301258087158,
0.2852068841457367,
-0.2694903612136841,
0.7876462936401367,
-0.6543023586273193,
-0.4400082528591156,
-0.24739249050617218,
0.3440684974193573,
0.2822320759296417,
0.2453424334526062,
0.6354997754096985,
-0.8545591831207275,
-0.0768672302365303,
-0.32727450132369995,
-0.643266499042511,
-0.07211737334728241,
0.04880978912115097,
-0.17791883647441864,
0.0692414715886116,
0.46882903575897217,
-0.1768539398908615,
0.30992624163627625,
0.3210926949977875,
0.10009180754423141,
0.10851182043552399,
-0.1908804178237915,
0.5690966248512268,
-1.122491478919983,
0.42555564641952515,
-0.0387711301445961,
0.015430412255227566,
-0.4606413245201111,
0.17867667973041534,
0.3522793650627136,
-0.49553683400154114,
-0.14203910529613495,
0.18513703346252441,
-0.35838043689727783,
-0.5238320827484131,
-0.3796731233596802,
0.2543639838695526,
-0.03769097849726677,
0.7492980360984802,
-0.25455766916275024,
0.8660522103309631,
0.41753193736076355,
-0.6355365514755249,
-0.11674616485834122,
0.1397356241941452,
-0.4735525846481323,
0.5876584053039551,
-0.7052372097969055,
0.0787912905216217,
0.03914894163608551,
0.20778706669807434,
-1.2301105260849,
-0.011096522212028503,
0.0075942641124129295,
-0.459735244512558,
0.4786892831325531,
-0.3019222617149353,
-0.7092947363853455,
-0.5259597301483154,
-0.12295228242874146,
0.2819211781024933,
0.526257336139679,
-0.6211459636688232,
0.8091588020324707,
0.6115285754203796,
0.027539288625121117,
-0.6676996946334839,
-0.2376057505607605,
0.28066685795783997,
-0.033755719661712646,
-0.37618541717529297,
0.3391518294811249,
0.3000885844230652,
0.13181130588054657,
-0.4559860825538635,
-0.2932904362678528,
0.03335641324520111,
0.32288870215415955,
0.6871796250343323,
0.17554736137390137,
-0.09360988438129425,
-0.0285517405718565,
0.10805074125528336,
-0.5650442242622375,
-0.17851455509662628,
-0.026459218934178352,
0.5963152050971985,
-0.0266242828220129,
-0.381130188703537,
-0.04371735081076622,
0.09144502878189087,
0.841037929058075,
-0.48146480321884155,
0.9971736669540405,
0.4930429458618164,
-0.08674270659685135,
0.1892811506986618,
-0.7440563440322876,
-0.06823661923408508,
-0.40626004338264465,
-0.024849839508533478,
-0.524218738079071,
-0.6494770050048828,
0.5139479041099548,
-0.2799423038959503,
0.08608405292034149,
0.639729917049408,
0.5875282883644104,
0.06654410064220428,
0.9042447805404663,
0.6369389891624451,
-0.2832489311695099,
0.6924355030059814,
-0.42520973086357117,
0.22630861401557922,
-0.9433515071868896,
-0.4139305353164673,
-0.8336200714111328,
-0.671083927154541,
-0.44183433055877686,
-0.4528765380382538,
0.45883336663246155,
-0.09046956896781921,
0.02456166408956051,
0.6733509302139282,
-0.5379209518432617,
0.39539840817451477,
0.5994560718536377,
-0.02331322804093361,
0.18812447786331177,
-0.29626569151878357,
-0.39154529571533203,
-0.11189935356378555,
-0.7446473836898804,
-0.5126358866691589,
1.0496362447738647,
0.10641299933195114,
0.761687695980072,
0.06314350664615631,
0.48973438143730164,
0.2943514883518219,
0.35252442955970764,
-0.7798891067504883,
0.5863520503044128,
0.03425402566790581,
-0.26529058814048767,
-0.17658932507038116,
-0.3134133517742157,
-1.1281956434249878,
0.5504099726676941,
-0.1535428762435913,
-0.4074028432369232,
0.2217329442501068,
-0.24563860893249512,
0.0391838476061821,
0.1005270853638649,
-0.6371183395385742,
0.8998157978057861,
0.2369115948677063,
-0.1958184391260147,
-0.3523728847503662,
-0.7532550692558289,
0.25559327006340027,
-0.15516884624958038,
-0.10281828790903091,
-0.05659860372543335,
0.07896967977285385,
0.7550138235092163,
-0.31213098764419556,
0.43563029170036316,
-0.12236339598894119,
0.023294853046536446,
-0.16465488076210022,
-0.02920161932706833,
0.251857191324234,
-0.12483277916908264,
-0.3693449795246124,
0.2701483368873596,
-0.4416099786758423,
-0.40176934003829956,
-0.6199455261230469,
0.7127461433410645,
-0.6604651212692261,
-0.4841894805431366,
-0.2730764150619507,
-0.4026942253112793,
-0.12474139779806137,
0.33196479082107544,
0.2914506494998932,
0.4656951427459717,
-0.10017967969179153,
0.6582155823707581,
0.58865886926651,
-0.0378984659910202,
0.3350405991077423,
0.6455029845237732,
-0.21131865680217743,
-0.12496335059404373,
0.8580223321914673,
0.3684154748916626,
-0.02607210911810398,
0.7633285522460938,
-0.15507297217845917,
-0.18063557147979736,
-0.29955559968948364,
-0.35624486207962036,
-0.07443417608737946,
-0.8609937429428101,
-0.3371535837650299,
-0.8537473678588867,
-0.19453378021717072,
-0.29777875542640686,
-0.13643258810043335,
-0.5384913682937622,
-0.5684401988983154,
0.11907704174518585,
0.05263770744204521,
0.044321220368146896,
0.601561427116394,
0.3394921123981476,
0.1826062947511673,
-0.4402843713760376,
0.5908574461936951,
0.20298552513122559,
0.45492833852767944,
0.2840678095817566,
-0.769244372844696,
-0.38630402088165283,
-0.4840998649597168,
-0.5514048337936401,
-0.6635313034057617,
0.043595343828201294,
-0.05172378197312355,
0.9243003129959106,
0.3443988263607025,
0.032887473702430725,
0.5428885817527771,
-0.6217326521873474,
0.526665985584259,
-0.2706335783004761,
-0.8528664708137512,
0.8857199549674988,
-0.07909245789051056,
0.42104393243789673,
0.7130281329154968,
0.47950315475463867,
-0.29713600873947144,
-0.7929340600967407,
-0.5162511467933655,
-0.8728175759315491,
0.8152898550033569,
0.563410222530365,
-0.31362617015838623,
0.10622624307870865,
0.42840248346328735,
0.06044379249215126,
0.15197768807411194,
-0.42406120896339417,
-0.4645825922489166,
-0.5489148497581482,
0.02376377210021019,
-0.2209307849407196,
-0.3038058578968048,
0.13853245973587036,
-0.11552787572145462,
0.590326189994812,
-0.12621870636940002,
0.32217228412628174,
0.02807590179145336,
-0.477057546377182,
0.09396379441022873,
0.18822620809078217,
0.7215049266815186,
0.629021942615509,
-0.2519693076610565,
-0.028760718181729317,
-0.05385163426399231,
-0.516623318195343,
0.3014300465583801,
0.18108989298343658,
-0.2809546887874603,
0.060850728303194046,
0.08302921056747437,
0.7573594450950623,
0.9766160845756531,
-0.32582157850265503,
0.3350791335105896,
-0.24340029060840607,
0.03538975119590759,
0.10062418133020401,
0.36721473932266235,
0.06258480995893478,
0.1692230999469757,
0.7639167308807373,
0.22286014258861542,
0.2808779180049896,
-0.2845304310321808,
0.15620042383670807,
0.06343637406826019,
-0.3403337597846985,
0.13752466440200806,
0.9938824772834778,
0.1399206817150116,
-0.5256499648094177,
0.4376180171966553,
0.10414794832468033,
-0.3072291314601898,
0.8000087738037109,
0.1908104121685028,
0.6119707226753235,
-0.3070714473724365,
0.031175175681710243,
0.5178929567337036,
0.3408006727695465,
-0.1478322148323059,
-0.36173465847969055,
-0.38198864459991455,
-0.2939493954181671,
0.022194363176822662,
-0.7160528898239136,
-0.8310121893882751,
-0.31546223163604736,
-1.0511388778686523,
0.1694095879793167,
-0.2514873147010803,
-0.3280681371688843,
0.3244357705116272,
0.09741826355457306,
-0.3680291473865509,
0.12784633040428162,
-0.15022771060466766,
0.9081100821495056,
-0.35904771089553833,
1.0013426542282104,
0.4686567485332489,
-0.6202805042266846,
-0.46001389622688293,
0.22580786049365997,
-0.1450069695711136,
-0.6894446611404419,
0.6751857399940491,
0.6196447610855103,
-0.35316282510757446,
0.200611412525177,
0.026306070387363434,
-0.7721601128578186,
1.4134385585784912,
0.28904619812965393,
-0.5206130146980286,
0.2141416221857071,
-0.14191147685050964,
0.5402196645736694,
-0.22941742837429047,
0.4961257576942444,
0.48859289288520813,
0.5671338438987732,
0.16193100810050964,
-0.5413259863853455,
-0.1831219345331192,
-0.2987527847290039,
0.12488245218992233,
0.506740391254425,
-0.9214996099472046,
0.4762098491191864,
-0.13384240865707397,
-0.15963415801525116,
0.131405308842659,
0.7333840727806091,
0.15484501421451569,
0.15210668742656708,
0.49536341428756714,
0.5738421082496643,
0.7781368494033813,
-0.4610986113548279,
1.4389698505401611,
-0.37862175703048706,
0.45426979660987854,
0.6663945317268372,
-0.5302836894989014,
1.0195282697677612,
0.10839179158210754,
-0.1945856809616089,
0.45948630571365356,
0.5863714814186096,
-0.4681669771671295,
0.5781925320625305,
-0.10410857200622559,
0.2790972590446472,
-0.19590431451797485,
-0.05072245001792908,
-0.4222521483898163,
0.48083755373954773,
-0.09179194271564484,
-0.3480283319950104,
-0.06069980189204216,
0.1314132809638977,
-0.2038760930299759,
-0.041913531720638275,
-0.261653333902359,
0.8616107702255249,
-0.10165216028690338,
-0.8871782422065735,
0.5714706778526306,
0.02686307020485401,
0.49447283148765564,
-0.6118963360786438,
0.17901499569416046,
-0.5435027480125427,
0.291452556848526,
0.14791016280651093,
-0.6956305503845215,
0.22781944274902344,
-0.15559826791286469,
-0.50737065076828,
-0.20337539911270142,
0.5837051868438721,
-0.10244707018136978,
-0.6719213724136353,
0.34288594126701355,
0.18335779011249542,
0.09931208938360214,
-0.05465678498148918,
-0.5905250906944275,
0.11445412039756775,
-0.4375910758972168,
-0.3936232328414917,
0.6117680668830872,
0.04461255297064781,
0.21168100833892822,
0.8921255469322205,
0.4721945822238922,
-0.5278228521347046,
-0.020934412255883217,
0.5361364483833313,
0.8210659027099609,
-0.6580454707145691,
-0.5471940040588379,
-0.5843773484230042,
0.020647775381803513,
-0.20313619077205658,
-0.07850595563650131,
0.9099245071411133,
0.7246856093406677,
0.4265897870063782,
0.010515522211790085,
0.13195842504501343,
0.15320426225662231,
0.48803994059562683,
-0.5002845525741577,
1.0188428163528442,
-0.8071491718292236,
0.08423952758312225,
-0.23925814032554626,
-1.1322126388549805,
-0.27678290009498596,
0.6427136659622192,
-0.19323205947875977,
0.17169421911239624,
0.684440553188324,
0.6926631331443787,
-0.1075194925069809,
-0.10186295211315155,
0.49274179339408875,
0.14294090867042542,
0.2939983010292053,
0.5134751796722412,
0.5561494827270508,
-0.7156214118003845,
0.9784215092658997,
-0.06677410751581192,
-0.06523048132658005,
-0.7674828171730042,
-0.6046542525291443,
-0.8459150791168213,
-0.7584215998649597,
-0.049149345606565475,
-0.11250145733356476,
-0.03933475539088249,
0.28185734152793884,
0.8012217283248901,
-0.6656615138053894,
0.03696171194314957,
0.4894641041755676,
0.3339422941207886,
-0.4168093800544739,
-0.2253323495388031,
0.30309489369392395,
-0.33846139907836914,
-0.7972853779792786,
0.5353540182113647,
0.7371572852134705,
-0.1968405693769455,
-0.15805433690547943,
0.09164790064096451,
-0.302306205034256,
-0.05697595700621605,
0.6100602746009827,
0.10063127428293228,
-0.7147824764251709,
0.058045752346515656,
0.11545145511627197,
-0.355400949716568,
0.531743586063385,
1.0567865371704102,
-0.8464855551719666,
0.3978573679924011,
0.2990827262401581,
0.7465794682502747,
0.7647721767425537,
0.042856600135564804,
0.46024417877197266,
-0.62083899974823,
0.10354707390069962,
-0.033371035009622574,
0.6309518218040466,
0.3753896951675415,
-0.1243179589509964,
0.9028654098510742,
0.0438685305416584,
-0.7379082441329956,
-0.7754945158958435,
-0.16295066475868225,
-1.1080132722854614,
-0.11440476775169373,
0.7149724364280701,
-0.06803496927022934,
-0.17445392906665802,
0.09916277974843979,
-0.32858729362487793,
0.3991023302078247,
-0.48333171010017395,
1.0532362461090088,
0.6654859185218811,
0.1943383812904358,
-0.26397714018821716,
-0.5709728002548218,
0.03135426342487335,
0.5101313591003418,
-0.8416532278060913,
-0.14637362957000732,
0.0895431861281395,
-0.1004861518740654,
0.5286991000175476,
0.24658913910388947,
-0.1371142417192459,
0.35280105471611023,
0.08370810002088547,
-0.08059128373861313,
-0.23643659055233002,
-0.4861973226070404,
-0.40217018127441406,
0.6192854046821594,
-0.12574107944965363,
-0.13753852248191833
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18260v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18260v1
|
Toward Interactive Regional Understanding in Vision-Large Language Models
| 2024-03-27T05:22:06 | 2024-03-27T05:22:06 |
Jungbeom Lee, Sanghyuk Chun, Sangdoo Yun
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Recent Vision-Language Pre-training (VLP) models have demonstrated
significant advancements. Nevertheless, these models heavily rely on image-text
pairs that capture only coarse and global information of an image, leading to a
limitation in their regional understanding ability. In this work, we introduce
\textbf{RegionVLM}, equipped with explicit regional modeling capabilities,
allowing them to understand user-indicated image regions. To achieve this, we
design a simple yet innovative architecture, requiring no modifications to the
model architecture or objective function. Additionally, we leverage a dataset
that contains a novel source of information, namely Localized Narratives, which
has been overlooked in previous VLP research. Our experiments demonstrate that
our single generalist model not only achieves an interactive dialogue system
but also exhibits superior performance on various zero-shot region
understanding tasks, without compromising its ability for global image
understanding.
|
[
-0.5448734760284424,
-0.7994975447654724,
1.026296854019165,
-0.01697503589093685,
-0.5183085799217224,
-0.15573973953723907,
-0.31094303727149963,
-0.5385488271713257,
0.24717791378498077,
0.8644617795944214,
-0.4142124354839325,
-0.6502836346626282,
-0.31681618094444275,
-0.3167917728424072,
-0.2309676706790924,
0.6340238451957703,
-0.07838734239339828,
-0.043456900864839554,
-0.01123792678117752,
-0.2912456691265106,
-0.18650740385055542,
-0.6552324295043945,
-0.46331730484962463,
-0.21774077415466309,
0.4925309419631958,
0.19831141829490662,
0.7702414989471436,
0.6084359288215637,
0.5774515271186829,
0.3543134331703186,
-0.07619325071573257,
0.12644918262958527,
-0.33601516485214233,
-0.1470322161912918,
-0.16085359454154968,
-0.6400395631790161,
-0.6206644177436829,
-0.41081705689430237,
0.7240115404129028,
0.7825573086738586,
-0.14373593032360077,
-0.013084916397929192,
-0.18103687465190887,
0.3546155095100403,
-0.5958446264266968,
0.28430700302124023,
-0.8163127303123474,
0.37891072034835815,
-0.11861176043748856,
-0.20853069424629211,
-0.48706814646720886,
0.13928359746932983,
0.7409427762031555,
-0.857734739780426,
0.4742237627506256,
-0.013861983083188534,
1.0134837627410889,
0.21363545954227448,
-0.3292878270149231,
-0.12739942967891693,
-0.9260298013687134,
0.6043855547904968,
-0.3850472569465637,
0.2369934618473053,
0.22559402883052826,
0.4535508155822754,
0.07287170737981796,
-0.719590425491333,
-0.620985209941864,
0.008238354697823524,
-0.20043496787548065,
0.2770921289920807,
-0.5212318301200867,
0.2366003692150116,
-0.006529266946017742,
0.30456870794296265,
-0.5135437846183777,
0.2626703083515167,
-0.3182953894138336,
-0.05804324522614479,
0.1098228394985199,
0.3605925440788269,
0.4653366506099701,
-0.12402684986591339,
-0.550597071647644,
0.23803801834583282,
-0.5017719864845276,
0.2252092957496643,
-0.19165246188640594,
0.4366629719734192,
-0.450924813747406,
0.361176460981369,
-0.0773003026843071,
1.1556280851364136,
-0.06867873668670654,
-0.09567920118570328,
0.2181994915008545,
-0.37764906883239746,
-0.5591785311698914,
-0.29255348443984985,
0.604771614074707,
0.35504209995269775,
0.013271787203848362,
-0.15240320563316345,
-0.1413104236125946,
-0.17269745469093323,
0.2559509575366974,
-0.5516998767852783,
-0.2228218913078308,
0.07798006385564804,
-0.4317432940006256,
-0.06517674773931503,
-0.05538010597229004,
-0.6164922714233398,
-0.591597855091095,
-0.7044128179550171,
0.40799278020858765,
-0.20872850716114044,
-0.33433911204338074,
0.27499812841415405,
0.06676820665597916,
0.5211042761802673,
0.7736126780509949,
-0.7026515007019043,
0.10454884171485901,
0.2287290245294571,
0.8577263951301575,
-0.03400306776165962,
-0.4536485970020294,
-0.5895651578903198,
0.11611365526914597,
-0.37765198945999146,
0.905173122882843,
-0.6717692613601685,
-0.18329644203186035,
0.06995882093906403,
-0.12828946113586426,
0.10012761503458023,
-0.533584475517273,
-0.06237517669796944,
-0.4666394293308258,
0.3450348973274231,
-0.2715926468372345,
0.059788208454847336,
-0.4307537078857422,
0.1877610683441162,
-0.45860862731933594,
0.598816454410553,
-0.13426366448402405,
-0.6816975474357605,
0.48621243238449097,
-0.5911953449249268,
-0.13574828207492828,
0.38489586114883423,
-0.5076594352722168,
-0.053697798401117325,
0.40204551815986633,
0.7259736657142639,
0.359332799911499,
-0.1366497427225113,
0.42382925748825073,
-0.25271889567375183,
-0.45920631289482117,
0.08572071045637131,
-0.4648502767086029,
0.4194769263267517,
0.05518238991498947,
-0.20025251805782318,
0.3318559229373932,
-0.5334789752960205,
-0.16960899531841278,
0.18355269730091095,
-0.13699661195278168,
-0.3647547662258148,
-0.07880904525518417,
-0.28804412484169006,
-0.0027610037941485643,
0.3938608765602112,
-0.3501463830471039,
0.4140697717666626,
-0.143355593085289,
0.04331707954406738,
0.627741813659668,
-0.013357177376747131,
0.9099134802818298,
0.24696479737758636,
0.6614006757736206,
0.23354189097881317,
0.3076304793357849,
-0.5746158957481384,
-0.2417578548192978,
-1.21367347240448,
-0.5938373804092407,
0.09725285321474075,
0.6514149308204651,
-1.4991408586502075,
0.07982197403907776,
-0.28851041197776794,
-0.38488826155662537,
-0.675942599773407,
0.009345492348074913,
0.3949754238128662,
0.6151245832443237,
0.2842545807361603,
-0.6245642304420471,
-0.39455366134643555,
-0.9461212158203125,
0.29594188928604126,
-0.0682816132903099,
-0.22072270512580872,
0.6115458011627197,
0.22239461541175842,
0.17084334790706635,
1.2620930671691895,
-0.555942177772522,
-0.3670285940170288,
-0.7265815734863281,
0.021272342652082443,
0.4078318774700165,
0.03462795913219452,
0.7803277373313904,
-0.9525748491287231,
-0.4293299615383148,
0.3816394805908203,
-1.123509168624878,
0.0019711737986654043,
-0.21593160927295685,
-0.13771837949752808,
0.12800206243991852,
0.2901400029659271,
-0.3397824764251709,
0.8598779439926147,
0.6154135465621948,
-0.44793424010276794,
0.3416016399860382,
-0.6298162937164307,
0.20528864860534668,
-0.8351762890815735,
-0.0009553381823934615,
0.4690665304660797,
-0.27522042393684387,
-0.9501492381095886,
0.20567429065704346,
-0.13452842831611633,
-0.3400098979473114,
-0.690996527671814,
0.7005164623260498,
-0.5341305732727051,
-0.42373916506767273,
-0.22341901063919067,
0.3586396872997284,
0.0029498073272407055,
0.7123395800590515,
0.7691161632537842,
0.5847644209861755,
0.9574344158172607,
-0.44640716910362244,
0.17363320291042328,
0.24137088656425476,
-0.7379305958747864,
0.4639319181442261,
-0.6467498540878296,
0.07266934216022491,
-0.4774898290634155,
0.38974079489707947,
-0.6618939638137817,
-0.3371228277683258,
0.20324739813804626,
-0.2716248333454132,
0.09526239335536957,
-0.6791626214981079,
-0.2842708230018616,
-0.15416045486927032,
0.2631867229938507,
0.32106813788414,
0.6485827565193176,
-0.6818800568580627,
1.0241549015045166,
0.33313605189323425,
-0.3112293779850006,
-0.5023318529129028,
-0.6664688587188721,
0.19025442004203796,
-0.3310132622718811,
-0.57745361328125,
-0.04667947068810463,
0.23468539118766785,
-0.3259076774120331,
0.02268136851489544,
0.2898496091365814,
-0.46568140387535095,
-0.14221647381782532,
0.1324421912431717,
0.4554566740989685,
-0.38713356852531433,
0.07716457545757294,
-0.2741701602935791,
-0.11157450079917908,
-0.4070311486721039,
-0.2790173888206482,
0.6578091382980347,
-0.42142781615257263,
-0.3808988928794861,
-0.6350314021110535,
0.4300130009651184,
0.6043543815612793,
-0.828843355178833,
0.7268167734146118,
0.5739154815673828,
-0.17344647645950317,
-0.1678084284067154,
-0.27537354826927185,
0.07710354030132294,
-0.48641857504844666,
0.6168093681335449,
-0.46088501811027527,
-0.9341560006141663,
0.6401417255401611,
0.019404558464884758,
0.0060761733911931515,
-0.11814585328102112,
0.5563962459564209,
-0.18180757761001587,
0.7996628284454346,
0.872529149055481,
0.22564417123794556,
0.7212302088737488,
-0.15367141366004944,
0.4131494164466858,
-0.6299593448638916,
-0.2923934757709503,
-0.2506990432739258,
-0.017247522249817848,
0.005637580994516611,
-0.8586605191230774,
0.6191011667251587,
0.037831563502550125,
-0.2533188462257385,
-0.049673303961753845,
-0.14764103293418884,
0.7552882432937622,
0.5027156472206116,
0.16788245737552643,
0.25380924344062805,
0.32096564769744873,
-0.06654667109251022,
-0.4158829152584076,
-0.8368103504180908,
-0.4474223554134369,
0.5986998081207275,
0.4790157079696655,
0.9125888347625732,
0.20370616018772125,
0.4579465687274933,
0.09459511935710907,
0.011853652074933052,
-0.687202513217926,
0.678849995136261,
-0.4224890470504761,
-0.264304518699646,
-0.14683207869529724,
-0.2703622579574585,
-0.7961505055427551,
0.7380700707435608,
-0.31454747915267944,
-1.1497970819473267,
0.2627602219581604,
0.4472532868385315,
-0.5114909410476685,
0.6740791201591492,
-0.7806159257888794,
0.7159807085990906,
-0.2712918817996979,
-0.1143597811460495,
0.059455931186676025,
-0.4794706106185913,
0.2966160774230957,
0.049519408494234085,
0.2935224175453186,
0.12279094755649567,
0.11134905368089676,
0.05807871371507645,
-0.120720274746418,
1.2139415740966797,
-0.514599084854126,
0.04203358292579651,
0.29124969244003296,
0.30432334542274475,
-0.040270302444696426,
-0.1973194181919098,
0.27930697798728943,
0.2643522322177887,
-0.4829855263233185,
-0.5079004764556885,
-0.7821727395057678,
0.3489030599594116,
-0.6565101146697998,
-0.5518510937690735,
-0.20880229771137238,
-0.5109706521034241,
-0.11050909012556076,
0.11303938925266266,
0.10332740843296051,
1.0912903547286987,
0.04929158091545105,
0.07636801153421402,
0.9187217950820923,
-0.6932861804962158,
0.1932835429906845,
0.8216943144798279,
-0.7510479688644409,
-0.21376356482505798,
0.9212096929550171,
-0.20147420465946198,
0.432381808757782,
0.43565163016319275,
-0.11365810036659241,
-0.20308010280132294,
-0.6315466165542603,
-0.4320124387741089,
0.10596034675836563,
-0.9988641142845154,
0.1889163702726364,
-0.4453456997871399,
-0.0848444327712059,
-0.0005001457175239921,
-0.48311254382133484,
-0.3538314700126648,
0.1619136780500412,
-0.2149488776922226,
-0.03433871641755104,
-0.10046232491731644,
1.025987982749939,
-0.09927208721637726,
0.504453718662262,
-0.7805184721946716,
0.4504268765449524,
0.34302306175231934,
0.1668761670589447,
0.29394540190696716,
-0.6000274419784546,
-0.25592541694641113,
-0.2185957431793213,
0.1831248253583908,
-0.553773820400238,
0.40122976899147034,
0.09526140987873077,
0.6118061542510986,
0.41542476415634155,
-0.10645363479852676,
0.9253104329109192,
-0.6148859262466431,
1.0922846794128418,
0.26146644353866577,
-0.9347834587097168,
0.7351532578468323,
-0.37819772958755493,
0.8668021559715271,
0.3653925359249115,
0.17965130507946014,
-0.517792820930481,
-0.4211350679397583,
-0.26334619522094727,
-0.8976012468338013,
0.5768617391586304,
-0.11522239446640015,
0.24226151406764984,
0.21927835047245026,
0.34703803062438965,
0.13105863332748413,
0.005538474302738905,
-0.9505327939987183,
-0.07816730439662933,
-0.010654101148247719,
-0.2268819808959961,
0.076612688601017,
-0.17482022941112518,
-0.039648815989494324,
-0.34935736656188965,
0.24758917093276978,
-0.2630522847175598,
0.29945725202560425,
0.49519550800323486,
-0.25311341881752014,
0.23689091205596924,
0.17874941229820251,
0.4231857657432556,
0.8505576848983765,
-0.0340462364256382,
0.16542808711528778,
0.12232185900211334,
-0.32294970750808716,
-0.15084770321846008,
-0.216995507478714,
-0.2862086296081543,
-0.029598305001854897,
0.7345557808876038,
1.3059369325637817,
0.16134370863437653,
-0.5055066347122192,
0.5498476624488831,
-0.5598346590995789,
-0.09216190874576569,
-0.2613685429096222,
-0.01922803558409214,
-0.13069479167461395,
0.5152286887168884,
0.45906001329421997,
0.15936590731143951,
-0.0449233204126358,
-0.5299831628799438,
-0.028864186257123947,
0.1682061403989792,
-0.8419153094291687,
-0.3692180812358856,
0.4006109833717346,
0.4207497537136078,
-0.11752248555421829,
0.7825602889060974,
-0.22666601836681366,
-0.7972781658172607,
0.5526310801506042,
0.33019447326660156,
0.502998948097229,
0.2503681480884552,
0.5414793491363525,
0.19921742379665375,
0.3022456765174866,
0.41990798711776733,
0.30650854110717773,
-0.165252685546875,
-0.8654508590698242,
-0.6868136525154114,
-0.6745215058326721,
-0.5765743851661682,
0.15891200304031372,
-0.807141900062561,
0.07549793273210526,
-0.3078671395778656,
0.06177970767021179,
-0.16083091497421265,
-0.40066999197006226,
-0.9746358394622803,
0.22231487929821014,
0.529292643070221,
0.909878671169281,
-0.8788901567459106,
0.9515445828437805,
0.8555529117584229,
-0.10771369189023972,
-0.5467699766159058,
0.1526387333869934,
-0.06667395681142807,
-0.9036825299263,
0.5967003107070923,
0.19684135913848877,
-0.14446888864040375,
-0.2277722805738449,
-0.7004896998405457,
-0.5658713579177856,
1.0614262819290161,
0.3722294867038727,
-0.4163024127483368,
0.005469406023621559,
0.0036053326912224293,
0.6462758779525757,
-0.5935198068618774,
0.13471387326717377,
0.4764458239078522,
0.09072735160589218,
0.2981623709201813,
-1.1542079448699951,
-0.4438099265098572,
-0.12665629386901855,
0.17265643179416656,
0.22165943682193756,
-0.4089568555355072,
0.7148847579956055,
-0.4541417360305786,
-0.19224901497364044,
0.11446290463209152,
0.8146788477897644,
0.0864468663930893,
0.19182933866977692,
0.5975696444511414,
0.3969201147556305,
0.7247788310050964,
-0.2084040492773056,
1.301291584968567,
0.10169903934001923,
0.29831886291503906,
1.5643280744552612,
-0.257224440574646,
0.9361521005630493,
0.31208088994026184,
0.05203869938850403,
0.3315776586532593,
0.5320827960968018,
0.1911814659833908,
0.7957639694213867,
-0.12013690918684006,
-0.6308150887489319,
-0.8457260727882385,
-0.4601964056491852,
-0.02342510037124157,
0.883326530456543,
0.39836442470550537,
-0.20277534425258636,
-0.4151849150657654,
0.13876941800117493,
-0.23123739659786224,
0.1294597089290619,
-0.7444827556610107,
0.8549145460128784,
-0.04961121827363968,
-0.36887863278388977,
0.1371258944272995,
-0.35936295986175537,
0.5561379790306091,
-0.8281150460243225,
-0.13058680295944214,
-0.22862693667411804,
0.1287560909986496,
0.0654185488820076,
-1.0927789211273193,
0.032969482243061066,
0.17998936772346497,
-0.17597360908985138,
-0.06074243038892746,
0.6602364778518677,
-0.6545949578285217,
-0.372218519449234,
0.22276081144809723,
0.6080875992774963,
0.2626194953918457,
0.11467316746711731,
-0.46183720231056213,
0.21991926431655884,
0.3480096459388733,
0.01339347567409277,
0.2581193745136261,
0.5060045123100281,
-0.00967583991587162,
0.6843357682228088,
0.40577638149261475,
0.08302110433578491,
-0.1273593157529831,
0.16502662003040314,
0.6156620383262634,
-0.5827115178108215,
-0.6618485450744629,
-0.6546515822410583,
0.7514458298683167,
-0.20337773859500885,
-0.2554801106452942,
0.26312345266342163,
-0.0019288993207737803,
0.7867299318313599,
-0.014878220856189728,
1.0247448682785034,
-0.02650609239935875,
0.18264368176460266,
-0.8093690276145935,
0.6640516519546509,
-0.7038478255271912,
-0.0389481745660305,
-0.0017802978400141,
-0.7792826890945435,
-0.5596425533294678,
0.6724770069122314,
-0.5821080207824707,
-0.2942970395088196,
0.3588877022266388,
0.45485788583755493,
-0.2977600395679474,
-0.2665884792804718,
0.6647554636001587,
0.35940682888031006,
0.4919935464859009,
0.5180988907814026,
0.8234290480613708,
0.18617725372314453,
0.3818490505218506,
-0.17941217124462128,
-0.4223308861255646,
0.16899213194847107,
-0.9346981644630432,
-1.0938173532485962,
-0.6638010144233704,
-0.0123901953920722,
0.037332918494939804,
-0.21371696889400482,
0.6370172500610352,
0.7532234191894531,
-0.43105730414390564,
-0.08088240027427673,
0.34049901366233826,
-0.18621407449245453,
0.5302712917327881,
-0.18713058531284332,
0.26432424783706665,
-0.06744299829006195,
-0.6919831037521362,
0.4403649568557739,
0.6785236597061157,
0.2667970061302185,
-0.40360715985298157,
0.0006967370864003897,
0.2655055820941925,
0.01636756770312786,
0.6284359693527222,
0.31222009658813477,
-0.9969249367713928,
-0.32198044657707214,
-0.22812709212303162,
0.08342213183641434,
0.22512082755565643,
0.757935643196106,
-0.8501567244529724,
1.032798171043396,
0.043271973729133606,
0.45379748940467834,
0.48790547251701355,
0.028289593756198883,
0.891411542892456,
-0.6860593557357788,
0.6819756031036377,
0.018755177035927773,
0.673775851726532,
0.5295388102531433,
-0.14985086023807526,
0.30216261744499207,
-0.14260366559028625,
-0.35216063261032104,
-0.49811071157455444,
0.5039548873901367,
-0.9905327558517456,
-0.28801876306533813,
0.8817493915557861,
-0.6334204077720642,
-0.36433669924736023,
-0.09805984050035477,
-0.5958009958267212,
-0.2476223111152649,
-0.12725043296813965,
0.35989847779273987,
0.580420732498169,
-0.12681972980499268,
-0.42490166425704956,
-0.5941871404647827,
0.020174842327833176,
0.13167712092399597,
-0.8118671774864197,
-0.09693065285682678,
0.6510623097419739,
0.11175388842821121,
0.11242134124040604,
0.8976891040802002,
0.14754287898540497,
0.29075726866722107,
-0.06580988317728043,
0.2229064404964447,
0.10677558928728104,
-0.6818439960479736,
-0.6197109222412109,
0.09878595173358917,
0.11458688229322433,
-0.10924702137708664
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18253v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18253v2
|
Enhancing Metaphor Detection through Soft Labels and Target Word Prediction
| 2024-03-27T04:51:42 | 2024-04-09T03:47:29 |
Kaidi Jia, Rongsheng Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Metaphors play a significant role in our everyday communication, yet
detecting them presents a challenge. Traditional methods often struggle with
improper application of language rules and a tendency to overlook data
sparsity. To address these issues, we integrate knowledge distillation and
prompt learning into metaphor detection. Our approach revolves around a
tailored prompt learning framework specifically designed for metaphor
detection. By strategically masking target words and providing relevant prompt
data, we guide the model to accurately predict the contextual meanings of these
words. This approach not only mitigates confusion stemming from the literal
meanings of the words but also ensures effective application of language rules
for metaphor detection. Furthermore, we've introduced a teacher model to
generate valuable soft labels. These soft labels provide a similar effect to
label smoothing and help prevent the model from becoming over confident and
effectively addresses the challenge of data sparsity. Experimental results
demonstrate that our model has achieved state-of-the-art performance, as
evidenced by its remarkable results across various datasets.
|
[
-0.44063520431518555,
-0.7547130584716797,
0.5099076628684998,
0.004739266820251942,
-0.7112895846366882,
-0.0038332671392709017,
-0.05910835415124893,
-0.27850526571273804,
0.17140738666057587,
0.26119160652160645,
-0.6093554496765137,
-0.3677961826324463,
-0.9667408466339111,
0.23613181710243225,
-0.2492516189813614,
1.0854122638702393,
0.24272441864013672,
0.021743586286902428,
-0.13579174876213074,
-0.17844215035438538,
-1.121960163116455,
-0.2077089548110962,
-0.6533033847808838,
-0.49735507369041443,
0.7225722670555115,
0.4530155658721924,
0.7657161355018616,
0.8573898077011108,
0.032527774572372437,
0.4014674425125122,
-0.25732263922691345,
0.1084853932261467,
-0.3253346085548401,
0.5525884628295898,
-0.29859650135040283,
-0.5777402520179749,
0.004342163447290659,
0.3507077693939209,
0.5172483325004578,
0.8045324087142944,
-0.17995209991931915,
-0.02923152595758438,
0.11674146354198456,
0.396625280380249,
-0.5803139805793762,
0.33366861939430237,
-0.9903692603111267,
0.24157828092575073,
-0.21441102027893066,
-0.20613496005535126,
-0.2960266172885895,
-0.093776173889637,
0.1256307065486908,
-0.6460968852043152,
0.16200895607471466,
0.2864181399345398,
0.663008451461792,
0.3421931266784668,
-0.4037702977657318,
-0.21625325083732605,
-0.3886082172393799,
0.884926438331604,
-0.23652975261211395,
0.26981785893440247,
0.23431842029094696,
0.6820282340049744,
-0.3840150535106659,
-1.0121911764144897,
-0.7174177765846252,
-0.24496982991695404,
0.005066735669970512,
0.0705440565943718,
-0.2805645167827606,
-0.032907236367464066,
0.3458239436149597,
0.15281963348388672,
-0.2965661883354187,
0.00917069986462593,
-0.34981462359428406,
-0.37789246439933777,
0.06453980505466461,
0.30311518907546997,
0.26947474479675293,
-0.1824619174003601,
-0.7391895651817322,
-0.27468541264533997,
-0.3255867660045624,
-0.18332155048847198,
0.16414335370063782,
0.4928460419178009,
0.15150868892669678,
0.05527601018548012,
0.17201834917068481,
0.7670419216156006,
-0.08439701050519943,
-0.32996171712875366,
0.23214785754680634,
0.11086789518594742,
-0.019830087199807167,
0.4266313314437866,
0.4239448606967926,
0.20197941362857819,
0.4523938298225403,
-0.32875004410743713,
-0.46356257796287537,
0.5157614946365356,
0.11452775448560715,
-0.6963303685188293,
-0.3021806478500366,
-0.16383957862854004,
-0.0372026190161705,
-0.38069790601730347,
-0.055935658514499664,
-0.6627162098884583,
-0.8160035610198975,
-0.5927898287773132,
0.5783033967018127,
-0.5545600652694702,
-0.22273243963718414,
0.3141824007034302,
-0.7106331586837769,
-0.23647412657737732,
0.3753798007965088,
-0.5494738221168518,
0.17049166560173035,
0.643937349319458,
0.7786340117454529,
0.05881575867533684,
-0.28556516766548157,
-0.8878675103187561,
0.2801387906074524,
-0.2490309178829193,
0.8723229765892029,
-0.6718259453773499,
-0.2185174971818924,
-0.04168195277452469,
-0.08884257823228836,
-0.004522675648331642,
-0.5289919972419739,
0.664049506187439,
-0.15575642883777618,
0.445570170879364,
-0.13268589973449707,
-0.666002094745636,
-0.2467573583126068,
0.5434393882751465,
-0.7280892133712769,
1.0178468227386475,
0.24488095939159393,
-0.7989572882652283,
0.5178552269935608,
-0.2500286102294922,
-0.2624766528606415,
0.3947661817073822,
-0.23383556306362152,
-0.1603166162967682,
0.26655927300453186,
0.15962940454483032,
0.6122391223907471,
-0.5453407764434814,
0.6415359973907471,
-0.09610315412282944,
-0.6112712025642395,
0.5842373371124268,
-0.5449868440628052,
0.5634652972221375,
0.3096013069152832,
-0.4166121482849121,
0.045465338975191116,
-0.4873410761356354,
-0.14963136613368988,
0.21178185939788818,
0.18713337182998657,
-0.7886820435523987,
-0.3044876754283905,
0.17294974625110626,
0.2970573306083679,
-0.12156780064105988,
-0.21160949766635895,
0.19011689722537994,
-0.27077391743659973,
0.2693875730037689,
0.8788362145423889,
-0.2357495278120041,
0.3627178966999054,
-0.39421555399894714,
0.7387457489967346,
0.4665999710559845,
0.16297362744808197,
-0.4530540108680725,
-0.48560237884521484,
-0.46880683302879333,
-0.6128685474395752,
0.5630180835723877,
0.3976135551929474,
-1.13021719455719,
0.46893081068992615,
-0.3331262767314911,
-0.43634313344955444,
-0.4920359253883362,
0.20659886300563812,
0.26264503598213196,
1.1299575567245483,
0.5453552603721619,
-0.43439096212387085,
-0.39791110157966614,
-0.7790283560752869,
-0.49558553099632263,
0.0229538194835186,
-0.3051181435585022,
0.08770864456892014,
0.49210748076438904,
-0.08294101059436798,
1.103432536125183,
-0.7590712904930115,
-0.6987716555595398,
-0.39694324135780334,
0.37716975808143616,
0.1936270147562027,
0.34701332449913025,
0.747317373752594,
-1.1472280025482178,
-0.3764435648918152,
-0.6614369750022888,
-0.5514028072357178,
-0.24224570393562317,
-0.0444214791059494,
-0.053216006606817245,
-0.36906182765960693,
0.4800991415977478,
-0.42859312891960144,
0.24798069894313812,
-0.05036170780658722,
-0.6292937397956848,
0.39207953214645386,
0.15880602598190308,
0.010707947425544262,
-1.168102741241455,
-0.20476889610290527,
0.3191819489002228,
-0.23624452948570251,
-0.7084587812423706,
-0.217554971575737,
-0.08213791996240616,
0.04069199413061142,
-0.6660544276237488,
0.8186538219451904,
-0.28196439146995544,
0.3764764964580536,
-0.44337642192840576,
0.11946070194244385,
0.4180465042591095,
0.18005520105361938,
0.27610039710998535,
0.6972129940986633,
0.7254263162612915,
-0.5695714950561523,
0.41842249035835266,
0.10075201094150543,
-0.413245290517807,
0.7249066233634949,
-0.5804330110549927,
0.011842610314488411,
-0.507444441318512,
0.5814111828804016,
-1.1619371175765991,
-0.0805516391992569,
0.5961013436317444,
-0.3715060353279114,
0.3568436801433563,
-0.12090958654880524,
-0.7011582851409912,
-0.29753488302230835,
-0.37134459614753723,
0.36618152260780334,
0.6911053657531738,
-0.6704456806182861,
0.5092376470565796,
0.3375243842601776,
0.2598833739757538,
-0.48650720715522766,
-0.6223546862602234,
0.14829544723033905,
-0.7637968063354492,
-0.17440566420555115,
0.28347355127334595,
0.08081552386283875,
-0.012234699912369251,
-0.1377732902765274,
-0.08063332736492157,
-0.3207489848136902,
0.232557013630867,
0.2564927935600281,
0.3374389410018921,
0.09266939014196396,
0.33899861574172974,
0.07909800112247467,
-0.3413401246070862,
0.11367731541395187,
-0.4292633831501007,
0.34823077917099,
0.060422834008932114,
0.08639460057020187,
-0.2893912196159363,
0.11238782107830048,
0.73198002576828,
0.12442921102046967,
1.0292397737503052,
1.0477255582809448,
-0.6387487649917603,
-0.30350178480148315,
-0.552811861038208,
-0.6358088254928589,
-0.5685084462165833,
-0.051785096526145935,
-0.26473987102508545,
-0.5393633246421814,
0.31493911147117615,
-0.42234063148498535,
-0.38818609714508057,
-0.04056582599878311,
-0.011313042603433132,
0.0763486847281456,
0.8619731068611145,
0.5743312239646912,
-0.1562168151140213,
0.6100755333900452,
-0.026313740760087967,
0.09858057647943497,
-0.5270757675170898,
-0.33211877942085266,
-0.455005019903183,
-0.409732848405838,
-0.21868042647838593,
-0.48288533091545105,
0.5517185926437378,
0.026440871879458427,
-0.17487424612045288,
0.21918463706970215,
-0.8252627849578857,
0.4585730731487274,
0.5913020372390747,
0.2221815437078476,
0.1661190688610077,
0.2267061471939087,
-0.16253136098384857,
-0.4705379605293274,
-0.7951511144638062,
-0.518184244632721,
0.5202187299728394,
0.3979882001876831,
0.6094372272491455,
-0.2857128977775574,
0.5803139805793762,
0.41896727681159973,
0.36018070578575134,
-0.9091079235076904,
0.7082690596580505,
0.09431810677051544,
-0.4635155200958252,
0.009844595566391945,
-0.3374931514263153,
-1.0660009384155273,
0.337470144033432,
-0.22432255744934082,
-0.6035266518592834,
-0.14103879034519196,
0.16125237941741943,
-0.0743061900138855,
0.11262428015470505,
-0.686651885509491,
0.8480554819107056,
0.003699517110362649,
-0.3918554186820984,
0.10668908804655075,
-0.6809197664260864,
0.3124065399169922,
-0.03222789242863655,
0.30756518244743347,
-0.25655075907707214,
-0.23199833929538727,
0.7746511101722717,
-0.1292349249124527,
1.0804264545440674,
-0.3057478666305542,
0.03710758686065674,
0.5760639309883118,
-0.003381668357178569,
0.2906872630119324,
-0.21184110641479492,
-0.026027701795101166,
0.10422996431589127,
-0.18188227713108063,
-0.3039078414440155,
-0.6433833241462708,
0.4377257525920868,
-0.26317518949508667,
-0.498706191778183,
-0.6917322278022766,
-0.7512108087539673,
-0.14505034685134888,
0.0509219728410244,
0.2128215730190277,
0.30146095156669617,
0.1274661421775818,
0.0173431858420372,
0.6785154938697815,
-0.12003207206726074,
0.058280088007450104,
0.5033389329910278,
0.09271105378866196,
-0.23636439442634583,
0.9674670696258545,
0.22436107695102692,
-0.3155542016029358,
0.028899971395730972,
0.608869194984436,
-0.7108286619186401,
-0.06305946409702301,
-0.2753549814224243,
0.014186421409249306,
-0.7866683006286621,
-0.5368227362632751,
-0.4591675400733948,
0.012275568209588528,
-0.39465194940567017,
-0.14427027106285095,
-0.06617866456508636,
-0.2247653305530548,
-0.42507848143577576,
-0.06705207377672195,
0.8014772534370422,
0.3338444232940674,
0.010726984590291977,
0.49473515152931213,
-0.7265068888664246,
0.4152528643608093,
0.23964720964431763,
0.09017524123191833,
-0.125666543841362,
-0.8444158434867859,
0.27629759907722473,
-0.024911660701036453,
-0.39664849638938904,
-1.122045874595642,
0.531548023223877,
0.29679298400878906,
0.28649628162384033,
0.5560885667800903,
0.2507096529006958,
0.6545326113700867,
-0.5325736999511719,
0.7082300186157227,
0.5465055108070374,
-1.0248734951019287,
0.849626898765564,
-0.3000638782978058,
0.2960560619831085,
0.493495911359787,
0.5066277384757996,
-0.5982509255409241,
-0.3226206302642822,
-0.693661630153656,
-0.9146818518638611,
0.4699861705303192,
0.0013227977324277163,
0.5035016536712646,
-0.1319224238395691,
0.40041384100914,
0.40345707535743713,
0.5889820456504822,
-0.662916362285614,
-0.23779921233654022,
-0.22327734529972076,
-0.40264782309532166,
-0.04735983535647392,
-0.22402991354465485,
-0.0649392157793045,
-0.5271680355072021,
0.47257229685783386,
-0.19909411668777466,
-0.050067417323589325,
-0.21486793458461761,
0.034223731607198715,
0.09103425592184067,
0.29719847440719604,
0.009743306785821915,
0.32255202531814575,
0.2096879482269287,
0.4186810851097107,
0.18548086285591125,
-0.5613153576850891,
0.1280560940504074,
0.10984731465578079,
-0.13432243466377258,
0.30922946333885193,
0.27031657099723816,
0.7643011808395386,
0.4418065845966339,
-0.8138001561164856,
0.5254336595535278,
0.01476365327835083,
0.07789051532745361,
-0.178618386387825,
0.37049373984336853,
-0.10720538347959518,
0.16610534489154816,
0.4809260070323944,
-0.20212414860725403,
0.46046286821365356,
-0.49273020029067993,
0.3159564435482025,
0.29386189579963684,
-0.4388267993927002,
-0.1486881822347641,
0.6545509099960327,
-0.036846183240413666,
0.01135010551661253,
0.6179788112640381,
-0.10841541737318039,
-0.8774574398994446,
0.8260049819946289,
0.7536245584487915,
0.6144075393676758,
-0.48307424783706665,
0.4082367718219757,
0.20894649624824524,
0.1058531180024147,
-0.2549073100090027,
0.14435091614723206,
-0.13825346529483795,
-0.6768345236778259,
0.10235026478767395,
-0.525728702545166,
-0.3602011501789093,
0.4441465139389038,
-0.7958922982215881,
0.48026394844055176,
-0.262342631816864,
-0.25841715931892395,
0.05479448288679123,
-0.10571198910474777,
-0.81145179271698,
0.4389461874961853,
0.3540475070476532,
1.1266248226165771,
-1.3728063106536865,
0.7412415742874146,
0.9145911335945129,
-0.30963078141212463,
-0.9814832806587219,
-0.027288809418678284,
0.035119861364364624,
-0.5675020813941956,
0.6444563865661621,
0.8692975640296936,
-0.08433946222066879,
-0.0053724986501038074,
-0.6860457062721252,
-0.2657487690448761,
1.1017123460769653,
0.740507960319519,
-0.39728984236717224,
0.2975301146507263,
0.1064889132976532,
0.4568454325199127,
-0.24648818373680115,
0.24952735006809235,
0.6458995938301086,
0.6828555464744568,
0.457719087600708,
-0.539642333984375,
0.14808563888072968,
0.012919915840029716,
0.006999640259891748,
-0.033879492431879044,
-0.26928451657295227,
0.712009072303772,
0.08155566453933716,
-0.21735255420207977,
-0.2470967322587967,
0.82879239320755,
0.5169630646705627,
0.812501847743988,
0.8855802416801453,
0.21946266293525696,
0.8083666563034058,
-0.24004708230495453,
0.6551030874252319,
-0.19183604419231415,
0.029402581974864006,
1.0502232313156128,
-0.16078510880470276,
0.2718144953250885,
0.7989172339439392,
0.21477265655994415,
0.44755998253822327,
0.7038971185684204,
-0.07386525720357895,
0.6423690915107727,
0.37618204951286316,
-0.5302314162254333,
-0.3883707821369171,
-0.9700577855110168,
-0.38548600673675537,
0.37648025155067444,
0.6385435461997986,
-0.341318815946579,
-0.36505067348480225,
0.3110349774360657,
0.022045500576496124,
0.43503427505493164,
-0.42674896121025085,
0.3962787687778473,
0.2539096176624298,
-0.6823523640632629,
0.5622491240501404,
-0.10689720511436462,
0.7953124642372131,
-0.6163103580474854,
-0.3331686854362488,
-0.037287984043359756,
0.12101670354604721,
0.14753231406211853,
-0.6699879169464111,
0.012373925186693668,
-0.15051165223121643,
0.1502447873353958,
-0.2601401209831238,
1.1216137409210205,
-0.7400825023651123,
-0.35955774784088135,
0.2728399932384491,
0.6967650055885315,
0.226138174533844,
-0.12300678342580795,
-0.8655920624732971,
0.21139879524707794,
-0.44930300116539,
-0.2105383425951004,
0.37320324778556824,
0.76545250415802,
-0.044840507209300995,
0.7725845575332642,
0.2800544202327728,
-0.07912340015172958,
-0.1658952683210373,
-0.004422484897077084,
1.0919761657714844,
-0.3112165033817291,
-0.8340630531311035,
-0.8587485551834106,
0.4484868347644806,
-0.10777553170919418,
-0.25450506806373596,
0.5780428051948547,
0.24992576241493225,
0.5362510681152344,
-0.4089512228965759,
0.5972129702568054,
0.18825513124465942,
0.19011043012142181,
-0.3205553889274597,
0.5598556399345398,
-0.5386976599693298,
0.11110824346542358,
-0.4103279411792755,
-0.8642162084579468,
-0.3947618901729584,
0.8069567084312439,
-0.2920476198196411,
0.05099392309784889,
0.48102736473083496,
0.5951335430145264,
-0.4291364252567291,
0.05511248856782913,
0.35298529267311096,
-0.04041057825088501,
0.023817460983991623,
0.48330411314964294,
0.9310093522071838,
-0.43520212173461914,
0.3816615641117096,
-0.2623034417629242,
-0.2128051221370697,
-0.03190258517861366,
-1.279542326927185,
-1.081175446510315,
-0.8326370716094971,
-0.5860235095024109,
-0.38338980078697205,
0.14376428723335266,
0.951250433921814,
0.717869222164154,
-0.5372719764709473,
0.3281100392341614,
-0.254658967256546,
0.2879355847835541,
-0.30361828207969666,
-0.2973189055919647,
0.18246503174304962,
-0.37250378727912903,
-0.8445838689804077,
0.408769816160202,
-0.09664779156446457,
0.37903672456741333,
-0.06343620270490646,
0.012981072068214417,
0.11948861926794052,
0.2923350930213928,
0.40883925557136536,
0.023873018100857735,
-0.56126469373703,
-0.2333063781261444,
-0.34487438201904297,
-0.08104817569255829,
-0.27229979634284973,
0.7444376945495605,
-1.3266667127609253,
0.37675800919532776,
0.14625133574008942,
0.3899793326854706,
-0.14575636386871338,
0.04977327585220337,
0.38226640224456787,
-1.048159122467041,
0.644137978553772,
0.3258623778820038,
0.3429067134857178,
0.5497605800628662,
-0.5601416826248169,
0.4965987205505371,
0.5179381966590881,
0.16955751180648804,
-1.247929573059082,
0.30702051520347595,
-0.7060585618019104,
-0.49664437770843506,
0.9716044068336487,
-0.1690027117729187,
-0.29689931869506836,
-0.21952466666698456,
-0.36517298221588135,
0.5629816055297852,
-0.4116213023662567,
1.0209800004959106,
0.5769484639167786,
0.32423579692840576,
0.17071738839149475,
-0.43114495277404785,
0.46389955282211304,
0.47270822525024414,
-0.41802483797073364,
-0.14467331767082214,
0.6061295866966248,
0.5237654447555542,
0.06547597795724869,
0.3046323359012604,
0.2245984971523285,
0.25806763768196106,
-0.058196380734443665,
-0.31588032841682434,
-0.3924463391304016,
-0.7115606069564819,
-0.34616073966026306,
0.23658715188503265,
-0.20324620604515076,
-0.5139073729515076
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18252v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18252v2
|
Beyond Embeddings: The Promise of Visual Table in Visual Reasoning
| 2024-03-27T04:49:23 | 2024-06-17T09:57:09 |
Yiwu Zhong, Zi-Yuan Hu, Michael R. Lyu, Liwei Wang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.MM
|
Visual representation learning has been a cornerstone in computer vision,
involving typical forms such as visual embeddings, structural symbols, and
text-based representations. Despite the success of CLIP-type visual embeddings,
they often lack access to world knowledge critical for visual reasoning. In
this work, we propose Visual Table, a novel form of visual representation
tailored for visual reasoning. Visual tables are constructed as hierarchical
descriptions of visual scenes, featuring a scene description and multiple
object-centric descriptions covering categories, attributes, and knowledge.
Thanks to the structural and textual formats, visual tables offer unique
advantages over mere visual embeddings, such as interpretability and
controllable editing. Furthermore, they deliver instance-level world knowledge
and detailed attributes that are essential for visual reasoning. To create
visual tables, we develop a generator trained on the dataset with collected,
small-scale annotations. Extensive results on 11 visual reasoning benchmarks
demonstrate that the generated visual tables significantly outperform previous
structural and text-based representations. Moreover, they consistently enhance
state-of-the-art multimodal large language models across diverse benchmarks,
showcasing their potential for advancing visual reasoning tasks. Our code is
available at https://github.com/LaVi-Lab/Visual-Table.
|
[
-0.3445320427417755,
-0.83153235912323,
0.8493006825447083,
-0.16205507516860962,
-0.372262179851532,
-0.0010306459153071046,
0.007887134328484535,
-0.45402947068214417,
-0.005376231390982866,
0.42188939452171326,
-0.12720298767089844,
-0.6635119915008545,
-0.2703286111354828,
-0.1458648443222046,
-0.327279269695282,
0.5118691921234131,
-0.15641054511070251,
0.20562094449996948,
-0.6405922770500183,
-0.33021578192710876,
-0.5972229838371277,
-0.2026393860578537,
0.21061687171459198,
-0.21082352101802826,
0.7759174108505249,
0.6446031332015991,
0.7682849764823914,
0.9046640992164612,
0.5636078715324402,
0.2762469947338104,
0.3718472421169281,
0.255686491727829,
-0.13842888176441193,
0.15625859797000885,
0.046611275523900986,
-0.6360158920288086,
-0.41849926114082336,
-0.12496376782655716,
0.5149207711219788,
0.6371806859970093,
0.054361745715141296,
0.17489686608314514,
-0.004451927728950977,
0.5672634243965149,
-0.46624755859375,
0.8363416194915771,
-0.651317834854126,
0.5879554152488708,
-0.2567127048969269,
-0.09770389646291733,
-0.5796313881874084,
-0.27354535460472107,
0.04355756565928459,
-0.7904303073883057,
-0.0534074567258358,
0.36148199439048767,
0.5424147248268127,
0.18655602633953094,
-0.3449324071407318,
0.27557745575904846,
-0.5415447354316711,
0.22691063582897186,
-0.012696323916316032,
0.7416182160377502,
0.06221381574869156,
0.8525227308273315,
-0.04944286122918129,
-1.0159906148910522,
-0.7069212198257446,
-0.48263877630233765,
-0.028244957327842712,
0.09338337928056717,
-0.04361943155527115,
-0.18209393322467804,
0.5693420767784119,
0.1992223858833313,
-0.6069986820220947,
-0.2611587643623352,
-0.1273210346698761,
0.06914803385734558,
0.34182390570640564,
0.27338895201683044,
0.5448458790779114,
-0.12146007269620895,
-0.4863986670970917,
-0.2198552042245865,
-0.9112207293510437,
-0.02269812300801277,
-0.35850656032562256,
0.14035126566886902,
0.024904320016503334,
0.9407060146331787,
-0.13532555103302002,
0.9290705919265747,
-0.5490342974662781,
0.08344511687755585,
-0.09456969797611237,
0.07332654297351837,
-0.03587747737765312,
-0.05118453502655029,
0.45161259174346924,
0.5864506363868713,
0.34369543194770813,
-0.10890773683786392,
0.03815680742263794,
0.38759520649909973,
0.19072827696800232,
-0.4705043137073517,
-0.5785969495773315,
-0.3348897397518158,
-0.41943663358688354,
-0.22762273252010345,
0.23732632398605347,
-0.7249317765235901,
-0.564644992351532,
-0.3896518051624298,
0.6058408617973328,
-0.312481552362442,
0.13392680883407593,
-0.2811494469642639,
-0.5361265540122986,
0.2269788384437561,
0.6922698020935059,
-0.5014991760253906,
0.06023983284831047,
0.24435755610466003,
0.6753153800964355,
0.06745201349258423,
-0.22164995968341827,
-0.4809991419315338,
0.7355822920799255,
-0.42603522539138794,
0.9465762972831726,
-0.7573503255844116,
-0.15307703614234924,
0.03188147023320198,
-0.29188182950019836,
0.5452905297279358,
-0.33365195989608765,
0.020482465624809265,
-0.21115413308143616,
-0.21890783309936523,
-0.623370885848999,
-0.22862763702869415,
-0.11070220917463303,
0.37806621193885803,
-0.8779256939888,
0.6501889824867249,
-0.1289139837026596,
-0.6357405781745911,
0.9502665400505066,
-0.45040181279182434,
-0.35773134231567383,
0.49879834055900574,
-0.7690110802650452,
-0.3273429870605469,
0.07626263797283173,
0.5490566492080688,
0.5331672430038452,
-0.24526172876358032,
-0.03347637876868248,
-0.6067147254943848,
-0.3189552128314972,
0.45278409123420715,
-0.12246641516685486,
0.0014014773769304156,
-0.0780889168381691,
-0.16509589552879333,
0.25803372263908386,
-0.7686500549316406,
0.08131881058216095,
0.37863272428512573,
-0.20818917453289032,
-0.13301852345466614,
0.22288493812084198,
-0.019832778722047806,
0.16078631579875946,
-0.015588682144880295,
-0.4924241602420807,
0.29971134662628174,
0.29739296436309814,
0.6463614106178284,
0.5016152262687683,
-0.089652419090271,
0.4807857871055603,
-0.08823423832654953,
0.15653468668460846,
0.07342720031738281,
-0.007938358001410961,
-0.3368605673313141,
-0.5702652335166931,
-0.7941063642501831,
-0.22150273621082306,
0.06092426925897598,
0.4948666989803314,
-1.2556434869766235,
0.04061795026063919,
-0.3686598837375641,
-0.32254472374916077,
0.0706634521484375,
-0.06734851747751236,
0.26765063405036926,
0.40166717767715454,
0.5562753081321716,
-0.0070907422341406345,
-0.5739089846611023,
-0.9728905558586121,
-0.18125620484352112,
-0.05863887816667557,
0.10587116330862045,
0.23796065151691437,
0.7318267822265625,
0.12841582298278809,
0.8889594674110413,
-0.6884193420410156,
-0.43994271755218506,
-0.5898202657699585,
-0.17494380474090576,
-0.233652725815773,
0.3670060932636261,
0.2568046450614929,
-0.6246129870414734,
-0.3748611807823181,
0.23748303949832916,
-1.0645498037338257,
0.2547054588794708,
-0.2925078272819519,
-0.39185357093811035,
0.0002555253158789128,
0.6421183943748474,
-0.4706036448478699,
0.7648171782493591,
-0.14698781073093414,
-0.29958078265190125,
0.30095356702804565,
-0.14502593874931335,
-0.0429692417383194,
-0.6746397614479065,
-0.09877410531044006,
0.05440526828169823,
-0.3117538392543793,
-0.1916702687740326,
0.11870697885751724,
0.005530083552002907,
-0.6349250078201294,
-0.22785085439682007,
0.5050854682922363,
-0.6432973146438599,
-0.2885289490222931,
0.25565624237060547,
0.34725090861320496,
0.14898180961608887,
0.598930299282074,
0.17865493893623352,
0.4088802933692932,
0.4570173919200897,
-0.23672397434711456,
0.3736959397792816,
0.6558815836906433,
-0.6203994750976562,
0.6747666597366333,
-0.5449059009552002,
-0.18977048993110657,
-0.19023741781711578,
0.2979956269264221,
-0.8144841194152832,
-0.4428226947784424,
0.16789810359477997,
-0.18541882932186127,
0.2742718756198883,
-0.22971127927303314,
-0.3531419336795807,
-0.40436798334121704,
-0.2118336260318756,
0.016575217247009277,
0.3496026396751404,
-0.7902863621711731,
0.6493760943412781,
0.5069392919540405,
0.11795613914728165,
-0.5604159235954285,
-1.0986884832382202,
0.2287464439868927,
-0.019409915432333946,
-0.6272799968719482,
0.2664324641227722,
0.4162255823612213,
-0.22337743639945984,
0.23736880719661713,
-0.33301523327827454,
0.015100284479558468,
-0.3138301968574524,
0.4878883957862854,
0.20437410473823547,
-0.18747654557228088,
0.35565805435180664,
-0.05390484631061554,
-0.05818775296211243,
-0.044399164617061615,
-0.2707001864910126,
0.18925921618938446,
-0.5413098335266113,
-0.5142248272895813,
-0.25875556468963623,
0.46316981315612793,
0.41982197761535645,
-0.5568511486053467,
0.5007542967796326,
0.6571992039680481,
-0.43099403381347656,
-0.5101785659790039,
-0.3485547602176666,
0.0012608241522684693,
-0.3590342104434967,
0.5627241730690002,
-0.6031309962272644,
-0.7195320129394531,
0.5742046236991882,
0.08043500036001205,
-0.024009643122553825,
0.24154387414455414,
0.17944855988025665,
-0.3854773938655853,
0.9688266515731812,
0.3540390431880951,
0.7905933260917664,
0.4075550436973572,
-0.28790196776390076,
0.09812083840370178,
-0.6049764156341553,
-0.8038141131401062,
-0.29407379031181335,
-0.4577111601829529,
-0.41767221689224243,
-0.8001174926757812,
0.5071704983711243,
-0.003697288455441594,
-0.5248900055885315,
0.11037346720695496,
-0.5134482979774475,
0.7353599071502686,
0.6755653023719788,
0.5501769781112671,
0.3399510681629181,
0.30052030086517334,
-0.19524918496608734,
-0.20389606058597565,
-0.6790854334831238,
-0.589418351650238,
0.6105816960334778,
0.10348910093307495,
0.9386865496635437,
-0.12306699901819229,
0.5515413284301758,
0.2795490622520447,
0.1935025155544281,
-0.6451880931854248,
0.7949797511100769,
-0.20384974777698517,
-0.16950036585330963,
-0.2517267167568207,
-0.5578386187553406,
-0.5125571489334106,
0.5659672617912292,
-0.6028409600257874,
-0.6596066951751709,
0.13797469437122345,
0.36500898003578186,
0.01962248794734478,
0.5594925284385681,
-0.6545439958572388,
1.2895452976226807,
-0.3066677153110504,
-0.5688683390617371,
-0.008103225380182266,
-0.33616653084754944,
0.34322506189346313,
0.7382897734642029,
-0.012109204195439816,
-0.012318621389567852,
0.005641106516122818,
0.43977949023246765,
-0.5869433879852295,
0.7342191338539124,
-0.297021746635437,
0.32657501101493835,
0.5256733894348145,
0.4176967740058899,
0.234510600566864,
0.2597425878047943,
0.3663291037082672,
0.10040789097547531,
-0.001625402015633881,
-0.157332643866539,
-0.8067945837974548,
0.551480770111084,
-0.3575868308544159,
-0.5256596207618713,
-0.3864324986934662,
-0.4966677725315094,
-0.16323664784431458,
0.1369265466928482,
-0.04048328101634979,
0.7708307504653931,
-0.18927259743213654,
0.46971726417541504,
0.4175490736961365,
-0.37493476271629333,
0.30164870619773865,
-0.2596808969974518,
-0.4568427503108978,
-0.5536656379699707,
1.0151958465576172,
0.3300533890724182,
-0.17486673593521118,
0.7715377807617188,
0.2297305315732956,
-0.29571089148521423,
-0.31621676683425903,
-0.7922165393829346,
-0.32047924399375916,
-1.0324172973632812,
-0.31782224774360657,
-0.49786612391471863,
0.04909569025039673,
0.2423797994852066,
-0.3418945074081421,
-0.005766868591308594,
-0.8383447527885437,
0.1089460700750351,
-0.2833477258682251,
0.36318060755729675,
0.9326850175857544,
0.1414119303226471,
0.07355052977800369,
-0.6537449359893799,
0.4178413450717926,
0.8186600208282471,
0.3698630630970001,
0.1521560549736023,
0.11135432869195938,
-0.06208835542201996,
-0.20574301481246948,
-0.13626539707183838,
-1.0570865869522095,
0.21626487374305725,
0.2589423954486847,
0.8047510981559753,
0.22729602456092834,
-0.2982134222984314,
0.8994531035423279,
-0.6887607574462891,
0.671708881855011,
0.37558498978614807,
-0.9390302300453186,
0.6539229154586792,
-0.2629808485507965,
0.4256657361984253,
0.2756783366203308,
0.0776246041059494,
-0.13770413398742676,
-0.06375130265951157,
-0.1945706605911255,
-0.70977383852005,
0.38758236169815063,
-0.03157257288694382,
-0.1487840712070465,
0.02804167941212654,
0.17497794330120087,
0.14953996241092682,
0.08347908407449722,
-1.0936462879180908,
0.23567087948322296,
-0.6145168542861938,
-0.17268982529640198,
0.35594066977500916,
-0.14386823773384094,
-0.15027521550655365,
-0.4881399869918823,
0.10652260482311249,
-0.19149591028690338,
0.42108580470085144,
0.08104408532381058,
-0.5361926555633545,
0.1247139498591423,
0.1974954754114151,
0.2487170249223709,
0.7361980676651001,
0.16364075243473053,
0.6818034648895264,
0.17299261689186096,
-0.17919817566871643,
-0.11929824203252792,
0.0052435919642448425,
-0.023547129705548286,
-0.08800722658634186,
0.5699237585067749,
0.7976877689361572,
0.3050305247306824,
-0.5246715545654297,
0.41738271713256836,
0.05848865956068039,
-0.04215956851840019,
-0.23729316890239716,
-0.10783558338880539,
0.13263440132141113,
0.292577862739563,
0.10840209573507309,
-0.08713085949420929,
0.14707358181476593,
-0.8152230381965637,
0.34314626455307007,
0.5020557641983032,
-0.49668169021606445,
-0.0672549456357956,
0.8897114396095276,
0.2080175280570984,
0.06645938754081726,
0.5794167518615723,
-0.04163014516234398,
-0.4604805111885071,
0.3866140842437744,
0.32827994227409363,
0.28069785237312317,
0.16001901030540466,
0.39508697390556335,
0.34474658966064453,
0.29910898208618164,
0.15723541378974915,
0.6064415574073792,
-0.39967799186706543,
-0.4816534221172333,
-0.11702017486095428,
-0.49112194776535034,
-0.2603916525840759,
-0.4309740364551544,
-0.4249036908149719,
0.024183129891753197,
-0.6426939964294434,
-0.11010093241930008,
-0.16520781815052032,
-0.42510271072387695,
-0.7861969470977783,
-0.12142369896173477,
0.3976909816265106,
0.7119384407997131,
-0.746972382068634,
0.46051621437072754,
0.827607274055481,
-0.9066707491874695,
-0.5472428798675537,
-0.41834044456481934,
-0.2807134985923767,
-0.7809113264083862,
0.6499334573745728,
0.3615249991416931,
0.2258240431547165,
-0.4932629466056824,
-0.7857096195220947,
-0.6407963633537292,
1.0256253480911255,
0.5011525750160217,
-0.49848297238349915,
-0.021679727360606194,
0.4472407400608063,
0.3666696846485138,
-0.3064604699611664,
-0.013306792825460434,
0.3255437910556793,
0.5967056751251221,
0.31683221459388733,
-0.21881382167339325,
0.2861812710762024,
-0.22390536963939667,
0.24242515861988068,
0.1550525575876236,
-0.08995389938354492,
0.7370067238807678,
-0.38197171688079834,
-0.08466053009033203,
-0.23384015262126923,
0.8042359352111816,
0.32280510663986206,
0.15852737426757812,
0.21926070749759674,
0.7961203455924988,
0.46453332901000977,
-0.7124444842338562,
0.9909482002258301,
0.3115025758743286,
-0.3294261693954468,
1.3295048475265503,
-0.22815345227718353,
0.8658958673477173,
0.44638174772262573,
-0.022146426141262054,
0.8005709648132324,
0.2501288652420044,
-0.3026253879070282,
0.3599125146865845,
0.21405524015426636,
0.08677610754966736,
-0.747950553894043,
-0.19093765318393707,
-0.4173352122306824,
0.6130437850952148,
0.5366358160972595,
-0.34126296639442444,
-0.4052802324295044,
0.011555125005543232,
-0.4732014238834381,
0.2753661274909973,
-0.41102367639541626,
0.758628785610199,
0.24372735619544983,
-0.1561388373374939,
0.14760933816432953,
-0.4846765697002411,
-0.18403112888336182,
-0.23296356201171875,
-0.7711483240127563,
0.058720871806144714,
0.1350652277469635,
-0.2866172790527344,
-1.1791647672653198,
0.03504560887813568,
-0.26050084829330444,
0.14117495715618134,
-0.3302980363368988,
0.4451700747013092,
-0.5832682251930237,
-0.3827049136161804,
-0.15810410678386688,
0.6422391533851624,
-0.1285271942615509,
-0.05848263204097748,
-0.31433621048927307,
0.14806346595287323,
-0.1750923991203308,
-0.04734449461102486,
0.07367894053459167,
0.6767875552177429,
-0.3335372507572174,
0.6275790333747864,
0.39316844940185547,
-0.2774287164211273,
0.07232305407524109,
0.24903081357479095,
0.8072342276573181,
-0.7005385756492615,
-0.6457437872886658,
-0.7069220542907715,
0.8016166687011719,
-0.16430175304412842,
-0.07797784358263016,
0.5082483291625977,
0.5470848083496094,
0.6117445826530457,
-0.4944084882736206,
0.5599719882011414,
-0.17627689242362976,
-0.2698587477207184,
-0.5776245594024658,
0.6528742909431458,
-0.5835482478141785,
-0.16682089865207672,
-0.31373777985572815,
-1.1273632049560547,
-0.7774823307991028,
0.8735217452049255,
-0.2361653596162796,
-0.08259060233831406,
0.6890270113945007,
0.3274204134941101,
0.07857467979192734,
0.06536640226840973,
0.39067450165748596,
0.11005175858736038,
0.3316675126552582,
0.5681132674217224,
1.1537035703659058,
-0.06154460832476616,
0.8055482506752014,
-0.1589318811893463,
-0.04308275505900383,
0.04835483431816101,
-0.7651639580726624,
-1.1351975202560425,
-0.6381428837776184,
-0.11902491003274918,
-0.08639983087778091,
0.012205244973301888,
0.634161651134491,
0.6101619005203247,
-0.3328234553337097,
0.013409980572760105,
-0.18662318587303162,
0.1893044412136078,
-0.2114708572626114,
-0.14788612723350525,
0.36161667108535767,
0.037038419395685196,
-0.14773450791835785,
0.3142048716545105,
0.440446138381958,
0.16531044244766235,
-0.1559753566980362,
0.13172906637191772,
-0.0029849151615053415,
-0.36797425150871277,
0.8822110891342163,
0.16738781332969666,
-0.6744012832641602,
-0.5013377666473389,
-0.23448269069194794,
0.13840025663375854,
0.27715736627578735,
0.7369468808174133,
-0.9007526636123657,
0.4645633399486542,
0.7588487267494202,
0.3747132420539856,
0.762697696685791,
-0.3030129373073578,
0.5528028607368469,
-0.6191997528076172,
0.2864617705345154,
0.29147398471832275,
0.9290117621421814,
0.47184988856315613,
-0.0030332442838698626,
0.42527130246162415,
-0.05245525389909744,
-0.0641670674085617,
-0.844415545463562,
0.4158032536506653,
-1.2856035232543945,
-0.19642716646194458,
0.5604977607727051,
-0.013095732778310776,
-0.564041256904602,
0.18018902838230133,
-0.3150917589664459,
0.2714102864265442,
-0.35528069734573364,
0.5530552864074707,
0.29864034056663513,
-0.14460331201553345,
-0.5403793454170227,
-0.2530803084373474,
0.44566330313682556,
-0.08662708103656769,
-1.0587331056594849,
0.08196166902780533,
0.8736192584037781,
-0.24226103723049164,
0.20003898441791534,
-0.14158014953136444,
-0.47343096137046814,
0.3537180423736572,
0.48347151279449463,
0.19231367111206055,
-0.5479960441589355,
-0.788090169429779,
0.20087701082229614,
0.528317928314209,
-0.02200302667915821,
-0.15404386818408966
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18251v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18251v1
|
Since the Scientific Literature Is Multilingual, Our Models Should Be Too
| 2024-03-27T04:47:10 | 2024-03-27T04:47:10 |
Abteen Ebrahimi, Kenneth Church
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
English has long been assumed the $\textit{lingua franca}$ of scientific
research, and this notion is reflected in the natural language processing (NLP)
research involving scientific document representation. In this position piece,
we quantitatively show that the literature is largely multilingual and argue
that current models and benchmarks should reflect this linguistic diversity. We
provide evidence that text-based models fail to create meaningful
representations for non-English papers and highlight the negative user-facing
impacts of using English-only models non-discriminately across a multilingual
domain. We end with suggestions for the NLP community on how to improve
performance on non-English documents.
|
[
-0.04879128932952881,
-0.05757687985897064,
0.35969385504722595,
0.6148967146873474,
-0.16436854004859924,
0.22009415924549103,
-0.1528022587299347,
-1.1381129026412964,
0.4017651081085205,
0.2259441763162613,
0.04371146857738495,
-0.13667312264442444,
-0.8878843784332275,
0.808499813079834,
-0.46641188859939575,
0.8771137595176697,
0.08459781855344772,
0.6298456788063049,
-0.6484289765357971,
-0.386159747838974,
-0.1918427050113678,
-0.5701373219490051,
-0.458086222410202,
-0.5849712491035461,
0.8365896940231323,
-0.019802752882242203,
0.7484544515609741,
0.2830541431903839,
0.38256752490997314,
0.18062034249305725,
-0.296531617641449,
0.21895228326320648,
-0.29358047246932983,
0.21263787150382996,
-0.2848259508609772,
-0.6752464175224304,
-0.2763201594352722,
0.1823965609073639,
0.6797842979431152,
1.0174992084503174,
0.13518115878105164,
-0.16547314822673798,
0.023954885080456734,
0.38951754570007324,
-0.23889119923114777,
0.1189064085483551,
-0.4045714735984802,
0.08872102200984955,
-0.07417988777160645,
-0.1329914629459381,
-0.7518287897109985,
0.15733513236045837,
0.02021671272814274,
-0.6923174858093262,
0.3724555969238281,
0.30960890650749207,
0.8344086408615112,
-0.18418623507022858,
-0.7684561610221863,
-0.29253047704696655,
-0.8852056264877319,
0.9495961666107178,
-0.6237784624099731,
0.5741414427757263,
0.3451078236103058,
-0.013148216530680656,
-0.145560160279274,
-0.6645876169204712,
-0.2610190808773041,
-0.4861794114112854,
-0.1886330395936966,
0.020901760086417198,
-0.003086285199970007,
-0.2615654468536377,
0.20303934812545776,
0.0577302910387516,
-0.6919490098953247,
0.18621094524860382,
-0.7456936240196228,
-0.12035723030567169,
0.8103421926498413,
-0.25442081689834595,
0.33302929997444153,
-0.05032797157764435,
0.12428253889083862,
0.028763556852936745,
-0.5315380096435547,
-0.10767193883657455,
0.2072049379348755,
0.5688389539718628,
-0.12268900871276855,
0.7492502927780151,
0.3661080300807953,
0.4386883080005646,
-0.5814491510391235,
-0.07506480813026428,
0.2078036069869995,
-0.39687639474868774,
0.07603146880865097,
0.06477249413728714,
0.8605074286460876,
0.40526294708251953,
0.19606487452983856,
-0.36716556549072266,
-0.04430224746465683,
0.15396274626255035,
0.21015724539756775,
-0.6181015968322754,
-0.08768093585968018,
0.05707385763525963,
-0.2158190757036209,
0.2526443898677826,
-0.18154260516166687,
-0.7714753746986389,
-0.2567039728164673,
-0.08307211846113205,
-0.017565643414855003,
-0.2577248513698578,
-0.5055393576622009,
0.25359150767326355,
-0.29600346088409424,
-0.29593151807785034,
0.20799845457077026,
-0.8474169373512268,
0.3896700143814087,
0.6500170826911926,
0.9369405508041382,
-0.08346307277679443,
-0.5739932656288147,
0.18511518836021423,
0.13691547513008118,
-0.6159065961837769,
1.086132287979126,
-0.5876972675323486,
-0.7705066204071045,
-0.08302715420722961,
0.21626658737659454,
-0.17769795656204224,
-0.15878348052501678,
0.7807613015174866,
-0.37092745304107666,
0.6043784618377686,
-0.6007497310638428,
-0.47510460019111633,
-0.32742178440093994,
0.057153139263391495,
-0.883827805519104,
0.8415391445159912,
-0.27554556727409363,
-0.8198239207267761,
0.4042864441871643,
-0.7999114990234375,
-0.4996528625488281,
0.08457846194505692,
0.010889191180467606,
-0.22461064159870148,
0.2597743570804596,
0.1830337792634964,
0.09994231164455414,
-0.4008618891239166,
0.6008808016777039,
-0.34304994344711304,
-0.14450979232788086,
0.02973533608019352,
-0.4118525981903076,
0.7733784914016724,
0.2155291587114334,
0.10067617148160934,
-0.3254227042198181,
-0.7806091904640198,
-0.02711251564323902,
0.11853741854429245,
-0.23804770410060883,
-0.716878354549408,
0.2516852915287018,
0.6541634202003479,
0.14043782651424408,
0.1746721863746643,
-0.678963303565979,
0.06479775905609131,
-0.4992862641811371,
0.4274241328239441,
0.015255114994943142,
-0.42875543236732483,
0.6137580871582031,
-0.40037888288497925,
0.5940055251121521,
-0.3599074184894562,
-0.40223097801208496,
-0.08050809800624847,
-0.7471619844436646,
-0.22086958587169647,
-0.19025468826293945,
0.5196486711502075,
0.28345173597335815,
-0.40803536772727966,
-0.33770525455474854,
0.036701351404190063,
-0.6572408080101013,
-0.5192834734916687,
-0.025189239531755447,
0.23944450914859772,
0.19611425697803497,
0.5115023255348206,
0.028615394607186317,
-0.6990218162536621,
-0.9594961404800415,
-0.5730817914009094,
-0.4277646541595459,
0.1847030222415924,
0.10726019740104675,
0.8072047829627991,
-0.15031932294368744,
0.6931014060974121,
-0.1430610865354538,
0.00415731081739068,
-0.22660057246685028,
0.5367740392684937,
0.028296470642089844,
0.27530887722969055,
0.7624309062957764,
-1.1269035339355469,
-0.5510993003845215,
0.1261960119009018,
-1.0027287006378174,
-0.15972578525543213,
0.057059407234191895,
0.11858971416950226,
0.45473673939704895,
0.31979119777679443,
-0.6416578888893127,
-0.014674205332994461,
0.7212375998497009,
-0.36737173795700073,
0.6377682089805603,
-0.44604581594467163,
0.2913174033164978,
-0.8970304131507874,
0.28539860248565674,
0.35633641481399536,
-0.12626738846302032,
-0.5458768606185913,
0.06789813190698624,
0.352424293756485,
-0.3168536424636841,
-0.2411070168018341,
0.7424740791320801,
-0.6910442113876343,
0.06815510243177414,
-0.35749849677085876,
-0.09770756959915161,
0.7334264516830444,
-0.21255512535572052,
0.39752352237701416,
0.6667209267616272,
0.4039098918437958,
-0.36551153659820557,
0.08599713444709778,
-0.05380794033408165,
-0.021168863400816917,
0.5399199724197388,
-0.7604634165763855,
-0.4779982268810272,
-0.4192506968975067,
0.3180093765258789,
-0.6742637157440186,
-0.17201779782772064,
-0.1520693153142929,
-0.34025073051452637,
0.5673162341117859,
-0.007189049385488033,
-0.46887049078941345,
-0.4154316484928131,
-0.09721826761960983,
0.3966479003429413,
0.034624408930540085,
-0.2556622624397278,
0.5581763982772827,
0.39250651001930237,
-0.30220815539360046,
-0.6299991607666016,
-0.775322675704956,
0.35118338465690613,
-0.08091583102941513,
-0.7694789171218872,
0.4866318702697754,
-0.027807867154479027,
-0.4344591796398163,
0.12472380697727203,
0.08388029038906097,
-0.41678386926651,
0.07165935635566711,
-0.07570280134677887,
0.2189120054244995,
-0.3837946057319641,
0.5321810841560364,
-0.08281225711107254,
0.2136191874742508,
0.21312107145786285,
-0.054218392819166183,
0.17965687811374664,
0.11437105387449265,
-0.1796884834766388,
0.11262514442205429,
0.9775501489639282,
0.6545069813728333,
-0.23765571415424347,
0.8889048099517822,
0.3164089322090149,
-0.37800899147987366,
0.005348756909370422,
-0.23320269584655762,
-0.09155773371458054,
-0.3123783767223358,
0.7396162748336792,
-0.09882663190364838,
-0.5596826672554016,
0.5980281829833984,
0.2814638018608093,
0.39944106340408325,
0.8403534293174744,
0.12240598350763321,
-0.32158830761909485,
0.9864433407783508,
0.9594689011573792,
0.23515507578849792,
-0.01698845624923706,
-0.016280196607112885,
0.4403570592403412,
-0.4746161699295044,
-0.29545047879219055,
-1.1558332443237305,
0.026448676362633705,
-0.60362708568573,
-0.3070717453956604,
0.1831636130809784,
0.13759133219718933,
0.05373862013220787,
0.25414302945137024,
-0.6316999793052673,
0.49118250608444214,
0.2970632314682007,
-0.5113911032676697,
0.4509415924549103,
0.08300749212503433,
-0.13539214432239532,
-0.5307521820068359,
-0.9311204552650452,
-0.8029406666755676,
1.0310885906219482,
0.374022901058197,
0.7880392074584961,
-0.14013570547103882,
0.35449081659317017,
0.03881729394197464,
0.4443033039569855,
-0.5605400204658508,
0.18838389217853546,
-0.29023128747940063,
-0.9107363820075989,
-0.13710150122642517,
-0.28728151321411133,
-1.1233007907867432,
0.726227343082428,
-0.18359437584877014,
-0.2338642030954361,
0.07367104291915894,
-0.18461072444915771,
0.006361790932714939,
0.2892071008682251,
-0.7509843707084656,
0.8328823447227478,
-0.46850287914276123,
-0.29076245427131653,
-0.0833870992064476,
-0.20558354258537292,
0.36708107590675354,
-0.19135764241218567,
0.7539315819740295,
-0.1452932357788086,
-0.04904933273792267,
0.9892024993896484,
0.002798789879307151,
0.7127730250358582,
-0.0403897762298584,
-0.16633401811122894,
0.04534650593996048,
0.03023107908666134,
0.20888067781925201,
0.36324816942214966,
-0.4489707946777344,
0.4437198042869568,
0.5281499028205872,
-0.5845097899436951,
-0.18020310997962952,
0.6219416260719299,
-0.7452147006988525,
-0.45456844568252563,
-0.8633783459663391,
-0.6929114460945129,
-0.06063079833984375,
0.12327397614717484,
0.3811766505241394,
0.1550413817167282,
-0.43021970987319946,
0.06512485444545746,
0.21700447797775269,
-0.26290982961654663,
0.35399147868156433,
0.7010607123374939,
-0.527751088142395,
0.06698338687419891,
0.6461269855499268,
0.533976674079895,
-0.00032228464260697365,
0.36883610486984253,
0.12542521953582764,
-0.3906809389591217,
-0.4580526053905487,
-0.2789528965950012,
0.598487138748169,
-0.7486521005630493,
0.08205648511648178,
-0.9617586731910706,
-0.0901576355099678,
-0.5907372236251831,
-0.16010692715644836,
-0.4104962944984436,
-0.5200334787368774,
-0.6605551838874817,
-0.10989630222320557,
0.3009738028049469,
0.8054496645927429,
-0.2376806139945984,
-0.027181612327694893,
-0.7294089794158936,
0.3193795680999756,
-0.09383046627044678,
0.2277783751487732,
-0.22342172265052795,
-0.6124205589294434,
-0.6109825968742371,
0.1266973912715912,
-0.1574316918849945,
-0.7803583145141602,
0.6246059536933899,
0.5727593898773193,
0.6776418685913086,
-0.1552298665046692,
-0.08429700881242752,
0.3056895136833191,
-0.7167901992797852,
0.9421705603599548,
0.1384749412536621,
-0.4132654070854187,
0.1774500012397766,
-0.17479676008224487,
0.3085571527481079,
0.3488067388534546,
0.8431306481361389,
-0.9266391396522522,
-0.6624712347984314,
-0.3955458700656891,
-0.8459466695785522,
0.3994016647338867,
-0.24197156727313995,
0.37499213218688965,
-0.19702371954917908,
-0.2073151022195816,
0.33108195662498474,
0.20771698653697968,
-1.4097750186920166,
-0.05555184558033943,
-0.29826799035072327,
0.018867388367652893,
-0.39436107873916626,
-0.36758267879486084,
-0.20266486704349518,
-0.1783331036567688,
0.7075577974319458,
-0.18938995897769928,
0.17280645668506622,
0.3112746775150299,
-0.014474340714514256,
-0.19426219165325165,
0.25696393847465515,
0.5202890634536743,
0.8438047170639038,
-0.15293733775615692,
0.1438891589641571,
-0.24867776036262512,
-0.3231144845485687,
0.08034054189920425,
0.2905696630477905,
-0.3434095084667206,
0.49998632073402405,
0.743478536605835,
0.31859609484672546,
0.2849613428115845,
-0.4773738384246826,
0.04238882660865784,
-0.14301978051662445,
-0.21722102165222168,
-0.05208975821733475,
-0.3487905263900757,
0.4282982647418976,
-0.0394650436937809,
0.5803267955780029,
0.4750159680843353,
0.11484209448099136,
-0.5024970769882202,
-0.09105175733566284,
0.5807428359985352,
-0.0054604304023087025,
-0.47444459795951843,
0.7925437092781067,
0.29802724719047546,
-0.249339759349823,
0.018847675994038582,
-0.25389307737350464,
-0.4355199337005615,
0.673761785030365,
0.6924141049385071,
0.5561227798461914,
-0.012416917830705643,
0.4909307360649109,
0.6108920574188232,
0.5752109885215759,
-0.5553709864616394,
0.2805788218975067,
0.5609133243560791,
-0.6712624430656433,
-0.6122863292694092,
-0.6205284595489502,
-0.2851252853870392,
-0.11648604273796082,
-0.3283199965953827,
0.44389277696609497,
-0.16729600727558136,
-0.22812068462371826,
0.487537145614624,
-0.035641755908727646,
-0.39036479592323303,
0.033932123333215714,
0.2103136032819748,
0.8436000943183899,
-1.1203694343566895,
0.7096391916275024,
0.6555347442626953,
-0.2577037215232849,
-0.46369999647140503,
-0.5235862135887146,
-0.20783734321594238,
-0.2102961391210556,
0.7689685225486755,
0.0987170860171318,
-0.010016212239861488,
-0.42457520961761475,
-0.5489856600761414,
-0.9551395773887634,
0.4508472681045532,
0.4085801839828491,
-0.5353382229804993,
-0.14521771669387817,
0.026493754237890244,
0.9690375328063965,
-0.3694848120212555,
0.36186063289642334,
-0.20636038482189178,
0.5610047578811646,
-0.12133350968360901,
-1.0704472064971924,
-0.46206560730934143,
-0.5334346294403076,
-0.13075612485408783,
-0.08763648569583893,
-0.3574848771095276,
1.081945538520813,
-0.09289897233247757,
-0.32082539796829224,
-0.26817765831947327,
0.5727996826171875,
-0.03149581700563431,
0.6158047914505005,
-0.1020953431725502,
0.29610708355903625,
0.8860730528831482,
0.06767304241657257,
1.3136284351348877,
-0.21995368599891663,
0.22328051924705505,
0.9521351456642151,
-0.6934553980827332,
0.6751359105110168,
0.601862907409668,
-0.3439212441444397,
0.3308512568473816,
0.7899486422538757,
-0.22583100199699402,
0.4133819341659546,
-0.07298893481492996,
-0.16574448347091675,
-0.04338601976633072,
-0.4094684422016144,
-0.6155861616134644,
0.4280872046947479,
0.2695353329181671,
-0.48233652114868164,
-0.288128137588501,
0.1596255600452423,
0.004377163015305996,
0.5988014340400696,
-0.12285658717155457,
0.37316498160362244,
0.28894275426864624,
-0.827951967716217,
0.7380048632621765,
0.4454350769519806,
0.8460851907730103,
-0.7498140335083008,
0.06701402366161346,
-0.11947093158960342,
-0.41262710094451904,
-0.34117767214775085,
-0.5216491222381592,
0.581581711769104,
0.07935204356908798,
-0.6069196462631226,
-0.37192922830581665,
0.49203014373779297,
-0.4730701148509979,
-1.1307640075683594,
0.742233395576477,
0.6058732271194458,
0.30780744552612305,
0.1265302151441574,
-0.6629866361618042,
-0.21866649389266968,
0.04597994685173035,
-0.24774427711963654,
0.21266597509384155,
0.46160879731178284,
-0.32251542806625366,
0.5741123557090759,
0.5446202754974365,
0.4288998246192932,
0.017794828861951828,
0.14098849892616272,
0.3938053250312805,
-0.5728098750114441,
-0.36586442589759827,
-0.7345473766326904,
0.3001647889614105,
-0.08186390995979309,
-0.3215155303478241,
0.7969761490821838,
0.7090021371841431,
0.7780890464782715,
-0.016850939020514488,
0.7606509923934937,
0.06711605936288834,
0.5746937394142151,
-0.23241682350635529,
0.6824997067451477,
-0.8888365626335144,
0.1925324946641922,
-0.12372103333473206,
-0.8382755517959595,
-0.5272122621536255,
0.5537410378456116,
-0.14027878642082214,
0.14798113703727722,
0.9845033288002014,
0.538833737373352,
0.011982282623648643,
0.1918332427740097,
0.4972764551639557,
0.19791138172149658,
0.2982168197631836,
0.17309355735778809,
0.7000361084938049,
-0.44024568796157837,
0.23041003942489624,
-0.0780857503414154,
0.09929893910884857,
-0.018926523625850677,
-1.079999327659607,
-0.6328217387199402,
-0.5091835260391235,
-0.4264422357082367,
-0.25376832485198975,
-0.1728893369436264,
0.6939641833305359,
0.4869394600391388,
-0.7316159605979919,
-0.35159191489219666,
0.27132752537727356,
0.1745356172323227,
-0.18311192095279694,
-0.16037781536579132,
0.0706900879740715,
-0.3022124171257019,
-0.7897994518280029,
0.47747355699539185,
0.4464741349220276,
0.0867030918598175,
-0.4268951416015625,
-0.07018691301345825,
-0.5802993774414062,
0.1422962248325348,
0.5076002478599548,
0.5254994034767151,
-0.6244078278541565,
0.21350052952766418,
0.1897338181734085,
-0.46963995695114136,
0.2208736538887024,
0.5674484372138977,
-0.44813963770866394,
0.46653321385383606,
0.2809617817401886,
0.3141232132911682,
0.48485615849494934,
-0.5277546048164368,
0.8017667531967163,
-0.609693706035614,
0.30150744318962097,
0.7064865231513977,
0.6683273911476135,
0.7774231433868408,
-0.3258950114250183,
0.5787475109100342,
0.38244763016700745,
-0.6313604116439819,
-1.1334869861602783,
-0.009358398616313934,
-0.4084097445011139,
-0.7361360788345337,
0.9025459885597229,
-0.19054365158081055,
-0.37480077147483826,
-0.37481462955474854,
-0.043469637632369995,
0.03298473358154297,
-0.3177594840526581,
0.7365992665290833,
1.1238120794296265,
0.12448631972074509,
-0.21672597527503967,
-0.9462367296218872,
0.33379971981048584,
0.51796555519104,
-0.5343194603919983,
0.024698108434677124,
0.31531277298927307,
-0.03966284543275833,
0.6237128376960754,
0.6501360535621643,
-0.17353667318820953,
0.09903912246227264,
0.07653187960386276,
0.3623800277709961,
0.17280805110931396,
-0.42305201292037964,
-0.12537190318107605,
0.1851024031639099,
0.4061843454837799,
0.6902651190757751
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18249v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18249v2
|
Exploring the Deceptive Power of LLM-Generated Fake News: A Study of Real-World Detection Challenges
| 2024-03-27T04:39:18 | 2024-04-08T19:55:37 |
Yanshen Sun, Jianfeng He, Limeng Cui, Shuo Lei, Chang-Tien Lu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SI
|
Recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have enabled the creation
of fake news, particularly in complex fields like healthcare. Studies highlight
the gap in the deceptive power of LLM-generated fake news with and without
human assistance, yet the potential of prompting techniques has not been fully
explored. Thus, this work aims to determine whether prompting strategies can
effectively narrow this gap. Current LLM-based fake news attacks require human
intervention for information gathering and often miss details and fail to
maintain context consistency. Therefore, to better understand threat tactics,
we propose a strong fake news attack method called conditional
Variational-autoencoder-Like Prompt (VLPrompt). Unlike current methods,
VLPrompt eliminates the need for additional data collection while maintaining
contextual coherence and preserving the intricacies of the original text. To
propel future research on detecting VLPrompt attacks, we created a new dataset
named VLPrompt fake news (VLPFN) containing real and fake texts. Our
experiments, including various detection methods and novel human study metrics,
were conducted to assess their performance on our dataset, yielding numerous
findings.
|
[
-0.24719174206256866,
-1.0085148811340332,
0.7423343658447266,
0.02317162975668907,
-0.4383416473865509,
0.030043836683034897,
0.08234454691410065,
-0.5026864409446716,
0.2959921061992645,
0.38345178961753845,
-0.9218761324882507,
-0.26767879724502563,
-0.4169851839542389,
0.4367285668849945,
-0.2760063707828522,
0.7534897923469543,
0.015685776248574257,
0.23744651675224304,
-0.10474833101034164,
0.0643094927072525,
-0.4704849123954773,
-0.6166396737098694,
-0.4392554461956024,
-0.18833445012569427,
0.7118327617645264,
0.28057387471199036,
0.3678223788738251,
0.30560341477394104,
0.23601825535297394,
0.18822036683559418,
0.06449011713266373,
0.2808215618133545,
-0.3249513506889343,
0.18623945116996765,
0.031966760754585266,
-0.5564107298851013,
-0.13907653093338013,
0.2017333209514618,
0.43235471844673157,
0.2502337694168091,
-0.22853736579418182,
0.04462134465575218,
-0.07352030277252197,
0.6021175980567932,
-0.38517138361930847,
-0.2774088680744171,
-0.6344114542007446,
0.3181449770927429,
-0.051371388137340546,
-0.33381402492523193,
-0.41526171565055847,
-0.22290517389774323,
-0.023693403229117393,
-0.38900405168533325,
0.5226518511772156,
0.309436559677124,
0.9816776514053345,
0.17296487092971802,
-0.5140347480773926,
-0.4507768154144287,
-0.43907833099365234,
0.28358590602874756,
-0.7271861433982849,
0.22119870781898499,
0.37942999601364136,
0.41727134585380554,
-0.24417813122272491,
-0.5904859304428101,
-0.9580740332603455,
-0.5787875652313232,
-0.09141705930233002,
0.3263618052005768,
-0.5780107975006104,
-0.008619498461484909,
0.3375648558139801,
0.4532574415206909,
-0.7021271586418152,
0.41063177585601807,
-0.24266643822193146,
-0.5144275426864624,
0.26350119709968567,
0.13274706900119781,
0.48961642384529114,
-0.5411033034324646,
-0.6033053398132324,
-0.19311515986919403,
-0.6995486617088318,
-0.13529007136821747,
0.531589686870575,
0.05344867706298828,
-0.443320095539093,
0.5797415971755981,
-0.29594528675079346,
0.8041171431541443,
0.20939725637435913,
-0.03348974138498306,
0.1293865442276001,
-0.3972925543785095,
-0.4243758022785187,
0.2242499440908432,
0.7210388779640198,
0.3844601809978485,
0.02464723214507103,
0.23437950015068054,
-0.24906830489635468,
0.13764570653438568,
0.3744848370552063,
-0.6623435020446777,
-0.05305466428399086,
0.11026912182569504,
-0.6201228499412537,
-0.6815632581710815,
-0.034680090844631195,
-0.8001869320869446,
-0.7136494517326355,
-0.2296658307313919,
0.4297453463077545,
-0.333589643239975,
-0.2446722388267517,
0.15650221705436707,
-0.17351043224334717,
0.3861987590789795,
0.4344886839389801,
-0.405470073223114,
-0.021376213058829308,
0.41433823108673096,
0.6314312815666199,
-0.15736685693264008,
0.0506310760974884,
-0.6599407196044922,
-0.2979026734828949,
-0.1911337673664093,
0.7688387632369995,
-0.09459096938371658,
-0.4531022608280182,
0.1579515039920807,
0.0031665218994021416,
0.14428898692131042,
-0.6478936672210693,
0.8263466954231262,
-0.5500916838645935,
0.7266221642494202,
-0.6276921033859253,
-0.553085207939148,
0.059552814811468124,
0.7219993472099304,
-0.7267149686813354,
0.7530008554458618,
0.15127462148666382,
-0.7922478318214417,
0.4815947711467743,
-0.28814610838890076,
-0.48983821272850037,
0.10857772827148438,
-0.4552534818649292,
-0.5803735256195068,
0.20702679455280304,
0.550421416759491,
0.27859121561050415,
-0.27081558108329773,
0.22234326601028442,
0.07539433985948563,
-0.0706712007522583,
0.4707689881324768,
-1.1006406545639038,
0.6578940153121948,
0.16818135976791382,
-0.5257818698883057,
-0.08680792152881622,
-0.5590749382972717,
-0.30654090642929077,
0.30894601345062256,
-0.30387169122695923,
-0.2332027703523636,
-0.3534088730812073,
-0.18796145915985107,
0.1873559206724167,
0.09650571644306183,
-0.4940992295742035,
0.4005705714225769,
-0.3878605365753174,
-0.04112730175256729,
0.6892263889312744,
0.33789047598838806,
0.010919944383203983,
-0.6930950880050659,
0.6948802471160889,
0.05601714551448822,
0.17179343104362488,
-0.3580390214920044,
-0.516051173210144,
-0.606200635433197,
-0.35111886262893677,
0.25250110030174255,
0.6260510087013245,
-0.9713001847267151,
0.3017866015434265,
-0.04598531499505043,
-0.035076238214969635,
-0.5759985446929932,
-0.29556897282600403,
0.4341224730014801,
0.9913528561592102,
0.3584977388381958,
0.10888093709945679,
-0.675137460231781,
-0.8310852646827698,
-0.629092812538147,
-0.16428229212760925,
-0.21181678771972656,
0.18522299826145172,
0.29421672224998474,
-0.12584243714809418,
0.8816304802894592,
-0.2030511498451233,
-0.144398033618927,
-0.2264166623353958,
0.2201458215713501,
0.25723007321357727,
0.16196364164352417,
0.5128037333488464,
-1.113600730895996,
-0.4306904673576355,
-0.5259270668029785,
-0.8000604510307312,
-0.4260116517543793,
-0.43041184544563293,
0.3132334053516388,
0.34761595726013184,
0.5351518988609314,
-0.5454996824264526,
0.5281553268432617,
0.5193674564361572,
-0.4452801048755646,
0.862024188041687,
-0.2628406584262848,
0.4768888056278229,
-0.9304788708686829,
-0.10851369053125381,
0.015803135931491852,
-0.3720363676548004,
-0.7361838817596436,
-0.19477351009845734,
0.16200514137744904,
-0.1281263679265976,
-0.5795182585716248,
0.6980057954788208,
-0.5411617755889893,
0.2657129764556885,
-0.2639198303222656,
-0.10646615922451019,
0.0758172944188118,
0.07152146846055984,
-0.1355983316898346,
0.6537655591964722,
0.2729014456272125,
-0.4580000638961792,
0.35788586735725403,
-0.08170467615127563,
-0.28303757309913635,
0.8420014977455139,
-0.6436618566513062,
-0.0924268290400505,
-0.32089468836784363,
0.6227084398269653,
-1.0537946224212646,
-0.5628747940063477,
0.6436453461647034,
-0.6758162379264832,
0.13524310290813446,
-0.04280121624469757,
-0.8263158202171326,
-0.6516644954681396,
-0.34683310985565186,
0.07801131904125214,
0.7223939895629883,
-0.730368971824646,
0.3461422026157379,
-0.08408339321613312,
0.27669066190719604,
-0.42943352460861206,
-0.7697584629058838,
0.4810807406902313,
-0.23765039443969727,
-0.4180621802806854,
0.4133555293083191,
-0.1578313708305359,
-0.32245197892189026,
-0.08761101961135864,
-0.38724416494369507,
0.21150359511375427,
-0.05283525586128235,
0.17491306364536285,
0.3580077290534973,
-0.11463648080825806,
-0.14144498109817505,
0.03291863203048706,
-0.03311470150947571,
0.19848866760730743,
-0.17234490811824799,
0.500190019607544,
0.15420317649841309,
-0.6346590518951416,
-1.1112339496612549,
0.2440798282623291,
0.4581146538257599,
0.23344139754772186,
0.7007706165313721,
0.583926260471344,
-0.46514686942100525,
-0.27179595828056335,
-0.7182262539863586,
-0.6527956128120422,
-0.5190169215202332,
-0.05066898837685585,
-0.03374014422297478,
-0.7425466775894165,
0.19521375000476837,
0.0007621403783559799,
-0.27099716663360596,
0.1635710448026657,
0.5940567255020142,
-0.08219629526138306,
0.852660596370697,
0.2428952306509018,
-0.1420316845178604,
0.4141818583011627,
-0.01275693066418171,
0.03406009450554848,
-0.2600841820240021,
-0.23659756779670715,
-0.09964552521705627,
0.0041299727745354176,
-0.412973016500473,
-0.47351717948913574,
0.37427595257759094,
-0.03242683410644531,
0.18328948318958282,
0.04305143654346466,
-0.5551769137382507,
0.4799785912036896,
0.49024564027786255,
0.30835989117622375,
0.23081925511360168,
0.33133113384246826,
-0.11029642075300217,
-0.22230352461338043,
-0.738440990447998,
-0.23863540589809418,
0.7872691750526428,
0.27712559700012207,
0.5130267143249512,
0.05076628923416138,
0.5887605547904968,
0.8282440304756165,
0.5038625001907349,
-0.6718710064888,
0.4394918382167816,
0.19568488001823425,
-0.4453067183494568,
-0.00496468972414732,
-0.3506292700767517,
-0.918226420879364,
0.328121155500412,
-0.21973752975463867,
-0.3329560160636902,
0.09017060697078705,
0.3870072364807129,
-0.3536396622657776,
0.29227280616760254,
-0.41670307517051697,
0.27444618940353394,
-0.3610613942146301,
-0.09010224044322968,
0.022070730105042458,
-0.5639443397521973,
0.35180991888046265,
-0.0201884713023901,
0.38894060254096985,
-0.0802423357963562,
0.02889767661690712,
0.23443849384784698,
-0.34489381313323975,
1.1629760265350342,
-0.23864944279193878,
-0.24733111262321472,
0.09431380033493042,
0.07715892046689987,
0.7955318093299866,
0.238958939909935,
-0.04143216460943222,
-0.029635079205036163,
-0.5529135465621948,
-0.4213443994522095,
-0.27006229758262634,
0.5912741422653198,
-0.41026628017425537,
-0.8060289621353149,
-0.5279513597488403,
-0.3126143515110016,
-0.14498017728328705,
0.11003261804580688,
0.7082807421684265,
0.32954323291778564,
-0.2905176877975464,
0.008756961673498154,
0.8488491177558899,
-0.3739400804042816,
0.3335109055042267,
0.7176045179367065,
0.01586463861167431,
-0.38475072383880615,
0.8175913691520691,
-0.026126211509108543,
0.1264505535364151,
0.311398446559906,
0.40298694372177124,
-0.2727227509021759,
-0.4116886556148529,
-0.5202295780181885,
0.22738341987133026,
-0.4522784948348999,
-0.19367896020412445,
-0.42281872034072876,
-0.16670937836170197,
-0.5766451358795166,
-0.2419643998146057,
0.04988028109073639,
0.11337338387966156,
-0.5024951100349426,
-0.15289781987667084,
0.2254139482975006,
0.5415083765983582,
-0.24692240357398987,
0.3108445703983307,
-0.6748524904251099,
0.7686838507652283,
0.547439694404602,
-0.18525473773479462,
-0.1589505672454834,
-0.5296363234519958,
0.07010731846094131,
0.1869359165430069,
-0.09808923304080963,
-1.0756263732910156,
0.6210843324661255,
-0.25191375613212585,
0.7949888706207275,
0.3307819068431854,
0.4220008850097656,
0.2374984323978424,
-0.46185314655303955,
1.0334270000457764,
0.4081009030342102,
-0.6315646171569824,
0.5339660048484802,
-0.6658034324645996,
0.31545811891555786,
0.4478963315486908,
0.5114555358886719,
-0.5538323521614075,
-0.2479037344455719,
-0.8015344738960266,
-0.6888046860694885,
0.36080309748649597,
0.2704603374004364,
0.22670763731002808,
0.026419786736369133,
0.4362700283527374,
0.10454530268907547,
0.31639838218688965,
-0.9348226189613342,
-0.39896172285079956,
-0.22016173601150513,
-0.228122279047966,
0.4234558939933777,
-0.4608120620250702,
-0.2819838225841522,
0.03172268718481064,
0.20924589037895203,
0.009186401031911373,
0.36356234550476074,
0.6848675608634949,
-0.16776005923748016,
-0.06909939646720886,
0.1343231052160263,
0.8901246786117554,
0.432708740234375,
0.11436660587787628,
0.3089435398578644,
0.20065391063690186,
-0.4568839967250824,
0.2385985404253006,
0.05032174661755562,
-0.16118186712265015,
0.20985069870948792,
0.5589557886123657,
0.8729537129402161,
-0.05410906299948692,
-0.7360342741012573,
0.8564345836639404,
-0.22342433035373688,
-0.4425325393676758,
-0.33528420329093933,
0.0384664312005043,
-0.19445545971393585,
0.1548556089401245,
0.7712841629981995,
-0.2164011299610138,
0.09073955565690994,
-0.46008768677711487,
0.33817118406295776,
0.2805524468421936,
-0.4363550543785095,
-0.2988021671772003,
0.6955071091651917,
-0.007304759696125984,
-0.567983090877533,
0.4562726318836212,
-0.16480426490306854,
-0.6167486906051636,
0.7557827234268188,
0.6537818908691406,
0.46906203031539917,
-0.307372123003006,
0.455681174993515,
0.08550858497619629,
0.4909517168998718,
-0.18220792710781097,
0.22621621191501617,
0.04179356247186661,
-0.6197260618209839,
-0.17534171044826508,
-0.34036925435066223,
-0.4129292070865631,
0.6495636701583862,
-0.4993482530117035,
0.1983105093240738,
-0.3216857612133026,
0.023302819579839706,
-0.13432250916957855,
-0.1997261792421341,
-0.5272185206413269,
0.32396450638771057,
0.5589404106140137,
0.9382363557815552,
-0.8708650469779968,
0.6595360636711121,
0.37654444575309753,
-0.1681961715221405,
-0.4602561891078949,
0.612299382686615,
0.5542829036712646,
-0.8756622076034546,
0.5902975797653198,
0.45296144485473633,
0.03849968686699867,
-0.12526273727416992,
-0.779225766658783,
-0.3118579387664795,
0.7874802947044373,
0.5540019869804382,
-0.8101997971534729,
-0.16579288244247437,
0.3644265830516815,
0.44733726978302,
-0.300218403339386,
-0.2165464162826538,
0.14140936732292175,
0.669043242931366,
-0.08876053988933563,
-0.6651328802108765,
0.30263829231262207,
-0.023410063236951828,
-0.2078101485967636,
-0.2009890228509903,
-0.5749779939651489,
0.8176954388618469,
0.04178384318947792,
-0.20228514075279236,
-0.16232551634311676,
0.6713333129882812,
0.5108331441879272,
0.5614598989486694,
0.6819301247596741,
0.40370693802833557,
0.827744722366333,
0.2169976830482483,
1.2487096786499023,
-0.0983511209487915,
0.07079299539327621,
0.9462259411811829,
-0.10938727855682373,
0.3591093420982361,
0.43088001012802124,
0.11644597351551056,
0.6491133570671082,
0.6969352960586548,
-0.19805002212524414,
0.4362271726131439,
0.4748424291610718,
-0.6223435401916504,
-0.23524153232574463,
-0.016510343179106712,
-0.34526389837265015,
0.08830750733613968,
0.5115103721618652,
-0.45172789692878723,
-0.2921575903892517,
0.6216612458229065,
0.2630805969238281,
0.16640155017375946,
-0.17179323732852936,
0.3966415226459503,
0.15421666204929352,
-0.5969902873039246,
0.6394551396369934,
-0.12251633405685425,
0.9131391048431396,
-0.48484209179878235,
-0.09911958873271942,
-0.316935271024704,
-0.3259812593460083,
0.09265895932912827,
-0.43261536955833435,
0.022658037021756172,
0.0004093094321433455,
-0.29120272397994995,
-0.39218372106552124,
0.9864069223403931,
-0.2493143230676651,
-0.247808575630188,
0.037135813385248184,
0.6021664142608643,
-0.14249566197395325,
-0.10622170567512512,
-0.8463663458824158,
0.14249201118946075,
0.14175212383270264,
-0.4468570947647095,
0.38408371806144714,
0.37721890211105347,
-0.0315483957529068,
0.46286073327064514,
0.9712035059928894,
0.22167757153511047,
-0.11926976591348648,
0.07778553664684296,
0.7734556198120117,
-0.6070291996002197,
-0.5023300051689148,
-0.9585486650466919,
0.26598310470581055,
-0.37695184350013733,
-0.11534373462200165,
0.9391748905181885,
0.304427832365036,
0.4345569312572479,
-0.0581284761428833,
0.8380091786384583,
0.015277952887117863,
0.5575056672096252,
-0.7053143382072449,
0.8225280046463013,
-0.4984337091445923,
0.38731661438941956,
0.11857008934020996,
-0.21703419089317322,
-0.37011292576789856,
0.18777720630168915,
-0.24689200520515442,
-0.24906863272190094,
0.4828944802284241,
0.756367027759552,
-0.07251328229904175,
-0.11429113149642944,
0.42628535628318787,
0.28082916140556335,
0.39299026131629944,
-0.04213452339172363,
0.9534044861793518,
-0.15152797102928162,
0.3811432719230652,
0.09112051129341125,
-0.18559369444847107,
-0.69134521484375,
-1.09004807472229,
-0.915152907371521,
-0.42086586356163025,
-0.1784174144268036,
-0.6672699451446533,
0.3338877558708191,
0.6864410042762756,
0.5503278970718384,
-0.5471351146697998,
0.3381076455116272,
-0.41302940249443054,
0.02444317564368248,
0.07938599586486816,
-0.29115524888038635,
0.46166855096817017,
-0.164437398314476,
-0.4724927246570587,
0.7970905303955078,
-0.058273445814847946,
0.5040390491485596,
-0.3974500894546509,
0.1748218834400177,
0.008744344115257263,
0.38469287753105164,
0.437206894159317,
0.44433262944221497,
-0.7132397294044495,
-0.1983279585838318,
0.12317777425050735,
-0.2565125823020935,
-0.041850488632917404,
0.9444473385810852,
-1.2303138971328735,
0.3689640760421753,
0.5570182800292969,
0.47469598054885864,
0.2710791230201721,
0.04157601296901703,
0.622725784778595,
-0.9339039325714111,
0.2687191963195801,
0.2984772026538849,
0.14945605397224426,
0.4379604160785675,
-0.8336659669876099,
0.12818960845470428,
0.5996670722961426,
-0.3153057098388672,
-1.1781760454177856,
0.355062335729599,
-0.8481656312942505,
-0.6068611145019531,
1.2777361869812012,
0.09304261207580566,
-0.36760878562927246,
-0.2018125355243683,
-0.5083776712417603,
0.17272861301898956,
-0.45737865567207336,
0.7674226760864258,
0.27552899718284607,
-0.31887078285217285,
-0.14956042170524597,
-0.716857373714447,
0.7777621150016785,
0.2996913492679596,
-0.8694552183151245,
-0.1323518007993698,
0.5596487522125244,
0.32505759596824646,
-0.10753579437732697,
0.6944783926010132,
0.1609475314617157,
0.43053439259529114,
-0.011568623594939709,
-0.2780853509902954,
-0.2312782257795334,
-0.06573843210935593,
-0.5196511149406433,
0.19510191679000854,
-0.41658902168273926,
-0.0065163979306817055
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18182v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18182v1
|
ZAEBUC-Spoken: A Multilingual Multidialectal Arabic-English Speech Corpus
| 2024-03-27T01:19:23 | 2024-03-27T01:19:23 |
Injy Hamed, Fadhl Eryani, David Palfreyman, Nizar Habash
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present ZAEBUC-Spoken, a multilingual multidialectal Arabic-English speech
corpus. The corpus comprises twelve hours of Zoom meetings involving multiple
speakers role-playing a work situation where Students brainstorm ideas for a
certain topic and then discuss it with an Interlocutor. The meetings cover
different topics and are divided into phases with different language setups.
The corpus presents a challenging set for automatic speech recognition (ASR),
including two languages (Arabic and English) with Arabic spoken in multiple
variants (Modern Standard Arabic, Gulf Arabic, and Egyptian Arabic) and English
used with various accents. Adding to the complexity of the corpus, there is
also code-switching between these languages and dialects. As part of our work,
we take inspiration from established sets of transcription guidelines to
present a set of guidelines handling issues of conversational speech,
code-switching and orthography of both languages. We further enrich the corpus
with two layers of annotations; (1) dialectness level annotation for the
portion of the corpus where mixing occurs between different variants of Arabic,
and (2) automatic morphological annotations, including tokenization,
lemmatization, and part-of-speech tagging.
|
[
-0.5195292234420776,
-0.4022781252861023,
-0.004638211335986853,
0.5914807915687561,
-0.16407854855060577,
0.4174294173717499,
-0.5237317681312561,
-0.6469641327857971,
0.2286117970943451,
0.4776019752025604,
-0.4114486277103424,
-0.6579421162605286,
-0.35030728578567505,
0.27293872833251953,
-0.46227791905403137,
0.878093957901001,
0.19745485484600067,
0.5635598301887512,
0.23748864233493805,
-0.2927815914154053,
-0.3375559449195862,
-0.5892946124076843,
-0.4449756443500519,
-0.3006940484046936,
0.6397790312767029,
0.8442760109901428,
0.9527422785758972,
0.2674085795879364,
0.10913306474685669,
0.29008665680885315,
-0.0322190560400486,
0.0985487550497055,
0.12983663380146027,
0.20073412358760834,
-0.0426357239484787,
-0.1957922726869583,
-0.3395009934902191,
-0.37658998370170593,
0.6013442277908325,
0.9080930948257446,
-0.23798178136348724,
-0.04179031401872635,
-0.08262009173631668,
0.5231983661651611,
-0.4033532440662384,
-0.035545989871025085,
-0.4716396629810333,
-0.11062660068273544,
-0.5135635137557983,
-0.08712548017501831,
-0.2819323241710663,
-0.30635809898376465,
0.016043592244386673,
-0.09250620007514954,
0.14281585812568665,
-0.376198947429657,
0.5837515592575073,
0.1396491676568985,
-0.5702672600746155,
-0.7440032362937927,
-0.7002384662628174,
0.46835094690322876,
-0.4351584017276764,
0.5488457679748535,
0.6896844506263733,
0.24412401020526886,
0.10566994547843933,
-0.578275203704834,
-0.6830070614814758,
-0.14524422585964203,
0.09758159518241882,
0.20394128561019897,
-0.07572892308235168,
0.04509137570858002,
0.04347974807024002,
0.05067566782236099,
-0.5670563578605652,
0.08770573884248734,
-0.6639453172683716,
-0.4163028299808502,
0.4716635048389435,
-0.24595792591571808,
0.44976896047592163,
-0.20373260974884033,
-0.06511034071445465,
-0.10250213742256165,
-0.6136459112167358,
0.018421078100800514,
0.6982223391532898,
0.5874630212783813,
-0.15866586565971375,
0.396880567073822,
-0.0838271975517273,
0.5710653066635132,
-0.23892687261104584,
0.0569695383310318,
0.6499180197715759,
-0.17211003601551056,
0.07456369698047638,
0.40839478373527527,
0.5856814384460449,
0.15934491157531738,
0.20838022232055664,
-0.012415507808327675,
0.04635513573884964,
-0.18681184947490692,
0.14787085354328156,
-0.8206406831741333,
-0.4233415126800537,
0.3617832064628601,
-0.49831798672676086,
0.13386379182338715,
-0.07394872605800629,
-0.9528070688247681,
-0.25464656949043274,
-0.1887930929660797,
0.30581405758857727,
-0.7183133363723755,
-0.36280274391174316,
-0.04461798444390297,
-0.09928500652313232,
-0.021810075268149376,
0.3254276514053345,
-0.900344967842102,
0.24241934716701508,
0.1632286161184311,
0.7814282774925232,
0.1440187692642212,
-0.38500675559043884,
-0.2924695611000061,
0.1903919130563736,
-0.07931402325630188,
0.7497009038925171,
-0.695992112159729,
-0.7340473532676697,
0.3147267699241638,
-0.20340792834758759,
-0.15887904167175293,
-0.5341035723686218,
0.72632896900177,
-0.4199175238609314,
0.03196942061185837,
0.12339839339256287,
-0.2367863655090332,
-0.46983861923217773,
-0.12864889204502106,
-0.7374159097671509,
0.9321814179420471,
0.04349832236766815,
-0.3368132710456848,
0.14174965023994446,
-0.9635499119758606,
-0.8226823210716248,
0.33882641792297363,
-0.537509024143219,
-0.2915196716785431,
-0.26260900497436523,
0.3051677942276001,
0.23683610558509827,
0.15793460607528687,
-0.18923208117485046,
0.4533928334712982,
-0.0926838144659996,
0.40302643179893494,
-0.28804710507392883,
1.0251312255859375,
0.4175192713737488,
-0.530074417591095,
0.3274304270744324,
-0.968495786190033,
0.31280386447906494,
-0.32820069789886475,
-0.46551284193992615,
-0.038119491189718246,
0.2499021738767624,
0.9101493954658508,
0.29610171914100647,
0.28954851627349854,
-0.531140148639679,
0.11800547689199448,
-0.18472124636173248,
0.5790848135948181,
0.36608651280403137,
-0.33197179436683655,
0.132455974817276,
-0.36158642172813416,
0.48810967803001404,
0.20780500769615173,
-0.2251608669757843,
-0.2124800831079483,
-0.5003700256347656,
-0.9287496209144592,
-0.5316724181175232,
0.48345884680747986,
0.7172715663909912,
-0.7116321921348572,
0.28303834795951843,
-0.09737274050712585,
-0.6556801199913025,
-0.7078106999397278,
0.13350608944892883,
0.29868996143341064,
-0.2553001046180725,
0.6089866161346436,
-0.017979109659790993,
-0.7604241967201233,
-1.0421775579452515,
0.22128014266490936,
-0.20145364105701447,
0.043176714330911636,
0.34277403354644775,
0.4359515905380249,
-0.46363040804862976,
0.7785838842391968,
0.05216020345687866,
-0.5016723275184631,
-0.7293981313705444,
0.49309760332107544,
0.2448250949382782,
0.6447666883468628,
0.5794751644134521,
-0.8395314812660217,
-0.8448578119277954,
0.18142980337142944,
-0.08944019675254822,
-0.22767658531665802,
-0.22639337182044983,
0.2797369062900543,
0.5110191702842712,
0.671355664730072,
-0.11599595099687576,
0.4233570694923401,
0.9179268479347229,
-0.1288737803697586,
0.5866187810897827,
-0.2286156564950943,
0.44198235869407654,
-1.1431853771209717,
-0.10333554446697235,
-0.5430836081504822,
-0.23485127091407776,
-0.7659881114959717,
-0.13653703033924103,
0.33520975708961487,
-0.09056250751018524,
-0.3572191596031189,
0.1554582417011261,
-0.5458215475082397,
0.06799588352441788,
-0.32013240456581116,
-0.06296642869710922,
-0.295119047164917,
0.35561543703079224,
0.2563844323158264,
1.2500176429748535,
0.6978460550308228,
-0.6604141592979431,
0.38061487674713135,
0.4748093783855438,
-0.5516040325164795,
0.5247493386268616,
-0.5536259412765503,
0.3245445787906647,
0.11383547633886337,
0.0885988175868988,
-0.9551090002059937,
-0.1777733713388443,
0.13499601185321808,
-0.7746617794036865,
0.3085389733314514,
-0.07257891446352005,
-0.5172588229179382,
0.03449920937418938,
-0.23240268230438232,
0.5855150818824768,
0.028194664046168327,
-0.4940875470638275,
0.8491538763046265,
0.5034857392311096,
-0.6715638041496277,
-0.4290061295032501,
-0.5597135424613953,
0.3382410705089569,
-0.018429946154356003,
-0.7679795026779175,
0.4478887915611267,
-0.18777315318584442,
-0.22674548625946045,
-0.3022896945476532,
0.19796766340732574,
-0.38599321246147156,
-0.18881531059741974,
0.6394032835960388,
0.08396723121404648,
-0.1894209384918213,
0.0709879919886589,
0.20043325424194336,
0.14555706083774567,
-0.13735687732696533,
0.2401076704263687,
1.0259066820144653,
-0.20848123729228973,
-0.3198701739311218,
-0.32245370745658875,
1.0201172828674316,
0.4364512264728546,
-0.19417023658752441,
0.6253403425216675,
0.6743957996368408,
-0.5465299487113953,
0.0546029731631279,
-0.6284416913986206,
0.17823901772499084,
-0.4345850944519043,
0.5889394879341125,
-0.7284655570983887,
-0.6410471200942993,
0.8039330840110779,
0.21379926800727844,
0.17664065957069397,
0.2673201560974121,
0.9698423147201538,
-0.18903499841690063,
0.7684938907623291,
0.4634271264076233,
-0.26599279046058655,
0.5456432104110718,
0.07049451768398285,
0.033440764993429184,
-0.545754075050354,
-0.2379654496908188,
-0.9337804913520813,
-0.04935820400714874,
-0.509686291217804,
-0.4286084473133087,
0.44037264585494995,
-0.1275046169757843,
0.23202256858348846,
0.6665720343589783,
0.004895747173577547,
0.3982766270637512,
0.7202601432800293,
0.09677939862012863,
0.14230193197727203,
-0.03218286484479904,
-0.15927429497241974,
-0.04468458145856857,
-0.5213807821273804,
-0.540581464767456,
0.8403691053390503,
0.037780649960041046,
0.5657663345336914,
0.5799883604049683,
0.6806156039237976,
0.5376348495483398,
-0.1330748200416565,
-0.7404409646987915,
0.43459469079971313,
0.0036366761196404696,
-0.7771450281143188,
-0.27440109848976135,
-0.25400620698928833,
-1.1136258840560913,
0.5182835459709167,
-0.08456157147884369,
-0.7510519623756409,
0.1987224668264389,
-0.013829121366143227,
-0.6222917437553406,
0.0712663009762764,
-0.667207658290863,
0.5870535373687744,
-0.054635606706142426,
-0.13517114520072937,
-0.7251954674720764,
-0.9678706526756287,
-0.34875768423080444,
0.11221107095479965,
0.4875674843788147,
0.024888014420866966,
0.159080371260643,
0.8363831639289856,
-0.14252609014511108,
0.7287552952766418,
0.20523719489574432,
0.0719204694032669,
0.11555537581443787,
0.03152196854352951,
-0.15796370804309845,
0.06237975135445595,
-0.16272501647472382,
0.535101056098938,
0.3301173746585846,
-0.3144057095050812,
0.02841198444366455,
0.28757724165916443,
-0.9087372422218323,
-0.27134862542152405,
-0.7994848489761353,
-0.6088471412658691,
-0.2519245743751526,
0.24981647729873657,
0.22998684644699097,
0.7478391528129578,
-0.405463844537735,
0.31008607149124146,
0.23860083520412445,
-0.3732962906360626,
0.4550556540489197,
0.6421950459480286,
-0.2603820860385895,
-0.6247757077217102,
0.9927866458892822,
0.21123996376991272,
0.13193203508853912,
0.19157640635967255,
-0.1449829787015915,
-0.16794973611831665,
-0.5645750761032104,
-0.8157418966293335,
0.1927231401205063,
-0.7475141286849976,
-0.1986420601606369,
-0.7121898531913757,
-0.5000511407852173,
-0.7550218105316162,
-0.25302794575691223,
-0.2518393099308014,
-0.531990110874176,
-0.3041803240776062,
0.02870037406682968,
0.19804438948631287,
0.6417140364646912,
-0.5787046551704407,
0.2640850245952606,
-0.8565535545349121,
0.30858922004699707,
-0.021889839321374893,
-0.14222750067710876,
-0.3881966173648834,
-0.6646699905395508,
-0.4399641454219818,
0.11777667701244354,
-0.1658886820077896,
-1.0655571222305298,
0.4378727078437805,
0.7077399492263794,
0.47992372512817383,
0.45806166529655457,
-0.03477531671524048,
0.6395471692085266,
-0.8545913696289062,
0.6706602573394775,
0.14046353101730347,
-0.9948195815086365,
0.42360636591911316,
-0.27935001254081726,
0.4744594991207123,
0.6905706524848938,
0.46353164315223694,
-1.0385686159133911,
-0.6073710918426514,
-0.3977419137954712,
-1.1155929565429688,
0.6264631748199463,
0.3528091609477997,
0.2334519773721695,
-0.14627143740653992,
-0.4332824945449829,
0.29859787225723267,
0.26201164722442627,
-0.5237952470779419,
-0.617808997631073,
-0.39547199010849,
-0.09836647659540176,
0.1523895263671875,
-0.5847500562667847,
-0.2152327597141266,
-0.44686123728752136,
0.7583345770835876,
0.10690177977085114,
0.32485395669937134,
0.06029350683093071,
-0.6024065613746643,
0.10612817108631134,
0.6943112015724182,
0.8745187520980835,
0.8289446234703064,
-0.24228139221668243,
0.27675220370292664,
-0.03366060554981232,
-0.8430456519126892,
-0.16664725542068481,
0.48364290595054626,
-0.10782823711633682,
0.41900739073753357,
0.2166711986064911,
0.4886895716190338,
0.24510085582733154,
-0.9386203289031982,
0.18633803725242615,
0.04921424761414528,
-0.24700669944286346,
-0.8701019883155823,
-0.18206144869327545,
0.135890930891037,
0.2884279787540436,
0.6209547519683838,
-0.013612178154289722,
0.2976331114768982,
-0.7747019529342651,
0.3225089907646179,
0.11026538163423538,
-0.1738107055425644,
-0.06636942923069,
0.3300904631614685,
0.6437613368034363,
-0.499294251203537,
0.6017946004867554,
-0.08548130840063095,
-0.931885838508606,
0.5007691979408264,
0.45158880949020386,
0.42181509733200073,
-0.5954908728599548,
0.3203713595867157,
0.44292041659355164,
0.2478000521659851,
0.3505639433860779,
0.539856493473053,
-0.24972477555274963,
-1.0166352987289429,
0.10389047861099243,
-0.2422734647989273,
-0.782051682472229,
-0.07574450224637985,
-0.9366679787635803,
0.10703587532043457,
-0.12031727284193039,
-0.15662680566310883,
0.34339824318885803,
-0.10768529772758484,
-0.3387361764907837,
-0.0031143357045948505,
0.16251398622989655,
0.5939808487892151,
-0.5372273921966553,
1.106432557106018,
0.6902832388877869,
-0.5062553286552429,
-0.39415985345840454,
-0.25608816742897034,
-0.061401791870594025,
-0.7375530004501343,
0.5326969623565674,
0.300483763217926,
-0.3926980197429657,
0.1308232694864273,
-0.04587269574403763,
-0.5649335980415344,
0.675585150718689,
-0.03076377883553505,
-0.45367491245269775,
0.3163222074508667,
0.14470015466213226,
0.16707609593868256,
-0.10075385868549347,
0.42662328481674194,
0.5860477685928345,
0.40236252546310425,
-0.0073968032374978065,
-1.3419325351715088,
-0.41964104771614075,
-0.33902230858802795,
-0.4243656396865845,
0.12571345269680023,
-0.48637863993644714,
0.9179970622062683,
-0.2705897390842438,
-0.40804922580718994,
0.364959716796875,
0.9119211435317993,
-0.24886545538902283,
0.08241671323776245,
0.5898590087890625,
0.08281473070383072,
0.7995460033416748,
-0.00690680043771863,
0.34120306372642517,
-0.41136157512664795,
-0.09396259486675262,
1.3713105916976929,
-0.4968889653682709,
1.071106195449829,
0.53425532579422,
-0.12740522623062134,
0.6204662322998047,
0.5139421224594116,
0.13615202903747559,
0.43807482719421387,
-0.013092352077364922,
-0.7020024657249451,
-0.14003250002861023,
-0.18625254929065704,
-0.7684507966041565,
0.5796664953231812,
0.6434028148651123,
-0.14008711278438568,
-0.23742280900478363,
0.19275997579097748,
0.3009837865829468,
0.1976659744977951,
-0.24583472311496735,
0.6718468070030212,
-0.29262930154800415,
-0.272519052028656,
0.3276239335536957,
0.20707879960536957,
0.7107451558113098,
-0.6469688415527344,
0.003455282188951969,
0.06300061196088791,
0.10210295021533966,
-0.4229176938533783,
-0.5903794169425964,
0.3044980466365814,
0.06198028847575188,
-0.13104628026485443,
-0.19047605991363525,
0.2604477107524872,
-0.8557412028312683,
-0.5816629528999329,
0.29351481795310974,
0.5268349051475525,
0.4862252175807953,
0.022352809086441994,
-0.4390452802181244,
0.3318064510822296,
0.07822670787572861,
0.1377016007900238,
0.22433185577392578,
0.16124239563941956,
0.1265808641910553,
0.5851139426231384,
0.40198057889938354,
0.19272609055042267,
0.20965813100337982,
0.6290573477745056,
0.7849422693252563,
-0.6550085544586182,
-0.5030588507652283,
-0.5949134826660156,
0.3869243264198303,
-0.16404388844966888,
-0.43463417887687683,
0.6415355205535889,
0.8161576390266418,
0.86577308177948,
-0.130888432264328,
0.9264950156211853,
-0.31037312746047974,
0.7203502655029297,
-0.5136126279830933,
0.9030142426490784,
-0.23350992798805237,
-0.29716354608535767,
-0.2944699227809906,
-0.6333373188972473,
-0.29971811175346375,
1.4054452180862427,
0.1107393428683281,
-0.12452317774295807,
0.9171622395515442,
0.7879133224487305,
0.33135414123535156,
0.22171840071678162,
0.5271544456481934,
-0.00693447794765234,
0.2504393756389618,
0.4318453371524811,
0.7037068605422974,
-0.26907750964164734,
0.7065960764884949,
-0.17222745716571808,
-0.132823646068573,
-0.3247486352920532,
-0.5374861359596252,
-0.9172766804695129,
-0.9908660650253296,
-0.36764925718307495,
-0.3883732557296753,
0.14648397266864777,
1.5604982376098633,
0.5025234222412109,
-1.057398796081543,
-0.9703257083892822,
0.471393883228302,
-0.09233471006155014,
-0.26629728078842163,
-0.15127234160900116,
0.1703644096851349,
-0.15399686992168427,
-0.9388750791549683,
0.6628207564353943,
0.1380344182252884,
-0.027985326945781708,
-0.06873935461044312,
0.1546940803527832,
-0.6211065053939819,
-0.05646533519029617,
0.5532408356666565,
0.46631813049316406,
-0.494722843170166,
-0.3813197612762451,
-0.29623469710350037,
-0.2908613383769989,
0.22552332282066345,
0.8578646183013916,
-0.4225686490535736,
0.35307061672210693,
0.12370852380990982,
0.4367463290691376,
0.39659178256988525,
-0.19188033044338226,
0.454032838344574,
-0.6861367225646973,
0.5022952556610107,
0.4677577614784241,
0.4695385694503784,
0.3551759123802185,
0.1066303625702858,
0.35908031463623047,
-0.06722255051136017,
-0.5944129228591919,
-0.6899389028549194,
0.41155698895454407,
-1.1637747287750244,
-0.14818175137043,
1.2265890836715698,
-0.017099328339099884,
0.3677866458892822,
-0.7658514976501465,
-0.7306486964225769,
0.1921001672744751,
-0.8207789659500122,
0.7126119136810303,
0.994539737701416,
-0.19876357913017273,
-0.17776615917682648,
-0.4671853482723236,
0.38946816325187683,
0.3348058760166168,
-0.6470494866371155,
-0.20869994163513184,
0.5968052744865417,
0.07706017047166824,
0.30885079503059387,
0.7362014651298523,
0.06734011322259903,
0.5056193470954895,
0.003955865744501352,
0.42802032828330994,
0.05910507217049599,
-0.49661368131637573,
-0.274172306060791,
0.10617168247699738,
0.10931604355573654,
-0.43761885166168213
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18167v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18167v2
|
Mechanistic Understanding and Mitigation of Language Model Non-Factual Hallucinations
| 2024-03-27T00:23:03 | 2024-06-17T21:35:41 |
Lei Yu, Meng Cao, Jackie Chi Kit Cheung, Yue Dong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
State-of-the-art language models (LMs) sometimes generate non-factual
hallucinations that misalign with world knowledge. To explore the mechanistic
causes of these hallucinations, we create diagnostic datasets with
subject-relation queries and adapt interpretability methods to trace
hallucinations through internal model representations. We discover two general
and distinct mechanistic causes of hallucinations shared across LMs (Llama-2,
Pythia, GPT-J): 1) knowledge enrichment hallucinations: insufficient subject
attribute knowledge in lower layer MLPs, and 2) answer extraction
hallucinations: failure to select the correct object attribute in upper layer
attention heads. We also found these two internal mechanistic causes of
hallucinations are reflected in external manifestations. Based on insights from
our mechanistic analysis, we propose a novel hallucination mitigation method
through targeted restoration of the LM's internal fact recall pipeline,
demonstrating superior performance compared to baselines.
|
[
-0.209589883685112,
-0.9586629867553711,
0.693430483341217,
-0.13010679185390472,
0.09782161563634872,
-0.009458176791667938,
-0.07156810909509659,
-0.5335850715637207,
0.38188374042510986,
0.7287878394126892,
-0.6631101965904236,
-0.0763377770781517,
-0.4586643576622009,
-0.054109103977680206,
-0.3701583445072174,
0.8884902000427246,
0.03763230890035629,
-0.08958406746387482,
-0.1873471587896347,
-0.08345088362693787,
-0.5512264966964722,
-0.8351910710334778,
-0.35797175765037537,
-0.38212719559669495,
0.4306524097919464,
0.32417404651641846,
0.7614814639091492,
0.1065838411450386,
0.41348668932914734,
0.1458972841501236,
0.13455317914485931,
0.2718188762664795,
-0.581222653388977,
0.09975864738225937,
-0.2850733697414398,
-0.42258381843566895,
-0.2668827474117279,
-0.29983600974082947,
0.21159042418003082,
0.8079565763473511,
-0.28115516901016235,
-0.07666830718517303,
0.10486306250095367,
0.7236515283584595,
-0.6804728507995605,
0.020804433152079582,
-0.7648951411247253,
0.25852447748184204,
-0.004319008439779282,
-0.44015929102897644,
-0.41539809107780457,
-0.037606071680784225,
0.13533028960227966,
-0.3596760034561157,
0.4080342650413513,
0.054529622197151184,
0.604758620262146,
0.6257482767105103,
-0.1359611600637436,
-0.6034777760505676,
-0.8571641445159912,
0.5306687355041504,
-0.5980048775672913,
0.4367024004459381,
0.4478689134120941,
0.24548262357711792,
-0.2242322415113449,
-0.42889589071273804,
-0.5830774307250977,
-0.3131542503833771,
-0.3812459111213684,
-0.2091355174779892,
-0.260304719209671,
0.004533426370471716,
0.36795487999916077,
0.32106226682662964,
-0.9069535136222839,
0.06003887206315994,
-0.6399129033088684,
-0.7352995276451111,
0.2656024694442749,
0.208814799785614,
0.4902380406856537,
-0.11153900623321533,
-0.09571856260299683,
0.05576736479997635,
-0.8334415555000305,
-0.08921053260564804,
0.25965169072151184,
0.2161225527524948,
0.19227811694145203,
0.5255447626113892,
-0.16716158390045166,
0.3488636910915375,
-0.22335880994796753,
-0.24433259665966034,
0.05259190499782562,
-0.3252008259296417,
-0.2647903561592102,
0.4530266225337982,
0.4585544168949127,
0.13245397806167603,
0.34888195991516113,
-0.6106760501861572,
0.04661994054913521,
0.09479659050703049,
0.34993043541908264,
-0.6964101195335388,
-0.47699108719825745,
0.4361714720726013,
-0.46015915274620056,
-0.25357967615127563,
-0.08172447234392166,
-0.6264135837554932,
-0.7207421660423279,
-0.3676093816757202,
0.5743127465248108,
-0.31129249930381775,
-0.6641784310340881,
0.19852405786514282,
-0.0739595890045166,
0.18584959208965302,
0.08286098390817642,
-0.9023680686950684,
0.15553753077983856,
0.41287827491760254,
0.8348879814147949,
-0.08919671922922134,
-0.35121750831604004,
-0.21910321712493896,
0.18895289301872253,
-0.26197242736816406,
0.7566856145858765,
-0.3463335633277893,
-0.16239862143993378,
-0.1057622879743576,
0.013228211551904678,
-0.008594198152422905,
-0.7866222858428955,
0.45526981353759766,
-0.21522720158100128,
0.23206938803195953,
-0.5183786153793335,
-0.30389195680618286,
-0.514818549156189,
-0.027286721393465996,
-0.5620256662368774,
0.7774803638458252,
-0.027007384225726128,
-0.6622406840324402,
0.10923169553279877,
-0.2785191535949707,
-0.31420961022377014,
-0.14224356412887573,
-0.11398839950561523,
-0.19616983830928802,
0.5091801285743713,
0.0866103246808052,
0.41321465373039246,
-0.31749802827835083,
0.5094017386436462,
-0.16795296967029572,
-0.443453848361969,
0.15481334924697876,
-0.39636629819869995,
0.6211435794830322,
0.1761576384305954,
-0.24463757872581482,
0.25916585326194763,
-0.761056125164032,
-0.37569379806518555,
0.20402641594409943,
0.25383272767066956,
-0.3163701295852661,
0.06689632683992386,
-0.2798507809638977,
0.3401550352573395,
0.09679309278726578,
-0.03481362387537956,
0.017587387934327126,
-0.2858850359916687,
0.1429632306098938,
0.6855883598327637,
0.3397054672241211,
0.32612839341163635,
-0.40425291657447815,
0.2587036192417145,
0.41090449690818787,
0.12454485893249512,
0.06820575892925262,
-0.3659772574901581,
-0.9326054453849792,
-0.02575520984828472,
-0.4593169689178467,
0.49716344475746155,
-0.697223424911499,
0.3769702613353729,
-0.08340778946876526,
-0.3338352143764496,
-0.4627872407436371,
0.0056882258504629135,
0.18937928974628448,
0.6950980424880981,
0.49977269768714905,
0.11750410497188568,
-0.5955823063850403,
-1.1194020509719849,
-0.18888254463672638,
-0.07793346792459488,
0.049332574009895325,
0.08454985916614532,
0.5313995480537415,
-0.48273923993110657,
0.5624746084213257,
-0.2676127552986145,
-0.5054756999015808,
-0.2740862965583801,
0.09304028749465942,
0.06582948565483093,
0.27211254835128784,
0.34870076179504395,
-0.27559056878089905,
0.09410757571458817,
-0.1675427109003067,
-0.9224212169647217,
-0.34327730536460876,
-0.4596315026283264,
-0.0982840284705162,
0.4540110230445862,
0.5112689733505249,
-0.556320309638977,
0.5120831727981567,
0.41354313492774963,
-0.46009019017219543,
0.8229874968528748,
-0.10820338875055313,
0.0944051593542099,
-0.843197226524353,
-0.12230950593948364,
-0.29166993498802185,
0.14276988804340363,
-0.5539928078651428,
-0.05662400647997856,
-0.10915447771549225,
-0.027254849672317505,
-0.12069976329803467,
0.25556227564811707,
-0.43568992614746094,
-0.16248507797718048,
-0.3184228837490082,
0.31730881333351135,
0.16133911907672882,
0.6636842489242554,
-0.0730392262339592,
0.7014206051826477,
0.6525803208351135,
-0.8123237490653992,
0.33527904748916626,
0.08672308176755905,
-0.2567448318004608,
0.23001320660114288,
-0.2456165999174118,
0.15914864838123322,
-0.30676358938217163,
-0.09373896569013596,
-0.8967914581298828,
-0.09407736361026764,
0.6067889332771301,
-0.2517651915550232,
0.24327263236045837,
0.27787503600120544,
-0.6213206648826599,
0.0613735169172287,
-0.26405781507492065,
0.13459542393684387,
0.30158674716949463,
-0.6922303438186646,
0.5096873641014099,
0.20033109188079834,
-0.03931720554828644,
-0.4385286271572113,
-0.5874433517456055,
0.20910228788852692,
-0.23070663213729858,
-0.4906521439552307,
0.1081027165055275,
0.0047569358721375465,
-0.5514826774597168,
-0.08724001795053482,
-0.33553704619407654,
0.1983305960893631,
0.2996222674846649,
-0.03199651092290878,
0.0029656565748155117,
-0.24748477339744568,
0.372601181268692,
0.1117606908082962,
-0.09430314600467682,
0.39431053400039673,
-0.05343196541070938,
0.7815563678741455,
0.17936304211616516,
-0.43885183334350586,
-0.5955702066421509,
0.1472686529159546,
0.5492329597473145,
0.0215718075633049,
0.8773813843727112,
0.28386011719703674,
-0.6162173748016357,
-0.2912837564945221,
-0.6766743659973145,
-0.8432683348655701,
-0.36713677644729614,
0.5324348211288452,
-0.5968360304832458,
-0.5979345440864563,
0.6582645773887634,
0.08303063362836838,
-0.32529187202453613,
0.3149729073047638,
0.6181498169898987,
0.062045592814683914,
0.7039155960083008,
0.299485981464386,
-0.18795986473560333,
0.09581907093524933,
0.001663931179791689,
0.5944292545318604,
-0.7451500296592712,
-0.5101629495620728,
-0.33542758226394653,
-0.17809656262397766,
-0.5495851039886475,
-0.43835943937301636,
0.3004547357559204,
0.056128956377506256,
0.01861579902470112,
0.0021140361204743385,
-0.44049906730651855,
0.4757046401500702,
0.23284022510051727,
0.1186920627951622,
0.38042429089546204,
0.21254096925258636,
-0.15346474945545197,
-0.19865170121192932,
-0.4877028167247772,
-0.6288591027259827,
0.8773518204689026,
0.31197771430015564,
0.7781639099121094,
0.2605874538421631,
0.4020542800426483,
0.20468966662883759,
-0.043156687170267105,
-0.556682825088501,
0.4241357445716858,
0.24807585775852203,
-0.5589448809623718,
-0.12270784378051758,
-0.3646225333213806,
-0.41315793991088867,
0.3814402222633362,
-0.11805470287799835,
-1.1722851991653442,
0.06799368560314178,
0.008886491879820824,
-0.08619789779186249,
0.32908663153648376,
-0.5655310750007629,
0.6654906272888184,
-0.27193766832351685,
-0.5370473265647888,
-0.45609745383262634,
-0.4063471555709839,
0.6978854537010193,
-0.06098465248942375,
0.16953922808170319,
-0.024067649617791176,
0.3761308193206787,
0.4873005449771881,
-0.24873705208301544,
0.9528206586837769,
-0.18850144743919373,
-0.4007123112678528,
0.1530720442533493,
0.430157333612442,
0.551466703414917,
-0.024996137246489525,
0.1402895152568817,
0.2835629880428314,
-0.10508997738361359,
-0.07585611194372177,
-0.7864981889724731,
0.7783296704292297,
-0.5795615911483765,
-0.8265834450721741,
-0.41852709650993347,
-0.7285141348838806,
-0.22431299090385437,
-0.30359476804733276,
0.24128100275993347,
0.2673608660697937,
-0.04015836864709854,
0.14892995357513428,
0.7675230503082275,
-0.37887513637542725,
0.3510279655456543,
0.45089486241340637,
-0.4897181987762451,
0.01573070138692856,
1.1579474210739136,
0.11311136186122894,
0.20330819487571716,
0.27391165494918823,
0.18922607600688934,
-0.19177092611789703,
-0.5229591131210327,
-0.08133377134799957,
0.4203893542289734,
-0.8997517824172974,
-0.05588357150554657,
-0.7821128964424133,
-0.20394746959209442,
-0.44134747982025146,
0.21481801569461823,
-0.12379606068134308,
-0.5089764595031738,
-0.5341313481330872,
-0.3115389347076416,
0.3389316201210022,
0.6496093273162842,
-0.1025979146361351,
0.1506418138742447,
-0.5356194376945496,
0.37715908885002136,
0.01648956537246704,
0.16609874367713928,
0.3486925959587097,
-0.5883413553237915,
-0.10139989107847214,
0.04527784883975983,
-0.3305966258049011,
-1.1100356578826904,
0.2621571123600006,
0.013411629013717175,
0.6522759795188904,
0.6329194903373718,
-0.10089365392923355,
0.8493510484695435,
-0.17030009627342224,
0.6670346260070801,
-0.07966794073581696,
-1.0034077167510986,
0.4596104621887207,
-0.017485294491052628,
-0.14030194282531738,
0.1788097470998764,
0.2590470016002655,
-0.591295599937439,
-0.7004161477088928,
-0.43091312050819397,
-0.6340174674987793,
0.5477457642555237,
0.37481972575187683,
-0.13461574912071228,
0.14004161953926086,
0.5687519311904907,
0.32172706723213196,
-0.021217646077275276,
-0.8681501746177673,
-0.10091307014226913,
-0.28163468837738037,
-0.09173516929149628,
-0.009663242846727371,
-0.5007254481315613,
-0.024328866973519325,
-0.24048329889774323,
0.9007495641708374,
-0.05908685922622681,
0.165063738822937,
0.24419163167476654,
-0.6775001287460327,
-0.12865087389945984,
-0.004437255207449198,
0.8934441804885864,
0.8072044849395752,
-0.2908790111541748,
0.23660579323768616,
0.1058533787727356,
-0.2058379352092743,
-0.04239189624786377,
-0.2541850507259369,
-0.0464998334646225,
-0.14063872396945953,
0.49037638306617737,
0.8646263480186462,
0.14458224177360535,
-0.6799102425575256,
0.02456076443195343,
0.006421916652470827,
0.12617897987365723,
-0.37054920196533203,
0.16539107263088226,
-0.019896335899829865,
0.3088572919368744,
0.4435214698314667,
-0.134124755859375,
0.4310688376426697,
-0.7469203472137451,
0.19698284566402435,
0.6890597343444824,
-0.3101479411125183,
-0.5768365859985352,
0.5699208378791809,
-0.25568637251853943,
-0.1851683408021927,
0.5281570553779602,
-0.05827845260500908,
-0.5000818967819214,
0.4635618031024933,
0.6956780552864075,
0.8936659097671509,
-0.21633484959602356,
0.24070528149604797,
0.4215712547302246,
0.7232541441917419,
0.10493521392345428,
0.23851607739925385,
-0.04590471088886261,
-0.8692002296447754,
-0.11171603947877884,
-0.5562134385108948,
-0.36321520805358887,
0.5838645100593567,
-0.6516135334968567,
0.27655747532844543,
-0.3212146461009979,
0.3526085615158081,
-0.27181369066238403,
-0.23154829442501068,
-0.30502575635910034,
0.001461371430195868,
0.26861754059791565,
0.3939569294452667,
-0.9146869778633118,
0.7806347608566284,
0.19580434262752533,
-0.6920323371887207,
-0.4567877948284149,
0.4496930241584778,
-0.02009098045527935,
-0.8388358354568481,
0.4151180386543274,
0.2849644720554352,
-0.15066488087177277,
-0.08598814904689789,
-0.4141554534435272,
-0.7370069026947021,
0.926361620426178,
0.3283476233482361,
-0.4777505695819855,
-0.0319950245320797,
0.3761866092681885,
0.4818231463432312,
-0.2806187868118286,
0.01415979489684105,
0.9009979963302612,
0.3671984374523163,
0.024393273517489433,
-0.7715224027633667,
0.44606947898864746,
0.10150071233510971,
-0.26842162013053894,
0.16230039298534393,
-0.3034136891365051,
0.5802668929100037,
-0.48434579372406006,
-0.2468234896659851,
-0.09083519876003265,
0.32891377806663513,
0.4027743935585022,
0.24827085435390472,
0.15800827741622925,
0.6370349526405334,
0.9958764910697937,
0.011605935171246529,
0.8311036229133606,
-0.3070594072341919,
0.16183657944202423,
1.0709717273712158,
-0.3438897728919983,
0.3974069654941559,
0.7724230289459229,
0.07297377288341522,
0.3942648470401764,
0.541489839553833,
0.1101720854640007,
0.7412393689155579,
0.2771017551422119,
-0.0877191424369812,
-0.0303407683968544,
-0.13323499262332916,
-0.45250675082206726,
0.5337607264518738,
0.5676286220550537,
-0.21072764694690704,
-0.20675022900104523,
0.18983802199363708,
0.11246882379055023,
-0.26552116870880127,
-0.07323912531137466,
1.0337826013565063,
-0.08359066396951675,
-0.5716870427131653,
0.6638431549072266,
-0.3640156090259552,
0.4211146831512451,
-0.2993595600128174,
-0.17396779358386993,
-0.4398072063922882,
0.17577038705348969,
-0.2657489478588104,
-0.26026028394699097,
0.7497705817222595,
-0.3587590754032135,
-0.29971858859062195,
-0.009637609124183655,
0.6948553323745728,
-0.38783806562423706,
-0.41018640995025635,
0.5566133260726929,
0.5532853603363037,
0.4143581986427307,
-0.457368940114975,
-0.2796766757965088,
0.1313328742980957,
0.07490163296461105,
-0.12033503502607346,
0.29431793093681335,
0.6086630821228027,
-0.27242130041122437,
0.5040497183799744,
0.653494656085968,
0.15016499161720276,
-0.0008040887187235057,
0.31383776664733887,
0.7748997211456299,
-0.7581207752227783,
-0.06563485413789749,
-1.1507385969161987,
0.4170518219470978,
0.09175261855125427,
0.028332166373729706,
0.36934012174606323,
0.39867132902145386,
0.4840509295463562,
-0.1999870091676712,
0.7238219380378723,
0.24355554580688477,
0.37395602464675903,
-0.7454041242599487,
1.0105241537094116,
-0.6504374146461487,
0.487167090177536,
-0.07673535495996475,
-0.9770370125770569,
-0.2147001177072525,
0.7667428851127625,
-0.046385906636714935,
-0.2464565932750702,
1.0202817916870117,
0.9940981864929199,
0.13288664817810059,
0.1051209419965744,
0.5620211362838745,
0.639820396900177,
0.3648717999458313,
0.681288480758667,
0.9913829565048218,
-0.33737435936927795,
0.49013662338256836,
-0.39930668473243713,
-0.1639682650566101,
-0.35311204195022583,
-0.7304508090019226,
-1.0610802173614502,
-0.8331533670425415,
-0.3306828737258911,
-0.275677889585495,
-0.025012042373418808,
0.7360448837280273,
0.2880561649799347,
-1.0051089525222778,
-0.04355819523334503,
-0.19976617395877838,
0.4504978656768799,
0.009429948404431343,
-0.3231935501098633,
0.25067761540412903,
-0.5310084223747253,
-0.2675812542438507,
0.37085649371147156,
0.3987572193145752,
0.1635889708995819,
-0.5726675391197205,
0.008676436729729176,
0.0070540281012654305,
0.060453541576862335,
0.5229532122612,
-0.018457526341080666,
-1.1875224113464355,
-0.3235829174518585,
0.09991467744112015,
0.17842894792556763,
0.0909413993358612,
0.9060595035552979,
-0.7646573185920715,
0.35917338728904724,
0.24279767274856567,
0.34997573494911194,
0.039196401834487915,
-0.3234773576259613,
0.36418861150741577,
-0.6704344153404236,
0.5139397382736206,
0.16738851368427277,
0.5485217571258545,
0.4325503408908844,
-0.7282609343528748,
0.5071205496788025,
0.2875170409679413,
-0.34213924407958984,
-1.0937793254852295,
0.3354153335094452,
-0.6015158295631409,
-0.4358718693256378,
0.9316602945327759,
0.32818132638931274,
0.05562163516879082,
-0.18065761029720306,
-0.3259347975254059,
0.31760507822036743,
-0.000041886836697813123,
1.3575704097747803,
0.9811204671859741,
-0.2856653332710266,
-0.3391422927379608,
-0.63648921251297,
0.653784990310669,
0.36839771270751953,
-1.00523042678833,
0.29252201318740845,
0.5850995182991028,
0.06577855348587036,
0.30270546674728394,
0.256695955991745,
0.011835089884698391,
0.12158399075269699,
-0.14991992712020874,
0.2417391687631607,
0.09012608975172043,
-0.6362055540084839,
-0.16402436792850494,
0.07002042979001999,
-0.05942673236131668,
0.05628865957260132
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18159v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18159v2
|
Oh! We Freeze: Improving Quantized Knowledge Distillation via Signal Propagation Analysis for Large Language Models
| 2024-03-26T23:51:44 | 2024-03-28T08:22:31 |
Kartikeya Bhardwaj, Nilesh Prasad Pandey, Sweta Priyadarshi, Kyunggeun Lee, Jun Ma, Harris Teague
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large generative models such as large language models (LLMs) and diffusion
models have revolutionized the fields of NLP and computer vision respectively.
However, their slow inference, high computation and memory requirement makes it
challenging to deploy them on edge devices. In this study, we propose a
light-weight quantization aware fine tuning technique using knowledge
distillation (KD-QAT) to improve the performance of 4-bit weight quantized LLMs
using commonly available datasets to realize a popular language use case, on
device chat applications. To improve this paradigm of finetuning, as main
contributions, we provide insights into stability of KD-QAT by empirically
studying the gradient propagation during training to better understand the
vulnerabilities of KD-QAT based approaches to low-bit quantization errors.
Based on our insights, we propose ov-freeze, a simple technique to stabilize
the KD-QAT process. Finally, we experiment with the popular 7B LLaMAv2-Chat
model at 4-bit quantization level and demonstrate that ov-freeze results in
near floating point precision performance, i.e., less than 0.7% loss of
accuracy on Commonsense Reasoning benchmarks.
|
[
-0.5200333595275879,
-1.0469788312911987,
0.5120438933372498,
-0.21088765561580658,
-0.5951781868934631,
0.27817681431770325,
-0.2210131287574768,
-0.09619608521461487,
-0.22163040935993195,
0.1741620898246765,
-0.08537633717060089,
-0.5150085687637329,
-0.6464625597000122,
-0.33101528882980347,
-0.18933454155921936,
0.7269899249076843,
0.27150845527648926,
0.01774693839251995,
-0.027568219229578972,
-0.19781920313835144,
-0.475435346364975,
-0.13056425750255585,
-1.0048733949661255,
-0.2764430046081543,
0.2033432424068451,
0.374996542930603,
0.8149802684783936,
0.43774452805519104,
0.2947392761707306,
0.31249547004699707,
-0.42857369780540466,
0.05131877213716507,
-0.5279049873352051,
0.21648289263248444,
0.1786014884710312,
-0.675449550151825,
-0.5198854207992554,
-0.3512822985649109,
0.1816481649875641,
0.4780721962451935,
-0.580204427242279,
-0.025014154613018036,
0.062366098165512085,
0.892327606678009,
-0.7222486138343811,
0.034700505435466766,
-0.8901422619819641,
-0.1650010198354721,
-0.1920311450958252,
-0.09915086627006531,
-0.17607635259628296,
-0.35724958777427673,
0.2809176743030548,
-0.5618966221809387,
0.18497371673583984,
-0.09574616700410843,
0.6897708773612976,
0.7167595028877258,
-0.4356178641319275,
-0.08036769181489944,
-0.9288759827613831,
0.7997639775276184,
-1.00697922706604,
0.662770688533783,
0.42465338110923767,
0.38004592061042786,
-0.2090751677751541,
-0.8696600198745728,
-0.6108164191246033,
0.16479039192199707,
0.45899665355682373,
-0.015823284164071083,
-0.37618178129196167,
0.2809027433395386,
0.3208028972148895,
0.37090855836868286,
-0.14379732310771942,
-0.025486862286925316,
-0.25891974568367004,
-0.2961260974407196,
0.3355315625667572,
0.03846205398440361,
-0.05394000560045242,
0.3558439612388611,
-0.12465235590934753,
0.008418568409979343,
-0.463161438703537,
-0.07849910855293274,
0.07986016571521759,
-0.028126273304224014,
-0.13104841113090515,
0.162643700838089,
-0.6439385414123535,
0.6413230895996094,
0.384751558303833,
-0.5040582418441772,
0.06926415115594864,
-0.12350206077098846,
-0.44594427943229675,
0.1481076329946518,
0.7268956303596497,
0.6709766387939453,
-0.057518500834703445,
0.028957180678844452,
-0.12643931806087494,
0.049882642924785614,
-0.23255091905593872,
-1.0774288177490234,
-0.712604820728302,
0.2975330352783203,
-0.42365899682044983,
-0.049666229635477066,
-0.632440984249115,
-0.6747333407402039,
-0.6381897926330566,
-0.06538940966129303,
0.5421391725540161,
-0.6756125688552856,
-0.3785804212093353,
0.40277400612831116,
-0.2460891753435135,
-0.08446495234966278,
0.23648330569267273,
-0.947239100933075,
0.3521510660648346,
0.37153416872024536,
0.8407573103904724,
0.276775985956192,
0.3381422162055969,
-0.45528265833854675,
-0.06132335215806961,
-0.1424098014831543,
0.3105246126651764,
-0.12114382535219193,
-0.24916768074035645,
-0.2644445300102234,
-0.5756555795669556,
0.36332541704177856,
-0.5386056900024414,
0.6922594308853149,
-0.9665282964706421,
-0.276312917470932,
-0.029427945613861084,
-0.6223079562187195,
-0.007189625408500433,
0.005815332289785147,
-0.5477328896522522,
0.7102786898612976,
-0.25523898005485535,
-0.8930505514144897,
0.6360655426979065,
-0.4207163155078888,
-0.25987371802330017,
-0.006012988742440939,
0.15209519863128662,
-0.708447277545929,
0.22791501879692078,
0.4740334451198578,
0.5654342770576477,
-0.31878596544265747,
0.26849251985549927,
-0.33958858251571655,
-0.1914387196302414,
0.17452149093151093,
-0.7182744145393372,
0.5581978559494019,
0.5715005397796631,
-0.28185340762138367,
-0.16295385360717773,
-0.8087539672851562,
0.16256068646907806,
-0.02835933305323124,
-0.2686501145362854,
-0.8411528468132019,
0.11383134126663208,
-0.40807098150253296,
-0.038828879594802856,
0.15134954452514648,
-0.5086027383804321,
0.3465849459171295,
-0.39264047145843506,
0.9412451982498169,
0.3030504584312439,
-0.058034833520650864,
0.625725507736206,
0.08111841976642609,
0.4108545184135437,
0.1979626566171646,
0.20481863617897034,
-0.19715218245983124,
-0.6302188634872437,
-0.6638998985290527,
-0.3101609945297241,
0.4776892364025116,
0.32741662859916687,
-1.389855146408081,
0.0158059261739254,
-0.2971976697444916,
-0.5501887798309326,
-0.7428617477416992,
0.1490112841129303,
0.2692314088344574,
0.6270352602005005,
0.3140885829925537,
0.15180762112140656,
-0.2245086431503296,
-0.6650132536888123,
-0.11018531024456024,
0.039312444627285004,
-0.11175629496574402,
-0.07089806348085403,
0.11737355589866638,
0.08077406883239746,
0.9776390790939331,
-0.8034145832061768,
-0.3137238025665283,
0.07372919470071793,
0.4465481638908386,
0.11500781029462814,
0.449280709028244,
0.4519840180873871,
-0.8101531267166138,
-0.5730627179145813,
0.14216189086437225,
-0.3466781675815582,
-0.011003986932337284,
0.28986039757728577,
0.08685404807329178,
0.39748528599739075,
0.7734177708625793,
-0.5216862559318542,
0.3938102424144745,
0.8200733661651611,
-0.3960346281528473,
0.16938699781894684,
-0.10479015111923218,
0.3337908685207367,
-1.0862493515014648,
-0.2251136600971222,
0.0679820105433464,
-0.32167506217956543,
-0.5458775758743286,
-0.31904757022857666,
0.30602115392684937,
0.06402719765901566,
-0.49008679389953613,
0.3000100553035736,
-0.21836063265800476,
0.5363470315933228,
-0.27440324425697327,
0.1835060566663742,
0.12323374301195145,
0.23890212178230286,
-0.09128621220588684,
0.44246456027030945,
0.7353076338768005,
-0.7317793965339661,
0.3477618992328644,
-0.14022842049598694,
-0.314670205116272,
0.7273504137992859,
-0.6723434329032898,
0.05437052249908447,
-0.13814207911491394,
-0.01040612068027258,
-1.0624219179153442,
0.14390787482261658,
0.03356755152344704,
-0.444830983877182,
0.29497620463371277,
-0.6318952441215515,
-0.4891553521156311,
-0.023016000166535378,
-0.25483810901641846,
0.6605490446090698,
0.9712346792221069,
-0.4500040113925934,
0.3728486895561218,
0.2973055839538574,
0.05292924493551254,
-0.2711825668811798,
-0.4628339409828186,
-0.15097428858280182,
-0.7023281455039978,
-0.7302642464637756,
0.25844863057136536,
-0.10801868140697479,
-0.3835827112197876,
-0.12126005440950394,
-0.3536411225795746,
-0.3886686861515045,
0.27889013290405273,
0.10531237721443176,
-0.02793610654771328,
-0.2065597027540207,
0.22625145316123962,
0.42648759484291077,
-0.0746205672621727,
-0.2507583498954773,
-0.5434195399284363,
0.4782218635082245,
-0.062000054866075516,
0.0033521854784339666,
-0.7880766987800598,
-0.3269747495651245,
0.5290858149528503,
-0.12011878192424774,
0.6747381091117859,
0.6843284368515015,
-0.2639119625091553,
-0.3668194115161896,
-0.6502728462219238,
-0.37421461939811707,
-0.5717617869377136,
0.23775754868984222,
-0.5109076499938965,
-1.068671464920044,
0.5077385902404785,
-0.47451120615005493,
-0.12247171998023987,
0.2289367914199829,
0.3190234899520874,
-0.1765957623720169,
1.0238839387893677,
0.6718931794166565,
-0.21106547117233276,
0.45261266827583313,
-0.3086744546890259,
0.23579715192317963,
-0.49470973014831543,
0.01885439269244671,
-0.3840058743953705,
-0.37394586205482483,
-0.3451101779937744,
-0.5225131511688232,
0.6045008301734924,
0.8172919154167175,
-0.08324180543422699,
-0.02673421800136566,
-0.40835434198379517,
0.4770037829875946,
0.40787559747695923,
0.05110333859920502,
0.5719789266586304,
-0.02631247416138649,
0.027117500081658363,
-0.1452881544828415,
-0.8408191204071045,
-0.11649611592292786,
0.9665088653564453,
0.506537914276123,
1.0643388032913208,
-0.16304390132427216,
0.6065841317176819,
0.11558656394481659,
-0.1340620070695877,
-0.7831979393959045,
0.2766939699649811,
-0.07000819593667984,
-0.2906787097454071,
-0.7316694855690002,
-0.6187107563018799,
-0.712323009967804,
0.1496947854757309,
0.017171453684568405,
-0.6241487860679626,
0.028533637523651123,
0.6152874827384949,
-0.577614963054657,
0.3116769790649414,
-0.9193076491355896,
0.7692551016807556,
0.023091524839401245,
-0.28147125244140625,
-0.349127858877182,
-0.2989892363548279,
0.6409837007522583,
0.050290435552597046,
0.36684083938598633,
-0.28760698437690735,
0.08554308861494064,
0.7347650527954102,
-0.6548587679862976,
0.7955231070518494,
-0.4743228256702423,
-0.6228433847427368,
0.4175466299057007,
0.2495959997177124,
0.4453502893447876,
0.269538551568985,
-0.06556811928749084,
0.23415978252887726,
0.34538668394088745,
-0.21959738433361053,
-0.7959677577018738,
0.6146316528320312,
-0.5700701475143433,
-0.3700988292694092,
0.055013012140989304,
-0.2598130404949188,
-0.3111812472343445,
0.1376744955778122,
0.34064778685569763,
0.4482061564922333,
0.12974369525909424,
0.2813553810119629,
0.9946672320365906,
0.031854964792728424,
0.5186827182769775,
0.5387467741966248,
-0.2104916274547577,
-0.5769819617271423,
0.9197086691856384,
0.12232479453086853,
0.6484448909759521,
0.3141109049320221,
0.26681268215179443,
-0.05685228481888771,
-0.9089487791061401,
-0.36717262864112854,
-0.15041720867156982,
-0.5345636606216431,
-0.6242144107818604,
-0.3347715735435486,
0.03066399320960045,
-0.19405899941921234,
0.12542273104190826,
-0.8534834980964661,
-0.4894696772098541,
-0.21610523760318756,
0.18018950521945953,
0.9355807900428772,
0.20204496383666992,
0.02491559274494648,
0.7868043184280396,
-0.8524191975593567,
0.6201474070549011,
0.4028586149215698,
0.6052789092063904,
0.019303103908896446,
-0.6143091917037964,
-0.48045477271080017,
0.43043434619903564,
-0.3580891788005829,
-0.39885589480400085,
0.3449837565422058,
0.5131750106811523,
0.12302988022565842,
0.5920602679252625,
0.48808613419532776,
0.9233049750328064,
-0.27491191029548645,
0.5734692811965942,
0.24962680041790009,
-1.257071852684021,
0.5422468781471252,
-0.2590578496456146,
0.6033849120140076,
0.41224968433380127,
0.31723371148109436,
-0.4522092938423157,
-0.38695764541625977,
-0.32799863815307617,
-0.979486346244812,
0.5169759392738342,
0.21038936078548431,
-0.03204473853111267,
0.24625292420387268,
0.45256999135017395,
-0.024740422144532204,
0.37060442566871643,
-0.2822429835796356,
-0.4394162595272064,
-0.10409680008888245,
-0.08261231333017349,
0.17041626572608948,
-0.329427570104599,
-0.010066957212984562,
-0.22400756180286407,
0.6286482214927673,
-0.2733374536037445,
-0.17870989441871643,
0.12911835312843323,
0.11816781014204025,
-0.12482535094022751,
0.21293026208877563,
0.3070797026157379,
0.4456113278865814,
-0.12446554005146027,
0.31130123138427734,
0.23505456745624542,
-0.6421805024147034,
0.054858382791280746,
-0.09354032576084137,
-0.21163076162338257,
-0.20391036570072174,
-0.025098169222474098,
0.8395919799804688,
0.06538069248199463,
-0.5737014412879944,
0.2967996597290039,
-0.44942542910575867,
-0.35336849093437195,
0.024932190775871277,
0.05077973008155823,
0.3740355968475342,
0.5268480777740479,
0.38645291328430176,
-0.07223401963710785,
0.21949897706508636,
-0.33319079875946045,
-0.009923958219587803,
0.622783362865448,
-0.19604502618312836,
-0.38239234685897827,
0.9804474711418152,
0.36472341418266296,
0.11660344153642654,
0.6742023229598999,
-0.47643983364105225,
-0.2792109251022339,
0.3050902485847473,
0.1935843527317047,
0.7269681692123413,
-0.31060081720352173,
0.07426118105649948,
0.15581876039505005,
0.09545739740133286,
-0.1810247302055359,
0.44445353746414185,
-0.1483888179063797,
-0.886507511138916,
-0.5468614101409912,
-0.7803633213043213,
0.14408782124519348,
0.09875577688217163,
-0.4500584900379181,
0.2921852767467499,
-0.41454488039016724,
-0.46075451374053955,
0.008643238805234432,
-0.19855988025665283,
-0.528615415096283,
0.16811679303646088,
0.2071024775505066,
0.6639770865440369,
-0.5970079898834229,
1.2091083526611328,
0.22022049129009247,
0.06387511640787125,
-0.6697734594345093,
-0.052027519792318344,
-0.18907001614570618,
-0.5135751962661743,
0.6980869174003601,
-0.4517703950405121,
-0.15041851997375488,
0.3363765478134155,
-0.6645454168319702,
-0.9654382467269897,
1.4012850522994995,
0.5098957419395447,
-1.012394905090332,
0.38083264231681824,
-0.04552038386464119,
0.48795270919799805,
0.30556750297546387,
-0.07853350788354874,
0.8515731692314148,
0.28535640239715576,
0.386224627494812,
-1.2995926141738892,
-0.07893668115139008,
0.040821440517902374,
0.022503653541207314,
0.5148464441299438,
-0.6601490378379822,
0.5330358743667603,
-0.2010219246149063,
-0.21508580446243286,
0.11258780211210251,
0.6713066697120667,
0.08954278379678726,
0.5911308526992798,
0.44018325209617615,
0.7898744940757751,
0.7276854515075684,
-0.17076723277568817,
0.4300926625728607,
-0.3541208505630493,
0.3910488486289978,
0.9924459457397461,
-0.023146098479628563,
0.819493293762207,
0.7402015924453735,
-0.1960359364748001,
-0.09135115146636963,
0.1392802745103836,
0.28018251061439514,
0.896153450012207,
0.4423466622829437,
-0.3145608901977539,
-0.08604447543621063,
0.025402190163731575,
-0.236465185880661,
0.12689591944217682,
0.5683187246322632,
0.04280544072389603,
-0.031849320977926254,
0.402280330657959,
0.1852806657552719,
-0.05261607840657234,
-0.5801827907562256,
0.7785003185272217,
0.32350993156433105,
-0.2421451061964035,
1.1504164934158325,
0.029039528220891953,
0.925163209438324,
-0.2514374852180481,
-0.04932897165417671,
-0.17953796684741974,
0.23787380754947662,
-0.25254005193710327,
-0.3770924508571625,
0.1282709389925003,
-0.3551939129829407,
0.0023873576428741217,
-0.05701303854584694,
0.639241099357605,
-0.4472505748271942,
-0.26106834411621094,
0.0036606600042432547,
0.30683523416519165,
0.014438929036259651,
-0.2593483626842499,
-0.2512761056423187,
0.5053912401199341,
-0.023570435121655464,
-0.21189217269420624,
0.2757548689842224,
0.9985070824623108,
0.061388470232486725,
0.8734521865844727,
0.33564186096191406,
-0.0059395888820290565,
0.35648113489151,
-0.016060341149568558,
0.9039310216903687,
-0.3935818076133728,
-0.2625211477279663,
-1.076139211654663,
0.7460578680038452,
0.14909876883029938,
-0.2290390580892563,
0.7032170295715332,
0.37538230419158936,
0.6848723888397217,
-0.016084469854831696,
0.8552027344703674,
-0.19260063767433167,
0.16735373437404633,
-0.9009963274002075,
0.9722428917884827,
-0.37473008036613464,
0.4070216715335846,
-0.2723312973976135,
-0.6922500729560852,
-0.19152018427848816,
0.1556382030248642,
-0.1611015945672989,
-0.15336495637893677,
0.5258306860923767,
0.4793860912322998,
0.004889144562184811,
-0.14277315139770508,
0.7392619848251343,
0.49925103783607483,
0.2905611991882324,
0.3592735528945923,
0.6744641661643982,
-0.666606068611145,
0.6805074214935303,
-0.5414730906486511,
-0.18226630985736847,
-0.21029619872570038,
-0.9528228044509888,
-0.9083986878395081,
-0.7341591715812683,
-0.7710753083229065,
-0.1788177490234375,
0.17596173286437988,
0.3959534466266632,
0.8474420309066772,
-0.4440109431743622,
0.038738906383514404,
-0.3702471852302551,
0.10622536391019821,
-0.11748209595680237,
-0.2160557061433792,
0.33196112513542175,
-0.2694404721260071,
-0.6751230955123901,
0.2286006659269333,
0.049025457352399826,
0.16862443089485168,
-0.14112818241119385,
-0.07108578085899353,
0.27491888403892517,
-0.17402629554271698,
0.6436651945114136,
0.1439134031534195,
-0.6457940936088562,
-0.1403653621673584,
-0.2604256272315979,
0.2490232139825821,
0.002220374997705221,
0.5414591431617737,
-1.0123090744018555,
0.5771895051002502,
0.39773106575012207,
0.2910904884338379,
0.5123862624168396,
-0.028049148619174957,
0.6155111193656921,
-0.6227094531059265,
0.1401849091053009,
0.19439253211021423,
0.16086073219776154,
0.07029619067907333,
-0.21310964226722717,
0.05485868826508522,
0.03265928104519844,
-0.6902129054069519,
-0.7419964075088501,
0.10945256054401398,
-0.7909298539161682,
-0.18939237296581268,
0.881385087966919,
-0.11657866090536118,
-0.12304289638996124,
-0.1104033812880516,
-0.48881983757019043,
0.35365918278694153,
-0.7541144490242004,
1.0204086303710938,
0.3697485327720642,
-0.02656240202486515,
-0.43650275468826294,
-0.6006698608398438,
0.9877446293830872,
0.12631434202194214,
-0.43100279569625854,
0.13052453100681305,
0.27347075939178467,
0.40830954909324646,
0.09107132256031036,
0.5898165106773376,
0.17612744867801666,
0.10866700857877731,
0.016704384237527847,
0.16494998335838318,
0.033026039600372314,
-0.017873993143439293,
-0.40914589166641235,
0.08475934714078903,
0.5892196297645569,
-0.25230008363723755
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18152v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18152v1
|
Large Language Models as Financial Data Annotators: A Study on Effectiveness and Efficiency
| 2024-03-26T23:32:52 | 2024-03-26T23:32:52 |
Toyin Aguda, Suchetha Siddagangappa, Elena Kochkina, Simerjot Kaur, Dongsheng Wang, Charese Smiley, Sameena Shah
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Collecting labeled datasets in finance is challenging due to scarcity of
domain experts and higher cost of employing them. While Large Language Models
(LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable performance in data annotation tasks on
general domain datasets, their effectiveness on domain specific datasets
remains underexplored. To address this gap, we investigate the potential of
LLMs as efficient data annotators for extracting relations in financial
documents. We compare the annotations produced by three LLMs (GPT-4, PaLM 2,
and MPT Instruct) against expert annotators and crowdworkers. We demonstrate
that the current state-of-the-art LLMs can be sufficient alternatives to
non-expert crowdworkers. We analyze models using various prompts and parameter
settings and find that customizing the prompts for each relation group by
providing specific examples belonging to those groups is paramount.
Furthermore, we introduce a reliability index (LLM-RelIndex) used to identify
outputs that may require expert attention. Finally, we perform an extensive
time, cost and error analysis and provide recommendations for the collection
and usage of automated annotations in domain-specific settings.
|
[
-0.15706948935985565,
-0.6907789707183838,
0.4655074179172516,
0.3287888765335083,
-0.21641813218593597,
0.16611872613430023,
-0.48155322670936584,
-0.7140432000160217,
0.15749400854110718,
0.6398355960845947,
-0.07828161865472794,
-0.3924565315246582,
-0.8070253729820251,
0.139512836933136,
-0.5438043475151062,
1.0940274000167847,
-0.11776184290647507,
-0.024682598188519478,
-0.27812641859054565,
0.11242156475782394,
-0.005603982601314783,
-0.7603099942207336,
-0.9017624258995056,
-0.3960537612438202,
0.56458979845047,
0.04688349738717079,
0.9358713030815125,
0.7971661686897278,
0.8398573398590088,
0.37043339014053345,
0.0029594514053314924,
0.11002606898546219,
-0.4436330497264862,
0.125229611992836,
-0.1160304918885231,
-0.1820281594991684,
-0.4868033230304718,
0.23735325038433075,
0.32449859380722046,
0.8286340236663818,
-0.056201864033937454,
0.1830812692642212,
-0.11186133325099945,
0.701316773891449,
-0.48396873474121094,
0.8523773550987244,
-0.5007185935974121,
-0.25388550758361816,
-0.47197604179382324,
-0.09931626170873642,
-0.40822914242744446,
-0.5066257119178772,
0.4077010750770569,
-0.8166627287864685,
-0.06198136880993843,
0.21394027769565582,
0.8971990942955017,
0.18220819532871246,
-0.3151477575302124,
-0.5529658198356628,
-0.5963305830955505,
0.6557407379150391,
-0.6364373564720154,
0.378480464220047,
0.6697400808334351,
0.30229827761650085,
-0.058388158679008484,
-0.6346978545188904,
-0.19162516295909882,
-0.3964751064777374,
-0.15544280409812927,
0.006288798991590738,
-0.2227039635181427,
0.000019523062292137183,
0.34381961822509766,
0.32333457469940186,
0.02569614350795746,
0.43821144104003906,
-0.27221307158470154,
-0.227633535861969,
0.7908444404602051,
0.029247406870126724,
-0.06046842411160469,
-0.05789953097701073,
-0.3184085786342621,
-0.026615578681230545,
-0.7365863919258118,
-0.28500059247016907,
0.5014727115631104,
0.3423939347267151,
0.04391747713088989,
0.5680496096611023,
-0.00786471925675869,
0.7388797998428345,
-0.15245021879673004,
-0.6438490748405457,
0.17907343804836273,
-0.13236641883850098,
-0.14214769005775452,
-0.34002768993377686,
0.6183831691741943,
0.3150024712085724,
0.9266456365585327,
-0.2965330481529236,
-0.5574374794960022,
-0.4953239858150482,
-0.04930156469345093,
-0.4875100255012512,
-0.5716589689254761,
0.05238117650151253,
-0.4278258979320526,
-0.1473330408334732,
0.13213612139225006,
-0.7431708574295044,
-0.39732274413108826,
-0.4284876883029938,
0.23192574083805084,
-0.17024222016334534,
-0.2526804208755493,
-0.12564688920974731,
-0.26759612560272217,
0.1289389580488205,
0.41441431641578674,
-1.0493179559707642,
0.3398652672767639,
0.9987319707870483,
0.7367751002311707,
0.07825664430856705,
-0.04673689231276512,
-0.7724930644035339,
0.3567303717136383,
-0.32256415486335754,
0.9202027320861816,
-0.6208227276802063,
-0.4006727337837219,
0.31542491912841797,
-0.24717289209365845,
-0.08256814628839493,
-0.6693971157073975,
0.34013643860816956,
-0.6453484296798706,
-0.07370691746473312,
-0.38024386763572693,
-0.9425897598266602,
0.02474244497716427,
-0.03769832104444504,
-0.9538769125938416,
0.72339928150177,
0.30037564039230347,
-0.7629199624061584,
0.5805394053459167,
-0.7984060049057007,
-0.4900588393211365,
0.3948233127593994,
-0.2711000442504883,
-0.43790221214294434,
-0.1162993535399437,
0.18028561770915985,
0.8140218257904053,
-0.5107983946800232,
0.42775800824165344,
-0.5234425663948059,
-0.2851699888706207,
0.6696971654891968,
-0.39564526081085205,
0.3153568506240845,
0.053331807255744934,
-0.23342368006706238,
-0.13712728023529053,
-0.7121461033821106,
-0.5366269946098328,
0.19936056435108185,
-0.4422515332698822,
-0.6123164296150208,
0.11995834112167358,
0.3091251850128174,
-0.11982782930135727,
0.3362533748149872,
-0.27033722400665283,
0.25297242403030396,
-0.18593621253967285,
0.5149116516113281,
0.9773691296577454,
-0.029080849140882492,
0.10619683563709259,
-0.18591885268688202,
0.506938636302948,
-0.2973700761795044,
-0.16269606351852417,
-0.16606980562210083,
-0.33876368403434753,
-0.45390141010284424,
-0.5752245783805847,
0.6430607438087463,
0.3890455663204193,
-0.6320883631706238,
0.11031394451856613,
-0.07239558547735214,
-0.3869155943393707,
-0.24040725827217102,
0.39112043380737305,
0.26259130239486694,
0.34009018540382385,
0.004724620375782251,
-0.05051545426249504,
-0.28963109850883484,
-1.2209043502807617,
-0.303077757358551,
-0.18026849627494812,
0.01258467510342598,
0.39815670251846313,
0.4912826418876648,
0.1721334308385849,
0.8327479362487793,
-0.7071899175643921,
-0.07731771469116211,
-0.26657289266586304,
0.13367211818695068,
0.16591757535934448,
0.20476694405078888,
0.8194059729576111,
-0.8927258849143982,
-0.30654263496398926,
-0.008505684323608875,
-0.7086784839630127,
-0.2240941971540451,
-0.31785792112350464,
0.04201245680451393,
0.3473184108734131,
0.2698163092136383,
-0.5566113591194153,
0.3717671036720276,
0.3515709340572357,
-0.21661123633384705,
0.40249204635620117,
-0.1435646116733551,
-0.05784323439002037,
-0.7768761515617371,
0.2641867697238922,
0.621719241142273,
-0.2674671709537506,
-0.6894992589950562,
-0.34973835945129395,
0.10106309503316879,
0.08820697665214539,
0.06985373795032501,
0.7403432726860046,
-0.4914975166320801,
-0.3138599097728729,
-0.3532131016254425,
0.5373140573501587,
-0.19083088636398315,
0.37562739849090576,
0.1871761977672577,
0.7291152477264404,
0.351296991109848,
-0.2691575586795807,
0.522817075252533,
0.20897313952445984,
-0.5051084756851196,
0.47365957498550415,
-0.6880276203155518,
-0.008631788194179535,
0.19522838294506073,
0.16248910129070282,
-0.9836745262145996,
-0.33219292759895325,
0.1986953765153885,
0.032725606113672256,
0.4701021611690521,
-0.07794773578643799,
-0.7508561015129089,
-0.3574642539024353,
-0.13252483308315277,
-0.0004566629359032959,
0.25088897347450256,
-0.6031386256217957,
0.44744792580604553,
0.5175413489341736,
-0.6068440675735474,
-0.5567682981491089,
-0.5070250630378723,
0.23475921154022217,
-0.37418317794799805,
-0.5906329154968262,
-0.23744109272956848,
0.3332309126853943,
-0.7488515377044678,
-0.16698715090751648,
-0.0439438633620739,
-0.17935898900032043,
0.4177478551864624,
0.28575819730758667,
0.6043761968612671,
-0.01116420142352581,
0.5006792545318604,
-0.2849365770816803,
-0.30427438020706177,
0.13768810033798218,
-0.10659506171941757,
0.11899454891681671,
0.16912446916103363,
-0.21310800313949585,
-0.25428012013435364,
0.3664221465587616,
0.37002936005592346,
-0.3713979423046112,
0.8499467968940735,
0.360609769821167,
-0.3479536771774292,
0.04191259294748306,
-1.0133566856384277,
0.10858616977930069,
-0.4566626250743866,
0.30302694439888,
-0.41973504424095154,
-1.0615870952606201,
0.6424052715301514,
-0.2881002724170685,
0.3087574243545532,
0.8393070697784424,
0.5238603353500366,
0.1645052134990692,
0.4686177968978882,
0.759946346282959,
-0.45791900157928467,
0.44191181659698486,
-0.15972039103507996,
0.2897157073020935,
-0.4089004397392273,
-0.27467265725135803,
-0.6641573905944824,
0.011534400284290314,
-0.2105533927679062,
-0.20937404036521912,
0.09298068284988403,
0.11658620834350586,
-0.07351730763912201,
0.3004096746444702,
-0.1184859573841095,
0.43035733699798584,
0.42591965198516846,
-0.3064832389354706,
0.38790079951286316,
-0.06049605831503868,
0.3071587085723877,
0.008408114314079285,
-0.5298126935958862,
-0.7614766955375671,
1.1646807193756104,
0.6363787055015564,
0.86253422498703,
-0.09328698366880417,
0.5637105703353882,
0.2862725853919983,
0.8706072568893433,
-0.577619731426239,
0.2858143150806427,
-0.17517875134944916,
-0.5050007700920105,
-0.37240034341812134,
-0.6680129170417786,
-0.6861426830291748,
-0.06164173036813736,
-0.14809833467006683,
-0.7638842463493347,
0.24746204912662506,
0.05374812334775925,
-0.4701204299926758,
0.34084567427635193,
-0.6987217664718628,
0.7081108689308167,
-0.1859927922487259,
-0.2518264353275299,
0.18099047243595123,
-0.30606627464294434,
0.44248276948928833,
-0.7676928639411926,
0.3657318651676178,
-0.20448382198810577,
-0.2903884947299957,
1.0057940483093262,
-0.6053311824798584,
0.8751989006996155,
-0.23001451790332794,
-0.5734051465988159,
0.30467304587364197,
-0.21557842195034027,
0.806377112865448,
0.04932432621717453,
-0.35385602712631226,
0.20661601424217224,
-0.19557547569274902,
-0.30838584899902344,
-0.49534887075424194,
0.6339437961578369,
-0.5236649513244629,
-0.5715329647064209,
-0.21918489038944244,
-0.6776733994483948,
-0.2933371067047119,
-0.12897029519081116,
-0.2987540066242218,
0.4490956664085388,
0.05271498113870621,
0.22029687464237213,
0.19513636827468872,
0.048064813017845154,
0.5838707685470581,
0.4928905665874481,
-0.21275117993354797,
-0.5271612405776978,
0.8034999370574951,
0.4640447199344635,
0.11138477921485901,
0.22009772062301636,
0.005717711057513952,
-0.3686564564704895,
-0.48152798414230347,
-0.23192326724529266,
0.3095510005950928,
-0.736224353313446,
-0.3885875642299652,
-0.5435099005699158,
0.0798623189330101,
-0.3905676305294037,
-0.2133709043264389,
-0.21240319311618805,
-0.5997391939163208,
-0.21260420978069305,
-0.44727057218551636,
0.9183343052864075,
0.9111003279685974,
-0.25399887561798096,
0.1284129023551941,
-0.7211523056030273,
0.15763609111309052,
0.43712660670280457,
0.4023401737213135,
0.17192387580871582,
-0.24678562581539154,
-0.6848953366279602,
-0.30951353907585144,
0.1435350775718689,
-0.7360041737556458,
0.31848645210266113,
0.08075714111328125,
0.6273320317268372,
0.6723561882972717,
-0.0867355465888977,
0.6933937072753906,
-0.063327357172966,
0.48849716782569885,
-0.006995116826146841,
-0.9403927326202393,
0.13687297701835632,
-0.4651612341403961,
-0.11255595833063126,
0.5056243538856506,
0.5352703928947449,
-0.43577510118484497,
-0.4628741443157196,
-0.4926213324069977,
-1.0753015279769897,
0.5685629844665527,
0.11582916229963303,
-0.10451733320951462,
-0.22370651364326477,
0.7791635394096375,
0.33520516753196716,
0.47449687123298645,
-0.4645751118659973,
-0.22612181305885315,
0.11948958784341812,
-0.0409405454993248,
-0.21536077558994293,
-0.45708343386650085,
-0.055916979908943176,
0.01288856565952301,
0.6246067881584167,
-0.03111773543059826,
-0.29721972346305847,
0.05884677544236183,
0.17572645843029022,
-0.18737086653709412,
-0.035601288080215454,
0.38001057505607605,
1.0246912240982056,
-0.11517129093408585,
-0.07719392329454422,
0.07430959492921829,
-0.21227103471755981,
-0.07095011323690414,
0.48835882544517517,
0.08307286351919174,
0.037311941385269165,
0.6848711371421814,
0.4734137952327728,
0.44636449217796326,
-0.7987326979637146,
0.5031118988990784,
0.19431954622268677,
-0.26441511511802673,
-0.5298067331314087,
-0.24371609091758728,
0.3838719427585602,
0.4258439540863037,
0.688940167427063,
-0.2861682176589966,
0.050536807626485825,
-0.42512592673301697,
0.20965074002742767,
0.36324870586395264,
-0.05395369231700897,
-0.020214557647705078,
0.6357809901237488,
0.40819787979125977,
-0.2521650791168213,
0.7485391497612,
0.14144708216190338,
-0.419675350189209,
0.5530604720115662,
0.22927658259868622,
0.8087061643600464,
0.07410745322704315,
-0.04683192819356918,
-0.11851874738931656,
0.12628692388534546,
-0.3677149713039398,
0.04273489862680435,
-0.022831428796052933,
-0.4404667317867279,
-0.7989461421966553,
-0.5887770056724548,
-0.765609860420227,
0.029904542490839958,
-0.6658218502998352,
-0.11809445172548294,
-0.4184483289718628,
-0.3219197392463684,
0.4032006859779358,
0.03043079376220703,
-0.717234194278717,
0.03494773805141449,
0.0867767408490181,
0.8791194558143616,
-0.7159461975097656,
0.6768556237220764,
0.5085819959640503,
-0.46536651253700256,
-0.819234311580658,
-0.24669727683067322,
-0.14165924489498138,
-0.7596144080162048,
1.0267120599746704,
0.022827107459306717,
0.22528138756752014,
-0.4064127802848816,
-0.5067905783653259,
-0.6834692358970642,
0.9560940265655518,
0.3832995891571045,
-0.9420245289802551,
0.0611821711063385,
0.0873233750462532,
0.46463924646377563,
-0.4674006402492523,
0.19787761569023132,
0.6495805978775024,
0.8580440878868103,
0.04848724603652954,
-0.9772292375564575,
-0.0683891773223877,
-0.2784620523452759,
-0.15909330546855927,
0.4454686939716339,
-0.8386180400848389,
0.7669872641563416,
-0.07358267903327942,
0.11267590522766113,
0.04520950838923454,
0.8106696605682373,
0.1389014571905136,
0.4312167465686798,
0.5101483464241028,
0.23893776535987854,
0.9549394249916077,
-0.23363500833511353,
1.2182351350784302,
-0.5253108143806458,
0.4480929374694824,
0.9386610984802246,
-0.5236618518829346,
0.863426148891449,
0.38268640637397766,
-0.2515847682952881,
0.1087811291217804,
0.6639197468757629,
-0.4365043342113495,
0.012200620025396347,
0.5536285638809204,
-0.10427971184253693,
-0.5852011442184448,
-0.06407323479652405,
-0.16483063995838165,
0.21985234320163727,
0.15800392627716064,
-0.5950925946235657,
0.07020699977874756,
-0.1692451387643814,
0.2944263517856598,
0.05892671272158623,
-0.19418221712112427,
0.8225721716880798,
0.46730417013168335,
-0.2895382344722748,
-0.05252490192651749,
0.016120629385113716,
0.5340076088905334,
-0.6600767970085144,
-0.0055572050623595715,
-0.2221989929676056,
0.0658862441778183,
-0.06944200396537781,
-0.5131546258926392,
0.11923312395811081,
0.3010299801826477,
-0.10579735040664673,
-0.21870797872543335,
0.78005450963974,
-0.35526809096336365,
-0.7204282283782959,
0.24892768263816833,
0.5943084955215454,
0.29364413022994995,
-0.19720780849456787,
-0.3345688581466675,
-0.0872560366988182,
-0.17230577766895294,
-0.6835353374481201,
0.333053320646286,
0.5055854916572571,
-0.0051564062014222145,
0.7545216083526611,
0.7146608233451843,
0.050923511385917664,
-0.4091353416442871,
0.22816027700901031,
0.8697443008422852,
-0.8520917892456055,
-0.07709640264511108,
-0.9316961765289307,
0.18050245940685272,
-0.27545517683029175,
-0.3026309907436371,
0.8821496963500977,
0.6960007548332214,
0.6104747653007507,
-0.004141377285122871,
0.9626170992851257,
0.510219395160675,
0.5013301968574524,
-0.48375236988067627,
0.6123949289321899,
-0.2312224805355072,
0.4413171112537384,
-0.4884028732776642,
-0.981349527835846,
-0.3676146864891052,
0.5810127258300781,
-0.7172757387161255,
0.19437390565872192,
0.32885584235191345,
0.30744925141334534,
0.19598546624183655,
0.24299313127994537,
0.25555261969566345,
0.12094522267580032,
0.30414366722106934,
0.3142201602458954,
0.6293736100196838,
0.008943641558289528,
0.5796066522598267,
-0.31189194321632385,
-0.12514208257198334,
-0.27624019980430603,
-0.8252410888671875,
-1.1227346658706665,
-0.31222453713417053,
-0.6645469665527344,
-0.04897565022110939,
0.09041114151477814,
0.9847784042358398,
0.40723904967308044,
-0.4685780107975006,
-0.3971407115459442,
0.613713800907135,
-0.015980495139956474,
-0.0064275688491761684,
-0.17708590626716614,
0.7161909341812134,
-0.17990969121456146,
-0.6792592406272888,
0.2620750367641449,
0.570851743221283,
0.2166362702846527,
-0.5379179120063782,
0.13403677940368652,
0.13842080533504486,
0.1631411612033844,
0.5390872359275818,
0.11877179890871048,
-0.45223650336265564,
-0.3192855715751648,
-0.24870622158050537,
-0.049738265573978424,
-0.26043111085891724,
0.8189907670021057,
-0.27242764830589294,
-0.0022676358930766582,
0.08664275705814362,
0.7005286812782288,
0.42470914125442505,
0.28490135073661804,
0.70412677526474,
-0.23347824811935425,
-0.07297372817993164,
-0.055619653314352036,
0.5448377728462219,
0.38088029623031616,
-0.30138882994651794,
0.7771573662757874,
0.22216318547725677,
-0.6927333474159241,
-0.5024263858795166,
-0.24648305773735046,
-0.8554551601409912,
-0.18198248744010925,
1.3318063020706177,
-0.5409350395202637,
-0.41132065653800964,
-0.326980322599411,
-0.17033186554908752,
-0.13474763929843903,
-0.7818188667297363,
0.7295124530792236,
0.9150627255439758,
0.03636708855628967,
0.04590051621198654,
-0.6904958486557007,
0.4496476948261261,
0.1295553594827652,
-0.7217926979064941,
0.4393032193183899,
0.45564520359039307,
0.17778651416301727,
0.16867688298225403,
0.6297619342803955,
0.0562882162630558,
0.014950359240174294,
0.020953111350536346,
0.009572084993124008,
-0.3611336946487427,
-0.012998920865356922,
-0.08875594288110733,
0.40573838353157043,
0.2667078673839569,
0.2909136712551117
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18148v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18148v1
|
Large Language Models Produce Responses Perceived to be Empathic
| 2024-03-26T23:14:34 | 2024-03-26T23:14:34 |
Yoon Kyung Lee, Jina Suh, Hongli Zhan, Junyi Jessy Li, Desmond C. Ong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated surprising performance on many
tasks, including writing supportive messages that display empathy. Here, we had
these models generate empathic messages in response to posts describing common
life experiences, such as workplace situations, parenting, relationships, and
other anxiety- and anger-eliciting situations. Across two studies (N=192, 202),
we showed human raters a variety of responses written by several models (GPT4
Turbo, Llama2, and Mistral), and had people rate these responses on how
empathic they seemed to be. We found that LLM-generated responses were
consistently rated as more empathic than human-written responses. Linguistic
analyses also show that these models write in distinct, predictable ``styles",
in terms of their use of punctuation, emojis, and certain words. These results
highlight the potential of using LLMs to enhance human peer support in contexts
where empathy is important.
|
[
-0.30108052492141724,
-0.8282617330551147,
0.9153952598571777,
0.4055068790912628,
-0.18652699887752533,
-0.02257557027041912,
-0.21342553198337555,
-0.617327868938446,
0.45510026812553406,
0.20284315943717957,
-0.3813515901565552,
-0.2904548943042755,
-0.821173906326294,
0.5465957522392273,
-0.24621032178401947,
0.8202265501022339,
0.09229177236557007,
0.3418397903442383,
-0.003935667220503092,
0.01850883476436138,
-0.08472542464733124,
-1.0177339315414429,
-0.8923037648200989,
-0.6219329237937927,
0.8503116369247437,
0.24112078547477722,
0.6280909776687622,
0.3266330063343048,
0.75773686170578,
0.3285941779613495,
-0.06865724176168442,
-0.07185463607311249,
-0.29416078329086304,
0.21122150123119354,
-0.056356173008680344,
-0.3419547975063324,
-0.8270001411437988,
0.23160941898822784,
0.40954384207725525,
0.44286784529685974,
-0.2098517268896103,
0.11681242287158966,
0.363320529460907,
0.38630175590515137,
-0.0739690363407135,
-0.051301103085279465,
-0.25793030858039856,
0.2665742337703705,
0.27391430735588074,
-0.1292230784893036,
-0.4489786922931671,
-0.27879491448402405,
0.03743327409029007,
-0.3645516037940979,
-0.18955852091312408,
0.3162960112094879,
0.5184831619262695,
-0.088419109582901,
-0.3995135724544525,
-0.30116549134254456,
-0.5661187767982483,
0.7056424617767334,
-0.7230361700057983,
0.10248227417469025,
0.36954808235168457,
0.0003390628844499588,
-0.06312169134616852,
-0.5599732995033264,
-0.5400515794754028,
-0.33782535791397095,
-0.18220463395118713,
0.014899238012731075,
-0.44474321603775024,
0.09860727936029434,
0.47502902150154114,
0.2875542938709259,
-0.34605780243873596,
0.31620529294013977,
-0.023733554407954216,
0.10041733831167221,
0.7392010688781738,
0.619049608707428,
0.2968050539493561,
-0.08866361528635025,
-0.014368081465363503,
0.0040053557604551315,
-0.6721558570861816,
0.07777750492095947,
0.4518287479877472,
0.1353716254234314,
-0.422007292509079,
0.6819149255752563,
0.20833410322666168,
0.722783088684082,
0.11356346309185028,
-0.17578212916851044,
-0.0243583582341671,
0.11737831681966782,
-0.22672948241233826,
-0.06515782326459885,
0.8407709002494812,
0.8778964877128601,
0.814723789691925,
-0.0045381998643279076,
-0.2756386995315552,
0.2621742784976959,
0.44616368412971497,
-0.8876274228096008,
0.08541283756494522,
0.09741030633449554,
-0.840151309967041,
-0.5201846957206726,
-0.1212429478764534,
-0.7194235920906067,
-0.7809619307518005,
-0.14076371490955353,
0.16512945294380188,
-0.023476406931877136,
-0.3854551911354065,
0.001586918719112873,
-0.13235963881015778,
0.25716301798820496,
0.40163013339042664,
-0.8739531636238098,
0.5605000853538513,
0.7818366289138794,
0.9716167449951172,
0.016005786135792732,
-0.3455698490142822,
-0.6117395758628845,
-0.060795124620199203,
-0.2552717626094818,
0.726711630821228,
-1.0230746269226074,
-0.5061872005462646,
0.09093065559864044,
-0.006595107261091471,
0.2593362331390381,
-0.452950656414032,
0.6442198157310486,
0.09206487983465195,
-0.07680582255125046,
-0.5410597920417786,
-0.4472068250179291,
0.12040694057941437,
0.46747034788131714,
-0.49867352843284607,
0.6749404072761536,
0.13152377307415009,
-0.8854470252990723,
0.13389331102371216,
-0.464394748210907,
-0.2737419009208679,
-0.21385937929153442,
-0.10143497586250305,
-0.14204241335391998,
0.5770294666290283,
0.033914629369974136,
0.942349374294281,
-0.6856322288513184,
0.12283168733119965,
-0.5870814919471741,
-0.20684435963630676,
0.6100389957427979,
-0.22124122083187103,
0.1643371880054474,
0.24441635608673096,
-0.22105593979358673,
-0.03328419104218483,
-0.4179999530315399,
-0.24463889002799988,
0.27225130796432495,
-0.30943864583969116,
-0.42373499274253845,
-0.1773195117712021,
0.11252214014530182,
0.4174627661705017,
-0.0566994808614254,
-1.0237444639205933,
0.1199909970164299,
-0.21747541427612305,
0.658504843711853,
0.8079432249069214,
0.04365108162164688,
0.24816139042377472,
-0.663161039352417,
0.6443634629249573,
0.058962613344192505,
0.1169215589761734,
-0.1953016072511673,
-0.6833817362785339,
-0.4404976963996887,
-0.19120077788829803,
-0.5030080676078796,
0.23233196139335632,
-0.12166813760995865,
0.17646831274032593,
-0.2186249941587448,
-0.6733137369155884,
-0.4965623617172241,
0.06048305705189705,
0.6765547394752502,
0.4186667501926422,
0.061065010726451874,
-0.40182381868362427,
-0.4011405110359192,
-1.0391502380371094,
-0.7231348752975464,
-0.23391476273536682,
0.003125734394416213,
0.7351354360580444,
0.32010120153427124,
-0.08709492534399033,
0.4461025297641754,
-0.44150540232658386,
-0.04367489367723465,
-0.3649289906024933,
0.031232841312885284,
0.04430535063147545,
0.1869039237499237,
0.47931423783302307,
-0.6773626208305359,
-0.6517648696899414,
-0.13947506248950958,
-0.677452027797699,
-0.24777460098266602,
-0.04052097722887993,
-0.027113035321235657,
0.08310700953006744,
0.39095598459243774,
-0.544522225856781,
0.20037834346294403,
0.7868553400039673,
-0.6431417465209961,
0.13523700833320618,
0.031310923397541046,
0.26123204827308655,
-1.3339462280273438,
0.012223332189023495,
0.21946150064468384,
-0.14474859833717346,
-0.616430938243866,
-0.26445531845092773,
-0.2554362714290619,
0.040246304124593735,
-0.397312194108963,
0.8468122482299805,
-0.44461509585380554,
0.0396215058863163,
-0.05664336308836937,
0.15103359520435333,
-0.03896849602460861,
0.1600124090909958,
0.3156929910182953,
0.3684062361717224,
0.5976833701133728,
-0.20419496297836304,
0.6419393420219421,
0.2747873067855835,
0.044394902884960175,
0.6903334259986877,
-0.9568111300468445,
0.2926338016986847,
-0.03088964708149433,
0.2218972146511078,
-0.9936327338218689,
-0.4416182041168213,
0.1834857165813446,
-0.513247549533844,
0.3363806903362274,
0.06699755787849426,
-0.636981189250946,
-0.5503777265548706,
-0.33550748229026794,
0.2750745117664337,
0.5553712844848633,
-0.47323161363601685,
0.9573862552642822,
0.3817509114742279,
-0.4328423738479614,
-0.10543554276227951,
-0.8969138264656067,
0.2532873749732971,
-0.39481809735298157,
-0.4982472360134125,
-0.1629631668329239,
-0.112277552485466,
-0.7664228677749634,
-0.16561733186244965,
0.3139738440513611,
-0.015673451125621796,
0.1115819439291954,
0.7138961553573608,
0.012261471711099148,
0.14828608930110931,
0.15046557784080505,
-0.0661347359418869,
0.09881895035505295,
0.38974669575691223,
0.4218815565109253,
0.6675096750259399,
-0.3273508548736572,
-0.4370931088924408,
-0.32442089915275574,
0.5661293268203735,
0.6288568377494812,
0.07157330960035324,
0.9568238854408264,
0.35218513011932373,
-0.3028066158294678,
0.03269212320446968,
-0.6941231489181519,
-0.5187986493110657,
-0.4354138672351837,
0.056804753839969635,
-0.3456401228904724,
-1.1913971900939941,
0.5128145217895508,
0.11218879371881485,
-0.1929263025522232,
-0.07982765138149261,
0.8504591584205627,
0.16513477265834808,
1.279486894607544,
0.42764919996261597,
-0.24092382192611694,
0.33081984519958496,
0.2711247205734253,
0.6190658807754517,
-1.0287134647369385,
-0.22570255398750305,
-0.3455730080604553,
-0.3035064935684204,
-0.7066139578819275,
-0.017998669296503067,
0.2519143223762512,
-0.31782856583595276,
-0.3165972828865051,
-0.042962346225976944,
-0.4659017324447632,
0.06273996829986572,
0.34617677330970764,
0.24900442361831665,
0.19441138207912445,
0.013868605718016624,
0.10695266723632812,
-0.1877128630876541,
-0.4920123517513275,
-0.8932861685752869,
1.103682041168213,
0.679958164691925,
1.0947766304016113,
0.08764144778251648,
0.8169033527374268,
0.2944023907184601,
0.8269818425178528,
-0.7204838395118713,
0.5835375785827637,
0.1145254373550415,
-0.41776207089424133,
-0.07236172258853912,
-0.2654701769351959,
-0.7305054068565369,
-0.06770634651184082,
-0.2679409980773926,
-0.80580735206604,
-0.0866776704788208,
0.259103387594223,
-0.36474689841270447,
0.3421250879764557,
-0.6398643255233765,
0.37996581196784973,
-0.07177960127592087,
-0.4328717291355133,
-0.10461090505123138,
-0.6608631610870361,
0.19187016785144806,
-0.38712403178215027,
0.23440413177013397,
-0.12449511140584946,
0.01900295354425907,
0.5357426404953003,
-0.25421062111854553,
1.161628007888794,
0.052531611174345016,
-0.24697861075401306,
0.24056974053382874,
0.484957754611969,
0.5268832445144653,
-0.04359396547079086,
-0.2945828139781952,
0.08626962453126907,
-0.34767651557922363,
-0.18506622314453125,
-0.4556569755077362,
0.8775177597999573,
-0.7916311621665955,
-0.7223853468894958,
-0.5339195728302002,
-0.6198705434799194,
-0.10476237535476685,
-0.09985274821519852,
0.10765790939331055,
0.4150215983390808,
-0.35768356919288635,
0.2501407265663147,
0.20259477198123932,
-0.5153303146362305,
0.4345204830169678,
0.5882595181465149,
-0.21542613208293915,
-0.255156010389328,
0.23395586013793945,
-0.18985335528850555,
0.42099860310554504,
0.2686631679534912,
0.44539380073547363,
-0.04477286711335182,
0.1426483690738678,
-0.008791839703917503,
0.5786631107330322,
-0.479123055934906,
-0.28081992268562317,
-0.7568387985229492,
0.10310212522745132,
-0.5682258605957031,
-0.536625862121582,
-0.2521876394748688,
-0.2232794463634491,
0.04319610074162483,
-0.4494846761226654,
0.6883252859115601,
1.187157392501831,
-0.4016832113265991,
0.20071808993816376,
-1.050878882408142,
0.04244045913219452,
0.27849820256233215,
0.25959059596061707,
0.24027086794376373,
-0.5629527568817139,
0.02185332030057907,
0.004298816435039043,
-0.16766807436943054,
-0.6922128200531006,
0.6340678334236145,
0.1982974112033844,
0.27672135829925537,
0.5112497210502625,
-0.15753327310085297,
0.2575521171092987,
-0.6287775635719299,
0.9414898157119751,
0.30219584703445435,
-0.8650446534156799,
0.31744927167892456,
-0.5984863638877869,
-0.20106376707553864,
-0.16638365387916565,
0.5455737709999084,
-0.7221301794052124,
-0.6014901995658875,
-0.5455525517463684,
-0.5067640542984009,
0.450827956199646,
0.03019818291068077,
0.6773970127105713,
-0.5175195932388306,
0.5475173592567444,
-0.020424557849764824,
0.17283809185028076,
-0.7853721380233765,
-0.1689649373292923,
-0.03612585365772247,
-0.14434221386909485,
-0.3497813045978546,
-0.7954038381576538,
-0.3674578070640564,
-0.10933414101600647,
-0.047012172639369965,
0.08545564860105515,
0.560746431350708,
0.3120252192020416,
0.36550140380859375,
-0.5060979723930359,
0.20754340291023254,
0.4614490270614624,
0.27763059735298157,
0.022720541805028915,
0.2575594484806061,
0.1926138699054718,
-0.29571333527565,
0.20321400463581085,
-0.31673234701156616,
0.41769376397132874,
-0.3390620946884155,
0.706801176071167,
0.5585311055183411,
0.12324799597263336,
-0.6272153258323669,
0.7664952874183655,
-0.20196659862995148,
-0.06035970523953438,
-0.2914893329143524,
-0.0005216759745962918,
0.3529425859451294,
0.43921664357185364,
-0.04236331582069397,
-0.4603711664676666,
0.14113359153270721,
-0.7703571915626526,
-0.16162286698818207,
0.4188288450241089,
-0.17275361716747284,
-0.6282909512519836,
0.446553498506546,
0.2762356102466583,
-0.615364134311676,
0.6907843351364136,
0.15594425797462463,
-0.616237223148346,
0.37793344259262085,
0.8256368041038513,
0.9725866913795471,
-0.3980368375778198,
0.15588058531284332,
0.34630662202835083,
0.20389442145824432,
-0.15031926333904266,
0.6357455253601074,
0.11542525887489319,
-0.8746030330657959,
0.0005736759630963206,
-0.8950284719467163,
-0.5312595367431641,
-0.18370521068572998,
-0.9881933331489563,
-0.22588062286376953,
-0.4958954453468323,
-0.45823249220848083,
-0.2750883400440216,
-0.24043770134449005,
-0.8732807040214539,
0.31794148683547974,
0.17354966700077057,
0.883530855178833,
-1.3620635271072388,
0.6307428479194641,
0.9183935523033142,
-0.391488641500473,
-1.1790882349014282,
-0.13751456141471863,
-0.049904078245162964,
-0.9626756310462952,
0.9212228059768677,
0.2173106074333191,
-0.17206469178199768,
-0.028704583644866943,
-0.5688686370849609,
-0.6085418462753296,
0.9117476344108582,
0.20255734026432037,
-0.5285534858703613,
0.014945783652365208,
0.2554466128349304,
0.9904996752738953,
-0.8804053664207458,
0.36085593700408936,
0.47129106521606445,
0.5055150985717773,
-0.3289794921875,
-0.9832509160041809,
0.38904058933258057,
-0.5584768652915955,
0.19144068658351898,
-0.00011052370973629877,
-0.8863332867622375,
0.9272008538246155,
-0.3294631540775299,
0.21549145877361298,
0.32434505224227905,
0.18519850075244904,
0.27064600586891174,
0.19291949272155762,
0.17166665196418762,
0.5767611861228943,
0.42284515500068665,
-0.08037470281124115,
1.5224969387054443,
-0.5868980884552002,
-0.03926648572087288,
0.8446726202964783,
-0.48632219433784485,
0.9866600632667542,
0.6541624069213867,
0.15050692856311798,
0.5160771012306213,
0.5290077924728394,
-0.05929572880268097,
0.11754398047924042,
0.14960640668869019,
-0.33992114663124084,
-0.4385644197463989,
-0.6585531830787659,
-0.1680586189031601,
0.35792818665504456,
0.20515374839305878,
-0.8540939688682556,
0.21785706281661987,
-0.05756790190935135,
0.35213032364845276,
0.20064124464988708,
-0.43715226650238037,
0.7047832012176514,
0.6872148513793945,
-0.5487585663795471,
0.17888569831848145,
-0.14614343643188477,
0.5512822866439819,
-0.2885318398475647,
-0.23102660477161407,
-0.31486445665359497,
0.07996615022420883,
-0.2936713397502899,
-1.0608247518539429,
0.10438510775566101,
0.3359717130661011,
-0.05065341293811798,
-0.4359520673751831,
0.6642362475395203,
-0.00589496735483408,
-0.41950759291648865,
0.7367214560508728,
0.6343657970428467,
0.4052337110042572,
-0.0012767422012984753,
-0.39104318618774414,
0.2748240530490875,
-0.3602830469608307,
-0.784362256526947,
0.5429854989051819,
0.6314403414726257,
0.07534415274858475,
0.8016286492347717,
0.5732690095901489,
0.2637079656124115,
0.004949952010065317,
0.15915869176387787,
1.0525189638137817,
-0.617849588394165,
-0.024797597900032997,
-1.072835087776184,
0.3091248869895935,
-0.16254056990146637,
-0.22093628346920013,
1.0377252101898193,
0.17844758927822113,
0.512942373752594,
-0.10224342346191406,
0.6474340558052063,
-0.015703855082392693,
0.6931179761886597,
-0.266589879989624,
0.4990391433238983,
-0.5105129480361938,
-0.02645682357251644,
-0.6792626976966858,
-1.05083429813385,
-0.3472664952278137,
0.7052167057991028,
-0.49750810861587524,
0.31784966588020325,
0.6042934060096741,
0.9594523906707764,
0.2386961728334427,
-0.17771215736865997,
0.6114058494567871,
0.4712531864643097,
0.3569366931915283,
0.6486046314239502,
1.0288468599319458,
0.08289003372192383,
0.07021034508943558,
-0.09184165298938751,
-0.13567301630973816,
-0.01265648566186428,
-1.0530898571014404,
-1.1871659755706787,
-0.2718852460384369,
0.034469179809093475,
-0.5078306198120117,
-0.07897709310054779,
1.172563076019287,
0.195044606924057,
-0.41576480865478516,
-0.25482022762298584,
0.10413988679647446,
-0.4919627904891968,
0.28446659445762634,
-0.17866475880146027,
0.10855467617511749,
0.027469858527183533,
-0.6558483839035034,
0.0173856932669878,
0.4733869135379791,
0.09566719830036163,
-0.17527277767658234,
-0.3653131127357483,
0.4038809835910797,
0.25713565945625305,
0.6970551013946533,
-0.06895815581083298,
-0.7125126123428345,
-0.6235395669937134,
0.16449043154716492,
-0.3077903687953949,
-0.0644463375210762,
0.8153344988822937,
-0.25665992498397827,
0.25250107049942017,
0.3156141936779022,
0.22426094114780426,
-0.09475980699062347,
0.1735566109418869,
0.8744716644287109,
-0.2380983531475067,
0.009559535421431065,
0.2526089549064636,
0.53962641954422,
0.5906506776809692,
-0.5468741655349731,
0.5176977515220642,
-0.0418783463537693,
-0.7621027827262878,
-0.9668341279029846,
0.3432150185108185,
-0.7184182405471802,
0.13042715191841125,
1.645689845085144,
-0.42083582282066345,
-0.09735464304685593,
0.19528262317180634,
-0.39493992924690247,
0.08128853887319565,
-0.6370112299919128,
0.8854386210441589,
0.8634271025657654,
-0.34198787808418274,
-0.19668589532375336,
-0.11199501156806946,
0.3196197748184204,
0.19927605986595154,
-0.6391705274581909,
-0.05122346058487892,
0.5201265811920166,
0.2704176902770996,
-0.09748301655054092,
0.5399429202079773,
0.029993891716003418,
0.10179309546947479,
0.06825646758079529,
0.11061257123947144,
0.00779063580557704,
-0.11941433697938919,
-0.47363099455833435,
0.02886764146387577,
0.6000920534133911,
0.4474632441997528
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18140v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18140v1
|
Juru: Legal Brazilian Large Language Model from Reputable Sources
| 2024-03-26T22:54:12 | 2024-03-26T22:54:12 |
Roseval Malaquias Junior, Ramon Pires, Roseli Romero, Rodrigo Nogueira
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The high computational cost associated with pretraining large language models
limits their research. Two strategies have emerged to address this issue:
domain specialization and pretraining with high-quality data. To explore these
strategies, we specialized the Sabi\'a-2 Small model with 1.9 billion unique
tokens from reputable Brazilian legal sources and conducted few-shot
evaluations on legal and general knowledge exams. Our model, Juru, demonstrates
the benefits of domain specialization with a reduced amount of pretraining
data. However, this specialization comes at the expense of degrading
performance in other knowledge areas within the same language. This study
contributes to the growing body of scientific evidence showing that pretraining
data selection may enhance the performance of large language models, enabling
the exploration of these models at a lower cost.
|
[
-0.1299903690814972,
-0.9829515814781189,
0.4281156361103058,
0.004222353920340538,
-0.464474081993103,
0.004558223765343428,
-0.346355140209198,
-0.4425651431083679,
0.17920120060443878,
0.7439137101173401,
0.1158793717622757,
-0.10352294147014618,
-0.6365463733673096,
-0.11027701199054718,
-0.4146057367324829,
0.9446704983711243,
0.39892470836639404,
0.2545594871044159,
-0.3217029273509979,
-0.3998073637485504,
-0.11609216034412384,
-0.7318912744522095,
-0.7708303928375244,
-0.3019222915172577,
0.6702808141708374,
0.12950827181339264,
0.5977498888969421,
0.5426774621009827,
0.4064476490020752,
0.22974596917629242,
-0.18370148539543152,
-0.19336095452308655,
-0.5908334851264954,
-0.17900118231773376,
-0.3828394114971161,
-0.8173794746398926,
-0.36054885387420654,
0.0037131987046450377,
0.8733095526695251,
0.5692440867424011,
-0.2623758316040039,
0.2506923973560333,
-0.12912142276763916,
0.8801117539405823,
-0.7670323848724365,
0.15694105625152588,
-0.45143547654151917,
-0.30506396293640137,
-0.7353917956352234,
-0.11759566515684128,
-0.45077505707740784,
-0.3879987299442291,
0.06816393882036209,
-0.5626389980316162,
0.1642817258834839,
-0.000821306137368083,
0.9532830119132996,
0.41470974683761597,
-0.5543652772903442,
-0.06406586617231369,
-0.6134365797042847,
0.4588887393474579,
-0.39899012446403503,
0.3208058774471283,
0.44126343727111816,
0.5823988914489746,
-0.06854411959648132,
-0.8082189559936523,
-0.3387240469455719,
-0.5128495097160339,
-0.029223747551441193,
-0.1192428320646286,
-0.4288349449634552,
0.008166615851223469,
0.4493131637573242,
0.14395050704479218,
-0.5543226003646851,
0.31517845392227173,
-0.5641312003135681,
-0.27510228753089905,
0.6651425361633301,
-0.05786830559372902,
0.15610060095787048,
0.2452799528837204,
0.059764496982097626,
-0.10421200841665268,
-1.2092326879501343,
-0.015533603727817535,
1.030747413635254,
0.19886773824691772,
0.10694210976362228,
0.47188565135002136,
-0.2169022262096405,
0.7346651554107666,
-0.3061644434928894,
-0.27683475613594055,
0.3186854124069214,
-0.1790219247341156,
-0.2964521050453186,
-0.306860089302063,
0.7980440855026245,
-0.28312182426452637,
0.34194332361221313,
-0.1718917340040207,
-0.09285907447338104,
-0.08895725756883621,
0.352077454328537,
-0.9871694445610046,
-0.2483804076910019,
0.07398812472820282,
-0.4876497685909271,
-0.17411912977695465,
-0.12961430847644806,
-0.5893028974533081,
-0.40192991495132446,
-0.3197518587112427,
0.32986941933631897,
-0.36565953493118286,
-0.328692764043808,
0.006286866031587124,
-0.1306747943162918,
-0.1825665682554245,
0.4217747747898102,
-0.6082352995872498,
0.3135497272014618,
0.40532535314559937,
0.3986157476902008,
0.056536123156547546,
-0.05684208124876022,
-0.7997151017189026,
0.04141324386000633,
-0.4040259122848511,
0.7829647064208984,
-0.7307602763175964,
-0.3300606906414032,
-0.08665244281291962,
-0.0859965980052948,
-0.04680127650499344,
-0.46547314524650574,
0.4128207564353943,
-0.9219403862953186,
0.017015790566802025,
-0.28752461075782776,
-0.45911943912506104,
-0.25102725625038147,
0.039218660444021225,
-0.8805138468742371,
0.7149837613105774,
0.3838656544685364,
-0.8261327743530273,
0.6161766648292542,
-0.8295332789421082,
-0.7166242599487305,
0.42813801765441895,
-0.4670625627040863,
-0.2886675298213959,
0.15484194457530975,
-0.10020463168621063,
0.17678096890449524,
-0.7264647483825684,
0.5283806324005127,
-0.1554318517446518,
-0.4133372902870178,
0.24885587394237518,
-0.2510381042957306,
1.0207382440567017,
0.5281179547309875,
-0.15147343277931213,
0.12016218900680542,
-0.7991260290145874,
-0.20174279808998108,
0.32732611894607544,
-0.30969393253326416,
-0.6312705278396606,
-0.09909585118293762,
-0.06722056120634079,
0.10900668799877167,
0.17300812900066376,
-0.3520808815956116,
0.22646751999855042,
-0.27324122190475464,
0.3784558176994324,
0.3182964622974396,
-0.13858091831207275,
0.5634866952896118,
-0.07189982384443283,
0.9955710172653198,
0.04854763671755791,
0.10135328024625778,
0.028189947828650475,
-0.3510097861289978,
-0.6723024249076843,
-0.41552624106407166,
1.046427607536316,
0.2730816900730133,
-0.5440555810928345,
0.2793559730052948,
-0.4165695607662201,
-0.6465857625007629,
-0.7088545560836792,
0.10572695732116699,
0.3922046720981598,
0.1326655000448227,
0.22003602981567383,
-0.2994755208492279,
-0.2584425210952759,
-1.1916218996047974,
-0.2691488265991211,
0.09420076757669449,
0.1974206417798996,
0.3310984969139099,
0.7450858354568481,
-0.21990403532981873,
0.8232089877128601,
-0.28230661153793335,
-0.2613483965396881,
-0.46153491735458374,
0.1936086118221283,
0.14095327258110046,
0.43059003353118896,
1.1411762237548828,
-0.6758735775947571,
-0.4463105797767639,
0.12643396854400635,
-0.2600778639316559,
0.04304834455251694,
-0.0936143547296524,
-0.11074521392583847,
0.2425161898136139,
0.3531566262245178,
-0.35853010416030884,
0.49754831194877625,
0.42182087898254395,
-0.30556520819664,
0.47287896275520325,
-0.2989075183868408,
0.1135367825627327,
-0.7324100732803345,
0.4507552981376648,
-0.010443353094160557,
-0.35073748230934143,
-0.4320111572742462,
0.35716167092323303,
0.19016686081886292,
-0.034279417246580124,
-0.44673871994018555,
0.6912375688552856,
-0.3631563186645508,
-0.2463568150997162,
-0.39138492941856384,
-0.1625249981880188,
-0.07795717567205429,
0.31738409399986267,
0.07806223630905151,
0.9753064513206482,
0.6190155744552612,
-0.6850077509880066,
0.1589297354221344,
0.18619734048843384,
-0.8540861010551453,
0.24045395851135254,
-0.7732328176498413,
0.04442412033677101,
-0.13250571489334106,
0.24999280273914337,
-0.33981776237487793,
-0.3469599187374115,
-0.021121742203831673,
-0.1580289751291275,
0.35393837094306946,
-0.7442247867584229,
-0.7403026223182678,
-0.30377253890037537,
0.30901259183883667,
0.4906580150127411,
0.5444853901863098,
-0.3510280251502991,
0.5207740068435669,
0.7614730596542358,
-0.3570427894592285,
-0.7421575784683228,
-0.8273330926895142,
-0.009051131084561348,
-0.3257223069667816,
-0.38281023502349854,
0.12449895590543747,
0.19896623492240906,
-0.19134609401226044,
0.06249648705124855,
0.17282047867774963,
-0.269889771938324,
0.33549392223358154,
0.1474725604057312,
0.05467391386628151,
-0.2327665090560913,
0.051945243030786514,
0.38461431860923767,
-0.10674833506345749,
0.14308784902095795,
-0.08402394503355026,
0.7917981147766113,
0.04621492698788643,
-0.2158263623714447,
-0.31585368514060974,
0.12886185944080353,
0.5019983649253845,
-0.5445494055747986,
0.8297463655471802,
0.3141835927963257,
-0.1989012062549591,
-0.13025155663490295,
-0.6400933265686035,
0.22369976341724396,
-0.4243854880332947,
0.38582512736320496,
-0.5691654682159424,
-1.0353772640228271,
0.4796409606933594,
-0.06369227170944214,
-0.21482884883880615,
0.505127489566803,
0.5986688733100891,
0.25821584463119507,
0.6225707530975342,
0.6691933274269104,
-0.14120113849639893,
0.7260522842407227,
-0.29484522342681885,
0.2516380548477173,
-0.3443944752216339,
-0.21823321282863617,
-0.8114960193634033,
-0.03546440601348877,
-0.5272555351257324,
-0.3661474883556366,
0.326938658952713,
0.025041406974196434,
-0.34608888626098633,
0.5268424153327942,
-0.10377524048089981,
0.7768092751502991,
0.9608019590377808,
0.06007219851016998,
0.2582385241985321,
0.151539146900177,
-0.13179652392864227,
0.18357574939727783,
-0.8455886244773865,
-0.4862430989742279,
1.3369097709655762,
0.3578883409500122,
0.7037233710289001,
-0.06402630358934402,
0.6174373030662537,
0.1920119673013687,
0.31211909651756287,
-0.639383852481842,
0.34274226427078247,
-0.08356177061796188,
-1.009207010269165,
-0.3724293112754822,
-0.6441704630851746,
-1.126874566078186,
0.20306038856506348,
-0.2852323651313782,
-0.5428655743598938,
0.23781834542751312,
0.15010228753089905,
-0.5694138407707214,
-0.052727941423654556,
-0.5271967649459839,
0.9388656616210938,
-0.26308920979499817,
-0.5371502041816711,
-0.7245851755142212,
-0.6060191988945007,
0.31555378437042236,
-0.3720797300338745,
0.23638376593589783,
-0.006228419952094555,
0.20804791152477264,
1.0971581935882568,
-0.4110241234302521,
0.42947521805763245,
-0.3100883662700653,
-0.0007064352394081652,
0.6193703413009644,
0.16621887683868408,
0.5256226062774658,
0.11386556178331375,
-0.2598305642604828,
0.09594695270061493,
0.1598980873823166,
-0.6115047335624695,
-0.5302446484565735,
0.43152686953544617,
-0.7196346521377563,
-0.5560732483863831,
-0.46432769298553467,
-0.29129040241241455,
-0.19017896056175232,
0.38132303953170776,
0.41340872645378113,
0.40045469999313354,
-0.49408504366874695,
0.5070315003395081,
0.20872315764427185,
-0.09745631366968155,
0.08484779298305511,
0.5962253212928772,
-0.035729583352804184,
-0.4131597876548767,
0.7851794958114624,
0.30886736512184143,
0.03257347643375397,
0.08150982856750488,
0.0914858803153038,
-0.32719796895980835,
-0.8324921131134033,
-0.22420482337474823,
0.34755733609199524,
-0.5200526118278503,
-0.2679916024208069,
-0.638319194316864,
-0.02363365702331066,
-0.44871631264686584,
0.07644098997116089,
-0.5919190049171448,
-0.4855438470840454,
-0.06209675595164299,
-0.10217481106519699,
0.18456511199474335,
0.5303725004196167,
0.08057927340269089,
0.5486984848976135,
-0.8004965782165527,
0.24118486046791077,
0.16761107742786407,
0.32879459857940674,
-0.3084009885787964,
-0.7420841455459595,
-0.45515626668930054,
0.17931407690048218,
0.04608383774757385,
-0.6013451218605042,
0.33247944712638855,
-0.1229773610830307,
0.8134282231330872,
0.6217583417892456,
-0.0643012523651123,
0.6283128261566162,
-0.4021156430244446,
0.5621779561042786,
0.24634650349617004,
-0.8761019110679626,
0.6436907649040222,
-0.40613436698913574,
-0.2635818123817444,
0.9567902684211731,
0.46321144700050354,
0.037261173129081726,
-0.12482073903083801,
-0.9306319952011108,
-0.5126983523368835,
0.7092666029930115,
0.304804265499115,
0.16797654330730438,
0.10760720819234848,
0.3664826452732086,
0.23816576600074768,
0.37112289667129517,
-0.8197862505912781,
0.0013294910313561559,
0.019564101472496986,
0.2205558717250824,
-0.03960951045155525,
-0.27565649151802063,
-0.3631453216075897,
-0.43443483114242554,
0.5920604467391968,
-0.19395765662193298,
0.18281805515289307,
-0.3325960338115692,
-0.4225199818611145,
0.0023944200947880745,
0.3266450762748718,
0.3709850609302521,
0.7751443982124329,
0.27648767828941345,
-0.19500884413719177,
0.046690698713064194,
-0.34739255905151367,
0.10274290293455124,
0.023065974935889244,
-0.34723377227783203,
-0.08377953618764877,
0.21808546781539917,
0.9423100352287292,
-0.0242305900901556,
-0.7956734895706177,
0.7348647117614746,
0.1960737258195877,
-0.2746105194091797,
-0.29252296686172485,
0.391422837972641,
-0.13827982544898987,
0.3138223886489868,
0.22551363706588745,
0.13666802644729614,
0.1823379397392273,
-0.6846750974655151,
-0.09767073392868042,
0.2551986277103424,
0.08362036943435669,
-0.21836088597774506,
0.6797286868095398,
0.38516655564308167,
0.05506611242890358,
0.6219889521598816,
-0.3458516001701355,
-0.4299628436565399,
0.6030568480491638,
0.3839249908924103,
0.40000560879707336,
-0.1151358038187027,
0.31191855669021606,
0.531155526638031,
0.23250721395015717,
-0.5063114166259766,
0.10596148669719696,
0.026520680636167526,
-0.5549294352531433,
-0.5425079464912415,
-0.5469450950622559,
-0.41320329904556274,
0.2690121829509735,
-0.73666912317276,
0.33273041248321533,
-0.477615624666214,
-0.3512102961540222,
-0.3330265283584595,
0.2660328149795532,
-0.9125021696090698,
0.39064648747444153,
0.002945855027064681,
0.8702676892280579,
-0.932306706905365,
1.2863528728485107,
0.5453416109085083,
-0.7879995107650757,
-0.3571718633174896,
-0.27802008390426636,
-0.4286107122898102,
-0.6422908902168274,
0.7014892101287842,
-0.04683421552181244,
0.10961799323558807,
0.004297969862818718,
-0.6470893025398254,
-0.8746032118797302,
0.8504891395568848,
0.7473971843719482,
-0.8338959217071533,
-0.1966705173254013,
0.06421414017677307,
0.6930661797523499,
-0.34424862265586853,
0.1638699322938919,
0.9489400386810303,
0.49048879742622375,
-0.02323169633746147,
-0.7327925562858582,
-0.05525114759802818,
-0.35527679324150085,
-0.22926676273345947,
0.1431952863931656,
-0.7396025061607361,
0.5920190215110779,
-0.23333442211151123,
-0.259567528963089,
-0.04733451083302498,
0.6309781670570374,
0.1789204478263855,
0.05561916530132294,
0.4999064803123474,
0.5414822101593018,
1.0776129961013794,
-0.06138814985752106,
1.1634557247161865,
-0.4043551981449127,
0.12477017194032669,
1.195842981338501,
-0.3290920853614807,
0.7585877776145935,
0.34583958983421326,
-0.3045315742492676,
0.5167701244354248,
0.5338315367698669,
-0.20923393964767456,
0.5502114295959473,
0.2331397384405136,
0.0032161902636289597,
-0.5004874467849731,
-0.0910320058465004,
-0.4587368071079254,
0.5557636618614197,
0.44453364610671997,
-0.30380886793136597,
0.08357241749763489,
-0.07785484939813614,
-0.060762014240026474,
-0.037009090185165405,
-0.04308675229549408,
0.5463089942932129,
-0.05567853897809982,
-0.6980542540550232,
0.1591964066028595,
-0.04706361144781113,
0.34569430351257324,
-0.5460770130157471,
0.339889794588089,
-0.25857168436050415,
-0.10422898083925247,
0.03172817826271057,
-0.41535091400146484,
0.2898373603820801,
0.2292177379131317,
0.3288160264492035,
-0.08915907889604568,
0.6681562066078186,
-0.2745492160320282,
-0.2814423739910126,
0.31423839926719666,
0.5894089341163635,
0.28347644209861755,
-0.3545299470424652,
-0.5613652467727661,
0.027306674048304558,
-0.4043404757976532,
-0.4476411044597626,
0.5337659120559692,
0.35307765007019043,
-0.17912310361862183,
0.6154317259788513,
0.7844401001930237,
0.1599648892879486,
-0.12052644044160843,
0.281203031539917,
1.0099958181381226,
-0.6534025073051453,
-0.8875302672386169,
-0.489962637424469,
0.46957096457481384,
-0.2777228057384491,
-0.39591696858406067,
0.4381316900253296,
0.8276163935661316,
0.7692714333534241,
-0.00508035346865654,
0.9529109597206116,
-0.08063844591379166,
0.41528114676475525,
-0.6091288328170776,
1.0315773487091064,
-0.6296647787094116,
-0.025888700038194656,
0.016214096918702126,
-1.0160813331604004,
-0.3158856928348541,
0.8086068034172058,
-0.4166721701622009,
0.05279343202710152,
0.8068735599517822,
0.5918394327163696,
-0.09752018749713898,
-0.26368090510368347,
0.47835931181907654,
0.1609896719455719,
0.1481517106294632,
0.295194536447525,
0.7357409000396729,
-0.3350777328014374,
0.49316608905792236,
-0.07922539860010147,
-0.11650620400905609,
-0.5629867315292358,
-0.5998047590255737,
-1.1899751424789429,
-0.46846631169319153,
-0.4472116529941559,
-0.3645188510417938,
-0.03034106083214283,
0.8007174134254456,
0.7200688719749451,
-0.753060519695282,
-0.07319213449954987,
-0.07004187256097794,
-0.04911026358604431,
0.118710957467556,
-0.09351778775453568,
0.25698575377464294,
-0.3711765706539154,
-0.6356440186500549,
0.5817128419876099,
-0.043667472898960114,
0.13163848221302032,
0.002248836448416114,
-0.10468123108148575,
0.08211775124073029,
0.16487708687782288,
0.4796155095100403,
0.4359208047389984,
-0.5289576053619385,
-0.03529386967420578,
-0.277582049369812,
-0.34450575709342957,
-0.04844477400183678,
1.120743989944458,
-0.6533253192901611,
0.2469674050807953,
0.6824767589569092,
0.6689786314964294,
0.8933113217353821,
0.007026105187833309,
0.6394028067588806,
-0.3814968168735504,
0.621407687664032,
0.30265840888023376,
0.6858583688735962,
-0.06533731520175934,
-0.09944088757038116,
0.9382060170173645,
0.1705337017774582,
-0.4528792202472687,
-0.7619030475616455,
0.07541052997112274,
-0.9420880675315857,
-0.3538793623447418,
1.3187205791473389,
-0.32627204060554504,
-0.38526710867881775,
-0.014684543013572693,
-0.1776689738035202,
0.25881996750831604,
-0.2839365005493164,
0.5664935111999512,
0.7130755186080933,
0.2840062379837036,
0.1257593333721161,
-0.4959423243999481,
0.440678209066391,
0.2849133610725403,
-0.8269170522689819,
0.03693888708949089,
0.6644989848136902,
0.46682748198509216,
0.06415615975856781,
0.7425315380096436,
-0.27145659923553467,
0.49261346459388733,
0.3133447766304016,
0.021181445568799973,
-0.3474735617637634,
-0.7080867886543274,
-0.3327222168445587,
0.321588933467865,
0.1351666897535324,
0.18156957626342773
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18125v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18125v1
|
For those who don't know (how) to ask: Building a dataset of technology questions for digital newcomers
| 2024-03-26T22:08:33 | 2024-03-26T22:08:33 |
Evan Lucas, Kelly S. Steelman, Leo C. Ureel, Charles Wallace
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While the rise of large language models (LLMs) has created rich new
opportunities to learn about digital technology, many on the margins of this
technology struggle to gain and maintain competency due to lexical or
conceptual barriers that prevent them from asking appropriate questions.
Although there have been many efforts to understand factuality of LLM-created
content and ability of LLMs to answer questions, it is not well understood how
unclear or nonstandard language queries affect the model outputs. We propose
the creation of a dataset that captures questions of digital newcomers and
outsiders, utilizing data we have compiled from a decade's worth of one-on-one
tutoring. In this paper we lay out our planned efforts and some potential uses
of this dataset.
|
[
-0.8429368734359741,
-0.8610355854034424,
0.8214573264122009,
-0.43708181381225586,
0.11571527272462845,
0.38867175579071045,
0.20195035636425018,
-0.20382998883724213,
0.20569172501564026,
0.5144162178039551,
-1.0414446592330933,
-0.5987823009490967,
-0.4929513931274414,
0.2095702737569809,
-0.7668418288230896,
0.8448440432548523,
0.016822993755340576,
-0.35200250148773193,
-0.358612984418869,
0.2180558145046234,
-0.610623836517334,
-0.275002121925354,
-0.5542086958885193,
0.08922231197357178,
0.3781963288784027,
1.1214097738265991,
0.25539448857307434,
0.3516729176044464,
0.29137715697288513,
0.27744945883750916,
0.04151393473148346,
-0.01197130884975195,
-0.5216332674026489,
-0.006155600771307945,
-0.06227140501141548,
-0.7905892729759216,
0.12718898057937622,
-0.013435092754662037,
0.3900700509548187,
1.09492826461792,
0.30600470304489136,
0.5377306342124939,
-0.24725021421909332,
0.6241811513900757,
-0.3761495351791382,
-0.08048659563064575,
-0.8659708499908447,
0.12992258369922638,
-0.43046045303344727,
-0.4360491633415222,
-0.2145071178674698,
-0.5982444286346436,
0.030600013211369514,
-0.581244170665741,
0.662377655506134,
-0.09377095103263855,
0.5985429286956787,
0.35389605164527893,
-0.7078479528427124,
-0.46420803666114807,
-0.9575772881507874,
0.5344545841217041,
-0.4964649975299835,
0.2513110041618347,
0.9084705114364624,
0.530971884727478,
-0.04890806972980499,
-0.8263624310493469,
-0.6581292748451233,
0.18364009261131287,
0.1649225503206253,
-0.11826510727405548,
0.01988043449819088,
-0.5207513570785522,
0.11150546371936798,
0.29777413606643677,
-0.5485785603523254,
-0.09246723353862762,
-0.9293306469917297,
-0.12100528925657272,
0.6523729562759399,
0.4215328097343445,
0.1416928768157959,
-0.058695219457149506,
-0.14060184359550476,
0.24244116246700287,
-0.7886258959770203,
0.05384601652622223,
0.5346880555152893,
0.47263938188552856,
-0.28836914896965027,
0.6411607265472412,
-0.012950939126312733,
0.8956299424171448,
0.3369261920452118,
-0.2599978744983673,
-0.20825424790382385,
-0.46615588665008545,
0.4448971748352051,
-0.06347349286079407,
0.16224390268325806,
0.363008588552475,
0.5408558249473572,
-0.13771140575408936,
-0.1877865344285965,
-0.559420645236969,
0.20597268640995026,
-0.5768612027168274,
-0.2174975723028183,
0.44232177734375,
-0.26500484347343445,
-0.018541879951953888,
0.196794793009758,
-0.6818957924842834,
-0.6981449127197266,
-0.48782482743263245,
0.2720712423324585,
-0.10007836669683456,
-0.490439236164093,
-0.019413579255342484,
-0.06977084279060364,
0.1928548812866211,
0.4177330732345581,
-1.2011637687683105,
0.545621395111084,
0.4906672537326813,
0.7605493664741516,
-0.05179580673575401,
-0.03169706091284752,
-0.11748328804969788,
-0.2293633371591568,
-0.43008944392204285,
0.8795667886734009,
-0.1917707473039627,
-0.677734375,
0.18623541295528412,
0.14864347875118256,
0.09077473729848862,
-0.6578755974769592,
0.03433096036314964,
-0.9153897762298584,
0.38174572587013245,
-0.5858044028282166,
-0.6653051376342773,
-0.024555791169404984,
0.5000447034835815,
-0.7095972299575806,
0.7529891729354858,
0.22434483468532562,
-1.006080150604248,
0.3134290874004364,
-0.31855517625808716,
-0.16923512518405914,
0.2651650309562683,
-0.369602233171463,
0.12512174248695374,
-0.02469312958419323,
0.31821706891059875,
0.41634759306907654,
-0.33120787143707275,
0.27294906973838806,
0.0924888551235199,
-0.333372563123703,
0.34177157282829285,
-0.16035951673984528,
0.8209400177001953,
0.11389178782701492,
0.003842675592750311,
-0.5217723846435547,
-0.7883135080337524,
-0.13606028258800507,
0.2436378449201584,
-0.42318975925445557,
-0.24956288933753967,
-0.06493442505598068,
-0.1285414844751358,
0.08950044959783554,
0.35255715250968933,
-0.6708886623382568,
0.1561373472213745,
-0.10202710330486298,
0.24771250784397125,
0.7740163803100586,
0.1599448323249817,
0.14318111538887024,
-0.5179046988487244,
0.9294113516807556,
0.04478365555405617,
-0.1483294814825058,
-0.33832094073295593,
-0.37451601028442383,
-0.716982901096344,
0.4565143585205078,
0.30996543169021606,
0.558890700340271,
-1.1447138786315918,
0.05830405652523041,
-0.15887629985809326,
-0.5101661086082458,
-0.5358172059059143,
0.39309418201446533,
-0.22996564209461212,
0.7622143030166626,
0.16398894786834717,
0.18352776765823364,
-0.5752339959144592,
-0.8412090539932251,
0.19914434850215912,
-0.46113836765289307,
-0.19001346826553345,
0.6893421411514282,
0.4269089996814728,
0.22099460661411285,
1.2960110902786255,
-0.6112699508666992,
0.11093676090240479,
-0.18929654359817505,
-0.02232043258845806,
0.34253913164138794,
0.05460815131664276,
0.16211558878421783,
-0.7017220258712769,
-0.3724428415298462,
-0.33373114466667175,
-0.7917036414146423,
-0.12015726417303085,
-0.2504211366176605,
0.386949747800827,
-0.037011656910181046,
0.8036983013153076,
-0.3256252706050873,
-0.09177350997924805,
0.5695256590843201,
-0.27264487743377686,
0.40071630477905273,
-0.07758883386850357,
0.23751263320446014,
-1.3278135061264038,
0.04464153200387955,
0.15678781270980835,
-0.0028260161634534597,
-0.6735568046569824,
-0.29108238220214844,
-0.2471608966588974,
-0.2913113832473755,
-0.7225537896156311,
0.9055194854736328,
-0.19885960221290588,
-0.11177882552146912,
-0.11171246320009232,
0.38706544041633606,
-0.3173249065876007,
-0.036387600004673004,
-0.09685970097780228,
1.142791986465454,
0.515568196773529,
-0.8579320311546326,
0.2242928445339203,
0.3712465167045593,
-0.43121954798698425,
0.7931857705116272,
-0.7156965732574463,
0.513130247592926,
-0.376430869102478,
-0.20578263700008392,
-1.132455587387085,
-0.2691349387168884,
-0.025812961161136627,
-0.5780227780342102,
0.2798611521720886,
-0.4033595323562622,
-0.46607792377471924,
-0.5586743354797363,
-0.004513399209827185,
0.6309411525726318,
0.30106115341186523,
-0.683435320854187,
0.41204652190208435,
0.7269534468650818,
-0.6676187515258789,
-0.3074643313884735,
-0.6226106286048889,
0.3828815519809723,
-0.3149156868457794,
-0.840440571308136,
0.2202948033809662,
-0.025130635127425194,
-0.6018546223640442,
-0.10045809298753738,
0.10378663241863251,
-0.5725674033164978,
0.2850000858306885,
-0.1343957483768463,
0.20917434990406036,
-0.34291714429855347,
0.36390992999076843,
-0.11606475710868835,
-0.11915501952171326,
0.36464959383010864,
-0.22179292142391205,
0.6580423712730408,
0.12222783267498016,
-0.39196643233299255,
-0.18222446739673615,
0.1949070543050766,
0.06250561773777008,
0.15175990760326385,
0.42363330721855164,
0.27940449118614197,
-0.21266676485538483,
-0.343875914812088,
-0.6378106474876404,
-0.36868759989738464,
-0.5507723689079285,
0.19819365441799164,
-0.3087248206138611,
-0.9660844802856445,
0.5699859261512756,
-0.008738354779779911,
0.11536760628223419,
0.2035871148109436,
0.4992491602897644,
-0.3240801990032196,
0.43844231963157654,
0.6871181130409241,
0.1439015120267868,
0.13708680868148804,
-0.2822446823120117,
0.007582658901810646,
-0.17881713807582855,
-0.6077913045883179,
-0.5341852903366089,
-0.13422204554080963,
-0.5870778560638428,
-0.25562718510627747,
0.26895996928215027,
-0.31653502583503723,
-0.18617038428783417,
0.24828442931175232,
-0.17977987229824066,
0.5415338277816772,
0.6954872012138367,
0.18490949273109436,
0.49932050704956055,
-0.04992477595806122,
0.4010215997695923,
-0.14111573994159698,
-0.6662904024124146,
-0.755298376083374,
1.4116467237472534,
0.1265002340078354,
1.0141534805297852,
0.0774003192782402,
0.695574164390564,
0.6371706128120422,
-0.07504308968782425,
-0.7838776111602783,
0.6472702622413635,
-0.03454430401325226,
-1.0216459035873413,
-0.18793560564517975,
-0.4504946768283844,
-1.0756052732467651,
-0.4866514205932617,
-0.0684729740023613,
-0.591124951839447,
0.208098903298378,
0.18942832946777344,
-0.3425343930721283,
0.4549521505832672,
-0.4786636531352997,
0.5104097723960876,
-0.35640689730644226,
-0.29246222972869873,
0.2930717468261719,
-0.6137111186981201,
0.5424315929412842,
-0.4047444462776184,
0.28927356004714966,
-0.06259851157665253,
-0.04226650297641754,
0.9091265201568604,
-0.37892600893974304,
1.0495938062667847,
-0.2960245907306671,
-0.2509831488132477,
0.8586660027503967,
0.16587424278259277,
-0.050970956683158875,
-0.16979913413524628,
-0.007941573858261108,
-0.026925168931484222,
0.3709765672683716,
-0.22308878600597382,
-0.40538489818573,
0.44448164105415344,
-0.6590346693992615,
-0.7437973618507385,
-0.15954524278640747,
-0.4642358124256134,
-0.292965292930603,
0.14202497899532318,
0.07242673635482788,
0.3487619161605835,
-0.262355774641037,
0.10839325934648514,
0.7371028661727905,
-0.2697894275188446,
0.32419994473457336,
0.68317711353302,
-0.1186840832233429,
-0.012078735046088696,
0.9707502722740173,
0.3184029161930084,
0.16272878646850586,
0.16602879762649536,
0.19764961302280426,
-0.484640896320343,
-0.34013035893440247,
-0.520999550819397,
0.3011026978492737,
-0.9997296929359436,
0.11736276000738144,
-0.4591964781284332,
-0.17405931651592255,
-0.24122251570224762,
-0.08669916540384293,
-0.1699371635913849,
-0.42963486909866333,
-0.5166724324226379,
-0.12598851323127747,
0.4579367935657501,
1.2543190717697144,
0.05375516414642334,
0.29153212904930115,
-0.7040187120437622,
0.2689683735370636,
0.5819141268730164,
0.025163967162370682,
-0.08503350615501404,
-0.7519811391830444,
-0.22682605683803558,
-0.09569084644317627,
-0.34581610560417175,
-0.8782764673233032,
0.14072924852371216,
0.0520654171705246,
0.5233302712440491,
0.20318473875522614,
0.2233027070760727,
0.2865757942199707,
-0.3331087827682495,
0.9345817565917969,
-0.18932776153087616,
-0.7492213845252991,
0.5864354372024536,
-0.41237422823905945,
0.15410877764225006,
0.8298450112342834,
0.9621132016181946,
-0.6505348682403564,
0.05572935566306114,
-0.5451077818870544,
-0.4633328318595886,
0.7089226245880127,
-0.18689608573913574,
0.528351902961731,
0.008518262766301632,
0.49887770414352417,
0.3327920734882355,
0.23249030113220215,
-0.5579612255096436,
-0.4587392508983612,
-0.24486638605594635,
-0.27509748935699463,
0.13218718767166138,
-0.0699491798877716,
0.13578981161117554,
-0.1847297102212906,
0.35119184851646423,
-0.26469337940216064,
0.12785135209560394,
-0.2194962501525879,
0.125908762216568,
0.0037226108834147453,
0.09199237078428268,
0.22525106370449066,
0.9289638996124268,
-0.09405701607465744,
0.24796496331691742,
0.20131219923496246,
-0.3267517685890198,
0.4460037052631378,
-0.10763195157051086,
-0.49935758113861084,
-0.04798482358455658,
0.277226984500885,
0.38199520111083984,
-0.2517879903316498,
-0.8570851683616638,
0.3467285931110382,
-0.2396114468574524,
-0.5684749484062195,
-0.5455758571624756,
0.011318489909172058,
0.4581005871295929,
0.01420492585748434,
0.4299405813217163,
-0.5784499645233154,
-0.24301952123641968,
-0.7373157739639282,
0.32523050904273987,
0.44496142864227295,
-0.27147728204727173,
-0.33078205585479736,
0.6132041215896606,
0.19878815114498138,
-0.7144128680229187,
0.7025570869445801,
0.08038730919361115,
-0.15710225701332092,
0.7969968318939209,
0.5797908902168274,
0.48574933409690857,
-0.008217466995120049,
0.550027072429657,
0.27165520191192627,
0.4574677646160126,
0.1146463081240654,
0.6188509464263916,
-0.11956941336393356,
-0.8033589720726013,
-0.0307448860257864,
-0.03157452493906021,
-0.68939208984375,
0.06630127131938934,
-0.4475201666355133,
0.6876102089881897,
-0.6919792294502258,
-0.3197707235813141,
-0.17512430250644684,
-0.1002872958779335,
-0.8296766877174377,
0.37152498960494995,
0.06877047568559647,
0.9091117978096008,
-1.0049253702163696,
0.3026984930038452,
0.6715319752693176,
-0.6320222616195679,
-0.5038268566131592,
0.1421668380498886,
0.0881923958659172,
-0.8589622378349304,
0.9251697063446045,
-0.18747581541538239,
0.24708865582942963,
0.20352083444595337,
-0.6668582558631897,
-1.0389602184295654,
1.0278035402297974,
0.2930399179458618,
-0.29544779658317566,
-0.24678616225719452,
0.621974527835846,
0.33863773941993713,
-0.090022973716259,
0.2410683035850525,
0.6319737434387207,
0.41435593366622925,
0.35503318905830383,
-0.5052692890167236,
-0.19159837067127228,
-0.17556649446487427,
-0.5755653381347656,
-0.043381765484809875,
-0.43057072162628174,
1.0084232091903687,
-0.30881521105766296,
-0.3555144965648651,
-0.015051967464387417,
0.2522065341472626,
0.04664410650730133,
0.4911409616470337,
0.3271627426147461,
0.08074826747179031,
0.8898061513900757,
-0.15673452615737915,
0.930538535118103,
-0.31941893696784973,
0.056563135236501694,
1.0905706882476807,
0.006390446797013283,
0.5611282587051392,
0.3955722749233246,
-0.4292023479938507,
0.32588598132133484,
0.9833664298057556,
-0.21189071238040924,
0.3025982677936554,
0.3445810377597809,
-0.45987483859062195,
-0.33415523171424866,
-0.2197589874267578,
-0.348103791475296,
0.3826104998588562,
0.2927408516407013,
-0.09519033879041672,
-0.3724595010280609,
-0.09884434193372726,
-0.09823740273714066,
0.2888028919696808,
-0.21960338950157166,
0.9499468207359314,
0.10623949021100998,
-0.44222620129585266,
0.46199238300323486,
-0.0010917701292783022,
0.5725986957550049,
-0.45700380206108093,
0.14687754213809967,
-0.5787867307662964,
-0.19731350243091583,
-0.19950801134109497,
-1.0919922590255737,
0.293160080909729,
0.23709283769130707,
-0.17319512367248535,
0.27881231904029846,
0.4112440049648285,
-0.2089284509420395,
-0.9014909267425537,
-0.16011346876621246,
1.00077486038208,
0.4711044132709503,
0.2546497881412506,
-0.44230154156684875,
-0.27940842509269714,
-0.17775435745716095,
0.21035762131214142,
0.10465124249458313,
0.3553210496902466,
-0.02889218181371689,
0.9704448580741882,
0.26780664920806885,
0.13793645799160004,
0.24212679266929626,
-0.05510559305548668,
0.8888645768165588,
-0.673152506351471,
-0.2353897988796234,
-0.6659116148948669,
0.5340374112129211,
0.1843477338552475,
-0.6707221269607544,
0.9794299602508545,
0.40976056456565857,
1.0483081340789795,
0.11910498887300491,
0.8979097008705139,
-0.1355021595954895,
0.7024377584457397,
-0.5783190727233887,
0.4354979395866394,
-0.7658417224884033,
0.3702920079231262,
-0.17164918780326843,
-0.8187194466590881,
0.09306506812572479,
0.29674145579338074,
-0.28557702898979187,
0.30039823055267334,
0.378793329000473,
0.9534788727760315,
-0.011217225342988968,
0.20876218378543854,
0.2615740895271301,
-0.04550259932875633,
0.4092804789543152,
0.2936210036277771,
1.0886435508728027,
-0.3303494155406952,
0.5756433010101318,
-0.3233408033847809,
0.10524708777666092,
0.12853051722049713,
-0.8072128891944885,
-1.083860993385315,
-0.6630712151527405,
-0.19323548674583435,
-0.35709497332572937,
0.057077083736658096,
1.0392345190048218,
0.5982690453529358,
-1.0207778215408325,
-0.43359610438346863,
-0.037786439061164856,
0.13895641267299652,
0.5732406973838806,
-0.16413100063800812,
0.13929110765457153,
-0.1666947901248932,
-0.6332209706306458,
0.40728798508644104,
-0.43188145756721497,
0.2644319236278534,
-0.6739757657051086,
0.20270514488220215,
-0.21564188599586487,
0.08701100200414658,
0.2516355812549591,
0.5003955364227295,
-0.32102110981941223,
0.010893643833696842,
0.3010682463645935,
0.2766678035259247,
0.06463853269815445,
1.055586338043213,
-0.7852687835693359,
0.43694257736206055,
0.30454036593437195,
1.0484105348587036,
0.598397433757782,
0.328120619058609,
0.36646097898483276,
-1.0055025815963745,
-0.15747709572315216,
0.3317458927631378,
0.11787328869104385,
0.6734063625335693,
-0.257569283246994,
0.20700432360172272,
0.3386150598526001,
-0.4237440228462219,
-0.47619763016700745,
0.12507516145706177,
-0.45349738001823425,
-0.3933814764022827,
0.9685138463973999,
0.20917820930480957,
0.19964823126792908,
-0.7438265085220337,
-0.19063182175159454,
-0.10940957069396973,
-0.026250779628753662,
1.100703239440918,
0.6989098191261292,
0.023610848933458328,
-0.4670169949531555,
-0.6537746787071228,
0.16399931907653809,
0.03792527690529823,
-1.0774390697479248,
-0.024298537522554398,
0.435569167137146,
0.5302488207817078,
-0.018141144886612892,
0.8311113715171814,
0.08882110565900803,
0.030324548482894897,
0.2231188416481018,
-0.22682346403598785,
-0.28348466753959656,
-0.4754865765571594,
-0.11849532276391983,
0.23521289229393005,
0.3885321319103241,
-0.02181149274110794
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18120v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18120v1
|
Don't Trust: Verify -- Grounding LLM Quantitative Reasoning with Autoformalization
| 2024-03-26T22:01:13 | 2024-03-26T22:01:13 |
Jin Peng Zhou, Charles Staats, Wenda Li, Christian Szegedy, Kilian Q. Weinberger, Yuhuai Wu
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLM), such as Google's Minerva and OpenAI's GPT
families, are becoming increasingly capable of solving mathematical
quantitative reasoning problems. However, they still make unjustified logical
and computational errors in their reasoning steps and answers. In this paper,
we leverage the fact that if the training corpus of LLMs contained sufficiently
many examples of formal mathematics (e.g. in Isabelle, a formal theorem proving
environment), they can be prompted to translate i.e. autoformalize informal
mathematical statements into formal Isabelle code -- which can be verified
automatically for internal consistency. This provides a mechanism to
automatically reject solutions whose formalized versions are inconsistent
within themselves or with the formalized problem statement. We evaluate our
method on GSM8K, MATH and MultiArith datasets and demonstrate that our approach
provides a consistently better heuristic than vanilla majority voting -- the
previously best method to identify correct answers, by more than 12% on GSM8K.
In our experiments it improves results consistently across all datasets and LLM
model sizes. The code can be found at https://github.com/jinpz/dtv.
|
[
-0.14178124070167542,
-0.6732535362243652,
0.847663402557373,
0.3435742259025574,
-0.12950725853443146,
0.2682341933250427,
-0.14349108934402466,
-0.07353706657886505,
-0.3579182028770447,
0.33449527621269226,
-0.29965952038764954,
-0.6829137802124023,
-0.7317289113998413,
0.23074381053447723,
-0.4694176912307739,
0.6354185342788696,
-0.5576401352882385,
0.11977294832468033,
-0.4993545413017273,
-0.07165990769863129,
0.18856003880500793,
-0.574169933795929,
-0.5336651802062988,
-0.5881049036979675,
-0.12473245710134506,
0.2975330352783203,
0.7613845467567444,
0.6813012957572937,
0.37260234355926514,
0.325541615486145,
0.2540898323059082,
0.4821808338165283,
-0.3822108507156372,
0.0961938425898552,
0.14823709428310394,
-0.538080632686615,
-0.4170932173728943,
-0.014151470735669136,
0.41196590662002563,
0.19630813598632812,
-0.14006316661834717,
0.3658618927001953,
-0.16808055341243744,
0.5756300091743469,
-0.6180415153503418,
0.3550834655761719,
-0.7775382995605469,
-0.15413758158683777,
0.06559579819440842,
-0.1358933448791504,
-0.6542118191719055,
-0.7724317312240601,
-0.2870510220527649,
-0.5006462335586548,
-0.09804054349660873,
0.016405992209911346,
1.1540430784225464,
0.7472769021987915,
-0.5606129765510559,
-0.04634599760174751,
-0.8572268486022949,
0.7654402852058411,
-0.6398256421089172,
0.10341103374958038,
0.904664933681488,
0.44223150610923767,
-0.18014469742774963,
-0.2895669937133789,
-0.39195749163627625,
-0.3848519027233124,
-0.04645213484764099,
0.10082834213972092,
-0.1891116350889206,
-0.052311159670352936,
0.6348518133163452,
0.2850818336009979,
-0.7434930205345154,
-0.07441025227308273,
-0.13122637569904327,
-0.3281914293766022,
0.6590710878372192,
-0.15638886392116547,
0.35683637857437134,
0.014234810136258602,
-0.1024235263466835,
-0.17238624393939972,
-1.0916671752929688,
0.07365700602531433,
0.3443979322910309,
-0.40782156586647034,
-0.03271090239286423,
0.7351390719413757,
-0.3140561282634735,
0.5012353658676147,
0.4727954566478729,
-0.050848908722400665,
-0.006513844709843397,
-0.1109587699174881,
-0.6052529215812683,
0.1311059296131134,
0.7763962149620056,
0.12692728638648987,
0.5005566477775574,
-0.10812846571207047,
-0.39401137828826904,
0.3472355008125305,
0.009557187557220459,
-0.6707509756088257,
-0.3919927179813385,
0.4813084304332733,
-0.026072220876812935,
-0.3767668604850769,
-0.023265773430466652,
-0.13090790808200836,
0.04570743441581726,
-0.4413054585456848,
0.5678405165672302,
-0.40959420800209045,
0.12550511956214905,
0.20478470623493195,
0.3720588684082031,
0.20481717586517334,
0.41286566853523254,
-0.6101211309432983,
0.2207501232624054,
0.7624965906143188,
0.48684048652648926,
0.31545567512512207,
0.005537654273211956,
-0.7382133603096008,
0.11302404850721359,
-0.6725784540176392,
0.627228856086731,
-0.12964333593845367,
-0.18908748030662537,
-0.11141715198755264,
-0.06640024483203888,
0.07251247018575668,
-0.42070192098617554,
0.6791384220123291,
-0.746608316898346,
0.20735278725624084,
-0.25440365076065063,
-0.4630905091762543,
0.003430871991440654,
0.5809630751609802,
-0.38814687728881836,
1.1560759544372559,
0.05570046976208687,
-0.41153085231781006,
0.22479861974716187,
-0.3877946138381958,
-0.015208990313112736,
-0.27985596656799316,
-0.25584906339645386,
-0.6765629649162292,
-0.09613434225320816,
0.595185399055481,
0.20434966683387756,
-0.13463570177555084,
0.5835370421409607,
-0.6265897154808044,
-0.23695632815361023,
0.4978131651878357,
-0.43557971715927124,
1.031034231185913,
0.1598116010427475,
-0.6345615983009338,
0.09902485460042953,
-0.8311221599578857,
0.3723408579826355,
0.19469022750854492,
0.18120819330215454,
-0.44660547375679016,
-0.3332374095916748,
-0.757107138633728,
0.24176323413848877,
0.1923772096633911,
-0.5569923520088196,
0.1311141550540924,
-0.306904137134552,
0.6254178285598755,
0.8643522262573242,
-0.18396763503551483,
0.5084362030029297,
-0.5577043294906616,
0.4243685007095337,
0.028042316436767578,
0.10906463861465454,
-0.225637286901474,
-0.4202391803264618,
-0.8199852705001831,
-0.12838907539844513,
0.5440152287483215,
0.656925618648529,
-0.779286801815033,
0.4594372510910034,
-0.3053356111049652,
-0.4270450174808502,
-0.3838574290275574,
0.12319383770227432,
0.3372058868408203,
0.6941128969192505,
0.33533984422683716,
0.2936350107192993,
-0.519028902053833,
-0.8984065651893616,
-0.1118987649679184,
-0.39617350697517395,
-0.07078735530376434,
0.056628234684467316,
0.557389497756958,
-0.2912759780883789,
1.1444026231765747,
-0.24616315960884094,
0.09797833859920502,
0.5292643904685974,
0.3639642894268036,
-0.027104025706648827,
0.5455292463302612,
0.4919482469558716,
-0.452886700630188,
-0.5508220791816711,
-0.26815366744995117,
-1.088951587677002,
-0.39301955699920654,
-0.0295671708881855,
-0.2903608977794647,
0.33193472027778625,
0.4965340793132782,
-0.43989133834838867,
0.5195523500442505,
0.6914346218109131,
-0.17335624992847443,
0.4438408613204956,
-0.29620692133903503,
0.3948120176792145,
-0.7196739315986633,
-0.2337580919265747,
0.10992958396673203,
-0.6338176727294922,
0.07505811750888824,
0.07202231884002686,
0.3755340874195099,
-0.04624522477388382,
0.07451490312814713,
0.44175922870635986,
-0.23880907893180847,
0.054537251591682434,
0.05857623741030693,
-0.07785853743553162,
0.29075154662132263,
0.06378896534442902,
-0.13912074267864227,
1.0144014358520508,
0.3854178488254547,
-0.5348048806190491,
0.4428027868270874,
0.3049144148826599,
-0.12370819598436356,
0.6465247869491577,
-0.9752688407897949,
0.3541894555091858,
0.01663261465728283,
0.43087881803512573,
-1.1104562282562256,
-0.30781081318855286,
0.2429748773574829,
-0.6809470057487488,
-0.05211987718939781,
-0.5305643081665039,
-0.7840262055397034,
-0.07074308395385742,
-0.17416222393512726,
0.3988412916660309,
0.7033675312995911,
-0.6848065853118896,
0.6660553812980652,
0.13915999233722687,
0.1044405996799469,
-0.7690492868423462,
-0.730015754699707,
0.11539764702320099,
-0.22115778923034668,
-1.0812445878982544,
0.22475221753120422,
-0.09152861684560776,
-0.764594316482544,
0.029577286913990974,
-0.26581865549087524,
-0.39452099800109863,
0.29568690061569214,
0.2610894441604614,
0.3148283362388611,
-0.2852441370487213,
-0.03193717449903488,
0.22334948182106018,
-0.4151272177696228,
0.35371077060699463,
-0.560174286365509,
0.03206637501716614,
-0.3861040771007538,
-0.755262553691864,
-0.20239010453224182,
0.04156564921140671,
0.5794968605041504,
-0.166400745511055,
0.3403626084327698,
0.4986405372619629,
-0.5565940737724304,
-0.3424416184425354,
-0.5622824430465698,
-0.40125054121017456,
-0.4424264132976532,
-0.3380315899848938,
-0.42196619510650635,
-0.7932591438293457,
0.5192422270774841,
-0.1393205225467682,
0.2053941786289215,
0.3466615676879883,
0.5521643757820129,
-0.046014443039894104,
1.0392662286758423,
0.22147411108016968,
0.15237081050872803,
-0.09583312273025513,
-0.12242534011602402,
0.2487393468618393,
-0.5070275068283081,
-0.09568025171756744,
-0.621903657913208,
0.0673830583691597,
-0.4074156582355499,
-0.5257107019424438,
0.5072523355484009,
0.027234897017478943,
-0.46932071447372437,
0.26085367798805237,
-0.37413129210472107,
0.4994279742240906,
0.4540463984012604,
0.1041092723608017,
0.6199045181274414,
0.052918411791324615,
-0.24063394963741302,
-0.29953813552856445,
-0.34611764550209045,
-0.7603831887245178,
1.2155612707138062,
0.3335511386394501,
0.826250433921814,
0.19888965785503387,
0.8903746008872986,
0.16582894325256348,
0.4357195198535919,
-0.5888725519180298,
0.4387423098087311,
-0.11795230209827423,
-0.35472679138183594,
-0.30078190565109253,
-0.7042624354362488,
-0.5163850784301758,
0.07107951492071152,
0.03705819323658943,
-0.3159160614013672,
-0.04567596688866615,
0.2330121248960495,
-0.44573572278022766,
0.0803169384598732,
-0.6317875385284424,
0.574205219745636,
-0.31622475385665894,
-0.37791067361831665,
0.013989695347845554,
-0.26359590888023376,
0.7473798990249634,
-0.185189351439476,
0.3362295627593994,
-0.15370658040046692,
0.03687555342912674,
0.3601186275482178,
-0.6185237765312195,
0.8161764144897461,
0.09796679019927979,
-0.5601826310157776,
0.302082359790802,
0.5487207770347595,
0.8289915919303894,
0.578809380531311,
-0.0030926300678402185,
0.19390201568603516,
0.05767650902271271,
-0.3151627779006958,
-0.8574563264846802,
0.7285448908805847,
-1.015197515487671,
-0.6521394848823547,
-0.5889005064964294,
-0.05855178460478783,
-0.30227893590927124,
0.10325293987989426,
0.2870652973651886,
0.295176237821579,
0.08148474246263504,
0.17038559913635254,
1.0798232555389404,
0.28983792662620544,
0.23778362572193146,
0.30526894330978394,
-0.13945777714252472,
-0.7135789394378662,
0.4470595121383667,
0.07647446542978287,
0.2724239230155945,
0.19312630593776703,
0.3016562759876251,
-0.33147433400154114,
-0.48277556896209717,
-0.7892295718193054,
0.10155895352363586,
-0.7953159213066101,
-0.30101096630096436,
-0.5344924926757812,
-0.3115970492362976,
-0.5314127206802368,
0.025994041934609413,
-0.4818110764026642,
-0.6909372210502625,
0.013887547887861729,
-0.06927522271871567,
0.4565034806728363,
0.4217216968536377,
-0.16654589772224426,
0.20855458080768585,
-0.8872717618942261,
0.3775167167186737,
0.4501713216304779,
0.11952928453683853,
-0.545326292514801,
-0.6981098651885986,
0.07251852750778198,
0.18501034379005432,
-0.06988710910081863,
-0.6052537560462952,
0.24199619889259338,
-0.11674785614013672,
0.35657799243927,
0.17324131727218628,
0.3311767578125,
0.7812978625297546,
-0.24296291172504425,
0.5022427439689636,
-0.2251802682876587,
-1.320835828781128,
0.412697970867157,
-0.4172733724117279,
0.030534766614437103,
0.48815837502479553,
0.3826550841331482,
-0.15339136123657227,
-0.3943847417831421,
-0.9474561810493469,
-0.6917319893836975,
0.1047280803322792,
0.4167770743370056,
-0.2845960855484009,
0.3692254424095154,
0.5187140107154846,
-0.12510238587856293,
0.13233299553394318,
-0.7757628560066223,
-0.16140304505825043,
-0.2761254906654358,
-0.3177758753299713,
0.29898884892463684,
-0.42470067739486694,
-0.6541915535926819,
-0.0756741315126419,
0.8415201902389526,
-0.4439811110496521,
0.1464730054140091,
0.3938738703727722,
-0.27795299887657166,
-0.3373700678348541,
0.21514588594436646,
0.744130551815033,
0.9746323227882385,
-0.062249306589365005,
0.3597797751426697,
-0.08881371468305588,
-0.24254590272903442,
0.48870500922203064,
0.06153455749154091,
-0.6153074502944946,
0.11398790031671524,
0.25959667563438416,
0.3379480242729187,
0.14633403718471527,
-0.29851263761520386,
0.40719637274742126,
-0.24605238437652588,
-0.5422196984291077,
-0.923076331615448,
-0.18305088579654694,
-0.18245044350624084,
-0.03464678302407265,
0.19517171382904053,
0.08968358486890793,
-0.10741303116083145,
0.011468729004263878,
0.5605120658874512,
0.3002026379108429,
-0.12526419758796692,
-0.16066114604473114,
0.6031378507614136,
-0.07118387520313263,
0.07915432751178741,
0.5727512240409851,
-0.46331900358200073,
-0.5883700251579285,
0.6700460910797119,
0.395412802696228,
0.9716385006904602,
-0.05230417847633362,
0.26854515075683594,
0.5247151851654053,
0.5427375435829163,
-0.48585596680641174,
0.06685605645179749,
0.06497855484485626,
-0.7100794911384583,
-0.8306547403335571,
-0.1851707100868225,
-0.7432460784912109,
0.07158663123846054,
-0.455407053232193,
0.29000160098075867,
-0.8282244205474854,
-0.10407675057649612,
-0.46271705627441406,
-0.10546725988388062,
-0.23637884855270386,
0.14979659020900726,
0.20495572686195374,
0.5580956339836121,
-0.8992369771003723,
0.8295127749443054,
0.6722792387008667,
-0.07603435963392258,
-0.9553104639053345,
-0.06553014367818832,
0.215974360704422,
-1.0966365337371826,
0.8985298275947571,
-0.16539525985717773,
-0.31524723768234253,
-0.07537399232387543,
-0.8397985696792603,
-0.975490927696228,
0.9667812585830688,
0.4560629427433014,
-0.6393471360206604,
0.1361488401889801,
0.03828924894332886,
0.19837908446788788,
-0.2407177835702896,
0.4935392141342163,
0.23334619402885437,
0.6158195734024048,
0.35538947582244873,
-1.0466136932373047,
0.20235538482666016,
0.045112498104572296,
-0.2721593677997589,
-0.16800057888031006,
-0.534034788608551,
0.9106599688529968,
-0.13654322922229767,
0.0336901918053627,
-0.08824587613344193,
0.6827834844589233,
0.6813440322875977,
0.2521192133426666,
0.4558398723602295,
0.766615629196167,
1.1232603788375854,
-0.3098500370979309,
0.695841372013092,
-0.38761642575263977,
0.44315776228904724,
1.1647217273712158,
-0.3863042891025543,
0.4764041304588318,
0.2733858525753021,
-0.08855504542589188,
0.554523766040802,
0.7252527475357056,
-0.1813572645187378,
0.13250188529491425,
0.25408798456192017,
-0.142436221241951,
-0.7824028134346008,
0.3406170606613159,
-0.24352361261844635,
0.37011098861694336,
0.31365472078323364,
-0.05004730820655823,
-0.44311219453811646,
-0.4087352752685547,
0.23167148232460022,
0.31261974573135376,
-0.03898231312632561,
0.4463341534137726,
0.39167797565460205,
-0.5558618307113647,
0.9427199959754944,
0.1101665124297142,
0.3658074736595154,
-0.4422720968723297,
-0.05835801735520363,
-0.07386034727096558,
0.35731640458106995,
-0.3513370454311371,
-0.4879724085330963,
0.5167103409767151,
-0.000740080839022994,
0.023038355633616447,
-0.4824368357658386,
0.585578978061676,
-0.2367064207792282,
-0.4119809865951538,
-0.0699930414557457,
0.6481097936630249,
-0.16959133744239807,
-0.28356456756591797,
-0.8044058084487915,
0.00902195181697607,
-0.04761191084980965,
0.05610087513923645,
0.23514297604560852,
0.8931655883789062,
-0.39219099283218384,
0.9216355085372925,
0.9585074782371521,
-0.13005968928337097,
-0.010015681385993958,
-0.10623985528945923,
0.6240732073783875,
-0.43636929988861084,
-0.45295578241348267,
-1.2695398330688477,
0.2803105413913727,
-0.17596670985221863,
0.024899126961827278,
1.1092156171798706,
0.44885435700416565,
0.7841569781303406,
0.07159414142370224,
0.9213406443595886,
0.40232500433921814,
0.1764565110206604,
-0.6960024237632751,
0.43218207359313965,
-0.11358838528394699,
0.48091670870780945,
0.050097282975912094,
-0.6698272824287415,
-0.4508664309978485,
0.8633038401603699,
-0.5496250987052917,
-0.005382515490055084,
0.9539636373519897,
0.6023642420768738,
0.004126737825572491,
-0.1048930361866951,
0.30383193492889404,
0.3418166935443878,
0.4711093306541443,
0.6004692912101746,
0.9392837882041931,
-0.6513963937759399,
0.6683815121650696,
-0.4417915642261505,
-0.3484486937522888,
-0.13680556416511536,
-1.2713589668273926,
-0.9482125043869019,
-0.14108039438724518,
-0.7955743074417114,
-1.1922191381454468,
-0.12724904716014862,
0.9152956008911133,
0.7568438649177551,
-0.7947892546653748,
-0.07596740871667862,
-0.05247137323021889,
0.4095250964164734,
-0.06100872531533241,
-0.17485620081424713,
0.3134070336818695,
-0.35419681668281555,
-0.5220962762832642,
0.3076544404029846,
0.2574034631252289,
0.3435758054256439,
-0.43365931510925293,
0.052083879709243774,
0.4547542929649353,
0.16562215983867645,
0.299146831035614,
0.2722192704677582,
-0.7558655738830566,
-0.2310493439435959,
0.3857412040233612,
-0.3622523546218872,
0.25124287605285645,
0.7753823399543762,
-0.7104689478874207,
0.031742196530103683,
0.5037664771080017,
0.7200909852981567,
0.16982854902744293,
0.21170000731945038,
0.8128159046173096,
-0.23706595599651337,
-0.12659388780593872,
0.24246057868003845,
0.37400397658348083,
0.28539785742759705,
-0.540712833404541,
0.48796042799949646,
0.29523757100105286,
-0.7892763018608093,
-0.8479993343353271,
0.2840728461742401,
-0.9344685673713684,
0.21556586027145386,
1.2366300821304321,
-0.5480943918228149,
-0.6703550815582275,
-0.3096146881580353,
0.17159195244312286,
-0.15949690341949463,
-0.5409468412399292,
1.0146163702011108,
0.8624845147132874,
0.15531004965305328,
-0.040745168924331665,
-0.4717821776866913,
0.6484050154685974,
0.46543648838996887,
-0.6844804286956787,
0.05274348706007004,
0.2895926833152771,
0.631091296672821,
0.1412699669599533,
0.6098493337631226,
-0.4343891143798828,
0.2623734772205353,
-0.15444180369377136,
-0.24538132548332214,
-0.46574950218200684,
0.007428821641951799,
-0.46440136432647705,
0.03476359322667122,
0.22947464883327484,
0.020523523911833763
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18121v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18121v1
|
ChatGPT Role-play Dataset: Analysis of User Motives and Model Naturalness
| 2024-03-26T22:01:13 | 2024-03-26T22:01:13 |
Yufei Tao, Ameeta Agrawal, Judit Dombi, Tetyana Sydorenko, Jung In Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Recent advances in interactive large language models like ChatGPT have
revolutionized various domains; however, their behavior in natural and
role-play conversation settings remains underexplored. In our study, we address
this gap by deeply investigating how ChatGPT behaves during conversations in
different settings by analyzing its interactions in both a normal way and a
role-play setting. We introduce a novel dataset of broad range of human-AI
conversations annotated with user motives and model naturalness to examine (i)
how humans engage with the conversational AI model, and (ii) how natural are AI
model responses. Our study highlights the diversity of user motives when
interacting with ChatGPT and variable AI naturalness, showing not only the
nuanced dynamics of natural conversations between humans and AI, but also
providing new avenues for improving the effectiveness of human-AI
communication.
|
[
-0.5181082487106323,
-1.074795126914978,
0.07287867367267609,
-0.00866355188190937,
-0.06987472623586655,
-0.07079123705625534,
-0.37292200326919556,
-0.4743436574935913,
0.002435046946629882,
0.6126862168312073,
-0.8023679256439209,
-0.22285793721675873,
-0.20048904418945312,
-0.28537717461586,
-0.1360747069120407,
1.1450579166412354,
0.44657352566719055,
0.08259188383817673,
-0.08140233904123306,
-0.1839965283870697,
-0.6608806252479553,
-0.7501823306083679,
-0.8865141868591309,
-0.2714390754699707,
0.5165097117424011,
0.5051432847976685,
0.9353719353675842,
0.27008697390556335,
0.5979543924331665,
0.29160696268081665,
0.08336932212114334,
0.17385852336883545,
-0.7883558869361877,
0.32443445920944214,
0.14486974477767944,
-0.47931626439094543,
-0.09995409101247787,
0.3857777714729309,
0.46105796098709106,
0.35621437430381775,
-0.2363310158252716,
0.12549462914466858,
0.33026960492134094,
0.3174494504928589,
-0.16806939244270325,
0.5343621373176575,
-0.36363986134529114,
-0.028721380978822708,
-0.44334957003593445,
-0.10363994538784027,
-0.22252540290355682,
-0.14225389063358307,
0.47081080079078674,
-0.4474278390407562,
0.35386237502098083,
-0.02595844306051731,
0.7189887166023254,
0.3043867349624634,
-0.706590473651886,
-0.2931429445743561,
-1.0128650665283203,
0.5996606945991516,
-0.699613094329834,
0.0528596006333828,
0.6233814358711243,
0.4719187915325165,
-0.33015280961990356,
-0.5148809552192688,
-0.5452790856361389,
-0.5480263829231262,
-0.31068098545074463,
0.008503338322043419,
-0.1549483686685562,
0.2718146741390228,
0.37967827916145325,
0.42228686809539795,
-0.5365878939628601,
0.12575264275074005,
-0.3794514238834381,
-0.11600497364997864,
0.9381589889526367,
0.26644691824913025,
0.699408233165741,
-0.20342357456684113,
-0.14184126257896423,
-0.08459552377462387,
-0.585780680179596,
0.49283289909362793,
0.5274345278739929,
0.29188546538352966,
-0.3139888048171997,
0.7907483577728271,
0.0035294631961733103,
0.8220520615577698,
-0.31011971831321716,
0.419281542301178,
-0.34533223509788513,
-0.35981589555740356,
-0.1953405737876892,
-0.17555586993694305,
0.8101605176925659,
0.6330008506774902,
0.6225280165672302,
-0.052328526973724365,
0.03266330435872078,
0.10889167338609695,
0.4186048209667206,
-0.7659909725189209,
-0.4382062554359436,
0.002547915792092681,
-0.3779686689376831,
-0.3564945161342621,
0.038694869726896286,
-0.7045918107032776,
-0.45041149854660034,
-0.5750806927680969,
0.11822067201137543,
-0.3889766037464142,
-0.23505470156669617,
-0.08383594453334808,
0.0031960962805896997,
0.41059359908103943,
0.2089611291885376,
-1.104632019996643,
0.45022597908973694,
0.7531316876411438,
0.6475299596786499,
-0.07902508974075317,
-0.2742924392223358,
-0.6065466403961182,
-0.31681394577026367,
-0.29801347851753235,
0.6237630248069763,
-0.5837969183921814,
-0.5297133326530457,
-0.022765513509511948,
-0.28565406799316406,
-0.3481847643852234,
-0.3198729455471039,
0.7849260568618774,
-0.5074995756149292,
0.6815364360809326,
-0.25832998752593994,
-0.4444146156311035,
-0.38373035192489624,
0.6016674041748047,
-0.6959584951400757,
0.7566584944725037,
-0.29235613346099854,
-0.5885245203971863,
0.41757622361183167,
-1.4212502241134644,
-0.2645527422428131,
0.20384062826633453,
-0.25275346636772156,
-0.02645408734679222,
0.06129083409905434,
0.1248377189040184,
0.2904709577560425,
-0.32394683361053467,
0.32800620794296265,
-0.1368340700864792,
-0.5449851751327515,
0.525449812412262,
-0.8896822333335876,
0.7088369131088257,
0.165394127368927,
-0.10963291674852371,
0.2641519010066986,
-0.5008609294891357,
-0.17174190282821655,
0.11915653198957443,
-0.06386476010084152,
-0.2841358482837677,
0.35516083240509033,
0.1395551711320877,
0.2367708683013916,
-0.04472566023468971,
-0.34968826174736023,
0.4290119707584381,
-0.3612821102142334,
0.6768476366996765,
0.42394980788230896,
0.2551455795764923,
0.33756205439567566,
-0.37304002046585083,
0.48543453216552734,
-0.3010614216327667,
0.26114407181739807,
-0.06800125539302826,
-0.8627623915672302,
-0.3962123990058899,
-0.4051005244255066,
0.18086139857769012,
0.5010167956352234,
-0.19178506731987,
0.2016020119190216,
-0.02937336079776287,
-0.29177331924438477,
-0.4654466211795807,
-0.27617520093917847,
0.0815717801451683,
0.524806022644043,
0.089815653860569,
-0.31821057200431824,
-0.3185283839702606,
-0.934681236743927,
-0.2789905369281769,
-0.39769524335861206,
-0.26521775126457214,
0.9305031299591064,
0.18505661189556122,
-0.30898600816726685,
1.368153691291809,
-0.3321528136730194,
-0.04741709679365158,
-0.22681403160095215,
0.6174913644790649,
0.14758603274822235,
0.4821423292160034,
0.6096574664115906,
-1.1798365116119385,
-0.5427351593971252,
-0.11590425670146942,
-0.5549637675285339,
-0.00942368432879448,
-0.24125580489635468,
-0.16204938292503357,
0.08851159363985062,
0.09881354868412018,
-0.9615731835365295,
0.8160351514816284,
0.4428577721118927,
-0.5766125917434692,
0.3840157091617584,
-0.08754955232143402,
0.6904147267341614,
-0.9148778915405273,
0.30550429224967957,
-0.04443255066871643,
0.03930462896823883,
-1.012876033782959,
-0.2280208021402359,
-0.47550100088119507,
-0.36499515175819397,
-0.316987544298172,
0.5686336159706116,
-0.1769494116306305,
-0.1406305879354477,
-0.25274592638015747,
-0.15309879183769226,
-0.28357017040252686,
0.45950350165367126,
0.22723406553268433,
0.8655688166618347,
0.5104172229766846,
-0.5065513849258423,
0.3148706257343292,
0.6682841777801514,
-0.10022880136966705,
0.3184192180633545,
-0.952267587184906,
0.22550661861896515,
-0.18822769820690155,
0.28980329632759094,
-1.0453323125839233,
-0.6649686098098755,
0.44675853848457336,
-0.5729758143424988,
-0.01723003201186657,
-0.7122434377670288,
-0.5436342358589172,
-0.1048603430390358,
-0.05992862954735756,
0.3674617111682892,
0.5124086737632751,
-0.38823390007019043,
0.3976963758468628,
0.2378290444612503,
-0.24849772453308105,
-0.14187638461589813,
-0.4147624373435974,
0.4094946086406708,
-0.5383933186531067,
-1.035301685333252,
0.25786176323890686,
-0.38331183791160583,
-0.40456685423851013,
-0.2886827886104584,
0.1564812958240509,
-0.21224822103977203,
0.2200031876564026,
0.2525103986263275,
0.4765035808086395,
-0.20790255069732666,
-0.023099467158317566,
-0.4131340980529785,
0.008053312078118324,
0.1297432780265808,
0.2572095990180969,
0.8565062880516052,
-0.2388940453529358,
-0.42501264810562134,
-0.566264808177948,
0.37293776869773865,
0.4796037971973419,
-0.4342605471611023,
0.7119684815406799,
0.6278462409973145,
-0.27895691990852356,
0.3417241871356964,
-0.28909337520599365,
-0.5033109784126282,
-0.44809824228286743,
0.16724826395511627,
-0.05443277955055237,
-1.0589263439178467,
0.6909646987915039,
0.3985435962677002,
0.42263761162757874,
0.19474317133426666,
0.5249799489974976,
-0.31528446078300476,
1.194045901298523,
0.3019876480102539,
-0.034156911075115204,
0.4484661817550659,
0.00011526985326781869,
0.17026257514953613,
-0.43767568469047546,
-0.08857743442058563,
-0.334516316652298,
-0.4749204218387604,
-0.964808464050293,
-0.21952411532402039,
0.1612398475408554,
-0.027043212205171585,
-0.41144895553588867,
0.023439407348632812,
-0.1827785223722458,
0.5675245523452759,
0.5824777483940125,
-0.09107204526662827,
0.032682713121175766,
-0.3028176724910736,
0.47478100657463074,
-0.18267139792442322,
-0.4727787971496582,
-0.6909534335136414,
0.9017608761787415,
0.21723774075508118,
0.5141239166259766,
0.5020948052406311,
0.7081281542778015,
0.39777782559394836,
0.2593126893043518,
-0.7728402614593506,
0.42216604948043823,
0.312162309885025,
-0.8916379809379578,
-0.5074518918991089,
-0.5233381390571594,
-1.2350406646728516,
0.018553033471107483,
-0.30488938093185425,
-1.2696655988693237,
-0.2589278221130371,
0.3474583923816681,
-0.39781028032302856,
-0.03732083737850189,
-0.9220632314682007,
1.2195475101470947,
-0.16366711258888245,
-0.2606148421764374,
-0.18518821895122528,
-0.8240950107574463,
0.5463329553604126,
0.3279981017112732,
-0.13893871009349823,
-0.06044982001185417,
0.33773261308670044,
0.555354654788971,
-0.10101435333490372,
1.1496416330337524,
-0.05068834498524666,
0.09772603213787079,
0.47645148634910583,
0.24174271523952484,
0.5451642274856567,
0.47858452796936035,
0.21984480321407318,
0.10623205453157425,
-0.2908748984336853,
-0.4144269526004791,
-0.5967774987220764,
0.45671436190605164,
-0.6866048574447632,
-0.5984094142913818,
-0.4355836510658264,
-0.5915252566337585,
-0.33941134810447693,
0.20030206441879272,
0.2680487036705017,
0.5014011859893799,
-0.7876725196838379,
0.15146000683307648,
0.5873221755027771,
-0.07140611112117767,
0.5077028274536133,
0.2936335802078247,
-0.04303138330578804,
0.10500052571296692,
0.720621645450592,
-0.06907495111227036,
0.22278673946857452,
0.05628599971532822,
0.3304084241390228,
-0.25910139083862305,
-0.17121940851211548,
-0.3594587743282318,
-0.05066853389143944,
-0.16134054958820343,
0.3370181620121002,
-0.3047797679901123,
-0.28192058205604553,
-0.080417200922966,
0.07070892304182053,
-0.2283647656440735,
-0.1959516853094101,
-0.3107421398162842,
0.15870454907417297,
0.357610285282135,
0.8854803442955017,
0.06967197358608246,
0.3502722680568695,
-1.0362597703933716,
0.1618286818265915,
0.7247504591941833,
0.42420947551727295,
-0.25408825278282166,
-0.33734503388404846,
0.09235227108001709,
0.4806026518344879,
-0.17867225408554077,
-0.8823791742324829,
0.4308409094810486,
0.2797439694404602,
0.7534992098808289,
0.4193762540817261,
0.006440676283091307,
0.37178346514701843,
-0.3062151074409485,
1.1672523021697998,
-0.23595042526721954,
-0.6119341850280762,
0.48678719997406006,
-0.8990594744682312,
0.11048391461372375,
0.4479624629020691,
0.33551254868507385,
-0.9938457608222961,
0.16244855523109436,
-0.9096938371658325,
-0.5171604752540588,
1.0214933156967163,
0.7259393930435181,
0.27054664492607117,
0.23761163651943207,
0.1012747585773468,
-0.09295549243688583,
0.07582434266805649,
-0.5596439838409424,
-0.13260672986507416,
-0.1863679140806198,
-0.051550403237342834,
-0.2891247868537903,
-0.04597845301032066,
-0.4999644160270691,
0.10390819609165192,
0.22616170346736908,
-0.1838546097278595,
0.5466693043708801,
-0.26370006799697876,
0.007639529649168253,
0.11577014625072479,
0.27086707949638367,
0.7066962122917175,
0.3560149669647217,
-0.25813066959381104,
-0.07335352152585983,
-0.06471066921949387,
-0.4209418296813965,
-0.26533666253089905,
0.35760119557380676,
0.023539597168564796,
-0.4836105704307556,
0.3466426730155945,
0.8079988360404968,
0.23644299805164337,
-0.6502101421356201,
0.3543669581413269,
-0.48580408096313477,
-0.019152702763676643,
-0.13270828127861023,
0.45226094126701355,
0.15258172154426575,
0.19290731847286224,
0.06628984212875366,
0.39714086055755615,
0.4079243242740631,
-0.589397668838501,
0.23141631484031677,
0.40474849939346313,
-0.511787474155426,
-0.5040318369865417,
0.36605775356292725,
0.256038635969162,
-0.8099281191825867,
1.017413854598999,
-0.21817642450332642,
-0.5168473124504089,
0.647418200969696,
0.2309335172176361,
0.8785850405693054,
-0.017580242827534676,
0.37423717975616455,
0.28030455112457275,
0.034638963639736176,
0.0557405985891819,
0.09860146045684814,
-0.3126900792121887,
-0.8756736516952515,
-0.3891468942165375,
0.12458517402410507,
-0.5003281831741333,
0.21586817502975464,
-0.5517647862434387,
0.18846578896045685,
-0.06842895597219467,
-0.0710684061050415,
-0.02292504534125328,
0.061628423631191254,
-0.6770897507667542,
-0.016146836802363396,
0.38947921991348267,
0.42382824420928955,
-0.7307732701301575,
0.49393442273139954,
0.6009441614151001,
-0.5623541474342346,
-0.6251276731491089,
0.4159955680370331,
0.21147853136062622,
-0.5872274041175842,
0.5309284925460815,
0.3762759566307068,
0.18883594870567322,
0.030778393149375916,
-0.8318784236907959,
-0.6419837474822998,
0.9530242681503296,
0.06616427004337311,
-0.08975108712911606,
0.12578174471855164,
0.45099303126335144,
0.742366373538971,
-0.19531933963298798,
0.4101888835430145,
0.5976855754852295,
0.40285471081733704,
0.1598290354013443,
-0.8492080569267273,
-0.5047728419303894,
-0.5940855145454407,
-0.23766320943832397,
0.09388591349124908,
-0.7990787029266357,
0.39861777424812317,
0.018753675743937492,
-0.2780418395996094,
-0.09626452624797821,
0.5521332025527954,
0.32980766892433167,
0.40158969163894653,
0.6257463097572327,
0.025406792759895325,
0.6595019102096558,
-0.10180602967739105,
0.8164903521537781,
-0.19379247725009918,
0.3345554769039154,
0.8065993189811707,
-0.3349139392375946,
0.45645570755004883,
0.2526571452617645,
-0.008874076418578625,
0.03221023082733154,
0.7461462616920471,
0.13008682429790497,
0.2306917905807495,
0.2737482488155365,
-0.33408093452453613,
-0.3863084614276886,
0.029144980013370514,
0.060762036591768265,
0.832492470741272,
0.38448283076286316,
0.26312175393104553,
-0.144147127866745,
-0.17258910834789276,
0.0018116275314241648,
-0.1957062929868698,
0.00042071694042533636,
0.8613485097885132,
-0.24571263790130615,
-0.9890100359916687,
0.04449070617556572,
-0.21925872564315796,
0.5120875835418701,
-0.5694068074226379,
-0.3662968575954437,
-0.2718527317047119,
-0.31274959444999695,
-0.07278315722942352,
-0.8762339949607849,
0.14994493126869202,
0.16547541320323944,
-0.025470826774835587,
0.02511572279036045,
0.776404619216919,
-0.3541652262210846,
-0.10355887562036514,
-0.24258528649806976,
0.3528473973274231,
0.08499062061309814,
-0.012160892598330975,
-0.7107229828834534,
-0.28419649600982666,
0.0688411295413971,
-0.4816519021987915,
0.3332545757293701,
0.34852927923202515,
-0.3584255278110504,
0.7127567529678345,
0.9095569849014282,
-0.34494224190711975,
-0.14157187938690186,
0.043483901768922806,
0.6884210109710693,
-0.6239579319953918,
-0.6913178563117981,
-0.793009340763092,
0.8760142922401428,
-0.4416756331920624,
-0.7266461849212646,
0.5871747732162476,
0.41272416710853577,
0.2483007162809372,
0.09574837237596512,
0.6956946849822998,
-0.2740519642829895,
0.3028751313686371,
-0.37187281250953674,
0.775149405002594,
-0.10742560029029846,
0.38862937688827515,
-0.021739549934864044,
-0.7558040022850037,
-0.19422870874404907,
0.6432885527610779,
-0.3670724332332611,
0.23388181626796722,
-0.057335685938596725,
0.8200004696846008,
-0.28592661023139954,
0.6232973337173462,
0.23179341852664948,
-0.10958819091320038,
0.7223840951919556,
0.16395261883735657,
1.3056546449661255,
0.05440523102879524,
0.18167157471179962,
0.07716646790504456,
-0.416377991437912,
-0.3700122535228729,
-0.865344226360321,
-1.0790045261383057,
-0.591014564037323,
-0.17767062783241272,
-0.026347720995545387,
-0.05812940001487732,
1.2306461334228516,
0.6751891374588013,
-0.5846842527389526,
-0.2759571373462677,
-0.33521249890327454,
-0.21586062014102936,
-0.13592378795146942,
-0.2710787057876587,
0.27036744356155396,
-0.4604608714580536,
-0.7377921938896179,
0.4818167984485626,
-0.1800529658794403,
0.10403016954660416,
-0.28780749440193176,
-0.3244234025478363,
-0.11703962087631226,
0.3569665551185608,
0.3986431360244751,
0.7405275702476501,
-0.2574094533920288,
-0.26450881361961365,
0.2531251013278961,
-0.07062235474586487,
0.12227629870176315,
0.9917120337486267,
-0.5174711346626282,
0.39118140935897827,
0.4597117602825165,
0.48113879561424255,
0.6565383672714233,
0.23452188074588776,
0.9350664019584656,
-0.7881956696510315,
-0.021959159523248672,
0.5007950067520142,
0.013190881349146366,
0.20968513190746307,
-0.473764032125473,
0.5026674270629883,
0.10363959521055222,
-0.930316150188446,
-0.6087676286697388,
0.3262098729610443,
-0.9998405575752258,
0.15431469678878784,
1.1495447158813477,
-0.08525097370147705,
0.15851198136806488,
-0.12766188383102417,
-0.7488962411880493,
0.16579562425613403,
-0.4598854184150696,
0.8444388508796692,
0.7669916152954102,
-0.5799548625946045,
-0.09519187361001968,
-0.7377752661705017,
0.8708721995353699,
0.24009232223033905,
-0.829741895198822,
0.2863035500049591,
0.7136285305023193,
-0.07953297346830368,
-0.0484723225235939,
0.487747460603714,
0.15657345950603485,
0.27068763971328735,
-0.32254090905189514,
-0.11963663250207901,
0.09301038831472397,
-0.15561024844646454,
-0.22525763511657715,
-0.09990150481462479,
0.10027539730072021,
-0.21424968540668488
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18105v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18105v2
|
Large Language Models for Education: A Survey and Outlook
| 2024-03-26T21:04:29 | 2024-04-01T18:47:45 |
Shen Wang, Tianlong Xu, Hang Li, Chaoli Zhang, Joleen Liang, Jiliang Tang, Philip S. Yu, Qingsong Wen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The advent of Large Language Models (LLMs) has brought in a new era of
possibilities in the realm of education. This survey paper summarizes the
various technologies of LLMs in educational settings from multifaceted
perspectives, encompassing student and teacher assistance, adaptive learning,
and commercial tools. We systematically review the technological advancements
in each perspective, organize related datasets and benchmarks, and identify the
risks and challenges associated with deploying LLMs in education. Furthermore,
we outline future research opportunities, highlighting the potential promising
directions. Our survey aims to provide a comprehensive technological picture
for educators, researchers, and policymakers to harness the power of LLMs to
revolutionize educational practices and foster a more effective personalized
learning environment.
|
[
-0.4246264398097992,
-0.9657108187675476,
0.6823635101318359,
-0.041089896112680435,
0.21518176794052124,
0.4684813916683197,
-0.3811585307121277,
-0.35404732823371887,
0.0680203065276146,
0.5689578056335449,
-0.35421010851860046,
-0.3492543399333954,
-0.8767458200454712,
-0.05049111694097519,
-0.7180944681167603,
0.46404480934143066,
-0.06333472579717636,
0.2797034978866577,
-0.26367244124412537,
0.2304949313402176,
-0.5247675180435181,
-0.8113966584205627,
-0.6896713376045227,
-0.43058350682258606,
0.6934648752212524,
0.6102430820465088,
0.46157804131507874,
0.2293766438961029,
0.536393940448761,
0.41140100359916687,
-0.15514634549617767,
-0.06550482660531998,
-0.14320091903209686,
0.20184098184108734,
-0.12681040167808533,
-0.40242084860801697,
-0.6361364126205444,
0.13198688626289368,
1.00264310836792,
1.1328668594360352,
-0.2323751151561737,
0.169777974486351,
0.20935951173305511,
0.5756832361221313,
-0.3967074453830719,
-0.1055668368935585,
-0.29115569591522217,
0.16701874136924744,
-0.22744981944561005,
-0.02618004009127617,
-0.4475458860397339,
-0.5073530077934265,
0.33151814341545105,
-0.3064082860946655,
-0.19360871613025665,
-0.06582679599523544,
0.14911432564258575,
-0.20547521114349365,
-0.7264586687088013,
-0.4491460919380188,
-0.8985830545425415,
0.9716920852661133,
-0.5162659883499146,
0.8002249002456665,
0.09174011647701263,
0.6932615637779236,
-0.3568371832370758,
-0.8418772220611572,
-0.2549892067909241,
-0.15965236723423004,
0.48825961351394653,
-0.09070438146591187,
0.29778605699539185,
-0.15175293385982513,
0.06603040546178818,
0.31464388966560364,
-0.3188345730304718,
0.7771688103675842,
-0.4709835350513458,
-0.040916766971349716,
0.5448706746101379,
0.5352205634117126,
0.34276899695396423,
0.20642392337322235,
-0.2203824818134308,
-0.16657795011997223,
-0.8259522318840027,
-0.16369840502738953,
0.3844740092754364,
0.32004737854003906,
-0.10538429766893387,
0.5948822498321533,
0.04936975985765457,
0.9832887649536133,
-0.43632036447525024,
-0.3949321508407593,
0.07597989588975906,
-0.17458535730838776,
-0.24912714958190918,
-0.11857585608959198,
0.597221314907074,
0.18755929172039032,
0.13689394295215607,
0.2372463345527649,
-0.22840964794158936,
-0.2187221646308899,
-0.1515571027994156,
-0.6514309048652649,
0.15828374028205872,
0.100448377430439,
-0.2371278703212738,
-0.12824079394340515,
-0.12551382184028625,
-1.10761296749115,
-0.8673532605171204,
-0.50409996509552,
0.17445255815982819,
-0.13056154549121857,
-0.4067220687866211,
0.29420390725135803,
-0.030015286058187485,
0.20045886933803558,
0.6487120985984802,
-1.0254050493240356,
0.2152911275625229,
0.7370235323905945,
0.7967565059661865,
-0.1631581038236618,
-0.1708972454071045,
0.008525257930159569,
0.013624724000692368,
-0.35290348529815674,
0.5644643902778625,
-0.8146708607673645,
-0.8761595487594604,
0.6232175827026367,
-0.03869011998176575,
0.23529933393001556,
-0.5986422300338745,
0.16900114715099335,
-0.41230130195617676,
0.37578195333480835,
-0.18707481026649475,
-0.6434386372566223,
-0.10141389816999435,
0.5113468170166016,
-0.5277359485626221,
0.7583454251289368,
0.12681163847446442,
-0.3796059489250183,
-0.020872842520475388,
-0.5967509746551514,
-0.282190203666687,
0.18206243216991425,
-0.13591942191123962,
-0.28497233986854553,
0.2031896859407425,
-0.15053492784500122,
0.6886270046234131,
-0.632652759552002,
0.5076302289962769,
-0.30630767345428467,
-0.4088548719882965,
0.4417213499546051,
-0.6069468259811401,
0.8310801386833191,
0.37621980905532837,
-0.0008681885083205998,
0.0570286400616169,
-0.6997188329696655,
-0.08724770694971085,
0.308648943901062,
-0.5266730785369873,
-0.24228785932064056,
0.1811627447605133,
0.09945960342884064,
0.41513267159461975,
0.5765150785446167,
-0.4060763418674469,
0.3883063793182373,
-0.11629769206047058,
0.5510277152061462,
0.8548818826675415,
-0.20991501212120056,
0.5134568810462952,
-0.22981862723827362,
0.8232890963554382,
-0.15312714874744415,
0.36191824078559875,
-0.45047813653945923,
-0.3146790862083435,
-0.4656851887702942,
0.0037217724602669477,
0.24942347407341003,
0.3015817105770111,
-0.6058148145675659,
0.1515752226114273,
-0.35477665066719055,
-0.5408103466033936,
-0.2869783639907837,
0.1851448267698288,
-0.03717615455389023,
0.17206960916519165,
-0.06804557144641876,
0.051495835185050964,
-0.5730985999107361,
-0.6571658253669739,
-0.09761222451925278,
-0.02636980637907982,
-0.0233332347124815,
0.24761910736560822,
0.27308788895606995,
-0.2509384751319885,
0.5993988513946533,
-0.362007737159729,
-0.08402779698371887,
-0.3176751136779785,
-0.3509827256202698,
0.04443490877747536,
0.33284956216812134,
0.45811957120895386,
-0.7897628545761108,
-0.5349340438842773,
-0.03594685345888138,
-0.5952712297439575,
0.13117031753063202,
0.21291567385196686,
0.2439422607421875,
0.05563923716545105,
0.6194576621055603,
-0.20666691660881042,
-0.2541176974773407,
0.7994179725646973,
-0.09592989832162857,
0.48460137844085693,
-0.02285197749733925,
0.10415858030319214,
-1.1189578771591187,
-0.26912978291511536,
0.15190687775611877,
-0.04051057994365692,
-0.5644134879112244,
-0.03392487019300461,
0.017840981483459473,
-0.16498513519763947,
-0.5206066370010376,
0.8468883037567139,
-0.642431378364563,
-0.18021363019943237,
-0.45903465151786804,
0.6699651479721069,
-0.30715543031692505,
-0.3241790533065796,
0.06607659161090851,
0.9011543989181519,
0.6947012543678284,
-0.35982590913772583,
0.6385560631752014,
0.07388759404420853,
-0.5213987827301025,
0.5726384520530701,
-0.5241217017173767,
0.05302520841360092,
-0.004379953257739544,
0.45975106954574585,
-0.615634024143219,
-0.44075238704681396,
0.05934692919254303,
-0.3428296744823456,
0.35071220993995667,
0.26142269372940063,
-0.6571378111839294,
-0.6645165085792542,
-0.5355040431022644,
0.1823544055223465,
0.643159031867981,
-0.642848551273346,
0.5685469508171082,
0.7126648426055908,
-0.3668915629386902,
-0.5165157914161682,
-0.6573330163955688,
0.4702012240886688,
-0.2290707528591156,
-0.2620665729045868,
-0.26399335265159607,
-0.27321913838386536,
-0.5316858291625977,
-0.25529399514198303,
0.22227050364017487,
-0.07141461223363876,
0.32016098499298096,
0.13751539587974548,
0.593161940574646,
-0.2302349954843521,
0.1495623141527176,
-0.0652640238404274,
0.25280728936195374,
0.20661911368370056,
-0.3504377007484436,
0.6018073558807373,
-0.010088106617331505,
-0.28584417700767517,
-0.026670828461647034,
0.2701682448387146,
0.6735097169876099,
-0.08745914697647095,
0.7461501359939575,
0.2344290316104889,
-0.46496841311454773,
-0.28347331285476685,
-0.6135110259056091,
-0.1789407730102539,
-0.5229958295822144,
0.6636663675308228,
0.004264879506081343,
-1.2255295515060425,
0.04195669665932655,
-0.5321670174598694,
0.254407674074173,
-0.06528616696596146,
0.7110117673873901,
0.09873250126838684,
0.946923017501831,
0.8360694646835327,
-0.11399858444929123,
0.8634117841720581,
-0.20096956193447113,
0.3732113838195801,
-0.9819790720939636,
-0.6177465319633484,
-0.47648000717163086,
-0.05433575063943863,
-0.6167023181915283,
-0.23728132247924805,
0.43132099509239197,
-0.21892495453357697,
-0.4141171872615814,
-0.058126114308834076,
-0.3756938576698303,
0.15510573983192444,
0.4023471176624298,
-0.2452353686094284,
0.33278942108154297,
-0.0734996423125267,
0.08470432460308075,
0.2061355859041214,
-0.5124475955963135,
-0.8440863490104675,
1.2060104608535767,
0.545082688331604,
0.8125488758087158,
0.20418870449066162,
0.5240505933761597,
0.051919229328632355,
0.5554404854774475,
-0.8026546835899353,
0.7737346291542053,
-0.2525043487548828,
-0.8761957287788391,
-0.45034241676330566,
-0.11755398660898209,
-0.8093982338905334,
0.2897037863731384,
-0.22561465203762054,
-0.732082188129425,
-0.13153201341629028,
0.08060020953416824,
-0.14055050909519196,
0.5155211687088013,
-0.7823461890220642,
0.42935052514076233,
-0.3047098219394684,
-0.3512672185897827,
-0.155594602227211,
-0.4845349192619324,
0.5451245307922363,
-0.5298789143562317,
0.5442330241203308,
-0.08590389788150787,
-0.2679762840270996,
0.7895764112472534,
0.08886028081178665,
0.9187313318252563,
-0.08176042884588242,
-0.502117395401001,
0.42513784766197205,
-0.2458360493183136,
0.3780367970466614,
-0.35851040482521057,
-0.27747541666030884,
-0.043202947825193405,
-0.05968683958053589,
-0.2542141079902649,
-0.2834412753582001,
1.1788725852966309,
-0.7707625031471252,
-0.8234977722167969,
-0.5407670736312866,
-0.6925025582313538,
-0.5975901484489441,
0.15314702689647675,
-0.14377009868621826,
0.3043519854545593,
-0.2540808916091919,
0.17118924856185913,
0.7061046361923218,
-0.4410376250743866,
0.6642181873321533,
0.526040256023407,
-0.6545649170875549,
-0.16134606301784515,
1.0314961671829224,
0.4460892975330353,
0.294506311416626,
0.15308281779289246,
0.14373521506786346,
-0.4856278896331787,
-0.6727628111839294,
-0.07723668217658997,
0.2984859347343445,
-0.871806800365448,
0.026429396122694016,
-0.3323192596435547,
-0.41430264711380005,
-0.6000703573226929,
-0.410942941904068,
-0.28376346826553345,
-0.14934314787387848,
-0.36939486861228943,
-0.15060372650623322,
0.026998117566108704,
1.278616189956665,
0.19121308624744415,
0.6027473211288452,
-0.6742033362388611,
-0.06684917211532593,
0.3934420645236969,
0.5097704529762268,
0.08739489316940308,
-0.5497546195983887,
-0.20947246253490448,
0.015804750844836235,
-0.3352748453617096,
-0.3652125298976898,
0.23532070219516754,
-0.0393519327044487,
0.42359814047813416,
0.19750100374221802,
-0.3877372741699219,
0.17112688720226288,
-0.7189438939094543,
1.066245436668396,
0.5054616332054138,
-0.6062567830085754,
0.2425195425748825,
-0.31790560483932495,
0.23000945150852203,
-0.050295256078243256,
0.5276970267295837,
-0.8842498064041138,
-0.13680830597877502,
-0.2837010622024536,
-0.8011327981948853,
0.451555997133255,
-0.7094547152519226,
0.5910881757736206,
0.22987519204616547,
0.12377721816301346,
0.18838189542293549,
0.3214380741119385,
-0.45166265964508057,
-0.22926150262355804,
-0.005712183658033609,
-0.37112125754356384,
-0.330024778842926,
-0.36340704560279846,
0.17565380036830902,
-0.09364776313304901,
0.6731812357902527,
0.15870903432369232,
-0.06480178236961365,
-0.4620566666126251,
0.06807376444339752,
-0.04443885758519173,
0.6972423791885376,
0.4216407537460327,
0.8970081806182861,
0.12165452539920807,
0.14378932118415833,
0.16964489221572876,
-0.5176541805267334,
0.36559996008872986,
-0.11275327205657959,
-0.08150725811719894,
-0.26213547587394714,
0.2609161138534546,
0.5601921081542969,
0.26362186670303345,
-0.916983425617218,
0.36911946535110474,
0.11356139183044434,
-0.17051605880260468,
-0.7158327102661133,
0.14938990771770477,
0.39476215839385986,
0.3475452661514282,
0.27469855546951294,
-0.47217223048210144,
-0.0027903716545552015,
-0.5780937671661377,
-0.28920891880989075,
0.6039734482765198,
-0.31315532326698303,
-0.44588178396224976,
0.6262707710266113,
0.3001464307308197,
-0.5360686779022217,
0.4736676514148712,
0.5017411708831787,
0.014247807674109936,
0.38549646735191345,
0.7539329528808594,
0.7508115172386169,
-0.6309236288070679,
0.2104567289352417,
0.12958675622940063,
0.29230186343193054,
-0.33379077911376953,
0.1053723394870758,
0.3374873101711273,
-0.6479622721672058,
-0.14336800575256348,
-0.5853927135467529,
-0.6960548758506775,
0.3184269964694977,
-0.33435824513435364,
0.506449282169342,
-0.6182894706726074,
-0.2808575928211212,
0.11441367864608765,
-0.17152009904384613,
-0.549727737903595,
0.27282413840293884,
0.5121108889579773,
0.9626439809799194,
-0.8893828988075256,
1.0091359615325928,
1.1321940422058105,
-0.09511025995016098,
-0.49926796555519104,
-0.326183021068573,
0.21990016102790833,
-0.718718409538269,
0.5321358442306519,
-0.16445046663284302,
-0.21825239062309265,
0.19066406786441803,
-0.6131159663200378,
-0.8295391798019409,
1.0100451707839966,
0.289995938539505,
-1.062287449836731,
-0.27887898683547974,
0.22897617518901825,
0.46197596192359924,
-0.30984407663345337,
0.13569426536560059,
0.5332886576652527,
0.5049144625663757,
-0.0751132220029831,
-0.7360865473747253,
-0.33562400937080383,
0.040742065757513046,
0.30881375074386597,
0.20566590130329132,
-0.5887660384178162,
0.7336090207099915,
0.04100874066352844,
0.05560101196169853,
0.13032522797584534,
0.4896947145462036,
0.20049673318862915,
0.3237636387348175,
0.21420161426067352,
0.026187153533101082,
0.503435492515564,
-0.09808080643415451,
0.9645657539367676,
-0.197842076420784,
0.21393734216690063,
0.8574188947677612,
-0.3564147651195526,
0.782120943069458,
0.501885175704956,
-0.5572102665901184,
0.3000432848930359,
0.6986309885978699,
-0.023342318832874298,
-0.03592648729681969,
0.244608074426651,
-0.6621972918510437,
-0.19520817697048187,
-0.4443517327308655,
-0.3824055790901184,
0.306809663772583,
0.7720882296562195,
-0.2481105476617813,
-0.15356765687465668,
0.4839674234390259,
-0.04637235403060913,
0.35431233048439026,
-0.6237573623657227,
0.35333898663520813,
0.3187256455421448,
-0.4159590005874634,
0.07027101516723633,
0.03704945743083954,
0.8623270392417908,
-0.6943981051445007,
-0.12353132665157318,
0.04172348976135254,
0.056134626269340515,
-0.0019304797751829028,
-1.00572669506073,
-0.1259133219718933,
-0.11450424790382385,
0.09187792241573334,
-0.349575936794281,
0.6633752584457397,
-0.48195186257362366,
-0.603339433670044,
0.3380405604839325,
0.6335425972938538,
0.0031240121461451054,
0.4543359577655792,
-0.3235998749732971,
0.45184603333473206,
-0.33226460218429565,
-0.24108724296092987,
0.5843824148178101,
0.23097428679466248,
-0.21436868607997894,
0.9795095324516296,
0.2210896611213684,
0.1931416243314743,
0.37753456830978394,
0.1421339213848114,
0.7641735672950745,
-0.633585512638092,
0.030591892078518867,
-0.5313514471054077,
0.2418021410703659,
0.03235902637243271,
-0.3647072911262512,
0.9327202439308167,
0.354934960603714,
0.8601068258285522,
-0.004368536174297333,
1.043676733970642,
0.1774153858423233,
0.6299145221710205,
-0.23806484043598175,
0.45103204250335693,
-0.45089802145957947,
0.2731616497039795,
-0.19840174913406372,
-0.9174862504005432,
-0.25486263632774353,
0.09266188740730286,
-0.37688982486724854,
0.39638054370880127,
0.5019274353981018,
0.35132020711898804,
0.2014056295156479,
0.2203548401594162,
0.5472123026847839,
0.17641304433345795,
0.29632702469825745,
0.2839764952659607,
1.169490933418274,
-0.09017527848482132,
0.019663972780108452,
-0.11887959390878677,
-0.21968208253383636,
-0.3917655348777771,
-0.615388810634613,
-0.9511078596115112,
-0.6572684049606323,
-0.21477186679840088,
0.12049959599971771,
0.08814636617898941,
1.054046869277954,
0.32863491773605347,
-0.6450775861740112,
-0.558434247970581,
0.23441082239151,
0.2683664858341217,
0.3953656852245331,
-0.15352319180965424,
0.06328098475933075,
-0.1635291576385498,
-1.212944507598877,
0.43498778343200684,
0.20471923053264618,
0.3587341904640198,
-0.8118927478790283,
0.12017031759023666,
-0.1189262792468071,
0.11987563967704773,
1.0166441202163696,
0.38069969415664673,
-0.7781603932380676,
-0.3929104506969452,
0.20067456364631653,
-0.09547016769647598,
-0.2537406086921692,
0.8037241697311401,
-0.5719081163406372,
0.4546225666999817,
0.13015614449977875,
0.7776430249214172,
0.1205025464296341,
-0.5402655005455017,
0.3762565851211548,
-0.24118080735206604,
0.08990008383989334,
0.19571061432361603,
0.352027028799057,
0.6119632124900818,
-0.03289760649204254,
0.21860764920711517,
-0.0006843302980996668,
-0.5603507161140442,
-1.0409128665924072,
0.17141371965408325,
-0.6429123878479004,
-0.32156458497047424,
0.9966551661491394,
0.08461324870586395,
-0.081969253718853,
-0.08335919678211212,
0.07490319758653641,
0.09821046143770218,
0.025666186586022377,
0.6488938927650452,
0.9007458090782166,
0.1596130132675171,
-0.19922491908073425,
-0.9688771367073059,
-0.10194115340709686,
0.11497191339731216,
-0.8544379472732544,
-0.16735194623470306,
0.6428284645080566,
0.44095563888549805,
-0.0006642561638727784,
0.4108704924583435,
-0.35744208097457886,
-0.1183200553059578,
-0.17886748909950256,
0.059808168560266495,
0.021865682676434517,
-0.5305556654930115,
-0.6404365301132202,
0.20032921433448792,
0.5023651123046875,
0.08668085187673569
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18098v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18098v1
|
GPTs and Language Barrier: A Cross-Lingual Legal QA Examination
| 2024-03-26T20:47:32 | 2024-03-26T20:47:32 |
Ha-Thanh Nguyen, Hiroaki Yamada, Ken Satoh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this paper, we explore the application of Generative Pre-trained
Transformers (GPTs) in cross-lingual legal Question-Answering (QA) systems
using the COLIEE Task 4 dataset. In the COLIEE Task 4, given a statement and a
set of related legal articles that serve as context, the objective is to
determine whether the statement is legally valid, i.e., if it can be inferred
from the provided contextual articles or not, which is also known as an
entailment task. By benchmarking four different combinations of English and
Japanese prompts and data, we provide valuable insights into GPTs' performance
in multilingual legal QA scenarios, contributing to the development of more
efficient and accurate cross-lingual QA solutions in the legal domain.
|
[
-0.38527071475982666,
-0.6905031800270081,
0.6351300477981567,
0.21145670115947723,
-0.24800395965576172,
0.13251128792762756,
0.11973584443330765,
-0.567269504070282,
0.034881990402936935,
0.43802690505981445,
-0.5446780920028687,
-0.40099409222602844,
-0.5316882133483887,
0.5201982259750366,
-0.2690407633781433,
1.0005897283554077,
-0.4695299565792084,
0.09630431234836578,
-0.22229903936386108,
-0.19899402558803558,
-0.7271111607551575,
-0.38316047191619873,
-0.6042219400405884,
0.1384221464395523,
0.09749208390712738,
0.061653949320316315,
0.6820202469825745,
-0.05789637565612793,
0.40153175592422485,
0.3938652276992798,
0.35651183128356934,
-0.526250958442688,
-0.1254027634859085,
0.12280911952257156,
-0.42603635787963867,
-0.7347163558006287,
-0.14911134541034698,
-0.05264470726251602,
0.42772993445396423,
0.37863343954086304,
-0.12944933772087097,
0.06221183389425278,
-0.1577945053577423,
0.36508068442344666,
-0.6363535523414612,
0.12106992304325104,
-0.4867800176143646,
0.5301033854484558,
-0.26090672612190247,
-0.2426673024892807,
-0.2416391670703888,
-0.4377090632915497,
0.15030302107334137,
-0.8790278434753418,
0.3754529654979706,
-0.08850600570440292,
1.19905424118042,
0.5120269656181335,
-0.6874678730964661,
-0.4234708547592163,
-0.48948609828948975,
0.3248916268348694,
-0.4582212567329407,
0.907242476940155,
0.31727761030197144,
0.5179455876350403,
0.10935664176940918,
-1.0418927669525146,
-0.680225670337677,
-0.2684401273727417,
-0.12778215110301971,
0.49157482385635376,
-0.36936768889427185,
-0.07832092046737671,
0.47445863485336304,
0.23780828714370728,
-0.9736026525497437,
0.06150621175765991,
-0.2425282895565033,
-0.5310404300689697,
0.4539180397987366,
-0.09828435629606247,
0.6773296594619751,
-0.012866715900599957,
-0.16679610311985016,
-0.07058002054691315,
-0.8783249258995056,
0.10487835854291916,
0.505997359752655,
0.04373491555452347,
-0.17219246923923492,
0.4921615421772003,
-0.1871882677078247,
0.5328542590141296,
0.1827637255191803,
-0.001854763482697308,
0.41411009430885315,
-0.5147910118103027,
-0.19063043594360352,
-0.020721860229969025,
0.9547479152679443,
0.05940840393304825,
0.329127699136734,
-0.3451780378818512,
-0.1750124990940094,
-0.27441856265068054,
0.1925562173128128,
-0.745475709438324,
0.14535140991210938,
0.0166494008153677,
-0.09419210255146027,
0.30541670322418213,
0.19850894808769226,
-0.941102147102356,
0.002943878062069416,
-0.24955494701862335,
0.5159709453582764,
-0.2581285536289215,
-0.25451627373695374,
0.14173585176467896,
0.1020435094833374,
0.6058024168014526,
-0.04041112959384918,
-0.739469051361084,
0.2249024510383606,
0.3747597932815552,
0.3989415168762207,
0.3443153202533722,
-0.21240459382534027,
-0.7028053402900696,
0.12337559461593628,
-0.20988042652606964,
0.6180791258811951,
-0.5454795956611633,
-0.5627581477165222,
0.31448307633399963,
0.4458199739456177,
-0.40961357951164246,
-0.5167650580406189,
0.6641316413879395,
-0.9496859312057495,
0.5911505818367004,
-0.39360931515693665,
-0.32096102833747864,
-0.11433706432580948,
0.33952751755714417,
-0.6234481930732727,
0.7335538864135742,
0.4820590913295746,
-0.6435845494270325,
0.7157347202301025,
-0.6884986162185669,
-0.9307365417480469,
0.4519464373588562,
-0.5653260946273804,
-0.4904193878173828,
-0.41516226530075073,
0.4687754511833191,
0.10125803202390671,
-0.27627119421958923,
0.2600022554397583,
0.30931422114372253,
-0.1468643993139267,
-0.011355149559676647,
-0.37793123722076416,
1.0403447151184082,
0.22755926847457886,
-0.7773309350013733,
0.13383527100086212,
-0.4488452076911926,
0.01934104599058628,
0.17326799035072327,
-0.3445872664451599,
-0.15144726634025574,
-0.20488938689231873,
-0.2344469279050827,
0.49791258573532104,
0.1338023990392685,
-0.6344855427742004,
-0.0526207759976387,
-0.18634627759456635,
0.3220939040184021,
0.342037558555603,
0.010531239211559296,
0.11489351093769073,
-0.0024044704623520374,
1.3293771743774414,
0.04085908085107803,
0.25610730051994324,
0.1560201197862625,
-0.7958563566207886,
-0.5890318155288696,
0.16106130182743073,
0.49301186203956604,
1.0732431411743164,
-1.4340530633926392,
0.3839150667190552,
-0.43184715509414673,
-0.06811311841011047,
-0.6574057936668396,
0.08572671562433243,
0.5339879393577576,
0.38586437702178955,
0.3805335760116577,
-0.06614984571933746,
-0.43831533193588257,
-0.9239345788955688,
-0.22896377742290497,
-0.4501793086528778,
-0.3564493954181671,
-0.03709829971194267,
0.6142546534538269,
-0.20013098418712616,
0.8993936777114868,
-0.10252384841442108,
-0.31864121556282043,
-0.2152514010667801,
0.1311064511537552,
0.11895065754652023,
0.2486312836408615,
0.6522853970527649,
-1.0559645891189575,
-0.7660835981369019,
0.16990113258361816,
-0.7589337229728699,
-0.341949999332428,
-0.32126569747924805,
-0.021082814782857895,
0.05308213829994202,
0.7251015901565552,
-0.5900009870529175,
0.3107956349849701,
0.48388832807540894,
-0.6757531762123108,
0.6326513290405273,
-0.10337670147418976,
0.5076767206192017,
-1.1621794700622559,
-0.22562740743160248,
0.03939058631658554,
-0.18772605061531067,
-0.5692799687385559,
0.25490638613700867,
0.23680563271045685,
-0.1847144514322281,
-0.6477698087692261,
0.11347910016775131,
-0.5466481447219849,
-0.16060155630111694,
0.20391930639743805,
0.0650065541267395,
-0.11339347809553146,
0.3106038272380829,
-0.046201858669519424,
1.264327049255371,
0.6767573356628418,
-0.39384299516677856,
0.3820711076259613,
0.3811850845813751,
-0.30090007185935974,
1.0102204084396362,
-0.563826322555542,
0.18023176491260529,
-0.012916622683405876,
0.039100904017686844,
-0.5673297047615051,
0.009415833279490471,
0.5092738270759583,
-0.20893117785453796,
0.2962009012699127,
-0.19407837092876434,
-0.5508579015731812,
-0.5293030142784119,
0.10511130839586258,
0.585853099822998,
0.48042193055152893,
-0.31898191571235657,
0.7609205842018127,
0.2671169340610504,
-0.24830393493175507,
-0.5617138147354126,
-0.6857534050941467,
0.2022855281829834,
-0.32932278513908386,
-0.5360342860221863,
0.33876171708106995,
0.13495516777038574,
-0.011896280571818352,
0.09933649003505707,
0.14329946041107178,
-0.18857184052467346,
-0.09485989063978195,
-0.03501516580581665,
-0.017784709110856056,
-0.4026162624359131,
0.04193389043211937,
0.17100666463375092,
0.04171290621161461,
0.4629184305667877,
-0.11226264387369156,
0.4340316951274872,
-0.22661732137203217,
-0.7443145513534546,
-0.39972034096717834,
0.33136552572250366,
0.25174573063850403,
-0.42393526434898376,
0.2243839055299759,
0.5854768753051758,
-0.2081947773694992,
0.11583082377910614,
-0.505494236946106,
0.10421307384967804,
-0.5201388001441956,
0.5250006318092346,
-1.0603246688842773,
-1.1877371072769165,
0.6840446591377258,
0.3155929744243622,
-0.18075674772262573,
0.5441004037857056,
0.45941469073295593,
0.30199241638183594,
0.7470102906227112,
0.4655865430831909,
-0.1667279452085495,
0.17674396932125092,
0.10194841772317886,
0.6186009049415588,
-0.40685853362083435,
-0.21599680185317993,
-0.6151997447013855,
0.22458866238594055,
-1.0567541122436523,
-0.23478534817695618,
0.6046231389045715,
-0.004108780529350042,
-0.19952704012393951,
0.542277991771698,
-0.15282323956489563,
0.4318279027938843,
0.5278968214988708,
-0.10202944278717041,
0.2604885697364807,
-0.2962457537651062,
-0.23799769580364227,
0.04852316901087761,
-0.7885054349899292,
-0.25547975301742554,
0.7907275557518005,
0.27319350838661194,
0.37014883756637573,
0.3449307978153229,
0.4196797013282776,
0.09001943469047546,
0.3569934070110321,
-0.6810687184333801,
0.6882959008216858,
0.1108977422118187,
-0.7775984406471252,
-0.5655016303062439,
-0.5083524584770203,
-1.215336799621582,
0.3796076774597168,
-0.002185148186981678,
-0.47007179260253906,
0.24563167989253998,
-0.33417436480522156,
-0.4154503047466278,
0.22794662415981293,
-0.5877953767776489,
1.0820376873016357,
-0.21290887892246246,
-0.2776188850402832,
0.02552105113863945,
-0.7281643152236938,
0.23168300092220306,
-0.3279134929180145,
0.22512394189834595,
0.0407373383641243,
0.11913669109344482,
0.8274363875389099,
-0.5494572520256042,
0.6292631030082703,
-0.209010049700737,
-0.5105109810829163,
0.5170192122459412,
0.014452388510107994,
0.33186209201812744,
0.20132610201835632,
0.3250867426395416,
0.04206754267215729,
0.22561849653720856,
-0.29242050647735596,
-0.604414165019989,
0.21067509055137634,
-0.6012107729911804,
-0.9757986068725586,
-0.3621810972690582,
-0.5367894768714905,
-0.5507742762565613,
0.36584797501564026,
0.47339141368865967,
0.08972655981779099,
-0.10797934979200363,
-0.16200195252895355,
0.37801310420036316,
-0.33843839168548584,
0.3045201003551483,
0.9363309144973755,
0.1843751072883606,
-0.011696313507854939,
0.8083823919296265,
0.1269671767950058,
0.03340616822242737,
0.48987865447998047,
-0.05633042752742767,
-0.6955018043518066,
-0.5646172165870667,
-0.6988351345062256,
0.26729679107666016,
-0.8661017417907715,
-0.08869700878858566,
-0.48523375391960144,
-0.3050723075866699,
-0.7120650410652161,
-0.1025257408618927,
-0.0455898754298687,
0.08555915206670761,
0.17910940945148468,
-0.25426098704338074,
0.035362571477890015,
0.5253012180328369,
0.06916502863168716,
0.0007400278700515628,
-0.8259649276733398,
0.4646359086036682,
0.7643442749977112,
0.4130561649799347,
-0.6954692006111145,
-0.5419212579727173,
-0.13717886805534363,
-0.07044173777103424,
-0.25616922974586487,
-1.0515837669372559,
0.03969557210803032,
-0.05553599074482918,
0.8086480498313904,
0.4060360789299011,
-0.025109896436333656,
0.5134017467498779,
-0.762060284614563,
0.8069582581520081,
0.16425764560699463,
-1.1404489278793335,
0.5639270544052124,
-0.33526521921157837,
0.23001399636268616,
0.5606557130813599,
0.7440899610519409,
-0.6786137819290161,
-0.7792112231254578,
-0.38747158646583557,
-0.7011162042617798,
0.3416792154312134,
0.38424238562583923,
0.20226892828941345,
-0.017890451475977898,
0.15467970073223114,
0.1509554088115692,
0.024931760504841805,
-0.936259925365448,
0.19603712856769562,
-0.4166272282600403,
-0.1908348649740219,
0.03286231681704521,
0.020973604172468185,
0.03545432165265083,
-0.24517887830734253,
0.5655079483985901,
-0.21117737889289856,
0.11117017269134521,
0.20657292008399963,
-0.4351355731487274,
0.09913327544927597,
0.6868898868560791,
0.5372692346572876,
0.8594015836715698,
0.11599008738994598,
0.0002762474468909204,
0.34483325481414795,
-0.6445183753967285,
0.528203010559082,
0.41972076892852783,
-0.29786446690559387,
0.12380010634660721,
0.42312079668045044,
0.8592665195465088,
-0.07874127477407455,
-0.6751474738121033,
0.6708327531814575,
-0.0768781304359436,
-0.5234423279762268,
-0.3352712094783783,
-0.3041626811027527,
-0.1760006994009018,
0.1746407151222229,
0.2571977972984314,
-0.6030154228210449,
0.337617427110672,
-0.5427172780036926,
0.3699776232242584,
0.24809621274471283,
-0.4375584125518799,
-0.38439705967903137,
0.96429443359375,
0.25947365164756775,
-0.0503837987780571,
0.6023203134536743,
-0.3924267888069153,
-0.7412341833114624,
0.6495961546897888,
0.5112016797065735,
1.040155291557312,
-0.44488751888275146,
0.4855057895183563,
0.2526102364063263,
0.6334578990936279,
0.10886449366807938,
0.34865495562553406,
-0.025731021538376808,
-0.9108611941337585,
-0.7520251274108887,
-0.31504207849502563,
-0.30734696984291077,
0.10365153849124908,
-0.7101784944534302,
-0.06718940287828445,
-0.021948494017124176,
-0.0868665874004364,
-0.2932742238044739,
-0.3710479736328125,
-0.8963649868965149,
0.30455267429351807,
-0.13440974056720734,
0.593700110912323,
-0.9766797423362732,
0.7327448129653931,
0.7583288550376892,
-0.7916713953018188,
-0.7345709800720215,
0.330959290266037,
-0.22716090083122253,
-0.781212568283081,
0.8687611818313599,
-0.028683394193649292,
-0.09482978284358978,
0.0002468028978910297,
0.007924030534923077,
-0.5487678647041321,
0.7713492512702942,
0.42359641194343567,
-0.5215345025062561,
-0.021082118153572083,
1.0283833742141724,
0.5834908485412598,
0.026845011860132217,
0.2199694663286209,
0.9516685009002686,
0.5737908482551575,
-0.32430627942085266,
-1.2100963592529297,
0.3805208206176758,
-0.41961029171943665,
-0.05106683447957039,
0.1889754682779312,
-0.33365297317504883,
0.6706047058105469,
-0.005407588556408882,
-0.5295716524124146,
-0.3451347053050995,
0.5441884398460388,
0.15020832419395447,
0.1178193986415863,
0.8106316924095154,
0.6369845271110535,
0.5043936371803284,
-0.4436010718345642,
1.1107746362686157,
-0.3627154231071472,
0.13494592905044556,
0.8771687746047974,
-0.5574466586112976,
0.4999261498451233,
0.5041868686676025,
-0.5667868256568909,
0.6299394369125366,
0.6834364533424377,
-0.06848552078008652,
0.3534601926803589,
0.2756134271621704,
-0.3548320233821869,
-0.11764249950647354,
-0.08959619700908661,
-0.500758171081543,
0.3138136863708496,
0.19479762017726898,
0.06587434560060501,
-0.3104058504104614,
0.3002837598323822,
-0.14325381815433502,
0.09989786148071289,
-0.19018617272377014,
0.7291882634162903,
-0.12871161103248596,
-0.8020809292793274,
0.47439318895339966,
-0.04428909346461296,
0.607237696647644,
-0.5824230313301086,
0.07902466505765915,
-0.4027199149131775,
-0.24344247579574585,
-0.024211417883634567,
-1.032336950302124,
0.3278171718120575,
0.15981867909431458,
0.2295868992805481,
-0.2739156186580658,
0.34000760316848755,
-0.4611775577068329,
-0.3892700970172882,
0.4315517246723175,
0.6184111833572388,
0.24229253828525543,
0.05005888640880585,
-0.8777608275413513,
-0.37334921956062317,
-0.15010137856006622,
-0.24368876218795776,
0.030198834836483,
0.7747788429260254,
-0.4111652970314026,
0.4954264163970947,
0.25227129459381104,
-0.1909170150756836,
0.4516597390174866,
0.6527238488197327,
0.712491512298584,
-0.6106587052345276,
-0.9283427000045776,
-0.5153236389160156,
0.4673563539981842,
0.07168085873126984,
-0.28264716267585754,
0.8358843922615051,
0.7589396238327026,
1.302929401397705,
-0.22656716406345367,
0.8525747060775757,
-0.22429810464382172,
0.27418217062950134,
-0.9246114492416382,
0.48051220178604126,
-0.3928905427455902,
-0.06341089308261871,
-0.15992486476898193,
-0.7977918982505798,
-0.11792679131031036,
0.26603832840919495,
-0.4448105990886688,
0.26713234186172485,
1.0793486833572388,
0.7847212553024292,
-0.0019110178109258413,
-0.036369867622852325,
0.5118075609207153,
-0.24285325407981873,
0.4342844486236572,
0.9573211669921875,
0.9509778022766113,
-0.6527473330497742,
0.7759073972702026,
-0.048764318227767944,
0.16416242718696594,
0.28034961223602295,
-0.3474479913711548,
-0.734231173992157,
-0.6686089038848877,
-0.5028089284896851,
-0.2770845293998718,
0.14161960780620575,
0.2153378427028656,
0.40384766459465027,
-1.1230082511901855,
-0.23184514045715332,
-0.18646927177906036,
-0.061653364449739456,
-0.10328710079193115,
-0.3013466000556946,
0.39528805017471313,
-0.6504992842674255,
-0.9287821650505066,
0.37362897396087646,
-0.08335033059120178,
0.27261531352996826,
-0.06731219589710236,
-0.1748584359884262,
-0.12876130640506744,
-0.2027951180934906,
0.5899983644485474,
0.4065701961517334,
-0.5710169672966003,
-0.4803043603897095,
-0.20122450590133667,
-0.07393182814121246,
0.14128823578357697,
1.017566442489624,
-0.4963364005088806,
0.3821864128112793,
0.4992092549800873,
0.8586726188659668,
0.4744393825531006,
-0.19878897070884705,
0.7515823841094971,
-0.7689563632011414,
0.41486021876335144,
0.33947011828422546,
0.5851523280143738,
0.15384815633296967,
-0.22749248147010803,
0.7240344882011414,
0.27707886695861816,
-0.3031992018222809,
-0.3786433935165405,
0.3502775728702545,
-0.589656412601471,
-0.3577653765678406,
1.0810680389404297,
-0.382515549659729,
0.07915620505809784,
-0.6419073939323425,
0.11301964521408081,
0.357221782207489,
0.13177461922168732,
0.5685030221939087,
0.7180654406547546,
0.1577814668416977,
-0.32977163791656494,
-0.9243988394737244,
0.6460681557655334,
0.6648121476173401,
-1.1905558109283447,
-0.48999983072280884,
0.45939362049102783,
0.4238360524177551,
0.2518077790737152,
0.8142818808555603,
-0.30999287962913513,
0.45875266194343567,
-0.0007296978728845716,
0.17993348836898804,
0.16150538623332977,
-0.013523412868380547,
-0.26048704981803894,
0.3268583416938782,
-0.24572007358074188,
-0.3098539412021637
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18093v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18093v1
|
Enhancing Legal Document Retrieval: A Multi-Phase Approach with Large Language Models
| 2024-03-26T20:25:53 | 2024-03-26T20:25:53 |
Hai-Long Nguyen, Duc-Minh Nguyen, Tan-Minh Nguyen, Ha-Thanh Nguyen, Thi-Hai-Yen Vuong, Ken Satoh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models with billions of parameters, such as GPT-3.5, GPT-4,
and LLaMA, are increasingly prevalent. Numerous studies have explored effective
prompting techniques to harness the power of these LLMs for various research
problems. Retrieval, specifically in the legal data domain, poses a challenging
task for the direct application of Prompting techniques due to the large number
and substantial length of legal articles. This research focuses on maximizing
the potential of prompting by placing it as the final phase of the retrieval
system, preceded by the support of two phases: BM25 Pre-ranking and BERT-based
Re-ranking. Experiments on the COLIEE 2023 dataset demonstrate that integrating
prompting techniques on LLMs into the retrieval system significantly improves
retrieval accuracy. However, error analysis reveals several existing issues in
the retrieval system that still need resolution.
|
[
-0.33323365449905396,
-0.6519916653633118,
1.0940498113632202,
0.3049424886703491,
-0.533126175403595,
0.06494881212711334,
-0.20015625655651093,
-0.3444470167160034,
0.0016043606447055936,
0.39629310369491577,
-0.2510967552661896,
-0.5151355266571045,
-0.6153744459152222,
0.3135051131248474,
-0.697609007358551,
0.8432031273841858,
0.11289386451244354,
0.3108469247817993,
0.14820300042629242,
0.010583622381091118,
-0.6681174039840698,
-0.5274893045425415,
-0.8665645718574524,
-0.5672444701194763,
0.8880089521408081,
0.3339497447013855,
0.4991624057292938,
0.22475400567054749,
0.395855575799942,
0.2113739550113678,
-0.30430489778518677,
-0.18205979466438293,
-0.4375952482223511,
0.5523561835289001,
-0.08021540939807892,
-0.6597568392753601,
-0.2649235129356384,
-0.021783336997032166,
0.6065127849578857,
0.3603282570838928,
-0.5089099407196045,
-0.19817417860031128,
0.025162389501929283,
0.7699643969535828,
-0.4014208912849426,
0.11939948797225952,
-0.6991076469421387,
0.0009379361290484667,
-0.3600095510482788,
-0.496463418006897,
-0.6891352534294128,
-0.42495661973953247,
0.13850824534893036,
-0.6854838728904724,
0.30791962146759033,
0.27453309297561646,
0.8110685348510742,
0.08800715953111649,
-0.6404222846031189,
-0.5530641674995422,
-0.4471415579319,
0.5200015902519226,
-0.5858443975448608,
0.6351256966590881,
0.45213717222213745,
0.05741250514984131,
-0.38822558522224426,
-0.8210347294807434,
-0.6519186496734619,
-0.5589240193367004,
0.13236260414123535,
0.2141125649213791,
-0.10072604566812515,
0.2280893623828888,
0.3717341721057892,
0.017219385132193565,
-0.49480536580085754,
0.22244767844676971,
-0.3030310571193695,
-0.1162380501627922,
0.4357832670211792,
-0.04988962039351463,
0.05212324485182762,
-0.2357652336359024,
-0.0936211496591568,
-0.16139629483222961,
-0.9317723512649536,
-0.12997496128082275,
0.5664229989051819,
0.3565617501735687,
0.45275166630744934,
0.6366063356399536,
-0.12476499378681183,
0.5233436822891235,
0.2899492084980011,
0.13846652209758759,
0.12228305637836456,
-0.506407618522644,
-0.1637076437473297,
-0.008751330897212029,
0.6387501955032349,
0.24410873651504517,
0.019316310063004494,
0.07922334223985672,
-0.43958479166030884,
-0.6926114559173584,
0.5202284455299377,
-0.6851701140403748,
0.05343325808644295,
0.5353997349739075,
-0.5157536864280701,
-0.09038715064525604,
0.22739605605602264,
-1.0898981094360352,
-0.7288108468055725,
-0.6208951473236084,
0.5828073620796204,
-0.3983289301395416,
0.05613579973578453,
0.14407189190387726,
-0.13361449539661407,
0.39462244510650635,
0.5879253149032593,
-0.7780022621154785,
-0.013885756954550743,
0.8518984317779541,
0.7567498087882996,
0.2744824290275574,
0.10528270155191422,
-0.7749162912368774,
0.23175767064094543,
-0.49249279499053955,
0.66209876537323,
-0.7504588961601257,
-0.7111455202102661,
0.38450101017951965,
0.1436324417591095,
0.18386071920394897,
-0.6902807950973511,
0.8159748911857605,
-0.919514000415802,
0.1100199744105339,
-0.8503716588020325,
-0.4813680648803711,
-0.2755102515220642,
0.240034818649292,
-0.6964055299758911,
1.0810275077819824,
-0.251742959022522,
-0.3202962875366211,
0.689511775970459,
-0.6926866173744202,
-0.4763502776622772,
0.33258527517318726,
-0.17859509587287903,
-0.40420469641685486,
0.08500896394252777,
0.3702909052371979,
0.44481801986694336,
-0.3032296299934387,
0.4375065565109253,
0.13149583339691162,
-0.32068854570388794,
-0.21233241260051727,
-0.23939742147922516,
0.6131260991096497,
0.3177754878997803,
-0.20164616405963898,
0.1807456612586975,
-0.24401578307151794,
-0.2731883227825165,
0.07617659866809845,
-0.7726374864578247,
-0.1888015866279602,
0.04730207100510597,
-0.4447766840457916,
-0.025310680270195007,
0.4032808542251587,
-0.46837177872657776,
0.3013265132904053,
0.13908229768276215,
0.28946295380592346,
0.6464599967002869,
0.136094868183136,
0.3350568115711212,
-0.39832958579063416,
0.7614120244979858,
-0.01876091957092285,
0.059352219104766846,
-0.3865535259246826,
-0.6453037858009338,
-0.6457852125167847,
-0.0815485343337059,
0.47231587767601013,
0.6974520087242126,
-0.6166096329689026,
0.31365740299224854,
-0.22896915674209595,
-0.30677151679992676,
-0.7331434488296509,
0.3751847743988037,
0.21038740873336792,
0.24612250924110413,
0.4715663194656372,
-0.024771317839622498,
-0.48859548568725586,
-0.5487871766090393,
0.13853158056735992,
-0.2533237934112549,
-0.06935764849185944,
0.24681749939918518,
0.410418301820755,
-0.03800053149461746,
0.6359983086585999,
-0.06818662583827972,
-0.19789402186870575,
-0.24378585815429688,
0.4998586177825928,
0.5820682048797607,
0.11676688492298126,
0.37099120020866394,
-0.9284704923629761,
-0.5121097564697266,
0.0597049854695797,
-0.6606945395469666,
-0.3672148883342743,
-0.15464793145656586,
-0.053039129823446274,
0.08859400451183319,
0.7352280020713806,
-0.6192932724952698,
0.23148870468139648,
-0.05881058797240257,
-0.060727693140506744,
0.6431088447570801,
-0.5132511258125305,
0.5158973336219788,
-0.7251321077346802,
0.11381419003009796,
-0.01860695518553257,
-0.30233654379844666,
-0.533443808555603,
0.23843145370483398,
0.28438282012939453,
-0.1282147765159607,
-0.330767959356308,
0.32296186685562134,
-0.7187443375587463,
-0.02032632753252983,
-0.3039121925830841,
0.22304359078407288,
0.0023966156877577305,
0.0180970411747694,
-0.3237926661968231,
1.0566256046295166,
0.40088537335395813,
-0.6864683628082275,
0.4313162863254547,
0.23796270787715912,
-0.00625733332708478,
0.908233642578125,
-0.6438472270965576,
0.2563880681991577,
-0.649482786655426,
0.4539971351623535,
-0.8593084812164307,
-0.12044772505760193,
0.18925319612026215,
-0.05979105830192566,
0.7440100312232971,
-0.34183409810066223,
-0.8312519788742065,
-0.6349301338195801,
-0.6036302447319031,
0.07206027954816818,
0.32584577798843384,
-0.42664623260498047,
0.6229572296142578,
0.15161624550819397,
-0.614662230014801,
-0.7508460283279419,
-0.10156293958425522,
0.5236979722976685,
-0.29040899872779846,
-0.3035143315792084,
0.2852567136287689,
-0.26978543400764465,
-0.06167511269450188,
-0.10685191303491592,
0.1055869609117508,
0.1990809291601181,
-0.1858653426170349,
0.13385017216205597,
0.2267431914806366,
-0.10758895426988602,
0.06463395804166794,
0.16251516342163086,
0.1003507673740387,
0.12987594306468964,
-0.2831820547580719,
0.7463579177856445,
0.15153726935386658,
-0.41213205456733704,
-0.46271800994873047,
0.4044397473335266,
0.3916831910610199,
-0.2294999659061432,
0.3966159522533417,
0.23780576884746552,
-0.2572295367717743,
0.1826893836259842,
-0.9756783246994019,
-0.08554547280073166,
-0.5129130482673645,
0.0941850021481514,
-0.4493027627468109,
-0.7967753410339355,
0.5430315136909485,
0.12431079149246216,
0.026151930913329124,
0.13002552092075348,
0.7772705554962158,
-0.07083852589130402,
0.9108202457427979,
0.30359578132629395,
-0.3125746250152588,
0.8354335427284241,
-0.045143019407987595,
0.16066911816596985,
-0.8605676293373108,
-0.6162229180335999,
-0.8371882438659668,
-0.034401629120111465,
-0.3485964238643646,
-0.40015336871147156,
0.4334813058376312,
0.010941618122160435,
0.04790656641125679,
0.30971911549568176,
-0.261661171913147,
0.6270411014556885,
0.764396607875824,
0.34177836775779724,
0.3177546262741089,
0.03336445614695549,
-0.5301571488380432,
0.20994684100151062,
-0.3888312578201294,
-0.5234441161155701,
1.1438251733779907,
0.2451026290655136,
0.5528972744941711,
0.24360068142414093,
0.9330856800079346,
0.3033049404621124,
0.1197708398103714,
-0.901072084903717,
0.6986942291259766,
-0.03459654748439789,
-0.7613817453384399,
-0.5056530833244324,
-0.23689571022987366,
-1.4148571491241455,
0.4102872312068939,
-0.1023867279291153,
-0.681001603603363,
0.34705135226249695,
-0.2357977330684662,
-0.5821876525878906,
-0.18472672998905182,
-0.39846310019493103,
0.1831759363412857,
-0.11176272481679916,
-0.5091331005096436,
-0.3849831819534302,
-0.5478687286376953,
0.08907852321863174,
-0.46105846762657166,
0.25447800755500793,
-0.1249711662530899,
-0.21249200403690338,
0.6089388132095337,
-0.3610909879207611,
0.5824376344680786,
-0.2963315546512604,
-0.4077567160129547,
0.33423423767089844,
0.10572226345539093,
0.8008884191513062,
0.02606808766722679,
-0.4476534426212311,
-0.5190132856369019,
0.18434645235538483,
-0.32635748386383057,
-0.5800748467445374,
0.5816320776939392,
-0.18913760781288147,
-1.039899468421936,
-0.4471559524536133,
-0.4942150413990021,
-0.1178138479590416,
0.5776484608650208,
0.09282916784286499,
0.27535632252693176,
0.2475491464138031,
0.32942402362823486,
0.6457700133323669,
-0.10601817071437836,
0.446123868227005,
0.8646464943885803,
-0.13912303745746613,
-0.16912908852100372,
0.8222047686576843,
0.3444235622882843,
-0.2863127589225769,
0.2297687530517578,
0.25158724188804626,
-0.745761513710022,
-1.0152156352996826,
-0.07802353799343109,
0.511509120464325,
-0.8258340358734131,
-0.2684456706047058,
-0.6002324223518372,
0.06789616495370865,
-0.5541669726371765,
-0.05019798502326012,
0.2500889003276825,
0.09507980197668076,
-0.46822458505630493,
-0.32781538367271423,
0.23336178064346313,
1.00544011592865,
-0.03744067996740341,
0.2655284106731415,
-0.9404804110527039,
0.30580392479896545,
0.31931307911872864,
0.2655111849308014,
-0.03524492681026459,
-0.5751418471336365,
0.11622601002454758,
-0.2806117832660675,
-0.27611953020095825,
-1.0710842609405518,
0.1752084493637085,
-0.0016769494395703077,
0.8849343061447144,
0.2601673901081085,
-0.0804465040564537,
0.731025755405426,
-0.7558256387710571,
0.7765812277793884,
-0.09618140757083893,
-0.7949017882347107,
0.7202187776565552,
-0.5943191051483154,
0.07786085456609726,
0.7005094289779663,
0.5851299166679382,
-0.3610362410545349,
-0.5523637533187866,
-0.4085249602794647,
-0.9885482788085938,
0.5074611306190491,
0.048385828733444214,
0.46109697222709656,
-0.012997899204492569,
0.7451217770576477,
-0.03167649731040001,
0.28836891055107117,
-0.4740297496318817,
0.3142419159412384,
0.1617329716682434,
-0.2395462989807129,
0.3911379873752594,
-0.47758492827415466,
-0.07821530103683472,
-0.13869191706180573,
0.8669025897979736,
-0.10434774309396744,
0.1797247678041458,
0.22547940909862518,
-0.03091190755367279,
-0.04797506704926491,
0.3874548077583313,
0.6107434034347534,
0.8266481161117554,
-0.13430152833461761,
-0.04852120205760002,
0.19883035123348236,
-0.5208085775375366,
0.34837108850479126,
0.3455883860588074,
-0.2679404616355896,
0.011936725117266178,
0.13373547792434692,
0.3720250427722931,
0.21840129792690277,
-0.44259244203567505,
0.42015138268470764,
0.08067146688699722,
-0.36944249272346497,
-0.1412537693977356,
-0.17886364459991455,
-0.07643774151802063,
0.5145195126533508,
0.9298771619796753,
-0.8546811938285828,
0.33313196897506714,
-0.49305281043052673,
0.3921297490596771,
0.4289279580116272,
-0.22274371981620789,
0.07562478631734848,
0.8107306361198425,
0.1254567801952362,
-0.10730255395174026,
0.5803147554397583,
-0.2052483856678009,
-0.4256613850593567,
0.42874523997306824,
0.3582833409309387,
0.32057055830955505,
-0.2117190957069397,
0.3392143249511719,
0.3521591126918793,
0.27576586604118347,
-0.6756700277328491,
0.584933876991272,
0.025316409766674042,
-0.2886972427368164,
-0.5180376172065735,
-0.5122248530387878,
-0.376608282327652,
0.06622826308012009,
-0.5486618876457214,
0.4141542613506317,
-0.45138290524482727,
-0.49031153321266174,
-0.16238339245319366,
0.13097955286502838,
-0.48806115984916687,
-0.009731289930641651,
0.01637193188071251,
0.9567535519599915,
-0.33837631344795227,
0.7352503538131714,
0.39139676094055176,
-0.7112602591514587,
-0.7745082974433899,
-0.06120306998491287,
0.18227113783359528,
-0.7044969201087952,
0.5873389840126038,
-0.0357290655374527,
0.1269572228193283,
0.18445073068141937,
-0.644756555557251,
-0.42414945363998413,
1.24510657787323,
0.35135477781295776,
-0.8486234545707703,
-0.17775209248065948,
-0.046437494456768036,
0.5269190669059753,
0.10976197570562363,
0.19816911220550537,
0.6518137454986572,
0.769554078578949,
0.41339752078056335,
-0.8838145136833191,
0.2706351578235626,
0.05634869635105133,
-0.04586812108755112,
0.28131920099258423,
-0.3794858753681183,
0.522955596446991,
-0.15433651208877563,
-0.19869032502174377,
0.07440914958715439,
0.6667583584785461,
0.4777435064315796,
0.3752557933330536,
0.5031232237815857,
0.3445070683956146,
1.2546314001083374,
-0.12696829438209534,
1.1272952556610107,
-0.27497735619544983,
0.2923029959201813,
0.8328898549079895,
-0.5518848896026611,
0.9443592429161072,
0.4801778495311737,
-0.3026290237903595,
0.2423933446407318,
0.7482855319976807,
-0.2402668595314026,
0.25858426094055176,
0.14507435262203217,
-0.4881366193294525,
-0.15354101359844208,
-0.4083235561847687,
-0.33466479182243347,
-0.08680683374404907,
0.37935319542884827,
-0.4648415446281433,
-0.13311055302619934,
0.020357202738523483,
0.24344661831855774,
-0.21446020901203156,
-0.15004251897335052,
0.7528281807899475,
0.14183409512043,
-0.8143946528434753,
0.09395800530910492,
-0.1425926387310028,
0.40002918243408203,
-0.48265498876571655,
-0.04397236555814743,
-0.3650335371494293,
-0.4833889305591583,
-0.13228672742843628,
-1.0362505912780762,
-0.18746720254421234,
-0.013060933910310268,
0.02047903649508953,
-0.3387104272842407,
0.5912284851074219,
-0.44058915972709656,
-0.35416489839553833,
0.5268146395683289,
0.4010646343231201,
0.13904047012329102,
-0.1440853774547577,
-0.8207777142524719,
0.11833968013525009,
-0.2901112735271454,
-0.3511532247066498,
0.1464584767818451,
0.6222872734069824,
-0.10519731044769287,
0.7400068044662476,
0.9443967342376709,
0.12978021800518036,
0.4375828504562378,
0.6180225610733032,
0.8905107378959656,
-0.5121408104896545,
-0.26731783151626587,
-0.6251484751701355,
0.2695417106151581,
0.04549236595630646,
0.29269030690193176,
0.5138287544250488,
0.37955009937286377,
0.37950077652931213,
0.2435845583677292,
0.6158958077430725,
-0.1309288889169693,
0.31457239389419556,
-0.9181024432182312,
0.41535618901252747,
-0.49469178915023804,
0.36493346095085144,
-0.1586640477180481,
-1.0758723020553589,
-0.3562633991241455,
0.31704920530319214,
-0.2285337597131729,
0.18815840780735016,
0.7423080205917358,
1.0165690183639526,
0.14682382345199585,
-0.07172540575265884,
0.40722376108169556,
0.15766634047031403,
0.6564991474151611,
0.21140174567699432,
0.745296835899353,
-0.1285819262266159,
0.6894763708114624,
0.23283720016479492,
0.04249382019042969,
-0.4676719307899475,
-0.840071976184845,
-0.5793081521987915,
-0.5740718245506287,
-0.050846438854932785,
-0.43599408864974976,
0.32981106638908386,
0.8347250819206238,
0.6318474411964417,
-0.7783395051956177,
-0.136714369058609,
0.18682032823562622,
-0.060416366904973984,
0.19127753376960754,
-0.1551377922296524,
0.03517695888876915,
-0.7374716997146606,
-0.8459088802337646,
0.6780111789703369,
0.085964135825634,
0.16641783714294434,
-0.08732530474662781,
-0.09459324181079865,
-0.5910338759422302,
0.013983819633722305,
0.6558811068534851,
0.20503263175487518,
-0.710453987121582,
-0.3073175549507141,
-0.14251111447811127,
-0.20096518099308014,
0.1275719851255417,
1.1417231559753418,
-0.39804306626319885,
0.4688659906387329,
0.7989806532859802,
0.607605516910553,
0.6869344115257263,
0.2872391641139984,
0.8782994151115417,
-0.5724567770957947,
-0.043990615755319595,
0.1466832458972931,
0.6008045077323914,
0.20868970453739166,
-0.4928135573863983,
0.5926161408424377,
0.061646170914173126,
-0.6756516098976135,
-0.5273004174232483,
-0.07705642282962799,
-0.8592577576637268,
-0.23989546298980713,
1.159365177154541,
-0.03775785118341446,
-0.04734262824058533,
-0.4387173354625702,
-0.5149288177490234,
0.30525851249694824,
-0.9132604002952576,
0.6351755857467651,
1.210664987564087,
-0.057140082120895386,
-0.3866630494594574,
-1.1486682891845703,
0.2559387683868408,
0.5867236852645874,
-0.7250524759292603,
-0.13667985796928406,
0.6555446982383728,
0.2250087857246399,
0.22378985583782196,
0.7801840901374817,
-0.30504468083381653,
0.1573675274848938,
-0.4292844533920288,
-0.40859007835388184,
0.084898941218853,
-0.46851274371147156,
-0.7206337451934814,
0.28005555272102356,
0.22458091378211975,
0.18619246780872345
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18063v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18063v2
|
Heracles: A Hybrid SSM-Transformer Model for High-Resolution Image and Time-Series Analysis
| 2024-03-26T19:29:21 | 2024-06-03T18:22:30 |
Badri N. Patro, Suhas Ranganath, Vinay P. Namboodiri, Vijay S. Agneeswaran
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.MM
|
Transformers have revolutionized image modeling tasks with adaptations like
DeIT, Swin, SVT, Biformer, STVit, and FDVIT. However, these models often face
challenges with inductive bias and high quadratic complexity, making them less
efficient for high-resolution images. State space models (SSMs) such as Mamba,
V-Mamba, ViM, and SiMBA offer an alternative to handle high resolution images
in computer vision tasks. These SSMs encounter two major issues. First, they
become unstable when scaled to large network sizes. Second, although they
efficiently capture global information in images, they inherently struggle with
handling local information. To address these challenges, we introduce Heracles,
a novel SSM that integrates a local SSM, a global SSM, and an attention-based
token interaction module. Heracles leverages a Hartely kernel-based state space
model for global image information, a localized convolutional network for local
details, and attention mechanisms in deeper layers for token interactions. Our
extensive experiments demonstrate that Heracles-C-small achieves
state-of-the-art performance on the ImageNet dataset with 84.5\% top-1
accuracy. Heracles-C-Large and Heracles-C-Huge further improve accuracy to
85.9\% and 86.4\%, respectively. Additionally, Heracles excels in transfer
learning tasks on datasets such as CIFAR-10, CIFAR-100, Oxford Flowers, and
Stanford Cars, and in instance segmentation on the MSCOCO dataset. Heracles
also proves its versatility by achieving state-of-the-art results on seven
time-series datasets, showcasing its ability to generalize across domains with
spectral data, capturing both local and global information. The project page is
available at this link.\url{https://github.com/badripatro/heracles}
|
[
-0.33058661222457886,
-0.32759425044059753,
0.38219597935676575,
-0.09080648422241211,
-0.17872117459774017,
0.41593241691589355,
-0.02669922448694706,
-0.22322292625904083,
0.34860700368881226,
0.4333094358444214,
-0.17472554743289948,
-0.25223055481910706,
-0.6067302227020264,
-0.05574275180697441,
-0.41172850131988525,
0.48918604850769043,
-0.21235179901123047,
-0.16336803138256073,
0.02273261547088623,
-0.4430117607116699,
-0.33637160062789917,
-0.44126957654953003,
-0.6060963869094849,
0.11498448252677917,
0.5249559283256531,
0.31858351826667786,
0.9083446860313416,
0.4962710440158844,
0.8902975916862488,
0.49081918597221375,
-0.2595011591911316,
0.3244708180427551,
-0.3909823000431061,
0.0609034039080143,
-0.3906209170818329,
-0.4446328282356262,
-0.2578701972961426,
-0.10990237444639206,
0.7249172925949097,
0.5098884105682373,
-0.2998276948928833,
0.5041013956069946,
-0.2190018594264984,
0.589847207069397,
-0.7593593001365662,
0.23647387325763702,
-0.45785781741142273,
0.4351978302001953,
-0.4452359974384308,
-0.10847250372171402,
-0.268561452627182,
-0.09316138178110123,
0.2962460219860077,
-0.6824621558189392,
0.17877428233623505,
0.37307029962539673,
1.2118722200393677,
0.5224208235740662,
-0.6065617203712463,
0.40317243337631226,
-1.0657535791397095,
0.9136523604393005,
-0.4810362458229065,
0.3010398745536804,
-0.12500272691249847,
0.9577809572219849,
-0.18991100788116455,
-0.8983054161071777,
-0.4693177044391632,
0.024911152198910713,
-0.036608219146728516,
0.5358613729476929,
-0.6187974810600281,
-0.41359055042266846,
0.26701638102531433,
0.7287819385528564,
-0.26504814624786377,
0.06853283196687698,
-0.9087430238723755,
-0.1117936372756958,
0.2464543879032135,
0.677646815776825,
-0.04594486206769943,
-0.5078928470611572,
-0.6851065754890442,
0.08713074028491974,
-0.42837491631507874,
0.3111664950847626,
0.017071427777409554,
0.005585290025919676,
-0.35448747873306274,
0.49775952100753784,
0.18943442404270172,
0.4598873555660248,
0.2088204324245453,
0.00997176580131054,
0.03717922419309616,
-0.12981124222278595,
-0.14653107523918152,
-0.33678045868873596,
0.6743977069854736,
0.16519984602928162,
-0.3428906798362732,
-0.09577936679124832,
0.09455268830060959,
0.2816774845123291,
0.7271102070808411,
-0.6210981011390686,
-0.013381506316363811,
0.19872808456420898,
-0.7475723028182983,
-0.3428528606891632,
-0.06039118394255638,
-0.7467281222343445,
-0.26215630769729614,
-0.4325200319290161,
0.5369566679000854,
-0.14544178545475006,
-0.43926918506622314,
-0.02900698222219944,
-0.1436987817287445,
0.18289801478385925,
0.20632271468639374,
-0.5160124897956848,
0.28644925355911255,
0.13887397944927216,
0.9851388335227966,
-0.5326064229011536,
-0.14313271641731262,
-0.3574521839618683,
0.38296887278556824,
-0.6552097797393799,
0.7592298984527588,
-0.30226656794548035,
-0.10621991753578186,
-0.29825082421302795,
0.26402488350868225,
-0.0328228697180748,
-0.4857615530490875,
0.18348240852355957,
-0.7227439284324646,
-0.2895783483982086,
0.015300302766263485,
-0.38656938076019287,
-0.092595174908638,
0.0017301724292337894,
-0.8588019609451294,
1.313583493232727,
0.25236326456069946,
-0.7592611908912659,
0.058506231755018234,
-0.606743335723877,
-0.1704878956079483,
-0.0023161438293755054,
-0.1001257598400116,
-0.44518613815307617,
0.2577073276042938,
0.02629753202199936,
0.7940565943717957,
-0.3988174498081207,
0.38766661286354065,
-0.42165666818618774,
-0.20600736141204834,
0.07687411457300186,
-0.20396998524665833,
0.36298611760139465,
0.43626296520233154,
-0.01967620849609375,
0.325385719537735,
-0.6184867024421692,
-0.48721030354499817,
0.29734721779823303,
-0.15296989679336548,
-0.21480776369571686,
0.04707449674606323,
-0.00410424405708909,
0.2642812728881836,
-0.06476866453886032,
-0.6128368973731995,
0.1254376620054245,
-0.08163848519325256,
0.6364488005638123,
0.8335888981819153,
-0.07297645509243011,
0.7292830348014832,
-0.11046188324689865,
0.3019590973854065,
0.33912935853004456,
0.47671273350715637,
-0.623308539390564,
-0.4042307138442993,
-0.6499221324920654,
-0.5235930681228638,
0.12871761620044708,
0.386015921831131,
-0.8665695786476135,
0.3068512976169586,
-0.5131468772888184,
-0.71910560131073,
-0.15596285462379456,
-0.12117072939872742,
-0.17295704782009125,
0.4959445297718048,
0.5217525959014893,
-0.47282007336616516,
-0.40228861570358276,
-1.0146644115447998,
0.0006617663893848658,
0.2903580963611603,
-0.06390190869569778,
0.2503053545951843,
0.7607674598693848,
-0.2046923041343689,
0.9533831477165222,
-0.6292230486869812,
-0.46005135774612427,
-0.18661931157112122,
-0.12360081821680069,
0.44451645016670227,
0.4143776297569275,
0.49240511655807495,
-0.8679766654968262,
-0.20136475563049316,
-0.007868586108088493,
-0.8939970135688782,
0.5896859169006348,
-0.16864793002605438,
-0.16749103367328644,
-0.2128833830356598,
0.16438226401805878,
-0.482389897108078,
0.7654517292976379,
0.6605334877967834,
-0.29539892077445984,
0.5260809063911438,
-0.35649314522743225,
0.23137898743152618,
-1.6071799993515015,
0.06409181654453278,
0.5623413324356079,
-0.10911273211240768,
-0.6398251056671143,
0.04066351428627968,
0.2578033208847046,
-0.3652738928794861,
-0.5308456420898438,
0.3610287606716156,
-0.3197143077850342,
-0.550543487071991,
0.04932546615600586,
-0.15848380327224731,
-0.09411130100488663,
0.7632992267608643,
-0.03191085904836655,
0.5890014171600342,
0.6333097815513611,
-0.5596423745155334,
0.5939210653305054,
0.3614945411682129,
-0.2363385111093521,
0.7464928030967712,
-0.5707433819770813,
-0.03336536884307861,
-0.02842961624264717,
0.19864974915981293,
-0.9768004417419434,
-0.23916307091712952,
0.03503158316016197,
-0.05520449951291084,
0.5081931352615356,
-0.26470765471458435,
-0.32164299488067627,
-0.7076930403709412,
-0.3349580466747284,
0.481252521276474,
0.4104668200016022,
-1.0755031108856201,
1.1884156465530396,
0.567267119884491,
-0.05817711353302002,
-0.2658523619174957,
-0.3458014130592346,
0.33534783124923706,
-0.1705736666917801,
-0.7583598494529724,
0.5923466086387634,
0.20896822214126587,
-0.08621037006378174,
0.10883666574954987,
-0.44038403034210205,
-0.06981301307678223,
-0.16718241572380066,
0.40336087346076965,
0.8882356286048889,
-0.1926720142364502,
-0.24472782015800476,
-0.024813737720251083,
-0.47088882327079773,
-0.31590911746025085,
-0.45888665318489075,
0.22244887053966522,
-0.6908789873123169,
-0.20234128832817078,
-0.6865613460540771,
0.15897846221923828,
0.6129387617111206,
-0.5273442268371582,
0.4724130928516388,
0.6673408150672913,
-0.5644640922546387,
0.0780094712972641,
-0.3932158052921295,
-0.13785013556480408,
-0.5622549653053284,
0.23610594868659973,
-0.43186625838279724,
-0.8850939273834229,
0.5708795785903931,
-0.324969083070755,
0.10879494994878769,
0.4618363380432129,
0.34133315086364746,
-0.5699345469474792,
1.0020408630371094,
0.35178765654563904,
-0.333578884601593,
0.5074731111526489,
-0.7529985904693604,
0.1773771494626999,
-1.0333243608474731,
-0.036989785730838776,
-0.3387635052204132,
-0.6448577642440796,
-0.44402429461479187,
-0.6230024099349976,
0.6247954964637756,
-0.2883417308330536,
-0.18593032658100128,
0.5588571429252625,
-0.33557942509651184,
0.25059881806373596,
0.46280381083488464,
0.19019444286823273,
0.03331200033426285,
0.41695091128349304,
-0.07843365520238876,
-0.39051324129104614,
-0.9209174513816833,
-0.44699734449386597,
0.9424490332603455,
0.5127235651016235,
1.0838682651519775,
-0.08055296540260315,
0.18226273357868195,
0.5410125255584717,
0.11160025000572205,
-0.5626122951507568,
0.3803774118423462,
-0.4346771836280823,
-0.49096617102622986,
-0.17504602670669556,
-0.468209445476532,
-0.9016280174255371,
0.536509096622467,
-0.30071401596069336,
-0.8857407569885254,
0.3065067231655121,
0.4268120527267456,
-0.4424411952495575,
1.02272367477417,
-0.1906948685646057,
0.6580087542533875,
-0.07811982929706573,
-0.7501510977745056,
-0.43871262669563293,
-0.6630748510360718,
0.12282832711935043,
0.22376082837581635,
0.024867376312613487,
-0.03007381409406662,
0.22756430506706238,
0.6963663697242737,
-0.11390980333089828,
0.9472988843917847,
0.011683521792292595,
0.013755504973232746,
0.29625648260116577,
0.2434648871421814,
0.46580326557159424,
-0.02403777837753296,
0.3277784287929535,
0.7859882712364197,
0.045471541583538055,
-0.46274498105049133,
-0.38022083044052124,
0.7171837091445923,
-0.597192645072937,
-0.3534644842147827,
-0.3984757959842682,
-0.5205198526382446,
0.13601315021514893,
0.014019893482327461,
0.12238752841949463,
0.748298704624176,
0.2206331491470337,
0.2320592999458313,
0.5708910226821899,
-0.12995682656764984,
0.28148117661476135,
0.21086011826992035,
0.17232364416122437,
-0.40070176124572754,
1.171357274055481,
0.15790413320064545,
-0.08796264231204987,
0.13126572966575623,
0.19259199500083923,
-0.16358345746994019,
-0.22299452126026154,
-0.6683365702629089,
0.13914529979228973,
-0.704832136631012,
-0.34473535418510437,
-0.11734168231487274,
-0.055595848709344864,
0.09047801792621613,
-0.26886171102523804,
-0.7803104519844055,
-0.5550853610038757,
-0.1273626983165741,
0.024937981739640236,
-0.003642671974375844,
0.7397364377975464,
0.009418556466698647,
0.48097744584083557,
-0.8848735690116882,
0.6059832572937012,
0.048795610666275024,
0.24797303974628448,
-0.17571456730365753,
-0.5676211714744568,
-0.2642002999782562,
-0.4447990357875824,
-0.5091333389282227,
-0.8765280246734619,
0.25473344326019287,
-0.2042098492383957,
0.699640154838562,
0.6362972855567932,
-0.31378763914108276,
0.609527587890625,
-0.25698408484458923,
0.8902047872543335,
0.37621819972991943,
-0.8414487838745117,
0.415485680103302,
-0.25388893485069275,
0.20608898997306824,
-0.022508792579174042,
0.25504860281944275,
-0.6965259909629822,
-0.526689350605011,
-0.6730974316596985,
-0.8334412574768066,
0.8812212347984314,
0.27056884765625,
-0.10835016518831253,
0.38671794533729553,
0.6136202216148376,
-0.05895454064011574,
0.14215561747550964,
-0.24822811782360077,
-0.3046371340751648,
-0.2757118046283722,
-0.3848493993282318,
-0.030483385547995567,
0.04285028576850891,
0.0704592764377594,
-0.4168737530708313,
0.4890387952327728,
-0.37912970781326294,
0.3554978668689728,
0.09821804612874985,
-0.2523249387741089,
-0.17005689442157745,
0.051150981336832047,
0.10692010819911957,
0.3626207411289215,
0.20762373507022858,
0.3161220848560333,
0.4380297362804413,
-0.36785608530044556,
0.13993044197559357,
-0.1591557115316391,
-0.1699860394001007,
-0.13709235191345215,
0.21681232750415802,
0.7408110499382019,
0.4987676441669464,
0.016220366582274437,
0.3886032998561859,
-0.02803392894566059,
-0.07497644424438477,
-0.29402220249176025,
0.2086675465106964,
0.014264536090195179,
0.5311599373817444,
0.47432297468185425,
0.7566319108009338,
0.14319396018981934,
-0.04086099565029144,
-0.09423868358135223,
0.18764890730381012,
-0.4287111461162567,
-0.7090215682983398,
0.8223004341125488,
0.13756966590881348,
0.037683017551898956,
0.6982337832450867,
0.22158662974834442,
-0.5704720616340637,
1.0281962156295776,
0.44582778215408325,
0.4937751293182373,
-0.47224146127700806,
0.10812827199697495,
0.6842207908630371,
0.3455461859703064,
-0.020102625712752342,
0.3444881737232208,
-0.19842873513698578,
-0.8313671350479126,
-0.15326297283172607,
-0.3924596309661865,
-0.3196534514427185,
0.04643208160996437,
-0.8475254774093628,
-0.08663588762283325,
-0.534140408039093,
-0.4732635021209717,
0.1451815664768219,
-0.4182775616645813,
-0.8531812429428101,
0.0023679009173065424,
0.1508106142282486,
1.2341032028198242,
-0.6386843919754028,
0.47066250443458557,
0.6872978210449219,
-0.16312243044376373,
-0.7058135867118835,
-0.4522767663002014,
0.08121420443058014,
-0.39442169666290283,
0.4840151071548462,
0.3016660511493683,
-0.16713495552539825,
0.12492519617080688,
-0.526813805103302,
-1.019263505935669,
1.3890180587768555,
0.05494774505496025,
-0.5258249640464783,
0.1590224653482437,
-0.0006837603868916631,
0.17390233278274536,
-0.30104851722717285,
0.14471493661403656,
0.6041951775550842,
0.4050201177597046,
0.09649810940027237,
-0.46968990564346313,
-0.058093126863241196,
-0.17196522653102875,
0.49842458963394165,
0.5078577399253845,
-0.842100977897644,
0.6305006742477417,
-0.6905751824378967,
-0.15297453105449677,
0.20294657349586487,
0.8258242011070251,
-0.0452253594994545,
0.07369451224803925,
0.7349603772163391,
0.5560802817344666,
0.6795719265937805,
-0.3935990035533905,
0.7669652700424194,
-0.13064658641815186,
0.40992477536201477,
0.7589874863624573,
-0.5073394775390625,
0.9007541537284851,
0.7852265238761902,
-0.3216516971588135,
0.29736268520355225,
0.6718681454658508,
-0.5822376608848572,
0.43662405014038086,
0.01461697742342949,
0.03812205791473389,
-0.32031819224357605,
0.19338077306747437,
0.03564782813191414,
0.3982316553592682,
0.4037964642047882,
-0.03955507278442383,
-0.1184873878955841,
0.29365670680999756,
-0.5603346824645996,
-0.305562287569046,
-0.3453913629055023,
0.32795220613479614,
0.013302027247846127,
-0.19649046659469604,
0.05872903764247894,
0.06473544239997864,
0.5205377340316772,
-0.6321291923522949,
-0.09711457788944244,
-0.2528128921985626,
0.30500200390815735,
-0.3394588530063629,
-0.6649499535560608,
0.31436872482299805,
-0.08961521089076996,
-0.026186468079686165,
0.11155690252780914,
0.9827666282653809,
0.08707122504711151,
-0.4558069705963135,
0.27315646409988403,
0.04242665693163872,
0.007774681784212589,
0.20624198019504547,
-0.39362743496894836,
-0.06155336648225784,
-0.4021884500980377,
-0.4928366541862488,
-0.20141717791557312,
-0.3046896755695343,
-0.312654972076416,
0.8502744436264038,
0.8428855538368225,
0.07279469817876816,
0.2209227830171585,
-0.059925127774477005,
0.8571399450302124,
-0.7953303456306458,
-0.7388991713523865,
-0.3702315390110016,
0.5933153033256531,
-0.27046576142311096,
-0.2800748646259308,
0.5760783553123474,
0.6164087653160095,
0.5662791132926941,
-0.09860769659280777,
0.5290436744689941,
0.07058031111955643,
0.1944420486688614,
-0.3663078248500824,
0.41882023215293884,
-0.7027076482772827,
0.1435137242078781,
0.016159866005182266,
-0.679289698600769,
-0.16755276918411255,
0.5270676612854004,
-0.3731003999710083,
-0.27649417519569397,
0.49233222007751465,
0.6440663933753967,
-0.5193990468978882,
0.31122174859046936,
0.34709179401397705,
0.2669059932231903,
0.1976233422756195,
0.3029407858848572,
1.4479331970214844,
-0.4916628897190094,
0.5772470235824585,
-0.2504378855228424,
-0.28234949707984924,
-0.10839303582906723,
-0.5863479375839233,
-0.7626922130584717,
-0.5755216479301453,
-0.3258786201477051,
-0.17930105328559875,
-0.3058626651763916,
0.6342572569847107,
1.0523468255996704,
-0.7715076804161072,
-0.20108070969581604,
0.36469078063964844,
-0.23741236329078674,
-0.23556073009967804,
-0.15768936276435852,
0.5069237947463989,
-0.13082760572433472,
-0.5350655317306519,
0.35753798484802246,
0.7586762309074402,
0.04625588655471802,
-0.2909460961818695,
-0.2410721629858017,
0.3257892429828644,
-0.097403883934021,
0.5292991995811462,
0.10384248197078705,
-0.5946705341339111,
-0.10707393288612366,
0.2234247326850891,
-0.06819911301136017,
0.3316575288772583,
0.9372884631156921,
-0.6469788551330566,
0.27214568853378296,
0.07632521539926529,
0.533605694770813,
1.0797040462493896,
-0.38330569863319397,
0.31270113587379456,
-0.6279485821723938,
0.07332877814769745,
-0.15296430885791779,
0.956120491027832,
0.24828489124774933,
-0.4021780788898468,
0.4095799922943115,
0.1850389540195465,
-0.23785436153411865,
-0.4660218060016632,
0.058512087911367416,
-0.9148183465003967,
-0.26577121019363403,
0.6620728969573975,
-0.09313745051622391,
-0.5671330094337463,
0.09406712651252747,
-0.32254719734191895,
0.23881854116916656,
-0.2291000485420227,
0.7651537656784058,
0.32618606090545654,
0.014342321082949638,
0.08993381261825562,
-0.551539957523346,
0.1498890519142151,
0.32589760422706604,
-0.8904783725738525,
-0.29924270510673523,
0.29573512077331543,
0.3859385550022125,
0.6565501689910889,
0.1437399983406067,
-0.21744489669799805,
0.5228830575942993,
-0.12487384676933289,
0.016065683215856552,
-0.07382097095251083,
-0.7230518460273743,
-0.5310451984405518,
0.17660360038280487,
-0.38487324118614197,
-0.41533127427101135
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18058v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18058v1
|
COIG-CQIA: Quality is All You Need for Chinese Instruction Fine-tuning
| 2024-03-26T19:24:18 | 2024-03-26T19:24:18 |
Yuelin Bai, Xinrun Du, Yiming Liang, Yonggang Jin, Ziqiang Liu, Junting Zhou, Tianyu Zheng, Xincheng Zhang, Nuo Ma, Zekun Wang, Ruibin Yuan, Haihong Wu, Hongquan Lin, Wenhao Huang, Jiajun Zhang, Wenhu Chen, Chenghua Lin, Jie Fu, Min Yang, Shiwen Ni, Ge Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recently, there have been significant advancements in large language models
(LLMs), particularly focused on the English language. These advancements have
enabled these LLMs to understand and execute complex instructions with
unprecedented accuracy and fluency. However, despite these advancements, there
remains a noticeable gap in the development of Chinese instruction tuning. The
unique linguistic features and cultural depth of the Chinese language pose
challenges for instruction tuning tasks. Existing datasets are either derived
from English-centric LLMs or are ill-suited for aligning with the interaction
patterns of real-world Chinese users. To bridge this gap, we introduce
COIG-CQIA, a high-quality Chinese instruction tuning dataset. Our aim is to
build a diverse, wide-ranging instruction-tuning dataset to better align model
behavior with human interactions. To this end, we collect a high-quality
human-written corpus from various sources on the Chinese Internet, including
Q&A communities, Wikis, examinations, and existing NLP datasets. This corpus
was rigorously filtered and carefully processed to form the COIG-CQIA dataset.
Furthermore, we train models of various scales on different subsets of CQIA,
following in-depth evaluation and analyses. The findings from our experiments
offer valuable insights for selecting and developing Chinese instruction-tuning
datasets. We also find that models trained on CQIA-Subset achieve competitive
results in human assessment as well as knowledge and security benchmarks. Data
are available at https://huggingface.co/datasets/m-a-p/COIG-CQIA
|
[
-0.07911257445812225,
-0.667163074016571,
0.030228182673454285,
0.08807678520679474,
-0.04110877588391304,
0.04180658236145973,
-0.20442640781402588,
-0.5348415374755859,
-0.14439743757247925,
0.274371862411499,
-0.4668457508087158,
-0.7391919493675232,
-0.24074937403202057,
-0.3743641674518585,
-0.2535749673843384,
0.6349344849586487,
0.21630321443080902,
0.381896048784256,
0.00916808471083641,
0.02991873025894165,
-0.5833272337913513,
-0.3786448836326599,
-0.9036048650741577,
-0.19459092617034912,
0.40968433022499084,
0.7045349478721619,
0.7515485882759094,
0.9834989905357361,
0.576919436454773,
0.1742958128452301,
0.17562344670295715,
0.5115877389907837,
-0.5769822001457214,
-0.40279093384742737,
-0.17984892427921295,
-0.33709096908569336,
-0.6231443881988525,
0.21411995589733124,
0.38695353269577026,
0.6540110111236572,
-0.2669569253921509,
0.33101412653923035,
0.27018603682518005,
0.48445937037467957,
-0.6450888514518738,
-0.11328492313623428,
-0.6247597336769104,
0.05953143164515495,
-0.1127571314573288,
-0.13909417390823364,
-0.3921714723110199,
-0.46894657611846924,
0.09489810466766357,
-0.8285526037216187,
0.2900834381580353,
0.23406711220741272,
1.3247848749160767,
0.2936766743659973,
-0.2816716134548187,
-0.2799001932144165,
-0.3815186023712158,
0.7951238751411438,
-0.7565457224845886,
0.5002362728118896,
0.27635428309440613,
0.08271748572587967,
-0.394425630569458,
-0.5561350584030151,
-0.33497780561447144,
-0.32624179124832153,
-0.11335337162017822,
0.2634104788303375,
0.3325113356113434,
0.3436804711818695,
0.13236497342586517,
0.4819595515727997,
-0.6922906041145325,
0.5981044173240662,
-0.29403480887413025,
-0.30394577980041504,
0.8013755083084106,
0.2807232737541199,
0.7542764544487,
0.22012600302696228,
-0.3868972063064575,
-0.3671298623085022,
-0.8788464665412903,
0.6314618587493896,
0.2696872353553772,
0.1821669340133667,
-0.24770593643188477,
0.1080784723162651,
-0.19301217794418335,
0.9244469404220581,
0.30746808648109436,
-0.14229236543178558,
-0.1232157051563263,
-0.29942503571510315,
-0.29520082473754883,
-0.04161057993769646,
0.726853609085083,
0.36028343439102173,
0.08328042924404144,
-0.21620824933052063,
-0.1219291165471077,
-0.23190148174762726,
0.14852161705493927,
-0.8379018306732178,
-0.5527637004852295,
0.30649590492248535,
-0.4480569064617157,
0.038631241768598557,
0.5189653038978577,
-0.5149751305580139,
-0.21447618305683136,
-0.5594745874404907,
0.3192395865917206,
-0.2948855757713318,
0.014408146031200886,
0.10636532306671143,
0.02924918569624424,
0.6704245805740356,
0.10935859382152557,
-1.2112212181091309,
0.04831857234239578,
0.9966517090797424,
0.55196613073349,
-0.3469633162021637,
-0.36804383993148804,
-0.6988593339920044,
0.051405854523181915,
-0.6603682637214661,
0.4699341654777527,
-0.6066534519195557,
-0.05692381039261818,
0.13758409023284912,
0.21423259377479553,
-0.14897572994232178,
-0.6665066480636597,
0.7097878456115723,
-0.481790155172348,
0.25138339400291443,
-0.35402747988700867,
-0.6787289381027222,
-0.21269994974136353,
0.2788621485233307,
-0.5812555551528931,
0.7855402231216431,
0.05278526246547699,
-0.3118295669555664,
0.3892349302768707,
-0.5186125636100769,
-0.5122235417366028,
0.0743969976902008,
-0.05934921279549599,
-0.5172398686408997,
-0.0424044206738472,
0.22894372045993805,
0.5189873576164246,
-0.25669553875923157,
0.34689053893089294,
-0.20692400634288788,
-0.7803531885147095,
0.008967162109911442,
-0.4524098336696625,
0.9202067852020264,
0.2596854269504547,
-0.1993396133184433,
0.007593728601932526,
-0.8120714426040649,
0.35446372628211975,
-0.1970931887626648,
-0.3455595076084137,
-0.3373394310474396,
0.07321026176214218,
-0.27173078060150146,
0.22938616573810577,
0.574401319026947,
-0.44729238748550415,
-0.03373654559254646,
-0.4690464437007904,
0.21084129810333252,
0.6992871761322021,
-0.05644960701465607,
0.306982159614563,
-0.2838493287563324,
0.3013836443424225,
0.09749659895896912,
0.5289884805679321,
-0.18165931105613708,
-0.2327449917793274,
-0.8405666351318359,
-0.06496841460466385,
0.29936185479164124,
0.6653170585632324,
-0.5917569398880005,
0.6568112373352051,
-0.011861220933496952,
-0.6512939929962158,
-0.7923087477684021,
0.20932377874851227,
0.5208702683448792,
0.25816529989242554,
0.3876676857471466,
-0.21301329135894775,
-0.1021234467625618,
-0.6105133295059204,
-0.2758077085018158,
-0.10385113209486008,
-0.4167121946811676,
0.2361985594034195,
-0.04940922185778618,
0.07312565296888351,
0.45559075474739075,
-0.41815972328186035,
-0.19584786891937256,
0.191655695438385,
-0.057773131877183914,
0.1203053891658783,
0.6149263978004456,
0.27039164304733276,
-0.5428218245506287,
-0.5492173433303833,
0.1429470181465149,
-0.5976930856704712,
-0.05077334865927696,
-0.5494465231895447,
-0.6070180535316467,
-0.09184771031141281,
0.40950825810432434,
-0.010586605407297611,
-0.077629953622818,
0.7864950299263,
-0.32434800267219543,
0.3406521677970886,
-0.20215825736522675,
0.3396277129650116,
-1.1242315769195557,
-0.014759582467377186,
0.0002884577843360603,
0.14799697697162628,
-0.6523890495300293,
0.5370423793792725,
0.20440061390399933,
-0.07714240252971649,
-0.47344550490379333,
0.3363127112388611,
-0.44431403279304504,
0.17325323820114136,
-0.04170889034867287,
0.17697906494140625,
0.15950338542461395,
0.7456997036933899,
-0.053142327815294266,
0.9488551616668701,
0.28544312715530396,
-0.7677125334739685,
0.3778700530529022,
0.14689752459526062,
-0.44308698177337646,
0.2817367911338806,
-0.8253945112228394,
0.22530227899551392,
0.5408955216407776,
-0.34948521852493286,
-0.6214708685874939,
-0.33870235085487366,
0.4293181896209717,
-0.17252999544143677,
0.3564637303352356,
0.16878868639469147,
-0.15667903423309326,
0.014577865600585938,
-0.2748942971229553,
0.06125104799866676,
0.3462599515914917,
-0.9174228310585022,
0.17370302975177765,
0.3558233082294464,
0.22293773293495178,
-0.6972057223320007,
-0.3548566997051239,
0.0471440888941288,
0.14442792534828186,
-0.6869019865989685,
0.5118640661239624,
-0.15691030025482178,
0.09195403009653091,
-0.23833736777305603,
0.00873093493282795,
-0.40970712900161743,
0.5546815395355225,
0.0766473338007927,
0.4151904284954071,
-0.3297588527202606,
0.1013912782073021,
0.32614579796791077,
0.22141069173812866,
0.1354236602783203,
-0.14632602035999298,
0.2620655596256256,
0.14632609486579895,
-0.5286797881126404,
-0.8240354657173157,
0.04803140088915825,
0.16837264597415924,
-0.37019798159599304,
0.5739802718162537,
0.6880547404289246,
-0.31837767362594604,
-0.2703031599521637,
-0.0866895541548729,
-0.1696256548166275,
-0.5172590613365173,
0.4446691870689392,
-0.11166149377822876,
-0.8349015712738037,
0.1961241513490677,
0.09560315310955048,
0.5079548358917236,
0.13285143673419952,
0.29367372393608093,
-0.2097516804933548,
0.9917249083518982,
0.5704400539398193,
-0.2657328248023987,
0.6807487607002258,
0.005342155694961548,
0.23199070990085602,
-0.6650699377059937,
-0.23544718325138092,
-0.47618263959884644,
-0.2840827703475952,
-0.8515904545783997,
-0.12116959691047668,
0.2814804017543793,
0.03572496399283409,
-0.3605138957500458,
0.13143327832221985,
-0.6256036162376404,
0.5962222218513489,
0.6679189801216125,
0.37273043394088745,
0.12696488201618195,
-0.11066605150699615,
0.36244797706604004,
0.21676701307296753,
-0.8804476857185364,
-0.527953565120697,
0.7012958526611328,
0.3724365532398224,
0.9013993740081787,
-0.06240048632025719,
0.5043910145759583,
0.1532081663608551,
0.060060467571020126,
-0.6348071694374084,
0.39950335025787354,
-0.7192819118499756,
-0.34720778465270996,
-0.4755406379699707,
-0.40608954429626465,
-1.033599853515625,
-0.045303825289011,
-0.22889067232608795,
-0.42748385667800903,
0.17627106606960297,
0.4075917601585388,
-0.7149268388748169,
0.05343392863869667,
-0.8443537354469299,
1.0669969320297241,
-0.5345474481582642,
-0.5873862504959106,
-0.13798323273658752,
-0.4128758907318115,
0.5938217639923096,
0.2675071954727173,
-0.20833741128444672,
-0.15906915068626404,
0.07916737347841263,
0.5973737835884094,
-0.2625058591365814,
0.8311352133750916,
-0.19670428335666656,
-0.5029540657997131,
0.45733267068862915,
-0.12217944115400314,
0.34651240706443787,
0.009908079169690609,
-0.004754910711199045,
0.33341875672340393,
0.2584153711795807,
-0.7332229614257812,
-0.5251900553703308,
0.6144636273384094,
-1.0548189878463745,
-0.7419785857200623,
-0.12319202721118927,
-0.3226986229419708,
-0.05042515695095062,
0.02263755537569523,
0.2622854709625244,
0.4300791621208191,
-0.5014191269874573,
0.10310368239879608,
0.8357939124107361,
-0.5099015235900879,
0.2225215882062912,
0.5210519433021545,
0.2968432307243347,
0.05960145220160484,
1.3970496654510498,
0.36484748125076294,
0.2868359088897705,
0.5248830318450928,
0.03422030061483383,
0.05945650488138199,
-0.5437999963760376,
-0.5826122760772705,
-0.09975335747003555,
-0.35641351342201233,
-0.1444157063961029,
-0.06627725064754486,
-0.481322705745697,
-0.2644633948802948,
-0.07196730375289917,
-0.19033828377723694,
0.019606931135058403,
-0.6226001977920532,
0.13700218498706818,
-0.12990736961364746,
0.39263468980789185,
0.11510898172855377,
0.33210960030555725,
-1.0466763973236084,
0.3232579231262207,
0.44388285279273987,
0.511965274810791,
0.04376722499728203,
-0.6826279759407043,
-0.8962857127189636,
0.4344709813594818,
-0.4216093420982361,
-0.38360345363616943,
0.2843568027019501,
0.6026785969734192,
0.4834987223148346,
0.5503354072570801,
0.1624017059803009,
0.7251821756362915,
-0.257591187953949,
1.1426074504852295,
-0.15291418135166168,
-0.9197022914886475,
0.31264016032218933,
-0.1607642024755478,
0.22177085280418396,
0.41880500316619873,
0.1965574473142624,
-0.8010057806968689,
-0.2755807638168335,
-0.1754687875509262,
-0.6062801480293274,
0.6101387739181519,
-0.3282744586467743,
0.20336291193962097,
0.2232493758201599,
0.5414958596229553,
0.07346551865339279,
-0.18055394291877747,
-0.2538317143917084,
0.014105800539255142,
-0.36225420236587524,
-0.460231751203537,
0.2786424160003662,
-0.08246822655200958,
-0.11262379586696625,
-0.128644660115242,
0.7879108786582947,
-0.3347952365875244,
0.005413542035967112,
-0.12879730761051178,
-0.059929609298706055,
-0.08557072281837463,
0.2239229679107666,
0.47162920236587524,
0.6562082171440125,
0.001044396311044693,
-0.25837573409080505,
0.25156262516975403,
-0.6218066811561584,
0.14667931199073792,
-0.2396768182516098,
-0.3083064556121826,
-0.26378586888313293,
0.4953913986682892,
0.6961520910263062,
0.012853788211941719,
-0.6788050532341003,
0.4314248561859131,
-0.26038676500320435,
0.15741756558418274,
-0.3126620352268219,
0.9086780548095703,
-0.12250225991010666,
0.0024291351437568665,
0.12935571372509003,
-0.24574030935764313,
0.19100698828697205,
-0.4295822083950043,
0.17362427711486816,
0.32584357261657715,
-0.3961816132068634,
-0.4564407169818878,
0.45980796217918396,
0.6061474680900574,
-0.20024217665195465,
0.9025761485099792,
-0.3247619569301605,
-0.25115302205085754,
0.8135281801223755,
0.2178070992231369,
0.8282012343406677,
-0.305846244096756,
0.29858532547950745,
0.6482864022254944,
0.389655739068985,
-0.12104012817144394,
0.2768487334251404,
0.1086912602186203,
-0.8404507637023926,
-0.4018692076206207,
-0.3467717170715332,
-0.8040364980697632,
0.12521420419216156,
-0.8754547238349915,
0.3841765224933624,
-0.6293296217918396,
0.3501230478286743,
-0.5081304311752319,
0.3259401023387909,
-0.5683766007423401,
0.5247687101364136,
0.21961426734924316,
0.9208043217658997,
-0.7101219892501831,
0.9220567941665649,
0.35934150218963623,
-0.2358148992061615,
-1.1098530292510986,
0.2152429074048996,
-0.3750855624675751,
-0.8126799464225769,
0.2611703872680664,
0.13585779070854187,
-0.11054891347885132,
-0.07117432355880737,
-1.0134369134902954,
-0.7046127319335938,
1.221319556236267,
0.4648478627204895,
-0.9902135729789734,
-0.08731931447982788,
0.23171046376228333,
0.7117169499397278,
-0.3176482319831848,
0.1348893791437149,
0.8152660131454468,
0.24537035822868347,
-0.2095451056957245,
-0.3904333710670471,
-0.04400899261236191,
-0.11430376023054123,
-0.2574627697467804,
-0.15918010473251343,
-1.3614670038223267,
0.6977474093437195,
-0.1339133381843567,
-0.5246078372001648,
0.08863179385662079,
0.8784365057945251,
0.09219846874475479,
0.4967047870159149,
0.2599371075630188,
0.25073951482772827,
1.0715558528900146,
-0.32109203934669495,
0.6930382251739502,
-0.6552978157997131,
-0.06515467166900635,
1.1314749717712402,
-0.014749589376151562,
0.8519641160964966,
-0.01825753226876259,
0.040331434458494186,
0.4515964090824127,
1.204525113105774,
-0.24055682122707367,
0.08776791393756866,
0.11393285542726517,
-0.027128195390105247,
-0.429389625787735,
-0.3705599009990692,
-0.20186978578567505,
0.5976351499557495,
0.347608357667923,
-0.06891000270843506,
0.3427409827709198,
-0.4547310769557953,
-0.06534220278263092,
0.2088228017091751,
-0.4134403467178345,
0.802923321723938,
-0.0034634307958185673,
-0.8049269318580627,
0.7124004364013672,
0.02111855521798134,
0.7258371710777283,
-0.4879625141620636,
-0.2103816717863083,
-0.4450518786907196,
-0.1723780333995819,
-0.3738539218902588,
-0.531326949596405,
0.04532627761363983,
-0.07275722920894623,
0.007843413390219212,
0.18154087662696838,
0.40982335805892944,
-0.868043065071106,
-0.19360460340976715,
0.16416019201278687,
0.2376488596200943,
0.08071709424257278,
0.29314926266670227,
-0.7059682011604309,
-0.142271488904953,
0.07117871195077896,
-0.06745866686105728,
0.3598300516605377,
0.42696312069892883,
-0.0024056502152234316,
0.47325533628463745,
0.620928168296814,
0.10360397398471832,
0.018043402582406998,
0.03315507248044014,
0.6024772524833679,
-0.659898579120636,
-0.30044785141944885,
-0.5822187066078186,
0.31199249625205994,
-0.0870313048362732,
-0.5238314867019653,
0.5053759217262268,
0.43715786933898926,
1.2229793071746826,
0.10565466433763504,
0.6226405501365662,
0.27062538266181946,
0.3450559973716736,
-0.7588307857513428,
0.8634912967681885,
-0.5492761135101318,
0.21256938576698303,
0.18568649888038635,
-0.5473694801330566,
-0.07367107272148132,
0.2721043527126312,
-0.013040411286056042,
-0.21542353928089142,
0.2706511616706848,
1.1786139011383057,
-0.05250699073076248,
-0.0922158882021904,
0.6669836044311523,
0.03505328670144081,
0.48685041069984436,
0.8638865351676941,
0.6794502139091492,
-0.6932033896446228,
0.4427621364593506,
-0.14967072010040283,
-0.12327215075492859,
-0.1869696080684662,
-0.6544597148895264,
-0.9229481816291809,
-0.3925100862979889,
-0.24759061634540558,
0.0025545847602188587,
0.18138034641742706,
1.2792975902557373,
0.6552771329879761,
-1.1363544464111328,
-0.4017910361289978,
0.26975151896476746,
0.32351794838905334,
-0.6630284190177917,
-0.1823926568031311,
0.5965463519096375,
-0.6401121616363525,
-0.9676368236541748,
0.3285386562347412,
0.05480300635099411,
-0.10356086492538452,
-0.31047290563583374,
-0.14341168105602264,
-0.0071146865375339985,
0.24246148765087128,
0.43460261821746826,
0.362072229385376,
-0.4557904005050659,
-0.6382282972335815,
0.33604952692985535,
-0.45091891288757324,
-0.003099856898188591,
0.5718426704406738,
-0.18822349607944489,
0.5323387384414673,
0.5571480393409729,
1.0141870975494385,
-0.3009948432445526,
0.04676177352666855,
0.745300829410553,
-0.6959766149520874,
-0.18581704795360565,
-0.10864913463592529,
0.0900520533323288,
0.35356834530830383,
-0.7294277548789978,
0.3965897560119629,
-0.08820954710245132,
-0.7256952524185181,
-0.46028342843055725,
-0.07185612618923187,
-0.6722655892372131,
-0.1422623246908188,
0.8403687477111816,
-0.5526251196861267,
-0.26536819338798523,
-0.061215922236442566,
-0.2676849067211151,
0.4834393262863159,
-0.38929635286331177,
1.3165422677993774,
0.7888209223747253,
-0.10404534637928009,
-0.2055429220199585,
-0.1590353548526764,
0.6522104144096375,
0.551936149597168,
-0.985858142375946,
0.1529158353805542,
0.37589070200920105,
-0.13003435730934143,
-0.13978320360183716,
-0.06704217940568924,
0.29917779564857483,
0.6969244480133057,
-0.1093410924077034,
0.14407679438591003,
-0.10003505647182465,
-0.35863766074180603,
-0.20193953812122345,
0.2388819456100464,
0.30046072602272034,
-0.46916404366493225
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18051v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18051v1
|
Supervisory Prompt Training
| 2024-03-26T19:08:20 | 2024-03-26T19:08:20 |
Jean Ghislain Billa, Min Oh, Liang Du
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The performance of Large Language Models (LLMs) relies heavily on the quality
of prompts, which are often manually engineered and task-specific, making them
costly and non-scalable. We propose a novel approach, Supervisory Prompt
Training (SPT). SPT automates the generation of highly effective prompts using
a dual LLM system. In this system, one LLM, the generator, performs a task
while the other, the corrector, provides feedback and generates improved
prompts. In contrast to earlier techniques, both the generator and corrector
collaboratively and continuously improve their prompts over time. We also
introduce the concept of \textit{impact scores} to measure the sentence-level
effectiveness of the prompts. Our method was tested on four benchmarks, testing
the level of hallucinations in LLMs. Notably, we were able to increase the
accuracy of GPT-4 on GSM8K from 65.8\% to 94.1\% (28.3\% increase). SPT
advances LLMs by refining prompts to enhance performance and reduce
hallucinations, offering an efficient and scalable alternative to traditional
model fine-tuning.
|
[
-0.24775636196136475,
-0.9043402075767517,
0.8912962079048157,
0.520034670829773,
-0.18886278569698334,
0.09091124683618546,
-0.4513900876045227,
-0.17775589227676392,
0.23942944407463074,
0.5004175305366516,
-0.8561037182807922,
-0.45013901591300964,
-0.6512375473976135,
0.32436317205429077,
-0.10683117806911469,
0.9915854930877686,
0.0547361895442009,
0.39576753973960876,
0.1364893913269043,
0.19497518241405487,
-0.8727120757102966,
-0.6639036536216736,
-1.0611416101455688,
-0.12318365275859833,
0.9045959711074829,
0.4146612584590912,
0.3767785131931305,
0.48605355620384216,
0.49686869978904724,
0.24080201983451843,
-0.03515217825770378,
0.4374297261238098,
-0.46352720260620117,
0.3627990186214447,
-0.11793626844882965,
-0.22637148201465607,
-0.2911655604839325,
0.08664284646511078,
0.5893000960350037,
0.4976292848587036,
-0.3749639391899109,
-0.030778277665376663,
0.17613554000854492,
0.367635577917099,
-0.31628483533859253,
0.27475324273109436,
-0.5331811904907227,
0.06919094175100327,
-0.0005689539830200374,
-0.4790984094142914,
-0.8469559550285339,
-0.5401706695556641,
-0.08134661614894867,
-0.3809497356414795,
0.26488932967185974,
0.03761199861764908,
0.5996356010437012,
0.4696405529975891,
-0.4716251790523529,
-0.27329832315444946,
-0.5108925104141235,
0.5055517554283142,
-0.43393564224243164,
0.20647405087947845,
0.15498857200145721,
0.5238223075866699,
-0.11173877120018005,
-0.5819181799888611,
-0.28338074684143066,
-0.6804099082946777,
-0.06844344735145569,
0.22716771066188812,
0.22427964210510254,
0.2602437734603882,
0.6612400412559509,
0.12202133238315582,
-0.4047192335128784,
0.29241934418678284,
-0.29548755288124084,
-0.09799586236476898,
0.6077576279640198,
0.5150144696235657,
0.2993150055408478,
-0.04217088967561722,
-0.38692349195480347,
-0.12079205363988876,
-0.5332305431365967,
0.06254704296588898,
0.3478127121925354,
0.6276624798774719,
0.24543039500713348,
0.2871747314929962,
-0.06261429935693741,
0.4619744122028351,
0.4915013611316681,
-0.12868013978004456,
-0.14513938128948212,
0.005724833346903324,
0.0023893180768936872,
0.29508480429649353,
0.7121512293815613,
0.41950616240501404,
0.060158923268318176,
-0.24680747091770172,
-0.46454668045043945,
0.3647722899913788,
0.5107889771461487,
-0.6372998356819153,
-0.15598322451114655,
-0.07874190807342529,
-0.1259669065475464,
-0.3812316060066223,
0.10345912724733353,
-0.6277234554290771,
-0.7671611905097961,
-0.6007076501846313,
0.5713251233100891,
-0.6010188460350037,
-0.030038340017199516,
-0.004107956774532795,
-0.05871468037366867,
0.14255425333976746,
0.5991681218147278,
-1.077659010887146,
0.06417414546012878,
0.6139992475509644,
0.9311632513999939,
-0.490213543176651,
-0.5852370858192444,
-0.9521458745002747,
0.09780240058898926,
-0.37319415807724,
0.9188737273216248,
-0.27885645627975464,
-0.4768315851688385,
-0.09295669943094254,
-0.002647103276103735,
-0.22733385860919952,
-0.610893964767456,
0.5411605834960938,
-0.23301202058792114,
0.182780459523201,
-0.3768310546875,
-0.3470916152000427,
0.0592813678085804,
0.019013231620192528,
-0.39075717329978943,
1.2814769744873047,
0.11247718334197998,
-0.4990401864051819,
0.49034935235977173,
-0.5987347364425659,
-0.41397520899772644,
0.07663841545581818,
-0.18270619213581085,
-0.10635395348072052,
0.12342315167188644,
0.4075363576412201,
0.6234987378120422,
-0.10798359662294388,
0.6939863562583923,
0.010117053985595703,
-0.5787777900695801,
0.020675472915172577,
-0.3916650116443634,
0.6707684993743896,
-0.019387396052479744,
-0.3671424686908722,
0.5266845226287842,
-0.8523491621017456,
-0.13214753568172455,
-0.03587677329778671,
-0.3765232264995575,
0.03977181762456894,
-0.3234052360057831,
-0.04809509590268135,
0.1392265409231186,
0.25231340527534485,
-0.3981485962867737,
0.19114379584789276,
-0.25927460193634033,
0.20385512709617615,
1.0982692241668701,
0.10260739177465439,
0.26053255796432495,
-0.40162187814712524,
0.5824657678604126,
-0.08231090754270554,
0.2339968979358673,
-0.32413536310195923,
-0.20128750801086426,
-0.8269011378288269,
-0.40280425548553467,
-0.32790616154670715,
0.7367928624153137,
-0.833935022354126,
0.6727590560913086,
0.12056361138820648,
-0.6576713919639587,
-0.3550768792629242,
-0.16016162931919098,
0.16552138328552246,
0.579444169998169,
0.3966972231864929,
-0.1284649521112442,
-0.5979394316673279,
-0.7325644493103027,
-0.38016313314437866,
-0.041178539395332336,
-0.08671925216913223,
0.03918531909584999,
0.24824906885623932,
-0.19520361721515656,
0.9072000980377197,
-0.3542274534702301,
-0.02302723005414009,
-0.4708782732486725,
0.13282248377799988,
0.39756110310554504,
0.38338547945022583,
0.19541387259960175,
-0.22217078506946564,
-0.6732197999954224,
-0.21122021973133087,
-0.8973456025123596,
-0.42780518531799316,
-0.29455065727233887,
0.09107085317373276,
0.17930611968040466,
0.44530096650123596,
-0.5629071593284607,
0.11142344027757645,
0.2213631421327591,
-0.37773072719573975,
0.8782015442848206,
-0.4088013768196106,
0.16023439168930054,
-1.0509272813796997,
-0.16727305948734283,
-0.07790923118591309,
-0.18853305280208588,
-0.7092552781105042,
-0.15481151640415192,
0.28535813093185425,
-0.2937588095664978,
-0.30026429891586304,
0.3707049489021301,
-0.4683939218521118,
0.10415618121623993,
-0.2839289903640747,
-0.007995065301656723,
-0.3301199972629547,
0.6071993708610535,
-0.06462883204221725,
1.0744751691818237,
0.7098605036735535,
-0.5883602499961853,
0.6865278482437134,
0.08420536667108536,
-0.26828405261039734,
0.921192467212677,
-0.5766096115112305,
0.2783205211162567,
-0.19994866847991943,
0.2970091998577118,
-0.8034762144088745,
-0.338806688785553,
0.1081063374876976,
-0.13776758313179016,
0.31008726358413696,
0.31357401609420776,
-0.5299954414367676,
-0.34962165355682373,
-0.25414228439331055,
-0.3816811144351959,
0.5339634418487549,
-0.8246329426765442,
0.5831525921821594,
-0.03230171278119087,
-0.3146180212497711,
-0.5075003504753113,
-0.3948609232902527,
0.35360613465309143,
-0.3750242292881012,
-0.5943475365638733,
-0.14943309128284454,
-0.020809950307011604,
-0.0899132788181305,
-0.5734628438949585,
-0.18090775609016418,
0.30276256799697876,
0.14177319407463074,
0.46533524990081787,
0.2603699266910553,
-0.05536867678165436,
0.11173802614212036,
0.12437352538108826,
-0.38741689920425415,
0.2002057433128357,
-0.1272871345281601,
0.581332802772522,
-0.10338176041841507,
-0.2983735203742981,
-0.960966169834137,
0.3538084030151367,
0.31835830211639404,
-0.026461495086550713,
0.7719278335571289,
0.5199360847473145,
-0.10342638194561005,
-0.6474578976631165,
-0.620424747467041,
-0.6407238841056824,
-0.5395985245704651,
0.2784814238548279,
-0.43118351697921753,
-0.8851262331008911,
0.35952049493789673,
-0.1694292426109314,
-0.06008371710777283,
0.18474839627742767,
0.4545460045337677,
-0.011023834347724915,
1.1019917726516724,
0.7783176898956299,
0.12055035680532455,
0.7885751724243164,
0.08787132054567337,
0.3064362406730652,
-0.5318026542663574,
-0.16137909889221191,
-0.23897022008895874,
-0.0020206060726195574,
-0.10972462594509125,
-0.19818222522735596,
0.4785872995853424,
0.03210392966866493,
-0.4355376362800598,
0.41623640060424805,
-0.6817457675933838,
0.5087882280349731,
0.7249758243560791,
0.27804893255233765,
0.27147287130355835,
-0.0983152762055397,
-0.14777521789073944,
-0.1030312031507492,
-0.5719584822654724,
-0.8519303202629089,
0.6728341579437256,
0.49707677960395813,
0.7751955389976501,
-0.32607173919677734,
0.7613175511360168,
0.2868363857269287,
0.23579318821430206,
-0.6964436173439026,
0.7696365118026733,
0.10942787677049637,
-0.2347153127193451,
-0.3913511037826538,
-0.48966506123542786,
-0.4423588812351227,
0.19235841929912567,
0.12841303646564484,
-0.656019926071167,
-0.0814887285232544,
0.0030733507592231035,
-0.6352869868278503,
0.21553470194339752,
-0.925481915473938,
0.8047316074371338,
-0.2751302123069763,
-0.12750303745269775,
-0.08813945204019547,
-0.6868036985397339,
0.11337602883577347,
-0.23040083050727844,
-0.2466285526752472,
-0.13116703927516937,
0.10984257608652115,
0.7756161689758301,
-0.3934510350227356,
1.0557348728179932,
-0.4647558033466339,
-0.3577842116355896,
0.10944049060344696,
-0.045180849730968475,
0.8671930432319641,
0.1607092320919037,
-0.11014152318239212,
-0.039002154022455215,
-0.10388930141925812,
-0.15127739310264587,
-0.7125833630561829,
0.45473727583885193,
-0.6453186869621277,
-0.7129343748092651,
-0.47163712978363037,
-0.760151743888855,
-0.4158790409564972,
0.021390331909060478,
0.34542882442474365,
0.33396297693252563,
-0.2339455634355545,
-0.2552904784679413,
0.7672102451324463,
-0.46978282928466797,
0.3041435480117798,
0.5502780675888062,
-0.04532374441623688,
-0.4788464307785034,
0.6292144060134888,
0.12075106799602509,
0.25968122482299805,
0.05589386820793152,
0.11430041491985321,
-0.2657628059387207,
-0.41653570532798767,
-0.4823862314224243,
0.21905790269374847,
-0.7834538221359253,
-0.05922685191035271,
-0.937264621257782,
-0.3101685345172882,
-0.4616561532020569,
-0.39895549416542053,
-0.120717853307724,
-0.1498211771249771,
-0.2666747570037842,
-0.4597909152507782,
0.588616132736206,
0.7490828633308411,
-0.17117518186569214,
0.8634850978851318,
-0.587981104850769,
0.08355613052845001,
0.48292824625968933,
0.2509116530418396,
-0.07193820923566818,
-0.6445974707603455,
-0.2527746260166168,
-0.20630447566509247,
-0.3040600121021271,
-0.8187418580055237,
0.3094973564147949,
-0.09874343127012253,
0.4823661148548126,
0.40786212682724,
0.028487857431173325,
0.5502875447273254,
-0.6022507548332214,
0.96370530128479,
0.34846213459968567,
-0.9802291989326477,
0.7856087684631348,
-0.5484251379966736,
0.09336778521537781,
0.5773869156837463,
0.134510800242424,
-0.8244180083274841,
-0.6610797047615051,
-0.43681278824806213,
-0.6648349761962891,
1.1733736991882324,
-0.22822019457817078,
0.08903244137763977,
-0.11908779293298721,
0.29857462644577026,
0.33474090695381165,
0.13982851803302765,
-0.5147205591201782,
-0.10020580887794495,
0.023986129090189934,
-0.3276200592517853,
-0.2603267431259155,
-0.4004805386066437,
-0.05232633277773857,
-0.19345469772815704,
0.7855640053749084,
-0.026939524337649345,
0.2752254903316498,
0.03220480680465698,
-0.06350800395011902,
-0.19014997780323029,
0.20110541582107544,
0.4782949984073639,
0.6894961595535278,
-0.16954179108142853,
0.2671305239200592,
0.5635310411453247,
-0.5322679281234741,
0.3200932741165161,
-0.05211731791496277,
-0.06867948174476624,
0.10578736662864685,
0.30996352434158325,
1.196658730506897,
-0.01989523507654667,
-0.5175221562385559,
0.3854250907897949,
-0.043763116002082825,
-0.05228679999709129,
-0.1763833910226822,
0.33525896072387695,
-0.1208232194185257,
0.41170868277549744,
0.29401513934135437,
-0.06234438717365265,
-0.1243700459599495,
-0.5233723521232605,
0.32920733094215393,
0.05436977744102478,
-0.4406775236129761,
-0.20934946835041046,
0.660366415977478,
0.164403036236763,
-0.48685139417648315,
0.4000965654850006,
-0.19939491152763367,
-0.5600500702857971,
0.6027738451957703,
0.7458551526069641,
0.9328444600105286,
-0.4698254466056824,
0.39334380626678467,
0.47168418765068054,
0.3348061144351959,
-0.6634973883628845,
0.3179587721824646,
0.015182683244347572,
-0.3573119640350342,
-0.36810582876205444,
-0.5474099516868591,
-0.6762843132019043,
-0.10733793675899506,
-0.6839373111724854,
0.5450829267501831,
-0.6058914065361023,
-0.12554475665092468,
-0.23732542991638184,
-0.028808733448386192,
-0.22838914394378662,
0.04617007449269295,
-0.00024150813987944275,
0.7985210418701172,
-0.8498032689094543,
0.7836213111877441,
0.6501482129096985,
-0.4576878547668457,
-1.0573506355285645,
-0.0957951471209526,
-0.10520349442958832,
-0.8512913584709167,
0.6103981733322144,
0.5097261071205139,
-0.004930459428578615,
0.18819235265254974,
-0.5199690461158752,
-0.5156779885292053,
1.0072665214538574,
0.41870832443237305,
-0.8079997897148132,
-0.14611956477165222,
0.009971125982701778,
0.630927562713623,
-0.22571276128292084,
0.3139652609825134,
0.6952045559883118,
0.4633287787437439,
-0.05736687779426575,
-1.0380005836486816,
0.24752123653888702,
0.10818313807249069,
0.12488911300897598,
0.2523718774318695,
-0.6425480842590332,
0.7615044116973877,
-0.1989573836326599,
-0.46946462988853455,
0.013268526643514633,
0.5701761245727539,
0.41082867980003357,
0.5179556012153625,
0.5175074934959412,
0.34752607345581055,
1.1307045221328735,
-0.19287489354610443,
0.8159831166267395,
-0.35091644525527954,
0.2816380262374878,
1.169373631477356,
-0.5030686855316162,
0.4226912260055542,
0.5469226837158203,
0.015907052904367447,
0.1825992465019226,
0.7372786402702332,
-0.1998828798532486,
0.48259562253952026,
0.279522180557251,
-0.3688543140888214,
-0.2862197458744049,
-0.16785207390785217,
-0.27777114510536194,
-0.15550976991653442,
0.20632347464561462,
-0.25905561447143555,
-0.26236313581466675,
0.5936116576194763,
0.006390145048499107,
0.20671892166137695,
-0.198726624250412,
0.8890222907066345,
0.3359620273113251,
-0.6301692128181458,
0.5654276013374329,
-0.12850157916545868,
0.8819042444229126,
-0.6926572918891907,
0.30249473452568054,
-0.389885276556015,
0.17798247933387756,
-0.10017170757055283,
-0.49433261156082153,
0.236813023686409,
0.3368401825428009,
-0.1256111115217209,
-0.7032546997070312,
0.4204282760620117,
-0.44903504848480225,
-0.28003984689712524,
0.2952837347984314,
0.45528489351272583,
0.2572003901004791,
-0.26560142636299133,
-0.34388598799705505,
-0.15574894845485687,
-0.2077140361070633,
-0.21680423617362976,
0.07711970061063766,
0.821932852268219,
-0.0183316208422184,
0.5373256802558899,
0.4734150171279907,
0.30812305212020874,
0.11418670415878296,
0.2820000648498535,
0.8306824564933777,
-0.8989640474319458,
-0.7353188991546631,
-0.9568551182746887,
0.24445994198322296,
-0.13362187147140503,
-0.38465943932533264,
0.961193859577179,
0.38568273186683655,
0.5073877573013306,
-0.198242649435997,
0.7467683553695679,
0.1597656011581421,
0.6327036023139954,
-0.49755388498306274,
0.708102822303772,
-0.1784875988960266,
0.26803484559059143,
-0.19224797189235687,
-1.0065938234329224,
-0.3248804807662964,
0.5562269687652588,
-0.539792537689209,
-0.09085603058338165,
1.016990065574646,
1.138388752937317,
0.1381571888923645,
0.14848485589027405,
0.4663920998573303,
0.15040406584739685,
0.3285731077194214,
0.5205470323562622,
1.5813802480697632,
-0.11672384291887283,
0.25267642736434937,
-0.25415104627609253,
-0.268966406583786,
-0.17434771358966827,
-0.5565881133079529,
-1.161098599433899,
-0.3540162444114685,
-0.1183278039097786,
-0.26980429887771606,
0.333440899848938,
1.2064419984817505,
0.4484739303588867,
-0.7567793726921082,
-0.22103993594646454,
-0.11726337671279907,
-0.24047857522964478,
-0.41088730096817017,
-0.21424873173236847,
0.43641936779022217,
-0.7670127153396606,
-0.5024325847625732,
0.6863386631011963,
0.43454939126968384,
0.003500380553305149,
-0.17363935708999634,
-0.0615837424993515,
0.15935425460338593,
0.08555707335472107,
0.6440877914428711,
-0.3728971481323242,
-0.61942058801651,
-0.3817300796508789,
0.040661536157131195,
-0.4273282289505005,
0.10059666633605957,
0.8833621740341187,
-0.5538250207901001,
0.16623923182487488,
0.31746143102645874,
0.6523681879043579,
0.17658980190753937,
0.022940324619412422,
0.5389021635055542,
-0.6759146451950073,
0.04113587364554405,
0.27155226469039917,
0.1510220766067505,
0.3332573473453522,
-0.8193637728691101,
0.4567735195159912,
0.2910255789756775,
-0.66134113073349,
-1.0198898315429688,
0.1225617453455925,
-1.0390377044677734,
-0.13987264037132263,
1.252956509590149,
0.009596167132258415,
-0.030081450939178467,
-0.044595569372177124,
-0.8307913541793823,
0.37190961837768555,
-0.7951613068580627,
1.0294804573059082,
0.7062856554985046,
-0.05363723635673523,
-0.2467738538980484,
-0.5638158917427063,
0.5768066048622131,
0.56732177734375,
-0.829460620880127,
0.17889609932899475,
0.5837923884391785,
0.15217210352420807,
-0.04615416005253792,
0.6643776297569275,
0.2196398675441742,
0.20052498579025269,
0.05893031507730484,
0.11765290051698685,
-0.21437814831733704,
-0.5753106474876404,
-0.7643666863441467,
0.17365983128547668,
-0.03526169806718826,
0.0226824339479208
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18031v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18031v1
|
The Impact of Syntactic and Semantic Proximity on Machine Translation with Back-Translation
| 2024-03-26T18:38:14 | 2024-03-26T18:38:14 |
Nicolas Guerin, Shane Steinert-Threlkeld, Emmanuel Chemla
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Unsupervised on-the-fly back-translation, in conjunction with multilingual
pretraining, is the dominant method for unsupervised neural machine
translation. Theoretically, however, the method should not work in general. We
therefore conduct controlled experiments with artificial languages to determine
what properties of languages make back-translation an effective training
method, covering lexical, syntactic, and semantic properties. We find, contrary
to popular belief, that (i) parallel word frequency distributions, (ii)
partially shared vocabulary, and (iii) similar syntactic structure across
languages are not sufficient to explain the success of back-translation. We
show however that even crude semantic signal (similar lexical fields across
languages) does improve alignment of two languages through back-translation. We
conjecture that rich semantic dependencies, parallel across languages, are at
the root of the success of unsupervised methods based on back-translation.
Overall, the success of unsupervised machine translation was far from being
analytically guaranteed. Instead, it is another proof that languages of the
world share deep similarities, and we hope to show how to identify which of
these similarities can serve the development of unsupervised, cross-linguistic
tools.
|
[
-0.3691193759441376,
-0.20419953763484955,
0.6612192988395691,
0.3860081434249878,
-0.14265020191669464,
0.16838547587394714,
-0.5913235545158386,
-0.5391246676445007,
0.3737987279891968,
0.34392356872558594,
-0.39477625489234924,
-0.47546079754829407,
-0.6717851758003235,
0.21628685295581818,
-0.6671222448348999,
1.0475142002105713,
-0.09423720091581345,
0.09459616243839264,
-0.1793111264705658,
-0.5121819376945496,
-0.16935843229293823,
-0.8825687170028687,
0.10618554800748825,
-0.38555780053138733,
0.6010887622833252,
0.03662547469139099,
1.0534600019454956,
0.533765435218811,
0.5324647426605225,
0.34145861864089966,
0.058287233114242554,
-0.16404467821121216,
-0.11905393749475479,
-0.016565168276429176,
-0.3665643036365509,
-0.6502755284309387,
-0.043310534209012985,
0.002303048502653837,
0.9160096049308777,
1.220259666442871,
0.1691320538520813,
-0.1050347164273262,
0.13325543701648712,
0.6216000318527222,
-0.5017237663269043,
-0.13948069512844086,
-0.5779059529304504,
0.24159377813339233,
-0.34826362133026123,
-0.10123185068368912,
-0.16261781752109528,
-0.10991232842206955,
0.11663462221622467,
-0.5653520822525024,
0.25535082817077637,
0.06626155227422714,
0.7879152894020081,
0.4733651280403137,
-0.4678628146648407,
-0.09330911189317703,
-0.8317680358886719,
0.8687337040901184,
-0.4713735580444336,
0.6311945915222168,
0.17943909764289856,
0.20243936777114868,
-0.34304165840148926,
-0.4981664717197418,
-0.6809658408164978,
-0.09359289705753326,
-0.3098508417606354,
0.28683847188949585,
-0.009996667504310608,
0.005440776702016592,
0.2348410040140152,
0.41234081983566284,
-0.5055848956108093,
0.2508441209793091,
-0.22966963052749634,
-0.1803617626428604,
0.33234933018684387,
-0.0341816246509552,
0.43936485052108765,
0.08726229518651962,
-0.3862147331237793,
-0.2516847252845764,
-0.6407656073570251,
-0.14827685058116913,
0.4346004128456116,
0.29627928137779236,
-0.04270752891898155,
0.7474819421768188,
-0.2798555791378021,
0.5300620794296265,
-0.27012789249420166,
0.1036248505115509,
0.4463213086128235,
-0.8302633166313171,
0.18804749846458435,
0.19937647879123688,
0.8371317982673645,
0.3223033547401428,
0.41301754117012024,
-0.6886395812034607,
-0.2054298222064972,
0.23365487158298492,
0.1565517783164978,
-0.4420103132724762,
0.02619488351047039,
0.014577420428395271,
-0.46019992232322693,
-0.09517888724803925,
0.048892538994550705,
-0.38714611530303955,
0.11580643057823181,
-0.09793476015329361,
0.40906858444213867,
-0.19613994657993317,
-0.18366532027721405,
-0.026352498680353165,
-0.20089249312877655,
0.2929878234863281,
0.009056785143911839,
-0.9125149846076965,
0.5360135436058044,
0.6627525091171265,
0.8193677067756653,
-0.3522569537162781,
-0.9180282950401306,
-0.2722697854042053,
0.2551387846469879,
-0.44807514548301697,
0.7148213982582092,
-0.3331899344921112,
-0.047358158975839615,
-0.06995229423046112,
0.08556203544139862,
-0.1646011620759964,
-0.5040299892425537,
-0.11961725354194641,
-0.5067566633224487,
0.24420663714408875,
-0.20011359453201294,
-0.38065171241760254,
-0.22205454111099243,
-0.01012383308261633,
-0.45446446537971497,
0.5782594084739685,
-0.1539923995733261,
-0.7157745361328125,
0.521947979927063,
-0.2925426661968231,
-0.8960566520690918,
-0.3298504948616028,
-0.2890835702419281,
-0.3170630633831024,
0.417718768119812,
0.032582949846982956,
0.22270305454730988,
-0.14979588985443115,
0.06564214080572128,
-0.2253410369157791,
-0.44311094284057617,
0.40789327025413513,
-0.2742989957332611,
0.6536449790000916,
0.15046167373657227,
-0.40954968333244324,
-0.02517596259713173,
-0.46697771549224854,
0.06447960436344147,
0.09704458713531494,
-0.18134520947933197,
-0.5330089330673218,
-0.19157825410366058,
-0.06756073236465454,
0.4215382933616638,
0.34160467982292175,
-0.667509913444519,
0.005055524408817291,
-0.8971541523933411,
0.25829172134399414,
0.2131979763507843,
-0.29967397451400757,
0.6559655666351318,
0.048970092087984085,
0.35002434253692627,
0.07365404814481735,
-0.1909591555595398,
-0.008179361931979656,
-0.423025906085968,
-0.46524307131767273,
-0.04633261263370514,
0.4040217995643616,
0.5942683219909668,
-0.43387195467948914,
0.44503945112228394,
-0.23880144953727722,
-0.16591373085975647,
-0.624284565448761,
0.22464916110038757,
0.8694950342178345,
0.23578400909900665,
0.38066646456718445,
-0.6841254830360413,
-0.2972511649131775,
-0.9443964958190918,
-0.5904961228370667,
0.2294011265039444,
0.1383185237646103,
-0.1784212738275528,
0.41870808601379395,
-0.08434895426034927,
0.5971415042877197,
-0.2536959946155548,
-0.2948606014251709,
-0.0994226336479187,
-0.013483435846865177,
0.08508006483316422,
0.4552040994167328,
0.6025022268295288,
-0.7088091969490051,
-0.3588978350162506,
0.3635389804840088,
-0.8581514954566956,
0.08067009598016739,
0.13124096393585205,
-0.07408744096755981,
0.284580260515213,
0.4358067810535431,
-0.7516460418701172,
0.5950645208358765,
0.6890992522239685,
0.07764855027198792,
0.117774099111557,
-0.48474860191345215,
0.10221400111913681,
-1.1398897171020508,
0.2619408369064331,
-0.5050008893013,
0.03340364992618561,
-0.4730432629585266,
0.23387819528579712,
-0.1116098165512085,
-0.22191204130649567,
-0.37733280658721924,
0.38659796118736267,
-0.36185741424560547,
-0.8146018981933594,
-0.42531052231788635,
0.25238412618637085,
-0.12213650345802307,
0.48494288325309753,
0.2420882284641266,
0.6865577101707458,
0.16215428709983826,
-0.40241539478302,
0.43053412437438965,
0.27791664004325867,
-0.10398275405168533,
0.36402058601379395,
-0.6344864368438721,
0.17483170330524445,
0.1346733421087265,
0.16294892132282257,
-0.8524760007858276,
-0.12832272052764893,
0.15073774755001068,
-0.7936278581619263,
0.2465885728597641,
0.13588449358940125,
-0.6948559284210205,
-0.09821190685033798,
0.03707556053996086,
0.4703935980796814,
0.47042739391326904,
-0.5174227952957153,
0.267255574464798,
0.189540833234787,
0.1529977023601532,
-0.5412704348564148,
-1.0842938423156738,
0.10778604447841644,
-0.11600156128406525,
-0.5851717591285706,
0.29043665528297424,
0.32101893424987793,
-0.331844300031662,
0.11492753773927689,
-0.23995038866996765,
-0.1085582822561264,
0.18195651471614838,
0.24337133765220642,
-0.21057561039924622,
-0.29069003462791443,
0.10981737822294235,
0.06189591437578201,
-0.3125382363796234,
-0.017597122117877007,
-0.8729095458984375,
0.3660163879394531,
-0.16282625496387482,
-0.47713249921798706,
-0.2764796018600464,
0.5633400082588196,
0.4764821231365204,
-0.4136320948600769,
0.9944004416465759,
0.5706798434257507,
-0.2781006395816803,
0.08918501436710358,
-0.2819328308105469,
-0.27416175603866577,
-0.41449180245399475,
0.44652751088142395,
-0.568695068359375,
-0.5866350531578064,
0.5378406643867493,
-0.07065309584140778,
-0.0696064680814743,
0.4052167534828186,
0.6164124011993408,
-0.15191280841827393,
0.9653843641281128,
0.7348165512084961,
-0.012954387813806534,
0.29565662145614624,
-0.021255865693092346,
0.13863998651504517,
-0.4747854471206665,
-0.18794381618499756,
-0.8323149681091309,
-0.3727858066558838,
-0.8237626552581787,
0.007271731738001108,
0.09829716384410858,
0.03345366567373276,
0.10633382201194763,
0.6485841870307922,
-0.2785768508911133,
0.28045040369033813,
0.7789643406867981,
-0.15806864202022552,
0.36035895347595215,
0.2318878173828125,
-0.3146423101425171,
-0.2362459897994995,
-0.7080440521240234,
-0.1353229135274887,
0.8105223178863525,
0.0037714543286710978,
0.6034703254699707,
-0.031140316277742386,
0.9660837054252625,
-0.22803856432437897,
-0.08634878695011139,
-0.6194959282875061,
0.2217945009469986,
-0.41487929224967957,
-0.38208332657814026,
-0.21881942451000214,
-0.32549580931663513,
-1.1414198875427246,
0.26291096210479736,
-0.07387403398752213,
-0.44086024165153503,
-0.09453092515468597,
0.048470593988895416,
-0.05183328688144684,
0.12999847531318665,
-0.7736707925796509,
1.1646113395690918,
-0.4451846778392792,
-0.026291489601135254,
-0.4063858985900879,
-1.1409178972244263,
-0.11314846575260162,
-0.3533060550689697,
0.20916584134101868,
0.4081270098686218,
-0.1027594655752182,
0.647390604019165,
-0.5666434168815613,
0.7486845850944519,
0.2500358819961548,
-0.1431524157524109,
-0.019159717485308647,
0.014279572293162346,
0.244877427816391,
-0.4402017593383789,
0.4086478650569916,
0.4827883243560791,
0.08712683618068695,
-0.588707447052002,
-0.9797548651695251,
0.7367448806762695,
-0.8524551391601562,
-0.5851694941520691,
-0.3960261642932892,
-0.7855947017669678,
-0.22531650960445404,
0.5352911949157715,
0.48310109972953796,
0.0298423171043396,
0.13246043026447296,
0.1727602332830429,
0.34027135372161865,
-0.18859541416168213,
0.2632557451725006,
0.5042595863342285,
-0.3265218436717987,
-0.31761929392814636,
1.0855692625045776,
0.14198262989521027,
0.5048828125,
0.6696057319641113,
0.2563549876213074,
-0.3270743787288666,
-0.5701307654380798,
-0.40359777212142944,
0.21734552085399628,
-0.6306766867637634,
0.2822266221046448,
-0.7205528020858765,
-0.11529821902513504,
-0.4801905155181885,
-0.1906658560037613,
-0.6682666540145874,
-0.7156696915626526,
0.1973416954278946,
0.09856656938791275,
0.23175813257694244,
0.7305744886398315,
-0.1285848617553711,
0.26509860157966614,
-0.9540327191352844,
0.16236455738544464,
-0.016360076144337654,
0.02676829695701599,
-0.2737109363079071,
-0.44812390208244324,
-0.39730146527290344,
-0.021657859906554222,
0.07980576157569885,
-0.7567288279533386,
0.2022642195224762,
0.13339033722877502,
0.5861631631851196,
-0.06459452956914902,
-0.12918299436569214,
0.49776768684387207,
-0.4792078733444214,
0.45439139008522034,
0.27868226170539856,
-0.7766460180282593,
0.42702001333236694,
-0.2594279646873474,
0.3501255214214325,
0.5337722301483154,
0.4274521768093109,
-0.47790488600730896,
-0.717981219291687,
-0.5717544555664062,
-0.7184534072875977,
0.4292503893375397,
0.2560144066810608,
0.08364947885274887,
0.03969807177782059,
0.09668821096420288,
0.15832822024822235,
0.4878983795642853,
-0.4584622383117676,
-0.1654418408870697,
-0.31093457341194153,
-0.1923820525407791,
-0.3719099164009094,
0.41261404752731323,
0.010859315283596516,
-0.019100861623883247,
0.10480612516403198,
-0.03594911843538284,
0.11691739410161972,
0.04144938662648201,
-0.19931258261203766,
-0.12026519328355789,
0.19316841661930084,
0.5636379718780518,
0.3326018750667572,
0.09988605976104736,
0.3392483592033386,
0.24574360251426697,
-0.429324746131897,
0.15067100524902344,
0.20501284301280975,
-0.3022805154323578,
0.1245836392045021,
0.4594586193561554,
0.49788999557495117,
0.3099364936351776,
-0.2933432459831238,
0.49388641119003296,
0.23975872993469238,
0.19207879900932312,
-0.23331649601459503,
-0.3219669461250305,
0.06236906349658966,
0.2419011890888214,
-0.041420549154281616,
0.34555840492248535,
-0.04188275337219238,
-0.7066270112991333,
0.31558433175086975,
0.5339049100875854,
-0.35841357707977295,
-0.5857282876968384,
0.5297054648399353,
0.11002206802368164,
-0.3064621090888977,
0.5290876030921936,
-0.002394789829850197,
-0.8881077170372009,
0.581774115562439,
0.6409629583358765,
0.6690744757652283,
-0.15284651517868042,
-0.31636181473731995,
-0.011825026012957096,
0.473822683095932,
-0.11722999066114426,
-0.029576018452644348,
-0.215982586145401,
-0.7079036831855774,
-0.5175395607948303,
-0.6051225662231445,
-0.18495015799999237,
-0.3223247528076172,
-0.6321015954017639,
0.11127637326717377,
-0.18731345236301422,
0.06800540536642075,
-0.0443665087223053,
-0.06190904974937439,
-0.6369197368621826,
0.12178803980350494,
-0.061750538647174835,
0.5515190958976746,
-0.7996096611022949,
1.0829997062683105,
0.9117125272750854,
-0.6568867564201355,
-0.7074999213218689,
0.25117364525794983,
-0.1305406093597412,
-0.8755707144737244,
0.9785319566726685,
0.08861110359430313,
-0.2885323166847229,
0.14274197816848755,
-0.19603359699249268,
-0.9405738711357117,
0.7256633639335632,
0.3600093126296997,
-0.4477788507938385,
-0.12166296690702438,
0.3448546826839447,
0.7806403040885925,
-0.1577979028224945,
-0.20778802037239075,
0.48159801959991455,
0.2902033030986786,
-0.0988234356045723,
-1.3505762815475464,
0.13646343350410461,
0.037006162106990814,
0.11873112618923187,
0.43492910265922546,
-0.6314746737480164,
0.43669483065605164,
-0.322544127702713,
-0.1616276651620865,
0.2613486647605896,
0.8245146870613098,
-0.2235211879014969,
0.3219466805458069,
0.09295278787612915,
0.7312779426574707,
0.26227104663848877,
0.019915349781513214,
1.1249825954437256,
-0.40030810236930847,
0.23087647557258606,
1.0139974355697632,
-0.2933926284313202,
0.7274934649467468,
0.7931436896324158,
-0.06451063603162766,
0.2294320911169052,
0.23646382987499237,
-0.11380111426115036,
0.7882416844367981,
0.15944133698940277,
-0.0008407080313190818,
-0.10995074361562729,
-0.3382396101951599,
-0.5927807688713074,
0.47544246912002563,
0.2198149710893631,
-0.5124471783638,
-0.34300342202186584,
0.23226752877235413,
-0.03916674852371216,
0.49291741847991943,
-0.022412659600377083,
0.592427134513855,
0.4349542558193207,
-0.8164369463920593,
0.5461035370826721,
-0.09486663341522217,
0.5704560279846191,
-0.4264931082725525,
0.039603788405656815,
-0.16346238553524017,
0.4761390686035156,
-0.2618558704853058,
-0.9033360481262207,
0.7175804972648621,
-0.26574668288230896,
0.00733408285304904,
-0.19092610478401184,
0.6580944657325745,
-0.5037774443626404,
0.010409451089799404,
0.659672200679779,
0.5758600234985352,
0.5547243356704712,
-0.0812617763876915,
-0.36612653732299805,
0.053823504596948624,
-0.3449614942073822,
-0.005992202088236809,
0.6059253215789795,
0.5857114791870117,
-0.12931384146213531,
0.35136571526527405,
0.6260046362876892,
0.220180481672287,
0.20397885143756866,
0.0003921889583580196,
0.6831550002098083,
-0.8050137758255005,
-0.4851653277873993,
-0.6892067790031433,
-0.081499844789505,
0.2779797613620758,
-0.3248913586139679,
1.0712040662765503,
0.4669046998023987,
1.4700021743774414,
0.03566058352589607,
0.626538097858429,
0.26428189873695374,
0.15690389275550842,
-0.5464489459991455,
0.670594334602356,
-0.6524834632873535,
-0.1799795925617218,
-0.2914428412914276,
-1.1271451711654663,
-0.46632587909698486,
0.4562273919582367,
-0.39700978994369507,
0.10931940376758575,
1.0291168689727783,
0.6423770189285278,
-0.013036735355854034,
-0.15509094297885895,
0.552039623260498,
0.05636650323867798,
-0.21044740080833435,
0.6732603311538696,
1.0198400020599365,
-0.3995153307914734,
0.8084813952445984,
-0.34320709109306335,
-0.06474464386701584,
0.10936532914638519,
-0.5472971796989441,
-0.9969736337661743,
-0.4335039556026459,
-0.07380184531211853,
-0.6295009255409241,
0.3335704207420349,
0.728337287902832,
0.4671325087547302,
-0.7912741899490356,
-0.19252629578113556,
-0.3066573739051819,
-0.01654202677309513,
-0.3394671082496643,
-0.06564128398895264,
0.23605352640151978,
-0.3795332908630371,
-0.5957615375518799,
0.4389607906341553,
0.3464755117893219,
0.09714702516794205,
-0.2058221399784088,
-0.1634395718574524,
-0.034916289150714874,
-0.4212428033351898,
0.3042977750301361,
0.5629072189331055,
-0.8696430325508118,
-0.28989771008491516,
0.16913144290447235,
-0.45780953764915466,
-0.07213900983333588,
0.829339861869812,
-0.6030881404876709,
0.2264825403690338,
0.5162538886070251,
0.895125687122345,
0.39131754636764526,
-0.12930548191070557,
0.7866688370704651,
-0.8325104713439941,
0.5818919539451599,
-0.12940333783626556,
0.22572791576385498,
0.2593958377838135,
-0.31589072942733765,
0.37595707178115845,
0.6288143992424011,
-0.38315486907958984,
-0.4972444176673889,
0.43027472496032715,
-0.48361536860466003,
-0.25319671630859375,
0.9949101805686951,
-0.36037376523017883,
-0.42105555534362793,
-0.170000821352005,
0.19268886744976044,
0.49382930994033813,
-0.045921117067337036,
0.5875247120857239,
0.6668072938919067,
0.046743422746658325,
0.21800994873046875,
-0.4124787449836731,
0.314134418964386,
0.8740652799606323,
-0.41922926902770996,
-0.20217284560203552,
0.19299280643463135,
0.21871677041053772,
0.5602086782455444,
0.2767680585384369,
-0.2726554870605469,
0.26521262526512146,
0.22737540304660797,
0.0702017992734909,
0.12968501448631287,
-0.5145812034606934,
-0.5235196948051453,
-0.19302673637866974,
0.11652123183012009,
-0.4528543949127197
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18025v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18025v2
|
Improving Pre-trained Language Model Sensitivity via Mask Specific losses: A case study on Biomedical NER
| 2024-03-26T18:23:16 | 2024-03-28T11:01:21 |
Micheal Abaho, Danushka Bollegala, Gary Leeming, Dan Joyce, Iain E Buchan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Adapting language models (LMs) to novel domains is often achieved through
fine-tuning a pre-trained LM (PLM) on domain-specific data. Fine-tuning
introduces new knowledge into an LM, enabling it to comprehend and efficiently
perform a target domain task. Fine-tuning can however be inadvertently
insensitive if it ignores the wide array of disparities (e.g in word meaning)
between source and target domains. For instance, words such as chronic and
pressure may be treated lightly in social conversations, however, clinically,
these words are usually an expression of concern. To address insensitive
fine-tuning, we propose Mask Specific Language Modeling (MSLM), an approach
that efficiently acquires target domain knowledge by appropriately weighting
the importance of domain-specific terms (DS-terms) during fine-tuning. MSLM
jointly masks DS-terms and generic words, then learns mask-specific losses by
ensuring LMs incur larger penalties for inaccurately predicting DS-terms
compared to generic words. Results of our analysis show that MSLM improves LMs
sensitivity and detection of DS-terms. We empirically show that an optimal
masking rate not only depends on the LM, but also on the dataset and the length
of sequences. Our proposed masking strategy outperforms advanced masking
strategies such as span- and PMI-based masking.
|
[
-0.39187005162239075,
-0.7529350519180298,
0.3209857642650604,
-0.04826265946030617,
-0.30411049723625183,
0.21360133588314056,
-0.26478517055511475,
-0.3328155279159546,
0.11013280600309372,
0.7637813091278076,
-0.46616730093955994,
-0.5176032781600952,
-0.7910774946212769,
-0.022779040038585663,
-0.03390725702047348,
1.0535048246383667,
-0.06122709810733795,
0.1988832950592041,
-0.2844100892543793,
-0.25149640440940857,
-0.6199206113815308,
-0.7683568000793457,
-0.743098795413971,
-0.3995661735534668,
0.5821747779846191,
0.16466428339481354,
0.315920889377594,
0.5666078925132751,
0.6307428479194641,
0.16895630955696106,
-0.1849711388349533,
0.2934011220932007,
-0.5202213525772095,
-0.06140894070267677,
-0.22383366525173187,
-0.2337944656610489,
-0.45251384377479553,
-0.21412606537342072,
0.5927972197532654,
1.047748327255249,
-0.19940190017223358,
0.18182677030563354,
0.2514048218727112,
0.7161977291107178,
-0.7763354182243347,
-0.2102280706167221,
-0.8758262991905212,
0.19565771520137787,
-0.3510732054710388,
-0.3271850347518921,
-0.5202065706253052,
0.1249791607260704,
0.13408882915973663,
-0.4806135892868042,
0.40667924284935,
0.039077769964933395,
0.9978895783424377,
0.49265849590301514,
-0.2377907782793045,
0.02593029849231243,
-0.6215652823448181,
0.6870435476303101,
-0.7866915464401245,
0.37589845061302185,
0.674759030342102,
0.21503816545009613,
0.014126447029411793,
-0.5921164751052856,
-0.25342443585395813,
-0.03691967576742172,
-0.22849105298519135,
-0.003568743821233511,
-0.38393306732177734,
0.4042362868785858,
0.3179549276828766,
0.08356435596942902,
-0.6176900863647461,
0.16490499675273895,
-0.4319273829460144,
-0.5827519297599792,
0.39703091979026794,
0.2949386537075043,
0.10289499908685684,
0.2729544937610626,
-0.1840861439704895,
0.26971930265426636,
-0.9011087417602539,
-0.1177624762058258,
0.17864924669265747,
0.4924872815608978,
0.18434767425060272,
0.3022226393222809,
-0.25690725445747375,
0.986627459526062,
0.1633109599351883,
-0.05007040873169899,
0.14501133561134338,
-0.09323127567768097,
-0.3058798909187317,
-0.025264887139201164,
0.2593540549278259,
0.2430369108915329,
0.22951430082321167,
-0.15739883482456207,
-0.2300075888633728,
0.21687988936901093,
0.3241608738899231,
-0.9289557933807373,
-0.24078179895877838,
-0.11946012824773788,
-0.5338062047958374,
-0.16079914569854736,
-0.2967008352279663,
-0.4593028426170349,
-0.5969382524490356,
-0.4260950982570648,
0.8235931992530823,
-0.23643611371517181,
-0.13674123585224152,
0.5838309526443481,
0.22269834578037262,
0.022334489971399307,
0.22887296974658966,
-0.5987225770950317,
0.5630427598953247,
0.3233563005924225,
0.8306715488433838,
-0.2845380902290344,
0.17021828889846802,
-0.7343689799308777,
0.16893048584461212,
-0.11727133393287659,
0.6153345108032227,
-0.500134289264679,
-0.24446788430213928,
-0.09531699866056442,
-0.026971282437443733,
-0.39203980565071106,
-0.7152613401412964,
0.25188782811164856,
-0.4568592309951782,
0.055436085909605026,
0.19836583733558655,
-0.5825044512748718,
0.06105879321694374,
0.028020339086651802,
-0.4226933419704437,
0.4949389100074768,
0.08403410762548447,
-0.676118016242981,
0.1240280419588089,
-0.6745519638061523,
-0.7163503766059875,
0.10607486218214035,
-0.06965959817171097,
-0.585337221622467,
0.34818342328071594,
0.09777110815048218,
0.5225886106491089,
-0.010186634957790375,
0.29151907563209534,
-0.14235839247703552,
-0.11947140842676163,
0.2397030144929886,
-0.10622874647378922,
0.3337773084640503,
0.1641896516084671,
-0.22923122346401215,
0.267314076423645,
-0.7413588166236877,
-0.027879970148205757,
-0.08122501522302628,
0.013898012228310108,
-0.6205147504806519,
0.1161765456199646,
-0.0823054313659668,
0.29270756244659424,
0.005381448660045862,
-0.41516852378845215,
-0.19224807620048523,
-0.5523709058761597,
0.4019138216972351,
0.8400654792785645,
-0.054506804794073105,
0.36500251293182373,
-0.4227229058742523,
0.6626524925231934,
0.06406276673078537,
0.2915763854980469,
-0.027151426300406456,
-0.42227715253829956,
-0.7274609804153442,
-0.4872632920742035,
0.3482626676559448,
0.3829196095466614,
-0.7675954699516296,
0.269233375787735,
-0.06257829815149307,
-0.3011029064655304,
-0.8079491257667542,
0.03476322814822197,
0.6811859011650085,
0.919327437877655,
0.3978015184402466,
-0.586980938911438,
-0.644067108631134,
-1.0207865238189697,
-0.41771385073661804,
0.2856544554233551,
-0.10471738129854202,
0.48606938123703003,
0.21942579746246338,
-0.35699862241744995,
0.7648249268531799,
-0.6683171391487122,
-0.6131093502044678,
-0.03167269378900528,
0.011200526729226112,
-0.026300298050045967,
0.4977121949195862,
0.12810683250427246,
-0.7656376957893372,
-0.5014001131057739,
0.003499093931168318,
-0.19198185205459595,
-0.3092100918292999,
-0.06271715462207794,
-0.062282007187604904,
0.15272915363311768,
0.7777621150016785,
-0.2049694061279297,
0.6429988741874695,
0.6474280953407288,
-0.3167582154273987,
0.36915645003318787,
-0.21444286406040192,
-0.23347750306129456,
-0.8259685039520264,
0.19914735853672028,
-0.1497558206319809,
-0.37526267766952515,
-0.9787105917930603,
-0.10961715131998062,
-0.04368240386247635,
-0.08615420758724213,
-0.5360102653503418,
0.7119357585906982,
-0.4862365126609802,
0.33881935477256775,
-0.42661237716674805,
-0.20406605303287506,
0.2261706292629242,
0.39290615916252136,
0.3750489056110382,
0.4716044068336487,
0.6760738492012024,
-0.8478302955627441,
-0.3898465037345886,
0.10322105139493942,
-0.3343627452850342,
0.3572733998298645,
-0.7106797695159912,
0.33552980422973633,
-0.1897476315498352,
0.06927575916051865,
-0.6325023770332336,
-0.0005028900923207402,
0.2345847636461258,
-0.37269437313079834,
0.5824544429779053,
-0.03016907162964344,
-0.03306075930595398,
-0.2600170075893402,
-0.07688669860363007,
0.5917394757270813,
0.3643577992916107,
-0.19494348764419556,
0.44559425115585327,
0.6648528575897217,
-0.17373187839984894,
-0.4737181067466736,
-0.6563001871109009,
0.07755182683467865,
-0.3370504677295685,
-0.3764095604419708,
0.6773922443389893,
-0.4395699203014374,
0.0902029275894165,
-0.1487179696559906,
-0.24700361490249634,
-0.12014590203762054,
0.18671266734600067,
0.16847024857997894,
-0.02265460602939129,
-0.3258102536201477,
0.3485458493232727,
-0.056761953979730606,
-0.21432651579380035,
-0.22503662109375,
-0.16871273517608643,
0.6990091800689697,
-0.12194298952817917,
-0.2735733091831207,
-0.13178522884845734,
0.4501928985118866,
0.1938522458076477,
-0.4264838695526123,
0.807361900806427,
0.6432139873504639,
-0.7787215113639832,
-0.24363821744918823,
-0.6039848327636719,
-0.5237308144569397,
-0.4662429392337799,
0.5278565883636475,
-0.5629710555076599,
-1.1705878973007202,
0.6583231687545776,
-0.15092065930366516,
-0.4624026417732239,
0.319178968667984,
0.5330159664154053,
0.019099541008472443,
1.1680934429168701,
0.9903945326805115,
-0.0246878769248724,
0.4204561710357666,
0.08508531004190445,
0.3276474177837372,
-0.9503903985023499,
-0.010403970256447792,
-0.449217289686203,
-0.25067636370658875,
-0.28572386503219604,
-0.4171592891216278,
0.35393550992012024,
0.11605625599622726,
-0.2022499293088913,
0.15048955380916595,
-0.6534947156906128,
0.5215023159980774,
0.4505804479122162,
0.384051114320755,
0.1447756588459015,
0.08253420144319534,
0.18128135800361633,
-0.23399528861045837,
-0.8998425006866455,
-0.40266746282577515,
1.0872793197631836,
0.4879108965396881,
0.7158098220825195,
-0.006715717725455761,
0.5642088651657104,
0.15613099932670593,
0.5281859040260315,
-0.6055166721343994,
0.2930556833744049,
-0.3969462215900421,
-0.6116050481796265,
-0.26677805185317993,
-0.46423572301864624,
-1.0064501762390137,
-0.03541722893714905,
-0.15776632726192474,
-0.679323673248291,
0.2731674909591675,
0.30038607120513916,
-0.6533831357955933,
0.30134353041648865,
-0.5154446363449097,
0.871773898601532,
-0.019945433363318443,
-0.17875182628631592,
0.024595804512500763,
-0.9301202893257141,
0.2189788818359375,
-0.5658151507377625,
0.2758726477622986,
-0.23481851816177368,
-0.0932600125670433,
0.7442018389701843,
-0.2815224528312683,
1.1740258932113647,
-0.19706140458583832,
-0.023572027683258057,
-0.050753142684698105,
0.05402085930109024,
0.2612341344356537,
-0.22871311008930206,
-0.0719047412276268,
0.33608517050743103,
-0.08287457376718521,
-0.45963311195373535,
-0.3752051293849945,
0.521831214427948,
-0.5165853500366211,
-0.6002317667007446,
-0.26953211426734924,
-0.5881596207618713,
-0.43301743268966675,
0.1821671426296234,
0.5653006434440613,
0.3597258925437927,
-0.07618644833564758,
-0.0010720212012529373,
1.0353013277053833,
-0.49609076976776123,
-0.043623052537441254,
0.9661713242530823,
0.06118661165237427,
-0.2688242495059967,
0.9688535332679749,
0.057609859853982925,
0.5557737350463867,
0.4931349456310272,
0.3683244287967682,
-0.04649825766682625,
-0.8728505969047546,
-0.21145914494991302,
0.25114476680755615,
-0.5049532651901245,
-0.5818359851837158,
-0.5904208421707153,
-0.4658714830875397,
-0.5197299718856812,
-0.05536849796772003,
-0.1459919512271881,
-0.16665838658809662,
-0.35306069254875183,
-0.0011996971443295479,
0.3716012239456177,
0.4251497983932495,
-0.07350262254476547,
0.4480949342250824,
-0.6748347878456116,
0.33612021803855896,
0.09243584424257278,
0.6336522698402405,
-0.4828028380870819,
-1.0370980501174927,
-0.4278261661529541,
0.006527697667479515,
-0.012474852614104748,
-0.7843000292778015,
0.5641183257102966,
0.7078945636749268,
0.5546022057533264,
0.36147642135620117,
0.2428743690252304,
0.6991686820983887,
-0.7216857671737671,
0.35091036558151245,
0.1332068145275116,
-1.0561461448669434,
0.6763129830360413,
-0.24426138401031494,
0.31079137325286865,
0.5166374444961548,
0.26160162687301636,
-0.7250433564186096,
-0.38687804341316223,
-0.44980764389038086,
-0.9782316088676453,
0.6011058688163757,
-0.0712677463889122,
0.3929236829280853,
0.03528590500354767,
0.3933785855770111,
0.2292417734861374,
0.30954158306121826,
-0.7157363891601562,
-0.31854015588760376,
0.015220382250845432,
-0.2205437421798706,
-0.3214062750339508,
-0.24501268565654755,
-0.381641149520874,
-0.2583416700363159,
0.6826449036598206,
-0.28849101066589355,
0.16213887929916382,
0.3443375825881958,
-0.42388230562210083,
-0.18854522705078125,
0.08476735651493073,
1.033144474029541,
0.41775959730148315,
-0.33505403995513916,
0.3658219873905182,
0.3192596435546875,
-0.5464909076690674,
-0.08454399555921555,
0.17686885595321655,
-0.1240302100777626,
0.08823955804109573,
0.2976799011230469,
1.0552892684936523,
-0.053378913551568985,
-0.7578594088554382,
0.5520904064178467,
0.08071998506784439,
-0.12324777245521545,
0.19400452077388763,
-0.2562474012374878,
-0.030932586640119553,
-0.15345163643360138,
0.040244873613119125,
0.3139590322971344,
0.2517673075199127,
-0.1371128410100937,
0.42907604575157166,
0.3754200041294098,
-0.639850378036499,
-0.19663910567760468,
0.5527209043502808,
0.007396313827484846,
-0.2755773067474365,
0.11485708504915237,
-0.06876868009567261,
-0.6288038492202759,
0.6011708974838257,
0.7594666481018066,
0.7723141312599182,
-0.6534467935562134,
0.12682367861270905,
0.1656935214996338,
0.36534905433654785,
0.18275748193264008,
-0.07190801203250885,
0.23618613183498383,
-0.8292660117149353,
-0.4524814188480377,
-0.7315313220024109,
-0.26017025113105774,
0.37339600920677185,
-0.6668182611465454,
0.16483451426029205,
-0.5339813232421875,
-0.30321183800697327,
0.13223843276500702,
-0.2210860252380371,
-0.7583302855491638,
0.3705717921257019,
0.2661394476890564,
0.8719903230667114,
-0.9438728094100952,
0.8957792520523071,
0.6807246804237366,
-0.23407548666000366,
-0.6011723875999451,
-0.19511263072490692,
-0.14495177567005157,
-0.8771302103996277,
0.650085985660553,
0.14301806688308716,
-0.2397502213716507,
-0.022102799266576767,
-0.30048710107803345,
-0.8459989428520203,
0.6833805441856384,
0.4505791962146759,
-0.7763731479644775,
0.1842588186264038,
0.3395446240901947,
0.6746891736984253,
-0.5241596102714539,
-0.19917473196983337,
0.3853401839733124,
0.15960514545440674,
-0.2979006767272949,
-1.0994014739990234,
0.1652965247631073,
-0.2717922329902649,
-0.022748960182070732,
0.2817710041999817,
-0.3144095242023468,
0.7706978917121887,
-0.15906305611133575,
-0.2414775937795639,
0.0020748176611959934,
0.21526576578617096,
-0.0349312499165535,
0.7708413004875183,
0.5213297009468079,
0.25886183977127075,
0.8351675868034363,
0.031157024204730988,
0.8774241805076599,
-0.31421828269958496,
0.1064443439245224,
1.2042462825775146,
-0.35434064269065857,
0.7404247522354126,
0.510330855846405,
0.05350389704108238,
0.13571076095104218,
0.676776647567749,
0.40963423252105713,
0.7100173830986023,
0.7857878804206848,
-0.4441031813621521,
-0.3098747432231903,
-0.408647358417511,
-0.4216316342353821,
0.2635786831378937,
0.5853838324546814,
-0.3080686926841736,
0.11300788819789886,
0.5841037034988403,
-0.04704730957746506,
0.30994877219200134,
-0.4606233239173889,
0.8853581547737122,
0.29706329107284546,
-0.2631917893886566,
0.694030225276947,
0.008919592015445232,
0.8065800666809082,
-0.785649299621582,
0.23842234909534454,
-0.34834471344947815,
0.32469257712364197,
-0.12817992269992828,
-0.19082991778850555,
0.6375152468681335,
-0.18760208785533905,
-0.44522950053215027,
-0.20048052072525024,
1.1317129135131836,
-0.699065625667572,
-0.4786246120929718,
0.3135492503643036,
0.4219018816947937,
0.1380072832107544,
-0.4101700484752655,
-0.6103513836860657,
0.02742764726281166,
-0.11210481077432632,
-0.09795510768890381,
0.5481549501419067,
0.1863860934972763,
-0.28834468126296997,
0.6348780989646912,
0.6336150169372559,
0.26708734035491943,
-0.04503113031387329,
0.30559712648391724,
0.8279803395271301,
-0.4838204085826874,
-0.2110704630613327,
-0.659270703792572,
0.39345991611480713,
-0.06106628477573395,
-0.17265014350414276,
0.45856013894081116,
0.41361087560653687,
0.7916950583457947,
-0.31774383783340454,
0.5999305248260498,
0.43331053853034973,
0.7975318431854248,
-0.5158036947250366,
0.9390254616737366,
-0.5810220837593079,
0.30664151906967163,
-0.2519308626651764,
-0.489437997341156,
-0.9345619678497314,
0.5995631217956543,
-0.3173642158508301,
-0.037531547248363495,
0.4937695264816284,
1.1995362043380737,
0.07796013355255127,
-0.587291955947876,
0.7131339311599731,
0.15506340563297272,
0.12384699285030365,
0.6918797492980957,
0.6276245713233948,
-0.32617324590682983,
0.36628592014312744,
-0.2201593965291977,
-0.2418959140777588,
-0.20554642379283905,
-0.9978265762329102,
-0.8083757758140564,
-0.5814446210861206,
-0.6855681538581848,
-0.38833552598953247,
0.34435245394706726,
0.5468023419380188,
0.9874942302703857,
-0.9677647948265076,
0.17003272473812103,
0.021811190992593765,
0.004524929914623499,
-0.16658061742782593,
-0.16157740354537964,
0.5939799547195435,
-0.30937230587005615,
-0.40909209847450256,
0.23265065252780914,
0.27308061718940735,
-0.0025108037516474724,
0.1542748212814331,
-0.2789531648159027,
0.06457871943712234,
0.25725314021110535,
0.692998468875885,
0.23745551705360413,
-0.6485701203346252,
-0.35628825426101685,
0.19421027600765228,
-0.16653747856616974,
-0.09591253101825714,
0.951943576335907,
-0.7117176651954651,
0.596198320388794,
0.11733486503362656,
0.7842215895652771,
0.23648659884929657,
-0.3219725489616394,
0.6261085271835327,
-0.9991456270217896,
0.07191376388072968,
0.47882217168807983,
0.2188875824213028,
0.4976763427257538,
-0.3881820738315582,
0.42116352915763855,
0.1914132535457611,
-0.36789095401763916,
-1.0553860664367676,
0.44341447949409485,
-0.9023878574371338,
-0.5203053951263428,
1.0774474143981934,
-0.10427533835172653,
0.07077894359827042,
-0.31036001443862915,
-0.47170984745025635,
0.31103673577308655,
0.11467109620571136,
0.8577238321304321,
0.5297009944915771,
0.01171177253127098,
-0.10979761183261871,
-0.42558202147483826,
0.9536359310150146,
0.8657488226890564,
-0.6053325533866882,
0.008378233760595322,
0.1796647161245346,
0.3224218189716339,
-0.0008293315768241882,
0.8413033485412598,
-0.004205275792628527,
0.1286388337612152,
-0.4249163269996643,
0.25818973779678345,
-0.056205641478300095,
-0.22250698506832123,
-0.7438446879386902,
-0.17418989539146423,
0.06661668419837952,
-0.33697932958602905
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18024v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18024v1
|
Enriching Word Usage Graphs with Cluster Definitions
| 2024-03-26T18:22:05 | 2024-03-26T18:22:05 |
Mariia Fedorova, Andrey Kutuzov, Nikolay Arefyev, Dominik Schlechtweg
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present a dataset of word usage graphs (WUGs), where the existing WUGs for
multiple languages are enriched with cluster labels functioning as sense
definitions. They are generated from scratch by fine-tuned encoder-decoder
language models. The conducted human evaluation has shown that these
definitions match the existing clusters in WUGs better than the definitions
chosen from WordNet by two baseline systems. At the same time, the method is
straightforward to use and easy to extend to new languages. The resulting
enriched datasets can be extremely helpful for moving on to explainable
semantic change modeling.
|
[
-0.2795105576515198,
-0.4950975179672241,
0.414897620677948,
-0.12049823254346848,
-0.38181066513061523,
-0.0029332037083804607,
-0.1879030168056488,
-0.4774703085422516,
0.2160482108592987,
0.42267224192619324,
-0.3585875332355499,
-0.6455790996551514,
-0.7896226644515991,
0.3404827415943146,
-0.5143291354179382,
0.6830196380615234,
0.04217299073934555,
-0.20107221603393555,
-0.3058256208896637,
-0.4652666747570038,
-0.5626763105392456,
-0.1714370995759964,
-0.35386475920677185,
-0.6631419062614441,
0.7098307013511658,
0.3829047977924347,
0.8368018269538879,
0.6624395251274109,
0.26551225781440735,
0.302486777305603,
-0.29962414503097534,
0.2851749062538147,
-0.5233162045478821,
-0.1600176990032196,
-0.07407404482364655,
-0.12324876338243484,
-0.352397084236145,
-0.08648604154586792,
0.4491603970527649,
1.2937648296356201,
-0.3588273525238037,
0.045121628791093826,
0.23106993734836578,
0.5161570906639099,
-0.5631881356239319,
0.28816303610801697,
-0.8491564393043518,
-0.1749649941921234,
-0.2969699800014496,
0.07639650255441666,
-0.06753494590520859,
-0.2549958825111389,
0.0650007501244545,
-0.8093218803405762,
0.08521617949008942,
-0.09582765400409698,
0.8828607797622681,
0.17205621302127838,
-0.4008302390575409,
-0.27608463168144226,
-0.2905966341495514,
0.38241419196128845,
-0.5399994254112244,
0.6708175539970398,
0.549382746219635,
0.28000113368034363,
-0.30936264991760254,
-1.0210444927215576,
-0.7455257177352905,
0.15635965764522552,
-0.4629681408405304,
0.15744449198246002,
-0.6617457866668701,
0.1785510927438736,
0.09373810887336731,
0.4083360731601715,
-0.306855171918869,
0.1744648665189743,
-0.47764238715171814,
-0.29354703426361084,
0.4897099435329437,
0.3362685739994049,
0.28547269105911255,
-0.03184384107589722,
-0.14168445765972137,
-0.3065999746322632,
-0.7160823941230774,
-0.10411782562732697,
0.29350367188453674,
0.32542622089385986,
-0.04837944731116295,
0.7891666889190674,
-0.2593831717967987,
1.2802091836929321,
-0.18397416174411774,
0.06388568133115768,
0.5739141702651978,
-0.2685680687427521,
-0.43587368726730347,
-0.14214298129081726,
0.4280073642730713,
0.5534204244613647,
0.3208783268928528,
-0.45791003108024597,
0.15145783126354218,
0.2593096196651459,
0.048190321773290634,
-0.6466178894042969,
-0.40178126096725464,
-0.11807741969823837,
-0.46204450726509094,
-0.16416357457637787,
0.26901257038116455,
-0.4646606147289276,
-0.5838015079498291,
-0.47793054580688477,
0.20663122832775116,
-0.547842800617218,
-0.3761656880378723,
0.412932813167572,
-0.8755726218223572,
0.037310827523469925,
0.008395214565098286,
-0.5360413789749146,
0.17139895260334015,
0.5341101288795471,
0.7100648283958435,
-0.25409796833992004,
-0.42241400480270386,
-0.17826077342033386,
0.3289739489555359,
-0.5655130743980408,
0.9256240129470825,
-0.8111201524734497,
-0.7283732891082764,
0.11740004271268845,
0.22123584151268005,
0.07976903766393661,
-0.6849612593650818,
0.2457226663827896,
-0.4831075072288513,
0.13380344212055206,
-0.4519977569580078,
-0.7972724437713623,
-0.48170265555381775,
0.3576699197292328,
-0.6268110871315002,
1.2153356075286865,
0.5744096040725708,
-0.7521653771400452,
0.8780896067619324,
-0.8732640743255615,
-0.6161479949951172,
0.5170741081237793,
0.20567286014556885,
0.13162736594676971,
0.2653791904449463,
0.11438839882612228,
0.4134864807128906,
0.14609530568122864,
0.12193746864795685,
-0.26128342747688293,
-0.1141173243522644,
0.223292738199234,
0.16158132255077362,
0.8443006277084351,
0.3685283660888672,
0.3687871992588043,
0.2926882803440094,
-0.8762640357017517,
0.05223482847213745,
-0.09938152134418488,
-0.3607484996318817,
-0.7789620161056519,
0.21957524120807648,
-0.09259674698114395,
-0.1450001448392868,
0.2913368046283722,
-0.5451042652130127,
-0.06421241164207458,
-0.48294004797935486,
0.5605436563491821,
0.3843754529953003,
-0.011257985606789589,
0.3117169141769409,
0.09381483495235443,
0.43597400188446045,
0.10777749121189117,
-0.05806700885295868,
-0.15932904183864594,
-0.5278273820877075,
-0.775463342666626,
-0.10425235331058502,
0.1918918639421463,
0.3361318111419678,
-0.7426896095275879,
0.855807900428772,
-0.4514766335487366,
-0.6033955812454224,
-0.4019138216972351,
0.08198989182710648,
-0.08045040816068649,
0.5069041848182678,
0.4906007647514343,
-0.17403028905391693,
-0.46399590373039246,
-0.8220611214637756,
-0.4065520763397217,
0.00199683359824121,
-0.19595995545387268,
0.31250545382499695,
0.39204034209251404,
-0.6868163347244263,
1.17879319190979,
-0.6710953712463379,
-0.09588120877742767,
-0.4358653128147125,
-0.08487605303525925,
0.12535816431045532,
-0.0025388672947883606,
0.2706661820411682,
-0.5984015464782715,
-0.5152352452278137,
0.23904985189437866,
-0.48091205954551697,
-0.29494577646255493,
0.3487159013748169,
-0.2778596878051758,
-0.4652411639690399,
0.7230861783027649,
-0.022464755922555923,
0.5875494480133057,
0.8250428438186646,
-0.7643423676490784,
0.515786349773407,
-0.1562259942293167,
-0.0789484903216362,
-1.2694916725158691,
-0.009435094892978668,
-0.1593605875968933,
-0.20517143607139587,
-0.588375449180603,
0.1680038869380951,
-0.10290888696908951,
-0.2108106166124344,
-0.28228962421417236,
0.6199876666069031,
-0.5052617192268372,
-0.09511924535036087,
-0.5496898889541626,
0.25589632987976074,
0.17758296430110931,
0.03531463071703911,
-0.22643408179283142,
0.6620526909828186,
0.8167970776557922,
-0.7800148129463196,
0.4310707449913025,
0.3991246521472931,
-0.4736063480377197,
0.42627856135368347,
-0.8507165908813477,
-0.06135078892111778,
-0.07485321164131165,
0.05272925645112991,
-0.837999165058136,
-0.3644346296787262,
0.050391413271427155,
-0.32200929522514343,
-0.1432356834411621,
-0.11152380704879761,
-0.6822558641433716,
-0.5082934498786926,
0.19946715235710144,
0.16030961275100708,
0.45390987396240234,
-0.9877950549125671,
0.3250177800655365,
0.709009051322937,
0.3357676565647125,
0.029019853100180626,
-0.7687571048736572,
0.26200857758522034,
-0.5217795968055725,
-0.47100716829299927,
0.49253687262535095,
0.2747424840927124,
-0.33498603105545044,
0.3252275288105011,
0.22736623883247375,
-0.09146934747695923,
0.19403809309005737,
0.2599659562110901,
-0.06919685006141663,
0.1929706633090973,
0.6408572793006897,
0.16993673145771027,
-0.11694424599409103,
-0.34984102845191956,
-0.40307000279426575,
0.6993147730827332,
-0.16687358915805817,
-0.21969199180603027,
-0.11515803635120392,
0.5158488154411316,
0.06324411928653717,
-0.4101560115814209,
0.7260265350341797,
0.7606622576713562,
-0.5683079361915588,
0.007938103750348091,
-0.14288106560707092,
-0.20122374594211578,
-0.5121828317642212,
0.2859232425689697,
-0.4116876423358917,
-1.3796693086624146,
0.5920689702033997,
-0.37628600001335144,
-0.08884789794683456,
0.536513090133667,
0.33843860030174255,
-0.10816562175750732,
1.0283751487731934,
0.8134399056434631,
0.029675710946321487,
0.5000174045562744,
-0.06327126920223236,
0.2601530849933624,
-0.8113240003585815,
-0.07730521261692047,
-0.5253984928131104,
-0.41282352805137634,
-0.649957537651062,
-0.4481946527957916,
0.4409531354904175,
0.46489155292510986,
0.0061522251926362514,
0.4968413710594177,
-0.6310693621635437,
0.6116356253623962,
0.2473461776971817,
-0.10895486921072006,
0.23508307337760925,
0.31916964054107666,
-0.13080672919750214,
0.049485303461551666,
-0.7626990079879761,
-0.35686472058296204,
0.7213173508644104,
-0.03887910023331642,
0.6515101194381714,
0.0459975004196167,
0.4165647029876709,
0.3174242377281189,
0.2501819133758545,
-0.9244747161865234,
0.4074851870536804,
-0.43256717920303345,
-0.22817784547805786,
-0.19299471378326416,
-0.36385682225227356,
-1.6554112434387207,
0.4002654552459717,
-0.2641389071941376,
-0.9901679158210754,
0.2574235498905182,
0.19916674494743347,
0.0994747132062912,
0.2065657377243042,
-0.6655756235122681,
0.8676148653030396,
0.1879587173461914,
0.2982759475708008,
-0.5923696160316467,
-0.013422565534710884,
0.07490301877260208,
0.4073103964328766,
0.18666717410087585,
-0.223423570394516,
0.0031339554116129875,
0.8413732051849365,
-0.6488770246505737,
0.8299688696861267,
-0.1815376728773117,
-0.00984119065105915,
0.6548393964767456,
-0.09460889548063278,
0.3477308750152588,
-0.39166945219039917,
-0.22737286984920502,
0.3990107476711273,
-0.04119214415550232,
-0.4385323226451874,
-0.3684134781360626,
0.3863719403743744,
-0.3388986885547638,
-0.14036978781223297,
-0.07156255096197128,
-0.49833011627197266,
-0.27658748626708984,
0.33768022060394287,
0.25711390376091003,
0.5496699810028076,
-0.41260629892349243,
0.1369674801826477,
0.05567128583788872,
-0.2882966101169586,
0.2726980149745941,
0.35816720128059387,
-0.3787742853164673,
-0.18050578236579895,
0.7623941898345947,
-0.029108984395861626,
0.062479935586452484,
-0.25089314579963684,
0.7287293672561646,
-0.5121344923973083,
-0.3695957660675049,
-0.3465771973133087,
0.05845019221305847,
-0.6785287857055664,
-0.17836008965969086,
-0.5276694297790527,
0.1332550197839737,
-0.5183449983596802,
-0.1627272218465805,
0.20606134831905365,
-0.3873509466648102,
-0.1620803326368332,
-0.36103254556655884,
0.9075515866279602,
0.9426859617233276,
-0.18400482833385468,
0.8744856119155884,
-0.822356641292572,
0.1912192702293396,
0.38416871428489685,
0.5863354206085205,
-0.08638016134500504,
-0.416004478931427,
-0.5355810523033142,
0.04897911101579666,
-0.046548981219530106,
-1.3042761087417603,
0.4247244894504547,
0.5098527073860168,
0.7339496612548828,
0.7363393306732178,
-0.3114376664161682,
0.9615931510925293,
-0.33740708231925964,
0.8419046998023987,
0.2522277534008026,
-0.9261546730995178,
0.4950275123119354,
-0.5546537637710571,
0.6008305549621582,
0.46737977862358093,
0.17584814131259918,
-0.9891305565834045,
-0.10874073952436447,
-0.5185302495956421,
-0.7872849106788635,
0.28907454013824463,
-0.19631266593933105,
0.3084801435470581,
-0.41511693596839905,
0.45915383100509644,
0.28686636686325073,
0.11843293905258179,
-0.2626917064189911,
-0.050258852541446686,
-0.22043345868587494,
-0.19761112332344055,
-0.10217784345149994,
-0.15068626403808594,
-0.2773444950580597,
-0.5343965888023376,
0.4181212782859802,
-0.4041215181350708,
0.12232491374015808,
-0.29215508699417114,
-0.3703707456588745,
0.17140741646289825,
0.3154997229576111,
-0.14144836366176605,
0.8513267040252686,
0.3832203149795532,
0.35767799615859985,
0.43640169501304626,
-0.3739009201526642,
-0.32537779211997986,
-0.037242259830236435,
-0.08585932105779648,
0.008940476924180984,
0.3437427580356598,
0.9569191932678223,
0.06547701358795166,
-0.6756284832954407,
0.1878519207239151,
0.15550468862056732,
-0.06069984287023544,
-0.15396593511104584,
0.1694420427083969,
0.39550548791885376,
-0.19651873409748077,
0.07482176274061203,
-0.17326992750167847,
0.3249496519565582,
-0.531369149684906,
0.15856942534446716,
0.3377402126789093,
-0.7317327857017517,
-0.2917161285877228,
0.13000279664993286,
0.05819227546453476,
-0.14795979857444763,
0.6876488924026489,
-0.6313868761062622,
-0.5869989991188049,
0.3601610064506531,
0.7678618431091309,
0.6410287618637085,
0.09625016897916794,
0.10948798060417175,
0.5117480754852295,
0.15323449671268463,
0.17383942008018494,
0.41386741399765015,
-0.07135247439146042,
-1.37064790725708,
-0.31849804520606995,
-0.5528773069381714,
-0.14297430217266083,
-0.09406670928001404,
-0.9531319737434387,
0.17352914810180664,
0.09749942272901535,
-0.2658310532569885,
-0.14884935319423676,
-0.3905910551548004,
-0.8180885314941406,
0.21421781182289124,
-0.0005724948132410645,
0.8794500827789307,
-0.9095179438591003,
0.9115897417068481,
0.9353423118591309,
0.08630774170160294,
-0.7445099949836731,
-0.2995918393135071,
-0.13430865108966827,
-0.9304998517036438,
0.058047834783792496,
0.08993213623762131,
-0.1387578248977661,
0.14426885545253754,
-0.49123623967170715,
-0.7152686715126038,
0.9734691381454468,
-0.19309724867343903,
-0.4196288287639618,
0.47898638248443604,
0.12261991202831268,
0.7240962982177734,
-0.25430500507354736,
-0.10429885238409042,
1.0202651023864746,
0.754654586315155,
-0.200006902217865,
-0.5037680864334106,
-0.08992352336645126,
-0.20193657279014587,
-0.017854344099760056,
0.3208951950073242,
-0.06956624239683151,
0.538873553276062,
-0.22698837518692017,
-0.6574608087539673,
-0.27555614709854126,
0.7454240322113037,
-0.02221747115254402,
0.19764703512191772,
0.9708360433578491,
0.8883432745933533,
1.0201092958450317,
-0.25266414880752563,
1.0491834878921509,
-0.320609986782074,
0.06333921104669571,
1.0829411745071411,
-0.05054580047726631,
0.7477348446846008,
0.37714508175849915,
-0.4476194381713867,
0.7046631574630737,
0.6992123126983643,
-0.2063315063714981,
0.19128519296646118,
0.18894195556640625,
-0.1300577074289322,
-0.36248910427093506,
-0.2911650240421295,
-0.28017061948776245,
0.7388487458229065,
0.8677501678466797,
-0.13067911565303802,
-0.47995609045028687,
-0.07343372702598572,
0.043858081102371216,
0.19960641860961914,
-0.36388611793518066,
1.0744469165802002,
-0.07569525390863419,
-0.5272144675254822,
0.3317252993583679,
0.22567953169345856,
0.7728005647659302,
-0.5807903409004211,
0.12510575354099274,
-0.016085591167211533,
-0.08504857122898102,
-0.40348121523857117,
-0.8930107355117798,
0.5263579487800598,
0.12700620293617249,
0.034193094819784164,
0.012082517147064209,
1.0485072135925293,
-0.6557826995849609,
-0.7053621411323547,
0.5126022696495056,
0.7337913513183594,
0.362988144159317,
-0.05298646539449692,
-0.4197409451007843,
-0.20410235226154327,
-0.08483031392097473,
0.20031195878982544,
0.10631751269102097,
0.3334970474243164,
-0.21862845122814178,
0.24556222558021545,
0.5908955335617065,
0.07497766613960266,
0.4153508245944977,
0.4688020348548889,
0.7323018908500671,
-0.6397550106048584,
-0.6504493951797485,
-0.6110876202583313,
0.5024518966674805,
-0.3193960189819336,
-0.5398494005203247,
0.8445072770118713,
0.6494858860969543,
0.7666231989860535,
0.14678065478801727,
1.0880213975906372,
-0.3505842983722687,
0.494610071182251,
-0.28448471426963806,
0.7925710082054138,
-0.6727318167686462,
-0.1307961344718933,
-0.03415801003575325,
-0.7923111319541931,
-0.25110211968421936,
0.6382306814193726,
0.03613602742552757,
-0.08170749247074127,
0.3690808117389679,
0.8227307200431824,
-0.18608137965202332,
0.036682408303022385,
0.4130626320838928,
0.09987995773553848,
0.22185982763767242,
0.047403112053871155,
0.7847708463668823,
-0.05965343117713928,
0.3574356734752655,
-0.22340162098407745,
-0.30588433146476746,
-0.04183760657906532,
-0.9117293357849121,
-0.7411582469940186,
-0.8232839107513428,
-0.3256533443927765,
-0.3621610403060913,
-0.1864255666732788,
0.4629589021205902,
0.7266336679458618,
-0.7527859807014465,
-0.27340999245643616,
-0.1339472532272339,
0.09444276988506317,
-0.4683302640914917,
-0.21402253210544586,
0.4020393490791321,
-0.3578245937824249,
-0.5163407921791077,
0.7704837322235107,
0.0330311544239521,
0.03128286823630333,
-0.1278824657201767,
-0.1566849797964096,
0.2364417016506195,
-0.05701184272766113,
0.9174158573150635,
0.05429776385426521,
-0.4545164704322815,
-0.399133563041687,
-0.20220470428466797,
0.23403605818748474,
0.04405389726161957,
1.0306843519210815,
-0.8682546019554138,
0.5910554528236389,
0.7161454558372498,
0.3687411844730377,
0.4465563893318176,
0.13864192366600037,
0.39302054047584534,
-0.847665011882782,
0.20937030017375946,
-0.2452864646911621,
0.609403133392334,
0.6273844838142395,
0.009309111163020134,
0.48782867193222046,
0.26403573155403137,
0.03503740578889847,
-0.5547024011611938,
0.47745203971862793,
-0.9448570609092712,
-0.4369027316570282,
1.3265804052352905,
-0.014837835915386677,
0.046528011560440063,
-0.3408718407154083,
0.14748358726501465,
0.3765031695365906,
-0.03064824640750885,
0.6562302708625793,
0.6162661910057068,
-0.24633583426475525,
0.05944417789578438,
-0.019720686599612236,
0.4498036503791809,
-0.041117362678050995,
-0.9979041218757629,
0.1198379397392273,
0.6256513595581055,
0.27741312980651855,
-0.04961317777633667,
0.3615790903568268,
-0.3503279983997345,
-0.007144347298890352,
0.14729352295398712,
0.1801731288433075,
-0.22525528073310852,
-0.09711327403783798,
-0.36861780285835266,
-0.07507536560297012,
0.054184336215257645,
-0.20283497869968414
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18018v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18018v2
|
DORE: A Dataset For Portuguese Definition Generation
| 2024-03-26T18:07:10 | 2024-03-28T10:19:46 |
Anna Beatriz Dimas Furtado, Tharindu Ranasinghe, Frédéric Blain, Ruslan Mitkov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Definition modelling (DM) is the task of automatically generating a
dictionary definition for a specific word. Computational systems that are
capable of DM can have numerous applications benefiting a wide range of
audiences. As DM is considered a supervised natural language generation
problem, these systems require large annotated datasets to train the machine
learning (ML) models. Several DM datasets have been released for English and
other high-resource languages. While Portuguese is considered a
mid/high-resource language in most natural language processing tasks and is
spoken by more than 200 million native speakers, there is no DM dataset
available for Portuguese. In this research, we fill this gap by introducing
DORE; the first dataset for Definition MOdelling for PoRtuguEse containing more
than 100,000 definitions. We also evaluate several deep learning based DM
models on DORE and report the results. The dataset and the findings of this
paper will facilitate research and study of Portuguese in wider contexts.
|
[
-0.4037681221961975,
-0.7632289528846741,
0.15087676048278809,
0.07988511025905609,
-0.112760029733181,
-0.13906656205654144,
-0.3324460983276367,
-0.2498391717672348,
0.02315548062324524,
0.7576752305030823,
-0.5006033182144165,
-0.2330479621887207,
-0.8928773999214172,
0.4703051745891571,
-0.5648913383483887,
0.9572999477386475,
-0.3211427330970764,
0.0023016834165900946,
-0.11886551976203918,
0.012793473899364471,
-0.4502362310886383,
-0.38885852694511414,
-0.5519187450408936,
-0.3245895504951477,
0.7488877177238464,
0.48530498147010803,
0.3018428385257721,
0.7321373820304871,
0.6098938584327698,
0.273598849773407,
-0.06900470703840256,
0.4006016254425049,
-0.8256232142448425,
0.17947033047676086,
-0.1765572428703308,
-0.34338563680648804,
-0.372948557138443,
0.06550072133541107,
0.6394508481025696,
0.7159171104431152,
-0.04551054164767265,
0.17298905551433563,
0.12204776704311371,
0.7492234706878662,
-0.4451836943626404,
0.5986743569374084,
-0.7174911499023438,
-0.45212772488594055,
-0.060968853533267975,
0.011126713827252388,
0.12983721494674683,
-0.3859597444534302,
0.03610304370522499,
-0.45336559414863586,
0.2120603770017624,
-0.5203186869621277,
0.8933486342430115,
0.39516204595565796,
-0.6193913221359253,
-0.6974509358406067,
-1.02588951587677,
0.6929836273193359,
-0.30936840176582336,
0.23764660954475403,
0.27140066027641296,
0.6117696166038513,
-0.3289976716041565,
-0.7737463712692261,
-0.9798660278320312,
-0.3216887414455414,
-0.013179603964090347,
-0.10242237150669098,
-0.4361671805381775,
-0.04232252389192581,
0.16955116391181946,
0.5400806069374084,
-0.2777835428714752,
0.3346302807331085,
-0.7164933681488037,
0.11198384314775467,
0.8751012086868286,
0.2675076425075531,
-0.09349226206541061,
-0.3603159487247467,
-0.44097912311553955,
-0.23118610680103302,
-0.9185879826545715,
-0.4063762128353119,
0.44382190704345703,
0.5286374688148499,
-0.18040142953395844,
0.37298089265823364,
-0.21583613753318787,
1.1873124837875366,
-0.3471466898918152,
-0.1255592554807663,
0.11050111800432205,
-0.2607841193675995,
-0.37973225116729736,
0.1034712865948677,
0.8821392059326172,
0.1538667231798172,
0.37015941739082336,
0.20093666017055511,
-0.523436963558197,
0.3855944275856018,
0.15719909965991974,
-0.7695626616477966,
-0.1762974113225937,
0.11655306071043015,
0.060962557792663574,
-0.5851449966430664,
0.08466217666864395,
-0.5621010661125183,
-0.12290360778570175,
-0.5825805068016052,
0.3002481460571289,
-0.40700995922088623,
-0.3143310546875,
0.31495994329452515,
0.23827970027923584,
0.04506402835249901,
0.19767987728118896,
-0.5778668522834778,
0.541382372379303,
0.5383639335632324,
0.4801940619945526,
0.05374596640467644,
-0.06572730839252472,
0.027481961995363235,
0.05796916037797928,
-0.44463491439819336,
0.5278716683387756,
-0.1496967226266861,
-0.7903283834457397,
-0.16613036394119263,
0.19772665202617645,
0.030841702595353127,
-0.45540356636047363,
0.6791236996650696,
-0.2748759686946869,
0.3030645251274109,
-0.06721307337284088,
-0.45399755239486694,
-0.667533814907074,
0.25964903831481934,
-0.8751871585845947,
1.1159729957580566,
0.27930545806884766,
-0.710848331451416,
0.6720734238624573,
-0.6955397725105286,
-0.4497467875480652,
0.528664767742157,
-0.4237191379070282,
0.10640724748373032,
0.15064942836761475,
0.0457148551940918,
0.6633373498916626,
-0.7518777251243591,
0.7070872783660889,
0.16074512898921967,
-0.11471977084875107,
0.40174680948257446,
-0.38604623079299927,
0.556176483631134,
0.5797151923179626,
-0.019067848101258278,
-0.48896390199661255,
-0.8828964829444885,
-0.21855156123638153,
0.20439904928207397,
-0.2543249726295471,
-0.5315006971359253,
0.08945741504430771,
0.29522573947906494,
0.48193031549453735,
0.375853031873703,
-0.6866089105606079,
0.27724263072013855,
-0.4679405093193054,
0.5791698098182678,
0.21805913746356964,
-0.18963216245174408,
-0.02099495753645897,
-0.47908785939216614,
0.5226293206214905,
0.30503249168395996,
-0.2689912021160126,
-0.2753407657146454,
-0.09990035742521286,
-0.7833108305931091,
-0.5630754232406616,
0.7178515195846558,
0.639054536819458,
-0.48093146085739136,
0.3401474952697754,
-0.5384219288825989,
-0.5717410445213318,
-0.7490212321281433,
0.09129467606544495,
0.32847297191619873,
0.8084583878517151,
-0.0241124015301466,
0.030550813302397728,
-0.9540484547615051,
-1.2985435724258423,
0.5580169558525085,
-0.05876655504107475,
0.02317989058792591,
0.6165388822555542,
0.7448117136955261,
-0.40658819675445557,
0.9562324285507202,
-0.5267925262451172,
-0.28717997670173645,
-0.283701628446579,
-0.0783698707818985,
0.5175131559371948,
0.08389917016029358,
0.7154662609100342,
-0.9996470808982849,
-0.23376719653606415,
-0.16044805943965912,
-0.7964043021202087,
-0.15730395913124084,
0.36127012968063354,
0.14256468415260315,
0.24663905799388885,
0.013452323153614998,
0.05325008183717728,
0.3444502353668213,
0.631031334400177,
0.2760053873062134,
-0.0478065051138401,
-0.5112084746360779,
0.1431386023759842,
-1.549077033996582,
0.3560519516468048,
0.1882125288248062,
0.01329310517758131,
-0.5334030389785767,
-0.1580696702003479,
-0.10357305407524109,
-0.18080686032772064,
-0.6449613571166992,
0.8763359189033508,
-0.11647768318653107,
0.3518489599227905,
-0.3080673813819885,
0.27777013182640076,
0.009624824859201908,
-0.06584914028644562,
0.3621428310871124,
0.3959219753742218,
0.8540467023849487,
-1.1994105577468872,
0.5692024827003479,
0.5494037866592407,
-0.3556121587753296,
0.5177233219146729,
-0.7646995782852173,
-0.039167895913124084,
-0.29078182578086853,
0.08383862674236298,
-1.2393907308578491,
-0.4636671245098114,
0.10989502817392349,
-0.18544362485408783,
0.37784528732299805,
-0.16184525191783905,
-0.4760926365852356,
-0.8438194394111633,
0.2724554240703583,
0.15621094405651093,
0.5085592865943909,
-0.5607737898826599,
-0.017017314210534096,
0.8164414763450623,
-0.03165027126669884,
-0.42181992530822754,
-0.8236229419708252,
0.2505349814891815,
-0.4041912853717804,
-0.8610923886299133,
0.447537899017334,
0.1953500509262085,
-0.6171514391899109,
-0.3066658675670624,
0.19797641038894653,
-0.3176782429218292,
0.13596294820308685,
0.3599547743797302,
0.19240936636924744,
0.11251294612884521,
0.36302831768989563,
-0.12174555659294128,
-0.07525599747896194,
-0.18258294463157654,
-0.2157335877418518,
0.3922828435897827,
0.22811822593212128,
0.3749670088291168,
-0.10920283198356628,
0.2194487452507019,
0.27039527893066406,
-0.04208467900753021,
0.5407367944717407,
-0.1619328409433365,
-0.3130950927734375,
-0.47448500990867615,
-0.3958136737346649,
0.10026577860116959,
-0.39979007840156555,
0.13752737641334534,
-0.5819737315177917,
-0.7524120807647705,
0.5192316174507141,
-0.04913055896759033,
-0.05382990092039108,
0.5747693181037903,
0.869395911693573,
0.01628831960260868,
0.5563685297966003,
0.9579073786735535,
0.05192629620432854,
0.3238796889781952,
-0.5234184265136719,
0.0025488748215138912,
-0.27625855803489685,
-0.17969681322574615,
-0.6489784717559814,
-0.4946972727775574,
-1.0240700244903564,
-0.42827096581459045,
0.18408848345279694,
0.004118560813367367,
0.0730452686548233,
0.580193281173706,
-0.5679534077644348,
0.005958680994808674,
0.3497653305530548,
0.02023814246058464,
0.29182636737823486,
0.06005795672535896,
-0.0776982232928276,
0.1317160427570343,
-0.8064059019088745,
-1.053511619567871,
1.2496963739395142,
-0.15711817145347595,
0.9447654485702515,
-0.14563995599746704,
0.9176974296569824,
0.18680015206336975,
-0.06918562203645706,
-0.7174944877624512,
0.5402176380157471,
-0.40630635619163513,
-0.5581452250480652,
-0.03763681650161743,
-0.5617702007293701,
-1.4382691383361816,
-0.3340676426887512,
-0.00702464347705245,
-0.2073124349117279,
0.1071123406291008,
0.22054274380207062,
-0.07240627706050873,
0.12934300303459167,
-0.15963852405548096,
0.5164307355880737,
-0.4433164596557617,
-0.17240165174007416,
-0.2772136330604553,
-0.31808409094810486,
0.4377943277359009,
-0.4899333119392395,
0.24256755411624908,
-0.257108598947525,
-0.14926528930664062,
0.7803888320922852,
-0.5128657817840576,
0.7782045006752014,
0.10864295065402985,
-0.48835328221321106,
0.7703140377998352,
0.2487884759902954,
-0.009291212074458599,
-0.032283179461956024,
-0.5122733116149902,
0.49178963899612427,
0.18522757291793823,
-0.1837502121925354,
-0.1906435489654541,
0.9282766580581665,
-0.676220178604126,
-0.18983595073223114,
-0.3991357088088989,
-0.4296780228614807,
0.20825177431106567,
0.058003976941108704,
0.21642154455184937,
0.3715723752975464,
-0.9627647995948792,
-0.13043133914470673,
0.4265143573284149,
-0.16046836972236633,
0.47544658184051514,
0.9982986450195312,
-0.17741718888282776,
-0.11489568650722504,
0.7756094336509705,
0.6069856286048889,
-0.15843185782432556,
0.40151718258857727,
0.24638746678829193,
-0.3365435302257538,
-0.367093026638031,
-0.4511992633342743,
0.0681023970246315,
-0.30859386920928955,
-0.03163488581776619,
-0.4161365330219269,
-0.21161280572414398,
-0.26330259442329407,
0.23542509973049164,
-0.045923758298158646,
-0.6247073411941528,
-0.1637001782655716,
-0.08904507011175156,
0.919946014881134,
1.2204402685165405,
-0.3946378529071808,
0.48030534386634827,
-0.771000862121582,
0.3617430329322815,
0.10568711161613464,
0.20312783122062683,
-0.31462568044662476,
-0.3878844380378723,
-0.23504996299743652,
0.5526708960533142,
-0.20285558700561523,
-0.7632443904876709,
0.761346161365509,
0.17490637302398682,
0.7346248626708984,
0.10143743455410004,
-0.21985512971878052,
0.24818353354930878,
-0.21700479090213776,
0.46293380856513977,
-0.09998030215501785,
-0.4351605772972107,
0.9528751969337463,
-0.6282413005828857,
-0.08471572399139404,
0.4616583287715912,
0.8068972826004028,
-0.6796967387199402,
0.29085421562194824,
-0.8188400268554688,
-0.7679262161254883,
0.6575317978858948,
-0.010088023729622364,
0.37236112356185913,
-0.6472827196121216,
0.49597153067588806,
0.6287721991539001,
0.5672857165336609,
-0.2005305290222168,
-0.020453806966543198,
0.21529266238212585,
-0.15509983897209167,
-0.4175489544868469,
-0.36151042580604553,
-0.1146438717842102,
-0.1131979450583458,
0.5440731048583984,
0.01699681021273136,
-0.1333240568637848,
-0.10251359641551971,
-0.038019999861717224,
-0.06705529987812042,
0.14024360477924347,
0.30586951971054077,
0.7387614846229553,
0.014014202170073986,
-0.1501007229089737,
-0.03579328581690788,
-0.47626033425331116,
0.1815105378627777,
0.273021936416626,
-0.3013980984687805,
0.04342563450336456,
0.014727639965713024,
0.8920927047729492,
0.15616600215435028,
-0.7418196201324463,
0.25759539008140564,
0.04613712057471275,
-0.4466607868671417,
-0.4388427138328552,
0.10858606547117233,
-0.17922119796276093,
-0.3613797426223755,
0.1620965152978897,
-0.4453415274620056,
-0.19819575548171997,
-0.36565113067626953,
0.4410690665245056,
-0.02241167426109314,
-0.5906787514686584,
-0.26064369082450867,
0.5416322350502014,
0.3597690165042877,
-0.294548898935318,
0.8336388468742371,
0.013313708826899529,
-0.17762422561645508,
0.723854124546051,
0.14388003945350647,
0.7102953195571899,
-0.25160276889801025,
0.11643175035715103,
0.4416711628437042,
-0.042323917150497437,
-0.1786557137966156,
1.0261739492416382,
0.15589308738708496,
-0.8159651756286621,
-0.589937686920166,
-1.0864479541778564,
-0.20951417088508606,
0.19792333245277405,
-0.5808115005493164,
0.8179278373718262,
-0.10914474725723267,
-0.13776306807994843,
-0.06571800261735916,
0.1507607251405716,
-1.0203793048858643,
0.5524836778640747,
0.4316626191139221,
0.8378449082374573,
-0.9838656187057495,
0.9990533590316772,
0.7461071014404297,
-0.6442832350730896,
-0.6770805716514587,
-0.6661002039909363,
-0.191888228058815,
-0.8889564275741577,
1.3101626634597778,
-0.015241469256579876,
0.004003899171948433,
0.049302052706480026,
-0.3778180480003357,
-0.6633008122444153,
0.8339535593986511,
0.39336130023002625,
-1.015717625617981,
0.14653244614601135,
0.4999934732913971,
0.6418952345848083,
-0.6859074234962463,
0.06024686247110367,
0.653456449508667,
0.6246967315673828,
0.48953625559806824,
-0.984446108341217,
-0.3451448082923889,
0.063046894967556,
-0.04245007783174515,
0.473641961812973,
-0.5556173324584961,
0.9163764715194702,
-0.05714130401611328,
-0.08327550441026688,
-0.05616580322384834,
0.196650430560112,
-0.11304198950529099,
-0.041465286165475845,
0.2507663071155548,
0.7774300575256348,
0.7810652852058411,
-0.25144410133361816,
1.1143391132354736,
-0.5646682381629944,
-0.02099563553929329,
1.1263744831085205,
-0.5149335265159607,
0.6225513815879822,
0.26085785031318665,
-0.16536052525043488,
0.279946506023407,
0.8372143507003784,
-0.13159134984016418,
0.30190351605415344,
0.7619218826293945,
-0.30702275037765503,
-0.1677788943052292,
-0.12572640180587769,
-0.14911971986293793,
1.1706019639968872,
0.6189556121826172,
-0.7023767232894897,
-0.47472846508026123,
0.07355177402496338,
0.06423355638980865,
0.2891489565372467,
-0.6212311387062073,
0.8742998838424683,
0.08297418802976608,
-0.5150500535964966,
0.7217194437980652,
-0.10780823230743408,
0.45148780941963196,
-0.5919825434684753,
-0.20279823243618011,
-0.21366311609745026,
0.3713187873363495,
-0.05857747793197632,
-0.7940075397491455,
0.33624500036239624,
0.06130490452051163,
-0.257351815700531,
-0.4659345746040344,
0.5377879738807678,
-0.3831382095813751,
-1.0556700229644775,
0.3829672336578369,
0.955279529094696,
0.546069324016571,
0.2080872505903244,
-0.6735823154449463,
-0.2368909865617752,
-0.15039238333702087,
-0.177969828248024,
0.12003383785486221,
0.6741839647293091,
-0.3983753025531769,
0.602902352809906,
0.18227137625217438,
0.21183231472969055,
-0.08161338418722153,
-0.03747997805476189,
0.9081531167030334,
-0.5968276858329773,
-0.21642610430717468,
-0.9694957733154297,
0.29687726497650146,
0.17218098044395447,
-0.40286538004875183,
0.73415207862854,
0.7372810244560242,
0.9070364832878113,
0.18407019972801208,
1.1330043077468872,
-0.5161239504814148,
0.6923253536224365,
-0.038072261959314346,
0.6522833108901978,
-0.5527754426002502,
0.05636360123753548,
-0.029922466725111008,
-0.8203967809677124,
-0.032676950097084045,
0.4845481216907501,
-0.4862368404865265,
-0.019223203882575035,
0.07030842453241348,
0.9294256567955017,
-0.07689252495765686,
-0.11502648144960403,
0.4159281849861145,
0.3584356904029846,
-0.0709083303809166,
0.5386672616004944,
0.7378829121589661,
-0.44396740198135376,
0.425118625164032,
-0.20968611538410187,
-0.21855628490447998,
-0.13559289276599884,
-1.1177719831466675,
-0.7031163573265076,
-0.7532504796981812,
-0.28068721294403076,
-0.3043212890625,
0.1028330996632576,
0.4496830105781555,
0.6489283442497253,
-0.7445825338363647,
-0.6639921069145203,
-0.08728590607643127,
-0.08179467171430588,
-0.195172518491745,
-0.06060111150145531,
0.2068660706281662,
0.010702910833060741,
-0.8879148960113525,
0.6071618795394897,
-0.09417940676212311,
0.19082707166671753,
-0.6332048177719116,
0.0626620277762413,
-0.32646089792251587,
0.1845742017030716,
0.2262510359287262,
0.160068079829216,
-0.24882933497428894,
0.0019573986064642668,
-0.2259802371263504,
-0.23961475491523743,
0.16243180632591248,
0.6674940586090088,
-1.3504446744918823,
0.6140313744544983,
0.5633238554000854,
-0.032318294048309326,
0.7613198161125183,
-0.4431576430797577,
1.0100752115249634,
-0.679038405418396,
0.5176109075546265,
0.31069016456604004,
0.43576547503471375,
0.4346558451652527,
-0.15826940536499023,
0.8194169998168945,
-0.025489015504717827,
-0.33154991269111633,
-0.7211471796035767,
0.34114953875541687,
-0.8983657360076904,
-0.15373851358890533,
0.8634359240531921,
0.09937936812639236,
-0.3812466561794281,
0.12713004648685455,
-0.3113018572330475,
0.536409318447113,
-0.16913023591041565,
0.6835989356040955,
0.4563996493816376,
0.13686393201351166,
0.3569566011428833,
-0.6614491939544678,
0.4249947667121887,
-0.446652889251709,
-0.3746878504753113,
0.2695556879043579,
0.6667587757110596,
0.4161050319671631,
-0.14359228312969208,
0.3438156545162201,
-0.12652550637722015,
-0.09425566345453262,
0.009455648250877857,
0.2971619665622711,
-0.364857017993927,
-0.24979649484157562,
-0.2894365191459656,
0.04083795100450516,
-0.11582283675670624,
-0.14511391520500183
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17919v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17919v3
|
LISA: Layerwise Importance Sampling for Memory-Efficient Large Language Model Fine-Tuning
| 2024-03-26T17:55:02 | 2024-05-25T10:20:27 |
Rui Pan, Xiang Liu, Shizhe Diao, Renjie Pi, Jipeng Zhang, Chi Han, Tong Zhang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, math.OC
|
The machine learning community has witnessed impressive advancements since
large language models (LLMs) first appeared. Yet, their massive memory
consumption has become a significant roadblock to large-scale training. For
instance, a 7B model typically requires at least 60 GB of GPU memory with full
parameter training, which presents challenges for researchers without access to
high-resource environments. Parameter Efficient Fine-Tuning techniques such as
Low-Rank Adaptation (LoRA) have been proposed to alleviate this problem.
However, in most large-scale fine-tuning settings, their performance does not
reach the level of full parameter training because they confine the parameter
search to a low-rank subspace. Attempting to complement this deficiency, we
investigate the layerwise properties of LoRA on fine-tuning tasks and observe
an unexpected but consistent skewness of weight norms across different layers.
Utilizing this key observation, a surprisingly simple training strategy is
discovered, which outperforms both LoRA and full parameter training in a wide
range of settings with memory costs as low as LoRA. We name it Layerwise
Importance Sampled AdamW (LISA), a promising alternative for LoRA, which
applies the idea of importance sampling to different layers in LLMs and
randomly freezes most middle layers during optimization. Experimental results
show that with similar or less GPU memory consumption, LISA surpasses LoRA or
even full parameter tuning in downstream fine-tuning tasks, where LISA
consistently outperforms LoRA by over 10%-35% in terms of MT-Bench score while
achieving on-par or better performance in MMLU, AGIEval and WinoGrande. On
large models, specifically LLaMA-2-70B, LISA surpasses LoRA on MT-Bench, GSM8K,
and PubMedQA, demonstrating its effectiveness across different domains.
|
[
-0.47013768553733826,
-0.8545783162117004,
0.765238344669342,
-0.16181519627571106,
-0.2821682393550873,
-0.24969273805618286,
-0.3666790723800659,
-0.429093599319458,
0.18790630996227264,
0.5608464479446411,
-0.22573350369930267,
-0.4355858266353607,
-0.718856692314148,
-0.6009244918823242,
-0.308869332075119,
0.8847429752349854,
0.2507990300655365,
-0.16862894594669342,
-0.020239196717739105,
-0.25063076615333557,
-0.14620833098888397,
-0.23017805814743042,
-0.9523308873176575,
-0.09834092110395432,
0.9696387052536011,
0.5787127017974854,
0.611749529838562,
0.6165341138839722,
0.5949899554252625,
0.18483516573905945,
-0.27083244919776917,
0.30077651143074036,
-0.684240996837616,
0.022205054759979248,
-0.003520245896652341,
-0.4238751232624054,
-0.7195151448249817,
0.011129549704492092,
0.7076115012168884,
0.9006470441818237,
-0.16492144763469696,
0.5842106342315674,
0.11177045106887817,
0.8876808285713196,
-1.1083799600601196,
0.05615196004509926,
-0.8902814388275146,
0.06581833958625793,
-0.32722777128219604,
-0.39631325006484985,
-0.29990261793136597,
-0.019477171823382378,
-0.20394685864448547,
-0.5212308764457703,
0.07671426981687546,
0.12006910145282745,
0.8501990437507629,
0.6349771022796631,
0.021261777728796005,
0.11132063716650009,
-0.7959752678871155,
0.98236083984375,
-0.9221739172935486,
0.21907037496566772,
0.5587182641029358,
0.30803266167640686,
-0.21878288686275482,
-0.27412691712379456,
-0.16288499534130096,
-0.16124269366264343,
0.6312880516052246,
0.09110723435878754,
-0.12835575640201569,
0.14714376628398895,
0.42012548446655273,
0.23026862740516663,
0.09624210745096207,
0.508200466632843,
-0.3590087890625,
0.16771207749843597,
0.39164334535598755,
-0.07547418773174286,
0.08074940741062164,
-0.01861036941409111,
-0.1530844271183014,
-0.28038978576660156,
-0.7722388505935669,
0.4774484932422638,
0.4520625174045563,
0.5420030951499939,
0.060418132692575455,
0.3444574177265167,
-0.12852266430854797,
0.9057322144508362,
0.21273688971996307,
-0.2615773677825928,
0.05812874063849449,
0.11216121912002563,
-0.3607116639614105,
0.17004600167274475,
0.47122007608413696,
0.1538136750459671,
0.08337455242872238,
-0.003031220519915223,
-0.07725290209054947,
-0.3366956412792206,
0.30752691626548767,
-0.972067654132843,
-0.30178210139274597,
0.3127424120903015,
-0.4536488354206085,
-0.27356240153312683,
-0.06350013613700867,
-0.48250308632850647,
-0.3409402072429657,
-0.2849551737308502,
0.4850662648677826,
-0.24680602550506592,
-0.16026721894741058,
0.18849532306194305,
0.011550506576895714,
0.017200598493218422,
0.5132996439933777,
-1.0712262392044067,
0.19315087795257568,
0.5756604671478271,
0.472219854593277,
-0.0668867826461792,
-0.18888244032859802,
-0.9696407914161682,
0.0379045307636261,
-0.6082453727722168,
0.6093684434890747,
-0.6902910470962524,
0.11294696480035782,
-0.42151927947998047,
-0.17252980172634125,
-0.16155259311199188,
-0.6919130086898804,
0.6323540806770325,
-0.432900607585907,
-0.21461421251296997,
-0.47523778676986694,
-0.08412054181098938,
-0.2053469866514206,
0.08254831284284592,
-0.6344176530838013,
1.3185744285583496,
0.13945485651493073,
-0.7389292120933533,
0.49579188227653503,
-0.5534229278564453,
-0.3221442699432373,
-0.26606330275535583,
-0.03412438556551933,
-0.8400124311447144,
0.45269498229026794,
0.334911048412323,
0.8652995824813843,
-0.45868876576423645,
-0.08948555588722229,
-0.6205724477767944,
-0.5771306157112122,
0.06580154597759247,
-0.21349120140075684,
0.6165639758110046,
0.2574462592601776,
-0.28613245487213135,
0.04782281443476677,
-1.0805553197860718,
0.2579616606235504,
0.21201398968696594,
-0.4948218762874603,
-0.7617844343185425,
0.1195509135723114,
-0.1021268293261528,
0.05073337256908417,
0.19095711410045624,
-0.3532341420650482,
0.0674264207482338,
-0.20639459788799286,
0.768369197845459,
0.5872125029563904,
-0.010380188003182411,
0.34929829835891724,
-0.145503431558609,
0.35187533497810364,
0.22026649117469788,
0.2632284462451935,
0.17981892824172974,
-0.42464014887809753,
-0.8334411978721619,
-0.2595040202140808,
0.3806062340736389,
0.21620357036590576,
-0.3316304087638855,
0.4206775724887848,
-0.25852108001708984,
-0.3828680217266083,
-0.5523015856742859,
0.5206994414329529,
0.2374608963727951,
0.37450313568115234,
0.36497995257377625,
-0.37488269805908203,
-0.33548110723495483,
-0.9302046298980713,
0.011022880673408508,
-0.10986942052841187,
0.1393621861934662,
0.49146005511283875,
0.11732027679681778,
-0.06740568578243256,
0.6464588046073914,
-0.31014445424079895,
-0.31554123759269714,
-0.3834685981273651,
-0.20197801291942596,
0.29612988233566284,
0.43923115730285645,
0.6662460565567017,
-0.4068589210510254,
-0.19396959245204926,
0.03185196965932846,
-0.312389075756073,
0.007714811246842146,
-0.10655578970909119,
-0.2726692259311676,
-0.039774902164936066,
0.622972846031189,
-0.41058313846588135,
0.16049540042877197,
0.7094756364822388,
0.22930091619491577,
0.007827994413673878,
-0.5175207853317261,
-0.16543498635292053,
-1.0110689401626587,
0.1568874567747116,
-0.02468418888747692,
-0.15712544322013855,
-0.40149062871932983,
0.15129394829273224,
0.18073256313800812,
-0.030442269518971443,
-0.38590434193611145,
0.28415000438690186,
-0.6121557354927063,
-0.34400156140327454,
-0.23386873304843903,
0.030855150893330574,
-0.030584482476115227,
0.6591340899467468,
-0.30846738815307617,
0.6765735745429993,
0.4820689857006073,
-0.7066647410392761,
-0.17738176882266998,
-0.175807386636734,
-0.5806781649589539,
0.2719683051109314,
-0.4056490659713745,
0.23744292557239532,
-0.08010346442461014,
-0.00502083171159029,
-0.870742678642273,
-0.08516930043697357,
0.036829542368650436,
0.02092631720006466,
0.34661734104156494,
-0.293575644493103,
-0.375805139541626,
-0.18760649859905243,
-0.2998315393924713,
0.4648027718067169,
0.5945317149162292,
-0.6074233651161194,
0.5768987536430359,
0.5837728977203369,
-0.014704838395118713,
-0.7046197056770325,
-0.599037230014801,
0.042288828641176224,
-0.43580564856529236,
-0.36217746138572693,
0.04855330288410187,
0.012865795753896236,
-0.033141691237688065,
-0.04319525137543678,
-0.17431609332561493,
0.038956161588430405,
0.5427036881446838,
0.37573644518852234,
-0.010271698236465454,
-0.384934663772583,
-0.1839352250099182,
0.3128013014793396,
0.0009607147658243775,
-0.009219403378665447,
-0.3840397000312805,
0.47924721240997314,
-0.03876662999391556,
-0.5826027393341064,
-0.21029771864414215,
0.09647861868143082,
0.5510191917419434,
-0.03850231692194939,
0.7830397486686707,
0.8334445357322693,
-0.22915877401828766,
-0.5645169615745544,
-0.7553909420967102,
-0.004585162736475468,
-0.40072867274284363,
0.6317984461784363,
-0.26782530546188354,
-0.7408644556999207,
0.7291529178619385,
-0.1316426694393158,
-0.005103128496557474,
0.43731552362442017,
0.39335864782333374,
-0.23793762922286987,
0.948834240436554,
0.6375764012336731,
-0.4191599488258362,
0.6499269008636475,
-0.3040318787097931,
0.39431285858154297,
-1.082218885421753,
0.35615187883377075,
-0.45910266041755676,
-0.6881468892097473,
-0.4113060534000397,
-0.5090980529785156,
0.6230461001396179,
0.374240517616272,
-0.25868138670921326,
0.10203365981578827,
-0.3190411329269409,
0.6425454616546631,
0.6655391454696655,
0.27988505363464355,
0.152923583984375,
0.20201733708381653,
0.10365014523267746,
0.1391545832157135,
-0.9316418170928955,
0.0026906183920800686,
1.1024013757705688,
0.3882637917995453,
0.8225746154785156,
-0.047611843794584274,
0.6642786264419556,
-0.0004115314222872257,
-0.11902359873056412,
-0.7215622067451477,
0.6083831191062927,
-0.36492636799812317,
-0.2576950490474701,
-0.5752670168876648,
-0.4335610270500183,
-0.9743894338607788,
0.1520712673664093,
-0.14528478682041168,
-0.5494081377983093,
0.33677464723587036,
0.4002225697040558,
-0.7210758924484253,
0.5849918723106384,
-0.6558637022972107,
0.4929701089859009,
-0.13461805880069733,
-0.4252171814441681,
-0.3585866689682007,
-0.5347262620925903,
0.2508419156074524,
-0.13177672028541565,
0.07523292303085327,
-0.35087698698043823,
0.1032719835639,
0.6143304109573364,
-0.23314571380615234,
0.9242685437202454,
-0.3779084086418152,
-0.14537404477596283,
0.10466258972883224,
-0.022410377860069275,
0.6462131142616272,
-0.08784621953964233,
-0.040739137679338455,
0.22620850801467896,
-0.054821133613586426,
-0.5902041792869568,
-0.4751023054122925,
0.8956125378608704,
-1.074791669845581,
-0.6390414237976074,
-0.04871273785829544,
-0.6394856572151184,
-0.3599478304386139,
0.06300187110900879,
0.06729716062545776,
0.2983997166156769,
-0.07066819816827774,
0.41425979137420654,
0.9540099501609802,
-0.3202323317527771,
0.3427128493785858,
0.19558531045913696,
-0.07609900832176208,
0.14228074252605438,
0.99385005235672,
0.20738165080547333,
0.5899679064750671,
0.42310646176338196,
0.2919541895389557,
0.3286688029766083,
-0.8952575922012329,
-0.6020524501800537,
-0.030407147482037544,
-0.6591054201126099,
-0.10326946526765823,
-0.6107989549636841,
-0.6106640100479126,
0.013721024617552757,
-0.11691532284021378,
-0.7208667397499084,
-0.6248927116394043,
-0.17986193299293518,
0.12501297891139984,
0.37994617223739624,
0.28964248299598694,
0.0274980328977108,
0.21497370302677155,
-0.43880027532577515,
0.315449059009552,
0.42801475524902344,
0.3063433766365051,
0.2541521191596985,
-0.6058875322341919,
-0.45416030287742615,
-0.1871763914823532,
-0.047556836158037186,
-0.07899244129657745,
0.19881494343280792,
0.45266780257225037,
0.536261260509491,
0.652880072593689,
-0.009641253389418125,
0.8582022190093994,
-0.4676321744918823,
0.5652527213096619,
-0.1280881017446518,
-0.6369551420211792,
0.5136391520500183,
-0.47043871879577637,
0.34744003415107727,
0.7001232504844666,
-0.10826773196458817,
-0.19177931547164917,
-0.37096109986305237,
-0.5083574056625366,
-1.086777925491333,
0.7306684255599976,
-0.042626649141311646,
0.18266992270946503,
0.3386455178260803,
0.5056799650192261,
-0.021458808332681656,
0.03905125707387924,
-0.5195697546005249,
-0.030273940414190292,
-0.016156351193785667,
-0.10527413338422775,
-0.16407299041748047,
-0.48089346289634705,
-0.24943006038665771,
-0.3030306100845337,
0.643435001373291,
-0.23431505262851715,
0.23392179608345032,
-0.0671728178858757,
-0.0919797271490097,
-0.4059670567512512,
0.3925052285194397,
0.5976268649101257,
0.7040239572525024,
-0.5968484282493591,
0.23169925808906555,
0.31613653898239136,
-0.5860210657119751,
-0.2198164463043213,
0.009844521060585976,
-0.18879424035549164,
-0.37400925159454346,
0.11322586983442307,
1.0653648376464844,
0.5800395011901855,
-0.4887441396713257,
0.32664239406585693,
0.19188763201236725,
-0.13067665696144104,
-0.3003036677837372,
0.5572769641876221,
0.19963310658931732,
0.23219622671604156,
0.32647737860679626,
0.18335071206092834,
0.015764953568577766,
-0.4231535792350769,
-0.43236255645751953,
0.6733969449996948,
-0.3816370666027069,
-0.1532854288816452,
0.7315694093704224,
-0.0951327532529831,
0.12698185443878174,
0.19012175500392914,
-0.026145827025175095,
-0.049119263887405396,
0.6414018869400024,
0.3039785623550415,
0.6780290007591248,
-0.1456884741783142,
-0.0936167910695076,
0.3345690071582794,
0.30382096767425537,
-0.3428713083267212,
0.16999125480651855,
-0.23458044230937958,
-0.6981276869773865,
-0.4926525950431824,
-0.6895193457603455,
-0.5695313215255737,
0.3976447582244873,
-0.6761723756790161,
0.19579476118087769,
-0.9518686532974243,
-0.08910714834928513,
0.02269165776669979,
-0.006284048315137625,
-0.5881766676902771,
0.04759247973561287,
0.23000970482826233,
0.716090738773346,
-0.7427545785903931,
1.2207095623016357,
0.5291110873222351,
-0.04021763801574707,
-0.8398845791816711,
-0.08829870074987411,
-0.18969431519508362,
-1.0453646183013916,
0.706965982913971,
-0.14239966869354248,
-0.3744146525859833,
-0.05483857914805412,
-0.49981918931007385,
-1.2611075639724731,
1.0843455791473389,
0.5267882943153381,
-0.7033442854881287,
-0.03415213152766228,
0.1658513993024826,
0.427664190530777,
-0.27428653836250305,
0.11076364666223526,
0.4860967695713043,
0.2589172124862671,
0.04721926897764206,
-0.6845720410346985,
-0.038507115095853806,
-0.27779117226600647,
0.35127687454223633,
0.26829639077186584,
-0.9257482886314392,
0.9725196957588196,
-0.2881254255771637,
0.14119702577590942,
-0.006019387859851122,
0.5181294083595276,
0.3232244849205017,
0.03992592170834541,
0.821631908416748,
0.6505861282348633,
0.7338657975196838,
0.16171711683273315,
0.9957970976829529,
-0.4349154233932495,
0.1355322152376175,
0.8894983530044556,
-0.17678943276405334,
1.0650475025177002,
0.5115558505058289,
-0.02552335150539875,
0.20941857993602753,
0.5955666303634644,
0.27131783962249756,
0.5114817023277283,
0.05374453589320183,
0.20123586058616638,
-0.6235442757606506,
0.1549416184425354,
-0.48629671335220337,
0.41940513253211975,
0.4383464753627777,
-0.37345463037490845,
-0.165455624461174,
-0.008566413074731827,
-0.004653474781662226,
-0.33398181200027466,
-0.5653478503227234,
0.527741014957428,
0.25035372376441956,
-0.48324325680732727,
0.8091186285018921,
-0.0650414228439331,
0.4096280634403229,
-0.620903491973877,
0.1595287024974823,
-0.15590666234493256,
0.5217856764793396,
-0.15597790479660034,
-0.3004433214664459,
-0.18522252142429352,
-0.2506410777568817,
-0.3581211268901825,
-0.09222166985273361,
0.6341124773025513,
-0.3008899986743927,
-0.7622776627540588,
0.3565015494823456,
0.4025086462497711,
0.13099491596221924,
-0.08821854740381241,
-0.6292845010757446,
0.1801818460226059,
-0.15723663568496704,
-0.4661655128002167,
0.8532244563102722,
0.3801144063472748,
-0.16720397770404816,
0.6911579370498657,
0.709346354007721,
0.4916799068450928,
0.06824096292257309,
0.36283689737319946,
0.9273369908332825,
-0.5765945315361023,
-0.5915004014968872,
-0.4861815273761749,
0.12887193262577057,
0.0837959572672844,
-0.2736128568649292,
0.6836105585098267,
0.4201676845550537,
0.6493681073188782,
0.21042421460151672,
0.6331124901771545,
0.25310391187667847,
0.6787320971488953,
-0.9324501752853394,
0.6626623272895813,
-0.8346506953239441,
0.5292489528656006,
-0.4655889868736267,
-1.1884268522262573,
-0.21678929030895233,
0.6050821542739868,
-0.4314265251159668,
0.11069023609161377,
0.4576965272426605,
0.5859744548797607,
-0.6359742879867554,
-0.1434096097946167,
0.4430866241455078,
0.3619547188282013,
0.17143243551254272,
0.7962812781333923,
0.6851077079772949,
-0.44877344369888306,
0.3033665418624878,
-0.17498667538166046,
-0.1557796746492386,
-0.5041099786758423,
-0.979216992855072,
-1.0111348628997803,
-0.5832481384277344,
-0.30710354447364807,
-0.273844450712204,
0.1486353576183319,
0.9668313264846802,
1.029221534729004,
-0.8806132078170776,
-0.04117404669523239,
0.2813774645328522,
-0.24763798713684082,
-0.4726148247718811,
-0.11248700320720673,
0.5615842938423157,
-0.30933621525764465,
-0.6588936448097229,
0.34746605157852173,
0.4046145975589752,
-0.24408455193042755,
-0.38733088970184326,
0.18393462896347046,
0.1206146627664566,
0.01042996346950531,
0.5521990656852722,
0.38886645436286926,
-0.7387675046920776,
-0.4405471980571747,
-0.34157174825668335,
-0.1236068457365036,
0.3751053512096405,
0.7053801417350769,
-0.5417367815971375,
0.07811231166124344,
0.2606503665447235,
1.0326991081237793,
0.7798627614974976,
-0.06847402453422546,
0.13666541874408722,
-0.635680079460144,
0.4266590178012848,
-0.024226965382695198,
0.391039103269577,
0.2784481346607208,
-0.5450787544250488,
0.36087051033973694,
-0.20075806975364685,
-0.581913411617279,
-0.8000934720039368,
-0.01808534748852253,
-1.530004858970642,
-0.32623934745788574,
1.1836897134780884,
0.15403716266155243,
-0.3989291787147522,
0.19040441513061523,
-0.13389991223812103,
-0.09859871864318848,
-0.38947367668151855,
1.1096673011779785,
0.5581119060516357,
-0.026874322444200516,
-0.4021959602832794,
-0.9922683835029602,
0.46042415499687195,
0.8086889982223511,
-0.6484373211860657,
0.03916449472308159,
0.23626525700092316,
0.2595093250274658,
0.04621366783976555,
0.5152188539505005,
0.16183015704154968,
0.13212503492832184,
-0.3804422914981842,
-0.03711525350809097,
-0.26081356406211853,
-0.3500460982322693,
-0.12926824390888214,
0.3364952504634857,
0.4362347424030304,
-0.031443387269973755
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15358v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15358v1
|
Introducing Syllable Tokenization for Low-resource Languages: A Case Study with Swahili
| 2024-03-26T17:26:50 | 2024-03-26T17:26:50 |
Jesse Atuhurra, Hiroyuki Shindo, Hidetaka Kamigaito, Taro Watanabe
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Many attempts have been made in multilingual NLP to ensure that pre-trained
language models, such as mBERT or GPT2 get better and become applicable to
low-resource languages. To achieve multilingualism for pre-trained language
models (PLMs), we need techniques to create word embeddings that capture the
linguistic characteristics of any language. Tokenization is one such technique
because it allows for the words to be split based on characters or subwords,
creating word embeddings that best represent the structure of the language.
Creating such word embeddings is essential to applying PLMs to other languages
where the model was not trained, enabling multilingual NLP. However, most PLMs
use generic tokenization methods like BPE, wordpiece, or unigram which may not
suit specific languages. We hypothesize that tokenization based on syllables
within the input text, which we call syllable tokenization, should facilitate
the development of syllable-aware language models. The syllable-aware language
models make it possible to apply PLMs to languages that are rich in syllables,
for instance, Swahili. Previous works introduced subword tokenization. Our work
extends such efforts. Notably, we propose a syllable tokenizer and adopt an
experiment-centric approach to validate the proposed tokenizer based on the
Swahili language. We conducted text-generation experiments with GPT2 to
evaluate the effectiveness of the syllable tokenizer. Our results show that the
proposed syllable tokenizer generates syllable embeddings that effectively
represent the Swahili language.
|
[
-0.42780250310897827,
-0.7489119172096252,
0.1546183079481125,
0.25342342257499695,
-0.6158528923988342,
-0.04998984932899475,
-0.24165165424346924,
-0.32421600818634033,
0.4144684076309204,
0.38806530833244324,
-0.10463161021471024,
-0.15595123171806335,
-0.5731251835823059,
0.030390731990337372,
-0.12755805253982544,
1.0109970569610596,
-0.25726598501205444,
0.2662945091724396,
0.04135841876268387,
-0.654053270816803,
-0.8787681460380554,
-0.9273843765258789,
-0.6658498048782349,
-0.4502401649951935,
0.5921857953071594,
0.35228124260902405,
0.5428804755210876,
0.3232719600200653,
0.14803604781627655,
0.2871234714984894,
-0.20609158277511597,
-0.117215096950531,
-0.08984740078449249,
-0.08890894055366516,
0.12378858029842377,
-0.7058733701705933,
-0.1369142234325409,
0.0585453137755394,
0.5083866119384766,
0.6153551936149597,
-0.2735385000705719,
0.30222609639167786,
0.0172160305082798,
0.26654618978500366,
-0.3579540550708771,
0.002389241475611925,
-0.7089062929153442,
0.13007310032844543,
-0.6038053631782532,
-0.1435038447380066,
-0.13034388422966003,
-0.20133043825626373,
-0.19400066137313843,
-0.26939353346824646,
0.12486791610717773,
0.12086069583892822,
0.7048377990722656,
0.11325289309024811,
-0.2996692359447479,
-0.23691995441913605,
-0.5090873837471008,
0.9430741667747498,
-0.8135606050491333,
0.3004762530326843,
0.5340642929077148,
0.18843016028404236,
-0.0664747878909111,
-0.8729763627052307,
-0.7315166592597961,
-0.09217935800552368,
-0.002132496563717723,
-0.04658955708146095,
-0.07376224547624588,
0.17280718684196472,
0.10951460152864456,
0.3966579735279083,
-0.41252148151397705,
0.3311331570148468,
-0.019526179879903793,
-0.24785186350345612,
0.06635891646146774,
-0.023720083758234978,
0.6017162203788757,
-0.40573468804359436,
-0.6778353452682495,
0.1749996840953827,
-0.6717724204063416,
0.36237064003944397,
0.5326725244522095,
0.545849621295929,
-0.07902507483959198,
0.8336705565452576,
0.09543800354003906,
0.3492683470249176,
-0.2779584228992462,
-0.2274557203054428,
0.05810492858290672,
-0.3122856318950653,
-0.0005170518415980041,
0.3111734986305237,
0.4592888057231903,
-0.07262493669986725,
0.3198935091495514,
0.06567555665969849,
-0.3945203125476837,
0.25507089495658875,
0.08907463401556015,
-1.1143981218338013,
0.022041697055101395,
0.31615519523620605,
-0.8585555553436279,
-0.27817732095718384,
-0.34431400895118713,
-0.4986710548400879,
-0.3419898450374603,
-0.05876636132597923,
0.582001268863678,
-0.545838475227356,
-0.3843485414981842,
-0.1825224906206131,
-0.3592388331890106,
0.2876104712486267,
-0.07541541755199432,
-1.0300378799438477,
0.17190228402614594,
0.8019452691078186,
0.9019332528114319,
0.012863856740295887,
-0.5519384741783142,
-0.4489930272102356,
-0.05928303301334381,
-0.28177356719970703,
0.5641168355941772,
-0.46762290596961975,
-0.6573888063430786,
0.045192278921604156,
-0.34407734870910645,
0.004993037320673466,
-0.5016833543777466,
0.6724880337715149,
-0.2742975652217865,
-0.051229026168584824,
-0.30360376834869385,
-0.5801771879196167,
-0.20468947291374207,
0.17675785720348358,
-0.4549775719642639,
1.2463549375534058,
0.2214319109916687,
-0.7870901823043823,
0.4551939070224762,
-0.7045438885688782,
-0.634104311466217,
0.37931135296821594,
-0.18909309804439545,
-0.2814107835292816,
0.5715838670730591,
0.11446401476860046,
0.09582753479480743,
-0.08709125965833664,
0.042839616537094116,
0.08302540332078934,
-0.42924168705940247,
0.43304282426834106,
-0.7175561189651489,
0.5572587251663208,
0.01968272775411606,
-0.45524707436561584,
0.10302028059959412,
-0.5404952764511108,
0.3807869255542755,
-0.015815958380699158,
-0.5318541526794434,
-0.451570063829422,
-0.027349796146154404,
0.4504914879798889,
0.0832701176404953,
0.21693366765975952,
-0.6509732604026794,
-0.04115292802453041,
-0.6022154092788696,
0.5986776947975159,
0.6157591938972473,
-0.12930719554424286,
0.21598771214485168,
-0.10727918893098831,
0.6563007831573486,
0.35438546538352966,
0.1901094764471054,
-0.18302331864833832,
-0.6125621795654297,
-1.063909888267517,
-0.4441843330860138,
0.913058340549469,
0.5949447154998779,
-0.8379563093185425,
0.24398380517959595,
0.029036415740847588,
-0.2139560580253601,
-0.8462337255477905,
0.19636595249176025,
0.25392279028892517,
0.3109560012817383,
0.5005857944488525,
-0.47305452823638916,
-0.6484807729721069,
-0.8866925239562988,
-0.2659323215484619,
-0.26821380853652954,
0.20239633321762085,
0.2009335607290268,
0.48866745829582214,
-0.21796894073486328,
0.8998585939407349,
-0.03129244223237038,
-0.4306893050670624,
-0.6084564328193665,
0.44339555501937866,
-0.033012181520462036,
0.5867580771446228,
0.5380306839942932,
-0.9087979793548584,
-0.2478288859128952,
-0.024607108905911446,
-0.20859187841415405,
-0.08242884278297424,
0.22518432140350342,
-0.07862824201583862,
0.35046520829200745,
0.20075812935829163,
-0.6430874466896057,
0.5825026035308838,
0.6834162473678589,
-0.22080154716968536,
0.5502676367759705,
-0.20567350089550018,
0.11062529683113098,
-1.2768498659133911,
0.18933948874473572,
-0.40320101380348206,
-0.151971235871315,
-0.7558203935623169,
0.034594208002090454,
-0.28261688351631165,
-0.5199496150016785,
-0.4547373950481415,
0.7023612856864929,
-0.4508199393749237,
-0.13041624426841736,
-0.5524390339851379,
0.08327602595090866,
-0.2339940220117569,
0.452632874250412,
0.14453183114528656,
0.8154205679893494,
0.21132732927799225,
-0.2520401179790497,
0.012683666311204433,
0.14159128069877625,
-0.3428952693939209,
0.5826416611671448,
-0.825073778629303,
-0.050223954021930695,
0.0571124330163002,
0.27118584513664246,
-0.791351318359375,
0.0983450785279274,
0.07566027343273163,
-0.39854753017425537,
0.2675803005695343,
-0.5840293765068054,
-0.42074865102767944,
-0.17180970311164856,
-0.285420298576355,
0.7647942304611206,
0.6087691783905029,
-0.46499374508857727,
0.5253506898880005,
0.5059158802032471,
-0.420746386051178,
-0.7276074886322021,
-0.8632953763008118,
0.24739523231983185,
-0.38750454783439636,
-0.2914583384990692,
0.2810349762439728,
0.08831290155649185,
-0.06538135558366776,
0.03742506727576256,
0.10344094783067703,
-0.2682023346424103,
0.2351822406053543,
0.3025077283382416,
0.1476048082113266,
-0.37644824385643005,
0.21209892630577087,
0.03801420331001282,
-0.3715738356113434,
-0.3698262572288513,
-0.4927975833415985,
0.9394387602806091,
-0.0719466507434845,
-0.4794579744338989,
-0.606296181678772,
0.6176626086235046,
0.3051964342594147,
-0.5655443072319031,
0.8588932156562805,
1.0694750547409058,
-0.5148769021034241,
-0.32519569993019104,
-0.6059927940368652,
0.009607371874153614,
-0.43271684646606445,
0.20736578106880188,
-0.5330309271812439,
-1.0367884635925293,
0.468410462141037,
-0.4044255018234253,
-0.14711149036884308,
0.26122570037841797,
0.5457454323768616,
-0.11188652366399765,
0.8176905512809753,
0.7845621109008789,
-0.26172563433647156,
0.5168269872665405,
-0.17310260236263275,
0.4297054409980774,
-0.8800879716873169,
0.1061064749956131,
-0.6674484610557556,
-0.4747774004936218,
-0.7212273478507996,
-0.7970917224884033,
0.14151251316070557,
0.5593419671058655,
0.2469559758901596,
0.17984363436698914,
-0.0975983589887619,
0.358463317155838,
0.6256970167160034,
-0.23509010672569275,
-0.2076987624168396,
0.0816071406006813,
-0.43850472569465637,
-0.15760207176208496,
-0.8014053702354431,
-0.624968409538269,
0.5814481377601624,
0.2070779651403427,
0.28649550676345825,
0.06351989507675171,
0.9555425047874451,
0.29973936080932617,
0.2546595335006714,
-1.1331015825271606,
0.4301915764808655,
-0.37223854660987854,
-0.2764491140842438,
-0.3912232518196106,
-0.25191643834114075,
-1.0353364944458008,
0.43365171551704407,
-0.06583835184574127,
-0.4504204988479614,
0.12877261638641357,
-0.022601468488574028,
-0.12238053232431412,
0.2623959481716156,
-0.5733346343040466,
0.9436169266700745,
-0.2260298728942871,
0.24153289198875427,
-0.4352478086948395,
-0.21230873465538025,
0.04325200244784355,
-0.05107295140624046,
0.28795531392097473,
-0.0366298109292984,
-0.20546071231365204,
0.6372035145759583,
-0.967282772064209,
1.0566258430480957,
-0.5446407794952393,
-0.02298193983733654,
0.6346950531005859,
-0.0549122653901577,
0.43390241265296936,
-0.13080380856990814,
-0.02343590557575226,
0.47064802050590515,
-0.020493904128670692,
-0.6496384143829346,
-0.33508190512657166,
0.5826151967048645,
-0.6183443069458008,
-0.4361455738544464,
-0.173904150724411,
-0.3873222768306732,
-0.26366743445396423,
0.2255239635705948,
0.18808293342590332,
0.640608012676239,
-0.3054754137992859,
0.10774081200361252,
0.3000437617301941,
-0.30322155356407166,
0.6611956357955933,
0.28073692321777344,
-0.09253530949354172,
-0.5341355800628662,
1.032921314239502,
0.3236393630504608,
-0.1599702537059784,
0.2470501959323883,
0.47748231887817383,
-0.33939260244369507,
-0.7626014351844788,
-0.7240118980407715,
0.048431072384119034,
-0.4723570644855499,
-0.10353940725326538,
-0.28490185737609863,
-0.05039519444108009,
-0.2502439618110657,
-0.11375810950994492,
-0.19886551797389984,
-0.6973693370819092,
-0.06935941427946091,
-0.06321915984153748,
0.1726822704076767,
0.5820623636245728,
-0.04128628969192505,
0.3465552031993866,
-0.9810216426849365,
0.2425568848848343,
0.26375922560691833,
0.17551839351654053,
0.13562069833278656,
-0.4646405577659607,
-0.29347264766693115,
-0.017598150297999382,
-0.0004304319736547768,
-0.5927810072898865,
0.16284839808940887,
0.23436516523361206,
0.6615110039710999,
0.13786357641220093,
-0.13899853825569153,
0.8710084557533264,
-0.7934518456459045,
1.0906168222427368,
0.31349945068359375,
-1.2423042058944702,
0.6389642953872681,
-0.0776001587510109,
0.03900250047445297,
0.5044302344322205,
0.17141002416610718,
-0.9248037338256836,
-0.25762349367141724,
-0.4728841483592987,
-1.0766270160675049,
0.4280347228050232,
0.20841249823570251,
0.5237051248550415,
-0.15357817709445953,
0.31486305594444275,
0.40035250782966614,
0.4024302065372467,
-0.576876163482666,
-0.1280369609594345,
-0.34769394993782043,
-0.3980920910835266,
-0.003142612287774682,
-0.6718171238899231,
0.04125535860657692,
0.11462011933326721,
0.6530969738960266,
-0.14906913042068481,
0.05668949708342552,
-0.030387355014681816,
-0.37415528297424316,
0.2057674080133438,
0.6069364547729492,
0.5387643575668335,
0.24564191699028015,
0.48818331956863403,
0.2413255125284195,
0.2676306366920471,
-0.6164149045944214,
0.263549268245697,
0.10952462255954742,
-0.32587307691574097,
0.25026851892471313,
0.2910357415676117,
1.1226454973220825,
0.3789610266685486,
-0.48122575879096985,
0.6304843425750732,
0.0902482271194458,
0.19185926020145416,
-0.10304659605026245,
-0.19728852808475494,
0.15645752847194672,
0.17995859682559967,
0.2239351123571396,
0.04166511446237564,
-0.11108820885419846,
-0.5366504788398743,
0.12998880445957184,
0.48648935556411743,
-0.28862661123275757,
-0.39877551794052124,
0.4901359975337982,
0.466017484664917,
-0.5216924548149109,
0.36711829900741577,
-0.06377094984054565,
-0.7532810568809509,
0.4209590256214142,
0.7096282839775085,
0.8544872999191284,
-0.31686803698539734,
0.38471677899360657,
0.21999171376228333,
0.2538858652114868,
0.04936479777097702,
0.4607534110546112,
-0.3578595221042633,
-0.65584796667099,
-0.213965505361557,
-1.0458675622940063,
-0.2911693751811981,
-0.01091344840824604,
-0.6036328077316284,
0.08595925569534302,
-0.329258531332016,
-0.6213219165802002,
-0.2564314603805542,
0.09736031293869019,
-0.578922688961029,
0.1246514543890953,
0.1819702535867691,
0.7712046504020691,
-0.7203603982925415,
1.007700800895691,
0.6864403486251831,
-0.4796687662601471,
-0.8632506728172302,
0.04439174756407738,
-0.35941579937934875,
-0.8869380950927734,
0.6225061416625977,
0.2569366693496704,
0.0428856797516346,
0.14482271671295166,
0.07951106131076813,
-0.5124898552894592,
0.9005532264709473,
0.15573959052562714,
-0.254413902759552,
0.31675219535827637,
0.572006106376648,
0.5803568363189697,
-0.15153440833091736,
0.08522693812847137,
0.21408000588417053,
0.4926756024360657,
-0.21841898560523987,
-0.8259652853012085,
-0.04025278985500336,
-0.09841791540384293,
0.5902356505393982,
0.3854898512363434,
-0.6714820265769958,
0.957706093788147,
-0.17289859056472778,
-0.3973906338214874,
0.5099257826805115,
0.7554436326026917,
0.14372441172599792,
0.1752077341079712,
0.5535577535629272,
0.6944921612739563,
0.8439070582389832,
-0.1363813728094101,
0.894411563873291,
-0.46764570474624634,
0.033958762884140015,
1.1111795902252197,
-0.34962594509124756,
1.2351380586624146,
0.7047783732414246,
-0.3014904260635376,
0.5688429474830627,
0.3953884541988373,
0.13400119543075562,
0.21175402402877808,
0.39880049228668213,
-0.5102763772010803,
-0.04927476868033409,
-0.7009789347648621,
-0.2672179639339447,
0.7322260737419128,
0.0926036387681961,
-0.13588570058345795,
-0.018236646428704262,
0.2241496443748474,
0.1022975891828537,
-0.12111461162567139,
-0.36544039845466614,
0.6254727840423584,
0.26723361015319824,
-0.335925817489624,
0.2656598687171936,
0.50359708070755,
0.9533675312995911,
-0.8714846968650818,
0.003705177456140518,
-0.35015568137168884,
0.04733751714229584,
-0.029094280675053596,
-0.4513118267059326,
0.07154729962348938,
0.3461759090423584,
-0.02577141672372818,
-0.09624338150024414,
0.9452944993972778,
-0.6847489476203918,
-0.41254499554634094,
0.1304115355014801,
0.6550414562225342,
0.2972801625728607,
0.1431090384721756,
-0.5737642049789429,
0.09124623984098434,
-0.35940122604370117,
-0.2371249943971634,
0.5590411424636841,
0.5350561141967773,
-0.29173725843429565,
0.29739120602607727,
0.8061602115631104,
0.4966742992401123,
0.10088732093572617,
0.5225829482078552,
0.41808855533599854,
-0.5562458634376526,
-0.6605514883995056,
-0.7705668210983276,
0.3777109384536743,
0.2332170307636261,
-0.4411899447441101,
0.8527616858482361,
0.5522173047065735,
0.6249849200248718,
-0.049361489713191986,
0.7967484593391418,
-0.1209314838051796,
0.1764613837003708,
-0.430308073759079,
0.7897279858589172,
-0.5249820351600647,
-0.1781078279018402,
0.11136721074581146,
-0.7689861059188843,
0.10834597796201706,
0.48231378197669983,
0.2600981593132019,
-0.031734928488731384,
0.5555195212364197,
0.5793771147727966,
0.24651412665843964,
-0.02890215441584587,
0.3707723915576935,
-0.015466857701539993,
0.05452172830700874,
0.1967652589082718,
0.8543030023574829,
-0.4698031544685364,
0.5393282771110535,
-0.16855645179748535,
-0.038468293845653534,
-0.0012089021038264036,
-0.8420365452766418,
-0.8384070992469788,
-0.5152122378349304,
-0.026498833671212196,
-0.051195256412029266,
-0.1875505894422531,
0.8725180625915527,
0.4879169464111328,
-0.9196720123291016,
-0.2159944474697113,
0.06816908717155457,
0.02882234752178192,
-0.27924618124961853,
-0.23095455765724182,
0.25965946912765503,
-0.4982280135154724,
-0.7223033308982849,
0.5174290537834167,
0.2827773094177246,
0.35425785183906555,
-0.2917456328868866,
-0.0046852570958435535,
-0.006798549089580774,
0.2842003405094147,
0.75136399269104,
0.21059757471084595,
-0.7904887795448303,
-0.4319198429584503,
-0.5298434495925903,
-0.07042431831359863,
-0.10039740055799484,
1.212967872619629,
-0.7038427591323853,
0.2319783717393875,
0.4847186207771301,
0.651573657989502,
0.19392317533493042,
-0.02664613537490368,
0.43983423709869385,
-0.9895428419113159,
0.5876240134239197,
0.15257452428340912,
0.5751404166221619,
0.4454241394996643,
-0.09325195103883743,
0.430846631526947,
0.46653270721435547,
-0.1840975284576416,
-1.0280284881591797,
0.2704502046108246,
-0.7923596501350403,
-0.2343142330646515,
1.035709261894226,
-0.3198907971382141,
-0.12072015553712845,
-0.14477024972438812,
-0.40995293855667114,
0.41418859362602234,
-0.012245368212461472,
0.5377141237258911,
0.7409385442733765,
0.04050346836447716,
0.21840649843215942,
-0.43523427844047546,
0.4669266641139984,
0.5797320008277893,
-0.7581952810287476,
0.013361024670302868,
0.11191397160291672,
0.28334975242614746,
0.10912594944238663,
0.8403031826019287,
-0.10174355655908585,
0.024923032149672508,
0.4084203541278839,
0.16336916387081146,
-0.07140903174877167,
-0.03276553750038147,
-0.3662847876548767,
0.18060420453548431,
0.3563072979450226,
-0.39039838314056396
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17887v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17887v1
|
The Unreasonable Ineffectiveness of the Deeper Layers
| 2024-03-26T17:20:04 | 2024-03-26T17:20:04 |
Andrey Gromov, Kushal Tirumala, Hassan Shapourian, Paolo Glorioso, Daniel A. Roberts
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, stat.ML
|
We empirically study a simple layer-pruning strategy for popular families of
open-weight pretrained LLMs, finding minimal degradation of performance on
different question-answering benchmarks until after a large fraction (up to
half) of the layers are removed. To prune these models, we identify the optimal
block of layers to prune by considering similarity across layers; then, to
"heal" the damage, we perform a small amount of finetuning. In particular, we
use parameter-efficient finetuning (PEFT) methods, specifically quantization
and Low Rank Adapters (QLoRA), such that each of our experiments can be
performed on a single A100 GPU. From a practical perspective, these results
suggest that layer pruning methods can complement other PEFT strategies to
further reduce computational resources of finetuning on the one hand, and can
improve the memory and latency of inference on the other hand. From a
scientific perspective, the robustness of these LLMs to the deletion of layers
implies either that current pretraining methods are not properly leveraging the
parameters in the deeper layers of the network or that the shallow layers play
a critical role in storing knowledge.
|
[
-0.7762590050697327,
-1.0520812273025513,
0.5151957869529724,
-0.0577373169362545,
-0.4110984802246094,
-0.025798777118325233,
-0.14005130529403687,
-0.19288887083530426,
-0.12299500405788422,
0.49751466512680054,
-0.5998859405517578,
-0.10821764171123505,
-0.24489955604076385,
-0.22807130217552185,
-0.3695325255393982,
1.0325696468353271,
0.003322022967040539,
-0.10237399488687515,
-0.42355018854141235,
0.07999695837497711,
-0.22173409163951874,
-0.40754902362823486,
-0.9795988202095032,
-0.4015422761440277,
0.7370049953460693,
0.5944658517837524,
0.6345170736312866,
0.5693482160568237,
0.5211604833602905,
0.22545106709003448,
-0.203168585896492,
0.2656092345714569,
-0.8448820114135742,
-0.18118630349636078,
0.05963248386979103,
-0.684635579586029,
-0.3836018741130829,
0.13136062026023865,
0.7252915501594543,
0.9147483110427856,
-0.27454888820648193,
0.239222452044487,
0.23991809785366058,
0.8480220437049866,
-0.7085961103439331,
-0.5404520034790039,
-0.6276535987854004,
0.25428053736686707,
-0.15408173203468323,
-0.33954232931137085,
-0.1636216938495636,
-0.41059091687202454,
0.2363884449005127,
-0.5578210353851318,
0.3481062054634094,
-0.015583191998302937,
0.7718557715415955,
0.42212021350860596,
-0.1543779969215393,
0.37916821241378784,
-0.9109057188034058,
0.7603870630264282,
-0.6198215484619141,
0.133838951587677,
0.38155895471572876,
0.2857215404510498,
0.24500690400600433,
-0.8746514320373535,
-0.19810910522937775,
-0.11713152378797531,
0.03628746047616005,
0.23931565880775452,
0.1379414051771164,
0.30621689558029175,
0.4437936246395111,
0.6203470826148987,
-0.27805858850479126,
0.29591628909111023,
-0.6172758340835571,
-0.20590625703334808,
0.4492277503013611,
-0.03647193685173988,
0.2872195243835449,
0.10746733844280243,
-0.6170473694801331,
-0.12314591556787491,
-1.1064636707305908,
0.27906596660614014,
0.5691470503807068,
-0.002074708230793476,
0.42173948884010315,
0.45696941018104553,
0.011720067821443081,
0.4208582639694214,
0.02042684145271778,
-0.044819414615631104,
-0.11810944974422455,
-0.1736157089471817,
-0.6542303562164307,
0.07116711884737015,
0.5097159147262573,
0.27375534176826477,
0.3547302186489105,
-0.4269263744354248,
-0.13536661863327026,
-0.16678066551685333,
0.4388643503189087,
-0.8633316159248352,
-0.48177027702331543,
0.3819112479686737,
-0.4330463707447052,
-0.3169403076171875,
-0.0396965928375721,
-0.38373881578445435,
-0.1650417596101761,
-0.14164870977401733,
0.5833141207695007,
-0.5306016802787781,
-0.26436957716941833,
0.13893355429172516,
-0.18944573402404785,
0.3768056631088257,
0.4497162103652954,
-0.39554470777511597,
0.7088901400566101,
0.7637744545936584,
0.6342827677726746,
0.0241630207747221,
-0.3128083646297455,
-0.44411540031433105,
0.17568019032478333,
-0.35642707347869873,
0.5309711694717407,
-0.19782844185829163,
-0.24495381116867065,
-0.6020662188529968,
0.12719444930553436,
-0.21222561597824097,
-0.8318350315093994,
0.9013701677322388,
-0.5933797955513,
0.22753170132637024,
-0.5852213501930237,
-0.5218105912208557,
-0.32527804374694824,
0.3436249792575836,
-0.7388293743133545,
0.6766217350959778,
-0.14522626996040344,
-0.6618785262107849,
0.11857651174068451,
-0.36703211069107056,
-0.37254998087882996,
-0.06498340517282486,
0.1953573375940323,
-0.6466325521469116,
0.4258042573928833,
0.23773054778575897,
0.4356693923473358,
-0.44607052206993103,
0.1950615495443344,
-0.297244668006897,
-0.5854976773262024,
-0.010234253481030464,
-0.46785101294517517,
0.755992591381073,
0.41114673018455505,
-0.27005770802497864,
-0.12542420625686646,
-0.6273564696311951,
0.3059021830558777,
0.2600671350955963,
-0.3157537877559662,
-0.3421688377857208,
0.12189789861440659,
-0.30933046340942383,
0.13648194074630737,
-0.08625531941652298,
-0.6139479279518127,
0.0010636685183271766,
-0.6118671298027039,
0.9854421019554138,
0.9334012269973755,
0.1330411434173584,
0.599482536315918,
-0.6097414493560791,
0.5122748613357544,
0.24159224331378937,
0.2906762659549713,
0.19258466362953186,
0.14142289757728577,
-0.8160740733146667,
-0.07406771183013916,
0.3285232186317444,
0.5411444902420044,
-0.5834307670593262,
-0.03968257084488869,
-0.18948356807231903,
-0.5130515694618225,
-0.38637787103652954,
0.23434042930603027,
0.6162795424461365,
0.7470376491546631,
0.48067617416381836,
-0.4113425314426422,
-0.2357816994190216,
-1.1989238262176514,
-0.3872476816177368,
0.05123019218444824,
-0.08144132792949677,
0.3752589225769043,
0.22619988024234772,
0.20222365856170654,
0.6393836736679077,
-0.2780664265155792,
-0.17163801193237305,
0.1205211728811264,
-0.2870875895023346,
-0.05191921442747116,
0.8903223276138306,
0.3807690441608429,
-0.6655325889587402,
-0.14844883978366852,
-0.2100365161895752,
-0.5109422206878662,
0.35731610655784607,
-0.11907598376274109,
-0.1848384141921997,
-0.35512861609458923,
0.4316962957382202,
-0.7652514576911926,
0.17897425591945648,
0.01716269925236702,
0.2343183308839798,
0.5785630345344543,
-0.07555873692035675,
-0.10201449692249298,
-0.41884610056877136,
-0.047093797475099564,
0.06362804025411606,
-0.20265449583530426,
-0.5947993993759155,
0.14443406462669373,
0.004943361040204763,
-0.16031719744205475,
-0.5218292474746704,
0.2556343972682953,
-0.5562692284584045,
0.03812452033162117,
0.10416620969772339,
-0.0386771559715271,
0.43540123105049133,
0.4801776111125946,
-0.2108098268508911,
0.7254999876022339,
0.34990185499191284,
-0.6540043354034424,
0.1533345729112625,
-0.032611750066280365,
-0.41401761770248413,
0.30417245626449585,
-0.949050784111023,
0.4672851860523224,
-0.2943800985813141,
-0.09653609991073608,
-0.9242475628852844,
-0.017124032601714134,
0.18728643655776978,
-0.0804017186164856,
0.35042789578437805,
-0.19416970014572144,
-0.32882124185562134,
-0.37509244680404663,
-0.5594888925552368,
0.6097169518470764,
0.6003325581550598,
-0.4587540030479431,
0.4151884913444519,
0.19813257455825806,
-0.15718884766101837,
-0.538692057132721,
-0.994076669216156,
-0.19470927119255066,
-0.6928396821022034,
-0.7360446453094482,
0.4746190011501312,
-0.0837249904870987,
-0.14015790820121765,
0.04440771043300629,
-0.5763130784034729,
-0.28431737422943115,
0.4996453523635864,
0.0877259224653244,
-0.18141521513462067,
-0.49823877215385437,
0.026326993480324745,
0.1610265076160431,
0.05465712025761604,
0.32014700770378113,
-0.3505014181137085,
0.46854519844055176,
-0.2873310148715973,
-0.5341402888298035,
-0.419335275888443,
0.19353920221328735,
0.17528869211673737,
-0.34816792607307434,
0.5876967906951904,
0.5596520304679871,
-0.37472087144851685,
-0.3974856734275818,
-0.7301139235496521,
-0.237538143992424,
-0.5163345336914062,
0.21664687991142273,
-0.39066311717033386,
-0.8917788863182068,
0.5040389895439148,
-0.3751120865345001,
-0.03833527863025665,
0.3596356213092804,
0.0024157678708434105,
-0.3941057622432709,
0.762541651725769,
0.3220985531806946,
0.08812513947486877,
0.29074257612228394,
-0.5757941007614136,
0.07864916324615479,
-0.9708845019340515,
-0.03738563135266304,
-0.30004796385765076,
-0.7400584816932678,
-0.17636637389659882,
-0.1516246646642685,
0.2360047847032547,
0.6610468029975891,
-0.5080869793891907,
-0.12557727098464966,
-0.7297428846359253,
0.7514969706535339,
0.8167846202850342,
0.7109680771827698,
0.022718073800206184,
0.3170783221721649,
0.054733119904994965,
0.15460588037967682,
-0.9514028429985046,
-0.45892471075057983,
0.9235614538192749,
0.5180273056030273,
0.6084169149398804,
-0.16380421817302704,
0.829541802406311,
-0.2375970035791397,
0.12573090195655823,
-0.668603777885437,
0.5846811532974243,
-0.16720081865787506,
-0.5868081450462341,
-0.5877758264541626,
-0.5651095509529114,
-0.8032166361808777,
0.10094378143548965,
0.05721452087163925,
-0.37299326062202454,
0.31863996386528015,
0.3519198000431061,
-0.7900793552398682,
0.6517229080200195,
-0.9807418584823608,
0.8027754426002502,
-0.42368388175964355,
-0.7039521336555481,
-0.09530539065599442,
-0.6689467430114746,
0.408281147480011,
0.0624573789536953,
-0.045001767575740814,
-0.09333697706460953,
-0.0707603469491005,
0.9463343024253845,
-0.7514100074768066,
0.7321119904518127,
-0.5632026791572571,
0.07204510271549225,
0.5857993364334106,
0.15192681550979614,
0.3400419056415558,
0.10446848720312119,
-0.006212244741618633,
-0.03952285274863243,
0.28183117508888245,
-0.7042458653450012,
-0.48847851157188416,
0.6303006410598755,
-1.0200283527374268,
-0.71242356300354,
0.02361205779016018,
-0.25581634044647217,
-0.34539994597435,
0.2542792558670044,
0.3205389976501465,
0.523844838142395,
-0.23407767713069916,
0.4511362314224243,
0.8386042714118958,
-0.339181512594223,
0.3666898012161255,
0.06634780019521713,
0.24737770855426788,
-0.4300670623779297,
1.0623960494995117,
0.4925762414932251,
0.32709965109825134,
0.34440839290618896,
0.28868886828422546,
0.10687386244535446,
-1.1239148378372192,
0.08848179131746292,
0.10263321548700333,
-0.5902965664863586,
-0.17974428832530975,
-0.3784680664539337,
-0.5108701586723328,
0.03264644742012024,
-0.039969466626644135,
-0.3637264668941498,
-0.47331151366233826,
-0.2876264154911041,
-0.3314361870288849,
-0.067072793841362,
0.27033981680870056,
0.14981397986412048,
0.6970474720001221,
-0.6394266486167908,
0.2439338117837906,
0.5358304381370544,
0.4197807312011719,
0.23615744709968567,
-0.3266506493091583,
-0.07364524155855179,
0.051799315959215164,
-0.4117923378944397,
-0.4578287601470947,
0.2219025045633316,
0.44495099782943726,
0.7101327180862427,
0.45698678493499756,
0.2010418325662613,
0.8592312335968018,
-0.46878254413604736,
0.5954439640045166,
0.24492761492729187,
-0.6249512434005737,
0.45826277136802673,
-0.14420905709266663,
0.24927298724651337,
0.8128421306610107,
0.5469138026237488,
-0.0028566145338118076,
-0.029276691377162933,
-0.8195551633834839,
-0.8908608555793762,
0.5743024945259094,
0.03451209515333176,
0.05063832178711891,
0.1555124670267105,
0.7736206650733948,
0.12084927409887314,
0.4034377634525299,
-0.6546086072921753,
-0.2576799690723419,
-0.19623041152954102,
0.06842216849327087,
-0.1806686967611313,
-0.5128728747367859,
-0.5109293460845947,
-0.5179346799850464,
0.47788387537002563,
0.021739423274993896,
0.3182523548603058,
0.48238903284072876,
-0.24603290855884552,
-0.09106375277042389,
0.2012462168931961,
0.2103441208600998,
0.8933966755867004,
-0.3755244016647339,
0.3772617280483246,
0.22915340960025787,
-0.49409908056259155,
0.07943116873502731,
0.012889065779745579,
-0.32941943407058716,
-0.5888572931289673,
0.3838770091533661,
0.7793051600456238,
0.09083282947540283,
-0.33132511377334595,
0.2364407777786255,
-0.05448678135871887,
-0.5124999284744263,
-0.15680088102817535,
0.25825265049934387,
0.07096688449382782,
0.20772869884967804,
0.3103709816932678,
0.39645838737487793,
0.05445585772395134,
-0.3578636348247528,
0.13966047763824463,
0.6071362495422363,
-0.5015689134597778,
-0.279991090297699,
0.5551180243492126,
0.16267992556095123,
-0.2430991530418396,
0.6958594918251038,
0.24730472266674042,
-0.40561792254447937,
0.8137224912643433,
0.14115427434444427,
0.7069015502929688,
0.003138084663078189,
0.2289268523454666,
0.22694268822669983,
0.6823282837867737,
-0.22663933038711548,
0.0021824927534908056,
-0.12285362929105759,
-0.6812069416046143,
-0.6190920472145081,
-0.5200400948524475,
-0.15813800692558289,
0.38366493582725525,
-0.7385169863700867,
-0.17472878098487854,
-1.0194064378738403,
-0.16917960345745087,
0.007968476042151451,
0.37086525559425354,
-0.7641775608062744,
0.43478357791900635,
0.04247777536511421,
1.0223314762115479,
-0.7003014087677002,
0.7914419174194336,
0.6392996311187744,
-0.3572249412536621,
-1.0433974266052246,
-0.29647698998451233,
-0.27848514914512634,
-0.797522246837616,
0.39402881264686584,
0.06840471178293228,
0.11413922905921936,
0.2907329201698303,
-0.8040657639503479,
-0.6703218817710876,
1.2071201801300049,
0.7254750728607178,
-0.5845118165016174,
-0.279394268989563,
0.05127909407019615,
0.2741509675979614,
0.08613421022891998,
0.20110821723937988,
0.5047690868377686,
0.40173450112342834,
-0.03356947749853134,
-0.6903876662254333,
0.1725890189409256,
-0.32645300030708313,
-0.18714214861392975,
0.16029679775238037,
-0.8829301595687866,
1.124519944190979,
-0.0989520326256752,
-0.370878666639328,
-0.0018242235528305173,
0.29526254534721375,
0.006146587897092104,
0.3166947066783905,
0.7050809264183044,
0.819715142250061,
0.9147777557373047,
-0.13888126611709595,
1.0798749923706055,
-0.12368680536746979,
0.16659177839756012,
1.0004945993423462,
0.0868513435125351,
0.524152398109436,
0.5561160445213318,
-0.3056829273700714,
0.08982790261507034,
0.8051856160163879,
0.00551945436745882,
0.6317697167396545,
0.2941996157169342,
-0.017022723332047462,
-0.4886646270751953,
0.26515376567840576,
-0.38113516569137573,
0.063145712018013,
0.09979908168315887,
-0.20573735237121582,
-0.14916086196899414,
-0.04631425067782402,
-0.14187157154083252,
-0.17416831851005554,
-0.6087874174118042,
0.7511047124862671,
0.3899029493331909,
-0.6286404728889465,
0.8127669095993042,
-0.2616956830024719,
0.4640849232673645,
-0.4614795446395874,
0.30954453349113464,
-0.33151859045028687,
0.2542043626308441,
-0.40056002140045166,
-0.47951048612594604,
0.1598864048719406,
-0.5633601546287537,
-0.11662223190069199,
-0.35607120394706726,
1.0282717943191528,
-0.12665262818336487,
-0.3504175841808319,
0.20698289573192596,
0.883315920829773,
0.09147204458713531,
-0.3138108551502228,
-0.8147056102752686,
-0.0871599093079567,
-0.11599884182214737,
-0.5799039602279663,
0.6015210747718811,
0.5544794201850891,
0.09567834436893463,
0.7706784605979919,
0.6591182947158813,
0.23635946214199066,
0.1843896359205246,
0.040083885192871094,
1.1670385599136353,
-0.5623580813407898,
-0.22944240272045135,
-0.8074028491973877,
0.29859912395477295,
-0.09379401057958603,
-0.12924185395240784,
0.7905588746070862,
0.46822747588157654,
0.9610192775726318,
0.17042961716651917,
0.5258511900901794,
0.31052061915397644,
0.3644859790802002,
-0.6087953448295593,
0.5709004402160645,
-0.7401715517044067,
0.5698984861373901,
-0.2602995038032532,
-1.076192855834961,
-0.015038980171084404,
0.4062158465385437,
-0.4892193377017975,
0.16303952038288116,
0.6915915012359619,
0.49783799052238464,
-0.34204164147377014,
0.11801280081272125,
0.24970293045043945,
0.3800833225250244,
0.12124544382095337,
0.8062689900398254,
0.953575611114502,
-0.33534276485443115,
0.6112796664237976,
-0.867337167263031,
-0.08340289443731308,
0.15235541760921478,
-0.7965114116668701,
-0.7801151871681213,
-0.13623693585395813,
-0.38533979654312134,
-0.10842311382293701,
0.004956081975251436,
0.2246067374944687,
0.8130249977111816,
-0.6073958873748779,
-0.06231771036982536,
-0.16465100646018982,
0.11888505518436432,
-0.41346192359924316,
-0.20867860317230225,
0.4833777844905853,
-0.1068587675690651,
-0.21367469429969788,
0.36163291335105896,
0.02963431365787983,
-0.03691314160823822,
-0.16171970963478088,
0.09902939945459366,
-0.1865309774875641,
-0.15449266135692596,
0.6224008202552795,
0.3682023286819458,
-0.589337944984436,
-0.41794633865356445,
-0.002096649957820773,
0.10567760467529297,
0.011311476118862629,
0.7249370813369751,
-0.8305646181106567,
-0.03187662735581398,
0.43528372049331665,
0.8794764876365662,
0.6377161145210266,
0.4126606583595276,
0.46164754033088684,
-0.7503408789634705,
0.12167719751596451,
0.5476572513580322,
0.16771522164344788,
0.1399543285369873,
-0.33166930079460144,
0.5262579917907715,
0.12488493323326111,
-0.7395840883255005,
-1.1165292263031006,
-0.017746686935424805,
-0.8952223658561707,
-0.5929568409919739,
0.7597898840904236,
-0.21688222885131836,
-0.49433964490890503,
0.22353480756282806,
-0.15045738220214844,
0.03656872361898422,
0.11931838095188141,
0.4816408157348633,
0.5385082960128784,
-0.11731968075037003,
-0.5957192778587341,
-0.7140330672264099,
0.5958886742591858,
0.8119698166847229,
-0.6362095475196838,
-0.22744634747505188,
0.45108217000961304,
0.48134058713912964,
0.09260200709104538,
0.6516536474227905,
0.02489769645035267,
0.040380656719207764,
-0.10416971892118454,
-0.41103941202163696,
-0.47034794092178345,
-0.476826548576355,
-0.23850850760936737,
0.7078880667686462,
0.19575057923793793,
0.038931261748075485
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17860v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17860v2
|
Exploring LLMs as a Source of Targeted Synthetic Textual Data to Minimize High Confidence Misclassifications
| 2024-03-26T16:49:25 | 2024-04-02T12:25:57 |
Philip Lippmann, Matthijs T. J. Spaan, Jie Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Natural Language Processing (NLP) models optimized for predictive performance
often make high confidence errors and suffer from vulnerability to adversarial
and out-of-distribution data. Existing work has mainly focused on mitigation of
such errors using either humans or an automated approach. In this study, we
explore the usage of large language models (LLMs) for data augmentation as a
potential solution to the issue of NLP models making wrong predictions with
high confidence during classification tasks. We compare the effectiveness of
synthetic data generated by LLMs with that of human data obtained via the same
procedure. For mitigation, humans or LLMs provide natural language
characterizations of high confidence misclassifications to generate synthetic
data, which are then used to extend the training set. We conduct an extensive
evaluation of our approach on three classification tasks and demonstrate its
effectiveness in reducing the number of high confidence misclassifications
present in the model, all while maintaining the same level of accuracy.
Moreover, we find that the cost gap between humans and LLMs surpasses an order
of magnitude, as LLMs attain human-like performance while being more scalable.
|
[
-0.2921895384788513,
-0.8490538597106934,
0.5645425915718079,
0.016096292063593864,
0.19850672781467438,
0.332367479801178,
-0.5063564777374268,
-0.7161401510238647,
0.003733742982149124,
0.681789755821228,
-0.4893360733985901,
-0.4958716630935669,
-0.5009166598320007,
0.33365723490715027,
-0.3644719123840332,
0.7330594658851624,
0.05508890748023987,
-0.008059581741690636,
-0.3559114933013916,
0.33905914425849915,
-0.3394677937030792,
-0.9853450655937195,
-0.5858968496322632,
-0.5370218753814697,
0.5844671726226807,
0.2899010479450226,
0.9659496545791626,
0.7094191908836365,
0.545638918876648,
0.24495111405849457,
-0.026368511840701103,
0.6973860859870911,
-0.4146657884120941,
0.1067211702466011,
-0.22165250778198242,
-0.6695848107337952,
-0.43760666251182556,
0.027315884828567505,
0.7247565984725952,
0.8445027470588684,
-0.05175623297691345,
-0.0000382629077648744,
0.296736478805542,
0.5246846079826355,
-0.7620906233787537,
0.0022523740772157907,
-0.6994682550430298,
0.055083684623241425,
-0.11407932639122009,
-0.4070962965488434,
-0.6657800078392029,
-0.3046552538871765,
0.15952938795089722,
-0.6087533235549927,
0.45532113313674927,
0.2350636124610901,
0.5865024328231812,
0.44283372163772583,
-0.14016063511371613,
-0.150641068816185,
-0.9530131816864014,
1.029985785484314,
-0.7662131190299988,
0.18393561244010925,
0.5494261384010315,
0.232887864112854,
-0.5478143692016602,
-0.33221644163131714,
-0.6845359802246094,
-0.27104032039642334,
-0.21087594330310822,
-0.1536182314157486,
-0.03369111940264702,
0.16449138522148132,
0.28337040543556213,
0.2622797191143036,
-0.5710346698760986,
0.3842855989933014,
-0.21594667434692383,
-0.48591184616088867,
0.9406031370162964,
0.18600045144557953,
0.2593967914581299,
-0.25305700302124023,
-0.25798457860946655,
-0.26860588788986206,
-0.8179218173027039,
-0.30882805585861206,
0.48671862483024597,
0.5173687934875488,
0.2702329754829407,
0.905066192150116,
-0.12561237812042236,
0.6622504591941833,
-0.35741832852363586,
-0.24617315828800201,
0.17855459451675415,
-0.39812156558036804,
-0.2662556767463684,
0.09428779035806656,
0.6920026540756226,
0.33012792468070984,
0.45700356364250183,
-0.17485076189041138,
-0.24476756155490875,
0.45842134952545166,
0.4108637869358063,
-0.5682580471038818,
0.026755960658192635,
0.010436665266752243,
-0.06773027777671814,
-0.5622092485427856,
-0.0827840194106102,
-0.5913266539573669,
-0.47723302245140076,
-0.5756093263626099,
0.38640525937080383,
-0.36032605171203613,
0.1620115041732788,
0.31391194462776184,
0.027087315917015076,
-0.09544254094362259,
0.368995726108551,
-0.8240551352500916,
0.3167068064212799,
0.6587405204772949,
0.6113362908363342,
-0.4295145273208618,
-0.14090321958065033,
-0.39762449264526367,
0.36058926582336426,
-0.6110309958457947,
0.5358797311782837,
-0.39831751585006714,
-0.44061335921287537,
0.021749522536993027,
-0.0922585129737854,
-0.044458985328674316,
-0.6754944324493408,
0.9970422983169556,
-0.28364133834838867,
0.3009111285209656,
0.1744796633720398,
-0.6606430411338806,
-0.0643390417098999,
0.4120440185070038,
-0.708710789680481,
1.3112069368362427,
0.0331525020301342,
-0.7382031679153442,
0.1544915735721588,
-0.5356031060218811,
-0.4344073235988617,
-0.006331511307507753,
-0.03571613132953644,
-0.3533967137336731,
-0.036250051110982895,
0.30628731846809387,
0.6625800728797913,
-0.4933021664619446,
0.35358285903930664,
-0.17295397818088531,
-0.5820953249931335,
0.4192870855331421,
-0.712142825126648,
0.2591548562049866,
-0.022615574300289154,
-0.11650663614273071,
-0.10709662735462189,
-0.9247704148292542,
-0.0022133083548396826,
0.06416649371385574,
-0.6385564804077148,
-0.5072862505912781,
-0.024169327691197395,
0.07024645060300827,
0.19244317710399628,
0.09903603047132492,
-0.5143659710884094,
0.2091957926750183,
-0.766867458820343,
-0.047892697155475616,
0.7928245067596436,
0.004053369164466858,
0.44617369771003723,
-0.5902456045150757,
0.3931407630443573,
-0.24647939205169678,
0.012114988639950752,
0.005388558376580477,
-0.4057784974575043,
-0.7906447052955627,
-0.15932215750217438,
0.46036073565483093,
0.590297281742096,
-0.9024181365966797,
0.6965975165367126,
-0.4479341208934784,
-0.517677366733551,
-0.5455891489982605,
0.35594090819358826,
0.21537739038467407,
0.4989378750324249,
0.45652151107788086,
0.008174043148756027,
-0.7939667105674744,
-0.9611406326293945,
-0.4246874153614044,
-0.08085640519857407,
-0.4189872145652771,
-0.04224832355976105,
0.3429192006587982,
-0.5461969375610352,
1.100783348083496,
-0.5049142837524414,
-0.2547290027141571,
-0.32212239503860474,
0.11778274178504944,
-0.1235131174325943,
0.49370115995407104,
0.28514862060546875,
-0.6645498871803284,
-0.29190149903297424,
-0.08551959693431854,
-0.6217499375343323,
-0.04599136486649513,
-0.3188367784023285,
-0.10992671549320221,
0.4992021322250366,
0.2865939438343048,
-0.6821739673614502,
0.5218963027000427,
0.4647924602031708,
0.009857348166406155,
0.4968870282173157,
-0.2920691668987274,
-0.018069902434945107,
-1.1249758005142212,
-0.16124433279037476,
0.3560657501220703,
-0.29137730598449707,
-0.742591381072998,
-0.2061442732810974,
0.04706442356109619,
0.11080289632081985,
-0.21095134317874908,
0.47716042399406433,
-0.25880226492881775,
0.013034725561738014,
-0.3141438961029053,
0.007577143609523773,
0.12080365419387817,
0.3415181338787079,
0.19991923868656158,
0.7380377650260925,
0.36759647727012634,
-0.7020515203475952,
0.4234081506729126,
0.22216512262821198,
-0.2353920191526413,
0.39576274156570435,
-0.463340163230896,
0.0735127329826355,
-0.22739113867282867,
0.4010060131549835,
-0.7125738263130188,
-0.5846216678619385,
0.1298096626996994,
-0.6210998296737671,
0.43527060747146606,
0.009061766788363457,
-0.817876935005188,
-0.294732004404068,
-0.3944535255432129,
0.04117840155959129,
0.5432950258255005,
-0.6189294457435608,
0.5611331462860107,
0.219191312789917,
-0.13419018685817719,
-0.5640547871589661,
-1.0539571046829224,
0.352741539478302,
-0.20904326438903809,
-0.6987590193748474,
0.6349887847900391,
0.006984436884522438,
-0.2163739949464798,
-0.24442069232463837,
0.16671715676784515,
0.19738973677158356,
0.1032618060708046,
0.19823360443115234,
0.668581485748291,
0.06683189421892166,
0.5804855823516846,
-0.1355355978012085,
-0.10864754766225815,
0.14123816788196564,
-0.1429879516363144,
0.48639115691185,
0.2765333354473114,
-0.4011913537979126,
-0.5388079881668091,
0.20832327008247375,
0.39519163966178894,
0.05435735359787941,
1.048502802848816,
0.5878999829292297,
-0.6298457384109497,
-0.40586140751838684,
-0.7092723250389099,
-0.3841079771518707,
-0.4729953706264496,
0.37196964025497437,
-0.01664750836789608,
-0.5996087789535522,
-0.0016522551886737347,
-0.07094893604516983,
0.042614296078681946,
0.4289338290691376,
0.448091983795166,
-0.22062450647354126,
1.0636030435562134,
0.4817323684692383,
-0.17014585435390472,
0.21292470395565033,
-0.20089887082576752,
0.21306101977825165,
-0.7191460728645325,
-0.12178640812635422,
-0.6336615085601807,
-0.13725143671035767,
-0.6896263360977173,
-0.8053455352783203,
0.40585047006607056,
-0.167353093624115,
-0.04168185219168663,
0.1696132868528366,
-0.4523452818393707,
0.38485294580459595,
0.5214729905128479,
0.15138211846351624,
0.45839524269104004,
0.2699817419052124,
0.262620210647583,
-0.20870450139045715,
-0.8231775760650635,
-0.7208272218704224,
1.4208571910858154,
0.5597159266471863,
0.9489611983299255,
-0.12988175451755524,
0.5814871191978455,
0.3051397204399109,
0.3608245849609375,
-0.7471951842308044,
0.5064533948898315,
-0.1528174877166748,
-0.49629518389701843,
-0.4099164605140686,
-0.6374871730804443,
-0.8541255593299866,
0.16554267704486847,
-0.7236820459365845,
-0.3421100378036499,
-0.06933456659317017,
0.13313716650009155,
-0.09509468078613281,
0.3625023365020752,
-0.6770025491714478,
0.41843169927597046,
-0.1531398594379425,
-0.41207611560821533,
-0.09219525754451752,
-0.5020244717597961,
0.2775525748729706,
-0.37445351481437683,
0.36621156334877014,
0.06553123146295547,
-0.09262316673994064,
0.5592911243438721,
-0.4054763913154602,
0.9493777751922607,
0.05685283616185188,
-0.29164838790893555,
0.1931745707988739,
-0.14584025740623474,
0.9385650753974915,
-0.26537540555000305,
-0.30042243003845215,
-0.023287810385227203,
-0.45334169268608093,
-0.3404693305492401,
-0.668359637260437,
0.6361014246940613,
-0.6690371036529541,
-0.4574984610080719,
-0.36926913261413574,
-0.7124302983283997,
-0.5668936967849731,
-0.22728511691093445,
0.18109460175037384,
0.19168630242347717,
0.013408971950411797,
0.40434446930885315,
0.7097086906433105,
-0.33129966259002686,
0.28782182931900024,
0.2020692080259323,
-0.008933699689805508,
-0.19289182126522064,
0.7798539400100708,
0.08080832660198212,
0.5598224997520447,
0.233243927359581,
0.26518309116363525,
-0.5153550505638123,
-0.6182326078414917,
-0.3108212649822235,
0.13798710703849792,
-0.6649273037910461,
-0.25024881958961487,
-0.5032764077186584,
-0.3378194570541382,
-0.4940607249736786,
-0.1415439397096634,
-0.19694304466247559,
-0.43888843059539795,
-0.4179845452308655,
-0.31628963351249695,
0.3489965498447418,
0.43563228845596313,
0.15548571944236755,
0.4678710997104645,
-0.8797093033790588,
0.2890484929084778,
0.19378425180912018,
0.22737543284893036,
-0.17871610820293427,
-0.6250720620155334,
-0.1991564780473709,
0.22844301164150238,
-0.13556267321109772,
-0.619114875793457,
0.8014433979988098,
0.1691729724407196,
0.5588982701301575,
-0.18267850577831268,
0.18616116046905518,
0.5042360424995422,
-0.2222234606742859,
0.585362434387207,
0.09630241245031357,
-0.708979070186615,
0.4808654189109802,
-0.31427374482154846,
0.1285656839609146,
0.41642579436302185,
0.4401766061782837,
-0.46909818053245544,
-0.44473710656166077,
-0.4542144536972046,
-0.7409918308258057,
0.6458904147148132,
0.4444483518600464,
0.1713072657585144,
0.11115676164627075,
0.43955978751182556,
-0.03871952369809151,
0.08586762100458145,
-0.696010172367096,
-0.0523807629942894,
0.3850748538970947,
-0.5313746929168701,
-0.2727612853050232,
-0.20894412696361542,
0.0031216845382004976,
-0.021931808441877365,
0.9551158547401428,
-0.25985389947891235,
-0.2135036289691925,
0.3465132415294647,
-0.16718077659606934,
-0.2421676516532898,
0.360454797744751,
0.3059248924255371,
0.28658074140548706,
-0.07390961796045303,
0.11370225250720978,
0.37468576431274414,
-0.5188774466514587,
0.14816059172153473,
-0.06550843268632889,
-0.28238776326179504,
0.05177827551960945,
0.43602511286735535,
0.5486128926277161,
0.1240462064743042,
-0.9031875729560852,
0.2960714101791382,
0.12298835813999176,
-0.10972604155540466,
-0.34980759024620056,
0.19300535321235657,
0.146967351436615,
-0.015555016696453094,
0.49178072810173035,
0.3374108672142029,
0.08695951849222183,
-0.5085892081260681,
-0.02513178624212742,
0.38383233547210693,
-0.012128752656280994,
0.1087910458445549,
0.21119527518749237,
0.15718117356300354,
-0.3566650450229645,
0.32843393087387085,
-0.0115180853754282,
-0.4521247148513794,
0.4123263359069824,
0.5696981549263,
0.5040200352668762,
-0.30219173431396484,
0.1262715607881546,
0.34677764773368835,
0.4451984167098999,
-0.41492676734924316,
-0.16813130676746368,
0.3914177119731903,
-0.8335103392601013,
-0.7754580974578857,
-0.750746488571167,
-0.5034402012825012,
0.07682344317436218,
-0.37802302837371826,
0.4784809350967407,
-0.3930697441101074,
-0.24934299290180206,
0.00899494718760252,
-0.10292059183120728,
-0.4635310173034668,
0.3711521029472351,
0.18619348108768463,
0.6848438382148743,
-0.7355105876922607,
0.8149693608283997,
0.4501955509185791,
-0.08237846940755844,
-0.759728193283081,
0.03765759989619255,
-0.0747668445110321,
-0.4765108525753021,
0.5553930997848511,
0.19189611077308655,
-0.20923712849617004,
-0.19700908660888672,
-0.5057485699653625,
-0.6912441849708557,
0.8641006350517273,
0.39887529611587524,
-0.6906698346138,
-0.26705658435821533,
0.6128414869308472,
0.761732816696167,
-0.17403896152973175,
-0.1892370730638504,
0.7277707457542419,
0.6254176497459412,
0.1738833636045456,
-0.8957119584083557,
-0.02641919068992138,
0.01247512549161911,
0.0878768116235733,
0.16933199763298035,
-0.07814815640449524,
0.6955224275588989,
0.021909071132540703,
-0.2079804688692093,
-0.029766209423542023,
0.2750575840473175,
0.38318684697151184,
0.2852705717086792,
0.4560970067977905,
0.3905158042907715,
0.8710384368896484,
-0.12281794846057892,
1.2210066318511963,
0.09582827985286713,
0.19154028594493866,
1.0865424871444702,
-0.31689348816871643,
0.8652077913284302,
0.4990830421447754,
-0.3397619128227234,
0.2926531136035919,
0.490930438041687,
0.05779889598488808,
0.0301238801330328,
0.4330311417579651,
-0.3329913914203644,
-0.31090009212493896,
-0.24332092702388763,
-0.08226132392883301,
0.4091891944408417,
0.5643278360366821,
-0.4253845810890198,
0.07413981854915619,
0.07263340801000595,
-0.1166042611002922,
0.42495232820510864,
-0.32038646936416626,
0.7245063185691833,
-0.19901281595230103,
-0.6590178608894348,
0.8141039609909058,
0.24931159615516663,
1.0939706563949585,
-0.5209009647369385,
-0.01671484485268593,
0.004360135179013014,
0.24760061502456665,
-0.3987129032611847,
-0.6110169291496277,
0.43729469180107117,
0.07299911230802536,
-0.10313408821821213,
-0.14790183305740356,
0.9577992558479309,
-0.6193183660507202,
-0.7607364654541016,
0.10693226009607315,
0.2461230456829071,
-0.04957420378923416,
-0.35434144735336304,
-0.2759200930595398,
-0.09044948220252991,
-0.054374825209379196,
-0.1162453144788742,
0.3445262312889099,
0.11884676665067673,
-0.18140451610088348,
0.8677129745483398,
1.0615650415420532,
0.3596155345439911,
0.00842547882348299,
-0.03860627859830856,
0.7838366627693176,
-0.5641688108444214,
-0.27355682849884033,
-0.9556524157524109,
0.22453047335147858,
-0.3091508746147156,
0.18461917340755463,
0.6956809163093567,
0.544052004814148,
0.7352765798568726,
-0.11454979330301285,
0.959283709526062,
0.5759662389755249,
0.9320296049118042,
-0.6975285410881042,
0.4828473627567291,
-0.3683460056781769,
0.586063802242279,
-0.17893710732460022,
-1.0901881456375122,
-0.4858187735080719,
0.4890455901622772,
-0.22909873723983765,
-0.11045403778553009,
0.41312626004219055,
1.0030901432037354,
0.1618528515100479,
-0.01533874124288559,
0.32196497917175293,
-0.08205558359622955,
0.35047632455825806,
0.4985121190547943,
0.9958685636520386,
-0.3387959897518158,
0.464861124753952,
-0.2774007320404053,
-0.09881122410297394,
-0.3094486594200134,
-0.7780861258506775,
-0.8572651743888855,
-0.22356997430324554,
-0.10887489467859268,
-0.270873486995697,
-0.03335515782237053,
1.2168006896972656,
0.6935935020446777,
-0.5584012866020203,
-0.019126327708363533,
-0.19405587017536163,
-0.03188200667500496,
0.2854207158088684,
-0.26581528782844543,
0.16037140786647797,
-0.3584032356739044,
-0.9090768098831177,
0.5968527793884277,
0.0936485156416893,
0.5629547238349915,
-0.5655847787857056,
-0.1846177875995636,
-0.0741729810833931,
0.3260352909564972,
0.601674497127533,
-0.094505175948143,
-0.6481691598892212,
-0.2994922697544098,
0.10433827340602875,
-0.2759014666080475,
-0.05442360043525696,
0.7200165390968323,
-0.8671703338623047,
0.3342601954936981,
0.34801775217056274,
0.9528527855873108,
0.34301623702049255,
0.19853273034095764,
0.8223593831062317,
-1.1341378688812256,
0.15617577731609344,
0.4597361981868744,
0.21587114036083221,
0.712103545665741,
-0.6422463655471802,
0.673994243144989,
0.17519155144691467,
-0.37911975383758545,
-1.046023964881897,
-0.012411008588969707,
-0.7368709444999695,
-0.2948794960975647,
1.264343023300171,
0.10361982882022858,
-0.12273694574832916,
-0.2313033938407898,
-0.43401628732681274,
0.20173229277133942,
-0.1572752743959427,
0.8513621091842651,
0.8260047435760498,
0.035216234624385834,
0.20758245885372162,
-0.5938321948051453,
0.6611761450767517,
0.49864810705184937,
-1.2694364786148071,
0.3143024444580078,
0.6260059475898743,
0.030426084995269775,
0.3615685701370239,
0.1045055165886879,
-0.05548857897520065,
-0.0032514105550944805,
-0.27733370661735535,
0.16911886632442474,
0.03860215097665787,
-0.3672791123390198,
-0.287380188703537,
0.06624113768339157,
0.025543823838233948,
0.05702854320406914
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17859v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17859v2
|
ChroniclingAmericaQA: A Large-scale Question Answering Dataset based on Historical American Newspaper Pages
| 2024-03-26T16:48:13 | 2024-05-10T17:15:24 |
Bhawna Piryani, Jamshid Mozafari, Adam Jatowt
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Question answering (QA) and Machine Reading Comprehension (MRC) tasks have
significantly advanced in recent years due to the rapid development of deep
learning techniques and, more recently, large language models. At the same
time, many benchmark datasets have become available for QA and MRC tasks.
However, most existing large-scale benchmark datasets have been created
predominantly using synchronous document collections like Wikipedia or the Web.
Archival document collections, such as historical newspapers, contain valuable
information from the past that is still not widely used to train large language
models. To further contribute to advancing QA and MRC tasks and to overcome the
limitation of previous datasets, we introduce ChroniclingAmericaQA, a
large-scale temporal QA dataset with 487K question-answer pairs created based
on the historical newspaper collection Chronicling America. Our dataset is
constructed from a subset of the Chronicling America newspaper collection
spanning 120 years. One of the significant challenges for utilizing digitized
historical newspaper collections is the low quality of OCR text. Therefore, to
enable realistic testing of QA models, our dataset can be used in three
different ways: answering questions from raw and noisy content, answering
questions from cleaner, corrected version of the content, as well as answering
questions from scanned images of newspaper pages. This and the fact that
ChroniclingAmericaQA spans the longest time period among available QA datasets
make it quite a unique and useful resource.
|
[
-0.44718220829963684,
-0.8127920031547546,
0.7009280323982239,
-0.13838568329811096,
-0.23920033872127533,
0.36572733521461487,
0.03939054161310196,
-0.29751208424568176,
0.05820303410291672,
0.5858871936798096,
-0.4191807210445404,
-0.34298959374427795,
-0.13263942301273346,
0.2312624454498291,
-0.3828652799129486,
0.9872202277183533,
-0.37692365050315857,
-0.02850225754082203,
-0.3156817853450775,
-0.365016907453537,
-0.3638356626033783,
-0.5888605713844299,
-0.6422670483589172,
0.09175477176904678,
0.7160236239433289,
0.39697301387786865,
0.7832028269767761,
0.6435449123382568,
0.36549538373947144,
0.1501302868127823,
0.04256581887602806,
0.31324243545532227,
-0.5483225584030151,
0.08448486775159836,
-0.15500670671463013,
-0.458774209022522,
0.01857653819024563,
0.06524848192930222,
0.5617163777351379,
0.6130355596542358,
-0.02603512443602085,
0.45898106694221497,
-0.1611545830965042,
0.7702715396881104,
-0.5781188607215881,
0.05217615142464638,
-0.4113457202911377,
-0.24384906888008118,
0.06698891520500183,
-0.2997993230819702,
-0.08015501499176025,
-0.8199567794799805,
-0.046431273221969604,
-0.6469800472259521,
0.2962200939655304,
-0.046477340161800385,
1.0895347595214844,
0.2236296832561493,
-0.6834130883216858,
-0.5516257286071777,
-0.7981259226799011,
0.47328242659568787,
-0.44854071736335754,
0.3399781286716461,
0.7671594619750977,
0.41085949540138245,
0.18343956768512726,
-0.7871639728546143,
-0.7575913667678833,
-0.08795621246099472,
0.1472703516483307,
0.29229143261909485,
-0.051443953067064285,
-0.4185480773448944,
0.19640158116817474,
0.45788872241973877,
-0.9398606419563293,
-0.1472032368183136,
-0.6009500622749329,
0.025349605828523636,
0.21570080518722534,
0.32834920287132263,
0.14268334209918976,
-0.2739942669868469,
-0.18176396191120148,
-0.2036101371049881,
-0.397204726934433,
0.38170138001441956,
0.26837968826293945,
-0.007781560532748699,
0.24010920524597168,
0.507087767124176,
-0.478596568107605,
0.5164791941642761,
-0.27055248618125916,
-0.16749067604541779,
0.013668756000697613,
-0.3708753287792206,
-0.12491872161626816,
-0.3360308110713959,
0.3792911767959595,
0.3763785660266876,
0.21334180235862732,
-0.35037508606910706,
0.03248202055692673,
-0.11385314911603928,
0.45688265562057495,
-0.5052328109741211,
-0.11398357152938843,
0.46576857566833496,
-0.5867449641227722,
0.14645792543888092,
0.26166629791259766,
-0.9131535291671753,
-0.3082645535469055,
-0.4814029037952423,
0.28397127985954285,
-0.18346230685710907,
0.08690893650054932,
0.1289995312690735,
-0.13948090374469757,
0.326509952545166,
0.37306004762649536,
-0.5702678561210632,
0.10264025628566742,
0.7605143189430237,
0.7766941785812378,
0.021581172943115234,
-0.10954592376947403,
-0.6444171667098999,
-0.10656075924634933,
-0.49109360575675964,
0.790878415107727,
-0.39148110151290894,
0.07381638139486313,
0.30089735984802246,
0.12811432778835297,
0.003530154237523675,
-0.6874498128890991,
0.4528305232524872,
-1.2675445079803467,
0.4114050567150116,
-0.26741501688957214,
-0.24371105432510376,
-0.2855004370212555,
0.5062623023986816,
-0.9133684635162354,
1.2217077016830444,
0.5817111134529114,
-0.6832428574562073,
0.10621936619281769,
-0.024125969037413597,
-0.33312472701072693,
-0.24009685218334198,
0.1490563154220581,
-0.4322413206100464,
-0.09639298915863037,
0.568428635597229,
0.10208497196435928,
-0.27607765793800354,
0.24264481663703918,
-0.1079096794128418,
-0.3519414961338043,
0.3090316653251648,
-0.5205497741699219,
0.8807832598686218,
0.37003931403160095,
-0.20949412882328033,
-0.3670583665370941,
-0.5842943787574768,
-0.062062256038188934,
-0.03921692445874214,
-0.4968869686126709,
-0.3841099143028259,
-0.30746373534202576,
0.013998511247336864,
0.20994479954242706,
0.31688809394836426,
-0.4667730927467346,
0.24901697039604187,
0.03688172623515129,
0.36956384778022766,
0.38979196548461914,
0.44393038749694824,
0.147833451628685,
-0.8621535897254944,
0.9039346575737,
-0.1779942661523819,
0.13711439073085785,
-0.5522642135620117,
-0.16667088866233826,
-0.7244463562965393,
0.12553855776786804,
0.4326696991920471,
0.9298141002655029,
-1.0369380712509155,
0.21899855136871338,
-0.4016842246055603,
-0.44038528203964233,
-0.5255666971206665,
-0.1903870552778244,
0.058821484446525574,
0.6605652570724487,
0.4851887822151184,
-0.22993826866149902,
-0.44601088762283325,
-0.6162453293800354,
-0.004322037100791931,
-0.36967623233795166,
-0.3855743110179901,
0.5195857882499695,
0.2923630475997925,
0.2827762961387634,
0.7290095090866089,
-0.6578009724617004,
-0.23424828052520752,
0.3009335696697235,
0.19587120413780212,
0.29042813181877136,
0.19096429646015167,
0.22381868958473206,
-0.7693920135498047,
-0.3651406764984131,
-0.27004629373550415,
-0.6375184655189514,
0.08960886299610138,
-0.5724179744720459,
-0.2001025229692459,
0.2257981151342392,
0.8523925542831421,
-0.13741807639598846,
0.4010687470436096,
0.6095377802848816,
-0.29660534858703613,
0.5318436622619629,
-0.05015582963824272,
0.7374961972236633,
-1.1618317365646362,
0.38284629583358765,
-0.36755943298339844,
-0.3130114674568176,
-0.4090423583984375,
0.04820284619927406,
0.2344348281621933,
-0.15949399769306183,
-0.295671671628952,
0.4697391092777252,
-0.3648158311843872,
0.11080838739871979,
0.07182745635509491,
0.18360589444637299,
0.3011523485183716,
0.46175616979599,
-0.07825441658496857,
0.9202056527137756,
0.011055580340325832,
-0.33326199650764465,
0.33626654744148254,
0.5554419755935669,
-0.5271623134613037,
0.6477004289627075,
-0.4686497747898102,
0.23621538281440735,
-0.5012367963790894,
0.2587094306945801,
-1.147107720375061,
-0.012072240002453327,
0.11899950355291367,
-0.6206971406936646,
-0.07726556807756424,
0.10918869823217392,
-0.7066398859024048,
-0.5634836554527283,
-0.07310450077056885,
0.3271714150905609,
0.4166269302368164,
-0.5919138789176941,
0.5289160013198853,
0.2759261429309845,
-0.522893488407135,
-0.5345191955566406,
-0.4712047278881073,
0.23988792300224304,
-0.11515817791223526,
-0.41083958745002747,
-0.12695610523223877,
-0.12904928624629974,
0.02132437936961651,
0.06327815353870392,
-0.08275296539068222,
-0.5604391694068909,
-0.039642490446567535,
0.0423460379242897,
0.3464781939983368,
-0.508705735206604,
0.43836477398872375,
-0.08034433424472809,
0.029000379145145416,
-0.13919851183891296,
-0.11151107400655746,
0.5916076898574829,
0.2436036318540573,
-0.05333409830927849,
-0.38172921538352966,
0.6458567976951599,
0.7206546068191528,
-0.6450404524803162,
0.7892398238182068,
0.3856602609157562,
-0.28995370864868164,
0.08648671954870224,
-0.7576581239700317,
-0.14554788172245026,
-0.37626999616622925,
0.21217654645442963,
-0.24559956789016724,
-1.1572692394256592,
0.6184563636779785,
0.21507485210895538,
0.4654606282711029,
0.3164127469062805,
0.3891788125038147,
-0.27087652683258057,
0.6651490330696106,
0.11019871383905411,
-0.3863028585910797,
0.5004661083221436,
0.018210381269454956,
-0.20322750508785248,
-0.5888756513595581,
-0.10612472146749496,
-0.8166074752807617,
-0.21654631197452545,
-0.1227039098739624,
-0.6174541115760803,
0.32441258430480957,
-0.013272975571453571,
-0.3872223496437073,
0.043868258595466614,
-0.2383449822664261,
0.5018898248672485,
0.7566189169883728,
0.1925281286239624,
0.7648880481719971,
-0.05923006311058998,
0.19132673740386963,
0.2785674035549164,
-0.5146971940994263,
-0.7315848469734192,
1.0873628854751587,
0.36370766162872314,
0.6782507300376892,
0.058491192758083344,
0.2332949936389923,
0.2561126947402954,
0.3207767903804779,
-0.6035723686218262,
0.09239024668931961,
-0.2950860559940338,
-0.7978686094284058,
-0.3772018253803253,
-0.5185924172401428,
-1.2274647951126099,
-0.106257364153862,
-0.15922491252422333,
-0.28160083293914795,
0.3127959966659546,
0.05654248967766762,
-0.7573603987693787,
0.3652346730232239,
-0.35461780428886414,
0.7986148595809937,
0.03502916917204857,
0.0809185653924942,
-0.022574976086616516,
-0.7513620853424072,
0.22760768234729767,
-0.046467844396829605,
0.17602574825286865,
0.03175240382552147,
-0.10909616947174072,
0.5845775008201599,
-0.09900086373090744,
0.5928636789321899,
0.1486906260251999,
-0.046966712921857834,
0.4897659420967102,
-0.03731223940849304,
0.3715583384037018,
0.22711209952831268,
-0.09910058230161667,
-0.17206797003746033,
0.6563072204589844,
-0.5571795105934143,
-0.5609257817268372,
0.38963884115219116,
-0.784020721912384,
-0.3808273375034332,
-0.38470155000686646,
-0.6090853214263916,
-0.36356809735298157,
0.1461396962404251,
0.0784921944141388,
0.8292703628540039,
-0.33407360315322876,
0.4934593737125397,
0.7218387126922607,
-0.11605270951986313,
0.2562622129917145,
0.5392227172851562,
-0.04485553130507469,
-0.5250682234764099,
0.800747811794281,
0.12526774406433105,
0.06580643355846405,
0.5397704243659973,
-0.1349492371082306,
-0.39942970871925354,
-0.585608184337616,
-0.5335195064544678,
0.3224974572658539,
-0.4962661564350128,
-0.3514482378959656,
-0.7732991576194763,
-0.22091767191886902,
-0.4625477194786072,
-0.049440015107393265,
0.11104041337966919,
-0.2667803466320038,
-0.7028272151947021,
0.20191317796707153,
0.13789266347885132,
0.5261372923851013,
0.22056527435779572,
0.23446987569332123,
-1.0767238140106201,
0.989549994468689,
0.5816117525100708,
0.4707067310810089,
0.120856873691082,
-0.4970828592777252,
-0.3493349254131317,
-0.06637898087501526,
-0.15954992175102234,
-0.9808080196380615,
0.2392135113477707,
-0.034110307693481445,
0.39351752400398254,
0.21754604578018188,
0.58864426612854,
0.4623715877532959,
-0.48968788981437683,
0.7202694416046143,
-0.4037872552871704,
-0.4379838705062866,
0.10039839893579483,
-0.5440331697463989,
0.6980836391448975,
1.1357700824737549,
0.723887026309967,
-1.0564934015274048,
-0.670129120349884,
-0.4739803671836853,
-0.6127116084098816,
0.45648232102394104,
-0.040087953209877014,
0.0992889329791069,
-0.09320327639579773,
0.6819653511047363,
0.1982327103614807,
0.21230842173099518,
-0.24047932028770447,
-0.08025017380714417,
-0.3001580834388733,
-0.3911755681037903,
-0.23275122046470642,
-0.12810057401657104,
-0.15202905237674713,
0.10856875777244568,
0.6271553635597229,
-0.23127108812332153,
-0.10014556348323822,
0.4659324884414673,
-0.3170121908187866,
-0.12463828176259995,
0.27944037318229675,
0.2768751084804535,
0.9520142078399658,
-0.2854214608669281,
0.14882934093475342,
0.001442094799131155,
-0.6405259370803833,
0.12462695688009262,
0.36538511514663696,
-0.3970179557800293,
-0.1293712705373764,
0.25560250878334045,
0.5267975330352783,
-0.41248881816864014,
-1.1095170974731445,
0.274850994348526,
-0.36057066917419434,
-0.2302817851305008,
-0.5278689861297607,
-0.18384914100170135,
0.051640428602695465,
0.3926144242286682,
0.8797197937965393,
-0.4318256676197052,
0.06952936947345734,
-0.659041702747345,
0.509000301361084,
0.20886050164699554,
-0.4753764271736145,
0.22040754556655884,
0.5270907878875732,
-0.09183257073163986,
0.03940710797905922,
0.9957391023635864,
0.11533138900995255,
-0.47630223631858826,
0.890556275844574,
0.059039197862148285,
0.3044964671134949,
0.006402448285371065,
0.48558053374290466,
0.7219209671020508,
0.4688098132610321,
-0.009996295906603336,
0.3754688501358032,
0.04080778732895851,
-0.36505499482154846,
-0.2767505645751953,
-0.5433967709541321,
-0.4492998421192169,
0.43986776471138,
-0.9404116868972778,
-0.2876640856266022,
-0.4524582624435425,
-0.039983589202165604,
-0.22589018940925598,
0.42491093277931213,
-0.5682486891746521,
0.5465729236602783,
-0.05651935935020447,
1.025381326675415,
-0.8831570744514465,
0.4925256073474884,
0.545102596282959,
-0.44497358798980713,
-0.6377363204956055,
0.28881752490997314,
-0.04682677611708641,
-0.7016403675079346,
0.05360587313771248,
0.016155166551470757,
0.5219360589981079,
0.2491244673728943,
-0.4316626489162445,
-0.749338686466217,
1.022282361984253,
-0.03515778109431267,
-0.38513463735580444,
-0.1941048949956894,
0.18444520235061646,
0.530890703201294,
-0.1036163717508316,
0.0381634496152401,
0.7929329872131348,
0.3636515736579895,
0.06060970947146416,
-0.7372836470603943,
0.06868085265159607,
-0.09441263228654861,
-0.2598266005516052,
0.17289821803569794,
-0.7984820008277893,
0.6888272762298584,
0.040200814604759216,
-0.5042123198509216,
0.6131545305252075,
0.8484534025192261,
0.09901335835456848,
0.3888899087905884,
0.6344408988952637,
0.5904530882835388,
0.9016848802566528,
-0.1551538109779358,
0.933253288269043,
0.004230700433254242,
0.07717228680849075,
1.2689343690872192,
0.12320634722709656,
1.0372833013534546,
0.29178178310394287,
-0.2198861688375473,
0.4540364444255829,
0.906905472278595,
-0.1351519376039505,
0.21304358541965485,
0.082302987575531,
-0.35413095355033875,
-0.28775423765182495,
-0.19897986948490143,
-0.2701192796230316,
0.2847599387168884,
0.036116812378168106,
-0.23962447047233582,
-0.37203535437583923,
0.15489211678504944,
0.031571164727211,
0.37327876687049866,
-0.31351014971733093,
0.8775032162666321,
-0.20490781962871552,
-0.9674758315086365,
0.4810791015625,
-0.34912464022636414,
0.24461644887924194,
-0.46366390585899353,
-0.011693316511809826,
-0.5626418590545654,
-0.21666327118873596,
0.24499711394309998,
-0.9920514225959778,
0.4214491844177246,
-0.15000367164611816,
-0.5033623576164246,
0.047840919345617294,
0.11321792006492615,
-0.6632874608039856,
-0.38145971298217773,
-0.3008774518966675,
0.6723400950431824,
0.020697258412837982,
-0.23175349831581116,
-0.4521472156047821,
-0.015089880675077438,
-0.11595924198627472,
-0.17788319289684296,
0.16050566732883453,
0.5020012259483337,
-0.11073967814445496,
0.3459581434726715,
0.8041394948959351,
0.010064175352454185,
0.007346844766288996,
-0.13081952929496765,
0.9952476024627686,
-0.7729701399803162,
-0.6972916126251221,
-0.08222656697034836,
0.2812369465827942,
0.18400371074676514,
-0.49500933289527893,
0.41121402382850647,
0.7429579496383667,
0.5053640604019165,
-0.015590762719511986,
0.6274441480636597,
0.09852198511362076,
1.212520956993103,
-0.615610659122467,
0.7326871752738953,
-0.651497483253479,
-0.19114884734153748,
0.1820443719625473,
-0.813974142074585,
-0.2876712381839752,
0.17968352138996124,
-0.11316034197807312,
-0.12580552697181702,
0.7683647274971008,
0.6912181973457336,
0.21431514620780945,
-0.007595208939164877,
0.19935274124145508,
0.08496816456317902,
0.24493896961212158,
0.6609144806861877,
0.8884394764900208,
-0.5007041692733765,
1.0909208059310913,
-0.17898741364479065,
-0.24094118177890778,
-0.20149214565753937,
-0.5908360481262207,
-0.9772143363952637,
-0.9199082255363464,
-0.15401001274585724,
-0.5824990272521973,
0.32533302903175354,
0.3971891701221466,
0.37394455075263977,
-0.9450526237487793,
0.0521400161087513,
0.43415841460227966,
0.03379499167203903,
-0.2962113320827484,
-0.27454522252082825,
0.7458899021148682,
-0.16922226548194885,
-0.8055456876754761,
0.0219026580452919,
-0.0019460449693724513,
0.16111792623996735,
-0.26759135723114014,
0.48106735944747925,
-0.402004212141037,
0.14523202180862427,
0.39684492349624634,
0.9269553422927856,
-0.2823792099952698,
-0.3879522383213043,
0.4807943105697632,
-0.3969385027885437,
0.3675679862499237,
0.9236916303634644,
-1.0223076343536377,
0.4333823621273041,
0.6979047060012817,
0.9619618058204651,
0.4730762839317322,
0.6579285860061646,
0.3321661949157715,
-0.41289079189300537,
-0.14406102895736694,
0.46172380447387695,
-0.16771157085895538,
0.3043293356895447,
-0.38883379101753235,
0.37328794598579407,
-0.11062317341566086,
-0.7568128108978271,
-0.46092522144317627,
-0.05860651656985283,
-1.1588972806930542,
-0.5976825952529907,
0.9158002734184265,
-0.13550209999084473,
-0.3430638313293457,
-0.8837389945983887,
-0.3571871221065521,
0.32790252566337585,
-0.4917541742324829,
1.0914747714996338,
0.6211639046669006,
0.14829818904399872,
-0.527369499206543,
-0.8375056385993958,
0.29787978529930115,
0.24371136724948883,
-1.1654311418533325,
0.16595464944839478,
0.8399702906608582,
0.0639766976237297,
0.02954551763832569,
0.6848616003990173,
-0.20972378551959991,
0.5436587929725647,
-0.033706434071063995,
-0.23356804251670837,
-0.11639712005853653,
-0.32647019624710083,
-0.39345645904541016,
0.5700145363807678,
-0.214291051030159,
-0.133042111992836
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17856v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17856v1
|
Verbing Weirds Language (Models): Evaluation of English Zero-Derivation in Five LLMs
| 2024-03-26T16:45:27 | 2024-03-26T16:45:27 |
David R. Mortensen, Valentina Izrailevitch, Yunze Xiao, Hinrich Schütze, Leonie Weissweiler
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Lexical-syntactic flexibility, in the form of conversion (or zero-derivation)
is a hallmark of English morphology. In conversion, a word with one part of
speech is placed in a non-prototypical context, where it is coerced to behave
as if it had a different part of speech. However, while this process affects a
large part of the English lexicon, little work has been done to establish the
degree to which language models capture this type of generalization. This paper
reports the first study on the behavior of large language models with reference
to conversion. We design a task for testing lexical-syntactic flexibility --
the degree to which models can generalize over words in a construction with a
non-prototypical part of speech. This task is situated within a natural
language inference paradigm. We test the abilities of five language models --
two proprietary models (GPT-3.5 and GPT-4), three open-source models (Mistral
7B, Falcon 40B, and Llama 2 70B). We find that GPT-4 performs best on the task,
followed by GPT-3.5, but that the open source language models are also able to
perform it and that the 7B parameter Mistral displays as little difference
between its baseline performance on the natural language inference task and the
non-prototypical syntactic category task, as the massive GPT-4.
|
[
-0.20970618724822998,
-0.9377633333206177,
0.6742439270019531,
-0.024509118869900703,
-0.3232969343662262,
-0.461117684841156,
-0.26243525743484497,
-0.445953369140625,
0.07638109475374222,
0.3509736657142639,
-0.5844481587409973,
-0.3579402267932892,
-0.5572772026062012,
0.41165146231651306,
-0.6854534149169922,
1.0088967084884644,
0.008203965611755848,
0.1630197912454605,
0.1398027390241623,
-0.018144940957427025,
-0.213184654712677,
-0.6236371397972107,
-0.166234090924263,
-0.06859087198972702,
0.359109491109848,
0.13662688434123993,
1.103554606437683,
0.4743889570236206,
0.16801653802394867,
0.2821202576160431,
-0.02373466268181801,
-0.15749026834964752,
-0.33543750643730164,
0.1916624754667282,
-0.5529366135597229,
-0.7490365505218506,
-0.404634028673172,
0.18330949544906616,
0.4818355143070221,
0.8574948310852051,
-0.1810472309589386,
0.15197111666202545,
-0.26258087158203125,
0.3281368315219879,
-0.4382966458797455,
0.04305132478475571,
-0.8113196492195129,
-0.05127531290054321,
-0.24285723268985748,
0.24748213589191437,
-0.44440239667892456,
-0.03280862048268318,
0.10668440163135529,
-0.3565036952495575,
0.6059371829032898,
0.11564020067453384,
1.1642887592315674,
-0.008219919167459011,
-0.4349866211414337,
-0.18274672329425812,
-0.9892663359642029,
0.6173381209373474,
-0.9620189666748047,
0.8884832262992859,
0.36341220140457153,
0.18191446363925934,
-0.08696021139621735,
-0.7445586919784546,
-0.965535581111908,
-0.6785573959350586,
0.23089081048965454,
-0.040116555988788605,
-0.29885098338127136,
0.2281101793050766,
0.21522654592990875,
0.5366619825363159,
-0.4546184837818146,
0.16479620337486267,
-0.6932188868522644,
-0.03404289111495018,
0.7053632140159607,
0.02022835798561573,
0.2962968945503235,
-0.3562992215156555,
-0.13563773036003113,
0.020822718739509583,
-0.6139064431190491,
-0.16378827393054962,
0.3982492685317993,
0.589828372001648,
-0.03707734867930412,
0.9116734862327576,
0.004096456337720156,
0.5123063921928406,
0.0512172169983387,
0.06703954935073853,
0.24114227294921875,
-0.33391672372817993,
-0.6001904010772705,
-0.4226405620574951,
0.42200812697410583,
0.3968871533870697,
0.22594815492630005,
-0.4967474639415741,
-0.5429245829582214,
0.3118891716003418,
0.2980545163154602,
-0.507228434085846,
-0.08239496499300003,
-0.03820279985666275,
-0.17308448255062103,
-0.041075412184000015,
-0.06938226521015167,
-0.2995191812515259,
-0.2086370289325714,
-0.21458102762699127,
0.49805593490600586,
-0.6203137636184692,
-0.35439273715019226,
0.4425728917121887,
-0.15623335540294647,
0.3922348916530609,
0.15966308116912842,
-1.0557862520217896,
0.5315295457839966,
0.5582150816917419,
0.6975834369659424,
-0.4070577025413513,
-0.3404042422771454,
-0.21093474328517914,
0.03988172858953476,
-0.4616222679615021,
0.7440975904464722,
-0.4770040214061737,
-0.4722765386104584,
-0.15533289313316345,
0.327030748128891,
-0.21597151458263397,
-0.48324909806251526,
0.5057648420333862,
-0.34803882241249084,
0.3941594064235687,
0.16958506405353546,
-0.7579081058502197,
-0.3950296938419342,
0.2876167297363281,
-0.591774582862854,
0.9847612380981445,
0.24581952393054962,
-0.3209661543369293,
0.4336787760257721,
-0.4978955388069153,
-0.04099750891327858,
0.08398162573575974,
-0.30851659178733826,
-0.017383214086294174,
0.5822045803070068,
-0.24967247247695923,
0.44006478786468506,
-0.3198610246181488,
0.15546399354934692,
-0.3493921160697937,
-0.05416979640722275,
0.1265711933374405,
-0.42332619428634644,
0.3805640637874603,
0.13552863895893097,
-0.3761562407016754,
0.24341610074043274,
-0.529444694519043,
-0.06516452133655548,
0.31657674908638,
0.05012305825948715,
-0.36592066287994385,
-0.008441862650215626,
-0.016351209953427315,
0.3011045753955841,
-0.07669371366500854,
-0.708530843257904,
0.32483839988708496,
-0.701717734336853,
0.25665560364723206,
0.4447867274284363,
0.010876677930355072,
0.3371279239654541,
-0.339205265045166,
0.6397066712379456,
0.06575064361095428,
0.0016144922701641917,
0.32719773054122925,
-0.827119767665863,
-0.8227413892745972,
0.060849618166685104,
0.12755003571510315,
0.3180077075958252,
-0.5980441570281982,
0.09899526089429855,
-0.21454767882823944,
-0.5574320554733276,
-0.4051331579685211,
0.0030317245982587337,
0.08863478153944016,
0.13464605808258057,
0.1987561732530594,
-0.21247369050979614,
-0.21604909002780914,
-1.0520308017730713,
-0.496279239654541,
-0.16110534965991974,
-0.19742140173912048,
0.0023466625716537237,
0.48256006836891174,
-0.2137923240661621,
0.7552255988121033,
-0.3255707919597626,
-0.03853272274136543,
-0.3900635838508606,
0.08172126859426498,
0.28890666365623474,
0.12556825578212738,
0.8051959276199341,
-0.7342702150344849,
-0.19367066025733948,
-0.030860580503940582,
-0.08340132236480713,
-0.0056967539712786674,
0.04682878032326698,
0.233356773853302,
0.7326188087463379,
0.5308527946472168,
-0.6340274810791016,
0.5531864762306213,
0.687035083770752,
-0.5818611979484558,
0.8444137573242188,
-0.27980491518974304,
-0.1822662502527237,
-0.8078544735908508,
-0.06102439761161804,
-0.08398456871509552,
-0.20702391862869263,
-0.898909866809845,
0.29879528284072876,
0.0595114566385746,
0.047163497656583786,
-0.5920199155807495,
0.5632630586624146,
-0.5382626056671143,
0.06036398932337761,
-0.05143990367650986,
0.016319384798407555,
-0.2801242768764496,
0.2862609922885895,
-0.10635523498058319,
0.6339438557624817,
0.4935522675514221,
-0.7892735004425049,
0.2428113967180252,
-0.21625909209251404,
0.07873329520225525,
-0.024185340851545334,
-0.405906617641449,
0.36954477429389954,
-0.34587788581848145,
-0.30332618951797485,
-1.2974317073822021,
-0.2769055664539337,
0.030139699578285217,
-0.22306106984615326,
0.0718793123960495,
-0.09597349166870117,
-0.5475001931190491,
-0.24420000612735748,
-0.22902342677116394,
0.13525736331939697,
0.5508384704589844,
0.01422121562063694,
0.514552891254425,
0.2312413603067398,
-0.1143527403473854,
-0.04319905489683151,
-0.858082115650177,
-0.051338911056518555,
-0.10627485066652298,
-0.5375815629959106,
0.3147321343421936,
-0.06728477030992508,
-0.19536462426185608,
0.20104828476905823,
-0.42210420966148376,
-0.14660194516181946,
0.03868775814771652,
0.009204312227666378,
0.39425382018089294,
-0.409128338098526,
-0.010285310447216034,
-0.005297456402331591,
0.36544373631477356,
0.078923299908638,
-0.17671532928943634,
0.5491804480552673,
-0.252714067697525,
-0.5692081451416016,
-0.10983605682849884,
0.1669001430273056,
0.7866846323013306,
0.06290162354707718,
0.5789477229118347,
0.1822638064622879,
-0.5062707662582397,
-0.32635223865509033,
-0.5436576008796692,
-0.09901675581932068,
-0.4186588227748871,
0.49331673979759216,
-0.6951642036437988,
-0.8545113801956177,
0.5030081272125244,
0.2232193499803543,
0.20042647421360016,
0.6094875335693359,
0.679200291633606,
0.38616225123405457,
0.922455906867981,
0.8233034014701843,
0.35239386558532715,
0.25457343459129333,
-0.10159321129322052,
0.5462659001350403,
-0.22026023268699646,
-0.11952093243598938,
-0.4044419229030609,
-0.08716773241758347,
-0.8732749223709106,
-0.6289032697677612,
0.06472539901733398,
0.07711845636367798,
0.051581524312496185,
0.3519059419631958,
-0.06818392127752304,
0.3554263114929199,
0.0059836977161467075,
-0.355467826128006,
0.3501681983470917,
0.023454269394278526,
-0.40506330132484436,
-0.2169192135334015,
-0.3739617168903351,
-0.596348226070404,
0.9830331802368164,
0.4593310058116913,
0.5828900337219238,
0.5810108184814453,
0.5105292201042175,
-0.03439389914274216,
0.35784676671028137,
-1.1061171293258667,
0.7012706398963928,
-0.4295731782913208,
-0.772964358329773,
-0.35601672530174255,
0.0356609933078289,
-0.8633140921592712,
0.3663347661495209,
-0.1313348412513733,
-0.8630002737045288,
-0.008143269456923008,
-0.007794551085680723,
-0.10940733551979065,
0.4369039237499237,
-0.9049311280250549,
0.5407909750938416,
0.019366037100553513,
-0.3386296331882477,
-0.15688805282115936,
-0.32322195172309875,
0.5121968984603882,
-0.04976092278957367,
0.31213343143463135,
-0.21679215133190155,
-0.20286142826080322,
0.3449595272541046,
-0.15101617574691772,
0.7838889360427856,
-0.1161070466041565,
-0.45863115787506104,
0.030678585171699524,
0.6313797235488892,
0.23729407787322998,
-0.28700754046440125,
-0.2515498697757721,
0.14661946892738342,
0.32266783714294434,
-0.1714640110731125,
-0.7913858294487,
0.3925258219242096,
-0.7087757587432861,
-0.9862138032913208,
-0.2988887131214142,
-0.5697402954101562,
-0.42370325326919556,
0.3763267993927002,
0.18131549656391144,
-0.006942718755453825,
-0.29773756861686707,
-0.05678572878241539,
0.1441648006439209,
0.19011645019054413,
0.2917324900627136,
0.5969586372375488,
-0.7669417262077332,
0.18802261352539062,
0.5589807033538818,
0.26502782106399536,
0.6579716801643372,
0.06170802190899849,
0.26924511790275574,
-0.5873729586601257,
-0.8891787528991699,
-0.4514946937561035,
0.38801735639572144,
-0.6034689545631409,
0.2613196074962616,
-0.317604124546051,
-0.397628515958786,
-0.8751955032348633,
0.20648223161697388,
-0.37744128704071045,
-0.7211615443229675,
-0.05784369632601738,
-0.29647988080978394,
0.012010416947305202,
1.179895043373108,
0.21588057279586792,
-0.05502380430698395,
-0.7303135395050049,
0.31383559107780457,
0.11525339633226395,
0.21609744429588318,
-0.24398811161518097,
-0.8485599756240845,
0.279936283826828,
-0.12457608431577682,
-0.2504783868789673,
-1.3568378686904907,
0.6094138026237488,
0.20135726034641266,
0.628341019153595,
0.4306788444519043,
-0.14579525589942932,
0.519553542137146,
-0.6069552898406982,
0.9665688276290894,
0.04304380714893341,
-1.0006643533706665,
0.1045757457613945,
-0.4294212758541107,
-0.11580248922109604,
0.21101893484592438,
0.46464747190475464,
-0.8864442706108093,
-0.7263624668121338,
-0.7495493292808533,
-0.9302322864532471,
0.5483335256576538,
0.2207368165254593,
0.39295315742492676,
-0.29977601766586304,
0.4562211334705353,
0.3327424228191376,
0.18500442802906036,
-0.8306508660316467,
-0.34263357520103455,
-0.1640833467245102,
0.14827655255794525,
-0.1315804421901703,
-0.09781469404697418,
0.06212662160396576,
-0.39399850368499756,
0.503094494342804,
-0.1209869235754013,
0.16572658717632294,
0.352162629365921,
-0.2226102501153946,
0.14035046100616455,
0.6366347074508667,
0.7958046793937683,
0.6229813098907471,
-0.14539197087287903,
0.4357449412345886,
0.3020284175872803,
-0.5146907567977905,
0.21882881224155426,
-0.07114221155643463,
-0.08956138044595718,
0.24854031205177307,
0.05337037518620491,
0.8470682501792908,
0.1425613909959793,
-0.4147080183029175,
0.4326612055301666,
0.09953691065311432,
-0.3371751606464386,
-0.20584920048713684,
0.2446536421775818,
0.21141688525676727,
-0.10713375359773636,
0.17699208855628967,
-0.14022193849086761,
0.2470618337392807,
-0.7113001942634583,
0.08937478810548782,
0.3142925500869751,
-0.12156607955694199,
-0.779721200466156,
0.4515018165111542,
-0.1007642149925232,
-0.4051480293273926,
0.25270384550094604,
-0.7016289234161377,
-0.35276785492897034,
0.39515137672424316,
0.982154369354248,
0.9366306066513062,
-0.44461944699287415,
0.0650523453950882,
0.187079057097435,
0.3571746349334717,
0.036399319767951965,
0.534974217414856,
0.15951800346374512,
-0.8548410534858704,
-0.43093693256378174,
-0.6477876901626587,
-0.34070464968681335,
0.5035201907157898,
-0.6254475712776184,
0.4744633734226227,
-0.4147913455963135,
-0.13389717042446136,
0.09713846445083618,
-0.3765351474285126,
-0.6369253993034363,
0.03901653736829758,
0.40858906507492065,
1.0062177181243896,
-0.9831917881965637,
0.8519881963729858,
1.290341854095459,
-0.3945182263851166,
-1.0693285465240479,
0.21049480140209198,
0.1817598193883896,
-0.7922355532646179,
0.6986343860626221,
0.023264484480023384,
-0.37792298197746277,
0.053855836391448975,
-0.5182238817214966,
-0.8533986210823059,
0.7476154565811157,
0.5524118542671204,
-0.5320616960525513,
-0.4566846191883087,
0.4070367217063904,
0.6303125023841858,
-0.11244385689496994,
0.16195860505104065,
0.7601146101951599,
0.35262739658355713,
0.0031683603301644325,
-1.2973299026489258,
0.31336089968681335,
-0.18591982126235962,
0.20882302522659302,
0.2252296507358551,
-0.2966153621673584,
1.1148052215576172,
-0.23701311647891998,
-0.6054049730300903,
0.10879779607057571,
0.60074383020401,
0.1654878705739975,
-0.1623724102973938,
0.7298744916915894,
0.42387840151786804,
0.823092520236969,
0.24093450605869293,
0.9071365594863892,
-0.3709987998008728,
0.4941214919090271,
0.7012229561805725,
-0.36344999074935913,
0.9866071343421936,
0.7646268010139465,
-0.2081918865442276,
0.5248051881790161,
0.22936464846134186,
0.08447250723838806,
0.2974921762943268,
0.37018823623657227,
-0.25308725237846375,
-0.21487058699131012,
0.15615659952163696,
-0.002481142757460475,
0.674012303352356,
0.6159850358963013,
-0.11935403198003769,
-0.558832049369812,
-0.12383043766021729,
0.200309157371521,
-0.07463861256837845,
-0.20869775116443634,
0.4463890790939331,
0.06745225191116333,
-0.7213043570518494,
0.7029042840003967,
0.40165477991104126,
0.7383639812469482,
-0.714265763759613,
0.10619401186704636,
-0.15283620357513428,
0.2505930960178375,
-0.23915991187095642,
-0.6903757452964783,
0.6553241014480591,
0.012487318366765976,
-0.07944993674755096,
0.06925450265407562,
0.5416393280029297,
-0.32967597246170044,
-0.42018499970436096,
0.4526022672653198,
0.6879815459251404,
0.5138108730316162,
0.10390029102563858,
-0.46112027764320374,
-0.3048151433467865,
0.039076730608940125,
-0.28756237030029297,
0.2141915261745453,
0.5440766215324402,
-0.4714495539665222,
0.5166748762130737,
0.5997153520584106,
0.3245004713535309,
0.4231733977794647,
0.19136783480644226,
0.7434895038604736,
-0.8422374725341797,
-0.566116452217102,
-0.8871016502380371,
0.3133562505245209,
0.36049243807792664,
-0.4119863212108612,
0.8101139068603516,
0.4930574893951416,
0.9418463706970215,
-0.2614976763725281,
0.6442112326622009,
-0.14861853420734406,
0.18476155400276184,
-0.5614360570907593,
0.6242589354515076,
-0.5466191172599792,
0.05071884021162987,
-0.0528748519718647,
-0.6824417114257812,
-0.2589355409145355,
0.40518027544021606,
-0.40639305114746094,
-0.04137923941016197,
1.1144564151763916,
0.8170441389083862,
-0.3568956255912781,
0.07223032414913177,
0.8263153433799744,
0.42433467507362366,
0.368502676486969,
0.2713051736354828,
0.7024189233779907,
-0.1659124493598938,
0.26028984785079956,
-0.20365913212299347,
-0.07151879370212555,
0.06794151663780212,
-0.89786297082901,
-0.6289302110671997,
-0.6713597178459167,
-0.1673782765865326,
-0.34288257360458374,
-0.04825423285365105,
0.8921036124229431,
0.6073645353317261,
-0.7761423587799072,
-0.38862714171409607,
-0.23500867187976837,
-0.2595234811306,
-0.0403720885515213,
-0.24488380551338196,
0.10097444802522659,
-0.5009270906448364,
-0.8861827254295349,
0.4678518772125244,
0.11219470202922821,
0.22166547179222107,
-0.41315579414367676,
0.21547211706638336,
-0.24486716091632843,
0.2259470373392105,
0.5223987698554993,
0.06128695607185364,
-1.0262173414230347,
-0.5518448352813721,
0.3463960289955139,
-0.03396064043045044,
-0.04688268527388573,
0.7217981219291687,
-0.3889533281326294,
0.22023358941078186,
0.5137085914611816,
0.48919105529785156,
0.4705032706260681,
-0.15832319855690002,
0.5430610775947571,
-0.6979309916496277,
0.30090588331222534,
0.2984768748283386,
0.3243654668331146,
0.1772823929786682,
-0.18599171936511993,
0.16241219639778137,
0.4913908541202545,
-0.31626707315444946,
-0.7661815881729126,
0.4776619076728821,
-0.7804331183433533,
-0.37515947222709656,
1.3330440521240234,
-0.03672656789422035,
-0.42117977142333984,
-0.296355277299881,
-0.03252477943897247,
0.1978338211774826,
-0.14012250304222107,
0.5772457122802734,
0.9982362985610962,
-0.5067269802093506,
0.09291238337755203,
-0.8605557084083557,
0.41842544078826904,
0.8009675145149231,
-0.4344647228717804,
0.22902347147464752,
0.41811227798461914,
0.7829543948173523,
0.29646873474121094,
0.5125014781951904,
-0.18800349533557892,
0.04437616467475891,
-0.15788650512695312,
0.2075943648815155,
0.009911666624248028,
-0.05173707380890846,
-0.642639696598053,
0.1512434035539627,
0.4450356662273407,
-0.14880453050136566
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17853v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17853v1
|
Using Domain Knowledge to Guide Dialog Structure Induction via Neural Probabilistic Soft Logic
| 2024-03-26T16:42:30 | 2024-03-26T16:42:30 |
Connor Pryor, Quan Yuan, Jeremiah Liu, Mehran Kazemi, Deepak Ramachandran, Tania Bedrax-Weiss, Lise Getoor
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Dialog Structure Induction (DSI) is the task of inferring the latent dialog
structure (i.e., a set of dialog states and their temporal transitions) of a
given goal-oriented dialog. It is a critical component for modern dialog system
design and discourse analysis. Existing DSI approaches are often purely
data-driven, deploy models that infer latent states without access to domain
knowledge, underperform when the training corpus is limited/noisy, or have
difficulty when test dialogs exhibit distributional shifts from the training
domain. This work explores a neural-symbolic approach as a potential solution
to these problems. We introduce Neural Probabilistic Soft Logic Dialogue
Structure Induction (NEUPSL DSI), a principled approach that injects symbolic
knowledge into the latent space of a generative neural model. We conduct a
thorough empirical investigation on the effect of NEUPSL DSI learning on hidden
representation quality, few-shot learning, and out-of-domain generalization
performance. Over three dialog structure induction datasets and across
unsupervised and semi-supervised settings for standard and cross-domain
generalization, the injection of symbolic knowledge using NEUPSL DSI provides a
consistent boost in performance over the canonical baselines.
|
[
-0.06697707623243332,
-0.9513165950775146,
0.6813803911209106,
-0.26675665378570557,
-0.12624938786029816,
0.03336944803595543,
0.12716710567474365,
-0.03895588219165802,
-0.09440393000841141,
0.1880328506231308,
-0.9147025942802429,
-0.5323507785797119,
-0.5353155732154846,
-0.024423781782388687,
-0.0632920116186142,
1.1010528802871704,
0.20447349548339844,
0.18297749757766724,
-0.23980383574962616,
0.07746139913797379,
-0.4509395956993103,
-0.5825662016868591,
-0.4889746904373169,
-0.5222285985946655,
0.15735755860805511,
-0.1969332993030548,
0.6382009983062744,
0.1164412721991539,
-0.07613173127174377,
0.3505249321460724,
-0.19434256851673126,
0.4097839593887329,
-0.2752654254436493,
0.15184791386127472,
0.009349824860692024,
-0.7653278708457947,
-0.6109380722045898,
0.015758618712425232,
0.4730890095233917,
1.0118175745010376,
-0.1954914927482605,
-0.1863461285829544,
0.24994349479675293,
0.4108118414878845,
-0.4426270127296448,
0.7205536961555481,
-0.7140306234359741,
0.2632625699043274,
0.06655857712030411,
-0.3897567093372345,
-0.4740879237651825,
-0.4771064817905426,
0.4062429964542389,
-0.7512773871421814,
0.18040461838245392,
-0.2871344983577728,
0.6154664754867554,
0.3449629843235016,
-0.5826675891876221,
-0.2839340269565582,
-0.5714559555053711,
0.7803659439086914,
-0.8618581295013428,
0.11910107731819153,
0.17449142038822174,
0.4610958695411682,
-0.5470792651176453,
-0.33236923813819885,
-0.6606961488723755,
-0.10119419544935226,
-0.24124561250209808,
0.14683683216571808,
-0.06198469176888466,
0.3460541069507599,
0.30480289459228516,
0.006826795171946287,
-0.4725169837474823,
-0.34613779187202454,
-0.06087799370288849,
0.043275028467178345,
0.4996604323387146,
0.32917773723602295,
0.42954587936401367,
-0.14082223176956177,
0.05766603723168373,
0.22909855842590332,
-0.782279908657074,
-0.29680517315864563,
0.46131110191345215,
0.5315043330192566,
-0.1737700253725052,
0.24323652684688568,
-0.18607521057128906,
0.7718361020088196,
0.5340884327888489,
-0.23663152754306793,
0.38866299390792847,
-0.4315893352031708,
-0.14743246138095856,
0.26381343603134155,
0.45178303122520447,
0.10719309002161026,
0.5463492274284363,
-0.222441628575325,
-0.37110474705696106,
0.150848388671875,
0.25896409153938293,
-0.8006647229194641,
0.015819793567061424,
-0.05316665396094322,
-0.518166720867157,
-0.36368101835250854,
-0.11663280427455902,
-0.2157643586397171,
-0.3739529252052307,
-0.5709367394447327,
0.43114906549453735,
-0.5042644143104553,
-0.4991426467895508,
-0.07529246807098389,
-0.19251291453838348,
0.10359128564596176,
0.40799105167388916,
-0.8868687748908997,
0.4882589876651764,
0.7891104817390442,
0.6342938542366028,
0.2642821669578552,
0.028328262269496918,
-0.5578553676605225,
0.11031372100114822,
-0.4875941872596741,
0.6765202283859253,
-0.7052595019340515,
-0.19205516576766968,
0.2072107344865799,
-0.020194415003061295,
-0.4426001012325287,
-0.6931331157684326,
0.02230311930179596,
-0.6270657181739807,
0.21346701681613922,
0.19746385514736176,
-0.574729323387146,
-0.13061055541038513,
0.14405308663845062,
-0.3669362962245941,
0.5873348116874695,
0.27515530586242676,
-0.4508934020996094,
0.35827311873435974,
-0.6616877913475037,
-0.620007336139679,
0.19893065094947815,
-0.8091549873352051,
-0.17735084891319275,
0.5124624371528625,
0.16688863933086395,
0.5008430480957031,
-0.06297734379768372,
0.8366380929946899,
-0.2019965797662735,
-0.3590657114982605,
0.31938111782073975,
-0.4784606695175171,
0.7584804892539978,
0.0036985967308282852,
-0.5050004720687866,
-0.02836477756500244,
-0.5436549186706543,
0.06877051293849945,
0.08182685822248459,
0.312801331281662,
-0.24791811406612396,
-0.11110170930624008,
-0.2850622832775116,
0.33879920840263367,
-0.28409186005592346,
-0.4174058735370636,
0.17590777575969696,
-0.8855257630348206,
0.4694848954677582,
0.8161062002182007,
0.24202224612236023,
0.7074692249298096,
-0.029683049768209457,
0.29800480604171753,
0.6059250831604004,
0.12506675720214844,
0.010797620750963688,
-0.6316338777542114,
-0.4747586250305176,
0.1859520673751831,
0.32666951417922974,
0.4187725782394409,
-1.0218266248703003,
0.6083372831344604,
-0.1901094764471054,
-0.05109339579939842,
-0.08624201267957687,
-0.006964848842471838,
0.4144335389137268,
0.6073840260505676,
-0.0794532522559166,
-0.3698006272315979,
-0.10923615097999573,
-0.9653736352920532,
0.07418996095657349,
-0.24490603804588318,
-0.21925297379493713,
0.5217702388763428,
0.5486853718757629,
-0.028835255652666092,
0.8266023397445679,
-0.7218990325927734,
-0.30569514632225037,
-0.49592775106430054,
0.4349142014980316,
0.5050060749053955,
0.3047139048576355,
0.6048137545585632,
-0.7838301658630371,
-0.41746988892555237,
-0.24521014094352722,
-1.1003069877624512,
-0.013615254312753677,
-0.23518508672714233,
-0.17397668957710266,
0.3211826980113983,
0.32009196281433105,
-0.7524309754371643,
0.7789585590362549,
0.3676275312900543,
-0.2860040068626404,
0.5442888736724854,
0.0008222627220675349,
0.0783519297838211,
-1.2207868099212646,
-0.3734317421913147,
0.04145197570323944,
0.08100155740976334,
-0.7779498100280762,
-0.5834683775901794,
-0.16929972171783447,
-0.2975526452064514,
-0.468919962644577,
0.31579580903053284,
-0.2813743054866791,
-0.1120351254940033,
-0.21812163293361664,
0.08485762029886246,
-0.038469817489385605,
0.9120949506759644,
0.3125867247581482,
0.9962611198425293,
0.6416800618171692,
-0.6333462595939636,
-0.1298057734966278,
0.4302014112472534,
-0.3371567130088806,
0.7002924680709839,
-0.7328541874885559,
0.2791486978530884,
-0.24601738154888153,
0.4778881371021271,
-0.8464462757110596,
0.11417590081691742,
0.30502545833587646,
-0.4802894592285156,
0.39984649419784546,
-0.6066368222236633,
-0.393290638923645,
0.2589079439640045,
0.19525881111621857,
0.49332866072654724,
0.4494496285915375,
-0.4845343828201294,
0.9119605422019958,
0.3342766761779785,
-0.31518465280532837,
-0.4076922535896301,
-0.2877903878688812,
-0.03387269377708435,
0.14777374267578125,
-0.7635857462882996,
0.4501175582408905,
-0.08604860305786133,
-0.41825392842292786,
0.10758809000253677,
-0.4053788483142853,
-0.30848631262779236,
0.03111836686730385,
0.6189781427383423,
0.17483830451965332,
-0.4354959726333618,
0.1391129046678543,
0.395942360162735,
-0.35708892345428467,
0.2385035753250122,
-0.5926554799079895,
0.3743062913417816,
-0.13576282560825348,
-0.3451519310474396,
-0.9244272708892822,
0.5966420769691467,
0.5043306946754456,
0.16636382043361664,
0.7142467498779297,
0.03381406143307686,
-0.4409853518009186,
-0.5467566251754761,
-0.2391565591096878,
-0.4642271399497986,
-0.4832867681980133,
0.25460290908813477,
-0.6433097124099731,
-0.5061778426170349,
0.22617051005363464,
-0.40136969089508057,
-0.09857753664255142,
0.25147369503974915,
0.31336838006973267,
-0.17839013040065765,
1.2600691318511963,
0.6381325721740723,
0.14510057866573334,
0.4989742636680603,
-0.4470271170139313,
0.4894695580005646,
-0.4925133287906647,
-0.256669282913208,
-0.15771935880184174,
-0.2981796860694885,
-0.29307377338409424,
-0.3648390769958496,
0.3620210886001587,
-0.22543172538280487,
-0.10226038098335266,
0.2012082189321518,
-0.14448724687099457,
0.33278247714042664,
0.3423263430595398,
0.11054766923189163,
0.1449553370475769,
0.15728913247585297,
-0.10871850699186325,
-0.06289736181497574,
-0.8056138157844543,
-0.4762710630893707,
0.9719891548156738,
0.15747804939746857,
0.6100939512252808,
0.02601522020995617,
0.8803809881210327,
0.36390867829322815,
0.11268948763608932,
-0.8519415259361267,
0.6897742748260498,
-0.09933770447969437,
-0.29251348972320557,
-0.14081068336963654,
-0.46361133456230164,
-0.691565215587616,
-0.01922052726149559,
-0.05963229760527611,
-0.5847410559654236,
0.28986889123916626,
0.039892006665468216,
-0.6000628471374512,
0.06070121377706528,
-0.7911987900733948,
0.49837878346443176,
-0.16152554750442505,
-0.2151927351951599,
-0.31992557644844055,
-0.6104223132133484,
0.062393222004175186,
0.15996704995632172,
-0.22414012253284454,
-0.11967936158180237,
0.46692606806755066,
0.7825252413749695,
-0.5050668120384216,
1.206880807876587,
-0.611663818359375,
-0.10153321921825409,
0.4336135983467102,
0.06484715640544891,
0.47515204548835754,
0.34175682067871094,
-0.02160288579761982,
0.4513280391693115,
-0.2746626138687134,
-0.23671773076057434,
-1.2882788181304932,
0.4075780212879181,
-0.8734115362167358,
-0.750557541847229,
-0.3175455927848816,
-0.4784683287143707,
-0.5726087689399719,
0.01451710145920515,
0.005903478246182203,
0.9327972531318665,
-0.15607640147209167,
-0.10318959504365921,
0.9656881093978882,
-0.13728655874729156,
0.09914164245128632,
0.23394648730754852,
0.5044826865196228,
-0.12341718375682831,
0.6281095743179321,
0.1630793660879135,
0.21290037035942078,
0.3185628056526184,
0.02270982600748539,
-0.28297552466392517,
-0.552628219127655,
-0.4656105637550354,
0.22784677147865295,
-0.5996943712234497,
-0.3251725435256958,
-0.7833588123321533,
-0.6767982840538025,
-0.5468467473983765,
-0.12176680564880371,
-0.2744908034801483,
-0.541020929813385,
-0.1936504989862442,
-0.2850778102874756,
-0.02625359781086445,
0.8187975883483887,
0.35251584649086,
0.3280434310436249,
-0.5267848372459412,
0.4967987835407257,
0.4452657997608185,
0.29003649950027466,
-0.08907011896371841,
-0.6335172653198242,
0.14339320361614227,
0.10853693634271622,
-0.23795711994171143,
-0.7911897897720337,
0.32722756266593933,
0.4050911068916321,
0.7868485450744629,
0.6753005385398865,
0.0025288620963692665,
0.5888053178787231,
-0.6815975308418274,
0.6191481351852417,
0.2692238986492157,
-0.7478978633880615,
0.8384851813316345,
-0.3709810674190521,
0.20240899920463562,
0.5822456479072571,
0.38492482900619507,
-0.2832483947277069,
-0.2701967656612396,
-0.717534601688385,
-0.4354898929595947,
0.6703852415084839,
0.23266401886940002,
0.33978891372680664,
-0.10459843277931213,
0.5037248730659485,
0.29100361466407776,
0.48325684666633606,
-0.1873335838317871,
-0.21743160486221313,
-0.2094910889863968,
-0.313247948884964,
0.14763765037059784,
-0.18534383177757263,
-0.2572186589241028,
-0.17566494643688202,
0.6204614639282227,
-0.5224568843841553,
0.5376972556114197,
-0.06354274600744247,
-0.35376879572868347,
0.15357239544391632,
0.3185505270957947,
0.3827030062675476,
0.7112916111946106,
-0.1398543417453766,
0.05855899304151535,
0.057236067950725555,
-0.18076938390731812,
0.11514110863208771,
-0.1261448860168457,
-0.2433062493801117,
0.03432152792811394,
0.18130816519260406,
0.7951588034629822,
0.18467438220977783,
-0.3286948502063751,
0.6600324511528015,
-0.24934211373329163,
-0.5324775576591492,
-0.24384060502052307,
0.08402833342552185,
-0.2850838005542755,
0.45070457458496094,
0.27973440289497375,
0.04005216434597969,
0.22345250844955444,
-0.6529865860939026,
0.3579241633415222,
0.4556666910648346,
-0.3614676594734192,
-0.6727798581123352,
0.3531692922115326,
0.3328486680984497,
-0.3466956615447998,
1.0655289888381958,
-0.27334579825401306,
-0.5446152687072754,
0.5445148944854736,
0.7792683839797974,
1.1959296464920044,
0.09115615487098694,
0.5965737104415894,
0.18548144400119781,
-0.017239246517419815,
0.3970787525177002,
0.32483819127082825,
-0.42707589268684387,
-0.9138251543045044,
-0.46375757455825806,
-0.547827422618866,
-0.210668683052063,
0.25806015729904175,
-0.3148554265499115,
-0.06179608032107353,
-0.440537691116333,
-0.14842131733894348,
-0.04570003226399422,
-0.026146622374653816,
-0.68568354845047,
0.17304468154907227,
0.37156224250793457,
0.706630289554596,
-1.2283763885498047,
0.7493012547492981,
0.45652517676353455,
-0.2585420608520508,
-0.7258076667785645,
0.3309168219566345,
0.3874674141407013,
-0.6954399943351746,
1.142016887664795,
0.18623895943164825,
-0.32009321451187134,
-0.2018955498933792,
-0.4843742847442627,
-0.5044208765029907,
0.8718463182449341,
0.25064077973365784,
-0.27208369970321655,
-0.1257420927286148,
0.22984179854393005,
0.5657046437263489,
-0.5957784056663513,
0.33187493681907654,
0.43690139055252075,
0.12112564593553543,
0.09244920313358307,
-0.48857516050338745,
0.18839770555496216,
-0.6703326106071472,
0.0385904535651207,
0.07484478503465652,
-0.19046896696090698,
0.4030989706516266,
-0.20660683512687683,
-0.4484211206436157,
-0.04712662100791931,
0.7914527058601379,
0.21025414764881134,
0.3391048014163971,
0.7275326251983643,
0.3107573390007019,
0.5430121421813965,
-0.12416746467351913,
0.6572341918945312,
-0.5080986022949219,
-0.2503552734851837,
1.1291743516921997,
-0.4818163812160492,
0.3948194980621338,
0.49449390172958374,
0.12692315876483917,
0.8489360213279724,
0.27522018551826477,
0.2018090933561325,
0.7243525385856628,
0.1939268559217453,
-0.4671750068664551,
-0.28139910101890564,
-0.4221936762332916,
-0.20635685324668884,
0.39562249183654785,
0.5727764964103699,
-0.3098282516002655,
-0.29899367690086365,
-0.3240082859992981,
-0.3368237018585205,
0.009115737862884998,
0.1926061511039734,
1.1328856945037842,
0.1673460751771927,
-0.6406410932540894,
0.5080714225769043,
-0.32873669266700745,
0.3808041214942932,
-0.7726609110832214,
-0.4635598063468933,
-0.35522496700286865,
0.1288563311100006,
-0.14563335478305817,
-0.5624293088912964,
0.40111926198005676,
-0.31935828924179077,
-0.14757007360458374,
-0.4599111080169678,
0.8573213815689087,
-0.14912070333957672,
-0.12043590843677521,
0.09128923714160919,
0.6288190484046936,
0.045161571353673935,
-0.22036662697792053,
-0.6387644410133362,
-0.45680296421051025,
-0.3942957818508148,
-0.1537647247314453,
0.5427367091178894,
0.5723740458488464,
-0.19574670493602753,
0.3555261790752411,
0.5795217156410217,
-0.13936792314052582,
-0.36251917481422424,
0.6563035249710083,
0.9691869616508484,
-0.5382297039031982,
-0.6080232858657837,
-0.5868124961853027,
0.3821954131126404,
-0.21547386050224304,
-0.12089988589286804,
0.5225565433502197,
0.2621474266052246,
0.5516406297683716,
-0.05864252522587776,
1.0018166303634644,
0.0174888763576746,
-0.1993902325630188,
-0.49419093132019043,
0.7655640840530396,
-0.33899322152137756,
-0.05315733328461647,
-0.3005879521369934,
-0.7553236484527588,
-0.05801752209663391,
0.5570164322853088,
-0.5344293713569641,
0.030848294496536255,
0.7361387014389038,
1.115944743156433,
0.06634961068630219,
0.3067949712276459,
0.5079967975616455,
0.10127229988574982,
0.17644408345222473,
0.716766893863678,
1.1592748165130615,
-0.3112814128398895,
0.2613968849182129,
-0.04066327214241028,
-0.49934080243110657,
0.0954243540763855,
-0.5770307779312134,
-1.163615345954895,
-0.6768626570701599,
-0.5645079016685486,
-0.4286118447780609,
0.3944346308708191,
0.6846562027931213,
1.035212755203247,
-0.845062792301178,
-0.14804641902446747,
-0.2687779366970062,
0.2043931782245636,
-0.44939154386520386,
-0.2730674147605896,
0.22789950668811798,
-0.5325609445571899,
-0.6506586074829102,
0.7235419154167175,
0.606182873249054,
-0.0930229127407074,
0.001311441999860108,
0.13169898092746735,
-0.09137164056301117,
0.2670188546180725,
0.7335827946662903,
-0.1012452095746994,
-0.5443218350410461,
-0.02363361045718193,
-0.11458749324083328,
0.05496257543563843,
0.10310255736112595,
1.0210633277893066,
-0.8483877182006836,
0.14833541214466095,
0.4908542037010193,
0.6855680346488953,
0.18505381047725677,
-0.1643788069486618,
0.8936957120895386,
-1.0365797281265259,
0.13876603543758392,
0.2567903399467468,
0.22632458806037903,
-0.09667477011680603,
-0.5555164813995361,
0.4697532057762146,
0.47082406282424927,
-0.1287764012813568,
-0.5957514047622681,
0.512536346912384,
-0.6711068749427795,
-0.3470110595226288,
0.9647414088249207,
-0.06236470490694046,
-0.48715436458587646,
-0.45635128021240234,
-0.038163453340530396,
0.2246917337179184,
-0.4532899260520935,
0.7153015732765198,
0.2789849042892456,
-0.32019180059432983,
0.10897178947925568,
-0.4788523018360138,
0.64176344871521,
0.5092628598213196,
-0.8950024843215942,
0.08645661920309067,
0.4777613580226898,
0.1978539228439331,
0.1890922337770462,
0.7307414412498474,
-0.24948126077651978,
0.23116329312324524,
0.2797122299671173,
-0.3489561676979065,
0.0452752523124218,
-0.6202242970466614,
-0.2748928666114807,
0.36063849925994873,
-0.3017269968986511,
-0.07473358511924744
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17848v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17848v1
|
ArabicaQA: A Comprehensive Dataset for Arabic Question Answering
| 2024-03-26T16:37:54 | 2024-03-26T16:37:54 |
Abdelrahman Abdallah, Mahmoud Kasem, Mahmoud Abdalla, Mohamed Mahmoud, Mohamed Elkasaby, Yasser Elbendary, Adam Jatowt
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
In this paper, we address the significant gap in Arabic natural language
processing (NLP) resources by introducing ArabicaQA, the first large-scale
dataset for machine reading comprehension and open-domain question answering in
Arabic. This comprehensive dataset, consisting of 89,095 answerable and 3,701
unanswerable questions created by crowdworkers to look similar to answerable
ones, along with additional labels of open-domain questions marks a crucial
advancement in Arabic NLP resources. We also present AraDPR, the first dense
passage retrieval model trained on the Arabic Wikipedia corpus, specifically
designed to tackle the unique challenges of Arabic text retrieval. Furthermore,
our study includes extensive benchmarking of large language models (LLMs) for
Arabic question answering, critically evaluating their performance in the
Arabic language context. In conclusion, ArabicaQA, AraDPR, and the benchmarking
of LLMs in Arabic question answering offer significant advancements in the
field of Arabic NLP. The dataset and code are publicly accessible for further
research https://github.com/DataScienceUIBK/ArabicaQA.
|
[
-0.6814413666725159,
-0.8267039656639099,
0.4218257665634155,
0.14336298406124115,
-0.24647967517375946,
0.14666089415550232,
0.17027732729911804,
-0.4567081928253174,
-0.12423120439052582,
0.6206890940666199,
-0.22655445337295532,
-0.6566764116287231,
-0.6733616590499878,
0.21674177050590515,
-0.6634494066238403,
0.8939048051834106,
-0.34375059604644775,
-0.07151259481906891,
-0.0120040662586689,
-0.5669999718666077,
-0.33732062578201294,
-0.35095539689064026,
-0.6781100630760193,
0.07352983206510544,
0.6224798560142517,
0.6729344725608826,
1.1786882877349854,
0.44696176052093506,
0.44143959879875183,
0.21000812947750092,
-0.10839629173278809,
0.21999283134937286,
-0.19667193293571472,
0.14155223965644836,
-0.048868194222450256,
-0.17679272592067719,
-0.08529640734195709,
-0.4964603781700134,
0.780018150806427,
0.8552011847496033,
-0.2564058005809784,
0.38327422738075256,
-0.2794605493545532,
0.9281344413757324,
-0.7146170139312744,
-0.10356111079454422,
-0.5170033574104309,
-0.10429279506206512,
-0.2867034673690796,
0.1496352255344391,
-0.07255809754133224,
-0.5672082901000977,
0.1721353381872177,
-0.30641642212867737,
-0.0012322684051468968,
0.047797419130802155,
0.5995227098464966,
0.4123499393463135,
-0.6212664842605591,
-0.5141523480415344,
-0.5679035186767578,
0.5905401110649109,
-0.5116787552833557,
0.21700449287891388,
0.5119543075561523,
0.33533868193626404,
0.07989651709794998,
-0.7990359663963318,
-0.8124507665634155,
0.12997323274612427,
0.22874824702739716,
-0.12484685331583023,
-0.3614310026168823,
-0.21303483843803406,
-0.03220074623823166,
0.317080020904541,
-0.7524715662002563,
-0.12152769416570663,
-0.2489604949951172,
0.11465998739004135,
0.4569441080093384,
-0.017885668203234673,
0.6216896772384644,
0.060144636780023575,
-0.127733051776886,
-0.15048660337924957,
-0.7198444604873657,
0.17091836035251617,
0.08076543360948563,
-0.087223120033741,
-0.098118357360363,
0.8045201301574707,
-0.43642181158065796,
0.7747823596000671,
-0.5564819574356079,
0.28195831179618835,
0.09215791523456573,
-0.11279357224702835,
-0.019405269995331764,
0.14321942627429962,
0.4512384235858917,
-0.005397870671004057,
0.5093194246292114,
-0.21518047153949738,
-0.03642262890934944,
-0.32279732823371887,
0.19715504348278046,
-1.0073758363723755,
-0.12416582554578781,
0.6117243766784668,
-0.31705722212791443,
0.16063043475151062,
-0.0757715031504631,
-0.6222827434539795,
-0.21820691227912903,
-0.11545592546463013,
0.19128914177417755,
-0.32144173979759216,
-0.22930312156677246,
0.2208644449710846,
0.011279485188424587,
0.5018687844276428,
0.3693082332611084,
-0.7447364330291748,
0.40866538882255554,
0.7443728446960449,
0.8964296579360962,
-0.21964988112449646,
-0.10545565187931061,
-0.3157884180545807,
0.05507122725248337,
-0.5081391930580139,
0.8277342915534973,
-0.7607661485671997,
-0.12159940600395203,
0.2712622582912445,
-0.37972185015678406,
0.08790372312068939,
-0.7798739075660706,
0.7984744310379028,
-1.3606477975845337,
-0.09843504428863525,
-0.12469247728586197,
-0.4886481463909149,
-0.6320697665214539,
0.21052883565425873,
-0.9899095296859741,
0.9093868732452393,
0.12701572477817535,
-0.917535662651062,
-0.1812654286623001,
-0.7498749494552612,
-0.06097866967320442,
0.04258600249886513,
0.05790349096059799,
-0.25077947974205017,
-0.09864254295825958,
0.6488134860992432,
0.06772977113723755,
-0.39040428400039673,
0.13920404016971588,
-0.08841866254806519,
-0.3289957046508789,
0.662765622138977,
-0.49901992082595825,
0.815579354763031,
0.41167452931404114,
0.10945937782526016,
-0.08358149975538254,
-0.7247967720031738,
0.36458292603492737,
-0.04714949056506157,
-0.23819978535175323,
-0.17219246923923492,
-0.14911343157291412,
0.36504828929901123,
0.33064258098602295,
0.35968923568725586,
-0.5381425619125366,
0.0885680615901947,
-0.3349252939224243,
0.16610980033874512,
0.5343192219734192,
0.12709642946720123,
0.244802325963974,
-0.42320412397384644,
0.7069022059440613,
0.012383717112243176,
-0.3114873468875885,
-0.12597475945949554,
-0.5988739728927612,
-0.6225343346595764,
-0.24508649110794067,
0.5543311238288879,
0.6472482681274414,
-0.8014118671417236,
0.09537627547979355,
-0.07382961362600327,
-0.5898736119270325,
-0.7551462650299072,
0.11754022538661957,
0.18459266424179077,
0.4180506765842438,
0.4931284487247467,
-0.3320940136909485,
-0.3810274302959442,
-0.8104639649391174,
-0.23169660568237305,
-0.2529620826244354,
-0.16190887987613678,
0.3557189404964447,
0.64356529712677,
-0.15078021585941315,
0.8890686631202698,
-0.622501015663147,
-0.010741538368165493,
-0.23224128782749176,
0.06743603944778442,
0.4333135783672333,
0.24976348876953125,
0.38230887055397034,
-0.8641635179519653,
-0.7526559829711914,
-0.07059402018785477,
-0.6586223840713501,
-0.17933602631092072,
0.24918046593666077,
-0.36128532886505127,
0.13962949812412262,
0.3101320266723633,
-0.8090879321098328,
0.44185352325439453,
0.6050844192504883,
-0.37143588066101074,
0.43823108077049255,
0.1176125779747963,
0.09984669834375381,
-1.0843464136123657,
0.3508318066596985,
-0.3824942111968994,
-0.008789227344095707,
-0.6603983044624329,
0.27815645933151245,
-0.024262111634016037,
-0.178915873169899,
-0.5013596415519714,
0.8614093661308289,
-0.23026347160339355,
-0.060960110276937485,
-0.35086560249328613,
-0.008521867915987968,
-0.048672210425138474,
0.39357370138168335,
0.08681891113519669,
1.315200924873352,
0.5394495129585266,
-0.54156893491745,
0.2211936116218567,
0.8477781414985657,
-0.6909633278846741,
0.13761839270591736,
-1.005334734916687,
0.4867343306541443,
-0.3427527844905853,
0.2621849775314331,
-1.0076555013656616,
-0.06521975994110107,
0.28583550453186035,
-0.39604252576828003,
-0.1404368132352829,
-0.03673328831791878,
-0.4794759750366211,
-0.0423738993704319,
0.06218346580862999,
0.948167085647583,
0.36217251420021057,
-0.4927949607372284,
0.4346470832824707,
0.3535870611667633,
-0.87421715259552,
-0.9436740875244141,
-0.04593922197818756,
0.15745611488819122,
-0.051652077585458755,
-0.6687578558921814,
0.19921496510505676,
-0.11641203612089157,
-0.4859362542629242,
-0.07715999335050583,
-0.09625262767076492,
-0.5965664982795715,
0.13832423090934753,
0.13966691493988037,
0.13087913393974304,
-0.3383650779724121,
0.2823697626590729,
0.06586802750825882,
-0.09527033567428589,
0.2370842844247818,
-0.03369792178273201,
0.6226984858512878,
-0.03269999474287033,
-0.30704450607299805,
-0.2790285646915436,
0.7438554763793945,
0.1979677677154541,
-0.5680546164512634,
1.0983024835586548,
0.5296120047569275,
-0.3545770049095154,
0.010783437639474869,
-0.3047027289867401,
0.045685965567827225,
-0.4155326187610626,
0.5561858415603638,
-0.42012035846710205,
-0.8835233449935913,
0.5081407427787781,
0.04994068667292595,
0.19328853487968445,
0.4642430245876312,
0.5505909323692322,
-0.10985066741704941,
1.0933332443237305,
0.4906081259250641,
-0.48733046650886536,
-0.03392013534903526,
-0.01843946985900402,
0.08269675821065903,
-0.5654171705245972,
-0.10445263236761093,
-1.0214800834655762,
-0.3358268737792969,
-0.43727242946624756,
-0.530467689037323,
0.4588865339756012,
0.20322994887828827,
-0.539823591709137,
-0.2236679345369339,
-0.05549710988998413,
0.6179093718528748,
0.6616237759590149,
-0.17231276631355286,
0.5378151535987854,
0.17482443153858185,
0.10937200486660004,
0.24681024253368378,
-0.5835164785385132,
-0.777509868144989,
1.2617253065109253,
0.17092756927013397,
0.43988603353500366,
0.546870768070221,
0.30756875872612,
0.4549964964389801,
0.24726293981075287,
-0.4202457666397095,
0.35956817865371704,
0.31435009837150574,
-0.8135616779327393,
-0.5006498694419861,
-0.2741847038269043,
-1.1721656322479248,
0.324296772480011,
0.09868188947439194,
-0.45846548676490784,
0.024538712576031685,
-0.3940471410751343,
-0.3170788586139679,
0.2368142455816269,
-0.23894470930099487,
0.8062453866004944,
0.09250598400831223,
0.005581539589911699,
-0.26546305418014526,
-0.7647033929824829,
0.13713692128658295,
-0.22969381511211395,
0.023243334144353867,
-0.21232543885707855,
-0.4133065640926361,
0.9303463101387024,
-0.4326455891132355,
0.26657137274742126,
-0.030112216249108315,
-0.22992967069149017,
0.5859359502792358,
0.009891858324408531,
0.2874951660633087,
0.3084908723831177,
-0.33046185970306396,
0.3353267312049866,
0.27312830090522766,
-0.9278334975242615,
-0.5724431872367859,
0.45263463258743286,
-1.2384814023971558,
-0.4635998606681824,
-0.7151201963424683,
-0.709425687789917,
-0.34708812832832336,
0.16147370636463165,
-0.276871919631958,
0.32553040981292725,
-0.37911760807037354,
0.20507724583148956,
0.7382777333259583,
-0.3105565011501312,
0.4337681829929352,
0.7432548999786377,
-0.32977190613746643,
-0.42268601059913635,
0.5299238562583923,
-0.08900825679302216,
-0.03528367727994919,
0.5300267934799194,
-0.4434419572353363,
-0.4753492474555969,
-0.9138598442077637,
-0.8231462836265564,
0.26962900161743164,
-0.7085033059120178,
-0.2438066601753235,
-0.7456744909286499,
-0.44766467809677124,
-0.05669906735420227,
0.1384168118238449,
0.024754315614700317,
-0.5368251800537109,
-0.28374379873275757,
-0.0691751092672348,
0.38338300585746765,
0.6728134155273438,
0.1765051931142807,
0.2653461992740631,
-1.0201189517974854,
0.6342401504516602,
0.2935743033885956,
0.1994149535894394,
0.13233403861522675,
-0.6776139140129089,
-0.27211588621139526,
0.13714097440242767,
-0.33873802423477173,
-0.8658487796783447,
0.5264685750007629,
0.19795462489128113,
0.09233807027339935,
0.40520837903022766,
0.27849945425987244,
0.3420090973377228,
-0.6131075620651245,
0.5080393552780151,
-0.3149549067020416,
-0.6551311612129211,
0.20200197398662567,
-0.1709764152765274,
0.746239423751831,
0.6579345464706421,
0.8427484035491943,
-0.9630183577537537,
-0.053767140954732895,
-0.2797645330429077,
-0.8257343769073486,
0.5552515983581543,
0.4736449420452118,
0.2627525329589844,
-0.028953494504094124,
0.38810908794403076,
0.3577275574207306,
0.3139590919017792,
-0.2522680163383484,
-0.5304620862007141,
-0.03522162884473801,
-0.3455185294151306,
-0.14775504171848297,
-0.3307834267616272,
-0.08615778386592865,
-0.1039794310927391,
0.8184279799461365,
-0.1578163206577301,
0.15948468446731567,
0.07869716733694077,
-0.33581897616386414,
-0.09843780845403671,
0.46020740270614624,
0.21411684155464172,
1.0307856798171997,
-0.26577913761138916,
-0.04257901757955551,
0.12692886590957642,
-0.6426352858543396,
0.20369696617126465,
0.4708752930164337,
-0.47158265113830566,
0.05990353226661682,
0.2942933440208435,
0.4815506637096405,
-0.4538504481315613,
-1.207603096961975,
0.228396937251091,
-0.14011016488075256,
0.06824859231710434,
-0.576524555683136,
-0.10604154318571091,
0.19830961525440216,
0.12057004868984222,
0.8095563650131226,
-0.1181362196803093,
0.2499500811100006,
-0.370087206363678,
0.28746020793914795,
0.3954121768474579,
-0.38825172185897827,
-0.04349001869559288,
0.5019869804382324,
-0.018362633883953094,
-0.06954070925712585,
1.016572117805481,
0.19834527373313904,
-0.34635454416275024,
0.823866605758667,
0.26364946365356445,
0.4549449682235718,
-0.06971846520900726,
0.5816901326179504,
0.27951034903526306,
0.1351909190416336,
0.40528205037117004,
0.7217104434967041,
-0.1715337485074997,
-0.8783769607543945,
-0.3933298885822296,
-0.673215389251709,
-0.7695425748825073,
-0.06334080547094345,
-0.6376262903213501,
-0.242315873503685,
-0.3306896686553955,
0.2157057523727417,
0.07078476995229721,
0.2343057543039322,
-0.5976741909980774,
0.37626680731773376,
0.04700383543968201,
1.1444401741027832,
-0.4956974387168884,
0.7686268091201782,
0.7062363624572754,
-0.4971139132976532,
-0.4788498282432556,
-0.005634771194308996,
-0.46432748436927795,
-0.9494854807853699,
0.4203048646450043,
0.16586804389953613,
0.09625732153654099,
0.2542080879211426,
-0.7622210383415222,
-1.1076853275299072,
0.7937644124031067,
0.12582053244113922,
-0.15300461649894714,
0.06881073117256165,
0.6654959321022034,
0.40028172731399536,
-0.06841817498207092,
0.5707426071166992,
0.5612380504608154,
0.39227741956710815,
0.03785628825426102,
-0.4781778156757355,
-0.06600732356309891,
-0.43522241711616516,
-0.20640720427036285,
0.17582856118679047,
-0.6216478943824768,
0.5883263945579529,
-0.2555585503578186,
-0.1792040914297104,
0.7120988368988037,
1.0800062417984009,
0.27133360505104065,
0.356746107339859,
0.19003987312316895,
0.6870757341384888,
0.7640227675437927,
0.026569928973913193,
0.9651151895523071,
-0.3635994493961334,
-0.20557278394699097,
0.936947226524353,
-0.2620227634906769,
1.2017412185668945,
0.3571491837501526,
-0.40832504630088806,
0.7809918522834778,
0.572873592376709,
0.508171558380127,
0.447179913520813,
0.19910065829753876,
-0.6705763936042786,
-0.25688180327415466,
-0.38883543014526367,
-0.663174033164978,
0.49104103446006775,
0.20684002339839935,
-0.08502484858036041,
-0.2377476990222931,
-0.16018079221248627,
0.11711151152849197,
0.11052072048187256,
-0.3586929440498352,
0.844810426235199,
0.1346159279346466,
-0.7413300275802612,
0.7078653573989868,
0.34360218048095703,
0.05091860517859459,
-0.5695110559463501,
-0.22019296884536743,
-0.45646932721138,
-0.09736128896474838,
0.04176213592290878,
-0.9382634162902832,
0.24194835126399994,
0.11426610499620438,
-0.20570974051952362,
0.09473858028650284,
0.48385342955589294,
-0.33720746636390686,
-0.5355474948883057,
-0.15419568121433258,
0.7881320714950562,
0.2979932427406311,
-0.46115660667419434,
-0.6380830407142639,
-0.17309127748012543,
-0.08908083289861679,
-0.09853620082139969,
0.2780754864215851,
0.5891953110694885,
-0.03924209624528885,
0.9091190099716187,
0.7071820497512817,
-0.22871138155460358,
0.032272931188344955,
0.04337368160486221,
0.877789318561554,
-0.8725296258926392,
-0.31383436918258667,
-0.5221990346908569,
0.29882076382637024,
0.14828571677207947,
-0.3858221769332886,
0.7078859806060791,
0.6388570070266724,
0.6487749218940735,
-0.01379831787198782,
0.7950842976570129,
0.1547035574913025,
0.7936745285987854,
-0.39029985666275024,
0.8028945326805115,
-0.2761377692222595,
0.03441011160612106,
-0.0030174991115927696,
-1.1116302013397217,
-0.17643968760967255,
0.29353460669517517,
-0.1408129185438156,
0.1161230057477951,
0.5428237318992615,
0.7247634530067444,
0.09454484283924103,
0.35809043049812317,
0.046017080545425415,
0.23867067694664001,
-0.022126445546746254,
0.6223690509796143,
0.9378083348274231,
-0.625436544418335,
0.6717371940612793,
0.01165816094726324,
0.10967564582824707,
-0.05085218697786331,
-0.3582375645637512,
-0.6838992238044739,
-0.5244745016098022,
-0.1988137662410736,
-0.3293359875679016,
0.26928260922431946,
0.7783216238021851,
0.17074473202228546,
-1.1973079442977905,
-0.2967188060283661,
0.10963448882102966,
0.33332428336143494,
-0.240544855594635,
-0.1475875824689865,
0.6900306344032288,
-0.07957108318805695,
-0.7885144948959351,
0.18989495933055878,
-0.07821743935346603,
-0.07932817190885544,
-0.05520480498671532,
-0.22744989395141602,
-0.5268470048904419,
0.3348132371902466,
0.38533976674079895,
0.6431532502174377,
-0.3210766017436981,
0.08237282186746597,
0.005500092636793852,
-0.07598735392093658,
0.1528720259666443,
0.400126188993454,
-0.9102460741996765,
0.16881819069385529,
0.4083809554576874,
1.1462963819503784,
0.4469292163848877,
0.23793260753154755,
0.3814307153224945,
-0.38819462060928345,
-0.04265163838863373,
0.4229084253311157,
0.10281333327293396,
0.3186304569244385,
0.13929250836372375,
0.569205641746521,
-0.39688974618911743,
-0.6494139432907104,
-0.5409542918205261,
0.24919646978378296,
-0.863018810749054,
-0.264717161655426,
0.9300845265388489,
-0.08690142631530762,
-0.06272067129611969,
-0.6437106728553772,
-0.48409759998321533,
0.1129918172955513,
-0.523737370967865,
1.013109564781189,
0.898518979549408,
0.22617840766906738,
-0.27527278661727905,
-0.6065061092376709,
0.39286428689956665,
0.7933577299118042,
-0.9649344682693481,
-0.26267993450164795,
0.5231690406799316,
-0.0672546923160553,
-0.2433251291513443,
0.6495004296302795,
0.10030979663133621,
0.4969464838504791,
-0.25022241473197937,
-0.10381221026182175,
0.18584688007831573,
-0.39163336157798767,
-0.2582528293132782,
0.5904235243797302,
0.3909529149532318,
-0.06409069895744324
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17846v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17846v2
|
Hierarchical Open-Vocabulary 3D Scene Graphs for Language-Grounded Robot Navigation
| 2024-03-26T16:36:43 | 2024-06-03T17:12:25 |
Abdelrhman Werby, Chenguang Huang, Martin Büchner, Abhinav Valada, Wolfram Burgard
|
cs.RO
|
cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
Recent open-vocabulary robot mapping methods enrich dense geometric maps with
pre-trained visual-language features. While these maps allow for the prediction
of point-wise saliency maps when queried for a certain language concept,
large-scale environments and abstract queries beyond the object level still
pose a considerable hurdle, ultimately limiting language-grounded robotic
navigation. In this work, we present HOV-SG, a hierarchical open-vocabulary 3D
scene graph mapping approach for language-grounded robot navigation. Leveraging
open-vocabulary vision foundation models, we first obtain state-of-the-art
open-vocabulary segment-level maps in 3D and subsequently construct a 3D scene
graph hierarchy consisting of floor, room, and object concepts, each enriched
with open-vocabulary features. Our approach is able to represent multi-story
buildings and allows robotic traversal of those using a cross-floor Voronoi
graph. HOV-SG is evaluated on three distinct datasets and surpasses previous
baselines in open-vocabulary semantic accuracy on the object, room, and floor
level while producing a 75% reduction in representation size compared to dense
open-vocabulary maps. In order to prove the efficacy and generalization
capabilities of HOV-SG, we showcase successful long-horizon
language-conditioned robot navigation within real-world multi-storage
environments. We provide code and trial video data at http://hovsg.github.io/.
|
[
-0.4969673454761505,
-0.9329337477684021,
0.5415772795677185,
0.00041379043250344694,
-0.0893954262137413,
0.171919047832489,
-0.04659649729728699,
-0.09102289378643036,
0.10268285870552063,
0.6082409024238586,
-0.24870182573795319,
-1.3105491399765015,
-0.2972809970378876,
-0.2677347958087921,
0.01937808096408844,
0.4642542898654938,
0.10747287422418594,
-0.23013849556446075,
-0.20728473365306854,
-0.20253077149391174,
-0.12380709499120712,
-0.6270978450775146,
-0.3341236710548401,
-0.07244615256786346,
0.4933590292930603,
0.2666100263595581,
1.2015948295593262,
0.799787163734436,
0.5150843262672424,
0.21647125482559204,
-0.19113758206367493,
0.12374638766050339,
-0.500770628452301,
-0.14558769762516022,
-0.15705135464668274,
0.18689027428627014,
-0.8096274733543396,
-0.5124870538711548,
0.7562958002090454,
1.0058376789093018,
-0.06815915554761887,
-0.17351055145263672,
0.05672328919172287,
0.9010682106018066,
-0.788769006729126,
0.500231146812439,
-0.12431487441062927,
0.34529587626457214,
0.043152425438165665,
-0.4228377044200897,
-0.23515644669532776,
0.03149037808179855,
0.3218074142932892,
-1.0354723930358887,
0.04001358896493912,
0.2793891131877899,
0.9514322876930237,
0.4204600155353546,
-0.3314811885356903,
0.13385143876075745,
-0.5567277669906616,
0.5848419666290283,
-0.3180749714374542,
0.6209766864776611,
0.399280309677124,
0.43849900364875793,
-0.3116813600063324,
-0.3235311210155487,
-0.22741977870464325,
-0.4654995799064636,
0.11008275300264359,
0.4995500147342682,
-0.1276574283838272,
0.37056905031204224,
0.10773403197526932,
0.2982415556907654,
-0.6727307438850403,
-0.044032562524080276,
-0.24742774665355682,
-0.04959049075841904,
0.07770166546106339,
-0.1618124395608902,
0.44557642936706543,
-0.2693626880645752,
-0.7865637540817261,
-0.36558598279953003,
-0.6449137926101685,
0.1946687251329422,
0.04103250801563263,
0.7030576467514038,
-0.08729749917984009,
0.7603300213813782,
-0.42469552159309387,
0.9699604511260986,
-0.41753846406936646,
-0.2311577945947647,
0.45311203598976135,
-0.4204718768596649,
-0.13344629108905792,
0.06843080371618271,
0.6163841485977173,
0.6573560237884521,
0.44049185514450073,
-0.3018152713775635,
-0.05815974250435829,
-0.06594493240118027,
0.2767080068588257,
-0.4783228933811188,
-0.38053733110427856,
0.23823902010917664,
-0.22848817706108093,
0.025586776435375214,
0.025643562898039818,
-0.8432475328445435,
-0.41633668541908264,
-0.01376731414347887,
0.22516217827796936,
-0.30282777547836304,
-0.2798546552658081,
0.6119229793548584,
-0.2600335478782654,
0.24109505116939545,
0.35497182607650757,
-0.3220135271549225,
0.16455550491809845,
0.291249543428421,
1.0121631622314453,
0.0628557801246643,
-0.36665090918540955,
-0.7992482781410217,
0.6343626379966736,
-0.49451541900634766,
0.38318875432014465,
-0.5259175896644592,
-0.45021960139274597,
0.2922981381416321,
-0.0031935139559209347,
0.07489383965730667,
-0.47675621509552,
0.22040283679962158,
-0.23734520375728607,
0.02901514247059822,
0.09011983871459961,
-0.019755737856030464,
-0.34182554483413696,
0.6879248023033142,
-0.5315841436386108,
1.0047179460525513,
0.43263953924179077,
-0.45227259397506714,
0.15473167598247528,
-0.6031395196914673,
-0.40931832790374756,
0.1143401637673378,
-0.022944556549191475,
-0.008970188908278942,
-0.42240411043167114,
0.4538058042526245,
0.46399468183517456,
0.06683633476495743,
0.01816565915942192,
-0.24039411544799805,
-0.25346505641937256,
-0.612380862236023,
0.23978015780448914,
0.34806010127067566,
-0.18491233885288239,
-0.170389324426651,
0.391999751329422,
-0.5531324744224548,
-0.22115406394004822,
0.06564000993967056,
-0.25453096628189087,
-0.6079944372177124,
0.262260764837265,
-0.3476579189300537,
0.4160015881061554,
0.3973587453365326,
-0.4765513241291046,
0.3555751144886017,
-0.566248893737793,
0.016573119908571243,
0.1607341468334198,
-0.15691882371902466,
0.849118709564209,
0.02993166074156761,
0.7429523468017578,
0.15284959971904755,
0.014333980157971382,
-0.5090550780296326,
-0.6974754333496094,
-0.713955819606781,
-0.357355535030365,
-0.21873147785663605,
0.6647018790245056,
-1.024483323097229,
0.8297185301780701,
-0.5507275462150574,
-0.37255996465682983,
-0.21140578389167786,
-0.2226366549730301,
0.4137316644191742,
0.7575969696044922,
0.7764491438865662,
-0.1314401477575302,
-0.24759358167648315,
-0.6517067551612854,
0.1699547916650772,
-0.2063285857439041,
-0.2263607382774353,
0.6298637986183167,
0.3704119920730591,
-0.3589627742767334,
0.7217790484428406,
-0.578109085559845,
-0.8225325345993042,
-0.18905971944332123,
-0.22241047024726868,
-0.07479394972324371,
0.3010108470916748,
0.6494545936584473,
-0.5093339085578918,
0.06138200685381889,
0.48939165472984314,
-0.7178619503974915,
0.14625637233257294,
-0.04860653355717659,
-0.4065273106098175,
0.03777133300900459,
0.8088608384132385,
-0.4642809331417084,
0.7919114232063293,
0.5613499879837036,
-0.19921287894248962,
0.05002546310424805,
-0.24995003640651703,
0.06119491159915924,
-0.9364275932312012,
-0.1250474900007248,
0.23328636586666107,
-0.19320063292980194,
-0.4500342905521393,
0.4138992428779602,
-0.25277775526046753,
-0.24049240350723267,
-0.5951388478279114,
0.6339702010154724,
-0.3466056287288666,
-0.4655427634716034,
0.09034005552530289,
0.8717541694641113,
-0.004301749635487795,
0.9853736758232117,
0.31018927693367004,
0.4144893288612366,
0.8979448080062866,
-0.8040586113929749,
0.09240445494651794,
0.25914883613586426,
-0.24342505633831024,
0.05667966976761818,
-0.5863690376281738,
0.0044255442917346954,
-0.07499535381793976,
0.4861343502998352,
-0.9705399870872498,
-0.23131132125854492,
0.45814603567123413,
-0.277551531791687,
-0.25959286093711853,
-0.3584648072719574,
-0.6102495193481445,
-0.35791128873825073,
-0.06506688892841339,
0.2175007462501526,
0.40596649050712585,
-0.6252861618995667,
0.7984076738357544,
0.46270817518234253,
0.22018107771873474,
-0.5814424157142639,
-0.3672390580177307,
-0.03097478114068508,
0.16374698281288147,
-0.6281740069389343,
0.37238427996635437,
0.2876502275466919,
-0.12905170023441315,
-0.017347408458590508,
-0.28460612893104553,
0.032873429358005524,
0.003247929271310568,
0.3377346992492676,
0.2854717969894409,
-0.2536957263946533,
-0.21724392473697662,
-0.05597767233848572,
-0.0469677671790123,
0.0255286805331707,
-0.4988432228565216,
0.7778847217559814,
-0.6849425435066223,
-0.41249656677246094,
0.03443846106529236,
0.0195433609187603,
0.623255729675293,
-0.18940654397010803,
0.6552109122276306,
0.41425833106040955,
-0.5318067669868469,
0.0010772717650979757,
0.2567678987979889,
0.26656022667884827,
-0.46568548679351807,
0.5381003618240356,
-0.4861382246017456,
-0.9789237380027771,
0.4677410125732422,
-0.46244168281555176,
0.254562646150589,
0.414654016494751,
0.25406917929649353,
-0.12115495651960373,
0.9136906862258911,
0.3650266230106354,
0.09926192462444305,
0.25603148341178894,
-0.5042827129364014,
0.40962764620780945,
-0.8303412199020386,
-0.5491666793823242,
-0.48607590794563293,
-0.3080004155635834,
-0.30109870433807373,
-0.97041916847229,
0.6660616397857666,
0.26319587230682373,
-0.4083462357521057,
0.2973879277706146,
-0.4423946738243103,
0.44451096653938293,
0.25278374552726746,
0.029371168464422226,
0.22482243180274963,
0.07329266518354416,
-0.5239264965057373,
0.28452441096305847,
-0.9207987189292908,
-0.3430948257446289,
0.48419198393821716,
0.23693935573101044,
0.3658309578895569,
-0.1003468856215477,
0.5038150548934937,
0.08264607936143875,
-0.2704547345638275,
-0.9919871687889099,
0.8653991222381592,
-0.21188002824783325,
-0.1539156436920166,
-0.6194165945053101,
-0.29859378933906555,
-1.1100068092346191,
0.6334917545318604,
0.06480376422405243,
-0.41174378991127014,
0.1478702276945114,
0.08926097303628922,
-0.28136420249938965,
0.5424545407295227,
-0.4912737309932709,
0.8983164429664612,
-0.1388453096151352,
-0.15765196084976196,
0.004559978377074003,
-0.9766230583190918,
0.1447058767080307,
0.10787847638130188,
0.4944388270378113,
-0.10781306773424149,
-0.058351848274469376,
0.262256383895874,
-0.3299802541732788,
0.7232307195663452,
-0.45987051725387573,
-0.29844725131988525,
0.2205999493598938,
0.24745507538318634,
0.23494264483451843,
-0.16424107551574707,
0.2257307767868042,
0.5698802471160889,
-0.38284724950790405,
-0.38350433111190796,
-0.4889289140701294,
0.4500061273574829,
-0.7155249714851379,
-0.39065590500831604,
-0.42480385303497314,
-0.47613778710365295,
-0.3365492820739746,
0.3229807913303375,
-0.037013813853263855,
0.3084743320941925,
-0.4377230107784271,
0.5142772793769836,
0.5176196098327637,
-0.6185083985328674,
0.10126661509275436,
0.0848643109202385,
-0.6653332114219666,
-0.0750783383846283,
0.956690788269043,
-0.17004723846912384,
0.2483418583869934,
0.7102082371711731,
0.314418762922287,
-0.24640393257141113,
-0.353862464427948,
-0.6756683588027954,
-0.33886101841926575,
-0.496042400598526,
-0.08654624968767166,
-0.5530425310134888,
-0.4138754904270172,
-0.1789584457874298,
-0.6586052179336548,
-0.4763427972793579,
-0.354231595993042,
-0.1087101474404335,
-0.001445088884793222,
0.14120876789093018,
0.4129619598388672,
0.11425409466028214,
0.31260889768600464,
-0.8044270873069763,
0.9479940533638,
0.0660790503025055,
0.17304112017154694,
-0.15397322177886963,
-0.3264143764972687,
-0.2750120460987091,
0.24254493415355682,
0.12014646083116531,
-0.35802212357521057,
0.34726837277412415,
0.1269526481628418,
0.3620378077030182,
0.38326510787010193,
0.047521837055683136,
0.8511350750923157,
-0.6226038932800293,
0.8406970500946045,
0.18438373506069183,
-0.670181393623352,
0.8886269927024841,
-0.9784138798713684,
0.717856228351593,
0.23327915370464325,
0.23819446563720703,
-0.2355765998363495,
-0.4037019610404968,
-0.3261096179485321,
-1.251133680343628,
0.4583283066749573,
0.10698400437831879,
-0.1715240329504013,
-0.055386338382959366,
0.3063124120235443,
-0.16460013389587402,
0.21879751980304718,
-0.5200528502464294,
-0.1706107258796692,
-0.7386375665664673,
0.11470678448677063,
0.005343197379261255,
0.36625680327415466,
-0.22056901454925537,
-0.3618873059749603,
0.3375698924064636,
-0.35950613021850586,
0.06492901593446732,
0.06173517927527428,
-0.1382412165403366,
0.05432703718543053,
0.0034808742348104715,
0.40319955348968506,
0.46241065859794617,
-0.470874160528183,
0.05136631429195404,
-0.1798272728919983,
-0.4223898649215698,
-0.14224779605865479,
-0.05480111762881279,
-0.15987305343151093,
-0.07149539142847061,
0.20325085520744324,
0.733927309513092,
0.3502987325191498,
-0.5954766869544983,
0.6064181327819824,
0.40790238976478577,
-0.4057442247867584,
-0.18732516467571259,
0.11808225512504578,
-0.06142186000943184,
-0.012496658600866795,
0.04622771218419075,
0.2567351758480072,
0.09017698466777802,
-0.5051094889640808,
0.06755585968494415,
0.27272260189056396,
-0.40701866149902344,
-0.07406583428382874,
0.5510166883468628,
0.2333279848098755,
-0.2583029270172119,
0.6748539209365845,
-0.04092101752758026,
-0.4275079369544983,
0.5922209024429321,
0.2505115568637848,
0.8325824737548828,
-0.09169036149978638,
0.2943859100341797,
0.5865098834037781,
0.4232581555843353,
-0.19482097029685974,
0.250073105096817,
-0.23808880150318146,
-0.798353910446167,
-0.1956912726163864,
-0.6363353729248047,
-0.5203818082809448,
-0.20935098826885223,
-0.7583595514297485,
0.05424576625227928,
-0.706720769405365,
0.00015256607730407268,
-0.6403654217720032,
-0.5405738949775696,
-0.6255609393119812,
0.3668522536754608,
0.18074347078800201,
0.6582200527191162,
-0.2720722258090973,
0.839679479598999,
0.9389768242835999,
-0.16981852054595947,
-0.2549852132797241,
0.27368971705436707,
-0.1869862675666809,
-0.9926159381866455,
0.5134121179580688,
0.14447002112865448,
-0.997683048248291,
0.05690658092498779,
-0.4504995048046112,
-0.9357883334159851,
1.0222941637039185,
0.04109044000506401,
-0.639808177947998,
-0.25716644525527954,
0.13981010019779205,
0.6447567343711853,
-0.45911186933517456,
-0.3245605230331421,
0.31891900300979614,
0.4987267255783081,
0.2859511375427246,
-0.534802258014679,
-0.29747503995895386,
-0.2701012194156647,
0.15805239975452423,
0.20286589860916138,
-0.5900920033454895,
0.32981976866722107,
-0.26216891407966614,
-0.11628534644842148,
0.035017576068639755,
0.7924225926399231,
0.5462992191314697,
0.16524723172187805,
0.8541048169136047,
0.7451731562614441,
0.656261682510376,
-0.3428974151611328,
0.9504228830337524,
-0.5074281692504883,
0.01617668755352497,
1.0759952068328857,
-0.44362375140190125,
0.9863041043281555,
0.22210197150707245,
0.46121564507484436,
0.6989840269088745,
0.427021861076355,
0.1770068258047104,
0.8547831177711487,
0.4317892789840698,
0.09448405355215073,
-0.36316734552383423,
-0.3397849500179291,
-0.38174429535865784,
0.35035258531570435,
0.7019938826560974,
0.1706094890832901,
-0.29640495777130127,
0.14630120992660522,
-0.18558883666992188,
0.00075168238254264,
-0.4236431121826172,
0.4724631607532501,
-0.1103358194231987,
-0.36242973804473877,
0.602834165096283,
-0.05864661931991577,
0.17920923233032227,
-0.6681910753250122,
-0.1970423012971878,
-0.020460935309529305,
0.0186931099742651,
-0.01417491678148508,
-0.906378448009491,
0.039335038512945175,
-0.22931526601314545,
0.17587627470493317,
-0.5414752960205078,
0.6980592012405396,
-0.5546841621398926,
-0.034658897668123245,
0.5168272256851196,
0.7620181441307068,
0.14151911437511444,
-0.16901081800460815,
-0.29421454668045044,
-0.13234958052635193,
-0.2722735106945038,
-0.15213771164417267,
0.26151344180107117,
0.5893675088882446,
-0.07655975222587585,
0.7809458374977112,
0.5430282354354858,
-0.19931147992610931,
0.034681107848882675,
0.3727557957172394,
0.8504630923271179,
-0.682511568069458,
-0.7006412148475647,
-0.3895098865032196,
0.6797617673873901,
0.15862493216991425,
-0.47154396772384644,
0.8083869814872742,
0.7213331460952759,
1.0418157577514648,
-0.04739854112267494,
0.5352635979652405,
0.30430087447166443,
0.06317492574453354,
-0.6888672709465027,
0.5340458750724792,
-0.8850182294845581,
0.020885663107037544,
-0.505064070224762,
-1.0292651653289795,
-0.5466107130050659,
0.9984495043754578,
0.07284446805715561,
0.08621697127819061,
0.7576189041137695,
0.6286416053771973,
0.09354715049266815,
-0.4169810712337494,
0.5394788980484009,
0.2627181112766266,
0.13786466419696808,
0.4967147707939148,
0.867790699005127,
-0.30281737446784973,
0.5480720400810242,
-0.14665502309799194,
-0.17727287113666534,
-0.1124616265296936,
-0.6182109713554382,
-1.0719658136367798,
-0.5120288729667664,
-0.46060654520988464,
-0.3678171932697296,
0.10941961407661438,
0.42424920201301575,
0.6278331279754639,
-0.30086514353752136,
-0.20646348595619202,
-0.31204771995544434,
0.03258747234940529,
-0.2337108701467514,
-0.1697024554014206,
0.39333122968673706,
-0.011917650699615479,
-0.6805998086929321,
1.01136314868927,
0.896649956703186,
-0.006394288968294859,
-0.49969378113746643,
-0.21897374093532562,
-0.10644979029893875,
-0.19638590514659882,
0.7789210677146912,
0.32310596108436584,
-0.8625449538230896,
-0.40041622519493103,
0.30060097575187683,
-0.10126303136348724,
0.40260177850723267,
0.5521339178085327,
-1.1057937145233154,
0.748260498046875,
0.5334499478340149,
0.49624544382095337,
0.3549656569957733,
0.15913505852222443,
0.5453175902366638,
-0.9521602988243103,
0.37658053636550903,
0.25714319944381714,
0.5112575888633728,
0.29494723677635193,
-0.16959016025066376,
0.751589834690094,
0.13096892833709717,
-0.24683749675750732,
-0.4312596619129181,
0.17138636112213135,
-1.4093401432037354,
-0.22287176549434662,
1.3844677209854126,
-0.07298506051301956,
-0.30652090907096863,
-0.22460348904132843,
-0.32538795471191406,
0.1492694467306137,
-0.4605453610420227,
0.4840048849582672,
0.678886353969574,
0.19126757979393005,
-0.036254700273275375,
-0.7239353656768799,
0.28822460770606995,
0.019445782527327538,
-0.8074120283126831,
-0.03125593811273575,
0.7697805166244507,
-0.518158495426178,
0.4254133403301239,
0.4834701418876648,
-0.19272074103355408,
0.213384747505188,
-0.0444757342338562,
0.14893688261508942,
-0.03393452614545822,
-0.961850643157959,
-0.041357431560754776,
0.418331116437912,
-0.47840169072151184,
-0.5189045667648315
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14415v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14415v1
|
Domain Adaptation in Intent Classification Systems: A Review
| 2024-03-26T15:59:05 | 2024-03-26T15:59:05 |
Jesse Atuhurra, Hidetaka Kamigaito, Taro Watanabe, Eric Nichols
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Dialogue agents, which perform specific tasks, are part of the long-term goal
of NLP researchers to build intelligent agents that communicate with humans in
natural language. Such systems should adapt easily from one domain to another
to assist users in completing tasks. Researchers have developed a broad range
of techniques, objectives, and datasets for intent classification to achieve
such systems. Despite the progress in developing intent classification systems
(ICS), a systematic review of the progress from a technical perspective is yet
to be conducted. In effect, important implementation details of intent
classification remain restricted and unclear, making it hard for natural
language processing (NLP) researchers to develop new methods. To fill this gap,
we review contemporary works in intent classification. Specifically, we conduct
a thorough technical review of the datasets, domains, tasks, and methods needed
to train the intent classification part of dialogue systems. Our structured
analysis describes why intent classification is difficult and studies the
limitations to domain adaptation while presenting opportunities for future
work.
|
[
-0.17197196185588837,
-0.40676912665367126,
0.5386934280395508,
0.21625398099422455,
0.18879640102386475,
0.02153027057647705,
-0.3434372544288635,
-0.6171398162841797,
-0.07800538837909698,
0.7915993928909302,
-0.6079519987106323,
-0.36603426933288574,
-0.6127620935440063,
0.1567000150680542,
-0.042194664478302,
1.1177926063537598,
-0.1552933007478714,
-0.16373343765735626,
-0.16071508824825287,
-0.2345891147851944,
-0.8232072591781616,
-0.5323452949523926,
-0.9267955422401428,
-0.1090133786201477,
0.15501195192337036,
0.3633674383163452,
0.3288014531135559,
-0.184080570936203,
0.7246570587158203,
0.3755558133125305,
0.17208540439605713,
0.2389509379863739,
-0.45988917350769043,
0.399865061044693,
-0.3124973475933075,
-0.4418729543685913,
-0.4732985198497772,
0.013792484998703003,
0.41607990860939026,
0.7995787858963013,
0.05862479284405708,
-0.16995373368263245,
0.19225749373435974,
0.616992175579071,
-0.4553844928741455,
0.32718709111213684,
-0.5792544484138489,
0.12465480715036392,
0.027594171464443207,
-0.48119983077049255,
-0.9094229340553284,
-0.1759742945432663,
0.647102415561676,
-0.7645521759986877,
0.15106569230556488,
0.26167920231819153,
0.13091376423835754,
0.2398529201745987,
-0.5137098431587219,
-0.6713387966156006,
-1.1207000017166138,
0.9006416201591492,
-0.6325086355209351,
0.15686333179473877,
0.17511606216430664,
0.22178219258785248,
-0.5848841667175293,
-0.7864013910293579,
-0.272433340549469,
-0.16112905740737915,
-0.06981232017278671,
-0.23321479558944702,
-0.05434786528348923,
0.36386528611183167,
0.23164819180965424,
0.06953106820583344,
-0.35041162371635437,
-0.1884893774986267,
-0.2900586724281311,
-0.12377811968326569,
0.7801650166511536,
0.26681578159332275,
0.301128625869751,
0.1231982484459877,
-0.40113168954849243,
0.09583385288715363,
-0.32474201917648315,
0.37109658122062683,
-0.007735133171081543,
0.46973249316215515,
0.19633477926254272,
0.33346182107925415,
-0.3626372814178467,
0.658900260925293,
0.18299849331378937,
-0.27750977873802185,
0.006042125169187784,
-0.18449853360652924,
-0.3009340763092041,
0.34453195333480835,
0.5886530876159668,
0.22274859249591827,
0.21141493320465088,
-0.09635167568922043,
-0.08126834779977798,
-0.3440592885017395,
0.7536967992782593,
-0.5239140391349792,
0.15551309287548065,
0.21322306990623474,
-0.34712880849838257,
0.07185990363359451,
-0.16589966416358948,
-0.04964733496308327,
-0.3713515102863312,
-0.34580397605895996,
0.29482054710388184,
-0.40744510293006897,
-0.09178297966718674,
0.48404383659362793,
-0.06803055852651596,
0.27312135696411133,
0.9035736322402954,
-0.9975841641426086,
0.8165106773376465,
0.8717738389968872,
0.5918928384780884,
-0.5135188698768616,
-0.4001769721508026,
-0.03030778281390667,
-0.05016523599624634,
-0.14319677650928497,
0.8759052753448486,
-0.5758990049362183,
-0.36072951555252075,
0.22979150712490082,
0.21135836839675903,
-0.6556552648544312,
-0.19812369346618652,
0.8560777902603149,
-0.7735735774040222,
0.3930020034313202,
0.027750426903367043,
-0.5286480188369751,
-0.4989754557609558,
0.15283405780792236,
-0.3479122817516327,
0.5490157604217529,
0.33159753680229187,
-0.6019730567932129,
0.3024696111679077,
-0.9999783039093018,
-0.4607948958873749,
0.19672343134880066,
0.11352965980768204,
0.001268956926651299,
0.11007189005613327,
-0.31079724431037903,
0.4613337218761444,
-0.17589716613292694,
0.27444183826446533,
-0.039050064980983734,
-0.17261236906051636,
0.5125128030776978,
-0.23918694257736206,
0.8170092105865479,
0.12692411243915558,
-0.3548443019390106,
0.14976821839809418,
-0.40618783235549927,
0.0014235085109248757,
-0.29682204127311707,
-0.14936263859272003,
-0.44344377517700195,
0.4018867015838623,
-0.3437267243862152,
0.14860568940639496,
0.07697177678346634,
-0.3081057667732239,
0.4795956313610077,
-0.1838100105524063,
0.17998838424682617,
0.6958551406860352,
-0.03185102343559265,
0.8804395794868469,
-0.3097168207168579,
0.5072886943817139,
-0.1568346619606018,
0.4501883387565613,
0.1673285812139511,
-0.7961918115615845,
-0.7783973813056946,
0.08846061676740646,
0.32073962688446045,
0.6648058891296387,
-0.7469303011894226,
0.47991251945495605,
-0.4330737590789795,
-0.2479267716407776,
-0.28091225028038025,
-0.026404868811368942,
0.17194205522537231,
0.16668975353240967,
0.12255941331386566,
-0.9257504343986511,
-0.2514466941356659,
-0.5317330360412598,
-0.10657192766666412,
-0.3850710391998291,
0.04934035986661911,
0.5092257261276245,
0.3784734010696411,
-0.13444864749908447,
1.0087376832962036,
-0.5123779773712158,
-0.4880159795284271,
-0.36150839924812317,
0.09433919191360474,
0.055931299924850464,
0.3849373459815979,
0.519792377948761,
-0.8740837574005127,
-0.5678370594978333,
0.08352281153202057,
-0.5588188171386719,
0.12333928048610687,
-0.31219691038131714,
0.006670946255326271,
0.00418114336207509,
0.5047430396080017,
-0.7212084531784058,
0.5336087346076965,
0.23129813373088837,
-0.44251111149787903,
0.41308149695396423,
0.09685712307691574,
0.21888937056064606,
-0.5177164077758789,
-0.1996285319328308,
-0.0746462419629097,
-0.2487565279006958,
-1.2433193922042847,
-0.41895797848701477,
-0.26627209782600403,
0.09579139947891235,
-0.4385323226451874,
0.5389114618301392,
-0.32283884286880493,
-0.02319876104593277,
-0.5269362926483154,
-0.09999355673789978,
-0.11170074343681335,
0.5981851816177368,
0.30037379264831543,
0.4547538161277771,
0.5748050212860107,
-1.0650724172592163,
0.30515700578689575,
0.5257633328437805,
-0.22608032822608948,
0.5789992809295654,
-0.25070565938949585,
0.259933203458786,
0.13143791258335114,
0.4105897843837738,
-0.622650146484375,
-0.2702784836292267,
0.7752509117126465,
-0.47454923391342163,
0.4527597725391388,
-0.13982021808624268,
0.17003405094146729,
-0.04292938858270645,
-0.21024277806282043,
0.4605933427810669,
0.3486716151237488,
-0.23944132030010223,
0.7402276992797852,
0.35309094190597534,
-0.5628395676612854,
-0.5532850027084351,
-0.24711890518665314,
0.020972788333892822,
-0.16722606122493744,
-0.5699832439422607,
0.31379270553588867,
-0.15974238514900208,
-0.3551863431930542,
0.11810386180877686,
-0.009444287046790123,
-0.2493685483932495,
0.2039112001657486,
0.246192067861557,
-0.029644329100847244,
-0.2528356611728668,
0.18000446259975433,
-0.011537588201463223,
0.03977547958493233,
0.244175985455513,
-0.2858811616897583,
0.23540346324443817,
0.1726762354373932,
-0.3096020817756653,
-0.6700004935264587,
0.25518345832824707,
0.5251708030700684,
0.19704397022724152,
0.5647895336151123,
0.2708679735660553,
-0.08344598859548569,
-0.598638117313385,
-0.20038025081157684,
-0.021374749019742012,
-0.4576406180858612,
0.2591616213321686,
-0.3699074983596802,
-0.8724167943000793,
0.18837127089500427,
-0.5164779424667358,
0.25775253772735596,
0.5023185610771179,
0.2118392139673233,
0.06012808904051781,
0.8921105861663818,
1.016137957572937,
0.2588788866996765,
0.49823030829429626,
-0.1087145060300827,
0.43538618087768555,
-1.025283932685852,
-0.16785207390785217,
-0.6686280369758606,
-0.29828211665153503,
-0.5956113934516907,
-0.30952510237693787,
-0.01085486076772213,
-0.33077844977378845,
0.30669355392456055,
0.34325161576271057,
-0.6497064232826233,
0.05571671202778816,
0.4006510376930237,
-0.0981205478310585,
0.21818658709526062,
-0.02468251995742321,
0.5456216335296631,
0.11462343484163284,
-0.5783960223197937,
-0.6139289736747742,
1.15751314163208,
0.295812726020813,
0.6717292666435242,
0.18595410883426666,
0.39554545283317566,
0.6034854054450989,
0.29176807403564453,
-1.0735679864883423,
0.6471717357635498,
-0.13195635378360748,
-0.620551347732544,
-0.6047287583351135,
-0.12489143759012222,
-1.0982730388641357,
-0.004676733165979385,
0.07067679613828659,
-0.7231125235557556,
0.46820807456970215,
-0.2468963861465454,
-0.3125009834766388,
0.07164987176656723,
-0.8268235325813293,
0.7890088558197021,
-0.22316744923591614,
0.010945151560008526,
-0.06913270056247711,
-0.6691722869873047,
0.1680828183889389,
-0.15491507947444916,
0.1437235176563263,
-0.33943822979927063,
0.06064080446958542,
1.0600864887237549,
-0.1514677107334137,
1.0032213926315308,
-0.39319685101509094,
-0.22202931344509125,
0.5508288741111755,
-0.06626910716295242,
0.35658061504364014,
-0.0614275224506855,
-0.11569803208112717,
-0.061743199825286865,
-0.18710337579250336,
-0.2877095341682434,
-0.7263623476028442,
0.4349549412727356,
-0.5941998362541199,
-0.8336583971977234,
-0.7231629490852356,
-0.5499395132064819,
-0.4308319687843323,
0.13581646978855133,
-0.07673168927431107,
0.3642197847366333,
-0.5392137169837952,
0.10006124526262283,
0.8043189644813538,
0.14956307411193848,
0.290630578994751,
0.4627699553966522,
0.035631388425827026,
0.17398610711097717,
0.6958268284797668,
-0.2014644891023636,
0.32033368945121765,
0.3825313448905945,
-0.18256376683712006,
-0.07953016459941864,
-1.2026821374893188,
-0.1718389391899109,
-0.05780700966715813,
-0.7310426831245422,
-0.005657855421304703,
-0.48935019969940186,
-0.3907066881656647,
-0.6678290963172913,
-0.24254009127616882,
-0.07724978029727936,
-0.6035988330841064,
-0.5068749785423279,
0.3935932219028473,
0.29793787002563477,
1.0699020624160767,
0.3248673677444458,
0.46599751710891724,
-0.633135974407196,
0.22511452436447144,
0.4587334394454956,
0.34482187032699585,
-0.3992472290992737,
-0.8132764101028442,
-0.245878666639328,
-0.0714348554611206,
-0.4237763583660126,
-0.4635774791240692,
0.20281492173671722,
0.5789318084716797,
0.5865458250045776,
0.24650335311889648,
0.34638911485671997,
0.23861543834209442,
-0.49881646037101746,
0.8261916041374207,
0.05450650677084923,
-0.7268801331520081,
0.5289466381072998,
0.008537882007658482,
0.045160479843616486,
0.6946139931678772,
0.610813319683075,
-0.7306985855102539,
-0.07621175795793533,
-0.45605507493019104,
-0.556925356388092,
1.35581374168396,
0.18711672723293304,
0.3032965660095215,
0.3686372637748718,
0.5008653998374939,
0.41360291838645935,
0.012526781298220158,
-0.5032151341438293,
-0.13144198060035706,
0.010057362727820873,
-0.31169843673706055,
-0.03763164207339287,
-0.02571714296936989,
-0.21531473100185394,
-0.07663308829069138,
0.7195844650268555,
-0.40920186042785645,
0.5425786972045898,
0.3722589612007141,
-0.3228224515914917,
0.020894411951303482,
0.45694777369499207,
0.5766285061836243,
0.4968627393245697,
-0.20378266274929047,
-0.25162747502326965,
0.05581577494740486,
-0.7111044526100159,
0.220382422208786,
-0.011773222126066685,
-0.29164090752601624,
0.07611601054668427,
0.1737091988325119,
1.06864595413208,
0.14946261048316956,
-0.4620426297187805,
0.6659591197967529,
-0.6494156718254089,
-0.4394385814666748,
-0.369365394115448,
0.5772944092750549,
-0.4143756926059723,
0.2684088349342346,
0.38890141248703003,
0.41556400060653687,
0.4320400059223175,
-0.6960616111755371,
-0.1728295534849167,
0.30973008275032043,
-0.6069997549057007,
-0.5308657884597778,
0.008380623534321785,
0.5237722992897034,
-0.7298719882965088,
0.3263254761695862,
-0.5493665933609009,
-0.5109617114067078,
0.31343233585357666,
0.48524218797683716,
1.262906789779663,
-0.4579715430736542,
0.3483061194419861,
0.05267060920596123,
0.13006889820098877,
-0.15371458232402802,
0.08676165342330933,
-0.18443110585212708,
-0.8391156792640686,
-0.4195232391357422,
-0.40590307116508484,
-0.8358927965164185,
-0.11990158259868622,
-0.3757474720478058,
0.130691260099411,
-0.38372188806533813,
-0.31079724431037903,
0.1501735895872116,
-0.018228625878691673,
-0.5355651378631592,
0.20598740875720978,
-0.006925889290869236,
0.8270235657691956,
-0.631935715675354,
0.6123557686805725,
0.8493878841400146,
0.35973069071769714,
-0.3013975918292999,
0.03204872086644173,
-0.14940057694911957,
-0.4383237361907959,
0.5514922142028809,
0.014551911503076553,
-0.2685444951057434,
-0.06442327052354813,
-0.6398810148239136,
-0.8098784685134888,
0.870704174041748,
-0.2296929806470871,
-0.09105424582958221,
-0.28288644552230835,
0.15701192617416382,
0.6880981922149658,
-0.7934292554855347,
-0.015127758495509624,
0.5191015005111694,
0.4069768488407135,
-0.05799124017357826,
-1.0247670412063599,
0.02329941652715206,
-0.16465146839618683,
-0.23873017728328705,
0.1083693876862526,
-0.4030647575855255,
0.32434722781181335,
-0.005541608668863773,
-0.316650390625,
0.05412483960390091,
0.5114774107933044,
-0.2105906456708908,
0.7052168846130371,
0.6109084486961365,
-0.01820669323205948,
0.5615599751472473,
-0.21616004407405853,
0.6911932229995728,
-0.0371210016310215,
0.20285314321517944,
0.9733707308769226,
-0.6609904766082764,
0.5573765635490417,
0.2630496621131897,
-0.29378896951675415,
0.7950870990753174,
0.41255220770835876,
0.2521917223930359,
0.5324220061302185,
0.01488141342997551,
-0.4949142634868622,
-0.06656414270401001,
-0.3580397367477417,
0.011862196959555149,
0.6132696270942688,
0.9197778105735779,
-0.11270463466644287,
0.30893993377685547,
0.009277604520320892,
-0.4653250575065613,
-0.2903752326965332,
-0.25292935967445374,
1.1797953844070435,
0.051108501851558685,
-0.9459859728813171,
0.19854408502578735,
-0.19818156957626343,
0.5075318813323975,
-0.6919663548469543,
0.028404271230101585,
0.36882907152175903,
0.18060709536075592,
-0.24347513914108276,
-0.7162037491798401,
0.10745133459568024,
-0.1940896064043045,
-0.04618687182664871,
-0.36791402101516724,
1.0795291662216187,
-0.08754599839448929,
0.18658176064491272,
0.18641790747642517,
0.27586832642555237,
0.20735293626785278,
0.08233106881380081,
-0.8625399470329285,
-0.07281351089477539,
0.14057712256908417,
-0.37020519375801086,
0.2520390450954437,
0.580378532409668,
-0.15275432169437408,
0.747565746307373,
0.5047827363014221,
-0.015958746895194054,
0.1556938886642456,
-0.12028561532497406,
0.6959874033927917,
-0.79726642370224,
-0.249978706240654,
-0.23460820317268372,
0.39316412806510925,
-0.08034858852624893,
-0.39063501358032227,
0.6226853132247925,
0.2442011833190918,
0.8776369690895081,
-0.07331017404794693,
1.008072853088379,
-0.23939812183380127,
0.42629697918891907,
-0.4537166357040405,
0.04653405398130417,
-0.21698538959026337,
0.169260635972023,
0.0063299196772277355,
-0.8550227284431458,
-0.2641279697418213,
0.2685377299785614,
-0.4345123767852783,
0.1037495881319046,
1.0511723756790161,
0.2802834212779999,
-0.04485548660159111,
0.30402234196662903,
0.14944109320640564,
0.00922601018100977,
0.21684406697750092,
0.5858469605445862,
1.0194363594055176,
-0.42700132727622986,
0.4620473384857178,
-0.27398553490638733,
-0.23470433056354523,
-0.6620380878448486,
-0.46275749802589417,
-0.6667186617851257,
-0.6478421092033386,
-0.46460047364234924,
0.04847806319594383,
0.05548689886927605,
0.7179847955703735,
0.6734846830368042,
-0.9651861786842346,
-0.277601420879364,
0.02846555970609188,
0.27352359890937805,
-0.1978713870048523,
-0.2235611081123352,
0.26428186893463135,
-0.7424797415733337,
-0.7745823860168457,
0.4066223204135895,
0.5984353423118591,
-0.02249024622142315,
0.05268409848213196,
-0.2983723282814026,
-0.12145604938268661,
0.10213914513587952,
0.7177058458328247,
0.6271364688873291,
-0.5490645170211792,
-0.47497493028640747,
0.1858365386724472,
-0.1732935756444931,
0.17713478207588196,
1.2591750621795654,
-0.40884387493133545,
0.429056316614151,
0.40439409017562866,
0.6610604524612427,
0.0690576359629631,
-0.1616840660572052,
0.395764023065567,
-0.4482148587703705,
-0.17788146436214447,
0.5785168409347534,
0.11394510418176651,
0.2721281051635742,
-0.3803366422653198,
0.5073936581611633,
-0.020713310688734055,
-1.0157480239868164,
-0.6448627710342407,
0.28131845593452454,
-1.3631401062011719,
-0.3763929605484009,
1.2299705743789673,
-0.15754786133766174,
-0.40864431858062744,
-1.0480215549468994,
-0.586787223815918,
0.065680593252182,
-0.44653233885765076,
0.7164434790611267,
0.608428955078125,
-0.6355997323989868,
0.38402408361434937,
-0.5067580342292786,
0.9762406945228577,
0.2321556806564331,
-0.8922420144081116,
0.23574545979499817,
0.22544430196285248,
-0.0010389889357611537,
0.49148255586624146,
0.9963386654853821,
0.1926714926958084,
0.4076860547065735,
-0.32653069496154785,
0.18642288446426392,
0.6092990636825562,
-0.4320034682750702,
-0.3854420483112335,
0.1858062744140625,
0.5124600529670715,
0.059035900980234146
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17816v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17816v1
|
Graph Language Model (GLM): A new graph-based approach to detect social instabilities
| 2024-03-26T15:53:02 | 2024-03-26T15:53:02 |
Wallyson Lemes de Oliveira, Vahid Shamsaddini, Ali Ghofrani, Rahul Singh Inda, Jithendra Sai Veeramaneni, Étienne Voutaz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This scientific report presents a novel methodology for the early prediction
of important political events using News datasets. The methodology leverages
natural language processing, graph theory, clique analysis, and semantic
relationships to uncover hidden predictive signals within the data. Initially,
we designed a preliminary version of the method and tested it on a few events.
This analysis revealed limitations in the initial research phase. We then
enhanced the model in two key ways: first, we added a filtration step to only
consider politically relevant news before further processing; second, we
adjusted the input features to make the alert system more sensitive to
significant spikes in the data. After finalizing the improved methodology, we
tested it on eleven events including US protests, the Ukraine war, and French
protests. Results demonstrate the superiority of our approach compared to
baseline methods. Through targeted refinements, our model can now provide
earlier and more accurate predictions of major political events based on subtle
patterns in news data.
|
[
-0.2572762966156006,
-1.2886241674423218,
0.45642074942588806,
-0.1093023344874382,
-0.4651356637477875,
0.5287905931472778,
0.09040194004774094,
-0.5803132653236389,
0.2692040503025055,
0.3910083472728729,
-0.3954886496067047,
-0.6781832575798035,
-0.8392696380615234,
-0.3768089711666107,
-0.8478368520736694,
0.9186106324195862,
0.2193528413772583,
-0.014522308483719826,
0.15166358649730682,
-0.0018201107159256935,
-0.08246853947639465,
-0.7666739821434021,
-0.8384824991226196,
-0.6407191157341003,
0.5014593601226807,
0.06380151957273483,
1.0623594522476196,
0.4670105278491974,
0.5592948794364929,
0.19100737571716309,
-0.2902326285839081,
0.13267727196216583,
-0.7426390647888184,
-0.1422247290611267,
0.1433529555797577,
-0.10310232639312744,
-0.22069092094898224,
0.0031957016326487064,
0.6146408319473267,
0.5204638838768005,
-0.03314652666449547,
0.21717333793640137,
0.20806530117988586,
0.86627197265625,
-0.2674160599708557,
0.502170979976654,
-0.9038917422294617,
-0.13399305939674377,
-0.4912552237510681,
-0.061375632882118225,
-0.4486962854862213,
-0.5054352283477783,
-0.10966652631759644,
-0.14942988753318787,
0.1983126848936081,
0.17548006772994995,
0.9204487204551697,
-0.15852391719818115,
-0.6072934865951538,
-0.28617894649505615,
-0.7137980461120605,
0.36504900455474854,
-0.6247665286064148,
0.32493531703948975,
0.29453983902931213,
0.4422735571861267,
-0.6576277017593384,
-0.7633171677589417,
-0.5323025584220886,
-0.1849849820137024,
-0.23631122708320618,
-0.16934765875339508,
-0.4258190095424652,
-0.07398293167352676,
0.004354423843324184,
0.009841597639024258,
-0.6527097225189209,
-0.10344282537698746,
-0.5170519351959229,
-0.3151107430458069,
0.7603896856307983,
0.3389754593372345,
0.5239149332046509,
-0.46951010823249817,
-0.1728472262620926,
0.4184655547142029,
-0.7573837041854858,
0.23895905911922455,
0.7437426447868347,
0.7851402759552002,
-0.4751516878604889,
0.52876216173172,
-0.20161810517311096,
0.7540918588638306,
-0.23082323372364044,
0.23934303224086761,
0.07006825506687164,
-0.5890114903450012,
0.0098134595900774,
-0.06037513539195061,
0.9312402606010437,
0.5264878869056702,
0.3020704984664917,
0.0026740445755422115,
-0.04351133853197098,
0.5331657528877258,
-0.16710618138313293,
-0.6504858136177063,
-0.38278406858444214,
0.3040827214717865,
-0.5760197043418884,
-0.6568025946617126,
-0.0018992036348208785,
-1.106791377067566,
-0.7669450640678406,
-0.4355296790599823,
-0.058865856379270554,
-0.3235020339488983,
-0.2952106297016144,
-0.1671459674835205,
0.05844905227422714,
-0.354736864566803,
0.34330466389656067,
-0.47118112444877625,
0.3490397334098816,
0.6170848608016968,
1.2138619422912598,
-0.044140830636024475,
0.09802458435297012,
-0.7576755285263062,
-0.007791092619299889,
-0.3294319212436676,
0.7862644195556641,
-0.7650168538093567,
-0.25562405586242676,
0.2431812435388565,
-0.011501708999276161,
0.1994009017944336,
-0.21373890340328217,
0.37289389967918396,
-0.6287190914154053,
0.09214679151773453,
-0.11354614794254303,
-0.42282772064208984,
-0.16048003733158112,
-0.013241652399301529,
-0.7380079627037048,
1.0588557720184326,
0.15774843096733093,
-0.9915171265602112,
0.38720571994781494,
-0.6760149002075195,
-0.459585964679718,
-0.005645168479532003,
-0.08695108443498611,
-0.4829466640949249,
-0.05359254404902458,
0.06301623582839966,
0.30127808451652527,
-0.12870575487613678,
0.5469054579734802,
-0.6946019530296326,
-0.2704879641532898,
-0.07654603570699692,
0.14304578304290771,
0.892281174659729,
0.03480686619877815,
-0.08341514319181442,
0.5425432920455933,
-0.9264129400253296,
-0.0012905359035357833,
0.12090318650007248,
-0.059994231909513474,
-0.1725877821445465,
0.5305472016334534,
-0.06178274750709534,
0.36529242992401123,
-0.03987322375178337,
-0.5007895827293396,
0.09907206147909164,
-0.367332398891449,
0.6453826427459717,
0.8034836649894714,
0.3149285614490509,
0.4480079710483551,
-0.30172884464263916,
0.21375150978565216,
0.01780647598206997,
0.44424933195114136,
0.17642493546009064,
-0.7772912383079529,
-0.3345559537410736,
0.10397902131080627,
0.08135335892438889,
0.7690773010253906,
-0.5928499102592468,
0.2350856214761734,
0.18468432128429413,
-0.5843494534492493,
-0.1588209867477417,
0.14117276668548584,
0.05729761719703674,
0.375979483127594,
0.11651130765676498,
-0.03463142365217209,
-0.9692445993423462,
-0.40473049879074097,
-0.26442408561706543,
-0.5192579627037048,
0.3018287122249603,
-0.12145856767892838,
0.44771239161491394,
-0.3741508424282074,
0.8673143982887268,
-0.2787230908870697,
-0.03936510905623436,
-0.2035522758960724,
0.4295341968536377,
0.3422868549823761,
-0.06781570613384247,
0.6026018857955933,
-0.7019504308700562,
-0.5104010701179504,
0.40919822454452515,
-0.5166454315185547,
0.03176235780119896,
0.4194822311401367,
-0.16181640326976776,
0.39142364263534546,
0.583495020866394,
-0.279677152633667,
0.7348542809486389,
0.7388010621070862,
-0.4496981203556061,
0.42405739426612854,
0.20291422307491302,
-0.10930182784795761,
-0.7700247168540955,
-0.22333431243896484,
-0.06839930266141891,
-0.2758622169494629,
-0.9887051582336426,
-0.4215744435787201,
-0.0007330711232498288,
-0.3557951748371124,
-0.42491164803504944,
0.5723288655281067,
-0.42803847789764404,
0.030864400789141655,
-0.1960100680589676,
0.29437750577926636,
-0.29041004180908203,
0.06281593441963196,
-0.5203050374984741,
0.24241304397583008,
0.5120561718940735,
-0.62348872423172,
0.36282017827033997,
-0.06679609417915344,
-0.5687621235847473,
-0.08830399811267853,
-0.6318961381912231,
0.32839521765708923,
-0.5311533212661743,
0.03321177512407303,
-1.4173698425292969,
-0.2725845277309418,
0.4220234751701355,
-0.5145428776741028,
0.12428408861160278,
-0.26459938287734985,
-0.44395992159843445,
-0.6570597887039185,
-0.06539139896631241,
-0.17539085447788239,
0.3243408799171448,
-0.06256186217069626,
0.6529982686042786,
0.8342775106430054,
-0.23642969131469727,
-0.3230797350406647,
-0.27024903893470764,
-0.011519688181579113,
-0.1130562573671341,
-0.6699033975601196,
-0.20413096249103546,
0.06833436340093613,
-0.5394697189331055,
0.21416503190994263,
0.1293330043554306,
-0.005444537848234177,
0.16504427790641785,
0.39354240894317627,
0.45302408933639526,
0.06444675475358963,
0.21925587952136993,
-0.3297329843044281,
-0.09392401576042175,
-0.009427126497030258,
0.019358044490218163,
0.8226437568664551,
-0.1335291713476181,
-0.17018543183803558,
-0.5340119004249573,
0.3668314814567566,
0.8810049295425415,
-0.2689450681209564,
0.6774981021881104,
0.5395326018333435,
-0.541938066482544,
0.122188039124012,
-0.16643765568733215,
-0.1872774362564087,
-0.36446598172187805,
0.4818286895751953,
0.2844255268573761,
-0.6450409889221191,
1.021803617477417,
0.02792298048734665,
-0.0751313790678978,
0.24156013131141663,
0.5559795498847961,
0.2473629266023636,
1.457871675491333,
0.6682307124137878,
-0.5683507919311523,
0.8644008040428162,
-0.02015407383441925,
0.49706271290779114,
-0.33146432042121887,
-0.2301921546459198,
-0.719967782497406,
-0.23271317780017853,
-0.42933952808380127,
-0.23555658757686615,
0.11433549225330353,
0.009397406131029129,
-0.38678422570228577,
-0.09246618300676346,
-0.5018783807754517,
0.2815055251121521,
0.13293491303920746,
-0.04398125410079956,
0.22888289391994476,
0.16767489910125732,
0.00624341843649745,
-0.001920986222103238,
-0.4755244851112366,
-0.5527240633964539,
0.9700613617897034,
0.23171943426132202,
0.6339806318283081,
0.10849673300981522,
0.39569419622421265,
0.4725240170955658,
0.8556939363479614,
-0.452298104763031,
0.4078678786754608,
-0.10323743522167206,
-0.6598406434059143,
-0.6497237086296082,
-0.29122453927993774,
-0.9526858925819397,
0.23167164623737335,
-0.2913021445274353,
-1.1608357429504395,
0.10874928534030914,
0.07827004045248032,
-0.1705084890127182,
0.37100687623023987,
-0.529259979724884,
0.6720277070999146,
-0.1271492838859558,
-0.08577916026115417,
0.001687619835138321,
-0.5396807789802551,
0.4195432662963867,
0.07202864438295364,
0.8897350430488586,
-0.6409139037132263,
0.20299042761325836,
0.4733526408672333,
-0.32069486379623413,
1.0659173727035522,
-0.4236641228199005,
0.2004692256450653,
0.39964231848716736,
-0.0711517482995987,
1.1680752038955688,
-0.04059625044465065,
-0.34938329458236694,
0.019796103239059448,
-0.16348320245742798,
-0.4296262264251709,
-0.5077710747718811,
0.38219448924064636,
-0.7631967663764954,
-0.2903183400630951,
-0.1486499160528183,
-0.4838384985923767,
-0.021947920322418213,
0.2690444886684418,
0.4562612473964691,
0.4853900074958801,
-0.4003608524799347,
0.08360011875629425,
0.022669250145554543,
0.3787285387516022,
0.40237048268318176,
0.5658412575721741,
-0.8630886077880859,
-0.5558492541313171,
0.659078061580658,
0.5503766536712646,
0.25748729705810547,
-0.014182201586663723,
0.3682032823562622,
-0.10280716419219971,
-0.8573608994483948,
-0.10882706940174103,
0.14263515174388885,
-0.5754944086074829,
-0.22724738717079163,
-0.6556292176246643,
-0.20386028289794922,
-0.4674087464809418,
-0.030068514868617058,
-0.12985651195049286,
-0.06374984979629517,
-0.15725143253803253,
-0.23722177743911743,
0.32295045256614685,
1.0613716840744019,
0.2090308964252472,
0.3987177014350891,
-0.5500123500823975,
0.1938912719488144,
-0.15069787204265594,
0.2797272503376007,
-0.2003912776708603,
-0.24319857358932495,
-0.22196920216083527,
0.1141529232263565,
-0.30959731340408325,
-1.397033452987671,
0.5695423483848572,
0.20705711841583252,
0.5862707495689392,
0.3869383931159973,
0.35702720284461975,
0.45986396074295044,
-0.46997445821762085,
0.7384987473487854,
0.15241965651512146,
-0.9090457558631897,
0.8722246289253235,
-0.5419427156448364,
-0.15146997570991516,
0.1867053210735321,
0.33104783296585083,
-0.36310499906539917,
-0.881860613822937,
-0.7376598119735718,
-0.9603646397590637,
0.3097308278083801,
0.020695751532912254,
0.12788566946983337,
-0.12770946323871613,
0.31739097833633423,
-0.0788240060210228,
0.25158464908599854,
-0.531836986541748,
-0.27320823073387146,
-0.09636059403419495,
-0.010091529227793217,
-0.2958757281303406,
-0.327725887298584,
-0.378918319940567,
-0.4135282635688782,
0.4960090219974518,
-0.41693419218063354,
-0.012646912597119808,
0.11171484738588333,
0.22983354330062866,
-0.5807360410690308,
0.10950984805822372,
0.6998386383056641,
0.9554889798164368,
-0.32754626870155334,
0.06504719704389572,
0.02126147411763668,
-0.4132295250892639,
0.12152569741010666,
0.14974725246429443,
-0.32172343134880066,
0.45843732357025146,
0.3423197269439697,
0.8100088238716125,
0.12049481272697449,
-0.20302918553352356,
0.3209979832172394,
-0.03816241770982742,
-0.09788359701633453,
-0.31538090109825134,
-0.22982023656368256,
-0.029740381985902786,
0.2511698305606842,
0.467242032289505,
-0.03626786544919014,
0.05964663252234459,
-0.9705088138580322,
0.4103277623653412,
0.7250993847846985,
-0.5939981937408447,
-0.5843132734298706,
0.6706165671348572,
0.09460903704166412,
-0.4340461492538452,
0.3412868082523346,
-0.41533493995666504,
-0.524743914604187,
0.7545676231384277,
0.5463086366653442,
0.5143488049507141,
-0.36865249276161194,
0.6472710371017456,
0.2666669189929962,
0.6153708696365356,
0.13692094385623932,
0.6199321150779724,
0.7866519689559937,
-0.8025186657905579,
-0.4404655992984772,
-0.3896534740924835,
-0.38658711314201355,
0.31042778491973877,
-0.6426926255226135,
0.4913080036640167,
-0.6316471695899963,
-0.6461501717567444,
0.10736245661973953,
0.40109071135520935,
-0.4631651043891907,
-0.1585647165775299,
0.07364189624786377,
0.8067388534545898,
-1.2922005653381348,
0.811286449432373,
0.6003003716468811,
-0.007408880162984133,
-0.6510390639305115,
-0.10937003046274185,
0.46684783697128296,
-0.7750414609909058,
0.4749484360218048,
-0.07493575662374496,
0.05384042486548424,
-0.17254658043384552,
-0.6621617078781128,
-1.1549856662750244,
0.7719427943229675,
0.6883037686347961,
-0.5386582016944885,
-0.021627169102430344,
-0.2126528024673462,
0.49338892102241516,
-0.511885941028595,
-0.09391437470912933,
0.549445629119873,
0.6913447976112366,
-0.0240778811275959,
-0.5532780885696411,
0.11969468742609024,
-0.345542311668396,
-0.1563461869955063,
0.7786588668823242,
-0.7013376355171204,
1.1812429428100586,
-0.20204301178455353,
-0.6976920366287231,
-0.194467693567276,
0.5902200937271118,
-0.08306805789470673,
0.8497753143310547,
0.4273357391357422,
0.027677059173583984,
1.4134820699691772,
-0.3143400251865387,
1.2065542936325073,
-0.6219288110733032,
0.5931054949760437,
0.9417992234230042,
-0.5094679594039917,
0.6665813326835632,
0.2194523811340332,
-0.21648699045181274,
0.7488005757331848,
0.5548250079154968,
0.39293619990348816,
0.5537201166152954,
0.32843726873397827,
-0.10154269635677338,
0.0003571835986804217,
-0.1936476081609726,
-0.5045226216316223,
0.19627411663532257,
0.6108499765396118,
-0.07944381237030029,
-0.4399898052215576,
-0.10531504452228546,
0.1609906256198883,
0.0670873150229454,
-0.3980184495449066,
0.5500176548957825,
-0.02361697517335415,
-0.1832444667816162,
0.3562731444835663,
-0.42916324734687805,
0.11447881907224655,
-0.6706292629241943,
0.014569458551704884,
-0.06287050247192383,
0.1383739709854126,
-0.2828473746776581,
-0.7959096431732178,
0.5883406400680542,
-0.345670223236084,
-0.25911012291908264,
0.3451632559299469,
1.1725304126739502,
-0.39144790172576904,
-0.5494002103805542,
0.7967664003372192,
0.5050890445709229,
-0.0927569568157196,
-0.09849189221858978,
-0.6058996915817261,
0.43354737758636475,
-0.04651936888694763,
-0.26339489221572876,
0.30099913477897644,
0.5981046557426453,
-0.3517512083053589,
0.6346371173858643,
0.8463383913040161,
0.27994948625564575,
0.008397365920245647,
0.2505391240119934,
1.0702298879623413,
-0.5241914987564087,
-0.5868961811065674,
-1.0266610383987427,
0.6874619722366333,
-0.47810235619544983,
0.0030541475862264633,
0.7052741646766663,
0.40208953619003296,
0.37339669466018677,
0.40640056133270264,
1.019673466682434,
0.15971966087818146,
0.6775168776512146,
-0.4759499132633209,
0.651626467704773,
-0.1707710325717926,
-0.07460848987102509,
-0.3991594612598419,
-0.3753639757633209,
-0.4692307114601135,
0.2772884964942932,
-0.44949644804000854,
-0.37055647373199463,
0.6009441018104553,
0.7529319524765015,
0.3610564172267914,
0.22670134902000427,
0.26805874705314636,
0.38965463638305664,
0.49277743697166443,
0.2360810786485672,
0.8551996350288391,
-0.018319126218557358,
0.5798551440238953,
-0.16242849826812744,
-0.2516525387763977,
-0.5879956483840942,
-0.9738036394119263,
-1.0350838899612427,
-0.5087344646453857,
-0.1919989138841629,
-0.6691286563873291,
0.3769756257534027,
0.5745493173599243,
0.6107081174850464,
-0.8466658592224121,
-0.09639059752225876,
-0.1350642740726471,
0.5193453431129456,
-0.1437595784664154,
-0.2672286927700043,
0.38691893219947815,
-0.37166544795036316,
-0.37896987795829773,
0.12699460983276367,
0.3133929967880249,
0.23882152140140533,
-0.07802233844995499,
0.0033258344046771526,
-0.22910097241401672,
0.13419879972934723,
0.7618836164474487,
0.27974066138267517,
-0.5941628217697144,
-0.8464246988296509,
-0.21993295848369598,
-0.05108475312590599,
-0.15999557077884674,
0.8526901006698608,
-0.47358807921409607,
0.37833598256111145,
0.6299811005592346,
0.12351575493812561,
0.16202817857265472,
0.10154872387647629,
0.5512940287590027,
-0.6882275342941284,
0.5185070037841797,
0.08636146038770676,
0.4139339327812195,
0.2155584990978241,
-0.6857799887657166,
0.6175397038459778,
0.40199488401412964,
-0.6306604146957397,
-1.199745774269104,
0.3549511134624481,
-0.6122607588768005,
-0.04962595924735069,
1.0637423992156982,
0.3199877142906189,
-0.3894852101802826,
-0.5702719688415527,
-0.29952847957611084,
0.34905919432640076,
-0.5355204939842224,
0.7918848991394043,
1.086099624633789,
-0.32293927669525146,
-0.11998321115970612,
-0.8026052713394165,
0.4633457660675049,
-0.2976425886154175,
-0.6298919916152954,
0.2224879115819931,
0.39882102608680725,
0.05087574943900108,
0.2573046088218689,
0.9169679284095764,
-0.1555507928133011,
0.16539901494979858,
-0.0465889610350132,
-0.27917206287384033,
-0.06358984857797623,
-0.44622132182121277,
-0.11717962473630905,
0.46753865480422974,
-0.2218431681394577,
-0.010624530725181103
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17811v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17811v1
|
Are Compressed Language Models Less Subgroup Robust?
| 2024-03-26T15:50:37 | 2024-03-26T15:50:37 |
Leonidas Gee, Andrea Zugarini, Novi Quadrianto
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
To reduce the inference cost of large language models, model compression is
increasingly used to create smaller scalable models. However, little is known
about their robustness to minority subgroups defined by the labels and
attributes of a dataset. In this paper, we investigate the effects of 18
different compression methods and settings on the subgroup robustness of BERT
language models. We show that worst-group performance does not depend on model
size alone, but also on the compression method used. Additionally, we find that
model compression does not always worsen the performance on minority subgroups.
Altogether, our analysis serves to further research into the subgroup
robustness of model compression.
|
[
-0.6224995851516724,
-0.4736924469470978,
-0.05790788307785988,
-0.09723363071680069,
-0.08622510731220245,
-0.05467049404978752,
-0.41692355275154114,
-0.5578790903091431,
-0.16488420963287354,
-0.007747546304017305,
-0.640756368637085,
-0.3152053952217102,
-0.7288265228271484,
0.13843312859535217,
-0.3806860148906708,
0.7295382618904114,
0.7821628451347351,
0.14595437049865723,
-0.0659203752875328,
-0.06223422288894653,
-0.21637925505638123,
-0.9432412981987,
-0.37994298338890076,
-0.13843902945518494,
0.21362613141536713,
-0.04577495530247688,
0.9679727554321289,
0.5012366771697998,
0.39676302671432495,
0.36440014839172363,
-0.4583788812160492,
-0.29940900206565857,
-0.6937793493270874,
0.25424715876579285,
0.43929117918014526,
-0.611841082572937,
-0.3313857913017273,
-0.23949724435806274,
0.6513117551803589,
0.8097356557846069,
-0.15483731031417847,
-0.01225498877465725,
0.13605426251888275,
0.5657867789268494,
-0.6425271034240723,
-0.1356620043516159,
-0.911030113697052,
-0.1295771300792694,
-0.1069134995341301,
0.3834611475467682,
-0.7372638583183289,
-0.508187472820282,
0.039712049067020416,
0.02635691687464714,
0.7026494145393372,
0.18430393934249878,
0.9353129863739014,
0.44710564613342285,
-0.2592489421367645,
0.014885527081787586,
-0.5820114612579346,
1.0397114753723145,
-1.2012112140655518,
0.3366718292236328,
0.6481797099113464,
0.20504319667816162,
-0.1297573745250702,
-0.21658581495285034,
-0.4567853808403015,
0.07459791004657745,
-0.1126636192202568,
-0.265462726354599,
-0.28784316778182983,
0.32806575298309326,
0.442218154668808,
0.6713864207267761,
-0.7051443457603455,
0.8382829427719116,
-0.45907458662986755,
-0.4818170368671417,
0.6209484934806824,
0.020874274894595146,
0.3465401530265808,
-0.22790387272834778,
0.03099232167005539,
-0.3902199864387512,
-0.7362860441207886,
0.07999493181705475,
0.7260357737541199,
0.7431331872940063,
0.010238668881356716,
0.47005847096443176,
0.3491133153438568,
0.9295400977134705,
-0.12166249006986618,
-0.4203840494155884,
-0.05584682151675224,
-0.13825729489326477,
-0.36646726727485657,
-0.2579774856567383,
0.5474492907524109,
0.4406561255455017,
0.12312610447406769,
-0.2842878997325897,
-0.34508684277534485,
0.2608203887939453,
0.09844199568033218,
-0.8127986788749695,
-0.6210363507270813,
0.021672679111361504,
-0.998283326625824,
-0.20018184185028076,
-0.15099327266216278,
-0.6055083870887756,
-0.21367114782333374,
0.05420941486954689,
0.12636829912662506,
-0.4599290192127228,
0.0639934092760086,
-0.11977792531251907,
-0.2511581778526306,
0.10336463898420334,
0.1832442432641983,
-1.2709295749664307,
0.45561352372169495,
0.5433099865913391,
0.7750012874603271,
-0.1693277359008789,
0.08583042025566101,
-0.35739561915397644,
-0.21950523555278778,
-0.07399986684322357,
0.6381269693374634,
-0.6053508520126343,
-0.6190267205238342,
0.06867159903049469,
-0.11769057810306549,
-0.0655287355184555,
-0.5691894888877869,
0.44966721534729004,
-0.39159706234931946,
0.30120909214019775,
-0.3974969983100891,
-0.8544307947158813,
-0.1657363474369049,
-0.13553957641124725,
-0.94835364818573,
0.7272699475288391,
0.23852241039276123,
-0.6323478817939758,
0.5662525296211243,
0.08872351050376892,
-0.4703659117221832,
-0.1255710870027542,
-0.08752143383026123,
-0.47468301653862,
0.5697237849235535,
0.6591497659683228,
0.4806385934352875,
-0.16300511360168457,
-0.0858960673213005,
-0.5626079440116882,
-0.4556760787963867,
0.26640114188194275,
-0.36797651648521423,
1.0036698579788208,
0.2590002715587616,
0.2814590334892273,
-0.3207017481327057,
-0.4592699110507965,
0.20621058344841003,
-0.0984092578291893,
-0.4755290746688843,
-0.366899311542511,
0.07924391329288483,
-0.20311422646045685,
0.045271970331668854,
-0.08503507822751999,
-0.34666907787323,
0.6866683959960938,
-0.12018827348947525,
0.335540235042572,
1.0586742162704468,
-0.16559283435344696,
0.5758420825004578,
-0.43166595697402954,
0.5909066200256348,
-0.5261062979698181,
0.18948566913604736,
0.12658530473709106,
-0.6508961915969849,
-0.8084426522254944,
-0.6128618121147156,
0.7784298062324524,
0.23070363700389862,
-0.5829854011535645,
0.5567141771316528,
-0.31308308243751526,
-0.43025869131088257,
-0.400534987449646,
-0.04334551841020584,
0.23792783915996552,
0.22574716806411743,
0.10660835355520248,
-0.4815833568572998,
-0.36073413491249084,
-1.0813056230545044,
-0.06965424120426178,
-0.5311466455459595,
-0.2881157696247101,
0.20866607129573822,
0.2717770040035248,
-0.06974907219409943,
0.6937041282653809,
-0.5247325897216797,
0.05804034695029259,
-0.4990284740924835,
0.47390449047088623,
0.2865707278251648,
0.4836921989917755,
1.0385675430297852,
-0.5453898310661316,
-0.47988972067832947,
-0.5097101926803589,
-0.043498508632183075,
-0.30098649859428406,
0.25459179282188416,
0.2632737457752228,
0.47928333282470703,
0.1875978261232376,
-0.30388423800468445,
0.3880801498889923,
1.2369385957717896,
0.028953758999705315,
0.35968729853630066,
0.18246370553970337,
-0.15692822635173798,
-0.8491390347480774,
-0.3184465765953064,
0.008974427357316017,
-0.19050908088684082,
-0.711399495601654,
-0.10265335440635681,
-0.0921827107667923,
-0.19419032335281372,
-0.24353958666324615,
0.039271291345357895,
-0.4443924129009247,
-0.1441446840763092,
-0.20191892981529236,
-0.45236706733703613,
-0.22655874490737915,
0.6590843796730042,
-0.019365521147847176,
0.9228864908218384,
0.6979947686195374,
-0.8202071785926819,
-0.09287095069885254,
0.1434544026851654,
-0.6531785130500793,
-0.032909195870161057,
-0.6989288926124573,
0.35916319489479065,
-0.49608904123306274,
0.2656635344028473,
-0.7742753028869629,
-0.40672317147254944,
-0.3449428379535675,
-0.42075708508491516,
0.6848955750465393,
-0.3292323052883148,
-0.5515703558921814,
-0.2142135500907898,
-0.44076448678970337,
0.40665215253829956,
1.0323054790496826,
-0.430625319480896,
0.2285977154970169,
0.4309540092945099,
-0.2324707955121994,
-0.5077922344207764,
-1.0009639263153076,
-0.3451582193374634,
-0.3986815810203552,
-0.734387993812561,
0.193471297621727,
-0.24043121933937073,
-0.22294215857982635,
-0.010850686579942703,
-0.2001808136701584,
-0.47251811623573303,
0.14612917602062225,
0.17172986268997192,
0.1772354245185852,
-0.02325744740664959,
0.4283350706100464,
-0.010050869546830654,
0.3090001940727234,
-0.5397316813468933,
0.14083202183246613,
0.6756771802902222,
-0.15732203423976898,
-0.21739789843559265,
-0.17411623895168304,
0.6848433613777161,
0.19625118374824524,
0.09335874021053314,
1.2259271144866943,
0.2308017611503601,
-0.3124162256717682,
-0.20572388172149658,
-0.41907814145088196,
-0.4363158941268921,
-0.5141069889068604,
0.21868689358234406,
-0.08333317935466766,
-1.3864765167236328,
0.7159091830253601,
0.12681697309017181,
0.16335512697696686,
0.48981210589408875,
0.6412340402603149,
-0.10719119012355804,
1.0820904970169067,
0.8219221234321594,
-0.39782676100730896,
0.4816857874393463,
0.018111955374479294,
0.23183447122573853,
-0.5308480858802795,
0.06741905212402344,
-1.0309900045394897,
-0.4450133740901947,
-0.671222448348999,
-0.3520835041999817,
0.3585379123687744,
0.18196377158164978,
-0.04526791721582413,
0.3779970109462738,
-0.5741317272186279,
0.5217158198356628,
0.5547966957092285,
-0.056830357760190964,
0.0481702946126461,
0.23602275550365448,
0.35592642426490784,
-0.3770799934864044,
-1.192047119140625,
-0.4682298004627228,
0.7910319566726685,
0.2893390655517578,
1.221781849861145,
0.6711239814758301,
0.5834498405456543,
0.5121821761131287,
0.43691253662109375,
-0.7790988683700562,
0.4841882288455963,
-0.5411802530288696,
-0.8262805342674255,
-0.24437294900417328,
-0.5593859553337097,
-1.0230554342269897,
0.14905981719493866,
-0.25429898500442505,
-1.2595908641815186,
0.6538868546485901,
0.17806774377822876,
-0.3030417561531067,
0.31299543380737305,
-0.930033802986145,
0.2721744477748871,
0.012414022348821163,
0.3735332489013672,
0.2049364596605301,
-0.6413030028343201,
0.5593984723091125,
-0.2697388529777527,
0.10353665798902512,
-0.10742796212434769,
0.20232123136520386,
0.700031042098999,
-0.7540385723114014,
0.9762082099914551,
0.1335752308368683,
-0.09605947136878967,
0.13582676649093628,
0.1513083130121231,
0.5001652240753174,
-0.3781311810016632,
-0.3780607581138611,
0.1709018349647522,
-0.22174251079559326,
-0.6052453517913818,
-0.7654152512550354,
0.4357289671897888,
-0.6048136353492737,
-0.5361595153808594,
-0.09848855435848236,
-0.6253633499145508,
-0.27665138244628906,
-0.1650320440530777,
0.7141590714454651,
0.5819448232650757,
0.15379251539707184,
0.4061327576637268,
0.5043988823890686,
-0.3103950321674347,
0.7221256494522095,
0.247159942984581,
0.054983992129564285,
-0.23917770385742188,
0.7777121663093567,
0.19817803800106049,
0.6252045631408691,
0.14942674338817596,
-0.058479972183704376,
-0.15028570592403412,
-0.6551562547683716,
0.023809652775526047,
0.011823927983641624,
-0.748677134513855,
-0.30476105213165283,
-0.2808900475502014,
-0.00965888425707817,
-0.8255289196968079,
-0.05628065764904022,
-0.3290480077266693,
-0.9122262597084045,
0.11737439036369324,
0.005994319450110197,
0.029156651347875595,
0.5361881256103516,
-0.19498305022716522,
0.5955703258514404,
-0.9605841636657715,
-0.11395587027072906,
0.5661698579788208,
0.12936951220035553,
0.038900576531887054,
-0.48229753971099854,
-0.2758646011352539,
-0.15208140015602112,
0.024515122175216675,
-0.9399498701095581,
0.40155935287475586,
0.6094401478767395,
0.5144309401512146,
0.6357851028442383,
0.45164915919303894,
0.4944610595703125,
-0.372100830078125,
1.2401686906814575,
0.10357870906591415,
-1.0115824937820435,
0.22602108120918274,
-0.07090707868337631,
0.23491601645946503,
0.45501530170440674,
0.18401633203029633,
-0.09292085468769073,
-0.5476754307746887,
-0.564483642578125,
-0.7482412457466125,
0.6360864043235779,
0.5495566129684448,
0.3372165858745575,
0.1388626992702484,
0.1603531837463379,
0.2647984027862549,
0.07084325700998306,
-1.067710280418396,
-0.46529367566108704,
0.00335316127166152,
-0.08584217727184296,
0.036149293184280396,
-0.5759336352348328,
-0.030083656311035156,
-0.13140085339546204,
0.6262699365615845,
-0.027021469548344612,
0.4913158118724823,
-0.22736385464668274,
0.08758476376533508,
0.08031254261732101,
0.34719252586364746,
0.5308656096458435,
0.20275256037712097,
-0.3407091498374939,
0.10761143267154694,
0.09979817271232605,
-0.2309958040714264,
0.23875662684440613,
-0.013436634093523026,
-0.014580096118152142,
0.16878066956996918,
0.9859797954559326,
0.9287970662117004,
-0.34249669313430786,
-0.6016488671302795,
0.3480839729309082,
-0.42735227942466736,
-0.07768602669239044,
0.3160869777202606,
0.337158203125,
-0.4448014497756958,
0.11474224179983139,
0.281116783618927,
0.06489450484514236,
0.10132020711898804,
-0.47435462474823,
-0.25926271080970764,
0.5211231708526611,
-0.0854041650891304,
-0.18137232959270477,
0.3985411524772644,
0.09510009735822678,
-0.1708349883556366,
0.9262152314186096,
0.08867409825325012,
-0.6945299506187439,
0.4699373245239258,
0.5240721106529236,
0.646314799785614,
-0.4292747676372528,
-0.13088934123516083,
0.23291264474391937,
0.796230673789978,
0.013199633918702602,
-0.15333431959152222,
-0.1385064572095871,
-0.728010356426239,
-0.7489210367202759,
-0.3397136330604553,
-0.24423737823963165,
0.22676239907741547,
-0.9288641810417175,
-0.21392962336540222,
0.07851462811231613,
-0.6317272782325745,
-0.30496716499328613,
-0.41711241006851196,
-0.25974810123443604,
0.36563757061958313,
0.1795232743024826,
0.9166569113731384,
-0.974723219871521,
0.6504449248313904,
0.5332169532775879,
0.09963878244161606,
-0.9913608431816101,
0.3218976855278015,
0.057819582521915436,
-0.48876768350601196,
0.48448261618614197,
-0.037400320172309875,
0.2049805372953415,
-0.40521004796028137,
-0.9323410987854004,
-0.9779983162879944,
0.5170965790748596,
0.7548226714134216,
-0.33160415291786194,
-0.08163043111562729,
-0.06526236236095428,
0.6675954461097717,
0.0762133002281189,
-0.24169626832008362,
0.101572185754776,
0.24277694523334503,
0.11775786429643631,
-1.0212037563323975,
-0.20208746194839478,
-0.3237408697605133,
0.272898405790329,
0.16541624069213867,
-0.6691096425056458,
1.066039800643921,
0.04842618852853775,
-0.39138543605804443,
0.20039567351341248,
0.623579740524292,
-0.03276965022087097,
-0.2861293852329254,
0.7091310620307922,
0.5895721912384033,
0.9705226421356201,
-0.2124643325805664,
1.522770881652832,
-0.1524379700422287,
0.5115004777908325,
0.9999527931213379,
0.04097774997353554,
0.5263215899467468,
0.1497306525707245,
-0.3933349549770355,
0.26436224579811096,
0.8048540949821472,
-0.0596308596432209,
0.6952396631240845,
0.19276247918605804,
-0.2938176393508911,
-0.6293689012527466,
-0.10925248265266418,
-0.5252367258071899,
0.3169081509113312,
0.2645603120326996,
-0.4184219241142273,
-0.00013423811469692737,
-0.21408791840076447,
-0.0052838935516774654,
-0.17166800796985626,
-0.15504099428653717,
0.5496053099632263,
0.05267341062426567,
-0.5960085988044739,
0.7549976110458374,
0.080937959253788,
0.5669743418693542,
-0.350005179643631,
0.39243683218955994,
-0.48083749413490295,
-0.08284550160169601,
-0.10781547427177429,
-0.3450143039226532,
0.18087884783744812,
0.1380571871995926,
-0.31296810507774353,
-0.005769908893853426,
0.8937081694602966,
-0.3913134038448334,
-0.4466792941093445,
-0.31513217091560364,
0.3453013300895691,
0.21834589540958405,
0.26091018319129944,
-0.24272561073303223,
0.29458117485046387,
0.08732403069734573,
-0.12833328545093536,
0.2795797288417816,
0.033389512449502945,
0.07712043076753616,
0.8559403419494629,
0.42661041021347046,
0.008618357591331005,
0.379299521446228,
0.14743004739284515,
1.0331120491027832,
-0.21103481948375702,
-0.21617886424064636,
-0.8954236507415771,
0.4228629767894745,
-0.26256245374679565,
0.0469881147146225,
0.9549921154975891,
0.39519232511520386,
0.5962044596672058,
-0.06986943632364273,
0.8472912311553955,
-0.3024744987487793,
0.3667130768299103,
-0.7540257573127747,
0.5456005930900574,
-0.49042436480522156,
0.3790622353553772,
-0.4123668968677521,
-0.9636414647102356,
-0.5457813739776611,
0.6864537000656128,
0.09376197308301926,
0.29813921451568604,
0.3454110026359558,
0.7690613865852356,
0.13341857492923737,
-0.004041558597236872,
0.350873202085495,
0.20927882194519043,
0.4673023521900177,
0.48052528500556946,
0.7413342595100403,
-0.09371133893728256,
0.33377471566200256,
-0.37897300720214844,
0.08099495619535446,
-0.020078502595424652,
-0.9299251437187195,
-1.2723263502120972,
-0.5531890988349915,
-0.3408953845500946,
-0.24930904805660248,
-0.18060676753520966,
0.6728366017341614,
1.0928372144699097,
-0.7448687553405762,
0.18837963044643402,
0.07675634324550629,
0.18944905698299408,
-0.06955116987228394,
-0.2084631472826004,
0.496426522731781,
-0.10044211894273758,
-1.0680054426193237,
0.4086510241031647,
-0.022786593064665794,
0.4225695729255676,
-0.1764899641275406,
-0.10294579714536667,
0.1730320155620575,
0.15514400601387024,
0.3606455624103546,
0.18064665794372559,
-0.5945660471916199,
-0.20641857385635376,
-0.19440039992332458,
-0.07125012576580048,
-0.1412232518196106,
0.9187402129173279,
-0.6100594997406006,
0.4547475278377533,
0.5459707975387573,
0.47022876143455505,
0.2055400013923645,
0.2807672619819641,
0.8264515399932861,
-1.315733551979065,
0.4868651032447815,
0.4348718225955963,
0.521901547908783,
0.34432974457740784,
-0.19623354077339172,
0.5388908386230469,
-0.06180887669324875,
-0.7506693601608276,
-1.064774990081787,
0.4251652657985687,
-0.6550512909889221,
-0.40687137842178345,
1.2104270458221436,
-0.2933797538280487,
-0.035987041890621185,
0.008534037508070469,
-0.0857420340180397,
0.11211547255516052,
-0.466998815536499,
0.8564791083335876,
1.1081912517547607,
-0.34301355481147766,
-0.41297492384910583,
-0.07410351932048798,
0.48841872811317444,
0.6426042318344116,
-0.4768053889274597,
-0.23839764297008514,
0.6931374669075012,
-0.2150803953409195,
-0.03579346090555191,
0.1841418296098709,
0.26756080985069275,
-0.12706893682479858,
0.021940914914011955,
-0.23380236327648163,
0.12648886442184448,
0.03725631907582283,
-0.513197660446167,
0.26501601934432983,
0.2237180769443512,
0.08426913619041443
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17806v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17806v1
|
Have Faith in Faithfulness: Going Beyond Circuit Overlap When Finding Model Mechanisms
| 2024-03-26T15:44:58 | 2024-03-26T15:44:58 |
Michael Hanna, Sandro Pezzelle, Yonatan Belinkov
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Many recent language model (LM) interpretability studies have adopted the
circuits framework, which aims to find the minimal computational subgraph, or
circuit, that explains LM behavior on a given task. Most studies determine
which edges belong in a LM's circuit by performing causal interventions on each
edge independently, but this scales poorly with model size. Edge attribution
patching (EAP), gradient-based approximation to interventions, has emerged as a
scalable but imperfect solution to this problem. In this paper, we introduce a
new method - EAP with integrated gradients (EAP-IG) - that aims to better
maintain a core property of circuits: faithfulness. A circuit is faithful if
all model edges outside the circuit can be ablated without changing the model's
performance on the task; faithfulness is what justifies studying circuits,
rather than the full model. Our experiments demonstrate that circuits found
using EAP are less faithful than those found using EAP-IG, even though both
have high node overlap with circuits found previously using causal
interventions. We conclude more generally that when using circuits to compare
the mechanisms models use to solve tasks, faithfulness, not overlap, is what
should be measured.
|
[
-0.46894851326942444,
-0.7617405652999878,
0.7857770919799805,
0.4363841414451599,
-0.07392268627882004,
0.24517305195331573,
0.01658126711845398,
-0.6713399291038513,
0.32794785499572754,
0.49370822310447693,
-0.8235398530960083,
-0.1682627946138382,
-0.5357075929641724,
-0.2826440632343292,
-0.3598865568637848,
0.580109715461731,
-0.4221951961517334,
0.157118558883667,
-0.2568828761577606,
-0.23923082649707794,
0.08585041761398315,
-0.14142918586730957,
-0.4560222029685974,
-0.9620447158813477,
0.37561899423599243,
0.11938412487506866,
0.7898203134536743,
0.9450169801712036,
0.7400991320610046,
0.32585906982421875,
-0.07484738528728485,
0.4265054762363434,
0.003534917486831546,
-0.13133814930915833,
-0.46731290221214294,
-0.5905870795249939,
-0.510287880897522,
0.2655622661113739,
0.5253636240959167,
0.7364638447761536,
-0.007721577771008015,
0.07349488884210587,
0.41994553804397583,
0.6606160998344421,
-0.7392823100090027,
-0.07643895596265793,
-0.7586890459060669,
-0.15335173904895782,
-0.22771809995174408,
-0.21873831748962402,
-0.3278234004974365,
-0.415877103805542,
-0.33972054719924927,
-0.4779221713542938,
0.1932993084192276,
-0.1766965687274933,
1.048275351524353,
0.1476154625415802,
-0.21381482481956482,
-0.22638916969299316,
-0.6705941557884216,
0.778093159198761,
-0.7068948149681091,
0.5127292275428772,
0.5657987594604492,
-0.07094395905733109,
-0.3588138222694397,
-0.8676440119743347,
-0.42511776089668274,
-0.1350080817937851,
-0.08993632346391678,
-0.0946187898516655,
-0.23101644217967987,
0.5545635223388672,
0.441017210483551,
0.4422142803668976,
-0.007143739145249128,
-0.06615956872701645,
-0.059688497334718704,
-0.2744387686252594,
0.37464582920074463,
0.08224080502986908,
0.4666576385498047,
0.08807259798049927,
-0.43579167127609253,
0.16640397906303406,
-0.9911025166511536,
0.33521828055381775,
0.6704652309417725,
0.043989039957523346,
0.27910560369491577,
0.5937663316726685,
0.010760544799268246,
0.5679464936256409,
0.1519799530506134,
0.24707455933094025,
-0.07339292764663696,
-0.4406060576438904,
-0.2169462889432907,
-0.15692153573036194,
0.599089503288269,
0.26372504234313965,
0.4005271792411804,
-0.22088441252708435,
-0.27021223306655884,
0.13239270448684692,
0.3864237368106842,
-0.4274595379829407,
-0.3661595284938812,
0.12980151176452637,
-0.5440276265144348,
-0.18482166528701782,
0.11856137216091156,
-0.32133805751800537,
0.08252003788948059,
-0.3437611758708954,
0.2914433479309082,
-0.4678248167037964,
-0.14608682692050934,
0.01425106730312109,
0.04409961774945259,
0.05973658710718155,
0.18901117146015167,
-0.9317695498466492,
0.8560031056404114,
0.9831668734550476,
1.1036659479141235,
0.018158478662371635,
-0.6462621092796326,
-0.8636540770530701,
0.05446618050336838,
-0.3299391269683838,
0.7144520878791809,
-0.6293076872825623,
-0.2645561993122101,
0.04771272465586662,
0.22722867131233215,
-0.1626819521188736,
-0.44172927737236023,
0.742164671421051,
-0.5583285689353943,
-0.37004730105400085,
-0.7231429815292358,
-0.6432459950447083,
0.02042836882174015,
0.21955373883247375,
-0.7544570565223694,
0.9984868168830872,
0.04997441917657852,
-0.7950577139854431,
0.2986886501312256,
-0.6221663951873779,
-0.3110201060771942,
-0.33755311369895935,
-0.12207014113664627,
-0.507250189781189,
0.3368457555770874,
0.2519403398036957,
0.054951999336481094,
0.18730132281780243,
0.08783114701509476,
-0.7010467648506165,
-0.5054754018783569,
0.4410960376262665,
-0.6452287435531616,
0.9240657687187195,
-0.055860862135887146,
-0.42138147354125977,
-0.04787496104836464,
-0.5281372666358948,
0.36150357127189636,
-0.2946312129497528,
0.014828928746283054,
-0.4799022674560547,
0.3007025420665741,
0.10392975062131882,
0.2646934390068054,
0.08990424871444702,
-0.8698508739471436,
0.279177188873291,
-0.6483298540115356,
0.5161303877830505,
1.0950528383255005,
-0.011596894823014736,
0.4581944942474365,
-0.5525866746902466,
0.3615708351135254,
-0.25589892268180847,
0.3763624429702759,
-0.1408531665802002,
-0.567367434501648,
-0.6857845783233643,
-0.22478756308555603,
0.2129332572221756,
0.3266550302505493,
-0.6621951460838318,
0.3350653350353241,
-0.24203842878341675,
-0.27648070454597473,
-0.4458305239677429,
0.10740220546722412,
0.6365835666656494,
0.3100925385951996,
0.42311322689056396,
-0.4849417209625244,
-0.14355623722076416,
-1.1708838939666748,
-0.9030202031135559,
-0.47852441668510437,
-0.03860672935843468,
0.24907927215099335,
0.4292083978652954,
-0.01743549294769764,
0.9872891902923584,
-0.3686721920967102,
-0.16639581322669983,
0.06295298784971237,
0.27851104736328125,
0.14552488923072815,
0.7483620643615723,
0.30014875531196594,
-0.4082697927951813,
-0.6301892399787903,
0.10693241655826569,
-0.5522366166114807,
-0.20247365534305573,
-0.05825142562389374,
-0.13668344914913177,
-0.10854261368513107,
0.631086528301239,
-0.5537450313568115,
0.5189548134803772,
0.5532545447349548,
-0.1813279390335083,
0.16764593124389648,
-0.13318388164043427,
0.41138070821762085,
-0.515357255935669,
-0.21655064821243286,
0.007350624538958073,
-0.5051541924476624,
-0.761134147644043,
0.38167646527290344,
0.34064149856567383,
0.33704110980033875,
-0.2525005340576172,
0.5902010202407837,
-0.5558642148971558,
-0.0055401939898729324,
-0.30038532614707947,
-0.21468712389469147,
0.21639268100261688,
0.4045804738998413,
-0.2053561955690384,
0.7266252040863037,
0.39053383469581604,
-0.18895907700061798,
0.021208835765719414,
0.08957026898860931,
-0.15062232315540314,
0.538862943649292,
-0.616948127746582,
0.24609780311584473,
0.21684935688972473,
-0.047633253037929535,
-0.7687151432037354,
-0.020189868286252022,
0.2912102937698364,
-0.3827187120914459,
0.37704333662986755,
-0.30432233214378357,
-0.43006476759910583,
-0.08471133559942245,
-0.5282453894615173,
0.7256833910942078,
0.5947849750518799,
-0.7447277307510376,
0.9247876405715942,
0.024596983566880226,
-0.0061869267374277115,
-0.6240414381027222,
-0.8703601956367493,
-0.11327828466892242,
0.037331726402044296,
-1.004506230354309,
0.6063761711120605,
0.15660881996154785,
-0.5141254663467407,
0.05182656645774841,
-0.26750779151916504,
-0.3233286738395691,
0.0073830983601510525,
0.2925330400466919,
0.08334419876337051,
-0.15797840058803558,
-0.017698723822832108,
0.28711411356925964,
-0.10619986057281494,
0.35544902086257935,
-0.1857796162366867,
0.31936734914779663,
-0.21493850648403168,
-1.1222468614578247,
-0.42640191316604614,
0.38740965723991394,
0.4381767213344574,
-0.2939082384109497,
0.5505807399749756,
0.29605624079704285,
-0.5076885223388672,
-0.1673968881368637,
-0.7800859808921814,
-0.40188032388687134,
-0.5791157484054565,
0.054824892431497574,
-0.40369024872779846,
-0.5455856919288635,
0.8802192807197571,
-0.19420522451400757,
0.15055516362190247,
0.2548724412918091,
0.048179108649492264,
-0.19422510266304016,
0.9635015726089478,
0.7417314648628235,
-0.07226090133190155,
0.6391459107398987,
0.13410629332065582,
0.19413982331752777,
-1.0801641941070557,
-0.09375111758708954,
-0.36911627650260925,
-0.34692487120628357,
-0.4390476644039154,
-0.43704938888549805,
0.1708400398492813,
0.4199584424495697,
-0.11688444018363953,
0.04201129078865051,
-0.23726864159107208,
0.5226502418518066,
0.4870154559612274,
0.5283413529396057,
0.5789588093757629,
0.2344713658094406,
0.0700988844037056,
-0.38304603099823,
-0.6844193339347839,
-0.24590036273002625,
0.9442624449729919,
0.5476521253585815,
0.8108029365539551,
-0.17532037198543549,
0.6351962685585022,
0.151187002658844,
0.6053609848022461,
-0.48561587929725647,
0.2516162097454071,
0.08292020857334137,
-0.35338935256004333,
-0.23404838144779205,
-0.36262160539627075,
-0.6821186542510986,
0.002450574655085802,
0.06804211437702179,
-1.0562262535095215,
0.4043487310409546,
0.5873205065727234,
0.05443772301077843,
0.6413357257843018,
-0.27104905247688293,
0.532795250415802,
-0.016712119802832603,
-0.7078493237495422,
-0.1727321296930313,
-0.3800997734069824,
0.4555477499961853,
0.17013207077980042,
0.2658718228340149,
0.15721659362316132,
0.12067297101020813,
0.4633956849575043,
-0.8133471608161926,
0.6164090037345886,
0.018826300278306007,
-0.021012237295508385,
0.33375298976898193,
0.18892207741737366,
1.2260345220565796,
-0.005631269887089729,
0.17560993134975433,
0.26499855518341064,
-0.3423857092857361,
-0.5420787334442139,
-0.921464204788208,
0.7551709413528442,
-0.3413710296154022,
-0.5729969143867493,
-0.23366418480873108,
-0.49461624026298523,
-0.28643128275871277,
-0.01931190863251686,
0.395141065120697,
0.618093729019165,
-0.09937933087348938,
-0.14330729842185974,
1.013824462890625,
0.17842358350753784,
0.4267694354057312,
0.2149379551410675,
-0.26072242856025696,
-0.17618660628795624,
0.8337050080299377,
0.03144746273756027,
0.7781497836112976,
-0.03233104199171066,
-0.16939029097557068,
-0.06954505294561386,
-0.46860620379447937,
-0.44193896651268005,
0.27970680594444275,
-0.7468823790550232,
0.04355107992887497,
-0.752321720123291,
-0.3705369532108307,
0.12700152397155762,
-0.3960074782371521,
-0.9135806560516357,
-0.30013522505760193,
0.02883814089000225,
0.002579065039753914,
0.22860561311244965,
0.5129549503326416,
-0.2333638072013855,
0.2728129029273987,
-0.8376076221466064,
0.2371828556060791,
0.2650434076786041,
0.7333282232284546,
0.019055090844631195,
-0.47544431686401367,
-0.24819079041481018,
0.2293960303068161,
-0.41580426692962646,
-0.9345154166221619,
-0.09769117832183838,
0.15089794993400574,
0.6305863261222839,
0.33067184686660767,
-0.2769818603992462,
0.8488739132881165,
-0.5866634249687195,
0.5771183967590332,
0.2746672034263611,
-1.5225881338119507,
0.3007815182209015,
-0.409913569688797,
0.12916886806488037,
0.717613697052002,
0.16104663908481598,
-0.32814860343933105,
-0.7113396525382996,
-0.8228123188018799,
-0.8035510182380676,
0.3830117881298065,
0.7371910810470581,
0.0609765499830246,
0.1826019436120987,
0.5299164056777954,
-0.30072879791259766,
0.060056693851947784,
-0.9169765114784241,
-0.32432931661605835,
-0.10086536407470703,
-0.22341787815093994,
0.3954204022884369,
-0.06250494718551636,
-0.41913920640945435,
-0.043781913816928864,
0.6082552671432495,
-0.2809402644634247,
0.2807849645614624,
0.41440650820732117,
0.009564951062202454,
-0.5634806156158447,
0.06243985518813133,
0.3643515706062317,
0.8984077572822571,
-0.020818382501602173,
0.24554888904094696,
0.016687093302607536,
-0.5305179357528687,
0.17949797213077545,
0.020187923684716225,
-0.13769376277923584,
0.23164744675159454,
0.9353169798851013,
0.324305921792984,
-0.05257422849535942,
-0.4400129020214081,
0.6841253638267517,
0.12192071229219437,
-0.18342667818069458,
0.0015791798941791058,
0.03596270829439163,
-0.06905867159366608,
0.3952583372592926,
0.05734248086810112,
0.40037235617637634,
0.47064992785453796,
-0.6094932556152344,
0.4615885317325592,
0.9062672257423401,
-1.0455213785171509,
-0.20352686941623688,
0.5562963485717773,
-0.08590757101774216,
-0.555638313293457,
0.8704337477684021,
0.011942371726036072,
-0.7682269215583801,
0.8390244841575623,
0.24823284149169922,
0.9749924540519714,
-0.42373722791671753,
0.10938799381256104,
0.08455855399370193,
0.7772347927093506,
-0.4693971574306488,
0.2870911657810211,
0.12034538388252258,
-0.6584402918815613,
-0.6797590255737305,
-0.3138205111026764,
-0.2607145607471466,
-0.06362947821617126,
-0.9377050399780273,
0.14990048110485077,
-0.3002179265022278,
-0.02796757221221924,
-0.24214504659175873,
-0.35795310139656067,
-0.30946946144104004,
0.13341431319713593,
-0.45899853110313416,
1.1253522634506226,
-1.197862148284912,
0.8412162661552429,
0.38469675183296204,
-0.1830965131521225,
-0.7841750383377075,
0.2490445077419281,
-0.23182499408721924,
-0.7557592988014221,
0.2839006781578064,
-0.008475866168737411,
-0.24383091926574707,
-0.2180536985397339,
-0.5910381078720093,
-0.6795176267623901,
0.880863606929779,
0.4034437835216522,
-0.6191336512565613,
0.1402454823255539,
-0.01436921488493681,
0.3236840069293976,
-0.11897572129964828,
0.22621536254882812,
0.4192563593387604,
0.5744191408157349,
-0.08331795036792755,
-0.9813644886016846,
0.2206479161977768,
-0.41873934864997864,
-0.273005872964859,
0.5812317728996277,
-0.5437007546424866,
0.962225079536438,
0.028735626488924026,
-0.0403234101831913,
0.0908949002623558,
0.6270359754562378,
0.40135565400123596,
0.5178102254867554,
0.6347278356552124,
0.3327162563800812,
0.5990813970565796,
-0.14968253672122955,
1.0324124097824097,
-0.36371666193008423,
0.5123340487480164,
1.0555391311645508,
0.08255478739738464,
0.42205995321273804,
0.972969651222229,
-0.329266220331192,
0.4549156129360199,
0.6115841865539551,
0.09035471826791763,
0.5352422595024109,
0.24109460413455963,
-0.1641433984041214,
-0.3925017714500427,
-0.12187568843364716,
-0.360086590051651,
-0.17569448053836823,
0.1112445592880249,
-0.601219892501831,
-0.0684194266796112,
-0.22211763262748718,
-0.022557027637958527,
0.3350425660610199,
-0.5170093774795532,
0.3584311306476593,
0.33146050572395325,
-0.6393279433250427,
0.13666920363903046,
0.09085047245025635,
0.3142905533313751,
-0.7046704292297363,
-0.4194622337818146,
-0.21259652078151703,
0.07199937850236893,
-0.42025047540664673,
-0.7789201736450195,
0.5354605913162231,
-0.4670031666755676,
-0.27293428778648376,
-0.2210524082183838,
0.8238819241523743,
-0.37849894165992737,
-0.5663853883743286,
0.48077112436294556,
0.468736857175827,
-0.2456933856010437,
-0.20549829304218292,
-0.4949871897697449,
0.09576099365949631,
0.01376180350780487,
-0.4101916551589966,
0.2782127559185028,
0.2845635712146759,
-0.2504843473434448,
0.7553431987762451,
0.5360051393508911,
0.29216405749320984,
-0.017221957445144653,
-0.16226446628570557,
1.2166317701339722,
-0.46403107047080994,
-0.3103051781654358,
-1.2395405769348145,
0.604956865310669,
-0.23704002797603607,
-0.10268763452768326,
0.7426539063453674,
0.4296248257160187,
0.6714057326316833,
0.3853289484977722,
0.6951324939727783,
0.3573977053165436,
-0.11174166947603226,
-0.9061739444732666,
0.3514835834503174,
-0.618854820728302,
0.5561225414276123,
-0.5052297711372375,
-1.085262417793274,
-0.0037588125560432673,
0.5304747819900513,
-0.03226824104785919,
0.08231013268232346,
0.8339425921440125,
0.77205491065979,
-0.7347396016120911,
0.0909760370850563,
0.10018404573202133,
0.08898837864398956,
0.342560738325119,
0.43877655267715454,
0.8501157164573669,
-0.48585018515586853,
0.08446310460567474,
-0.2732081413269043,
-0.38497430086135864,
0.22721968591213226,
-0.920936644077301,
-0.9181666374206543,
-0.33296921849250793,
-0.09923733025789261,
-0.6101688146591187,
0.24147917330265045,
0.7921556830406189,
0.43742838501930237,
-0.40922385454177856,
-0.04983920603990555,
-0.7359083294868469,
0.42563527822494507,
-0.5709888935089111,
-0.1618732213973999,
0.4076741933822632,
-0.25555169582366943,
-0.6022510528564453,
0.16694492101669312,
0.49060457944869995,
-0.19085122644901276,
-0.499936580657959,
-0.02323455736041069,
-0.0444558784365654,
0.3986455202102661,
0.056346096098423004,
0.1864764392375946,
-0.7488565444946289,
-0.49609848856925964,
0.10048752278089523,
0.05405342951416969,
0.18518757820129395,
1.216679573059082,
-0.3989773094654083,
0.38666394352912903,
0.38810184597969055,
0.683360755443573,
0.5114219784736633,
0.052743133157491684,
0.918171226978302,
-0.5025037527084351,
-0.09114992618560791,
-0.026256831362843513,
0.3817347586154938,
0.13195718824863434,
-0.4967350363731384,
0.4885333776473999,
0.24066142737865448,
-0.5787506699562073,
-1.0022996664047241,
0.8037019968032837,
-0.724175214767456,
-0.26847410202026367,
0.9002774953842163,
-0.6075679659843445,
-0.2265305072069168,
-0.3769330084323883,
0.2503102421760559,
0.0030515992548316717,
-0.05221182107925415,
0.7962771058082581,
0.8645296096801758,
-0.41254326701164246,
-0.0385713092982769,
-0.334629088640213,
0.6393795609474182,
0.4943069815635681,
-0.614811360836029,
0.04983118548989296,
0.029050840064883232,
0.21483494341373444,
0.3516331613063812,
0.8475393056869507,
0.01880873553454876,
0.3839128315448761,
0.16175350546836853,
-0.14874935150146484,
-0.22650596499443054,
-0.39257240295410156,
-0.2764091491699219,
0.07603202760219574,
0.2098790407180786,
0.09470801055431366
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17804v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17804v1
|
Improving Text-to-Image Consistency via Automatic Prompt Optimization
| 2024-03-26T15:42:01 | 2024-03-26T15:42:01 |
Oscar Mañas, Pietro Astolfi, Melissa Hall, Candace Ross, Jack Urbanek, Adina Williams, Aishwarya Agrawal, Adriana Romero-Soriano, Michal Drozdzal
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Impressive advances in text-to-image (T2I) generative models have yielded a
plethora of high performing models which are able to generate aesthetically
appealing, photorealistic images. Despite the progress, these models still
struggle to produce images that are consistent with the input prompt,
oftentimes failing to capture object quantities, relations and attributes
properly. Existing solutions to improve prompt-image consistency suffer from
the following challenges: (1) they oftentimes require model fine-tuning, (2)
they only focus on nearby prompt samples, and (3) they are affected by
unfavorable trade-offs among image quality, representation diversity, and
prompt-image consistency. In this paper, we address these challenges and
introduce a T2I optimization-by-prompting framework, OPT2I, which leverages a
large language model (LLM) to improve prompt-image consistency in T2I models.
Our framework starts from a user prompt and iteratively generates revised
prompts with the goal of maximizing a consistency score. Our extensive
validation on two datasets, MSCOCO and PartiPrompts, shows that OPT2I can boost
the initial consistency score by up to 24.9% in terms of DSG score while
preserving the FID and increasing the recall between generated and real data.
Our work paves the way toward building more reliable and robust T2I systems by
harnessing the power of LLMs.
|
[
-0.16078047454357147,
-0.48523297905921936,
0.7720200419425964,
0.31436797976493835,
-0.3334744870662689,
-0.11597812920808792,
-0.39483484625816345,
-0.24477554857730865,
-0.15555499494075775,
0.07606809586286545,
-0.603874921798706,
-0.4959283471107483,
-0.5762339234352112,
0.5301189422607422,
0.11753400415182114,
0.5506232976913452,
-0.20259028673171997,
-0.07029138505458832,
-0.3576487600803375,
-0.13209061324596405,
-0.8596768975257874,
0.20237794518470764,
-1.177668571472168,
-0.062126222997903824,
0.4269142746925354,
0.5803546905517578,
0.8470290899276733,
0.8136167526245117,
0.14342749118804932,
0.131185382604599,
-0.020111050456762314,
0.5905099511146545,
-0.5509095788002014,
0.35541802644729614,
-0.0442035086452961,
-0.3513970673084259,
0.008230156265199184,
-0.23947042226791382,
0.747494101524353,
0.32655295729637146,
0.09760989993810654,
-0.2815600633621216,
0.2695026993751526,
0.5259026288986206,
-0.5531101822853088,
0.13603757321834564,
-0.41222047805786133,
-0.025044018402695656,
0.10077457875013351,
-0.3920361399650574,
-0.5555534362792969,
-0.49734100699424744,
-0.10637258738279343,
-0.8091897368431091,
0.13201433420181274,
0.08005379885435104,
1.057066798210144,
0.49901556968688965,
-0.38856589794158936,
-0.10414446145296097,
-0.4524860084056854,
0.8384043574333191,
-0.5072203874588013,
0.271629273891449,
0.43505531549453735,
0.1542627364397049,
-0.2849386930465698,
-0.28049400448799133,
-0.4399016797542572,
-0.18571151793003082,
0.06556247174739838,
0.3225083351135254,
-0.3658728301525116,
-0.08187884837388992,
0.20159032940864563,
-0.08121149986982346,
-0.5425442457199097,
0.38730764389038086,
0.10451716184616089,
-0.2741169035434723,
0.37205183506011963,
0.20281200110912323,
0.3783402442932129,
-0.07361656427383423,
-0.24489843845367432,
-0.2268003225326538,
-0.7692899703979492,
0.14734932780265808,
0.33480411767959595,
0.11344251036643982,
0.03307461738586426,
0.6451845169067383,
0.08317337930202484,
0.7173905968666077,
0.31050464510917664,
-0.11213978379964828,
0.1168760359287262,
-0.5402961373329163,
0.2900467813014984,
-0.18786661326885223,
0.8906697034835815,
0.9675114750862122,
0.2974019944667816,
-0.1806192845106125,
-0.4443739056587219,
0.1819031983613968,
0.01959827169775963,
-0.8155276775360107,
-0.11468948423862457,
0.2549118995666504,
-0.4616011381149292,
-0.3630025088787079,
-0.03982158005237579,
-0.7373597621917725,
-0.36259889602661133,
-0.4051551818847656,
0.44726213812828064,
-0.4884638488292694,
-0.06968872994184494,
-0.18037980794906616,
-0.20500044524669647,
0.11727324873209,
0.6482434272766113,
-0.9194867610931396,
-0.11381754279136658,
0.5486576557159424,
1.0722362995147705,
-0.30437418818473816,
-0.025605130940675735,
-0.7782381772994995,
0.10734885931015015,
-0.7665266394615173,
0.8781066536903381,
-0.47824886441230774,
-0.6184948086738586,
0.06986752897500992,
-0.1502373069524765,
0.01874605379998684,
-0.6267456412315369,
0.5730420351028442,
-0.2769106328487396,
0.4152475893497467,
-0.4770062565803528,
-0.6513147950172424,
0.37398195266723633,
0.3686967194080353,
-0.5093340873718262,
1.0834318399429321,
0.11526980996131897,
-0.6203139424324036,
0.3699772357940674,
-0.3575375974178314,
-0.26417407393455505,
-0.04717640206217766,
-0.2863720655441284,
-0.7094210386276245,
0.2904994487762451,
0.3899296820163727,
0.06989140808582306,
-0.38785505294799805,
0.413957804441452,
-0.09280594438314438,
-0.48862120509147644,
0.0467805415391922,
-0.5015265345573425,
0.6173189878463745,
0.09978647530078888,
-0.23385173082351685,
0.18624553084373474,
-0.5473335981369019,
0.12667888402938843,
0.22407345473766327,
-0.18724535405635834,
-0.1015184223651886,
0.03746877238154411,
0.08595069497823715,
-0.05453460291028023,
0.35390815138816833,
-0.5790814161300659,
0.4175000488758087,
-0.012155207805335522,
0.39942997694015503,
0.7447933554649353,
0.08455967158079147,
0.4568016231060028,
-0.3834259808063507,
0.40814346075057983,
0.15158575773239136,
0.058262404054403305,
-0.7090901732444763,
-0.612540066242218,
-0.6784139275550842,
-0.19167864322662354,
0.18428370356559753,
0.6964755058288574,
-0.9047187566757202,
0.6020135283470154,
-0.28572162985801697,
-0.28988179564476013,
-0.4432273507118225,
-0.06521038711071014,
0.18155692517757416,
0.8579806089401245,
0.24355559051036835,
-0.12351813167333603,
-0.2047325223684311,
-0.9039527177810669,
-0.13462947309017181,
-0.23121389746665955,
-0.31000572443008423,
0.49713557958602905,
0.08960141241550446,
-0.3629663288593292,
1.080670952796936,
-0.4708283245563507,
-0.32191503047943115,
-0.03536001220345497,
0.275126576423645,
0.10477294772863388,
0.7708957195281982,
0.5990050435066223,
-0.6186873316764832,
-0.4884873330593109,
-0.22138912975788116,
-0.7096034288406372,
-0.3359319865703583,
-0.4029480516910553,
-0.22946393489837646,
0.317757248878479,
0.3922862708568573,
-0.5890940427780151,
0.25138890743255615,
0.21738691627979279,
-0.4349685311317444,
0.5554038882255554,
-0.4648842215538025,
0.4236365556716919,
-1.310621976852417,
0.052648115903139114,
0.28005772829055786,
-0.28362134099006653,
-0.44973546266555786,
-0.2979710102081299,
0.3329334259033203,
-0.2897513210773468,
-0.0180814266204834,
0.7901777625083923,
-0.4247318208217621,
0.13458895683288574,
-0.35024747252464294,
-0.16329219937324524,
0.33779382705688477,
0.24819518625736237,
0.04166942834854126,
1.3027749061584473,
0.8677923083305359,
-0.44854453206062317,
0.19581101834774017,
0.46219736337661743,
-0.07128878682851791,
0.9904239177703857,
-0.9970712065696716,
0.403229683637619,
-0.34392812848091125,
0.22518247365951538,
-1.2017756700515747,
-0.48756706714630127,
0.37937480211257935,
-0.39577221870422363,
0.5997493267059326,
-0.013624225743114948,
-0.7253370881080627,
-0.10194335132837296,
-0.4426952302455902,
0.6166552305221558,
0.8462373614311218,
-0.7694747447967529,
0.717700183391571,
-0.14257051050662994,
-0.09721668064594269,
-0.4028777480125427,
-0.4324154555797577,
0.45159605145454407,
0.04682813957333565,
-0.7862105369567871,
0.4573763310909271,
-0.12093144655227661,
0.09501151740550995,
-0.08639686554670334,
0.007533449213951826,
0.08276782929897308,
-0.13629861176013947,
0.036866992712020874,
0.4062131643295288,
-0.1386992186307907,
0.222142294049263,
0.23371142148971558,
-0.290113627910614,
-0.18079687654972076,
-0.5764477849006653,
0.26525551080703735,
0.20608815550804138,
-0.25172266364097595,
-0.9882732033729553,
0.516995906829834,
0.35818225145339966,
-0.09169626235961914,
0.4302823841571808,
0.4362073242664337,
-0.34919366240501404,
-0.01029778178781271,
-0.4710738956928253,
-0.2231195867061615,
-0.47604453563690186,
0.36079034209251404,
-0.46642500162124634,
-0.6740971207618713,
0.4171430766582489,
-0.17812500894069672,
0.18194237351417542,
0.2625345289707184,
0.20961016416549683,
-0.40021687746047974,
1.22572660446167,
0.5863319039344788,
0.15999212861061096,
0.6458742022514343,
0.02025718428194523,
-0.07506993412971497,
-0.6253278255462646,
-0.34836187958717346,
-0.47005704045295715,
-0.1445447951555252,
-0.23116926848888397,
-0.40841126441955566,
0.6092959642410278,
0.029253704473376274,
-0.1728588193655014,
0.1937650740146637,
-0.3839837908744812,
0.6846227645874023,
0.6431832313537598,
0.45799678564071655,
0.13967405259609222,
0.35713890194892883,
0.04686356335878372,
-0.28477296233177185,
-0.6944306492805481,
-0.6444512009620667,
0.7467163801193237,
0.27853935956954956,
0.7427154779434204,
-0.08085545897483826,
0.6225436925888062,
0.22709175944328308,
-0.08149363845586777,
-0.7236866354942322,
0.6306610107421875,
-0.3177509903907776,
0.04862317070364952,
-0.034737080335617065,
-0.5105909705162048,
-0.8953142762184143,
-0.2362946718931198,
-0.30518513917922974,
-0.5747020840644836,
0.3636768162250519,
0.5477856397628784,
-0.2249942421913147,
0.07606576383113861,
-0.7409612536430359,
0.9178618788719177,
-0.1435159295797348,
-0.6595744490623474,
0.12989595532417297,
-0.6840808987617493,
-0.05602487921714783,
0.10193286836147308,
-0.39047771692276,
-0.004545867443084717,
-0.35162079334259033,
0.29415398836135864,
-0.3971627950668335,
0.7987174391746521,
-0.17553730309009552,
-0.272561252117157,
0.23154586553573608,
0.02743171527981758,
0.7437742948532104,
-0.044618867337703705,
-0.1680441051721573,
0.13944153487682343,
-0.4052577316761017,
-0.6277773380279541,
-0.8346652984619141,
0.5186700820922852,
-0.8072026371955872,
-0.4423598349094391,
0.00008552625513402745,
-0.41212695837020874,
-0.1666528582572937,
0.06887511163949966,
0.7656733393669128,
0.718824028968811,
-0.17342212796211243,
-0.20612114667892456,
1.0614627599716187,
-0.26141107082366943,
0.5264970660209656,
-0.18258395791053772,
0.16171292960643768,
-0.6375728249549866,
0.9435774683952332,
-0.23410232365131378,
0.2784493863582611,
0.3041403591632843,
0.016152966767549515,
-0.6178879737854004,
-0.418450266122818,
-0.8251432776451111,
0.1988232284784317,
-0.7129886150360107,
-0.43563640117645264,
-0.4775015413761139,
0.12238772958517075,
-0.34751343727111816,
-0.3098239004611969,
-0.32219651341438293,
-0.15387172996997833,
-0.9720818996429443,
0.32020828127861023,
0.30250540375709534,
0.4449332654476166,
0.1902671903371811,
0.2739562690258026,
-0.737529456615448,
0.29348671436309814,
0.14676550030708313,
0.4501907527446747,
-0.13008850812911987,
-0.7209378480911255,
0.2551749050617218,
-0.08587873727083206,
-0.18408550322055817,
-0.8111370801925659,
0.04630072042346001,
0.39452365040779114,
0.2753704786300659,
0.5229512453079224,
0.1577129364013672,
0.5710824131965637,
-0.5504122972488403,
0.7439785003662109,
0.5254793763160706,
-0.8973001837730408,
0.8714412450790405,
-0.47421330213546753,
0.5812440514564514,
0.5629838705062866,
0.08557514101266861,
-0.5655632019042969,
-0.37352296710014343,
-0.2955443859100342,
-0.7587304711341858,
0.5744695663452148,
0.3087051808834076,
0.2075146734714508,
-0.034923821687698364,
0.604200005531311,
0.11945071071386337,
0.018143313005566597,
-0.4982171654701233,
0.08900006860494614,
-0.4052545130252838,
-0.8696257472038269,
0.09266345947980881,
-0.5114795565605164,
-0.04782295972108841,
0.16809499263763428,
0.47574397921562195,
-0.44082412123680115,
0.2518673837184906,
0.21542015671730042,
0.07509227842092514,
-0.34055018424987793,
0.14638902246952057,
0.7303186058998108,
0.38597601652145386,
0.24932478368282318,
0.02869543805718422,
-0.14142166078090668,
-0.2821846604347229,
0.40105879306793213,
-0.01577072963118553,
-0.7610347867012024,
0.051003485918045044,
0.2747226059436798,
1.1548410654067993,
-0.15466177463531494,
-0.7721876502037048,
0.6254900097846985,
-0.08441854268312454,
-0.08332838118076324,
-0.185243159532547,
0.2586064040660858,
-0.2546289265155792,
0.2545102536678314,
0.5015965104103088,
0.5065728425979614,
-0.06362591683864594,
-0.2432565838098526,
0.047147221863269806,
0.44518372416496277,
-0.21007810533046722,
-0.16856324672698975,
0.8380948305130005,
0.2731155753135681,
-0.441275030374527,
0.8469348549842834,
-0.27945733070373535,
-0.43175920844078064,
0.6856043338775635,
0.6804696321487427,
0.8860334753990173,
0.025597231462597847,
0.22570160031318665,
0.6778616905212402,
0.216050386428833,
-0.4844118654727936,
0.31798097491264343,
0.03140158951282501,
-0.5798030495643616,
-0.0040411194786429405,
-0.09319610148668289,
-0.49545758962631226,
-0.36012589931488037,
-0.3194136321544647,
0.5911591649055481,
-0.4338156282901764,
-0.3428742587566376,
-0.2958342730998993,
-0.200968399643898,
-0.32138246297836304,
0.22066687047481537,
0.1519429087638855,
0.8476389646530151,
-0.7890087962150574,
0.48489075899124146,
0.6729922890663147,
-0.26573362946510315,
-0.8269121050834656,
0.2427913099527359,
-0.05452686548233032,
-0.5971482396125793,
0.2829608917236328,
0.5450089573860168,
-0.031060831621289253,
0.3054176867008209,
-0.7467067837715149,
-0.6142675280570984,
1.1204720735549927,
0.5045433044433594,
-0.8562411069869995,
0.09579720348119736,
-0.048061396926641464,
0.40591666102409363,
-0.5182912349700928,
0.3494471311569214,
0.3090483844280243,
0.4978718161582947,
0.4112186133861542,
-0.5453144311904907,
0.17499083280563354,
-0.30052322149276733,
0.46022942662239075,
0.12010853737592697,
-0.4755440354347229,
0.28821301460266113,
-0.707578718662262,
-0.41328415274620056,
0.5630534291267395,
0.7658798694610596,
0.4770020842552185,
0.5233086943626404,
0.6542556881904602,
0.6234720349311829,
0.8072128295898438,
-0.3787473440170288,
1.0049092769622803,
-0.22484031319618225,
0.14879731833934784,
0.8050522804260254,
-0.18271882832050323,
0.6039729118347168,
0.4314175546169281,
0.19160065054893494,
0.057241931557655334,
1.0068050622940063,
-0.5214546322822571,
0.5726763606071472,
-0.299468994140625,
-0.30216607451438904,
-0.3522186577320099,
-0.47174742817878723,
-0.08301329612731934,
0.009242314845323563,
-0.13678587973117828,
-0.37852469086647034,
-0.2380651980638504,
0.12874217331409454,
-0.174617201089859,
0.28483426570892334,
-0.24085953831672668,
0.8127574324607849,
-0.308710515499115,
-0.9705045223236084,
0.5391315221786499,
-0.10639136284589767,
0.6950182318687439,
-0.31533151865005493,
-0.07234668731689453,
-0.39099472761154175,
-0.14106912910938263,
-0.10313946008682251,
-0.8690940141677856,
0.034756358712911606,
0.10923616588115692,
-0.41993236541748047,
-0.24218735098838806,
0.6910779476165771,
-0.8157696723937988,
-0.34901511669158936,
-0.10536683350801468,
0.11929018050432205,
-0.03687293827533722,
0.10967499762773514,
-0.5128012895584106,
0.31951287388801575,
0.06967157125473022,
0.009322570636868477,
-0.03638872504234314,
0.46861371397972107,
0.05888165533542633,
0.45039477944374084,
0.4173911511898041,
-0.1256738156080246,
-0.295174777507782,
0.21506495773792267,
0.6839035749435425,
-0.40253517031669617,
-0.445977121591568,
-0.8517332673072815,
0.45505276322364807,
-0.24179676175117493,
-0.47033989429473877,
0.22189554572105408,
0.5450663566589355,
0.33864355087280273,
-0.14124982059001923,
0.5192887783050537,
0.15287959575653076,
0.07288238406181335,
-0.6418315768241882,
0.5790307521820068,
-0.7144929766654968,
0.09168343991041183,
-0.14884009957313538,
-1.0779609680175781,
-0.26788005232810974,
0.4291553795337677,
-0.0022296253591775894,
0.06238566339015961,
0.45751768350601196,
1.0171055793762207,
0.00883069820702076,
-0.15008322894573212,
0.25605475902557373,
-0.02056068740785122,
0.3549576699733734,
0.5148483514785767,
0.7889177203178406,
-0.49878525733947754,
0.4109652042388916,
0.12694908678531647,
-0.329942524433136,
-0.10219968855381012,
-1.042738676071167,
-0.8008043766021729,
-0.43019968271255493,
-0.7371776103973389,
-0.48487117886543274,
0.1829598844051361,
1.0135513544082642,
0.5511694550514221,
-0.6348919868469238,
0.12619242072105408,
-0.4287564158439636,
-0.13105499744415283,
-0.06549574434757233,
-0.1829136610031128,
0.295680433511734,
-0.5908716917037964,
-0.9233068227767944,
0.1736379861831665,
0.5590628385543823,
0.6336390376091003,
0.18253454566001892,
-0.14632177352905273,
0.3954172134399414,
0.18216700851917267,
0.31771615147590637,
0.25220441818237305,
-0.6957745552062988,
-0.1525166779756546,
0.2751215398311615,
-0.43582233786582947,
0.3812675476074219,
0.5978663563728333,
-0.5493765473365784,
0.6027429699897766,
0.31203165650367737,
0.8235917687416077,
-0.022467980161309242,
0.30698296427726746,
0.7343831062316895,
-0.8579874038696289,
-0.004044747911393642,
0.20096752047538757,
0.29819822311401367,
0.7652014493942261,
-0.5176284313201904,
0.33594661951065063,
0.24130673706531525,
-0.4737928509712219,
-0.5956816673278809,
0.4516955018043518,
-1.144505262374878,
-0.21421396732330322,
1.1841373443603516,
-0.16598884761333466,
-0.030915742740035057,
0.24215605854988098,
-0.5811685919761658,
0.18811385333538055,
-0.6375662684440613,
0.795050323009491,
0.4841853380203247,
0.07744764536619186,
-0.6024140119552612,
0.017289742827415466,
0.5415031909942627,
0.7930549383163452,
-0.8131199479103088,
-0.06787069886922836,
0.8141844272613525,
0.2634314298629761,
0.03486527130007744,
0.5749981999397278,
0.10470183193683624,
0.44332677125930786,
-0.15991050004959106,
-0.23335832357406616,
-0.06597870588302612,
-0.3594033122062683,
-0.4398758113384247,
-0.0292400773614645,
-0.04899667575955391,
-0.3119191825389862
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00693v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00693v1
|
Large Language Models for Human-Robot Interaction: Opportunities and Risks
| 2024-03-26T15:36:40 | 2024-03-26T15:36:40 |
Jesse Atuhurra
|
cs.RO
|
cs.RO, cs.CL
|
The tremendous development in large language models (LLM) has led to a new
wave of innovations and applications and yielded research results that were
initially forecast to take longer. In this work, we tap into these recent
developments and present a meta-study about the potential of large language
models if deployed in social robots. We place particular emphasis on the
applications of social robots: education, healthcare, and entertainment. Before
being deployed in social robots, we also study how these language models could
be safely trained to ``understand'' societal norms and issues, such as trust,
bias, ethics, cognition, and teamwork. We hope this study provides a
resourceful guide to other robotics researchers interested in incorporating
language models in their robots.
|
[
-0.05439304560422897,
-0.7677133083343506,
0.7178277969360352,
0.025477522984147072,
0.03301607444882393,
0.17144982516765594,
-0.18241479992866516,
-0.7987796664237976,
0.14615894854068756,
0.8525396585464478,
-0.2823185920715332,
-0.25677770376205444,
-0.8759870529174805,
-0.032170094549655914,
-0.28770771622657776,
0.45779746770858765,
0.13081064820289612,
0.15039560198783875,
-0.08691613376140594,
0.04344457760453224,
-0.1773252785205841,
-0.9868023991584778,
-0.741072952747345,
-0.5275427103042603,
0.7707172632217407,
0.36035698652267456,
1.0764029026031494,
0.3474239706993103,
0.7969469428062439,
0.4228988289833069,
-0.11913160234689713,
-0.2471914291381836,
-0.29473578929901123,
-0.02872150018811226,
-0.29243454337120056,
-0.4290753901004791,
-0.5493041276931763,
0.19519774615764618,
0.8274772763252258,
1.063193917274475,
-0.13974665105342865,
0.10882546007633209,
-0.02418934367597103,
0.5763232111930847,
-0.38721972703933716,
0.2794036567211151,
-0.38322415947914124,
0.10186998546123505,
-0.016571639105677605,
-0.02796158194541931,
-0.3731288015842438,
-0.4620436131954193,
0.25901636481285095,
-0.19805243611335754,
-0.43370771408081055,
-0.10422614961862564,
0.5530461072921753,
0.17204280197620392,
-0.6886080503463745,
-0.46502524614334106,
-0.9627914428710938,
0.656213104724884,
-0.6640880703926086,
0.24078822135925293,
0.31967130303382874,
0.6255816221237183,
-0.48375993967056274,
-0.6148108243942261,
-0.6859931945800781,
-0.47347384691238403,
0.2490023672580719,
-0.15571996569633484,
-0.11266656219959259,
0.36887773871421814,
0.19423583149909973,
-0.11985168606042862,
-0.29269078373908997,
0.349605530500412,
-0.35911011695861816,
0.09908583015203476,
0.9658843874931335,
0.3785777688026428,
0.7115666270256042,
-0.2549258768558502,
-0.12800142168998718,
-0.3569764494895935,
-0.7009642124176025,
-0.011420653201639652,
0.6642815470695496,
0.432441771030426,
-0.21184727549552917,
0.9517602920532227,
-0.0641714483499527,
0.4708494246006012,
-0.429019033908844,
-0.18176786601543427,
0.3073199689388275,
-0.25328996777534485,
-0.024489808827638626,
-0.14759233593940735,
0.7342504262924194,
0.4949830174446106,
0.6932427883148193,
-0.020205000415444374,
0.042321737855672836,
0.12367962300777435,
0.36854851245880127,
-0.4312747120857239,
0.08246377855539322,
0.06004021689295769,
-0.44497814774513245,
-0.3960224688053131,
-0.062358271330595016,
-0.6170966625213623,
-0.6942880749702454,
-0.12594430148601532,
0.4144212305545807,
-0.05632040649652481,
-0.4786074161529541,
0.683007001876831,
-0.05121780186891556,
0.2714979946613312,
0.23411183059215546,
-0.5699423551559448,
0.30469489097595215,
0.7056292295455933,
0.6228679418563843,
0.09199877083301544,
-0.27718448638916016,
-0.26164302229881287,
0.2258383333683014,
-0.37444868683815,
0.3808048367500305,
-0.5573045015335083,
-0.5274442434310913,
0.44628414511680603,
0.3567289412021637,
0.0757032185792923,
-0.31728458404541016,
0.3513418734073639,
-0.505644679069519,
-0.08937611430883408,
0.03380483761429787,
-0.2639369070529938,
-0.3310485780239105,
0.08019475638866425,
-0.689077615737915,
0.5225106477737427,
0.09013042598962784,
-0.554490864276886,
-0.04851164296269417,
-0.7692770957946777,
-0.8240662813186646,
0.03698053956031799,
0.07195872068405151,
-0.2263331413269043,
-0.205518439412117,
-0.42439594864845276,
0.8155671954154968,
-0.3103736937046051,
0.4983692169189453,
-0.5332709550857544,
-0.14345839619636536,
0.605768620967865,
-0.4131637215614319,
1.0669970512390137,
0.03586067259311676,
-0.1404125988483429,
0.20547452569007874,
-0.277319073677063,
-0.33373695611953735,
0.26898592710494995,
-0.11449970304965973,
-0.36145076155662537,
0.37567561864852905,
0.1628129780292511,
0.45653027296066284,
0.4378434121608734,
-0.3381689190864563,
-0.004036180675029755,
-0.28211262822151184,
0.5838428139686584,
0.6419721245765686,
-0.22951288521289825,
0.6690395474433899,
-0.22437140345573425,
0.8151727914810181,
-0.5845797061920166,
0.40521949529647827,
0.07730484753847122,
-0.6273180246353149,
-0.27996987104415894,
0.00809552799910307,
0.194205641746521,
0.6140950322151184,
-0.7432119846343994,
0.49817603826522827,
-0.0046705217100679874,
-0.4757630228996277,
-0.32202816009521484,
0.07698594033718109,
0.2277969866991043,
0.03454068675637245,
-0.040312908589839935,
-0.1515292227268219,
-0.4808422029018402,
-0.8252483606338501,
-0.21458232402801514,
-0.3353821933269501,
-0.09291766583919525,
0.6616142392158508,
0.5319734811782837,
-0.8837683796882629,
0.6399702429771423,
-0.4042452871799469,
0.15461593866348267,
-0.7089800834655762,
-0.12332906574010849,
-0.0687277764081955,
0.3063773512840271,
0.4435892701148987,
-0.8127074241638184,
-0.3422934412956238,
0.03772958368062973,
-0.6580823063850403,
0.17061413824558258,
0.2048536092042923,
0.014715014025568962,
0.2040065973997116,
0.5187927484512329,
-0.8320271372795105,
0.29621973633766174,
0.8615166544914246,
-0.10195837169885635,
0.24119403958320618,
-0.2718067765235901,
-0.043297022581100464,
-1.1928210258483887,
-0.0638410821557045,
0.14100845158100128,
-0.3099399507045746,
-0.733176589012146,
0.07230193167924881,
-0.16601261496543884,
-0.31560462713241577,
-0.6121808290481567,
0.7601177096366882,
-0.31629863381385803,
-0.1408766508102417,
-0.4342256486415863,
0.41288381814956665,
-0.4651569426059723,
-0.24665911495685577,
0.1908952295780182,
0.32358065247535706,
0.450944185256958,
-0.6827833652496338,
0.26724737882614136,
-0.03538557514548302,
-0.45833271741867065,
0.00784098356962204,
-0.9476777911186218,
0.15757997334003448,
0.047322023659944534,
0.46764326095581055,
-0.8359548449516296,
-0.7688774466514587,
0.3483591079711914,
-0.4729383885860443,
0.08474473655223846,
0.09854836761951447,
-0.7869240045547485,
-0.7559489011764526,
-0.24859702587127686,
0.16379034519195557,
0.542913556098938,
-0.22378113865852356,
0.6511727571487427,
1.248981237411499,
-0.24507474899291992,
-0.49890804290771484,
-0.35321611166000366,
0.1945265382528305,
-0.336806982755661,
-0.8115590810775757,
-0.03812680393457413,
0.0016316085821017623,
-0.5335355997085571,
-0.12227197736501694,
0.3656385540962219,
-0.05001188442111015,
0.528403639793396,
0.3153386116027832,
0.3505087196826935,
0.06415872275829315,
0.08247993886470795,
0.018518924713134766,
-0.2646268308162689,
0.2847411632537842,
0.28962528705596924,
0.8310855031013489,
0.030799895524978638,
-0.21995809674263,
-0.3352077007293701,
0.26744014024734497,
0.46987444162368774,
0.07970191538333893,
0.7993963360786438,
0.32193437218666077,
-0.5794332027435303,
0.2094593048095703,
-0.4014285206794739,
-0.25466692447662354,
-0.5540488958358765,
0.7476056814193726,
0.3465270400047302,
-1.1137139797210693,
0.21000578999519348,
-0.30594944953918457,
-0.025852054357528687,
0.08488509804010391,
0.5394084453582764,
-0.3575040400028229,
1.0369453430175781,
0.9746918678283691,
-0.23317351937294006,
0.6193302273750305,
0.021541912108659744,
0.3413364291191101,
-0.696394145488739,
-0.13276571035385132,
-0.4870275557041168,
-0.18378397822380066,
-0.7176501154899597,
-0.789028525352478,
0.23089030385017395,
-0.38833287358283997,
-0.32791104912757874,
0.42814549803733826,
0.018535196781158447,
0.3134410083293915,
0.3847683370113373,
0.004371010698378086,
0.08079864084720612,
-0.3701503574848175,
0.5380589962005615,
0.4490537643432617,
-0.5829588770866394,
-0.8860591053962708,
1.0977895259857178,
0.6433591246604919,
1.0057406425476074,
0.01671404018998146,
0.5032302141189575,
0.25118333101272583,
0.1457279771566391,
-0.6689447164535522,
0.7886108160018921,
-0.37944382429122925,
-0.8060177564620972,
-0.7570933103561401,
-0.34591349959373474,
-1.2551069259643555,
0.003238533390685916,
-0.3259029984474182,
-0.8111003637313843,
-0.19347265362739563,
0.05201778560876846,
-0.3372666537761688,
0.3184521198272705,
-0.7219788432121277,
0.724075436592102,
-0.3703257441520691,
-0.06210049241781235,
-0.5083175897598267,
-1.1619926691055298,
0.2798402011394501,
0.035217296332120895,
0.523449718952179,
-0.17850840091705322,
0.04000697657465935,
0.5644325017929077,
0.2701868712902069,
1.2350493669509888,
-0.07512976974248886,
-0.2979148328304291,
0.3604790270328522,
-0.10896773636341095,
0.5170378088951111,
-0.10957425832748413,
-0.0502445325255394,
0.31807202100753784,
-0.14276087284088135,
-0.15490536391735077,
-0.336944043636322,
0.3729317784309387,
-0.8960918188095093,
-0.8048499822616577,
-0.4459221363067627,
-0.7989617586135864,
-0.09382922947406769,
0.031952448189258575,
-0.37246671319007874,
0.031402308493852615,
-0.271749347448349,
0.43738120794296265,
0.6457560658454895,
-0.88471919298172,
0.33302173018455505,
0.5196462869644165,
-0.44313278794288635,
-0.05355646461248398,
0.6429406404495239,
0.08250261843204498,
0.6186543107032776,
0.19849562644958496,
0.3936704993247986,
-0.24761728942394257,
-0.1016240119934082,
-0.030263740569353104,
0.3424890637397766,
-0.39325106143951416,
0.15912313759326935,
-0.7404637336730957,
-0.3295014798641205,
-0.3571678698062897,
-0.45208483934402466,
-0.47107428312301636,
-0.28685227036476135,
-0.11105938255786896,
0.029101252555847168,
0.35065338015556335,
1.1107394695281982,
-0.2512138783931732,
0.5776736736297607,
-0.7635429501533508,
0.3541082739830017,
0.2776971459388733,
0.17646728456020355,
-0.01760883815586567,
-0.3484911322593689,
-0.19681695103645325,
0.1563323587179184,
0.02149043045938015,
-0.6925002932548523,
0.27801191806793213,
-0.3035767674446106,
0.6341904401779175,
0.2664949893951416,
-0.015008097514510155,
0.12172295153141022,
-0.7400137186050415,
0.6093296408653259,
0.23237423598766327,
-0.6868746876716614,
0.36118921637535095,
-0.6308445930480957,
0.05309246852993965,
0.223528653383255,
0.6505036354064941,
-0.8340981602668762,
-0.26591819524765015,
-0.551567554473877,
-0.9476467967033386,
0.5270326733589172,
-0.1260780394077301,
0.8270920515060425,
-0.09207876771688461,
0.32903581857681274,
-0.08840616047382355,
0.2236962765455246,
-0.8443172574043274,
-0.11469636112451553,
0.42833036184310913,
-0.10997016727924347,
-0.42654627561569214,
-0.4380894601345062,
-0.1073484867811203,
-0.12832611799240112,
0.2989203929901123,
0.11767430603504181,
0.2144845426082611,
-0.46570324897766113,
0.007303139660507441,
-0.2946251630783081,
0.19847774505615234,
0.461314857006073,
0.5214201211929321,
-0.0777888149023056,
0.09591148793697357,
0.17916224896907806,
-0.4091610014438629,
0.033846162259578705,
-0.09393055737018585,
0.19629156589508057,
-0.31704404950141907,
0.232951357960701,
0.18778124451637268,
0.5557929873466492,
-1.1020045280456543,
0.5666936635971069,
0.24342754483222961,
-0.05508015677332878,
-0.6194391846656799,
0.0962413102388382,
0.5929425954818726,
0.5945574045181274,
-0.022001182660460472,
-0.229251891374588,
0.12584108114242554,
-1.0456186532974243,
-0.004987944848835468,
0.7421303391456604,
-0.3441266417503357,
-0.3120725452899933,
0.40599530935287476,
0.33386433124542236,
-0.7413568496704102,
0.42786988615989685,
0.006795159541070461,
-0.6535669565200806,
0.7562375664710999,
0.5376075506210327,
0.7634265422821045,
-0.4859488606452942,
0.4848710000514984,
0.058230966329574585,
0.505040168762207,
-0.265854150056839,
0.2210949957370758,
0.49666428565979004,
-0.9482601284980774,
-0.4521237313747406,
-0.2567473351955414,
-0.7746661901473999,
-0.10224238783121109,
-0.3488087058067322,
0.3876587450504303,
-0.261974036693573,
-0.35922476649284363,
-0.15756230056285858,
-0.13882705569267273,
-0.47327932715415955,
-0.09132438898086548,
0.3292027413845062,
0.5095606446266174,
-0.9464262127876282,
1.0382479429244995,
0.7534981369972229,
-0.2246699333190918,
-0.6783627271652222,
0.10580573230981827,
-0.0772230476140976,
-0.8092508316040039,
0.8319578170776367,
0.03614372760057449,
-0.5494476556777954,
-0.36701059341430664,
-0.720872700214386,
-0.9647672772407532,
1.0061825513839722,
0.4931366443634033,
-0.5733574628829956,
-0.3118770718574524,
0.28760379552841187,
0.5780280828475952,
-0.4089626371860504,
-0.022388441488146782,
0.29799002408981323,
0.49062663316726685,
-0.14138543605804443,
-0.8915001749992371,
-0.08473096787929535,
0.07064859569072723,
0.11521327495574951,
0.04548568278551102,
-0.9548463821411133,
0.854101300239563,
-0.33353543281555176,
-0.05411672592163086,
0.0589967779815197,
0.3780117928981781,
0.1776719093322754,
0.3249624967575073,
0.4708651602268219,
-0.12447073310613632,
0.6908025145530701,
0.3127058744430542,
1.339855432510376,
-0.3511314392089844,
0.09786473214626312,
0.9673159718513489,
-0.6636475324630737,
0.8363659977912903,
0.18130619823932648,
-0.2667418420314789,
0.41346126794815063,
0.47602978348731995,
0.3073412775993347,
0.12509571015834808,
0.4106946885585785,
-0.19422869384288788,
-0.279848575592041,
-0.20189321041107178,
-0.27892953157424927,
0.4514240622520447,
0.6321735978126526,
-0.3572201728820801,
0.26369330286979675,
0.14189128577709198,
0.0688779279589653,
0.09881279617547989,
-0.21803370118141174,
0.38229256868362427,
0.4176037311553955,
-0.16535671055316925,
-0.27209627628326416,
-0.14161798357963562,
0.6097187995910645,
-0.48570799827575684,
-0.17343996465206146,
0.37564751505851746,
0.19319233298301697,
0.08755196630954742,
-0.9598554372787476,
0.22783760726451874,
-0.16264215111732483,
0.2558775246143341,
-0.1810462921857834,
0.9880744814872742,
-0.2524707615375519,
-0.582044780254364,
0.8159692883491516,
0.4541986882686615,
0.26162970066070557,
0.07327448576688766,
-0.4875415861606598,
0.08078434318304062,
-0.4415084421634674,
-0.13407360017299652,
0.4627005457878113,
0.49339812994003296,
-0.005698440130800009,
1.1969518661499023,
0.29605117440223694,
-0.12968705594539642,
-0.006398317404091358,
0.061982691287994385,
0.8333250284194946,
-0.7813454270362854,
-0.04647919535636902,
-0.8865588903427124,
0.45517534017562866,
0.035056762397289276,
-0.07065951824188232,
0.7194995284080505,
0.15654590725898743,
0.5614731311798096,
-0.10895560681819916,
0.7898876070976257,
-0.025955235585570335,
0.39169105887413025,
-0.33025211095809937,
0.9732843637466431,
-0.575008749961853,
-0.028376543894410133,
-0.7626067399978638,
-0.5196772217750549,
-0.38264936208724976,
0.7407077550888062,
-0.5139425992965698,
0.18828727304935455,
0.41689640283584595,
0.5336006879806519,
0.4250031113624573,
-0.11904677003622055,
0.55039381980896,
0.03300812840461731,
0.19676904380321503,
0.34383460879325867,
1.1538492441177368,
0.000017492473489255644,
0.2952601909637451,
-0.20768198370933533,
-0.21779990196228027,
-0.5684053897857666,
-0.8336015939712524,
-1.1514265537261963,
-0.6062503457069397,
-0.13760897517204285,
-0.3420960605144501,
0.29118603467941284,
1.1023790836334229,
0.4309351444244385,
-0.3103017210960388,
-0.6260794401168823,
0.3513113856315613,
0.40326768159866333,
0.24364641308784485,
-0.1617318093776703,
0.04441468417644501,
-0.05676395446062088,
-0.7664157152175903,
0.19857022166252136,
0.2340795248746872,
0.14278849959373474,
-0.5697858333587646,
-0.19473907351493835,
-0.35986024141311646,
0.2714252769947052,
1.0251576900482178,
0.27295538783073425,
-0.6040425300598145,
-0.7573469877243042,
0.3141632676124573,
-0.11039048433303833,
-0.269594669342041,
0.6075866222381592,
-0.2646792531013489,
0.14632561802864075,
0.2509879469871521,
0.7419286370277405,
0.1525944471359253,
-0.3225488066673279,
0.8973481059074402,
-0.0033260569907724857,
0.1364644467830658,
0.280909925699234,
0.4087304174900055,
0.3626496195793152,
-0.3716678023338318,
0.7393792867660522,
-0.11821861565113068,
-0.7094778418540955,
-0.9238869547843933,
0.3909394145011902,
-1.0443074703216553,
-0.19710661470890045,
1.4751955270767212,
0.14817360043525696,
-0.23509927093982697,
-0.24924972653388977,
-0.28485721349716187,
0.49469804763793945,
-0.22661784291267395,
1.0296146869659424,
0.7329400777816772,
0.06541506946086884,
-0.1588059961795807,
-1.121537685394287,
0.10639311373233795,
-0.10747530311346054,
-0.8062232732772827,
0.13462941348552704,
0.19553717970848083,
0.1690872609615326,
0.1572227030992508,
0.6652395129203796,
-0.19946099817752838,
0.2361549586057663,
-0.15791109204292297,
0.3739427924156189,
0.566486656665802,
-0.5272790193557739,
-0.26731640100479126,
-0.15992471575737,
0.24893908202648163,
0.17406296730041504
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17768v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17768v1
|
SciNews: From Scholarly Complexities to Public Narratives -- A Dataset for Scientific News Report Generation
| 2024-03-26T14:54:48 | 2024-03-26T14:54:48 |
Dongqi Pu, Yifan Wang, Jia Loy, Vera Demberg
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Scientific news reports serve as a bridge, adeptly translating complex
research articles into reports that resonate with the broader public. The
automated generation of such narratives enhances the accessibility of scholarly
insights. In this paper, we present a new corpus to facilitate this paradigm
development. Our corpus comprises a parallel compilation of academic
publications and their corresponding scientific news reports across nine
disciplines. To demonstrate the utility and reliability of our dataset, we
conduct an extensive analysis, highlighting the divergences in readability and
brevity between scientific news narratives and academic manuscripts. We
benchmark our dataset employing state-of-the-art text generation models. The
evaluation process involves both automatic and human evaluation, which lays the
groundwork for future explorations into the automated generation of scientific
news reports. The dataset and code related to this work are available at
https://dongqi.me/projects/SciNews.
|
[
-0.12717483937740326,
-0.14929917454719543,
0.5712497234344482,
0.4813464879989624,
-0.2414410561323166,
0.32829055190086365,
-0.1544855535030365,
-0.5966687798500061,
0.5072718858718872,
0.16714048385620117,
-0.2521674931049347,
-0.6654843688011169,
-0.5557631254196167,
0.6672157645225525,
-0.7427975535392761,
1.309885025024414,
-0.07000476121902466,
0.08499260991811752,
-0.4884856641292572,
0.03337273746728897,
0.052330248057842255,
0.13784776628017426,
0.1299382597208023,
0.14724715054035187,
0.6536361575126648,
0.25824081897735596,
0.5612750053405762,
0.9165424108505249,
0.7017899751663208,
0.19490602612495422,
0.08168382197618484,
0.531310498714447,
-0.45181307196617126,
0.14958468079566956,
-0.25432056188583374,
-0.15194422006607056,
-0.22294142842292786,
-0.061712298542261124,
0.8777002096176147,
0.7816179394721985,
0.1885182112455368,
0.4480689465999603,
-0.1562632918357849,
0.6870813965797424,
-0.3449426293373108,
0.050452135503292084,
-0.42054101824760437,
0.0378505103290081,
-0.6118393540382385,
-0.29410412907600403,
-0.3670834004878998,
-0.49973058700561523,
0.31473469734191895,
-0.8765282034873962,
0.4373053312301636,
0.3580024242401123,
0.767032265663147,
0.03531104326248169,
-0.5377848744392395,
-0.3685370981693268,
-0.5523701906204224,
0.5858124494552612,
-0.3182221055030823,
0.011892487294971943,
-0.19776026904582977,
0.24347834289073944,
-0.15196265280246735,
-1.0954707860946655,
-0.2859201431274414,
-0.3217143714427948,
-0.1988517940044403,
0.2457132190465927,
-0.3044900596141815,
-0.5606435537338257,
0.007548039313405752,
0.035870060324668884,
-0.8484296798706055,
-0.20917439460754395,
-1.0639158487319946,
-0.05044926330447197,
0.6699074506759644,
0.32855165004730225,
0.20964975655078888,
-0.5405499935150146,
-0.016976187005639076,
-0.002626842586323619,
-0.6094237565994263,
-0.3085882067680359,
0.43789049983024597,
0.20037084817886353,
-0.04839914292097092,
0.492961585521698,
-0.33128735423088074,
0.5430803894996643,
-0.14919312298297882,
-0.12842002511024475,
0.49667495489120483,
-0.42649081349372864,
0.21978963911533356,
0.6073147654533386,
0.7510707974433899,
0.7135769128799438,
-0.21488182246685028,
-0.21150606870651245,
0.23613257706165314,
0.17427200078964233,
0.48766130208969116,
-0.7775073647499084,
-0.16483677923679352,
0.19367715716362,
-0.505396842956543,
-0.7306873202323914,
0.2440585345029831,
-0.8529186844825745,
-0.5040143132209778,
-0.22190283238887787,
-0.1397167444229126,
-0.1036849096417427,
-0.10237586498260498,
0.1625218242406845,
-0.27407217025756836,
-0.49323806166648865,
0.5431783199310303,
-0.3904978632926941,
0.1470094621181488,
0.38078898191452026,
0.993036687374115,
-0.42845746874809265,
-0.33467334508895874,
-0.4333500564098358,
0.6041789650917053,
-0.1924619823694229,
0.8148627877235413,
-0.3054690659046173,
-0.21948036551475525,
-0.17241357266902924,
-0.22712385654449463,
0.150827556848526,
-0.27700328826904297,
0.8002013564109802,
-0.3458363711833954,
0.2904638350009918,
-0.14723899960517883,
-0.2893752455711365,
-0.10513538867235184,
-0.16301970183849335,
-0.681117594242096,
0.5218640565872192,
0.07643284648656845,
-1.182239055633545,
0.5060738325119019,
-0.808525025844574,
-0.6449663639068604,
0.26699328422546387,
-0.23204904794692993,
-0.36224061250686646,
0.011976475827395916,
0.18203690648078918,
0.2258533388376236,
-0.4630437195301056,
0.6900174617767334,
-0.03841891512274742,
-0.0003575919836293906,
-0.008134585805237293,
-0.1470470279455185,
0.3728776276111603,
0.3698354959487915,
0.026573508977890015,
0.09773888438940048,
-0.9236482977867126,
-0.3107014298439026,
0.08270938694477081,
-0.2779790759086609,
-0.2224583625793457,
0.19123849272727966,
0.34211745858192444,
-0.07204882800579071,
0.22925147414207458,
-0.9343248605728149,
0.222409188747406,
-0.24785444140434265,
0.5803784132003784,
0.2694936990737915,
0.04825710877776146,
0.3668572008609772,
-0.4979887306690216,
0.11343837529420853,
0.1975003033876419,
0.0011612515663728118,
-0.5839950442314148,
-0.2901553511619568,
-0.2269660085439682,
-0.18434026837348938,
0.5359207987785339,
0.2844869792461395,
-0.389401912689209,
0.1365930140018463,
-0.2910802662372589,
-0.6929349303245544,
-0.6244145631790161,
-0.1922183781862259,
0.2366672307252884,
0.7241610884666443,
0.4108586311340332,
-0.08041965961456299,
-0.8113299012184143,
-0.8065871596336365,
-0.4425560534000397,
-0.015992239117622375,
-0.23655802011489868,
0.11650990694761276,
0.5247628688812256,
-0.11464881896972656,
1.145316243171692,
-0.5886355042457581,
0.1330447643995285,
0.044696006923913956,
0.6511489748954773,
0.12012100219726562,
0.35925817489624023,
0.309354692697525,
-0.9670137763023376,
-0.15338975191116333,
-0.08095340430736542,
-0.994236409664154,
-0.20341940224170685,
-0.3586465120315552,
-0.10264695435762405,
0.13335184752941132,
0.45193836092948914,
-0.4799140989780426,
0.36121734976768494,
0.3500290513038635,
-0.47031840682029724,
0.9739270806312561,
-0.06099516153335571,
0.3096027076244354,
-1.0176620483398438,
0.3761274814605713,
0.23293845355510712,
-0.07560660690069199,
-0.3377622067928314,
-0.36049455404281616,
-0.054302554577589035,
-0.14523005485534668,
-0.4832184910774231,
0.3742625415325165,
-0.4965256154537201,
-0.22400185465812683,
0.05191342160105705,
0.22295846045017242,
0.26199871301651,
-0.2740509510040283,
0.1701839715242386,
0.2781449556350708,
0.2649264931678772,
-0.3832550346851349,
0.3855055570602417,
0.4884331226348877,
-0.433245450258255,
0.16277700662612915,
-0.8112310171127319,
-0.35898011922836304,
-0.4301724433898926,
0.5913587212562561,
-0.45606663823127747,
-0.8225222826004028,
0.11711499094963074,
-0.3819296061992645,
0.0056233033537864685,
0.2544786334037781,
-0.5056756138801575,
-0.364507794380188,
-0.30416521430015564,
0.15510274469852448,
-0.0039041112177073956,
-0.370520681142807,
0.18586619198322296,
0.2812671959400177,
-0.5588028430938721,
-0.30892473459243774,
-0.5457626581192017,
0.37184199690818787,
-0.018342316150665283,
-0.9223986864089966,
0.5574052929878235,
0.10156732052564621,
-0.48543867468833923,
0.22558392584323883,
-0.11249484121799469,
0.12805020809173584,
-0.1937246024608612,
0.29859644174575806,
0.5195412039756775,
-0.24100811779499054,
0.11707935482263565,
0.46683308482170105,
0.04015529900789261,
0.230051189661026,
-0.18719172477722168,
0.07836540043354034,
-0.2834133505821228,
-0.11057879775762558,
-0.1511322259902954,
0.5432795286178589,
0.6670970916748047,
-0.2446441948413849,
0.4662780463695526,
0.3860583007335663,
-0.11145472526550293,
0.08281183987855911,
-0.05690230801701546,
-0.2787962555885315,
-0.37776538729667664,
0.36234280467033386,
0.11317942291498184,
-0.6537103056907654,
0.046728529036045074,
-0.22500422596931458,
0.3365267813205719,
0.5894920825958252,
0.3660026788711548,
0.07061906158924103,
0.7835442423820496,
0.08086918294429779,
0.1967015117406845,
-0.1677945852279663,
0.2112971395254135,
0.10989325493574142,
-0.39102113246917725,
-0.4093029201030731,
-0.6244637370109558,
-0.14630240201950073,
-0.3528497517108917,
-0.12544038891792297,
0.4916938245296478,
-0.07376205176115036,
-0.1571570634841919,
0.13028837740421295,
-0.7125857472419739,
0.4172683656215668,
0.5530834197998047,
-0.17043951153755188,
0.7863456010818481,
0.09547177702188492,
0.1657753735780716,
-0.17889229953289032,
-0.582942008972168,
-0.8675673604011536,
1.0492032766342163,
0.36722391843795776,
0.5898770093917847,
-0.12439317256212234,
0.7673388719558716,
0.4673961102962494,
0.31112852692604065,
-0.226562038064003,
0.2601291537284851,
-0.1527993530035019,
-0.37179216742515564,
-0.2057173252105713,
-0.48616209626197815,
-0.9049184322357178,
0.040129970759153366,
-0.4100378155708313,
-0.33356061577796936,
0.15532076358795166,
-0.26820775866508484,
-0.6015644073486328,
-0.023975085467100143,
-0.5049676895141602,
0.49039891362190247,
-0.22859059274196625,
-0.25309208035469055,
-0.1903194636106491,
-1.0031126737594604,
0.5921571850776672,
-0.2665652930736542,
0.1639472097158432,
-0.035022053867578506,
0.024248246103525162,
0.8676923513412476,
0.029337486252188683,
0.6118759512901306,
0.22027893364429474,
0.27248042821884155,
0.1191224604845047,
-0.023608600720763206,
0.31056493520736694,
0.5970280170440674,
0.10217558592557907,
0.1019551157951355,
-0.0673951804637909,
-0.3017747700214386,
-0.12254136055707932,
0.6383892297744751,
-0.661715030670166,
-0.2248964011669159,
-0.5784218907356262,
-0.951301634311676,
-0.14625680446624756,
0.27933505177497864,
0.24277116358280182,
0.4955401122570038,
-0.3177749514579773,
0.18689757585525513,
0.48170697689056396,
-0.23865729570388794,
0.2626662850379944,
0.6559881567955017,
-0.2016325145959854,
-0.25079745054244995,
0.9934682250022888,
0.1850154846906662,
-0.24907410144805908,
0.22436797618865967,
0.10796406120061874,
0.004565669689327478,
-0.636016845703125,
-0.5614316463470459,
0.10829135030508041,
-0.0592866912484169,
-0.42677736282348633,
-0.7744011878967285,
-0.2941901981830597,
-0.4836934506893158,
-0.28088340163230896,
-0.22068336606025696,
-0.5833009481430054,
-0.4263344407081604,
-0.205048069357872,
0.3448145091533661,
1.0524921417236328,
-0.15766936540603638,
-0.16501498222351074,
-0.9933160543441772,
0.36511796712875366,
-0.02208428457379341,
-0.16402800381183624,
-0.2388293743133545,
0.034316036850214005,
-0.31537196040153503,
-0.11560524255037308,
-0.5031753182411194,
-0.6648680567741394,
0.579584002494812,
0.1331617534160614,
0.23973160982131958,
0.2665823698043823,
0.35511261224746704,
0.22048354148864746,
-0.5701718926429749,
0.6312690377235413,
0.5076162219047546,
-0.48181965947151184,
0.6858916282653809,
-0.9251378178596497,
0.20510894060134888,
0.5969956517219543,
0.6179295778274536,
-0.31415432691574097,
-0.7369593381881714,
-0.7850812673568726,
-1.107998251914978,
0.4877537786960602,
0.16502369940280914,
-0.2677803635597229,
0.022113731130957603,
0.005318444222211838,
0.5334922075271606,
0.3375304043292999,
-0.13152466714382172,
0.0496082678437233,
-0.44219815731048584,
-0.2813398241996765,
0.04516816511750221,
0.03827585652470589,
-0.4886230528354645,
-0.188543900847435,
0.44220706820487976,
-0.03757600113749504,
0.00784857664257288,
0.34919336438179016,
-0.06251047551631927,
-0.1318773627281189,
0.1069495901465416,
0.7824322581291199,
0.8406204581260681,
-0.1753212958574295,
0.03448161482810974,
-0.30442485213279724,
-0.8294409513473511,
-0.3520403802394867,
0.3457861542701721,
-0.4975890517234802,
0.3231852948665619,
0.44795992970466614,
0.6877422332763672,
0.16542434692382812,
-0.7582453489303589,
0.3411411643028259,
-0.1253332793712616,
-0.5225645899772644,
-0.02929663471877575,
-0.13961732387542725,
0.18480440974235535,
0.2800489664077759,
0.8497500419616699,
0.5143247246742249,
0.4330337643623352,
-0.35837695002555847,
0.482334703207016,
-0.3422071933746338,
0.043630339205265045,
-0.3429482877254486,
0.7556455135345459,
0.4703880846500397,
0.30813437700271606,
0.45500242710113525,
-0.3111112713813782,
-0.1531297266483307,
0.5261252522468567,
0.5479767918586731,
0.38799014687538147,
0.2904673218727112,
0.7622275948524475,
0.452739417552948,
0.024812020361423492,
-0.07582180947065353,
-0.13858826458454132,
0.30564916133880615,
-0.24261388182640076,
-0.5419487953186035,
-0.7875987887382507,
-0.4007910490036011,
-0.06362016499042511,
-0.6177822351455688,
0.3284550607204437,
-0.1307588666677475,
0.08537625521421432,
0.43472912907600403,
0.17591536045074463,
-0.04216286912560463,
-0.034332454204559326,
0.15521177649497986,
1.0712178945541382,
-0.8967629671096802,
0.510054349899292,
0.6536797285079956,
-0.35865435004234314,
-0.47289398312568665,
-0.013520625419914722,
0.11699537932872772,
-0.20864878594875336,
0.8617861866950989,
0.07401638478040695,
0.06603504717350006,
-0.17093728482723236,
-0.5297746062278748,
-0.6582668423652649,
1.1880559921264648,
0.6700426340103149,
-0.9104763269424438,
-0.06735511124134064,
0.046971894800662994,
0.5985729098320007,
-0.5676953196525574,
0.15987111628055573,
0.3269372284412384,
0.8245872855186462,
0.0801737979054451,
-0.7841912508010864,
0.06287240236997604,
-0.4608405530452728,
-0.3619668185710907,
-0.050172824412584305,
-0.722118616104126,
0.8700429797172546,
-0.34094706177711487,
-0.08552383631467819,
-0.08048321306705475,
1.0475233793258667,
0.45543789863586426,
0.7256182432174683,
0.15727446973323822,
0.34667184948921204,
0.970515787601471,
-0.017468193545937538,
0.7410321831703186,
-0.3489476144313812,
-0.07119911909103394,
1.0827885866165161,
-0.20600919425487518,
0.43749502301216125,
0.49750208854675293,
-0.04049139469861984,
0.5291829705238342,
0.41243863105773926,
-0.364043265581131,
0.5084072351455688,
0.45550379157066345,
-0.30181026458740234,
0.013976387679576874,
-0.4949101507663727,
-0.5112208127975464,
0.3792228102684021,
0.16296453773975372,
-0.4682542085647583,
-0.6757844090461731,
0.09313858300447464,
0.0959945023059845,
0.30301976203918457,
-0.32202744483947754,
0.3052818477153778,
-0.032339856028556824,
-0.5221554040908813,
0.15170840919017792,
-0.012659206055104733,
0.4377876818180084,
-0.39064595103263855,
-0.010109304450452328,
0.08168532699346542,
-0.17404937744140625,
-0.648213267326355,
-0.8696132898330688,
0.49008116126060486,
0.3633906841278076,
-0.5645757913589478,
-0.0912213996052742,
0.7531533241271973,
-0.23685140907764435,
-0.39702388644218445,
-0.22187158465385437,
0.3749334514141083,
0.23682615160942078,
0.21997833251953125,
-0.2549014091491699,
0.10607413202524185,
-0.1391351819038391,
-0.32526546716690063,
0.38571545481681824,
0.3709203600883484,
-0.2032875269651413,
0.335670530796051,
0.6991631388664246,
0.1557520478963852,
0.04654219001531601,
0.03693319484591484,
0.9183260202407837,
-0.48997944593429565,
-0.3189036548137665,
-0.3308412432670593,
0.3973004221916199,
-0.481993705034256,
-0.7535861730575562,
0.8643764853477478,
0.9517212510108948,
0.34726884961128235,
-0.17327667772769928,
1.1064821481704712,
-0.24148237705230713,
0.7573977112770081,
-0.09378115087747574,
1.011301040649414,
-0.1630668044090271,
0.09021205455064774,
-0.13848347961902618,
-0.353270560503006,
-0.4519995450973511,
0.133039191365242,
-0.18578673899173737,
-0.5095548033714294,
0.6669079661369324,
0.42512544989585876,
0.0937553271651268,
0.5709518790245056,
-0.22408440709114075,
0.28471118211746216,
0.013726873323321342,
0.1563069075345993,
0.7895520925521851,
-0.051747702062129974,
0.6622304916381836,
0.06447908282279968,
-0.20451776683330536,
-0.40289995074272156,
-1.0161259174346924,
-0.668364942073822,
-0.6512581706047058,
-0.27046918869018555,
-0.31982895731925964,
0.3409661650657654,
0.44309234619140625,
0.4490097165107727,
-0.7462100982666016,
0.011617344804108143,
-0.3873625695705414,
-0.17657439410686493,
0.051355212926864624,
-0.2298053801059723,
0.5856834053993225,
-0.47618722915649414,
-0.5306012034416199,
0.3990304172039032,
0.24603071808815002,
-0.31173139810562134,
-0.4394432306289673,
-0.045053865760564804,
-0.024139758199453354,
-0.05540373548865318,
0.45775285363197327,
0.35333874821662903,
0.00419642636552453,
0.10981276631355286,
0.022865192964673042,
-0.2895444929599762,
-0.08476758003234863,
0.8897002339363098,
-0.779000461101532,
0.13572397828102112,
0.568088173866272,
0.4809735417366028,
0.6460068225860596,
-0.189361572265625,
0.702035129070282,
-0.636346161365509,
-0.018742812797427177,
0.5500242114067078,
0.08997755497694016,
0.37152522802352905,
-0.3795051574707031,
0.5068889260292053,
0.25373685359954834,
-0.5637335181236267,
-1.2253557443618774,
-0.14555250108242035,
-1.1069692373275757,
-0.40030741691589355,
0.9126190543174744,
-0.003749317955225706,
-0.5967284440994263,
-0.310472309589386,
-0.2588430941104889,
0.18542562425136566,
-0.7592830657958984,
0.9250649213790894,
0.40348175168037415,
-0.121394582092762,
0.34229862689971924,
-0.541732668876648,
0.4605593979358673,
0.06583021581172943,
-0.9156857132911682,
0.15835806727409363,
0.5669785141944885,
-0.029171574860811234,
0.48257121443748474,
0.15082387626171112,
-0.33986765146255493,
0.5372748970985413,
0.2507912814617157,
-0.035507235676050186,
-0.4283628761768341,
-0.6560848355293274,
0.22174105048179626,
0.4689140021800995,
-0.5063455104827881,
0.34753385186195374
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17760v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17760v2
|
Constructions Are So Difficult That Even Large Language Models Get Them Right for the Wrong Reasons
| 2024-03-26T14:51:12 | 2024-05-29T23:41:37 |
Shijia Zhou, Leonie Weissweiler, Taiqi He, Hinrich Schütze, David R. Mortensen, Lori Levin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we make a contribution that can be understood from two
perspectives: from an NLP perspective, we introduce a small challenge dataset
for NLI with large lexical overlap, which minimises the possibility of models
discerning entailment solely based on token distinctions, and show that GPT-4
and Llama 2 fail it with strong bias. We then create further challenging
sub-tasks in an effort to explain this failure. From a Computational
Linguistics perspective, we identify a group of constructions with three
classes of adjectives which cannot be distinguished by surface features. This
enables us to probe for LLM's understanding of these constructions in various
ways, and we find that they fail in a variety of ways to distinguish between
them, suggesting that they don't adequately represent their meaning or capture
the lexical properties of phrasal heads.
|
[
-0.5105294585227966,
-0.7877411842346191,
0.8064419627189636,
0.19868357479572296,
-0.015993749722838402,
0.2225191593170166,
-0.12514518201351166,
-0.5630852580070496,
0.07650242745876312,
0.2000269889831543,
-0.3486824929714203,
-0.16188137233257294,
-0.9459884166717529,
0.33468326926231384,
-0.3811553716659546,
0.9033709168434143,
-0.2816475033760071,
-0.3978281319141388,
-0.2949361503124237,
-0.11822444945573807,
-0.2617276608943939,
-0.5935670137405396,
-0.46173998713493347,
-0.24357444047927856,
0.3280520737171173,
0.07524377852678299,
1.126801609992981,
0.7742897868156433,
0.5075697302818298,
0.277172714471817,
-0.32754889130592346,
0.5030098557472229,
-0.16374002397060394,
-0.21530067920684814,
-0.1854517012834549,
-0.6790819764137268,
-0.2610054016113281,
0.18479347229003906,
0.44451645016670227,
1.1220647096633911,
0.18162280321121216,
-0.029562121257185936,
0.13295596837997437,
0.5745996832847595,
-0.6143208146095276,
0.19168488681316376,
-0.8941903114318848,
0.21716661751270294,
-0.50191730260849,
-0.003316842019557953,
-0.2826596200466156,
0.038244135677814484,
-0.02245536632835865,
-0.26478904485702515,
0.28346332907676697,
0.19408856332302094,
1.2967299222946167,
0.34393417835235596,
-0.5855765342712402,
-0.5339959859848022,
-0.4807305335998535,
0.6713967323303223,
-0.8656944632530212,
0.3624401390552521,
0.5851621627807617,
-0.15118561685085297,
-0.5038251280784607,
-0.5424885153770447,
-0.6129924058914185,
-0.2482781559228897,
-0.1903325319290161,
-0.14262089133262634,
-0.0537753663957119,
0.15824708342552185,
0.3713339865207672,
0.5368384718894958,
-0.49124637246131897,
0.3412288725376129,
-0.30738207697868347,
-0.212669238448143,
0.3608945608139038,
0.15769606828689575,
0.2949955463409424,
-0.5921966433525085,
-0.2892917990684509,
0.2817079722881317,
-1.1019115447998047,
-0.08618844300508499,
0.5381712913513184,
0.3769899606704712,
-0.12690138816833496,
0.8168585896492004,
0.26005128026008606,
0.6344332098960876,
0.0640820562839508,
-0.05490526556968689,
0.19732455909252167,
-0.23413388431072235,
-0.15883557498455048,
-0.2807544767856598,
0.6777042746543884,
0.03663552924990654,
0.1491892784833908,
-0.20545190572738647,
-0.11598709225654602,
0.3586573302745819,
0.19505922496318817,
-0.30387505888938904,
0.01377522200345993,
0.5715773105621338,
-0.08174565434455872,
-0.3465808928012848,
0.07376841455698013,
-0.17906241118907928,
-0.2768951952457428,
-0.322413831949234,
0.30471566319465637,
-0.14633698761463165,
-0.3785211145877838,
0.2871706783771515,
-0.08249488472938538,
0.5950159430503845,
0.09715526551008224,
-0.8604273200035095,
0.40704360604286194,
1.0543841123580933,
0.7632580399513245,
-0.2047916054725647,
-0.42375436425209045,
-0.027294853702187538,
0.0364474318921566,
-0.6089275479316711,
0.7825762629508972,
-0.5133710503578186,
-0.2752302587032318,
-0.07745326310396194,
0.05358244106173515,
-0.11821791529655457,
-0.5775691866874695,
0.4544053077697754,
-0.34125205874443054,
0.3629964292049408,
-0.3011121451854706,
-0.6267234086990356,
-0.1690964549779892,
0.4414985477924347,
-0.5261174440383911,
0.8923128247261047,
0.21968795359134674,
-0.8967881798744202,
0.19363684952259064,
-0.2140265852212906,
-0.42967894673347473,
-0.03171800822019577,
-0.44176411628723145,
-0.24705998599529266,
0.5727313756942749,
-0.05855404958128929,
0.32977619767189026,
-0.3455468416213989,
0.44523394107818604,
-0.17251117527484894,
-0.16362984478473663,
0.19880825281143188,
-0.13750894367694855,
0.6837766170501709,
0.09437907487154007,
-0.4394126832485199,
-0.38525155186653137,
-0.6463125348091125,
-0.05119799077510834,
0.23725789785385132,
-0.41963446140289307,
-0.18719100952148438,
0.3111804723739624,
-0.07483973354101181,
0.2386827915906906,
0.19914747774600983,
-0.32591915130615234,
0.3348813056945801,
-0.5060377717018127,
0.6500253081321716,
0.7433855533599854,
-0.3211037218570709,
0.2757263779640198,
-0.3404500186443329,
0.5624027848243713,
0.11217548698186874,
-0.21401266753673553,
0.42782577872276306,
-0.7124223113059998,
-0.9609072208404541,
-0.004565899726003408,
0.5106679797172546,
0.5750584602355957,
-0.8220880031585693,
0.19981060922145844,
-0.20276622474193573,
-0.41145050525665283,
-0.37694087624549866,
0.25103312730789185,
0.6557536721229553,
0.2127220183610916,
0.06613197177648544,
-0.31719526648521423,
-0.7078359127044678,
-1.0300800800323486,
-0.3545522689819336,
-0.36696696281433105,
0.04635251685976982,
0.2733895778656006,
0.736448347568512,
-0.2589012086391449,
0.8033607006072998,
-0.44340646266937256,
-0.14513912796974182,
-0.34536638855934143,
0.06262773275375366,
0.4097175598144531,
0.3787241280078888,
0.6561481356620789,
-0.7216715812683105,
-0.04239797592163086,
-0.01892688311636448,
-0.8161014914512634,
0.016399292275309563,
-0.02021563984453678,
0.0677492544054985,
-0.11435335874557495,
0.540529191493988,
-0.9565802216529846,
0.25213149189949036,
0.2793809175491333,
-0.5297495722770691,
0.618556022644043,
0.003100695786997676,
-0.32674410939216614,
-0.816292941570282,
-0.40234437584877014,
0.069953054189682,
-0.06948709487915039,
-0.7250669598579407,
0.4748779535293579,
-0.2256484031677246,
0.18836522102355957,
-0.5433504581451416,
0.32610616087913513,
-0.4359242022037506,
-0.06433036178350449,
-0.20623131096363068,
0.08872497081756592,
0.04456261917948723,
0.6713299751281738,
-0.20938098430633545,
0.37512722611427307,
0.40818002820014954,
-0.6856350898742676,
0.22634275257587433,
0.3309346139431,
-0.3099851906299591,
0.4522281587123871,
-0.7249277234077454,
0.3596055805683136,
-0.33276158571243286,
0.1456766575574875,
-0.9254950881004333,
-0.6199202537536621,
0.23059843480587006,
-0.4319472312927246,
0.3366332948207855,
-0.12454178184270859,
-0.5545099377632141,
-0.28631791472435,
-0.3200837969779968,
0.7406184673309326,
0.24855655431747437,
-0.509794294834137,
0.7030773162841797,
0.41525986790657043,
-0.06229919195175171,
-0.5786494016647339,
-0.9485889077186584,
0.3316787779331207,
-0.4730146825313568,
-0.5561539530754089,
0.46746134757995605,
0.2504591941833496,
-0.6948742270469666,
-0.007699744310230017,
-0.03762504458427429,
-0.13514810800552368,
0.15819740295410156,
0.31614166498184204,
0.1829635500907898,
-0.35580459237098694,
0.020063871517777443,
-0.10925210267305374,
0.1832675188779831,
0.2109074741601944,
-0.10619611293077469,
0.3113167881965637,
-0.2713397145271301,
-0.5384847521781921,
-0.23537664115428925,
0.23474963009357452,
0.6951488852500916,
-0.08112513273954391,
0.5093634724617004,
0.19407732784748077,
-0.5298742651939392,
-0.31199368834495544,
-0.6680128574371338,
0.36332783102989197,
-0.4372214376926422,
0.33188679814338684,
-0.7809133529663086,
-1.0219072103500366,
0.5999594330787659,
0.18102885782718658,
0.10002374649047852,
0.6578866839408875,
0.3983805477619171,
0.013452927581965923,
1.0016835927963257,
0.47865405678749084,
0.07412856072187424,
-0.19312544167041779,
-0.2686189115047455,
0.24290968477725983,
-0.8712601065635681,
-0.11767279356718063,
-0.561089038848877,
-0.2273925542831421,
-0.9020833373069763,
-0.28037944436073303,
0.20365576446056366,
0.06570960581302643,
-0.2407452017068863,
0.6016759276390076,
-0.4027329683303833,
0.39804694056510925,
0.3352699279785156,
-0.003833797527477145,
0.2162870615720749,
0.0074920617043972015,
0.061580900102853775,
-0.15711264312267303,
-0.6209754943847656,
-0.6646199822425842,
0.8387494683265686,
0.4132438600063324,
0.4343235492706299,
0.42849305272102356,
0.326267272233963,
0.12987643480300903,
-0.12072363495826721,
-0.8225975632667542,
0.5781450271606445,
-0.19669032096862793,
-0.6407168507575989,
0.00011617007112363353,
-0.2693323493003845,
-1.0504587888717651,
0.4605761468410492,
-0.14672991633415222,
-0.5710403323173523,
0.4619857966899872,
-0.054536957293748856,
-0.21293745934963226,
0.35645702481269836,
-0.649437665939331,
0.7259454131126404,
-0.2202843278646469,
-0.3412487208843231,
0.03992025554180145,
-0.478486567735672,
0.5541727542877197,
-0.07841701805591583,
0.6411932110786438,
-0.2457176297903061,
-0.12552206218242645,
0.4803222715854645,
-0.671420156955719,
0.8291881084442139,
0.04052302613854408,
-0.39836740493774414,
0.508117139339447,
0.36283814907073975,
0.31324824690818787,
-0.17883282899856567,
0.06976746767759323,
0.12980809807777405,
-0.11228075623512268,
-0.47901591658592224,
-0.7128298878669739,
0.4352692663669586,
-0.7516623139381409,
-0.7659149169921875,
-0.3576299846172333,
-0.31809818744659424,
-0.3220435678958893,
-0.13623228669166565,
0.5049296617507935,
0.5347008109092712,
-0.0018427312606945634,
-0.22398711740970612,
0.13178496062755585,
-0.03832258656620979,
0.24969393014907837,
0.029914356768131256,
-0.05519316717982292,
0.05938156321644783,
1.0401445627212524,
0.21355916559696198,
0.25208157300949097,
0.08544206619262695,
0.048172589391469955,
-0.20499522984027863,
-0.9036101698875427,
-0.3053111732006073,
0.35141393542289734,
-0.7990677356719971,
0.03358329087495804,
-0.3358546197414398,
-0.4240153729915619,
-0.14596028625965118,
-0.11026196926832199,
-0.30766865611076355,
-0.567030131816864,
-0.2614540159702301,
-0.29519006609916687,
0.05590643361210823,
1.193928837776184,
-0.22482146322727203,
0.1431482881307602,
-0.39605745673179626,
0.3921797573566437,
0.35806789994239807,
0.1868327409029007,
0.026412881910800934,
-0.6499301791191101,
0.10656396299600601,
-0.11764716356992722,
-0.18002229928970337,
-0.6857824325561523,
0.19744612276554108,
0.29470294713974,
0.3576946556568146,
0.3451346457004547,
-0.2425040453672409,
0.46562039852142334,
-0.632070004940033,
0.8555574417114258,
-0.04150000959634781,
-0.9787492752075195,
0.4949702322483063,
-0.36104056239128113,
0.03457590565085411,
0.510981559753418,
0.3352891504764557,
-0.09013058990240097,
-0.7018892168998718,
-0.7315278053283691,
-1.0388898849487305,
0.25041815638542175,
0.35464802384376526,
0.11149511486291885,
-0.4418034255504608,
0.5553740859031677,
0.09007391333580017,
0.018033964559435844,
-0.9015526175498962,
-0.010413090698421001,
-0.06292039155960083,
-0.1653163731098175,
0.12454947829246521,
-0.49119332432746887,
0.03218359872698784,
-0.0988159105181694,
0.5433533191680908,
-0.06889315694570541,
0.20021624863147736,
0.20629413425922394,
-0.26693156361579895,
0.32768648862838745,
0.31509265303611755,
0.6270306706428528,
0.7271995544433594,
-0.07168568670749664,
0.5240805745124817,
0.27289000153541565,
-0.32252737879753113,
0.22437597811222076,
-0.15688428282737732,
0.004196206107735634,
0.10833030939102173,
0.7640427947044373,
0.8662348389625549,
0.13741080462932587,
-0.4090523421764374,
0.5996511578559875,
0.17005257308483124,
-0.4422813653945923,
-0.4047448933124542,
-0.17134131491184235,
0.03557988628745079,
0.07877720147371292,
0.10894879698753357,
-0.14043541252613068,
-0.058056578040122986,
-0.6607283353805542,
-0.20929794013500214,
0.6230977177619934,
-0.22612275183200836,
-0.4819160997867584,
0.5941619873046875,
-0.11795374751091003,
-0.2742091417312622,
0.6139562129974365,
-0.44649168848991394,
-0.6532566547393799,
0.8296425342559814,
0.32993972301483154,
0.6793699860572815,
0.2201886773109436,
-0.1047111377120018,
0.14697949588298798,
0.45843538641929626,
-0.3254827558994293,
0.26427075266838074,
0.22635792195796967,
-1.0773698091506958,
-0.744757354259491,
-0.4248490333557129,
-0.4879800081253052,
0.13224153220653534,
-0.427299827337265,
0.2589488923549652,
-0.655720055103302,
-0.20710180699825287,
0.24862708151340485,
-0.4749000072479248,
-0.710238516330719,
0.13440032303333282,
0.19322220981121063,
0.5729623436927795,
-0.9452800750732422,
0.18393568694591522,
0.6216873526573181,
-0.391083687543869,
-0.781001091003418,
-0.16036011278629303,
0.14993734657764435,
-0.6205909252166748,
0.7103919982910156,
0.14681707322597504,
-0.20119930803775787,
-0.23271910846233368,
-0.7769095301628113,
-0.8305327892303467,
0.4317793548107147,
0.4052945375442505,
-0.16546927392482758,
-0.5753927230834961,
0.3265513479709625,
0.47709453105926514,
-0.24864059686660767,
0.05157330632209778,
0.6693573594093323,
0.5787242650985718,
-0.08010809123516083,
-1.218664526939392,
0.14887098968029022,
-0.11200990527868271,
-0.07906346023082733,
0.11098439246416092,
-0.4495830535888672,
0.8265318870544434,
-0.246771439909935,
-0.4217768907546997,
0.10577859729528427,
0.5961113572120667,
0.24347396194934845,
0.11318431049585342,
0.497432142496109,
0.8961436152458191,
0.47636696696281433,
-0.35898420214653015,
1.1450737714767456,
-0.06508304178714752,
0.3346109688282013,
0.8927876353263855,
-0.06264512985944748,
0.8512621521949768,
0.3895532190799713,
-0.6451102495193481,
0.5111228227615356,
0.7345860004425049,
-0.10940435528755188,
0.3477056920528412,
0.521065890789032,
-0.13293534517288208,
-0.2773774266242981,
-0.12793965637683868,
-0.3664751946926117,
1.0346074104309082,
0.7445864081382751,
-0.023445559665560722,
-0.1533179134130478,
-0.12067267298698425,
0.08915185928344727,
0.12783117592334747,
-0.3767836093902588,
0.5981996655464172,
0.3633222281932831,
-0.6896523833274841,
0.6501591205596924,
0.12651759386062622,
0.8820211887359619,
-0.28551727533340454,
0.044009823352098465,
0.021785251796245575,
0.004584009293466806,
-0.6109675765037537,
-0.7048399448394775,
0.5050199627876282,
-0.11672840267419815,
0.009536624886095524,
-0.051342979073524475,
0.4792695939540863,
-0.11676511913537979,
-0.48232173919677734,
0.004531582351773977,
0.9058231711387634,
0.4473671615123749,
0.20339007675647736,
-0.4051378071308136,
0.01252001617103815,
-0.036558847874403,
-0.2258460968732834,
0.08195210248231888,
0.5696752071380615,
-0.030375579372048378,
0.4276437759399414,
0.3677152693271637,
0.1803673356771469,
-0.0740814208984375,
0.015858113765716553,
0.5898624062538147,
-0.6765595078468323,
-0.1485704928636551,
-1.1341127157211304,
0.39992454648017883,
0.3555472791194916,
-0.44994083046913147,
0.6191319823265076,
0.5287714600563049,
0.8388150334358215,
0.05724528059363365,
0.5854677557945251,
-0.08198323845863342,
0.4387165606021881,
-0.6522502303123474,
0.3216557800769806,
-0.528927743434906,
0.33583390712738037,
-0.2209453135728836,
-0.9036266207695007,
-0.5077857375144958,
0.6686574816703796,
-0.11978820711374283,
-0.0348651222884655,
0.7273480892181396,
0.6162546277046204,
-0.057970430701971054,
-0.16122275590896606,
0.04913453385233879,
0.4438510239124298,
0.2125403732061386,
0.8869611620903015,
1.20195734500885,
-0.3857179582118988,
0.34432899951934814,
-0.03861626610159874,
0.08954011648893356,
0.18733829259872437,
-0.8759443163871765,
-0.9789084792137146,
-0.5666606426239014,
-0.45128002762794495,
-0.6156489253044128,
-0.16197071969509125,
0.8251008987426758,
0.46872058510780334,
-0.7989376187324524,
-0.06306301802396774,
-0.38311484456062317,
0.34296223521232605,
0.047757238149642944,
-0.18529029190540314,
0.60169517993927,
-0.3521753251552582,
-0.7036933302879333,
0.574016273021698,
0.17492689192295074,
0.0742306038737297,
-0.3751406669616699,
0.2709692716598511,
-0.12785454094409943,
0.11411993950605392,
0.5733639597892761,
0.35260888934135437,
-1.1016560792922974,
-0.4432436227798462,
-0.2952297031879425,
-0.15641947090625763,
0.22346186637878418,
0.6716336607933044,
-0.6564434170722961,
-0.06547275185585022,
0.399024099111557,
0.8391303420066833,
0.24639363586902618,
-0.18547682464122772,
0.5494080185890198,
-0.7612389922142029,
0.16111350059509277,
0.05290190875530243,
0.5563450455665588,
0.5324823260307312,
-0.28239285945892334,
0.7681213021278381,
0.36229273676872253,
-0.32710781693458557,
-0.8481352925300598,
0.7009034752845764,
-0.8365688323974609,
-0.46510079503059387,
1.2588931322097778,
0.14266622066497803,
-0.22922594845294952,
-0.3694293200969696,
-0.027624016627669334,
-0.17183025181293488,
0.3009057939052582,
0.7449238896369934,
1.130959153175354,
-0.24445104598999023,
0.18739646673202515,
-0.870358407497406,
0.588221549987793,
0.4567236602306366,
-0.5132226943969727,
-0.2846178710460663,
0.4447970688343048,
0.20200425386428833,
0.3917659521102905,
0.46456506848335266,
-0.1076463833451271,
0.0813300684094429,
0.027245953679084778,
-0.2581183612346649,
0.09063511341810226,
-0.12144192308187485,
-0.2253790646791458,
0.4786564111709595,
0.47967299818992615,
-0.02571188658475876
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17752v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17752v3
|
Can multiple-choice questions really be useful in detecting the abilities of LLMs?
| 2024-03-26T14:43:48 | 2024-05-23T13:32:25 |
Wangyue Li, Liangzhi Li, Tong Xiang, Xiao Liu, Wei Deng, Noa Garcia
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multiple-choice questions (MCQs) are widely used in the evaluation of large
language models (LLMs) due to their simplicity and efficiency. However, there
are concerns about whether MCQs can truly measure LLM's capabilities,
particularly in knowledge-intensive scenarios where long-form generation (LFG)
answers are required. The misalignment between the task and the evaluation
method demands a thoughtful analysis of MCQ's efficacy, which we undertake in
this paper by evaluating nine LLMs on four question-answering (QA) datasets in
two languages: Chinese and English. We identify a significant issue: LLMs
exhibit an order sensitivity in bilingual MCQs, favoring answers located at
specific positions, i.e., the first position. We further quantify the gap
between MCQs and long-form generation questions (LFGQs) by comparing their
direct outputs, token logits, and embeddings. Our results reveal a relatively
low correlation between answers from MCQs and LFGQs for identical questions.
Additionally, we propose two methods to quantify the consistency and confidence
of LLMs' output, which can be generalized to other QA evaluation benchmarks.
Notably, our analysis challenges the idea that the higher the consistency, the
greater the accuracy. We also find MCQs to be less reliable than LFGQs in terms
of expected calibration error. Finally, the misalignment between MCQs and LFGQs
is not only reflected in the evaluation performance but also in the embedding
space. Our code and models can be accessed at
https://github.com/Meetyou-AI-Lab/Can-MC-Evaluate-LLMs.
|
[
-0.4552549123764038,
-0.8835435509681702,
0.8591411113739014,
0.2093040496110916,
-0.08411629498004913,
0.14097769558429718,
-0.07679854333400726,
-0.3370403051376343,
0.019084211438894272,
0.28941360116004944,
-0.4101158678531647,
-0.25550031661987305,
-0.5704030394554138,
0.29344990849494934,
-0.12585829198360443,
0.5147606134414673,
-0.15231801569461823,
0.29225635528564453,
-0.6044556498527527,
-0.45821166038513184,
-0.5322378277778625,
-0.4620346128940582,
-0.7650984525680542,
-0.18011486530303955,
0.5640783309936523,
0.25909706950187683,
0.8739882707595825,
0.4408614933490753,
0.435381144285202,
0.20751173794269562,
-0.037448085844516754,
0.46538010239601135,
-0.20311790704727173,
0.16288791596889496,
0.07654432952404022,
-0.59364253282547,
-0.41583704948425293,
-0.044033776968717575,
0.8446123600006104,
0.5328920483589172,
-0.0022407816722989082,
0.3605795204639435,
0.12391402572393417,
0.6107568740844727,
-0.5634897947311401,
-0.13840198516845703,
-0.5068989992141724,
0.035617392510175705,
-0.18912865221500397,
-0.11882977187633514,
-0.23967759311199188,
-0.4157457649707794,
-0.12300250679254532,
-0.05967915058135986,
-0.11453685909509659,
0.13064053654670715,
0.7518759369850159,
0.2982361614704132,
-0.5877377986907959,
-0.40497303009033203,
-0.5280594825744629,
0.856879711151123,
-0.8534664511680603,
0.4984875023365021,
0.2744118273258209,
0.5098807215690613,
-0.24876858294010162,
-0.2823866307735443,
-0.7293374538421631,
-0.3911653459072113,
0.051774438470602036,
0.4145006835460663,
0.17273320257663727,
-0.09100024402141571,
0.40817928314208984,
0.24629908800125122,
-0.6797015070915222,
0.3652864396572113,
-0.11355007439851761,
-0.35377827286720276,
0.7843161225318909,
0.2931288480758667,
0.4829370677471161,
-0.25437578558921814,
-0.3743339478969574,
-0.021659430116415024,
-0.7117016315460205,
0.482076495885849,
0.4686015844345093,
0.1694849580526352,
0.18897782266139984,
0.8380297422409058,
0.04729228466749191,
0.6292264461517334,
0.034540046006441116,
-0.3529842793941498,
0.14549189805984497,
-0.5337781310081482,
-0.08611387759447098,
-0.2889305651187897,
0.803975522518158,
0.2381521761417389,
0.25551655888557434,
0.12714315950870514,
-0.1999371349811554,
-0.18424056470394135,
0.05880130082368851,
-0.5140027403831482,
0.18756911158561707,
0.5544291734695435,
-0.26086437702178955,
0.03696382790803909,
0.18560250103473663,
-0.36301925778388977,
-0.260793000459671,
-0.1232786625623703,
0.48822349309921265,
-0.15793567895889282,
-0.29139676690101624,
0.052274592220783234,
-0.09487420320510864,
0.5054259896278381,
0.0027991263195872307,
-0.5938295722007751,
0.04726770520210266,
0.6664860844612122,
0.5733880400657654,
-0.4314882457256317,
-0.5607331395149231,
-0.5224580764770508,
-0.08373051136732101,
-0.31322115659713745,
0.6725778579711914,
-0.3172200620174408,
-0.37123745679855347,
-0.08279877156019211,
-0.017770571634173393,
-0.4585370123386383,
-0.7265840172767639,
0.47467514872550964,
-0.5961970686912537,
0.1790306568145752,
-0.4576716721057892,
-0.5180538296699524,
0.1509426385164261,
0.5218507647514343,
-0.7785856127738953,
1.1160129308700562,
0.06754309684038162,
-0.6997022032737732,
0.3568284213542938,
-0.35049545764923096,
-0.23370607197284698,
-0.20430460572242737,
-0.5587862133979797,
-0.5265580415725708,
-0.13005152344703674,
0.296891450881958,
0.5131200551986694,
-0.20042955875396729,
0.35354384779930115,
-0.4401877820491791,
-0.33382540941238403,
0.7428821921348572,
-0.7143649458885193,
0.9302070140838623,
0.007920646108686924,
-0.27970951795578003,
-0.23532749712467194,
-0.5192439556121826,
0.36989668011665344,
0.11229834705591202,
-0.6755650639533997,
0.0033065290190279484,
0.054648470133543015,
-0.5523141026496887,
0.43605563044548035,
0.2333238273859024,
-0.3762844502925873,
-0.02183220349252224,
-0.18872494995594025,
0.1250959187746048,
0.6529293656349182,
0.06503146886825562,
0.14847587049007416,
-0.689757764339447,
0.8783596754074097,
0.07059574127197266,
0.23719704151153564,
0.1630570888519287,
-0.6864171624183655,
-0.6404479742050171,
-0.08400560170412064,
0.2804340124130249,
0.6710071563720703,
-0.8857532143592834,
0.28787416219711304,
-0.1645449548959732,
-0.47821980714797974,
-0.5655058026313782,
0.37743550539016724,
0.45130282640457153,
0.27303072810173035,
0.1447201520204544,
-0.16580836474895477,
-0.21394562721252441,
-0.867453932762146,
-0.37912628054618835,
-0.28280216455459595,
-0.005640385206788778,
0.49136480689048767,
0.4941990077495575,
-0.059206344187259674,
0.7748630046844482,
-0.09100621938705444,
0.2805424928665161,
-0.12344135344028473,
-0.21445439755916595,
0.22601766884326935,
0.1866634339094162,
0.5988847613334656,
-0.735444962978363,
-0.3149121403694153,
-0.27156367897987366,
-0.7293134331703186,
-0.10832575708627701,
0.0188145749270916,
-0.22610315680503845,
0.05825440585613251,
0.32811489701271057,
-0.7503154873847961,
0.03245719522237778,
0.5915853381156921,
-0.11081863939762115,
0.8030582666397095,
-0.02043842524290085,
0.33422014117240906,
-0.9423568844795227,
-0.09171785414218903,
-0.27330824732780457,
-0.05175420641899109,
-0.5961652398109436,
0.18320412933826447,
0.2897413671016693,
0.2024890035390854,
-0.6291166543960571,
0.554927408695221,
-0.4243556261062622,
-0.1404096931219101,
0.14205552637577057,
0.4207356870174408,
0.02539960667490959,
0.24188411235809326,
-0.3040418326854706,
0.8932983875274658,
0.29055389761924744,
-0.7025898694992065,
0.268047571182251,
-0.12408296018838882,
-0.46315744519233704,
0.5232391953468323,
-0.5019999146461487,
0.33071181178092957,
-0.1845436841249466,
0.008112309500575066,
-1.3507927656173706,
-0.07800357788801193,
0.33081698417663574,
-0.6357759833335876,
0.20338240265846252,
0.14317870140075684,
-0.5850935578346252,
-0.5400011539459229,
-0.43050822615623474,
0.4919419586658478,
0.2457004189491272,
-0.3595787584781647,
0.5246633887290955,
0.15843771398067474,
-0.03901536017656326,
-0.8955763578414917,
-0.6689094305038452,
-0.23988285660743713,
-0.25464311242103577,
-0.7920273542404175,
-0.07715047150850296,
-0.41739389300346375,
-0.28174784779548645,
-0.2754569947719574,
-0.18489375710487366,
-0.007933404296636581,
0.34697312116622925,
0.05635424703359604,
0.15804141759872437,
-0.4461604952812195,
0.2873997688293457,
0.17580285668373108,
0.13142970204353333,
0.21956460177898407,
0.041288357228040695,
0.31587734818458557,
-0.1081763431429863,
-0.7946479320526123,
0.0932857096195221,
0.09453194588422775,
0.6914355754852295,
-0.31404173374176025,
0.498752236366272,
0.6381874680519104,
-0.2499692440032959,
-0.16790586709976196,
-0.6960891485214233,
0.15874259173870087,
-0.43966546654701233,
0.3070337474346161,
-0.5035797953605652,
-0.9162180423736572,
0.6472308039665222,
0.1705055683851242,
0.1660432666540146,
0.5833691358566284,
0.6092755198478699,
-0.23420727252960205,
1.313759684562683,
0.1325514018535614,
0.08074353635311127,
0.08297831565141678,
-0.09125856310129166,
0.1976476013660431,
-0.9094035029411316,
-0.20722004771232605,
-0.564574122428894,
-0.2820117473602295,
-0.45007264614105225,
-0.4619310796260834,
0.38902968168258667,
0.2709181010723114,
-0.18645022809505463,
-0.06544031202793121,
-0.12263959646224976,
0.48897382616996765,
0.28994816541671753,
0.05951116606593132,
0.23458193242549896,
-0.342700719833374,
-0.3291161060333252,
0.10549858957529068,
-0.848671019077301,
-0.823253333568573,
1.2144935131072998,
0.36698636412620544,
0.3722551763057709,
0.3146102726459503,
0.7679327130317688,
0.016617031767964363,
0.297600120306015,
-0.8077274560928345,
0.529547929763794,
0.013998596929013729,
-0.6875102519989014,
-0.6213656663894653,
-0.348403662443161,
-0.969954788684845,
0.40366193652153015,
-0.10205987095832825,
-0.45218178629875183,
-0.04836754873394966,
-0.07955323904752731,
-0.5891740322113037,
0.15963812172412872,
-0.6232030391693115,
0.7898680567741394,
-0.8329741954803467,
-0.19523011147975922,
0.2532787322998047,
-0.38728025555610657,
0.5086183547973633,
-0.2363215833902359,
0.29437631368637085,
-0.2843128442764282,
-0.11618184298276901,
0.7911101579666138,
-0.0960458368062973,
0.46681517362594604,
-0.05910082533955574,
-0.36852335929870605,
0.5480533838272095,
-0.026238173246383667,
0.13026125729084015,
0.23523078858852386,
-0.3046739995479584,
-0.04404425248503685,
0.2993282675743103,
-0.4978523552417755,
-0.8856879472732544,
0.6972465515136719,
-0.7277516722679138,
-0.8720353841781616,
-0.1913013458251953,
-0.38791805505752563,
-0.3232070505619049,
0.1585800051689148,
0.12977401912212372,
0.20795439183712006,
-0.131321519613266,
-0.07929348945617676,
0.606556236743927,
-0.2495216280221939,
0.3799312710762024,
0.33951470255851746,
-0.2765985429286957,
-0.3223802447319031,
0.7670818567276001,
0.47066444158554077,
0.5374998450279236,
0.2630433738231659,
0.2195439636707306,
-0.45758697390556335,
-0.6208692193031311,
-0.6145473718643188,
0.3496403396129608,
-0.6951414346694946,
-0.11371086537837982,
-0.36794695258140564,
-0.28162407875061035,
-0.29752206802368164,
0.1492350846529007,
-0.0660986676812172,
-0.2857848107814789,
-0.3566984534263611,
-0.08007282018661499,
-0.26607638597488403,
0.5712376236915588,
0.2596389949321747,
-0.08579126745462418,
-0.7380461096763611,
0.42442214488983154,
0.7362289428710938,
0.22180378437042236,
0.09167308360338211,
-0.41163545846939087,
-0.06737874448299408,
0.36113449931144714,
-0.3958473205566406,
-1.0449978113174438,
0.0109183918684721,
0.017105115577578545,
0.9577399492263794,
0.38601216673851013,
-0.10540253669023514,
0.5982488989830017,
-0.22688865661621094,
1.0254839658737183,
-0.1444764882326126,
-0.7463849782943726,
0.36074715852737427,
-0.0700216144323349,
0.3850995600223541,
0.6549375653266907,
0.5450912117958069,
-0.34662213921546936,
-0.5929586887359619,
-0.5376707911491394,
-0.4630545973777771,
0.39753246307373047,
0.15283207595348358,
0.10398077964782715,
-0.23429939150810242,
0.38236093521118164,
0.09082391858100891,
0.1347844898700714,
-0.6754827499389648,
-0.2593574523925781,
0.14849628508090973,
-0.015955697745084763,
-0.1659443974494934,
-0.3157025873661041,
0.04207608103752136,
0.00815545953810215,
0.3923601806163788,
-0.11290378868579865,
0.23537661135196686,
0.26454561948776245,
-0.14786964654922485,
-0.0012344156857579947,
0.48467594385147095,
0.6568601727485657,
0.8946487307548523,
-0.17208875715732574,
0.2563018500804901,
0.45305606722831726,
-0.21525327861309052,
0.21544389426708221,
-0.2188923954963684,
-0.048601727932691574,
-0.02174406312406063,
0.44178691506385803,
0.3445284068584442,
-0.09801747649908066,
-0.7638267874717712,
0.6705276370048523,
-0.022488266229629517,
-0.19381935894489288,
-0.3200335204601288,
0.14790324866771698,
0.18132838606834412,
0.34774887561798096,
0.3086545765399933,
-0.23155656456947327,
-0.08504364639520645,
-0.7091695070266724,
0.13625113666057587,
0.664455235004425,
-0.25750601291656494,
-0.04259059578180313,
0.4381212592124939,
-0.04242365434765816,
-0.4951811134815216,
0.6189345121383667,
-0.27136892080307007,
-0.706876277923584,
1.0325125455856323,
0.43331843614578247,
0.6155309081077576,
-0.3089527189731598,
0.17662659287452698,
0.19196294248104095,
0.4519709348678589,
-0.1311091184616089,
0.6814413666725159,
-0.03209715336561203,
-0.9886853694915771,
-0.39201855659484863,
-0.4206175208091736,
-0.37776029109954834,
0.1058414876461029,
-0.5364724397659302,
0.21698114275932312,
-0.38129428029060364,
-0.4685502052307129,
-0.20793095231056213,
0.0487109012901783,
-0.8125943541526794,
0.07037262618541718,
0.155600443482399,
0.6297343373298645,
-0.8006622195243835,
0.4755801558494568,
0.6363587975502014,
-0.3034069538116455,
-0.8400048017501831,
-0.11313082277774811,
-0.15172308683395386,
-0.9297038912773132,
0.5545767545700073,
0.21091127395629883,
-0.19557830691337585,
-0.24908530712127686,
-0.45731320977211,
-0.8687944412231445,
1.4436039924621582,
0.29361578822135925,
-0.3813815414905548,
0.12725183367729187,
0.47034355998039246,
0.5992827415466309,
-0.383447527885437,
0.5722081661224365,
0.5853456854820251,
0.6296611428260803,
-0.28645652532577515,
-1.1613292694091797,
0.04209880903363228,
-0.13925105333328247,
-0.19642774760723114,
0.11004959791898727,
-0.824069619178772,
0.7779902219772339,
-0.3082641363143921,
-0.3980482220649719,
0.13413037359714508,
0.3523317277431488,
0.708411455154419,
0.48006290197372437,
0.48136818408966064,
0.32430341839790344,
0.8825616240501404,
-0.058936990797519684,
0.9759812951087952,
-0.2015790492296219,
0.23125073313713074,
0.7942638397216797,
-0.23169668018817902,
0.9849973917007446,
0.6545884609222412,
-0.39149752259254456,
0.2269110232591629,
0.6539485454559326,
0.09480169415473938,
-0.04816335067152977,
0.5470259785652161,
0.0752267837524414,
-0.4665749967098236,
0.11833284050226212,
-0.3260907828807831,
0.2715146243572235,
0.2445547878742218,
-0.2713266611099243,
0.11335521936416626,
-0.0783643051981926,
-0.03892460837960243,
-0.13155139982700348,
-0.13400253653526306,
0.39824193716049194,
0.2382126897573471,
-0.7880039215087891,
0.7246154546737671,
-0.1490057110786438,
0.5457759499549866,
-0.43398356437683105,
0.07113084942102432,
-0.395819753408432,
-0.23399104177951813,
-0.31172606348991394,
-0.9730443954467773,
-0.03729256987571716,
-0.17208674550056458,
0.045542214065790176,
-0.07481830567121506,
0.5654180645942688,
-0.4006462097167969,
-0.4895610511302948,
0.2721930146217346,
1.1727043390274048,
0.2400800585746765,
0.12061707675457001,
-0.8094398975372314,
-0.16955769062042236,
-0.08411054313182831,
-0.18869081139564514,
0.2425748109817505,
0.3027091324329376,
-0.04209037870168686,
0.7915271520614624,
0.5537427663803101,
0.06357985734939575,
0.35694584250450134,
0.2146722823381424,
0.3953271210193634,
-0.4981765151023865,
-0.04273926839232445,
-0.8559866547584534,
0.49947798252105713,
0.15441007912158966,
-0.3584585189819336,
0.894798755645752,
0.5563997030258179,
0.9204899072647095,
0.02808510512113571,
0.7035936713218689,
0.24670128524303436,
0.36257386207580566,
-0.7605106830596924,
0.49291786551475525,
-0.6120813488960266,
0.5047113299369812,
-0.18435335159301758,
-1.0652068853378296,
-0.26598072052001953,
0.20071455836296082,
-0.34346505999565125,
0.2616981863975525,
0.7653711438179016,
0.8631354570388794,
-0.014585207216441631,
-0.28604939579963684,
0.5049505829811096,
-0.031230458989739418,
0.22559799253940582,
0.7838584780693054,
1.4261143207550049,
-0.43442580103874207,
0.6341415047645569,
-0.13687153160572052,
-0.029328513890504837,
0.07279618829488754,
-0.6679384112358093,
-0.9577476382255554,
-0.4588489830493927,
-0.2484104037284851,
-0.21857625246047974,
-0.1436028629541397,
0.6619890332221985,
0.17168840765953064,
-0.6622645854949951,
-0.40506380796432495,
0.4527720510959625,
0.5164293646812439,
-0.2572551667690277,
-0.22456400096416473,
0.4650198817253113,
-0.17107099294662476,
-0.6137775182723999,
0.28471609950065613,
0.028173230588436127,
0.26371321082115173,
-0.47804200649261475,
-0.1879078596830368,
-0.19854184985160828,
0.09085472673177719,
0.6479517221450806,
0.15636038780212402,
-0.9237258434295654,
-0.5045825839042664,
0.4512331485748291,
-0.1830243468284607,
0.0257877167314291,
0.6282901167869568,
-0.43524277210235596,
0.3545858561992645,
0.5787662863731384,
0.7965065240859985,
0.07779671251773834,
0.13199259340763092,
0.36967235803604126,
-0.4893072247505188,
-0.5621451139450073,
0.2802754044532776,
0.4319877624511719,
0.15215475857257843,
-0.28418609499931335,
0.2967930734157562,
-0.1442970186471939,
-0.6980429887771606,
-0.7031528949737549,
0.26269739866256714,
-0.9137158989906311,
-0.11114891618490219,
1.4100408554077148,
-0.03091280534863472,
-0.04082604497671127,
-0.18164651095867157,
-0.19741205871105194,
0.1330592930316925,
-0.010036177933216095,
0.6998104453086853,
1.077337622642517,
-0.38742154836654663,
-0.14783351123332977,
-0.6992770433425903,
0.2691885232925415,
0.6330385208129883,
-0.6649872064590454,
-0.27387216687202454,
0.35710200667381287,
0.21157580614089966,
0.3066186010837555,
0.7274864315986633,
-0.12710599601268768,
0.46914801001548767,
-0.324734628200531,
-0.4570579528808594,
-0.02082221396267414,
-0.11292441189289093,
-0.5896198749542236,
0.21372133493423462,
0.47671765089035034,
-0.13095588982105255
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17748v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17748v1
|
UCxn: Typologically Informed Annotation of Constructions Atop Universal Dependencies
| 2024-03-26T14:40:10 | 2024-03-26T14:40:10 |
Leonie Weissweiler, Nina Böbel, Kirian Guiller, Santiago Herrera, Wesley Scivetti, Arthur Lorenzi, Nurit Melnik, Archna Bhatia, Hinrich Schütze, Lori Levin, Amir Zeldes, Joakim Nivre, William Croft, Nathan Schneider
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The Universal Dependencies (UD) project has created an invaluable collection
of treebanks with contributions in over 140 languages. However, the UD
annotations do not tell the full story. Grammatical constructions that convey
meaning through a particular combination of several morphosyntactic elements --
for example, interrogative sentences with special markers and/or word orders --
are not labeled holistically. We argue for (i) augmenting UD annotations with a
'UCxn' annotation layer for such meaning-bearing grammatical constructions, and
(ii) approaching this in a typologically informed way so that morphosyntactic
strategies can be compared across languages. As a case study, we consider five
construction families in ten languages, identifying instances of each
construction in UD treebanks through the use of morphosyntactic patterns. In
addition to findings regarding these particular constructions, our study yields
important insights on methodology for describing and identifying constructions
in language-general and language-particular ways, and lays the foundation for
future constructional enrichment of UD treebanks.
|
[
-0.3511991500854492,
-0.27693700790405273,
0.6602893471717834,
0.23994815349578857,
-0.33763936161994934,
0.2825130522251129,
-0.031346797943115234,
-0.8262040019035339,
0.3959946930408478,
0.5797554850578308,
-0.32314497232437134,
-0.5190830230712891,
-0.34107881784439087,
0.19440202414989471,
-0.2663518786430359,
0.9655244946479797,
-0.01587119698524475,
-0.3192294239997864,
-0.05669292062520981,
-0.2830328345298767,
-0.0008136666147038341,
-0.8997219800949097,
-0.051880285143852234,
-0.30907100439071655,
0.5695509314537048,
-0.010582190938293934,
0.8276892900466919,
1.1817467212677002,
0.13218748569488525,
0.3145906627178192,
-0.5571468472480774,
-0.03876626864075661,
0.0583733506500721,
0.18645745515823364,
-0.23820926249027252,
-0.4150560200214386,
-0.1881430298089981,
-0.09464798867702484,
0.5450360178947449,
1.214402198791504,
0.14512909948825836,
0.2499302327632904,
0.2147894650697708,
0.4788517355918884,
-0.743721067905426,
0.5584307312965393,
-0.5233156681060791,
0.1725718379020691,
-0.6532106995582581,
-0.22213870286941528,
-0.32680952548980713,
0.08171214908361435,
0.24520863592624664,
-0.3909408748149872,
0.01181334350258112,
-0.14330774545669556,
0.8312363028526306,
0.019313624128699303,
-0.3791021704673767,
-0.057887088507413864,
-0.6746038198471069,
0.516741931438446,
-0.4662095010280609,
0.16681508719921112,
0.3462606966495514,
-0.2641952633857727,
-0.2854091227054596,
-0.40370309352874756,
0.014573296532034874,
-0.2663368582725525,
-0.37943607568740845,
0.33637377619743347,
-0.03990268334746361,
0.5041419863700867,
0.18475951254367828,
0.3920820653438568,
-0.3977315127849579,
0.24543701112270355,
-0.06742636114358902,
-0.37297508120536804,
0.5255742073059082,
-0.0717853233218193,
0.45111948251724243,
-0.7884783744812012,
-0.3292001783847809,
0.18596979975700378,
-1.0141940116882324,
-0.014954742975533009,
0.4424129128456116,
0.46097737550735474,
-0.12212305516004562,
0.7209869623184204,
-0.23704543709754944,
0.6889735460281372,
-0.19553495943546295,
0.1741267740726471,
0.045588649809360504,
-0.4588715136051178,
-0.11083435267210007,
0.0572676919400692,
0.6306192874908447,
-0.08110553026199341,
0.646235466003418,
-0.558845043182373,
0.004985011648386717,
0.16833551228046417,
0.2005998194217682,
-0.2852063775062561,
-0.33868101239204407,
-0.04882042109966278,
-0.1742733120918274,
-0.4120858907699585,
0.5199187994003296,
-0.5751165151596069,
0.00624433159828186,
-0.45769232511520386,
-0.02233322337269783,
-0.043835803866386414,
-0.3514029383659363,
-0.19541098177433014,
-0.04103431478142738,
-0.12022369354963303,
0.15834304690361023,
-0.835315465927124,
0.008570137433707714,
0.7430354356765747,
0.6433769464492798,
0.2560961842536926,
-0.2799188494682312,
-0.40747854113578796,
0.33348798751831055,
-0.2580127418041229,
1.050574779510498,
-0.7628619074821472,
-0.492587685585022,
0.3238869607448578,
0.00456578703597188,
0.13562911748886108,
-0.3447743356227875,
0.3472416400909424,
-0.12983909249305725,
0.40986770391464233,
-0.12792564928531647,
-0.45924630761146545,
-0.2895940840244293,
-0.048699960112571716,
-0.4996649920940399,
0.9450265765190125,
0.5168699026107788,
-0.5805360078811646,
0.2872122824192047,
-0.5184006094932556,
-0.6371243000030518,
0.5535102486610413,
-0.5017179846763611,
0.003128018230199814,
0.5055052638053894,
-0.25115469098091125,
0.46370232105255127,
0.25224509835243225,
0.2244175225496292,
-0.19599489867687225,
0.053718991577625275,
0.02761024236679077,
-0.018005428835749626,
1.3241571187973022,
-0.015655411407351494,
-0.7367068529129028,
-0.034514378756284714,
-0.9053850769996643,
-0.014183376915752888,
-0.22419659793376923,
-0.5005751252174377,
-0.6497530937194824,
-0.019032582640647888,
0.04549279436469078,
0.11453317850828171,
-0.17186518013477325,
-0.5311296582221985,
0.45213037729263306,
-0.46284249424934387,
0.38441652059555054,
0.8895512223243713,
-0.24629764258861542,
0.28933683037757874,
-0.13951265811920166,
0.5577378869056702,
-0.2502731382846832,
-0.014538980089128017,
-0.26794445514678955,
-0.6920859813690186,
-0.6471689343452454,
-0.020934801548719406,
0.5197977423667908,
0.39338019490242004,
-0.4442735016345978,
0.4159216582775116,
-0.17724618315696716,
-0.14802871644496918,
-0.05277102440595627,
0.13412058353424072,
0.7950981855392456,
0.22129078209400177,
0.1523713320493698,
-0.3604992628097534,
-0.9428225159645081,
-0.6867990493774414,
0.10236874967813492,
-0.7949182391166687,
0.1751682311296463,
0.1412891149520874,
0.4180460572242737,
-0.12058810889720917,
0.8434062600135803,
-0.2803332805633545,
-0.25060662627220154,
-0.14502398669719696,
0.4607103168964386,
-0.1320013850927353,
0.23108269274234772,
0.9483864307403564,
-0.571453869342804,
-0.36589428782463074,
0.40752431750297546,
-0.4199824333190918,
-0.2823466360569,
-0.16785435378551483,
0.03217937424778938,
0.263542503118515,
0.4158160984516144,
-0.6573501229286194,
0.40240487456321716,
0.396138459444046,
-0.6414369344711304,
0.8678110837936401,
-0.09834912419319153,
-0.2361089140176773,
-1.0530670881271362,
-0.17734917998313904,
-0.23870255053043365,
-0.13584505021572113,
-0.34025317430496216,
0.22487978637218475,
-0.2267095148563385,
0.576607882976532,
-0.2818153500556946,
0.46290063858032227,
-0.6219329237937927,
0.03496641665697098,
-0.04553110525012016,
-0.09458573907613754,
0.030950045213103294,
0.42543765902519226,
0.03449200466275215,
0.4804200828075409,
0.4087943434715271,
-0.4525604546070099,
0.25998201966285706,
0.26832419633865356,
-0.3461773991584778,
0.49647799134254456,
-0.2958613634109497,
-0.08207176625728607,
-0.1448940485715866,
0.03433145955204964,
-0.8371574878692627,
-0.3597387373447418,
0.3381425142288208,
-0.3392404317855835,
0.0908774882555008,
-0.5405396819114685,
-0.6255984902381897,
-0.31566160917282104,
-0.21927903592586517,
0.24922005832195282,
0.1915808767080307,
-0.6502358317375183,
0.48366034030914307,
0.26153314113616943,
-0.09797738492488861,
-0.40931200981140137,
-0.6252709031105042,
0.2196090817451477,
-0.30337613821029663,
-0.4746529161930084,
0.5204197764396667,
-0.14386741816997528,
-0.719528317451477,
0.1299435943365097,
-0.15024180710315704,
-0.22511228919029236,
0.42457476258277893,
0.5431162714958191,
0.3872527480125427,
-0.3781195878982544,
0.20959590375423431,
0.025799429044127464,
-0.10306031256914139,
0.062162529677152634,
-0.4341660141944885,
0.262139230966568,
0.036241576075553894,
-0.07998249679803848,
-0.1479751169681549,
0.5673698782920837,
0.5027912259101868,
-0.1793171763420105,
0.2488686740398407,
0.145016148686409,
-0.3888515532016754,
-0.07642246037721634,
-0.5946162939071655,
0.26052314043045044,
-0.35534512996673584,
0.07949227094650269,
-0.5604416131973267,
-0.9504138827323914,
0.39784878492355347,
0.00869760476052761,
0.11157681792974472,
0.581778883934021,
0.24911943078041077,
-0.42174407839775085,
1.0974414348602295,
0.7393462061882019,
-0.10432519763708115,
0.44204431772232056,
-0.19443106651306152,
-0.3039211332798004,
-0.7751195430755615,
-0.12666454911231995,
-0.7038255929946899,
0.06954299658536911,
-0.6840181946754456,
0.1848783642053604,
-0.0036056251265108585,
0.10050633549690247,
-0.06850434094667435,
0.8806201815605164,
-0.4132995307445526,
0.3866278827190399,
0.45426201820373535,
-0.3302442729473114,
0.6244527101516724,
0.1365625113248825,
-0.4612598121166229,
0.2045302391052246,
-0.4815129339694977,
-0.5081716775894165,
1.0204190015792847,
-0.17995354533195496,
0.31361067295074463,
0.0968114510178566,
0.6513590216636658,
0.2404860109090805,
0.33621275424957275,
-0.5808622241020203,
0.3399660885334015,
-0.36648133397102356,
-0.4535583257675171,
0.04304276034235954,
-0.3732258379459381,
-1.3344998359680176,
0.2507094144821167,
-0.1431698352098465,
-1.2200020551681519,
0.3174437880516052,
0.033593129366636276,
-0.6862263679504395,
0.22065934538841248,
-0.6806714534759521,
0.5131461024284363,
-0.42215433716773987,
0.12813547253608704,
0.0577683299779892,
-0.48283126950263977,
0.06110578030347824,
0.22374625504016876,
0.20884141325950623,
-0.09918086230754852,
0.15932342410087585,
0.3259449005126953,
-0.5138598084449768,
0.9566287994384766,
0.2877620756626129,
-0.2976781725883484,
0.24771392345428467,
0.038650114089250565,
0.3125344216823578,
0.07752968370914459,
0.08658658713102341,
0.21883346140384674,
0.15257665514945984,
-0.2386247217655182,
-0.3709002435207367,
0.46806514263153076,
-0.5974407196044922,
-0.7039723992347717,
-0.4543323516845703,
-0.6008925437927246,
-0.2541312873363495,
0.1657237708568573,
0.5370211601257324,
0.7415218949317932,
-0.09736792743206024,
0.03843291103839874,
0.19479985535144806,
0.5272900462150574,
0.6631991863250732,
0.09112053364515305,
-0.31873857975006104,
-0.18473447859287262,
0.5767583250999451,
0.38866665959358215,
0.1309833973646164,
0.5851735472679138,
0.2422347068786621,
-0.16772326827049255,
-0.5096777081489563,
-0.5364217758178711,
0.2821466326713562,
-0.36571788787841797,
-0.23220837116241455,
-0.40932002663612366,
-0.39447346329689026,
-0.3153444826602936,
-0.23544326424598694,
-0.10439516603946686,
-0.7266684174537659,
-0.24809099733829498,
-0.4105271100997925,
0.3567256033420563,
1.1126108169555664,
-0.24842569231987,
0.3210427463054657,
-0.6831260323524475,
0.12772347033023834,
0.4363654553890228,
0.3583199381828308,
-0.35234448313713074,
0.024492401629686356,
-0.15888383984565735,
0.14804285764694214,
-0.10901924967765808,
-0.6702306270599365,
-0.14741066098213196,
0.15645760297775269,
0.6601150035858154,
0.784653902053833,
-0.16338567435741425,
0.585469663143158,
-0.20446351170539856,
0.5329063534736633,
0.06795112788677216,
-0.916220486164093,
0.7384214997291565,
-0.4186726212501526,
0.2841376066207886,
0.4005048871040344,
0.1525232195854187,
-0.32842957973480225,
-0.5472056269645691,
-0.9018965363502502,
-0.7957838773727417,
0.41327542066574097,
0.2909429371356964,
0.2662542760372162,
-0.05827180668711662,
0.6225489377975464,
0.21221065521240234,
0.05120927095413208,
-0.9207351207733154,
-0.23437543213367462,
-0.05268136039376259,
0.020919183269143105,
0.2872190773487091,
-0.6046280264854431,
-0.0511118583381176,
-0.1525844931602478,
0.4150943160057068,
-0.1121814101934433,
-0.21213677525520325,
0.05014221742749214,
-0.2986263334751129,
-0.08298142999410629,
0.28997907042503357,
0.29770323634147644,
0.843451976776123,
-0.15130779147148132,
0.5085753798484802,
-0.4162445366382599,
-0.5211113691329956,
0.048013947904109955,
0.26904261112213135,
-0.6261605620384216,
0.3059975802898407,
0.7134945392608643,
0.6342897415161133,
0.3370649814605713,
-0.37593188881874084,
0.07304824888706207,
0.35318678617477417,
-0.18207137286663055,
-0.23726600408554077,
0.033227089792490005,
-0.15654347836971283,
0.23664826154708862,
-0.010003607720136642,
-0.0754735916852951,
0.0541628859937191,
-0.7907941937446594,
0.08323205262422562,
0.4910663962364197,
-0.757301390171051,
-0.7590445280075073,
0.29138725996017456,
0.174605131149292,
-0.1626153290271759,
0.5044994354248047,
-0.17104972898960114,
-0.566156804561615,
0.5103362202644348,
0.4346942603588104,
0.9904986023902893,
-0.43366739153862,
0.5887823104858398,
0.2968970537185669,
0.30912911891937256,
-0.019444791600108147,
0.28380465507507324,
-0.4559330940246582,
-0.7239354848861694,
-0.7718245387077332,
-0.4913179278373718,
-0.26326364278793335,
-0.04726918786764145,
-0.6584576964378357,
0.02994483895599842,
-0.2402408868074417,
-0.027827810496091843,
0.23544096946716309,
-0.30338552594184875,
-0.3023536205291748,
0.11983392387628555,
0.3970109522342682,
0.4531877040863037,
-0.6080924272537231,
0.788861870765686,
1.0249378681182861,
-0.5377228260040283,
-0.5298462510108948,
0.01568649150431156,
0.2425031214952469,
-0.5879158973693848,
0.6925298571586609,
0.1963725984096527,
-0.11926744878292084,
-0.1130649596452713,
-0.30194035172462463,
-0.7855744957923889,
0.7981546521186829,
0.5393974781036377,
-0.30242717266082764,
-0.22556443512439728,
0.5325461626052856,
0.4991483688354492,
-0.42988163232803345,
0.09689212590456009,
0.3384498953819275,
0.7512556910514832,
-0.09415005147457123,
-0.7552446126937866,
-0.015240843407809734,
-0.4256785213947296,
0.11741124838590622,
0.39467692375183105,
-0.2452014982700348,
0.4546565115451813,
-0.35018035769462585,
-0.6823337078094482,
0.541446328163147,
0.5575989484786987,
-0.07581352442502975,
-0.21030262112617493,
0.649188220500946,
0.6295219659805298,
0.5062444806098938,
-0.3571391701698303,
0.9319484233856201,
-0.20757922530174255,
0.24726639688014984,
1.2216598987579346,
0.24472256004810333,
0.553298830986023,
0.47380298376083374,
-0.2646818459033966,
0.7521752119064331,
0.6734203100204468,
-0.05993041396141052,
0.19744649529457092,
0.47066277265548706,
-0.3591456413269043,
-0.4265769422054291,
-0.5871137976646423,
-0.4767056107521057,
0.7201684713363647,
0.27275729179382324,
-0.29546859860420227,
-0.45001786947250366,
-0.15316812694072723,
0.46965962648391724,
0.13777126371860504,
-0.26202723383903503,
0.6967541575431824,
0.1472461223602295,
-0.6572991013526917,
0.1677773892879486,
-0.4466884732246399,
0.3606359660625458,
-0.4531234800815582,
-0.09146608412265778,
-0.22931860387325287,
-0.05161820724606514,
-0.3407171964645386,
-0.9324453473091125,
0.42875227332115173,
-0.09307369589805603,
-0.12140671163797379,
-0.3911281228065491,
0.22281290590763092,
-0.2950204312801361,
-0.6132110953330994,
0.6104342341423035,
0.6345821619033813,
-0.1402502804994583,
-0.35793793201446533,
-0.2069389373064041,
-0.32613012194633484,
0.02677186392247677,
-0.016596825793385506,
0.19958063960075378,
0.561957597732544,
-0.25205180048942566,
0.260770320892334,
0.5557676553726196,
0.18483342230319977,
-0.0798603966832161,
0.4466087520122528,
0.492695152759552,
-0.6636753082275391,
-0.3498125970363617,
-0.8590128421783447,
0.840913712978363,
0.159976989030838,
-0.6392800211906433,
0.6613076329231262,
0.3965204656124115,
1.1758029460906982,
0.2066584974527359,
0.8117735981941223,
0.02336425520479679,
-0.06160105764865875,
-0.4275246262550354,
0.3269801139831543,
-0.3517521023750305,
0.18407361209392548,
-0.46062782406806946,
-1.2267475128173828,
-0.7755934596061707,
0.3466946482658386,
0.1354455053806305,
-0.25521814823150635,
0.5544386506080627,
0.290927916765213,
0.05766568332910538,
0.21523062884807587,
0.20309528708457947,
0.4266088604927063,
-0.04912600293755531,
0.23239727318286896,
1.0448346138000488,
0.03645269572734833,
0.8212506175041199,
-0.8600362539291382,
-0.33128276467323303,
-0.10237705707550049,
-0.866084635257721,
-0.8186376094818115,
-0.8359158635139465,
-0.5502059459686279,
-0.2283579707145691,
0.0164061076939106,
0.7543503642082214,
0.6590932607650757,
-0.9633245468139648,
-0.41081511974334717,
-0.4844560921192169,
0.36045917868614197,
-0.38358914852142334,
-0.2347819060087204,
0.45567628741264343,
-0.2425186187028885,
-0.5339424014091492,
0.3821835219860077,
0.8642147183418274,
0.14997290074825287,
-0.2968151271343231,
0.320689857006073,
-0.2115717977285385,
-0.22756464779376984,
0.8696122765541077,
0.46223849058151245,
-0.965864896774292,
-0.6746301651000977,
-0.09100181609392166,
0.2164662480354309,
0.35956910252571106,
0.868128776550293,
-0.673364520072937,
0.4940006136894226,
0.46334952116012573,
0.37247204780578613,
0.06909122318029404,
-0.08855537325143814,
0.4959874153137207,
-0.5624679923057556,
-0.026123786345124245,
-0.005242363084107637,
0.8462348580360413,
0.15454551577568054,
-0.5328758358955383,
0.8845904469490051,
0.44434812664985657,
-0.1618722826242447,
-0.4517628252506256,
0.6422698497772217,
-1.0224084854125977,
-0.18890127539634705,
1.18378746509552,
-0.2737816274166107,
0.08008420467376709,
-0.6509763598442078,
-0.2801865041255951,
-0.05942288413643837,
-0.014112330973148346,
1.0899477005004883,
0.7754769921302795,
-0.3339332938194275,
0.010701281949877739,
-0.0666956827044487,
0.19911350309848785,
0.3747948408126831,
-0.9148539304733276,
0.05477378889918327,
0.5975376963615417,
-0.12386281788349152,
0.6111332178115845,
0.2399507611989975,
-0.15007080137729645,
0.18933050334453583,
-0.26704469323158264,
0.024627774953842163,
0.11903578788042068,
-0.4507911503314972,
0.0945286825299263,
0.209982767701149,
-0.031187662854790688,
-0.1356867253780365
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17733v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17733v1
|
Continual Few-shot Event Detection via Hierarchical Augmentation Networks
| 2024-03-26T14:20:42 | 2024-03-26T14:20:42 |
Chenlong Zhang, Pengfei Cao, Yubo Chen, Kang Liu, Zhiqiang Zhang, Mengshu Sun, Jun Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Traditional continual event detection relies on abundant labeled data for
training, which is often impractical to obtain in real-world applications. In
this paper, we introduce continual few-shot event detection (CFED), a more
commonly encountered scenario when a substantial number of labeled samples are
not accessible. The CFED task is challenging as it involves memorizing previous
event types and learning new event types with few-shot samples. To mitigate
these challenges, we propose a memory-based framework: Hierarchical
Augmentation Networks (HANet). To memorize previous event types with limited
memory, we incorporate prototypical augmentation into the memory set. For the
issue of learning new event types in few-shot scenarios, we propose a
contrastive augmentation module for token representations. Despite comparing
with previous state-of-the-art methods, we also conduct comparisons with
ChatGPT. Experiment results demonstrate that our method significantly
outperforms all of these methods in multiple continual few-shot event detection
tasks.
|
[
-0.14297443628311157,
-0.5698263049125671,
0.3586970567703247,
-0.17027725279331207,
-0.39560139179229736,
0.09710226207971573,
0.0736723393201828,
-0.385159432888031,
0.2060638815164566,
0.04812224209308624,
-0.8255342245101929,
-0.46909788250923157,
-0.40739914774894714,
-0.14581745862960815,
-0.05472787842154503,
0.8812788724899292,
-0.025789683684706688,
-0.42914271354675293,
0.05868087336421013,
-0.3858341574668884,
-0.49058273434638977,
-0.5628663897514343,
-1.317041277885437,
-0.5702191591262817,
0.43352770805358887,
0.5470700263977051,
0.38935911655426025,
0.5211233496665955,
0.5624370574951172,
0.21308661997318268,
-0.1617523580789566,
0.477512925863266,
-0.6244397163391113,
-0.050970856100320816,
0.19477340579032898,
-0.40086326003074646,
-0.22869306802749634,
-0.3416915833950043,
0.8193157315254211,
0.515568196773529,
0.21346768736839294,
-0.22173459827899933,
-0.0095535758882761,
0.3849162757396698,
-0.9290454387664795,
0.03679082542657852,
-0.7400315999984741,
0.6064394116401672,
-0.3562016189098358,
-0.373557448387146,
-0.212077334523201,
0.4399459660053253,
-0.14480595290660858,
-0.7983883619308472,
0.0872315764427185,
0.025848958641290665,
0.65438312292099,
0.2584907114505768,
-0.13077880442142487,
0.13915814459323883,
-0.4240323007106781,
0.7144634127616882,
-0.6295391917228699,
0.09250418096780777,
0.4173724949359894,
0.28318551182746887,
-0.3000090718269348,
-0.8433222770690918,
-0.4555548429489136,
-0.3881807327270508,
-0.11386416852474213,
0.3469715416431427,
-0.39659035205841064,
0.2816920578479767,
0.32974815368652344,
0.032238755375146866,
-0.6813122034072876,
0.3340165913105011,
0.3143782615661621,
-0.33665770292282104,
0.15427379310131073,
0.4583134353160858,
0.09296314418315887,
-0.23398256301879883,
-0.4405606985092163,
0.19848214089870453,
-0.4227103888988495,
-0.20961634814739227,
0.019286898896098137,
0.10220461338758469,
-0.16003111004829407,
0.10317234694957733,
-0.2603410482406616,
0.4489288628101349,
0.45647624135017395,
-0.4662434756755829,
0.20727351307868958,
-0.48281049728393555,
-0.4379781186580658,
-0.09243746846914291,
0.6039648652076721,
-0.017079459503293037,
-0.024849824607372284,
-0.24926124513149261,
-0.14232051372528076,
-0.16570104658603668,
-0.09724818915128708,
-0.7607043981552124,
-0.33428043127059937,
0.1290092170238495,
-0.714042067527771,
-0.19772449135780334,
0.043223436921834946,
-0.4887937903404236,
-0.3725999593734741,
-0.04279172793030739,
0.5262520909309387,
-0.7063214182853699,
-0.10151155292987823,
-0.24862590432167053,
-0.4714663326740265,
0.03350585699081421,
0.30027371644973755,
-0.8209930658340454,
0.25268954038619995,
0.7613054513931274,
1.166914463043213,
-0.5841674208641052,
-0.3322625458240509,
-0.9444016814231873,
0.26922285556793213,
-0.34803134202957153,
1.0452656745910645,
-0.42777514457702637,
-0.32682788372039795,
-0.13673827052116394,
-0.03957950323820114,
0.015614993870258331,
-0.8012582659721375,
0.3063654899597168,
-0.44031044840812683,
-0.17393410205841064,
-0.04382724687457085,
-0.764464259147644,
0.12130605429410934,
0.6925915479660034,
-0.41527634859085083,
1.0195924043655396,
0.019684992730617523,
-0.7543243169784546,
0.6389987468719482,
-0.23118728399276733,
-0.26795637607574463,
0.4880661070346832,
-0.5302745699882507,
-0.7406216859817505,
-0.05788784101605415,
0.27744948863983154,
0.18650825321674347,
0.505666971206665,
-0.02800602838397026,
-0.4246733784675598,
-0.5395339727401733,
-0.13430729508399963,
-0.6433709263801575,
0.3925566077232361,
-0.13920101523399353,
-0.24865217506885529,
0.04400354623794556,
-0.8799439668655396,
-0.3356698155403137,
-0.19568561017513275,
-0.400869756937027,
-0.11636346578598022,
-0.10109484940767288,
0.2063116729259491,
0.18892556428909302,
0.14358533918857574,
-0.56795734167099,
0.14450618624687195,
-0.40446245670318604,
-0.06853501498699188,
0.6799125075340271,
0.501777172088623,
0.4452432692050934,
-0.6014859080314636,
0.48806557059288025,
0.7599326968193054,
0.031719598919153214,
-0.8060670495033264,
-0.2933449149131775,
-0.6403186321258545,
-0.25783437490463257,
-0.33121269941329956,
0.6382157206535339,
-1.1383273601531982,
0.40822842717170715,
-0.010940940119326115,
-0.09426974505186081,
0.30954721570014954,
0.32212063670158386,
0.13674375414848328,
0.7231218218803406,
0.39170223474502563,
-0.2108973264694214,
-0.7570981979370117,
-0.7400150895118713,
-0.04970652610063553,
-0.44452720880508423,
-0.027113910764455795,
0.1844976544380188,
0.7726711630821228,
-0.2818617522716522,
0.88392573595047,
-0.2362838089466095,
-0.5117210149765015,
-0.07693765312433243,
0.45387619733810425,
0.06617281585931778,
0.7267415523529053,
0.5354164838790894,
-0.3668055534362793,
-0.1628686785697937,
0.3499835431575775,
-0.7291378378868103,
0.022961320355534554,
-0.7962878942489624,
0.07528535276651382,
0.2626878619194031,
0.60893714427948,
-0.08738141506910324,
0.6389944553375244,
0.06551854312419891,
0.1051710695028305,
0.5887308120727539,
0.024385839700698853,
0.09803662449121475,
-0.6843771934509277,
-0.07515405863523483,
-0.28200122714042664,
-0.6482770442962646,
-0.5841367840766907,
-0.2194259911775589,
0.10390801727771759,
-0.01955365017056465,
-0.5920597314834595,
0.6901847720146179,
-0.21839149296283722,
-0.1688215732574463,
-0.6952925324440002,
-0.031041529029607773,
-0.1467401385307312,
0.5017767548561096,
0.3356718420982361,
0.3909372389316559,
0.7318494319915771,
-0.4289478361606598,
0.3355385661125183,
0.17650315165519714,
-0.013639161363244057,
0.9570626616477966,
-0.23989319801330566,
0.09753122925758362,
-0.3280097246170044,
0.6379679441452026,
-0.9636178612709045,
-0.3615002930164337,
0.27774885296821594,
-0.3629346191883087,
0.3723852038383484,
-0.5483999848365784,
-0.5724707245826721,
-0.3429342806339264,
-0.4279009997844696,
0.5004626512527466,
0.3865758180618286,
-0.7815011739730835,
0.4535417854785919,
0.08376872539520264,
0.2225717306137085,
-0.48924756050109863,
-1.1432573795318604,
0.20811012387275696,
-0.14029762148857117,
-0.5910933613777161,
0.36958345770835876,
0.1316021829843521,
0.26995089650154114,
0.07220978289842606,
-0.5520492196083069,
-0.4291185438632965,
-0.21677635610103607,
0.3039874732494354,
0.22006265819072723,
-0.5569903254508972,
0.4193568825721741,
-0.12273762375116348,
-0.24023675918579102,
-0.4736078381538391,
-0.5766109824180603,
0.29769718647003174,
-0.054822809994220734,
-0.5938946604728699,
-0.924176037311554,
0.5057862997055054,
0.17220905423164368,
0.43550732731819153,
0.589011549949646,
1.023377537727356,
-0.8839702606201172,
0.0771583765745163,
-0.6811795234680176,
-0.3045240044593811,
-0.45603930950164795,
0.290482759475708,
-0.06455456465482712,
-1.1288496255874634,
0.7659222483634949,
-0.15191124379634857,
-0.09642568230628967,
0.3975889980792999,
0.38041746616363525,
-0.37988829612731934,
0.586049497127533,
0.21403536200523376,
-0.42263197898864746,
0.8169155716896057,
-0.19709643721580505,
-0.3144910931587219,
-0.6144809126853943,
-0.002786494791507721,
-0.04796699807047844,
-0.5192371010780334,
-0.22332227230072021,
-0.27714261412620544,
0.6967557668685913,
0.19313523173332214,
-0.3643982708454132,
0.10324136167764664,
-0.11512797325849533,
0.8293534517288208,
0.20092982053756714,
0.2875748574733734,
0.42582228779792786,
-0.146367147564888,
0.09503025561571121,
-0.07531200349330902,
-1.1339051723480225,
0.037267472594976425,
0.5948553085327148,
0.24054814875125885,
0.5735000371932983,
-0.3098185062408447,
1.3389238119125366,
0.19126920402050018,
0.242445170879364,
-0.8640986680984497,
0.2757962644100189,
-0.0995599776506424,
-0.6033273339271545,
-0.265804260969162,
-0.4007108807563782,
-0.8589000701904297,
0.2060861438512802,
-0.1890985667705536,
-1.036044716835022,
0.5840222835540771,
0.25444674491882324,
-0.5805984735488892,
0.5854724049568176,
-0.2669500410556793,
0.7479516863822937,
0.1187041699886322,
-0.48624923825263977,
-0.18959562480449677,
-0.6409775614738464,
0.6097180843353271,
-0.013254129327833652,
-0.14302513003349304,
0.1283046007156372,
-0.16001273691654205,
0.7809200286865234,
-0.5757275819778442,
1.0155709981918335,
-0.030958808958530426,
0.5114232301712036,
0.552853524684906,
-0.11127053201198578,
0.770149290561676,
0.23501698672771454,
0.029413966462016106,
-0.23902538418769836,
0.03056342899799347,
-0.5715892314910889,
-0.3250832259654999,
0.7124881148338318,
-0.2564499080181122,
-0.03829846903681755,
-0.4424848258495331,
-0.42615464329719543,
-0.017732860520482063,
0.06977341324090958,
0.38175147771835327,
0.6664028167724609,
-0.40993762016296387,
0.08104472607374191,
0.40598002076148987,
-0.17121118307113647,
0.8668333292007446,
0.18315981328487396,
0.11193392425775528,
-0.23748190701007843,
0.6986098885536194,
0.049121417105197906,
0.16752541065216064,
0.41560062766075134,
0.006006503943353891,
0.1194782555103302,
-0.5640742182731628,
-0.262470543384552,
0.0006653679884038866,
-0.8026019930839539,
-0.5408276319503784,
-0.5668165683746338,
-0.18643805384635925,
-0.23185305297374725,
-0.5015113949775696,
-0.2574823498725891,
-0.3656015992164612,
-0.5140162110328674,
-0.05903303250670433,
0.11755571514368057,
0.10951679944992065,
-0.6560380458831787,
0.8366325497627258,
-0.8339149355888367,
0.8428419828414917,
0.4985610544681549,
0.12907332181930542,
0.11695197969675064,
-0.6658678650856018,
-0.11929352581501007,
-0.35900628566741943,
-0.44325166940689087,
-0.7358758449554443,
0.264167845249176,
0.41860440373420715,
0.48140040040016174,
0.7066690921783447,
-0.2151988446712494,
0.9441204071044922,
-0.33011874556541443,
0.6786709427833557,
0.35464927554130554,
-0.7665619850158691,
0.5755995512008667,
-0.35642778873443604,
0.7246164679527283,
0.8372426629066467,
0.06660132855176926,
-0.7617806196212769,
-0.18101170659065247,
-0.7184951305389404,
-0.5974314212799072,
0.8966786861419678,
0.2012915015220642,
0.11945442855358124,
-0.5087587833404541,
0.2660194933414459,
-0.0807802751660347,
-0.005508508998900652,
-0.6688870787620544,
-0.1921955943107605,
0.0016615227796137333,
0.1974603831768036,
0.4834633469581604,
-0.012879105284810066,
0.25807031989097595,
0.032930538058280945,
0.5059165954589844,
-0.145572230219841,
0.1888623684644699,
0.12422030419111252,
-0.17021191120147705,
-0.045195627957582474,
0.24073918163776398,
0.2682129442691803,
0.40262657403945923,
-0.36617594957351685,
0.09525197744369507,
0.6252177953720093,
-0.47854673862457275,
0.038240231573581696,
0.13252206146717072,
-0.1604255884885788,
0.13684728741645813,
0.7701173424720764,
0.8483453392982483,
0.4456143379211426,
-0.4535822868347168,
0.5321379899978638,
0.4904906749725342,
-0.08575977385044098,
-0.3074812591075897,
-0.06788871437311172,
-0.09727509319782257,
0.2806890904903412,
0.4519869387149811,
0.08095463365316391,
0.30157729983329773,
-0.7451551556587219,
0.7638033628463745,
0.3502720296382904,
-0.649014949798584,
0.07716209441423416,
0.37010350823402405,
0.05047714710235596,
0.07981307059526443,
0.5272482633590698,
-0.5832395553588867,
-0.45021241903305054,
0.8510210514068604,
0.5726417899131775,
0.7829186916351318,
0.021122360602021217,
0.31566503643989563,
0.45179566740989685,
0.40707722306251526,
-0.12525340914726257,
0.10503926873207092,
-0.32382330298423767,
-0.8428520560264587,
-0.4044771194458008,
-0.23546864092350006,
-0.5399309992790222,
0.5246890187263489,
-0.3790111243724823,
0.1659003496170044,
-0.5644524693489075,
-0.08655579388141632,
-0.030855191871523857,
-0.1008262187242508,
-0.5541079640388489,
-0.032462671399116516,
0.4884524643421173,
0.7990610599517822,
-0.7386642098426819,
0.6285943388938904,
0.34081974625587463,
-0.30545520782470703,
-0.1874912530183792,
-0.03042243979871273,
0.44741326570510864,
-0.5729315876960754,
0.5432682633399963,
0.2559746503829956,
-0.012676834128797054,
0.03892199695110321,
-0.4120399057865143,
-0.29564547538757324,
1.0326751470565796,
-0.038941770792007446,
-0.528052568435669,
0.043712716549634933,
-0.2191341668367386,
0.35942700505256653,
-0.2722649574279785,
0.25144535303115845,
0.9791849851608276,
0.6623662710189819,
0.46822410821914673,
-0.48611465096473694,
-0.5125628113746643,
0.19403217732906342,
-0.18035225570201874,
0.1163768619298935,
-0.31434741616249084,
0.4444091320037842,
0.0051517304964363575,
-0.3114648759365082,
0.2199944108724594,
0.7490237951278687,
0.5611612796783447,
0.9870736002922058,
0.399185448884964,
0.6633023023605347,
0.752540111541748,
-0.016676584258675575,
0.9709084033966064,
0.33654338121414185,
0.2050187587738037,
1.274709939956665,
-0.14793674647808075,
0.6318419575691223,
0.29207882285118103,
-0.04958673194050789,
0.3319162428379059,
0.5328285694122314,
-0.008088926784694195,
0.4225257635116577,
0.11502920836210251,
-0.6715149283409119,
-0.646375834941864,
-0.06314942240715027,
-0.21802271902561188,
0.39446520805358887,
0.3898347020149231,
-0.015497284010052681,
-0.7024659514427185,
0.3422723114490509,
-0.014753374271094799,
-0.3779063820838928,
-0.6676580905914307,
0.8927278518676758,
0.12440237402915955,
-0.3196333646774292,
0.4660360813140869,
-0.193208247423172,
0.9239228367805481,
-0.6302667856216431,
0.07587035000324249,
-0.5167280435562134,
0.014024225994944572,
-0.36486175656318665,
-0.566066563129425,
0.4993506073951721,
-0.04256907477974892,
0.09828481823205948,
0.3576335608959198,
1.1028246879577637,
-0.4495883285999298,
-0.3861192464828491,
-0.03591931611299515,
0.5527898669242859,
0.12834100425243378,
-0.12480764836072922,
-0.5324172973632812,
0.007468920201063156,
-0.45844683051109314,
-0.04661722853779793,
0.47167760133743286,
0.4450969994068146,
-0.01757473312318325,
0.39321839809417725,
0.36099711060523987,
-0.17945151031017303,
0.18105481564998627,
0.1874902993440628,
0.8871909379959106,
-0.4458702504634857,
-0.797129213809967,
-0.7521330118179321,
0.28100788593292236,
-0.25592559576034546,
-0.4103987514972687,
0.2020951211452484,
0.6717042922973633,
0.5327448844909668,
-0.08891887217760086,
0.6836910247802734,
0.27202308177948,
0.03337133675813675,
-0.5237858295440674,
0.1645401418209076,
-0.28184109926223755,
0.14313678443431854,
-0.19974783062934875,
-0.38390085101127625,
-0.68525630235672,
0.46197709441185,
-0.061726126819849014,
-0.06176033988595009,
0.853404700756073,
0.6293050646781921,
-0.4617741107940674,
-0.11236444860696793,
0.6122124791145325,
-0.08300147950649261,
0.1961183100938797,
1.011040210723877,
0.9893819689750671,
-0.47864532470703125,
0.6991660594940186,
-0.2029983103275299,
-0.29169148206710815,
-0.4178479015827179,
-1.058174729347229,
-0.9195133447647095,
-0.3475857973098755,
-0.7022086977958679,
0.18659254908561707,
0.25641077756881714,
0.8617768287658691,
0.9736502766609192,
-1.012143611907959,
0.12632732093334198,
-0.3082537055015564,
0.17684389650821686,
-0.2563473880290985,
-0.2531881332397461,
0.3364465832710266,
-0.8038656115531921,
-0.43335196375846863,
0.6343482136726379,
0.8130102753639221,
0.13188230991363525,
0.21546843647956848,
0.12207862734794617,
-0.1284165233373642,
-0.08102045953273773,
0.6670363545417786,
0.6876430511474609,
-0.37380582094192505,
-0.6551436185836792,
-0.38264524936676025,
-0.0019093084847554564,
0.40708738565444946,
0.7160707116127014,
-1.2670129537582397,
0.4147714376449585,
0.683335542678833,
1.0116190910339355,
0.8987153172492981,
-0.11793471872806549,
-0.13245424628257751,
-1.2464749813079834,
0.5440130233764648,
0.34406423568725586,
0.3128787875175476,
0.11402233690023422,
-0.24401640892028809,
0.3973519802093506,
0.548337459564209,
-0.5052715539932251,
-0.4511125385761261,
0.3965904414653778,
-1.2969951629638672,
-0.10786721855401993,
0.9304050207138062,
-0.1442044973373413,
0.11481273919343948,
-0.4760284125804901,
-0.29135704040527344,
0.05111333727836609,
-0.3393515944480896,
0.492784708738327,
0.5989362001419067,
-0.6327903866767883,
-0.5789496898651123,
-0.2987324595451355,
0.5569648742675781,
0.18057532608509064,
-1.048758864402771,
-0.22237521409988403,
0.8470711708068848,
-0.04680812358856201,
0.07246000319719315,
1.0587798357009888,
0.1933794468641281,
0.794842004776001,
0.2805699110031128,
-0.5086333155632019,
-0.19472919404506683,
-0.40285640954971313,
-0.5655577778816223,
0.2135714739561081,
-0.345818430185318,
-0.49422264099121094
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17727v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17727v1
|
FastPerson: Enhancing Video Learning through Effective Video Summarization that Preserves Linguistic and Visual Contexts
| 2024-03-26T14:16:56 | 2024-03-26T14:16:56 |
Kazuki Kawamura, Jun Rekimoto
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.MM
|
Quickly understanding lengthy lecture videos is essential for learners with
limited time and interest in various topics to improve their learning
efficiency. To this end, video summarization has been actively researched to
enable users to view only important scenes from a video. However, these studies
focus on either the visual or audio information of a video and extract
important segments in the video. Therefore, there is a risk of missing
important information when both the teacher's speech and visual information on
the blackboard or slides are important, such as in a lecture video. To tackle
this issue, we propose FastPerson, a video summarization approach that
considers both the visual and auditory information in lecture videos.
FastPerson creates summary videos by utilizing audio transcriptions along with
on-screen images and text, minimizing the risk of overlooking crucial
information for learners. Further, it provides a feature that allows learners
to switch between the summary and original videos for each chapter of the
video, enabling them to adjust the pace of learning based on their interests
and level of understanding. We conducted an evaluation with 40 participants to
assess the effectiveness of our method and confirmed that it reduced viewing
time by 53\% at the same level of comprehension as that when using traditional
video playback methods.
|
[
-0.3980889320373535,
-0.8801588416099548,
0.26534581184387207,
0.40246546268463135,
-0.5770337581634521,
0.06012044474482536,
-0.28305715322494507,
0.06506551057100296,
0.4100325107574463,
0.24218672513961792,
-0.1525210440158844,
-0.33505645394325256,
-0.7166860103607178,
-0.022272871807217598,
-0.6396414637565613,
0.9505527019500732,
0.08318687975406647,
-0.007290528621524572,
-0.11255770921707153,
-0.2543027102947235,
-0.44175752997398376,
-0.03373812884092331,
-0.61446213722229,
-0.17795710265636444,
0.2360152006149292,
0.8228707313537598,
0.9503030776977539,
0.9918093085289001,
0.2845240533351898,
0.3327327072620392,
-0.1678323745727539,
0.01571926660835743,
-0.24770887196063995,
-0.04375314712524414,
-0.021510334685444832,
-0.21807481348514557,
-0.5448299646377563,
-0.33933430910110474,
0.9013571739196777,
0.5394762754440308,
-0.05920685455203056,
0.4948144555091858,
0.06166728958487511,
0.7755428552627563,
-0.7096078991889954,
0.2305915206670761,
-0.1274046152830124,
0.46195217967033386,
-0.25649645924568176,
-0.7791042923927307,
-0.3191455006599426,
-0.41053375601768494,
0.5610029101371765,
-0.5727262496948242,
0.4435577690601349,
-0.35309576988220215,
0.2799223065376282,
0.5097305774688721,
-0.559873640537262,
0.27465203404426575,
-0.6990099549293518,
0.41914379596710205,
-0.3691558539867401,
0.6816003322601318,
0.24120694398880005,
0.7141082286834717,
0.2946016490459442,
-0.4604285955429077,
-0.5168977975845337,
0.25525757670402527,
-0.017284072935581207,
0.15240703523159027,
0.20615804195404053,
0.282181054353714,
0.33557742834091187,
0.5831444263458252,
-0.5308634042739868,
-0.15425091981887817,
-0.3651299476623535,
-0.39832890033721924,
0.5747890472412109,
0.2914913296699524,
0.6130363941192627,
-0.611838161945343,
-0.31299054622650146,
-0.35536283254623413,
-0.20143140852451324,
0.2778233289718628,
0.3175545930862427,
-0.14959697425365448,
-0.22860024869441986,
0.5313305854797363,
-0.355618417263031,
0.6621825098991394,
-0.06517837941646576,
-0.8524661660194397,
0.1360492706298828,
-0.2994253635406494,
-0.3506796061992645,
0.5278782844543457,
0.5637552738189697,
0.7753109335899353,
0.3507891297340393,
0.2376679927110672,
0.19583135843276978,
-0.2378728985786438,
-0.2605040967464447,
-1.3174861669540405,
-0.4565987288951874,
0.05522383749485016,
-0.6766769289970398,
0.09439924359321594,
0.005634160712361336,
-1.1146266460418701,
-0.408978134393692,
-0.5375137329101562,
0.3728639781475067,
-0.413465678691864,
-0.24526289105415344,
-0.28626543283462524,
-0.40604138374328613,
0.014189275912940502,
0.666732668876648,
-1.0955686569213867,
0.4008057713508606,
0.13297753036022186,
1.0637165307998657,
0.04919767752289772,
-0.5735716223716736,
-1.0405046939849854,
0.39465856552124023,
-0.14003421366214752,
0.5078595280647278,
-0.21254149079322815,
-0.46225473284721375,
0.05155652388930321,
0.0010397746227681637,
0.21804295480251312,
-0.4500766396522522,
-0.13637545704841614,
-0.21967966854572296,
0.2996779978275299,
0.03197788447141647,
-0.38895875215530396,
-0.37665659189224243,
0.17431610822677612,
-0.5618669390678406,
0.7428963780403137,
-0.18133918941020966,
-0.7115305066108704,
0.30384954810142517,
-0.3211692273616791,
-0.5678234100341797,
0.0184859000146389,
-0.2334139347076416,
-0.2371898740530014,
-0.0890410840511322,
0.17384928464889526,
0.6177368760108948,
0.3094214200973511,
0.3073456883430481,
0.4056072235107422,
-0.45644059777259827,
0.05696222558617592,
-0.23069199919700623,
0.21840791404247284,
0.0031234342604875565,
-0.5265350937843323,
0.4047754108905792,
-0.9119252562522888,
-0.1967570185661316,
-0.13264136016368866,
-0.27571484446525574,
-0.37489762902259827,
0.21481601893901825,
0.17859265208244324,
0.13203248381614685,
-0.11605321615934372,
0.01047775149345398,
-0.030663035809993744,
-0.23671400547027588,
0.2633984088897705,
0.739361047744751,
0.12333183735609055,
0.6418567299842834,
0.1070307195186615,
0.7067139744758606,
-0.15540610253810883,
0.27909794449806213,
-0.7629407048225403,
-0.26254162192344666,
-0.6382686495780945,
-0.20963391661643982,
-0.022935573011636734,
0.6206739544868469,
-0.7610317468643188,
-0.26978030800819397,
-0.16560494899749756,
-0.26969781517982483,
-0.3879399597644806,
0.691723108291626,
0.46455708146095276,
0.5065160989761353,
0.6119056940078735,
-0.670663058757782,
-0.6393795609474182,
-0.6276112794876099,
-0.440769225358963,
-0.21069897711277008,
-0.363907128572464,
0.45015060901641846,
0.23567889630794525,
-0.17885367572307587,
0.8963585495948792,
-0.8849068880081177,
-0.48783302307128906,
-0.36837705969810486,
-0.00862107239663601,
-0.06049596145749092,
0.26116135716438293,
0.48597997426986694,
-0.9878420233726501,
-0.6744042634963989,
-0.17343086004257202,
-0.7725266218185425,
0.3798549175262451,
-0.43331748247146606,
-0.1027555987238884,
-0.3501386344432831,
0.5379883050918579,
-0.5316804647445679,
0.5652943849563599,
-0.0554911307990551,
-0.37214764952659607,
0.4464114010334015,
-0.4647306203842163,
0.2297191619873047,
-0.769503116607666,
-0.1892063319683075,
-0.04351644590497017,
-0.3859909474849701,
-0.5986955761909485,
-0.1452607959508896,
-0.04410644993185997,
-0.4417285919189453,
-0.7979617118835449,
0.7186216711997986,
-0.2244236320257187,
-0.2637158930301666,
-0.3342410922050476,
0.6889147162437439,
-0.15400731563568115,
0.474231481552124,
0.26138201355934143,
0.7610946893692017,
0.6044768691062927,
-0.7070367336273193,
0.1489366739988327,
0.8553139567375183,
-0.4864244759082794,
0.4723375141620636,
-0.5095058083534241,
-0.32302969694137573,
-0.257028728723526,
0.18854433298110962,
-0.6762577295303345,
-0.7453392744064331,
0.09667059034109116,
-0.2846421003341675,
0.1963818222284317,
-0.060460031032562256,
-0.10943964123725891,
0.22371365129947662,
-0.5293522477149963,
0.46120357513427734,
0.48679304122924805,
-0.4757653772830963,
0.7384776473045349,
0.32076260447502136,
-0.4752693176269531,
-0.7137532234191895,
-0.37265196442604065,
0.1937756985425949,
-0.2606271803379059,
-0.4874792695045471,
0.4548007547855377,
-0.22552160918712616,
-0.3975810706615448,
-0.21323928236961365,
-0.4287620186805725,
-0.1554534137248993,
-0.11394093185663223,
0.18094362318515778,
0.0954093262553215,
0.024999940767884254,
0.07003238052129745,
0.043364834040403366,
0.015602522529661655,
0.0696733295917511,
0.12403653562068939,
0.09445367753505707,
0.2965732216835022,
0.4377852976322174,
-0.6964026093482971,
0.7001163363456726,
0.707986056804657,
-0.33631324768066406,
0.3111587464809418,
0.9347795844078064,
-0.1873839944601059,
-0.18950414657592773,
-0.3990781307220459,
-0.34371280670166016,
-0.4072297513484955,
0.7847007513046265,
0.009260267950594425,
-0.5264850854873657,
0.27076026797294617,
0.08592014759778976,
0.052745383232831955,
-0.05733152851462364,
0.3699258267879486,
-0.012198328040540218,
0.8795349597930908,
0.9292590618133545,
0.1818912923336029,
1.2441481351852417,
-0.39671090245246887,
-0.02845907397568226,
-0.613466739654541,
-0.7701048254966736,
0.007142308633774519,
-0.13153591752052307,
-0.14674808084964752,
-0.42580661177635193,
0.3572874367237091,
0.014939709566533566,
-0.193475142121315,
0.1509103626012802,
-0.32006895542144775,
0.7429333329200745,
0.40585461258888245,
0.40225568413734436,
0.3519197106361389,
-0.07701404392719269,
0.35708868503570557,
-0.2344772219657898,
-0.5436981320381165,
-0.3514024019241333,
0.7541888356208801,
0.21365493535995483,
0.6360355615615845,
0.5374050736427307,
0.5212059020996094,
0.534281313419342,
0.04753801226615906,
-1.0300263166427612,
1.0067631006240845,
-0.08240960538387299,
-0.2775993347167969,
-0.5057340264320374,
-0.4313625693321228,
-0.4466281831264496,
0.4336693286895752,
-0.19779238104820251,
-0.3114364445209503,
-0.08737371861934662,
0.632101833820343,
-0.4348866939544678,
0.15105195343494415,
-0.7183718681335449,
1.1363894939422607,
-0.35315531492233276,
-0.6596723198890686,
-0.40460920333862305,
-0.978574275970459,
0.4720989763736725,
0.16517750918865204,
0.4125211238861084,
-0.0026519745588302612,
-0.0653211772441864,
0.9971739649772644,
-0.7276097536087036,
0.6490623354911804,
-0.3411112427711487,
0.34352320432662964,
0.5304169654846191,
0.13716855645179749,
0.023324323818087578,
0.23323054611682892,
0.7087715268135071,
-0.4104261100292206,
-0.33078959584236145,
-0.41108235716819763,
-0.6162042617797852,
0.2913177013397217,
-0.5849019885063171,
-0.8190006613731384,
-0.15067332983016968,
-0.24050651490688324,
0.04744350537657738,
0.3277314007282257,
-0.0645255520939827,
0.6500818133354187,
-0.25932082533836365,
-0.014667810872197151,
0.9493982195854187,
-0.3288832902908325,
0.7015140652656555,
0.3087933361530304,
-0.318377286195755,
-0.6863784790039062,
0.9843810796737671,
0.022932015359401703,
0.21107560396194458,
0.5452468991279602,
0.33458229899406433,
-0.10454163700342178,
-0.4720921814441681,
-0.6135482788085938,
-0.003945300355553627,
-1.0437718629837036,
0.10342284291982651,
-0.7046467661857605,
0.3437679708003998,
-0.24254384636878967,
-0.2080507129430771,
-0.22631417214870453,
-0.5745108127593994,
-0.2190120965242386,
-0.3213915228843689,
0.2718507945537567,
0.08364659547805786,
0.21087057888507843,
0.6601080298423767,
-0.852607011795044,
0.6034491658210754,
1.1169472932815552,
0.15221872925758362,
0.17174485325813293,
-0.5616884827613831,
-0.4217508137226105,
-0.6103370785713196,
-0.38328659534454346,
-0.9507017135620117,
0.3778652548789978,
0.7651404738426208,
0.374338835477829,
0.8289911150932312,
-0.2348128706216812,
1.0426932573318481,
-0.7845281362533569,
0.954461932182312,
0.5711690187454224,
-1.2276912927627563,
0.9016708135604858,
-0.08856885880231857,
0.5158945918083191,
0.42754170298576355,
0.5115069150924683,
-0.6464129090309143,
-0.0954161062836647,
-0.3086126446723938,
-1.1774765253067017,
0.3449205458164215,
0.07717428356409073,
-0.0934605821967125,
0.2816846966743469,
-0.015142115764319897,
0.28655847907066345,
0.19871041178703308,
-0.31574124097824097,
-0.296560138463974,
-0.9741824865341187,
0.029877765104174614,
-0.5414891242980957,
-0.19345276057720184,
-0.11946327239274979,
-0.45184189081192017,
0.4867003262042999,
-0.288009911775589,
-0.13124991953372955,
0.30274638533592224,
-0.6949690580368042,
0.21503359079360962,
0.4011361002922058,
0.8009785413742065,
0.8342183828353882,
-0.5027196407318115,
0.2736443281173706,
0.09962180256843567,
-0.8458656072616577,
0.25234729051589966,
-0.10367921739816666,
-0.03022722527384758,
0.53555828332901,
0.4543282687664032,
0.738659143447876,
0.7661771774291992,
-0.9747888445854187,
0.6056650876998901,
-0.01389636006206274,
-0.07487303018569946,
-0.3466140627861023,
0.12665434181690216,
-0.3673063814640045,
0.21150796115398407,
0.40947240591049194,
0.327541708946228,
0.43775781989097595,
-0.7553164958953857,
0.1616271287202835,
-0.19118212163448334,
0.041433464735746384,
-0.473492294549942,
1.1765843629837036,
0.7100833654403687,
-0.6848629117012024,
0.3961925804615021,
0.29243895411491394,
-0.5743911862373352,
0.37443551421165466,
0.17225156724452972,
0.835959792137146,
-0.40339407324790955,
0.474473237991333,
0.4722290337085724,
-0.048496320843696594,
-0.35413074493408203,
0.21083372831344604,
-0.7842021584510803,
-0.0818447470664978,
-0.6417312622070312,
-0.189963236451149,
-0.904503583908081,
-0.4162425994873047,
-0.7310306429862976,
0.24504126608371735,
-0.38903066515922546,
-0.1630028486251831,
0.11852378398180008,
-0.18603096902370453,
-0.5124248266220093,
0.27722927927970886,
0.13025915622711182,
1.1016273498535156,
-0.9378708600997925,
0.6143974661827087,
0.5657645463943481,
-0.3494378328323364,
-0.5830162167549133,
-0.2116636484861374,
-0.04929530620574951,
-0.03784535452723503,
0.7009412050247192,
0.1598493605852127,
-0.09671663492918015,
-0.20950575172901154,
0.023625586181879044,
-0.34423744678497314,
1.1005926132202148,
0.3887580335140228,
-0.5481699705123901,
-0.22494027018547058,
-0.2280678153038025,
0.16565853357315063,
0.0903606116771698,
0.380879670381546,
0.4584551155567169,
0.37534648180007935,
-0.11952705681324005,
-0.7313317060470581,
-0.29975607991218567,
-0.14015695452690125,
-0.26430609822273254,
0.3266058564186096,
-0.7825886011123657,
0.5275377631187439,
-0.5099478960037231,
-0.028574705123901367,
-0.20670732855796814,
0.826926589012146,
-0.09290929138660431,
0.804129421710968,
0.5400102734565735,
-0.04824063554406166,
0.6066976189613342,
0.1829356551170349,
0.6896642446517944,
0.06212475895881653,
0.05719168484210968,
1.3622174263000488,
0.28122586011886597,
0.6306115388870239,
0.7223403453826904,
-0.1746465116739273,
0.4355407655239105,
0.5903216600418091,
0.13398845493793488,
0.5753902196884155,
-0.1257133185863495,
-0.3867757022380829,
-0.4835743308067322,
-0.006665434222668409,
-0.4044247269630432,
0.47470149397850037,
0.11387172341346741,
-0.2987990081310272,
0.05504174903035164,
0.44362255930900574,
-0.09872344881296158,
0.16621121764183044,
-0.7246924042701721,
0.6722450852394104,
0.11407700181007385,
-0.644025444984436,
0.24367274343967438,
-0.4324001967906952,
0.458275705575943,
-0.705367922782898,
-0.19172413647174835,
-0.39498159289360046,
0.3160000443458557,
-0.6817969679832458,
-0.28030046820640564,
-0.004221455194056034,
0.34616386890411377,
-0.20381468534469604,
-0.31509485840797424,
0.20995160937309265,
-0.6908063888549805,
-0.05500445514917374,
0.0027372653130441904,
0.340015709400177,
0.43692347407341003,
0.2234608232975006,
-0.08316818624734879,
-0.16855722665786743,
0.021768109872937202,
-0.10055042803287506,
0.34123551845550537,
0.26164743304252625,
-0.15347325801849365,
0.6646652817726135,
0.18141084909439087,
-0.09875901788473129,
-0.07207795977592468,
0.12301145493984222,
0.5593215823173523,
-0.8962101340293884,
-0.7322514057159424,
-0.9424175024032593,
0.6179865598678589,
-0.13799050450325012,
-0.4051211178302765,
1.260766863822937,
0.7346750497817993,
0.9527384042739868,
-0.417574942111969,
0.3385904133319855,
0.20630648732185364,
0.04646831378340721,
-0.5789769887924194,
0.5900859236717224,
-0.4950283169746399,
-0.12677890062332153,
-0.7748871445655823,
-0.970338761806488,
-0.30974480509757996,
0.42356711626052856,
0.1006547287106514,
-0.5495573878288269,
0.6769157648086548,
0.21641626954078674,
-0.04193853959441185,
-0.005435315892100334,
0.23632992804050446,
0.13473480939865112,
0.2516118288040161,
0.2838444411754608,
0.7807600498199463,
-0.3697052299976349,
0.9257693290710449,
-0.453930139541626,
-0.39492568373680115,
-0.5116060376167297,
-0.8784142732620239,
-1.3002010583877563,
-0.24886493384838104,
-0.8067755103111267,
0.18059970438480377,
-0.06382580101490021,
0.7132806181907654,
0.80023193359375,
-0.3924820125102997,
-0.5306954979896545,
0.4486435353755951,
0.2727316915988922,
-0.5277117490768433,
-0.23051060736179352,
0.7469236254692078,
0.38520410656929016,
-0.6866982579231262,
0.6066101789474487,
0.31520089507102966,
0.2558228671550751,
-0.20697538554668427,
-0.27679362893104553,
0.11313269287347794,
-0.03020135499536991,
0.9669195413589478,
0.5257797241210938,
-0.37503936886787415,
-0.20448197424411774,
0.008129127323627472,
0.5223881006240845,
0.0656261071562767,
1.0813989639282227,
-0.7948683500289917,
0.7837137579917908,
0.626194417476654,
0.38627246022224426,
0.9024950861930847,
0.09611805528402328,
0.46255528926849365,
-0.736375093460083,
0.5548921227455139,
-0.11508932709693909,
0.3900167942047119,
0.5722073912620544,
-0.2680615186691284,
0.3292592465877533,
0.24692240357398987,
-0.3881562650203705,
-0.9364076256752014,
0.003636234672740102,
-1.1692544221878052,
-0.16435885429382324,
0.5314781665802002,
-0.11870985478162766,
0.004385844804346561,
0.06527794897556305,
-0.4181784987449646,
0.4518490731716156,
-0.3790411949157715,
0.8983390927314758,
0.34782376885414124,
-0.13784149289131165,
-0.30930089950561523,
-0.7395566701889038,
0.5875773429870605,
0.4879351556301117,
-0.6600612998008728,
-0.017505502328276634,
0.3757932186126709,
0.39358747005462646,
-0.008884040638804436,
0.6084696054458618,
0.23089219629764557,
0.813262939453125,
-0.208501935005188,
-0.13322731852531433,
-0.2978391647338867,
-0.674822211265564,
-0.16943128407001495,
0.44172200560569763,
-0.3309784233570099,
-0.4893190264701843
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19713v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19713v2
|
NJUST-KMG at TRAC-2024 Tasks 1 and 2: Offline Harm Potential Identification
| 2024-03-26T14:09:49 | 2024-04-01T14:16:42 |
Jingyuan Wang, Shengdong Xu, Yang Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This report provide a detailed description of the method that we proposed in
the TRAC-2024 Offline Harm Potential dentification which encloses two
sub-tasks. The investigation utilized a rich dataset comprised of social media
comments in several Indian languages, annotated with precision by expert judges
to capture the nuanced implications for offline context harm. The objective
assigned to the participants was to design algorithms capable of accurately
assessing the likelihood of harm in given situations and identifying the most
likely target(s) of offline harm. Our approach ranked second in two separate
tracks, with F1 values of 0.73 and 0.96 respectively. Our method principally
involved selecting pretrained models for finetuning, incorporating contrastive
learning techniques, and culminating in an ensemble approach for the test set.
|
[
-0.4176400601863861,
-0.961613118648529,
0.4963350296020508,
-0.07979606837034225,
-0.3731955587863922,
0.11519534885883331,
0.1063375249505043,
-0.9677029252052307,
0.31007295846939087,
0.3626822531223297,
-0.842617392539978,
-0.27019286155700684,
-0.6628374457359314,
-0.04966384544968605,
-0.27122679352760315,
1.0847680568695068,
0.036490727216005325,
-0.07338110357522964,
-0.031375981867313385,
0.03607252612709999,
-1.0699291229248047,
-0.35075506567955017,
-0.665957510471344,
0.16860070824623108,
1.0545246601104736,
0.603778064250946,
0.16409140825271606,
0.08104385435581207,
0.9447117447853088,
0.2568463385105133,
-0.10616618394851685,
0.0436188206076622,
-0.653245210647583,
-0.19226820766925812,
-0.01438247412443161,
-0.6297566890716553,
-0.23089969158172607,
0.017604632303118706,
0.2377033680677414,
0.5000393390655518,
-0.05862932652235031,
0.3391587734222412,
-0.07321671396493912,
0.5956515669822693,
-0.8239456415176392,
-0.16247032582759857,
-0.42048314213752747,
0.33505380153656006,
-0.4246025085449219,
-0.28768065571784973,
-0.5508195757865906,
-0.4806012809276581,
0.416361927986145,
-0.7433212399482727,
-0.0758003517985344,
-0.07755127549171448,
0.9620157480239868,
0.45531752705574036,
-0.7415932416915894,
-0.36392277479171753,
-0.7303975820541382,
0.8027187585830688,
-0.5097823739051819,
0.19234837591648102,
0.6804842948913574,
0.5521433353424072,
0.014174392446875572,
-0.9044393301010132,
-0.18971934914588928,
0.19653484225273132,
-0.11627242714166641,
0.19732512533664703,
0.09605316817760468,
0.3230409026145935,
0.30860644578933716,
0.4614052474498749,
-0.41548997163772583,
0.041134078055620193,
-0.5830718874931335,
-0.311470627784729,
0.6805517077445984,
0.05907382071018219,
0.3750157952308655,
-0.09072892367839813,
-0.28586435317993164,
-0.22680456936359406,
-0.7106534838676453,
0.04388020187616348,
0.4873020350933075,
0.5456772446632385,
-0.2614119052886963,
0.44895562529563904,
-0.15876524150371552,
0.7539993524551392,
-0.003878373187035322,
-0.20640739798545837,
0.218529611825943,
-0.6220561861991882,
-0.07568538933992386,
0.5577158331871033,
0.6049612164497375,
0.5276973843574524,
-0.27983054518699646,
-0.09427693486213684,
0.01763683743774891,
0.06285186111927032,
0.6834676265716553,
-0.4198307394981384,
-0.17969784140586853,
0.021649133414030075,
-0.5864613056182861,
-0.8516110181808472,
-0.01334715262055397,
-1.2992770671844482,
-0.46257084608078003,
-0.2150566279888153,
0.9774898290634155,
-0.05297422036528587,
-0.21676912903785706,
-0.38241681456565857,
-0.07645752280950546,
0.19410359859466553,
0.0845768004655838,
-0.7071108818054199,
0.20353126525878906,
0.23627804219722748,
0.9010937809944153,
-0.20307613909244537,
0.4492535889148712,
-0.30727389454841614,
0.06328050792217255,
-0.09686397761106491,
0.8235511183738708,
-0.3193228840827942,
-0.4329124093055725,
0.01587645523250103,
0.02489091455936432,
0.1882910281419754,
-0.14141346514225006,
1.1847865581512451,
-0.6774640083312988,
0.3542683720588684,
-0.9566155076026917,
-0.28310295939445496,
-0.8565716743469238,
0.4937463402748108,
-0.7888531684875488,
0.9522151350975037,
0.3795247972011566,
-1.0615407228469849,
0.5959331393241882,
-0.9558268189430237,
-0.5230164527893066,
0.1252448856830597,
0.05336703360080719,
-0.5795301795005798,
-0.0971449762582779,
-0.07018016278743744,
0.38355326652526855,
-0.23451098799705505,
0.13767017424106598,
-0.3208288848400116,
-0.4337325692176819,
-0.12722855806350708,
-0.2885130047798157,
0.81563800573349,
0.14352630078792572,
-0.63194340467453,
0.3250424265861511,
-0.677598237991333,
0.25899311900138855,
0.19056610763072968,
-0.2258845865726471,
-0.481659471988678,
-0.1293579638004303,
0.1196657195687294,
0.6471330523490906,
-0.000676836643833667,
-0.7959035038948059,
-0.05329214408993721,
-0.44530436396598816,
0.46840187907218933,
0.7746041417121887,
0.4968198835849762,
-0.002166924299672246,
-0.3953814208507538,
0.517330527305603,
-0.17309482395648956,
0.4202772080898285,
0.3097171485424042,
-0.5780848860740662,
-0.46595045924186707,
0.0527661107480526,
0.8031983375549316,
0.4989694654941559,
-0.790694534778595,
0.06991507858037949,
-0.13324527442455292,
-0.8235795497894287,
-0.05070439726114273,
-0.32500359416007996,
0.6469073295593262,
0.6225298047065735,
0.21433058381080627,
-0.36757683753967285,
-1.0346057415008545,
-0.822137176990509,
-0.221231609582901,
-0.08085568249225616,
0.2300354689359665,
0.32835760712623596,
0.31987589597702026,
-0.24711482226848602,
0.7673825025558472,
-0.5503386855125427,
-0.606158435344696,
-0.021488573402166367,
0.3915358781814575,
-0.24602718651294708,
0.29895421862602234,
0.4789443910121918,
-1.1313446760177612,
-0.6824800372123718,
-0.14635397493839264,
-0.8088809847831726,
-0.24123887717723846,
-0.09743495285511017,
-0.2436968833208084,
-0.019451621919870377,
0.36391276121139526,
-0.3629578649997711,
0.6242784261703491,
0.5052638649940491,
-0.0009319176315329969,
0.2583587169647217,
-0.03407502919435501,
0.48447442054748535,
-0.8922616839408875,
0.23396220803260803,
-0.015770914033055305,
-0.10002506524324417,
-0.9619693160057068,
0.0657050833106041,
-0.1968829184770584,
-0.10555887967348099,
-0.8711933493614197,
0.21823352575302124,
-0.16191503405570984,
-0.10445287823677063,
-0.11496149748563766,
0.18459917604923248,
-0.3158890902996063,
0.6448934674263,
-0.362934410572052,
0.4488885700702667,
0.20988036692142487,
-0.6981323957443237,
-0.04351256787776947,
0.3039247989654541,
-0.2662457227706909,
0.17642825841903687,
-0.7134805917739868,
0.15188950300216675,
0.010359480045735836,
0.19945554435253143,
-1.0820214748382568,
-0.6672862768173218,
0.4435713291168213,
-0.5092265605926514,
0.26107749342918396,
0.10153786838054657,
-0.3643888831138611,
-0.19860278069972992,
-0.275114506483078,
0.7648144364356995,
0.28780755400657654,
-0.1958819329738617,
0.740693986415863,
1.048679232597351,
-0.1147492527961731,
-0.31663209199905396,
-0.8783342838287354,
-0.021860981360077858,
-0.666643500328064,
-0.24788476526737213,
0.46393242478370667,
0.1169307678937912,
-0.31292659044265747,
-0.5146209597587585,
0.06989563256502151,
-0.2110588252544403,
0.18189959228038788,
0.7867154479026794,
0.2503752112388611,
0.3649023771286011,
-0.1155916377902031,
0.19551564753055573,
-0.06076718494296074,
0.24549244344234467,
0.2996530830860138,
0.4190649688243866,
0.22265952825546265,
-0.2578882575035095,
-0.3163021206855774,
0.15982258319854736,
0.1592307984828949,
-0.014679286628961563,
0.4747619926929474,
0.5524518489837646,
-0.5394550561904907,
0.4563591480255127,
-0.36000558733940125,
-0.0881577655673027,
-0.49156880378723145,
0.11938399821519852,
0.07052548229694366,
-0.8342384696006775,
0.5267463326454163,
-0.1790788471698761,
0.23954996466636658,
0.7110093832015991,
0.6582870483398438,
0.02348260208964348,
1.2019671201705933,
0.68623286485672,
0.12955883145332336,
0.4983895421028137,
-0.17419765889644623,
0.43138638138771057,
-0.4488216042518616,
-0.6114333868026733,
-0.35510531067848206,
-0.30185842514038086,
-1.0416606664657593,
-0.05721685290336609,
0.6280487179756165,
-0.028432991355657578,
0.11466173827648163,
0.46662065386772156,
-0.7445648312568665,
0.22249242663383484,
0.4483305811882019,
0.5569159984588623,
-0.19579558074474335,
-0.09416860342025757,
-0.2295977622270584,
-0.017535939812660217,
-0.6273087859153748,
-0.29126694798469543,
1.1564077138900757,
0.5004181861877441,
0.00619668560102582,
0.2643651068210602,
0.42775776982307434,
0.6350768208503723,
0.40348151326179504,
-0.7372051477432251,
0.521994948387146,
0.03983372077345848,
-1.2655248641967773,
-0.4144604802131653,
-0.3253500163555145,
-0.9319945573806763,
-0.11593296378850937,
-0.28441092371940613,
-0.8051003217697144,
0.03474602475762367,
0.24955244362354279,
-0.636300802230835,
0.17637841403484344,
-0.6560423374176025,
0.7835180163383484,
-0.2621891498565674,
-0.30125513672828674,
-0.19922690093517303,
-1.2758057117462158,
0.8025186657905579,
-0.6789650321006775,
0.5229265689849854,
0.13310055434703827,
0.31981906294822693,
1.2957165241241455,
-0.45999470353126526,
0.8581970930099487,
-0.5323680639266968,
-0.1159195676445961,
0.7678218483924866,
-0.32396742701530457,
0.34037214517593384,
-0.22343073785305023,
0.16882076859474182,
0.3203667998313904,
0.24689216911792755,
-0.23466908931732178,
-0.16180847585201263,
0.5849520564079285,
-0.6876093149185181,
0.030515162274241447,
-0.5405948758125305,
-0.34657132625579834,
-0.35453787446022034,
0.44530531764030457,
0.4923626482486725,
0.5419402718544006,
-0.15472838282585144,
0.1345459222793579,
0.6480344533920288,
-0.3168286681175232,
0.6451777815818787,
0.168881356716156,
0.09685897082090378,
-0.4714377522468567,
1.1611138582229614,
0.07593581080436707,
0.08838235586881638,
0.5515877604484558,
0.25166913866996765,
-0.5669004321098328,
-0.28159889578819275,
-0.15875425934791565,
-0.20910188555717468,
-0.9002702236175537,
-0.2085975706577301,
-0.5796367526054382,
0.08264031261205673,
-0.19978593289852142,
0.05120227113366127,
-0.12055662274360657,
-0.3286624252796173,
-0.2117551863193512,
-0.027245404198765755,
0.12456944584846497,
0.7056970000267029,
-0.15244188904762268,
0.6552101373672485,
-1.0066131353378296,
0.22540949285030365,
0.3453924357891083,
0.18591347336769104,
-0.13260267674922943,
-0.4756889045238495,
-0.24810612201690674,
0.3937687277793884,
-0.5870984792709351,
-0.7148953080177307,
0.22553953528404236,
0.2939053773880005,
0.4560356140136719,
0.5484238862991333,
0.310916930437088,
0.9069452881813049,
-0.2557317614555359,
0.8984752893447876,
0.3240511417388916,
-0.559100866317749,
0.6955969929695129,
-0.48831409215927124,
0.11168651282787323,
1.0348366498947144,
0.829466700553894,
-0.33324897289276123,
-0.022979194298386574,
-0.5130806565284729,
-0.8458961844444275,
0.6622704863548279,
0.40059787034988403,
-0.14311958849430084,
-0.0443706251680851,
0.44682300090789795,
0.1233326867222786,
-0.02139064483344555,
-0.6870238184928894,
-0.1422790288925171,
-0.0034753421787172556,
-0.19049367308616638,
0.04899551719427109,
-0.3866174817085266,
-0.15679869055747986,
-0.16861042380332947,
0.5960659384727478,
0.17816166579723358,
0.7365836501121521,
0.08715341240167618,
-0.08341416716575623,
-0.6235358715057373,
-0.08829811215400696,
1.0198736190795898,
0.6579685807228088,
-0.32308489084243774,
0.0008927525486797094,
0.5051727890968323,
-0.7471266984939575,
0.26651397347450256,
-0.09600228071212769,
-0.05654125660657883,
-0.08476119488477707,
0.6231862902641296,
0.6256251335144043,
0.27395790815353394,
-0.8898434042930603,
0.6122276186943054,
-0.27784138917922974,
-0.5283451080322266,
-0.5257158875465393,
-0.13516077399253845,
-0.4935137629508972,
-0.18747064471244812,
0.22616705298423767,
0.06691616773605347,
0.5299428105354309,
-0.4984837770462036,
0.28605911135673523,
0.1899082213640213,
-0.9745853543281555,
-0.3887411952018738,
0.651494562625885,
0.12327661365270615,
-0.10662682354450226,
0.2673996686935425,
-0.20250263810157776,
-0.7545074820518494,
0.3470432162284851,
0.007759246043860912,
0.7033992409706116,
-0.26994141936302185,
-0.048364490270614624,
0.4727521538734436,
0.12361875921487808,
0.014279479160904884,
0.46796566247940063,
0.11002159863710403,
-0.20701952278614044,
-0.600723922252655,
-0.47618526220321655,
-0.1976231336593628,
0.14327719807624817,
-0.8998081088066101,
0.47084370255470276,
-0.4005091190338135,
-0.4105384945869446,
0.16649462282657623,
0.09769343584775925,
-0.36261823773384094,
0.8396593332290649,
-0.029214443638920784,
0.47741881012916565,
-1.0650213956832886,
0.3767203986644745,
0.6968551874160767,
-0.3511407971382141,
-0.9974783062934875,
-0.10312093794345856,
0.41367608308792114,
-0.35873740911483765,
0.742827296257019,
0.38543349504470825,
0.1308189034461975,
0.06589436531066895,
-0.35022449493408203,
-1.0155409574508667,
1.0733567476272583,
-0.020274575799703598,
-0.6862236261367798,
-0.17881521582603455,
0.29758816957473755,
0.4546974003314972,
0.4416024684906006,
0.5236006379127502,
0.39573362469673157,
0.4595462679862976,
0.3115079700946808,
-1.0670413970947266,
0.051933445036411285,
-0.13637816905975342,
-0.22475506365299225,
0.8581483364105225,
-0.729417622089386,
0.40882453322410583,
0.16184182465076447,
-0.2932404577732086,
-0.31814244389533997,
0.26232701539993286,
0.0627698078751564,
0.3701014220714569,
0.9296485781669617,
0.7306725978851318,
0.3333100378513336,
-0.18663211166858673,
0.9116409420967102,
-0.17719778418540955,
0.28631114959716797,
0.9340387582778931,
0.059365853667259216,
0.5221269726753235,
0.5033696293830872,
-0.3178877532482147,
0.29452964663505554,
1.238051414489746,
0.1951911747455597,
1.2582215070724487,
0.05244510993361473,
-0.234933003783226,
0.08286715298891068,
-0.49650606513023376,
-0.20900724828243256,
0.7237667441368103,
0.24592845141887665,
-0.3138456642627716,
-0.057773176580667496,
0.36624854803085327,
-0.2552106976509094,
-0.5046628713607788,
-0.4005379378795624,
1.0161153078079224,
-0.04136623069643974,
-0.7868884801864624,
0.27781108021736145,
0.22983355820178986,
0.4465996325016022,
-0.5829247236251831,
-0.2600756585597992,
0.4367404878139496,
0.12441927194595337,
-0.17774590849876404,
-0.5590762495994568,
0.7508803009986877,
-0.2808012068271637,
0.10440614819526672,
-0.0016499240882694721,
1.0977542400360107,
0.004684310872107744,
-0.3878641128540039,
0.12987233698368073,
0.022990649566054344,
0.2651706635951996,
-0.14604195952415466,
-0.5160643458366394,
0.12433741241693497,
0.029455041512846947,
-0.043502915650606155,
0.6070182919502258,
0.24890650808811188,
-0.5001155734062195,
0.4517161250114441,
0.4400600492954254,
-0.3037198781967163,
-0.016150886192917824,
0.017446085810661316,
0.9687478542327881,
-0.3112163543701172,
-0.6350435018539429,
-0.6814475655555725,
0.5609592199325562,
-0.01504928432404995,
-0.5373244285583496,
0.8172053694725037,
0.3412478566169739,
0.8522812128067017,
0.16882607340812683,
0.5383416414260864,
-0.683536171913147,
0.7274791598320007,
-0.3877790570259094,
0.4956924617290497,
-0.5228898525238037,
-0.12789615988731384,
-0.6922423839569092,
-0.7123955488204956,
-0.23108364641666412,
0.5368909239768982,
-0.3214834928512573,
0.21851207315921783,
0.5858191251754761,
0.5481153726577759,
0.1344613879919052,
0.3395211100578308,
0.1426057368516922,
-0.2345929592847824,
0.20796748995780945,
0.49957993626594543,
0.6441622972488403,
-0.806755006313324,
0.5800846219062805,
-0.6955872178077698,
-0.2220357358455658,
-0.41393205523490906,
-0.89295893907547,
-0.9796275496482849,
-0.5835187435150146,
-0.2929171621799469,
-0.0033309569116681814,
-0.08022913336753845,
0.796524703502655,
0.6959636807441711,
-0.9356303811073303,
0.2389979511499405,
-0.3659649193286896,
-0.5824146270751953,
0.1290760189294815,
-0.23102976381778717,
0.4111812114715576,
0.24715684354305267,
-0.10563003271818161,
0.1414678692817688,
0.014914111234247684,
0.0006095131975598633,
-0.11237141489982605,
0.0589405782520771,
-0.6314920783042908,
-0.26383477449417114,
0.8759604096412659,
0.05350925028324127,
-0.7370109558105469,
-0.5548517107963562,
-0.17176714539527893,
0.03480551019310951,
-0.20623351633548737,
0.7188079953193665,
-0.410287082195282,
0.5267872214317322,
0.5713199973106384,
0.6300631165504456,
0.4399239420890808,
0.2706114649772644,
0.3344118595123291,
-0.8905359506607056,
0.18655680119991302,
0.3366298973560333,
-0.09498729556798935,
0.037871263921260834,
-0.7827814221382141,
0.6003526449203491,
0.1487497091293335,
-0.7644535303115845,
-1.1179873943328857,
-0.062717005610466,
-1.1392087936401367,
-0.18548354506492615,
0.7373180389404297,
-0.37287086248397827,
-0.08806570619344711,
-0.3449854254722595,
-0.41046828031539917,
0.8596754670143127,
0.014317197725176811,
1.0526667833328247,
0.6651163697242737,
0.027215315029025078,
-0.41161179542541504,
-0.8959046006202698,
0.5909076929092407,
0.3063754439353943,
-1.156982183456421,
-0.4646133482456207,
0.18255457282066345,
0.019936755299568176,
0.3689090609550476,
0.3509658873081207,
-0.19832660257816315,
0.35189858078956604,
-0.03520161285996437,
-0.056322067975997925,
0.1404605358839035,
-0.1554078310728073,
-0.2213224172592163,
0.17194607853889465,
-0.17036369442939758,
-0.23398053646087646
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17706v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17706v1
|
Enhanced Short Text Modeling: Leveraging Large Language Models for Topic Refinement
| 2024-03-26T13:50:34 | 2024-03-26T13:50:34 |
Shuyu Chang, Rui Wang, Peng Ren, Haiping Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Crafting effective topic models for brief texts, like tweets and news
headlines, is essential for capturing the swift shifts in social dynamics.
Traditional topic models, however, often fall short in accurately representing
the semantic intricacies of short texts due to their brevity and lack of
contextual data. In our study, we harness the advanced capabilities of Large
Language Models (LLMs) to introduce a novel approach termed "Topic Refinement".
This approach does not directly involve itself in the initial modeling of
topics but focuses on improving topics after they have been mined. By employing
prompt engineering, we direct LLMs to eliminate off-topic words within a given
topic, ensuring that only contextually relevant words are preserved or
substituted with ones that fit better semantically. This method emulates
human-like scrutiny and improvement of topics, thereby elevating the semantic
quality of the topics generated by various models. Our comprehensive evaluation
across three unique datasets has shown that our topic refinement approach
significantly enhances the semantic coherence of topics.
|
[
-0.3339901268482208,
-1.0844979286193848,
0.715354323387146,
0.05808956176042557,
-0.5588319301605225,
0.35286271572113037,
-0.45328181982040405,
-0.2813428044319153,
0.5552969574928284,
0.47185298800468445,
-0.7569931149482727,
-0.4189598262310028,
-0.4997607171535492,
0.21920761466026306,
-0.5695898532867432,
0.9146583676338196,
0.10322682559490204,
-0.22019615769386292,
-0.15540309250354767,
0.1307549923658371,
-0.48720940947532654,
-0.09471452236175537,
-0.6514307260513306,
-0.282638818025589,
0.6460543274879456,
0.7841770052909851,
0.7195432186126709,
0.6292975544929504,
0.4155799448490143,
0.1869484782218933,
-0.598630428314209,
0.13762089610099792,
-0.8180396556854248,
0.0978248119354248,
-0.5094572901725769,
-0.1769820600748062,
-0.32432442903518677,
-0.1319921761751175,
0.6593623757362366,
0.867004930973053,
0.171230286359787,
0.01119239628314972,
0.3282727599143982,
0.5430237054824829,
-0.30853214859962463,
-0.21196964383125305,
-0.792277991771698,
-0.3462171256542206,
-0.38429078459739685,
-0.395477294921875,
-0.1661946177482605,
-0.2970736026763916,
0.44570404291152954,
-0.35463353991508484,
0.46682509779930115,
0.10136924684047699,
1.0058740377426147,
0.11618482321500778,
-0.448731392621994,
-0.22675737738609314,
-0.44872960448265076,
0.8169850707054138,
-0.5360596179962158,
0.23215028643608093,
0.14930884540081024,
0.030121443793177605,
-0.2166694849729538,
-0.9234005212783813,
-0.30790480971336365,
-0.2907170355319977,
-0.22054527699947357,
-0.225125253200531,
0.035247303545475006,
0.11411450058221817,
0.2692846953868866,
0.23053079843521118,
-0.3065934479236603,
0.21454432606697083,
-0.3568304479122162,
-0.16866785287857056,
0.6945982575416565,
0.21412408351898193,
0.3061152398586273,
-0.47452956438064575,
-0.12481190264225006,
0.31246522068977356,
-0.8791649341583252,
-0.0561404712498188,
0.1920183151960373,
0.48339733481407166,
-0.11742009967565536,
0.6062488555908203,
-0.6337692737579346,
0.4302695393562317,
0.039273299276828766,
-0.10983462631702423,
0.014299634844064713,
-0.5674830079078674,
0.1108015850186348,
-0.051354482769966125,
0.30278149247169495,
0.4264531135559082,
-0.09014821797609329,
-0.18602785468101501,
-0.22840699553489685,
-0.16182127594947815,
0.10720004141330719,
-1.0281403064727783,
-0.08523721247911453,
0.26253488659858704,
-0.7359617948532104,
-0.3355844020843506,
-0.09811589866876602,
-0.8538035154342651,
-0.39702898263931274,
-0.5913006067276001,
0.30542632937431335,
-0.05079031363129616,
-0.001321158604696393,
0.08065417408943176,
-0.2632509171962738,
0.0471372976899147,
0.5856552720069885,
-0.7375605702400208,
-0.06891416758298874,
0.9191736578941345,
1.038885235786438,
-0.2810736298561096,
-0.12056129425764084,
-0.3592721223831177,
0.2490154206752777,
-0.36104339361190796,
0.8888846039772034,
-0.6200408339500427,
-0.5091851949691772,
-0.10311155021190643,
0.06088041141629219,
0.4243493974208832,
-0.225696861743927,
0.7653067708015442,
-0.638913094997406,
0.24505822360515594,
-0.4314723312854767,
-0.6397770643234253,
0.21175140142440796,
0.3553670048713684,
-0.6062495708465576,
0.8156962394714355,
-0.24609123170375824,
-0.9568890333175659,
0.3128350079059601,
-0.8786676526069641,
-0.40586546063423157,
-0.16179439425468445,
-0.0754961222410202,
-0.284913033246994,
0.2734036445617676,
0.39748576283454895,
0.5481376647949219,
-0.514138400554657,
0.608076274394989,
-0.39149564504623413,
-0.38172969222068787,
-0.060170598328113556,
-0.12954933941364288,
0.44511890411376953,
0.1745624840259552,
0.002284660702571273,
0.42014163732528687,
-0.5777574181556702,
-0.28561919927597046,
-0.010650919750332832,
-0.015596548095345497,
-0.5188096761703491,
0.11376728862524033,
-0.02541378140449524,
0.03184826299548149,
0.4035097062587738,
-0.39811864495277405,
0.060576777905225754,
-0.6479758620262146,
0.6206403970718384,
0.6367881894111633,
0.46531927585601807,
0.7900549173355103,
-0.5196539163589478,
0.11421556025743484,
-0.2690095603466034,
0.028513794764876366,
-0.3897124230861664,
-0.604498028755188,
-0.6205182075500488,
-0.3269462287425995,
0.43245407938957214,
0.33753877878189087,
-0.8253480195999146,
0.3402712047100067,
-0.29219526052474976,
-0.4816054403781891,
-0.2450665831565857,
-0.13227038085460663,
-0.12037928402423859,
0.47524458169937134,
0.2710171937942505,
0.012435190379619598,
-0.48883140087127686,
-0.8807259798049927,
-0.5955368280410767,
0.05950368940830231,
-0.1253199577331543,
0.06303578615188599,
0.44984573125839233,
-0.4181402027606964,
1.3661221265792847,
-0.5975930690765381,
0.22306910157203674,
-0.34729263186454773,
0.3613654375076294,
0.12366815656423569,
0.41875123977661133,
0.403067946434021,
-0.9439553618431091,
-0.4542606770992279,
-0.3625684976577759,
-0.21453027427196503,
-0.31291937828063965,
-0.151961550116539,
-0.32506975531578064,
-0.0730435699224472,
0.750451922416687,
-0.6361417174339294,
0.4259631633758545,
0.09207959473133087,
-0.389987975358963,
0.47942599654197693,
-0.049997661262750626,
0.18166066706180573,
-1.405027985572815,
-0.09179384261369705,
-0.046436067670583725,
-0.3268478214740753,
-0.8408517837524414,
-0.03214190527796745,
0.10303779691457748,
-0.5352693796157837,
-0.4496515989303589,
0.9533734321594238,
-0.453036367893219,
0.19416563212871552,
-0.8552901148796082,
0.23944933712482452,
0.23839670419692993,
-0.09893680363893509,
0.07963427156209946,
0.6180051565170288,
0.455439031124115,
-0.6106035113334656,
0.31161776185035706,
0.06936842203140259,
-0.337411105632782,
0.20746588706970215,
-0.8931775093078613,
-0.06645316630601883,
-0.39055904746055603,
0.2807389199733734,
-0.8248569965362549,
-0.36358562111854553,
-0.011340026743710041,
-0.19577385485172272,
0.2514905631542206,
0.0018241186626255512,
-0.5945588946342468,
-0.2089773714542389,
-0.5076161623001099,
0.10585326701402664,
0.6194374561309814,
-0.4988913834095001,
0.3011026978492737,
0.3641476333141327,
-0.595622718334198,
-0.1854419857263565,
-0.42586368322372437,
0.38843366503715515,
-0.481853723526001,
-0.7135850191116333,
0.8562109470367432,
-0.10822178423404694,
-0.4939306080341339,
0.18547865748405457,
0.08839800208806992,
-0.17503692209720612,
0.26990243792533875,
-0.21976132690906525,
-0.007568948436528444,
-0.01490367203950882,
0.6193158626556396,
0.37104532122612,
-0.05773157998919487,
-0.19620241224765778,
0.07122710347175598,
0.5770595669746399,
0.17757666110992432,
0.0013153222389519215,
-0.6020351052284241,
0.5037623047828674,
0.2782557010650635,
-0.24071212112903595,
0.7531090378761292,
0.43327948451042175,
-0.6015143394470215,
-0.20371384918689728,
-0.5104958415031433,
-0.756658136844635,
-0.47798797488212585,
0.4439719617366791,
-0.24439632892608643,
-1.273616909980774,
0.5410123467445374,
-0.3897404372692108,
0.011198197491466999,
0.5808528065681458,
0.4368108808994293,
0.028710657730698586,
0.7278435826301575,
1.0520340204238892,
0.016162941232323647,
0.7420760989189148,
0.05960660055279732,
0.25472503900527954,
-0.4087085723876953,
0.0028365461621433496,
-0.7755798697471619,
-0.07143893837928772,
-0.5867403745651245,
-0.4338878095149994,
-0.12861961126327515,
0.1562393605709076,
-0.024758826941251755,
0.11889532953500748,
-0.31829068064689636,
0.5374266505241394,
0.2834694981575012,
0.23015204071998596,
0.0995466560125351,
0.14606405794620514,
0.27335256338119507,
-0.2380143404006958,
-0.4126669466495514,
-0.9328436255455017,
0.7009428143501282,
0.49448007345199585,
0.8605289459228516,
-0.1772148162126541,
0.7524763345718384,
0.5226846933364868,
0.27933555841445923,
-0.5754989385604858,
0.5722940564155579,
-0.05301602557301521,
-0.4793468415737152,
-0.4337396025657654,
-0.4200981855392456,
-0.6485000252723694,
0.11213168501853943,
-0.15758094191551208,
-0.6319864392280579,
0.21936334669589996,
-0.03752388060092926,
-0.41455018520355225,
0.17068937420845032,
-0.5669405460357666,
0.7465628385543823,
0.02898441068828106,
-0.400882750749588,
-0.4689280390739441,
-0.48018741607666016,
0.15629829466342926,
-0.35284188389778137,
0.19060751795768738,
-0.3984622061252594,
-0.4693196415901184,
0.7714385986328125,
-0.4701956510543823,
0.981568455696106,
-0.03454630449414253,
-0.14161229133605957,
0.3410707414150238,
-0.4137452244758606,
0.6307851672172546,
0.44154977798461914,
-0.18120922148227692,
-0.07739659398794174,
-0.3280019164085388,
-0.5765201449394226,
-0.4906938076019287,
0.7741647362709045,
-0.564335823059082,
-0.971064031124115,
0.07337023317813873,
-0.4172973036766052,
-0.1205369308590889,
0.2696998715400696,
0.11380716413259506,
0.46213552355766296,
-0.43202993273735046,
0.2971213757991791,
0.6468861699104309,
-0.30667418241500854,
0.4915732741355896,
0.3345118463039398,
-0.05771531164646149,
-0.3410896956920624,
0.6072131991386414,
0.08053845912218094,
0.10891584306955338,
0.6026198267936707,
0.33695581555366516,
-0.32541966438293457,
-0.5981693267822266,
-0.07291533797979355,
0.28344249725341797,
-0.7075533270835876,
-0.04363970085978508,
-0.8418565392494202,
-0.023885730654001236,
-0.6001704931259155,
-0.43780630826950073,
-0.36559706926345825,
-0.49399182200431824,
-0.7764809131622314,
-0.10351043939590454,
0.47533634305000305,
0.5007619261741638,
0.0963309109210968,
0.4851519763469696,
-0.9185316562652588,
0.43290963768959045,
0.22402280569076538,
0.07690339535474777,
-0.18769267201423645,
-0.7105450630187988,
-0.24413622915744781,
0.22687886655330658,
-0.29189884662628174,
-0.9668930768966675,
0.3082752227783203,
0.271789014339447,
0.554092526435852,
0.2998419404029846,
0.3801545202732086,
0.6970118284225464,
-0.6321669816970825,
0.9971400499343872,
-0.031382303684949875,
-1.0760674476623535,
0.9793753027915955,
-0.4233320951461792,
0.34520867466926575,
0.5359183549880981,
0.43327468633651733,
-0.4631177484989166,
-0.3078557550907135,
-0.5395679473876953,
-1.0393848419189453,
0.3990738093852997,
0.20689745247364044,
0.42298662662506104,
-0.1961042582988739,
0.6991134881973267,
0.2663232088088989,
0.2711876332759857,
-0.39868980646133423,
0.03280451148748398,
-0.03701295331120491,
-0.13561980426311493,
-0.1554488241672516,
-0.7492261528968811,
0.013813097029924393,
-0.11994336545467377,
0.6809043884277344,
-0.048583801835775375,
0.08997993171215057,
0.13605688512325287,
-0.06962324678897858,
0.027041688561439514,
0.4606839120388031,
0.8332456946372986,
0.8413243889808655,
-0.15908822417259216,
-0.07613752037286758,
0.2679799497127533,
-0.24109461903572083,
0.021376317366957664,
0.2734534442424774,
-0.31451845169067383,
0.31948232650756836,
0.24375714361667633,
0.6706739068031311,
0.3100197911262512,
-0.5159772634506226,
0.3763580322265625,
-0.13989876210689545,
0.11632698029279709,
0.10841561108827591,
-0.21930783987045288,
0.20626278221607208,
0.36498236656188965,
0.48385336995124817,
-0.13838766515254974,
0.21206197142601013,
-0.6438979506492615,
0.39849063754081726,
0.1533501297235489,
-0.2754603326320648,
-0.34115681052207947,
0.4851069152355194,
0.460953950881958,
-0.23467764258384705,
0.31065475940704346,
-0.08150608837604523,
-0.3579648733139038,
0.6924953460693359,
0.2990286648273468,
0.873336672782898,
0.058397743850946426,
0.12337065488100052,
0.2944132089614868,
0.27700185775756836,
-0.3520597219467163,
0.2288666069507599,
0.02548515610396862,
-0.5052012205123901,
-0.6373262405395508,
-0.513810932636261,
-0.5536587834358215,
-0.04493166133761406,
-0.48009493947029114,
0.6245197653770447,
-0.14284144341945648,
-0.3511483371257782,
-0.13006249070167542,
0.3010883033275604,
-0.23633868992328644,
0.22660981118679047,
-0.08032193779945374,
1.128981351852417,
-0.7221916317939758,
0.8155609369277954,
0.8674910664558411,
0.012670169584453106,
-0.3316115736961365,
0.5559383630752563,
-0.23271408677101135,
-0.19863902032375336,
0.5233604311943054,
0.3339981436729431,
0.18651802837848663,
0.06509450078010559,
-0.6008573174476624,
-0.9750120043754578,
1.1644113063812256,
0.38424059748649597,
-0.6507068872451782,
-0.1992962658405304,
0.11867624521255493,
0.512676477432251,
-0.333893746137619,
0.03381967917084694,
0.24623511731624603,
0.2794381380081177,
0.08277445286512375,
-0.8613674640655518,
0.09487232565879822,
0.02493911236524582,
0.2614113390445709,
0.22612513601779938,
-0.6733421087265015,
0.8229442238807678,
-0.3150820732116699,
-0.35444989800453186,
0.2579585611820221,
1.049109935760498,
0.2066810578107834,
0.47986748814582825,
0.24695229530334473,
0.34683820605278015,
0.8632025718688965,
-0.07416003942489624,
0.9165831804275513,
-0.4615894854068756,
0.4062364101409912,
1.017978549003601,
-0.35148513317108154,
0.6436927318572998,
0.48632821440696716,
0.368704617023468,
0.15742114186286926,
0.9609158039093018,
0.35715052485466003,
0.9053316116333008,
0.19086584448814392,
-0.15119895339012146,
-0.21104015409946442,
-0.47296419739723206,
-0.49220654368400574,
0.1864294409751892,
0.48725810647010803,
-0.36828139424324036,
-0.44948920607566833,
0.30068930983543396,
-0.014944224618375301,
0.11454429477453232,
-0.6458819508552551,
0.677842915058136,
0.2152269184589386,
-0.4429711103439331,
0.17102248966693878,
0.355256587266922,
0.9068806171417236,
-0.41082289814949036,
0.09925059974193573,
-0.30288487672805786,
-0.04003143310546875,
0.03240644931793213,
-0.6393598914146423,
0.5991689562797546,
0.14734123647212982,
-0.39575085043907166,
-0.4798998534679413,
1.2325330972671509,
-0.4624399244785309,
-0.22840332984924316,
0.12583492696285248,
0.5552352070808411,
-0.07996321469545364,
-0.21103216707706451,
-0.6772871017456055,
0.16088861227035522,
-0.06733578443527222,
-0.35633471608161926,
0.07626760751008987,
0.6853313446044922,
-0.22999683022499084,
0.5424067974090576,
0.4806046187877655,
0.0022004416678100824,
-0.26418909430503845,
0.16913112998008728,
1.108891248703003,
-0.9124517440795898,
-0.7754218578338623,
-1.0264270305633545,
0.519137442111969,
-0.38962098956108093,
-0.1510368436574936,
0.7615787386894226,
0.44611069560050964,
0.6697732210159302,
0.0665285512804985,
0.6107727289199829,
0.09208741039037704,
1.0150381326675415,
-0.5814953446388245,
0.849763035774231,
-0.7421870827674866,
0.44109290838241577,
-0.1556025743484497,
-0.7579489350318909,
-0.2733992040157318,
0.10083433240652084,
-0.5751739144325256,
0.012675992213189602,
0.5837282538414001,
0.8847513794898987,
-0.019102709367871284,
0.2140025496482849,
0.33408039808273315,
0.10976530611515045,
0.4400857090950012,
-0.09553249180316925,
1.0499072074890137,
-0.06896594166755676,
0.31138280034065247,
-0.38871490955352783,
-0.09940918534994125,
-0.3893606960773468,
-1.0279500484466553,
-1.1284898519515991,
-0.46301886439323425,
-0.5075781345367432,
-0.06462211161851883,
0.4110768139362335,
1.0095211267471313,
0.6148432493209839,
-0.574894905090332,
0.01938658021390438,
-0.08079861104488373,
0.3316122591495514,
0.44754162430763245,
-0.2801768481731415,
0.5019980072975159,
-0.42616039514541626,
-0.6684896349906921,
0.3540355861186981,
0.24262972176074982,
0.12923496961593628,
-0.06646816432476044,
0.13774333894252777,
-0.09704387187957764,
0.27849438786506653,
0.7540928721427917,
-0.05960133671760559,
-0.7486777305603027,
-0.4044390022754669,
-0.005437857937067747,
-0.28375840187072754,
-0.18011462688446045,
0.9594504237174988,
-0.5802932977676392,
0.05424622818827629,
0.8154172301292419,
0.7058883905410767,
0.21448543667793274,
0.20941223204135895,
0.4549062252044678,
-0.8209061026573181,
0.33396443724632263,
0.25824427604675293,
0.36414697766304016,
0.5140769481658936,
-0.4254652261734009,
0.18857137858867645,
0.36913439631462097,
-0.4924949109554291,
-0.8709909915924072,
0.288323312997818,
-0.658719003200531,
-0.5750859975814819,
1.188985824584961,
0.21033872663974762,
-0.23270034790039062,
-0.1556394249200821,
-0.3877306580543518,
0.23317670822143555,
-0.5694671273231506,
0.8773912191390991,
0.5653867125511169,
0.1721981018781662,
-0.39514660835266113,
-0.3759777545928955,
0.5983090400695801,
0.25915226340293884,
-0.9228811264038086,
-0.0880005732178688,
0.3394731283187866,
0.24017441272735596,
-0.016969285905361176,
0.6339900493621826,
0.08779299259185791,
0.11687341332435608,
-0.39237281680107117,
-0.15179064869880676,
0.2596392333507538,
-0.40209996700286865,
-0.32200077176094055,
0.24990084767341614,
0.0722399652004242,
0.191557377576828
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17691v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17691v2
|
Not All Similarities Are Created Equal: Leveraging Data-Driven Biases to Inform GenAI Copyright Disputes
| 2024-03-26T13:32:32 | 2024-05-07T09:15:01 |
Uri Hacohen, Adi Haviv, Shahar Sarfaty, Bruria Friedman, Niva Elkin-Koren, Roi Livni, Amit H Bermano
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
The advent of Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) models, including
GitHub Copilot, OpenAI GPT, and Stable Diffusion, has revolutionized content
creation, enabling non-professionals to produce high-quality content across
various domains. This transformative technology has led to a surge of synthetic
content and sparked legal disputes over copyright infringement. To address
these challenges, this paper introduces a novel approach that leverages the
learning capacity of GenAI models for copyright legal analysis, demonstrated
with GPT2 and Stable Diffusion models. Copyright law distinguishes between
original expressions and generic ones (Sc\`enes \`a faire), protecting the
former and permitting reproduction of the latter. However, this distinction has
historically been challenging to make consistently, leading to over-protection
of copyrighted works. GenAI offers an unprecedented opportunity to enhance this
legal analysis by revealing shared patterns in preexisting works. We propose a
data-driven approach to identify the genericity of works created by GenAI,
employing "data-driven bias" to assess the genericity of expressive
compositions. This approach aids in copyright scope determination by utilizing
the capabilities of GenAI to identify and prioritize expressive elements and
rank them according to their frequency in the model's dataset. The potential
implications of measuring expressive genericity for copyright law are profound.
Such scoring could assist courts in determining copyright scope during
litigation, inform the registration practices of Copyright Offices, allowing
registration of only highly original synthetic works, and help copyright owners
signal the value of their works and facilitate fairer licensing deals. More
generally, this approach offers valuable insights to policymakers grappling
with adapting copyright law to the challenges posed by the era of GenAI.
|
[
-0.20303961634635925,
-0.38956713676452637,
0.4279734194278717,
0.07801502197980881,
-0.27733591198921204,
0.15643224120140076,
-0.14277492463588715,
-0.3884722888469696,
0.07857474684715271,
0.6316649317741394,
-0.41641485691070557,
-0.23470467329025269,
-0.632243275642395,
-0.1913803666830063,
-0.5866332054138184,
1.0091426372528076,
0.040028106421232224,
0.005427636671811342,
-0.27189183235168457,
-0.4983718991279602,
-0.36236757040023804,
-0.21924374997615814,
-0.3105453848838806,
-0.091433085501194,
0.3039552867412567,
-0.0554901584982872,
0.4794534146785736,
0.5975098609924316,
0.1717986911535263,
0.2675098478794098,
0.006398388650268316,
-0.33003222942352295,
-0.6588714122772217,
0.07682022452354431,
-0.21538510918617249,
-0.5021071434020996,
-0.09018155187368393,
0.3262990713119507,
0.5875809788703918,
0.3112173080444336,
0.006701946258544922,
0.3374435603618622,
0.14873988926410675,
0.8675995469093323,
-0.5875446796417236,
-0.007351151667535305,
-0.73590087890625,
0.2427351027727127,
-0.4326997399330139,
-0.16943807899951935,
-0.31185466051101685,
-0.4488959312438965,
0.1946558654308319,
-1.0276778936386108,
0.5538507103919983,
-0.3834056854248047,
0.9580431580543518,
0.5569725036621094,
-0.3343227505683899,
-0.37392738461494446,
-0.7099857926368713,
0.7373338937759399,
-0.6314167976379395,
0.057308122515678406,
-0.29019927978515625,
0.592921257019043,
-0.04971415549516678,
-0.928855299949646,
-0.737676739692688,
-0.06407438963651657,
0.2632707357406616,
0.26081928610801697,
-0.2724519371986389,
-0.23580045998096466,
0.5019139647483826,
0.43584054708480835,
-0.7681604623794556,
0.05145042762160301,
-0.4518321752548218,
-0.295428991317749,
0.7641746401786804,
-0.17301002144813538,
0.6611650586128235,
-0.25643202662467957,
-0.1788800209760666,
-0.0072307405062019825,
-0.8383602499961853,
-0.09364834427833557,
0.9678974151611328,
-0.057225972414016724,
-0.07197868078947067,
0.4902542233467102,
-0.054552722722291946,
0.3364838659763336,
0.18185028433799744,
0.2783477306365967,
0.3214203417301178,
-0.05116841569542885,
-0.21517127752304077,
-0.18692553043365479,
0.9562236070632935,
0.17658959329128265,
0.5146602392196655,
-0.2228987216949463,
-0.036328140646219254,
0.016755351796746254,
0.21576455235481262,
-0.44085079431533813,
-0.1912504881620407,
0.04436459019780159,
-0.8374324440956116,
-0.3198131322860718,
0.5528044700622559,
-1.0774074792861938,
-0.6343720555305481,
-0.8111945986747742,
0.4234108030796051,
-0.0810219794511795,
-0.5289506912231445,
-0.27497318387031555,
-0.511461615562439,
0.37599945068359375,
0.043624795973300934,
-0.7069374322891235,
-0.19402030110359192,
0.8408107161521912,
0.6677426099777222,
-0.011020530015230179,
-0.18648137152194977,
-0.3686317503452301,
0.3647572696208954,
-0.20100654661655426,
0.5553194284439087,
-0.5833710432052612,
-0.2125398963689804,
-0.09260497242212296,
-0.07613439857959747,
-0.034542255103588104,
-0.7584453821182251,
0.09353535622358322,
-0.6665244102478027,
0.1370375156402588,
-0.23900698125362396,
-0.6010488271713257,
-0.18548056483268738,
0.020482631400227547,
-1.1802526712417603,
0.43772682547569275,
0.3770078718662262,
-0.5966219902038574,
1.0209038257598877,
-0.6769117116928101,
-0.4263290762901306,
0.3561578691005707,
-0.6603130102157593,
-0.5640592575073242,
0.16176347434520721,
-0.018839288502931595,
0.022373495623469353,
-0.14561310410499573,
0.4527330994606018,
-0.2400115579366684,
0.0506407730281353,
0.16648665070533752,
-0.36164459586143494,
0.9433765411376953,
0.47953709959983826,
-0.6365665793418884,
0.11567547172307968,
-0.7885298728942871,
-0.10662630945444107,
0.2557264566421509,
-0.2840947210788727,
-0.31061020493507385,
-0.10160944610834122,
-0.028331339359283447,
0.1502462923526764,
0.12270524352788925,
-0.5008623003959656,
0.19584345817565918,
0.049288567155599594,
0.5948196053504944,
0.8346319198608398,
-0.1341678649187088,
0.47262993454933167,
-0.5853940844535828,
0.7382538914680481,
-0.18952366709709167,
0.29852423071861267,
0.2968737781047821,
-0.7701577544212341,
-0.22237904369831085,
-0.2179160863161087,
0.7184310555458069,
0.3410516083240509,
-0.7869579792022705,
0.10832765698432922,
-0.7061259746551514,
-0.3256915807723999,
-0.8213003277778625,
0.2531719505786896,
0.12096425890922546,
0.24456705152988434,
0.07517500221729279,
-0.4909215271472931,
-0.4849565923213959,
-0.7696974277496338,
-0.4944095313549042,
0.026997515931725502,
-0.2769678235054016,
0.48889702558517456,
0.05109765753149986,
-0.15772847831249237,
1.1034282445907593,
0.07398980855941772,
-0.41642969846725464,
-0.26214879751205444,
0.6579781770706177,
0.1871953010559082,
0.4727137088775635,
0.8603824377059937,
-1.0992796421051025,
-0.6387262940406799,
0.137564554810524,
-1.014022707939148,
-0.4654380977153778,
-0.5015122294425964,
-0.12246935814619064,
-0.025992589071393013,
0.30791962146759033,
-0.48006364703178406,
0.5551053881645203,
0.19644473493099213,
-0.21900206804275513,
0.46573349833488464,
0.05551007762551308,
0.31591784954071045,
-0.6982129216194153,
0.2797752618789673,
-0.07865873724222183,
0.012572173960506916,
-0.48476606607437134,
0.4915468096733093,
-0.22660385072231293,
-0.08686668425798416,
-0.4321366548538208,
0.2045297920703888,
-0.2509708106517792,
-0.3555849492549896,
-0.3148018717765808,
-0.3246981203556061,
-0.02796126715838909,
0.25999271869659424,
-0.18198223412036896,
0.8329545259475708,
0.38474103808403015,
-0.32223567366600037,
0.2200329452753067,
-0.005978287197649479,
-0.3255816698074341,
0.7392449975013733,
-0.6469982862472534,
0.3485759496688843,
-0.24318821728229523,
0.1386224776506424,
-0.44632384181022644,
-0.22093059122562408,
0.38847118616104126,
-0.3376955986022949,
0.22576308250427246,
-0.7830111980438232,
-0.4083751440048218,
-0.19696228206157684,
-0.1866675615310669,
0.7978095412254333,
0.6806250214576721,
-0.5032346844673157,
1.1358875036239624,
0.40827783942222595,
-0.16924266517162323,
-0.575446367263794,
-0.6278403997421265,
0.15533165633678436,
-0.4831402897834778,
-0.7347744703292847,
0.4515078067779541,
-0.10285856574773788,
-0.20371177792549133,
0.1723450869321823,
0.26817482709884644,
-0.03977581858634949,
-0.12094030529260635,
0.31990498304367065,
-0.037804294377565384,
-0.08834130316972733,
-0.2652657628059387,
0.1800300031900406,
0.043574415147304535,
0.17869573831558228,
-0.47799983620643616,
0.4793500304222107,
0.33875396847724915,
-0.2762501537799835,
-0.2643583416938782,
0.37041234970092773,
0.7279369831085205,
0.09226614236831665,
0.024657776579260826,
0.4267476499080658,
-0.0766884833574295,
-0.27872341871261597,
-0.5019693970680237,
0.40639665722846985,
-0.44544917345046997,
-0.14038275182247162,
-0.2982444167137146,
-0.6160913109779358,
0.7331448793411255,
0.010022887028753757,
0.1912475973367691,
0.7767834067344666,
0.5474026203155518,
0.3694460391998291,
0.5967235565185547,
0.3686995506286621,
-0.2869095802307129,
0.6348670125007629,
-0.5615828037261963,
0.0038661279249936342,
-0.716799795627594,
-0.2788696587085724,
-0.16067971289157867,
-0.6350107789039612,
-0.6789275407791138,
-0.1478196680545807,
0.14414545893669128,
-0.3937963545322418,
-0.2284633219242096,
0.3670332729816437,
-0.5511376261711121,
0.6451863646507263,
0.7849202752113342,
0.1266270875930786,
0.38414469361305237,
0.11186040937900543,
0.08413410186767578,
0.23519138991832733,
-0.34333768486976624,
-0.5160039067268372,
1.6940257549285889,
0.3029868006706238,
0.40411317348480225,
0.2344663292169571,
0.6294119358062744,
0.8127759099006653,
0.41586175560951233,
-0.7004603743553162,
0.3918802738189697,
-0.5252563953399658,
-0.7195956707000732,
-0.14605963230133057,
-0.7068274617195129,
-0.9867972135543823,
-0.05483495816588402,
0.06309017539024353,
-0.38379406929016113,
0.5064789652824402,
-0.17005325853824615,
-0.33373016119003296,
0.37773382663726807,
-0.47113582491874695,
0.6877937316894531,
-0.10108169913291931,
-0.42475244402885437,
-0.26249876618385315,
-0.5418421626091003,
0.30786266922950745,
-0.22891496121883392,
0.3001743257045746,
-0.03205828741192818,
0.29949626326560974,
0.9327248334884644,
-0.3430024981498718,
0.5815751552581787,
-0.1967080533504486,
-0.015698308125138283,
0.6562063097953796,
0.10401816666126251,
0.03180645406246185,
-0.002797244116663933,
0.00434795580804348,
0.1931782066822052,
0.0954090803861618,
-0.42171862721443176,
-0.782655656337738,
0.5493702292442322,
-0.7396602034568787,
-0.37101128697395325,
-0.10870060324668884,
-0.4489494562149048,
0.2816142141819,
0.3132382035255432,
0.6495898962020874,
0.12490734457969666,
-0.34847989678382874,
-0.24817295372486115,
0.48665371537208557,
-0.06376350671052933,
0.18271826207637787,
0.4217431843280792,
0.1278470754623413,
-0.4110301733016968,
1.209314227104187,
0.16279993951320648,
0.14164215326309204,
-0.15491287410259247,
0.24735385179519653,
-0.10709401220083237,
-0.565639078617096,
-0.6573913097381592,
0.13242802023887634,
-0.7724481821060181,
-0.07928735017776489,
-0.2987707257270813,
-0.16930781304836273,
-0.38873887062072754,
0.0544029138982296,
-0.030262498185038567,
-0.32510942220687866,
-0.2736782431602478,
0.23841477930545807,
0.0026253925170749426,
1.0650149583816528,
-0.1690603345632553,
0.039158351719379425,
-0.5354140400886536,
0.511193573474884,
0.6875845193862915,
0.4806424379348755,
0.031200090423226357,
-0.5763813257217407,
0.2865523397922516,
0.17989332973957062,
-0.45039376616477966,
-0.6333695650100708,
0.18638354539871216,
0.2091168314218521,
0.5794610977172852,
0.5415821671485901,
-0.18429122865200043,
0.1883411556482315,
-0.5091536641120911,
0.7111837267875671,
-0.0674365907907486,
-1.0699328184127808,
0.5627983212471008,
-0.4327082931995392,
-0.34939587116241455,
0.6202363967895508,
0.32735154032707214,
-0.12011582404375076,
-0.2000562995672226,
-0.7745403051376343,
-0.5864470601081848,
0.13250775635242462,
0.33263909816741943,
0.23929131031036377,
0.3902066648006439,
0.520191490650177,
0.3668029308319092,
0.26798003911972046,
-0.8236882090568542,
0.22211764752864838,
-0.4485834538936615,
-0.4733816683292389,
0.46269166469573975,
0.27552327513694763,
-0.3112359941005707,
-0.3152044415473938,
0.3659045994281769,
-0.1205061599612236,
0.2750072777271271,
-0.0008718485478311777,
-0.2486666738986969,
-0.18110400438308716,
0.1381775438785553,
0.20899277925491333,
0.817756712436676,
0.10991400480270386,
-0.2597880959510803,
-0.4707801342010498,
-0.5945103764533997,
0.12550033628940582,
0.2544811964035034,
-0.5502434372901917,
-0.023109233006834984,
0.20071269571781158,
0.453461617231369,
-0.44288936257362366,
-0.6869162321090698,
0.6839094161987305,
0.05583316087722778,
-0.4524245858192444,
-0.3771193325519562,
0.02119625173509121,
-0.4866771697998047,
0.3951784670352936,
0.33692318201065063,
0.0004174227360635996,
0.5101023316383362,
-0.7841941118240356,
0.36968907713890076,
0.528897225856781,
-0.1321546584367752,
-0.21609796583652496,
0.8788236975669861,
0.04082915186882019,
0.07652489840984344,
0.5481477975845337,
-0.1860290765762329,
-0.5066958069801331,
0.9800436496734619,
0.04115124046802521,
0.9577602744102478,
0.024141231551766396,
0.3352818191051483,
-0.0320090614259243,
-0.042203497141599655,
-0.07191405445337296,
0.14940062165260315,
0.00905811320990324,
-0.5250025391578674,
-0.19333966076374054,
-0.20567427575588226,
-0.1570313423871994,
0.17841275036334991,
-0.6031529903411865,
0.024068720638751984,
-0.8141051530838013,
-0.1632908433675766,
0.16586001217365265,
-0.35118165612220764,
-0.7959404587745667,
-0.040586117655038834,
0.20671811699867249,
0.3268764019012451,
-0.9528367519378662,
0.5156617164611816,
0.3464738726615906,
-0.8781991600990295,
-0.7589569091796875,
0.2493865042924881,
0.2120155394077301,
-0.5668389797210693,
0.6554972529411316,
0.11436870694160461,
0.3364063501358032,
0.00012320898531470448,
-0.8458055257797241,
-0.45061764121055603,
1.1690411567687988,
0.44240713119506836,
-0.5092777013778687,
0.1272209733724594,
0.37004488706588745,
0.6269963979721069,
-0.42544642090797424,
0.04775715991854668,
0.8082438111305237,
0.31499388813972473,
0.35739395022392273,
-0.561216413974762,
0.13481122255325317,
-0.4645727574825287,
-0.15973050892353058,
0.062335435301065445,
-0.3003075122833252,
0.7118415236473083,
-0.019563570618629456,
-0.5229009985923767,
0.31368300318717957,
0.5379600524902344,
0.15966060757637024,
0.7291564345359802,
0.43760085105895996,
0.884126603603363,
0.6660070419311523,
-0.10219085961580276,
0.9997225999832153,
-0.006022214889526367,
0.31429335474967957,
0.9080805778503418,
-0.2418990284204483,
0.4533635973930359,
0.2990233600139618,
-0.2821747958660126,
0.8353788256645203,
0.21542416512966156,
-0.7187249064445496,
0.4803343415260315,
0.5370648503303528,
-0.3662646412849426,
0.13115918636322021,
-0.1059473305940628,
-0.19429035484790802,
0.1382666677236557,
0.1239321380853653,
-0.6496404409408569,
0.15494954586029053,
0.030405201017856598,
-0.30218076705932617,
0.16866491734981537,
-0.12093528360128403,
1.0294126272201538,
-0.1655821055173874,
-0.5297911167144775,
0.12502911686897278,
-0.3800289034843445,
0.65497225522995,
-0.18044337630271912,
0.027928628027439117,
-0.14256010949611664,
-0.13635697960853577,
-0.2682967185974121,
-0.965318500995636,
0.28109586238861084,
0.06750790774822235,
-0.2642403244972229,
0.0858282744884491,
0.3318127393722534,
-0.3129202723503113,
-0.34284067153930664,
0.2364608645439148,
0.21710242331027985,
-0.03199896961450577,
-0.1310984343290329,
-0.7752045392990112,
0.0827997550368309,
-0.11003661900758743,
0.11589910835027695,
0.33584439754486084,
0.43734365701675415,
-0.0421505905687809,
0.4519307315349579,
0.6546214818954468,
0.30625998973846436,
0.2501354515552521,
0.5173483490943909,
0.8488677740097046,
-0.22153660655021667,
-0.5255194902420044,
-0.5246023535728455,
0.39148491621017456,
-0.3974277377128601,
-0.13691535592079163,
0.29425227642059326,
0.43993547558784485,
1.014634132385254,
-0.17402075231075287,
1.250431776046753,
-0.34673917293548584,
0.18149474263191223,
-0.6332622766494751,
0.8817723393440247,
-0.4264846444129944,
0.32902470231056213,
-0.45278871059417725,
-1.0076980590820312,
-0.22039999067783356,
0.2310211956501007,
-0.4548315703868866,
0.23043613135814667,
0.03173665702342987,
0.5377339720726013,
-0.4085753262042999,
0.0009922278113663197,
-0.09260126203298569,
-0.22560586035251617,
0.6444975733757019,
0.698206901550293,
0.939387857913971,
-0.5103890895843506,
0.48258087038993835,
-0.10346799343824387,
-0.3433639407157898,
0.19405856728553772,
-0.8751542568206787,
-0.6879364848136902,
-0.39667806029319763,
-0.40450242161750793,
-0.31512001156806946,
-0.11699255555868149,
0.6222787499427795,
0.5297679901123047,
-0.9119449257850647,
-0.06683483719825745,
-0.34283167123794556,
0.006438741460442543,
-0.02505006454885006,
-0.33559438586235046,
0.271528035402298,
-0.06703639030456543,
-0.5476680397987366,
-0.0779644101858139,
0.05740770325064659,
0.32092681527137756,
-0.1664591282606125,
-0.09837377816438675,
0.17896296083927155,
0.2112293392419815,
0.29817619919776917,
0.7181320786476135,
-0.7692340612411499,
0.04583720490336418,
-0.5506885051727295,
0.11074811220169067,
0.14842258393764496,
1.4316293001174927,
-0.6711058020591736,
0.6699559688568115,
0.7755116820335388,
0.8372518420219421,
0.19224612414836884,
0.2557957172393799,
0.7028886675834656,
-0.5558688044548035,
0.08666420727968216,
0.247286856174469,
0.34496474266052246,
0.2075110226869583,
-0.4186660647392273,
0.5020703673362732,
0.522300124168396,
-0.6611421704292297,
-0.24098645150661469,
0.4228730797767639,
-0.876043438911438,
-0.43225806951522827,
0.9447345733642578,
-0.35465461015701294,
0.08857323974370956,
-0.09724021703004837,
-0.010918838903307915,
0.3941614627838135,
-0.2160881757736206,
1.0496842861175537,
0.517991840839386,
0.2949041426181793,
-0.11690464615821838,
-0.6800543069839478,
0.5486177802085876,
0.18526725471019745,
-0.6431792974472046,
-0.10246580094099045,
0.5439770221710205,
0.5108730792999268,
0.22714419662952423,
0.21077561378479004,
-0.49878671765327454,
0.3970218598842621,
-0.2756972312927246,
-0.12874963879585266,
-0.06497881561517715,
-0.25745534896850586,
-0.4451172947883606,
0.19751141965389252,
-0.12491615116596222,
0.06091717258095741
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18872v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18872v1
|
Targeted Visualization of the Backbone of Encoder LLMs
| 2024-03-26T12:51:02 | 2024-03-26T12:51:02 |
Isaac Roberts, Alexander Schulz, Luca Hermes, Barbara Hammer
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Attention based Large Language Models (LLMs) are the state-of-the-art in
natural language processing (NLP). The two most common architectures are
encoders such as BERT, and decoders like the GPT models. Despite the success of
encoder models, on which we focus in this work, they also bear several risks,
including issues with bias or their susceptibility for adversarial attacks,
signifying the necessity for explainable AI to detect such issues. While there
does exist various local explainability methods focusing on the prediction of
single inputs, global methods based on dimensionality reduction for
classification inspection, which have emerged in other domains and that go
further than just using t-SNE in the embedding space, are not widely spread in
NLP.
To reduce this gap, we investigate the application of DeepView, a method for
visualizing a part of the decision function together with a data set in two
dimensions, to the NLP domain. While in previous work, DeepView has been used
to inspect deep image classification models, we demonstrate how to apply it to
BERT-based NLP classifiers and investigate its usability in this domain,
including settings with adversarially perturbed input samples and pre-trained,
fine-tuned, and multi-task models.
|
[
-0.4894748628139496,
-0.7057949900627136,
0.651935875415802,
0.06361138075590134,
-0.32857775688171387,
-0.1610150933265686,
-0.12902961671352386,
-0.15872354805469513,
0.14989805221557617,
0.821990430355072,
-0.44836917519569397,
-0.7760621309280396,
-0.6429978013038635,
-0.18161365389823914,
-0.5358132719993591,
0.9586374163627625,
-0.02983909659087658,
-0.05232977867126465,
-0.442870169878006,
0.08974967896938324,
-0.3995984196662903,
-0.4262373745441437,
-0.6692723631858826,
-0.25476235151290894,
0.3357474207878113,
0.18244408071041107,
0.864977240562439,
0.5602980852127075,
0.6925827860832214,
0.2148265391588211,
-0.2096303105354309,
-0.12566103041172028,
-0.34792760014533997,
0.0630313903093338,
-0.09317579865455627,
-0.4266548752784729,
-0.3478681445121765,
-0.19488780200481415,
0.4989960789680481,
0.8489004373550415,
0.1670287698507309,
0.06960871070623398,
0.30171966552734375,
0.6519249677658081,
-0.3727554380893707,
0.39152005314826965,
-0.45181456208229065,
0.35191234946250916,
-0.01896335370838642,
-0.14004988968372345,
-0.28663143515586853,
-0.22444464266300201,
0.4915022552013397,
-0.34333372116088867,
0.2691797912120819,
-0.08105890452861786,
0.651131808757782,
0.6295048594474792,
-0.5477112531661987,
-0.20291103422641754,
-0.5195192694664001,
0.6977987289428711,
-0.6044824123382568,
0.4551502764225006,
0.20052480697631836,
0.43220415711402893,
-0.1470324993133545,
-0.650818943977356,
-0.3391769230365753,
-0.03471944481134415,
-0.17855989933013916,
0.21628034114837646,
-0.2300204634666443,
0.09020878374576569,
0.2588348090648651,
0.4430631697177887,
-0.6920931935310364,
0.16430042684078217,
-0.1712958663702011,
-0.19602300226688385,
0.5061922669410706,
0.06447943300008774,
0.4474214017391205,
-0.10000483691692352,
-0.48482635617256165,
-0.15045733749866486,
-0.5695284008979797,
0.0023326470982283354,
0.024225980043411255,
0.13085775077342987,
-0.30368390679359436,
0.5151654481887817,
0.017459135502576828,
0.7354241013526917,
-0.10845884680747986,
0.003203353378921747,
0.04722100868821144,
-0.08394934237003326,
-0.5499891042709351,
0.052558932453393936,
0.5509549379348755,
0.5801469683647156,
0.3874284327030182,
-0.12255288660526276,
0.00963843148201704,
0.05509988218545914,
0.37888383865356445,
-0.8565256595611572,
-0.4133736193180084,
0.3514237105846405,
-0.7549533843994141,
-0.3692808449268341,
-0.3681389093399048,
-0.8920294046401978,
-0.8499753475189209,
-0.36812490224838257,
0.21253351867198944,
-0.3766134977340698,
-0.1458689123392105,
0.20914985239505768,
0.038860052824020386,
0.4362543821334839,
0.47937193512916565,
-0.9065543413162231,
0.13723325729370117,
0.6169539093971252,
0.6186400055885315,
-0.3311036229133606,
-0.053003475069999695,
-0.26018020510673523,
0.06903918832540512,
-0.35284703969955444,
0.7297644019126892,
-0.47744181752204895,
-0.2021346539258957,
0.1362694650888443,
-0.20597675442695618,
-0.009660477750003338,
-0.47986528277397156,
0.4554165005683899,
-0.47831854224205017,
-0.059496793895959854,
-0.20093931257724762,
-0.56326824426651,
-0.4344721734523773,
0.6094439625740051,
-0.5569162964820862,
0.5483859181404114,
-0.24072149395942688,
-0.9955897927284241,
0.49802166223526,
-0.5897207260131836,
-0.3650516867637634,
-0.16150981187820435,
-0.30559101700782776,
-0.42447227239608765,
0.1057041585445404,
0.8527858853340149,
0.8740673065185547,
-0.07778354734182358,
0.22130253911018372,
-0.3217046558856964,
-0.31832650303840637,
0.06116310879588127,
-0.582910418510437,
0.6461880207061768,
0.11924849450588226,
-0.2077225148677826,
0.25231611728668213,
-0.6954206824302673,
-0.1618833690881729,
0.2646617889404297,
-0.37281033396720886,
-0.28675365447998047,
0.21130159497261047,
-0.0771212950348854,
-0.005817117635160685,
0.17289862036705017,
-0.3778649866580963,
0.37189367413520813,
-0.5139349699020386,
0.23304778337478638,
0.5680497884750366,
-0.0519905686378479,
0.40980881452560425,
0.3937278091907501,
0.5287381410598755,
0.023915670812129974,
0.19887636601924896,
-0.2770352363586426,
-0.4605826139450073,
-1.0521363019943237,
-0.2317284792661667,
0.23754635453224182,
0.5627681016921997,
-0.7103949785232544,
0.22305896878242493,
-0.2561587989330292,
-0.0932769775390625,
-0.3880670368671417,
0.032974448055028915,
0.16257427632808685,
0.432160347700119,
0.2577303946018219,
-0.2970088720321655,
-0.4237878918647766,
-1.2266254425048828,
-0.1862150877714157,
0.039898138493299484,
-0.3154776990413666,
0.2992001473903656,
0.5471118092536926,
-0.49210190773010254,
0.7865537405014038,
-0.4056154787540436,
-0.4159429371356964,
-0.4881676137447357,
0.02107422798871994,
0.3952919840812683,
0.3026930093765259,
0.5927596688270569,
-0.586237370967865,
-0.2682466208934784,
0.15189127624034882,
-0.9941892027854919,
0.036071740090847015,
-0.2989150881767273,
-0.026799114421010017,
-0.0994119942188263,
0.5593097805976868,
-0.26372936367988586,
0.799997866153717,
0.4241172969341278,
-0.21492889523506165,
0.21106532216072083,
-0.20813928544521332,
-0.1540689468383789,
-0.9364575743675232,
-0.18114715814590454,
0.09432432800531387,
-0.18520581722259521,
-0.7020393013954163,
0.06139613687992096,
0.07582664489746094,
-0.3997843563556671,
-0.21068798005580902,
0.3280230760574341,
-0.4208739697933197,
-0.4369834363460541,
-0.26620879769325256,
0.22324809432029724,
0.10329415649175644,
0.5572017431259155,
0.19507034122943878,
0.48585912585258484,
0.8297181725502014,
-0.3952060639858246,
0.4018937945365906,
0.2810109257698059,
-0.31588074564933777,
0.4165991246700287,
-0.7258124947547913,
0.06025681644678116,
-0.3682173490524292,
0.19107170403003693,
-1.0179729461669922,
-0.19773344695568085,
0.1677829921245575,
-0.3842270076274872,
0.5455671548843384,
-0.25095486640930176,
-0.45214295387268066,
-0.20276859402656555,
-0.45121926069259644,
0.18703357875347137,
0.2838840186595917,
-1.0155493021011353,
0.7632529139518738,
0.27690625190734863,
-0.07925432175397873,
-0.6359831094741821,
-0.8795089721679688,
0.3271738886833191,
-0.2284858375787735,
-0.6799090504646301,
0.10614731162786484,
0.2356269210577011,
-0.20335395634174347,
-0.12416976690292358,
-0.006759831681847572,
0.05703750625252724,
0.25758883357048035,
0.401803582906723,
0.18269315361976624,
-0.1319398134946823,
0.044082146137952805,
-0.03522595763206482,
-0.11296023428440094,
0.40114399790763855,
-0.27921637892723083,
0.41173672676086426,
-0.29765406250953674,
-0.5929287075996399,
-0.713840126991272,
0.34866875410079956,
0.4390155076980591,
-0.43642428517341614,
0.4329763650894165,
0.6617280840873718,
-0.4033551812171936,
-0.2709951102733612,
-0.5171669721603394,
-0.13670654594898224,
-0.42282581329345703,
0.625867486000061,
-0.2596660554409027,
-0.736267626285553,
0.5403042435646057,
-0.11220704019069672,
0.018902761861681938,
0.2990868389606476,
0.4661898612976074,
-0.21499694883823395,
1.181566596031189,
0.7584407329559326,
-0.2559342384338379,
0.25526031851768494,
-0.4808747172355652,
0.36092671751976013,
-0.9927920699119568,
-0.4797576665878296,
-0.25838303565979004,
-0.49674537777900696,
-0.42520302534103394,
-0.47915589809417725,
0.33201444149017334,
-0.009752714075148106,
-0.12127295881509781,
-0.023184658959507942,
-0.5361714959144592,
0.5639666318893433,
0.5409085154533386,
-0.0018927681958302855,
0.09131783246994019,
0.21170487999916077,
-0.26494264602661133,
-0.3266840875148773,
-0.674418568611145,
-0.5553658604621887,
1.1437307596206665,
0.724711537361145,
1.0722736120224,
-0.07737646251916885,
0.7515338063240051,
0.2054770588874817,
0.2178116887807846,
-0.9160171151161194,
0.5478913187980652,
-0.36906319856643677,
-0.33880817890167236,
-0.2522082030773163,
-0.11893284320831299,
-0.95295250415802,
0.44467270374298096,
-0.07636142522096634,
-0.7894870638847351,
0.3195479214191437,
0.338334321975708,
-0.3289826512336731,
0.5049221515655518,
-0.7639239430427551,
1.0388294458389282,
-0.5470796227455139,
-0.20814073085784912,
-0.07674005627632141,
-0.5151381492614746,
0.3987162709236145,
0.2523705065250397,
0.10671993345022202,
0.2140447348356247,
0.19640640914440155,
0.5832783579826355,
-0.10242806375026703,
1.1336169242858887,
-0.12593309581279755,
-0.2632770538330078,
-0.057983316481113434,
0.19518090784549713,
0.47341784834861755,
0.2101743221282959,
0.26027873158454895,
0.12484050542116165,
-0.4105416536331177,
-0.20514662563800812,
-0.6200680136680603,
0.7769103646278381,
-0.6131204962730408,
-0.6858136057853699,
-0.30407747626304626,
-0.5442091226577759,
-0.2672075629234314,
0.06572199612855911,
-0.059338878840208054,
0.5075920224189758,
-0.02166086435317993,
0.379431813955307,
0.8553846478462219,
-0.7015000581741333,
0.2345183938741684,
0.06653930246829987,
-0.48756828904151917,
-0.08555388450622559,
0.8998581171035767,
-0.2271721065044403,
-0.0076379962265491486,
0.4725266993045807,
0.0912439152598381,
-0.32404133677482605,
-0.951448380947113,
-0.33306756615638733,
-0.01839311420917511,
-0.8734984993934631,
0.0437275692820549,
-0.43239036202430725,
-0.15426534414291382,
-0.3317335844039917,
-0.29214492440223694,
-0.20502042770385742,
-0.22843745350837708,
-0.43520933389663696,
-0.11068399250507355,
-0.055138226598501205,
0.7755865454673767,
0.1668466180562973,
0.24940982460975647,
-0.3708389103412628,
0.40109479427337646,
0.7335819602012634,
0.43652305006980896,
0.03903748840093613,
-0.42505964636802673,
-0.15918900072574615,
-0.12043920904397964,
-0.2543918192386627,
-0.7767244577407837,
0.5186182856559753,
0.015509862452745438,
0.6186186671257019,
0.5939464569091797,
-0.19689828157424927,
0.44660305976867676,
-0.29102984070777893,
0.7431386709213257,
0.06572023779153824,
-0.8230119347572327,
0.9714602828025818,
-0.2503131628036499,
0.41763588786125183,
0.26677337288856506,
0.16598725318908691,
-0.2820125222206116,
-0.25082576274871826,
-0.2901989817619324,
-0.941211998462677,
0.48895329236984253,
0.13535751402378082,
0.047647032886743546,
0.2026345282793045,
0.2956655025482178,
0.08775236457586288,
-0.07849583029747009,
-0.5959901809692383,
-0.2055044025182724,
-0.43404319882392883,
-0.15968982875347137,
-0.0007699866546317935,
-0.3984368145465851,
-0.14933481812477112,
-0.0864972248673439,
0.31696614623069763,
-0.2866271734237671,
0.22062094509601593,
0.23838023841381073,
-0.25890499353408813,
0.3456959128379822,
0.256030797958374,
0.31733354926109314,
0.5832990407943726,
-0.5002061724662781,
0.24453668296337128,
0.15701986849308014,
-0.2846943438053131,
-0.3652515411376953,
0.13182981312274933,
-0.24416370689868927,
-0.16213646531105042,
0.6360786557197571,
1.105792760848999,
0.059555504471063614,
-0.45231032371520996,
0.631111204624176,
-0.24076545238494873,
-0.1966707706451416,
-0.21192826330661774,
-0.17331522703170776,
0.19035568833351135,
0.553386926651001,
0.20246513187885284,
0.021105894818902016,
0.5002704858779907,
-0.4347679913043976,
-0.051674582064151764,
0.7062743306159973,
-0.5186021327972412,
-0.1276940256357193,
0.8965294361114502,
0.3153149485588074,
-0.08663590997457504,
0.6623740792274475,
0.13566787540912628,
-0.7060822248458862,
0.7526307702064514,
0.3004117012023926,
0.9170030355453491,
0.2168956995010376,
0.17549149692058563,
0.18560555577278137,
0.5318098068237305,
0.379282683134079,
0.12721401453018188,
-0.1689365655183792,
-0.713795006275177,
-0.4260023534297943,
-0.5645705461502075,
-0.4428459703922272,
0.39308732748031616,
-0.8830581903457642,
-0.1760454922914505,
-0.44919082522392273,
-0.002642023842781782,
0.13823826611042023,
-0.19941404461860657,
-0.8614512085914612,
0.5373066663742065,
0.7187299132347107,
0.8163459897041321,
-0.7360685467720032,
0.7803211212158203,
0.6905071139335632,
-0.16366761922836304,
-0.4495634138584137,
0.24031907320022583,
0.016276197507977486,
-1.0385137796401978,
0.8152123093605042,
0.4318317174911499,
-0.03314335271716118,
-0.3505760729312897,
-0.5902048945426941,
-0.7332938313484192,
0.9581672549247742,
0.3682834208011627,
-0.6315352320671082,
0.20520968735218048,
0.1511305868625641,
0.6449670791625977,
-0.25471121072769165,
-0.039821557700634,
0.7072861194610596,
0.46611088514328003,
-0.2021978199481964,
-0.6022053956985474,
-0.0036738880444318056,
-0.14523804187774658,
0.25634974241256714,
0.05593392997980118,
-0.3133132755756378,
0.4354715347290039,
-0.565517783164978,
-0.08879708498716354,
-0.3793398141860962,
0.6230189800262451,
0.1262655258178711,
0.23713436722755432,
0.49262097477912903,
0.6393833756446838,
0.44623732566833496,
-0.24243126809597015,
1.3195527791976929,
0.042395852506160736,
0.31251025199890137,
0.9731217622756958,
-0.17247895896434784,
0.6819019317626953,
0.6028754711151123,
-0.20468324422836304,
0.16733701527118683,
0.6202744841575623,
-0.2877970337867737,
0.6628780961036682,
0.35857078433036804,
0.23200520873069763,
-0.4069700241088867,
-0.0626189187169075,
-0.3216533958911896,
0.4427799582481384,
0.5351131558418274,
-0.5317246913909912,
-0.24838444590568542,
0.1695108264684677,
-0.15179160237312317,
0.007568230852484703,
-0.4627676010131836,
0.7101757526397705,
0.0037972917780280113,
-0.2473921924829483,
0.4955802261829376,
-0.32444947957992554,
0.7831767797470093,
-0.3572026789188385,
-0.09642850607633591,
-0.3505130708217621,
0.4680401384830475,
-0.20883594453334808,
-1.076935887336731,
0.2243756204843521,
-0.15039943158626556,
-0.030631788074970245,
-0.39455509185791016,
0.8200305104255676,
-0.31213846802711487,
-0.6469809412956238,
0.5607014298439026,
0.22881658375263214,
0.28793662786483765,
-0.1920127123594284,
-0.551209568977356,
0.126055508852005,
0.2591259777545929,
-0.44807299971580505,
0.39857375621795654,
0.27432018518447876,
0.006528673227876425,
1.0184866189956665,
0.42193493247032166,
-0.053876109421253204,
0.02633563056588173,
0.44977307319641113,
0.9335269927978516,
-0.5200862884521484,
-0.2130826711654663,
-0.8333775401115417,
0.4811517894268036,
-0.1864761859178543,
-0.12470262497663498,
0.7392929792404175,
0.5119146704673767,
0.6632684469223022,
-0.19852495193481445,
0.8880808353424072,
0.34302961826324463,
0.30904892086982727,
-0.6311104893684387,
0.7419568300247192,
-0.7554897665977478,
0.46667447686195374,
-0.07917732745409012,
-0.6588126420974731,
-0.6605385541915894,
0.677731990814209,
-0.3448525667190552,
-0.181454136967659,
0.5783950090408325,
0.5126749277114868,
-0.018580790609121323,
-0.15540067851543427,
0.2838258147239685,
0.27046915888786316,
0.3101937174797058,
0.635572612285614,
0.7376770377159119,
-0.2489466369152069,
0.7311995029449463,
-0.45710137486457825,
-0.1931535005569458,
-0.2637706398963928,
-0.8409181237220764,
-1.4120289087295532,
-0.20441129803657532,
-0.45825403928756714,
-0.07543518394231796,
0.1017666831612587,
0.3198230266571045,
0.5270344018936157,
-0.9645686745643616,
0.002801788505166769,
0.11762839555740356,
0.11472981423139572,
-0.05359460413455963,
-0.1639680564403534,
0.8554576635360718,
-0.10760203748941422,
-0.5964682698249817,
0.3841518461704254,
0.4237450957298279,
0.11746006458997726,
-0.40486353635787964,
0.19380927085876465,
0.13306289911270142,
-0.09979980438947678,
0.6681680083274841,
-0.027504898607730865,
-0.9578208327293396,
-0.2178581953048706,
-0.163564532995224,
0.11159796267747879,
-0.004729526117444038,
0.5675021409988403,
-0.8584417700767517,
0.6537330746650696,
0.4985639452934265,
0.8647499084472656,
0.7007243037223816,
-0.062284450978040695,
0.5984111428260803,
-0.8031905293464661,
0.09868790954351425,
0.20455984771251678,
0.5844900608062744,
0.47127765417099,
-0.3814602196216583,
0.4731995463371277,
-0.2935490310192108,
-0.5334426164627075,
-0.6367084383964539,
0.2313825786113739,
-1.0888216495513916,
-0.18531310558319092,
0.9166354537010193,
-0.16545729339122772,
-0.12516175210475922,
-0.06509675830602646,
-0.4278772473335266,
0.057772327214479446,
-0.26771125197410583,
0.7945182919502258,
0.5281673073768616,
-0.1845385581254959,
-0.2681352198123932,
-0.7468923926353455,
0.4162111282348633,
0.38437819480895996,
-0.9128510355949402,
0.10388351231813431,
0.32675930857658386,
0.18349219858646393,
0.24489308893680573,
0.13781210780143738,
-0.07543978840112686,
-0.025330277159810066,
-0.11821246147155762,
0.19807948172092438,
-0.054992999881505966,
-0.35323983430862427,
-0.6251690983772278,
0.15522940456867218,
-0.0818655863404274,
-0.4639258086681366
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17661v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17661v2
|
Language Models for Text Classification: Is In-Context Learning Enough?
| 2024-03-26T12:47:39 | 2024-04-14T15:45:53 |
Aleksandra Edwards, Jose Camacho-Collados
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent foundational language models have shown state-of-the-art performance
in many NLP tasks in zero- and few-shot settings. An advantage of these models
over more standard approaches based on fine-tuning is the ability to understand
instructions written in natural language (prompts), which helps them generalise
better to different tasks and domains without the need for specific training
data. This makes them suitable for addressing text classification problems for
domains with limited amounts of annotated instances. However, existing research
is limited in scale and lacks understanding of how text generation models
combined with prompting techniques compare to more established methods for text
classification such as fine-tuning masked language models. In this paper, we
address this research gap by performing a large-scale evaluation study for 16
text classification datasets covering binary, multiclass, and multilabel
problems. In particular, we compare zero- and few-shot approaches of large
language models to fine-tuning smaller language models. We also analyse the
results by prompt, classification type, domain, and number of labels. In
general, the results show how fine-tuning smaller and more efficient language
models can still outperform few-shot approaches of larger language models,
which have room for improvement when it comes to text classification.
|
[
-0.43325477838516235,
-0.8308221101760864,
0.4111822545528412,
0.07687201350927353,
-0.17095020413398743,
-0.2664146423339844,
-0.5068398118019104,
-0.6373473405838013,
-0.5449478030204773,
0.4479774534702301,
-0.5034996271133423,
-0.4096542298793793,
-0.6494927406311035,
0.46997156739234924,
-0.29982033371925354,
1.167486310005188,
0.09751157462596893,
-0.026000363752245903,
-0.25178298354148865,
-0.2008361518383026,
-0.8469229340553284,
-0.5681401491165161,
-0.8332812190055847,
-0.42605990171432495,
0.3227398097515106,
0.4655853509902954,
0.3184451162815094,
0.4170651137828827,
0.2548719644546509,
0.24108895659446716,
-0.29651975631713867,
0.24684199690818787,
-0.20047110319137573,
0.1703624427318573,
-0.08172665536403656,
-0.259252667427063,
-0.06276626139879227,
0.10927240550518036,
0.6300899386405945,
0.8630669713020325,
0.2133255898952484,
0.14041389524936676,
0.38212284445762634,
0.3733310103416443,
-0.5635601282119751,
0.15772929787635803,
-0.5187664031982422,
-0.03802819550037384,
0.02408866211771965,
-0.1780088245868683,
-0.8535696268081665,
-0.16275173425674438,
0.33189186453819275,
-0.31015077233314514,
0.30091628432273865,
0.19453588128089905,
0.5908481478691101,
0.11889898777008057,
-0.5351928472518921,
-0.6159324049949646,
-0.5902012586593628,
1.0315810441970825,
-0.6854822039604187,
0.20391109585762024,
0.4908042848110199,
0.21681711077690125,
-0.026505541056394577,
-0.4180385172367096,
-0.4348134696483612,
-0.1941848248243332,
-0.2252800613641739,
-0.24197179079055786,
-0.18184389173984528,
0.014626550488173962,
0.5185392498970032,
0.03666676580905914,
-0.46321776509284973,
0.5203214883804321,
-0.15444360673427582,
-0.1696910858154297,
0.3874325752258301,
0.06693704426288605,
0.3837566375732422,
-0.292617529630661,
-0.37403741478919983,
-0.042304959148168564,
-0.6129694581031799,
0.1282222867012024,
-0.023053575307130814,
0.7015517950057983,
-0.1616312563419342,
0.28458261489868164,
-0.28152263164520264,
1.1244308948516846,
0.01682298816740513,
-0.3002261519432068,
-0.10346579551696777,
-0.31280604004859924,
-0.30128857493400574,
0.026962660253047943,
0.6674114465713501,
0.2718318998813629,
0.36923497915267944,
-0.16103875637054443,
-0.2547437250614166,
0.0179419107735157,
0.006539615802466869,
-1.1000927686691284,
-0.010254654102027416,
0.13914375007152557,
-0.3767412602901459,
-0.1958809196949005,
-0.09707562625408173,
-0.5702423453330994,
-0.42100223898887634,
-0.4616183340549469,
0.459305077791214,
-0.4023572504520416,
0.001861018012277782,
0.212387353181839,
-0.12815392017364502,
0.19673442840576172,
0.6066632866859436,
-1.077176570892334,
0.17287595570087433,
0.7821997404098511,
0.8390883803367615,
-0.10578081011772156,
-0.09791245311498642,
-0.644000232219696,
-0.2885211110115051,
-0.3805902898311615,
0.8875399231910706,
-0.6988130807876587,
-0.14621412754058838,
0.25369369983673096,
-0.07130467146635056,
-0.25982466340065,
-0.42321857810020447,
0.40467000007629395,
-0.4030064344406128,
0.5189771056175232,
-0.1881803721189499,
-0.8142382502555847,
-0.22624002397060394,
0.3421308696269989,
-0.45522645115852356,
0.8295906186103821,
-0.018442200496792793,
-0.7430171966552734,
0.6261937022209167,
-0.5448861718177795,
-0.36220782995224,
0.2496107816696167,
-0.04709762707352638,
-0.3297636806964874,
0.09089796990156174,
0.19118845462799072,
0.9727599620819092,
-0.38374507427215576,
0.3734408915042877,
-0.05234494060277939,
-0.3607349991798401,
0.2916748523712158,
-0.5049671530723572,
0.7508941292762756,
0.12570913136005402,
-0.38282206654548645,
0.014582975767552853,
-0.7520740032196045,
0.06747221946716309,
-0.30056026577949524,
-0.2818140685558319,
-0.6023512482643127,
-0.1746826171875,
0.17557354271411896,
0.2836993932723999,
-0.04037485271692276,
-0.463782399892807,
0.30599114298820496,
-0.4968423843383789,
0.5978638529777527,
0.43304961919784546,
0.06874145567417145,
0.7460132241249084,
-0.27655571699142456,
0.46882450580596924,
-0.21517856419086456,
-0.18258294463157654,
-0.7416694760322571,
-0.6795044541358948,
-0.65635085105896,
-0.2266039252281189,
0.5756598114967346,
0.3443181812763214,
-0.7834731936454773,
0.44441527128219604,
-0.07198237627744675,
-0.37350329756736755,
-0.18241192400455475,
0.02373911254107952,
0.5379440188407898,
0.596862256526947,
0.31990551948547363,
-0.10541561990976334,
-0.18049776554107666,
-0.5964570641517639,
-0.13960415124893188,
-0.011100885458290577,
-0.20232518017292023,
0.43179836869239807,
0.6032811403274536,
-0.30461838841438293,
0.9195793867111206,
-0.2152547836303711,
-0.10239505022764206,
-0.35993674397468567,
0.48809200525283813,
-0.0700097605586052,
0.46247532963752747,
0.6161870956420898,
-0.6397193670272827,
-0.5824080109596252,
0.09347658604383469,
-0.6922244429588318,
-0.17525270581245422,
-0.1853574961423874,
0.2773684561252594,
0.40492895245552063,
0.5731155276298523,
-0.39064669609069824,
0.23396125435829163,
0.3818204700946808,
-0.3307497799396515,
0.3445100486278534,
-0.10287805646657944,
0.03819553926587105,
-0.8357272744178772,
0.06843861937522888,
0.2232896238565445,
-0.3652368187904358,
-1.0522328615188599,
0.08506458252668381,
0.31941068172454834,
-0.21150383353233337,
-0.4300895631313324,
0.8659690618515015,
-0.3426651656627655,
0.22181062400341034,
-0.5949090719223022,
0.16416701674461365,
0.0969282016158104,
0.3872373104095459,
0.2845361530780792,
0.5671411752700806,
0.6195404529571533,
-0.940548837184906,
0.010051176883280277,
0.19798018038272858,
-0.6058506369590759,
0.48873111605644226,
-0.4315546154975891,
0.2368278056383133,
-0.2270353138446808,
0.30064988136291504,
-0.9253393411636353,
-0.40463951230049133,
0.06372877210378647,
-0.3593100309371948,
0.5095009803771973,
-0.0463988333940506,
-0.48517993092536926,
-0.06473295390605927,
-0.20857132971286774,
0.3643617630004883,
0.34771278500556946,
-0.8066225051879883,
0.24179516732692719,
0.15778422355651855,
-0.1821863204240799,
-0.4814160466194153,
-0.46197840571403503,
-0.08060630410909653,
-0.29993563890457153,
-0.2704498767852783,
0.16185328364372253,
-0.031234558671712875,
-0.15397138893604279,
-0.3466868996620178,
-0.008277145214378834,
-0.21826304495334625,
0.27293241024017334,
0.15165331959724426,
-0.0066362181678414345,
-0.18049854040145874,
0.5495554804801941,
0.1808030903339386,
-0.2303803712129593,
-0.16668127477169037,
-0.2628643810749054,
0.3882359564304352,
-0.19568991661071777,
0.0051892162300646305,
-0.38903141021728516,
0.36018845438957214,
0.2936617136001587,
-0.08858140558004379,
0.805477499961853,
0.44565171003341675,
-0.581716001033783,
-0.583049476146698,
-0.3737431466579437,
-0.37673160433769226,
-0.41170835494995117,
0.1405690610408783,
-0.3052656352519989,
-1.2039998769760132,
0.17737679183483124,
-0.16356231272220612,
0.08997514843940735,
0.5557203888893127,
0.41775569319725037,
-0.023959053680300713,
1.0000758171081543,
1.0684943199157715,
-0.013738125562667847,
0.4228442311286926,
-0.0025469253305345774,
0.09178315103054047,
-0.5526914000511169,
-0.11584378033876419,
-0.9567590951919556,
-0.02984130010008812,
-0.5425360202789307,
-0.15542761981487274,
0.15237440168857574,
0.2928093671798706,
-0.13135381042957306,
0.44093427062034607,
-0.5874008536338806,
0.7065057754516602,
0.41239067912101746,
-0.06276647001504898,
0.2477087676525116,
0.03620199114084244,
0.04907755181193352,
0.022320985794067383,
-0.9835780262947083,
-0.7490655183792114,
0.8044601082801819,
0.39926281571388245,
0.47398149967193604,
-0.23360449075698853,
0.44394445419311523,
0.07712488621473312,
0.4526831805706024,
-0.8624058961868286,
0.2946002185344696,
-0.20035994052886963,
-0.736816942691803,
-0.4625606834888458,
-0.39328035712242126,
-0.9649626612663269,
0.3099413812160492,
-0.4169524610042572,
-0.7869624495506287,
0.1808486431837082,
0.11408108472824097,
-0.4741256535053253,
0.10260961949825287,
-0.8776754140853882,
1.0357052087783813,
0.04088502749800682,
0.015852903947234154,
0.15165376663208008,
-0.5788840055465698,
0.3122616112232208,
-0.350986123085022,
0.30857735872268677,
-0.05690843239426613,
0.11522387713193893,
0.8078441619873047,
-0.2300507128238678,
1.130513310432434,
-0.10964330285787582,
-0.1968139111995697,
0.35092777013778687,
-0.07246293872594833,
0.266519695520401,
-0.024103175848722458,
-0.049053750932216644,
0.16321292519569397,
0.07951465994119644,
-0.21564818918704987,
-0.6616503596305847,
0.47833359241485596,
-0.4188252091407776,
-0.12914592027664185,
-0.3178456723690033,
-0.20485205948352814,
-0.3001026511192322,
0.12918978929519653,
0.6033118963241577,
0.8547371029853821,
-0.01613817922770977,
0.40164467692375183,
0.8047048449516296,
-0.47989335656166077,
0.621250569820404,
0.47108978033065796,
-0.1274486631155014,
0.08844315260648727,
0.7449425458908081,
0.0924435406923294,
0.24874739348888397,
0.5835195183753967,
0.35541731119155884,
-0.2209159880876541,
-0.4489646553993225,
-0.618922233581543,
-0.028351470828056335,
-0.7256355285644531,
-0.4434359073638916,
-0.5712960958480835,
-0.13160288333892822,
-0.28671205043792725,
-0.2979164123535156,
-0.019035985693335533,
-0.23838284611701965,
-0.3741956055164337,
0.09746892750263214,
0.415828675031662,
0.7902827262878418,
0.33870911598205566,
0.6213774681091309,
-0.7675949335098267,
0.1668098121881485,
0.29487860202789307,
0.5022761225700378,
0.14620977640151978,
-0.7507153749465942,
-0.34218621253967285,
-0.16904564201831818,
-0.10832636803388596,
-0.8767052888870239,
0.35332098603248596,
0.2904113233089447,
0.3127785921096802,
0.2972182333469391,
0.08755617588758469,
0.39505234360694885,
-0.7366642951965332,
0.724162220954895,
0.11479540914297104,
-0.9487483501434326,
0.548703134059906,
-0.3035098612308502,
0.563328742980957,
0.6393796801567078,
0.5343554615974426,
-0.788101315498352,
-0.2658472955226898,
-0.5136269330978394,
-0.5987632274627686,
0.8735047578811646,
0.08525315672159195,
0.2997700870037079,
-0.07126522064208984,
0.5363953709602356,
0.34260815382003784,
0.23301418125629425,
-0.785949170589447,
-0.060268584638834,
0.15693728625774384,
-0.2633986473083496,
-0.26635313034057617,
-0.3111567199230194,
0.17583797872066498,
-0.12917284667491913,
0.4615182876586914,
-0.3699291944503784,
0.13777264952659607,
-0.060672663152217865,
-0.2623119354248047,
-0.00879323948174715,
0.5501754879951477,
0.6617451310157776,
0.527482271194458,
-0.023144664242863655,
0.10803858935832977,
0.342526376247406,
-0.2261180728673935,
0.10942016541957855,
-0.1607690155506134,
-0.43724414706230164,
0.042294587939977646,
0.6651167869567871,
0.9835988879203796,
0.39146897196769714,
-0.5862248539924622,
0.6328180432319641,
-0.12299516052007675,
-0.14337974786758423,
0.24741020798683167,
0.11478987336158752,
-0.34376004338264465,
-0.015160962007939816,
0.1741323620080948,
0.15724937617778778,
0.16852504014968872,
-0.43420806527137756,
0.10094151645898819,
0.45585381984710693,
-0.4611419141292572,
-0.2004479169845581,
0.3813694715499878,
0.2222936600446701,
-0.41882774233818054,
0.40299543738365173,
-0.30268150568008423,
-0.43569260835647583,
0.5647902488708496,
0.6202398538589478,
0.9278383255004883,
-0.1372191160917282,
0.370609849691391,
0.5004733800888062,
0.3538593351840973,
-0.36880993843078613,
-0.2878691256046295,
-0.31434664130210876,
-0.7499415278434753,
-0.6221795082092285,
-0.7836135029792786,
-0.649117648601532,
0.37864574790000916,
-0.46102604269981384,
0.24298083782196045,
-0.42532771825790405,
0.012215041555464268,
0.26262572407722473,
0.04296721890568733,
-0.6130447387695312,
0.31608423590660095,
0.1626930832862854,
0.9548932313919067,
-1.047595500946045,
0.7016229629516602,
0.6562714576721191,
-0.12122178822755814,
-0.5547536015510559,
-0.019044168293476105,
-0.1815727800130844,
-0.1550789326429367,
0.583204984664917,
0.8244497179985046,
-0.09551741182804108,
-0.029545925557613373,
-0.857404887676239,
-0.5356552004814148,
0.4784657955169678,
0.11035999655723572,
-0.5727313756942749,
0.19483406841754913,
-0.06727790087461472,
0.7844589948654175,
-0.5678324103355408,
0.24296006560325623,
0.4627301096916199,
0.31508806347846985,
-0.16224874556064606,
-0.9785494208335876,
-0.12431777268648148,
-0.0031519278418272734,
0.13369344174861908,
0.10052534192800522,
-0.30651241540908813,
0.6377862095832825,
0.05414417386054993,
-0.3664257824420929,
0.03635690361261368,
0.5100634098052979,
0.17868922650814056,
0.4882891774177551,
0.4673788547515869,
0.04916849732398987,
0.7891125679016113,
-0.16676287353038788,
1.2007304430007935,
-0.11133141815662384,
0.27865684032440186,
0.9781296849250793,
-0.13654470443725586,
0.9428995847702026,
0.028806865215301514,
0.0240000169724226,
0.383836030960083,
0.693291187286377,
0.18669292330741882,
0.3740067780017853,
0.04971461743116379,
-0.13914012908935547,
-0.30849379301071167,
-0.06103932857513428,
-0.13076165318489075,
0.34746578335762024,
0.3278603255748749,
-0.0966290757060051,
-0.24821066856384277,
0.5032713413238525,
-0.16547806560993195,
0.24116003513336182,
-0.3780212700366974,
1.0256390571594238,
0.16737784445285797,
-0.7482083439826965,
0.5503891706466675,
0.3482048213481903,
0.9389025568962097,
-0.3438224792480469,
0.0760422945022583,
-0.044263068586587906,
0.09462235122919083,
-0.1078156977891922,
-0.5035586357116699,
0.10163762420415878,
0.36235183477401733,
-0.2981656789779663,
-0.38193702697753906,
0.9579817056655884,
-0.47484269738197327,
-0.3075973093509674,
0.013250620104372501,
0.21966181695461273,
0.19037829339504242,
-0.16176150739192963,
-0.5011855959892273,
-0.1707666665315628,
-0.12662562727928162,
-0.16192267835140228,
0.42148637771606445,
0.6021637916564941,
-0.2312106192111969,
0.5901397466659546,
0.4070010185241699,
-0.2639213800430298,
0.02861836366355419,
0.13403110206127167,
0.44005006551742554,
-0.638634979724884,
-0.4935275614261627,
-0.9137439131736755,
0.3166753351688385,
-0.005295019596815109,
-0.5072690844535828,
0.7668867111206055,
0.3598191738128662,
0.8599199056625366,
-0.16363897919654846,
0.690365731716156,
0.23672956228256226,
0.6327081322669983,
-0.656658947467804,
0.4393588602542877,
-0.36224591732025146,
0.04771532863378525,
-0.31568074226379395,
-0.8785340189933777,
-0.6880508065223694,
0.7463738918304443,
-0.3477320671081543,
0.2141733467578888,
0.5652090311050415,
0.4665442407131195,
0.06318238377571106,
0.20658817887306213,
0.34405529499053955,
-0.14333495497703552,
0.11433232575654984,
0.36531421542167664,
0.8799231052398682,
-0.46129485964775085,
0.22270724177360535,
-0.18887391686439514,
-0.34345120191574097,
-0.29007813334465027,
-0.9830890893936157,
-1.1483874320983887,
-0.7252064347267151,
-0.45102575421333313,
-0.005314692389219999,
-0.15961159765720367,
0.818881094455719,
0.7681096196174622,
-0.9254522919654846,
-0.03563553839921951,
-0.08744539320468903,
0.17126905918121338,
-0.13490936160087585,
-0.1766992211341858,
0.22931362688541412,
-0.8615986704826355,
-0.8433308005332947,
0.34750282764434814,
0.28228771686553955,
0.14896763861179352,
-0.10706499963998795,
0.048609208315610886,
0.08902425318956375,
0.03812408447265625,
0.9600329995155334,
0.3597628176212311,
-0.6064677238464355,
-0.3103282153606415,
-0.08009952306747437,
-0.30029335618019104,
-0.16043969988822937,
0.749466061592102,
-0.8037556409835815,
0.4977664649486542,
0.5662344694137573,
0.7092534899711609,
0.35977110266685486,
-0.0021183262579143047,
0.3654976189136505,
-1.1521273851394653,
0.1393987536430359,
0.13273587822914124,
0.16248799860477448,
0.4146040380001068,
-0.19560790061950684,
0.3235531449317932,
-0.1731109768152237,
-0.6756800413131714,
-0.9310050010681152,
0.15217050909996033,
-0.6898542046546936,
-0.6007382273674011,
1.3488906621932983,
0.061797115951776505,
-0.05753844231367111,
-0.16727274656295776,
-0.299384742975235,
0.03651837259531021,
-0.17402788996696472,
0.5834691524505615,
0.8344133496284485,
-0.00636932160705328,
-0.13511578738689423,
-0.7117853760719299,
0.7993647456169128,
0.30293911695480347,
-0.8089805245399475,
0.19849053025245667,
0.580733060836792,
0.09417101740837097,
0.28468987345695496,
0.5354568958282471,
0.25890395045280457,
0.12817224860191345,
-0.2635278105735779,
-0.09551236033439636,
0.22734865546226501,
-0.8009282350540161,
-0.8568045496940613,
0.3026484251022339,
0.09339040517807007,
0.08052777498960495
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17647v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17647v2
|
Intrinsic Subgraph Generation for Interpretable Graph based Visual Question Answering
| 2024-03-26T12:29:18 | 2024-03-27T10:07:59 |
Pascal Tilli, Ngoc Thang Vu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The large success of deep learning based methods in Visual Question Answering
(VQA) has concurrently increased the demand for explainable methods. Most
methods in Explainable Artificial Intelligence (XAI) focus on generating
post-hoc explanations rather than taking an intrinsic approach, the latter
characterizing an interpretable model. In this work, we introduce an
interpretable approach for graph-based VQA and demonstrate competitive
performance on the GQA dataset. This approach bridges the gap between
interpretability and performance. Our model is designed to intrinsically
produce a subgraph during the question-answering process as its explanation,
providing insight into the decision making. To evaluate the quality of these
generated subgraphs, we compare them against established post-hoc
explainability methods for graph neural networks, and perform a human
evaluation. Moreover, we present quantitative metrics that correlate with the
evaluations of human assessors, acting as automatic metrics for the generated
explanatory subgraphs. Our implementation is available at
https://github.com/DigitalPhonetics/Intrinsic-Subgraph-Generation-for-VQA.
|
[
-0.4029439091682434,
-0.95270836353302,
0.4353863596916199,
-0.2684318721294403,
-0.5581744909286499,
0.24835379421710968,
0.25270259380340576,
-0.5859812498092651,
0.24437813460826874,
0.2600758373737335,
-0.9330384731292725,
-0.48212766647338867,
-0.30795058608055115,
-0.033598657697439194,
-0.40754973888397217,
0.7242435812950134,
-0.034125540405511856,
-0.15156975388526917,
-0.6743676066398621,
-0.2713627219200134,
-0.632029116153717,
-0.31758177280426025,
-0.6772423982620239,
-0.6198716163635254,
0.41765353083610535,
0.2757621705532074,
0.8185988068580627,
0.5373156070709229,
0.2820602357387543,
0.3449360430240631,
0.06766410171985626,
0.14900873601436615,
-0.650941014289856,
-0.10861995816230774,
-0.24417990446090698,
-0.3836492896080017,
-0.503225564956665,
-0.25547462701797485,
0.597836434841156,
0.6805044412612915,
0.1150674968957901,
0.47406232357025146,
-0.18949323892593384,
0.47203338146209717,
-0.15229929983615875,
0.45479461550712585,
-0.7261951565742493,
0.11924605071544647,
-0.10341581702232361,
-0.32082879543304443,
-0.2187613695859909,
-0.3562070429325104,
0.28842195868492126,
-0.8249568939208984,
0.2816145122051239,
0.10659237951040268,
1.1317927837371826,
0.30137768387794495,
-0.2073136419057846,
-0.09963949024677277,
-0.33350497484207153,
0.3081338107585907,
-0.3725305199623108,
0.25968998670578003,
-0.07831459492444992,
0.817460834980011,
0.067375548183918,
-1.1937260627746582,
-0.6538136601448059,
0.04732692241668701,
-0.12657175958156586,
0.48147550225257874,
-0.579291582107544,
-0.05554242432117462,
0.11697724461555481,
0.4785900413990021,
-0.7825929522514343,
0.054992809891700745,
-0.310511976480484,
-0.18558725714683533,
0.5853865146636963,
0.4307408630847931,
0.4835287928581238,
-0.3031722903251648,
-0.11486582458019257,
0.24404174089431763,
-0.6287931799888611,
0.5647463798522949,
0.23458051681518555,
0.06917800009250641,
0.15788652002811432,
0.6734986901283264,
-0.6229968070983887,
0.4383455812931061,
-0.04109298810362816,
0.34914731979370117,
0.226261168718338,
-0.5406826138496399,
-0.1802160143852234,
-0.08217964321374893,
0.5981152653694153,
0.4722585380077362,
0.6090284585952759,
-0.038352400064468384,
0.17158786952495575,
0.15621276199817657,
0.33502620458602905,
-0.8371302485466003,
-0.6396437287330627,
0.13101571798324585,
-0.5407688617706299,
-0.373755544424057,
-0.19869615137577057,
-0.5051714181900024,
-0.26062989234924316,
-0.27502721548080444,
0.29188209772109985,
-0.2853495478630066,
-0.25444498658180237,
-0.08431007713079453,
-0.37132391333580017,
0.32932767271995544,
0.4699772894382477,
-0.35416078567504883,
0.3348471224308014,
0.32980725169181824,
0.6933661699295044,
0.09992410242557526,
-0.1858847290277481,
-0.6397716999053955,
-0.10836469382047653,
-0.417390912771225,
0.7667780518531799,
-0.3438562750816345,
-0.2367483228445053,
-0.282696396112442,
-0.04236169531941414,
0.10309815406799316,
-0.5571414828300476,
0.3283560574054718,
-0.7044335603713989,
-0.016978131607174873,
-0.39707282185554504,
-0.31157830357551575,
-0.4281085431575775,
0.1741591840982437,
-0.5276311635971069,
0.8765196800231934,
0.43955060839653015,
-0.8020266890525818,
0.6216725707054138,
-0.6489735841751099,
-0.30236920714378357,
0.6777511835098267,
-0.3575303554534912,
-0.4612821638584137,
0.05053047835826874,
0.5917393565177917,
0.16208259761333466,
-0.25989416241645813,
0.056745875626802444,
-0.24958111345767975,
-0.37711840867996216,
0.4077603220939636,
-0.21914026141166687,
0.7241922616958618,
-0.08697711676359177,
-0.5513926148414612,
0.5828033685684204,
-0.5294355750083923,
0.46231892704963684,
0.474216490983963,
0.16969045996665955,
0.05579930543899536,
0.11748801171779633,
-0.4915901720523834,
0.22020551562309265,
-0.016165591776371002,
-0.4236675798892975,
-0.17228050529956818,
-0.12870775163173676,
0.758932888507843,
0.9142508506774902,
0.19763445854187012,
0.02983664721250534,
0.13108201324939728,
0.6698966026306152,
-0.07127977907657623,
0.32640063762664795,
-0.02214638516306877,
-0.6310539841651917,
-0.6027107238769531,
-0.3160869777202606,
0.3831920027732849,
0.5288366675376892,
-1.2654945850372314,
-0.12990224361419678,
-0.5373164415359497,
-0.6118111610412598,
-0.4466796815395355,
0.11151658743619919,
0.5241497755050659,
1.1219359636306763,
0.38131850957870483,
-0.467926025390625,
-0.2657579481601715,
-1.0633500814437866,
-0.08164652436971664,
-0.36873242259025574,
0.15685804188251495,
0.8258489966392517,
0.5986616015434265,
-0.14888118207454681,
0.9573843479156494,
-0.638227641582489,
0.012897726148366928,
-0.3929300904273987,
0.2813096344470978,
0.13391374051570892,
0.06932076811790466,
0.6688562631607056,
-0.7768924236297607,
-0.32401740550994873,
0.04347505792975426,
-1.1480767726898193,
-0.30611100792884827,
-0.15487663447856903,
-0.46244606375694275,
-0.13983884453773499,
0.4326983690261841,
-0.4089394211769104,
0.646231472492218,
0.19152212142944336,
-0.28803762793540955,
0.7877399921417236,
0.12838749587535858,
0.026918990537524223,
-0.3447917401790619,
0.061451613903045654,
0.06698720902204514,
-0.6024419665336609,
-0.2542145252227783,
0.22239099442958832,
-0.30787399411201477,
-0.2822762131690979,
-0.5594351887702942,
0.5322624444961548,
-0.32613733410835266,
-0.365654319524765,
0.03661584109067917,
0.4045512080192566,
0.21307942271232605,
0.5543336272239685,
0.1047845333814621,
0.597867488861084,
0.7012103796005249,
-0.31722766160964966,
0.5053092241287231,
0.4133013188838959,
-0.5280093550682068,
0.5281721949577332,
-1.3578304052352905,
0.012130419723689556,
-0.26036036014556885,
0.2780178189277649,
-1.3394629955291748,
-0.18786342442035675,
0.5680974721908569,
-0.7471864223480225,
0.03505240008234978,
-0.33472922444343567,
-0.008061151020228863,
-0.6149015426635742,
0.04905964434146881,
0.5007998943328857,
0.5552650094032288,
-0.6024904847145081,
0.5199011564254761,
0.1654922366142273,
-0.37016966938972473,
-0.41081517934799194,
-0.6445004940032959,
0.1814185231924057,
-0.10065161436796188,
-0.8797546625137329,
0.015103532001376152,
0.08723672479391098,
-0.13957762718200684,
0.498352974653244,
0.006470273714512587,
0.04689471051096916,
0.1623259335756302,
0.4121265709400177,
0.29083171486854553,
-0.4891115128993988,
-0.2375010848045349,
0.18955637514591217,
-0.410986989736557,
0.25953397154808044,
-0.5148473978042603,
0.22927629947662354,
-0.2976132333278656,
-0.31117910146713257,
-0.783569872379303,
0.4854857623577118,
0.4021546244621277,
-0.4934323728084564,
0.5879948735237122,
0.5549304485321045,
-0.15338732302188873,
-0.15858104825019836,
0.29141443967819214,
0.21987761557102203,
-0.4665614664554596,
0.40489107370376587,
-0.6237300038337708,
-0.6157944798469543,
0.5588982105255127,
-0.11553894728422165,
-0.2044716477394104,
0.5331973433494568,
0.6340306997299194,
-0.17897829413414001,
1.3517142534255981,
0.20812547206878662,
0.4796319603919983,
0.5535756945610046,
-0.5569374561309814,
0.005362749565392733,
-0.664695680141449,
-0.2313385158777237,
-0.028276663273572922,
-0.3734334111213684,
-0.3069491982460022,
-0.19159534573554993,
0.5076687335968018,
0.12670844793319702,
-0.2506972551345825,
-0.011572053655982018,
-0.5513649582862854,
0.4679804742336273,
0.8531196713447571,
0.26468080282211304,
0.07424246519804001,
-0.029767395928502083,
0.024609142914414406,
0.014443543739616871,
-0.7390959858894348,
-0.4027707278728485,
0.7107269763946533,
0.16243554651737213,
0.628872811794281,
0.10817689448595047,
0.3779659569263458,
0.341277152299881,
0.4401399791240692,
-0.7889001965522766,
0.4599120318889618,
-0.01105405855923891,
-0.3627867102622986,
-0.6707412600517273,
-0.7627554535865784,
-0.8948268890380859,
0.2712246775627136,
-0.31384190917015076,
-0.834750235080719,
0.0181913822889328,
0.3968057632446289,
-0.15421152114868164,
-0.08304592967033386,
-0.8178057074546814,
1.2648407220840454,
-0.39965274930000305,
-0.1425270140171051,
0.039962027221918106,
-0.6319498419761658,
0.37736448645591736,
0.2554091811180115,
-0.14507699012756348,
0.1984378844499588,
0.32849180698394775,
0.49799734354019165,
-0.53667151927948,
0.8166682124137878,
-0.4656752049922943,
0.3539249002933502,
0.7004547715187073,
0.0008237267029471695,
0.3022383153438568,
0.1634259670972824,
-0.09234806895256042,
0.3903695344924927,
-0.13025330007076263,
-0.6537615656852722,
-0.9122721552848816,
0.2310013771057129,
-0.858115553855896,
-0.5359095335006714,
0.09815343469381332,
-0.32902631163597107,
0.022808553650975227,
0.3422982096672058,
0.5724001526832581,
0.9303739070892334,
-0.1150919497013092,
0.02899063751101494,
0.2685298025608063,
-0.3259316384792328,
-0.036452386528253555,
-0.1575131118297577,
-0.3388271927833557,
-0.43441498279571533,
1.2872402667999268,
0.35652634501457214,
0.2606113851070404,
0.24374788999557495,
0.33930471539497375,
-0.6926267147064209,
-0.8989482522010803,
-0.9490988850593567,
0.06468389183282852,
-0.8036482334136963,
0.13598859310150146,
-0.44988980889320374,
-0.19029206037521362,
-0.360493540763855,
-0.18428775668144226,
0.0773531123995781,
-0.4810732901096344,
-0.08849209547042847,
-0.25710198283195496,
-0.004661555867642164,
0.6935162544250488,
0.1053151860833168,
0.3522360622882843,
-0.4887448251247406,
0.7241951823234558,
0.8090284466743469,
0.129961758852005,
0.16934067010879517,
-0.33305972814559937,
-0.24298742413520813,
0.15663017332553864,
-0.09314946085214615,
-0.7657434940338135,
0.058578286319971085,
0.2798524796962738,
0.8059053421020508,
0.1675833761692047,
0.1847919225692749,
0.7611656785011292,
-0.29726436734199524,
0.8459005355834961,
0.08411070704460144,
-1.2535759210586548,
0.622269868850708,
-0.31838908791542053,
0.1976051777601242,
0.3795885145664215,
0.25013625621795654,
-0.22137577831745148,
-0.28532329201698303,
-0.5981084108352661,
-1.0755149126052856,
0.49080464243888855,
0.3825736343860626,
-0.09279830008745193,
0.15179568529129028,
0.4573804438114166,
0.06883051246404648,
0.2648204267024994,
-0.5474556684494019,
-0.2088913917541504,
-0.779749870300293,
-0.07007911056280136,
-0.11165379732847214,
0.04734119027853012,
-0.23673154413700104,
-0.27235060930252075,
0.5772112011909485,
-0.578222930431366,
0.2523243725299835,
0.37337228655815125,
-0.372384637594223,
0.01307330559939146,
-0.25020551681518555,
0.3274316191673279,
1.134442925453186,
0.005019384436309338,
0.07760453969240189,
0.04541736841201782,
-0.19129197299480438,
-0.2113179862499237,
-0.029042590409517288,
-0.2865341901779175,
-0.08940478414297104,
0.7711965441703796,
0.985212504863739,
-0.4037865698337555,
-0.7409037947654724,
0.5415869951248169,
-0.5642105340957642,
-0.24967238306999207,
-0.1494847983121872,
0.08354786783456802,
-0.0018316881032660604,
0.4061765670776367,
0.2787569463253021,
-0.2633274793624878,
0.21037742495536804,
-0.6593729257583618,
0.23127099871635437,
0.4441434442996979,
-0.6924564838409424,
-0.3180105984210968,
0.9654803276062012,
0.243952214717865,
-0.2535238265991211,
0.9601156115531921,
-0.29485076665878296,
-0.6962875127792358,
0.8509931564331055,
0.2550182640552521,
0.6766502261161804,
0.38258153200149536,
0.7362831234931946,
0.1634971797466278,
0.3352832496166229,
0.9643741846084595,
0.46373093128204346,
-0.18954673409461975,
-0.545633852481842,
-0.5497767925262451,
-0.17397750914096832,
-0.6028943061828613,
-0.1285230964422226,
-0.8371344804763794,
-0.23177723586559296,
-0.30420222878456116,
0.038151953369379044,
0.3768227696418762,
-0.07662077248096466,
-0.6982476115226746,
0.6457668542861938,
0.14600273966789246,
0.6994097232818604,
-0.866909921169281,
0.32689571380615234,
0.6806817054748535,
-0.5563758015632629,
-0.7895137071609497,
-0.15933743119239807,
-0.1302780658006668,
-1.0980998277664185,
0.6696580648422241,
-0.05776628106832504,
-0.19578203558921814,
-0.018924105912446976,
-0.688461184501648,
-0.46799978613853455,
1.1351240873336792,
0.4391985833644867,
0.02366834506392479,
0.21037106215953827,
0.13404685258865356,
0.8143220543861389,
-0.22654245793819427,
0.3897723853588104,
0.27084341645240784,
0.29962968826293945,
0.3974760174751282,
-0.30885377526283264,
0.293661504983902,
-0.5736371278762817,
-0.16911914944648743,
0.08979401737451553,
-0.471243292093277,
0.6819919347763062,
-0.28932321071624756,
-0.37235891819000244,
0.03638370335102081,
0.8412990570068359,
0.08073193579912186,
0.5920211672782898,
0.6175621151924133,
0.3593699038028717,
0.9722021818161011,
-0.15029416978359222,
1.2876228094100952,
0.0016251029446721077,
0.11272726953029633,
1.1749266386032104,
0.06251446157693863,
0.45666414499282837,
0.09821490198373795,
0.001502052997238934,
0.7160213589668274,
0.8971357941627502,
0.2803112864494324,
0.35459911823272705,
0.38812506198883057,
0.18683627247810364,
-0.8031075596809387,
-0.3650643229484558,
-0.39696213603019714,
0.5681516528129578,
0.12781600654125214,
-0.38048693537712097,
-0.21234743297100067,
-0.38378986716270447,
-0.46378207206726074,
-0.18776409327983856,
-0.41745585203170776,
0.6345207095146179,
-0.11470387876033783,
-0.4971717894077301,
0.5663403868675232,
-0.4505454897880554,
-0.22369427978992462,
-0.42334794998168945,
-0.25261253118515015,
-0.1368437558412552,
-0.050916146486997604,
-0.34212300181388855,
-1.2582426071166992,
0.2297121286392212,
-0.0690610334277153,
-0.2114848494529724,
-0.1795942336320877,
0.5779695510864258,
0.10452280938625336,
-0.48688042163848877,
0.13305719196796417,
0.8405203819274902,
0.2552204430103302,
-0.07830121368169785,
-0.8424890637397766,
-0.32542508840560913,
-0.12157175689935684,
-0.21717728674411774,
0.01572347618639469,
0.7516223192214966,
-0.4277590811252594,
0.8192869424819946,
0.7025349736213684,
-0.2616226077079773,
0.04446633160114288,
0.24640335142612457,
1.09620201587677,
-0.45681527256965637,
-0.627571165561676,
-0.5873183012008667,
0.7629397511482239,
-0.18441791832447052,
-0.4327987730503082,
0.6660583019256592,
0.3291458189487457,
0.5444628000259399,
0.17103411257266998,
0.9343537092208862,
-0.028989659622311592,
0.16564591228961945,
-0.5343726277351379,
0.5509815216064453,
-0.714516282081604,
-0.13838472962379456,
-0.5170767903327942,
-0.6321308612823486,
-0.011449767276644707,
0.2737536132335663,
-0.3970218300819397,
-0.15025393664836884,
0.39455142617225647,
0.5075939893722534,
0.003580366261303425,
-0.06863591820001602,
0.18530668318271637,
0.3012782335281372,
0.4454253017902374,
0.5896247625350952,
1.2146732807159424,
-0.14404314756393433,
0.8939982056617737,
-0.07598349452018738,
-0.4891815483570099,
0.0037560174241662025,
-0.802166759967804,
-0.7981528043746948,
-0.3727432191371918,
-0.5268732905387878,
-0.38282445073127747,
-0.10525280982255936,
0.02957492507994175,
0.825709879398346,
-0.4093836843967438,
0.34373366832733154,
-0.08782148361206055,
0.512524425983429,
-0.5249803066253662,
-0.30374664068222046,
0.4847145974636078,
0.1872677057981491,
-0.4862704873085022,
0.14189931750297546,
0.18263833224773407,
-0.17136292159557343,
-0.1452803760766983,
-0.031904567033052444,
0.11317798495292664,
0.16825821995735168,
0.7394028902053833,
0.4654102325439453,
-0.49823373556137085,
-0.5902000665664673,
0.1291971057653427,
0.2846943736076355,
0.19576235115528107,
0.6787355542182922,
-0.9603022933006287,
0.600799560546875,
0.7759092450141907,
0.6002200841903687,
0.6249064803123474,
0.45965221524238586,
0.4697890281677246,
-0.6125808358192444,
-0.41107234358787537,
0.05104558914899826,
0.33851954340934753,
0.16009272634983063,
-0.389522522687912,
0.7295261025428772,
0.4437028169631958,
-0.3770082890987396,
-0.7277334332466125,
0.5116966366767883,
-1.0544402599334717,
-0.2411346137523651,
0.7225393652915955,
-0.3916441798210144,
-0.4243600368499756,
-0.2760658860206604,
-0.37411779165267944,
0.23364682495594025,
-0.1475287675857544,
0.31860998272895813,
0.2304343581199646,
-0.7909625768661499,
-0.20026208460330963,
-0.25229400396347046,
-0.0036451169289648533,
0.0970822125673294,
-0.956305742263794,
-0.11845260113477707,
0.5395963788032532,
0.16043101251125336,
0.08006851375102997,
0.8018642663955688,
0.07726553827524185,
0.591647744178772,
0.41540372371673584,
-0.16757431626319885,
-0.45436179637908936,
-0.3402388393878937,
-0.019478676840662956,
0.2543853521347046,
-0.023719148710370064,
-0.40568703413009644
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17645v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17645v3
|
DANCER: Entity Description Augmented Named Entity Corrector for Automatic Speech Recognition
| 2024-03-26T12:27:32 | 2024-04-11T12:07:33 |
Yi-Cheng Wang, Hsin-Wei Wang, Bi-Cheng Yan, Chi-Han Lin, Berlin Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
End-to-end automatic speech recognition (E2E ASR) systems often suffer from
mistranscription of domain-specific phrases, such as named entities, sometimes
leading to catastrophic failures in downstream tasks. A family of fast and
lightweight named entity correction (NEC) models for ASR have recently been
proposed, which normally build on phonetic-level edit distance algorithms and
have shown impressive NEC performance. However, as the named entity (NE) list
grows, the problems of phonetic confusion in the NE list are exacerbated; for
example, homophone ambiguities increase substantially. In view of this, we
proposed a novel Description Augmented Named entity CorrEctoR (dubbed DANCER),
which leverages entity descriptions to provide additional information to
facilitate mitigation of phonetic confusion for NEC on ASR transcription. To
this end, an efficient entity description augmented masked language model
(EDA-MLM) comprised of a dense retrieval model is introduced, enabling MLM to
adapt swiftly to domain-specific entities for the NEC task. A series of
experiments conducted on the AISHELL-1 and Homophone datasets confirm the
effectiveness of our modeling approach. DANCER outperforms a strong baseline,
the phonetic edit-distance-based NEC model (PED-NEC), by a character error rate
(CER) reduction of about 7% relatively on AISHELL-1 for named entities. More
notably, when tested on Homophone that contain named entities of high phonetic
confusion, DANCER offers a more pronounced CER reduction of 46% relatively over
PED-NEC for named entities.
|
[
-0.14842376112937927,
-0.6555992364883423,
-0.22693641483783722,
0.19907218217849731,
-0.13772641122341156,
0.24060826003551483,
-0.09162696450948715,
-0.7051223516464233,
0.794201135635376,
0.8260930180549622,
-0.10250627994537354,
-0.22361937165260315,
-0.6431424617767334,
0.1976596564054489,
-0.8259896636009216,
0.6847113370895386,
0.006455231923609972,
0.24658551812171936,
0.019046055153012276,
-0.0889512449502945,
-0.5541979670524597,
-0.38216543197631836,
-1.0342618227005005,
-0.2031152844429016,
0.325853168964386,
0.3637051582336426,
0.5113200545310974,
0.8451471328735352,
0.47024229168891907,
0.30838239192962646,
-0.18666677176952362,
0.052742186933755875,
-0.07646483927965164,
0.24537332355976105,
-0.07364735007286072,
-0.41230642795562744,
-1.0645710229873657,
-0.37773555517196655,
0.7708721160888672,
0.7646538615226746,
-0.2508658468723297,
0.3590528070926666,
-0.18540707230567932,
0.7044544816017151,
-0.7104084491729736,
0.006478623952716589,
-0.9043750166893005,
-0.027799079194664955,
-0.37202250957489014,
-0.1848468780517578,
-0.32773539423942566,
0.008269954472780228,
0.10040971636772156,
-0.671260416507721,
0.25461652874946594,
0.20439094305038452,
0.8908189535140991,
0.7893861532211304,
-0.4028826653957367,
-0.4102427363395691,
-1.2186405658721924,
0.3257799744606018,
-0.21493607759475708,
0.8627957105636597,
0.4237141013145447,
0.41265928745269775,
-0.11254037171602249,
-0.8196496963500977,
-0.6576844453811646,
-0.019289933145046234,
0.2480878233909607,
0.13252316415309906,
-0.15453240275382996,
0.19361215829849243,
0.3081710636615753,
0.23286886513233185,
-0.32506880164146423,
0.027881523594260216,
-0.47674858570098877,
-0.3174268305301666,
0.5500010251998901,
-0.03707606717944145,
0.47402364015579224,
0.029261333867907524,
-0.2921893894672394,
0.29181838035583496,
-0.6524682641029358,
0.13874000310897827,
0.46921178698539734,
0.22814251482486725,
0.05125952512025833,
0.8410387635231018,
0.07948978245258331,
0.6927793025970459,
0.4707017242908478,
-0.3200610280036926,
0.0421261340379715,
0.388090580701828,
-0.40892350673675537,
0.7358506917953491,
0.1715351641178131,
0.406179279088974,
0.1735772341489792,
-0.37478265166282654,
-0.4360406696796417,
0.22611474990844727,
0.16968418657779694,
-0.7839148044586182,
-0.6177006959915161,
0.07690251618623734,
-0.22598162293434143,
0.1887352615594864,
-0.17139993607997894,
-0.38097789883613586,
-0.4120604693889618,
-0.7450069189071655,
0.4039821922779083,
-0.13579849898815155,
-0.2525607645511627,
0.026004677638411522,
0.03756792098283768,
0.10480207204818726,
0.3204251229763031,
-0.5089643001556396,
0.6419452428817749,
0.49123433232307434,
0.4475995898246765,
-0.06433048099279404,
0.03348879516124725,
-0.8583526015281677,
0.4575299322605133,
-0.3936668038368225,
0.6467604637145996,
-0.6497296690940857,
-0.39948511123657227,
-0.5299090147018433,
0.04516333341598511,
-0.38742315769195557,
-0.8441183567047119,
0.48656392097473145,
-0.6051875352859497,
-0.14996501803398132,
0.008086051791906357,
-0.8508853912353516,
-0.23832720518112183,
-0.1039254292845726,
-0.8781285285949707,
0.9222466349601746,
-0.23186755180358887,
-0.6215977668762207,
0.4842345118522644,
-0.48774003982543945,
-0.38358449935913086,
0.1857120543718338,
0.0017544275615364313,
-0.5049616694450378,
-0.17892073094844818,
0.19518907368183136,
0.24271048605442047,
-0.24554383754730225,
0.052229829132556915,
0.2269868701696396,
-0.47501063346862793,
0.2814010977745056,
-0.02962181158363819,
0.4835783839225769,
0.09251266717910767,
-0.4164370894432068,
0.14262767136096954,
-1.2412813901901245,
-0.09616716206073761,
-0.17802035808563232,
-0.32653093338012695,
-0.4124721586704254,
-0.058468908071517944,
0.1197521984577179,
0.09281014651060104,
-0.035155560821294785,
-0.40469375252723694,
-0.13165563344955444,
-0.47299647331237793,
-0.02752041257917881,
0.35879021883010864,
-0.07879167795181274,
0.6090546250343323,
-0.14844805002212524,
0.6539549231529236,
-0.014955362305045128,
-0.1821868121623993,
0.15685459971427917,
-0.5544000864028931,
-1.1815869808197021,
-0.40065962076187134,
0.7240501642227173,
0.947704017162323,
-1.0170435905456543,
0.2995185852050781,
-0.2737799882888794,
-0.40511107444763184,
-0.9550489783287048,
-0.10375087708234787,
0.7080329656600952,
0.690909206867218,
0.6578041315078735,
-0.27974075078964233,
-0.9979762434959412,
-0.6926330327987671,
-0.48760131001472473,
-0.23266266286373138,
-0.0028423569165170193,
0.2652806043624878,
0.2578602135181427,
-0.4063027501106262,
0.7490429282188416,
0.09111212939023972,
-0.393803209066391,
-0.09331440925598145,
-0.2823777496814728,
-0.07454447448253632,
0.5584892630577087,
0.1894616335630417,
-0.8004500865936279,
-0.4930758476257324,
-0.06541035324335098,
-0.1972440928220749,
-0.10768866539001465,
-0.2482185959815979,
0.022872600704431534,
0.1085151731967926,
0.20846113562583923,
-0.38262125849723816,
0.5181548595428467,
0.21470941603183746,
-0.2982799708843231,
0.5432319045066833,
-0.07900126278400421,
0.2598704397678375,
-1.0543092489242554,
-0.0977269783616066,
0.08168935030698776,
-0.33183276653289795,
-0.9252933263778687,
-0.10331734269857407,
0.09147811681032181,
0.028349801898002625,
-0.38659805059432983,
0.6549374461174011,
-0.7143542766571045,
-0.36751264333724976,
-0.3686272203922272,
0.25307607650756836,
-0.3121255040168762,
0.2283065766096115,
0.17143568396568298,
0.6249303817749023,
0.805679440498352,
-1.048749327659607,
0.5975685119628906,
0.3962940573692322,
0.2025306075811386,
0.836391031742096,
-0.6410988569259644,
0.41092443466186523,
-0.13811898231506348,
0.15529562532901764,
-0.42036640644073486,
-0.26076507568359375,
0.27702438831329346,
-0.716705858707428,
0.8025087714195251,
-0.6291511654853821,
-0.3354290723800659,
-0.4152701497077942,
0.33054351806640625,
0.3668726086616516,
0.24077026546001434,
-0.674680769443512,
0.8599534034729004,
0.6620199680328369,
0.037286728620529175,
-0.6977779865264893,
-0.5496401190757751,
0.5272784233093262,
-0.2716933488845825,
-0.6866027116775513,
0.5438308119773865,
0.01890694350004196,
-0.4375615417957306,
-0.2243405282497406,
-0.40011855959892273,
-0.28485992550849915,
0.07291081547737122,
0.3216820955276489,
0.3017541766166687,
-0.07947933673858643,
0.3613891005516052,
0.06621103733778,
-0.4039512276649475,
-0.10476220399141312,
-0.23280368745326996,
0.3303445279598236,
-0.014597386121749878,
-0.2261439859867096,
-0.5063572525978088,
-0.04029446095228195,
0.1569027453660965,
-0.3340379297733307,
0.6188434958457947,
0.6473300457000732,
-0.8767262697219849,
-0.03789091110229492,
-0.7140394449234009,
0.038091469556093216,
-0.36782002449035645,
0.3132471442222595,
-0.7018781900405884,
-0.5965931415557861,
0.7111544013023376,
0.08217614889144897,
-0.19452254474163055,
0.4138948917388916,
0.21882498264312744,
0.21627742052078247,
0.6977900266647339,
0.26252618432044983,
0.19669395685195923,
0.15957322716712952,
-0.24059627950191498,
0.17139844596385956,
-1.2699674367904663,
-0.4464271068572998,
-0.568225085735321,
-0.44274649024009705,
-0.4552488327026367,
-0.6930960416793823,
0.18331776559352875,
0.44216281175613403,
-0.10461151599884033,
0.6940542459487915,
-0.6658787131309509,
0.45833054184913635,
0.3009463846683502,
-0.056928783655166626,
0.27804815769195557,
-0.18814927339553833,
-0.1076955795288086,
-0.13000410795211792,
-0.2208293378353119,
-0.6666015386581421,
0.9468643069267273,
0.33989691734313965,
0.7318570017814636,
0.25506019592285156,
0.7045902013778687,
0.1619604080915451,
0.061993006616830826,
-0.7700878977775574,
0.591586709022522,
-0.22402501106262207,
-0.5402792096138,
-0.21843300759792328,
-0.21381539106369019,
-0.6519848108291626,
0.11359652131795883,
-0.1845778524875641,
-0.6472415328025818,
0.32600313425064087,
0.4826090931892395,
-0.19638484716415405,
0.5249472260475159,
-0.4155966639518738,
0.40994271636009216,
-0.08913660794496536,
-0.08638966828584671,
0.18963366746902466,
-0.6833451986312866,
0.1896374374628067,
-0.05397200211882591,
-0.022836990654468536,
-0.02273547649383545,
-0.2815563678741455,
0.7569583654403687,
-0.5113078951835632,
0.36291074752807617,
-0.3818971514701843,
0.05188697949051857,
0.31105199456214905,
0.22711974382400513,
0.8737249374389648,
-0.0579741969704628,
-0.15961883962154388,
-0.030670104548335075,
-0.3261163532733917,
-0.018161101266741753,
-0.49719101190567017,
0.6645587682723999,
-0.5360334515571594,
-0.2525377869606018,
0.10311012715101242,
-0.21043457090854645,
-0.08349042385816574,
-0.21497580409049988,
0.37696465849876404,
0.6903257966041565,
0.16375508904457092,
0.0463574193418026,
0.7955752611160278,
-0.08989474177360535,
0.17974616587162018,
0.6857082843780518,
-0.24638335406780243,
-0.5199146866798401,
0.9073145985603333,
0.1872057318687439,
0.0841921716928482,
0.4018097519874573,
-0.37761372327804565,
-0.3959888815879822,
-0.5515350699424744,
-0.8922968506813049,
0.09108783304691315,
-0.700627326965332,
-0.14117659628391266,
-1.1422004699707031,
-0.1465088278055191,
-0.36308541893959045,
-0.20301425457000732,
-0.597728967666626,
-0.955864429473877,
-0.5222583413124084,
-0.1368759572505951,
0.4619659185409546,
0.4624326229095459,
0.12317433208227158,
0.26334723830223083,
-0.5551157593727112,
0.5550227165222168,
0.21045401692390442,
0.35413309931755066,
-0.17524854838848114,
-0.8137733936309814,
-0.1881803572177887,
0.06901303678750992,
0.04278869926929474,
-1.0547332763671875,
0.501944363117218,
0.5533464550971985,
0.44780534505844116,
0.15162788331508636,
0.11162189394235611,
1.278314232826233,
-0.6105394959449768,
0.6328226327896118,
0.2614479959011078,
-1.120496392250061,
0.6545172333717346,
0.03451768308877945,
-0.3395620286464691,
0.07578828185796738,
0.01693260855972767,
-0.7001475691795349,
-0.445108562707901,
-0.4760962128639221,
-0.9905085563659668,
0.5185056924819946,
0.520264208316803,
-0.15297792851924896,
-0.18306522071361542,
0.6716049909591675,
-0.11120620369911194,
0.1299286186695099,
-0.5818635821342468,
-0.8253419399261475,
-0.14062125980854034,
0.013707082718610764,
0.21578608453273773,
-0.1674400418996811,
0.2993406653404236,
-0.29586079716682434,
1.2777457237243652,
0.048307742923498154,
0.360017329454422,
0.2866494059562683,
-0.6628151535987854,
-0.4583023488521576,
0.44785723090171814,
0.44413119554519653,
0.23580443859100342,
0.07573586702346802,
-0.0036031415220350027,
0.6096214056015015,
-0.6487336158752441,
0.1632750928401947,
0.4003138840198517,
-0.11573891341686249,
0.26599642634391785,
0.07740294188261032,
1.037757158279419,
0.26536786556243896,
-0.3575705289840698,
0.16280514001846313,
0.05225878208875656,
0.21934017539024353,
-0.7632770538330078,
0.10225764662027359,
0.12939150631427765,
0.22167786955833435,
0.2876504361629486,
0.3001675605773926,
0.6009407639503479,
-0.2552960216999054,
0.2837508022785187,
0.0883428230881691,
-0.7175167202949524,
-0.3193095922470093,
1.252647876739502,
0.22673338651657104,
-0.7644789218902588,
0.4567710757255554,
-0.3048745095729828,
-0.5292463302612305,
0.8478518724441528,
0.5694931149482727,
1.0697755813598633,
-0.8127478361129761,
-0.18635259568691254,
0.406098872423172,
0.21172063052654266,
-0.09162895381450653,
0.2638251781463623,
0.07312355190515518,
-0.564221203327179,
-0.3913029134273529,
-0.7369723916053772,
-0.2527836263179779,
-0.33068209886550903,
-0.8210102319717407,
0.6355294585227966,
-0.22873736917972565,
-0.272260457277298,
0.13879241049289703,
-0.20886601507663727,
-0.6424968242645264,
0.442846417427063,
0.2428189218044281,
0.5695076584815979,
-0.35348212718963623,
0.8520087599754333,
0.9754279851913452,
-0.21805216372013092,
-1.1832412481307983,
-0.23708279430866241,
0.1749824434518814,
-0.38312745094299316,
0.8557048439979553,
0.1973784863948822,
-0.27743473649024963,
0.24595065414905548,
0.07696717977523804,
-0.8797851204872131,
1.1836917400360107,
0.2208731472492218,
-1.003771185874939,
-0.15490758419036865,
0.10539162158966064,
0.64154452085495,
-0.5007498264312744,
0.3127327263355255,
0.5417520403862,
0.3578657805919647,
0.4087241291999817,
-1.4458589553833008,
-0.2782161235809326,
-0.33717119693756104,
0.07224103063344955,
0.4801875650882721,
-0.20719769597053528,
0.7292199730873108,
-0.5275636315345764,
-0.2688770294189453,
0.212304025888443,
0.6859220266342163,
0.1769859492778778,
0.5873244404792786,
0.5891079902648926,
0.5687271952629089,
0.8962710499763489,
-0.13518351316452026,
0.8168188333511353,
-0.4268975555896759,
0.18045306205749512,
1.5286977291107178,
-0.4393548369407654,
0.7497913837432861,
0.11363023519515991,
-0.10206516832113266,
0.38944604992866516,
0.437582403421402,
0.17605838179588318,
-0.0307441595941782,
0.4717770218849182,
-0.3111906349658966,
-0.25484025478363037,
0.025442901998758316,
-0.27175408601760864,
0.5670344233512878,
0.42092791199684143,
-0.3540610373020172,
0.3676619231700897,
0.3297187387943268,
-0.06763862818479538,
0.08373105525970459,
-0.7092174887657166,
0.8976531624794006,
0.002787339501082897,
-0.14412319660186768,
0.44625264406204224,
0.06639707833528519,
0.5157484412193298,
0.025029221549630165,
-0.17376330494880676,
0.17128270864486694,
0.20757490396499634,
-0.38438859581947327,
-0.24385541677474976,
0.42059770226478577,
0.271138072013855,
-0.2531564235687256,
0.060655057430267334,
0.9627071619033813,
-0.7676717638969421,
-0.48899930715560913,
0.3452295660972595,
0.17644277215003967,
0.43325790762901306,
-0.13231191039085388,
-0.7051048874855042,
-0.21110504865646362,
-0.14838427305221558,
0.1845427006483078,
-0.245821014046669,
0.21282440423965454,
-0.0853060930967331,
0.9355276823043823,
0.4000122845172882,
0.2561657726764679,
0.4819789528846741,
0.2769017517566681,
0.5590813755989075,
-0.6016926765441895,
-0.6397636532783508,
-0.36656901240348816,
0.7713291645050049,
0.08616262674331665,
0.15979956090450287,
0.6759776473045349,
0.9067893624305725,
0.6921845078468323,
-0.05227624997496605,
0.2758289873600006,
0.09634245187044144,
1.0306974649429321,
-0.6310739517211914,
0.6907983422279358,
-0.43744957447052,
0.8303526043891907,
-0.4500966966152191,
-1.1151059865951538,
-0.29915615916252136,
0.4990963041782379,
0.0920361801981926,
0.1263347864151001,
0.41015344858169556,
0.7996949553489685,
0.09415563941001892,
-0.1205921471118927,
0.4844452738761902,
0.20353861153125763,
0.2078477293252945,
0.08246579766273499,
0.6564481258392334,
-0.897620677947998,
0.4917988181114197,
-0.3549642264842987,
0.22601038217544556,
-0.19013623893260956,
-0.3764444589614868,
-0.8046284317970276,
-0.6937260627746582,
-0.9167094826698303,
-0.5350805521011353,
0.28019484877586365,
1.370845913887024,
0.5522646307945251,
-0.8591055274009705,
0.0024544137995690107,
0.2968089282512665,
-0.014300732873380184,
-0.1350516825914383,
-0.2431531548500061,
0.41365036368370056,
0.0668778344988823,
-0.9435363411903381,
0.43571412563323975,
0.3125501275062561,
0.2507818937301636,
0.1792227178812027,
-0.39506590366363525,
0.08895588666200638,
0.16622692346572876,
0.4368281662464142,
0.0915498360991478,
-1.0251506567001343,
-0.21489208936691284,
0.04796963185071945,
0.15629656612873077,
-0.10078506171703339,
0.7009691596031189,
-0.6861463189125061,
0.802001953125,
-0.13976500928401947,
0.43628376722335815,
0.27155569195747375,
-0.0960419550538063,
0.265774667263031,
-0.7968774437904358,
-0.051735613495111465,
0.37818074226379395,
0.5544106960296631,
0.514533519744873,
-0.6111530661582947,
0.5928702354431152,
0.2800450921058655,
-0.5110263824462891,
-0.7389037609100342,
0.07174883782863617,
-1.126198410987854,
0.40534067153930664,
1.2292965650558472,
-0.036448802798986435,
0.042367469519376755,
-0.4736022353172302,
-0.258029967546463,
0.6755046248435974,
-0.4151563346385956,
0.5643003582954407,
0.2314162403345108,
0.02751814015209675,
-0.2781484127044678,
-0.46872198581695557,
0.5142990350723267,
0.037995848804712296,
-0.7148362994194031,
-0.20664580166339874,
0.6790318489074707,
0.4048303961753845,
0.042949263006448746,
0.4598154127597809,
-0.007996896281838417,
0.5113859176635742,
-0.05876590311527252,
0.5565774440765381,
-0.2081862837076187,
-0.5793009400367737,
-0.28930413722991943,
-0.33965036273002625,
0.0035643591545522213,
-0.22781048715114594
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17640v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17640v1
|
REFeREE: A REference-FREE Model-Based Metric for Text Simplification
| 2024-03-26T12:21:51 | 2024-03-26T12:21:51 |
Yichen Huang, Ekaterina Kochmar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Text simplification lacks a universal standard of quality, and annotated
reference simplifications are scarce and costly. We propose to alleviate such
limitations by introducing REFeREE, a reference-free model-based metric with a
3-stage curriculum. REFeREE leverages an arbitrarily scalable pretraining stage
and can be applied to any quality standard as long as a small number of human
annotations are available. Our experiments show that our metric outperforms
existing reference-based metrics in predicting overall ratings and reaches
competitive and consistent performance in predicting specific ratings while
requiring no reference simplifications at inference time.
|
[
-0.3191421329975128,
0.06198243051767349,
0.5621044039726257,
0.5726954340934753,
-0.5871618986129761,
-0.4187358021736145,
0.18196548521518707,
-0.6107850670814514,
0.04192623123526573,
0.31614136695861816,
-0.5816841721534729,
-0.232572540640831,
-0.42405661940574646,
0.32135364413261414,
-0.4807682931423187,
1.4953725337982178,
-0.24182765185832977,
0.3741336762905121,
-0.5499928593635559,
-0.1492241621017456,
-0.3295958638191223,
-0.3792470395565033,
-0.4169955253601074,
-0.8150277733802795,
0.6796103715896606,
0.6011805534362793,
0.7886309027671814,
0.7446209788322449,
0.844355583190918,
0.20394977927207947,
-0.2846851944923401,
0.13204076886177063,
-0.24586400389671326,
-0.009544621221721172,
-0.3861517310142517,
-0.5099884271621704,
-0.8092231750488281,
0.7530531883239746,
0.6899144649505615,
0.8996163010597229,
-0.006692884489893913,
0.4083271026611328,
0.0823604092001915,
0.7796298265457153,
-1.0071098804473877,
0.2721483111381531,
-0.23992565274238586,
0.018684497103095055,
-0.1120237410068512,
-0.243898406624794,
-0.3373975157737732,
-0.6872081160545349,
-0.04147942364215851,
-1.0898454189300537,
0.5975045561790466,
-0.019473208114504814,
1.0290051698684692,
0.49385154247283936,
-0.44694507122039795,
-0.12216152250766754,
-0.7510529160499573,
0.7858594655990601,
-0.3432371914386749,
0.17783738672733307,
0.4410558342933655,
0.4952044188976288,
0.1819913387298584,
-0.8690268993377686,
-0.3783761262893677,
-0.053580209612846375,
-0.20757026970386505,
0.3477366268634796,
0.1479736864566803,
0.2723473906517029,
0.2400694191455841,
0.3825812041759491,
0.06593839824199677,
-0.2853604555130005,
-0.5627402067184448,
-0.18438872694969177,
0.6822096705436707,
0.13113252818584442,
-0.12651318311691284,
-0.14819245040416718,
-0.3905387222766876,
0.1447909027338028,
-0.690317690372467,
-0.07461577653884888,
0.4137522876262665,
0.23065350949764252,
0.21968677639961243,
0.005393021274358034,
-0.5716370940208435,
0.3482656180858612,
-0.003338528797030449,
-0.22758804261684418,
0.04840771481394768,
-0.4888318181037903,
-0.09655730426311493,
-0.1324998289346695,
0.8001968264579773,
0.6202232837677002,
0.25213998556137085,
-0.18089042603969574,
-0.3236956000328064,
0.0138918561860919,
0.2513032853603363,
-1.0170629024505615,
-0.19971036911010742,
-0.19282066822052002,
-0.45938968658447266,
-0.39640167355537415,
0.37376832962036133,
-0.618907630443573,
-0.1530071198940277,
-0.3281385004520416,
0.5720953345298767,
-0.04569543898105621,
0.08099441230297089,
0.08496551215648651,
-0.2302386313676834,
-0.09033800661563873,
1.0168659687042236,
-0.5383107662200928,
0.27670949697494507,
0.4004879295825958,
0.7906118035316467,
-0.1241554543375969,
-0.11963945627212524,
-0.36531081795692444,
0.13986696302890778,
-0.6533504128456116,
0.8260514140129089,
-0.46981579065322876,
-0.5471938252449036,
-0.06922506541013718,
-0.19621996581554413,
0.5497732758522034,
-0.6398169994354248,
1.2396843433380127,
-0.27145835757255554,
0.24596378207206726,
-0.14979656040668488,
-0.501004695892334,
-0.26346638798713684,
-0.15451554954051971,
-0.9788676500320435,
1.278967022895813,
-0.024547116830945015,
-0.701732337474823,
0.666313886642456,
-0.4646126627922058,
-0.010985988192260265,
0.20718872547149658,
0.23690198361873627,
-0.42496201395988464,
0.13633334636688232,
0.0021166661754250526,
0.256479948759079,
-0.6816757917404175,
0.5162608027458191,
-0.41575178503990173,
-0.8046160936355591,
-0.22425463795661926,
-0.4053729474544525,
0.41987377405166626,
0.38977891206741333,
0.029582127928733826,
0.11424227803945541,
-1.083666205406189,
0.1923636943101883,
-0.5697036981582642,
-0.33092281222343445,
-0.2752372920513153,
0.08181796967983246,
-0.000027513606255524792,
0.2890794575214386,
0.2997783422470093,
-0.5122302770614624,
0.03612806275486946,
0.19832216203212738,
0.07728705555200577,
0.32448941469192505,
-0.134272500872612,
0.4222441017627716,
-0.5551269054412842,
0.5583786964416504,
0.15685832500457764,
0.2156093865633011,
-0.3166522979736328,
-0.32711541652679443,
-1.2426669597625732,
-0.34473156929016113,
0.6794946193695068,
0.22068940103054047,
-0.5729727745056152,
0.14563657343387604,
-0.3253817558288574,
-0.8188891410827637,
-0.8260754346847534,
0.1880672127008438,
0.5691008567810059,
0.33915314078330994,
0.779000461101532,
-0.30308112502098083,
-0.48920220136642456,
-1.0219831466674805,
-0.6603253483772278,
-0.3400269150733948,
-0.2745261788368225,
-0.07770481705665588,
0.4567234516143799,
0.16350418329238892,
0.988411009311676,
-0.24142321944236755,
-0.7917523384094238,
-0.12465760111808777,
0.4041747748851776,
0.26160508394241333,
0.6350864768028259,
0.3094719648361206,
-0.602546215057373,
-0.3346533477306366,
-0.38577356934547424,
-0.7961353063583374,
-0.7664839029312134,
0.05716535076498985,
0.07899948209524155,
-0.3450728952884674,
0.9064118266105652,
-0.08916740864515305,
0.6144776344299316,
0.4557574987411499,
-0.24939769506454468,
0.6576796770095825,
-0.23683393001556396,
0.10338006168603897,
-0.5681623220443726,
0.43576711416244507,
0.04583054035902023,
-0.43673259019851685,
-0.5511327385902405,
0.12822353839874268,
0.4798007309436798,
0.0008059913525357842,
-0.3321487605571747,
0.9450072050094604,
-0.3353743851184845,
0.22813959419727325,
-0.33744221925735474,
0.3681212365627289,
0.43722087144851685,
0.19024473428726196,
-0.010932035744190216,
0.7977940440177917,
-0.2505796551704407,
-0.6818477511405945,
0.005306687206029892,
0.09092877805233002,
-0.47370946407318115,
0.9981259107589722,
-0.7709584832191467,
-0.17392343282699585,
-0.19671136140823364,
0.631692111492157,
-0.7162662744522095,
-0.04900161921977997,
0.06081303581595421,
-0.2782025635242462,
-0.059070441871881485,
-0.050743021070957184,
-0.47053080797195435,
-0.3535782992839813,
-0.31831949949264526,
0.6576324701309204,
0.09165531396865845,
-0.4711024761199951,
0.4387896955013275,
-0.23402807116508484,
-0.16484187543392181,
-0.6119742393493652,
-0.4924910068511963,
-0.37841057777404785,
0.23669470846652985,
-0.015438694506883621,
0.3136722147464752,
-0.4854964017868042,
0.006483353208750486,
-0.017822694033384323,
-0.4816008508205414,
-0.4673832952976227,
0.15974119305610657,
0.46494215726852417,
0.2812277376651764,
-0.14137710630893707,
-0.03535205125808716,
0.10226581245660782,
-0.3748849034309387,
0.015990691259503365,
-0.01913006789982319,
-0.3528590202331543,
0.04202016070485115,
-0.29426488280296326,
-0.8566509485244751,
0.25868284702301025,
0.44835972785949707,
0.10829125344753265,
0.22264309227466583,
0.1081290915608406,
-0.21325349807739258,
-0.02345762960612774,
-0.7690984010696411,
0.2282797396183014,
-0.4511573016643524,
0.14787665009498596,
-0.35683196783065796,
-0.6623693108558655,
0.3135303258895874,
-0.08670645207166672,
-0.027916323393583298,
0.7493276000022888,
0.008935172110795975,
0.06827694177627563,
0.9885694980621338,
0.7215980291366577,
0.33551812171936035,
0.5007954835891724,
0.22713375091552734,
-0.13537943363189697,
-0.8716587424278259,
-0.5219302177429199,
-1.0345025062561035,
-0.224985271692276,
-0.35659441351890564,
-0.43805137276649475,
0.13951805233955383,
0.913665235042572,
-0.5285590887069702,
0.12430208176374435,
-0.33075442910194397,
0.9486697316169739,
0.6782479882240295,
-0.0070634144358336926,
0.8701121807098389,
-0.5129972696304321,
-0.30710768699645996,
-0.2510751187801361,
-0.351114958524704,
-0.8119801878929138,
1.0688658952713013,
0.3086051940917969,
0.7359715700149536,
0.08307206630706787,
0.6997196674346924,
0.13814640045166016,
1.1390851736068726,
-0.6592019200325012,
0.5642629861831665,
-0.15728211402893066,
-0.969406008720398,
-0.002187477657571435,
-0.45281341671943665,
-0.2906293570995331,
0.5032777190208435,
-0.3536141514778137,
-0.4531823396682739,
0.19865792989730835,
0.20711643993854523,
-0.2071201652288437,
0.2586927115917206,
-0.422110378742218,
0.5356940031051636,
0.3544732332229614,
-0.4334212839603424,
0.04793357476592064,
-0.2804276645183563,
0.3440285325050354,
-0.5784234404563904,
0.4291762113571167,
-0.4636911451816559,
-0.38539743423461914,
0.8870292901992798,
-0.7842062711715698,
0.6586127281188965,
-0.13957048952579498,
0.06496413797140121,
0.2301231175661087,
0.2974868416786194,
0.14811626076698303,
0.18376775085926056,
-0.45192959904670715,
0.08145381510257721,
0.2591349184513092,
-0.42664283514022827,
-0.6157317757606506,
0.4205036461353302,
-0.872861921787262,
-0.6110377907752991,
-0.5175087451934814,
-0.3318721652030945,
-0.24178263545036316,
0.4958597719669342,
0.19832904636859894,
-0.009966029785573483,
-0.2779243290424347,
0.31955304741859436,
0.21472202241420746,
0.21685825288295746,
0.40818536281585693,
0.8409824967384338,
-0.1969798356294632,
-0.7430877685546875,
0.8010572195053101,
-0.03262367844581604,
0.17488457262516022,
0.24567802250385284,
0.25079038739204407,
-0.13105730712413788,
-0.2467760294675827,
-0.17070408165454865,
0.18849977850914001,
-0.8087120056152344,
-0.6283965706825256,
-0.4316379427909851,
-0.2528643310070038,
0.1591624617576599,
-0.07128816097974777,
-0.32640838623046875,
-0.6071884632110596,
-0.5225387811660767,
0.08102195709943771,
-0.25337108969688416,
1.0879919528961182,
-0.2175954431295395,
0.7394759058952332,
-0.6659988760948181,
0.12817400693893433,
0.3255385160446167,
0.9156235456466675,
-0.10497678071260452,
-0.7694922089576721,
-0.3574273884296417,
-0.24355481564998627,
-0.6613429188728333,
-0.5974212884902954,
0.0949086919426918,
0.4525177478790283,
0.4468066990375519,
0.7044424414634705,
0.10370726883411407,
0.7073478102684021,
-0.6810479760169983,
0.9677338600158691,
0.5127680897712708,
-1.3532030582427979,
0.4291994273662567,
-0.23685087263584137,
0.3498002290725708,
0.8709117770195007,
0.5831899046897888,
-0.525503933429718,
-0.5531932711601257,
-0.8327183127403259,
-0.6346274018287659,
0.9343788027763367,
-0.03387538343667984,
0.027526821941137314,
0.03456100821495056,
0.6566154360771179,
0.1676861196756363,
0.48745447397232056,
-0.8395509123802185,
-0.343966543674469,
-0.3728891611099243,
-0.017743777483701706,
-0.1764051765203476,
-0.5560107231140137,
-0.1086178570985794,
-0.3235231339931488,
0.8111531138420105,
-0.14330275356769562,
-0.12832139432430267,
0.3236957788467407,
0.09821167588233948,
-0.20136882364749908,
0.2621712386608124,
0.6355732083320618,
0.5317384004592896,
-0.26562952995300293,
-0.10929965227842331,
0.06528207659721375,
-0.44982537627220154,
0.42037078738212585,
0.05897499620914459,
-0.45566827058792114,
0.5810136795043945,
0.502572238445282,
0.5403290390968323,
0.5866053104400635,
-0.07605968415737152,
0.8184072971343994,
0.0018925750628113747,
-0.7193878293037415,
0.04529290646314621,
-0.01776951178908348,
-0.31308263540267944,
-0.13989846408367157,
0.40380293130874634,
0.1800931692123413,
0.24469426274299622,
-0.09313221275806427,
0.2436031699180603,
-0.048580609261989594,
-1.0041251182556152,
-0.31035399436950684,
1.218299388885498,
0.6817378401756287,
-0.15987063944339752,
0.18936219811439514,
0.05372541770339012,
-0.18946175277233124,
0.3680862486362457,
0.3914027214050293,
0.8942430019378662,
-0.2538984715938568,
0.26541680097579956,
0.5731145143508911,
0.12842963635921478,
-0.6899285912513733,
0.12567028403282166,
0.04044735059142113,
-0.33233842253685,
-0.3104124069213867,
-0.8552361130714417,
-0.7977679967880249,
0.07243464142084122,
-0.925904393196106,
0.5004910826683044,
-0.8419268727302551,
-0.1821673959493637,
0.23262794315814972,
0.14825253188610077,
-0.8043538928031921,
0.569524884223938,
-0.06446091830730438,
1.5377839803695679,
-0.8275794982910156,
0.6836848258972168,
0.5369287133216858,
-0.7876792550086975,
-0.9182964563369751,
-0.14104819297790527,
0.21068118512630463,
-0.10822388529777527,
1.1004128456115723,
0.3453657925128937,
-0.2968820631504059,
-0.12416663020849228,
-0.5243129134178162,
-0.7003564238548279,
0.9512093663215637,
0.2741852104663849,
-0.33112648129463196,
-0.30635419487953186,
-0.21494799852371216,
0.689859926700592,
-0.35438841581344604,
0.9434579014778137,
0.22386197745800018,
0.48206576704978943,
0.044314540922641754,
-1.1843849420547485,
-0.08872784674167633,
-0.367659330368042,
0.15732833743095398,
0.20993003249168396,
-0.8772230744361877,
0.8462662696838379,
-0.10004127025604248,
-0.22694694995880127,
0.6387478113174438,
0.8844476342201233,
-0.26447948813438416,
0.24053868651390076,
0.30242791771888733,
0.3846595883369446,
0.7277199625968933,
-0.4839972257614136,
0.797156810760498,
-0.40253812074661255,
0.5265851020812988,
1.3216439485549927,
-0.10471930354833603,
0.9212999939918518,
0.37018781900405884,
-0.12452626973390579,
0.8206115961074829,
0.3863682150840759,
0.05838886648416519,
0.3033978044986725,
0.31055596470832825,
-0.3994772434234619,
-0.6272967457771301,
-0.3500420153141022,
-0.3341585397720337,
0.20954708755016327,
0.08684193342924118,
-0.2653049826622009,
-0.5530340671539307,
-0.5273931622505188,
-0.08674421161413193,
0.31965282559394836,
-0.4878111779689789,
0.7727639079093933,
0.09864739328622818,
-0.8942484855651855,
0.1932045817375183,
-0.0029013967141509056,
0.5712000131607056,
-0.7286460995674133,
-0.22879572212696075,
-0.5505250096321106,
0.3381962776184082,
-0.26238003373146057,
-0.47617340087890625,
-0.043021779507398605,
-0.17838209867477417,
-0.4509730935096741,
-0.35409897565841675,
0.10889729857444763,
-0.5125141143798828,
-0.3369498550891876,
0.19011570513248444,
0.49021223187446594,
0.20067957043647766,
0.08528362214565277,
-0.41946813464164734,
-0.21361994743347168,
-0.28180640935897827,
-0.13396309316158295,
0.11130894720554352,
0.8186862468719482,
-0.26661962270736694,
0.9447858333587646,
0.5197296142578125,
0.22897180914878845,
-0.4309399724006653,
0.14555791020393372,
0.7349884510040283,
-0.7826862931251526,
-0.547119677066803,
-0.39714816212654114,
0.26867687702178955,
-0.06677684932947159,
-0.5499219298362732,
0.4123155176639557,
0.5783883929252625,
0.9903967380523682,
0.16415220499038696,
0.6710600852966309,
0.48444581031799316,
0.7836624383926392,
-0.18020567297935486,
0.6562937498092651,
-0.8969494104385376,
0.16674959659576416,
-0.5132533311843872,
-1.0310511589050293,
-0.5678206086158752,
0.5687760710716248,
-0.03469080105423927,
0.3154262900352478,
0.8899292945861816,
0.34570080041885376,
0.0069906702265143394,
0.18598340451717377,
0.3613937199115753,
-0.3136575222015381,
0.2908037006855011,
0.2422371208667755,
0.5717059969902039,
-0.6379704475402832,
0.92717045545578,
-0.0769013985991478,
-0.2770753502845764,
-0.5596324801445007,
-1.3485373258590698,
-0.916358470916748,
-0.3117571473121643,
-0.262370228767395,
-0.4096032977104187,
0.09315865486860275,
0.7083860039710999,
0.695830225944519,
-0.7776067852973938,
-0.08131159096956253,
0.20454537868499756,
-0.08056121319532394,
-0.184057354927063,
-0.19406886398792267,
-0.026522250846028328,
-0.5496689677238464,
-0.9515842795372009,
0.028972458094358444,
-0.006735654082149267,
0.09324204176664352,
-0.21657869219779968,
0.08801396936178207,
0.034262776374816895,
0.29709935188293457,
0.3459860682487488,
0.28452372550964355,
-0.817809522151947,
-0.4331285357475281,
-0.5431498289108276,
-0.5221045017242432,
-0.12265365570783615,
0.9987014532089233,
-0.8058952689170837,
0.6539736390113831,
0.2695601284503937,
0.32023200392723083,
0.2450290322303772,
0.20900283753871918,
0.7169928550720215,
-0.8968159556388855,
0.3015036880970001,
0.10420569777488708,
0.15670128166675568,
0.2765493094921112,
0.099232979118824,
0.794705331325531,
0.5229198336601257,
-0.570351243019104,
-0.675026535987854,
0.15886756777763367,
-0.6304786801338196,
-0.05259796604514122,
0.8740182518959045,
-0.34351325035095215,
0.059915415942668915,
0.0015758828958496451,
-0.09331423789262772,
0.13939368724822998,
-0.3318246603012085,
0.48702460527420044,
1.0268299579620361,
0.21770799160003662,
0.15292009711265564,
-0.6438472867012024,
1.069994330406189,
0.5850675106048584,
-0.6476569771766663,
0.1607183814048767,
0.48043292760849,
0.3887995779514313,
0.3933301866054535,
0.8353946208953857,
-0.22177454829216003,
0.606605052947998,
0.10170625150203705,
0.28253859281539917,
-0.13700011372566223,
-0.5813156366348267,
-0.21881195902824402,
0.08323404937982559,
0.17358969151973724,
0.324209064245224
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17636v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17636v2
|
Mix-Initiative Response Generation with Dynamic Prefix Tuning
| 2024-03-26T12:11:29 | 2024-03-27T05:55:35 |
Yuxiang Nie, Heyan Huang, Xian-Ling Mao, Lizi Liao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Mixed initiative serves as one of the key factors in controlling conversation
directions. For a speaker, responding passively or leading proactively would
result in rather different responses. However, most dialogue systems focus on
training a holistic response generation model without any distinction among
different initiatives. It leads to the cross-contamination problem, where the
model confuses different initiatives and generates inappropriate responses.
Moreover, obtaining plenty of human annotations for initiative labels can be
expensive. To address this issue, we propose a general mix-Initiative Dynamic
Prefix Tuning framework (IDPT) to decouple different initiatives from the
generation model, which learns initiative-aware prefixes in both supervised and
unsupervised settings. Specifically, IDPT decouples initiative factors into
different prefix parameters and uses the attention mechanism to adjust the
selection of initiatives in guiding generation dynamically. The prefix
parameters can be tuned towards accurate initiative prediction as well as
mix-initiative response generation. Extensive experiments on two public
dialogue datasets show that the proposed IDPT outperforms previous baselines on
both automatic metrics and human evaluations. It also manages to generate
appropriate responses with manipulated initiatives.
|
[
-0.8265810608863831,
-0.7166177034378052,
0.4217909872531891,
0.2595978379249573,
-0.43619102239608765,
0.646929919719696,
-0.1894373744726181,
-0.3685776889324188,
0.3790210783481598,
0.42545729875564575,
-0.9602077007293701,
-0.07079756259918213,
-0.38867655396461487,
-0.021227896213531494,
-0.12072440981864929,
1.012251377105713,
0.3229871094226837,
0.022635139524936676,
-0.12067814916372299,
-0.24192804098129272,
-0.6629371047019958,
0.01984691619873047,
-0.9167991876602173,
-0.4766009747982025,
0.5421095490455627,
0.7850648760795593,
0.5791242122650146,
0.40099650621414185,
0.4719572961330414,
0.30791768431663513,
-0.15918707847595215,
0.5648661255836487,
-0.5227789878845215,
0.09347514063119888,
-0.44200384616851807,
0.013210092671215534,
-0.6912555694580078,
0.13476964831352234,
0.604452908039093,
0.4426797926425934,
-0.3109246790409088,
0.05002722144126892,
0.24287588894367218,
0.3411235213279724,
-0.6370141506195068,
0.033624593168497086,
-1.0255175828933716,
-0.1598885953426361,
0.13850024342536926,
-0.47638943791389465,
-0.069545678794384,
0.016760049387812614,
0.20228219032287598,
-0.4676692485809326,
0.13810035586357117,
-0.02075645886361599,
0.451188325881958,
0.3203308582305908,
-0.5046892166137695,
-0.1112075075507164,
-0.9648664593696594,
0.7149114012718201,
-0.7776679992675781,
-0.26610949635505676,
0.26806238293647766,
0.21720696985721588,
-0.5056675672531128,
-0.5020174980163574,
-0.6109550595283508,
0.2631103992462158,
0.10708725452423096,
0.3320995569229126,
0.1325889676809311,
0.24461296200752258,
-0.0301331989467144,
0.5561138987541199,
-0.10318921506404877,
0.12386662513017654,
0.02769569866359234,
-0.03122844360768795,
0.6842777132987976,
0.4244914948940277,
0.17443841695785522,
-0.013308713212609291,
-0.5568399429321289,
-0.2669697105884552,
-0.6195709109306335,
0.19780297577381134,
0.5984343886375427,
0.5073572993278503,
-0.16560572385787964,
0.29074615240097046,
-0.4952431619167328,
0.5461375117301941,
0.6612280011177063,
-0.1083059012889862,
0.004268929362297058,
-0.8429180979728699,
-0.0851849764585495,
0.3584780693054199,
0.6549832820892334,
0.39798423647880554,
0.0058842129074037075,
-0.0029835719615221024,
-0.22055459022521973,
-0.10858059674501419,
0.36710962653160095,
-0.9130834341049194,
-0.2938457727432251,
0.19189999997615814,
-0.05860000476241112,
-0.5286815762519836,
0.013820863328874111,
-0.8551270961761475,
-0.06868123263120651,
-0.5678372383117676,
0.09681390970945358,
-0.16664044559001923,
-0.5076929330825806,
-0.10034674406051636,
-0.000468940386781469,
0.3053014874458313,
0.3491518795490265,
-0.9901291728019714,
0.35643672943115234,
0.7398342490196228,
0.46143874526023865,
-0.4060835540294647,
0.07812226563692093,
-0.9538020491600037,
0.12444005161523819,
0.0020746421068906784,
0.6846895813941956,
-0.7015127539634705,
-0.6114500164985657,
-0.25258341431617737,
-0.27560439705848694,
-0.08383490145206451,
-0.632933497428894,
0.21020899713039398,
-0.1807755082845688,
0.2017098069190979,
0.05203907936811447,
-0.19510692358016968,
0.2279548943042755,
0.23428522050380707,
-0.41715824604034424,
0.9285112023353577,
0.11091398447751999,
-0.9164677262306213,
0.5096573829650879,
-0.7826808094978333,
-0.39635762572288513,
0.4199744462966919,
-0.32655853033065796,
-0.5351800322532654,
0.23598620295524597,
0.35341861844062805,
0.1015152558684349,
-0.3772701025009155,
0.7324764132499695,
-0.2624064087867737,
-0.3051549196243286,
0.3714034855365753,
-0.5284387469291687,
0.5422133803367615,
0.028881432488560677,
-0.4325456917285919,
0.4669703543186188,
-1.1122153997421265,
0.2742096185684204,
-0.13949525356292725,
-0.5838238596916199,
-0.2740115523338318,
0.16056521236896515,
-0.17589712142944336,
0.15655212104320526,
-0.20130766928195953,
-0.5986276268959045,
0.04126424342393875,
-0.30664774775505066,
0.317637175321579,
0.67923903465271,
0.42508503794670105,
0.38008955121040344,
-0.2437586486339569,
0.39085817337036133,
0.14585013687610626,
-0.07629771530628204,
-0.2801227867603302,
-0.6766608953475952,
-0.8436005711555481,
-0.4541822075843811,
0.2809574604034424,
0.5295184850692749,
-0.9323475956916809,
0.59296715259552,
-0.2475280910730362,
-0.20792672038078308,
-0.6279200315475464,
-0.10666921734809875,
0.5360363721847534,
0.49187707901000977,
0.3613065481185913,
-0.5211923718452454,
-0.20843523740768433,
-0.8601404428482056,
-0.46954458951950073,
-0.3672533333301544,
-0.0654815211892128,
0.5455685257911682,
0.2583215832710266,
0.11681606620550156,
1.1684423685073853,
-0.28325894474983215,
0.1454518735408783,
-0.296189546585083,
0.8354724645614624,
-0.07535272091627121,
0.560664713382721,
0.16212423145771027,
-1.0032936334609985,
-0.4146108031272888,
-0.22194644808769226,
0.13685745000839233,
-0.13177968561649323,
-0.1835615187883377,
-0.297134131193161,
-0.34741783142089844,
0.33828067779541016,
-0.48594892024993896,
0.5592978000640869,
0.30503493547439575,
-0.3125278949737549,
0.31515568494796753,
-0.02860373444855213,
0.15495404601097107,
-1.2933491468429565,
-0.16963297128677368,
-0.21565577387809753,
-0.14461980760097504,
-0.6502254605293274,
-0.24953262507915497,
-0.04761829227209091,
-0.052173297852277756,
-0.6123118996620178,
0.45897647738456726,
-0.3587091267108917,
0.12297323346138,
-0.23408520221710205,
-0.29456865787506104,
-0.0829939916729927,
0.6627286076545715,
0.014761523343622684,
0.7301657199859619,
0.16583600640296936,
-0.7168297171592712,
0.4208311140537262,
0.33615538477897644,
-0.42791715264320374,
0.7842185497283936,
-0.590507447719574,
0.35149240493774414,
-0.07236041873693466,
0.24844688177108765,
-1.1092778444290161,
-0.6171957850456238,
0.39785611629486084,
-0.23601670563220978,
0.5686384439468384,
-0.14235983788967133,
-0.2819986641407013,
-0.11275786906480789,
-0.11595454066991806,
0.5203866958618164,
0.25033921003341675,
-0.46780288219451904,
0.6801332831382751,
0.2835387885570526,
-0.33161473274230957,
-0.2554183900356293,
-0.4740523397922516,
0.1370192915201187,
-0.41982150077819824,
-0.39350563287734985,
0.5240055322647095,
-0.36806976795196533,
-0.2556982934474945,
-0.1342763900756836,
-0.13706326484680176,
-0.0027831601910293102,
0.17898738384246826,
0.23565733432769775,
-0.11138837784528732,
0.033628709614276886,
-0.1386294811964035,
0.25098717212677,
-0.08164557814598083,
-0.054259058088064194,
0.1560482531785965,
0.42179635167121887,
0.21401925384998322,
-0.5818784832954407,
-0.3412301242351532,
0.619886040687561,
0.8107530474662781,
-0.6278116703033447,
0.33691221475601196,
0.5750678777694702,
0.12424374371767044,
-0.17795677483081818,
-0.23093244433403015,
-0.44411927461624146,
-0.5205385684967041,
0.2717539370059967,
-0.36004719138145447,
-0.6821061372756958,
0.3114134967327118,
-0.44530126452445984,
0.24668098986148834,
-0.14248117804527283,
0.7461991906166077,
0.0683462992310524,
1.161548137664795,
0.5372574329376221,
0.12663568556308746,
0.631767749786377,
0.09776882827281952,
0.4715731143951416,
-0.9132014513015747,
-0.14983084797859192,
-0.32541775703430176,
-0.6158228516578674,
-0.5932829976081848,
-0.2853466272354126,
0.45398035645484924,
-0.22058309614658356,
-0.07076770812273026,
0.02296910062432289,
-0.40581998229026794,
0.3538961410522461,
0.6889156103134155,
-0.014638468623161316,
0.3215678036212921,
-0.011057903990149498,
-0.0370589978992939,
0.03312526270747185,
-0.7310959100723267,
0.01476086862385273,
0.6704970598220825,
0.14480715990066528,
0.7904496788978577,
-0.02602238953113556,
0.8577696084976196,
0.017297498881816864,
0.10607140511274338,
-0.7134596109390259,
0.7080817818641663,
0.29091042280197144,
-0.40478840470314026,
-0.30540716648101807,
-0.4686829447746277,
-0.8515912890434265,
0.3028777539730072,
-0.3341010510921478,
-0.640695333480835,
0.3456438481807709,
0.05314817279577255,
-0.5190420746803284,
0.1486111581325531,
-0.30510279536247253,
0.5395761728286743,
-0.2571706771850586,
-0.15283547341823578,
-0.3039943277835846,
-0.8577558994293213,
0.3661045432090759,
-0.050550248473882675,
-0.14359621703624725,
-0.574995219707489,
0.3134942352771759,
0.2334919571876526,
-0.24075104296207428,
0.8712206482887268,
0.030888451263308525,
-0.08496265113353729,
0.2775671184062958,
0.023340990766882896,
0.5398023724555969,
0.29734286665916443,
0.25066593289375305,
-0.29333943128585815,
-0.5715917944908142,
-0.21047057211399078,
-0.49871546030044556,
0.5968106985092163,
-0.57987380027771,
-0.6983856558799744,
0.025098398327827454,
-0.8463372588157654,
-0.43095967173576355,
0.056860845535993576,
0.45275771617889404,
0.5100077986717224,
-0.44933852553367615,
0.26263678073883057,
0.7902277708053589,
-0.056509241461753845,
0.5807656645774841,
0.6903836727142334,
0.341999888420105,
-0.5453542470932007,
0.7279486656188965,
-0.18792806565761566,
0.6647080779075623,
0.23669062554836273,
0.14906899631023407,
-0.05505761876702309,
-0.3775938153266907,
-0.43585580587387085,
-0.13809284567832947,
-0.2692319452762604,
-0.3137719929218292,
-0.4420612156391144,
-0.0401347391307354,
-0.28383275866508484,
0.20943249762058258,
-0.4801082909107208,
-0.3166995942592621,
-0.23647509515285492,
-0.04608668014407158,
0.3216486871242523,
0.31030577421188354,
0.016790056601166725,
0.30967795848846436,
-0.5411209464073181,
0.553615927696228,
0.6163546442985535,
0.31023696064949036,
-0.33923882246017456,
-0.29004526138305664,
-0.08161671459674835,
0.38142767548561096,
-0.35130441188812256,
-0.7856729030609131,
0.21831411123275757,
0.48584333062171936,
0.525173544883728,
0.4429342448711395,
0.4466226398944855,
0.7566389441490173,
-0.25049328804016113,
0.5640525221824646,
0.25790730118751526,
-0.664824903011322,
0.8399118185043335,
-0.4624420702457428,
0.7522720694541931,
0.7167899012565613,
-0.00799519568681717,
-0.25939875841140747,
-0.8070234656333923,
-0.7090646028518677,
-1.2013494968414307,
0.9551376104354858,
0.32147499918937683,
0.08613008260726929,
-0.07674146443605423,
0.0910710021853447,
0.01661396026611328,
0.3478116989135742,
-0.2404249906539917,
-0.02296837978065014,
0.010537570342421532,
-0.06079048663377762,
0.10778161138296127,
-0.20739510655403137,
-0.5828173756599426,
-0.17913013696670532,
0.6124060153961182,
-0.309878408908844,
0.06161115691065788,
-0.04523688554763794,
0.32705745100975037,
-0.3869880437850952,
0.48591750860214233,
0.33080485463142395,
0.5553032159805298,
-0.22089345753192902,
-0.062264688313007355,
-0.0932111144065857,
-0.3062146008014679,
0.21439982950687408,
-0.135558620095253,
-0.32705846428871155,
-0.09247161448001862,
-0.002318826736882329,
1.0349435806274414,
0.28707122802734375,
-0.5543355345726013,
0.3603280782699585,
-0.4543581008911133,
-0.14313870668411255,
-0.021338043734431267,
0.46638885140419006,
0.04455669969320297,
0.2529451251029968,
0.21478766202926636,
0.10396692901849747,
0.20545560121536255,
-0.6411222815513611,
0.18505673110485077,
0.48273995518684387,
-0.24634188413619995,
-0.16585616767406464,
0.46078193187713623,
0.7359794974327087,
-0.41541609168052673,
0.8003047108650208,
-0.2564004361629486,
-0.22110892832279205,
0.754396915435791,
0.478873610496521,
1.187684416770935,
-0.3599757254123688,
0.23203635215759277,
0.16834667325019836,
-0.0500367172062397,
0.29156556725502014,
0.2714414894580841,
-0.4701847732067108,
-0.736858606338501,
-0.4326242506504059,
-0.46604228019714355,
-0.5751360058784485,
0.5044218897819519,
-0.9986153244972229,
0.22836089134216309,
-0.38369831442832947,
-0.3447973132133484,
0.02698628045618534,
-0.08456762135028839,
-0.6174514889717102,
0.05274442583322525,
0.30068275332450867,
0.6396587491035461,
-0.9122188091278076,
0.756443202495575,
0.7687197923660278,
-0.023382101207971573,
-0.7737170457839966,
0.370307058095932,
-0.023838765919208527,
-0.44460147619247437,
0.4055306315422058,
0.11464519798755646,
-0.36407598853111267,
0.09827300906181335,
-0.3940185606479645,
-0.8480038046836853,
0.9317882657051086,
0.13603289425373077,
-0.47005710005760193,
0.0960000604391098,
0.2885814607143402,
0.28022170066833496,
-0.6011040210723877,
0.09565261006355286,
0.7722177505493164,
0.5088379383087158,
0.3290785253047943,
-0.978257417678833,
-0.06174249202013016,
-0.2876524031162262,
0.1594323366880417,
0.2833928167819977,
-0.7384577393531799,
0.7005484104156494,
0.020827215164899826,
-0.3279811143875122,
0.2665081024169922,
0.6130614876747131,
0.18734963238239288,
0.33016395568847656,
0.6618149280548096,
0.6843656897544861,
0.3314371705055237,
-0.32534125447273254,
0.6431731581687927,
-0.48717668652534485,
-0.08393451571464539,
1.3530690670013428,
-0.23601658642292023,
0.37801286578178406,
0.5966999530792236,
0.14956843852996826,
0.2933843731880188,
0.6140159964561462,
0.13392490148544312,
0.8801819086074829,
0.19484223425388336,
-0.5976983904838562,
-0.3775509297847748,
-0.28180497884750366,
-0.1148562952876091,
0.7213135957717896,
0.678687572479248,
0.030119679868221283,
-0.34188440442085266,
0.008343908935785294,
-0.11078564077615738,
-0.04648013785481453,
-0.2733921706676483,
1.1226210594177246,
-0.2523448169231415,
-1.3248538970947266,
0.4748381972312927,
-0.08679253607988358,
0.380255788564682,
-0.6017823219299316,
-0.3662315905094147,
-0.3377583622932434,
0.21797513961791992,
-0.05977689102292061,
-0.8132883310317993,
0.02571219578385353,
-0.27529558539390564,
-0.13617557287216187,
-0.32141607999801636,
0.6143293380737305,
-0.9368330836296082,
-0.1967756748199463,
0.19922985136508942,
0.3894696533679962,
-0.12460323423147202,
0.13109153509140015,
-0.7174486517906189,
0.0502389520406723,
0.0762733742594719,
-0.3465285003185272,
0.49139872193336487,
0.5727365016937256,
-0.08624386787414551,
0.414193332195282,
0.6041456460952759,
0.009863156825304031,
-0.07623996585607529,
0.033250592648983,
1.0090792179107666,
-0.28133511543273926,
-0.6653270721435547,
-0.5172790884971619,
0.7401397824287415,
-0.29012957215309143,
-0.49136221408843994,
0.42229971289634705,
0.23963193595409393,
0.6699925661087036,
0.21391355991363525,
0.6412798762321472,
0.0931769460439682,
0.5681235194206238,
-0.2926541268825531,
0.06716126948595047,
-0.37315982580184937,
0.1893346756696701,
-0.025069529190659523,
-1.030908465385437,
0.11209391057491302,
0.1858799308538437,
0.037781789898872375,
-0.12462863326072693,
0.16794654726982117,
0.8004322052001953,
-0.3151690661907196,
-0.08898217231035233,
0.055642351508140564,
-0.15074408054351807,
0.5435121655464172,
0.41414329409599304,
0.8986985683441162,
0.23715157806873322,
0.3547734022140503,
-0.06225667893886566,
-0.3038754165172577,
-0.5102736353874207,
-0.9851707816123962,
-0.8007029294967651,
-0.28128981590270996,
-0.5210447311401367,
-0.09346767514944077,
0.09928840398788452,
0.7242872714996338,
0.7633889317512512,
-0.6856052279472351,
0.013663275167346,
-0.34567561745643616,
-0.059229642152786255,
-0.18408720195293427,
-0.2630658447742462,
-0.12023546546697617,
-0.4361097514629364,
-0.9754136204719543,
0.7173601388931274,
0.6236974596977234,
0.12174975126981735,
-0.2634916305541992,
0.048914194107055664,
-0.17583194375038147,
0.43427228927612305,
0.2410161793231964,
0.4357827305793762,
-0.6079804301261902,
-0.23213441669940948,
-0.37281206250190735,
0.01625741645693779,
0.27727165818214417,
1.215012550354004,
-0.7685554027557373,
0.7152289748191833,
0.4714295566082001,
0.535871684551239,
0.5614761114120483,
0.3093896210193634,
0.7883203029632568,
-1.1821959018707275,
0.29193976521492004,
0.4740665853023529,
0.08604873716831207,
0.3873240649700165,
-0.4670026898384094,
0.3079696297645569,
0.08523759990930557,
-0.4156164824962616,
-0.7260555028915405,
0.6672894358634949,
-0.8346145749092102,
-0.24094873666763306,
1.0489709377288818,
-0.07228238135576248,
-0.008075254037976265,
-0.053731150925159454,
-0.2370508909225464,
0.32214099168777466,
-0.5577030777931213,
0.5807075500488281,
0.4758674204349518,
-0.3597007989883423,
-0.05138386785984039,
-0.24723291397094727,
0.5674189925193787,
0.6081244349479675,
-0.662434458732605,
0.02273942343890667,
0.4220191538333893,
0.005314260721206665,
0.14050471782684326,
0.6096051931381226,
0.0015113542322069407,
0.21658676862716675,
-0.07593684643507004,
-0.06902115792036057,
0.0917820930480957,
-0.6144872307777405,
-0.08076252043247223,
-0.20492762327194214,
-0.0857783630490303,
-0.3883640766143799
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17612v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17612v2
|
"You are an expert annotator": Automatic Best-Worst-Scaling Annotations for Emotion Intensity Modeling
| 2024-03-26T11:45:22 | 2024-04-22T12:12:15 |
Christopher Bagdon, Prathamesh Karmalker, Harsha Gurulingappa, Roman Klinger
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Labeling corpora constitutes a bottleneck to create models for new tasks or
domains. Large language models mitigate the issue with automatic corpus
labeling methods, particularly for categorical annotations. Some NLP tasks such
as emotion intensity prediction, however, require text regression, but there is
no work on automating annotations for continuous label assignments. Regression
is considered more challenging than classification: The fact that humans
perform worse when tasked to choose values from a rating scale lead to
comparative annotation methods, including best-worst scaling. This raises the
question if large language model-based annotation methods show similar
patterns, namely that they perform worse on rating scale annotation tasks than
on comparative annotation tasks. To study this, we automate emotion intensity
predictions and compare direct rating scale predictions, pairwise comparisons
and best-worst scaling. We find that the latter shows the highest reliability.
A transformer regressor fine-tuned on these data performs nearly on par with a
model trained on the original manual annotations.
|
[
-0.5565543174743652,
-0.5533367395401001,
0.19406914710998535,
0.3838578164577484,
-0.06197812035679817,
0.04653904214501381,
-0.3577011525630951,
-0.5487700700759888,
-0.016179297119379044,
0.29752251505851746,
-0.11969433724880219,
-0.3847479820251465,
-0.9627532958984375,
0.39383143186569214,
-0.35438528656959534,
1.001735806465149,
0.08259540796279907,
0.057163529098033905,
-0.18348734080791473,
-0.15834848582744598,
-0.41845935583114624,
-0.666984498500824,
-0.6537067294120789,
-0.5959506034851074,
0.5252895951271057,
0.060503583401441574,
0.9495654106140137,
0.4588114321231842,
0.9732635021209717,
0.3815254271030426,
-0.1776605099439621,
-0.13523168861865997,
-0.3460000455379486,
0.18624329566955566,
0.1423027217388153,
-0.365418404340744,
-0.40334492921829224,
-0.05556885153055191,
-0.06643672287464142,
0.6520108580589294,
0.029317455366253853,
0.47650688886642456,
-0.1289714127779007,
0.5305697917938232,
-0.6366602182388306,
0.2996365427970886,
-0.5566219091415405,
0.043753042817115784,
0.3381478190422058,
-0.1702631711959839,
-0.6896278262138367,
-0.3919451832771301,
0.13045690953731537,
-0.36957159638404846,
0.19916848838329315,
0.2305399626493454,
0.9464794397354126,
0.8877100348472595,
-0.36864879727363586,
-0.27281123399734497,
-1.0029526948928833,
0.4846409559249878,
-0.4279695451259613,
0.05721510574221611,
0.5212677121162415,
0.27933016419410706,
0.38684067130088806,
-0.44435566663742065,
-0.24400387704372406,
-0.2728595435619354,
-0.39749905467033386,
-0.08284568786621094,
-0.5093476176261902,
0.2709333598613739,
0.422071635723114,
0.22574293613433838,
-0.41673099994659424,
0.2570752501487732,
-0.27762749791145325,
-0.10655618458986282,
0.8488304615020752,
0.012239173986017704,
0.14823313057422638,
-0.2550552785396576,
-0.24981987476348877,
-0.12469947338104248,
-0.16092441976070404,
-0.062040604650974274,
0.16871647536754608,
0.14969652891159058,
0.2933712899684906,
0.521952748298645,
0.07847928255796432,
0.43932467699050903,
0.4080349802970886,
-0.01957598701119423,
0.46892625093460083,
0.5181578397750854,
-0.342088907957077,
0.08220265805721283,
0.8896059989929199,
0.8236461281776428,
0.5521253943443298,
-0.252712219953537,
-0.36993980407714844,
0.19082441926002502,
0.4601408839225769,
-0.5214702486991882,
-0.45358750224113464,
0.09087934345006943,
-0.34928229451179504,
-0.5661505460739136,
-0.24763666093349457,
-0.6365587115287781,
-0.5346792936325073,
-0.3049277663230896,
0.7555292844772339,
-0.28419676423072815,
-0.2787776291370392,
-0.2161618024110794,
0.05145883187651634,
-0.3029942810535431,
0.21595856547355652,
-0.9160301685333252,
0.20628787577152252,
0.4900036156177521,
0.8070717453956604,
-0.06848844140768051,
-0.04051339626312256,
-0.2380014806985855,
-0.4140888750553131,
-0.49492597579956055,
0.8270888924598694,
-0.5238160490989685,
-0.37059953808784485,
0.10936584323644638,
-0.03963644057512283,
-0.0892750695347786,
-0.6180318593978882,
0.732550323009491,
-0.3602297902107239,
-0.1737576127052307,
-0.13802729547023773,
-0.6172922849655151,
-0.23468588292598724,
0.05722319334745407,
-0.6840457320213318,
1.0762276649475098,
0.40397214889526367,
-0.7894724607467651,
0.5157046914100647,
-0.6079338788986206,
-0.2621123194694519,
0.1809721142053604,
0.3450663387775421,
-0.4870944917201996,
0.0780322328209877,
0.019772391766309738,
0.6386798024177551,
-0.09858375042676926,
0.5456405282020569,
-0.3820885121822357,
-0.2779051959514618,
0.29329386353492737,
-0.2155817300081253,
0.2344365268945694,
0.07885658740997314,
-0.6800399422645569,
0.17366540431976318,
-0.9910150170326233,
-0.24897827208042145,
-0.08312010765075684,
-0.05985778570175171,
-0.5019044280052185,
0.06646005064249039,
0.2509210705757141,
0.2957853674888611,
0.1461566984653473,
-0.5336543917655945,
0.15630686283111572,
-0.08044005185365677,
0.21355028450489044,
0.9284353852272034,
-0.09777572005987167,
0.4087277948856354,
-0.15758921205997467,
0.5488394498825073,
-0.22256645560264587,
0.07029084861278534,
0.04904359206557274,
-0.3821544349193573,
-0.765136182308197,
-0.18758563697338104,
0.11598319560289383,
0.5933824777603149,
-0.22314225137233734,
0.42057904601097107,
-0.04022756963968277,
-0.9410545825958252,
-0.6601814031600952,
0.018881119787693024,
0.5282241702079773,
0.8443421721458435,
0.6743431091308594,
-0.07573666423559189,
-0.45976266264915466,
-1.1086138486862183,
-0.3621675670146942,
-0.45438846945762634,
-0.14871132373809814,
0.15098750591278076,
0.42547205090522766,
-0.2454603910446167,
0.7336953282356262,
-0.5961851477622986,
-0.3815579116344452,
-0.17055973410606384,
0.8460263609886169,
-0.17900779843330383,
0.36146801710128784,
0.5248687267303467,
-0.827289342880249,
-0.5951315760612488,
-0.12452014535665512,
-0.6548314690589905,
-0.46645429730415344,
-0.18650543689727783,
0.08159364014863968,
0.5390490293502808,
0.35710427165031433,
-0.17230239510536194,
0.3154217302799225,
0.5665401816368103,
-0.37629929184913635,
0.3955959379673004,
-0.2920793890953064,
0.2176421582698822,
-0.5053797364234924,
0.15404638648033142,
0.5888481736183167,
0.10216154903173447,
-0.8077557682991028,
-0.3416743576526642,
0.16153451800346375,
0.22802096605300903,
0.035973306745290756,
0.2775711417198181,
-0.0023682108148932457,
0.18311531841754913,
-0.15292024612426758,
-0.28346624970436096,
-0.052286457270383835,
0.41700130701065063,
0.2971392571926117,
0.461616575717926,
0.33077970147132874,
-0.2287788689136505,
0.32498642802238464,
0.3032885789871216,
-0.1295381337404251,
0.47459128499031067,
-0.6922007203102112,
0.07649720460176468,
-0.23929618299007416,
-0.03047020360827446,
-1.0235580205917358,
-0.30824214220046997,
-0.3204699754714966,
-0.4771992862224579,
0.47186946868896484,
-0.006408361718058586,
-0.3802947402000427,
-0.608006477355957,
-0.02295462042093277,
-0.09557212889194489,
0.7040141820907593,
-0.4326646327972412,
0.5768356919288635,
0.2086310088634491,
-0.09927535802125931,
-0.6751109957695007,
-0.8662087917327881,
0.0046733976341784,
-0.42339637875556946,
-0.4372518062591553,
0.03862619027495384,
-0.15537506341934204,
-0.5036140084266663,
-0.25107595324516296,
-0.015903854742646217,
-0.16211779415607452,
0.2973497211933136,
0.7228023409843445,
0.24503302574157715,
-0.16348673403263092,
0.4283846914768219,
-0.13151466846466064,
-0.3207930326461792,
0.40185368061065674,
0.42090263962745667,
0.18473167717456818,
-0.28092458844184875,
0.08550116419792175,
-0.48635733127593994,
0.3247103989124298,
0.4827611744403839,
-0.1941264569759369,
0.6757358908653259,
0.7466644644737244,
-0.27995994687080383,
0.154401034116745,
-0.8181682229042053,
0.0006839488632977009,
-0.4252471327781677,
0.4459122121334076,
-0.40255919098854065,
-0.6508345603942871,
0.36846038699150085,
-0.09992575645446777,
0.10355895757675171,
0.8012957572937012,
0.4771716892719269,
-0.1908319890499115,
1.394067406654358,
0.8657273054122925,
-0.16357135772705078,
0.230403333902359,
-0.06620859354734421,
0.2082757204771042,
-0.6587372422218323,
-0.19260190427303314,
-0.6340051293373108,
-0.41843199729919434,
-0.6029422283172607,
-0.09595870971679688,
0.27999818325042725,
-0.01517332810908556,
-0.5510077476501465,
0.31870487332344055,
-0.9433388113975525,
0.1390051245689392,
0.4434657096862793,
-0.06498023867607117,
0.14251497387886047,
-0.14015816152095795,
0.5941575169563293,
-0.16028155386447906,
-0.31485816836357117,
-0.7972482442855835,
1.0404011011123657,
0.47053807973861694,
0.7251580953598022,
-0.3042686879634857,
0.5835903882980347,
0.28748494386672974,
0.9255654215812683,
-0.7218602895736694,
0.2300293892621994,
-0.21402649581432343,
-0.5726214051246643,
-0.3925640285015106,
-0.32420632243156433,
-0.5670767426490784,
0.07087843865156174,
-0.3551153242588043,
-0.7642589211463928,
0.23671627044677734,
0.4115307629108429,
-0.4204651117324829,
0.4267292022705078,
-0.8597736954689026,
0.931069552898407,
0.045224081724882126,
-0.03633805364370346,
0.2835319936275482,
-0.7382751107215881,
0.04346179962158203,
-0.2617846727371216,
0.5129720568656921,
-0.2437271624803543,
-0.2114710807800293,
0.7440380454063416,
-0.2150840014219284,
0.7427504658699036,
-0.34429454803466797,
0.15473775565624237,
0.28616416454315186,
0.4893801510334015,
0.426493376493454,
-0.3112252950668335,
-0.4384472668170929,
-0.04903218150138855,
-0.3355492055416107,
-0.14065609872341156,
-0.4871011972427368,
0.3024629056453705,
-1.0791274309158325,
-0.37564507126808167,
-0.28679513931274414,
-0.3980053663253784,
-0.21487584710121155,
-0.23214472830295563,
0.5193217992782593,
0.260597288608551,
0.041162434965372086,
0.05570976063609123,
0.47243794798851013,
0.015034262090921402,
0.45036569237709045,
0.17393438518047333,
0.1462060809135437,
-0.3444719612598419,
0.9133917689323425,
0.28074026107788086,
0.2558734118938446,
0.4742795526981354,
0.36782220005989075,
0.061915360391139984,
-0.29613152146339417,
-0.38323307037353516,
-0.07567543536424637,
-0.798492431640625,
-0.4752579629421234,
-0.9910397529602051,
0.055387917906045914,
-0.29867833852767944,
-0.6489287614822388,
-0.37257120013237,
-0.30552634596824646,
-0.18584267795085907,
-0.5208353996276855,
0.694189190864563,
0.8620045185089111,
-0.25283583998680115,
0.34700068831443787,
-0.42735522985458374,
0.06574905663728714,
0.31699520349502563,
0.16598959267139435,
-0.1803836226463318,
-0.46259889006614685,
-0.1475747525691986,
-0.43671393394470215,
-0.1666077822446823,
-0.802619457244873,
0.7411719560623169,
0.28746142983436584,
-0.04245275631546974,
0.3648069202899933,
0.31182849407196045,
0.46267077326774597,
-0.2599707841873169,
0.8847951292991638,
0.12422291189432144,
-0.929526150226593,
0.3963591456413269,
-0.15526996552944183,
0.1779034286737442,
0.6798396110534668,
0.7484051585197449,
-0.4557167887687683,
-0.6650686264038086,
-0.7238808870315552,
-1.2038547992706299,
0.4693833291530609,
0.03053382970392704,
0.005261789541691542,
-0.038085341453552246,
0.5057382583618164,
0.31166699528694153,
0.1445532888174057,
-0.7382014989852905,
-0.4398506283760071,
-0.2794462740421295,
-0.32085734605789185,
-0.5927097201347351,
-0.3246390223503113,
0.22902031242847443,
-0.1513793021440506,
0.6573820114135742,
-0.16736315190792084,
0.10889073461294174,
0.3244365155696869,
-0.21870175004005432,
-0.7736992835998535,
0.043573927134275436,
0.40659281611442566,
0.35803717374801636,
-0.49843767285346985,
0.25108951330184937,
0.44310837984085083,
-0.32827767729759216,
0.13649243116378784,
-0.0060736979357898235,
-0.10898660868406296,
0.26773959398269653,
0.6835874319076538,
0.8920334577560425,
0.22911295294761658,
-0.4339572787284851,
0.5464857816696167,
-0.04324004426598549,
-0.23841963708400726,
-0.4469708502292633,
-0.06120077893137932,
-0.06999804824590683,
0.1786765605211258,
0.511613130569458,
0.2612469494342804,
0.38873693346977234,
-0.25511085987091064,
0.19938628375530243,
-0.10828541964292526,
-0.7221804261207581,
-0.2403201311826706,
0.8510452508926392,
0.22447197139263153,
-0.4891441762447357,
0.46148231625556946,
-0.0527866892516613,
-0.6871986389160156,
0.7965231537818909,
0.2936200499534607,
0.8999478220939636,
-0.6198447942733765,
0.3046259880065918,
0.7406314015388489,
0.3871133029460907,
-0.3029235899448395,
0.04557971656322479,
0.23942650854587555,
-0.1581362634897232,
-0.46148213744163513,
-0.7534112930297852,
-0.6282979249954224,
-0.186210036277771,
-0.9854496121406555,
0.379082590341568,
-0.24378064274787903,
-0.30767250061035156,
0.21416603028774261,
-0.14080500602722168,
-0.6801483631134033,
0.8170862793922424,
0.4169665277004242,
0.59781414270401,
-1.1417109966278076,
0.34614047408103943,
0.7658500671386719,
-0.3463280498981476,
-0.9584137797355652,
-0.4182997941970825,
0.04571620002388954,
-0.4939599335193634,
0.9057444334030151,
0.2840656340122223,
0.14315639436244965,
-0.14858034253120422,
-0.4204410910606384,
-0.6433244347572327,
0.8986647129058838,
0.16525036096572876,
-0.7427664995193481,
-0.18704695999622345,
0.15213923156261444,
0.9888964891433716,
-0.3714246451854706,
0.8800830245018005,
0.517920970916748,
0.5853949189186096,
-0.10856650024652481,
-1.0347967147827148,
0.12391743808984756,
-0.23741362988948822,
-0.19035491347312927,
0.20476913452148438,
-0.727499783039093,
0.8056342005729675,
-0.12847551703453064,
0.2091914266347885,
-0.16699044406414032,
0.580532968044281,
-0.5094234943389893,
0.45441997051239014,
0.8385274410247803,
0.3842446804046631,
0.5623474717140198,
-0.15929338335990906,
0.9372596740722656,
-0.30002105236053467,
0.5324640274047852,
1.079813003540039,
0.10125298798084259,
0.9570132493972778,
0.06682772934436798,
-0.06824369728565216,
0.3811722695827484,
0.7853923439979553,
-0.3011898994445801,
0.11722224950790405,
0.2862732708454132,
0.08739405125379562,
-0.3714301884174347,
0.09788556396961212,
-0.11804402619600296,
0.23877187073230743,
0.28242018818855286,
-0.6345237493515015,
0.07429398596286774,
0.32252851128578186,
0.15020886063575745,
0.11005088686943054,
-0.32254254817962646,
0.9919888973236084,
-0.034830354154109955,
-0.6115249395370483,
0.6702084541320801,
-0.2799072861671448,
0.7737528681755066,
-0.140341117978096,
0.28975552320480347,
-0.15766747295856476,
-0.007386818993836641,
-0.4460470676422119,
-0.5978606939315796,
0.3987082839012146,
0.32264548540115356,
-0.1088666170835495,
-0.29483097791671753,
0.4749765992164612,
-0.36180928349494934,
-0.5005306005477905,
0.3925115466117859,
0.06965597718954086,
0.24407975375652313,
-0.27101731300354004,
-0.4471001625061035,
0.07982052862644196,
-0.20917917788028717,
-0.8282305002212524,
0.1336490958929062,
0.44088178873062134,
0.11353074014186859,
0.796030580997467,
0.10577549785375595,
-0.10779118537902832,
0.09460528939962387,
0.15704992413520813,
0.5863590836524963,
-0.7071433067321777,
0.11163805425167084,
-0.7602356672286987,
0.6466668844223022,
0.009452944621443748,
-0.5649788975715637,
0.20504502952098846,
0.41368603706359863,
0.512812077999115,
-0.04396750405430794,
0.7661831378936768,
-0.10496801882982254,
0.4344407618045807,
0.20394112169742584,
0.6236913204193115,
-0.5695307850837708,
-0.22181148827075958,
-0.6144366264343262,
-0.8038760423660278,
-0.6825712323188782,
0.6419447660446167,
-0.37808361649513245,
-0.09168387949466705,
0.6551656723022461,
0.4855618178844452,
0.43270671367645264,
0.05027146264910698,
0.4738500118255615,
0.43114152550697327,
0.2680389881134033,
0.3378472924232483,
0.44831058382987976,
-0.15845423936843872,
0.529325008392334,
-0.8548418879508972,
-0.39892107248306274,
-0.5621820092201233,
-0.5860178470611572,
-0.9811493754386902,
-0.7612960338592529,
-0.7121111154556274,
-0.44502899050712585,
-0.11072590947151184,
1.177356243133545,
0.547900915145874,
-0.6174096465110779,
0.04056764021515846,
0.0854404866695404,
-0.24474048614501953,
-0.2550346553325653,
-0.23139627277851105,
0.5349404811859131,
-0.5578603148460388,
-0.8980412483215332,
-0.24688787758350372,
0.1674729883670807,
-0.03895246237516403,
-0.2952170968055725,
0.2324136644601822,
0.18474222719669342,
0.04995986446738243,
0.6143062114715576,
0.009904303587973118,
-0.5428287982940674,
-0.718868613243103,
-0.18501652777194977,
-0.33808842301368713,
0.2817102372646332,
0.474813312292099,
-0.522454023361206,
0.5924254655838013,
0.2779473066329956,
0.3710991442203522,
0.22643715143203735,
-0.022259032353758812,
0.48271965980529785,
-0.17489512264728546,
-0.17462535202503204,
0.45896998047828674,
0.2201990932226181,
0.46596187353134155,
-0.5800817608833313,
0.7068193554878235,
-0.1948940008878708,
-0.8759485483169556,
-0.9731252193450928,
-0.09823373705148697,
-0.8629802465438843,
0.06727933883666992,
1.0858831405639648,
-0.4077923893928528,
-0.46665358543395996,
0.04336152225732803,
-0.4758467674255371,
0.32268571853637695,
-0.5503923296928406,
1.0747243165969849,
0.7280170321464539,
-0.3346096873283386,
-0.1497790515422821,
-0.5153687596321106,
0.7052800059318542,
0.5645098090171814,
-0.41955578327178955,
0.20648913085460663,
0.13822342455387115,
-0.05307838320732117,
0.48579156398773193,
0.1331556737422943,
0.23144729435443878,
-0.00842650793492794,
0.11599823832511902,
0.5065750479698181,
-0.007377668283879757,
-0.11163941025733948,
-0.395462304353714,
0.5011146664619446,
0.34407493472099304,
0.34555232524871826
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17611v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17611v1
|
Denoising Table-Text Retrieval for Open-Domain Question Answering
| 2024-03-26T11:44:49 | 2024-03-26T11:44:49 |
Deokhyung Kang, Baikjin Jung, Yunsu Kim, Gary Geunbae Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In table-text open-domain question answering, a retriever system retrieves
relevant evidence from tables and text to answer questions. Previous studies in
table-text open-domain question answering have two common challenges: firstly,
their retrievers can be affected by false-positive labels in training datasets;
secondly, they may struggle to provide appropriate evidence for questions that
require reasoning across the table. To address these issues, we propose
Denoised Table-Text Retriever (DoTTeR). Our approach involves utilizing a
denoised training dataset with fewer false positive labels by discarding
instances with lower question-relevance scores measured through a false
positive detection model. Subsequently, we integrate table-level ranking
information into the retriever to assist in finding evidence for questions that
demand reasoning across the table. To encode this ranking information, we
fine-tune a rank-aware column encoder to identify minimum and maximum values
within a column. Experimental results demonstrate that DoTTeR significantly
outperforms strong baselines on both retrieval recall and downstream QA tasks.
Our code is available at https://github.com/deokhk/DoTTeR.
|
[
-0.3939945101737976,
-0.9317619204521179,
0.4818294942378998,
-0.3126446604728699,
-0.2929214835166931,
-0.027656495571136475,
0.13849185407161713,
-0.28068241477012634,
0.0821462869644165,
0.5541902780532837,
0.008274108171463013,
-0.6039554476737976,
-0.5722935199737549,
0.3347073793411255,
-0.46460267901420593,
1.1831157207489014,
-0.0003032571403309703,
-0.04941318556666374,
-0.4505803883075714,
-0.0997992679476738,
-0.6455249190330505,
-0.6179682612419128,
-0.598218560218811,
-0.26245757937431335,
0.4256068766117096,
0.7287196516990662,
0.5929895639419556,
0.4323398172855377,
0.547671377658844,
0.060078687965869904,
-0.23931096494197845,
0.04425307363271713,
-0.8197305202484131,
0.33637580275535583,
-0.01971108466386795,
-0.3893989026546478,
-0.612890899181366,
-0.12888871133327484,
0.5305529832839966,
0.4705590605735779,
-0.24191591143608093,
0.20772868394851685,
-0.07917533814907074,
0.7669976353645325,
-0.692913830280304,
0.20717181265354156,
-0.8411334156990051,
0.12508006393909454,
0.008529813960194588,
-0.1493624597787857,
-0.5509607791900635,
-0.7479478120803833,
0.03736837953329086,
-0.5838325619697571,
0.398495614528656,
-0.18378540873527527,
0.9446836709976196,
0.22718320786952972,
-0.4869152903556824,
-0.050547849386930466,
-0.8745239973068237,
0.3483963906764984,
-0.40881162881851196,
0.5030891299247742,
0.6218956708908081,
0.4136262536048889,
0.07197792828083038,
-0.77951979637146,
-0.824565052986145,
-0.04835812374949455,
-0.33464306592941284,
0.3195821940898895,
-0.2656971216201782,
-0.12562499940395355,
0.3814011514186859,
0.5331602096557617,
-0.8180316686630249,
-0.3520638048648834,
-0.2272530049085617,
0.05485127493739128,
0.10543058067560196,
0.050629742443561554,
0.26905080676078796,
0.09757702797651291,
-0.08968094736337662,
-0.19586181640625,
-0.6528298854827881,
-0.020997853949666023,
-0.23941107094287872,
0.21464434266090393,
0.48529472947120667,
0.6391034722328186,
-0.41510024666786194,
0.7014150023460388,
0.18902426958084106,
0.35363152623176575,
0.11283845454454422,
-0.07807198911905289,
-0.12336055189371109,
0.1417813003063202,
0.12257838249206543,
0.29379895329475403,
-0.06579850614070892,
-0.4261173903942108,
-0.3093995749950409,
0.23503364622592926,
0.2891017496585846,
-1.1114965677261353,
-0.44654667377471924,
0.24066567420959473,
-0.28359171748161316,
-0.04612733796238899,
0.12929785251617432,
-1.1977896690368652,
-0.38527166843414307,
0.05270735174417496,
0.9923912882804871,
-0.19447936117649078,
-0.13378141820430756,
0.1422201544046402,
-0.523768961429596,
0.23357994854450226,
0.3082748055458069,
-0.6031045913696289,
0.47835758328437805,
0.48571690917015076,
0.4065367877483368,
-0.09626799076795578,
0.23285982012748718,
-0.944771409034729,
0.19005799293518066,
-0.40680158138275146,
0.744002103805542,
-0.8744531273841858,
-0.3139583468437195,
0.1339135318994522,
-0.09454401582479477,
-0.08879704773426056,
-0.851548969745636,
0.7812344431877136,
-1.0591809749603271,
0.34094497561454773,
-0.5482993721961975,
-0.5632943511009216,
-0.09773588925600052,
0.4626753032207489,
-0.8836513161659241,
1.1137659549713135,
0.09520198404788971,
-0.7288603782653809,
0.6465796828269958,
-0.6408830881118774,
-0.3126409947872162,
0.14261755347251892,
-0.008292010985314846,
-0.614433765411377,
-0.08084846287965775,
0.577543318271637,
0.13628344237804413,
-0.13162094354629517,
-0.07235479354858398,
0.07964982837438583,
-0.572791576385498,
0.10863268375396729,
-0.20440661907196045,
0.24297060072422028,
0.1418912559747696,
-0.23766598105430603,
-0.16170205175876617,
-0.6215178966522217,
0.07205313444137573,
0.21499289572238922,
-0.47197064757347107,
-0.44634026288986206,
0.009007581509649754,
-0.2997640371322632,
0.07137373089790344,
0.00631752610206604,
-0.8888466954231262,
0.052169762551784515,
-0.26750630140304565,
0.43720191717147827,
0.08518996834754944,
0.5790374875068665,
0.46684277057647705,
-0.4269959032535553,
0.3898007571697235,
0.27542436122894287,
-0.11401086300611496,
0.2250913679599762,
-0.5558767914772034,
-0.832254946231842,
-0.11057456582784653,
0.48972904682159424,
0.552191436290741,
-1.1488161087036133,
0.10431056469678879,
-0.39333397150039673,
-0.33980655670166016,
-0.6482764482498169,
-0.29728516936302185,
0.4362126290798187,
0.8987818360328674,
0.9230478405952454,
-0.17321553826332092,
-0.2862545847892761,
-0.7206908464431763,
-0.2935752272605896,
0.08186403661966324,
-0.23535767197608948,
0.19055981934070587,
0.6320597529411316,
0.0680067241191864,
1.0799728631973267,
-0.7789356708526611,
-0.43144431710243225,
-0.10826006531715393,
0.14053235948085785,
0.28611403703689575,
0.4417872130870819,
0.22552490234375,
-0.9024251699447632,
-0.6528135538101196,
-0.04908638447523117,
-0.6138702034950256,
0.062292251735925674,
0.2667134702205658,
-0.13041481375694275,
0.1967756301164627,
0.42085570096969604,
-0.742987334728241,
0.6479388475418091,
-0.14912858605384827,
-0.40195733308792114,
0.31835320591926575,
-0.1718045175075531,
0.45087799429893494,
-0.6415104269981384,
0.3680616021156311,
-0.267435759305954,
0.025191782042384148,
-0.8598277568817139,
-0.10037090629339218,
0.1609475314617157,
-0.46529436111450195,
0.030571753159165382,
0.5942361354827881,
-0.4629078507423401,
0.1888025552034378,
0.09049049019813538,
0.4639967381954193,
0.43689337372779846,
0.4459662139415741,
0.1554068773984909,
1.097682237625122,
0.11430879682302475,
-0.7214465737342834,
-0.3659247159957886,
0.9010593295097351,
-0.18043117225170135,
0.6037480235099792,
-0.7142179012298584,
0.3351016044616699,
-0.4003719985485077,
-0.08532296866178513,
-1.221425175666809,
0.06463206559419632,
0.32037195563316345,
-0.5997248888015747,
0.35809728503227234,
-0.44024696946144104,
-0.32788869738578796,
-0.4336630702018738,
-0.2080133557319641,
0.19977551698684692,
0.5474525690078735,
-0.7531142830848694,
0.2600920796394348,
0.5592051148414612,
-0.2587849795818329,
-0.8342741131782532,
-0.425287663936615,
0.1082124188542366,
-0.018796106800436974,
-0.07504452764987946,
0.5285894870758057,
0.020488135516643524,
-0.0888645201921463,
-0.051303036510944366,
-0.7634351253509521,
-0.5776198506355286,
-0.19736014306545258,
-0.08823435753583908,
0.057641640305519104,
-0.2090023308992386,
0.34254831075668335,
0.25578829646110535,
-0.11940331012010574,
0.19458431005477905,
-0.16352668404579163,
0.23867763578891754,
-0.17796294391155243,
0.07358746975660324,
-0.15330220758914948,
0.2462548464536667,
0.37075069546699524,
-0.5047553777694702,
0.7334771156311035,
0.4898521602153778,
-0.4484238624572754,
-0.17961858212947845,
-0.5369083881378174,
-0.6488111615180969,
-0.4197655916213989,
0.26992475986480713,
-0.5876419544219971,
-0.9388421773910522,
0.47203123569488525,
0.1851455718278885,
-0.009557703509926796,
0.32996949553489685,
0.13380742073059082,
-0.16532379388809204,
0.9737809300422668,
0.372521311044693,
0.15389695763587952,
0.15759223699569702,
-0.2823190987110138,
0.24272556602954865,
-0.5789875388145447,
-0.32156458497047424,
-0.8801383376121521,
-0.10436666011810303,
-0.20999212563037872,
-0.3954602777957916,
0.5612959265708923,
0.027194466441869736,
-0.31651729345321655,
0.21153363585472107,
-0.8784314393997192,
0.5728426575660706,
0.6093457341194153,
0.48266303539276123,
0.5713552832603455,
0.10480744391679764,
-0.016667548567056656,
-0.12483880668878555,
-0.8065160512924194,
-0.4155101776123047,
0.8687264919281006,
0.0033561058808118105,
0.6658984422683716,
0.08044449985027313,
0.6014584302902222,
0.4178783893585205,
0.2799462676048279,
-0.3193087577819824,
0.5793221592903137,
-0.12086344510316849,
-0.7301644682884216,
-0.5606036186218262,
-0.6614728569984436,
-1.1891140937805176,
0.49624061584472656,
-0.3968656063079834,
-0.42882782220840454,
0.365263432264328,
0.10654882341623306,
-0.09524089097976685,
0.26869145035743713,
-0.6031998991966248,
1.3182543516159058,
0.43874141573905945,
-0.16581355035305023,
-0.049327097833156586,
-0.5624873042106628,
0.19256621599197388,
0.1131991446018219,
-0.2091272622346878,
0.1263628900051117,
0.02530839666724205,
0.8009770512580872,
-0.43898844718933105,
0.5384177565574646,
-0.4986819922924042,
0.05156851187348366,
0.3712838292121887,
0.48125675320625305,
0.38589292764663696,
0.2596890330314636,
-0.28831642866134644,
-0.02169080264866352,
0.2983831763267517,
-0.3472805619239807,
-0.6187013387680054,
0.45881766080856323,
-0.5726177096366882,
-0.5601880550384521,
-0.27001914381980896,
-0.26446133852005005,
-0.3303127586841583,
0.28195738792419434,
0.01893417164683342,
0.6041311621665955,
-0.34083107113838196,
0.22221973538398743,
1.0634088516235352,
-0.07757315039634705,
0.29371967911720276,
0.5266420841217041,
0.06243094801902771,
-0.5873485207557678,
1.0486253499984741,
0.09843163937330246,
-0.0421297624707222,
0.9916243553161621,
0.08347024768590927,
-0.47531843185424805,
-0.5782473683357239,
-0.5739096999168396,
0.06267695873975754,
-0.6677676439285278,
-0.5461569428443909,
-0.7325085997581482,
-0.15915755927562714,
-0.1327708661556244,
0.17878063023090363,
0.1294347494840622,
-0.7729653716087341,
-0.2349432408809662,
-0.2332809865474701,
0.4829234480857849,
0.31926384568214417,
0.21586555242538452,
0.14501836895942688,
-0.862247884273529,
0.667205274105072,
0.6053467988967896,
0.6117925643920898,
-0.06255114823579788,
-0.7233649492263794,
-0.11299800127744675,
-0.050163302570581436,
0.0354401059448719,
-0.8959639668464661,
0.42730411887168884,
0.2545531392097473,
0.6433333158493042,
-0.08068881183862686,
0.6588981747627258,
0.4590034782886505,
-0.3711791932582855,
0.4687206447124481,
-0.1656709760427475,
-0.7018588781356812,
0.5612615942955017,
-0.22884871065616608,
0.32750794291496277,
0.8995049595832825,
0.5465716123580933,
-0.42111432552337646,
-0.34531790018081665,
-0.12371453642845154,
-0.6917158961296082,
0.6438714265823364,
0.29936444759368896,
-0.26570746302604675,
-0.3067212700843811,
0.6109743714332581,
0.30886152386665344,
0.4199939966201782,
-0.8225690722465515,
-0.21996961534023285,
-0.3630932867527008,
-0.19083811342716217,
0.10481002181768417,
-0.5989099144935608,
-0.12554532289505005,
-0.27368488907814026,
0.5391361713409424,
0.1161014586687088,
0.582746684551239,
0.6237161159515381,
-0.5401338338851929,
-0.11651197075843811,
0.5505627393722534,
0.43797147274017334,
0.5297569632530212,
-0.6222495436668396,
0.22040851414203644,
0.03866099566221237,
-0.9530357122421265,
0.03366509824991226,
0.18987470865249634,
-0.6102091073989868,
0.17008386552333832,
-0.312004953622818,
0.4595637321472168,
-0.20090270042419434,
-0.5307469367980957,
0.48411351442337036,
-0.2446642518043518,
-0.2508394420146942,
0.0006297736545093358,
-0.12132485210895538,
-0.21890932321548462,
-0.06663244217634201,
0.4988082945346832,
-0.22443701326847076,
0.3132489025592804,
-0.1951434314250946,
0.511786699295044,
0.3784303665161133,
-0.7827630639076233,
-0.13290759921073914,
0.9885598421096802,
0.23488709330558777,
-0.2738262712955475,
0.8379638195037842,
-0.13971459865570068,
-0.41892504692077637,
0.6294794082641602,
0.44706666469573975,
0.6350978016853333,
-0.024433093145489693,
0.2751901149749756,
0.552070677280426,
0.43366095423698425,
0.20457251369953156,
0.7696292400360107,
-0.029839469119906425,
-0.5094437599182129,
-0.08334387093782425,
-0.4596810042858124,
-0.6127246022224426,
0.10863999277353287,
-0.5615198016166687,
-0.18687808513641357,
-0.16653288900852203,
-0.2679065465927124,
0.001294344780035317,
0.02979939803481102,
-0.3800608515739441,
0.1652589589357376,
-0.31556499004364014,
0.8861610889434814,
-0.43123599886894226,
0.683310866355896,
0.486684650182724,
-0.849542498588562,
-0.29321128129959106,
-0.11215902119874954,
-0.42448514699935913,
-0.28699856996536255,
0.6145163774490356,
0.09191127121448517,
0.03707509487867355,
0.28209882974624634,
-0.21553035080432892,
-0.6173388957977295,
0.8647218942642212,
0.08240390568971634,
-0.017926618456840515,
0.22183506190776825,
0.40901419520378113,
0.5808308720588684,
-0.09780678898096085,
0.49764689803123474,
0.6408620476722717,
0.5958614349365234,
-0.09549602121114731,
-0.7263092398643494,
0.31276935338974,
-0.1703905314207077,
-0.33343377709388733,
0.500663697719574,
-0.11982045322656631,
0.6700396537780762,
-0.17111366987228394,
-0.2576057016849518,
-0.06685515493154526,
0.44464409351348877,
-0.05576562136411667,
0.513562798500061,
0.34858348965644836,
0.6499373316764832,
0.6524258255958557,
-0.244195818901062,
0.5503168106079102,
-0.10238345712423325,
0.09830598533153534,
1.0183815956115723,
-0.44363683462142944,
1.0472933053970337,
0.32499566674232483,
0.046626608818769455,
0.5373890995979309,
0.30811625719070435,
0.02571333386003971,
0.5983333587646484,
0.09889417886734009,
-0.24603047966957092,
-0.08345630019903183,
0.07170885801315308,
-0.3798946142196655,
0.15895505249500275,
0.39443790912628174,
0.03838558495044708,
-0.46772342920303345,
-0.07852890342473984,
-0.19498957693576813,
0.26651450991630554,
-0.4045327305793762,
0.9970355033874512,
-0.14792805910110474,
-0.5995246767997742,
0.9534294605255127,
-0.3265380263328552,
0.16693319380283356,
-0.1763758808374405,
-0.5957254767417908,
-0.6789181232452393,
0.025007588788866997,
-0.08047377318143845,
-0.7877367734909058,
0.07639133185148239,
-0.1853507161140442,
-0.3684858977794647,
-0.18605276942253113,
0.716334879398346,
-0.7349249124526978,
0.14456453919410706,
-0.12932462990283966,
0.7808117866516113,
0.18488427996635437,
-0.3606337308883667,
-0.3716159462928772,
-0.3563429117202759,
-0.289794385433197,
-0.12080822885036469,
0.29737669229507446,
0.4984571933746338,
0.10128504782915115,
0.643178403377533,
0.3877031207084656,
-0.3961435854434967,
-0.11983487010002136,
0.18951819837093353,
0.93559730052948,
-0.750490128993988,
-0.3920277953147888,
-0.35413312911987305,
0.17369577288627625,
-0.20661190152168274,
-0.036651454865932465,
0.569392204284668,
0.8716926574707031,
0.6135731339454651,
-0.4567212462425232,
0.20184646546840668,
-0.01620723493397236,
0.8890538215637207,
-0.31537023186683655,
1.088208794593811,
-0.4301019012928009,
0.27434855699539185,
-0.20448030531406403,
-0.8039789795875549,
-0.451089471578598,
0.4216957688331604,
-0.3344298005104065,
-0.12098171561956406,
0.7049605846405029,
0.81379234790802,
0.038269348442554474,
0.05763610079884529,
0.3554578125476837,
0.3749012053012848,
0.16731800138950348,
0.48881638050079346,
0.7758793234825134,
-0.6294277906417847,
1.2452397346496582,
-0.060383185744285583,
-0.09349508583545685,
-0.2933725118637085,
-0.36108121275901794,
-0.977268397808075,
-0.4942249655723572,
-0.31391555070877075,
-0.3528256118297577,
0.3528745770454407,
0.2484099119901657,
0.4280517101287842,
-0.8745973706245422,
-0.07787880301475525,
-0.005764019209891558,
0.43888989090919495,
-0.5266760587692261,
-0.28084707260131836,
0.5887289643287659,
-0.34620076417922974,
-0.4174773693084717,
0.3371317386627197,
0.12166814506053925,
-0.13441680371761322,
0.482298344373703,
0.22206704318523407,
-0.3443434238433838,
-0.021866105496883392,
0.7823035717010498,
0.3142777383327484,
-0.28105002641677856,
-0.4746340811252594,
0.27012813091278076,
-0.19915056228637695,
0.5578547120094299,
0.6151511669158936,
-1.0612788200378418,
0.3710453510284424,
0.5132535696029663,
0.7756452560424805,
0.7966210246086121,
0.2892908751964569,
0.3560229539871216,
-0.8013514876365662,
-0.3687341511249542,
0.655197024345398,
-0.06454051285982132,
-0.010242053307592869,
-0.28095629811286926,
0.7763232588768005,
0.1396940052509308,
-0.6134445667266846,
-0.9471214413642883,
-0.05081257224082947,
-0.9803522229194641,
-0.34339579939842224,
0.7152703404426575,
0.20136062800884247,
-0.11554723978042603,
-0.5693548321723938,
-0.21653562784194946,
0.20056605339050293,
-0.5299437046051025,
1.0656309127807617,
0.2448395937681198,
-0.0017239301232621074,
-0.3143256604671478,
-0.6463953852653503,
0.783605694770813,
0.3687887489795685,
-0.8092289566993713,
0.3135717213153839,
0.5739309191703796,
0.17116467654705048,
-0.006510973442345858,
0.5985667705535889,
-0.21832166612148285,
0.5066280364990234,
0.3424781560897827,
0.235291987657547,
-0.07885750383138657,
-0.2831995189189911,
-0.28295812010765076,
0.6146029233932495,
0.10806538164615631,
-0.36356043815612793
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17599v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17599v1
|
Coimagining the Future of Voice Assistants with Cultural Sensitivity
| 2024-03-26T11:09:58 | 2024-03-26T11:09:58 |
Katie Seaborn, Yuto Sawa, Mizuki Watanabe
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Voice assistants (VAs) are becoming a feature of our everyday life. Yet, the
user experience (UX) is often limited, leading to underuse, disengagement, and
abandonment. Co-designing interactions for VAs with potential end-users can be
useful. Crowdsourcing this process online and anonymously may add value.
However, most work has been done in the English-speaking West on dialogue data
sets. We must be sensitive to cultural differences in language, social
interactions, and attitudes towards technology. Our aims were to explore the
value of co-designing VAs in the non-Western context of Japan and demonstrate
the necessity of cultural sensitivity. We conducted an online elicitation study
(N = 135) where Americans (n = 64) and Japanese people (n = 71) imagined
dialogues (N = 282) and activities (N = 73) with future VAs. We discuss the
implications for coimagining interactions with future VAs, offer design
guidelines for the Japanese and English-speaking US contexts, and suggest
opportunities for cultural plurality in VA design and scholarship.
|
[
-0.7205888032913208,
-0.31163841485977173,
0.2574841380119324,
0.21754351258277893,
0.037715472280979156,
0.14145195484161377,
-0.06796300411224365,
-0.8879445791244507,
0.5957944989204407,
0.33856549859046936,
-0.8211812973022461,
-0.0168246328830719,
-0.10716276615858078,
0.19289375841617584,
0.06448066234588623,
0.2912558913230896,
0.2118038684129715,
-0.08204162120819092,
-0.35128727555274963,
-0.29512545466423035,
-0.569731593132019,
-0.7775609493255615,
-0.6750783920288086,
-0.08638013899326324,
0.31992414593696594,
0.6344591975212097,
0.6052336096763611,
-0.04953446611762047,
-0.008423268795013428,
0.28312596678733826,
0.01749703846871853,
-0.12266268581151962,
-0.23667043447494507,
0.32710492610931396,
0.18360404670238495,
-0.6595968008041382,
-0.5082984566688538,
0.07948037981987,
0.07388746738433838,
0.9158951044082642,
-0.08546208590269089,
0.138093963265419,
0.023177897557616234,
0.3302094042301178,
-0.47585657238960266,
-0.04928832873702049,
-0.3815633952617645,
0.34182479977607727,
0.009700843133032322,
-0.06994030624628067,
-0.24479739367961884,
-0.30101653933525085,
0.2314595729112625,
-1.1726449728012085,
0.3174203336238861,
-0.2012968361377716,
0.7778629064559937,
0.3702138364315033,
-0.3259693682193756,
-0.14711575210094452,
-1.1136795282363892,
0.6748082041740417,
-0.351057231426239,
0.5962755084037781,
0.7218683362007141,
0.25765904784202576,
-0.08019009232521057,
-0.3733871281147003,
-0.5159194469451904,
-0.12163493782281876,
0.17908860743045807,
0.4544297456741333,
-0.315341591835022,
-0.15026570856571198,
0.3042602241039276,
0.14470849931240082,
-0.4509165585041046,
0.4168204665184021,
-0.43253469467163086,
-0.23935529589653015,
0.7901394963264465,
0.10142666101455688,
0.7222291827201843,
0.24105526506900787,
-0.2120799422264099,
-0.12276669591665268,
-0.5141119360923767,
0.2374342530965805,
0.42829975485801697,
0.15994785726070404,
-0.47698974609375,
0.021537424996495247,
-0.42689526081085205,
0.311786413192749,
0.09521780908107758,
-0.11815845221281052,
0.07892095297574997,
-0.02208009362220764,
-0.12037148326635361,
0.11721737682819366,
0.6507276296615601,
0.5195358991622925,
0.6289317011833191,
0.19785287976264954,
0.34585776925086975,
-0.06849910318851471,
0.40071505308151245,
-0.6019566655158997,
0.1896003782749176,
0.05747217684984207,
-0.5875057578086853,
-0.07898236811161041,
-0.16556039452552795,
-0.6967878341674805,
-0.5076514482498169,
-0.5054059028625488,
0.3024230897426605,
0.22831279039382935,
-0.6868255734443665,
-0.2597675621509552,
-0.25002241134643555,
0.10702652484178543,
0.383897602558136,
-0.9065486192703247,
0.5730299353599548,
0.40994498133659363,
0.7558319568634033,
-0.016778945922851562,
-0.1912454515695572,
-0.13432030379772186,
-0.06590836495161057,
-0.4815440773963928,
0.3896172344684601,
-0.4487341046333313,
-1.244520664215088,
-0.13021281361579895,
0.02663780190050602,
0.17908570170402527,
-0.6514784693717957,
0.3637922406196594,
-0.17405620217323303,
0.5324371457099915,
-0.4657347500324249,
-0.024378517642617226,
0.13258256018161774,
-0.17219743132591248,
-0.7600974440574646,
0.385519802570343,
0.0071809617802500725,
-0.16974617540836334,
0.44262051582336426,
-0.8013326525688171,
-0.6725903153419495,
0.2937048375606537,
-0.3353589177131653,
-0.24706944823265076,
0.3142881393432617,
0.34290412068367004,
0.25926777720451355,
-0.13236871361732483,
0.34007728099823,
-0.3479235768318176,
-0.6815552711486816,
0.3654804527759552,
-0.7981151938438416,
1.2215853929519653,
0.4333106577396393,
-0.32459691166877747,
-0.16772569715976715,
-0.5933697819709778,
-0.17869389057159424,
-0.05561228096485138,
0.26876479387283325,
-0.5490407943725586,
-0.1424473524093628,
-0.10313140600919724,
0.2351861447095871,
-0.04552531987428665,
-0.5834705233573914,
-0.2580271363258362,
-0.1910107433795929,
0.25594428181648254,
0.5299662351608276,
0.023915043100714684,
0.47373712062835693,
-0.19664844870567322,
1.2583094835281372,
-0.30881839990615845,
0.8449865579605103,
-0.041911158710718155,
-0.7504338622093201,
-0.6544256210327148,
-0.05114263668656349,
-0.35067039728164673,
0.29525506496429443,
-0.7845792770385742,
0.2696371376514435,
-0.25602176785469055,
-0.5128430128097534,
-0.6386348605155945,
-0.2665529251098633,
0.11670397222042084,
0.6411640048027039,
0.03707445412874222,
-0.4814782738685608,
-0.41516563296318054,
-1.025994896888733,
-0.1437578797340393,
-0.524307906627655,
-0.3370184004306793,
0.6307573318481445,
-0.14305001497268677,
0.3352143466472626,
0.9413594007492065,
-0.24277830123901367,
-0.2533213198184967,
-0.0029412824660539627,
0.12644290924072266,
-0.22015133500099182,
0.17446979880332947,
0.3026359975337982,
-1.1338868141174316,
-0.5442779064178467,
-0.06536129117012024,
-0.6528064012527466,
-0.5310172438621521,
-0.20125143229961395,
0.2028980404138565,
0.21505342423915863,
0.561492383480072,
0.02825932204723358,
0.40906739234924316,
0.7582895755767822,
0.11358419805765152,
-0.024820629507303238,
0.0438900887966156,
0.5815876126289368,
-1.4224371910095215,
0.24696795642375946,
0.057492323219776154,
0.12198270857334137,
-0.8304300904273987,
-0.25195571780204773,
-0.3886076509952545,
-0.7993797659873962,
-0.6537094712257385,
0.5680973529815674,
-0.6315446496009827,
-0.30127596855163574,
-0.2553725242614746,
-0.16625173389911652,
0.24085299670696259,
0.24327708780765533,
0.5076421499252319,
1.0283604860305786,
0.14812113344669342,
-0.4484024941921234,
0.06718523800373077,
0.12958252429962158,
-0.26036426424980164,
1.0864547491073608,
-0.749903678894043,
0.4264122545719147,
0.21155214309692383,
0.38748303055763245,
-0.6071247458457947,
-0.11673706024885178,
0.14812926948070526,
-0.8003762364387512,
-0.08226113021373749,
-0.16172879934310913,
0.2879469096660614,
-0.28879597783088684,
-0.015137983486056328,
0.39758560061454773,
0.5474291443824768,
-0.37286004424095154,
0.5811311602592468,
0.924549400806427,
-0.6655731201171875,
-0.35249096155166626,
-0.7470322251319885,
0.38132521510124207,
-0.4346957206726074,
-0.5357558727264404,
0.09782839566469193,
-0.09116124361753464,
-0.5541517734527588,
-0.36088770627975464,
0.2669747769832611,
-0.37260866165161133,
0.5655269622802734,
0.552681565284729,
0.17097416520118713,
-0.008825207129120827,
-0.10394113510847092,
-0.01545617263764143,
-0.3088955879211426,
-0.015945203602313995,
0.11943421512842178,
0.3403558135032654,
-0.010283973067998886,
-0.46431589126586914,
-0.7343306541442871,
0.9365729093551636,
0.6240113973617554,
-0.36170583963394165,
0.16391459107398987,
0.8491679430007935,
-0.5779629349708557,
0.435397744178772,
-0.5407912135124207,
-0.18019729852676392,
-0.4697636663913727,
0.11521471291780472,
-0.5204789638519287,
-0.9485203623771667,
0.5861772894859314,
0.044842906296253204,
-0.22982358932495117,
0.043661732226610184,
0.5519129633903503,
-0.20670805871486664,
1.0453760623931885,
0.8315829634666443,
-0.059324417263269424,
0.652988851070404,
0.09983442723751068,
0.0725761353969574,
-0.8675514459609985,
-0.3317234218120575,
-0.7652358412742615,
-0.29471853375434875,
-0.7748702764511108,
-0.21254560351371765,
0.751846194267273,
-0.5552917122840881,
0.19454079866409302,
0.08210432529449463,
-0.42534729838371277,
0.19289274513721466,
0.7069783210754395,
-0.13116315007209778,
0.09849666804075241,
-0.05050409957766533,
0.4674309194087982,
-0.25637903809547424,
-0.49970197677612305,
-0.2654404044151306,
0.6666814088821411,
0.24993057548999786,
0.7939630150794983,
0.30713942646980286,
0.534647524356842,
0.21947431564331055,
0.09506452828645706,
-0.6856705546379089,
0.4402938783168793,
-0.060958750545978546,
-0.5820373296737671,
-0.4810941815376282,
-0.06725677102804184,
-1.1808058023452759,
0.0915694609284401,
-0.07235433906316757,
-0.7742294669151306,
0.734632134437561,
0.37371131777763367,
-0.43665510416030884,
-0.32078513503074646,
-1.1254278421401978,
0.5435910820960999,
-0.15587377548217773,
-0.5495524406433105,
-0.14941571652889252,
-0.8732980489730835,
0.001363862887956202,
0.15678976476192474,
0.3741787075996399,
-0.05720223858952522,
-0.016631493344902992,
0.46712684631347656,
-0.24732744693756104,
1.2273000478744507,
-0.3432089388370514,
-0.2711346447467804,
0.347337007522583,
0.07485530525445938,
-0.004396568518131971,
-0.021743007004261017,
-0.26518332958221436,
0.3310502767562866,
0.06774561107158661,
-0.20846283435821533,
-0.43731337785720825,
0.7372040748596191,
-0.9311597347259521,
-0.799318253993988,
-0.24351052939891815,
-0.42833206057548523,
-0.4489489197731018,
0.046564992517232895,
0.37473565340042114,
0.38297799229621887,
-0.617713987827301,
0.15373894572257996,
0.42150354385375977,
-0.40435361862182617,
0.23213578760623932,
0.6478744745254517,
0.1295042783021927,
-0.08535116165876389,
0.8856143355369568,
0.42886805534362793,
0.42431578040122986,
0.2925167679786682,
0.4706980586051941,
-0.29718562960624695,
0.2249729186296463,
-0.7074154019355774,
-0.3960152864456177,
-0.28813105821609497,
0.434850811958313,
-0.35102522373199463,
0.06302393972873688,
-0.652996301651001,
-0.3521813750267029,
-0.17849740386009216,
-0.23147238790988922,
-0.4277362525463104,
0.16989463567733765,
0.2015993446111679,
0.5201050043106079,
-0.11974851042032242,
0.05016174167394638,
-0.3773638904094696,
0.323686420917511,
0.5194078683853149,
0.22518284618854523,
-0.21597404778003693,
-0.36474618315696716,
-0.20093253254890442,
-0.04789445549249649,
0.030119948089122772,
-0.6040712594985962,
0.3442816436290741,
0.17726364731788635,
0.5678688883781433,
0.2152906209230423,
0.13991041481494904,
0.8497947454452515,
-0.2072121798992157,
1.1872848272323608,
-0.05561463162302971,
-0.7779447436332703,
0.4697376489639282,
-0.2714923322200775,
0.5465349555015564,
0.580038845539093,
0.5410791039466858,
-1.1364610195159912,
-0.3382951617240906,
-0.8610376119613647,
-0.7470079660415649,
0.39459142088890076,
-0.20771127939224243,
0.6843374371528625,
0.3733629584312439,
-0.14604254066944122,
0.5627939701080322,
0.1426871418952942,
-0.3849965035915375,
0.01734158582985401,
-0.4195195436477661,
-0.03426305949687958,
-0.05883096531033516,
0.16063594818115234,
-0.073722243309021,
-0.13733217120170593,
0.30924996733665466,
-0.20838694274425507,
0.24702681601047516,
0.22347629070281982,
0.1921834498643875,
-0.2959052622318268,
0.39362430572509766,
0.7699622511863708,
0.5635386109352112,
0.08197779953479767,
-0.06304294615983963,
0.3100915253162384,
-0.47462278604507446,
0.18775440752506256,
-0.15491630136966705,
-0.15975359082221985,
-0.11407209187746048,
0.11050425469875336,
0.856644332408905,
-0.07585904747247696,
-0.3634062111377716,
0.4001557230949402,
-0.5664746165275574,
0.13714419305324554,
-0.8081207275390625,
-0.003595147980377078,
0.21399414539337158,
-0.20907214283943176,
0.1418476402759552,
-0.12231893837451935,
0.537651777267456,
-0.8423728346824646,
-0.2407163679599762,
0.35823768377304077,
-0.4041375517845154,
-0.343176007270813,
0.7758617401123047,
0.7953251600265503,
-0.664065957069397,
0.16563500463962555,
0.11551975458860397,
-0.3373463451862335,
0.6687709093093872,
0.5313959121704102,
0.9429625272750854,
-0.5437027215957642,
0.1291426122188568,
0.03937462344765663,
0.1660422682762146,
0.5101966857910156,
0.21862633526325226,
-0.35818010568618774,
-0.544909656047821,
0.003329108003526926,
0.046398717910051346,
-0.962191641330719,
0.13404671847820282,
-0.9717082977294922,
0.26890072226524353,
-0.23664478957653046,
-0.3890930414199829,
-0.41194701194763184,
-0.14145785570144653,
-0.8015648722648621,
0.548037588596344,
0.34567791223526,
0.4125141203403473,
-1.3102192878723145,
0.48598456382751465,
0.6175270080566406,
-0.17597897350788116,
-0.7435091733932495,
0.3343558609485626,
0.3620777428150177,
-0.751666247844696,
0.1255965232849121,
-0.03688827529549599,
-0.42407864332199097,
-0.1469692438840866,
-0.09947774559259415,
-0.7014583945274353,
1.0386892557144165,
0.43739956617355347,
-0.6181134581565857,
0.1742546409368515,
0.11887331306934357,
0.7810496687889099,
-0.05365390703082085,
0.4647713899612427,
0.1998789757490158,
0.20626763999462128,
-0.2966737151145935,
-1.1270877122879028,
-0.26489582657814026,
-0.6057687997817993,
0.1401248723268509,
-0.1680746227502823,
-1.162981390953064,
0.4250431954860687,
0.09565162658691406,
-0.1866721659898758,
-0.025452373549342155,
0.36643004417419434,
-0.013448012992739677,
0.5702924132347107,
0.6814920902252197,
-0.002098695607855916,
0.7992919683456421,
0.08107031881809235,
1.0346404314041138,
0.0639474093914032,
-0.5594923496246338,
1.0180226564407349,
-0.4501039385795593,
0.6518698334693909,
0.5848332047462463,
-0.21493937075138092,
0.5342574715614319,
0.6013199687004089,
0.3946440517902374,
0.01859450712800026,
-0.07070934027433395,
-0.5323274731636047,
0.0008347255061380565,
-0.9288787245750427,
-0.555480420589447,
0.8104790449142456,
0.42786407470703125,
-0.039321109652519226,
0.6321626901626587,
0.42856565117836,
0.02916630357503891,
0.3197970688343048,
0.04531973600387573,
1.0080559253692627,
0.18995890021324158,
-0.7997003197669983,
0.28868064284324646,
-0.45737171173095703,
0.5230953693389893,
-0.36612287163734436,
0.11790253967046738,
-0.27388855814933777,
-0.43531346321105957,
-0.1117713451385498,
-0.6564756631851196,
0.16710025072097778,
0.24570952355861664,
-0.04075472801923752,
-0.3739699721336365,
0.8137368559837341,
-0.13037970662117004,
-0.4673502743244171,
0.2238132506608963,
0.4946422278881073,
0.4420214593410492,
0.020709726959466934,
-0.42122113704681396,
0.472947895526886,
-0.17661987245082855,
0.0326981358230114,
0.23475243151187897,
0.20449846982955933,
-0.5515506267547607,
0.5116109251976013,
0.5014892816543579,
0.19078192114830017,
-0.17427842319011688,
0.776549756526947,
0.3376622498035431,
-0.08192820847034454,
-0.8288758993148804,
-0.40763145685195923,
0.499632865190506,
-0.1635008454322815,
-0.597689151763916,
0.3171103298664093,
0.3782773017883301,
0.9320279359817505,
-0.06793853640556335,
1.108181357383728,
-0.06448661535978317,
0.34026286005973816,
-0.1929379254579544,
0.7582928538322449,
-0.6546548008918762,
-0.14879612624645233,
-0.2650850713253021,
-0.32692867517471313,
0.11441931873559952,
0.5181818008422852,
-0.15237896144390106,
0.25367146730422974,
0.06616902351379395,
0.772842288017273,
0.10012312233448029,
0.39261025190353394,
0.6513973474502563,
-0.23495884239673615,
0.43193382024765015,
0.52510005235672,
0.9267876148223877,
0.06928635388612747,
0.2735181152820587,
-0.7616420984268188,
-0.3168533146381378,
-0.30436480045318604,
-0.7525376081466675,
-0.39778977632522583,
-1.0020767450332642,
-0.13053832948207855,
0.05296159163117409,
-0.07171719521284103,
1.061510682106018,
0.8529027700424194,
-0.40097084641456604,
-0.3772847056388855,
0.23443278670310974,
-0.24002665281295776,
-0.08039269596338272,
-0.2202761322259903,
-0.1621226817369461,
0.4217908978462219,
-1.2141207456588745,
0.5578285455703735,
0.223345085978508,
0.1572977602481842,
-0.4949038326740265,
-0.05811772868037224,
0.26465296745300293,
-0.11142564564943314,
0.5452642440795898,
0.7318365573883057,
-0.645237386226654,
-0.5096993446350098,
0.34681808948516846,
0.10004401952028275,
-0.004998071119189262,
0.7739331126213074,
-0.8450536131858826,
1.0182548761367798,
0.27489280700683594,
0.4010503888130188,
0.21555911004543304,
0.2757354974746704,
1.2194154262542725,
-0.7346193194389343,
0.5014600157737732,
0.35767555236816406,
0.056829314678907394,
0.6529495716094971,
-0.5341705679893494,
0.29934942722320557,
0.23078840970993042,
-0.42550623416900635,
-0.6658132076263428,
0.325573205947876,
-0.9231880307197571,
0.09146774560213089,
0.9078811407089233,
-0.02576591446995735,
0.13784809410572052,
-0.4331552982330322,
-0.41707104444503784,
0.5400698781013489,
-0.3616925776004791,
0.7135811448097229,
0.6011093854904175,
-0.34902507066726685,
-0.21107569336891174,
-0.5762024521827698,
0.31988459825515747,
0.6251833438873291,
-1.020511507987976,
-0.0840749591588974,
0.307017058134079,
0.09288503974676132,
0.12003330141305923,
0.9302480220794678,
-0.03164749592542648,
0.6007619500160217,
0.0732145756483078,
0.2969486117362976,
-0.10430148243904114,
-0.1925501823425293,
-0.5275827050209045,
-0.19849705696105957,
0.4564283788204193,
-0.3179451525211334
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17582v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17582v1
|
Towards a Zero-Data, Controllable, Adaptive Dialog System
| 2024-03-26T10:45:11 | 2024-03-26T10:45:11 |
Dirk Väth, Lindsey Vanderlyn, Ngoc Thang Vu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Conversational Tree Search (V\"ath et al., 2023) is a recent approach to
controllable dialog systems, where domain experts shape the behavior of a
Reinforcement Learning agent through a dialog tree. The agent learns to
efficiently navigate this tree, while adapting to information needs, e.g.,
domain familiarity, of different users. However, the need for additional
training data hinders deployment in new domains. To address this, we explore
approaches to generate this data directly from dialog trees. We improve the
original approach, and show that agents trained on synthetic data can achieve
comparable dialog success to models trained on human data, both when using a
commercial Large Language Model for generation, or when using a smaller
open-source model, running on a single GPU. We further demonstrate the
scalability of our approach by collecting and testing on two new datasets:
ONBOARD, a new domain helping foreign residents moving to a new city, and the
medical domain DIAGNOSE, a subset of Wikipedia articles related to scalp and
head symptoms. Finally, we perform human testing, where no statistically
significant differences were found in either objective or subjective measures
between models trained on human and generated data.
|
[
-0.26763883233070374,
-0.9693596363067627,
0.5981482863426208,
-0.3165159225463867,
0.10189887136220932,
0.4131963849067688,
-0.11808811873197556,
-0.4043360650539398,
0.13067969679832458,
0.6587525606155396,
-0.7995508313179016,
-0.4177401661872864,
-0.122543565928936,
0.001832780078984797,
-0.11973066627979279,
1.0702470541000366,
0.142884761095047,
-0.3518349528312683,
-0.22709916532039642,
-0.17294220626354218,
-0.5844382047653198,
-0.6294854283332825,
-0.8969206213951111,
-0.2575668692588806,
0.4722403585910797,
0.2976689040660858,
1.0665937662124634,
0.5863253474235535,
-0.0675269365310669,
0.2578750550746918,
0.2046319544315338,
0.2566439211368561,
-0.5247766971588135,
0.3839751183986664,
-0.20702917873859406,
-0.18999917805194855,
-0.5396534204483032,
-0.08246300369501114,
0.31206613779067993,
0.7233076691627502,
-0.25040656328201294,
-0.3093528747558594,
-0.09370120614767075,
0.3350827395915985,
-0.18070751428604126,
0.41524648666381836,
-1.0317537784576416,
0.10838865488767624,
0.3279969394207001,
-0.8360514044761658,
-0.5856814384460449,
-0.38257670402526855,
0.5314834713935852,
-1.035640001296997,
0.46305185556411743,
0.1516621857881546,
0.7732594013214111,
0.15512675046920776,
-0.7257221341133118,
-0.49534788727760315,
-0.6907259821891785,
0.751720130443573,
-0.5374491810798645,
0.28103363513946533,
0.275305837392807,
0.43010038137435913,
-0.46348050236701965,
-0.26601189374923706,
-0.3622317910194397,
-0.2586241662502289,
0.09293712675571442,
-0.014983980916440487,
-0.3961036503314972,
0.17889933288097382,
0.07266563922166824,
0.09751174598932266,
-0.6660188436508179,
-0.22142326831817627,
-0.2107720971107483,
-0.28502321243286133,
0.5541491508483887,
0.38112393021583557,
0.3261645436286926,
-0.006137648597359657,
-0.03194897249341011,
-0.2662685215473175,
-0.6489759087562561,
0.03295043483376503,
0.07855311781167984,
0.5730043053627014,
0.12514422833919525,
0.2950342297554016,
-0.43139782547950745,
0.6901689171791077,
0.2645130157470703,
-0.01688152179121971,
0.14233189821243286,
-0.3195628523826599,
-0.4193428158760071,
0.17187710106372833,
0.5039231777191162,
0.2501298785209656,
0.3415593206882477,
-0.3221839368343353,
-0.20304644107818604,
0.008197630755603313,
0.5707789063453674,
-0.7323570847511292,
-0.3959205746650696,
0.1329527348279953,
-0.19862471520900726,
-0.5503337383270264,
-0.5688318014144897,
-0.49160072207450867,
-0.2833949625492096,
-0.551798939704895,
0.2260003238916397,
-0.46006855368614197,
-0.2651330828666687,
-0.05101531744003296,
0.15853948891162872,
0.04470448195934296,
0.7798851132392883,
-0.8056896328926086,
0.5037398338317871,
0.37349095940589905,
0.729354739189148,
-0.2532493770122528,
0.13367649912834167,
-0.5145143866539001,
-0.09033238887786865,
-0.7130720615386963,
0.5840346813201904,
-0.6439228057861328,
-0.5746575593948364,
0.11128132045269012,
0.14017409086227417,
-0.333266943693161,
-0.7621651291847229,
0.10795232653617859,
-0.7420494556427002,
0.4097190499305725,
0.03395166993141174,
-0.42776113748550415,
-0.263558030128479,
0.2742971181869507,
-0.3938058912754059,
0.6940407752990723,
0.5595417022705078,
-0.4514526128768921,
0.3011741638183594,
-0.7928382158279419,
-0.23396946489810944,
0.26728200912475586,
-0.3599800169467926,
-0.3308058977127075,
-0.036032725125551224,
0.1085958331823349,
0.28489989042282104,
-0.14250148832798004,
0.39897438883781433,
-0.2543852925300598,
-0.07879935950040817,
0.29821935296058655,
-0.5165861248970032,
0.7417240738868713,
0.20642489194869995,
-0.2775315046310425,
0.0008188440697267652,
-0.5618560910224915,
0.30921152234077454,
0.20718610286712646,
-0.36416444182395935,
-0.1972997933626175,
0.3082897663116455,
-0.04461588338017464,
0.09689946472644806,
0.04835384711623192,
-0.5955567955970764,
0.5028786659240723,
-0.2737756371498108,
0.2766587734222412,
0.839554488658905,
0.3093995749950409,
0.2980060875415802,
-0.4871351718902588,
0.7263042330741882,
0.27501943707466125,
0.00942601915448904,
-0.3712005317211151,
-0.36565259099006653,
-0.8179136514663696,
0.16919425129890442,
0.13765127956867218,
0.48081880807876587,
-1.0615229606628418,
0.3793726861476898,
-0.3495534658432007,
-0.1735333949327469,
-0.2456735521554947,
-0.052536994218826294,
0.153618723154068,
0.44447919726371765,
0.0851898118853569,
-0.5340825319290161,
-0.4910260736942291,
-0.626189112663269,
0.25748249888420105,
-0.3446887731552124,
-0.1550220400094986,
0.9588342905044556,
0.2751694619655609,
-0.3320932984352112,
1.207017421722412,
-0.6219691038131714,
-0.07330354303121567,
-0.0469420850276947,
0.12475891411304474,
-0.06009020656347275,
0.4656763970851898,
0.5863989591598511,
-0.6263917088508606,
-0.578131914138794,
0.5695146322250366,
-0.8628467917442322,
0.10213509947061539,
-0.2246871292591095,
0.0026656892150640488,
0.44559383392333984,
0.3188626766204834,
-0.711076557636261,
0.4266975522041321,
0.46864640712738037,
-0.3964933156967163,
0.424590528011322,
-0.2895318269729614,
-0.01807369850575924,
-0.9250503778457642,
0.043582383543252945,
-0.12070541828870773,
-0.6669039130210876,
-0.7979148030281067,
-0.29293903708457947,
-0.40230631828308105,
-0.39971116185188293,
-0.2132178694009781,
0.485743910074234,
-0.1134420782327652,
0.0060827285051345825,
-0.25035372376441956,
0.10252630710601807,
-0.23885765671730042,
1.0537784099578857,
0.20085927844047546,
0.8838050961494446,
0.5888223052024841,
-0.7737191319465637,
0.207362100481987,
0.3595402240753174,
-0.048874225467443466,
0.7260801792144775,
-0.5302249789237976,
0.4412940442562103,
-0.24820147454738617,
0.38789597153663635,
-0.8020483255386353,
-0.4307517409324646,
0.4213235676288605,
-0.7348744869232178,
-0.08568131923675537,
-0.22105783224105835,
-0.07356812804937363,
0.017029615119099617,
0.013435698114335537,
0.2873438000679016,
0.6153334975242615,
-0.46717017889022827,
0.45884406566619873,
0.44868460297584534,
-0.3111308217048645,
-0.013022586703300476,
0.0052474429830908775,
0.08324916660785675,
-0.1513795554637909,
-0.3240464925765991,
-0.10803937911987305,
-0.3092634975910187,
0.01932714506983757,
0.05667256563901901,
-0.20631013810634613,
-0.3741479814052582,
0.23003534972667694,
0.39025431871414185,
0.32557129859924316,
-0.4140552580356598,
0.13846507668495178,
-0.0930604338645935,
0.0546610951423645,
-0.008502614684402943,
-0.5360645055770874,
0.39377346634864807,
0.09250862896442413,
-0.12970049679279327,
-0.4759993851184845,
0.18138116598129272,
0.6097820401191711,
0.21482066810131073,
0.18780438601970673,
-0.032983243465423584,
-0.2255043238401413,
-0.4371182322502136,
-0.15478496253490448,
-0.077742800116539,
-0.520864725112915,
0.06384459882974625,
-0.24585933983325958,
-1.041593074798584,
0.08600369095802307,
-0.12113173305988312,
0.252755731344223,
0.17609846591949463,
0.5275510549545288,
-0.0559183694422245,
1.440085768699646,
0.6306469440460205,
-0.014128136448562145,
0.4758155941963196,
-0.013814409263432026,
0.31580206751823425,
-0.4447495937347412,
-0.11808838695287704,
-0.448085755109787,
0.0592556856572628,
-0.8503119349479675,
-0.5588635206222534,
0.6150066256523132,
-0.28498566150665283,
-0.21673624217510223,
0.3790070712566376,
-0.6180512309074402,
0.18391956388950348,
0.5773506164550781,
0.08154138177633286,
0.4055004119873047,
0.3231666386127472,
0.03796796873211861,
0.07346920669078827,
-0.8229171633720398,
-0.4873674511909485,
1.1896653175354004,
0.2178449183702469,
0.6053550243377686,
-0.10663493722677231,
0.2828834652900696,
0.708784282207489,
0.31317025423049927,
-0.7969346046447754,
0.4637886583805084,
0.22309944033622742,
-0.5313604474067688,
-0.42451587319374084,
-0.723061740398407,
-1.40135657787323,
0.294845849275589,
0.0946226716041565,
-0.9473966956138611,
0.07651792466640472,
0.3479350209236145,
-0.4140273928642273,
0.21026836335659027,
-0.6465714573860168,
0.6351742148399353,
-0.10016486048698425,
0.026138195767998695,
-0.17003774642944336,
-0.3053704798221588,
0.15973614156246185,
-0.21785786747932434,
-0.005832761060446501,
-0.21955673396587372,
0.3363685607910156,
0.7808645367622375,
-0.34905245900154114,
0.896062433719635,
-0.5528889298439026,
0.018438655883073807,
0.48304668068885803,
0.5382593870162964,
0.5331292748451233,
-0.06501168012619019,
0.31689560413360596,
-0.1619626134634018,
0.2251071333885193,
-0.6551093459129333,
-0.741184651851654,
0.6475763916969299,
-0.9562753438949585,
-0.535564124584198,
-0.47792065143585205,
-0.6917688846588135,
-0.610945463180542,
0.13423271477222443,
-0.4311792552471161,
0.305325984954834,
-0.47866013646125793,
0.2694571614265442,
0.7424994707107544,
-0.4445652663707733,
0.16249074041843414,
0.8861724138259888,
-0.2679920792579651,
-0.17294546961784363,
1.1397439241409302,
-0.03907252475619316,
0.2938445806503296,
0.17099568247795105,
-0.06247562915086746,
-0.028076736256480217,
-0.4564174711704254,
-0.5917503237724304,
-0.15882255136966705,
-0.15320205688476562,
-0.18710650503635406,
-0.7572864294052124,
-0.48657453060150146,
-0.21461926400661469,
-0.12535357475280762,
-0.1865323930978775,
-0.2912527918815613,
-0.1571062058210373,
-0.12313719838857651,
0.5610839128494263,
0.9784478545188904,
0.2694358825683594,
0.48640885949134827,
-0.4704417586326599,
0.07435246556997299,
0.5321850180625916,
0.25456658005714417,
0.0796174630522728,
-0.2970561385154724,
-0.2907992899417877,
0.43320944905281067,
-0.6902746558189392,
-0.4366310238838196,
0.5966635942459106,
0.10730040818452835,
0.19325962662696838,
0.28405043482780457,
0.06611815840005875,
0.47105684876441956,
-0.42673447728157043,
0.8091566562652588,
0.11738452315330505,
-0.6868930459022522,
0.46516913175582886,
-0.788320779800415,
0.2813277542591095,
0.4714798331260681,
0.3510267436504364,
-0.8301060795783997,
-0.2304602861404419,
-0.9021867513656616,
-0.41398128867149353,
1.1242880821228027,
0.3901711702346802,
0.2916461229324341,
0.15935032069683075,
0.18101349472999573,
0.11114836484193802,
0.33064544200897217,
-0.24232591688632965,
0.038126882165670395,
-0.14628471434116364,
-0.1601617932319641,
-0.07852241396903992,
0.20994362235069275,
-0.11906875669956207,
-0.12535104155540466,
0.6946254372596741,
-0.572356104850769,
0.4078759253025055,
0.2487010955810547,
0.102261982858181,
-0.4576231837272644,
0.13213473558425903,
0.23785094916820526,
0.5435474514961243,
-0.4708215594291687,
0.009142939932644367,
-0.015256110578775406,
-0.16048213839530945,
0.29192641377449036,
-0.3057712912559509,
-0.4336732029914856,
0.16921910643577576,
-0.043786969035863876,
1.071519374847412,
0.07196741551160812,
-1.036159634590149,
0.48541995882987976,
-0.1716623306274414,
-0.4719959795475006,
-0.2787644863128662,
0.2695501744747162,
-0.1926354467868805,
0.05257999524474144,
0.2726113796234131,
0.17661674320697784,
-0.1285797506570816,
-0.7093250155448914,
0.42284277081489563,
0.5573572516441345,
-0.6399697065353394,
-0.7130875587463379,
0.5008245706558228,
0.33524972200393677,
-0.4899883270263672,
0.6971712112426758,
-0.19542808830738068,
-0.3004198968410492,
0.48675355315208435,
0.40579289197921753,
0.7099661231040955,
-0.1639222353696823,
0.7504352927207947,
0.1601451188325882,
-0.04825799539685249,
0.36412742733955383,
0.009303520433604717,
-0.42651429772377014,
-1.0231263637542725,
-0.15235333144664764,
-0.3201497793197632,
-0.7075004577636719,
0.3577337861061096,
-0.4704531133174896,
-0.24088555574417114,
-0.6675413846969604,
-0.06907056272029877,
0.0789920911192894,
0.12761646509170532,
-0.829157829284668,
0.36879754066467285,
-0.07391458004713058,
0.6445714831352234,
-0.7709293365478516,
0.8871166706085205,
0.2966408431529999,
-0.07783713936805725,
-0.5967752933502197,
0.002105176681652665,
-0.05912282317876816,
-0.949508786201477,
0.30363932251930237,
-0.1787823587656021,
0.12407330423593521,
-0.12931576371192932,
-0.6604958176612854,
-0.9337120652198792,
1.0178741216659546,
0.2412981390953064,
-0.38608840107917786,
-0.27949294447898865,
0.16901297867298126,
0.7704867124557495,
-0.5768612027168274,
0.2566169798374176,
0.770293653011322,
0.18334083259105682,
0.2620037794113159,
-0.9920693039894104,
-0.07780482620000839,
-0.2972296178340912,
0.026440419256687164,
0.05152967944741249,
-0.4748585522174835,
0.610159158706665,
0.19006697833538055,
-0.4221862852573395,
-0.016321953386068344,
0.29091331362724304,
0.08366110175848007,
0.35519659519195557,
0.6329949498176575,
0.2759297490119934,
0.8951047658920288,
0.07215409725904465,
1.0580720901489258,
-0.37374210357666016,
0.32194262742996216,
1.2151246070861816,
-0.4798562228679657,
0.4838232100009918,
0.24865394830703735,
-0.1768147200345993,
0.3856179416179657,
0.6976329684257507,
0.263451486825943,
0.43170830607414246,
0.07948286086320877,
-0.4098641276359558,
-0.2527039051055908,
-0.6559701561927795,
0.0019246120937168598,
0.27303197979927063,
0.34390297532081604,
-0.2248828113079071,
-0.4329216182231903,
-0.08407104760408401,
0.11221016198396683,
-0.2554026246070862,
-0.04660278931260109,
1.1188138723373413,
-0.22382639348506927,
-0.8754904270172119,
0.9221773147583008,
-0.12234736979007721,
0.18292805552482605,
-0.6238265037536621,
-0.21130479872226715,
-0.17275576293468475,
-0.06611277163028717,
-0.0687083974480629,
-0.3954602777957916,
0.14981094002723694,
0.01622043550014496,
0.07587779313325882,
-0.351762592792511,
0.4802687168121338,
-0.40625903010368347,
-0.2432018220424652,
0.12204068154096603,
0.7586629986763,
0.34067103266716003,
-0.019353413954377174,
-0.5611533522605896,
-0.05951995030045509,
0.413131445646286,
-0.22673015296459198,
0.44309109449386597,
0.39006978273391724,
-0.3999316990375519,
0.6913970708847046,
0.7792226076126099,
0.06665370613336563,
0.11759840697050095,
-0.2748419940471649,
0.9744409322738647,
-0.6298224329948425,
-0.3121732771396637,
-0.1428457796573639,
0.09340064972639084,
0.007496022153645754,
-0.15153557062149048,
0.46894097328186035,
0.5180994868278503,
0.8889060616493225,
0.0405789352953434,
1.2320069074630737,
-0.18945768475532532,
0.6061004400253296,
-0.27216145396232605,
0.2835529148578644,
-0.3626793920993805,
-0.04743003845214844,
0.18272089958190918,
-0.7531942129135132,
0.08615725487470627,
0.3282880187034607,
-0.07001699507236481,
0.025221770629286766,
0.547057569026947,
1.1260520219802856,
-0.15403980016708374,
0.1369333416223526,
0.5119338035583496,
0.3852618634700775,
0.5386594533920288,
0.7702733874320984,
0.744110107421875,
-0.22240713238716125,
0.37785202264785767,
0.12428075820207596,
-0.14982634782791138,
-0.3104735016822815,
-0.2960398495197296,
-0.7523249983787537,
-0.5850533246994019,
-0.2608664631843567,
-0.27400603890419006,
0.2114354521036148,
1.0941942930221558,
1.0793652534484863,
-1.007940411567688,
-0.3205453157424927,
-0.36158066987991333,
0.0973573699593544,
-0.045454639941453934,
-0.28336766362190247,
0.19414088129997253,
-0.39551159739494324,
-0.6540355682373047,
0.7354878783226013,
0.2137291580438614,
0.12238069623708725,
-0.30666273832321167,
-0.27573609352111816,
0.18216705322265625,
0.44677048921585083,
0.5172332525253296,
0.5485950112342834,
-0.5914477109909058,
-0.5922704339027405,
-0.11668545007705688,
-0.042463768273591995,
0.42007556557655334,
1.1128848791122437,
-1.0158586502075195,
0.7547619938850403,
0.1512218862771988,
0.8232557773590088,
0.6115815043449402,
0.20414000749588013,
0.7215074896812439,
-0.6340603828430176,
-0.13387148082256317,
0.25247320532798767,
-0.155458003282547,
0.2601926028728485,
-0.44886651635169983,
0.4797477424144745,
0.2349376678466797,
-0.5249735116958618,
-0.6053340435028076,
0.06353174895048141,
-1.2050724029541016,
-0.15999990701675415,
0.8150506615638733,
-0.035436153411865234,
-0.2878182530403137,
-0.37519142031669617,
-0.503193736076355,
-0.023095393553376198,
-0.8484936952590942,
0.8480784296989441,
0.3809920847415924,
-0.37920495867729187,
0.1108337938785553,
-0.6647955179214478,
0.6839228868484497,
0.2735266387462616,
-0.847281277179718,
0.34588906168937683,
0.6408368945121765,
0.4165191054344177,
0.10953319817781448,
1.0696983337402344,
0.15858906507492065,
0.31251630187034607,
-0.03025807999074459,
-0.0682452991604805,
0.1612677127122879,
-0.3736567497253418,
-0.29417499899864197,
0.17342911660671234,
0.10909593850374222,
-0.1393740475177765
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17564v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17564v1
|
Task-Oriented Paraphrase Analytics
| 2024-03-26T10:14:12 | 2024-03-26T10:14:12 |
Marcel Gohsen, Matthias Hagen, Martin Potthast, Benno Stein
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Since paraphrasing is an ill-defined task, the term "paraphrasing" covers
text transformation tasks with different characteristics. Consequently,
existing paraphrasing studies have applied quite different (explicit and
implicit) criteria as to when a pair of texts is to be considered a paraphrase,
all of which amount to postulating a certain level of semantic or lexical
similarity. In this paper, we conduct a literature review and propose a
taxonomy to organize the 25~identified paraphrasing (sub-)tasks. Using
classifiers trained to identify the tasks that a given paraphrasing instance
fits, we find that the distributions of task-specific instances in the known
paraphrase corpora vary substantially. This means that the use of these
corpora, without the respective paraphrase conditions being clearly defined
(which is the normal case), must lead to incomparable and misleading results.
|
[
-0.013754135929048061,
-0.6769760251045227,
0.6978043913841248,
0.44519832730293274,
-0.32412266731262207,
-0.14971882104873657,
0.13981451094150543,
-0.1823953539133072,
0.14872729778289795,
0.7422758936882019,
-0.49116194248199463,
-0.6640592813491821,
-0.6275435090065002,
0.3845336139202118,
-0.8848891854286194,
1.2543416023254395,
-0.18033425509929657,
-0.05370129272341728,
-0.5365524291992188,
-0.2990145683288574,
-0.3885033130645752,
-0.4889168441295624,
-0.13091039657592773,
-0.08127392828464508,
0.4979530870914459,
0.39707231521606445,
0.5751612782478333,
0.462107390165329,
0.8265361785888672,
0.32120129466056824,
-0.002813940169289708,
-0.10023977607488632,
-0.11776639521121979,
0.22696024179458618,
-0.5738638043403625,
-0.651006817817688,
-0.37638452649116516,
-0.17247548699378967,
0.29679742455482483,
0.7406580448150635,
-0.009822855703532696,
0.48788386583328247,
0.3731788396835327,
0.29089483618736267,
-0.7387694716453552,
0.2614682614803314,
-0.6589398384094238,
-0.030840083956718445,
-0.2347528338432312,
-0.5970948934555054,
-0.17858317494392395,
-0.13131296634674072,
0.278004914522171,
-0.6098100543022156,
0.6147985458374023,
0.15443795919418335,
0.44615647196769714,
0.06886257976293564,
-0.023127596825361252,
-0.6601961851119995,
-0.43121248483657837,
0.9667631387710571,
-0.5705405473709106,
-0.16474993526935577,
0.3215627074241638,
-0.06004280224442482,
0.38419604301452637,
-0.8962906002998352,
-0.25813332200050354,
0.07680414617061615,
-0.43445447087287903,
-0.1069624274969101,
-0.2033977061510086,
-0.009354778565466404,
0.05398242548108101,
0.17755569517612457,
-0.5744836926460266,
-0.23642748594284058,
-0.3625769317150116,
-0.14096295833587646,
0.3715774118900299,
0.44846221804618835,
0.4095766544342041,
-0.3491919934749603,
-0.37597858905792236,
0.1087644025683403,
-0.3416672945022583,
0.05566202476620674,
0.10096866637468338,
0.3000164330005646,
0.35135746002197266,
0.6240134835243225,
-0.44215619564056396,
0.33346691727638245,
-0.04968275874853134,
-0.2957567572593689,
0.3599899411201477,
-0.446149617433548,
-0.43219590187072754,
0.12476947158575058,
0.5875826478004456,
0.33827537298202515,
0.058084920048713684,
-0.46524670720100403,
-0.32276979088783264,
0.0564568005502224,
0.5312076210975647,
-0.28270187973976135,
-0.22179099917411804,
0.005010524298995733,
-0.5724166035652161,
-0.3094092607498169,
-0.07537844032049179,
-0.9490668773651123,
-0.32697969675064087,
-0.5804764628410339,
0.7030287384986877,
-0.5225558280944824,
0.03237263485789299,
-0.29012152552604675,
-0.3554025888442993,
0.10437062382698059,
-0.03544670343399048,
-0.6614927053451538,
0.5792937874794006,
0.8357245326042175,
0.8561093807220459,
-0.573635458946228,
-0.6141585111618042,
-0.2080736607313156,
0.12693428993225098,
-0.2984250485897064,
0.9750508666038513,
-0.6643531322479248,
-0.32356739044189453,
-0.0026842618826776743,
0.20405879616737366,
-0.5124154686927795,
-0.5650948286056519,
0.7573937177658081,
-0.21433234214782715,
0.22723020613193512,
-0.3481161594390869,
-0.5090509653091431,
-0.30946677923202515,
0.12961158156394958,
-0.22862300276756287,
0.8798014521598816,
0.16546398401260376,
-0.9099289178848267,
0.23445148766040802,
-0.36749714612960815,
-0.46079951524734497,
0.1750556379556656,
-0.14117074012756348,
-0.25060153007507324,
0.17619465291500092,
0.16955368220806122,
0.6322086453437805,
-0.5722063779830933,
0.22774672508239746,
0.043601565062999725,
-0.3660614490509033,
0.04632096737623215,
0.08844370394945145,
0.7556432485580444,
0.32434162497520447,
-0.5340403914451599,
0.35388094186782837,
-0.5824404358863831,
0.010143007151782513,
-0.2412329465150833,
0.24698187410831451,
-1.0143119096755981,
0.016773393377661705,
0.15275444090366364,
0.06365501880645752,
0.48274344205856323,
-0.5476000905036926,
-0.2517480254173279,
-0.12941701710224152,
0.3969966471195221,
0.2968319356441498,
0.4575430750846863,
0.5538881421089172,
-0.4872807562351227,
0.6340593099594116,
-0.09228246659040451,
0.2457878291606903,
0.11885188519954681,
-0.3774018883705139,
-0.47237536311149597,
-0.08984173834323883,
0.03637965768575668,
0.7432726621627808,
-0.7138417363166809,
0.2054734081029892,
-0.513752281665802,
-0.8015555143356323,
-0.4458066523075104,
0.2605994939804077,
0.6427101492881775,
0.6792737245559692,
0.7380282878875732,
0.02040955424308777,
-0.4640994668006897,
-1.0106008052825928,
-0.5656599998474121,
0.029292849823832512,
0.060821566730737686,
-0.3194548487663269,
0.5226817727088928,
0.12719136476516724,
0.5738343596458435,
-0.33271974325180054,
-0.6467097997665405,
-0.46114709973335266,
0.37911051511764526,
-0.08426624536514282,
0.40459144115448,
0.7094414234161377,
-1.0010722875595093,
-0.6413480043411255,
-0.00014665645721834153,
-0.895132303237915,
-0.30231428146362305,
-0.2741650640964508,
-0.03871218487620354,
-0.18151775002479553,
1.035549521446228,
-0.5006228685379028,
0.23374420404434204,
0.2616006135940552,
-0.2927579879760742,
0.4098251461982727,
-0.22799864411354065,
0.22750523686408997,
-1.0251516103744507,
0.17603996396064758,
0.023669183254241943,
0.22800543904304504,
-0.5047367215156555,
0.1800432652235031,
0.14606237411499023,
0.05077335238456726,
-0.2860525846481323,
0.04315458983182907,
-0.4544367790222168,
-0.1355835199356079,
-0.3814164698123932,
0.013514785096049309,
-0.2646488845348358,
0.6264625787734985,
0.09833092987537384,
0.38637104630470276,
0.77107834815979,
-0.685018002986908,
0.3915933072566986,
0.3475782871246338,
-0.5250899195671082,
0.8649592995643616,
-0.5199776887893677,
-0.12369490414857864,
-0.299987256526947,
-0.06959203630685806,
-0.974094569683075,
0.018961936235427856,
0.15166394412517548,
-0.2770404517650604,
-0.11713100224733353,
0.11135919392108917,
-0.5094652771949768,
0.22567710280418396,
-0.14057013392448425,
0.33031725883483887,
0.47641676664352417,
0.027040190994739532,
0.45924004912376404,
0.16421209275722504,
-0.5980716943740845,
-0.4142138659954071,
-0.5960990786552429,
0.2805636525154114,
-0.8134660124778748,
0.16858966648578644,
0.7181781530380249,
0.2549881041049957,
-0.4354613423347473,
0.3229551613330841,
-0.23334816098213196,
-0.1754196435213089,
-0.16363810002803802,
0.26931214332580566,
-0.003650364000350237,
0.011944079771637917,
0.071845643222332,
0.08294221013784409,
0.22105318307876587,
0.15791380405426025,
-0.08237981796264648,
0.2948152720928192,
0.45670440793037415,
-0.10710293054580688,
-0.36507126688957214,
0.7194510698318481,
0.6730691194534302,
-0.2512068450450897,
0.44003817439079285,
0.5006483197212219,
-0.17793844640254974,
-0.07963663339614868,
-0.2868882715702057,
0.27532723546028137,
-0.38252028822898865,
0.3080272674560547,
-0.6334875226020813,
-0.23697656393051147,
0.41927799582481384,
0.29869383573532104,
0.4024546444416046,
0.6489713191986084,
0.371162086725235,
-0.18502818048000336,
0.7656130790710449,
0.529995858669281,
0.22312018275260925,
0.31873413920402527,
0.11482061445713043,
-0.08829624205827713,
-0.7523053884506226,
-0.44517776370048523,
-0.7364639043807983,
-0.40470656752586365,
-0.7095614075660706,
-0.23288266360759735,
0.2885536849498749,
-0.30163276195526123,
-0.016059324145317078,
0.810597836971283,
-0.5155649781227112,
0.10953433811664581,
0.5691729784011841,
-0.10965809226036072,
0.10538928955793381,
0.12133240699768066,
0.1053372323513031,
-0.015046491287648678,
-0.5590842962265015,
-0.5154331922531128,
0.9829212427139282,
-0.14862675964832306,
0.4071803092956543,
-0.032895296812057495,
0.9303125739097595,
0.5220048427581787,
0.30724260210990906,
-0.6878055930137634,
0.9329326748847961,
-0.29784566164016724,
-0.5416472554206848,
-0.2693048417568207,
-0.27864471077919006,
-1.1590265035629272,
0.26426392793655396,
0.03066316992044449,
-0.7208791375160217,
0.19043901562690735,
-0.18166102468967438,
-0.03330036997795105,
-0.05959274619817734,
-0.5278823971748352,
0.8923842310905457,
0.003692374564707279,
0.1279909461736679,
-0.16431808471679688,
-0.6776543855667114,
0.004349865019321442,
-0.1307920664548874,
0.36768093705177307,
-0.12056581676006317,
-0.23415200412273407,
1.1606559753417969,
-0.18751664459705353,
0.6420629024505615,
-0.2635357081890106,
0.18058881163597107,
0.5710982084274292,
0.2260575294494629,
0.17975103855133057,
-0.4786151349544525,
-0.005380347371101379,
-0.21095749735832214,
0.7315526604652405,
-0.6090333461761475,
-0.5849358439445496,
0.6211632490158081,
-0.3014080226421356,
-0.5993701219558716,
-0.4994710683822632,
-0.682709813117981,
-0.5526819229125977,
0.12261716276407242,
0.5600775480270386,
0.4130660593509674,
-0.042776089161634445,
0.43227246403694153,
0.3851950764656067,
0.17520859837532043,
0.33625730872154236,
0.20417918264865875,
0.2472204566001892,
0.038629062473773956,
1.002489447593689,
0.15070651471614838,
0.2197347730398178,
0.8822782635688782,
0.09074266254901886,
-0.11077981442213058,
-0.8921194076538086,
0.22638309001922607,
0.13312286138534546,
-0.8763545751571655,
-0.061173614114522934,
-0.5518486499786377,
0.19401201605796814,
-0.7997506260871887,
0.014392172917723656,
0.21031568944454193,
-0.17830511927604675,
-0.3282444477081299,
0.03986018896102905,
0.1282762885093689,
0.4530387222766876,
0.4803730547428131,
0.20742209255695343,
-0.7873347997665405,
0.3281712532043457,
0.18801335990428925,
-0.2416875809431076,
-0.08472266793251038,
-0.7112407088279724,
-0.03857792168855667,
-0.27827003598213196,
-0.10981344431638718,
-0.9547134041786194,
0.5975565314292908,
0.27108854055404663,
0.7861073017120361,
0.07135098427534103,
0.2859002649784088,
0.7109899520874023,
-0.4471525251865387,
0.6967405080795288,
0.12969952821731567,
-0.9395714998245239,
0.31893253326416016,
-0.26048544049263,
0.31121885776519775,
0.6838658452033997,
0.7091431617736816,
-0.31068941950798035,
-0.6783662438392639,
-0.7358900308609009,
-0.9881477355957031,
0.5130599737167358,
0.33405062556266785,
0.24694441258907318,
-0.12279011309146881,
0.2222163826227188,
0.4634385406970978,
0.27074718475341797,
-0.5397704243659973,
-0.11147575080394745,
-0.057639915496110916,
-0.5630082488059998,
-0.4318675398826599,
-0.15759961307048798,
-0.16420194506645203,
-0.12465450912714005,
0.3817344605922699,
0.03119516931474209,
0.2525268495082855,
0.3362250328063965,
-0.3908814787864685,
0.3375856578350067,
0.4674775302410126,
0.21192996203899384,
0.9134871959686279,
-0.012759028002619743,
0.4692225456237793,
0.1561078429222107,
-0.43590161204338074,
0.07439263164997101,
0.012359924614429474,
-0.05137399584054947,
0.30494430661201477,
0.6615325212478638,
0.5343008637428284,
0.5237128138542175,
-0.8954210877418518,
0.31564635038375854,
0.43010449409484863,
-0.47252827882766724,
-0.05177706107497215,
0.06570985168218613,
-0.053943004459142685,
0.2751980721950531,
0.5379452705383301,
-0.09964627027511597,
0.5134115815162659,
-0.8380576372146606,
0.03561495617032051,
0.11021776497364044,
-0.38737723231315613,
-0.4030771553516388,
0.39561375975608826,
-0.036146607249975204,
-0.3383897840976715,
0.17095164954662323,
-0.14999043941497803,
-0.2598634660243988,
0.41284945607185364,
0.37054741382598877,
0.9027292132377625,
-0.19394297897815704,
0.2635088860988617,
0.039877839386463165,
0.20026960968971252,
-0.26004931330680847,
0.12964659929275513,
-0.3314264416694641,
-0.34350350499153137,
-0.10388772189617157,
-0.7826719880104065,
-0.27193117141723633,
0.15445448458194733,
-0.997668981552124,
0.10199400782585144,
-0.029749330133199692,
0.11486665904521942,
0.5225755572319031,
-0.5070323348045349,
-0.5026004314422607,
0.46629270911216736,
-0.2001739740371704,
0.4827655851840973,
-0.7267783284187317,
0.6642846465110779,
1.0962785482406616,
-0.20254597067832947,
-0.24898146092891693,
0.3214423954486847,
-0.20816676318645477,
-0.5899344086647034,
0.7018610239028931,
-0.1597580462694168,
-0.054027169942855835,
-0.043296296149492264,
-0.09446565061807632,
-0.6776440739631653,
1.107413411140442,
-0.03425467759370804,
-0.24375464022159576,
-0.6501400470733643,
0.2507375478744507,
0.7671414613723755,
-0.3591187298297882,
-0.27461448311805725,
0.472676545381546,
0.11647899448871613,
-0.26894018054008484,
-1.1614162921905518,
0.11680004745721817,
-0.005249088164418936,
0.1324535608291626,
0.13673430681228638,
-0.14063437283039093,
0.9627309441566467,
0.37722504138946533,
-0.03390489146113396,
0.13280200958251953,
0.6070622205734253,
-0.3170994222164154,
0.6446806788444519,
0.5952156186103821,
0.14827707409858704,
0.2365795224905014,
0.23620213568210602,
0.7835710644721985,
-0.039882298558950424,
0.40033042430877686,
1.0238248109817505,
-0.014798687770962715,
0.6646342873573303,
0.6459843516349792,
-0.13260024785995483,
0.32385963201522827,
0.3554987609386444,
0.06713740527629852,
0.8159838318824768,
-0.18228155374526978,
-0.012709666974842548,
-0.22986775636672974,
0.05798114836215973,
0.09172551333904266,
0.5734702944755554,
0.5551226735115051,
-0.7288608551025391,
-0.5047462582588196,
0.33813193440437317,
-0.15321865677833557,
0.39719051122665405,
-0.6430371999740601,
0.8901481628417969,
0.006100332830101252,
-1.2193599939346313,
0.4969898760318756,
0.0501277856528759,
0.6091027855873108,
-0.47536078095436096,
0.19957184791564941,
-0.021689513698220253,
0.12713027000427246,
-0.4941085875034332,
-0.9003840684890747,
0.7166645526885986,
0.08974570035934448,
0.03914180397987366,
-0.6627504825592041,
0.4511365592479706,
-0.18896397948265076,
-0.34544339776039124,
0.23388969898223877,
0.7618077397346497,
0.30272960662841797,
-0.17002901434898376,
-0.5640667676925659,
-0.3131362199783325,
0.09430237114429474,
-0.1511407345533371,
0.6207445859909058,
0.6509557962417603,
-0.31326529383659363,
0.3186243772506714,
0.1370755434036255,
-0.15970613062381744,
0.08993840962648392,
-0.2966601848602295,
0.24512992799282074,
-0.640379786491394,
-0.6280984878540039,
-0.8719685077667236,
-0.012139063328504562,
0.005434728227555752,
-0.5445951223373413,
1.101441740989685,
0.41186419129371643,
0.4872460663318634,
-0.25358903408050537,
0.791045069694519,
-0.34259647130966187,
0.7562808990478516,
-0.35319069027900696,
0.21154241263866425,
-0.4994922876358032,
-0.0401015467941761,
-0.5706278681755066,
-1.0235216617584229,
0.0034629821311682463,
0.3327319025993347,
-0.4350363314151764,
-0.4825856387615204,
0.9499508738517761,
0.4562283158302307,
-0.23544830083847046,
0.05929487571120262,
0.29734084010124207,
-0.29999953508377075,
-0.0684606060385704,
0.30381935834884644,
0.3752947747707367,
-0.21979159116744995,
1.0421642065048218,
-0.2700986862182617,
-0.10121485590934753,
-0.18095292150974274,
-0.4515012800693512,
-0.6729624271392822,
-1.0960489511489868,
-0.6696277260780334,
-0.03314042463898659,
0.11558284610509872,
0.43106725811958313,
0.2373756468296051,
-0.7905775904655457,
-0.2769523859024048,
-0.6601473093032837,
-0.10623735934495926,
-0.906451404094696,
-0.2959219813346863,
0.3815189003944397,
-0.7707479596138,
-0.9656487703323364,
0.12987710535526276,
0.021494632586836815,
-0.3014770448207855,
-0.0012833261862397194,
0.6075940728187561,
-0.2512407600879669,
0.20254136621952057,
0.46161192655563354,
0.22532090544700623,
-0.5735871195793152,
-0.253406286239624,
0.1632382571697235,
-0.12793606519699097,
-0.16210933029651642,
1.0227952003479004,
-0.41632214188575745,
0.07928426563739777,
0.7612086534500122,
0.5050524473190308,
0.38330793380737305,
-0.0028682048432528973,
0.1694546788930893,
-0.7694409489631653,
-0.05919133871793747,
0.4676385819911957,
0.18537463247776031,
0.13060078024864197,
-0.047500334680080414,
0.23415441811084747,
0.33413466811180115,
-0.48586776852607727,
-0.9107418060302734,
0.11188139021396637,
-0.9487833380699158,
-0.63033527135849,
1.3776241540908813,
-0.4101816713809967,
-0.21048854291439056,
-0.35240721702575684,
-0.17874735593795776,
0.21570618450641632,
0.04486444965004921,
0.7043659687042236,
0.7929875254631042,
-0.5933578610420227,
0.1765175610780716,
-0.5200362205505371,
0.6248582601547241,
0.6221242547035217,
-0.8088672161102295,
0.08841139823198318,
0.12788020074367523,
0.6128796339035034,
0.5478691458702087,
0.197234109044075,
-0.16357280313968658,
0.20564575493335724,
0.06952141225337982,
-0.21399228274822235,
0.21222561597824097,
-0.06537511944770813,
0.019140547141432762,
0.6944983601570129,
-0.15931543707847595,
-0.4023822546005249
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17556v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17556v1
|
m3P: Towards Multimodal Multilingual Translation with Multimodal Prompt
| 2024-03-26T10:04:24 | 2024-03-26T10:04:24 |
Jian Yang, Hongcheng Guo, Yuwei Yin, Jiaqi Bai, Bing Wang, Jiaheng Liu, Xinnian Liang, Linzheng Cahi, Liqun Yang, Zhoujun Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Multilingual translation supports multiple translation directions by
projecting all languages in a shared space, but the translation quality is
undermined by the difference between languages in the text-only modality,
especially when the number of languages is large. To bridge this gap, we
introduce visual context as the universal language-independent representation
to facilitate multilingual translation. In this paper, we propose a framework
to leverage the multimodal prompt to guide the Multimodal Multilingual neural
Machine Translation (m3P), which aligns the representations of different
languages with the same meaning and generates the conditional vision-language
memory for translation. We construct a multilingual multimodal instruction
dataset (InstrMulti102) to support 102 languages. Our method aims to minimize
the representation distance of different languages by regarding the image as a
central language. Experimental results show that m3P outperforms previous
text-only baselines and multilingual multimodal methods by a large margin.
Furthermore, the probing experiments validate the effectiveness of our method
in enhancing translation under the low-resource and massively multilingual
scenario.
|
[
-0.5088709592819214,
-0.36256900429725647,
0.6294730305671692,
0.5162604451179504,
-0.18342486023902893,
-0.31890755891799927,
-0.48284777998924255,
-0.029012983664870262,
0.06212574988603592,
0.14921675622463226,
-0.8045839071273804,
-0.38705289363861084,
-0.643246591091156,
0.3942330479621887,
0.09457210451364517,
0.7230511903762817,
-0.08308088034391403,
0.4527694880962372,
-0.31285175681114197,
-0.5106838345527649,
-0.9162517786026001,
-0.40141311287879944,
-0.541231632232666,
0.008113776333630085,
0.9527367949485779,
0.5137067437171936,
0.559381902217865,
0.39525672793388367,
0.4422101676464081,
0.3277644217014313,
0.1660478562116623,
0.5403193831443787,
0.040956318378448486,
0.1721017211675644,
-0.07577186822891235,
-0.28201359510421753,
-0.1845957636833191,
-0.2814805507659912,
0.8539842963218689,
0.6185442209243774,
0.17324930429458618,
-0.010673781856894493,
0.2351849526166916,
0.5391795635223389,
-0.6356395483016968,
0.33832472562789917,
-0.27612096071243286,
0.22057944536209106,
0.009539580903947353,
-0.4444790780544281,
-0.6282397508621216,
0.08682925999164581,
-0.2986687123775482,
-0.37698832154273987,
-0.26572510600090027,
0.10642306506633759,
0.3619300425052643,
0.3069290220737457,
-0.8804839849472046,
-0.001941316993907094,
-0.2934509217739105,
0.6545417904853821,
-0.27260804176330566,
0.5308251976966858,
0.11530331522226334,
0.5144030451774597,
-0.03205504268407822,
-0.39804211258888245,
-0.636123538017273,
-0.20899175107479095,
-0.14545591175556183,
0.25114840269088745,
-0.06598919630050659,
-0.1469055712223053,
0.20357482135295868,
-0.10370799899101257,
-0.7641294598579407,
-0.026021312922239304,
-0.19181154668331146,
-0.28727999329566956,
0.14426583051681519,
0.1172882691025734,
0.725972592830658,
-0.35490038990974426,
-0.8791082501411438,
-0.39331522583961487,
-0.6273073554039001,
0.26793840527534485,
-0.09545273333787918,
0.3594619929790497,
-0.20026491582393646,
0.603939950466156,
0.07068365812301636,
0.7132682204246521,
-0.37793803215026855,
-0.36198410391807556,
0.28737887740135193,
-0.5641158819198608,
-0.018353773280978203,
0.15885964035987854,
0.9182073473930359,
0.8234509229660034,
-0.014328472316265106,
-0.032517723739147186,
-0.2204677164554596,
0.009436030872166157,
-0.1637277603149414,
-0.8038432598114014,
0.31804075837135315,
0.005187950097024441,
-0.38322722911834717,
0.3135952949523926,
-0.31601792573928833,
-0.5590525269508362,
-0.21148933470249176,
-0.2942080795764923,
0.31726333498954773,
-0.6492350101470947,
-0.2063591033220291,
0.01258570421487093,
-0.06567958742380142,
0.17417021095752716,
0.4003131687641144,
-0.8929452896118164,
-0.3104533553123474,
0.16561338305473328,
0.7783700823783875,
-0.08896729350090027,
-0.7748141884803772,
-0.5218265652656555,
0.36391040682792664,
-0.39655405282974243,
0.5536839365959167,
-0.36072856187820435,
-0.23230326175689697,
-0.03578141704201698,
0.20823147892951965,
-0.23382318019866943,
-0.30634424090385437,
0.3640855550765991,
-0.35934770107269287,
0.47932207584381104,
-0.4982588589191437,
-0.12731294333934784,
-0.5031882524490356,
0.48704293370246887,
-0.4211045801639557,
0.4506114721298218,
-0.12336227297782898,
-0.31896400451660156,
0.3058925271034241,
-0.6351825594902039,
-0.32071807980537415,
0.05920947715640068,
-0.3659190535545349,
0.1255722939968109,
-0.013675621710717678,
0.5755376815795898,
0.43242642283439636,
-0.2015787810087204,
0.29828110337257385,
-0.08713213354349136,
-0.03726038709282875,
0.2979945242404938,
-0.9000895619392395,
0.6241021156311035,
0.34382763504981995,
-0.23451243340969086,
0.2532939910888672,
-0.3343062400817871,
0.06405624747276306,
0.03984706848859787,
-0.2402731329202652,
-0.0678427591919899,
-0.3553600013256073,
0.2877923548221588,
0.7205445766448975,
0.31394529342651367,
-0.33460697531700134,
0.34511637687683105,
0.19460628926753998,
0.03845078498125076,
0.6269689202308655,
-0.22673463821411133,
0.6569743156433105,
-0.10378962755203247,
0.6617021560668945,
0.4163625240325928,
-0.0993184894323349,
-0.8141960501670837,
-0.8125663995742798,
-0.5795623064041138,
-0.43632423877716064,
0.08959696441888809,
0.7694921493530273,
-1.2385720014572144,
-0.09164447337388992,
-0.3486745059490204,
0.2795666456222534,
-0.5736255645751953,
0.31550201773643494,
0.6297851800918579,
0.5457080602645874,
0.5206645727157593,
-0.11166588962078094,
-0.4342572093009949,
-1.0195082426071167,
0.17405372858047485,
0.1008095070719719,
0.022297021001577377,
0.20686854422092438,
0.13039906322956085,
-0.577454149723053,
0.3066900968551636,
-0.07262842357158661,
-0.3924066722393036,
-0.41597387194633484,
0.05336624011397362,
0.33335080742836,
0.6490220427513123,
0.5251330733299255,
-0.9579619765281677,
-0.45905160903930664,
0.15944327414035797,
-1.0142673254013062,
0.017038723453879356,
-0.36202099919319153,
-0.2018606811761856,
0.369999498128891,
0.5400105714797974,
-0.8041062355041504,
0.04243109002709389,
0.7756884694099426,
-0.3051281273365021,
0.1876733899116516,
-0.5987380743026733,
0.6174278259277344,
-1.2679611444473267,
0.14511486887931824,
-0.14229394495487213,
-0.27370598912239075,
-0.3889463245868683,
0.2961080074310303,
0.4257446825504303,
-0.43904685974121094,
-0.7184901833534241,
0.6538260579109192,
-0.5760279893875122,
0.02664117142558098,
-0.14642593264579773,
0.28149497509002686,
0.18042874336242676,
0.6587256789207458,
0.07047631591558456,
0.7354081869125366,
0.565114438533783,
-0.6160811185836792,
0.36938419938087463,
0.23236697912216187,
-0.21959200501441956,
0.76375812292099,
-0.1660359650850296,
-0.1954270452260971,
-0.4138614237308502,
0.2755792438983917,
-1.0112371444702148,
-0.25161904096603394,
0.45760393142700195,
-0.46506065130233765,
0.5080470442771912,
-0.13825182616710663,
-0.5916655659675598,
-0.051253460347652435,
0.04240148514509201,
0.5547482371330261,
0.36341166496276855,
-0.5537393093109131,
0.40099242329597473,
-0.08004830032587051,
-0.2537077069282532,
-0.6066633462905884,
-0.8046725988388062,
0.5400481820106506,
-0.11581915616989136,
-0.9038277268409729,
0.18010586500167847,
-0.3240611255168915,
0.007559850346297026,
-0.17540998756885529,
0.21115396916866302,
0.09689528495073318,
-0.1777692586183548,
0.00890810415148735,
0.29878637194633484,
-0.5027663111686707,
0.24352510273456573,
0.25828272104263306,
-0.5222060084342957,
-0.11698533594608307,
-0.3689046800136566,
0.5093700885772705,
-0.2243650108575821,
-0.4828329086303711,
-0.42565760016441345,
0.7700513601303101,
0.6860056519508362,
-0.4097158908843994,
0.6783232688903809,
0.9865795969963074,
-0.10813412070274353,
0.08793075382709503,
-0.20599541068077087,
-0.07469356060028076,
-0.4336058497428894,
0.3571275472640991,
-0.7354856729507446,
-0.5068159699440002,
0.16196167469024658,
-0.03250911459326744,
-0.07211623340845108,
0.187367245554924,
0.6523397564888,
-0.14624999463558197,
1.4248460531234741,
0.5706900358200073,
0.0885457694530487,
0.31481751799583435,
-0.05810357630252838,
0.13081324100494385,
-0.6968932747840881,
-0.2765001654624939,
-0.10816644877195358,
-0.4814607799053192,
-0.4099261462688446,
-0.6769620776176453,
0.6314221024513245,
0.24908879399299622,
0.2675172686576843,
0.2948431074619293,
-0.23026977479457855,
0.4006902277469635,
0.6680824756622314,
-0.01623397506773472,
0.16533339023590088,
0.11034376919269562,
-0.5906349420547485,
-0.37367621064186096,
-0.8889520168304443,
-0.385263592004776,
0.5544830560684204,
-0.052841637283563614,
0.13332948088645935,
0.4663289487361908,
0.427390456199646,
0.03229663148522377,
0.13200850784778595,
-0.6928049921989441,
0.7088728547096252,
-0.10419369488954544,
-0.3558432161808014,
0.028492087498307228,
-0.4378798007965088,
-0.8198538422584534,
0.7815520167350769,
-0.1664610505104065,
-0.3909067213535309,
0.08749771118164062,
0.20250606536865234,
-0.050611574202775955,
0.11549060046672821,
-0.9017193913459778,
1.2198201417922974,
-0.5493171811103821,
-0.2991275191307068,
-0.14954814314842224,
-0.7557329535484314,
0.30194786190986633,
0.24073602259159088,
0.35871803760528564,
-0.0909731537103653,
-0.23550762236118317,
-0.027140172198414803,
-0.035100486129522324,
0.5270825028419495,
-0.23804830014705658,
-0.0524662509560585,
0.06530925631523132,
0.17471937835216522,
0.2195928990840912,
0.20390048623085022,
0.3499492406845093,
0.01895921677350998,
-0.0561581514775753,
-0.5360413193702698,
-0.6206924915313721,
0.6188243627548218,
-0.4396551847457886,
-0.4491240084171295,
-0.27257415652275085,
-0.8723130226135254,
-0.17025409638881683,
0.4806230962276459,
0.26953619718551636,
0.44948121905326843,
-0.01901952363550663,
0.17314715683460236,
0.6645039319992065,
-0.4884355366230011,
0.8451771140098572,
0.3866691291332245,
-0.6065877676010132,
-0.5269991159439087,
1.0637093782424927,
-0.15654516220092773,
0.1009102538228035,
0.6972764730453491,
0.1494375765323639,
-0.4714902937412262,
-0.18399958312511444,
-1.2749707698822021,
0.004953111056238413,
-0.9618256688117981,
-0.1920132339000702,
-0.6629887819290161,
0.409463495016098,
-0.39646363258361816,
-0.2632167935371399,
-0.1329488605260849,
-0.3336099684238434,
-0.008614975959062576,
0.2561493217945099,
-0.02126478962600231,
0.07138611376285553,
-0.2166459709405899,
0.1051676943898201,
-1.0650607347488403,
0.5232699513435364,
0.37073516845703125,
-0.10342985391616821,
-0.2670310139656067,
-0.3528667092323303,
-0.11516910791397095,
0.24969223141670227,
-0.2074105590581894,
-0.7210698127746582,
0.5419650673866272,
0.24626106023788452,
0.48831644654273987,
0.4472734034061432,
-0.19742630422115326,
0.7397489547729492,
-0.7708790302276611,
0.5864574313163757,
0.6175901889801025,
-0.6831496953964233,
0.37127891182899475,
-0.37489694356918335,
0.7695690989494324,
0.2665223777294159,
0.4724518954753876,
-0.993932843208313,
-0.01336620468646288,
-0.10347440093755722,
-0.6358526349067688,
0.37456366419792175,
-0.14614465832710266,
0.23003678023815155,
-0.05447278916835785,
-0.1836579293012619,
-0.08088289201259613,
0.22353018820285797,
-0.9007582664489746,
-0.17355148494243622,
-0.25546616315841675,
-0.29393577575683594,
-0.42061594128608704,
-0.16618198156356812,
-0.20685093104839325,
-0.08412354439496994,
0.2107865959405899,
-0.47799110412597656,
0.41167593002319336,
0.0005453901248984039,
-0.46890372037887573,
0.19827957451343536,
0.46090152859687805,
0.9907706379890442,
0.5067825317382812,
0.017783040180802345,
0.33920082449913025,
0.016477452591061592,
-0.014478766359388828,
0.29221537709236145,
-0.038092125207185745,
-0.11034346371889114,
0.2006569504737854,
0.33978161215782166,
0.7466992139816284,
0.2320551574230194,
-0.6967843174934387,
0.6774786114692688,
-0.10826293379068375,
0.1017366349697113,
-0.011378751136362553,
-0.2749272882938385,
0.2248152643442154,
0.3398396372795105,
0.22110161185264587,
0.5143222808837891,
0.04616524651646614,
-0.43774616718292236,
0.2947966158390045,
0.3491092920303345,
-0.5287986993789673,
-0.21010521054267883,
0.7230799198150635,
0.09315032511949539,
-0.05769546702504158,
0.5467948317527771,
-0.3786001205444336,
-0.27724218368530273,
0.2368786782026291,
0.7018956542015076,
0.6051023006439209,
-0.2281535118818283,
0.27300578355789185,
0.36257046461105347,
0.4157242774963379,
0.013299571350216866,
0.27232033014297485,
-0.21248988807201385,
-0.6536292433738708,
-0.424478679895401,
-0.3000718355178833,
-0.15565046668052673,
-0.2631101608276367,
-0.44561493396759033,
0.17781300842761993,
-0.15139585733413696,
0.04044764116406441,
-0.3581598401069641,
-0.6048386096954346,
-0.5356309413909912,
0.08395488560199738,
0.596497118473053,
0.6854411363601685,
-0.5669535398483276,
1.012492299079895,
0.7434282302856445,
-0.545512855052948,
-0.324273020029068,
-0.3471547067165375,
0.21860206127166748,
-0.8930575251579285,
0.7860064506530762,
0.5872708559036255,
-0.30294325947761536,
-0.03526584059000015,
-0.2916252613067627,
-0.5699697732925415,
0.9114839434623718,
0.665287971496582,
-0.45315471291542053,
0.26300227642059326,
0.1857028603553772,
0.20387038588523865,
-0.4444170594215393,
-0.022986464202404022,
-0.06406737118959427,
0.6176908016204834,
0.0003555386792868376,
-0.5693888664245605,
0.015848340466618538,
-0.4775545299053192,
0.20336924493312836,
0.12817849218845367,
-0.32425788044929504,
0.7390215396881104,
-0.3733915388584137,
-0.2464827448129654,
0.01360693946480751,
0.6659420728683472,
0.18103863298892975,
0.19364792108535767,
0.24338853359222412,
0.43649354577064514,
0.49523913860321045,
0.013174367137253284,
1.2595207691192627,
-0.5241475701332092,
-0.1587149053812027,
0.968802273273468,
0.04068366065621376,
0.7056429982185364,
0.9273501038551331,
0.3034560978412628,
0.09703584015369415,
0.48856908082962036,
0.274924635887146,
0.7165688872337341,
-0.26599082350730896,
-0.55229252576828,
-0.25913316011428833,
-0.3494011461734772,
-0.47685855627059937,
0.42314374446868896,
0.24505272507667542,
-0.42701730132102966,
-0.21476350724697113,
0.3706035315990448,
0.1907823383808136,
0.042594633996486664,
-0.3270837068557739,
0.5278176069259644,
0.25552114844322205,
-0.8745077848434448,
0.7968319058418274,
0.17509639263153076,
0.650785505771637,
-0.7222304940223694,
-0.2094385325908661,
-0.4398222863674164,
0.34723275899887085,
0.15343540906906128,
-0.6062814593315125,
0.09500741958618164,
-0.38223183155059814,
-0.3092465400695801,
-0.9788141846656799,
0.3337365686893463,
-0.9201435446739197,
-0.5215550661087036,
0.3624660074710846,
0.7321273684501648,
-0.0022264004219323397,
-0.0683605894446373,
-0.7180531620979309,
-0.04561657831072807,
0.1329852193593979,
0.0007599137024953961,
0.5155918002128601,
0.7159242630004883,
0.0004607881710398942,
0.6828063130378723,
0.6715837121009827,
-0.17379280924797058,
0.2691609263420105,
0.15295584499835968,
0.4957524836063385,
-0.49972495436668396,
-0.4891511797904968,
-0.853656530380249,
0.6576778888702393,
0.22108149528503418,
-0.6258935928344727,
0.9506589770317078,
0.3337678611278534,
0.8724708557128906,
-0.25332579016685486,
0.36295124888420105,
-0.027185123413801193,
-0.21259286999702454,
-0.8496825098991394,
0.5877522826194763,
-0.8705580830574036,
-0.07296299189329147,
-0.15735654532909393,
-0.8387995362281799,
-0.5431206822395325,
0.5574955344200134,
0.13564665615558624,
-0.27697667479515076,
0.8808650970458984,
0.9170392751693726,
-0.19934822618961334,
-0.3763864040374756,
0.7208865284919739,
-0.3408987522125244,
0.16623562574386597,
0.5659872889518738,
0.7612608075141907,
-0.3106076121330261,
0.7429100275039673,
-0.15332365036010742,
-0.14702263474464417,
-0.12134121358394623,
-0.8543918132781982,
-0.6231406331062317,
-0.6890215873718262,
-0.01042250543832779,
-0.1972513198852539,
-0.2342488020658493,
0.9963580965995789,
0.5452265739440918,
-0.5523418188095093,
-0.3399392068386078,
0.3119259774684906,
0.1637694239616394,
-0.5038702487945557,
-0.11185744404792786,
-0.06363244354724884,
-0.79353266954422,
-0.7452244162559509,
0.7771626114845276,
0.6521309614181519,
0.11806659400463104,
-0.385999470949173,
-0.36601942777633667,
-0.2587510645389557,
-0.4392074942588806,
0.8418099284172058,
0.08484641462564468,
-0.5935623049736023,
0.07231496274471283,
0.14572998881340027,
-0.4014369249343872,
0.23054252564907074,
0.8391902446746826,
-0.38879650831222534,
0.798588752746582,
0.4254775047302246,
0.8212305903434753,
0.3280026912689209,
-0.4944840669631958,
0.7982816100120544,
-0.8615506887435913,
0.652315616607666,
-0.027688520029187202,
0.7315760850906372,
0.5106988549232483,
-0.05937648192048073,
0.10701240599155426,
0.25507643818855286,
-0.192362979054451,
-0.4043918550014496,
0.4340616762638092,
-0.9503191709518433,
-0.45021235942840576,
0.9798053503036499,
-0.19439469277858734,
-0.26862332224845886,
0.2666836380958557,
-0.41839799284935,
0.00677997013553977,
-0.40714383125305176,
0.3138344883918762,
0.5652283430099487,
0.14214526116847992,
-0.7384206056594849,
-0.7360081076622009,
0.18376193940639496,
0.5188233256340027,
-0.5285108089447021,
-0.32370027899742126,
0.7611237168312073,
-0.2343025952577591,
0.317003458738327,
0.6509028673171997,
-0.019733158871531487,
0.49708208441734314,
0.072130486369133,
0.3784027695655823,
-0.08069909363985062,
-0.6664860844612122,
-0.43459421396255493,
0.05972794443368912,
-0.12297678738832474,
-0.35162490606307983
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17553v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17553v1
|
RuBia: A Russian Language Bias Detection Dataset
| 2024-03-26T10:01:01 | 2024-03-26T10:01:01 |
Veronika Grigoreva, Anastasiia Ivanova, Ilseyar Alimova, Ekaterina Artemova
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Warning: this work contains upsetting or disturbing content.
Large language models (LLMs) tend to learn the social and cultural biases
present in the raw pre-training data. To test if an LLM's behavior is fair,
functional datasets are employed, and due to their purpose, these datasets are
highly language and culture-specific. In this paper, we address a gap in the
scope of multilingual bias evaluation by presenting a bias detection dataset
specifically designed for the Russian language, dubbed as RuBia. The RuBia
dataset is divided into 4 domains: gender, nationality, socio-economic status,
and diverse, each of the domains is further divided into multiple fine-grained
subdomains. Every example in the dataset consists of two sentences with the
first reinforcing a potentially harmful stereotype or trope and the second
contradicting it. These sentence pairs were first written by volunteers and
then validated by native-speaking crowdsourcing workers. Overall, there are
nearly 2,000 unique sentence pairs spread over 19 subdomains in RuBia. To
illustrate the dataset's purpose, we conduct a diagnostic evaluation of
state-of-the-art or near-state-of-the-art LLMs and discuss the LLMs'
predisposition to social biases.
|
[
-0.3146722912788391,
-0.6668745875358582,
0.26435184478759766,
0.48488956689834595,
-0.18940338492393494,
0.07700511813163757,
-0.4886285960674286,
-0.1837916374206543,
0.05126779153943062,
0.39148589968681335,
-0.5332188606262207,
-0.46151018142700195,
-0.6712230443954468,
0.12568901479244232,
-0.23752161860466003,
1.5685596466064453,
-0.0019476317102089524,
0.6533190011978149,
-0.31714364886283875,
-0.12540829181671143,
-0.47923266887664795,
-0.23043347895145416,
-0.08348735421895981,
-0.5353990197181702,
0.29998984932899475,
0.5282329320907593,
0.4825280010700226,
0.4173817038536072,
0.23886269330978394,
0.1331319510936737,
-0.04204288497567177,
0.04122406989336014,
-0.33722442388534546,
0.0941201001405716,
-0.16148224472999573,
-0.4008711874485016,
-0.41740038990974426,
0.14284150302410126,
0.5922555327415466,
0.5191144347190857,
-0.06447820365428925,
0.6578609347343445,
-0.15189871191978455,
0.6085835695266724,
-0.5223976373672485,
-0.1018713116645813,
-0.7002297639846802,
0.1250714361667633,
-0.7304406762123108,
-0.018420783802866936,
-0.3879873752593994,
-0.2435728758573532,
0.05553745850920677,
-0.46739497780799866,
0.28024837374687195,
0.10779546201229095,
0.89799964427948,
-0.03228149935603142,
-0.41227027773857117,
-0.13836760818958282,
-0.3785516321659088,
0.8929941058158875,
-0.37416794896125793,
0.1718626171350479,
0.3848389685153961,
0.2783394455909729,
-0.19497545063495636,
0.008336644619703293,
-0.5998133420944214,
-0.04619979113340378,
0.0019229080062359571,
-0.2990450859069824,
-0.15640908479690552,
-0.5982301831245422,
0.2752467393875122,
0.137471005320549,
-0.8985090255737305,
-0.02913646586239338,
-0.1399013102054596,
-0.38175928592681885,
0.3089025020599365,
-0.016484666615724564,
0.3958641290664673,
-0.04746090620756149,
-0.20012685656547546,
0.0704149454832077,
-0.7812106609344482,
-0.2688235640525818,
0.9839065074920654,
0.4396308660507202,
-0.36756619811058044,
0.14117859303951263,
-0.39263999462127686,
0.6927934885025024,
-0.058073271065950394,
-0.3630727231502533,
0.626173734664917,
-0.0938798040151596,
-0.017162906005978584,
-0.4210573434829712,
0.6128524541854858,
0.17501194775104523,
0.9332462549209595,
-0.05337413772940636,
-0.17504003643989563,
0.31703293323516846,
0.04518977552652359,
-0.3919881284236908,
-0.09053874015808105,
0.08920348435640335,
-0.43922820687294006,
-0.39474034309387207,
-0.5172698497772217,
-1.1031033992767334,
-0.6588900089263916,
-0.23547422885894775,
0.03598359599709511,
-0.09613612294197083,
-0.4188724756240845,
0.11347246915102005,
0.1191277951002121,
0.1352797895669937,
-0.010875489562749863,
-0.7295662760734558,
0.4137738049030304,
0.625601053237915,
0.47455543279647827,
-0.1780421882867813,
-0.35293927788734436,
-0.6278010010719299,
-0.317676305770874,
-0.18965278565883636,
0.9481157064437866,
-0.6490212082862854,
-0.028044788166880608,
0.16957734525203705,
-0.049433883279561996,
0.37581947445869446,
-0.6384459137916565,
0.5367396473884583,
-0.5029419660568237,
0.33858731389045715,
-0.3680505156517029,
0.17458868026733398,
0.155254065990448,
0.4782954454421997,
-0.4038577079772949,
0.7780162692070007,
0.03016534261405468,
-0.8283448815345764,
0.9556417465209961,
-0.43576908111572266,
-0.622728168964386,
-0.07497697323560715,
-0.1664019525051117,
-0.761596143245697,
-0.354826956987381,
0.23048605024814606,
0.35001975297927856,
-0.5244414806365967,
0.7513870000839233,
-0.3975410461425781,
-0.037120603024959564,
0.6067438721656799,
-0.22188328206539154,
0.7210428714752197,
0.31800469756126404,
-0.3781087100505829,
0.05172375589609146,
-0.7002321481704712,
-0.3309400975704193,
0.09890290349721909,
-0.2708677649497986,
-0.40756362676620483,
-0.12180813401937485,
0.33441564440727234,
0.3523675501346588,
0.07503904402256012,
-0.5334883332252502,
0.08065426349639893,
-0.026791982352733612,
-0.07666473090648651,
1.009384036064148,
-0.4437895119190216,
0.46544525027275085,
-0.3561372756958008,
0.6664616465568542,
0.29780763387680054,
0.402395099401474,
0.06536665558815002,
-0.277516633272171,
-0.8675180077552795,
-0.34926658868789673,
0.30475765466690063,
0.35990288853645325,
-0.7066053152084351,
0.07922989130020142,
-0.38089504837989807,
-0.052728887647390366,
-0.4409644901752472,
0.23998260498046875,
0.5770302414894104,
0.18227872252464294,
0.01700596511363983,
-0.09591922909021378,
-0.47714847326278687,
-1.2758088111877441,
-0.6446371674537659,
0.38659951090812683,
0.2262285053730011,
0.19837482273578644,
0.7941226959228516,
0.03223351389169693,
0.6033974885940552,
-0.32936176657676697,
-0.6132949590682983,
-0.31029877066612244,
-0.05091780796647072,
0.31912317872047424,
0.36102399230003357,
0.5383151173591614,
-0.7005424499511719,
-0.8077892661094666,
0.05293343588709831,
-0.3784780502319336,
-0.2818978726863861,
0.06767105311155319,
-0.13979880511760712,
0.31671178340911865,
-0.11275055259466171,
-0.32404980063438416,
0.10754171758890152,
0.6892711520195007,
-0.7227960228919983,
0.4590793251991272,
0.1366613507270813,
0.0646873340010643,
-1.0594837665557861,
0.18344296514987946,
0.3882797658443451,
-0.2704782783985138,
-0.7019446492195129,
-0.08680006116628647,
0.06868693232536316,
0.17648987472057343,
-0.3188445270061493,
0.4290769398212433,
-0.701069176197052,
-0.3316226601600647,
-0.09040554612874985,
0.287186861038208,
-0.0780942291021347,
0.3579578697681427,
-0.015356664545834064,
0.6358623504638672,
0.8277847170829773,
-0.34461626410484314,
0.22918067872524261,
0.07005184143781662,
-0.6800337433815002,
0.7620852589607239,
-0.18411388993263245,
0.1886691153049469,
-0.2494838833808899,
0.15412147343158722,
-0.5924954414367676,
-0.11370208859443665,
0.31403952836990356,
-0.6014516949653625,
0.15679433941841125,
-0.22626358270645142,
-0.39660370349884033,
0.06055173650383949,
-0.20158664882183075,
0.5819990038871765,
0.35767218470573425,
-0.5026203989982605,
0.2809658348560333,
0.767305314540863,
-0.028449082747101784,
-1.2533901929855347,
-0.7477555274963379,
-0.010775593109428883,
-0.44702234864234924,
-0.6636371612548828,
-0.27144771814346313,
0.018518147990107536,
-0.46375736594200134,
-0.31734782457351685,
0.19973500072956085,
-0.09485351294279099,
0.005060974974185228,
-0.04676118493080139,
0.18128550052642822,
0.006906595081090927,
0.06178717687726021,
-0.3078727424144745,
0.1430157721042633,
-0.018067093566060066,
-0.059341371059417725,
0.7286317348480225,
-0.03600584343075752,
0.012983137741684914,
-0.07132881134748459,
0.017475619912147522,
0.5335501432418823,
-0.21227890253067017,
0.6353722214698792,
0.7671768069267273,
-0.3047644793987274,
-0.6664761900901794,
-0.6916249394416809,
0.036119867116212845,
-0.37055861949920654,
0.33349788188934326,
-0.27613693475723267,
-0.5960189700126648,
0.80486661195755,
0.28302982449531555,
-0.27691754698753357,
-0.026325764134526253,
0.6458591818809509,
0.538799524307251,
0.6778568625450134,
0.4574684798717499,
-0.5295323133468628,
0.32845500111579895,
-0.21068766713142395,
0.27404868602752686,
-0.7485962510108948,
-0.39869922399520874,
-0.6970577239990234,
-0.09048553556203842,
-0.45584574341773987,
-0.5713014006614685,
0.23649707436561584,
-0.7955369353294373,
0.03349180892109871,
-0.10927344113588333,
-0.21260349452495575,
0.6747556924819946,
0.20150887966156006,
-0.04350803419947624,
0.14724001288414001,
0.1806178241968155,
-0.02491154335439205,
-0.18396779894828796,
-0.45310845971107483,
-0.5050704479217529,
1.32770574092865,
0.34301409125328064,
0.8594264984130859,
0.18522252142429352,
0.1305660754442215,
0.7453126311302185,
0.5831084251403809,
-0.6186804175376892,
0.29501697421073914,
-0.1771274358034134,
-1.1892765760421753,
-0.09073283523321152,
-0.42623016238212585,
-0.8817822933197021,
0.5369284152984619,
-0.4000270962715149,
-0.673608124256134,
0.18661171197891235,
0.23618972301483154,
0.08897491544485092,
0.25251710414886475,
-0.46432769298553467,
0.9912603497505188,
-0.11521946638822556,
-0.68206787109375,
-0.2653668224811554,
-0.34309542179107666,
0.6928514838218689,
-0.09281405061483383,
0.66031813621521,
-0.42678993940353394,
0.2671789526939392,
0.7361788749694824,
0.20793138444423676,
0.7185136675834656,
-0.14407049119472504,
0.03809899836778641,
-0.1255905032157898,
0.21393850445747375,
0.24740402400493622,
0.05857142433524132,
0.01685955375432968,
0.1330254226922989,
-0.23834644258022308,
-0.5795613527297974,
-0.12130232155323029,
0.8171789646148682,
-0.7779609560966492,
-0.33298277854919434,
-0.8491798639297485,
-0.6583964824676514,
-0.25854170322418213,
0.21378128230571747,
-0.2456570416688919,
0.40552210807800293,
-0.5711231827735901,
-0.05476245656609535,
0.6073732376098633,
-0.4776240587234497,
-0.06526488810777664,
1.0255151987075806,
-0.3172011971473694,
-0.15387913584709167,
0.8940101861953735,
-0.1663389950990677,
0.1300620138645172,
0.18709412217140198,
0.11580272763967514,
0.09644973278045654,
-0.35520869493484497,
-0.532667875289917,
0.35684794187545776,
-0.6505687236785889,
-0.22707447409629822,
-0.3842187821865082,
0.48752561211586,
-0.6408693790435791,
0.2069646120071411,
-0.24151729047298431,
0.030014581978321075,
0.007861948572099209,
0.053069278597831726,
0.127588152885437,
0.7648190855979919,
-0.16683326661586761,
0.3471939265727997,
-0.17152079939842224,
0.36454176902770996,
-0.01312150526791811,
0.49014517664909363,
-0.28504329919815063,
-0.6096504926681519,
-0.4312819540500641,
0.007160678040236235,
-0.32730597257614136,
-0.6811598539352417,
0.7165578007698059,
0.05021306127309799,
0.5461907982826233,
0.4479231536388397,
-0.28265103697776794,
0.20319408178329468,
-0.38695642352104187,
0.6161980032920837,
-0.05473678559064865,
-1.0161813497543335,
0.41400888562202454,
-0.5956026315689087,
0.1765580177307129,
0.16064319014549255,
0.348121702671051,
-0.7953843474388123,
-0.186455637216568,
-0.4388923645019531,
-0.40075695514678955,
1.0639313459396362,
-0.024876058101654053,
0.04088493809103966,
0.05431414768099785,
0.03841410577297211,
0.3357131779193878,
0.13820575177669525,
-1.2682138681411743,
-0.43998003005981445,
0.14256985485553741,
-0.13171805441379547,
-0.21187669038772583,
-0.3237236440181732,
-0.3830755949020386,
0.008176610805094242,
0.8730721473693848,
-0.17557194828987122,
-0.07669834047555923,
-0.09790267795324326,
-0.4650571644306183,
-0.3612692058086395,
0.4802275002002716,
0.6546062231063843,
0.8785077929496765,
0.0504009909927845,
0.08472920954227448,
0.21806837618350983,
-0.5783395767211914,
0.04718573018908501,
-0.14819815754890442,
-0.2747170329093933,
-0.021903885528445244,
0.17872105538845062,
0.7034358978271484,
-0.49471649527549744,
-0.6850658059120178,
0.8766377568244934,
-0.1800081431865692,
-0.002810673089697957,
-0.5262118577957153,
-0.501309335231781,
-0.20674222707748413,
0.0685950368642807,
0.22680430114269257,
0.10265049338340759,
0.2511095106601715,
-0.6976156234741211,
0.04498554393649101,
0.7860270738601685,
-0.18107099831104279,
-0.45236125588417053,
0.11692287772893906,
0.4030185639858246,
-0.20220442116260529,
0.2128855139017105,
-0.07171396911144257,
-0.6730017066001892,
0.5024248361587524,
0.35785600543022156,
0.6532136797904968,
-0.2765860855579376,
0.5774480700492859,
0.1475389003753662,
0.6656398773193359,
0.12462356686592102,
0.3336378335952759,
0.16859106719493866,
-1.1713800430297852,
-0.4242280125617981,
-0.654727578163147,
-0.04724736511707306,
0.5640424489974976,
-0.7010452747344971,
0.44315972924232483,
-0.39263424277305603,
-0.15182174742221832,
-0.04228130355477333,
-0.1635938435792923,
-0.6426498889923096,
0.26930665969848633,
0.3625301718711853,
0.5703520774841309,
-1.5117309093475342,
0.8100509643554688,
0.6754359602928162,
-0.026560069993138313,
-0.0757003203034401,
0.036372143775224686,
0.15715990960597992,
-0.9837089776992798,
0.8722017407417297,
0.021738609299063683,
0.07796596735715866,
-0.8241479396820068,
-0.4309823513031006,
-0.7366306185722351,
0.4296763241291046,
0.45842301845550537,
-0.20250888168811798,
0.4365290105342865,
0.4055730104446411,
0.5850436687469482,
-0.5034046769142151,
0.25115251541137695,
0.8386440873146057,
0.601886510848999,
-0.6787036061286926,
-0.9462339282035828,
0.13368907570838928,
-0.37551242113113403,
-0.21240009367465973,
0.1321885883808136,
-0.8470364212989807,
0.9025960564613342,
-0.02436373010277748,
0.03021661937236786,
-0.2237362265586853,
0.23355454206466675,
0.05674685910344124,
0.28348207473754883,
0.6064676642417908,
0.35524797439575195,
0.4239976406097412,
-0.35430824756622314,
0.8118339776992798,
-0.1365991234779358,
0.1519378423690796,
0.8031686544418335,
-0.204281285405159,
0.33004239201545715,
0.5803597569465637,
-0.15400277078151703,
0.527675449848175,
0.5173357725143433,
0.12604157626628876,
0.5288724303245544,
0.6611145734786987,
-0.22319336235523224,
-0.3731767237186432,
-0.351691871881485,
-0.17975850403308868,
0.43004730343818665,
0.3739093542098999,
-0.36129894852638245,
0.051261890679597855,
0.1052333191037178,
0.4736071228981018,
0.23053765296936035,
-0.009692586958408356,
0.45044150948524475,
-0.19821865856647491,
-0.8390106558799744,
0.35063886642456055,
-0.10218364000320435,
0.8842607140541077,
-0.49885210394859314,
0.02416275255382061,
-0.5057244896888733,
0.4564136862754822,
-0.3125211298465729,
-0.5265874862670898,
-0.036681290715932846,
0.18404747545719147,
-0.25151896476745605,
-0.3051443099975586,
0.6319913864135742,
-0.5884395837783813,
-0.31422704458236694,
0.3269270658493042,
0.4384382963180542,
0.3115364909172058,
0.19421491026878357,
-0.5913351774215698,
0.39285728335380554,
0.18744952976703644,
-0.17070968449115753,
0.5484346151351929,
0.46224552392959595,
-0.07462780922651291,
0.9539699554443359,
0.5333952307701111,
0.4691672623157501,
-0.056832265108823776,
0.36349257826805115,
0.8987926244735718,
-0.28125080466270447,
-0.3683021366596222,
-0.7045019268989563,
0.5458362698554993,
-0.16571541130542755,
-0.5476164221763611,
0.7495405673980713,
0.48752278089523315,
0.917464017868042,
-0.29953625798225403,
0.8944195508956909,
0.05415688082575798,
0.6120153069496155,
-0.4542700946331024,
0.8016795516014099,
-0.5397775173187256,
0.20617571473121643,
-0.35505884885787964,
-0.7559817433357239,
-0.36107712984085083,
0.7270503640174866,
-0.51215660572052,
0.17669890820980072,
0.7038967609405518,
0.9593364000320435,
-0.1312350481748581,
-0.26961442828178406,
0.39137691259384155,
0.3405835032463074,
0.18050219118595123,
0.37454289197921753,
0.8656874299049377,
-0.2181731015443802,
0.5250291228294373,
-0.11009121686220169,
-0.36254867911338806,
-0.09742052853107452,
-0.8254908323287964,
-1.199620246887207,
-0.5299725532531738,
-0.18727850914001465,
-0.500312864780426,
0.3519802689552307,
0.7612947225570679,
0.7736631631851196,
-0.878981351852417,
-0.605747401714325,
0.45196372270584106,
0.4645036458969116,
0.2600685954093933,
-0.25359848141670227,
-0.20017603039741516,
-0.24986283481121063,
-0.7666808366775513,
0.06714243441820145,
-0.06193054839968681,
-0.38150495290756226,
-0.61549973487854,
-0.006046307738870382,
-0.4355808198451996,
-0.2839489281177521,
0.24955865740776062,
-0.011895475909113884,
-0.6319730281829834,
-0.19065436720848083,
-0.11043614149093628,
0.13529421389102936,
-0.06511490792036057,
0.9126679301261902,
-0.49007266759872437,
0.43921104073524475,
0.475006103515625,
0.13920104503631592,
0.40595221519470215,
-0.40064236521720886,
0.7721593976020813,
-0.7427878975868225,
0.39603865146636963,
0.17657551169395447,
0.5517091751098633,
0.7349230647087097,
-0.24247828125953674,
0.29186999797821045,
0.3043336570262909,
-0.663065493106842,
-0.9061521887779236,
0.2627843916416168,
-0.7334246039390564,
-0.1885438859462738,
1.5022156238555908,
-0.11332035064697266,
-0.21602888405323029,
-0.2693140208721161,
-0.15590837597846985,
0.20035630464553833,
-0.6618730425834656,
1.000689148902893,
0.8418805599212646,
0.2693077027797699,
0.11082705110311508,
-0.3790768086910248,
0.7136085033416748,
0.5992513298988342,
-0.6417275667190552,
0.24880358576774597,
0.7070218324661255,
0.8266513347625732,
0.21158403158187866,
0.5159962177276611,
-0.09243457764387131,
0.25074028968811035,
-0.2260494828224182,
0.5051632523536682,
0.2805992364883423,
-0.3385560214519501,
-0.45517274737358093,
-0.1338152289390564,
0.13525064289569855,
0.023158997297286987
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17552v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17552v1
|
Naive Bayes-based Context Extension for Large Language Models
| 2024-03-26T09:59:45 | 2024-03-26T09:59:45 |
Jianlin Su, Murtadha Ahmed, Wenbo, Luo Ao, Mingren Zhu, Yunfeng Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown promising in-context learning
abilities. However, conventional In-Context Learning (ICL) approaches are often
impeded by length limitations of transformer architecture, which pose
challenges when attempting to effectively integrate supervision from a
substantial number of demonstration examples. In this paper, we introduce a
novel framework, called Naive Bayes-based Context Extension (NBCE), to enable
existing LLMs to perform ICL with an increased number of demonstrations by
significantly expanding their context size. Importantly, this expansion does
not require fine-tuning or dependence on particular model architectures, all
the while preserving linear efficiency. NBCE initially splits the context into
equal-sized windows fitting the target LLM's maximum length. Then, it
introduces a voting mechanism to select the most relevant window, regarded as
the posterior context. Finally, it employs Bayes' theorem to generate the test
task. Our experimental results demonstrate that NBCE substantially enhances
performance, particularly as the number of demonstration examples increases,
consistently outperforming alternative methods. The NBCE code will be made
publicly accessible. The code NBCE is available at:
https://github.com/amurtadha/NBCE-master
|
[
-0.41488152742385864,
-0.6472033858299255,
0.5591006875038147,
0.4920899569988251,
-0.36262214183807373,
-0.06385643780231476,
-0.4873254895210266,
-0.1439152956008911,
-0.25159984827041626,
0.23629021644592285,
-0.379420667886734,
-0.6481606364250183,
-0.5107566714286804,
-0.05072709172964096,
-0.3642609417438507,
0.8804060816764832,
0.1976989507675171,
-0.28765663504600525,
0.02518589049577713,
0.17450806498527527,
-0.6120604276657104,
0.032003480941057205,
-0.666923463344574,
0.07421428710222244,
0.24703186750411987,
0.5484374165534973,
0.38758206367492676,
0.40831273794174194,
0.09664981812238693,
0.3398904502391815,
0.07106839865446091,
-0.04552006721496582,
-0.3448038697242737,
0.04783184453845024,
-0.24283812940120697,
-0.423534631729126,
-0.29385408759117126,
-0.1341746598482132,
0.8537696599960327,
0.7337557673454285,
0.05276329815387726,
-0.03076968342065811,
0.3593747019767761,
0.4932534098625183,
-0.9106194376945496,
0.5710211396217346,
-0.6227163076400757,
-0.18733616173267365,
0.08691137284040451,
-0.08222398161888123,
-0.6382893919944763,
-0.17083975672721863,
0.5280194878578186,
-0.28966277837753296,
0.009750448167324066,
-0.20144416391849518,
0.25352931022644043,
-0.0474415048956871,
-0.8084526658058167,
0.16261418163776398,
-0.6445473432540894,
0.7733830809593201,
-0.8336670398712158,
0.33240970969200134,
-0.041253671050071716,
0.5450553894042969,
-0.30369019508361816,
-0.5540817975997925,
-0.5214090943336487,
-0.4463302493095398,
-0.1466585248708725,
-0.07476656883955002,
-0.15488916635513306,
0.21983282268047333,
0.33457276225090027,
0.01350210141390562,
-0.4896305501461029,
0.14436763525009155,
-0.2908855378627777,
0.05219715088605881,
0.3889019191265106,
-0.276456743478775,
0.05001162365078926,
0.01045566238462925,
-0.45390963554382324,
-0.14635708928108215,
-0.7711849212646484,
0.14633187651634216,
-0.05215195566415787,
0.23705025017261505,
-0.14125889539718628,
0.2443564087152481,
-0.2912895381450653,
0.7795876860618591,
-0.10435207188129425,
-0.09672238677740097,
0.10420370101928711,
0.39495617151260376,
-0.4063125252723694,
-0.06244504451751709,
0.7815550565719604,
0.27039074897766113,
0.04468151926994324,
-0.3261341452598572,
-0.06964254379272461,
-0.12900957465171814,
0.047767121344804764,
-0.8575713038444519,
0.013201666064560413,
-0.05151243135333061,
-0.2933134436607361,
-0.24107424914836884,
0.06569698452949524,
-0.8512556552886963,
-0.09590895473957062,
-0.21668469905853271,
0.5899519324302673,
-0.6388753652572632,
-0.12061721831560135,
0.061169419437646866,
-0.05515490844845772,
0.36660271883010864,
0.29853495955467224,
-0.6427255868911743,
0.3418635427951813,
0.839472234249115,
0.7153743505477905,
-0.2422366738319397,
-0.050390202552080154,
-0.8344852328300476,
0.19514116644859314,
-0.5480450987815857,
0.48376110196113586,
-0.5015324354171753,
-0.2375430166721344,
0.27927884459495544,
0.13135142624378204,
-0.06538383662700653,
-0.3979720175266266,
0.2428899109363556,
-0.807593047618866,
0.2928234934806824,
0.13737520575523376,
-0.6026725172996521,
-0.2881728410720825,
0.1447194218635559,
-0.303078293800354,
0.6947038769721985,
0.25504645705223083,
-0.2340954840183258,
0.4085768461227417,
-0.7526856064796448,
-0.5500013828277588,
0.26432809233665466,
-0.46821892261505127,
-0.18474604189395905,
0.3203299641609192,
0.23146957159042358,
0.7942832708358765,
-0.2433575540781021,
0.7903372049331665,
-0.35367023944854736,
-0.5905238389968872,
0.22688306868076324,
-0.9042537212371826,
0.6370518803596497,
-0.09190898388624191,
-0.6273466348648071,
0.3416083753108978,
-0.8040691614151001,
-0.1822797656059265,
-0.16482526063919067,
-0.32101672887802124,
-0.3591661751270294,
0.050041425973176956,
-0.010340945795178413,
0.12130976468324661,
0.05000370740890503,
-0.6644310355186462,
0.20175011456012726,
-0.6090555787086487,
0.25896671414375305,
0.7047236561775208,
-0.04517030343413353,
0.5674362778663635,
-0.221202090382576,
0.47931018471717834,
-0.10595394670963287,
0.13152341544628143,
-0.18642696738243103,
-0.4326179623603821,
-0.4720173478126526,
-0.5218513607978821,
0.18097788095474243,
0.43314680457115173,
-0.8847271800041199,
0.6100986003875732,
-0.7770135402679443,
-0.1312224119901657,
-0.027089370414614677,
-0.050179172307252884,
0.28868553042411804,
0.3511078953742981,
0.23599077761173248,
0.05337866023182869,
-0.24835528433322906,
-1.1383525133132935,
-0.0028102239593863487,
-0.2050929218530655,
-0.4151294529438019,
0.14582079648971558,
0.30440908670425415,
-0.05659984424710274,
1.3967257738113403,
-0.40146008133888245,
-0.15779249370098114,
-0.29274478554725647,
-0.20476144552230835,
0.4737084209918976,
0.7522040009498596,
0.518591582775116,
-0.7472612261772156,
-0.6449666023254395,
0.08377008140087128,
-0.350851446390152,
-0.15683917701244354,
-0.26820388436317444,
-0.01868484541773796,
0.12909413874149323,
0.7552468180656433,
-0.24545229971408844,
0.37744084000587463,
0.5839938521385193,
-0.13549022376537323,
0.5271440744400024,
-0.11320053040981293,
-0.009872672148048878,
-1.1724259853363037,
-0.14463554322719574,
0.19417905807495117,
-0.38722801208496094,
-0.5097323060035706,
0.0202645193785429,
0.3962022066116333,
0.029727138578891754,
-0.5138674378395081,
0.5224379897117615,
-0.23588956892490387,
0.10271820425987244,
-0.6071592569351196,
0.12801529467105865,
-0.2908269166946411,
0.5527637004852295,
0.17272146046161652,
0.6861003637313843,
0.8414479494094849,
-0.46194422245025635,
0.12782344222068787,
-0.041843023151159286,
-0.7029553651809692,
0.183609738945961,
-0.33410346508026123,
-0.36376190185546875,
-0.257803738117218,
0.3360052704811096,
-1.0399521589279175,
-0.1904265433549881,
-0.018324779346585274,
-0.22996707260608673,
0.6997502446174622,
-0.4403986632823944,
-0.3871905505657196,
-0.19765548408031464,
-0.402336061000824,
0.276027113199234,
0.5719526410102844,
-1.0472289323806763,
0.6342204809188843,
-0.0006145482184365392,
-0.17023377120494843,
-0.622788667678833,
-0.4909258484840393,
0.29729852080345154,
-0.4691234529018402,
-0.47199058532714844,
0.4968944787979126,
-0.06113800033926964,
-0.08530303090810776,
-0.05366513505578041,
-0.10969134420156479,
-0.11039326339960098,
0.0773058533668518,
0.09555870294570923,
0.3148566484451294,
-0.46464648842811584,
0.18007530272006989,
0.6079462766647339,
0.06654691696166992,
0.13343071937561035,
-0.30117008090019226,
0.492215096950531,
-0.3755768835544586,
-0.21715694665908813,
-0.37961190938949585,
0.349097341299057,
0.5100763440132141,
0.09705846011638641,
0.7265878915786743,
0.3811466097831726,
-0.3841930329799652,
-0.49975451827049255,
-0.6008757948875427,
-0.16272619366645813,
-0.5680571794509888,
0.7074305415153503,
-0.4151809513568878,
-1.2470898628234863,
0.18764005601406097,
-0.3965330719947815,
0.10468626022338867,
0.14717914164066315,
0.15593481063842773,
0.13965947926044464,
0.8225489258766174,
0.6743891835212708,
-0.2582767605781555,
0.5256701707839966,
-0.24869070947170258,
0.19545142352581024,
-1.0703169107437134,
0.031058330088853836,
-0.024289516732096672,
-0.2232319563627243,
-0.6997050642967224,
-0.5430759191513062,
0.5689598321914673,
0.25985416769981384,
-0.2116166204214096,
0.3412688970565796,
-0.09017281234264374,
0.7016533613204956,
0.4330889880657196,
0.06390807777643204,
0.18239730596542358,
-0.05500510334968567,
0.007039318326860666,
0.06747835874557495,
-0.8154004216194153,
-0.6098394989967346,
0.9945776462554932,
0.3536405563354492,
0.44018834829330444,
0.43922606110572815,
0.5381296873092651,
-0.1003810316324234,
0.853380560874939,
-0.7829355001449585,
0.7741597294807434,
-0.15791894495487213,
-0.49521729350090027,
-0.3703671991825104,
-0.4831150770187378,
-0.7947420477867126,
0.5829451084136963,
-0.12311648577451706,
-1.0112967491149902,
0.34934696555137634,
0.04061899706721306,
-0.4432046711444855,
0.23912453651428223,
-0.5809845924377441,
0.8671976327896118,
-0.029303155839443207,
-0.5983462929725647,
-0.2750539183616638,
-0.6181937456130981,
0.6610380411148071,
-0.14764921367168427,
0.2328203022480011,
0.09210352599620819,
-0.18118661642074585,
0.6007884740829468,
-0.23487648367881775,
1.0743359327316284,
-0.1337740421295166,
-0.28493356704711914,
0.1162378266453743,
0.11655274778604507,
0.38801518082618713,
0.5703572630882263,
0.15738478302955627,
-0.16361428797245026,
-0.17049647867679596,
-0.24949686229228973,
-0.7701529860496521,
0.9681280851364136,
-0.2260792851448059,
-0.7141155004501343,
-0.2985541522502899,
-0.5835453867912292,
-0.7565922141075134,
0.07707890123128891,
0.002477186731994152,
0.6788874864578247,
-0.1771937608718872,
0.7554410696029663,
0.5720685124397278,
-0.485411137342453,
0.7163918614387512,
0.7982124090194702,
-0.3374522030353546,
-0.25563570857048035,
0.6655595898628235,
-0.2822096049785614,
0.34921181201934814,
0.6743209362030029,
0.49882972240448,
-0.2587515413761139,
-0.6766266822814941,
-0.31809911131858826,
-0.05348900333046913,
-0.5345498323440552,
-0.21650582551956177,
-0.506993293762207,
-0.04100556671619415,
-0.4936070442199707,
-0.35358867049217224,
-0.17526400089263916,
-0.25163429975509644,
-0.027571892365813255,
-0.07166728377342224,
0.19118008017539978,
0.3226281404495239,
-0.13458508253097534,
0.9163015484809875,
-0.674058198928833,
0.02486351504921913,
0.6758192777633667,
0.6016752123832703,
0.18130864202976227,
-0.4648691713809967,
-0.10717121511697769,
-0.14231987297534943,
-0.2870396077632904,
-0.8369832634925842,
0.38696596026420593,
0.16392748057842255,
0.40301525592803955,
0.693656861782074,
0.07644042372703552,
0.5392266511917114,
-0.658182680606842,
0.514244794845581,
0.18088994920253754,
-0.9017566442489624,
0.4131656289100647,
-0.6876937747001648,
0.359986275434494,
0.4851055145263672,
0.20266754925251007,
-0.34256577491760254,
-0.37919381260871887,
-0.44912078976631165,
-0.8690672516822815,
0.6055052280426025,
0.10711320489645004,
0.19719037413597107,
-0.37020230293273926,
0.4179166853427887,
-0.018375413492321968,
0.036338113248348236,
-0.8663793802261353,
-0.11422409117221832,
0.3922376036643982,
-0.05452549085021019,
-0.15478675067424774,
-0.21965928375720978,
0.22142578661441803,
-0.19949476420879364,
0.8991569876670837,
-0.46795010566711426,
0.028767596930265427,
-0.003638466354459524,
-0.17242646217346191,
0.19673466682434082,
0.5182076692581177,
0.31301212310791016,
0.5172305107116699,
-0.3394712209701538,
0.011564567685127258,
0.3538186252117157,
-0.07858535647392273,
-0.018905047327280045,
0.22265514731407166,
0.0018622243078425527,
-0.2059280127286911,
0.5542125105857849,
0.8056657910346985,
0.6366255283355713,
-0.8040839433670044,
0.870606541633606,
-0.09767548739910126,
-0.15359123051166534,
-0.297680139541626,
0.08339060842990875,
0.06902870535850525,
0.4150245487689972,
0.5094548463821411,
-0.032996244728565216,
0.2726025879383087,
-0.5541635155677795,
0.32743704319000244,
0.5983293652534485,
-0.394543319940567,
-0.09761752188205719,
0.3759497404098511,
0.05076591297984123,
-0.05754593014717102,
0.35921621322631836,
-0.22771087288856506,
-0.5059919357299805,
0.5713915824890137,
0.8188870549201965,
0.7422340512275696,
-0.24720096588134766,
0.10292733460664749,
0.2628551721572876,
0.35120025277137756,
-0.1291295289993286,
0.04742240160703659,
-0.22128136456012726,
-0.5855907201766968,
-0.9877946972846985,
-0.5411758422851562,
-0.012123271822929382,
0.33543661236763,
-0.6157830953598022,
0.3480781316757202,
-0.21607241034507751,
0.1686534732580185,
-0.5189428925514221,
-0.2194853574037552,
-0.4581912159919739,
0.13097892701625824,
0.09940601885318756,
1.0512093305587769,
-0.7842709422111511,
1.0104037523269653,
0.32004833221435547,
0.19630342721939087,
-0.4680415391921997,
0.1883474886417389,
-0.19149081408977509,
-0.39544349908828735,
0.5833715200424194,
0.3907567262649536,
0.07841092348098755,
0.03984777629375458,
-0.3661758601665497,
-0.8308338522911072,
0.9591747522354126,
0.37752455472946167,
-0.7901104688644409,
0.1723632961511612,
0.038472503423690796,
0.3702867031097412,
-0.4653419852256775,
0.15857303142547607,
0.5060046315193176,
0.2056775689125061,
0.008578049950301647,
-0.7336717844009399,
0.03036380372941494,
0.0011708333622664213,
0.2969532012939453,
0.07762225717306137,
-0.38498029112815857,
0.15250809490680695,
-0.019663460552692413,
-0.0766494870185852,
0.09036894887685776,
0.9578446745872498,
0.2564149498939514,
-0.013952705077826977,
0.8458773493766785,
0.15309733152389526,
0.18563704192638397,
0.14704732596874237,
0.9883779287338257,
-0.16762664914131165,
0.09820839017629623,
1.4254240989685059,
-0.2935757339000702,
1.0597864389419556,
0.27577826380729675,
-0.11657190322875977,
0.5297859907150269,
0.13923443853855133,
0.3743709623813629,
0.4889659285545349,
0.2507869303226471,
-0.5636842846870422,
-0.2250782996416092,
0.238862544298172,
-0.09384611994028091,
0.4021102786064148,
0.5558047890663147,
-0.4077741503715515,
-0.27613750100135803,
0.32282087206840515,
-0.11640763282775879,
0.0850922241806984,
-0.051446616649627686,
0.7073785066604614,
0.07107893377542496,
-0.6763104796409607,
0.20019909739494324,
0.09220559895038605,
0.8950675129890442,
-0.626797616481781,
0.007697016000747681,
0.06913349777460098,
0.3283153772354126,
0.23188890516757965,
-0.5227290987968445,
0.31114041805267334,
-0.15745733678340912,
-0.03289368003606796,
-0.20253455638885498,
0.45480799674987793,
-0.5109754204750061,
-0.5172224044799805,
0.3643752634525299,
0.3161567151546478,
-0.2834429442882538,
-0.12842199206352234,
-0.13783623278141022,
-0.13847719132900238,
-0.08477623760700226,
-0.2581918239593506,
0.5979114174842834,
0.4194423258304596,
-0.2758593261241913,
0.5312456488609314,
0.4636858105659485,
-0.15457487106323242,
0.13470686972141266,
0.00019237193919252604,
0.7781658172607422,
-0.30699285864830017,
-0.35481780767440796,
-0.9356364607810974,
0.3735590875148773,
-0.2863195538520813,
-0.11862601339817047,
0.745311975479126,
0.8912078738212585,
0.8238144516944885,
-0.25057971477508545,
0.8241899609565735,
0.008454847149550915,
0.33298543095588684,
-0.363783061504364,
0.4775560796260834,
-0.3998512029647827,
0.3882151246070862,
-0.26369231939315796,
-0.9760806560516357,
-0.5295826196670532,
0.7930132746696472,
-0.5149178504943848,
-0.10336790233850479,
0.6922346949577332,
0.8189676403999329,
-0.2797362208366394,
0.07822664827108383,
0.4302854835987091,
0.25138014554977417,
0.7125573754310608,
0.7587864398956299,
0.8016172051429749,
-0.31518927216529846,
0.38246864080429077,
-0.4005746841430664,
-0.8518391251564026,
0.039274465292692184,
-1.1010982990264893,
-0.8993423581123352,
-0.5365490317344666,
-0.6531839966773987,
-0.017587358132004738,
-0.01917283795773983,
1.12450110912323,
0.9404599070549011,
-0.6729662418365479,
-0.35712066292762756,
-0.13670411705970764,
-0.16486415266990662,
-0.331941157579422,
-0.27052444219589233,
0.5250270962715149,
-0.4763246774673462,
-0.8183614015579224,
0.9398229122161865,
0.322414755821228,
-0.11174466460943222,
0.02173304371535778,
0.12202844023704529,
-0.15910807251930237,
-0.14130067825317383,
0.9790212512016296,
0.024478966370224953,
-0.4700668752193451,
-0.18825297057628632,
-0.3714853525161743,
0.3421070873737335,
-0.20787982642650604,
0.6988521814346313,
-1.0636193752288818,
0.1520957201719284,
0.3735908269882202,
0.6606937646865845,
0.40402308106422424,
-0.3573412597179413,
0.6910762786865234,
-0.9480518698692322,
0.03490303456783295,
0.20098154246807098,
0.5940055251121521,
-0.0679120421409607,
-0.07076063752174377,
0.15842114388942719,
0.01001433003693819,
-0.2182188481092453,
-0.6095133423805237,
0.1932743489742279,
-1.0026962757110596,
-0.6323784589767456,
1.1852234601974487,
-0.05906079337000847,
-0.23912644386291504,
0.03574627265334129,
-0.14350666105747223,
0.10569633543491364,
-0.3628057837486267,
0.7830854058265686,
0.2956587076187134,
0.2198934108018875,
-0.0675945058465004,
-0.6730927228927612,
0.32694509625434875,
0.31685104966163635,
-0.735376238822937,
0.16790664196014404,
0.5666118860244751,
0.3112556040287018,
-0.07553081959486008,
0.4335898458957672,
-0.09618517756462097,
0.3279656767845154,
-0.6391063332557678,
-0.2968771755695343,
0.11720617115497589,
-0.3974437415599823,
-0.559667706489563,
0.5048097968101501,
-0.14835713803768158,
-0.10871877521276474
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17546v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17546v1
|
Decoding excellence: Mapping the demand for psychological traits of operations and supply chain professionals through text mining
| 2024-03-26T09:51:43 | 2024-03-26T09:51:43 |
S. Di Luozzo, A. Fronzetti Colladon, M. M. Schiraldi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SI, econ.GN, physics.soc-ph, q-fin.EC, I.2.7; J.4; H.4.0
|
The current study proposes an innovative methodology for the profiling of
psychological traits of Operations Management (OM) and Supply Chain Management
(SCM) professionals. We use innovative methods and tools of text mining and
social network analysis to map the demand for relevant skills from a set of job
descriptions, with a focus on psychological characteristics. The proposed
approach aims to evaluate the market demand for specific traits by combining
relevant psychological constructs, text mining techniques, and an innovative
measure, namely, the Semantic Brand Score. We apply the proposed methodology to
a dataset of job descriptions for OM and SCM professionals, with the objective
of providing a mapping of their relevant required skills, including
psychological characteristics. In addition, the analysis is then detailed by
considering the region of the organization that issues the job description, its
organizational size, and the seniority level of the open position in order to
understand their nuances. Finally, topic modeling is used to examine key
components and their relative significance in job descriptions. By employing a
novel methodology and considering contextual factors, we provide an innovative
understanding of the attitudinal traits that differentiate professionals. This
research contributes to talent management, recruitment practices, and
professional development initiatives, since it provides new figures and
perspectives to improve the effectiveness and success of Operations Management
and Supply Chain Management professionals.
|
[
-0.3612896203994751,
-0.4453172981739044,
0.4702923893928528,
0.1778746396303177,
-0.13626894354820251,
0.3109315037727356,
-0.21070370078086853,
-0.6457891464233398,
0.4240116775035858,
0.7637673616409302,
-1.0541335344314575,
-0.6207794547080994,
-0.7069064378738403,
0.25479114055633545,
-0.2298024445772171,
1.1251882314682007,
-0.02311071753501892,
0.0045681241899728775,
-0.5178412199020386,
-0.17924270033836365,
-0.34253990650177,
-0.859309196472168,
-0.5752877593040466,
-0.36159348487854004,
0.20117922127246857,
0.537322461605072,
0.6756049394607544,
0.740165650844574,
0.8707712888717651,
0.2279415875673294,
-0.07704537361860275,
0.2690504789352417,
-0.6532942056655884,
0.12369678169488907,
-0.3586306869983673,
-0.27475813031196594,
-0.7589064836502075,
0.21109914779663086,
0.2445978969335556,
0.7720302939414978,
-0.38016948103904724,
0.6337842345237732,
0.05051817744970322,
0.8008971810340881,
-0.48276710510253906,
0.27361270785331726,
-0.741029679775238,
0.059739768505096436,
-0.04681281000375748,
-0.6489061713218689,
-0.08980963379144669,
-0.3192129135131836,
0.16057898104190826,
-0.6434687972068787,
0.5640081763267517,
-0.06745462864637375,
1.0038522481918335,
-0.1631414145231247,
-0.3584235906600952,
-0.6429517865180969,
-0.6936554908752441,
0.8141158819198608,
-0.186778262257576,
0.30260881781578064,
0.7165580987930298,
0.035449348390102386,
0.2267346829175949,
-0.3024654984474182,
-0.0980667769908905,
0.3492394685745239,
-0.1365337371826172,
0.173823282122612,
0.25200578570365906,
-0.0011955318041145802,
0.011149192228913307,
0.9330599308013916,
-0.18337580561637878,
-0.07965457439422607,
-0.44514718651771545,
0.1781495213508606,
0.8580477237701416,
0.5615840554237366,
0.35760578513145447,
0.22969914972782135,
-0.3681844472885132,
-0.22855190932750702,
-0.2003316879272461,
0.22250638902187347,
0.4458511173725128,
0.23070977628231049,
0.2377222180366516,
0.48896631598472595,
-0.8173781633377075,
0.36286461353302,
-0.39199796319007874,
-0.21374471485614777,
0.14489680528640747,
-0.3546452224254608,
0.11630449444055557,
0.22024093568325043,
0.570471465587616,
0.71097332239151,
0.2720060348510742,
-0.17018312215805054,
-0.3312359154224396,
0.09764964878559113,
0.7116343975067139,
-0.40221428871154785,
-0.205712229013443,
-0.09097500145435333,
-0.9727703928947449,
-0.6430118083953857,
0.32660192251205444,
-1.0905272960662842,
-0.5664176344871521,
-0.3198585510253906,
0.03909583389759064,
-0.28708145022392273,
-0.4824725091457367,
-0.001353421132080257,
-0.3481634259223938,
0.369160532951355,
-0.24333158135414124,
-1.0731827020645142,
0.5259086489677429,
0.9465764760971069,
0.8645840883255005,
-0.27261635661125183,
-0.10643590986728668,
0.01675606705248356,
0.17897318303585052,
-0.35367152094841003,
0.6104257702827454,
-0.6131477952003479,
-0.3582650125026703,
0.2772309184074402,
-0.08184868842363358,
0.07217821478843689,
-0.6319783329963684,
0.9468943476676941,
-0.5610105395317078,
-0.32681572437286377,
-0.6171572208404541,
-0.23195697367191315,
-0.248904287815094,
0.44466671347618103,
-0.3368220329284668,
1.191085696220398,
0.3398938775062561,
-0.3984489142894745,
0.47985953092575073,
-0.6263611912727356,
-0.39472100138664246,
0.22308659553527832,
-0.2855652868747711,
-0.253133624792099,
0.6442087888717651,
0.05693082511425018,
0.4519624412059784,
-0.3305453360080719,
-0.11511608958244324,
-0.1801588535308838,
-0.2162991613149643,
0.6030772924423218,
0.22541449964046478,
0.5295982360839844,
0.1700228452682495,
0.08524351567029953,
-0.10899162292480469,
-0.6228553056716919,
0.20916010439395905,
0.05270750820636749,
-0.32668814063072205,
-0.2641746699810028,
0.43905121088027954,
0.002131848596036434,
0.4704055190086365,
0.2910839915275574,
-0.18742381036281586,
0.13661478459835052,
-0.2610054612159729,
0.43515798449516296,
0.9889640808105469,
0.10641162097454071,
0.4890824556350708,
-0.20257960259914398,
0.6763353943824768,
-0.4048333168029785,
0.43563032150268555,
-0.002526452299207449,
-0.3324343264102936,
-0.7576172351837158,
-0.2107485681772232,
-0.2666209638118744,
0.5356603264808655,
-0.49032047390937805,
0.6087803840637207,
-0.4012496769428253,
-0.7559826374053955,
-0.6940019130706787,
0.08296798914670944,
0.17280472815036774,
0.4767317473888397,
0.4826423227787018,
-0.5408357381820679,
-0.6009061336517334,
-0.7448310852050781,
-0.7924436330795288,
-0.2459224909543991,
0.07986778765916824,
0.13808909058570862,
0.21037079393863678,
-0.2540071904659271,
0.9145388603210449,
-1.0539630651474,
-0.8282244205474854,
-0.288117378950119,
0.04347473010420799,
0.5957044363021851,
0.16574570536613464,
0.07765348255634308,
-0.652628481388092,
-0.18872499465942383,
0.10093670338392258,
-1.0566338300704956,
-0.03676816076040268,
0.25609177350997925,
-0.4057633578777313,
-0.0344918891787529,
0.3766331076622009,
-0.37726855278015137,
0.279579222202301,
0.16044458746910095,
-0.6287610530853271,
0.7263161540031433,
-0.1848384439945221,
0.3166356384754181,
-0.6009544134140015,
0.11422322690486908,
0.36275437474250793,
0.3139456808567047,
-0.7015112638473511,
0.43719717860221863,
-0.2905440032482147,
-0.4518965184688568,
0.06147320941090584,
-0.06429822742938995,
-0.35766616463661194,
-0.18736271560192108,
-0.01067722961306572,
-0.3154433071613312,
-0.07508112490177155,
0.3592478036880493,
0.1462470144033432,
0.4060145914554596,
0.6064832210540771,
-0.5905036926269531,
0.35241401195526123,
0.41937389969825745,
-0.4080437421798706,
1.0087802410125732,
-0.43090859055519104,
-0.003538339864462614,
0.07241006195545197,
-0.2662680745124817,
-0.928490400314331,
-0.13232344388961792,
-0.025167914107441902,
-0.4591743052005768,
-0.167769193649292,
0.021134549751877785,
-0.7150024771690369,
-0.4654618501663208,
-0.09301694482564926,
-0.12195947021245956,
0.7869516015052795,
0.03801112622022629,
0.596394419670105,
0.21816791594028473,
-0.41918468475341797,
-0.2404232770204544,
-0.8204862475395203,
-0.1172330304980278,
-0.48215848207473755,
-0.44481658935546875,
0.5395921468734741,
0.1644730269908905,
-0.08909344673156738,
-0.14128166437149048,
-0.6510506868362427,
-0.30909156799316406,
0.260295033454895,
0.2122395634651184,
0.3891676366329193,
-0.10197246074676514,
-0.2597896158695221,
-0.2820392847061157,
-0.4050655961036682,
0.6126059889793396,
-0.1625508815050125,
0.39621713757514954,
-0.14741355180740356,
0.023035194724798203,
-0.4507664442062378,
0.5391011238098145,
0.633642315864563,
-0.6166849732398987,
1.065475344657898,
0.9557919502258301,
-0.3041386306285858,
-0.15775181353092194,
-0.4512246251106262,
-0.6843100190162659,
-0.5188460350036621,
0.3437099754810333,
-0.2597294747829437,
-0.37594836950302124,
0.5602375268936157,
-0.31594064831733704,
-0.37109291553497314,
0.42072197794914246,
0.18148083984851837,
-0.19741195440292358,
1.146086573600769,
0.99888014793396,
0.08631684631109238,
0.28177130222320557,
-0.5111792087554932,
0.7318548560142517,
-0.7662038207054138,
-0.6415017247200012,
-0.492482990026474,
-0.5571385025978088,
-0.30227091908454895,
0.05937369167804718,
0.6070058345794678,
0.33263441920280457,
0.003111855825409293,
-0.2635253965854645,
-0.9947347640991211,
0.34156638383865356,
0.38084015250205994,
0.27017971873283386,
0.30019789934158325,
0.2963082194328308,
0.0018469374626874924,
-0.2122524529695511,
-0.35594648122787476,
-0.7224060893058777,
0.8993702530860901,
0.3644280433654785,
0.44783416390419006,
-0.12623941898345947,
0.34191614389419556,
0.38140788674354553,
0.0007242539431899786,
-0.886874794960022,
0.7046197056770325,
-0.26414400339126587,
-0.4152258634567261,
-0.07406759262084961,
-0.40479880571365356,
-0.38508832454681396,
0.03282740339636803,
-0.5806252956390381,
-0.7192250490188599,
0.196897491812706,
-0.08119127154350281,
-0.0370815135538578,
0.2273196280002594,
-0.465256005525589,
0.9334179759025574,
-0.3189641833305359,
0.08383313566446304,
-0.2676815986633301,
-0.24643537402153015,
-0.012602708302438259,
-0.03571529686450958,
0.44036051630973816,
-0.4713442027568817,
-0.30403679609298706,
0.9623475670814514,
-0.451740026473999,
0.4957374334335327,
0.09529143571853638,
0.08256342262029648,
-0.14818407595157623,
0.02139192819595337,
0.42741432785987854,
-0.27905893325805664,
-0.6754646301269531,
0.32874423265457153,
-0.020831266418099403,
-0.4874522387981415,
-0.43443605303764343,
0.6442528963088989,
-0.9756374359130859,
-0.08676088601350784,
-0.443677693605423,
-0.2519840896129608,
-0.41490352153778076,
0.26678353548049927,
0.4879920780658722,
0.28456294536590576,
-0.084486223757267,
0.1349501609802246,
0.6875677108764648,
0.0175747349858284,
0.05101971700787544,
0.39845794439315796,
0.2973519265651703,
-0.4185626804828644,
1.102892518043518,
0.45555514097213745,
0.11550275981426239,
0.15428639948368073,
-0.08963991701602936,
-0.26993849873542786,
-0.39228588342666626,
0.23990988731384277,
0.25104743242263794,
-0.8281876444816589,
-0.05312139913439751,
-0.7265946269035339,
-0.06545178592205048,
-0.4342796802520752,
-0.6136572360992432,
-0.3786364197731018,
0.18808384239673615,
-0.2350168377161026,
-0.11447886377573013,
0.697248637676239,
0.6723236441612244,
0.4134226441383362,
0.5315279960632324,
-0.4333075284957886,
0.2406993955373764,
0.1536312997341156,
0.7640959024429321,
0.16787248849868774,
0.17625471949577332,
-0.5628927946090698,
-0.1392078399658203,
-0.7953874468803406,
-1.0330817699432373,
0.5015448927879333,
0.2129502147436142,
0.7512157559394836,
0.5940918326377869,
0.347896933555603,
0.5540118217468262,
0.08599236607551575,
0.9057579040527344,
0.17468595504760742,
-1.1449508666992188,
0.6434717178344727,
-0.48168858885765076,
-0.2719167470932007,
0.7625302672386169,
0.8236819505691528,
-0.6762999296188354,
-0.1426812708377838,
-0.870888352394104,
-1.3289051055908203,
1.179784893989563,
0.41515040397644043,
-0.08770221471786499,
-0.0665794163942337,
0.2737613320350647,
0.06849881261587143,
0.5722236633300781,
-0.244077667593956,
-0.5642054677009583,
0.14414232969284058,
-0.3438372313976288,
-0.24191337823867798,
-0.49503305554389954,
-0.06529694050550461,
-0.32725486159324646,
0.6393159627914429,
0.11255977302789688,
0.5197785496711731,
0.12090004235506058,
0.29059898853302,
0.08085396885871887,
0.24135281145572662,
0.07663384079933167,
0.9068963527679443,
-0.2774645686149597,
0.2570343613624573,
0.20019258558750153,
-0.3185257315635681,
-0.021696539595723152,
-0.16796234250068665,
0.35938337445259094,
0.016348885372281075,
0.2351614236831665,
0.5396305322647095,
0.014787247404456139,
-0.6543574333190918,
0.35990142822265625,
0.3793201744556427,
-0.1443152129650116,
-0.4134529232978821,
0.14986474812030792,
-0.21239931881427765,
-0.0640484169125557,
0.8386030197143555,
0.07950498908758163,
0.44821321964263916,
-0.8960739374160767,
-0.05729633942246437,
0.0392918661236763,
-0.9766913056373596,
-0.1354176551103592,
0.3797518014907837,
0.009598618373274803,
-0.36579591035842896,
0.8420448303222656,
-0.17585018277168274,
-0.5460259914398193,
0.6055830717086792,
0.3773685097694397,
0.7340986728668213,
-0.2690354883670807,
0.39800482988357544,
0.018468134105205536,
0.40261122584342957,
-0.4584752023220062,
0.5797330141067505,
0.0716450959444046,
-0.5172751545906067,
0.007307345047593117,
-0.5858930945396423,
-0.21140387654304504,
-0.1079111397266388,
-1.313509464263916,
0.4896816909313202,
-0.25330832600593567,
-0.3418140113353729,
-0.3168821334838867,
-0.02641482651233673,
-0.8907126188278198,
0.3965359926223755,
-0.23331378400325775,
0.5291228294372559,
-1.0265429019927979,
0.22017315030097961,
1.032226800918579,
-0.40533447265625,
-0.5238814353942871,
-0.339019775390625,
-0.13657382130622864,
-0.8341975808143616,
0.39652642607688904,
0.1349002718925476,
0.08979387581348419,
0.14621680974960327,
0.035319846123456955,
-0.5141808390617371,
1.1320489645004272,
0.07261417806148529,
0.14162962138652802,
-0.24870498478412628,
0.35193270444869995,
0.5614604949951172,
-0.7938123941421509,
0.43292102217674255,
0.7599239945411682,
0.24362199008464813,
-0.25610408186912537,
-0.5146452784538269,
0.10541300475597382,
-0.3111141622066498,
0.2778736352920532,
0.21435485780239105,
-0.4932195246219635,
0.6968561410903931,
0.13009092211723328,
-0.09547381848096848,
-0.18052391707897186,
0.3229035437107086,
0.5573599338531494,
0.5950922966003418,
0.3306766748428345,
0.5975106358528137,
0.7530180811882019,
-0.33658239245414734,
0.8648188710212708,
-0.34471648931503296,
0.4949919879436493,
0.5238378643989563,
0.007062938995659351,
0.6815105676651001,
0.44101160764694214,
-0.03751225024461746,
0.8605380654335022,
0.6439101696014404,
-0.2055966556072235,
0.5759143233299255,
0.19700172543525696,
0.057920023798942566,
-0.4486680328845978,
-0.5498117208480835,
-0.5695505142211914,
0.4482939839363098,
0.5465133190155029,
-0.8324705362319946,
0.039650674909353256,
0.030201438814401627,
-0.22353972494602203,
0.3467857539653778,
-0.619858980178833,
0.8710132241249084,
0.11022347211837769,
-0.24294178187847137,
0.5477467775344849,
0.024889392778277397,
0.49079591035842896,
-0.4495457112789154,
0.046362727880477905,
0.024199560284614563,
0.18025904893875122,
-0.448995977640152,
-1.0516554117202759,
0.5910669565200806,
-0.1447044014930725,
-0.4920274019241333,
-0.7931765913963318,
0.6001179814338684,
-0.28341659903526306,
-0.4703713357448578,
0.20348790287971497,
0.3874676823616028,
0.13163907825946808,
-0.37877413630485535,
-0.5265742540359497,
0.40157222747802734,
-0.42160502076148987,
0.23949910700321198,
0.04811404272913933,
0.7465326189994812,
0.2587100863456726,
0.637408435344696,
0.45042964816093445,
0.27253884077072144,
-0.34476184844970703,
-0.31665757298469543,
0.5068511366844177,
-0.8937013149261475,
-1.104526400566101,
-0.8538947105407715,
0.5736091732978821,
-0.47610294818878174,
-0.582324743270874,
0.7260596752166748,
0.5808965563774109,
0.879624605178833,
-0.48456472158432007,
0.5003005862236023,
0.184129998087883,
0.27665695548057556,
-0.21482481062412262,
0.8370729088783264,
-0.44816747307777405,
0.11634204536676407,
-0.6695868372917175,
-0.9368024468421936,
0.2880091965198517,
0.3931232690811157,
-0.4328184127807617,
-0.10719244927167892,
0.6544061899185181,
0.5953313708305359,
0.0626191720366478,
0.1552995890378952,
-0.09599670767784119,
-0.019461065530776978,
0.006142568774521351,
0.5369575619697571,
0.8377299308776855,
-0.491227924823761,
0.603936493396759,
-0.23036369681358337,
-0.2963099777698517,
-0.540479302406311,
-0.565346360206604,
-0.7231393456459045,
-0.6446638703346252,
-0.6730375289916992,
-0.3467101454734802,
-0.03326033055782318,
0.5733538866043091,
0.8619300723075867,
-0.39322787523269653,
-0.6302446722984314,
-0.07890059053897858,
0.3383318781852722,
-1.0761446952819824,
-0.3557884395122528,
-0.11480604857206345,
-0.2241193652153015,
-0.02821226231753826,
0.03791175037622452,
0.27467313408851624,
-0.35078415274620056,
-0.022918326780200005,
0.1383841186761856,
0.22430163621902466,
0.09099964797496796,
0.7080885171890259,
-0.14070452749729156,
-0.570884644985199,
0.2416742742061615,
0.10640958696603775,
0.09179144352674484,
-0.32500776648521423,
0.9735914468765259,
-0.32648441195487976,
0.35031118988990784,
0.6180676817893982,
0.4787260591983795,
0.012889426201581955,
-0.10942097753286362,
0.6706323027610779,
-0.6485026478767395,
-0.38468635082244873,
0.019962577149271965,
-0.03592994436621666,
0.16378508508205414,
-0.7464585304260254,
0.7230046987533569,
0.5755516290664673,
-0.4356248676776886,
-0.9897801876068115,
0.27437055110931396,
-1.139382243156433,
-0.03532194718718529,
0.9287388324737549,
0.1961573362350464,
0.16779495775699615,
-0.20000965893268585,
-0.05116171017289162,
0.22308653593063354,
-0.5322384238243103,
1.012384057044983,
0.7032092809677124,
-0.1266329437494278,
-0.04562721028923988,
-0.5295257568359375,
0.6012569069862366,
0.12925581634044647,
-0.5425779223442078,
-0.0016838371520861983,
-0.06610330939292908,
-0.07866322249174118,
0.029624834656715393,
0.6774998903274536,
-0.08695711940526962,
-0.019242094829678535,
-0.25498348474502563,
0.22319532930850983,
-0.04696684330701828,
-0.24477717280387878,
-0.0579281784594059,
0.6224237680435181,
0.0657501071691513,
-0.07792308926582336
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17545v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17545v1
|
A Gaze-grounded Visual Question Answering Dataset for Clarifying Ambiguous Japanese Questions
| 2024-03-26T09:49:35 | 2024-03-26T09:49:35 |
Shun Inadumi, Seiya Kawano, Akishige Yuguchi, Yasutomo Kawanishi, Koichiro Yoshino
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Situated conversations, which refer to visual information as visual question
answering (VQA), often contain ambiguities caused by reliance on directive
information. This problem is exacerbated because some languages, such as
Japanese, often omit subjective or objective terms. Such ambiguities in
questions are often clarified by the contexts in conversational situations,
such as joint attention with a user or user gaze information. In this study, we
propose the Gaze-grounded VQA dataset (GazeVQA) that clarifies ambiguous
questions using gaze information by focusing on a clarification process
complemented by gaze information. We also propose a method that utilizes gaze
target estimation results to improve the accuracy of GazeVQA tasks. Our
experimental results showed that the proposed method improved the performance
in some cases of a VQA system on GazeVQA and identified some typical problems
of GazeVQA tasks that need to be improved.
|
[
-0.6015177369117737,
-1.2919681072235107,
0.907471239566803,
0.015224847942590714,
-0.5222585797309875,
-0.02184007130563259,
-0.2747838497161865,
-0.43637606501579285,
0.30884626507759094,
0.7177326679229736,
-1.0900719165802002,
-0.4626444876194,
-0.5242742300033569,
-0.12497836351394653,
0.025196928530931473,
0.07128845900297165,
-0.4908297061920166,
0.15720458328723907,
-0.495541512966156,
-0.44954586029052734,
-0.8939408659934998,
-0.0746978148818016,
-0.19490395486354828,
-0.0070970915257930756,
0.2153722047805786,
0.8027446269989014,
0.7878025770187378,
0.31467610597610474,
0.5184439420700073,
0.3895113468170166,
0.0496203750371933,
0.25760969519615173,
-0.573230504989624,
0.1555940955877304,
-0.07974384725093842,
-0.9004610776901245,
0.1328374445438385,
-0.3083418607711792,
0.570671796798706,
1.0026342868804932,
0.0334644541144371,
0.6219961047172546,
-0.12360379844903946,
0.5208979845046997,
-0.9350710511207581,
0.13096879422664642,
-0.47821393609046936,
0.38707953691482544,
-0.025995809584856033,
-0.3018987774848938,
-0.20330585539340973,
-0.3013898432254791,
0.18115593492984772,
-0.8581658601760864,
0.08661103248596191,
0.06597328931093216,
1.4345775842666626,
0.8501003384590149,
-0.2643064856529236,
0.3565569818019867,
-0.4754007160663605,
0.7157290577888489,
-0.44838809967041016,
0.20923252403736115,
0.23720373213291168,
0.6164034605026245,
-0.15255028009414673,
-0.33175721764564514,
-0.43587708473205566,
0.19157202541828156,
-0.2471623420715332,
0.5273406505584717,
-0.00032899179495871067,
0.006574335973709822,
0.8862897157669067,
0.13745452463626862,
-0.5101307034492493,
-0.5301734805107117,
-0.3492794930934906,
0.013493857346475124,
0.15137921273708344,
0.21618039906024933,
0.5317097306251526,
-0.5259634852409363,
-0.3586180508136749,
0.14325253665447235,
-0.3883659839630127,
0.5061973333358765,
-0.039853278547525406,
-0.17067648470401764,
0.10536317527294159,
0.9116938710212708,
-0.8124747276306152,
0.8636389374732971,
0.49798107147216797,
0.10401416569948196,
0.30798211693763733,
-0.13074839115142822,
-0.27054524421691895,
-0.2086988240480423,
0.441523015499115,
0.861544132232666,
0.23323053121566772,
0.14595790207386017,
0.3867705464363098,
-0.06699147820472717,
0.5250284671783447,
-0.3941730558872223,
0.029882149770855904,
0.3555377125740051,
-0.26159629225730896,
-0.015315605327486992,
0.06090972200036049,
-0.7596372365951538,
-0.10961487144231796,
-0.5599159002304077,
0.5499955415725708,
-0.03377336636185646,
-0.10963007062673569,
0.046955522149801254,
-0.3445992171764374,
0.5725417733192444,
0.7602996230125427,
-0.38284796476364136,
-0.16568192839622498,
0.21937978267669678,
0.3991721272468567,
0.27735090255737305,
0.08716598153114319,
-0.503693699836731,
0.1530933678150177,
-0.2779355049133301,
0.2975977063179016,
-0.444390207529068,
-0.10589589178562164,
-0.13282541930675507,
0.4661373794078827,
-0.1106748878955841,
-0.3687250316143036,
0.27854764461517334,
-0.6209177374839783,
0.5128109455108643,
-0.7299450039863586,
-0.0701475664973259,
-0.45693179965019226,
0.6224281787872314,
-0.4089421331882477,
1.0806787014007568,
0.09422392398118973,
-0.9715511798858643,
0.5007540583610535,
-0.2190757691860199,
-0.15180939435958862,
0.4796788692474365,
-0.3819715678691864,
-0.378858357667923,
-0.1833871304988861,
0.7625792026519775,
0.3555082082748413,
-0.01411073561757803,
0.4709740877151489,
-0.21659335494041443,
-0.5492358803749084,
0.24262849986553192,
-0.1264110803604126,
0.6575254797935486,
-0.019993392750620842,
-0.8036366701126099,
-0.01912960596382618,
-0.7138897180557251,
0.4863390326499939,
0.09953784197568893,
-0.0705653578042984,
-0.6474940180778503,
-0.07524855434894562,
-0.5019733309745789,
-0.09144268929958344,
0.47212404012680054,
-0.5673518180847168,
-0.03257332369685173,
-0.18842540681362152,
0.015455454587936401,
0.3622945547103882,
0.49845507740974426,
0.09932827949523926,
0.06434579193592072,
0.5683171153068542,
0.26589083671569824,
0.4253419041633606,
-0.08457992225885391,
-0.7426224946975708,
-1.245460033416748,
0.13168266415596008,
-0.07507775723934174,
0.7366651892662048,
-1.5139780044555664,
-0.12987586855888367,
-0.20066140592098236,
-0.2381528913974762,
-0.635956346988678,
-0.15732765197753906,
0.6517882943153381,
0.9097223877906799,
0.3579218089580536,
-0.4480632245540619,
-0.4960431754589081,
-1.1745768785476685,
-0.31348204612731934,
-0.22635377943515778,
0.023575397208333015,
0.7575583457946777,
0.1539551168680191,
0.08999396860599518,
0.9584116339683533,
-0.7927361726760864,
0.3255830705165863,
0.14504414796829224,
0.30260688066482544,
0.09103602170944214,
0.245306134223938,
0.323310524225235,
-1.3542354106903076,
-0.5281563997268677,
-0.14204764366149902,
-1.1415715217590332,
-0.07924630492925644,
-0.16586260497570038,
-0.5008441805839539,
-0.44115737080574036,
0.46198195219039917,
-0.4198996126651764,
0.599618673324585,
0.10776831954717636,
-0.03735610842704773,
0.21481674909591675,
0.1967698037624359,
0.8166184425354004,
-0.946256160736084,
0.10067877918481827,
0.24395333230495453,
-0.45512163639068604,
-0.6743333339691162,
0.22974130511283875,
0.16468921303749084,
-0.25289785861968994,
-0.5637072324752808,
0.15658514201641083,
-0.6064515709877014,
-0.16195741295814514,
-0.036913637071847916,
0.5586767196655273,
0.11133959144353867,
0.8325936198234558,
0.3712688982486725,
0.7855587005615234,
0.7067707777023315,
-0.6087557673454285,
0.42707914113998413,
0.6912084221839905,
-0.3520166277885437,
0.702327311038971,
-0.6307170391082764,
-0.08342821151018143,
-0.5922439694404602,
-0.374240517616272,
-1.2936612367630005,
-0.726992666721344,
0.9243159294128418,
-0.48410624265670776,
0.20247052609920502,
-0.46041810512542725,
0.15947529673576355,
-0.6340389847755432,
0.12408336997032166,
0.5449023842811584,
0.25357145071029663,
-0.5865007638931274,
0.425919771194458,
0.4311777353286743,
-0.09872987121343613,
-1.2039562463760376,
-0.6147307753562927,
0.1352391391992569,
-0.2987492084503174,
-0.6569400429725647,
-0.16105543076992035,
0.13931316137313843,
-0.2787834405899048,
0.11686544120311737,
-0.1876421719789505,
-0.15360920131206512,
0.14851349592208862,
0.5479571223258972,
0.49403509497642517,
-0.36383700370788574,
-0.12602469325065613,
-0.20694316923618317,
-0.08569225668907166,
0.13151957094669342,
0.17476598918437958,
0.13765974342823029,
-0.12368480116128922,
-0.5223480463027954,
-0.307843953371048,
0.3994583785533905,
0.5407501459121704,
-0.1498701423406601,
0.369649738073349,
0.4687593877315521,
-0.3183980882167816,
0.010769188404083252,
-0.6130005121231079,
0.1447405070066452,
-0.5063544511795044,
0.1726197749376297,
-0.6159956455230713,
-0.970899224281311,
0.4800238311290741,
-0.19081194698810577,
-0.23072212934494019,
0.08384199440479279,
0.4708736538887024,
-0.2657199203968048,
0.9423205852508545,
0.44814974069595337,
0.2853354811668396,
0.5199017524719238,
0.18327531218528748,
0.2090722769498825,
-0.8575645685195923,
-0.37857747077941895,
-0.18298937380313873,
-0.19885244965553284,
-0.265177458524704,
-0.6361250877380371,
0.6222319602966309,
-0.1608787178993225,
0.14788712561130524,
0.5721372961997986,
-0.5447773933410645,
0.482146680355072,
0.7236403226852417,
0.6481439471244812,
0.1548643559217453,
-0.1645781397819519,
0.10845580697059631,
-0.3741937577724457,
-0.5759141445159912,
-0.2506512701511383,
0.5740752816200256,
0.06240633875131607,
0.6504902243614197,
-0.0633053258061409,
0.17388314008712769,
-0.07323847711086273,
-0.08734653890132904,
-0.6680747866630554,
0.7296151518821716,
0.5301397442817688,
-0.7647927403450012,
-0.5950236320495605,
-0.47023358941078186,
-0.5185831189155579,
0.6428356170654297,
-0.15508387982845306,
-0.8937377333641052,
0.38571158051490784,
0.07158280164003372,
-0.16724930703639984,
-0.1109258159995079,
-0.731238603591919,
0.9581684470176697,
-0.21110816299915314,
-0.7217606902122498,
0.16002339124679565,
-0.9656543731689453,
0.6325539946556091,
0.241731196641922,
-0.118319571018219,
-0.23143932223320007,
0.23673684895038605,
0.5113455653190613,
-0.5154188871383667,
0.9273015856742859,
-0.4673934578895569,
0.1463954597711563,
0.5471310019493103,
-0.3822365403175354,
0.2884034216403961,
0.2006099373102188,
0.26882800459861755,
0.02263137511909008,
0.0038492721505463123,
-0.49173402786254883,
-0.7773997783660889,
0.2511788010597229,
-0.49452415108680725,
-1.0187759399414062,
-0.10797127336263657,
-0.2791665494441986,
-0.6682664155960083,
0.29058417677879333,
0.38351309299468994,
0.3501810133457184,
-0.03597862273454666,
0.37497425079345703,
0.927368700504303,
-0.24520477652549744,
-0.10432513803243637,
0.5493181943893433,
0.03663252294063568,
-0.0395529605448246,
0.39070257544517517,
-0.041786354035139084,
0.24905526638031006,
0.47025346755981445,
-0.2972021698951721,
-0.08972027897834778,
-0.18063123524188995,
-0.8750953674316406,
0.12859706580638885,
-1.0602103471755981,
0.11362488567829132,
-0.5150872468948364,
0.020090803503990173,
0.05332005023956299,
-0.15654495358467102,
-0.1190781444311142,
-0.16723944246768951,
-0.11358223855495453,
0.027634883299469948,
0.20835313200950623,
0.08706485480070114,
0.39085114002227783,
0.2274027317762375,
-0.5398029088973999,
0.9849017858505249,
0.4128299951553345,
0.21485991775989532,
-0.47570890188217163,
-0.4891720116138458,
-0.06512870639562607,
0.5425148010253906,
0.15417879819869995,
-1.006404995918274,
0.042896661907434464,
-0.22700966894626617,
0.7334783673286438,
0.1899796426296234,
0.2872030436992645,
1.3012570142745972,
-0.36391162872314453,
0.9187296032905579,
0.3706374168395996,
-0.7729172706604004,
0.9453306198120117,
-0.441141277551651,
0.5967106819152832,
0.8833168745040894,
0.49507975578308105,
-0.5231711268424988,
-0.6242161989212036,
-0.5273931622505188,
-0.7755507826805115,
0.717094898223877,
0.2552439272403717,
-0.07547640055418015,
0.3659338653087616,
0.5941065549850464,
-0.30615532398223877,
0.463913232088089,
-0.6637399792671204,
-0.43824002146720886,
-0.23151814937591553,
-0.09707646071910858,
0.18160486221313477,
-0.12661990523338318,
-0.3252218961715698,
-0.2398759424686432,
0.6408296227455139,
-0.22264041006565094,
0.0609142892062664,
0.2650952637195587,
-0.25011128187179565,
-0.5514662265777588,
0.16606248915195465,
-0.03431426361203194,
0.6681506633758545,
-0.09742214530706406,
-0.21283146739006042,
0.3703002631664276,
-0.4461967945098877,
0.11539541929960251,
-0.3776339590549469,
-0.8567504286766052,
0.1979197859764099,
-0.15032130479812622,
1.0205183029174805,
0.49166756868362427,
-0.8250386118888855,
0.6362908482551575,
-0.2428697794675827,
-0.2896154522895813,
-0.14287173748016357,
0.2868926525115967,
-0.1740274280309677,
0.3583514988422394,
0.05844588950276375,
0.17031994462013245,
0.36863797903060913,
-0.4142177104949951,
0.204598069190979,
0.4903598725795746,
-0.5885586142539978,
0.44075530767440796,
0.790208101272583,
0.023588307201862335,
0.13555297255516052,
0.4475013017654419,
0.4942784011363983,
-0.6196721196174622,
0.6846034526824951,
-0.0197923481464386,
0.5645771026611328,
0.07172856479883194,
0.5313053727149963,
0.7206653952598572,
0.30855879187583923,
0.05413685739040375,
0.48970669507980347,
-0.42200252413749695,
-0.5118020176887512,
-0.28739455342292786,
-0.2509620785713196,
-0.9057994484901428,
-0.018483594059944153,
-1.196837306022644,
0.2791374623775482,
-0.28303778171539307,
-0.36328941583633423,
-0.052506666630506516,
-0.14946348965168,
-0.4929909408092499,
0.6569673418998718,
0.20086966454982758,
0.23645982146263123,
-0.7359572052955627,
0.2022152990102768,
0.8182860612869263,
-0.4964029788970947,
-0.8558299541473389,
0.11720582842826843,
-0.05933881551027298,
-0.8398901224136353,
0.3087468445301056,
0.124092236161232,
-0.3990727663040161,
-0.17641469836235046,
-1.0676398277282715,
-1.1290745735168457,
0.9356818199157715,
0.026382282376289368,
-0.4912029802799225,
0.27548083662986755,
0.15743762254714966,
0.4389527440071106,
0.11200488358736038,
0.06706421822309494,
0.22875025868415833,
0.6766079068183899,
0.5568537712097168,
-0.49735039472579956,
0.0700213834643364,
-0.6805860996246338,
-0.021194791421294212,
0.2102138102054596,
-0.8000118732452393,
0.3366892337799072,
-0.2028682380914688,
-0.4120282828807831,
0.13208217918872833,
0.4858258366584778,
-0.07198072224855423,
0.3785995841026306,
0.38381609320640564,
0.20738543570041656,
0.7981294393539429,
-0.49532854557037354,
0.7082533836364746,
0.1000344306230545,
0.16942287981510162,
1.2149815559387207,
-0.12715061008930206,
0.6111119985580444,
0.7337177991867065,
0.039088647812604904,
0.2946285307407379,
0.6610100865364075,
-0.19092264771461487,
0.40683993697166443,
0.04169540852308273,
-0.037617556750774384,
-0.7373999953269958,
0.0924842432141304,
-0.2819540798664093,
0.28934207558631897,
0.43199053406715393,
0.022107549011707306,
-0.16051176190376282,
0.25214850902557373,
-0.26855745911598206,
0.1345006376504898,
-0.24582555890083313,
0.6844668984413147,
-0.17916524410247803,
-1.2024601697921753,
0.7330779433250427,
-0.040248021483421326,
-0.033863890916109085,
-0.42672452330589294,
0.027887966483831406,
-0.029537487775087357,
-0.0195455402135849,
-0.10614676028490067,
-0.953578531742096,
-0.03793555870652199,
0.159690722823143,
-0.2180825173854828,
-0.004341033287346363,
0.653181791305542,
-0.5359015464782715,
-0.30974143743515015,
-0.37973254919052124,
0.5284530520439148,
0.09803436696529388,
0.007895255461335182,
-0.7528355717658997,
-0.1743026077747345,
0.41063112020492554,
-0.3314569890499115,
-0.10814628005027771,
0.6123694777488708,
-0.17288005352020264,
0.7956135272979736,
0.33353424072265625,
-0.38102880120277405,
0.25991877913475037,
-0.04774421826004982,
0.8880345225334167,
-0.5368564128875732,
-0.42839664220809937,
-0.1670709103345871,
0.8023215532302856,
-0.38966241478919983,
-0.35989508032798767,
1.1735934019088745,
0.10019268840551376,
0.581211268901825,
-0.3210359513759613,
0.7942466735839844,
-0.15658067166805267,
0.6601831316947937,
-0.6924801468849182,
0.24059905111789703,
-0.8406456112861633,
0.06255051493644714,
-0.4320337772369385,
-0.7540101408958435,
-0.24348832666873932,
0.7575882077217102,
-0.570306122303009,
-0.2588188052177429,
0.5238486528396606,
0.6993390321731567,
-0.19409166276454926,
0.03746665641665459,
0.3786240816116333,
0.12858887016773224,
-0.2586456537246704,
0.559389591217041,
1.0983877182006836,
-0.6582053303718567,
0.3541816771030426,
-0.40968161821365356,
-0.11469969898462296,
-0.444364458322525,
-0.4308222532272339,
-0.8851005434989929,
-0.4862525463104248,
-0.7963516712188721,
-0.1741134524345398,
0.1555738002061844,
0.2002321034669876,
0.5576748251914978,
-0.5809510350227356,
0.3042755722999573,
0.15099409222602844,
0.014497584663331509,
-0.14187327027320862,
-0.2670227885246277,
0.03660522401332855,
-0.17048043012619019,
-0.847028911113739,
0.22473178803920746,
0.3927631378173828,
-0.09304684400558472,
0.04264584928750992,
0.19862662255764008,
-0.06260904669761658,
-0.10133714228868484,
0.2357078343629837,
0.5003430843353271,
-0.7916150093078613,
-0.5946350693702698,
0.20533832907676697,
-0.05802243947982788,
0.3471797704696655,
0.4923485815525055,
-0.6416535973548889,
0.9770182967185974,
0.3792908787727356,
0.3133590519428253,
0.7461682558059692,
0.8172851204872131,
0.5486474633216858,
-0.9553508758544922,
0.3384943902492523,
0.06974586099386215,
0.41886135935783386,
0.3500734567642212,
-0.6776280999183655,
0.4472290277481079,
0.24980895221233368,
-0.12909361720085144,
-0.5328298211097717,
0.3240680396556854,
-1.3352241516113281,
-0.22859206795692444,
1.1707817316055298,
-0.2584042251110077,
-0.63067626953125,
-0.49405208230018616,
-0.7170370817184448,
0.18286535143852234,
0.1832953244447708,
0.48324939608573914,
0.8662784099578857,
0.25991955399513245,
-0.583634614944458,
-0.5538954138755798,
0.24455370008945465,
0.6239315867424011,
-0.6877603530883789,
0.030660532414913177,
0.994911253452301,
0.19185125827789307,
0.2420547902584076,
0.42838066816329956,
0.011717520654201508,
0.7507408261299133,
0.06814530491828918,
-0.16735011339187622,
0.15447811782360077,
-0.24243435263633728,
0.1220819428563118,
0.3212435245513916,
-0.22152596712112427,
-0.5650360584259033
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17540v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17540v2
|
Large Language Models Are State-of-the-Art Evaluator for Grammatical Error Correction
| 2024-03-26T09:43:15 | 2024-05-26T11:55:11 |
Masamune Kobayashi, Masato Mita, Mamoru Komachi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have been reported to outperform existing
automatic evaluation metrics in some tasks, such as text summarization and
machine translation. However, there has been a lack of research on LLMs as
evaluators in grammatical error correction (GEC). In this study, we investigate
the performance of LLMs in GEC evaluation by employing prompts designed to
incorporate various evaluation criteria inspired by previous research. Our
extensive experimental results demonstrate that GPT-4 achieved Kendall's rank
correlation of 0.662 with human judgments, surpassing all existing methods.
Furthermore, in recent GEC evaluations, we have underscored the significance of
the LLMs scale and particularly emphasized the importance of fluency among
evaluation criteria.
|
[
-0.09377218037843704,
-0.8623117804527283,
1.1128628253936768,
0.31615543365478516,
0.03489347919821739,
-0.0060709575191140175,
-0.6172375679016113,
-0.19475172460079193,
0.001453535514883697,
-0.22425682842731476,
-0.29131001234054565,
-0.5069460868835449,
-0.7474130988121033,
0.6751193404197693,
-0.35452160239219666,
0.815156877040863,
-0.00667054345831275,
0.39856672286987305,
-0.3314264118671417,
0.22008395195007324,
-0.6750755906105042,
-0.709187388420105,
-0.5204852819442749,
-0.14509901404380798,
0.7258861660957336,
0.33922529220581055,
0.7615109086036682,
0.0590321309864521,
0.5807603597640991,
0.4931192696094513,
-0.3784415125846863,
0.31724345684051514,
-0.4488231837749481,
-0.0659986063838005,
-0.20999516546726227,
-0.30111515522003174,
-0.6973938345909119,
0.03147799149155617,
1.0723881721496582,
0.7093486189842224,
-0.18716980516910553,
-0.23928596079349518,
0.24361568689346313,
0.7465783953666687,
-0.6363280415534973,
0.33384788036346436,
-0.38641294836997986,
0.022572334855794907,
-0.0629626214504242,
-0.11115894466638565,
-0.7512302994728088,
-0.612151563167572,
-0.06145652011036873,
-0.4697941541671753,
0.052594274282455444,
0.03171182796359062,
0.7249304056167603,
-0.06978524476289749,
-0.2435663789510727,
-0.5420904159545898,
-0.6723487973213196,
0.6800583004951477,
-0.9493803977966309,
0.33942702412605286,
0.3037164509296417,
0.027634426951408386,
-0.34745195508003235,
-0.5269504189491272,
-0.41048604249954224,
-0.565681517124176,
0.021025143563747406,
0.1439376175403595,
-0.2494698017835617,
0.3461281657218933,
0.20413880050182343,
0.5012197494506836,
-0.3461874723434448,
0.34871748089790344,
-0.09188724309206009,
-0.1848890781402588,
0.5286963582038879,
0.3448124825954437,
0.21158218383789062,
-0.3771725594997406,
0.1578541398048401,
0.09702586382627487,
-0.43891435861587524,
-0.1127970963716507,
0.313742458820343,
0.4431920051574707,
-0.04271640256047249,
0.47472691535949707,
-0.18799178302288055,
0.8086980581283569,
0.09751925617456436,
-0.14354728162288666,
0.3207424283027649,
-0.4061143696308136,
-0.3517639935016632,
-0.3103439211845398,
0.7786216139793396,
0.492674857378006,
0.4240480959415436,
-0.20337235927581787,
-0.3752759099006653,
0.12732954323291779,
0.20498372614383698,
-0.5485633611679077,
0.0032561803236603737,
-0.32113298773765564,
-0.20297719538211823,
-0.17567120492458344,
0.3361862003803253,
-0.7816233038902283,
-0.29094284772872925,
-0.3363213539123535,
0.5734144449234009,
-0.07833267748355865,
0.023563073948025703,
0.24106766283512115,
0.1976388841867447,
-0.060025282204151154,
0.6290570497512817,
-0.89426189661026,
0.48591241240501404,
0.7431237697601318,
0.9219829440116882,
-0.11492925137281418,
-0.48250526189804077,
-0.5653578042984009,
-0.5380899906158447,
-0.7832321524620056,
0.5605545043945312,
-0.62570720911026,
-0.6095437407493591,
0.2304713875055313,
0.07242146879434586,
-0.46726083755493164,
-0.38737723231315613,
0.6659876108169556,
-0.5537900924682617,
0.1367674618959427,
-0.634329617023468,
-0.895346999168396,
-0.19611607491970062,
0.1284106969833374,
-0.5296729207038879,
1.0791072845458984,
0.11262259632349014,
-0.4408762753009796,
0.22138623893260956,
-0.6254276633262634,
-0.4709376096725464,
0.10663282126188278,
-0.011760714463889599,
-0.2877366840839386,
0.39362090826034546,
0.3427709639072418,
0.6574530005455017,
-0.3152656555175781,
0.4637829661369324,
-0.08333181589841843,
-0.5912231206893921,
0.4646177887916565,
-0.47023963928222656,
0.23365512490272522,
-0.029896678403019905,
-0.438167542219162,
0.2574693560600281,
-0.5586022734642029,
0.1442878395318985,
0.10184499621391296,
-0.5331804156303406,
0.013883480802178383,
-0.2737322151660919,
-0.41835349798202515,
0.011169841513037682,
0.001740552601404488,
-0.3621790111064911,
0.23460130393505096,
-0.21713310480117798,
0.5116941928863525,
0.8683199286460876,
-0.09010422229766846,
0.3228747248649597,
-0.27976569533348083,
0.7950757145881653,
-0.6167498826980591,
-0.0066728233359754086,
-0.07599461078643799,
-0.6327729225158691,
-0.9251169562339783,
0.009355456568300724,
0.4136030077934265,
0.49598774313926697,
-0.4238133132457733,
0.6165662407875061,
-0.35599827766418457,
-0.587701141834259,
-0.17576371133327484,
0.35560154914855957,
0.6213570237159729,
0.4348459839820862,
0.07708379626274109,
0.12354040890932083,
-0.4803331196308136,
-0.5953971743583679,
-0.20696531236171722,
-0.3264978229999542,
0.09077306091785431,
0.3835105895996094,
0.4573427140712738,
-0.08058583736419678,
0.737042248249054,
-0.15861135721206665,
-0.14533476531505585,
-0.49126482009887695,
0.031287435442209244,
0.3079589605331421,
0.06354740262031555,
0.436061829328537,
-0.1562650203704834,
-0.29565128684043884,
-0.15605007112026215,
-0.6673968434333801,
-0.3609197735786438,
0.1530756801366806,
0.10872218012809753,
0.4265943169593811,
0.45164796710014343,
-0.6675154566764832,
0.07229175418615341,
0.7044980525970459,
-0.5327005386352539,
0.8587935566902161,
-0.46670496463775635,
0.6133095026016235,
-0.47798800468444824,
-0.16000883281230927,
0.034883104264736176,
-0.26942747831344604,
-0.5107886791229248,
-0.03963065147399902,
0.30666279792785645,
0.12440257519483566,
-0.3020935356616974,
0.3820290267467499,
-0.4659249484539032,
-0.29984498023986816,
0.1459120362997055,
0.32605352997779846,
0.05479815974831581,
0.13991813361644745,
-0.47427719831466675,
0.88690584897995,
0.28619521856307983,
-0.4914068281650543,
0.5487805604934692,
0.048918113112449646,
-0.4598301351070404,
0.42174357175827026,
-0.4893583655357361,
0.38947349786758423,
-0.05445554107427597,
0.1542215496301651,
-1.3516556024551392,
-0.42260512709617615,
-0.09506230056285858,
-0.28916576504707336,
0.39013490080833435,
0.06913648545742035,
-0.7051880359649658,
-0.685508668422699,
-0.23927724361419678,
0.06480678170919418,
0.5846835374832153,
-0.6436262130737305,
0.5035086274147034,
-0.12223302572965622,
-0.4388275146484375,
-0.18953967094421387,
-0.6628431081771851,
0.25577715039253235,
0.06521163880825043,
-0.8672268986701965,
-0.11789713054895401,
-0.05446891859173775,
-0.39607372879981995,
-0.12354589253664017,
0.1601191610097885,
0.5463376045227051,
0.060537826269865036,
0.22458216547966003,
0.5314969420433044,
-0.2914555072784424,
0.3918323218822479,
-0.48884326219558716,
-0.0346764400601387,
0.10697921365499496,
0.1992446929216385,
0.5155509114265442,
-0.7200595736503601,
-0.5794510245323181,
-0.5535518527030945,
-0.11758456379175186,
0.48192906379699707,
0.18615712225437164,
0.3111335039138794,
-0.043434690684080124,
-0.2519241273403168,
0.11035369336605072,
-1.0070563554763794,
0.07824967801570892,
-0.4686123728752136,
0.5700073838233948,
-0.2989163398742676,
-0.9323141574859619,
0.4077531099319458,
0.13568015396595,
-0.36330631375312805,
0.6813176870346069,
0.5929690599441528,
0.014662321656942368,
0.8931424617767334,
0.16213497519493103,
-0.22061461210250854,
0.16934743523597717,
0.13242734968662262,
0.2779947817325592,
-0.579767644405365,
-0.18427379429340363,
-0.676647424697876,
-0.33692044019699097,
-0.22304852306842804,
-0.4536148011684418,
0.24448718130588531,
0.11770986020565033,
-0.20843416452407837,
-0.21897491812705994,
-0.14995905756950378,
0.6309772729873657,
0.20342127978801727,
-0.10466527193784714,
0.5075554847717285,
-0.04112814739346504,
-0.44983211159706116,
-0.30135637521743774,
-0.5157706141471863,
-0.6337816119194031,
1.010545015335083,
0.5094072818756104,
0.9452018737792969,
0.08455503731966019,
0.3304818272590637,
0.3694970905780792,
0.39918479323387146,
-0.8828961849212646,
0.7497339248657227,
-0.3281683921813965,
-0.21181875467300415,
-0.5237986445426941,
-0.48147058486938477,
-0.5316544771194458,
0.37243160605430603,
-0.010744696483016014,
-0.697823703289032,
-0.10031924396753311,
0.11968281120061874,
-0.5662549734115601,
0.3653619885444641,
-0.9354076981544495,
0.7605510354042053,
-0.35943517088890076,
-0.16767846047878265,
-0.03370451554656029,
-0.24075259268283844,
0.22210203111171722,
-0.07868886739015579,
0.3753375709056854,
-0.09551283717155457,
-0.004266999661922455,
0.609112024307251,
-0.5642421841621399,
0.7579305768013,
-0.27594608068466187,
-0.19609418511390686,
0.16847524046897888,
0.17482292652130127,
0.8260100483894348,
-0.20194557309150696,
-0.26193827390670776,
0.1469402015209198,
-0.5830479264259338,
0.033739324659109116,
-0.7391651272773743,
0.8260766863822937,
-0.7307465672492981,
-0.6403759121894836,
-0.5220968723297119,
-0.4902864992618561,
-0.4641403257846832,
-0.15545977652072906,
0.19304047524929047,
0.36519506573677063,
-0.31355395913124084,
0.1532697230577469,
0.26777029037475586,
-0.11544894427061081,
0.6259896755218506,
0.5272778272628784,
-0.5159391164779663,
-0.41261881589889526,
0.42757442593574524,
0.16111433506011963,
0.46197131276130676,
0.07595860958099365,
0.3915870487689972,
-0.3921477794647217,
-0.5999288558959961,
-0.5222529172897339,
0.4177488386631012,
-0.9968485236167908,
-0.19352254271507263,
-0.5500330328941345,
-0.16178704798221588,
-0.35358792543411255,
-0.4739846885204315,
-0.28496554493904114,
-0.08180295675992966,
-0.25775596499443054,
-0.4918125569820404,
0.4279291331768036,
1.1435844898223877,
0.09028471261262894,
0.40624237060546875,
-0.7125061750411987,
-0.14224429428577423,
0.3111477494239807,
0.3228703737258911,
0.025753429159522057,
-0.8783162236213684,
0.053539879620075226,
-0.18429413437843323,
-0.012832662090659142,
-0.6812632083892822,
0.1922675222158432,
0.25695592164993286,
0.42745891213417053,
0.17765702307224274,
-0.5940456986427307,
0.9106245636940002,
-0.5092342495918274,
0.9805358052253723,
0.2400350123643875,
-1.2708321809768677,
0.4564243257045746,
-0.3647705018520355,
0.31291624903678894,
0.37863704562187195,
-0.04321388155221939,
-0.7265527844429016,
-0.1866699457168579,
-0.4545426368713379,
-0.5061745047569275,
0.5529398322105408,
0.1170569360256195,
0.24771767854690552,
-0.20162199437618256,
0.508983314037323,
-0.19443021714687347,
-0.0451463982462883,
-0.5493296384811401,
0.15539883077144623,
0.2990146577358246,
-0.10515222698450089,
-0.44819438457489014,
-0.8625983595848083,
0.2385062575340271,
-0.17676669359207153,
0.901803731918335,
-0.00609160028398037,
0.009432967752218246,
0.30249637365341187,
-0.20373253524303436,
-0.38011452555656433,
0.6733011603355408,
0.7012884020805359,
0.929190456867218,
0.015818072482943535,
0.003211860079318285,
0.572589635848999,
-0.2927069067955017,
0.30496907234191895,
-0.05194317549467087,
-0.08680035173892975,
0.2853206396102905,
0.6059163212776184,
0.6754891872406006,
0.6858561038970947,
-0.49634549021720886,
0.7987200021743774,
0.06750867515802383,
-0.20732343196868896,
-0.30939027667045593,
-0.10398312658071518,
0.23768682777881622,
0.03983139991760254,
0.2776227295398712,
-0.06530003994703293,
0.024600818753242493,
-0.3498682975769043,
-0.009480681270360947,
0.24281206727027893,
-0.05893829092383385,
-0.33264634013175964,
0.3863752484321594,
0.279427707195282,
-0.24905814230442047,
0.6524472236633301,
-0.4270808696746826,
-0.5431156754493713,
0.5550174713134766,
0.5751526355743408,
0.6249973177909851,
-0.6836742162704468,
0.17033490538597107,
0.4375388026237488,
0.32230818271636963,
-0.47597694396972656,
0.393461138010025,
0.5859009623527527,
-0.588134765625,
-0.6804545521736145,
-0.6427913308143616,
-0.23851104080677032,
0.12505100667476654,
-0.4184436798095703,
0.4136248230934143,
-0.6169790029525757,
-0.32249724864959717,
-0.06951366364955902,
-0.18726897239685059,
-0.6849579215049744,
0.09365347772836685,
0.09977222979068756,
0.6541892886161804,
-0.8669936656951904,
0.4811258912086487,
0.6308444142341614,
-0.2211889922618866,
-1.141927719116211,
-0.40571239590644836,
0.30437585711479187,
-0.7522956728935242,
0.7251055836677551,
0.12174345552921295,
-0.22406788170337677,
-0.12469236552715302,
-0.06771808117628098,
-0.8989250063896179,
0.7783504128456116,
0.4022051692008972,
-1.1981678009033203,
-0.27205419540405273,
0.11635041981935501,
0.5832216739654541,
-0.2879772484302521,
0.4247143268585205,
0.7615926861763,
0.7358337044715881,
0.001019038143567741,
-1.3147400617599487,
-0.02106827311217785,
-0.26600807905197144,
0.3814380466938019,
0.14096097648143768,
-0.41891226172447205,
0.9549856781959534,
-0.38906151056289673,
-0.01502789556980133,
0.478990763425827,
0.2878473699092865,
0.13552585244178772,
-0.0695861354470253,
0.48201343417167664,
0.6620153784751892,
0.9101781845092773,
-0.36693593859672546,
1.3303877115249634,
0.19717924296855927,
0.6668379306793213,
1.1343982219696045,
-0.40697231888771057,
0.8284492492675781,
0.2140207439661026,
-0.6191367506980896,
0.45283108949661255,
0.4931476414203644,
-0.23299956321716309,
0.14351408183574677,
0.4231157898902893,
-0.1340954750776291,
-0.2765621840953827,
0.2328375279903412,
-0.21020016074180603,
0.23214302957057953,
0.38067761063575745,
-0.5861559510231018,
-0.2288159430027008,
-0.022811925038695335,
0.3038339912891388,
0.2636796236038208,
-0.627143383026123,
0.6682016849517822,
0.013618153519928455,
-0.7324563264846802,
0.5666376352310181,
0.09015088528394699,
0.7001166939735413,
-0.5251922011375427,
-0.036825891584157944,
-0.287405788898468,
0.3591715097427368,
-0.35222387313842773,
-0.6533618569374084,
-0.05401860177516937,
0.32014113664627075,
-0.07135684043169022,
0.10526164621114731,
0.7808051109313965,
-0.15865173935890198,
-0.5891117453575134,
0.44610360264778137,
0.3167336881160736,
0.22440309822559357,
-0.1603967696428299,
-0.3637838363647461,
0.38007357716560364,
-0.13156992197036743,
-0.1894998401403427,
-0.08164449036121368,
0.2947181761264801,
-0.023027708753943443,
0.5453457236289978,
0.49988892674446106,
0.12365574389696121,
0.18225637078285217,
0.6545301079750061,
0.4882647395133972,
-0.7050266861915588,
-0.5242318511009216,
-1.1492432355880737,
0.44352278113365173,
0.11505461484193802,
-0.3158491253852844,
0.9590739607810974,
0.4996444284915924,
0.6690649390220642,
-0.2546859085559845,
0.7392777800559998,
0.23437340557575226,
0.5051577091217041,
-0.8728023767471313,
0.27518361806869507,
-0.16653920710086823,
0.35083094239234924,
-0.592961311340332,
-1.0402334928512573,
-0.4708602726459503,
0.593122661113739,
-0.6099104285240173,
0.5692079067230225,
0.9895975589752197,
0.8059257864952087,
0.3771209418773651,
0.2689642906188965,
0.6589948534965515,
0.4737779498100281,
0.28483012318611145,
0.5058906078338623,
1.1160374879837036,
-0.19181093573570251,
0.30563628673553467,
0.02520284615457058,
-0.2398400902748108,
-0.5536984205245972,
-0.9481431841850281,
-0.8150084614753723,
-0.2646333575248718,
-0.13797038793563843,
-0.39967772364616394,
0.391263484954834,
0.9757552146911621,
0.3907848298549652,
-0.7036716341972351,
-0.10570187866687775,
-0.07887011021375656,
-0.25207972526550293,
-0.03147250413894653,
-0.15968585014343262,
0.4356991946697235,
-0.7620986104011536,
-0.8064651489257812,
0.5824850797653198,
0.35091137886047363,
-0.006068134214729071,
-0.22715283930301666,
-0.43077290058135986,
-0.06115023419260979,
-0.19999609887599945,
0.6531525254249573,
-0.2617509067058563,
-1.2200541496276855,
-0.5473043918609619,
0.012988991104066372,
-0.2926386594772339,
0.19514405727386475,
0.892755389213562,
-0.46758490800857544,
0.47480353713035583,
0.44597214460372925,
0.7508946061134338,
0.016958480700850487,
0.1743643581867218,
0.546443521976471,
-0.5822908282279968,
-0.16628600656986237,
0.16319216787815094,
0.8576549291610718,
0.6400348544120789,
-0.43387913703918457,
0.6641314625740051,
0.37769192457199097,
-0.7941614985466003,
-0.40287190675735474,
-0.30627167224884033,
-0.8431636691093445,
0.05966104939579964,
1.5552581548690796,
-0.28332582116127014,
-0.0150334807112813,
0.21362341940402985,
-0.3110121488571167,
-0.2562577724456787,
-0.5234705805778503,
0.5160446763038635,
1.383850336074829,
0.031345754861831665,
-0.02588053047657013,
-0.644769012928009,
0.2323179841041565,
0.700002908706665,
-0.8247652053833008,
0.08277048170566559,
0.8726232647895813,
0.4359978437423706,
0.14635807275772095,
0.5972140431404114,
-0.39352136850357056,
0.4017018973827362,
-0.20022259652614594,
-0.02127879112958908,
0.015165437012910843,
-0.27241450548171997,
-0.8558925986289978,
-0.08768091350793839,
0.593666136264801,
0.11160603165626526
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17536v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17536v1
|
ILLUMINER: Instruction-tuned Large Language Models as Few-shot Intent Classifier and Slot Filler
| 2024-03-26T09:41:21 | 2024-03-26T09:41:21 |
Paramita Mirza, Viju Sudhi, Soumya Ranjan Sahoo, Sinchana Ramakanth Bhat
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
State-of-the-art intent classification (IC) and slot filling (SF) methods
often rely on data-intensive deep learning models, limiting their practicality
for industry applications. Large language models on the other hand,
particularly instruction-tuned models (Instruct-LLMs), exhibit remarkable
zero-shot performance across various natural language tasks. This study
evaluates Instruct-LLMs on popular benchmark datasets for IC and SF,
emphasizing their capacity to learn from fewer examples. We introduce
ILLUMINER, an approach framing IC and SF as language generation tasks for
Instruct-LLMs, with a more efficient SF-prompting method compared to prior
work. A comprehensive comparison with multiple baselines shows that our
approach, using the FLAN-T5 11B model, outperforms the state-of-the-art joint
IC+SF method and in-context learning with GPT3.5 (175B), particularly in slot
filling by 11.1--32.2 percentage points. Additionally, our in-depth ablation
study demonstrates that parameter-efficient fine-tuning requires less than 6%
of training data to yield comparable performance with traditional full-weight
fine-tuning.
|
[
-0.22937670350074768,
-0.7521167993545532,
0.4703957438468933,
-0.22498521208763123,
0.004158415365964174,
-0.08990459889173508,
-0.4024272859096527,
-0.40970578789711,
-0.42626312375068665,
0.5647718906402588,
-0.33224132657051086,
-0.6403053998947144,
-0.3072555661201477,
-0.06466388702392578,
-0.28862112760543823,
0.757693886756897,
0.05037025362253189,
0.08988016843795776,
-0.05599159374833107,
0.1273242086172104,
-0.6094290018081665,
0.048503704369068146,
-0.6911038160324097,
-0.44093945622444153,
0.38330283761024475,
0.97225022315979,
0.4972814917564392,
0.5560870170593262,
0.26605167984962463,
0.26190006732940674,
0.29010888934135437,
0.29216626286506653,
-0.47738760709762573,
0.061431750655174255,
-0.011732921004295349,
-0.3439371883869171,
-0.18088723719120026,
-0.054132282733917236,
0.3584292531013489,
0.727532148361206,
-0.19644658267498016,
0.07512326538562775,
0.08291315287351608,
0.46455928683280945,
-0.9090600609779358,
0.12188982963562012,
-0.9299343228340149,
-0.021144937723875046,
-0.28150469064712524,
-0.16518913209438324,
-0.8554945588111877,
-0.2755078375339508,
0.08505037426948547,
-0.3919094204902649,
0.37401747703552246,
0.20826613903045654,
0.5037927031517029,
0.26976820826530457,
-0.21006980538368225,
-0.2918752431869507,
-0.9410678148269653,
0.8242498636245728,
-0.8211401104927063,
0.2728084325790405,
0.4527141749858856,
0.15686066448688507,
-0.18141570687294006,
-0.6554225087165833,
-0.47893550992012024,
-0.14828284084796906,
-0.08922182768583298,
-0.058279819786548615,
-0.1775379776954651,
0.4607537090778351,
0.23827670514583588,
0.4954985976219177,
-0.6801407933235168,
0.6552563905715942,
-0.41950523853302,
0.15435916185379028,
0.5720090270042419,
0.23738695681095123,
0.30825793743133545,
0.16681137681007385,
-0.15139906108379364,
-0.1416739523410797,
-0.8247842788696289,
0.008677768521010876,
0.16986523568630219,
0.33841922879219055,
0.0049707721918821335,
0.5668317079544067,
-0.24277138710021973,
1.0138612985610962,
0.3254529535770416,
-0.21824811398983002,
-0.06581926345825195,
0.01867293380200863,
-0.6362091898918152,
0.45281273126602173,
0.8648197650909424,
0.12919987738132477,
0.19584590196609497,
-0.2274477481842041,
-0.14892809092998505,
-0.13383981585502625,
0.24392595887184143,
-1.0554925203323364,
-0.20269954204559326,
0.08286409080028534,
-0.007912685163319111,
0.00814884528517723,
-0.003514877986162901,
-0.2815088927745819,
-0.33522292971611023,
-0.24739491939544678,
0.411123126745224,
-0.6421942710876465,
0.10722792148590088,
0.41142481565475464,
0.18129974603652954,
0.5546846985816956,
0.48476481437683105,
-1.1288942098617554,
-0.07345312088727951,
0.8339928388595581,
0.7856183052062988,
-0.073244608938694,
-0.055928099900484085,
-0.5846944451332092,
0.3320859968662262,
-0.4338758587837219,
0.7308821678161621,
-0.7760181427001953,
-0.1748746931552887,
0.18025662004947662,
-0.267124205827713,
-0.34448084235191345,
-0.5175670385360718,
0.3763413429260254,
-0.46338939666748047,
0.44096839427948,
0.24883879721164703,
-0.913943350315094,
-0.4037148952484131,
0.09000404179096222,
-0.4333633780479431,
0.9770365953445435,
0.32530859112739563,
-0.3271883726119995,
0.6143611073493958,
-0.661713182926178,
-0.5756381750106812,
0.5074808597564697,
-0.2993817925453186,
-0.40849900245666504,
0.31346601247787476,
0.21289217472076416,
0.7775433659553528,
-0.2232668250799179,
0.07260341942310333,
-0.16815043985843658,
-0.6764295697212219,
0.1832057684659958,
-0.7601186633110046,
0.3285135328769684,
0.0425993837416172,
-0.45817655324935913,
0.13555988669395447,
-0.6908839344978333,
0.12656891345977783,
-0.2030397206544876,
-0.2886456251144409,
-0.2200329601764679,
-0.2575545608997345,
0.0346248559653759,
0.10942137241363525,
-0.09981406480073929,
-0.5369051694869995,
0.3863925337791443,
-0.8261099457740784,
0.41919395327568054,
0.625268280506134,
0.00038565314025618136,
0.6339421272277832,
-0.26649025082588196,
0.6072759032249451,
-0.16124281287193298,
0.05987405776977539,
-0.43161627650260925,
-0.30023467540740967,
-1.0448287725448608,
-0.3090366721153259,
0.21259146928787231,
0.4654270112514496,
-0.7311903238296509,
0.3934723436832428,
-0.2605716586112976,
-0.6268647313117981,
-0.7952553033828735,
0.2822836637496948,
0.5108278393745422,
0.3723689913749695,
0.24732431769371033,
-0.1465217024087906,
-0.07406263053417206,
-0.7220554351806641,
-0.12634719908237457,
0.12519551813602448,
0.10110490769147873,
0.3109849691390991,
0.15645170211791992,
0.05254511162638664,
0.7001820206642151,
-0.3628908693790436,
-0.47925660014152527,
-0.43891578912734985,
0.1771879494190216,
0.25324901938438416,
0.456150621175766,
0.4974716305732727,
-0.35866519808769226,
-0.9460702538490295,
0.23839376866817474,
-0.4955882132053375,
0.20470461249351501,
-0.09876857697963715,
0.08007931709289551,
0.25797519087791443,
0.6264163851737976,
-0.5730685591697693,
0.5322985053062439,
0.31643566489219666,
-0.01889900118112564,
-0.018124902620911598,
-0.09117938578128815,
0.09314922243356705,
-0.9145981073379517,
-0.21418994665145874,
-0.06652086973190308,
-0.022971652448177338,
-0.8522351980209351,
-0.3928905725479126,
0.04007212445139885,
-0.13169939815998077,
-0.801367461681366,
0.7209478616714478,
-0.588704526424408,
0.137445867061615,
-0.5041342377662659,
-0.1515410840511322,
-0.08071336895227432,
0.6000763177871704,
-0.06925015896558762,
0.9807366132736206,
0.5297555923461914,
-0.7774123549461365,
0.04615897312760353,
0.22641752660274506,
-0.8985777497291565,
0.21369332075119019,
-0.48422178626060486,
0.3448394536972046,
-0.2804669141769409,
-0.21689356863498688,
-1.1113171577453613,
-0.5824430584907532,
0.2768210768699646,
-0.09408251196146011,
0.6138468980789185,
-0.4059861898422241,
-0.5471611618995667,
-0.11289273947477341,
-0.10653214156627655,
0.36213427782058716,
0.42900294065475464,
-0.7464303374290466,
0.46666473150253296,
-0.05221312865614891,
-0.07788122445344925,
-0.6855926513671875,
-0.6707862615585327,
-0.2298346757888794,
-0.26885488629341125,
-0.310127854347229,
0.44346296787261963,
0.034878406673669815,
0.07217678427696228,
-0.027436062693595886,
0.04341544210910797,
0.016988089308142662,
0.17307120561599731,
0.24593937397003174,
0.09892076253890991,
-0.43841201066970825,
0.25750625133514404,
0.24379542469978333,
-0.10952881723642349,
-0.28246238827705383,
-0.13037431240081787,
0.6890978217124939,
0.018860679119825363,
-0.7352465391159058,
-0.6943166255950928,
0.1107247844338417,
0.5961626172065735,
-0.2869928777217865,
0.8348699808120728,
0.5540019273757935,
-0.1702868789434433,
-0.5031731724739075,
-0.6211674809455872,
-0.20889422297477722,
-0.5077475905418396,
0.31886813044548035,
-0.12202674895524979,
-0.997314453125,
-0.1347513496875763,
0.04880634322762489,
0.45126649737358093,
0.051362622529268265,
0.3805585205554962,
0.06575991958379745,
1.1667208671569824,
0.6896510720252991,
-0.16320039331912994,
0.9397362470626831,
-0.3069935441017151,
0.4069593846797943,
-0.6234512329101562,
-0.11374573409557343,
-0.31334188580513,
-0.41878730058670044,
-0.36603718996047974,
-0.233133003115654,
0.4080979526042938,
0.11717426031827927,
-0.2561698853969574,
0.106281578540802,
-0.5881612300872803,
0.7929252982139587,
0.5718156695365906,
-0.07655040174722672,
0.17922334372997284,
0.1274714320898056,
0.29525259137153625,
0.10856926441192627,
-0.8470980525016785,
-0.4685106873512268,
1.0910457372665405,
0.010700183920562267,
1.0523549318313599,
0.08744887262582779,
0.6345666646957397,
-0.02947184070944786,
0.5407324433326721,
-1.052655577659607,
0.3369343876838684,
-0.31778332591056824,
-0.45125508308410645,
-0.2776887118816376,
-0.0756521001458168,
-0.9932104349136353,
0.2447373867034912,
-0.19611336290836334,
-0.7352008819580078,
0.07799162715673447,
0.438348650932312,
-0.5576164126396179,
0.40032055974006653,
-0.9253094792366028,
0.8969889283180237,
-0.6023623943328857,
-0.3862769305706024,
-0.11033652722835541,
-0.10269100219011307,
0.43325892090797424,
0.21975448727607727,
-0.20229731500148773,
-0.28646430373191833,
0.06723941117525101,
0.25923046469688416,
-0.051454659551382065,
0.925550639629364,
-0.19368800520896912,
-0.10241939127445221,
0.06868448853492737,
-0.06548219919204712,
0.4964209794998169,
0.021341711282730103,
-0.21353377401828766,
-0.17085087299346924,
-0.517876923084259,
-0.018651556223630905,
-0.6997125148773193,
0.6762591600418091,
-0.4947108030319214,
-0.4323805272579193,
-0.34825682640075684,
-0.4554607570171356,
-0.22644469141960144,
0.32973712682724,
0.6812562942504883,
0.702458918094635,
-0.20716042816638947,
0.6380089521408081,
1.0259501934051514,
-0.21619756519794464,
0.6002470254898071,
0.5627669095993042,
0.003989499527961016,
-0.3048105835914612,
0.7201289534568787,
-0.04323821887373924,
0.23255157470703125,
0.7382835745811462,
-0.020526885986328125,
-0.080960713326931,
-0.76654452085495,
-0.558861255645752,
0.02506856434047222,
-0.4754617512226105,
-0.585188090801239,
-0.599108099937439,
-0.35708680748939514,
-0.12471938878297806,
-0.48912951350212097,
-0.42717763781547546,
-0.03703818842768669,
-0.42696502804756165,
-0.000297067774226889,
0.5042455792427063,
0.6379643082618713,
0.4144507050514221,
0.7190946340560913,
-0.5567544102668762,
0.03453204408288002,
0.23644454777240753,
0.51943039894104,
0.13863831758499146,
-0.4212195873260498,
-0.5431225895881653,
-0.004905170761048794,
-0.27686819434165955,
-0.5316176414489746,
0.2779369652271271,
0.5684762001037598,
0.5507837533950806,
0.709326982498169,
0.12213537842035294,
0.7346668839454651,
-0.4429948031902313,
0.5845741629600525,
0.1548372209072113,
-0.6917001605033875,
0.5824759602546692,
-0.14167095720767975,
0.518295168876648,
0.8670203685760498,
0.2642560303211212,
-0.39015254378318787,
-0.39068931341171265,
-0.3983152508735657,
-0.9831098318099976,
1.1557018756866455,
-0.11648893356323242,
0.29225215315818787,
-0.040940605103969574,
0.34549155831336975,
0.25504809617996216,
0.21514378488063812,
-0.6286565065383911,
-0.25976821780204773,
0.06115426868200302,
-0.6044462323188782,
-0.09570516645908356,
-0.0651017352938652,
0.22044825553894043,
-0.24876448512077332,
0.8233996033668518,
-0.2779107093811035,
0.026051778346300125,
-0.19716764986515045,
-0.45570430159568787,
-0.09881129115819931,
0.7401692271232605,
0.6135857105255127,
0.5287272334098816,
-0.10721684247255325,
-0.13901442289352417,
0.07947937399148941,
-0.33412548899650574,
0.1270570158958435,
0.06634986400604248,
-0.5918962359428406,
-0.17797788977622986,
0.26492807269096375,
1.236186146736145,
0.5673515796661377,
-0.7338499426841736,
0.5465041399002075,
-0.20179703831672668,
-0.14651542901992798,
-0.4263339936733246,
0.7736850380897522,
-0.2606942057609558,
0.07578156143426895,
0.11548104137182236,
-0.028474990278482437,
0.1982053965330124,
-0.37288516759872437,
-0.14899064600467682,
0.6322351694107056,
-0.6538690328598022,
-0.11882398277521133,
0.4447396695613861,
0.08882025629281998,
-0.1079799011349678,
0.8523390889167786,
-0.33120715618133545,
-0.0891905128955841,
0.23845480382442474,
0.5351163148880005,
1.0932320356369019,
-0.1790340691804886,
0.17535534501075745,
0.3532397747039795,
0.31629109382629395,
-0.019363176077604294,
0.15603525936603546,
-0.17286129295825958,
-0.7094305753707886,
-0.5398759841918945,
-0.46353602409362793,
-0.3136797249317169,
0.7364002466201782,
-0.5803620219230652,
0.2702655494213104,
-0.5728811025619507,
0.07668004930019379,
0.09541589021682739,
-0.13067570328712463,
-0.8025383353233337,
-0.10783499479293823,
0.14412419497966766,
0.7250813245773315,
-0.6387247443199158,
0.8199469447135925,
0.8263524770736694,
-0.30560964345932007,
-0.8863440155982971,
0.021554259583353996,
-0.24513700604438782,
-0.5789843797683716,
0.2864948809146881,
0.5663770437240601,
-0.18163754045963287,
0.25667813420295715,
-0.5832434892654419,
-0.694036066532135,
1.0692565441131592,
0.5772454142570496,
-0.6436624526977539,
-0.07062475383281708,
0.13885997235774994,
0.22461774945259094,
-0.471346378326416,
0.3279832899570465,
0.44610828161239624,
0.2860148549079895,
0.04834594950079918,
-0.6774266958236694,
-0.3136712312698364,
0.005342863500118256,
0.11159767955541611,
0.4778594374656677,
-0.5571164488792419,
0.55424565076828,
-0.10267764329910278,
-0.5043788552284241,
0.11821833997964859,
0.7010956406593323,
0.03977632150053978,
0.26639410853385925,
0.3796602189540863,
0.47706666588783264,
0.6846138834953308,
-0.12672773003578186,
0.728071391582489,
-0.2309144139289856,
-0.004279555752873421,
1.1341500282287598,
-0.3163129687309265,
0.8346094489097595,
0.21452759206295013,
0.13825292885303497,
0.5472895503044128,
0.3319910168647766,
-0.07800675928592682,
0.5732276439666748,
-0.10339514911174774,
-0.3292182981967926,
-0.2764066159725189,
-0.12964393198490143,
-0.1932237446308136,
0.8179255127906799,
0.6242089867591858,
-0.19592732191085815,
-0.15617594122886658,
0.29763907194137573,
-0.021049056202173233,
0.004775921814143658,
-0.343682199716568,
1.1120705604553223,
0.027174625545740128,
-0.8529986143112183,
0.4568791389465332,
-0.00029342545894905925,
0.8305045366287231,
-0.5707877278327942,
-0.27299267053604126,
-0.19328244030475616,
0.36464348435401917,
-0.2303648144006729,
-0.68682861328125,
-0.17365729808807373,
0.028281977400183678,
-0.26101624965667725,
-0.21438398957252502,
0.5791972875595093,
-0.7671339511871338,
-0.4203569293022156,
-0.11190485209226608,
0.10279053449630737,
-0.10839936882257462,
0.12310134619474411,
-0.4932328164577484,
-0.19864237308502197,
-0.030847903341054916,
-0.01772386021912098,
0.21173174679279327,
0.33374112844467163,
0.05420311912894249,
0.6426314115524292,
0.4510907232761383,
-0.11923790723085403,
0.11700538545846939,
0.17161446809768677,
0.4347083568572998,
-0.4872855842113495,
-0.3233087956905365,
-0.7505882978439331,
0.45008501410484314,
-0.0014680410968139768,
-0.3785175681114197,
0.7118683457374573,
0.7271733283996582,
1.241097331047058,
-0.2379768341779709,
0.8363061547279358,
0.04581586271524429,
0.3475790023803711,
-0.9153994917869568,
0.48923972249031067,
-0.48339810967445374,
0.3259983956813812,
-0.03614524379372597,
-0.8309963941574097,
-0.15640494227409363,
0.5781478881835938,
-0.41624879837036133,
0.26423925161361694,
0.3088274896144867,
0.8865399360656738,
-0.4600616991519928,
-0.09736648947000504,
0.4265393912792206,
-0.0948663130402565,
0.23102149367332458,
0.6869916319847107,
0.9785637259483337,
-0.4495280683040619,
0.423236608505249,
-0.4020427167415619,
-0.10182354599237442,
-0.6229548454284668,
-0.6206465363502502,
-1.0557243824005127,
-0.29205524921417236,
-0.4949673116207123,
0.15484918653964996,
-0.23943382501602173,
1.0584716796875,
0.8441100120544434,
-0.9033680558204651,
-0.22334323823451996,
-0.22656604647636414,
0.1750575751066208,
-0.29596298933029175,
-0.24440087378025055,
0.2593477666378021,
-0.5586236119270325,
-0.9350345730781555,
0.6631065607070923,
0.458220899105072,
0.1393342912197113,
-0.14784567058086395,
-0.06143907457590103,
0.029067156836390495,
-0.018187616020441055,
0.5671358704566956,
0.3936643898487091,
-0.8262912631034851,
-0.15037019550800323,
0.03398263081908226,
-0.12802165746688843,
0.09588151425123215,
0.8132334351539612,
-0.6317965388298035,
0.4492223262786865,
0.31081438064575195,
0.6932111382484436,
0.5254183411598206,
-0.12165900319814682,
0.5249832272529602,
-0.9998400211334229,
0.16297663748264313,
0.31712523102760315,
0.2740810811519623,
0.4560715854167938,
-0.44264981150627136,
0.3448407053947449,
-0.4445333480834961,
-0.4257428050041199,
-0.8330874443054199,
0.33215582370758057,
-0.7661761045455933,
-0.1747482270002365,
1.024878740310669,
0.2991020679473877,
-0.14079606533050537,
-0.14641186594963074,
-0.11644405871629715,
0.10598838329315186,
-0.4970530569553375,
0.4563583433628082,
0.33354875445365906,
-0.3348393142223358,
-0.49587228894233704,
-0.4763655662536621,
0.7077345848083496,
0.24857401847839355,
-0.7448104023933411,
0.04358971118927002,
0.5217593312263489,
0.10553033649921417,
-0.09396382421255112,
0.6281800866127014,
0.19142931699752808,
0.4584681987762451,
-0.3267503082752228,
0.13120444118976593,
-0.3246692419052124,
-0.44897744059562683,
-0.37678027153015137,
0.09013678878545761,
0.39858555793762207,
-0.15897727012634277
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17534v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17534v1
|
Sparse Logistic Regression with High-order Features for Automatic Grammar Rule Extraction from Treebanks
| 2024-03-26T09:39:53 | 2024-03-26T09:39:53 |
Santiago Herrera, Caio Corro, Sylvain Kahane
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Descriptive grammars are highly valuable, but writing them is time-consuming
and difficult. Furthermore, while linguists typically use corpora to create
them, grammar descriptions often lack quantitative data. As for formal
grammars, they can be challenging to interpret. In this paper, we propose a new
method to extract and explore significant fine-grained grammar patterns and
potential syntactic grammar rules from treebanks, in order to create an
easy-to-understand corpus-based grammar. More specifically, we extract
descriptions and rules across different languages for two linguistic phenomena,
agreement and word order, using a large search space and paying special
attention to the ranking order of the extracted rules. For that, we use a
linear classifier to extract the most salient features that predict the
linguistic phenomena under study. We associate statistical information to each
rule, and we compare the ranking of the model's results to those of other
quantitative and statistical measures. Our method captures both well-known and
less well-known significant grammar rules in Spanish, French, and Wolof.
|
[
-0.23129722476005554,
-1.173888087272644,
0.46601322293281555,
0.5938971638679504,
-0.21121789515018463,
-0.19921879470348358,
-0.2951711416244507,
-0.7336132526397705,
0.3887922763824463,
0.5672012567520142,
-0.3976045548915863,
-0.6302464604377747,
-0.6356149911880493,
0.20948350429534912,
-0.4691874086856842,
1.1055034399032593,
0.21767912805080414,
-0.025390326976776123,
-0.22049209475517273,
0.13848644495010376,
-0.5654374361038208,
-0.7384852766990662,
-0.28667405247688293,
0.13825103640556335,
0.4915567934513092,
0.22448809444904327,
0.7054648399353027,
0.806806206703186,
0.4573955833911896,
0.3424554765224457,
-0.41550564765930176,
0.15123027563095093,
-0.24202831089496613,
0.06886748969554901,
0.06675016134977341,
-0.2519052028656006,
-0.6039440631866455,
-0.34507930278778076,
0.28838613629341125,
0.8942633271217346,
0.00006250845763133839,
0.5238996148109436,
0.0912967324256897,
0.16231068968772888,
-0.46852487325668335,
0.9413416981697083,
-0.49876704812049866,
-0.14770366251468658,
-0.19945217669010162,
-0.1746734082698822,
-0.4049135148525238,
-0.6161722540855408,
0.06095406040549278,
-0.4081611931324005,
0.31407439708709717,
-0.025024211034178734,
0.9799347519874573,
-0.00240070722065866,
-0.06461276113986969,
-0.32386937737464905,
-0.5874989032745361,
0.6151671409606934,
-0.49757057428359985,
0.23588281869888306,
0.5845282077789307,
0.2068004608154297,
-0.24124667048454285,
-0.6221569776535034,
-0.07499037683010101,
0.057381946593523026,
-0.816957950592041,
-0.20860666036605835,
-0.42143791913986206,
0.16213509440422058,
0.3611447215080261,
0.15500390529632568,
-0.7635884284973145,
-0.11603900045156479,
-0.1620018035173416,
-0.19819964468479156,
0.6103934645652771,
0.018713852390646935,
-0.1778370589017868,
-0.5900922417640686,
0.018720563501119614,
0.030561015009880066,
-0.2760651409626007,
0.43992185592651367,
0.07046398520469666,
0.7224596738815308,
0.11619304120540619,
0.4856368899345398,
-0.3690534234046936,
0.6867110133171082,
-0.08131446689367294,
-0.402804970741272,
0.28946787118911743,
-0.39190489053726196,
-0.30503883957862854,
0.05693498253822327,
0.6412323117256165,
0.010126283392310143,
0.10304175317287445,
-0.07511003315448761,
-0.49225592613220215,
0.3383026421070099,
-0.2754339277744293,
-0.596563994884491,
-0.03139868378639221,
-0.1276029497385025,
-0.5625401735305786,
-0.5306574106216431,
0.04735277220606804,
-1.1915438175201416,
-0.001004508463665843,
-0.2420543134212494,
0.18976224958896637,
-0.1485459953546524,
-0.13459919393062592,
0.06070796400308609,
0.1325819194316864,
0.1942974030971527,
0.25548020005226135,
-1.128585934638977,
0.6913886070251465,
0.8557121753692627,
0.6049227118492126,
0.24742688238620758,
0.036243684589862823,
-0.8201949000358582,
-0.18629495799541473,
-0.25682052969932556,
0.7172870635986328,
-0.7283698320388794,
-0.1387016326189041,
0.16352054476737976,
0.19243519008159637,
0.037455763667821884,
-0.5106027722358704,
0.6020681858062744,
-0.227913036942482,
0.24113807082176208,
-0.0017884557601064444,
-0.20424102246761322,
-0.17167262732982635,
-0.09830150753259659,
-0.5799720883369446,
1.3033549785614014,
0.3213789165019989,
-0.2986873388290405,
0.42987099289894104,
-0.20659591257572174,
-0.6321060061454773,
0.3825484812259674,
-0.2397773265838623,
-0.5462056994438171,
0.19216197729110718,
0.11505235731601715,
0.8458184599876404,
-0.14644119143486023,
0.5998521447181702,
-0.2615472376346588,
-0.1363850235939026,
0.03297591581940651,
-0.2601082921028137,
0.8875627517700195,
0.16487714648246765,
-0.49530401825904846,
0.009137831628322601,
-0.9066759347915649,
0.15360726416110992,
0.09348860383033752,
-0.2144351750612259,
-0.5749484300613403,
0.006859536748379469,
0.35866379737854004,
0.09312494844198227,
0.20048613846302032,
-0.24503961205482483,
0.12624235451221466,
-0.3171400725841522,
0.23267489671707153,
0.5566651225090027,
-0.0028419820591807365,
0.20384545624256134,
-0.06686658412218094,
0.444723904132843,
-0.6476147174835205,
0.30465981364250183,
0.009447919204831123,
-0.5215777158737183,
-0.4747875928878784,
-0.5617656707763672,
0.5667592883110046,
0.5599352717399597,
0.13269057869911194,
0.7600047588348389,
-0.07968517392873764,
-0.14165008068084717,
-0.32756146788597107,
0.3853621482849121,
0.5714470148086548,
0.01710810326039791,
0.37091973423957825,
-0.2285677045583725,
-0.7478026747703552,
-0.6099889874458313,
0.11937087774276733,
-0.3367784321308136,
0.29019275307655334,
0.14665192365646362,
0.246541827917099,
-0.05595404654741287,
0.8141944408416748,
-0.7037845253944397,
-0.18483026325702667,
-0.32048213481903076,
0.2743036448955536,
0.2702389657497406,
0.2384285181760788,
0.7060073018074036,
-0.7643610835075378,
-0.2530803382396698,
0.21446147561073303,
-0.6261736154556274,
-0.20751847326755524,
0.056094940751791,
-0.21330250799655914,
0.23537977039813995,
0.7842374444007874,
-0.8678576350212097,
0.45003169775009155,
0.2803534269332886,
-0.7332507371902466,
0.38081130385398865,
0.048516895622015,
-0.31960031390190125,
-0.8058231472969055,
-0.01284683495759964,
0.10706424713134766,
-0.39544835686683655,
-0.586796760559082,
0.0871867761015892,
-0.0649862140417099,
0.1929991990327835,
-0.05830344185233116,
0.4083171784877777,
-0.1903388351202011,
-0.09280848503112793,
0.21007391810417175,
-0.20851953327655792,
-0.11043651401996613,
0.6762243509292603,
0.2277161031961441,
-0.10556729137897491,
0.3469592034816742,
-0.3225249946117401,
0.211027130484581,
0.2419930249452591,
-0.31425195932388306,
0.06020420789718628,
-0.41022488474845886,
-0.5484734177589417,
-0.36108529567718506,
-0.13326174020767212,
-1.045944094657898,
-0.18476811051368713,
0.04778386279940605,
-0.23784002661705017,
0.34020307660102844,
-0.33008646965026855,
-0.6430210471153259,
-0.15440575778484344,
0.15174120664596558,
0.3006730079650879,
0.7028878927230835,
-0.23240123689174652,
0.5445721745491028,
0.40351179242134094,
-0.6327459812164307,
-0.5728245377540588,
-0.13775700330734253,
-0.1432453989982605,
-0.38401350378990173,
-0.12472566962242126,
0.09267350286245346,
0.23784354329109192,
-0.6215832233428955,
0.025467896834015846,
-0.13593298196792603,
-0.20640192925930023,
0.3594183623790741,
0.34710875153541565,
0.42984166741371155,
-0.4441145658493042,
0.03493135794997215,
-0.005989350378513336,
0.09194926172494888,
0.1126052662730217,
-0.24749335646629333,
0.5374125838279724,
-0.22271175682544708,
0.2281711846590042,
-0.26712045073509216,
0.4820278584957123,
0.6733565926551819,
-0.3522171378135681,
0.13426700234413147,
0.4884408712387085,
-0.5997548699378967,
-0.1180730015039444,
-0.5029007196426392,
-0.06953199207782745,
-0.37027329206466675,
0.322496622800827,
-0.39819619059562683,
-0.588426947593689,
0.22291433811187744,
0.1217183917760849,
0.23991835117340088,
0.4643290042877197,
0.29003670811653137,
-0.15323323011398315,
1.1516575813293457,
0.9508376717567444,
-0.04031309485435486,
0.6730000972747803,
-0.056434765458106995,
-0.0760960504412651,
0.2161419540643692,
-0.3245503902435303,
-0.781795859336853,
0.0933782160282135,
-0.7568052411079407,
-0.020989902317523956,
-0.05847042053937912,
0.37570372223854065,
0.08043879270553589,
0.6187635064125061,
-0.10813675820827484,
0.48458003997802734,
0.44689422845840454,
-0.005261764395982027,
0.3656126856803894,
0.2956855595111847,
-0.1651887446641922,
0.23700901865959167,
-0.6218137145042419,
-0.4771071672439575,
0.5576687455177307,
0.20405873656272888,
0.7068238258361816,
0.23892486095428467,
0.8562228083610535,
0.27246999740600586,
0.09878533333539963,
-0.8695625066757202,
0.5866107940673828,
-0.5001921653747559,
-0.26260000467300415,
-0.4837090075016022,
-0.48259007930755615,
-1.24951171875,
0.24788746237754822,
-0.5592057704925537,
-0.7015597820281982,
0.38615912199020386,
0.1333037167787552,
-0.667151927947998,
-0.4121165871620178,
-0.9393929243087769,
1.0897281169891357,
-0.29625022411346436,
-0.3848475515842438,
0.08307947963476181,
-0.6664074659347534,
0.23566141724586487,
-0.011501519940793514,
0.6673852801322937,
-0.22037933766841888,
0.3441751301288605,
0.5932658910751343,
-0.6184712648391724,
1.0832343101501465,
-0.07930635660886765,
-0.03627299144864082,
0.2561337649822235,
0.3871830701828003,
0.5177151560783386,
0.03313927352428436,
0.36330941319465637,
0.04615205526351929,
0.45343315601348877,
-0.5140356421470642,
-0.5944687724113464,
0.4832431972026825,
-0.528772234916687,
-0.31341060996055603,
-0.44057244062423706,
-0.2888047695159912,
-0.06510458886623383,
0.2261309176683426,
-0.08773297071456909,
0.5003141164779663,
-0.3069234788417816,
-0.048485834151506424,
0.42282113432884216,
0.07923279702663422,
0.7154514789581299,
0.24316109716892242,
-0.3588680624961853,
-0.31027087569236755,
0.9354656934738159,
0.07804752141237259,
0.11907508224248886,
0.5297276973724365,
0.3269997239112854,
-0.3140047490596771,
-0.37382152676582336,
-0.2919636070728302,
0.29699182510375977,
-0.5080720782279968,
-0.3101539611816406,
-0.5832565426826477,
-0.12666969001293182,
-0.6060008406639099,
-0.11736250668764114,
0.09582118690013885,
-0.7682799100875854,
-0.19858697056770325,
-0.0397174172103405,
0.4506599009037018,
0.890204668045044,
0.2897125780582428,
0.11581321805715561,
-0.6819465160369873,
0.29053932428359985,
0.2559559941291809,
0.10944210737943649,
-0.3764735758304596,
-0.1276167780160904,
0.008446748368442059,
-0.40022262930870056,
0.08981213718652725,
-0.6185740828514099,
0.7057694792747498,
0.14135389029979706,
0.46943172812461853,
0.37025144696235657,
-0.28503552079200745,
1.1056766510009766,
-0.3632398247718811,
0.19837771356105804,
0.1510418951511383,
-0.8231091499328613,
0.47920742630958557,
-0.1351664513349533,
0.009047983214259148,
0.3596400320529938,
0.32301294803619385,
-0.38907450437545776,
-0.5916925668716431,
-0.7279031276702881,
-0.9323334693908691,
0.598294198513031,
0.3089584410190582,
-0.14008499681949615,
-0.058663323521614075,
0.3569178581237793,
0.24586310982704163,
0.1502063274383545,
-0.8440713286399841,
0.04687020555138588,
-0.074790358543396,
-0.6995712518692017,
-0.2671208381652832,
-0.29787200689315796,
0.11526141315698624,
-0.24121521413326263,
0.4526558518409729,
-0.12555265426635742,
-0.0943436250090599,
-0.133910670876503,
-0.2795787453651428,
-0.28674331307411194,
0.31668153405189514,
0.3004315495491028,
0.41375380754470825,
-0.34490126371383667,
0.4609445035457611,
-0.0847267284989357,
-0.39722076058387756,
-0.031786590814590454,
0.5051684975624084,
-0.3371533453464508,
0.3688008487224579,
0.6346930861473083,
0.40826714038848877,
0.5181112885475159,
-0.8861018419265747,
0.5484325289726257,
-0.10703042894601822,
-0.27026236057281494,
-0.21576710045337677,
-0.1400156468153,
-0.2650291621685028,
0.49337998032569885,
0.02975170686841011,
0.2792079746723175,
0.16222579777240753,
-0.7487455010414124,
0.3631930649280548,
0.46571430563926697,
-0.07459037005901337,
-0.27354520559310913,
0.1949998140335083,
-0.12399852275848389,
-0.11043547093868256,
-0.005640349816530943,
-0.37008172273635864,
-0.20412535965442657,
0.4899107813835144,
0.5526335835456848,
0.5551914572715759,
-0.07434794306755066,
0.3236404061317444,
0.39672568440437317,
0.07385259866714478,
-0.4513271152973175,
0.40570563077926636,
-0.11983846127986908,
-0.22555392980575562,
-0.5248389840126038,
-1.2048070430755615,
0.2765752971172333,
0.14356385171413422,
-0.8216180205345154,
0.5824111700057983,
-0.5402998924255371,
-0.04851437360048294,
0.5320470333099365,
-0.13497337698936462,
-0.486519455909729,
-0.1331355720758438,
0.22116820514202118,
0.34299397468566895,
-1.0659682750701904,
0.5467446446418762,
0.4629891812801361,
-0.33326655626296997,
-0.556995689868927,
-0.13377155363559723,
-0.07173527777194977,
-0.7532896399497986,
0.7062304615974426,
0.03291664272546768,
0.11252842098474503,
-0.09089015424251556,
-0.36476314067840576,
-1.1796413660049438,
0.704433798789978,
0.35722944140434265,
-0.6273484230041504,
-0.5230182409286499,
-0.030960800126194954,
0.701376736164093,
-0.30070120096206665,
0.29845523834228516,
0.60178142786026,
0.3145384192466736,
0.07257567346096039,
-0.9723156094551086,
0.2062847763299942,
-0.1146906241774559,
0.026260999962687492,
0.4558018147945404,
-0.4159109890460968,
0.5816381573677063,
-0.05186538025736809,
-0.24708868563175201,
0.19990789890289307,
0.4728442430496216,
-0.14460952579975128,
0.23699471354484558,
0.5934588313102722,
0.2725715637207031,
0.9482234716415405,
-0.1325562596321106,
0.5530670285224915,
-0.0933152437210083,
0.45699504017829895,
0.9880503416061401,
-0.0715303122997284,
0.9530004262924194,
0.21417121589183807,
-0.06748508661985397,
0.7050796151161194,
0.9448548555374146,
-0.02960408478975296,
0.44180968403816223,
0.10648223757743835,
-0.2482570856809616,
-0.2942626476287842,
-0.19645237922668457,
0.06088728830218315,
0.6871114373207092,
0.4518401324748993,
-0.5470905900001526,
-0.41494011878967285,
-0.1892484575510025,
0.18002928793430328,
0.12154363840818405,
-0.5533376336097717,
1.1515251398086548,
-0.2161710262298584,
-0.7232718467712402,
1.045778751373291,
-0.04715178534388542,
0.30161991715431213,
-0.42385196685791016,
-0.4379331171512604,
-0.14109115302562714,
0.0548296719789505,
-0.3958270847797394,
-0.3220630884170532,
0.07838326692581177,
0.29362842440605164,
-0.09730041027069092,
-0.39674097299575806,
0.3389371633529663,
-0.5978113412857056,
-0.7449721097946167,
0.3187800943851471,
0.7143751382827759,
0.2802979052066803,
0.42148128151893616,
-0.4058917760848999,
-0.10186725854873657,
-0.227780282497406,
0.11016976833343506,
0.2517840266227722,
0.5506398677825928,
-0.5479304194450378,
0.05132988840341568,
0.5090069770812988,
0.2170984447002411,
0.2200385332107544,
-0.04089949652552605,
0.5448996424674988,
-0.8197997808456421,
-0.4600208103656769,
-0.9592597484588623,
0.04258603975176811,
0.21287895739078522,
-0.1030699610710144,
0.4670250713825226,
0.731586754322052,
0.8855775594711304,
0.06668701767921448,
0.7747156620025635,
-0.4056326448917389,
0.18516455590724945,
-0.6614298820495605,
0.03003896027803421,
-0.2631964087486267,
0.13199540972709656,
-0.4662831723690033,
-0.905876100063324,
-0.6856483221054077,
0.6660802960395813,
-0.016686441376805305,
-0.3020734190940857,
0.7200102806091309,
0.8587235808372498,
-0.1356302946805954,
-0.0063528576865792274,
0.3317471742630005,
0.5138483047485352,
-0.007274629548192024,
0.34152138233184814,
0.5325541496276855,
-0.07721724361181259,
0.8431895971298218,
-0.3974103331565857,
-0.44897744059562683,
-0.4846346378326416,
-0.605684220790863,
-0.8449110984802246,
-0.559550940990448,
-0.23024022579193115,
-0.6159542798995972,
0.08018975704908371,
1.3678092956542969,
0.6843443512916565,
-0.9394323825836182,
-0.4690077006816864,
-0.3745470941066742,
0.27275365591049194,
-0.6975821852684021,
-0.31184640526771545,
0.5140178203582764,
-0.6681199669837952,
-0.6668225526809692,
0.1990644782781601,
0.028020301833748817,
0.30877798795700073,
0.13602755963802338,
0.17955951392650604,
-0.22394315898418427,
-0.24186639487743378,
0.9454993605613708,
0.29977256059646606,
-0.7743552327156067,
-0.22333954274654388,
0.08500024676322937,
-0.1201815977692604,
0.008762084878981113,
0.7431222796440125,
-0.6880577802658081,
0.15420636534690857,
0.5020902156829834,
0.35037535429000854,
0.4997847378253937,
0.12739434838294983,
0.20736879110336304,
-0.8130237460136414,
0.06136627867817879,
0.11462175846099854,
0.4573037028312683,
-0.18976038694381714,
-0.5054588913917542,
0.3575599193572998,
0.5325779914855957,
-0.11328252404928207,
-0.937527060508728,
0.10825150460004807,
-1.1062415838241577,
-0.4112975001335144,
1.343796730041504,
-0.07606671005487442,
-0.4500381648540497,
-0.3199208378791809,
-0.2832164466381073,
-0.03605412691831589,
-0.4807739853858948,
0.7525274157524109,
0.5108328461647034,
-0.30688220262527466,
-0.06612256914377213,
-0.4919169545173645,
0.7789306640625,
0.3464595675468445,
-0.6524721384048462,
0.5258910059928894,
0.7728029489517212,
0.16064031422138214,
0.26983150839805603,
0.3434169590473175,
-0.2831459045410156,
0.2486415058374405,
-0.1134319007396698,
-0.0513615757226944,
0.3791280686855316,
-0.626880407333374,
-0.46507343649864197,
0.48421722650527954,
0.27926263213157654,
0.30923229455947876
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17528v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17528v1
|
Multilingual Sentence-T5: Scalable Sentence Encoders for Multilingual Applications
| 2024-03-26T09:31:55 | 2024-03-26T09:31:55 |
Chihiro Yano, Akihiko Fukuchi, Shoko Fukasawa, Hideyuki Tachibana, Yotaro Watanabe
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Prior work on multilingual sentence embedding has demonstrated that the
efficient use of natural language inference (NLI) data to build
high-performance models can outperform conventional methods. However, the
potential benefits from the recent ``exponential'' growth of language models
with billions of parameters have not yet been fully explored. In this paper, we
introduce Multilingual Sentence T5 (m-ST5), as a larger model of NLI-based
multilingual sentence embedding, by extending Sentence T5, an existing
monolingual model. By employing the low-rank adaptation (LoRA) technique, we
have achieved a successful scaling of the model's size to 5.7 billion
parameters. We conducted experiments to evaluate the performance of sentence
embedding and verified that the method outperforms the NLI-based prior
approach. Furthermore, we also have confirmed a positive correlation between
the size of the model and its performance. It was particularly noteworthy that
languages with fewer resources or those with less linguistic similarity to
English benefited more from the parameter increase. Our model is available at
https://huggingface.co/pkshatech/m-ST5.
|
[
-0.28860512375831604,
-0.7236403822898865,
0.4096209704875946,
0.5328598022460938,
-0.31958073377609253,
-0.10368560254573822,
-0.3234756290912628,
-0.6766570210456848,
0.3517918586730957,
0.4457564949989319,
-0.4047809839248657,
-0.4570658504962921,
-0.6771599054336548,
0.4617282748222351,
-0.2411823272705078,
0.7541218400001526,
0.08208920061588287,
-0.010296429507434368,
-0.27571383118629456,
-0.5091568231582642,
-0.4635075330734253,
-0.6603212356567383,
-0.5685641169548035,
0.04651429131627083,
0.7198412418365479,
0.5433267951011658,
0.5585672855377197,
0.5873114466667175,
0.5162822008132935,
0.20373235642910004,
0.05544520542025566,
0.16914108395576477,
-0.391279399394989,
-0.05022435635328293,
0.2696489691734314,
-0.6134985089302063,
-0.5472201704978943,
-0.3082784414291382,
0.8121308088302612,
0.8577225208282471,
-0.31285008788108826,
0.10831650346517563,
-0.09986414015293121,
0.35955867171287537,
-0.6378499269485474,
0.02327343448996544,
-0.26674190163612366,
0.2729428708553314,
-0.08911219239234924,
0.1645749807357788,
-0.8014147877693176,
-0.2918592095375061,
-0.23339249193668365,
-0.47230464220046997,
-0.2991124391555786,
0.23896312713623047,
0.534714937210083,
0.30373281240463257,
-0.6498222351074219,
-0.0788189172744751,
-0.48656436800956726,
0.8393890261650085,
-0.84630286693573,
0.6011679172515869,
0.06287288665771484,
0.25881481170654297,
0.21526256203651428,
-0.6565435528755188,
-0.40411415696144104,
-0.34213536977767944,
0.11641094833612442,
0.12180178612470627,
-0.023838456720113754,
-0.034747328609228134,
0.31200215220451355,
0.2233055680990219,
-0.5540546178817749,
0.2693885564804077,
-0.3381578028202057,
0.2483985275030136,
0.5036320686340332,
-0.01329525001347065,
0.21118304133415222,
-0.21692955493927002,
-0.36810219287872314,
0.021447889506816864,
-0.6819643378257751,
-0.00237840274348855,
0.3389328122138977,
0.4153318405151367,
-0.41050463914871216,
0.5473212599754333,
-0.04025914520025253,
0.578665554523468,
-0.21371878683567047,
-0.2554449737071991,
0.37387287616729736,
-0.6285626292228699,
-0.014011933468282223,
0.1698123663663864,
0.7067954540252686,
0.18623188138008118,
0.3868167996406555,
-0.3037640452384949,
0.1453568935394287,
0.06961444765329361,
0.20444966852664948,
-1.0484694242477417,
0.22488538920879364,
0.29825106263160706,
-0.5951066017150879,
-0.2703559398651123,
0.06601941585540771,
-0.6848160028457642,
-0.31875789165496826,
0.31010371446609497,
0.1423453539609909,
-0.476098895072937,
-0.02354777604341507,
0.3673842251300812,
-0.17388449609279633,
0.30826327204704285,
0.05692271143198013,
-0.8975731730461121,
0.21070913970470428,
0.42176681756973267,
0.8493872284889221,
-0.019886959344148636,
-0.6392540335655212,
-0.6226813793182373,
0.23989328742027283,
-0.23356035351753235,
0.6433489322662354,
-0.7982695698738098,
-0.3215062916278839,
0.07829910516738892,
-0.041808925569057465,
-0.0025117197073996067,
-0.35186922550201416,
0.9230003952980042,
-0.34197691082954407,
0.439839631319046,
-0.11915070563554764,
-0.5019745826721191,
0.021167578175663948,
0.23576830327510834,
-0.7872374057769775,
0.9101625680923462,
-0.15148267149925232,
-0.7027453780174255,
0.4999393820762634,
-1.0896481275558472,
-0.5994309782981873,
-0.05390119180083275,
0.10272959619760513,
-0.4866519868373871,
0.19787779450416565,
0.4533612132072449,
0.2532200217247009,
-0.42083385586738586,
-0.01880698651075363,
-0.7370132207870483,
-0.22710171341896057,
0.14740236103534698,
-0.5321999788284302,
0.6507010459899902,
0.12826238572597504,
0.1358613222837448,
0.15723708271980286,
-0.6613052487373352,
0.010208665393292904,
0.11356962472200394,
-0.44079524278640747,
-0.20532049238681793,
-0.16042950749397278,
0.3710375130176544,
0.28011393547058105,
0.3389461934566498,
-0.8880972266197205,
0.400569349527359,
-0.4242353141307831,
0.7853814363479614,
0.39328330755233765,
0.06532619148492813,
0.47271963953971863,
-0.15503276884555817,
0.5333673357963562,
0.47072872519493103,
0.1650015264749527,
-0.3710635304450989,
-0.4837648868560791,
-0.7182224988937378,
-0.15044288337230682,
0.5691640973091125,
0.5089124441146851,
-0.694876492023468,
0.29141175746917725,
-0.6542567014694214,
-0.18362799286842346,
-0.8833027482032776,
0.031235238537192345,
0.044988106936216354,
-0.014874088577926159,
0.37776219844818115,
0.03218555077910423,
-0.6884565949440002,
-1.0211470127105713,
-0.4067230522632599,
0.1246446967124939,
0.14983031153678894,
0.1389172077178955,
0.6882400512695312,
-0.31521403789520264,
0.6549645662307739,
-0.4233807623386383,
-0.10306844860315323,
-0.649701714515686,
0.052194491028785706,
0.2714111804962158,
0.4508422911167145,
0.6635200381278992,
-0.7855261564254761,
-0.42473748326301575,
0.10147828608751297,
-0.8960453271865845,
0.0638643130660057,
-0.04121441766619682,
0.08460581302642822,
0.28350865840911865,
0.5237178206443787,
-0.4984703063964844,
0.1442231833934784,
0.7128018736839294,
-0.36121633648872375,
0.14679865539073944,
-0.7201634049415588,
0.08359640091657639,
-1.6067867279052734,
-0.07130125910043716,
-0.0017485233256593347,
-0.4880901277065277,
-0.5580431818962097,
0.3111990690231323,
0.14748401939868927,
-0.32153722643852234,
-0.3904203176498413,
0.3420695960521698,
-0.4450252950191498,
-0.2007247507572174,
-0.016981512308120728,
0.2417566031217575,
-0.02900836244225502,
0.381556898355484,
-0.2060689777135849,
0.7664188742637634,
0.3117179870605469,
-0.3431183397769928,
0.3057858645915985,
0.2217981368303299,
-0.342600017786026,
0.5829032063484192,
-0.7491207122802734,
0.10217679291963577,
-0.1841275990009308,
0.16193704307079315,
-0.7441329956054688,
-0.16714917123317719,
-0.1379743069410324,
-0.2042822241783142,
-0.21193861961364746,
-0.030942514538764954,
-0.7479314804077148,
-0.24159973859786987,
-0.3549826145172119,
0.34790003299713135,
0.3485276401042938,
-0.5662177801132202,
0.6612769365310669,
0.30141961574554443,
-0.1152154952287674,
-0.43750572204589844,
-1.0346133708953857,
0.43448352813720703,
-0.5722965002059937,
-0.6880425214767456,
0.18892157077789307,
-0.19693875312805176,
-0.013112868182361126,
-0.13077197968959808,
0.3464949429035187,
-0.09851797670125961,
0.10699211806058884,
0.010825635865330696,
-0.01585150510072708,
-0.4978717267513275,
0.12866032123565674,
0.17059093713760376,
-0.11728904396295547,
-0.11483440548181534,
-0.4671475291252136,
0.313111811876297,
-0.20715992152690887,
-0.2500247359275818,
-0.15494580566883087,
0.7897087335586548,
0.7505689859390259,
-0.40222084522247314,
1.094435453414917,
0.7756404876708984,
-0.40585342049598694,
-0.24736541509628296,
-0.3284146785736084,
-0.012496615760028362,
-0.4081242084503174,
0.4285924434661865,
-0.8258767127990723,
-1.0386207103729248,
0.45542430877685547,
-0.0725453570485115,
-0.10699944943189621,
0.3021184802055359,
0.20746469497680664,
0.04315580055117607,
0.9784920811653137,
0.8997800350189209,
-0.28105783462524414,
0.45091405510902405,
0.0267951600253582,
0.36650243401527405,
-0.6814314126968384,
0.23998041450977325,
-0.4188763201236725,
-0.30578985810279846,
-0.8812929391860962,
-0.4985977113246918,
0.5954485535621643,
0.024027323350310326,
-0.19012726843357086,
0.29199615120887756,
0.0021812361665070057,
0.432258665561676,
0.5126506686210632,
0.02317808009684086,
0.32869237661361694,
0.06652650982141495,
-0.1345217227935791,
-0.20775990188121796,
-0.9680062532424927,
-0.38674554228782654,
0.8555856347084045,
0.3268830478191376,
0.6161977052688599,
0.6970917582511902,
0.6188943982124329,
0.3494276702404022,
-0.07756618410348892,
-0.6419291496276855,
0.3931609094142914,
-0.6293426156044006,
-0.22006365656852722,
-0.3186214864253998,
-0.4159523546695709,
-0.9626723527908325,
0.5850784778594971,
-0.3330303430557251,
-0.5991373062133789,
0.08646790683269501,
-0.27282965183258057,
-0.362356036901474,
0.13145838677883148,
-1.056054949760437,
1.2179977893829346,
-0.2466103434562683,
-0.31778669357299805,
-0.293817937374115,
-0.46179503202438354,
-0.000048500049160793424,
-0.037905119359493256,
0.2664479613304138,
0.17115895450115204,
-0.21801622211933136,
0.5601087808609009,
-0.2549442946910858,
0.6753926277160645,
-0.21351367235183716,
-0.06930814683437347,
-0.1347786784172058,
-0.39687293767929077,
0.513957142829895,
0.05454658716917038,
-0.2306518405675888,
-0.03229993209242821,
0.09713712334632874,
-0.7087926268577576,
-0.8001894354820251,
0.7066925168037415,
-0.6089425683021545,
-0.3654021918773651,
-0.15488198399543762,
-0.6126437187194824,
-0.34441399574279785,
0.34383928775787354,
-0.027061237022280693,
0.4231194853782654,
-0.39902687072753906,
0.7005235552787781,
0.3947691023349762,
-0.34034252166748047,
0.8972650170326233,
0.13253900408744812,
-0.23076966404914856,
-0.40470683574676514,
0.6473399996757507,
0.1125190407037735,
0.15696598589420319,
0.6765324473381042,
0.18510973453521729,
-0.21287183463573456,
-0.49327585101127625,
-0.6694462895393372,
0.29483142495155334,
-0.5395697951316833,
0.211368128657341,
-0.7297565937042236,
0.15606257319450378,
-0.5623576641082764,
-0.2037205696105957,
-0.2310342788696289,
-0.4636896550655365,
0.009390260092914104,
-0.26947471499443054,
0.296650230884552,
0.6753398180007935,
0.145308256149292,
0.29413050413131714,
-0.7344894409179688,
0.24618613719940186,
-0.1497461050748825,
0.2845427393913269,
-0.19814087450504303,
-0.4790540337562561,
-0.5715237855911255,
0.06927957385778427,
0.04854631796479225,
-0.5775618553161621,
0.5551764369010925,
0.5439180731773376,
0.41646382212638855,
0.37102195620536804,
0.02777770720422268,
0.8209112882614136,
-0.5850697159767151,
0.708708643913269,
-0.035966161638498306,
-0.8342134952545166,
0.3532038927078247,
-0.3821374475955963,
0.8167168498039246,
0.27113762497901917,
0.1720670610666275,
-0.5743613243103027,
-0.3075563311576843,
-0.37399736046791077,
-0.7529072165489197,
0.5003613829612732,
0.03711214289069176,
0.2970096468925476,
0.1120588481426239,
0.35429146885871887,
0.04916803911328316,
0.2545039653778076,
-1.0464656352996826,
-0.09119503945112228,
-0.219575896859169,
-0.46061134338378906,
-0.42223602533340454,
-0.3777289390563965,
0.2324315905570984,
0.024593066424131393,
0.2828584611415863,
-0.4246330261230469,
0.5467571020126343,
-0.014380610547959805,
-0.48678624629974365,
0.3333567678928375,
0.621789276599884,
0.808793306350708,
0.327959269285202,
-0.11798795312643051,
0.11021582782268524,
0.6124747395515442,
-0.275093674659729,
-0.05298500880599022,
0.1112435907125473,
0.16202016174793243,
-0.1216428354382515,
0.6716154217720032,
1.0478482246398926,
0.4614470303058624,
-0.5049946308135986,
0.4580112099647522,
-0.11171441525220871,
-0.06548500806093216,
-0.35133662819862366,
-0.2715660333633423,
0.3139144480228424,
0.25587916374206543,
0.16510769724845886,
-0.05831785872578621,
0.12168624997138977,
-0.6755192279815674,
0.17323938012123108,
0.07613822817802429,
-0.33721402287483215,
-0.23022648692131042,
0.7468239665031433,
0.2179516702890396,
-0.07584372162818909,
0.4373287260532379,
-0.10212721675634384,
-0.20050890743732452,
0.4698134958744049,
0.7521349787712097,
0.6269559264183044,
-0.13681931793689728,
0.22069494426250458,
0.3604399859905243,
0.49681445956230164,
0.061074428260326385,
0.4273523688316345,
0.13556647300720215,
-0.8708632588386536,
-0.44899651408195496,
-0.4735654592514038,
-0.2896426022052765,
-0.30619022250175476,
-0.6205639243125916,
-0.04459719732403755,
-0.1645735204219818,
0.06849566102027893,
0.17282381653785706,
-0.16156071424484253,
-0.4366821348667145,
0.07898565381765366,
0.2302219569683075,
0.9388535618782043,
-0.8629752397537231,
1.0927810668945312,
0.7161425352096558,
-0.5915189385414124,
-0.3407851457595825,
-0.032871052622795105,
-0.4729437530040741,
-0.4047382175922394,
0.5394029021263123,
0.26213619112968445,
-0.24883392453193665,
0.054362691938877106,
-0.26038408279418945,
-0.7593129277229309,
0.9967189431190491,
0.8091932535171509,
-0.2950923442840576,
-0.10224155336618423,
0.5385513305664062,
0.6981505751609802,
-0.92859947681427,
0.22323021292686462,
0.22702139616012573,
0.43639543652534485,
-0.06434447318315506,
-0.7718909382820129,
0.0019276767270639539,
-0.2909647226333618,
0.29787442088127136,
0.13587531447410583,
-0.6364348530769348,
0.8500634431838989,
-0.3674333095550537,
0.07648415863513947,
0.07549510896205902,
0.7998426556587219,
0.09006983786821365,
-0.07062871009111404,
0.36821162700653076,
0.6199663877487183,
0.8357530832290649,
-0.025392351672053337,
1.476775884628296,
-0.41119569540023804,
0.2394619584083557,
1.1204822063446045,
-0.3992467224597931,
1.389978289604187,
0.4494484066963196,
0.013762744143605232,
0.7732005715370178,
0.522249698638916,
-0.011164194904267788,
0.5181900858879089,
-0.2111607939004898,
-0.2402697503566742,
-0.23410353064537048,
-0.2355366349220276,
-0.1924392729997635,
0.5346195697784424,
0.24552305042743683,
-0.35947707295417786,
0.025679394602775574,
0.3862532675266266,
-0.0059273685328662395,
-0.12527646124362946,
-0.2269788533449173,
0.6678797006607056,
0.09641414135694504,
-0.5438559055328369,
0.5292709469795227,
0.31541383266448975,
0.7489286065101624,
-0.42509815096855164,
0.14605948328971863,
-0.2901374101638794,
0.4174410104751587,
-0.08587142080068588,
-0.42745688557624817,
0.32615113258361816,
0.00003044664117624052,
-0.2936559319496155,
-0.47054722905158997,
0.5182512998580933,
-0.6783398985862732,
-0.7276278138160706,
0.43040868639945984,
0.7053259015083313,
-0.020818402990698814,
0.18612131476402283,
-0.5877140164375305,
-0.024211635813117027,
-0.12579363584518433,
0.07823391258716583,
0.3202085494995117,
0.42055007815361023,
-0.07987955212593079,
0.809045672416687,
0.39784911274909973,
-0.04176311939954758,
0.08968018740415573,
0.40271222591400146,
0.47642800211906433,
-0.8713942766189575,
-0.7901046872138977,
-0.748462975025177,
0.4789223372936249,
-0.1351284384727478,
-0.3209664225578308,
0.897334635257721,
0.7295629382133484,
0.687926173210144,
-0.24818913638591766,
0.8032709360122681,
0.20311538875102997,
0.36607393622398376,
-0.6169182658195496,
0.6044133901596069,
-0.6168845295906067,
0.008430879563093185,
-0.005390083882957697,
-0.767301619052887,
-0.4388399124145508,
0.5388829708099365,
-0.3733801245689392,
0.2735466957092285,
1.0844054222106934,
0.5510154366493225,
-0.21732540428638458,
0.03204740211367607,
0.4779847264289856,
0.397674560546875,
0.09027332812547684,
0.6343933343887329,
0.48439836502075195,
-0.6295463442802429,
0.43925201892852783,
0.1185562014579773,
0.2178330272436142,
-0.1047392189502716,
-0.8647220730781555,
-0.7472309470176697,
-0.461120069026947,
-0.31455129384994507,
0.013250667601823807,
0.1266917586326599,
0.8670071363449097,
0.791596531867981,
-0.8037992119789124,
-0.4167020916938782,
0.009129336103796959,
0.0736451968550682,
-0.2800736725330353,
-0.126023069024086,
0.05709751695394516,
-0.28892844915390015,
-0.8776453137397766,
0.6164289116859436,
0.30137163400650024,
-0.1803896278142929,
-0.29181912541389465,
0.021782953292131424,
-0.5407401323318481,
0.16535425186157227,
0.9279011487960815,
-0.14726538956165314,
-0.7005499601364136,
-0.439424991607666,
-0.021230528131127357,
-0.050147395581007004,
0.25591254234313965,
0.560063898563385,
-0.45546090602874756,
0.22637823224067688,
0.2263079732656479,
0.766956090927124,
0.5502581000328064,
-0.08014827221632004,
0.8056483864784241,
-0.9226757884025574,
0.39080002903938293,
-0.23937688767910004,
0.60233473777771,
0.49522683024406433,
-0.19987468421459198,
0.512299656867981,
0.08867603540420532,
-0.2556251585483551,
-0.784679114818573,
0.22572439908981323,
-0.9144800305366516,
-0.16464994847774506,
1.2006155252456665,
-0.24624767899513245,
-0.24773375689983368,
0.0978941097855568,
-0.09418502449989319,
-0.08763036876916885,
-0.4262521266937256,
0.5438057780265808,
0.873741090297699,
0.11169186234474182,
-0.7898393273353577,
-0.6983848214149475,
0.0857330858707428,
0.3964729905128479,
-1.0994009971618652,
-0.2249334752559662,
0.3368893265724182,
-0.07132911682128906,
0.16586120426654816,
0.18748381733894348,
0.11774320900440216,
0.1266627311706543,
0.28395557403564453,
0.08865050971508026,
-0.09946766495704651,
-0.1351369172334671,
-0.5788506865501404,
0.8109412789344788,
0.28509512543678284,
-0.28622785210609436
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17524v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17524v1
|
Provably Secure Disambiguating Neural Linguistic Steganography
| 2024-03-26T09:25:57 | 2024-03-26T09:25:57 |
Yuang Qi, Kejiang Chen, Kai Zeng, Weiming Zhang, Nenghai Yu
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL
|
Recent research in provably secure neural linguistic steganography has
overlooked a crucial aspect: the sender must detokenize stegotexts to avoid
raising suspicion from the eavesdropper. The segmentation ambiguity problem,
which arises when using language models based on subwords, leads to occasional
decoding failures in all neural language steganography implementations based on
these models. Current solutions to this issue involve altering the probability
distribution of candidate words, rendering them incompatible with provably
secure steganography. We propose a novel secure disambiguation method named
SyncPool, which effectively addresses the segmentation ambiguity problem. We
group all tokens with prefix relationships in the candidate pool before the
steganographic embedding algorithm runs to eliminate uncertainty among
ambiguous tokens. To enable the receiver to synchronize the sampling process of
the sender, a shared cryptographically-secure pseudorandom number generator
(CSPRNG) is deployed to select a token from the ambiguity pool. SyncPool does
not change the size of the candidate pool or the distribution of tokens and
thus is applicable to provably secure language steganography methods. We
provide theoretical proofs and experimentally demonstrate the applicability of
our solution to various languages and models, showing its potential to
significantly improve the reliability and security of neural linguistic
steganography systems.
|
[
-0.32250651717185974,
-0.6863073110580444,
0.21444186568260193,
0.17560477554798126,
-0.8695265650749207,
0.32630741596221924,
-0.0940454751253128,
-0.45323821902275085,
0.3711526095867157,
-0.06457031518220901,
-0.46809953451156616,
-0.16034649312496185,
-0.9591915011405945,
0.10263187438249588,
-0.5245335102081299,
0.34414857625961304,
0.07851871103048325,
0.487774521112442,
0.16948992013931274,
-0.22796116769313812,
-0.37429922819137573,
-0.5769765973091125,
-0.4163754880428314,
-0.19670450687408447,
0.2676616311073303,
-0.17479968070983887,
1.148701786994934,
0.6832655072212219,
0.5084101557731628,
0.4481107294559479,
-0.5136620402336121,
0.4201601445674896,
-0.20693650841712952,
0.5861310958862305,
-0.34552985429763794,
-0.3512691855430603,
0.060128968209028244,
-0.28502586483955383,
0.6371830105781555,
0.4031054675579071,
-0.14807668328285217,
-0.03677613288164139,
-0.31568536162376404,
0.6001985669136047,
-0.8027582764625549,
-0.1836772859096527,
-0.8020449876785278,
-0.016136080026626587,
-0.796406626701355,
0.058699578046798706,
-0.2732049226760864,
-0.21087808907032013,
0.046228520572185516,
-0.387055903673172,
0.10235511511564255,
0.4232930839061737,
0.8281483054161072,
0.3132335841655731,
0.2002485692501068,
-0.1841408908367157,
-0.34842947125434875,
0.5661967396736145,
-0.44340503215789795,
0.5382106304168701,
0.7281886339187622,
0.11494056135416031,
-0.02691986970603466,
-0.8024746179580688,
-0.5403022766113281,
0.24299558997154236,
0.00760218221694231,
-0.17535145580768585,
-0.09249860793352127,
0.16182614862918854,
-0.05922345817089081,
0.43930232524871826,
-0.4857231676578522,
0.03480558469891548,
-0.17207825183868408,
-0.5782535672187805,
0.41401779651641846,
-0.2589223086833954,
0.518983006477356,
-0.025427695363759995,
-0.4903087317943573,
0.07469848543405533,
-0.5900716185569763,
-0.4252323806285858,
0.6928708553314209,
0.19543014466762543,
0.4089760184288025,
0.26726865768432617,
0.22800946235656738,
0.4826858937740326,
0.1503008008003235,
0.3490467667579651,
0.32896485924720764,
-0.1644972413778305,
-0.23027127981185913,
0.3161870837211609,
0.8535192608833313,
0.04332511126995087,
0.009884625673294067,
-0.3074132204055786,
-0.1561317890882492,
-0.12058047205209732,
0.028503119945526123,
-0.5642250180244446,
-0.38000792264938354,
0.3375011682510376,
-0.3541146516799927,
-0.26649942994117737,
0.05410519242286682,
-0.7185528874397278,
-0.4093223512172699,
0.16928933560848236,
0.3605063855648041,
-0.49181321263313293,
-0.31054502725601196,
0.025559386238455772,
-0.15597321093082428,
-0.21375034749507904,
-0.08917804062366486,
-0.9538576602935791,
0.20120175182819366,
0.619382917881012,
0.9625162482261658,
0.014014429412782192,
-0.10958489030599594,
-0.2921070158481598,
-0.1676400899887085,
-0.25502416491508484,
0.18960867822170258,
-0.5391948223114014,
-0.1378503441810608,
-0.025991296395659447,
-0.034917060285806656,
-0.0924585834145546,
-0.5544834136962891,
0.04195756837725639,
-1.04732346534729,
0.10001888126134872,
-0.14075571298599243,
-0.6597246527671814,
0.2961932420730591,
-0.07047753781080246,
-0.6864587068557739,
0.7192729711532593,
-0.2228562980890274,
-0.976473867893219,
0.11122842878103256,
-0.06172505393624306,
-0.10030145943164825,
0.5205271244049072,
-0.08137960731983185,
-0.8207640647888184,
-0.07208187133073807,
0.033481527119874954,
-0.01526585128158331,
0.34833136200904846,
0.6830642819404602,
-0.3249032199382782,
-0.5104914903640747,
0.4213314950466156,
-0.46443653106689453,
0.9305328726768494,
0.45347562432289124,
-0.4183860123157501,
-0.01832590438425541,
-0.2567373216152191,
0.15399761497974396,
-0.016583623364567757,
0.2214697152376175,
-0.6653611063957214,
-0.03667884320020676,
-0.07460365444421768,
-0.04147843271493912,
0.4304635524749756,
-0.5357242226600647,
-0.13498707115650177,
-0.297235369682312,
0.6191779375076294,
0.7974377870559692,
-0.040336042642593384,
0.7494565844535828,
0.09614229202270508,
0.30383628606796265,
0.19376559555530548,
0.41698017716407776,
0.016000065952539444,
-0.5241373181343079,
-0.4043791890144348,
-0.5217357277870178,
0.8493273854255676,
0.506894052028656,
-0.8712143898010254,
0.39207300543785095,
0.258340060710907,
-0.15570564568042755,
-0.6885107159614563,
0.16321487724781036,
0.5977345108985901,
0.3477027714252472,
0.35919079184532166,
-0.43251028656959534,
-0.8031859397888184,
-0.7852763533592224,
-0.21444319188594818,
-0.1516844928264618,
0.28963422775268555,
-0.10055315494537354,
0.3839081823825836,
0.07673969119787216,
0.5118408799171448,
-0.20280353724956512,
-0.10900489240884781,
0.05200039967894554,
0.09025350958108902,
-0.14355044066905975,
0.7170988917350769,
0.37757357954978943,
-1.0057684183120728,
-0.14324837923049927,
-0.5194099545478821,
-0.41768667101860046,
0.04738682135939598,
-0.1123969778418541,
-0.6278910040855408,
-0.14200127124786377,
0.5391591191291809,
-0.4457457363605499,
0.4812699556350708,
0.3496769368648529,
-0.22290626168251038,
0.2706831693649292,
-0.39127495884895325,
-0.11025041341781616,
-0.9699383974075317,
-0.08005107194185257,
-0.24072718620300293,
-0.5525939464569092,
-0.6395187973976135,
0.14116020500659943,
0.2870589792728424,
0.2509937584400177,
-0.4702726900577545,
0.24096928536891937,
-0.6447581052780151,
0.0967613235116005,
-0.13436280190944672,
0.10831916332244873,
-0.3314840793609619,
-0.04021711274981499,
0.20704399049282074,
0.6688762307167053,
0.879070520401001,
-0.23763658106327057,
0.3039749264717102,
0.5172644257545471,
-0.24038589000701904,
0.30139005184173584,
-0.41594797372817993,
0.18423891067504883,
-0.204176127910614,
0.13277949392795563,
-0.8430560231208801,
-0.05528254806995392,
0.47544535994529724,
-0.378570020198822,
0.4728061556816101,
-0.2298939824104309,
-0.44361254572868347,
-0.16328047215938568,
-0.19539393484592438,
0.5026988983154297,
0.650251567363739,
-0.49105992913246155,
-0.2977393865585327,
0.4922368824481964,
0.09870648384094238,
-1.0335352420806885,
-0.8195042610168457,
0.1479913294315338,
-0.11556544154882431,
-0.5999628901481628,
0.5053820013999939,
0.07319202274084091,
-0.28699713945388794,
-0.03944602236151695,
-0.6154226660728455,
-0.537325382232666,
0.232167586684227,
0.3467359244823456,
0.4730418026447296,
0.1595040112733841,
0.05426904186606407,
0.08009720593690872,
-0.14725220203399658,
-0.21837544441223145,
-0.4872332811355591,
0.556474506855011,
-0.06581234931945801,
-0.45719999074935913,
-0.25430598855018616,
0.4123910367488861,
0.10393580049276352,
-0.32092273235321045,
1.060922622680664,
0.5919120907783508,
-0.5863333344459534,
-0.33984270691871643,
-0.2309604436159134,
-0.4333864450454712,
-0.5396965742111206,
0.1656448394060135,
-0.15907502174377441,
-0.9875518679618835,
0.7812143564224243,
-0.12027517706155777,
-0.09518271684646606,
-0.003184520872309804,
0.2284625917673111,
-0.27927476167678833,
0.7602959871292114,
0.1387380063533783,
0.043107133358716965,
0.8665850162506104,
0.044381093233823776,
0.36036697030067444,
-0.6847195029258728,
-0.19234873354434967,
-0.25772616267204285,
-0.6259217858314514,
-0.28106123208999634,
-0.4142971336841583,
0.010081786662340164,
0.49363693594932556,
0.05286085978150368,
0.34664615988731384,
-0.6129582524299622,
0.8307401537895203,
0.6167657971382141,
0.2029508352279663,
0.13775719702243805,
0.170261412858963,
-0.4860643148422241,
-0.2306423932313919,
-0.53571617603302,
-0.3550136089324951,
0.6162920594215393,
0.09835591912269592,
0.4764587879180908,
0.22795383632183075,
1.1134203672409058,
0.3047689199447632,
0.06652575731277466,
-0.15892009437084198,
0.4609467387199402,
-0.185807004570961,
-0.9005081057548523,
-0.3409714102745056,
-0.38944023847579956,
-0.9879372715950012,
0.5642763376235962,
-0.057701438665390015,
-1.0005607604980469,
0.38905787467956543,
0.24585044384002686,
-0.30699384212493896,
0.496644526720047,
-0.5075323581695557,
0.6773627400398254,
-0.05970223993062973,
-0.5814006328582764,
0.2507787346839905,
-1.0560784339904785,
0.3856457471847534,
-0.2572859823703766,
0.3291955888271332,
-0.1360275149345398,
-0.015300334431231022,
0.49294498562812805,
-0.9371800422668457,
0.6151387095451355,
-0.2773776650428772,
0.1559065282344818,
0.22938647866249084,
0.37613049149513245,
0.4712563157081604,
0.13059836626052856,
-0.12464215606451035,
0.34544530510902405,
-0.11594739556312561,
-0.2560783624649048,
-0.4320809841156006,
0.6473944783210754,
-0.5157713294029236,
-0.5448769927024841,
-0.4635738730430603,
-0.3113866448402405,
-0.14730970561504364,
0.40295183658599854,
0.4201374053955078,
0.18016690015792847,
0.22054414451122284,
-0.04475082829594612,
0.713914692401886,
0.1612163782119751,
0.6925110220909119,
-0.11769882589578629,
0.14639544486999512,
-0.47683486342430115,
0.734654426574707,
0.1362079232931137,
0.2763623893260956,
0.153713658452034,
0.004209036007523537,
-0.8142520189285278,
-0.9010201692581177,
-0.5150482654571533,
0.08734606951475143,
-0.6680026054382324,
-0.3342621922492981,
-0.09420762211084366,
-0.2678837180137634,
-0.172157883644104,
-0.21398279070854187,
-0.38276687264442444,
-0.39373940229415894,
-0.3629542589187622,
-0.1320720762014389,
0.3388487696647644,
0.13714224100112915,
-0.2848389148712158,
0.4458599388599396,
-0.6576756238937378,
0.28180399537086487,
0.10630959272384644,
0.35011497139930725,
-0.2951290011405945,
-0.5096589922904968,
0.15704619884490967,
0.09794887900352478,
0.014939282089471817,
-1.4129078388214111,
0.5024754405021667,
0.20229707658290863,
0.6708287596702576,
0.28848230838775635,
0.25722193717956543,
1.0673729181289673,
-0.5235844254493713,
0.6587605476379395,
0.39086249470710754,
-1.351738691329956,
0.4001932740211487,
-0.08034569770097733,
0.03194744139909744,
0.7334243655204773,
0.21110740303993225,
-0.5892553925514221,
-0.525829017162323,
-0.7722460627555847,
-1.2760907411575317,
0.6476571559906006,
0.4053228497505188,
0.11449386179447174,
-0.1727941930294037,
0.40597227215766907,
-0.058723293244838715,
0.4216625988483429,
-0.4651784896850586,
-0.6425564885139465,
-0.3207627236843109,
-0.3287138342857361,
0.26766765117645264,
-0.17563863098621368,
-0.1630420684814453,
0.04817631468176842,
0.627068817615509,
0.1948082000017166,
0.11662818491458893,
0.26436126232147217,
-0.3685700595378876,
-0.03384231775999069,
0.3268016576766968,
0.5213832855224609,
0.5498759150505066,
-0.0019833992701023817,
0.8726277947425842,
0.07649536430835724,
-0.699899435043335,
0.21740223467350006,
0.13440579175949097,
-0.4822620451450348,
0.4408092200756073,
-0.003756921272724867,
0.4815137982368469,
0.07563605904579163,
-0.3992673456668854,
0.6624817848205566,
0.02026059851050377,
-0.37841516733169556,
-0.03353872522711754,
-0.388685405254364,
0.250971257686615,
0.30485087633132935,
0.32983556389808655,
0.5781833529472351,
0.03457384184002876,
0.0308714397251606,
0.5356413722038269,
0.4370500445365906,
-0.3747106194496155,
-0.2681431472301483,
0.7580311298370361,
0.07520080357789993,
-0.319547563791275,
0.6658187508583069,
-0.5099357962608337,
-0.7052035927772522,
0.3381858468055725,
0.7001135945320129,
0.8418295979499817,
-0.5206326246261597,
0.3994682729244232,
0.12764814496040344,
0.42466244101524353,
-0.6289628148078918,
0.47222208976745605,
-0.15538553893566132,
-0.6754711866378784,
-0.1141003742814064,
-0.5285261273384094,
-0.09285356104373932,
-0.14111202955245972,
-0.5530418753623962,
-0.2841436266899109,
-0.6151063442230225,
-0.4034753739833832,
-0.135165274143219,
-0.43746623396873474,
-0.2437364012002945,
-0.061295997351408005,
0.5071720480918884,
0.6423211097717285,
-0.7290170788764954,
0.9190014004707336,
0.5230438709259033,
-0.07776399701833725,
-0.617999255657196,
-0.3484998643398285,
0.0955209732055664,
-0.9709304571151733,
0.5811426639556885,
-0.17828001081943512,
-0.020645108073949814,
-0.19481132924556732,
-0.5167975425720215,
-0.7169831395149231,
1.0130696296691895,
0.5266093611717224,
-0.9690262079238892,
0.10148496925830841,
0.0914534479379654,
0.3979418873786926,
0.12142868340015411,
0.15045323967933655,
0.20034891366958618,
0.4098101258277893,
0.2872113585472107,
-0.8612241744995117,
0.26178959012031555,
-0.20738309621810913,
0.06481647491455078,
0.3344793915748596,
-0.5153900384902954,
0.7811073064804077,
0.04512336105108261,
-0.5652363300323486,
0.1326950043439865,
0.5972715020179749,
0.46031492948532104,
0.22481030225753784,
0.6080027222633362,
0.5064072608947754,
1.26455819606781,
-0.28206688165664673,
0.4770137667655945,
-0.2597130239009857,
0.43750670552253723,
1.105995774269104,
-0.006136721465736628,
0.8190152645111084,
0.9386701583862305,
-0.03144075348973274,
0.12808236479759216,
0.738601803779602,
0.11871204525232315,
0.8038440346717834,
0.624079167842865,
-0.5275611281394958,
-0.5713202357292175,
-0.0074775866232812405,
-0.425504595041275,
-0.041766103357076645,
0.30578112602233887,
-0.6978492140769958,
-0.1933099776506424,
-0.2086254507303238,
0.14007213711738586,
0.07149873673915863,
-0.19168899953365326,
0.3033796548843384,
0.2004673033952713,
-0.34918132424354553,
0.463434636592865,
0.012313074432313442,
0.8633987307548523,
-0.5892964005470276,
0.27451878786087036,
-0.2284904569387436,
0.20986120402812958,
-0.3530821204185486,
-0.5257706642150879,
0.44831597805023193,
-0.09685639292001724,
0.4223453104496002,
-0.5929825305938721,
0.8670089244842529,
-0.7377268671989441,
-0.0861964300274849,
-0.12706336379051208,
0.42056751251220703,
0.33291110396385193,
0.09055990725755692,
-0.8185812830924988,
0.3308194875717163,
-0.0550495870411396,
0.09484747797250748,
0.384123295545578,
0.07433810085058212,
-0.12327185273170471,
0.47549208998680115,
0.6441473364830017,
0.3138178288936615,
0.650120198726654,
0.20122407376766205,
0.5266749858856201,
-0.0816015750169754,
-0.5661581754684448,
-1.1950805187225342,
0.38140761852264404,
-0.3005255162715912,
-0.20515313744544983,
0.9084932208061218,
0.36772483587265015,
0.6752986311912537,
0.0063445065170526505,
0.5736438035964966,
-0.002377315890043974,
-0.29195380210876465,
-0.16152030229568481,
0.8542042374610901,
-0.14639972150325775,
0.24668559432029724,
-0.2770210802555084,
-0.7179660797119141,
-0.5635323524475098,
0.9063622355461121,
-0.20945657789707184,
-0.2955453097820282,
0.528439998626709,
0.8174078464508057,
-0.07262551784515381,
0.17910945415496826,
0.26341739296913147,
-0.17101715505123138,
-0.0846078172326088,
0.3793542981147766,
0.9520216584205627,
-0.6240799427032471,
0.3331787884235382,
-0.3485402762889862,
-0.0021086730994284153,
-0.014886299148201942,
-0.7005850076675415,
-0.6731998324394226,
-0.6011234521865845,
-0.5605142712593079,
-0.36267992854118347,
0.4721315801143646,
0.6683753132820129,
0.9762787222862244,
-0.6243603229522705,
0.2579798698425293,
-0.2633322477340698,
0.4420182406902313,
-0.2735522389411926,
-0.12674233317375183,
0.3509467542171478,
-0.18099768459796906,
-0.6937338709831238,
0.2976267635822296,
0.11264953017234802,
0.34461572766304016,
-0.26433953642845154,
-0.0613543801009655,
-0.12360501289367676,
0.10066068172454834,
-0.34398066997528076,
0.31256240606307983,
-0.5744359493255615,
-0.1924324482679367,
0.014298760332167149,
-0.06863263994455338,
-0.1737315058708191,
0.5230069756507874,
-0.2334180772304535,
0.662474513053894,
0.7529609203338623,
0.6670068502426147,
0.39553284645080566,
0.11301233619451523,
0.11639578640460968,
-1.2478278875350952,
0.2991744875907898,
0.1569962054491043,
0.5292017459869385,
0.14368945360183716,
-0.3818252384662628,
-0.101858951151371,
0.5211330652236938,
-0.31243595480918884,
-0.9988946318626404,
0.2961677014827728,
-0.8312345147132874,
-0.35385677218437195,
0.763242781162262,
-0.4712044596672058,
-0.49100497364997864,
-0.1931193619966507,
-0.02327602170407772,
0.18988999724388123,
-0.2723006010055542,
0.6573020815849304,
0.6703276634216309,
0.33514896035194397,
-0.27753472328186035,
-0.08357687294483185,
0.6480252742767334,
0.6255354881286621,
-0.3968539535999298,
-0.04066282510757446,
0.3193337917327881,
0.3515967130661011,
0.3259578049182892,
0.6385124921798706,
-0.3756793439388275,
0.01387301366776228,
0.24152253568172455,
-0.28361403942108154,
-0.3499237596988678,
-0.10741617530584335,
-0.32664477825164795,
0.35636672377586365,
-0.1891023814678192,
-0.7475836873054504
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17516v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17516v2
|
MapGuide: A Simple yet Effective Method to Reconstruct Continuous Language from Brain Activities
| 2024-03-26T09:18:59 | 2024-04-02T12:05:41 |
Xinpei Zhao, Jingyuan Sun, Shaonan Wang, Jing Ye, Xiaohan Zhang, Chengqing Zong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Decoding continuous language from brain activity is a formidable yet
promising field of research. It is particularly significant for aiding people
with speech disabilities to communicate through brain signals. This field
addresses the complex task of mapping brain signals to text. The previous best
attempt reverse-engineered this process in an indirect way: it began by
learning to encode brain activity from text and then guided text generation by
aligning with predicted brain responses. In contrast, we propose a simple yet
effective method that guides text reconstruction by directly comparing them
with the predicted text embeddings mapped from brain activities. Comprehensive
experiments reveal that our method significantly outperforms the current
state-of-the-art model, showing average improvements of 77% and 54% on BLEU and
METEOR scores. We further validate the proposed modules through detailed
ablation studies and case analyses and highlight a critical correlation: the
more precisely we map brain activities to text embeddings, the better the text
reconstruction results. Such insight can simplify the task of reconstructing
language from brain activities for future work, emphasizing the importance of
improving brain-to-text-embedding mapping techniques.
|
[
0.12418544292449951,
-1.040076732635498,
0.558715283870697,
0.2229483425617218,
-0.43799787759780884,
-0.06768746674060822,
-0.5717167258262634,
-0.3023536205291748,
0.27411502599716187,
0.625393271446228,
-0.4806003272533417,
-0.664351761341095,
-0.617453396320343,
-0.09382326900959015,
-0.7557244300842285,
0.9825019240379333,
0.03924890235066414,
-0.12444361299276352,
-0.10560159385204315,
0.014550363644957542,
-0.47651147842407227,
-0.3125183880329132,
-1.0544273853302002,
-0.5062555074691772,
0.4938018321990967,
0.18721173703670502,
0.2282758206129074,
0.6235659122467041,
0.40842312574386597,
0.21517488360404968,
-0.3038335144519806,
0.2450440376996994,
-0.5237418413162231,
0.2156974971294403,
0.03261759504675865,
-0.042008690536022186,
-0.5815914273262024,
-0.33499497175216675,
0.653193473815918,
0.9354513883590698,
-0.5421730875968933,
-0.046855948865413666,
0.3498719334602356,
0.7539263963699341,
-0.35009822249412537,
0.09643227607011795,
-0.49253588914871216,
-0.38097304105758667,
-0.10354544967412949,
-0.33202463388442993,
-0.6946826577186584,
-0.31320226192474365,
0.06336673349142075,
-0.2819199860095978,
0.33414512872695923,
0.08416325598955154,
0.6079379320144653,
0.27036699652671814,
-0.620897114276886,
-0.7159208059310913,
-0.7424039244651794,
0.7424471974372864,
-0.4536888003349304,
0.5074809193611145,
0.5819055438041687,
0.1326703131198883,
-0.27969393134117126,
-0.7423436045646667,
-0.5580956935882568,
0.10450438410043716,
-0.11440975964069366,
0.20399107038974762,
-0.05717513710260391,
0.16761304438114166,
0.1734996885061264,
0.013755641877651215,
-0.6527959704399109,
-0.14192165434360504,
-0.4707152247428894,
-0.33228573203086853,
0.5127297043800354,
0.17424681782722473,
0.49173590540885925,
-0.1157182902097702,
-0.0391591340303421,
-0.11135878413915634,
-0.6830663681030273,
-0.12089262902736664,
-0.04681691899895668,
0.18818660080432892,
-0.05188571289181709,
0.5582120418548584,
0.017243418842554092,
0.8046557903289795,
-0.2130751758813858,
-0.25483936071395874,
0.2625909149646759,
-0.34223082661628723,
-0.28119611740112305,
0.2217351794242859,
0.46096062660217285,
0.350053995847702,
0.2473558932542801,
-0.44491034746170044,
-0.06462154537439346,
-0.08420754224061966,
0.28883442282676697,
-0.6240549087524414,
-0.2788660228252411,
0.2642957866191864,
-0.4052363336086273,
0.35431554913520813,
-0.28693920373916626,
-0.7560583353042603,
-0.36679667234420776,
-0.16588382422924042,
0.17110635340213776,
-0.6532856822013855,
-0.36194488406181335,
0.3861405849456787,
-0.06375662982463837,
0.05125979334115982,
0.19229719042778015,
-1.0704371929168701,
0.07969697564840317,
0.7836208343505859,
0.9053059220314026,
-0.41305115818977356,
-0.1785263568162918,
-0.3042018711566925,
0.364469975233078,
-0.0632372796535492,
0.9131836295127869,
-0.26700302958488464,
-0.4616928696632385,
0.18074531853199005,
-0.09910401701927185,
0.009617974050343037,
-0.36417871713638306,
0.6850399971008301,
-0.453000009059906,
-0.056514982134103775,
-0.21885839104652405,
-0.48445746302604675,
-0.4634072184562683,
0.17893408238887787,
-0.5568394660949707,
0.64085453748703,
-0.13777661323547363,
-0.4584414064884186,
0.18241649866104126,
-0.6567339897155762,
-0.5599620938301086,
-0.1022106409072876,
-0.10807833820581436,
-0.467288076877594,
0.11756481975317001,
0.12813730537891388,
0.22571800649166107,
-0.060570280998945236,
0.028179306536912918,
0.13018031418323517,
-0.25051960349082947,
0.19418343901634216,
-0.32636919617652893,
0.9784653186798096,
-0.10724950581789017,
-0.3888542354106903,
0.09226345270872116,
-0.7008187770843506,
-0.029495181515812874,
-0.2676602005958557,
-0.6219505071640015,
-0.5046030879020691,
0.4551208019256592,
0.10648936778306961,
-0.1072295531630516,
0.07322488725185394,
-0.7258052825927734,
-0.015443618409335613,
-0.6522299647331238,
0.46281230449676514,
0.4203799068927765,
0.1319197416305542,
0.5116724371910095,
-0.08606400340795517,
0.21854838728904724,
-0.05018499121069908,
-0.29738184809684753,
-0.4312441945075989,
-0.6767482757568359,
-0.6405639052391052,
-0.5392366647720337,
0.1292584389448166,
0.4398350119590759,
-0.5219830274581909,
0.45625850558280945,
-0.5029521584510803,
-0.5163277387619019,
-0.748236894607544,
-0.17341461777687073,
0.394845187664032,
0.8502917289733887,
0.6270323991775513,
-0.2128523290157318,
-0.5544641017913818,
-0.7125930190086365,
-0.31689369678497314,
0.01906355656683445,
-0.2049102783203125,
0.07794562727212906,
0.2949298024177551,
-0.43890663981437683,
0.716948926448822,
-0.5295465588569641,
-0.4179631471633911,
-0.04326966032385826,
0.22658009827136993,
0.16013407707214355,
0.4908498227596283,
0.23314349353313446,
-0.586298406124115,
-0.4824187159538269,
0.25846463441848755,
-0.6719232201576233,
0.004868815653026104,
-0.17842349410057068,
-0.17245863378047943,
0.2639062702655792,
0.31839266419410706,
-0.44190382957458496,
0.6219558715820312,
0.5855491161346436,
-0.6786827445030212,
0.05532527714967728,
-0.3509705662727356,
0.31252357363700867,
-0.6762024760246277,
0.4229583740234375,
-0.1693059355020523,
-0.18269164860248566,
-0.7616763710975647,
-0.1314101666212082,
0.14072874188423157,
0.026921771466732025,
0.03526235371828079,
0.46165934205055237,
-0.8061777353286743,
0.15978118777275085,
-0.7443088293075562,
0.33289191126823425,
-0.31173038482666016,
0.40770071744918823,
-0.028539104387164116,
0.6070371866226196,
0.5822962522506714,
-0.5555020570755005,
0.11464473605155945,
0.5283123254776001,
-0.4984578490257263,
0.3830472230911255,
-0.3956126272678375,
0.3579382002353668,
-0.46883511543273926,
0.13427646458148956,
-1.2279372215270996,
-0.025492114946246147,
0.21834847331047058,
-0.5667540431022644,
0.3579135835170746,
0.04271331802010536,
-0.3418624699115753,
0.08372306823730469,
0.06841828674077988,
0.5117032527923584,
0.935688316822052,
-0.3804005980491638,
0.6788599491119385,
0.8238004446029663,
-0.20717735588550568,
-0.41427505016326904,
-1.0280869007110596,
0.022373786196112633,
-0.056426409631967545,
-0.4605160057544708,
0.5280539393424988,
-0.22832974791526794,
0.052304431796073914,
-0.16108238697052002,
-0.23849458992481232,
-0.20867803692817688,
0.07166250795125961,
0.34797215461730957,
-0.07796807587146759,
0.03930756449699402,
-0.09543421864509583,
0.34279611706733704,
-0.25471231341362,
0.15942241251468658,
0.03598429635167122,
0.47045451402664185,
0.37646031379699707,
-0.3061496615409851,
-0.18179458379745483,
0.6180538535118103,
0.2633671760559082,
-0.13951095938682556,
0.444519966840744,
0.45282113552093506,
-0.674689769744873,
-0.18775345385074615,
-0.2462306171655655,
-0.24008212983608246,
-0.4939470589160919,
0.44707173109054565,
-0.07233593612909317,
-0.643420398235321,
0.14657558500766754,
-0.22023074328899384,
0.2328118085861206,
0.04269605502486229,
0.6239132881164551,
-0.21386779844760895,
1.076457142829895,
0.8852049708366394,
0.3039652705192566,
0.3856051564216614,
-0.0699814110994339,
0.21030943095684052,
-0.9718204140663147,
-0.6210976839065552,
-0.5140893459320068,
-0.3582727015018463,
-0.06718378514051437,
-0.10967671126127243,
0.2318345457315445,
-0.01585659198462963,
0.2345239222049713,
0.3544577956199646,
-0.764086127281189,
0.23341426253318787,
0.184462770819664,
0.4137290418148041,
0.22709545493125916,
0.4293077290058136,
0.0899784192442894,
-0.29507771134376526,
-0.6084368824958801,
-0.602522611618042,
1.1618545055389404,
0.0750250443816185,
0.4012854993343353,
0.0343092679977417,
0.7834411263465881,
0.0072160386480391026,
0.7641991376876831,
-0.8944200277328491,
0.6707617044448853,
-0.05958941578865051,
-0.501966655254364,
-0.310884565114975,
-0.2392042577266693,
-1.2424628734588623,
0.05676669254899025,
-0.22080089151859283,
-0.8475092649459839,
-0.020166050642728806,
0.3182505965232849,
-0.22836382687091827,
-0.04436786472797394,
-0.8260864615440369,
0.5680550336837769,
0.03796388953924179,
-0.28108012676239014,
-0.4587711989879608,
-0.21141301095485687,
0.13941632211208344,
-0.24123340845108032,
0.5885938405990601,
0.018494905903935432,
-0.2884999215602875,
0.8862059712409973,
0.12059661000967026,
0.7753081321716309,
-0.22221216559410095,
-0.30990636348724365,
0.07997595518827438,
0.054271597415208817,
0.15933509171009064,
-0.14915330708026886,
-0.24637769162654877,
0.0861053317785263,
-0.17073781788349152,
-0.3799671530723572,
-0.5711761713027954,
0.9341068863868713,
-0.282012015581131,
-0.4915626049041748,
-0.2688274681568146,
-0.4660343527793884,
0.050647884607315063,
0.4462045729160309,
-0.0057274354621768,
0.5076256394386292,
-0.31677088141441345,
0.1656261533498764,
0.8040980100631714,
0.0735323429107666,
0.7544224262237549,
0.5265063047409058,
-0.0324384942650795,
-0.6016628742218018,
0.9280797839164734,
0.07238458842039108,
-0.3695237636566162,
0.5700303316116333,
-0.24987544119358063,
-0.19943508505821228,
-1.033670425415039,
-0.05392399802803993,
0.4369247853755951,
-0.6113696098327637,
-0.03199750930070877,
-0.5160403251647949,
0.1765628308057785,
-0.19860151410102844,
-0.16493837535381317,
-0.23210178315639496,
-0.19549818336963654,
-0.2155204713344574,
0.016142424196004868,
-0.012476799078285694,
0.3964279890060425,
-0.08206334710121155,
0.48152923583984375,
-0.736738920211792,
0.4551057517528534,
0.13212259113788605,
0.1051536351442337,
-0.0684833824634552,
-0.3333123028278351,
-0.588058590888977,
0.2957180142402649,
-0.22392301261425018,
-1.2321842908859253,
0.4225953221321106,
0.33893075585365295,
0.5831233859062195,
0.17649833858013153,
0.004607491195201874,
0.7783143520355225,
-0.8469032049179077,
0.7443894743919373,
0.16497883200645447,
-0.8242907524108887,
0.5885261297225952,
0.0809304267168045,
0.4253917336463928,
0.3651215136051178,
0.29639455676078796,
-0.47847357392311096,
-0.20167085528373718,
-0.48655495047569275,
-1.1045546531677246,
0.3937152624130249,
0.40584316849708557,
0.0421513132750988,
-0.27671974897384644,
0.545595109462738,
0.1832083910703659,
0.04836638271808624,
-0.4412653148174286,
-0.32775264978408813,
-0.0413665734231472,
-0.5211842656135559,
-0.22602811455726624,
-0.22869937121868134,
-0.4286079704761505,
-0.23377138376235962,
0.5673572421073914,
0.014544263482093811,
0.6892468333244324,
0.2916921079158783,
-0.29121318459510803,
0.11020178347826004,
-0.008983435109257698,
0.7700982093811035,
0.6641063690185547,
-0.09607642143964767,
0.2026301473379135,
0.18866616487503052,
-0.8952212333679199,
-0.11287575215101242,
0.07012352347373962,
-0.18810251355171204,
0.24832530319690704,
0.4009869396686554,
0.5570226311683655,
0.18298274278640747,
-0.8172820806503296,
0.3949210047721863,
0.00911488477140665,
-0.026200121268630028,
-0.3670375347137451,
0.14050504565238953,
0.18413077294826508,
0.12863966822624207,
0.4662725627422333,
0.13322634994983673,
0.2198365330696106,
-0.45001912117004395,
0.27880018949508667,
0.35597681999206543,
-0.2771528959274292,
-0.6466562747955322,
0.6384075880050659,
0.42847001552581787,
-0.9399641752243042,
0.6254147291183472,
0.24470430612564087,
-0.12206460535526276,
0.45367446541786194,
0.7709689140319824,
0.9277642965316772,
-0.22064098715782166,
-0.14999324083328247,
0.6433969140052795,
0.31593865156173706,
-0.24666514992713928,
0.6143547296524048,
-0.13606329262256622,
-0.4398476183414459,
-0.5043585300445557,
-0.22515003383159637,
-0.1405254751443863,
-0.17693190276622772,
-0.555438756942749,
0.20683114230632782,
-0.1311964988708496,
-0.21714745461940765,
-0.03403174504637718,
-0.3113008141517639,
-0.5194729566574097,
0.4185384213924408,
0.019193969666957855,
0.9208405017852783,
-0.4811965227127075,
1.0657991170883179,
0.7608481049537659,
-0.184170663356781,
-0.23959681391716003,
0.27363184094429016,
-0.1845363825559616,
-0.6828060746192932,
0.2935544550418854,
0.11239589005708694,
-0.30062630772590637,
0.5802456140518188,
-0.46811768412590027,
-0.6861082911491394,
1.2664233446121216,
0.36289000511169434,
-0.49231719970703125,
-0.19616860151290894,
-0.19701293110847473,
0.5176597833633423,
-0.14930196106433868,
0.39666226506233215,
0.4834524393081665,
0.4824577271938324,
-0.3346446454524994,
-0.6768719553947449,
0.41486480832099915,
-0.02815372124314308,
-0.18626248836517334,
0.2840653359889984,
-0.30958089232444763,
0.15681520104408264,
0.02938169613480568,
-0.7523456811904907,
0.04395545646548271,
0.8874022364616394,
0.3084162771701813,
0.3963887393474579,
0.36011993885040283,
0.13746197521686554,
0.7647932171821594,
-0.18058297038078308,
0.7032710313796997,
-0.4358571767807007,
0.2949690520763397,
0.5927254557609558,
0.21883094310760498,
1.033238410949707,
0.9776372313499451,
0.26600995659828186,
0.5318157076835632,
0.1608312427997589,
0.3999193608760834,
0.9678402543067932,
0.13034588098526,
-0.3809550702571869,
-0.14968909323215485,
0.2863959074020386,
-0.20993097126483917,
0.27678945660591125,
0.6176474094390869,
-0.3386918306350708,
-0.3053169548511505,
0.173248291015625,
0.02945712022483349,
0.41231462359428406,
-0.10713685303926468,
0.6269863843917847,
0.1712581217288971,
-1.0213974714279175,
0.6295061707496643,
0.05049772560596466,
0.6682016849517822,
-0.8080606460571289,
-0.2222161889076233,
-0.39109012484550476,
0.051668595522642136,
-0.2271009087562561,
-0.8392030596733093,
0.8203127384185791,
-0.058924008160829544,
-0.08713031560182571,
-0.6236141920089722,
0.6801822781562805,
-0.7558079361915588,
0.10632170736789703,
0.14798703789710999,
0.1356862485408783,
0.40294843912124634,
0.07469076663255692,
-0.45006027817726135,
0.2557544708251953,
0.3873014450073242,
-0.3031458556652069,
0.12073928862810135,
0.28226161003112793,
0.3859637975692749,
0.584347128868103,
0.5280149579048157,
0.021648334339261055,
-0.10796983540058136,
-0.41431093215942383,
0.5622263550758362,
-0.8692482709884644,
-0.5310589075088501,
-0.8499434590339661,
1.0306768417358398,
-0.2219473123550415,
-0.37269580364227295,
0.5717488527297974,
0.6437138319015503,
0.5554404258728027,
-0.17330467700958252,
0.6538130640983582,
-0.07285120338201523,
0.4579637348651886,
-0.6061083078384399,
0.909470796585083,
-0.39350426197052,
0.19622810184955597,
0.006131485104560852,
-0.6712307333946228,
-0.4124268591403961,
0.7163618206977844,
0.009847643785178661,
-0.3146405816078186,
1.0794159173965454,
0.9369580745697021,
-0.15318059921264648,
-0.1159777119755745,
0.1771010160446167,
0.1202552318572998,
0.33157435059547424,
0.6493071913719177,
0.37618184089660645,
-0.47178569436073303,
0.9481371641159058,
0.0833527073264122,
-0.699005126953125,
-0.06132081151008606,
-0.8847368955612183,
-0.8096904754638672,
-0.8652029037475586,
-0.5838510394096375,
-0.39547643065452576,
0.1245117262005806,
0.41498324275016785,
0.5409526228904724,
-0.5961053967475891,
-0.43929097056388855,
-0.24781100451946259,
0.21149924397468567,
-0.6321321129798889,
-0.09241137653589249,
0.4502060115337372,
0.06655333191156387,
-0.9584509134292603,
0.6960392594337463,
0.3793676495552063,
-0.17091521620750427,
-0.13577532768249512,
-0.19260954856872559,
-0.037096455693244934,
0.10550316423177719,
0.6173996329307556,
0.5370996594429016,
-0.5003686547279358,
-0.38098883628845215,
0.004869725555181503,
-0.3653440773487091,
-0.10829238593578339,
0.8607056736946106,
-0.6882800459861755,
0.40461769700050354,
0.7746548652648926,
0.8373088240623474,
0.8081984519958496,
-0.36698365211486816,
0.6116822361946106,
-0.7013766765594482,
0.04481840506196022,
0.16353212296962738,
0.22081083059310913,
0.43213269114494324,
-0.09884799271821976,
0.39489954710006714,
0.15059919655323029,
-0.5961156487464905,
-0.9852428436279297,
0.38442644476890564,
-1.4801539182662964,
-0.20110870897769928,
1.3421318531036377,
-0.16784244775772095,
-0.555753231048584,
-0.24109993875026703,
-0.6818879842758179,
0.6028227806091309,
-0.09649685770273209,
1.2355130910873413,
0.5982679724693298,
-0.1972576528787613,
-0.24181528389453888,
-0.26527082920074463,
0.5299143195152283,
0.358269065618515,
-0.6133246421813965,
0.0692252665758133,
0.4342186450958252,
0.25066325068473816,
0.15560206770896912,
0.9203653335571289,
0.08699987083673477,
0.2074367105960846,
0.05540028586983681,
-0.055945709347724915,
-0.11835801601409912,
-0.13427650928497314,
-0.1958901286125183,
0.38576623797416687,
-0.21127384901046753,
-0.33955731987953186
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17497v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17497v1
|
Sharing the Cost of Success: A Game for Evaluating and Learning Collaborative Multi-Agent Instruction Giving and Following Policies
| 2024-03-26T08:58:28 | 2024-03-26T08:58:28 |
Philipp Sadler, Sherzod Hakimov, David Schlangen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
In collaborative goal-oriented settings, the participants are not only
interested in achieving a successful outcome, but do also implicitly negotiate
the effort they put into the interaction (by adapting to each other). In this
work, we propose a challenging interactive reference game that requires two
players to coordinate on vision and language observations. The learning signal
in this game is a score (given after playing) that takes into account the
achieved goal and the players' assumed efforts during the interaction. We show
that a standard Proximal Policy Optimization (PPO) setup achieves a high
success rate when bootstrapped with heuristic partner behaviors that implement
insights from the analysis of human-human interactions. And we find that a
pairing of neural partners indeed reduces the measured joint effort when
playing together repeatedly. However, we observe that in comparison to a
reasonable heuristic pairing there is still room for improvement -- which
invites further research in the direction of cost-sharing in collaborative
interactions.
|
[
-0.2982545495033264,
-0.12481804192066193,
0.7031737565994263,
0.5590728521347046,
0.0628487765789032,
0.29108574986457825,
-0.4015837609767914,
-0.2504391670227051,
0.23355571925640106,
0.3631250858306885,
-0.5873894095420837,
-0.25279688835144043,
-0.3770000636577606,
-0.1040467694401741,
0.6687253713607788,
0.9567235708236694,
-0.023973198607563972,
0.012719905935227871,
-0.5401472449302673,
-0.29264864325523376,
-0.7281994819641113,
-0.2326633781194687,
-1.035584568977356,
-0.8024661540985107,
0.5349323153495789,
0.8147554397583008,
0.9398481845855713,
0.40586069226264954,
0.7420119643211365,
0.3403905928134918,
0.24687683582305908,
0.241397887468338,
-0.7231055498123169,
0.05951746553182602,
-0.3474067151546478,
-0.49650701880455017,
-0.45232337713241577,
0.37507596611976624,
0.47155246138572693,
0.8393545150756836,
-0.4174119532108307,
-0.18260036408901215,
0.3081691563129425,
0.6608110666275024,
-0.5855693817138672,
0.4246223568916321,
-0.21314570307731628,
0.12138349562883377,
0.4322299361228943,
-0.08728273957967758,
-0.304314523935318,
-0.3587094247341156,
0.5116602182388306,
-1.1579184532165527,
-0.05515224114060402,
0.024383148178458214,
0.6749809384346008,
0.1876027137041092,
0.01733064278960228,
-0.5802326798439026,
-0.5645338892936707,
0.8972234725952148,
-0.021235011518001556,
-0.06934785842895508,
0.46141600608825684,
0.1347000151872635,
-0.4120631814002991,
-0.37119245529174805,
-0.4889494776725769,
-0.3482053577899933,
0.048077020794153214,
0.47166427969932556,
-0.25723063945770264,
0.22204647958278656,
-0.16774897277355194,
-0.025719480589032173,
-0.15887433290481567,
-0.3207376003265381,
-0.33840399980545044,
-0.054309193044900894,
0.865492582321167,
0.008458220399916172,
0.12481267750263214,
0.2731724679470062,
-0.6331388354301453,
-0.3365950882434845,
-0.20558495819568634,
0.3303528428077698,
0.5629368424415588,
0.01591004617512226,
-0.42256027460098267,
0.1459229290485382,
-0.05241338536143303,
0.13615188002586365,
0.15643151104450226,
0.17127299308776855,
0.32172340154647827,
-0.6693588495254517,
0.1202784925699234,
-0.09661279618740082,
0.594648540019989,
0.8965844511985779,
0.40276116132736206,
-0.509372353553772,
-0.1158403605222702,
0.18179911375045776,
0.41854622960090637,
-0.1648266315460205,
-0.3708524703979492,
-0.14643065631389618,
-0.3543451726436615,
-0.27481886744499207,
0.020956719294190407,
-0.7020338773727417,
-0.1442110389471054,
-0.23697714507579803,
0.9191994667053223,
-0.30894774198532104,
-0.21611978113651276,
0.020899584516882896,
-0.39823034405708313,
0.22587476670742035,
0.41944420337677,
-0.6346562504768372,
0.7621480822563171,
0.6757199764251709,
0.7976141571998596,
-0.08026403188705444,
-0.7873317003250122,
-0.7072534561157227,
0.12326783686876297,
-0.5611435174942017,
0.49040043354034424,
-0.33107972145080566,
-0.8279711604118347,
-0.29308152198791504,
-0.3433162569999695,
-0.03712967410683632,
-0.4582979679107666,
0.2140868455171585,
-0.21271292865276337,
0.18865615129470825,
-0.7572129368782043,
-0.5963208675384521,
0.08146284520626068,
0.42359447479248047,
-0.7131607532501221,
0.2678539454936981,
0.2006707638502121,
-0.31492921710014343,
0.6158226132392883,
-0.8916260600090027,
-0.1657838523387909,
0.45713427662849426,
-0.17940258979797363,
-0.36995917558670044,
0.1183747947216034,
-0.44719019532203674,
-0.04272178187966347,
-0.43045204877853394,
-0.07475616037845612,
-0.1151493638753891,
-0.7284497618675232,
-0.027486998587846756,
-0.006342488806694746,
0.5142472982406616,
-0.008637075312435627,
-0.3925411105155945,
0.29781851172447205,
-0.3985714018344879,
-0.09715359658002853,
0.26036277413368225,
-0.5681784749031067,
-0.38878771662712097,
0.18669439852237701,
-0.3138541579246521,
-0.006800408009439707,
0.29522204399108887,
-0.17312444746494293,
0.1873009204864502,
0.19921867549419403,
0.039458829909563065,
0.6789078116416931,
0.10248711705207825,
0.768566370010376,
-0.6400696635246277,
0.36064964532852173,
-0.4207668900489807,
0.7121280431747437,
0.19510488212108612,
-0.5546867847442627,
-0.6009134650230408,
-0.03837616369128227,
0.07547088712453842,
0.2322305142879486,
-1.0479475259780884,
-0.11070778220891953,
0.11327393352985382,
-0.1788061112165451,
-0.6100628972053528,
0.15460878610610962,
0.7777642011642456,
0.36051350831985474,
0.21087181568145752,
-0.9165467619895935,
0.033729083836078644,
-0.6058409214019775,
0.034516602754592896,
-0.28251826763153076,
0.22915227711200714,
0.7070534229278564,
0.31032684445381165,
0.31681108474731445,
0.5946530699729919,
-0.2924615442752838,
-0.7708753347396851,
-0.16275417804718018,
0.4120258390903473,
-0.08558094501495361,
0.777247428894043,
0.69898521900177,
-0.9061938524246216,
-0.8857582807540894,
-0.0843934416770935,
-0.6811191439628601,
0.20077453553676605,
-0.16081666946411133,
-0.20188646018505096,
-0.09093472361564636,
0.16673149168491364,
-0.12249407917261124,
0.19282162189483643,
0.6682646870613098,
-0.5352854132652283,
0.682647705078125,
-0.9335436820983887,
0.4816722273826599,
-0.6213200688362122,
-0.280264288187027,
-0.020953156054019928,
0.029162127524614334,
-0.4349554181098938,
0.3368036150932312,
-0.49042797088623047,
0.16768868267536163,
-0.21907101571559906,
-0.053310591727495193,
-0.6252437829971313,
-0.15366162359714508,
-0.22400394082069397,
0.3116440773010254,
-0.03694159910082817,
0.7272211313247681,
0.22252008318901062,
1.053604006767273,
0.44478505849838257,
-0.3042319118976593,
0.5112618207931519,
0.06831175833940506,
-0.004233387298882008,
1.0507537126541138,
-0.7620928883552551,
0.3878318667411804,
0.11298878490924835,
-0.18519710004329681,
-0.5401714444160461,
-0.08934767544269562,
0.49689531326293945,
-0.46665722131729126,
-0.07433409243822098,
0.06762426346540451,
-0.210814967751503,
0.009064817801117897,
-0.6130725741386414,
0.29246777296066284,
0.3153499364852905,
-0.27933269739151,
0.23402203619480133,
0.38728997111320496,
0.40611493587493896,
-0.6444678902626038,
-0.14702394604682922,
0.15912607312202454,
-0.015455744229257107,
-0.2877383530139923,
0.5561527609825134,
-0.2157810777425766,
-0.3377574682235718,
0.47626742720603943,
0.1022045686841011,
-0.08157999068498611,
0.09486202895641327,
0.1705288141965866,
0.21536080539226532,
-0.08243607729673386,
0.039212580770254135,
-0.38180649280548096,
-0.341257780790329,
0.14707234501838684,
-0.3373521864414215,
0.3907504975795746,
-0.4020252525806427,
-0.16073694825172424,
-0.3992239534854889,
0.5830338597297668,
0.3629958927631378,
-0.19748249650001526,
0.9452658891677856,
0.299362450838089,
-0.3189879357814789,
0.0691528394818306,
-0.403787761926651,
-0.09550902247428894,
-0.46658164262771606,
0.2908696234226227,
-0.6442452073097229,
-0.4933530390262604,
0.43949174880981445,
-0.522891640663147,
-0.11207625269889832,
-0.0008070277399383485,
0.016180584207177162,
-0.4064522981643677,
0.6132676601409912,
0.920579195022583,
0.19286905229091644,
0.22073990106582642,
-0.2659142315387726,
-0.3710753321647644,
-0.5851652026176453,
-0.6296001076698303,
-0.3143037259578705,
-0.38980069756507874,
-0.5006368160247803,
-0.6279398798942566,
0.5580561757087708,
0.3638293147087097,
-0.20330974459648132,
0.42396506667137146,
-0.47160854935646057,
0.8498819470405579,
1.2068685293197632,
0.33609136939048767,
0.3410702645778656,
-0.301365464925766,
-0.20315656065940857,
-0.30633264780044556,
-0.7670247554779053,
-0.06946362555027008,
0.759443998336792,
-0.10099118947982788,
0.29643574357032776,
0.4491691589355469,
1.0516096353530884,
0.37725120782852173,
0.1060505360364914,
-0.7167518138885498,
0.4049553871154785,
-0.01432553119957447,
-0.18484748899936676,
-0.45042070746421814,
-0.7432163953781128,
-1.0373339653015137,
0.04405941069126129,
-0.6886312961578369,
-0.7610558867454529,
0.3243623673915863,
0.12046653032302856,
-0.3648175895214081,
0.0356668196618557,
-0.6505572199821472,
1.0114238262176514,
-0.16716668009757996,
-0.971487820148468,
-0.8332066535949707,
-0.5898823142051697,
-0.045365240424871445,
0.09441886842250824,
0.2550676465034485,
0.18328696489334106,
-0.13523434102535248,
0.787793755531311,
-0.20298506319522858,
0.34419676661491394,
-0.21588392555713654,
0.5281569957733154,
0.5376489758491516,
0.27362513542175293,
0.35146886110305786,
-0.11935792863368988,
-0.02590884640812874,
0.08375771343708038,
-0.18513208627700806,
-0.5978918671607971,
-0.6427663564682007,
0.6747286319732666,
-1.041905164718628,
-0.6314525604248047,
-0.41534650325775146,
-0.7893557548522949,
-0.015730759128928185,
0.07731267064809799,
-0.043843187391757965,
0.018768804147839546,
-0.26546910405158997,
0.36382079124450684,
0.18343058228492737,
-0.1418685019016266,
0.5228175520896912,
0.43213069438934326,
0.2390686571598053,
-0.7442401647567749,
1.136017918586731,
0.10994526743888855,
0.6698073148727417,
0.09787163883447647,
0.4117121994495392,
-0.014902598224580288,
-0.30286043882369995,
-0.058928798884153366,
0.29012614488601685,
-0.45349979400634766,
0.12561866641044617,
0.16124597191810608,
0.22497020661830902,
0.09045473486185074,
-0.5343918204307556,
-0.49039340019226074,
0.17470864951610565,
-0.01026578713208437,
0.3050684928894043,
-0.02346975728869438,
0.8179370164871216,
-0.639310896396637,
0.6933120489120483,
-0.6163089871406555,
-0.258220374584198,
0.4418618381023407,
0.3698534071445465,
-0.02680305391550064,
0.3634188175201416,
-0.2326117753982544,
-0.1295628696680069,
-0.39336735010147095,
-1.0215332508087158,
0.12456783652305603,
-0.04747544601559639,
0.7081387042999268,
0.1744382679462433,
0.3062525987625122,
0.54327392578125,
-0.19965490698814392,
0.5092371106147766,
0.7117081880569458,
-1.1052240133285522,
0.17205724120140076,
-0.14505775272846222,
0.06942443549633026,
0.8101453185081482,
0.4738466441631317,
-0.4065820872783661,
0.2698048949241638,
-0.6753215789794922,
-0.5611562728881836,
1.0280745029449463,
0.4194945991039276,
-0.12349839508533478,
0.3388315737247467,
0.4630086421966553,
-0.18209531903266907,
0.32006892561912537,
-0.5099325180053711,
-0.2973136305809021,
0.3770769536495209,
-0.006677106022834778,
-0.07117907702922821,
-0.0020879993680864573,
-0.38592514395713806,
0.10687970370054245,
0.2961697578430176,
-0.17779240012168884,
0.11456805467605591,
0.28522151708602905,
0.2549807131290436,
-0.25357043743133545,
-0.07917947322130203,
0.4163724184036255,
0.50071781873703,
-0.16026198863983154,
0.05609791725873947,
0.08507358282804489,
-0.3102738559246063,
0.12778383493423462,
-0.10183456540107727,
0.054202716797590256,
-0.40949365496635437,
0.47542333602905273,
0.6717480421066284,
0.43294447660446167,
-0.41361865401268005,
0.7832269072532654,
-0.27567142248153687,
-0.6041810512542725,
0.02739616669714451,
0.1864464282989502,
0.09260240942239761,
0.796173632144928,
0.23321299254894257,
0.31208333373069763,
0.10803327709436417,
-0.7765719890594482,
0.5505917072296143,
0.42569395899772644,
-0.7130086421966553,
-0.27008554339408875,
0.5506384968757629,
0.5330138206481934,
-1.0220316648483276,
0.38565075397491455,
-0.7448731660842896,
-0.6953189373016357,
0.72425377368927,
0.34080979228019714,
0.4999811053276062,
-0.09325306862592697,
0.7168204188346863,
-0.005667549092322588,
0.2455838918685913,
-0.11501109600067139,
0.15713141858577728,
-0.4812569320201874,
-0.8616832494735718,
-0.385113388299942,
-0.06626102328300476,
-1.0145872831344604,
-0.2580219507217407,
-0.6741565465927124,
0.23403578996658325,
-0.44632232189178467,
-0.19575399160385132,
-0.0978301614522934,
0.5647963881492615,
-0.7168182730674744,
-0.14788579940795898,
-0.1230497732758522,
0.16372857987880707,
-0.5015171766281128,
0.5916593074798584,
0.7009015083312988,
-0.967819094657898,
-0.787004828453064,
-0.00808978546410799,
-0.02904854156076908,
-0.7052944898605347,
0.5584108233451843,
-0.1821192502975464,
-0.2843049168586731,
-0.012045006267726421,
-0.2934703230857849,
-0.46373194456100464,
1.0217453241348267,
0.49086830019950867,
-0.6834115386009216,
-0.3265312910079956,
-0.1293654590845108,
0.293204665184021,
-0.4000496566295624,
0.1349097341299057,
0.2955435514450073,
0.3534303605556488,
0.4325946271419525,
-1.1948283910751343,
-0.08807364106178284,
0.21916401386260986,
-0.5197908282279968,
-0.008709177374839783,
-1.0666778087615967,
0.9401634335517883,
-0.72275710105896,
0.08448652923107147,
-0.13959790766239166,
0.5597538948059082,
0.25156500935554504,
0.7798671722412109,
0.9026168584823608,
0.15818145871162415,
0.6266729235649109,
0.02880210615694523,
0.6864583492279053,
-0.18170826137065887,
0.5878185033798218,
1.192166805267334,
-0.3782152533531189,
0.5538131594657898,
0.624754011631012,
-0.3695216774940491,
0.2416292279958725,
0.19907841086387634,
0.09268585592508316,
0.7273195385932922,
0.28426244854927063,
-0.3931666314601898,
-0.3754698634147644,
-0.36481937766075134,
-0.051960840821266174,
0.47132691740989685,
0.12581965327262878,
-0.08076398074626923,
-0.1464739292860031,
-0.165988489985466,
0.05680368095636368,
0.6503646373748779,
-0.12335503101348877,
0.8689528703689575,
0.07549560815095901,
-0.9550588130950928,
-0.015800973400473595,
-0.3608684241771698,
0.6588704586029053,
-0.38236719369888306,
-0.4189489483833313,
-0.03735756501555443,
0.46127375960350037,
0.13426871597766876,
-0.5909020900726318,
0.24219878017902374,
-0.4930292069911957,
-0.08056016266345978,
0.07510517537593842,
0.26431798934936523,
-0.5858498811721802,
-0.018511047586798668,
0.8390094041824341,
0.6244694590568542,
0.2353486716747284,
0.033896494656801224,
-0.7407809495925903,
0.25760605931282043,
-0.15067324042320251,
0.1622600555419922,
0.3821146786212921,
0.17189949750900269,
0.21469689905643463,
0.4071614742279053,
0.51369309425354,
0.37501558661460876,
-0.39819324016571045,
-0.04933726415038109,
0.5521259903907776,
-0.2100062072277069,
-0.38983070850372314,
-0.5970631837844849,
0.2133684754371643,
-0.445640504360199,
-0.317261666059494,
0.4567130506038666,
0.2606266736984253,
1.0129108428955078,
0.16590161621570587,
0.3666733503341675,
0.15364359319210052,
-0.3025098741054535,
-0.08106449246406555,
0.8007503747940063,
-0.7246126532554626,
-0.06309299170970917,
-0.34430691599845886,
-0.9851069450378418,
-0.22864551842212677,
0.798904538154602,
-0.14070430397987366,
-0.17625689506530762,
0.5157569646835327,
0.24059715867042542,
0.3229471743106842,
-0.024670932441949844,
0.6492124795913696,
-0.5490112900733948,
0.15130363404750824,
1.1539853811264038,
0.6091596484184265,
-0.36480143666267395,
0.6903219819068909,
-0.646058201789856,
-0.7873161435127258,
-0.007756001316010952,
-0.6029338240623474,
-0.6105188727378845,
-0.6765974760055542,
-0.6664401888847351,
-0.4777736961841583,
0.7659597992897034,
1.327769160270691,
0.774442195892334,
-0.2814791202545166,
-0.6731040477752686,
-0.26328691840171814,
0.3091391921043396,
-0.8335837721824646,
-0.18109522759914398,
0.2688163220882416,
-0.47399333119392395,
-1.0383955240249634,
0.30244994163513184,
0.13704532384872437,
-0.2931613624095917,
-0.13751158118247986,
-0.5686321258544922,
-0.2665141820907593,
0.12260039895772934,
0.28354018926620483,
0.21906833350658417,
-0.27742522954940796,
-0.4543495178222656,
0.05487760528922081,
-0.04026344418525696,
-0.05564848333597183,
0.7490649223327637,
-0.5997507572174072,
0.6392887830734253,
0.19157780706882477,
0.6158835291862488,
0.442295104265213,
-0.18342772126197815,
0.7652662992477417,
-0.44746604561805725,
0.014843098819255829,
0.1185513362288475,
0.13692693412303925,
0.1772283911705017,
-0.34146395325660706,
0.7350720167160034,
0.6573991775512695,
-0.7819772362709045,
-0.6572413444519043,
-0.1543818861246109,
-0.7433435916900635,
0.038114648312330246,
0.6199283003807068,
-0.7427491545677185,
-0.15439973771572113,
0.07588081061840057,
-0.3033117949962616,
0.34447240829467773,
-0.6471956372261047,
0.710742712020874,
0.8184403777122498,
-0.34503817558288574,
-0.13982677459716797,
-0.03463462367653847,
0.4908413887023926,
0.5584395527839661,
-0.45949533581733704,
-0.3712140917778015,
0.4374649226665497,
-0.07601298391819,
0.607344925403595,
0.6908469796180725,
0.47391343116760254,
0.5325314402580261,
0.6887122988700867,
0.22742381691932678,
-0.13342784345149994,
-0.8336776494979858,
-0.07487817108631134,
0.42314204573631287,
0.29599878191947937,
-0.8909119367599487
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17491v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17491v1
|
DGoT: Dynamic Graph of Thoughts for Scientific Abstract Generation
| 2024-03-26T08:47:23 | 2024-03-26T08:47:23 |
Xinyu Ning, Yutong Zhao, Yitong Liu, Hongwen Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The method of training language models based on domain datasets has obtained
significant achievements in the task of generating scientific paper abstracts.
However, such models face problems of generalization and expensive training
costs. The use of large language models (LLMs) to solve the task of generating
paper abstracts saves the cost of model training. However, due to the
hallucination problem of LLM, it is often necessary to improve the reliability
of the results through multi-round query prompt approach such as Graph of
Thoughts (GoT), which also brings additional reasoning costs. In this paper, we
propose a Dynamic Graph of Thought (DGoT). It not only inherits the advantages
of the existing GoT prompt approach, but also dynamically adjust the graph
structure according to data characteristics while reducing model reasoning
cost. Experimental results show that our method's cost-effectiveness in
abstract generation tasks is only 43.7% to 56.4% of other multi-round query
prompt approaches. Our code is available at https://github.com/JayceNing/DGoT.
|
[
-0.341354638338089,
-1.124194622039795,
1.0491362810134888,
0.05678229033946991,
-0.4233485758304596,
0.5364160537719727,
-0.13903898000717163,
-0.3759387135505676,
0.3926126956939697,
0.14174070954322815,
-0.6496163010597229,
-0.3907180726528168,
-0.5076671838760376,
0.214584618806839,
-0.15383358299732208,
0.9314619898796082,
-0.15184760093688965,
-0.32862621545791626,
-0.1415148675441742,
0.12464838474988937,
-0.40144288539886475,
-0.14908424019813538,
-0.8674997091293335,
-0.23053863644599915,
0.6508945822715759,
-0.026878612115979195,
0.44832685589790344,
0.4599449634552002,
0.477871298789978,
0.37266072630882263,
-0.08267703652381897,
0.5627243518829346,
-0.4578782618045807,
0.5130190253257751,
-0.07539409399032593,
-0.21889197826385498,
-0.8274043798446655,
-0.1506340354681015,
0.7682786583900452,
0.6177565455436707,
-0.11268903315067291,
-0.18904326856136322,
-0.21550972759723663,
0.8889220356941223,
-0.061772964894771576,
0.5734073519706726,
-1.1414995193481445,
-0.05222707241773605,
-0.03127538040280342,
-0.27681103348731995,
-0.3301667869091034,
-0.49187996983528137,
0.05811309814453125,
-0.6367036700248718,
0.0625581368803978,
0.08219140768051147,
0.6451182961463928,
0.26936495304107666,
-0.2530461847782135,
-0.42590034008026123,
-0.36061716079711914,
0.5205995440483093,
-0.6479156613349915,
0.16264884173870087,
0.003508738474920392,
0.4363667964935303,
-0.5359656810760498,
-0.9507783651351929,
-0.8439269065856934,
-0.3535163998603821,
0.07692278176546097,
0.1681595891714096,
-0.09068401157855988,
-0.04270118847489357,
0.34157830476760864,
0.21941226720809937,
-0.4860890805721283,
-0.42109429836273193,
-0.11638311296701431,
0.0884663462638855,
0.6981989741325378,
0.23039796948432922,
0.3482096791267395,
-0.08667050302028656,
-0.08597980439662933,
0.01301914919167757,
-0.6079919934272766,
-0.399720698595047,
0.5300865173339844,
0.4217947721481323,
0.056102998554706573,
0.2367708384990692,
-0.40528029203414917,
0.8940180540084839,
0.3971686065196991,
-0.25467148423194885,
0.49844664335250854,
-0.28953349590301514,
0.24452733993530273,
0.05112224817276001,
0.6875210404396057,
0.17386330664157867,
0.1875535547733307,
-0.18120215833187103,
-0.3530270755290985,
-0.1144036203622818,
0.3520527482032776,
-0.8711060881614685,
-0.444562703371048,
0.12104235589504242,
-0.1378858983516693,
-0.47834792733192444,
-0.25172385573387146,
-0.7398609519004822,
-0.1259329617023468,
-0.3151252567768097,
-0.03011384606361389,
-0.5240560173988342,
-0.32956498861312866,
0.1302368938922882,
0.11950197070837021,
-0.4962729811668396,
0.6370755434036255,
-0.775134265422821,
0.11501450091600418,
0.2356468290090561,
1.0142066478729248,
-0.3202439546585083,
-0.10778038203716278,
-0.3774108588695526,
0.038521137088537216,
-0.10995012521743774,
0.9376847147941589,
-0.5742818117141724,
-0.31721818447113037,
-0.32708653807640076,
-0.3721434772014618,
-0.25251534581184387,
-0.031088298186659813,
0.11593286693096161,
-0.6891497373580933,
0.2870236933231354,
-0.20259039103984833,
-0.4932660460472107,
-0.15041151642799377,
0.504038393497467,
-0.6048646569252014,
0.8589140176773071,
0.22805024683475494,
-1.137072205543518,
0.22423523664474487,
-0.8941844701766968,
-0.19218797981739044,
0.4561133086681366,
-0.6680582761764526,
-0.2942736744880676,
-0.15368734300136566,
0.30265286564826965,
0.1175883561372757,
-0.030825920403003693,
0.7078983187675476,
-0.259430468082428,
-0.0824434757232666,
0.26603782176971436,
-0.2574850618839264,
0.5055395364761353,
0.4684280455112457,
-0.5003293752670288,
0.17032521963119507,
-1.006138801574707,
0.26733294129371643,
0.44239121675491333,
-0.3709883987903595,
-0.22513127326965332,
0.12341369688510895,
-0.41244691610336304,
0.11752952635288239,
0.09709464013576508,
-0.4942493140697479,
0.6045348644256592,
-0.3902367055416107,
0.42902684211730957,
0.7161946296691895,
0.22734588384628296,
-0.015396451577544212,
-0.009885714389383793,
0.5499930381774902,
-0.19557301700115204,
-0.2579195499420166,
-0.14482402801513672,
-0.5868489146232605,
-0.5350068807601929,
-0.44018691778182983,
0.22360190749168396,
0.30812329053878784,
-0.964122474193573,
0.37912747263908386,
-0.2706625163555145,
-0.49623626470565796,
-0.07126292586326599,
-0.3240739405155182,
0.33416077494621277,
0.7760269045829773,
0.13745519518852234,
0.055517345666885376,
-0.39683976769447327,
-0.7063304781913757,
-0.04239923134446144,
-0.25449928641319275,
0.1844576746225357,
0.3114898204803467,
0.675364077091217,
-0.17982865869998932,
0.9468058943748474,
-0.9264324903488159,
0.37524139881134033,
-0.16545237600803375,
0.16510038077831268,
0.36371907591819763,
0.1769939512014389,
0.5109575390815735,
-0.5919082760810852,
-0.6110104322433472,
-0.11418840289115906,
-0.7357470989227295,
-0.1854265332221985,
-0.06483010202646255,
-0.2721187174320221,
0.029165849089622498,
0.23877395689487457,
-0.8348791599273682,
0.21089372038841248,
0.3462955355644226,
-0.09908399730920792,
0.7379301190376282,
-0.3165176510810852,
0.24028551578521729,
-1.074684500694275,
0.16627134382724762,
-0.22437173128128052,
-0.25573933124542236,
-0.3338577449321747,
0.06456160545349121,
-0.17768733203411102,
-0.424514502286911,
-0.2612239122390747,
0.5611746907234192,
-0.5966104865074158,
0.3832305669784546,
-0.5806744694709778,
0.4468761086463928,
-0.03919528052210808,
0.46242305636405945,
0.07145451009273529,
0.8603637218475342,
0.7090146541595459,
-0.6180221438407898,
0.6680156588554382,
0.35132819414138794,
-0.3710833191871643,
0.36735284328460693,
-0.6343096494674683,
0.6643393635749817,
-0.18160881102085114,
0.6459001302719116,
-0.9932311773300171,
-0.2742631733417511,
0.40686264634132385,
-0.17463253438472748,
0.35691842436790466,
0.18101051449775696,
-0.3547604978084564,
-0.559632420539856,
-0.25396308302879333,
0.4111054837703705,
0.31774285435676575,
-0.5676353573799133,
0.1752871721982956,
0.46726173162460327,
-0.49131518602371216,
-0.47581782937049866,
-0.3402744233608246,
0.1546276956796646,
-0.15135551989078522,
-0.8528176546096802,
0.5136534571647644,
-0.22353699803352356,
-0.28751447796821594,
0.003223470412194729,
-0.07192021608352661,
0.36541467905044556,
-0.3000915050506592,
-0.06933727115392685,
0.0826282650232315,
0.02652326598763466,
0.27568575739860535,
0.26940593123435974,
-0.17555183172225952,
0.07057265937328339,
-0.5764636397361755,
0.6157480478286743,
-0.2488120198249817,
-0.29518115520477295,
-0.07014990597963333,
0.34762129187583923,
0.4419432580471039,
-0.1290813833475113,
0.272007018327713,
-0.031980689615011215,
-0.23912066221237183,
-0.5480346083641052,
-0.151715487241745,
-0.1465902328491211,
-0.5119063854217529,
0.589806079864502,
-0.569593608379364,
-0.6658602356910706,
0.5193014144897461,
-0.24090810120105743,
0.1695757508277893,
0.2440313696861267,
0.8477250337600708,
0.1398332118988037,
1.1133607625961304,
0.31329047679901123,
0.29571887850761414,
0.3720722198486328,
-0.1251276731491089,
0.41526731848716736,
-0.5423805117607117,
-0.17840100824832916,
-0.2939140200614929,
-0.3130166232585907,
-0.4202168583869934,
-0.21454398334026337,
0.5037084817886353,
-0.25433075428009033,
-0.07909850776195526,
-0.09588555246591568,
-0.925377607345581,
0.4199050962924957,
0.24993906915187836,
0.22422361373901367,
0.34023359417915344,
0.37542837858200073,
-0.27796781063079834,
0.07466666400432587,
-0.6639921069145203,
-0.7305431365966797,
0.87742018699646,
0.05794071406126022,
0.7922478914260864,
-0.10518530756235123,
0.624036967754364,
0.27068689465522766,
0.08321035653352737,
-0.5965209603309631,
0.9175940752029419,
0.30322515964508057,
-0.3974902033805847,
-0.41036084294319153,
-0.5898452997207642,
-1.053523302078247,
0.41463616490364075,
0.044377896934747696,
-0.8007116317749023,
-0.15649966895580292,
0.44645512104034424,
-0.12471494823694229,
0.49074873328208923,
-0.18088127672672272,
0.36033445596694946,
-0.4661029577255249,
-0.17473052442073822,
-0.2701052129268646,
-0.45005694031715393,
0.4315823018550873,
-0.4244929850101471,
0.07619301229715347,
-0.11235412955284119,
0.22932282090187073,
0.8104594349861145,
-0.5407715439796448,
0.6872206330299377,
-0.28444796800613403,
-0.17386579513549805,
0.5542516708374023,
-0.07132130116224289,
1.0755544900894165,
0.36550942063331604,
-0.16470596194267273,
-0.18952396512031555,
-0.5076398253440857,
-0.1620255708694458,
-0.658385694026947,
0.8126890659332275,
-0.36585861444473267,
-0.7936627268791199,
-0.5535817742347717,
-1.0301432609558105,
-0.32623136043548584,
0.42634913325309753,
0.22606314718723297,
0.3364230990409851,
-0.06038865074515343,
-0.32073697447776794,
0.6359100937843323,
-0.1826995462179184,
0.2649228870868683,
0.14442658424377441,
-0.5642396211624146,
-0.6467899680137634,
0.7755110859870911,
0.11197281628847122,
0.2716902196407318,
0.03971177712082863,
0.19958972930908203,
-0.23828360438346863,
-0.8361458778381348,
-0.5581727027893066,
0.3437556326389313,
-0.7234506607055664,
-0.1610420197248459,
-0.9830122590065002,
-0.07825131714344025,
-0.2963176667690277,
-0.0155645115301013,
-0.21131779253482819,
-0.6984302997589111,
0.1660812944173813,
-0.38773471117019653,
0.9059924483299255,
0.40521296858787537,
0.20707222819328308,
0.29751306772232056,
-0.44527336955070496,
0.2216477245092392,
0.3798697590827942,
0.23760564625263214,
0.2021225094795227,
-0.3223838210105896,
-0.18216721713542938,
0.17850172519683838,
-0.5925195217132568,
-0.8032947778701782,
0.35901695489883423,
0.004051647614687681,
0.5759045481681824,
0.14366371929645538,
-0.04995909333229065,
0.4643233120441437,
-0.7560597658157349,
0.5538167953491211,
0.5011603832244873,
-0.6067526340484619,
0.6365892887115479,
-0.6950730085372925,
0.25236397981643677,
0.5595422983169556,
0.2566303014755249,
-0.2127026468515396,
-0.7003465890884399,
-0.7652961611747742,
-0.8887215852737427,
0.5573512315750122,
0.2316429615020752,
0.12301146984100342,
-0.2636153995990753,
0.45976153016090393,
0.3969012498855591,
0.457984060049057,
-0.5679358243942261,
-0.09584325551986694,
-0.31533747911453247,
-0.1481725126504898,
0.45011815428733826,
-0.0027900650165975094,
-0.12521065771579742,
-0.38138359785079956,
0.6760234832763672,
-0.21088907122612,
0.4436086118221283,
0.008074969984591007,
0.20799507200717926,
-0.16192826628684998,
0.0873478576540947,
0.5766943693161011,
1.002632737159729,
-0.35829615592956543,
0.3148784041404724,
0.1322784721851349,
-0.5975551605224609,
0.2672409117221832,
-0.034873295575380325,
-0.560164749622345,
0.19733184576034546,
0.0989452674984932,
1.1710103750228882,
-0.2557552754878998,
-0.45910555124282837,
0.03914634883403778,
0.02520844340324402,
-0.4635385572910309,
-0.07814757525920868,
0.32964178919792175,
0.2323564738035202,
0.1459590345621109,
0.29012492299079895,
-0.14184518158435822,
0.04216544330120087,
-0.43260008096694946,
0.23868168890476227,
0.4368123710155487,
-0.05673154816031456,
-0.4428503215312958,
0.7396359443664551,
0.3782580494880676,
-0.3857101500034332,
0.7469176054000854,
-0.5609105229377747,
-0.5943458080291748,
0.43026235699653625,
0.811268150806427,
0.9130680561065674,
0.0931091234087944,
0.2562432289123535,
0.26151227951049805,
0.0015548577066510916,
0.07038474828004837,
0.5751601457595825,
0.21517695486545563,
-0.4352083206176758,
-0.559772789478302,
-0.5369648337364197,
-0.4838620722293854,
0.3686695098876953,
0.043870359659194946,
0.26607590913772583,
-0.41357696056365967,
-0.45907241106033325,
0.09622839093208313,
0.036199603229761124,
-0.2674461603164673,
0.22733300924301147,
0.0977160781621933,
0.5520375967025757,
-0.4482437074184418,
0.8982749581336975,
0.7570191025733948,
-0.419646292924881,
-0.7168058753013611,
-0.09237931668758392,
-0.18564940989017487,
-0.5777842402458191,
0.8601325750350952,
0.052705228328704834,
-0.48886239528656006,
0.2130119651556015,
-0.4903324246406555,
-0.9335671663284302,
0.8347625136375427,
0.4653303921222687,
-0.7743018269538879,
-0.20586366951465607,
-0.22025282680988312,
0.3914019465446472,
-0.6719123125076294,
0.17236843705177307,
0.173665851354599,
0.7639966607093811,
0.25128138065338135,
-0.5531627535820007,
0.36354097723960876,
-0.3940408527851105,
-0.20817512273788452,
0.301924467086792,
-0.6360594034194946,
1.021570086479187,
-0.3930233120918274,
-0.32909050583839417,
-0.3260507583618164,
0.5920405983924866,
0.7810295224189758,
0.3175598084926605,
0.5648154616355896,
0.3648870885372162,
1.2302887439727783,
0.05687621608376503,
0.8837704062461853,
-0.31019842624664307,
0.3537445068359375,
0.9435985088348389,
-0.47590166330337524,
0.09467530995607376,
0.4075542688369751,
-0.3515643775463104,
0.5352128744125366,
0.645652711391449,
-0.08151919394731522,
0.7938644886016846,
0.6167724132537842,
-0.31127163767814636,
0.03857138380408287,
0.45459306240081787,
-0.6562092304229736,
-0.03477796912193298,
0.24386800825595856,
-0.15590164065361023,
-0.3376883864402771,
-0.04295285418629646,
0.23858751356601715,
0.05018199235200882,
0.036515459418296814,
0.43696799874305725,
0.08926104754209518,
-0.7305771112442017,
0.8949809074401855,
-0.2566087543964386,
0.4771575927734375,
-0.704838216304779,
-0.11612692475318909,
-0.263993501663208,
0.08451145142316818,
-0.14498165249824524,
-0.5199739933013916,
0.12723322212696075,
0.23174454271793365,
-0.2910483181476593,
-0.12382207810878754,
0.7866354584693909,
-0.36999890208244324,
-0.7334089875221252,
-0.01862250082194805,
0.628728449344635,
0.44141051173210144,
-0.006110357120633125,
-0.8794795870780945,
-0.04430757090449333,
0.22179047763347626,
-0.7181902527809143,
0.30916959047317505,
0.6821905970573425,
-0.2433333694934845,
0.6855270266532898,
0.6477543115615845,
0.34492039680480957,
-0.05511923506855965,
0.04626622796058655,
1.048399806022644,
-0.5716372728347778,
-0.5621443390846252,
-0.8906077146530151,
0.3280235826969147,
-0.3914041519165039,
-0.14094260334968567,
0.5814346075057983,
0.4408796727657318,
0.42228996753692627,
-0.19509148597717285,
1.0515575408935547,
-0.19415581226348877,
0.41019096970558167,
-0.6210145354270935,
0.8970694541931152,
-0.504438042640686,
0.12686046957969666,
-0.4504154920578003,
-1.0968984365463257,
-0.2779170274734497,
0.668136477470398,
-0.2867109775543213,
0.20194017887115479,
1.1514936685562134,
0.6079027056694031,
-0.13191591203212738,
0.03039250150322914,
-0.014069988392293453,
-0.027695298194885254,
0.6480602622032166,
0.34639719128608704,
0.9545207023620605,
0.09614504873752594,
0.37715286016464233,
-0.00887287501245737,
-0.41016289591789246,
0.03919139876961708,
-1.163784384727478,
-0.8408288359642029,
-0.37592342495918274,
-0.6943597197532654,
-0.2690701186656952,
0.23291178047657013,
0.7474228739738464,
0.455917626619339,
-0.4429382085800171,
-0.00010704060696298257,
-0.367348313331604,
-0.015910347923636436,
-0.2282971739768982,
-0.13991694152355194,
0.8854756355285645,
-0.744164228439331,
-0.7939173579216003,
0.5240710377693176,
0.28751546144485474,
-0.05416760966181755,
-0.12208292633295059,
-0.04651525989174843,
-0.36214205622673035,
0.24130862951278687,
0.6077858209609985,
0.028166458010673523,
-0.4921765625476837,
-0.3325062394142151,
-0.0033267936669290066,
-0.00981968268752098,
0.17865608632564545,
0.7595181465148926,
-0.7300600409507751,
0.5490587949752808,
0.5399681329727173,
0.49237582087516785,
0.7647145390510559,
0.008631671778857708,
0.47271618247032166,
-0.5243397951126099,
0.2551080584526062,
0.2267683893442154,
0.3639025092124939,
0.1635936200618744,
-0.4529663622379303,
0.59695965051651,
0.39597177505493164,
-0.6274732351303101,
-1.0139060020446777,
0.3266022205352783,
-1.0288194417953491,
-0.30829742550849915,
0.9170041084289551,
-0.076434426009655,
-0.29800039529800415,
0.0022857722360640764,
-0.46857520937919617,
0.41210806369781494,
-0.6042189598083496,
1.1947940587997437,
0.761436402797699,
-0.5495629906654358,
0.15731054544448853,
-0.43667662143707275,
0.3909587860107422,
0.12699857354164124,
-1.0269259214401245,
0.308664470911026,
0.6419593095779419,
0.031007390469312668,
0.3146800696849823,
0.8466922640800476,
-0.0493493378162384,
-0.1402260959148407,
0.2706809341907501,
0.19564981758594513,
-0.47979775071144104,
-0.2794945240020752,
0.29664260149002075,
0.18075761198997498,
0.1089375838637352,
-0.11227816343307495
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17486v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17486v1
|
KDMCSE: Knowledge Distillation Multimodal Sentence Embeddings with Adaptive Angular margin Contrastive Learning
| 2024-03-26T08:32:39 | 2024-03-26T08:32:39 |
Cong-Duy Nguyen, Thong Nguyen, Xiaobao Wu, Anh Tuan Luu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Previous work on multimodal sentence embedding has proposed multimodal
contrastive learning and achieved promising results. However, by taking the
rest of the batch as negative samples without reviewing when forming
contrastive pairs, those studies encountered many suspicious and noisy negative
examples, significantly affecting the methods' overall performance. In this
work, we propose KDMCSE (Knowledge Distillation Multimodal contrastive learning
of Sentence Embeddings), a novel approach that enhances the discrimination and
generalizability of multimodal representation and inherits the knowledge from
the teacher model to learn the difference between positive and negative
instances and via that, can detect noisy and wrong negative samples effectively
before they are calculated in the contrastive objective. Furthermore, to
overcome the limitation of modeling the variation within negative pairs, we
introduce a new contrastive objective, AdapACSE (Adaptive Angular Margin
Supervised Contrastive Learning for Multimodal sentence embeddings), that
enhances the discriminative representation by strengthening the margin within
the angular space while capturing varying semantics within the negative.
Experimental results on widely used Semantic Textual Similarity (STS)
benchmarks demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach.
|
[
-0.5281158089637756,
-0.6871306896209717,
0.705979585647583,
0.010221472941339016,
-0.5175353288650513,
0.05808170512318611,
-0.1201595887541771,
-0.10092499852180481,
0.28082820773124695,
0.047925058752298355,
-0.5731874704360962,
-0.8976426720619202,
-0.8900195956230164,
-0.010611764155328274,
-0.24232250452041626,
0.8921172618865967,
-0.02321380376815796,
0.5027517080307007,
-0.3362240791320801,
-0.5166987180709839,
-0.5356061458587646,
-0.168768510222435,
-0.2764889597892761,
0.03823288902640343,
0.3071568012237549,
0.536647617816925,
0.42429736256599426,
0.2743208408355713,
0.1683390736579895,
0.22424675524234772,
-0.022333191707730293,
0.2198057323694229,
-0.38442280888557434,
0.3992100656032562,
-0.1441630870103836,
-0.458420068025589,
-0.005708086304366589,
0.1638326495885849,
0.22084571421146393,
0.45295271277427673,
-0.31905418634414673,
-0.20197202265262604,
-0.0023896440397948027,
0.639488935470581,
-1.0080218315124512,
0.25395113229751587,
-0.5345516204833984,
0.25919294357299805,
0.3201706111431122,
0.07772546261548996,
-0.36964601278305054,
-0.4398379623889923,
0.08812324702739716,
-0.8235586881637573,
0.0634918287396431,
-0.3108530342578888,
0.5020832419395447,
0.21928814053535461,
-0.9589675664901733,
-0.9769187569618225,
-0.23383605480194092,
1.060178518295288,
-0.5253017544746399,
0.6366205215454102,
0.2711222767829895,
0.4242783784866333,
0.17595860362052917,
-0.6340436935424805,
-0.7320824265480042,
-0.5215123891830444,
0.02368670515716076,
0.30817607045173645,
-0.08053496479988098,
0.033758342266082764,
-0.2324305772781372,
0.16337712109088898,
-0.004766625817865133,
-0.06826005131006241,
-0.18586376309394836,
-0.38070017099380493,
0.13553780317306519,
-0.09833572804927826,
0.23055163025856018,
-0.18768605589866638,
-0.7173544764518738,
-0.4432808458805084,
-0.18209610879421234,
-0.13020560145378113,
0.2833792567253113,
-0.05388613045215607,
-0.17736482620239258,
0.4235517680644989,
-0.22322000563144684,
0.35582587122917175,
0.05861705169081688,
-0.3290470242500305,
0.5965330004692078,
-0.5241491794586182,
-0.03611626476049423,
0.19114205241203308,
0.4579189121723175,
0.6546525955200195,
-0.11623115837574005,
0.008996731601655483,
-0.006079626735299826,
0.5618477463722229,
0.15944749116897583,
-0.8657675385475159,
-0.45229601860046387,
-0.21109765768051147,
-0.45699071884155273,
-0.6106227040290833,
-0.10641216486692429,
-1.2849494218826294,
-0.5270636677742004,
-0.47616884112358093,
0.5868014693260193,
-0.723066508769989,
-0.08320263028144836,
0.1536712944507599,
-0.3486514985561371,
-0.11833751946687698,
0.21359030902385712,
-0.5765669345855713,
0.4051399230957031,
0.28070688247680664,
0.6395423412322998,
0.04234950616955757,
-0.16034391522407532,
-0.6118715405464172,
-0.04112286865711212,
-0.2430383861064911,
0.5863593220710754,
-0.7012306451797485,
-0.5122181177139282,
-0.2357085794210434,
-0.08120740950107574,
0.041784562170505524,
-0.25574153661727905,
1.0150638818740845,
-0.5980982780456543,
0.27708396315574646,
-0.19115523993968964,
-0.6561299562454224,
-0.42998236417770386,
0.3721282184123993,
-0.4956127107143402,
0.6343358755111694,
-0.11908483505249023,
-0.4554152488708496,
0.602556049823761,
-0.4898562729358673,
-0.3123421370983124,
-0.4346679747104645,
-0.15319503843784332,
-0.6843414902687073,
0.018152432516217232,
0.47353824973106384,
0.5133867263793945,
0.07924585044384003,
0.1722787469625473,
-0.3956893980503082,
0.0895325243473053,
0.1958528608083725,
-0.639899730682373,
0.6760380864143372,
0.32166990637779236,
-0.1602732092142105,
-0.11119816452264786,
-1.1079400777816772,
-0.05456121265888214,
-0.18075861036777496,
-0.2813928723335266,
-0.8275180459022522,
-0.13099607825279236,
-0.14056192338466644,
0.34104499220848083,
0.04387999698519707,
-0.7296491861343384,
-0.0630127340555191,
0.12645204365253448,
0.37398266792297363,
0.7728697657585144,
0.21966178715229034,
0.6061733365058899,
-0.15748026967048645,
0.5408809781074524,
0.6106821894645691,
-0.06528822332620621,
-0.30241498351097107,
-0.3355375826358795,
-0.6523473858833313,
-0.44680190086364746,
0.2435196042060852,
0.24271991848945618,
-1.0943280458450317,
0.2539278566837311,
0.07791586965322495,
-0.532759964466095,
-0.6302650570869446,
0.37631458044052124,
0.5438615679740906,
0.7276719212532043,
0.7806088924407959,
-0.19952630996704102,
-0.5829489231109619,
-0.7414734363555908,
0.14135126769542694,
0.11290493607521057,
0.3556381165981293,
0.4132290780544281,
0.45447981357574463,
-0.3179130554199219,
0.6545278429985046,
-0.8370380401611328,
-0.6322569847106934,
0.08554603904485703,
0.22778503596782684,
-0.2648509740829468,
0.4315086901187897,
0.6570677757263184,
-1.0801997184753418,
-0.7910573482513428,
-0.19536498188972473,
-0.5209624171257019,
-0.19837060570716858,
0.15217715501785278,
-0.1993945837020874,
0.12705016136169434,
0.8345672488212585,
-0.45799651741981506,
0.00990518182516098,
0.7063238024711609,
-0.6517605781555176,
0.6381915807723999,
-0.2557031810283661,
0.32714080810546875,
-1.3022798299789429,
-0.28036755323410034,
0.09048233926296234,
-0.04839341342449188,
-0.4348282217979431,
-0.04819480702280998,
0.2828270494937897,
-0.08497613668441772,
-0.24006156623363495,
-0.012068349868059158,
-0.49123436212539673,
0.41835492849349976,
-0.09614014625549316,
0.4544157087802887,
0.3495917320251465,
0.5696330070495605,
-0.17373713850975037,
0.5541956424713135,
0.6120969653129578,
-0.6784132719039917,
0.4059671461582184,
0.3184398412704468,
-0.5293672680854797,
1.0327234268188477,
-0.16276726126670837,
-0.03822501748800278,
-0.40333279967308044,
0.24309390783309937,
-1.3203189373016357,
0.12681981921195984,
0.1294093281030655,
-0.4714553952217102,
0.1787821501493454,
-0.05118237063288689,
0.08704238384962082,
0.07294093072414398,
-0.6067321300506592,
0.3396064341068268,
0.43116331100463867,
-0.6034411191940308,
0.5138686895370483,
0.344611257314682,
-0.08383180946111679,
-0.7907738089561462,
-0.6755470037460327,
0.00037465078639797866,
-0.19828931987285614,
-0.27349430322647095,
0.33033281564712524,
-0.010777435265481472,
-0.12221229821443558,
0.3565824627876282,
-0.06303146481513977,
-0.1514768898487091,
0.11799579113721848,
-0.1296781748533249,
0.21033765375614166,
-0.3543647229671478,
0.6133015155792236,
0.3853066861629486,
-0.2870330214500427,
-0.10624796152114868,
-0.19431543350219727,
0.5647445917129517,
0.1588921695947647,
-0.383713960647583,
-0.47982537746429443,
0.17266015708446503,
0.5327849984169006,
-0.12983466684818268,
0.6692302227020264,
0.913237988948822,
-0.07474151253700256,
-0.09862446039915085,
-0.6148849725723267,
-0.22817644476890564,
-0.3876766264438629,
0.6850073933601379,
-0.3179083466529846,
-0.7906288504600525,
0.1251114010810852,
-0.025476742535829544,
-0.3723587989807129,
0.2638462483882904,
0.33625292778015137,
0.04944350942969322,
0.8329840302467346,
0.5638610124588013,
-0.06963338702917099,
0.32448258996009827,
-0.04343012720346451,
0.11364685744047165,
-0.5583216547966003,
-0.2870631217956543,
-0.4686909317970276,
-0.3886089622974396,
-0.3908718526363373,
-0.4993091821670532,
0.3360343873500824,
0.20273259282112122,
-0.010023796930909157,
0.13023632764816284,
-0.2679221034049988,
0.579347550868988,
0.512885332107544,
0.22724778950214386,
0.4060411751270294,
-0.08259039372205734,
-0.5740967988967896,
-0.2231196016073227,
-0.2594098150730133,
-0.30255982279777527,
1.0242557525634766,
0.08053231984376907,
0.743915319442749,
0.3197783827781677,
0.5884108543395996,
0.4012528657913208,
-0.08165541291236877,
-0.7910075783729553,
0.4448988139629364,
-0.40285125374794006,
-0.17475241422653198,
-0.12468912452459335,
-0.4370850920677185,
-0.5511397123336792,
0.4718523323535919,
-0.33269041776657104,
-0.22760702669620514,
0.6238942742347717,
-0.05139877274632454,
-0.28299251198768616,
0.19714581966400146,
-1.2777172327041626,
0.7670314311981201,
0.15312759578227997,
-0.10107676684856415,
-0.5094484090805054,
-0.5394237637519836,
0.14354507625102997,
0.20462976396083832,
0.2746068239212036,
0.017125390470027924,
-0.41070497035980225,
0.48223361372947693,
-0.2384631335735321,
0.9562109708786011,
-0.7011138796806335,
-0.22290389239788055,
0.35623669624328613,
0.28753355145454407,
0.367118775844574,
0.24275848269462585,
0.08410093933343887,
-0.18410778045654297,
-0.07604451477527618,
-0.332501083612442,
-0.6201037764549255,
0.8590908050537109,
-0.7703378796577454,
-0.40808814764022827,
-0.186452254652977,
-0.41459354758262634,
-0.3250375986099243,
0.28079044818878174,
-0.13070979714393616,
0.49662718176841736,
-0.2908688187599182,
0.4349353015422821,
0.5612586140632629,
-0.17297549545764923,
0.3884866535663605,
0.5709342956542969,
0.020804420113563538,
-0.7421228885650635,
0.9331443309783936,
-0.09958881139755249,
0.42658141255378723,
0.5723537802696228,
0.1120867133140564,
-0.4100234806537628,
-0.3772294521331787,
-0.21835406124591827,
-0.14640434086322784,
-1.018247127532959,
-0.3163784444332123,
-0.8435724377632141,
0.15712334215641022,
-0.40991294384002686,
-0.3042428195476532,
-0.1864633709192276,
-0.589832603931427,
-0.5337604880332947,
-0.3186911642551422,
0.30169135332107544,
0.44714587926864624,
-0.31067192554473877,
0.06476043909788132,
-0.6065930128097534,
0.5241325497627258,
0.5655385255813599,
0.30804234743118286,
0.13889150321483612,
-0.24883484840393066,
-0.10006018728017807,
0.18568573892116547,
-0.7712568044662476,
-0.6477531790733337,
0.24433432519435883,
0.4269988238811493,
0.5132752656936646,
0.4265129864215851,
0.1880507469177246,
0.583387017250061,
-0.336240291595459,
0.7141180634498596,
0.45787331461906433,
-0.9924570322036743,
0.3119675815105438,
0.12841780483722687,
0.2598714232444763,
0.7486045360565186,
0.6872246265411377,
-0.5791327953338623,
-0.2659238874912262,
-0.32262134552001953,
-0.5201906561851501,
0.3887593746185303,
0.01669152081012726,
0.2768371105194092,
-0.17080047726631165,
0.019104747101664543,
0.41004523634910583,
0.18583159148693085,
-0.7919508814811707,
-0.10228683799505234,
-0.40977513790130615,
-0.5593550801277161,
-0.31952014565467834,
-0.5816814303398132,
0.056218720972537994,
0.046898968517780304,
0.8659645318984985,
-0.04234182834625244,
0.056538090109825134,
0.4300239682197571,
-0.3516237437725067,
0.23822706937789917,
0.651988685131073,
0.470159113407135,
0.21145690977573395,
-0.0490974485874176,
0.4933658540248871,
0.28153035044670105,
-0.814021646976471,
0.46422117948532104,
0.17677685618400574,
0.07477684319019318,
-0.015949971973896027,
0.20017963647842407,
0.5617568492889404,
0.21973784267902374,
-0.6435691714286804,
0.7010046243667603,
-0.10522139817476273,
-0.3002321124076843,
-0.08752049505710602,
-0.06729605793952942,
0.16599728167057037,
0.2940041422843933,
0.1653890758752823,
0.4134060740470886,
0.3019990921020508,
-0.3959246575832367,
0.3688226044178009,
0.22950327396392822,
-0.8908928036689758,
-0.09682463109493256,
0.4051327407360077,
0.2513573169708252,
0.2834652066230774,
0.3415195941925049,
-0.5682834386825562,
-0.3763621151447296,
0.6073030829429626,
0.3018011450767517,
0.5171074271202087,
-0.3444358706474304,
0.4705773890018463,
0.28984054923057556,
-0.01714234985411167,
0.2640148997306824,
0.1374911069869995,
-0.43317845463752747,
-0.9942377209663391,
-0.2148040384054184,
-0.4275611937046051,
-0.12565648555755615,
-0.27673956751823425,
-0.7595157027244568,
0.6006162762641907,
-0.17350950837135315,
0.11974264681339264,
0.1047634407877922,
-0.07667325437068939,
-0.13866981863975525,
0.22141540050506592,
0.0577901229262352,
0.6400736570358276,
-0.8770531415939331,
0.7181448340415955,
0.579913854598999,
-0.36256635189056396,
-0.24656245112419128,
-0.09567110240459442,
0.04774714633822441,
-0.745717465877533,
0.6645234227180481,
0.17625963687896729,
-0.18602041900157928,
-0.05341742932796478,
-0.20639891922473907,
-0.475214421749115,
1.4312267303466797,
0.2926698327064514,
-0.4998084306716919,
0.21649828553199768,
-0.1043437123298645,
0.45277535915374756,
-0.2904585897922516,
0.15080435574054718,
0.2197706550359726,
0.21155574917793274,
0.1683460772037506,
-0.4722242057323456,
0.0318591482937336,
-0.19443541765213013,
-0.11376691609621048,
0.25829675793647766,
-0.6005876064300537,
0.8595232963562012,
-0.10144771635532379,
-0.11974435299634933,
0.06827477365732193,
0.3337720036506653,
0.0594443716108799,
0.49233636260032654,
0.6726029515266418,
1.0143071413040161,
0.6880980730056763,
0.1374530792236328,
0.5594401955604553,
-0.1878611445426941,
0.3580131530761719,
1.109144687652588,
-0.2963080108165741,
0.5372368693351746,
0.6007070541381836,
-0.042933396995067596,
0.795901894569397,
-0.07449992746114731,
-0.02342122234404087,
1.1477214097976685,
-0.18355867266654968,
-0.5419068932533264,
-0.10917803645133972,
-0.13886725902557373,
-0.3615507185459137,
0.4512239396572113,
0.3938094675540924,
-0.4986358880996704,
-0.6310887932777405,
0.47347280383110046,
-0.056286681443452835,
0.6034417748451233,
-0.2698324918746948,
0.8851797580718994,
0.20810608565807343,
-0.45267391204833984,
0.3912310302257538,
0.020782316103577614,
0.8975064158439636,
-0.6663128137588501,
-0.25989705324172974,
0.031231136992573738,
0.5129712224006653,
-0.05095015466213226,
-0.6123708486557007,
0.1291019469499588,
-0.44065454602241516,
-0.20289024710655212,
-0.0986156165599823,
0.6907718777656555,
-0.56363844871521,
-0.5469871163368225,
0.4993668496608734,
0.32003119587898254,
-0.43581247329711914,
0.36790281534194946,
-0.43147996068000793,
-0.2176205962896347,
0.10883139818906784,
0.08812393993139267,
0.2466326504945755,
0.7214921116828918,
0.37481066584587097,
0.6233089566230774,
0.42603740096092224,
-0.1493789404630661,
-0.01579066552221775,
0.11673188209533691,
0.97210294008255,
-0.3583928942680359,
-0.8304069638252258,
-0.9658032059669495,
0.2640627324581146,
-0.14901207387447357,
-0.3062957525253296,
0.8599104881286621,
0.45260897278785706,
0.8407720923423767,
-0.24381452798843384,
0.6121336817741394,
-0.0659455955028534,
0.6148000359535217,
-0.8795452117919922,
0.6022847890853882,
-0.34945279359817505,
0.10166516900062561,
-0.38856688141822815,
-0.6393316984176636,
-0.10187482833862305,
0.5831119418144226,
-0.3169233202934265,
0.00730219716206193,
0.8437519073486328,
0.9643783569335938,
-0.2744218111038208,
0.31769677996635437,
0.3641120493412018,
0.4778205156326294,
0.2913171350955963,
0.617211103439331,
0.6868414282798767,
-0.5003465414047241,
0.8404415845870972,
-0.5354704260826111,
-0.14028656482696533,
-0.02334785647690296,
-0.8511384129524231,
-0.7021530270576477,
-0.8887778520584106,
-0.27639833092689514,
-0.27870166301727295,
0.22832918167114258,
0.9044219255447388,
0.48006969690322876,
-0.9361264705657959,
0.0815376341342926,
-0.3106827437877655,
0.12231007218360901,
-0.26623716950416565,
-0.2350652664899826,
0.44838187098503113,
-0.677916407585144,
-0.6090241074562073,
0.1856691539287567,
0.020462950691580772,
0.06784463673830032,
-0.14298635721206665,
-0.14661280810832977,
-0.5835743546485901,
-0.23603002727031708,
0.7069100737571716,
-0.31114035844802856,
-0.19047369062900543,
-0.1484166979789734,
-0.2057020366191864,
-0.10021693259477615,
0.04240623861551285,
0.722038745880127,
-0.7902132868766785,
0.6017268300056458,
0.21810245513916016,
0.7124608755111694,
0.3529296815395355,
-0.13076816499233246,
0.3377131521701813,
-0.839187741279602,
0.3717294931411743,
0.25489920377731323,
0.4671805799007416,
0.16912105679512024,
-0.27421092987060547,
0.13324159383773804,
0.36154475808143616,
-0.33440500497817993,
-0.4022619426250458,
0.2673158347606659,
-0.9681795835494995,
-0.49745577573776245,
1.1243047714233398,
-0.2227144092321396,
0.10657855123281479,
-0.22106832265853882,
-0.6015654802322388,
0.1400936394929886,
-0.6532984375953674,
1.0917296409606934,
0.9795267581939697,
0.39305439591407776,
-0.09172394871711731,
-0.2812449038028717,
0.34652307629585266,
0.49100247025489807,
-0.38285157084465027,
-0.2410106658935547,
0.675775945186615,
0.22447749972343445,
0.3737952709197998,
0.24688582122325897,
-0.3475273549556732,
0.46973323822021484,
0.16539573669433594,
0.011664802208542824,
-0.19844113290309906,
-0.021520856767892838,
-0.30815669894218445,
0.47517505288124084,
-0.13755619525909424,
-0.341306209564209
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17445v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17445v1
|
Incorporating Exponential Smoothing into MLP: A Simple but Effective Sequence Model
| 2024-03-26T07:23:46 | 2024-03-26T07:23:46 |
Jiqun Chu, Zuoquan Lin
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Modeling long-range dependencies in sequential data is a crucial step in
sequence learning. A recently developed model, the Structured State Space (S4),
demonstrated significant effectiveness in modeling long-range sequences.
However, It is unclear whether the success of S4 can be attributed to its
intricate parameterization and HiPPO initialization or simply due to State
Space Models (SSMs). To further investigate the potential of the deep SSMs, we
start with exponential smoothing (ETS), a simple SSM, and propose a stacked
architecture by directly incorporating it into an element-wise MLP. We augment
simple ETS with additional parameters and complex field to reduce the inductive
bias. Despite increasing less than 1\% of parameters of element-wise MLP, our
models achieve comparable results to S4 on the LRA benchmark.
|
[
-0.2187878042459488,
-0.6342805027961731,
0.8595099449157715,
0.1421544849872589,
-0.17584407329559326,
-0.10753054171800613,
0.1163690835237503,
-0.6593700647354126,
0.3167106807231903,
0.4374291002750397,
-0.3884240686893463,
-0.26834017038345337,
-0.46636125445365906,
-0.10073000192642212,
-0.3650963008403778,
0.7174270749092102,
0.14115822315216064,
-0.2128351330757141,
-0.002158533548936248,
0.13799594342708588,
-0.2345777302980423,
-0.2914547324180603,
-0.5073111057281494,
-0.31729045510292053,
0.30699265003204346,
0.24766027927398682,
0.6816923022270203,
0.8940693140029907,
0.24649396538734436,
0.3136080503463745,
-0.1773936152458191,
0.3956640362739563,
-0.37038716673851013,
0.37600037455558777,
0.17351314425468445,
-0.38255906105041504,
-0.5590003132820129,
-0.3567189574241638,
1.0972154140472412,
1.149979591369629,
-0.1776389330625534,
0.00486293900758028,
0.10952391475439072,
0.7444904446601868,
-0.4425361454486847,
0.0705094039440155,
-0.4055232107639313,
0.3013617694377899,
-0.034444354474544525,
-0.4741040766239166,
-0.5132793188095093,
-0.11552172899246216,
0.11168283224105835,
-0.687522828578949,
0.04785942658782005,
0.13687995076179504,
0.5979605317115784,
0.5185120701789856,
-0.6892430186271667,
0.20190146565437317,
-1.2619885206222534,
0.5961639285087585,
-0.629723072052002,
0.4563734531402588,
0.1350955069065094,
0.10133872926235199,
-0.8049931526184082,
-0.7696170806884766,
-0.2645774185657501,
-0.09309472888708115,
0.18983770906925201,
-0.03708679974079132,
0.25480377674102783,
0.12780362367630005,
0.5631455779075623,
0.3545551896095276,
-0.3583264946937561,
0.5093350410461426,
-0.5218751430511475,
0.12102710455656052,
0.5917842388153076,
0.3533419966697693,
-0.12018635123968124,
-0.09102179110050201,
-0.8141459822654724,
0.2708868682384491,
-0.8963056802749634,
0.4649578332901001,
0.3139341473579407,
0.46219635009765625,
-0.10118688642978668,
0.6144344806671143,
-0.1277456283569336,
0.5019609332084656,
0.1667729914188385,
0.15958121418952942,
0.08185521513223648,
0.0059015098959207535,
-0.3164704740047455,
-0.12443456798791885,
0.34913063049316406,
0.12124243378639221,
-0.2777586877346039,
0.1847759187221527,
-0.1608193963766098,
0.0904909297823906,
0.38611891865730286,
-0.9788368940353394,
-0.08398677408695221,
0.6147236824035645,
-0.33781927824020386,
0.02354222908616066,
0.0038753487169742584,
-0.4930489957332611,
-0.40116405487060547,
-0.4069274663925171,
0.3382432758808136,
-0.4754537343978882,
0.12292192131280899,
0.20521031320095062,
-0.045455168932676315,
0.24314890801906586,
0.2713298201560974,
-0.9348914623260498,
0.5592432618141174,
0.8669570684432983,
0.8145674467086792,
-0.2539274990558624,
-0.054215721786022186,
-0.6139870882034302,
0.07465272396802902,
-0.5181826949119568,
0.7855614423751831,
-0.5146575570106506,
-0.49510765075683594,
0.08152128756046295,
-0.030646495521068573,
0.1882440745830536,
-0.1610235720872879,
0.6450353860855103,
-0.508125364780426,
0.08886754512786865,
0.011400443501770496,
-1.020606517791748,
-0.044156257063150406,
-0.2323182076215744,
-0.7349352240562439,
1.6075608730316162,
-0.11233066767454147,
-0.29598918557167053,
0.6323282718658447,
-0.527131974697113,
-0.41009822487831116,
0.4384119510650635,
-0.42657792568206787,
-0.5506945848464966,
0.31007516384124756,
0.07597671449184418,
0.7250227332115173,
0.2501126825809479,
0.13890425860881805,
-0.5669159889221191,
-0.6810340881347656,
-0.03161896392703056,
0.11150877922773361,
0.36553627252578735,
0.2535046339035034,
-0.14075659215450287,
0.14003729820251465,
-1.1402339935302734,
-0.04270530864596367,
-0.03956272080540657,
-0.5272977352142334,
-0.6192117929458618,
0.49162426590919495,
-0.18276174366474152,
0.48827657103538513,
-0.1158456951379776,
-0.3896234631538391,
0.3794870972633362,
-0.5553412437438965,
0.5636642575263977,
0.727009654045105,
0.022456353530287743,
0.7728543281555176,
-0.08740854263305664,
0.22985075414180756,
0.08852595835924149,
-0.024084756150841713,
-0.5631382465362549,
-0.633630096912384,
-0.5519612431526184,
-0.4712536633014679,
0.033258311450481415,
0.19452041387557983,
-0.5417947769165039,
0.7865130305290222,
-0.27085864543914795,
-0.3474879562854767,
-0.11713840067386627,
-0.07952869683504105,
-0.06085357069969177,
0.38568514585494995,
0.4832085072994232,
-0.48953667283058167,
-0.39108574390411377,
-0.7558841109275818,
-0.15141190588474274,
0.4029243588447571,
-0.23224149644374847,
-0.03730187937617302,
0.41636911034584045,
0.034534115344285965,
0.6118992567062378,
-0.44055870175361633,
-0.013919329270720482,
0.01056862622499466,
-0.09165503829717636,
0.508806586265564,
0.6757959723472595,
0.26631754636764526,
-0.5433872938156128,
-0.1331673264503479,
-0.5053304433822632,
-0.4564270079135895,
0.3923094570636749,
-0.05263599753379822,
-0.19969148933887482,
-0.02034616842865944,
0.42633166909217834,
-1.0292023420333862,
0.6931211352348328,
0.31043827533721924,
-0.5849037170410156,
0.2680703103542328,
-0.4108508229255676,
-0.08358949422836304,
-1.206978440284729,
-0.06233998015522957,
0.3436436355113983,
-0.3410196006298065,
-0.9730199575424194,
0.36443597078323364,
0.26425427198410034,
-0.16000647842884064,
-0.3350033164024353,
0.12347563356161118,
-0.42696499824523926,
-0.6243925094604492,
-0.3648890256881714,
-0.3372667133808136,
-0.02572482079267502,
0.6650252938270569,
0.21648819744586945,
0.19417910277843475,
0.21053755283355713,
-0.7967420816421509,
-0.27564552426338196,
0.02250543422996998,
-0.5349153876304626,
0.25898629426956177,
-0.7138060927391052,
0.07094242423772812,
-0.2208234965801239,
0.886157214641571,
-0.9579756855964661,
-0.030225858092308044,
-0.04124603047966957,
0.06329016387462616,
0.6189107894897461,
-0.32909712195396423,
-0.2593008577823639,
-0.26990771293640137,
-0.4444458484649658,
0.4471697509288788,
0.6131531596183777,
-0.4198625981807709,
0.7432389855384827,
0.2600853443145752,
-0.25160345435142517,
-0.6940986514091492,
-0.2605953812599182,
-0.2192322015762329,
-0.3351114094257355,
-0.5265998244285583,
0.8236720561981201,
-0.0043727932497859,
0.12680132687091827,
-0.22357569634914398,
-0.2656962275505066,
0.3108687400817871,
0.19181039929389954,
0.6652747392654419,
0.47478142380714417,
-0.21697327494621277,
0.1880996972322464,
0.07526370882987976,
-0.12679541110992432,
-0.0173652321100235,
-0.6815638542175293,
0.6771954894065857,
-0.1180523931980133,
-0.12282752245664597,
-0.28760817646980286,
0.5273974537849426,
0.33404767513275146,
0.0538441464304924,
0.48797178268432617,
0.2499038428068161,
-0.6726330518722534,
-0.649470865726471,
-0.09389818459749222,
-0.22078704833984375,
-0.4900388717651367,
0.34998929500579834,
-0.42786818742752075,
-1.063138723373413,
0.5128325819969177,
-0.29148805141448975,
0.35637810826301575,
0.6139389872550964,
0.389472633600235,
-0.38937920331954956,
1.1080355644226074,
0.8102858662605286,
0.13760286569595337,
0.5109310746192932,
-0.4544751048088074,
0.17278234660625458,
-0.7483558654785156,
-0.15494894981384277,
-0.536350667476654,
-0.45501643419265747,
-0.8669188618659973,
-0.7009772062301636,
0.22509363293647766,
0.029080769047141075,
-0.5715445280075073,
0.24656742811203003,
-0.25170502066612244,
0.19517402350902557,
0.37038716673851013,
0.27172061800956726,
0.1616208553314209,
0.07128798216581345,
-0.16121287643909454,
0.035258106887340546,
-0.7261081337928772,
-0.30122923851013184,
0.9575400948524475,
0.7790920734405518,
0.630969762802124,
-0.18888463079929352,
0.695899486541748,
0.326055109500885,
-0.2826458811759949,
-0.7740473747253418,
0.5328121781349182,
-0.12597720324993134,
-0.24766325950622559,
-0.44083407521247864,
-0.22767634689807892,
-0.9996381998062134,
0.3732556402683258,
-0.4028475284576416,
-0.6150019764900208,
0.5992578864097595,
0.2363211214542389,
-0.8778426051139832,
0.10365612804889679,
-0.2866879105567932,
0.3641829192638397,
-0.040572986006736755,
-0.45909804105758667,
-0.20740531384944916,
-0.8284187316894531,
0.32033729553222656,
0.21484997868537903,
0.17891915142536163,
-0.25855550169944763,
-0.19788804650306702,
0.468906044960022,
-0.7822568416595459,
0.6929035782814026,
-0.16631503403186798,
-0.057281844317913055,
-0.14656545221805573,
0.003126526949927211,
0.6812703609466553,
-0.23696035146713257,
0.1152123510837555,
0.07470887899398804,
-0.2711097002029419,
-0.6951402425765991,
-0.4297102391719818,
0.7801214456558228,
-0.5835844874382019,
-0.2695510685443878,
-0.2905699610710144,
-0.519295334815979,
-0.2915063798427582,
0.017433151602745056,
0.014889752492308617,
0.47631680965423584,
0.13331948220729828,
0.1487800031900406,
0.7598527669906616,
0.0033077867701649666,
0.4914400577545166,
0.36894991993904114,
-0.25806188583374023,
0.1584123969078064,
0.43349990248680115,
0.16749322414398193,
0.13485087454319,
0.3118880093097687,
0.15442416071891785,
-0.17977558076381683,
-0.6268310546875,
-0.3025026023387909,
-0.066129170358181,
-0.6568750143051147,
0.15793976187705994,
-0.5115303993225098,
-0.30308181047439575,
-0.12958481907844543,
-0.1455899477005005,
-0.49617233872413635,
-0.922585129737854,
0.07142394036054611,
-0.5022871494293213,
0.2601757347583771,
0.7831349968910217,
0.11086193472146988,
0.05706694722175598,
-0.6597087979316711,
0.3134934604167938,
0.1404363065958023,
0.32045334577560425,
-0.06417005509138107,
-0.6201260685920715,
-0.441851943731308,
-0.24639035761356354,
-0.27332210540771484,
-0.5108802318572998,
0.5060770511627197,
0.5031859278678894,
0.44405001401901245,
0.45753857493400574,
-0.17731553316116333,
0.8509613871574402,
-0.8810311555862427,
0.9924389719963074,
0.006520660128444433,
-0.5539080500602722,
0.4582247734069824,
-0.3200310468673706,
0.32065829634666443,
0.07585038244724274,
0.7803099751472473,
-0.05231089890003204,
-0.3551427125930786,
-0.5587621927261353,
-1.353613257408142,
0.2714883089065552,
-0.13432089984416962,
-0.050197530537843704,
0.15277130901813507,
0.4165021479129791,
0.32529500126838684,
0.0005874123889952898,
-0.4864535331726074,
-0.37158501148223877,
0.027385033667087555,
0.06365500390529633,
-0.1706925481557846,
-0.2539876103401184,
-0.11452780663967133,
-0.17399375140666962,
0.5151827931404114,
-0.0973411425948143,
0.36289864778518677,
0.10066237300634384,
0.020174114033579826,
-0.41557735204696655,
0.20126031339168549,
0.6296938061714172,
0.4855186641216278,
-0.3043789267539978,
0.0564754344522953,
-0.14928320050239563,
-0.396552711725235,
-0.01513615157455206,
0.4296422004699707,
-0.20865193009376526,
-0.21460215747356415,
0.08901401609182358,
0.8415018320083618,
0.6485477089881897,
-0.12021678686141968,
0.06122080981731415,
0.29632294178009033,
-0.07728902995586395,
-0.5022470951080322,
0.0069666216149926186,
0.08364678174257278,
0.4277820289134979,
0.7238205671310425,
0.2615066468715668,
0.420754998922348,
-0.6448851227760315,
0.34640926122665405,
0.15793290734291077,
-0.1822238266468048,
-0.3122749924659729,
0.772396981716156,
0.24471481144428253,
-0.18501214683055878,
0.5217678546905518,
0.29025590419769287,
-0.3365171551704407,
0.6122428178787231,
0.37163060903549194,
0.5862790942192078,
-0.35726433992385864,
-0.20924299955368042,
0.3353225886821747,
0.12111257016658783,
-0.22847212851047516,
0.6000527739524841,
-0.2655453085899353,
-0.5765769481658936,
-0.8804515600204468,
-0.6451264023780823,
-0.1599602848291397,
0.03796778991818428,
-0.7068235278129578,
0.12880097329616547,
-0.6572365760803223,
-0.19557853043079376,
0.2909785211086273,
0.1596047282218933,
-0.9366087913513184,
0.15641586482524872,
0.3986772894859314,
1.0939702987670898,
-0.8599793910980225,
0.966191828250885,
0.305880069732666,
-0.0786997452378273,
-0.953241765499115,
-0.4043300747871399,
-0.0062578413635492325,
-0.8958864212036133,
0.6221292614936829,
0.36905789375305176,
-0.051032837480306625,
-0.1411833018064499,
-0.5898715853691101,
-1.0574795007705688,
1.2186694145202637,
-0.18807056546211243,
-0.7213481664657593,
-0.08683263510465622,
0.06640750169754028,
0.6201255321502686,
-0.6126891374588013,
0.11106574535369873,
0.5510343909263611,
0.10163915902376175,
0.11105292290449142,
-0.4501515328884125,
0.24449372291564941,
-0.3909733295440674,
0.26869818568229675,
0.6593596339225769,
-0.36874768137931824,
0.7613080143928528,
-0.35519444942474365,
-0.21228142082691193,
0.24958547949790955,
0.8579068183898926,
0.5310863852500916,
0.33353736996650696,
0.4931831657886505,
0.8553003072738647,
0.5769088864326477,
-0.0037327774334698915,
1.0995672941207886,
-0.2990451455116272,
0.05898096784949303,
1.2778503894805908,
-0.5644703507423401,
1.3396077156066895,
0.565098762512207,
-0.391671359539032,
0.7592880129814148,
0.8496987223625183,
0.13140450417995453,
0.33298003673553467,
0.1791307032108307,
0.00030786023125983775,
-0.24068672955036163,
0.2215166687965393,
-0.4090730845928192,
0.16960081458091736,
0.8889548778533936,
-0.465099573135376,
0.11667957156896591,
-0.329926073551178,
-0.23877708613872528,
-0.1558002233505249,
-0.5942128896713257,
0.44592222571372986,
0.4662168025970459,
-0.5397788286209106,
0.07247712463140488,
-0.06969340145587921,
0.5552383065223694,
-0.680580198764801,
-0.3018619418144226,
-0.1672191172838211,
-0.07623254507780075,
-0.5210786461830139,
-0.5739896297454834,
-0.13475801050662994,
-0.3454343378543854,
-0.08894198387861252,
-0.12439316511154175,
0.7197951674461365,
-0.6070725321769714,
-0.34897035360336304,
0.16607236862182617,
0.21014294028282166,
0.13629715144634247,
0.307887464761734,
-0.3735821545124054,
-0.29224100708961487,
-0.6389409303665161,
-0.6508842706680298,
0.440133661031723,
-0.04267280176281929,
-0.11745484173297882,
0.6323592662811279,
0.9515188336372375,
0.1402769386768341,
0.29943981766700745,
0.04702082648873329,
0.7166155576705933,
-0.7883089184761047,
-0.9470410943031311,
-0.5553152561187744,
0.8907649517059326,
-0.2173943966627121,
-0.055317576974630356,
0.7777170538902283,
0.45375844836235046,
0.6987069845199585,
0.03474625200033188,
0.45998504757881165,
0.20790089666843414,
0.5176992416381836,
-0.6490643620491028,
0.14067505300045013,
-0.4361390173435211,
0.5956385135650635,
0.0011539739789441228,
-1.1310573816299438,
-0.008327428251504898,
0.22454607486724854,
-0.1815727949142456,
0.17761699855327606,
0.6513710618019104,
0.5200748443603516,
0.07408025115728378,
0.0842459499835968,
0.4348193407058716,
0.3250073790550232,
0.2022765725851059,
0.6238189935684204,
1.0546789169311523,
-0.45846864581108093,
-0.03586745634675026,
-0.24566148221492767,
-0.22215448319911957,
-0.3839833736419678,
-1.1513783931732178,
-0.3933354616165161,
-0.4611082077026367,
-0.08058624714612961,
-0.3482886254787445,
-0.050187453627586365,
1.2393642663955688,
0.8705049157142639,
-0.6677302122116089,
-0.17001520097255707,
0.0354011245071888,
-0.11264573782682419,
-0.43906620144844055,
-0.19840234518051147,
0.4177088141441345,
-0.15760168433189392,
-0.5966457724571228,
0.881125807762146,
0.6712208390235901,
-0.09717050194740295,
-0.21951179206371307,
0.00013941366341896355,
-0.04341012239456177,
0.2756798267364502,
0.8137416839599609,
0.6394108533859253,
-0.5335608124732971,
-0.36743995547294617,
-0.1732228696346283,
-0.04243152216076851,
0.07129925489425659,
1.0566798448562622,
-0.7413567304611206,
0.3644702136516571,
0.43511685729026794,
0.4921158254146576,
0.84457927942276,
-0.017184048891067505,
0.927980899810791,
-0.6790140867233276,
0.24048908054828644,
0.15359270572662354,
0.8096066117286682,
0.03069145791232586,
-0.6663654446601868,
0.504033625125885,
0.019901689141988754,
-0.8321197032928467,
-0.6690253019332886,
0.3390887677669525,
-1.186313509941101,
-0.31750041246414185,
0.8516839146614075,
-0.16849474608898163,
0.0862860381603241,
-0.14384934306144714,
0.32913461327552795,
0.01948312297463417,
-0.43927091360092163,
0.7213201522827148,
0.23704016208648682,
-0.4851881265640259,
0.11868592351675034,
-0.6220231652259827,
0.5944593548774719,
0.39153188467025757,
-0.5689895749092102,
-0.5379270911216736,
0.6280874013900757,
0.16576164960861206,
-0.03492842614650726,
0.5037820339202881,
-0.026652688160538673,
0.3218452036380768,
0.09383721649646759,
-0.16546906530857086,
-0.13651542365550995,
-0.5927444100379944,
-0.7337859272956848,
0.41204580664634705,
-0.027848701924085617,
-0.056680191308259964
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17431v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17431v1
|
Robust and Scalable Model Editing for Large Language Models
| 2024-03-26T06:57:23 | 2024-03-26T06:57:23 |
Yingfa Chen, Zhengyan Zhang, Xu Han, Chaojun Xiao, Zhiyuan Liu, Chen Chen, Kuai Li, Tao Yang, Maosong Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) can make predictions using parametric
knowledge--knowledge encoded in the model weights--or contextual
knowledge--knowledge presented in the context. In many scenarios, a desirable
behavior is that LLMs give precedence to contextual knowledge when it conflicts
with the parametric knowledge, and fall back to using their parametric
knowledge when the context is irrelevant. This enables updating and correcting
the model's knowledge by in-context editing instead of retraining. Previous
works have shown that LLMs are inclined to ignore contextual knowledge and fail
to reliably fall back to parametric knowledge when presented with irrelevant
context. In this work, we discover that, with proper prompting methods,
instruction-finetuned LLMs can be highly controllable by contextual knowledge
and robust to irrelevant context. Utilizing this feature, we propose EREN (Edit
models by REading Notes) to improve the scalability and robustness of LLM
editing. To better evaluate the robustness of model editors, we collect a new
dataset, that contains irrelevant questions that are more challenging than the
ones in existing datasets. Empirical results show that our method outperforms
current state-of-the-art methods by a large margin. Unlike existing techniques,
it can integrate knowledge from multiple edits, and correctly respond to
syntactically similar but semantically unrelated inputs (and vice versa). The
source code can be found at https://github.com/thunlp/EREN.
|
[
-0.20835605263710022,
-1.1969984769821167,
0.7433016300201416,
0.10546068102121353,
0.0678466260433197,
-0.4801008403301239,
-0.5846481919288635,
-0.17502634227275848,
-0.039508141577243805,
0.5866081118583679,
-0.3348678946495056,
-0.6774646043777466,
-0.48606330156326294,
0.00861526932567358,
-0.41164925694465637,
0.9162598848342896,
-0.1998175084590912,
0.010764669626951218,
-0.313814252614975,
-0.37940824031829834,
-0.44822046160697937,
-0.2731591463088989,
-0.7036660313606262,
-0.15918537974357605,
0.5846320986747742,
0.44834598898887634,
0.6403698921203613,
0.9786266684532166,
0.22600983083248138,
0.2954230010509491,
-0.6298788189888,
0.2669806182384491,
-0.39129164814949036,
0.405315101146698,
-0.3085935711860657,
-0.39194121956825256,
-0.8569789528846741,
-0.4650765657424927,
0.7966806292533875,
0.6782974600791931,
-0.15539368987083435,
0.17531873285770416,
0.33043041825294495,
0.5367196798324585,
-0.5090044140815735,
-0.013274691998958588,
-0.650307834148407,
-0.24065253138542175,
-0.06120452657341957,
-0.06150215491652489,
-0.542161226272583,
0.025961754843592644,
0.0531347393989563,
-0.6710930466651917,
0.08808039873838425,
0.024381930008530617,
0.6980656385421753,
0.45468762516975403,
-0.1826966404914856,
-0.18922537565231323,
-0.5280545949935913,
0.5440671443939209,
-0.935175359249115,
0.43556180596351624,
0.5567970871925354,
0.11243987083435059,
-0.2166391909122467,
-0.6127081513404846,
-0.4664599597454071,
-0.15494251251220703,
0.07813525199890137,
-0.03887142241001129,
-0.010701654478907585,
0.12879671156406403,
0.4755462408065796,
-0.06716567277908325,
-0.23061956465244293,
0.3905394375324249,
-0.08951979875564575,
-0.09455778449773788,
0.09257365763187408,
0.23411451280117035,
0.48973211646080017,
-0.29317691922187805,
0.10773167759180069,
0.031461868435144424,
-0.9114183187484741,
0.055245958268642426,
0.2901645302772522,
0.37567833065986633,
-0.06902150809764862,
0.7534130215644836,
-0.10748313367366791,
1.2385962009429932,
0.17019174993038177,
-0.03802650794386864,
-0.16695693135261536,
-0.12986035645008087,
-0.3998737037181854,
-0.20540586113929749,
0.5708991289138794,
0.43133270740509033,
0.0898880884051323,
0.13414409756660461,
-0.3954784572124481,
-0.6278573274612427,
0.05433890223503113,
-0.6180271506309509,
-0.09207359701395035,
0.32986387610435486,
-0.25606000423431396,
-0.2531852126121521,
-0.18732459843158722,
-0.8224613666534424,
-0.3319880962371826,
-0.3085162341594696,
0.4107373058795929,
-0.37827104330062866,
0.1985377073287964,
-0.07228723168373108,
0.04522250220179558,
-0.07338802516460419,
0.7253199815750122,
-1.0333300828933716,
-0.009218879044055939,
0.5925227999687195,
0.8228772878646851,
0.07622508704662323,
-0.5714272856712341,
-0.7546224594116211,
0.41454559564590454,
-0.34467580914497375,
0.5849345326423645,
-0.8395546078681946,
-0.1233956515789032,
0.02049470692873001,
0.014938034117221832,
-0.01059313677251339,
-0.36917591094970703,
0.5105927586555481,
-0.74811851978302,
0.1818244457244873,
-0.2879403531551361,
-0.8380874991416931,
-0.07918978482484818,
0.4499377906322479,
-0.6380540728569031,
0.9013186097145081,
-0.021520165726542473,
-0.7914525270462036,
0.3728853762149811,
-0.5220218896865845,
-0.41075658798217773,
-0.37287694215774536,
0.12472774088382721,
-0.3049308657646179,
-0.028395839035511017,
0.7235053777694702,
0.6308335065841675,
-0.025090781971812248,
0.42115265130996704,
-0.4896756708621979,
-0.007275429088622332,
0.10386676341295242,
-0.4675244688987732,
0.5792006850242615,
-0.0020307637751102448,
0.0004520622896961868,
0.4085123538970947,
-0.9158332943916321,
-0.05404309555888176,
-0.10633579641580582,
-0.6631641983985901,
-0.501308023929596,
-0.021433452144265175,
-0.04103197902441025,
0.0687602311372757,
0.15168330073356628,
-0.2896038889884949,
0.20088046789169312,
-0.3603476583957672,
0.6128811836242676,
0.9835490584373474,
0.19131098687648773,
0.6140053868293762,
-0.42570340633392334,
0.5097147226333618,
-0.10284309089183807,
-0.03989000618457794,
-0.4910363256931305,
-0.22017192840576172,
-0.9803977012634277,
-0.2540335953235626,
0.43005549907684326,
0.5908061861991882,
-0.5987551212310791,
0.3496873676776886,
-0.2541600465774536,
-0.22910960018634796,
-0.21975840628147125,
0.4920339584350586,
0.15665198862552643,
0.8523540496826172,
0.30578863620758057,
0.48193731904029846,
-0.45430704951286316,
-0.6508516669273376,
-0.5386073589324951,
-0.006029090844094753,
-0.2300366312265396,
0.31522780656814575,
0.47686663269996643,
-0.20729799568653107,
0.771316647529602,
-0.33592820167541504,
-0.04472189396619797,
-0.23171885311603546,
-0.14954663813114166,
0.07864776998758316,
0.6923824548721313,
0.20988352596759796,
-0.46042752265930176,
-0.4678837060928345,
0.08149213343858719,
-0.7258488535881042,
-0.3362157344818115,
-0.3817920386791229,
-0.23524682223796844,
0.1473095417022705,
0.8948866128921509,
-0.4422559142112732,
0.1285616159439087,
0.3173479437828064,
-0.14550524950027466,
0.2880570888519287,
-0.46952757239341736,
0.05524309352040291,
-1.3494387865066528,
0.15601854026317596,
-0.10616873949766159,
-0.5009363889694214,
-0.6639406085014343,
0.15359582006931305,
0.40264230966567993,
-0.08738265186548233,
-0.4588052034378052,
0.7559962272644043,
-0.47659391164779663,
0.31270870566368103,
0.012536285445094109,
0.2789837121963501,
0.04326391965150833,
0.4603143334388733,
-0.05314076319336891,
0.5288774967193604,
0.5993993878364563,
-0.6249393820762634,
0.1897943764925003,
0.35949355363845825,
-0.33965426683425903,
0.5389938354492188,
-0.8271580934524536,
0.25297173857688904,
-0.21460452675819397,
0.13707272708415985,
-0.652927815914154,
-0.6072281002998352,
0.13139528036117554,
-0.217563197016716,
0.5580827593803406,
-0.20859326422214508,
-0.4042724072933197,
-0.0034969791304320097,
-0.2602176368236542,
0.021926524117588997,
0.13304586708545685,
-0.6673940420150757,
0.6673785448074341,
0.24324867129325867,
-0.5442715287208557,
-0.6489675641059875,
-0.8417071104049683,
0.13762113451957703,
-0.3114776313304901,
-0.4930771291255951,
-0.06388068199157715,
-0.04936780035495758,
-0.2844075858592987,
0.03574176877737045,
-0.09019950032234192,
-0.3111226260662079,
-0.06039158254861832,
0.0655531957745552,
0.4493899643421173,
-0.09288372099399567,
0.3639979958534241,
0.5739898085594177,
-0.011725648306310177,
-0.15663930773735046,
-0.27124136686325073,
0.07008305937051773,
0.0018327576108276844,
-0.5361305475234985,
-0.3837822377681732,
0.18546263873577118,
0.9368063807487488,
-0.144711434841156,
0.7539819478988647,
0.27340012788772583,
-0.5658647418022156,
-0.4260019063949585,
-0.5401791334152222,
-0.07293398678302765,
-0.4177355170249939,
0.6441881060600281,
-0.40573787689208984,
-1.2458537817001343,
0.7599746584892273,
0.05316896736621857,
0.3688447177410126,
0.2676696479320526,
0.603507936000824,
0.05643365532159805,
0.9669115543365479,
0.6472545266151428,
-0.01975465565919876,
0.5557852387428284,
0.11582870036363602,
-0.01583637110888958,
-1.030744194984436,
0.021429676562547684,
-0.4988737404346466,
-0.2661944031715393,
-0.22937214374542236,
-0.4799613356590271,
0.30144667625427246,
0.24784952402114868,
-0.46042436361312866,
0.1517833024263382,
-0.25936537981033325,
0.797127366065979,
0.3660256266593933,
0.23790259659290314,
0.2994178533554077,
-0.12438604980707169,
-0.17109188437461853,
-0.09206215292215347,
-1.0820510387420654,
-0.6846398711204529,
1.177268147468567,
0.4285229742527008,
1.070061206817627,
0.10167080163955688,
0.4672929644584656,
0.11042987555265427,
0.2915182113647461,
-0.643744707107544,
0.34391286969184875,
0.09915994107723236,
-0.5921210646629333,
-0.6766610741615295,
-0.37845468521118164,
-0.4441007673740387,
0.1900044083595276,
-0.05598846450448036,
-0.8008869886398315,
0.23650504648685455,
0.5109966993331909,
-0.7180983424186707,
0.6079663634300232,
-0.6379686594009399,
0.8974424004554749,
-0.006550995633006096,
-0.5708358287811279,
0.07612930238246918,
-0.5873199105262756,
0.2383696585893631,
-0.2612397372722626,
0.30946022272109985,
0.2800191342830658,
-0.35701629519462585,
0.7298104763031006,
-0.5982885956764221,
0.9813358187675476,
0.0836338922381401,
-0.20488673448562622,
0.2099398672580719,
0.33193302154541016,
0.8037225604057312,
0.40006041526794434,
-0.16869136691093445,
-0.25025808811187744,
-0.014175291173160076,
-0.2805372476577759,
-0.7939808368682861,
0.9627819061279297,
-0.4089856743812561,
-0.7092962861061096,
0.0453982949256897,
-0.8262941241264343,
-0.27844667434692383,
0.4102479815483093,
0.2439119815826416,
0.7200142741203308,
-0.12349431961774826,
0.2069309502840042,
0.7929114103317261,
-0.3789342939853668,
0.36596959829330444,
0.4878637492656708,
-0.3932032585144043,
-0.3987445533275604,
0.7256949543952942,
0.14103402197360992,
0.4767057001590729,
0.550088107585907,
0.22824981808662415,
-0.15806548297405243,
-0.47786709666252136,
-0.7091274261474609,
0.011440040543675423,
-0.9814396500587463,
-0.05880264937877655,
-0.7769946455955505,
0.07956420630216599,
-0.3636241853237152,
-0.4857751727104187,
-0.3108041286468506,
-0.520821213722229,
-0.37172603607177734,
-0.11201000213623047,
0.2727830708026886,
0.8784757852554321,
-0.11619414389133453,
0.1871589869260788,
-0.8509126305580139,
0.11006295680999756,
0.4967372715473175,
0.4011783301830292,
0.13580848276615143,
-0.8990856409072876,
-0.22752662003040314,
0.00047691393410786986,
0.020190298557281494,
-0.9012385010719299,
0.3087862432003021,
0.19193558394908905,
0.4262188971042633,
0.47321438789367676,
-0.007699991576373577,
0.7473122477531433,
-0.5212212204933167,
0.5916675329208374,
-0.29616957902908325,
-1.1220355033874512,
0.6502966284751892,
-0.6774717569351196,
0.5934933423995972,
0.5642291307449341,
0.14533865451812744,
-0.596254825592041,
-0.6149662733078003,
-0.2636983394622803,
-0.6980475783348083,
0.8571311831474304,
-0.2640272080898285,
0.2581961452960968,
0.07320751249790192,
0.48307299613952637,
0.05718662962317467,
0.1420062929391861,
-0.6745468378067017,
0.006832379847764969,
0.0024160025641322136,
-0.19800151884555817,
0.07075465470552444,
-0.54137122631073,
-0.06835418939590454,
-0.44111278653144836,
0.7497844099998474,
-0.0141676664352417,
-0.15297339856624603,
0.29822874069213867,
-0.2917686402797699,
-0.2739257216453552,
0.5802775025367737,
0.8000220656394958,
0.9010263681411743,
-0.2021304816007614,
0.1731216311454773,
0.680112361907959,
-0.2465762197971344,
-0.011113430373370647,
-0.1794014573097229,
-0.5159408450126648,
-0.15014950931072235,
0.6320416331291199,
0.8791151642799377,
0.43703705072402954,
-0.7292007207870483,
0.178410604596138,
0.07574181258678436,
-0.14205266535282135,
0.0760713443160057,
-0.0844728946685791,
0.270261287689209,
0.10683178901672363,
-0.25947678089141846,
0.22303615510463715,
-0.26917892694473267,
-0.11204849928617477,
0.0483756884932518,
-0.0017576069803908467,
-0.41367125511169434,
-0.19097675383090973,
0.8194031119346619,
0.1589042842388153,
-0.3064891993999481,
0.49839404225349426,
0.09255044907331467,
-0.5502521395683289,
0.34229764342308044,
0.5235676169395447,
0.6085218191146851,
-0.07229437679052353,
-0.040410030633211136,
0.4044080674648285,
0.4331281781196594,
-0.1484142243862152,
-0.039914920926094055,
-0.0039122821763157845,
-0.6618939638137817,
-0.5543103814125061,
-0.3830123245716095,
-0.5168220400810242,
0.43986478447914124,
-0.6501965522766113,
0.2886466979980469,
-0.7304331064224243,
0.11994300782680511,
-0.07398898899555206,
-0.671196460723877,
-0.41147834062576294,
-0.057734839618206024,
-0.30033355951309204,
1.0759927034378052,
-0.6968466639518738,
0.7854415774345398,
1.0400738716125488,
-0.26076388359069824,
-0.8917500972747803,
0.044417764991521835,
0.18717840313911438,
-0.42208701372146606,
0.4695377051830292,
-0.004957730416208506,
0.20187635719776154,
0.011341854929924011,
-0.5949454307556152,
-0.6392036080360413,
0.732215404510498,
0.5578166842460632,
-0.8182805776596069,
-0.02925778366625309,
-0.258579283952713,
0.3578214943408966,
-0.1608114093542099,
0.09323243796825409,
0.3932149112224579,
0.6363093256950378,
-0.02359268069267273,
-0.8132988214492798,
0.03907226771116257,
-0.1703759729862213,
-0.02307778224349022,
0.11862118542194366,
-0.3879862129688263,
0.8400273323059082,
-0.25260084867477417,
0.08027183264493942,
0.062017105519771576,
0.5789252519607544,
-0.010653885081410408,
0.06845398247241974,
0.35251384973526,
0.6787056922912598,
0.8730109930038452,
0.1966179758310318,
0.9126940369606018,
-0.4332160949707031,
0.3014538586139679,
1.5499892234802246,
-0.24605266749858856,
0.9327728748321533,
0.5529121160507202,
-0.00843508169054985,
0.15490105748176575,
0.5905373692512512,
0.27508872747421265,
0.03651285171508789,
-0.09436486661434174,
-0.311702162027359,
-0.5074155926704407,
0.22817060351371765,
-0.14004722237586975,
0.2672363221645355,
0.24798381328582764,
-0.2820051312446594,
-0.25845104455947876,
0.10637757182121277,
0.3319214880466461,
0.303576797246933,
-0.2989599406719208,
0.6466431021690369,
-0.03983844444155693,
-0.711213231086731,
0.509457528591156,
0.14177189767360687,
0.4962736964225769,
-0.6294777989387512,
-0.07311475276947021,
-0.11724792420864105,
0.11961641162633896,
-0.09763357788324356,
-0.7756662368774414,
0.35376033186912537,
0.3120509088039398,
-0.38544169068336487,
-0.24192534387111664,
0.6985822319984436,
-0.5954812169075012,
-0.503635048866272,
-0.06223693862557411,
0.7099987268447876,
-0.10196225345134735,
0.041668329387903214,
-0.5166900753974915,
0.09087125211954117,
0.12169608473777771,
-0.4849012494087219,
0.2754835784435272,
0.5404159426689148,
-0.07803180068731308,
0.8454006910324097,
0.63547682762146,
0.2526519000530243,
-0.015691127628087997,
0.08632703870534897,
0.9211043119430542,
-0.4999687671661377,
-0.46040359139442444,
-1.0110211372375488,
0.3936287462711334,
-0.06713063269853592,
-0.2946890592575073,
0.8806426525115967,
0.14307621121406555,
0.8149362802505493,
-0.13650000095367432,
0.7345431447029114,
-0.047879040241241455,
0.5918436646461487,
-0.6906276345252991,
1.018504023551941,
-0.5073464512825012,
0.4652169644832611,
-0.33584722876548767,
-0.8876568675041199,
-0.5829347372055054,
0.5561167001724243,
-0.44231685996055603,
0.08530111610889435,
0.5928504467010498,
1.0416513681411743,
-0.12296587973833084,
-0.16127483546733856,
0.4138246476650238,
0.4141014814376831,
0.23714330792427063,
0.4080958962440491,
0.7295971512794495,
-0.02364785224199295,
0.27431049942970276,
-0.1462809145450592,
-0.17955048382282257,
0.007604773156344891,
-0.9754058718681335,
-1.1490873098373413,
-0.4193900525569916,
-0.15599404275417328,
-0.10527147352695465,
0.15091443061828613,
0.9382086992263794,
0.593946635723114,
-0.9043745398521423,
0.05789110064506531,
-0.19124066829681396,
0.45099472999572754,
-0.030643247067928314,
-0.16775479912757874,
0.5355520248413086,
-0.3624258041381836,
-0.8858025670051575,
0.45386138558387756,
0.3570678234100342,
0.0993357002735138,
-0.058226436376571655,
-0.12868548929691315,
-0.262882798910141,
0.05422743409872055,
0.46996060013771057,
0.3197939693927765,
-0.6771161556243896,
-0.3508354127407074,
-0.06211058050394058,
-0.04071876406669617,
-0.21550028026103973,
0.6011476516723633,
-0.3537498414516449,
0.7805267572402954,
0.7603614926338196,
0.853570818901062,
-0.0794311985373497,
-0.0007961682276800275,
0.6280314326286316,
-0.5441264510154724,
0.14934541285037994,
0.004066470079123974,
0.5302667021751404,
0.3936994671821594,
-0.34234070777893066,
0.09580281376838684,
-0.04223742336034775,
-0.7814666628837585,
-0.8965817093849182,
-0.03355107083916664,
-0.775454044342041,
-0.18586477637290955,
1.1295866966247559,
-0.41527965664863586,
-0.36413124203681946,
0.030757375061511993,
-0.3811657130718231,
0.1937285214662552,
-0.3462078869342804,
0.4550495445728302,
0.9921608567237854,
0.1255008727312088,
-0.24322609603405,
-0.7963740825653076,
0.21297435462474823,
0.6738570928573608,
-0.7130787372589111,
0.3800067901611328,
0.8070228695869446,
0.34407368302345276,
-0.31979838013648987,
0.3165479600429535,
0.014800368808209896,
0.304485559463501,
-0.08981722593307495,
-0.09105780720710754,
-0.5396875739097595,
-0.4651782512664795,
-0.704245388507843,
0.11026642471551895,
0.3576168715953827,
0.18981805443763733
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17428v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17428v1
|
Aligning Large Language Models for Enhancing Psychiatric Interviews through Symptom Delineation and Summarization
| 2024-03-26T06:50:04 | 2024-03-26T06:50:04 |
Jae-hee So, Joonhwan Chang, Eunji Kim, Junho Na, JiYeon Choi, Jy-yong Sohn, Byung-Hoon Kim, Sang Hui Chu
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have accelerated their
usage in various domains. Given the fact that psychiatric interviews are
goal-oriented and structured dialogues between the professional interviewer and
the interviewee, it is one of the most underexplored areas where LLMs can
contribute substantial value. Here, we explore the use of LLMs for enhancing
psychiatric interviews, by analyzing counseling data from North Korean
defectors with traumatic events and mental health issues. Specifically, we
investigate whether LLMs can (1) delineate the part of the conversation that
suggests psychiatric symptoms and name the symptoms, and (2) summarize
stressors and symptoms, based on the interview dialogue transcript. Here, the
transcript data was labeled by mental health experts for training and
evaluation of LLMs. Our experimental results show that appropriately prompted
LLMs can achieve high performance on both the symptom delineation task and the
summarization task. This research contributes to the nascent field of applying
LLMs to psychiatric interview and demonstrates their potential effectiveness in
aiding mental health practitioners.
|
[
-0.2613045871257782,
-0.4102727472782135,
1.2289912700653076,
0.3288056552410126,
-0.1405794769525528,
0.14922232925891876,
-0.3374200165271759,
-0.435558557510376,
0.5086354613304138,
0.50826495885849,
-0.631576657295227,
-0.7321088910102844,
-0.6122179627418518,
0.3088744580745697,
-0.27651989459991455,
1.176997184753418,
-0.08224373310804367,
0.1818731278181076,
0.027547668665647507,
0.2899706959724426,
-0.5011563897132874,
-0.6148782968521118,
-0.8090068101882935,
-0.22564764320850372,
0.3473629951477051,
0.13318940997123718,
0.7127458453178406,
0.37328749895095825,
0.5752617716789246,
0.2573518753051758,
-0.2447836846113205,
0.15141548216342926,
-0.5800804495811462,
0.4669249355792999,
-0.2155112773180008,
-0.579413652420044,
-0.702227771282196,
0.009966176003217697,
0.5124792456626892,
0.9128352999687195,
-0.2685791850090027,
0.03228091821074486,
-0.1052379310131073,
0.07582835853099823,
-0.3726801872253418,
0.10293693840503693,
-0.46044570207595825,
0.2570219039916992,
0.07009560614824295,
-0.057180006057024,
-0.10693737864494324,
-0.4386506676673889,
-0.01032364834100008,
-0.3983179032802582,
0.20021173357963562,
-0.4129810631275177,
0.7257258296012878,
0.3569537103176117,
-0.49913957715034485,
0.05403022840619087,
-0.91274493932724,
0.6498004198074341,
-1.1480329036712646,
0.20985746383666992,
0.48682767152786255,
0.08952290564775467,
-0.3461783826351166,
-0.36694464087486267,
-0.3361590802669525,
-0.06322038173675537,
-0.2631407678127289,
0.1438998132944107,
-0.04942568391561508,
0.37606117129325867,
0.5062217116355896,
0.67235267162323,
-0.4836301803588867,
0.4870113730430603,
-0.47936955094337463,
-0.13598956167697906,
0.7399556636810303,
0.853453516960144,
0.5406197309494019,
-0.22933824360370636,
-0.019177213311195374,
0.31827589869499207,
-0.3958057463169098,
-0.3143194019794464,
-0.025264864787459373,
0.18087154626846313,
-0.3523465394973755,
0.5631592273712158,
-0.16219009459018707,
0.6376497149467468,
-0.0015266374684870243,
-0.6649211645126343,
-0.022976843640208244,
-0.09554357826709747,
-0.2561156749725342,
0.13055886328220367,
0.7496739625930786,
0.9502572417259216,
0.05134141445159912,
-0.15386466681957245,
-0.1740032583475113,
0.038493212312459946,
0.3905346095561981,
-0.7323398590087891,
-0.4277481436729431,
0.4235277771949768,
-0.5983301997184753,
-0.028993405401706696,
-0.32978543639183044,
-1.1176695823669434,
-1.0608316659927368,
-0.4594891369342804,
0.005825255997478962,
-0.17517204582691193,
-0.6126497983932495,
0.2299967110157013,
-0.11827400326728821,
0.1008206307888031,
0.33202415704727173,
-0.6222906708717346,
0.20293721556663513,
0.851679265499115,
0.8581476807594299,
-0.29854297637939453,
0.07765134423971176,
-0.2020527869462967,
0.059486210346221924,
-0.600384533405304,
0.557015061378479,
-0.4196612238883972,
-0.5712465643882751,
0.07561001181602478,
0.09876862913370132,
-0.08775129914283752,
-0.7487863898277283,
0.5131726861000061,
0.0076983324252069,
0.1458536833524704,
-0.15059906244277954,
-0.4775594174861908,
0.11470168828964233,
0.3796827495098114,
-0.5181847810745239,
0.7356465458869934,
0.35598084330558777,
-0.6078315377235413,
0.16013333201408386,
-0.29043251276016235,
-0.22515489161014557,
0.0022101781796664,
-0.45321086049079895,
-0.015352930873632431,
0.36784353852272034,
0.23699550330638885,
0.7208564281463623,
-0.3058951199054718,
0.28452956676483154,
-0.20141921937465668,
-0.3170616924762726,
0.4869099259376526,
-0.014454896561801434,
0.36015552282333374,
-0.14803683757781982,
0.11937765777111053,
-0.05175088718533516,
-0.6762259006500244,
-0.10797000676393509,
0.038751132786273956,
-0.3882746994495392,
-0.5033004283905029,
-0.16458407044410706,
-0.2660515308380127,
0.41382554173469543,
-0.05180599167943001,
-0.554760217666626,
0.10448712855577469,
-0.7711004614830017,
-0.0043173739686608315,
0.4464397728443146,
0.45181164145469666,
0.027190104126930237,
-0.3652353584766388,
0.946018397808075,
0.12680107355117798,
-0.05646418780088425,
-0.31613874435424805,
-0.2712187170982361,
-0.36714282631874084,
-0.6302279233932495,
-0.328347772359848,
0.6993433237075806,
-0.37298130989074707,
0.22118692100048065,
-0.2543226480484009,
-0.48882684111595154,
-0.45167726278305054,
-0.12697972357273102,
0.23676379024982452,
0.568322479724884,
0.16110743582248688,
0.0035363943316042423,
-0.9970951676368713,
-0.7576456665992737,
-0.4142938256263733,
-0.025874009355902672,
-0.4033910036087036,
0.14399653673171997,
0.11761484295129776,
-0.22251205146312714,
0.6388731598854065,
-0.7180692553520203,
-0.2086956650018692,
-0.5088194608688354,
-0.07696305215358734,
0.49379077553749084,
0.1476253867149353,
0.2699686884880066,
-0.29027292132377625,
-0.3549244999885559,
-0.1454971432685852,
-0.7422457933425903,
-0.38645991683006287,
-0.16802331805229187,
0.08037900924682617,
-0.00824239943176508,
0.7664626240730286,
-0.7728707790374756,
0.17901326715946198,
0.5845621228218079,
-0.38644734025001526,
0.7889510989189148,
0.028193509206175804,
0.08794065564870834,
-1.3644967079162598,
-0.09509335458278656,
0.07009067386388779,
-0.10759302973747253,
-0.8786680698394775,
-0.3650661110877991,
-0.400392085313797,
-0.16808126866817474,
-0.15424945950508118,
0.3936501443386078,
-0.340127557516098,
0.2827247083187103,
-0.38103803992271423,
0.5018441081047058,
0.00873586442321539,
0.2476467788219452,
-0.08083143830299377,
0.2636865973472595,
0.5840301513671875,
-0.639315664768219,
0.3912919759750366,
0.24728909134864807,
-0.40076813101768494,
0.7830678820610046,
-0.2925459146499634,
-0.09968457370996475,
-0.41567763686180115,
0.24183808267116547,
-1.069219708442688,
-0.4434957504272461,
0.28920891880989075,
0.07878857105970383,
0.2926929295063019,
0.06971187144517899,
-0.1659378558397293,
-0.26496434211730957,
-0.21431989967823029,
0.4728514552116394,
0.3324524462223053,
-0.1611027717590332,
0.36442843079566956,
0.5744695067405701,
-0.6476751565933228,
-0.26414310932159424,
-0.5632308721542358,
0.2800742983818054,
-0.7611586451530457,
-0.11663500219583511,
0.45263364911079407,
0.16080671548843384,
-0.49357759952545166,
-0.2585853934288025,
-0.2848204970359802,
-0.09958446770906448,
0.04944925010204315,
0.4719434678554535,
0.553526759147644,
-0.2921055257320404,
0.24086858332157135,
-0.10432697832584381,
-0.09466724842786789,
0.45743444561958313,
0.10365854203701019,
0.556971549987793,
0.25247517228126526,
-0.1687566339969635,
-0.4569638967514038,
0.5158989429473877,
0.536746621131897,
0.009333685971796513,
0.6891286969184875,
0.36377114057540894,
-0.5338011980056763,
-0.010441026650369167,
-0.604766845703125,
-0.28895482420921326,
-0.3298308849334717,
0.7961877584457397,
-0.2215675264596939,
-0.9865830540657043,
0.5348308682441711,
-0.5640413761138916,
-0.06616640090942383,
0.2374604195356369,
0.5089240074157715,
0.022977998480200768,
1.4001727104187012,
0.5150318145751953,
-0.16674639284610748,
0.24763084948062897,
0.035609859973192215,
0.5851003527641296,
-1.130049228668213,
-0.37134596705436707,
-0.39149191975593567,
-0.3879450559616089,
-0.5583018660545349,
-0.28246009349823,
0.4861186742782593,
0.02124347724020481,
-0.1559205800294876,
-0.26110586524009705,
-0.36869123578071594,
0.43491417169570923,
-0.19601087272167206,
0.07705692946910858,
0.31356334686279297,
-0.18289220333099365,
0.1012568548321724,
-0.6716978549957275,
-0.49483489990234375,
-0.5159436464309692,
0.774332582950592,
0.5161712169647217,
1.1552882194519043,
0.05048872157931328,
0.5851573348045349,
-0.22969703376293182,
0.24689848721027374,
-0.8713839054107666,
0.6986753940582275,
-0.17020758986473083,
-0.11594394594430923,
-0.21878878772258759,
-0.3496316373348236,
-0.7968797087669373,
0.23601692914962769,
-0.0013637688243761659,
-1.2381044626235962,
0.2650519609451294,
-0.13223661482334137,
-0.6120290756225586,
0.048189926892519,
-0.2680412530899048,
0.6811543107032776,
-0.2549874782562256,
0.5363117456436157,
-0.11176390200853348,
-0.40234771370887756,
0.7628839015960693,
-0.25767478346824646,
0.09400300681591034,
-0.42959049344062805,
-0.08471427857875824,
0.867134690284729,
-0.3095565140247345,
0.9347204566001892,
-0.1407112032175064,
-0.4326004683971405,
-0.3425235450267792,
0.3288358449935913,
0.14940831065177917,
0.2431754618883133,
0.020691361278295517,
-0.008638842962682247,
0.39909741282463074,
0.1443161964416504,
-0.9423868656158447,
0.6530871391296387,
-0.6459459662437439,
-0.8851664066314697,
-0.1468227654695511,
-0.8645442724227905,
-0.5993556380271912,
0.04224459081888199,
0.07363530993461609,
0.17772100865840912,
-0.21144041419029236,
-0.30089688301086426,
0.6361868977546692,
-0.6025875210762024,
0.0004161774995736778,
0.6371155977249146,
-0.6506659984588623,
-0.3580677807331085,
0.4942907691001892,
-0.07008206844329834,
0.2652873396873474,
-0.08799359947443008,
0.21009205281734467,
-0.15548542141914368,
-0.28320983052253723,
0.20469340682029724,
0.8168494701385498,
-0.7413066029548645,
-0.20060212910175323,
-0.6831355094909668,
-0.4309747815132141,
-0.49375221133232117,
0.09962408989667892,
-0.2335098832845688,
-0.3460346758365631,
-0.11263709515333176,
-0.507239043712616,
0.2688818573951721,
0.4815519452095032,
0.0002085518790408969,
0.2504075765609741,
-0.831308901309967,
0.503709077835083,
-0.1556408703327179,
0.3280470073223114,
0.015262780711054802,
-0.4467218518257141,
-0.3948502540588379,
0.09477207064628601,
-0.13484881818294525,
-1.205618977546692,
0.530694305896759,
0.16272792220115662,
0.5388572812080383,
0.6471736431121826,
0.19120897352695465,
1.0159729719161987,
-0.20054350793361664,
0.9032073616981506,
0.09554550796747208,
-0.6756751537322998,
0.7399803400039673,
-0.21816065907478333,
0.443744033575058,
0.35961976647377014,
0.6905784606933594,
-1.0754064321517944,
-0.9920992851257324,
-0.3556134104728699,
-0.8417359590530396,
0.8575298190116882,
-0.3420116901397705,
0.18289950489997864,
-0.21151593327522278,
0.5529166460037231,
-0.14631007611751556,
-0.010438312776386738,
-0.3267606794834137,
-0.11539731919765472,
0.17032228410243988,
-0.3919110596179962,
-0.18755385279655457,
-0.6368677616119385,
-0.6962844133377075,
-0.17442436516284943,
0.5188384652137756,
0.2825474441051483,
0.29163116216659546,
0.3165052831172943,
0.24426907300949097,
-0.010039332322776318,
0.3280472159385681,
0.43868669867515564,
0.6183229684829712,
-0.038668058812618256,
0.2575865089893341,
0.24820491671562195,
-0.44137927889823914,
0.2725420296192169,
0.15040579438209534,
0.2123100608587265,
0.32509469985961914,
0.24726992845535278,
0.8584528565406799,
0.13068601489067078,
-0.9895906448364258,
0.3081291913986206,
-0.0032205369789153337,
-0.09456807374954224,
-0.12801094353199005,
0.10845252126455307,
0.1017036885023117,
0.562626302242279,
0.008377385325729847,
-0.6424400806427002,
0.14205926656723022,
-0.5198355317115784,
-0.12569773197174072,
0.3035583198070526,
-0.3003811538219452,
-0.2842528820037842,
0.3721838891506195,
-0.1510758399963379,
-0.375434011220932,
0.858261227607727,
0.10779749602079391,
-0.5433197021484375,
0.3498583137989044,
0.9186111092567444,
0.6697173118591309,
-0.6467123031616211,
0.3397449851036072,
0.2642812430858612,
0.1757047176361084,
-0.2657085657119751,
0.5841143727302551,
0.36369794607162476,
-0.6775705218315125,
-0.6315772533416748,
-0.523611307144165,
-0.3090956211090088,
0.6568653583526611,
-0.8023124933242798,
0.04237121716141701,
-0.3123936951160431,
-0.4490428566932678,
-0.26936662197113037,
-0.34758806228637695,
-0.3704827129840851,
0.2330833524465561,
0.3755732476711273,
0.6406667232513428,
-1.0397719144821167,
0.2385656237602234,
0.9488921761512756,
0.007663133554160595,
-1.0190763473510742,
0.009058765135705471,
0.26279428601264954,
-0.30046314001083374,
0.38363271951675415,
0.1406920999288559,
0.3195079565048218,
-0.30271023511886597,
-0.021113475784659386,
-0.9561812877655029,
0.9741045832633972,
0.7401365637779236,
-0.27041471004486084,
-0.17677854001522064,
0.5356910228729248,
0.7803044319152832,
-0.4206216037273407,
0.21350568532943726,
0.8436365127563477,
0.29366233944892883,
-0.058900829404592514,
-1.1060882806777954,
0.3353734016418457,
-0.2297499179840088,
0.24458716809749603,
0.2559469938278198,
-0.11719866842031479,
0.7772856950759888,
-0.09185575693845749,
-0.48612648248672485,
-0.079849474132061,
0.26031437516212463,
0.36541974544525146,
0.18497315049171448,
0.32966580986976624,
0.35832205414772034,
1.0490134954452515,
0.08769655227661133,
0.8953776359558105,
-0.43929603695869446,
0.01024348009377718,
1.4121192693710327,
-0.44258010387420654,
0.4543248116970062,
0.40640509128570557,
-0.09355514496564865,
0.4913446605205536,
0.4916720688343048,
-0.025469698011875153,
0.14835724234580994,
0.21799540519714355,
-0.4881608188152313,
-0.2766776978969574,
-0.4438876509666443,
-0.19744887948036194,
0.3027486503124237,
0.6684265732765198,
-0.5946110486984253,
-0.4402260184288025,
0.31819963455200195,
0.35004112124443054,
-0.07089535146951675,
-0.3237152099609375,
0.7686184048652649,
0.5426136255264282,
-0.492629736661911,
0.5030239820480347,
0.1134173721075058,
0.21995647251605988,
-0.4823245704174042,
0.022918401286005974,
-0.4046749472618103,
0.1294773370027542,
-0.515453040599823,
-0.7625565528869629,
0.607052743434906,
0.13877052068710327,
-0.1935088187456131,
-0.07856877893209457,
0.6821371912956238,
-0.5516972541809082,
-0.4186076521873474,
0.07026929408311844,
0.5693480372428894,
0.5934394598007202,
-0.35282769799232483,
-0.20351332426071167,
0.006141582038253546,
-0.2699849605560303,
-0.031130963936448097,
0.5209512114524841,
0.6183883547782898,
-0.14282827079296112,
0.5538901090621948,
0.2096007615327835,
0.5439938306808472,
0.010836866684257984,
0.3578309118747711,
0.6983153820037842,
-0.778499186038971,
-0.41578972339630127,
-1.1171445846557617,
0.5177236795425415,
-0.13248489797115326,
-0.13817276060581207,
0.8392632603645325,
0.4827643632888794,
0.4922920763492584,
-0.15225359797477722,
0.8187101483345032,
0.23888875544071198,
0.7481536865234375,
-0.3978514075279236,
0.454533189535141,
-0.3495238125324249,
0.2491942197084427,
-0.4001380503177643,
-0.7248237133026123,
-0.2836833894252777,
0.4989093542098999,
-0.437440425157547,
-0.1067960262298584,
0.6424684524536133,
1.0894640684127808,
0.18040594458580017,
-0.1448032408952713,
0.3726147413253784,
0.5457485914230347,
0.4123481810092926,
0.7243232131004333,
1.1321008205413818,
0.102572500705719,
0.25345709919929504,
-0.15512798726558685,
-0.13362601399421692,
0.050488200038671494,
-0.6483286023139954,
-0.8280858993530273,
-0.47510552406311035,
-0.4984343647956848,
-0.19253283739089966,
-0.17065945267677307,
0.9375364780426025,
0.3475778102874756,
-0.4222576320171356,
-0.30087709426879883,
0.4336707592010498,
-0.06271960586309433,
-0.2734878361225128,
-0.2926475703716278,
0.15935571491718292,
-0.10776574164628983,
-0.5628994703292847,
0.6094915270805359,
0.43993791937828064,
0.13671889901161194,
-0.2766059935092926,
0.13952697813510895,
0.18142296373844147,
-0.006987240631133318,
0.5509457588195801,
0.01760929264128208,
-0.889636754989624,
-0.08493597060441971,
-0.19813790917396545,
-0.15985126793384552,
0.004309233743697405,
1.096115231513977,
-0.6044408679008484,
0.3010256290435791,
0.16472284495830536,
0.5998340845108032,
0.04361063614487648,
0.2834528088569641,
0.9055987596511841,
-0.6638588309288025,
-0.10087591409683228,
0.30363693833351135,
0.1564125120639801,
0.3014746308326721,
-0.6338731646537781,
0.22174037992954254,
-0.1404791921377182,
-0.5302550196647644,
-1.1221282482147217,
0.18366698920726776,
-0.8272534012794495,
-0.17356209456920624,
1.1617658138275146,
-0.2669408619403839,
0.26900428533554077,
-0.2668208181858063,
-0.4133128821849823,
0.27476978302001953,
0.035772789269685745,
1.12723708152771,
0.7084853649139404,
-0.5407422184944153,
-0.421474426984787,
-0.6770926117897034,
0.6933267116546631,
0.38990727066993713,
-0.823879599571228,
0.0793461799621582,
0.5536705255508423,
0.2660195827484131,
-0.08733702450990677,
0.8487796187400818,
-0.17934182286262512,
0.15449008345603943,
-0.23708529770374298,
-0.1235409751534462,
0.13653743267059326,
-0.056113101541996,
-0.6263762712478638,
-0.10168792307376862,
0.0922589972615242,
0.14973928034305573
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17413v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17413v1
|
LM-Combiner: A Contextual Rewriting Model for Chinese Grammatical Error Correction
| 2024-03-26T06:12:21 | 2024-03-26T06:12:21 |
Yixuan Wang, Baoxin Wang, Yijun Liu, Dayong Wu, Wanxiang Che
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Over-correction is a critical problem in Chinese grammatical error correction
(CGEC) task. Recent work using model ensemble methods based on voting can
effectively mitigate over-correction and improve the precision of the GEC
system. However, these methods still require the output of several GEC systems
and inevitably lead to reduced error recall. In this light, we propose the
LM-Combiner, a rewriting model that can directly modify the over-correction of
GEC system outputs without a model ensemble. Specifically, we train the model
on an over-correction dataset constructed through the proposed K-fold cross
inference method, which allows it to directly generate filtered sentences by
combining the original and the over-corrected text. In the inference stage, we
directly take the original sentences and the output results of other systems as
input and then obtain the filtered sentences through LM-Combiner. Experiments
on the FCGEC dataset show that our proposed method effectively alleviates the
over-correction of the original system (+18.2 Precision) while ensuring the
error recall remains unchanged. Besides, we find that LM-Combiner still has a
good rewriting performance even with small parameters and few training data,
and thus can cost-effectively mitigate the over-correction of black-box GEC
systems (e.g., ChatGPT).
|
[
-0.14873966574668884,
-0.7633154392242432,
0.41755256056785583,
-0.2784750461578369,
-0.2339887171983719,
-0.11576933413743973,
-0.3812839686870575,
-0.3958812952041626,
0.17085528373718262,
0.6143383383750916,
-0.5020812153816223,
-0.2975478768348694,
-0.3214491903781891,
-0.05103522911667824,
-0.46997377276420593,
1.0205283164978027,
-0.22102518379688263,
0.1723611056804657,
-0.17375081777572632,
0.08447761833667755,
-0.4179757535457611,
-0.6999228596687317,
-0.6551685333251953,
-0.519314706325531,
0.7361028790473938,
0.47990599274635315,
0.6183822154998779,
0.32036930322647095,
0.1662718951702118,
0.4383115768432617,
-0.14955592155456543,
0.4671059846878052,
-0.5260478258132935,
-0.15828271210193634,
-0.20809045433998108,
-0.6463226079940796,
-0.5909985303878784,
-0.266088604927063,
0.9438050985336304,
0.6623092293739319,
-0.413002073764801,
-0.3306293189525604,
0.43902838230133057,
0.6829379200935364,
-0.8643515110015869,
-0.14952877163887024,
-0.6771891117095947,
0.06817059218883514,
0.13889645040035248,
-0.1776086837053299,
-0.5901558995246887,
-0.19425052404403687,
-0.3436230421066284,
-0.5412581562995911,
0.5253480076789856,
-0.17364798486232758,
0.6322569251060486,
0.14381521940231323,
-0.3397621512413025,
0.0905030369758606,
-0.8814262747764587,
0.7622560858726501,
-0.9693431854248047,
0.14254678785800934,
0.05999156832695007,
0.3298974633216858,
-0.44838955998420715,
-0.6369168162345886,
-0.8073256015777588,
-0.05221504718065262,
-0.30793434381484985,
0.41051003336906433,
-0.01688072830438614,
0.29899176955223083,
0.03657900169491768,
0.6015647053718567,
-0.365119993686676,
-0.03847114369273186,
-0.5628994703292847,
-0.09226280450820923,
0.7332422137260437,
0.17375952005386353,
0.47730809450149536,
0.008270395919680595,
-0.04008025303483009,
-0.05782143771648407,
-0.640457808971405,
-0.0836973786354065,
0.07114985585212708,
0.2323785275220871,
0.34134963154792786,
0.5162647366523743,
-0.1325652152299881,
0.6949151158332825,
0.2719559371471405,
-0.01852189004421234,
0.07997319102287292,
-0.4240289032459259,
-0.6840987205505371,
0.2439919263124466,
0.6311221718788147,
0.5775525569915771,
0.08939279615879059,
-0.20631970465183258,
-0.5095449090003967,
0.16602732241153717,
0.26637086272239685,
-0.4260924756526947,
-0.08640509098768234,
0.18100644648075104,
-0.2555370628833771,
-0.18130610883235931,
0.2550819516181946,
-0.5489495396614075,
0.029573868960142136,
-0.4357966184616089,
0.43057680130004883,
-0.2253892421722412,
0.14099058508872986,
0.12272116541862488,
-0.04690228030085564,
-0.017971107736229897,
0.3972873389720917,
-0.7433733344078064,
0.3756560981273651,
0.7456384897232056,
0.7229921817779541,
0.0016745589673519135,
-0.839341938495636,
-0.5357903838157654,
0.085260309278965,
-0.3260795772075653,
0.5338867902755737,
-0.006542174611240625,
-0.5344299674034119,
0.1339835524559021,
0.2939572036266327,
-0.538579523563385,
-0.4141751825809479,
0.6946318745613098,
-0.47767937183380127,
0.4330119788646698,
-0.21721398830413818,
-0.8262971043586731,
-0.16773530840873718,
0.19853824377059937,
-0.7992552518844604,
1.0136226415634155,
-0.08209098875522614,
-0.6185295581817627,
0.4329121708869934,
-0.05945625156164169,
-0.6387902498245239,
-0.17977550625801086,
0.030500594526529312,
-0.5182358622550964,
-0.05395058915019035,
0.38972508907318115,
0.3082658052444458,
-0.17599906027317047,
0.6767961978912354,
-0.19071297347545624,
-0.6261311173439026,
0.18754757940769196,
-0.3870287835597992,
0.5891096591949463,
0.10504481196403503,
-0.2833217680454254,
0.3359290361404419,
-0.7845422029495239,
0.2915252149105072,
-0.06792964786291122,
-0.6528922915458679,
-0.28681090474128723,
-0.014962907880544662,
0.12799516320228577,
0.26081034541130066,
0.05672648921608925,
-0.6552409529685974,
0.2820259928703308,
-0.42678073048591614,
0.47496551275253296,
0.4429905414581299,
-0.21291211247444153,
0.6677699685096741,
-0.5762284398078918,
0.3041284382343292,
-0.23961476981639862,
-0.07527584582567215,
-0.3670942485332489,
-0.3203623592853546,
-1.0565221309661865,
0.11756867170333862,
0.21010065078735352,
0.8112310171127319,
-0.8581148982048035,
0.6849018335342407,
-0.1696813702583313,
-0.580611526966095,
-0.5503851771354675,
0.17954005300998688,
0.7214508652687073,
0.4561384618282318,
0.29812711477279663,
-0.13103927671909332,
-0.6181217432022095,
-0.6088387370109558,
-0.5020920038223267,
-0.022214040160179138,
-0.07909504324197769,
0.13299404084682465,
0.4853675961494446,
-0.008595305494964123,
0.7125861048698425,
-0.514398455619812,
-0.42671528458595276,
-0.5118681788444519,
0.02942558191716671,
0.1505662351846695,
0.5842847228050232,
0.2490568310022354,
-0.6078808903694153,
-0.11651160567998886,
0.26049596071243286,
-0.5886020064353943,
-0.25526347756385803,
-0.3454522490501404,
-0.007910811342298985,
0.6083701848983765,
0.8499687910079956,
-0.5774860382080078,
0.37004518508911133,
0.4507380425930023,
-0.27773067355155945,
0.499720960855484,
-0.7378023862838745,
0.36881062388420105,
-1.018865704536438,
-0.06464181840419769,
-0.11245880275964737,
-0.07346760481595993,
-0.6781651973724365,
0.36612969636917114,
0.32253408432006836,
0.1342601329088211,
-0.34023189544677734,
0.2699441611766815,
-0.480659544467926,
0.10660672187805176,
-0.4681164026260376,
0.17323794960975647,
-0.09631715714931488,
0.6176077723503113,
-0.16346444189548492,
0.3158096373081207,
0.059584688395261765,
-0.43769344687461853,
0.47301363945007324,
-0.0845220610499382,
-0.2748839557170868,
0.309661328792572,
-0.4968402683734894,
0.1392419934272766,
-0.27638158202171326,
0.7280269265174866,
-1.003639817237854,
-0.33916765451431274,
0.3560112416744232,
-0.32810139656066895,
0.22904211282730103,
-0.014848832972347736,
-0.2606532871723175,
-0.3531714081764221,
-0.2195281982421875,
0.35083886981010437,
0.27699699997901917,
-0.6034562587738037,
0.8320816159248352,
-0.11374132335186005,
0.04042115435004234,
-0.5360800623893738,
-1.0398852825164795,
0.1402917355298996,
0.09247463941574097,
-0.7918770909309387,
0.6752052307128906,
0.1384587436914444,
0.0852498933672905,
0.08897539973258972,
0.15293635427951813,
0.1000765711069107,
-0.3360964059829712,
0.06747705489397049,
0.3059779405593872,
-0.3999191224575043,
-0.0355595238506794,
0.07579243183135986,
-0.04438520967960358,
-0.14933988451957703,
-0.21694530546665192,
0.2961527705192566,
0.14247868955135345,
-0.6192628741264343,
-0.32120999693870544,
0.5128850936889648,
0.5340904593467712,
-0.02158639207482338,
0.6611568331718445,
0.1463741660118103,
-0.5879687070846558,
-0.3077890872955322,
-0.5406970977783203,
-0.10268741101026535,
-0.4268539249897003,
0.4862698018550873,
-0.18098708987236023,
-0.8007558584213257,
0.6372641324996948,
0.30201229453086853,
0.24548162519931793,
0.4250997304916382,
0.3874766230583191,
0.19433961808681488,
0.6291536092758179,
0.2734680771827698,
-0.5356734991073608,
0.4573349058628082,
0.19062550365924835,
0.2491028606891632,
-0.46356457471847534,
-0.13382574915885925,
-0.40928539633750916,
-0.4516119658946991,
-0.45679473876953125,
-0.31329211592674255,
0.1261395364999771,
0.1385313868522644,
-0.2553090453147888,
0.12448716163635254,
-0.2424165904521942,
0.554711103439331,
0.9120382070541382,
0.35553476214408875,
0.3108396530151367,
-0.11946777254343033,
-0.05977851524949074,
-0.0681348592042923,
-0.8343496322631836,
-0.1565828174352646,
0.6306044459342957,
-0.055275049060583115,
0.8958001136779785,
-0.03264089301228523,
0.719201385974884,
0.0257773008197546,
0.021258724853396416,
-0.625794529914856,
0.5532813668251038,
-0.4472026526927948,
-0.4178905189037323,
-0.4936923682689667,
-0.295013427734375,
-0.5505504608154297,
0.6507837176322937,
-0.2584613263607025,
-0.6446388363838196,
0.16668790578842163,
0.6381683349609375,
-0.43414029479026794,
0.6834002733230591,
-0.8087524175643921,
0.9457892775535583,
-0.24211643636226654,
-0.3531774878501892,
-0.15005278587341309,
-0.6032330989837646,
0.5533607602119446,
-0.021358026191592216,
0.12417837977409363,
0.5893100500106812,
0.30346018075942993,
0.41018402576446533,
-0.764119565486908,
1.1814700365066528,
0.02049754559993744,
-0.2914716601371765,
0.4296809434890747,
-0.06099935248494148,
0.72255939245224,
-0.460217148065567,
0.025927795097231865,
-0.09677071124315262,
-0.27936065196990967,
-0.11590827256441116,
-0.8422962427139282,
0.7540105581283569,
-0.5318480134010315,
-0.5730358362197876,
-0.3197508454322815,
-0.36578965187072754,
0.23408924043178558,
0.18197590112686157,
0.4942859411239624,
0.22422252595424652,
-0.4083590507507324,
0.17631246149539948,
-0.017306281253695488,
-0.03538283333182335,
0.29351887106895447,
0.3107946217060089,
-0.2556965947151184,
-0.6409507393836975,
0.6174437403678894,
0.3760284185409546,
0.6214686632156372,
0.42061567306518555,
-0.00831461139023304,
0.21923227608203888,
-0.22319425642490387,
-0.669900119304657,
-0.011681566946208477,
-0.9152184128761292,
0.04808686673641205,
-0.6501461863517761,
-0.49922701716423035,
-0.35853612422943115,
-0.5113584995269775,
-0.30620577931404114,
-0.3200024962425232,
-0.09926438331604004,
0.017954422160983086,
0.12012186646461487,
0.4455016553401947,
-0.005537519697099924,
0.6806337833404541,
-0.971133828163147,
0.15284782648086548,
0.06990248709917068,
0.1353425830602646,
0.19490258395671844,
-0.6305143237113953,
-0.15815654397010803,
0.14040231704711914,
-0.19685031473636627,
-0.6725906133651733,
0.48412996530532837,
0.3074900805950165,
0.4473634362220764,
0.13516314327716827,
-0.13129733502864838,
0.9593799710273743,
-0.711426854133606,
0.7680526375770569,
0.03350558504462242,
-1.0869299173355103,
0.32528239488601685,
-0.1503434032201767,
0.372493714094162,
0.1883159726858139,
-0.38634970784187317,
-1.0583940744400024,
-0.4821509122848511,
-0.49162557721138,
-0.9926315546035767,
0.9579530358314514,
0.1863134801387787,
-0.11234907805919647,
0.21565455198287964,
0.4650152623653412,
-0.22833625972270966,
-0.1567477434873581,
-0.7340749502182007,
-0.15463358163833618,
-0.18769079446792603,
-0.17912057042121887,
-0.4427548348903656,
-0.41874271631240845,
0.10483907908201218,
-0.23114013671875,
0.9800041913986206,
-0.1259983777999878,
-0.09054941684007645,
0.43657535314559937,
-0.15965910255908966,
-0.5221731662750244,
0.6153696775436401,
0.7214454412460327,
0.32598915696144104,
-0.08264104276895523,
0.12301134318113327,
0.6891245245933533,
-0.3187817633152008,
-0.1102614626288414,
0.02714204415678978,
-0.44551903009414673,
0.059077680110931396,
0.6023914217948914,
0.7281929850578308,
0.6408940553665161,
-0.3974205553531647,
0.21153360605239868,
0.27672305703163147,
-0.2826729118824005,
-0.1523595154285431,
0.23659661412239075,
0.1915077120065689,
0.11530139297246933,
0.2206374853849411,
0.14228051900863647,
0.033465053886175156,
-0.44013622403144836,
0.3671022057533264,
0.24595534801483154,
-0.08504385501146317,
-0.06186915189027786,
0.612306535243988,
0.1497606784105301,
-0.08131003379821777,
0.4226250946521759,
0.0595523826777935,
-0.8379833698272705,
0.8074268102645874,
0.8494676947593689,
0.8110391497612,
-0.6061738133430481,
-0.12228915840387344,
0.5453999042510986,
0.5025268197059631,
-0.5077995657920837,
0.1655256599187851,
0.20123961567878723,
-0.9242860078811646,
-0.5323679447174072,
-0.07629045844078064,
-0.3861791491508484,
0.09765175729990005,
-0.5649341940879822,
0.4845477044582367,
-0.24302908778190613,
0.30723392963409424,
0.04241340979933739,
-0.38957545161247253,
-0.04633088782429695,
0.5682682991027832,
-0.021516364067792892,
0.5874398946762085,
-0.8541454672813416,
0.8426297307014465,
0.6060711741447449,
-0.2435109168291092,
-0.9086990356445312,
-0.15924111008644104,
0.221197709441185,
-0.7091907858848572,
0.23552089929580688,
-0.03624894469976425,
-0.26722922921180725,
-0.42454925179481506,
-0.3819813132286072,
-0.5742642283439636,
1.0978074073791504,
0.217241570353508,
-0.9968252182006836,
-0.08293077349662781,
0.07919678837060928,
0.5669794678688049,
-0.352963924407959,
0.05848921090364456,
0.543454110622406,
0.4037288725376129,
0.4254276752471924,
-1.0560039281845093,
0.1700894832611084,
-0.2766796052455902,
-0.06201606243848801,
0.3233269453048706,
-0.5526124835014343,
1.1489524841308594,
-0.20060937106609344,
-0.1944301873445511,
0.2532511055469513,
0.6070530414581299,
0.18634845316410065,
0.40408653020858765,
0.5383074283599854,
0.48570576310157776,
0.6667746305465698,
0.04397475719451904,
0.9471985101699829,
0.04122510179877281,
0.5928117036819458,
1.4664480686187744,
-0.45701542496681213,
0.9242839217185974,
0.5981677770614624,
0.007952000945806503,
0.07545574754476547,
0.3934245705604553,
-0.05574169009923935,
0.28324827551841736,
0.18657615780830383,
-0.275918573141098,
-0.36889204382896423,
0.3992810845375061,
-0.3372364342212677,
0.22479553520679474,
0.0057097068056464195,
-0.6381435990333557,
-0.29493698477745056,
-0.2939234972000122,
0.15340684354305267,
0.21979553997516632,
-0.573440670967102,
0.6551105976104736,
0.12519629299640656,
-1.1965715885162354,
0.6553819179534912,
0.2991456091403961,
0.8839558362960815,
-0.2450825721025467,
-0.11225306987762451,
-0.18707533180713654,
0.8278130292892456,
-0.43003618717193604,
-0.7461340427398682,
0.3451147675514221,
-0.09287481755018234,
-0.2542003095149994,
0.06410758942365646,
1.1202489137649536,
-1.0010496377944946,
-0.8148488402366638,
0.3803620934486389,
0.18838411569595337,
-0.043786510825157166,
-0.1881084442138672,
-0.2863751947879791,
-0.20812007784843445,
0.322017103433609,
-0.049702391028404236,
0.022776473313570023,
0.3749821186065674,
-0.3561123311519623,
0.4776599407196045,
0.6646368503570557,
0.005560257472097874,
0.05191982537508011,
0.35978156328201294,
0.8566666841506958,
-0.9339525699615479,
-0.6941560506820679,
-1.0568403005599976,
0.5466501712799072,
-0.02594715729355812,
-0.1743415892124176,
0.5052472949028015,
0.3555911183357239,
1.0831096172332764,
-0.27434834837913513,
0.9684064388275146,
0.10795171558856964,
0.36010339856147766,
-0.7252022624015808,
0.8657539486885071,
-0.6238980293273926,
0.10252400487661362,
-0.329091876745224,
-0.6431911587715149,
-0.605671226978302,
0.3496054708957672,
-0.19355273246765137,
0.2035556137561798,
0.5404285192489624,
0.9758590459823608,
-0.1799890697002411,
0.14634454250335693,
0.4986058175563812,
0.08634082227945328,
0.10774959623813629,
0.8603606224060059,
0.7442455887794495,
-0.6708993315696716,
0.46353328227996826,
-0.20572912693023682,
-0.05632859840989113,
-0.4639924466609955,
-0.7300127744674683,
-0.8007043600082397,
-0.27700355648994446,
-0.11713287979364395,
-0.37645506858825684,
0.3652154207229614,
0.8721508979797363,
0.09547138214111328,
-0.9335751533508301,
-0.05710447579622269,
-0.18223242461681366,
0.10001535713672638,
-0.39639928936958313,
-0.12574757635593414,
0.40782275795936584,
-0.22751711308956146,
-0.8708300590515137,
0.28296545147895813,
-0.025615869089961052,
-0.07322949171066284,
0.08916433900594711,
-0.264009565114975,
-0.14681747555732727,
-0.22111816704273224,
0.5151803493499756,
0.2657906413078308,
-1.0808483362197876,
-0.2871592342853546,
0.09443602710962296,
-0.18926593661308289,
0.0030363406985998154,
1.0130360126495361,
-0.4309096336364746,
0.41291165351867676,
0.594214916229248,
0.661374032497406,
0.13332925736904144,
-0.029725439846515656,
0.932201623916626,
-0.6903728246688843,
0.036973025649785995,
-0.2805415093898773,
0.8780789375305176,
0.2999880909919739,
-0.5184908509254456,
0.27615562081336975,
0.2469594031572342,
-0.583879292011261,
-0.4913557767868042,
-0.14082959294319153,
-0.9266068935394287,
-0.37506622076034546,
1.1997871398925781,
-0.21086399257183075,
-0.2914978861808777,
0.16712628304958344,
-0.7935513854026794,
0.6273881793022156,
-0.2685556411743164,
0.6211068630218506,
0.8886268138885498,
0.3601047396659851,
-0.19768379628658295,
-0.23826876282691956,
0.21346989274024963,
0.7504962086677551,
-0.6361362934112549,
0.22006967663764954,
0.7258753180503845,
0.2615263760089874,
0.08542654663324356,
0.49493059515953064,
0.05178695544600487,
0.603800892829895,
0.015736481174826622,
0.36079511046409607,
0.12972508370876312,
-0.05808073282241821,
-0.46466711163520813,
0.005253050476312637,
-0.2381463199853897,
-0.33352988958358765
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17411v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17411v1
|
PCToolkit: A Unified Plug-and-Play Prompt Compression Toolkit of Large Language Models
| 2024-03-26T06:11:07 | 2024-03-26T06:11:07 |
Jinyi Li, Yihuai Lan, Lei Wang, Hao Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Prompt compression is an innovative method for efficiently condensing input
prompts while preserving essential information. To facilitate quick-start
services, user-friendly interfaces, and compatibility with common datasets and
metrics, we present the Prompt Compression Toolkit (PCToolkit). This toolkit is
a unified plug-and-play solution for compressing prompts in Large Language
Models (LLMs), featuring cutting-edge prompt compressors, diverse datasets, and
metrics for comprehensive performance evaluation. PCToolkit boasts a modular
design, allowing for easy integration of new datasets and metrics through
portable and user-friendly interfaces. In this paper, we outline the key
components and functionalities of PCToolkit. We conducted evaluations of the
compressors within PCToolkit across various natural language tasks, including
reconstruction, summarization, mathematical problem-solving, question
answering, few-shot learning, synthetic tasks, code completion, boolean
expressions, multiple choice questions, and lies recognition.
|
[
-0.6445163488388062,
-0.5506027340888977,
0.5814651250839233,
0.6574249863624573,
-0.4900888204574585,
0.2292386144399643,
-0.452750563621521,
-0.008203902281820774,
0.11820190399885178,
0.3562556803226471,
-0.7808350324630737,
-0.3840736448764801,
-0.2723757326602936,
0.44679924845695496,
-0.2396848499774933,
0.6096437573432922,
0.271026611328125,
-0.1237216591835022,
-0.3716070353984833,
0.2909497320652008,
-1.085908055305481,
-0.5518161058425903,
-0.7291480898857117,
-0.039438869804143906,
0.26950809359550476,
0.3749554753303528,
0.5350315570831299,
0.1674708127975464,
0.38232022523880005,
0.3519129455089569,
-0.12104232609272003,
0.17761291563510895,
-0.2501492202281952,
0.56373131275177,
0.08346638828516006,
-0.30509936809539795,
-0.3015318512916565,
-0.22401010990142822,
0.4240293502807617,
0.599882960319519,
-0.1889173537492752,
0.284686803817749,
0.1713525950908661,
0.253094881772995,
-0.4248271584510803,
0.2474830597639084,
-0.22897543013095856,
0.12797799706459045,
-0.037483781576156616,
-0.3637278974056244,
-0.6897398829460144,
-0.6358621120452881,
-0.36664703488349915,
-0.5730530619621277,
0.13914644718170166,
-0.10198810696601868,
0.22119545936584473,
0.4612053334712982,
-0.30243417620658875,
-0.10036760568618774,
-0.2422093003988266,
0.6340717077255249,
-0.5300666689872742,
0.22368186712265015,
0.2430138736963272,
0.6921924352645874,
-0.4997844398021698,
-0.688730001449585,
-0.5858017206192017,
-0.012410913594067097,
-0.16849792003631592,
0.0721702128648758,
-0.33166608214378357,
0.39905786514282227,
0.37019380927085876,
0.4594789445400238,
-0.7511929869651794,
0.2863790988922119,
-0.1305551677942276,
-0.6934820413589478,
0.176147922873497,
0.33001843094825745,
0.5394871830940247,
-0.4807003438472748,
-0.12845724821090698,
-0.3343973457813263,
-0.5772799253463745,
0.25766947865486145,
0.305878609418869,
0.6459960341453552,
-0.24059604108333588,
0.42364266514778137,
-0.26269081234931946,
0.9766125679016113,
-0.13899658620357513,
-0.6451818943023682,
0.1284576803445816,
-0.30063000321388245,
-0.36396002769470215,
0.2199753075838089,
0.8518835306167603,
0.20435293018817902,
0.010566062293946743,
-0.14524808526039124,
-0.1446867138147354,
0.09452950954437256,
-0.005175365600734949,
-0.7719979286193848,
-0.20426002144813538,
0.1916288137435913,
-0.4090355932712555,
-0.33663105964660645,
0.04640593379735947,
-0.9522728323936462,
-0.4300996959209442,
-0.5707939267158508,
0.07536959648132324,
-0.06235252320766449,
0.1686408817768097,
0.2085985541343689,
-0.32224589586257935,
-0.0040125371888279915,
0.7860710024833679,
-0.3567475378513336,
0.3309333324432373,
0.7352093458175659,
0.9244274497032166,
-0.13406389951705933,
0.06406363099813461,
-1.010289192199707,
-0.26928016543388367,
-0.028522349894046783,
0.9030694961547852,
-0.5900771617889404,
-0.7666887640953064,
-0.07477489858865738,
0.2523861825466156,
0.40792474150657654,
-0.3546115756034851,
0.662968635559082,
-0.11928645521402359,
0.37777483463287354,
-0.34184595942497253,
-0.27554404735565186,
0.13033276796340942,
0.19885830581188202,
-0.8103532791137695,
1.270654559135437,
-0.03610238432884216,
-0.5082530975341797,
0.03557611256837845,
-0.2395094782114029,
-0.3471154570579529,
0.4752299189567566,
-0.21810057759284973,
0.09174150973558426,
0.3841053247451782,
0.4973715841770172,
0.5118775963783264,
-0.6966579556465149,
0.4775576591491699,
-0.12141696363687515,
-0.4257854223251343,
-0.034691911190748215,
-0.6865852475166321,
1.1624449491500854,
0.1408412605524063,
0.11350065469741821,
0.036234963685274124,
-0.8032436370849609,
-0.1870035082101822,
-0.15414662659168243,
-0.7087106704711914,
-0.05898376554250717,
-0.6915491223335266,
0.19525094330310822,
0.3837544023990631,
0.17637088894844055,
-0.6708115339279175,
0.917592465877533,
-0.010857708752155304,
0.3024667501449585,
0.6788228750228882,
0.054118745028972626,
0.14182500541210175,
0.11310600489377975,
1.056489109992981,
-0.4778330624103546,
0.20449618995189667,
-0.5568126440048218,
-0.659855842590332,
-0.2012617290019989,
-0.5580397248268127,
0.21691331267356873,
0.5946678519248962,
-1.0026606321334839,
0.7738262414932251,
-0.23350952565670013,
-0.5188245177268982,
-0.23408088088035583,
-0.037634335458278656,
0.08470484614372253,
0.9058815240859985,
0.12735289335250854,
-0.1321326196193695,
-0.4666729271411896,
-0.7286586165428162,
0.19228686392307281,
-0.27618101239204407,
-0.5468581914901733,
0.07436452805995941,
-0.18727943301200867,
0.05002441257238388,
1.1487172842025757,
-0.5249118208885193,
-0.09100397676229477,
-0.5628346800804138,
0.5714880228042603,
0.4779399037361145,
0.29546332359313965,
0.586243212223053,
-0.395651638507843,
-0.4111788868904114,
-0.25639769434928894,
-0.2526661455631256,
-0.7253813147544861,
-0.23097378015518188,
0.3236267566680908,
-0.1567511409521103,
0.5856233239173889,
-0.8702864646911621,
0.49849551916122437,
0.5639748573303223,
-0.3951180577278137,
0.9810739755630493,
-0.14823877811431885,
0.19756707549095154,
-1.1563881635665894,
0.3445848524570465,
-0.4149235785007477,
-0.5388327240943909,
-0.4856773614883423,
-0.1590753048658371,
0.16355229914188385,
-0.4419023394584656,
-0.581631064414978,
0.6684213876724243,
-0.22398258745670319,
-0.1301952749490738,
-0.16621063649654388,
0.12646053731441498,
0.17076420783996582,
0.39459842443466187,
-0.24790412187576294,
1.2875593900680542,
0.45553305745124817,
-0.6078559756278992,
0.7105920910835266,
0.3187671899795532,
-0.22687864303588867,
0.47819674015045166,
-0.5875278115272522,
0.22555041313171387,
-0.21214735507965088,
0.4053111672401428,
-1.1206200122833252,
-0.3338090181350708,
0.06315986067056656,
-0.4629044830799103,
0.24730683863162994,
-0.043159518390893936,
-0.9522348046302795,
-0.5538779497146606,
-0.4996183216571808,
0.40766316652297974,
0.6265408992767334,
-0.7531692385673523,
0.5620061755180359,
0.02706911787390709,
-0.5144616365432739,
-0.47530508041381836,
-0.561142086982727,
0.4177066385746002,
0.027979156002402306,
-0.20711220800876617,
0.3503094017505646,
-0.5263568758964539,
0.12770162522792816,
-0.33336707949638367,
0.07153481990098953,
0.03259804844856262,
0.02629387564957142,
0.2335270196199417,
0.4109823703765869,
0.09911046177148819,
0.4168602526187897,
0.17054373025894165,
-0.24340376257896423,
-0.1082620918750763,
0.06765864044427872,
0.905963122844696,
0.13602904975414276,
-0.08181378990411758,
-0.453685998916626,
0.24960123002529144,
0.613871157169342,
0.058371178805828094,
0.24506592750549316,
0.42414072155952454,
-0.1530829817056656,
-0.1202712282538414,
-0.528741180896759,
-0.13998888432979584,
-0.5173052549362183,
0.24952846765518188,
-0.29169026017189026,
-1.0060667991638184,
0.4212420880794525,
-0.3082466125488281,
0.03498315438628197,
0.20250587165355682,
0.3901045024394989,
0.2736687958240509,
1.0406079292297363,
0.8603557348251343,
-0.34604257345199585,
0.19701528549194336,
0.35349977016448975,
0.30192145705223083,
-0.5610156059265137,
-0.19661909341812134,
-0.9159864783287048,
-0.1936563104391098,
-0.22820967435836792,
-0.3266094923019409,
0.27194511890411377,
0.09581346064805984,
-0.10653796046972275,
0.34115228056907654,
-0.596759557723999,
0.6291415691375732,
0.39644306898117065,
-0.19446983933448792,
0.1990731805562973,
0.024625027552247047,
-0.25359413027763367,
0.014017308130860329,
-0.7022110223770142,
-0.37190505862236023,
0.6000555753707886,
0.07894766330718994,
0.7152767777442932,
-0.0009169512195512652,
0.4755522906780243,
0.18591678142547607,
0.029296323657035828,
-1.110225796699524,
0.7953301668167114,
-0.2521103024482727,
-0.05222718045115471,
-0.08171889185905457,
-0.40752628445625305,
-0.6970683932304382,
-0.39593783020973206,
0.10229431092739105,
-0.9633559584617615,
0.33706891536712646,
0.2220201939344406,
-0.6647658348083496,
0.1585814654827118,
-0.44107767939567566,
0.7063555121421814,
-0.04365353658795357,
0.07074382901191711,
0.12424862384796143,
-0.5401023626327515,
0.36165711283683777,
0.03935204818844795,
-0.005629898048937321,
0.09186415374279022,
-0.14950783550739288,
0.627434253692627,
-0.5783773064613342,
0.9239758253097534,
-0.16736863553524017,
0.07875487953424454,
0.07958927750587463,
0.3780555725097656,
0.2511802315711975,
0.17369507253170013,
0.14237867295742035,
-0.05818706005811691,
-0.0063546812161803246,
-0.13681575655937195,
-0.8648480772972107,
0.41839733719825745,
-0.35882771015167236,
-0.3057858943939209,
-0.1767348200082779,
-0.5265842080116272,
-0.19678235054016113,
0.16959868371486664,
0.22429907321929932,
0.9781888723373413,
-0.1738879680633545,
0.12846137583255768,
0.6452694535255432,
-0.7508363127708435,
0.7644856572151184,
0.1517181396484375,
-0.5399641394615173,
-0.6420278549194336,
0.5038665533065796,
-0.41273245215415955,
-0.004748768173158169,
0.44267210364341736,
0.237412229180336,
-0.14311611652374268,
0.03349453955888748,
-0.3358387053012848,
0.13430380821228027,
-0.9125407338142395,
-0.830771803855896,
-0.480773001909256,
0.15592369437217712,
-0.558531641960144,
-0.33678877353668213,
-0.19966855645179749,
-0.7718688249588013,
-0.13799478113651276,
-0.021204521879553795,
0.3062107264995575,
0.689516007900238,
0.042358867824077606,
0.6350657343864441,
-0.7890620827674866,
0.3763403594493866,
0.4549824893474579,
0.16233643889427185,
-0.10379573702812195,
-0.21831738948822021,
0.19942781329154968,
-0.6216434240341187,
-0.11464126408100128,
-0.8323270678520203,
0.4734708368778229,
0.13296863436698914,
0.33036118745803833,
0.506438136100769,
0.27420932054519653,
0.644592821598053,
-0.363885760307312,
1.2073891162872314,
0.412732869386673,
-0.886195957660675,
0.46705755591392517,
0.1524919718503952,
0.8906520009040833,
0.78824383020401,
0.2566797137260437,
-0.780341625213623,
-0.10633821785449982,
-0.1793222278356552,
-0.6311001777648926,
0.644885778427124,
-0.15014852583408356,
-0.01106751523911953,
-0.043878741562366486,
0.16943039000034332,
0.48617294430732727,
0.5659220814704895,
-0.42641499638557434,
-0.13081404566764832,
-0.11932769417762756,
-0.4241359531879425,
-0.1966150403022766,
-0.2845563590526581,
0.03181304782629013,
-0.31071773171424866,
0.44024860858917236,
-0.32414939999580383,
0.4442930817604065,
0.12443888187408447,
-0.14911046624183655,
0.2869022786617279,
0.46468082070350647,
0.4307905435562134,
0.31088942289352417,
-0.20957647264003754,
0.29408973455429077,
-0.2337736040353775,
-0.7353721261024475,
0.2872019112110138,
0.1599397212266922,
0.16092638671398163,
0.294173002243042,
0.36286985874176025,
0.5953944325447083,
0.15444302558898926,
-0.8996047973632812,
0.5298920273780823,
-0.6774099469184875,
0.17193223536014557,
0.1871872991323471,
-0.22558802366256714,
-0.2051997184753418,
-0.28569820523262024,
0.2212028205394745,
0.10704545676708221,
0.339732825756073,
-0.5038407444953918,
-0.08526958525180817,
0.15364237129688263,
-0.2171720415353775,
-0.49408045411109924,
0.18496336042881012,
0.18753784894943237,
-0.5080986022949219,
0.7692564725875854,
-0.3356768786907196,
-0.8027887344360352,
0.4021764397621155,
0.44019702076911926,
1.0714385509490967,
-0.35568782687187195,
0.3635222315788269,
0.39811497926712036,
0.42230165004730225,
0.06618834286928177,
0.31044134497642517,
-0.5573359727859497,
-0.14030614495277405,
-0.7238136529922485,
-0.6281963586807251,
-0.24574291706085205,
0.1165771633386612,
-0.47249460220336914,
0.5082041025161743,
-0.46024271845817566,
-0.06957773119211197,
-0.28897613286972046,
-0.154391348361969,
-0.9416738152503967,
0.05483730882406235,
-0.06294088065624237,
1.5487169027328491,
-0.694333553314209,
0.7088794708251953,
0.6131161451339722,
-0.20408640801906586,
-1.0256855487823486,
-0.15946686267852783,
0.33027660846710205,
-0.5745023488998413,
0.7632553577423096,
0.34055909514427185,
0.02655310183763504,
-0.1544942706823349,
-0.5267021059989929,
-0.5262319445610046,
0.8730283379554749,
0.7420828938484192,
-0.5716906785964966,
-0.06283516436815262,
0.3399779796600342,
0.2503761649131775,
-0.29622507095336914,
0.36733803153038025,
0.6533333659172058,
0.5287155508995056,
0.09062191843986511,
-1.2338029146194458,
0.10719108581542969,
-0.33193227648735046,
-0.1765863597393036,
0.14755289256572723,
-0.21080073714256287,
0.6994922757148743,
0.4068433344364166,
-0.08651723712682724,
0.2641143202781677,
-0.017472200095653534,
0.1355021595954895,
-0.039911750704050064,
0.3617786467075348,
0.5195809006690979,
0.795352578163147,
-0.23467113077640533,
1.115154504776001,
-0.3585236966609955,
0.10885275900363922,
1.0712748765945435,
0.03229657560586929,
0.5809626579284668,
0.559113085269928,
-0.234551340341568,
0.1889997124671936,
0.6688324213027954,
0.1678091287612915,
0.40070244669914246,
-0.07292185723781586,
-0.2667613625526428,
-0.4005358815193176,
-0.3870970606803894,
-0.2684314250946045,
0.21487091481685638,
0.10954579710960388,
0.08656948804855347,
-0.45730873942375183,
0.15151150524616241,
0.07068293541669846,
-0.24068568646907806,
-0.34470289945602417,
0.844048798084259,
0.04860743507742882,
-0.6447826027870178,
0.27971529960632324,
-0.26219987869262695,
0.6124294996261597,
-0.7970132827758789,
-0.13814692199230194,
-0.35501161217689514,
-0.4110628664493561,
0.010980517603456974,
-0.7408699989318848,
-0.04561714828014374,
0.08273780345916748,
-0.0058753578923642635,
-0.3280237019062042,
0.8509787917137146,
-0.08294151723384857,
-0.380596786737442,
-0.06733328849077225,
0.23467497527599335,
0.1455339789390564,
-0.10917878895998001,
-0.6000074148178101,
0.47012215852737427,
0.03263931721448898,
-0.030424492433667183,
0.0040944223292171955,
0.468357115983963,
0.347553014755249,
0.5270093083381653,
0.5011377334594727,
0.3353736996650696,
-0.05578218027949333,
0.2985917031764984,
1.0467114448547363,
-0.5015480518341064,
-0.8050264716148376,
-0.5352905988693237,
0.6926314234733582,
-0.2643682360649109,
-0.41252240538597107,
0.630558967590332,
0.43256330490112305,
0.39243388175964355,
-0.1999322474002838,
0.795459508895874,
-0.0667305514216423,
0.3202124834060669,
-0.48160287737846375,
0.2890092730522156,
-0.2505964934825897,
0.2974298894405365,
-0.3779045343399048,
-1.0872999429702759,
-0.5247158408164978,
0.23640891909599304,
-0.08531557023525238,
-0.20452407002449036,
0.5447925925254822,
0.6083255410194397,
-0.19236522912979126,
-0.0027511720545589924,
0.37374210357666016,
0.0004085382679477334,
0.5244834423065186,
0.29446300864219666,
0.5500720739364624,
-0.1046341061592102,
0.4635607600212097,
-0.3535851538181305,
-0.3868009150028229,
-0.1320730596780777,
-1.196252465248108,
-0.9523990154266357,
-0.41882285475730896,
-0.22176817059516907,
0.12224487960338593,
-0.22540855407714844,
1.2530241012573242,
0.7216276526451111,
-0.6525333523750305,
-0.22851674258708954,
-0.23548223078250885,
-0.12749184668064117,
0.061898499727249146,
-0.2845780849456787,
0.2653945982456207,
-0.693651020526886,
-0.492249995470047,
0.6071648597717285,
0.5926979780197144,
0.017964627593755722,
-0.40837982296943665,
0.06515337526798248,
0.3229779005050659,
0.017295073717832565,
0.6750983595848083,
0.2759663164615631,
-0.5649693608283997,
-0.016937291249632835,
-0.07263175398111343,
0.2986708879470825,
0.05400414392352104,
1.1815060377120972,
-1.3295518159866333,
0.8266483545303345,
0.6568413972854614,
0.8107069134712219,
-0.141872376203537,
0.008544768206775188,
0.719033420085907,
-1.163985252380371,
0.5665866136550903,
0.13246987760066986,
0.5568814873695374,
0.48347243666648865,
-0.4329051673412323,
0.2955717444419861,
0.07843723148107529,
-0.6197735071182251,
-1.1049760580062866,
0.22697201371192932,
-1.1565455198287964,
-0.4100256562232971,
0.6844049096107483,
0.07877318561077118,
-0.18584994971752167,
-0.14417250454425812,
-0.806904673576355,
0.09643764793872833,
-0.6559902429580688,
0.6134944558143616,
0.6698251962661743,
-0.07800468057394028,
-0.19817866384983063,
-0.47157010436058044,
0.6778143644332886,
0.015328388661146164,
-1.0519357919692993,
0.31750836968421936,
0.6087936162948608,
-0.08974116295576096,
0.2382316291332245,
0.23820926249027252,
0.12666472792625427,
0.5678222179412842,
-0.22642002999782562,
0.3047259747982025,
-0.27855971455574036,
-0.4163567125797272,
-0.7941281795501709,
0.3742857277393341,
-0.030298510566353798,
0.2682191729545593
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17407v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17407v3
|
Transcribing Bengali Text with Regional Dialects to IPA using District Guided Tokens
| 2024-03-26T05:55:21 | 2024-04-02T04:15:36 |
S M Jishanul Islam, Sadia Ahmmed, Sahid Hossain Mustakim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, F.2.2; I.2.7
|
Accurate transcription of Bengali text to the International Phonetic Alphabet
(IPA) is a challenging task due to the complex phonology of the language and
context-dependent sound changes. This challenge is even more for regional
Bengali dialects due to unavailability of standardized spelling conventions for
these dialects, presence of local and foreign words popular in those regions
and phonological diversity across different regions. This paper presents an
approach to this sequence-to-sequence problem by introducing the District
Guided Tokens (DGT) technique on a new dataset spanning six districts of
Bangladesh. The key idea is to provide the model with explicit information
about the regional dialect or "district" of the input text before generating
the IPA transcription. This is achieved by prepending a district token to the
input sequence, effectively guiding the model to understand the unique phonetic
patterns associated with each district. The DGT technique is applied to
fine-tune several transformer-based models, on this new dataset. Experimental
results demonstrate the effectiveness of DGT, with the ByT5 model achieving
superior performance over word-based models like mT5, BanglaT5, and umT5. This
is attributed to ByT5's ability to handle a high percentage of
out-of-vocabulary words in the test set. The proposed approach highlights the
importance of incorporating regional dialect information into ubiquitous
natural language processing systems for languages with diverse phonological
variations. The following work was a result of the "Bhashamul" challenge, which
is dedicated to solving the problem of Bengali text with regional dialects to
IPA transcription https://www.kaggle.com/competitions/regipa/. The training and
inference notebooks are available through the competition link.
|
[
-0.028249580413103104,
-0.3877342939376831,
0.10162048786878586,
0.2811330556869507,
-0.456661194562912,
0.3878535032272339,
-0.0696135014295578,
0.048799093812704086,
0.29463163018226624,
0.48718732595443726,
-0.2634483873844147,
-0.5174212455749512,
-0.5293830633163452,
0.43189167976379395,
-0.10191760212182999,
0.48277974128723145,
0.05210199952125549,
0.17084601521492004,
0.6218968629837036,
0.03636933118104935,
-0.9905633330345154,
-0.7744712233543396,
-0.006036137696355581,
-0.12571100890636444,
0.31538307666778564,
0.3467637300491333,
0.09206872433423996,
0.9832133054733276,
0.4722019135951996,
0.23496174812316895,
-0.6226451396942139,
0.3089349865913391,
-0.06097875162959099,
0.035202980041503906,
-0.21108554303646088,
-0.7017867565155029,
-0.44544538855552673,
-0.3835451006889343,
0.6054538488388062,
0.8217689394950867,
-0.36066189408302307,
0.1828589141368866,
0.008959277532994747,
0.5336295962333679,
-0.27738532423973083,
0.14491789042949677,
-0.7417066693305969,
-0.21403458714485168,
-0.7301695346832275,
-0.303316593170166,
-0.5858697891235352,
-0.43846333026885986,
-0.03015211969614029,
-0.21704919636249542,
0.3268904387950897,
0.3067256510257721,
0.6470489501953125,
0.1173444464802742,
-0.5838634967803955,
-0.3860369622707367,
-0.6414822340011597,
0.4182263910770416,
-0.5684518218040466,
0.35688069462776184,
0.40209758281707764,
0.3782835602760315,
-0.23416265845298767,
-0.6169022917747498,
-0.5715905427932739,
0.2888273000717163,
-0.20663025975227356,
0.12017335742712021,
-0.017231175675988197,
0.17748704552650452,
0.1541929990053177,
0.5283322930335999,
-0.6742720603942871,
-0.16245006024837494,
-0.5854067206382751,
-0.0915120542049408,
0.3695369064807892,
0.13554979860782623,
0.23153698444366455,
-0.667718768119812,
-0.43529337644577026,
-0.10254046320915222,
-0.5824984312057495,
0.06872188299894333,
0.40756896138191223,
1.0803712606430054,
-0.07200268656015396,
0.4286317825317383,
0.1817266047000885,
0.7292979955673218,
0.4021884799003601,
-0.3217924237251282,
0.3069497346878052,
-0.36626946926116943,
-0.12919171154499054,
0.4756584167480469,
-0.038319408893585205,
-0.030997436493635178,
0.12158416211605072,
-0.007932673208415508,
-0.47135141491889954,
-0.2583622336387634,
0.043535880744457245,
-0.3487561345100403,
-0.14884264767169952,
0.11627601832151413,
-0.559063196182251,
0.24345047771930695,
0.14761318266391754,
-0.8891869187355042,
-0.428048700094223,
-0.5323682427406311,
0.25939929485321045,
-0.5005695223808289,
-0.40869441628456116,
0.06964495778083801,
-0.31954437494277954,
0.04818394035100937,
-0.017706992104649544,
-1.1163196563720703,
0.04850929230451584,
0.7034328579902649,
1.0038937330245972,
-0.14840960502624512,
-0.3299293518066406,
-0.3070797026157379,
0.34105855226516724,
-0.3265822231769562,
0.5422840118408203,
-0.5241737365722656,
-0.7334221601486206,
0.1820894032716751,
-0.2927568852901459,
-0.15900549292564392,
-0.877308189868927,
0.3538037836551666,
-0.45733147859573364,
-0.2799603343009949,
-0.3442743718624115,
-0.47189629077911377,
-0.23536428809165955,
0.1730525940656662,
-0.4533541202545166,
0.887650728225708,
0.14018560945987701,
-0.5557726621627808,
0.4747992753982544,
-0.42382916808128357,
-0.797337532043457,
0.2393457591533661,
0.1713685542345047,
0.0402192585170269,
0.22703522443771362,
0.4928082823753357,
0.2793846130371094,
0.003502683248370886,
0.5841521620750427,
0.30282795429229736,
-0.6990389227867126,
0.0110061876475811,
-0.6469789147377014,
0.9469590187072754,
0.0947648137807846,
-0.23963873088359833,
0.1203041821718216,
-0.993395209312439,
-0.21952180564403534,
-0.326170414686203,
-0.2787310779094696,
-0.3682202696800232,
-0.410286545753479,
0.0329061821103096,
-0.23929709196090698,
0.060271330177783966,
-0.4914022982120514,
0.6718712449073792,
-0.2932506203651428,
0.38434910774230957,
0.8366472721099854,
0.19717484712600708,
0.2856919765472412,
-0.35138097405433655,
0.5945532321929932,
0.2072669416666031,
0.14414280652999878,
-0.24257341027259827,
-0.3203887641429901,
-0.4008575677871704,
-0.9753801226615906,
0.9081082940101624,
0.6361037492752075,
-0.6313309669494629,
0.7317405939102173,
-0.602656364440918,
-0.5148846507072449,
-0.9303688406944275,
-0.41137418150901794,
-0.059610795229673386,
0.32134172320365906,
0.43977323174476624,
-0.3111942410469055,
-0.7703394889831543,
-0.48510071635246277,
0.20057745277881622,
-0.24277186393737793,
0.26714614033699036,
0.13364987075328827,
0.2744846045970917,
-0.1656101942062378,
1.0616930723190308,
-0.36583131551742554,
-0.42943984270095825,
-0.4276607632637024,
0.2523936629295349,
0.4763197898864746,
0.2033761888742447,
0.3750365972518921,
-0.943098783493042,
-0.4245302081108093,
0.02016567625105381,
-0.11895125359296799,
-0.4763590097427368,
-0.08322564512491226,
0.0776282474398613,
0.24015597999095917,
0.1999855488538742,
-0.26683831214904785,
0.611749529838562,
0.422993004322052,
-0.04975728690624237,
0.5133563876152039,
-0.07034942507743835,
0.32787519693374634,
-1.1114472150802612,
0.16430369019508362,
-0.3876570463180542,
-0.1557244509458542,
-0.5321536064147949,
-0.00991097092628479,
-0.07849802076816559,
-0.05763906612992287,
-0.17133449018001556,
0.824073314666748,
-0.40721067786216736,
-0.009527825750410557,
-0.016331452876329422,
-0.19192539155483246,
-0.2561491131782532,
0.5003360509872437,
-0.04042898863554001,
0.9594271183013916,
0.4064006507396698,
-0.397541880607605,
0.20667865872383118,
0.621124267578125,
-0.46572431921958923,
0.22269226610660553,
-0.1469147801399231,
-0.06464063376188278,
-0.0028539332561194897,
0.3346497416496277,
-1.0326601266860962,
0.001385185751132667,
0.16106142103672028,
-0.44156432151794434,
0.35471099615097046,
-0.48984095454216003,
-0.3828670382499695,
-0.19352596998214722,
0.15801358222961426,
0.3985826373100281,
0.7168470025062561,
-0.7723219990730286,
0.47069093585014343,
0.19960036873817444,
-0.4248020052909851,
-0.6375362873077393,
-0.8137421607971191,
0.22713874280452728,
-0.49370598793029785,
-0.1836439073085785,
0.27510350942611694,
0.27192336320877075,
-0.20698334276676178,
-0.3643594980239868,
-0.04472830519080162,
-0.28304824233055115,
-0.26553159952163696,
0.12503521144390106,
0.011858740821480751,
0.0927010178565979,
-0.08930669724941254,
0.07662428915500641,
0.05354570969939232,
-0.4528021216392517,
-0.29254308342933655,
0.7594478130340576,
0.4370781183242798,
-0.18510353565216064,
-0.5374398827552795,
0.5869503617286682,
0.5339174270629883,
-0.47899380326271057,
0.238592267036438,
0.30831724405288696,
-0.23197513818740845,
-0.5104906558990479,
-0.32390931248664856,
-0.17483656108379364,
-0.38790690898895264,
0.14292676746845245,
-0.7463201284408569,
-0.41182783246040344,
0.8665212988853455,
-0.37019526958465576,
-0.4832916557788849,
-0.14121732115745544,
0.7249836325645447,
0.24352654814720154,
0.5208804607391357,
0.35753288865089417,
-0.28384947776794434,
0.626762330532074,
-0.193918377161026,
0.5609945058822632,
-0.6219369173049927,
-0.20894162356853485,
-0.5174174308776855,
-0.225043386220932,
-0.7034953832626343,
-0.3266233205795288,
0.5196136832237244,
-0.001720879110507667,
-0.008529901504516602,
0.33464372158050537,
-0.4147205948829651,
0.06597018986940384,
0.8304092288017273,
0.19464756548404694,
0.25160619616508484,
0.20687653124332428,
-0.22042948007583618,
-0.32983067631721497,
-0.8832343816757202,
-0.3506098687648773,
0.7792898416519165,
0.16907726228237152,
0.7153680920600891,
0.23992589116096497,
1.0912781953811646,
0.5456477403640747,
0.07086551189422607,
-0.5357765555381775,
0.4407172203063965,
-0.4127767086029053,
-0.5858769416809082,
-0.05814512446522713,
-0.1949872076511383,
-0.7322863936424255,
-0.046893663704395294,
0.3905664384365082,
-0.5432311296463013,
0.5519207119941711,
0.0273997001349926,
-0.22330515086650848,
0.40293434262275696,
-0.640827476978302,
0.2025839388370514,
-0.014294453896582127,
-0.0008052993798628449,
0.1279888153076172,
-0.8728263974189758,
-0.028065277263522148,
0.01602979563176632,
0.0509357675909996,
0.25210869312286377,
0.42998072504997253,
0.37495875358581543,
-0.4626176357269287,
1.0693773031234741,
-0.4376963973045349,
-0.18288592994213104,
0.4750175178050995,
0.015541807748377323,
0.1157589703798294,
-0.37089803814888,
-0.35761114954948425,
0.3919208347797394,
-0.0006069770315662026,
-0.3364092707633972,
-0.5943557620048523,
0.05490577593445778,
-0.4737723767757416,
-0.4474514424800873,
-0.4807033836841583,
-0.38680166006088257,
-0.06859719008207321,
0.20086365938186646,
0.3242337703704834,
0.9391614198684692,
0.1696217656135559,
-0.23756279051303864,
0.3030368983745575,
-0.04735037684440613,
0.3684985935688019,
0.1454632580280304,
-0.13108649849891663,
-0.7415194511413574,
1.0139445066452026,
0.4507450461387634,
-0.01203201338648796,
0.6948301792144775,
0.15002590417861938,
-0.5567096471786499,
-0.9381534457206726,
-0.6371138691902161,
-0.010030575096607208,
-0.7291373014450073,
-0.3993755280971527,
0.06240704655647278,
-0.05117882043123245,
-0.6727783679962158,
-0.10250537097454071,
-0.033833131194114685,
-0.22967864573001862,
0.11632639169692993,
0.03608573600649834,
0.18016061186790466,
0.8582243919372559,
-0.34349656105041504,
0.5044949650764465,
-0.9646680355072021,
-0.018989691510796547,
0.07756341993808746,
0.12348580360412598,
0.051205068826675415,
-0.7605745196342468,
-0.08644478768110275,
-0.04506468400359154,
0.013672523200511932,
-0.8978418111801147,
0.5231465697288513,
-0.04632212966680527,
0.2663828134536743,
-0.07713653147220612,
0.290612131357193,
1.0612878799438477,
-0.6247918605804443,
0.971854567527771,
-0.39012375473976135,
-1.2379400730133057,
0.5377246737480164,
-0.5104440450668335,
0.008946448564529419,
0.46553465723991394,
0.03651321679353714,
-0.635772705078125,
-0.04153724014759064,
-0.28152504563331604,
-0.8508752584457397,
0.27726995944976807,
-0.0016432751435786486,
-0.07620280981063843,
-0.24332670867443085,
0.6798772215843201,
0.5192613005638123,
0.28543516993522644,
-0.26217547059059143,
-0.23768486082553864,
-0.0935661643743515,
-0.48137426376342773,
0.19719067215919495,
-0.2666345536708832,
0.043273694813251495,
-0.3452480137348175,
0.49962133169174194,
-0.04504842683672905,
0.24024075269699097,
0.572181224822998,
-0.04554681479930878,
0.2886422872543335,
0.32062819600105286,
0.7328944206237793,
0.6720824837684631,
-0.2664458453655243,
-0.0775880217552185,
-0.14681142568588257,
-0.563092052936554,
0.3483103811740875,
0.0147474966943264,
-0.20907407999038696,
0.1971711963415146,
0.8380588293075562,
0.8184453248977661,
-0.31409981846809387,
-0.36611300706863403,
0.329765647649765,
0.08245082199573517,
0.024411555379629135,
0.04303364083170891,
-0.29741019010543823,
-0.4510031044483185,
0.24121059477329254,
0.7061163187026978,
0.017922280356287956,
0.21087253093719482,
-0.5553624629974365,
0.2952941358089447,
-0.17051897943019867,
-0.1654527187347412,
-0.3715047240257263,
0.3101000487804413,
0.45158249139785767,
-0.6233482360839844,
0.6843544244766235,
-0.3119174540042877,
-0.9761649370193481,
0.5415739417076111,
0.8772111535072327,
0.7601359486579895,
-0.3823705017566681,
-0.07257071882486343,
0.20939233899116516,
0.2051905393600464,
-0.05555456131696701,
0.5299696326255798,
-0.0022923697251826525,
-0.3838208019733429,
-0.3774271607398987,
-0.5288642048835754,
-0.46402597427368164,
-0.17071306705474854,
-0.8825264573097229,
0.242969810962677,
-0.20368240773677826,
-0.14968687295913696,
-0.5004443526268005,
-0.004057653713971376,
-0.20652419328689575,
0.42064398527145386,
-0.06414539366960526,
1.1278184652328491,
-0.806934654712677,
0.7560819983482361,
0.7038105726242065,
-0.06746374070644379,
-1.0266541242599487,
0.5898938179016113,
-0.3494454324245453,
-0.8753827214241028,
0.8545311689376831,
0.07688935101032257,
-0.06384008377790451,
0.22093844413757324,
-0.11253438889980316,
-0.3647558093070984,
0.8454189896583557,
0.21847236156463623,
-0.756571352481842,
0.04090528562664986,
0.2942335903644562,
0.4711630344390869,
-0.06944199651479721,
-0.0860011875629425,
0.6103811860084534,
0.5881810188293457,
0.1604510247707367,
-1.0433436632156372,
-0.21589329838752747,
0.007690041791647673,
0.031008360907435417,
0.25044456124305725,
-0.7408945560455322,
0.6880720257759094,
0.022187499329447746,
-0.11339455097913742,
0.18398497998714447,
0.5732743740081787,
0.18865132331848145,
0.0926627665758133,
0.3731019198894501,
0.265151709318161,
0.9834266304969788,
-0.16456016898155212,
0.8131542801856995,
-0.3184983432292938,
0.2633976340293884,
0.792742908000946,
-0.571387767791748,
0.7750973701477051,
0.556732177734375,
-0.23058541119098663,
0.18868620693683624,
0.8054047226905823,
0.05752555653452873,
0.9466239213943481,
0.46527618169784546,
-0.3067573010921478,
-0.005888653453439474,
-0.424317330121994,
-0.18927611410617828,
0.9771077036857605,
0.14262501895427704,
0.18319205939769745,
0.0003163578803651035,
0.05103430896997452,
-0.25001513957977295,
0.3482491075992584,
-0.4079361855983734,
0.6501014828681946,
-0.2154797911643982,
-0.5786097049713135,
0.4643112123012543,
-0.043335314840078354,
0.8084448575973511,
-0.6375411748886108,
-0.23215076327323914,
-0.7599963545799255,
0.324056476354599,
0.032552432268857956,
-0.38572052121162415,
0.34732311964035034,
-0.0718613713979721,
-0.3127475082874298,
-0.2608560025691986,
0.2768568992614746,
-0.7048447728157043,
-0.3525415360927582,
0.11550342291593552,
0.3879738748073578,
0.0409650020301342,
0.3006902039051056,
-0.10970056802034378,
0.18781687319278717,
0.14007404446601868,
0.20932991802692413,
-0.035661693662405014,
0.6948577761650085,
-0.20391851663589478,
0.4286240041255951,
0.15280626714229584,
0.6985741257667542,
0.19726061820983887,
0.1257864385843277,
0.25357332825660706,
-0.6245983839035034,
-0.7955029606819153,
-0.7722287774085999,
0.3654102385044098,
0.26128914952278137,
-0.4613766372203827,
0.549068808555603,
0.5044214725494385,
0.7756776809692383,
-0.16502122581005096,
1.0379674434661865,
-0.04223174974322319,
0.6659231781959534,
-0.6476149559020996,
0.662172257900238,
-0.3937717378139496,
-0.02087232656776905,
0.004506437573581934,
-0.713030219078064,
-0.4304231107234955,
0.5127158761024475,
0.0071218120865523815,
0.039420273154973984,
0.6280183792114258,
0.7114459276199341,
0.01651332713663578,
-0.02483835071325302,
0.16547971963882446,
0.1260208636522293,
0.41315698623657227,
0.1566910445690155,
0.6009920835494995,
-0.39125755429267883,
0.1424015462398529,
-0.1370893269777298,
-0.26236671209335327,
-0.10250512510538101,
-0.7074277400970459,
-0.7278724312782288,
-0.8678761720657349,
0.10376732051372528,
-0.10057005286216736,
0.4076625406742096,
1.054132342338562,
0.6976012587547302,
-0.7781980633735657,
-0.2942708134651184,
0.2856093645095825,
0.14801953732967377,
-0.4163375198841095,
-0.1896781027317047,
0.7214557528495789,
0.0577445924282074,
-1.0201927423477173,
0.4644266963005066,
0.16994930803775787,
0.21763284504413605,
-0.011761784553527832,
0.348553329706192,
-0.3529634475708008,
0.003485467517748475,
0.3413057327270508,
-0.05603910982608795,
-0.5885718464851379,
-0.5230084657669067,
0.0076747555285692215,
0.024522289633750916,
0.2103971689939499,
1.1082770824432373,
-0.5122093558311462,
0.4146568477153778,
0.5244088768959045,
0.6426644921302795,
0.10831510275602341,
0.3409901261329651,
0.6125040054321289,
-1.2600200176239014,
0.2805153727531433,
0.16352041065692902,
0.27774330973625183,
0.5470731854438782,
-0.26412293314933777,
0.49765706062316895,
0.49773046374320984,
-0.3276377320289612,
-1.0818454027175903,
0.15702702105045319,
-0.8554297685623169,
-0.11034496873617172,
1.0192058086395264,
-0.10543442517518997,
-0.1312088668346405,
-0.233153834939003,
-0.6467527151107788,
0.48377278447151184,
-0.39795562624931335,
0.9014756679534912,
0.8269550800323486,
-0.024423856288194656,
0.21176965534687042,
0.01048419252038002,
0.29566648602485657,
0.4192977845668793,
-0.2984645664691925,
0.49310702085494995,
0.11961877346038818,
0.08491118997335434,
0.1209828183054924,
0.5172597765922546,
0.2278035581111908,
-0.10112964361906052,
0.19295033812522888,
0.15981940925121307,
-0.1066884770989418,
-0.6092555522918701,
-0.7676562070846558,
0.1779567450284958,
-0.024704616516828537,
-0.5499087572097778
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17385v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17385v1
|
ELLEN: Extremely Lightly Supervised Learning For Efficient Named Entity Recognition
| 2024-03-26T05:11:51 | 2024-03-26T05:11:51 |
Haris Riaz, Razvan-Gabriel Dumitru, Mihai Surdeanu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this work, we revisit the problem of semi-supervised named entity
recognition (NER) focusing on extremely light supervision, consisting of a
lexicon containing only 10 examples per class. We introduce ELLEN, a simple,
fully modular, neuro-symbolic method that blends fine-tuned language models
with linguistic rules. These rules include insights such as ''One Sense Per
Discourse'', using a Masked Language Model as an unsupervised NER, leveraging
part-of-speech tags to identify and eliminate unlabeled entities as false
negatives, and other intuitions about classifier confidence scores in local and
global context. ELLEN achieves very strong performance on the CoNLL-2003
dataset when using the minimal supervision from the lexicon above. It also
outperforms most existing (and considerably more complex) semi-supervised NER
methods under the same supervision settings commonly used in the literature
(i.e., 5% of the training data). Further, we evaluate our CoNLL-2003 model in a
zero-shot scenario on WNUT-17 where we find that it outperforms GPT-3.5 and
achieves comparable performance to GPT-4. In a zero-shot setting, ELLEN also
achieves over 75% of the performance of a strong, fully supervised model
trained on gold data. Our code is available at:
https://github.com/hriaz17/ELLEN.
|
[
-0.004212900530546904,
-0.9090919494628906,
0.6642417311668396,
0.1935378462076187,
-0.14513911306858063,
-0.12678371369838715,
-0.30418315529823303,
-0.841850996017456,
0.1440131813287735,
0.34932997822761536,
0.008506717160344124,
-0.657126247882843,
-0.658957839012146,
0.2669241726398468,
-0.8877782821655273,
1.2399617433547974,
0.3963974416255951,
0.02506876178085804,
0.1699761301279068,
0.02143789455294609,
0.1556410938501358,
-0.3725229799747467,
-0.9999365210533142,
-0.35735487937927246,
0.45094922184944153,
0.3576608896255493,
0.46242302656173706,
0.47255027294158936,
0.29175126552581787,
0.2055778205394745,
-0.466522216796875,
0.1844182163476944,
-0.5993713736534119,
-0.4896862804889679,
0.03868699446320534,
-0.19183054566383362,
-0.603388786315918,
-0.0539107471704483,
0.4569065570831299,
0.9354225397109985,
-0.2850989103317261,
0.1670265644788742,
0.12655971944332123,
0.07677436619997025,
-0.5783252716064453,
0.09485603123903275,
-0.9286717176437378,
0.19557525217533112,
-0.3055180609226227,
0.14436125755310059,
-0.8172053098678589,
0.30645301938056946,
0.2771300673484802,
-0.8150666952133179,
0.5275350213050842,
0.26965510845184326,
1.2237895727157593,
0.09418807923793793,
-0.43605777621269226,
0.14292657375335693,
-0.930210292339325,
0.8524878621101379,
-0.36668482422828674,
0.20651191473007202,
0.13803963363170624,
0.005281777121126652,
-0.040997229516506195,
-0.8451512455940247,
-0.6056934595108032,
-0.17449399828910828,
0.03536461293697357,
-0.029285157099366188,
-0.7923384308815002,
0.3121188282966614,
0.4698801338672638,
0.19445154070854187,
-0.15169313549995422,
0.2172265648841858,
-0.6661823987960815,
-0.023449357599020004,
0.5684036612510681,
-0.24833525717258453,
0.058041833341121674,
-0.24841277301311493,
-0.7252196073532104,
0.24844379723072052,
-0.6247415542602539,
-0.03529677540063858,
0.3184942901134491,
0.2718507945537567,
-0.20190566778182983,
0.3631019592285156,
-0.07617399096488953,
0.8265727162361145,
0.13323907554149628,
0.12243316322565079,
0.2134099304676056,
0.3823063373565674,
-0.3474174439907074,
0.2995109558105469,
0.7733591794967651,
0.18162685632705688,
0.41936513781547546,
-0.42574000358581543,
-0.3916662633419037,
0.2381899207830429,
0.1864132583141327,
-0.380652517080307,
-0.7485924363136292,
-0.3063740134239197,
-0.4076297879219055,
-0.5595932602882385,
0.04025505110621452,
-0.5350030660629272,
-0.32265374064445496,
-0.4238836169242859,
0.7503176331520081,
-0.2139778435230255,
-0.06356197595596313,
0.023982899263501167,
-0.1049521416425705,
0.202392116189003,
0.7201269268989563,
-0.7157950401306152,
0.6592191457748413,
0.5719935297966003,
0.5440459847450256,
-0.2653118073940277,
-0.0598112978041172,
-0.9396316409111023,
0.1617988795042038,
-0.43084147572517395,
0.556631863117218,
-0.5852667093276978,
-0.08864154666662216,
-0.2532212734222412,
0.15491004288196564,
0.2381591498851776,
-0.5636526942253113,
0.4769214391708374,
-0.4587763547897339,
-0.2480350285768509,
0.2477789670228958,
-0.690010130405426,
-0.29935383796691895,
0.010374218225479126,
-0.5768762826919556,
1.1001086235046387,
-0.1341247260570526,
-0.7180271744728088,
0.4077622890472412,
-0.2782658338546753,
-0.5127361416816711,
0.16404321789741516,
-0.2836862802505493,
-0.18402792513370514,
0.4270738661289215,
0.01118491217494011,
0.8509193062782288,
-0.08521834760904312,
0.5445066094398499,
-0.23566244542598724,
-0.32863205671310425,
-0.14726759493350983,
-0.4414716362953186,
0.501876950263977,
-0.3315944969654083,
-0.4513635039329529,
0.016971003264188766,
-1.4127388000488281,
-0.20804308354854584,
0.1944139450788498,
-0.11569051444530487,
-0.6798557043075562,
-0.20267803966999054,
0.4297756850719452,
0.0445273220539093,
0.050604209303855896,
-0.7199215888977051,
-0.11197010427713394,
-0.18392615020275116,
0.1994127333164215,
0.8127151131629944,
-0.13492520153522491,
0.4981449544429779,
0.10614147782325745,
0.26059579849243164,
-0.12522664666175842,
0.22708041965961456,
0.1936168223619461,
-0.649732768535614,
-1.0236592292785645,
-0.1958630532026291,
0.6731643676757812,
0.5265309810638428,
-0.5318872928619385,
0.28928476572036743,
0.007164692971855402,
-0.5212581753730774,
-0.6596947312355042,
0.3153286278247833,
0.6199513673782349,
0.9874023795127869,
0.7749049663543701,
0.019322428852319717,
-0.3621559143066406,
-1.1738048791885376,
-0.09534107148647308,
0.0020331924315541983,
0.05039522051811218,
0.355857789516449,
0.6250945329666138,
0.004185291938483715,
0.4895700216293335,
-0.575332760810852,
-0.3070305585861206,
-0.3481113314628601,
0.41654062271118164,
0.38271787762641907,
0.46277451515197754,
0.27665841579437256,
-0.8601050972938538,
-0.5147401094436646,
0.03551926091313362,
-0.9697358012199402,
0.05451079457998276,
-0.056813549250364304,
0.06100981682538986,
-0.07922355085611343,
0.6332272887229919,
-0.45558756589889526,
0.7145825624465942,
0.40023961663246155,
-0.027972398325800896,
0.16837722063064575,
-0.20479220151901245,
-0.5415348410606384,
-0.7502028942108154,
0.051570501178503036,
0.17348504066467285,
-0.5532535910606384,
-0.707945704460144,
-0.17797698080539703,
0.25316545367240906,
-0.10095075517892838,
-0.6156922578811646,
0.6796073317527771,
-0.7915926575660706,
0.32116031646728516,
-0.23897509276866913,
-0.010148187167942524,
-0.14133195579051971,
0.42612069845199585,
0.2940872609615326,
0.31299373507499695,
1.0261578559875488,
-0.8609426021575928,
0.33099305629730225,
0.23257246613502502,
-0.29200804233551025,
0.5943645238876343,
-0.9159902930259705,
0.1397290974855423,
-0.3127073049545288,
0.05087973177433014,
-0.5384015440940857,
-0.031018875539302826,
-0.04885970428586006,
-0.10992640256881714,
0.751632034778595,
-0.34394699335098267,
-0.31847426295280457,
-0.032267726957798004,
-0.15806829929351807,
0.28524380922317505,
0.5863034129142761,
-0.7706230282783508,
0.6409468650817871,
0.5033954977989197,
0.18459199368953705,
-0.5964691638946533,
-0.7281218767166138,
0.29750534892082214,
-0.1691838502883911,
-0.30019688606262207,
0.703326404094696,
0.2542124092578888,
-0.26921194791793823,
0.29696300625801086,
-0.36683905124664307,
0.13745303452014923,
-0.02655387669801712,
0.2736234962940216,
0.28674131631851196,
0.053647033870220184,
0.19215315580368042,
-0.02099301666021347,
-0.3941936194896698,
-0.2356787770986557,
-0.18648521602153778,
0.11989220231771469,
-0.10491738468408585,
-0.016483880579471588,
-0.5473601818084717,
0.3353816866874695,
-0.0854971781373024,
-0.09344366937875748,
0.8221836090087891,
0.5148394107818604,
-0.8490755558013916,
-0.7511507868766785,
-0.584152102470398,
-0.20635072886943817,
-0.3908928334712982,
0.1214771419763565,
-0.22796045243740082,
-0.8158575892448425,
0.4004746079444885,
-0.045777928084135056,
-0.18834783136844635,
0.42430606484413147,
-0.16338728368282318,
-0.16614098846912384,
0.8515258431434631,
1.1210963726043701,
-0.21036392450332642,
0.3558838665485382,
-0.3712400496006012,
0.3686699867248535,
-0.9882725477218628,
-0.3171564042568207,
-0.22122283279895782,
-0.5223208069801331,
-0.5300622582435608,
-0.35936057567596436,
0.37949302792549133,
0.1713932901620865,
0.17043600976467133,
0.449919730424881,
-0.553888738155365,
0.4637777805328369,
0.5201421976089478,
0.1377154290676117,
0.32062771916389465,
-0.18406111001968384,
-0.013057579286396503,
0.038705457001924515,
-0.4865148365497589,
-0.6123479008674622,
1.1479014158248901,
0.1360866129398346,
1.1115429401397705,
-0.2133190929889679,
0.9815925359725952,
0.37641987204551697,
0.262544184923172,
-0.5922486782073975,
0.7546452879905701,
-0.2211773842573166,
-0.6031830310821533,
0.015872960910201073,
-0.5643731951713562,
-0.9211827516555786,
0.05843416601419449,
-0.2107909619808197,
-0.9623426795005798,
0.19949229061603546,
0.23196640610694885,
-0.5970495939254761,
0.4003945291042328,
-0.6679033041000366,
0.835997462272644,
-0.2526908218860626,
-0.2671615183353424,
-0.018859418109059334,
-0.909037709236145,
0.20031903684139252,
-0.1494084745645523,
-0.020847132429480553,
-0.199171245098114,
-0.11606743931770325,
0.9047670364379883,
-0.04118724912405014,
0.8380228281021118,
-0.17715756595134735,
0.09487994015216827,
0.09086193889379501,
-0.043510809540748596,
0.7537198066711426,
0.23183517158031464,
0.13961726427078247,
0.33674660325050354,
-0.33793094754219055,
-0.2446071207523346,
-0.23803828656673431,
0.8039311170578003,
-0.5204605460166931,
-0.30564865469932556,
-0.6202326416969299,
-0.181246817111969,
-0.009067017585039139,
0.2702854871749878,
0.3892934024333954,
0.3927491307258606,
-0.3131764829158783,
0.22893770039081573,
1.0868483781814575,
-0.1374903917312622,
0.3615278899669647,
0.5546239614486694,
-0.31533607840538025,
0.006587063428014517,
0.812667191028595,
0.306671142578125,
0.04519180580973625,
0.7353342771530151,
-0.12932147085666656,
0.06481977552175522,
-0.432181179523468,
-0.16763776540756226,
0.32488754391670227,
-0.6098399758338928,
-0.37368613481521606,
-1.0806971788406372,
-0.15770909190177917,
0.11952050030231476,
-0.10670386999845505,
-0.3880309462547302,
-0.5774916410446167,
-0.6573955416679382,
-0.4417705237865448,
0.23761795461177826,
0.8135712146759033,
0.08787766844034195,
0.41416695713996887,
-0.46590158343315125,
0.6221120357513428,
0.3094021677970886,
-0.1741151362657547,
-0.0469374805688858,
-0.5506426095962524,
0.21524620056152344,
-0.4669772982597351,
-0.13153007626533508,
-1.057274341583252,
0.05734926834702492,
0.48887795209884644,
0.38472428917884827,
0.6732786297798157,
0.0515851229429245,
0.649171769618988,
-0.7064362168312073,
0.4885086119174957,
0.08847609907388687,
-0.9347677230834961,
0.6001410484313965,
-0.23921725153923035,
-0.3708887994289398,
0.569969117641449,
0.22508926689624786,
-0.24099165201187134,
-0.2258867770433426,
-1.32076895236969,
-1.1187669038772583,
0.7977102398872375,
0.12227702885866165,
0.3526992201805115,
-0.13158202171325684,
0.218509703874588,
0.022516993805766106,
0.48739755153656006,
-0.9409990906715393,
-0.24753129482269287,
0.6005871295928955,
-0.06281287223100662,
0.10677393525838852,
-0.14052024483680725,
-0.06689468026161194,
-0.41867002844810486,
1.0988991260528564,
-0.1510460525751114,
0.1298302561044693,
0.02209492027759552,
-0.1360097974538803,
-0.04612192511558533,
0.21322090923786163,
-0.004433124791830778,
0.5050620436668396,
-0.05700851231813431,
0.5295181274414062,
0.5599203109741211,
0.05942952260375023,
-0.20159867405891418,
0.49453622102737427,
-0.5826427936553955,
0.32298094034194946,
0.4855209290981293,
0.747666597366333,
0.6533355116844177,
-0.32125550508499146,
0.7689030766487122,
-0.060256682336330414,
0.08518083393573761,
-0.3488623797893524,
0.05993801727890968,
0.0358731709420681,
0.16214437782764435,
0.30789509415626526,
0.3186120390892029,
0.26770079135894775,
-0.29703426361083984,
0.1580488383769989,
0.5237454175949097,
-0.5274983048439026,
-0.6715801358222961,
0.8721917271614075,
0.004680706653743982,
0.012344916351139545,
0.6794927716255188,
-0.6364429593086243,
-0.30721086263656616,
0.45113784074783325,
0.6661041378974915,
0.6565791368484497,
-0.17453429102897644,
0.32488569617271423,
0.16750852763652802,
0.3334519565105438,
-0.31114745140075684,
0.4924556314945221,
-0.20970484614372253,
-0.6341837644577026,
-0.11675720661878586,
-0.8513365983963013,
-0.2195127010345459,
0.4029718339443207,
-0.6777156591415405,
0.6201566457748413,
-0.5599206686019897,
-0.19064971804618835,
0.5838996767997742,
-0.42972177267074585,
-0.7671241760253906,
0.27410513162612915,
0.3368792235851288,
0.9563668966293335,
-1.0882014036178589,
0.5448723435401917,
1.0355679988861084,
-0.3160880506038666,
-1.1713429689407349,
-0.16940687596797943,
0.08856160193681717,
-0.6679115891456604,
0.3048088252544403,
0.3630330264568329,
-0.0338895283639431,
0.24877631664276123,
-0.755779504776001,
-0.5273839235305786,
0.8052257299423218,
0.6035540699958801,
-0.683295488357544,
-0.14796525239944458,
-0.5798290371894836,
0.5669082999229431,
-0.11949947476387024,
0.029870958998799324,
0.18327942490577698,
0.26327669620513916,
-0.1510154753923416,
-0.8871007561683655,
-0.22825953364372253,
-0.4108186662197113,
-0.06751707941293716,
0.4451867341995239,
-0.7106755375862122,
0.6231516599655151,
-0.32783207297325134,
-0.07230190932750702,
-0.029453348368406296,
0.8906363844871521,
0.012225592508912086,
0.5819694399833679,
0.4191061854362488,
0.9648227691650391,
1.1088495254516602,
-0.09039147943258286,
0.9211191534996033,
-0.04571951553225517,
0.5047314763069153,
1.1479891538619995,
-0.351097047328949,
0.8788378238677979,
0.6310896873474121,
-0.09499211609363556,
0.19924227893352509,
0.3266330063343048,
-0.30917516350746155,
0.5463218092918396,
0.24508662521839142,
-0.5109438896179199,
-0.5068650245666504,
-0.6376559138298035,
-0.13048744201660156,
0.54990553855896,
0.004050697200000286,
-0.4460105895996094,
-0.2729162573814392,
0.21329525113105774,
0.424169659614563,
0.009802468121051788,
-0.33325910568237305,
0.7399919033050537,
0.4549296200275421,
-0.28804320096969604,
0.1640687882900238,
0.20478598773479462,
0.7010454535484314,
-0.5343851447105408,
-0.3014064431190491,
0.19575782120227814,
0.44343093037605286,
-0.5562524795532227,
-0.47180745005607605,
-0.21420134603977203,
0.5249047875404358,
-0.16969536244869232,
-0.08634603023529053,
0.8163406252861023,
-0.4726239740848541,
-0.8120234608650208,
0.7056747078895569,
0.37307432293891907,
0.373289555311203,
-0.016577009111642838,
-0.3311249315738678,
-0.3018440306186676,
-0.19266681373119354,
-0.2506698966026306,
0.1788332611322403,
0.6611193418502808,
-0.20449449121952057,
0.3048557937145233,
0.5114174485206604,
0.27928584814071655,
0.2242634892463684,
0.24027281999588013,
0.7948169708251953,
-0.436945378780365,
-0.39928334951400757,
-0.8455793261528015,
0.38876697421073914,
-0.21172791719436646,
-0.4610680043697357,
0.6443610191345215,
0.7680706977844238,
1.1040948629379272,
-0.037843700498342514,
0.43363747000694275,
-0.23831330239772797,
0.25202223658561707,
-0.39291372895240784,
0.4809258282184601,
-0.6809742450714111,
0.1765565425157547,
-0.5188254117965698,
-0.9700047373771667,
-0.47644463181495667,
0.6795434951782227,
-0.20854440331459045,
0.10735580325126648,
0.5050215721130371,
0.6952840089797974,
-0.7047837376594543,
0.11175309121608734,
0.39130455255508423,
0.22709311544895172,
0.1024906262755394,
0.46652713418006897,
0.9252296686172485,
-0.4316350817680359,
0.3937162160873413,
-0.3962688148021698,
-0.27623340487480164,
0.033275771886110306,
-0.9936773777008057,
-0.8219965100288391,
-0.294731467962265,
-0.5951807498931885,
0.032440461218357086,
0.019864819943904877,
0.8349723219871521,
0.9670377969741821,
-0.861247181892395,
0.3238923251628876,
-0.14673678576946259,
-0.016565194353461266,
-0.3243263065814972,
-0.19980116188526154,
0.4743802547454834,
-0.03267461061477661,
-0.6939786672592163,
0.7370988130569458,
0.32985320687294006,
-0.20283547043800354,
0.3157314360141754,
0.04620371758937836,
-0.4119037389755249,
-0.21006260812282562,
0.23106345534324646,
0.05962958186864853,
-0.5652402639389038,
-0.21394023299217224,
-0.17905482649803162,
0.11871901154518127,
-0.15622593462467194,
0.2417759746313095,
-0.7230740189552307,
0.5204349756240845,
0.1095590814948082,
0.5600469708442688,
0.777935266494751,
0.09845131635665894,
-0.03826739266514778,
-1.027396321296692,
-0.0400344617664814,
0.43845540285110474,
0.4705863296985626,
0.5480659604072571,
-0.5916476845741272,
0.6874151825904846,
0.35052332282066345,
-0.4185967445373535,
-0.9691156148910522,
-0.07006042450666428,
-1.1915704011917114,
0.24581414461135864,
1.1650031805038452,
-0.16288962960243225,
-0.2592749297618866,
0.07757691293954849,
-0.015360216610133648,
0.234889417886734,
-0.6528398990631104,
0.5510573983192444,
0.51917564868927,
-0.3899659812450409,
-0.14623455703258514,
-0.9404508471488953,
0.33529478311538696,
0.4411168694496155,
-0.590194046497345,
-0.17491768300533295,
0.3138008713722229,
0.35436880588531494,
0.2930741608142853,
0.5161725878715515,
0.03606075793504715,
0.2358608990907669,
-0.23612017929553986,
0.10059456527233124,
-0.06845663487911224,
-0.9871669411659241,
-0.45391640067100525,
0.2744322717189789,
0.01850205846130848,
-0.1809893250465393
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17368v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17368v1
|
ChatGPT Rates Natural Language Explanation Quality Like Humans: But on Which Scales?
| 2024-03-26T04:07:08 | 2024-03-26T04:07:08 |
Fan Huang, Haewoon Kwak, Kunwoo Park, Jisun An
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
As AI becomes more integral in our lives, the need for transparency and
responsibility grows. While natural language explanations (NLEs) are vital for
clarifying the reasoning behind AI decisions, evaluating them through human
judgments is complex and resource-intensive due to subjectivity and the need
for fine-grained ratings. This study explores the alignment between ChatGPT and
human assessments across multiple scales (i.e., binary, ternary, and 7-Likert
scale). We sample 300 data instances from three NLE datasets and collect 900
human annotations for both informativeness and clarity scores as the text
quality measurement. We further conduct paired comparison experiments under
different ranges of subjectivity scores, where the baseline comes from 8,346
human annotations. Our results show that ChatGPT aligns better with humans in
more coarse-grained scales. Also, paired comparisons and dynamic prompting
(i.e., providing semantically similar examples in the prompt) improve the
alignment. This research advances our understanding of large language models'
capabilities to assess the text explanation quality in different configurations
for responsible AI development.
|
[
-0.3565829396247864,
-0.7966419458389282,
0.4203880727291107,
0.33391526341438293,
-0.16541902720928192,
-0.08211261034011841,
-0.5222168564796448,
-0.6470199823379517,
-0.31308919191360474,
0.16084353625774384,
-0.4129015803337097,
-0.25193852186203003,
-0.6357287764549255,
0.14769583940505981,
-0.11514801532030106,
1.3655486106872559,
-0.03898606821894646,
0.016834506765007973,
-0.13027890026569366,
-0.20510420203208923,
-0.7141836285591125,
-0.23123273253440857,
-0.9956318140029907,
-0.48907819390296936,
0.6793305277824402,
0.3244725465774536,
1.2347545623779297,
0.6849020719528198,
0.8290882706642151,
0.32389357686042786,
-0.14798712730407715,
0.07494377344846725,
-0.2877247631549835,
0.011193223297595978,
-0.13400085270404816,
-0.20352225005626678,
-0.7000008225440979,
0.2296222746372223,
0.3429999351501465,
0.726312518119812,
-0.04272563382983208,
0.1871509999036789,
0.4511336088180542,
0.685764729976654,
-0.22449451684951782,
0.2774350345134735,
-0.2048424780368805,
-0.057194486260414124,
0.2581290602684021,
-0.07224473357200623,
-0.25075018405914307,
-0.42033928632736206,
0.634925365447998,
-0.6726652383804321,
0.31523045897483826,
0.1470184326171875,
0.9249187707901001,
0.605006217956543,
-0.37122872471809387,
-0.303975373506546,
-0.6984653472900391,
0.6882491111755371,
-0.7371160387992859,
0.17763349413871765,
0.2186318039894104,
0.3333376348018646,
0.033501364290714264,
-0.43406733870506287,
-0.6579532027244568,
-0.22684289515018463,
-0.39521583914756775,
0.04830223321914673,
-0.23954695463180542,
0.21047668159008026,
0.08146139234304428,
0.42452335357666016,
-0.9267643690109253,
0.30312636494636536,
-0.23908762633800507,
-0.5063924789428711,
0.7618395686149597,
-0.05859396234154701,
0.4113711714744568,
-0.3109358251094818,
-0.4929952025413513,
-0.23271967470645905,
-0.351575642824173,
0.3192964196205139,
0.3316723704338074,
0.2991543412208557,
-0.2502603232860565,
0.5198208689689636,
-0.0438464917242527,
0.7910600900650024,
0.021916624158620834,
0.06893262267112732,
0.005053119268268347,
-0.5490496754646301,
-0.20172026753425598,
0.2664332091808319,
1.1201117038726807,
0.7603967785835266,
0.5860951542854309,
-0.21490976214408875,
0.0028380993753671646,
0.1821080595254898,
0.3561442792415619,
-0.6429638266563416,
-0.061997659504413605,
0.24536707997322083,
-0.5140557885169983,
-0.2102474719285965,
0.04776322469115257,
-0.6448675394058228,
-0.7152054905891418,
-0.6468899846076965,
0.5222689509391785,
-0.48663491010665894,
-0.18760955333709717,
0.15641777217388153,
-0.1300642192363739,
0.37448224425315857,
0.3951757550239563,
-0.8941255211830139,
0.15830554068088531,
0.8183825612068176,
0.5574659705162048,
-0.11495077610015869,
-0.3193622827529907,
-0.32547080516815186,
-0.27115947008132935,
-0.17532411217689514,
0.8532696962356567,
-0.5030806064605713,
-0.009116468019783497,
-0.3771255612373352,
-0.36005255579948425,
-0.08255328238010406,
-0.19654886424541473,
1.0527297258377075,
-0.14238673448562622,
0.7014941573143005,
-0.21485546231269836,
-0.4268476665019989,
-0.4532928168773651,
0.4033319056034088,
-0.3944384753704071,
0.986992597579956,
-0.07906022667884827,
-0.704784095287323,
0.6855278611183167,
-0.9531717300415039,
-0.14601875841617584,
0.017688823863863945,
-0.08954928070306778,
-0.171140655875206,
-0.04562586545944214,
0.4936651289463043,
0.4493147134780884,
-0.24882584810256958,
0.5673685073852539,
0.11756966263055801,
-0.4259992241859436,
0.5578554272651672,
-0.9246434569358826,
0.513913094997406,
0.03384282439947128,
-0.4415249824523926,
0.2552017271518707,
-0.4958983361721039,
0.20545439422130585,
-0.20179471373558044,
-0.14299578964710236,
-0.1620473563671112,
0.14009548723697662,
-0.07344017922878265,
0.1275697499513626,
0.36558768153190613,
-0.38261982798576355,
0.05471448227763176,
-0.4992338716983795,
0.7133510708808899,
0.56634920835495,
-0.00026930056628771126,
0.3881368637084961,
-0.31573203206062317,
0.3168480694293976,
-0.23789380490779877,
0.2988220155239105,
0.030509471893310547,
-0.8091543912887573,
-0.34408828616142273,
-0.2354038804769516,
0.20751240849494934,
0.3860887885093689,
0.07714669406414032,
0.6225348711013794,
-0.6332370042800903,
-0.4944421350955963,
-0.7824389934539795,
-0.21759961545467377,
0.46061912178993225,
0.531819224357605,
0.29442688822746277,
-0.2463429719209671,
-0.12091019749641418,
-0.9756158590316772,
-0.6113811731338501,
-0.5232470035552979,
-0.34459754824638367,
0.2631371319293976,
0.17301928997039795,
-0.04517355188727379,
1.2215662002563477,
-0.1191723421216011,
0.006536081433296204,
-0.0500822588801384,
0.6097542643547058,
0.08894741535186768,
0.366576224565506,
0.25714415311813354,
-1.0585954189300537,
-0.32292190194129944,
0.06633437424898148,
-0.47868213057518005,
-0.1821342557668686,
-0.24740096926689148,
-0.1220138892531395,
0.08543457090854645,
0.17479689419269562,
-0.5326276421546936,
0.3483677804470062,
0.6241816878318787,
-0.5434759855270386,
0.4128422737121582,
-0.3068881332874298,
0.46039697527885437,
-0.7833729982376099,
0.1423969715833664,
0.001549795619212091,
-0.21877363324165344,
-0.6928086876869202,
-0.1388493925333023,
-0.07555501908063889,
-0.13475053012371063,
0.018395667895674706,
0.5416428446769714,
-0.24516203999519348,
-0.1875647008419037,
-0.08509425818920135,
0.7132366895675659,
0.40277019143104553,
0.4467070400714874,
0.005314996000379324,
0.9500420689582825,
0.27600646018981934,
-0.31981179118156433,
0.12453944236040115,
0.17232121527194977,
-0.048835210502147675,
0.629777729511261,
-0.9446125626564026,
0.11591988801956177,
-0.23344926536083221,
0.22605334222316742,
-1.2833173274993896,
-0.29983752965927124,
0.215430349111557,
-0.8998498320579529,
0.08998595923185349,
0.018681805580854416,
-0.49519598484039307,
-0.06415385007858276,
-0.2961121201515198,
0.34953001141548157,
0.3928118348121643,
-0.2704743444919586,
0.4084256589412689,
0.08088239282369614,
-0.10364226251840591,
-0.48310819268226624,
-0.5693483352661133,
0.14854370057582855,
-0.3908945620059967,
-0.8646938800811768,
0.23466013371944427,
-0.1143011674284935,
-0.44602733850479126,
-0.008008310571312904,
-0.23758083581924438,
-0.254675954580307,
0.1552131474018097,
0.32425767183303833,
0.23420891165733337,
-0.5419175028800964,
0.24185004830360413,
-0.24680183827877045,
-0.19103163480758667,
0.12255913764238358,
0.039581604301929474,
0.521605908870697,
-0.3922446668148041,
-0.3120321035385132,
-0.6434049010276794,
0.03728724643588066,
0.464358389377594,
-0.3397931158542633,
0.8266345858573914,
0.7806681990623474,
-0.1404215693473816,
0.5028197169303894,
-0.43770742416381836,
-0.19692611694335938,
-0.3985629081726074,
0.09109790623188019,
-0.11594356596469879,
-0.7745826244354248,
0.5266116261482239,
0.4139569401741028,
0.3434090316295624,
0.8291260600090027,
0.39339494705200195,
-0.18718181550502777,
1.1248282194137573,
0.2897945046424866,
-0.008992074988782406,
0.21306422352790833,
0.25936129689216614,
0.6384431719779968,
-0.7351279854774475,
-0.10552064329385757,
-0.6569905281066895,
-0.4087744951248169,
-0.9401856064796448,
-0.2562727630138397,
0.19646987318992615,
0.2592804431915283,
-0.4987534284591675,
0.28921425342559814,
-0.9053556323051453,
0.5820211172103882,
0.3192853033542633,
0.06654909998178482,
0.4138193130493164,
-0.13538850843906403,
0.4596494734287262,
-0.12937569618225098,
-0.427171528339386,
-1.011573076248169,
0.7094802260398865,
0.43868544697761536,
0.3580034673213959,
0.25380560755729675,
0.5079200267791748,
0.29265692830085754,
0.3269028067588806,
-0.866525411605835,
0.2462315559387207,
-0.1291147619485855,
-0.6446588635444641,
-0.7403501272201538,
-0.46845659613609314,
-1.105991005897522,
0.148384228348732,
-0.276822030544281,
-0.9526413083076477,
-0.16179731488227844,
0.24760401248931885,
-0.47132179141044617,
-0.1300673633813858,
-1.165374994277954,
1.097110629081726,
-0.03999870643019676,
-0.05897098034620285,
-0.2181752622127533,
-0.8760977983474731,
0.1775132566690445,
0.08607444912195206,
0.28566494584083557,
-0.3854874074459076,
0.009248635731637478,
0.7132293581962585,
-0.11194957047700882,
0.8495204448699951,
0.04940751940011978,
-0.08894245326519012,
0.25201648473739624,
-0.05140853300690651,
0.29398372769355774,
0.14205336570739746,
-0.19501689076423645,
0.24007949233055115,
-0.16250112652778625,
-0.412611722946167,
-0.8381134271621704,
0.47416090965270996,
-0.9456482529640198,
-0.48604461550712585,
-0.20227380096912384,
-0.5772032141685486,
-0.14975804090499878,
0.039762627333402634,
0.2890312075614929,
0.5647069811820984,
-0.11694289743900299,
0.03768542408943176,
0.5664894580841064,
-0.19557072222232819,
0.31340497732162476,
0.3451603651046753,
0.1480000764131546,
0.02208864316344261,
0.8262782096862793,
-0.2252408266067505,
0.45758160948753357,
0.4615415334701538,
0.5592994093894958,
-0.3549891710281372,
-0.35084855556488037,
-0.5406202673912048,
0.1283157765865326,
-0.41083264350891113,
-0.07470733672380447,
-0.4840301275253296,
-0.2671847343444824,
-0.2731912136077881,
-0.3074271082878113,
-0.1426226943731308,
-0.36471661925315857,
-0.10181574523448944,
0.025645140558481216,
0.4718109369277954,
0.6635099053382874,
0.09487783163785934,
0.5053628087043762,
-0.8103827238082886,
0.35972121357917786,
0.21671998500823975,
0.5172739624977112,
0.01978083699941635,
-0.6933508515357971,
0.2090863287448883,
0.415973961353302,
-0.19828784465789795,
-0.6277701258659363,
-0.07117731124162674,
0.22359710931777954,
0.34317517280578613,
0.501328706741333,
-0.04618602618575096,
0.7463487982749939,
-0.34618711471557617,
0.9934212565422058,
0.1034061536192894,
-0.9580092430114746,
0.3144415020942688,
-0.3835126459598541,
0.43567901849746704,
0.6202697157859802,
0.17054252326488495,
-1.0233638286590576,
-0.5837311744689941,
-0.5561813712120056,
-0.6808409690856934,
0.6915187239646912,
0.5728861093521118,
0.15736860036849976,
0.2458093762397766,
0.418154776096344,
0.37762370705604553,
-0.10568756610155106,
-0.7733838558197021,
-0.13682860136032104,
-0.16432401537895203,
-0.40975692868232727,
-0.1732092946767807,
-0.16445507109165192,
-0.09053054451942444,
0.14768025279045105,
0.3932311236858368,
-0.003732915036380291,
0.3822665214538574,
0.2668875455856323,
-0.026616396382451057,
0.07126510888338089,
0.5706308484077454,
0.6687033176422119,
0.7853794693946838,
-0.11941902339458466,
0.15062925219535828,
-0.2230968028306961,
-0.5048375725746155,
-0.03489616513252258,
0.16703999042510986,
0.18911105394363403,
-0.21791185438632965,
0.8904677629470825,
0.8489854335784912,
0.10241200774908066,
-0.5675196051597595,
0.5135599374771118,
-0.41894465684890747,
-0.0026170858182013035,
0.10783977061510086,
0.3074386715888977,
-0.04061348736286163,
0.0884309932589531,
0.17038790881633759,
0.11411644518375397,
0.21121256053447723,
-0.42433595657348633,
-0.11036612838506699,
0.22032132744789124,
-0.49297332763671875,
-0.33391693234443665,
0.5627046823501587,
0.2427685260772705,
-0.48649677634239197,
0.7707886695861816,
-0.24666814506053925,
-0.3915356695652008,
0.6314533352851868,
0.014863204210996628,
0.6937704086303711,
-0.011289995163679123,
0.4399428963661194,
0.3791828453540802,
0.4737454950809479,
-0.01688021793961525,
0.09735709428787231,
-0.08179595321416855,
-0.7543042302131653,
-0.8501335978507996,
-0.5082458853721619,
-0.49667078256607056,
-0.10434633493423462,
-0.6620009541511536,
0.06504977494478226,
0.03849290311336517,
0.017291724681854248,
0.5425490140914917,
0.05108640342950821,
-0.5797471404075623,
0.21145318448543549,
0.10854321718215942,
0.5411776900291443,
-0.7902172207832336,
0.2631639540195465,
0.6467984318733215,
-0.4200654923915863,
-1.154855489730835,
0.3702297508716583,
0.12765850126743317,
-0.8714612722396851,
0.4042719900608063,
0.584894061088562,
-0.07997448742389679,
-0.10923933237791061,
-0.40006697177886963,
-0.7096731662750244,
0.693517804145813,
0.3205083906650543,
-0.27326634526252747,
0.04126840457320213,
0.32508912682533264,
0.980946958065033,
0.04163859039545059,
0.4590746760368347,
0.7112066149711609,
0.7833431959152222,
-0.2816515862941742,
-1.1620571613311768,
-0.07581933587789536,
0.04551206901669502,
-0.3390617370605469,
0.4639037549495697,
-0.41830646991729736,
0.2988840341567993,
-0.07809707522392273,
-0.26988616585731506,
-0.1858462691307068,
0.45927494764328003,
0.03416517376899719,
0.38200080394744873,
0.5970780253410339,
0.1273861825466156,
0.6949062943458557,
-0.21059122681617737,
1.0410983562469482,
-0.044925007969141006,
0.2797773778438568,
1.0686062574386597,
0.13812334835529327,
0.5166468620300293,
0.43849417567253113,
-0.3216293454170227,
0.42297568917274475,
0.9336684346199036,
0.2258402556180954,
0.04085925593972206,
0.028361661359667778,
-0.0026942791882902384,
0.029635999351739883,
-0.26479315757751465,
-0.04006798937916756,
0.6121214628219604,
0.24199099838733673,
-0.21785612404346466,
-0.3305036723613739,
-0.15272822976112366,
0.10680583119392395,
0.14426876604557037,
-0.1921616494655609,
0.9960150122642517,
-0.1808612048625946,
-1.0261939764022827,
0.4024622142314911,
-0.1759229153394699,
0.2793293297290802,
-0.2695930302143097,
0.04996640980243683,
-0.37198472023010254,
-0.1421484500169754,
-0.3252868950366974,
-1.29635751247406,
0.37421634793281555,
0.18905983865261078,
-0.381038635969162,
-0.24228867888450623,
0.2881658971309662,
-0.4388338327407837,
-0.1757316291332245,
-0.011027037166059017,
0.30263739824295044,
0.4973430931568146,
-0.23523275554180145,
-0.6276133060455322,
-0.192318394780159,
0.008328523486852646,
-0.23281905055046082,
0.02684326469898224,
0.7476009726524353,
-0.3780469000339508,
0.5300637483596802,
0.3768983483314514,
-0.22894227504730225,
0.04522479698061943,
0.1593385934829712,
0.4374527931213379,
-0.41834574937820435,
-0.17747586965560913,
-1.0912055969238281,
0.6011484861373901,
-0.21860021352767944,
-0.5956469774246216,
0.5195550322532654,
0.352786660194397,
0.29615917801856995,
0.3408277630805969,
0.4483923017978668,
-0.22490355372428894,
0.29479506611824036,
-0.32939890027046204,
0.48821213841438293,
-0.21909643709659576,
0.013665183447301388,
-0.1525217443704605,
-1.0745755434036255,
-0.32350319623947144,
0.49488601088523865,
-0.3636249303817749,
-0.009488210082054138,
0.6192151308059692,
0.5838444232940674,
-0.0803292766213417,
0.3208416700363159,
0.06333374232053757,
0.1101914569735527,
0.39031973481178284,
0.19187244772911072,
0.7098344564437866,
-0.21346180140972137,
0.5837902426719666,
0.004613277968019247,
-0.2946370244026184,
-0.1513228416442871,
-0.9663329124450684,
-0.6567086577415466,
-0.5368877649307251,
-0.43459218740463257,
0.02804182469844818,
-0.21777084469795227,
0.7347116470336914,
0.5528169870376587,
-0.5604817867279053,
0.1789611130952835,
-0.1425262838602066,
0.09746073186397552,
-0.43389442563056946,
-0.30776289105415344,
0.6328791975975037,
-0.4707014262676239,
-0.7027248740196228,
-0.0626620352268219,
0.24986577033996582,
-0.16882607340812683,
-0.1995670646429062,
-0.08854948729276657,
0.29779163002967834,
-0.04261370003223419,
0.43341952562332153,
-0.03860330209136009,
-0.9795923233032227,
-0.7115011215209961,
-0.05826340988278389,
-0.3091029226779938,
0.30794188380241394,
0.7142319083213806,
-0.4820047616958618,
0.5500510334968567,
0.5630289912223816,
0.48255014419555664,
-0.004944405052810907,
0.3140179514884949,
0.6895401477813721,
-0.7170306444168091,
-0.011254237033426762,
0.22301369905471802,
-0.00636977469548583,
0.48630136251449585,
-0.5149259567260742,
0.5427441000938416,
-0.4300236105918884,
-0.9468857049942017,
-0.5289668440818787,
-0.021206745877861977,
-1.1675572395324707,
-0.025288820266723633,
0.9325997233390808,
-0.20971521735191345,
-0.05683986470103264,
-0.1267966628074646,
-0.536018431186676,
0.32308176159858704,
-0.5908380746841431,
0.8812825083732605,
0.9976813793182373,
-0.4241638481616974,
-0.04071731120347977,
-0.6626732349395752,
0.5016278028488159,
0.36304330825805664,
-0.8836713433265686,
0.48459210991859436,
0.4080790877342224,
-0.1109420582652092,
0.34000492095947266,
0.32672059535980225,
0.0032335922587662935,
0.2565917372703552,
-0.3485259711742401,
0.15023189783096313,
0.38083428144454956,
0.07291746884584427,
-0.39944934844970703,
-0.16746886074543,
0.25126364827156067,
-0.11409953981637955
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17363v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17363v1
|
Extracting Biomedical Entities from Noisy Audio Transcripts
| 2024-03-26T03:58:52 | 2024-03-26T03:58:52 |
Nima Ebadi, Kellen Morgan, Adrian Tan, Billy Linares, Sheri Osborn, Emma Majors, Jeremy Davis, Anthony Rios
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) technology is fundamental in transcribing
spoken language into text, with considerable applications in the clinical
realm, including streamlining medical transcription and integrating with
Electronic Health Record (EHR) systems. Nevertheless, challenges persist,
especially when transcriptions contain noise, leading to significant drops in
performance when Natural Language Processing (NLP) models are applied. Named
Entity Recognition (NER), an essential clinical task, is particularly affected
by such noise, often termed the ASR-NLP gap. Prior works have primarily studied
ASR's efficiency in clean recordings, leaving a research gap concerning the
performance in noisy environments. This paper introduces a novel dataset,
BioASR-NER, designed to bridge the ASR-NLP gap in the biomedical domain,
focusing on extracting adverse drug reactions and mentions of entities from the
Brief Test of Adult Cognition by Telephone (BTACT) exam. Our dataset offers a
comprehensive collection of almost 2,000 clean and noisy recordings. In
addressing the noise challenge, we present an innovative transcript-cleaning
method using GPT4, investigating both zero-shot and few-shot methodologies. Our
study further delves into an error analysis, shedding light on the types of
errors in transcription software, corrections by GPT4, and the challenges GPT4
faces. This paper aims to foster improved understanding and potential solutions
for the ASR-NLP gap, ultimately supporting enhanced healthcare documentation
practices.
|
[
-0.15209701657295227,
-0.5776287913322449,
0.6272273659706116,
-0.13709811866283417,
-0.1407252848148346,
0.0800626277923584,
-0.04820169880986214,
-0.8148699998855591,
0.14736181497573853,
0.5168223977088928,
-0.449638307094574,
-0.5509189367294312,
-0.6550144553184509,
0.42559269070625305,
-0.4316876530647278,
1.0490872859954834,
0.17842985689640045,
0.3094334304332733,
0.0418919213116169,
-0.2664853632450104,
-0.45410671830177307,
-0.38573408126831055,
-0.9945611357688904,
-0.3223300874233246,
0.500501275062561,
-0.03880257159471512,
0.30607858300209045,
0.7844960689544678,
0.8253446221351624,
0.2933487594127655,
-0.21319560706615448,
-0.018618227913975716,
-0.06682421267032623,
0.2366742491722107,
0.011401494033634663,
0.021663974970579147,
-0.4767914414405823,
-0.25615084171295166,
0.6920243501663208,
0.5790332555770874,
-0.2190982699394226,
0.22566208243370056,
-0.03171749413013458,
0.3447315990924835,
-0.2553398907184601,
0.3235149681568146,
-0.5921573638916016,
0.13133016228675842,
-0.5224558711051941,
-0.23277664184570312,
-0.02995406463742256,
-0.10553961992263794,
0.16908946633338928,
-0.5333449840545654,
0.3888263702392578,
-0.2814570963382721,
1.247657299041748,
0.6124366521835327,
-0.1712944656610489,
-0.4841521680355072,
-0.8076779246330261,
0.41996145248413086,
-0.7897612452507019,
0.661742091178894,
0.3031267821788788,
0.1771683394908905,
-0.12520994246006012,
-0.6894862651824951,
-0.3257419168949127,
0.3257996737957001,
0.024646511301398277,
0.08194229751825333,
-0.4238913357257843,
0.08309109508991241,
0.35552161931991577,
0.33647361397743225,
-0.41504019498825073,
0.09883251786231995,
-0.8560497760772705,
-0.5440672636032104,
0.33198490738868713,
-0.009547827765345573,
0.4541099965572357,
-0.10716179758310318,
-0.09595386683940887,
0.2324516773223877,
-0.5975944399833679,
0.010676318779587746,
0.013915901072323322,
0.2891750633716583,
0.1002604141831398,
0.4259030818939209,
0.08484135568141937,
0.4381834864616394,
0.01777186244726181,
-0.15274947881698608,
0.5959750413894653,
-0.30343711376190186,
-0.26716792583465576,
0.47273382544517517,
0.9315835237503052,
0.09533371031284332,
-0.33669817447662354,
-0.22985054552555084,
-0.23313723504543304,
0.16660559177398682,
0.3364585041999817,
-1.0180755853652954,
-0.5155772566795349,
0.43766483664512634,
-0.3304929733276367,
-0.04644722864031792,
-0.27880749106407166,
-0.9114930033683777,
-0.30224865674972534,
-0.3795994222164154,
0.5389553308486938,
-0.7596302032470703,
-0.03998323902487755,
0.11516731977462769,
-0.13037434220314026,
0.2887912392616272,
0.4048742949962616,
-0.7526912689208984,
0.6697934865951538,
0.603183925151825,
0.8058986067771912,
-0.04174138605594635,
0.34164702892303467,
-0.8004195094108582,
0.26577672362327576,
-0.07219426333904266,
0.9755713939666748,
-0.21339339017868042,
-0.5391213893890381,
-0.36357420682907104,
-0.16417750716209412,
-0.02284957841038704,
-0.9113597273826599,
0.5690014958381653,
-0.3184325695037842,
0.010599702596664429,
-0.27587366104125977,
-0.5359033346176147,
-0.09858595579862595,
-0.13698238134384155,
-0.6970639824867249,
0.5715181231498718,
-0.17770515382289886,
-0.5786436796188354,
0.5239760875701904,
-0.8360996842384338,
-0.38519349694252014,
0.24278992414474487,
-0.678498387336731,
-0.8771408796310425,
-0.12306207418441772,
0.25926896929740906,
0.1895127296447754,
-0.09755285084247589,
0.17800173163414001,
0.07375000417232513,
-0.4212034046649933,
0.1540856659412384,
-0.23966015875339508,
0.899093508720398,
0.16084285080432892,
-0.4971065819263458,
-0.01246685441583395,
-0.9638978838920593,
-0.042076267302036285,
-0.24029536545276642,
-0.44971781969070435,
-0.2960042953491211,
-0.21544744074344635,
-0.09786761552095413,
0.22263212502002716,
-0.2708836793899536,
-0.7819894552230835,
-0.14883440732955933,
-0.4055904448032379,
0.4880521595478058,
0.4554116427898407,
0.29308587312698364,
0.15717832744121552,
-0.3736919164657593,
0.38007956743240356,
0.2709505259990692,
-0.05711378529667854,
-0.08755078166723251,
-0.6721115112304688,
-0.35215333104133606,
-0.6601932644844055,
0.5291587114334106,
0.46311306953430176,
-0.4714670181274414,
0.22732965648174286,
-0.2253090739250183,
-0.2071172595024109,
-1.0377929210662842,
0.08621587604284286,
0.4410915672779083,
0.8854639530181885,
0.7416512370109558,
-0.4282350540161133,
-0.6176928877830505,
-0.7014169692993164,
-0.3025854229927063,
-0.18013590574264526,
-0.38182589411735535,
0.524476170539856,
0.2962445914745331,
-0.6762095093727112,
0.7211076617240906,
-0.25629767775535583,
-0.649406909942627,
0.2553649842739105,
0.122154101729393,
0.23855718970298767,
0.5422105193138123,
0.10809202492237091,
-0.480893075466156,
-0.1439220905303955,
-0.07213440537452698,
-0.6420652866363525,
-0.33793267607688904,
-0.016682760789990425,
0.10148375481367111,
-0.16400687396526337,
0.5439663529396057,
-0.7623307704925537,
0.4056873321533203,
0.18714143335819244,
-0.0896158218383789,
0.3634605407714844,
-0.0385502390563488,
0.19770283997058868,
-0.712529182434082,
0.138287752866745,
0.08877980709075928,
-0.130447655916214,
-0.6611515283584595,
-0.34541812539100647,
-0.11736921966075897,
-0.03334638476371765,
-0.24006465077400208,
0.3114004135131836,
-0.6894020438194275,
-0.010847204364836216,
0.12087031453847885,
-0.1856745332479477,
0.09022277593612671,
0.09331353008747101,
0.1268913298845291,
0.5407765507698059,
0.5147592425346375,
-0.48535141348838806,
-0.0778777003288269,
0.7657784819602966,
0.04328501597046852,
0.2665460407733917,
-0.6732466816902161,
0.3378066122531891,
-0.12841655313968658,
0.09884578734636307,
-0.4830912947654724,
-0.4057658910751343,
0.34112435579299927,
-0.5121860504150391,
0.707512378692627,
-0.20856012403964996,
-0.38649263978004456,
-0.16113924980163574,
-0.0399613082408905,
0.3686666190624237,
0.5358799695968628,
-0.15089692175388336,
0.4632810652256012,
0.7539874911308289,
-0.5032045245170593,
-0.4575961232185364,
-0.606285572052002,
0.2324332892894745,
-0.19342926144599915,
-0.2463206946849823,
0.4235357344150543,
0.14091531932353973,
-0.22260089218616486,
-0.02025284245610237,
-0.6028890013694763,
-0.45399701595306396,
-0.1675957292318344,
0.47736090421676636,
0.289072722196579,
-0.42853844165802,
0.161985382437706,
0.024365535005927086,
-0.09522309899330139,
0.33378198742866516,
0.07858042418956757,
0.1379956305027008,
-0.12363751232624054,
-0.19785702228546143,
-0.6066313982009888,
0.2719387710094452,
0.3359447121620178,
-0.1792089343070984,
0.0956944152712822,
0.69490647315979,
-0.7557682394981384,
0.13789702951908112,
-0.6281107068061829,
-0.2954106032848358,
-0.440792977809906,
0.25842705368995667,
-0.19614312052726746,
-0.6457400918006897,
0.5827588438987732,
-0.024449916556477547,
0.06347045302391052,
0.3115547001361847,
0.3562965393066406,
-0.24114063382148743,
0.5379451513290405,
0.1781049370765686,
0.09181542694568634,
0.17949216067790985,
-0.1254860758781433,
0.24578531086444855,
-0.9295468926429749,
-0.39192917943000793,
-0.5407346487045288,
-0.08647747337818146,
-0.3578866720199585,
-0.4848801791667938,
0.4162370264530182,
-0.21333082020282745,
-0.1772959977388382,
0.36404523253440857,
-0.6180063486099243,
0.26829782128334045,
0.5015600919723511,
0.2545633316040039,
0.42684194445610046,
-0.015105841681361198,
0.0010728572960942984,
-0.16844138503074646,
-0.45936840772628784,
-0.5394465327262878,
0.8782554864883423,
0.403272420167923,
0.38754886388778687,
0.22503939270973206,
1.021768569946289,
-0.06258679926395416,
0.2368650734424591,
-0.5820167064666748,
0.35640591382980347,
-0.16054381430149078,
-0.5974339246749878,
-0.3623282313346863,
-0.5806916356086731,
-1.1789100170135498,
-0.0682535469532013,
-0.19016195833683014,
-0.7064429521560669,
0.3884807825088501,
0.051650140434503555,
-0.9174870252609253,
0.23859570920467377,
-0.4249594509601593,
0.7448209524154663,
0.07346328347921371,
-0.09183628857135773,
0.2833439111709595,
-0.9907401204109192,
0.16027383506298065,
-0.32861554622650146,
0.4115757346153259,
-0.13416196405887604,
0.04354636371135712,
0.7412214875221252,
-0.4750966727733612,
0.3999907672405243,
-0.10807755589485168,
-0.024609584361314774,
0.2417125403881073,
-0.0695561096072197,
0.07498922944068909,
0.04266813397407532,
0.06329110264778137,
0.7171227931976318,
0.007916700094938278,
0.026746241375803947,
-0.22899112105369568,
0.4527844488620758,
-0.6594774127006531,
-0.2133983075618744,
-0.4093410074710846,
-0.2957277297973633,
-0.291828453540802,
0.359519362449646,
0.5881986618041992,
0.6654839515686035,
-0.11360998451709747,
0.027859464287757874,
0.783774197101593,
-0.45469000935554504,
0.2422686517238617,
0.5875778794288635,
0.17940546572208405,
-0.34672436118125916,
0.8271509408950806,
0.28619086742401123,
-0.12373515218496323,
0.20337733626365662,
-0.08086492866277695,
-0.26876702904701233,
-0.8079642653465271,
-0.4359951317310333,
0.30729225277900696,
-0.3537839949131012,
-0.47919395565986633,
-1.0909380912780762,
-0.38679736852645874,
-0.5282987356185913,
0.166591614484787,
-0.2570119798183441,
-0.0701589584350586,
-0.6613250970840454,
-0.1495393067598343,
0.32912325859069824,
0.5658478140830994,
-0.2522902190685272,
0.1268618255853653,
-1.1319389343261719,
0.7665332555770874,
0.05436026677489281,
0.4294278621673584,
-0.5072166323661804,
-0.3995055556297302,
-0.04432730749249458,
-0.020067138597369194,
-0.1955656111240387,
-0.9469061493873596,
0.5970607399940491,
0.46547892689704895,
0.33534663915634155,
0.2822718322277069,
-0.15508925914764404,
1.0100023746490479,
-0.970564603805542,
0.6227412819862366,
0.1219361275434494,
-0.8042542934417725,
0.5494568347930908,
-0.4380057752132416,
0.14030812680721283,
0.8268428444862366,
0.10772218555212021,
-0.3495052456855774,
-0.6094263195991516,
-0.8003354668617249,
-1.187164545059204,
0.46013835072517395,
0.45180025696754456,
-0.43886616826057434,
-0.17413626611232758,
0.3850476145744324,
0.11536375433206558,
0.24487364292144775,
-0.33290356397628784,
-0.2390863299369812,
-0.03319651260972023,
-0.2550742030143738,
0.12386815249919891,
0.16020892560482025,
-0.09481555223464966,
-0.18122948706150055,
0.7435328364372253,
0.21225233376026154,
0.5784530639648438,
0.5563772916793823,
-0.1467849612236023,
-0.24452157318592072,
0.30451256036758423,
0.14725250005722046,
-0.003839963348582387,
-0.3218008279800415,
0.0020495583303272724,
-0.01854602061212063,
-0.8479913473129272,
0.15847516059875488,
0.5084801912307739,
-0.15220481157302856,
0.4073745310306549,
0.24262861907482147,
0.4131830632686615,
0.25875571370124817,
-0.7380472421646118,
0.5357681512832642,
-0.23796485364437103,
-0.15268254280090332,
-0.39470022916793823,
-0.006091119255870581,
0.043774884194135666,
0.22086963057518005,
0.2731850743293762,
0.48992297053337097,
0.8366659879684448,
-0.33565640449523926,
0.7756242752075195,
0.19347913563251495,
-0.7372714281082153,
-0.3703722655773163,
1.0089261531829834,
0.04536847397685051,
-0.36441436409950256,
0.7555880546569824,
-0.10262993723154068,
-0.045446570962667465,
0.46203067898750305,
0.2589694559574127,
0.868847131729126,
-0.2855110764503479,
-0.02852487936615944,
0.22914019227027893,
-0.0549180768430233,
-0.02667303755879402,
0.2444802075624466,
0.036040663719177246,
-0.6207566857337952,
-0.6059560179710388,
-0.6625394225120544,
-0.4479081332683563,
0.30145344138145447,
-0.9323070645332336,
0.2654656767845154,
-0.432034969329834,
-0.4937979578971863,
0.6895577311515808,
-0.17901363968849182,
-0.6490512490272522,
0.24558688700199127,
0.2364404797554016,
0.33458879590034485,
-0.5962751507759094,
0.5910468697547913,
0.5272263884544373,
-0.39446836709976196,
-0.9579414129257202,
-0.06036854535341263,
0.5202098488807678,
-0.4395007789134979,
0.5518577098846436,
0.2651563286781311,
-0.025714412331581116,
-0.11282401531934738,
-0.18043974041938782,
-0.6082947850227356,
0.8746297359466553,
0.3339550495147705,
-0.6776577234268188,
-0.2366185337305069,
0.04764417186379433,
0.6951730251312256,
0.12238305807113647,
0.024371152743697166,
0.6603670120239258,
0.2694723308086395,
-0.06143629550933838,
-0.997440755367279,
0.1285897195339203,
-0.46252208948135376,
-0.5350607633590698,
0.38866132497787476,
-0.2725664973258972,
0.5033498406410217,
-0.2119540125131607,
-0.4018794894218445,
-0.001597613445483148,
0.2781447470188141,
0.3445364832878113,
0.6314440369606018,
0.3491153120994568,
0.48062390089035034,
0.9929468631744385,
-0.19221889972686768,
0.7086703777313232,
0.006805692333728075,
-0.01105297077447176,
1.1817760467529297,
-0.4814714193344116,
0.5803599953651428,
0.4316871464252472,
-0.17505031824111938,
0.4305711090564728,
0.4725777208805084,
-0.17209979891777039,
0.29102998971939087,
0.2777586281299591,
-0.5043312311172485,
0.14746350049972534,
-0.058560747653245926,
-0.29287317395210266,
0.4760496914386749,
0.5573661923408508,
-0.2420244812965393,
-0.15951736271381378,
-0.07061905413866043,
-0.037408556789159775,
-0.2856169641017914,
-0.28038501739501953,
1.3147759437561035,
0.28415071964263916,
-0.1364348977804184,
0.10664362460374832,
-0.4983787536621094,
0.4708670973777771,
-0.4017932415008545,
-0.2767636477947235,
0.35318416357040405,
0.13847245275974274,
-0.26528146862983704,
-0.34141358733177185,
0.5920345783233643,
0.0458061620593071,
-0.10329703241586685,
-0.15321405231952667,
0.6904011368751526,
-0.6061258912086487,
-0.19960546493530273,
0.1928023248910904,
0.46876898407936096,
0.537769615650177,
-0.09620831161737442,
-0.6543964743614197,
-0.008612265810370445,
-0.014886688441038132,
0.07865515351295471,
0.2203265279531479,
0.7475877404212952,
0.22390824556350708,
0.31327366828918457,
0.7396558523178101,
0.5769626498222351,
-0.025939911603927612,
0.0834154337644577,
0.6018505096435547,
-0.687100887298584,
-0.27197831869125366,
-0.7042936086654663,
0.4054509401321411,
-0.16551989316940308,
-0.23343326151371002,
0.42727580666542053,
0.8650553226470947,
0.34252309799194336,
0.07601112127304077,
0.6036568284034729,
0.30807429552078247,
0.9857361316680908,
-0.3150210678577423,
0.8418874144554138,
-0.13485416769981384,
0.5061445236206055,
-0.5908521413803101,
-0.3887765407562256,
-0.5872911810874939,
0.5503612756729126,
0.0864383801817894,
-0.17870087921619415,
0.5760962963104248,
0.649512529373169,
0.08699080348014832,
0.13842467963695526,
0.2482580989599228,
0.5388181805610657,
0.4103458523750305,
0.335460901260376,
0.3129899203777313,
-0.6877209544181824,
0.5300854444503784,
-0.08912871778011322,
0.06438066065311432,
0.0822051540017128,
-0.5538500547409058,
-0.41016513109207153,
-0.29071375727653503,
-0.7532786130905151,
-0.49948686361312866,
0.3310934007167816,
0.8351916074752808,
0.5030660629272461,
-1.0193085670471191,
0.3408401906490326,
-0.012932022102177143,
-0.24588775634765625,
-0.4080042243003845,
-0.1953144371509552,
0.5537084341049194,
-0.11582567542791367,
-0.46995729207992554,
0.5128037929534912,
0.44810551404953003,
0.2580488622188568,
0.4780595004558563,
0.25071701407432556,
0.09420666843652725,
0.044417668133974075,
0.271569162607193,
0.5418835878372192,
-0.5187006592750549,
-0.15511341392993927,
-0.00021788981393910944,
-0.14239069819450378,
0.3463229835033417,
0.6830005645751953,
-0.804218053817749,
0.4316919147968292,
0.06672417372465134,
0.7480684518814087,
0.5966064929962158,
-0.06570068001747131,
0.5766468048095703,
-0.7192044854164124,
-0.31870439648628235,
0.6929799318313599,
0.33739596605300903,
0.42021822929382324,
-0.6541257500648499,
0.565751314163208,
0.1316554844379425,
-0.7231146693229675,
-0.9470738768577576,
-0.23626382648944855,
-1.1027300357818604,
-0.06732908636331558,
1.106012225151062,
0.0699065625667572,
0.007621754426509142,
-0.7587175965309143,
-0.10905316472053528,
0.5051136016845703,
-0.6526697278022766,
0.823002815246582,
0.35107293725013733,
-0.5347545146942139,
0.04026950150728226,
-0.8861702084541321,
0.819265604019165,
0.04530586674809456,
-0.6885092854499817,
-0.10011809319257736,
0.7100273370742798,
0.5142589211463928,
0.2382614016532898,
1.078730583190918,
-0.6321855783462524,
0.31105664372444153,
0.09299137443304062,
0.10854975879192352,
0.037786319851875305,
-0.020245976746082306,
-0.6600995659828186,
0.0202645193785429,
-0.31726357340812683,
-0.18443354964256287
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17361v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17361v1
|
Bridging Textual and Tabular Worlds for Fact Verification: A Lightweight, Attention-Based Model
| 2024-03-26T03:54:25 | 2024-03-26T03:54:25 |
Shirin Dabbaghi Varnosfaderani, Canasai Kruengkrai, Ramin Yahyapour, Junichi Yamagishi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
FEVEROUS is a benchmark and research initiative focused on fact extraction
and verification tasks involving unstructured text and structured tabular data.
In FEVEROUS, existing works often rely on extensive preprocessing and utilize
rule-based transformations of data, leading to potential context loss or
misleading encodings. This paper introduces a simple yet powerful model that
nullifies the need for modality conversion, thereby preserving the original
evidence's context. By leveraging pre-trained models on diverse text and
tabular datasets and by incorporating a lightweight attention-based mechanism,
our approach efficiently exploits latent connections between different data
types, thereby yielding comprehensive and reliable verdict predictions. The
model's modular structure adeptly manages multi-modal information, ensuring the
integrity and authenticity of the original evidence are uncompromised.
Comparative analyses reveal that our approach exhibits competitive performance,
aligning itself closely with top-tier models on the FEVEROUS benchmark.
|
[
0.09340206533670425,
-0.9924424290657043,
0.6815451979637146,
0.021183526143431664,
-0.4467470347881317,
-0.2713274359703064,
-0.24641506373882294,
-0.22816143929958344,
0.09283478558063507,
0.6148132681846619,
-0.14559757709503174,
-0.606788694858551,
-0.44484567642211914,
0.0507417656481266,
-0.809577226638794,
1.3993455171585083,
0.07306331396102905,
-0.28620830178260803,
-0.7323687672615051,
-0.18460819125175476,
-0.1593557596206665,
-0.5618147850036621,
0.17297421395778656,
-0.2760792076587677,
0.32628580927848816,
0.6263647079467773,
0.8083864450454712,
0.9756375551223755,
0.6548712849617004,
0.2634800970554352,
0.23000577092170715,
0.4528566896915436,
-0.5926756262779236,
0.5070619583129883,
-0.2644980847835541,
-0.4086553454399109,
-0.5455759167671204,
0.1052868664264679,
0.2767297923564911,
0.43472832441329956,
-0.12130070477724075,
0.6106292009353638,
-0.08903049677610397,
0.6005170345306396,
-0.6002376079559326,
0.33723193407058716,
-0.9171721935272217,
-0.09012344479560852,
-0.469200998544693,
-0.23268960416316986,
-0.8020914793014526,
-0.488347589969635,
0.05925867334008217,
-0.36143308877944946,
0.5132487416267395,
0.28112050890922546,
0.8869425654411316,
0.34798333048820496,
-0.8549604415893555,
0.06959015130996704,
-0.7893513441085815,
0.3820197880268097,
-0.34777942299842834,
0.647927463054657,
0.0891372486948967,
0.005558923818171024,
-0.16324171423912048,
-1.0225839614868164,
-0.4903099238872528,
-0.3243746757507324,
-0.1969517022371292,
0.18663305044174194,
0.03601066395640373,
-0.215857595205307,
0.2709067761898041,
0.37565845251083374,
-0.7025681734085083,
-0.7719979286193848,
-0.16411983966827393,
-0.19620713591575623,
0.4584274888038635,
0.027492115274071693,
0.2944769859313965,
-0.48339542746543884,
-0.7435002326965332,
0.18242421746253967,
-0.4901861846446991,
0.1862751543521881,
-0.4779817461967468,
0.316192626953125,
-0.3226291835308075,
0.6243304014205933,
-0.3438551425933838,
0.6476825475692749,
0.15817458927631378,
-0.4132700264453888,
0.12057925015687943,
-0.3764597475528717,
-0.3084019720554352,
0.13343220949172974,
0.780400812625885,
0.460146427154541,
-0.2360849380493164,
-0.6729553937911987,
-0.2602307200431824,
0.08513956516981125,
0.2955643832683563,
-0.8302822709083557,
-0.20561076700687408,
0.30286937952041626,
-0.5751633048057556,
-0.3364821970462799,
0.051390476524829865,
-0.9124436974525452,
-0.6726445555686951,
-0.27853524684906006,
0.7048847079277039,
-0.4682556390762329,
-0.0948559120297432,
-0.16325843334197998,
-0.022812774404883385,
-0.10226132720708847,
0.5166354775428772,
-0.6732947826385498,
0.11027852445840836,
0.7227992415428162,
0.9100760221481323,
-0.07130760699510574,
0.07843499630689621,
-0.5864615440368652,
0.27396294474601746,
-0.37651708722114563,
1.153119444847107,
-0.5466064810752869,
-0.05044303461909294,
-0.17294634878635406,
-0.029916929081082344,
-0.13839350640773773,
-0.47613874077796936,
0.9138696193695068,
-0.6417915225028992,
-0.06238054484128952,
-0.48886144161224365,
-0.25668251514434814,
-0.45216885209083557,
0.5685980319976807,
-0.8316874504089355,
0.9161561131477356,
-0.0660918727517128,
-0.9251790046691895,
0.645114541053772,
-0.3425757586956024,
-0.6005276441574097,
0.028291283175349236,
-0.02886749804019928,
-0.564309298992157,
0.0974343940615654,
0.0380188524723053,
0.39232248067855835,
-0.6969637870788574,
0.6492476463317871,
-0.4380823075771332,
0.04392136260867119,
0.5787009596824646,
-0.27382129430770874,
0.2609330415725708,
0.307376891374588,
-0.3323923647403717,
0.3490045964717865,
-0.802905261516571,
-0.3223104178905487,
0.053133316338062286,
-0.39747127890586853,
-0.24069787561893463,
0.2325608730316162,
0.22168046236038208,
0.14377924799919128,
0.15373818576335907,
-0.5995218753814697,
0.1930374652147293,
-0.1953451782464981,
0.16186152398586273,
0.02427605353295803,
0.1404699683189392,
0.36604276299476624,
-0.7436539530754089,
0.05286354944109917,
0.304545134305954,
0.21919921040534973,
-0.0682266354560852,
-0.32401153445243835,
-0.709219217300415,
-0.3310772180557251,
0.6032492518424988,
0.6838722825050354,
-0.9288941621780396,
-0.022083433344960213,
-0.3839137852191925,
-0.739582359790802,
-0.10866139829158783,
0.11618310958147049,
0.11704789102077484,
0.8094748854637146,
0.402068555355072,
-0.05233035609126091,
-0.5659181475639343,
-0.7440594434738159,
-0.4182702302932739,
-0.24380366504192352,
0.22076170146465302,
0.033585354685783386,
0.3166082799434662,
-0.2813663184642792,
1.0402158498764038,
-0.13913363218307495,
-0.31926533579826355,
-0.5291374921798706,
0.3931620121002197,
0.4610988199710846,
0.496002733707428,
0.510097324848175,
-0.9905482530593872,
-0.3527948558330536,
0.2992618978023529,
-1.001518726348877,
-0.1538703739643097,
-0.20917589962482452,
0.0018531797686591744,
0.10843230038881302,
0.4102466404438019,
-0.49073511362075806,
0.44565653800964355,
0.15815512835979462,
-0.37929898500442505,
0.3064223825931549,
0.19567374885082245,
0.7315073013305664,
-0.9047885537147522,
0.31434211134910583,
0.10416270047426224,
-0.6198685169219971,
-0.9036975502967834,
0.2127598524093628,
0.38691622018814087,
-0.12370043247938156,
-0.2995072901248932,
0.36331745982170105,
-0.4893608093261719,
0.3689005970954895,
-0.0827999860048294,
0.04102020338177681,
0.1671345978975296,
0.2721919119358063,
-0.03620259463787079,
0.5997821092605591,
0.40752509236335754,
-0.5544787049293518,
0.5173380374908447,
0.09352979809045792,
-0.10951974242925644,
0.42008137702941895,
-0.5049439072608948,
-0.26601752638816833,
-0.1972321718931198,
-0.027783017605543137,
-0.9774553775787354,
-0.3744978904724121,
0.32374003529548645,
-0.3258877992630005,
0.20299717783927917,
-0.4540787935256958,
-0.581396758556366,
-0.07846802473068237,
-0.2775430381298065,
0.5714027285575867,
0.40501123666763306,
-0.21901041269302368,
1.0656251907348633,
0.5432304739952087,
-0.10414990037679672,
-0.4414984881877899,
-0.34479260444641113,
0.13767293095588684,
-0.06840380281209946,
-0.5215149521827698,
0.2684258818626404,
0.11530840396881104,
-0.5526465177536011,
-0.09067729115486145,
-0.3630797863006592,
-0.26827767491340637,
-0.02134030871093273,
0.5711733102798462,
0.4262622892856598,
-0.23932094871997833,
0.27106621861457825,
-0.05741274729371071,
0.21626991033554077,
0.0815361738204956,
-0.09141108393669128,
0.26500844955444336,
-0.057663410902023315,
-0.1264200061559677,
-0.16318382322788239,
0.19383126497268677,
1.0517666339874268,
-0.4075218439102173,
0.626860499382019,
0.5749614238739014,
-0.6308190822601318,
-0.1491488218307495,
-0.954806923866272,
-0.27932631969451904,
-0.3741846978664398,
0.09268085658550262,
-0.19009986519813538,
-0.19298234581947327,
0.5851985812187195,
-0.07274077832698822,
0.1083601638674736,
0.42266643047332764,
0.5105001926422119,
0.3855861723423004,
0.6233566999435425,
0.46669942140579224,
0.30610114336013794,
0.2230376899242401,
0.10954644531011581,
0.027055863291025162,
-0.42992058396339417,
-0.6982154250144958,
-0.5661843419075012,
0.03579673171043396,
-0.14901238679885864,
-0.5988901257514954,
0.9044893980026245,
-0.35499900579452515,
0.2660430073738098,
0.007031172513961792,
-0.3285213112831116,
0.317425936460495,
0.20662590861320496,
0.6619986295700073,
0.42764246463775635,
-0.1496870517730713,
0.03861073777079582,
0.015889372676610947,
-0.6506551504135132,
-0.49662086367607117,
1.2156496047973633,
0.06463490426540375,
0.8326364755630493,
0.3456266224384308,
0.49191272258758545,
0.6224223375320435,
0.7237070798873901,
-0.7450013160705566,
0.5072610974311829,
-0.09166683256626129,
-0.910542368888855,
-0.25388404726982117,
-0.5088140964508057,
-0.6455801725387573,
0.30468299984931946,
-0.7054194808006287,
-0.6018615961074829,
0.15631388127803802,
0.17400740087032318,
-0.47729766368865967,
0.32684800028800964,
-0.794962465763092,
1.163839340209961,
-0.05016541853547096,
-1.0792231559753418,
-0.1711631864309311,
-0.49069520831108093,
0.8032739758491516,
-0.09079248458147049,
0.6011285185813904,
-0.19491884112358093,
0.01937793754041195,
0.7538968324661255,
-0.5147835612297058,
0.680026650428772,
0.09987751394510269,
0.07807016372680664,
0.3314230144023895,
0.48910632729530334,
0.22864499688148499,
0.5581315159797668,
-0.16726326942443848,
-0.11079156398773193,
0.2588752210140228,
-0.24399468302726746,
-0.3284240961074829,
0.589044451713562,
-0.5689355134963989,
-0.8614851832389832,
-0.6517549157142639,
-0.7008143663406372,
-0.2273446023464203,
0.36954572796821594,
0.06911806762218475,
1.092434048652649,
-0.4060177206993103,
0.3539765179157257,
1.1063185930252075,
0.4178178310394287,
0.331177294254303,
0.6093537211418152,
-0.24268639087677002,
-0.21075673401355743,
0.7784146666526794,
0.052166152745485306,
-0.24185243248939514,
0.8068899512290955,
0.07735171169042587,
-0.3539907932281494,
-0.5281649231910706,
-0.5759813785552979,
0.12030138820409775,
-0.6656015515327454,
-0.5429876446723938,
-1.103632926940918,
0.06552625447511673,
-0.8615931868553162,
0.2551899552345276,
-0.4148629605770111,
-0.21527309715747833,
-0.08577634394168854,
0.25984394550323486,
0.4355352222919464,
0.7424834370613098,
-0.1158934086561203,
-0.09566466510295868,
-1.0630072355270386,
0.7828579545021057,
0.4910108745098114,
0.1385747492313385,
-0.27142176032066345,
-0.6706801652908325,
-0.29212674498558044,
-0.14824672043323517,
-0.18766184151172638,
-1.4722919464111328,
0.321378231048584,
0.3083593249320984,
0.49462008476257324,
0.570258617401123,
0.6269829273223877,
0.2895938456058502,
-0.34701934456825256,
0.5025143027305603,
-0.1411578357219696,
-1.0677381753921509,
0.4704265296459198,
-0.4173363745212555,
0.00367164914496243,
0.7852734327316284,
0.2934878468513489,
-0.41397446393966675,
-0.27935078740119934,
-0.5189664363861084,
-0.718040406703949,
0.5505722761154175,
-0.1568738967180252,
-0.34755855798721313,
0.25981995463371277,
0.4285617470741272,
0.3010268211364746,
0.2663295567035675,
-1.015380620956421,
-0.07750706374645233,
-0.44321438670158386,
-0.25113365054130554,
0.1769585907459259,
-0.3931003212928772,
-0.4466039836406708,
-0.2530059516429901,
0.6205006241798401,
-0.03995455056428909,
-0.1111331582069397,
0.6032641530036926,
-0.5967787504196167,
-0.00019356243137735873,
0.4244041442871094,
0.45049089193344116,
0.4829290509223938,
-0.43495872616767883,
0.6124898791313171,
-0.0022182827815413475,
-0.6044941544532776,
0.2370620220899582,
0.1348620504140854,
-0.3090642988681793,
0.13868586719036102,
0.39862197637557983,
0.20695360004901886,
0.3658069670200348,
-0.5257859230041504,
0.7380421757698059,
-0.25716447830200195,
0.05909392982721329,
0.1905428022146225,
-0.0137586435303092,
-0.30486610531806946,
0.15561561286449432,
0.3434599041938782,
0.44964948296546936,
0.7634092569351196,
-0.7746545076370239,
0.4318748414516449,
0.30981114506721497,
-0.19630001485347748,
-0.3914624750614166,
0.9021486043930054,
0.33057674765586853,
0.30069226026535034,
0.00642923079431057,
-0.249485045671463,
-0.5190953016281128,
0.47855129837989807,
0.37712615728378296,
0.49766018986701965,
-0.1263071894645691,
0.45567792654037476,
0.3726843297481537,
0.48340433835983276,
-0.10108904540538788,
0.2161431908607483,
-0.24817900359630585,
-0.3923759162425995,
-0.02633880265057087,
-0.5519571304321289,
-0.45516929030418396,
-0.07365133613348007,
-0.6793511509895325,
0.13422828912734985,
-0.44428664445877075,
-0.3047548234462738,
0.10107634216547012,
-0.14028938114643097,
-0.4897454082965851,
0.340268075466156,
0.04085199162364006,
0.8492887020111084,
-1.2209900617599487,
0.7123159170150757,
0.8704935312271118,
-0.3637356162071228,
-0.7251951694488525,
0.14785811305046082,
0.18970586359500885,
-0.4141218066215515,
0.3553646504878998,
0.16538847982883453,
0.028836507350206375,
-0.25583362579345703,
-0.4050266444683075,
-0.8683875203132629,
0.6986736059188843,
0.4033849537372589,
-0.3271541893482208,
0.24006034433841705,
-0.13975262641906738,
0.1642405241727829,
-0.06029800698161125,
0.27900755405426025,
0.4717559814453125,
0.585422933101654,
0.21055608987808228,
-0.8002557754516602,
0.3674303889274597,
-0.44963258504867554,
-0.5338118672370911,
-0.04559268057346344,
-0.5933533906936646,
0.9656403660774231,
-0.3624008893966675,
-0.5152718424797058,
-0.17965994775295258,
0.9125405550003052,
-0.05770654231309891,
0.6112096309661865,
0.4655565619468689,
0.33181092143058777,
0.7182608842849731,
-0.36937788128852844,
0.7026228308677673,
-0.5873442888259888,
0.19458672404289246,
0.733374834060669,
-0.6509865522384644,
0.5776762366294861,
0.3453048765659332,
0.1816888153553009,
0.6758179068565369,
0.48829731345176697,
0.13309107720851898,
0.5197593569755554,
-0.3152858018875122,
-0.29104575514793396,
-0.5683876276016235,
-0.46876439452171326,
-0.4683613181114197,
0.6017501950263977,
0.3086816668510437,
-0.0024799962993711233,
-0.27383455634117126,
-0.07534871250391006,
0.2870239019393921,
0.24773088097572327,
-0.4272507131099701,
0.9471462368965149,
-0.44025206565856934,
-0.8389899134635925,
0.6171441674232483,
0.042865145951509476,
0.3228279650211334,
-0.41359463334083557,
0.03008405677974224,
-0.18874846398830414,
0.11301828175783157,
-0.44256335496902466,
-0.3213198781013489,
0.15332502126693726,
0.027508404105901718,
-0.6437937617301941,
0.09754441678524017,
0.8294832706451416,
-0.5293081402778625,
-0.42584699392318726,
-0.41133272647857666,
0.6869569420814514,
-0.14384329319000244,
-0.014568440616130829,
-0.2513097822666168,
0.22275468707084656,
-0.07067321240901947,
-0.054056622087955475,
-0.01611718162894249,
0.9322697520256042,
-0.040923383086919785,
0.6213793754577637,
0.5723572373390198,
-0.005041406024247408,
-0.25211939215660095,
-0.10301286727190018,
0.9928950667381287,
-0.593967616558075,
-0.6235916018486023,
-0.9150089025497437,
0.4817482829093933,
-0.15932418406009674,
-0.048138029873371124,
0.7998250126838684,
0.8695536255836487,
-0.0032020120415836573,
-0.18880486488342285,
0.6272274851799011,
-0.08648885041475296,
0.3561774492263794,
-0.6263585090637207,
0.9611281752586365,
-0.4815582036972046,
0.015704872086644173,
-0.15526282787322998,
-0.38692668080329895,
-0.35133272409439087,
0.16623394191265106,
-0.3116346001625061,
-0.21892809867858887,
0.895248532295227,
0.6985185742378235,
-0.1036721020936966,
0.015850888565182686,
0.3697546124458313,
0.40111786127090454,
0.05400097742676735,
0.3849688768386841,
0.6254723072052002,
-0.33735063672065735,
0.4960828423500061,
-0.09964033961296082,
-0.6450405716896057,
-0.6176847815513611,
-0.9771141409873962,
-1.1392130851745605,
-0.7055004239082336,
-0.42932868003845215,
-0.48666584491729736,
0.049839720129966736,
1.024811029434204,
0.8367289304733276,
-0.7058867812156677,
-0.06912627071142197,
0.4800732731819153,
0.43005093932151794,
-0.0841914564371109,
-0.2067832052707672,
0.19112050533294678,
-0.31307607889175415,
-0.1705169677734375,
0.35038796067237854,
0.42718905210494995,
0.06997716426849365,
0.10099873691797256,
0.7043061852455139,
-0.09817097336053848,
0.509307861328125,
0.6128942370414734,
0.20337088406085968,
-0.5204167366027832,
-0.1116790920495987,
-0.03250889852643013,
-0.43843427300453186,
0.06529064476490021,
0.9853304624557495,
-0.9214664697647095,
0.3324783146381378,
0.6599828600883484,
0.4515736997127533,
0.2747212052345276,
0.2197822779417038,
0.31404075026512146,
-0.5666617155075073,
0.3285113573074341,
0.014502201229333878,
0.5101644396781921,
0.3902844488620758,
-0.4794602692127228,
0.248685821890831,
0.5936663150787354,
-0.6169683337211609,
-1.1120054721832275,
0.06118921935558319,
-1.4666489362716675,
-0.18237519264221191,
1.063880443572998,
-0.011677226051688194,
-0.7446848154067993,
-0.3585568070411682,
-0.14312231540679932,
0.44970178604125977,
-0.5595508217811584,
1.2097209692001343,
0.32222574949264526,
0.0757453516125679,
-0.10080980509519577,
-0.1640450656414032,
0.7513614892959595,
0.18713811039924622,
-1.0163606405258179,
0.500910758972168,
0.5924820899963379,
0.23239171504974365,
0.2993861436843872,
0.28675776720046997,
-0.08897040039300919,
0.5582762956619263,
0.13744497299194336,
0.20647266507148743,
-0.15872406959533691,
-0.5980178713798523,
0.19122540950775146,
0.815092146396637,
0.06966707110404968,
0.07670901715755463
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17359v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17359v1
|
Chain-of-Action: Faithful and Multimodal Question Answering through Large Language Models
| 2024-03-26T03:51:01 | 2024-03-26T03:51:01 |
Zhenyu Pan, Haozheng Luo, Manling Li, Han Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present a Chain-of-Action (CoA) framework for multimodal and
retrieval-augmented Question-Answering (QA). Compared to the literature, CoA
overcomes two major challenges of current QA applications: (i) unfaithful
hallucination that is inconsistent with real-time or domain facts and (ii) weak
reasoning performance over compositional information. Our key contribution is a
novel reasoning-retrieval mechanism that decomposes a complex question into a
reasoning chain via systematic prompting and pre-designed actions.
Methodologically, we propose three types of domain-adaptable `Plug-and-Play'
actions for retrieving real-time information from heterogeneous sources. We
also propose a multi-reference faith score (MRFS) to verify and resolve
conflicts in the answers. Empirically, we exploit both public benchmarks and a
Web3 case study to demonstrate the capability of CoA over other methods.
|
[
-0.25497201085090637,
-1.3321729898452759,
0.7104083299636841,
0.41493159532546997,
-0.0798250287771225,
0.33337634801864624,
0.11235394328832626,
-0.4848588705062866,
0.37647679448127747,
0.3195863664150238,
-0.6480703949928284,
0.027203019708395004,
-0.2769377529621124,
0.07294805347919464,
-0.445879727602005,
0.6113089919090271,
-0.23166313767433167,
0.06295209378004074,
-0.24248822033405304,
-0.47810813784599304,
-0.403876930475235,
-0.7077169418334961,
-0.5100769996643066,
0.011281032115221024,
0.9704081416130066,
0.162191241979599,
0.8387858271598816,
0.41393157839775085,
0.7112777233123779,
0.22780607640743256,
0.1876949816942215,
0.5251758098602295,
-0.30481287837028503,
0.34601861238479614,
-0.5641683340072632,
-0.37668576836586,
-0.6471052765846252,
-0.14092372357845306,
0.5749167799949646,
0.5864991545677185,
-0.2771981656551361,
0.3953758180141449,
-0.4259721040725708,
0.47802481055259705,
-1.0445184707641602,
-0.12568150460720062,
-0.5630780458450317,
-0.20443786680698395,
0.323287695646286,
-0.39099204540252686,
-0.5652298331260681,
-0.4337369501590729,
0.19599391520023346,
-0.6009194850921631,
-0.3287564218044281,
0.147755429148674,
0.7117685675621033,
0.08894244581460953,
-0.791691780090332,
-0.4895806908607483,
-0.8600178360939026,
0.6159077286720276,
-0.38882511854171753,
0.5123306512832642,
0.6045984029769897,
0.19446226954460144,
0.03199994936585426,
-0.8391803503036499,
-0.7755213975906372,
0.10252469033002853,
0.16917429864406586,
0.25176170468330383,
0.0787125825881958,
-0.11887022852897644,
0.16159860789775848,
0.45338326692581177,
-0.6666688323020935,
-0.41377338767051697,
-0.04540681466460228,
-0.10719635337591171,
0.49443304538726807,
0.1940806657075882,
0.2050773650407791,
0.129939466714859,
-0.4875558614730835,
-0.27834218740463257,
-0.6090671420097351,
0.04802994057536125,
0.19674518704414368,
0.019021712243556976,
0.014710134826600552,
0.586371123790741,
-0.13909520208835602,
0.6058424115180969,
-0.059706080704927444,
-0.040374092757701874,
-0.1494034379720688,
-0.5408548712730408,
-0.28232482075691223,
-0.23553647100925446,
0.7106337547302246,
0.07265373319387436,
-0.001013096421957016,
-0.03103574551641941,
0.02470403164625168,
-0.14955973625183105,
0.41373348236083984,
-0.5848363041877747,
0.02857084944844246,
0.4934956431388855,
-0.37295401096343994,
-0.05246773734688759,
0.3220598101615906,
-0.7828382253646851,
-0.10918214917182922,
-0.079193614423275,
0.7210487723350525,
-0.34561532735824585,
-0.43480995297431946,
0.1464778482913971,
-0.08355318009853363,
0.43052610754966736,
0.3541664779186249,
-0.34599706530570984,
0.4637793004512787,
0.44082286953926086,
0.5172023773193359,
-0.023370377719402313,
-0.4449222683906555,
-1.0044738054275513,
0.3659796714782715,
-0.39499878883361816,
0.5463045835494995,
-0.8023350834846497,
-0.08715330064296722,
0.36264219880104065,
0.10537204146385193,
-0.1425154060125351,
-0.3901919424533844,
0.32348743081092834,
-1.1680691242218018,
0.14919988811016083,
-0.47205236554145813,
-0.32811620831489563,
-0.39919766783714294,
0.635475218296051,
-0.8706164360046387,
0.8316568732261658,
-0.07436157763004303,
-0.4330922067165375,
0.0635029673576355,
-0.544438362121582,
-0.6230564117431641,
-0.3312273919582367,
0.10707541555166245,
-0.14751580357551575,
0.04500046372413635,
0.03800266236066818,
0.1565198302268982,
-0.4796755015850067,
0.24968081712722778,
-0.5185004472732544,
-0.23798568546772003,
0.6721453666687012,
-0.7236616611480713,
0.4531087875366211,
0.3384401202201843,
-0.00227312371134758,
0.05290042236447334,
-0.7577099800109863,
0.2254733443260193,
0.12610532343387604,
-0.279770165681839,
-0.4329831004142761,
0.13025091588497162,
-0.18567651510238647,
0.6300801038742065,
0.18771077692508698,
-0.24584299325942993,
0.42496129870414734,
0.18702107667922974,
0.2824282646179199,
0.6007497906684875,
0.2861767113208771,
0.15842550992965698,
-0.22602708637714386,
0.5877063274383545,
0.18485386669635773,
0.4978848099708557,
-0.16579774022102356,
-0.396013468503952,
-0.5776139497756958,
-0.19235219061374664,
0.1843506246805191,
0.5133962631225586,
-1.1719602346420288,
0.06072929874062538,
-0.10497079789638519,
-0.14904974400997162,
-0.4809781312942505,
-0.05242665112018585,
0.5936403274536133,
0.36505162715911865,
0.5580677390098572,
-0.43598440289497375,
-0.2856801450252533,
-0.45060625672340393,
-0.11326250433921814,
-0.5184421539306641,
0.17190106213092804,
0.11876067519187927,
0.6142839789390564,
-0.074071004986763,
0.8175224661827087,
-0.7225928902626038,
0.030200332403182983,
0.023885248228907585,
0.4995739161968231,
-0.16839276254177094,
0.21952390670776367,
0.14738526940345764,
-1.2557859420776367,
-0.11490665376186371,
-0.07209239155054092,
-0.9887651205062866,
0.223048135638237,
-0.161736860871315,
-0.19598045945167542,
-0.1147281676530838,
0.23836810886859894,
-0.5988959074020386,
0.2826702892780304,
0.6839238405227661,
-0.42067620158195496,
0.7121565937995911,
-0.11712025851011276,
0.6006737947463989,
-0.9852740168571472,
0.3035961389541626,
-0.3530389964580536,
-0.17548541724681854,
-0.6621571779251099,
0.4118885099887848,
0.08942897617816925,
-0.05777808278799057,
-0.6222417950630188,
0.5047634840011597,
-0.2617434859275818,
-0.07175391167402267,
-0.1581846922636032,
0.15135610103607178,
0.3654678463935852,
0.6540971398353577,
0.08576035499572754,
0.8062283396720886,
0.323483943939209,
-0.8847771883010864,
0.34191378951072693,
0.3458273410797119,
0.1109614148736,
0.5691925287246704,
-0.6209815740585327,
0.2770741879940033,
-0.005119440611451864,
0.3911232650279999,
-0.8133841156959534,
-0.4235835075378418,
0.09354346245527267,
-0.20584191381931305,
-0.1617881804704666,
-0.07451681047677994,
-0.6824468970298767,
-0.4052937924861908,
-0.22907142341136932,
0.8697920441627502,
0.11142298579216003,
-0.4459684491157532,
1.0019797086715698,
0.09049414843320847,
0.11906071752309799,
-0.7237708568572998,
-0.5366608500480652,
-0.1872253566980362,
0.12435126304626465,
-0.40537309646606445,
0.08872143179178238,
-0.39598119258880615,
-0.3086742162704468,
-0.10676367580890656,
-0.37797027826309204,
-0.6929188966751099,
-0.005813318770378828,
-0.0025103341322392225,
0.18879568576812744,
-0.05433168262243271,
0.3503411114215851,
0.18043939769268036,
0.3413974642753601,
0.12279580533504486,
-0.05082285404205322,
0.6147745251655579,
-0.21751901507377625,
-0.7484977841377258,
-0.32602909207344055,
0.7667171955108643,
0.949873685836792,
-0.7825927138328552,
0.6305131912231445,
0.49680429697036743,
-0.32376420497894287,
0.08139193058013916,
-0.5862692594528198,
-0.3531273603439331,
-0.4385189116001129,
0.01634831726551056,
-0.5587338805198669,
-0.8335964679718018,
0.7034012079238892,
-0.2612966299057007,
-0.03527102991938591,
0.1229197159409523,
0.47946518659591675,
-0.15297116339206696,
1.1071351766586304,
0.31075015664100647,
0.3213084638118744,
0.28863126039505005,
-0.06061460077762604,
0.4402941167354584,
-0.6485868692398071,
-0.19994370639324188,
-0.24036447703838348,
-0.07669427245855331,
-0.2774525582790375,
-0.5460432767868042,
0.424960196018219,
0.5233995914459229,
-0.18073995411396027,
0.254876971244812,
-0.019864503294229507,
0.2349010705947876,
0.31099948287010193,
0.03148476779460907,
0.5742576718330383,
-0.3505359888076782,
-0.09926123172044754,
0.4477384686470032,
-0.7029523849487305,
-0.2845604717731476,
0.7461112141609192,
0.3218706548213959,
0.9400205612182617,
0.5270013809204102,
0.20818820595741272,
0.20187468826770782,
0.18225787580013275,
-0.5603234171867371,
0.48961341381073,
0.2439204454421997,
-0.8842981457710266,
-0.13094449043273926,
-0.43504220247268677,
-0.7097791433334351,
0.4065992832183838,
-0.26703786849975586,
-0.46882617473602295,
0.3070164918899536,
0.25069984793663025,
-0.41936343908309937,
0.17729412019252777,
-0.6809884905815125,
0.6502865552902222,
-0.18849292397499084,
-0.847050666809082,
-0.2968178987503052,
-0.8493273258209229,
0.4398329257965088,
0.06504737585783005,
0.21437443792819977,
0.2480747550725937,
0.10894083976745605,
0.3919070065021515,
-0.2502425014972687,
0.6682285070419312,
0.14929161965847015,
-0.45828741788864136,
0.641106367111206,
0.4520295560359955,
0.6870440244674683,
0.3123243451118469,
0.04186577722430229,
-0.3016231656074524,
0.2687761187553406,
-0.41604897379875183,
-1.1213433742523193,
0.6191863417625427,
-0.3811987340450287,
-0.4017913341522217,
-0.5671277642250061,
-0.6255808472633362,
-0.5594363808631897,
0.010206724517047405,
-0.33862945437431335,
0.8103759288787842,
-0.10369940102100372,
0.09591808915138245,
0.8262451887130737,
-0.039842747151851654,
0.4493355453014374,
0.7150051593780518,
-0.3768925368785858,
-0.592269241809845,
1.0484567880630493,
-0.13687056303024292,
0.6305066347122192,
0.6534188389778137,
0.00017830505385063589,
-0.5362390875816345,
0.04704825207591057,
-0.3579310476779938,
0.3065212368965149,
-0.6200892925262451,
-0.09080064296722412,
-0.6687509417533875,
-0.0016213057097047567,
-0.1500522494316101,
0.03989534080028534,
-0.43107885122299194,
-0.2859458327293396,
-0.0754530057311058,
-0.02217375859618187,
0.2684117555618286,
0.5545651912689209,
0.17045608162879944,
-0.0950082316994667,
-0.9447833895683289,
0.7250741720199585,
0.707830548286438,
0.5244184732437134,
0.05507403239607811,
-0.1045742779970169,
-0.0734790489077568,
0.10178712755441666,
-0.3521999418735504,
-1.0068681240081787,
-0.052938006818294525,
-0.007674818858504295,
0.08390941470861435,
0.4120807945728302,
0.21379604935646057,
1.0503520965576172,
-0.42828473448753357,
0.8754035830497742,
0.28231748938560486,
-0.8402926921844482,
0.4289212226867676,
-0.27383071184158325,
0.315725713968277,
0.559306263923645,
0.7373529076576233,
-0.42750993371009827,
-0.2738845944404602,
-0.4796227514743805,
-0.6537579298019409,
0.28188392519950867,
0.15341511368751526,
0.032606158405542374,
-0.32409191131591797,
0.22597327828407288,
0.020073790103197098,
0.4949348568916321,
-0.5713416934013367,
-0.20499281585216522,
-0.15418770909309387,
-0.021185148507356644,
0.38324350118637085,
-0.18927572667598724,
-0.36042118072509766,
-0.12906478345394135,
0.5217012763023376,
-0.504731297492981,
0.3652476966381073,
0.5345978140830994,
-0.3940112292766571,
-0.05770203098654747,
0.40102818608283997,
0.8161941766738892,
1.0320916175842285,
-0.15532732009887695,
0.4429294466972351,
0.03246210142970085,
-0.44933754205703735,
0.3471145033836365,
-0.3235611319541931,
0.24152089655399323,
-0.4677608907222748,
0.5147984027862549,
0.4379071891307831,
0.019897256046533585,
-0.9729633927345276,
0.5780684947967529,
-0.10656370222568512,
-0.22228415310382843,
-0.136674702167511,
-0.2336404174566269,
-0.18617761135101318,
0.3394673764705658,
0.5590097904205322,
-0.11416981369256973,
0.18098758161067963,
-1.058409333229065,
0.39966413378715515,
0.2176012247800827,
-0.7365714907646179,
-0.4039691686630249,
0.5523312091827393,
0.1339491307735443,
-0.19710718095302582,
0.4960179924964905,
-0.21876053512096405,
-0.3670762777328491,
0.27319440245628357,
0.5605874061584473,
0.683408260345459,
-0.2800542712211609,
0.5014280676841736,
0.05571158230304718,
0.13964813947677612,
-0.15778037905693054,
0.786497950553894,
0.13856148719787598,
-0.5720948576927185,
-0.8436893224716187,
-0.37125280499458313,
-0.5024015307426453,
0.03689352795481682,
-0.8927659392356873,
-0.2648341655731201,
-0.41926008462905884,
-0.09267573803663254,
-0.45908257365226746,
-0.21500597894191742,
-0.2730012536048889,
0.41467198729515076,
-0.3158286213874817,
0.8045147061347961,
-0.6139429807662964,
0.7540077567100525,
0.6822777986526489,
-0.9329842925071716,
-0.6336991190910339,
0.32447949051856995,
-0.2475254386663437,
-0.3537117838859558,
0.5766667723655701,
-0.23737259209156036,
-0.47003793716430664,
-0.05498268082737923,
-0.44469407200813293,
-0.706108033657074,
1.0563002824783325,
0.2464909702539444,
-0.21857623755931854,
0.012117991223931313,
-0.006531422026455402,
0.5585862398147583,
-0.2755441963672638,
0.42474931478500366,
0.28451210260391235,
0.48336854577064514,
0.18762415647506714,
-0.802527666091919,
0.145809143781662,
-0.17333786189556122,
-0.2430923581123352,
0.10186496376991272,
-0.8547041416168213,
0.6530951857566833,
-0.02152957022190094,
-0.09881414473056793,
-0.016984933987259865,
0.8026182651519775,
0.29690462350845337,
0.31504884362220764,
0.4618547856807709,
0.3612859547138214,
0.7133389711380005,
-0.048940517008304596,
1.1696616411209106,
-0.20242641866207123,
0.2645294964313507,
1.0194035768508911,
-0.5955649614334106,
1.053851842880249,
0.7828694581985474,
-0.08267179131507874,
0.7695720791816711,
0.15817533433437347,
0.5210195183753967,
0.42415139079093933,
-0.031801749020814896,
-0.4280988276004791,
-0.513737142086029,
-0.37095141410827637,
-0.12732955813407898,
0.48717716336250305,
0.18146471679210663,
-0.050598397850990295,
-0.02787540666759014,
0.11808120459318161,
-0.17182114720344543,
0.23755601048469543,
-0.22563180327415466,
0.5576598048210144,
-0.012573549523949623,
-0.920333206653595,
0.5234246850013733,
-0.11868178844451904,
0.10436394065618515,
-0.8815887570381165,
-0.4913661777973175,
-0.09225904196500778,
0.01804553158581257,
0.03547322377562523,
-0.7812447547912598,
0.2652606666088104,
-0.19271165132522583,
-0.38002434372901917,
-0.15651239454746246,
0.4713403582572937,
-0.5384517312049866,
-0.13499514758586884,
0.4459369480609894,
0.7220460176467896,
-0.2891179323196411,
-0.12081466615200043,
-0.6498287320137024,
0.32801687717437744,
-0.5635648965835571,
-0.16176189482212067,
0.22830888628959656,
0.4410637617111206,
-0.29748231172561646,
1.0236932039260864,
0.7829034924507141,
-0.4407605826854706,
0.1058507040143013,
0.22906681895256042,
0.9108683466911316,
-0.6147387027740479,
-0.21599584817886353,
-0.5498923659324646,
0.524402379989624,
-0.16642871499061584,
-0.3310428857803345,
0.5675925016403198,
0.3930497169494629,
0.5197559595108032,
-0.06512030959129333,
0.3972195088863373,
-0.22548823058605194,
0.12413603812456131,
-0.5967494249343872,
0.2962712347507477,
-0.707195520401001,
-0.06838691979646683,
-0.4294794499874115,
-0.7082944512367249,
-0.28395646810531616,
0.2933015823364258,
-0.024567658081650734,
-0.06764431297779083,
1.1802947521209717,
0.6152964234352112,
-0.09615934640169144,
0.12563739717006683,
0.28535348176956177,
0.03542609140276909,
0.3850291669368744,
0.4797622561454773,
0.9696019291877747,
-0.7166850566864014,
0.5735896229743958,
0.024438263848423958,
-0.11877265572547913,
-0.10561642050743103,
-0.7640613317489624,
-0.6273355484008789,
-0.81220543384552,
-0.32240408658981323,
-0.42907726764678955,
0.14456677436828613,
0.9210061430931091,
0.5697700381278992,
-0.703890323638916,
-0.2347993701696396,
0.06874196976423264,
0.39005881547927856,
-0.9654363989830017,
-0.244437575340271,
0.29407474398612976,
-0.1952114701271057,
-0.477230429649353,
0.4456903636455536,
0.4381602704524994,
-0.27911391854286194,
-0.2932690382003784,
-0.09842396527528763,
-0.9161596894264221,
0.42013245820999146,
1.1218962669372559,
0.36622244119644165,
-0.7191488146781921,
-0.4840908348560333,
0.34939926862716675,
0.1221967414021492,
-0.0935528427362442,
1.0646809339523315,
-0.45757830142974854,
0.4372573792934418,
0.628894567489624,
0.8358269333839417,
0.2818693518638611,
0.2519061267375946,
0.6603513956069946,
-0.7022094130516052,
-0.23816515505313873,
0.18322569131851196,
0.08653395622968674,
-0.2019106149673462,
-0.10605563223361969,
0.48375198245048523,
0.2635388970375061,
-0.33143776655197144,
-0.7568594217300415,
0.6618734002113342,
-1.2630599737167358,
-0.38347822427749634,
1.1909396648406982,
-0.24018031358718872,
-0.3286140561103821,
-0.2407611608505249,
-0.14408855140209198,
0.12345004081726074,
-0.16014494001865387,
0.58078533411026,
0.8315335512161255,
-0.055643290281295776,
-0.25120654702186584,
-0.3115241229534149,
0.2111463099718094,
0.2609165608882904,
-1.018396019935608,
0.1716948002576828,
0.5697677135467529,
0.02535831369459629,
0.4733223617076874,
0.5893338322639465,
-0.3452587425708771,
0.5346201062202454,
-0.18145841360092163,
-0.07003148645162582,
0.1214202493429184,
-0.8024247884750366,
-0.13276106119155884,
0.5712199807167053,
-0.0057605872862041,
0.0421101339161396
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17344v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17344v2
|
Disambiguate Entity Matching using Large Language Models through Relation Discovery
| 2024-03-26T03:07:32 | 2024-05-29T14:40:55 |
Zezhou Huang
|
cs.DB
|
cs.DB, cs.CL
|
Entity matching is a critical challenge in data integration and cleaning,
central to tasks like fuzzy joins and deduplication. Traditional approaches
have focused on overcoming fuzzy term representations through methods such as
edit distance, Jaccard similarity, and more recently, embeddings and deep
neural networks, including advancements from large language models (LLMs) like
GPT. However, the core challenge in entity matching extends beyond term
fuzziness to the ambiguity in defining what constitutes a "match," especially
when integrating with external databases. This ambiguity arises due to varying
levels of detail and granularity among entities, complicating exact matches. We
propose a novel approach that shifts focus from purely identifying semantic
similarities to understanding and defining the "relations" between entities as
crucial for resolving ambiguities in matching. By predefining a set of
relations relevant to the task at hand, our method allows analysts to navigate
the spectrum of similarity more effectively, from exact matches to conceptually
related entities.
|
[
-0.6170927882194519,
-0.7380915284156799,
1.0657107830047607,
-0.030880602076649666,
-0.28961998224258423,
0.281177818775177,
-0.1259278506040573,
-0.5447683930397034,
0.2143499106168747,
0.5715694427490234,
-0.6579034328460693,
-0.5525768399238586,
-0.36287596821784973,
0.08269858360290527,
-0.526690661907196,
0.741454005241394,
-0.24100063741207123,
-0.18155963718891144,
-0.3844169080257416,
-0.1374126672744751,
-0.2641400694847107,
-0.3848268687725067,
-0.599947988986969,
-0.4042165279388428,
0.596413791179657,
0.14141541719436646,
0.9629276394844055,
0.9185500144958496,
0.6262595057487488,
0.38004356622695923,
-0.19681726396083832,
0.34324583411216736,
-0.48985305428504944,
0.29935649037361145,
-0.5024571418762207,
-0.3563063144683838,
-0.1104789674282074,
-0.29512783885002136,
0.6128742694854736,
1.2372689247131348,
-0.2490241974592209,
0.2446446269750595,
-0.08782406151294708,
0.6341555714607239,
-0.599838137626648,
0.37717321515083313,
-1.0981253385543823,
0.027167337015271187,
-0.45488104224205017,
0.019093774259090424,
-0.050185780972242355,
0.10469640046358109,
0.14389453828334808,
-0.844584047794342,
0.4139246344566345,
0.1897028535604477,
1.2119728326797485,
0.38173410296440125,
-0.5486003160476685,
-0.37840142846107483,
-0.9823265671730042,
0.19552507996559143,
-0.4623904824256897,
0.5910965204238892,
0.2970074415206909,
0.10723311454057693,
-0.37668514251708984,
-0.5173936486244202,
-0.7402500510215759,
-0.14121274650096893,
-0.304090291261673,
-0.31477653980255127,
-0.023528244346380234,
0.19816277921199799,
0.5636254549026489,
0.5314250588417053,
-0.44804590940475464,
0.07288176566362381,
0.0053349146619439125,
0.037483736872673035,
0.4793025255203247,
0.07566577941179276,
0.3657800853252411,
0.18868936598300934,
-0.41076093912124634,
0.10476185381412506,
-0.7437419295310974,
-0.6532120704650879,
0.28853586316108704,
0.3967234790325165,
0.3731100857257843,
0.5166636109352112,
-0.2361621856689453,
0.6054649949073792,
0.26896512508392334,
0.24576435983181,
0.24080483615398407,
-0.4772884249687195,
-0.2169414609670639,
0.24408791959285736,
0.7118425965309143,
0.21515876054763794,
0.4209049940109253,
-0.46350008249282837,
-0.18447808921337128,
0.016653310507535934,
0.09412004053592682,
-0.52226322889328,
-0.49541333317756653,
-0.11199475824832916,
-0.17419005930423737,
0.1004830077290535,
0.06497014313936234,
-0.7227665781974792,
-0.5138728618621826,
-0.6989253163337708,
0.5429747104644775,
-0.31040307879447937,
-0.4790664613246918,
-0.1387106031179428,
0.17390567064285278,
0.36662209033966064,
0.16015201807022095,
-0.8719996213912964,
0.37275394797325134,
1.0762252807617188,
0.9062328338623047,
0.23246793448925018,
-0.13620294630527496,
-0.4043276309967041,
0.4083387553691864,
-0.32911306619644165,
0.5990269780158997,
-0.6842960119247437,
-0.2282266616821289,
-0.0581088624894619,
-0.1800805926322937,
0.0042284633964300156,
-0.721683144569397,
0.22327782213687897,
-0.7888509035110474,
-0.08333619683980942,
-0.37567803263664246,
-0.7367900609970093,
-0.10991300642490387,
0.12673573195934296,
-0.8506354093551636,
0.999237060546875,
0.20387551188468933,
-0.7037365436553955,
0.49620336294174194,
-0.5594784021377563,
-0.4532104432582855,
0.08129352331161499,
-0.20471373200416565,
-0.34223270416259766,
0.10365671664476395,
0.036615435034036636,
0.40833306312561035,
-0.4261312484741211,
0.37968841195106506,
-0.6387982964515686,
-0.37053412199020386,
-0.04587600380182266,
0.32134196162223816,
0.5749850869178772,
0.1835295706987381,
-0.2423136681318283,
-0.15715321898460388,
-0.6133387684822083,
-0.37816596031188965,
0.21361976861953735,
0.2582874000072479,
-1.0747867822647095,
0.10482882708311081,
-0.27047571539878845,
0.2572982907295227,
0.25781556963920593,
-0.20881251990795135,
0.18739883601665497,
-0.4362121820449829,
0.4487241208553314,
0.49880921840667725,
0.03446037322282791,
0.5871235132217407,
-0.06062861904501915,
0.19473114609718323,
0.39373868703842163,
-0.2655775845050812,
-0.052280399948358536,
-0.15373454988002777,
-0.6932384967803955,
-0.22082267701625824,
0.7237415909767151,
0.5508620142936707,
-0.8217208981513977,
0.6196690797805786,
-0.6733939051628113,
-0.5249571204185486,
-0.7453457117080688,
0.3037569224834442,
0.2445196807384491,
0.6366832852363586,
0.41997531056404114,
-0.3016018271446228,
-0.4468557834625244,
-1.1093740463256836,
-0.2199954241514206,
-0.10925989598035812,
-0.2323867678642273,
0.3109859228134155,
0.6372900605201721,
-0.29900047183036804,
0.7701758742332458,
-0.7490208148956299,
-0.5875681638717651,
0.3938726782798767,
-0.1881771683692932,
0.20237627625465393,
0.4056343734264374,
0.6194422841072083,
-1.1222617626190186,
-0.597091794013977,
0.1444855034351349,
-0.6142223477363586,
0.1680377572774887,
-0.0749235674738884,
-0.3848598599433899,
-0.24479828774929047,
0.6567447185516357,
-0.7181136608123779,
0.05530352145433426,
0.10346246510744095,
-0.4692080318927765,
-0.025488771498203278,
-0.015015550889074802,
0.26408252120018005,
-1.2567601203918457,
0.15849222242832184,
0.06802261620759964,
-0.3135475516319275,
-0.6343468427658081,
0.36362960934638977,
-0.04442580044269562,
-0.040403928607702255,
-0.127043217420578,
0.3680420517921448,
-0.6637623906135559,
-0.0947684794664383,
0.13900625705718994,
0.5883936882019043,
-0.0701775774359703,
0.30055633187294006,
0.021413935348391533,
0.5237143039703369,
0.715839684009552,
-0.6588035821914673,
0.5757781863212585,
0.5481749773025513,
-0.14491978287696838,
0.9192630052566528,
-0.36445167660713196,
0.12379690259695053,
-0.14478300511837006,
0.17601139843463898,
-0.742473840713501,
-0.24484223127365112,
0.4019244611263275,
-0.23243224620819092,
0.43671709299087524,
-0.31363651156425476,
-0.7253922820091248,
-0.12661437690258026,
-0.2352115362882614,
0.7115406394004822,
0.2115352898836136,
-0.5409289598464966,
0.8061200380325317,
0.3997623920440674,
-0.15604543685913086,
-0.6939511299133301,
-0.5289083123207092,
0.2641552686691284,
-0.49256059527397156,
-0.5381704568862915,
0.6556141376495361,
0.20140399038791656,
-0.4690095782279968,
0.3391265869140625,
-0.46205106377601624,
-0.4681864380836487,
0.4380689263343811,
0.1896137148141861,
0.30025365948677063,
-0.35788077116012573,
0.3637757897377014,
-0.17029882967472076,
0.10246270149946213,
0.059811193495988846,
-0.26649773120880127,
0.3585536479949951,
0.29030948877334595,
-0.28275978565216064,
0.00011328083201078698,
0.6238852143287659,
0.46809667348861694,
-0.4617113471031189,
0.8519378304481506,
0.40598031878471375,
-0.9391769766807556,
0.007757775019854307,
-0.6677207350730896,
-0.00667261378839612,
-0.46114543080329895,
0.4822862148284912,
-0.7736284732818604,
-0.7178067564964294,
0.7433131337165833,
-0.19187606871128082,
-0.19779027998447418,
0.42742034792900085,
0.20401118695735931,
0.05682620778679848,
0.7423611879348755,
0.6632969379425049,
-0.22821082174777985,
0.3454824388027191,
0.15658795833587646,
0.5582195520401001,
-0.7688494324684143,
-0.3058231472969055,
-0.717170774936676,
-0.23848673701286316,
-0.776107907295227,
-0.41725316643714905,
-0.19979983568191528,
0.19764643907546997,
-0.31272998452186584,
0.5622686743736267,
-0.3434806764125824,
0.7095921635627747,
0.43400341272354126,
0.026172839105129242,
0.6031369566917419,
-0.358852356672287,
0.039836153388023376,
0.021943029016256332,
-0.17226390540599823,
-0.3487284183502197,
0.818998396396637,
0.0897618755698204,
0.607066810131073,
0.31688886880874634,
1.1165605783462524,
-0.000026613750378601253,
0.17846931517124176,
-0.8394211530685425,
0.4923205077648163,
-0.08307038247585297,
-0.5956838130950928,
-0.21722152829170227,
-0.9189876317977905,
-1.1055082082748413,
0.19583362340927124,
-0.39014166593551636,
-0.7312719821929932,
0.12317425012588501,
0.2593957483768463,
-0.1913507729768753,
0.29057371616363525,
-0.5108161568641663,
0.8661190867424011,
-0.07919818162918091,
-0.09143643081188202,
-0.0517524890601635,
-0.5590785145759583,
0.3765888512134552,
-0.39273756742477417,
0.2166242003440857,
-0.2281331717967987,
-0.26529014110565186,
0.4758964776992798,
-0.20645134150981903,
0.10912510752677917,
-0.013617892749607563,
-0.37587034702301025,
-0.11072696000337601,
0.4155595898628235,
0.43304744362831116,
0.11327007412910461,
-0.018721776083111763,
0.08668408542871475,
0.19393859803676605,
-0.34523332118988037,
-0.7014040946960449,
1.1424076557159424,
-0.3255784511566162,
-0.6251251697540283,
-0.35517773032188416,
-0.3641752600669861,
-0.35142961144447327,
0.35955700278282166,
-0.19652380049228668,
-0.07008277624845505,
-0.3261222839355469,
-0.14564988017082214,
0.9694742560386658,
0.23033201694488525,
0.06996038556098938,
0.4056571424007416,
-0.18930889666080475,
0.13557101786136627,
0.7087664008140564,
0.02448578178882599,
0.05050020292401314,
0.565467119216919,
-0.4708715081214905,
-0.6304733753204346,
-0.4532304108142853,
-0.2053922861814499,
0.4737647771835327,
-0.6095200181007385,
-0.35926398634910583,
-0.5721681118011475,
0.16863861680030823,
-0.13904017210006714,
0.19281703233718872,
-0.18343251943588257,
0.020976565778255463,
-0.3957182466983795,
0.11686626821756363,
0.20931565761566162,
0.769633948802948,
0.11509542167186737,
-0.1189202293753624,
-0.7537724375724792,
0.5473408102989197,
0.2110474556684494,
0.7127887010574341,
-0.09107086062431335,
-0.1532794088125229,
0.03030317649245262,
0.16200436651706696,
0.006633518263697624,
-1.1673922538757324,
-0.12571455538272858,
0.4161660373210907,
0.38818618655204773,
0.23126956820487976,
0.12917988002300262,
1.0875240564346313,
-0.768637478351593,
0.4276277720928192,
0.09317293018102646,
-1.1984063386917114,
0.4938048720359802,
-0.1632182002067566,
-0.2985498011112213,
0.6858997941017151,
0.7454710602760315,
-0.5567302107810974,
-0.06409572809934616,
-0.7075012922286987,
-1.2197235822677612,
0.4280870854854584,
0.23022213578224182,
0.08044753968715668,
-0.0988294929265976,
0.7018706202507019,
-0.280551940202713,
0.41023316979408264,
-0.5847789645195007,
-0.3499429523944855,
0.3676912188529968,
-0.4783180058002472,
-0.17993485927581787,
0.12165164947509766,
-0.14545105397701263,
-0.06754687428474426,
0.7440452575683594,
-0.02342212200164795,
0.18694299459457397,
0.13591177761554718,
-0.4642382860183716,
-0.06781564652919769,
0.010096641257405281,
0.11922542005777359,
0.678093433380127,
0.13040927052497864,
0.2985439896583557,
0.3720165491104126,
-0.037198930978775024,
0.10837162286043167,
0.6115676164627075,
0.06478472799062729,
0.25007060170173645,
0.285531610250473,
0.4311729967594147,
0.28167828917503357,
-0.6028506755828857,
0.4727683961391449,
0.14546577632427216,
-0.13110794126987457,
-0.2775132656097412,
-0.06787515431642532,
0.5215317010879517,
0.3460651934146881,
0.2905525863170624,
-0.2968937158584595,
0.35356733202934265,
-0.7209598422050476,
0.34407922625541687,
0.6802843809127808,
-0.4118623733520508,
-0.05246772989630699,
0.6516803503036499,
0.12138718366622925,
-0.35546454787254333,
0.8624831438064575,
-0.30536791682243347,
-0.5110049843788147,
0.49486851692199707,
0.13695533573627472,
0.5747832655906677,
-0.19022242724895477,
-0.15702110528945923,
0.25346773862838745,
0.06992827355861664,
-0.28599312901496887,
-0.17869701981544495,
-0.11968840658664703,
-0.6479942202568054,
-0.5945826172828674,
-0.5108456015586853,
-0.16120576858520508,
0.12831972539424896,
-0.8997833132743835,
0.4428618252277374,
-0.13714854419231415,
0.04656226560473442,
0.411540150642395,
-0.010454862378537655,
-0.919318675994873,
0.0437149815261364,
0.35323503613471985,
0.737604558467865,
-0.8464077115058899,
0.6868918538093567,
0.8017147779464722,
-0.5459232926368713,
-0.8241927027702332,
0.14993618428707123,
-0.15867120027542114,
-0.5080422163009644,
0.4070781469345093,
0.0629102811217308,
0.16746851801872253,
0.04932515695691109,
-0.15778109431266785,
-0.8250144720077515,
1.1001088619232178,
0.7084394097328186,
-0.9520007967948914,
-0.5019501447677612,
0.07900158315896988,
0.5472083687782288,
-0.29009437561035156,
0.09209032356739044,
0.8583893775939941,
0.38293004035949707,
-0.03650461137294769,
-1.1059510707855225,
0.4022144675254822,
0.021590646356344223,
0.08188110589981079,
0.8971570134162903,
-0.3253836929798126,
0.5306051969528198,
-0.0916546955704689,
-0.4541913568973541,
0.013759459368884563,
0.5543869137763977,
-0.2721394896507263,
0.3104564845561981,
0.6674764156341553,
0.7112873196601868,
0.9744465947151184,
-0.36614182591438293,
0.45704931020736694,
-0.13566455245018005,
0.7392006516456604,
1.4711791276931763,
-0.701074481010437,
0.7224881649017334,
0.5992393493652344,
-0.25574877858161926,
0.45072847604751587,
0.8500827550888062,
-0.33075830340385437,
0.26698020100593567,
0.5112962126731873,
-0.25525686144828796,
-0.5152809619903564,
-0.12848570942878723,
-0.3683527112007141,
0.34481051564216614,
0.3393409252166748,
-0.4600769579410553,
-0.4369238018989563,
-0.38398435711860657,
-0.006577958818525076,
0.5489804148674011,
-0.326530396938324,
1.0964711904525757,
0.012574720196425915,
-0.47937819361686707,
0.25954699516296387,
-0.38340064883232117,
0.5475262999534607,
-0.4326431453227997,
-0.33918097615242004,
0.038754772394895554,
0.034916285425424576,
-0.13174527883529663,
-0.8327138423919678,
0.2923937141895294,
-0.38408493995666504,
-0.2886415421962738,
0.2259225845336914,
0.4137418270111084,
-0.8394397497177124,
-0.1341274231672287,
0.6307347416877747,
0.5213527679443359,
-0.09659990668296814,
-0.42722728848457336,
-0.7274624109268188,
-0.23594771325588226,
-0.14631468057632446,
0.0477139949798584,
0.35230734944343567,
0.87873375415802,
-0.04452218860387802,
0.6330289244651794,
0.42264771461486816,
-0.09284042567014694,
-0.26156899333000183,
-0.255805104970932,
0.9099476337432861,
-0.707948625087738,
-0.2004043012857437,
-1.149161696434021,
0.1114242672920227,
-0.21364539861679077,
-0.023800276219844818,
0.31906431913375854,
0.7199754118919373,
1.1340694427490234,
-0.041432593017816544,
0.4391651153564453,
-0.05592324957251549,
0.3504295349121094,
-0.441677451133728,
0.5288094282150269,
-0.5318716764450073,
0.3394736051559448,
-0.5086211562156677,
-1.3397222757339478,
-0.3409208357334137,
0.6506549715995789,
0.019438758492469788,
-0.06924466788768768,
0.5634759068489075,
0.808897078037262,
-0.531296968460083,
-0.3940305709838867,
0.1065138503909111,
0.3854063153266907,
0.13148640096187592,
0.7622309923171997,
0.7608124613761902,
-0.3030420243740082,
0.6998385787010193,
-0.15774604678153992,
-0.10616685450077057,
-0.0326894074678421,
-0.8898613452911377,
-0.8683418035507202,
-0.96809321641922,
-0.6156609058380127,
-0.39893093705177307,
0.13058646023273468,
1.1577849388122559,
0.3764288127422333,
-0.6040579676628113,
0.17391815781593323,
0.08558376878499985,
0.2532101273536682,
-0.06383012235164642,
-0.2112208604812622,
0.27719545364379883,
0.01312810368835926,
-0.8923805952072144,
0.0027421757113188505,
0.0792284682393074,
0.12824700772762299,
-0.16980645060539246,
0.2794504165649414,
-0.517195463180542,
0.02031726762652397,
0.28535497188568115,
0.12259130924940109,
-0.7356153130531311,
-0.4067079424858093,
-0.2565082311630249,
0.10609941929578781,
-0.09474318474531174,
0.6812102794647217,
-0.5967919826507568,
0.2220289260149002,
0.27437683939933777,
0.8385982513427734,
0.43021637201309204,
-0.0006389137706719339,
0.4777272939682007,
-0.7635615468025208,
-0.0826178565621376,
0.3548153042793274,
0.4825764298439026,
0.5764951705932617,
-0.5158191323280334,
0.7991787195205688,
0.08231070637702942,
-0.353956013917923,
-1.1089532375335693,
0.579613208770752,
-1.008339762687683,
-0.1548420637845993,
0.8908867239952087,
-0.3744579255580902,
0.09896760433912277,
-0.22880640625953674,
-0.15846985578536987,
0.4112868010997772,
-0.16836987435817719,
0.7196431159973145,
0.7161911129951477,
0.12768200039863586,
0.1759616881608963,
-0.21364280581474304,
0.6045894026756287,
0.15606270730495453,
-0.55936598777771,
0.13569720089435577,
0.3454631268978119,
0.4948852062225342,
0.46366575360298157,
0.19537170231342316,
0.09104370325803757,
0.11508650332689285,
-0.19898205995559692,
-0.19426533579826355,
-0.0024049878120422363,
-0.03713497146964073,
-0.0753166601061821,
-0.09188207983970642,
0.20502053201198578,
-0.1390857845544815
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17343v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17343v3
|
Residual-based Language Models are Free Boosters for Biomedical Imaging
| 2024-03-26T03:05:20 | 2024-03-28T21:28:00 |
Zhixin Lai, Jing Wu, Suiyao Chen, Yucheng Zhou, Naira Hovakimyan
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In this study, we uncover the unexpected efficacy of residual-based large
language models (LLMs) as part of encoders for biomedical imaging tasks, a
domain traditionally devoid of language or textual data. The approach diverges
from established methodologies by utilizing a frozen transformer block,
extracted from pre-trained LLMs, as an innovative encoder layer for the direct
processing of visual tokens. This strategy represents a significant departure
from the standard multi-modal vision-language frameworks, which typically hinge
on language-driven prompts and inputs. We found that these LLMs could boost
performance across a spectrum of biomedical imaging applications, including
both 2D and 3D visual classification tasks, serving as plug-and-play boosters.
More interestingly, as a byproduct, we found that the proposed framework
achieved superior performance, setting new state-of-the-art results on
extensive, standardized datasets in MedMNIST-2D and 3D. Through this work, we
aim to open new avenues for employing LLMs in biomedical imaging and enriching
the understanding of their potential in this specialized domain.
|
[
-0.1566454917192459,
-0.39325663447380066,
0.6628215909004211,
-0.288352370262146,
-0.4689403772354126,
0.3820503056049347,
0.03181372955441475,
-0.5185806751251221,
0.27259352803230286,
0.6475335359573364,
-0.37413620948791504,
-0.33769339323043823,
-0.6479791402816772,
0.45700955390930176,
-0.4227970540523529,
0.7181906700134277,
0.006973476614803076,
0.5593490600585938,
-0.5831915140151978,
-0.19137784838676453,
-0.4166927933692932,
-0.3400304615497589,
-0.5827723741531372,
-0.5671469569206238,
0.7761518955230713,
-0.024631207808852196,
0.7553253769874573,
0.8723210096359253,
0.5614891648292542,
0.181749165058136,
-0.04217851534485817,
-0.06280887126922607,
-0.5599932074546814,
-0.02100597508251667,
-0.0891369953751564,
-0.3268609941005707,
-0.3830643892288208,
-0.3308826982975006,
0.648699164390564,
1.0197489261627197,
0.04982319474220276,
-0.15380503237247467,
-0.03522123023867607,
0.5051419734954834,
-0.619707465171814,
0.03762703761458397,
-0.549805760383606,
-0.2338877171278,
0.02608947455883026,
-0.5577502250671387,
-0.6619895100593567,
-0.09900417923927307,
-0.12569966912269592,
-0.5021711587905884,
0.10315114259719849,
-0.16575205326080322,
1.1344919204711914,
0.18438278138637543,
-0.4446922540664673,
-0.1476285606622696,
-0.7334871888160706,
0.5558741688728333,
-0.6305971741676331,
0.5442553162574768,
0.04045744240283966,
0.28688859939575195,
-0.21766382455825806,
-0.9116752743721008,
-0.1664551943540573,
-0.1878242790699005,
-0.09078573435544968,
0.3223245143890381,
-0.566429615020752,
0.08432399481534958,
0.12463778257369995,
0.28389009833335876,
-0.5131016373634338,
0.4316551089286804,
-0.5012047290802002,
-0.1692356914281845,
0.04191703349351883,
0.1321127861738205,
0.329583078622818,
0.20648851990699768,
-0.4750390946865082,
0.1079750582575798,
-0.9949994683265686,
-0.33743080496788025,
-0.2408503293991089,
0.06513874977827072,
-0.08698146045207977,
0.670187771320343,
0.08772151917219162,
0.8121045827865601,
-0.12991608679294586,
-0.08967205137014389,
0.3189134895801544,
0.051054928451776505,
-0.24635256826877594,
-0.284773051738739,
0.6038357019424438,
0.27779898047447205,
0.06702598184347153,
-0.33012518286705017,
-0.203281432390213,
0.12540477514266968,
-0.03606539964675903,
-0.9134460091590881,
0.11061246693134308,
0.30894604325294495,
-0.7676409482955933,
-0.3351321220397949,
-0.3371114730834961,
-0.7502830624580383,
-0.4666202664375305,
-0.19105204939842224,
0.32412755489349365,
-0.622157871723175,
-0.2780704200267792,
0.5606561303138733,
-0.2620913088321686,
0.5096719861030579,
0.13444840908050537,
-0.5222534537315369,
0.18850620090961456,
0.4423377811908722,
0.6954256296157837,
-0.05038394778966904,
-0.022963134571909904,
-0.4792885184288025,
0.22951257228851318,
-0.6987022161483765,
0.9293783903121948,
-0.6712853312492371,
-0.49657613039016724,
0.12095098197460175,
0.1643211990594864,
0.1214480996131897,
-0.6656538248062134,
0.4601658284664154,
-0.603556215763092,
0.24415560066699982,
-0.140838161110878,
-0.41250845789909363,
-0.2641172707080841,
0.020587947219610214,
-0.7486217617988586,
0.5862662196159363,
0.06445945054292679,
-0.42906463146209717,
0.395124226808548,
-0.3202621340751648,
-0.2885914444923401,
0.5591378808021545,
-0.5237904191017151,
-0.31539297103881836,
0.29052338004112244,
0.2090153843164444,
0.557349443435669,
-0.5549611449241638,
0.4738257825374603,
-0.4277496635913849,
-0.5455889105796814,
0.6392844915390015,
-0.5659476518630981,
0.5118902325630188,
-0.03617379069328308,
-0.2275170087814331,
0.038245756179094315,
-0.8372929096221924,
-0.28278690576553345,
0.18088732659816742,
-0.17253811657428741,
-0.42553430795669556,
-0.0695793479681015,
-0.04383865371346474,
0.27512285113334656,
-0.011326641775667667,
-0.9290334582328796,
-0.025125965476036072,
-0.43736639618873596,
0.28676819801330566,
0.4289846420288086,
-0.25137564539909363,
0.2922348976135254,
-0.3617945909500122,
0.5902873277664185,
-0.09232374280691147,
-0.2567465007305145,
-0.5122294425964355,
-0.46423667669296265,
-0.8106710910797119,
-1.0882786512374878,
0.1478230357170105,
0.43895798921585083,
-1.0628613233566284,
0.2532352805137634,
-0.733584463596344,
-0.3242946267127991,
-0.7100311517715454,
-0.3946681022644043,
0.23587985336780548,
0.737582802772522,
0.5194944143295288,
-0.04316917806863785,
-0.47786182165145874,
-1.271106481552124,
0.048798028379678726,
0.07224737852811813,
-0.2555196285247803,
0.33195245265960693,
0.4648730456829071,
-0.5790261030197144,
0.8657041788101196,
-0.48115089535713196,
-0.22751104831695557,
-0.28092387318611145,
-0.0709836483001709,
0.40055376291275024,
0.4667641222476959,
0.44588130712509155,
-0.4137026369571686,
-0.046629469841718674,
0.17523717880249023,
-0.9990028738975525,
0.03438042476773262,
-0.3826823830604553,
-0.00990645308047533,
0.2265738844871521,
0.5967580080032349,
-0.5821141004562378,
0.4869135618209839,
0.49106529355049133,
-0.16458943486213684,
0.48453769087791443,
-0.32670897245407104,
0.12476244568824768,
-0.9757974147796631,
0.5507030487060547,
-0.23235686123371124,
-0.4046926200389862,
-0.6327710151672363,
-0.07255031168460846,
0.2537955343723297,
-0.35382768511772156,
-0.4011566638946533,
0.7670503258705139,
-0.7766692638397217,
-0.0024959915317595005,
-0.5800902247428894,
-0.3742751479148865,
0.06971108168363571,
0.12316162139177322,
0.29548171162605286,
0.4728318452835083,
0.9404112696647644,
-0.3178551197052002,
0.0934172123670578,
-0.015325766988098621,
-0.027834711596369743,
0.34953370690345764,
-0.6232205629348755,
0.07317034155130386,
-0.7015098929405212,
0.42998549342155457,
-0.9003260731697083,
-0.1723218858242035,
0.18715304136276245,
-0.4305039942264557,
0.8149755597114563,
-0.22249729931354523,
-0.35020849108695984,
-0.718173086643219,
-0.19648271799087524,
0.5124983787536621,
0.9224358797073364,
-0.5075997114181519,
0.8815173506736755,
0.13751359283924103,
0.1472005993127823,
-0.603134036064148,
-0.9555016160011292,
0.3865378499031067,
-0.1550838053226471,
-0.3397863209247589,
0.3573576509952545,
0.2013092339038849,
0.08331452310085297,
0.2934739291667938,
0.1942000389099121,
-0.016014382243156433,
-0.04141417518258095,
0.25433671474456787,
0.6261595487594604,
-0.3310563266277313,
0.1284659206867218,
0.0744783952832222,
-0.2718232572078705,
-0.12715621292591095,
-0.3459321856498718,
0.37340694665908813,
0.012780074961483479,
-0.5031038522720337,
-0.4061225950717926,
0.43999090790748596,
1.0212351083755493,
-0.07280563563108444,
0.7978014945983887,
0.5353419780731201,
-0.6303404569625854,
0.2147587537765503,
-0.6545621156692505,
-0.24768391251564026,
-0.5045022368431091,
0.8117942214012146,
-0.24881942570209503,
-0.9395536780357361,
0.4567983150482178,
-0.28654733300209045,
-0.16106899082660675,
0.32945019006729126,
0.7200950980186462,
-0.2201012521982193,
0.7339338660240173,
0.7282093167304993,
0.1184721365571022,
0.104474738240242,
-0.19411058723926544,
-0.004556948784738779,
-0.8900509476661682,
-0.5472388863563538,
-0.22054123878479004,
-0.2445814311504364,
-0.20247621834278107,
-0.6461760997772217,
0.26854872703552246,
-0.050430186092853546,
-0.07676844298839569,
-0.16143719851970673,
-0.41735783219337463,
0.4441382586956024,
0.10349717736244202,
0.21185144782066345,
0.07850464433431625,
0.41290995478630066,
-0.1680203527212143,
-0.025203043594956398,
-0.9007951617240906,
-0.5341827869415283,
1.0502535104751587,
0.44296544790267944,
1.0158865451812744,
-0.49004244804382324,
0.39422714710235596,
0.014487081207334995,
0.7876767516136169,
-1.0065548419952393,
0.5041576027870178,
-0.3315110504627228,
-0.33366212248802185,
0.10433915257453918,
-0.18513928353786469,
-1.330611228942871,
0.29025179147720337,
-0.11769381165504456,
-0.38498178124427795,
0.4265498220920563,
0.1948038637638092,
-0.23901374638080597,
0.573113739490509,
-0.2369084656238556,
0.5304187536239624,
-0.22961734235286713,
-0.46403807401657104,
0.011803152039647102,
-0.5039209127426147,
0.4285350739955902,
-0.2832813858985901,
0.39591488242149353,
0.032739847898483276,
-0.2816498279571533,
0.529994547367096,
-0.19322383403778076,
0.9958643913269043,
-0.1780526489019394,
-0.12642893195152283,
0.20608650147914886,
0.3166565001010895,
0.1868142932653427,
-0.14151008427143097,
0.11202932149171829,
0.5286951661109924,
-0.026526788249611855,
-0.34329384565353394,
-0.2894723415374756,
0.6585010886192322,
-0.42121222615242004,
-0.32524988055229187,
-0.3266572058200836,
-0.596325159072876,
-0.2715093195438385,
0.2986661195755005,
0.25033554434776306,
0.7991980314254761,
-0.07033102214336395,
0.5836427807807922,
0.5085857510566711,
-0.733213484287262,
0.46982917189598083,
0.6312592029571533,
-0.27574002742767334,
-0.6689452528953552,
0.8740587830543518,
-0.2292163372039795,
0.2339949905872345,
0.6862292289733887,
0.0411907322704792,
-0.3963804244995117,
-0.5061155557632446,
-0.42309120297431946,
0.8295706510543823,
-0.6407333016395569,
-0.5725666880607605,
-0.6047996282577515,
-0.14663124084472656,
-0.22474852204322815,
-0.28094765543937683,
-0.6265815496444702,
-0.0629023090004921,
-0.5842103362083435,
0.004055269528180361,
0.09503854811191559,
0.3533945679664612,
-0.09388014674186707,
-0.06479107588529587,
-1.0270384550094604,
0.20049703121185303,
-0.20491603016853333,
0.46378079056739807,
-0.09649503231048584,
-0.5274584889411926,
-0.4232661724090576,
0.12430889159440994,
0.11181294173002243,
-0.7247369289398193,
0.5401722192764282,
0.10465747863054276,
0.6438116431236267,
0.3299850821495056,
-0.35085391998291016,
0.5393359065055847,
-0.6213501691818237,
0.6561737060546875,
0.4454220235347748,
-0.4893034100532532,
0.15230058133602142,
-0.36420074105262756,
0.3695383071899414,
0.09408905357122421,
0.26872512698173523,
-0.34635016322135925,
-0.40897855162620544,
-0.21773459017276764,
-0.9106366634368896,
0.22147472202777863,
-0.025028951466083527,
0.23052459955215454,
-0.1522810012102127,
0.46148446202278137,
0.3681657016277313,
0.06333539634943008,
-0.8086085915565491,
-0.23778481781482697,
-0.13991257548332214,
-0.3140287399291992,
0.06688175350427628,
-0.46435484290122986,
-0.2608310282230377,
-0.06949374824762344,
0.2557414174079895,
-0.301046222448349,
0.6842712163925171,
0.21913866698741913,
-0.03734486550092697,
0.008791138418018818,
0.17757000029087067,
0.6319338083267212,
0.33323946595191956,
-0.12020061165094376,
0.15961292386054993,
-0.15119969844818115,
-0.33166077733039856,
0.15286040306091309,
0.040130551904439926,
-0.09803011268377304,
0.020656850188970566,
0.5748223066329956,
0.8981550931930542,
0.20068520307540894,
-0.8251866102218628,
0.42133820056915283,
0.14527858793735504,
-0.3683328628540039,
-0.0998794287443161,
-0.549038827419281,
0.1323297619819641,
0.03992549329996109,
0.6572064757347107,
0.23463396728038788,
0.10798081010580063,
-0.09849273413419724,
0.344870924949646,
0.6849620342254639,
-0.6277027726173401,
-0.4772757291793823,
0.6659224033355713,
0.1185678243637085,
0.2615940570831299,
0.5318050980567932,
0.4952394962310791,
-0.11050340533256531,
0.4009649455547333,
0.9573841094970703,
1.0063830614089966,
0.09684953093528748,
0.11427637189626694,
0.16843605041503906,
0.3864034414291382,
-0.07204462587833405,
0.17484156787395477,
0.40046316385269165,
-0.9284554719924927,
-0.6421653032302856,
-0.5038547515869141,
0.07809492945671082,
0.4263507127761841,
-0.5933270454406738,
0.28689858317375183,
-0.09035623073577881,
-0.2866414487361908,
-0.3753202557563782,
-0.9025324583053589,
-0.6819018125534058,
0.2442154437303543,
0.522377610206604,
0.8404297828674316,
-0.6908868551254272,
0.7015954256057739,
0.6283904910087585,
-0.3119005262851715,
-0.40088099241256714,
-0.24331307411193848,
-0.3274664580821991,
-0.7932668924331665,
0.7515228986740112,
0.08158968389034271,
-0.3958628177642822,
0.06949301809072495,
-0.4516054391860962,
-1.0674891471862793,
1.0162324905395508,
0.7277916669845581,
-0.35563531517982483,
-0.08259215205907822,
0.2681674659252167,
0.758074164390564,
-0.41221746802330017,
0.1942807286977768,
0.29458048939704895,
0.004460267722606659,
0.288572758436203,
-0.6242343783378601,
0.2969197630882263,
-0.1530366837978363,
0.021685980260372162,
-0.06405189633369446,
-0.27993521094322205,
0.5448985695838928,
-0.252180278301239,
-0.4051751494407654,
0.31642472743988037,
0.4437430799007416,
0.2087654024362564,
0.18488207459449768,
0.02498207986354828,
0.3207072913646698,
0.484060674905777,
-0.04336550086736679,
1.3767746686935425,
-0.47014695405960083,
0.12308561056852341,
0.6671537160873413,
-0.4358856678009033,
0.6562917828559875,
0.6616841554641724,
0.15834937989711761,
0.5419977307319641,
0.4146689474582672,
-0.14540939033031464,
0.5353059768676758,
0.02542961575090885,
-0.1751130223274231,
-0.37947461009025574,
-0.25125980377197266,
-0.6113706231117249,
0.3665216863155365,
0.46698224544525146,
-0.5060148239135742,
-0.28267335891723633,
0.49753937125205994,
-0.174397274851799,
-0.17458979785442352,
-0.2802128791809082,
0.4561176896095276,
0.29982972145080566,
-0.13877885043621063,
0.8690213561058044,
-0.10616321116685867,
0.806489884853363,
-0.6511542201042175,
-0.11344718188047409,
-0.34835273027420044,
0.208826944231987,
-0.0867900401353836,
-0.597104012966156,
0.29655390977859497,
-0.25633546710014343,
0.13202673196792603,
-0.3034786283969879,
0.9467061161994934,
-0.39684730768203735,
-0.7430842518806458,
0.3892177939414978,
0.641810953617096,
0.1413755714893341,
0.25257325172424316,
-0.3355036675930023,
0.1174381747841835,
-0.04034177213907242,
-0.03871205076575279,
0.341741681098938,
0.4045354723930359,
0.21565520763397217,
0.9489129781723022,
0.5789675712585449,
0.23528285324573517,
-0.24754641950130463,
-0.13021516799926758,
1.1444274187088013,
-0.6142507791519165,
0.01604533940553665,
-0.846451997756958,
0.6540384888648987,
0.1268477588891983,
0.2143322080373764,
0.43238067626953125,
1.0695130825042725,
0.42317116260528564,
-0.4779021739959717,
0.6283427476882935,
0.401496022939682,
0.5718703866004944,
-0.6249973177909851,
0.8171907663345337,
-0.8304705619812012,
0.2691202461719513,
-0.031745415180921555,
-0.48466265201568604,
-0.7434171438217163,
0.23196245729923248,
-0.018803821876645088,
-0.04938562214374542,
0.9037927389144897,
0.9187018275260925,
-0.018001435324549675,
-0.4540230333805084,
0.7378985285758972,
0.13295643031597137,
0.4671551585197449,
0.4296122193336487,
0.8912409543991089,
-0.2785278856754303,
0.6161602139472961,
0.282335489988327,
-0.4705609679222107,
-0.0392654724419117,
-0.695026695728302,
-0.7790401577949524,
-0.32501548528671265,
-0.41879597306251526,
-0.4592309296131134,
-0.07673579454421997,
0.5690423250198364,
0.41838324069976807,
-0.36212751269340515,
-0.11191073805093765,
0.13179101049900055,
-0.2341964840888977,
-0.05685703083872795,
-0.151999369263649,
0.37860265374183655,
-0.1321123093366623,
-0.592380166053772,
0.5734933614730835,
0.7292940020561218,
0.2682356536388397,
-0.10484985262155533,
0.09071297943592072,
0.10792186111211777,
-0.07400201261043549,
0.6114675402641296,
0.4572802484035492,
-0.8250919580459595,
-0.13285930454730988,
0.3122725784778595,
-0.41106951236724854,
0.11779703944921494,
1.0398412942886353,
-1.2908700704574585,
0.5078420639038086,
0.3099183142185211,
0.8883821964263916,
0.5035521388053894,
-0.19698411226272583,
0.7228144407272339,
-0.32209545373916626,
0.40319231152534485,
0.48567962646484375,
0.49332883954048157,
0.5756807327270508,
-0.25429484248161316,
0.18377728760242462,
0.4875542223453522,
-0.28207913041114807,
-1.0105712413787842,
0.10750769823789597,
-0.9742336273193359,
-0.5319336652755737,
1.4556150436401367,
-0.007311125285923481,
-0.28482022881507874,
-0.0855126604437828,
-0.1818549782037735,
0.1453791707754135,
-0.14892055094242096,
0.47863852977752686,
0.21048909425735474,
-0.21028971672058105,
-0.21356788277626038,
-0.16975651681423187,
0.3663327693939209,
0.2778041958808899,
-0.6891075968742371,
-0.06938272714614868,
0.8044182658195496,
0.42914053797721863,
-0.09217940270900726,
0.8809903860092163,
-0.5905358791351318,
0.1480410248041153,
0.056707147508859634,
0.21273232996463776,
-0.2996518611907959,
-0.19559156894683838,
-0.6159729957580566,
0.30940306186676025,
-0.096714548766613,
-0.33419108390808105
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17336v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17336v1
|
Don't Listen To Me: Understanding and Exploring Jailbreak Prompts of Large Language Models
| 2024-03-26T02:47:42 | 2024-03-26T02:47:42 |
Zhiyuan Yu, Xiaogeng Liu, Shunning Liang, Zach Cameron, Chaowei Xiao, Ning Zhang
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL
|
Recent advancements in generative AI have enabled ubiquitous access to large
language models (LLMs). Empowered by their exceptional capabilities to
understand and generate human-like text, these models are being increasingly
integrated into our society. At the same time, there are also concerns on the
potential misuse of this powerful technology, prompting defensive measures from
service providers. To overcome such protection, jailbreaking prompts have
recently emerged as one of the most effective mechanisms to circumvent security
restrictions and elicit harmful content originally designed to be prohibited.
Due to the rapid development of LLMs and their ease of access via natural
languages, the frontline of jailbreak prompts is largely seen in online forums
and among hobbyists. To gain a better understanding of the threat landscape of
semantically meaningful jailbreak prompts, we systemized existing prompts and
measured their jailbreak effectiveness empirically. Further, we conducted a
user study involving 92 participants with diverse backgrounds to unveil the
process of manually creating jailbreak prompts. We observed that users often
succeeded in jailbreak prompts generation regardless of their expertise in
LLMs. Building on the insights from the user study, we also developed a system
using AI as the assistant to automate the process of jailbreak prompt
generation.
|
[
-0.5054671764373779,
-1.0441323518753052,
0.7964352965354919,
0.1762516349554062,
-0.054789718240499496,
0.1831478327512741,
-0.17637723684310913,
-0.4138999581336975,
0.2801162600517273,
0.629768967628479,
-0.7875494360923767,
-0.43532443046569824,
-0.4829760789871216,
0.37618038058280945,
-0.38222363591194153,
0.9481257796287537,
0.15801143646240234,
-0.1406862884759903,
0.10023947805166245,
0.22099141776561737,
-0.8991007804870605,
-0.3590222895145416,
-0.41468027234077454,
0.16292250156402588,
0.5083180069923401,
0.5707878470420837,
0.4741246998310089,
0.45606371760368347,
0.11702417582273483,
0.3101077973842621,
-0.31278377771377563,
-0.07767868787050247,
-0.2836306095123291,
0.4983941614627838,
-0.16300569474697113,
-0.3856261372566223,
-0.04805487394332886,
0.018094418570399284,
-0.16770215332508087,
0.42658793926239014,
0.04727495461702347,
0.17377151548862457,
-0.24748603999614716,
0.4736197292804718,
-0.4857957363128662,
-0.15797850489616394,
-0.7580811381340027,
0.03946910798549652,
-0.2891995310783386,
-0.07889527827501297,
-0.6739000678062439,
-0.5213225483894348,
-0.048495352268218994,
-0.3322772681713104,
0.06649044901132584,
0.15001246333122253,
0.2740723192691803,
0.27886104583740234,
-0.12405741959810257,
-0.4435262084007263,
-0.5664958357810974,
0.5281863212585449,
-0.5831553339958191,
0.001919051050208509,
0.5567432045936584,
0.4467344880104065,
-0.4702877998352051,
-0.21138803660869598,
-0.5549970269203186,
-0.6682361960411072,
0.14915455877780914,
-0.31437963247299194,
-0.5108476877212524,
-0.0372217632830143,
0.43540090322494507,
0.010278226807713509,
-0.6414868235588074,
0.3245706856250763,
-0.493913471698761,
-0.3217722177505493,
0.5915049910545349,
0.3290542960166931,
0.8404182195663452,
-0.32406023144721985,
-0.12591122090816498,
0.04914427176117897,
-0.9719204902648926,
-0.07237929105758667,
0.6736907958984375,
0.22875156998634338,
-0.18466663360595703,
0.6359695792198181,
0.008396468125283718,
0.8300734758377075,
0.08684160560369492,
-0.0012515813577920198,
-0.022152528166770935,
0.01340548973530531,
-0.0677904412150383,
0.16954055428504944,
1.215375304222107,
0.4494900703430176,
0.4522322714328766,
-0.42704102396965027,
-0.0022151460871100426,
-0.3267132341861725,
0.4349026381969452,
-0.6073329448699951,
-0.030871901661157608,
0.34899842739105225,
-0.4770195484161377,
-0.6099926829338074,
-0.12782496213912964,
-0.7402586936950684,
-0.8916975259780884,
-0.007840660400688648,
0.17275424301624298,
-0.4884520471096039,
-0.1406899094581604,
-0.19616125524044037,
-0.20041745901107788,
0.11326244473457336,
0.22415070235729218,
-1.1466727256774902,
-0.009286750108003616,
0.5450239777565002,
0.9938950538635254,
0.22948049008846283,
-0.07786346226930618,
-0.4473560154438019,
0.030008045956492424,
-0.21502557396888733,
0.5147294402122498,
-0.3943555951118469,
-0.8025262951850891,
-0.18456900119781494,
-0.03854125365614891,
0.07757258415222168,
-0.7847907543182373,
0.4774766266345978,
-0.4657764136791229,
-0.23978202044963837,
-0.19102421402931213,
-0.2882702648639679,
-0.07290521264076233,
0.19426916539669037,
-0.5606876611709595,
0.2896982431411743,
-0.09778021275997162,
-0.4881243407726288,
0.11012943834066391,
-0.5530745387077332,
-0.43173933029174805,
0.11266574263572693,
-0.06474527716636658,
-0.00030057039111852646,
0.22634613513946533,
0.42842069268226624,
0.3269043564796448,
-0.2078743427991867,
0.5031969547271729,
-0.4209677577018738,
-0.17503049969673157,
0.4239155948162079,
-0.4015199840068817,
0.9062218070030212,
0.48907405138015747,
-0.6176565885543823,
0.10318689793348312,
-0.2956588566303253,
-0.33622485399246216,
0.22180558741092682,
0.030854607000947,
-0.46617498993873596,
-0.172646626830101,
0.04670671373605728,
0.13486649096012115,
0.1965501755475998,
-0.6972254514694214,
0.24871836602687836,
-0.4148128032684326,
0.9436959624290466,
0.8819477558135986,
-0.02214001677930355,
0.1804719716310501,
-0.19367416203022003,
0.7559311985969543,
-0.1612125188112259,
0.1518472582101822,
-0.5981496572494507,
-0.3224261999130249,
0.014856298454105854,
0.05058257281780243,
-0.051873937249183655,
0.7601191401481628,
-0.3346909284591675,
0.4801423251628876,
0.195357546210289,
-0.588791012763977,
-0.6298736333847046,
0.33177822828292847,
0.3308933675289154,
0.6112192869186401,
0.4416343569755554,
0.12176710367202759,
-0.4955931603908539,
-0.9005727171897888,
-0.4687957763671875,
-0.44301268458366394,
0.0019407619256526232,
0.5247025489807129,
0.1687171310186386,
-0.34894952178001404,
0.8778994083404541,
-0.37426143884658813,
0.056454408913850784,
-0.5414500832557678,
0.08387333154678345,
0.25862622261047363,
0.4312252402305603,
0.594194769859314,
-0.4416605532169342,
-0.40961572527885437,
-0.24918232858181,
-1.0002021789550781,
-0.5653699040412903,
-0.30441224575042725,
0.12154774367809296,
-0.06053737923502922,
0.963901162147522,
-0.7144473791122437,
0.30796170234680176,
0.3421995937824249,
-0.6872103810310364,
0.8900153636932373,
-0.12107998877763748,
0.023752333596348763,
-0.9180142879486084,
-0.07810446619987488,
-0.0006219465285539627,
-0.21116720139980316,
-0.568332314491272,
0.1019965410232544,
-0.14006836712360382,
-0.3063172399997711,
-0.29572615027427673,
0.49496880173683167,
-0.2083660513162613,
0.01021051686257124,
-0.23692366480827332,
0.2718915641307831,
-0.20203109085559845,
-0.0886957049369812,
-0.4563286304473877,
1.1751587390899658,
0.32562100887298584,
-0.18269330263137817,
0.420712411403656,
0.5313644409179688,
-0.2837938070297241,
0.2685345709323883,
-0.9354826211929321,
0.2571691870689392,
-0.1311432272195816,
0.0052939425222575665,
-0.9001405835151672,
-0.1840449869632721,
0.5679919123649597,
-0.45181339979171753,
0.0806441679596901,
-0.22741477191448212,
-0.5494755506515503,
-0.27742353081703186,
-0.2284059375524521,
0.27752700448036194,
0.5255542397499084,
-0.6035817861557007,
0.1657998412847519,
0.6045061945915222,
-0.4634072482585907,
-0.25121447443962097,
-0.542820930480957,
0.6590166091918945,
-0.5072041749954224,
-0.8026071190834045,
-0.03422531858086586,
-0.30492982268333435,
-0.7628335952758789,
-0.39539477229118347,
0.026773685589432716,
0.16781876981258392,
0.6388760209083557,
0.60622638463974,
0.2674316465854645,
0.017602071166038513,
-0.07496438920497894,
0.326205313205719,
-0.11559772491455078,
0.46042826771736145,
-0.14495164155960083,
0.602713942527771,
-0.12208661437034607,
-0.14199881255626678,
-0.699487030506134,
0.33805331587791443,
0.7612388730049133,
-0.061479292809963226,
0.7856097221374512,
0.08990751951932907,
0.10790733993053436,
-0.14311955869197845,
-0.6038011312484741,
-0.14180022478103638,
-0.5169745087623596,
-0.09717690199613571,
-0.22347678244113922,
-1.0813713073730469,
0.4482768774032593,
-0.1694353073835373,
0.0499536395072937,
-0.0162382610142231,
0.5913242101669312,
-0.11681679636240005,
1.0828732252120972,
0.49611788988113403,
-0.4157954454421997,
0.5264348983764648,
0.12024308741092682,
0.29140421748161316,
-0.6640393137931824,
-0.4013960063457489,
-0.6684392690658569,
-0.21814195811748505,
-0.5154457092285156,
-0.08354655653238297,
0.23000705242156982,
0.19435496628284454,
-0.22410516440868378,
0.49430930614471436,
-0.377495676279068,
0.4543473422527313,
0.31978604197502136,
0.11512439697980881,
0.29001253843307495,
-0.25295770168304443,
0.021951979026198387,
0.027309013530611992,
-0.2710903584957123,
-0.8188552856445312,
0.9053690433502197,
0.424549400806427,
0.9835230708122253,
0.2802722752094269,
0.8290764689445496,
0.7465906143188477,
0.09787394106388092,
-0.8907171487808228,
0.6301708221435547,
0.00325286528095603,
-0.4417708218097687,
-0.12308575958013535,
-0.327910453081131,
-0.8661543130874634,
0.0416698195040226,
0.09190148860216141,
-1.0408216714859009,
0.008444628678262234,
0.19837747514247894,
-0.5241553783416748,
0.2711930274963379,
-0.8104651570320129,
0.8782941102981567,
-0.33426499366760254,
-0.010941113345324993,
-0.1233680471777916,
-0.730939507484436,
0.41780391335487366,
-0.11268021166324615,
0.7347918152809143,
-0.3072604835033417,
0.1307293027639389,
0.5142415165901184,
-0.8795173764228821,
1.0090081691741943,
-0.34340277314186096,
-0.1086941584944725,
0.4520244300365448,
0.4148959219455719,
0.45657458901405334,
0.25732001662254333,
-0.11002422124147415,
-0.026012960821390152,
-0.24893900752067566,
-0.053358934819698334,
-0.34232285618782043,
0.7536340355873108,
-0.8163185715675354,
-0.8456761240959167,
0.12634192407131195,
-0.5611151456832886,
-0.052556149661540985,
0.2598305344581604,
0.29961493611335754,
0.17691580951213837,
-0.2705957889556885,
-0.331004798412323,
0.6402641534805298,
-0.676939070224762,
0.45112669467926025,
0.20933112502098083,
-0.242057666182518,
-0.24329350888729095,
0.7408527731895447,
-0.2503768801689148,
-0.0503581240773201,
-0.05553872138261795,
0.29808324575424194,
-0.20001038908958435,
-0.6636307239532471,
-0.8641299605369568,
0.11938966065645218,
-0.5242369771003723,
-0.07043839991092682,
-0.674504816532135,
0.07328801602125168,
-0.46851345896720886,
-0.27524909377098083,
0.17530368268489838,
-0.32622042298316956,
-0.3308035135269165,
-0.2945137023925781,
0.6269342303276062,
0.8633506894111633,
-0.09797138720750809,
0.4833813011646271,
-1.205418586730957,
0.29794421792030334,
0.13371491432189941,
-0.040324095636606216,
-0.004134050570428371,
-0.45196494460105896,
0.030315766111016273,
-0.09196345508098602,
-0.19964684545993805,
-1.3103277683258057,
0.44003596901893616,
-0.08424349874258041,
0.5451108813285828,
0.3433362543582916,
0.37030842900276184,
0.4376024603843689,
-0.6253823041915894,
0.8066778182983398,
0.16576215624809265,
-1.2255350351333618,
0.9466524124145508,
-0.5876162052154541,
0.0842427909374237,
0.6962502002716064,
0.042706336826086044,
-0.6373498439788818,
-0.7833807468414307,
-0.3474682867527008,
-1.044135570526123,
0.60001540184021,
-0.08680102974176407,
0.6838589310646057,
-0.2879897952079773,
0.47848811745643616,
0.27325519919395447,
0.28397902846336365,
-0.5808936953544617,
-0.3296709954738617,
-0.2159723937511444,
-0.17528626322746277,
0.1179908886551857,
-0.2816845774650574,
-0.0413995198905468,
-0.04365570843219757,
0.36676013469696045,
0.12593257427215576,
-0.06094831973314285,
0.023935455828905106,
-0.4482212960720062,
-0.09371321648359299,
0.5893864035606384,
0.5812504291534424,
0.38317111134529114,
0.06882891058921814,
-0.09998129308223724,
-0.09717538952827454,
-0.560604453086853,
0.3490968942642212,
-0.057992879301309586,
-0.37366414070129395,
-0.04404086247086525,
0.35672512650489807,
0.8934535980224609,
-0.1679472029209137,
-1.1800765991210938,
0.5141147971153259,
-0.242155984044075,
-0.05350247770547867,
-0.43076303601264954,
0.2813217043876648,
-0.1890173852443695,
0.36662253737449646,
0.12941718101501465,
-0.07172778993844986,
0.24664795398712158,
-0.5180796384811401,
0.15507982671260834,
0.3944043517112732,
-0.424873411655426,
-0.38552233576774597,
0.8118282556533813,
0.260024756193161,
-0.46087753772735596,
0.9239720106124878,
-0.0895189493894577,
-0.3942594528198242,
0.6838879585266113,
0.6922932267189026,
1.182852864265442,
-0.07883617281913757,
0.4161810576915741,
0.2936114966869354,
0.5698176622390747,
0.13476142287254333,
0.15011867880821228,
-0.27886059880256653,
-0.6038845777511597,
-0.379959374666214,
-0.4686067998409271,
-0.36948615312576294,
0.23856869339942932,
-0.6997811198234558,
0.1528327912092209,
-0.9705386757850647,
-0.17097483575344086,
0.005104531534016132,
-0.6304919719696045,
-0.22645632922649384,
-0.1614266037940979,
0.269437700510025,
1.2968604564666748,
-0.8951456546783447,
0.43549883365631104,
0.5909284949302673,
-0.26786601543426514,
-0.8406794667243958,
0.23203042149543762,
0.2401338815689087,
-0.667787492275238,
0.5786877274513245,
0.5397012829780579,
0.09171757847070694,
-0.03725459426641464,
-0.883624792098999,
-0.25999292731285095,
0.6434565186500549,
0.4536445438861847,
-0.7726367115974426,
0.03255545720458031,
-0.11495710909366608,
0.3479689955711365,
-0.25186896324157715,
0.2602408528327942,
0.863475501537323,
0.5521903038024902,
0.01095604244619608,
-0.7485706806182861,
0.30294567346572876,
-0.32110023498535156,
-0.20938219130039215,
0.40623271465301514,
-0.39620837569236755,
0.6162477731704712,
-0.7592834234237671,
0.1567882001399994,
0.39642098546028137,
0.18844260275363922,
0.3480142056941986,
0.22237762808799744,
0.5263105034828186,
0.41721460223197937,
0.5993310809135437,
-0.043956104665994644,
0.9997548460960388,
-0.268327534198761,
-0.03232920542359352,
0.935750424861908,
-0.08010109513998032,
0.47886568307876587,
0.6086684465408325,
0.041419949382543564,
0.6578682065010071,
0.6466954350471497,
-0.34600961208343506,
0.5436005592346191,
0.31847745180130005,
-0.45780202746391296,
-0.35411641001701355,
-0.24341915547847748,
-0.22544243931770325,
0.39967602491378784,
0.4471168518066406,
-0.5662891268730164,
-0.3070330023765564,
0.4252163767814636,
0.2170531004667282,
0.18325501680374146,
-0.42158693075180054,
1.1269481182098389,
0.21543395519256592,
-0.39256665110588074,
0.3335520327091217,
0.17836149036884308,
0.5066993832588196,
-0.37407010793685913,
0.21462835371494293,
-0.09788648039102554,
-0.27017977833747864,
-0.15044401586055756,
-0.7135689854621887,
0.4465335011482239,
0.6836318969726562,
-0.24332109093666077,
-0.2640075087547302,
0.44752344489097595,
0.0956532210111618,
-0.05665915086865425,
0.48225101828575134,
0.4238566756248474,
0.4471745491027832,
-0.1071348637342453,
-0.7248754501342773,
0.22445648908615112,
0.05838095396757126,
-0.19033418595790863,
0.30289795994758606,
0.20296648144721985,
-0.08038656413555145,
0.7639948725700378,
0.7763903737068176,
0.04937746375799179,
-0.038408905267715454,
0.07400105893611908,
0.9059039950370789,
-0.8269367218017578,
-0.45787015557289124,
-1.3988630771636963,
0.49843844771385193,
0.09078902751207352,
-0.22447575628757477,
0.8010870814323425,
0.19375498592853546,
0.5621423721313477,
0.013153721578419209,
1.1814790964126587,
-0.3762015700340271,
0.28941407799720764,
-0.47774767875671387,
0.8485091924667358,
-0.3325061500072479,
0.7550796270370483,
-0.28571784496307373,
-0.45750582218170166,
-0.04948633909225464,
0.4751055836677551,
-0.6178387999534607,
-0.13846184313297272,
0.03674332797527313,
0.6506772637367249,
0.4566161334514618,
0.17381824553012848,
0.27569758892059326,
0.3687311112880707,
0.5193758606910706,
0.2575283944606781,
1.152019739151001,
-0.030985957011580467,
0.5943697094917297,
-0.012701990082859993,
-0.24169448018074036,
-0.24800483882427216,
-0.5851815938949585,
-1.0235652923583984,
-0.059967122972011566,
0.1042000874876976,
-0.5252559185028076,
0.021095501258969307,
1.10844886302948,
0.43495988845825195,
-0.8892784714698792,
-0.2008785456418991,
-0.3130321502685547,
0.25089526176452637,
0.3279021382331848,
-0.21015360951423645,
-0.17251171171665192,
-0.42010509967803955,
-0.4502410888671875,
0.9710872173309326,
0.2977418601512909,
0.13187596201896667,
-0.30148598551750183,
0.04805326089262962,
0.2865883708000183,
-0.08358103781938553,
0.39890751242637634,
0.470569908618927,
-0.7576658725738525,
-0.18189550936222076,
0.11909399926662445,
-0.11326764523983002,
-0.10370472073554993,
0.8251239657402039,
-0.7846241593360901,
0.5309637188911438,
0.39861559867858887,
0.6241523623466492,
0.09829074144363403,
0.08104994148015976,
0.8314760327339172,
-0.6281158924102783,
0.18841637670993805,
0.08357803523540497,
0.271030992269516,
0.3645167648792267,
-0.5829803347587585,
0.11744673550128937,
0.03860325738787651,
-0.5380701422691345,
-0.842633843421936,
0.421852171421051,
-0.5067276954650879,
-0.571022629737854,
0.8935607075691223,
-0.2315208613872528,
-0.19033370912075043,
-0.49014320969581604,
-0.535967230796814,
-0.03484409675002098,
-0.6971333026885986,
0.9378005266189575,
0.41150858998298645,
-0.13669541478157043,
-0.23133151233196259,
-0.7301584482192993,
0.2734092175960541,
0.13763518631458282,
-0.8516004085540771,
0.3106147050857544,
0.5613669753074646,
0.45390015840530396,
0.1575850397348404,
0.32182517647743225,
-0.07146302610635757,
0.22763691842556,
-0.1806332767009735,
-0.18762798607349396,
-0.3869261145591736,
-0.3442055284976959,
-0.7204198837280273,
0.13375498354434967,
0.35599228739738464,
0.030612938106060028
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17319v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17319v1
|
JMultiWOZ: A Large-Scale Japanese Multi-Domain Task-Oriented Dialogue Dataset
| 2024-03-26T02:01:18 | 2024-03-26T02:01:18 |
Atsumoto Ohashi, Ryu Hirai, Shinya Iizuka, Ryuichiro Higashinaka
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Dialogue datasets are crucial for deep learning-based task-oriented dialogue
system research. While numerous English language multi-domain task-oriented
dialogue datasets have been developed and contributed to significant
advancements in task-oriented dialogue systems, such a dataset does not exist
in Japanese, and research in this area is limited compared to that in English.
In this study, towards the advancement of research and development of
task-oriented dialogue systems in Japanese, we constructed JMultiWOZ, the first
Japanese language large-scale multi-domain task-oriented dialogue dataset.
Using JMultiWOZ, we evaluated the dialogue state tracking and response
generation capabilities of the state-of-the-art methods on the existing major
English benchmark dataset MultiWOZ2.2 and the latest large language model
(LLM)-based methods. Our evaluation results demonstrated that JMultiWOZ
provides a benchmark that is on par with MultiWOZ2.2. In addition, through
evaluation experiments of interactive dialogues with the models and human
participants, we identified limitations in the task completion capabilities of
LLMs in Japanese.
|
[
-0.6455005407333374,
-0.904538631439209,
0.4463430941104889,
0.19736386835575104,
-0.08546606451272964,
0.30818116664886475,
-0.47398027777671814,
-0.18643297255039215,
0.042882032692432404,
0.5047059059143066,
-1.0322773456573486,
-0.41720736026763916,
-0.7048975229263306,
0.1396292895078659,
0.14227823913097382,
0.8130539059638977,
0.029037723317742348,
0.21408528089523315,
-0.15665388107299805,
-0.23708578944206238,
-0.741398811340332,
-0.4621763825416565,
-0.6731934547424316,
-0.4696197211742401,
0.508479654788971,
0.40673986077308655,
0.5607411861419678,
-0.03763440251350403,
0.38264000415802,
0.24226810038089752,
0.33460038900375366,
0.5148243308067322,
-0.5630432963371277,
0.4664718210697174,
0.11814189702272415,
-0.5197300910949707,
-0.47715309262275696,
-0.26277482509613037,
0.5591581463813782,
0.9534018039703369,
-0.012142960913479328,
0.1479969322681427,
0.20143593847751617,
0.41744038462638855,
-0.6789733171463013,
0.6451400518417358,
-0.2796374559402466,
0.3524044454097748,
-0.3890029489994049,
-0.16226236522197723,
-0.5153594613075256,
0.0883171483874321,
0.17224746942520142,
-0.7310741543769836,
-0.04936867207288742,
0.1041642278432846,
0.261581152677536,
0.0018481039442121983,
-0.46796879172325134,
-0.11973804980516434,
-0.6806326508522034,
0.9758865833282471,
-0.9268819093704224,
0.3637494444847107,
0.29866406321525574,
0.23506994545459747,
-0.6164228320121765,
-0.43390893936157227,
-0.5334232449531555,
-0.16247154772281647,
0.06769322603940964,
0.2914939820766449,
-0.1280912309885025,
0.007779889740049839,
0.49127987027168274,
0.19393596053123474,
-0.5635560154914856,
0.259273499250412,
0.04349220171570778,
-0.1160443127155304,
0.536189079284668,
0.7796590328216553,
0.20262214541435242,
-0.17610405385494232,
-0.18631312251091003,
-0.10118936747312546,
-0.5191206932067871,
0.16215933859348297,
0.23225589096546173,
0.6139253377914429,
-0.10189680010080338,
0.3850593864917755,
-0.4363318681716919,
0.6071209907531738,
-0.07554829865694046,
-0.7205634117126465,
0.406244158744812,
-0.30183881521224976,
-0.25522536039352417,
-0.25667527318000793,
1.2145895957946777,
0.5156540274620056,
0.11873718351125717,
-0.18224838376045227,
0.04862337186932564,
-0.24667416512966156,
0.2738781273365021,
-0.8982869386672974,
0.08732816576957703,
0.21485988795757294,
-0.5630770325660706,
0.031638965010643005,
-0.2909604609012604,
-0.5595858097076416,
-0.33012497425079346,
-0.2995011806488037,
0.16265705227851868,
-0.2648407816886902,
-0.7422574162483215,
0.05058981850743294,
0.04551578685641289,
-0.06769470870494843,
0.43772080540657043,
-0.6067649126052856,
0.27980944514274597,
0.5828542113304138,
0.4798934757709503,
-0.44750458002090454,
-0.39964908361434937,
-0.07475782185792923,
0.025711672380566597,
-0.4880756735801697,
0.35671165585517883,
-0.6011978983879089,
-0.7682863473892212,
0.09253130108118057,
0.31917616724967957,
-0.1537117213010788,
-0.4692213833332062,
0.3799762725830078,
-0.23924566805362701,
0.34402960538864136,
0.008793006651103497,
-0.44465529918670654,
-0.22022826969623566,
0.30493852496147156,
-0.43282350897789,
0.7906713485717773,
0.08683094382286072,
-0.6681164503097534,
0.25461485981941223,
-0.7537209987640381,
-0.6714125871658325,
0.24215233325958252,
-0.1883852481842041,
-0.37474843859672546,
0.09811042249202728,
0.20292788743972778,
0.6357082724571228,
-0.49767324328422546,
0.7322161793708801,
-0.5597648620605469,
-0.27900224924087524,
0.3925500512123108,
-0.8696755170822144,
0.7335220575332642,
0.269441694021225,
-0.38173606991767883,
-0.3033943772315979,
-0.6553296446800232,
0.23269766569137573,
0.3876352310180664,
-0.1829775720834732,
-0.3082142472267151,
0.037881895899772644,
-0.07065944373607635,
0.16814032196998596,
0.2795255780220032,
-0.8008023500442505,
0.2899262011051178,
-0.07291528582572937,
0.1497742235660553,
0.3800899386405945,
0.008760413154959679,
-0.011349868960678577,
-0.01375306211411953,
0.5532363057136536,
0.1168803721666336,
0.1549404412508011,
-0.4535858631134033,
-0.5210323333740234,
-0.7056291699409485,
-0.08789759874343872,
-0.020223697647452354,
0.5177533626556396,
-0.8924870491027832,
0.35130730271339417,
-0.3644843101501465,
-0.4740930199623108,
-0.3777165412902832,
-0.06795717030763626,
0.5359500646591187,
0.4706895351409912,
0.08474712073802948,
-0.31845924258232117,
-0.4451609253883362,
-1.1361769437789917,
0.1631610244512558,
0.04258975014090538,
-0.15674592554569244,
0.5396979451179504,
0.24962632358074188,
0.01286603044718504,
0.5516126155853271,
-0.5374151468276978,
-0.17828381061553955,
-0.442376047372818,
0.03729228675365448,
0.3552103042602539,
0.3908235728740692,
0.21738727390766144,
-0.5463886260986328,
-0.4196455478668213,
-0.037039969116449356,
-0.9166359305381775,
0.0869024246931076,
0.11171823740005493,
-0.26369011402130127,
-0.0020487653091549873,
0.1603715717792511,
-0.9009062647819519,
0.17976014316082,
0.5769996047019958,
-0.07933011651039124,
0.26399052143096924,
0.10221941769123077,
0.6251526474952698,
-1.4682800769805908,
0.2912074327468872,
0.056130487471818924,
-0.23171836137771606,
-0.974095344543457,
-0.0795300081372261,
-0.1199682280421257,
-0.3657194972038269,
-0.30657002329826355,
0.30700474977493286,
-0.2542225420475006,
-0.1465449184179306,
-0.4843640625476837,
0.051160961389541626,
0.015535936690866947,
1.0184227228164673,
0.06150421127676964,
0.7834629416465759,
0.5604269504547119,
-0.6157341599464417,
0.485836386680603,
0.5037499070167542,
-0.5569114685058594,
0.6483126878738403,
-0.3133465051651001,
0.24178461730480194,
0.07963970303535461,
0.44368302822113037,
-0.9859244227409363,
-0.2226090133190155,
0.4343035817146301,
-0.3494144380092621,
0.4406636655330658,
-0.2505126893520355,
-0.4590888023376465,
-0.5649198293685913,
0.07882381975650787,
0.18099354207515717,
0.37156277894973755,
-0.3247562348842621,
0.505212664604187,
0.6022489070892334,
-0.7179451584815979,
-0.6159836053848267,
-0.4542701244354248,
0.13931162655353546,
-0.1355881690979004,
-0.19536983966827393,
-0.12928295135498047,
-0.025032343342900276,
0.05997047573328018,
-0.43424052000045776,
-0.09258262068033218,
0.0647657960653305,
0.2598942220211029,
0.5314503312110901,
0.40464138984680176,
-0.21808528900146484,
-0.18150779604911804,
0.156757652759552,
-0.07113084197044373,
0.2392343282699585,
0.047284968197345734,
0.6837121248245239,
0.23065480589866638,
-0.5030180215835571,
-0.4716280698776245,
0.5369293689727783,
0.6073360443115234,
-0.11728303134441376,
0.2909535765647888,
0.4843580424785614,
-0.2492705136537552,
-0.07899501174688339,
-0.4043033719062805,
0.2581692636013031,
-0.412708044052124,
0.654227077960968,
-0.7558680772781372,
-1.1445744037628174,
0.10530710965394974,
-0.45543941855430603,
0.5296178460121155,
0.3545190989971161,
0.6613546013832092,
-0.2631579041481018,
1.532812476158142,
0.27974507212638855,
-0.3018794059753418,
0.26362380385398865,
-0.03628181666135788,
0.26596692204475403,
-1.059799075126648,
-0.3509259819984436,
-0.5355796217918396,
-0.3627591133117676,
-0.3619841933250427,
-0.2974082827568054,
0.3899700939655304,
-0.20553189516067505,
-0.19598685204982758,
0.3750143051147461,
-0.1464756280183792,
0.18574844300746918,
0.44671180844306946,
-0.01648867316544056,
0.3499218225479126,
0.038984138518571854,
0.1889663189649582,
-0.13482385873794556,
-0.7589892148971558,
-0.20273955166339874,
1.225242018699646,
0.3536163866519928,
0.79653400182724,
0.1133822351694107,
0.31699132919311523,
0.38349559903144836,
0.10350111871957779,
-0.8217657804489136,
0.644115686416626,
-0.14468146860599518,
-0.42888137698173523,
-0.5442401170730591,
-0.49733129143714905,
-1.2287636995315552,
0.4030691683292389,
-0.07992014288902283,
-0.7572584748268127,
-0.2680264413356781,
-0.21002808213233948,
-0.12920033931732178,
0.11101485788822174,
-0.5859292149543762,
0.7449592351913452,
0.06063970550894737,
-0.1044202670454979,
-0.2807123363018036,
-0.49447429180145264,
0.3091844618320465,
0.11662846803665161,
0.18735715746879578,
-0.5313073396682739,
0.38495442271232605,
0.7354431748390198,
-0.2485927790403366,
0.8698728680610657,
-0.634096622467041,
-0.39981821179389954,
0.3205157518386841,
0.20724144577980042,
0.4774516224861145,
0.11072482168674469,
0.21053998172283173,
0.10026898235082626,
-0.06957440823316574,
-0.24055294692516327,
-0.5682483315467834,
0.7848393321037292,
-0.6627408266067505,
-0.8496673703193665,
0.1441223919391632,
-0.7988648414611816,
-0.8737717270851135,
0.23575027287006378,
-0.03232164680957794,
0.8418450951576233,
-0.3801473379135132,
0.2188287228345871,
0.5647948980331421,
-0.11129402369260788,
0.4060908257961273,
0.8002486824989319,
-0.3596707880496979,
-0.15148581564426422,
0.9648191928863525,
0.027082068845629692,
0.18539366126060486,
0.21567784249782562,
-0.1638953983783722,
-0.1355777233839035,
-0.5149455666542053,
-0.8750508427619934,
-0.2592579424381256,
-0.3640475571155548,
-0.3557519316673279,
-0.820724368095398,
-0.09644906967878342,
-0.17987225949764252,
0.38118138909339905,
-0.3827093243598938,
-0.23132812976837158,
0.3016211986541748,
0.029374847188591957,
0.04552409425377846,
0.5816709995269775,
0.4360676407814026,
-0.057793550193309784,
-0.8317384123802185,
0.452253520488739,
0.06355713307857513,
0.38380762934684753,
0.16884081065654755,
-0.23604080080986023,
-0.5183848738670349,
0.304237961769104,
-0.24397137761116028,
-0.2640131711959839,
0.16730214655399323,
-0.09038595855236053,
0.7404767870903015,
0.2254384160041809,
0.09681849181652069,
0.6357269287109375,
-0.5239871144294739,
0.9839924573898315,
0.2972346842288971,
-0.567978024482727,
0.5732561945915222,
-0.4426991045475006,
0.6579409837722778,
0.46863609552383423,
0.33656272292137146,
-0.5915079116821289,
-0.8454747200012207,
-0.4493168294429779,
-0.4999988377094269,
0.9682173132896423,
0.09919381886720657,
0.3731706738471985,
0.1347772777080536,
-0.1448778510093689,
0.6035059094429016,
0.38228902220726013,
-0.17621785402297974,
-0.4976893663406372,
-0.06828425079584122,
-0.21993431448936462,
-0.27635079622268677,
0.13267426192760468,
-0.32249125838279724,
0.050922319293022156,
0.7479348182678223,
-0.44657379388809204,
0.46057525277137756,
-0.08757100999355316,
-0.1321149319410324,
-0.07416851073503494,
0.5634037256240845,
0.34913673996925354,
0.47722071409225464,
0.018330169841647148,
-0.2748867869377136,
0.23623423278331757,
-0.47199544310569763,
0.24573403596878052,
0.24338626861572266,
-0.16060419380664825,
0.04326996952295303,
0.2146129310131073,
1.3590044975280762,
0.07461319863796234,
-0.8483601212501526,
0.5508342385292053,
-0.1333823949098587,
-0.3124815821647644,
-0.29609164595603943,
0.24154983460903168,
-0.002243875991553068,
0.35975348949432373,
0.4387548863887787,
-0.11188440024852753,
0.4297076463699341,
-0.4324112832546234,
-0.16345828771591187,
0.5448614358901978,
-0.19198811054229736,
-0.04426219314336777,
0.38639166951179504,
0.4232008755207062,
-0.12341739237308502,
0.6234256625175476,
0.029631370678544044,
-0.2796136140823364,
0.47255414724349976,
0.5768053531646729,
0.720621645450592,
-0.011449882760643959,
0.15801241993904114,
0.4857746958732605,
-0.19916070997714996,
0.0034708434250205755,
0.0846571996808052,
-0.350064218044281,
-0.7351698279380798,
-0.5635820031166077,
-0.3580976128578186,
-0.7424772381782532,
0.46415725350379944,
-0.8835198283195496,
-0.3138725459575653,
-0.29144367575645447,
-0.6120824217796326,
-0.07247179746627808,
0.23422519862651825,
-0.6724401116371155,
0.30091288685798645,
0.3971399664878845,
0.6061367392539978,
-0.49824801087379456,
0.8133805394172668,
0.4391742944717407,
0.14728543162345886,
-0.6268212795257568,
-0.09051944315433502,
-0.03968864679336548,
-0.8863233327865601,
0.42967256903648376,
0.21058353781700134,
-0.2245001494884491,
-0.08708778023719788,
-0.3532593846321106,
-0.8699240684509277,
1.1411622762680054,
-0.00429699569940567,
-0.7151972055435181,
0.017565812915563583,
0.26480934023857117,
0.4812449514865875,
-0.46282607316970825,
0.2289835512638092,
0.5396302342414856,
0.31511712074279785,
-0.2944262623786926,
-1.0924038887023926,
-0.0735655426979065,
-0.5681098103523254,
0.18146434426307678,
0.4559437930583954,
-0.9836668968200684,
0.34991738200187683,
0.08742746710777283,
-0.16960658133029938,
0.2204287350177765,
0.5242182612419128,
0.15344767272472382,
0.17111438512802124,
0.5215030908584595,
0.4329236149787903,
0.4339064061641693,
-0.3478798568248749,
0.9018027782440186,
-0.13089773058891296,
0.25984713435173035,
1.3405383825302124,
-0.5872368216514587,
0.6081165075302124,
0.3096683919429779,
-0.4399650990962982,
0.41347548365592957,
0.19649939239025116,
-0.24651752412319183,
0.48399850726127625,
0.0776117667555809,
-0.4004344642162323,
-0.4714738130569458,
-0.42573630809783936,
-0.2907562553882599,
0.3221016228199005,
0.6150113940238953,
-0.01569335348904133,
0.10300726443529129,
0.5589322447776794,
0.10013745725154877,
-0.2951042354106903,
-0.1887814700603485,
1.0153474807739258,
-0.046687278896570206,
-0.9281373023986816,
0.36807432770729065,
-0.09814475476741791,
0.7164217233657837,
-0.8416098952293396,
0.14317449927330017,
-0.2980000376701355,
0.07059137523174286,
0.03893555700778961,
-1.0460668802261353,
-0.1254543662071228,
0.19346347451210022,
-0.1718534380197525,
-0.08407250046730042,
0.6565506458282471,
-0.46321338415145874,
-0.2773486077785492,
0.24899619817733765,
0.7483237385749817,
0.11357812583446503,
0.3056710958480835,
-0.6185372471809387,
0.08464693278074265,
0.058270975947380066,
-0.7024592757225037,
0.587671160697937,
0.30134525895118713,
0.0861893743276596,
0.842102587223053,
0.5238417983055115,
-0.3431108891963959,
-0.2636679410934448,
0.5752149820327759,
0.5996218323707581,
-0.46335670351982117,
-0.1691872924566269,
-0.43058499693870544,
0.4921797513961792,
-0.12319568544626236,
-0.2765517830848694,
0.7980543971061707,
0.6538184881210327,
0.9460771679878235,
-0.16816504299640656,
1.3105483055114746,
-0.30710938572883606,
0.8450287580490112,
-0.4664859175682068,
0.3820025324821472,
-0.5472618937492371,
-0.31958627700805664,
-0.2396661639213562,
-0.7450538277626038,
0.13016514480113983,
0.19208815693855286,
0.14978961646556854,
0.09443943947553635,
0.4731246531009674,
0.7031142711639404,
-0.009961497038602829,
0.20377855002880096,
0.6117637753486633,
0.19953463971614838,
0.19740425050258636,
0.9984192848205566,
1.047814965248108,
-0.4645930826663971,
0.44775041937828064,
-0.28522470593452454,
0.08895193785429001,
-0.08399203419685364,
-0.2436811327934265,
-1.0130798816680908,
-0.6476850509643555,
-0.3469535708427429,
-0.23642289638519287,
-0.09225619584321976,
1.0130633115768433,
0.5528367757797241,
-0.8558323383331299,
-0.29749059677124023,
0.3056023120880127,
-0.4563429653644562,
-0.21673381328582764,
-0.2738599181175232,
-0.04150087386369705,
-0.3530920445919037,
-1.1360191106796265,
0.8133128881454468,
0.3701714873313904,
-0.10125511139631271,
-0.3038835823535919,
-0.20843002200126648,
0.2358120232820511,
-0.10733314603567123,
0.6544756293296814,
0.15767136216163635,
-0.7254953384399414,
-0.13590602576732635,
-0.06536848098039627,
-0.3539169132709503,
0.1499444842338562,
0.9750838279724121,
-0.4903237819671631,
0.42071399092674255,
0.14811116456985474,
0.6012438535690308,
0.537657618522644,
-0.2953154742717743,
0.8605740070343018,
-0.5734102725982666,
0.15613442659378052,
0.0063565378077328205,
0.48090580105781555,
0.2252376526594162,
-0.12170607596635818,
0.4637892246246338,
0.031656526029109955,
-0.26827260851860046,
-0.5234378576278687,
0.21029676496982574,
-1.0805741548538208,
-0.28825485706329346,
0.8761071562767029,
-0.48150113224983215,
0.20016978681087494,
-0.2698831558227539,
-0.6002700328826904,
0.2939494252204895,
-0.47017860412597656,
0.2812100648880005,
0.9428238272666931,
-0.18972158432006836,
-0.14327479898929596,
-0.6035655736923218,
0.15919221937656403,
0.36376258730888367,
-1.025277853012085,
0.49865952134132385,
0.5950794816017151,
0.1668531745672226,
0.20054103434085846,
0.7883102893829346,
-0.012339995242655277,
0.23665684461593628,
0.13599450886249542,
-0.06707391142845154,
-0.3519665598869324,
-0.2535131275653839,
0.03744246065616608,
0.2959933876991272,
0.06601042300462723,
-0.11619625240564346
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17314v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17314v1
|
Project MOSLA: Recording Every Moment of Second Language Acquisition
| 2024-03-26T01:52:59 | 2024-03-26T01:52:59 |
Masato Hagiwara, Joshua Tanner
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Second language acquisition (SLA) is a complex and dynamic process. Many SLA
studies that have attempted to record and analyze this process have typically
focused on a single modality (e.g., textual output of learners), covered only a
short period of time, and/or lacked control (e.g., failed to capture every
aspect of the learning process). In Project MOSLA (Moments of Second Language
Acquisition), we have created a longitudinal, multimodal, multilingual, and
controlled dataset by inviting participants to learn one of three target
languages (Arabic, Spanish, and Chinese) from scratch over a span of two years,
exclusively through online instruction, and recording every lesson using Zoom.
The dataset is semi-automatically annotated with speaker/language IDs and
transcripts by both human annotators and fine-tuned state-of-the-art speech
models. Our experiments reveal linguistic insights into learners' proficiency
development over time, as well as the potential for automatically detecting the
areas of focus on the screen purely from the unannotated multimodal data. Our
dataset is freely available for research purposes and can serve as a valuable
resource for a wide range of applications, including but not limited to SLA,
proficiency assessment, language and speech processing, pedagogy, and
multimodal learning analytics.
|
[
-0.1492459625005722,
-0.8463680744171143,
0.23330937325954437,
0.10867253690958023,
-0.013817054219543934,
0.2421073317527771,
-0.09731081128120422,
-0.36311838030815125,
0.38400980830192566,
0.08241798728704453,
-0.3456496000289917,
-0.43951672315597534,
-0.48827236890792847,
-0.42974457144737244,
-0.056479230523109436,
0.9934701919555664,
0.1959780603647232,
0.20715108513832092,
0.09043718129396439,
-0.4167926609516144,
-0.47259339690208435,
-0.4583123028278351,
-0.5247777104377747,
-0.18514154851436615,
0.49435707926750183,
0.5680582523345947,
0.52618008852005,
0.5711420774459839,
0.15125364065170288,
0.13109613955020905,
0.0600752979516983,
0.30821338295936584,
-0.15079796314239502,
-0.1458456665277481,
-0.05398664250969887,
-0.4652896523475647,
-0.4779285788536072,
0.03759508207440376,
0.7979865670204163,
0.7683846950531006,
-0.13338564336299896,
0.6476874947547913,
-0.10109856724739075,
0.7726425528526306,
-0.5496273040771484,
0.32968103885650635,
-0.40653979778289795,
0.07199802249670029,
-0.5563750863075256,
-0.14562124013900757,
-0.3524247705936432,
-0.2943190634250641,
0.09182005375623703,
-0.5086045861244202,
0.1272665411233902,
-0.6095780730247498,
0.5895732641220093,
-0.18623597919940948,
-0.7821874618530273,
-0.6046586632728577,
-0.8017035126686096,
0.7811569571495056,
-0.37349414825439453,
0.5074002146720886,
0.5110607147216797,
0.12045959383249283,
0.1618172973394394,
-0.4378014802932739,
-0.5472355484962463,
-0.16628398001194,
0.11657645553350449,
0.07321607321500778,
0.11606727540493011,
-0.29188886284828186,
0.20399777591228485,
-0.0521542951464653,
-0.6608005166053772,
0.12723812460899353,
-0.7035307884216309,
-0.5316550135612488,
0.6788090467453003,
0.19132184982299805,
0.45455849170684814,
-0.10019335895776749,
-0.24994753301143646,
-0.2805749177932739,
-0.678650975227356,
0.5314579010009766,
0.23443953692913055,
0.4290144145488739,
-0.22064360976219177,
0.7304534912109375,
0.1297997236251831,
0.3903188705444336,
-0.4464734196662903,
-0.5967644453048706,
0.6843190789222717,
-0.3560240864753723,
0.21123676002025604,
-0.23768195509910583,
0.6390047669410706,
0.23127764463424683,
0.12642642855644226,
-0.04154496639966965,
-0.25933948159217834,
0.2541518211364746,
-0.14395231008529663,
-0.3299867808818817,
-0.17176209390163422,
0.05392567440867424,
-0.254946231842041,
-0.004662993364036083,
-0.06440016627311707,
-1.0221549272537231,
-0.26538506150245667,
-0.5114624500274658,
0.3620103597640991,
-0.27190765738487244,
-0.4551225006580353,
-0.22964893281459808,
0.08570853620767593,
0.15950025618076324,
0.035630688071250916,
-0.869994580745697,
0.1153283342719078,
0.5277262926101685,
1.1256985664367676,
-0.38543999195098877,
-0.6229805946350098,
-0.6290437579154968,
0.11291991174221039,
-0.4525366425514221,
0.36522749066352844,
-0.4027479887008667,
-0.58855140209198,
0.47086668014526367,
0.03634146973490715,
-0.07226009666919708,
-0.2965151369571686,
0.11974631249904633,
-0.5894836783409119,
0.005366513039916754,
0.04914483055472374,
-0.29689037799835205,
-0.09522360563278198,
-0.04082365706562996,
-0.6304800510406494,
0.9930068850517273,
-0.045905400067567825,
-0.10564001649618149,
0.3884769380092621,
-0.8090691566467285,
-0.6296694278717041,
-0.11754852533340454,
-0.4084639847278595,
-0.2843340337276459,
0.30718907713890076,
-0.12792856991291046,
0.26866522431373596,
0.1652522087097168,
0.38445356488227844,
0.2068490833044052,
0.06734300404787064,
0.41996774077415466,
-0.480512797832489,
0.7605462670326233,
0.09056029468774796,
-0.49703842401504517,
-0.2051524966955185,
-0.9570069909095764,
0.1426648646593094,
0.05282299593091011,
-0.537600576877594,
-0.17937316000461578,
0.01580827683210373,
0.28879690170288086,
0.3839331567287445,
0.30325764417648315,
-0.4236868619918823,
0.08326249569654465,
-0.15467852354049683,
0.37977927923202515,
0.47224143147468567,
-0.03588861972093582,
0.3790930211544037,
-0.06802085787057877,
0.5493303537368774,
0.26508650183677673,
0.01504057552665472,
-0.44156259298324585,
-0.43404972553253174,
-0.8949421644210815,
0.11014322936534882,
0.16697603464126587,
0.5399609208106995,
-0.5558408498764038,
-0.1720731407403946,
-0.25242847204208374,
-0.45310232043266296,
-0.5112274289131165,
0.4850723147392273,
0.6060878038406372,
0.009112052619457245,
0.2837832272052765,
-0.578307569026947,
-0.3978320062160492,
-0.6976304650306702,
0.14064234495162964,
-0.25891542434692383,
0.08868634700775146,
0.12912893295288086,
0.4044170081615448,
-0.2182924449443817,
0.7822357416152954,
-0.5464017987251282,
-0.654351532459259,
-0.23577100038528442,
0.5762519240379333,
-0.168299600481987,
0.5511363744735718,
0.4940023124217987,
-0.6937142014503479,
-0.42796674370765686,
0.08774388581514359,
-0.5183178782463074,
0.10235275328159332,
-0.3556903898715973,
0.13080906867980957,
0.28274664282798767,
0.34923261404037476,
-0.4405955970287323,
0.14775854349136353,
0.7467176914215088,
-0.31196796894073486,
0.4093489646911621,
-0.29936516284942627,
-0.08197351545095444,
-0.8981242775917053,
0.03423517569899559,
-0.048561081290245056,
0.08656430244445801,
-0.8759809732437134,
-0.09352545440196991,
0.14055128395557404,
-0.2794307768344879,
-0.5162245035171509,
0.33476725220680237,
-0.6347943544387817,
-0.23910342156887054,
-0.3250584006309509,
0.4793664515018463,
-0.3233708143234253,
0.7608156800270081,
0.05528072640299797,
1.0766998529434204,
0.28681841492652893,
-0.5749674439430237,
-0.06937432289123535,
0.0734119564294815,
-0.37769457697868347,
0.319526344537735,
-0.348461776971817,
0.32202011346817017,
-0.051050592213869095,
-0.2294093817472458,
-0.9479031562805176,
-0.22297005355358124,
-0.07772106677293777,
-0.7103002667427063,
0.3062627613544464,
0.23088227212429047,
-0.20594066381454468,
0.13742715120315552,
-0.19841071963310242,
0.2761130630970001,
0.31667155027389526,
-0.15483225882053375,
0.7685579061508179,
0.9121401309967041,
-0.1684465855360031,
-0.48805132508277893,
-0.6365909576416016,
0.1084924042224884,
0.004331647418439388,
-0.16712339222431183,
-0.14126920700073242,
-0.10503247380256653,
-0.37687817215919495,
-0.2695389986038208,
0.20190586149692535,
-0.5399711728096008,
0.175510972738266,
0.5608483552932739,
0.27561306953430176,
-0.26817309856414795,
0.24943740665912628,
-0.04559726640582085,
-0.27435174584388733,
0.022862225770950317,
0.13969899713993073,
0.4698392152786255,
-0.020452717319130898,
-0.4703059196472168,
-0.7916649580001831,
0.3573955297470093,
1.01615309715271,
-0.3596181571483612,
0.5547276735305786,
0.6134012937545776,
-0.40002521872520447,
-0.19713187217712402,
-0.491670697927475,
0.009024395607411861,
-0.3376635015010834,
0.5143795013427734,
-0.2916621267795563,
-0.6476616263389587,
0.4722871780395508,
0.1389593929052353,
0.3862290680408478,
0.22975151240825653,
0.4602288007736206,
-0.2665424644947052,
0.849865734577179,
0.6885141134262085,
-0.26766619086265564,
0.5792073011398315,
-0.3811455965042114,
-0.03246550261974335,
-0.8123900890350342,
-0.5834038853645325,
-0.4015524089336395,
-0.1713593304157257,
-0.1350526213645935,
-0.7311541438102722,
0.3917869031429291,
0.03325822204351425,
0.2029128074645996,
0.1664332151412964,
0.0797099769115448,
0.43302205204963684,
0.47400152683258057,
0.0684567540884018,
0.3106745779514313,
0.04748264700174332,
0.20295879244804382,
-0.5266223549842834,
-0.26955461502075195,
-0.5648854970932007,
1.193605661392212,
0.43350884318351746,
0.25152477622032166,
0.46160584688186646,
0.28022903203964233,
0.5841869115829468,
0.14692813158035278,
-0.9319584369659424,
0.5136691331863403,
0.055027563124895096,
-0.50779128074646,
-0.5230724215507507,
-0.046345215290784836,
-0.8292823433876038,
0.45057713985443115,
0.0716223269701004,
-0.5311509966850281,
0.08859962970018387,
0.31064122915267944,
-0.3807304799556732,
0.027937840670347214,
-0.7487261891365051,
0.6558869481086731,
-0.4588063359260559,
-0.47190648317337036,
-0.4586145579814911,
-0.6383321285247803,
0.2203017920255661,
-0.41047677397727966,
0.5384509563446045,
-0.2780608832836151,
-0.2940579056739807,
0.9298138618469238,
0.048790741711854935,
1.230341911315918,
-0.41588982939720154,
-0.13537991046905518,
0.5253121256828308,
0.2364913523197174,
0.48478269577026367,
-0.0417766310274601,
0.1525822877883911,
-0.011216851882636547,
0.054277148097753525,
-0.4695168733596802,
-0.41195282340049744,
0.4644663631916046,
-0.9045819640159607,
-0.22582675516605377,
-0.6048247814178467,
-0.5512070059776306,
-0.44018638134002686,
-0.09759793430566788,
-0.23176200687885284,
0.6713109612464905,
-0.35033470392227173,
0.08264971524477005,
0.5785119533538818,
0.12275047600269318,
0.606991708278656,
0.9368641376495361,
-0.09783875942230225,
-0.21128389239311218,
1.3382128477096558,
0.5089691281318665,
0.4671001136302948,
0.22908523678779602,
0.10719333589076996,
-0.20166562497615814,
-0.7843818068504333,
-0.46551334857940674,
0.40680211782455444,
-0.7952205538749695,
0.17906033992767334,
-0.4653986990451813,
0.07177866250276566,
-0.3659536838531494,
-0.07268229871988297,
-0.44634684920310974,
-0.37871482968330383,
-0.4559657871723175,
-0.24098466336727142,
-0.12919007241725922,
0.7287152409553528,
-0.340136855840683,
0.23709987103939056,
-0.9301929473876953,
-0.005951059982180595,
0.42274633049964905,
-0.28972458839416504,
0.07956816256046295,
-0.5273536443710327,
-0.4715304970741272,
0.2412211298942566,
-0.2738977372646332,
-0.8031236529350281,
0.49039214849472046,
0.6689391732215881,
0.5759534239768982,
0.3311639130115509,
-0.48743030428886414,
0.8146030306816101,
-0.3110294044017792,
1.1932857036590576,
0.357244074344635,
-1.1416305303573608,
0.7884851098060608,
-0.1874687820672989,
0.34413060545921326,
0.4913392663002014,
0.23321114480495453,
-0.7060299515724182,
-0.08676574379205704,
-0.35653719305992126,
-0.6440351009368896,
0.7762362360954285,
-0.1994669884443283,
0.262244313955307,
0.1633450835943222,
0.06481515616178513,
0.12621907889842987,
0.10690854489803314,
-0.6447689533233643,
-0.21281495690345764,
-0.06525149196386337,
-0.11202052980661392,
-0.2515094578266144,
-0.5397325754165649,
-0.4919816255569458,
0.01615171879529953,
0.6259302496910095,
-0.45914778113365173,
-0.19038976728916168,
-0.16461709141731262,
-0.7244540452957153,
0.19006656110286713,
0.18051354587078094,
0.8924420475959778,
1.038175344467163,
0.2859858572483063,
0.23681026697158813,
0.3050985634326935,
-0.8566845655441284,
0.27398303151130676,
-0.6095537543296814,
-0.17566262185573578,
0.1989692896604538,
0.6867696642875671,
0.7905608415603638,
0.4758312702178955,
-1.1882691383361816,
0.6966620087623596,
0.4256943166255951,
-0.058473456650972366,
-0.5250886082649231,
-0.08249324560165405,
-0.0011290964903309941,
0.3643041253089905,
0.3855946958065033,
-0.20587757229804993,
-0.04438626393675804,
-0.622779905796051,
0.3259814977645874,
0.03727686405181885,
-0.5548913478851318,
-0.8874277472496033,
0.35280197858810425,
0.2992394268512726,
-0.46307796239852905,
0.5140423774719238,
-0.19169586896896362,
-0.2430734783411026,
0.7451912760734558,
0.4841380715370178,
0.5760140419006348,
-0.4082367718219757,
0.6916114091873169,
0.5458296537399292,
0.3538634479045868,
-0.027275092899799347,
0.33146005868911743,
-0.24816489219665527,
-0.7046740651130676,
-0.08544398099184036,
-0.3940874934196472,
-0.20119528472423553,
0.19671675562858582,
-0.933349609375,
-0.006336280144751072,
-0.23517362773418427,
-0.24970172345638275,
-0.06618810445070267,
-0.05633842945098877,
-0.4959060549736023,
0.14355818927288055,
0.2346872240304947,
0.5821295976638794,
-1.3224197626113892,
1.1518275737762451,
0.5851724147796631,
-0.6340283155441284,
-0.5582904815673828,
-0.33395862579345703,
0.5978182554244995,
-0.9869560599327087,
0.9139159917831421,
-0.08600080758333206,
-0.18539582192897797,
-0.1677362322807312,
0.014886951074004173,
-0.8221219778060913,
1.166131615638733,
-0.00886810477823019,
-0.5965874791145325,
0.007894526235759258,
0.2732829749584198,
0.6694735288619995,
-0.3299909234046936,
0.03001810796558857,
0.8702521324157715,
0.040537141263484955,
-0.03949475660920143,
-0.9259739518165588,
-0.5835057497024536,
-0.08426392078399658,
-0.004501179326325655,
0.15075138211250305,
-0.7080139517784119,
0.7659498453140259,
-0.4635942578315735,
-0.39748698472976685,
-0.141381174325943,
0.8331890106201172,
0.043733883649110794,
0.639798104763031,
0.4232840836048126,
0.24449215829372406,
0.9038547873497009,
-0.020540937781333923,
0.23277583718299866,
-0.20621785521507263,
0.3549405634403229,
1.3255552053451538,
-0.17411452531814575,
1.1881147623062134,
0.6917099356651306,
-0.37127581238746643,
0.1831267923116684,
0.375706285238266,
0.13048511743545532,
0.45773857831954956,
-0.12200509756803513,
-0.34071847796440125,
-0.07506375759840012,
-0.38317763805389404,
-0.2827911376953125,
0.5651952624320984,
0.707758367061615,
-0.22873666882514954,
0.04172481223940849,
0.4878188967704773,
0.15048055350780487,
0.23104748129844666,
-0.2030394822359085,
0.5853150486946106,
-0.14005017280578613,
-0.48249539732933044,
0.07236111164093018,
-0.3137367367744446,
0.5765506029129028,
-0.9157305359840393,
0.16924302279949188,
-0.3631017506122589,
0.14340849220752716,
-0.16559995710849762,
-0.7479783296585083,
0.22075212001800537,
-0.04093947634100914,
-0.1731608510017395,
-0.13646049797534943,
0.1683366447687149,
-0.8004516959190369,
-0.36099034547805786,
0.3555758595466614,
0.6781104803085327,
0.36067265272140503,
0.47448307275772095,
-0.33059588074684143,
0.4289482831954956,
0.18998712301254272,
-0.1893472671508789,
0.4897846579551697,
0.2803683280944824,
-0.02895091287791729,
0.6996471881866455,
0.6293609142303467,
0.25714799761772156,
0.3792533576488495,
0.15132221579551697,
0.5179527997970581,
-0.5445920825004578,
-0.2349061816930771,
-0.4830619692802429,
0.5662568807601929,
0.12225358933210373,
-0.8063234090805054,
0.7811721563339233,
0.7786587476730347,
1.018452763557434,
-0.09320295602083206,
0.7869552969932556,
-0.047666996717453,
0.5760273933410645,
-0.5048685073852539,
0.34700000286102295,
-0.6078094840049744,
-0.0831589475274086,
0.20140285789966583,
-0.47433894872665405,
-0.23083457350730896,
0.3961107134819031,
0.23053991794586182,
-0.5158545970916748,
0.7501259446144104,
0.9247531890869141,
0.21712656319141388,
-0.08397182822227478,
0.36646580696105957,
-0.10361906886100769,
0.6475162506103516,
0.4975805878639221,
0.5012051463127136,
-0.41722372174263,
0.48996999859809875,
-0.46778562664985657,
-0.22512567043304443,
-0.19988761842250824,
-0.39970457553863525,
-0.778779149055481,
-1.0611423254013062,
-0.3194562792778015,
-0.23468150198459625,
-0.02364068105816841,
1.0988081693649292,
0.3314341604709625,
-0.9284934401512146,
-0.8025338649749756,
0.40985846519470215,
-0.20754066109657288,
-0.3571709394454956,
-0.14425131678581238,
0.4887270927429199,
-0.4853660762310028,
-0.9247167706489563,
0.7189244627952576,
0.09226022660732269,
0.21434830129146576,
-0.6541376113891602,
-0.20289656519889832,
-0.3250364661216736,
-0.24220949411392212,
0.8245202898979187,
0.7438974976539612,
-0.6948493719100952,
-0.18022595345973969,
-0.011571154929697514,
-0.3153306245803833,
-0.02235615998506546,
1.0916318893432617,
-0.3836991786956787,
0.8364511728286743,
0.4071115553379059,
0.7171781063079834,
0.33742398023605347,
-0.30527135729789734,
0.42274010181427,
-0.54129958152771,
0.38711684942245483,
0.10539863258600235,
0.058536991477012634,
0.11115506291389465,
0.030087193474173546,
0.5675434470176697,
0.44913947582244873,
-0.2687843441963196,
-0.9978836178779602,
-0.07482393085956573,
-0.8588916063308716,
0.10009979456663132,
1.0637396574020386,
-0.2276591658592224,
0.14937859773635864,
-0.32510876655578613,
-0.15829430520534515,
0.24609242379665375,
-0.3467509150505066,
0.8140524625778198,
0.8031527996063232,
-0.15405334532260895,
-0.01569340005517006,
-0.8643063902854919,
0.3663194477558136,
0.4786161184310913,
-0.736801266670227,
0.021545791998505592,
0.7119884490966797,
0.09266529232263565,
0.6372045874595642,
0.6969980597496033,
-0.11961722373962402,
0.3721963167190552,
0.05490857735276222,
-0.15513955056667328,
-0.06962484121322632,
-0.7771828174591064,
-0.5715292692184448,
0.5736352205276489,
0.05957930162549019,
-0.6700432896614075
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17308v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17308v1
|
Neural Multimodal Topic Modeling: A Comprehensive Evaluation
| 2024-03-26T01:29:46 | 2024-03-26T01:29:46 |
Felipe González-Pizarro, Giuseppe Carenini
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2.7
|
Neural topic models can successfully find coherent and diverse topics in
textual data. However, they are limited in dealing with multimodal datasets
(e.g., images and text). This paper presents the first systematic and
comprehensive evaluation of multimodal topic modeling of documents containing
both text and images. In the process, we propose two novel topic modeling
solutions and two novel evaluation metrics. Overall, our evaluation on an
unprecedented rich and diverse collection of datasets indicates that both of
our models generate coherent and diverse topics. Nevertheless, the extent to
which one method outperforms the other depends on the metrics and dataset
combinations, which suggests further exploration of hybrid solutions in the
future. Notably, our succinct human evaluation aligns with the outcomes
determined by our proposed metrics. This alignment not only reinforces the
credibility of our metrics but also highlights the potential for their
application in guiding future multimodal topic modeling endeavors.
|
[
-0.385513037443161,
-0.7799865007400513,
0.6378006339073181,
0.26266393065452576,
-0.4271294176578522,
0.14310801029205322,
-0.45590314269065857,
-0.05736443027853966,
0.45461252331733704,
0.12867115437984467,
-0.4239294230937958,
-0.5322886109352112,
-0.7696641683578491,
-0.3656380772590637,
-0.6338306069374084,
0.9362855553627014,
0.14742304384708405,
0.32982954382896423,
-0.7336365580558777,
-0.16860729455947876,
-0.6461533904075623,
-0.061502762138843536,
-0.22785761952400208,
-0.1792839765548706,
0.8591919541358948,
0.1844513863325119,
0.6053542494773865,
0.4274168908596039,
0.8013674020767212,
0.40156790614128113,
-0.20002390444278717,
0.2370223104953766,
-0.20413696765899658,
0.20082613825798035,
-0.4364129304885864,
0.0023335039149969816,
-0.22447259724140167,
0.05586577579379082,
0.792450487613678,
0.9018307328224182,
0.07809705287218094,
-0.13650959730148315,
0.008575686253607273,
0.40027138590812683,
-0.5028162002563477,
-0.31944605708122253,
-0.5041432976722717,
0.11395274847745895,
-0.2094336748123169,
-0.40341514348983765,
-0.28628042340278625,
-0.07674572616815567,
0.4801655113697052,
-0.4810282588005066,
0.18829143047332764,
-0.32107797265052795,
0.7955659627914429,
0.01556466706097126,
-0.8903069496154785,
-0.38292068243026733,
-0.4763791859149933,
0.807776689529419,
-0.20760302245616913,
0.4144231975078583,
0.12483322620391846,
0.08153337985277176,
0.30110329389572144,
-1.030768632888794,
-0.537800133228302,
-0.3033384680747986,
0.12513113021850586,
0.30252161622047424,
-0.3531739413738251,
-0.23344452679157257,
-0.17603419721126556,
0.4112549126148224,
-0.8414665460586548,
-0.07835956662893295,
-0.14333803951740265,
-0.3457714915275574,
0.42865437269210815,
0.5451709628105164,
0.5513142943382263,
-0.3778941035270691,
-0.587749183177948,
-0.056570034474134445,
0.14058735966682434,
-0.1920825093984604,
0.4664933979511261,
0.0845981165766716,
-0.1934078484773636,
0.6712035536766052,
-0.16077743470668793,
0.6255661845207214,
-0.33246561884880066,
-0.30820372700691223,
0.13812780380249023,
-0.8977739810943604,
0.2832716703414917,
-0.4599502980709076,
0.8101711869239807,
0.730931282043457,
-0.21716642379760742,
-0.39808374643325806,
-0.19097401201725006,
0.4926232695579529,
0.5643901824951172,
-0.6535841226577759,
-0.07335425913333893,
0.19827653467655182,
-1.0269808769226074,
-0.2591833472251892,
-0.004490239545702934,
-1.050299048423767,
-0.6489397883415222,
-0.4999808669090271,
0.4550303518772125,
-0.42135459184646606,
-0.4675278067588806,
0.2021683305501938,
-0.41986221075057983,
-0.078343965113163,
0.5031329989433289,
-0.748710572719574,
0.17437775433063507,
0.896312415599823,
1.1277406215667725,
-0.5619284510612488,
-0.48299136757850647,
0.06883305311203003,
-0.3396790027618408,
-0.44022059440612793,
1.1237006187438965,
-0.4787639379501343,
-0.27894753217697144,
-0.086393803358078,
-0.2706329822540283,
0.09557586163282394,
-0.20962974429130554,
0.6765786409378052,
-0.37032637000083923,
0.21957427263259888,
-0.3003482222557068,
-0.4554474949836731,
-0.06182805448770523,
0.501846194267273,
-0.7929725646972656,
0.4751724898815155,
-0.1667611300945282,
-1.0935208797454834,
0.4403831958770752,
-0.751929521560669,
-0.3860341012477875,
-0.23757319152355194,
-0.11071963608264923,
-0.1277729719877243,
0.12007807195186615,
-0.07748116552829742,
0.38783833384513855,
-0.6482558846473694,
0.7524270415306091,
-0.3857067823410034,
-0.10287034511566162,
0.46059128642082214,
-0.7100614309310913,
0.3722391724586487,
0.22474722564220428,
0.09371170401573181,
0.542339563369751,
-0.5436068773269653,
-0.031146449968218803,
0.022798432037234306,
-0.11040355265140533,
-0.4128792881965637,
0.05893438309431076,
0.5486319065093994,
0.23246151208877563,
0.4761700928211212,
-0.41348057985305786,
0.08793547749519348,
0.0833156555891037,
0.41337719559669495,
0.7477308511734009,
0.07176373898983002,
0.6256803870201111,
-0.4273375868797302,
0.38390830159187317,
0.10718786716461182,
-0.004833702463656664,
-0.7973940372467041,
-0.6107609868049622,
-0.4682752788066864,
-0.4243135452270508,
0.6296297907829285,
0.27072685956954956,
-0.724289059638977,
0.3006201684474945,
-0.2852057218551636,
-0.7630537152290344,
-0.23066353797912598,
-0.19830399751663208,
0.3447495996952057,
0.32381391525268555,
0.06649094820022583,
-0.7440146207809448,
-0.17100250720977783,
-1.2495290040969849,
-0.11324681341648102,
-0.015289862640202045,
0.1348057985305786,
0.4547840654850006,
0.6144736409187317,
-0.18019188940525055,
0.859146237373352,
-0.28689539432525635,
-0.04062596708536148,
0.09019588679075241,
0.7485774159431458,
0.019892306998372078,
0.6508082151412964,
0.4293438494205475,
-1.1538656949996948,
-0.23760633170604706,
-0.059701982885599136,
-0.7720351219177246,
0.3943820893764496,
-0.4558491110801697,
-0.14162327349185944,
-0.19923099875450134,
-0.04581236466765404,
-0.7285111546516418,
0.3357030749320984,
0.18192097544670105,
-0.608806848526001,
0.534285843372345,
-0.2201552838087082,
0.3574220836162567,
-1.2383167743682861,
0.10269453376531601,
0.4923264980316162,
0.07134314626455307,
-0.5042700171470642,
-0.08415073901414871,
0.23953793942928314,
-0.4638567566871643,
-0.3228101134300232,
0.7675995826721191,
-0.19418972730636597,
-0.2581145763397217,
-0.24040284752845764,
0.04573342949151993,
0.20591458678245544,
0.2576863169670105,
0.05930086597800255,
0.46941235661506653,
0.7984406352043152,
-0.1377307027578354,
0.645496666431427,
0.39784011244773865,
-0.5113471746444702,
0.6164747476577759,
-0.6947982907295227,
0.15995019674301147,
-0.3475748896598816,
0.2423621267080307,
-1.482727289199829,
-0.25246164202690125,
-0.002784411422908306,
-0.4419666826725006,
0.40334779024124146,
0.20503737032413483,
-0.5749499201774597,
-0.14019596576690674,
-0.4261167347431183,
0.2959385812282562,
0.11241558194160461,
-0.2631210386753082,
0.46543824672698975,
0.42342522740364075,
-0.5434896945953369,
-0.5612980723381042,
-0.4909287691116333,
0.5246520042419434,
-0.1714995801448822,
-1.0030667781829834,
0.7207947969436646,
-0.18505461513996124,
-0.16894754767417908,
0.13080236315727234,
-0.0864923968911171,
-0.3996223211288452,
0.025376828387379646,
0.14885985851287842,
0.21711814403533936,
-0.21003516018390656,
0.45631471276283264,
0.05900447815656662,
-0.2566319406032562,
-0.23115405440330505,
-0.24349278211593628,
0.5132476091384888,
-0.2898803949356079,
-0.5831876993179321,
-0.5087794065475464,
0.6611250042915344,
0.5570765137672424,
-0.5930653214454651,
0.3873317539691925,
0.8327196836471558,
-0.5166893005371094,
0.22106404602527618,
-0.5042834281921387,
-0.23727287352085114,
-0.3577152192592621,
0.8364787697792053,
-0.16141843795776367,
-0.4217279255390167,
0.38001689314842224,
-0.14655645191669464,
-0.11436443775892258,
0.37410080432891846,
0.7140209078788757,
-0.10541408509016037,
0.6997278928756714,
0.6852521300315857,
0.24436381459236145,
0.5020560622215271,
-0.2897145748138428,
0.006093425210565329,
-0.5805143117904663,
-0.5891550779342651,
-0.600439190864563,
-0.5526735782623291,
-0.48668044805526733,
-0.3938896656036377,
0.17501364648342133,
-0.14051760733127594,
0.29899805784225464,
-0.0344935804605484,
-0.4237186312675476,
0.3091811239719391,
0.46937572956085205,
0.39511269330978394,
0.06118670105934143,
0.1529369205236435,
-0.13742391765117645,
-0.42686137557029724,
-0.5038688778877258,
-0.8478084802627563,
1.2218619585037231,
0.4543466567993164,
0.6124891042709351,
-0.19952885806560516,
0.37718498706817627,
0.5120198130607605,
0.32046598196029663,
-0.7281255722045898,
0.49804767966270447,
-0.5797962546348572,
-0.6995407342910767,
-0.22913673520088196,
-0.20517590641975403,
-0.8252422213554382,
0.5065875053405762,
-0.4835017919540405,
-0.6341756582260132,
0.34166768193244934,
-0.3382231295108795,
-0.14015424251556396,
0.1814931333065033,
-0.675224781036377,
1.2425074577331543,
-0.597195029258728,
-0.673438310623169,
-0.30203893780708313,
-0.5100826621055603,
0.2675342857837677,
-0.12636318802833557,
-0.11359810829162598,
-0.07063650339841843,
-0.5269566774368286,
0.9408782124519348,
0.26595690846443176,
0.6016424894332886,
-0.09124135971069336,
0.08207108825445175,
0.10009836405515671,
-0.27992334961891174,
-0.4018329977989197,
0.2311672866344452,
-0.13657942414283752,
0.2125592678785324,
-0.16067497432231903,
-0.37293002009391785,
-0.711419403553009,
0.8042953610420227,
-0.6519175171852112,
-0.22185441851615906,
-0.3994848132133484,
-0.8161411285400391,
-0.10116243362426758,
0.3175756633281708,
-0.08222006261348724,
0.7127538919448853,
-0.4529480040073395,
0.46527740359306335,
0.5089389085769653,
-0.4802352786064148,
0.6046460270881653,
0.387332946062088,
-0.15954211354255676,
-0.7500833868980408,
1.031096339225769,
-0.08783408254384995,
-0.2597987949848175,
0.3727753162384033,
0.1078549176454544,
-0.5057600140571594,
-0.6179888844490051,
-0.3605845868587494,
-0.038401149213314056,
-0.9268038272857666,
-0.09298768639564514,
-0.8778789043426514,
0.11667972058057785,
-0.08747782558202744,
0.01974455639719963,
-0.451927125453949,
-0.3973361551761627,
-0.3421002924442291,
0.15795397758483887,
-0.19829553365707397,
0.5059400796890259,
0.026738706976175308,
0.11399047821760178,
-0.6487093567848206,
0.6680446863174438,
0.34117019176483154,
0.41988489031791687,
0.044748496264219284,
-0.19290046393871307,
0.005431719124317169,
0.022142384201288223,
-0.7293354272842407,
-1.0079545974731445,
0.33405542373657227,
0.2232152223587036,
0.7554305195808411,
0.4228702485561371,
-0.29031217098236084,
0.3828887939453125,
-0.3098587989807129,
0.9865767359733582,
0.4419746696949005,
-0.7580437660217285,
0.5166137218475342,
-0.508041501045227,
0.1417025327682495,
0.4347279965877533,
0.6043980121612549,
-0.43677395582199097,
0.26425498723983765,
-0.37291568517684937,
-0.9123910069465637,
0.4520170986652374,
0.28280875086784363,
0.5681468844413757,
-0.06441667675971985,
0.10693864524364471,
0.37960630655288696,
0.2767944037914276,
-0.6303066611289978,
-0.14455552399158478,
-0.42415300011634827,
-0.08940304070711136,
-0.08103759586811066,
-0.29513198137283325,
-0.19908659160137177,
-0.1413627564907074,
0.1989460289478302,
-0.11934184283018112,
0.5387831926345825,
-0.008388325572013855,
-0.00812502484768629,
0.09369127452373505,
0.29795488715171814,
0.9167608618736267,
0.9350077509880066,
-0.13815443217754364,
0.11282504349946976,
-0.27318519353866577,
-0.21914954483509064,
0.1591094732284546,
0.25041911005973816,
0.10291356593370438,
0.4259283244609833,
0.5685902237892151,
0.7993334531784058,
0.20273831486701965,
-0.491375595331192,
0.6155639290809631,
-0.3772255480289459,
-0.16636337339878082,
0.0550682358443737,
-0.37722867727279663,
0.31107833981513977,
0.31078940629959106,
0.4300415813922882,
0.4821372926235199,
0.25475502014160156,
-0.596276044845581,
0.46007493138313293,
0.5105363726615906,
-0.501939594745636,
-0.23135292530059814,
0.42304861545562744,
0.3129306435585022,
-0.22290819883346558,
0.5633399486541748,
-0.08998265862464905,
-0.46902886033058167,
0.9179471135139465,
0.4273747503757477,
0.9603490233421326,
0.287407785654068,
0.4450060725212097,
0.16520249843597412,
0.20760497450828552,
0.1369912475347519,
0.2628507912158966,
-0.15604674816131592,
-0.6186310648918152,
-0.19988951086997986,
-0.5781972408294678,
-0.27322983741760254,
-0.06964409351348877,
-0.701937198638916,
0.1892150342464447,
-0.15522947907447815,
-0.4823641777038574,
0.6449991464614868,
-0.03305050730705261,
-0.31672027707099915,
0.29172658920288086,
0.2679961919784546,
0.9133360385894775,
-0.7316178679466248,
0.6108786463737488,
1.103987216949463,
-0.4361874759197235,
0.13387125730514526,
0.2006881833076477,
-0.08468074351549149,
-0.2240045666694641,
0.6332232356071472,
0.12479591369628906,
0.26368215680122375,
-0.38080477714538574,
-0.33294373750686646,
-0.5379623174667358,
1.1456331014633179,
0.2520081400871277,
-0.30891814827919006,
-0.039117518812417984,
0.05832240730524063,
0.5966619849205017,
-0.37699952721595764,
0.6212382912635803,
-0.11176768690347672,
0.4756286144256592,
0.08298739790916443,
-0.7229339480400085,
-0.3198672831058502,
-0.6696918606758118,
0.2276628017425537,
-0.0026702205650508404,
-0.5780721306800842,
0.9636792540550232,
0.026126347482204437,
-0.08122900128364563,
0.41822174191474915,
0.6172309517860413,
0.0518626943230629,
0.7100208401679993,
0.33403271436691284,
0.5869346261024475,
0.654410183429718,
-0.2801162004470825,
1.2155821323394775,
-0.34887561202049255,
0.40864118933677673,
0.9028628468513489,
-0.3913860023021698,
0.4936884343624115,
0.4956786334514618,
0.0026276297867298126,
0.07347553223371506,
0.8646066784858704,
-0.024973208084702492,
0.9119372367858887,
0.030453702434897423,
-0.14627397060394287,
-0.3102603554725647,
-0.47437119483947754,
-0.5192424654960632,
0.5469138026237488,
0.30686894059181213,
-0.33418118953704834,
-0.46627867221832275,
0.1021619588136673,
-0.4873529076576233,
0.22195006906986237,
-0.06456072628498077,
0.8177197575569153,
-0.033288490027189255,
-0.6111847758293152,
0.12347934395074844,
0.4031190574169159,
0.816163957118988,
-0.6741165518760681,
-0.05401637405157089,
-0.28917059302330017,
-0.07295289635658264,
0.020083321258425713,
-0.8257330060005188,
0.41467761993408203,
-0.05964748561382294,
-0.45567232370376587,
-0.5123912692070007,
1.1251695156097412,
-0.3610011339187622,
-0.43611398339271545,
0.1577952355146408,
0.42640766501426697,
-0.24417471885681152,
-0.06857477873563766,
-0.8936237096786499,
0.06042621284723282,
-0.19258281588554382,
-0.1346735954284668,
0.2915126085281372,
0.41629496216773987,
-0.08961264789104462,
0.5351467728614807,
0.6575849652290344,
-0.2128942310810089,
-0.041896235197782516,
-0.03323240950703621,
0.938051164150238,
-0.6155611872673035,
-0.5525789856910706,
-0.7462143898010254,
0.8911347389221191,
-0.17817465960979462,
-0.6464294195175171,
0.5459085702896118,
0.6805922389030457,
0.4509392976760864,
-0.16801832616329193,
0.7166000604629517,
0.03604993596673012,
0.16353173553943634,
-0.4499894976615906,
0.918825626373291,
-0.9674611687660217,
-0.04952185973525047,
-0.5034923553466797,
-1.0064910650253296,
-0.09714500606060028,
0.49482280015945435,
-0.18137633800506592,
0.09475211054086685,
0.8681885004043579,
0.6733909249305725,
-0.3043370544910431,
0.3092118203639984,
0.3228242099285126,
-0.2542043924331665,
-0.03159426152706146,
0.2851989269256592,
1.4561841487884521,
-0.25889354944229126,
0.27184104919433594,
-0.5037031769752502,
-0.14404296875,
-0.011793408542871475,
-0.9853136539459229,
-0.6970741748809814,
-0.9657703042030334,
-0.42815670371055603,
-0.11722131818532944,
0.06939664483070374,
0.4372485280036926,
1.0128579139709473,
-0.47179901599884033,
-0.02856311947107315,
0.21814219653606415,
0.20216773450374603,
0.15772290527820587,
-0.13290980458259583,
0.3122525215148926,
-0.11545087397098541,
-0.5009616017341614,
0.23754993081092834,
0.4592394530773163,
-0.06360070407390594,
-0.4956119954586029,
-0.08678200840950012,
-0.4187157154083252,
-0.050420235842466354,
0.41662663221359253,
-0.29132384061813354,
-0.7860813736915588,
0.272051602602005,
0.1579066514968872,
-0.42766910791397095,
0.04060318320989609,
1.0673255920410156,
-0.3462715446949005,
0.6544595956802368,
0.7058880925178528,
0.7892469167709351,
0.4809522032737732,
-0.058489974588155746,
0.3845476806163788,
-0.608573853969574,
0.3362232744693756,
0.2905111312866211,
0.5052131414413452,
0.4121701419353485,
-0.040841639041900635,
0.2807179391384125,
0.2037297934293747,
-0.16656626760959625,
-0.8288636803627014,
0.09936206042766571,
-1.195236086845398,
-0.36906152963638306,
0.8012015223503113,
-0.19735155999660492,
0.15062646567821503,
0.2220376431941986,
-0.2628497779369354,
0.14682669937610626,
-0.19697114825248718,
0.6838356852531433,
0.9005303382873535,
0.17503516376018524,
-0.19036120176315308,
-0.38989970088005066,
-0.3691202402114868,
0.5631953477859497,
-0.8927785158157349,
-0.5320743918418884,
0.6272842884063721,
0.06975117325782776,
0.521310031414032,
0.41406697034835815,
-0.21826189756393433,
0.4497207999229431,
0.2242821305990219,
0.04544699564576149,
-0.017336206510663033,
-0.7280867695808411,
-0.5083914995193481,
0.2641541063785553,
-0.3025306761264801,
-0.13581162691116333
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17307v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17307v1
|
HILL: Hierarchy-aware Information Lossless Contrastive Learning for Hierarchical Text Classification
| 2024-03-26T01:29:17 | 2024-03-26T01:29:17 |
He Zhu, Junran Wu, Ruomei Liu, Yue Hou, Ze Yuan, Shangzhe Li, Yicheng Pan, Ke Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IT, math.IT
|
Existing self-supervised methods in natural language processing (NLP),
especially hierarchical text classification (HTC), mainly focus on
self-supervised contrastive learning, extremely relying on human-designed
augmentation rules to generate contrastive samples, which can potentially
corrupt or distort the original information. In this paper, we tend to
investigate the feasibility of a contrastive learning scheme in which the
semantic and syntactic information inherent in the input sample is adequately
reserved in the contrastive samples and fused during the learning process.
Specifically, we propose an information lossless contrastive learning strategy
for HTC, namely \textbf{H}ierarchy-aware \textbf{I}nformation \textbf{L}ossless
contrastive \textbf{L}earning (HILL), which consists of a text encoder
representing the input document, and a structure encoder directly generating
the positive sample. The structure encoder takes the document embedding as
input, extracts the essential syntactic information inherent in the label
hierarchy with the principle of structural entropy minimization, and injects
the syntactic information into the text representation via hierarchical
representation learning. Experiments on three common datasets are conducted to
verify the superiority of HILL.
|
[
0.0953066423535347,
-0.515887439250946,
0.04086317494511604,
0.11698036640882492,
-0.012054210528731346,
0.32340672612190247,
0.10926448553800583,
-0.5163384079933167,
0.31760331988334656,
0.22003966569900513,
-0.48150864243507385,
-0.564875066280365,
-0.4716101884841919,
0.16403640806674957,
-0.166463702917099,
1.0354840755462646,
-0.020284077152609825,
-0.3068303167819977,
-0.18866290152072906,
-0.00021828603348694742,
-0.13018614053726196,
-0.5186083912849426,
-0.517553448677063,
-0.3544279932975769,
0.24353833496570587,
0.36814889311790466,
0.44024091958999634,
1.071754813194275,
0.523565411567688,
0.3548450469970703,
-0.026281043887138367,
0.00010940840002149343,
-0.5106006860733032,
0.35449132323265076,
-0.05495810508728027,
-0.35754209756851196,
-0.0820406898856163,
-0.05270525813102722,
0.6919906139373779,
0.749606728553772,
-0.2661466896533966,
-0.10974640399217606,
0.5980315804481506,
0.7185624837875366,
-0.8757836818695068,
0.24965223670005798,
-0.7707675099372864,
0.3676452338695526,
-0.12528207898139954,
-0.7110617756843567,
-0.5149074196815491,
-0.0521945059299469,
-0.09717292338609695,
-0.6785004734992981,
0.3485948443412781,
0.3223390579223633,
0.8249784111976624,
0.4914589822292328,
-0.35757601261138916,
-0.37381622195243835,
-0.49137571454048157,
0.7852016687393188,
-0.37293022871017456,
0.32388028502464294,
0.5250622034072876,
0.16516311466693878,
0.08398643136024475,
-0.3237425684928894,
-0.3774721920490265,
-0.039146918803453445,
-0.3019404113292694,
0.514427661895752,
-0.13485844433307648,
0.31373316049575806,
-0.04951421916484833,
0.7034359574317932,
-0.5960848331451416,
0.31611642241477966,
-0.15212514996528625,
-0.3158855438232422,
0.027370823547244072,
0.04956798255443573,
-0.0010765495244413614,
-0.47359132766723633,
-0.5755627751350403,
-0.12227308005094528,
-0.3136862814426422,
-0.12599284946918488,
0.11555998027324677,
0.2769879996776581,
-0.25512564182281494,
0.28163397312164307,
-0.3021884560585022,
0.3687664866447449,
0.5207077860832214,
-0.22575965523719788,
0.4472634196281433,
-0.14677517116069794,
-0.554044783115387,
0.279360294342041,
0.7538501620292664,
-0.03845004737377167,
-0.30715513229370117,
-0.28689199686050415,
-0.2070201188325882,
0.02876647375524044,
0.1559131145477295,
-0.7699989676475525,
-0.27414456009864807,
0.1676420420408249,
-0.47461268305778503,
-0.436743825674057,
-0.07556168735027313,
-0.6757789850234985,
-0.5176108479499817,
0.013371418230235577,
0.5135592818260193,
-0.41135159134864807,
-0.015747636556625366,
-0.0308226365596056,
-0.026144325733184814,
-0.00036413120687939227,
0.248922660946846,
-1.112148642539978,
0.5242635607719421,
0.18014593422412872,
0.681778073310852,
-0.24761246144771576,
-0.29123082756996155,
-0.63325035572052,
0.37214136123657227,
-0.2174786627292633,
0.5119644403457642,
-0.14962711930274963,
-0.17051491141319275,
0.07659352570772171,
-0.35834529995918274,
-0.09736984223127365,
-0.7648225426673889,
0.4055110216140747,
-0.2978197932243347,
0.28392142057418823,
0.3515327572822571,
-0.5199916958808899,
0.09031953662633896,
0.5178535580635071,
-0.6214384436607361,
1.04287850856781,
0.06665931642055511,
-1.254543662071228,
0.16546763479709625,
-0.1884656399488449,
-0.49482616782188416,
0.18320856988430023,
-0.36501723527908325,
-0.4985020160675049,
-0.30023765563964844,
0.05865541473031044,
0.41886356472969055,
0.0036962812300771475,
0.1563464254140854,
0.027146849781274796,
-0.11188159137964249,
-0.2400386482477188,
-0.3040394186973572,
0.7014535665512085,
0.16602236032485962,
-0.5360440611839294,
0.10444255918264389,
-0.8875643014907837,
-0.2549598217010498,
0.0632484182715416,
-0.6970917582511902,
-0.5759065747261047,
-0.10838515311479568,
-0.02963974140584469,
0.25066664814949036,
0.23398104310035706,
-0.5990790128707886,
-0.12117472290992737,
-0.4836682081222534,
0.02123936638236046,
0.7615803480148315,
-0.06824589520692825,
0.5410924553871155,
-0.402009516954422,
0.3613835871219635,
0.3350599408149719,
-0.19110718369483948,
-0.2794858515262604,
-0.009807497262954712,
-0.900165319442749,
-0.28555652499198914,
0.47053423523902893,
0.701191246509552,
-0.918518602848053,
0.8674042224884033,
-0.01647329516708851,
-0.10940001904964447,
-0.5579928755760193,
0.17865362763404846,
0.5600787401199341,
1.0024291276931763,
0.6453465819358826,
0.07940679788589478,
-0.7068618535995483,
-0.8674246072769165,
-0.10192827880382538,
-0.14556026458740234,
0.03248102217912674,
0.04821386933326721,
0.3698095977306366,
-0.35504236817359924,
0.6917887330055237,
-0.38455507159233093,
-0.6959800720214844,
-0.40765121579170227,
0.631914496421814,
-0.14037488400936127,
0.7687473893165588,
0.09317106753587723,
-0.7289942502975464,
-0.31046998500823975,
0.07404007762670517,
-0.8262141346931458,
-0.17056776583194733,
-0.23342211544513702,
-0.09648341685533524,
0.25106480717658997,
0.7316576242446899,
-0.263728529214859,
0.4222325086593628,
0.5490956902503967,
0.08014388382434845,
0.34484776854515076,
-0.49073290824890137,
0.04299096018075943,
-1.3354220390319824,
-0.23962858319282532,
0.3955773115158081,
-0.30659228563308716,
-0.4932456910610199,
0.02259756065905094,
0.22772963345050812,
0.09851832687854767,
0.10718956589698792,
0.38242107629776,
-0.5091070532798767,
0.2976955771446228,
-0.2830657362937927,
0.22384417057037354,
-0.09736689925193787,
0.7032522559165955,
0.1411719024181366,
0.3964006304740906,
0.5668631792068481,
-0.7267462611198425,
-0.22108137607574463,
0.21156053245067596,
-0.18203388154506683,
0.6269267797470093,
-0.25439542531967163,
-0.22389422357082367,
-0.4102931320667267,
0.3530895411968231,
-0.9870360493659973,
-0.12974990904331207,
0.4449101984500885,
-0.48427867889404297,
0.4459327757358551,
0.07722775638103485,
-0.29746851325035095,
0.04516100138425827,
-0.27580463886260986,
0.33074861764907837,
0.4904478192329407,
-0.633743405342102,
0.47050875425338745,
0.5453466773033142,
-0.20392447710037231,
-0.6828297972679138,
-0.8954578042030334,
-0.18206122517585754,
-0.12851274013519287,
-0.08968067914247513,
0.8254072070121765,
-0.03937586396932602,
0.007417107466608286,
0.09309534728527069,
-0.5451719164848328,
-0.34584686160087585,
-0.029180482029914856,
0.26690369844436646,
0.1272839456796646,
-0.14360405504703522,
0.5124886631965637,
0.15862074494361877,
-0.22722797095775604,
-0.16074314713478088,
-0.3661516606807709,
0.38497039675712585,
0.03007911518216133,
-0.006724739447236061,
-0.7641996741294861,
0.24188737571239471,
-0.0307797659188509,
0.01778355985879898,
0.5697000622749329,
0.4161681532859802,
-0.6688762307167053,
-0.40944522619247437,
-0.3743859529495239,
0.10520689934492111,
-0.43412312865257263,
0.23511230945587158,
-0.29083532094955444,
-0.9842962622642517,
0.158896803855896,
-0.08474459499120712,
-0.17857949435710907,
0.8976755738258362,
0.24576494097709656,
-0.4478724002838135,
0.7417797446250916,
0.8873676061630249,
-0.2784757614135742,
0.5041847825050354,
-0.3237018883228302,
-0.04593891650438309,
-0.6179710030555725,
-0.3472447097301483,
-0.7707244753837585,
-0.2465163916349411,
-0.8409752249717712,
-0.17477303743362427,
0.2337767779827118,
0.04230247810482979,
-0.2221907079219818,
0.1484503448009491,
-0.4184562861919403,
0.4693027138710022,
0.4941152036190033,
0.15129904448986053,
0.4193105399608612,
0.12222873419523239,
-0.1616908460855484,
-0.16844908893108368,
-0.7741550207138062,
0.06601805239915848,
0.35229986906051636,
0.3127027750015259,
1.1199482679367065,
-0.2615170180797577,
1.1919947862625122,
0.37296146154403687,
-0.021584372967481613,
-0.8121407628059387,
0.2738969027996063,
-0.15221260488033295,
-0.0910881832242012,
-0.2561888098716736,
-0.9887328743934631,
-1.0041123628616333,
0.23816828429698944,
-0.3827430009841919,
-0.45240288972854614,
0.42021235823631287,
0.29974129796028137,
-0.1246025562286377,
0.34522250294685364,
-0.47082602977752686,
0.7182390689849854,
-0.04941561818122864,
-0.17206993699073792,
-0.30103862285614014,
-0.8402395844459534,
-0.02493719570338726,
-0.009839455597102642,
0.2113170474767685,
0.27707239985466003,
0.005512367933988571,
0.8657332062721252,
-0.17611922323703766,
0.9358782768249512,
-0.09832729399204254,
0.04864111170172691,
0.01228658203035593,
0.2960883378982544,
0.2969766855239868,
-0.4218277335166931,
0.08385048806667328,
-0.08403045684099197,
-0.34700798988342285,
-0.34494006633758545,
-0.48696383833885193,
0.5436285138130188,
-0.5647468566894531,
-0.3756907880306244,
-0.605017900466919,
-0.49126681685447693,
-0.25098276138305664,
0.3214343786239624,
0.473755806684494,
0.5354859828948975,
-0.01797623001039028,
0.44042137265205383,
0.6307314038276672,
0.09874624758958817,
0.29657554626464844,
0.130940780043602,
0.1471131443977356,
-0.3857666552066803,
1.0268698930740356,
-0.03450567647814751,
0.1930999606847763,
1.0833091735839844,
0.5889032483100891,
-0.27281665802001953,
-0.652301013469696,
-0.07262373715639114,
0.06021573767066002,
-0.8209335803985596,
-0.49019739031791687,
-0.6595112085342407,
-0.5033062696456909,
-0.19674326479434967,
-0.21634213626384735,
-0.00468073645606637,
-0.4505186975002289,
-0.16549734771251678,
-0.12754006683826447,
-0.19566041231155396,
0.7364630103111267,
-0.03154692053794861,
0.43751320242881775,
-0.5894548892974854,
0.6341237425804138,
0.12171372026205063,
0.2201775163412094,
-0.08637067675590515,
-0.45561331510543823,
-0.376580148935318,
-0.14843982458114624,
-0.4510817229747772,
-0.6257896423339844,
0.3179643452167511,
0.28575029969215393,
0.6187011003494263,
0.2616254687309265,
0.35128867626190186,
0.5284270644187927,
-0.23374861478805542,
0.31795820593833923,
0.4445485770702362,
-0.9190807938575745,
0.6191133856773376,
-0.21010611951351166,
0.43174758553504944,
0.8631561994552612,
0.6106925010681152,
-0.39537128806114197,
-0.5557143688201904,
-0.6054994463920593,
-0.664879560470581,
0.6505432724952698,
0.111100934445858,
-0.2241925150156021,
-0.09722675383090973,
0.07935195416212082,
0.2674427330493927,
0.23049432039260864,
-1.0520087480545044,
-0.16618500649929047,
-0.2754231095314026,
-0.6565485596656799,
0.38007524609565735,
0.0016977170016616583,
0.24244728684425354,
-0.1504269540309906,
0.6333215832710266,
-0.1447272002696991,
-0.21911898255348206,
0.4177525043487549,
-0.2502829432487488,
-0.12286735326051712,
0.4335896074771881,
-0.18372924625873566,
0.15880247950553894,
-0.3331223428249359,
0.49772435426712036,
-0.16713491082191467,
-0.39284297823905945,
0.020319733768701553,
0.08331026881933212,
-0.2729651927947998,
-0.178806871175766,
0.21982859075069427,
0.5026490688323975,
0.39261868596076965,
-0.3087370693683624,
0.366044819355011,
0.11093693226575851,
-0.44281598925590515,
0.26519322395324707,
-0.19210271537303925,
-0.3032824397087097,
-0.07109314948320389,
0.3507158160209656,
0.29655027389526367,
0.4669507145881653,
-0.5705658793449402,
0.2507661283016205,
0.29700398445129395,
-0.5924707651138306,
0.15724284946918488,
0.34287193417549133,
0.25497397780418396,
-0.11641404777765274,
0.5156441330909729,
-0.32894840836524963,
-0.37970447540283203,
0.28919464349746704,
0.9417099952697754,
0.9043838977813721,
-0.5044610500335693,
0.3979789614677429,
0.5291325449943542,
0.17380045354366302,
0.07017730921506882,
-0.14232267439365387,
-0.5244892239570618,
-0.7032384872436523,
-0.1015334501862526,
-0.5962960720062256,
-0.5703557133674622,
0.06730221956968307,
-0.5469892024993896,
-0.14874830842018127,
-0.5966859459877014,
0.33237504959106445,
-0.09478667378425598,
-0.08915084600448608,
-0.23169024288654327,
0.46637842059135437,
-0.048939503729343414,
0.8354461789131165,
-0.5381671190261841,
0.681770384311676,
0.2321029156446457,
-0.39005881547927856,
-0.39724528789520264,
0.6518021821975708,
-0.15763816237449646,
-0.695327877998352,
0.7466017603874207,
0.3752589523792267,
-0.6971556544303894,
0.12098022550344467,
-0.3879658579826355,
-0.4509158134460449,
0.8764926195144653,
0.22774268686771393,
-0.2354716807603836,
-0.18026261031627655,
-0.024629950523376465,
0.48064500093460083,
-0.4337456226348877,
-0.07665068656206131,
0.17422540485858917,
0.08735185861587524,
0.3283426761627197,
-0.650589644908905,
0.031124738976359367,
-0.5081073045730591,
-0.1673150211572647,
0.25247013568878174,
-0.307308554649353,
0.7331902384757996,
-0.11443690955638885,
-0.6036621928215027,
0.04758121818304062,
0.7632215619087219,
0.035739053040742874,
0.23091325163841248,
0.5961310267448425,
0.5528575778007507,
0.9550431966781616,
0.09596811234951019,
1.0334579944610596,
-0.20758570730686188,
0.40828704833984375,
1.0848959684371948,
-0.035793885588645935,
0.9625101685523987,
0.19446928799152374,
0.13014507293701172,
0.7524831295013428,
0.5626473426818848,
0.2687583267688751,
0.6392573714256287,
0.358970046043396,
-0.0839107558131218,
-0.19879326224327087,
-0.2954882085323334,
-0.2067074179649353,
0.3712339699268341,
0.24635376036167145,
-0.0382373109459877,
-0.43938446044921875,
-0.2653951346874237,
-0.21212530136108398,
0.2557320296764374,
-0.45124927163124084,
0.918165385723114,
-0.05883147567510605,
-0.24847593903541565,
0.706117570400238,
0.02237938717007637,
1.0294198989868164,
-0.7661230564117432,
-0.18482454121112823,
0.014825371094048023,
0.22600369155406952,
-0.49318498373031616,
-0.5956728458404541,
0.2543671429157257,
-0.31718990206718445,
-0.1406107246875763,
-0.28438958525657654,
0.7253249883651733,
-0.7368283867835999,
-0.2612192630767822,
0.3172409236431122,
0.3484169840812683,
-0.22028577327728271,
0.11241909116506577,
-0.5510396361351013,
-0.4835459291934967,
-0.3619684875011444,
0.21714287996292114,
0.4870220720767975,
0.38049575686454773,
0.2644960582256317,
0.540225625038147,
0.16861207783222198,
0.12224622815847397,
-0.17196553945541382,
0.08707120269536972,
0.5447388887405396,
-0.7424027323722839,
-1.0842205286026,
-0.6702241897583008,
0.2762010097503662,
-0.19048041105270386,
-0.19095419347286224,
0.751848042011261,
0.6507255434989929,
0.9664372801780701,
0.026351701468229294,
0.8795974254608154,
0.13767266273498535,
0.5191888809204102,
-0.7847103476524353,
0.44503048062324524,
-0.5821439623832703,
-0.01087988168001175,
-0.21375584602355957,
-0.5518618226051331,
-0.39155396819114685,
0.6495316624641418,
0.03282489627599716,
0.11165867745876312,
1.1231781244277954,
0.45423629879951477,
-0.06321856379508972,
-0.0034534824080765247,
0.2863791286945343,
0.34137529134750366,
-0.2152266949415207,
0.5059865117073059,
0.669154942035675,
-0.4385432004928589,
0.6375364661216736,
-0.34631991386413574,
-0.5238977670669556,
-0.1562661975622177,
-0.7756212949752808,
-0.7809640169143677,
-0.7056389451026917,
-0.31783461570739746,
-0.2997736930847168,
0.025743989273905754,
0.955307126045227,
0.6758209466934204,
-0.7145164012908936,
-0.3963865041732788,
-0.29734140634536743,
0.29344406723976135,
-0.1984502077102661,
-0.23075246810913086,
0.4625244140625,
-0.6132286190986633,
-0.4404562711715698,
0.3969811797142029,
0.5548065900802612,
0.09053433686494827,
-0.11600134521722794,
-0.08617720007896423,
-0.10184543579816818,
-0.20301517844200134,
0.4435233473777771,
0.29456761479377747,
-0.3548862934112549,
-0.004938012454658747,
-0.23394539952278137,
-0.40998271107673645,
0.6211159825325012,
0.7916377186775208,
-0.9214174747467041,
0.3656381666660309,
0.62802654504776,
1.1516377925872803,
0.37831005454063416,
0.12633536756038666,
0.14087772369384766,
-0.9571104049682617,
-0.10313723981380463,
0.2222120463848114,
0.37109994888305664,
0.43201106786727905,
-0.5341771245002747,
0.23783676326274872,
0.2818923592567444,
-0.35200121998786926,
-0.21717408299446106,
0.26109424233436584,
-1.0757545232772827,
-0.22246681153774261,
0.8763470649719238,
0.1273939609527588,
-0.17401224374771118,
-0.20923347771167755,
-0.2302979677915573,
0.20680740475654602,
-0.3593478798866272,
0.9674054980278015,
0.28237661719322205,
-0.21780596673488617,
-0.1665438860654831,
-0.14670459926128387,
0.569969654083252,
0.21008114516735077,
-1.1879127025604248,
0.12587711215019226,
0.41444846987724304,
-0.13644136488437653,
0.45716333389282227,
0.7962344884872437,
0.0664234533905983,
0.07479730993509293,
0.22830352187156677,
-0.040260735899209976,
0.07880257815122604,
-0.585222065448761,
-0.5096827149391174,
0.4182107448577881,
-0.21988189220428467,
-0.35785335302352905
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17299v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17299v1
|
Decoding Probing: Revealing Internal Linguistic Structures in Neural Language Models using Minimal Pairs
| 2024-03-26T00:56:06 | 2024-03-26T00:56:06 |
Linyang He, Peili Chen, Ercong Nie, Yuanning Li, Jonathan R. Brennan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, q-bio.NC
|
Inspired by cognitive neuroscience studies, we introduce a novel `decoding
probing' method that uses minimal pairs benchmark (BLiMP) to probe internal
linguistic characteristics in neural language models layer by layer. By
treating the language model as the `brain' and its representations as `neural
activations', we decode grammaticality labels of minimal pairs from the
intermediate layers' representations. This approach reveals: 1) Self-supervised
language models capture abstract linguistic structures in intermediate layers
that GloVe and RNN language models cannot learn. 2) Information about syntactic
grammaticality is robustly captured through the first third layers of GPT-2 and
also distributed in later layers. As sentence complexity increases, more layers
are required for learning grammatical capabilities. 3) Morphological and
semantics/syntax interface-related features are harder to capture than syntax.
4) For Transformer-based models, both embeddings and attentions capture
grammatical features but show distinct patterns. Different attention heads
exhibit similar tendencies toward various linguistic phenomena, but with varied
contributions.
|
[
-0.25169286131858826,
-0.9817292094230652,
0.3982371389865875,
0.2952589690685272,
0.015000942163169384,
-0.19309116899967194,
-0.3506460189819336,
-0.240225687623024,
0.23413188755512238,
0.2780393958091736,
-0.5217025876045227,
-0.2586265504360199,
-0.462678998708725,
0.1129242554306984,
-0.3776789605617523,
0.853570818901062,
0.5420068502426147,
0.008577222935855389,
-0.474094420671463,
-0.025707146152853966,
-0.12075009942054749,
-0.7141403555870056,
-0.7471874356269836,
-0.46204423904418945,
0.4772050380706787,
0.26857051253318787,
0.5876958966255188,
0.6160022616386414,
0.3567657172679901,
0.36169517040252686,
-0.4347706735134125,
-0.08731962740421295,
-0.3965966999530792,
-0.12340723723173141,
-0.10928069055080414,
-0.6729199290275574,
-0.2448853850364685,
-0.10385151952505112,
0.596338152885437,
1.1611829996109009,
0.10879653692245483,
0.2547607421875,
0.262044757604599,
0.6295211911201477,
-0.5306419134140015,
0.309619277715683,
-0.5804408192634583,
-0.05811510980129242,
-0.21683281660079956,
-0.018359074369072914,
-0.7002673149108887,
0.19900314509868622,
-0.03008352965116501,
-0.20068728923797607,
0.5062767267227173,
-0.14018170535564423,
0.778556227684021,
0.18645933270454407,
-0.6157188415527344,
-0.06463504582643509,
-0.3752705752849579,
0.4119901657104492,
-0.641444981098175,
0.460324764251709,
0.6126397848129272,
0.005304984748363495,
0.15149568021297455,
-0.7405287623405457,
-0.37920376658439636,
-0.6187182664871216,
-0.5671921968460083,
0.012371333315968513,
-0.37672144174575806,
0.2240736335515976,
0.2461586445569992,
0.3623521327972412,
-0.7539571523666382,
-0.11372104287147522,
-0.4176922142505646,
-0.24696262180805206,
0.3716755211353302,
0.07856239378452301,
0.5023593306541443,
-0.4789395034313202,
-0.2547261416912079,
-0.1085791066288948,
-0.5137967467308044,
0.24678891897201538,
0.27852585911750793,
0.29873913526535034,
-0.3924674689769745,
0.6974145770072937,
-0.0834290161728859,
0.5578820705413818,
0.0582147054374218,
0.4597794711589813,
0.09032248705625534,
-0.36470022797584534,
-0.3134685456752777,
-0.009666233323514462,
0.7734813690185547,
0.04856070503592491,
-0.052764005959033966,
-0.4272155463695526,
-0.17806564271450043,
0.42047926783561707,
0.1462508887052536,
-0.301962286233902,
-0.5900421142578125,
0.13884156942367554,
-0.4681832492351532,
-0.3092774748802185,
-0.27345895767211914,
-0.6362066864967346,
-0.05780785158276558,
-0.29026278853416443,
0.22335036098957062,
-0.5410167574882507,
-0.3604825735092163,
0.16777513921260834,
-0.18799126148223877,
0.5756015181541443,
-0.28603771328926086,
-1.2526248693466187,
0.7647905349731445,
0.7883338332176208,
0.8418780565261841,
0.07242250442504883,
-0.4638647735118866,
-0.27807894349098206,
-0.041899632662534714,
-0.30308130383491516,
0.6092923879623413,
-0.4038396179676056,
0.005600581876933575,
0.029673611745238304,
-0.1837405115365982,
-0.25655022263526917,
-0.42377936840057373,
0.390459805727005,
-0.5479479432106018,
-0.058882247656583786,
-0.3453216254711151,
-0.5541744828224182,
-0.23865501582622528,
0.41987964510917664,
-0.7043638229370117,
1.0211262702941895,
0.07070400565862656,
-0.6970914602279663,
-0.15894223749637604,
-0.5403351783752441,
-0.24019818007946014,
0.19797971844673157,
-0.1573685258626938,
0.06336676329374313,
0.5880098938941956,
0.35446739196777344,
0.34057536721229553,
-0.07811778783798218,
0.06311861425638199,
-0.2564444839954376,
-0.01896052248775959,
0.31375017762184143,
-0.2947496473789215,
0.9761430025100708,
-0.09493165463209152,
-0.21302133798599243,
-0.03238942474126816,
-0.6989474892616272,
0.20388004183769226,
0.149105042219162,
-0.10048691928386688,
-0.3159821033477783,
-0.17266333103179932,
0.15456978976726532,
0.0029328649397939444,
0.3097071945667267,
-0.4292317032814026,
0.12420418858528137,
-0.6576453447341919,
0.7779561877250671,
0.445724219083786,
0.08024371415376663,
0.7781224846839905,
-0.07395797967910767,
0.3449820578098297,
0.15094582736492157,
-0.1995776742696762,
-0.1738719344139099,
-0.4357176721096039,
-1.127847671508789,
0.003709333250299096,
0.28343334794044495,
0.5080975294113159,
-0.5692209601402283,
0.40002188086509705,
-0.29154205322265625,
-0.27117258310317993,
-0.7755762934684753,
0.20181149244308472,
0.9054873585700989,
0.39278358221054077,
0.37543371319770813,
-0.21493349969387054,
-0.3603823482990265,
-1.1622709035873413,
-0.3988218903541565,
-0.18727688491344452,
-0.008442549034953117,
0.10337954759597778,
0.6599098443984985,
-0.1375613957643509,
0.5687564611434937,
-0.3330397605895996,
-0.30537712574005127,
-0.4452657699584961,
0.09152913093566895,
0.18848060071468353,
0.37048086524009705,
0.498374879360199,
-0.5123727917671204,
-0.25632765889167786,
0.15015095472335815,
-0.8395352959632874,
0.09625646471977234,
0.08999859541654587,
-0.10500751435756683,
-0.0380994975566864,
0.6682947278022766,
-0.8575153946876526,
0.06779255717992783,
0.5177106857299805,
-0.40709540247917175,
0.22574616968631744,
-0.19216598570346832,
-0.33393919467926025,
-0.65985107421875,
0.1915396898984909,
0.08888063579797745,
-0.08839897811412811,
-0.8407007455825806,
0.6038816571235657,
0.3654926121234894,
-0.06603250652551651,
-0.25293034315109253,
0.43896484375,
-0.8610289692878723,
-0.1560514122247696,
-0.18486367166042328,
0.06603722274303436,
-0.08008190244436264,
0.7834233045578003,
-0.1079552099108696,
0.5414679646492004,
0.6487609148025513,
-0.5251625776290894,
0.2238774299621582,
0.33618849515914917,
-0.280882865190506,
0.11956331878900528,
-0.8222512006759644,
0.5470592379570007,
-0.2638784945011139,
-0.1694682091474533,
-1.072034239768982,
-0.22239699959754944,
0.07722994685173035,
-0.8666144013404846,
0.2939830720424652,
-0.48944106698036194,
-0.4325399100780487,
0.038428377360105515,
-0.20628319680690765,
0.6476761698722839,
0.6038406491279602,
-0.30038025975227356,
0.5044066309928894,
0.2905058264732361,
-0.061796363443136215,
-0.3362713158130646,
-0.9592316746711731,
0.1575629860162735,
0.14112912118434906,
-0.7479013204574585,
0.1540713906288147,
0.08943888545036316,
-0.27263233065605164,
0.09337712824344635,
-0.17778511345386505,
-0.09028144180774689,
-0.07255412638187408,
0.07046384364366531,
-0.04908156767487526,
-0.743655800819397,
-0.15500085055828094,
0.025217881426215172,
-0.07827166467905045,
0.44636431336402893,
-0.2573186159133911,
0.7037885785102844,
-0.390054851770401,
0.012420644983649254,
-0.5002095699310303,
0.4984380900859833,
0.2899874746799469,
-0.5166363716125488,
0.36934828758239746,
0.2562304735183716,
-0.576791524887085,
-0.3847482204437256,
-0.5268908739089966,
-0.5014249086380005,
-0.5249775052070618,
0.3043055534362793,
-0.8086118102073669,
-0.5504111647605896,
0.5339813828468323,
0.21934568881988525,
-0.6817642450332642,
0.2515064775943756,
0.4159735143184662,
-0.23781539499759674,
0.7006081342697144,
0.7516165971755981,
-0.2835521996021271,
0.17520567774772644,
-0.5552447438240051,
0.06003731116652489,
-0.9548407793045044,
-0.3290266692638397,
-0.48360422253608704,
-0.39241597056388855,
-0.23507502675056458,
-0.14879652857780457,
0.3584764301776886,
0.1104951798915863,
0.06396732479333878,
0.26802343130111694,
-0.3532043397426605,
0.8575748801231384,
0.7115789651870728,
0.41390666365623474,
0.06465961784124374,
0.1045651063323021,
-0.3431701064109802,
-0.24261504411697388,
-0.710092306137085,
-0.22337281703948975,
0.8803252577781677,
0.34442487359046936,
0.4653105139732361,
0.014980867505073547,
0.408271849155426,
0.03826934099197388,
-0.23972353339195251,
-0.999718964099884,
0.6135053038597107,
-0.15877671539783478,
-0.6426090002059937,
-0.06464261561632156,
-0.41735416650772095,
-0.8370729684829712,
0.4484429955482483,
0.12066225707530975,
-0.6804898977279663,
0.2544463276863098,
0.2014094889163971,
-0.2102193981409073,
0.049332693219184875,
-0.798589825630188,
0.9905133247375488,
-0.161855548620224,
-0.37990036606788635,
-0.011913519352674484,
-0.8061524629592896,
0.4407097101211548,
0.6492742300033569,
-0.0277938861399889,
0.23351998627185822,
-0.2545631229877472,
0.48617592453956604,
0.04305019974708557,
1.1679283380508423,
-0.018469221889972687,
0.013420230709016323,
-0.03776352107524872,
0.6619794368743896,
0.1174025908112526,
0.04710962623357773,
0.15071676671504974,
0.0981249064207077,
-0.16587281227111816,
-0.6627812385559082,
-0.6965689659118652,
0.7944778800010681,
-0.6736271977424622,
-0.3857961595058441,
-0.5506502985954285,
-0.47871243953704834,
-0.3186151683330536,
0.2947023808956146,
0.39373165369033813,
0.5256954431533813,
-0.0877397432923317,
0.18378745019435883,
0.5611162781715393,
0.36905160546302795,
0.4877597987651825,
0.22348052263259888,
0.1801718920469284,
-0.5293159484863281,
0.6372950673103333,
-0.16963456571102142,
0.2758995294570923,
0.7286995649337769,
0.16893194615840912,
-0.35808905959129333,
-0.7102863192558289,
-0.2165171205997467,
0.6442159414291382,
-0.7595378756523132,
-0.09711062163114548,
-0.6691102385520935,
-0.3224262595176697,
-0.4402918815612793,
0.13639159500598907,
-0.3461947739124298,
-0.302955687046051,
-0.055354077368974686,
-0.3853346109390259,
0.1211884468793869,
0.7374480962753296,
-0.09521154314279556,
0.46333810687065125,
-0.6534614562988281,
0.41670069098472595,
0.12409824877977371,
0.10519309341907501,
-0.09763895720243454,
-0.524920642375946,
-0.12280844897031784,
0.20303083956241608,
-0.021342987194657326,
-1.0721707344055176,
0.48166623711586,
0.2834691107273102,
0.4309226870536804,
0.27768537402153015,
-0.2788178622722626,
0.595990002155304,
-0.4975435137748718,
0.7698062658309937,
-0.07650536298751831,
-1.3183796405792236,
0.708736002445221,
-0.42409417033195496,
0.35313862562179565,
0.5281298756599426,
0.35453394055366516,
-0.47574692964553833,
-0.29547956585884094,
-0.5406289100646973,
-0.7345606088638306,
0.7555412650108337,
0.3689934313297272,
0.3804193139076233,
-0.05704572796821594,
0.6367440223693848,
-0.14000023901462555,
-0.03836081549525261,
-1.0703105926513672,
-0.3256002366542816,
0.06369859725236893,
-0.22394444048404694,
-0.37234625220298767,
-0.5405404567718506,
-0.4159247875213623,
-0.3334599435329437,
0.2046714425086975,
-0.22525654733181,
0.4473097026348114,
0.3413587808609009,
-0.41228678822517395,
0.30785074830055237,
0.00034248470910824835,
0.6063002943992615,
0.2267158180475235,
-0.111302949488163,
0.5838067531585693,
0.0711807832121849,
-0.2582663893699646,
0.1147659569978714,
-0.2697139084339142,
-0.2706921696662903,
0.0778735876083374,
0.7060522437095642,
0.7542707920074463,
0.4874446988105774,
-0.12695863842964172,
0.6418300867080688,
0.14644646644592285,
-0.13382741808891296,
-0.30567246675491333,
-0.1598552167415619,
0.1942424178123474,
0.22723831236362457,
0.024745753034949303,
0.20988233387470245,
0.3933817446231842,
-0.6336541175842285,
0.2483072131872177,
0.402839720249176,
-0.4380510747432709,
-0.7764109969139099,
0.5541980862617493,
-0.024284206330776215,
-0.19272765517234802,
0.6782007217407227,
-0.22166576981544495,
-0.4756869375705719,
0.7191186547279358,
0.8676208257675171,
0.8003756403923035,
-0.22345691919326782,
0.10667873919010162,
0.39292043447494507,
0.7421073913574219,
-0.06386137008666992,
0.2765010595321655,
-0.2972080111503601,
-0.762051522731781,
-0.27092790603637695,
-0.20563293993473053,
-0.15305033326148987,
0.23107004165649414,
-0.9047892093658447,
0.11270537972450256,
-0.43099093437194824,
0.07447893917560577,
0.19589979946613312,
-0.2385307103395462,
-0.423130065202713,
0.12288862466812134,
0.2554817497730255,
0.879913866519928,
-0.8603843450546265,
0.8184921145439148,
0.6880621910095215,
-0.650050699710846,
-0.568691074848175,
-0.10565318912267685,
0.05889619514346123,
-0.7350651621818542,
0.7860773205757141,
0.3117057681083679,
-0.31744810938835144,
0.10808508843183517,
-0.6702742576599121,
-0.7834892868995667,
0.6342772245407104,
0.6575085520744324,
-0.17854349315166473,
-0.6162024736404419,
0.13539327681064606,
0.6178470253944397,
-0.12449958920478821,
0.38430482149124146,
0.536512553691864,
0.23904366791248322,
-0.31287145614624023,
-0.7397840023040771,
0.1555846929550171,
-0.6422247886657715,
0.1049874871969223,
0.12768834829330444,
-0.4754868149757385,
0.910251259803772,
-0.06605497747659683,
-0.39078599214553833,
0.21596600115299225,
0.7029472589492798,
-0.12837985157966614,
0.32147568464279175,
0.17826905846595764,
0.6828458905220032,
0.44221699237823486,
-0.11203552037477493,
1.217721939086914,
-0.34606698155403137,
0.3839286267757416,
0.9494122266769409,
0.07595565915107727,
1.1067769527435303,
0.5597031116485596,
0.010177366435527802,
0.2616882622241974,
0.2644379734992981,
0.023537395521998405,
0.6609695553779602,
0.23934417963027954,
-0.0549803264439106,
-0.20264208316802979,
0.24481788277626038,
-0.4210032522678375,
0.6068510413169861,
0.6456071138381958,
-0.16764067113399506,
-0.15914739668369293,
0.013693852350115776,
0.12149275094270706,
0.33460313081741333,
-0.17117275297641754,
0.9726676940917969,
0.28457263112068176,
-0.6660162806510925,
0.8381057977676392,
0.09023471176624298,
0.6109103560447693,
-0.722562849521637,
0.15870985388755798,
-0.6249294281005859,
0.33151885867118835,
-0.16541436314582825,
-0.4883657395839691,
0.2979291081428528,
-0.20084676146507263,
-0.15651825070381165,
-0.2706671357154846,
0.5915852189064026,
-0.5696239471435547,
-0.5044872164726257,
0.7286050915718079,
0.5245941281318665,
0.06998449563980103,
-0.25452905893325806,
-0.29407989978790283,
0.11036896705627441,
-0.18460941314697266,
-0.08342532068490982,
0.13772930204868317,
0.5047116875648499,
0.40401405096054077,
0.5749342441558838,
0.5814940333366394,
0.18875455856323242,
0.6000021696090698,
-0.04280608147382736,
0.7963496446609497,
-0.9280290007591248,
-0.41352516412734985,
-0.9327948689460754,
0.6146668791770935,
0.008810696192085743,
-0.44512441754341125,
0.6394374370574951,
0.7672842144966125,
0.9943144917488098,
-0.43891099095344543,
0.3637312054634094,
0.12658856809139252,
0.02650292031466961,
-0.820147693157196,
0.7188680171966553,
-0.4160384237766266,
-0.027261676266789436,
0.15311886370182037,
-0.655478835105896,
-0.4698297083377838,
0.6185726523399353,
-0.06772587448358536,
-0.1002419963479042,
1.0707883834838867,
1.0075807571411133,
-0.48402780294418335,
-0.029453912749886513,
0.4310629367828369,
0.49406570196151733,
-0.032107241451740265,
0.7754605412483215,
0.8654051423072815,
-0.5958139896392822,
0.42738014459609985,
-0.5813789963722229,
-0.25140833854675293,
0.04830612614750862,
-0.4289163649082184,
-1.1734707355499268,
-0.727948784828186,
-0.24458684027194977,
-0.2836288511753082,
0.08856872469186783,
0.5970590114593506,
0.738439679145813,
-0.7029474973678589,
-0.5163461565971375,
-0.35479432344436646,
-0.3283807337284088,
-0.4020572006702423,
-0.247783824801445,
0.3721820116043091,
-0.8279592394828796,
-0.6518934965133667,
0.9004537463188171,
0.09084106981754303,
-0.1552664190530777,
-0.20977835357189178,
0.40175333619117737,
-0.11272494494915009,
-0.11952896416187286,
0.6386349201202393,
0.1821153461933136,
-0.8458046913146973,
0.052866388112306595,
0.2972568869590759,
-0.28677743673324585,
-0.0033307436387985945,
1.0831385850906372,
-0.6098926067352295,
0.09687084704637527,
0.765812337398529,
0.8364292979240417,
0.603833019733429,
-0.30880066752433777,
0.44895005226135254,
-1.1051068305969238,
0.32809022068977356,
0.3925310969352722,
0.4663720428943634,
0.25471585988998413,
-0.37435922026634216,
0.38293129205703735,
0.22794398665428162,
-0.30167436599731445,
-0.8900454640388489,
0.4472304880619049,
-1.4033547639846802,
-0.03121238946914673,
1.100847840309143,
0.016939330846071243,
-0.5632193088531494,
0.17153654992580414,
-0.17289267480373383,
-0.08085136115550995,
-0.13896463811397552,
0.6093165874481201,
0.7354435920715332,
-0.056411754339933395,
-0.4729264974594116,
-0.5633028745651245,
0.5730790495872498,
0.8306719064712524,
-0.5616068243980408,
-0.016127929091453552,
0.39348697662353516,
0.2623280882835388,
0.27738505601882935,
0.4948549270629883,
-0.13887371122837067,
0.3095075190067291,
0.3610214293003082,
-0.18130703270435333,
-0.11532528698444366,
-0.4357653260231018,
-0.8499883413314819,
0.3644770383834839,
-0.05410728603601456,
-0.46593552827835083
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17297v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17297v1
|
InternLM2 Technical Report
| 2024-03-26T00:53:24 | 2024-03-26T00:53:24 |
Zheng Cai, Maosong Cao, Haojiong Chen, Kai Chen, Keyu Chen, Xin Chen, Xun Chen, Zehui Chen, Zhi Chen, Pei Chu, Xiaoyi Dong, Haodong Duan, Qi Fan, Zhaoye Fei, Yang Gao, Jiaye Ge, Chenya Gu, Yuzhe Gu, Tao Gui, Aijia Guo, Qipeng Guo, Conghui He, Yingfan Hu, Ting Huang, Tao Jiang, Penglong Jiao, Zhenjiang Jin, Zhikai Lei, Jiaxing Li, Jingwen Li, Linyang Li, Shuaibin Li, Wei Li, Yining Li, Hongwei Liu, Jiangning Liu, Jiawei Hong, Kaiwen Liu, Kuikun Liu, Xiaoran Liu, Chengqi Lv, Haijun Lv, Kai Lv, Li Ma, Runyuan Ma, Zerun Ma, Wenchang Ning, Linke Ouyang, Jiantao Qiu, Yuan Qu, Fukai Shang, Yunfan Shao, Demin Song, Zifan Song, Zhihao Sui, Peng Sun, Yu Sun, Huanze Tang, Bin Wang, Guoteng Wang, Jiaqi Wang, Jiayu Wang, Rui Wang, Yudong Wang, Ziyi Wang, Xingjian Wei, Qizhen Weng, Fan Wu, Yingtong Xiong, Chao Xu, Ruiliang Xu, Hang Yan, Yirong Yan, Xiaogui Yang, Haochen Ye, Huaiyuan Ying, Jia Yu, Jing Yu, Yuhang Zang, Chuyu Zhang, Li Zhang, Pan Zhang, Peng Zhang, Ruijie Zhang, Shuo Zhang, Songyang Zhang, Wenjian Zhang, Wenwei Zhang, Xingcheng Zhang, Xinyue Zhang, Hui Zhao, Qian Zhao, Xiaomeng Zhao, Fengzhe Zhou, Zaida Zhou, Jingming Zhuo, Yicheng Zou, Xipeng Qiu, Yu Qiao, Dahua Lin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The evolution of Large Language Models (LLMs) like ChatGPT and GPT-4 has
sparked discussions on the advent of Artificial General Intelligence (AGI).
However, replicating such advancements in open-source models has been
challenging. This paper introduces InternLM2, an open-source LLM that
outperforms its predecessors in comprehensive evaluations across 6 dimensions
and 30 benchmarks, long-context modeling, and open-ended subjective evaluations
through innovative pre-training and optimization techniques. The pre-training
process of InternLM2 is meticulously detailed, highlighting the preparation of
diverse data types including text, code, and long-context data. InternLM2
efficiently captures long-term dependencies, initially trained on 4k tokens
before advancing to 32k tokens in pre-training and fine-tuning stages,
exhibiting remarkable performance on the 200k ``Needle-in-a-Haystack" test.
InternLM2 is further aligned using Supervised Fine-Tuning (SFT) and a novel
Conditional Online Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (COOL RLHF)
strategy that addresses conflicting human preferences and reward hacking. By
releasing InternLM2 models in different training stages and model sizes, we
provide the community with insights into the model's evolution.
|
[
-0.3240194320678711,
-0.6377085447311401,
0.4466498792171478,
0.15807603299617767,
-0.06494971364736557,
0.16337275505065918,
-0.46408766508102417,
-0.6378023028373718,
-0.3602851331233978,
0.14211027324199677,
-0.42276298999786377,
-0.37174490094184875,
-0.4369232952594757,
-0.016024086624383926,
-0.4116959273815155,
1.1492829322814941,
-0.06219276785850525,
0.15489356219768524,
-0.2998427152633667,
-0.27191361784935,
-0.19563046097755432,
-0.6166580319404602,
-0.8993509411811829,
-0.46551620960235596,
0.42473268508911133,
0.3636995851993561,
0.5488762855529785,
0.4715037941932678,
0.483133465051651,
0.2291208952665329,
-0.08992244303226471,
0.18939760327339172,
-0.7976906895637512,
-0.3367518484592438,
-0.0651274248957634,
-0.4039173722267151,
-0.48055198788642883,
0.21040573716163635,
0.5099805593490601,
0.2537784278392792,
-0.34771728515625,
0.23362675309181213,
0.09765418618917465,
0.6378409266471863,
-0.3074343800544739,
0.2954292893409729,
-0.89881831407547,
-0.21112172305583954,
-0.2172030508518219,
0.11337490379810333,
-0.37793177366256714,
-0.2502480149269104,
-0.016242988407611847,
-0.5149449706077576,
-0.03620268031954765,
0.16531746089458466,
0.8088235259056091,
0.3441540002822876,
-0.07188478857278824,
-0.3471684455871582,
-0.7964192628860474,
0.6318395733833313,
-0.7702367305755615,
0.19517698884010315,
0.20380006730556488,
0.5104989409446716,
-0.15991735458374023,
-1.0494691133499146,
-0.581528902053833,
-0.5836450457572937,
0.0543907955288887,
0.06671757251024246,
-0.09069042652845383,
-0.0152432257309556,
-0.06590484082698822,
0.24611026048660278,
-0.5913616418838501,
0.4793398976325989,
-0.5672804117202759,
0.20935805141925812,
0.5527998805046082,
0.059647802263498306,
0.1925109326839447,
0.27868035435676575,
-0.4133777916431427,
0.18956255912780762,
-0.933861494064331,
0.12424445152282715,
0.35114574432373047,
0.09480863809585571,
-0.23285986483097076,
0.5087958574295044,
-0.06850947439670563,
0.3997359275817871,
-0.1200576052069664,
0.22224128246307373,
0.440706342458725,
-0.4201369285583496,
0.09048563241958618,
-0.08763500303030014,
0.7404810190200806,
0.2100875973701477,
0.4193432629108429,
-0.2912643253803253,
-0.24736455082893372,
0.028976980596780777,
0.41812512278556824,
-0.6846623420715332,
-0.1722981482744217,
0.2691897451877594,
-0.3751782178878784,
-0.2820034325122833,
0.04993177950382233,
-0.44956594705581665,
-0.16908523440361023,
-0.6674298644065857,
0.3758549988269806,
-0.4740696847438812,
-0.133636474609375,
-0.06255068629980087,
0.0933329239487648,
0.4742893576622009,
0.4545980393886566,
-0.6213380098342896,
0.2978573441505432,
1.1676167249679565,
1.1074188947677612,
-0.5316872000694275,
-0.4220717251300812,
-0.5149887800216675,
-0.031886931508779526,
-0.4084036946296692,
0.6487338542938232,
-0.48370561003685,
-0.31433287262916565,
-0.011812632903456688,
-0.36945220828056335,
0.26446789503097534,
-0.5337859988212585,
0.3318077027797699,
-0.5606516599655151,
0.2549300789833069,
0.1731460690498352,
-0.4331408739089966,
-0.011837962083518505,
0.49530768394470215,
-0.24618299305438995,
1.1722196340560913,
0.5273650288581848,
-0.7243335843086243,
0.10296471416950226,
-1.1112037897109985,
-0.11578034609556198,
0.30478760600090027,
-0.20734232664108276,
-0.27801385521888733,
0.1751524955034256,
-0.02572750858962536,
0.047867223620414734,
-0.4180629253387451,
0.25752943754196167,
-0.3197946846485138,
-0.5399960279464722,
-0.03892599046230316,
-0.28657111525535583,
0.492194801568985,
0.15213721990585327,
-0.2940695285797119,
0.5260348916053772,
-0.7163264751434326,
0.09701603651046753,
0.19004367291927338,
-0.36581680178642273,
-0.15333086252212524,
0.18865160644054413,
-0.1274283528327942,
0.20346802473068237,
0.3833964765071869,
-0.557196855545044,
0.1959722936153412,
-0.5176683664321899,
0.8794469237327576,
0.8368648886680603,
-0.32394883036613464,
0.2811397612094879,
-0.14813946187496185,
0.2965954542160034,
-0.05829869210720062,
0.44468462467193604,
-0.1514831781387329,
-0.3943898379802704,
-0.8061893582344055,
-0.2451663464307785,
0.26019176840782166,
0.5995158553123474,
-0.47521117329597473,
0.3664167821407318,
-0.3703376352787018,
-0.5764963626861572,
-0.6173574328422546,
0.14553764462471008,
0.29420652985572815,
0.46405288577079773,
0.45438164472579956,
-0.1582997590303421,
-0.34162044525146484,
-0.9739762544631958,
-0.09169919043779373,
-0.3138774037361145,
-0.21893133223056793,
0.4469574987888336,
0.4215363562107086,
-0.6974902153015137,
1.06134831905365,
-0.2832176983356476,
-0.26629334688186646,
-0.35761141777038574,
0.36111465096473694,
0.24337412416934967,
0.4180964231491089,
0.5073732137680054,
-0.38705477118492126,
-0.5918242931365967,
0.2445734441280365,
-0.6274496912956238,
-0.03139183297753334,
0.15991142392158508,
-0.07644256949424744,
0.1548173427581787,
0.6306778788566589,
-0.6348991394042969,
0.3224312365055084,
0.3739105463027954,
-0.19657957553863525,
0.694801390171051,
-0.5061226487159729,
-0.1740170568227768,
-0.7590303421020508,
0.245636984705925,
-0.23017649352550507,
-0.2880973219871521,
-0.5025184154510498,
0.25587359070777893,
0.15400037169456482,
-0.05134283006191254,
-0.5853237509727478,
0.7728440761566162,
-0.3600941300392151,
-0.080413818359375,
-0.28253641724586487,
0.0016856135334819555,
-0.4508918821811676,
0.5301166772842407,
-0.3364836573600769,
1.0766490697860718,
0.45426052808761597,
-0.502145528793335,
0.26923027634620667,
0.25835052132606506,
-0.5455992221832275,
0.23452359437942505,
-0.872542679309845,
0.6278395652770996,
-0.2622987926006317,
0.19824987649917603,
-0.7013401985168457,
-0.11231603473424911,
0.23326285183429718,
-0.36309710144996643,
0.23661045730113983,
0.09010002017021179,
-0.5383812189102173,
-0.409906268119812,
-0.4125174283981323,
0.3110625743865967,
0.7182455062866211,
-0.6909160614013672,
0.5993558764457703,
0.2444436103105545,
-0.33992263674736023,
-0.3280809223651886,
-0.32630592584609985,
0.17804710566997528,
-0.15034444630146027,
-0.43396756052970886,
0.16142751276493073,
-0.282470703125,
-0.4112304151058197,
-0.0022989262361079454,
0.15014363825321198,
0.15412063896656036,
0.17041032016277313,
0.18800701200962067,
0.3421512842178345,
-0.08796307444572449,
0.07169482856988907,
-0.24566650390625,
-0.1787024885416031,
0.11478391289710999,
-0.3409719169139862,
0.7436596751213074,
-0.34914278984069824,
-0.3911938965320587,
-0.20998501777648926,
0.1640528291463852,
0.41945359110832214,
-0.3571573495864868,
0.5457813739776611,
0.610834538936615,
-0.0571632944047451,
-0.366037517786026,
-0.4370366930961609,
0.08485088497400284,
-0.5010786056518555,
0.7106019854545593,
-0.2117559164762497,
-0.8553509712219238,
0.18693973124027252,
-0.16454046964645386,
0.3891896903514862,
0.3403397500514984,
0.5842634439468384,
-0.03690237179398537,
1.1175466775894165,
0.5099848508834839,
-0.28219613432884216,
0.4461577832698822,
-0.1044493243098259,
0.21437105536460876,
-0.8943134546279907,
-0.4225248396396637,
-0.4800593852996826,
-0.2999885082244873,
-0.37308603525161743,
-0.5753806829452515,
0.48222658038139343,
0.17618124186992645,
-0.5556525588035583,
-0.06684868782758713,
-0.23450568318367004,
0.5889237523078918,
0.6546173095703125,
0.01253858208656311,
0.14218714833259583,
-0.039251040667295456,
0.08159546554088593,
0.3714046776294708,
-0.4902186095714569,
-0.45493462681770325,
1.2938075065612793,
0.608828604221344,
0.6411767601966858,
0.024365916848182678,
0.4402000606060028,
0.4147132635116577,
0.708331286907196,
-0.686893105506897,
0.44867846369743347,
-0.2159040868282318,
-0.21574625372886658,
-0.4450756907463074,
-0.25110143423080444,
-0.6790273189544678,
0.09854460507631302,
0.20374108850955963,
-0.7621663808822632,
-0.3784118592739105,
0.1515529900789261,
-0.19051095843315125,
0.11169852316379547,
-0.5921593308448792,
0.5287770628929138,
-0.5559219717979431,
-0.24942316114902496,
-0.5139473676681519,
-0.7903951406478882,
0.40138885378837585,
-0.2069588154554367,
0.330613911151886,
-0.17691488564014435,
-0.15329571068286896,
0.46800678968429565,
-0.2679409384727478,
0.42831969261169434,
-0.11405976116657257,
0.03680763021111488,
0.2201204150915146,
-0.096833735704422,
0.7106590867042542,
0.2055986225605011,
-0.12980502843856812,
0.624907910823822,
-0.3652099072933197,
-0.18570652604103088,
-0.5266909003257751,
0.818480372428894,
-1.0728881359100342,
-0.6625636219978333,
-0.25938883423805237,
-0.36687591671943665,
-0.3561874330043793,
0.12604963779449463,
0.18297246098518372,
0.2677704095840454,
-0.3788539469242096,
0.2993412911891937,
0.4292493760585785,
-0.2611859440803528,
0.4186764657497406,
0.4537184536457062,
-0.38309353590011597,
-0.44970113039016724,
0.8728416562080383,
-0.2795198857784271,
0.20615002512931824,
0.0644468292593956,
0.2822715640068054,
-0.30143260955810547,
-0.7004054188728333,
-0.3472314774990082,
0.2635160982608795,
-0.5972426533699036,
-0.07850182801485062,
-0.617614209651947,
-0.4710093140602112,
-0.2218177616596222,
0.009608039632439613,
-0.4666176438331604,
-0.029363753274083138,
-0.47116127610206604,
-0.0228449497371912,
0.11248782277107239,
0.9946028590202332,
-0.14226016402244568,
0.27152469754219055,
-0.5640227198600769,
0.32006487250328064,
0.2679923474788666,
0.5986675024032593,
0.015026608482003212,
-0.5090857744216919,
-0.2869581878185272,
0.12636642158031464,
-0.12518838047981262,
-0.37664344906806946,
0.2462928593158722,
0.4190031588077545,
0.48274675011634827,
0.5556609034538269,
-0.25342658162117004,
0.5054477453231812,
-0.8991283178329468,
0.8961328864097595,
0.2710186541080475,
-0.7798925042152405,
0.37542012333869934,
-0.28034254908561707,
0.33577004075050354,
0.5880960822105408,
0.31626468896865845,
-0.3701585829257965,
-0.1353440135717392,
-0.3406451642513275,
-0.9110889434814453,
0.8722302913665771,
0.09900551289319992,
0.249440997838974,
0.013170786201953888,
0.48515018820762634,
0.3846326768398285,
0.22547708451747894,
-0.6515883803367615,
-0.13667088747024536,
-0.3076038956642151,
-0.28860190510749817,
-0.36496925354003906,
-0.3865566551685333,
-0.1078292652964592,
-0.4134671092033386,
0.6859399676322937,
-0.15812942385673523,
0.2364456057548523,
-0.16112400591373444,
-0.1184932142496109,
0.17420648038387299,
0.1448241025209427,
0.6129301190376282,
0.808027982711792,
-0.12301462143659592,
-0.02818598970770836,
0.20032097399234772,
-0.29051947593688965,
0.04469310864806175,
0.021334748715162277,
-0.12206793576478958,
-0.16914033889770508,
0.27806124091148376,
1.0263625383377075,
0.12834033370018005,
-0.8866134881973267,
0.48502013087272644,
-0.039467703551054,
-0.3208189010620117,
-0.6123790740966797,
0.20272117853164673,
-0.005455418955534697,
0.3123711049556732,
0.2694394886493683,
-0.12618383765220642,
-0.05507079139351845,
-0.5410712361335754,
0.1689041256904602,
0.5342661738395691,
-0.43223923444747925,
-0.5072317719459534,
0.6575191020965576,
0.2061357945203781,
-0.5311102271080017,
0.8567076325416565,
-0.23200495541095734,
-0.5292530655860901,
0.4202896058559418,
0.5020940899848938,
0.8479360342025757,
-0.08442971855401993,
0.22188539803028107,
0.2997135818004608,
0.2275320291519165,
-0.2129812389612198,
0.1878855973482132,
0.034031499177217484,
-0.42228367924690247,
-0.19021181762218475,
-0.6670633554458618,
-0.3757163882255554,
0.42399725317955017,
-0.4160492420196533,
0.46871960163116455,
-0.5035526752471924,
0.13640166819095612,
-0.33198630809783936,
-0.2834402024745941,
-0.8490228652954102,
-0.08988500386476517,
0.12720106542110443,
0.9943532347679138,
-0.315509557723999,
0.956278920173645,
0.5463954210281372,
-0.10361053794622421,
-0.5343042016029358,
-0.08951863646507263,
-0.07683435082435608,
-1.066612720489502,
0.83485347032547,
0.41407084465026855,
0.036345597356557846,
0.26389172673225403,
-0.791077733039856,
-0.9589633941650391,
1.0362951755523682,
0.11568500846624374,
-0.7932981848716736,
-0.3657725751399994,
0.20308993756771088,
0.6393351554870605,
-0.429513543844223,
0.4651910662651062,
0.6531578302383423,
0.4212566018104553,
0.025869201868772507,
-0.8496252298355103,
-0.35027024149894714,
-0.30062490701675415,
0.10372032970190048,
0.0861382707953453,
-0.6399112343788147,
0.9510994553565979,
-0.2646888792514801,
-0.18804362416267395,
0.2324521243572235,
0.5745201706886292,
0.1401490420103073,
0.1502579003572464,
0.4686618149280548,
0.6717405915260315,
0.45823934674263,
-0.07085081189870834,
0.9628852605819702,
-0.49014976620674133,
0.16956357657909393,
1.4143786430358887,
-0.41406986117362976,
1.012951135635376,
0.251387357711792,
-0.1314106583595276,
0.581579327583313,
0.48018184304237366,
-0.13445736467838287,
0.5867823362350464,
0.5632415413856506,
-0.15287718176841736,
0.08184980601072311,
0.07301659137010574,
-0.37431859970092773,
0.5440636873245239,
0.23494160175323486,
-0.07124684005975723,
-0.38403552770614624,
-0.012454060837626457,
-0.11372774839401245,
-0.19778257608413696,
-0.3024978041648865,
1.1113053560256958,
-0.002383328275755048,
-0.8086299896240234,
0.3743385076522827,
0.13991354405879974,
0.68272465467453,
-0.9030355215072632,
-0.025552930310368538,
-0.40839096903800964,
0.3580750524997711,
0.1449098140001297,
-0.5040251612663269,
0.17454922199249268,
0.21483618021011353,
0.1888672113418579,
-0.03661546856164932,
0.4839593768119812,
-0.3218875527381897,
-0.33261537551879883,
0.41009005904197693,
0.3226437270641327,
0.07731445878744125,
-0.13024215400218964,
-0.6412752270698547,
0.005726313218474388,
-0.21402700245380402,
-0.32913920283317566,
0.43544337153434753,
0.22946180403232574,
0.028347132727503777,
0.7644596099853516,
0.7171131372451782,
0.18409426510334015,
-0.065514475107193,
-0.03714883327484131,
0.9094852805137634,
-0.5272621512413025,
-0.6128667593002319,
-0.9239936470985413,
0.5053930282592773,
-0.11361658573150635,
-0.4690629541873932,
0.4826645255088806,
0.6040176749229431,
0.9740692973136902,
-0.0038862735964357853,
0.9320533871650696,
0.06573545932769775,
0.5256140828132629,
-0.4011199474334717,
0.6942495703697205,
-0.4515927731990814,
0.1823120415210724,
0.2571188807487488,
-0.9709722995758057,
0.022390834987163544,
0.21133632957935333,
-0.11774883419275284,
-0.09075908362865448,
0.5639433860778809,
0.6175153255462646,
0.02412582002580166,
-0.21806563436985016,
0.1843186318874359,
0.3391306698322296,
0.6148572564125061,
0.47794097661972046,
0.9566789269447327,
0.04500097036361694,
0.4668467938899994,
0.13252811133861542,
-0.37608203291893005,
-0.3019056022167206,
-0.7873047590255737,
-0.9322084188461304,
-0.2917550504207611,
-0.11852633208036423,
-0.09987278282642365,
0.1229613870382309,
1.0778558254241943,
0.6220608949661255,
-0.8030593395233154,
-0.16131310164928436,
-0.3266936242580414,
-0.2771584093570709,
-0.06428298354148865,
-0.18781833350658417,
0.17809343338012695,
-0.5993916988372803,
-0.6991593241691589,
0.5980574488639832,
0.48856523633003235,
-0.04005424678325653,
-0.5784811973571777,
-0.46687352657318115,
-0.019194813445210457,
0.22109508514404297,
0.705144464969635,
0.23455415666103363,
-0.8315711617469788,
-0.2879031002521515,
-0.2148011326789856,
-0.0668366327881813,
0.27059459686279297,
0.6850001215934753,
-0.7178559899330139,
0.32415562868118286,
0.299673467874527,
0.6627770662307739,
0.33901944756507874,
0.11626598238945007,
0.5829147696495056,
-0.5272090435028076,
0.08955536782741547,
0.2314804643392563,
0.16042883694171906,
0.1622411459684372,
-0.17326557636260986,
0.7816532254219055,
-0.0636906698346138,
-0.5973526239395142,
-0.9179627299308777,
0.15923559665679932,
-0.699245274066925,
-0.43814051151275635,
1.3363364934921265,
-0.23104196786880493,
0.01715436950325966,
0.023497993126511574,
-0.27958476543426514,
0.167231485247612,
-0.34448906779289246,
1.0915096998214722,
0.6094717383384705,
-0.046742480248212814,
-0.0659787505865097,
-0.5156271457672119,
0.4720040261745453,
0.07939706742763519,
-1.1229873895645142,
-0.09695367515087128,
0.3486391007900238,
0.2333919256925583,
-0.10975205898284912,
0.5056666731834412,
-0.06966576725244522,
0.00850845780223608,
-0.13228990137577057,
0.02012362703680992,
-0.6008718013763428,
-0.4417973458766937,
-0.35861727595329285,
0.19786687195301056,
0.27841129899024963,
-0.10565726459026337
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.