id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19424v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19424v1
|
The Role of Syntactic Span Preferences in Post-Hoc Explanation Disagreement
| 2024-03-28T13:56:23 | 2024-03-28T13:56:23 |
Jonathan Kamp, Lisa Beinborn, Antske Fokkens
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Post-hoc explanation methods are an important tool for increasing model
transparency for users. Unfortunately, the currently used methods for
attributing token importance often yield diverging patterns. In this work, we
study potential sources of disagreement across methods from a linguistic
perspective. We find that different methods systematically select different
classes of words and that methods that agree most with other methods and with
humans display similar linguistic preferences. Token-level differences between
methods are smoothed out if we compare them on the syntactic span level. We
also find higher agreement across methods by estimating the most important
spans dynamically instead of relying on a fixed subset of size $k$. We
systematically investigate the interaction between $k$ and spans and propose an
improved configuration for selecting important tokens.
|
[
-0.6666882038116455,
-0.7422337532043457,
0.5058352947235107,
0.45779743790626526,
-0.45627281069755554,
0.17327077686786652,
-0.27643507719039917,
-0.7917178869247437,
0.5891175866127014,
-0.16910669207572937,
-0.2804678976535797,
-0.03978053480386734,
-0.8788754343986511,
0.2404455542564392,
-0.21798643469810486,
1.0045617818832397,
-0.4256531298160553,
-0.07219266146421432,
-0.1885516345500946,
-0.0783611610531807,
-0.45754608511924744,
-0.4676721394062042,
-0.4800371825695038,
-0.40481796860694885,
0.9337369203567505,
0.280656635761261,
0.907354474067688,
0.6063220500946045,
0.443585604429245,
0.2176816165447235,
-0.4352565109729767,
0.17268379032611847,
-0.13999482989311218,
0.14835676550865173,
-0.29158273339271545,
-0.6821697950363159,
-0.3341372013092041,
0.0481734573841095,
0.4315112829208374,
0.9205038547515869,
0.1018361896276474,
0.16923408210277557,
-0.2626839876174927,
0.5606392621994019,
-0.9339568614959717,
-0.013297483325004578,
-0.634024441242218,
0.13008573651313782,
-0.643829882144928,
-0.2030726969242096,
-0.26861509680747986,
-0.32637906074523926,
0.5336806774139404,
-0.670715868473053,
0.0416342169046402,
0.01706310547888279,
1.184715986251831,
0.17373661696910858,
-0.5767586827278137,
-0.060517389327287674,
-0.4825671911239624,
0.6749201416969299,
-0.664175808429718,
0.42497727274894714,
0.7171485424041748,
0.1330433189868927,
0.036557406187057495,
-0.6972782015800476,
-0.5014128088951111,
0.17341749370098114,
-0.3840995132923126,
-0.018552232533693314,
-0.19326110184192657,
0.3347089886665344,
0.22604027390480042,
0.3740162253379822,
-0.28636467456817627,
0.32075029611587524,
-0.324641615152359,
-0.5612770318984985,
0.48776718974113464,
-0.026811379939317703,
0.24233058094978333,
-0.45745953917503357,
-0.23725512623786926,
0.14672555029392242,
-0.8716229200363159,
0.4945549964904785,
0.6404382586479187,
0.14027699828147888,
-0.015175019390881062,
0.8075105547904968,
-0.2735459506511688,
0.848145604133606,
0.36323854327201843,
0.35660478472709656,
0.259550005197525,
-0.5053434371948242,
-0.07813865691423416,
-0.023043647408485413,
0.46998509764671326,
0.5571363568305969,
0.12063033133745193,
-0.10770613700151443,
-0.020249882712960243,
0.317302405834198,
0.16120512783527374,
-0.455432653427124,
-0.11186373978853226,
0.19433559477329254,
-0.6275442838668823,
-0.014095653779804707,
0.2424289584159851,
-0.8028222918510437,
-0.3628746271133423,
-0.3307591378688812,
0.24857454001903534,
-0.023509008809924126,
-0.5387888550758362,
0.23031529784202576,
-0.5121269226074219,
0.15878118574619293,
0.3201221227645874,
-1.21274733543396,
0.24718935787677765,
0.55654376745224,
0.6939995288848877,
-0.18637698888778687,
-0.2671250104904175,
-0.5758731961250305,
-0.23832295835018158,
-0.580345869064331,
0.9497808814048767,
-0.7556490302085876,
-0.2144988477230072,
-0.17562235891819,
-0.17477227747440338,
-0.2749459445476532,
-0.36999017000198364,
0.4397853910923004,
-0.46964025497436523,
0.5191906094551086,
-0.7295535802841187,
-0.6426960825920105,
0.020766306668519974,
-0.045575011521577835,
-0.5750643014907837,
1.2511457204818726,
0.01567107066512108,
-1.265775203704834,
0.9046473503112793,
-0.8468812108039856,
-0.5066938400268555,
-0.11476373672485352,
-0.12030377238988876,
-0.2364092469215393,
0.5042193531990051,
0.23336532711982727,
0.2655087113380432,
0.26931026577949524,
0.17226096987724304,
-0.21396756172180176,
-0.518387496471405,
0.42488545179367065,
-0.04692494124174118,
0.4999588429927826,
0.16205227375030518,
-0.44247356057167053,
0.4270966649055481,
-0.5466996431350708,
-0.0872763991355896,
-0.07433223724365234,
-0.41236624121665955,
-0.7253410816192627,
-0.014339929446578026,
-0.2923000156879425,
0.180726557970047,
0.3487594425678253,
-0.35091593861579895,
-0.14749175310134888,
-0.6481297612190247,
0.7220267057418823,
0.8132113218307495,
0.025946233421564102,
0.5949196219444275,
-0.2566569745540619,
0.6616967916488647,
-0.1493837535381317,
0.10340054333209991,
-0.003486850531771779,
-0.3958996534347534,
-0.6295262575149536,
-0.0840117409825325,
0.34037312865257263,
-0.11666238307952881,
-0.32784131169319153,
0.2648681104183197,
-0.006914956960827112,
-0.2421160191297531,
-0.6007819771766663,
-0.43979206681251526,
0.45696696639060974,
0.260366827249527,
0.3241657018661499,
-0.12347206473350525,
-0.8562179803848267,
-0.9463074803352356,
-0.6414998173713684,
-0.5165731906890869,
0.12690310180187225,
0.25827839970588684,
0.07601123303174973,
0.24734187126159668,
1.3579565286636353,
-0.34470829367637634,
0.6669301390647888,
-0.28383928537368774,
0.16834330558776855,
-0.0924261286854744,
0.058997742831707,
0.6330965757369995,
-0.8565568923950195,
-0.464672327041626,
-0.020610276609659195,
-0.14076457917690277,
-0.3549136221408844,
0.001025037607178092,
-0.4591416120529175,
0.4369778037071228,
0.5797379016876221,
-0.726535439491272,
0.4452270269393921,
0.4970678389072418,
-0.5510786771774292,
0.8504371643066406,
0.13852831721305847,
0.03880041092634201,
-0.7780715823173523,
0.05831141024827957,
-0.12029562145471573,
-0.18092459440231323,
-0.44693711400032043,
-0.16432392597198486,
-0.009997610934078693,
0.5213374495506287,
-0.3780611753463745,
0.6586860418319702,
-0.6010352373123169,
-0.18436360359191895,
-0.16197547316551208,
0.18947069346904755,
0.266709566116333,
0.20250509679317474,
0.14500106871128082,
0.5674920082092285,
0.41607728600502014,
-0.41227030754089355,
-0.015471071936190128,
0.28120869398117065,
-0.06260845065116882,
0.2676387131214142,
-0.6836737394332886,
0.027065223082900047,
-0.1144021525979042,
0.2350512444972992,
-1.4462947845458984,
-0.15211695432662964,
0.23939202725887299,
-0.5133753418922424,
0.11649596691131592,
-0.03746365010738373,
-0.3137586712837219,
-0.4338623583316803,
-0.5672422051429749,
0.393013060092926,
0.16847263276576996,
-0.4666340947151184,
0.2703566551208496,
0.4479976296424866,
-0.07262153178453445,
-0.8218904137611389,
-0.5920347571372986,
-0.005991886369884014,
-0.6342913508415222,
-0.5923152565956116,
0.4680139124393463,
0.04132804274559021,
-0.5027197003364563,
-0.15234121680259705,
-0.835265040397644,
0.17430579662322998,
0.21689000725746155,
0.2721846401691437,
0.24596671760082245,
-0.22595368325710297,
0.46443209052085876,
0.29593271017074585,
-0.2510199546813965,
-0.09903624653816223,
-0.1315004527568817,
0.6858336329460144,
-0.061183180660009384,
-0.22883059084415436,
-0.31844741106033325,
0.3781459629535675,
0.4990338981151581,
-0.3286339342594147,
0.7075989842414856,
0.4364864230155945,
-0.1466996669769287,
0.06367135047912598,
-0.5768142342567444,
-0.31226012110710144,
-0.4025587737560272,
0.2706361413002014,
-0.2820090651512146,
-1.0971510410308838,
0.7223497033119202,
0.06164814159274101,
0.18129031360149384,
0.5659592151641846,
0.42936408519744873,
-0.08265558630228043,
0.7550950050354004,
0.4923783838748932,
0.09174059331417084,
0.8600825071334839,
0.33684223890304565,
0.19807526469230652,
-0.7065787315368652,
-0.06233454495668411,
-0.7753071188926697,
-0.5980395078659058,
-0.33093732595443726,
0.0027041921857744455,
0.04865562170743942,
0.31716224551200867,
-0.09994412958621979,
0.4629720151424408,
-0.35099032521247864,
0.379871666431427,
0.3729357421398163,
-0.10711807757616043,
0.18391793966293335,
0.03418844938278198,
-0.02978527545928955,
-0.22846104204654694,
-0.5851982235908508,
-0.2959193289279938,
0.7031692862510681,
0.3180921971797943,
0.39036473631858826,
0.0636129379272461,
0.4742259979248047,
-0.0735921785235405,
-0.056678060442209244,
-0.6879277229309082,
0.3436681032180786,
0.14998601377010345,
-0.7708678841590881,
-0.5425465703010559,
-0.3107772469520569,
-1.3064329624176025,
0.539454996585846,
-0.2569735050201416,
-0.9025490880012512,
0.14985953271389008,
0.1831607222557068,
-0.39610424637794495,
-0.004179597832262516,
-0.9365333914756775,
0.9960353970527649,
0.24122834205627441,
-0.05940784513950348,
-0.18619130551815033,
-1.1786292791366577,
0.11275538802146912,
0.15411917865276337,
0.07155787199735641,
-0.05542215704917908,
-0.03539266064763069,
1.0356100797653198,
-0.7543618679046631,
0.8715785145759583,
-0.11498671025037766,
-0.10372307151556015,
0.10484535992145538,
0.015283848159015179,
0.5362266898155212,
-0.1592191457748413,
-0.18852640688419342,
0.12640535831451416,
-0.038743872195482254,
-0.40545761585235596,
-0.48167720437049866,
0.1473829448223114,
-0.6418769955635071,
-0.8056523203849792,
-0.11768858134746552,
-0.35557952523231506,
-0.27220579981803894,
0.1926693469285965,
0.5422679781913757,
0.3417169153690338,
0.10203646868467331,
-0.027741773054003716,
0.2302590161561966,
-0.018261846154928207,
0.7012161612510681,
0.1746097058057785,
-0.1412678062915802,
0.1544165015220642,
0.3022219240665436,
0.2483091801404953,
0.5396435260772705,
0.37759771943092346,
0.599859356880188,
-0.5422333478927612,
-0.6754078269004822,
-0.2640920877456665,
0.32268181443214417,
-0.5838069319725037,
0.011354497633874416,
-0.6975939869880676,
0.026904823258519173,
-0.1927434206008911,
-0.4220871925354004,
-0.2034015953540802,
-0.8223878741264343,
-0.16877247393131256,
-0.6653303503990173,
0.5784209370613098,
0.37899401783943176,
0.03928971290588379,
0.4515497386455536,
-0.5150041580200195,
0.056521687656641006,
-0.05817604064941406,
0.3090130686759949,
0.0578405000269413,
-0.3520554006099701,
-0.22106175124645233,
-0.2493869811296463,
0.013971894048154354,
-1.0790517330169678,
-0.14635588228702545,
-0.08466432243585587,
0.7906709313392639,
0.47817039489746094,
0.02645685523748398,
0.815699577331543,
-0.23183894157409668,
1.0059787034988403,
0.27627816796302795,
-1.3134324550628662,
0.5664829015731812,
-0.3416321575641632,
0.043348755687475204,
0.47686734795570374,
0.2469548135995865,
-0.9376941919326782,
-0.5675871968269348,
-0.7205987572669983,
-1.1197482347488403,
0.8032108545303345,
0.1504114866256714,
-0.05558512359857559,
-0.2594105005264282,
0.44514229893684387,
0.40889251232147217,
0.2730177640914917,
-0.6495254039764404,
-0.19299741089344025,
-0.06034558266401291,
0.11182355880737305,
0.32856717705726624,
-0.25841182470321655,
-0.21191060543060303,
0.03444617986679077,
0.22722691297531128,
0.06972511857748032,
-0.13906806707382202,
0.11313863843679428,
-0.049351371824741364,
-0.3671385943889618,
0.30144137144088745,
0.6361147165298462,
1.270858883857727,
0.22016695141792297,
0.754043698310852,
0.14900550246238708,
-0.39662015438079834,
-0.048486460000276566,
0.035542551428079605,
0.05106806382536888,
0.28581178188323975,
0.6586930155754089,
0.9428879618644714,
0.10841347277164459,
-0.42175742983818054,
0.5454748868942261,
0.23109659552574158,
-0.06189323216676712,
0.38764482736587524,
-0.16440626978874207,
0.2042635679244995,
0.11326438933610916,
0.008919057436287403,
0.378693550825119,
0.07693926244974136,
-0.27969983220100403,
0.17008212208747864,
0.324617475271225,
-0.25608232617378235,
-0.5416173338890076,
0.37545666098594666,
0.03984612971544266,
-0.18792569637298584,
0.10868684202432632,
0.019467074424028397,
-0.4932769536972046,
0.5974425077438354,
0.2383568435907364,
0.4477268159389496,
-0.2918601632118225,
0.5175741910934448,
0.10617396980524063,
0.04427608847618103,
-0.2032654881477356,
0.18433840572834015,
-0.2840069532394409,
-0.7239716649055481,
-0.6098690629005432,
-0.44874686002731323,
-0.11641019582748413,
-0.3825664520263672,
-0.6688371300697327,
0.2118147611618042,
-0.26661744713783264,
-0.3701781630516052,
0.2664092779159546,
-0.17146161198616028,
-0.2801074981689453,
-0.23915572464466095,
-0.18192173540592194,
0.6606619954109192,
-0.9709303975105286,
0.2871984541416168,
0.6783044934272766,
-0.4043852686882019,
-1.0329350233078003,
0.24196869134902954,
0.0795869529247284,
-0.7856451869010925,
0.7146320343017578,
-0.0822557657957077,
-0.15312711894512177,
-0.4552341401576996,
-0.22271721065044403,
-0.8989030122756958,
0.5832840800285339,
0.4123760759830475,
-0.4337044060230255,
-0.20227503776550293,
-0.1876809448003769,
0.6767173409461975,
0.038180477917194366,
0.2317100614309311,
0.47191038727760315,
0.6487905383110046,
0.17031703889369965,
-1.2661378383636475,
0.27084285020828247,
-0.02331291325390339,
0.04289178550243378,
0.5537756085395813,
-0.5992119908332825,
0.8144897818565369,
-0.15802617371082306,
-0.3633217215538025,
-0.2838989198207855,
0.45224693417549133,
0.31800082325935364,
0.4036802351474762,
0.7154577374458313,
0.0845387801527977,
0.950165867805481,
0.03473599627614021,
0.8981993794441223,
0.09011462330818176,
0.3094542622566223,
0.8720768094062805,
-0.09215158224105835,
0.7062122821807861,
1.0131661891937256,
-0.5397893190383911,
0.5679636001586914,
1.3444416522979736,
0.36631980538368225,
0.33375784754753113,
0.5912826657295227,
0.050279244780540466,
-0.09677433222532272,
-0.10045453161001205,
-0.5240940451622009,
0.4278325140476227,
0.20629741251468658,
-0.2137080281972885,
-0.3615226745605469,
-0.2761635482311249,
0.3863524794578552,
0.01106665562838316,
-0.1672181934118271,
0.73798006772995,
-0.04189538210630417,
-0.9200470447540283,
0.37196770310401917,
0.021961046382784843,
0.6317662000656128,
-0.531932532787323,
0.2229471355676651,
-0.17429782450199127,
-0.22785882651805878,
-0.5851125717163086,
-0.6734862923622131,
0.6581595540046692,
-0.2469620406627655,
-0.14192569255828857,
-0.10414072871208191,
0.6016790270805359,
-0.30151447653770447,
0.05789971724152565,
0.26395195722579956,
0.6751565337181091,
0.32295358180999756,
-0.0070174080319702625,
-0.25987982749938965,
0.2677935063838959,
-0.2407034933567047,
-0.31793877482414246,
0.16416607797145844,
0.579007089138031,
-0.43042317032814026,
-0.04506399855017662,
0.5437324643135071,
0.30949994921684265,
0.25374412536621094,
0.25661030411720276,
0.7207724452018738,
-0.27039414644241333,
-0.864637017250061,
-1.0686900615692139,
0.6257070302963257,
-0.14860261976718903,
-0.5710636377334595,
0.825259804725647,
0.27489858865737915,
0.7155225276947021,
0.20455585420131683,
0.5196723341941833,
-0.12724602222442627,
0.289222776889801,
-0.6734297871589661,
0.391869455575943,
-0.5402803421020508,
0.2729484438896179,
-0.4634859561920166,
-0.7702652215957642,
-0.5441397428512573,
0.7225867509841919,
-0.4965135157108307,
0.13063089549541473,
0.9333291053771973,
0.31439700722694397,
0.06517298519611359,
0.28297820687294006,
0.032809726893901825,
0.11352795362472534,
0.2809976041316986,
0.30728375911712646,
1.0530427694320679,
0.15063069760799408,
0.2930893003940582,
0.32470574975013733,
-0.3070826530456543,
-0.2821749746799469,
-0.8418614268302917,
-0.7706325650215149,
-0.6506933569908142,
-0.3553580939769745,
-0.34392818808555603,
-0.04037606343626976,
1.048315167427063,
0.9480024576187134,
-0.4755342900753021,
0.054679714143276215,
-0.19027410447597504,
0.3514699637889862,
-0.4554440677165985,
-0.24806994199752808,
0.6680670976638794,
-0.3935195207595825,
-0.5525917410850525,
0.033679258078336716,
0.3416338562965393,
-0.10345397144556046,
0.1051110252737999,
0.11566111445426941,
-0.021475564688444138,
0.11597146838903427,
0.4776934087276459,
0.2965235412120819,
-1.018932819366455,
-0.6898513436317444,
0.11047128587961197,
0.05976606532931328,
0.28222715854644775,
1.2348129749298096,
-0.3793489336967468,
0.3363359570503235,
0.8589190244674683,
0.6737461686134338,
0.6672437191009521,
0.12956136465072632,
0.544565737247467,
-0.9084450006484985,
0.1274728626012802,
-0.07306008785963058,
0.4734410345554352,
0.1735514998435974,
-0.5348855257034302,
0.2790369391441345,
0.31556183099746704,
-0.31902238726615906,
-0.7934319376945496,
0.496812641620636,
-1.0350606441497803,
-0.515031635761261,
1.067639708518982,
-0.15891742706298828,
0.13889306783676147,
-0.2801733911037445,
-0.3708289861679077,
0.29357802867889404,
-0.43861719965934753,
0.8505361676216125,
1.26213800907135,
-0.41570425033569336,
-0.13190141320228577,
-0.016187215223908424,
0.82961505651474,
0.5778362154960632,
-0.7455276250839233,
0.33051908016204834,
0.35801565647125244,
0.12721027433872223,
0.2068709433078766,
0.8728322386741638,
-0.4233819246292114,
0.168272003531456,
-0.11297059059143066,
-0.2719944417476654,
0.14882194995880127,
-0.4218955934047699,
-0.26040253043174744,
0.1144145280122757,
0.18056844174861908,
-0.30322957038879395
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19423v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19423v1
|
Echo-chambers and Idea Labs: Communication Styles on Twitter
| 2024-03-28T13:55:51 | 2024-03-28T13:55:51 |
Aleksandra Sorokovikova, Michael Becker, Ivan P. Yamshchikov
|
cs.SI
|
cs.SI, cs.CL, J.4; K.4.1; K.4.2
|
This paper investigates the communication styles and structures of Twitter
(X) communities within the vaccination context. While mainstream research
primarily focuses on the echo-chamber phenomenon, wherein certain ideas are
reinforced and participants are isolated from opposing opinions, this study
reveals the presence of diverse communication styles across various
communities. In addition to the communities exhibiting echo-chamber behavior,
this research uncovers communities with distinct communication patterns. By
shedding light on the nuanced nature of communication within social networks,
this study emphasizes the significance of understanding the diversity of
perspectives within online communities.
|
[
-0.4155506491661072,
-1.0521527528762817,
0.556056797504425,
-0.2479773461818695,
-0.29154664278030396,
0.6385576128959656,
-0.10452642291784286,
-0.5854877233505249,
1.021050214767456,
0.06615427136421204,
-0.608718991279602,
-0.46652716398239136,
-0.5860116481781006,
0.15086729824543,
-0.6501626372337341,
0.8613486886024475,
0.07587530463933945,
-0.20702381432056427,
0.6618106961250305,
0.07851111888885498,
0.11705668270587921,
-0.690248429775238,
-0.9452552199363708,
0.017739612609148026,
0.7851962447166443,
0.5079973936080933,
0.4008236825466156,
0.39871200919151306,
0.12282390892505646,
0.23005883395671844,
-0.26939067244529724,
-0.14238137006759644,
-0.7890912890434265,
0.008161245845258236,
-0.16620120406150818,
-0.4657723307609558,
-0.1503390073776245,
-0.19468145072460175,
0.412338525056839,
0.3900264799594879,
-0.26791390776634216,
0.1546022593975067,
0.19758471846580505,
0.5226055383682251,
-0.5747440457344055,
-0.07831507921218872,
-0.6275677680969238,
0.02192654088139534,
-0.23972658812999725,
-0.6972692012786865,
-0.30688929557800293,
-0.35387927293777466,
0.11770118772983551,
-0.5283263921737671,
0.2697731554508209,
0.24705854058265686,
0.5933035612106323,
-0.5603623986244202,
-0.44392716884613037,
-0.2858380973339081,
-0.817555844783783,
0.4004829227924347,
-0.2748298943042755,
-0.14648902416229248,
0.32887548208236694,
0.457489550113678,
0.05040791630744934,
-0.6099147200584412,
-0.6278142333030701,
0.7648516893386841,
0.03350997343659401,
0.1555955708026886,
-0.9118677377700806,
0.07831854373216629,
-0.2674129009246826,
0.14554011821746826,
-0.5834169983863831,
-0.20967286825180054,
-0.5406187772750854,
0.3977563679218292,
0.3504149615764618,
0.0987560972571373,
0.24656721949577332,
-0.15355980396270752,
0.18365126848220825,
-0.11723890155553818,
-0.4670172929763794,
0.30580586194992065,
0.28492721915245056,
0.2777964174747467,
-0.17862890660762787,
0.061221152544021606,
-0.3769451677799225,
0.27415594458580017,
0.15877164900302887,
0.1002531498670578,
0.18318673968315125,
-0.5636809468269348,
-0.290175199508667,
0.11681383103132248,
0.4930868148803711,
0.43057572841644287,
0.1523580700159073,
-0.03695524483919144,
-0.129807710647583,
-0.3576918840408325,
0.5197485685348511,
-0.7888669371604919,
-0.07488029450178146,
0.2790328562259674,
-0.9375189542770386,
-0.7283214926719666,
0.13374465703964233,
-0.8796152472496033,
-0.44293704628944397,
0.1662205159664154,
0.5933369398117065,
-0.08614213019609451,
-0.8120853900909424,
-0.04047388955950737,
-0.7560733556747437,
0.1762351393699646,
0.3542320132255554,
-0.9770364761352539,
0.6445932984352112,
0.7299015522003174,
0.995519757270813,
0.29567694664001465,
0.21411655843257904,
-0.07413072139024734,
0.07939957082271576,
-0.5659365057945251,
0.8430289030075073,
-0.7685068249702454,
-0.6731725335121155,
0.2863558828830719,
-0.09052286297082901,
0.055365826934576035,
-0.29090580344200134,
0.05016684904694557,
-0.20156100392341614,
-0.033811021596193314,
-0.464214026927948,
-0.31952980160713196,
-0.04850751906633377,
0.07670360058546066,
-0.26927801966667175,
0.3706834018230438,
0.046280961483716965,
-0.7445974349975586,
0.5454769730567932,
-0.5575394034385681,
-0.34496408700942993,
0.1579846441745758,
-0.5761693120002747,
-0.3474292457103729,
0.2541468143463135,
-0.0207867082208395,
0.2570229470729828,
0.1697063148021698,
-0.23319123685359955,
-0.3530982434749603,
-0.5356437563896179,
0.3246215283870697,
-0.0795719102025032,
1.0914874076843262,
0.28240206837654114,
-0.7840645909309387,
0.578848659992218,
-0.2624669373035431,
0.06259719282388687,
0.06369475275278091,
0.43037307262420654,
-0.4788982570171356,
0.012490478344261646,
0.23021939396858215,
0.19313722848892212,
-0.6806344985961914,
-0.5066379308700562,
0.3592488467693329,
-0.10622987151145935,
0.9288514852523804,
0.7199645042419434,
0.5906215906143188,
0.05464772507548332,
-0.9313622713088989,
0.7277118563652039,
-0.3639991283416748,
0.56234210729599,
0.062482234090566635,
-0.8305235505104065,
-0.5339971780776978,
-0.2380700260400772,
-0.4269348084926605,
0.28255799412727356,
-0.5464252829551697,
0.33680519461631775,
-0.019660204648971558,
-0.7977964878082275,
-0.7494476437568665,
-0.22117219865322113,
0.261305034160614,
0.28195497393608093,
0.0771666169166565,
-0.07095212489366531,
-0.7053951621055603,
-1.0165953636169434,
-0.2767495810985565,
-0.48346030712127686,
0.425527423620224,
0.08782757073640823,
0.5126227140426636,
0.003776342375203967,
0.5167765617370605,
-0.1343228965997696,
0.012312415987253189,
-0.6745451092720032,
0.5356163382530212,
0.08453313261270523,
0.04019753634929657,
0.768302321434021,
-0.908900797367096,
-0.7082191109657288,
-0.043713152408599854,
-0.10025280714035034,
-0.08790943771600723,
0.16597896814346313,
0.009952775202691555,
0.03667238727211952,
0.5969038605690002,
-0.23411834239959717,
0.9977371692657471,
0.5367867350578308,
-0.25520071387290955,
0.3705211579799652,
0.5665467381477356,
0.9046501517295837,
-1.446698784828186,
-0.3359698951244354,
-0.038894232362508774,
-0.2811453342437744,
-0.9027217626571655,
-0.16044650971889496,
-0.1626802235841751,
0.33815082907676697,
-0.6462888121604919,
0.38747698068618774,
-0.20862726867198944,
0.429199755191803,
-0.4695679247379303,
-0.08657337725162506,
0.16574165225028992,
-0.049731794744729996,
0.22843985259532928,
0.6656685471534729,
0.7936190962791443,
-0.4329849183559418,
0.1796654760837555,
0.08401747047901154,
-0.2953593134880066,
0.3065212368965149,
-0.5693622827529907,
0.06284317374229431,
0.1635473221540451,
0.6657653450965881,
-1.100525140762329,
-0.3326224386692047,
0.41383326053619385,
-0.8537286520004272,
-0.057031989097595215,
-0.0888553038239479,
-0.7381367087364197,
-0.47072333097457886,
-0.6607876420021057,
0.47118160128593445,
0.8400474190711975,
-0.18731756508350372,
0.09017498791217804,
0.6558825969696045,
-0.22487585246562958,
-0.4471302628517151,
-0.8966628909111023,
0.17997711896896362,
-0.4998621940612793,
-0.4943963885307312,
0.34017452597618103,
0.08007443696260452,
-0.852198600769043,
0.18370606005191803,
0.173598513007164,
-0.4140068292617798,
0.07103636860847473,
0.1344912350177765,
-0.22994458675384521,
-0.24998871982097626,
0.2611146569252014,
0.07103260606527328,
0.4211161434650421,
-0.027059009298682213,
-0.05930723249912262,
0.6719884872436523,
-0.18140597641468048,
-0.38796645402908325,
-0.6554462313652039,
0.9352143406867981,
0.22476688027381897,
0.32059481739997864,
1.13260018825531,
0.44667670130729675,
-0.5859852433204651,
-0.33183783292770386,
-0.5370556116104126,
-0.685320258140564,
-0.5040201544761658,
0.2468401938676834,
-0.12908227741718292,
-1.0823382139205933,
0.5852105021476746,
0.26598480343818665,
-0.2561366856098175,
0.2671229839324951,
0.7689545750617981,
-0.42381158471107483,
0.7209807634353638,
0.9502686262130737,
0.1501162052154541,
0.7026368379592896,
0.07206274569034576,
0.6328064203262329,
-0.5467255711555481,
-0.007898370735347271,
-0.6037689447402954,
-0.4129479229450226,
-0.5844364762306213,
-0.1493726521730423,
0.2532626986503601,
-0.1143031045794487,
0.021999316290020943,
0.37918201088905334,
-0.816574215888977,
0.3851448595523834,
0.5401473045349121,
0.12420345842838287,
0.278931587934494,
-0.19487342238426208,
0.34707021713256836,
0.017575662583112717,
-0.7629703879356384,
-0.6680682897567749,
1.0181844234466553,
0.15628336369991302,
0.5971229076385498,
0.6048287153244019,
1.028764009475708,
0.30461055040359497,
0.43047475814819336,
-0.6426229476928711,
0.22873948514461517,
0.4360084533691406,
-0.7361599802970886,
-0.3183959722518921,
-0.19734229147434235,
-1.3560142517089844,
0.056200094521045685,
-0.26902201771736145,
-1.3906831741333008,
0.49190589785575867,
-0.13703666627407074,
-0.5357720851898193,
0.7292690277099609,
-0.6750931143760681,
0.4201004207134247,
0.3836590051651001,
-0.044804319739341736,
-0.1681111752986908,
-0.5835166573524475,
0.1749720424413681,
-0.3944331705570221,
0.3382757604122162,
0.1276182383298874,
0.11173500865697861,
0.6704254150390625,
-0.3264665901660919,
1.1405754089355469,
0.620036244392395,
0.3103693127632141,
0.6894239187240601,
-0.09525211900472641,
0.08131813257932663,
0.2723127007484436,
0.10999397933483124,
-0.06072482466697693,
0.13511811196804047,
-0.43518567085266113,
-0.1659507006406784,
0.4089488387107849,
-0.95320725440979,
-0.8690663576126099,
-0.47511932253837585,
-0.24550670385360718,
-0.0002755613240879029,
0.2729223966598511,
0.6817293167114258,
0.4409811496734619,
-0.41758716106414795,
0.4607985317707062,
0.6802921295166016,
-0.11527281999588013,
0.4559870660305023,
0.5518207550048828,
-0.382450670003891,
-0.20862329006195068,
0.3658277690410614,
0.3600876033306122,
0.5596728324890137,
0.4800761938095093,
0.154225155711174,
0.0508783757686615,
-0.38054952025413513,
0.006328929681330919,
0.017047451809048653,
-0.6721648573875427,
0.06165824085474014,
-0.8841589093208313,
-0.5352676510810852,
-1.137347936630249,
-0.4629780352115631,
-0.2850242853164673,
-0.4508802890777588,
0.21786758303642273,
-0.40861254930496216,
0.4838898181915283,
1.2688422203063965,
-0.15866532921791077,
0.43534088134765625,
-0.6016001105308533,
0.011083838529884815,
0.3815271854400635,
0.01670910231769085,
-0.08346102386713028,
-0.2719218134880066,
-0.11704593151807785,
-0.19264307618141174,
-0.4452206492424011,
-1.3076220750808716,
0.13160370290279388,
-0.21905793249607086,
0.6068027019500732,
0.5157510042190552,
0.0651467815041542,
0.3005184233188629,
-0.19943906366825104,
0.7480285167694092,
0.06633427739143372,
-0.9503366947174072,
0.8225955367088318,
-0.7539860606193542,
0.05532024800777435,
0.5170069932937622,
0.2540719211101532,
-1.0334935188293457,
-0.9323520660400391,
-1.1653481721878052,
-0.7695110440254211,
0.34508123993873596,
0.6888382434844971,
0.2093607485294342,
-0.23015707731246948,
-0.06000177934765816,
0.29654479026794434,
0.5725199580192566,
-0.4722563922405243,
-0.6017817258834839,
-0.15487682819366455,
0.23924744129180908,
0.1497470587491989,
-0.053273316472768784,
-0.9280346632003784,
-0.38665205240249634,
0.16466492414474487,
0.3333228528499603,
0.35884299874305725,
0.30103445053100586,
0.5397257804870605,
-0.5380836129188538,
0.5596245527267456,
0.7446219325065613,
1.2231980562210083,
-0.37805208563804626,
0.40998631715774536,
-0.23646466434001923,
-0.27303534746170044,
0.17510603368282318,
-0.28177204728126526,
0.12137596309185028,
0.25800397992134094,
0.4870840311050415,
0.5658738017082214,
-0.28894421458244324,
-0.22899526357650757,
0.6141762733459473,
-0.36448007822036743,
-0.3155462443828583,
-0.2561286389827728,
0.2578858435153961,
0.22266648709774017,
0.1948874592781067,
0.699653148651123,
0.1861041784286499,
0.42683300375938416,
-1.2371464967727661,
0.4091024696826935,
0.4084271788597107,
-0.4967832863330841,
-0.5105599761009216,
0.3111875057220459,
0.4258083403110504,
-0.5828984975814819,
0.15898817777633667,
-0.06502404063940048,
-0.3635188043117523,
0.9355702996253967,
0.5465735197067261,
1.3537627458572388,
-0.11900100857019424,
0.4435158967971802,
0.28598645329475403,
0.6528289318084717,
0.4017498195171356,
0.16568082571029663,
-0.025654861703515053,
-0.6247643828392029,
0.0031048296950757504,
-0.027186984196305275,
-0.7079925537109375,
0.3621308207511902,
-0.6897571682929993,
0.3641005754470825,
-0.45602595806121826,
-0.4962058365345001,
0.16313819587230682,
-0.2856351137161255,
-0.5046401619911194,
-0.09203996509313583,
0.26958420872688293,
1.0091965198516846,
-1.1023311614990234,
0.882689893245697,
0.6004554629325867,
-0.3161838948726654,
-0.7290403246879578,
0.47417208552360535,
0.6901711225509644,
-0.7183241248130798,
0.30591100454330444,
0.18792639672756195,
-0.6277092099189758,
-0.19393886625766754,
-0.5268228054046631,
-0.6921364068984985,
1.052425503730774,
-0.3034158945083618,
-0.4194941818714142,
0.3264515995979309,
-0.22493284940719604,
0.6593491435050964,
-0.7464548349380493,
0.33000725507736206,
0.2599713206291199,
0.3368856906890869,
-0.18758156895637512,
-1.1758296489715576,
0.028781911358237267,
-0.7910698056221008,
-0.3041342496871948,
0.19120213389396667,
-1.0589845180511475,
0.7545609474182129,
0.024164769798517227,
-0.2965421974658966,
-0.1027209460735321,
0.28212711215019226,
0.20180530846118927,
0.4645808935165405,
0.23818564414978027,
0.03389657288789749,
0.6638708710670471,
-0.05419111251831055,
1.2342289686203003,
-0.3148746192455292,
0.10167782753705978,
0.8185304999351501,
0.15496432781219482,
0.9195184707641602,
0.7799304127693176,
0.0653105229139328,
0.44814008474349976,
0.8740461468696594,
0.521528422832489,
0.5526930689811707,
0.19995418190956116,
-0.15699246525764465,
0.10181999206542969,
-0.271381676197052,
-0.9418120384216309,
0.11232098191976547,
0.39282840490341187,
-0.38220590353012085,
0.16984504461288452,
-0.17275211215019226,
0.32158273458480835,
-0.16241371631622314,
-0.13413292169570923,
0.6666731834411621,
0.024380875751376152,
-0.21154913306236267,
0.20793485641479492,
-0.3904205858707428,
0.5096242427825928,
-0.5048465728759766,
-0.12713029980659485,
0.1765054613351822,
-0.09311132878065109,
-0.32305285334587097,
-1.1977152824401855,
0.4892542064189911,
-0.3455670475959778,
-0.028469063341617584,
-0.4107673466205597,
0.5867508053779602,
-0.14217877388000488,
-0.16054128110408783,
0.32960832118988037,
0.8269622325897217,
0.12208101153373718,
-0.025805335491895676,
-0.6476007699966431,
0.40078204870224,
-0.16170546412467957,
-0.4470594525337219,
0.21359805762767792,
0.750352144241333,
0.05510594695806503,
0.5089288949966431,
0.21859759092330933,
0.3827374577522278,
0.059794116765260696,
0.25374653935432434,
0.9275527000427246,
-0.5185876488685608,
-0.5714402794837952,
-0.9218553304672241,
0.4030922055244446,
-0.5071279406547546,
-0.6831554174423218,
0.9043907523155212,
0.3497200012207031,
0.9475096464157104,
0.1748548150062561,
1.175858736038208,
-0.09577967971563339,
0.5003247261047363,
-0.12936289608478546,
0.8636506795883179,
-0.5250579118728638,
0.047008395195007324,
-0.525058388710022,
-0.703550398349762,
-0.09768272191286087,
0.5639103651046753,
-0.08037728816270828,
0.2544628083705902,
1.04226553440094,
0.7537978291511536,
0.15308625996112823,
0.40527471899986267,
0.22797882556915283,
0.3525097668170929,
0.3451290428638458,
0.22574597597122192,
0.9877197742462158,
-0.016691775992512703,
0.5693444013595581,
-0.612216055393219,
-0.546187698841095,
-0.5960706472396851,
-0.4405878484249115,
-1.037200689315796,
-1.025903582572937,
-0.40069466829299927,
-0.5851719975471497,
0.33959463238716125,
0.9563143253326416,
0.977618932723999,
-0.5569405555725098,
-0.3143126368522644,
-0.15236569941043854,
-0.02778845839202404,
-0.34858494997024536,
-0.3310393691062927,
0.04205704852938652,
-0.05079052597284317,
-0.6748147010803223,
-0.026884183287620544,
0.6994163990020752,
-0.004109060857445002,
-0.1571071594953537,
0.46959391236305237,
-0.18832193315029144,
0.5905212759971619,
0.4228534400463104,
0.29723408818244934,
-0.7103015184402466,
-0.5124720335006714,
0.0898936465382576,
-0.6117026209831238,
0.2038477510213852,
0.9173064827919006,
-0.3034609854221344,
0.6411991119384766,
0.6917527318000793,
0.2830274701118469,
0.2869165539741516,
-0.05259748175740242,
0.5954291224479675,
-0.2945743501186371,
0.1944015771150589,
0.5470852255821228,
0.23665662109851837,
0.08092409372329712,
-0.3707618713378906,
0.37065818905830383,
0.18512850999832153,
-0.5248194932937622,
-0.7235634922981262,
0.32452037930488586,
-0.98007732629776,
-0.553356945514679,
1.447001338005066,
0.4046989977359772,
-0.4175788462162018,
-0.5598320960998535,
-0.34619036316871643,
0.21167303621768951,
-0.7340996265411377,
1.1776071786880493,
1.081929326057434,
-0.589154839515686,
-0.3743620812892914,
-0.7827366590499878,
0.7109377384185791,
0.22086969017982483,
-0.7555825114250183,
-0.4508938491344452,
-0.4830276668071747,
0.12251141667366028,
-0.025414349511265755,
1.2693043947219849,
0.03306753188371658,
0.33990705013275146,
0.21233221888542175,
-0.043910566717386246,
0.5890275835990906,
-0.12058939784765244,
0.12003068625926971,
0.0955689325928688,
-0.10691826045513153,
-0.1567549854516983
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19414v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19414v1
|
BP4ER: Bootstrap Prompting for Explicit Reasoning in Medical Dialogue Generation
| 2024-03-28T13:38:13 | 2024-03-28T13:38:13 |
Yuhong He, Yongqi Zhang, Shizhu He, Jun Wan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Medical dialogue generation (MDG) has gained increasing attention due to its
substantial practical value. Previous works typically employ a
sequence-to-sequence framework to generate medical responses by modeling
dialogue context as sequential text with annotated medical entities. While
these methods have been successful in generating fluent responses, they fail to
provide process explanations of reasoning and require extensive entity
annotation. To address these limitations, we propose the method Bootstrap
Prompting for Explicit Reasoning in MDG (BP4ER), which explicitly model MDG's
multi-step reasoning process and iteratively enhance this reasoning process. We
employ a least-to-most prompting strategy to guide a large language model (LLM)
in explicit reasoning, breaking down MDG into simpler sub-questions. These
sub-questions build on answers from previous ones. Additionally, we also
introduce two distinct bootstrapping techniques for prompting, which
autonomously correct errors and facilitate the LLM's explicit reasoning. This
approach eliminates the need for entity annotation and increases the
transparency of the MDG process by explicitly generating the intermediate
reasoning chain. The experimental findings on the two public datasets indicate
that BP4ER outperforms state-of-the-art methods in terms of both objective and
subjective evaluation metrics.
|
[
-0.4742061495780945,
-0.7265903949737549,
1.018827199935913,
0.18336869776248932,
-0.38171565532684326,
-0.04976148530840874,
-0.03583116829395294,
-0.17538079619407654,
-0.07198087126016617,
0.26503250002861023,
-0.9395128488540649,
-0.5179648995399475,
-0.28245383501052856,
0.5569320917129517,
-0.023046839982271194,
1.036080002784729,
-0.13441181182861328,
0.39518508315086365,
-0.0710763931274414,
0.20540180802345276,
-0.5161490440368652,
-0.30196845531463623,
-0.7004926204681396,
-0.44645819067955017,
0.6628680229187012,
0.43813323974609375,
0.29395097494125366,
0.6759575009346008,
0.05522475764155388,
0.2543090879917145,
0.251260906457901,
0.168600395321846,
-0.13158084452152252,
0.515927791595459,
-0.1154092401266098,
-0.2622882127761841,
-0.22820964455604553,
-0.08310014009475708,
0.4999646842479706,
0.6991623640060425,
-0.14740398526191711,
0.1721244603395462,
-0.075127974152565,
0.576145350933075,
-0.41087716817855835,
0.23058390617370605,
-0.5511507391929626,
-0.028523916378617287,
0.08350136876106262,
-0.6269806623458862,
-0.47463715076446533,
-0.34595298767089844,
0.16770315170288086,
-0.37982678413391113,
0.33518919348716736,
0.13240785896778107,
0.6001185774803162,
0.32253140211105347,
-0.2945917844772339,
-0.22306762635707855,
-0.47121256589889526,
0.29190534353256226,
-0.7924516201019287,
0.18749646842479706,
0.3429948687553406,
0.24135878682136536,
-0.10344815999269485,
-0.8395256400108337,
-0.696082592010498,
-0.11588998138904572,
0.10200509428977966,
0.14478819072246552,
-0.014948982745409012,
0.38558438420295715,
0.31398046016693115,
0.22024396061897278,
-0.26636266708374023,
-0.009046373888850212,
-0.419821172952652,
-0.13359995186328888,
0.24439388513565063,
0.11177007108926773,
-0.22508585453033447,
-0.16589345037937164,
-0.5161446332931519,
0.1780167520046234,
-0.8573929071426392,
-0.05826009437441826,
0.0812903568148613,
0.08223994821310043,
0.11606024950742722,
0.4564184844493866,
-0.09565965831279755,
0.934266209602356,
0.5139098167419434,
-0.24486930668354034,
0.17135989665985107,
-0.4462651312351227,
-0.35168394446372986,
0.16760589182376862,
0.8528410792350769,
0.7789283394813538,
0.07397041469812393,
0.24395732581615448,
-0.22195225954055786,
-0.013958868570625782,
0.39426469802856445,
-0.9428536891937256,
-0.26464733481407166,
0.698191225528717,
-0.38477447628974915,
-0.3958640694618225,
-0.3937610387802124,
-0.8196834921836853,
-0.5038992166519165,
-0.25641679763793945,
0.2226128876209259,
-0.4273715913295746,
0.03863384202122688,
-0.10409753024578094,
-0.018370496109128,
0.31620651483535767,
0.3862815201282501,
-0.820439875125885,
0.23602934181690216,
0.36723485589027405,
0.7551661729812622,
-0.0552670955657959,
0.09183996915817261,
-0.641564130783081,
0.2880413234233856,
-0.4743342101573944,
0.9238578677177429,
-0.5861572027206421,
-0.272747278213501,
0.1422942578792572,
0.0257208663970232,
0.09485459327697754,
-0.4812000095844269,
0.530062198638916,
-0.16402371227741241,
0.5376176238059998,
-0.47564825415611267,
-0.5840060710906982,
-0.2186598777770996,
0.31734490394592285,
-0.2456716001033783,
0.677209734916687,
0.07947929948568344,
-0.6965336203575134,
0.6184219717979431,
-0.8218985795974731,
-0.3648298978805542,
0.38413700461387634,
-0.6802127957344055,
-0.2878054678440094,
-0.0910399779677391,
0.6379294395446777,
0.6884202361106873,
-0.6084951758384705,
0.4246448278427124,
0.0711524486541748,
-0.0953349620103836,
0.041484083980321884,
-0.32003292441368103,
0.2785293459892273,
0.11346612870693207,
-0.6986560821533203,
0.3868498206138611,
-0.7710007429122925,
0.011398173868656158,
0.172916978597641,
-0.30047863721847534,
0.22524233162403107,
-0.14917056262493134,
-0.41008079051971436,
0.4784517288208008,
-0.14792905747890472,
-0.3116399943828583,
0.09841742366552353,
-0.35376447439193726,
0.3176640272140503,
0.8564041256904602,
0.5885188579559326,
0.36780354380607605,
-0.49773073196411133,
0.6869937777519226,
0.20528854429721832,
-0.014123393222689629,
-0.8063355088233948,
-0.9467360377311707,
-0.6502618193626404,
-0.3840314447879791,
0.421712726354599,
0.5299510955810547,
-0.9547044038772583,
0.37512895464897156,
0.10145888477563858,
-0.11604776978492737,
-0.8627155423164368,
-0.11987850069999695,
0.47317394614219666,
0.9868997931480408,
0.529208779335022,
-0.29568350315093994,
-0.5361447930335999,
-0.9238018989562988,
-0.01783689111471176,
-0.31154537200927734,
-0.1968369036912918,
0.2846517264842987,
0.2581498622894287,
-0.223216250538826,
0.6578271985054016,
-0.2956464886665344,
0.02333737723529339,
-0.1929098665714264,
0.3316259980201721,
-0.06386441737413406,
0.5427747964859009,
0.12005779147148132,
-0.47638171911239624,
-0.1322534680366516,
-0.2773672938346863,
-0.5503753423690796,
-0.5093197822570801,
-0.46888467669487,
-0.15989424288272858,
0.37977492809295654,
0.2904512584209442,
-0.43692880868911743,
0.2998044192790985,
0.3811020851135254,
-0.013645948842167854,
0.638372540473938,
-0.11965932697057724,
0.47153276205062866,
-1.0803371667861938,
0.22621437907218933,
0.15229806303977966,
-0.38277408480644226,
-0.7649675011634827,
-0.11951132863759995,
-0.07754407823085785,
0.03255384787917137,
-0.049659352749586105,
0.4048145115375519,
-0.5462501049041748,
0.18478477001190186,
-0.1661132127046585,
0.0832487940788269,
0.06354136765003204,
0.45606619119644165,
0.227218359708786,
0.5955157279968262,
0.5824527740478516,
-0.7015959620475769,
0.47538134455680847,
0.3244500756263733,
-0.13756734132766724,
0.7260178327560425,
-0.6309532523155212,
0.14327719807624817,
-0.16568529605865479,
0.5730615258216858,
-1.2192535400390625,
-0.5124989151954651,
0.610931932926178,
-0.32548028230667114,
0.38743337988853455,
-0.6344823241233826,
-0.46954649686813354,
-0.5087103247642517,
-0.21665425598621368,
0.16716229915618896,
0.5794807076454163,
-0.5316024422645569,
0.40196970105171204,
0.14598707854747772,
-0.6172362565994263,
-0.5125166773796082,
-0.3840106129646301,
0.09342602640390396,
-0.07019822299480438,
-0.5179141163825989,
0.12045619636774063,
-0.34318816661834717,
-0.026094550266861916,
-0.5722553730010986,
-0.4273211658000946,
-0.0357508659362793,
-0.4678722620010376,
0.2753942012786865,
0.4635627865791321,
-0.21700520813465118,
0.08763988316059113,
0.42234012484550476,
-0.12104690074920654,
0.43849635124206543,
-0.5154854655265808,
0.5679737329483032,
-0.032837577164173126,
-0.418030321598053,
-0.4634965658187866,
0.39315763115882874,
0.3632798492908478,
-0.16006223857402802,
0.5773077607154846,
0.3423615097999573,
-0.3424582779407501,
-0.02707359567284584,
-0.8171325325965881,
-0.6332269906997681,
-0.469816118478775,
-0.13704602420330048,
-0.38328540325164795,
-0.6836498379707336,
0.164093017578125,
-0.47011420130729675,
0.2884226441383362,
-0.0069749243557453156,
1.1204636096954346,
-0.07809732854366302,
1.2280383110046387,
-0.0013235628139227629,
0.563834011554718,
0.02091127634048462,
0.0870191678404808,
0.14914356172084808,
-0.6208623647689819,
-0.6732940077781677,
-0.2137811779975891,
-0.1711876094341278,
-0.2844541668891907,
-0.7190870642662048,
0.603556215763092,
-0.24789626896381378,
-0.06945350021123886,
-0.09775099903345108,
-0.7466782331466675,
0.3671119511127472,
0.4169020354747772,
0.03309277445077896,
0.26450201869010925,
-0.009047814644873142,
-0.6090461611747742,
-0.047817252576351166,
-0.8371774554252625,
-0.5653247833251953,
0.6899412870407104,
0.42315906286239624,
0.6075598001480103,
-0.21712498366832733,
0.8140719532966614,
-0.12949790060520172,
0.3050263822078705,
-0.7022546529769897,
0.5168216228485107,
0.8339449763298035,
-0.6629289984703064,
0.02151469886302948,
-0.4786582291126251,
-0.9350684881210327,
0.27378609776496887,
-0.30343833565711975,
-0.5815687775611877,
0.16112898290157318,
0.5473592877388,
-0.6506808996200562,
-0.012132881209254265,
-0.6878674030303955,
0.6710191965103149,
0.032424092292785645,
-0.39581459760665894,
0.30285248160362244,
-1.1938284635543823,
0.5812792778015137,
-0.0730166882276535,
0.3120254576206207,
-0.029340390115976334,
-0.22918002307415009,
0.3962288498878479,
-0.6425887942314148,
0.7552669048309326,
-0.36402004957199097,
-0.2530165910720825,
0.1238246038556099,
0.18019695580005646,
0.5450966358184814,
0.14678502082824707,
0.19388017058372498,
-0.3009958863258362,
-0.07983523607254028,
-0.35750874876976013,
-0.522283673286438,
0.6145281791687012,
-0.08325982838869095,
-0.753104031085968,
-0.39777135848999023,
-0.4269767105579376,
-0.49231112003326416,
0.12273640930652618,
0.45893698930740356,
0.42765066027641296,
0.22304123640060425,
-0.28044888377189636,
0.5890487432479858,
-0.15606556832790375,
0.14768177270889282,
0.4674219787120819,
-0.22390858829021454,
-0.40097618103027344,
0.41926485300064087,
-0.22306956350803375,
0.4020366370677948,
0.029091279953718185,
0.2771555185317993,
-0.5399219989776611,
-0.5968612432479858,
-0.8385658264160156,
0.4330848157405853,
-0.754797101020813,
-0.34219178557395935,
-0.7172322869300842,
0.04317189380526543,
-0.3023814857006073,
-0.1474660187959671,
0.0032363126520067453,
-0.4227984845638275,
0.1246664971113205,
-0.23944136500358582,
0.32933470606803894,
0.7459803819656372,
-0.02588891237974167,
0.10815294831991196,
-0.7160996794700623,
0.4501195549964905,
0.22122526168823242,
0.3642732799053192,
-0.27411767840385437,
-0.40705418586730957,
0.0848807841539383,
-0.12980742752552032,
-0.2789902091026306,
-1.28852379322052,
0.1535339057445526,
-0.07796794176101685,
0.3046579360961914,
0.579983115196228,
0.1097528338432312,
0.7609947919845581,
-1.1309309005737305,
0.9046671390533447,
0.4991690218448639,
-0.8272705078125,
0.8231989145278931,
-0.4092198312282562,
0.3256438076496124,
0.5283706188201904,
0.653837263584137,
-0.2693987786769867,
-0.44486910104751587,
-0.7087470889091492,
-0.8989028334617615,
0.5205121040344238,
0.2733246088027954,
-0.19045212864875793,
-0.32544487714767456,
0.37074196338653564,
0.21460047364234924,
0.3764215111732483,
-0.5740963220596313,
-0.3415854573249817,
-0.22947780787944794,
-0.10914180427789688,
0.3276582956314087,
-0.1614150106906891,
-0.6210808157920837,
-0.2607917785644531,
0.7190477848052979,
-0.4884285628795624,
0.30949845910072327,
0.4460512697696686,
0.16168567538261414,
-0.3646928071975708,
0.4298112392425537,
0.6201940774917603,
0.731882631778717,
-0.03646676614880562,
0.11188336461782455,
0.1578906923532486,
-0.08353479951620102,
0.2965507209300995,
0.3406546413898468,
-0.010957161895930767,
0.2056524157524109,
0.022170415148139,
0.6694825887680054,
0.02737586572766304,
-0.630657970905304,
0.7199156880378723,
-0.03759362921118736,
-0.3411213159561157,
-0.14520326256752014,
-0.14047499001026154,
0.08521062880754471,
0.21222788095474243,
0.23627091944217682,
0.12624984979629517,
0.3186086416244507,
-0.33646491169929504,
0.26378577947616577,
0.113510861992836,
-0.23515446484088898,
-0.06312235444784164,
0.8092315793037415,
0.3749391436576843,
-0.10994193702936172,
0.25873634219169617,
-0.1025584489107132,
-0.3635595142841339,
-0.029632991179823875,
0.6712551712989807,
0.4339333772659302,
-0.468658447265625,
0.19433113932609558,
0.4812234938144684,
0.2920747697353363,
-0.21581968665122986,
0.3238907754421234,
-0.20147153735160828,
-0.38325127959251404,
-0.8252069354057312,
-0.21481937170028687,
-0.5841169953346252,
0.34141263365745544,
-0.5436988472938538,
0.1722067892551422,
-0.7055987119674683,
-0.1658865362405777,
0.20711979269981384,
-0.42886897921562195,
-0.4075683057308197,
0.3378923535346985,
0.2378360480070114,
0.8786083459854126,
-0.5488059520721436,
0.4619384706020355,
0.5868737101554871,
-0.6708473563194275,
-0.9410043358802795,
0.1833009421825409,
0.2865271270275116,
-0.9114381670951843,
0.1393018662929535,
0.3320487439632416,
-0.19145821034908295,
-0.04411475732922554,
-0.7397041916847229,
-0.20202046632766724,
0.9024538397789001,
0.35154178738594055,
-0.570374608039856,
-0.28338906168937683,
-0.24730783700942993,
0.24896389245986938,
-0.5841172933578491,
0.29990825057029724,
0.7697628140449524,
0.6070469617843628,
0.5029116272926331,
-0.7802844047546387,
0.5822126865386963,
-0.3006381094455719,
-0.06174774840474129,
0.11658129096031189,
-0.12470607459545135,
0.27873510122299194,
-0.579342246055603,
-0.11033350974321365,
0.1305367350578308,
0.27713149785995483,
0.7601832747459412,
0.22086460888385773,
0.611009418964386,
0.07802648097276688,
0.899777889251709,
-0.1401158571243286,
1.2738145589828491,
-0.4821472764015198,
-0.32113078236579895,
1.0298582315444946,
-0.3648255169391632,
0.5207549333572388,
0.5416001677513123,
0.16076159477233887,
0.8402778506278992,
0.6847485899925232,
-0.04265878349542618,
0.322998583316803,
0.3288825750350952,
-0.6410049200057983,
-0.17917996644973755,
0.12469685077667236,
-0.36149317026138306,
0.029300564900040627,
0.3743475675582886,
-0.6460162401199341,
0.09262479841709137,
-0.20775628089904785,
0.26726335287094116,
-0.14305642247200012,
-0.16348057985305786,
1.0093928575515747,
0.1167232096195221,
-1.1078433990478516,
0.8975533843040466,
-0.10101813077926636,
0.16588731110095978,
-0.5951393246650696,
-0.30004456639289856,
-0.02821960113942623,
-0.183767631649971,
-0.2644903361797333,
-0.5976263880729675,
-0.2474805861711502,
0.18481206893920898,
-0.08288907259702682,
-0.2995530962944031,
0.5780021548271179,
-0.6665469408035278,
-0.200736865401268,
-0.11464785784482956,
0.6063932776451111,
0.5130245089530945,
0.03812355548143387,
-0.8518493175506592,
-0.14622344076633453,
0.04048433154821396,
-0.1278652548789978,
0.03151039034128189,
0.6066344976425171,
0.10430214554071426,
0.6428245902061462,
0.8016824722290039,
0.13723768293857574,
0.025575904175639153,
0.41218504309654236,
0.9352409243583679,
-0.5136206150054932,
-0.389234334230423,
-0.7309769988059998,
0.7654469609260559,
-0.2842061221599579,
0.04556557536125183,
0.44538816809654236,
0.4065968990325928,
0.3356096148490906,
-0.1060483455657959,
0.9904112815856934,
0.11477585136890411,
0.5865478515625,
-0.5575238466262817,
0.36605191230773926,
-0.15911702811717987,
0.3849058747291565,
-0.3701198995113373,
-0.8026425242424011,
-0.2150610089302063,
0.8321855664253235,
-0.05936696380376816,
0.3689008951187134,
0.9984298348426819,
0.78973388671875,
0.17275646328926086,
0.11900540441274643,
0.3441835939884186,
0.3559936583042145,
0.19336684048175812,
0.4067985415458679,
0.8582302331924438,
-0.01777742989361286,
0.5163516998291016,
0.11194616556167603,
-0.5162493586540222,
-0.029692405834794044,
-1.0423529148101807,
-0.9766183495521545,
-0.620210587978363,
-0.31916525959968567,
-0.7590694427490234,
0.009501331485807896,
1.3750934600830078,
0.8386363983154297,
-0.7247308492660522,
0.12872812151908875,
-0.1339230090379715,
-0.14927998185157776,
-0.11341884732246399,
-0.15419551730155945,
-0.09942184388637543,
-0.46227169036865234,
-0.47783851623535156,
0.7423681020736694,
0.39932918548583984,
0.14269092679023743,
-0.28839296102523804,
-0.08194026350975037,
-0.11347052454948425,
0.2624116539955139,
0.321542888879776,
0.20584909617900848,
-0.8706748485565186,
-0.08457265049219131,
-0.32184287905693054,
0.23773562908172607,
0.41722363233566284,
1.110806941986084,
-0.9916496276855469,
0.590429425239563,
0.11711180955171585,
0.5595996975898743,
0.6429850459098816,
0.1714029461145401,
1.132706880569458,
-1.0335417985916138,
-0.29790422320365906,
0.41156816482543945,
0.487027108669281,
0.5269131660461426,
-0.22291213274002075,
0.4131373465061188,
0.1590331494808197,
-0.687251091003418,
-0.7476062178611755,
0.5713270306587219,
-0.7938105463981628,
-0.10202574729919434,
1.2703138589859009,
-0.19641894102096558,
0.0017175463726744056,
-0.4553240239620209,
-0.5974240899085999,
0.1611855924129486,
-0.6631229519844055,
0.5489091277122498,
0.5018731951713562,
-0.4761301279067993,
-0.6228134632110596,
-0.48132070899009705,
0.8273128867149353,
0.32821762561798096,
-1.0246615409851074,
-0.05499747768044472,
0.7135830521583557,
0.39198535680770874,
0.09019022434949875,
0.9001390337944031,
-0.1812017261981964,
0.4835364818572998,
0.005644897930324078,
-0.027249429374933243,
-0.03983965143561363,
-0.3104850947856903,
-0.43490102887153625,
0.11303207278251648,
0.11492186039686203,
-0.018226172775030136
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19399v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19399v3
|
KazParC: Kazakh Parallel Corpus for Machine Translation
| 2024-03-28T13:19:16 | 2024-04-09T20:58:41 |
Rustem Yeshpanov, Alina Polonskaya, Huseyin Atakan Varol
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce KazParC, a parallel corpus designed for machine translation
across Kazakh, English, Russian, and Turkish. The first and largest publicly
available corpus of its kind, KazParC contains a collection of 371,902 parallel
sentences covering different domains and developed with the assistance of human
translators. Our research efforts also extend to the development of a neural
machine translation model nicknamed Tilmash. Remarkably, the performance of
Tilmash is on par with, and in certain instances, surpasses that of industry
giants, such as Google Translate and Yandex Translate, as measured by standard
evaluation metrics, such as BLEU and chrF. Both KazParC and Tilmash are openly
available for download under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International
License (CC BY 4.0) through our GitHub repository.
|
[
-0.31291088461875916,
-0.40109795331954956,
0.7683098912239075,
0.45743799209594727,
-0.43949443101882935,
0.20743444561958313,
-0.45730459690093994,
-0.24311436712741852,
0.16021811962127686,
0.3804883062839508,
-0.5702828168869019,
-1.1580708026885986,
-0.7912324070930481,
0.5227431058883667,
-0.6632171869277954,
1.1241612434387207,
-0.3262750208377838,
0.24971012771129608,
-0.18086782097816467,
-0.1073732078075409,
-0.2257276475429535,
-0.4093886911869049,
-0.11325734853744507,
0.03557121381163597,
0.7379797101020813,
0.7903056144714355,
1.0759683847427368,
0.88917475938797,
0.753865122795105,
0.32729923725128174,
0.28678178787231445,
0.2110622525215149,
-0.022672036662697792,
0.1706114262342453,
-0.09092096239328384,
-0.5135888457298279,
-0.45329853892326355,
-0.21192820370197296,
1.053411602973938,
0.7118761539459229,
-0.16017970442771912,
0.43788227438926697,
-0.13334743678569794,
0.9943479895591736,
-0.7418364882469177,
0.3729131519794464,
-0.20830783247947693,
0.31852802634239197,
-0.846489667892456,
0.03620661050081253,
-0.2463182955980301,
-0.5577526688575745,
-0.31541937589645386,
-0.823215901851654,
0.11223866045475006,
0.1575758457183838,
0.618055522441864,
-0.0122313117608428,
-0.31728607416152954,
-0.2852238416671753,
-0.8366880416870117,
0.9833381175994873,
-0.6419340372085571,
0.45598071813583374,
0.492367148399353,
0.7859910130500793,
-0.16518738865852356,
-1.1814714670181274,
-0.7877299785614014,
-0.22615467011928558,
-0.04419993981719017,
0.044244784861803055,
-0.06914941221475601,
0.021748948842287064,
-0.0639779195189476,
0.5914992690086365,
-0.6935653686523438,
-0.2769385278224945,
-0.9065908789634705,
-0.13797186315059662,
0.4698036015033722,
0.7095891833305359,
0.787818968296051,
0.020405631512403488,
-0.21639284491539001,
0.016374757513403893,
-0.6441347002983093,
-0.14757440984249115,
0.5808607339859009,
0.6844770312309265,
0.029274437576532364,
0.8619792461395264,
-0.7391958236694336,
1.0402470827102661,
-0.3153897821903229,
-0.08333548903465271,
0.25152388215065,
-0.4628502428531647,
-0.252377450466156,
0.17483963072299957,
1.1066806316375732,
0.2676219642162323,
0.05337085202336311,
-0.40223434567451477,
-0.046794719994068146,
0.16493874788284302,
0.6493132710456848,
-0.5868078470230103,
-0.09077122807502747,
0.2645116448402405,
-0.5198977589607239,
-0.2986954152584076,
0.22622708976268768,
-0.8264991044998169,
-0.2593157887458801,
-0.3409944474697113,
0.13721917569637299,
-0.22023656964302063,
0.20160244405269623,
0.2503860890865326,
0.4403071701526642,
0.029497826471924782,
0.05465272068977356,
-0.8399263024330139,
0.6425076127052307,
0.9541181325912476,
1.1813265085220337,
-0.13053753972053528,
-0.9529926180839539,
-0.45067375898361206,
-0.16487209498882294,
-0.7344357967376709,
1.0965520143508911,
-0.5792835354804993,
0.030350837856531143,
0.1993158757686615,
0.2645640969276428,
-0.14228199422359467,
-0.3398999869823456,
0.9625980854034424,
-0.49845415353775024,
0.24791638553142548,
-0.5534317493438721,
-0.22524921596050262,
-0.2948974072933197,
-0.0662427544593811,
-0.6453648209571838,
0.42629340291023254,
0.38611236214637756,
-1.0526894330978394,
0.08856282383203506,
-0.69012051820755,
-0.3617231547832489,
0.12359142303466797,
-0.0426764078438282,
-0.22870999574661255,
-0.038225144147872925,
0.13871034979820251,
0.28450390696525574,
-0.7014553546905518,
0.22696712613105774,
-0.21887627243995667,
-0.44938647747039795,
0.1205172911286354,
0.252628892660141,
0.8012244701385498,
0.9243036508560181,
0.09537944197654724,
0.4720311760902405,
-0.3974783420562744,
-0.1356247216463089,
-0.08199270069599152,
-0.25866472721099854,
0.12061817198991776,
-0.06534112989902496,
0.3134341239929199,
0.3792782127857208,
0.21516865491867065,
-0.8751869797706604,
-0.013028815388679504,
-0.3040008544921875,
0.27807629108428955,
0.39960962533950806,
-0.48808568716049194,
0.4077480435371399,
-0.36631345748901367,
0.9076799154281616,
-0.044218502938747406,
0.031372565776109695,
0.0662531927227974,
-0.501101016998291,
-0.5970996022224426,
-0.23981575667858124,
0.4829985499382019,
0.637213945388794,
-0.5618177652359009,
0.1245688647031784,
-0.4183533489704132,
-0.5064354538917542,
-1.058725357055664,
0.2647435963153839,
0.3101595342159271,
0.30494651198387146,
0.41209834814071655,
-0.08392354100942612,
-0.4729060232639313,
-1.2274552583694458,
-0.5409596562385559,
0.17032192647457123,
-0.21427199244499207,
-0.1384110450744629,
0.08253084868192673,
0.3576802909374237,
0.3932626247406006,
-0.28729328513145447,
-0.541043221950531,
-0.4317122995853424,
-0.09500215202569962,
0.3199716806411743,
0.3461245000362396,
0.5355381965637207,
-0.5799111127853394,
-1.2265305519104004,
0.5092887878417969,
-0.8466160297393799,
-0.19405296444892883,
-0.0002715486043598503,
-0.3187660574913025,
0.24920654296875,
0.5415126085281372,
-0.9521670937538147,
0.36588844656944275,
0.6314443945884705,
-0.6205499172210693,
0.5899128317832947,
-0.1715097576379776,
0.6615128517150879,
-1.3662232160568237,
0.33815085887908936,
-0.42641159892082214,
-0.48643553256988525,
-0.62748783826828,
0.31363722681999207,
0.052036430686712265,
-0.10190284997224808,
-0.7239568829536438,
0.021750666201114655,
-0.30283695459365845,
-0.39138367772102356,
-0.46649667620658875,
0.05729338899254799,
-0.20912662148475647,
0.3268583118915558,
-0.4145272374153137,
1.156818151473999,
0.5988503098487854,
-0.2412205934524536,
0.847997784614563,
0.5152473449707031,
-0.7767863869667053,
0.2645205557346344,
-0.5768224596977234,
0.10563460737466812,
0.008410864509642124,
0.2921503186225891,
-0.6018191576004028,
-0.4653598368167877,
0.6887166500091553,
-0.5135167837142944,
0.07928105443716049,
0.038189392536878586,
-0.9408704042434692,
-0.3857695460319519,
-0.08980777114629745,
0.35480889678001404,
0.5344825387001038,
-0.3766302466392517,
0.24520239233970642,
0.28435125946998596,
-0.5485952496528625,
-0.6947479248046875,
-0.8479724526405334,
0.26043108105659485,
-0.11371570825576782,
-0.6577929854393005,
0.17966382205486298,
0.18458981812000275,
-0.1947450190782547,
0.1359504908323288,
0.0060210940428078175,
-0.11280812323093414,
-0.30897805094718933,
0.10959005355834961,
0.25053057074546814,
-0.4789530038833618,
0.036999817937612534,
0.24263982474803925,
-0.2179577350616455,
-0.063177190721035,
-0.5545712113380432,
0.7671515345573425,
-0.6385641098022461,
-0.29142192006111145,
-0.7540109753608704,
0.7947814464569092,
0.8788196444511414,
-0.05061478912830353,
1.1793423891067505,
0.6900746822357178,
-0.27372631430625916,
0.1407351940870285,
-0.20542269945144653,
0.33806952834129333,
-0.41781333088874817,
0.39157530665397644,
-0.49642255902290344,
-0.887641429901123,
0.8528757095336914,
0.1078663244843483,
-0.05453142896294594,
0.7306903004646301,
0.9328740835189819,
0.11377320438623428,
0.9217179417610168,
0.3944298326969147,
-0.34553438425064087,
-0.10793926566839218,
0.29848605394363403,
0.35350146889686584,
-0.3750886619091034,
-0.2920601963996887,
-0.5987318754196167,
-0.3899281322956085,
-0.7609004378318787,
-0.43010213971138,
-0.025426676496863365,
0.21448568999767303,
-0.1216340959072113,
0.7053775191307068,
-0.4225030541419983,
0.7407292127609253,
0.566916286945343,
-0.07989145070314407,
0.47715845704078674,
0.05639267340302467,
-0.1858053207397461,
0.04704675450921059,
-0.646638035774231,
-0.7219176888465881,
1.1946743726730347,
0.24632486701011658,
0.15775097906589508,
0.04886502027511597,
0.6011857390403748,
0.381359338760376,
0.13090184330940247,
-0.5966138243675232,
0.520313560962677,
-0.355313241481781,
-0.7391979098320007,
-0.0936126783490181,
-0.28888946771621704,
-1.0428723096847534,
0.07346078753471375,
-0.12518754601478577,
-0.8226003646850586,
-0.13530395925045013,
-0.12729494273662567,
-0.5817010402679443,
0.7217285633087158,
-0.46183115243911743,
1.1329644918441772,
0.41832590103149414,
-0.09301009774208069,
-0.5501230955123901,
-0.7008440494537354,
0.4687105119228363,
-0.15745384991168976,
-0.0704013854265213,
-0.3111703097820282,
-0.18392091989517212,
0.5164833068847656,
-0.41106417775154114,
0.2539295256137848,
0.14482036232948303,
0.3234896659851074,
0.4132949709892273,
0.2966875433921814,
0.17095127701759338,
-0.10505817085504532,
0.25817641615867615,
0.4074554443359375,
0.28287649154663086,
-0.9345963001251221,
-0.6081725358963013,
0.961546003818512,
-0.8802258372306824,
-0.44874876737594604,
-0.45023584365844727,
-0.9912346601486206,
0.016832781955599785,
0.3198663890361786,
0.14773505926132202,
-0.08268209546804428,
-0.15087497234344482,
0.2465144246816635,
0.008177647367119789,
-0.3868406116962433,
0.15439394116401672,
0.3704737722873688,
-0.5163670182228088,
-0.48704418540000916,
1.0262632369995117,
-0.14218881726264954,
-0.04528261348605156,
0.18993720412254333,
0.13514244556427002,
-0.03163294121623039,
-0.7622373104095459,
-0.7008888721466064,
0.1734403818845749,
-0.7261977791786194,
-0.5098021030426025,
-0.8901281356811523,
-0.21530605852603912,
-0.6487579941749573,
-0.045514218509197235,
-0.7172059416770935,
-0.6293169856071472,
0.022290721535682678,
-0.09560944885015488,
0.3911713659763336,
1.0475767850875854,
-0.23694825172424316,
0.5055625438690186,
-1.1126846075057983,
0.4646788537502289,
0.1614728718996048,
0.4490503668785095,
-0.3691333532333374,
-0.2967601418495178,
-0.4678264260292053,
-0.16065308451652527,
-0.2994932532310486,
-0.8899139761924744,
0.793422520160675,
-0.11332487314939499,
0.3689274489879608,
0.28198152780532837,
0.12460189312696457,
0.2718452215194702,
-0.7658088207244873,
0.769402027130127,
0.1421079784631729,
-0.8326759934425354,
0.14941489696502686,
-0.7613281011581421,
0.46286091208457947,
0.7024348378181458,
0.597163736820221,
-0.9025781750679016,
-0.3612515330314636,
-0.2575853765010834,
-0.5595812797546387,
1.1022597551345825,
0.6497576832771301,
-0.13280023634433746,
-0.03426815941929817,
0.11368252336978912,
0.4469291567802429,
0.24906578660011292,
-0.1583937108516693,
-0.29434075951576233,
-0.1371997594833374,
-0.46546632051467896,
-0.14981229603290558,
-0.2320115566253662,
-0.08845659345388412,
-0.21246594190597534,
0.4927334487438202,
0.2807857394218445,
0.48355957865715027,
0.14928428828716278,
-0.060632091015577316,
-0.3057945668697357,
0.328869104385376,
0.8310902118682861,
0.813816249370575,
-0.18175098299980164,
-0.012592348270118237,
0.21429865062236786,
-0.7437252402305603,
-0.2644062340259552,
0.23324599862098694,
-0.15940238535404205,
0.12613466382026672,
0.05236203595995903,
0.6061932444572449,
-0.3613899052143097,
-0.5209910869598389,
0.2311047911643982,
0.08578211069107056,
-0.3368541896343231,
-0.29032623767852783,
-0.44889816641807556,
0.40420353412628174,
0.45178085565567017,
0.14497819542884827,
0.04327205941081047,
0.37226107716560364,
-0.3670506477355957,
0.20949730277061462,
-0.10783560574054718,
-0.32842618227005005,
-0.45438382029533386,
0.4293570816516876,
-0.13269345462322235,
-0.48555678129196167,
0.7873216867446899,
-0.07071783393621445,
-0.7326568961143494,
0.4089512526988983,
0.43082112073898315,
1.0807944536209106,
-0.3545045554637909,
0.3821135461330414,
0.4724215567111969,
0.34967005252838135,
-0.26128441095352173,
0.49014946818351746,
-0.22670963406562805,
-0.3336741030216217,
-0.5344913005828857,
-0.7840248942375183,
-0.2538020610809326,
-0.04471603408455849,
-0.7021495699882507,
0.15888617932796478,
-0.32931676506996155,
-0.03523242101073265,
0.030389374122023582,
0.10163430124521255,
-0.6954562664031982,
-0.33717089891433716,
0.4209434688091278,
0.7773557901382446,
-0.9718590378761292,
1.2392882108688354,
0.8208310008049011,
-0.32501503825187683,
-0.3996953070163727,
-0.2226601094007492,
-0.17452223598957062,
-0.48917463421821594,
0.5867651104927063,
0.022766778245568275,
-0.09968376904726028,
-0.15123964846134186,
-0.4433716833591461,
-0.8396117091178894,
1.0319706201553345,
0.5821429491043091,
-0.43552592396736145,
0.11910082399845123,
0.7239923477172852,
0.6535707116127014,
-0.47876596450805664,
-0.1413712501525879,
0.7213253378868103,
0.5157936811447144,
-0.5244900584220886,
-1.2020193338394165,
-0.023167062550783157,
-0.3566170930862427,
-0.04633577913045883,
0.2114051729440689,
-0.7359201908111572,
1.0262447595596313,
-0.03740917518734932,
-0.4981611669063568,
0.43518877029418945,
0.8713533282279968,
0.34860384464263916,
0.45012152194976807,
0.26967576146125793,
0.4545108377933502,
0.38926294445991516,
0.12607216835021973,
1.2502961158752441,
-0.3585207164287567,
0.333048552274704,
1.2147331237792969,
0.19161279499530792,
0.73513263463974,
0.6249587535858154,
-0.605317234992981,
0.6136873364448547,
0.6009081602096558,
0.10801820456981659,
0.5759413242340088,
0.25585153698921204,
-0.4004743993282318,
-0.4855024516582489,
-0.27462559938430786,
-0.43113094568252563,
0.40705257654190063,
0.23894648253917694,
-0.4080922603607178,
-0.3797353506088257,
-0.07104818522930145,
-0.10568329691886902,
0.662899911403656,
-0.151667520403862,
0.22030621767044067,
0.23714688420295715,
-0.5714155435562134,
0.31801944971084595,
0.29637888073921204,
0.24765260517597198,
-0.492374986410141,
-0.01870398037135601,
-0.3453141152858734,
0.3006664514541626,
-0.13889577984809875,
-0.8492262959480286,
0.7570840716362,
-0.04149308428168297,
-0.11245034635066986,
-0.06225833669304848,
0.6578022837638855,
-0.6090208292007446,
-0.8514441847801208,
0.1730414479970932,
0.5394437909126282,
0.5463495254516602,
-0.22126539051532745,
-0.5373095870018005,
0.09411779046058655,
-0.20675484836101532,
-0.2556799352169037,
0.6375426650047302,
0.44874271750450134,
0.1243620440363884,
0.7935532331466675,
0.5910891890525818,
0.2597333788871765,
0.2597492039203644,
-0.25214695930480957,
0.9195433259010315,
-0.8050602078437805,
-0.5091081857681274,
-0.684736967086792,
0.11187803000211716,
0.1540384739637375,
-0.08895719796419144,
0.9393680691719055,
0.5826399922370911,
1.0719345808029175,
-0.5443095564842224,
0.6105272173881531,
-0.025829505175352097,
0.672831654548645,
-0.20625755190849304,
1.174594521522522,
-0.3734835088253021,
-0.22405320405960083,
-0.061948228627443314,
-1.0754743814468384,
-0.555842936038971,
0.4326839745044708,
-0.04176610708236694,
-0.429607093334198,
0.9469319581985474,
0.5468096137046814,
-0.14122377336025238,
0.24544984102249146,
0.6179414391517639,
-0.0979752168059349,
-0.23531471192836761,
0.8232468962669373,
0.873885452747345,
-0.64009690284729,
0.802221417427063,
-0.5639938712120056,
0.24243302643299103,
0.2619801461696625,
-0.5140584111213684,
-0.9037051796913147,
-0.7113138437271118,
-0.011369144544005394,
-0.4622002840042114,
0.3556598424911499,
1.1621237993240356,
0.30855798721313477,
-1.343424916267395,
-0.4364634156227112,
-0.3184216320514679,
-0.003044404787942767,
-0.2069409191608429,
-0.1315944492816925,
0.5406639575958252,
-0.724579930305481,
-0.9936065673828125,
0.48691582679748535,
0.08744649589061737,
-0.23545973002910614,
-0.20163722336292267,
-0.12217099964618683,
-0.22032222151756287,
-0.21438632905483246,
0.29898306727409363,
0.34266576170921326,
-0.8682713508605957,
0.15335814654827118,
0.07815482467412949,
-0.350028395652771,
0.09692629426717758,
1.1240475177764893,
-0.628695547580719,
0.5314491391181946,
0.9064317941665649,
0.6507176160812378,
0.23302017152309418,
-0.146734818816185,
0.9143219590187073,
-0.2145899087190628,
0.2985011339187622,
0.1769830882549286,
0.08745094388723373,
0.37294161319732666,
-0.3022630214691162,
0.24768106639385223,
0.09981945902109146,
-0.6439788937568665,
-0.794843316078186,
-0.029895586892962456,
-0.9154658317565918,
-0.22943122684955597,
0.8995289206504822,
-0.5343412756919861,
-0.42868757247924805,
-0.21368980407714844,
0.006985986605286598,
0.6251148581504822,
-0.3909206688404083,
0.9804698824882507,
0.7947675585746765,
0.4053463339805603,
-0.0019016030710190535,
-1.0470205545425415,
0.6266695261001587,
0.5411583185195923,
-0.5450549125671387,
0.27104100584983826,
0.24911122024059296,
0.07813607156276703,
0.07768607884645462,
0.45625731348991394,
-0.5189770460128784,
0.38557589054107666,
0.3660932779312134,
0.2732018828392029,
-0.28974172472953796,
-0.6222497820854187,
-0.22856560349464417,
0.16797499358654022,
-0.12680137157440186,
-0.6062725186347961
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19390v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19390v1
|
Checkpoint Merging via Bayesian Optimization in LLM Pretraining
| 2024-03-28T13:01:18 | 2024-03-28T13:01:18 |
Deyuan Liu, Zecheng Wang, Bingning Wang, Weipeng Chen, Chunshan Li, Zhiying Tu, Dianhui Chu, Bo Li, Dianbo Sui
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The rapid proliferation of large language models (LLMs) such as GPT-4 and
Gemini underscores the intense demand for resources during their training
processes, posing significant challenges due to substantial computational and
environmental costs. To alleviate this issue, we propose checkpoint merging in
pretraining LLM. This method utilizes LLM checkpoints with shared training
trajectories, and is rooted in an extensive search space exploration for the
best merging weight via Bayesian optimization. Through various experiments, we
demonstrate that: (1) Our proposed methodology exhibits the capacity to augment
pretraining, presenting an opportunity akin to obtaining substantial benefits
at minimal cost; (2) Our proposed methodology, despite requiring a given
held-out dataset, still demonstrates robust generalization capabilities across
diverse domains, a pivotal aspect in pretraining.
|
[
-0.5240724682807922,
-0.3676268458366394,
1.024915099143982,
-0.03765319287776947,
-0.3445815145969391,
0.29944321513175964,
-0.1391415148973465,
-0.3272493779659271,
0.015809498727321625,
0.559590220451355,
-0.937716543674469,
-0.3587789833545685,
-0.7743969559669495,
-0.3715513050556183,
-0.33644187450408936,
1.0409035682678223,
-0.2438257783651352,
0.1526222825050354,
-0.1430620402097702,
-0.014735686592757702,
-0.3925258219242096,
-0.6128469705581665,
-0.5941325426101685,
-0.18236850202083588,
0.6097382307052612,
0.13458365201950073,
0.4113198518753052,
0.40420252084732056,
0.6157819628715515,
0.30920276045799255,
0.07251998782157898,
0.10200678557157516,
-0.4869043827056885,
0.15056434273719788,
-0.11622463911771774,
-0.1669318825006485,
-0.3470328748226166,
0.07650014758110046,
0.9416868090629578,
1.0588735342025757,
-0.23038780689239502,
-0.31157246232032776,
0.18865938484668732,
0.49059155583381653,
-0.8161139488220215,
-0.028009574860334396,
-0.6222946643829346,
0.09837506711483002,
-0.304055780172348,
-0.017700202763080597,
0.19288495182991028,
-0.6319155693054199,
0.3620109260082245,
-0.665606677532196,
0.21217390894889832,
-0.25481733679771423,
0.6365970969200134,
0.36372601985931396,
-0.4168236255645752,
0.12908488512039185,
-0.7159919142723083,
0.8475750684738159,
-0.6774296760559082,
0.2080228179693222,
0.062255192548036575,
0.322037011384964,
-0.2723190486431122,
-0.4804181158542633,
-0.6026543378829956,
-0.012706517241895199,
0.24730484187602997,
0.2591463327407837,
-0.2227851152420044,
0.4701100289821625,
0.3133431077003479,
0.41836658120155334,
-0.6820987462997437,
0.2902248501777649,
-0.34749770164489746,
-0.39628177881240845,
0.27160441875457764,
0.10523612797260284,
0.355652779340744,
0.4403061270713806,
-0.19237978756427765,
-0.1868189126253128,
-0.7453358173370361,
-0.24063406884670258,
0.35781407356262207,
0.23429839313030243,
0.14732152223587036,
0.5706781148910522,
-0.3441676199436188,
0.760080099105835,
-0.2502652108669281,
0.13581016659736633,
0.15662232041358948,
-0.6755779981613159,
0.04840865731239319,
-0.08174323290586472,
0.7576331496238708,
0.3505616784095764,
0.1127365231513977,
-0.15600185096263885,
-0.19869095087051392,
0.1768428534269333,
0.23939287662506104,
-0.802128791809082,
-0.15072806179523468,
0.2733987271785736,
0.01071955356746912,
-0.17633159458637238,
-0.07933257520198822,
-0.504021942615509,
-0.027362311258912086,
-0.41183096170425415,
0.5681633949279785,
-0.42915016412734985,
-0.2007022202014923,
0.06732513755559921,
-0.22020940482616425,
0.2631063461303711,
0.45180806517601013,
-0.8874089121818542,
0.15886245667934418,
0.7303371429443359,
0.7957373857498169,
-0.18957707285881042,
-0.46732625365257263,
-0.699622631072998,
0.420810341835022,
-0.3814757764339447,
0.7129287123680115,
-0.3835556209087372,
-0.5160472393035889,
0.05050676688551903,
-0.24953728914260864,
-0.22949016094207764,
-0.5747901797294617,
0.06236741691827774,
-0.6373834609985352,
0.2757014334201813,
-0.4315841794013977,
-0.5041066408157349,
-0.1097022220492363,
0.24451352655887604,
-0.572521984577179,
1.0527844429016113,
0.4363764226436615,
-0.6718743443489075,
0.686555027961731,
-0.3838913142681122,
-0.3729054033756256,
0.21000002324581146,
-0.21119636297225952,
-0.40320873260498047,
0.1204562708735466,
0.30729469656944275,
0.44497430324554443,
-0.2626127302646637,
0.35253843665122986,
-0.4886167645454407,
-0.43009233474731445,
0.06403376162052155,
0.1290140599012375,
0.4754352569580078,
0.282649427652359,
-0.4472803771495819,
0.10956089943647385,
-0.28105705976486206,
0.013568634167313576,
-0.22735753655433655,
-0.44095343351364136,
-0.225360706448555,
-0.10141583532094955,
-0.3180285394191742,
-0.0033496206160634756,
0.7058427929878235,
-0.14696632325649261,
0.47665923833847046,
-0.23842424154281616,
0.17823262512683868,
0.6042299866676331,
-0.034928031265735626,
0.7227275371551514,
-0.4831358790397644,
0.6531324982643127,
0.1626344919204712,
0.08953802287578583,
-0.03179575130343437,
-0.4316224753856659,
-0.7303652763366699,
-0.4178641438484192,
0.18236036598682404,
0.5826180577278137,
-0.6100662350654602,
0.6996408104896545,
-0.36929798126220703,
-0.3837644159793854,
-0.2666116952896118,
0.2359352707862854,
0.3699261248111725,
0.23247383534908295,
0.4118115305900574,
-0.6468415260314941,
-0.44500502943992615,
-0.8435054421424866,
-0.16201339662075043,
-0.13874931633472443,
-0.12717902660369873,
0.09648250788450241,
0.17073434591293335,
-0.557492733001709,
0.8779388070106506,
-0.2958510220050812,
-0.049099963158369064,
-0.4217250645160675,
0.2844824194908142,
0.42260828614234924,
0.8019611239433289,
0.48495569825172424,
-0.2798651158809662,
-0.3804462254047394,
0.10695814341306686,
-0.557490348815918,
-0.3414429724216461,
-0.22514577209949493,
-0.27899307012557983,
-0.06823420524597168,
0.5892719030380249,
-0.612419068813324,
0.2578946352005005,
0.6147969961166382,
0.38337770104408264,
0.37293896079063416,
-0.33032655715942383,
0.3656032681465149,
-1.1411508321762085,
-0.10963595658540726,
-0.34003952145576477,
-0.1374739557504654,
-0.6215325593948364,
0.10015520453453064,
0.04650955647230148,
-0.2158551961183548,
-0.20426280796527863,
0.38213518261909485,
-0.6920920014381409,
-0.28489720821380615,
-0.3831951320171356,
0.19864940643310547,
-0.46200841665267944,
0.2862095534801483,
0.0606938935816288,
0.66059809923172,
0.8031841516494751,
-0.6366917490959167,
0.018128901720046997,
0.05797972157597542,
-0.35350093245506287,
0.16892944276332855,
-0.29851269721984863,
0.023570315912365913,
-0.15486419200897217,
0.48116689920425415,
-1.0605882406234741,
-0.264734148979187,
0.19288064539432526,
-0.1071435734629631,
0.29560428857803345,
-0.4126352071762085,
-0.45467641949653625,
-0.21493300795555115,
-0.21839921176433563,
0.689530074596405,
0.6185839772224426,
-0.4934697151184082,
0.5300465822219849,
0.2438490241765976,
-0.38607776165008545,
-0.5791370868682861,
-0.459405779838562,
-0.02540181577205658,
-0.4177013039588928,
-0.6106647849082947,
0.6602848768234253,
-0.014930478297173977,
0.142915740609169,
-0.1613987535238266,
-0.1287715584039688,
-0.013611949048936367,
-0.12732993066310883,
0.08598069101572037,
0.47607868909835815,
-0.08782372623682022,
-0.32129955291748047,
0.47009801864624023,
-0.16215640306472778,
-0.15177538990974426,
-0.6601141095161438,
0.636707603931427,
0.2559865713119507,
-0.551172137260437,
-0.452830046415329,
0.37059587240219116,
0.4781550467014313,
-0.08922745287418365,
0.8159261345863342,
0.6765344142913818,
-0.3757261633872986,
0.03459707275032997,
-0.9694923758506775,
-0.11199792474508286,
-0.46416813135147095,
0.3941298723220825,
-0.09332560747861862,
-1.2950565814971924,
0.5848276019096375,
-0.45148494839668274,
-0.03636380657553673,
0.04954574257135391,
0.45889967679977417,
-0.05003587156534195,
0.797278881072998,
0.5805162191390991,
-0.41200000047683716,
0.8509771823883057,
-0.23180602490901947,
0.18626555800437927,
-0.8331579566001892,
-0.09668672829866409,
-0.4255389869213104,
-0.29541122913360596,
-0.6415311694145203,
-0.8450208902359009,
0.32325875759124756,
0.27429062128067017,
-0.41971704363822937,
0.469306081533432,
-0.23176029324531555,
0.6852396726608276,
0.584021806716919,
0.00859048031270504,
0.09592990577220917,
0.11671826243400574,
-0.3197513520717621,
-0.1385599970817566,
-0.7736374139785767,
-0.15908366441726685,
1.22014319896698,
-0.08435215801000595,
0.5044873356819153,
0.0633750930428505,
1.214361310005188,
-0.3395417630672455,
0.3956625461578369,
-0.5073466300964355,
0.7152159214019775,
-0.09931948781013489,
-0.5543439388275146,
-0.2239350527524948,
-0.8653637766838074,
-1.0555055141448975,
0.3383360803127289,
-0.3316662609577179,
-0.8480252027511597,
-0.10119134187698364,
0.10866871476173401,
-0.4043431282043457,
0.08106574416160583,
-0.4132203757762909,
0.8894525170326233,
-0.3001897931098938,
-0.27065378427505493,
-0.6659516096115112,
-0.7109360694885254,
0.5277139544487,
-0.5376219749450684,
0.194566547870636,
-0.10120809823274612,
-0.12543600797653198,
0.7580704689025879,
-0.6759430170059204,
0.599316418170929,
-0.27295950055122375,
0.11428751796483994,
0.037289150059223175,
-0.00844570528715849,
0.5120612382888794,
-0.20983746647834778,
0.4359590411186218,
0.16182847321033478,
0.04924045875668526,
-0.5432736873626709,
-0.4704078733921051,
0.6152898073196411,
-0.8963989019393921,
-0.45810171961784363,
-0.48060670495033264,
-0.4575224816799164,
-0.5684318542480469,
0.2987629175186157,
0.3405906856060028,
0.14029084146022797,
-0.17099089920520782,
-0.2649594843387604,
0.5103346109390259,
-0.2645840048789978,
0.296362966299057,
0.5551885962486267,
-0.38107290863990784,
-0.7649010419845581,
0.7391718626022339,
-0.11411045491695404,
0.41190385818481445,
0.38038405776023865,
0.012379719875752926,
-0.33835408091545105,
-1.0802597999572754,
0.028817608952522278,
0.5209668874740601,
-0.47941380739212036,
-0.04235785827040672,
-0.536182701587677,
-0.2719881534576416,
-0.4569706320762634,
-0.3597027659416199,
-0.24828258156776428,
-0.42127594351768494,
-0.007118600886315107,
0.10913369059562683,
-0.13929344713687897,
0.5228447318077087,
-0.35259944200515747,
1.0949337482452393,
-1.305286169052124,
0.08638906478881836,
0.3973935544490814,
-0.03088877536356449,
-0.21750472486019135,
-0.48016852140426636,
-0.30584636330604553,
-0.06926725804805756,
-0.4473351538181305,
-0.8114129900932312,
0.38691791892051697,
0.05575136840343475,
0.9195326566696167,
0.5521498322486877,
-0.30639952421188354,
0.9170752167701721,
-0.35032919049263,
0.5229538083076477,
0.42023852467536926,
-0.8790125250816345,
0.6963860988616943,
-0.6519513726234436,
0.1287185698747635,
0.897547721862793,
0.6805222034454346,
-0.2991648316383362,
-0.48384472727775574,
-0.4677138030529022,
-0.9611528515815735,
0.5073519349098206,
0.3264842927455902,
-0.10863501578569412,
0.1823168247938156,
0.44554078578948975,
-0.16460153460502625,
0.3335377275943756,
-0.4922122061252594,
0.29840898513793945,
0.266777366399765,
-0.13510476052761078,
-0.33728089928627014,
0.07837481796741486,
-0.3483578860759735,
-0.35787320137023926,
0.5012429356575012,
-0.04681628942489624,
0.07990750670433044,
-0.30451229214668274,
-0.22404955327510834,
0.1605502963066101,
-0.10465096682310104,
0.1866503655910492,
0.4297488331794739,
-0.14251601696014404,
-0.25441214442253113,
0.32769396901130676,
-0.4045337736606598,
0.10553022474050522,
0.30139508843421936,
0.1448197215795517,
-0.3331035077571869,
0.44752073287963867,
0.5047338604927063,
0.34253355860710144,
-0.542500376701355,
0.5867035984992981,
-0.09128303080797195,
-0.34347280859947205,
-0.15290091931819916,
0.22050754725933075,
0.016585342586040497,
0.5695794820785522,
0.17872928082942963,
0.009218737483024597,
0.0633196234703064,
-0.527786910533905,
0.12928566336631775,
0.8044126033782959,
0.025533298030495644,
-0.1782839298248291,
0.5903775691986084,
0.11544633656740189,
0.3640999495983124,
0.9643513560295105,
-0.005449648480862379,
-0.9009254574775696,
0.3180050849914551,
0.2185726761817932,
0.9450796246528625,
-0.23027855157852173,
-0.13130958378314972,
0.49247464537620544,
0.30402857065200806,
-0.40042075514793396,
0.04547050595283508,
-0.4229981303215027,
-0.9884718656539917,
-0.853731095790863,
-0.6954318284988403,
-0.6395847797393799,
-0.11876566708087921,
-0.5156411528587341,
0.3849319517612457,
-0.5057581663131714,
-0.2668621242046356,
-0.49552205204963684,
0.16175003349781036,
-0.550403356552124,
0.1750200390815735,
0.2751949429512024,
0.451742023229599,
-0.8632113337516785,
1.0811173915863037,
0.4778369963169098,
-0.2977495789527893,
-0.7008247375488281,
0.17528127133846283,
-0.01580582745373249,
-0.9387595653533936,
0.5087969899177551,
0.37726783752441406,
0.02893868274986744,
0.02100229635834694,
-0.2982916235923767,
-0.908201277256012,
1.2093005180358887,
0.5062376856803894,
-0.8041150569915771,
-0.20958703756332397,
0.15676677227020264,
0.1604868620634079,
-0.3796702027320862,
-0.016172301024198532,
0.8475685119628906,
0.4434935450553894,
0.42533332109451294,
-0.8012170791625977,
0.0727245956659317,
-0.0020043919794261456,
0.040760692209005356,
0.4165816605091095,
-0.3808188736438751,
0.7152125835418701,
-0.24841710925102234,
-0.2842794954776764,
0.2929944694042206,
0.5349553227424622,
0.5911369919776917,
0.11535178869962692,
0.6149093508720398,
0.9833216071128845,
0.9104568362236023,
-0.22482329607009888,
0.7182390689849854,
-0.5413750410079956,
0.21743835508823395,
0.9639953970909119,
-0.2921055555343628,
0.6775249242782593,
0.45899301767349243,
-0.41501104831695557,
0.2644837200641632,
1.0536491870880127,
0.2613109052181244,
0.6782642602920532,
0.2122698575258255,
-0.7316864728927612,
-0.4937894940376282,
0.3344822824001312,
-0.5860859751701355,
-0.04210701212286949,
0.18687701225280762,
0.05652870237827301,
-0.23803755640983582,
-0.24014912545681,
0.01638680137693882,
-0.5026385188102722,
-0.10969898104667664,
0.8907126188278198,
-0.0010691398056223989,
-0.9608404636383057,
0.268235445022583,
-0.35944437980651855,
0.7350457310676575,
-0.9011465907096863,
0.3939965069293976,
-0.40859001874923706,
0.20238134264945984,
-0.06902450323104858,
-0.37708142399787903,
0.35022860765457153,
-0.22826780378818512,
0.18428044021129608,
-0.3921274244785309,
0.3864964246749878,
-0.5258927345275879,
-0.17022351920604706,
0.417370468378067,
0.5498445630073547,
0.34524276852607727,
-0.35833194851875305,
-0.45389845967292786,
0.11912006884813309,
-0.007138807792216539,
0.19220739603042603,
0.8319891095161438,
0.3148413896560669,
0.23554828763008118,
0.4587903916835785,
0.8336381316184998,
0.39086705446243286,
0.18717436492443085,
0.07184013724327087,
1.2506790161132812,
-0.6634179353713989,
-0.4840567409992218,
-0.7543790936470032,
0.46224814653396606,
0.09108906984329224,
-0.038597822189331055,
0.39566248655319214,
0.6903048753738403,
0.8560099601745605,
0.19321689009666443,
1.1201140880584717,
0.14969633519649506,
0.30585822463035583,
-0.8073639273643494,
0.5571842193603516,
-0.6139397025108337,
0.38604313135147095,
-0.3258269727230072,
-1.4704701900482178,
-0.10664141923189163,
0.677588164806366,
-0.45961758494377136,
0.28471803665161133,
0.8427419662475586,
0.9473744034767151,
-0.10877878963947296,
-0.28165334463119507,
0.2596151828765869,
-0.31312498450279236,
0.34119272232055664,
0.9660892486572266,
1.1298555135726929,
-0.08960097283124924,
0.5579320192337036,
-0.08413615822792053,
-0.6873587965965271,
-0.12597087025642395,
-0.8896195292472839,
-0.8537042140960693,
-0.5868178009986877,
-0.4201008379459381,
-0.340668261051178,
0.03292692080140114,
0.6603872776031494,
0.6735661625862122,
-0.528048574924469,
-0.3109837472438812,
-0.30541735887527466,
-0.1999640017747879,
0.04304395243525505,
-0.08302310854196548,
-0.08695068210363388,
-0.6919477581977844,
-0.8546342849731445,
0.5480616092681885,
0.2904922366142273,
0.37877190113067627,
-0.15770719945430756,
-0.2049858421087265,
0.13139478862285614,
0.03230193257331848,
0.17451930046081543,
0.29587557911872864,
-0.3265524208545685,
0.051345061510801315,
-0.3983977735042572,
-0.026317287236452103,
-0.19846324622631073,
1.1699564456939697,
-0.7139982581138611,
0.2760242521762848,
0.5651378035545349,
0.9566206336021423,
1.098612666130066,
0.032381098717451096,
0.9288793802261353,
-0.46444326639175415,
0.1627640724182129,
0.058560434728860855,
0.5157552361488342,
0.27149075269699097,
0.11571146547794342,
0.44255155324935913,
0.3740825057029724,
-0.7131593227386475,
-0.7151439189910889,
0.2785411775112152,
-1.201873779296875,
-0.07484384626150131,
0.842090904712677,
-0.11280317604541779,
0.251908540725708,
0.08051464706659317,
0.05386221408843994,
0.3103936016559601,
-0.14092181622982025,
0.5924060940742493,
0.8474211692810059,
-0.25304779410362244,
0.006372804753482342,
-0.33607959747314453,
0.3977854549884796,
0.6201296448707581,
-0.8937127590179443,
-0.19114290177822113,
0.5957937836647034,
0.2874318063259125,
-0.05025444179773331,
0.8525617122650146,
0.024785339832305908,
0.20000377297401428,
-0.08225089311599731,
-0.1251908391714096,
0.38647422194480896,
-0.315008282661438,
-0.3922106921672821,
-0.22927890717983246,
0.13659276068210602,
-0.14301876723766327
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19365v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19365v1
|
EthioMT: Parallel Corpus for Low-resource Ethiopian Languages
| 2024-03-28T12:26:45 | 2024-03-28T12:26:45 |
Atnafu Lambebo Tonja, Olga Kolesnikova, Alexander Gelbukh, Jugal Kalita
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent research in natural language processing (NLP) has achieved impressive
performance in tasks such as machine translation (MT), news classification, and
question-answering in high-resource languages. However, the performance of MT
leaves much to be desired for low-resource languages. This is due to the
smaller size of available parallel corpora in these languages, if such corpora
are available at all. NLP in Ethiopian languages suffers from the same issues
due to the unavailability of publicly accessible datasets for NLP tasks,
including MT. To help the research community and foster research for Ethiopian
languages, we introduce EthioMT -- a new parallel corpus for 15 languages. We
also create a new benchmark by collecting a dataset for better-researched
languages in Ethiopia. We evaluate the newly collected corpus and the benchmark
dataset for 23 Ethiopian languages using transformer and fine-tuning
approaches.
|
[
-0.7223867177963257,
-0.711430013179779,
0.3165523111820221,
0.30555620789527893,
-0.3256518840789795,
0.15825709700584412,
-0.678252100944519,
-0.728340744972229,
0.5958519577980042,
0.3440845310688019,
-0.30224812030792236,
-0.37499740719795227,
-0.8978742957115173,
0.46800553798675537,
-0.3386484682559967,
0.9487342834472656,
-0.2803686261177063,
-0.1387215554714203,
-0.09281961619853973,
-0.7288593053817749,
-0.5630066990852356,
-0.34581905603408813,
-0.8488526344299316,
0.22618317604064941,
0.6220090985298157,
0.8142086267471313,
0.6583501696586609,
0.8042510747909546,
0.5874977707862854,
0.256564736366272,
0.25848862528800964,
0.33722764253616333,
-0.12451615929603577,
0.18199333548545837,
-0.22460342943668365,
-0.1950615793466568,
-0.27678078413009644,
-0.49939584732055664,
0.6866450309753418,
0.9529564380645752,
-0.19221529364585876,
0.6628438830375671,
0.13069702684879303,
0.8616496324539185,
-0.589712917804718,
0.24106793105602264,
-0.5493190288543701,
-0.3006090521812439,
-0.9604968428611755,
0.21065281331539154,
-0.016622163355350494,
-0.3957527279853821,
-0.16674521565437317,
-0.4086952805519104,
0.2814909517765045,
0.434224396944046,
0.6138541102409363,
0.3532313406467438,
0.023350633680820465,
-0.12327326834201813,
-0.6594534516334534,
0.9318274259567261,
-0.4255119264125824,
0.2422971874475479,
0.7072442770004272,
0.5059782266616821,
0.32374322414398193,
-0.8613153696060181,
-0.49499934911727905,
-0.10478144139051437,
-0.09235405921936035,
-0.140986368060112,
0.02259676903486252,
-0.446386456489563,
0.22885632514953613,
0.3752160370349884,
-0.44970834255218506,
0.04702509194612503,
-0.3252628743648529,
-0.08816246688365936,
0.15813171863555908,
0.2762576937675476,
0.3741353452205658,
0.05327533930540085,
0.11851805448532104,
-0.013311590068042278,
-0.5727952122688293,
-0.12651990354061127,
0.27829331159591675,
0.4129507839679718,
-0.11427512019872665,
0.6599684953689575,
-0.37400367856025696,
0.6340115666389465,
-0.38451600074768066,
0.3031024932861328,
0.36205440759658813,
-0.053703173995018005,
-0.0425141341984272,
0.182143896818161,
0.6139587163925171,
0.09745782613754272,
-0.1137906089425087,
0.10442499816417694,
-0.26354923844337463,
0.09517248719930649,
0.2813211679458618,
-0.8275785446166992,
-0.04775797948241234,
0.11552431434392929,
-0.6038374900817871,
0.021310018375515938,
-0.25898346304893494,
-0.8664302229881287,
-0.054145876318216324,
-0.2572156488895416,
0.12544052302837372,
-0.6056927442550659,
-0.2623802721500397,
-0.12258991599082947,
0.11755498498678207,
-0.25235381722450256,
0.13915236294269562,
-1.1833642721176147,
0.8538609147071838,
0.7423267364501953,
1.0214219093322754,
-0.4831434488296509,
-0.525320291519165,
-0.5672720670700073,
0.02534603886306286,
-0.13478565216064453,
0.8318772315979004,
-0.6498247385025024,
0.033531226217746735,
0.14023829996585846,
0.09995938092470169,
-0.32168713212013245,
-0.7961931824684143,
1.3372952938079834,
-0.5294073820114136,
-0.23603582382202148,
-0.40223804116249084,
-0.31565532088279724,
-0.21210211515426636,
0.16485214233398438,
-0.9084315299987793,
1.0244884490966797,
0.2716573476791382,
-0.9188162684440613,
0.03353104367852211,
-0.7423214316368103,
-0.7459714412689209,
0.1749417632818222,
-0.1392648071050644,
-0.3527609705924988,
0.25475379824638367,
0.4440329074859619,
0.16055522859096527,
-0.803424596786499,
0.252803236246109,
-0.11912666261196136,
-0.3042886257171631,
-0.2108895629644394,
-0.31446167826652527,
0.8049585819244385,
0.6463887691497803,
-0.31938743591308594,
-0.2026115357875824,
-0.9498397707939148,
0.002327201422303915,
0.10421647131443024,
-0.1709144413471222,
-0.5154640674591064,
0.12306775897741318,
0.500140905380249,
-0.14165157079696655,
0.33671191334724426,
-0.780429482460022,
-0.183400958776474,
-0.1450442373752594,
0.42372480034828186,
0.2136809378862381,
-0.440798282623291,
0.2543967664241791,
-0.4576995372772217,
0.17669354379177094,
-0.09448820352554321,
0.035703856498003006,
0.02931436523795128,
-0.6559051871299744,
-1.0542786121368408,
-0.303803026676178,
0.43095406889915466,
0.42154571413993835,
-0.715850830078125,
0.07246237993240356,
-0.31101253628730774,
-0.40962234139442444,
-1.0037460327148438,
-0.08474433422088623,
0.018952922895550728,
0.5363247990608215,
0.7030898332595825,
-0.174929678440094,
-0.6708081364631653,
-1.2354403734207153,
-0.32173290848731995,
0.2320496290922165,
-0.25624191761016846,
0.09206143766641617,
0.4459468424320221,
-0.22275672852993011,
0.5083520412445068,
-0.39115557074546814,
-0.40968120098114014,
-0.3861406743526459,
0.296476811170578,
0.33210912346839905,
0.4911425709724426,
0.6369197368621826,
-0.7343268394470215,
-0.7737921476364136,
0.06165004521608353,
-0.45691248774528503,
-0.28835102915763855,
0.3977750837802887,
-0.011427059769630432,
0.3026576340198517,
0.2012312412261963,
-0.49763497710227966,
-0.08517657220363617,
0.6727446913719177,
0.18207696080207825,
0.25160837173461914,
-0.3107965290546417,
0.2724778950214386,
-0.8987603187561035,
0.21331451833248138,
-0.2759840786457062,
-0.22200654447078705,
-0.39599090814590454,
-0.039444442838430405,
0.24809323251247406,
-0.1435617059469223,
-0.45435917377471924,
0.3084537088871002,
-0.3350491225719452,
-0.05721931532025337,
-0.30838388204574585,
-0.07074911147356033,
-0.33392107486724854,
0.3307030498981476,
0.09733431786298752,
0.9030688405036926,
0.466060996055603,
-0.5722948908805847,
0.22770342230796814,
0.47443124651908875,
-0.6691910028457642,
0.6325910687446594,
-0.5680798292160034,
0.0911921039223671,
0.12659412622451782,
-0.12831823527812958,
-0.3164074420928955,
-0.39854228496551514,
-0.09906498342752457,
-0.1996459811925888,
0.38605231046676636,
0.1741323173046112,
-0.5772527456283569,
-0.2290380895137787,
-0.19191689789295197,
0.6533923149108887,
0.5187364220619202,
-0.5095796585083008,
0.29008185863494873,
0.6613865494728088,
-0.5612343549728394,
-0.5056573152542114,
-0.7880142331123352,
0.1582983136177063,
-0.17292018234729767,
-0.5960029363632202,
0.3457673490047455,
0.1293943077325821,
-0.2405865490436554,
0.0638865977525711,
0.15664973855018616,
-0.281038761138916,
-0.0036500212736427784,
-0.04051738604903221,
-0.01594812609255314,
-0.24781377613544464,
-0.0017515630461275578,
0.1440773755311966,
-0.22677165269851685,
-0.07307319343090057,
-0.3841884434223175,
0.7106751799583435,
-0.3513423204421997,
-0.3289930522441864,
-0.16579201817512512,
0.7240176796913147,
0.15283919870853424,
-0.3983393609523773,
1.0542793273925781,
0.7393589019775391,
-0.5001420378684998,
-0.19002220034599304,
-0.6339384317398071,
0.1488785743713379,
-0.38436028361320496,
0.2518651485443115,
-0.43955275416374207,
-0.9026250243186951,
0.5142216682434082,
-0.2322622835636139,
0.08631134778261185,
0.797065019607544,
0.8851476311683655,
-0.06466314196586609,
0.6432279944419861,
0.7928509712219238,
-0.21569575369358063,
0.2009178102016449,
-0.009968305006623268,
0.050589632242918015,
-0.8312094211578369,
0.01855579949915409,
-1.0032416582107544,
-0.40943777561187744,
-0.9129219055175781,
-0.2889689803123474,
0.07737953960895538,
-0.20668257772922516,
-0.2312089502811432,
0.8589813113212585,
-0.4037664234638214,
0.33834293484687805,
0.7563360929489136,
-0.1556241661310196,
0.4511999487876892,
0.06256356090307236,
-0.21617794036865234,
-0.17143221199512482,
-0.7008317112922668,
-0.6518662571907043,
0.9201800227165222,
0.036056045442819595,
0.33738550543785095,
0.009250006638467312,
0.7281317710876465,
0.23721781373023987,
0.36490240693092346,
-0.39737632870674133,
0.29270729422569275,
-0.20805005729198456,
-0.6442795991897583,
-0.22240975499153137,
-0.3651887774467468,
-0.9505395889282227,
0.09334725141525269,
0.007954245433211327,
-0.6583126187324524,
0.1618797332048416,
-0.1678955852985382,
-0.22817301750183105,
0.3526284992694855,
-0.4804885685443878,
0.8281873464584351,
0.060808319598436356,
-0.3453434705734253,
-0.5668180584907532,
-0.6634262204170227,
0.16361522674560547,
-0.4358580410480499,
0.5263489484786987,
-0.4062865376472473,
-0.08738668262958527,
0.7413935661315918,
-0.6123278737068176,
0.3737999200820923,
0.10829741507768631,
0.32399043440818787,
0.33560729026794434,
0.06917822360992432,
0.5252664089202881,
0.07807078957557678,
-0.3879398703575134,
0.6122317314147949,
0.06955907493829727,
-0.6122342944145203,
0.08059201389551163,
0.9134388566017151,
-0.7419843673706055,
-0.3133751451969147,
-0.30584606528282166,
-0.5978452563285828,
-0.2671367824077606,
0.20016102492809296,
0.413284033536911,
0.1728045642375946,
-0.40251249074935913,
0.16956715285778046,
0.2855697572231293,
-0.39004606008529663,
0.46824970841407776,
0.3424016237258911,
0.1907665729522705,
-0.48700276017189026,
1.0563241243362427,
0.2812632918357849,
0.008029828779399395,
0.40275490283966064,
0.020591333508491516,
-0.09954892098903656,
-0.6736965179443359,
-0.7085817456245422,
-0.031862348318099976,
-0.32062023878097534,
-0.13173505663871765,
-0.8049086332321167,
0.07800664007663727,
-0.17301082611083984,
0.049332115799188614,
-0.487345814704895,
-0.8752947449684143,
0.2030925303697586,
0.0557372160255909,
0.3181183934211731,
0.41967296600341797,
-0.29974761605262756,
0.20325565338134766,
-1.0878329277038574,
0.5697751045227051,
0.043546319007873535,
0.4777415990829468,
-0.1994621753692627,
-0.34688273072242737,
-0.6146409511566162,
-0.07628756016492844,
-0.22839932143688202,
-0.4368680715560913,
0.4488967955112457,
0.2757855951786041,
0.40157508850097656,
0.0035669750068336725,
0.2988893389701843,
0.3812839686870575,
-0.9183183312416077,
0.5156311392784119,
0.05982847884297371,
-0.7724962830543518,
0.41614508628845215,
-0.44523435831069946,
0.08574391156435013,
0.9876708388328552,
0.4504246115684509,
-0.7165428996086121,
-0.4140421152114868,
-0.5401182174682617,
-0.8318609595298767,
0.9209840297698975,
0.6829895377159119,
0.07384708523750305,
-0.24798543751239777,
-0.11250749230384827,
0.48097893595695496,
0.5071781873703003,
-0.05484673008322716,
-0.4372524917125702,
-0.08617423474788666,
-0.3319723308086395,
-0.0448734275996685,
-0.21221193671226501,
-0.0981733649969101,
-0.3623647391796112,
0.5514616370201111,
0.031858913600444794,
0.3375902771949768,
-0.03107648342847824,
-0.310168594121933,
-0.28950369358062744,
0.29203906655311584,
0.36143404245376587,
0.4310306906700134,
-0.34262314438819885,
0.29583242535591125,
0.46585404872894287,
-0.7519332766532898,
-0.12768276035785675,
0.426897794008255,
-0.42414379119873047,
0.24299006164073944,
0.20128925144672394,
0.667212724685669,
-0.15211698412895203,
-0.5421704649925232,
0.18505734205245972,
-0.0028465422801673412,
0.10676548629999161,
-0.29899224638938904,
-0.2864626348018646,
0.3206290006637573,
0.09267834573984146,
0.17273485660552979,
0.37964335083961487,
0.3059905171394348,
-0.4967733323574066,
0.11655192077159882,
-0.00664738891646266,
-0.15960267186164856,
-0.26421844959259033,
0.8804476261138916,
0.3536728620529175,
-0.38650190830230713,
0.702930212020874,
-0.018461288884282112,
-0.32724347710609436,
0.7417511940002441,
0.48234522342681885,
0.9775497317314148,
-0.12503936886787415,
0.07304883003234863,
0.5495668053627014,
0.45322731137275696,
-0.2875155210494995,
0.3168533146381378,
-0.11850419640541077,
-0.6384226679801941,
-0.4563978612422943,
-0.910614550113678,
-0.6886369585990906,
0.005708880722522736,
-0.6549201607704163,
0.28795668482780457,
-0.21546389162540436,
-0.16633205115795135,
-0.006073374301195145,
-0.02337959222495556,
-0.9001825451850891,
0.002329183043912053,
0.11901501566171646,
0.8446058630943298,
-0.48679956793785095,
1.136423110961914,
0.653057336807251,
-0.30788493156433105,
-0.28144484758377075,
-0.1926412284374237,
-0.253341406583786,
-0.8124627470970154,
0.5474461913108826,
0.23498381674289703,
-0.004174460656940937,
0.13754093647003174,
-0.23527656495571136,
-0.6800877451896667,
0.6514472961425781,
0.6331654787063599,
-0.7087007164955139,
0.509417712688446,
0.7007166147232056,
0.46523940563201904,
-0.17202067375183105,
0.37612777948379517,
0.7281156182289124,
0.842143714427948,
-0.5706636309623718,
-0.9192948341369629,
0.03110945038497448,
-0.22888657450675964,
0.008874425664544106,
0.4808714687824249,
-0.8226861953735352,
0.8306670784950256,
-0.036324892193078995,
-0.279496431350708,
0.13479280471801758,
0.7173269391059875,
-0.08110443502664566,
0.393400639295578,
0.41265735030174255,
0.6811270117759705,
0.6574899554252625,
-0.24548107385635376,
1.0942775011062622,
-0.39231523871421814,
0.21046046912670135,
1.152415156364441,
-0.27022314071655273,
1.0058200359344482,
0.47114914655685425,
-0.2851005494594574,
0.30809885263442993,
0.587548553943634,
0.14011149108409882,
0.5678119659423828,
0.035345450043678284,
-0.3179978132247925,
-0.13259561359882355,
-0.33552268147468567,
-0.3402288854122162,
0.01199098490178585,
0.3630073666572571,
0.081874780356884,
-0.34186872839927673,
0.040562067180871964,
-0.14699286222457886,
0.2882426977157593,
-0.16937504708766937,
0.3639673590660095,
0.39609605073928833,
-0.487575501203537,
0.5580019354820251,
0.25039562582969666,
0.681549608707428,
-0.45506447553634644,
0.08874780684709549,
-0.30277442932128906,
0.24736478924751282,
-0.13479916751384735,
-0.5588626265525818,
1.0198098421096802,
0.1702672839164734,
-0.03925362974405289,
-0.06315923482179642,
0.6625806093215942,
-0.3234764635562897,
-0.36172205209732056,
0.39982688426971436,
0.6772275567054749,
0.21466882526874542,
-0.2059861421585083,
-0.4160839021205902,
0.025791654363274574,
-0.29991260170936584,
-0.2465769201517105,
0.4397100806236267,
0.5371681451797485,
-0.2666965126991272,
0.4247038662433624,
0.6198452711105347,
0.08237235993146896,
0.00758559862151742,
0.19489246606826782,
0.7070087194442749,
-0.6926572322845459,
-0.09208552539348602,
-0.819572389125824,
-0.005379716400057077,
-0.16639047861099243,
-0.3113412857055664,
0.774562656879425,
0.8074455857276917,
1.0761120319366455,
-0.18592849373817444,
0.7510706186294556,
-0.4909859597682953,
0.9399283528327942,
-0.1109195128083229,
0.782055139541626,
-0.44060447812080383,
0.05170602351427078,
-0.00551907392218709,
-1.1842018365859985,
-0.25041863322257996,
0.37765997648239136,
-0.09088819473981857,
-0.4494262635707855,
1.0852057933807373,
0.3779991865158081,
-0.14992287755012512,
0.28675249218940735,
0.34438052773475647,
0.05782105401158333,
-0.10052786767482758,
0.48254987597465515,
0.7504537105560303,
-0.46721452474594116,
0.4810905158519745,
-0.5841601490974426,
-0.07687465846538544,
-0.15206903219223022,
-0.7526417374610901,
-0.6853235960006714,
-0.5937439203262329,
0.025943996384739876,
0.1545938104391098,
0.014025161042809486,
1.0793218612670898,
0.3217138648033142,
-1.278531551361084,
-0.33797386288642883,
-0.09270033240318298,
-0.07639610767364502,
-0.6376647353172302,
-0.08588766306638718,
0.548761248588562,
-0.5123996734619141,
-1.0944210290908813,
0.4045972228050232,
0.16827097535133362,
-0.434082567691803,
0.24152539670467377,
0.049303993582725525,
-0.08552373945713043,
-0.22229211032390594,
0.644140362739563,
0.3570534288883209,
-0.04076530411839485,
0.009604256600141525,
-0.16766288876533508,
-0.21614401042461395,
0.24315212666988373,
0.7935020923614502,
-0.55612713098526,
-0.013031845912337303,
0.6105256676673889,
1.0425692796707153,
0.8135044574737549,
-0.3922341763973236,
0.49205708503723145,
-0.5295615196228027,
0.39780521392822266,
0.31857237219810486,
0.6612053513526917,
0.43052858114242554,
-0.011765784583985806,
0.8035153150558472,
0.20989039540290833,
-0.5926189422607422,
-0.5287293195724487,
0.10139671713113785,
-0.9477970004081726,
0.05747992545366287,
0.71474689245224,
0.09751885384321213,
-0.31188055872917175,
-0.41355812549591064,
-0.2175544649362564,
0.4759413003921509,
-0.5899930596351624,
0.8120508790016174,
0.6018170118331909,
0.13951219618320465,
0.006568186450749636,
-1.2902703285217285,
0.5358981490135193,
0.5984057188034058,
-1.079653024673462,
0.12018009275197983,
0.23202569782733917,
0.08238758891820908,
0.2746184170246124,
0.6045429110527039,
-0.0783657506108284,
-0.15267620980739594,
0.11485544592142105,
-0.03989769518375397,
-0.04168408364057541,
-0.14963670074939728,
0.07699809223413467,
0.13701876997947693,
0.1457708775997162,
-0.4220612347126007
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19358v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19358v1
|
Risk prediction of pathological gambling on social media
| 2024-03-28T12:17:36 | 2024-03-28T12:17:36 |
Angelina Parfenova, Marianne Clausel
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper addresses the problem of risk prediction on social media data,
specifically focusing on the classification of Reddit users as having a
pathological gambling disorder. To tackle this problem, this paper focuses on
incorporating temporal and emotional features into the model. The preprocessing
phase involves dealing with the time irregularity of posts by padding
sequences. Two baseline architectures are used for preliminary evaluation: BERT
classifier on concatenated posts per user and GRU with LSTM on sequential data.
Experimental results demonstrate that the sequential models outperform the
concatenation-based model. The results of the experiments conclude that the
incorporation of a time decay layer (TD) and passing the emotion classification
layer (EmoBERTa) through LSTM improves the performance significantly.
Experiments concluded that the addition of a self-attention layer didn't
significantly improve the performance of the model, however provided easily
interpretable attention scores. The developed architecture with the inclusion
of EmoBERTa and TD layers achieved a high F1 score, beating existing benchmarks
on pathological gambling dataset. Future work may involve the early prediction
of risk factors associated with pathological gambling disorder and testing
models on other datasets. Overall, this research highlights the significance of
the sequential processing of posts including temporal and emotional features to
boost the predictive power, as well as adding an attention layer for
interpretability.
|
[
-0.07955727726221085,
-0.9841665625572205,
0.4093647003173828,
0.6316599249839783,
-0.5276432037353516,
0.1250021904706955,
0.0877087414264679,
-0.946833610534668,
0.6832559704780579,
0.5504432320594788,
-0.4594413936138153,
-0.4528377950191498,
-0.773527979850769,
-0.2760131061077118,
-0.1381797343492508,
1.1188547611236572,
0.023095974698662758,
0.03141589090228081,
0.12323899567127228,
0.06630963832139969,
-0.44027408957481384,
-0.6991544961929321,
-1.0426920652389526,
-0.18645966053009033,
0.6381134986877441,
-0.028726976364850998,
0.5581148266792297,
0.6033859252929688,
0.7623007893562317,
0.27845585346221924,
0.17182272672653198,
-0.3880764842033386,
-0.5759838223457336,
0.136198490858078,
-0.050389524549245834,
-0.16855835914611816,
-0.7052300572395325,
-0.16834646463394165,
0.17700998485088348,
-0.005409774836152792,
-0.29129481315612793,
0.304341584444046,
-0.019868234172463417,
0.5275392532348633,
-0.33442795276641846,
0.06510134786367416,
-0.44731491804122925,
0.38531407713890076,
-0.6068856716156006,
-0.9979692697525024,
-0.3698010742664337,
-0.5692715048789978,
0.2789219617843628,
-0.4607343077659607,
0.06265982985496521,
-0.0957183986902237,
0.40086865425109863,
0.40649139881134033,
-0.39534610509872437,
-0.1472272276878357,
-1.0438404083251953,
0.18272969126701355,
-0.3850882351398468,
0.18965421617031097,
0.4024403393268585,
0.4808609187602997,
-0.033314768224954605,
-0.3772031366825104,
-0.16411423683166504,
-0.027694715186953545,
-0.11678017675876617,
-0.03544469177722931,
-0.21106122434139252,
0.1809968203306198,
0.24615329504013062,
-0.06906718760728836,
-0.4274737536907196,
-0.06108690798282623,
-0.5885351896286011,
-0.21087664365768433,
0.8843981623649597,
0.36533766984939575,
0.20115631818771362,
-0.11835062503814697,
-0.2893868088722229,
0.22581593692302704,
-0.35042333602905273,
0.3344217836856842,
0.539392352104187,
0.16239361464977264,
-0.17538827657699585,
0.513943612575531,
0.10999823361635208,
0.29630136489868164,
0.3841427266597748,
-0.18522252142429352,
0.36357805132865906,
-0.014055813662707806,
-0.05979560688138008,
0.3700625002384186,
0.6442446708679199,
0.5184425115585327,
0.4509252905845642,
0.06075337529182434,
0.04439370334148407,
0.341633141040802,
0.5844686627388,
-0.6276291012763977,
-0.2532358169555664,
0.6922818422317505,
-0.6798583269119263,
-0.6786249279975891,
-0.21777361631393433,
-0.9275796413421631,
-0.6083593368530273,
0.013001999817788601,
0.4500199556350708,
-0.6069894433021545,
-0.07240022718906403,
0.2963566780090332,
0.062096208333969116,
-0.40800461173057556,
0.3712673783302307,
-0.5339634418487549,
0.31315523386001587,
0.5508306622505188,
0.6791346073150635,
-0.0959179624915123,
-0.03162335231900215,
-0.6325306296348572,
0.26608017086982727,
-0.024185597896575928,
0.8393976092338562,
-0.5166360139846802,
-0.2023208886384964,
0.2244952768087387,
0.10711304843425751,
0.1905522644519806,
0.11125510185956955,
0.6764373183250427,
-0.700671911239624,
-0.23652920126914978,
0.05370911583304405,
-0.48227065801620483,
-0.1666143387556076,
0.2097887396812439,
-0.8409169912338257,
0.7316802144050598,
-0.27433791756629944,
-1.12791907787323,
0.570036768913269,
-0.46611055731773376,
-0.8176111578941345,
0.2497032731771469,
0.1931118667125702,
-0.5779414176940918,
0.10102909803390503,
-0.04676898941397667,
0.6339030265808105,
0.37415385246276855,
0.25186657905578613,
-0.8402095437049866,
-0.5136840343475342,
0.46112197637557983,
-0.10258638858795166,
0.1208447739481926,
0.1301770955324173,
-0.29396265745162964,
0.14902925491333008,
-0.6442320346832275,
-0.11302174627780914,
-0.07814227044582367,
-0.07703779637813568,
-0.5739014744758606,
0.4285394251346588,
0.2878980338573456,
0.5623186826705933,
0.015854496508836746,
-0.5657121539115906,
-0.10781948268413544,
-0.17669300734996796,
0.3041260540485382,
0.851483941078186,
0.4375171363353729,
0.08163142204284668,
-0.34743544459342957,
0.5860608220100403,
0.232193261384964,
0.32813626527786255,
0.45949944853782654,
-0.28910937905311584,
-0.23640061914920807,
0.24594010412693024,
0.18196910619735718,
0.8856344819068909,
-0.5766326189041138,
0.316906601190567,
-0.17363490164279938,
-0.7239037752151489,
-0.27411171793937683,
-0.20264022052288055,
0.3523525297641754,
0.03144196420907974,
0.23387853801250458,
-0.47755247354507446,
-0.6304121613502502,
-0.42429637908935547,
-0.25941309332847595,
-0.09653806686401367,
0.2258041352033615,
0.43772295117378235,
0.20363761484622955,
-0.12546998262405396,
0.13358551263809204,
-0.3908352255821228,
-0.5505977869033813,
0.11090869456529617,
0.45506829023361206,
0.07463574409484863,
0.35894083976745605,
0.445798397064209,
-0.5811588168144226,
-0.571861743927002,
-0.024767158553004265,
-0.5815243721008301,
0.3449549973011017,
-0.10575682669878006,
-0.0524275004863739,
0.26441115140914917,
0.3947557210922241,
-0.36377573013305664,
0.7435528039932251,
0.2467116266489029,
-0.6707423329353333,
0.3600162863731384,
-0.16758698225021362,
0.43496349453926086,
-0.7031154036521912,
-0.04849217087030411,
0.43330782651901245,
-0.19553986191749573,
-0.7036058306694031,
-0.559232234954834,
-0.3136443495750427,
0.05257393419742584,
-0.34148460626602173,
0.5708608627319336,
-0.13108700513839722,
-0.17063866555690765,
-0.13518336415290833,
-0.13558165729045868,
-0.5523192286491394,
0.35071974992752075,
0.1540415734052658,
0.08772606402635574,
0.4760280251502991,
-0.4237881004810333,
0.19147726893424988,
-0.19697554409503937,
-0.4562787413597107,
0.4342038333415985,
-0.7669627666473389,
0.03886488080024719,
-0.3004991412162781,
0.07359755039215088,
-1.0216118097305298,
-0.3368290364742279,
0.3849724233150482,
-0.7922793626785278,
0.31154122948646545,
0.023229805752635002,
-0.17224028706550598,
-0.5309141874313354,
-0.4856431782245636,
0.38788366317749023,
0.3931300938129425,
0.2578429877758026,
0.6254836320877075,
0.6552939414978027,
-0.2946065664291382,
-0.6232706308364868,
-0.46888941526412964,
-0.24657860398292542,
-0.5808649063110352,
-0.7797242403030396,
0.5165334343910217,
0.18980441987514496,
-0.20595721900463104,
0.3019134998321533,
0.34470993280410767,
0.20308305323123932,
0.08196495473384857,
0.5050441026687622,
0.032165780663490295,
0.09748376160860062,
0.5055105090141296,
-0.16849789023399353,
-0.1678493320941925,
0.18238075077533722,
0.15227650105953217,
0.4596003592014313,
0.21915195882320404,
0.11616300791501999,
-0.5158808827400208,
0.3823819160461426,
0.24867703020572662,
-0.02159588597714901,
0.7943858504295349,
0.708289623260498,
-0.6743853092193604,
-0.26165395975112915,
-0.6213282942771912,
-0.24336913228034973,
-0.4418755769729614,
0.23270748555660248,
-0.14284536242485046,
-0.8978877663612366,
0.8604735136032104,
0.4805682897567749,
-0.14996303617954254,
0.3861299753189087,
0.5745205879211426,
-0.5516822934150696,
0.9124060273170471,
0.6159083843231201,
-0.037117328494787216,
0.7207468748092651,
0.2628428637981415,
-0.08173588663339615,
-0.18038851022720337,
-0.21398359537124634,
-0.09074258804321289,
-0.5399647951126099,
-0.9586016535758972,
-0.45418551564216614,
0.28887665271759033,
-0.4376664459705353,
-0.2566569149494171,
-0.06551261246204376,
-0.2675095200538635,
0.23442059755325317,
0.24351216852664948,
0.8065006136894226,
0.06952377408742905,
0.14591729640960693,
0.28927484154701233,
-0.32113590836524963,
-0.358605295419693,
-0.3377440273761749,
1.3746293783187866,
0.5851609110832214,
0.8870287537574768,
0.0036143360193818808,
0.722170352935791,
0.9974042177200317,
0.5671645402908325,
-0.39349302649497986,
0.20950250327587128,
-0.5040366649627686,
-0.8898555636405945,
-0.43292033672332764,
-0.1734633892774582,
-0.6425906419754028,
-0.3432370126247406,
-0.5754561424255371,
-0.8543297052383423,
0.25232991576194763,
0.5271868109703064,
-1.0589064359664917,
0.3287402093410492,
-0.38150185346603394,
0.8828896880149841,
-0.542884886264801,
-0.6153478026390076,
-0.3179362416267395,
-0.8478755354881287,
0.5810442566871643,
-0.192612424492836,
0.33517393469810486,
-0.19433847069740295,
0.20882758498191833,
0.883152186870575,
-0.25324463844299316,
1.0122838020324707,
-0.10704445093870163,
0.3361884355545044,
0.1575125902891159,
0.2102636694908142,
0.523344874382019,
0.14591693878173828,
0.10545768588781357,
-0.016809755936264992,
-0.00808833446353674,
-0.25138890743255615,
-0.3689608573913574,
0.6756926774978638,
-0.8424698114395142,
-0.3552038371562958,
-0.7394280433654785,
-0.09288521856069565,
-0.3233990967273712,
-0.24118675291538239,
0.070029616355896,
0.2313210666179657,
-0.3250475227832794,
0.05183248966932297,
0.6737245321273804,
-0.12417799234390259,
0.23455220460891724,
0.1805885136127472,
-0.012425857596099377,
-0.5577520728111267,
0.6992416381835938,
-0.030593324452638626,
-0.09349051862955093,
0.32369866967201233,
0.10300684720277786,
-0.2475392073392868,
-0.4654926061630249,
0.2530782222747803,
0.30116331577301025,
-0.5161178708076477,
-0.07350961863994598,
-0.7920039296150208,
-0.2994794249534607,
-0.4676095247268677,
-0.13909906148910522,
-0.2360546588897705,
-0.09943837672472,
-0.30878376960754395,
-0.36462992429733276,
0.5960118174552917,
0.8154550790786743,
-0.2741348445415497,
0.5182875990867615,
-0.8486557602882385,
0.0452931709587574,
0.07756609469652176,
0.5543188452720642,
0.1821378916501999,
-0.3696376383304596,
-0.15290214121341705,
-0.3583691716194153,
-0.28274837136268616,
-1.0689659118652344,
0.4442061185836792,
-0.004333874210715294,
0.44601067900657654,
0.8174722194671631,
-0.03888801112771034,
0.7463982701301575,
-0.4821430742740631,
0.10886190831661224,
0.11523296684026718,
-0.554309606552124,
0.6166790127754211,
-0.516238808631897,
-0.37640735507011414,
0.6630709171295166,
0.8338985443115234,
-0.7812963128089905,
-0.09272701293230057,
-0.741849958896637,
-0.39388126134872437,
0.623282253742218,
0.08758758753538132,
-0.1956983357667923,
0.0664278119802475,
0.5365272760391235,
0.14869564771652222,
0.05407773330807686,
-0.9718866348266602,
-0.17007611691951752,
-0.056611962616443634,
0.027769099920988083,
-0.4196118712425232,
-0.7499106526374817,
0.0071664354763925076,
-0.243991419672966,
0.45681944489479065,
0.35085344314575195,
0.3185802400112152,
0.17252133786678314,
0.17172104120254517,
-0.7109712362289429,
-0.032721005380153656,
0.43124955892562866,
0.4482073187828064,
-0.7300850749015808,
-0.010781372897326946,
-0.1659439504146576,
-0.36226609349250793,
0.2538449466228485,
0.3477477729320526,
0.04349573701620102,
-0.052408862859010696,
0.5757032632827759,
0.6233134269714355,
0.4316454529762268,
-0.353583961725235,
0.314168781042099,
0.028242915868759155,
-0.03206806629896164,
-0.5657922029495239,
-0.1815589815378189,
0.015989083796739578,
0.41260746121406555,
0.10843029618263245,
0.06237807497382164,
0.25019824504852295,
-0.6127396821975708,
0.6364650726318359,
0.1300640106201172,
-0.5882323980331421,
-0.5922866463661194,
0.8006016612052917,
0.46889880299568176,
-0.3298887312412262,
0.28045788407325745,
-0.22809380292892456,
-0.5346812605857849,
0.5963643789291382,
0.10029379278421402,
0.9662878513336182,
-0.5568344593048096,
0.4106457233428955,
0.6232569217681885,
0.34658893942832947,
0.10647346079349518,
0.7591617107391357,
0.3962792158126831,
-0.5922190546989441,
-0.29306167364120483,
-0.6962215900421143,
-0.026220830157399178,
0.08522111177444458,
-0.37035149335861206,
0.4948773682117462,
-0.6061456203460693,
-0.7129708528518677,
0.16157664358615875,
0.05537181347608566,
-0.5833048820495605,
0.3757632374763489,
0.25175637006759644,
0.6417464017868042,
-1.1290959119796753,
0.6453496813774109,
0.5298320651054382,
-0.1104528158903122,
-0.5606967210769653,
-0.08922313153743744,
0.0992206335067749,
-0.5154632925987244,
0.5350418090820312,
0.15566273033618927,
0.2867204248905182,
-0.4346781075000763,
-0.21131324768066406,
-0.7789285182952881,
0.8983432650566101,
-0.3037409782409668,
-0.4620656371116638,
-0.1289985179901123,
0.056603867560625076,
0.865200936794281,
-0.4392032027244568,
-0.05551834776997566,
0.2899355888366699,
0.13146573305130005,
0.5869664549827576,
-0.5692980885505676,
0.17724080383777618,
-0.23021376132965088,
-0.10565709322690964,
0.3559647500514984,
-0.20391061902046204,
0.7878891229629517,
-0.4084806442260742,
-0.43774688243865967,
-0.4313819110393524,
0.4851149618625641,
0.356494665145874,
0.5339927077293396,
0.46717754006385803,
0.5999151468276978,
0.32783523201942444,
-0.04134305194020271,
1.0332636833190918,
-0.31687411665916443,
0.21612419188022614,
1.14655339717865,
-0.18507784605026245,
0.9269347786903381,
0.27263063192367554,
-0.25049495697021484,
0.3656853437423706,
1.3219974040985107,
0.1897755265235901,
0.6672665476799011,
0.22723063826560974,
0.12786896526813507,
-0.3622180223464966,
0.06871616095304489,
-0.5959136486053467,
0.40729233622550964,
0.5250549912452698,
-0.593054473400116,
-0.08316412568092346,
0.025913072749972343,
-0.10897956043481827,
-0.20747292041778564,
-0.46434441208839417,
0.5613183379173279,
-0.015048719942569733,
-0.41775256395339966,
-0.30763354897499084,
-0.13393083214759827,
0.8114197850227356,
-0.4963831305503845,
-0.008400552906095982,
-0.18055172264575958,
0.4136415123939514,
-0.11505488306283951,
-0.9039941430091858,
0.6184576749801636,
-0.32651036977767944,
0.21176542341709137,
-0.03851843997836113,
1.1165711879730225,
-0.4395526945590973,
-0.9307774305343628,
0.43083620071411133,
0.24074670672416687,
0.16827018558979034,
-0.13627834618091583,
-0.6920368075370789,
-0.024704495444893837,
-0.25982969999313354,
-0.30421769618988037,
0.09123092144727707,
0.7184270024299622,
-0.10646812617778778,
0.7264214754104614,
0.5231629610061646,
0.3185216188430786,
-0.07893750071525574,
-0.24860233068466187,
0.7160041332244873,
-0.9057883024215698,
-0.8784908652305603,
-1.011109709739685,
0.5695620179176331,
0.013712513260543346,
-0.35052990913391113,
0.4800947308540344,
0.10128113627433777,
0.45285752415657043,
-0.084448903799057,
0.42280369997024536,
-0.04222027584910393,
0.3601920008659363,
-0.3735101819038391,
0.9103525280952454,
-0.6163334846496582,
-0.07753321528434753,
-0.5531104207038879,
-0.4100345969200134,
-0.1975475549697876,
0.1809515804052353,
-0.5214943289756775,
0.06749983876943588,
0.42879238724708557,
0.17410162091255188,
0.3139408230781555,
-0.18410299718379974,
0.1331472396850586,
0.22900813817977905,
0.00506186718121171,
0.8575587868690491,
0.5579620003700256,
-0.21679876744747162,
0.3316866159439087,
-0.5920475125312805,
-0.30394092202186584,
-0.7655261754989624,
-0.9552255868911743,
-1.1419789791107178,
-0.44912806153297424,
-0.20939601957798004,
-0.6886327862739563,
0.27859023213386536,
0.5830997824668884,
0.3377431333065033,
-0.7923687696456909,
-0.15742096304893494,
0.4667464792728424,
0.0018756460631266236,
-0.1616126298904419,
-0.2148040384054184,
0.4115842580795288,
0.12442395091056824,
-0.12023492157459259,
-0.5946852564811707,
0.3246137201786041,
0.23699167370796204,
-0.26823681592941284,
0.22798271477222443,
-0.38224706053733826,
0.027465561404824257,
0.5993782877922058,
0.14927756786346436,
-0.5666846036911011,
-0.43694207072257996,
0.1342819780111313,
-0.2170814722776413,
-0.08906368911266327,
0.6342280507087708,
-0.3259126842021942,
0.4204442501068115,
0.4795331358909607,
0.19349715113639832,
0.6076477766036987,
0.23739631474018097,
0.5920453667640686,
-0.35886162519454956,
0.10561563819646835,
0.41088011860847473,
0.3790712356567383,
-0.10778743773698807,
-0.9586079716682434,
0.5332812666893005,
0.2745389938354492,
-0.3243798315525055,
-0.5380135774612427,
-0.3620717525482178,
-1.1649096012115479,
-0.019381046295166016,
0.9821100831031799,
-0.03473407030105591,
-0.3795117437839508,
-0.15080203115940094,
0.09225808084011078,
0.2656431794166565,
-0.5126420855522156,
1.252058744430542,
0.9202591776847839,
-0.39304742217063904,
-0.07657462358474731,
-0.5690400004386902,
0.9519534111022949,
-0.02699395641684532,
-0.8309780955314636,
-0.05498746410012245,
0.2432146519422531,
0.31000420451164246,
0.20820054411888123,
0.8221767544746399,
-0.09725461900234222,
0.6916166543960571,
0.07999446988105774,
0.08197572827339172,
0.0625850260257721,
-0.3062889277935028,
-0.23284895718097687,
0.314609169960022,
-0.47491657733917236,
-0.02172660268843174
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19354v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19354v1
|
AIpom at SemEval-2024 Task 8: Detecting AI-produced Outputs in M4
| 2024-03-28T12:10:30 | 2024-03-28T12:10:30 |
Alexander Shirnin, Nikita Andreev, Vladislav Mikhailov, Ekaterina Artemova
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper describes AIpom, a system designed to detect a boundary between
human-written and machine-generated text (SemEval-2024 Task 8, Subtask C:
Human-Machine Mixed Text Detection). We propose a two-stage pipeline combining
predictions from an instruction-tuned decoder-only model and encoder-only
sequence taggers. AIpom is ranked second on the leaderboard while achieving a
Mean Absolute Error of 15.94. Ablation studies confirm the benefits of
pipelining encoder and decoder models, particularly in terms of improved
performance.
|
[
-0.4470120966434479,
-0.45843446254730225,
0.47979339957237244,
-0.018545284867286682,
-0.4714985489845276,
0.08115163445472717,
0.4143602252006531,
-0.6395191550254822,
-0.005117469467222691,
0.8408772349357605,
-0.5051107406616211,
-0.45442089438438416,
-0.96163409948349,
0.5282544493675232,
-0.6239808201789856,
0.5415937304496765,
0.030084801837801933,
-0.09640167653560638,
-0.32831451296806335,
0.2804463505744934,
-0.4683603048324585,
-0.6555207967758179,
-0.6397172212600708,
-0.7136957049369812,
0.011912494897842407,
0.6509377360343933,
0.37794309854507446,
0.9638471603393555,
0.5582396984100342,
0.2732962369918823,
0.19699455797672272,
0.5412309765815735,
0.07111959904432297,
0.16818416118621826,
0.07355577498674393,
-0.35094308853149414,
-0.5062217712402344,
0.13183504343032837,
0.6757888793945312,
0.05927002429962158,
0.15635767579078674,
-0.007908280938863754,
0.22116351127624512,
0.3125356435775757,
-0.4828399121761322,
0.02699819952249527,
-0.5354132652282715,
0.06977469474077225,
-0.23697930574417114,
-0.6278836727142334,
-0.7119051814079285,
0.05059684067964554,
-0.4137308895587921,
-0.14282070100307465,
0.02702461928129196,
0.2894657850265503,
0.7135632038116455,
0.5702077150344849,
-0.5832592844963074,
-0.5536002516746521,
-0.6451688408851624,
0.6663339138031006,
-0.8230396509170532,
0.2009636014699936,
0.49106407165527344,
-0.12372321635484695,
-0.25475454330444336,
-0.6391338109970093,
-0.5176131725311279,
0.344772070646286,
-0.07328884303569794,
0.2496892660856247,
-0.15658198297023773,
0.21165654063224792,
0.17294611036777496,
0.1554701328277588,
-0.4089002311229706,
0.2355463206768036,
-0.4489946961402893,
-0.5080119967460632,
0.7204194068908691,
0.22827666997909546,
0.3637605905532837,
-0.32097405195236206,
-0.4329369068145752,
0.2249084860086441,
-0.45565906167030334,
-0.05618096888065338,
0.5883042812347412,
-0.08748767524957657,
0.12913192808628082,
0.6990135312080383,
-0.0767296627163887,
0.5600822567939758,
-0.13110630214214325,
-0.11675269156694412,
0.10614540427923203,
-0.31452682614326477,
-0.10585715621709824,
0.17288899421691895,
1.0040764808654785,
0.2623060345649719,
-0.005815916694700718,
0.17974649369716644,
-0.35397955775260925,
0.35680893063545227,
0.2706291973590851,
-0.9157492518424988,
-0.3552975058555603,
0.1053626760840416,
-0.5493758916854858,
-0.40599483251571655,
0.11945746839046478,
-0.7314811944961548,
-0.4439607858657837,
-0.008447163738310337,
0.5734402537345886,
-0.4047657251358032,
0.007563199382275343,
-0.08394120633602142,
-0.15967395901679993,
0.2431817650794983,
0.3588510751724243,
-0.5770828723907471,
0.2144058644771576,
0.7748630046844482,
0.8820458054542542,
-0.2239934802055359,
-0.3703192174434662,
-0.937800943851471,
-0.11867984384298325,
-0.2907464802265167,
1.0576682090759277,
-0.5569301843643188,
-0.27677154541015625,
-0.164146289229393,
0.07171057164669037,
0.10930255800485611,
-0.670535683631897,
0.9135450720787048,
-0.32782161235809326,
0.24323195219039917,
0.09995925426483154,
-0.9003282189369202,
-0.15777882933616638,
0.14359480142593384,
-0.3140522241592407,
0.9418307542800903,
-0.2608635723590851,
-0.7451373338699341,
0.2755610942840576,
-0.6017347574234009,
-0.4462013244628906,
0.05972835794091225,
-0.1240263283252716,
-0.7215681672096252,
-0.21274760365486145,
0.04928844794631004,
0.385404109954834,
-0.36525866389274597,
0.1816536784172058,
-0.06313583254814148,
-0.5992345809936523,
0.2511192262172699,
-0.4763571321964264,
0.49431297183036804,
0.2607741951942444,
-0.47290271520614624,
0.1516401767730713,
-0.8653597235679626,
-0.13151651620864868,
-0.13580483198165894,
-0.8080733418464661,
0.029164327308535576,
0.2825092077255249,
-0.3728604018688202,
0.367082804441452,
0.17086952924728394,
-0.5868467688560486,
0.12323527783155441,
-0.19102442264556885,
0.512453556060791,
0.7405011653900146,
0.09964630007743835,
0.4411303400993347,
-0.3463311195373535,
0.6530983448028564,
0.12463727593421936,
-0.27125146985054016,
-0.7488018870353699,
-0.8503066897392273,
-0.8761330842971802,
-0.3067779541015625,
0.2543952763080597,
0.7584173679351807,
-0.632831335067749,
0.6857413649559021,
0.3170245885848999,
-0.20742493867874146,
-0.563953161239624,
0.049671921879053116,
0.3066362142562866,
0.6686895489692688,
0.1582101732492447,
-0.491109162569046,
-0.8002046346664429,
-0.8363639116287231,
-0.33515465259552,
-0.29541683197021484,
-0.24484051764011383,
-0.09289409220218658,
0.5829613208770752,
-0.5382363200187683,
0.39008277654647827,
-0.25434568524360657,
-0.26777544617652893,
0.11515743285417557,
0.5682570934295654,
0.03807119280099869,
0.5788111686706543,
0.06389551609754562,
-0.4066295027732849,
-0.35481035709381104,
-0.2761844992637634,
-0.6820491552352905,
-0.6475235223770142,
0.23996230959892273,
-0.27051085233688354,
0.10233812779188156,
0.7220624089241028,
-0.3677239716053009,
0.43664833903312683,
0.39949387311935425,
-0.598351240158081,
0.3307816684246063,
-0.2113937884569168,
0.5736185908317566,
-0.9516311287879944,
-0.12763835489749908,
-0.14889246225357056,
-0.5481729507446289,
-0.6768763065338135,
-0.279511034488678,
0.10413926094770432,
-0.3471291661262512,
-0.17991489171981812,
0.42000073194503784,
-0.41110196709632874,
-0.46314090490341187,
-0.6908461451530457,
-0.28872862458229065,
0.2390286922454834,
0.2660198211669922,
0.03306922689080238,
0.8224689960479736,
0.22054924070835114,
-0.5255593657493591,
0.158682718873024,
0.19600003957748413,
-0.13965868949890137,
0.12579910457134247,
-0.4764156937599182,
0.40586328506469727,
-0.14382340013980865,
0.09205320477485657,
-1.3063023090362549,
-0.45867809653282166,
0.5702463984489441,
-0.8736932277679443,
0.15526056289672852,
-0.06830854713916779,
-0.5065013766288757,
-0.4531312584877014,
-0.2592601478099823,
0.17324848473072052,
0.7044370174407959,
-0.3149382770061493,
0.5984288454055786,
0.46284881234169006,
-0.012665056623518467,
-0.27949023246765137,
-0.7692936658859253,
0.07617420703172684,
-0.19049468636512756,
-0.6426050662994385,
0.12648442387580872,
-0.06708735227584839,
-0.02132963202893734,
-0.04733376204967499,
0.2342614382505417,
-0.1503271609544754,
0.2910863161087036,
0.29309916496276855,
0.2189721316099167,
0.017913952469825745,
-0.15447992086410522,
0.138740673661232,
-0.3179405927658081,
0.26626670360565186,
-0.3035309910774231,
0.5499900579452515,
0.13636457920074463,
-0.4070826768875122,
-0.4905182421207428,
0.5697903037071228,
0.7700476050376892,
-0.3051966428756714,
0.4328138828277588,
0.7511040568351746,
-0.7808873653411865,
-0.08942683041095734,
-0.11587740480899811,
-0.3148311376571655,
-0.45849454402923584,
0.07529470324516296,
-0.40139463543891907,
-0.8002181053161621,
0.6385570168495178,
-0.1886117309331894,
-0.024009115993976593,
0.6515901684761047,
0.5938075184822083,
-0.16558170318603516,
1.6018366813659668,
0.3457271456718445,
0.3668951392173767,
0.1620170772075653,
-0.12959516048431396,
0.3044382333755493,
-0.8256523609161377,
-0.3101842403411865,
-0.7353867292404175,
-0.3191610276699066,
-0.5697969198226929,
-0.45584285259246826,
0.3210029602050781,
0.2922273278236389,
-0.22911882400512695,
0.14765052497386932,
-0.7765228748321533,
0.2684279978275299,
0.9962117671966553,
-0.09670481085777283,
0.3961695730686188,
-0.23674458265304565,
-0.15579372644424438,
-0.0025521840434521437,
-0.5543331503868103,
-0.7675994038581848,
0.9386168718338013,
0.41441699862480164,
0.5287227630615234,
-0.2429599016904831,
0.9066213965415955,
0.8409374356269836,
0.06600654125213623,
-0.9189656376838684,
0.49202579259872437,
-0.3056810200214386,
-0.47520536184310913,
-0.1450466513633728,
0.051180850714445114,
-0.8350624442100525,
0.37848785519599915,
-0.27087175846099854,
-0.5515396595001221,
0.15095949172973633,
0.4078274965286255,
-0.141665980219841,
0.34458890557289124,
-0.622736930847168,
0.7691100239753723,
-0.11954237520694733,
-0.21325315535068512,
0.027951590716838837,
-0.5296887755393982,
0.3962252736091614,
0.0021712423767894506,
0.3059948682785034,
-0.43388447165489197,
-0.2228509783744812,
0.7173041105270386,
-0.4601323902606964,
0.5854117274284363,
-0.07801224291324615,
0.08923353254795074,
0.7380079627037048,
0.14025765657424927,
0.5087282657623291,
-0.22701555490493774,
-0.26682165265083313,
0.12493377178907394,
-0.2865411937236786,
-0.3620634377002716,
0.18313248455524445,
0.42262953519821167,
-0.8412265181541443,
-0.4741244316101074,
-0.6980764865875244,
-0.15770013630390167,
0.14550648629665375,
0.43628066778182983,
0.854954183101654,
0.42596787214279175,
0.13110202550888062,
0.0757160484790802,
0.4639151990413666,
-0.1659485250711441,
0.4812113046646118,
0.3171010911464691,
0.006035658996552229,
-0.47508928179740906,
0.634242594242096,
-0.10239993780851364,
0.013310236856341362,
0.43410375714302063,
0.18054503202438354,
-0.28554636240005493,
-0.6484224200248718,
-0.6070500612258911,
-0.14288204908370972,
-0.8159140348434448,
-0.5282843112945557,
-0.8410769701004028,
-0.36227312684059143,
-0.5252712965011597,
-0.0574951097369194,
-0.28551357984542847,
-0.05684792250394821,
-0.7758516073226929,
0.12348054349422455,
-0.07244032621383667,
0.8405981063842773,
-0.16618910431861877,
0.26583874225616455,
-0.8929482698440552,
0.22866065800189972,
0.2463100701570511,
0.008180882781744003,
-0.38423705101013184,
-0.57993483543396,
-0.17741894721984863,
-0.022877616807818413,
-0.47826945781707764,
-0.9611038565635681,
0.6645458340644836,
0.3476097881793976,
0.27464738488197327,
0.31183338165283203,
-0.004581717774271965,
0.230145663022995,
-0.5319941639900208,
0.7445482015609741,
0.10898274183273315,
-1.0786563158035278,
0.8324362635612488,
-0.2363290786743164,
0.7109458446502686,
0.06827668100595474,
0.2718268930912018,
-0.47239118814468384,
-0.5067781805992126,
-0.2964310050010681,
-0.4866454303264618,
0.8307881951332092,
0.07160130888223648,
-0.22458720207214355,
-0.23696520924568176,
0.38963666558265686,
0.19457262754440308,
0.23432676494121552,
-0.476318359375,
0.0919404998421669,
-0.025738678872585297,
-0.33498191833496094,
0.1271466612815857,
-0.4757472276687622,
0.2653486430644989,
0.11320313811302185,
0.712322473526001,
-0.2931540310382843,
0.6240222454071045,
0.36559605598449707,
-0.051399897783994675,
-0.4353748559951782,
0.23589321970939636,
0.3849662244319916,
0.4736301004886627,
0.025063732638955116,
0.46791040897369385,
-0.1898857057094574,
-0.27188679575920105,
0.31619784235954285,
0.04729783162474632,
-0.36971884965896606,
-0.006137016694992781,
0.6644445061683655,
0.8587918877601624,
-0.1999298334121704,
-0.697064995765686,
0.45085737109184265,
-0.007787841837853193,
-0.3326495885848999,
-0.3127213716506958,
0.26292940974235535,
-0.03813866153359413,
0.31079137325286865,
0.5164167284965515,
0.4111905097961426,
0.6948584318161011,
-0.5919100046157837,
0.48348113894462585,
0.15387006103992462,
-0.2750904858112335,
-0.4506734311580658,
1.1036856174468994,
0.43163245916366577,
-0.5481759905815125,
0.44881853461265564,
-0.5112581849098206,
-0.9576364159584045,
0.8297485113143921,
0.46506500244140625,
0.8238086104393005,
-0.34295928478240967,
-0.10929245501756668,
0.43467485904693604,
0.4734962284564972,
0.07169827818870544,
0.43384623527526855,
0.14560730755329132,
-0.8783156871795654,
-0.5360546112060547,
-0.7190998792648315,
-0.44201719760894775,
0.19896911084651947,
-0.42060768604278564,
0.8014893531799316,
-0.29824382066726685,
-0.13096147775650024,
0.16470390558242798,
-0.03330009803175926,
-0.5163800120353699,
0.27542275190353394,
0.3829396069049835,
0.4879623055458069,
-1.0523432493209839,
0.7565562725067139,
0.8706054091453552,
0.09563705325126648,
-0.4268181025981903,
-0.06624916195869446,
0.2658631503582001,
-0.7591965198516846,
0.08465763926506042,
0.4057750105857849,
-0.17563264071941376,
0.07368537038564682,
-0.4164428114891052,
-0.6218178272247314,
1.0845242738723755,
0.20278269052505493,
-0.403158575296402,
0.10618678480386734,
0.016145378351211548,
0.2723882794380188,
-0.6048189401626587,
0.23085005581378937,
0.6743171811103821,
0.2745012938976288,
0.09787052124738693,
-0.7710244655609131,
-0.2424171268939972,
-0.35365092754364014,
-0.27088576555252075,
0.5280083417892456,
-0.7123308777809143,
0.888241171836853,
0.07707051932811737,
-0.2095838189125061,
0.09596599638462067,
0.62661212682724,
0.17657941579818726,
0.6266506314277649,
0.4368431866168976,
0.5479264259338379,
0.7735546231269836,
-0.16260232031345367,
0.7084106206893921,
-0.3072347640991211,
0.023502320051193237,
0.9995542168617249,
-0.14378716051578522,
0.660790205001831,
0.18789957463741302,
0.026725957170128822,
0.33031630516052246,
1.0017410516738892,
0.15170103311538696,
0.524451732635498,
-0.045949991792440414,
-0.182073175907135,
-0.34983575344085693,
-0.19060170650482178,
-0.10404694080352783,
0.819629430770874,
0.3970538377761841,
-0.5111952424049377,
0.3501017391681671,
0.140261709690094,
-0.04034150019288063,
0.14472274482250214,
-0.3941989243030548,
0.8945019245147705,
0.08940057456493378,
-1.0126757621765137,
0.3273051977157593,
0.3636568486690521,
0.9898837208747864,
-0.14061881601810455,
-0.24689310789108276,
0.010952363722026348,
0.3221021890640259,
-0.18088214099407196,
-0.8393608331680298,
0.4527134299278259,
0.020414933562278748,
-0.21266140043735504,
-0.24665576219558716,
1.6667900085449219,
-0.7659366130828857,
-0.4030072093009949,
0.3672367036342621,
0.34636780619621277,
0.22563272714614868,
0.0526873879134655,
-0.4599813222885132,
0.380945086479187,
0.0908045768737793,
-0.05501718819141388,
-0.039701733738183975,
0.39403489232063293,
0.1042858362197876,
0.5050328969955444,
0.3102043569087982,
-0.21043580770492554,
0.376555472612381,
-0.20844873785972595,
0.4329479932785034,
-0.442170113325119,
-0.6781530976295471,
-0.8539863228797913,
0.47975075244903564,
0.03524891659617424,
-0.14816038310527802,
0.4468751549720764,
0.6435280442237854,
0.6670700311660767,
0.048871975392103195,
0.9793300628662109,
0.09001284092664719,
0.6409217119216919,
-0.41147148609161377,
0.13968418538570404,
-0.5097306966781616,
0.2124481499195099,
0.1187809407711029,
-0.8784751892089844,
-0.01491488330066204,
0.44880354404449463,
0.04432231932878494,
-0.3365851640701294,
0.5523760318756104,
0.31274282932281494,
0.032880544662475586,
0.04936075583100319,
0.38954687118530273,
-0.018464230000972748,
0.3005785048007965,
0.41291168332099915,
0.9319750666618347,
-0.6343993544578552,
0.48773860931396484,
-0.34740129113197327,
-0.2533317804336548,
-0.4043525159358978,
-0.8324680328369141,
-0.8280671238899231,
-0.5426777005195618,
-0.3779909312725067,
-0.35452011227607727,
-0.0989898294210434,
0.6556804180145264,
0.6291749477386475,
-0.8523136973381042,
-0.2205594778060913,
-0.12685823440551758,
0.053705040365457535,
0.24426303803920746,
-0.2362706959247589,
-0.21505093574523926,
-0.12034918367862701,
-0.9803961515426636,
0.34092679619789124,
0.6907508373260498,
-0.030906924977898598,
-0.22438819706439972,
-0.32951223850250244,
-0.37333399057388306,
0.3454110026359558,
0.5606318712234497,
-0.09365503489971161,
-0.5336073040962219,
-0.552673876285553,
0.039111729711294174,
-0.05758558213710785,
0.24898269772529602,
0.7391406893730164,
-0.36783164739608765,
0.6065369844436646,
1.024282693862915,
0.5833088755607605,
0.642842173576355,
0.23214343190193176,
0.7079838514328003,
-0.6513640284538269,
0.13656947016716003,
0.467798113822937,
0.5462743043899536,
0.4594249725341797,
-0.6073353886604309,
0.6159127354621887,
0.33522582054138184,
-0.9788191318511963,
-0.6330793499946594,
0.19542363286018372,
-0.22618354856967926,
-0.20092256367206573,
0.8766481876373291,
-0.16595757007598877,
-0.2323238104581833,
-0.0522359274327755,
-0.14558500051498413,
0.5551585555076599,
-0.42926767468452454,
0.4579690396785736,
0.9120966792106628,
-0.5931777954101562,
-0.3264106512069702,
-0.38275620341300964,
0.4015316665172577,
0.3018711805343628,
-0.963616669178009,
-0.5241498947143555,
0.6895981431007385,
0.00977665837854147,
0.08436324447393417,
0.9454271793365479,
-0.08220040053129196,
0.3002852201461792,
0.12885382771492004,
0.08754786103963852,
0.1363038271665573,
-0.5519998669624329,
-0.27679315209388733,
0.06873199343681335,
0.28387242555618286,
-0.47172361612319946
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19352v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19352v1
|
A diverse Multilingual News Headlines Dataset from around the World
| 2024-03-28T12:08:39 | 2024-03-28T12:08:39 |
Felix Leeb, Bernhard Schölkopf
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Babel Briefings is a novel dataset featuring 4.7 million news headlines from
August 2020 to November 2021, across 30 languages and 54 locations worldwide
with English translations of all articles included. Designed for natural
language processing and media studies, it serves as a high-quality dataset for
training or evaluating language models as well as offering a simple, accessible
collection of articles, for example, to analyze global news coverage and
cultural narratives. As a simple demonstration of the analyses facilitated by
this dataset, we use a basic procedure using a TF-IDF weighted similarity
metric to group articles into clusters about the same event. We then visualize
the \emph{event signatures} of the event showing articles of which languages
appear over time, revealing intuitive features based on the proximity of the
event and unexpectedness of the event. The dataset is available on
\href{https://www.kaggle.com/datasets/felixludos/babel-briefings}{Kaggle} and
\href{https://huggingface.co/datasets/felixludos/babel-briefings}{HuggingFace}
with accompanying \href{https://github.com/felixludos/babel-briefings}{GitHub}
code.
|
[
-0.41294345259666443,
-0.6690836548805237,
0.17619585990905762,
0.7744364142417908,
-0.1925169974565506,
0.416884183883667,
-0.251511812210083,
-0.6398796439170837,
0.3323478102684021,
0.3081759512424469,
-0.6698793768882751,
-0.888336718082428,
-0.465608686208725,
0.2713964581489563,
-0.7203595042228699,
1.4085859060287476,
0.27284666895866394,
0.03397095575928688,
0.05590314790606499,
-0.15930041670799255,
-0.09181046485900879,
-0.03658880293369293,
-0.5413423180580139,
-0.0013734666863456368,
0.5033486485481262,
0.4463837742805481,
0.8027908205986023,
0.5018430352210999,
0.4210011065006256,
0.08874072134494781,
-0.2809142470359802,
0.1371539980173111,
-0.4322015047073364,
-0.29122209548950195,
-0.2321203202009201,
-0.2308821678161621,
-0.2878037989139557,
-0.005892103537917137,
0.8472338318824768,
0.7764338254928589,
-0.003147042589262128,
0.20581842958927155,
-0.1370266079902649,
0.7533496618270874,
-0.14890001714229584,
0.2691182494163513,
-0.44672951102256775,
0.16795441508293152,
-0.3152236342430115,
-0.005998024716973305,
-0.39784038066864014,
-0.31305643916130066,
0.12599346041679382,
-0.3285711705684662,
0.3913753032684326,
0.37101468443870544,
1.0456417798995972,
-0.048248834908008575,
-0.809139609336853,
-0.14343799650669098,
-0.3940502107143402,
0.685263991355896,
-0.23244887590408325,
0.47492271661758423,
0.2944522798061371,
0.3829347789287567,
-0.15329387784004211,
-0.3660193979740143,
-0.06064250320196152,
-0.023025762289762497,
-0.26059702038764954,
0.24016380310058594,
-0.2327810525894165,
-0.3871142864227295,
0.07733798772096634,
0.4257754683494568,
-0.9375515580177307,
0.08835898339748383,
-0.6117806434631348,
-0.18735066056251526,
0.6990712285041809,
0.10667436569929123,
0.29815053939819336,
-0.3655473291873932,
-0.29557594656944275,
0.24908645451068878,
-0.7155535817146301,
0.08479604125022888,
0.4368157684803009,
0.444755494594574,
-0.8551775217056274,
0.27953243255615234,
-0.5273874998092651,
1.172147512435913,
-0.0722929984331131,
-0.2857465445995331,
0.6324215531349182,
-0.5640280842781067,
0.26231735944747925,
0.08667465299367905,
0.8589349985122681,
0.7086029052734375,
0.2918969690799713,
-0.3640742897987366,
0.13755804300308228,
-0.21603992581367493,
0.08212703466415405,
-0.7190375328063965,
-0.1729499250650406,
0.29354506731033325,
-0.33604058623313904,
-0.3673425018787384,
0.007848909124732018,
-0.970914363861084,
-0.370146781206131,
-0.21806170046329498,
-0.24180863797664642,
-0.21556560695171356,
-0.00164197594858706,
0.24608714878559113,
-0.26163238286972046,
0.2534889578819275,
0.28893429040908813,
-0.7000270485877991,
-0.0954984799027443,
0.2429291307926178,
0.5470479726791382,
-0.2631854712963104,
-0.3647019565105438,
-0.4532252550125122,
0.04409695044159889,
-0.2849576473236084,
1.019590973854065,
-0.3916045129299164,
-0.23436161875724792,
0.09005459398031235,
0.2200111597776413,
0.03098028153181076,
-0.30535292625427246,
0.6105431318283081,
-0.4439491629600525,
0.12709327042102814,
-0.1857648342847824,
-0.18211549520492554,
-0.02965739741921425,
0.590405285358429,
-0.7982845902442932,
0.9549666047096252,
0.021297719329595566,
-0.8466607928276062,
0.337939590215683,
-0.5883941054344177,
-0.5445188879966736,
-0.06213455647230148,
-0.201976478099823,
-0.23480834066867828,
-0.07323912531137466,
0.720801830291748,
0.2522651255130768,
-0.3530649244785309,
0.44411447644233704,
0.07102475315332413,
0.061775121837854385,
0.05667814239859581,
-0.1419704705476761,
0.9138785600662231,
0.3226375877857208,
-0.10387331247329712,
0.05347529798746109,
-1.0178653001785278,
-0.2872251570224762,
0.10852599143981934,
-0.5466417074203491,
0.02711285650730133,
-0.14540763199329376,
0.4088759422302246,
0.36731135845184326,
0.37751156091690063,
-0.5680224299430847,
0.1360633820295334,
-0.4569433927536011,
0.08812715113162994,
0.24627500772476196,
0.07337278872728348,
0.3049655258655548,
-0.3698643147945404,
0.5782883763313293,
0.3501950204372406,
0.4092045724391937,
-0.6173463463783264,
-0.5914185047149658,
-0.37791377305984497,
-0.11350340396165848,
0.24491865932941437,
0.6301363110542297,
-0.7072113156318665,
0.3292628526687622,
-0.406226247549057,
-0.5740095376968384,
-0.4532526433467865,
0.06752235442399979,
0.3892069160938263,
0.4593240022659302,
0.14869609475135803,
0.24500076472759247,
-0.6366892457008362,
-1.1408121585845947,
-0.6247711777687073,
0.08141589909791946,
0.17222259938716888,
0.018359005451202393,
0.4123583436012268,
0.16967131197452545,
1.2182928323745728,
-0.3010876178741455,
0.0011311366688460112,
-0.42270058393478394,
0.1283455193042755,
0.4356192946434021,
0.3477601408958435,
0.7940293550491333,
-1.28225839138031,
-0.5571637153625488,
0.22286492586135864,
-0.8144327402114868,
-0.04766269400715828,
-0.16355565190315247,
-0.06752991676330566,
0.3080979883670807,
0.7450030446052551,
-0.25597313046455383,
0.2772560715675354,
0.8210717439651489,
-0.6801625490188599,
0.6557417511940002,
0.22451162338256836,
0.3755868375301361,
-1.31792414188385,
-0.008806251920759678,
-0.09982024133205414,
-0.28189635276794434,
-0.4339001178741455,
-0.09257589280605316,
0.31198835372924805,
-0.3009507656097412,
-0.756928026676178,
0.978244423866272,
-0.41008225083351135,
-0.0025139828212559223,
0.18648873269557953,
0.18456806242465973,
0.2630784809589386,
0.28361961245536804,
-0.2695019245147705,
0.6136988401412964,
0.7246886491775513,
-0.20340166985988617,
0.5336247682571411,
0.4136826992034912,
-0.5089494585990906,
0.4993906617164612,
-0.48980939388275146,
-0.3582582473754883,
-0.33271515369415283,
0.2335335910320282,
-0.762252151966095,
-0.38937637209892273,
0.16614580154418945,
-0.43886828422546387,
0.08726448565721512,
-0.1629668027162552,
-0.7019851207733154,
-0.40616828203201294,
-0.39805343747138977,
0.4056887626647949,
0.22042018175125122,
-0.5639986395835876,
0.2935093641281128,
0.5393902659416199,
-0.262704998254776,
-0.5780026316642761,
-0.8149489164352417,
0.46728774905204773,
-0.2614589333534241,
-0.4604184329509735,
0.2833521366119385,
-0.3615139126777649,
-0.32525619864463806,
0.20007024705410004,
-0.03538119047880173,
-0.04331041872501373,
0.035491108894348145,
-0.050698019564151764,
0.2287566214799881,
-0.15136341750621796,
0.02265002951025963,
0.011099313385784626,
-0.011162418872117996,
-0.1915358155965805,
-0.28525763750076294,
0.3033868372440338,
-0.42047831416130066,
-0.23981168866157532,
-0.23095859587192535,
0.5269356369972229,
0.53639155626297,
-0.31569525599479675,
0.8123868703842163,
0.8126786351203918,
-0.3729603588581085,
0.17200250923633575,
-0.5058518052101135,
0.09367459267377853,
-0.37736135721206665,
0.4472435414791107,
-0.346811980009079,
-0.6717575788497925,
0.852534830570221,
0.2218826860189438,
0.321856290102005,
0.6186100840568542,
0.6206485629081726,
0.1268407553434372,
0.9761889576911926,
0.5110356211662292,
-0.4305608570575714,
0.3832213580608368,
0.0022425635252147913,
0.21768617630004883,
-0.2831338047981262,
-0.5212887525558472,
-0.5849753618240356,
-0.36666277050971985,
-0.5612179636955261,
-0.25566577911376953,
0.28236785531044006,
0.10519041866064072,
0.09774447977542877,
0.22495482861995697,
-0.31212982535362244,
0.9694077372550964,
0.5441559553146362,
-0.11905819177627563,
0.5593506097793579,
0.19843260943889618,
0.06335936486721039,
-0.1465156078338623,
-0.6591091156005859,
-0.1201954185962677,
1.0492700338363647,
-0.11526055634021759,
0.903899610042572,
-0.031275056302547455,
0.565926730632782,
0.35501331090927124,
0.04198530688881874,
-0.6149333715438843,
0.29614508152008057,
0.0024077051784843206,
-0.7141269445419312,
0.022589953616261482,
-0.47338151931762695,
-1.1513606309890747,
0.0763215497136116,
-0.06505540758371353,
-0.803278923034668,
-0.04675205051898956,
-0.12324453890323639,
-0.21304109692573547,
0.2528679072856903,
-0.5607700347900391,
0.8224840760231018,
-0.17787332832813263,
0.1092856377363205,
-0.1599859744310379,
-0.8295053839683533,
0.1487191915512085,
-0.07432110607624054,
0.8282814621925354,
-0.6311527490615845,
0.01995157264173031,
0.7583016157150269,
0.45154231786727905,
0.7865892648696899,
0.2461533397436142,
-0.23251275718212128,
-0.02522803656756878,
-0.33417946100234985,
0.14449547231197357,
0.41805315017700195,
-0.1607326716184616,
0.5039520263671875,
-0.23351334035396576,
-0.6752741932868958,
-0.21611541509628296,
0.7211284637451172,
-0.5905561447143555,
-0.37324318289756775,
-0.31029537320137024,
-1.0805473327636719,
-0.22669273614883423,
0.3460577428340912,
0.29237493872642517,
0.7691609859466553,
-0.45056048035621643,
0.22974038124084473,
0.3847169578075409,
-0.36919695138931274,
0.48659610748291016,
0.7301728129386902,
-0.6701539754867554,
-0.310401976108551,
0.8217307329177856,
0.13403558731079102,
-0.06171170622110367,
0.518568754196167,
-0.07140278816223145,
-0.08706917613744736,
-0.4430837333202362,
-0.6856204867362976,
0.15700197219848633,
-0.5740999579429626,
-0.23093217611312866,
-0.6516368985176086,
-0.2966790795326233,
-0.3818885087966919,
-0.3559405505657196,
-0.2912512719631195,
-0.4617118239402771,
0.13650041818618774,
-0.1387297809123993,
0.4822264015674591,
0.5853816270828247,
0.067495197057724,
0.20426225662231445,
-0.9489349722862244,
0.60142582654953,
-0.1683173030614853,
0.18945668637752533,
-0.6154611110687256,
-0.28894785046577454,
-0.7874777317047119,
-0.04635974019765854,
-0.3310002386569977,
-0.8126981854438782,
0.40457209944725037,
0.40352752804756165,
0.4637204706668854,
0.4620618224143982,
0.028012843802571297,
0.3752167224884033,
-0.6636088490486145,
0.80223548412323,
0.11165346950292587,
-0.4735196530818939,
0.9261956214904785,
-0.8756976127624512,
0.7677538990974426,
0.37591224908828735,
0.42927834391593933,
-0.6744311451911926,
-0.9674770832061768,
-0.7212685346603394,
-1.003629207611084,
0.9436108469963074,
0.10301923751831055,
0.08802667260169983,
-0.23770149052143097,
-0.043660927563905716,
0.2870604693889618,
0.3499126732349396,
-0.6799576282501221,
-0.6501083970069885,
0.26530763506889343,
-0.37244075536727905,
-0.19856441020965576,
-0.2595076560974121,
-0.35697028040885925,
-0.2501724064350128,
0.49937042593955994,
-0.158376544713974,
-0.21589067578315735,
-0.1439787894487381,
-0.2344333976507187,
0.08964093774557114,
0.3548436760902405,
0.36202678084373474,
0.888050377368927,
-0.07129646092653275,
-0.0781082734465599,
0.1777677834033966,
-0.36677899956703186,
-0.2716538608074188,
0.3934347927570343,
-0.2289845049381256,
0.2999534606933594,
0.3601018488407135,
0.7274072170257568,
0.7434011101722717,
-0.9478254914283752,
0.2846664488315582,
-0.1843315064907074,
-0.026662174612283707,
-0.23204755783081055,
-0.3579314053058624,
0.24311648309230804,
0.4375949501991272,
0.5973190069198608,
0.020963070914149284,
0.20475558936595917,
-0.4408069849014282,
0.3096775412559509,
0.08294348418712616,
-0.041416652500629425,
-0.47021496295928955,
0.6244670748710632,
0.17666639387607574,
-0.1156778484582901,
0.5011032819747925,
-0.30215224623680115,
-0.3492027223110199,
0.8067255020141602,
0.5833925008773804,
0.47159603238105774,
-0.20232515037059784,
0.4585203230381012,
0.4716971516609192,
0.4282287359237671,
0.12539245188236237,
0.41441628336906433,
0.34859639406204224,
-0.6778813004493713,
-0.296924352645874,
-0.9076203107833862,
-0.2996775805950165,
-0.1049015074968338,
-0.7950989007949829,
0.4492186903953552,
-0.04638097807765007,
0.11788021773099899,
0.01991828717291355,
-0.052728984504938126,
-0.8801590800285339,
0.07467464357614517,
0.2956705093383789,
1.0931495428085327,
-1.1492363214492798,
0.5593668222427368,
0.9710466861724854,
-0.11426208168268204,
-0.14550301432609558,
-0.02968231402337551,
0.389276921749115,
-0.7802402377128601,
0.2399921715259552,
0.32475921511650085,
0.5082734823226929,
0.10918452590703964,
-0.2577320635318756,
-0.9926676154136658,
0.5897569060325623,
0.6836643218994141,
-0.3964700698852539,
-0.293005108833313,
0.24013935029506683,
0.1720876395702362,
-0.28220686316490173,
-0.1560172438621521,
0.8013358116149902,
0.6818108558654785,
-0.23755420744419098,
-1.1171848773956299,
-0.35660693049430847,
-0.504227876663208,
-0.40035343170166016,
0.27019479870796204,
-0.7329098582267761,
0.7662383317947388,
-0.24816620349884033,
0.003188470611348748,
-0.3252525329589844,
0.5132403373718262,
0.13092733919620514,
0.19243982434272766,
0.258197158575058,
0.5080864429473877,
0.6705431342124939,
-0.3434126079082489,
1.1469213962554932,
-0.659795880317688,
0.5349127054214478,
1.0596991777420044,
0.1887984275817871,
0.3960270881652832,
0.3632908761501312,
-0.2049110233783722,
0.44354772567749023,
0.6847603917121887,
-0.1792040467262268,
0.5653042197227478,
-0.18114475905895233,
-0.03197447955608368,
-0.1229672059416771,
-0.519234836101532,
-0.3230738043785095,
0.4609581232070923,
0.46794578433036804,
-0.019034726545214653,
-0.9789255857467651,
0.4946916997432709,
0.15069495141506195,
-0.18741507828235626,
-0.38678812980651855,
0.6122979521751404,
0.04178787022829056,
-0.48900362849235535,
0.4049690067768097,
-0.13700254261493683,
0.46138936281204224,
-0.6833146214485168,
0.2531589865684509,
-0.2773822546005249,
-0.046185724437236786,
-0.22734896838665009,
-0.9494082927703857,
0.5058264136314392,
0.05552734434604645,
-0.5644615888595581,
-0.3823827803134918,
0.4046046733856201,
-0.7209901809692383,
-0.8085787296295166,
0.30221328139305115,
0.7063571810722351,
0.22840821743011475,
0.09922243654727936,
-0.8559601306915283,
0.25525569915771484,
0.08077405393123627,
-0.5560498237609863,
0.3711533546447754,
0.39523962140083313,
-0.22281959652900696,
0.6181721091270447,
0.3553519546985626,
0.04953145235776901,
0.25420403480529785,
0.37140586972236633,
0.6119921803474426,
-0.7951774001121521,
-0.8936583995819092,
-0.7578422427177429,
0.6257829070091248,
-0.2163473218679428,
-0.4671228528022766,
1.0764760971069336,
0.9966615438461304,
0.7417886853218079,
-0.11794212460517883,
0.7651792764663696,
-0.18446126580238342,
0.35260477662086487,
-0.5896727442741394,
0.7274819016456604,
-0.8390049338340759,
-0.1619592159986496,
0.13095885515213013,
-0.44239097833633423,
-0.5293429493904114,
-0.010447464883327484,
-0.07338268309831619,
-0.1621379256248474,
0.7538310885429382,
0.6732726097106934,
-0.07612842321395874,
0.15611642599105835,
0.2713112235069275,
0.3041137158870697,
0.11182150989770889,
0.31905269622802734,
0.5447495579719543,
-0.1728140413761139,
0.68473881483078,
-0.11647654324769974,
-0.0178902056068182,
-0.3401815593242645,
-0.8438680768013,
-0.94535893201828,
-0.7257333397865295,
-0.4247777760028839,
-0.12176871299743652,
0.18655680119991302,
0.8517573475837708,
0.6120405197143555,
-1.0530732870101929,
-0.09421338140964508,
0.25038623809814453,
0.33761611580848694,
0.020934512838721275,
-0.31148359179496765,
0.5542910695075989,
-0.6226989030838013,
-1.1193448305130005,
0.7279898524284363,
0.3634512722492218,
-0.14325863122940063,
0.20058488845825195,
0.290548712015152,
-0.32464197278022766,
-0.27568188309669495,
0.5876091718673706,
0.21959629654884338,
-0.6048052906990051,
0.029790233820676804,
-0.19458982348442078,
-0.13352274894714355,
0.18485893309116364,
0.551322877407074,
-0.8204766511917114,
0.29406991600990295,
0.4428151249885559,
0.5418412089347839,
0.4025228023529053,
-0.2964100241661072,
0.3732789158821106,
-1.3186142444610596,
0.803745687007904,
0.015102875418961048,
0.45416808128356934,
0.494981586933136,
-0.3435835540294647,
0.5146462917327881,
0.10254590213298798,
-0.21061378717422485,
-0.8220336437225342,
0.22864991426467896,
-0.92417973279953,
-0.23904629051685333,
1.172554850578308,
0.008188705891370773,
-0.22458574175834656,
-0.3717453181743622,
-0.0794185996055603,
0.0316188707947731,
-0.5514354705810547,
0.8115749955177307,
0.8329574465751648,
-0.014658300206065178,
0.08001852035522461,
-0.9094916582107544,
0.46062710881233215,
0.14131532609462738,
-1.0148422718048096,
-0.06849952042102814,
0.4813728928565979,
0.23750148713588715,
0.20955637097358704,
0.5049514174461365,
-0.2516341507434845,
0.2620161473751068,
-0.066996268928051,
0.09613938629627228,
0.09966719895601273,
-0.7730115652084351,
-0.28022506833076477,
0.18300779163837433,
-0.34615394473075867,
-0.1409793198108673
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19346v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19346v2
|
Large Language Models Are Unconscious of Unreasonability in Math Problems
| 2024-03-28T12:04:28 | 2024-04-16T13:53:47 |
Jingyuan Ma, Damai Dai, Lei Sha, Zhifang Sui
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) demonstrate substantial capabilities in solving
math problems. However, they tend to produce hallucinations when given
questions containing unreasonable errors. In this paper, we study the behavior
of LLMs when faced with unreasonable math problems and further explore their
potential to address these problems. We construct the Unreasonable Math Problem
(UMP) benchmark to examine the error detection ability of LLMs. Experiments
show that LLMs are able to detect unreasonable errors, but still fail in
generating non-hallucinatory content. In order to improve their ability of
error detection and correction, we further design a strategic prompt template
called Critical Calculation and Conclusion(CCC). With CCC, LLMs can better
self-evaluate and detect unreasonable errors in math questions, making them
more reliable and safe in practical application scenarios.
|
[
-0.35758456587791443,
-0.9289759397506714,
0.8950099945068359,
0.38349446654319763,
0.03710653632879257,
-0.029494717717170715,
-0.4356808066368103,
-0.10865750908851624,
-0.21682485938072205,
0.6255740523338318,
-0.5822129249572754,
-0.36354687809944153,
-0.572502076625824,
0.2475171834230423,
-0.2917591631412506,
0.42501702904701233,
-0.18050651252269745,
0.10913112759590149,
-0.09767664223909378,
-0.40666329860687256,
-0.9030799865722656,
-0.7704094648361206,
-0.6728413105010986,
-0.15813496708869934,
0.0783267617225647,
0.4037325978279114,
0.8019202947616577,
0.3132953345775604,
0.4575020968914032,
0.4262520968914032,
-0.008401859551668167,
0.5065250992774963,
-0.3994269371032715,
0.22902435064315796,
-0.13912150263786316,
-0.5623403787612915,
-0.403219610452652,
-0.060073744505643845,
0.8578079342842102,
1.0075680017471313,
-0.4838469624519348,
-0.16510161757469177,
0.11810939013957977,
0.7710652351379395,
-0.5600924491882324,
0.2789323329925537,
-0.7748739719390869,
0.1397486925125122,
-0.060205522924661636,
-0.08995816856622696,
-0.7602456212043762,
-0.15571075677871704,
-0.33804231882095337,
-0.46438461542129517,
0.046744827181100845,
0.25170013308525085,
0.41126003861427307,
0.29154571890830994,
-0.09382637590169907,
-0.6212317943572998,
-0.6625471711158752,
0.7579419016838074,
-0.8413995504379272,
0.3367016613483429,
0.2788429260253906,
0.4289661645889282,
-0.7465514540672302,
-0.2545243799686432,
-0.7071889638900757,
-0.29043370485305786,
0.31871485710144043,
-0.07687469571828842,
-0.4509373605251312,
-0.11052817851305008,
0.7266843318939209,
0.027839157730340958,
-0.44702205061912537,
0.2317834496498108,
0.07167478650808334,
-0.08652879297733307,
0.42288416624069214,
0.7299654483795166,
0.4218636155128479,
-0.29980459809303284,
0.2609685957431793,
0.10118772089481354,
-0.5771749019622803,
-0.04015801474452019,
0.27873706817626953,
0.22711554169654846,
-0.03335538133978844,
0.7274147868156433,
0.09719526022672653,
0.6726622581481934,
-0.0978480726480484,
0.0475301593542099,
-0.032979972660541534,
0.24856719374656677,
-0.2195562869310379,
-0.10395810008049011,
0.553994357585907,
0.3498605489730835,
0.5766951441764832,
-0.0255676731467247,
-0.4517030417919159,
0.2657279670238495,
0.2679430842399597,
-0.4897933304309845,
-0.028641076758503914,
0.1640082597732544,
-0.2232518047094345,
-0.14419037103652954,
-0.18749842047691345,
-0.7314853668212891,
-0.4851696193218231,
-0.3358123302459717,
0.23798084259033203,
-0.30218344926834106,
-0.040497228503227234,
0.3513140082359314,
0.24210190773010254,
-0.17281867563724518,
0.44625747203826904,
-0.6803134679794312,
0.3436284065246582,
0.6135629415512085,
0.6666861772537231,
-0.09648595005273819,
-0.3091168701648712,
-0.6144386529922485,
-0.10094901919364929,
-0.6942763328552246,
0.7838826775550842,
-0.454314261674881,
-0.5395072102546692,
0.03590788692235947,
0.03217937797307968,
-0.04248891770839691,
-0.9134196043014526,
0.7275497317314148,
-0.3257715404033661,
-0.0775315910577774,
-0.38920554518699646,
-0.6875657439231873,
-0.04965248331427574,
0.3933451473712921,
-0.4623815417289734,
0.5956000685691833,
0.14816191792488098,
-0.597415030002594,
-0.04594399034976959,
-0.5476322770118713,
0.0842626690864563,
0.1077214777469635,
-0.43653371930122375,
-0.31746724247932434,
0.5442697405815125,
0.22390024363994598,
0.3781684637069702,
-0.47306281328201294,
0.41903260350227356,
-0.4395635724067688,
-0.44352108240127563,
0.8896081447601318,
-0.7814546823501587,
0.7416972517967224,
0.2611660659313202,
-0.3447136878967285,
-0.07759686559438705,
-0.8336682319641113,
0.3087642788887024,
0.5120639204978943,
-0.29424288868904114,
-0.23772642016410828,
0.16470281779766083,
-0.1576225459575653,
0.10786591470241547,
-0.150148406624794,
-0.18263180553913116,
0.14546039700508118,
-0.09621736407279968,
0.324017196893692,
1.0597248077392578,
-0.20190945267677307,
0.05444427207112312,
-0.293852835893631,
0.5292850136756897,
-0.05830702930688858,
-0.16774903237819672,
-0.053792715072631836,
-0.34228208661079407,
-0.9478433132171631,
0.002425761427730322,
0.06919872760772705,
0.4484880864620209,
-0.6553372144699097,
0.5129644274711609,
0.045547571033239365,
-0.2574109435081482,
-0.07273458689451218,
0.11805643886327744,
0.295937716960907,
0.69687819480896,
0.11436007171869278,
0.2390250712633133,
-0.610793948173523,
-0.6075594425201416,
-0.6292332410812378,
-0.02824932150542736,
-0.16316717863082886,
0.478991836309433,
0.38071680068969727,
-0.35421621799468994,
0.5461108088493347,
-0.5759800672531128,
-0.25918149948120117,
-0.2567456066608429,
0.16550813615322113,
0.35600319504737854,
0.40084752440452576,
0.2923576235771179,
-0.45023831725120544,
-0.3306347131729126,
-0.33783233165740967,
-1.0217257738113403,
-0.4911675453186035,
-0.20643475651741028,
0.17685283720493317,
0.4584285020828247,
0.5588690638542175,
-0.47387486696243286,
0.3894546627998352,
0.4455071687698364,
-0.4166697561740875,
0.7145459055900574,
-0.29529356956481934,
0.11022759228944778,
-0.6882212162017822,
-0.048331212252378464,
-0.03752432018518448,
0.007400106638669968,
-0.42006197571754456,
0.00847185030579567,
0.1631987988948822,
-0.055963922291994095,
-0.271124005317688,
0.36009952425956726,
-0.33884289860725403,
0.01672162488102913,
-0.3457534909248352,
0.09323272854089737,
-0.2434990257024765,
0.29801878333091736,
-0.1286591738462448,
0.7091257572174072,
0.42682576179504395,
-0.45652177929878235,
0.3646513521671295,
-0.024028653278946877,
-0.35964974761009216,
0.7015990018844604,
-0.6565322279930115,
0.11516977846622467,
-0.29690083861351013,
0.1576130986213684,
-1.1305590867996216,
-0.30013537406921387,
0.09005100280046463,
-0.49600842595100403,
0.06886135041713715,
0.1321108043193817,
-0.7304711937904358,
-0.39410075545310974,
-0.01501094177365303,
0.4808800220489502,
0.600018322467804,
-0.7419114708900452,
0.6134958267211914,
0.2877764105796814,
0.09128711372613907,
-0.4262785315513611,
-0.4435981512069702,
-0.021941931918263435,
-0.1508951634168625,
-0.5873608589172363,
-0.33665263652801514,
-0.27881336212158203,
-0.5765408873558044,
-0.23437842726707458,
-0.007895107381045818,
0.11045138537883759,
0.010554985143244267,
0.4227563738822937,
0.4712468087673187,
-0.07893937826156616,
-0.07778427749872208,
-0.38116347789764404,
-0.21519699692726135,
0.6298613548278809,
0.005368179641664028,
0.6877633333206177,
-0.3019658923149109,
-0.6557813882827759,
-0.2811272144317627,
0.3804098069667816,
0.6438141465187073,
0.2582736313343048,
0.47557416558265686,
0.06395551562309265,
-0.8279827833175659,
-0.4015768766403198,
-0.869088888168335,
-0.03243235871195793,
-0.5314236283302307,
0.3309885263442993,
-0.42427223920822144,
-0.7272362112998962,
0.7207211852073669,
-0.014495465904474258,
0.05896548181772232,
0.4899217486381531,
0.6799764633178711,
0.1047198474407196,
1.5165678262710571,
0.2664793133735657,
0.17767944931983948,
-0.1129782572388649,
-0.05953310802578926,
0.22577224671840668,
-0.865616500377655,
-0.34046491980552673,
-0.7575769424438477,
-0.05713919550180435,
-0.3379610478878021,
-0.3719838261604309,
0.40581128001213074,
0.20063798129558563,
-0.35006973147392273,
0.10652698576450348,
-0.4278225898742676,
0.7070528268814087,
0.07051453739404678,
-0.2096567451953888,
0.3156481683254242,
0.10710294544696808,
-0.4860888719558716,
-0.7704570293426514,
-0.5341949462890625,
-0.47456440329551697,
0.933330237865448,
0.44091182947158813,
1.0497524738311768,
0.12570321559906006,
0.17703422904014587,
0.02803846448659897,
0.38533860445022583,
-0.7076911330223083,
0.5850778222084045,
-0.0389208123087883,
-0.6683499813079834,
-0.3100285530090332,
-0.687112033367157,
-0.6459901928901672,
0.35505250096321106,
-0.05815664306282997,
-0.9861340522766113,
-0.10207921266555786,
-0.029580017551779747,
-0.21996930241584778,
0.5670315027236938,
-0.5022518038749695,
0.7093164920806885,
-0.28774476051330566,
-0.20918017625808716,
-0.029096033424139023,
0.006506164092570543,
0.4556124806404114,
-0.3050658106803894,
0.4217042028903961,
-0.24637550115585327,
0.08993327617645264,
0.6314425468444824,
-0.37736135721206665,
0.6329208612442017,
0.05542963370680809,
-0.1917424499988556,
0.4488324224948883,
0.6999809145927429,
0.621870219707489,
0.218980610370636,
-0.08970839530229568,
0.22789470851421356,
-0.32913219928741455,
-0.26085758209228516,
-0.6977207064628601,
0.7243068218231201,
-0.6627302169799805,
-0.7397895455360413,
-0.6761879920959473,
-0.9420540928840637,
-0.4815056324005127,
0.1636238843202591,
0.27743998169898987,
0.33460256457328796,
0.023318583145737648,
0.08227630704641342,
0.6047400236129761,
-0.2999047338962555,
0.5601633787155151,
0.8651566505432129,
-0.28821930289268494,
-0.2661021649837494,
0.6720851063728333,
0.28674352169036865,
0.11491713672876358,
-0.12997765839099884,
0.2503781318664551,
-0.44353702664375305,
-0.55182284116745,
-0.3205787241458893,
0.2798655927181244,
-0.9129388928413391,
-0.13571806252002716,
-0.7005932331085205,
-0.4143175184726715,
-0.29265403747558594,
-0.3912408947944641,
-0.4496968984603882,
0.0026786522939801216,
-0.31830593943595886,
0.2668774724006653,
-0.024109870195388794,
0.6305013298988342,
-0.16124661266803741,
0.08176911622285843,
-0.7472856640815735,
0.1969285011291504,
0.15321552753448486,
0.3461207449436188,
0.21648749709129333,
-0.9533605575561523,
0.20968644320964813,
-0.19706568121910095,
-0.3342965543270111,
-0.5923304557800293,
0.42154625058174133,
-0.4466016888618469,
0.4352911412715912,
0.550183892250061,
0.06520752608776093,
0.673632025718689,
-0.6629727482795715,
0.2968631088733673,
0.4124455749988556,
-1.1700141429901123,
0.19283288717269897,
-0.4134713411331177,
0.4354446232318878,
0.23876233398914337,
0.330371230840683,
-0.7493054270744324,
-0.2590261995792389,
-0.5862458348274231,
-0.37193554639816284,
0.5091319680213928,
0.22927048802375793,
0.1729055792093277,
-0.1751250922679901,
0.3917957842350006,
-0.1159432977437973,
-0.038896575570106506,
-0.7059220671653748,
-0.09325625002384186,
0.29839465022087097,
0.06252329796552658,
-0.06740420311689377,
-0.48071426153182983,
-0.12402445077896118,
-0.13567191362380981,
0.29472965002059937,
-0.23383593559265137,
0.1316731721162796,
-0.007943466305732727,
0.19580107927322388,
-0.6507309079170227,
0.35417842864990234,
0.6836700439453125,
1.011257290840149,
-0.07529448717832565,
0.15728668868541718,
0.5664241313934326,
-0.22509145736694336,
0.2040247619152069,
-0.14872223138809204,
0.06280691176652908,
0.014687283895909786,
0.3669133484363556,
0.19674549996852875,
0.14941640198230743,
-1.1363122463226318,
0.42668694257736206,
-0.1619594544172287,
-0.1856343299150467,
-0.649509847164154,
0.05324030667543411,
0.09831579774618149,
0.11513788998126984,
0.3486419916152954,
0.09188225120306015,
0.12642192840576172,
-0.550921618938446,
0.127055361866951,
0.584518313407898,
-0.13410420715808868,
-0.058322660624980927,
0.7507377862930298,
-0.10127703845500946,
-0.6364229321479797,
0.9293147325515747,
-0.15226826071739197,
-0.7802512645721436,
0.768792450428009,
0.9383155107498169,
0.5463945865631104,
-0.1991519182920456,
-0.005363854579627514,
0.28008201718330383,
0.3136841952800751,
-0.09216881543397903,
0.43739280104637146,
0.435700923204422,
-0.7831066250801086,
-0.3298393189907074,
-0.19505806267261505,
-0.5047853589057922,
0.4292932450771332,
-0.5472023487091064,
0.33426085114479065,
-0.9640475511550903,
0.12388046085834503,
0.18352633714675903,
-0.14484961330890656,
-0.5402345657348633,
0.11109458655118942,
0.11766719073057175,
0.6883614659309387,
-0.5058791637420654,
0.33422377705574036,
0.3784896731376648,
0.04573553055524826,
-1.0515443086624146,
-0.30278849601745605,
0.2793998420238495,
-1.0470935106277466,
0.5401361584663391,
0.3107629120349884,
-0.033508580178022385,
-0.4767119288444519,
-0.5872877240180969,
-0.45931997895240784,
0.46477341651916504,
0.5265652537345886,
-0.9334575533866882,
-0.03611190617084503,
0.3789076507091522,
0.46155303716659546,
-0.35106682777404785,
0.231828972697258,
0.5093405246734619,
0.4405279755592346,
0.2557782232761383,
-0.700946033000946,
0.35528889298439026,
0.06488803029060364,
-0.0070335399359464645,
0.33435240387916565,
-0.6252114772796631,
1.1868547201156616,
-0.4185353219509125,
-0.021430710330605507,
0.09492450207471848,
0.39553403854370117,
0.6444453597068787,
0.4167543053627014,
0.566983163356781,
0.7329481840133667,
0.6322345733642578,
-0.18750301003456116,
0.8331946730613708,
0.0753985270857811,
0.30562326312065125,
0.9133859872817993,
-0.4258281886577606,
0.7101268172264099,
0.40359556674957275,
-0.20064382255077362,
0.10803478211164474,
0.4698536694049835,
-0.14016900956630707,
-0.008509010076522827,
0.6821773052215576,
-0.19245579838752747,
-0.6360461115837097,
-0.0436943843960762,
-0.5007606148719788,
0.39377903938293457,
0.6113419532775879,
-0.20297934114933014,
-0.3115603029727936,
-0.16990189254283905,
0.2587655484676361,
0.2984573245048523,
-0.31594035029411316,
0.21264863014221191,
0.2775622308254242,
-0.7118483185768127,
0.7233787775039673,
0.15822680294513702,
0.36890220642089844,
-0.34897884726524353,
-0.2482345998287201,
-0.27598950266838074,
0.5332284569740295,
-0.14278492331504822,
-0.702708899974823,
0.24676547944545746,
0.06648466736078262,
-0.016373051330447197,
0.38103270530700684,
0.4260287582874298,
-0.03704323619604111,
-0.6717661619186401,
0.23301735520362854,
0.4919079840183258,
0.23531028628349304,
-0.17839063704013824,
-0.7166541814804077,
0.5730504989624023,
-0.06356538832187653,
0.0831170454621315,
0.14426513016223907,
0.709419310092926,
-0.016461333259940147,
0.9102783799171448,
0.6588200926780701,
0.024073978886008263,
-0.1833430826663971,
0.09358786791563034,
0.7623945474624634,
-0.7484204769134521,
-0.48301565647125244,
-1.0051015615463257,
0.27554604411125183,
0.047741737216711044,
-0.40889406204223633,
0.8282141089439392,
0.21687465906143188,
0.71632981300354,
0.0012114642886444926,
0.4531269669532776,
0.25992199778556824,
0.47711241245269775,
-0.5980474352836609,
0.44187116622924805,
-0.4853643774986267,
0.7310991287231445,
-0.4494873583316803,
-1.1802148818969727,
-0.45987752079963684,
0.6607967019081116,
-0.19706518948078156,
0.22117003798484802,
0.8912056088447571,
0.6005491018295288,
0.09567617624998093,
0.31046247482299805,
0.699807345867157,
0.2291310727596283,
0.41381320357322693,
0.8448013067245483,
1.0826460123062134,
-0.16890212893486023,
0.5893524289131165,
-0.12367230653762817,
-0.2559906840324402,
-0.19142933189868927,
-0.8277810215950012,
-1.3505338430404663,
-0.2927275002002716,
-0.16814103722572327,
-0.8698656558990479,
-0.13644152879714966,
0.9411954283714294,
0.3122576177120209,
-0.9475823044776917,
-0.2761057913303375,
-0.2036752998828888,
0.14897599816322327,
0.14966027438640594,
-0.2264152467250824,
0.266023725271225,
-0.38895660638809204,
-0.7748468518257141,
0.2198435366153717,
0.43451353907585144,
0.2513650059700012,
-0.45305168628692627,
-0.05434925854206085,
0.3226538598537445,
0.31729763746261597,
0.3317190706729889,
0.26924511790275574,
-0.7178376913070679,
-0.24964576959609985,
0.17352205514907837,
-0.15358226001262665,
-0.16828913986682892,
1.0968021154403687,
-0.3365999460220337,
0.43485525250434875,
0.12182904034852982,
0.892812192440033,
-0.18828673660755157,
-0.28915780782699585,
0.33841967582702637,
-0.12018376588821411,
0.21849451959133148,
0.36077016592025757,
0.6554530262947083,
0.21163183450698853,
-0.5511395335197449,
0.4207105040550232,
0.3130725026130676,
-0.6467993259429932,
-1.0707846879959106,
0.08448463678359985,
-0.7216522097587585,
-0.41244903206825256,
1.0588659048080444,
-0.18215526640415192,
-0.23711147904396057,
-0.04218052700161934,
-0.23760084807872772,
-0.24493536353111267,
-0.30260756611824036,
1.1045668125152588,
1.125811219215393,
-0.15770278871059418,
0.015230175107717514,
-0.7393881678581238,
0.2405925989151001,
0.9155792593955994,
-0.694012463092804,
0.25836288928985596,
0.6259458065032959,
0.22724400460720062,
0.19678723812103271,
0.4239276349544525,
-0.24762612581253052,
0.4597226679325104,
0.16318278014659882,
-0.37183430790901184,
0.036628905683755875,
-0.309967041015625,
-0.40893039107322693,
0.16546306014060974,
0.24503405392169952,
0.13582803308963776
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19340v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19340v1
|
Dataverse: Open-Source ETL (Extract, Transform, Load) Pipeline for Large Language Models
| 2024-03-28T11:57:08 | 2024-03-28T11:57:08 |
Hyunbyung Park, Sukyung Lee, Gyoungjin Gim, Yungi Kim, Dahyun Kim, Chanjun Park
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
To address the challenges associated with data processing at scale, we
propose Dataverse, a unified open-source Extract-Transform-Load (ETL) pipeline
for large language models (LLMs) with a user-friendly design at its core. Easy
addition of custom processors with block-based interface in Dataverse allows
users to readily and efficiently use Dataverse to build their own ETL pipeline.
We hope that Dataverse will serve as a vital tool for LLM development and open
source the entire library to welcome community contribution. Additionally, we
provide a concise, two-minute video demonstration of our system, illustrating
its capabilities and implementation.
|
[
-0.41867852210998535,
-0.8511643409729004,
0.43649327754974365,
0.22920827567577362,
-0.0761687308549881,
0.22539393603801727,
-0.2914135158061981,
-0.24954168498516083,
0.07615294307470322,
0.9677828550338745,
-0.6585662961006165,
-0.4790881872177124,
-0.6276285648345947,
0.23550058901309967,
-0.8509827852249146,
0.7755768895149231,
0.08085359632968903,
-0.16315975785255432,
-0.1367342323064804,
0.08376231044530869,
-0.36219552159309387,
-0.42771968245506287,
-0.46314480900764465,
-0.1675303876399994,
0.4306817054748535,
0.683811366558075,
0.9359268546104431,
1.1399264335632324,
0.6098760962486267,
0.2722731828689575,
0.15824580192565918,
-0.015613287687301636,
-0.6649258136749268,
0.4240287244319916,
-0.4787319302558899,
-0.3869877755641937,
-0.4238549470901489,
-0.012218466959893703,
0.8238126635551453,
1.0158898830413818,
-0.31075412034988403,
0.4616558849811554,
-0.17818371951580048,
0.8833085894584656,
-0.5820160508155823,
0.1928776055574417,
-0.5111356377601624,
0.12068730592727661,
-0.662851870059967,
-0.21811193227767944,
-0.4922972023487091,
-0.38711586594581604,
-0.29854816198349,
-0.5568222999572754,
-0.024179529398679733,
0.3580368757247925,
0.2971319258213043,
0.31510934233665466,
-0.3262764811515808,
0.2365482598543167,
-1.1752508878707886,
0.9744178652763367,
-0.36649858951568604,
0.7625037431716919,
0.0828285738825798,
0.83497154712677,
-0.24287083745002747,
-0.969708263874054,
-0.6160311102867126,
0.42863696813583374,
0.18435585498809814,
-0.2384631633758545,
-0.29686078429222107,
-0.31866157054901123,
0.32231467962265015,
0.5645017027854919,
-0.7121956944465637,
0.3033480942249298,
-0.5312738418579102,
0.11767414212226868,
0.6724058389663696,
0.5787571668624878,
0.13130544126033783,
0.16496728360652924,
-0.1612999588251114,
0.08019427955150604,
-1.1409275531768799,
-0.34575188159942627,
0.35216519236564636,
0.6326922178268433,
-0.08139504492282867,
0.8752730488777161,
-0.2844475209712982,
0.8490555882453918,
-0.32086068391799927,
0.2377859503030777,
0.15901535749435425,
-0.05511194095015526,
-0.5690395832061768,
0.03396229073405266,
0.6958216428756714,
0.2280900776386261,
0.065739206969738,
-0.27483439445495605,
-0.13876061141490936,
-0.149710550904274,
0.14219628274440765,
-0.9745417833328247,
-0.10434480011463165,
0.5919032692909241,
-0.4617191255092621,
-0.39964166283607483,
0.1423368752002716,
-1.1087361574172974,
-0.612700879573822,
-0.62345951795578,
-0.13518399000167847,
0.08788562566041946,
-0.5061909556388855,
0.12702296674251556,
-0.14848141372203827,
0.3310602307319641,
0.28526005148887634,
-0.5709013342857361,
0.5318253040313721,
0.9194940328598022,
0.7014586329460144,
-0.523544192314148,
-0.03587067872285843,
-1.1516293287277222,
0.09200270473957062,
-0.26866212487220764,
0.7440879344940186,
-0.6608507037162781,
-0.31503963470458984,
0.06462555378675461,
0.3866546154022217,
0.2975096106529236,
-0.5791004300117493,
0.5806488394737244,
-0.6346835494041443,
0.1350875347852707,
-0.20546504855155945,
-0.6149960160255432,
0.0994534119963646,
-0.16077658534049988,
-0.949972927570343,
0.9646228551864624,
0.3911513388156891,
-0.7573084831237793,
0.21461759507656097,
-0.9368351101875305,
-0.21029362082481384,
0.5206164121627808,
-0.3026542663574219,
0.01815982535481453,
0.0562276653945446,
-0.02904384769499302,
0.46854856610298157,
-0.6686506271362305,
0.4710133671760559,
-0.6857694387435913,
-0.3229343593120575,
0.334761381149292,
-0.4065094590187073,
1.2646430730819702,
0.7690598964691162,
-0.0353270098567009,
-0.053046051412820816,
-0.972097635269165,
-0.2207024246454239,
0.2523458003997803,
-0.3309800326824188,
-0.17201179265975952,
0.21481333673000336,
0.42790278792381287,
0.1705319583415985,
0.10138794034719467,
-0.805161714553833,
0.3830309510231018,
-0.35514792799949646,
0.4532068371772766,
0.7957981824874878,
-0.5304862260818481,
0.35338452458381653,
0.06162605434656143,
0.6252233982086182,
-0.09012499451637268,
0.08518809080123901,
0.02834158018231392,
-0.280778706073761,
-0.6759345531463623,
-0.5295601487159729,
0.14167490601539612,
0.5902062654495239,
-0.7116509079933167,
0.4466700851917267,
-0.513727068901062,
-0.38226908445358276,
-0.6613386273384094,
0.45016980171203613,
-0.1710614264011383,
0.4881495237350464,
0.23704794049263,
-0.1505611389875412,
-0.8021981716156006,
-0.9095408320426941,
-0.10604681819677353,
0.16885466873645782,
-0.19810493290424347,
0.23822134733200073,
0.25705957412719727,
-0.30980193614959717,
1.4083248376846313,
-0.7425532341003418,
-0.12106085568666458,
-0.40922483801841736,
-0.24507401883602142,
0.674899160861969,
0.23492980003356934,
0.28402599692344666,
-0.756108283996582,
-0.5804536938667297,
0.36179009079933167,
-0.9589058756828308,
-0.4658966064453125,
0.5577461123466492,
-0.23919659852981567,
0.15021410584449768,
0.5513691902160645,
-0.698834240436554,
0.28411558270454407,
0.5349843502044678,
-0.6382566690444946,
0.5039661526679993,
-0.05722881481051445,
-0.17954277992248535,
-1.0797606706619263,
0.4514022767543793,
-0.23073305189609528,
-0.6053481101989746,
-0.5990942120552063,
0.4117957353591919,
-0.005335239227861166,
-0.31688567996025085,
-0.7624433636665344,
0.5781952142715454,
-0.1518269181251526,
-0.4745165705680847,
-0.345176637172699,
-0.09693335741758347,
0.1156148687005043,
-0.10705720633268356,
0.04865549877285957,
0.5973266363143921,
0.9048015475273132,
-0.39096885919570923,
0.8083003759384155,
0.04008570685982704,
-0.23190107941627502,
0.7485010027885437,
-0.6325910687446594,
0.27928850054740906,
-0.16788901388645172,
0.1754722148180008,
-0.6672846078872681,
-0.34376993775367737,
0.13304831087589264,
0.05622883886098862,
0.3123268187046051,
-0.14871808886528015,
-0.7429001927375793,
-0.5645869970321655,
-0.17559997737407684,
-0.1298357993364334,
0.5414453744888306,
-0.8567340970039368,
0.6577329635620117,
0.4827042520046234,
-0.2861625850200653,
-0.5883432030677795,
-0.940015971660614,
0.33061376214027405,
-0.43974748253822327,
-0.5206438899040222,
0.106430783867836,
-0.3995327651500702,
-0.6514179110527039,
0.15100914239883423,
0.3482726514339447,
-0.1940692812204361,
0.2580982446670532,
0.3142075836658478,
0.420021653175354,
-0.01742180436849594,
-0.1189032569527626,
0.01251020934432745,
-0.17912638187408447,
0.012852005660533905,
-0.5719180703163147,
0.4596865773200989,
-0.04158757999539375,
-0.23518316447734833,
-0.0540546253323555,
0.7547334432601929,
0.7161138653755188,
0.013164888136088848,
0.6556411385536194,
0.4046904742717743,
-0.3473338484764099,
-0.3944830000400543,
-0.30136531591415405,
0.2061319649219513,
-0.5422711968421936,
0.2515019178390503,
-0.23343542218208313,
-1.2075523138046265,
0.461508184671402,
-0.23188374936580658,
0.3435695469379425,
0.5472527146339417,
0.8633779287338257,
-0.04371613636612892,
0.8578293919563293,
0.7865089178085327,
-0.24605368077754974,
0.07470676302909851,
-0.1596945971250534,
0.05598311871290207,
-0.631649374961853,
0.11135102808475494,
-0.6743278503417969,
-0.24213765561580658,
-0.22647243738174438,
-0.42881113290786743,
0.0448889285326004,
0.03939130902290344,
-0.475583016872406,
0.4346471130847931,
-0.5924103856086731,
0.6027156710624695,
0.2141573131084442,
-0.39907804131507874,
0.6135960221290588,
0.28702419996261597,
0.16251099109649658,
0.07560829073190689,
-0.3934214115142822,
-0.3289509415626526,
1.2689967155456543,
0.49810466170310974,
1.0062302350997925,
0.32872313261032104,
0.5334650278091431,
0.4452075958251953,
0.282441645860672,
-0.5980539321899414,
0.45401567220687866,
-0.3874405026435852,
-0.7091283202171326,
-0.17588692903518677,
-0.4656274914741516,
-0.9994983673095703,
-0.012718361802399158,
0.019619805738329887,
-0.8609501123428345,
0.23935522139072418,
-0.16494108736515045,
-0.08657849580049515,
0.364903062582016,
-0.4714900255203247,
0.676410973072052,
-0.027153227478265762,
-0.2941797077655792,
-0.05860559269785881,
-0.42871832847595215,
0.389667809009552,
-0.35052689909935,
0.5521481037139893,
0.06582719087600708,
0.02682122215628624,
0.5448783040046692,
-0.7665576934814453,
0.688765823841095,
-0.22336088120937347,
-0.14948770403862,
0.29547783732414246,
0.31732404232025146,
0.6090996861457825,
0.013914070092141628,
-0.1396191418170929,
0.4278998374938965,
-0.3514259159564972,
-0.1539134383201599,
-0.4424764811992645,
0.9187896847724915,
-0.7537016272544861,
-0.40762659907341003,
-0.07600802928209305,
-0.62338787317276,
0.26307934522628784,
0.29648444056510925,
-0.17227238416671753,
0.40418151021003723,
-0.1486646831035614,
0.41384103894233704,
0.5871554613113403,
-0.18103013932704926,
0.5889958143234253,
0.8462173938751221,
-0.9162449240684509,
-0.31867459416389465,
1.065934419631958,
0.13524222373962402,
0.1231636181473732,
0.30190861225128174,
0.14483454823493958,
-0.27838125824928284,
-0.3799631595611572,
-0.6137145757675171,
-0.1418992280960083,
-0.8521198034286499,
-0.2079022228717804,
-0.8554578423500061,
-0.1549520194530487,
-0.3267030417919159,
-0.17831265926361084,
-0.7854399085044861,
-0.6976688504219055,
-0.2942081391811371,
-0.1625760793685913,
0.6938452124595642,
0.6683409214019775,
-0.1358189433813095,
0.12562066316604614,
-0.6954348087310791,
0.2492855340242386,
0.3446193337440491,
0.5143179893493652,
-0.44956105947494507,
-0.43071797490119934,
-0.2431817650794983,
-0.2751147150993347,
-0.23701466619968414,
-0.3108060956001282,
0.6493939757347107,
0.22740931808948517,
0.42534732818603516,
0.3917500972747803,
0.044768594205379486,
0.3351249694824219,
-0.5345728397369385,
0.8556044697761536,
0.09694258123636246,
-0.7517830729484558,
0.4603272080421448,
-0.2010006606578827,
0.21979747712612152,
0.3230842053890228,
0.4838969111442566,
-0.4008788466453552,
-0.39720484614372253,
-0.37066030502319336,
-0.7322410345077515,
0.7291589975357056,
0.10263349115848541,
-0.19172824919223785,
0.1311851441860199,
0.1011008769273758,
0.7425885796546936,
0.17556768655776978,
-0.36377227306365967,
-0.6611281037330627,
-0.13966204226016998,
-0.1215418353676796,
-0.06296002119779587,
0.11630041897296906,
-0.22015082836151123,
-0.3432845175266266,
0.2852071225643158,
-0.37314414978027344,
0.319634348154068,
-0.0614844374358654,
-0.08152250945568085,
-0.4613122045993805,
0.2593015134334564,
-0.010623456910252571,
0.7102947235107422,
-0.4688228964805603,
0.25026777386665344,
-0.23964647948741913,
-0.37399572134017944,
-0.03377049043774605,
0.5311557650566101,
-0.10369250178337097,
-0.1964227855205536,
0.14504089951515198,
0.7862088680267334,
-0.19577813148498535,
-0.7812332510948181,
0.4206959307193756,
-0.21913690865039825,
-0.1710108071565628,
-0.4023243188858032,
0.07384662330150604,
0.17077064514160156,
0.44731736183166504,
0.5537589192390442,
-0.09044378250837326,
0.3745666444301605,
-0.4652533233165741,
0.27954337000846863,
0.2151860147714615,
-0.27057045698165894,
-0.34285977482795715,
0.8923227787017822,
-0.025891095399856567,
-0.20755437016487122,
0.7291581630706787,
-0.09609252959489822,
-0.2700327932834625,
0.30608493089675903,
0.5272918343544006,
1.1297903060913086,
0.025868171826004982,
0.07883647084236145,
0.032499849796295166,
0.19162139296531677,
0.06928638368844986,
0.40592044591903687,
0.11305470764636993,
-0.6660630106925964,
-0.9153496026992798,
-0.783973217010498,
-0.4488673508167267,
0.056819234043359756,
-0.33860015869140625,
0.6002624034881592,
-0.3948533236980438,
0.3028729557991028,
0.07594246417284012,
-0.12036287039518356,
-1.0109989643096924,
-0.11643111705780029,
0.48731565475463867,
1.0857365131378174,
-0.8414523005485535,
1.1840989589691162,
0.5565634369850159,
-0.008982363156974316,
-0.6191514134407043,
-0.7448480129241943,
0.24293626844882965,
-0.623786449432373,
1.0488380193710327,
0.07879336923360825,
0.24651122093200684,
0.23342855274677277,
-0.8337821960449219,
-0.9737949967384338,
1.153151035308838,
0.6648961901664734,
-0.6045541763305664,
0.3114427626132965,
0.6465088725090027,
0.29493555426597595,
-0.7044905424118042,
0.4097801744937897,
0.5627050995826721,
0.6512230038642883,
0.018662715330719948,
-0.7124641537666321,
0.09763838350772858,
-0.23810791969299316,
-0.17057274281978607,
0.25224006175994873,
-0.3966163098812103,
1.0456209182739258,
0.20188383758068085,
-0.3322017192840576,
-0.3126428425312042,
0.5205876231193542,
0.17050495743751526,
0.01956046000123024,
0.4491437077522278,
0.8057843446731567,
0.7547101974487305,
0.05695020779967308,
1.1973360776901245,
-0.21920953691005707,
0.5569228529930115,
0.9668952226638794,
-0.5530472993850708,
0.7548474669456482,
0.47080668807029724,
-0.4771418273448944,
0.42351770401000977,
0.3946954905986786,
0.053922273218631744,
0.4103982448577881,
0.04900011047720909,
-0.02786043845117092,
-0.2967735528945923,
-0.2546252906322479,
-0.2787027359008789,
0.3140065670013428,
0.46861732006073,
-0.3251415193080902,
-0.4331865608692169,
-0.0611003041267395,
-0.26190078258514404,
-0.3394862711429596,
-0.3156006634235382,
0.3644721806049347,
0.2936004102230072,
-0.2079596072435379,
0.5015650987625122,
-0.0768967941403389,
0.4488411247730255,
-0.3321904242038727,
-0.1460244059562683,
-0.2247716188430786,
0.0551961287856102,
-0.4010012745857239,
-1.0779215097427368,
0.6397373676300049,
0.21850687265396118,
-0.2525486350059509,
-0.3081454932689667,
0.8514558672904968,
-0.3602917492389679,
-0.6169184446334839,
0.4767172634601593,
0.413770854473114,
0.4623647928237915,
-0.1097455844283104,
-0.6634556651115417,
0.5985075235366821,
-0.08931946754455566,
-0.5966035723686218,
0.5163459777832031,
0.3842521607875824,
0.06332945078611374,
0.8851870894432068,
0.8653051257133484,
0.23758871853351593,
0.016551664099097252,
-0.0797392725944519,
1.0356240272521973,
-0.8219521045684814,
-0.13464772701263428,
-0.8277910947799683,
0.7544188499450684,
-0.13192559778690338,
0.17846471071243286,
0.5191395282745361,
0.5711043477058411,
0.5748439431190491,
-0.07119373232126236,
0.9347426295280457,
-0.5088061690330505,
0.7271355986595154,
-0.13146130740642548,
0.518303632736206,
-0.4993746876716614,
0.30936652421951294,
-0.10418816655874252,
-1.3061473369598389,
-0.4722508192062378,
0.017783593386411667,
0.105366051197052,
-0.5158782601356506,
0.7056774497032166,
0.6772334575653076,
-0.22700101137161255,
0.1952010691165924,
0.27038341760635376,
0.3132089674472809,
0.6622357368469238,
0.5784789323806763,
0.544823169708252,
-0.17756813764572144,
0.4459163248538971,
-0.29329928755760193,
-0.3513350784778595,
-0.20343488454818726,
-1.2053272724151611,
-0.7034363150596619,
-0.2528795301914215,
-0.4191420078277588,
-0.15175555646419525,
-0.3257890045642853,
1.0517350435256958,
0.5643633008003235,
-0.7656482458114624,
-0.3254437744617462,
-0.28971824049949646,
0.08910229057073593,
-0.19868695735931396,
-0.31313809752464294,
0.26198410987854004,
0.023407699540257454,
-0.9247926473617554,
0.7973290681838989,
0.4908030033111572,
-0.5303853154182434,
-0.7749741673469543,
-0.1350606232881546,
0.12811608612537384,
-0.2766461968421936,
0.6111488938331604,
0.43041011691093445,
-0.2348129004240036,
-0.1451295018196106,
-0.136361762881279,
-0.10881593078374863,
-0.03706507757306099,
0.6898384094238281,
-0.774653434753418,
0.6369502544403076,
0.5818790197372437,
0.8539057970046997,
0.3397282361984253,
-0.22302314639091492,
0.8607414364814758,
-0.6300038695335388,
0.14880628883838654,
-0.1937922239303589,
0.33923450112342834,
0.37134990096092224,
-0.6213213205337524,
0.7776476740837097,
0.4849565029144287,
-0.6130339503288269,
-0.8983511924743652,
0.11534930765628815,
-1.0884654521942139,
-0.2831021845340729,
1.0868560075759888,
0.06278820335865021,
-0.2919733226299286,
-0.29192671179771423,
0.07743668556213379,
0.016874436289072037,
-0.45765018463134766,
0.17041204869747162,
0.5571500658988953,
0.0674864798784256,
-0.05248744413256645,
-0.9920234084129333,
0.04880686476826668,
-0.1577579379081726,
-0.6838025450706482,
0.5220116376876831,
0.5061194896697998,
0.1932811439037323,
0.0552789531648159,
0.34641847014427185,
-0.3815023899078369,
-0.15079079568386078,
-0.26734158396720886,
0.23558960855007172,
-0.26500892639160156,
-0.38040098547935486,
-0.456874281167984,
0.26617375016212463,
-0.06440625339746475,
0.26539912819862366
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19335v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19335v2
|
KazSAnDRA: Kazakh Sentiment Analysis Dataset of Reviews and Attitudes
| 2024-03-28T11:51:11 | 2024-04-09T21:06:32 |
Rustem Yeshpanov, Huseyin Atakan Varol
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper presents KazSAnDRA, a dataset developed for Kazakh sentiment
analysis that is the first and largest publicly available dataset of its kind.
KazSAnDRA comprises an extensive collection of 180,064 reviews obtained from
various sources and includes numerical ratings ranging from 1 to 5, providing a
quantitative representation of customer attitudes. The study also pursued the
automation of Kazakh sentiment classification through the development and
evaluation of four machine learning models trained for both polarity
classification and score classification. Experimental analysis included
evaluation of the results considering both balanced and imbalanced scenarios.
The most successful model attained an F1-score of 0.81 for polarity
classification and 0.39 for score classification on the test sets. The dataset
and fine-tuned models are open access and available for download under the
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0) through our
GitHub repository.
|
[
-0.5355316400527954,
-0.1385730504989624,
0.14519846439361572,
0.7249907851219177,
-0.5059894919395447,
0.08239846676588058,
-0.056042272597551346,
-0.15537559986114502,
0.3192400634288788,
0.5498231649398804,
-0.6464331746101379,
-1.1123324632644653,
-0.5565122365951538,
0.043261170387268066,
-0.1486498862504959,
1.527907371520996,
-0.04992105811834335,
0.5797662138938904,
0.1513977348804474,
-0.6482412815093994,
-0.07112796604633331,
-0.41030430793762207,
0.010721540078520775,
-0.21355904638767242,
0.4939121603965759,
0.6454658508300781,
0.7755336761474609,
-0.25295737385749817,
0.4647984206676483,
0.23758621513843536,
0.05983226001262665,
-0.014973769895732403,
-0.11575508862733841,
0.3921910524368286,
-0.007191333454102278,
-0.45995745062828064,
-0.41436535120010376,
0.19342616200447083,
0.7093570828437805,
0.5402376055717468,
-0.30522534251213074,
0.849998950958252,
-0.059173405170440674,
1.148024082183838,
-0.6477566957473755,
0.3478300869464874,
-0.046709273010492325,
0.46530643105506897,
-0.16409797966480255,
0.2905981242656708,
-0.3617117404937744,
-0.6212831139564514,
-0.1276666224002838,
-0.49049481749534607,
0.19284431636333466,
-0.017527561634778976,
0.7890175580978394,
-0.06742849946022034,
-0.5245879292488098,
-0.5523266196250916,
-0.9034934639930725,
0.9735472202301025,
-0.5799996256828308,
0.19586099684238434,
-0.026982218027114868,
0.8113747835159302,
0.12566442787647247,
-0.16189414262771606,
-0.8430830836296082,
-0.14888672530651093,
0.2253710925579071,
0.579534113407135,
0.02004220150411129,
0.03525666892528534,
-0.06722339242696762,
0.5545644164085388,
-0.5274596214294434,
-0.465619295835495,
-0.719491720199585,
0.09025091677904129,
1.011447787284851,
0.6539860367774963,
0.23102699220180511,
-0.5749211311340332,
-0.329182893037796,
-0.20637747645378113,
-0.3254503905773163,
0.4309498071670532,
1.0434184074401855,
0.5092926621437073,
0.022760238498449326,
0.9082625508308411,
-0.7644139528274536,
0.6841502785682678,
0.267402708530426,
0.15439625084400177,
0.5408300757408142,
-0.25484970211982727,
-0.5944388508796692,
-0.02696220390498638,
0.8896182179450989,
0.4897523820400238,
-0.1837204247713089,
0.15738628804683685,
-0.12524613738059998,
0.3835066258907318,
0.48249226808547974,
-0.4301988184452057,
-0.20770516991615295,
0.5725113153457642,
-0.8363591432571411,
-0.8861576914787292,
0.6489107608795166,
-1.0656386613845825,
-0.881676971912384,
-0.35096243023872375,
0.14084061980247498,
0.23441888391971588,
-0.5280622243881226,
0.2295449674129486,
0.02791760489344597,
0.4358732998371124,
0.4482518136501312,
-0.5814945697784424,
0.401047021150589,
0.6787239909172058,
0.7795764207839966,
0.04233556240797043,
-0.15684551000595093,
-0.024367865175008774,
-0.5020514130592346,
-0.4914977252483368,
1.032591462135315,
-0.2833552062511444,
-0.31891921162605286,
-0.06848514080047607,
0.21868988871574402,
0.10778697580099106,
-0.5432958006858826,
0.7155611515045166,
-0.749485194683075,
0.2165844738483429,
-0.4540591239929199,
-0.23382554948329926,
-0.6596959829330444,
0.24595369398593903,
-0.7997743487358093,
0.5136382579803467,
0.6494076251983643,
-0.7388690114021301,
0.5600208044052124,
-0.5991708040237427,
-0.05948794260621071,
-0.0550432987511158,
0.09484094381332397,
-0.5274815559387207,
0.08342474699020386,
-0.17972597479820251,
0.27117711305618286,
-0.20139947533607483,
0.05796842649579048,
-0.520488440990448,
-0.011697109788656235,
0.24132201075553894,
0.26633772253990173,
1.2198983430862427,
0.6037600636482239,
-0.140459805727005,
0.3545309007167816,
-0.3866075575351715,
0.15015682578086853,
-0.22744956612586975,
-0.23512205481529236,
0.06611158698797226,
-0.2833329737186432,
0.4499029815196991,
0.6367252469062805,
0.07197847217321396,
-0.9206012487411499,
0.19732904434204102,
-0.4728449881076813,
-0.2343629002571106,
0.8084595799446106,
-0.040765322744846344,
0.4503677189350128,
-0.200167715549469,
1.2173806428909302,
0.3683116137981415,
0.6825599074363708,
0.5297426581382751,
-0.43870267271995544,
-0.6488165259361267,
-0.021388012915849686,
0.16937978565692902,
0.6243739128112793,
-0.4560783803462982,
0.446162611246109,
-0.2070099115371704,
-0.983449399471283,
-0.9313411116600037,
0.4764617085456848,
0.3173544108867645,
0.4536369740962982,
0.016326434910297394,
-0.09903305023908615,
-0.4016440212726593,
-1.2502833604812622,
-0.3041730523109436,
-0.18167106807231903,
0.12314064055681229,
0.2683370113372803,
0.19361236691474915,
0.10284443199634552,
0.6326232552528381,
-0.5393785834312439,
-0.6176279187202454,
-0.5325068831443787,
0.13763542473316193,
0.4921853542327881,
-0.0667860209941864,
0.6979316473007202,
-0.8227959275245667,
-1.1297298669815063,
0.24434125423431396,
-0.8015849590301514,
-0.01056853961199522,
0.4061473309993744,
-0.2764865756034851,
0.47376611828804016,
-0.19944749772548676,
-0.7739282846450806,
0.2334604263305664,
0.6525232791900635,
-0.6581164002418518,
0.7923917770385742,
0.5250935554504395,
0.4628104567527771,
-1.1804144382476807,
0.17511442303657532,
0.13009503483772278,
0.1591106653213501,
-0.5173822045326233,
-0.15182702243328094,
-0.25343161821365356,
-0.16230197250843048,
-0.34949377179145813,
0.2846219539642334,
-0.1030937060713768,
-0.3126462996006012,
-0.3411732316017151,
-0.11954433470964432,
0.14346902072429657,
0.5040097236633301,
-0.4128045439720154,
0.5136240124702454,
0.47753891348838806,
-0.16791117191314697,
1.0900766849517822,
0.8084768056869507,
-0.7887214422225952,
0.5403928756713867,
-0.4260109066963196,
-0.019156960770487785,
-0.48695120215415955,
0.24530033767223358,
-0.9316757321357727,
-0.4588724672794342,
0.8692299723625183,
-0.7632067799568176,
-0.21656686067581177,
-0.40412798523902893,
-0.2707015872001648,
-0.3248682916164398,
-0.548470139503479,
-0.09839620441198349,
0.4835476279258728,
-0.4233154356479645,
0.6437885761260986,
0.6696416139602661,
-0.6018241047859192,
-0.8738960027694702,
-0.200245663523674,
-0.3021540343761444,
-0.3471887409687042,
-0.32366251945495605,
-0.29230108857154846,
0.2893438935279846,
-0.5365919470787048,
0.02901393175125122,
0.012089760042726994,
-0.006081991828978062,
-0.3588142693042755,
0.6690646409988403,
0.4905858635902405,
-0.17934845387935638,
0.17129066586494446,
0.1323283463716507,
-0.1171097457408905,
0.3167954385280609,
0.19856047630310059,
0.5967088341712952,
-0.48061513900756836,
-0.008290049619972706,
-0.579547643661499,
0.3453028202056885,
0.9412713646888733,
0.23347504436969757,
0.910983145236969,
0.6075790524482727,
-0.04948277771472931,
-0.31331679224967957,
-0.0656481683254242,
0.4277700185775757,
-0.3940746486186981,
0.4788439869880676,
0.041153911501169205,
0.01788194291293621,
0.6399742364883423,
0.3494347929954529,
0.1064496859908104,
0.6315146684646606,
0.6330558061599731,
-0.13352881371974945,
1.3710812330245972,
0.3436606228351593,
-0.6856167316436768,
0.24724110960960388,
-0.0984281674027443,
0.4485028088092804,
-0.5552816987037659,
-0.4580449163913727,
-0.6046163439750671,
-0.17928215861320496,
-0.6370400786399841,
0.2061396837234497,
0.25187259912490845,
-0.17626048624515533,
-0.17472141981124878,
-0.23467722535133362,
-0.3705713450908661,
0.456538587808609,
0.1662352830171585,
0.41336649656295776,
0.1422627568244934,
-0.0558265782892704,
0.37921106815338135,
0.11510501801967621,
-0.17369647324085236,
-0.7986024618148804,
1.208419680595398,
0.12880584597587585,
0.5687668919563293,
0.18627728521823883,
0.20614641904830933,
0.8405607342720032,
0.8531409502029419,
-1.0343708992004395,
0.3652559220790863,
-0.25764769315719604,
-0.6849070191383362,
-0.3604375123977661,
-0.288591206073761,
-0.4739072024822235,
0.04767531901597977,
-0.4138312041759491,
-0.20415857434272766,
-0.07733285427093506,
0.22497586905956268,
-0.618023693561554,
0.218858540058136,
-0.49262529611587524,
0.8513458371162415,
0.23736466467380524,
-0.1610344797372818,
-0.3026629388332367,
-0.4822101593017578,
0.7993564605712891,
0.20727626979351044,
-0.06275743991136551,
-0.3770983815193176,
0.37906086444854736,
0.7872992157936096,
-0.2865435779094696,
0.4797033667564392,
-0.959847092628479,
0.1878352165222168,
0.5077148079872131,
-0.09082945436239243,
0.16540928184986115,
0.08803654462099075,
-0.1792433261871338,
0.002511832630261779,
0.2531474232673645,
-0.6761369705200195,
-0.8758836984634399,
0.6981579065322876,
-1.1406677961349487,
-0.21056139469146729,
-0.5769595503807068,
-0.19656498730182648,
-0.5015639066696167,
-0.05563006550073624,
0.11414915323257446,
0.37450772523880005,
-0.12647148966789246,
0.08269111812114716,
0.37621068954467773,
-0.36324191093444824,
-0.3584771156311035,
0.3260389268398285,
-0.7572246193885803,
-0.6425519585609436,
0.9200264811515808,
0.0838029533624649,
-0.03986567258834839,
-0.27349668741226196,
0.024457596242427826,
-0.32748040556907654,
-0.39376962184906006,
-0.6921699047088623,
-0.0708504319190979,
-1.02972412109375,
-0.4830630421638489,
-0.6050040125846863,
-0.35907840728759766,
-0.452207088470459,
0.1854247897863388,
-0.47238990664482117,
-0.4075779616832733,
0.1998857855796814,
-0.30311381816864014,
0.3082972466945648,
1.1735419034957886,
0.30521368980407715,
0.5559737086296082,
-0.6959844827651978,
0.3433134853839874,
0.11554666608572006,
0.628272533416748,
0.02369331382215023,
-0.22702272236347198,
-0.35865744948387146,
0.060290638357400894,
-0.3581545948982239,
-0.9025641679763794,
0.677552342414856,
-0.235412135720253,
0.25528383255004883,
0.4968061149120331,
0.23490402102470398,
0.17966094613075256,
0.3131572902202606,
0.7496307492256165,
-0.037361301481723785,
-0.7391915917396545,
0.21067754924297333,
-0.6216592192649841,
0.2615905702114105,
0.9138411283493042,
0.5902760624885559,
-0.6012927889823914,
-0.1704595983028412,
-0.5024114847183228,
-0.5769369006156921,
0.8583719730377197,
0.029878228902816772,
0.15314194560050964,
0.35885342955589294,
0.37157827615737915,
0.5878808498382568,
0.517929196357727,
-0.4829392433166504,
-0.3118894100189209,
-0.43349432945251465,
-0.8466025590896606,
-0.22043335437774658,
-0.16871939599514008,
0.08879831433296204,
-0.2916830778121948,
0.900577187538147,
0.12587939202785492,
0.2931031882762909,
-0.13074590265750885,
-0.14312955737113953,
-0.433943510055542,
0.24940083920955658,
0.4361985921859741,
0.5934758186340332,
-0.38793089985847473,
-0.4120733439922333,
-0.01595251075923443,
-0.9398362636566162,
0.1121767908334732,
-0.25104761123657227,
-0.3781840205192566,
0.07514245808124542,
-0.26926568150520325,
0.5359882116317749,
-0.5594403147697449,
-0.4758440852165222,
0.484499454498291,
-0.13656781613826752,
-0.2545892000198364,
-0.7220981121063232,
-0.03699243813753128,
-0.17287446558475494,
0.2189071625471115,
0.32156047224998474,
0.2568587362766266,
0.3738449215888977,
-0.42160457372665405,
-0.18393848836421967,
0.4234752953052521,
-0.5760015249252319,
-0.6613013744354248,
-0.0529850535094738,
0.02329774759709835,
0.0729156881570816,
0.7454667091369629,
-0.19560134410858154,
-0.8034213781356812,
0.6428824663162231,
-0.040455546230077744,
0.9179620146751404,
-0.3688189685344696,
0.8781772255897522,
0.6951119899749756,
0.010758311487734318,
-0.005600235424935818,
0.7135472893714905,
-0.03917016088962555,
-0.8053145408630371,
0.11036073416471481,
-0.9112306237220764,
-0.7205087542533875,
0.1499580442905426,
-1.0710058212280273,
0.46480587124824524,
-0.8302095532417297,
-0.4057314693927765,
0.16911809146404266,
0.43460148572921753,
-0.42566022276878357,
0.2549434006214142,
-0.060139745473861694,
0.6376346945762634,
-1.389233946800232,
0.35583171248435974,
0.7733346223831177,
-0.3619127571582794,
-0.47704893350601196,
-0.28136321902275085,
-0.13288238644599915,
-0.322674959897995,
0.6292759776115417,
0.22711549699306488,
-0.5099828839302063,
-0.386703222990036,
-0.7938013672828674,
-0.5158785581588745,
0.8933612108230591,
-0.21067307889461517,
-0.20134252309799194,
0.4184664487838745,
0.1513456106185913,
0.6271190643310547,
-0.4332732856273651,
-0.3016608655452728,
0.49659299850463867,
0.5247105956077576,
-0.31600421667099,
-0.4692271649837494,
-0.30902206897735596,
-0.7636303901672363,
-0.6751928925514221,
0.29684197902679443,
-0.9505072236061096,
0.9784170389175415,
0.15428023040294647,
-0.1673843413591385,
0.02661389857530594,
0.5424836277961731,
0.3224831521511078,
0.6742010712623596,
0.5379607081413269,
0.23048149049282074,
0.5569970011711121,
0.264727383852005,
0.7261714339256287,
-0.16511991620063782,
0.446431964635849,
0.8162280321121216,
-0.5043169856071472,
0.6179465651512146,
0.3106827735900879,
-0.46288836002349854,
0.676292359828949,
0.4802688658237457,
-0.1580163985490799,
0.6551088094711304,
0.0993688777089119,
-0.5989159345626831,
-0.20131488144397736,
-0.11885804682970047,
-0.14305634796619415,
0.6748565435409546,
0.2283276915550232,
-0.35243260860443115,
-0.19310423731803894,
0.13919445872306824,
-0.09559604525566101,
0.03503977507352829,
-0.6544516682624817,
0.5938194394111633,
-0.1361169070005417,
-0.5684257745742798,
-0.10676813125610352,
0.11505109816789627,
0.3002961575984955,
-0.3812662661075592,
0.08352188020944595,
-0.1610977202653885,
0.3446640372276306,
-0.5272538661956787,
-0.910166323184967,
0.5430220365524292,
0.09171392768621445,
-0.43747350573539734,
0.03470095619559288,
0.6601900458335876,
-0.08949165791273117,
-0.8998429775238037,
-0.04058520123362541,
0.38013213872909546,
0.01450851559638977,
0.02309277281165123,
-0.5432047843933105,
-0.15274415910243988,
-0.11907123029232025,
-0.6071137189865112,
0.3421911597251892,
0.10432664304971695,
-0.12550057470798492,
0.6150791645050049,
0.3013913035392761,
0.2000194489955902,
-0.006555043160915375,
0.019759690389037132,
0.8665421009063721,
-0.8903950452804565,
-0.6504335403442383,
-0.43566226959228516,
0.1381402313709259,
-0.14323174953460693,
-0.46315526962280273,
0.9195224046707153,
0.48374468088150024,
0.5330817103385925,
-0.5725179314613342,
1.0347528457641602,
0.05202201381325722,
0.7968356609344482,
-0.3209172189235687,
1.1081578731536865,
0.03773435577750206,
-0.29674679040908813,
-0.22527295351028442,
-0.6778859496116638,
-0.2072037309408188,
0.5886908769607544,
-0.4681210517883301,
0.1858098804950714,
0.0769742801785469,
0.6560434103012085,
0.11812636256217957,
0.5327266454696655,
-0.031689342111349106,
0.1390480101108551,
-0.13468872010707855,
0.24222977459430695,
1.1345134973526,
-0.39959946274757385,
0.14471633732318878,
-0.44665923714637756,
-0.16030733287334442,
-0.19215279817581177,
-0.32212698459625244,
-0.9005672931671143,
-0.5861418843269348,
-0.013792065903544426,
-0.675365149974823,
-0.07974687963724136,
1.3296579122543335,
0.26281073689460754,
-1.177677869796753,
-0.2930661737918854,
0.12525829672813416,
0.04014314338564873,
-0.008474457077682018,
-0.2823263704776764,
0.3640049993991852,
-0.16603203117847443,
-0.41572579741477966,
-0.33236801624298096,
0.12281820178031921,
-0.0035110206808894873,
-0.5796656012535095,
-0.20998094975948334,
0.29491665959358215,
0.08103320002555847,
0.45946139097213745,
0.2722216248512268,
-0.2971698045730591,
0.14062033593654633,
0.29107898473739624,
-0.08728853613138199,
0.16135273873806,
0.6628807783126831,
-0.5266422629356384,
0.1608162671327591,
0.6363306045532227,
-0.15339815616607666,
0.09104029834270477,
0.3680097162723541,
0.5262969732284546,
-0.06045368313789368,
0.12910345196723938,
0.43502259254455566,
0.03825818747282028,
0.3740987479686737,
-0.47609153389930725,
-0.06124039739370346,
-0.2728515565395355,
-0.4188002645969391,
-0.8852620124816895,
0.11341147869825363,
-1.1452265977859497,
0.16533078253269196,
0.8920236825942993,
-0.2323576807975769,
-0.5297009348869324,
-0.32135412096977234,
-0.39239567518234253,
0.12573875486850739,
-0.379764586687088,
1.466657280921936,
0.9564011096954346,
-0.20434588193893433,
0.06191512942314148,
-0.6766182780265808,
0.6704355478286743,
0.1944352090358734,
-0.8443311452865601,
0.32979223132133484,
0.5474029779434204,
0.37146905064582825,
0.03775779902935028,
0.5175629258155823,
-0.46693089604377747,
0.4957215487957001,
-0.005419551860541105,
0.11277512460947037,
-0.03866815194487572,
-0.7118417620658875,
-0.6249688863754272,
0.32572054862976074,
0.11579890549182892,
-0.06242809072136879
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19322v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19322v2
|
Plug-and-Play Grounding of Reasoning in Multimodal Large Language Models
| 2024-03-28T11:26:30 | 2024-06-18T05:57:14 |
Jiaxing Chen, Yuxuan Liu, Dehu Li, Xiang An, Weimo Deng, Ziyong Feng, Yongle Zhao, Yin Xie
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
The rise of Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs), renowned for their
advanced instruction-following and reasoning capabilities, has significantly
propelled the field of visual reasoning. However, due to limitations in their
image tokenization processes, most MLLMs struggle to capture fine details of
text and objects in images, especially in high-resolution samples. To overcome
this limitation, we introduce P2G, a novel framework for plug-and-play
grounding in MLLMs. P2G utilizes the tool-usage potential of MLLMs to employ
expert agents for on-the-fly grounding of reasoning into critical visual and
textual elements in images, thereby enabling deliberate reasoning through
multimodal prompting. Additionally, we develop P2GB, a benchmark designed to
evaluate MLLMs' proficiency in understanding inter-object relationships and
textual content in challenging high-resolution images. Extensive experiments on
visual reasoning tasks demonstrate the superiority of P2G, achieving
performance comparable to GPT-4V on P2GB with a 7B backbone. Our work
underscores the potential of grounding reasoning with external agents in MLLMs,
presenting a promising alternative to mere model scaling.
|
[
-0.44844359159469604,
-0.8116087317466736,
0.822651743888855,
0.22193457186222076,
-0.12493501603603363,
-0.23485034704208374,
-0.4110996127128601,
-0.06344830989837646,
-0.48795759677886963,
0.5269836187362671,
-0.3202076852321625,
-0.4357869029045105,
-0.4893818199634552,
-0.29622358083724976,
0.00976318959146738,
0.5245746374130249,
-0.07296739518642426,
-0.0451604463160038,
-0.6852812170982361,
-0.21837934851646423,
-0.7752777934074402,
-0.4209989905357361,
-0.5004053115844727,
-0.3776850402355194,
0.4980420768260956,
0.4137912392616272,
0.9947437644004822,
0.5193430185317993,
0.49642789363861084,
0.24352970719337463,
0.02111651375889778,
0.7264494299888611,
-0.2985604405403137,
0.07199079543352127,
-0.5141692757606506,
-0.5278956890106201,
-0.19750207662582397,
0.08595478534698486,
0.42167046666145325,
0.35410910844802856,
0.12970517575740814,
-0.09438951313495636,
-0.3548186719417572,
0.5691484212875366,
-0.6472551226615906,
0.389828622341156,
-0.7180599570274353,
0.10847019404172897,
0.2454378604888916,
-0.31683847308158875,
-0.875783383846283,
0.1718408614397049,
-0.12113581597805023,
-0.6819071769714355,
0.15899014472961426,
0.10674209892749786,
0.9366012215614319,
0.4258630573749542,
-0.5670105814933777,
-0.04233325645327568,
-0.5586734414100647,
0.5630171895027161,
-0.5487861633300781,
0.4030107855796814,
0.5632245540618896,
0.348642498254776,
-0.2786136865615845,
-0.7898825407028198,
-0.6024600267410278,
-0.3589850962162018,
-0.28902894258499146,
0.0375412218272686,
0.1328495740890503,
0.07204948365688324,
0.6531153321266174,
0.17154671251773834,
-0.5322472453117371,
-0.10076704621315002,
0.02098480425775051,
-0.17394959926605225,
0.4590187966823578,
-0.21505294740200043,
0.25208988785743713,
0.10893463343381882,
-0.40905940532684326,
0.0637321025133133,
-0.8521036505699158,
0.17763115465641022,
0.023245753720402718,
0.09722431004047394,
0.014687295071780682,
0.7546224594116211,
0.05653204023838043,
0.6824040412902832,
0.22460971772670746,
-0.24912339448928833,
0.05183491110801697,
-0.21081097424030304,
-0.20100003480911255,
-0.22174905240535736,
0.6066226363182068,
0.7721140384674072,
0.11277074366807938,
-0.22369366884231567,
-0.23881131410598755,
0.18292494118213654,
0.15380124747753143,
-0.7839992046356201,
-0.4645273685455322,
0.27490344643592834,
-0.6358110904693604,
-0.06844722479581833,
-0.1517213135957718,
-0.6122526526451111,
-0.7878623604774475,
-0.5685042142868042,
0.6545042991638184,
-0.2819669246673584,
-0.5096359848976135,
-0.07780623435974121,
-0.26838418841362,
0.3388846814632416,
0.6190935373306274,
-0.5833995342254639,
-0.06543144583702087,
0.5071280598640442,
0.8023495674133301,
0.08168641477823257,
-0.3404163420200348,
-0.8181793689727783,
0.24602673947811127,
-0.58517986536026,
0.9704532027244568,
-0.5275673270225525,
-0.115125872194767,
-0.03343065455555916,
0.1265072226524353,
0.1915842890739441,
-0.39779210090637207,
0.567469596862793,
-0.6195908188819885,
0.23074397444725037,
-0.4258297383785248,
-0.3338804543018341,
-0.2691311538219452,
0.44519248604774475,
-0.3186183571815491,
1.0275789499282837,
-0.04362422972917557,
-0.7699646353721619,
0.5541225075721741,
-0.3276402950286865,
-0.4257892370223999,
0.05989472568035126,
-0.5352670550346375,
-0.33861100673675537,
0.0585319921374321,
0.4361950159072876,
0.47590935230255127,
-0.4612124264240265,
0.4680749773979187,
-0.4966711699962616,
-0.43056508898735046,
0.019551705569028854,
-0.35791489481925964,
0.5670676231384277,
-0.047881487756967545,
-0.556520938873291,
0.3669125735759735,
-0.6406676173210144,
0.16399872303009033,
0.23381751775741577,
-0.22466449439525604,
-0.1065634936094284,
0.3095211982727051,
-0.001476030214689672,
0.7296091318130493,
0.08608677983283997,
-0.03599145635962486,
0.31828445196151733,
-0.00031399866566061974,
0.5215631723403931,
0.6051793694496155,
-0.33252039551734924,
0.5760486721992493,
-0.15085017681121826,
0.11842982470989227,
0.06573714315891266,
-0.07596038281917572,
-0.7941704988479614,
-0.8056730628013611,
-0.8962573409080505,
-0.4224649667739868,
0.022719455882906914,
0.6234235167503357,
-0.8895779252052307,
0.48604896664619446,
0.04582132026553154,
-0.48901715874671936,
-0.18856264650821686,
0.14575597643852234,
0.32544082403182983,
0.4568176567554474,
0.517780601978302,
-0.003053574822843075,
-0.2426573634147644,
-0.9648047089576721,
0.014189666137099266,
-0.22088655829429626,
-0.1463412642478943,
0.6245725750923157,
0.4291057288646698,
-0.3790428042411804,
1.0655169486999512,
-0.330476850271225,
-0.2720390558242798,
-0.05299410969018936,
0.3130596876144409,
0.03982176631689072,
0.6915233135223389,
0.4289148151874542,
-1.054013729095459,
-0.24404889345169067,
0.19985628128051758,
-1.0357412099838257,
-0.10802909731864929,
-0.395783931016922,
-0.368475079536438,
0.06617030501365662,
0.6886976957321167,
-1.141457438468933,
0.3669370710849762,
0.4347214102745056,
-0.7084373235702515,
0.5997960567474365,
-0.6026304364204407,
0.24055427312850952,
-0.5243016481399536,
0.11261371523141861,
0.043056923896074295,
-0.29317474365234375,
-0.413496732711792,
0.27981311082839966,
0.24278874695301056,
-0.25546902418136597,
-0.15717248618602753,
0.4718095064163208,
-0.6671211123466492,
-0.2001148760318756,
-0.35448721051216125,
-0.00512795802205801,
0.47263097763061523,
0.5435945987701416,
0.35044780373573303,
0.9277476072311401,
0.8458666205406189,
-0.48537155985832214,
0.6133875250816345,
0.2586589455604553,
-0.11456356197595596,
0.5859214067459106,
-0.6564875245094299,
0.27149277925491333,
-0.37536343932151794,
0.5529153943061829,
-1.1409233808517456,
-0.21754126250743866,
0.016461875289678574,
-0.325524240732193,
0.19163528084754944,
-0.523067831993103,
-0.8427083492279053,
-0.12774576246738434,
0.09313016384840012,
0.4132445156574249,
0.6295782923698425,
-0.6478109359741211,
0.9730398058891296,
0.2806703746318817,
0.09763048589229584,
-0.2738472819328308,
-0.5221161246299744,
0.35960933566093445,
-0.26612022519111633,
-0.8874290585517883,
0.20771963894367218,
0.033090297132730484,
-0.4391929805278778,
-0.15587496757507324,
0.08748528361320496,
-0.00047928851563483477,
-0.16663284599781036,
0.3292856514453888,
0.12257479876279831,
-0.44366613030433655,
0.36361265182495117,
-0.07986637949943542,
-0.1668468713760376,
0.1385674923658371,
-0.5112982392311096,
0.32507970929145813,
-0.23293441534042358,
-0.6036994457244873,
-0.1459951400756836,
0.40987512469291687,
0.8728160858154297,
-0.6607885360717773,
0.5601829886436462,
0.8498886823654175,
-0.4307883083820343,
-0.13998205959796906,
-0.8230758905410767,
-0.08359945565462112,
-0.4504387378692627,
0.14002183079719543,
-0.6175981760025024,
-0.6072899103164673,
0.28216060996055603,
-0.2806735336780548,
0.024250226095318794,
0.20503002405166626,
0.7272840738296509,
-0.17962096631526947,
1.3555164337158203,
0.3463600277900696,
0.500331699848175,
0.1353597193956375,
-0.19064843654632568,
0.21236373484134674,
-0.5199243426322937,
-0.3986985385417938,
-0.05744662135839462,
-0.1749115139245987,
-0.21083351969718933,
-1.179352045059204,
0.344143807888031,
0.4708224833011627,
-0.17866018414497375,
-0.11050241440534592,
-0.3768640458583832,
0.6716569662094116,
0.6478151679039001,
0.15906614065170288,
0.10961831361055374,
0.11988963931798935,
-0.3191971778869629,
0.08537056297063828,
-0.588657021522522,
-0.49925947189331055,
0.7260631918907166,
0.4904680550098419,
0.5992375016212463,
0.10072816163301468,
-0.11379658430814743,
0.2917120158672333,
0.10582102090120316,
-0.8347728252410889,
0.5516576170921326,
0.01805879920721054,
-0.5107954144477844,
-0.11334649473428726,
-0.20371675491333008,
-0.4599389433860779,
0.7297895550727844,
-0.2258981317281723,
-0.44564908742904663,
0.10228804498910904,
0.3336353898048401,
-0.09922077506780624,
0.3292303681373596,
-0.8365058898925781,
1.0597455501556396,
-0.19118081033229828,
-0.8837689757347107,
-0.2669336199760437,
-0.766450047492981,
0.3449024558067322,
0.4652153551578522,
0.41137900948524475,
-0.07795539498329163,
0.06762255728244781,
0.26423928141593933,
-0.21323423087596893,
0.6095962524414062,
-0.46915143728256226,
-0.44454240798950195,
0.5119034051895142,
0.229702889919281,
0.6763381361961365,
0.2720906138420105,
0.291507750749588,
0.059332527220249176,
-0.4345676898956299,
-0.46583178639411926,
-0.8501467108726501,
0.7330734729766846,
-0.6036943197250366,
-0.5886947512626648,
-0.16787374019622803,
-0.6524986028671265,
-0.5079900026321411,
0.17796343564987183,
0.1000218316912651,
0.5678046345710754,
0.36420395970344543,
0.2868973910808563,
0.9531965255737305,
-0.2410990595817566,
0.2152157574892044,
0.20659852027893066,
-0.3812800347805023,
-0.4429078996181488,
1.0216742753982544,
-0.10317511856555939,
0.1973099708557129,
0.3727749288082123,
0.24857492744922638,
-0.47074127197265625,
-0.42965200543403625,
-0.740613579750061,
0.14430981874465942,
-1.0809731483459473,
0.007255717180669308,
-0.7900820970535278,
0.17461611330509186,
-0.24085453152656555,
-0.3307168483734131,
-0.2889462113380432,
-0.1935453563928604,
-0.15229617059230804,
-0.03975287452340126,
0.10564097762107849,
0.3650372624397278,
0.010631140321493149,
0.07004857808351517,
-0.6386504769325256,
0.507670521736145,
0.6185621619224548,
0.33813974261283875,
-0.23618966341018677,
-0.48819199204444885,
-0.09256333112716675,
-0.14680983126163483,
-0.09689132124185562,
-0.7181944251060486,
-0.07947138696908951,
-0.03132983297109604,
0.5273705124855042,
0.6023777723312378,
-0.36486703157424927,
0.7462731599807739,
-0.7259945869445801,
0.8671656847000122,
0.27174144983291626,
-0.8090357184410095,
0.66805499792099,
-0.639528214931488,
0.198847696185112,
0.13337859511375427,
-0.10469865798950195,
-0.4353053867816925,
-0.19623248279094696,
-0.4876888394355774,
-0.9099550247192383,
0.5745373964309692,
0.2437017560005188,
-0.01685974933207035,
0.11187288165092468,
0.22876541316509247,
-0.05314512178301811,
0.17863143980503082,
-0.7459505200386047,
-0.05117814987897873,
-0.49005359411239624,
0.13053812086582184,
-0.16082707047462463,
-0.37245020270347595,
-0.2936755120754242,
-0.3279671370983124,
0.4849499464035034,
-0.5279254913330078,
0.3283996880054474,
0.10240662097930908,
-0.3823607861995697,
0.07534997165203094,
0.0480707585811615,
0.6933674216270447,
0.7262296080589294,
-0.0018969224765896797,
0.6765961050987244,
-0.0718868151307106,
0.12984733283519745,
0.24353422224521637,
-0.11026695370674133,
-0.06159432232379913,
-0.003865916980430484,
0.4641503691673279,
0.9095714092254639,
-0.020516395568847656,
-0.968602180480957,
0.700301468372345,
0.0013411624822765589,
-0.2774989604949951,
-0.21040979027748108,
-0.15762557089328766,
0.10080910474061966,
0.36872729659080505,
0.21619756519794464,
0.28479626774787903,
-0.030779359862208366,
-0.3986952304840088,
0.23159563541412354,
0.46114233136177063,
-0.21731075644493103,
-0.15357625484466553,
0.5424466133117676,
0.15883471071720123,
-0.10581846535205841,
0.4827202558517456,
-0.37264370918273926,
-0.3524572551250458,
0.6963142156600952,
0.6202964782714844,
0.40260306000709534,
0.27124178409576416,
0.19774949550628662,
0.35798928141593933,
0.49660977721214294,
-0.30134883522987366,
0.10162989795207977,
-0.08113270252943039,
-0.7747684121131897,
-0.6556512713432312,
-0.11918721348047256,
-0.26525208353996277,
0.24273048341274261,
-0.1726679801940918,
0.400588721036911,
-0.6435650587081909,
-0.04244950786232948,
-0.2727063000202179,
-0.5001875758171082,
-0.4849154055118561,
0.41465118527412415,
0.5472185015678406,
0.8138704299926758,
-0.8016341924667358,
0.5332725048065186,
0.9878677129745483,
-0.38193702697753906,
-0.6831035017967224,
-0.0631309300661087,
-0.07293546199798584,
-0.5772724151611328,
0.8989915251731873,
0.5973823070526123,
-0.05520278587937355,
-0.035918764770030975,
-0.5615361332893372,
-0.6236233711242676,
0.9720160365104675,
0.4351060688495636,
-0.27496466040611267,
-0.12874175608158112,
-0.28419145941734314,
0.31128090620040894,
-0.32032012939453125,
0.5994447469711304,
0.45054981112480164,
0.6562435626983643,
0.32606828212738037,
-0.8363769054412842,
0.044069599360227585,
-0.37294065952301025,
0.04604317247867584,
0.009340827353298664,
-0.6097537875175476,
1.018326759338379,
-0.32970452308654785,
-0.04973050206899643,
-0.366936594247818,
0.5267800092697144,
0.4111737608909607,
0.3039640486240387,
0.5677103996276855,
0.7617511749267578,
0.6676795482635498,
-0.12082146108150482,
0.7406981587409973,
-0.06214554235339165,
0.33204054832458496,
1.0191104412078857,
-0.4266868233680725,
0.560590922832489,
0.5128952860832214,
-0.02187407948076725,
0.5361234545707703,
0.38913020491600037,
-0.1888323873281479,
0.48462995886802673,
0.07571934908628464,
-0.3405730426311493,
-0.8033614158630371,
-0.1258544772863388,
-0.36184248328208923,
0.3877680003643036,
0.475498765707016,
-0.278395414352417,
-0.29300761222839355,
0.08406473696231842,
-0.17569056153297424,
0.18767531216144562,
-0.46565815806388855,
0.7460275292396545,
-0.17967072129249573,
-0.8386588096618652,
0.5371282696723938,
0.25680628418922424,
0.4294520318508148,
-0.2569565773010254,
-0.4190945327281952,
0.04190715402364731,
0.3305831551551819,
-0.2835523784160614,
-0.7441233992576599,
0.12963636219501495,
-0.1293269693851471,
-0.2485143393278122,
-0.47656697034835815,
0.9459615349769592,
-0.5234301686286926,
-0.29898956418037415,
0.24282050132751465,
0.45601633191108704,
-0.017593907192349434,
-0.371176153421402,
-0.5575401782989502,
-0.10847755521535873,
-0.3932817876338959,
-0.13866257667541504,
0.25974777340888977,
0.8028199672698975,
-0.15317709743976593,
0.7052915096282959,
0.8788111209869385,
-0.1264319270849228,
-0.0011166203767061234,
0.1186484694480896,
0.9616503715515137,
-0.3188624083995819,
-0.5641227960586548,
-0.8890472650527954,
0.874752402305603,
-0.18761613965034485,
-0.020236244425177574,
0.6615169048309326,
0.566133439540863,
0.4968303143978119,
-0.20556212961673737,
0.8302785158157349,
-0.1311292201280594,
-0.04356623813509941,
-0.744800329208374,
0.4909398555755615,
-0.5429579615592957,
-0.15659099817276,
-0.08709172904491425,
-0.5933120250701904,
-0.3892226219177246,
1.0421206951141357,
-0.332773357629776,
-0.2291351854801178,
0.8138942122459412,
0.9468086957931519,
-0.24628594517707825,
-0.318698525428772,
0.5284916758537292,
0.1314476728439331,
0.7025968432426453,
0.40170595049858093,
1.0124800205230713,
-0.1251673549413681,
0.4567889869213104,
0.06790470331907272,
-0.42604300379753113,
-0.12934507429599762,
-1.0884919166564941,
-1.3491302728652954,
-0.3018275499343872,
-0.30459392070770264,
-0.5692539215087891,
-0.18259134888648987,
1.056241750717163,
0.7893481850624084,
-0.6542259454727173,
0.11164627224206924,
-0.45013171434402466,
0.11094903945922852,
-0.24554228782653809,
-0.2217497080564499,
0.22323139011859894,
-0.44571778178215027,
-0.24486024677753448,
0.4440669119358063,
0.5913587808609009,
-0.13627012073993683,
-0.45593345165252686,
-0.09238848835229874,
-0.19003494083881378,
0.005825723055750132,
0.9210597276687622,
-0.05030956119298935,
-1.0509305000305176,
-0.2069225013256073,
-0.26982590556144714,
-0.11071101576089859,
0.16107489168643951,
1.1165800094604492,
-0.8736506700515747,
0.4479842483997345,
0.4035293757915497,
0.7046231031417847,
0.2662849724292755,
-0.005828863475471735,
0.4995064437389374,
-0.6667124629020691,
0.5670859813690186,
0.15838930010795593,
0.4985322654247284,
0.3844538629055023,
-0.31595999002456665,
0.29090553522109985,
0.5324503183364868,
-0.5560805797576904,
-0.8471665382385254,
0.38698267936706543,
-0.7741841673851013,
-0.26538804173469543,
1.5274124145507812,
-0.47078487277030945,
0.2900606393814087,
-0.02941773273050785,
-0.839009165763855,
-0.036866940557956696,
-0.19452154636383057,
0.5406342148780823,
0.8633163571357727,
0.1234542578458786,
-0.6865602135658264,
-0.4468674063682556,
0.4138779640197754,
0.23721081018447876,
-1.041190505027771,
0.1833808571100235,
0.8635368943214417,
-0.05382397770881653,
0.362517386674881,
0.6963263154029846,
0.09138432145118713,
0.3738085627555847,
0.22594301402568817,
-0.08752354234457016,
-0.281391978263855,
-0.6822165846824646,
0.006729272194206715,
0.5694156289100647,
0.13939477503299713,
0.15587720274925232
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19318v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19318v2
|
TableLLM: Enabling Tabular Data Manipulation by LLMs in Real Office Usage Scenarios
| 2024-03-28T11:21:12 | 2024-04-01T05:10:56 |
Xiaokang Zhang, Jing Zhang, Zeyao Ma, Yang Li, Bohan Zhang, Guanlin Li, Zijun Yao, Kangli Xu, Jinchang Zhou, Daniel Zhang-Li, Jifan Yu, Shu Zhao, Juanzi Li, Jie Tang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce TableLLM, a robust large language model (LLM) with 13 billion
parameters, purpose-built for proficiently handling tabular data manipulation
tasks, whether they are embedded within documents or spreadsheets, catering to
real-world office scenarios. We propose a distant supervision method for
training, which comprises a reasoning process extension strategy, aiding in
training LLMs to understand reasoning patterns more effectively as well as a
cross-way validation strategy, ensuring the quality of the automatically
generated data. To evaluate the performance of TableLLM, we have crafted a
benchmark tailored to address both document and spreadsheet formats as well as
constructed a well-organized evaluation pipeline capable of handling both
scenarios. Thorough evaluations underscore the advantages of TableLLM when
compared to various existing general-purpose and tabular data-focused LLMs. We
have publicly released the model checkpoint, source code, benchmarks, and a web
application for user interaction.Our codes and data are publicly available at
https://github.com/TableLLM/TableLLM.
|
[
-0.08220638334751129,
-1.3219001293182373,
0.5794784426689148,
-0.01948804222047329,
-0.11330768465995789,
0.0004175282665528357,
-0.2853325605392456,
-0.5529839992523193,
-0.31820282340049744,
0.7599347829818726,
-0.3871620297431946,
-1.0033509731292725,
-0.28188979625701904,
-0.09088572859764099,
-0.7856578826904297,
0.7964555025100708,
-0.20656879246234894,
0.11712532490491867,
-0.6473353505134583,
0.1225752905011177,
-0.48774969577789307,
-0.551243782043457,
-0.14379847049713135,
-0.3614232540130615,
0.5807452201843262,
0.914472222328186,
0.7537016868591309,
0.9167833924293518,
0.6112101078033447,
0.28501176834106445,
0.23603178560733795,
0.22929057478904724,
-0.5568822026252747,
0.32650789618492126,
0.01988108828663826,
-0.632008969783783,
-0.9181915521621704,
0.12191689759492874,
0.595285177230835,
0.821538507938385,
-0.5526142716407776,
0.12227974086999893,
-0.21344326436519623,
0.8829299211502075,
-0.18339867889881134,
0.4287385642528534,
-0.8607670664787292,
0.2928699254989624,
-0.25496479868888855,
0.09118300676345825,
-0.5893269181251526,
-0.7628339529037476,
-0.13035500049591064,
-0.5022498369216919,
-0.021636633202433586,
0.3993580937385559,
0.7329981923103333,
-0.04201216995716095,
-0.28531914949417114,
-0.16914872825145721,
-0.7902892827987671,
0.501212477684021,
-0.62565678358078,
0.7838249206542969,
0.3855110704898834,
0.5996930599212646,
-0.22415287792682648,
-1.0519846677780151,
-0.3605552613735199,
-0.5847762823104858,
-0.05308597534894943,
0.03743262588977814,
0.04830389842391014,
0.04024754464626312,
0.4496263265609741,
0.18101978302001953,
-0.8062167763710022,
0.10639148205518723,
-0.35732606053352356,
0.3247004449367523,
0.3673076927661896,
0.5591740608215332,
0.3377975523471832,
0.22597277164459229,
-0.27668923139572144,
0.06407368928194046,
-0.8391931056976318,
-0.20847079157829285,
0.19270379841327667,
0.1906295120716095,
-0.0781565010547638,
0.6323111057281494,
-0.24669858813285828,
1.004781723022461,
-0.4492265284061432,
0.1659761518239975,
-0.304002970457077,
-0.1787416934967041,
-0.5773842930793762,
0.1410815715789795,
0.5929756164550781,
0.22293893992900848,
0.027142666280269623,
-0.6681724190711975,
0.030859248712658882,
0.026720013469457626,
0.5436163544654846,
-0.7306221723556519,
-0.09178467094898224,
0.21705588698387146,
-0.13721705973148346,
-0.3516334295272827,
0.20447082817554474,
-0.9187039136886597,
-0.3258507251739502,
-0.6769735217094421,
0.11106424778699875,
-0.32918551564216614,
0.15516266226768494,
-0.24003581702709198,
0.42192432284355164,
0.23035921156406403,
0.7263888120651245,
-0.7802973985671997,
0.6088318228721619,
1.0914801359176636,
0.6474268436431885,
-0.6974906921386719,
-0.42483457922935486,
-0.9432101845741272,
0.459788978099823,
-0.6211435794830322,
0.7867134809494019,
-0.5674363374710083,
-0.3396685719490051,
0.09014292806386948,
-0.17490549385547638,
-0.07934623956680298,
-0.8367528319358826,
0.5640987157821655,
-0.5417801737785339,
-0.0028830692172050476,
-0.09987802803516388,
-0.5865029096603394,
0.06385822594165802,
0.6140619516372681,
-0.795062243938446,
1.0708009004592896,
0.29075929522514343,
-0.4047773480415344,
0.6126137375831604,
-0.5945077538490295,
-0.3133697509765625,
0.1143638864159584,
-0.15484470129013062,
-0.7222669720649719,
-0.259272962808609,
-0.16757848858833313,
0.5713615417480469,
-0.3127487897872925,
0.48607337474823,
-0.4562104344367981,
-0.12266677618026733,
0.19110406935214996,
-0.05154015123844147,
0.11806505173444748,
0.351790189743042,
0.1168961450457573,
0.48217207193374634,
-0.7003670334815979,
0.00575361680239439,
-0.15130382776260376,
-0.5762277841567993,
0.1604858934879303,
0.030565910041332245,
0.10501699894666672,
0.2229427546262741,
0.12978866696357727,
-0.3002355098724365,
0.425712525844574,
-0.09683727473020554,
0.23689575493335724,
0.259935200214386,
-0.34170764684677124,
0.5708149671554565,
-0.4681289494037628,
0.6814893484115601,
0.020319104194641113,
0.2193499356508255,
0.24058693647384644,
-0.04342079907655716,
-0.3939324617385864,
-0.10272680222988129,
0.21843953430652618,
0.74612957239151,
-0.3886556923389435,
0.29253557324409485,
-0.3729921579360962,
-0.6405581831932068,
0.1435544192790985,
0.46543511748313904,
0.137605220079422,
0.9453701376914978,
0.309370219707489,
0.14223726093769073,
-0.47582170367240906,
-0.783236026763916,
-0.422419011592865,
0.009670285508036613,
0.11782687157392502,
0.16676124930381775,
0.21163544058799744,
-0.30330318212509155,
1.086859107017517,
-0.49641045928001404,
-0.5324993133544922,
-0.8648027777671814,
0.2562488615512848,
0.33067792654037476,
0.2965552508831024,
0.11598139256238937,
-0.696483850479126,
-0.6520421504974365,
0.22298036515712738,
-0.9522168040275574,
-0.3054597079753876,
-0.27696412801742554,
-0.1930450052022934,
0.37761300802230835,
0.7387750744819641,
-0.6916325688362122,
0.47939586639404297,
0.16718311607837677,
-0.10068138688802719,
0.7621252536773682,
-0.17988774180412292,
-0.1290208101272583,
-0.9483420252799988,
0.08176058530807495,
0.04408850148320198,
-0.5489470958709717,
-0.96198970079422,
0.05735913664102554,
0.4276178479194641,
-0.29547733068466187,
-0.6924328804016113,
0.2489675134420395,
-0.8109087347984314,
-0.306058406829834,
0.13369965553283691,
0.1996699571609497,
-0.009019680321216583,
0.10177841037511826,
0.0615893192589283,
0.7794781923294067,
0.2907702922821045,
-0.3727261424064636,
0.5192370414733887,
0.37176209688186646,
-0.5095385909080505,
0.6209563612937927,
-0.41243821382522583,
-0.004005189519375563,
0.13938568532466888,
0.12339168787002563,
-0.7526494264602661,
-0.25179174542427063,
0.050069913268089294,
-0.006320099346339703,
0.6138341426849365,
-0.11398627609014511,
-0.6717114448547363,
-0.3250782787799835,
-0.38627153635025024,
-0.25823578238487244,
0.31985723972320557,
-0.508138120174408,
0.7815067768096924,
0.4386623501777649,
-0.20348647236824036,
-0.3487486243247986,
-0.9344479441642761,
0.5396573543548584,
-0.5570552945137024,
-0.6296637654304504,
0.26767364144325256,
0.13964535295963287,
-0.6605435609817505,
-0.1130480095744133,
-0.3420795798301697,
-0.22754909098148346,
0.002158617600798607,
0.40506207942962646,
0.439734548330307,
0.2718169689178467,
-0.040566083043813705,
-0.11163008958101273,
0.0379350371658802,
0.19836457073688507,
0.19107207655906677,
0.4681067168712616,
-0.10276256501674652,
-0.34279555082321167,
-0.09850107878446579,
0.19549201428890228,
0.4307098686695099,
0.013864731416106224,
0.6179426908493042,
0.4782183766365051,
-0.4880197048187256,
-0.4782780110836029,
-0.6545267105102539,
0.02749573066830635,
-0.4929716885089874,
0.5499880313873291,
-0.4328097105026245,
-0.4644789695739746,
0.6353520750999451,
-0.17719829082489014,
0.11167358607053757,
-0.1085563376545906,
0.4760308861732483,
-0.012360645458102226,
0.6508025527000427,
0.2338651865720749,
-0.27049171924591064,
0.45266786217689514,
-0.32710498571395874,
0.0011578662088140845,
-0.7145674824714661,
-0.41888511180877686,
-0.6489230394363403,
-0.11280567944049835,
-0.1847180426120758,
-0.4321810305118561,
0.4425314664840698,
0.061621926724910736,
-0.009448624216020107,
0.3352985382080078,
-0.2723042666912079,
0.49697792530059814,
0.36961185932159424,
0.06233098730444908,
0.3817881941795349,
-0.0332222618162632,
-0.1271631419658661,
-0.0552615225315094,
-0.7264819145202637,
-0.6994481682777405,
0.8570615649223328,
0.30802085995674133,
1.3489751815795898,
-0.041737403720617294,
0.6467646360397339,
0.40887704491615295,
0.5650195479393005,
-0.6755858063697815,
0.7872864007949829,
-0.04944862052798271,
-0.2918318212032318,
-0.42743781208992004,
-0.63470858335495,
-1.1128877401351929,
0.11124927550554276,
-0.044785045087337494,
-1.049014687538147,
-0.4252828061580658,
0.16525039076805115,
0.11825394630432129,
0.48275262117385864,
-0.7855503559112549,
1.0805788040161133,
-0.432866632938385,
-0.9752448797225952,
-0.1639842838048935,
-0.6067938208580017,
0.4677188992500305,
-0.05028102546930313,
0.3028023838996887,
-0.10655829310417175,
0.06014839559793472,
0.6167387962341309,
-0.8211675882339478,
0.6640414595603943,
-0.11494235694408417,
-0.21039745211601257,
0.26732099056243896,
0.473378449678421,
0.7060456275939941,
0.18335285782814026,
-0.37517857551574707,
0.09445538371801376,
-0.016162075102329254,
0.038432858884334564,
-0.4319726824760437,
0.9921669363975525,
-0.40031442046165466,
-0.6038158535957336,
-0.44620978832244873,
-1.058552622795105,
-0.4225844740867615,
0.1952138990163803,
-0.31728407740592957,
0.5178377628326416,
-0.3449527323246002,
0.4239650368690491,
0.37927481532096863,
-0.02144075371325016,
0.5080862641334534,
0.46689289808273315,
-0.414920836687088,
-0.23706689476966858,
0.6203718185424805,
0.4034273028373718,
0.18098175525665283,
0.801830530166626,
0.1381339281797409,
-0.668361485004425,
-0.6929861903190613,
-0.526628315448761,
-0.12196358293294907,
-0.6912981271743774,
-0.23979975283145905,
-0.5399991869926453,
0.04749106615781784,
-0.17719507217407227,
-0.20289771258831024,
-0.027144283056259155,
-0.39353102445602417,
-0.45781493186950684,
-0.38728320598602295,
0.46000710129737854,
0.7272319197654724,
0.20806743204593658,
0.11570191383361816,
-0.973544716835022,
0.4429175555706024,
0.5518246293067932,
0.5704981088638306,
-0.229252889752388,
-0.2840119004249573,
-0.39389270544052124,
-0.2895233631134033,
-0.30060845613479614,
-1.0700207948684692,
0.6624460816383362,
0.16757284104824066,
0.7030252814292908,
0.17319509387016296,
-0.15481601655483246,
0.5667732954025269,
-0.4905971884727478,
0.5304362177848816,
-0.22612740099430084,
-0.7953657507896423,
0.3234040141105652,
-0.5856077075004578,
0.2975965738296509,
0.6613691449165344,
0.2015349268913269,
-0.404186487197876,
-0.3906530737876892,
-0.10466589033603668,
-0.9265059232711792,
0.9618259072303772,
-0.17775985598564148,
-0.31489598751068115,
0.3253655731678009,
0.39458349347114563,
0.36133190989494324,
0.24026986956596375,
-0.6969075798988342,
-0.13217326998710632,
-0.00854798685759306,
-0.21639429032802582,
0.21667620539665222,
-0.1453104317188263,
-0.09355926513671875,
-0.3280992805957794,
0.38402748107910156,
-0.016829168424010277,
-0.06069410964846611,
0.01676119677722454,
-0.587683379650116,
-0.21324953436851501,
0.4319579303264618,
0.5060034394264221,
1.175743579864502,
-0.46540239453315735,
0.27337712049484253,
0.5481203198432922,
-0.5582548379898071,
-0.17206037044525146,
0.3097601532936096,
-0.007090597413480282,
-0.025474796071648598,
0.0899026021361351,
0.5420802235603333,
0.15228630602359772,
-0.4803307056427002,
-0.07938461750745773,
-0.18234390020370483,
-0.33745720982551575,
-0.23827360570430756,
0.22344620525836945,
0.3277844190597534,
-0.09783551841974258,
0.43315377831459045,
-0.655839741230011,
0.05946696922183037,
-0.7105432152748108,
0.46194174885749817,
0.5800813436508179,
-0.26460975408554077,
-0.13284854590892792,
1.082742691040039,
-0.2716235816478729,
-0.45277315378189087,
0.3829028606414795,
-0.11773419380187988,
-0.2657325565814972,
0.6536359190940857,
0.5586597323417664,
0.5064862966537476,
-0.03980271518230438,
0.13362018764019012,
-0.01996852643787861,
0.197769895195961,
0.07852674275636673,
0.45238780975341797,
-0.04412240535020828,
-0.4259888231754303,
-0.14377449452877045,
-0.44310423731803894,
-0.9942102432250977,
0.2270408570766449,
-0.5657917261123657,
0.3548943102359772,
-0.37211087346076965,
0.0634511336684227,
-0.06983046233654022,
0.10821633785963058,
-0.5707789063453674,
0.19893725216388702,
-0.09748360514640808,
1.2005507946014404,
-0.5354170799255371,
1.1854681968688965,
0.8053345084190369,
-0.215147465467453,
-0.7360767722129822,
-0.531317412853241,
-0.08077419549226761,
-0.5639753341674805,
0.5883767604827881,
0.1334582269191742,
0.23139575123786926,
-0.2053336501121521,
-0.4159216284751892,
-0.32349541783332825,
1.1592484712600708,
0.3567826449871063,
-0.9651980996131897,
0.11892230808734894,
0.9217826128005981,
0.4824744760990143,
-0.11981473118066788,
0.32964491844177246,
0.9024842977523804,
0.7204898595809937,
-0.09388501942157745,
-0.6317951083183289,
0.13734303414821625,
-0.05367675796151161,
-0.18477360904216766,
0.33501845598220825,
-0.37150028347969055,
0.596352756023407,
0.04852164164185524,
0.1389661282300949,
-0.26152774691581726,
0.4822302460670471,
0.3016962707042694,
0.41161438822746277,
0.2888641059398651,
0.7270178198814392,
0.4821631610393524,
-0.3123849928379059,
0.8949066400527954,
-0.36822783946990967,
0.07577752321958542,
1.454259991645813,
-0.8990673422813416,
0.6874628067016602,
0.5359121561050415,
-0.40050914883613586,
0.2813281714916229,
0.34400877356529236,
-0.07567080110311508,
0.15598164498806,
0.2619931995868683,
-0.1816883385181427,
0.11338435113430023,
0.12921133637428284,
-0.272787868976593,
0.22778217494487762,
0.5402283072471619,
-0.04638628661632538,
-0.5764217376708984,
-0.4042688012123108,
0.13251055777072906,
0.23144713044166565,
-0.34109559655189514,
0.8973467946052551,
0.18603549897670746,
-0.4566038250923157,
0.38337740302085876,
-0.10370804369449615,
0.20055696368217468,
-0.6765457391738892,
-0.061428021639585495,
-0.25762423872947693,
0.0894000381231308,
-0.40688952803611755,
-0.8967500329017639,
0.6057793498039246,
0.12170232087373734,
0.13360266387462616,
-0.5142061710357666,
0.9921519160270691,
-0.5189242362976074,
-0.3734804391860962,
0.16326212882995605,
0.6518373489379883,
0.09867949783802032,
0.023885296657681465,
-0.6130830645561218,
0.1525333672761917,
-0.32783517241477966,
-0.3724859654903412,
0.5643776655197144,
0.3790445327758789,
-0.16806115210056305,
0.8844944834709167,
0.6709699034690857,
0.3819023072719574,
0.16190551221370697,
0.42238983511924744,
0.9260262250900269,
-0.6671879291534424,
-0.38377049565315247,
-1.0387927293777466,
0.3249458968639374,
-0.07667821645736694,
0.2580205202102661,
0.8713284730911255,
1.1107981204986572,
0.4712820053100586,
-0.2387125939130783,
0.48399925231933594,
0.19829298555850983,
0.438768208026886,
-0.6571286916732788,
0.89516282081604,
-0.26285305619239807,
0.3419196903705597,
-0.32606610655784607,
-1.0750871896743774,
-0.6250850558280945,
0.27424678206443787,
-0.7102794647216797,
-0.1399002969264984,
0.5840830206871033,
0.7773987054824829,
-0.11025278270244598,
-0.052213359624147415,
0.526609480381012,
0.1570301353931427,
0.5305497646331787,
0.24868479371070862,
0.844996988773346,
0.04337672144174576,
0.7716284394264221,
-0.15126051008701324,
0.07318422943353653,
-0.15272857248783112,
-1.1127864122390747,
-0.8978468775749207,
-0.13735532760620117,
-0.17858600616455078,
0.05232558771967888,
0.0002317539183422923,
0.8899084329605103,
0.9573836922645569,
-0.6894105672836304,
-0.5358709692955017,
-0.44914525747299194,
0.34665024280548096,
-0.01961873471736908,
-0.32900893688201904,
0.27058181166648865,
-0.36916935443878174,
-0.6028625965118408,
0.41724076867103577,
0.354555606842041,
-0.011308551765978336,
-0.04241148382425308,
-0.006674223113805056,
-0.19078117609024048,
-0.27706652879714966,
0.609079897403717,
0.16520917415618896,
-0.26468464732170105,
0.18021364510059357,
-0.046923473477363586,
-0.1960200071334839,
0.47361382842063904,
0.5068093538284302,
-0.4926113784313202,
0.29681333899497986,
0.6677889823913574,
0.5416195392608643,
0.8753504157066345,
0.47722235321998596,
0.45935818552970886,
-0.691015899181366,
-0.01564551144838333,
0.11839448660612106,
0.43680205941200256,
0.28067222237586975,
-0.5217803716659546,
0.6668704152107239,
-0.13048261404037476,
-0.6807100772857666,
-0.9814278483390808,
0.06532186269760132,
-1.23909330368042,
-0.11273522675037384,
1.113926649093628,
-0.025488944724202156,
-0.33694127202033997,
-0.10723825544118881,
-0.2083905041217804,
0.3847948908805847,
-0.5444322824478149,
1.1060045957565308,
0.42866837978363037,
-0.2830818295478821,
-0.2277390956878662,
-0.7925586700439453,
0.41668516397476196,
0.21167458593845367,
-1.8051544427871704,
0.35354939103126526,
0.6850727200508118,
0.16061194241046906,
-0.26353588700294495,
0.2029346227645874,
-0.3398248851299286,
0.21693655848503113,
-0.3065335750579834,
0.06162050738930702,
-0.5001978278160095,
-0.39835259318351746,
-0.2019476741552353,
0.29485780000686646,
0.22652581334114075,
-0.03536245599389076
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19317v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19317v1
|
Beyond Borders: Investigating Cross-Jurisdiction Transfer in Legal Case Summarization
| 2024-03-28T11:18:31 | 2024-03-28T11:18:31 |
T. Y. S. S Santosh, Vatsal Venkatkrishna, Saptarshi Ghosh, Matthias Grabmair
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Legal professionals face the challenge of managing an overwhelming volume of
lengthy judgments, making automated legal case summarization crucial. However,
prior approaches mainly focused on training and evaluating these models within
the same jurisdiction. In this study, we explore the cross-jurisdictional
generalizability of legal case summarization models.Specifically, we explore
how to effectively summarize legal cases of a target jurisdiction where
reference summaries are not available. In particular, we investigate whether
supplementing models with unlabeled target jurisdiction corpus and extractive
silver summaries obtained from unsupervised algorithms on target data enhances
transfer performance. Our comprehensive study on three datasets from different
jurisdictions highlights the role of pre-training in improving transfer
performance. We shed light on the pivotal influence of jurisdictional
similarity in selecting optimal source datasets for effective transfer.
Furthermore, our findings underscore that incorporating unlabeled target data
yields improvements in general pre-trained models, with additional gains when
silver summaries are introduced. This augmentation is especially valuable when
dealing with extractive datasets and scenarios featuring limited alignment
between source and target jurisdictions. Our study provides key insights for
developing adaptable legal case summarization systems, transcending
jurisdictional boundaries.
|
[
-0.3598666489124298,
0.0333314873278141,
0.78415846824646,
0.0742001086473465,
-0.5649782419204712,
0.2308226227760315,
-0.08531274646520615,
-0.4885861575603485,
0.4430616497993469,
0.7701848149299622,
-0.08040408790111542,
-0.4170539379119873,
-0.8525967597961426,
-0.13591204583644867,
-0.5526543855667114,
1.201138973236084,
-0.0491502583026886,
-0.06204449385404587,
-0.07998882979154587,
-0.4851240813732147,
-0.3421403169631958,
-0.9583098292350769,
-0.0009550367249175906,
-0.2327684909105301,
0.12914469838142395,
0.30935293436050415,
0.4398266673088074,
0.3448176681995392,
0.6338924169540405,
0.24071650207042694,
0.09083271026611328,
-0.24256187677383423,
-0.44417068362236023,
-0.43914952874183655,
-0.6048184037208557,
-0.8394980430603027,
-0.5510746836662292,
-0.19028747081756592,
0.568034827709198,
0.7061339616775513,
-0.21036982536315918,
0.24641479551792145,
-0.2988317310810089,
0.8071979880332947,
-0.8829631805419922,
-0.0209084153175354,
-0.5593842267990112,
0.39076632261276245,
-0.21065111458301544,
-0.353091299533844,
-0.16872455179691315,
-0.42714670300483704,
0.34418120980262756,
-0.6527217030525208,
0.46133336424827576,
-0.09930291771888733,
0.6929346919059753,
0.1157221868634224,
-0.7465528249740601,
-0.16796539723873138,
-0.77972811460495,
0.3299410343170166,
-0.4162883460521698,
0.150968536734581,
-0.002366956789046526,
0.5436823964118958,
0.1392705738544464,
-0.9548182487487793,
-0.05118507519364357,
0.031173063442111015,
-0.23588575422763824,
0.40465179085731506,
-0.6035406589508057,
-0.09002912044525146,
0.25962671637535095,
0.23407869040966034,
-0.3713220953941345,
-0.133110910654068,
-0.6983489394187927,
-0.4092327654361725,
0.6325187683105469,
0.0414109081029892,
0.5031644105911255,
0.35325726866722107,
0.004512778948992491,
-0.06929074227809906,
-0.6927213072776794,
0.4264313578605652,
0.37916916608810425,
0.678588330745697,
-0.498862624168396,
0.5920659899711609,
-0.18454134464263916,
0.3121359348297119,
0.23224538564682007,
0.2106390744447708,
0.34533506631851196,
-0.7510923147201538,
-0.019455714151263237,
0.3305206298828125,
0.545962393283844,
0.6058555245399475,
0.4308878183364868,
-0.40731456875801086,
0.01696609891951084,
-0.5815208554267883,
0.339446485042572,
-0.8826902508735657,
-0.028232242912054062,
0.12669885158538818,
-0.8041832447052002,
0.1335357129573822,
0.5378851294517517,
-0.6353656649589539,
-0.2972370982170105,
-0.6092245578765869,
0.12427129596471786,
0.1688428521156311,
-0.2523219585418701,
0.09043658524751663,
-0.33935102820396423,
0.20029990375041962,
0.1627972275018692,
-0.9617295265197754,
0.41929352283477783,
0.6244901418685913,
0.8650044202804565,
-0.23539836704730988,
-0.06289985775947571,
-0.8091430068016052,
0.3727548122406006,
-0.3484607934951782,
0.807558000087738,
-0.5044177770614624,
-0.5152537226676941,
0.004231111612170935,
0.3565960228443146,
-0.09309323132038116,
-0.437527596950531,
0.23227976262569427,
-0.4929060637950897,
-0.25244995951652527,
-0.8255013823509216,
-0.10723953694105148,
-0.1489579826593399,
-0.03658090531826019,
-0.5835737586021423,
0.05348432809114456,
0.21406809985637665,
-0.6746736168861389,
0.7221308350563049,
-0.8124657869338989,
-0.913244366645813,
-0.149405837059021,
0.14837607741355896,
-0.20585060119628906,
0.46510428190231323,
0.38383644819259644,
0.2948147654533386,
0.017437251284718513,
0.39564770460128784,
-0.16090384125709534,
-0.4606887996196747,
-0.18707838654518127,
0.15605510771274567,
1.0082809925079346,
0.3138970136642456,
-0.22280403971672058,
0.16244728863239288,
-0.29901716113090515,
-0.3100017309188843,
-0.17332161962985992,
-0.12311401963233948,
-0.599448025226593,
-0.3354123532772064,
-0.10017715394496918,
0.09362278878688812,
0.03722916170954704,
-0.4872012436389923,
0.09751482307910919,
-0.12956959009170532,
0.25059741735458374,
0.29099807143211365,
-0.06026022136211395,
0.8930435180664062,
-0.4750283360481262,
0.9491139054298401,
0.17955061793327332,
-0.04811381921172142,
0.0800858661532402,
0.08223387598991394,
-0.34038254618644714,
-0.07292617857456207,
0.9030790328979492,
0.9144772291183472,
-0.7048929333686829,
0.11700702458620071,
-0.7924845218658447,
-0.29603061079978943,
-0.47683581709861755,
-0.16781063377857208,
0.09605696052312851,
0.34257644414901733,
0.2923486530780792,
-0.6681620478630066,
-0.6445389986038208,
-1.001525640487671,
-0.46249860525131226,
0.013414014130830765,
0.09768769890069962,
0.22694718837738037,
0.7584333419799805,
-0.1061142310500145,
1.074763536453247,
-0.1543157547712326,
-0.3785910904407501,
-0.6604211330413818,
0.11334875971078873,
0.14440681040287018,
0.24563489854335785,
0.9550108313560486,
-0.8279504179954529,
-0.6879867911338806,
0.412846177816391,
-0.7922936677932739,
-0.262474000453949,
-0.5262993574142456,
-0.2436586320400238,
-0.1546780914068222,
0.7159112095832825,
-0.29260945320129395,
0.6051134467124939,
0.21421682834625244,
-0.2434871792793274,
0.418707013130188,
-0.48902106285095215,
0.5165094137191772,
-1.1031665802001953,
0.2842227816581726,
-0.1308511346578598,
-0.44228610396385193,
-0.5921682119369507,
0.04913029447197914,
0.2756468951702118,
0.20493212342262268,
-0.6987243294715881,
0.30414003133773804,
-0.6819233298301697,
-0.61823570728302,
-0.2529865503311157,
-0.14993850886821747,
-0.05958223715424538,
0.1501094102859497,
0.17333535850048065,
1.0588767528533936,
0.557303786277771,
-0.29819849133491516,
0.15473169088363647,
0.2433340847492218,
-0.06314300745725632,
0.9740309119224548,
-0.4365769326686859,
-0.3674815595149994,
-0.24555940926074982,
0.4969509243965149,
-0.2699868083000183,
0.1764453798532486,
0.2831393778324127,
-0.017393378540873528,
0.41448888182640076,
-0.7186288833618164,
-0.20274946093559265,
-0.037663329392671585,
-0.28391534090042114,
0.46556487679481506,
0.5264259576797485,
-0.29775378108024597,
1.0005086660385132,
0.6267581582069397,
-0.40604469180107117,
-0.561837911605835,
-1.106518268585205,
0.3116234540939331,
-0.7441020011901855,
0.05746466666460037,
0.4730975925922394,
0.13274013996124268,
-0.3395916521549225,
0.06509995460510254,
0.1935446411371231,
-0.1009175181388855,
-0.028753681108355522,
0.36733123660087585,
-0.08324633538722992,
-0.07941554486751556,
-0.031242303550243378,
0.4424267113208771,
0.22416923940181732,
0.4324014186859131,
-0.1598559021949768,
0.05113966017961502,
0.05135088413953781,
-0.4329615533351898,
-0.1533597707748413,
0.5156740546226501,
0.5256858468055725,
-0.54533451795578,
0.39521804451942444,
0.2055796980857849,
-0.013570333831012249,
-0.07655838876962662,
-0.31100496649742126,
0.19886454939842224,
-0.3914097547531128,
0.3301377594470978,
-0.8463867902755737,
-0.7218888401985168,
0.9645933508872986,
-0.13598521053791046,
0.09315145760774612,
0.45599165558815,
0.41849610209465027,
0.25220948457717896,
0.3128354847431183,
1.0082383155822754,
-0.4387807846069336,
0.5656657814979553,
-0.058209944516420364,
0.2527676224708557,
-0.8679790496826172,
-0.08558938652276993,
-0.4282558858394623,
0.0991118773818016,
-0.5939744114875793,
-0.14633454382419586,
0.2639351189136505,
-0.28956788778305054,
0.0961882695555687,
0.501772940158844,
-0.07943082600831985,
1.0486799478530884,
0.3813774883747101,
-0.009343765676021576,
0.40298521518707275,
0.33379143476486206,
-0.20649296045303345,
0.2110266536474228,
-0.8281618356704712,
-0.007851803675293922,
1.6471641063690186,
0.1076933741569519,
0.4375951290130615,
0.23460331559181213,
0.7463549971580505,
0.6668429970741272,
0.3503350615501404,
-0.5397688150405884,
0.14927534759044647,
-0.5401817560195923,
-0.3324781060218811,
-0.057214003056287766,
-0.4989244043827057,
-1.1057838201522827,
0.36400240659713745,
-0.2727026343345642,
-0.6604164242744446,
0.48628050088882446,
-0.44978758692741394,
-0.7793055772781372,
0.5743111371994019,
-0.5529160499572754,
0.3422367572784424,
-0.11144933104515076,
-0.2482393980026245,
0.0392875112593174,
-0.8066583871841431,
0.3962065875530243,
-0.4903240203857422,
0.2515677213668823,
0.24952088296413422,
0.22349126636981964,
0.6788928508758545,
-0.30509671568870544,
0.37233877182006836,
-0.04400617256760597,
-0.16517001390457153,
0.3921676278114319,
0.07785049080848694,
0.04988942667841911,
-0.12258877605199814,
0.2663154602050781,
0.29164645075798035,
0.23929254710674286,
-0.3138907253742218,
-0.528459370136261,
0.48407620191574097,
-0.6116501092910767,
-0.5894830226898193,
-0.3500586450099945,
-0.9622437357902527,
-0.007188988383859396,
0.35541945695877075,
0.29113683104515076,
0.43197718262672424,
0.032384298741817474,
0.1389356404542923,
0.4596051871776581,
0.03846153989434242,
0.4106360077857971,
0.7114273905754089,
0.15080809593200684,
-0.058884114027023315,
0.9349200129508972,
0.5541616082191467,
-0.055632129311561584,
0.39147254824638367,
-0.057039838284254074,
-0.5936167240142822,
-0.8983568549156189,
-0.5087699294090271,
0.1501348912715912,
-0.9294862747192383,
0.09129271656274796,
-0.7070367336273193,
-0.24725615978240967,
-0.5816830992698669,
-0.4741083085536957,
-0.27024152874946594,
-0.34302154183387756,
-0.09613673388957977,
-0.18559063971042633,
0.17984409630298615,
0.6042110919952393,
-0.41334471106529236,
0.2337314337491989,
-0.9824082255363464,
0.453982412815094,
0.16173744201660156,
0.347964346408844,
-0.2590407133102417,
-1.0286331176757812,
-0.18123859167099,
0.047186534851789474,
0.30774667859077454,
-0.5411401987075806,
0.2518960237503052,
-0.10870365053415298,
0.7080148458480835,
-0.0031113300938159227,
0.336414635181427,
0.9814949631690979,
-0.5208004117012024,
0.4592079818248749,
0.09111928939819336,
-1.036165714263916,
0.437999963760376,
-0.4033023715019226,
0.3707835376262665,
1.0121876001358032,
0.38569778203964233,
-0.11236165463924408,
-0.28386813402175903,
-0.5175386667251587,
-0.7794696092605591,
0.6114487051963806,
0.1355525404214859,
0.2064470499753952,
0.8720755577087402,
0.509332001209259,
0.15545029938220978,
0.08704200387001038,
-0.5075783729553223,
0.13208569586277008,
0.06455674767494202,
-0.03676145523786545,
-0.29942309856414795,
0.1269085556268692,
-0.2716403007507324,
-0.3611902892589569,
0.3720055818557739,
-0.07837694138288498,
-0.07147157192230225,
0.31270670890808105,
-0.5388527512550354,
0.22819453477859497,
0.24975037574768066,
0.6738638877868652,
0.9831993579864502,
-0.1155022606253624,
-0.1293712705373764,
0.3165912926197052,
-0.47183260321617126,
0.3689277172088623,
0.2936103940010071,
-0.13122138381004333,
-0.08585444837808609,
0.47919920086860657,
0.4165395498275757,
-0.28800302743911743,
-0.4623076319694519,
0.6789186596870422,
-0.5783213973045349,
-0.3920583128929138,
-0.1722971796989441,
-0.13478726148605347,
-0.20986530184745789,
0.6560612916946411,
0.2230665385723114,
-0.09441540390253067,
0.6643837094306946,
-0.7162718176841736,
0.318932443857193,
0.30410394072532654,
-0.3007792532444,
-0.09424559026956558,
0.7021122574806213,
0.12495727092027664,
0.2421301305294037,
0.351612389087677,
0.07259195297956467,
-0.3584044873714447,
0.878969669342041,
0.27066487073898315,
0.6313403248786926,
0.3461809754371643,
0.05458204075694084,
0.1007738932967186,
0.35374611616134644,
-0.25136110186576843,
-0.048987749963998795,
-0.49161800742149353,
-0.34163567423820496,
-0.5350854396820068,
-0.061579395085573196,
-0.5618882179260254,
-0.3025275766849518,
-1.0575908422470093,
-0.04488386958837509,
-0.14320817589759827,
-0.31676849722862244,
-0.2912873923778534,
-0.07412342727184296,
-0.549528956413269,
-0.009393136948347092,
0.21983717381954193,
0.5887390971183777,
-1.2933613061904907,
0.5607798099517822,
0.6141799688339233,
-0.21155402064323425,
-0.3817638158798218,
-0.07687969505786896,
-0.21426671743392944,
-0.34750163555145264,
0.18751491606235504,
-0.04288230463862419,
-0.04756927490234375,
-0.2727121114730835,
-0.18917562067508698,
-0.7033194303512573,
1.0298998355865479,
0.48558786511421204,
-0.6877638697624207,
0.03931763768196106,
0.5275643467903137,
0.5787633657455444,
-0.5137476921081543,
0.31852471828460693,
1.1475203037261963,
0.07600544393062592,
0.1578383445739746,
-1.0866447687149048,
0.15030667185783386,
-0.2482670694589615,
-0.04574943706393242,
0.08867999911308289,
-0.5591451525688171,
0.7279819846153259,
-0.5683290958404541,
-0.1384371817111969,
-0.16676703095436096,
0.5801036953926086,
0.1496839076280594,
0.31851309537887573,
0.14942283928394318,
0.5057531595230103,
0.5692055821418762,
-0.15813744068145752,
1.0920606851577759,
-0.19586658477783203,
0.10224489867687225,
1.359220027923584,
-0.511335015296936,
0.36259108781814575,
0.5547938346862793,
-0.1773240864276886,
0.31275448203086853,
0.396499902009964,
-0.21740081906318665,
0.5857017040252686,
0.28133654594421387,
0.11669490486383438,
-0.12203414738178253,
-0.28115221858024597,
-0.5832629203796387,
0.47016122937202454,
0.011892624199390411,
-0.41142597794532776,
-0.6042295694351196,
0.1328076720237732,
-0.1785265952348709,
0.10096798837184906,
-0.5479186773300171,
0.7542838454246521,
-0.09641445428133011,
-0.6297857761383057,
0.005503406282514334,
-0.06782227009534836,
0.500829815864563,
-0.5475739240646362,
-0.12531043589115143,
-0.5986629724502563,
-0.09184194356203079,
-0.2888707220554352,
-0.7222248315811157,
0.4285966157913208,
0.2026551365852356,
-0.18000534176826477,
-0.3847203850746155,
0.5147188305854797,
-0.3240225911140442,
-0.4420796036720276,
0.29608577489852905,
0.5672208070755005,
0.49627214670181274,
-0.23734711110591888,
-0.5351361036300659,
-0.21154145896434784,
-0.010732205584645271,
0.04103297367691994,
0.7160916328430176,
0.5837290287017822,
-0.6201602816581726,
0.42922863364219666,
0.7343162298202515,
0.612077534198761,
0.00279966089874506,
0.24208001792430878,
0.7939656972885132,
-0.4369397461414337,
-0.8957909941673279,
-0.6181402802467346,
0.6086641550064087,
0.05567003786563873,
-0.05362020432949066,
0.5969478487968445,
0.6864277124404907,
0.760309636592865,
-0.02812483161687851,
0.9517315626144409,
0.0013833569828420877,
0.22146034240722656,
-0.5947889685630798,
0.8983932137489319,
-0.44441717863082886,
0.009350128471851349,
-0.008253482170403004,
-0.948028028011322,
-0.2578077018260956,
0.13596557080745697,
-0.46016693115234375,
-0.12375893443822861,
0.5065850615501404,
0.42695483565330505,
-0.5245851874351501,
-0.33598852157592773,
0.23873990774154663,
-0.4273621141910553,
0.2917419373989105,
0.8065701723098755,
0.48517802357673645,
-0.4481858015060425,
0.44767799973487854,
-0.2890039384365082,
0.005781857762485743,
-0.1062598004937172,
-0.8614951372146606,
-1.0409653186798096,
-0.18453222513198853,
-0.32010868191719055,
-0.03344639390707016,
0.11514745652675629,
0.4465782940387726,
0.7554347515106201,
-0.9621046781539917,
-0.45712563395500183,
0.0674925297498703,
-0.07226860523223877,
0.2557862102985382,
-0.20575179159641266,
0.39263716340065,
0.012293670326471329,
-0.44169047474861145,
0.11866290867328644,
-0.09547394514083862,
0.3814801573753357,
0.27683761715888977,
0.23713748157024384,
0.12979257106781006,
-0.08807681500911713,
0.5661126375198364,
0.5758110880851746,
-0.34488990902900696,
0.06195433810353279,
-0.5608766674995422,
0.1485583335161209,
0.11682832986116409,
1.068594217300415,
-0.5399140119552612,
0.5536428093910217,
0.29891571402549744,
0.7816476225852966,
0.5569819808006287,
0.5528634786605835,
0.7036173939704895,
-0.5687628984451294,
0.43407565355300903,
-0.050682272762060165,
0.5129855871200562,
-0.04390498623251915,
-0.3367760479450226,
0.5080379843711853,
-0.10034871846437454,
-0.12446007132530212,
-0.685698926448822,
-0.22465923428535461,
-0.76542729139328,
-0.39674004912376404,
0.8871302604675293,
-0.5402452349662781,
-0.14474216103553772,
-0.17931286990642548,
0.022608742117881775,
0.25539517402648926,
-0.30270951986312866,
0.5492379069328308,
0.7319745421409607,
-0.05627400055527687,
-0.08063147217035294,
-0.6775506138801575,
0.14938385784626007,
0.29817092418670654,
-1.1306231021881104,
-0.062014058232307434,
0.4934648871421814,
0.6036598682403564,
0.09419257193803787,
0.6146963238716125,
-0.38833266496658325,
0.4079035222530365,
-0.08625175803899765,
0.0910521075129509,
-0.1582367867231369,
-0.5199705362319946,
-0.7937626838684082,
0.3598988354206085,
-0.5488221645355225,
0.07007504999637604
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19305v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19305v2
|
MATEval: A Multi-Agent Discussion Framework for Advancing Open-Ended Text Evaluation
| 2024-03-28T10:41:47 | 2024-04-15T14:21:52 |
Yu Li, Shenyu Zhang, Rui Wu, Xiutian Huang, Yongrui Chen, Wenhao Xu, Guilin Qi, Dehai Min
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent advancements in generative Large Language Models(LLMs) have been
remarkable, however, the quality of the text generated by these models often
reveals persistent issues. Evaluating the quality of text generated by these
models, especially in open-ended text, has consistently presented a significant
challenge. Addressing this, recent work has explored the possibility of using
LLMs as evaluators. While using a single LLM as an evaluation agent shows
potential, it is filled with significant uncertainty and instability. To
address these issues, we propose the MATEval: A "Multi-Agent Text Evaluation
framework" where all agents are played by LLMs like GPT-4. The MATEval
framework emulates human collaborative discussion methods, integrating multiple
agents' interactions to evaluate open-ended text. Our framework incorporates
self-reflection and Chain-of-Thought (CoT) strategies, along with feedback
mechanisms, enhancing the depth and breadth of the evaluation process and
guiding discussions towards consensus, while the framework generates
comprehensive evaluation reports, including error localization, error types and
scoring. Experimental results show that our framework outperforms existing
open-ended text evaluation methods and achieves the highest correlation with
human evaluation, which confirms the effectiveness and advancement of our
framework in addressing the uncertainties and instabilities in evaluating
LLMs-generated text. Furthermore, our framework significantly improves the
efficiency of text evaluation and model iteration in industrial scenarios.
|
[
-0.34509357810020447,
-0.6201168298721313,
0.6996123790740967,
0.3700115382671356,
-0.45848360657691956,
0.22611789405345917,
-0.5994136929512024,
-0.29507705569267273,
-0.08298353105783463,
0.39244887232780457,
-0.2585591971874237,
-0.6054157614707947,
-0.34818801283836365,
0.4596041440963745,
-0.1334078013896942,
1.0309821367263794,
-0.2718776762485504,
0.2102866768836975,
-0.5565035343170166,
-0.34790682792663574,
-0.4955861568450928,
-0.5212423801422119,
-0.5643758773803711,
-0.6052621006965637,
0.2690339982509613,
0.21178191900253296,
0.8963461518287659,
0.0648292675614357,
0.702092170715332,
0.4063667058944702,
-0.10284290462732315,
0.4334012269973755,
-0.5625868439674377,
0.6303309202194214,
-0.27657952904701233,
-0.2431449443101883,
-0.6841118335723877,
0.37148696184158325,
0.779390811920166,
0.030838998034596443,
-0.38744115829467773,
-0.0874398797750473,
0.03597583249211311,
0.33595141768455505,
-0.49559205770492554,
0.23686395585536957,
-0.5053679943084717,
-0.07589387893676758,
0.13330963253974915,
-0.3398178815841675,
-0.49967649579048157,
-0.3986589014530182,
0.15508009493350983,
-0.33365193009376526,
-0.2036459892988205,
0.06740070879459381,
0.6403787136077881,
0.19027595221996307,
-0.2337200939655304,
-0.2440119981765747,
-0.7453532218933105,
0.6030007004737854,
-0.5601626634597778,
0.27024781703948975,
0.29356861114501953,
0.5301584601402283,
-0.3958786725997925,
-0.6351815462112427,
-0.656936526298523,
-0.12945106625556946,
0.03579379618167877,
0.6413673758506775,
0.006256300490349531,
0.18399836122989655,
-0.4215390384197235,
0.41833576560020447,
-0.3213319778442383,
-0.02329557202756405,
-0.22030918300151825,
-0.17640824615955353,
0.6358535885810852,
0.356374591588974,
0.28338173031806946,
-0.004588210489600897,
-0.6537943482398987,
0.007003592327237129,
-0.3283745348453522,
-0.10986700654029846,
0.3858022093772888,
0.16663245856761932,
-0.02997596189379692,
0.5054926872253418,
-0.0441470630466938,
0.5473641753196716,
-0.42597323656082153,
-0.23607675731182098,
0.12066290527582169,
-0.5424146056175232,
-0.242300346493721,
-0.1824251115322113,
1.2947498559951782,
0.6037286520004272,
0.020078405737876892,
-0.4557195007801056,
-0.33352023363113403,
0.2822152078151703,
0.4585510790348053,
-0.8717108368873596,
0.059168942272663116,
0.40008822083473206,
-0.48745042085647583,
-0.5705422759056091,
0.10462240129709244,
-1.139246940612793,
-0.5449057817459106,
-0.06891927868127823,
0.5400632619857788,
-0.20151804387569427,
-0.1829790472984314,
0.15026399493217468,
-0.19189703464508057,
0.26001980900764465,
0.7107477784156799,
-0.3470418155193329,
0.25182464718818665,
0.6003419756889343,
0.7275527119636536,
-0.18251913785934448,
-0.6439870595932007,
-0.5487529635429382,
0.130649596452713,
-0.4030081629753113,
1.0383260250091553,
-0.7930900454521179,
-0.44790294766426086,
-0.22210226953029633,
-0.3811337351799011,
-0.0698518455028534,
-0.34940528869628906,
1.0404859781265259,
-0.39277878403663635,
0.5605860352516174,
0.02265743725001812,
-0.35125622153282166,
0.05588037520647049,
0.5356304049491882,
-0.5485812425613403,
1.1311818361282349,
-0.03777291998267174,
-0.9083354473114014,
0.23258352279663086,
-0.7329689264297485,
-0.2083764672279358,
0.08294441550970078,
-0.5141740441322327,
-0.6042273044586182,
-0.18207092583179474,
0.24025997519493103,
0.21549788117408752,
-1.0482456684112549,
0.23074238002300262,
-0.21677608788013458,
-0.49779632687568665,
0.3350350558757782,
-0.6763474345207214,
0.41663026809692383,
0.2524498403072357,
-0.13019175827503204,
0.6867730617523193,
-0.39542144536972046,
0.07884127646684647,
0.1458808034658432,
-0.5023224353790283,
-0.17863990366458893,
-0.07207987457513809,
-0.2240859419107437,
0.2432861030101776,
0.15624627470970154,
-0.6634708642959595,
0.18167567253112793,
-0.4062321186065674,
0.5010744333267212,
0.8142111301422119,
0.21854016184806824,
0.3778994381427765,
-0.5722254514694214,
0.9372100830078125,
-0.27179908752441406,
0.3957955539226532,
-0.4044550955295563,
-0.8110849857330322,
-0.4256342947483063,
-0.15836530923843384,
0.06377077847719193,
0.15932689607143402,
-0.742958128452301,
0.020331472158432007,
-0.22890008985996246,
-0.7463460564613342,
-0.7716628313064575,
0.02438737265765667,
0.6263835430145264,
0.22309087216854095,
0.15495195984840393,
-0.12582768499851227,
-0.23482531309127808,
-0.5869065523147583,
-0.06086055561900139,
-0.6509290933609009,
0.23662272095680237,
0.14138701558113098,
0.23586134612560272,
-0.3225960433483124,
1.2925251722335815,
-0.17380651831626892,
-0.14267957210540771,
-0.15477922558784485,
0.3357221484184265,
-0.028963476419448853,
0.23622530698776245,
0.31852445006370544,
-0.6797289848327637,
-0.22569873929023743,
0.04550362378358841,
-0.7933241128921509,
0.051711007952690125,
-0.11035614460706711,
-0.5973327159881592,
0.15741807222366333,
0.1564171016216278,
-0.5456464886665344,
0.30339187383651733,
0.7317106127738953,
-0.28438329696655273,
0.8958619236946106,
-0.39771896600723267,
0.5099848508834839,
-1.1058440208435059,
-0.14537279307842255,
-0.19693009555339813,
-0.23497994244098663,
-0.19052864611148834,
0.2337496131658554,
-0.17961114645004272,
-0.07748133689165115,
-0.2897881269454956,
0.7704492807388306,
-0.4048517346382141,
-0.08085425943136215,
-0.19745540618896484,
0.6593905091285706,
0.3769471347332001,
0.24484603106975555,
-0.16230030357837677,
1.2687158584594727,
0.1468609869480133,
-0.3637501895427704,
0.6994619965553284,
0.604000449180603,
-0.2564067840576172,
0.8328043818473816,
-0.5000747442245483,
0.33678027987480164,
-0.13386505842208862,
0.2672100067138672,
-0.9029055833816528,
0.07278863340616226,
0.3387583792209625,
-0.6234042048454285,
0.021537305787205696,
-0.02593407593667507,
-0.5700192451477051,
-0.3924606144428253,
-0.5854023098945618,
0.35235583782196045,
0.2509312927722931,
-0.5230227708816528,
0.6303818821907043,
0.37086379528045654,
-0.13272950053215027,
-0.48589396476745605,
-0.4034992754459381,
0.30777639150619507,
-0.06234348192811012,
-0.8787615299224854,
0.16700422763824463,
-0.3650606870651245,
-0.19884684681892395,
0.06936274468898773,
-0.08469650894403458,
-0.06876963376998901,
0.03151478245854378,
0.12336399406194687,
0.1307348906993866,
-0.08659793436527252,
0.430696576833725,
-0.0542704313993454,
-0.133616104722023,
0.06254595518112183,
-0.24409820139408112,
0.5158880949020386,
-0.4507405459880829,
-0.3787357807159424,
-0.003632372710853815,
0.10237002372741699,
0.740435004234314,
-0.7307021617889404,
0.6755671501159668,
0.561618983745575,
-0.2748301327228546,
-0.34046074748039246,
-0.4108162522315979,
-0.05722890794277191,
-0.4672585427761078,
0.1696024090051651,
-0.45878052711486816,
-0.8647204041481018,
0.48266392946243286,
-0.14281417429447174,
0.0977526307106018,
0.3907887935638428,
0.870820939540863,
-0.09145247936248779,
0.5835430026054382,
0.5665682554244995,
0.14196649193763733,
-0.02375754714012146,
0.08984068781137466,
0.0313267782330513,
-0.9348910450935364,
-0.36773401498794556,
-0.6268916726112366,
0.15289288759231567,
-0.16299307346343994,
-0.7233666181564331,
0.5141465067863464,
0.18487200140953064,
-0.07413557916879654,
0.0935889333486557,
-0.3767383396625519,
0.40332502126693726,
0.25631052255630493,
0.1546114832162857,
0.6429706811904907,
-0.1777721345424652,
-0.6916789412498474,
0.0898338183760643,
-0.6549509167671204,
-0.9370803236961365,
1.0772440433502197,
0.48607337474823,
0.8272853493690491,
0.25220078229904175,
0.5499488115310669,
0.4312574565410614,
0.7585483193397522,
-0.7013918161392212,
0.5285646319389343,
0.29371577501296997,
-0.6379639506340027,
-0.4835696518421173,
-0.6144269704818726,
-0.8893715143203735,
0.6699017286300659,
-0.2646646499633789,
-0.7089841961860657,
-0.1990782469511032,
-0.24906140565872192,
-0.18672244250774384,
0.32851237058639526,
-0.3629414141178131,
1.0817961692810059,
-0.21230395138263702,
-0.5984647870063782,
-0.10387849807739258,
-0.33601319789886475,
0.36755409836769104,
-0.2387184351682663,
0.28800275921821594,
-0.14832055568695068,
-0.10265176743268967,
0.6416691541671753,
-0.5553634762763977,
0.5807382464408875,
0.22845935821533203,
-0.5144295692443848,
0.7296085357666016,
0.021401820704340935,
0.436111718416214,
0.1308007538318634,
-0.4937247335910797,
-0.11990126967430115,
-0.05067148432135582,
-0.15216657519340515,
-0.7422944903373718,
0.3862287402153015,
-0.773162841796875,
-0.2817342281341553,
-0.38932520151138306,
-0.08550422638654709,
-0.2890055179595947,
0.01943332329392433,
0.10530304908752441,
0.4558023512363434,
-0.5827692747116089,
-0.02996850572526455,
0.01262359693646431,
-0.3715856075286865,
0.510744035243988,
0.37712225317955017,
-0.5936572551727295,
-1.0197832584381104,
0.8640185594558716,
-0.4295576512813568,
0.3286241888999939,
0.047583866864442825,
0.35320159792900085,
-0.3873535394668579,
-0.3127972185611725,
-0.6250096559524536,
0.16879285871982574,
-0.9358958601951599,
-0.5310576558113098,
-0.5102542042732239,
-0.101376011967659,
-0.03044375777244568,
-0.0056972261518239975,
-0.5323270559310913,
0.0633932501077652,
-0.0295400433242321,
-0.03428703546524048,
0.3678576946258545,
0.9337555766105652,
0.4227456748485565,
0.45813632011413574,
-0.9875873327255249,
0.04944361746311188,
0.2688957452774048,
0.8142811059951782,
-0.09315942227840424,
-0.2959175705909729,
-0.2871994078159332,
0.012053126469254494,
-0.31806740164756775,
-1.1528432369232178,
0.16822297871112823,
0.05310696363449097,
0.7728546261787415,
0.253583163022995,
0.37892699241638184,
0.25717851519584656,
-0.29497572779655457,
0.6777981519699097,
0.11301232874393463,
-0.9570136070251465,
0.22267557680606842,
-0.6648449897766113,
0.00881381519138813,
0.6913483142852783,
0.005972962826490402,
-0.6186510920524597,
-0.45589348673820496,
-0.366281121969223,
-0.5426485538482666,
0.8151165246963501,
0.6980246901512146,
-0.123075470328331,
0.007684313226491213,
0.2143770456314087,
0.08728960156440735,
0.5712645649909973,
-0.6521367430686951,
0.013969878666102886,
0.07509966939687729,
-0.1554604470729828,
-0.1839531809091568,
-0.3644515573978424,
-0.19269917905330658,
0.11662880331277847,
0.6764131784439087,
-0.24712254106998444,
0.4634522795677185,
0.3047820031642914,
-0.08304166048765182,
-0.27241796255111694,
0.6604092121124268,
0.4827805459499359,
0.6415308117866516,
-0.3095659613609314,
0.04381478950381279,
0.02672569826245308,
-0.24826444685459137,
0.4064202606678009,
0.06916399300098419,
-0.07638552039861679,
-0.09314826130867004,
0.25978168845176697,
0.6349782943725586,
0.09870463609695435,
-0.6932284832000732,
0.8364083170890808,
-0.4491107165813446,
0.0029287429060786963,
-0.07477216422557831,
-0.2661456763744354,
0.12620583176612854,
0.29511725902557373,
0.027880387380719185,
0.08941109478473663,
-0.04678676277399063,
-0.584293007850647,
0.2580631971359253,
0.2733340859413147,
-0.44733336567878723,
-0.09914100915193558,
0.6901169419288635,
0.6655189990997314,
-0.2795494794845581,
0.3542031943798065,
-0.6180102229118347,
-0.8707299828529358,
0.5607007145881653,
0.4882415235042572,
1.0718084573745728,
-0.21532458066940308,
0.6065955758094788,
0.019857125356793404,
0.7555228471755981,
-0.06077541783452034,
0.4822847545146942,
0.06174013763666153,
-0.8137126564979553,
-0.5349629521369934,
-0.9022135138511658,
-0.9596467614173889,
-0.3309357166290283,
-0.2824018895626068,
0.3781670033931732,
-0.2994273602962494,
-0.35031208395957947,
-0.5521481037139893,
-0.15163205564022064,
-0.3415696918964386,
0.04495846480131149,
-0.15120211243629456,
0.6682329177856445,
-0.6033775806427002,
0.5904322266578674,
1.028862714767456,
-0.690148115158081,
-0.4687349498271942,
0.20426250994205475,
-0.2761712074279785,
-0.34179338812828064,
0.19950732588768005,
0.24915631115436554,
-0.5521600246429443,
-0.15495362877845764,
-0.2305804193019867,
-0.5026066303253174,
1.1202383041381836,
0.46770691871643066,
-0.16829973459243774,
0.2146422117948532,
-0.012240055948495865,
0.8328127264976501,
-0.36892765760421753,
0.9588795304298401,
0.2153758853673935,
0.6069546937942505,
0.05322382226586342,
-1.1643545627593994,
0.010148141533136368,
-0.3579053580760956,
-0.05603376775979996,
0.12840621173381805,
-1.1553475856781006,
0.7063605189323425,
-0.1228446289896965,
-0.3360826373100281,
0.14578460156917572,
0.6428956985473633,
0.09188027679920197,
0.29210156202316284,
0.230990469455719,
0.3686677813529968,
0.6532585620880127,
-0.07085266709327698,
1.0603158473968506,
-0.1855935901403427,
0.5161422491073608,
1.273276448249817,
-0.4700092077255249,
0.8898060321807861,
0.021733734756708145,
-0.3963801860809326,
0.3297412693500519,
0.3718408942222595,
0.22234272956848145,
-0.04825204983353615,
0.17332136631011963,
-0.27652284502983093,
-0.3445149064064026,
-0.09886832535266876,
-0.27210772037506104,
0.7487236261367798,
0.08681964874267578,
-0.09695685654878616,
-0.42769286036491394,
-0.011275381781160831,
0.004575057420879602,
0.4642840325832367,
0.06725731492042542,
0.792434573173523,
-0.08189099282026291,
-0.6875197291374207,
0.44999951124191284,
0.4853718876838684,
0.5692020654678345,
-0.35281357169151306,
-0.10538704693317413,
-0.19952936470508575,
0.041513387113809586,
0.006372504401952028,
-0.7345101833343506,
0.10291536897420883,
0.05120483785867691,
0.06111874803900719,
-0.19457130134105682,
0.6527004837989807,
-0.5403345823287964,
-0.21794553101062775,
0.6276031732559204,
0.6507235765457153,
0.3013066351413727,
-0.2901836633682251,
-0.4810672104358673,
0.3695194721221924,
-0.2872808873653412,
-0.1288461685180664,
0.07803070545196533,
0.4797731041908264,
0.007330130320042372,
0.6291120648384094,
0.4553786516189575,
-0.16547398269176483,
-0.06777197867631912,
0.09511608630418777,
1.0043829679489136,
-0.455634206533432,
-0.4064410328865051,
-0.8131767511367798,
0.44268009066581726,
-0.07742400467395782,
-0.4193713068962097,
0.5586390495300293,
0.5609632730484009,
0.5735636949539185,
0.3337084650993347,
0.7720818519592285,
0.41674545407295227,
0.2981342673301697,
-0.42588844895362854,
1.0224218368530273,
-0.45343008637428284,
0.3584502935409546,
-0.6788461804389954,
-1.1822582483291626,
-0.026293113827705383,
0.628385603427887,
-0.1599779725074768,
0.2520028054714203,
0.8737891316413879,
0.35896915197372437,
0.24380162358283997,
0.36203527450561523,
0.3853147625923157,
0.17364217340946198,
0.542478084564209,
0.2853390574455261,
1.2518771886825562,
-0.504291296005249,
0.8827841281890869,
0.004599791951477528,
-0.28688791394233704,
0.05619201436638832,
-1.0366681814193726,
-0.9415242075920105,
-0.5358818769454956,
-0.2341114729642868,
-0.38014769554138184,
0.3411467373371124,
1.1194599866867065,
0.36214613914489746,
-0.21699196100234985,
-0.37317439913749695,
0.05727538838982582,
0.08885650336742401,
0.1433277428150177,
-0.21576301753520966,
0.1826447993516922,
-0.4736407995223999,
-0.7542868256568909,
0.5072100162506104,
0.5841856598854065,
-0.16583096981048584,
-0.5238818526268005,
-0.5141642689704895,
-0.1136268675327301,
0.15484759211540222,
0.5523316264152527,
-0.23179031908512115,
-0.6263048052787781,
-0.09360845386981964,
-0.2974174916744232,
-0.301532119512558,
0.161989226937294,
0.6062724590301514,
-0.7952628135681152,
1.0111644268035889,
0.36447104811668396,
0.8721684217453003,
0.14882944524288177,
0.2889838218688965,
0.923826277256012,
-0.46693113446235657,
0.04227473586797714,
0.23109927773475647,
0.2703941762447357,
0.2537894546985626,
-0.1118512898683548,
0.6672921776771545,
0.14055320620536804,
-0.7295277714729309,
-0.6720885038375854,
0.08005490899085999,
-0.6928234100341797,
-0.19092170894145966,
1.1348172426223755,
-0.3210139870643616,
-0.026959413662552834,
0.017679622396826744,
-0.5569160580635071,
0.23805218935012817,
-0.6457200646400452,
0.45334139466285706,
0.9095284938812256,
0.09896211326122284,
-0.15355132520198822,
-0.33137747645378113,
0.24790872633457184,
0.4147137999534607,
-1.1117993593215942,
0.038834672421216965,
0.5816165208816528,
-0.19373372197151184,
-0.0006088786758482456,
0.9088548421859741,
-0.29685261845588684,
0.10342646390199661,
0.10024634748697281,
0.22975721955299377,
-0.12469248473644257,
-0.650282621383667,
-0.40320882201194763,
0.18801061809062958,
0.3778652250766754,
-0.04983459413051605
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19728v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19728v1
|
EmoScan: Automatic Screening of Depression Symptoms in Romanized Sinhala Tweets
| 2024-03-28T10:31:09 | 2024-03-28T10:31:09 |
Jayathi Hewapathirana, Deshan Sumanathilaka
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
This work explores the utilization of Romanized Sinhala social media data to
identify individuals at risk of depression. A machine learning-based framework
is presented for the automatic screening of depression symptoms by analyzing
language patterns, sentiment, and behavioural cues within a comprehensive
dataset of social media posts. The research has been carried out to compare the
suitability of Neural Networks over the classical machine learning techniques.
The proposed Neural Network with an attention layer which is capable of
handling long sequence data, attains a remarkable accuracy of 93.25% in
detecting depression symptoms, surpassing current state-of-the-art methods.
These findings underscore the efficacy of this approach in pinpointing
individuals in need of proactive interventions and support. Mental health
professionals, policymakers, and social media companies can gain valuable
insights through the proposed model. Leveraging natural language processing
techniques and machine learning algorithms, this work offers a promising
pathway for mental health screening in the digital era. By harnessing the
potential of social media data, the framework introduces a proactive method for
recognizing and assisting individuals at risk of depression. In conclusion,
this research contributes to the advancement of proactive interventions and
support systems for mental health, thereby influencing both research and
practical applications in the field.
|
[
-0.1323596090078354,
-0.9349055886268616,
0.7112284898757935,
0.4932901859283447,
-0.46423467993736267,
-0.006687987130135298,
-0.17837722599506378,
-0.13069219887256622,
0.8452678918838501,
0.3927614688873291,
-0.7515928745269775,
-0.8230074048042297,
-1.0366030931472778,
0.4536443054676056,
-0.47504425048828125,
0.6416789889335632,
-0.25932660698890686,
0.1522524207830429,
0.2944351136684418,
0.3339467942714691,
-0.2615298628807068,
-0.06226067245006561,
-1.339439034461975,
0.06209342181682587,
0.4932326376438141,
0.3189104199409485,
0.40639379620552063,
-0.05363835021853447,
0.5680521726608276,
0.24657906591892242,
0.052963923662900925,
0.22664763033390045,
-0.1814933717250824,
0.30997151136398315,
-0.049988918006420135,
-0.42410263419151306,
-0.2332175076007843,
-0.2529064118862152,
0.2521183490753174,
0.15249434113502502,
-0.05074536055326462,
0.19055436551570892,
0.2988477349281311,
0.5124363899230957,
-0.6111807227134705,
0.04949668049812317,
-0.40548521280288696,
0.5685330629348755,
-0.036304596811532974,
-0.3372425138950348,
0.026272697374224663,
-0.59244304895401,
-0.35546329617500305,
-0.36236247420310974,
0.03615759685635567,
-0.4068497121334076,
0.5901675820350647,
0.7909795641899109,
-0.4631059765815735,
-0.5922651290893555,
-0.5817883014678955,
0.6848459839820862,
-0.5969036221504211,
0.156312957406044,
0.8683730363845825,
0.6928980946540833,
0.07490944117307663,
-0.4307553768157959,
-0.049396418035030365,
0.0841645747423172,
-0.09718239307403564,
0.09941300749778748,
-0.2526782751083374,
0.14507286250591278,
0.14845813810825348,
0.2416583001613617,
-0.624483585357666,
-0.1381576955318451,
-0.5735111236572266,
-0.2630736231803894,
0.7707487344741821,
0.21347543597221375,
0.4844817519187927,
-0.42871907353401184,
0.05022843927145004,
0.2656276822090149,
-0.22849701344966888,
0.16889415681362152,
0.2045665979385376,
0.272869348526001,
-0.3406185209751129,
0.6099885702133179,
-0.31202441453933716,
0.6094087958335876,
-0.02561042085289955,
-0.09670068323612213,
-0.013922042213380337,
-0.05276063457131386,
-0.5720269680023193,
0.37760958075523376,
0.9466410279273987,
0.261348694562912,
-0.011446909978985786,
0.13942237198352814,
-0.21727606654167175,
0.15224722027778625,
0.4429170787334442,
-0.6737900376319885,
-0.16398359835147858,
0.4549550712108612,
-0.7352912425994873,
-0.4872460961341858,
-0.14201386272907257,
-0.9847505688667297,
-0.794437050819397,
-0.29720351099967957,
0.3132247030735016,
-0.5065298080444336,
-0.2787083089351654,
-0.01910342089831829,
-0.20889577269554138,
-0.41546720266342163,
0.25678011775016785,
-0.5779074430465698,
0.1674119383096695,
0.5662674903869629,
1.1483289003372192,
0.1422816514968872,
0.3495614230632782,
-0.16404032707214355,
-0.09683021903038025,
-0.27263182401657104,
0.6505968570709229,
-0.44306889176368713,
-0.062148962169885635,
0.11283479630947113,
0.2907180190086365,
-0.32659482955932617,
-0.2549368441104889,
0.8709626793861389,
-0.08164797723293304,
-0.0556885227560997,
-0.07918375730514526,
-0.24398857355117798,
-0.20834332704544067,
0.5981422066688538,
-0.812888503074646,
0.6798387765884399,
0.2348993867635727,
-0.9093138575553894,
0.06827742606401443,
-0.6732886433601379,
-0.46810564398765564,
0.008936041966080666,
-0.12433061003684998,
-0.3214628994464874,
-0.04117061570286751,
0.3288213908672333,
0.8731220364570618,
-0.44232261180877686,
0.3047226667404175,
-0.6477832794189453,
-0.3040996789932251,
0.3052188456058502,
-0.11080610752105713,
1.1700103282928467,
0.5847267508506775,
-0.5365493893623352,
-0.0831170454621315,
-0.556107223033905,
-0.136612668633461,
0.10970430076122284,
-0.10173717886209488,
-0.4516708254814148,
0.0002603716275189072,
-0.06142517551779747,
0.27622896432876587,
-0.0794316902756691,
-0.7296826243400574,
-0.45009857416152954,
-0.23822687566280365,
0.528946042060852,
0.5176639556884766,
0.28954505920410156,
-0.1191801056265831,
-0.0731678307056427,
0.9029763340950012,
-0.034861233085393906,
0.439956396818161,
-0.04391983151435852,
-0.6532465219497681,
-0.09481245279312134,
-0.5885977149009705,
0.09518758952617645,
0.7651920318603516,
-0.5738401412963867,
0.9215710759162903,
0.18266591429710388,
-0.6788058876991272,
-0.6756801009178162,
0.29325494170188904,
0.14498573541641235,
0.28284743428230286,
0.10524456948041916,
-0.2577971816062927,
-0.9938815236091614,
-0.6353017687797546,
-0.308891624212265,
0.15179936587810516,
-0.12398312240839005,
0.4063864052295685,
0.0567474439740181,
-0.7452729940414429,
0.6483879685401917,
-0.5719438195228577,
-0.7234489917755127,
-0.3028544485569,
-0.11873888969421387,
0.21224461495876312,
-0.01853863149881363,
0.38692188262939453,
-0.931613564491272,
-0.7153823375701904,
0.0020397945772856474,
-1.1006865501403809,
-0.3244560956954956,
-0.01601594313979149,
0.06678516417741776,
0.08749915659427643,
0.4455924332141876,
-0.34750011563301086,
0.657289981842041,
0.7894508242607117,
-0.5078669786453247,
-0.0998646542429924,
0.13639985024929047,
0.11543170362710953,
-1.331577181816101,
0.10123658180236816,
0.4069535732269287,
-0.2467409372329712,
-0.33273062109947205,
-0.6398608088493347,
-0.0675603449344635,
-0.45760297775268555,
-0.2409154176712036,
0.43079325556755066,
0.03411872684955597,
0.21247424185276031,
-0.29763102531433105,
0.010187219828367233,
0.03367270156741142,
0.03198074921965599,
-0.42112797498703003,
0.11830393224954605,
0.7934157848358154,
-0.6753162741661072,
0.5614578723907471,
-0.0463707372546196,
-0.09145203977823257,
0.5901848077774048,
-0.4250163733959198,
-0.33491453528404236,
-0.24553051590919495,
0.3570457696914673,
-1.180200219154358,
-0.5107243061065674,
0.7099090218544006,
-0.6343467235565186,
0.08918023854494095,
0.2173214554786682,
-0.23268726468086243,
-0.5670806765556335,
-0.27368056774139404,
0.3952955901622772,
0.1901392936706543,
-0.20476405322551727,
0.5714027881622314,
0.7006648778915405,
-0.20990319550037384,
-0.2849176824092865,
-0.7820566296577454,
0.1753598302602768,
-0.556557297706604,
-0.4645576775074005,
0.38143354654312134,
0.4052421450614929,
-0.11037205159664154,
0.12505026161670685,
0.3417847454547882,
-0.19732193648815155,
0.40249887108802795,
0.6062076687812805,
-0.1837557703256607,
0.09007801860570908,
0.27626264095306396,
0.33623573184013367,
-0.05234237760305405,
0.07295125722885132,
0.026794686913490295,
0.6791030168533325,
0.16299700736999512,
-0.028080595657229424,
-0.9067829847335815,
0.292807400226593,
0.421963632106781,
0.23876595497131348,
0.6383209228515625,
0.6644696593284607,
-0.9621211886405945,
-0.1783851832151413,
-0.15848396718502045,
-0.08647178113460541,
-0.43033042550086975,
-0.07615387439727783,
-0.17726276814937592,
-0.5232412815093994,
0.5303422808647156,
-0.2723538279533386,
-0.5399782657623291,
0.5856273770332336,
0.6214060187339783,
-0.14835458993911743,
1.3516628742218018,
0.6616738438606262,
-0.07017538696527481,
0.5941928625106812,
-0.16535775363445282,
0.5478814840316772,
-0.6166818141937256,
-0.06230011582374573,
-0.34682944416999817,
-0.3561364710330963,
-0.6295384764671326,
-0.1372273564338684,
0.22063948214054108,
-0.18248936533927917,
-0.363521546125412,
0.5326399207115173,
-0.811937153339386,
-0.02323022484779358,
0.12032450735569,
0.5668081641197205,
-0.033322323113679886,
0.06360377371311188,
-0.1715293973684311,
-0.2949320077896118,
-0.32961684465408325,
-0.5457332134246826,
1.180107831954956,
0.44811996817588806,
0.8580449819564819,
-0.14693349599838257,
0.9541632533073425,
0.8318238854408264,
0.2873981297016144,
-0.7762158513069153,
0.24758405983448029,
-0.3491184413433075,
-0.6092361211776733,
-0.44790324568748474,
-0.4190326929092407,
-1.0144554376602173,
-0.35960131883621216,
0.09576915949583054,
-0.7253627181053162,
0.39795830845832825,
-0.1077907383441925,
-0.6813636422157288,
0.26610273122787476,
-0.7356781363487244,
0.8431227803230286,
-0.5825567841529846,
0.1330648958683014,
-0.35939493775367737,
-0.43616122007369995,
0.4336705803871155,
-0.4730586111545563,
0.28249919414520264,
-0.4717314839363098,
0.16238464415073395,
0.7913280725479126,
-0.08930916339159012,
1.2362875938415527,
-0.16881857812404633,
-0.03939371928572655,
0.2186921238899231,
-0.08347543329000473,
0.06999874114990234,
0.23936717212200165,
-0.26433634757995605,
0.10801263898611069,
0.13618312776088715,
-0.35668259859085083,
-0.31791263818740845,
0.7308838367462158,
-0.8006495833396912,
-0.06327641010284424,
-0.2166774719953537,
-0.051696427166461945,
0.1278107464313507,
0.32523226737976074,
0.26375752687454224,
0.1056097149848938,
-0.4292409121990204,
0.034449733793735504,
0.16831251978874207,
-0.4638479948043823,
0.2641739249229431,
0.009137680754065514,
-0.16712990403175354,
-0.8590221405029297,
0.8007529973983765,
0.24138207733631134,
-0.29762518405914307,
0.33441534638404846,
0.3203602731227875,
-0.16422982513904572,
0.18020108342170715,
-0.18012087047100067,
0.2899642884731293,
-0.6591847538948059,
-0.4228205382823944,
-0.8812586665153503,
-0.18197695910930634,
-0.8519785404205322,
-0.10918642580509186,
-0.31068530678749084,
-0.3791525363922119,
-0.2153274118900299,
-0.08412840962409973,
0.29046982526779175,
0.7117514610290527,
-0.20398454368114471,
0.321173757314682,
-0.7370141744613647,
0.5949309468269348,
0.14188238978385925,
0.4841621220111847,
-0.11877454072237015,
-0.10790317505598068,
-0.25969380140304565,
0.19661056995391846,
-0.6751089096069336,
-1.2375833988189697,
0.7731346487998962,
0.2517565190792084,
0.33045288920402527,
1.013715147972107,
0.37361180782318115,
0.4456202983856201,
0.20233842730522156,
0.5057896971702576,
0.17278902232646942,
-0.741855263710022,
1.1755129098892212,
-0.24500809609889984,
-0.23282507061958313,
0.5440150499343872,
0.9260978698730469,
-1.129273772239685,
-0.26776430010795593,
-0.6796640157699585,
-0.6489764451980591,
0.9404672980308533,
0.23452217876911163,
-0.05558653175830841,
-0.0985710397362709,
0.19138647615909576,
-0.02535994164645672,
0.10354547202587128,
-0.35113945603370667,
-0.06907286494970322,
-0.364035964012146,
-0.7495893239974976,
-0.21914412081241608,
-0.13706447184085846,
-0.35884150862693787,
-0.3229418396949768,
0.5845463871955872,
-0.09200149774551392,
0.6919988393783569,
0.4699704647064209,
-0.01974204182624817,
-0.38967323303222656,
-0.14387358725070953,
0.2605290710926056,
0.24136163294315338,
-0.3913131654262543,
0.22250427305698395,
-0.11538530886173248,
-0.31887927651405334,
0.023156078532338142,
0.2989450991153717,
-0.3159855008125305,
0.3545188009738922,
0.03259596973657608,
0.8486109375953674,
0.015174233354628086,
-0.7113230228424072,
0.4529270827770233,
-0.35033783316612244,
-0.10600689053535461,
-0.7823590636253357,
-0.062081605195999146,
0.026365546509623528,
0.24314652383327484,
0.3313044309616089,
-0.07192084193229675,
0.3877035081386566,
-0.589413046836853,
0.11098075658082962,
0.24067158997058868,
-0.7654248476028442,
-0.4171063005924225,
0.37725841999053955,
0.10319261252880096,
-0.8687577247619629,
0.3475153148174286,
-0.1363339126110077,
-0.6542037129402161,
1.0779855251312256,
0.36122050881385803,
1.1830735206604004,
-0.6009078621864319,
0.6679496169090271,
0.5862742066383362,
0.34079763293266296,
-0.1766337901353836,
0.49365440011024475,
-0.0738699808716774,
-0.593033492565155,
0.09333211183547974,
-0.5692347884178162,
-0.38704800605773926,
0.03763966262340546,
-0.3572593033313751,
0.7141782641410828,
-0.7400159239768982,
-0.6414751410484314,
-0.09968391805887222,
0.02628841996192932,
-0.564755380153656,
0.7339929342269897,
0.6328966021537781,
0.5053964853286743,
-1.2595643997192383,
0.4887733459472656,
0.8201585412025452,
-0.1962626874446869,
-0.651561975479126,
0.18066641688346863,
0.30703890323638916,
-0.5745450258255005,
0.3453272581100464,
0.8299672603607178,
0.21697145700454712,
-0.007402734365314245,
-0.17163284122943878,
-0.979156494140625,
1.254280686378479,
0.3540992736816406,
-0.06043727695941925,
0.11956632882356644,
0.2512710690498352,
0.6691920757293701,
-0.6793045401573181,
0.5880986452102661,
0.5315759181976318,
0.4615083932876587,
-0.05855387821793556,
-0.7301241755485535,
0.2484109103679657,
-0.4270693063735962,
-0.032428860664367676,
0.14918261766433716,
-0.457966685295105,
0.5558462142944336,
0.15874406695365906,
-0.6003648042678833,
-0.5120314359664917,
-0.00701620988547802,
0.15248391032218933,
0.835253894329071,
0.5519809722900391,
0.816724956035614,
0.913263738155365,
0.235710009932518,
1.0459338426589966,
-0.4459317922592163,
0.4011309742927551,
0.32595083117485046,
-0.12471374124288559,
0.6035914421081543,
0.26616063714027405,
-0.15332673490047455,
0.41579490900039673,
1.1763440370559692,
0.022939041256904602,
0.6040864586830139,
-0.12216712534427643,
-0.2592373490333557,
-0.17326699197292328,
-0.39622876048088074,
-0.07852966338396072,
0.2191946804523468,
0.8172494769096375,
-1.0291563272476196,
-0.45248520374298096,
0.42917928099632263,
-0.28448185324668884,
-0.025218648836016655,
-0.26070430874824524,
0.6200070381164551,
0.5020272135734558,
-0.5443183779716492,
0.6279879808425903,
0.1702868789434433,
0.6760162115097046,
-0.3014158606529236,
0.254626601934433,
0.002428356558084488,
0.47859054803848267,
-0.6188229322433472,
-0.5615004301071167,
1.017404317855835,
0.09434135258197784,
0.06310773640871048,
-0.3147422969341278,
1.0856072902679443,
-0.10928361862897873,
-0.8569214344024658,
0.8330370187759399,
0.3026394844055176,
0.3759799301624298,
-0.5611262917518616,
-0.9494082927703857,
-0.10598573833703995,
-0.03740756958723068,
-0.11348637193441391,
0.04405086860060692,
0.6375279426574707,
-0.20442500710487366,
0.6037343144416809,
0.3119843304157257,
0.24004647135734558,
0.07813713699579239,
0.04183042794466019,
0.6441084742546082,
-0.7608695030212402,
-0.5921216011047363,
-0.9885635375976562,
0.11252984404563904,
-0.2572798430919647,
-0.14755059778690338,
0.5109459161758423,
0.3164026737213135,
0.5374879837036133,
0.008190058171749115,
0.9937251806259155,
-0.4661248028278351,
0.8055386543273926,
-0.04864177852869034,
0.8031483292579651,
-0.7436938285827637,
-0.19694191217422485,
-0.16172684729099274,
-0.5990461707115173,
-0.5171970129013062,
0.5072840452194214,
-0.6025344729423523,
-0.13040612637996674,
0.717279314994812,
0.926253080368042,
-0.05846858397126198,
-0.0054903458803892136,
0.19431044161319733,
0.04200286045670509,
0.11248470842838287,
0.6253067255020142,
0.44708457589149475,
-0.6814004182815552,
0.24922305345535278,
-0.5875458121299744,
-0.19708065688610077,
-0.7005177140235901,
-0.39977455139160156,
-0.9080421924591064,
-0.5987287163734436,
-0.27295151352882385,
-0.274152934551239,
0.005846854764968157,
1.1018420457839966,
0.28716346621513367,
-0.8265828490257263,
0.05560959503054619,
-0.2498173862695694,
0.35411176085472107,
-0.2482052892446518,
-0.22616498172283173,
0.39723750948905945,
-0.28654778003692627,
-0.5215831995010376,
0.04807116091251373,
0.20421001315116882,
-0.2673824429512024,
-0.09937096387147903,
-0.05475209653377533,
-0.09350492060184479,
-0.1397283971309662,
0.45272886753082275,
0.24827727675437927,
-0.5208041667938232,
0.38847577571868896,
0.050960756838321686,
-0.5649319887161255,
-0.08621471375226974,
0.7403133511543274,
-0.49543288350105286,
0.29309096932411194,
0.6717877984046936,
0.7437536120414734,
0.1234985813498497,
-0.02204415388405323,
0.5043531656265259,
-0.30341917276382446,
-0.00920950248837471,
0.4476141631603241,
0.36033275723457336,
0.5633512139320374,
-0.9844719171524048,
0.5443136692047119,
0.20958612859249115,
-0.3049689829349518,
-0.7567949891090393,
-0.13479292392730713,
-0.7745928764343262,
-0.32112225890159607,
1.2295756340026855,
-0.07288070768117905,
-0.5686615705490112,
-0.44848325848579407,
-0.37542828917503357,
0.8081627488136292,
-0.35428693890571594,
1.4160327911376953,
0.4684290289878845,
-0.08946958184242249,
-0.1304907649755478,
-0.5685814023017883,
0.551359236240387,
0.3957385718822479,
-0.6484233140945435,
-0.3208746910095215,
-0.1147238090634346,
0.028024470433592796,
0.08056765794754028,
0.8599724173545837,
-0.07847481220960617,
0.3117187023162842,
-0.4205282926559448,
0.21701116859912872,
0.21270208060741425,
0.010099472478032112,
-0.6466053128242493,
0.10163190960884094,
-0.42633846402168274,
-0.1860419511795044
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19285v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19285v2
|
Going Beyond Word Matching: Syntax Improves In-context Example Selection for Machine Translation
| 2024-03-28T10:13:34 | 2024-05-29T00:51:24 |
Chenming Tang, Zhixiang Wang, Yunfang Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In-context learning (ICL) is the trending prompting strategy in the era of
large language models (LLMs), where a few examples are demonstrated to evoke
LLMs' power for a given task. How to select informative examples remains an
open issue. Previous works on in-context example selection for machine
translation (MT) focus on superficial word-level features while ignoring deep
syntax-level knowledge. In this paper, we propose a syntax-based in-context
example selection method for MT, by computing the syntactic similarity between
dependency trees using Polynomial Distance. In addition, we propose an ensemble
strategy combining examples selected by both word-level and syntax-level
criteria. Experimental results between English and 6 common languages indicate
that syntax can effectively enhancing ICL for MT, obtaining the highest COMET
scores on 11 out of 12 translation directions.
|
[
-0.3248611390590668,
-0.4988393187522888,
0.7795799374580383,
0.18121051788330078,
-0.7359874248504639,
0.08493632078170776,
-0.2773081362247467,
-0.2837424874305725,
-0.051304079592227936,
0.30382317304611206,
-0.45365697145462036,
-0.6501848101615906,
-0.3886553645133972,
0.3999737799167633,
-0.6679856777191162,
1.0118333101272583,
-0.06335385143756866,
0.016031306236982346,
-0.6842591762542725,
-0.1195734441280365,
-0.45169752836227417,
-0.5011442303657532,
-0.49082136154174805,
-0.1927005648612976,
0.19924785196781158,
0.6020528674125671,
0.21467117965221405,
0.4954008460044861,
0.47384053468704224,
0.2885172665119171,
-0.0827968642115593,
0.38577529788017273,
-0.21831746399402618,
0.4058813154697418,
0.01378596294671297,
-0.47105950117111206,
0.20737040042877197,
-0.1316549926996231,
0.8359574675559998,
0.7033987641334534,
0.15613523125648499,
0.11574011296033859,
0.2269449383020401,
0.6483203768730164,
-0.3870653808116913,
0.2807862460613251,
-0.9919053316116333,
0.1383877694606781,
-0.160780668258667,
-0.32243144512176514,
-0.5725935101509094,
-0.2027522623538971,
0.18568578362464905,
-0.4225253462791443,
-0.07176008820533752,
0.291024774312973,
0.5463609099388123,
0.16951023042201996,
-0.3019201159477234,
-0.326445609331131,
-0.2297987937927246,
0.7750279903411865,
-0.6946994662284851,
0.36041030287742615,
0.27042198181152344,
0.2799077332019806,
-0.26354020833969116,
-0.6466785669326782,
-0.40255114436149597,
-0.2643328607082367,
-0.33349907398223877,
0.11024344712495804,
-0.08850805461406708,
-0.0015402676071971655,
0.20647984743118286,
0.11455407738685608,
-0.5501237511634827,
-0.10378200560808182,
-0.1209983304142952,
0.22164174914360046,
0.025604944676160812,
-0.09238553792238235,
0.24808156490325928,
-0.19091466069221497,
-0.4625774919986725,
-0.3043557107448578,
-1.0430988073349,
0.05458000302314758,
0.05632736161351204,
0.44935446977615356,
-0.030296092852950096,
0.3484090268611908,
-0.21818530559539795,
0.8631246089935303,
0.11965028941631317,
0.017892401665449142,
0.259123831987381,
-0.16414529085159302,
-0.25654336810112,
0.03307734429836273,
0.5736667513847351,
0.5394352674484253,
-0.0019974871538579464,
-0.4099695086479187,
-0.24090810120105743,
-0.21179364621639252,
-0.037641339004039764,
-0.8275020718574524,
-0.0034656815696507692,
0.0413290411233902,
-0.5006570219993591,
-0.13906195759773254,
0.14106111228466034,
-0.8980565667152405,
-0.017420638352632523,
-0.2974691390991211,
0.2007865458726883,
-0.6064441800117493,
0.034196577966213226,
-0.3658863306045532,
-0.35548684000968933,
0.3051498532295227,
0.18012471497058868,
-0.6522729992866516,
0.33962681889533997,
0.6488361954689026,
0.843707799911499,
-0.12562303245067596,
-0.4352165162563324,
-0.8274474740028381,
0.163052037358284,
-0.36721178889274597,
0.6675019264221191,
-0.7067334055900574,
-0.21431998908519745,
0.04543612152338028,
-0.2885565459728241,
-0.11542244255542755,
-0.7982026934623718,
0.259752094745636,
-0.39573541283607483,
0.3869071900844574,
-0.0874333530664444,
-0.6208109855651855,
-0.36356988549232483,
0.16971240937709808,
-0.05716699734330177,
1.0932774543762207,
0.5070706009864807,
-0.4900488555431366,
0.8232334852218628,
-0.6771003603935242,
-0.6299285888671875,
0.3035740554332733,
-0.286196768283844,
-0.30622678995132446,
0.18858031928539276,
0.1742924302816391,
0.6544179916381836,
-0.1741863191127777,
0.17535842955112457,
-0.28267940878868103,
-0.37996160984039307,
0.08613911271095276,
-0.08028177171945572,
0.5062042474746704,
0.25902530550956726,
-0.37063485383987427,
0.26991018652915955,
-0.42456990480422974,
0.09784157574176788,
-0.18062174320220947,
-0.1508263349533081,
-0.7108951210975647,
0.06079339236021042,
0.015957925468683243,
0.6023581027984619,
-0.03543534874916077,
-0.2009812593460083,
0.1469363421201706,
-0.6693774461746216,
0.5595213174819946,
0.4595654308795929,
-0.022495733574032784,
0.4728189706802368,
-0.16307894885540009,
0.5060895681381226,
-0.012728733941912651,
-0.15423808991909027,
-0.191159188747406,
-0.3450039327144623,
-0.4920329749584198,
-0.3042680323123932,
0.29682213068008423,
0.5396358966827393,
-0.924279510974884,
0.6631629467010498,
-0.323397696018219,
-0.19972001016139984,
-0.5231025815010071,
0.32027894258499146,
0.6943304538726807,
0.6597016453742981,
0.5900185108184814,
-0.029391445219516754,
-0.4783473014831543,
-0.846366822719574,
-0.4431348145008087,
-0.2334139347076416,
0.03504130616784096,
0.3886288106441498,
0.310702383518219,
0.12443365901708603,
0.900685727596283,
-0.18992188572883606,
-0.028907639905810356,
-0.5846943855285645,
-0.26960429549217224,
0.23860827088356018,
0.3406543731689453,
0.7439591288566589,
-0.844689130783081,
-0.7209736704826355,
0.09823670983314514,
-0.5698645710945129,
-0.10360006242990494,
-0.032349228858947754,
-0.22761015594005585,
0.07470347732305527,
0.9377431869506836,
-0.6459526419639587,
0.20741486549377441,
0.30164632201194763,
-0.2781215310096741,
-0.033231932669878006,
-0.25574132800102234,
0.25800076127052307,
-1.2696629762649536,
-0.1270027905702591,
0.10570929944515228,
-0.49233371019363403,
-0.4288366734981537,
0.46789678931236267,
0.29435935616493225,
0.08200216293334961,
-0.6811897158622742,
0.5355736613273621,
-0.3561893105506897,
-0.1848413199186325,
-0.015792952850461006,
0.42310845851898193,
-0.14848990738391876,
0.28100383281707764,
-0.17468786239624023,
0.7697795033454895,
0.6099482178688049,
-0.5790502429008484,
-0.09652294963598251,
0.24518950283527374,
-0.510455310344696,
0.4426269233226776,
-0.11932407319545746,
0.16911698877811432,
-0.02568388730287552,
0.2611960172653198,
-1.0279426574707031,
-0.09343110769987106,
0.0865122601389885,
-0.20134395360946655,
0.4337957799434662,
-0.303260862827301,
-0.7212681770324707,
-0.06511878222227097,
-0.31347885727882385,
0.3880143463611603,
0.7845265865325928,
-0.8412639498710632,
0.2355010062456131,
0.0368448831140995,
-0.023724805563688278,
-0.2459908276796341,
-0.5040316581726074,
0.3269304931163788,
-0.7583891153335571,
-0.26589593291282654,
0.4768233597278595,
-0.181916743516922,
-0.5510359406471252,
-0.21183468401432037,
-0.028200898319482803,
0.16755232214927673,
0.3576124608516693,
-0.05607864260673523,
0.039961088448762894,
-0.0994323343038559,
0.17567478120326996,
0.35257235169410706,
0.21266978979110718,
-0.10577500611543655,
-0.5907320976257324,
0.629240870475769,
-0.06019941344857216,
-0.15259483456611633,
-0.18080049753189087,
0.49806612730026245,
0.44128361344337463,
-0.16977524757385254,
0.5023747682571411,
0.3354414403438568,
-0.20571331679821014,
-0.5066520571708679,
-0.18894484639167786,
-0.3132305443286896,
-0.42440351843833923,
0.3516903519630432,
-0.4847297966480255,
-0.7244991064071655,
0.08914290368556976,
-0.19725680351257324,
-0.09256985783576965,
0.25085514783859253,
0.31033629179000854,
-0.021357713267207146,
0.9672574400901794,
0.5506792664527893,
-0.21147845685482025,
0.6712610721588135,
-0.14046797156333923,
0.20141668617725372,
-0.9970047473907471,
0.05156075954437256,
-0.5253898501396179,
-0.1483766883611679,
-0.5196331143379211,
-0.2795981466770172,
0.3647255599498749,
0.3576711416244507,
0.09024856984615326,
0.7642909288406372,
-0.439423531293869,
0.5960861444473267,
0.46940314769744873,
0.03346965089440346,
0.08134143054485321,
0.1366887390613556,
-0.43656259775161743,
0.08190903067588806,
-0.7247570157051086,
-0.3623914420604706,
0.7550426721572876,
-0.2035977840423584,
-0.009955476969480515,
0.2226947844028473,
0.8251757621765137,
0.07855451852083206,
0.33640918135643005,
-0.6952065229415894,
0.756503164768219,
-0.4005175530910492,
-0.012984726577997208,
-0.10031094402074814,
-0.42902112007141113,
-0.8329344391822815,
0.380308598279953,
-0.10992193222045898,
-0.6971563100814819,
-0.2583821415901184,
0.15691322088241577,
-0.05411519110202789,
-0.0007791872485540807,
-0.7174525856971741,
0.8301864862442017,
-0.005996428895741701,
0.012365848757326603,
-0.2851758897304535,
-0.8750931024551392,
-0.06914199143648148,
-0.1254987120628357,
0.312191367149353,
0.14012554287910461,
-0.15331928431987762,
0.27330487966537476,
-0.2214241623878479,
0.6367948651313782,
-0.1212548241019249,
0.1939551681280136,
0.22073256969451904,
0.19889067113399506,
0.5059111714363098,
-0.072637178003788,
-0.2626267969608307,
-0.07110155373811722,
-0.19569282233715057,
-0.05750352516770363,
-0.7323116660118103,
0.7675533294677734,
-0.25656238198280334,
-0.47543656826019287,
-0.06964975595474243,
-0.6187958717346191,
-0.3632385730743408,
0.12718378007411957,
0.35497868061065674,
0.5252028107643127,
0.1104629784822464,
0.34690746665000916,
0.35355958342552185,
-0.0581144243478775,
0.7718028426170349,
0.2523587942123413,
-0.22319553792476654,
-0.36169660091400146,
0.7239887118339539,
-0.14936664700508118,
0.41721221804618835,
0.9533118009567261,
0.3951587975025177,
-0.38293033838272095,
-0.8393492698669434,
-0.6700740456581116,
-0.10192389041185379,
-0.8506362438201904,
-0.43158209323883057,
-0.6152483820915222,
0.11148472875356674,
-0.2516798675060272,
-0.32569602131843567,
0.3723800778388977,
-0.4103628098964691,
-0.29088813066482544,
-0.10325411707162857,
0.4389283061027527,
0.6042618155479431,
0.6506893634796143,
0.1478041559457779,
-0.600576639175415,
-0.07339126616716385,
-0.022321218624711037,
0.14666078984737396,
-0.10797498375177383,
-0.6300851106643677,
-0.20818336308002472,
-0.3347075879573822,
-0.19015394151210785,
-0.6742854714393616,
0.4238969087600708,
0.4280853569507599,
0.6137588620185852,
0.30631089210510254,
-0.11042150855064392,
0.8370348215103149,
-0.657181978225708,
0.6904365420341492,
0.15281353890895844,
-1.0099761486053467,
0.6657420992851257,
-0.23828724026679993,
0.37385088205337524,
0.6715465784072876,
0.2585594058036804,
-0.5973849296569824,
-0.7944211363792419,
-0.67349773645401,
-0.8709955811500549,
0.4121449887752533,
0.299390971660614,
-0.04177364334464073,
-0.46004921197891235,
0.4225757420063019,
0.16928842663764954,
0.3463529944419861,
-0.7186263799667358,
-0.08368919789791107,
0.11705252528190613,
-0.5259851813316345,
-0.18865910172462463,
0.3385588526725769,
0.13949735462665558,
-0.38169431686401367,
0.48559442162513733,
-0.4501195549964905,
-0.06327967345714569,
0.2135765254497528,
-0.39857426285743713,
-0.0455879345536232,
0.2833543121814728,
0.5363524556159973,
0.5770948529243469,
-0.056060053408145905,
0.2243075668811798,
0.5350897908210754,
-0.08061855286359787,
-0.2129601538181305,
0.09783411026000977,
-0.3348917067050934,
0.026590978726744652,
0.3937509059906006,
0.44156530499458313,
0.3327428102493286,
-0.8285634517669678,
0.5945516228675842,
0.3121398091316223,
-0.045175470411777496,
-0.156509667634964,
0.040773022919893265,
-0.07889903336763382,
0.13488851487636566,
0.26124733686447144,
0.20269262790679932,
0.31120067834854126,
-0.7388743758201599,
0.3335520327091217,
0.7750521898269653,
-0.6323339343070984,
-0.08167781680822372,
0.29576677083969116,
-0.01877814717590809,
-0.5036751627922058,
0.48926010727882385,
-0.40177056193351746,
-0.5740665793418884,
0.5543041229248047,
0.8490796685218811,
0.7850769758224487,
0.07788874208927155,
-0.15263612568378448,
0.25282466411590576,
0.01720053143799305,
-0.04756869003176689,
0.18286001682281494,
-0.28481513261795044,
-0.3823000490665436,
-0.40290555357933044,
-0.4889976382255554,
-0.11619798094034195,
-0.06281507760286331,
-0.4049516022205353,
0.540981650352478,
-0.3778223991394043,
0.3512437343597412,
-0.21854393184185028,
-0.19576364755630493,
-0.5034404993057251,
0.03782716765999794,
-0.0006312655168585479,
1.0159122943878174,
-0.7001556158065796,
1.055704951286316,
0.6883290410041809,
-0.2658488154411316,
-0.6774612665176392,
0.24617311358451843,
-0.13166894018650055,
-0.5437610149383545,
0.5548183917999268,
0.39710569381713867,
-0.08924050629138947,
-0.0017460616072639823,
-0.6444135308265686,
-0.6503893733024597,
1.1344144344329834,
0.416705459356308,
-0.4668183922767639,
0.2522878348827362,
-0.20830146968364716,
0.5017997026443481,
-0.8400934338569641,
0.3142186403274536,
0.5243564248085022,
0.26404592394828796,
-0.07870253175497055,
-0.7073872685432434,
0.1383170783519745,
-0.13277333974838257,
0.046720992773771286,
0.6734803318977356,
-0.5126978158950806,
0.5557273030281067,
-0.03030654601752758,
-0.10093922913074493,
0.3762688934803009,
0.5067446231842041,
0.26574498414993286,
0.274685800075531,
0.8011195063591003,
0.3519095480442047,
0.46776852011680603,
0.20495100319385529,
1.118520736694336,
-0.47157081961631775,
0.08205549418926239,
1.059600591659546,
-0.2860468626022339,
0.9919829368591309,
0.7438262701034546,
-0.07548820972442627,
0.749873161315918,
0.6762731075286865,
-0.0060817524790763855,
0.7435083985328674,
0.237980917096138,
-0.33696863055229187,
-0.2178918570280075,
-0.08992303162813187,
-0.21530909836292267,
0.36851054430007935,
0.42000705003738403,
-0.6878112554550171,
-0.27117305994033813,
-0.12284401804208755,
0.07778583467006683,
0.2632342278957367,
-0.2455924153327942,
1.0471135377883911,
0.17451831698417664,
-0.961228609085083,
0.43105852603912354,
-0.23367701470851898,
0.46641767024993896,
-0.5345228314399719,
-0.6105703711509705,
-0.08853712677955627,
-0.15572787821292877,
-0.08695977926254272,
-0.7340163588523865,
0.18313337862491608,
-0.14220494031906128,
-0.1013566255569458,
-0.4308408200740814,
0.5612175464630127,
-0.5637203454971313,
-0.40753844380378723,
0.42112788558006287,
0.5138885378837585,
0.49183735251426697,
-0.0794869139790535,
-0.4836016595363617,
-0.47865280508995056,
-0.03995790332555771,
0.3082711100578308,
0.569489598274231,
0.6429546475410461,
-0.1966632604598999,
0.5426342487335205,
0.5417437553405762,
-0.023764636367559433,
-0.34972551465034485,
0.15239264070987701,
0.8016849160194397,
-0.5294338464736938,
-0.49228963255882263,
-1.0080790519714355,
0.33963629603385925,
-0.2634330093860626,
-0.5220552682876587,
0.8296410441398621,
0.7012242674827576,
1.0020818710327148,
-0.07753008604049683,
0.6221332550048828,
-0.08324545621871948,
0.3766792416572571,
-0.713286817073822,
0.3577863574028015,
-0.5742077231407166,
0.3003632426261902,
-0.5268179774284363,
-1.1402931213378906,
-0.5557460784912109,
0.5714828372001648,
-0.28371307253837585,
0.00988626666367054,
0.9990612864494324,
0.6935276985168457,
-0.2143513709306717,
-0.19861671328544617,
0.530808687210083,
0.02149496041238308,
0.14340327680110931,
0.46393129229545593,
0.7951092720031738,
-0.13547317683696747,
0.6844781041145325,
-0.08160815387964249,
-0.26816368103027344,
-0.20976361632347107,
-1.1807152032852173,
-0.9788593053817749,
-0.793251097202301,
-0.14298053085803986,
-0.27252471446990967,
0.02678249217569828,
1.5374714136123657,
0.819918692111969,
-0.5877845287322998,
-0.29159167408943176,
-0.298869252204895,
0.2441432923078537,
-0.5445524454116821,
-0.16389213502407074,
0.38082578778266907,
-0.682430624961853,
-0.5309659242630005,
0.8266507387161255,
0.4288877546787262,
-0.08249098807573318,
0.14567914605140686,
0.11735404282808304,
-0.14533764123916626,
-0.27089089155197144,
0.8085953593254089,
-0.12109542638063431,
-0.7926617860794067,
-0.4579293727874756,
-0.09614641964435577,
0.15315526723861694,
0.23115819692611694,
0.7573750019073486,
-0.8977884650230408,
0.17874418199062347,
0.3985714316368103,
0.49322372674942017,
0.332523375749588,
-0.0832321047782898,
0.573068380355835,
-0.9066439867019653,
0.23108063638210297,
0.25283196568489075,
0.6025765538215637,
0.5575641989707947,
-0.4090169370174408,
0.42323943972587585,
0.15476885437965393,
-0.4011859893798828,
-0.6005027890205383,
0.38256633281707764,
-0.832966148853302,
-0.43830618262290955,
1.288650631904602,
-0.21226978302001953,
-0.09077216684818268,
-0.10827531665563583,
-0.12140199542045593,
-0.006531272549182177,
-0.46819785237312317,
0.6617805361747742,
0.46831902861595154,
-0.011692257598042488,
-0.07047050446271896,
-0.45424285531044006,
0.6572149991989136,
0.45937418937683105,
-0.8386027812957764,
0.018528850749135017,
0.1933140903711319,
0.26838964223861694,
0.025411877781152725,
0.16794522106647491,
0.003747988026589155,
0.14471781253814697,
-0.3174278140068054,
-0.2089410275220871,
0.2765141427516937,
-0.3486878275871277,
-0.4832647144794464,
0.03167365863919258,
0.27383947372436523,
0.07766100019216537
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19283v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19283v1
|
Ungrammatical-syntax-based In-context Example Selection for Grammatical Error Correction
| 2024-03-28T10:05:57 | 2024-03-28T10:05:57 |
Chenming Tang, Fanyi Qu, Yunfang Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the era of large language models (LLMs), in-context learning (ICL) stands
out as an effective prompting strategy that explores LLMs' potency across
various tasks. However, applying LLMs to grammatical error correction (GEC) is
still a challenging task. In this paper, we propose a novel
ungrammatical-syntax-based in-context example selection strategy for GEC.
Specifically, we measure similarity of sentences based on their syntactic
structures with diverse algorithms, and identify optimal ICL examples sharing
the most similar ill-formed syntax to the test input. Additionally, we carry
out a two-stage process to further improve the quality of selection results. On
benchmark English GEC datasets, empirical results show that our proposed
ungrammatical-syntax-based strategies outperform commonly-used word-matching or
semantics-based methods with multiple LLMs. This indicates that for a
syntax-oriented task like GEC, paying more attention to syntactic information
can effectively boost LLMs' performance. Our code will be publicly available
after the publication of this paper.
|
[
0.07978546619415283,
-0.7675800919532776,
0.6118714213371277,
0.2610756456851959,
-0.37412452697753906,
0.03948235511779785,
-0.4845782518386841,
0.019364621490240097,
-0.07705079764127731,
0.16625824570655823,
-0.5119470357894897,
-0.9679011702537537,
-0.15638931095600128,
0.33541595935821533,
-0.40897372364997864,
0.8118309378623962,
-0.2620675563812256,
0.20602792501449585,
-0.5249481201171875,
-0.10293437540531158,
-0.43565666675567627,
-0.5022281408309937,
-0.37431952357292175,
-0.22289715707302094,
0.07440858334302902,
0.624191164970398,
0.19027093052864075,
0.24321819841861725,
0.23368410766124725,
0.31743356585502625,
-0.22636623680591583,
0.5603468418121338,
-0.29189443588256836,
0.047437988221645355,
-0.10210731625556946,
-0.2969473898410797,
-0.05618367716670036,
-0.37566596269607544,
0.7382273077964783,
0.7508158683776855,
-0.3852994441986084,
0.07044017314910889,
0.44238510727882385,
0.5204823613166809,
-0.5936864614486694,
0.36096271872520447,
-0.7294697761535645,
0.04129147529602051,
-0.1739778220653534,
-0.15885724127292633,
-0.606747567653656,
-0.19849634170532227,
-0.42209622263908386,
-0.4399518668651581,
0.08289673924446106,
-0.00004581431858241558,
0.3880598843097687,
-0.030234022065997124,
-0.15968677401542664,
-0.34730666875839233,
-0.3453092873096466,
0.4724768400192261,
-1.0130362510681152,
0.11640831083059311,
0.17928804457187653,
-0.03999168798327446,
-0.4573245942592621,
-0.6017571687698364,
-0.4766927659511566,
-0.32723721861839294,
-0.1839417964220047,
0.13101591169834137,
-0.17958411574363708,
0.2161330282688141,
0.21228569746017456,
-0.05509539321064949,
-0.5507856011390686,
0.21435756981372833,
-0.057635076344013214,
-0.0717431828379631,
0.17246124148368835,
-0.08543013036251068,
0.1823752373456955,
-0.08060835301876068,
-0.23002365231513977,
-0.0017632698873057961,
-0.8842254281044006,
0.04078846052289009,
0.34237346053123474,
0.4246312081813812,
0.00774510158225894,
0.41937339305877686,
-0.3959607481956482,
0.7255303263664246,
-0.004572422243654728,
0.04213448986411095,
0.2679842710494995,
-0.2603597044944763,
-0.18435285985469818,
0.02794785052537918,
0.46721211075782776,
0.592761218547821,
0.27648547291755676,
-0.2603735327720642,
-0.36176398396492004,
0.2783011794090271,
0.06751848757266998,
-0.44276508688926697,
-0.15098987519741058,
-0.18938036262989044,
-0.35777056217193604,
-0.22287628054618835,
0.2843222916126251,
-0.8948203921318054,
-0.012867344543337822,
-0.16473399102687836,
0.2055026739835739,
-0.16600053012371063,
0.3356086015701294,
-0.011203158646821976,
0.18699924647808075,
-0.07441890984773636,
0.21788610517978668,
-0.7665746212005615,
0.26022061705589294,
0.5328236818313599,
0.7157673835754395,
0.03943009674549103,
-0.48192107677459717,
-0.7482803463935852,
0.05082443356513977,
-0.34592291712760925,
0.8870936632156372,
-0.6093714833259583,
-0.5233612060546875,
0.24491119384765625,
-0.21712206304073334,
-0.1609313040971756,
-0.6014901399612427,
0.3851701319217682,
-0.34510567784309387,
0.24150316417217255,
-0.19533737003803253,
-0.7159801125526428,
-0.13354942202568054,
0.17272193729877472,
-0.19876083731651306,
1.1925193071365356,
0.24524104595184326,
-0.4738757312297821,
0.29469549655914307,
-0.752741277217865,
-0.5851175785064697,
0.08547582477331161,
-0.3022666871547699,
-0.41584840416908264,
0.1632700264453888,
0.37541911005973816,
0.6559177041053772,
-0.1685938835144043,
0.15950314700603485,
-0.32457685470581055,
-0.508267879486084,
0.18061910569667816,
-0.31216418743133545,
0.47092732787132263,
0.025754665955901146,
-0.4657398462295532,
0.2857290804386139,
-0.6433136463165283,
0.35770711302757263,
0.08912336826324463,
-0.3645196557044983,
-0.43317702412605286,
0.05355438217520714,
-0.0552719309926033,
0.26716673374176025,
-0.01740562915802002,
-0.47635403275489807,
0.16737520694732666,
-0.425944983959198,
0.5196307897567749,
0.6604811549186707,
-0.02530207671225071,
0.3684864342212677,
-0.09176820516586304,
0.49557870626449585,
-0.22177831828594208,
0.010612779296934605,
-0.1006421148777008,
-0.1719755232334137,
-0.6055548191070557,
-0.13101962208747864,
0.2558840811252594,
0.6470419764518738,
-0.5987227559089661,
0.6285767555236816,
-0.02507551573216915,
-0.19421209394931793,
-0.38133618235588074,
0.4348098337650299,
0.9467301964759827,
0.6985436677932739,
0.4078502058982849,
-0.09946107119321823,
-0.5594064593315125,
-0.5516806840896606,
-0.46217843890190125,
-0.48190510272979736,
0.13843145966529846,
0.36131903529167175,
0.28636905550956726,
-0.08738239109516144,
0.7413827776908875,
-0.4777432680130005,
-0.3198270797729492,
-0.4765399396419525,
0.04118382930755615,
0.09515553712844849,
0.11766038835048676,
0.5625005960464478,
-0.44186532497406006,
-0.4817611873149872,
0.02466673031449318,
-0.6247026920318604,
-0.5118361711502075,
-0.06815716624259949,
-0.14370572566986084,
0.4108871519565582,
0.9912348985671997,
-0.3774740397930145,
0.3350984752178192,
0.4120371639728546,
-0.45127931237220764,
0.37824881076812744,
-0.46109843254089355,
0.11204421520233154,
-1.0873923301696777,
-0.18081587553024292,
-0.019036857411265373,
-0.1552703082561493,
-0.3411436080932617,
0.21632929146289825,
0.3701450526714325,
0.267404168844223,
-0.4379121959209442,
0.38176897168159485,
-0.613149881362915,
-0.03176006302237511,
0.03761442005634308,
0.12271485477685928,
-0.3295500576496124,
0.6149895787239075,
-0.4845646619796753,
0.7984707355499268,
0.4739132523536682,
-0.2597030699253082,
0.3815186619758606,
0.2383274883031845,
-0.3229835331439972,
0.44931742548942566,
-0.2649228274822235,
0.25664326548576355,
-0.27220314741134644,
0.2938675880432129,
-1.0980160236358643,
-0.13667285442352295,
0.0880265012383461,
-0.18369846045970917,
0.2893006503582001,
-0.16905979812145233,
-0.6899473667144775,
-0.22985003888607025,
-0.2797316908836365,
0.216695174574852,
0.6040253639221191,
-0.920319139957428,
0.44042524695396423,
-0.03707531839609146,
-0.2269403636455536,
-0.43788865208625793,
-0.5943913459777832,
0.11229348927736282,
-0.2526554763317108,
-0.36564621329307556,
0.27361026406288147,
-0.09094669669866562,
-0.36611607670783997,
-0.03854243829846382,
-0.13631948828697205,
0.32067927718162537,
0.2180027961730957,
0.13456813991069794,
0.35024213790893555,
-0.15440087020397186,
0.07490958273410797,
0.1784238964319229,
0.06894871592521667,
-0.03209245204925537,
-0.5042024254798889,
0.34586334228515625,
-0.3225035071372986,
-0.6540359258651733,
-0.16651198267936707,
0.50706946849823,
0.27333053946495056,
-0.11927124112844467,
0.19951468706130981,
0.05968321114778519,
-0.3127138614654541,
-0.7286543250083923,
-0.5400491952896118,
-0.08903002738952637,
-0.4197181165218353,
0.5540633201599121,
-0.008979503996670246,
-0.6838117241859436,
0.38338503241539,
-0.10951343923807144,
-0.05679227411746979,
0.06061683967709541,
0.5572936534881592,
-0.18734534084796906,
0.6178832650184631,
0.25729262828826904,
-0.22846800088882446,
0.47943806648254395,
0.03485668823122978,
0.31890982389450073,
-0.6120284199714661,
-0.21535973250865936,
-0.5050165057182312,
-0.23007996380329132,
-0.28332653641700745,
-0.31608346104621887,
0.415729284286499,
0.2381741851568222,
0.042825814336538315,
0.2813774645328522,
-0.1717771291732788,
0.7984074950218201,
0.49860134720802307,
0.01862047240138054,
0.3417331874370575,
0.25991514325141907,
-0.6460389494895935,
0.016895048320293427,
-0.5857248902320862,
-0.41623497009277344,
0.8833276033401489,
-0.2089381217956543,
0.7580055594444275,
0.2049073725938797,
0.6677510142326355,
0.16395844519138336,
0.21814721822738647,
-0.460777223110199,
0.7496609687805176,
-0.5399132370948792,
0.09442555159330368,
-0.23136308789253235,
-0.23314228653907776,
-0.6357709169387817,
0.34230074286460876,
-0.06006857007741928,
-0.801084578037262,
-0.19537338614463806,
0.3736446797847748,
-0.2744640111923218,
0.35357755422592163,
-0.9095982313156128,
0.9163808822631836,
-0.05258873105049133,
-0.020518817007541656,
0.000752757303416729,
-0.7409474849700928,
-0.16859641671180725,
-0.011402605101466179,
0.09232958406209946,
0.10594450682401657,
0.04475158825516701,
0.20137256383895874,
-0.32815685868263245,
0.8317495584487915,
-0.13707301020622253,
0.13105559349060059,
0.3055115342140198,
0.11156294494867325,
0.754218339920044,
0.0632876381278038,
0.08239062130451202,
0.09685838967561722,
-0.3561389148235321,
-0.036580488085746765,
-0.8584293723106384,
0.7477463483810425,
-0.24808335304260254,
-0.3091462552547455,
-0.1783335953950882,
-0.39143773913383484,
-0.4663197994232178,
0.09298782795667648,
0.49494311213493347,
0.6240368485450745,
-0.3839804530143738,
0.1423489898443222,
0.2838747203350067,
0.22400639951229095,
0.7613200545310974,
0.44123926758766174,
-0.001071678358130157,
-0.15062792599201202,
0.38413307070732117,
-0.07783413678407669,
0.19667351245880127,
0.6332893371582031,
0.06877347826957703,
-0.3961348235607147,
-0.8869818449020386,
-0.6033592820167542,
0.05605505406856537,
-0.9433253407478333,
-0.432368665933609,
-0.49675390124320984,
0.03615104407072067,
-0.2894054055213928,
-0.3434078097343445,
-0.03447764739394188,
-0.04381163790822029,
-0.5323901772499084,
-0.14817260205745697,
0.3098104000091553,
0.4930664300918579,
0.2919367253780365,
0.19268974661827087,
-0.48673543334007263,
-0.05544394254684448,
0.0725736916065216,
0.3732222020626068,
-0.1379946917295456,
-0.4580954313278198,
0.04378248006105423,
-0.0809735357761383,
-0.1126556247472763,
-0.7864964008331299,
0.30732107162475586,
0.4130767583847046,
0.5008693337440491,
0.19526511430740356,
-0.1282384991645813,
0.8751673102378845,
-0.5913229584693909,
0.5077642202377319,
0.13269273936748505,
-0.9531486630439758,
0.5744950771331787,
-0.23131296038627625,
0.2530931830406189,
0.6920042037963867,
-0.20266692340373993,
-0.8395912647247314,
-0.4457643926143646,
-0.5531352162361145,
-0.8815883994102478,
0.4042028486728668,
0.1749812811613083,
-0.00037730432813987136,
-0.2630804777145386,
0.4690682888031006,
-0.1372147798538208,
0.15022344887256622,
-0.5992859601974487,
-0.15344955027103424,
0.27673840522766113,
-0.5749464631080627,
-0.1736679971218109,
-0.21411336958408356,
-0.05051647126674652,
-0.03780553489923477,
0.66789710521698,
-0.6498896479606628,
0.0883212462067604,
0.21089859306812286,
-0.38766735792160034,
-0.13173498213291168,
0.6346120238304138,
0.5105847120285034,
0.5468205213546753,
0.08761890232563019,
0.04656777158379555,
0.5827034115791321,
-0.1995047777891159,
0.04609676077961922,
0.13449174165725708,
-0.3239746391773224,
0.12487304955720901,
0.4056640565395355,
0.4827052652835846,
0.5862323045730591,
-0.8812993764877319,
0.6927878856658936,
0.17033232748508453,
-0.05487839877605438,
-0.33761101961135864,
-0.06707055866718292,
0.010843968018889427,
0.21852675080299377,
0.1912495493888855,
0.06428556144237518,
0.1002969965338707,
-0.4469115138053894,
0.19072313606739044,
0.6028493642807007,
-0.136469304561615,
-0.0925571396946907,
0.39581504464149475,
0.11128013581037521,
-0.3487379848957062,
0.629835844039917,
-0.6306279301643372,
-0.4858397841453552,
0.6186108589172363,
0.8168121576309204,
0.785275936126709,
-0.04756252095103264,
0.1601870208978653,
0.12318915873765945,
-0.08100858330726624,
-0.3972162902355194,
0.28856223821640015,
0.17888912558555603,
-0.6520599126815796,
-0.3597610592842102,
-0.20317180454730988,
-0.08756181597709656,
-0.017503157258033752,
-0.5988926887512207,
0.44225001335144043,
-0.5260739922523499,
0.383710116147995,
-0.30510950088500977,
-0.3417929410934448,
-0.33165663480758667,
-0.07164357602596283,
0.13179965317249298,
0.6780725121498108,
-0.8773247003555298,
0.7469381093978882,
0.9705358147621155,
-0.1294279843568802,
-1.0324102640151978,
0.14893454313278198,
0.2756793200969696,
-0.6884236335754395,
0.24684017896652222,
-0.004353417083621025,
-0.16359218955039978,
-0.11371958255767822,
-0.37467730045318604,
-0.6273108124732971,
1.1109168529510498,
0.49957606196403503,
-0.7455081939697266,
-0.17919370532035828,
-0.2626856863498688,
0.6566863059997559,
-0.6622835993766785,
0.16850896179676056,
0.6048974394798279,
0.09706148505210876,
-0.026527738198637962,
-0.8436248898506165,
0.10093227028846741,
-0.31940919160842896,
0.41929367184638977,
0.40409916639328003,
-0.5137110352516174,
0.5821791291236877,
-0.47735753655433655,
-0.11587568372488022,
0.2992748022079468,
0.658766508102417,
0.2703251838684082,
0.24312104284763336,
0.6658931374549866,
0.5095938444137573,
0.7544879913330078,
0.11894587427377701,
0.8867495059967041,
0.005903545301407576,
0.5546404719352722,
1.2722785472869873,
-0.36527422070503235,
0.9025944471359253,
0.5804557204246521,
-0.1795661598443985,
0.5831592679023743,
0.5072417855262756,
-0.236882284283638,
0.6428454518318176,
0.3123033344745636,
-0.2491680532693863,
-0.10143066942691803,
0.04124869033694267,
-0.06995004415512085,
0.5008054375648499,
0.13105519115924835,
-0.39351269602775574,
-0.5818396806716919,
-0.16297857463359833,
0.2368272840976715,
0.5768252611160278,
-0.3821842670440674,
0.786310613155365,
-0.1695074737071991,
-0.7122563719749451,
0.31604304909706116,
0.10787035524845123,
0.7718347311019897,
-0.5646442174911499,
-0.30347952246665955,
-0.44328880310058594,
0.21669350564479828,
-0.16657006740570068,
-0.5283015370368958,
0.005330332089215517,
0.19461043179035187,
-0.08503250777721405,
-0.14291664958000183,
0.6529412865638733,
-0.6906626224517822,
-0.4755851626396179,
0.4748757481575012,
0.331919401884079,
-0.0911872535943985,
-0.12345386296510696,
-0.4671703279018402,
-0.26975178718566895,
0.10472200810909271,
0.23250487446784973,
0.4015764892101288,
0.3380642533302307,
-0.3249308466911316,
0.48794636130332947,
0.4888824224472046,
0.15036502480506897,
-0.07836738228797913,
0.4393724799156189,
0.7009528875350952,
-0.4925059974193573,
-0.8432744741439819,
-0.8346825242042542,
0.35258641839027405,
-0.08541718870401382,
-0.5425832867622375,
0.6872022747993469,
0.4627474546432495,
1.3895632028579712,
-0.1993519812822342,
0.6828650236129761,
0.1158851757645607,
0.4180143475532532,
-0.9759736061096191,
0.26771530508995056,
-0.4118048846721649,
0.41978126764297485,
-0.5301439166069031,
-0.8681986927986145,
-0.5464552640914917,
0.6971063017845154,
-0.060038525611162186,
0.2306205928325653,
1.1071118116378784,
1.2663220167160034,
0.031242532655596733,
-0.028149200603365898,
0.3333769738674164,
0.14432142674922943,
0.006129350513219833,
0.6544618606567383,
0.7491503953933716,
-0.16224370896816254,
0.4471583664417267,
-0.12425848096609116,
-0.2233351469039917,
-0.4585568308830261,
-1.0126729011535645,
-0.8100007176399231,
-0.6086997985839844,
-0.33433210849761963,
-0.5136955976486206,
0.3183535039424896,
1.5136719942092896,
0.38101062178611755,
-0.7731532454490662,
-0.08642854541540146,
-0.22198544442653656,
0.005545397289097309,
-0.5045204162597656,
-0.09239515662193298,
0.3334053158760071,
-0.4757857024669647,
-0.5780665278434753,
0.5697277784347534,
0.3834618330001831,
-0.05621958151459694,
0.2774105370044708,
0.04459219425916672,
-0.09996753931045532,
-0.29386264085769653,
0.536756157875061,
0.22845308482646942,
-0.979356050491333,
-0.40989893674850464,
-0.08793694525957108,
-0.1360868513584137,
0.105832040309906,
1.1345502138137817,
-0.4450022280216217,
0.3526564836502075,
0.4250801205635071,
0.6428000330924988,
-0.0265665203332901,
0.08557786047458649,
0.2782301902770996,
-1.0850569009780884,
0.1130824163556099,
0.2748262286186218,
0.7515017986297607,
0.4017775356769562,
-0.518343448638916,
0.49484893679618835,
0.32271161675453186,
-0.3059128522872925,
-0.5957382917404175,
0.06549057364463806,
-0.9168710112571716,
-0.39109382033348083,
1.6326274871826172,
-0.22648818790912628,
-0.05817727372050285,
0.07722184807062149,
-0.2998664379119873,
0.03362968564033508,
-0.4894638955593109,
0.7777773141860962,
0.7812292575836182,
0.015936782583594322,
0.09962846338748932,
-0.2980876564979553,
0.44896432757377625,
0.6324417591094971,
-0.8672254681587219,
0.1718265563249588,
0.658272385597229,
0.4734545350074768,
-0.32960307598114014,
0.4070602059364319,
-0.23135995864868164,
0.38074827194213867,
-0.288991242647171,
0.04169950634241104,
-0.08186439424753189,
-0.4004693031311035,
-0.7876216769218445,
-0.020367886871099472,
0.08052483946084976,
-0.1428220421075821
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19279v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19279v1
|
Fine-Tuning Language Models with Reward Learning on Policy
| 2024-03-28T10:02:10 | 2024-03-28T10:02:10 |
Hao Lang, Fei Huang, Yongbin Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF) has emerged as an effective
approach to aligning large language models (LLMs) to human preferences. RLHF
contains three steps, i.e., human preference collecting, reward learning, and
policy optimization, which are usually performed serially. Despite its
popularity, however, (fixed) reward models may suffer from inaccurate
off-distribution, since policy optimization continuously shifts LLMs' data
distribution. Repeatedly collecting new preference data from the latest LLMs
may alleviate this issue, which unfortunately makes the resulting system more
complicated and difficult to optimize. In this paper, we propose reward
learning on policy (RLP), an unsupervised framework that refines a reward model
using policy samples to keep it on-distribution. Specifically, an unsupervised
multi-view learning method is introduced to learn robust representations of
policy samples. Meanwhile, a synthetic preference generation approach is
developed to simulate high-quality preference data with policy outputs.
Extensive experiments on three benchmark datasets show that RLP consistently
outperforms the state-of-the-art. Our code is available at
\url{https://github.com/AlibabaResearch/DAMO-ConvAI/tree/main/rlp}.
|
[
-0.28617316484451294,
-0.34694844484329224,
0.4918327331542969,
0.10058855265378952,
-0.07130986452102661,
0.11304100602865219,
-0.71190345287323,
0.1102852150797844,
0.21967747807502747,
0.6226853728294373,
-0.7915638089179993,
-0.28398486971855164,
-0.45387575030326843,
-0.22753547132015228,
0.3581058979034424,
1.048560619354248,
0.15107090771198273,
-0.029309431090950966,
-0.09481274336576462,
-0.15060992538928986,
-0.22853802144527435,
-0.4258074462413788,
-0.5981508493423462,
-0.7841919660568237,
0.6310502290725708,
0.7820444703102112,
0.43339815735816956,
0.6577026844024658,
0.02859634906053543,
0.20751015841960907,
0.044154051691293716,
0.6709235906600952,
-0.6809056401252747,
0.14711877703666687,
-0.4088781177997589,
-0.31654125452041626,
0.015567975118756294,
0.024400876834988594,
0.585061252117157,
0.5812017321586609,
-0.6405833959579468,
-0.2525634467601776,
0.16764415800571442,
0.8844593167304993,
-0.8157559633255005,
0.41018202900886536,
-0.6226477026939392,
-0.0026561827398836613,
-0.08196353912353516,
-0.4917233884334564,
-0.5745740532875061,
-0.5039634704589844,
0.10070439428091049,
-0.5274484157562256,
0.038240429013967514,
0.1579904407262802,
0.7321222424507141,
0.31862330436706543,
-0.2021694928407669,
-0.07220256328582764,
-0.4956611692905426,
1.0700366497039795,
-0.5567046403884888,
0.36907386779785156,
0.45439133048057556,
0.3546144366264343,
-0.3927863538265228,
-0.2563691735267639,
-0.3218958377838135,
-0.30705609917640686,
0.004810339771211147,
0.013793463818728924,
0.12312006950378418,
-0.02465680241584778,
-0.1378181427717209,
0.23526699841022491,
-0.3660874366760254,
0.43407920002937317,
-0.1258815973997116,
-0.13230015337467194,
0.7105065584182739,
0.04298774525523186,
-0.15004514157772064,
-0.16533724963665009,
-0.30100446939468384,
-0.6520970463752747,
-0.8753531575202942,
0.4592594504356384,
0.6174048781394958,
0.6633071899414062,
-0.20533259212970734,
0.3300907611846924,
-0.47085872292518616,
0.5602140426635742,
0.03527946025133133,
-0.1632617712020874,
0.4098223149776459,
0.15903113782405853,
-0.10387109220027924,
0.006603434216231108,
0.7881404757499695,
0.34338924288749695,
0.3741792142391205,
-0.09668929129838943,
-0.4353227913379669,
-0.10412726551294327,
0.3922731876373291,
-0.6399312615394592,
-0.3751506209373474,
0.23374269902706146,
-0.30391785502433777,
-0.5850106477737427,
0.03498219698667526,
-0.7762386798858643,
-0.6565871238708496,
-0.31604793667793274,
0.12513041496276855,
-0.13918064534664154,
-0.33368852734565735,
0.27516093850135803,
0.190163716673851,
0.12434972077608109,
0.3183591961860657,
-1.344548225402832,
-0.011352973990142345,
0.7354320883750916,
0.5022640824317932,
-0.47832804918289185,
-0.5394740104675293,
-0.8722284436225891,
-0.03729839250445366,
-0.3037421703338623,
1.0209431648254395,
-0.5162907838821411,
-0.2806153893470764,
0.39505261182785034,
0.17846859991550446,
-0.04059348255395889,
-0.7800200581550598,
0.3285421133041382,
-0.3790169954299927,
0.12343373894691467,
-0.22601769864559174,
-0.4910663962364197,
0.0834563598036766,
0.5253008008003235,
-0.6157873272895813,
0.7565677762031555,
0.11608272045850754,
-0.4355190098285675,
0.5533212423324585,
-0.8373466730117798,
-0.4000800549983978,
-0.17380653321743011,
-0.15166081488132477,
-0.48423686623573303,
0.027133487164974213,
0.361216276884079,
0.4948953688144684,
-0.18470655381679535,
0.5065045952796936,
-0.38457736372947693,
-0.10909271240234375,
0.2902432084083557,
-0.4126216769218445,
0.3709421455860138,
0.25433796644210815,
-0.09762398153543472,
0.6461054682731628,
-0.638555109500885,
0.07209429889917374,
0.015939708799123764,
-0.6976134777069092,
-0.10742663592100143,
0.19142824411392212,
0.13701999187469482,
0.032160062342882156,
0.11752969026565552,
-0.6371034383773804,
0.46653681993484497,
-0.6208339929580688,
0.5372772216796875,
0.9242492318153381,
-0.005741284694522619,
0.62180495262146,
-0.18925945460796356,
0.5016284584999084,
-0.036187104880809784,
0.23029476404190063,
-0.060652751475572586,
-0.08948177844285965,
-0.46181103587150574,
-0.028038056567311287,
0.32121703028678894,
0.3849971890449524,
-0.536238431930542,
0.38141128420829773,
-0.07989576458930969,
-0.16020025312900543,
-0.5436996817588806,
0.07067615538835526,
0.4522227942943573,
0.2000078409910202,
0.3382304906845093,
-0.2664578855037689,
-0.2409907877445221,
-0.8082110285758972,
-0.2509036064147949,
-0.08006948232650757,
0.0534207858145237,
0.5061426758766174,
0.17454098165035248,
-0.13165342807769775,
0.9219530820846558,
-0.651113748550415,
-0.4320099949836731,
-0.5126054883003235,
0.20743919909000397,
0.042143192142248154,
0.4622637629508972,
0.12329674512147903,
-0.5883743762969971,
-0.21714116632938385,
0.007272989954799414,
-0.21014302968978882,
0.10833163559436798,
0.011913028545677662,
0.08518660813570023,
0.4331224858760834,
0.2664521634578705,
-0.12154915183782578,
0.050934985280036926,
0.5497778654098511,
-0.262855589389801,
0.3462049067020416,
-0.7154892683029175,
-0.012942054308950901,
-0.8857274055480957,
-0.12475039809942245,
0.05437956377863884,
-0.36823102831840515,
-0.2812381982803345,
-0.010136370547115803,
0.1218583881855011,
0.09859040379524231,
-0.7369537949562073,
0.6808143854141235,
-0.074227474629879,
-0.0189701858907938,
-0.4684235155582428,
-0.22366075217723846,
-0.12227842211723328,
0.8999307751655579,
0.32593944668769836,
0.6745907664299011,
0.32728299498558044,
-0.5614438652992249,
0.4351575970649719,
0.06158900260925293,
-0.40289556980133057,
0.3415522575378418,
-0.40180590748786926,
-0.057332877069711685,
-0.1294059455394745,
0.1069352999329567,
-0.6411461234092712,
-0.43996408581733704,
0.1751476377248764,
-0.18083669245243073,
0.3432835042476654,
-0.2101336121559143,
-0.4104408919811249,
0.11896819621324539,
-0.39635366201400757,
0.10835661739110947,
0.2945348024368286,
-0.9071404933929443,
0.21889474987983704,
0.7725411653518677,
0.14016850292682648,
-0.6534996032714844,
-0.32713866233825684,
-0.3502289056777954,
-0.2279014140367508,
-0.003134440165013075,
0.39815691113471985,
0.21521152555942535,
0.019977305084466934,
-0.11765033006668091,
0.22565142810344696,
0.19415919482707977,
0.043269574642181396,
0.06991520524024963,
0.09150198101997375,
0.41629019379615784,
0.20541559159755707,
0.0016942508518695831,
-0.25428590178489685,
-0.1108132153749466,
-0.22477567195892334,
0.8162592649459839,
-0.33276596665382385,
-0.302306592464447,
-0.13759756088256836,
0.1469995677471161,
0.44920966029167175,
-0.38761958479881287,
0.48973605036735535,
0.3774094581604004,
-0.09303537011146545,
-0.5147324800491333,
-0.2688656747341156,
-0.4196162223815918,
-0.43150556087493896,
0.4256616532802582,
-0.19682498276233673,
-0.9020349383354187,
0.18425291776657104,
-0.3039870858192444,
0.15966808795928955,
0.03961097449064255,
0.6789392232894897,
-0.05161820352077484,
1.085599422454834,
0.8237140774726868,
-0.26338374614715576,
0.5074427723884583,
-0.3266729414463043,
0.08942504227161407,
-0.5976476073265076,
-0.5129079222679138,
-0.3156301975250244,
-0.21804878115653992,
-0.8172083497047424,
-0.2703867554664612,
0.24518617987632751,
0.049826424568891525,
-0.3704549968242645,
0.024365300312638283,
-0.3710709512233734,
0.5898274779319763,
0.7248460650444031,
0.03442695364356041,
0.13469620048999786,
0.15562833845615387,
-0.208236962556839,
-0.0535116083920002,
-0.70588219165802,
-0.20457707345485687,
1.0503544807434082,
0.37069642543792725,
1.1351029872894287,
0.041710931807756424,
0.7800686955451965,
0.3903619647026062,
0.1709308624267578,
-0.7681060433387756,
0.05468747764825821,
-0.3285335600376129,
0.08203364163637161,
-0.5755663514137268,
-0.41527673602104187,
-0.9832656979560852,
0.2953370213508606,
-0.39610135555267334,
-0.61118084192276,
0.41046953201293945,
0.509904682636261,
-0.40340203046798706,
0.27561670541763306,
-0.5812768340110779,
1.025871992111206,
-0.3921673893928528,
-0.45184746384620667,
-0.5327807664871216,
-0.46968111395835876,
0.2533009350299835,
0.19572941958904266,
0.1869281828403473,
-0.24222394824028015,
0.44957852363586426,
0.5580211281776428,
-0.37989237904548645,
0.7955923676490784,
-0.38000816106796265,
-0.1319562792778015,
-0.18205653131008148,
-0.011779856868088245,
0.6237881183624268,
0.24183611571788788,
0.08930832892656326,
-0.1797095239162445,
0.03301168233156204,
-0.3290773034095764,
-0.6347048878669739,
0.8599632382392883,
-0.8564484119415283,
-0.3207590579986572,
-0.49191775918006897,
-0.7187857627868652,
-0.567510187625885,
0.022312184795737267,
0.11154206842184067,
0.3740386962890625,
-0.11370198428630829,
0.13243815302848816,
0.8264206647872925,
-0.46208977699279785,
0.3189004361629486,
0.5405656099319458,
-0.4496464133262634,
-0.387767493724823,
1.1616917848587036,
-0.37716084718704224,
0.2599661946296692,
0.48175743222236633,
0.511117696762085,
-0.7900683879852295,
-0.10176880657672882,
-0.7040610313415527,
0.2541745603084564,
-0.4363192915916443,
-0.08904559910297394,
-0.16658005118370056,
-0.03736197203397751,
-0.3444121479988098,
0.010990757495164871,
-0.7827252149581909,
-0.12772467732429504,
-0.12654459476470947,
-0.025156166404485703,
0.46634936332702637,
0.6253112554550171,
-0.24085961282253265,
0.2109372615814209,
-0.37768375873565674,
0.05763521045446396,
0.31310921907424927,
0.6055624485015869,
-0.09355035424232483,
-0.3667888939380646,
-0.23198610544204712,
0.12292585521936417,
-0.26044994592666626,
-0.40612947940826416,
0.5604212880134583,
0.09361658990383148,
0.4785527288913727,
0.6015733480453491,
0.21751628816127777,
0.40129148960113525,
-0.46239954233169556,
0.3714381754398346,
0.25008654594421387,
-0.49272340536117554,
0.4646950364112854,
-0.19041582942008972,
0.25938671827316284,
0.6266547441482544,
0.09056875854730606,
-0.7259078025817871,
-0.09364894777536392,
-0.5548421740531921,
-0.7481986284255981,
0.8455411195755005,
-0.4818403124809265,
0.10259097069501877,
0.07672934979200363,
0.24303029477596283,
0.11263613402843475,
0.3120613396167755,
-0.6319899559020996,
-0.15940183401107788,
-0.30802294611930847,
0.014785872772336006,
-0.2096463292837143,
-0.1651199609041214,
-0.15355929732322693,
-0.16498126089572906,
0.6742923855781555,
-0.381676584482193,
-0.09723362326622009,
-0.244407519698143,
0.004446527920663357,
-0.12170195579528809,
0.5984587669372559,
0.6727530360221863,
0.6366165280342102,
-0.451989084482193,
0.20284385979175568,
-0.2427094578742981,
-0.08310368657112122,
0.20016056299209595,
-0.12899164855480194,
-0.1987808495759964,
-0.46329841017723083,
-0.1469147950410843,
1.1711137294769287,
0.3347998261451721,
-0.9771963357925415,
0.6038152575492859,
0.011138120666146278,
-0.290402352809906,
-0.2727694809436798,
0.2247617393732071,
0.056311581283807755,
0.19565284252166748,
0.021187761798501015,
-0.029034359380602837,
-0.24955083429813385,
-0.7218868136405945,
0.29052266478538513,
0.5914283990859985,
-0.6603215932846069,
0.004644986242055893,
0.40460121631622314,
0.14525450766086578,
-0.32886600494384766,
0.456753671169281,
-0.44671884179115295,
-0.6050615906715393,
0.1797209084033966,
0.5768988132476807,
0.5886108875274658,
-0.1338365375995636,
0.6631035804748535,
0.20531709492206573,
0.08672870695590973,
-0.45382562279701233,
0.21201908588409424,
-0.12155885994434357,
-0.9458519816398621,
-0.4480806887149811,
-0.8117311000823975,
-0.6599209308624268,
0.359136164188385,
-0.7497068047523499,
0.029431942850351334,
-0.3977842330932617,
0.25735920667648315,
-0.308788001537323,
0.024464135989546776,
-0.4437517523765564,
0.012004821561276913,
-0.08971210569143295,
0.5323135256767273,
-1.0821201801300049,
1.1967575550079346,
0.7203130722045898,
-0.317195326089859,
-0.9486485123634338,
0.0448697954416275,
-0.15028078854084015,
-0.8995058536529541,
0.4673624634742737,
-0.0865720734000206,
-0.1308603137731552,
0.04124044254422188,
-0.3816591501235962,
-0.6293995380401611,
0.6975797414779663,
0.31197088956832886,
-0.5026310682296753,
0.23455944657325745,
0.10715200752019882,
0.36839035153388977,
-0.4805724322795868,
0.1004982739686966,
0.7781013250350952,
0.35870397090911865,
0.00016011281695682555,
-0.7562909722328186,
-0.188654825091362,
0.1531848907470703,
0.0842142105102539,
0.3507939577102661,
-0.5554863214492798,
0.6671097874641418,
-0.3206084966659546,
0.07577423751354218,
-0.32982519268989563,
0.43725886940956116,
0.7476372122764587,
-0.07368077337741852,
0.7617622017860413,
0.6286762356758118,
0.7132576704025269,
0.014267796650528908,
1.0515493154525757,
-0.09069931507110596,
0.5542207956314087,
1.0349807739257812,
-0.3299811780452728,
1.0654767751693726,
0.5707584619522095,
-0.14809326827526093,
0.4613454341888428,
0.7613369822502136,
0.040983326733112335,
1.071729302406311,
0.3604699671268463,
0.014431692659854889,
-0.5479831695556641,
-0.2925492823123932,
-0.03129381686449051,
0.41132426261901855,
0.1404096931219101,
-0.06285522878170013,
-0.4928604066371918,
0.22556395828723907,
-0.10193381458520889,
0.4025246500968933,
-0.2924712300300598,
0.6657224297523499,
-0.14955419301986694,
-1.0478971004486084,
0.6459725499153137,
0.3098737895488739,
0.7932223677635193,
-0.5110088586807251,
-0.24556775391101837,
-0.33211615681648254,
0.46435245871543884,
-0.04711410775780678,
-0.7939018607139587,
0.09318750351667404,
-0.1523095965385437,
-0.3180704414844513,
-0.47421303391456604,
0.46624496579170227,
-0.7801215648651123,
-0.1971135437488556,
0.24177174270153046,
0.3222304582595825,
0.04426354914903641,
-0.016359567642211914,
-0.7181020975112915,
0.04573332518339157,
0.22936564683914185,
-0.18184120953083038,
0.6734222173690796,
0.013751299120485783,
-0.2583286464214325,
0.7559590339660645,
0.8029646873474121,
0.4064948856830597,
-0.18572892248630524,
0.43427443504333496,
0.5532913208007812,
-0.46097108721733093,
-0.9082214832305908,
-0.6671131253242493,
0.1966533660888672,
-0.0006209936109371483,
-0.3266821503639221,
0.2778897285461426,
0.48696234822273254,
1.1476118564605713,
-0.1457505226135254,
0.650869607925415,
0.25588259100914,
0.8167051672935486,
-0.6296742558479309,
0.7526440024375916,
-0.7074882388114929,
0.2833673655986786,
0.11705491691827774,
-0.7664893865585327,
-0.2690483629703522,
0.738351583480835,
-0.17930099368095398,
-0.24634166061878204,
0.5058600306510925,
1.023866891860962,
-0.14415812492370605,
-0.1893371343612671,
0.23853398859500885,
-0.23073911666870117,
0.34552380442619324,
0.6130959987640381,
0.7500521540641785,
0.1668461561203003,
0.26053616404533386,
-0.5006409883499146,
-0.1889929324388504,
-0.2126176357269287,
-0.9200984835624695,
-0.4991395175457001,
-0.5881834626197815,
-0.16030311584472656,
-0.21706511080265045,
0.16156025230884552,
1.335374355316162,
0.8189811706542969,
-1.0358513593673706,
-0.4980386793613434,
-0.20228730142116547,
0.2107897847890854,
-0.3318311870098114,
-0.2573857605457306,
0.5699766874313354,
-0.6215930581092834,
-0.7399566769599915,
0.5857004523277283,
0.3443535566329956,
-0.35768988728523254,
-0.596869945526123,
-0.5717451572418213,
-0.04563872143626213,
-0.18402338027954102,
0.4523223638534546,
0.6649569272994995,
-0.8979208469390869,
-0.33140724897384644,
-0.2512935996055603,
0.03242599964141846,
0.07751800119876862,
0.9818989634513855,
-0.8535494208335876,
0.38676345348358154,
0.33006489276885986,
0.7846729755401611,
0.5148435831069946,
0.01778269186615944,
0.5822338461875916,
-0.8483859300613403,
0.1335030049085617,
-0.06223380193114281,
0.4081871211528778,
0.37747740745544434,
-0.23764817416667938,
0.16240322589874268,
0.04420074447989464,
-0.624702513217926,
-0.9040005207061768,
0.42258891463279724,
-0.7492903470993042,
-0.39543476700782776,
1.1772692203521729,
-0.026276875287294388,
-0.2959868013858795,
0.0437336228787899,
0.006278763525187969,
0.04557758569717407,
-0.6859477162361145,
0.9731242656707764,
0.28487342596054077,
-0.25682416558265686,
-0.3886002004146576,
-0.24704863131046295,
0.9565783143043518,
0.5837495923042297,
-0.8116187453269958,
0.5000791549682617,
0.4160061776638031,
0.44651535153388977,
-0.16053535044193268,
0.6571177840232849,
-0.03524838387966156,
0.21758772432804108,
-0.67099529504776,
0.2520558536052704,
-0.18887092173099518,
-0.5686944127082825,
-0.639779269695282,
0.09225887060165405,
0.4493280351161957,
-0.3495987355709076
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19275v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19275v2
|
Knowledge Boundary and Persona Dynamic Shape A Better Social Media Agent
| 2024-03-28T10:01:23 | 2024-04-02T10:59:23 |
Junkai Zhou, Liang Pang, Ya Jing, Jia Gu, Huawei Shen, Xueqi Cheng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Constructing personalized and anthropomorphic agents holds significant
importance in the simulation of social networks. However, there are still two
key problems in existing works: the agent possesses world knowledge that does
not belong to its personas, and it cannot eliminate the interference of diverse
persona information on current actions, which reduces the personalization and
anthropomorphism of the agent. To solve the above problems, we construct the
social media agent based on personalized knowledge and dynamic persona
information. For personalized knowledge, we add external knowledge sources and
match them with the persona information of agents, thereby giving the agent
personalized world knowledge. For dynamic persona information, we use current
action information to internally retrieve the persona information of the agent,
thereby reducing the interference of diverse persona information on the current
action. To make the agent suitable for social media, we design five basic
modules for it: persona, planning, action, memory and reflection. To provide an
interaction and verification environment for the agent, we build a social media
simulation sandbox. In the experimental verification, automatic and human
evaluations demonstrated the effectiveness of the agent we constructed.
|
[
-0.5514018535614014,
-0.8848549723625183,
0.6709727048873901,
0.32453683018684387,
-0.033817924559116364,
0.5990294218063354,
-0.01661873236298561,
-0.5044505596160889,
0.628666341304779,
0.4715459644794464,
-0.731479823589325,
-0.1691640168428421,
-0.35820066928863525,
-0.3329152464866638,
0.05689528211951256,
0.6897343993186951,
0.2881701588630676,
-0.459452748298645,
-0.2567182779312134,
-0.1396734118461609,
-0.28548628091812134,
-0.3163847327232361,
-0.8505011796951294,
-0.41725364327430725,
0.6593598127365112,
0.3114795386791229,
0.7708705067634583,
0.37144261598587036,
0.3978515863418579,
0.5123139023780823,
-0.16441461443901062,
0.35955655574798584,
-0.7401653528213501,
0.13704732060432434,
-0.5211135149002075,
-0.1320679634809494,
-0.6512836813926697,
-0.08993159979581833,
0.5308516025543213,
0.3985348045825958,
0.09574757516384125,
0.27215445041656494,
-0.11308823525905609,
0.5745514035224915,
-0.4422255754470825,
0.08487285673618317,
-0.33121350407600403,
-0.026090489700436592,
0.06615649163722992,
-0.3059442639350891,
-0.07425788044929504,
-0.48322105407714844,
-0.07000929862260818,
-0.7401889562606812,
-0.09408611804246902,
-0.042771391570568085,
0.8828651309013367,
0.2486061304807663,
-0.726535439491272,
0.14619383215904236,
-1.4149208068847656,
0.34140098094940186,
-0.2037428915500641,
0.44372501969337463,
0.2587001323699951,
0.9759117364883423,
-0.2190628945827484,
-0.6814082860946655,
-0.49468833208084106,
0.17901216447353363,
0.3384872376918793,
-0.004516557790338993,
-0.06459245830774307,
-0.14721424877643585,
0.13218140602111816,
0.08378572016954422,
-0.29813337326049805,
-0.23686563968658447,
-0.3975134789943695,
-0.37763094902038574,
1.075005292892456,
0.25846999883651733,
0.25201770663261414,
-0.13297587633132935,
-0.4928379952907562,
-0.14686591923236847,
-0.4464339017868042,
0.3241508901119232,
0.7168595790863037,
-0.13977769017219543,
-0.21141426265239716,
0.2881968319416046,
-0.5020772218704224,
0.3251642882823944,
0.42873871326446533,
-0.49723049998283386,
0.22761136293411255,
0.08375931531190872,
0.14649717509746552,
-0.19561611115932465,
0.5658222436904907,
0.6818230748176575,
0.2516694962978363,
-0.32816728949546814,
-0.01799747720360756,
-0.08872146159410477,
0.4528088867664337,
-0.7245082855224609,
-0.09846629202365875,
0.3676079213619232,
-0.5558375716209412,
-0.27522218227386475,
0.25743332505226135,
-0.48675018548965454,
-0.7835034728050232,
-0.4488835632801056,
0.35291463136672974,
-0.6717900037765503,
-0.5265706777572632,
-0.20814092457294464,
-0.2625831961631775,
0.1560949981212616,
0.5810808539390564,
-0.3585905134677887,
0.46870771050453186,
0.3227956295013428,
0.701942503452301,
-0.11091069132089615,
-0.2263154536485672,
-0.23311124742031097,
0.5132541656494141,
0.010011877864599228,
1.0862736701965332,
-0.497875452041626,
-0.006990150548517704,
0.18339256942272186,
-0.026585465297102928,
0.0764545127749443,
-0.38790255784988403,
-0.05656817927956581,
-0.7960478067398071,
-0.17877008020877838,
-0.7940223217010498,
-0.6145855188369751,
-0.43006542325019836,
0.2923372685909271,
-0.6709939241409302,
0.5002529621124268,
0.2839829921722412,
-0.6118162274360657,
0.1806679368019104,
-0.8580498695373535,
-0.375987708568573,
0.47089216113090515,
-0.05273258686065674,
0.16428418457508087,
-0.10016436874866486,
-0.21274064481258392,
0.7128344178199768,
0.1690891981124878,
0.10188931971788406,
-0.6024207472801208,
-0.41271811723709106,
0.4309784173965454,
0.29180145263671875,
0.746589183807373,
0.23878148198127747,
-0.3134632706642151,
0.19584444165229797,
-0.7090603709220886,
-0.16925141215324402,
0.3134145438671112,
-0.2919001281261444,
-0.31770360469818115,
0.19720323383808136,
0.11128750443458557,
0.3633095622062683,
0.19523656368255615,
-0.5118911862373352,
0.14824970066547394,
0.04062966629862785,
0.21859486401081085,
0.9592987895011902,
0.5818651914596558,
0.5836296677589417,
-0.6746948957443237,
0.4952108561992645,
-0.17350730299949646,
0.3117794394493103,
0.40395593643188477,
-0.5181021690368652,
-0.39649471640586853,
0.06629108637571335,
-0.014278738759458065,
0.4509429335594177,
-0.9809466004371643,
0.3666124641895294,
-0.2601083815097809,
-0.629179060459137,
-0.1143687292933464,
0.13256368041038513,
0.12199368327856064,
0.02571292780339718,
-0.13998404145240784,
-0.4057730734348297,
-0.4312165379524231,
-0.7623799443244934,
-0.16216415166854858,
-0.24928203225135803,
0.14514106512069702,
0.4929543733596802,
0.4319288432598114,
-0.5073236227035522,
1.0779634714126587,
-0.5702629685401917,
-0.30515870451927185,
-0.27538320422172546,
-0.3180915117263794,
-0.31581708788871765,
0.16580091416835785,
0.7897844314575195,
-1.1912766695022583,
-0.642742931842804,
-0.08541691303253174,
-0.7888526916503906,
-0.09674397110939026,
-0.08084163814783096,
-0.6141466498374939,
-0.2217993140220642,
0.25014880299568176,
-0.71840900182724,
0.34375399351119995,
0.19366343319416046,
-0.5379511117935181,
0.5458065271377563,
-0.03504779934883118,
0.23835806548595428,
-1.1923128366470337,
0.13220053911209106,
0.139471635222435,
-0.4742211401462555,
-0.8446248769760132,
0.17873233556747437,
-0.14813032746315002,
-0.15098802745342255,
-0.5650600790977478,
1.02711820602417,
-0.312473326921463,
0.023081142455339432,
-0.38497430086135864,
0.2046503722667694,
-0.09207280725240707,
0.6333304047584534,
-0.12280420958995819,
0.13525542616844177,
0.4066799283027649,
-0.9441633224487305,
0.6927816867828369,
0.20815391838550568,
-0.1252635419368744,
0.8390106558799744,
-0.5531953573226929,
0.3766725957393646,
-0.33457043766975403,
0.2842070460319519,
-0.8046348094940186,
-0.6199707388877869,
0.4564650058746338,
-0.370652973651886,
0.03406086191534996,
0.21918803453445435,
-0.6228392124176025,
-0.3591620922088623,
-0.34813421964645386,
0.10379024595022202,
0.6041369438171387,
-0.2709282636642456,
0.6993731260299683,
0.8961983919143677,
0.02541174180805683,
-0.03488932549953461,
-0.21256454288959503,
-0.08384858071804047,
-0.2596772313117981,
-0.9550027847290039,
0.700302004814148,
-0.36853131651878357,
-0.5302169919013977,
0.1983012855052948,
0.09325284510850906,
-0.05426944047212601,
-0.1779223382472992,
0.43593254685401917,
-0.4451243579387665,
0.21394473314285278,
0.03168468549847603,
0.2525721788406372,
0.048061951994895935,
0.054540254175662994,
0.1432325839996338,
0.6224474906921387,
-0.07360776513814926,
-0.2623901069164276,
-0.4787629246711731,
0.2593396306037903,
0.6450150609016418,
-0.0615079291164875,
0.6736058592796326,
0.7565218210220337,
-0.7063819169998169,
-0.15746670961380005,
-0.9148222208023071,
-0.20662766695022583,
-0.6029207706451416,
-0.1004880741238594,
-0.3788180947303772,
-0.7190011739730835,
1.2749907970428467,
-0.23079240322113037,
0.048666901886463165,
0.04880433529615402,
0.6724644303321838,
0.04946020618081093,
0.8980060815811157,
0.7473379373550415,
0.1646537184715271,
0.61346834897995,
-0.29154953360557556,
-0.055103931576013565,
-0.7622114419937134,
-0.6415734887123108,
0.18226490914821625,
-0.5940321087837219,
-0.23079703748226166,
-0.1824459731578827,
0.1958947330713272,
-0.54068523645401,
-0.33889880776405334,
0.4327004849910736,
-0.45609012246131897,
0.303220272064209,
0.512878954410553,
0.5318717956542969,
0.1357247531414032,
-0.034180909395217896,
-0.029820075258612633,
-0.006298491265624762,
-0.4213804304599762,
-0.6347137689590454,
0.5046543478965759,
0.466024249792099,
0.7074032425880432,
0.46932026743888855,
0.6207268238067627,
0.47485679388046265,
0.09896057099103928,
-0.5205660462379456,
0.8078063130378723,
0.3784036636352539,
-0.9269818067550659,
-0.06290698796510696,
-0.28811347484588623,
-0.7228623628616333,
0.19254934787750244,
-0.20134486258029938,
-1.0212595462799072,
0.37969815731048584,
0.16507287323474884,
-0.6169043779373169,
0.30478015542030334,
-0.551933765411377,
0.5657166242599487,
-0.07821136713027954,
-0.686583936214447,
-0.09736239165067673,
-0.7014309763908386,
0.2720666229724884,
0.038929130882024765,
0.2352330982685089,
-0.2648869454860687,
-0.10715994238853455,
0.5951442718505859,
-0.5525704026222229,
1.0668026208877563,
-0.5179836750030518,
0.31029072403907776,
0.49175798892974854,
0.3199438750743866,
0.37683603167533875,
0.13266503810882568,
0.03456524759531021,
-0.38794001936912537,
0.0062977042980492115,
-0.2761729061603546,
-0.7310223579406738,
0.485469251871109,
-0.9458419680595398,
-0.6032434105873108,
-0.09758806973695755,
-0.4681102931499481,
-0.18696217238903046,
0.32731711864471436,
0.22532503306865692,
0.10578207671642303,
-0.5410443544387817,
0.31894245743751526,
0.6756734848022461,
-0.20685093104839325,
0.23047733306884766,
0.5858718156814575,
-0.2265384942293167,
-0.34681233763694763,
0.8822777271270752,
0.22976958751678467,
-0.02671138383448124,
0.34302788972854614,
0.1946250945329666,
-0.14830507338047028,
-0.10305339097976685,
-0.11989607661962509,
0.19816234707832336,
-0.6549122929573059,
-0.11739432066679001,
-0.7595844864845276,
-0.4740835726261139,
-0.5885748863220215,
-0.18458084762096405,
-0.35739755630493164,
0.06884799152612686,
0.19514909386634827,
0.11111465096473694,
0.3989866077899933,
0.7077234387397766,
-0.15111996233463287,
0.7517163157463074,
-0.5732881426811218,
0.27472496032714844,
0.504676878452301,
0.3248366117477417,
0.05474889278411865,
-0.2227274477481842,
-0.2001459300518036,
0.021345214918255806,
-0.5429390072822571,
-1.3864271640777588,
0.0916571244597435,
0.112803153693676,
0.7665315270423889,
1.0656274557113647,
0.20909832417964935,
0.43702825903892517,
-0.4822467267513275,
0.2921138405799866,
-0.20299671590328217,
-0.569643497467041,
0.5237689018249512,
-0.6909832954406738,
0.2079000174999237,
0.41508549451828003,
0.41308289766311646,
-0.6656814217567444,
-0.48297807574272156,
-0.9836976528167725,
-0.5406477451324463,
0.4248824417591095,
0.5867061018943787,
0.25812771916389465,
0.3695859909057617,
0.8616655468940735,
0.022583182901144028,
0.2873463034629822,
-0.5730772614479065,
-0.11686316132545471,
-0.02155877836048603,
0.08589600771665573,
0.23631715774536133,
-0.17191027104854584,
0.020784789696335793,
-0.43691644072532654,
0.6083449125289917,
0.07359639555215836,
0.4139450490474701,
-0.047970421612262726,
0.01826997846364975,
-0.22463783621788025,
-0.3546633720397949,
0.31861573457717896,
0.7920821309089661,
-0.4486365020275116,
0.11392410099506378,
0.022323522716760635,
-0.4887641370296478,
0.22451451420783997,
-0.08476442843675613,
-0.2562180757522583,
-0.17859682440757751,
0.12038219720125198,
0.6692960262298584,
0.22360652685165405,
-0.43305569887161255,
0.4580329656600952,
-0.05419496074318886,
-0.18982061743736267,
-0.7554107904434204,
0.47011834383010864,
0.46627572178840637,
0.6813015341758728,
0.2887479364871979,
0.02020415849983692,
0.226210817694664,
-0.6859169602394104,
0.17558112740516663,
0.26595839858055115,
-0.2891947031021118,
-0.6406583786010742,
0.7486475110054016,
0.3385906517505646,
-0.7819159030914307,
0.1688469499349594,
-0.5693421959877014,
-0.5946158170700073,
0.5260241627693176,
0.47814565896987915,
0.535091757774353,
-0.7117451429367065,
0.6883038282394409,
-0.07627186179161072,
0.19372040033340454,
0.17570912837982178,
0.45001718401908875,
-0.0362325981259346,
-0.9071292877197266,
-0.12326264381408691,
-0.37458744645118713,
-0.4691717028617859,
0.3008265197277069,
-0.3158915638923645,
0.2549962103366852,
-0.8164032697677612,
-0.4572807848453522,
0.2606246769428253,
0.3477761745452881,
-0.7681823372840881,
0.19718222320079803,
-0.1570245921611786,
0.6560690402984619,
-0.871550977230072,
0.5632396936416626,
1.503519058227539,
-0.22211188077926636,
-0.6506503820419312,
-0.09403572231531143,
0.2558174729347229,
-0.43741652369499207,
0.2592276632785797,
0.11735694110393524,
-0.08788446336984634,
-0.007269652094691992,
-0.6755465865135193,
-0.9162594079971313,
1.2732425928115845,
0.5114896893501282,
-0.0693698599934578,
-0.05290279537439346,
-0.0000036166802601655945,
0.6195685267448425,
-0.612326443195343,
-0.16073496639728546,
0.024027414619922638,
0.44549912214279175,
0.6692721843719482,
-0.34905263781547546,
0.27960482239723206,
-0.6386227607727051,
0.2462911754846573,
-0.188030406832695,
-1.0625840425491333,
0.6774491667747498,
-0.07018666714429855,
-0.23438549041748047,
-0.3305665850639343,
0.6078916192054749,
0.26487821340560913,
0.6054659485816956,
0.550006091594696,
0.19689200818538666,
0.7196710109710693,
0.23972754180431366,
0.8686067461967468,
-0.33637771010398865,
0.12656864523887634,
0.8178238868713379,
-0.41740429401397705,
0.446533739566803,
0.09741624444723129,
0.03939297795295715,
0.7083262801170349,
1.0551806688308716,
0.073322594165802,
0.44068339467048645,
0.031633246690034866,
-0.2988615334033966,
-0.48725423216819763,
-0.1295243799686432,
-0.2228705883026123,
0.42437174916267395,
0.2360115349292755,
-0.0925036072731018,
-0.03224613144993782,
0.19490265846252441,
0.014978516846895218,
0.11734473705291748,
-0.07060366868972778,
0.7271084785461426,
-0.0008995646494440734,
-0.40549236536026,
-0.19009126722812653,
0.2956736087799072,
0.3165934681892395,
-0.3916301429271698,
0.1298857480287552,
-0.2500912845134735,
0.28678229451179504,
-0.26735568046569824,
-0.4345485270023346,
0.4035448729991913,
-0.41351279616355896,
-0.036670390516519547,
-0.0395033173263073,
1.577622890472412,
-0.17451748251914978,
-0.2171146124601364,
0.20828431844711304,
0.7410801649093628,
0.28698650002479553,
-0.5121654272079468,
-0.6639481782913208,
0.10705606639385223,
-0.34742364287376404,
-0.42841842770576477,
0.2788006663322449,
0.49241873621940613,
-0.019544921815395355,
0.8853671550750732,
0.5468591451644897,
-0.056683916598558426,
-0.27934354543685913,
-0.13575920462608337,
1.0193027257919312,
-0.5481651425361633,
-0.799452006816864,
-0.7631748914718628,
0.5993895530700684,
-0.6849219799041748,
-0.07903401553630829,
0.6506537199020386,
0.3884429931640625,
0.4641287624835968,
-0.07939762622117996,
0.7114821672439575,
-0.41864922642707825,
0.3891335725784302,
0.016357600688934326,
1.0411604642868042,
-0.6726290583610535,
-0.008882987312972546,
-0.445846289396286,
-1.2469496726989746,
0.02396283857524395,
0.7435404062271118,
-0.14273561537265778,
0.40093278884887695,
0.3042326271533966,
0.5714442729949951,
-0.28804895281791687,
-0.1788642704486847,
0.2771751880645752,
-0.05621187016367912,
0.3262033462524414,
0.3904998302459717,
0.8637727499008179,
-0.2464008778333664,
0.20953583717346191,
-0.5774583220481873,
-0.513486385345459,
-0.4776729345321655,
-0.6123806238174438,
-1.3637876510620117,
-0.946064829826355,
-0.48068907856941223,
-0.5701826810836792,
0.10021981596946716,
0.9432991147041321,
1.085982322692871,
-0.20791403949260712,
-0.1446927785873413,
0.3902120590209961,
0.4702015221118927,
-0.245370015501976,
-0.27984458208084106,
0.0807497650384903,
0.2055385559797287,
-0.4972933232784271,
0.03974157199263573,
0.20052297413349152,
0.16721011698246002,
-0.452850341796875,
-0.3461105227470398,
-0.23248639702796936,
0.3002651035785675,
0.8737638592720032,
0.3820390999317169,
-0.3692264258861542,
-0.5728195309638977,
0.2546772062778473,
-0.024665141478180885,
-0.16012468934059143,
0.6152610778808594,
-0.6087765693664551,
0.2760879099369049,
0.6495283246040344,
0.2986396253108978,
0.46910345554351807,
0.30424556136131287,
0.5418976545333862,
-0.7797385454177856,
0.11038816720247269,
0.08007251471281052,
0.13633356988430023,
0.33503085374832153,
-0.7744938135147095,
0.4520602226257324,
0.47306838631629944,
-0.43798375129699707,
-0.6091464757919312,
0.3823777139186859,
-1.0298510789871216,
-0.32887598872184753,
1.4519271850585938,
0.018919937312602997,
-0.4018913805484772,
-0.19756990671157837,
-0.23207654058933258,
0.3152795433998108,
-0.6162754893302917,
0.9095653891563416,
0.699723482131958,
-0.4067453444004059,
-0.18332019448280334,
-0.5513785481452942,
0.4980604946613312,
-0.1961672008037567,
-0.8181204795837402,
-0.5222684741020203,
0.4655144214630127,
0.435038685798645,
0.3470354676246643,
0.9594480991363525,
0.23681557178497314,
0.12661947309970856,
0.0732169896364212,
0.1138436421751976,
-0.23184987902641296,
-0.4489981532096863,
0.3189881145954132,
0.38898569345474243,
-0.024877918884158134,
0.07520553469657898
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19270v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19270v1
|
sDPO: Don't Use Your Data All at Once
| 2024-03-28T09:56:04 | 2024-03-28T09:56:04 |
Dahyun Kim, Yungi Kim, Wonho Song, Hyeonwoo Kim, Yunsu Kim, Sanghoon Kim, Chanjun Park
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
As development of large language models (LLM) progresses, aligning them with
human preferences has become increasingly important. We propose stepwise DPO
(sDPO), an extension of the recently popularized direct preference optimization
(DPO) for alignment tuning. This approach involves dividing the available
preference datasets and utilizing them in a stepwise manner, rather than
employing it all at once. We demonstrate that this method facilitates the use
of more precisely aligned reference models within the DPO training framework.
Furthermore, sDPO trains the final model to be more performant, even
outperforming other popular LLMs with more parameters.
|
[
-0.24112370610237122,
-0.09242281317710876,
0.7225959300994873,
0.24986107647418976,
-0.5518595576286316,
-0.024862978607416153,
0.11285538226366043,
-0.2354782074689865,
-0.031770870089530945,
0.8498831391334534,
-0.7333340048789978,
-0.30024293065071106,
-0.5419877767562866,
0.1964855194091797,
-0.15696123242378235,
0.7211212515830994,
-0.13094517588615417,
0.34025856852531433,
-0.35392099618911743,
0.06473295390605927,
-0.1750277876853943,
-0.04318898543715477,
-0.690885603427887,
-0.6911390423774719,
0.4053487181663513,
0.772016167640686,
0.9321111440658569,
1.2765960693359375,
0.6143326163291931,
0.2780998647212982,
-0.02649213932454586,
0.22942614555358887,
-0.4376954138278961,
0.17271488904953003,
-0.10110189020633698,
-0.4514141380786896,
-0.5729496479034424,
0.27655112743377686,
0.4422226846218109,
0.8791297078132629,
-0.23750272393226624,
0.06411118805408478,
-0.2553921639919281,
1.1184515953063965,
-0.6108797788619995,
-0.26486214995384216,
-0.6459528803825378,
0.10726121813058853,
-0.004533279687166214,
-0.21118591725826263,
-0.30200207233428955,
-0.7022223472595215,
0.10992097854614258,
-0.6655935645103455,
0.027699360623955727,
-0.00479627912864089,
0.5617648363113403,
0.670109212398529,
-0.3999671936035156,
-0.22544391453266144,
-0.8065046072006226,
0.953382670879364,
-0.4532886743545532,
0.5877556800842285,
0.4010132849216461,
-0.010906376875936985,
-0.33334389328956604,
-0.20481951534748077,
-0.7565257549285889,
-0.15966609120368958,
0.2513694763183594,
-0.03969363495707512,
0.2554013133049011,
0.2045123279094696,
0.21554121375083923,
0.22614794969558716,
-0.31271612644195557,
0.32919007539749146,
-0.2189733386039734,
0.03587925061583519,
0.888842761516571,
0.06475263088941574,
0.10422872006893158,
-0.11867465078830719,
-0.6936406493186951,
-0.09138574451208115,
-0.9143986105918884,
-0.05456704646348953,
0.6852297782897949,
0.39535951614379883,
0.340703547000885,
0.7300848960876465,
-0.12704215943813324,
1.1058573722839355,
0.5296839475631714,
-0.6329461932182312,
0.32037103176116943,
-0.38038545846939087,
-0.307911217212677,
0.2206726372241974,
0.85454261302948,
0.4860113263130188,
0.3723302185535431,
-0.04416273534297943,
-0.09741469472646713,
-0.1308126002550125,
0.41633594036102295,
-0.6121122241020203,
0.11331001669168472,
0.6038703918457031,
-0.20372270047664642,
-0.5516772270202637,
-0.28075626492500305,
-0.7626966238021851,
-0.46931588649749756,
-0.9243645668029785,
0.09962862730026245,
-0.4262588322162628,
-0.18394963443279266,
0.2674162983894348,
0.04382627084851265,
0.2611299753189087,
0.15840105712413788,
-1.2497540712356567,
0.2546084523200989,
1.0135812759399414,
0.785119354724884,
-0.31682515144348145,
-0.4871968924999237,
-0.49449822306632996,
0.30416616797447205,
-0.7596679329872131,
0.5846506357192993,
-0.7448164820671082,
-0.6973187923431396,
-0.08342983573675156,
-0.20321619510650635,
0.08143428713083267,
-0.6051938533782959,
0.9876265525817871,
-0.44169536232948303,
-0.03283882513642311,
-0.4616754353046417,
-0.606189489364624,
0.3198537230491638,
-0.10903546214103699,
-0.6012147068977356,
1.1594244241714478,
-0.17652717232704163,
-0.6398001313209534,
0.7752093076705933,
-0.34067192673683167,
-0.5057383179664612,
-0.29917049407958984,
-0.2647906243801117,
-0.3729916214942932,
0.21168354153633118,
0.18276575207710266,
0.42267897725105286,
-0.044111497700214386,
0.35399672389030457,
-0.5514461398124695,
-0.4756719768047333,
-0.1603149026632309,
0.20514187216758728,
0.6696663498878479,
0.3272689878940582,
0.05505116283893585,
-0.02484194189310074,
-1.0560791492462158,
-0.17544502019882202,
0.08086749166250229,
-0.3641032874584198,
-0.7142410278320312,
0.24584190547466278,
-0.6347750425338745,
0.4897609055042267,
0.373545378446579,
-0.68447345495224,
0.4846670925617218,
-0.3592042624950409,
0.14720670878887177,
1.111690640449524,
-0.37586352229118347,
0.8282229900360107,
-0.2852301299571991,
0.5371571183204651,
0.23875194787979126,
0.27160757780075073,
0.2454131692647934,
-0.1699441522359848,
-0.7257170081138611,
-0.2658088505268097,
0.13649439811706543,
0.43392735719680786,
-0.5914738178253174,
0.9491080641746521,
-0.3046215772628784,
-0.4377819001674652,
-0.7912378907203674,
0.37369057536125183,
0.04442521557211876,
0.9064765572547913,
0.0966496467590332,
-0.1411474198102951,
-0.5684832334518433,
-1.0040936470031738,
-0.019469453021883965,
-0.207535982131958,
-0.08903146535158157,
0.1700245589017868,
0.22865056991577148,
0.03314416855573654,
1.109236478805542,
-0.7874456644058228,
0.17316341400146484,
-0.09840209782123566,
-0.17951731383800507,
0.27596813440322876,
0.47280997037887573,
0.3956562876701355,
-0.7635558247566223,
-0.6152268648147583,
-0.20188170671463013,
-0.2057618945837021,
-0.2791815400123596,
-0.06837179511785507,
-0.3704359233379364,
0.013314707204699516,
0.222093403339386,
-0.46628013253211975,
-0.19494237005710602,
0.7336714267730713,
-0.0972009003162384,
0.11792408674955368,
-0.20902156829833984,
0.10487263649702072,
-1.1651643514633179,
-0.056571438908576965,
0.10055341571569443,
-0.2408107966184616,
-0.7608746290206909,
-0.33117374777793884,
0.22965870797634125,
-0.2704200744628906,
-0.32682451605796814,
0.549365758895874,
-0.30927908420562744,
0.012734903953969479,
-0.45492950081825256,
0.1485014259815216,
0.043335456401109695,
0.19954396784305573,
0.3828974962234497,
0.8303854465484619,
0.538092851638794,
-0.7872546315193176,
0.2926905155181885,
0.5459585189819336,
-0.30659037828445435,
0.7061975002288818,
-0.5745819807052612,
0.44460025429725647,
-0.353324830532074,
0.02719561755657196,
-1.0615259408950806,
0.03438735753297806,
0.22496634721755981,
-0.07932621240615845,
0.5685340166091919,
-0.24228879809379578,
-0.3510916531085968,
-0.28539299964904785,
-0.5671960711479187,
0.04872733727097511,
0.36394020915031433,
-0.8542385101318359,
0.1669447124004364,
0.41163191199302673,
-0.05528615042567253,
-0.9615532755851746,
-0.32872462272644043,
-0.3381544351577759,
-0.4488542079925537,
-0.48690107464790344,
0.48724138736724854,
-0.12471853941679001,
-0.1689010113477707,
-0.5361685156822205,
-0.5437533855438232,
0.04855412617325783,
-0.0567464753985405,
0.1884806603193283,
0.458111047744751,
0.4100355803966522,
0.19099019467830658,
-0.008656415157020092,
-0.3134964108467102,
-0.3316746950149536,
-0.2044104039669037,
0.589123010635376,
0.6514062881469727,
-0.15741583704948425,
-0.3927833139896393,
0.43716636300086975,
0.5900751352310181,
-0.01483129058033228,
0.39501217007637024,
0.15772926807403564,
0.05969943106174469,
-0.16962814331054688,
-0.4563221037387848,
0.0914808064699173,
-0.5262371301651001,
0.11162612587213516,
-0.3891746699810028,
-0.4398442506790161,
0.03110923245549202,
-0.3484047055244446,
0.23841024935245514,
-0.011059427633881569,
0.3032492399215698,
-0.16576485335826874,
1.1491299867630005,
0.9733638763427734,
-0.2790118157863617,
0.8977392911911011,
0.3186740279197693,
0.21467934548854828,
-1.091209888458252,
-0.010738572105765343,
-0.6833112835884094,
-0.3617912828922272,
-0.6590904593467712,
-0.4405016601085663,
-0.014151221141219139,
0.2924465239048004,
-0.401454895734787,
0.4795496463775635,
-0.5495662689208984,
0.5080838203430176,
0.39745351672172546,
0.1696706861257553,
0.48232150077819824,
-0.08097516000270844,
-0.006257145199924707,
-0.1680440753698349,
-0.39323821663856506,
-0.6065971255302429,
1.473069190979004,
0.3160039186477661,
0.980958104133606,
-0.24440816044807434,
1.091596007347107,
-0.17924483120441437,
-0.17081379890441895,
-1.0580047369003296,
0.5894148349761963,
-0.4252700209617615,
-0.5488837957382202,
-0.3414698839187622,
-0.5198490619659424,
-0.7227932810783386,
0.1911648064851761,
0.20983649790287018,
-0.6543225049972534,
0.5818739533424377,
0.23088344931602478,
-0.38646456599235535,
0.015630705282092094,
-0.6222614049911499,
0.42786943912506104,
-0.35401052236557007,
-0.308444619178772,
-0.0459684394299984,
-0.5654642581939697,
0.2882828414440155,
-0.22107139229774475,
-0.048609212040901184,
-0.5897089838981628,
-0.5690789222717285,
0.5668208003044128,
-0.4581308662891388,
0.6427062749862671,
-0.05402085557579994,
-0.27719569206237793,
-0.041045550256967545,
-0.08221254497766495,
0.7333268523216248,
-0.1430826485157013,
-0.4287416338920593,
0.00643543154001236,
-0.11868920922279358,
-0.3892144560813904,
-0.30642881989479065,
0.9383819699287415,
-0.8749362230300903,
-0.6949434876441956,
-0.5099607706069946,
-0.37461307644844055,
-0.5391396880149841,
0.263799786567688,
0.019819259643554688,
-0.08138447254896164,
-0.19322431087493896,
-0.3542281985282898,
0.7204498648643494,
0.2230122834444046,
0.3740200400352478,
0.5255823731422424,
-0.16247321665287018,
-0.44179871678352356,
0.5957726836204529,
-0.02360994927585125,
0.6803320050239563,
0.46294716000556946,
0.4297443628311157,
-0.4955960512161255,
-0.6028813123703003,
-0.36952877044677734,
0.3477548658847809,
-0.7642524838447571,
0.023130353540182114,
-0.39886724948883057,
0.32720109820365906,
-0.5419623851776123,
-0.25345703959465027,
-0.7008774280548096,
-0.4542481005191803,
-0.173637256026268,
-0.13093072175979614,
0.21089711785316467,
0.3865659832954407,
-0.18232324719429016,
0.2797653377056122,
-0.5628321766853333,
0.46917930245399475,
0.40317386388778687,
0.565366268157959,
-0.4823552668094635,
-0.3573482632637024,
0.1512453407049179,
-0.025037182494997978,
-0.336688369512558,
-0.721470296382904,
0.2540380358695984,
0.10529324412345886,
0.6021106839179993,
0.5127995014190674,
0.0645802840590477,
0.9018585085868835,
-0.7212505340576172,
0.4955216944217682,
0.2859986126422882,
-0.9741663336753845,
0.8116124272346497,
-0.25384992361068726,
0.30137181282043457,
1.0343066453933716,
1.107295274734497,
-0.4284464716911316,
0.16857296228408813,
-0.32833367586135864,
-0.7001513838768005,
0.8786210417747498,
-0.21492448449134827,
0.11089222878217697,
0.13088521361351013,
0.6349255442619324,
0.34929534792900085,
0.5240523219108582,
-0.49221351742744446,
-0.21456241607666016,
0.0033742256928235292,
-0.11006982624530792,
-0.11258183419704437,
-0.2162504494190216,
-0.5413077473640442,
-0.440405935049057,
0.7777167558670044,
-0.31355899572372437,
-0.08563586324453354,
0.15014035999774933,
0.24284134805202484,
-0.5008094310760498,
0.06026104837656021,
0.35158559679985046,
1.1043750047683716,
-0.25296393036842346,
-0.19451263546943665,
-0.17732775211334229,
-0.4774729907512665,
0.3329569101333618,
-0.044373612850904465,
-0.35588258504867554,
-0.09290236234664917,
0.04016741365194321,
0.8246381878852844,
0.12216470390558243,
-0.4136693775653839,
0.27944299578666687,
0.14615938067436218,
-0.11810027807950974,
-0.06849420070648193,
0.09570705890655518,
0.10561123490333557,
-0.09986045211553574,
-0.12166617065668106,
0.03786524012684822,
-0.01733589358627796,
-0.5638854503631592,
0.1447286307811737,
0.3045527935028076,
-0.4753410518169403,
-0.07480699568986893,
0.40765607357025146,
0.3665873110294342,
-0.23354704678058624,
0.5577569007873535,
0.27728694677352905,
-0.15899786353111267,
0.3772611618041992,
0.5286088585853577,
0.8856906294822693,
-0.5305659174919128,
0.4548429548740387,
0.44450172781944275,
0.022975338622927666,
-0.373542845249176,
0.26641324162483215,
-0.22383154928684235,
-1.087390661239624,
-0.4979630708694458,
-0.8653746247291565,
-0.5760406851768494,
-0.03192562609910965,
-0.7261290550231934,
0.7373246550559998,
-0.520552933216095,
-0.032319530844688416,
0.30500999093055725,
0.17223593592643738,
-0.5596394538879395,
0.24269196391105652,
0.14130790531635284,
0.7231853604316711,
-1.0013375282287598,
1.1500877141952515,
0.6807654500007629,
-0.1443943977355957,
-0.497158408164978,
0.19694378972053528,
0.058710694313049316,
-1.1693990230560303,
0.4397631287574768,
-0.17566156387329102,
-0.120688796043396,
-0.11380220204591751,
-0.5540100932121277,
-1.050135612487793,
1.1045809984207153,
0.3815131187438965,
-0.9613635540008545,
-0.023214465007185936,
0.27390968799591064,
0.3391832709312439,
-0.4942658841609955,
-0.08964884281158447,
0.9867004752159119,
0.4195578694343567,
0.7824356555938721,
-0.7702805399894714,
-0.08234981447458267,
0.34269678592681885,
0.14163510501384735,
0.5385607481002808,
-0.9702996611595154,
0.5977282524108887,
-0.24916759133338928,
-0.03443266451358795,
-0.19228073954582214,
0.10633156448602676,
0.3584606647491455,
-0.1497185379266739,
0.8059877157211304,
0.659048855304718,
0.8628643751144409,
-0.018963906913995743,
0.9440711140632629,
-0.22099801898002625,
0.21435865759849548,
1.1931729316711426,
-0.8019660711288452,
0.7548208832740784,
0.966316282749176,
-0.44571784138679504,
-0.07424641400575638,
0.9037976264953613,
0.12168562412261963,
0.866910994052887,
0.11026632785797119,
-0.12618353962898254,
-0.5011218786239624,
-0.010285447351634502,
-0.2192336767911911,
0.6919944286346436,
-0.12478303909301758,
-0.3491984009742737,
0.0046697948127985,
-0.422380268573761,
0.17318813502788544,
0.17930734157562256,
-0.25777631998062134,
0.8520450592041016,
0.06560415029525757,
-0.8249152898788452,
0.4615403413772583,
-0.4263905882835388,
0.6275795698165894,
-0.818550169467926,
0.24271154403686523,
-0.2889384925365448,
0.2629927098751068,
-0.23425452411174774,
-0.695728600025177,
0.3103256821632385,
-0.16539302468299866,
-0.2273045778274536,
-0.5166623592376709,
0.37113526463508606,
-0.4741799235343933,
-0.6605860590934753,
0.31260374188423157,
0.1898248791694641,
-0.0747683197259903,
0.21526260673999786,
-0.7108437418937683,
0.1255834996700287,
0.23226244747638702,
-0.34345853328704834,
0.4402211606502533,
0.24584251642227173,
0.2831348180770874,
0.7640089392662048,
0.6198218464851379,
0.34368059039115906,
-0.27356407046318054,
0.0005168052157387137,
0.9285857081413269,
-0.6667385101318359,
-0.26294928789138794,
-0.9540019035339355,
0.400574654340744,
-0.3534037470817566,
-0.5080572366714478,
0.5311363935470581,
0.6070013642311096,
0.8594116568565369,
0.12290894985198975,
0.8427032828330994,
0.12845711410045624,
0.6143833994865417,
-0.5397518277168274,
0.18572759628295898,
-0.6694905161857605,
0.34208446741104126,
-0.4381694793701172,
-1.1343328952789307,
-0.10143908113241196,
0.5361791849136353,
-0.3774530589580536,
-0.08054335415363312,
0.5600248575210571,
0.5473471283912659,
0.027542058378458023,
0.06691284477710724,
0.42900365591049194,
-0.1963154673576355,
0.2616153359413147,
0.3738868832588196,
0.6159993410110474,
-0.14565983414649963,
0.34494665265083313,
-0.7145523428916931,
-0.4472898840904236,
-0.06623177230358124,
-1.1466518640518188,
-0.6599913835525513,
-0.48357445001602173,
-0.40027615427970886,
0.030332166701555252,
-0.149236261844635,
1.06938636302948,
0.7759361267089844,
-0.6899446249008179,
-0.3822169601917267,
0.0034405947662889957,
0.3221047520637512,
-0.2695251405239105,
-0.06245352700352669,
0.12701547145843506,
-0.36802613735198975,
-1.3064361810684204,
0.6308619976043701,
0.26711463928222656,
0.20698665082454681,
-0.398519903421402,
0.04763844609260559,
-0.37929341197013855,
0.1740405261516571,
0.37517261505126953,
0.10273385047912598,
-0.4127205014228821,
-0.4075223207473755,
0.03731442987918854,
-0.06508277356624603,
0.44417423009872437,
0.9321804046630859,
-0.2869568467140198,
0.8281927704811096,
0.7115575075149536,
0.3074691593647003,
0.4356207847595215,
0.3268033266067505,
1.1384040117263794,
-0.7402341365814209,
0.36213335394859314,
0.3155810236930847,
0.29638195037841797,
0.4144584536552429,
-0.6025634407997131,
0.6145579814910889,
-0.10485626012086868,
-0.7194478511810303,
-0.6144989132881165,
0.5393193960189819,
-1.0226943492889404,
-0.13978539407253265,
1.1735914945602417,
0.07935629785060883,
-0.0819680318236351,
0.06000221148133278,
-0.12827345728874207,
0.09820853918790817,
-0.5474141240119934,
0.8060959577560425,
0.8379520177841187,
-0.5964903831481934,
0.061817046254873276,
-0.4869256615638733,
0.7784405946731567,
0.401498019695282,
-0.5570340752601624,
0.10979647189378738,
0.38520631194114685,
0.5396995544433594,
0.1398656666278839,
0.8052686452865601,
-0.07708084583282471,
-0.24686454236507416,
0.028707480058073997,
-0.008069888688623905,
0.006969433277845383,
-0.42442587018013,
-0.5798516273498535,
-0.14865149557590485,
0.21695151925086975,
-0.6500024199485779
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19267v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19267v2
|
MineLand: Simulating Large-Scale Multi-Agent Interactions with Limited Multimodal Senses and Physical Needs
| 2024-03-28T09:53:41 | 2024-05-23T14:27:15 |
Xianhao Yu, Jiaqi Fu, Renjia Deng, Wenjuan Han
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
While Vision-Language Models (VLMs) hold promise for tasks requiring
extensive collaboration, traditional multi-agent simulators have facilitated
rich explorations of an interactive artificial society that reflects collective
behavior. However, these existing simulators face significant limitations.
Firstly, they struggle with handling large numbers of agents due to high
resource demands. Secondly, they often assume agents possess perfect
information and limitless capabilities, hindering the ecological validity of
simulated social interactions. To bridge this gap, we propose a multi-agent
Minecraft simulator, MineLand, that bridges this gap by introducing three key
features: large-scale scalability, limited multimodal senses, and physical
needs. Our simulator supports 64 or more agents. Agents have limited visual,
auditory, and environmental awareness, forcing them to actively communicate and
collaborate to fulfill physical needs like food and resources. Additionally, we
further introduce an AI agent framework, Alex, inspired by multitasking theory,
enabling agents to handle intricate coordination and scheduling. Our
experiments demonstrate that the simulator, the corresponding benchmark, and
the AI agent framework contribute to more ecological and nuanced collective
behavior.The source code of MineLand and Alex is openly available at
https://github.com/cocacola-lab/MineLand.
|
[
-0.6333911418914795,
-0.7269021272659302,
0.8091205358505249,
0.4804547131061554,
0.25580406188964844,
0.3790971040725708,
-0.3345472514629364,
-0.7286950945854187,
0.5083387494087219,
0.3175797462463379,
-0.6233053207397461,
-0.06538982689380646,
-0.24329321086406708,
0.06603502482175827,
0.07357976585626602,
0.6497965455055237,
0.11701037734746933,
-0.4142617881298065,
-0.6339725852012634,
-0.24674801528453827,
-0.3799184560775757,
-0.44350776076316833,
-0.3633580505847931,
-0.0865679457783699,
0.7770968675613403,
0.40394291281700134,
0.8306047916412354,
0.552770733833313,
0.5081145763397217,
0.497883141040802,
0.04540335759520531,
0.39457079768180847,
-0.5374777913093567,
0.28537726402282715,
-0.23203806579113007,
-0.02873442880809307,
-0.4002920091152191,
0.05425846949219704,
0.5866060256958008,
0.32820653915405273,
0.012693822383880615,
0.2896970212459564,
-0.22404499351978302,
0.17009153962135315,
-0.5464655160903931,
0.6769118905067444,
-0.34676989912986755,
0.059070587158203125,
0.3836248219013214,
0.13416139781475067,
-0.08734041452407837,
0.3519212603569031,
0.10905051976442337,
-0.8648584485054016,
-0.19625137746334076,
0.27377989888191223,
0.8169615268707275,
0.3859926462173462,
-0.476508229970932,
0.18019303679466248,
-0.6813125610351562,
0.8166925311088562,
-0.2240278273820877,
0.043852344155311584,
0.30261215567588806,
0.47735053300857544,
0.07639279961585999,
-0.4217866063117981,
-0.9544257521629333,
-0.35542556643486023,
0.1921149492263794,
0.2965921461582184,
0.013899299316108227,
0.16991274058818817,
0.26171794533729553,
-0.2003776729106903,
-0.4968315362930298,
-0.21273240447044373,
-0.5104765295982361,
0.02157541923224926,
0.5799614191055298,
0.44502097368240356,
0.40113401412963867,
-0.24766142666339874,
-0.4608873426914215,
-0.4058305025100708,
-0.14168928563594818,
0.3572505712509155,
0.24170075356960297,
0.43748560547828674,
-0.301489919424057,
0.7311030030250549,
-0.10289036482572556,
0.33376049995422363,
-0.35621944069862366,
-0.03264970704913139,
0.3455119729042053,
-0.44883719086647034,
-0.13047383725643158,
-0.2989700734615326,
0.4935949742794037,
0.7152920365333557,
0.252313494682312,
-0.08634699136018753,
-0.05781903117895126,
0.4023565948009491,
0.5115482807159424,
-0.6383692026138306,
0.07155067473649979,
0.7300916910171509,
-0.2882654368877411,
-0.5172638893127441,
-0.1738784909248352,
-0.8815123438835144,
-0.4142872989177704,
-0.3691950738430023,
0.36500290036201477,
-0.3451472222805023,
-0.8280094265937805,
-0.0854717493057251,
-0.5857576727867126,
-0.006800915580242872,
0.5958263278007507,
-0.3796409070491791,
0.5281620025634766,
0.5626619458198547,
1.0285818576812744,
0.1574786901473999,
-1.0500255823135376,
-0.3041793406009674,
0.3775918185710907,
-0.16569708287715912,
0.4886530041694641,
-0.7516846060752869,
-0.2498392015695572,
-0.32637977600097656,
-0.06583473086357117,
-0.028622612357139587,
-0.31719934940338135,
-0.5272998213768005,
-0.2460131198167801,
-0.2477988600730896,
-0.4045380651950836,
0.18933114409446716,
-0.1965087652206421,
0.7555801868438721,
-0.8214275240898132,
0.5611093640327454,
0.29843538999557495,
-0.1812461018562317,
0.39354050159454346,
-1.103675365447998,
-0.20986910164356232,
0.1023881658911705,
-0.0774456113576889,
0.006097969599068165,
0.04930542781949043,
-0.3881989121437073,
0.15147855877876282,
-0.07898040115833282,
0.15094436705112457,
-0.6229738593101501,
-0.3471473157405853,
0.0993310958147049,
-0.15053217113018036,
0.5045751333236694,
0.31916308403015137,
-0.1443105787038803,
0.4054410457611084,
-0.4172283411026001,
0.15881994366645813,
0.12008148431777954,
-0.10818719863891602,
-0.15723545849323273,
0.17140188813209534,
0.4115407466888428,
0.5963762402534485,
0.30090436339378357,
-0.43781542778015137,
0.31550249457359314,
0.07427553087472916,
0.42425042390823364,
0.859399676322937,
-0.21304632723331451,
0.4193651080131531,
-0.8118202686309814,
0.5800735950469971,
0.17316292226314545,
0.32844483852386475,
-0.14020663499832153,
-0.388477087020874,
-0.33095023036003113,
-0.5767731666564941,
-0.20375336706638336,
0.4454810917377472,
-0.9289565086364746,
0.009988604113459587,
-0.2974122166633606,
-0.3567180931568146,
-0.16849303245544434,
0.08056282997131348,
0.450568825006485,
-0.21205675601959229,
0.31538769602775574,
-0.6576360464096069,
-0.5043106079101562,
-0.3928946852684021,
0.3444943428039551,
-0.3520401418209076,
0.17235006392002106,
0.8318555951118469,
0.7809308171272278,
-0.44451743364334106,
0.9931759238243103,
-0.004895495250821114,
-0.393588125705719,
-0.18487480282783508,
-0.1021411269903183,
-0.051160722970962524,
0.3679606318473816,
0.7615300416946411,
-0.8126571774482727,
-0.312778115272522,
0.1743677705526352,
-0.9284331202507019,
0.22795510292053223,
-0.06912640482187271,
-0.007815918885171413,
-0.1046997606754303,
0.19723136723041534,
-0.8895772695541382,
0.35296395421028137,
0.9183858036994934,
-0.364319384098053,
0.5628458261489868,
-0.3167363107204437,
0.21494939923286438,
-0.9620117545127869,
0.00624930439516902,
-0.09927216917276382,
-0.1910136342048645,
-0.33700892329216003,
0.5584717988967896,
-0.19617129862308502,
-0.32699164748191833,
-0.5251621603965759,
0.6315575838088989,
-0.5386669635772705,
-0.19634361565113068,
-0.11891017854213715,
0.0709279477596283,
0.11091019958257675,
0.4859936535358429,
-0.16491156816482544,
0.8941466808319092,
0.620964765548706,
-0.6219659447669983,
0.7476477026939392,
0.06124100461602211,
0.20143188536167145,
0.7918789982795715,
-0.5942990183830261,
-0.08220608532428741,
-0.4043513238430023,
0.32242080569267273,
-0.6223225593566895,
-0.5995129942893982,
0.06835152953863144,
-0.160189688205719,
-0.14021021127700806,
-0.13423770666122437,
-0.5848854780197144,
-0.4699186682701111,
-0.4620386064052582,
0.4484688937664032,
0.5167103409767151,
-0.31888189911842346,
1.321557879447937,
0.4527857005596161,
0.10554387420415878,
-0.40887895226478577,
-0.456336110830307,
0.4399087429046631,
-0.1253318041563034,
-0.7049065232276917,
-0.22271953523159027,
-0.2694220244884491,
-0.6685200333595276,
0.41863906383514404,
0.07951470464468002,
-0.16851045191287994,
0.184106707572937,
0.7443660497665405,
-0.010904802940785885,
-0.15220840275287628,
0.06484168767929077,
-0.17437975108623505,
0.20074957609176636,
0.08821619302034378,
-0.44320032000541687,
0.6239994764328003,
-0.36942169070243835,
-0.34210583567619324,
-0.06886716932058334,
0.5572487115859985,
1.1163626909255981,
-0.5297921299934387,
0.7994707822799683,
0.2855607271194458,
-0.398281455039978,
-0.28472447395324707,
-0.32261502742767334,
-0.06030735746026039,
-0.5427976250648499,
0.3729235827922821,
-0.5450716614723206,
-0.5611326098442078,
0.5614731311798096,
-0.3490038514137268,
0.14855583012104034,
0.09226782619953156,
0.1691211611032486,
-0.18173392117023468,
0.9728697538375854,
0.47450727224349976,
0.16126702725887299,
0.4080309569835663,
-0.28262701630592346,
-0.022774191573262215,
-0.882429838180542,
-0.2992759048938751,
-0.2352617084980011,
-0.4074554443359375,
-0.2363208830356598,
-0.9359483122825623,
0.3592914640903473,
-0.6289112567901611,
-0.36733075976371765,
0.2551724910736084,
-0.25485366582870483,
0.7270340323448181,
0.5706180334091187,
0.13063594698905945,
0.03139660134911537,
0.09342003613710403,
-0.22983704507350922,
0.22316530346870422,
-0.5432398319244385,
-0.5697810053825378,
0.6111127734184265,
-0.0360836423933506,
0.48789411783218384,
0.46380555629730225,
0.5746849775314331,
0.3464125394821167,
0.27698084712028503,
-0.5675644278526306,
0.7053598165512085,
0.1746017336845398,
-0.9254777431488037,
-0.45951685309410095,
-0.5375046133995056,
-0.8907139897346497,
0.5185799598693848,
-0.441055566072464,
-0.7015331983566284,
-0.05878831446170807,
0.13317450881004333,
-0.26754578948020935,
0.33382028341293335,
-0.9451297521591187,
0.861737847328186,
-0.21783049404621124,
-0.7760533690452576,
-0.4693407118320465,
-0.5761841535568237,
0.065751813352108,
-0.07029848545789719,
0.6310896277427673,
-0.4248470962047577,
-0.03911526873707771,
-0.15389588475227356,
-0.383414626121521,
1.0624481439590454,
-0.1738310158252716,
0.2991785705089569,
0.48701170086860657,
0.3323066234588623,
0.4779578447341919,
0.09179353713989258,
0.06933101266622543,
0.03783576563000679,
0.15897305309772491,
-0.6039950847625732,
-0.2422647774219513,
0.9202606678009033,
-1.0970101356506348,
-0.4732852578163147,
-0.6706746220588684,
-0.7341092824935913,
-0.09193162620067596,
0.1822003722190857,
-0.503704309463501,
0.1533258855342865,
-0.4619859755039215,
0.06602764874696732,
0.2178434580564499,
-0.17294065654277802,
0.4660983085632324,
0.3978199064731598,
-0.5420576930046082,
-0.17012643814086914,
1.159471869468689,
0.258887380361557,
0.3266147971153259,
-0.13506938517093658,
-0.026524493470788002,
0.05368316173553467,
-0.08494504541158676,
-0.39923277497291565,
-0.10906865447759628,
-0.14116251468658447,
0.02328721433877945,
-0.8518381714820862,
-0.13839662075042725,
-0.14262814819812775,
-0.4018370807170868,
-0.4069678485393524,
-0.06998239457607269,
-0.026273438706994057,
-0.18379467725753784,
0.3497264087200165,
1.0147560834884644,
-0.4192613363265991,
0.21381612122058868,
-0.5396199822425842,
0.4338156282901764,
0.5769887566566467,
0.6045588254928589,
0.13675333559513092,
0.31660521030426025,
-0.27941980957984924,
0.17786280810832977,
-0.010298250243067741,
-0.6304106712341309,
0.4110180735588074,
-0.10189514607191086,
0.35112303495407104,
0.22431840002536774,
0.033856213092803955,
0.8520771265029907,
-0.44952836632728577,
0.7453750967979431,
0.12732398509979248,
-0.8072429895401001,
0.26955950260162354,
-0.5027212500572205,
0.1267431527376175,
0.38885486125946045,
-0.16242451965808868,
-0.562549352645874,
-0.5238820910453796,
-0.7178621292114258,
-0.9220137596130371,
0.6750510334968567,
0.26051589846611023,
0.42450881004333496,
-0.059400249272584915,
-0.3478075861930847,
-0.15274377167224884,
0.3755966126918793,
-0.5903293490409851,
0.08601248264312744,
-0.42543932795524597,
-0.1500709056854248,
-0.3804323375225067,
-0.06484105437994003,
-0.4718928039073944,
0.04868212714791298,
0.26063692569732666,
-0.1149071753025055,
0.11260843276977539,
0.1904500126838684,
-0.002118470845744014,
-0.3346175253391266,
-0.18419095873832703,
0.5495188236236572,
0.5428963303565979,
-0.24962344765663147,
0.4096592366695404,
0.29951563477516174,
-0.5305652022361755,
0.21064697206020355,
0.03685789927840233,
0.036770399659872055,
-0.2636093199253082,
0.0809297114610672,
0.40351930260658264,
-0.05852390453219414,
-0.8819388151168823,
0.523581326007843,
-0.3146710693836212,
-0.2467949390411377,
-0.4918897747993469,
0.31416255235671997,
0.09690132737159729,
0.7089542150497437,
0.13382488489151,
0.621555745601654,
-0.11955251544713974,
-0.6943598389625549,
0.06675475835800171,
0.40529006719589233,
-0.43170517683029175,
-0.2803157567977905,
0.8684637546539307,
0.3603637218475342,
-0.35634586215019226,
0.4355658292770386,
-0.47672635316848755,
-0.3058958053588867,
1.3734568357467651,
0.23350000381469727,
0.4880210757255554,
0.05552765354514122,
0.30606594681739807,
0.15175485610961914,
0.6595928072929382,
-0.1283675879240036,
0.3946930170059204,
0.11901051551103592,
-0.6341693997383118,
-0.34397366642951965,
-0.3466642200946808,
-0.7997495532035828,
-0.31389322876930237,
-0.10842704772949219,
-0.21814580261707306,
-0.7414335608482361,
-0.2739703357219696,
-0.25542816519737244,
0.03993280604481697,
-0.8117560148239136,
-0.033972181379795074,
0.04279719293117523,
0.6155000329017639,
-0.67486971616745,
0.45067036151885986,
0.9465043544769287,
-0.4447774589061737,
-0.7909573912620544,
-0.22136183083057404,
0.2936267852783203,
-0.6711550354957581,
0.23797401785850525,
0.3889522850513458,
-0.3093538284301758,
-0.09177327156066895,
-0.8689892292022705,
-0.9015048146247864,
1.198468565940857,
0.028680913150310516,
-0.36242982745170593,
0.14265821874141693,
-0.17870213091373444,
0.5939804911613464,
-0.3957464098930359,
0.3074297606945038,
-0.12541915476322174,
0.7667295932769775,
-0.04972723871469498,
-1.1042320728302002,
0.01758159138262272,
-0.5746387243270874,
-0.06262487918138504,
-0.10755279660224915,
-1.3190996646881104,
0.9940119385719299,
-0.5306459069252014,
0.02092006988823414,
-0.05085327848792076,
0.2733280658721924,
0.47853636741638184,
0.6847507953643799,
0.7700945138931274,
0.3266921639442444,
0.6635010242462158,
0.0992608517408371,
1.0915004014968872,
-0.42616739869117737,
0.32500019669532776,
0.8404715657234192,
-0.8071610927581787,
0.5150732398033142,
0.498370885848999,
-0.05518616363406181,
0.19461612403392792,
0.12397181242704391,
0.04185910150408745,
0.36109817028045654,
0.3374764025211334,
-0.5775810480117798,
-0.23705747723579407,
-0.5716952681541443,
-0.4437701404094696,
0.5699942708015442,
0.2500828802585602,
0.23431715369224548,
0.09948661923408508,
0.05683548375964165,
-0.18230777978897095,
-0.043987371027469635,
-0.25069329142570496,
0.5456604361534119,
-0.0995819941163063,
-0.4408896863460541,
-0.23696564137935638,
-0.2838994562625885,
0.4437238872051239,
-0.5268648266792297,
-0.4123614430427551,
-0.07411767542362213,
0.022512206807732582,
0.04259888082742691,
-0.5780035257339478,
-0.07208925485610962,
-0.18966175615787506,
-0.18870650231838226,
-0.4679095447063446,
0.47510308027267456,
-0.30430731177330017,
-0.28620532155036926,
0.5205196142196655,
0.7051346302032471,
0.16465073823928833,
-0.167217418551445,
-0.26309168338775635,
0.15383556485176086,
-0.44250959157943726,
-0.316636860370636,
0.34701505303382874,
0.9315742254257202,
-0.020150506868958473,
0.7244160771369934,
0.931061863899231,
0.1512078046798706,
-0.04853039234876633,
-0.21254262328147888,
1.0885533094406128,
-0.7132098078727722,
-0.47017648816108704,
-0.6304869651794434,
0.339566171169281,
-0.4313225746154785,
-0.13022737205028534,
0.4704055190086365,
0.4620663821697235,
0.8699579834938049,
-0.30759307742118835,
0.950417697429657,
-0.3622851073741913,
-0.19400213658809662,
0.019310353323817253,
0.7138293981552124,
-0.7524142265319824,
-0.023873936384916306,
-0.22105926275253296,
-0.8481128215789795,
-0.08480759710073471,
0.7095133662223816,
0.1434846669435501,
0.3147541582584381,
0.5225422978401184,
0.5965690612792969,
-0.19251041114330292,
-0.3667674958705902,
0.7924728989601135,
0.32088467478752136,
0.31227463483810425,
0.6868130564689636,
1.2262678146362305,
0.23210173845291138,
0.604461133480072,
-0.23812822997570038,
-0.08720965683460236,
-0.2392926663160324,
-0.6328833699226379,
-0.9541791677474976,
-0.39277562499046326,
0.10757037997245789,
-0.430420458316803,
0.23744472861289978,
1.2470961809158325,
1.0620325803756714,
-0.23292964696884155,
-0.3803526759147644,
0.1240825355052948,
0.22896775603294373,
-0.41408368945121765,
-0.1900300234556198,
-0.36207884550094604,
-0.13583137094974518,
-0.6873281002044678,
0.3337448835372925,
0.580400824546814,
0.21729932725429535,
-0.26701265573501587,
-0.3008281886577606,
0.010277343913912773,
0.23608604073524475,
0.6645643711090088,
0.44177818298339844,
-0.3715396523475647,
-0.46956583857536316,
-0.012307710014283657,
-0.36903664469718933,
-0.1184505894780159,
0.32330039143562317,
-0.7812132239341736,
0.5562525987625122,
0.06233591213822365,
0.27102652192115784,
0.46870115399360657,
-0.06976326555013657,
0.39674535393714905,
-0.6575043201446533,
0.3935404121875763,
0.0926823616027832,
0.23623700439929962,
-0.06786808371543884,
-0.17532111704349518,
0.547792375087738,
0.25738435983657837,
-0.3101641535758972,
-0.6242308020591736,
0.2749675214290619,
-1.1073873043060303,
-0.28774741291999817,
0.9834931492805481,
-0.06463337689638138,
-0.5858280062675476,
-0.13177959620952606,
-0.45935267210006714,
-0.1524984985589981,
-0.6237621307373047,
0.7917982339859009,
0.7605470418930054,
0.3321846127510071,
-0.3421945869922638,
-0.7256502509117126,
-0.055706676095724106,
0.1494508981704712,
-0.8836476802825928,
-0.14274898171424866,
0.8519451022148132,
0.06316445022821426,
0.45610886812210083,
0.7093012928962708,
0.4543626606464386,
0.3578883707523346,
0.6525558233261108,
0.2963346242904663,
-0.5229300856590271,
-0.8729296326637268,
0.20181769132614136,
0.46996915340423584,
0.054197706282138824,
-0.15222175419330597
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19260v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19260v3
|
NaijaHate: Evaluating Hate Speech Detection on Nigerian Twitter Using Representative Data
| 2024-03-28T09:34:31 | 2024-06-24T05:31:35 |
Manuel Tonneau, Pedro Vitor Quinta de Castro, Karim Lasri, Ibrahim Farouq, Lakshminarayanan Subramanian, Victor Orozco-Olvera, Samuel P. Fraiberger
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
To address the global issue of online hate, hate speech detection (HSD)
systems are typically developed on datasets from the United States, thereby
failing to generalize to English dialects from the Majority World. Furthermore,
HSD models are often evaluated on non-representative samples, raising concerns
about overestimating model performance in real-world settings. In this work, we
introduce NaijaHate, the first dataset annotated for HSD which contains a
representative sample of Nigerian tweets. We demonstrate that HSD evaluated on
biased datasets traditionally used in the literature consistently overestimates
real-world performance by at least two-fold. We then propose NaijaXLM-T, a
pretrained model tailored to the Nigerian Twitter context, and establish the
key role played by domain-adaptive pretraining and finetuning in maximizing HSD
performance. Finally, owing to the modest performance of HSD systems in
real-world conditions, we find that content moderators would need to review
about ten thousand Nigerian tweets flagged as hateful daily to moderate 60% of
all hateful content, highlighting the challenges of moderating hate speech at
scale as social media usage continues to grow globally. Taken together, these
results pave the way towards robust HSD systems and a better protection of
social media users from hateful content in low-resource settings.
|
[
-0.5721426606178284,
-0.7618213891983032,
-0.04610208421945572,
0.28289932012557983,
-0.3327157497406006,
0.3453432619571686,
-0.17210012674331665,
-0.6146654486656189,
0.6425097584724426,
0.5666211247444153,
-0.6703730821609497,
-0.5324129462242126,
-0.9091717004776001,
0.08925917744636536,
-0.5808756351470947,
1.03218674659729,
0.27304840087890625,
-0.21751117706298828,
0.3385240137577057,
-0.25960496068000793,
-0.10641749948263168,
-0.5714374780654907,
-0.5577482581138611,
0.12571841478347778,
0.5067952871322632,
0.14343476295471191,
0.5996993184089661,
0.21592383086681366,
0.20203714072704315,
0.1450963169336319,
-0.016434364020824432,
0.041780706495046616,
-0.7154883742332458,
0.4492257833480835,
-0.11913163214921951,
-0.24275758862495422,
-0.12503384053707123,
0.14173415303230286,
0.47738152742385864,
0.22152413427829742,
-0.24954800307750702,
0.1307125836610794,
0.25815802812576294,
0.03362198546528816,
-0.5503296256065369,
-0.25708940625190735,
-0.6520857214927673,
-0.031119463965296745,
-0.4710138142108917,
0.14270572364330292,
0.01274032797664404,
-0.672490119934082,
0.142607182264328,
-0.641244649887085,
0.24245412647724152,
-0.09254880994558334,
0.6374911665916443,
0.23955124616622925,
-0.2683454751968384,
-0.4906110465526581,
-0.4983993172645569,
0.9839475750923157,
-0.623064398765564,
0.37751370668411255,
0.3638995289802551,
0.610112190246582,
-0.04192729294300079,
-0.363225519657135,
-0.3910292088985443,
-0.3047352433204651,
0.41521552205085754,
0.012719917111098766,
-0.3365212678909302,
-0.19490057229995728,
0.369873046875,
0.46586915850639343,
-0.3606469929218292,
0.22917014360427856,
-0.24173565208911896,
-0.5336216688156128,
0.6972416043281555,
0.029843181371688843,
0.24809713661670685,
-0.2464592456817627,
-0.25561949610710144,
0.08821824938058853,
-0.27381250262260437,
-0.4144390821456909,
0.6524665951728821,
0.6574525833129883,
-0.1096225455403328,
0.13263188302516937,
-0.17555968463420868,
0.40848520398139954,
0.01733328029513359,
-0.39193081855773926,
0.21757201850414276,
0.3096328675746918,
-0.04065440967679024,
0.19753216207027435,
0.8762674331665039,
0.38879522681236267,
0.47160574793815613,
-0.27446040511131287,
-0.3062548339366913,
0.5528674721717834,
0.592710554599762,
-1.0847814083099365,
0.08359309285879135,
0.025121942162513733,
-0.3609665036201477,
-0.5959669351577759,
-0.41953974962234497,
-1.0903151035308838,
-1.001671552658081,
-0.06686367839574814,
0.5097426772117615,
-0.21491853892803192,
-0.3780321478843689,
-0.35611769556999207,
-0.17506223917007446,
-0.30099570751190186,
0.30913251638412476,
-0.5769349932670593,
0.4526326358318329,
0.3515053689479828,
0.7756245136260986,
-0.38367992639541626,
0.29646843671798706,
-0.4345526695251465,
-0.38203567266464233,
-0.14987504482269287,
0.5993125438690186,
-0.45153942704200745,
-0.2639888525009155,
0.19311748445034027,
-0.29346051812171936,
0.23705993592739105,
-0.7312508821487427,
0.9590572714805603,
-0.5162014961242676,
0.050729475915431976,
-0.15573561191558838,
-0.5818321704864502,
0.0018042944138869643,
0.2429802119731903,
-0.5060058236122131,
0.9075900316238403,
0.5973182916641235,
-0.7199416756629944,
0.5795943140983582,
-0.6219532489776611,
-0.43835097551345825,
0.04884824529290199,
0.017701679840683937,
-0.5736806392669678,
0.029491545632481575,
0.30956166982650757,
0.2905510663986206,
-0.3665265738964081,
0.19187337160110474,
-0.6770033240318298,
-0.19741958379745483,
-0.14059245586395264,
-0.26046332716941833,
1.190178632736206,
0.5159007906913757,
-0.46612876653671265,
0.04456895962357521,
-0.7069364786148071,
-0.21018964052200317,
0.14400796592235565,
0.08899398148059845,
-0.4023039937019348,
-0.09136134386062622,
0.6048760414123535,
0.38906586170196533,
-0.2549278438091278,
-1.1014819145202637,
-0.15925630927085876,
-0.26071956753730774,
0.31308647990226746,
0.8502956628799438,
0.04697524011135101,
0.006058517377823591,
-0.28293105959892273,
0.9419047236442566,
-0.06905055046081543,
0.3352689743041992,
0.38990893959999084,
-0.4324062168598175,
-0.25802284479141235,
-0.07236439734697342,
0.25813913345336914,
0.32568302750587463,
-0.9544212222099304,
-0.0633094534277916,
-0.026406047865748405,
-0.4737197160720825,
-0.553797721862793,
0.040722351521253586,
0.2246580570936203,
0.4082029163837433,
0.4655486047267914,
-0.093979611992836,
-1.0131680965423584,
-0.8765132427215576,
-0.44102203845977783,
0.11035487800836563,
-0.029293740168213844,
0.05042154714465141,
0.4653942286968231,
-0.08709792047739029,
0.7711642980575562,
-0.056502796709537506,
-0.5176984667778015,
-0.20662692189216614,
0.17623308300971985,
-0.04888977110385895,
0.16437487304210663,
0.890357494354248,
-0.7577837109565735,
-0.687178909778595,
-0.28066012263298035,
-0.5440518856048584,
-0.6207038760185242,
0.16214251518249512,
-0.10770894587039948,
-0.11839327961206436,
0.2612046003341675,
0.35182592272758484,
0.5233606696128845,
0.6736806035041809,
-0.2533797025680542,
0.4920910894870758,
0.7791510820388794,
0.263608455657959,
-1.0165101289749146,
-0.46221986413002014,
0.14552734792232513,
-0.4639818072319031,
-0.7246789336204529,
0.002952985465526581,
-0.34152939915657043,
-0.06543700397014618,
-0.4031262993812561,
0.4448539614677429,
-0.05301836133003235,
0.12484370917081833,
-0.4340602457523346,
0.1394103765487671,
-0.4245237410068512,
0.1781008094549179,
0.1460665613412857,
0.5973639488220215,
0.46689704060554504,
-0.4983454644680023,
0.3376043438911438,
0.13996097445487976,
-0.7303314805030823,
1.003915786743164,
-0.4415602684020996,
-0.06119479984045029,
0.09678778052330017,
0.07599593698978424,
-0.505286455154419,
-0.31335052847862244,
0.3533913493156433,
-0.4696957767009735,
-0.10205463320016861,
-0.146697998046875,
-0.2972204089164734,
-0.5307375192642212,
-0.14934894442558289,
0.23499760031700134,
0.32818129658699036,
-0.5351804494857788,
0.5426442623138428,
1.0085948705673218,
0.13842137157917023,
-0.4751146137714386,
-0.4838953912258148,
0.21726489067077637,
-0.34469592571258545,
-0.48763930797576904,
0.38595831394195557,
0.08671514689922333,
-0.17559048533439636,
-0.22503256797790527,
-0.22630846500396729,
-0.2837746739387512,
0.27805638313293457,
0.5097780823707581,
-0.3165558874607086,
-0.22016245126724243,
-0.10110008716583252,
0.08881206810474396,
0.3465082049369812,
0.20459456741809845,
-0.17997387051582336,
0.5871874690055847,
0.24020467698574066,
0.18831364810466766,
-0.5106545090675354,
0.3313082456588745,
0.2226434350013733,
0.220576211810112,
0.8233435153961182,
0.8035695552825928,
-0.5393831133842468,
-0.49470922350883484,
-0.5767086148262024,
-0.16012683510780334,
-0.3174028694629669,
0.19425319135189056,
-0.09309371560811996,
-0.9396371245384216,
0.4829773008823395,
0.30254223942756653,
0.09337873756885529,
0.23531612753868103,
0.42695266008377075,
-0.03817671164870262,
0.6262240409851074,
0.3919762074947357,
-0.026752235367894173,
0.5675965547561646,
-0.18917308747768402,
0.09087955951690674,
-0.6652214527130127,
0.09462492167949677,
-0.7050776481628418,
-0.33088433742523193,
-0.8487275242805481,
-0.15309058129787445,
0.3149632513523102,
-0.2729800045490265,
-0.17715415358543396,
0.4455067217350006,
-0.2932239770889282,
0.39662501215934753,
0.27084478735923767,
0.2563256621360779,
-0.07562705874443054,
0.24103660881519318,
0.15689949691295624,
-0.3456927239894867,
-0.5521100163459778,
-0.40863871574401855,
1.1559715270996094,
0.1497878134250641,
0.4783792793750763,
-0.05055634304881096,
0.7575646042823792,
0.6058564186096191,
0.8916147351264954,
-0.6392984390258789,
0.1513538658618927,
-0.21142438054084778,
-0.8861870765686035,
-0.22894254326820374,
-0.5475637912750244,
-0.7103359699249268,
0.3555029034614563,
-0.2487090826034546,
-0.5537952780723572,
0.36152002215385437,
0.14718283712863922,
-0.37862199544906616,
0.5339577198028564,
-0.25397592782974243,
0.7591533660888672,
0.10481312870979309,
-0.457485556602478,
-0.10508295893669128,
-0.29621702432632446,
0.5040013194084167,
-0.21495400369167328,
0.5259982347488403,
-0.14195537567138672,
0.07492560148239136,
1.2971599102020264,
-0.40049147605895996,
0.6489772200584412,
-0.5589624047279358,
-0.21476759016513824,
0.3433845043182373,
0.09592912346124649,
-0.02767590619623661,
-0.3184167742729187,
-0.5034464001655579,
0.4379318952560425,
-0.2391568422317505,
-0.4687668979167938,
-0.4074520170688629,
0.7330491542816162,
-0.564342737197876,
-0.29247885942459106,
-0.41570141911506653,
-0.31831490993499756,
-0.4457768499851227,
0.17464159429073334,
0.3934442400932312,
0.575117290019989,
-0.4796348214149475,
0.4561389982700348,
0.47541502118110657,
-0.1547490954399109,
0.04894927889108658,
0.15405532717704773,
-0.45016151666641235,
-0.3703722059726715,
0.714573860168457,
0.3410379886627197,
0.25598809123039246,
-0.028983578085899353,
0.10622306168079376,
-0.46051228046417236,
-0.5099185109138489,
-0.4749792516231537,
-0.1300651729106903,
-0.29403749108314514,
-0.2455011010169983,
-0.698766827583313,
0.16165262460708618,
-0.4790014624595642,
-0.03271600976586342,
-0.36084792017936707,
-0.3821321427822113,
0.033477120101451874,
0.10516509413719177,
0.1657722443342209,
0.7125640511512756,
-0.3741323947906494,
0.7767030000686646,
-0.1360112428665161,
0.9517313838005066,
0.1382722407579422,
0.4071683883666992,
-0.09192425012588501,
-1.0615452527999878,
-0.23408329486846924,
0.39219534397125244,
-0.5473436117172241,
-1.0657093524932861,
0.48508793115615845,
-0.009474107064306736,
0.34348177909851074,
0.3598007261753082,
0.4212747812271118,
0.6333478093147278,
-0.10164815932512283,
0.4869832396507263,
-0.12890225648880005,
-0.6579918265342712,
0.5411913990974426,
-0.32187023758888245,
-0.09287497401237488,
0.544437050819397,
0.7402614951133728,
-0.5130331516265869,
-0.6763115525245667,
-0.5413655638694763,
-0.20658081769943237,
0.8499327898025513,
0.444682240486145,
0.12508347630500793,
-0.17824193835258484,
-0.024866143241524696,
0.05147546902298927,
0.2823359966278076,
-0.5543166995048523,
-0.3592302203178406,
-0.49483343958854675,
-0.0033198297023773193,
0.11040335893630981,
-0.3180276155471802,
0.2674146890640259,
-0.13458706438541412,
0.8284658789634705,
0.3770127594470978,
0.089507095515728,
-0.015529409050941467,
-0.22267018258571625,
-0.08088444173336029,
0.15188470482826233,
0.3154171109199524,
0.5501130819320679,
-0.4941215515136719,
-0.486746221780777,
-0.2183595448732376,
-0.6623305082321167,
0.10456410050392151,
-0.19369389116764069,
-0.3446044921875,
0.26261430978775024,
0.142793670296669,
0.7983070611953735,
0.10520395636558533,
-0.3198535740375519,
0.5246599912643433,
-0.10819803178310394,
-0.31212252378463745,
-0.16543377935886383,
0.0692284107208252,
-0.24878840148448944,
-0.15546788275241852,
0.3391994535923004,
0.15725529193878174,
0.28389760851860046,
-0.5600451231002808,
0.2714209258556366,
0.28252625465393066,
-0.5881468057632446,
-0.17247794568538666,
0.7506784796714783,
0.252545028924942,
-0.32867082953453064,
0.4336962103843689,
-0.31084540486335754,
-0.8619784712791443,
0.6368218064308167,
0.5216578841209412,
0.728339672088623,
-0.8158034086227417,
0.4984355866909027,
0.5590360760688782,
0.49557754397392273,
0.3164769411087036,
0.22475329041481018,
-0.1221940889954567,
-0.8245364427566528,
-0.360050767660141,
-1.0214295387268066,
-0.20338906347751617,
0.4405827224254608,
-0.9385572671890259,
0.195443257689476,
-0.7903433442115784,
-0.3124507665634155,
0.11565674841403961,
0.019443852826952934,
-0.44458210468292236,
0.5033354163169861,
0.29409733414649963,
0.6258876919746399,
-0.9331381320953369,
0.5383572578430176,
0.14839547872543335,
0.016894707456231117,
-0.27369415760040283,
-0.11475257575511932,
0.17684990167617798,
-0.6561965942382812,
0.34491074085235596,
0.2803390622138977,
-0.18748469650745392,
-0.15064997971057892,
-0.5811001658439636,
-0.28770920634269714,
0.18441927433013916,
0.3125455677509308,
-0.519990861415863,
0.5650804042816162,
0.10577469319105148,
0.7181607484817505,
-0.39129215478897095,
0.2993936538696289,
0.5727314352989197,
0.3506663143634796,
-0.007447647862136364,
-0.881628155708313,
-0.06268587708473206,
-0.09411861002445221,
-0.01623908244073391,
0.35085898637771606,
-0.34602394700050354,
0.7025735378265381,
0.092899851500988,
-0.49420180916786194,
-0.20821431279182434,
0.6083515882492065,
-0.20441046357154846,
0.31536543369293213,
0.6069137454032898,
0.5474010705947876,
0.633177638053894,
-0.09266713261604309,
1.2011332511901855,
0.18205147981643677,
0.10257694125175476,
1.1416618824005127,
-0.15408065915107727,
0.5008503198623657,
0.04503725469112396,
-0.2797452211380005,
0.40361902117729187,
0.3670105040073395,
0.15556909143924713,
0.44858619570732117,
0.3256520926952362,
-0.30404576659202576,
-0.39084041118621826,
-0.5966298580169678,
-0.40820810198783875,
0.44281628727912903,
0.544879138469696,
-0.14821557700634003,
-0.5484126806259155,
0.4914724826812744,
-0.045309100300073624,
0.5643095374107361,
-0.4976382553577423,
0.5116258263587952,
-0.010794572532176971,
-0.09254235774278641,
0.7571224570274353,
0.049757540225982666,
0.8561076521873474,
-0.24597826600074768,
0.07694993913173676,
-0.13429874181747437,
-0.030049018561840057,
-0.1761966049671173,
-0.5380921363830566,
0.6979183554649353,
0.3597414791584015,
-0.051719654351472855,
-0.2581380009651184,
0.36987805366516113,
-0.12193841487169266,
-0.2714063823223114,
0.4379551112651825,
0.023423250764608383,
0.13034795224666595,
-0.7238753437995911,
-0.7844743728637695,
0.3778790533542633,
0.13300025463104248,
0.1128196194767952,
0.40408867597579956,
0.13910126686096191,
-0.31741851568222046,
0.51924067735672,
0.5480000972747803,
0.12201975286006927,
0.1679450273513794,
0.2866731286048889,
0.6845870614051819,
-0.4597488343715668,
-0.6222646236419678,
-0.5718182325363159,
-0.21380513906478882,
-0.3202361762523651,
-0.6154789924621582,
0.8173828125,
0.5252957940101624,
1.0900236368179321,
0.08641345798969269,
0.8424674272537231,
-0.2280597686767578,
1.2347384691238403,
-0.14073504507541656,
0.5306221842765808,
-0.444367378950119,
-0.09089003503322601,
-0.3656698763370514,
-0.9293019771575928,
-0.3581339716911316,
0.8817077279090881,
-0.4965483546257019,
-0.06571637839078903,
0.3600076138973236,
0.8593159914016724,
-0.20254138112068176,
0.40175801515579224,
0.4469546377658844,
0.6889845132827759,
0.3987007141113281,
0.2498006671667099,
0.8392859101295471,
-0.8244999647140503,
0.4070875346660614,
-0.615784227848053,
-0.14933103322982788,
-0.16867664456367493,
-0.6638197302818298,
-1.0059089660644531,
-0.40544214844703674,
-0.3417128026485443,
-0.4970453679561615,
0.2276739478111267,
0.9439080953598022,
0.694122314453125,
-1.2156825065612793,
-0.28873443603515625,
0.35421597957611084,
0.23244912922382355,
0.0031819187570363283,
-0.2627738416194916,
0.030071523040533066,
0.08385895937681198,
-0.6546258926391602,
0.23961539566516876,
-0.0224208515137434,
-0.33511531352996826,
-0.024771342054009438,
0.08713888376951218,
-0.17029103636741638,
-0.026538603007793427,
0.7283845543861389,
0.21314625442028046,
-0.6139546632766724,
0.0852193534374237,
-0.33980637788772583,
-0.01392863318324089,
0.12402000278234482,
0.5974231362342834,
-0.7937847375869751,
0.2598543167114258,
0.01662047579884529,
0.524182140827179,
0.3926275372505188,
0.17573517560958862,
0.039867620915174484,
-0.5525857210159302,
0.16225898265838623,
0.47564375400543213,
0.007763618603348732,
0.3593451678752899,
0.027381641790270805,
0.28035879135131836,
0.1921602487564087,
-0.3616867959499359,
-0.9369027018547058,
0.045145273208618164,
-0.8375927209854126,
-0.02493516355752945,
0.8760638236999512,
0.08272181451320648,
-0.3065216839313507,
-0.5201534628868103,
-0.2891555726528168,
0.1456584930419922,
-0.8194154500961304,
0.9391010999679565,
0.6717475652694702,
0.37329375743865967,
0.073394775390625,
-0.74396812915802,
0.56731778383255,
0.01565457135438919,
-0.7208604216575623,
-0.0449163056910038,
0.6445879936218262,
0.24722197651863098,
0.11965847760438919,
0.47142717242240906,
0.04385188966989517,
0.38272103667259216,
-0.022502144798636436,
-0.07286208122968674,
0.10010063648223877,
-0.2004595547914505,
-0.13381439447402954,
0.3645192086696625,
-0.615746259689331,
-0.027322111651301384
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19259v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19259v1
|
J-CRe3: A Japanese Conversation Dataset for Real-world Reference Resolution
| 2024-03-28T09:32:43 | 2024-03-28T09:32:43 |
Nobuhiro Ueda, Hideko Habe, Yoko Matsui, Akishige Yuguchi, Seiya Kawano, Yasutomo Kawanishi, Sadao Kurohashi, Koichiro Yoshino
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Understanding expressions that refer to the physical world is crucial for
such human-assisting systems in the real world, as robots that must perform
actions that are expected by users. In real-world reference resolution, a
system must ground the verbal information that appears in user interactions to
the visual information observed in egocentric views. To this end, we propose a
multimodal reference resolution task and construct a Japanese Conversation
dataset for Real-world Reference Resolution (J-CRe3). Our dataset contains
egocentric video and dialogue audio of real-world conversations between two
people acting as a master and an assistant robot at home. The dataset is
annotated with crossmodal tags between phrases in the utterances and the object
bounding boxes in the video frames. These tags include indirect reference
relations, such as predicate-argument structures and bridging references as
well as direct reference relations. We also constructed an experimental model
and clarified the challenges in multimodal reference resolution tasks.
|
[
-0.515482485294342,
-0.8189014196395874,
0.5412301421165466,
-0.07636626064777374,
-0.09900683909654617,
-0.13307972252368927,
-0.36477136611938477,
-0.863395631313324,
0.17901702225208282,
0.5418977737426758,
-0.7775081396102905,
-0.3007715940475464,
-0.4395647346973419,
0.2645357847213745,
0.08864370733499527,
0.35662633180618286,
-0.28525760769844055,
0.17257757484912872,
-0.37370458245277405,
-0.34851357340812683,
-0.7406399250030518,
-0.5160365104675293,
-0.17855697870254517,
-0.21704937517642975,
0.5047869086265564,
0.7957668900489807,
0.942451536655426,
0.6458218693733215,
0.7469632029533386,
0.38239529728889465,
0.8061311841011047,
0.20470745861530304,
-0.0920647606253624,
0.42847204208374023,
-0.3774988353252411,
-0.6161251664161682,
-0.535507082939148,
0.00633143400773406,
0.4253367483615875,
0.6498315930366516,
0.21296492218971252,
0.21744410693645477,
0.009022481739521027,
0.5008801817893982,
-0.5784663558006287,
0.47235140204429626,
-0.24990242719650269,
0.20334607362747192,
-0.15654200315475464,
-0.19689680635929108,
-0.2561618983745575,
0.07986956834793091,
0.13369522988796234,
-0.9681857824325562,
0.3454870879650116,
0.09815859794616699,
1.3247978687286377,
0.3611675500869751,
-0.1842072308063507,
-0.08541025966405869,
-1.124627947807312,
0.49036622047424316,
-0.3072706460952759,
0.6126856207847595,
0.537749707698822,
0.6036693453788757,
0.14088982343673706,
-0.41085827350616455,
-0.8587261438369751,
-0.06727883964776993,
-0.21885180473327637,
0.3055722713470459,
-0.03714734688401222,
0.18238094449043274,
0.3463614583015442,
-0.11035948991775513,
-0.5412610173225403,
-0.4368612766265869,
-0.2691909968852997,
-0.23735825717449188,
0.35144665837287903,
0.22214068472385406,
0.2041340172290802,
-0.3644787073135376,
-0.15540455281734467,
-0.3367757499217987,
-0.31162676215171814,
-0.5245996713638306,
0.24860723316669464,
0.2937372326850891,
-0.10267031192779541,
0.5636518597602844,
-0.24930308759212494,
0.7714250683784485,
0.042543280869722366,
-0.4374317228794098,
0.28272300958633423,
-0.576248049736023,
0.0016741763101890683,
-0.25937193632125854,
0.7231470942497253,
0.8310858607292175,
0.49302464723587036,
-0.04668938368558884,
0.3884686529636383,
0.07133276015520096,
0.5277791023254395,
-0.5262615084648132,
-0.15542270243167877,
-0.08989507704973221,
-0.27815043926239014,
0.49323245882987976,
0.25311723351478577,
-0.8337399363517761,
-0.03303460776805878,
-0.6320086717605591,
0.4312693178653717,
-0.19891303777694702,
-0.12609270215034485,
-0.0739385262131691,
-0.022165905684232712,
-0.09142644703388214,
0.5299112796783447,
-0.2951241731643677,
0.2736376225948334,
0.11256520450115204,
0.60506671667099,
0.550110936164856,
-0.16067065298557281,
-0.08920945972204208,
0.6348423957824707,
-0.08821535855531693,
0.6650499105453491,
-0.6332283616065979,
-0.5597891807556152,
-0.06928884238004684,
0.20725120604038239,
0.022076215595006943,
-0.5667144060134888,
0.5314614176750183,
-0.18968422710895538,
0.5008142590522766,
-0.025442736223340034,
0.06472578644752502,
-0.38747695088386536,
0.5451410412788391,
-0.5607243776321411,
0.5273398160934448,
-0.03656166046857834,
-0.32220354676246643,
0.03780471906065941,
-0.6437955498695374,
-0.07064048200845718,
0.15583227574825287,
-0.4316839575767517,
-0.17646564543247223,
-0.4720757305622101,
0.1253780573606491,
0.6599141359329224,
-0.35489487648010254,
0.2423102855682373,
-0.4585448205471039,
0.11648644506931305,
0.15945278108119965,
-0.41526901721954346,
0.0031064075883477926,
0.20878270268440247,
-0.008663293905556202,
-0.32223135232925415,
-0.7456809878349304,
-0.03263811394572258,
0.23777590692043304,
0.28025105595588684,
-0.5960283279418945,
-0.032938335090875626,
-0.37604865431785583,
0.37094831466674805,
0.39473551511764526,
-0.6619841456413269,
0.05930526554584503,
0.11278984695672989,
-0.05926337465643883,
0.3385161757469177,
0.07638438791036606,
0.23647016286849976,
-0.18355101346969604,
0.5174636244773865,
0.18195199966430664,
0.2960537075996399,
-0.48085254430770874,
-0.4823099672794342,
-0.7793984413146973,
0.02886735275387764,
0.06892354786396027,
0.6533105373382568,
-0.8942177891731262,
0.40035662055015564,
-0.717890202999115,
-0.43880370259284973,
-0.5198777318000793,
-0.011124765500426292,
0.67299485206604,
0.6462711095809937,
0.43366286158561707,
-0.33428555727005005,
-0.7457643151283264,
-1.4125250577926636,
-0.08336028456687927,
-0.45872095227241516,
-0.21791428327560425,
0.8271274566650391,
0.17994053661823273,
-0.09796980768442154,
1.0330893993377686,
-0.5085902810096741,
-0.6997747421264648,
0.02711348980665207,
0.156542107462883,
0.012476670555770397,
0.45843929052352905,
0.27371591329574585,
-0.938817024230957,
-0.34754079580307007,
0.03474817052483559,
-0.9129525423049927,
-0.07284584641456604,
-0.2466040849685669,
-0.2902347147464752,
-0.3158246874809265,
0.4044533967971802,
-0.33422425389289856,
0.22806844115257263,
0.45855972170829773,
-0.008558617904782295,
0.17885617911815643,
0.0015863559674471617,
0.5903311967849731,
-1.1438599824905396,
0.08392971754074097,
0.564612627029419,
-0.5879546403884888,
-0.4355662763118744,
0.026055922731757164,
-0.14280907809734344,
-0.25708240270614624,
-0.3460639715194702,
0.31853097677230835,
-0.4687783122062683,
-0.18141406774520874,
-0.009476181119680405,
0.7984246015548706,
0.2516471743583679,
0.7323005199432373,
0.5237458348274231,
0.6000069975852966,
0.11360061913728714,
-0.4943418502807617,
0.4894535541534424,
0.40924960374832153,
-0.14633773267269135,
0.9576774835586548,
-0.3656226396560669,
0.16224278509616852,
-0.07001564651727676,
0.4349208176136017,
-0.9350771903991699,
-0.5513953566551208,
0.6672571301460266,
-0.650489091873169,
0.07364602386951447,
-0.18511974811553955,
-0.6158552765846252,
-0.27563172578811646,
0.017509758472442627,
0.5781933665275574,
-0.10544463992118835,
-0.32631880044937134,
0.8046370148658752,
0.5385613441467285,
-0.3339747190475464,
-0.3309350609779358,
-0.6558252573013306,
0.1624699831008911,
-0.004479617811739445,
-0.5470584034919739,
0.5991932153701782,
0.01937549188733101,
-0.2295851707458496,
0.10788638144731522,
0.1347716748714447,
-0.13833963871002197,
-0.35961616039276123,
0.4475395381450653,
0.6501774191856384,
-0.055345937609672546,
-0.28257808089256287,
-0.3209601640701294,
-0.2063562124967575,
0.2568764388561249,
0.5925177335739136,
0.4588540494441986,
-0.03138898313045502,
-0.5315789580345154,
-0.7945433855056763,
0.36951208114624023,
0.3017154037952423,
0.4469691514968872,
0.29208579659461975,
0.47068825364112854,
-0.5008664131164551,
0.5592656135559082,
-0.5913068652153015,
-0.005855242721736431,
-0.4516593813896179,
0.6404024958610535,
-0.79081791639328,
-0.48058080673217773,
0.4434331953525543,
-0.1158713772892952,
0.09621237218379974,
0.13509824872016907,
0.5146169662475586,
-0.2244230955839157,
1.203752875328064,
0.2228897511959076,
0.2095913141965866,
0.5465277433395386,
-0.11110636591911316,
0.3607340455055237,
-1.0727667808532715,
-0.5138583183288574,
-0.6929045915603638,
-0.38505086302757263,
-0.1767326295375824,
-0.7583701610565186,
0.5186690092086792,
-0.045701149851083755,
-0.15796741843223572,
0.7339470982551575,
-0.2490428239107132,
0.5409836173057556,
0.22783784568309784,
0.234025776386261,
0.44979509711265564,
-0.2549077570438385,
0.13410671055316925,
-0.5046023726463318,
-0.41762101650238037,
-0.6666678190231323,
0.47584983706474304,
0.3960804045200348,
0.7104746103286743,
0.20609121024608612,
0.15812934935092926,
0.3083663284778595,
0.3200061321258545,
-0.8050385117530823,
0.8103309869766235,
0.1866161823272705,
-0.6952658891677856,
0.14859096705913544,
-0.3681308925151825,
-0.9507570266723633,
0.24938932061195374,
-0.08864931017160416,
-0.7157384157180786,
0.21794673800468445,
0.16040924191474915,
-0.21480320394039154,
0.11526560038328171,
-0.6905210018157959,
0.7540857195854187,
0.043304443359375,
-0.5900393724441528,
-0.3985174000263214,
-0.9779702425003052,
0.4590371251106262,
0.4475317895412445,
0.4471960961818695,
-0.26150500774383545,
0.053744908422231674,
0.7711821794509888,
-0.10381662100553513,
0.9837530851364136,
-0.24287471175193787,
-0.10201259702444077,
0.2445678859949112,
0.34442758560180664,
0.21291452646255493,
0.2528108060359955,
0.3798229396343231,
0.25095194578170776,
0.028920864686369896,
-0.19403189420700073,
-0.7398384213447571,
0.7446727752685547,
-1.0588223934173584,
-0.5029225945472717,
-0.30113884806632996,
-0.4274387061595917,
-0.573756992816925,
-0.021075313910841942,
-0.09622356295585632,
0.5645869970321655,
-0.2339649498462677,
0.10945972800254822,
0.18233031034469604,
0.07344470918178558,
0.09414355456829071,
0.7405165433883667,
-0.28206345438957214,
-0.3916320502758026,
0.8183432221412659,
0.22331556677818298,
0.36033663153648376,
0.4840371310710907,
-0.32648834586143494,
-0.21292755007743835,
0.2973181903362274,
-0.6640943288803101,
0.3737550377845764,
-0.7619922161102295,
-0.4476458430290222,
-0.5372973680496216,
-0.005330386571586132,
-0.18848860263824463,
-0.15579326450824738,
-0.48839375376701355,
-0.3430800437927246,
-0.17401041090488434,
0.11242064088582993,
0.0689624771475792,
0.5232731699943542,
-0.052052393555641174,
0.29432958364486694,
-1.154140830039978,
0.7258173823356628,
0.17137114703655243,
0.21492931246757507,
-0.22006914019584656,
-0.4341863989830017,
-0.5913193821907043,
0.3572027087211609,
-0.5225548148155212,
-0.6975640654563904,
0.32691097259521484,
0.11766022443771362,
0.49777844548225403,
0.12053722143173218,
-0.07207318395376205,
1.4187235832214355,
-0.3642484247684479,
1.0677238702774048,
0.21957240998744965,
-0.6897090077400208,
0.5618196129798889,
-0.3393630385398865,
0.2610616385936737,
0.5566878318786621,
0.5708878636360168,
-0.8371007442474365,
-0.34587562084198,
-0.8300825953483582,
-0.7594656348228455,
0.6995537877082825,
-0.09443612396717072,
0.12479043006896973,
-0.07493773102760315,
0.39561980962753296,
0.0037396710831671953,
-0.07985542714595795,
-0.7082050442695618,
-0.29306620359420776,
-0.20829415321350098,
-0.23959924280643463,
0.10496627539396286,
0.2444065511226654,
-0.22071407735347748,
-0.06427226960659027,
0.6195743083953857,
-0.24143390357494354,
0.7176145911216736,
0.435963898897171,
-0.255953848361969,
-0.41465631127357483,
0.07201283425092697,
0.3547394573688507,
0.2566136121749878,
-0.20095577836036682,
0.02151135914027691,
-0.0390070416033268,
-0.33395087718963623,
0.04806144908070564,
-0.21178197860717773,
0.39757606387138367,
0.16100141406059265,
0.3772614896297455,
0.5857911705970764,
0.18167729675769806,
-0.823763370513916,
0.4209778904914856,
-0.2711249887943268,
-0.1859564185142517,
-0.627958357334137,
0.1358029991388321,
-0.23758308589458466,
0.004334484692662954,
0.23739728331565857,
0.5545814633369446,
0.10691732168197632,
-0.7009376287460327,
0.13386759161949158,
0.22021082043647766,
-0.4696529507637024,
-0.5819385647773743,
0.5159894227981567,
0.509919285774231,
-0.3991360366344452,
0.5533486604690552,
0.07096876204013824,
-0.4047539532184601,
0.31466004252433777,
0.5640026926994324,
0.5676109194755554,
-0.07792630046606064,
-0.02775292843580246,
0.7844852805137634,
-0.10502291470766068,
0.12136129289865494,
0.11546500027179718,
-0.2854529619216919,
-1.2455661296844482,
-0.4698403775691986,
0.06192640960216522,
-0.8454893827438354,
0.06732508540153503,
-1.0624463558197021,
0.2527938485145569,
-0.47841691970825195,
-0.30125051736831665,
-0.17809569835662842,
-0.12148062139749527,
-0.8638598918914795,
0.2660170793533325,
0.31404027342796326,
0.3036639988422394,
-0.8089486956596375,
0.787146806716919,
0.6100258231163025,
-0.28282251954078674,
-0.545850396156311,
0.004088892135769129,
-0.027041107416152954,
-0.8325113654136658,
0.7750653624534607,
0.07813155651092529,
-0.45042380690574646,
-0.05650718882679939,
-0.5026584267616272,
-0.7924250960350037,
0.9778091907501221,
0.1671203076839447,
-0.8109135031700134,
0.067278653383255,
0.12049296498298645,
0.42678403854370117,
-0.4610966742038727,
0.5450677871704102,
0.4287089407444,
0.6722861528396606,
-0.2694687247276306,
-1.1079823970794678,
-0.2100886106491089,
-0.5123794674873352,
0.013568339869379997,
0.32630038261413574,
-1.0713708400726318,
0.040792517364025116,
0.047570403665304184,
-0.30437636375427246,
0.06030973047018051,
0.8807512521743774,
0.1772419959306717,
0.015080043114721775,
0.6782422065734863,
0.45550337433815,
0.15615753829479218,
-0.09334266185760498,
0.8227765560150146,
-0.33270925283432007,
0.11301156878471375,
1.3020029067993164,
-0.5951530933380127,
0.7190914750099182,
0.4734245836734772,
-0.3088114261627197,
0.722545325756073,
0.23366568982601166,
0.1906467229127884,
0.2628473937511444,
-0.37196898460388184,
-0.2579817771911621,
-0.32678356766700745,
-0.47794657945632935,
-0.1892147809267044,
0.4068986475467682,
0.8637290000915527,
-0.143252894282341,
-0.17438660562038422,
0.38866329193115234,
-0.013705446384847164,
0.47776520252227783,
-0.011801110580563545,
0.8504400253295898,
-0.38388991355895996,
-0.8387580513954163,
0.15409258008003235,
-0.06133553758263588,
0.4185815453529358,
-0.6170426607131958,
-0.32718154788017273,
0.20010125637054443,
0.23414169251918793,
-0.10613038390874863,
-0.9200699329376221,
0.5125971436500549,
0.008313702419400215,
-0.22563646733760834,
-0.2625451385974884,
0.4504966139793396,
-0.5083354115486145,
-0.19545452296733856,
0.31360673904418945,
0.466891884803772,
0.38024255633354187,
0.3989376425743103,
-0.8761928677558899,
0.025818824768066406,
0.08305209875106812,
-0.21250024437904358,
0.41257864236831665,
0.3731285333633423,
-0.02869354747235775,
0.7363169193267822,
0.31624290347099304,
-0.049495879560709,
-0.060669463127851486,
0.23023980855941772,
0.6815075874328613,
-0.6042300462722778,
-0.012517476454377174,
-0.49122872948646545,
0.22968615591526031,
-0.046342942863702774,
-0.36152225732803345,
0.5815991163253784,
0.5201679468154907,
1.0592820644378662,
-0.04269443824887276,
0.8965759873390198,
-0.4053570032119751,
0.8847612738609314,
-0.3958001434803009,
-0.3320128321647644,
-0.48971378803253174,
-0.09675463289022446,
-0.31329774856567383,
-0.750938355922699,
-0.5947856903076172,
1.165428638458252,
-0.20455634593963623,
0.0466415211558342,
0.556642472743988,
0.9697286486625671,
-0.131818488240242,
0.03303556889295578,
0.4454178512096405,
0.19414468109607697,
0.4682424068450928,
0.42040127515792847,
0.8057739734649658,
-0.7257989048957825,
0.6245967149734497,
-0.651415228843689,
0.0901636853814125,
-0.1156710758805275,
-0.6193445324897766,
-0.4628763794898987,
-0.8984715938568115,
-0.5432449579238892,
-0.42008182406425476,
0.007291609887033701,
1.3003251552581787,
0.8334181308746338,
-0.3540825843811035,
-0.19529356062412262,
0.27755066752433777,
-0.3905293047428131,
-0.24811169505119324,
-0.35485318303108215,
-0.19289261102676392,
-0.05544038489460945,
-1.2260403633117676,
0.33895230293273926,
0.32211872935295105,
-0.04529294744133949,
-0.4866318702697754,
-0.07741881161928177,
-0.1714353710412979,
-0.2034858912229538,
0.4127032458782196,
0.3824169635772705,
-0.5944610834121704,
-0.7008999586105347,
-0.3146984577178955,
-0.028689531609416008,
0.4664228856563568,
0.9443861246109009,
-0.9395235180854797,
0.5578930377960205,
0.2881564795970917,
0.17945097386837006,
0.42117536067962646,
0.4318721294403076,
0.7907131314277649,
-0.9699671864509583,
0.43699342012405396,
0.3507317006587982,
0.5304225087165833,
0.3848089277744293,
-0.270868718624115,
0.5981679558753967,
0.3282518982887268,
-0.6627350449562073,
-0.46090584993362427,
0.30028560757637024,
-1.2851170301437378,
-0.10472327470779419,
0.8062052726745605,
-0.37724769115448,
-0.35352417826652527,
-0.5072066187858582,
-0.6121320724487305,
0.3286401033401489,
-0.4509669542312622,
0.43145763874053955,
0.8667535781860352,
-0.3056526780128479,
-0.38242074847221375,
-0.7891718149185181,
-0.0935341864824295,
0.2600664496421814,
-0.6553769707679749,
0.2617715895175934,
0.7020421028137207,
-0.11354450136423111,
0.7807369828224182,
0.5945293307304382,
-0.19425068795681,
0.24410690367221832,
-0.006107238586992025,
0.3253585398197174,
0.020624153316020966,
-0.5627741813659668,
0.27510249614715576,
0.22016578912734985,
0.0038769140373915434,
-0.3550201654434204
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19727v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19727v1
|
New Semantic Task for the French Spoken Language Understanding MEDIA Benchmark
| 2024-03-28T08:40:02 | 2024-03-28T08:40:02 |
Nadège Alavoine, Gaëlle Laperriere, Christophe Servan, Sahar Ghannay, Sophie Rosset
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Intent classification and slot-filling are essential tasks of Spoken Language
Understanding (SLU). In most SLUsystems, those tasks are realized by
independent modules. For about fifteen years, models achieving both of
themjointly and exploiting their mutual enhancement have been proposed. A
multilingual module using a joint modelwas envisioned to create a touristic
dialogue system for a European project, HumanE-AI-Net. A combination ofmultiple
datasets, including the MEDIA dataset, was suggested for training this joint
model. The MEDIA SLU datasetis a French dataset distributed since 2005 by ELRA,
mainly used by the French research community and free foracademic research
since 2020. Unfortunately, it is annotated only in slots but not intents. An
enhanced version ofMEDIA annotated with intents has been built to extend its
use to more tasks and use cases. This paper presents thesemi-automatic
methodology used to obtain this enhanced version. In addition, we present the
first results of SLUexperiments on this enhanced dataset using joint models for
intent classification and slot-filling.
|
[
-0.5903267860412598,
-0.47382262349128723,
0.3938877582550049,
0.032382216304540634,
0.03485405817627907,
-0.33778804540634155,
-0.4962378740310669,
-0.4125278890132904,
0.11651583760976791,
0.7620545029640198,
-0.6277956962585449,
-0.40730994939804077,
-0.539092481136322,
-0.09434329718351364,
-0.24370694160461426,
0.587983250617981,
-0.18900348246097565,
0.1612747609615326,
-0.03147195652127266,
-0.6486618518829346,
-0.6212075352668762,
-0.28542229533195496,
-0.6870319843292236,
-0.26198264956474304,
0.5457752346992493,
0.618169367313385,
0.5832342505455017,
0.21915023028850555,
0.3252454996109009,
0.3253967761993408,
0.21168191730976105,
0.3874223530292511,
-0.46968045830726624,
-0.2556900978088379,
-0.16459345817565918,
-0.2521241307258606,
-0.4234997630119324,
0.2147892266511917,
0.6732900142669678,
0.7984686493873596,
-0.030292300507426262,
0.03746770694851875,
0.1751595288515091,
0.5155846476554871,
-0.5968067646026611,
0.35922569036483765,
-0.48825928568840027,
-0.06141440197825432,
0.08201645314693451,
-0.33909541368484497,
-0.5064675211906433,
0.034065891057252884,
0.16040605306625366,
-0.712918758392334,
0.07945393770933151,
-0.181575208902359,
0.8080230355262756,
0.3063564598560333,
-0.41825515031814575,
-0.18974526226520538,
-0.7788053750991821,
0.8600022792816162,
-0.4447264075279236,
0.7231695652008057,
0.5634583830833435,
0.24367143213748932,
-0.08447612822055817,
-0.5547361969947815,
-0.6604411602020264,
-0.050427187234163284,
-0.19657571613788605,
0.14079800248146057,
-0.11946635693311691,
0.009522476233541965,
0.24776194989681244,
0.15143683552742004,
-0.6413713097572327,
0.2588057816028595,
-0.4774125814437866,
-0.1848851889371872,
0.861351728439331,
-0.09939121454954147,
0.37832775712013245,
-0.12527939677238464,
-0.38741347193717957,
-0.0652959793806076,
-0.6827104687690735,
0.08999445289373398,
0.14103728532791138,
0.19031643867492676,
-0.07802704721689224,
0.5942480564117432,
-0.36968788504600525,
0.9027790427207947,
-0.44996362924575806,
-0.09935616701841354,
0.4625296890735626,
-0.19765004515647888,
-0.22021225094795227,
0.12229128926992416,
0.5223923325538635,
0.5205697417259216,
0.3392578959465027,
-0.0803467258810997,
-0.35202497243881226,
0.04181231930851936,
0.07157880067825317,
-0.29331174492836,
-0.02106490544974804,
0.22946706414222717,
-0.20871031284332275,
0.20681248605251312,
-0.005176431033760309,
-0.02996627241373062,
-0.06198849156498909,
-0.6210371851921082,
0.5421116352081299,
-0.3801347315311432,
-0.386795312166214,
0.4586150348186493,
-0.014846334233880043,
0.17408150434494019,
0.7517234683036804,
-0.5124027729034424,
0.3333168625831604,
0.6912519335746765,
0.7138783931732178,
-0.37248891592025757,
-0.3346812129020691,
-0.7670420408248901,
0.2206975668668747,
0.018493250012397766,
0.9719969034194946,
-0.46662309765815735,
-0.33393919467926025,
0.26052698493003845,
0.29213351011276245,
-0.38160571455955505,
-0.24734607338905334,
0.9484306573867798,
-0.41964754462242126,
0.5240426063537598,
0.026229530572891235,
-0.652062177658081,
-0.7539342641830444,
-0.03496526926755905,
-0.9663006663322449,
1.0488004684448242,
0.19184689223766327,
-0.39605188369750977,
0.45871251821517944,
-0.7088222503662109,
-0.12357276678085327,
0.34843799471855164,
-0.23287996649742126,
0.1145537793636322,
-0.020272642374038696,
0.25328966975212097,
0.5156353712081909,
0.036793388426303864,
0.39100947976112366,
-0.22062793374061584,
-0.28639230132102966,
0.3386880159378052,
-0.5508315563201904,
0.6621924638748169,
0.1194242611527443,
-0.12760286033153534,
0.057984963059425354,
-0.6036639213562012,
-0.17938145995140076,
-0.3092605769634247,
-0.11953846365213394,
-0.3531264364719391,
0.03358210250735283,
0.4304078221321106,
0.4209738075733185,
0.00489139836281538,
-0.5725044012069702,
-0.0960342288017273,
-0.2838127017021179,
0.39003488421440125,
0.5346320271492004,
-0.017966346815228462,
0.6722539663314819,
-0.25608181953430176,
0.18509219586849213,
-0.040753498673439026,
0.2539495825767517,
-0.21437014639377594,
-0.5079755783081055,
-0.6541640162467957,
-0.2347298413515091,
0.21974427998065948,
0.7088395357131958,
-0.6611278057098389,
0.35098326206207275,
-0.49259892106056213,
-0.23130366206169128,
-0.4695408344268799,
0.14150436222553253,
0.09288492798805237,
0.22625011205673218,
0.20114420354366302,
-0.5507681369781494,
0.01707199029624462,
-0.8532182574272156,
0.06935767829418182,
0.14971117675304413,
0.14836129546165466,
0.7406074404716492,
0.10770098865032196,
-0.04261808469891548,
0.6166900992393494,
-0.20681194961071014,
-0.5923041701316833,
-0.3813745677471161,
0.1936868280172348,
0.4107702672481537,
0.47255969047546387,
0.38916224241256714,
-1.0927720069885254,
-0.3822626769542694,
-0.10272304713726044,
-0.7094395160675049,
-0.0931510403752327,
-0.05446838587522507,
-0.07625290006399155,
0.13411813974380493,
0.44016575813293457,
-0.607594907283783,
0.5117907524108887,
0.4264732301235199,
-0.05431981757283211,
0.05741965025663376,
-0.05102938413619995,
0.27985531091690063,
-0.8284624814987183,
-0.2450639009475708,
0.25764235854148865,
-0.30862733721733093,
-0.8697012066841125,
-0.31222742795944214,
-0.03567836061120033,
-0.2515089511871338,
-0.8506949543952942,
0.8047066330909729,
-0.4481363296508789,
-0.20505854487419128,
-0.38392430543899536,
0.5211443305015564,
0.10627051442861557,
0.6042577028274536,
0.5739561915397644,
0.5643614530563354,
0.5720435380935669,
-0.6420478820800781,
0.15347975492477417,
0.38177433609962463,
-0.5476173758506775,
0.4077046811580658,
-0.3827972114086151,
-0.015979284420609474,
-0.1723984032869339,
0.19308491051197052,
-1.0189121961593628,
-0.22698812186717987,
0.26459193229675293,
-0.4311050474643707,
0.3078280985355377,
-0.14054888486862183,
-0.25099045038223267,
-0.16587640345096588,
0.13696660101413727,
0.43794727325439453,
0.06545485556125641,
-0.37952861189842224,
0.7050723433494568,
0.7243862748146057,
-0.49108341336250305,
-0.6887993812561035,
-0.40339046716690063,
0.1055288091301918,
-0.23541615903377533,
-0.8571012020111084,
0.24099896848201752,
0.03519642353057861,
-0.11844434589147568,
0.06443791836500168,
0.11191742867231369,
-0.25281473994255066,
-0.0752580389380455,
0.14364029467105865,
0.2771379351615906,
-0.26489678025245667,
0.3689534366130829,
-0.04768107831478119,
-0.2725433111190796,
-0.2210492342710495,
-0.3227918744087219,
0.5138011574745178,
0.033005982637405396,
-0.42793112993240356,
-0.896073043346405,
0.6173271536827087,
0.2728355824947357,
-0.4171658456325531,
0.3901958167552948,
0.9037273526191711,
-0.2576468884944916,
-0.12320201098918915,
-0.8388611674308777,
-0.09336040914058685,
-0.46013563871383667,
0.11712317168712616,
-0.5125892162322998,
-1.0610166788101196,
0.4001229703426361,
0.01261749118566513,
0.2093873918056488,
0.3899582326412201,
0.39316898584365845,
-0.055147022008895874,
0.8886725902557373,
0.5809154510498047,
0.0552235022187233,
0.5963569283485413,
-0.45033523440361023,
0.016026591882109642,
-0.6880444884300232,
-0.05022495985031128,
-0.45676738023757935,
-0.22269165515899658,
-0.6256288886070251,
-0.5814584493637085,
0.3673020601272583,
-0.12456397712230682,
0.3604191839694977,
0.49381157755851746,
-0.29077669978141785,
0.28227367997169495,
0.39033856987953186,
0.08223026990890503,
0.38949722051620483,
0.09024544060230255,
0.19714516401290894,
0.005336978007107973,
-0.8491634130477905,
-0.6367954015731812,
0.8999125361442566,
0.2083517462015152,
0.7680416703224182,
0.20209325850009918,
0.623846173286438,
0.3326009213924408,
0.19282293319702148,
-0.8521844148635864,
0.5837355852127075,
-0.12910893559455872,
-0.3521474301815033,
-0.46596652269363403,
-0.1622958928346634,
-0.9046468734741211,
0.29815658926963806,
0.07905344665050507,
-1.0227981805801392,
0.6494201421737671,
0.004657410550862551,
-0.3163103759288788,
-0.05550325661897659,
-0.9513823986053467,
0.9350042939186096,
-0.143461674451828,
-0.4841988980770111,
-0.5632143020629883,
-0.38392841815948486,
0.1866726130247116,
0.028217772021889687,
0.4281606376171112,
-0.5304766893386841,
-0.020911332219839096,
0.682137131690979,
-0.007637285627424717,
0.7234305143356323,
-0.42260849475860596,
-0.08425106853246689,
0.26578229665756226,
-0.1212024986743927,
0.37055888772010803,
0.2515944242477417,
-0.14904101192951202,
-0.05491234362125397,
-0.1648245006799698,
-0.3563399612903595,
-0.5261971950531006,
0.6977012753486633,
-0.6123068928718567,
-0.4870193898677826,
-0.2235080450773239,
-0.6857122778892517,
-0.19277864694595337,
0.14516259729862213,
-0.0521310530602932,
0.9401932954788208,
-0.3180685341358185,
0.03884531185030937,
0.9081683158874512,
-0.2462860345840454,
0.4504666030406952,
0.7310875058174133,
0.010141043923795223,
-0.003088701982051134,
1.0160531997680664,
0.0010196438524872065,
0.18664878606796265,
0.5718576908111572,
-0.1415480524301529,
-0.57085120677948,
-0.5723907947540283,
-0.4620922803878784,
0.16850849986076355,
-0.8292105197906494,
0.08297961205244064,
-0.9995365738868713,
-0.3138098120689392,
-0.4071890413761139,
0.008782904595136642,
-0.1401611864566803,
-0.7071595191955566,
-0.035906754434108734,
-0.10355863720178604,
0.3001362085342407,
0.6487058401107788,
-0.32014283537864685,
0.41797971725463867,
-0.9364930391311646,
0.3138960599899292,
0.09898631274700165,
0.2502560019493103,
-0.3027123808860779,
-0.30877017974853516,
-0.3601914346218109,
-0.06768672913312912,
0.05557515472173691,
-0.8571590185165405,
0.2772737145423889,
0.42314374446868896,
1.1268012523651123,
0.33547767996788025,
-0.1325758397579193,
0.2091287225484848,
-0.5672731995582581,
0.539490282535553,
-0.09022253751754761,
-0.6149771213531494,
0.601325273513794,
-0.3987692892551422,
0.15401116013526917,
0.7656158804893494,
0.6379116773605347,
-0.8023205995559692,
-0.260224312543869,
-0.7492798566818237,
-0.6490581631660461,
0.9633984565734863,
0.18123409152030945,
0.09812020510435104,
0.12825611233711243,
0.023778250440955162,
0.32840126752853394,
0.013684148900210857,
-0.7808286547660828,
0.025981320068240166,
0.00028007884975522757,
-0.17503418028354645,
-0.488956481218338,
-0.10839753597974777,
-0.16214017570018768,
-0.3957214951515198,
0.9056571125984192,
0.05404499173164368,
0.3072921633720398,
0.24148692190647125,
-0.7679393291473389,
0.14044858515262604,
0.3372350335121155,
0.5602555274963379,
0.6817531585693359,
-0.17497806251049042,
-0.14060313999652863,
-0.13313201069831848,
-0.3401639759540558,
0.02375055104494095,
0.36239975690841675,
-0.14184492826461792,
0.31233611702919006,
0.10651753842830658,
1.1144189834594727,
0.15221768617630005,
-0.7149985432624817,
0.6060770750045776,
-0.21186643838882446,
-0.11124241352081299,
-0.6410951018333435,
0.1781574934720993,
-0.16194908320903778,
0.08029186725616455,
0.0387348048388958,
-0.1691550612449646,
0.4946634769439697,
-0.3834967017173767,
0.5473405718803406,
0.2745065987110138,
-0.8002392053604126,
-0.06737760454416275,
0.13925112783908844,
0.4643913507461548,
-0.29032522439956665,
0.35808342695236206,
-0.47995343804359436,
-0.3118423819541931,
0.09971089661121368,
0.03267757594585419,
0.8447107672691345,
-0.39915212988853455,
0.48188066482543945,
0.5081106424331665,
0.25681212544441223,
0.06829380244016647,
0.4934971332550049,
-0.3177061080932617,
-1.0261139869689941,
-0.5846796631813049,
-0.6149032115936279,
-0.21878735721111298,
0.3518837094306946,
-0.7492387890815735,
0.3857305645942688,
0.3337816298007965,
0.05826317146420479,
0.3513352572917938,
-0.1700419783592224,
-0.913316547870636,
0.1483224481344223,
0.04660536348819733,
1.0344430208206177,
-1.002638816833496,
1.0394030809402466,
0.6560710072517395,
-0.1776932179927826,
-0.8707529306411743,
-0.3524666428565979,
-0.005182304419577122,
-0.9245728850364685,
0.559664785861969,
0.3871484100818634,
-0.00870289746671915,
0.15934063494205475,
-0.1324744075536728,
-0.6815270185470581,
0.7606238722801208,
-0.3310115337371826,
-0.5777878165245056,
0.26979756355285645,
0.2611149549484253,
0.08280038088560104,
-0.6362971663475037,
0.3252895176410675,
0.5980434417724609,
0.4805055558681488,
0.024079682305455208,
-0.9150306582450867,
-0.3230648934841156,
-0.35608595609664917,
-0.2513069808483124,
0.29498615860939026,
-0.3170674443244934,
0.4355657994747162,
0.10712339729070663,
-0.2871525287628174,
-0.16249418258666992,
0.5869849324226379,
-0.28710266947746277,
0.3209722936153412,
0.941164493560791,
0.6072341203689575,
0.5937319397926331,
-0.28386369347572327,
0.8741555213928223,
-0.18911084532737732,
0.1368086189031601,
1.3166507482528687,
-0.49408620595932007,
0.8687345385551453,
0.30796271562576294,
0.056703705340623856,
0.37754812836647034,
0.7825286388397217,
0.10339359194040298,
0.4122191071510315,
-0.08574137091636658,
-0.5624306797981262,
-0.3889863193035126,
-0.5252447128295898,
-0.10182970762252808,
0.7834830284118652,
0.9908521771430969,
-0.035443246364593506,
-0.3431910276412964,
0.5000457763671875,
-0.2471911758184433,
0.001996278762817383,
-0.2827947437763214,
1.021454095840454,
0.0843420997262001,
-0.793887197971344,
0.33917322754859924,
-0.15184204280376434,
0.3957820236682892,
-0.4034273028373718,
-0.00870948564261198,
-0.0378001444041729,
0.024818019941449165,
-0.09483209252357483,
-1.0134587287902832,
0.16133049130439758,
-0.2609040439128876,
0.044431231915950775,
-0.21987658739089966,
0.9794124960899353,
-0.6725802421569824,
-0.4040526747703552,
0.31618693470954895,
0.8204663991928101,
0.4011479616165161,
-0.0659714937210083,
-0.8798068761825562,
0.13366055488586426,
-0.14259248971939087,
-0.0066916802898049355,
0.007759629748761654,
0.33736419677734375,
-0.22329354286193848,
0.4898216128349304,
0.3747221529483795,
-0.016660166904330254,
0.06427345424890518,
0.7200032472610474,
0.6445627808570862,
-0.3338201940059662,
-0.6418136358261108,
-0.2754545211791992,
0.5032044649124146,
-0.28770217299461365,
-0.041412923485040665,
0.5706747770309448,
0.687232255935669,
1.0398147106170654,
0.17898261547088623,
0.8484321236610413,
0.03357024863362312,
0.4908890128135681,
-0.596297562122345,
0.36713725328445435,
-0.7187404632568359,
0.11727511137723923,
0.03282473608851433,
-1.112015962600708,
0.1661287099123001,
0.5147427320480347,
-0.3630906045436859,
-0.21128609776496887,
0.6094014644622803,
1.0598640441894531,
-0.4654620587825775,
0.24958786368370056,
0.3322780430316925,
0.03400715813040733,
0.05071207508444786,
0.4990023672580719,
1.0246580839157104,
-0.38740190863609314,
0.17172636091709137,
-0.40836337208747864,
-0.5288437008857727,
-0.15257790684700012,
-0.5997483730316162,
-0.7460659742355347,
-0.9642388224601746,
-0.37649571895599365,
-0.26661089062690735,
0.14506801962852478,
0.8068423867225647,
0.7978313565254211,
-0.8052260279655457,
-0.42836692929267883,
0.11620884388685226,
0.07344319671392441,
-0.20304077863693237,
-0.25886115431785583,
0.35142743587493896,
-0.3927677273750305,
-0.9462047219276428,
0.41609540581703186,
0.5136416554450989,
0.06646204739809036,
-0.25355637073516846,
-0.11797348409891129,
-0.44669875502586365,
-0.055538542568683624,
0.5869933366775513,
0.2702409327030182,
-0.7294942736625671,
-0.25142431259155273,
-0.05395585671067238,
0.01856091618537903,
0.1540934294462204,
1.0112347602844238,
-0.5665932893753052,
0.499931663274765,
0.5092938542366028,
0.4677855968475342,
0.7348864078521729,
-0.40886741876602173,
0.6798601746559143,
-0.6772149205207825,
0.5218501091003418,
0.27314624190330505,
0.5874212384223938,
0.4114294648170471,
-0.27135562896728516,
0.5495023727416992,
0.09517187625169754,
-0.49441567063331604,
-0.6757474541664124,
0.3572343587875366,
-1.5778489112854004,
-0.15770724415779114,
1.243758201599121,
-0.0330049991607666,
-0.2627846300601959,
-0.5827245712280273,
-0.20940285921096802,
0.236595019698143,
-0.47542718052864075,
0.2307719886302948,
0.6698169112205505,
-0.17462103068828583,
-0.37190762162208557,
-1.0378880500793457,
0.64002925157547,
0.3319854140281677,
-0.6135183572769165,
-0.06679828464984894,
0.48974958062171936,
0.023250792175531387,
0.12147483974695206,
0.9769547581672668,
0.0006789079052396119,
0.538926362991333,
-0.3843178153038025,
0.011781663633883,
0.197747603058815,
-0.4573739469051361,
-0.09053191542625427,
-0.1661009043455124,
-0.008957634679973125,
-0.08188208192586899
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19219v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19219v1
|
Collaborative Knowledge Infusion for Low-resource Stance Detection
| 2024-03-28T08:32:14 | 2024-03-28T08:32:14 |
Ming Yan, Joey Tianyi Zhou, Ivor W. Tsang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Stance detection is the view towards a specific target by a given context
(\textit{e.g.} tweets, commercial reviews). Target-related knowledge is often
needed to assist stance detection models in understanding the target well and
making detection correctly. However, prevailing works for knowledge-infused
stance detection predominantly incorporate target knowledge from a singular
source that lacks knowledge verification in limited domain knowledge. The
low-resource training data further increases the challenge for the data-driven
large models in this task. To address those challenges, we propose a
collaborative knowledge infusion approach for low-resource stance detection
tasks, employing a combination of aligned knowledge enhancement and efficient
parameter learning techniques. Specifically, our stance detection approach
leverages target background knowledge collaboratively from different knowledge
sources with the help of knowledge alignment. Additionally, we also introduce
the parameter-efficient collaborative adaptor with a staged optimization
algorithm, which collaboratively addresses the challenges associated with
low-resource stance detection tasks from both network structure and learning
perspectives. To assess the effectiveness of our method, we conduct extensive
experiments on three public stance detection datasets, including low-resource
and cross-target settings. The results demonstrate significant performance
improvements compared to the existing stance detection approaches.
|
[
-0.42298993468284607,
-0.4273575246334076,
0.6222419142723083,
-0.11464138329029083,
-0.4828716814517975,
0.0981983169913292,
-0.1850869357585907,
-0.19550451636314392,
0.566969633102417,
0.5030401945114136,
-0.6789905428886414,
-0.6066762804985046,
-0.680095374584198,
-0.2876173257827759,
0.11818219721317291,
1.1921238899230957,
-0.028004063293337822,
0.18104222416877747,
-0.3703060448169708,
-0.7385532855987549,
-0.398296982049942,
-0.06746964901685715,
-0.7723712921142578,
-0.39963099360466003,
0.3956400454044342,
0.7466409206390381,
0.5436820387840271,
0.3530929982662201,
0.34936943650245667,
0.2326456755399704,
-0.0635104849934578,
0.14721210300922394,
-0.5316718220710754,
0.09822310507297516,
-0.32855719327926636,
-0.31979668140411377,
-0.5281684398651123,
0.12427332252264023,
0.7181065678596497,
0.7577051520347595,
-0.043693657964468,
0.16469499468803406,
0.18628592789173126,
0.6479332447052002,
-0.8705441951751709,
-0.28918930888175964,
-0.5756810903549194,
0.08586578816175461,
-0.2878653407096863,
0.23406106233596802,
-0.19511550664901733,
-0.26217538118362427,
0.08296217024326324,
-0.7119305729866028,
0.17715860903263092,
0.15490926802158356,
0.5912507176399231,
0.5142826437950134,
-0.22642113268375397,
-0.07380224764347076,
-0.4427211284637451,
0.8858848810195923,
-0.4418983459472656,
0.6141197681427002,
0.2818973958492279,
0.1811201423406601,
-0.20751971006393433,
-0.3853646218776703,
-0.7211284637451172,
-0.1001351922750473,
-0.0807650089263916,
0.30366870760917664,
-0.1729409247636795,
0.07434060424566269,
0.16156813502311707,
0.07187283784151077,
-0.4222184121608734,
0.17933493852615356,
0.020443860441446304,
-0.22373166680335999,
0.4416394829750061,
-0.00345512549392879,
0.06307242065668106,
-0.3574313819408417,
-0.6107579469680786,
-0.11944733560085297,
-0.3344593644142151,
0.10651260614395142,
0.39133310317993164,
0.37115761637687683,
-0.4208415448665619,
0.3689410388469696,
-0.4289450943470001,
0.7926802039146423,
0.7325649261474609,
-0.16568097472190857,
0.029557283967733383,
-0.5793033838272095,
-0.22715973854064941,
0.10625934600830078,
0.7912212014198303,
0.287113219499588,
-0.5308897495269775,
-0.050298284739255905,
-0.12642836570739746,
-0.21433547139167786,
0.0351739265024662,
-0.554257869720459,
-0.07648579031229019,
0.022313283756375313,
-0.6183310151100159,
-0.4111638367176056,
-0.037812020629644394,
-0.7451419830322266,
-1.1023505926132202,
-0.3616540729999542,
0.33128705620765686,
-0.3881409764289856,
-0.5315576195716858,
-0.02424183487892151,
-0.3413982391357422,
0.37474325299263,
0.45037826895713806,
-0.7477132678031921,
0.08968717604875565,
0.8862188458442688,
0.8020620942115784,
-0.26390540599823,
0.009388068690896034,
-0.8567929863929749,
0.38643884658813477,
-0.10574090480804443,
0.8679970502853394,
-0.5295307040214539,
-0.24991290271282196,
-0.2807758152484894,
-0.19834303855895996,
0.0338897705078125,
-0.3969355523586273,
0.4466005265712738,
-0.43365323543548584,
0.17310427129268646,
-0.5930004119873047,
-0.771704375743866,
-0.12378881126642227,
0.7583552598953247,
-0.7244880795478821,
0.7907464504241943,
0.2196665108203888,
-0.812904953956604,
1.1598788499832153,
-0.816430389881134,
-0.13333846628665924,
0.18512170016765594,
-0.3170568645000458,
-0.3552546203136444,
-0.13013696670532227,
0.3438125252723694,
0.49616917967796326,
-0.1315808743238449,
0.017477087676525116,
-0.7355414032936096,
-0.10768868029117584,
-0.10197903960943222,
0.035196948796510696,
0.9220550060272217,
-0.04220922291278839,
-0.24184824526309967,
0.22331765294075012,
-0.4836158752441406,
-0.31573301553726196,
-0.06276378780603409,
-0.34108471870422363,
-0.5105253458023071,
-0.0783948078751564,
-0.28033727407455444,
0.1259840428829193,
0.24360767006874084,
-0.47186732292175293,
0.2750834822654724,
-0.287571519613266,
-0.21945220232009888,
0.6857051253318787,
0.5201706886291504,
0.9031082987785339,
-0.13698692619800568,
0.4454345107078552,
0.03244458884000778,
0.4011991620063782,
0.5334658622741699,
-0.2656138837337494,
-0.5632085800170898,
-0.3670762777328491,
-0.010118508711457253,
0.10657350718975067,
-0.790656328201294,
0.4811754822731018,
-0.24992352724075317,
-0.3091723918914795,
-0.349412739276886,
0.5763208270072937,
0.3884807527065277,
0.7519540190696716,
0.3025374710559845,
-0.35681217908859253,
-0.463334321975708,
-0.7170007228851318,
-0.5411912798881531,
-0.37604010105133057,
0.21278363466262817,
0.02448016032576561,
0.37556618452072144,
0.05873335525393486,
0.8822457194328308,
-0.40463870763778687,
-0.5105825066566467,
-0.35978981852531433,
0.13510927557945251,
0.0029527274891734123,
0.29252827167510986,
0.7462500333786011,
-0.8573416471481323,
-0.6644479036331177,
-0.16483348608016968,
-0.6674015522003174,
0.2973068654537201,
0.061955541372299194,
-0.3857250511646271,
0.0720047578215599,
0.6353184580802917,
-0.2139018326997757,
-0.02768033929169178,
0.4752398729324341,
-0.3345715403556824,
0.12831582129001617,
0.3149389922618866,
0.14313258230686188,
-1.590050458908081,
-0.2586885690689087,
0.5329070687294006,
-0.20668044686317444,
-0.6007219552993774,
-0.258429616689682,
-0.21082434058189392,
-0.10002952069044113,
-0.5586806535720825,
0.46901625394821167,
-0.0546737015247345,
-0.06498417258262634,
-0.2964417338371277,
0.18846537172794342,
-0.014796575531363487,
0.47106319665908813,
0.28592392802238464,
0.3438835144042969,
0.3955113887786865,
-0.33897221088409424,
0.3668375015258789,
0.2073165625333786,
-0.08797773718833923,
1.3230276107788086,
-0.09340658783912659,
0.38616666197776794,
-0.011340182274580002,
0.5423079133033752,
-1.0213204622268677,
-0.532905101776123,
0.7557891011238098,
-0.2649059593677521,
0.2458397001028061,
-0.8257614374160767,
-0.4177187383174896,
-0.10575701296329498,
-0.4320946931838989,
0.2879566252231598,
0.10623825341463089,
-0.7280552387237549,
0.5450540781021118,
0.570033073425293,
0.467526912689209,
-0.7696954607963562,
-0.20938926935195923,
-0.37265098094940186,
-0.5167530179023743,
-0.5004425644874573,
0.26380419731140137,
0.3728293180465698,
-0.4442494511604309,
0.11034654080867767,
-0.1353357583284378,
-0.08326337486505508,
-0.1477484256029129,
0.2616842985153198,
0.017695866525173187,
-0.06796108186244965,
0.18956808745861053,
0.02134358137845993,
-0.06670752912759781,
-0.08896328508853912,
-0.6505193114280701,
0.2597888708114624,
-0.012906253337860107,
-0.734529435634613,
-0.7891608476638794,
0.20298875868320465,
0.7756211757659912,
0.11948899179697037,
0.9762071371078491,
1.0722732543945312,
-0.42281991243362427,
-0.16628491878509521,
-0.4790548086166382,
-0.3018266558647156,
-0.48009592294692993,
0.1325690597295761,
0.20914509892463684,
-0.5134737491607666,
0.1264563798904419,
-0.25775066018104553,
-0.19547396898269653,
0.07800975441932678,
0.49241846799850464,
-0.43995487689971924,
0.7160487174987793,
0.7236676812171936,
-0.6901655793190002,
0.8584024310112,
-0.3693138360977173,
0.019177021458745003,
-0.6789407134056091,
-0.1396801471710205,
-0.21859630942344666,
-0.5818653702735901,
-0.31856539845466614,
-0.47724443674087524,
0.6442611217498779,
0.039122045040130615,
-0.2355928122997284,
0.3336629867553711,
-0.4725300371646881,
0.2720678746700287,
0.29250290989875793,
0.6727839708328247,
0.22181355953216553,
-0.2082689106464386,
0.11641845107078552,
-0.08616694808006287,
-0.4958897829055786,
-0.15462468564510345,
1.0207592248916626,
0.039095934480428696,
0.3247184157371521,
0.09956725686788559,
0.9858824014663696,
0.33073410391807556,
0.23328904807567596,
-1.2130367755889893,
0.6633487343788147,
-0.0643591359257698,
-0.3450978994369507,
-0.3269341289997101,
-0.007213383447378874,
-0.529312014579773,
-0.03916095197200775,
-0.551429271697998,
-0.4761575758457184,
0.32576024532318115,
0.4779635965824127,
-0.40774959325790405,
0.46505287289619446,
-0.5776308178901672,
0.9064427018165588,
-0.13058246672153473,
-0.6472826600074768,
-0.6663625836372375,
-0.5074665546417236,
0.2052287757396698,
0.05331391468644142,
-0.04007752984762192,
-0.05459542199969292,
-0.1440194696187973,
0.9491614103317261,
-0.4766840934753418,
1.0885885953903198,
-0.9782932996749878,
0.12280628830194473,
0.2792064845561981,
-0.1985214799642563,
0.8877387046813965,
0.12235642969608307,
-0.2632148563861847,
-0.19096581637859344,
-0.6113497018814087,
-0.38802197575569153,
-0.6464594006538391,
0.4496527314186096,
-0.5113291144371033,
-0.5169806480407715,
-0.09416068345308304,
-0.4526229500770569,
-0.6489724516868591,
0.15903984010219574,
0.2863110899925232,
0.023555325344204903,
-0.3135046660900116,
0.39645370841026306,
0.5217195153236389,
0.22099561989307404,
0.3679845333099365,
0.47566571831703186,
0.47520938515663147,
-0.4001024067401886,
0.8082965612411499,
-0.18918989598751068,
0.15757636725902557,
0.3597276210784912,
0.4254104495048523,
-0.4602838158607483,
-0.8311896324157715,
-0.2180401086807251,
0.06377087533473969,
-0.6518115997314453,
-0.14986495673656464,
-0.35187166929244995,
0.35957711935043335,
-0.14738334715366364,
-0.44463175535202026,
-0.4915125072002411,
-0.14127327501773834,
-0.18948674201965332,
0.04529806226491928,
0.6470987796783447,
0.46294015645980835,
-0.2016908973455429,
0.4139523506164551,
-0.5223532915115356,
0.3212708532810211,
0.3961627185344696,
0.17117729783058167,
-0.2802453339099884,
-0.30547985434532166,
-0.3586839735507965,
-0.006318370345979929,
-0.45029962062835693,
-0.7991048097610474,
-0.03261217474937439,
-0.05627211555838585,
0.6664190888404846,
0.7286346554756165,
0.35727623105049133,
0.6580142378807068,
0.14831200242042542,
0.645171046257019,
0.43284571170806885,
-0.8290295600891113,
0.739133894443512,
-0.4927314519882202,
-0.11921651661396027,
0.9872407913208008,
0.5908153057098389,
-0.22884692251682281,
-0.32111144065856934,
-0.4981723427772522,
-0.39996540546417236,
0.8068742156028748,
-0.04806215316057205,
-0.13383321464061737,
0.34674984216690063,
0.24309948086738586,
-0.018672369420528412,
0.124794602394104,
-0.3739160895347595,
0.17051801085472107,
-0.17546482384204865,
-0.27828848361968994,
0.33576515316963196,
0.28609544038772583,
-0.47494277358055115,
-0.4587184488773346,
0.5431606769561768,
-0.40593913197517395,
-0.010970067232847214,
-0.10075223445892334,
-0.31085431575775146,
-0.3405488431453705,
0.01889025606215,
0.2618221342563629,
0.22394897043704987,
-0.10722701996564865,
-0.3935697376728058,
0.5680726766586304,
-0.45677751302719116,
0.11461304873228073,
-0.05373236909508705,
0.014320466667413712,
-0.1974363923072815,
0.21881477534770966,
0.6109648942947388,
0.3309207558631897,
0.05330986902117729,
0.780622124671936,
0.22484871745109558,
-0.1976175159215927,
-0.2377886176109314,
0.05983981862664223,
0.005127356853336096,
0.6086966395378113,
0.10794290900230408,
0.4053983986377716,
0.10384989529848099,
-0.32264959812164307,
0.35187819600105286,
0.8857851028442383,
-0.7050684690475464,
-0.2824004292488098,
0.3470097780227661,
0.323419451713562,
0.047321829944849014,
0.20302729308605194,
-0.32496213912963867,
-0.4601404368877411,
0.45807304978370667,
0.12676182389259338,
0.7983320951461792,
0.05268782377243042,
0.33345481753349304,
0.33345264196395874,
-0.22611106932163239,
-0.08089673519134521,
0.04028809815645218,
-0.32625049352645874,
-1.0804316997528076,
-0.1420242339372635,
-0.4316727817058563,
-0.7511448860168457,
0.16929849982261658,
-0.7913920879364014,
0.6574451327323914,
-0.7158225178718567,
-0.1333865225315094,
0.0906461700797081,
0.2800758481025696,
-0.6652705073356628,
-0.05760261043906212,
0.13614583015441895,
0.5124981999397278,
-1.0150913000106812,
0.8540391325950623,
1.1014792919158936,
-0.38379332423210144,
-0.8019497990608215,
0.8049734234809875,
0.5397884249687195,
-0.7588827610015869,
0.5282689929008484,
-0.22795112431049347,
-0.44199275970458984,
-0.12092751264572144,
-0.682470440864563,
-0.5455730557441711,
1.131630778312683,
0.5480218529701233,
-0.10952597111463547,
0.31412774324417114,
-0.09162961691617966,
0.5043129920959473,
-0.22640235722064972,
-0.35937103629112244,
0.26822420954704285,
0.637170672416687,
0.2754334509372711,
-0.5698294639587402,
0.28435829281806946,
0.36927053332328796,
-0.4738124907016754,
0.18106205761432648,
-0.9618508219718933,
0.4385358393192291,
0.14277160167694092,
0.10615424066781998,
-0.40297797322273254,
0.7628502249717712,
0.48531243205070496,
0.4679757356643677,
0.9818055629730225,
0.6660922765731812,
0.8951811790466309,
0.23860090970993042,
0.7577096223831177,
-0.16490580141544342,
0.1387498527765274,
0.8004220724105835,
-0.4442160129547119,
0.6389992237091064,
0.6259266138076782,
0.04261663556098938,
0.7054390907287598,
0.5474736094474792,
0.017941851168870926,
0.6600563526153564,
-0.26099318265914917,
-0.6497879028320312,
-0.48080289363861084,
-0.5408433079719543,
-0.010684828273952007,
0.679404079914093,
0.4930565357208252,
-0.2620859444141388,
-0.3065945506095886,
0.07920914888381958,
0.11470576375722885,
0.061906665563583374,
-0.5743396878242493,
1.0417828559875488,
-0.1455705463886261,
-0.7464817762374878,
0.3838326036930084,
-0.31854379177093506,
0.7215373516082764,
-0.43069005012512207,
-0.004886078182607889,
-0.08694322407245636,
0.29296937584877014,
-0.40422990918159485,
-0.8079566955566406,
0.3650825619697571,
-0.1456409990787506,
-0.2917177677154541,
-0.30063554644584656,
0.9922253489494324,
-0.18566468358039856,
-0.03575070947408676,
0.38828766345977783,
0.5579046010971069,
-0.20621109008789062,
-0.10687258839607239,
-0.7314131855964661,
-0.17927072942256927,
-0.223268523812294,
0.0016487296670675278,
0.6189843416213989,
0.3631121516227722,
-0.12960171699523926,
0.2068084329366684,
0.6972107887268066,
-0.0012017772532999516,
-0.4798491299152374,
0.033679068088531494,
1.1605112552642822,
-0.09688161313533783,
-0.521173357963562,
-0.6837942004203796,
0.40851539373397827,
-0.47893863916397095,
-0.06192340701818466,
0.6537213921546936,
0.2560715973377228,
0.8232519626617432,
0.06360232830047607,
0.7731303572654724,
-0.09397636353969574,
0.3090505003929138,
-0.43223774433135986,
0.8819869756698608,
-0.6925952434539795,
0.026301244273781776,
-0.40772244334220886,
-0.6511476635932922,
-0.19367004930973053,
0.34347397089004517,
-0.4659918248653412,
-0.24768632650375366,
0.4111894369125366,
0.8265707492828369,
-0.3604266345500946,
-0.1622467190027237,
0.1347137838602066,
-0.3392829895019531,
0.07795468717813492,
0.489290326833725,
0.6879947781562805,
-0.07306763529777527,
0.7686764597892761,
-0.4619022607803345,
-0.1424102932214737,
-0.38727694749832153,
-1.0215160846710205,
-0.9856618046760559,
-0.6175155639648438,
-0.5285991430282593,
-0.48246368765830994,
-0.031247280538082123,
1.279835820198059,
1.1259325742721558,
-0.8479794263839722,
0.06601787358522415,
-0.3118804693222046,
0.42625096440315247,
-0.4451926052570343,
-0.22919312119483948,
0.33003097772598267,
-0.18345223367214203,
-0.6910633444786072,
0.7011975049972534,
0.0018546574283391237,
-0.17817971110343933,
-0.07972686737775803,
-0.33152973651885986,
-0.18726547062397003,
-0.2809106111526489,
0.3049162030220032,
0.545274019241333,
-0.40982621908187866,
-0.4412403404712677,
-0.14211688935756683,
0.11264462769031525,
0.09899915009737015,
0.8369529247283936,
-0.7675090432167053,
0.47900280356407166,
0.6061898469924927,
0.61062091588974,
0.40958407521247864,
0.2914317548274994,
0.5819352269172668,
-1.4301899671554565,
0.5183995962142944,
0.3614175617694855,
0.5756760835647583,
0.4266808331012726,
-0.6200856566429138,
0.3381938934326172,
0.6381133794784546,
-0.16053849458694458,
-0.7006880640983582,
0.359826922416687,
-1.131548285484314,
0.02224471978843212,
1.0747724771499634,
-0.014553659595549107,
-0.05732914060354233,
-0.370549738407135,
-0.05863918364048004,
0.5476123690605164,
-0.6941368579864502,
0.4637347161769867,
0.5186014175415039,
-0.3833709955215454,
-0.12492584437131882,
-0.0868203267455101,
0.8436164259910583,
0.2954002320766449,
-0.657864511013031,
-0.2692931592464447,
0.4357132911682129,
0.20435389876365662,
0.2284288853406906,
0.595335066318512,
0.23672005534172058,
0.23730874061584473,
-0.11027166247367859,
-0.1648590862751007,
0.020136218518018723,
-0.12365933507680893,
-0.22238372266292572,
0.20779629051685333,
-0.0107264444231987,
-0.6067782044410706
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19211v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19211v1
|
Dual-Personalizing Adapter for Federated Foundation Models
| 2024-03-28T08:19:33 | 2024-03-28T08:19:33 |
Yiyuan Yang, Guodong Long, Tao Shen, Jing Jiang, Michael Blumenstein
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Recently, foundation models, particularly large language models (LLMs), have
demonstrated an impressive ability to adapt to various tasks by fine-tuning
large amounts of instruction data. Notably, federated foundation models emerge
as a privacy preservation method to fine-tune models collaboratively under
federated learning (FL) settings by leveraging many distributed datasets with
non-IID data. To alleviate communication and computation overhead,
parameter-efficient methods are introduced for efficiency, and some research
adapted personalization methods to federated foundation models for better user
preferences alignment. However, a critical gap in existing research is the
neglect of test-time distribution shifts in real-world applications. Therefore,
to bridge this gap, we propose a new setting, termed test-time personalization,
which not only concentrates on the targeted local task but also extends to
other tasks that exhibit test-time distribution shifts. To address challenges
in this new setting, we explore a simple yet effective solution to learn a
comprehensive foundation model. Specifically, a dual-personalizing adapter
architecture (FedDPA) is proposed, comprising a global adapter and a local
adapter for addressing test-time distribution shifts and personalization,
respectively. Additionally, we introduce an instance-wise dynamic weighting
mechanism to optimize the balance between the global and local adapters,
enhancing overall performance. The effectiveness of the proposed method has
been evaluated on benchmark datasets across different NLP tasks.
|
[
-0.31255224347114563,
-0.6999407410621643,
0.0819639265537262,
0.620728075504303,
0.005929749924689531,
0.1468818485736847,
-0.28668516874313354,
-0.38353005051612854,
-0.03275415673851967,
0.26630693674087524,
-0.6513004302978516,
-0.32969191670417786,
-0.17975705862045288,
-0.016829494386911392,
-0.14709651470184326,
1.0182634592056274,
-0.19976945221424103,
-0.19689598679542542,
-0.23730918765068054,
-0.361101359128952,
-0.5001227855682373,
-0.20405437052249908,
-0.5559015274047852,
-0.5134867429733276,
0.2738725543022156,
0.5225663185119629,
0.53554767370224,
0.6342516541481018,
0.5012495517730713,
0.27973511815071106,
-0.10713454335927963,
-0.14240330457687378,
-0.3993662893772125,
0.188332200050354,
-0.3674730956554413,
-0.6134727597236633,
-0.2623840570449829,
-0.23137801885604858,
0.7813811898231506,
0.6799900531768799,
-0.3163430988788605,
0.39957305788993835,
-0.16935883462429047,
0.6431650519371033,
-0.6218165755271912,
0.36856457591056824,
-0.3076194226741791,
0.34505704045295715,
-0.07052929699420929,
-0.19255991280078888,
-0.3678956627845764,
-0.31711089611053467,
0.3165685534477234,
-0.5188928246498108,
0.5701249837875366,
-0.20431670546531677,
0.5588280558586121,
0.24646198749542236,
-0.555291473865509,
0.09592260420322418,
-1.0056027173995972,
0.7423439025878906,
-0.4294174313545227,
0.5057681202888489,
-0.10177011787891388,
0.6430466175079346,
0.05236174911260605,
-0.5614030957221985,
-0.3242621421813965,
0.015595200471580029,
-0.25420039892196655,
-0.047017719596624374,
-0.09111636132001877,
-0.0241402518004179,
-0.01595195010304451,
0.6829919815063477,
-0.5259631872177124,
0.3632550835609436,
0.1984076052904129,
-0.0876075029373169,
0.7303950786590576,
0.13072718679904938,
0.13259074091911316,
0.31771719455718994,
-0.6181836724281311,
-0.3285601735115051,
-0.43070608377456665,
0.464067667722702,
0.33681875467300415,
0.3762947916984558,
-0.30091166496276855,
0.30293241143226624,
-0.6301091313362122,
0.7395906448364258,
0.4103042483329773,
-0.20966973900794983,
0.4402482807636261,
-0.39797142148017883,
-0.2544189393520355,
-0.06255843490362167,
0.4378632605075836,
0.1189989447593689,
0.16797727346420288,
-0.4021792411804199,
-0.1426917016506195,
0.04260975494980812,
0.11634285002946854,
-1.0260436534881592,
-0.19606588780879974,
0.07826659083366394,
-0.3472793698310852,
-0.6603418588638306,
0.017443057149648666,
-0.9498475193977356,
-0.4278305768966675,
-0.25704076886177063,
0.20400531589984894,
0.09051616489887238,
-0.34542950987815857,
0.25084927678108215,
0.16906306147575378,
0.03279551491141319,
0.12113825976848602,
-1.2021430730819702,
0.5588738322257996,
0.6626408100128174,
0.8412758708000183,
-0.3243274986743927,
-0.14268358051776886,
-0.6727721691131592,
0.1973574459552765,
0.1010899692773819,
0.6973825693130493,
-0.5268416404724121,
-0.25472673773765564,
-0.036431144922971725,
0.16992518305778503,
-0.1565459817647934,
-0.3959587812423706,
0.06753924489021301,
-0.5964856743812561,
0.37616145610809326,
-0.2780708074569702,
-0.4363623559474945,
-0.07664752006530762,
0.22823211550712585,
-0.4138782322406769,
0.7541195750236511,
0.21688510477542877,
-0.6904954314231873,
0.23074720799922943,
-0.8093035817146301,
-0.6035121083259583,
-0.07388636469841003,
-0.20578381419181824,
-0.6026807427406311,
0.13631118834018707,
0.1576329469680786,
0.6287208795547485,
-0.12220446765422821,
0.4425780773162842,
-0.481574684381485,
-0.5695883631706238,
-0.014493482187390327,
-0.15051978826522827,
0.6805346608161926,
0.02056305855512619,
-0.8207843899726868,
0.22222110629081726,
-0.7751950025558472,
-0.09701406955718994,
0.3635886013507843,
-0.3372344374656677,
-0.44341591000556946,
-0.04907054081559181,
0.019841566681861877,
0.1803349405527115,
0.3772749900817871,
-0.6738489866256714,
0.15543904900550842,
-0.6228387355804443,
0.3332337439060211,
1.1668459177017212,
-0.20490022003650665,
0.6812345385551453,
-0.414569228887558,
0.5137767791748047,
0.16411419212818146,
0.10425660759210587,
0.1175989881157875,
-0.20767006278038025,
-0.6446123719215393,
-0.05147290229797363,
0.0475674569606781,
0.6072020530700684,
-0.1234361082315445,
0.42897742986679077,
-0.5811718106269836,
-0.2908404767513275,
-0.22260037064552307,
0.3108885586261749,
0.45427432656288147,
0.6636353731155396,
0.2436520904302597,
-0.2742897868156433,
-0.18051202595233917,
-0.9676857590675354,
-0.14445534348487854,
0.006578672211617231,
-0.12885546684265137,
0.6409204602241516,
0.22889479994773865,
-0.3969118297100067,
0.9654148817062378,
-0.843152642250061,
-0.49344322085380554,
0.1048411875963211,
-0.17085325717926025,
0.04839898273348808,
0.2737751305103302,
0.8717546463012695,
-1.1279436349868774,
-0.5221314430236816,
0.09680438786745071,
-0.5275735855102539,
-0.14880308508872986,
-0.14287038147449493,
-0.20563645660877228,
0.023542748764157295,
-0.09554239362478256,
-0.024548575282096863,
0.13740041851997375,
0.8635889291763306,
-0.8722102046012878,
0.4165944457054138,
-0.15769948065280914,
-0.08097167313098907,
-1.2896844148635864,
-0.0009439749992452562,
-0.013282635249197483,
-0.23616378009319305,
-0.5695220232009888,
0.16216091811656952,
0.06226075440645218,
0.021426565945148468,
-0.06356548517942429,
1.0213738679885864,
-0.24505527317523956,
-0.11803961545228958,
-0.15141619741916656,
-0.1579294353723526,
-0.10261853039264679,
0.3946467638015747,
0.04430655390024185,
0.9631791710853577,
0.19000111520290375,
-0.3868449330329895,
0.20663879811763763,
0.46438392996788025,
-0.1255084127187729,
0.7223493456840515,
-0.574336588382721,
0.10614131391048431,
0.0704796239733696,
0.29101333022117615,
-0.8094263076782227,
-0.22163645923137665,
0.06603968143463135,
0.17605477571487427,
0.16480261087417603,
0.15040132403373718,
-0.32576698064804077,
-0.1624465137720108,
-0.31238678097724915,
0.31075504422187805,
0.4292733669281006,
-1.0258634090423584,
0.6438707709312439,
0.33095234632492065,
-0.011450113728642464,
-0.7055237889289856,
-0.7229481339454651,
-0.30817142128944397,
-0.2478388547897339,
-1.0365406274795532,
0.753730833530426,
-0.4995567500591278,
-0.12605832517147064,
-0.11816731095314026,
-0.37929534912109375,
-0.15322089195251465,
0.3851126432418823,
0.5717765688896179,
-0.055581532418727875,
-0.4771135747432709,
0.2679497003555298,
0.4031417667865753,
-0.14108924567699432,
-0.1591474711894989,
-0.1507057100534439,
0.3234390318393707,
-0.28586462140083313,
-0.08097619563341141,
-0.42844539880752563,
0.33168715238571167,
0.2948007881641388,
-0.3146724998950958,
0.9254822731018066,
0.6672794818878174,
-0.38611525297164917,
-0.44134530425071716,
-0.6948128342628479,
-0.35626110434532166,
-0.5619247555732727,
0.16040517389774323,
-0.5537999868392944,
-1.181128978729248,
0.48262619972229004,
-0.10706810653209686,
0.3520427644252777,
-0.2081221342086792,
0.5944626927375793,
0.0327889546751976,
0.7059885859489441,
0.949676513671875,
-0.2603936493396759,
0.7993620038032532,
-0.2718079686164856,
0.17526856064796448,
-0.7353206276893616,
-0.06979475170373917,
-0.27175459265708923,
-0.7108261585235596,
-0.18619544804096222,
-0.11402346193790436,
0.09600314497947693,
-0.21081553399562836,
-0.3103601336479187,
0.15518257021903992,
-0.5057006478309631,
0.4242120385169983,
0.4710058867931366,
0.20482859015464783,
0.35607585310935974,
0.19355455040931702,
-0.018063558265566826,
-0.023504121229052544,
-0.29846155643463135,
-0.16726814210414886,
1.0905466079711914,
0.192013218998909,
0.5057302713394165,
0.35326388478279114,
0.754951536655426,
0.2206992655992508,
0.502338707447052,
-0.4003154933452606,
0.3609330654144287,
-0.5333825945854187,
-0.5237387418746948,
-0.12182817608118057,
-0.6571507453918457,
-0.6538698077201843,
0.3295477032661438,
-0.1032094955444336,
-0.631661057472229,
0.4157201051712036,
0.5155376195907593,
-0.3357200622558594,
0.30407923460006714,
-0.8250154256820679,
1.0364431142807007,
-0.21087221801280975,
-0.32178133726119995,
-0.16043445467948914,
-0.622782826423645,
0.4153977930545807,
-0.10537996143102646,
0.12732240557670593,
-0.23054006695747375,
-0.05486276373267174,
0.46644672751426697,
-0.0043861172161996365,
0.9187284708023071,
-0.4639628827571869,
0.15085317194461823,
-0.3937687873840332,
0.03210067376494408,
0.7207596302032471,
0.42178890109062195,
-0.19299206137657166,
-0.11119083315134048,
-0.10072185099124908,
-0.400189071893692,
-0.571036159992218,
1.0602830648422241,
-0.8495969772338867,
-0.5272687673568726,
-0.30442872643470764,
-0.7515974640846252,
-0.40986454486846924,
0.3298581838607788,
-0.11841475963592529,
0.24366970360279083,
-0.49795976281166077,
0.30813369154930115,
0.7471322417259216,
-0.02904760092496872,
0.26794567704200745,
0.9529216885566711,
0.06114215403795242,
-0.15423671901226044,
0.7359820008277893,
-0.18362094461917877,
0.36201006174087524,
0.8623762130737305,
0.6548770070075989,
-0.2679829001426697,
-0.5593745112419128,
-0.26580432057380676,
0.3321152627468109,
-0.48923879861831665,
-0.0947253629565239,
-0.6760475635528564,
0.13106395304203033,
-0.40216875076293945,
-0.5524628758430481,
-0.3242104947566986,
-0.37223657965660095,
-0.546954870223999,
-0.14605818688869476,
0.2711387276649475,
0.06574911624193192,
0.22543154656887054,
0.5585882663726807,
-0.33434444665908813,
0.4321032464504242,
0.5161222815513611,
0.6390443444252014,
-0.17564871907234192,
-0.3311377465724945,
0.06929361075162888,
0.10852056741714478,
-0.16730019450187683,
-0.5714130997657776,
-0.17669221758842468,
0.4591454565525055,
0.34579116106033325,
0.45542028546333313,
0.23015424609184265,
0.6265456676483154,
-0.33737534284591675,
0.31627896428108215,
-0.15839487314224243,
-0.6913978457450867,
0.36664879322052,
-0.13487623631954193,
0.3695193827152252,
0.692897617816925,
-0.0012073145480826497,
-0.5578150749206543,
-0.023825185373425484,
-0.3315911591053009,
-0.5616591572761536,
0.6965582966804504,
-0.01366292592138052,
0.3386305272579193,
0.4426427185535431,
0.5221592783927917,
0.3328976631164551,
0.11204943805932999,
-0.5523420572280884,
-0.4262542724609375,
-0.12445278465747833,
-0.411592036485672,
-0.34597909450531006,
-0.20109087228775024,
-0.30774083733558655,
-0.13111427426338196,
0.487265408039093,
-0.49317821860313416,
0.06474321335554123,
-0.11454791575670242,
-0.06326945126056671,
-0.16828913986682892,
0.36782485246658325,
0.4698513448238373,
0.6820418238639832,
-0.36409810185432434,
-0.11194494366645813,
0.1473129540681839,
-0.4473595917224884,
0.4478561580181122,
0.7088673710823059,
-0.5513023734092712,
-0.15463891625404358,
0.03418662026524544,
0.9111198782920837,
0.675598680973053,
-0.4911879599094391,
0.644738495349884,
-0.38984251022338867,
0.12640243768692017,
-0.3372740149497986,
0.47883790731430054,
0.21903689205646515,
0.3616890013217926,
-0.07635322213172913,
0.2385244369506836,
-0.0349133275449276,
-0.29529672861099243,
0.22975316643714905,
0.44504860043525696,
-0.19404348731040955,
-0.6532415747642517,
0.8125872015953064,
0.34261927008628845,
-0.3039827048778534,
0.4504113495349884,
0.11648312211036682,
-0.1200379952788353,
0.5596200823783875,
0.776335597038269,
0.9742671847343445,
-0.581531822681427,
0.5449727177619934,
-0.03706159070134163,
-0.05833381414413452,
-0.14866438508033752,
0.14033207297325134,
-0.42108413577079773,
-0.857510507106781,
0.03780128061771393,
-0.871706485748291,
-0.2668432593345642,
-0.1488564908504486,
-0.6891517043113708,
0.2438821941614151,
-0.5374847650527954,
0.11454712599515915,
0.05487174540758133,
0.1514766961336136,
-0.8740250468254089,
0.22738367319107056,
-0.04254663363099098,
0.9922365546226501,
-0.8817197680473328,
0.8770227432250977,
0.7849954962730408,
0.18028061091899872,
-0.4864605963230133,
-0.13070830702781677,
0.1557965874671936,
-0.6556482315063477,
0.17634634673595428,
0.24020875990390778,
0.07789956778287888,
0.039902444928884506,
0.2975132167339325,
-0.6862507462501526,
1.557492971420288,
0.498236745595932,
-0.7720558047294617,
-0.32836073637008667,
0.18180076777935028,
0.635057270526886,
-0.48539188504219055,
-0.14980784058570862,
0.46875160932540894,
0.30006730556488037,
-0.11045927554368973,
-0.5644045472145081,
0.25049489736557007,
-0.14774104952812195,
0.1508949100971222,
0.3464723229408264,
-0.9797723293304443,
0.5152956247329712,
-0.22070898115634918,
-0.22217316925525665,
-0.14678575098514557,
0.6563546061515808,
0.2657608389854431,
0.4663509726524353,
0.8244694471359253,
0.378435343503952,
0.7242301106452942,
-0.04269297420978546,
1.0468244552612305,
-0.24056240916252136,
0.41820594668388367,
1.314850926399231,
-0.37226447463035583,
0.6035375595092773,
0.377125084400177,
-0.1716136634349823,
0.3586333096027374,
0.4124993681907654,
0.00811876729130745,
0.6705529093742371,
0.04838203266263008,
-0.42873063683509827,
-0.10960089415311813,
0.03871457278728485,
-0.45570507645606995,
0.23771944642066956,
0.008201073855161667,
-0.49551287293434143,
-0.1951799988746643,
0.005622121039777994,
-0.07783716917037964,
0.14178812503814697,
0.16425304114818573,
0.6694024205207825,
-0.008112361654639244,
-0.37656521797180176,
0.10345291346311569,
0.10080617666244507,
0.7737346887588501,
-0.8070281744003296,
0.24383024871349335,
-0.40109267830848694,
0.7952788472175598,
-0.20026300847530365,
-0.42512062191963196,
0.3672550320625305,
-0.21426141262054443,
-0.5478881001472473,
-0.5072914361953735,
0.49792560935020447,
-0.3603229820728302,
-0.5367961525917053,
0.5700603127479553,
0.08808440715074539,
-0.5003560185432434,
0.05896703526377678,
-0.6508756279945374,
-0.03456827998161316,
0.012717296369373798,
-0.5938532948493958,
0.6686467528343201,
-0.16261045634746552,
-0.13885454833507538,
0.7493982315063477,
0.7019950747489929,
0.04302384331822395,
0.17884191870689392,
-0.051497943699359894,
0.7819947004318237,
-0.3977353572845459,
-0.7858000993728638,
-0.5614987015724182,
0.4035769999027252,
0.07161077111959457,
-0.5437043905258179,
0.5841666460037231,
0.5124703645706177,
1.045986533164978,
-0.1831296980381012,
0.5868734121322632,
-0.031223440542817116,
0.29745402932167053,
-0.2735075354576111,
0.5616896152496338,
-0.5845429301261902,
0.2668428122997284,
-0.10095791518688202,
-0.9075799584388733,
-0.32882821559906006,
0.319307416677475,
-0.33186542987823486,
-0.17450566589832306,
0.2858075201511383,
0.7421373724937439,
-0.4663812220096588,
0.2546221613883972,
-0.04481127858161926,
0.14938311278820038,
0.7204831838607788,
0.6414855718612671,
0.18840321898460388,
-0.2546078562736511,
0.34674081206321716,
-1.0149115324020386,
-0.41381385922431946,
-0.2976887822151184,
-0.7190994620323181,
-1.052375316619873,
-0.5592235326766968,
-0.4600190222263336,
-0.03952273726463318,
0.3021441400051117,
0.6751991510391235,
0.9009381532669067,
-0.996386706829071,
-0.23228071630001068,
-0.18695330619812012,
0.038010373711586,
-0.48660144209861755,
-0.3138510584831238,
0.3779740631580353,
-0.021596157923340797,
-0.5150988698005676,
0.4870242774486542,
0.13544081151485443,
0.1322530210018158,
-0.2652170956134796,
-0.01897081546485424,
0.0005961183924227953,
-0.15278150141239166,
0.2900432050228119,
0.26982977986335754,
-0.553744912147522,
-0.4081929624080658,
0.14820322394371033,
0.1371176689863205,
0.10898710042238235,
0.8700297474861145,
-0.7149881720542908,
0.7838423252105713,
0.522529661655426,
0.8822876811027527,
0.5227522253990173,
0.276150643825531,
0.6734027862548828,
-0.9793624877929688,
0.3378811180591583,
0.13525225222110748,
0.19293497502803802,
0.3647172451019287,
-0.8454036712646484,
0.5308204293251038,
0.2364710122346878,
-0.5922173857688904,
-1.0863054990768433,
0.2288638800382614,
-0.8272190093994141,
-0.011986156925559044,
0.758009672164917,
-0.4230025112628937,
0.03634101524949074,
0.24428336322307587,
0.19015608727931976,
0.08719556033611298,
-0.30298730731010437,
1.022656798362732,
0.6186801195144653,
-0.1831437647342682,
0.0188591331243515,
-0.3159051537513733,
0.33621883392333984,
0.42272618412971497,
-0.9529703259468079,
-0.05984827131032944,
0.2578664720058441,
0.8089781999588013,
0.0027746560517698526,
0.5506775975227356,
0.2253510057926178,
0.2001831829547882,
-0.46758708357810974,
-0.27806907892227173,
-0.362308531999588,
-0.33577001094818115,
-0.6216304302215576,
0.28712061047554016,
-0.29770588874816895,
-0.25804653763771057
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19726v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19726v1
|
A Benchmark Evaluation of Clinical Named Entity Recognition in French
| 2024-03-28T07:59:58 | 2024-03-28T07:59:58 |
Nesrine Bannour, Christophe Servan, Aurélie Névéol, Xavier Tannier
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, q-bio.QM
|
Background: Transformer-based language models have shown strong performance
on many Natural LanguageProcessing (NLP) tasks. Masked Language Models (MLMs)
attract sustained interest because they can be adaptedto different languages
and sub-domains through training or fine-tuning on specific corpora while
remaining lighterthan modern Large Language Models (LLMs). Recently, several
MLMs have been released for the biomedicaldomain in French, and experiments
suggest that they outperform standard French counterparts. However,
nosystematic evaluation comparing all models on the same corpora is available.
Objective: This paper presentsan evaluation of masked language models for
biomedical French on the task of clinical named entity recognition.Material and
methods: We evaluate biomedical models CamemBERT-bio and DrBERT and compare
them tostandard French models CamemBERT, FlauBERT and FrALBERT as well as
multilingual mBERT using three publicallyavailable corpora for clinical named
entity recognition in French. The evaluation set-up relies on
gold-standardcorpora as released by the corpus developers. Results: Results
suggest that CamemBERT-bio outperformsDrBERT consistently while FlauBERT offers
competitive performance and FrAlBERT achieves the lowest carbonfootprint.
Conclusion: This is the first benchmark evaluation of biomedical masked
language models for Frenchclinical entity recognition that compares model
performance consistently on nested entity recognition using metricscovering
performance and environmental impact.
|
[
-0.21724045276641846,
-0.4044925570487976,
0.6795452833175659,
0.3553102910518646,
-0.15908010303974152,
0.4055289030075073,
-0.23790447413921356,
-0.8812233209609985,
0.29903289675712585,
0.8717684149742126,
-0.39258185029029846,
-0.7868306636810303,
-0.8117902874946594,
0.5692764520645142,
-0.12101995199918747,
0.7303986549377441,
-0.20270264148712158,
0.5631992816925049,
-0.07170163840055466,
-0.4403155446052551,
-0.39645999670028687,
-0.6182935833930969,
-0.8787379264831543,
-0.44106194376945496,
0.5039540529251099,
-0.2400505691766739,
0.3732282519340515,
0.4838871657848358,
0.8332130312919617,
0.3031903803348541,
-0.06690183281898499,
0.2287159562110901,
-0.28614917397499084,
-0.07303182780742645,
-0.19306057691574097,
-0.017470840364694595,
-0.5032508969306946,
-0.1139381006360054,
0.7337104678153992,
0.9370078444480896,
0.18861164152622223,
-0.13327521085739136,
-0.1921207457780838,
0.4510704576969147,
-0.44846150279045105,
0.3586518168449402,
-0.5965052843093872,
0.0755387544631958,
-0.033171460032463074,
-0.048304300755262375,
-0.5204553604125977,
-0.26074036955833435,
0.22563345730304718,
-0.3097277879714966,
0.47156286239624023,
-0.03347332030534744,
0.8395564556121826,
0.1263296902179718,
-0.2784908413887024,
-0.3394646942615509,
-0.586689293384552,
0.5878429412841797,
-0.5884766578674316,
0.950162410736084,
0.22669033706188202,
0.3613225221633911,
-0.059386856853961945,
-1.0094107389450073,
-0.21395808458328247,
-0.46845510601997375,
-0.3029147982597351,
0.1290605068206787,
-0.5231428742408752,
0.04927061125636101,
0.3005441129207611,
0.2309504747390747,
-0.7787691354751587,
0.1957363337278366,
-0.4600924253463745,
-0.5240838527679443,
0.5867091417312622,
-0.045299261808395386,
0.185921773314476,
-0.019389526918530464,
-0.5384013652801514,
0.06940904259681702,
-0.5188087224960327,
-0.061944399029016495,
-0.160225048661232,
0.2543262541294098,
-0.03623814880847931,
0.2645779848098755,
-0.1430596560239792,
0.36529797315597534,
-0.23609580099582672,
-0.2811643183231354,
0.4570339322090149,
0.19864581525325775,
-0.5027572512626648,
0.23860135674476624,
0.6851361989974976,
0.17869052290916443,
0.2429593950510025,
-0.7765147686004639,
-0.2843254804611206,
0.19717472791671753,
0.2765366733074188,
-1.0164052248001099,
-0.5666170120239258,
0.31954607367515564,
-0.42709460854530334,
-0.128353551030159,
-0.12067879736423492,
-0.5219846963882446,
-0.46794795989990234,
-0.20448611676692963,
0.3728138506412506,
-0.4846447706222534,
0.022154994308948517,
0.304082453250885,
-0.02333921566605568,
-0.13806018233299255,
0.5227953791618347,
-0.47024068236351013,
0.7345302104949951,
0.5114130973815918,
0.7410285472869873,
-0.5465191006660461,
0.08417070657014847,
-0.6153373718261719,
-0.09359365701675415,
-0.16843761503696442,
0.7685777544975281,
-0.49039459228515625,
-0.48318183422088623,
-0.15056748688220978,
0.5221348404884338,
-0.6150822639465332,
-0.8384419083595276,
0.5597869753837585,
-0.42306429147720337,
-0.1481322944164276,
0.09314873814582825,
-0.7099230289459229,
-0.28701022267341614,
-0.0072954208590090275,
-0.8094844222068787,
0.7222246527671814,
-0.04296097159385681,
-0.6383416652679443,
0.42057985067367554,
-0.29325053095817566,
-0.13338781893253326,
0.668956995010376,
-0.33576175570487976,
-0.6063835024833679,
-0.10055173933506012,
0.2219388335943222,
0.5833988785743713,
-0.2061580866575241,
0.3115547299385071,
0.0604776069521904,
-0.07355426996946335,
0.2901846468448639,
-0.3447212278842926,
0.7693220973014832,
-0.06774629652500153,
-0.36203086376190186,
-0.024328527972102165,
-1.0875941514968872,
0.03737639635801315,
0.07163538038730621,
-0.019601956009864807,
-0.3553922176361084,
-0.3154916763305664,
0.3303990960121155,
0.04914122819900513,
-0.24257908761501312,
-0.7847656011581421,
-0.2561539113521576,
-0.4007021188735962,
0.44372084736824036,
0.20364977419376373,
0.3195817470550537,
-0.10836530476808548,
-0.05256076157093048,
0.5062955617904663,
-0.02537453919649124,
-0.14843431115150452,
0.145202174782753,
-0.6201120018959045,
-0.6057568192481995,
-1.0204704999923706,
0.857734739780426,
0.6792101263999939,
-0.416611909866333,
0.1910882294178009,
-0.26374638080596924,
-0.5165290832519531,
-0.586259663105011,
-0.10439011454582214,
0.4586670398712158,
0.49697697162628174,
0.5737650990486145,
-0.4906337857246399,
-0.3823215365409851,
-1.310070276260376,
-0.20267468690872192,
0.2151675820350647,
-0.10234455019235611,
0.4846589267253876,
0.9590791463851929,
-0.6497460603713989,
0.4189913868904114,
-0.24806609749794006,
-0.13078737258911133,
-0.0480230338871479,
0.17981092631816864,
0.058259446173906326,
0.4405454397201538,
0.6275701522827148,
-0.6378464698791504,
-0.1698669046163559,
-0.07196743786334991,
-0.6960854530334473,
-0.08850361406803131,
0.19811218976974487,
-0.030593575909733772,
0.007836486212909222,
0.3172799348831177,
-0.49706771969795227,
0.5462867021560669,
0.6704606413841248,
-0.0027147524524480104,
0.3944331705570221,
-0.21125352382659912,
0.20150935649871826,
-0.7543074488639832,
0.20615549385547638,
-0.04303015023469925,
-0.8147343993186951,
-0.7055965065956116,
-0.02089356817305088,
0.4108574092388153,
-0.32294708490371704,
-0.654189944267273,
0.8496806621551514,
-0.6481884717941284,
0.22662924230098724,
0.03606553003191948,
0.19217462837696075,
0.1098799854516983,
0.32922104001045227,
0.786219596862793,
0.4148590862751007,
0.49204015731811523,
-0.45747804641723633,
0.16224102675914764,
0.23265472054481506,
-0.4906836152076721,
0.35915568470954895,
-0.7703404426574707,
0.14368025958538055,
0.040917228907346725,
0.2585401237010956,
-0.7006999254226685,
-0.053278543055057526,
0.08030663430690765,
-0.20299404859542847,
0.5009171962738037,
-0.11075489968061447,
-0.4122273325920105,
-0.344456285238266,
0.09783577173948288,
0.37319982051849365,
0.34243080019950867,
-0.4645465612411499,
0.14523518085479736,
0.39066842198371887,
-0.18294338881969452,
-0.3203210234642029,
-0.7832996845245361,
0.2423950880765915,
-0.13665658235549927,
-0.42462268471717834,
0.5998252630233765,
0.06744884699583054,
-0.1161295473575592,
-0.25973939895629883,
-0.2202000766992569,
-0.20617641508579254,
-0.04428518936038017,
0.2873877286911011,
0.26414862275123596,
-0.2837609648704529,
0.3067980408668518,
-0.14519596099853516,
-0.3289611339569092,
-0.13581077754497528,
-0.03623044118285179,
0.18130868673324585,
-0.224704772233963,
-0.2227967381477356,
-0.21580415964126587,
0.35959509015083313,
0.3023011386394501,
-0.380629301071167,
1.046765923500061,
0.5168401598930359,
-0.9547482132911682,
-0.0302926953881979,
-0.713994026184082,
-0.2256460189819336,
-0.304756760597229,
0.23627027869224548,
-0.3302758038043976,
-0.8655881285667419,
0.5775997638702393,
-0.16161775588989258,
-0.22616268694400787,
0.6774773597717285,
0.6764594316482544,
0.2645021677017212,
0.659815788269043,
0.43222787976264954,
0.4034152328968048,
-0.272878497838974,
-0.12211095541715622,
0.4564920961856842,
-0.6364772319793701,
-0.2684503197669983,
-0.5810806155204773,
0.16013561189174652,
-0.8204044103622437,
-0.6149880290031433,
0.3263390362262726,
0.10037863254547119,
0.12747043371200562,
0.7525995969772339,
-0.661740243434906,
0.11222267150878906,
0.17859908938407898,
0.29740896821022034,
0.4977591633796692,
0.06372309476137161,
-0.4810689389705658,
-0.3448050618171692,
-0.6525651812553406,
-1.0012680292129517,
0.7835574746131897,
0.6998386979103088,
0.32944047451019287,
-0.03997962176799774,
0.873349666595459,
0.30685165524482727,
0.7190852165222168,
-0.4938426911830902,
0.4667908549308777,
-0.26573264598846436,
-0.5026964545249939,
0.1268519163131714,
-0.3658781945705414,
-0.9387833476066589,
0.3287726938724518,
-0.40178677439689636,
-1.0383250713348389,
0.5784873366355896,
-0.2633714973926544,
-0.39840325713157654,
0.19147197902202606,
-0.46381598711013794,
1.0640013217926025,
-0.1444094032049179,
-0.28642886877059937,
0.22552235424518585,
-0.42340990900993347,
0.27075767517089844,
-0.22013044357299805,
0.23094885051250458,
-0.19225303828716278,
0.04363219067454338,
0.8194687366485596,
-0.2783300280570984,
0.5998675227165222,
0.12305215001106262,
0.13957804441452026,
-0.1806439757347107,
0.05071886256337166,
0.27032727003097534,
0.3967265784740448,
-0.025199195370078087,
0.9018995761871338,
0.3613978326320648,
-0.11088650673627853,
-0.08804634213447571,
0.7647631168365479,
-0.4577491581439972,
-0.3049973249435425,
-0.6015074253082275,
-0.30454859137535095,
-0.26916924118995667,
0.40651872754096985,
0.5144615173339844,
0.7678963541984558,
-0.5867766737937927,
0.17921000719070435,
0.7614713311195374,
-0.5348940491676331,
0.02093346416950226,
0.9022821187973022,
-0.17370617389678955,
-0.47576940059661865,
0.5920832753181458,
-0.06449252367019653,
0.16962888836860657,
0.6619524359703064,
-0.18845538794994354,
-0.3155341148376465,
-0.6387031674385071,
-0.6161001920700073,
0.49469417333602905,
-0.6344770193099976,
-0.29676130414009094,
-1.3964792490005493,
-0.6578388214111328,
-0.4708314836025238,
-0.007080656476318836,
-0.48548346757888794,
-0.4617055356502533,
0.0659429281949997,
0.019763294607400894,
0.19993017613887787,
0.39888453483581543,
0.12214741855859756,
-0.03501494228839874,
-0.7617045640945435,
0.3418523371219635,
0.019771143794059753,
0.3647345304489136,
-0.46680086851119995,
-0.18836510181427002,
-0.0924467071890831,
-0.1469133347272873,
-0.001521124504506588,
-1.1335233449935913,
0.5348737239837646,
0.03408452868461609,
0.8414438366889954,
0.270221471786499,
-0.15081648528575897,
0.30867284536361694,
-0.8587319254875183,
0.3376223146915436,
0.02024821937084198,
-0.6060378551483154,
0.2535059452056885,
-0.044191356748342514,
-0.016043325886130333,
0.6620381474494934,
0.4767916798591614,
-0.46088922023773193,
-0.4090830385684967,
-0.7302035689353943,
-0.5788902640342712,
0.385336697101593,
0.767151951789856,
-0.30831795930862427,
-0.3460030257701874,
0.1636897772550583,
0.32240602374076843,
0.44145870208740234,
-0.7091536521911621,
-0.4252481460571289,
0.272372305393219,
-0.0014516091905534267,
-0.1622226983308792,
-0.17776712775230408,
-0.22999928891658783,
-0.115892693400383,
0.6989046931266785,
0.1580238789319992,
0.6926714181900024,
0.5123109221458435,
-0.3003300726413727,
0.11505384743213654,
0.3020694851875305,
0.6460456848144531,
0.45477309823036194,
-0.4499349296092987,
0.03945127874612808,
0.20814846456050873,
-0.5976670980453491,
-0.10698150098323822,
0.568202018737793,
-0.08555195480585098,
0.5669132471084595,
0.7042046189308167,
0.8644523620605469,
0.4682064652442932,
-0.7435125112533569,
0.27542752027511597,
-0.18395519256591797,
-0.31030574440956116,
-0.271077036857605,
-0.15954242646694183,
0.16339297592639923,
0.3060320317745209,
-0.08496065437793732,
0.15994201600551605,
0.33744820952415466,
-0.24324439465999603,
0.25723549723625183,
0.5654773116111755,
-0.5576716661453247,
-0.02443915791809559,
0.8884037733078003,
-0.09123178571462631,
-0.4967917501926422,
0.45607683062553406,
-0.23053303360939026,
-0.4756294786930084,
0.6421637535095215,
0.3636392652988434,
1.0846014022827148,
-0.44471096992492676,
0.25936925411224365,
0.4663238525390625,
0.43101662397384644,
0.019810395315289497,
-0.15797796845436096,
0.06863652914762497,
-0.7032725811004639,
-0.01572921872138977,
-0.9046403765678406,
-0.4228578805923462,
0.36022526025772095,
-0.6079825162887573,
0.264302134513855,
-0.3438914716243744,
-0.3780999183654785,
0.6011738777160645,
-0.05504848062992096,
-0.9776100516319275,
0.5155127644538879,
0.17808495461940765,
0.8662295937538147,
-0.7064089179039001,
0.7109575271606445,
0.7059923410415649,
-0.27110543847084045,
-0.48257148265838623,
-0.38593560457229614,
-0.09099134802818298,
-0.8173448443412781,
0.741427481174469,
0.39286983013153076,
0.0043485211208462715,
-0.09423534572124481,
0.0030551175586879253,
-0.5986924767494202,
0.9423788189888,
0.13951140642166138,
-0.8393265604972839,
0.22745724022388458,
0.23067040741443634,
0.9648778438568115,
-0.7206457257270813,
0.3604964315891266,
0.5538160800933838,
0.21530403196811676,
-0.06384020298719406,
-1.0615547895431519,
0.0006058699218556285,
-0.2201303243637085,
-0.004678631667047739,
0.027408244088292122,
-0.3346080780029297,
0.5531250834465027,
-0.05979081615805626,
-0.44690024852752686,
0.12404856085777283,
0.18159976601600647,
0.38059625029563904,
0.5530069470405579,
0.21494059264659882,
0.38287660479545593,
0.8093443512916565,
-0.12760469317436218,
1.0243679285049438,
-0.45047640800476074,
0.3730178475379944,
0.8324181437492371,
-0.5191728472709656,
0.6642157435417175,
0.1423206925392151,
-0.3351145088672638,
0.5325192213058472,
0.5125285387039185,
0.040903471410274506,
0.49435877799987793,
0.23980358242988586,
-0.32785165309906006,
-0.21274903416633606,
-0.040671758353710175,
-0.45884454250335693,
0.299009770154953,
0.38247063755989075,
-0.6889435648918152,
-0.13847136497497559,
0.2942427396774292,
0.01745735853910446,
0.09000011533498764,
-0.15887224674224854,
0.5955908298492432,
0.32570332288742065,
-0.3298793137073517,
0.6854227781295776,
0.23166705667972565,
0.07967986166477203,
-0.4311719834804535,
-0.06008489057421684,
-0.11473900079727173,
0.3404058814048767,
-0.15450970828533173,
-0.146829292178154,
0.12105388194322586,
0.05636114999651909,
-0.10908988118171692,
-0.0578354112803936,
0.678518533706665,
-0.4726532995700836,
-1.001470685005188,
0.5716079473495483,
0.44837069511413574,
0.371567964553833,
-0.08497481048107147,
-0.8143743276596069,
-0.019729526713490486,
-0.3520069122314453,
0.05134405568242073,
0.19917196035385132,
0.15421895682811737,
-0.2436293363571167,
0.5284507870674133,
0.3164089024066925,
0.30719977617263794,
-0.10745470225811005,
0.346067875623703,
0.49353307485580444,
-0.42263853549957275,
-0.38271382451057434,
-0.5857561230659485,
0.16961441934108734,
-0.10923998057842255,
0.09114228188991547,
0.7391305565834045,
0.7279640436172485,
0.5086642503738403,
-0.31938984990119934,
0.45744588971138,
0.4875929653644562,
0.841767430305481,
-0.554310142993927,
0.7913978695869446,
-0.3719650208950043,
0.31855106353759766,
-0.4883464276790619,
-0.9605445861816406,
-0.46125710010528564,
0.6161838173866272,
-0.40252137184143066,
0.08989163488149643,
1.0123083591461182,
0.8477030396461487,
-0.2581688463687897,
0.07378455251455307,
0.709256649017334,
0.16589520871639252,
0.13389098644256592,
0.6168928742408752,
0.24768789112567902,
-0.7217506170272827,
-0.14857184886932373,
-0.45611247420310974,
-0.2803228795528412,
-0.17744731903076172,
-0.8783549666404724,
-1.127449631690979,
-0.36202433705329895,
-0.7273180484771729,
-0.4419211447238922,
0.5163206458091736,
0.7608860731124878,
0.7338882088661194,
-1.2888113260269165,
0.2407958060503006,
0.030863765627145767,
-0.18871836364269257,
-0.42930930852890015,
-0.18644976615905762,
0.6762556433677673,
0.22255802154541016,
-0.6966825723648071,
0.5279570817947388,
0.6311782002449036,
-0.06604571640491486,
-0.22731170058250427,
0.08011096715927124,
-0.02942987158894539,
0.20390842854976654,
0.5008386373519897,
0.19180816411972046,
-0.7590728998184204,
-0.12957945466041565,
-0.030718062072992325,
-0.5421366691589355,
0.10634025931358337,
0.9403538703918457,
-0.9247689843177795,
0.5654116272926331,
0.04921892285346985,
0.5192099213600159,
0.6705300211906433,
-0.25549042224884033,
0.2261848896741867,
-0.4484883248806,
0.3525829315185547,
0.45000821352005005,
0.5583454966545105,
0.4251883625984192,
-0.3475660979747772,
0.6702991127967834,
0.44683852791786194,
-0.5361983180046082,
-0.774061918258667,
-0.08178318291902542,
-0.8821384310722351,
0.05981431528925896,
0.9339572787284851,
-0.24214749038219452,
0.04512564465403557,
-0.1865883469581604,
0.003454097779467702,
0.18801555037498474,
-0.12116880714893341,
0.4510011374950409,
0.5109389424324036,
-0.16089573502540588,
-0.3212377727031708,
-1.0048437118530273,
0.5757845044136047,
0.18440894782543182,
-0.5307844281196594,
-0.3581411838531494,
0.3183940649032593,
0.4561522603034973,
0.06634587794542313,
0.7855580449104309,
-0.3741513192653656,
0.20134343206882477,
0.021742025390267372,
0.17138049006462097,
0.07771827280521393,
-0.265981525182724,
-0.20368152856826782,
-0.11334101110696793,
-0.2838901877403259,
-0.0008287086966447532
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19201v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19201v1
|
Understanding Archives: Towards New Research Interfaces Relying on the Semantic Annotation of Documents
| 2024-03-28T07:55:29 | 2024-03-28T07:55:29 |
Nicolas Gutehrlé, Iana Atanassova
|
cs.DL
|
cs.DL, cs.CL
|
The digitisation campaigns carried out by libraries and archives in recent
years have facilitated access to documents in their collections. However,
exploring and exploiting these documents remain difficult tasks due to the
sheer quantity of documents available for consultation. In this article, we
show how the semantic annotation of the textual content of study corpora of
archival documents allow to facilitate their exploitation and valorisation.
First, we present a methodological framework for the construction of new
interfaces based on textual semantics, then address the current technological
obstacles and their potential solutions. We conclude by presenting a practical
case of the application of this framework.
|
[
-0.8737220168113708,
-0.3875434994697571,
0.9251242280006409,
-0.37964320182800293,
-0.2304910272359848,
0.006893318146467209,
-0.021984515711665154,
-0.6480420827865601,
0.45022687315940857,
0.8408287167549133,
-0.8513197302818298,
-0.5882606506347656,
-0.6195036768913269,
0.5181305408477783,
-0.4255830943584442,
0.6069833040237427,
-0.35280048847198486,
0.10922352969646454,
-0.5410142540931702,
-0.37226569652557373,
-0.6186249256134033,
-0.5906599760055542,
-0.23150335252285004,
-0.19136673212051392,
0.3703295886516571,
0.31286120414733887,
0.6867861151695251,
0.6608723998069763,
0.7100571393966675,
0.4150533080101013,
-0.02862001769244671,
0.27509525418281555,
-0.3832530379295349,
0.2655986249446869,
-0.008115126751363277,
-0.7096352577209473,
0.12325425446033478,
-0.04770161584019661,
0.2995448708534241,
0.7451850771903992,
0.43021947145462036,
0.060760024935007095,
-0.24752621352672577,
0.3452857732772827,
-0.5849272012710571,
0.09756866842508316,
-0.25589290261268616,
0.1366005539894104,
-0.3516615033149719,
-1.0996652841567993,
-0.3370201885700226,
-0.188299298286438,
0.110151506960392,
-1.3863834142684937,
0.050115227699279785,
0.18546143174171448,
0.7407382726669312,
-0.013166572898626328,
-0.225610613822937,
-0.90096116065979,
-0.6951190829277039,
0.6770730018615723,
-0.4128430485725403,
0.4558062255382538,
0.6456025838851929,
0.5426491498947144,
-0.18896210193634033,
-1.0419255495071411,
-0.20411887764930725,
0.13508667051792145,
-0.4530206620693207,
-0.21390607953071594,
-0.11012743413448334,
-0.2604908347129822,
0.07088623940944672,
0.28375154733657837,
-0.19865214824676514,
0.026519890874624252,
-0.5278405547142029,
-0.3287949860095978,
0.35252267122268677,
0.24159573018550873,
0.6332187056541443,
-0.3234606981277466,
-0.4593660235404968,
-0.010603660717606544,
-0.6483733654022217,
-0.5717669129371643,
0.6248302459716797,
0.019113169983029366,
0.30440962314605713,
0.7161803245544434,
-0.14612948894500732,
0.4833914041519165,
-0.31119978427886963,
0.28511446714401245,
0.43525955080986023,
-0.36156564950942993,
-0.001394773949868977,
0.07153420150279999,
0.24422509968280792,
0.2277836948633194,
0.06670857965946198,
-0.3425610363483429,
0.04330029338598251,
0.17857806384563446,
0.3519105911254883,
-0.4814710021018982,
-0.1200137808918953,
0.3974176049232483,
-0.5396048426628113,
-0.07411137223243713,
0.07586470991373062,
-0.6008415222167969,
-0.31460797786712646,
-0.7489688396453857,
0.6072108149528503,
-0.7218116521835327,
-0.45856615900993347,
0.21700561046600342,
-0.8510605096817017,
0.13737355172634125,
0.7613465785980225,
-1.0051690340042114,
0.4496780037879944,
1.1512877941131592,
0.7802244424819946,
0.22721943259239197,
-0.14722348749637604,
-0.4811916649341583,
0.248244971036911,
-0.09002247452735901,
0.9205588102340698,
-0.5311869382858276,
-0.6818376779556274,
0.3140425384044647,
0.38390904664993286,
0.5397864580154419,
-0.4619464874267578,
0.7847071290016174,
-0.5520765781402588,
0.33206915855407715,
-0.24067528545856476,
-0.538368821144104,
-0.3068585693836212,
0.18921536207199097,
-0.895905613899231,
0.9334955215454102,
0.2607538104057312,
-0.858675479888916,
0.43387311697006226,
-0.7626112103462219,
-0.029871027916669846,
0.3069179952144623,
-0.1433136910200119,
0.3684976398944855,
0.13406147062778473,
-0.2160511314868927,
0.3154984712600708,
-0.14681003987789154,
0.16514664888381958,
-0.2597513198852539,
-0.0651312991976738,
0.1527872383594513,
0.07499682903289795,
0.9022017121315002,
0.46560823917388916,
-0.01532914862036705,
-0.11489149183034897,
-0.8788251876831055,
-0.5819450616836548,
-0.28548792004585266,
0.025680815801024437,
-1.2727468013763428,
-0.17540059983730316,
0.3169451951980591,
-0.07052955776453018,
0.23970048129558563,
-0.30501458048820496,
0.43053096532821655,
-0.23170047998428345,
0.3094967007637024,
0.36893391609191895,
-0.013965311460196972,
0.640272855758667,
-0.2691096365451813,
0.29429885745048523,
-0.10480083525180817,
0.0961182713508606,
-0.6424345374107361,
-0.281981885433197,
-0.3197343647480011,
-0.2164161503314972,
0.32170501351356506,
0.15767903625965118,
-0.8177851438522339,
0.025189317762851715,
-0.34564828872680664,
-0.16511310636997223,
-0.6130619049072266,
0.1499936729669571,
-0.11700990796089172,
0.44358062744140625,
0.2596796154975891,
-0.5858020782470703,
-0.8010201454162598,
-0.8039058446884155,
0.09991481900215149,
-0.14715425670146942,
-0.4068467915058136,
0.5104819536209106,
0.4888303875923157,
-0.19900664687156677,
0.9574943780899048,
-0.11547533422708511,
-0.44850125908851624,
0.4315759837627411,
0.9594501256942749,
-0.02314901165664196,
0.2630597949028015,
0.09421972185373306,
-1.5119595527648926,
0.32496124505996704,
0.11385712027549744,
-1.275431513786316,
-0.3489631116390228,
-0.20439277589321136,
-0.41348496079444885,
0.002965659601613879,
0.5292753577232361,
-0.3214666545391083,
0.3292865753173828,
0.020301448181271553,
-0.42065921425819397,
0.17517365515232086,
-0.27809765934944153,
0.5193231105804443,
-0.7150071859359741,
0.04863696172833443,
-0.20224744081497192,
0.09974978119134903,
-0.6004230976104736,
0.04527801275253296,
0.03525752201676369,
-0.2747358977794647,
-0.9289140105247498,
0.616355836391449,
-0.8144941329956055,
-0.06391365081071854,
-0.20274457335472107,
0.7766673564910889,
0.31679120659828186,
-0.038294319063425064,
0.39913615584373474,
0.26810577511787415,
0.2602997124195099,
-0.22801615297794342,
0.23124897480010986,
0.854844331741333,
-0.09211232513189316,
0.8046090006828308,
0.020370837301015854,
-0.09340770542621613,
-0.42080315947532654,
-0.010829081758856773,
-0.8443953990936279,
-0.12167174369096756,
0.18945364654064178,
-0.7220327258110046,
0.34683215618133545,
-0.2915726602077484,
-0.47044289112091064,
0.16381359100341797,
-0.6438874006271362,
0.3968183398246765,
0.22452175617218018,
-0.52567058801651,
1.0266777276992798,
0.5430841445922852,
-0.03969968855381012,
-0.44851985573768616,
-0.8429487347602844,
0.5693813562393188,
-0.37260037660598755,
-0.9955530166625977,
0.05409563332796097,
0.06708678603172302,
-0.7385712265968323,
0.5960099697113037,
0.25770074129104614,
-0.29424425959587097,
0.2510879933834076,
0.45093798637390137,
0.3449232876300812,
-0.18267913162708282,
0.04475836828351021,
-0.21500198543071747,
-0.4435131847858429,
0.17291446030139923,
-0.14839769899845123,
0.30292314291000366,
0.41056013107299805,
-0.3132084012031555,
-0.22798636555671692,
0.7607429623603821,
0.5244916081428528,
-0.11272244155406952,
0.5725890398025513,
0.5134791135787964,
-0.3852126896381378,
0.2089943140745163,
-0.7627045512199402,
-0.0963059589266777,
-0.4444803297519684,
-0.13046251237392426,
-0.5298051238059998,
-0.8400923609733582,
0.45983654260635376,
-0.5158064961433411,
0.018734309822320938,
0.5814363956451416,
0.2665594220161438,
0.21012011170387268,
0.1287367194890976,
0.45362767577171326,
0.3844006657600403,
0.06375037133693695,
-0.38868239521980286,
0.12837284803390503,
-1.2486326694488525,
-0.500065803527832,
-0.8973772525787354,
0.16014255583286285,
-0.5797305107116699,
-0.25560396909713745,
0.21323628723621368,
0.044009651988744736,
0.28243356943130493,
0.4993002414703369,
-0.6044608950614929,
-0.0718778446316719,
0.4192475378513336,
-0.07636354863643646,
0.6359153985977173,
-0.2760085463523865,
0.42298421263694763,
-0.101877860724926,
-0.4444321393966675,
-0.9340249300003052,
0.9769186973571777,
0.2806906998157501,
0.7595482468605042,
-0.05845298990607262,
0.9774165749549866,
0.3738388121128082,
0.2925111651420593,
-0.5349610447883606,
0.3448692560195923,
0.08393576741218567,
-0.6762679219245911,
-0.29619795083999634,
-0.09739437699317932,
-1.0634592771530151,
0.01210334338247776,
-0.4572816789150238,
-0.7560052275657654,
0.8619353771209717,
-0.3136230409145355,
0.13638845086097717,
0.11358921974897385,
-0.7073665261268616,
0.7518723011016846,
-0.2864934504032135,
-0.697973906993866,
-0.105926014482975,
-0.7008047103881836,
0.18216201663017273,
0.013131599873304367,
0.7638869881629944,
-0.06618133187294006,
-0.2852023243904114,
0.7120274901390076,
-0.2082083374261856,
0.5511798858642578,
-0.1346856951713562,
0.08275436609983444,
0.4150647521018982,
0.38582995533943176,
0.27397194504737854,
-0.1816837191581726,
-0.2565389573574066,
0.10428723692893982,
0.4597460627555847,
-0.22562286257743835,
-0.5960410833358765,
0.6342110633850098,
-0.39068087935447693,
-0.5494204163551331,
-0.30640077590942383,
-0.42311158776283264,
-0.0056763021275401115,
0.3415059447288513,
-0.15226122736930847,
0.7959648966789246,
-0.3723120391368866,
0.20610064268112183,
0.6670917272567749,
-0.07759939879179001,
0.002902598585933447,
0.2928367257118225,
-0.015966810286045074,
0.01740245334804058,
0.6639026999473572,
0.2189871221780777,
-0.008674846962094307,
0.6710678935050964,
-0.0008185699116438627,
-0.44330474734306335,
-0.6287238597869873,
-0.39385491609573364,
0.0003910922387149185,
-1.1448618173599243,
0.04059552401304245,
-0.8377216458320618,
0.3904343247413635,
-0.38843032717704773,
-0.5174027681350708,
0.32686305046081543,
-0.5320805311203003,
-0.5199756622314453,
-0.06469397246837616,
0.5630260705947876,
0.7566152811050415,
-0.17000384628772736,
-0.08931995183229446,
-0.7882965207099915,
0.49792107939720154,
-0.1676996946334839,
0.2738834321498871,
-0.09789049625396729,
-0.05323392525315285,
-0.17340338230133057,
-0.35657861828804016,
0.18121276795864105,
-0.9319738745689392,
0.26243865489959717,
-0.3357299864292145,
0.5514612793922424,
-0.00808730162680149,
0.28189927339553833,
0.15625940263271332,
-0.5184728503227234,
0.670478880405426,
-0.3497946560382843,
-0.5285738706588745,
0.4368145763874054,
-0.5488768219947815,
-0.20136922597885132,
0.9262306690216064,
0.9112045764923096,
-0.37738436460494995,
-0.30750763416290283,
-0.9408940672874451,
-1.2956675291061401,
0.39973780512809753,
-0.06773152202367783,
0.11490478366613388,
-0.17221248149871826,
0.2309054583311081,
0.4272967576980591,
0.18694539368152618,
-0.22197827696800232,
0.13562962412834167,
-0.12706820666790009,
-0.17469638586044312,
0.2953309118747711,
-0.4778604805469513,
-0.45168542861938477,
0.3750900328159332,
0.791282057762146,
0.11801894009113312,
-0.07457917183637619,
0.43925610184669495,
-0.20808765292167664,
0.2495599091053009,
0.22140902280807495,
-0.008946429006755352,
0.9071910381317139,
-0.28753331303596497,
0.35790255665779114,
-0.060551807284355164,
-0.11465369910001755,
-0.1120728924870491,
0.08319052308797836,
-0.1913868486881256,
0.40646839141845703,
0.3924579322338104,
0.635194718837738,
0.6404252648353577,
-0.5751142501831055,
0.38882026076316833,
-0.13608352839946747,
-0.505560576915741,
-0.6956363320350647,
-0.23240162432193756,
0.19294382631778717,
0.053951144218444824,
0.45162031054496765,
-0.3920024335384369,
0.5050123929977417,
-0.9118580222129822,
0.3380953073501587,
0.4534168541431427,
-0.07398217171430588,
0.2571024000644684,
0.5862586498260498,
0.21085047721862793,
-0.6240697503089905,
0.28013476729393005,
0.03747415915131569,
-0.233308345079422,
0.285495400428772,
0.190961554646492,
0.6830741763114929,
0.3995310366153717,
0.03304942697286606,
0.077536441385746,
0.09451668709516525,
-0.18350180983543396,
-0.16996319591999054,
-0.4470234215259552,
-0.2904772162437439,
-0.12779344618320465,
-0.555928111076355,
-0.7949845194816589,
-0.3828508257865906,
-0.6595607399940491,
0.6367939114570618,
-0.047483786940574646,
0.25470852851867676,
0.41157540678977966,
-0.15020771324634552,
-0.5484545826911926,
0.19457270205020905,
-0.048225849866867065,
1.350614309310913,
-0.9836081266403198,
0.40226030349731445,
0.3915289342403412,
-0.5740346312522888,
-0.4397149085998535,
-0.7512710094451904,
0.21875710785388947,
-0.7018874883651733,
0.8672792911529541,
-0.18614976108074188,
-0.00722295418381691,
-0.27061185240745544,
-0.059567518532276154,
-0.37520021200180054,
0.9757669568061829,
-0.08447234332561493,
-0.12357260286808014,
0.1790771633386612,
0.08708236366510391,
0.5425561666488647,
-0.33403220772743225,
0.4934377372264862,
0.5961580872535706,
1.026436448097229,
0.09868457168340683,
-0.159413680434227,
0.1598156839609146,
-0.6593702435493469,
-0.20748475193977356,
0.4672333300113678,
0.13293950259685516,
0.5902742743492126,
0.6282381415367126,
-0.37084993720054626,
0.3021821975708008,
0.5239863395690918,
-0.33745256066322327,
0.6545381546020508,
0.3068779408931732,
0.39086830615997314,
0.4483923316001892,
-0.31906840205192566,
1.247661828994751,
-0.13879859447479248,
-0.01790294237434864,
0.8428767919540405,
-0.06464704126119614,
0.5715640783309937,
0.8863732814788818,
0.025369243696331978,
0.2980736494064331,
0.6085444092750549,
-0.13130724430084229,
0.25773563981056213,
0.3852439522743225,
-0.6380939483642578,
0.30421409010887146,
-0.5339603424072266,
-0.21481411159038544,
0.09886875748634338,
0.5603426098823547,
-0.011866793967783451,
-0.3579590320587158,
0.2118404656648636,
0.12896785140037537,
0.5696922540664673,
-0.13727468252182007,
0.9370192885398865,
-0.2867383360862732,
-0.43759968876838684,
0.2280876785516739,
-0.2723209857940674,
0.5993401408195496,
-0.7438387274742126,
-0.43166714906692505,
0.14577902853488922,
-0.6801157593727112,
-0.6698951125144958,
-0.7522671818733215,
0.6131203770637512,
-0.2829391658306122,
0.009659843519330025,
-0.14234493672847748,
0.9232752919197083,
-0.1288459599018097,
-0.20903457701206207,
0.46430715918540955,
0.3720313012599945,
0.38811415433883667,
0.3824220895767212,
0.17045976221561432,
0.583371639251709,
-0.3903622329235077,
-0.15534135699272156,
0.528708815574646,
1.0816755294799805,
-0.24592110514640808,
0.23483961820602417,
0.7193041443824768,
0.30623066425323486,
-0.15286438167095184,
-0.015583992004394531,
0.635282039642334,
-0.3855053782463074,
-0.26324740052223206,
-0.4118139147758484,
0.4734937846660614,
-0.095622718334198,
-0.27828249335289,
0.5818168520927429,
0.5172890424728394,
1.015028715133667,
0.11666909605264664,
0.8539323210716248,
-0.30205684900283813,
0.49994510412216187,
-0.6796108484268188,
0.3872673511505127,
-0.6023039817810059,
0.37920650839805603,
-0.16340793669223785,
-0.4702930152416229,
-0.4567394256591797,
0.35292646288871765,
-0.49155673384666443,
-0.5238898396492004,
0.6775493025779724,
0.6579046845436096,
-0.303862065076828,
0.30788180232048035,
0.13438336551189423,
0.007589611224830151,
0.08093415200710297,
0.12584330141544342,
0.8521623015403748,
-0.21351510286331177,
0.2690139710903168,
-0.44993990659713745,
-0.20767146348953247,
-0.14028187096118927,
-1.1443921327590942,
-0.5328789353370667,
-1.0243167877197266,
0.22109587490558624,
-0.41235047578811646,
0.2826613485813141,
0.5754557847976685,
0.33977210521698,
-0.2773512005805969,
-0.17000283300876617,
0.1535479575395584,
-0.018374763429164886,
0.38808974623680115,
-0.21371035277843475,
0.5322924256324768,
-0.374949187040329,
-0.7146637439727783,
0.07826560735702515,
0.4597141444683075,
-0.28906890749931335,
-0.47628483176231384,
0.060920991003513336,
-0.5447790026664734,
-0.3270438015460968,
0.2782815992832184,
0.6719094514846802,
-0.28823578357696533,
-0.36269819736480713,
-0.26523682475090027,
0.2379453331232071,
0.2683221697807312,
1.2786893844604492,
-0.8659107089042664,
0.6540833711624146,
0.6199463605880737,
1.3211908340454102,
0.9117677807807922,
-0.16188795864582062,
0.5188097953796387,
-0.2542187571525574,
0.4545396566390991,
0.11180655658245087,
0.3928067088127136,
0.6765119433403015,
-0.6708498001098633,
0.8691185712814331,
0.0958651676774025,
-0.27972784638404846,
-0.6582691073417664,
-0.08987458050251007,
-1.0938102006912231,
-0.4429757297039032,
0.7533103227615356,
-0.12910766899585724,
-0.6922228932380676,
-0.6240307092666626,
-0.5514315962791443,
0.20285047590732574,
-0.030104555189609528,
0.7334561347961426,
0.8845871686935425,
-0.22479179501533508,
-0.11344682425260544,
-1.098543405532837,
0.24069644510746002,
0.27331650257110596,
-0.7590416669845581,
0.01777423545718193,
0.7186907529830933,
-0.05788121744990349,
0.6382774710655212,
0.8006649017333984,
-0.6059864163398743,
0.3845418095588684,
0.10995440930128098,
-0.057226404547691345,
-0.5362240076065063,
-0.14177286624908447,
-0.17847299575805664,
0.2116677612066269,
0.19447363913059235,
0.0445927269756794
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19725v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19725v1
|
MUGC: Machine Generated versus User Generated Content Detection
| 2024-03-28T07:33:53 | 2024-03-28T07:33:53 |
Yaqi Xie, Anjali Rawal, Yujing Cen, Dixuan Zhao, Sunil K Narang, Shanu Sushmita
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
As advanced modern systems like deep neural networks (DNNs) and generative AI
continue to enhance their capabilities in producing convincing and realistic
content, the need to distinguish between user-generated and machine generated
content is becoming increasingly evident. In this research, we undertake a
comparative evaluation of eight traditional machine-learning algorithms to
distinguish between machine-generated and human-generated data across three
diverse datasets: Poems, Abstracts, and Essays. Our results indicate that
traditional methods demonstrate a high level of accuracy in identifying
machine-generated data, reflecting the documented effectiveness of popular
pre-trained models like RoBERT. We note that machine-generated texts tend to be
shorter and exhibit less word variety compared to human-generated content.
While specific domain-related keywords commonly utilized by humans, albeit
disregarded by current LLMs (Large Language Models), may contribute to this
high detection accuracy, we show that deeper word representations like word2vec
can capture subtle semantic variances. Furthermore, readability, bias, moral,
and affect comparisons reveal a discernible contrast between machine-generated
and human generated content. There are variations in expression styles and
potentially underlying biases in the data sources (human and
machine-generated). This study provides valuable insights into the advancing
capacities and challenges associated with machine-generated content across
various domains.
|
[
-0.5426006317138672,
-0.7491815686225891,
0.3239235281944275,
0.003447817638516426,
-0.19049185514450073,
0.4544728994369507,
-0.2362653613090515,
-0.6558620929718018,
-0.13022713363170624,
0.7137501835823059,
-0.6112542748451233,
-0.6512883305549622,
-0.7558246850967407,
0.6178517937660217,
-0.32486632466316223,
0.7629616260528564,
-0.07761752605438232,
-0.1428951919078827,
-0.5350233912467957,
0.1873450130224228,
-0.6107383370399475,
-0.3677081763744354,
-0.526138186454773,
-0.5462641716003418,
0.5852692127227783,
0.1647181659936905,
0.5648061633110046,
0.48622119426727295,
0.4956108033657074,
0.30777987837791443,
0.03879452869296074,
0.8329333066940308,
-0.6177456378936768,
0.11955803632736206,
-0.07307258248329163,
-0.10475979745388031,
0.2618987560272217,
0.22211213409900665,
0.3919104337692261,
0.3765392303466797,
0.38619324564933777,
0.0723624974489212,
0.2680501639842987,
0.8442820310592651,
-0.8761985301971436,
0.06155500188469887,
-0.7445510625839233,
0.21577417850494385,
-0.263135701417923,
-0.445595920085907,
-0.6397202610969543,
-0.01962299831211567,
-0.12786562740802765,
-0.49694889783859253,
0.4875410199165344,
0.21396102011203766,
0.9379662275314331,
0.16394780576229095,
-0.3906150162220001,
-1.0074392557144165,
-0.7359064221382141,
0.9566618204116821,
-0.37384232878685,
0.18575534224510193,
0.490438848733902,
0.07170771807432175,
-0.4662894904613495,
-0.7745233774185181,
-0.9310657382011414,
-0.3058921694755554,
-0.10011892765760422,
0.16958433389663696,
-0.3811718225479126,
-0.453731894493103,
0.29259899258613586,
0.32556888461112976,
-0.8517863154411316,
0.40953555703163147,
-0.1951303631067276,
-0.4880989193916321,
0.9582728743553162,
0.40296807885169983,
0.709654688835144,
-0.5674628019332886,
-0.32920560240745544,
-0.22021624445915222,
-0.7795979976654053,
-0.04934747517108917,
0.7582992315292358,
0.061922747641801834,
0.20385877788066864,
0.625420331954956,
-0.11797782778739929,
0.5655459761619568,
-0.2248564511537552,
-0.11266477406024933,
0.1266961395740509,
-0.08010836690664291,
-0.009347105398774147,
0.03146756812930107,
1.2749990224838257,
0.3708966374397278,
0.4156935513019562,
-0.34004831314086914,
-0.16353394091129303,
0.13899226486682892,
0.40843063592910767,
-0.75445157289505,
-0.484650194644928,
-0.1356196105480194,
-0.6374680995941162,
-0.4077568054199219,
0.5797995924949646,
-0.46315112709999084,
-0.8899024128913879,
-0.3723073899745941,
-0.005267463158816099,
-0.23919960856437683,
-0.19821485877037048,
0.07114260643720627,
-0.44516676664352417,
0.2973105311393738,
0.2712078094482422,
-0.7322239875793457,
0.17740730941295624,
0.8310211300849915,
0.8859033584594727,
-0.6926181316375732,
-0.15211287140846252,
-0.34455034136772156,
-0.1505628377199173,
-0.6056241989135742,
0.9966820478439331,
-0.355698823928833,
-0.3559586703777313,
0.1192096471786499,
0.12383099645376205,
0.2635005712509155,
-0.8669388890266418,
0.6422547101974487,
-0.6452149152755737,
0.24126262962818146,
-0.5333986282348633,
-0.560695469379425,
-0.16446876525878906,
-0.07937415689229965,
-1.0328776836395264,
1.13291597366333,
0.31644901633262634,
-1.1885716915130615,
0.813232421875,
-0.3893054127693176,
-0.5842399597167969,
0.1650518774986267,
-0.4111408591270447,
-0.7000805735588074,
-0.10500694811344147,
0.1232106015086174,
0.6944143176078796,
-0.4568294584751129,
0.0614192895591259,
-0.4186069369316101,
-0.48704424500465393,
0.6754739284515381,
-0.48987850546836853,
0.8309957981109619,
0.605609118938446,
-0.4442427456378937,
-0.2282918393611908,
-0.676298975944519,
-0.07265104353427887,
0.44858527183532715,
-0.1452682763338089,
-0.24726653099060059,
0.31745800375938416,
0.18710839748382568,
0.17053595185279846,
-0.07607102394104004,
-0.4713627099990845,
-0.04411177337169647,
-0.023780344054102898,
0.5393667817115784,
0.586484432220459,
-0.08688423037528992,
0.12602277100086212,
-0.3266806900501251,
0.3382014334201813,
0.163009375333786,
-0.3952118456363678,
-0.2138112485408783,
-0.6731218099594116,
-0.1743544638156891,
-0.45365288853645325,
0.3479006886482239,
0.6113036274909973,
-0.7932939529418945,
0.6332557201385498,
-0.12928779423236847,
-0.361240953207016,
-0.5623714327812195,
0.2334582656621933,
0.2731444835662842,
0.415599524974823,
0.2586977779865265,
-0.5170655250549316,
-0.5647737979888916,
-0.60565584897995,
-0.43281641602516174,
-0.18177570402622223,
-0.43100056052207947,
0.6818347573280334,
0.5141199827194214,
-0.35749033093452454,
0.8916597962379456,
-0.754337728023529,
-0.002236185595393181,
-0.3378182649612427,
0.6200569868087769,
-0.3417753577232361,
0.27365055680274963,
0.5821185111999512,
-0.8809795379638672,
-0.5814747214317322,
0.10475163906812668,
-1.057518482208252,
-0.32051366567611694,
-0.2633635997772217,
-0.09223854541778564,
0.04100396856665611,
0.09262233227491379,
-0.3555704355239868,
0.7969474196434021,
0.23672209680080414,
-0.19898244738578796,
0.6151221394538879,
0.006199326831847429,
0.4804140031337738,
-0.8706256747245789,
-0.0287016648799181,
-0.13940118253231049,
-0.26084956526756287,
-0.48259323835372925,
-0.2840496599674225,
0.03881188482046127,
-0.11290939897298813,
-0.31902992725372314,
0.511736273765564,
-0.590076744556427,
-0.26642027497291565,
-0.6841592788696289,
0.3031565845012665,
0.422333300113678,
0.09364744275808334,
0.25407207012176514,
0.9783210754394531,
0.2304348349571228,
-0.5889952778816223,
0.5375867486000061,
0.24722331762313843,
-0.6072260737419128,
0.32011017203330994,
-0.5730734467506409,
0.47787606716156006,
-0.10978101193904877,
0.3134588599205017,
-1.041121006011963,
-0.41889268159866333,
0.4244075119495392,
-0.7404026389122009,
0.1939917653799057,
0.2768688201904297,
-0.7680914998054504,
-0.5263083577156067,
-0.37213948369026184,
0.1768198311328888,
0.5541446805000305,
-0.5518301129341125,
0.12643836438655853,
0.3238118886947632,
0.05641747638583183,
-0.45794451236724854,
-0.9139953851699829,
0.3975919783115387,
-0.08057516813278198,
-0.7100944519042969,
0.437194287776947,
0.07116924971342087,
-0.27853408455848694,
-0.014967693015933037,
0.2599979639053345,
-0.1680789291858673,
0.18983469903469086,
0.3280597925186157,
0.10231059789657593,
-0.19579251110553741,
0.00750715471804142,
0.0007942075608298182,
0.08295852690935135,
-0.07870928198099136,
-0.2424054741859436,
0.572587788105011,
0.16971004009246826,
-0.3636419177055359,
-0.6288449764251709,
0.49864068627357483,
0.20905110239982605,
-0.15864045917987823,
0.7892345786094666,
1.260780930519104,
-0.257547527551651,
-0.24433603882789612,
-0.3877842426300049,
-0.08453573286533356,
-0.4143885672092438,
-0.04483891651034355,
-0.3027714788913727,
-0.9374188184738159,
0.43735355138778687,
-0.06519857794046402,
-0.19366712868213654,
0.679374635219574,
0.765438437461853,
-0.2731601893901825,
1.0693289041519165,
0.3910791575908661,
-0.020044073462486267,
0.3521016836166382,
-0.23349326848983765,
0.20004281401634216,
-0.7624689936637878,
-0.08969864249229431,
-0.7206284999847412,
-0.2536781132221222,
-0.9417784214019775,
-0.11840159446001053,
-0.27125659584999084,
0.02557842619717121,
-0.0834031030535698,
0.5267249345779419,
-0.7829666137695312,
0.3199689984321594,
0.49182844161987305,
0.11318887770175934,
0.29882195591926575,
-0.051343388855457306,
0.11661722511053085,
0.03358951956033707,
-0.45829758048057556,
-0.9376189708709717,
1.1197783946990967,
0.09334911406040192,
0.5924065113067627,
-0.0647033229470253,
0.623075544834137,
1.092956781387329,
0.19560682773590088,
-0.7845717668533325,
0.27740710973739624,
-0.36348050832748413,
-0.42899900674819946,
0.008669916540384293,
-0.5085244178771973,
-1.1959294080734253,
0.03798246383666992,
-0.45851218700408936,
-0.5923648476600647,
0.01933687925338745,
-0.07829666137695312,
0.071752168238163,
0.49486082792282104,
-0.7029200792312622,
0.8043558597564697,
-0.0330820307135582,
-0.29012027382850647,
0.04007653146982193,
-0.4433935880661011,
0.2320166975259781,
-0.01996014639735222,
0.0022661176044493914,
-0.1794183999300003,
-0.00677859503775835,
0.64548259973526,
-0.1174500361084938,
0.6631093621253967,
0.14383284747600555,
0.006311055272817612,
0.8314928412437439,
0.13614590466022491,
0.48487594723701477,
0.06293582916259766,
-0.038293130695819855,
0.2921101152896881,
-0.32206153869628906,
-0.46366727352142334,
-0.5573862195014954,
0.4603002667427063,
-0.8234438300132751,
-0.2887589633464813,
-0.28593435883522034,
-0.2298988550901413,
0.33082693815231323,
0.24205422401428223,
0.6672524809837341,
0.3937496542930603,
-0.46407029032707214,
0.18927177786827087,
0.6420297622680664,
-0.48009443283081055,
0.33424708247184753,
0.2284226268529892,
0.11875031143426895,
-0.34324637055397034,
0.9842343330383301,
-0.17765840888023376,
-0.027620477601885796,
0.3731449246406555,
0.20541389286518097,
-0.22402116656303406,
-0.5865420699119568,
-0.7921465635299683,
-0.0352635383605957,
-0.5560975074768066,
-0.19700123369693756,
-0.7170484066009521,
-0.2913929522037506,
-0.5117698907852173,
-0.2074493169784546,
-0.08383600413799286,
0.08690833300352097,
-0.7880569696426392,
0.18729065358638763,
0.1710871458053589,
0.9118164777755737,
0.15773293375968933,
0.1646343171596527,
-0.5690280795097351,
0.4604019224643707,
0.045357584953308105,
-0.02498774044215679,
-0.20652468502521515,
-0.35414811968803406,
-0.03252045437693596,
0.03265555575489998,
-0.5366798639297485,
-0.8690504431724548,
0.31960949301719666,
-0.01610768400132656,
0.2079443633556366,
0.6946531534194946,
0.15721170604228973,
0.33636096119880676,
-0.46580731868743896,
1.163759469985962,
0.22228386998176575,
-0.6416723132133484,
0.2992579936981201,
-0.07285089790821075,
0.09113819897174835,
0.3264831006526947,
0.5617383122444153,
-0.607729434967041,
-0.1088198870420456,
-0.40149784088134766,
-0.3349109888076782,
0.3996357023715973,
0.28161144256591797,
0.29757869243621826,
-0.2913445234298706,
0.3425993323326111,
0.46736177802085876,
0.27216511964797974,
-0.42990729212760925,
0.08754892647266388,
-0.35533151030540466,
-0.1850084513425827,
-0.0037966470699757338,
-0.10562871396541595,
0.22121553122997284,
0.17536605894565582,
0.2859397232532501,
-0.10167311877012253,
0.4396009147167206,
0.1858116239309311,
-0.26860085129737854,
0.14815956354141235,
0.03277371823787689,
0.6095012426376343,
0.4284764230251312,
0.20987319946289062,
0.23523318767547607,
-0.030732378363609314,
-0.7770149111747742,
-0.06677408516407013,
-0.31680694222450256,
-0.3749989867210388,
0.05472312867641449,
0.8036708235740662,
1.024328589439392,
-0.2350175827741623,
-0.8531420230865479,
0.6257750391960144,
-0.1007896289229393,
-0.3857627213001251,
-0.3316728472709656,
0.27935072779655457,
-0.24976575374603271,
0.041595347225666046,
0.03374963998794556,
0.017838971689343452,
0.3834629952907562,
-0.5559030771255493,
0.2133110910654068,
0.5138363838195801,
-0.3660811483860016,
-0.26011791825294495,
0.5021634697914124,
-0.10117650777101517,
-0.43593865633010864,
0.7544190287590027,
-0.529017448425293,
-0.4038867652416229,
0.5227159857749939,
0.47169357538223267,
1.159949779510498,
0.334095299243927,
0.3845161497592926,
0.14107197523117065,
0.13716186583042145,
0.09098990261554718,
-0.028165945783257484,
-0.3488979637622833,
-0.8882411122322083,
-0.33888745307922363,
-0.39359572529792786,
-0.20450471341609955,
0.22242805361747742,
-0.5997402667999268,
0.42943355441093445,
-0.32539141178131104,
-0.25112444162368774,
0.23731264472007751,
0.3192899823188782,
-0.8841579556465149,
0.09163995832204819,
0.23272600769996643,
0.5510576367378235,
-0.8598868250846863,
0.3646411597728729,
0.46235495805740356,
-0.4215315282344818,
-0.5744839906692505,
0.18951845169067383,
0.2053501158952713,
-0.5437402725219727,
0.6339012980461121,
0.3126069903373718,
-0.2798082232475281,
-0.1759684532880783,
-0.6277945041656494,
-0.23837977647781372,
1.168370246887207,
0.01922892965376377,
-0.09072058647871017,
0.20444242656230927,
0.31687095761299133,
0.5953211188316345,
-0.5484905242919922,
0.3662870526313782,
0.4618683159351349,
0.3828659653663635,
0.20026007294654846,
-0.35054734349250793,
-0.14588125050067902,
-0.0794084221124649,
0.19379299879074097,
-0.06640345603227615,
-0.376800000667572,
0.7316466569900513,
0.02535790205001831,
-0.630036473274231,
0.049424100667238235,
0.8321387767791748,
0.07832645624876022,
0.7532446980476379,
0.38724076747894287,
0.3114732801914215,
0.8529241681098938,
-0.0646226555109024,
0.9925059080123901,
0.1902446150779724,
0.19934090971946716,
0.7073768973350525,
-0.47904008626937866,
0.6271623373031616,
0.07380970567464828,
-0.29126790165901184,
0.7772336602210999,
0.9788646697998047,
-0.34129995107650757,
0.3658234775066376,
0.5054601430892944,
-0.41161033511161804,
-0.08675380796194077,
-0.1840122938156128,
-0.0948011726140976,
0.6471208930015564,
0.08921601623296738,
-0.3962807357311249,
0.1642640382051468,
0.11287575215101242,
0.016440970823168755,
0.34717780351638794,
-0.1669607162475586,
1.1898914575576782,
0.0826723650097847,
-0.6644256114959717,
0.6012853384017944,
0.14456041157245636,
0.5887137651443481,
-0.1157403364777565,
0.007271669339388609,
0.0997040644288063,
-0.15301457047462463,
-0.49181610345840454,
-0.9228163361549377,
0.3021777868270874,
0.3726527988910675,
-0.35953718423843384,
0.06482132524251938,
1.3194326162338257,
-0.07969075441360474,
-0.2806110382080078,
0.12860997021198273,
0.4124881327152252,
0.44603267312049866,
-0.19639001786708832,
-0.6962997317314148,
0.18601463735103607,
-0.22411365807056427,
-0.19435521960258484,
0.16880486905574799,
0.5762414932250977,
-0.16218450665473938,
0.5512400269508362,
0.6893499493598938,
0.032460395246744156,
0.0007618652889505029,
0.19063594937324524,
0.7903390526771545,
-0.4633808434009552,
-0.35212594270706177,
-0.8508124947547913,
0.2302272468805313,
-0.4029102325439453,
-0.07093075662851334,
0.602369487285614,
0.5472173094749451,
1.0576906204223633,
-0.26543328166007996,
1.0788657665252686,
-0.16444924473762512,
0.4133237302303314,
-0.6093811988830566,
0.6767693161964417,
-0.4416905343532562,
0.07329395413398743,
-0.43177151679992676,
-0.7211666703224182,
-0.19708193838596344,
0.40670856833457947,
-0.3527849316596985,
0.03757451847195625,
0.5246784090995789,
0.7771728038787842,
-0.07252225279808044,
0.20891530811786652,
0.16228243708610535,
-0.5222032070159912,
0.29871493577957153,
0.2601950466632843,
1.189211368560791,
-0.26989561319351196,
0.21693576872348785,
0.03985743224620819,
-0.1798783391714096,
-0.3224632441997528,
-0.9221212863922119,
-1.2264310121536255,
-0.7538330554962158,
-0.2384994477033615,
-0.27399033308029175,
-0.1977483034133911,
0.6934186220169067,
0.5152725577354431,
-0.8521979451179504,
0.09702203422784805,
-0.2478438764810562,
0.23839105665683746,
-0.3279426693916321,
-0.23518183827400208,
0.3824304938316345,
-0.31773656606674194,
-0.5330893993377686,
0.10266349464654922,
0.23188498616218567,
-0.07287660986185074,
-0.5000333786010742,
-0.26962968707084656,
0.24410270154476166,
0.20403924584388733,
0.776701807975769,
0.2756084203720093,
-0.7597367763519287,
-0.34132808446884155,
0.16421112418174744,
-0.40701374411582947,
0.16541282832622528,
1.1948964595794678,
-0.6630573272705078,
0.5510253310203552,
0.7921801209449768,
0.9059693813323975,
0.4375133812427521,
0.18445059657096863,
0.16384397447109222,
-0.5322794318199158,
-0.10214278846979141,
0.1862678974866867,
0.023731045424938202,
0.549126386642456,
-0.5872563719749451,
0.3401739299297333,
0.4941243827342987,
-0.7046387195587158,
-0.6579201221466064,
0.49021852016448975,
-0.7204160094261169,
-0.422925740480423,
1.0250957012176514,
-0.3498650789260864,
-0.16289259493350983,
-0.21651571989059448,
-0.34706008434295654,
0.4619868993759155,
-0.08363646268844604,
0.8773423433303833,
0.7683151960372925,
-0.1596631407737732,
0.10707812756299973,
-0.7731325626373291,
0.630754292011261,
-0.1290738880634308,
-0.8302278518676758,
-0.010097095742821693,
0.5390055179595947,
0.09297651052474976,
0.04209570214152336,
0.37659740447998047,
-0.1712721884250641,
0.2375217229127884,
0.07301457971334457,
0.14260610938072205,
-0.19565808773040771,
-0.3170081675052643,
0.09887228161096573,
0.0735795721411705,
-0.12040750682353973,
-0.09675029665231705
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19183v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19183v2
|
Empirical Analysis for Unsupervised Universal Dependency Parse Tree Aggregation
| 2024-03-28T07:27:10 | 2024-04-03T05:53:38 |
Adithya Kulkarni, Oliver Eulenstein, Qi Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Dependency parsing is an essential task in NLP, and the quality of dependency
parsers is crucial for many downstream tasks. Parsers' quality often varies
depending on the domain and the language involved. Therefore, it is essential
to combat the issue of varying quality to achieve stable performance. In
various NLP tasks, aggregation methods are used for post-processing aggregation
and have been shown to combat the issue of varying quality. However,
aggregation methods for post-processing aggregation have not been sufficiently
studied in dependency parsing tasks. In an extensive empirical study, we
compare different unsupervised post-processing aggregation methods to identify
the most suitable dependency tree structure aggregation method.
|
[
-0.5105105638504028,
-0.6328260898590088,
0.5459778308868408,
0.4397988021373749,
-0.3177827298641205,
-0.11632058024406433,
0.21115311980247498,
-0.794011652469635,
0.20614254474639893,
0.29280340671539307,
-0.11123714596033096,
-0.5625914931297302,
-0.6882609724998474,
0.0711820125579834,
-0.25423696637153625,
0.7115994095802307,
0.16792377829551697,
0.060917310416698456,
-0.34896188974380493,
-0.6601259112358093,
-0.5640527009963989,
-0.5638893246650696,
-0.5589087009429932,
-0.20350930094718933,
0.2272777408361435,
0.2276773899793625,
0.5064064264297485,
0.3746049702167511,
0.5388279557228088,
0.3454917073249817,
-0.4385913610458374,
-0.08206859976053238,
-0.0007321343873627484,
-0.023922104388475418,
-0.4835456311702728,
-0.31039509177207947,
-0.7156941294670105,
-0.044768210500478745,
0.5552907586097717,
1.3557515144348145,
-0.309322327375412,
0.42566993832588196,
0.5756751298904419,
0.8148497343063354,
-0.8152649998664856,
0.12774701416492462,
-0.6330403089523315,
0.03562000021338463,
-0.30154022574424744,
-0.17408253252506256,
-0.3462734818458557,
0.01297533418983221,
0.035744085907936096,
-0.33937355875968933,
0.2966443598270416,
-0.1025678738951683,
0.8242005705833435,
0.11148208379745483,
-0.4475874602794647,
-0.009660466574132442,
-0.4690571129322052,
0.8444631695747375,
-0.8337588310241699,
0.24850545823574066,
0.2580840587615967,
-0.18025678396224976,
-0.2688635289669037,
-0.8758238554000854,
-0.0023717826697975397,
0.1272146999835968,
-0.47657108306884766,
0.02954881079494953,
-0.20998716354370117,
0.3212642967700958,
-0.08148267865180969,
0.7618933916091919,
-0.5867283344268799,
0.3834044635295868,
0.09950532764196396,
-0.09264170378446579,
0.3566286563873291,
0.21275584399700165,
0.4226139187812805,
-0.43515127897262573,
-0.37134212255477905,
0.10345581918954849,
-0.45770806074142456,
0.6445340514183044,
0.005967937875539064,
0.08350758254528046,
0.17663593590259552,
0.5209435820579529,
-0.42959922552108765,
0.8228240013122559,
-0.038497570902109146,
0.09773600846529007,
0.16040931642055511,
-0.3416411578655243,
-0.4434907138347626,
0.09359870851039886,
0.8841939568519592,
0.2950887382030487,
0.0843144878745079,
-0.06113549321889877,
-0.14768333733081818,
0.3603251278400421,
0.2974337637424469,
-0.7115557193756104,
-0.2572755515575409,
0.4131994843482971,
-0.8242415189743042,
-0.1767246574163437,
0.016611410304903984,
-0.8681758046150208,
0.24217857420444489,
-0.3785986006259918,
0.03782670572400093,
-0.31468015909194946,
-0.49063435196876526,
-0.11474398523569107,
-0.027206281200051308,
-0.0036462920252233744,
0.11322073638439178,
-0.9818054437637329,
0.611290693283081,
0.5133299231529236,
0.8785064220428467,
-0.3377443253993988,
-0.4455505609512329,
-0.5460172891616821,
-0.09234330803155899,
-0.31998997926712036,
1.3657138347625732,
-0.49398869276046753,
-0.099851094186306,
-0.14733237028121948,
0.013176126405596733,
-0.1923653483390808,
-0.4860199987888336,
0.7314165830612183,
-0.5031318664550781,
0.23592998087406158,
-0.2241394966840744,
-0.7532426118850708,
-0.50328129529953,
-0.1075231283903122,
-0.5308079719543457,
0.984075129032135,
0.6463881731033325,
-1.0156351327896118,
0.6975287199020386,
-0.6511483788490295,
-0.25997284054756165,
0.35122963786125183,
-0.22142153978347778,
-0.26003608107566833,
0.5622892379760742,
0.367810994386673,
0.557655394077301,
-0.2665822505950928,
0.7115511894226074,
-0.20252488553524017,
-0.1241360604763031,
-0.2135096788406372,
-0.31472161412239075,
1.4050506353378296,
0.279344379901886,
-0.08110477030277252,
0.21874867379665375,
-0.9097455739974976,
0.20852109789848328,
0.008555944077670574,
-0.17478707432746887,
-0.7493076920509338,
0.33625584840774536,
0.055198244750499725,
-0.09552046656608582,
0.09707409143447876,
-0.49449262022972107,
0.05738278478384018,
-0.6315134763717651,
0.07046106457710266,
0.608738899230957,
0.24022318422794342,
0.2573147714138031,
0.20451615750789642,
0.2943153381347656,
-0.009005640633404255,
0.10297786444425583,
-0.04727407917380333,
-0.6132538914680481,
-0.3138520121574402,
-0.15291394293308258,
0.5157930850982666,
0.4837840497493744,
-0.19993220269680023,
0.8616957068443298,
0.010726257227361202,
-0.14128023386001587,
-0.28761208057403564,
0.16622819006443024,
0.5327924489974976,
0.6549004912376404,
0.38061222434043884,
-0.5782243609428406,
-0.7104228138923645,
-0.7488101124763489,
-0.2536150813102722,
-0.22075241804122925,
-0.28161758184432983,
-0.2487674057483673,
0.15888755023479462,
-0.3331587016582489,
1.1863569021224976,
-0.6819339990615845,
-0.2927970588207245,
-0.21079957485198975,
0.5064975023269653,
0.3761894702911377,
0.3893105387687683,
0.911077082157135,
-0.37592947483062744,
-0.4792928695678711,
-0.09316860139369965,
-0.7878478169441223,
-0.460003525018692,
0.25699514150619507,
-0.008451792411506176,
0.18859389424324036,
0.3051328659057617,
-0.5704038143157959,
0.3797354996204376,
0.7680723667144775,
-0.6637998819351196,
0.7585776448249817,
-0.2961510419845581,
0.29076966643333435,
-0.85211580991745,
0.13700956106185913,
-0.17834384739398956,
-0.25141724944114685,
-0.531153678894043,
0.23228250443935394,
-0.14672283828258514,
0.21351608633995056,
-0.433695912361145,
-0.11405448615550995,
-0.6408544778823853,
-0.558829665184021,
-0.21363812685012817,
-0.23114868998527527,
0.26350533962249756,
0.5916802287101746,
-0.28272032737731934,
0.730130672454834,
0.7156345248222351,
-0.638998806476593,
0.2694847881793976,
0.03641922399401665,
-0.5120000839233398,
0.540998101234436,
-0.8413133025169373,
-0.26532477140426636,
-0.02675156109035015,
-0.18286803364753723,
-1.3376036882400513,
-0.0014032975304871798,
-0.11100593209266663,
-0.40491780638694763,
0.23154190182685852,
-0.11848636716604233,
-0.2911262810230255,
0.05467379838228226,
-0.28477489948272705,
0.47434088587760925,
0.22217637300491333,
-0.8384974598884583,
0.6324501037597656,
0.4398629665374756,
-0.06755489856004715,
-0.321216344833374,
-0.5144852995872498,
-0.0030249746050685644,
-0.3879556953907013,
-0.7054798603057861,
0.24309758841991425,
0.1701612025499344,
-0.4415326714515686,
0.31250929832458496,
-0.279990553855896,
-0.226058691740036,
0.21545255184173584,
0.231398344039917,
-0.04071999713778496,
-0.4056343138217926,
-0.4365586042404175,
0.14001676440238953,
-0.46668073534965515,
0.33076146245002747,
0.0006134362192824483,
0.6000518202781677,
-0.09696495532989502,
-0.4035135507583618,
-0.44791123270988464,
0.6886818408966064,
0.4301067590713501,
-0.24471500515937805,
0.7470436096191406,
0.26040399074554443,
-0.03130482882261276,
0.10909097641706467,
-0.5071214437484741,
0.36223265528678894,
-0.42970699071884155,
0.29468652606010437,
-0.20467807352542877,
-0.8862391710281372,
0.6943953633308411,
-0.2056359499692917,
0.19801118969917297,
0.783200204372406,
0.11440815776586533,
-0.26640230417251587,
1.3077336549758911,
0.5222540497779846,
-0.22267337143421173,
0.29532602429389954,
0.0026699374429881573,
0.11600671708583832,
-0.8428224921226501,
0.04006090387701988,
-0.7943095564842224,
0.07165637612342834,
-0.560470700263977,
0.05838540568947792,
0.07426120340824127,
0.5147697925567627,
-0.0066320570185780525,
0.17233242094516754,
-0.6498706936836243,
0.4543816149234772,
0.5106157064437866,
-0.22316624224185944,
0.5320004224777222,
0.4063885509967804,
-0.0492686927318573,
0.1816457062959671,
-0.4423636198043823,
-0.3252139985561371,
0.7711055874824524,
0.0666593387722969,
0.08426178991794586,
-0.025858009234070778,
0.18759945034980774,
0.37441810965538025,
0.21378326416015625,
-0.7441737651824951,
0.5814063549041748,
-0.3987894654273987,
-0.1649039387702942,
-0.4417946934700012,
-0.48205646872520447,
-1.495278000831604,
0.7206907272338867,
0.1787332445383072,
-1.1521419286727905,
0.40309765934944153,
0.3150535225868225,
-0.003666396252810955,
0.20394356548786163,
-0.9276309609413147,
1.1000020503997803,
0.011906294152140617,
0.04126176983118057,
-0.15599508583545685,
-0.6844920516014099,
0.4455842077732086,
0.12610548734664917,
0.15746621787548065,
0.010190083645284176,
0.33974969387054443,
0.9969295859336853,
-0.6779063940048218,
0.5246937274932861,
-0.18014094233512878,
0.03522801399230957,
0.6274076700210571,
0.16235117614269257,
0.49942824244499207,
-0.013255505822598934,
0.07666537910699844,
0.7050378918647766,
0.11022656410932541,
-0.5631277561187744,
-0.5701451897621155,
0.6035216450691223,
-0.8515558242797852,
-0.5142408013343811,
-0.4756573438644409,
-0.2616455852985382,
-0.29221436381340027,
0.14759677648544312,
0.44935494661331177,
0.479543536901474,
-0.32884374260902405,
0.0715969055891037,
0.29212626814842224,
0.11648114770650864,
0.9196226596832275,
0.4663638472557068,
-0.20485083758831024,
-0.4400789439678192,
0.5864445567131042,
0.24978363513946533,
0.15035556256771088,
0.26276636123657227,
0.43175581097602844,
-0.22211267054080963,
-0.7503089904785156,
-0.4075205326080322,
-0.050714120268821716,
-0.3707018792629242,
-0.32657670974731445,
-0.9321106672286987,
-0.19825094938278198,
-0.4522891044616699,
-0.11106140911579132,
-0.4246615767478943,
-0.3203488290309906,
-0.17600345611572266,
-0.29953983426094055,
0.39965716004371643,
0.5062263011932373,
-0.025086909532546997,
0.6317939758300781,
-1.0098507404327393,
0.5090704560279846,
0.38503211736679077,
0.6353267431259155,
0.0036810184828937054,
-0.22459322214126587,
-0.1183585599064827,
-0.1574045717716217,
-0.08400548994541168,
-1.1149290800094604,
0.2613382041454315,
-0.04177366569638252,
0.6474758386611938,
0.9302821755409241,
-0.22114139795303345,
0.8374919891357422,
-0.34233057498931885,
0.8669477701187134,
0.3214706778526306,
-0.9782692193984985,
0.5419490337371826,
-0.30848875641822815,
0.1905406415462494,
0.8126224875450134,
0.13764874637126923,
-0.22796550393104553,
-0.17294657230377197,
-0.8404651880264282,
-1.2022813558578491,
0.8921772837638855,
0.18791520595550537,
-0.4147695302963257,
0.22750698029994965,
0.15096956491470337,
-0.06657116115093231,
0.006515342276543379,
-0.5182368755340576,
-0.3911043405532837,
-0.034594472497701645,
0.2885451912879944,
-0.1146635189652443,
-0.8494006395339966,
0.21564558148384094,
-0.4377783536911011,
0.21115171909332275,
0.3460204601287842,
-0.11315490305423737,
-0.04117339104413986,
-0.13799048960208893,
-0.24515984952449799,
0.2861860990524292,
-0.04081980884075165,
0.8804076910018921,
-0.6276079416275024,
0.4089732766151428,
0.036047011613845825,
-0.5614838004112244,
0.24661701917648315,
-0.13008514046669006,
-0.17100420594215393,
0.19956471025943756,
0.5453735589981079,
0.5894783139228821,
-0.13047054409980774,
-0.40898841619491577,
0.4786742925643921,
0.11310788244009018,
-0.2533426582813263,
-0.1505466103553772,
0.09792836010456085,
0.03968772292137146,
-0.248612180352211,
0.07914526015520096,
0.18793439865112305,
0.5867264866828918,
-0.39655372500419617,
0.22788327932357788,
0.39496949315071106,
-0.14878077805042267,
-0.3134107291698456,
0.30646613240242004,
0.0022738042753189802,
-0.32869651913642883,
0.631992518901825,
-0.2635883092880249,
-0.18281468749046326,
0.5480625629425049,
0.5243114233016968,
0.8946459293365479,
-0.9124575257301331,
0.20811676979064941,
0.255084753036499,
0.20939692854881287,
-0.1698373705148697,
0.050945933908224106,
-0.14119358360767365,
-0.7058497071266174,
-1.1834166049957275,
-0.7510569095611572,
-0.20025114715099335,
0.24607893824577332,
-0.8878074884414673,
-0.19955743849277496,
0.03619174659252167,
0.07940971106290817,
-0.13937993347644806,
-0.35863959789276123,
-0.3940761685371399,
0.38611966371536255,
-0.6652808785438538,
0.3733246326446533,
-1.3145816326141357,
0.35223397612571716,
0.9829436540603638,
-0.25533512234687805,
-0.8213554620742798,
-0.18694941699504852,
-0.07868264615535736,
-0.4797755777835846,
0.4010922908782959,
0.04761229455471039,
-0.0903228297829628,
-0.10250820219516754,
-0.2724286913871765,
-1.1407667398452759,
0.5154918432235718,
0.2534600496292114,
-0.21327261626720428,
0.27131715416908264,
0.3598629832267761,
0.7381442189216614,
-0.21015162765979767,
0.4681175947189331,
0.8771550059318542,
0.28819647431373596,
-0.06005241721868515,
-0.5086356997489929,
0.05653535947203636,
-0.35935738682746887,
0.33758214116096497,
0.5030332803726196,
-0.310901939868927,
0.6338331699371338,
0.40090349316596985,
-0.317870557308197,
-0.6119909286499023,
0.7320350408554077,
0.40884608030319214,
0.4743274450302124,
0.9000093340873718,
0.851983368396759,
0.40896904468536377,
0.31767746806144714,
0.7971221804618835,
-0.11881685256958008,
0.41050902009010315,
1.188385248184204,
-0.0662919282913208,
0.6491698622703552,
0.4034644663333893,
-0.664826512336731,
0.349806547164917,
0.6770155429840088,
0.12956151366233826,
0.2845936417579651,
-0.07231052219867706,
-0.03686335310339928,
-0.04521588236093521,
-0.2966810166835785,
-0.4178287982940674,
0.5589268803596497,
0.41136226058006287,
-0.2547021508216858,
-0.5989221334457397,
-0.24301640689373016,
0.11244651675224304,
-0.051468852907419205,
-0.3926977813243866,
0.8802014589309692,
-0.04692068323493004,
-0.8248641490936279,
0.5003165006637573,
-0.2032506912946701,
0.43086203932762146,
-0.44058293104171753,
-0.11461245268583298,
-0.36275267601013184,
-0.0036958837881684303,
-0.5985313653945923,
-0.7780075073242188,
0.7425321936607361,
0.06874509900808334,
-0.21929684281349182,
-0.3531942069530487,
0.5128975510597229,
0.19905006885528564,
-0.52384352684021,
0.6937388777732849,
0.6191346049308777,
0.38944703340530396,
-0.4871353507041931,
-0.27027323842048645,
-0.32985153794288635,
0.08391132950782776,
-0.7374992370605469,
0.6683828830718994,
0.650532603263855,
0.03756529837846756,
0.14625568687915802,
0.7617802023887634,
0.1767350733280182,
0.015808643773198128,
0.2821072041988373,
0.9024884700775146,
-0.5141850113868713,
-0.5267447829246521,
-0.9876836538314819,
0.8688424229621887,
-0.07632865011692047,
-0.3577330708503723,
1.0943701267242432,
0.7168658971786499,
0.6787165999412537,
0.18911230564117432,
0.28279128670692444,
-0.16296657919883728,
0.47177818417549133,
-0.5591091513633728,
0.26106059551239014,
-0.5887596011161804,
0.31176745891571045,
-0.5506657361984253,
-1.3633947372436523,
-0.5919865369796753,
0.403166264295578,
0.1990431547164917,
-0.2192101776599884,
1.1144260168075562,
0.47192203998565674,
-0.1911170482635498,
0.10782591998577118,
0.3083319365978241,
0.17536301910877228,
0.22368305921554565,
0.11978702992200851,
0.6921794414520264,
-0.03329319879412651,
0.3662884831428528,
-0.26309043169021606,
-0.43125706911087036,
0.04149273782968521,
-0.8471332788467407,
-0.6045185923576355,
-0.40282171964645386,
-0.1987224966287613,
-0.24071639776229858,
-0.2227153331041336,
0.5921591520309448,
0.4716138243675232,
-1.121643304824829,
-0.29018014669418335,
-0.6658937931060791,
0.08964522182941437,
-0.5625556111335754,
-0.2977001965045929,
0.8614261746406555,
-0.8272639513015747,
-0.37948769330978394,
0.3960103988647461,
0.41722121834754944,
-0.2783428132534027,
0.16728821396827698,
0.5037131905555725,
-0.1929304301738739,
-0.3619796633720398,
0.9425767660140991,
0.08743602782487869,
-0.4627085030078888,
-0.07706239074468613,
-0.44920673966407776,
0.21070095896720886,
0.5289493203163147,
1.1118234395980835,
-0.5848326086997986,
0.09584945440292358,
0.8405689001083374,
0.5013788938522339,
0.37901294231414795,
0.5661848187446594,
0.32238930463790894,
-0.7711949348449707,
0.22505265474319458,
-0.013498365879058838,
0.7273119688034058,
-0.11058308929204941,
-0.4535490572452545,
0.583008885383606,
0.32170310616493225,
-0.951572597026825,
-0.5410778522491455,
0.10362683981657028,
-1.0894994735717773,
-0.6321508288383484,
1.0399543046951294,
-0.19478976726531982,
-0.07012975960969925,
-0.7091270685195923,
-0.24004101753234863,
0.23506611585617065,
-0.35760658979415894,
0.6739854216575623,
0.5047323107719421,
-0.6671506762504578,
-0.1937333643436432,
-0.18777644634246826,
0.3150455057621002,
0.6144750118255615,
-1.003846287727356,
0.036882542073726654,
0.6647881269454956,
0.13271212577819824,
0.3219252824783325,
0.9165902733802795,
-0.13382431864738464,
-0.16340455412864685,
0.0006350923795253038,
0.2721827030181885,
0.2049562931060791,
-0.29100993275642395,
-0.35347822308540344,
0.7030943036079407,
0.1685411036014557,
-0.37210166454315186
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19181v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19181v2
|
Make Large Language Model a Better Ranker
| 2024-03-28T07:22:16 | 2024-06-24T13:22:22 |
Wenshuo Chao, Zhi Zheng, Hengshu Zhu, Hao Liu
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) demonstrate robust capabilities across various
fields, leading to a paradigm shift in LLM-enhanced Recommender System (RS).
Research to date focuses on point-wise and pair-wise recommendation paradigms,
which are inefficient for LLM-based recommenders due to high computational
costs. However, existing list-wise approaches also fall short in ranking tasks
due to misalignment between ranking objectives and next-token prediction.
Moreover, these LLM-based methods struggle to effectively address the order
relation among candidates, particularly given the scale of ratings. To address
these challenges, this paper introduces the large language model framework with
Aligned Listwise Ranking Objectives (ALRO). ALRO is designed to bridge the gap
between the capabilities of LLMs and the nuanced requirements of ranking tasks.
Specifically, ALRO employs explicit feedback in a listwise manner by
introducing soft lambda loss, a customized adaptation of lambda loss designed
for optimizing order relations. This mechanism provides more accurate
optimization goals, enhancing the ranking process. Additionally, ALRO
incorporates a permutation-sensitive learning mechanism that addresses position
bias, a prevalent issue in generative models, without imposing additional
computational burdens during inference. Our evaluative studies reveal that ALRO
outperforms both existing embedding-based recommendation methods and LLM-based
recommendation baselines.
|
[
-0.17267285287380219,
-0.2630777955055237,
0.5937520861625671,
-0.0630578100681305,
-0.26522237062454224,
0.005900962743908167,
-0.41777142882347107,
-0.3694179356098175,
0.045986805111169815,
0.6012154817581177,
-0.18265001475811005,
-0.5622596144676208,
-0.8398100137710571,
-0.31048545241355896,
-0.27065229415893555,
1.2823971509933472,
0.2760322391986847,
-0.006978245452046394,
0.024074429646134377,
-0.32098546624183655,
-0.31580156087875366,
-0.5052821636199951,
-0.7709366679191589,
-0.36730295419692993,
0.7139207720756531,
0.421174556016922,
1.0725338459014893,
0.5563631057739258,
0.6145315170288086,
0.31725218892097473,
-0.08603879064321518,
0.13853557407855988,
-0.6957243084907532,
0.2542136311531067,
-0.1437465250492096,
-0.37795963883399963,
-0.7659086585044861,
-0.11485119163990021,
0.5628197193145752,
0.7053180932998657,
-0.41180482506752014,
0.04850112274289131,
0.196885883808136,
0.677033007144928,
-0.6106512546539307,
-0.03204767405986786,
-0.9010008573532104,
-0.20513901114463806,
-0.16748031973838806,
-0.11269114911556244,
-0.48466190695762634,
-0.3567226529121399,
0.06817270815372467,
-0.46303054690361023,
-0.15846024453639984,
0.4452590048313141,
0.587097704410553,
0.27044713497161865,
-0.27428701519966125,
-0.08255968987941742,
-0.794141411781311,
0.8292221426963806,
-0.8055015802383423,
0.6792914867401123,
0.43285465240478516,
0.3274643123149872,
-0.14543436467647552,
-0.27361732721328735,
-0.15460985898971558,
-0.2617812156677246,
0.38846513628959656,
-0.08637787401676178,
0.002295263111591339,
0.07102563977241516,
-0.06802775710821152,
0.2952171266078949,
-0.48510172963142395,
0.45537295937538147,
-0.17389261722564697,
0.010389150120317936,
0.5780438780784607,
-0.09829892218112946,
-0.027865353971719742,
0.051673345267772675,
-0.23845987021923065,
-0.20941869914531708,
-0.8965875506401062,
0.008652860298752785,
0.4898054897785187,
0.4577401280403137,
0.13538646697998047,
0.5201994776725769,
-0.0667242631316185,
0.5804718136787415,
0.30176499485969543,
-0.17906852066516876,
0.1665973663330078,
0.07821682840585709,
-0.10289750248193741,
0.11038610339164734,
0.7310782670974731,
0.5582661628723145,
0.1739206463098526,
-0.14179234206676483,
-0.35329529643058777,
-0.31663358211517334,
0.10962432622909546,
-0.8711245059967041,
-0.08554597198963165,
0.17984701693058014,
-0.5049213767051697,
-0.31448325514793396,
0.2014169692993164,
-0.4324934184551239,
-0.524307906627655,
-0.09457024186849594,
0.3790603280067444,
-0.3370974659919739,
0.02232624590396881,
0.029711641371250153,
0.3459663987159729,
0.0992286205291748,
0.41174381971359253,
-0.9494352340698242,
0.23728235065937042,
0.9656663537025452,
0.6647466421127319,
-0.25282204151153564,
-0.28190115094184875,
-0.9192447662353516,
0.3365669250488281,
-0.45905137062072754,
0.759536623954773,
-0.7596355080604553,
-0.22040748596191406,
0.09013548493385315,
-0.2083590030670166,
0.16877417266368866,
-0.6961162090301514,
0.6157791018486023,
-0.6393676400184631,
0.11737717688083649,
0.024490874260663986,
-0.5106899738311768,
-0.05510251969099045,
0.12437813729047775,
-0.43932044506073,
1.0911059379577637,
-0.005236162804067135,
-0.28666117787361145,
0.393221378326416,
-0.25775665044784546,
-0.24530288577079773,
0.17611068487167358,
-0.08222200721502304,
-0.2885529696941376,
0.07314006239175797,
0.2760692238807678,
0.7430028915405273,
-0.47100508213043213,
0.5907235145568848,
-0.4613882005214691,
-0.49958536028862,
0.0285170990973711,
-0.1329134702682495,
0.3097851574420929,
0.09684332460165024,
-0.26880452036857605,
0.6012740731239319,
-0.40202629566192627,
0.059701818972826004,
-0.17057810723781586,
-0.3205121159553528,
-0.6553989052772522,
0.23784874379634857,
0.015215764753520489,
0.18356816470623016,
0.26152893900871277,
-0.207721546292305,
0.3273491859436035,
-0.6834253668785095,
0.4525984525680542,
0.8996853232383728,
-0.32703134417533875,
0.7129434943199158,
-0.26016032695770264,
0.5318751335144043,
-0.4265208840370178,
0.2854156196117401,
0.33488956093788147,
-0.296059787273407,
-0.6682819128036499,
-0.17303937673568726,
0.2766707241535187,
0.49867838621139526,
-0.4726550281047821,
0.7690390348434448,
-0.47201573848724365,
-0.4133756756782532,
-0.6557710766792297,
0.5151406526565552,
0.31311464309692383,
0.05540434643626213,
0.22907739877700806,
-0.12027949094772339,
-0.4476030468940735,
-0.7763695120811462,
-0.015486931428313255,
-0.27888333797454834,
-0.007403686176985502,
0.3102220892906189,
0.14802555739879608,
-0.4178266227245331,
0.3666081130504608,
-0.46066713333129883,
-0.481830894947052,
-0.5272672176361084,
-0.32766810059547424,
0.6022898554801941,
0.20905537903308868,
0.21718661487102509,
-0.44129014015197754,
-0.29160380363464355,
-0.00866680033504963,
-0.3621652126312256,
-0.13704268634319305,
0.3307417631149292,
-0.2922147214412689,
0.1532379686832428,
0.6057537198066711,
-0.2803446650505066,
0.0050741941668093204,
0.6367114782333374,
-0.12210506945848465,
0.10286577045917511,
-0.21196414530277252,
-0.010762041434645653,
-1.0056825876235962,
-0.08279242366552353,
-0.07078853994607925,
-0.25764894485473633,
-0.20728030800819397,
0.02526037022471428,
-0.12379298359155655,
-0.1278262883424759,
-0.18583980202674866,
0.6751426458358765,
-0.1773388534784317,
-0.03699752688407898,
-0.2670402228832245,
0.024399539455771446,
0.09090322256088257,
0.4313792288303375,
-0.2419077754020691,
0.5604074597358704,
0.36687466502189636,
-0.5413758158683777,
0.05591502785682678,
0.2014341503381729,
-0.5015063285827637,
0.39848312735557556,
-0.7432124018669128,
0.07834852486848831,
0.007634694222360849,
0.35159528255462646,
-0.8660940527915955,
0.19682557880878448,
0.042651787400245667,
-0.04817545413970947,
0.2509082555770874,
-0.32760992646217346,
-0.3751872181892395,
-0.19151464104652405,
-0.6904110312461853,
0.6644523739814758,
0.3304821252822876,
-0.6419960856437683,
0.32847464084625244,
0.45591920614242554,
-0.3787332773208618,
-0.847573459148407,
-0.15982511639595032,
0.05879443883895874,
-0.31118422746658325,
-0.3904653787612915,
0.6926276683807373,
-0.17313134670257568,
-0.40415865182876587,
-0.20842194557189941,
0.004918398801237345,
0.3537536561489105,
-0.08190860599279404,
0.2613474726676941,
0.4057929217815399,
-0.05511106923222542,
0.36312946677207947,
-0.10007520020008087,
-0.18542097508907318,
-0.2744362950325012,
-0.32967713475227356,
0.7138304710388184,
-0.16519887745380402,
-0.21109628677368164,
-0.08640628308057785,
0.2504057288169861,
0.7549074292182922,
-0.4045110046863556,
0.7287214994430542,
0.5111708045005798,
-0.1000969335436821,
-0.3294287621974945,
-0.8114746809005737,
-0.083722323179245,
-0.4968527853488922,
0.6298849582672119,
-0.3096786141395569,
-0.9479106068611145,
0.2918398380279541,
0.0329304002225399,
0.09319926053285599,
0.40858012437820435,
0.3619789183139801,
-0.0024853511713445187,
1.3252187967300415,
0.7775307893753052,
-0.5453319549560547,
0.6491760015487671,
-0.34091106057167053,
0.47791361808776855,
-1.1451438665390015,
-0.07536877691745758,
-0.351414293050766,
-0.33724695444107056,
-0.5587886571884155,
-0.2876027822494507,
0.45478007197380066,
0.42301133275032043,
-0.5340648889541626,
0.18844422698020935,
-0.6358196139335632,
0.3624279201030731,
0.3666447699069977,
-0.051180124282836914,
0.16003572940826416,
0.08007314056158066,
-0.09617290645837784,
0.08787029981613159,
-0.7832383513450623,
-0.5002918839454651,
1.109358549118042,
0.3753969967365265,
0.8910894393920898,
0.4067598879337311,
0.6452326774597168,
0.2772463858127594,
0.42657434940338135,
-1.0863189697265625,
0.5917590260505676,
-0.6100848913192749,
-0.22968655824661255,
-0.47885438799858093,
-0.21312199532985687,
-0.9474350214004517,
0.2526983916759491,
-0.19349366426467896,
-0.6398741006851196,
0.10720036178827286,
-0.07022514939308167,
-0.2999843657016754,
0.2337409406900406,
-0.22655439376831055,
0.6613253951072693,
-0.4999045431613922,
-0.6397433876991272,
-0.3017611801624298,
-0.3862342834472656,
0.20946364104747772,
0.11606760323047638,
0.4049052596092224,
-0.2055046558380127,
-0.1784413605928421,
0.904737114906311,
-0.6951481103897095,
0.4158916473388672,
-0.04341264069080353,
-0.28992611169815063,
0.009541953913867474,
0.20914514362812042,
0.6683754920959473,
-0.019323280081152916,
-0.6729716062545776,
0.06680306047201157,
-0.23421122133731842,
-0.1110321655869484,
-0.545571506023407,
1.1058851480484009,
-0.8135745525360107,
-0.8636636734008789,
-0.3214036226272583,
-0.5928313136100769,
-0.20378249883651733,
0.09043020009994507,
0.1805310696363449,
0.4969545304775238,
0.12025146931409836,
0.23541612923145294,
0.4520602524280548,
-0.37182095646858215,
0.3031024932861328,
0.36904454231262207,
-0.4995713233947754,
-0.6677755117416382,
0.9602378010749817,
0.06545467674732208,
0.1405622959136963,
0.5445675849914551,
0.4153885245323181,
-0.45473629236221313,
-0.781240701675415,
-0.3544691801071167,
0.37175363302230835,
-0.6612669229507446,
-0.26669296622276306,
-0.39282742142677307,
-0.0992007851600647,
-0.4851570129394531,
-0.24451924860477448,
-0.21733662486076355,
-0.21889415383338928,
0.17992068827152252,
-0.09943719208240509,
0.4439215660095215,
0.6313095092773438,
0.3578093349933624,
0.27189329266548157,
-0.4616624712944031,
0.08493504673242569,
0.15001770853996277,
0.5446670651435852,
0.24085299670696259,
-0.8203318119049072,
-0.1850818395614624,
-0.44552743434906006,
-0.11798832565546036,
-0.4137948453426361,
0.45056241750717163,
0.3238498568534851,
0.530151903629303,
0.6894204020500183,
-0.001584396231919527,
0.7318671345710754,
-0.6807646155357361,
0.2730047106742859,
0.08284857124090195,
-0.6877186894416809,
0.47085079550743103,
-0.4705737233161926,
0.32943010330200195,
0.8156160116195679,
0.2164909988641739,
-0.4535391926765442,
-0.3115788698196411,
-0.2921384274959564,
-1.1841111183166504,
0.5102123618125916,
-0.22461926937103271,
0.08716785162687302,
0.07914285361766815,
0.3868202865123749,
0.27342844009399414,
0.257467120885849,
-0.8022911548614502,
-0.14429333806037903,
0.10927508026361465,
-0.3219076097011566,
-0.4532967507839203,
-0.27733179926872253,
0.04111211746931076,
-0.38906073570251465,
0.9200116395950317,
-0.09344684332609177,
-0.021389193832874298,
-0.13607634603977203,
-0.11323458701372147,
-0.19010493159294128,
0.4653821885585785,
0.3549889624118805,
0.5899075865745544,
-0.34834617376327515,
0.1671036034822464,
0.13756731152534485,
-0.047150541096925735,
0.1267806887626648,
0.2991160452365875,
-0.06716775894165039,
-0.30388590693473816,
0.3955090343952179,
0.7337087392807007,
0.4377067983150482,
-0.7413302063941956,
0.531659722328186,
0.2869943678379059,
0.19819530844688416,
-0.18216639757156372,
0.10035935044288635,
0.1032906100153923,
0.19001096487045288,
0.5296341180801392,
-0.0611751526594162,
0.296946257352829,
-0.7640736103057861,
0.017078358680009842,
0.7157308459281921,
-0.5033550262451172,
0.06867245584726334,
0.6051878333091736,
0.38229435682296753,
-0.48796018958091736,
0.44035181403160095,
0.07702746242284775,
-0.6783677935600281,
0.42273175716400146,
0.40739914774894714,
0.5539687275886536,
-0.40781891345977783,
0.07486552745103836,
0.20871302485466003,
0.1209174171090126,
-0.3364221155643463,
-0.04721071571111679,
-0.0857941135764122,
-0.6024860143661499,
-0.3446403443813324,
-0.7476418018341064,
-0.42666661739349365,
0.3267115354537964,
-0.369735985994339,
0.3824581205844879,
-0.6648784875869751,
-0.12440036982297897,
-0.08431609719991684,
0.0037461428437381983,
-0.5127598643302917,
-0.008400984108448029,
0.04931347072124481,
0.35265323519706726,
-0.4209037721157074,
0.8033334016799927,
0.6886433959007263,
-0.21406152844429016,
-0.7535789012908936,
-0.12829066812992096,
-0.2277018427848816,
-0.7537896633148193,
0.7179356813430786,
0.3941175043582916,
-0.47482964396476746,
-0.0480189323425293,
-0.22827975451946259,
-1.043487787246704,
0.9184045791625977,
0.38123446702957153,
-0.9057520031929016,
0.11187280714511871,
-0.05551088601350784,
0.4771655797958374,
-0.5291069746017456,
0.5246301293373108,
-0.05253716558218002,
0.33451908826828003,
-0.04721314460039139,
-0.8860000371932983,
0.13429944217205048,
-0.19281679391860962,
0.026916589587926865,
0.6236032843589783,
-0.7614941596984863,
0.5792648196220398,
-0.3067193925380707,
0.26774582266807556,
0.1455547958612442,
0.478232204914093,
0.3547801375389099,
0.14588123559951782,
0.6939204335212708,
0.4250468611717224,
0.6049430966377258,
0.3228895962238312,
1.114943265914917,
-0.3346242904663086,
-0.06516014784574509,
1.1260960102081299,
-0.7608489990234375,
1.2780040502548218,
0.30963367223739624,
-0.14137516915798187,
0.5720873475074768,
0.5964904427528381,
-0.1186947152018547,
0.4382570683956146,
0.3018244206905365,
-0.055037982761859894,
-0.4258299171924591,
-0.2008066475391388,
-0.43592557311058044,
0.44298186898231506,
0.2187213897705078,
-0.48187583684921265,
0.15801814198493958,
-0.05459560453891754,
-0.15517528355121613,
0.13483944535255432,
-0.44003283977508545,
0.6921193599700928,
0.1526874154806137,
-0.8767855763435364,
0.7503877282142639,
0.22290562093257904,
1.0213568210601807,
-0.5844719409942627,
-0.06822843849658966,
-0.17815367877483368,
0.4095376133918762,
-0.15011562407016754,
-0.37339240312576294,
-0.15534353256225586,
-0.10629840195178986,
-0.343392550945282,
-0.27568966150283813,
0.5895702242851257,
-0.5010377764701843,
-0.8313961625099182,
0.6214298605918884,
0.4756207764148712,
0.19112618267536163,
-0.018827391788363457,
-0.6754005551338196,
0.21169281005859375,
-0.18243572115898132,
-0.08327260613441467,
0.47013983130455017,
0.03208073228597641,
-0.4514758288860321,
0.8809049129486084,
0.5123518705368042,
0.13258837163448334,
-0.38302239775657654,
0.4711019694805145,
0.4810415506362915,
-0.4820334315299988,
-0.3933279812335968,
-0.766864001750946,
-0.12580300867557526,
0.11691322177648544,
-0.23571336269378662,
0.5648502707481384,
0.6229249238967896,
0.6705778241157532,
0.22987325489521027,
0.43659746646881104,
0.29241257905960083,
0.34825509786605835,
-0.40418314933776855,
0.7531532645225525,
-0.5685305595397949,
0.7968687415122986,
-0.34886738657951355,
-1.5068472623825073,
-0.33911263942718506,
0.5790335536003113,
-0.6059008240699768,
0.3580334484577179,
0.50416100025177,
0.9169428944587708,
-0.03089745342731476,
-0.5296928882598877,
0.35173094272613525,
0.2309778332710266,
0.2089126706123352,
0.6647480130195618,
0.7756722569465637,
-0.4687570631504059,
0.7239946126937866,
-0.05365399643778801,
-0.1318146139383316,
-0.44340577721595764,
-0.7174800038337708,
-0.839621365070343,
-0.380053848028183,
-0.39284902811050415,
-0.15575312077999115,
0.42151907086372375,
1.1518043279647827,
0.7800493836402893,
-0.733246386051178,
-0.5414479374885559,
0.14044257998466492,
0.2618143558502197,
-0.254473477602005,
-0.2361789494752884,
0.5623544454574585,
0.11231473088264465,
-0.8486154079437256,
0.5017926692962646,
0.2818475663661957,
-0.36656445264816284,
-0.16065914928913116,
-0.36842772364616394,
-0.243471160531044,
-0.11267074197530746,
0.856354832649231,
-0.038671545684337616,
-0.9847126007080078,
-0.32479214668273926,
-0.19723628461360931,
-0.1211482360959053,
-0.00591640779748559,
0.5699687004089355,
-0.7458542585372925,
-0.0033857112284749746,
0.37534335255622864,
0.5225913524627686,
0.23597630858421326,
-0.0022426971700042486,
0.7022397518157959,
-0.287461519241333,
-0.12554053962230682,
0.12588979303836823,
0.3594430088996887,
0.5318071246147156,
-0.44114938378334045,
0.5220193862915039,
-0.3808060884475708,
-0.5972511172294617,
-0.8585690259933472,
0.0798255205154419,
-1.1286283731460571,
-0.28914210200309753,
1.3908425569534302,
0.18945735692977905,
0.1311168670654297,
0.07652441412210464,
-0.21193869411945343,
0.16254590451717377,
-0.7694206237792969,
0.8231856226921082,
0.5074381828308105,
-0.1287848800420761,
-0.15440350770950317,
-0.4782618284225464,
0.26713836193084717,
0.7991496920585632,
-0.5666790008544922,
0.01362825371325016,
0.38665422797203064,
0.21788929402828217,
-0.1226276159286499,
0.3799460828304291,
-0.018162820488214493,
-0.007932387292385101,
-0.7620100975036621,
0.12320144474506378,
-0.06359777599573135,
-0.3845801055431366,
-0.39608821272850037,
0.34206119179725647,
0.721126914024353,
0.11952584236860275
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19167v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19167v1
|
Mitigating Misleading Chain-of-Thought Reasoning with Selective Filtering
| 2024-03-28T06:28:35 | 2024-03-28T06:28:35 |
Yexin Wu, Zhuosheng Zhang, Hai Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models have manifested remarkable capabilities by leveraging
chain-of-thought (CoT) reasoning techniques to solve intricate questions
through step-by-step reasoning chains. Despite its success, the efficacy of
such reasoning is inherently contingent upon the quality of CoT. However,
flawless CoT reasoning cannot be guaranteed due to the presence of
indecomposable questions and the potential for erroneous reasoning chains,
particularly in the case of small-scale language models. To tackle this
challenge, we propose a novel approach called the selective filtering reasoner
(SelF-Reasoner) that assesses the entailment relationship between the question
and the candidate reasoning chain. Then, we proceed with CoT reasoning when the
reasoning chain demonstrates confidence; otherwise, we opt to predict the
answer directly. SelF-Reasoner improves the fine-tuned T5 baseline consistently
over the ScienceQA, ECQA, and LastLetter tasks. Code is available at
\texttt{https://github.com/LibroWu/SelF-Reasoner}.
|
[
-0.5117511749267578,
-0.7564587593078613,
0.9584543704986572,
0.1427461951971054,
-0.2919779419898987,
0.24120843410491943,
-0.027946610003709793,
-0.4474436342716217,
0.2194220870733261,
0.9770662188529968,
-0.6167729496955872,
-0.2437894344329834,
-0.43598854541778564,
0.15312550961971283,
-0.36759063601493835,
0.9104423522949219,
-0.20521827042102814,
-0.22082412242889404,
-0.17531514167785645,
-0.14137816429138184,
-0.37711331248283386,
-0.3335317373275757,
-0.754552960395813,
-0.4946938753128052,
0.597606897354126,
0.3794833719730377,
0.4664372205734253,
0.4231793284416199,
0.21780717372894287,
0.13579820096492767,
-0.13594172894954681,
0.39422306418418884,
-0.5172959566116333,
0.4046419858932495,
-0.7980931401252747,
-0.3796691596508026,
-0.23719951510429382,
-0.18498244881629944,
0.3628727197647095,
0.3442157208919525,
-0.06468704342842102,
0.2300281971693039,
0.07434064149856567,
0.7336214780807495,
-1.1132991313934326,
-0.5180982351303101,
-0.8973318338394165,
-0.06824224442243576,
-0.11974653601646423,
-0.12745440006256104,
-0.6019457578659058,
-0.012752333655953407,
-0.1335388422012329,
-0.3118584156036377,
0.3217222988605499,
0.3256497085094452,
0.6673213243484497,
0.6225148439407349,
-0.545680046081543,
-0.01240566186606884,
-0.821610152721405,
0.7615625262260437,
-0.4683676064014435,
0.3862408399581909,
0.7431991100311279,
0.38702720403671265,
-0.26432523131370544,
-0.6353679895401001,
-0.5773867964744568,
-0.17865243554115295,
0.05291911959648132,
0.17916351556777954,
-0.12216649949550629,
0.1624516248703003,
0.206544890999794,
0.3385908603668213,
-0.7464805841445923,
-0.1630886197090149,
-0.37710699439048767,
-0.41813087463378906,
0.502426266670227,
-0.06932146847248077,
0.09061715751886368,
0.03343512862920761,
-0.26235055923461914,
0.17920587956905365,
-0.6588336825370789,
-0.19578740000724792,
0.2590155601501465,
-0.18763725459575653,
0.3163084387779236,
0.3924434781074524,
-0.47493088245391846,
0.8620050549507141,
0.5200132727622986,
0.3307643234729767,
-0.2696385979652405,
-0.4023994505405426,
-0.22558778524398804,
0.16740575432777405,
0.6473414897918701,
-0.1917029619216919,
0.171415314078331,
0.03986979275941849,
-0.3665735423564911,
0.2682214081287384,
0.3878715932369232,
-0.6157961487770081,
-0.6665401458740234,
0.6085314750671387,
-0.27053597569465637,
-0.31459569931030273,
-0.19130370020866394,
-0.5456013083457947,
-0.33968865871429443,
0.08250566571950912,
0.4863123297691345,
-0.14078068733215332,
-0.24150539934635162,
0.08546694368124008,
-0.09687761962413788,
-0.06829499453306198,
0.07409397512674332,
-0.6659404635429382,
0.18585419654846191,
0.36280277371406555,
0.4680609405040741,
0.03439442068338394,
-0.11853861808776855,
-0.6263198256492615,
0.3573450744152069,
-0.4410681426525116,
1.1637927293777466,
-0.8604924082756042,
-0.13585057854652405,
-0.5011231899261475,
-0.25629642605781555,
0.0228748582303524,
-0.35366544127464294,
0.6109498143196106,
-0.6028715968132019,
0.2195989489555359,
-0.3908730447292328,
-0.4358264207839966,
0.0870390310883522,
0.5905341506004333,
-0.6882514357566833,
0.9670642018318176,
-0.15122607350349426,
-0.605393648147583,
0.29557761549949646,
-0.3382805585861206,
-0.18195085227489471,
-0.07351309806108475,
-0.31794100999832153,
-0.260230153799057,
-0.13475440442562103,
0.5997080206871033,
-0.010601181536912918,
-0.40363892912864685,
0.4054485857486725,
-0.5703573822975159,
-0.21801967918872833,
0.20824895799160004,
-0.5219223499298096,
0.6236209869384766,
0.5658363699913025,
-0.29543522000312805,
0.31579074263572693,
-0.6962227821350098,
0.2255123108625412,
-0.0736384242773056,
0.03321787342429161,
-0.26661568880081177,
0.1049235463142395,
-0.3912331163883209,
0.5212839245796204,
0.31785041093826294,
-0.6766985654830933,
-0.012405683286488056,
-0.2560165822505951,
0.3258635699748993,
0.7886290550231934,
0.24625466763973236,
0.36147114634513855,
-0.30635806918144226,
0.6854141354560852,
0.16792090237140656,
0.45331302285194397,
0.12680493295192719,
-0.5104890465736389,
-0.8402559161186218,
-0.1176002100110054,
0.4337623715400696,
0.1948194056749344,
-1.034348964691162,
0.5163400173187256,
0.2781323194503784,
-0.5364115834236145,
-0.6570928692817688,
0.25198936462402344,
0.4954015016555786,
0.445701539516449,
0.7822371125221252,
-0.01978258416056633,
-0.5211760401725769,
-0.8096264004707336,
-0.7580423951148987,
-0.1982344686985016,
0.16492773592472076,
-0.08388470113277435,
0.4340609610080719,
-0.21932452917099,
1.0886591672897339,
-0.6143174767494202,
-0.316750705242157,
-0.33866190910339355,
-0.1343119740486145,
0.08859867602586746,
0.5138656497001648,
0.2444208711385727,
-0.6937902569770813,
-0.2523058354854584,
-0.13687238097190857,
-0.43559354543685913,
-0.3397936224937439,
-0.2925562858581543,
-0.5283808708190918,
0.024512937292456627,
0.4540860950946808,
-0.42781803011894226,
0.43996432423591614,
0.5043063163757324,
-0.6876121759414673,
0.6795700192451477,
-0.2533542811870575,
-0.23161639273166656,
-0.723080039024353,
0.07697603106498718,
0.08705941587686539,
-0.41635778546333313,
-0.22945041954517365,
0.11625348776578903,
0.12965261936187744,
0.28512999415397644,
-0.10332557559013367,
0.70412677526474,
-0.3811359703540802,
0.3805469572544098,
-0.5097470879554749,
0.12156926840543747,
0.3170723617076874,
0.2941441237926483,
-0.16269436478614807,
0.44996386766433716,
0.445339173078537,
-0.8033633232116699,
0.08293060213327408,
0.06350474059581757,
-0.00037972588324919343,
0.24452118575572968,
-0.6059592962265015,
0.28489556908607483,
-0.1451655626296997,
0.6755952835083008,
-0.8824293613433838,
-0.04826122522354126,
0.37177032232284546,
-0.3520234227180481,
-0.004598440136760473,
-0.2019951045513153,
-0.3606473505496979,
-0.6409862041473389,
-0.19797368347644806,
0.6248196363449097,
0.27187731862068176,
-0.8383331298828125,
0.8027234673500061,
0.24890254437923431,
0.3496249318122864,
-0.7518056631088257,
-0.6535537838935852,
-0.20935197174549103,
-0.045463211834430695,
-0.2794875204563141,
0.295211523771286,
-0.20884837210178375,
-0.04506519064307213,
0.11049201339483261,
-0.7959960103034973,
-0.1834685206413269,
0.015113181434571743,
-0.2552521228790283,
0.3072100281715393,
0.10654441267251968,
0.2599914073944092,
0.34292104840278625,
-0.16284188628196716,
0.35606369376182556,
-0.790834367275238,
0.4870435893535614,
-0.1071501299738884,
-0.37572813034057617,
-0.01082619559019804,
0.06532477587461472,
0.5531367063522339,
-0.4618096947669983,
0.7171539068222046,
0.4856053590774536,
-0.2984774112701416,
-0.6476994752883911,
-0.8846357464790344,
-0.37450799345970154,
-0.4958067536354065,
-0.018659355118870735,
-0.675326943397522,
-0.843352735042572,
0.5521864295005798,
0.12358579784631729,
-0.2819218933582306,
0.572624921798706,
0.22610829770565033,
-0.0671965554356575,
1.2724037170410156,
0.13135312497615814,
-0.08725183457136154,
0.32877010107040405,
-0.1102781593799591,
0.5571632385253906,
-0.9718044996261597,
-0.05374304950237274,
-0.3879968523979187,
-0.22852382063865662,
-0.72294682264328,
-0.26679837703704834,
0.33107930421829224,
0.014644953422248363,
-0.49044597148895264,
0.133855938911438,
-0.7996028661727905,
0.8106328248977661,
0.41223275661468506,
0.4068707823753357,
0.29266220331192017,
-0.15849922597408295,
-0.5080033540725708,
0.3245956003665924,
-0.8865622878074646,
-0.46050119400024414,
0.8609142899513245,
0.11762095987796783,
0.8725395202636719,
-0.09389084577560425,
0.8693458437919617,
0.04452815279364586,
0.0755346491932869,
-0.3996858596801758,
0.6103302240371704,
-0.23568220436573029,
-0.9448710083961487,
-0.26836511492729187,
-0.5801727175712585,
-0.8301706910133362,
0.5867777466773987,
-0.04830807074904442,
-0.727118194103241,
0.442046582698822,
0.5001106858253479,
-0.35702595114707947,
0.38431495428085327,
-0.4554344415664673,
0.9203476309776306,
-0.31992825865745544,
-0.635899007320404,
-0.5445811152458191,
-0.47327932715415955,
0.39474689960479736,
-0.21430565416812897,
-0.002986158011481166,
-0.1374787837266922,
0.27320587635040283,
0.5868069529533386,
-0.4982185661792755,
0.720959484577179,
-0.026947561651468277,
-0.0023415940813720226,
0.5732421278953552,
0.42427918314933777,
0.5143356323242188,
-0.06171642243862152,
-0.0947503075003624,
-0.06710462272167206,
0.20227226614952087,
-0.6623347997665405,
-0.6428707838058472,
0.8249094486236572,
-0.5363767147064209,
-1.0212388038635254,
-0.5421303510665894,
-0.22698362171649933,
-0.22593273222446442,
0.2900775372982025,
0.32114651799201965,
0.19638767838478088,
0.14713431894779205,
-0.05676054581999779,
0.541325569152832,
0.12155085057020187,
0.22821931540966034,
0.3693528175354004,
-0.3570983111858368,
-0.4825109839439392,
0.8380511403083801,
0.10110542923212051,
0.5531709790229797,
0.2738884389400482,
0.4703317880630493,
-0.3845539689064026,
-0.35742685198783875,
-0.3601064085960388,
0.4168309271335602,
-0.7696322202682495,
-0.24043534696102142,
-0.5804305076599121,
-0.3270154595375061,
-0.06707604974508286,
0.07808464020490646,
-0.4399498701095581,
-0.4622802436351776,
0.0198530163615942,
-0.0843222439289093,
0.16694587469100952,
0.5595291256904602,
0.19721254706382751,
-0.11950879544019699,
-0.4624715745449066,
0.4570518434047699,
0.40106216073036194,
0.5463639497756958,
-0.01488803792744875,
-0.46102458238601685,
0.0007854339783079922,
0.1858978122472763,
-0.673611044883728,
-0.6713045239448547,
0.21628563106060028,
-0.05514056608080864,
0.6497222185134888,
0.47792771458625793,
0.558154284954071,
0.8855686187744141,
-0.15383103489875793,
0.6345714926719666,
0.03372082859277725,
-1.095554232597351,
1.1546789407730103,
-0.07487385720014572,
0.5036789178848267,
0.71836256980896,
0.14358043670654297,
-0.13134697079658508,
-0.891467273235321,
-0.7215291261672974,
-0.8025919198989868,
0.5035911202430725,
0.3760416805744171,
-0.4116661548614502,
-0.19453908503055573,
0.33288371562957764,
0.05164295434951782,
-0.1662655621767044,
-0.8269661068916321,
-0.07220941036939621,
-0.2512802183628082,
-0.23258662223815918,
0.23669396340847015,
-0.2672422528266907,
0.027202146127820015,
-0.23173438012599945,
0.9046164751052856,
-0.3031282424926758,
-0.08936329185962677,
0.6777665615081787,
-0.14546088874340057,
-0.34438076615333557,
0.3715038001537323,
0.223610058426857,
0.7238649725914001,
-0.09812008589506149,
0.4295428395271301,
0.2908327281475067,
-0.3421509861946106,
0.1413622498512268,
-0.23679079115390778,
-0.3178229033946991,
-0.2872939109802246,
0.1336713284254074,
0.5218345522880554,
-0.038713451474905014,
-0.4639763832092285,
0.20707952976226807,
0.1005244255065918,
0.008054840378463268,
-0.21358872950077057,
0.3943754732608795,
-0.21207758784294128,
0.05553174391388893,
0.2624243199825287,
0.41153985261917114,
0.3242839574813843,
-0.39797520637512207,
0.011519988998770714,
0.22013989090919495,
-0.4861297309398651,
-0.16647101938724518,
0.7903170585632324,
0.1819775402545929,
-0.02273312397301197,
0.4803759753704071,
-0.18077963590621948,
-0.756075918674469,
0.659546971321106,
0.7813640236854553,
0.949744462966919,
-0.38103973865509033,
0.13905084133148193,
0.4471716284751892,
0.46396923065185547,
-0.4392981231212616,
0.36359938979148865,
-0.4009973108768463,
-0.9567087888717651,
-0.5249757170677185,
-0.3968313932418823,
-0.37739482522010803,
0.13577105104923248,
-0.4955023527145386,
0.2229699343442917,
-0.5364171266555786,
-0.22736839950084686,
-0.15694104135036469,
-0.1407284438610077,
-0.551514208316803,
0.5003793239593506,
0.18969017267227173,
0.9201595187187195,
-0.5323709845542908,
1.0559825897216797,
0.5482040643692017,
-0.4495187997817993,
-0.809708833694458,
0.43253087997436523,
-0.281607985496521,
-0.3815081715583801,
0.3430102467536926,
0.18504202365875244,
-0.6860147714614868,
-0.0907558724284172,
-0.5803206562995911,
-1.0371912717819214,
0.9013718962669373,
0.3478272557258606,
-0.8188197016716003,
0.22092968225479126,
-0.2296074479818344,
0.5695076584815979,
-0.31413474678993225,
0.4728868901729584,
0.716526210308075,
0.42428770661354065,
0.19800712168216705,
-0.9218710660934448,
0.3309996426105499,
-0.24408891797065735,
-0.17325171828269958,
0.2447386533021927,
-0.7259830236434937,
0.4335450232028961,
-0.2851139307022095,
0.03972386568784714,
-0.17873695492744446,
0.5547139644622803,
0.7844083905220032,
0.4881662130355835,
0.7492097020149231,
0.4199824631214142,
1.052009105682373,
0.16788190603256226,
1.1082849502563477,
-0.38887226581573486,
0.3750233054161072,
1.267835021018982,
-0.3681785762310028,
0.8480762243270874,
0.5682512521743774,
0.055947769433259964,
0.7875608801841736,
0.642041027545929,
0.08743059635162354,
0.6158083081245422,
0.08839891105890274,
-0.22944632172584534,
-0.8075149655342102,
0.00773330545052886,
-0.23413905501365662,
0.5112534165382385,
0.4409633278846741,
-0.37100112438201904,
0.05446508526802063,
-0.22608020901679993,
-0.3137465715408325,
0.1899709403514862,
-0.4427243173122406,
0.492628812789917,
0.25838202238082886,
-1.0589182376861572,
0.6337887644767761,
-0.3286900222301483,
0.29352691769599915,
-0.4363729655742645,
0.15157121419906616,
-0.0513458214700222,
0.42242053151130676,
-0.3301700949668884,
-0.8402217030525208,
0.33643800020217896,
-0.07311379164457321,
-0.15325549244880676,
-0.24440424144268036,
1.109599232673645,
-0.47220709919929504,
-0.44906094670295715,
0.5729644298553467,
0.5683194398880005,
-0.025726305320858955,
-0.2976544201374054,
-0.5973705649375916,
-0.17108063399791718,
0.06669553369283676,
-0.22177152335643768,
0.027659354731440544,
0.46911513805389404,
-0.30978119373321533,
1.1163723468780518,
0.6619277596473694,
0.20778028666973114,
-0.18548130989074707,
0.3497599959373474,
1.0465140342712402,
-0.7913627028465271,
-0.9621052145957947,
-1.022094488143921,
0.17983095347881317,
-0.23753024637699127,
-0.22121094167232513,
0.5179624557495117,
0.45563748478889465,
0.800129234790802,
-0.06723197549581528,
0.6884779334068298,
0.1624063104391098,
0.24384327232837677,
-0.5085288882255554,
0.7616179585456848,
-0.33994919061660767,
0.5991106629371643,
-0.045226939022541046,
-0.8955984711647034,
-0.21562573313713074,
0.7915668487548828,
-0.6198647022247314,
0.19738833606243134,
1.122368335723877,
0.730599045753479,
-0.060394156724214554,
0.23828768730163574,
0.3086818754673004,
0.40145382285118103,
0.3460674285888672,
0.6080186367034912,
1.092109203338623,
-0.28946977853775024,
0.69525545835495,
-0.13049249351024628,
0.024110905826091766,
0.021904101595282555,
-0.6234248876571655,
-1.0969352722167969,
-0.32781001925468445,
-0.4928528964519501,
-0.5237101316452026,
0.17200303077697754,
1.0767707824707031,
0.7346482276916504,
-0.9362345933914185,
0.013018474914133549,
-0.6058518290519714,
0.5190603137016296,
-0.3108369708061218,
-0.20777757465839386,
-0.014759247191250324,
-0.4646313786506653,
-0.18009838461875916,
0.4125820994377136,
0.1499648094177246,
-0.39503419399261475,
-0.3422040343284607,
0.0681813433766365,
-0.18602022528648376,
0.34142711758613586,
0.4022548198699951,
0.058120954781770706,
-1.0565907955169678,
-0.5141304731369019,
-0.20804789662361145,
0.05435345694422722,
-0.05227355286478996,
0.8551268577575684,
-1.276823878288269,
0.7214695811271667,
0.3977513909339905,
0.2567667067050934,
0.7688157558441162,
0.013554203324019909,
0.6213622093200684,
-0.5804223418235779,
-0.30336079001426697,
0.38944393396377563,
0.5070573091506958,
0.15370889008045197,
-0.6421919465065002,
0.5912853479385376,
0.03883826732635498,
-0.6951708197593689,
-0.7071583271026611,
0.4433647692203522,
-0.9363552331924438,
-0.4888201653957367,
1.0698760747909546,
0.0886673554778099,
-0.418437659740448,
-0.3012390434741974,
-0.32205623388290405,
0.21052832901477814,
-0.3714914917945862,
1.0287301540374756,
0.7436116933822632,
-0.208485409617424,
-0.3124023675918579,
-0.2089327722787857,
0.35903939604759216,
0.6266874670982361,
-0.5843891501426697,
-0.10452651232481003,
0.21453505754470825,
0.5326757431030273,
0.10776961594820023,
0.5954534411430359,
-0.004973636008799076,
0.36674949526786804,
-0.03119470551609993,
-0.16181375086307526,
0.08694543689489365,
-0.462738573551178,
-0.1943719983100891,
0.15714767575263977,
0.036299899220466614,
-0.21267807483673096
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19161v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19161v1
|
Improving Vietnamese-English Medical Machine Translation
| 2024-03-28T06:07:15 | 2024-03-28T06:07:15 |
Nhu Vo, Dat Quoc Nguyen, Dung D. Le, Massimo Piccardi, Wray Buntine
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Machine translation for Vietnamese-English in the medical domain is still an
under-explored research area. In this paper, we introduce MedEV -- a
high-quality Vietnamese-English parallel dataset constructed specifically for
the medical domain, comprising approximately 360K sentence pairs. We conduct
extensive experiments comparing Google Translate, ChatGPT (gpt-3.5-turbo),
state-of-the-art Vietnamese-English neural machine translation models and
pre-trained bilingual/multilingual sequence-to-sequence models on our new MedEV
dataset. Experimental results show that the best performance is achieved by
fine-tuning "vinai-translate" for each translation direction. We publicly
release our dataset to promote further research.
|
[
-0.03592868894338608,
-0.34906262159347534,
0.6838107109069824,
0.12928466498851776,
-0.4411610960960388,
0.06977996230125427,
-0.22693213820457458,
-0.1890581250190735,
0.15960693359375,
0.4963986277580261,
-0.16295401751995087,
-0.6891100406646729,
-0.7784234285354614,
0.41874441504478455,
-0.12586762011051178,
1.038562297821045,
-0.3784337639808655,
0.5020524859428406,
-0.10889604687690735,
-0.5431704521179199,
-0.7028829455375671,
-0.46126261353492737,
-0.5624163746833801,
-0.0959547907114029,
0.7466914057731628,
0.5450923442840576,
0.7048329710960388,
0.8010917901992798,
0.9540903568267822,
0.2735159695148468,
0.5928727388381958,
0.4484701454639435,
-0.4135642647743225,
0.02002028375864029,
-0.06206873431801796,
-0.3578852117061615,
-0.8797297477722168,
-0.07034270465373993,
0.3880216181278229,
0.3744488060474396,
-0.07979363948106766,
-0.11250526458024979,
-0.2375776618719101,
0.6278854012489319,
-0.2570830285549164,
0.2956821322441101,
-0.40776169300079346,
-0.2942902445793152,
-0.2073344588279724,
-0.4139144718647003,
-0.37666159868240356,
-0.2666172981262207,
0.02820257656276226,
-0.8570743203163147,
0.06146874278783798,
0.23393192887306213,
0.9771624803543091,
0.4287596344947815,
-0.6474407911300659,
0.06020617112517357,
-0.5644614100456238,
0.7241085171699524,
-0.5008537173271179,
0.3641209304332733,
0.3553510308265686,
0.5819745659828186,
0.03600673750042915,
-0.7046082019805908,
-0.2124161273241043,
-0.06787360459566116,
-0.18401792645454407,
0.4266391098499298,
-0.036097101867198944,
-0.00288629368878901,
-0.06301923841238022,
0.13146544992923737,
-1.2194421291351318,
0.2003718763589859,
-0.7476077675819397,
0.14981210231781006,
0.677650511264801,
0.3739093244075775,
0.2757304608821869,
-0.18032845854759216,
-0.3136396110057831,
-0.0714288055896759,
-0.7796197533607483,
-0.41258323192596436,
-0.2653213143348694,
0.08957580476999283,
-0.2408670037984848,
0.7452719807624817,
-0.17244526743888855,
0.6865217089653015,
-0.600472629070282,
-0.08561015874147415,
0.6314088106155396,
-0.5748986005783081,
-0.5659390687942505,
-0.10369214415550232,
0.814860463142395,
0.7716450095176697,
0.4937945306301117,
-0.10457329452037811,
-0.3495931923389435,
0.28557902574539185,
0.20195910334587097,
-0.5724530816078186,
-0.1782837063074112,
0.5588151216506958,
-0.5550805330276489,
-0.2306278944015503,
-0.08490455895662308,
-0.5084527134895325,
-0.16792158782482147,
-0.46001166105270386,
0.4094719886779785,
-0.3830404579639435,
-0.2109784632921219,
0.5187031626701355,
0.025733178481459618,
0.04329371824860573,
0.23321440815925598,
-0.24623559415340424,
0.3710952699184418,
0.7218599915504456,
0.8593102693557739,
-0.4018002450466156,
-0.5922192335128784,
-0.7586269378662109,
-0.07311523705720901,
-0.31824395060539246,
0.8536779284477234,
-0.27590206265449524,
-0.20578013360500336,
0.06766510009765625,
0.2500172555446625,
-0.22209683060646057,
-0.7810044288635254,
0.5303874015808105,
-0.1648571491241455,
0.42885953187942505,
0.08302170783281326,
-0.5792166590690613,
0.1253826916217804,
0.003521447768434882,
-0.44232386350631714,
0.3730721175670624,
0.2976863384246826,
-0.577705979347229,
0.18264399468898773,
-0.6209269762039185,
-0.5753641128540039,
0.23339326679706573,
-0.22377122938632965,
-0.4047342538833618,
0.21915073692798615,
0.5570094585418701,
0.6021894812583923,
-0.7792835831642151,
0.36091163754463196,
0.3389155864715576,
-0.15647895634174347,
0.08365614712238312,
-0.21847839653491974,
0.5564042925834656,
0.4722292423248291,
-0.03017682209610939,
0.2510598301887512,
-0.799167811870575,
-0.3533940017223358,
0.1113191694021225,
-0.07340539246797562,
-0.4856235980987549,
-0.20916053652763367,
0.3780883550643921,
0.45374172925949097,
-0.06596310436725616,
-0.5491353273391724,
0.14539198577404022,
-0.3421623706817627,
0.5876790881156921,
0.34425637125968933,
-0.1911863386631012,
0.357124388217926,
-0.6008789539337158,
0.6731206178665161,
0.2554480731487274,
0.3028899133205414,
-0.3883585035800934,
-0.9070630073547363,
-0.5171242952346802,
-0.6286140084266663,
0.32864680886268616,
0.9377509355545044,
-1.0417746305465698,
0.1425473988056183,
-0.6101343035697937,
-0.23000282049179077,
-1.4875260591506958,
-0.21086101233959198,
0.30154821276664734,
0.7655491232872009,
0.6402795314788818,
-0.17320382595062256,
-0.26685622334480286,
-1.1276646852493286,
-0.14180494844913483,
0.005650589242577553,
-0.29031845927238464,
0.4625302851200104,
0.2947748601436615,
-0.6208595037460327,
0.29901671409606934,
-0.5926315784454346,
-0.4906073808670044,
0.06009040027856827,
0.263869047164917,
0.1756279021501541,
0.38795360922813416,
0.5948395729064941,
-0.8444761037826538,
-0.6679824590682983,
0.5862812399864197,
-0.7950317859649658,
-0.12088660150766373,
-0.07904481142759323,
-0.10457863658666611,
0.10859836637973785,
0.42244672775268555,
-0.7902122139930725,
0.36994364857673645,
0.6450451612472534,
-0.3908199667930603,
0.33604833483695984,
-0.5368520021438599,
0.6607818007469177,
-1.5435973405838013,
0.03657705709338188,
-0.18209560215473175,
-0.5570943355560303,
-0.4757404327392578,
-0.06593308597803116,
0.25075024366378784,
-0.0991705134510994,
-0.6927345991134644,
0.3649590015411377,
-0.20151042938232422,
0.3161373734474182,
-0.3101496994495392,
0.05226931720972061,
0.010136667639017105,
-0.01260570902377367,
-0.32989874482154846,
0.8561801910400391,
0.5756223201751709,
-0.26514700055122375,
0.7281458973884583,
0.22795167565345764,
-0.23110483586788177,
0.7140481472015381,
-0.7820857167243958,
-0.014239871874451637,
-0.21375232934951782,
-0.10028628259897232,
-0.7143145799636841,
-0.3929346799850464,
-0.010041981004178524,
-0.6054584980010986,
0.28891852498054504,
0.0005505760782398283,
-0.4186593294143677,
-0.2713073790073395,
-0.04559139534831047,
0.5081456899642944,
0.8763173818588257,
-0.3139760196208954,
-0.03588320314884186,
0.40086641907691956,
-0.42209240794181824,
-0.24601954221725464,
-0.5384753942489624,
0.19750194251537323,
-0.2397848665714264,
-0.5290325880050659,
0.194053515791893,
0.21537922322750092,
-0.25329867005348206,
0.022487003356218338,
0.3043367266654968,
-0.2545897364616394,
-0.39900919795036316,
-0.14853481948375702,
0.26776814460754395,
-0.5729694962501526,
0.38670262694358826,
0.03565698862075806,
-0.3435119390487671,
0.11454831063747406,
-0.6643780469894409,
0.20123210549354553,
0.024590671062469482,
0.05866582691669464,
-0.297713041305542,
0.592797577381134,
1.0342295169830322,
-0.3995957672595978,
0.7115548849105835,
0.39690321683883667,
-0.46370789408683777,
0.3032996654510498,
-0.4667510986328125,
-0.044354118406772614,
-0.37038448452949524,
0.720221221446991,
-0.4742744565010071,
-0.7117549180984497,
0.14332756400108337,
-0.0216470118612051,
0.05063211917877197,
0.5786421895027161,
0.610112726688385,
-0.25548917055130005,
1.1342557668685913,
0.4621943235397339,
-0.2552759349346161,
-0.2503300905227661,
-0.04291074723005295,
0.02691756747663021,
-0.3910422921180725,
-0.09066607803106308,
-0.3864835798740387,
-0.08288635313510895,
-0.988615095615387,
-0.7244789004325867,
0.24910211563110352,
-0.4948781430721283,
-0.007010459899902344,
0.5346432328224182,
-0.5289141535758972,
0.18951880931854248,
0.427761048078537,
0.03877528756856918,
0.31339964270591736,
0.08638942986726761,
-0.023061253130435944,
-0.31695088744163513,
-0.59958416223526,
-0.341850221157074,
1.2934139966964722,
0.18562282621860504,
0.627577543258667,
-0.2704952657222748,
0.33717966079711914,
0.07497849315404892,
0.30833151936531067,
-0.5090360045433044,
0.15866543352603912,
-0.6341339349746704,
-0.19106975197792053,
0.023423297330737114,
-0.6298616528511047,
-1.1914645433425903,
0.0553954541683197,
-0.009680639952421188,
0.06840189546346664,
-0.14314767718315125,
0.0398094542324543,
-0.042434945702552795,
0.1144169494509697,
-0.8621242046356201,
0.9148671627044678,
-0.3739175796508789,
-0.10239662230014801,
-0.21044108271598816,
-0.6221452355384827,
0.08821089565753937,
-0.2714887857437134,
0.16773001849651337,
-0.18516306579113007,
-0.2724469304084778,
0.4173855483531952,
-0.3580085039138794,
0.035409118980169296,
0.08065646141767502,
0.044432420283555984,
-0.07814671844244003,
-0.3508822023868561,
0.30209335684776306,
0.33695513010025024,
0.32683342695236206,
0.19528436660766602,
-0.20827622711658478,
-0.7960147857666016,
-0.6185582876205444,
0.7911795973777771,
-0.7597309947013855,
-0.38373279571533203,
-0.35455629229545593,
-0.8198246955871582,
-0.10984344035387039,
0.20359160006046295,
0.5199775695800781,
0.1342296302318573,
-0.16591647267341614,
0.05866607278585434,
0.47400742769241333,
-0.5301004648208618,
-0.2652468979358673,
0.4601266086101532,
-0.2039087861776352,
-0.6542104482650757,
1.056040644645691,
0.09888073801994324,
0.17944511771202087,
0.5877360105514526,
0.12801626324653625,
0.06988826394081116,
-0.2610730230808258,
-0.6474818587303162,
0.7140122652053833,
-0.16035500168800354,
-0.26742732524871826,
-0.8128717541694641,
-0.3898499011993408,
-0.5489955544471741,
-0.22708557546138763,
-0.5311482548713684,
-0.44454407691955566,
0.09572859853506088,
-0.09967155009508133,
0.663982629776001,
0.9494054317474365,
0.2724161148071289,
0.2996501624584198,
-0.7294937372207642,
0.631818413734436,
0.13224263489246368,
0.1614389419555664,
-0.8939700722694397,
-0.44751647114753723,
-0.30333447456359863,
-0.09224981814622879,
0.15369068086147308,
-0.6936584115028381,
0.7625205516815186,
-0.020354555919766426,
0.18377605080604553,
0.14840702712535858,
-0.2689885199069977,
0.5377438068389893,
-1.1486945152282715,
0.4171260595321655,
0.08488982170820236,
-0.10135190188884735,
0.7395864725112915,
-0.5450306534767151,
0.4648646414279938,
0.3432909846305847,
0.45171308517456055,
-0.5109149217605591,
-0.37062257528305054,
-0.5359143018722534,
-0.8030237555503845,
0.17708799242973328,
0.5983477234840393,
-0.2519375681877136,
0.19032374024391174,
0.25068140029907227,
0.24950416386127472,
0.38889065384864807,
0.1114044338464737,
-0.3528366982936859,
-0.05015969276428223,
-0.5326900482177734,
-0.7655536532402039,
0.06384290754795074,
0.025569168850779533,
-0.5558830499649048,
0.4277280569076538,
0.004889219533652067,
0.5063004493713379,
0.18549922108650208,
0.014171556569635868,
0.12379293143749237,
0.16515445709228516,
0.8893029093742371,
0.6544919610023499,
-0.24615466594696045,
-0.02871289849281311,
-0.0778188407421112,
-0.8282462954521179,
0.3230821192264557,
0.6007363200187683,
-0.12219059467315674,
0.4968402683734894,
0.2002265751361847,
0.7744423151016235,
-0.2978460192680359,
-0.6346267461776733,
0.45728927850723267,
-0.3845863938331604,
-0.23858003318309784,
0.10349949449300766,
-0.39935389161109924,
0.026494815945625305,
-0.1520448476076126,
-0.014735513366758823,
0.24036845564842224,
0.09650588780641556,
0.024223091080784798,
0.4507542848587036,
-0.1901812106370926,
-0.4434170126914978,
-0.46054571866989136,
0.827008068561554,
0.40308424830436707,
-0.36059442162513733,
0.8428156971931458,
0.18607504665851593,
-0.2375486046075821,
0.6539194583892822,
0.28789231181144714,
1.0164486169815063,
-0.5636826157569885,
0.2214968055486679,
0.2772229313850403,
0.5535284876823425,
-0.10455470532178879,
0.5149000883102417,
0.5377393364906311,
-0.15211251378059387,
-0.5437049865722656,
-0.13740313053131104,
-0.22249595820903778,
0.3606538474559784,
-0.6127162575721741,
0.4178679287433624,
0.33680087327957153,
-0.05268299952149391,
-0.06794461607933044,
-0.38528692722320557,
-1.0061135292053223,
0.2676342725753784,
-0.2890540361404419,
0.872342050075531,
-0.9160523414611816,
1.2749578952789307,
1.0583360195159912,
-0.1800764948129654,
-0.30405405163764954,
-0.2858634889125824,
-0.09914398938417435,
-0.8010347485542297,
0.40678492188453674,
0.1301516443490982,
0.24465838074684143,
0.10202687233686447,
-0.3607652485370636,
-0.5269267559051514,
0.8941826224327087,
0.48477402329444885,
-0.655469536781311,
0.06933227181434631,
0.6021537780761719,
0.6042813658714294,
-0.5815457105636597,
-0.035571444779634476,
0.7394806742668152,
0.16753742098808289,
-0.6122263669967651,
-1.1449817419052124,
-0.3281495273113251,
-0.43243494629859924,
-0.19645299017429352,
0.21397040784358978,
-0.5195696353912354,
0.7829689979553223,
-0.0037575748283416033,
0.32895901799201965,
0.038176991045475006,
0.5212998390197754,
0.1088600903749466,
0.33230459690093994,
0.17997492849826813,
0.5788642168045044,
0.6418558359146118,
-0.1595820039510727,
1.158747911453247,
-0.11553124338388443,
0.14560212194919586,
1.03607976436615,
-0.17308783531188965,
0.8441287279129028,
0.5937409400939941,
0.10121101886034012,
-0.20856718719005585,
0.46473032236099243,
0.2669525742530823,
0.6715133190155029,
0.13673396408557892,
-0.2776382565498352,
0.07841039448976517,
-0.2144576907157898,
-0.4287128746509552,
0.2604182958602905,
0.5331164002418518,
-0.47202491760253906,
0.18807165324687958,
0.5917068123817444,
0.17826993763446808,
0.1577008217573166,
-0.0284800436347723,
0.6341922283172607,
0.3791118860244751,
-0.8215455412864685,
0.7794646620750427,
-0.05496063455939293,
0.43184739351272583,
-0.38263365626335144,
-0.1881324201822281,
-0.5028908252716064,
0.3505479097366333,
0.11133886128664017,
-0.5495244860649109,
0.056547682732343674,
0.11908973753452301,
-0.11164221912622452,
-0.22823280096054077,
0.4223814904689789,
-0.692430853843689,
-0.5533396601676941,
0.2981261610984802,
0.7099753022193909,
0.4014597535133362,
0.12797001004219055,
-0.6880218386650085,
-0.12649346888065338,
-0.28555557131767273,
0.14599432051181793,
0.16060121357440948,
0.7136836647987366,
0.01194864884018898,
0.4196856915950775,
0.20478543639183044,
0.4723075330257416,
0.12695302069187164,
0.13103315234184265,
0.8077846169471741,
-0.5403260588645935,
-0.297427773475647,
-0.7023130059242249,
0.43565037846565247,
-0.038615237921476364,
-0.5456705093383789,
0.6618339419364929,
0.8055635690689087,
1.0800318717956543,
-0.34497585892677307,
0.8430792689323425,
0.29170966148376465,
0.4321466088294983,
-0.40801379084587097,
0.8712641000747681,
-0.6298887729644775,
-0.22559741139411926,
0.08713497966527939,
-0.704217791557312,
-0.5790206789970398,
0.34542855620384216,
0.17897270619869232,
-0.256870299577713,
1.010689616203308,
0.723655641078949,
-0.1917538046836853,
-0.35158246755599976,
0.7938982844352722,
0.49740830063819885,
0.27803024649620056,
0.8586504459381104,
0.5121254324913025,
-0.9151884317398071,
0.3358973264694214,
-0.2549763321876526,
-0.4097786247730255,
-0.13073845207691193,
-0.3024432957172394,
-0.8146933913230896,
-0.6361190676689148,
-0.4523894786834717,
-0.435820609331131,
0.587842583656311,
0.8205097913742065,
0.6959184408187866,
-0.9853552579879761,
-0.27851900458335876,
-0.04705725982785225,
-0.23000767827033997,
-0.4808061420917511,
-0.053827278316020966,
0.5023415088653564,
-0.5746858716011047,
-0.7649855613708496,
0.5449167490005493,
0.5143063068389893,
-0.10293781757354736,
0.023844722658395767,
-0.3063502609729767,
-0.24851079285144806,
-0.18281884491443634,
0.6992729902267456,
0.07137849181890488,
-0.5067909955978394,
0.037451356649398804,
0.5307187438011169,
-0.5692166686058044,
0.35814139246940613,
0.8946900367736816,
-0.7986416220664978,
0.7895298004150391,
0.5097877979278564,
0.9356755614280701,
0.13908542692661285,
-0.10503207892179489,
1.1395885944366455,
-0.5473113656044006,
0.2737662196159363,
0.2977100908756256,
0.32579824328422546,
0.401516854763031,
-0.2556178867816925,
0.7299512028694153,
0.4173119366168976,
-0.9395843148231506,
-0.5932446122169495,
-0.06923986226320267,
-0.6604494452476501,
-0.009776255115866661,
1.1116468906402588,
-0.08857256919145584,
-0.3097792863845825,
-0.35580259561538696,
-0.5208019018173218,
0.3697322905063629,
-0.14693079888820648,
0.4577433466911316,
0.47440198063850403,
0.06675508618354797,
-0.0856018215417862,
-1.2143157720565796,
0.6940169334411621,
0.7191891074180603,
-0.924310564994812,
-0.2008194774389267,
0.2832033932209015,
-0.12026923894882202,
-0.2424929141998291,
0.5750449299812317,
-0.14405246078968048,
0.6174896359443665,
-0.3270152807235718,
-0.18148931860923767,
0.09602680057287216,
-0.5757001638412476,
-0.4378005564212799,
-0.22994768619537354,
-0.12115468829870224,
-0.7533071637153625
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19159v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19159v1
|
Disentangling Length from Quality in Direct Preference Optimization
| 2024-03-28T06:03:47 | 2024-03-28T06:03:47 |
Ryan Park, Rafael Rafailov, Stefano Ermon, Chelsea Finn
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) has been a crucial
component in the recent success of Large Language Models. However, RLHF is know
to exploit biases in human preferences, such as verbosity. A well-formatted and
eloquent answer is often more highly rated by users, even when it is less
helpful and objective. A number of approaches have been developed to control
those biases in the classical RLHF literature, but the problem remains
relatively under-explored for Direct Alignment Algorithms such as Direct
Preference Optimization (DPO). Unlike classical RLHF, DPO does not train a
separate reward model or use reinforcement learning directly, so previous
approaches developed to control verbosity cannot be directly applied to this
setting. Our work makes several contributions. For the first time, we study the
length problem in the DPO setting, showing significant exploitation in DPO and
linking it to out-of-distribution bootstrapping. We then develop a principled
but simple regularization strategy that prevents length exploitation, while
still maintaining improvements in model quality. We demonstrate these effects
across datasets on summarization and dialogue, where we achieve up to 20\%
improvement in win rates when controlling for length, despite the GPT4 judge's
well-known verbosity bias.
|
[
-0.4558141231536865,
-0.6538923382759094,
0.7354922890663147,
0.2146264612674713,
-0.5018369555473328,
0.1751234531402588,
-0.45706918835639954,
-0.38849353790283203,
0.18309755623340607,
0.41325363516807556,
-0.7369710803031921,
-0.28560611605644226,
-0.7002840042114258,
0.11287228018045425,
0.17278727889060974,
1.1090856790542603,
-0.16257715225219727,
-0.16911561787128448,
-0.3314148485660553,
-0.1437222957611084,
-0.4285353124141693,
-0.43060001730918884,
-0.38474759459495544,
-0.45334264636039734,
0.8469910025596619,
0.6643280386924744,
1.018141508102417,
1.0781848430633545,
0.5527173280715942,
0.22598464787006378,
-0.14203916490077972,
0.3619050085544586,
-0.7073864340782166,
0.2466803342103958,
0.051317840814590454,
-0.4625047445297241,
-0.2909311354160309,
0.016270607709884644,
0.856965959072113,
0.7333654165267944,
-0.3084017336368561,
-0.1197069063782692,
0.2087240368127823,
1.240465760231018,
-0.6284253001213074,
0.059569112956523895,
-0.22172386944293976,
0.27712711691856384,
-0.008745492435991764,
-0.35836949944496155,
-0.3088304102420807,
-0.3608122766017914,
0.3156396448612213,
-0.6802886128425598,
0.11424601823091507,
-0.009823922999203205,
0.9920209646224976,
0.5064361095428467,
-0.22889570891857147,
-0.16957737505435944,
-1.0411614179611206,
0.9788571000099182,
-0.7172237634658813,
0.3299269676208496,
0.38933131098747253,
0.11740066111087799,
-0.16609787940979004,
-0.13077467679977417,
-0.2904382348060608,
-0.3802379071712494,
-0.3201885223388672,
-0.004228394478559494,
0.12105489522218704,
0.4025489389896393,
0.22567100822925568,
0.3903762698173523,
-0.5059207081794739,
0.43667352199554443,
-0.4894579350948334,
-0.14014175534248352,
0.956890344619751,
0.09259364753961563,
-0.16141018271446228,
-0.1676187664270401,
-0.3635854423046112,
-0.27228912711143494,
-0.6064092516899109,
0.37227556109428406,
0.7791954278945923,
0.12103378772735596,
0.2868218421936035,
0.4493170976638794,
-0.3637447655200958,
0.7607435584068298,
0.31532904505729675,
-0.19945146143436432,
-0.06747821718454361,
-0.13159491121768951,
0.004812553059309721,
0.11623982340097427,
0.820986270904541,
0.37105926871299744,
0.2699113190174103,
-0.03589995950460434,
-0.4867877960205078,
-0.1683911681175232,
0.17970265448093414,
-0.7499762773513794,
0.0368717797100544,
0.37913885712623596,
-0.3198329508304596,
-0.3341490924358368,
0.1870175302028656,
-0.9284672141075134,
-0.40330860018730164,
-0.39309704303741455,
0.1918494701385498,
-0.21413080394268036,
-0.14530202746391296,
0.3188043236732483,
0.017516082152724266,
0.056111473590135574,
0.006754221860319376,
-1.199916958808899,
0.543518602848053,
0.7679668068885803,
0.7732969522476196,
-0.3518558740615845,
-0.3611213266849518,
-0.8254802227020264,
-0.268087238073349,
-0.5114965438842773,
0.3291262090206146,
-0.3705749213695526,
-0.4816599190235138,
0.012668391689658165,
-0.23077447712421417,
0.24910202622413635,
-0.5353156328201294,
0.44374513626098633,
-0.6063165068626404,
0.5196914076805115,
-0.24006247520446777,
-0.590241014957428,
0.04217731952667236,
0.040386006236076355,
-0.6609543561935425,
0.7961905002593994,
0.028700003400444984,
-0.6849730014801025,
0.6473982334136963,
-0.4987238347530365,
-0.3218810558319092,
-0.3286904990673065,
-0.2320435345172882,
-0.5705289840698242,
0.33234772086143494,
0.36011096835136414,
0.21005669236183167,
-0.006327913608402014,
0.5180922746658325,
-0.1255372315645218,
-0.6801034808158875,
0.3117186725139618,
-0.3750748932361603,
0.10702868551015854,
0.0897187814116478,
-0.45833370089530945,
0.4502149522304535,
-0.5878978967666626,
-0.14020958542823792,
0.09524413198232651,
-0.46462157368659973,
-0.26102325320243835,
0.05986694619059563,
-0.3280865550041199,
0.17619480192661285,
0.23548848927021027,
-0.4776526391506195,
0.2713932693004608,
-0.6798154711723328,
0.21043533086776733,
1.0964360237121582,
-0.026267359033226967,
0.7427067756652832,
-0.26733285188674927,
0.6088181734085083,
0.0345003716647625,
0.3964233994483948,
0.34083986282348633,
0.003516074502840638,
-0.6871918439865112,
-0.21820992231369019,
0.5263293385505676,
0.17477719485759735,
-0.5965132713317871,
0.5920370221138,
-0.3116496503353119,
-0.21868717670440674,
-0.5827906131744385,
0.3360295295715332,
0.4654051661491394,
0.5880901217460632,
0.40810471773147583,
-0.43373289704322815,
-0.15493802726268768,
-1.1530406475067139,
-0.1373024731874466,
-0.23482967913150787,
-0.10231229662895203,
0.36545267701148987,
0.0261447224766016,
0.07953888922929764,
1.1385327577590942,
-0.9180960655212402,
-0.14883029460906982,
-0.25269871950149536,
0.003140268148854375,
0.29865992069244385,
0.43963462114334106,
0.30932971835136414,
-0.666598379611969,
-0.37403082847595215,
-0.34884753823280334,
-0.32583847641944885,
0.000987728126347065,
-0.11804023385047913,
-0.24480967223644257,
0.21351183950901031,
0.0435233972966671,
-0.4780065715312958,
0.3261702358722687,
0.42239782214164734,
-0.3695439398288727,
0.658444881439209,
-0.40522098541259766,
0.16305482387542725,
-0.48738130927085876,
-0.2093881219625473,
0.20682214200496674,
-0.3638018071651459,
-0.34958377480506897,
-0.2864842414855957,
-0.032758112996816635,
0.08197720348834991,
-0.319440096616745,
0.4189402461051941,
-0.34060993790626526,
-0.17356586456298828,
-0.40111830830574036,
0.20388643443584442,
0.249626025557518,
0.873600959777832,
0.2818526029586792,
0.723371148109436,
0.1874488741159439,
-0.7814220786094666,
0.43795791268348694,
0.1653485745191574,
-0.09928259253501892,
0.246262326836586,
-0.8485826849937439,
0.06077663600444794,
-0.25332656502723694,
0.12994900345802307,
-0.9091746807098389,
-0.21422933042049408,
0.24828845262527466,
-0.33850714564323425,
0.4902101755142212,
-0.1686767041683197,
-0.3472864329814911,
-0.17877532541751862,
-0.569415271282196,
0.29494109749794006,
0.7671147584915161,
-0.5631178617477417,
-0.05789898335933685,
0.17497821152210236,
-0.16722749173641205,
-0.9293085336685181,
-0.19529490172863007,
-0.3821212351322174,
-0.4822271168231964,
-0.5104807615280151,
0.4183153510093689,
0.0059063914231956005,
-0.18639089167118073,
-0.249758780002594,
-0.4770635962486267,
0.02216164767742157,
0.11769409477710724,
-0.062092624604701996,
0.2524952292442322,
0.11614230275154114,
0.45969444513320923,
0.1473267525434494,
-0.08557966351509094,
0.05283351242542267,
-0.134908065199852,
0.524082601070404,
-0.03114570491015911,
-0.23021727800369263,
-0.6233894228935242,
0.27694931626319885,
0.3953225016593933,
-0.20273642241954803,
0.4685320258140564,
0.3989505171775818,
0.1271478831768036,
-0.24603991210460663,
-0.4695618152618408,
-0.666665256023407,
-0.4764973223209381,
0.4761723577976227,
-0.18135389685630798,
-0.9283473491668701,
0.238908052444458,
0.02235177904367447,
0.0007701505674049258,
0.3078383207321167,
0.10076325386762619,
0.014820053242146969,
1.0650585889816284,
0.8759713172912598,
-0.11116829514503479,
0.6733560562133789,
-0.08574435114860535,
-0.1448349505662918,
-0.6147007942199707,
0.005281809717416763,
-0.12102250009775162,
-0.6563349962234497,
-0.6090574264526367,
-0.21808651089668274,
0.23085139691829681,
0.24291880428791046,
-0.23705025017261505,
0.049474768340587616,
-0.5848050713539124,
0.49279192090034485,
0.5330120921134949,
0.30391308665275574,
0.3315730094909668,
0.010133640840649605,
0.09116367995738983,
-0.3109993636608124,
-0.7506957650184631,
-0.3275814354419708,
0.9378835558891296,
0.7260870933532715,
0.9098457098007202,
0.09337974339723587,
0.9010981321334839,
0.29374265670776367,
-0.1761358678340912,
-0.9652776718139648,
0.31308019161224365,
0.04415639117360115,
-0.19642750918865204,
-0.7758719325065613,
-0.719414472579956,
-0.9468668103218079,
0.20839984714984894,
0.09365349262952805,
-0.48439669609069824,
0.4066949188709259,
0.4690382182598114,
-0.47630152106285095,
0.06229430437088013,
-0.4064377546310425,
0.6897248029708862,
-0.4617821276187897,
-0.7319018840789795,
-0.1721917986869812,
-0.7318174242973328,
0.25734713673591614,
0.31200525164604187,
0.004258942324668169,
-0.3128141164779663,
-0.07873152196407318,
0.8723565340042114,
-0.4234171509742737,
0.6109402775764465,
-0.22017668187618256,
-0.24981065094470978,
0.08823113143444061,
0.1229933351278305,
0.5976380109786987,
0.3196192681789398,
0.23378734290599823,
-0.14971792697906494,
-0.08511945605278015,
-0.5597124099731445,
-0.8156667351722717,
0.6583349108695984,
-0.913171112537384,
-0.7478719353675842,
-0.4237012565135956,
-0.2532733976840973,
-0.5204052925109863,
-0.05214906111359596,
0.23823896050453186,
0.3676382899284363,
-0.1942920684814453,
0.01582002267241478,
0.8606135249137878,
-0.18076252937316895,
0.4398514926433563,
0.3198142349720001,
-0.16609518229961395,
-0.45925548672676086,
0.7780025005340576,
-0.12314733862876892,
0.5362380146980286,
0.38725608587265015,
0.5572472214698792,
-0.6251979470252991,
-0.3050370216369629,
-0.505448579788208,
0.4341050684452057,
-0.5936572551727295,
0.017565647140145302,
-0.25767338275909424,
0.04075426235795021,
-0.24366997182369232,
0.11340012401342392,
-0.5783634781837463,
-0.4259892702102661,
-0.3342262804508209,
-0.31010186672210693,
0.3738580346107483,
0.7621281743049622,
-0.1871263086795807,
0.24899785220623016,
-0.6209445595741272,
0.11843160539865494,
0.42926883697509766,
0.6963396072387695,
-0.11057694256305695,
-0.6576923131942749,
-0.2497410923242569,
0.007904504425823689,
-0.2592856287956238,
-0.876392662525177,
0.40274572372436523,
0.04588551074266434,
0.3174048960208893,
0.41067829728126526,
0.09854801744222641,
0.5890913009643555,
-0.36579856276512146,
0.6681432723999023,
0.3453511595726013,
-0.7792133092880249,
0.6708877682685852,
-0.25856223702430725,
0.192906454205513,
0.6334689855575562,
0.5838443040847778,
-0.691692054271698,
0.014057605527341366,
-0.5224287509918213,
-0.9222054481506348,
0.6857454776763916,
-0.06180089712142944,
0.053090184926986694,
0.058085694909095764,
0.40386131405830383,
0.25364384055137634,
0.39433789253234863,
-0.4445734918117523,
-0.18214872479438782,
-0.1568448841571808,
-0.022274695336818695,
-0.2652352750301361,
-0.6477194428443909,
-0.39609336853027344,
-0.12158259004354477,
0.683772087097168,
-0.20324912667274475,
0.017992053180933,
0.4592559337615967,
-0.0870547816157341,
-0.05507177487015724,
0.5363401174545288,
0.8011226654052734,
0.9998629093170166,
-0.44861292839050293,
-0.034850507974624634,
-0.36855411529541016,
-0.35984137654304504,
0.3305036425590515,
-0.0237587857991457,
0.021459033712744713,
0.07864303886890411,
0.18226048350334167,
0.9929742217063904,
-0.08166321367025375,
-0.6585814952850342,
0.5942906737327576,
0.018295053392648697,
-0.2774910032749176,
-0.019351424649357796,
-0.0343831405043602,
-0.36560437083244324,
-0.062458571046590805,
0.16856177151203156,
-0.24246948957443237,
0.18325185775756836,
-0.255892813205719,
0.21543441712856293,
0.1332980841398239,
-0.9534279108047485,
-0.17999625205993652,
0.3553624749183655,
0.40269735455513,
-0.07472429424524307,
0.6806415319442749,
-0.19235481321811676,
-0.34913370013237,
0.5537355542182922,
0.11710022389888763,
0.6755070686340332,
0.15747570991516113,
0.4838637709617615,
0.35403501987457275,
0.0021165465004742146,
-0.35093849897384644,
-0.20909033715724945,
-0.18790853023529053,
-0.6381490230560303,
-0.6799671053886414,
-0.6551873087882996,
-0.44581589102745056,
0.019537316635251045,
-0.8521569967269897,
0.06890882551670074,
-0.589599609375,
-0.12175452709197998,
-0.28188997507095337,
0.22037562727928162,
-0.47107642889022827,
0.0036532278172671795,
0.023176878690719604,
0.44103777408599854,
-0.6795657277107239,
0.4787439703941345,
0.2649521827697754,
-0.5943756699562073,
-0.7624977231025696,
0.17180411517620087,
-0.13019269704818726,
-0.5470415949821472,
0.7419156432151794,
0.0630832090973854,
-0.11844415962696075,
-0.13648384809494019,
-0.3956635296344757,
-0.7499723434448242,
1.0040874481201172,
0.2996748387813568,
-0.7790882587432861,
-0.0555134117603302,
0.02046101540327072,
0.4089014232158661,
-0.1307000368833542,
-0.04749350994825363,
0.859442412853241,
0.3793407678604126,
-0.02043071947991848,
-1.0016554594039917,
0.010702242143452168,
0.3120529353618622,
0.11956187337636948,
0.2815944254398346,
-0.6924780011177063,
0.39488211274147034,
-0.23383623361587524,
-0.13360828161239624,
-0.16221587359905243,
0.5925325155258179,
0.20541076362133026,
-0.10252264142036438,
0.5030298233032227,
0.40134039521217346,
0.7249059081077576,
-0.06348215043544769,
0.9487856030464172,
-0.018980497494339943,
0.4727267026901245,
1.2088369131088257,
-0.23883220553398132,
0.5878980755805969,
0.7872295379638672,
-0.2859174609184265,
0.44707271456718445,
0.8944144248962402,
0.27960634231567383,
0.7613592147827148,
0.6995599269866943,
-0.23324249684810638,
-0.20210115611553192,
-0.030628245323896408,
-0.1929115355014801,
0.41810593008995056,
0.05954738333821297,
-0.31615889072418213,
0.053507428616285324,
-0.10521966218948364,
0.14969800412654877,
0.48161426186561584,
-0.15884073078632355,
1.089844822883606,
-0.12249293923377991,
-1.0151935815811157,
0.6410955190658569,
-0.13238312304019928,
0.9708622694015503,
-0.6201537847518921,
0.025009147822856903,
-0.5781955718994141,
0.24684129655361176,
-0.11178440600633621,
-0.6954430341720581,
0.14955632388591766,
-0.27352216839790344,
-0.3240748941898346,
-0.22534088790416718,
0.42258840799331665,
-0.47814297676086426,
-0.09580636024475098,
0.32555994391441345,
0.48013898730278015,
-0.041317734867334366,
-0.07821638882160187,
-0.46969202160835266,
0.04209829121828079,
0.07893252372741699,
-0.3182034492492676,
0.4043698310852051,
0.28496333956718445,
0.1855648308992386,
0.5353010296821594,
0.43752750754356384,
0.24357278645038605,
-0.23687498271465302,
-0.08964614570140839,
0.8501882553100586,
-0.6055021286010742,
-0.5610960721969604,
-1.1234493255615234,
0.3486417531967163,
-0.36192938685417175,
-0.25922876596450806,
0.43240535259246826,
0.417893648147583,
0.8101935386657715,
-0.2205638885498047,
0.46868982911109924,
0.24135276675224304,
0.27898457646369934,
-0.5703446865081787,
0.4969957172870636,
-0.5342238545417786,
0.36182108521461487,
-0.14662596583366394,
-0.8871455788612366,
-0.10521475225687027,
0.3615574836730957,
-0.41346997022628784,
-0.10254650563001633,
0.6631434559822083,
0.6988482475280762,
0.13413138687610626,
-0.4679184556007385,
0.45624834299087524,
-0.16242526471614838,
0.4031844735145569,
0.5097187757492065,
0.9070137143135071,
-0.005840832833200693,
0.7249020338058472,
-0.48232316970825195,
-0.43555960059165955,
-0.21802370250225067,
-0.8673619031906128,
-0.5995106101036072,
-0.3815196752548218,
-0.33883240818977356,
-0.32043343782424927,
0.16963723301887512,
0.837153434753418,
0.7452906966209412,
-0.425911009311676,
-0.2978949546813965,
-0.12788762152194977,
0.384651780128479,
-0.408771812915802,
-0.25383901596069336,
0.4013998806476593,
-0.5280793309211731,
-0.6332300901412964,
0.23469342291355133,
0.27981850504875183,
0.047884777188301086,
-0.42745736241340637,
-0.32523855566978455,
-0.016416210681200027,
-0.01084491703659296,
0.2845030725002289,
0.3908945322036743,
-0.794447124004364,
-0.4262736141681671,
0.06620263308286667,
-0.058271899819374084,
0.3086443543434143,
0.8031527996063232,
-0.6210075616836548,
0.45836982131004333,
0.5264094471931458,
0.6077733039855957,
0.26936954259872437,
0.2800181210041046,
0.8794319033622742,
-1.166630506515503,
0.09846886247396469,
0.3655053675174713,
0.20068402588367462,
0.38894447684288025,
-0.661591112613678,
0.4167385697364807,
0.14986522495746613,
-0.7808529734611511,
-0.5596344470977783,
0.5457955598831177,
-0.7774192690849304,
-0.3715662956237793,
1.2331137657165527,
-0.06286311149597168,
-0.08624666929244995,
0.3451831340789795,
-0.3714410960674286,
0.08101741969585419,
-0.6726914048194885,
1.0012353658676147,
0.7626153230667114,
-0.3744342029094696,
-0.04902948811650276,
-0.2866058051586151,
1.052860140800476,
0.5140898823738098,
-0.5557441711425781,
0.274263471364975,
0.7523560523986816,
0.2706924378871918,
0.10625460743904114,
0.7535550594329834,
-0.09865912050008774,
0.27881112694740295,
-0.28785327076911926,
-0.08154464513063431,
-0.15451650321483612,
-0.4666789472103119,
-0.6033525466918945,
-0.08660809695720673,
0.4901140630245209,
-0.3946128487586975
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19154v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19154v2
|
STaR-GATE: Teaching Language Models to Ask Clarifying Questions
| 2024-03-28T05:35:22 | 2024-03-29T05:15:12 |
Chinmaya Andukuri, Jan-Philipp Fränken, Tobias Gerstenberg, Noah D. Goodman
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
When prompting language models to complete a task, users often leave
important aspects unsaid. While asking questions could resolve this ambiguity
(GATE; Li et al., 2023), models often struggle to ask good questions. We
explore a language model's ability to self-improve (STaR; Zelikman et al.,
2022) by rewarding the model for generating useful questions-a simple method we
dub STaR-GATE. We generate a synthetic dataset of 25,500 unique persona-task
prompts to simulate conversations between a pretrained language model-the
Questioner-and a Roleplayer whose preferences are unknown to the Questioner. By
asking questions, the Questioner elicits preferences from the Roleplayer. The
Questioner is iteratively finetuned on questions that increase the probability
of high-quality responses to the task, which are generated by an Oracle with
access to the Roleplayer's latent preferences. After two iterations of
self-improvement, the Questioner asks better questions, allowing it to generate
responses that are preferred over responses from the initial model on 72% of
tasks. Our results indicate that teaching a language model to ask better
questions leads to better personalized responses.
|
[
-0.38925743103027344,
-1.0610198974609375,
0.6298862099647522,
-0.09018543362617493,
0.20800602436065674,
-0.20002801716327667,
-0.2221057116985321,
-0.2715981900691986,
-0.09439551830291748,
0.6419509649276733,
-0.6872398853302002,
-0.06820759922266006,
-0.3883310854434967,
-0.05755187198519707,
-0.29240942001342773,
1.1531431674957275,
0.11805057525634766,
0.18190662562847137,
-0.19223956763744354,
0.15231037139892578,
-0.8025204539299011,
-0.21474646031856537,
-0.9390729069709778,
-0.2766707241535187,
0.6640251278877258,
0.8423088788986206,
0.73039311170578,
0.7281930446624756,
0.3417648673057556,
0.3820143938064575,
0.22079156339168549,
-0.1381613314151764,
-0.4754776954650879,
0.5042465925216675,
-0.6295998692512512,
-0.7175605297088623,
-0.15159498155117035,
-0.028272802010178566,
0.3655054271221161,
0.9646396636962891,
0.13595251739025116,
0.3197171092033386,
0.09957971423864365,
0.5646610856056213,
-0.40936070680618286,
0.1636604517698288,
-0.5608184933662415,
-0.2710004150867462,
-0.11616682261228561,
-0.014852586202323437,
-0.12902948260307312,
-0.2422582358121872,
0.02655518800020218,
-0.3909316062927246,
0.4163845479488373,
-0.07140959799289703,
1.025915265083313,
0.17506711184978485,
-0.41805171966552734,
-0.30077964067459106,
-0.9664090275764465,
0.531481146812439,
-0.48638027906417847,
0.3923954665660858,
0.5137068629264832,
0.5203531384468079,
0.0797274187207222,
-0.5771047472953796,
-0.6423771977424622,
-0.33824455738067627,
-0.09682540595531464,
0.0009455716935917735,
-0.0754513069987297,
0.056188710033893585,
0.4048113524913788,
0.395891398191452,
-0.523260772228241,
-0.11122054606676102,
-0.5889191627502441,
-0.22636747360229492,
0.40369072556495667,
0.17564871907234192,
0.3309636414051056,
-0.38168415427207947,
0.08477868139743805,
-0.2271491289138794,
-0.7352628707885742,
0.6356479525566101,
0.4481198489665985,
0.2389104813337326,
0.3231387734413147,
0.32171446084976196,
-0.5060641765594482,
0.8046914339065552,
0.36967822909355164,
0.240750253200531,
-0.2989455461502075,
-0.19698990881443024,
0.09562970697879791,
-0.5173102021217346,
0.42823848128318787,
0.5557057857513428,
0.33519086241722107,
-0.04981080815196037,
-0.3696433901786804,
0.261773943901062,
0.31687062978744507,
-0.6989388465881348,
-0.33205586671829224,
0.42595088481903076,
-0.33448436856269836,
-0.10855057835578918,
-0.04799697548151016,
-0.5834324359893799,
-0.34905126690864563,
-0.3438801169395447,
0.7207530736923218,
-0.040428850799798965,
-0.2325364351272583,
0.12953831255435944,
0.0069107008166611195,
0.11230050772428513,
0.3592803478240967,
-1.3057403564453125,
0.3150748014450073,
0.45539021492004395,
0.19047614932060242,
0.20243316888809204,
-0.3354674279689789,
-0.9365007281303406,
-0.13312026858329773,
-0.5351887941360474,
0.8393940329551697,
-0.4754610061645508,
-0.3831104636192322,
-0.16615915298461914,
0.15919049084186554,
-0.010974406264722347,
-0.8704228401184082,
0.1878807246685028,
-0.4637281596660614,
0.3972352147102356,
-0.9877424240112305,
-0.48048916459083557,
0.02883036620914936,
0.3873479962348938,
-0.4171485900878906,
0.7133891582489014,
0.236197829246521,
-0.1973249912261963,
0.35554561018943787,
-0.5732362270355225,
0.0926596149802208,
0.1946125030517578,
-0.3943791687488556,
0.059858288615942,
0.15716451406478882,
0.5534355044364929,
0.6074753999710083,
-0.4285532832145691,
0.4402764141559601,
-0.023614905774593353,
-0.00861806608736515,
0.26584023237228394,
-0.12184439599514008,
0.2688668966293335,
0.43671920895576477,
-0.4688904583454132,
0.26934078335762024,
-0.2783544361591339,
0.3103477358818054,
0.16394202411174774,
0.05060845986008644,
-0.19047857820987701,
-0.18976826965808868,
-0.22616688907146454,
0.351193904876709,
0.14145003259181976,
-0.5668479800224304,
0.12942928075790405,
-0.591209352016449,
0.11382762342691422,
0.7417178153991699,
0.2084617167711258,
0.367046594619751,
-0.7450339794158936,
0.6038740873336792,
-0.027881160378456116,
0.3947378396987915,
-0.4478374719619751,
-0.3507744073867798,
-1.0983262062072754,
0.6403847932815552,
0.06940881162881851,
0.3363680839538574,
-0.8159276843070984,
-0.1666032373905182,
0.2152903527021408,
-0.6921964883804321,
-0.6800742745399475,
0.3536034822463989,
0.4709152579307556,
0.9263161420822144,
0.2710617780685425,
-0.2988021671772003,
-0.15330183506011963,
-0.9021632075309753,
-0.32427483797073364,
-0.5451006889343262,
0.1330614686012268,
0.4732292890548706,
0.5305198431015015,
0.11420784890651703,
0.9252433776855469,
-0.6632953882217407,
0.19478322565555573,
-0.4421972334384918,
0.05613105744123459,
0.08786097913980484,
0.5896337628364563,
0.2617083489894867,
-0.5677070021629333,
-0.6445898413658142,
-0.24396906793117523,
-0.725037157535553,
-0.29684746265411377,
-0.3029311001300812,
-0.06260940432548523,
-0.25930479168891907,
0.43171054124832153,
-0.41212084889411926,
0.021320296451449394,
0.4282638132572174,
-0.5280324220657349,
0.7422440648078918,
-0.24736976623535156,
0.4766312837600708,
-1.0035972595214844,
0.1238541230559349,
-0.323373019695282,
-0.2644389569759369,
-0.9216518998146057,
0.2233279049396515,
0.02229052223265171,
-0.4208083748817444,
-0.21311894059181213,
0.9345871210098267,
-0.2697215676307678,
0.15736648440361023,
-0.612079381942749,
0.1142423078417778,
-0.09019012004137039,
0.42459070682525635,
0.043255046010017395,
0.8798431754112244,
0.8660882115364075,
-0.9547606110572815,
0.2532115578651428,
0.2888975739479065,
-0.24212372303009033,
0.6571587920188904,
-0.9704288244247437,
0.20340590178966522,
-0.5101839900016785,
-0.20556049048900604,
-0.9901834726333618,
-0.28313109278678894,
0.2750687301158905,
-0.39323073625564575,
-0.046781379729509354,
-0.03546448424458504,
-0.09043069183826447,
-0.3324921429157257,
0.1427105814218521,
0.3101617991924286,
0.5874320268630981,
-0.7169389724731445,
0.10996841639280319,
0.29008200764656067,
-0.48733311891555786,
-0.6494148373603821,
-0.15030087530612946,
-0.13605858385562897,
0.03624492138624191,
-0.7759969234466553,
0.14400245249271393,
-0.4718628525733948,
-0.26585137844085693,
0.2235001176595688,
-0.2083979994058609,
0.0441322922706604,
0.18564990162849426,
0.11960931867361069,
-0.052361615002155304,
-0.18746455013751984,
0.5579695105552673,
-0.03000893071293831,
-0.20746274292469025,
0.2705252766609192,
-0.3199678957462311,
0.6900234818458557,
-0.5055740475654602,
-0.41530054807662964,
-0.27737531065940857,
0.48947593569755554,
0.027908101677894592,
-0.4830544590950012,
0.4093691408634186,
0.42206108570098877,
-0.3163153827190399,
-0.37756285071372986,
-0.7186780571937561,
-0.7725982069969177,
-0.5580971837043762,
0.32612723112106323,
-0.5057456493377686,
-1.171573281288147,
0.6479257345199585,
-0.0257262010127306,
0.0987817719578743,
0.4794677197933197,
0.3208546042442322,
-0.3323919177055359,
1.2030583620071411,
0.8343173265457153,
0.20211827754974365,
0.31456270813941956,
-0.3847784101963043,
0.015251997858285904,
-0.4694122076034546,
-0.264337956905365,
-0.5089305639266968,
-0.13916441798210144,
-0.2297990918159485,
-0.43575456738471985,
0.11940211802721024,
0.38092711567878723,
-0.18970517814159393,
0.435146689414978,
-0.28777948021888733,
0.5237926244735718,
0.628262460231781,
-0.05543731525540352,
0.1110462099313736,
-0.32422906160354614,
-0.05165248364210129,
-0.1358671635389328,
-0.6506153345108032,
-0.701616108417511,
0.8327562808990479,
0.4278096556663513,
0.9498927593231201,
-0.00244930200278759,
0.887546956539154,
0.03470146656036377,
0.349422425031662,
-0.6497315764427185,
0.5566051006317139,
0.34115856885910034,
-0.9236506819725037,
-0.4840426445007324,
-0.5190298557281494,
-1.1161936521530151,
0.0220333281904459,
-0.08219651877880096,
-0.7135910987854004,
0.21279558539390564,
0.6948176026344299,
-0.7175154685974121,
0.15301810204982758,
-0.687794029712677,
1.2892247438430786,
-0.5063508749008179,
-0.5831409096717834,
-0.1505572497844696,
-0.3606584668159485,
0.2262205332517624,
0.028484433889389038,
-0.03724979981780052,
-0.02801451086997986,
0.22458215057849884,
0.6654790043830872,
-0.5313966274261475,
0.7941288352012634,
-0.30643048882484436,
-0.03975401446223259,
0.47791343927383423,
0.37314167618751526,
0.42546015977859497,
0.31872835755348206,
0.09379924833774567,
-0.4772554636001587,
0.0455259308218956,
-0.40916627645492554,
-1.1804643869400024,
0.663970410823822,
-0.6861775517463684,
-1.2906596660614014,
-0.1370771825313568,
-0.4894443154335022,
-0.31199997663497925,
0.15698270499706268,
0.0763237327337265,
0.4070284366607666,
-0.11539463698863983,
-0.16880956292152405,
0.6609139442443848,
-0.38469359278678894,
0.23559007048606873,
0.6146674156188965,
-0.4529269337654114,
-0.12272852659225464,
0.8389798998832703,
0.009097588248550892,
0.5537837743759155,
0.15213896334171295,
0.476088285446167,
-0.4934820830821991,
-0.17332309484481812,
-0.5700321793556213,
0.5309453010559082,
-0.8569169640541077,
-0.026255924254655838,
-0.7543004155158997,
-0.0788816288113594,
-0.5516931414604187,
-0.07442746311426163,
-0.5017218589782715,
-0.27296075224876404,
-0.03610462695360184,
-0.07928506284952164,
0.0771261528134346,
1.0624504089355469,
-0.026995904743671417,
0.5500150918960571,
-0.8184568285942078,
-0.12433195114135742,
0.8190087676048279,
0.3644271790981293,
-0.06630116701126099,
-0.5403982996940613,
-0.1481880396604538,
0.02693966217339039,
-0.4131830036640167,
-1.0834506750106812,
0.2871047556400299,
-0.032804179936647415,
0.7663607001304626,
0.42377984523773193,
-0.033018119633197784,
0.6812512278556824,
-0.3136327862739563,
0.9513647556304932,
0.001644875155761838,
-0.9926482439041138,
0.910631537437439,
-0.5045740008354187,
0.5034469962120056,
0.6685175895690918,
0.4991183280944824,
-1.106184959411621,
-0.4170008897781372,
-0.7447060346603394,
-0.4868926405906677,
0.5676241517066956,
0.08765240013599396,
0.47461146116256714,
-0.2258656919002533,
0.7272877097129822,
0.1647474616765976,
0.2469494789838791,
-0.955569863319397,
-0.3228393793106079,
-0.2980857789516449,
0.0480065681040287,
-0.22198115289211273,
-0.19529326260089874,
0.008785250596702099,
-0.10911686718463898,
0.6898833513259888,
-0.18836863338947296,
0.28267747163772583,
0.23404686152935028,
-0.06626010686159134,
-0.34162604808807373,
0.48053863644599915,
0.42463311553001404,
0.653876781463623,
0.15387268364429474,
0.22519150376319885,
0.20334553718566895,
0.02958873100578785,
0.1809452623128891,
-0.1033501848578453,
-0.23863950371742249,
-0.36371588706970215,
0.11303647607564926,
0.922721803188324,
-0.19909590482711792,
-0.6758419871330261,
0.4275473356246948,
-0.09710693359375,
-0.18471181392669678,
-0.05880548804998398,
0.5857031941413879,
0.13172616064548492,
0.18387486040592194,
-0.02248120866715908,
-0.03822582587599754,
0.09004966914653778,
-0.8023895025253296,
0.460519939661026,
0.29492172598838806,
-0.6979275941848755,
-0.34403693675994873,
0.9466471672058105,
0.23832353949546814,
-0.5399030447006226,
0.4765931963920593,
-0.19235306978225708,
-0.5805977582931519,
0.4498489499092102,
0.6405040621757507,
0.5789647102355957,
-0.5394986271858215,
0.5735750794410706,
0.6922656297683716,
0.27534735202789307,
-0.1459733247756958,
0.6366307139396667,
-0.16428016126155853,
-0.7636880874633789,
-0.25857013463974,
-0.33997026085853577,
-0.45959630608558655,
0.4180116057395935,
-0.3137764036655426,
0.12414126098155975,
-0.42182472348213196,
-0.16289988160133362,
-0.21274903416633606,
-0.037117183208465576,
-0.7306691408157349,
0.5007848739624023,
-0.3414318263530731,
0.5539742112159729,
-0.9292752742767334,
0.4971088767051697,
0.6659327149391174,
-0.8517885208129883,
-1.2140685319900513,
-0.07181351631879807,
-0.21078276634216309,
-0.5619205236434937,
0.8243290781974792,
0.14805108308792114,
0.22486795485019684,
0.17509815096855164,
-0.4118811786174774,
-1.0495315790176392,
0.7589512467384338,
0.32394203543663025,
-0.5052587389945984,
0.12756802141666412,
0.3447035551071167,
0.5097495317459106,
-0.2864280641078949,
0.560945451259613,
0.08879013359546661,
0.33433544635772705,
-0.09787069261074066,
-0.8400737643241882,
0.012378362938761711,
-0.5964160561561584,
-0.21986661851406097,
0.08120410889387131,
-0.4065857529640198,
1.023003339767456,
-0.47861239314079285,
-0.2514980137348175,
-0.032335903495550156,
0.8515604138374329,
-0.06001628190279007,
0.056080520153045654,
0.9637786149978638,
0.07882222533226013,
0.9262460470199585,
-0.17060405015945435,
1.0106455087661743,
-0.4738570749759674,
0.15540409088134766,
1.0593384504318237,
0.04201066866517067,
0.5701025724411011,
0.3059998154640198,
0.500757098197937,
0.5056645274162292,
0.6989830136299133,
0.059002358466386795,
0.2550323009490967,
0.3918551802635193,
-0.19815708696842194,
-0.615108072757721,
-0.1160043478012085,
-0.2991989552974701,
0.4425787925720215,
0.08082866668701172,
-0.2882336974143982,
-0.3984188735485077,
0.19626843929290771,
-0.07458847761154175,
0.5062921047210693,
-0.1800224632024765,
0.5078407526016235,
-0.07072270661592484,
-1.390971064567566,
0.3609813451766968,
0.14007563889026642,
0.2318945974111557,
-0.6810564398765564,
0.015225502662360668,
-0.6113117933273315,
0.1965837925672531,
0.06532035768032074,
-0.633719801902771,
0.18207593262195587,
0.08558215200901031,
-0.23675645887851715,
-0.35493022203445435,
0.6208840608596802,
-0.7996950149536133,
-0.26365506649017334,
0.04531106352806091,
0.8867278695106506,
0.37732410430908203,
-0.09363630414009094,
-0.7675983309745789,
-0.22205296158790588,
-0.1709204912185669,
-0.022530008107423782,
0.07141734659671783,
0.05333655700087547,
-0.2519543170928955,
0.9293190836906433,
0.6088971495628357,
0.11660747230052948,
-0.11673586070537567,
0.363021582365036,
0.7447136640548706,
-0.7402698993682861,
-0.560968816280365,
-0.5529923439025879,
0.845794677734375,
-0.1315947026014328,
-0.5012090802192688,
0.9469391107559204,
0.354573518037796,
1.104801893234253,
-0.3110598027706146,
0.6690356135368347,
-0.09135343134403229,
0.5783292055130005,
-0.3402236998081207,
0.6693644523620605,
-0.6494878530502319,
0.4691697061061859,
-0.31864288449287415,
-0.7138445377349854,
0.23494446277618408,
0.6854096055030823,
-0.4299356937408447,
0.42748790979385376,
0.8446400761604309,
1.3166229724884033,
0.162938192486763,
-0.10562483221292496,
0.5987007021903992,
-0.06843654811382294,
0.5610415935516357,
0.5474625825881958,
1.154647946357727,
-0.3966875672340393,
0.49517032504081726,
-0.5106602311134338,
-0.24710187315940857,
0.3177752196788788,
-0.4126319885253906,
-1.0375627279281616,
-1.0147114992141724,
-0.3716224730014801,
-0.2877935767173767,
0.16779838502407074,
1.1199722290039062,
0.7692561745643616,
-0.7558313012123108,
-0.6406712532043457,
-0.1329616904258728,
0.0592154935002327,
-0.34349966049194336,
-0.1455201953649521,
0.11006886512041092,
-0.9269803166389465,
-0.7680875062942505,
0.41481178998947144,
-0.12608730792999268,
0.010084712877869606,
-0.41881754994392395,
-0.14486566185951233,
0.17666670680046082,
0.05472581461071968,
0.27661803364753723,
0.32136857509613037,
-0.582118570804596,
-0.58359295129776,
0.4580395519733429,
-0.07940913736820221,
-0.2800707519054413,
0.9354252219200134,
-0.5618700385093689,
0.6974494457244873,
0.4401443898677826,
0.77013099193573,
0.4016989469528198,
0.08782291412353516,
0.8470882773399353,
-0.5660256147384644,
-0.5344735980033875,
0.24325403571128845,
0.058599960058927536,
0.30891498923301697,
-0.5277829766273499,
0.15051522850990295,
0.266741544008255,
-0.7766497135162354,
-0.4024721384048462,
0.5965348482131958,
-0.5243240594863892,
-0.2959290146827698,
1.0586847066879272,
0.024646159261465073,
-0.1928040087223053,
-0.1886858493089676,
-0.3614755868911743,
0.10595129430294037,
-0.23497670888900757,
0.9811431169509888,
0.7192696928977966,
-0.22440218925476074,
-0.4322557747364044,
-0.6154627203941345,
0.9693368673324585,
0.9720237851142883,
-1.0022960901260376,
0.1895471215248108,
0.40102818608283997,
0.6235958337783813,
-0.0217207670211792,
0.9992737770080566,
0.09862826764583588,
0.45641881227493286,
-0.15055997669696808,
0.05245387554168701,
-0.11300461739301682,
-0.6081007719039917,
-0.2513185143470764,
0.16855865716934204,
0.49098366498947144,
0.08725543320178986
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19142v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19142v1
|
A Tulu Resource for Machine Translation
| 2024-03-28T04:30:07 | 2024-03-28T04:30:07 |
Manu Narayanan, Noëmi Aepli
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present the first parallel dataset for English-Tulu translation. Tulu,
classified within the South Dravidian linguistic family branch, is
predominantly spoken by approximately 2.5 million individuals in southwestern
India. Our dataset is constructed by integrating human translations into the
multilingual machine translation resource FLORES-200. Furthermore, we use this
dataset for evaluation purposes in developing our English-Tulu machine
translation model. For the model's training, we leverage resources available
for related South Dravidian languages. We adopt a transfer learning approach
that exploits similarities between high-resource and low-resource languages.
This method enables the training of a machine translation system even in the
absence of parallel data between the source and target language, thereby
overcoming a significant obstacle in machine translation development for
low-resource languages. Our English-Tulu system, trained without using parallel
English-Tulu data, outperforms Google Translate by 19 BLEU points (in September
2023). The dataset and code are available here:
https://github.com/manunarayanan/Tulu-NMT.
|
[
-0.011151419952511787,
-0.17476624250411987,
-0.041254159063100815,
0.35399940609931946,
-0.30845868587493896,
0.43793758749961853,
-0.4453590214252472,
-0.3600723147392273,
0.00946823600679636,
0.14713972806930542,
-0.347649484872818,
-0.06568925827741623,
-0.7899978160858154,
0.39117762446403503,
-0.3584083914756775,
0.884885847568512,
-0.1643773466348648,
0.3137681484222412,
0.12950652837753296,
-0.6403005719184875,
-0.5891518592834473,
-0.44934725761413574,
-0.7175475358963013,
-0.22239354252815247,
0.6223567128181458,
0.5928930640220642,
0.5648614168167114,
0.7558030486106873,
0.6336759924888611,
0.20031267404556274,
-0.02306240238249302,
0.4591602683067322,
-0.764752984046936,
0.03652867302298546,
-0.31467416882514954,
-0.6505990028381348,
-0.14752648770809174,
0.06355790793895721,
0.7884366512298584,
0.8530922532081604,
-0.036126647144556046,
0.47039729356765747,
0.21034027636051178,
0.887492835521698,
-0.28909799456596375,
0.36551693081855774,
-0.4969492554664612,
0.12939631938934326,
-0.5705597400665283,
-0.0005688485689461231,
-0.4154563844203949,
-0.47388583421707153,
-0.13093142211437225,
-0.41661927103996277,
0.17618416249752045,
0.26141297817230225,
0.9534643292427063,
0.36503955721855164,
-0.5207819938659668,
-0.028207318857312202,
-0.7265052795410156,
0.9061082005500793,
-0.10031607002019882,
0.3798786997795105,
0.42720136046409607,
0.5942245721817017,
-0.13360150158405304,
-0.6742984056472778,
-0.4692257344722748,
0.004083867650479078,
-0.33262941241264343,
0.07690519839525223,
0.07083760201931,
-0.5577775239944458,
0.06433373689651489,
0.5887844562530518,
-0.656755268573761,
-0.14456707239151,
-1.0035336017608643,
0.06544526666402817,
0.6611647605895996,
0.395510733127594,
0.0897005945444107,
-0.20002955198287964,
-0.29723501205444336,
-0.15837536752223969,
-0.5451955795288086,
0.030920501798391342,
0.12939651310443878,
0.4255847930908203,
-0.5409814119338989,
0.6873239278793335,
0.20863492786884308,
0.7341465353965759,
-0.14757198095321655,
-0.041155654937028885,
0.38044244050979614,
-0.4538881480693817,
-0.3163970708847046,
-0.06847807765007019,
0.9190760850906372,
0.12050606310367584,
0.3491479456424713,
-0.10202713310718536,
-0.07470091432332993,
0.1811550259590149,
0.037067193537950516,
-0.4996195435523987,
0.053032465279102325,
-0.24060963094234467,
-0.48945632576942444,
-0.39894482493400574,
-0.10673138499259949,
-0.8136802315711975,
-0.4940377473831177,
-0.28261125087738037,
-0.17971587181091309,
-0.3705132305622101,
-0.4609644114971161,
-0.19067122042179108,
0.3107234239578247,
0.2566971480846405,
-0.09331982582807541,
-0.6122175455093384,
0.23345257341861725,
0.48624899983406067,
1.0497695207595825,
-0.38107821345329285,
-0.7056084275245667,
-0.5421040058135986,
0.2420709878206253,
-0.28593480587005615,
0.6516954302787781,
-0.6694424748420715,
-0.45595118403434753,
-0.056381382048130035,
0.33038970828056335,
-0.40359070897102356,
-0.41507115960121155,
0.7028664946556091,
-0.24892935156822205,
0.25948983430862427,
-0.3003424406051636,
-0.20395474135875702,
-0.3789765536785126,
-0.1424485743045807,
-0.6164484024047852,
0.8597778677940369,
0.3438309133052826,
-0.6402883529663086,
-0.038571398705244064,
-0.6381118893623352,
-0.9129065871238708,
0.09522803127765656,
-0.41622668504714966,
-0.3202139437198639,
0.1446211189031601,
0.1634119600057602,
0.204472154378891,
-0.8174425363540649,
0.11040353775024414,
-0.024942437186837196,
-0.23802486062049866,
-0.06798887997865677,
-0.2612018883228302,
0.8906089067459106,
0.966450035572052,
-0.014647488482296467,
-0.11330898106098175,
-0.549597978591919,
-0.2629147171974182,
0.3573252260684967,
-0.26900866627693176,
-0.19336780905723572,
-0.5099490284919739,
0.2431357055902481,
0.22822587192058563,
0.3552781641483307,
-0.48489612340927124,
0.4393233060836792,
-0.0197502002120018,
0.5053699612617493,
0.46832120418548584,
-0.33988600969314575,
0.6545668244361877,
-0.2845076322555542,
0.712793231010437,
0.2097339779138565,
-0.004965764936059713,
0.023742206394672394,
-0.6532585024833679,
-0.5376369953155518,
-0.11262203752994537,
0.3807298243045807,
0.7502592206001282,
-0.4400012493133545,
-0.020264893770217896,
-0.4275888204574585,
-0.5416719317436218,
-0.827414870262146,
0.156834214925766,
0.35773807764053345,
0.764766275882721,
0.2393709123134613,
0.03834541514515877,
-0.663611114025116,
-0.8950267434120178,
-0.10745514184236526,
0.06827560812234879,
0.1671558916568756,
0.1650623232126236,
0.11915671080350876,
-0.05086278170347214,
0.23855870962142944,
-0.38356590270996094,
-0.6396622061729431,
-0.36544662714004517,
0.15146228671073914,
0.34684789180755615,
0.46253740787506104,
0.6289553642272949,
-0.887680172920227,
-0.756234884262085,
0.5326610207557678,
-1.0944819450378418,
0.05213885009288788,
-0.061768218874931335,
-0.27377891540527344,
0.28578415513038635,
0.41949111223220825,
-0.4372999370098114,
0.42045438289642334,
0.8420037031173706,
-0.11715982109308243,
0.18796350061893463,
-0.34774065017700195,
0.4940621256828308,
-1.5542336702346802,
0.4371577799320221,
-0.17723014950752258,
-0.27409905195236206,
-0.29285839200019836,
0.007065117359161377,
0.1447293758392334,
-0.5437357425689697,
-0.4636988937854767,
0.30092015862464905,
-0.4791316092014313,
-0.12692071497440338,
-0.1287042647600174,
-0.14799290895462036,
0.039346273988485336,
0.4512614905834198,
-0.22498132288455963,
1.2950658798217773,
0.5167875289916992,
-0.34609174728393555,
0.4964805245399475,
0.5430983901023865,
-0.13682647049427032,
0.5366589426994324,
-0.5565852522850037,
0.27730390429496765,
-0.13756851851940155,
-0.07714831084012985,
-0.6423125863075256,
-0.1735377013683319,
0.4782077968120575,
-0.45129212737083435,
0.3683680593967438,
-0.31732067465782166,
-0.1314261257648468,
-0.36075302958488464,
0.08628803491592407,
0.5222712159156799,
0.519698441028595,
-0.2615230977535248,
0.3868475556373596,
0.6677767634391785,
-0.2983677387237549,
-0.6865372061729431,
-1.0505337715148926,
0.114446721971035,
-0.1672791987657547,
-0.5008907318115234,
0.12202034145593643,
0.2527129352092743,
0.07943923026323318,
0.16714011132717133,
0.09271659702062607,
-0.25842031836509705,
-0.28417882323265076,
0.2609587013721466,
0.3200565278530121,
-0.15267150104045868,
-0.04637320712208748,
-0.03864845633506775,
-0.1011110469698906,
-0.24205447733402252,
-0.42766204476356506,
0.561192512512207,
-0.48778650164604187,
0.07641088217496872,
-0.3513789176940918,
0.40611815452575684,
0.8504152894020081,
-0.5563601851463318,
0.9110531806945801,
0.5632843971252441,
-0.6994176506996155,
0.36840948462486267,
-0.23136349022388458,
0.23377297818660736,
-0.30501797795295715,
0.33905884623527527,
-0.8873726725578308,
-0.40042877197265625,
0.6064535975456238,
-0.024065395817160606,
0.18059872090816498,
0.469467431306839,
0.6689155697822571,
-0.20121286809444427,
0.7813165187835693,
0.6680492758750916,
-0.5134300589561462,
0.2320350706577301,
-0.5614418387413025,
0.23539482057094574,
-0.6590359210968018,
-0.4474063813686371,
-0.6297340393066406,
-0.44832944869995117,
-0.6630048751831055,
-0.21130001544952393,
0.10337755084037781,
0.11409300565719604,
0.03547242283821106,
0.8748272657394409,
-0.47873449325561523,
0.23398840427398682,
0.47772714495658875,
0.10967867076396942,
0.34999769926071167,
0.4740382134914398,
-0.22816859185695648,
-0.18032799661159515,
-0.6651456356048584,
-0.3786999583244324,
1.163480281829834,
0.1276402771472931,
0.7378146648406982,
0.06257946044206619,
0.3887646496295929,
0.46277114748954773,
0.15670746564865112,
-0.455314576625824,
0.25456634163856506,
-0.5280272364616394,
-0.2832961082458496,
-0.266956627368927,
-0.5340502262115479,
-1.195883870124817,
0.026966920122504234,
-0.10687141865491867,
-0.1072550117969513,
0.13914626836776733,
-0.151145800948143,
-0.1947907954454422,
0.42825189232826233,
-0.9638252258300781,
0.8230382204055786,
-0.3606729209423065,
-0.39856696128845215,
-0.6589317917823792,
-0.6008911728858948,
0.22086846828460693,
-0.24871310591697693,
0.2321711778640747,
-0.14589934051036835,
0.10818175226449966,
0.6294318437576294,
-0.21163155138492584,
0.19803601503372192,
-0.05106683447957039,
0.336128830909729,
0.07432401180267334,
0.10374078899621964,
0.4414965808391571,
0.12278149276971817,
-0.22837349772453308,
0.3200116753578186,
-0.11400024592876434,
-0.8592919111251831,
-0.2826712131500244,
0.8992360234260559,
-1.0097019672393799,
-0.21383258700370789,
-0.6532340049743652,
-0.9438597559928894,
0.05221976339817047,
0.29879316687583923,
0.32371392846107483,
0.03475075960159302,
0.28661876916885376,
0.10766289383172989,
0.2390720248222351,
-0.12631243467330933,
0.20453983545303345,
0.23538032174110413,
-0.25180575251579285,
-0.3639911711215973,
1.0273704528808594,
0.012006836012005806,
-0.10434325784444809,
0.07936332374811172,
0.30224525928497314,
-0.3380362093448639,
-0.3575405478477478,
-0.7583689093589783,
0.4882689416408539,
-0.38819241523742676,
-0.25848764181137085,
-0.44770875573158264,
-0.36419034004211426,
-0.5539411306381226,
0.1401974856853485,
-0.45904430747032166,
-0.30173617601394653,
-0.028236934915184975,
0.044534098356962204,
0.40892890095710754,
1.0239810943603516,
0.03307855874300003,
0.12112057954072952,
-0.8910998106002808,
0.418451726436615,
0.03266260027885437,
0.23150990903377533,
-0.35585319995880127,
-0.8432483077049255,
-0.35105863213539124,
0.09289313107728958,
0.030424781143665314,
-0.8086622357368469,
0.5288481712341309,
0.33508679270744324,
0.5103759169578552,
-0.039839550852775574,
-0.03213588520884514,
0.6994442939758301,
-0.5489271283149719,
0.4226658344268799,
0.2547209560871124,
-0.2962650656700134,
0.4694325923919678,
-0.10858726501464844,
0.16499173641204834,
0.6997513175010681,
0.630950391292572,
-0.7483555674552917,
-0.1121644377708435,
-0.2086581438779831,
-0.29562124609947205,
0.6481039524078369,
0.26388785243034363,
-0.10178413987159729,
0.34966593980789185,
0.26670965552330017,
0.3967738747596741,
0.1118861511349678,
-0.30583301186561584,
-0.5550627112388611,
-0.17367929220199585,
-0.32154327630996704,
-0.06364014744758606,
-0.062380604445934296,
0.030048204585909843,
-0.4146299660205841,
0.5570341348648071,
0.22981159389019012,
0.002313050674274564,
-0.02111263945698738,
-0.455453097820282,
-0.3317708671092987,
-0.05573778226971626,
0.5868523120880127,
0.7077621221542358,
-0.13779455423355103,
-0.11050625145435333,
0.13719592988491058,
-0.85495924949646,
0.2620842158794403,
0.4184550344944,
-0.33865660429000854,
0.017397351562976837,
-0.20897696912288666,
0.8313010334968567,
-0.21743351221084595,
-0.1824594885110855,
0.16750827431678772,
-0.2599726617336273,
0.12824998795986176,
-0.4256761968135834,
-0.4256979525089264,
0.09261507540941238,
0.06812131404876709,
0.4979122281074524,
0.4294483959674835,
-0.13830789923667908,
-0.24603766202926636,
0.22843793034553528,
-0.14289817214012146,
-0.3570275902748108,
-0.2763921022415161,
0.9075048565864563,
0.47323063015937805,
-0.395654559135437,
0.7401847839355469,
-0.27284204959869385,
-0.32502204179763794,
0.3135223984718323,
0.34677085280418396,
0.7414334416389465,
-0.2894424796104431,
-0.0032088798470795155,
0.6386911869049072,
0.32431864738464355,
0.023755043745040894,
0.22159409523010254,
0.3973999619483948,
-0.2272607833147049,
-0.4221127927303314,
-0.6901928782463074,
-0.3382627069950104,
0.4518876075744629,
-0.6306322813034058,
0.8034095764160156,
-0.08988926559686661,
0.02711954154074192,
-0.11998359858989716,
0.12500393390655518,
-0.9257997274398804,
-0.16576224565505981,
0.2075657695531845,
0.8889862895011902,
-1.0855562686920166,
1.2732985019683838,
1.199630856513977,
-0.759949803352356,
-0.5928994417190552,
-0.3596797287464142,
-0.2759338319301605,
-0.8686689138412476,
0.5945448279380798,
0.054638706147670746,
-0.11570841819047928,
0.1678716391324997,
-0.15506237745285034,
-0.6428562998771667,
0.935276210308075,
0.6782162189483643,
-0.7667587995529175,
-0.04579482972621918,
0.5796535015106201,
0.3861886262893677,
-0.3628307580947876,
-0.03279057890176773,
0.6085219979286194,
0.41207611560821533,
-0.16587017476558685,
-0.9659970998764038,
-0.16750138998031616,
-0.2969098389148712,
-0.034912724047899246,
0.08594566583633423,
-0.726548433303833,
0.6530184149742126,
-0.3060612976551056,
-0.33417564630508423,
0.051327645778656006,
0.9296252131462097,
0.1466977447271347,
0.11905712634325027,
0.3991258442401886,
0.5078447461128235,
0.8057951927185059,
-0.009559165686368942,
0.9418643116950989,
-0.5699673891067505,
0.41676613688468933,
1.1599152088165283,
-0.13877590000629425,
0.5828120708465576,
0.6676449775695801,
-0.32697588205337524,
-0.010836727917194366,
0.4955832064151764,
0.020145554095506668,
0.5833086967468262,
0.0620514340698719,
-0.3372812867164612,
0.03724097087979317,
-0.5557048320770264,
-0.6825413703918457,
0.42716658115386963,
0.426196426153183,
-0.3322766125202179,
-0.2658662796020508,
0.2341848462820053,
0.07312541455030441,
0.5438986420631409,
-0.18408389389514923,
0.2741601765155792,
0.23005369305610657,
-0.6326936483383179,
0.898246169090271,
-0.07817571610212326,
0.5199551582336426,
-0.4833131432533264,
-0.10092794895172119,
-0.7141857743263245,
0.2715647518634796,
-0.15705566108226776,
-0.8999084830284119,
0.618340015411377,
0.1277361512184143,
-0.09316417574882507,
-0.12086322903633118,
0.5055354237556458,
-0.7142380475997925,
-0.6955358386039734,
0.1654902994632721,
0.5153194665908813,
0.5096848011016846,
0.17230479419231415,
-0.7554711699485779,
-0.06995829939842224,
0.03247186169028282,
0.060657989233732224,
0.2431061863899231,
0.27913397550582886,
-0.3738526999950409,
0.6113865971565247,
0.536125123500824,
0.3168962895870209,
0.3929957449436188,
0.1542840301990509,
0.5437414050102234,
-0.5029305815696716,
-0.357999712228775,
-0.4797874093055725,
0.04933791980147362,
-0.0997849777340889,
-0.31716346740722656,
0.5051558017730713,
0.8601029515266418,
1.0032188892364502,
-0.290676474571228,
1.0649257898330688,
-0.3721945881843567,
0.4836415648460388,
0.045729923993349075,
0.9290060997009277,
-0.41402536630630493,
-0.1483725756406784,
0.4060312509536743,
-0.9151082038879395,
-0.09402985125780106,
0.4897920787334442,
0.0008367183618247509,
-0.588352382183075,
0.8993712663650513,
0.6101195812225342,
-0.2550395131111145,
0.014471657574176788,
0.46700212359428406,
0.06016567349433899,
0.07671962678432465,
0.8682535290718079,
0.5290667414665222,
-0.8764445781707764,
1.2014886140823364,
-0.5382360816001892,
-0.2801505923271179,
-0.004027307964861393,
-0.6526471376419067,
-0.6932572722434998,
-0.7071310877799988,
-0.12399785220623016,
-0.4468672573566437,
0.16043999791145325,
0.8886069655418396,
0.40020331740379333,
-1.2085421085357666,
-0.5162243247032166,
-0.003917166031897068,
-0.0027215390000492334,
-0.37696006894111633,
-0.10707701742649078,
0.4242812991142273,
-0.4433864653110504,
-1.0609841346740723,
0.5101521611213684,
0.19423460960388184,
-0.1203395426273346,
-0.2136632353067398,
-0.3851509094238281,
-0.5231369137763977,
-0.6075581312179565,
0.39566558599472046,
0.6075175404548645,
-0.40328386425971985,
-0.11485178768634796,
0.2868354618549347,
-0.6426717638969421,
0.2540314495563507,
0.7135760188102722,
-0.5664511322975159,
0.3563285768032074,
0.6730939149856567,
1.0499341487884521,
0.5903675556182861,
-0.26927193999290466,
0.7217841744422913,
-0.5218729376792908,
0.7086259722709656,
-0.15165792405605316,
0.5105428099632263,
0.4301856756210327,
-0.36674460768699646,
0.9757055640220642,
0.522412121295929,
-0.36594557762145996,
-0.7485684752464294,
0.18138550221920013,
-0.9339297413825989,
0.2910248637199402,
1.0458954572677612,
-0.39642980694770813,
-0.26216965913772583,
-0.17283223569393158,
-0.3274540901184082,
0.7986534237861633,
-0.27339810132980347,
0.6622858643531799,
0.5403915047645569,
0.21116945147514343,
-0.16956795752048492,
-0.6551774740219116,
0.29567158222198486,
0.4501955807209015,
-0.524574875831604,
0.07147008925676346,
0.08007730543613434,
0.11727342754602432,
0.08344237506389618,
0.21869276463985443,
-0.47006499767303467,
0.332624226808548,
-0.16596315801143646,
0.0827953889966011,
-0.3608402609825134,
-0.22456489503383636,
-0.4033709466457367,
-0.09591272473335266,
-0.0762925073504448,
-0.7425124049186707
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19135v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19135v3
|
Streamlining Redundant Layers to Compress Large Language Models
| 2024-03-28T04:12:13 | 2024-05-23T02:29:26 |
Xiaodong Chen, Yuxuan Hu, Jing Zhang, Yanling Wang, Cuiping Li, Hong Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
This paper introduces LLM-Streamline, a novel layer pruning approach for
large language models. It is based on the observation that different layers
have varying impacts on hidden states, enabling the identification of less
important layers. LLMStreamline comprises two parts: layer pruning, which
removes consecutive layers with the lowest importance based on target sparsity,
and layer replacement, where a lightweight network is trained to replace the
pruned layers to mitigate performance loss. Additionally, a new metric called
"stability" is proposed to address the limitations of accuracy in evaluating
model compression. Experiments show that LLM-Streamline surpasses previous
state-of-the-art pruning methods in both accuracy and stability.
|
[
-0.4001302719116211,
-0.9092065095901489,
0.33722007274627686,
0.1323849856853485,
-0.25556477904319763,
0.2089100331068039,
-0.3061770796775818,
-0.4018656313419342,
0.1975390911102295,
0.5979670882225037,
-0.7910997271537781,
-0.2888757586479187,
-0.547735869884491,
-0.16751977801322937,
-0.7746466994285583,
0.701435923576355,
-0.011974873952567577,
-0.08352933824062347,
-0.1651628464460373,
0.1497550904750824,
-0.34073489904403687,
-0.3743327260017395,
-0.7321645021438599,
-0.5180633664131165,
0.6208170652389526,
0.3597145974636078,
0.7956163883209229,
0.8781901597976685,
0.38230985403060913,
0.4089697301387787,
-0.4978230595588684,
0.24789981544017792,
-0.7847824096679688,
0.3374764621257782,
0.2610544264316559,
-0.408083975315094,
-0.4134708344936371,
-0.3118494153022766,
0.9383740425109863,
0.8888427019119263,
-0.27638912200927734,
0.2703953981399536,
0.3779386878013611,
0.6944998502731323,
-0.6394068598747253,
-0.0037703290581703186,
-0.5325201153755188,
-0.079069122672081,
-0.1745748370885849,
-0.34122252464294434,
-0.44328850507736206,
-0.3548060357570648,
-0.11426762491464615,
-0.09090503305196762,
0.222091943025589,
-0.3445096015930176,
1.077390432357788,
0.3097264766693115,
-0.26030397415161133,
0.3098929524421692,
-1.0244299173355103,
0.7952394485473633,
-0.8410624265670776,
0.22939236462116241,
0.16351057589054108,
0.2861289381980896,
-0.049814727157354355,
-0.6628425121307373,
-0.10387015342712402,
-0.045080967247486115,
0.10858937352895737,
0.04691757634282112,
0.03692615032196045,
0.10311119258403778,
0.08363435417413712,
0.4338873028755188,
-0.17496976256370544,
0.362790048122406,
-0.7670353055000305,
-0.13133278489112854,
0.6849774122238159,
0.03401407226920128,
0.2987710237503052,
0.14815488457679749,
-0.5120307207107544,
0.040326833724975586,
-0.9548929333686829,
0.13677482306957245,
0.6082782745361328,
0.2759947180747986,
0.27400413155555725,
0.4687558114528656,
-0.3282027244567871,
0.6474172472953796,
-0.35611292719841003,
-0.5199002027511597,
0.19075262546539307,
0.14941631257534027,
-0.33299073576927185,
0.16582204401493073,
0.47343698143959045,
0.30768150091171265,
0.09034933149814606,
-0.1027471050620079,
-0.47757625579833984,
0.05243130773305893,
0.11235153675079346,
-0.6939319372177124,
-0.1886657476425171,
0.41668468713760376,
-0.4927505850791931,
-0.474667489528656,
-0.13578404486179352,
-0.2719510495662689,
-0.2544536590576172,
-0.4800192713737488,
0.1900242120027542,
-0.3553456664085388,
-0.3898516297340393,
0.11250908672809601,
0.01127091608941555,
0.2238902747631073,
0.5514695048332214,
-0.536379337310791,
0.6963151097297668,
1.1206939220428467,
0.9253891706466675,
0.037324823439121246,
-0.5072146654129028,
-0.5068743228912354,
0.22367915511131287,
-0.16996297240257263,
0.6417476534843445,
-0.48701635003089905,
0.03191012889146805,
-0.018650321289896965,
0.02825590968132019,
0.2609599232673645,
-0.6375979781150818,
0.9899879693984985,
-0.36171525716781616,
-0.08807270228862762,
-0.05349157005548477,
-0.6122863292694092,
-0.4298916459083557,
0.13776682317256927,
-0.8622560501098633,
0.9906649589538574,
-0.11005081236362457,
-0.6292187571525574,
-0.06967649608850479,
0.15321514010429382,
-0.4116819500923157,
0.2610202729701996,
0.10022584348917007,
-0.5211991667747498,
0.3875090479850769,
0.21890461444854736,
0.503436803817749,
-0.3571231961250305,
0.4387131631374359,
-0.47938066720962524,
-0.6269536018371582,
-0.1317642629146576,
-0.4113162159919739,
0.8666526675224304,
0.2955445647239685,
0.07337449491024017,
0.02437007799744606,
-0.7999850511550903,
0.28637245297431946,
0.07090412080287933,
-0.6376628875732422,
-0.051161039620637894,
0.2815493643283844,
0.0675252228975296,
0.3283165395259857,
0.2294112741947174,
-0.524574875831604,
0.21125082671642303,
-0.39789968729019165,
0.8823345303535461,
0.8160979151725769,
-0.12465178966522217,
0.2924601435661316,
-0.5179886817932129,
0.5352036952972412,
-0.013634653761982918,
0.1831475794315338,
-0.11612500995397568,
-0.19916418194770813,
-1.0398528575897217,
-0.33810943365097046,
0.3652191758155823,
0.6596503257751465,
-0.5729751586914062,
0.5281092524528503,
-0.5337107181549072,
-0.5257768034934998,
-0.5387336015701294,
0.41873377561569214,
0.3238224387168884,
0.2534298896789551,
0.2554284930229187,
-0.1870177686214447,
-0.6481423377990723,
-1.1511421203613281,
-0.17035463452339172,
-0.02524317428469658,
-0.010417873039841652,
0.019210973754525185,
0.1609809398651123,
0.0736229345202446,
0.771994948387146,
-0.3291275203227997,
-0.20073775947093964,
-0.4519101083278656,
-0.12040090560913086,
0.09069487452507019,
0.6239022016525269,
-0.07585422694683075,
-0.516203761100769,
-0.2065398246049881,
-0.07814205437898636,
-0.42420268058776855,
-0.25990965962409973,
0.05254577472805977,
0.18256817758083344,
-0.05096698924899101,
0.48243817687034607,
-0.5637780427932739,
0.07522112876176834,
0.9150989651679993,
0.06144831329584122,
0.3748912811279297,
0.009244884364306927,
-0.3610878586769104,
-0.7280741930007935,
-0.1670595407485962,
0.1446566879749298,
-0.498460590839386,
-0.8379009366035461,
0.18620112538337708,
0.0919095128774643,
-0.327476441860199,
-0.6676054000854492,
0.36517098546028137,
-0.89649498462677,
-0.07111074030399323,
-0.23599639534950256,
0.036362212151288986,
0.10757644474506378,
0.4548102021217346,
-0.066745325922966,
0.24681203067302704,
0.5549502968788147,
-0.39828652143478394,
0.42525428533554077,
-0.16779473423957825,
-0.49530449509620667,
-0.12093468755483627,
-0.6225892305374146,
0.24460092186927795,
-0.24501526355743408,
0.34049472212791443,
-0.8448759913444519,
0.13398334383964539,
-0.0530562587082386,
0.0015006959438323975,
0.4570610523223877,
-0.5243607759475708,
-0.47818732261657715,
-0.42323023080825806,
-0.34369799494743347,
0.4108561873435974,
0.6009776592254639,
-0.3192252218723297,
0.48572319746017456,
0.5476491451263428,
-0.3184790015220642,
-0.6836155652999878,
-0.8509818315505981,
0.18190141022205353,
-0.3216298818588257,
-0.831091582775116,
0.33321699500083923,
0.038836073130369186,
-0.04389607161283493,
-0.014168004505336285,
-0.27336373925209045,
-0.32194486260414124,
0.40892648696899414,
0.3384641408920288,
0.2735833525657654,
-0.24212896823883057,
-0.14110739529132843,
-0.022236190736293793,
0.03820297122001648,
0.04106835648417473,
-0.20301449298858643,
0.7682247161865234,
-0.05630828067660332,
-0.14272896945476532,
-0.4974293112754822,
0.42499297857284546,
0.3690437376499176,
-0.26891016960144043,
0.6361493468284607,
0.5118547677993774,
-0.25115281343460083,
-0.6212198138237,
-0.7618459463119507,
-0.07165026664733887,
-0.566398024559021,
0.32340651750564575,
-0.3748411536216736,
-1.233431100845337,
0.6855539679527283,
-0.2909725308418274,
-0.030040491372346878,
0.12983176112174988,
0.28175973892211914,
0.06381288915872574,
0.8958336114883423,
0.6788614988327026,
-0.056081224232912064,
0.35284239053726196,
-0.3313862979412079,
0.2338821440935135,
-0.7874667048454285,
-0.03548151254653931,
-0.5987244844436646,
-0.5971595048904419,
-0.3126926124095917,
-0.4069565236568451,
-0.114265576004982,
0.6240288019180298,
-0.014186324551701546,
0.35125732421875,
-0.5461769104003906,
0.8212264776229858,
0.36059480905532837,
0.17071786522865295,
0.13660494983196259,
-0.010129682719707489,
0.07504361122846603,
0.33063724637031555,
-0.7023800611495972,
-0.5221666097640991,
0.5521326661109924,
0.7251805663108826,
0.7083545923233032,
0.27882128953933716,
0.8876551389694214,
-0.06445781886577606,
0.08267738670110703,
-0.901474118232727,
0.8305236101150513,
-0.1647210568189621,
-0.4377419948577881,
-0.51433926820755,
-0.6166114807128906,
-0.7262471914291382,
0.31347760558128357,
-0.1620481312274933,
-0.7901884317398071,
-0.0021544783376157284,
0.09253749996423721,
-0.33055612444877625,
0.47073277831077576,
-0.8776643872261047,
0.4163331389427185,
-0.13630931079387665,
-0.3858691453933716,
0.06426848471164703,
-0.4019617438316345,
0.6744312047958374,
0.10539362579584122,
0.1481660008430481,
-0.3345014452934265,
-0.29367420077323914,
0.720783531665802,
-0.6835308074951172,
0.9189461469650269,
-0.05571150779724121,
-0.1769278347492218,
0.32764655351638794,
0.3074546754360199,
0.7657040357589722,
-0.30521997809410095,
0.06010358780622482,
0.15933312475681305,
-0.04297545552253723,
-0.5191845893859863,
-0.5096230506896973,
1.0314967632293701,
-0.7531973123550415,
-0.7177425622940063,
0.14171841740608215,
-0.41184085607528687,
-0.17672322690486908,
0.1861894428730011,
-0.10555535554885864,
0.5988744497299194,
0.06905295699834824,
0.3128196597099304,
0.38702160120010376,
-0.15510758757591248,
0.7052215337753296,
0.23417982459068298,
-0.2170487344264984,
-0.34005206823349,
0.8329890370368958,
0.4145950675010681,
0.27321067452430725,
0.4619275629520416,
0.1982143223285675,
-0.03214597702026367,
-0.8794228434562683,
0.08884789049625397,
0.3176984190940857,
-0.9240934252738953,
-0.2604371905326843,
-0.5730483531951904,
-0.7644545435905457,
-0.2951795160770416,
0.0429694727063179,
-0.5471636056900024,
-0.6387047171592712,
-0.009345951490104198,
-0.22566664218902588,
-0.1509391963481903,
0.804402232170105,
0.3975274860858917,
0.35778796672821045,
-0.9359295964241028,
-0.14899244904518127,
0.16233977675437927,
0.4020106792449951,
0.058160893619060516,
-0.3576311767101288,
-0.24671654403209686,
-0.3765796422958374,
-0.2223978042602539,
-0.659917414188385,
0.635400116443634,
0.2950652241706848,
0.5836001634597778,
0.2625144124031067,
0.0019521549111232162,
0.7427550554275513,
-0.7039427161216736,
0.7325278520584106,
0.3315064311027527,
-1.0314539670944214,
0.3981483280658722,
-0.2769976258277893,
0.5637282133102417,
0.3055776059627533,
0.21539166569709778,
-0.40052786469459534,
-0.5418321490287781,
-0.6778255701065063,
-1.0753532648086548,
0.49590373039245605,
0.06443009525537491,
0.0594610758125782,
0.28258687257766724,
0.3391727805137634,
-0.09053947031497955,
0.20943911373615265,
-0.8177820444107056,
-0.37428075075149536,
0.18522842228412628,
-0.06529024988412857,
-0.05649469047784805,
-0.6996604204177856,
-0.25589999556541443,
-0.18520915508270264,
0.5877344012260437,
0.05840976908802986,
0.10866345465183258,
0.0653746947646141,
-0.17355671525001526,
-0.16670182347297668,
0.2716131806373596,
0.7028398513793945,
0.9406145215034485,
-0.2932617962360382,
0.44091206789016724,
0.07785417884588242,
-0.39613595604896545,
0.27332180738449097,
-0.21251657605171204,
-0.38367703557014465,
-0.08519922941923141,
0.6103045344352722,
0.842186450958252,
0.20885691046714783,
-0.3617267608642578,
0.3700782358646393,
0.08183519542217255,
-0.4691285192966461,
-0.33520883321762085,
0.10699347406625748,
0.1932065635919571,
0.14613953232765198,
0.25558143854141235,
0.31622618436813354,
-0.05066149681806564,
-0.36682945489883423,
0.2483338862657547,
0.2924332022666931,
-0.4914896488189697,
-0.3276377022266388,
0.3321716785430908,
0.3519456684589386,
-0.37865743041038513,
0.4967878460884094,
0.34130188822746277,
-0.5623790621757507,
0.4702160358428955,
0.32905203104019165,
0.9413325190544128,
-0.22363261878490448,
0.15731751918792725,
0.27495259046554565,
0.5608232021331787,
-0.41363343596458435,
0.001392219914123416,
0.019396187737584114,
-0.6976233720779419,
-0.9772976636886597,
-0.5615073442459106,
0.06383232027292252,
0.46593552827835083,
-0.5332801342010498,
0.5800880193710327,
-0.7008416056632996,
-0.10189951956272125,
-0.01932263746857643,
0.1370815932750702,
-0.361410915851593,
0.06802545487880707,
0.4748379588127136,
1.1212600469589233,
-0.9869154095649719,
1.3579752445220947,
0.34101977944374084,
-0.23524980247020721,
-1.1235424280166626,
-0.22005899250507355,
0.17010661959648132,
-0.661247193813324,
0.7267743349075317,
0.13844534754753113,
-0.2792208790779114,
0.015526438131928444,
-0.47642141580581665,
-1.1733468770980835,
1.2480089664459229,
0.6415970921516418,
-0.7720268964767456,
-0.1815013289451599,
-0.14718449115753174,
0.25047823786735535,
-0.31821176409721375,
0.2340649664402008,
0.30622512102127075,
0.26922309398651123,
0.3078557252883911,
-0.9429759979248047,
0.09167642891407013,
-0.32690221071243286,
0.2390487641096115,
0.42791661620140076,
-0.8129233121871948,
1.1303961277008057,
0.205935999751091,
-0.5365578532218933,
-0.05930906534194946,
0.42434248328208923,
-0.02033855952322483,
-0.17843089997768402,
0.7257269620895386,
0.8343576192855835,
0.6651390194892883,
-0.05867614224553108,
0.8241320848464966,
-0.31796497106552124,
0.5366173386573792,
1.2505056858062744,
-0.27762630581855774,
1.1807252168655396,
0.48073500394821167,
-0.08631528913974762,
0.3041640520095825,
0.4357439875602722,
0.07377202808856964,
0.3327673077583313,
0.3017224669456482,
-0.10271115601062775,
-0.39791780710220337,
0.07091715186834335,
-0.1853022575378418,
0.2913621962070465,
0.05933474376797676,
-0.2275153398513794,
-0.2645323872566223,
-0.3686402440071106,
0.24523548781871796,
-0.21146182715892792,
-0.4217916429042816,
0.45153045654296875,
0.19021080434322357,
-0.646295428276062,
0.9836052060127258,
0.07564596831798553,
0.5109049081802368,
-0.6243200302124023,
0.17404457926750183,
-0.18620413541793823,
0.38860446214675903,
-0.3998965620994568,
-0.7159825563430786,
0.24502483010292053,
-0.2974885106086731,
-0.052440185099840164,
-0.48571276664733887,
0.9827828407287598,
-0.46908894181251526,
-0.5946910977363586,
0.5396613478660583,
0.4413931965827942,
0.039377033710479736,
0.11813591420650482,
-0.7977384328842163,
0.5830879807472229,
0.1121811717748642,
-0.440387099981308,
0.3543647527694702,
0.39198383688926697,
0.04515095800161362,
1.1212762594223022,
0.5965245366096497,
0.5739225149154663,
0.3382261395454407,
0.19511958956718445,
1.1098158359527588,
-0.6495741605758667,
-0.4152364730834961,
-0.7928727865219116,
0.6416035890579224,
-0.24763770401477814,
-0.0011363029479980469,
0.7414103746414185,
0.6034167408943176,
0.7554644346237183,
0.20227837562561035,
0.5044038891792297,
0.2742113769054413,
0.6040127873420715,
-0.654305636882782,
0.5064861178398132,
-0.5554675459861755,
0.8157410621643066,
-0.09406128525733948,
-1.0762701034545898,
-0.38644713163375854,
0.2620140016078949,
-0.07899393141269684,
0.00044766682549379766,
0.8585128784179688,
0.8750608563423157,
-0.1064857617020607,
-0.1880749762058258,
0.5160056352615356,
0.3545745611190796,
0.2293531894683838,
0.4703908860683441,
1.0213346481323242,
-0.3862781226634979,
0.6528728008270264,
-0.7174597382545471,
-0.058403708040714264,
0.011722375638782978,
-1.0067936182022095,
-0.7154901027679443,
-0.49217796325683594,
-0.5963703393936157,
-0.3083743155002594,
-0.12253940105438232,
0.5581005811691284,
1.0058577060699463,
-0.6014175415039062,
-0.6274030804634094,
0.07570317387580872,
-0.0916827991604805,
-0.4227333664894104,
-0.1904136836528778,
0.20728382468223572,
-0.1307372748851776,
-0.4944486618041992,
0.5646434426307678,
0.3720051348209381,
-0.17778810858726501,
-0.6249529123306274,
-0.06046469137072563,
-0.33512112498283386,
-0.018717419356107712,
0.4321272373199463,
0.12444540113210678,
-0.9833452105522156,
-0.27524614334106445,
-0.5370462536811829,
0.03331441432237625,
-0.009890757501125336,
0.97352534532547,
-0.6706653833389282,
-0.1403011679649353,
0.713420033454895,
0.5671188235282898,
0.6094370484352112,
0.1829851120710373,
0.5546859502792358,
-1.1310889720916748,
0.48018693923950195,
0.3603033423423767,
0.518333911895752,
0.4193453788757324,
-0.18491917848587036,
0.3544011116027832,
0.06579305231571198,
-0.6569724082946777,
-0.9536319971084595,
0.3786928653717041,
-1.2031999826431274,
-0.4930970072746277,
1.3263604640960693,
-0.2544079124927521,
-0.7484075427055359,
0.14040663838386536,
-0.07280735671520233,
-0.06921958923339844,
-0.32103198766708374,
0.34747692942619324,
0.7460123300552368,
0.19916124641895294,
-0.9665042757987976,
-0.6658098101615906,
0.42340344190597534,
0.31756800413131714,
-0.4002305865287781,
0.196981281042099,
0.5533486604690552,
0.27783963084220886,
0.16058878600597382,
0.41056156158447266,
0.10895533859729767,
-0.2927355170249939,
-0.1586281806230545,
-0.016066614538431168,
-0.30923858284950256,
-0.3752903342247009,
-0.5616836547851562,
0.6367617845535278,
0.23646478354930878,
0.04104120656847954
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19121v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19121v2
|
Code Comparison Tuning for Code Large Language Models
| 2024-03-28T03:25:23 | 2024-06-05T04:00:08 |
Yufan Jiang, Qiaozhi He, Xiaomin Zhuang, Zhihua Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present Code Comparison Tuning (CCT), a simple and effective tuning method
for code large language models (Code LLMs) to better handle subtle code errors.
Specifically, we integrate the concept of comparison into instruction tuning,
both at the token and sequence levels, enabling the model to discern even the
slightest deviations in code. To compare the original code with an erroneous
version containing manually added code errors, we use token-level preference
loss for detailed token-level comparisons. Additionally, we combine code
segments to create a new instruction tuning sample for sequence-level
comparisons, enhancing the model's bug-fixing capability. Experimental results
on the HumanEvalFix benchmark show that CCT surpasses instruction tuning in
pass@1 scores by up to 4 points across diverse code LLMs, and extensive
analysis demonstrates the effectiveness of our method.
|
[
-0.19985613226890564,
-0.5673507452011108,
0.32171186804771423,
0.3667735159397125,
-0.4274139106273651,
0.2521210014820099,
-0.4174646735191345,
-0.3472369909286499,
-0.08654983341693878,
0.5413158535957336,
-0.4185066521167755,
-0.7884241938591003,
-0.285561203956604,
0.11797881871461868,
-0.3350274860858917,
0.9231343865394592,
0.08866941928863525,
0.27295148372650146,
-0.024851778522133827,
-0.15888313949108124,
-0.7077204585075378,
-0.4365522861480713,
-1.0499473810195923,
-0.03338195011019707,
0.6180132627487183,
0.6266608238220215,
0.6449517607688904,
0.9142685532569885,
1.016110897064209,
0.25459256768226624,
-0.19657094776630402,
0.27495771646499634,
-0.3983173370361328,
-0.18202941119670868,
-0.010963727720081806,
-0.6639347076416016,
-0.6445134282112122,
-0.19040453433990479,
0.43587809801101685,
0.3065289258956909,
-0.10249011963605881,
0.08726927638053894,
-0.1134856790304184,
0.7194106578826904,
-0.45714613795280457,
0.03244931623339653,
-0.7252844572067261,
0.15667055547237396,
-0.14139240980148315,
-0.5493181347846985,
-0.5531393885612488,
-0.7116742730140686,
-0.5915902853012085,
-0.19680693745613098,
0.46404922008514404,
0.31757816672325134,
0.5837132930755615,
0.6867311596870422,
-0.4561442732810974,
-0.15256717801094055,
-0.33203619718551636,
0.689842700958252,
-1.067694067955017,
0.2846663296222687,
0.2166001945734024,
-0.08142033964395523,
-0.1331287920475006,
-0.5063411593437195,
-0.4568026065826416,
-0.5597214698791504,
0.01892954111099243,
0.006702790502458811,
-0.1840372532606125,
0.39232969284057617,
0.5535680055618286,
0.6415103673934937,
-0.7736198306083679,
0.3085627853870392,
-0.20945806801319122,
-0.457417756319046,
0.4096922278404236,
0.26103225350379944,
0.2288607805967331,
0.02718191221356392,
-0.23017257452011108,
-0.28619199991226196,
-0.9409341216087341,
-0.04231097921729088,
0.331095814704895,
0.19822348654270172,
-0.10537269711494446,
0.35806193947792053,
-0.232439786195755,
0.8712818026542664,
0.20504730939865112,
0.22047987580299377,
0.08073313534259796,
-0.29685378074645996,
-0.2867208421230316,
0.14423327147960663,
0.33580532670021057,
0.6297783851623535,
0.13122782111167908,
0.0032307328656315804,
-0.5242992043495178,
0.0998610109090805,
0.3202938139438629,
-0.8550559878349304,
-0.4112342596054077,
0.004560112953186035,
-0.40985146164894104,
-0.33778300881385803,
0.10067769140005112,
-0.4227830171585083,
-0.39195144176483154,
-0.5121636390686035,
0.16625212132930756,
-0.25266191363334656,
-0.07788115739822388,
0.24808265268802643,
-0.02285894565284252,
0.46680566668510437,
0.15845082700252533,
-0.6639554500579834,
0.15063218772411346,
0.8709976673126221,
0.8255048394203186,
-0.34634658694267273,
-0.1973143368959427,
-1.0478761196136475,
-0.3314037024974823,
-0.6338964700698853,
0.8190461993217468,
-0.7057771682739258,
-0.4100857973098755,
-0.049972888082265854,
-0.030466577038168907,
0.15003404021263123,
-0.818615198135376,
0.7150346636772156,
-0.6359491944313049,
-0.5872098803520203,
-0.47047504782676697,
-0.539012610912323,
0.12763424217700958,
0.2534521222114563,
-0.6502682566642761,
1.0919787883758545,
0.320112407207489,
-0.6641637086868286,
0.47755640745162964,
-0.5000419616699219,
-0.44633233547210693,
-0.07939264923334122,
0.08038514852523804,
-0.6307873725891113,
0.4190517067909241,
0.061982739716768265,
0.21947835385799408,
-0.07592397183179855,
-0.18128351867198944,
-0.31585144996643066,
-0.7694882154464722,
0.11046908795833588,
-0.4044671952724457,
0.5096534490585327,
0.32129916548728943,
-0.33126065135002136,
0.3842080235481262,
-0.7879126071929932,
0.4554031789302826,
-0.1789541393518448,
-0.5740194916725159,
-0.24984316527843475,
-0.014004746451973915,
-0.09366818517446518,
0.024914830923080444,
0.18665052950382233,
-0.18290327489376068,
0.5548849701881409,
-0.25445690751075745,
0.5462543368339539,
0.8070597052574158,
-0.03086329624056816,
0.19527216255664825,
-0.4206436276435852,
0.5420527458190918,
0.09771048277616501,
0.37585029006004333,
-0.22596658766269684,
-0.30757036805152893,
-1.0253316164016724,
-0.15495166182518005,
0.513748824596405,
0.5843893885612488,
-0.6343787312507629,
0.5114355683326721,
0.012059910222887993,
-0.2916056215763092,
-0.5314112901687622,
0.21755331754684448,
0.6722487807273865,
0.1407749354839325,
0.346011757850647,
-0.4648948311805725,
-0.4482478201389313,
-0.7344397902488708,
-0.559511125087738,
-0.16802853345870972,
0.09313923120498657,
0.16536308825016022,
0.3498835861682892,
-0.21381868422031403,
0.6574205160140991,
-0.36982855200767517,
0.1664229780435562,
-0.11957767605781555,
0.187103271484375,
0.15157043933868408,
0.6542413234710693,
0.4543825685977936,
-0.6422277092933655,
-0.45081350207328796,
0.2341536283493042,
-0.0665084570646286,
-0.23565778136253357,
-0.0042676799930632114,
0.04899100586771965,
0.29926589131355286,
0.7211834788322449,
-0.15945006906986237,
0.547061026096344,
0.7145282626152039,
-0.5118535161018372,
0.50926673412323,
-0.36101090908050537,
0.7481858134269714,
-0.8342204093933105,
-0.16222228109836578,
-0.35840123891830444,
-0.49190741777420044,
-0.23221947252750397,
0.44002634286880493,
0.7109586596488953,
0.21549615263938904,
-0.5252138376235962,
0.03373873978853226,
-0.2919260561466217,
-0.23428088426589966,
-0.3178170919418335,
-0.1701240986585617,
-0.1394611895084381,
0.45766544342041016,
-0.24152302742004395,
1.1428611278533936,
0.3211485743522644,
-0.469246506690979,
0.4579927325248718,
-0.1428491175174713,
-0.4026710093021393,
0.3712121546268463,
-0.7976223230361938,
0.6362983584403992,
0.29495805501937866,
-0.04843984544277191,
-0.92279052734375,
-0.03012789599597454,
-0.10403986275196075,
-0.4165060222148895,
0.5021661520004272,
-0.22956454753875732,
-0.6554162502288818,
-0.32141679525375366,
-0.4320344030857086,
0.5262994170188904,
0.4413996636867523,
-0.5521712899208069,
-0.15333250164985657,
-0.21363265812397003,
-0.034437522292137146,
-0.5429751873016357,
-0.6095576286315918,
0.14198116958141327,
-0.11757723242044449,
-0.34423547983169556,
0.22726836800575256,
-0.4488513767719269,
-0.18829548358917236,
-0.2148650586605072,
-0.4560631811618805,
-0.013586058281362057,
0.09130515158176422,
-0.06757063418626785,
0.16682957112789154,
-0.5440449714660645,
0.12139103561639786,
0.09899269789457321,
-0.13158687949180603,
-0.11976822465658188,
-0.34664300084114075,
0.5271977782249451,
-0.38674309849739075,
-0.6462283134460449,
-0.07752199470996857,
0.2010290026664734,
0.4924090504646301,
-0.3565811514854431,
0.43416932225227356,
0.5173936486244202,
0.005819639656692743,
-0.3360222280025482,
-0.7299215197563171,
-0.12550361454486847,
-0.4990087151527405,
0.49996063113212585,
-0.2697870135307312,
-1.1648340225219727,
0.6252378225326538,
-0.008244656026363373,
0.0537044033408165,
0.23710526525974274,
0.3668901324272156,
0.23708787560462952,
1.2411478757858276,
0.8897830843925476,
-0.3535335063934326,
0.5520546436309814,
0.15655182301998138,
0.2541119456291199,
-0.5633440017700195,
0.18373458087444305,
-0.9843131303787231,
-0.2542932629585266,
-0.7690223455429077,
-0.7238252758979797,
0.2863042652606964,
0.34394803643226624,
-0.5200313925743103,
0.5485012531280518,
-0.7018806338310242,
1.105421781539917,
0.4438953995704651,
0.17705939710140228,
0.5655426383018494,
-0.18352831900119781,
-0.08895225822925568,
0.13195432722568512,
-0.662992537021637,
-0.25071749091148376,
0.8215108513832092,
0.12852372229099274,
0.8545177578926086,
0.1076352670788765,
0.620829164981842,
0.41913655400276184,
0.3844982981681824,
-0.627537727355957,
0.3405941426753998,
-0.26117926836013794,
-0.3374534845352173,
-0.1900869905948639,
-0.7414026260375977,
-0.5322946310043335,
-0.13178463280200958,
0.11727538704872131,
-0.4349251687526703,
-0.06250447034835815,
0.2909686267375946,
-0.33229199051856995,
0.3465421199798584,
-0.7896647453308105,
1.0894482135772705,
-0.058898087590932846,
-0.18567799031734467,
-0.38353100419044495,
-0.5304402112960815,
0.3278487026691437,
-0.05989508703351021,
-0.08080153167247772,
0.15114951133728027,
-0.17965783178806305,
0.4236926734447479,
-0.49440252780914307,
0.7742931842803955,
0.16282141208648682,
-0.2605106830596924,
0.025546696037054062,
0.37103721499443054,
0.7382981777191162,
0.218478724360466,
-0.19436103105545044,
0.283247709274292,
0.13237327337265015,
-0.578514039516449,
-0.5243990421295166,
0.8769023418426514,
-0.7670049667358398,
-0.520322859287262,
-0.1449080854654312,
-0.4639197885990143,
-0.018794864416122437,
0.22931702435016632,
0.34515565633773804,
0.5661870241165161,
0.12663818895816803,
0.2570905089378357,
1.1719309091567993,
-0.45621636509895325,
0.5569126009941101,
0.7697388529777527,
-0.07682295888662338,
-0.23954518139362335,
0.7710328698158264,
-0.4006047546863556,
0.49781426787376404,
0.6861158013343811,
0.09667161852121353,
-0.1378062218427658,
-0.7372598052024841,
-0.36719170212745667,
-0.013963958248496056,
-0.7428339719772339,
-0.6193484663963318,
-0.10596439242362976,
-0.21722468733787537,
-0.2664915919303894,
-0.27826714515686035,
-0.450713187456131,
-0.047528594732284546,
0.006758182309567928,
-0.0005069104954600334,
0.4602687954902649,
0.8180132508277893,
0.17920182645320892,
0.33493781089782715,
-0.9343770146369934,
0.16776658594608307,
0.16258881986141205,
0.713817298412323,
-0.36308959126472473,
-0.7185128927230835,
-0.3486168086528778,
-0.13710126280784607,
-0.3609144985675812,
-0.651167094707489,
0.1664818972349167,
0.1835039108991623,
0.37570545077323914,
0.23874571919441223,
0.0034210942685604095,
0.9172380566596985,
-0.5027627944946289,
0.7078919410705566,
0.08811893314123154,
-1.3683489561080933,
0.6966818571090698,
-0.35710328817367554,
0.6018469333648682,
0.6546458005905151,
-0.15207359194755554,
-0.6998583078384399,
-0.5674192309379578,
-0.40434789657592773,
-0.5877779126167297,
0.5894104838371277,
0.1300920993089676,
0.024268273264169693,
-0.22045208513736725,
0.5766618847846985,
-0.07871825993061066,
0.08552103489637375,
-0.6943708658218384,
-0.25832587480545044,
0.01891859993338585,
-0.19409619271755219,
-0.12440592050552368,
-0.10766740143299103,
0.22752024233341217,
-0.2589188516139984,
0.38246095180511475,
-0.4107941687107086,
0.31034305691719055,
0.05055553838610649,
-0.15150736272335052,
-0.5254983901977539,
0.287841796875,
0.882803738117218,
0.7123164534568787,
-0.05749772861599922,
0.2928829789161682,
0.532861590385437,
-0.5160393714904785,
-0.1281445026397705,
-0.32631373405456543,
0.2086917757987976,
-0.06782573461532593,
0.4518555700778961,
0.6626513004302979,
0.5058983564376831,
-0.6401239633560181,
0.6463291049003601,
-0.3130825161933899,
-0.07112771272659302,
0.05408114939928055,
0.4371061623096466,
0.06436707824468613,
0.11513364315032959,
-0.06389454752206802,
0.3452809453010559,
0.14307934045791626,
-0.5061972141265869,
0.33427536487579346,
0.3554060161113739,
-0.487754225730896,
0.022042609751224518,
0.5595712065696716,
0.13692988455295563,
-0.6459442973136902,
0.9616043567657471,
-0.4021719992160797,
-0.4630533754825592,
1.1137652397155762,
0.4678880572319031,
0.8295570611953735,
-0.3075249195098877,
-0.08785158395767212,
0.3563927114009857,
0.5554972887039185,
-0.15339477360248566,
0.26183801889419556,
-0.1869138777256012,
-0.4057084023952484,
-0.7816662192344666,
-0.6524274349212646,
-0.3587523400783539,
-0.123726025223732,
-0.783226490020752,
0.5781936645507812,
-0.5516857504844666,
0.18553376197814941,
-0.16910427808761597,
0.052828412503004074,
-0.5091806054115295,
-0.029997466132044792,
-0.0032664400059729815,
1.3343114852905273,
-0.5268397927284241,
1.0721430778503418,
0.581085205078125,
-0.2201191633939743,
-1.0222004652023315,
0.22851552069187164,
-0.15839426219463348,
-0.7779647707939148,
0.37240132689476013,
0.08284006267786026,
-0.10421740263700485,
0.13216249644756317,
-0.719309389591217,
-0.5829511284828186,
0.9442853331565857,
0.44035372138023376,
-1.019718050956726,
0.27498579025268555,
0.09154051542282104,
0.5047999620437622,
-0.15914888679981232,
0.36126992106437683,
0.876771092414856,
0.4534945487976074,
0.12112095206975937,
-1.0036247968673706,
0.0007543524843640625,
-0.10039525479078293,
0.06671903282403946,
0.6394808888435364,
-0.8757815957069397,
0.7653773427009583,
-0.3073921203613281,
0.0314345583319664,
0.26891952753067017,
0.3776659071445465,
0.08553962409496307,
0.32106930017471313,
0.5752050876617432,
0.46119263768196106,
0.6636060476303101,
-0.31621235609054565,
0.8565239310264587,
-0.5899629592895508,
0.5671561360359192,
0.9806764721870422,
-0.22029228508472443,
0.674916684627533,
0.1479252427816391,
-0.21569865942001343,
0.08031369745731354,
0.858824610710144,
0.028347546234726906,
0.3992196023464203,
0.5372212529182434,
-0.12968328595161438,
-0.4275814890861511,
0.305307537317276,
-0.5283768773078918,
0.11705651879310608,
0.09565209597349167,
-0.09875869005918503,
0.036789197474718094,
-0.31759390234947205,
-0.0749196708202362,
-0.09684904664754868,
-0.6425589323043823,
0.9070428609848022,
0.09610385447740555,
-0.7457882165908813,
0.7039953470230103,
0.20268641412258148,
0.5328198075294495,
-0.4572533667087555,
-0.2860700488090515,
-0.6776658892631531,
0.28309714794158936,
-0.3029323220252991,
-0.49873989820480347,
0.38128840923309326,
0.0558362640440464,
-0.2978246212005615,
-0.035134460777044296,
0.4259478449821472,
-0.39239853620529175,
-0.3221515715122223,
0.11457046121358871,
0.0020643349271267653,
0.02382766269147396,
-0.17822828888893127,
-0.800986647605896,
0.44617724418640137,
0.21909286081790924,
0.03323422372341156,
0.2387993335723877,
0.4765368700027466,
-0.10866792500019073,
0.5034170746803284,
0.4671655595302582,
0.14475609362125397,
0.14376364648342133,
0.2441861480474472,
0.8826929926872253,
-1.0260318517684937,
-0.509992241859436,
-0.843232274055481,
0.32010501623153687,
-0.10814464837312698,
-0.5869112014770508,
0.5819944143295288,
0.6623838543891907,
0.9993982315063477,
-0.16245754063129425,
0.45570001006126404,
0.047423508018255234,
0.30439403653144836,
-0.765832781791687,
0.5013017654418945,
-0.40547043085098267,
0.6980675458908081,
-0.3187655508518219,
-1.0678696632385254,
-0.4102071523666382,
0.48630598187446594,
-0.16189487278461456,
0.07435870915651321,
1.0809521675109863,
1.3808226585388184,
-0.04802914336323738,
0.09647967666387558,
0.6661162376403809,
0.27555525302886963,
0.1992216855287552,
0.7437863945960999,
0.944499671459198,
-0.37406954169273376,
0.4476376175880432,
-0.004143831320106983,
-0.32757124304771423,
-0.31292724609375,
-1.0807387828826904,
-0.9584131240844727,
-0.1798643320798874,
-0.5496180653572083,
-0.3287962079048157,
0.35332897305488586,
1.1384199857711792,
0.7570903897285461,
-1.0056939125061035,
0.03984760120511055,
-0.306903600692749,
0.3415195643901825,
-0.5451546907424927,
-0.15418605506420135,
0.1812250167131424,
-0.7651119828224182,
-0.5868543386459351,
0.3372143805027008,
0.5005162954330444,
-0.30624839663505554,
0.027552297338843346,
-0.19130708277225494,
0.4650768041610718,
0.2337397038936615,
0.3676662743091583,
-0.016942841932177544,
-0.5791754126548767,
-0.5350074172019958,
0.10820991545915604,
-0.3175884187221527,
0.20467278361320496,
1.502920389175415,
-0.3298725187778473,
0.263845831155777,
0.37213101983070374,
0.5744729042053223,
0.2954626977443695,
-0.22256609797477722,
0.2768012285232544,
-0.9390081763267517,
-0.03256480395793915,
0.19299058616161346,
0.1791301816701889,
0.0723203495144844,
-0.5314237475395203,
0.4644884765148163,
0.07623283565044403,
-0.8285922408103943,
-0.7341448068618774,
0.29336613416671753,
-1.2871922254562378,
-0.2550170421600342,
1.0989638566970825,
-0.17290657758712769,
-0.14916937053203583,
-0.02614535391330719,
-0.4243045151233673,
0.15776818990707397,
-0.3131396174430847,
0.8920883536338806,
0.5475040078163147,
0.11613983660936356,
-0.18442991375923157,
-0.5875464081764221,
0.6991287469863892,
0.4293029010295868,
-0.7312933802604675,
0.1688123494386673,
0.38030388951301575,
0.38050368428230286,
-0.36138561367988586,
0.23525825142860413,
-0.22422002255916595,
0.660050630569458,
-0.007590471301227808,
0.16352461278438568,
0.05050903186202049,
-0.09213588386774063,
-0.6448771953582764,
-0.2001018077135086,
0.5167495012283325,
0.020440567284822464
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19723v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19723v1
|
HGT: Leveraging Heterogeneous Graph-enhanced Large Language Models for Few-shot Complex Table Understanding
| 2024-03-28T03:20:54 | 2024-03-28T03:20:54 |
Rihui Jin, Yu Li, Guilin Qi, Nan Hu, Yuan-Fang Li, Jiaoyan Chen, Jianan Wang, Yongrui Chen, Dehai Min
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB, cs.MM
|
Table understanding (TU) has achieved promising advancements, but it faces
the challenges of the scarcity of manually labeled tables and the presence of
complex table structures.To address these challenges, we propose HGT, a
framework with a heterogeneous graph (HG)-enhanced large language model (LLM)
to tackle few-shot TU tasks.It leverages the LLM by aligning the table
semantics with the LLM's parametric knowledge through soft prompts and
instruction turning and deals with complex tables by a multi-task pre-training
scheme involving three novel multi-granularity self-supervised HG pre-training
objectives.We empirically demonstrate the effectiveness of HGT, showing that it
outperforms the SOTA for few-shot complex TU on several benchmarks.
|
[
-0.3523349165916443,
-1.3686470985412598,
0.5448869466781616,
0.017670707777142525,
-0.10743718594312668,
0.13170094788074493,
-0.19759954512119293,
-0.3350314795970917,
-0.11445335298776627,
0.34219104051589966,
-0.6066744327545166,
-0.8222970366477966,
-0.5137556195259094,
-0.08758559077978134,
-0.06545425206422806,
0.9888930916786194,
0.0789039358496666,
-0.11273717880249023,
0.010093449614942074,
0.06740133464336395,
-0.13879333436489105,
-0.28347620368003845,
-0.2588607966899872,
-0.7361561059951782,
0.6517338752746582,
0.9123348593711853,
0.8339232802391052,
0.9246337413787842,
0.46008777618408203,
0.24057519435882568,
0.08335375040769577,
0.10866721719503403,
-0.8004471659660339,
-0.28533563017845154,
0.11533524841070175,
-0.281218022108078,
-0.794614315032959,
-0.12903062999248505,
0.4884401559829712,
0.8374989032745361,
-0.14141547679901123,
0.25191208720207214,
0.2950313687324524,
0.4280272424221039,
-0.5298132300376892,
0.686357319355011,
-0.6024926900863647,
0.4047047793865204,
-0.5206406712532043,
-0.14691662788391113,
-0.351176917552948,
-0.07918640226125717,
0.21398770809173584,
-0.9087891578674316,
-0.026830516755580902,
0.09983933717012405,
0.873141348361969,
0.18864303827285767,
-0.43421658873558044,
0.20518431067466736,
-0.6525471210479736,
0.17667941749095917,
-0.6334476470947266,
0.48315227031707764,
0.4218582808971405,
0.7497311234474182,
-0.13867723941802979,
-1.0200912952423096,
-0.8435583114624023,
-0.2595069408416748,
-0.22085747122764587,
0.10034901648759842,
-0.12820681929588318,
0.32505175471305847,
0.3023482859134674,
0.08122244477272034,
-0.7461598515510559,
0.30034661293029785,
0.10282903164625168,
-0.16575656831264496,
0.03196733072400093,
0.3815443813800812,
0.24582168459892273,
-0.29387912154197693,
-0.40519458055496216,
0.20932196080684662,
-0.8043509125709534,
-0.3232016861438751,
0.10956902801990509,
0.6669432520866394,
-0.46651291847229004,
0.6275225281715393,
-0.30165380239486694,
1.1572082042694092,
-0.05995712801814079,
-0.207708477973938,
0.1389055848121643,
-0.3003295660018921,
-0.4530285894870758,
-0.1351911425590515,
0.6286881566047668,
-0.26932305097579956,
0.21419769525527954,
-0.4230327606201172,
0.13564693927764893,
-0.015812834724783897,
-0.15702106058597565,
-0.6894975900650024,
-0.2073902040719986,
-0.1210741475224495,
-0.26618504524230957,
-0.013703746721148491,
-0.13735876977443695,
-0.802699625492096,
-0.3059288263320923,
-0.3793124556541443,
0.641044020652771,
-0.26537927985191345,
-0.14427658915519714,
0.10477035492658615,
-0.005635783076286316,
0.22320447862148285,
0.4423561692237854,
-0.704890787601471,
0.20292781293392181,
0.7669458389282227,
0.8011323809623718,
-0.2124403417110443,
-0.7653740644454956,
-1.0289942026138306,
0.6845346689224243,
0.08811549097299576,
0.7690991163253784,
-0.7207179069519043,
-0.13183647394180298,
0.08077102154493332,
-0.28174394369125366,
0.034258633852005005,
-0.1828722357749939,
0.44663965702056885,
-0.29303064942359924,
0.14566682279109955,
-0.2174873948097229,
-0.3921603858470917,
0.021530767902731895,
0.7750076055526733,
-0.4324420690536499,
0.8181023597717285,
0.19543342292308807,
-0.7616577744483948,
0.40953874588012695,
-0.7179049849510193,
-0.5425246357917786,
0.4111647307872772,
-0.47218918800354004,
-0.4205675721168518,
-0.28509652614593506,
0.13000398874282837,
0.5803802609443665,
-0.27373626828193665,
0.013543723151087761,
-0.5369974970817566,
-0.403604120016098,
-0.4284771680831909,
-0.24110539257526398,
0.31242331862449646,
0.22805693745613098,
-0.28231656551361084,
0.3402739465236664,
-0.5928977727890015,
0.032295458018779755,
0.06658504903316498,
-0.6534058451652527,
0.09067054092884064,
-0.3517146110534668,
0.17107456922531128,
0.38118380308151245,
0.11582296341657639,
-0.28461891412734985,
0.357368141412735,
-0.20665958523750305,
0.46162283420562744,
0.40101999044418335,
-0.14726094901561737,
0.5809077024459839,
-0.11126068234443665,
0.5922200679779053,
-0.037242427468299866,
-0.006397332530468702,
0.10359912365674973,
-0.21354499459266663,
-0.4905277192592621,
-0.28600287437438965,
0.26174619793891907,
0.54929119348526,
-1.0247581005096436,
0.31454846262931824,
-0.46860986948013306,
-0.4628797769546509,
-0.0475505068898201,
0.183810293674469,
0.4686615467071533,
0.8589007258415222,
0.41652965545654297,
0.044709425419569016,
-0.34299004077911377,
-0.7042437195777893,
-0.3423364758491516,
0.07896372675895691,
0.15346288681030273,
0.5897775888442993,
0.33786019682884216,
-0.5619708299636841,
0.8566492199897766,
-0.6064951419830322,
-0.6148250102996826,
-0.6533287167549133,
0.5287680625915527,
0.040183428674936295,
0.39149439334869385,
0.32186996936798096,
-0.32854223251342773,
-0.8142669200897217,
0.4002542793750763,
-0.8419222235679626,
0.022756120190024376,
-0.007295284885913134,
-0.37084367871284485,
-0.19781075417995453,
0.6092086434364319,
-0.57845139503479,
0.37057462334632874,
0.4147632122039795,
-0.30884167551994324,
0.4446214437484741,
-0.07836795598268509,
-0.037628404796123505,
-0.7564069032669067,
-0.13047385215759277,
0.13055460155010223,
-0.536226212978363,
-0.7299718856811523,
-0.0068520670756697655,
-0.1489085853099823,
-0.33254286646842957,
-0.523566722869873,
0.49466121196746826,
-0.5609498620033264,
-0.27148938179016113,
-0.28057172894477844,
0.15881526470184326,
-0.010421046987175941,
0.6316049695014954,
0.10451799631118774,
0.7539336085319519,
0.5420032739639282,
-0.5197601318359375,
0.046125464141368866,
0.43000778555870056,
-0.29865166544914246,
0.5459514856338501,
-0.5247311592102051,
0.3146321475505829,
-0.2368428260087967,
0.26344162225723267,
-0.9733998775482178,
-0.4094051420688629,
0.22714920341968536,
-0.1613595187664032,
0.5120694041252136,
-0.43814992904663086,
-0.37827545404434204,
-0.46002674102783203,
-0.016285939142107964,
0.10747195780277252,
0.1848098635673523,
-0.5174537897109985,
1.1974886655807495,
0.38430044054985046,
0.07015463709831238,
-0.8536036014556885,
-0.8150056004524231,
0.15371577441692352,
-0.12937211990356445,
-0.5910313129425049,
0.4424791932106018,
0.2637529969215393,
-0.13505251705646515,
-0.06297498196363449,
-0.27093255519866943,
-0.24503988027572632,
0.07261473685503006,
0.1853412538766861,
-0.037820782512426376,
-0.3770417869091034,
0.2691258192062378,
-0.031897224485874176,
-0.17766886949539185,
-0.24572741985321045,
-0.31908220052719116,
1.0698614120483398,
-0.370873361825943,
-0.2643098533153534,
-0.5526912212371826,
0.09386750310659409,
0.2874853014945984,
-0.24489478766918182,
0.567157506942749,
0.9278268814086914,
-0.39299389719963074,
-0.017679596319794655,
-0.2973100244998932,
-0.20730091631412506,
-0.4529920816421509,
0.6809190511703491,
-0.827653706073761,
-0.9553258419036865,
0.5668095350265503,
-0.2051568329334259,
-0.017942344769835472,
0.4327385127544403,
0.6303796172142029,
-0.3709902763366699,
0.6586509943008423,
0.6382416486740112,
-0.11130081862211227,
0.5827338695526123,
-0.23777644336223602,
0.017309118062257767,
-0.3774662911891937,
-0.2196083813905716,
-0.7562448382377625,
-0.3232386112213135,
-0.4195360839366913,
-0.2951657176017761,
0.5635011792182922,
-0.16750043630599976,
-0.5557315349578857,
0.18265517055988312,
-0.08637715131044388,
0.7539668679237366,
0.46118736267089844,
0.4500383734703064,
0.41281017661094666,
0.11924713850021362,
0.12904475629329681,
0.24678398668766022,
-1.119192123413086,
-0.45110630989074707,
0.6511430144309998,
0.4138455390930176,
1.2533433437347412,
0.016623113304376602,
0.69843989610672,
0.2846372723579407,
0.18323245644569397,
-0.8667325973510742,
0.3737948536872864,
-0.2514163851737976,
-0.6520419120788574,
-0.6837029457092285,
-0.7020894289016724,
-0.9374977946281433,
0.3028618097305298,
-0.4445972144603729,
-0.6482798457145691,
-0.030639339238405228,
0.4276129901409149,
-0.4074155390262604,
0.1706867218017578,
-0.9083108901977539,
1.3361772298812866,
-0.1801026463508606,
-0.7271532416343689,
-0.09456797689199448,
-0.7453874945640564,
0.4330246150493622,
0.260310560464859,
0.15843605995178223,
-0.10946469753980637,
0.12002105265855789,
0.5927494764328003,
-0.34567028284072876,
0.9431357979774475,
-0.2886591851711273,
0.1348351687192917,
0.22790418565273285,
0.3088974356651306,
0.6800845265388489,
-0.04150482267141342,
-0.05816115811467171,
-0.013197600841522217,
-0.18338847160339355,
-0.5079735517501831,
-0.4574381709098816,
0.6346678733825684,
-0.7655153274536133,
-0.6175581812858582,
-0.24184639751911163,
-0.7900092601776123,
-0.43640533089637756,
0.23293176293373108,
0.3923400640487671,
0.3263383209705353,
-0.13483767211437225,
0.10305166244506836,
0.4171404242515564,
0.0027243071235716343,
0.31269219517707825,
0.17765574157238007,
-0.027599889785051346,
0.04494354501366615,
0.7355512976646423,
0.1146552786231041,
0.33359983563423157,
0.3225296437740326,
0.47879737615585327,
-0.25401222705841064,
-0.44747138023376465,
-0.5323880910873413,
0.021019726991653442,
-0.7549120187759399,
-0.33702683448791504,
-0.9875653386116028,
0.11629561334848404,
-0.27906525135040283,
-0.03739675134420395,
0.000011186548363184556,
-0.22315660119056702,
-0.3063926100730896,
-0.1688842922449112,
0.3433453440666199,
0.5921870470046997,
0.0634254738688469,
1.018031358718872,
-0.9222612977027893,
0.4463433623313904,
0.7453266382217407,
0.4110291004180908,
-0.05935441330075264,
-0.6683178544044495,
-0.17424647510051727,
-0.2033197283744812,
0.052611298859119415,
-0.9744784832000732,
0.1399470716714859,
0.48394155502319336,
0.6112432479858398,
0.2977628707885742,
-0.4322828948497772,
1.0191673040390015,
-0.562323272228241,
0.404776006937027,
0.1112622618675232,
-1.293095350265503,
0.2241375744342804,
-0.5872274041175842,
0.5789178609848022,
0.9594878554344177,
0.34361594915390015,
-0.3872481882572174,
0.17525339126586914,
-0.3103145360946655,
-0.5081313252449036,
0.8686967492103577,
-0.12318018823862076,
0.20251908898353577,
0.29000425338745117,
0.37052854895591736,
0.24394282698631287,
0.24023619294166565,
-1.2147091627120972,
-0.09178967028856277,
-0.17217524349689484,
-0.29193440079689026,
0.18329459428787231,
-0.14750544726848602,
-0.24792630970478058,
-0.35914677381515503,
0.428440123796463,
-0.47689932584762573,
0.15406176447868347,
-0.3007679581642151,
-0.3857884109020233,
-0.10039765387773514,
0.4323357045650482,
0.2607669532299042,
0.6208702921867371,
-0.08505075424909592,
0.5398234128952026,
0.3436092138290405,
-0.4330141246318817,
-0.042545612901449203,
0.14584538340568542,
0.21189028024673462,
-0.3198075294494629,
0.586469829082489,
0.7879766821861267,
-0.013178504072129726,
-0.27806201577186584,
0.39314791560173035,
0.1590941697359085,
-0.09358184784650803,
0.5072280168533325,
0.02689775638282299,
0.17853689193725586,
0.034428052604198456,
0.09887844324111938,
-0.5144010782241821,
0.2750462293624878,
-0.8914496898651123,
0.40869075059890747,
0.3856562674045563,
-0.43582582473754883,
-0.08096151053905487,
0.4156825542449951,
0.2355811595916748,
-0.2550261318683624,
0.4758237898349762,
-0.3941103219985962,
-0.5671687126159668,
0.46523353457450867,
0.7126533389091492,
0.4030764102935791,
0.07650920748710632,
0.27313461899757385,
0.26511842012405396,
0.2716843783855438,
0.1101611778140068,
0.5726532340049744,
-0.23141257464885712,
-0.6051771640777588,
-0.49788376688957214,
-0.29413843154907227,
-0.4676623046398163,
-0.019812699407339096,
-0.2685803771018982,
0.29118335247039795,
-0.49211588501930237,
-0.04200223460793495,
0.23603034019470215,
-0.1859757900238037,
-0.9093992710113525,
0.046895913779735565,
0.06688529998064041,
0.6829866170883179,
-1.0219531059265137,
0.9580385684967041,
0.43148672580718994,
-0.5141430497169495,
-1.0137195587158203,
0.08391234278678894,
-0.0671854242682457,
-0.9415526390075684,
0.6581704616546631,
-0.029872603714466095,
-0.2377070188522339,
0.3469637334346771,
-0.6744030117988586,
-0.4518097937107086,
0.7242093682289124,
0.5198543071746826,
-0.8490114808082581,
-0.18545766174793243,
0.43766361474990845,
0.3466963768005371,
-0.19900831580162048,
0.1888227015733719,
0.8904993534088135,
0.7835416793823242,
0.3617945909500122,
-0.8329775929450989,
-0.22676171362400055,
0.17705275118350983,
-0.4430024325847626,
0.18852205574512482,
-0.30170494318008423,
0.877122700214386,
-0.1325979232788086,
-0.11896307021379471,
-0.6514440774917603,
0.761929988861084,
0.15613001585006714,
0.48774588108062744,
0.518308699131012,
0.5658370852470398,
0.6786490082740784,
-0.32618600130081177,
0.9239882826805115,
-0.02326025627553463,
0.2623448073863983,
1.7174723148345947,
-0.405829519033432,
0.5023887157440186,
0.2989320456981659,
-0.15023009479045868,
0.38985908031463623,
0.5626007914543152,
0.25006282329559326,
0.40016818046569824,
0.2915480434894562,
-0.13476279377937317,
-0.48612380027770996,
-0.19631174206733704,
-0.43082910776138306,
0.8287293314933777,
0.44463279843330383,
0.05774715170264244,
-0.7924880385398865,
0.10294631868600845,
0.050322260707616806,
0.12691687047481537,
-0.4585411250591278,
0.9907810688018799,
0.009427648037672043,
-0.05114317685365677,
0.4722203016281128,
-0.1312466859817505,
0.6397702097892761,
-0.6069360971450806,
0.01760425604879856,
-0.0477982833981514,
-0.2441725879907608,
-0.5367898941040039,
-0.8271515369415283,
0.1980801373720169,
0.050302863121032715,
0.17358532547950745,
0.010511084459722042,
0.7450814247131348,
-0.5996096134185791,
-0.09692037105560303,
-0.02432931214570999,
1.1465014219284058,
-0.03712249547243118,
-0.21262376010417938,
-0.6494849920272827,
-0.01426015980541706,
-0.29685887694358826,
-0.09559443593025208,
0.15084008872509003,
0.7650038599967957,
0.14335165917873383,
0.47110483050346375,
0.2834646999835968,
-0.31031712889671326,
0.09156495332717896,
0.3910129964351654,
0.815929651260376,
-0.5654764771461487,
-0.6506116390228271,
-1.0907124280929565,
0.19524967670440674,
0.12654981017112732,
-0.28463730216026306,
0.6734209656715393,
0.5546806454658508,
0.48251980543136597,
-0.14687807857990265,
0.6406546831130981,
0.06359713524580002,
-0.03435606509447098,
-0.5203036665916443,
0.7280592322349548,
-0.43668267130851746,
-0.032041825354099274,
-0.32262223958969116,
-1.0125631093978882,
-0.5540079474449158,
0.6361951231956482,
-0.49446120858192444,
0.06543150544166565,
0.4441370368003845,
0.5235947370529175,
-0.3651997447013855,
-0.23875692486763,
0.3335212767124176,
0.19274388253688812,
0.32204434275627136,
0.5337040424346924,
0.921126663684845,
0.12098058313131332,
0.7003071904182434,
0.05190247669816017,
-0.13245545327663422,
-0.15470224618911743,
-0.8659886121749878,
-1.0587009191513062,
-0.292672723531723,
-0.2021838277578354,
-0.34944164752960205,
-0.04360879212617874,
1.17626953125,
0.9937285780906677,
-0.46497631072998047,
-0.26732954382896423,
-0.24534207582473755,
0.16220061480998993,
0.05530143529176712,
-0.16107255220413208,
0.4333832263946533,
-0.3714253306388855,
-0.6676228642463684,
0.23238691687583923,
0.4607239067554474,
0.2946227490901947,
-0.18256080150604248,
-0.04418407753109932,
-0.3925376236438751,
-0.17166924476623535,
0.7619126439094543,
0.36234062910079956,
-0.4000771939754486,
-0.24300815165042877,
-0.03193378075957298,
-0.48853588104248047,
0.37142691016197205,
0.6522403359413147,
-0.6841796636581421,
0.20587058365345,
0.7212891578674316,
0.9118009209632874,
1.020087480545044,
0.053141940385103226,
0.3390446901321411,
-0.8025926947593689,
0.33223387598991394,
0.3763711750507355,
0.34788647294044495,
0.08520995080471039,
-0.4327560365200043,
0.5926486253738403,
-0.021561959758400917,
-0.13770802319049835,
-0.6407387256622314,
0.46620842814445496,
-1.1506621837615967,
-0.30750465393066406,
1.1039721965789795,
0.02160073257982731,
-0.3538531959056854,
-0.2998790740966797,
-0.19772759079933167,
0.47627443075180054,
-0.22037628293037415,
0.686785101890564,
0.4595767855644226,
-0.22698381543159485,
-0.17711421847343445,
-0.1927744746208191,
0.515766441822052,
0.3350542187690735,
-1.6015318632125854,
0.07224907726049423,
0.5693961381912231,
-0.058061420917510986,
-0.10122068971395493,
0.5803619027137756,
0.0758652538061142,
0.2909940779209137,
-0.13940323889255524,
0.11285911500453949,
-0.42959287762641907,
-0.5980855226516724,
-0.23679523169994354,
0.5018929839134216,
0.11908005177974701,
-0.11486440896987915
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19116v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19116v1
|
MFORT-QA: Multi-hop Few-shot Open Rich Table Question Answering
| 2024-03-28T03:14:18 | 2024-03-28T03:14:18 |
Che Guan, Mengyu Huang, Peng Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In today's fast-paced industry, professionals face the challenge of
summarizing a large number of documents and extracting vital information from
them on a daily basis. These metrics are frequently hidden away in tables
and/or their nested hyperlinks. To address this challenge, the approach of
Table Question Answering (QA) has been developed to extract the relevant
information. However, traditional Table QA training tasks that provide a table
and an answer(s) from a gold cell coordinate(s) for a question may not always
ensure extracting the accurate answer(s). Recent advancements in Large Language
Models (LLMs) have opened up new possibilities for extracting information from
tabular data using prompts. In this paper, we introduce the Multi-hop Few-shot
Open Rich Table QA (MFORT-QA) approach, which consists of two major steps. The
first step involves Few-Shot Learning (FSL), where relevant tables and
associated contexts of hyperlinks are retrieved based on a given question. The
retrieved content is then used to construct few-shot prompts as inputs to an
LLM, such as ChatGPT. To tackle the challenge of answering complex questions,
the second step leverages Chain-of-thought (CoT) prompting to decompose the
complex question into a sequential chain of questions and reasoning thoughts in
a multi-hop manner. Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) enhances this process
by retrieving relevant tables and contexts of hyperlinks that are relevant to
the resulting reasoning thoughts and questions. These additional contexts are
then used to supplement the prompt used in the first step, resulting in more
accurate answers from an LLM. Empirical results from OTT-QA demonstrate that
our abstractive QA approach significantly improves the accuracy of extractive
Table QA methods.
|
[
-0.4694138467311859,
-1.3736276626586914,
0.5983216166496277,
-0.1612614393234253,
-0.27806100249290466,
0.14094331860542297,
0.29630985856056213,
-0.320544570684433,
0.09530176222324371,
0.4548438787460327,
-0.7744033336639404,
-0.33284899592399597,
-0.13896657526493073,
0.2300766557455063,
0.041935455054044724,
1.0070979595184326,
-0.12051551043987274,
-0.04780052229762077,
-0.05150265991687775,
-0.021687079221010208,
-0.7517138123512268,
-0.31672948598861694,
-0.5455083847045898,
0.11137392371892929,
0.6704770922660828,
0.906525731086731,
0.4916243255138397,
0.4139929711818695,
0.5245917439460754,
0.25504714250564575,
0.12248243391513824,
0.4981480836868286,
-0.45850256085395813,
0.4605059027671814,
0.08519367128610611,
-0.5632349848747253,
-0.44929859042167664,
-0.08949922770261765,
0.5905758738517761,
0.25251761078834534,
-0.046544138342142105,
0.5106459856033325,
0.006024430505931377,
0.8858942985534668,
-0.7690942883491516,
0.17171674966812134,
-0.7672597765922546,
0.001957859843969345,
-0.3569319248199463,
-0.44745558500289917,
-0.43255093693733215,
-0.41225603222846985,
-0.15739454329013824,
-0.6235365867614746,
-0.07823696732521057,
0.28233376145362854,
0.793205738067627,
-0.05445123091340065,
-0.3231673538684845,
-0.24665792286396027,
-0.6439419984817505,
0.6225967407226562,
-0.3498009741306305,
0.6329811215400696,
0.11180388927459717,
0.8037967085838318,
-0.3604079782962799,
-0.6100781559944153,
-0.7642440795898438,
-0.18255946040153503,
-0.045833520591259,
0.1907237321138382,
-0.06746415048837662,
-0.23120944201946259,
0.631915807723999,
0.04401344060897827,
-0.812922477722168,
-0.2407880276441574,
-0.24770890176296234,
0.04225587472319603,
0.352423757314682,
0.338443398475647,
0.21434371173381805,
-0.2985711097717285,
-0.3912004828453064,
-0.14042586088180542,
-0.7133644223213196,
0.3814884126186371,
0.01216268539428711,
0.3575149178504944,
0.08189001679420471,
0.7489009499549866,
-0.5953420400619507,
0.9074859023094177,
-0.11914220452308655,
-0.5077271461486816,
0.1898629367351532,
-0.27989211678504944,
-0.14295370876789093,
-0.14934788644313812,
0.6023914813995361,
-0.044435735791921616,
0.14011546969413757,
-0.03684297949075699,
-0.10193747282028198,
-0.19265402853488922,
0.09699779003858566,
-0.6050207614898682,
-0.09438712894916534,
0.42169681191444397,
-0.201966792345047,
-0.1189584955573082,
-0.022675707936286926,
-1.3650643825531006,
-0.2781184911727905,
-0.12930642068386078,
0.6314588785171509,
-0.25370094180107117,
0.2393423318862915,
-0.3221665322780609,
-0.18023432791233063,
0.6520002484321594,
0.5013367533683777,
-0.6017946600914001,
0.12026061117649078,
0.4943128228187561,
0.6579436659812927,
-0.15170258283615112,
-0.2570500373840332,
-1.3415226936340332,
0.2788251042366028,
-0.22879600524902344,
1.0864734649658203,
-0.49014750123023987,
-0.13436377048492432,
0.054579947143793106,
-0.16361135244369507,
-0.001489357091486454,
-0.43723148107528687,
0.541236400604248,
-0.932374894618988,
0.1428307145833969,
-0.4406653344631195,
-0.1663895696401596,
0.0830102264881134,
0.8792760968208313,
-0.6524975895881653,
0.8803675770759583,
0.19554349780082703,
-0.8950249552726746,
0.3235805034637451,
-0.6771191358566284,
-0.024367982521653175,
0.05685993656516075,
-0.2948688864707947,
-0.3764168918132782,
-0.23031972348690033,
0.558929443359375,
0.35694223642349243,
-0.3351137340068817,
-0.13799169659614563,
-0.21492086350917816,
-0.19351744651794434,
0.3804205358028412,
-0.2904873192310333,
0.5021456480026245,
0.2836867868900299,
-0.02751639485359192,
-0.004155348986387253,
-0.6800048351287842,
0.21434377133846283,
0.16362465918064117,
-0.7320197820663452,
-0.0038118716329336166,
-0.4340079128742218,
-0.1950325071811676,
0.5772567987442017,
-0.18271492421627045,
-0.6440903544425964,
0.3860059380531311,
-0.3085819184780121,
-0.10125337541103363,
0.4498673379421234,
0.46479788422584534,
0.2878977358341217,
-0.5215102434158325,
0.7174291014671326,
0.24990808963775635,
0.11018714308738708,
-0.21657916903495789,
-0.6214480400085449,
-0.39098429679870605,
-0.20285187661647797,
0.27810800075531006,
0.8362444043159485,
-1.1617445945739746,
-0.03622026741504669,
-0.042021650820970535,
-0.4941268563270569,
-0.6484642624855042,
0.24815356731414795,
0.2807169258594513,
0.7887871265411377,
0.6297942996025085,
0.00229392247274518,
-0.30839890241622925,
-0.5790796279907227,
-0.36427468061447144,
0.0015148678794503212,
0.02376617304980755,
0.45396703481674194,
0.4699752628803253,
-0.01306035928428173,
0.8165115118026733,
-0.7810618281364441,
-0.2444395273923874,
-0.6091145277023315,
0.08110611140727997,
0.23765042424201965,
0.4840534031391144,
0.10444425791501999,
-0.614274799823761,
-0.497760146856308,
-0.13190913200378418,
-0.6612488627433777,
0.11366204172372818,
-0.21684011816978455,
-0.5936852097511292,
-0.06922224909067154,
0.2838435173034668,
-0.8122337460517883,
0.26051074266433716,
0.18389318883419037,
-0.11175324767827988,
0.9644213914871216,
0.1932726949453354,
0.4788903594017029,
-1.0876637697219849,
0.08785345405340195,
-0.1328154057264328,
0.049530886113643646,
-0.6114716529846191,
0.12973345816135406,
-0.07231321930885315,
-0.40054893493652344,
-0.6329106092453003,
0.6792226433753967,
-0.583013117313385,
-0.20719464123249054,
-0.016614748165011406,
0.5637466907501221,
0.28613993525505066,
0.6081575155258179,
-0.20326803624629974,
0.9159210324287415,
0.35847458243370056,
-0.605938732624054,
0.2707768976688385,
0.8327176570892334,
0.03554440662264824,
0.5537104606628418,
-0.42943644523620605,
0.18682004511356354,
-0.22705794870853424,
0.1731386035680771,
-0.9445470571517944,
-0.1414945125579834,
0.31578609347343445,
-0.5118900537490845,
0.49379971623420715,
-0.22465065121650696,
-0.3164922595024109,
-0.39637476205825806,
-0.4447918236255646,
0.2596989572048187,
0.359708309173584,
-0.44518333673477173,
0.7574860453605652,
0.33696436882019043,
-0.2402401566505432,
-0.854597806930542,
-0.4213859438896179,
-0.10944928973913193,
-0.11071509122848511,
-0.7637336850166321,
-0.016745494678616524,
-0.10779327899217606,
-0.3421993553638458,
-0.34921303391456604,
-0.1569373458623886,
-0.30599072575569153,
-0.061662644147872925,
-0.049038685858249664,
0.2747861444950104,
-0.3336537480354309,
0.28073620796203613,
0.12307405471801758,
-0.2521328926086426,
-0.04277235269546509,
0.07832474261522293,
0.578859269618988,
-0.162848100066185,
-0.1533164232969284,
-0.4704797565937042,
0.5425561666488647,
0.2268918752670288,
-0.7134076356887817,
0.59433513879776,
0.7262828350067139,
-0.29670512676239014,
-0.07508142292499542,
-0.6291935443878174,
-0.35526958107948303,
-0.41046977043151855,
0.08610887080430984,
-0.7550751566886902,
-0.7334586381912231,
0.5741159915924072,
-0.14944157004356384,
0.31107524037361145,
0.5158998370170593,
0.4469659626483917,
-0.419526070356369,
0.6973264813423157,
0.38934361934661865,
0.12440063804388046,
0.23759250342845917,
-0.3864060342311859,
0.08831493556499481,
-0.7992401123046875,
-0.37795838713645935,
-1.0357096195220947,
-0.13260529935359955,
-0.538385272026062,
-0.3472312092781067,
0.8145672678947449,
0.16854001581668854,
-0.08415248245000839,
-0.03027467615902424,
-0.10170719772577286,
0.41981175541877747,
0.7097207903862,
0.3265473246574402,
0.3504791259765625,
-0.14758746325969696,
-0.027092471718788147,
0.2006625086069107,
-0.9736785888671875,
-0.5036280155181885,
0.791023313999176,
0.20916183292865753,
0.9535619020462036,
0.09963986277580261,
0.988914430141449,
0.07326525449752808,
0.14249272644519806,
-0.8752226829528809,
0.32311367988586426,
0.28097712993621826,
-0.6241694092750549,
-0.6154813766479492,
-0.5475413203239441,
-0.9974212646484375,
0.29779252409935,
-0.7354546189308167,
-0.6874259114265442,
0.013150477781891823,
0.29380175471305847,
-0.6549235582351685,
0.2687598168849945,
-0.46354520320892334,
1.1856532096862793,
-0.11418183147907257,
-0.6296943426132202,
0.23813121020793915,
-0.8160755634307861,
0.6179925799369812,
-0.046622902154922485,
0.12752489745616913,
0.10391346365213394,
0.24964772164821625,
0.860106348991394,
-0.20950134098529816,
0.2983871102333069,
-0.21716620028018951,
0.19371359050273895,
0.7425478100776672,
0.403077095746994,
0.7523483037948608,
0.10781902819871902,
0.07621258497238159,
-0.36619341373443604,
0.16172118484973907,
-0.4885493814945221,
-0.7090622186660767,
0.48202383518218994,
-0.48296013474464417,
-0.5212603807449341,
-0.32178932428359985,
-0.6479944586753845,
-0.6580444574356079,
0.08273202180862427,
-0.004679461009800434,
0.7117502689361572,
-0.015383554622530937,
0.05213957279920578,
0.7700297236442566,
-0.38804373145103455,
0.2851591408252716,
0.21551081538200378,
0.11679910123348236,
-0.3595345914363861,
0.6170387268066406,
0.13075877726078033,
0.02014758065342903,
0.6385663747787476,
0.3299574553966522,
-0.51553875207901,
-0.4175334870815277,
-0.8039405941963196,
0.3253735601902008,
-0.7044377326965332,
-0.5944572687149048,
-1.0236403942108154,
0.06618616729974747,
-0.2899925410747528,
-0.16629329323768616,
0.08391895890235901,
-0.3503163456916809,
-0.11825746297836304,
-0.15279363095760345,
0.3050438165664673,
0.4081892669200897,
0.1952304095029831,
0.3099364936351776,
-1.5511966943740845,
0.6480189561843872,
0.7470729351043701,
0.14005984365940094,
-0.11954157799482346,
-0.3589399755001068,
-0.058242879807949066,
-0.10349687933921814,
-0.3383234441280365,
-1.4535887241363525,
0.32334741950035095,
-0.015398356132209301,
0.7286201119422913,
0.08296247571706772,
-0.006003719288855791,
0.6356702446937561,
-0.5337412357330322,
0.6923108696937561,
0.03280292823910713,
-0.6529947519302368,
0.57750403881073,
-0.31560084223747253,
0.31164878606796265,
0.8519001603126526,
0.455284982919693,
-0.29584887623786926,
-0.11049744486808777,
-0.5361189842224121,
-0.6086640357971191,
0.4816269278526306,
-0.08015059679746628,
-0.21253381669521332,
-0.024189963936805725,
0.3416261076927185,
0.2470771223306656,
0.24996915459632874,
-0.5552109479904175,
-0.05413118004798889,
0.04771953821182251,
0.018000474199652672,
0.17810851335525513,
-0.48074713349342346,
-0.0859614759683609,
0.11033300310373306,
0.722779393196106,
-0.276015043258667,
0.309780478477478,
0.19558726251125336,
-0.2148265242576599,
-0.16553935408592224,
0.840196430683136,
0.46130451560020447,
0.6624043583869934,
-0.2917120158672333,
0.2262672483921051,
0.27491840720176697,
-0.3173953890800476,
0.21716704964637756,
-0.050563447177410126,
-0.11704076826572418,
-0.0202989149838686,
0.11348246783018112,
0.3596925437450409,
-0.21777398884296417,
-0.6234556436538696,
0.5149785280227661,
0.09388061612844467,
0.07104089856147766,
0.19393545389175415,
-0.03882709890604019,
-0.18593847751617432,
0.356678307056427,
0.3519981801509857,
-0.3606203496456146,
0.3853985667228699,
-0.7051261067390442,
0.6962173581123352,
0.49237096309661865,
-0.4151431918144226,
0.09032654017210007,
0.5180738568305969,
0.00372278387658298,
-0.18644613027572632,
0.7680030465126038,
-0.29199153184890747,
-0.3591703772544861,
0.44568657875061035,
0.4896949827671051,
0.7828707098960876,
-0.03317767009139061,
0.34577763080596924,
0.5523277521133423,
0.3530207574367523,
0.31351998448371887,
0.8440734148025513,
0.09790769964456558,
-0.527283787727356,
-0.45159897208213806,
-0.7437252402305603,
-0.4353979527950287,
-0.004532599821686745,
-0.3715471923351288,
0.12136784195899963,
-0.12172850966453552,
0.02553604170680046,
-0.07141147553920746,
0.11943696439266205,
-0.8035537600517273,
0.16395200788974762,
-0.262892484664917,
1.129482626914978,
-0.9064883589744568,
0.4699144959449768,
0.3779706656932831,
-0.754949688911438,
-1.1461681127548218,
-0.12816205620765686,
-0.07408253103494644,
-0.49521005153656006,
0.38935360312461853,
-0.04299928620457649,
0.04579503834247589,
0.12736767530441284,
-0.6175092458724976,
-0.5790840983390808,
1.0163710117340088,
0.020246541127562523,
-0.37560567259788513,
0.010837666690349579,
-0.06184177100658417,
0.29042840003967285,
-0.1736201047897339,
0.3042968511581421,
0.7305681109428406,
0.593156099319458,
0.21257777512073517,
-0.6666983962059021,
0.06676419824361801,
-0.03369102627038956,
-0.5998104810714722,
0.3525315225124359,
-0.36298537254333496,
0.7306744456291199,
-0.5491496324539185,
0.08240412920713425,
-0.19453640282154083,
0.6612741947174072,
0.8174474835395813,
0.5182080864906311,
0.3449782431125641,
0.28559330105781555,
0.57275390625,
-0.1544056087732315,
0.881123423576355,
-0.035695381462574005,
0.001985452603548765,
1.1119613647460938,
-0.14588961005210876,
1.0367976427078247,
0.6509736776351929,
-0.07761548459529877,
0.41004082560539246,
0.46583104133605957,
0.23088867962360382,
0.30672168731689453,
0.2144443392753601,
-0.04231308773159981,
-0.16803036630153656,
-0.10143714398145676,
-0.30633482336997986,
0.642427921295166,
0.27272847294807434,
0.0407031774520874,
-0.6291107535362244,
-0.12078769505023956,
-0.10326652973890305,
-0.18506166338920593,
-0.3322126567363739,
1.0813614130020142,
0.031059790402650833,
-0.4846913814544678,
0.3235030770301819,
-0.15022218227386475,
0.14595408737659454,
-0.6393163204193115,
-0.5340502858161926,
-0.37491631507873535,
-0.49840235710144043,
-0.19528809189796448,
-0.7707710862159729,
0.0063561080023646355,
0.11158818751573563,
0.09867037832736969,
0.11768906563520432,
0.7832817435264587,
-0.5363420248031616,
-0.06191760674118996,
-0.3580920994281769,
1.3934810161590576,
0.31469476222991943,
-0.21134784817695618,
-0.7680603861808777,
-0.1955016553401947,
-0.25840842723846436,
-0.3068881034851074,
0.197442427277565,
0.684258759021759,
-0.051000263541936874,
0.6702110171318054,
0.698233962059021,
-0.15113568305969238,
0.25694772601127625,
-0.11190755665302277,
1.1032756567001343,
-0.6636698246002197,
-0.6443001627922058,
-0.5345488786697388,
0.6677940487861633,
0.21573016047477722,
-0.14502669870853424,
0.5255580544471741,
0.6380163431167603,
0.3331766724586487,
-0.3310089111328125,
0.4388692378997803,
0.05453328788280487,
0.6029155254364014,
-0.813620924949646,
0.43007659912109375,
-0.4518868923187256,
-0.014307414181530476,
-0.5452158451080322,
-1.1001298427581787,
-0.2283639758825302,
0.2559029459953308,
-0.0551692470908165,
-0.0006813224754296243,
0.7650167346000671,
0.8192688226699829,
-0.021656552329659462,
-0.26450198888778687,
0.37548813223838806,
0.028315765783190727,
0.3981577754020691,
0.50959312915802,
0.8955588936805725,
-0.43916600942611694,
0.7154663801193237,
-0.1722133457660675,
-0.3318653404712677,
-0.13906435668468475,
-0.6179925203323364,
-0.589113175868988,
-0.4437127411365509,
-0.1059969887137413,
-0.4454406797885895,
-0.01958400569856167,
1.0120614767074585,
0.24702443182468414,
-0.8241838812828064,
-0.09517192840576172,
0.38037109375,
0.21117649972438812,
-0.2872670292854309,
-0.2712647318840027,
0.6212788224220276,
-0.5065063834190369,
-0.2877587676048279,
0.4606112539768219,
0.27049311995506287,
0.15510569512844086,
-0.018663369119167328,
0.2546100914478302,
-0.6455667614936829,
0.035162512212991714,
0.7960080504417419,
0.33048418164253235,
-0.23939092457294464,
-0.25498923659324646,
0.28905215859413147,
-0.08571011573076248,
0.3577883839607239,
0.6620252132415771,
-0.8077436089515686,
0.48200926184654236,
0.8328877687454224,
1.0309017896652222,
0.42566198110580444,
0.4479770362377167,
0.19916628301143646,
-0.8366825580596924,
-0.22709445655345917,
0.3564908504486084,
0.21118861436843872,
-0.005207337439060211,
-0.36480340361595154,
0.4894695580005646,
0.10794572532176971,
-0.5579033493995667,
-0.5809597969055176,
0.30811071395874023,
-1.2229586839675903,
-0.034561026841402054,
1.016524076461792,
0.06501351296901703,
-0.3710794150829315,
-0.3930850923061371,
-0.5750133991241455,
0.2860666811466217,
-0.5574297308921814,
0.8742296099662781,
0.31741008162498474,
-0.42132022976875305,
-0.33191168308258057,
-0.7570959329605103,
0.8025596737861633,
-0.02254199981689453,
-1.408240795135498,
-0.0067931534722447395,
0.7402356863021851,
-0.07087849080562592,
0.21414095163345337,
0.8022722601890564,
-0.11237013339996338,
0.4934178590774536,
0.08131233602762222,
-0.0812939703464508,
-0.1169654130935669,
-0.7929667234420776,
-0.13707293570041656,
0.6916124224662781,
0.24421672523021698,
-0.4327910244464874
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19114v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19114v1
|
Top Leaderboard Ranking = Top Coding Proficiency, Always? EvoEval: Evolving Coding Benchmarks via LLM
| 2024-03-28T03:10:39 | 2024-03-28T03:10:39 |
Chunqiu Steven Xia, Yinlin Deng, Lingming Zhang
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.PL
|
LLMs have become the go-to choice for code generation tasks, with an
exponential increase in the training, development, and usage of LLMs
specifically for code generation. To evaluate the ability of LLMs on code, both
academic and industry practitioners rely on popular handcrafted benchmarks.
However, prior benchmarks contain only a very limited set of problems, both in
quantity and variety. Further, due to popularity and age, many benchmarks are
prone to data leakage where example solutions can be readily found on the web
and thus potentially in training data. Such limitations inevitably lead us to
inquire: Is the leaderboard performance on existing benchmarks reliable and
comprehensive enough to measure the program synthesis ability of LLMs? To
address this, we introduce EvoEval -- a program synthesis benchmark suite
created by evolving existing benchmarks into different targeted domains for a
comprehensive evaluation of LLM coding abilities. Our study on 51 LLMs shows
that compared to the high performance obtained on standard benchmarks like
HumanEval, there is a significant drop in performance (on average 39.4%) when
using EvoEval. Additionally, the decrease in performance can range from 19.6%
to 47.7%, leading to drastic ranking changes amongst LLMs and showing potential
overfitting of existing benchmarks. Furthermore, we showcase various insights,
including the brittleness of instruction-following models when encountering
rewording or subtle changes as well as the importance of learning problem
composition and decomposition. EvoEval not only provides comprehensive
benchmarks, but can be used to further evolve arbitrary problems to keep up
with advances and the ever-changing landscape of LLMs for code. We have
open-sourced our benchmarks, tools, and complete LLM generations at
https://github.com/evo-eval/evoeval
|
[
-0.316305547952652,
-0.5757306814193726,
0.46830540895462036,
0.09096665680408478,
-0.18053948879241943,
0.6392825245857239,
-0.2914624810218811,
-0.3826236426830292,
-0.09162081032991409,
0.38602790236473083,
-0.41576552391052246,
-0.8382449150085449,
-0.6260441541671753,
0.013367347419261932,
-0.221574068069458,
0.8626910448074341,
-0.14165019989013672,
-0.10401444882154465,
-0.8222163319587708,
-0.13913248479366302,
-0.42780858278274536,
-0.5130423903465271,
-0.2682461440563202,
-0.15491877496242523,
-0.07500319927930832,
0.7121698260307312,
0.3109362721443176,
0.806647539138794,
0.4727175831794739,
0.2215525060892105,
-0.02562793903052807,
0.23905445635318756,
-0.8318151831626892,
0.5566393733024597,
-0.0001599962852196768,
-0.3483428955078125,
-0.7386879920959473,
-0.13115067780017853,
0.31967973709106445,
0.34853118658065796,
-0.3029186427593231,
0.26527395844459534,
0.13434265553951263,
0.8462349772453308,
-0.47375431656837463,
-0.11099866777658463,
-1.0945889949798584,
0.04558403789997101,
-0.07005950808525085,
-0.5492632985115051,
-0.10488878935575485,
-0.6309961080551147,
-0.3539116084575653,
-0.3521995544433594,
0.18187269568443298,
0.1278766244649887,
0.4983759820461273,
0.35542023181915283,
-0.0846351906657219,
-0.3685983121395111,
-0.5221589207649231,
0.6202836632728577,
-0.23652026057243347,
0.4858550727367401,
0.09497176855802536,
0.41836974024772644,
-0.2237313985824585,
-0.7198801636695862,
-0.1441892832517624,
-0.4442328214645386,
0.8720801472663879,
0.19842351973056793,
0.02637648396193981,
-0.17420616745948792,
0.09330013394355774,
0.6098456978797913,
-0.46405529975891113,
0.2024834007024765,
-0.37997227907180786,
-0.11840850114822388,
0.6866985559463501,
0.11866769939661026,
0.24212777614593506,
0.31952419877052307,
-0.3747609853744507,
-0.28577640652656555,
-1.2235174179077148,
-0.060554176568984985,
0.5196477174758911,
-0.20672746002674103,
0.321762353181839,
0.40574491024017334,
0.03797389566898346,
0.38007184863090515,
-0.06275608390569687,
0.11254461854696274,
0.25113874673843384,
-0.25573229789733887,
-0.15612775087356567,
0.1172000840306282,
0.4413028955459595,
0.650062084197998,
0.23119540512561798,
-0.09030195325613022,
-0.24549247324466705,
-0.091787189245224,
0.5341542363166809,
-0.6294524669647217,
-0.46578356623649597,
0.353731632232666,
-0.1188528761267662,
-0.491469144821167,
-0.06869152933359146,
-0.8459255695343018,
-0.25768861174583435,
0.04380594566464424,
0.14334933459758759,
-0.09926114231348038,
-0.15660084784030914,
-0.25215578079223633,
0.003734070109203458,
0.4057070016860962,
0.2752031087875366,
-0.7598608732223511,
0.168960303068161,
0.9796634316444397,
0.6218289136886597,
-0.5101383924484253,
-0.3350014388561249,
-0.5922385454177856,
-0.1843508929014206,
-0.7666418552398682,
0.75188148021698,
-0.5876418948173523,
-0.6658052802085876,
0.09904608130455017,
-0.2563196122646332,
0.2961110472679138,
-1.0455011129379272,
0.240156888961792,
-0.29004958271980286,
-0.43508923053741455,
-0.10441472381353378,
-0.7106824517250061,
0.5397934913635254,
0.2289322316646576,
-0.37718576192855835,
1.2387040853500366,
0.04715338721871376,
-0.12230324745178223,
0.39171379804611206,
-0.07152397185564041,
-0.29720914363861084,
0.18368059396743774,
-0.4755535125732422,
-0.6001325845718384,
0.2204917073249817,
0.21246059238910675,
0.1810455173254013,
-0.40970805287361145,
0.1435338407754898,
-0.13954199850559235,
-0.195168599486351,
0.22815538942813873,
-0.10798358917236328,
0.16882728040218353,
0.22676657140254974,
-0.44415122270584106,
0.03496503457427025,
-0.8992234468460083,
0.41344907879829407,
0.011422514915466309,
-0.4829846918582916,
-0.0028252541087567806,
0.046297457069158554,
-0.3585236668586731,
0.0485130175948143,
0.25017496943473816,
-0.45693713426589966,
0.2264026552438736,
-0.003488699207082391,
0.38467299938201904,
1.0131235122680664,
0.28996822237968445,
-0.00009232023876393214,
-0.421884149312973,
0.7733265161514282,
-0.3295702338218689,
0.26051175594329834,
-0.09767724573612213,
-0.8608019948005676,
-0.5856411457061768,
0.09187949448823929,
0.05144995078444481,
0.6117956638336182,
-0.516752302646637,
0.6222256422042847,
-0.12875314056873322,
-0.6389145851135254,
-0.6829221844673157,
0.5085251927375793,
0.4176311492919922,
0.21774232387542725,
0.42848554253578186,
-0.3627975285053253,
-0.5095324516296387,
-0.6601164937019348,
-0.3197357654571533,
-0.5314262509346008,
-0.07091828435659409,
0.16001473367214203,
0.30977389216423035,
-0.1000758558511734,
0.3950200378894806,
-0.30060508847236633,
0.0951395332813263,
-0.3382732570171356,
-0.18656079471111298,
0.21536597609519958,
0.5309450626373291,
0.26882654428482056,
-0.3008764088153839,
-0.5385972261428833,
0.1481838822364807,
-0.5411196947097778,
-0.3059487044811249,
-0.23092931509017944,
-0.5574593544006348,
-0.14455139636993408,
0.7132496237754822,
-0.08163079619407654,
0.02030818723142147,
0.6559451222419739,
0.009735845029354095,
0.5464914441108704,
-0.35305479168891907,
0.169435515999794,
-0.690109133720398,
-0.016597241163253784,
-0.15191274881362915,
-0.14827482402324677,
-0.454645037651062,
0.3839322626590729,
0.06580789387226105,
0.044666144996881485,
-0.2553442716598511,
0.03983248397707939,
-0.396770179271698,
-0.25477883219718933,
-0.032680124044418335,
-0.052191779017448425,
-0.058957405388355255,
0.30016931891441345,
-0.26563704013824463,
0.9119570851325989,
0.6981094479560852,
-0.5509416460990906,
0.5008825659751892,
0.11328846961259842,
-0.4744429886341095,
0.4636684060096741,
-0.6925354599952698,
0.4388410151004791,
0.2067662924528122,
-0.2999536693096161,
-0.9148452877998352,
0.0009551781113259494,
-0.0959763452410698,
-0.38280555605888367,
0.40136122703552246,
-0.09124889224767685,
-0.2847142517566681,
-0.33246901631355286,
-0.6722802519798279,
-0.014129780232906342,
1.0221391916275024,
-0.6274301409721375,
-0.06667257845401764,
0.3969992995262146,
-0.2893771529197693,
-0.34116944670677185,
-0.7039616703987122,
0.16866646707057953,
0.05678127333521843,
-0.479547917842865,
0.5625250339508057,
-0.6249814629554749,
-0.12218976020812988,
-0.21314787864685059,
-0.5350713729858398,
0.10363899171352386,
0.0846613422036171,
0.1553463488817215,
0.25090447068214417,
0.01884516328573227,
0.04939588904380798,
0.262163907289505,
0.00029627681942656636,
0.20349793136119843,
-0.2472018450498581,
0.1147930920124054,
-0.2955613434314728,
-0.5147213339805603,
0.10439606010913849,
0.08865543454885483,
0.7989134788513184,
-0.032499246299266815,
0.27470287680625916,
0.020971553400158882,
-0.004136762116104364,
-0.772067666053772,
-0.5112766027450562,
0.14198750257492065,
-0.4630592465400696,
0.4044565260410309,
-0.4427235722541809,
-0.7376112341880798,
0.4256976544857025,
-0.44660645723342896,
0.2720605432987213,
0.349176287651062,
0.6035605072975159,
0.07086172699928284,
0.6696072220802307,
0.541366696357727,
0.2738375663757324,
0.30860069394111633,
-0.19553224742412567,
-0.0686219185590744,
-0.9872128963470459,
-0.6037014722824097,
-0.4177495837211609,
-0.2168978452682495,
-0.8683473467826843,
-0.3949567377567291,
0.6018565893173218,
0.25729426741600037,
-0.034645408391952515,
0.33742162585258484,
-0.9985296130180359,
0.6768227815628052,
0.3244120478630066,
0.10229389369487762,
0.2820039391517639,
0.23035882413387299,
-0.35708141326904297,
-0.07498377561569214,
-0.8004279732704163,
-0.3201697766780853,
1.3909603357315063,
0.363269567489624,
0.8826776742935181,
-0.06841149181127548,
0.9762758016586304,
0.5507195591926575,
0.2152767777442932,
-0.4824642241001129,
0.7277179956436157,
0.09882619976997375,
-0.08025795221328735,
-0.12147322297096252,
-0.4364505708217621,
-0.7867173552513123,
0.13375858962535858,
0.005376609042286873,
-0.3104299306869507,
0.14896206557750702,
0.16076940298080444,
-0.1922122687101364,
0.2732475996017456,
-0.2967422306537628,
0.770112931728363,
-0.44623586535453796,
-0.6815159916877747,
-0.11207715421915054,
-0.2556658983230591,
-0.01707860454916954,
-0.23311449587345123,
0.14090219140052795,
-0.1602054387331009,
-0.29519718885421753,
0.5017272233963013,
-0.7100892066955566,
0.3940790295600891,
0.23099204897880554,
-0.14360958337783813,
0.5375415682792664,
0.16632014513015747,
0.4726805090904236,
0.08730153739452362,
-0.17938244342803955,
0.19557835161685944,
-0.3478020429611206,
-0.29261869192123413,
-0.33476218581199646,
0.9863767027854919,
-0.8953641653060913,
-0.6741399765014648,
-0.18184421956539154,
0.12149091064929962,
-0.24211466312408447,
-0.20251250267028809,
0.5431404709815979,
0.4822763204574585,
-0.2521229088306427,
0.2066727578639984,
0.8424261212348938,
-0.380239337682724,
0.13695187866687775,
-0.028723666444420815,
-0.08870219439268112,
-0.8739812970161438,
1.0136936902999878,
0.046546436846256256,
0.31801512837409973,
0.2841138243675232,
0.0362132303416729,
-0.016329096630215645,
-0.9625774025917053,
-0.5294765830039978,
-0.05288206413388252,
-0.9826691746711731,
-0.2023908942937851,
-0.21811360120773315,
-0.28674519062042236,
-0.12914779782295227,
-0.41828253865242004,
-0.5186167359352112,
-0.44242897629737854,
0.07391613721847534,
-0.41313260793685913,
0.3123074769973755,
0.9237323999404907,
-0.11259254813194275,
-0.4631805717945099,
-0.7325351238250732,
-0.006897135637700558,
0.5857602953910828,
0.41873183846473694,
-0.07768377661705017,
-0.33206331729888916,
-0.25756847858428955,
-0.4785662889480591,
-0.4246133863925934,
-0.8898419737815857,
0.18469423055648804,
0.3235073387622833,
1.0071526765823364,
-0.15431548655033112,
-0.07602891325950623,
0.3669147491455078,
-0.5000613927841187,
1.0166819095611572,
0.25223034620285034,
-0.8517045378684998,
0.8905953168869019,
0.025800619274377823,
0.36021876335144043,
0.7785654664039612,
0.24950556457042694,
-0.24721065163612366,
-0.6318402290344238,
-0.6170640587806702,
-0.973792552947998,
0.3029094338417053,
0.381797194480896,
-0.0723632350564003,
-0.2281063348054886,
0.33621224761009216,
0.51319420337677,
0.5818570852279663,
-0.16783492267131805,
-0.19942940771579742,
-0.2526981234550476,
-0.007625469472259283,
0.1987920105457306,
-0.12845607101917267,
0.09178674966096878,
-0.2809309661388397,
0.5660243630409241,
0.07937085628509521,
0.5313785076141357,
0.16426482796669006,
-0.14377672970294952,
-0.3752022385597229,
0.32734599709510803,
0.6010408401489258,
1.0637115240097046,
-0.12548895180225372,
0.11847767233848572,
0.19211333990097046,
-0.551516592502594,
0.048628296703100204,
-0.28682732582092285,
0.08073294907808304,
-0.13698190450668335,
0.49823883175849915,
0.6629151105880737,
0.08973560482263565,
-0.8012596368789673,
0.44944262504577637,
0.25195205211639404,
-0.24434351921081543,
-0.12524551153182983,
0.42546573281288147,
-0.127017080783844,
-0.010257765650749207,
0.5241906642913818,
0.09599719196557999,
-0.120272696018219,
-0.7544183731079102,
0.40621328353881836,
0.033715613186359406,
-0.08648203313350677,
-0.34656739234924316,
0.9413102865219116,
0.5218391418457031,
-0.30478793382644653,
0.5924349427223206,
-0.27673688530921936,
-0.5827376246452332,
1.1340399980545044,
0.22532381117343903,
1.1507922410964966,
-0.40105241537094116,
0.14005392789840698,
0.4282854199409485,
0.40861594676971436,
0.038640689104795456,
0.38618433475494385,
-0.15146365761756897,
-0.3133098781108856,
-0.1924583613872528,
-0.5152311325073242,
-0.7579165697097778,
-0.011299907229840755,
-0.5558604001998901,
0.14846977591514587,
-0.7066690325737,
-0.1448068469762802,
-0.325592577457428,
-0.21254423260688782,
-0.6654978394508362,
-0.12765996158123016,
0.27767714858055115,
0.8174801468849182,
-0.45409640669822693,
0.6826028227806091,
0.9355262517929077,
-0.15945880115032196,
-0.15543629229068756,
-0.10169021040201187,
-0.13543280959129333,
-0.8353452682495117,
0.29481935501098633,
0.0037479496095329523,
-0.00765442568808794,
0.07080142945051193,
-0.6415851712226868,
-0.47079259157180786,
1.2327929735183716,
0.18139144778251648,
-0.8247945308685303,
0.2797790467739105,
0.12363927811384201,
0.5755614638328552,
-0.6133221387863159,
0.3201729357242584,
0.4992484748363495,
0.10234586894512177,
0.33810171484947205,
-0.8167945742607117,
0.02848244644701481,
-0.40238749980926514,
0.3294680118560791,
0.09445766359567642,
-0.6580963730812073,
0.7542843222618103,
-0.3421943485736847,
-0.018218329176306725,
0.05086228996515274,
0.258037269115448,
0.4861030578613281,
0.3784353733062744,
-0.012632465921342373,
0.432757705450058,
0.8655215501785278,
-0.09793353825807571,
1.031663179397583,
-0.7022689580917358,
0.2562825679779053,
0.7656140923500061,
-0.42412975430488586,
0.930110514163971,
0.1718614250421524,
-0.31180742383003235,
0.6101517081260681,
0.6567794680595398,
-0.2368927001953125,
0.7175111770629883,
0.40474095940589905,
-0.11250192672014236,
-0.48863083124160767,
0.28686678409576416,
-0.6316851377487183,
-0.14406485855579376,
0.3646872639656067,
-0.2877453565597534,
-0.09389009326696396,
-0.08324724435806274,
-0.058453306555747986,
0.08069951087236404,
-0.377786785364151,
0.6695416569709778,
0.11549048125743866,
-0.7687614560127258,
0.8391883373260498,
-0.24096687138080597,
0.3783286213874817,
-0.6306055784225464,
-0.2755061686038971,
-0.3902018964290619,
0.12407144904136658,
-0.16717594861984253,
-0.9588965177536011,
-0.10172178596258163,
0.09794111549854279,
0.3928966820240021,
-0.4837441146373749,
0.6343718767166138,
-0.4816964864730835,
-0.16699498891830444,
0.15283270180225372,
0.6889621019363403,
0.3266143500804901,
0.2869318425655365,
-0.6311479806900024,
0.6071270704269409,
0.12659239768981934,
-0.196349635720253,
0.44728535413742065,
0.22779688239097595,
0.2638820707798004,
0.6301319599151611,
0.5778929591178894,
0.3036045730113983,
0.3194807469844818,
-0.08072584867477417,
0.960953950881958,
-0.5130797624588013,
-0.4912952184677124,
-0.7087891101837158,
0.23566153645515442,
-0.14925193786621094,
-0.5593323111534119,
0.630462646484375,
0.5323479175567627,
0.9775524139404297,
-0.022334879264235497,
0.9263731241226196,
0.15598492324352264,
-0.10352849960327148,
-0.5949659943580627,
0.48430734872817993,
-0.44029948115348816,
0.6035322546958923,
-0.06437063217163086,
-1.4057133197784424,
-0.0367240272462368,
0.3540874719619751,
-0.07987385988235474,
0.12455607205629349,
0.7672638893127441,
0.5838493704795837,
0.3790494203567505,
-0.23561614751815796,
0.5412358641624451,
0.101018987596035,
0.462506502866745,
0.857715368270874,
0.8487547039985657,
-0.2731688320636749,
0.7629208564758301,
-0.06362088024616241,
-0.3895713984966278,
-0.4242406189441681,
-0.8251041173934937,
-0.7742571830749512,
-0.22646476328372955,
-0.9032630920410156,
-0.24843432009220123,
0.5496485829353333,
1.0671814680099487,
0.4781700074672699,
-0.7429829835891724,
-0.2389853447675705,
-0.5135717391967773,
0.1665501594543457,
-0.5370131134986877,
-0.1385493278503418,
0.14891766011714935,
-0.2745267450809479,
-0.5530835390090942,
0.6632979512214661,
0.32552269101142883,
0.002820781199261546,
-0.2773212194442749,
-0.4015621244907379,
0.33044788241386414,
0.14974795281887054,
0.5379951000213623,
0.4733861982822418,
-0.37081554532051086,
-0.23809325695037842,
0.12545177340507507,
-0.11109663546085358,
0.3532586395740509,
0.7603902816772461,
-0.642661452293396,
0.8079380989074707,
0.7212036848068237,
0.7739085555076599,
0.40640562772750854,
0.013877158984541893,
0.417229026556015,
-0.7269942164421082,
-0.43788450956344604,
0.1624065339565277,
0.11036920547485352,
0.3770688772201538,
-0.46141737699508667,
0.6530646681785583,
0.3227987289428711,
-0.8929181098937988,
-0.7893385291099548,
0.13903753459453583,
-0.7149035334587097,
-0.10736034065485,
1.0862706899642944,
0.14277562499046326,
-0.2453896552324295,
0.09002937376499176,
0.24308304488658905,
-0.10919875651597977,
-0.5363422632217407,
0.6205138564109802,
0.6378235816955566,
-0.45244553685188293,
-0.23167304694652557,
-0.8270180821418762,
0.44610026478767395,
0.1744476556777954,
-0.8994367122650146,
-0.02173621766269207,
0.4269219934940338,
0.3069639801979065,
-0.06540079414844513,
0.5045630931854248,
-0.16749514639377594,
0.43743932247161865,
0.3811839520931244,
0.21746085584163666,
-0.4676898717880249,
-0.49077993631362915,
-0.21235530078411102,
0.2786513566970825,
0.504507839679718,
-0.230864480137825
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19113v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19113v1
|
FACTOID: FACtual enTailment fOr hallucInation Detection
| 2024-03-28T03:09:42 | 2024-03-28T03:09:42 |
Vipula Rawte, S. M Towhidul Islam Tonmoy, Krishnav Rajbangshi, Shravani Nag, Aman Chadha, Amit P. Sheth, Amitava Das
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The widespread adoption of Large Language Models (LLMs) has facilitated
numerous benefits. However, hallucination is a significant concern. In
response, Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) has emerged as a highly
promising paradigm to improve LLM outputs by grounding them in factual
information. RAG relies on textual entailment (TE) or similar methods to check
if the text produced by LLMs is supported or contradicted, compared to
retrieved documents. This paper argues that conventional TE methods are
inadequate for spotting hallucinations in content generated by LLMs. For
instance, consider a prompt about the 'USA's stance on the Ukraine war''. The
AI-generated text states, ...U.S. President Barack Obama says the U.S. will not
put troops in Ukraine...'' However, during the war the U.S. president is Joe
Biden which contradicts factual reality. Moreover, current TE systems are
unable to accurately annotate the given text and identify the exact portion
that is contradicted. To address this, we introduces a new type of TE called
``Factual Entailment (FE).'', aims to detect factual inaccuracies in content
generated by LLMs while also highlighting the specific text segment that
contradicts reality. We present FACTOID (FACTual enTAILment for hallucInation
Detection), a benchmark dataset for FE. We propose a multi-task learning (MTL)
framework for FE, incorporating state-of-the-art (SoTA) long text embeddings
such as e5-mistral-7b-instruct, along with GPT-3, SpanBERT, and RoFormer. The
proposed MTL architecture for FE achieves an avg. 40\% improvement in accuracy
on the FACTOID benchmark compared to SoTA TE methods. As FE automatically
detects hallucinations, we assessed 15 modern LLMs and ranked them using our
proposed Auto Hallucination Vulnerability Index (HVI_auto). This index
quantifies and offers a comparative scale to evaluate and rank LLMs according
to their hallucinations.
|
[
-0.3630152940750122,
-1.1903423070907593,
0.9457119107246399,
0.2626752257347107,
-0.2751829922199249,
-0.06118675693869591,
-0.1783493608236313,
-0.5515429377555847,
0.3824179172515869,
0.8481957316398621,
-0.4159315526485443,
-0.7115159630775452,
-0.5713717341423035,
0.36221152544021606,
-0.4786587059497833,
0.8688493371009827,
-0.11800225079059601,
-0.3074537217617035,
-0.5718242526054382,
0.03532233089208603,
-0.4759663939476013,
-0.565450131893158,
-0.3164219856262207,
-0.1624068319797516,
0.2743651866912842,
0.281705766916275,
0.48446810245513916,
0.48814132809638977,
0.4528878629207611,
0.3549909293651581,
0.03340497985482216,
0.8328779339790344,
-0.36078134179115295,
0.418388307094574,
-0.09699316322803497,
-0.31766998767852783,
-0.4637639820575714,
-0.0675588846206665,
0.31232133507728577,
0.380626380443573,
-0.027106354013085365,
0.07099314033985138,
0.06263527274131775,
0.6424604654312134,
-0.7582324743270874,
-0.1574702262878418,
-0.8759862184524536,
0.10896920412778854,
-0.24770641326904297,
-0.593654453754425,
-0.6501238942146301,
-0.41802534461021423,
-0.057321857661008835,
-0.5451916456222534,
0.5336935520172119,
0.5107606053352356,
0.944141685962677,
0.8047064542770386,
-0.2502640187740326,
-0.6480422616004944,
-0.5848684906959534,
0.6122068762779236,
-0.5374728441238403,
0.6739405393600464,
0.6631042957305908,
-0.058718446642160416,
-0.31368350982666016,
-0.47224462032318115,
-0.9172683358192444,
-0.5416637659072876,
-0.23005764186382294,
0.13276569545269012,
0.15114936232566833,
0.07179973274469376,
0.4603647291660309,
0.3994545340538025,
-0.6881645321846008,
-0.2094326764345169,
-0.11634013056755066,
-0.33585402369499207,
0.3917962908744812,
0.14093835651874542,
0.2772567570209503,
-0.4011092782020569,
-0.44346100091934204,
0.1997784525156021,
-0.7065156698226929,
-0.5197442770004272,
0.3374713361263275,
0.00947608146816492,
0.021385731175541878,
0.8436117768287659,
-0.017462704330682755,
0.40567317605018616,
0.2540730834007263,
-0.23014280200004578,
0.40548840165138245,
-0.2255038022994995,
-0.2669636011123657,
0.29111817479133606,
0.5119798183441162,
0.05713413283228874,
0.11332984268665314,
-0.4704141616821289,
-0.24550794064998627,
0.27915436029434204,
0.5295348167419434,
-0.6346311569213867,
0.0051298318430781364,
0.3925867974758148,
-0.2731477916240692,
-0.15087220072746277,
0.0831667110323906,
-0.845023512840271,
-0.7986354827880859,
-0.5085261464118958,
0.6155737042427063,
-0.6749714016914368,
-0.1322285532951355,
0.2553648054599762,
-0.09479597210884094,
0.12349943071603775,
0.17152173817157745,
-0.536266028881073,
0.23516952991485596,
0.7626262307167053,
0.82753986120224,
-0.46176308393478394,
-0.32600000500679016,
-0.5624179840087891,
0.21140003204345703,
-0.5342726111412048,
0.9913667440414429,
-0.4613262712955475,
-0.25203004479408264,
0.07920323312282562,
0.2469903826713562,
0.007266653701663017,
-0.8231838941574097,
0.8462867736816406,
-0.26090195775032043,
0.20196957886219025,
-0.37743934988975525,
-0.5211370587348938,
-0.37610307335853577,
0.37441378831863403,
-0.6016699075698853,
1.1826951503753662,
-0.22393617033958435,
-0.8343763947486877,
0.3931279480457306,
-0.25618183612823486,
-0.5369852185249329,
-0.20857225358486176,
-0.3924693763256073,
-0.539070725440979,
0.031816061586141586,
0.19464175403118134,
0.5025665163993835,
-0.36675629019737244,
0.5909867882728577,
-0.13178107142448425,
-0.5109297037124634,
0.2532656490802765,
-0.47693711519241333,
0.5263064503669739,
0.12589628994464874,
-0.6550276875495911,
0.04410382732748985,
-0.7381365895271301,
-0.40506699681282043,
-0.1750420182943344,
-0.10520204156637192,
-0.38123008608818054,
0.11892958730459213,
-0.08616853505373001,
-0.04161132127046585,
0.07167090475559235,
-0.5514901876449585,
-0.29438522458076477,
-0.5386772751808167,
-0.3126419484615326,
0.5865408182144165,
0.16515034437179565,
0.1311536431312561,
-0.5740742087364197,
0.18759028613567352,
0.08885021507740021,
-0.20743794739246368,
0.025522034615278244,
-0.3323208689689636,
-0.9433013796806335,
-0.4111962616443634,
0.040180839598178864,
0.5812665820121765,
-1.093782901763916,
0.7711607217788696,
-0.18805718421936035,
-0.21707479655742645,
-0.4402146637439728,
-0.04538242146372795,
0.501095175743103,
0.5109657049179077,
0.5432900190353394,
0.30492305755615234,
-0.7523468732833862,
-0.7753747701644897,
-0.33782482147216797,
-0.16914363205432892,
-0.00894722156226635,
0.06344960629940033,
0.7122461199760437,
-0.23881369829177856,
0.6089991927146912,
-0.4197479784488678,
-0.7089807987213135,
0.010427737608551979,
0.3060653507709503,
0.023265400901436806,
0.30856141448020935,
0.28539812564849854,
-0.9177188873291016,
-0.3591920733451843,
0.008609064854681492,
-1.210435152053833,
-0.10882088541984558,
-0.2999960482120514,
-0.12521222233772278,
0.7294691801071167,
0.6311336159706116,
-0.6088729500770569,
0.5838598012924194,
0.1260344386100769,
-0.4758985638618469,
0.5690433979034424,
-0.28517070412635803,
0.4142809510231018,
-0.9234846830368042,
-0.030064763501286507,
-0.07465603202581406,
-0.022541562095284462,
-0.4550226330757141,
0.07020527124404907,
-0.022306766360998154,
0.3713012933731079,
-0.1878376454114914,
0.23447902500629425,
-0.43978551030158997,
-0.04186714440584183,
-0.3659946322441101,
0.16062846779823303,
0.06987314671278,
0.3406517505645752,
0.11441462486982346,
0.7726000547409058,
0.4492327570915222,
-0.7588819861412048,
0.27048906683921814,
0.22151105105876923,
-0.2233285754919052,
0.6073160767555237,
-0.392892450094223,
0.16080939769744873,
-0.34495875239372253,
0.06053343787789345,
-0.8457542061805725,
-0.31786245107650757,
0.3963561952114105,
-0.5248785614967346,
0.20874539017677307,
0.27545052766799927,
-0.6112009882926941,
0.010520354844629765,
-0.3488389551639557,
0.07238056510686874,
0.2824738621711731,
-0.6655488014221191,
0.8064771294593811,
0.4787518382072449,
0.29569268226623535,
-0.6081672310829163,
-0.5684372186660767,
0.21188490092754364,
-0.26948755979537964,
-0.4509105980396271,
0.5275038480758667,
-0.02425251714885235,
-0.3494560420513153,
0.06590886414051056,
-0.27839338779449463,
0.0489095114171505,
-0.14642448723316193,
0.41012445092201233,
0.3774811625480652,
-0.17267708480358124,
0.5182099342346191,
-0.002169520827010274,
0.10359391570091248,
0.24495774507522583,
0.005306350998580456,
0.5152607560157776,
-0.04912852123379707,
-0.38277363777160645,
-0.12234071642160416,
0.2627941966056824,
0.48262152075767517,
-0.08652536571025848,
0.7052651047706604,
0.7402055263519287,
-0.8306229114532471,
-0.3375507593154907,
-0.9994981288909912,
-0.18670378625392914,
-0.4578710198402405,
0.24003073573112488,
-0.554533839225769,
-0.5882008671760559,
0.3638615012168884,
-0.03822881728410721,
-0.08503993600606918,
0.4601563811302185,
0.5293132066726685,
-0.12310914695262909,
0.6859576106071472,
0.3840068280696869,
0.3461551070213318,
-0.08661877363920212,
-0.2178790122270584,
0.21406474709510803,
-0.8428163528442383,
-0.5729074478149414,
-0.4453466236591339,
0.05902569741010666,
-0.6152826547622681,
-0.5944820046424866,
0.3737744688987732,
-0.27587100863456726,
-0.014008029364049435,
0.14634892344474792,
-0.6788407564163208,
0.34055453538894653,
0.10548750311136246,
0.3083399534225464,
0.38544538617134094,
0.14558899402618408,
0.05118202045559883,
-0.16233862936496735,
-0.25689199566841125,
-0.5891069173812866,
0.9814578890800476,
0.10698654502630234,
0.639786958694458,
0.11088955402374268,
0.708199143409729,
0.5729306936264038,
0.12487633526325226,
-0.8106898069381714,
0.75934898853302,
-0.17219272255897522,
-0.6480640172958374,
-0.4242635667324066,
-0.23994721472263336,
-0.8468115925788879,
0.3912246525287628,
-0.5622915625572205,
-0.5291925668716431,
0.33787986636161804,
-0.06278472393751144,
-0.17739801108837128,
0.29248490929603577,
-0.40546977519989014,
0.4953865110874176,
-0.17594939470291138,
-0.5478052496910095,
-0.20090602338314056,
-0.16009007394313812,
0.5747340321540833,
-0.20644405484199524,
0.1539289802312851,
-0.1278000921010971,
-0.16417299211025238,
0.6669562458992004,
-0.061862923204898834,
0.6959322690963745,
0.007633580826222897,
-0.22365126013755798,
0.21350303292274475,
0.09387024492025375,
0.5390880703926086,
0.07666883617639542,
-0.037295278161764145,
-0.1098647192120552,
-0.2511349022388458,
0.0257277712225914,
-0.5196545720100403,
0.7998678684234619,
-0.39512479305267334,
-0.849753201007843,
-0.6416639685630798,
-0.5098590850830078,
-0.20225156843662262,
-0.09291666746139526,
0.5345340967178345,
0.4030602276325226,
-0.23171110451221466,
0.2982034683227539,
1.162566065788269,
-0.2772863507270813,
0.0636293962597847,
0.3068407475948334,
-0.16742652654647827,
-0.16364377737045288,
1.1997194290161133,
0.16421197354793549,
-0.28469666838645935,
0.3318995535373688,
-0.04923103749752045,
-0.45524871349334717,
-0.4890275001525879,
-0.3739977478981018,
0.45857441425323486,
-0.7353767156600952,
-0.12230495363473892,
-1.0047589540481567,
-0.2551622986793518,
-0.5358730554580688,
-0.022802118211984634,
-0.16033300757408142,
0.0157014187425375,
-0.3081801235675812,
-0.10287601500749588,
0.38822636008262634,
0.6298928260803223,
0.1032586470246315,
-0.13510370254516602,
-0.2906324863433838,
1.0097975730895996,
0.09142433851957321,
0.1864500343799591,
-0.1550900787115097,
-0.6969784498214722,
-0.10505954921245575,
-0.07676171511411667,
-0.323771595954895,
-0.9787880182266235,
0.4011729955673218,
0.12161582708358765,
0.649260938167572,
0.32322412729263306,
0.49194133281707764,
0.7364887595176697,
-0.582892656326294,
0.5383891463279724,
-0.12791045010089874,
-0.9556925892829895,
0.41310468316078186,
0.09006313979625702,
-0.19576984643936157,
0.406681090593338,
0.6728827357292175,
-0.3380756080150604,
-0.712314248085022,
-0.47492754459381104,
-0.6347099542617798,
0.5188940167427063,
0.1379397064447403,
-0.08417170494794846,
-0.25018835067749023,
0.20528224110603333,
0.4497668147087097,
0.0925210639834404,
-0.5880962014198303,
-0.2718796730041504,
-0.14365042746067047,
-0.2773718535900116,
0.2254633903503418,
-0.2943896949291229,
-0.1265469342470169,
-0.28872740268707275,
0.7194478511810303,
-0.07798830419778824,
0.45743435621261597,
0.5471800565719604,
-0.36936327815055847,
0.011849639005959034,
0.1091674417257309,
0.5035683512687683,
0.817474365234375,
-0.2945341467857361,
0.5363028645515442,
0.4196608066558838,
-0.599779486656189,
0.095296211540699,
-0.06417149305343628,
-0.16581547260284424,
0.4220660626888275,
0.40915361046791077,
0.7205873727798462,
-0.03383424133062363,
-0.6319704651832581,
0.43241867423057556,
0.3505886495113373,
-0.4703840911388397,
-0.6680207848548889,
-0.07489009946584702,
-0.15199881792068481,
0.17270313203334808,
0.3772086203098297,
-0.02390139177441597,
0.5298426151275635,
-0.721417248249054,
0.36713919043540955,
0.41295355558395386,
-0.17395319044589996,
-0.21877218782901764,
0.5919817090034485,
-0.03457820415496826,
-0.26293620467185974,
0.3555918335914612,
-0.4221786856651306,
-0.54937344789505,
0.5984473824501038,
0.6405291557312012,
1.0077158212661743,
-0.04119269177317619,
0.3638204038143158,
0.33010804653167725,
0.5955315828323364,
-0.11811106652021408,
0.49058103561401367,
0.17027191817760468,
-0.7370830178260803,
-0.41356417536735535,
-0.5670737624168396,
-0.23849211633205414,
0.3603893518447876,
-0.40015172958374023,
0.30901944637298584,
-0.2036856710910797,
-0.041253942996263504,
0.019208574667572975,
-0.21839618682861328,
-0.5294261574745178,
0.24929219484329224,
0.1504475325345993,
0.43316376209259033,
-0.7059025764465332,
0.7078038454055786,
0.49714720249176025,
-0.31192752718925476,
-0.17334507405757904,
0.5523740649223328,
-0.010465606115758419,
-0.4702443480491638,
0.5971816182136536,
0.2533257007598877,
-0.44577106833457947,
-0.16270889341831207,
-0.47692081332206726,
-0.5648273825645447,
0.8183939456939697,
0.23072344064712524,
-0.12367665022611618,
-0.1165727823972702,
0.1215142235159874,
0.42071568965911865,
-0.3151252567768097,
0.000323881657095626,
0.5685798525810242,
0.5476970076560974,
0.14467203617095947,
-0.5160536766052246,
0.5261929035186768,
0.06647254526615143,
-0.19522905349731445,
0.13275685906410217,
-0.31013223528862,
0.8045003414154053,
-0.323253870010376,
-0.6080405712127686,
-0.1488572508096695,
0.7668523192405701,
0.3961664140224457,
0.7407832741737366,
0.567023754119873,
0.5423227548599243,
0.9321650862693787,
-0.05013921856880188,
0.7778215408325195,
-0.11422394216060638,
0.020051375031471252,
1.0091657638549805,
-0.38620856404304504,
0.7924632430076599,
0.6478403210639954,
0.027927512302994728,
0.45071959495544434,
0.35772839188575745,
-0.025563286617398262,
0.3182970881462097,
0.1282602846622467,
-0.16380350291728973,
-0.3716264069080353,
-0.21123820543289185,
-0.4065389037132263,
0.37402045726776123,
0.6785240769386292,
-0.14309312403202057,
-0.057802654802799225,
0.2254990041255951,
-0.02539876289665699,
0.47179052233695984,
0.05734100565314293,
0.7930388450622559,
-0.028654463589191437,
-0.7440396547317505,
0.9325417280197144,
-0.2355724722146988,
0.9018775820732117,
-0.17260217666625977,
-0.3995310366153717,
-0.18217916786670685,
0.015801511704921722,
-0.37075525522232056,
-0.560677707195282,
0.5958917140960693,
0.12576960027217865,
-0.09661146253347397,
0.05615520104765892,
0.8080272078514099,
-0.4798480272293091,
-0.43671292066574097,
0.2546168565750122,
0.6122692227363586,
0.3661085069179535,
-0.23367834091186523,
-0.2792212963104248,
0.09600233286619186,
-0.11471874266862869,
-0.10858709365129471,
-0.03428630158305168,
0.8348395228385925,
-0.021205632016062737,
0.6042484641075134,
0.5597036480903625,
0.09322382509708405,
-0.0858793705701828,
-0.12887069582939148,
0.7096498608589172,
-0.6396954655647278,
-0.19287820160388947,
-0.8444167375564575,
0.1813269406557083,
-0.23376306891441345,
-0.14428234100341797,
0.9081629514694214,
0.7282583117485046,
0.7258197665214539,
-0.12605711817741394,
0.6840873956680298,
-0.16775093972682953,
0.6537577509880066,
-0.7770037055015564,
0.6810269355773926,
-0.7245913147926331,
0.3334503471851349,
-0.0180062223225832,
-0.8834433555603027,
-0.0955745279788971,
0.5119234919548035,
-0.29600703716278076,
-0.27603015303611755,
1.1510157585144043,
1.0130960941314697,
0.043067771941423416,
0.07770594954490662,
0.5570892095565796,
0.20603321492671967,
-0.11348482221364975,
0.16152529418468475,
0.9036240577697754,
-0.3708397150039673,
0.5203102231025696,
-0.1496518850326538,
0.041549019515514374,
-0.31325817108154297,
-0.5988887548446655,
-1.1571122407913208,
-0.8419086337089539,
-0.3478904962539673,
-0.44664210081100464,
0.3473982810974121,
0.8959246873855591,
0.28091466426849365,
-0.9086557626724243,
-0.0792325809597969,
-0.013185599818825722,
0.33077430725097656,
-0.13163211941719055,
-0.2334209680557251,
0.5783052444458008,
-0.6869549751281738,
-0.7265200018882751,
0.32066693902015686,
0.2306414693593979,
-0.08725429326295853,
-0.2515636682510376,
-0.10203704982995987,
-0.333029180765152,
0.26500579714775085,
0.6337082386016846,
-0.21184135973453522,
-1.173091173171997,
-0.44157877564430237,
0.27810728549957275,
-0.17611947655677795,
-0.028868285939097404,
0.6092230677604675,
-0.8437419533729553,
0.3681963086128235,
0.5678693652153015,
0.8642331957817078,
0.4096227288246155,
-0.15224045515060425,
0.12690599262714386,
-0.7236191034317017,
0.09390206634998322,
0.25997257232666016,
0.17476248741149902,
0.3416081964969635,
-0.6060120463371277,
0.6084845662117004,
0.3742603063583374,
-0.4424571692943573,
-1.0035693645477295,
0.0016367698553949594,
-0.8084213733673096,
-0.5111058354377747,
1.2314825057983398,
0.15406467020511627,
-0.28594374656677246,
-0.5822029709815979,
-0.3571702837944031,
0.39833053946495056,
-0.12330813705921173,
1.1171207427978516,
0.6868650913238525,
0.045609068125486374,
0.012222393415868282,
-0.7764224410057068,
0.8028208017349243,
0.3425264060497284,
-0.9351425766944885,
0.1918458342552185,
0.5415771007537842,
-0.15340963006019592,
0.41340750455856323,
0.3555079400539398,
0.05937494710087776,
0.2106928676366806,
0.1512189507484436,
0.2113204151391983,
-0.16031095385551453,
-0.561148464679718,
0.07926104962825775,
0.06721334159374237,
-0.31965312361717224,
-0.38616782426834106
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17605v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17605v1
|
NativE: Multi-modal Knowledge Graph Completion in the Wild
| 2024-03-28T03:04:00 | 2024-03-28T03:04:00 |
Yichi Zhang, Zhuo Chen, Lingbing Guo, Yajing Xu, Binbin Hu, Ziqi Liu, Wen Zhang, Huajun Chen
|
cs.MM
|
cs.MM, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.IR
|
Multi-modal knowledge graph completion (MMKGC) aims to automatically discover
the unobserved factual knowledge from a given multi-modal knowledge graph by
collaboratively modeling the triple structure and multi-modal information from
entities. However, real-world MMKGs present challenges due to their diverse and
imbalanced nature, which means that the modality information can span various
types (e.g., image, text, numeric, audio, video) but its distribution among
entities is uneven, leading to missing modalities for certain entities.
Existing works usually focus on common modalities like image and text while
neglecting the imbalanced distribution phenomenon of modal information. To
address these issues, we propose a comprehensive framework NativE to achieve
MMKGC in the wild. NativE proposes a relation-guided dual adaptive fusion
module that enables adaptive fusion for any modalities and employs a
collaborative modality adversarial training framework to augment the imbalanced
modality information. We construct a new benchmark called WildKGC with five
datasets to evaluate our method. The empirical results compared with 21 recent
baselines confirm the superiority of our method, consistently achieving
state-of-the-art performance across different datasets and various scenarios
while keeping efficient and generalizable. Our code and data are released at
https://github.com/zjukg/NATIVE
|
[
-0.36355069279670715,
-0.7756299376487732,
0.16133514046669006,
-0.1401359736919403,
-0.3168981671333313,
0.5910655856132507,
-0.3365381062030792,
-0.5225649476051331,
0.3244611918926239,
0.049906983971595764,
-0.6958757638931274,
-0.6721754670143127,
-0.30392247438430786,
0.08021175116300583,
0.4231206476688385,
0.6623266935348511,
0.015770135447382927,
-0.16293588280677795,
-0.3491644859313965,
-0.555309534072876,
-0.6304076910018921,
-0.13034659624099731,
-0.049459636211395264,
-0.45897507667541504,
0.42271241545677185,
0.4687938094139099,
0.8452292680740356,
0.47355878353118896,
0.14855961501598358,
0.23077650368213654,
0.09917476773262024,
0.7501209378242493,
-0.5566235780715942,
0.09365634620189667,
0.2272922396659851,
-0.13125482201576233,
-0.4589764475822449,
0.03880530595779419,
0.6330983638763428,
0.8150712847709656,
-0.0827767550945282,
-0.06972698867321014,
-0.16853317618370056,
0.5171954035758972,
-0.8498387336730957,
0.3556782901287079,
-0.7167707085609436,
0.18657605350017548,
-0.09483979642391205,
0.05444828420877457,
-0.31619763374328613,
-0.15778936445713043,
0.23205943405628204,
-1.0049978494644165,
0.19757969677448273,
-0.03269326314330101,
0.6157070994377136,
0.26371708512306213,
-1.2305009365081787,
0.11821296811103821,
-0.6807422041893005,
0.4164319932460785,
-0.43716704845428467,
0.6195037364959717,
0.3877500295639038,
0.5670549273490906,
-0.1905449628829956,
-0.596157431602478,
-0.5893644690513611,
-0.2330586463212967,
-0.40688687562942505,
0.5773919224739075,
0.017399108037352562,
0.33401328325271606,
0.12475613504648209,
0.6320078372955322,
-0.7689495086669922,
-0.003799751168116927,
-0.32478025555610657,
-0.7920610904693604,
0.51465904712677,
0.1410127878189087,
0.05793368071317673,
-0.48773518204689026,
-0.563486635684967,
0.10905705392360687,
-0.4916723370552063,
0.13108830153942108,
0.26428353786468506,
0.2864486277103424,
-0.38560572266578674,
0.5800383687019348,
-0.7010691165924072,
1.1380332708358765,
-0.19746777415275574,
-0.3702608346939087,
0.6014512181282043,
-0.8262723088264465,
-0.1306733936071396,
-0.1647687405347824,
0.9313300848007202,
0.43348535895347595,
-0.3588760197162628,
-0.2616894543170929,
0.22310946881771088,
0.14691665768623352,
-0.011799904517829418,
-0.3412848711013794,
-0.377789169549942,
-0.12676724791526794,
-0.3945067524909973,
-0.1717313677072525,
-0.132692351937294,
-0.776846706867218,
-0.5739996433258057,
-0.3482512831687927,
0.47350701689720154,
-0.509549081325531,
-0.5598187446594238,
-0.1000094935297966,
-0.06093032658100128,
-0.05842865630984306,
0.30848070979118347,
-0.7315323352813721,
-0.15567466616630554,
0.3397846221923828,
0.9666726589202881,
0.10539048910140991,
-0.2297191172838211,
-0.3193766176700592,
0.4626868963241577,
0.07038029283285141,
0.5818900465965271,
-0.4992372989654541,
-0.4124857485294342,
-0.23395992815494537,
-0.06294144690036774,
-0.4150862693786621,
-0.2785114347934723,
0.7398667931556702,
-0.4101117253303528,
0.051183875650167465,
-0.5154973864555359,
-0.30155596137046814,
-0.5992137789726257,
0.6081073880195618,
-0.7702746391296387,
0.931108295917511,
-0.010108682326972485,
-0.743798017501831,
0.7390351891517639,
-0.4671403467655182,
-0.5188072323799133,
0.1352851688861847,
-0.23942525684833527,
-0.17785488069057465,
-0.15527237951755524,
0.19711123406887054,
0.5355890989303589,
-0.12108568847179413,
0.07861354947090149,
-0.568403959274292,
-0.13779981434345245,
-0.18592189252376556,
-0.25594785809516907,
0.3569619357585907,
0.2950859069824219,
-0.014646600000560284,
0.1816985160112381,
-1.0318992137908936,
-0.19598257541656494,
-0.10733026266098022,
-0.40604496002197266,
-0.5354788303375244,
0.03891150653362274,
-0.09346556663513184,
0.31106260418891907,
0.20970191061496735,
-0.6538770794868469,
0.5122172236442566,
-0.20748820900917053,
0.25516101717948914,
0.5956963300704956,
-0.004307450260967016,
0.5363686680793762,
-0.23440445959568024,
0.2986193895339966,
0.003342929994687438,
0.2767421007156372,
-0.28113946318626404,
-0.6730846166610718,
-0.26277846097946167,
-0.5677304863929749,
0.23072470724582672,
0.4198148548603058,
-1.054938793182373,
0.3535225987434387,
-0.42781370878219604,
-0.5985708236694336,
-0.3450826108455658,
0.21279136836528778,
0.22423599660396576,
0.8917106986045837,
0.23407083749771118,
-0.40013355016708374,
-0.5765402317047119,
-0.8343138098716736,
0.17781862616539001,
-0.1642056554555893,
0.005975382402539253,
0.7402580380439758,
0.1132744550704956,
-0.38022008538246155,
1.0974937677383423,
-0.520957887172699,
-0.6306204795837402,
0.14623256027698517,
0.35997843742370605,
-0.13369758427143097,
0.35247549414634705,
0.4819980561733246,
-1.179930329322815,
-0.3725016415119171,
0.2973121106624603,
-0.9698226451873779,
0.23809882998466492,
0.0314147062599659,
-0.20596922934055328,
0.011649259366095066,
0.21359997987747192,
-0.5167208909988403,
0.15755118429660797,
0.7749305963516235,
-0.38724833726882935,
0.5062728524208069,
-0.17105111479759216,
0.42094913125038147,
-1.2418268918991089,
0.294677734375,
-0.20356017351150513,
-0.13559043407440186,
-0.44748228788375854,
0.15293560922145844,
0.13100142776966095,
-0.057153865694999695,
-0.045321766287088394,
0.3139953315258026,
-0.3146424889564514,
0.21432697772979736,
0.016076259315013885,
0.05005110800266266,
-0.07536336779594421,
0.633787214756012,
-0.12700499594211578,
0.34120243787765503,
0.5272994041442871,
-0.5037726759910583,
0.8158597946166992,
0.10657147318124771,
0.003680532332509756,
0.5614871382713318,
-0.1834501028060913,
-0.10016366094350815,
-0.04422733560204506,
0.559476375579834,
-1.0338265895843506,
-0.5212098956108093,
0.35956045985221863,
-0.5143604278564453,
0.2949051558971405,
-0.5605520009994507,
-0.5540738701820374,
-0.4828847348690033,
-0.052096884697675705,
0.5149411559104919,
0.25787553191185,
-0.34894540905952454,
1.1476054191589355,
0.2495550662279129,
0.49751585721969604,
-0.7161538004875183,
-0.39047306776046753,
0.07024098932743073,
0.19168376922607422,
-0.9591835737228394,
0.38098201155662537,
-0.1983160823583603,
0.16697898507118225,
0.1302785873413086,
-0.2780349552631378,
0.06746234744787216,
-0.003892939304932952,
0.40012142062187195,
0.19066110253334045,
-0.16749973595142365,
0.19316014647483826,
0.006287802010774612,
-0.07661471515893936,
-0.35041671991348267,
-0.3322811722755432,
0.26762819290161133,
-0.1234491840004921,
-0.499577134847641,
0.011660723946988583,
0.14040835201740265,
0.8395236134529114,
-0.46205610036849976,
0.6575584411621094,
0.8978281617164612,
-0.6151620149612427,
0.27943944931030273,
-0.6539252400398254,
-0.12681514024734497,
-0.4406076967716217,
0.2670324444770813,
-0.3262270390987396,
-0.8461239337921143,
0.8200230002403259,
-0.1985357105731964,
0.266889363527298,
0.23812876641750336,
0.4475492238998413,
0.3390331566333771,
1.195349931716919,
0.6261035799980164,
-0.07872352749109268,
0.1305791735649109,
-0.2922411561012268,
0.09004653245210648,
-0.6483484506607056,
-0.827879786491394,
0.012615249492228031,
-0.5361778140068054,
-0.4126335382461548,
-0.368191659450531,
0.7255834937095642,
0.1043066531419754,
0.25188663601875305,
0.14443260431289673,
-0.4799175262451172,
0.3947402238845825,
0.5964435338973999,
0.4285582900047302,
0.7154089212417603,
-0.15884952247142792,
-0.6224403977394104,
-0.20552651584148407,
-0.7573529481887817,
0.06522051990032196,
1.1458345651626587,
-0.07537464052438736,
0.5983425974845886,
0.2792632281780243,
0.3636266589164734,
0.12450804561376572,
0.346343994140625,
-0.9638230204582214,
0.26966211199760437,
-0.05105375498533249,
-0.7228410243988037,
0.055060822516679764,
-0.7104550004005432,
-0.7303246259689331,
0.3751367926597595,
-0.6597222089767456,
-0.40117114782333374,
-0.02964061126112938,
0.4320446252822876,
-0.4166359305381775,
0.4534500241279602,
-0.8675759434700012,
0.9791938662528992,
0.026652054861187935,
-0.2526126801967621,
-0.331925630569458,
-0.986142098903656,
1.0212870836257935,
-0.1447231024503708,
0.3400260806083679,
-0.19526307284832,
-0.025668075308203697,
0.5768617391586304,
-0.23249712586402893,
0.7723621129989624,
-0.28779375553131104,
0.2818962633609772,
0.21865227818489075,
0.05455111339688301,
0.3483378291130066,
0.35808995366096497,
0.125339537858963,
-0.1428156942129135,
-0.12765498459339142,
-0.43290770053863525,
-0.653079628944397,
0.7884381413459778,
-0.8640007376670837,
-0.08322912454605103,
-0.23353543877601624,
-0.8912860751152039,
-0.5142350196838379,
0.33340147137641907,
0.18750494718551636,
0.4465735852718353,
-0.255288690328598,
0.26463645696640015,
0.6242370009422302,
-0.03024212084710598,
0.3007199168205261,
0.7458239197731018,
0.15026293694972992,
-0.642081081867218,
0.8391954898834229,
0.11501869559288025,
0.3110828995704651,
0.3487067222595215,
0.24390967190265656,
-0.31583166122436523,
-0.3733176589012146,
-0.7433410286903381,
0.02628082036972046,
-0.6621954441070557,
-0.4099612236022949,
-0.8452593088150024,
0.01466241106390953,
-0.39272797107696533,
-0.11613915115594864,
-0.3020869493484497,
-0.2001136839389801,
-0.05345746874809265,
-0.11601992696523666,
0.6198113560676575,
0.47681063413619995,
-0.39712217450141907,
0.1841515451669693,
-0.8512597680091858,
0.4914589822292328,
0.6708149909973145,
0.4604579210281372,
0.07884997129440308,
-0.10281253606081009,
-0.15979579091072083,
0.41696858406066895,
-0.28745606541633606,
-0.7795900702476501,
-0.047661662101745605,
0.29179051518440247,
0.7088459730148315,
0.5057046413421631,
0.28676164150238037,
0.6972357034683228,
-0.11092663556337357,
0.6646268963813782,
0.4368802011013031,
-0.4364932179450989,
0.4137263000011444,
-0.6444557905197144,
0.46776604652404785,
0.677450954914093,
0.4507497251033783,
-0.8056498765945435,
-0.18132978677749634,
-0.41375845670700073,
-0.8104682564735413,
0.4959125518798828,
-0.03893398493528366,
-0.037764519453048706,
0.3586505949497223,
0.14761100709438324,
0.18693754076957703,
0.055537715554237366,
-0.7313469052314758,
-0.38172316551208496,
-0.48400354385375977,
-0.22342492640018463,
-0.03766615688800812,
0.11884813010692596,
-0.4329086244106293,
-0.26561281085014343,
0.4850751757621765,
-0.5335764288902283,
-0.06193392351269722,
0.06385211646556854,
-0.19094513356685638,
-0.2466137409210205,
-0.0833413228392601,
0.5887908339500427,
0.5167102217674255,
-0.39374104142189026,
0.2235993593931198,
0.13581542670726776,
-0.704521656036377,
-0.015254697762429714,
0.46504902839660645,
-0.21892111003398895,
-0.06492044031620026,
0.16488038003444672,
0.49295422434806824,
0.4176749587059021,
-0.5856656432151794,
0.49220654368400574,
-0.025466613471508026,
-0.2628898620605469,
0.07246141135692596,
-0.18716613948345184,
0.05040524899959564,
-0.04810333251953125,
0.585250973701477,
0.7452495694160461,
-0.026418281719088554,
-0.47850480675697327,
0.29576951265335083,
0.4534797966480255,
-0.43222475051879883,
-0.4265595078468323,
0.6561738848686218,
0.40949469804763794,
0.3557901382446289,
0.6196972131729126,
-0.3719283938407898,
-0.6183977127075195,
0.28595346212387085,
0.155815988779068,
0.4596616327762604,
0.036743711680173874,
0.12874236702919006,
0.4181953966617584,
0.30759671330451965,
0.10600753128528595,
0.05060163512825966,
-0.30134791135787964,
-0.7423409819602966,
-0.6847541928291321,
-0.4898744821548462,
-0.22876934707164764,
0.025153128430247307,
-0.2838440537452698,
0.3721544146537781,
-0.3685842454433441,
0.04762227460741997,
-0.14024138450622559,
0.12430761754512787,
-0.630470335483551,
-0.05632198229432106,
0.23485463857650757,
0.780311644077301,
-1.0638341903686523,
0.721232533454895,
0.745688796043396,
-0.4564031660556793,
-0.9163923263549805,
-0.5376172661781311,
0.5184530019760132,
-0.7665242552757263,
0.1130870059132576,
-0.080545574426651,
0.1115441769361496,
0.009711205959320068,
-0.25688812136650085,
-0.855833113193512,
1.507218599319458,
0.19466404616832733,
-0.18410958349704742,
0.046327099204063416,
-0.06845701485872269,
0.16833184659481049,
-0.07464739680290222,
0.13680453598499298,
0.17800559103488922,
0.5367159843444824,
0.8359788060188293,
-1.2129919528961182,
0.058079592883586884,
-0.19194389879703522,
-0.5524137616157532,
0.36642950773239136,
-0.7604312300682068,
0.43136298656463623,
-0.1764063984155655,
0.11342021077871323,
-0.20736035704612732,
0.5854844450950623,
0.34594863653182983,
0.5888023376464844,
0.45700976252555847,
0.7902697324752808,
0.7644500136375427,
-0.07803758978843689,
0.5297496318817139,
-0.2820807695388794,
0.15614236891269684,
0.824312150478363,
-0.14425796270370483,
0.33299463987350464,
0.07050399482250214,
0.021079016849398613,
0.2849971652030945,
0.8557409644126892,
-0.1354398876428604,
0.6204276084899902,
-0.32400089502334595,
-0.6395869255065918,
-0.3797953128814697,
-0.37358811497688293,
-0.6411736011505127,
0.5806457996368408,
0.2782953083515167,
-0.033228594809770584,
-0.4619227945804596,
0.18818199634552002,
-0.06850526481866837,
-0.0715983435511589,
-0.319423109292984,
0.6399413347244263,
-0.1737240105867386,
-0.568359375,
0.5330098867416382,
0.09898950904607773,
1.0520656108856201,
-1.026252031326294,
-0.0059531270526349545,
-0.25375795364379883,
-0.0648200511932373,
-0.4775022268295288,
-0.2315310537815094,
0.2074689418077469,
-0.5684195756912231,
-0.32351016998291016,
0.012937910854816437,
0.8431287407875061,
-0.47169211506843567,
-0.25643929839134216,
0.03748525679111481,
0.638608455657959,
-0.3982447385787964,
-0.027337143197655678,
-0.48139286041259766,
-0.12805040180683136,
-0.011735866777598858,
0.1131090596318245,
0.26589465141296387,
0.35819125175476074,
-0.09758833050727844,
0.5647279024124146,
0.8523967862129211,
-0.18922370672225952,
0.26079457998275757,
-0.07926386594772339,
1.000573992729187,
-0.19578836858272552,
-0.48462435603141785,
-0.5651452541351318,
0.524421215057373,
-0.05452994257211685,
-0.26438015699386597,
0.8801526427268982,
0.8833807110786438,
0.8669635653495789,
0.13871246576309204,
0.740502655506134,
-0.5056654214859009,
0.15470214188098907,
-0.34255972504615784,
0.9596685171127319,
-0.6106786727905273,
0.02577177993953228,
-0.2890419363975525,
-0.7022205591201782,
-0.4145219922065735,
0.1786995679140091,
0.011811808682978153,
-0.18533271551132202,
0.43505504727363586,
0.8600167632102966,
-0.5390682220458984,
0.15136276185512543,
0.3617546260356903,
0.010445415042340755,
0.19068413972854614,
0.657960832118988,
0.7315897941589355,
-0.33452489972114563,
0.959574818611145,
-0.4177021384239197,
-0.46604424715042114,
-0.059523072093725204,
-0.7996116876602173,
-0.5645425319671631,
-0.7308976650238037,
-0.3548176884651184,
-0.33002662658691406,
-0.27947625517845154,
1.0381600856781006,
1.1196746826171875,
-0.32823851704597473,
0.10936541110277176,
0.07148724049329758,
0.3597913980484009,
-0.2589770555496216,
-0.2089756280183792,
0.24184592068195343,
0.1656254529953003,
-0.24694986641407013,
0.5303071141242981,
0.24291178584098816,
0.16668455302715302,
-0.1753922402858734,
-0.2044704705476761,
-0.3907206654548645,
-0.541351318359375,
0.5574181079864502,
0.5010305047035217,
-0.656205415725708,
-0.22316090762615204,
0.23732830584049225,
0.06082817167043686,
-0.06331267207860947,
1.0450671911239624,
-1.1005805730819702,
1.0509177446365356,
0.4496648907661438,
0.44526737928390503,
0.28330740332603455,
-0.17247512936592102,
0.6231534481048584,
-1.0925686359405518,
0.2425214946269989,
0.3317317068576813,
0.2905818819999695,
0.2585532069206238,
-0.23791784048080444,
0.4187015891075134,
0.9284918308258057,
-0.27561378479003906,
-0.6985368728637695,
0.4105299413204193,
-1.281013011932373,
-0.11225342005491257,
1.0096206665039062,
-0.0035406823735684156,
0.06178279221057892,
-0.3637009561061859,
-0.18629606068134308,
0.3937736749649048,
-0.3347306549549103,
0.6719909310340881,
0.5010762810707092,
0.023356981575489044,
-0.0883382111787796,
-0.3815155625343323,
0.4947819113731384,
0.15269146859645844,
-0.426151841878891,
0.03820275142788887,
0.9521064162254333,
0.15397050976753235,
0.24474357068538666,
0.533716082572937,
0.03217627480626106,
0.3610762059688568,
0.0630059689283371,
-0.03881264850497246,
-0.518894374370575,
-0.04624054953455925,
-0.09365643560886383,
0.2745943069458008,
-0.17116983234882355,
-0.07147516310214996
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19103v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19103v1
|
Automated Black-box Prompt Engineering for Personalized Text-to-Image Generation
| 2024-03-28T02:35:53 | 2024-03-28T02:35:53 |
Yutong He, Alexander Robey, Naoki Murata, Yiding Jiang, Joshua Williams, George J. Pappas, Hamed Hassani, Yuki Mitsufuji, Ruslan Salakhutdinov, J. Zico Kolter
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Prompt engineering is effective for controlling the output of text-to-image
(T2I) generative models, but it is also laborious due to the need for manually
crafted prompts. This challenge has spurred the development of algorithms for
automated prompt generation. However, these methods often struggle with
transferability across T2I models, require white-box access to the underlying
model, and produce non-intuitive prompts. In this work, we introduce PRISM, an
algorithm that automatically identifies human-interpretable and transferable
prompts that can effectively generate desired concepts given only black-box
access to T2I models. Inspired by large language model (LLM) jailbreaking,
PRISM leverages the in-context learning ability of LLMs to iteratively refine
the candidate prompts distribution for given reference images. Our experiments
demonstrate the versatility and effectiveness of PRISM in generating accurate
prompts for objects, styles and images across multiple T2I models, including
Stable Diffusion, DALL-E, and Midjourney.
|
[
-0.3892035484313965,
-0.6144949793815613,
0.7957504391670227,
0.5974050760269165,
-0.13712847232818604,
0.21190881729125977,
0.15724965929985046,
-0.2343415915966034,
-0.03362197428941727,
0.2784847915172577,
-0.8267558813095093,
-0.39480820298194885,
-0.26837217807769775,
0.432843416929245,
-0.1154070496559143,
0.6140873432159424,
-0.09125974029302597,
-0.20109626650810242,
0.0850028544664383,
0.31430742144584656,
-1.2079212665557861,
-0.017408739775419235,
-0.4206765294075012,
-0.2404276728630066,
0.238194540143013,
0.6010710000991821,
0.48596811294555664,
0.48284223675727844,
-0.010160448960959911,
0.2502627670764923,
0.09358944743871689,
0.14888691902160645,
-0.3681891858577728,
0.0984913781285286,
-0.5296462178230286,
-0.3485337197780609,
-0.08056581765413284,
-0.07911714166402817,
0.2471785992383957,
0.3702315390110016,
0.2233729362487793,
0.23602215945720673,
0.06357124447822571,
0.41999122500419617,
-0.6150126457214355,
0.07942208647727966,
-0.6451593637466431,
0.26457348465919495,
-0.09632755070924759,
-0.6924633383750916,
-0.8645612597465515,
-0.3550666272640228,
0.11561273038387299,
-0.7739888429641724,
0.24215556681156158,
0.4335075914859772,
0.8721169829368591,
0.1792639195919037,
-0.2436491996049881,
-0.49377113580703735,
-0.4319499731063843,
0.758648157119751,
-0.22442838549613953,
0.037847429513931274,
0.09206801652908325,
0.6581135988235474,
-0.22816811501979828,
-0.559252917766571,
-0.34717032313346863,
-0.20135648548603058,
-0.16872645914554596,
-0.008587158285081387,
0.040536195039749146,
-0.10771021991968155,
0.11195297539234161,
-0.12532174587249756,
-0.5373905301094055,
0.1410410851240158,
-0.5094846487045288,
-0.25830480456352234,
0.4691382348537445,
0.4142291247844696,
0.5511544346809387,
-0.41129863262176514,
-0.4506346583366394,
0.03546275943517685,
-0.7758998274803162,
0.08477616310119629,
0.12981615960597992,
0.06391886621713638,
-0.28918707370758057,
0.6321219205856323,
-0.14631932973861694,
0.6539226174354553,
0.43664973974227905,
-0.05239170044660568,
0.2597564160823822,
-0.2454967349767685,
0.13569164276123047,
0.14397285878658295,
0.9054736495018005,
0.757058322429657,
0.21646203100681305,
-0.41052743792533875,
-0.21644099056720734,
-0.1350601464509964,
0.2506701648235321,
-1.024953842163086,
-0.3607591390609741,
0.26024073362350464,
-0.3910672664642334,
-0.6020014882087708,
-0.03123617172241211,
-0.9738534688949585,
-0.8003963232040405,
-0.3029758632183075,
0.3741195499897003,
-0.25432732701301575,
0.02034933678805828,
-0.09153232723474503,
-0.4505840539932251,
0.126114159822464,
0.5334113240242004,
-0.71303790807724,
-0.3577408492565155,
0.36111706495285034,
0.9930051565170288,
-0.2868487536907196,
-0.15133029222488403,
-0.6165221333503723,
0.25997161865234375,
-0.5303903222084045,
1.0192335844039917,
-0.6891815066337585,
-0.6260583996772766,
-0.07253991812467575,
-0.06737063080072403,
0.26659703254699707,
-0.45876601338386536,
-0.001920806709676981,
-0.5326886177062988,
0.30899396538734436,
-0.1525721698999405,
-0.3264208436012268,
0.055088143795728683,
0.08033464103937149,
-0.3740541338920593,
0.5476426482200623,
0.18970294296741486,
-0.5649596452713013,
0.24502678215503693,
-0.8576619625091553,
-0.0070026349276304245,
0.4140622317790985,
-0.24535880982875824,
-0.4779210090637207,
0.18119563162326813,
0.3010933995246887,
0.524217426776886,
-0.4707670509815216,
0.5628353357315063,
-0.43790003657341003,
-0.273059219121933,
0.4020217955112457,
-0.14974690973758698,
0.7515413165092468,
0.27769652009010315,
-0.42813587188720703,
0.19876396656036377,
-0.74338698387146,
-0.1340027004480362,
0.2848433554172516,
0.14180921018123627,
-0.0629216805100441,
-0.10530184209346771,
0.24637842178344727,
0.24949823319911957,
0.18416833877563477,
-0.6636780500411987,
0.36518463492393494,
-0.2056928128004074,
0.4695039689540863,
0.906639039516449,
0.36188486218452454,
0.6531196236610413,
-0.21675921976566315,
0.5422453880310059,
-0.054363250732421875,
-0.07236234098672867,
-0.6107738614082336,
-0.6239908337593079,
-0.3655960261821747,
-0.14269088208675385,
0.1082150861620903,
1.0325695276260376,
-1.0710076093673706,
0.28623509407043457,
-0.061240941286087036,
-0.2722492516040802,
-0.24316398799419403,
0.08185166120529175,
0.21986545622348785,
0.8919590711593628,
0.2774657607078552,
-0.3202882409095764,
-0.18730854988098145,
-1.002417802810669,
0.01826677843928337,
0.041888702660799026,
-0.435230553150177,
0.4295298159122467,
0.4314629137516022,
-0.21412022411823273,
1.385664463043213,
-0.7049698233604431,
-0.313336580991745,
-0.0261676087975502,
0.36294957995414734,
-0.0027911283541470766,
0.47349995374679565,
0.7250224947929382,
-0.6732406616210938,
-0.5174185037612915,
-0.15056581795215607,
-1.0353498458862305,
-0.7014676928520203,
-0.5136715173721313,
-0.2555161714553833,
-0.11218474060297012,
0.5072380900382996,
-0.3379257619380951,
0.4453541040420532,
0.1681142896413803,
-0.7648678421974182,
0.8001192212104797,
-0.1306457817554474,
0.17669661343097687,
-1.3478069305419922,
0.12982061505317688,
0.281464546918869,
-0.2775149643421173,
-0.5388391017913818,
-0.09316915273666382,
0.2730874717235565,
-0.6428256630897522,
-0.6742877960205078,
1.0914536714553833,
-0.615053653717041,
-0.02486119233071804,
-0.3693218529224396,
0.07540644705295563,
0.18144460022449493,
0.451151967048645,
0.09046943485736847,
1.066895842552185,
0.7439275979995728,
-0.44799116253852844,
0.5401132106781006,
0.43714189529418945,
-0.2302463799715042,
1.0262858867645264,
-0.7948744893074036,
0.15276820957660675,
-0.20903019607067108,
0.10713914036750793,
-0.9310666918754578,
-0.26474592089653015,
0.6854073405265808,
-0.2217455506324768,
0.277140736579895,
-0.1538362056016922,
-0.39610499143600464,
-0.06080246716737747,
-0.329039067029953,
0.507583737373352,
0.6248202919960022,
-0.7642929553985596,
0.5644448399543762,
0.12391702085733414,
-0.43713515996932983,
-0.2800726592540741,
-0.4607217311859131,
0.5394127368927002,
-0.22525814175605774,
-0.69977205991745,
0.40524598956108093,
-0.3267320990562439,
-0.11406617611646652,
-0.019512953236699104,
0.372846782207489,
-0.019678471609950066,
0.1756572425365448,
0.3500446081161499,
0.4582226574420929,
0.015090486034750938,
-0.05376088246703148,
0.23554545640945435,
-0.3255401849746704,
0.0904659628868103,
-0.35595229268074036,
0.380927175283432,
0.03665420413017273,
-0.14205588400363922,
-0.7032836079597473,
0.38670405745506287,
0.29814955592155457,
-0.25602540373802185,
0.4501916766166687,
0.3317778706550598,
-0.20452986657619476,
-0.6045111417770386,
-0.290496289730072,
-0.13549068570137024,
-0.6191695928573608,
0.1364584118127823,
-0.6676253080368042,
-0.4956435263156891,
0.4226638674736023,
-0.30377137660980225,
0.21719162166118622,
-0.1756824553012848,
0.627641499042511,
-0.10769189149141312,
0.8822894096374512,
0.6037294268608093,
0.21220405399799347,
0.6669459939002991,
-0.25733014941215515,
0.011608359403908253,
-0.7559243440628052,
-0.13551628589630127,
-0.2401648461818695,
-0.31987422704696655,
-0.27051424980163574,
-0.416229784488678,
0.4723258316516876,
-0.14410074055194855,
-0.1829436719417572,
0.15198473632335663,
-0.6959781646728516,
0.6771271824836731,
0.39925551414489746,
0.2482512891292572,
0.14897875487804413,
0.2876889705657959,
0.002258678898215294,
0.16109296679496765,
-0.31655964255332947,
-0.5765214562416077,
0.8392047882080078,
0.33503514528274536,
0.8331837058067322,
-0.17109490931034088,
0.7473760843276978,
0.5903341174125671,
0.4915629029273987,
-0.7511849403381348,
0.6760605573654175,
0.271695077419281,
-0.33503445982933044,
-0.07476966828107834,
-0.3153873682022095,
-0.9484716057777405,
0.11903541535139084,
-0.34526365995407104,
-0.901997983455658,
0.47529366612434387,
0.3610588014125824,
-0.27085191011428833,
0.05351569131016731,
-0.9140356183052063,
0.8529057502746582,
-0.14137089252471924,
-0.47479480504989624,
0.12215699255466461,
-0.48622557520866394,
0.3280143737792969,
-0.30022966861724854,
0.027476420626044273,
-0.17148125171661377,
-0.238326758146286,
0.2591950297355652,
-0.2827591896057129,
0.8771384358406067,
-0.308004230260849,
-0.023655036464333534,
0.1541125476360321,
0.45852208137512207,
0.4155949354171753,
0.20660196244716644,
-0.10549257695674896,
0.07187342643737793,
-0.4323728382587433,
-0.41857293248176575,
-0.6408286690711975,
0.3430057764053345,
-0.5192228555679321,
-0.5811904072761536,
-0.09525229036808014,
-0.5600590705871582,
-0.08691412955522537,
0.28075167536735535,
0.6357320547103882,
0.6120894551277161,
-0.03738944232463837,
-0.1164349690079689,
0.5522593855857849,
-0.6675525903701782,
0.41861408948898315,
0.3434026539325714,
-0.14813286066055298,
-0.37920013070106506,
1.1383246183395386,
-0.20797693729400635,
0.028299611061811447,
0.30909276008605957,
0.27071821689605713,
-0.22865711152553558,
-0.5827862620353699,
-1.1385844945907593,
0.2025066465139389,
-0.6590298414230347,
-0.3214002847671509,
-0.3462005853652954,
0.0395430289208889,
-0.12151534110307693,
-0.8686205148696899,
-0.10564932227134705,
-0.23685501515865326,
-0.7065100073814392,
0.10823055356740952,
0.1444823294878006,
0.5962775349617004,
0.3460341989994049,
0.3692590594291687,
-0.7538158297538757,
0.6841140389442444,
0.32157421112060547,
0.28350356221199036,
-0.19626222550868988,
-0.45076319575309753,
0.2629065215587616,
-0.09920535236597061,
-0.6198362708091736,
-1.379820704460144,
0.45202797651290894,
0.22473569214344025,
0.1595803052186966,
0.2759096324443817,
0.2619069814682007,
0.40463003516197205,
-0.7245268225669861,
0.8679295778274536,
0.546634316444397,
-0.9620453119277954,
0.7428154349327087,
-0.33375778794288635,
0.16601397097110748,
0.2932671308517456,
0.011221910826861858,
-0.43545541167259216,
-0.5126111507415771,
-0.28943830728530884,
-0.7154046297073364,
0.7911021709442139,
0.005376913584768772,
0.1142958328127861,
0.26990070939064026,
0.4254799783229828,
0.17777292430400848,
0.17002539336681366,
-0.726180374622345,
-0.18029522895812988,
-0.3512369394302368,
-0.6112598776817322,
0.08434601128101349,
-0.1556956022977829,
-0.08396873623132706,
0.3147949278354645,
0.5168613791465759,
-0.391290545463562,
0.19260047376155853,
0.11067669838666916,
-0.3799700438976288,
-0.1415686011314392,
0.3894941508769989,
0.4646405875682831,
0.7700132727622986,
0.014264026656746864,
-0.2426651120185852,
0.03159024566411972,
-0.20539812743663788,
0.5942997932434082,
0.11605776846408844,
-0.8751586675643921,
-0.09521281719207764,
-0.06691291183233261,
0.9975773096084595,
-0.10287927836179733,
-0.6248874664306641,
0.6514973044395447,
-0.20810125768184662,
-0.11424911022186279,
-0.3263043463230133,
0.18282482028007507,
-0.1679299920797348,
0.2825644612312317,
0.4427791237831116,
0.20563706755638123,
0.26427650451660156,
-0.3474491834640503,
0.09283381700515747,
0.4358690679073334,
-0.050603289157152176,
-0.38206911087036133,
0.8350179195404053,
0.5773471593856812,
-0.7158136963844299,
0.6428624987602234,
-0.4934386909008026,
-0.24217331409454346,
0.5881145596504211,
0.634148120880127,
1.0644038915634155,
-0.07478474825620651,
0.590369701385498,
0.1947425901889801,
0.20985066890716553,
0.09496967494487762,
0.0023246221244335175,
-0.12359742075204849,
-0.518670916557312,
-0.12934018671512604,
-0.42359867691993713,
-0.49668270349502563,
-0.06697652488946915,
-0.22973749041557312,
0.6723171472549438,
-0.4400642216205597,
-0.018174557015299797,
0.008144975639879704,
-0.46062541007995605,
-0.5395636558532715,
0.04680516943335533,
0.26707136631011963,
0.9717385172843933,
-0.9176879525184631,
0.37467148900032043,
0.6696914434432983,
-0.21975845098495483,
-0.7239627242088318,
-0.09811033308506012,
0.16824600100517273,
-0.6357172727584839,
0.5918650031089783,
0.45185068249702454,
0.1615268439054489,
0.049874961376190186,
-0.6094499230384827,
-0.5216062664985657,
1.155004858970642,
0.4676293134689331,
-0.4647825360298157,
-0.21505817770957947,
0.18831655383110046,
0.3160850405693054,
-0.5922555327415466,
0.32919663190841675,
0.391105055809021,
0.42795446515083313,
0.2751298248767853,
-0.8112794756889343,
0.15272103250026703,
-0.4533695578575134,
0.19974656403064728,
0.09298250824213028,
-0.2248152494430542,
0.4165967106819153,
-0.44932690262794495,
-0.4549533426761627,
0.1723887026309967,
0.5956462621688843,
0.5865771770477295,
0.620012104511261,
0.5231413245201111,
0.2588508427143097,
0.6009073853492737,
0.025502564385533333,
0.9872562289237976,
-0.3759649693965912,
0.06949283182621002,
0.8113827109336853,
-0.16902782022953033,
0.3303390145301819,
0.2735290229320526,
0.34647926688194275,
0.42821136116981506,
0.7509087920188904,
-0.5953108072280884,
0.511073648929596,
0.016969842836260796,
-0.07995771616697311,
0.00006895070691825822,
-0.1093812808394432,
-0.06516703963279724,
-0.0036932413931936026,
0.34689995646476746,
-0.382350891828537,
-0.3595733940601349,
0.4544179439544678,
-0.2376021146774292,
-0.0821303203701973,
-0.3480618894100189,
0.7268809080123901,
0.04888009652495384,
-0.7534455060958862,
0.6295850872993469,
0.0675925686955452,
0.7384437918663025,
-0.2958666980266571,
-0.26880893111228943,
-0.04912373423576355,
-0.13499903678894043,
-0.23827718198299408,
-1.0746090412139893,
0.051169831305742264,
0.2429506480693817,
-0.08653002977371216,
-0.5624096989631653,
0.82427978515625,
-0.34161803126335144,
-0.39033254981040955,
-0.05264122411608696,
0.3432976007461548,
0.028754055500030518,
0.1259484738111496,
-0.8606140613555908,
-0.10334089398384094,
0.07795911282300949,
-0.3849916160106659,
0.13888245820999146,
0.33539557456970215,
-0.13203759491443634,
0.9076167941093445,
0.49027055501937866,
0.18600554764270782,
0.1501922607421875,
-0.15838995575904846,
0.6988555788993835,
-0.5342944264411926,
-0.7045983076095581,
-0.6687661409378052,
0.7821638584136963,
-0.10188444703817368,
-0.2569447159767151,
0.39133065938949585,
0.37551024556159973,
0.44596177339553833,
-0.47495463490486145,
0.9372466802597046,
-0.09105130285024643,
0.14879150688648224,
-0.5163941383361816,
0.5651607513427734,
-0.5426377654075623,
0.37768012285232544,
-0.2568889558315277,
-0.8827114701271057,
-0.12880773842334747,
0.5098981857299805,
-0.3127720355987549,
-0.30247822403907776,
0.45470497012138367,
1.1719932556152344,
-0.15024690330028534,
-0.18419001996517181,
0.06495554000139236,
-0.15950843691825867,
0.6850826740264893,
0.6345345973968506,
0.8356858491897583,
-0.1636984497308731,
0.5135669112205505,
-0.35496243834495544,
-0.46000680327415466,
-0.2514278292655945,
-1.0589851140975952,
-0.8394043445587158,
-0.5987626910209656,
-0.41408511996269226,
-0.4185028672218323,
-0.03155703842639923,
1.000780463218689,
0.8241402506828308,
-0.5949810743331909,
-0.1493673175573349,
-0.18813031911849976,
0.12207692861557007,
0.10607937723398209,
-0.28930234909057617,
0.23797659575939178,
-0.44170764088630676,
-0.7606095671653748,
0.37074142694473267,
0.41126248240470886,
0.2811533808708191,
-0.20056216418743134,
0.00373655604198575,
0.5905669927597046,
0.13031445443630219,
0.48314177989959717,
0.3740006387233734,
-0.46136289834976196,
-0.20849455893039703,
-0.07822413742542267,
-0.1567089855670929,
0.12747636437416077,
0.8572085499763489,
-0.7647513747215271,
0.5594486594200134,
0.573293149471283,
0.6005095839500427,
0.10139909386634827,
0.2714020609855652,
0.793159008026123,
-0.890141487121582,
0.2535494863986969,
0.07125917077064514,
0.2880924940109253,
0.4977864623069763,
-0.5055350065231323,
0.24954578280448914,
0.3311441242694855,
-0.4529714584350586,
-0.8578097820281982,
0.4405522644519806,
-0.9809803366661072,
-0.5085445642471313,
1.1054182052612305,
0.03563421964645386,
-0.41095438599586487,
-0.2858714759349823,
-0.623948335647583,
-0.15786097943782806,
-0.589326798915863,
1.0235317945480347,
0.3705003261566162,
-0.07281042635440826,
-0.5723179578781128,
-0.24805130064487457,
0.401065856218338,
0.02418462745845318,
-0.987133800983429,
-0.001375236315652728,
0.7687577605247498,
0.49438443779945374,
0.391669899225235,
0.42110466957092285,
0.12642721831798553,
0.5443146824836731,
-0.29130271077156067,
0.1352175772190094,
-0.537087082862854,
-0.3825542628765106,
-0.2754588723182678,
0.464390367269516,
-0.09274793416261673,
-0.11153867840766907
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19094v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19094v1
|
Learning From Correctness Without Prompting Makes LLM Efficient Reasoner
| 2024-03-28T02:12:49 | 2024-03-28T02:12:49 |
Yuxuan Yao, Han Wu, Zhijiang Guo, Biyan Zhou, Jiahui Gao, Sichun Luo, Hanxu Hou, Xiaojin Fu, Linqi Song
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated outstanding performance across
various tasks, yet they still exhibit limitations such as hallucination,
unfaithful reasoning, and toxic content. One potential approach to mitigate
these issues is learning from human or external feedback (e.g. tools). In this
paper, we introduce an intrinsic self-correct reasoning framework for LLMs that
eliminates the need for human feedback, external tools, and handcraft prompts.
The proposed framework, based on a multi-step reasoning paradigm
\textbf{Le}arning from \textbf{Co}rrectness (\textsc{LeCo}), improves reasoning
performance without needing to learn from errors. This paradigm prioritizes
learning from correct reasoning steps, and a unique method to measure
confidence for each reasoning step based on generation logits. Experimental
results across various multi-step reasoning tasks demonstrate the effectiveness
of the framework in improving reasoning performance with reduced token
consumption.
|
[
0.002114953938871622,
-0.6185740232467651,
0.7375500202178955,
0.23101957142353058,
-0.06799200177192688,
0.07734187692403793,
-0.3521689176559448,
-0.2446594387292862,
-0.19362962245941162,
0.4603310227394104,
-0.5768783688545227,
-0.33002012968063354,
-0.266182541847229,
0.2620494067668915,
-0.04651176929473877,
0.6220803260803223,
-0.023708906024694443,
0.09340208023786545,
-0.28903669118881226,
-0.08055424690246582,
-0.16972394287586212,
-0.45871952176094055,
-0.9150272011756897,
-0.5182937383651733,
0.7533302903175354,
0.7602644562721252,
0.25994905829429626,
0.6179540753364563,
0.32303696870803833,
0.3062804341316223,
0.12404382973909378,
0.5745756030082703,
-0.2628781497478485,
0.278774619102478,
-0.49403277039527893,
-0.6956300139427185,
-0.4508233070373535,
-0.19011728465557098,
0.2189284861087799,
0.2275780439376831,
-0.22342060506343842,
0.043808769434690475,
0.3049555718898773,
0.7504745721817017,
-0.535959005355835,
0.03455667197704315,
-0.6671742796897888,
-0.0737951472401619,
-0.03620105981826782,
-0.36120322346687317,
-0.6907949447631836,
-0.1263200342655182,
-0.21606527268886566,
-0.5713682770729065,
0.2674877643585205,
0.15332794189453125,
0.5092744827270508,
0.6748181581497192,
-0.15406356751918793,
-0.5060485601425171,
-0.3556693196296692,
0.811531662940979,
-0.5993180871009827,
0.5752168893814087,
0.4483944773674011,
0.21883511543273926,
-0.15725399553775787,
-0.4682733714580536,
-0.5306662321090698,
-0.23490017652511597,
-0.03929608315229416,
0.0648232027888298,
0.18244975805282593,
0.11398622393608093,
0.4595251977443695,
0.06388962268829346,
-0.3041248619556427,
0.11784558743238449,
-0.10755376517772675,
-0.45840567350387573,
0.5588006377220154,
-0.055665239691734314,
0.03771136328577995,
-0.201186403632164,
-0.254304438829422,
-0.09538133442401886,
-1.15672767162323,
0.12540403008460999,
0.25533679127693176,
0.27801206707954407,
0.1291656643152237,
0.5284415483474731,
-0.04868447780609131,
0.49393707513809204,
0.40456289052963257,
-0.5814316272735596,
-0.00852102693170309,
-0.29400956630706787,
-0.19379451870918274,
-0.09317468851804733,
0.5324565172195435,
-0.0028785320464521646,
0.11129941791296005,
-0.22236478328704834,
-0.3173673450946808,
-0.007197235710918903,
0.2932960093021393,
-0.6066744923591614,
-0.2959936261177063,
0.48493829369544983,
-0.1488475799560547,
-0.11757511645555496,
-0.23235149681568146,
-0.3958791196346283,
-0.30697205662727356,
-0.5378091931343079,
0.324057936668396,
-0.468915730714798,
-0.1432458758354187,
-0.09953319281339645,
0.06017722189426422,
0.1710151731967926,
0.7559350728988647,
-0.6827018857002258,
0.06821106374263763,
0.6727523803710938,
0.731564462184906,
-0.12295391410589218,
-0.17050659656524658,
-0.9022718667984009,
0.20481035113334656,
-0.5158606767654419,
0.7604005932807922,
-0.15904909372329712,
-0.2793816030025482,
-0.37044742703437805,
-0.16744785010814667,
0.06385692209005356,
-0.6732161641120911,
0.6183758974075317,
-0.3643709123134613,
0.0367940329015255,
-0.5072914958000183,
-0.5230585336685181,
-0.361166775226593,
0.28675422072410583,
-0.22831092774868011,
1.0715599060058594,
-0.19018059968948364,
-0.47706735134124756,
0.49297642707824707,
-0.8703112006187439,
-0.4188474714756012,
0.08608942478895187,
-0.22278402745723724,
-0.06664334982633591,
-0.017735861241817474,
0.3906543552875519,
0.637897253036499,
0.03779527544975281,
0.46535614132881165,
-0.2864026725292206,
-0.27852317690849304,
-0.06219371035695076,
-0.40963777899742126,
0.7498700022697449,
0.18659180402755737,
-0.8727633953094482,
0.37000975012779236,
-0.8074928522109985,
0.04579591751098633,
-0.07851260900497437,
-0.46525609493255615,
-0.28401562571525574,
0.1564856320619583,
-0.6913893818855286,
0.5363979339599609,
0.032817985862493515,
-0.34094488620758057,
0.11287777870893478,
-0.40747690200805664,
0.3015105426311493,
1.1540299654006958,
-0.23158062994480133,
0.5627442598342896,
-0.37643852829933167,
0.2376430481672287,
0.18816155195236206,
0.03895687684416771,
-0.32673075795173645,
-0.19882144033908844,
-1.158008098602295,
-0.4774911105632782,
0.004730647429823875,
0.7303577065467834,
-0.8125882744789124,
0.7845174670219421,
0.15942522883415222,
-0.34901881217956543,
-0.4223606586456299,
0.546732485294342,
0.3586485981941223,
0.6432193517684937,
0.48972100019454956,
0.04588784649968147,
-0.4057675004005432,
-0.5115463137626648,
-0.13539817929267883,
-0.2922631502151489,
0.017873985692858696,
0.2284197062253952,
0.38393184542655945,
-0.24774758517742157,
0.7027069330215454,
-0.027210289612412453,
-0.06831470876932144,
-0.19488734006881714,
0.21159324049949646,
0.10298244655132294,
0.4841036796569824,
-0.010930751450359821,
-0.397746205329895,
-0.2595919966697693,
-0.1774452030658722,
-1.0126861333847046,
-0.2751888930797577,
-0.31593939661979675,
-0.2738216817378998,
0.5266286134719849,
0.7106031775474548,
-0.5551077723503113,
0.3345640003681183,
0.18291182816028595,
-0.16500599682331085,
0.5696942210197449,
-0.34497031569480896,
-0.06391692906618118,
-0.5962592959403992,
0.08750542998313904,
0.017877917736768723,
-0.46043363213539124,
-0.21893371641635895,
0.10554420948028564,
0.2411244958639145,
0.26019418239593506,
-0.33196568489074707,
0.8183241486549377,
-0.5427771806716919,
0.2543593943119049,
-0.29983919858932495,
0.09787103533744812,
0.17451211810112,
0.6325247883796692,
0.13345296680927277,
0.7412872910499573,
0.5389158129692078,
-0.9361976981163025,
0.2753714621067047,
-0.16614599525928497,
0.0037481938488781452,
0.9895241856575012,
-0.6487261056900024,
0.34003645181655884,
-0.24446670711040497,
0.14620941877365112,
-0.7735477089881897,
-0.10037049651145935,
0.5512299537658691,
-0.3576253652572632,
0.2846485376358032,
-0.048726171255111694,
-0.5606316328048706,
-0.38433194160461426,
-0.20897448062896729,
0.03681795299053192,
0.3399414122104645,
-0.937943696975708,
0.866503119468689,
-0.0759865865111351,
0.04321425408124924,
-0.9357998371124268,
-0.42289838194847107,
-0.056639429181814194,
-0.11605709791183472,
-0.5681899189949036,
-0.16040277481079102,
-0.4224338233470917,
-0.434374064207077,
-0.3022751808166504,
-0.24953535199165344,
0.11001528054475784,
0.17332196235656738,
0.3345423638820648,
0.1718665510416031,
0.09667930752038956,
0.5872876048088074,
0.12837158143520355,
-0.12062246352434158,
0.1975155621767044,
-0.391834557056427,
0.2899954915046692,
-0.17545443773269653,
-0.6554650664329529,
-0.5399410128593445,
0.018230944871902466,
0.4405743181705475,
-0.03976980224251747,
0.46187064051628113,
0.35441499948501587,
-0.12579746544361115,
-0.4622277021408081,
-0.8360329270362854,
-0.44826701283454895,
-0.5324981212615967,
-0.09377270936965942,
-0.4456735849380493,
-1.003026008605957,
0.29015153646469116,
-0.10073676705360413,
0.26602017879486084,
0.26357805728912354,
0.5686967968940735,
-0.351321816444397,
0.9312237501144409,
0.1797458529472351,
0.3587472140789032,
0.023200660943984985,
-0.03879545256495476,
0.26696041226387024,
-0.8070788383483887,
-0.3256700336933136,
-0.4276888966560364,
0.12872259318828583,
-0.08003450185060501,
-0.7204753160476685,
0.2470536231994629,
0.20597465336322784,
-0.5655705332756042,
-0.0059659662656486034,
-0.5027556419372559,
0.4926479458808899,
0.6877140402793884,
0.27515149116516113,
0.5407498478889465,
-0.09516226500272751,
-0.6554207801818848,
0.06444943696260452,
-0.7851837873458862,
-0.5803623795509338,
1.0016175508499146,
0.4053955078125,
0.8996232748031616,
-0.008892057463526726,
0.9315904974937439,
0.24214303493499756,
0.5195962190628052,
-0.8956370949745178,
0.6123145222663879,
0.41891297698020935,
-0.707850456237793,
-0.4417371451854706,
-0.7574272751808167,
-0.6540035605430603,
0.372818261384964,
0.046907879412174225,
-0.5264571309089661,
0.03502149134874344,
0.5363500118255615,
-0.43492087721824646,
0.2989579439163208,
-0.6512689590454102,
0.4626607596874237,
-0.6171956658363342,
-0.6787513494491577,
-0.2869396507740021,
-0.5922079682350159,
0.3641778230667114,
-0.07546283304691315,
0.49881666898727417,
-0.17084576189517975,
0.006647047121077776,
0.3690938353538513,
-0.5965511798858643,
1.0356742143630981,
-0.3805873394012451,
-0.3888477087020874,
0.5495339035987854,
0.35709065198898315,
0.7502256631851196,
-0.029615774750709534,
0.028456995263695717,
0.022693326696753502,
-0.2541351616382599,
-0.2810516357421875,
-0.78793865442276,
0.5993746519088745,
-0.5492466688156128,
-0.9284183382987976,
-0.3535686433315277,
-0.23289698362350464,
-0.1788594126701355,
0.3845687210559845,
0.19731248915195465,
0.37068507075309753,
0.22797250747680664,
0.010608063079416752,
0.8570623397827148,
0.05729000270366669,
0.5313979983329773,
0.41667187213897705,
-0.17532506585121155,
-0.41420915722846985,
0.7277295589447021,
0.19203594326972961,
0.22502274811267853,
0.3237573206424713,
0.38313305377960205,
-0.6976775527000427,
-0.27982327342033386,
-0.6027886271476746,
0.3571379780769348,
-0.9974877238273621,
-0.26437705755233765,
-0.6347616910934448,
0.08289847522974014,
-0.34619367122650146,
-0.24779635667800903,
-0.35930535197257996,
-0.24355164170265198,
-0.31280919909477234,
-0.2734696567058563,
0.04111998528242111,
0.6109923720359802,
-0.5325227379798889,
0.17547102272510529,
-0.8836914896965027,
0.17548902332782745,
0.644520103931427,
0.3113972544670105,
0.4377841651439667,
-0.458230197429657,
-0.043634261935949326,
0.00891655869781971,
-0.4006689488887787,
-0.46677330136299133,
0.09066442400217056,
0.040869396179914474,
0.8130778670310974,
0.4573705792427063,
0.19307591021060944,
0.6998995542526245,
-0.46523821353912354,
0.5983378887176514,
0.34639617800712585,
-1.3527535200119019,
0.7422671914100647,
-0.27258965373039246,
0.32167863845825195,
0.5507259368896484,
0.4243124723434448,
-0.36171045899391174,
-0.3214457333087921,
-0.7352313995361328,
-0.8489068746566772,
0.4522325098514557,
0.018310196697711945,
-0.14444506168365479,
-0.22632598876953125,
0.4208022654056549,
0.16474206745624542,
0.07253889739513397,
-0.9732342958450317,
0.026444287970662117,
-0.318865567445755,
-0.14270837604999542,
0.24951879680156708,
-0.04415169358253479,
-0.23938272893428802,
-0.43045493960380554,
1.1119263172149658,
-0.6050918102264404,
0.05593770369887352,
0.5739829540252686,
-0.4572620987892151,
-0.31013166904449463,
0.295795202255249,
0.4483947455883026,
0.8309153318405151,
0.1737581193447113,
0.47286009788513184,
0.2964688539505005,
0.17561757564544678,
0.4240782558917999,
-0.5358222723007202,
-0.019233359023928642,
-0.2637384235858917,
0.36596816778182983,
0.3586689531803131,
0.17417897284030914,
-0.7494924664497375,
0.5500654578208923,
0.06501034647226334,
-0.0629865899682045,
-0.18156790733337402,
0.35310134291648865,
0.11631597578525543,
0.33794525265693665,
0.331948459148407,
0.17596843838691711,
-0.029049424454569817,
-0.24563772976398468,
0.36067309975624084,
0.2656865119934082,
-0.3541196286678314,
-0.14930304884910583,
0.48933839797973633,
0.42932820320129395,
-0.14331597089767456,
0.6305240988731384,
-0.40683528780937195,
-0.2502000033855438,
0.20982088148593903,
0.437576562166214,
0.6200215220451355,
-0.2386990338563919,
0.3712402284145355,
0.6684172749519348,
0.3033856153488159,
-0.4327511489391327,
0.10942753404378891,
-0.4596543312072754,
-0.8539451956748962,
-0.8291832208633423,
-0.3961544632911682,
-0.5245466232299805,
-0.15672262012958527,
-0.30240514874458313,
0.2029867023229599,
-0.8967502117156982,
-0.025586649775505066,
-0.43125391006469727,
-0.413563996553421,
-0.3949268162250519,
0.35143953561782837,
0.01964978314936161,
0.8987485766410828,
-0.38182008266448975,
0.6730793714523315,
0.36239540576934814,
-0.3098877966403961,
-1.110106110572815,
-0.17299893498420715,
0.12756049633026123,
-0.8690627217292786,
0.773984432220459,
0.3284556567668915,
-0.5950170755386353,
-0.11319305002689362,
-0.8817185163497925,
-0.7391524314880371,
0.7286022305488586,
0.36196619272232056,
-0.7277719974517822,
0.01361826527863741,
-0.3796350061893463,
0.2705190181732178,
-0.12887607514858246,
0.26293161511421204,
0.22185546159744263,
0.5392037630081177,
0.543571412563324,
-0.767406165599823,
0.17088007926940918,
-0.07857712358236313,
-0.436490535736084,
0.03007054142653942,
-0.6144943833351135,
0.5185111165046692,
-0.4837587773799896,
-0.2436097413301468,
-0.2016214281320572,
0.5450189709663391,
0.6350173354148865,
0.11394894123077393,
0.580009937286377,
0.7178431749343872,
1.216572880744934,
-0.12368524819612503,
0.8325981497764587,
-0.12526586651802063,
0.13911275565624237,
1.3349356651306152,
-0.41373464465141296,
0.690778374671936,
0.4100830852985382,
-0.04977535083889961,
0.8391698002815247,
0.5437039732933044,
0.38038814067840576,
0.26314789056777954,
0.2064991146326065,
-0.1898871809244156,
-0.8251211047172546,
0.13086120784282684,
-0.05687298998236656,
0.44356033205986023,
0.35042300820350647,
-0.23175682127475739,
-0.2120942622423172,
-0.24103087186813354,
0.29676032066345215,
0.1274237483739853,
-0.3671511709690094,
0.8659804463386536,
0.22385133802890778,
-0.9013174176216125,
0.664916455745697,
-0.1714440882205963,
0.9007419943809509,
-0.47462695837020874,
-0.05000656098127365,
-0.11205761134624481,
0.18232455849647522,
-0.40208208560943604,
-0.5211941599845886,
0.4844755530357361,
-0.16076010465621948,
-0.09242186695337296,
-0.3032979369163513,
0.767085075378418,
-0.23007217049598694,
-0.38859090209007263,
0.38200268149375916,
0.7812291979789734,
0.016470255330204964,
-0.14771829545497894,
-0.74542635679245,
-0.29610753059387207,
-0.1465039700269699,
-0.0383891724050045,
0.07698477059602737,
0.5832585096359253,
-0.04132508486509323,
0.9298937320709229,
0.9433803558349609,
0.08408802002668381,
-0.12523353099822998,
0.05628242343664169,
0.5670948624610901,
-0.6801169514656067,
-0.4408448338508606,
-1.061094880104065,
0.4916475713253021,
-0.17158156633377075,
0.025638939812779427,
0.7345005869865417,
0.2838871479034424,
0.7551261782646179,
0.11138708889484406,
0.897786557674408,
0.16193582117557526,
0.6876929998397827,
-0.5410369038581848,
0.34602856636047363,
-0.556088924407959,
0.34698155522346497,
-0.053151894360780716,
-0.692091166973114,
-0.4470224678516388,
1.088957667350769,
-0.3213444650173187,
-0.035903409123420715,
0.7451088428497314,
0.934245228767395,
0.24446246027946472,
-0.0369860976934433,
0.352102130651474,
0.10312070697546005,
0.36149734258651733,
0.2737267315387726,
0.9318768978118896,
0.06003737077116966,
0.25940045714378357,
-0.1608263999223709,
-0.3494099974632263,
-0.042752549052238464,
-1.1226009130477905,
-1.0371981859207153,
-0.22684504091739655,
-0.24820612370967865,
-0.4808117747306824,
0.006708926055580378,
1.4005481004714966,
0.8593228459358215,
-0.7765635251998901,
-0.21722576022148132,
-0.30862957239151,
0.6489200592041016,
-0.2677950859069824,
-0.23768079280853271,
0.09683781862258911,
-0.8398222923278809,
-0.3102104067802429,
0.5792753100395203,
0.6273333430290222,
-0.044656902551651,
-0.35277801752090454,
-0.42758968472480774,
-0.13943076133728027,
0.21073397994041443,
0.7179775238037109,
0.29420650005340576,
-0.9280363321304321,
-0.5837414264678955,
0.12172188609838486,
-0.0010934622259810567,
0.3555354177951813,
0.8223139643669128,
-0.6855056881904602,
0.4518689811229706,
0.42897120118141174,
0.4578748345375061,
0.13073256611824036,
-0.1142733246088028,
0.5389907956123352,
-0.6529446840286255,
-0.14898601174354553,
0.2046137899160385,
0.4186444878578186,
0.6042517423629761,
-0.7035070657730103,
0.5769936442375183,
0.4439171850681305,
-0.6178194880485535,
-0.513898491859436,
0.2633521556854248,
-0.6842819452285767,
-0.28464972972869873,
1.2218210697174072,
-0.4147222638130188,
-0.3045717179775238,
-0.43413710594177246,
-0.40110892057418823,
0.19972795248031616,
-0.5938384532928467,
0.8134288191795349,
0.6769835948944092,
-0.5391156673431396,
-0.47685620188713074,
0.08742544054985046,
0.4712570607662201,
0.4690034091472626,
-0.9653505086898804,
0.1100156158208847,
0.6378952860832214,
0.48950672149658203,
0.28185954689979553,
0.8015074133872986,
-0.06673917919397354,
0.20918281376361847,
-0.25051069259643555,
0.10879754275083542,
-0.04004869982600212,
-0.7532827258110046,
-0.17597037553787231,
0.22358141839504242,
0.31691962480545044,
0.2915163040161133
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19056v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19056v1
|
CAUSE: Counterfactual Assessment of User Satisfaction Estimation in Task-Oriented Dialogue Systems
| 2024-03-27T23:45:31 | 2024-03-27T23:45:31 |
Amin Abolghasemi, Zhaochun Ren, Arian Askari, Mohammad Aliannejadi, Maarten de Rijke, Suzan Verberne
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
An important unexplored aspect in previous work on user satisfaction
estimation for Task-Oriented Dialogue (TOD) systems is their evaluation in
terms of robustness for the identification of user dissatisfaction: current
benchmarks for user satisfaction estimation in TOD systems are highly skewed
towards dialogues for which the user is satisfied. The effect of having a more
balanced set of satisfaction labels on performance is unknown. However,
balancing the data with more dissatisfactory dialogue samples requires further
data collection and human annotation, which is costly and time-consuming. In
this work, we leverage large language models (LLMs) and unlock their ability to
generate satisfaction-aware counterfactual dialogues to augment the set of
original dialogues of a test collection. We gather human annotations to ensure
the reliability of the generated samples. We evaluate two open-source LLMs as
user satisfaction estimators on our augmented collection against
state-of-the-art fine-tuned models. Our experiments show that when used as
few-shot user satisfaction estimators, open-source LLMs show higher robustness
to the increase in the number of dissatisfaction labels in the test collection
than the fine-tuned state-of-the-art models. Our results shed light on the need
for data augmentation approaches for user satisfaction estimation in TOD
systems. We release our aligned counterfactual dialogues, which are curated by
human annotation, to facilitate further research on this topic.
|
[
-0.695365309715271,
-0.607075035572052,
0.6991771459579468,
-0.10445179790258408,
-0.33339157700538635,
0.1238834336400032,
0.013710455037653446,
-0.65684974193573,
0.10213927924633026,
0.4764813482761383,
-0.7672797441482544,
-0.09381446242332458,
-0.4869973659515381,
0.13632673025131226,
-0.23974992334842682,
0.9202309250831604,
0.052048854529857635,
0.11845728754997253,
-0.518179178237915,
-0.1929115653038025,
-0.6322852969169617,
-0.423694908618927,
-0.31308794021606445,
-0.463480144739151,
0.4167528450489044,
0.318830668926239,
0.8196871280670166,
-0.17361600697040558,
0.09950979799032211,
0.3388688564300537,
0.22231696546077728,
0.27646881341934204,
-0.4847790002822876,
0.39625218510627747,
-0.2243565320968628,
-0.23663689196109772,
-0.478151798248291,
0.11549536138772964,
0.04545216262340546,
0.6174309849739075,
0.03956263139843941,
0.2465926706790924,
0.20824900269508362,
0.24950076639652252,
-0.7220912575721741,
0.11523238569498062,
-0.49249476194381714,
-0.13995708525180817,
0.01983078010380268,
0.028227996081113815,
-0.3335039019584656,
-0.3020128905773163,
0.21439416706562042,
-0.46577832102775574,
-0.23654228448867798,
-0.216292142868042,
0.719937801361084,
0.4570366144180298,
-0.2361859530210495,
-0.2470497041940689,
-0.7603297829627991,
1.1172213554382324,
-0.9878966212272644,
0.33638060092926025,
0.44063082337379456,
0.023091426119208336,
-0.30304715037345886,
-0.3383558988571167,
-0.8437979817390442,
-0.39136990904808044,
-0.13584576547145844,
0.35427290201187134,
-0.2726036310195923,
-0.06260766834020615,
0.2859088182449341,
0.34288424253463745,
-0.5898420810699463,
0.2703206241130829,
0.2529030740261078,
-0.0907357931137085,
0.6912741661071777,
0.39225125312805176,
0.2903049886226654,
-0.27414077520370483,
-0.3939706087112427,
0.09767457097768784,
-0.486137330532074,
0.2036462277173996,
0.3680286705493927,
0.12240023165941238,
0.01586485095322132,
0.6306073665618896,
-0.4099738597869873,
0.9327324628829956,
0.056014664471149445,
-0.20767921209335327,
0.34869271516799927,
-0.566300094127655,
-0.3680552840232849,
-0.3848888576030731,
0.9961691498756409,
0.510019063949585,
0.299313485622406,
-0.21420079469680786,
-0.43962493538856506,
0.2217349410057068,
0.40270933508872986,
-0.6973350644111633,
-0.18485043942928314,
0.5299334526062012,
-0.08662905544042587,
-0.17014345526695251,
-0.016171813011169434,
-0.6383089423179626,
-0.4715268909931183,
-0.5579029321670532,
0.4927966296672821,
-0.20007573068141937,
-0.19690991938114166,
-0.28275564312934875,
0.10186837613582611,
-0.18070189654827118,
0.3994549810886383,
-0.5043361783027649,
-0.10176458209753036,
0.6913870573043823,
0.6267926096916199,
-0.17813925445079803,
-0.033731307834386826,
-0.6865101456642151,
-0.08729951083660126,
-0.4640527069568634,
0.6971350312232971,
-0.4925555884838104,
-0.5833615064620972,
-0.03109043650329113,
-0.1567167043685913,
0.00733244139701128,
-0.43549636006355286,
0.5366811752319336,
-0.2843448221683502,
0.39158475399017334,
-0.32124802470207214,
-0.4234447777271271,
0.10234271734952927,
0.42284226417541504,
-0.28566041588783264,
1.1407228708267212,
0.2350497841835022,
-0.6365162134170532,
0.40107783675193787,
-0.641593337059021,
-0.2351611852645874,
0.12253303080797195,
-0.08499693125486374,
-0.33088669180870056,
0.3087165355682373,
0.11917328834533691,
0.21093153953552246,
-0.428352028131485,
0.6007309556007385,
-0.4731289744377136,
-0.37910494208335876,
0.7218503355979919,
-0.5548282861709595,
0.8103559017181396,
0.3101128041744232,
-0.3644018769264221,
0.1353214681148529,
-0.4727659821510315,
-0.006776893045753241,
-0.3759140372276306,
-0.11820724606513977,
-0.5356631875038147,
-0.08385536819696426,
-0.0782611295580864,
0.3962534964084625,
0.4638877809047699,
-1.108303189277649,
0.16864478588104248,
-0.5137434005737305,
-0.05478956550359726,
0.6799348592758179,
-0.10683563351631165,
-0.08308722823858261,
-0.30739596486091614,
0.4215881824493408,
0.1984403282403946,
0.2729138433933258,
-0.09697982668876648,
-0.608826756477356,
-0.5705727338790894,
-0.43120232224464417,
0.24327872693538666,
0.5145200490951538,
-0.7582683563232422,
0.5457456111907959,
-0.41025903820991516,
-0.6452279090881348,
-0.3312138617038727,
0.31291550397872925,
0.598028302192688,
0.7991265058517456,
0.2602022588253021,
-0.565392255783081,
-0.6274383664131165,
-0.7746384143829346,
-0.199417382478714,
-0.44957435131073,
-0.23292602598667145,
0.4699563682079315,
0.34990090131759644,
-0.3756166994571686,
1.1735572814941406,
-0.3345044255256653,
-0.057981837540864944,
-0.1623479425907135,
0.4980206787586212,
0.12179984152317047,
0.4211023151874542,
0.3927765190601349,
-0.7122376561164856,
-0.5509915947914124,
-0.036017097532749176,
-0.6981520056724548,
-0.36386576294898987,
-0.00984236691147089,
0.25049954652786255,
0.5779197216033936,
0.10629983246326447,
-0.7625285983085632,
0.5091466307640076,
0.5963708758354187,
-0.2696974575519562,
0.6198731660842896,
0.08430671691894531,
0.3772681951522827,
-0.9607827663421631,
0.1269383579492569,
0.07041171938180923,
-0.3503713309764862,
-0.5958325862884521,
-0.09539393335580826,
-0.3459036946296692,
0.035600777715444565,
-0.24973858892917633,
0.6421668529510498,
-0.1957673579454422,
-0.16939681768417358,
-0.3818080723285675,
0.27142614126205444,
-0.08094320446252823,
0.6436334848403931,
-0.11172585934400558,
0.8633551001548767,
0.28197064995765686,
-0.24110516905784607,
0.28832435607910156,
0.43271586298942566,
-0.4470205008983612,
0.8611304759979248,
-0.6314570307731628,
0.018459748476743698,
0.10076531022787094,
0.33313730359077454,
-1.493236780166626,
-0.19606110453605652,
0.2576337158679962,
-0.5039623379707336,
-0.01158759742975235,
-0.1637994945049286,
-0.4256322979927063,
-0.2619101107120514,
-0.26804423332214355,
0.1008092537522316,
0.5470760464668274,
-0.493694931268692,
0.6359581351280212,
0.42995232343673706,
-0.40033361315727234,
-0.5434703230857849,
-0.4904971122741699,
0.2731914818286896,
-0.13076700270175934,
-0.384285569190979,
-0.1355375349521637,
-0.25176143646240234,
-0.20136061310768127,
-0.23679746687412262,
-0.22113145887851715,
0.0228789821267128,
0.2101365625858307,
0.7133913040161133,
0.5605278015136719,
0.03537512198090553,
0.18385177850723267,
-0.17452964186668396,
-0.1679675281047821,
-0.0346355140209198,
-0.1750081479549408,
0.44706565141677856,
0.14178243279457092,
-0.45816487073898315,
-0.580248236656189,
0.39834052324295044,
0.635269820690155,
-0.06545411050319672,
0.42283469438552856,
0.7412135601043701,
-0.13497081398963928,
0.39220887422561646,
-0.8265568614006042,
-0.05216507613658905,
-0.42553749680519104,
0.1786874532699585,
-0.4752013683319092,
-0.7381813526153564,
0.5591445565223694,
-0.015294374898076057,
0.25784462690353394,
0.3580974340438843,
0.44149330258369446,
-0.3789694607257843,
1.3664424419403076,
0.12593385577201843,
0.047102052718400955,
0.5573390126228333,
0.007435904815793037,
0.03167932480573654,
-0.7433782815933228,
-0.07343940436840057,
-0.6019713878631592,
-0.20774689316749573,
-0.5669834017753601,
-0.14134496450424194,
0.37912431359291077,
-0.0111638642847538,
-0.33819425106048584,
0.18271778523921967,
-0.07059092074632645,
0.0012803153367713094,
0.4330061078071594,
0.04948164150118828,
0.3781772255897522,
0.01866891235113144,
-0.060726042836904526,
-0.18017646670341492,
-0.40635502338409424,
-0.4991849362850189,
1.033384084701538,
0.25234776735305786,
0.6576146483421326,
0.31651610136032104,
0.6130152344703674,
0.36104029417037964,
0.5428590178489685,
-0.6608014106750488,
0.48438823223114014,
-0.3244773745536804,
-0.3422980010509491,
-0.48178866505622864,
-0.5456172823905945,
-0.7051253914833069,
-0.03230363503098488,
-0.2105962187051773,
-1.2262581586837769,
0.40212616324424744,
0.33264321088790894,
-0.31646451354026794,
-0.11438123881816864,
-0.7826640009880066,
0.9171501994132996,
-0.12074185162782669,
-0.5429556965827942,
0.016382519155740738,
-0.3701038062572479,
0.35808879137039185,
-0.13210999965667725,
-0.010782723315060139,
0.09741658717393875,
0.14695535600185394,
0.6950600147247314,
-0.767451286315918,
1.0945632457733154,
-0.44911038875579834,
-0.3272629380226135,
0.2543085515499115,
0.0878647193312645,
0.7951470017433167,
0.011015214957296848,
-0.12007400393486023,
0.028904935345053673,
0.022427253425121307,
-0.4178071916103363,
-0.7237046957015991,
0.9916774034500122,
-0.7748358845710754,
-0.9340519309043884,
-0.2350310981273651,
-0.690218985080719,
-0.7807933688163757,
0.0075192563235759735,
-0.09142592549324036,
0.6580417156219482,
-0.10211450606584549,
0.16037683188915253,
0.5146247148513794,
-0.0755554810166359,
0.5361328721046448,
0.45752960443496704,
-0.2331348955631256,
-0.23826777935028076,
0.8747363686561584,
0.11892996728420258,
0.44350025057792664,
0.08654848486185074,
0.1881323605775833,
-0.7495223879814148,
-0.4782920777797699,
-0.7311990261077881,
-0.179382786154747,
-0.3519107699394226,
-0.2354477196931839,
-0.7857085466384888,
0.1486838161945343,
-0.3560344874858856,
0.17433056235313416,
-0.30917027592658997,
-0.4711920917034149,
-0.1737026870250702,
0.009969612583518028,
0.239531472325325,
0.7234693765640259,
0.030493643134832382,
0.3390662670135498,
-0.7380343675613403,
0.47841665148735046,
0.538214385509491,
0.3702458441257477,
-0.017077531665563583,
-0.523789644241333,
-0.2872438430786133,
0.3898104131221771,
-0.39979276061058044,
-0.8511239290237427,
0.3614004850387573,
-0.22346171736717224,
0.599770724773407,
0.16850288212299347,
0.3132137358188629,
0.8987414836883545,
0.142681285738945,
1.0434355735778809,
0.37682080268859863,
-0.9312499761581421,
0.295564204454422,
-0.3752501904964447,
0.5017880797386169,
0.6065517067909241,
0.31705141067504883,
-0.2787560224533081,
-0.5339218378067017,
-0.40162473917007446,
-0.7152026891708374,
0.715252697467804,
-0.028911663219332695,
0.04817315191030502,
0.0017844396643340588,
-0.09237033873796463,
0.14256277680397034,
0.24031604826450348,
-0.6202917695045471,
-0.14603078365325928,
-0.5389351844787598,
-0.4614515006542206,
-0.3563040494918823,
-0.4460902214050293,
-0.22485801577568054,
0.18053358793258667,
0.73405921459198,
-0.13896673917770386,
-0.10036589950323105,
0.3364255726337433,
-0.12443917989730835,
-0.3064175844192505,
0.5961254239082336,
0.5612202286720276,
0.8643350005149841,
-0.3354591727256775,
0.0062844534404575825,
0.058133285492658615,
-0.24049633741378784,
0.16771194338798523,
0.255440354347229,
-0.22910548746585846,
0.0925530418753624,
-0.06716908514499664,
0.8233247399330139,
-0.0153873972594738,
-0.8737547993659973,
0.575680673122406,
0.04224995896220207,
0.17829281091690063,
-0.3502737283706665,
0.0973687469959259,
0.08689553290605545,
0.02552802301943302,
0.5351965427398682,
0.2257664054632187,
0.3131841719150543,
-0.622812807559967,
-0.018098492175340652,
0.8284624218940735,
-0.8739933967590332,
-0.23030412197113037,
0.2744322419166565,
0.3239997625350952,
-0.3635196387767792,
0.3336637020111084,
-0.19837571680545807,
-0.4002883732318878,
0.10847330093383789,
0.24987395107746124,
0.897329568862915,
-0.227265864610672,
0.3068757653236389,
0.31803208589553833,
0.09377247095108032,
0.056385889649391174,
0.32945388555526733,
-0.20909392833709717,
-0.45992475748062134,
-0.6391075849533081,
-0.5471140742301941,
-0.4759366512298584,
0.2332853078842163,
-0.3971361517906189,
-0.1602785885334015,
0.10545854270458221,
-0.41538259387016296,
-0.18876774609088898,
0.12517304718494415,
-0.6087141036987305,
0.4577330946922302,
-0.14770518243312836,
0.4885748028755188,
-0.8744136691093445,
0.5483711957931519,
0.5059828758239746,
-0.45241960883140564,
-0.5292941331863403,
-0.054767318069934845,
-0.06429353356361389,
-0.45238763093948364,
0.759777843952179,
-0.037741102278232574,
-0.2302585244178772,
-0.2194119691848755,
-0.3407202959060669,
-0.3945979177951813,
0.7572591304779053,
0.38763073086738586,
-0.6893652677536011,
0.3657366931438446,
0.45443251729011536,
0.7955802083015442,
-0.4470134377479553,
0.7536389827728271,
0.2429634928703308,
0.5752314329147339,
0.025753078982234,
-1.1300373077392578,
0.07714638859033585,
-0.3036738634109497,
-0.06157451122999191,
0.18009673058986664,
-0.25042101740837097,
0.47796931862831116,
0.014797837473452091,
-0.11785971373319626,
0.4690435528755188,
0.35514354705810547,
0.26312559843063354,
0.4677121937274933,
0.8357553482055664,
0.651591956615448,
0.2764224112033844,
-0.24242645502090454,
1.1921042203903198,
-0.10070756077766418,
0.1297159641981125,
1.408830165863037,
-0.14341890811920166,
0.7528969645500183,
0.7384905815124512,
-0.14287972450256348,
0.5072495341300964,
0.5156413316726685,
0.1818629503250122,
0.07040691375732422,
0.014875717461109161,
-0.17617616057395935,
-0.6642259359359741,
-0.6221446394920349,
-0.11351272463798523,
0.39589253067970276,
0.23488636314868927,
-0.17717792093753815,
0.03750578686594963,
-0.09635044634342194,
-0.3339739143848419,
-0.0017272403929382563,
-0.04088635370135307,
1.0461231470108032,
-0.15889869630336761,
-1.104549765586853,
0.5684979557991028,
-0.39207589626312256,
0.5651963353157043,
-0.3049856424331665,
-0.022315412759780884,
-0.34550023078918457,
-0.18983952701091766,
-0.2820073962211609,
-0.8754791617393494,
0.041265495121479034,
0.22669552266597748,
-0.11838800460100174,
-0.10408476740121841,
0.44826170802116394,
-0.3895167410373688,
-0.5372662544250488,
0.039361752569675446,
0.7722321152687073,
0.20521050691604614,
0.05964207276701927,
-0.501011312007904,
0.06873226165771484,
0.21975362300872803,
-0.31744176149368286,
0.3140029311180115,
0.08017461001873016,
-0.13442912697792053,
0.6538918614387512,
0.7669966816902161,
-0.08450309187173843,
-0.20178091526031494,
0.21327224373817444,
0.703344464302063,
-0.3392423987388611,
-0.3193213641643524,
-0.5944819450378418,
0.8381203413009644,
-0.22456389665603638,
-0.38320228457450867,
0.68973708152771,
0.3713657557964325,
0.732265830039978,
-0.16756610572338104,
0.8581482172012329,
0.09342887997627258,
0.8761852383613586,
-0.17083638906478882,
0.3325745463371277,
-0.6462544798851013,
0.4657805860042572,
-0.5244689583778381,
-0.8049203753471375,
0.18336479365825653,
0.08136967569589615,
-0.5266412496566772,
0.14821761846542358,
0.024326074868440628,
0.9220432043075562,
-0.24317766726016998,
0.01768484152853489,
0.5819266438484192,
0.36472514271736145,
0.29636117815971375,
0.4491952061653137,
1.1481075286865234,
-0.41929206252098083,
0.5356674194335938,
-0.0360637903213501,
-0.15959210693836212,
-0.2687184512615204,
-0.7456847429275513,
-0.6782927513122559,
-0.6098328828811646,
-0.44381994009017944,
-0.08847597986459732,
0.1664547473192215,
0.7086734175682068,
0.5141196846961975,
-0.9118348360061646,
-0.14109712839126587,
-0.07470382004976273,
0.09554135054349899,
0.06811534613370895,
-0.2830357253551483,
-0.001020446652546525,
-0.3025655150413513,
-0.9906834959983826,
0.2044634073972702,
0.2344530075788498,
0.06938023120164871,
-0.44744956493377686,
-0.2644639015197754,
-0.22947591543197632,
0.14117775857448578,
0.46419376134872437,
0.3628491461277008,
-1.06546151638031,
-0.4290488660335541,
-0.02810605615377426,
-0.1680329442024231,
-0.07091640681028366,
0.6799008250236511,
-0.8699486255645752,
0.6974148154258728,
0.5850779414176941,
0.5122873187065125,
0.35688894987106323,
0.36993634700775146,
0.7148306965827942,
-0.7004230618476868,
-0.20157140493392944,
-0.09040584415197372,
0.297288179397583,
0.5143139362335205,
-0.18780140578746796,
0.3761211037635803,
-0.021369783207774162,
-0.4903968870639801,
-1.0507543087005615,
0.42293310165405273,
-1.1437071561813354,
-0.16095824539661407,
0.8437082171440125,
-0.6696701049804688,
0.2753649652004242,
-0.6000581979751587,
-0.21860937774181366,
0.2635185122489929,
-0.5358049869537354,
0.8795488476753235,
0.5317543745040894,
-0.38522812724113464,
-0.07324282079935074,
-0.22256726026535034,
0.45666131377220154,
0.7856089472770691,
-0.8187806010246277,
0.17128311097621918,
0.7350081205368042,
0.0538167804479599,
0.5772413015365601,
0.42419007420539856,
0.05421612411737442,
0.37548401951789856,
-0.22812572121620178,
-0.1505945771932602,
-0.22398260235786438,
0.034593138843774796,
-0.06686464697122574,
0.25040918588638306,
0.21646222472190857,
-0.048856303095817566
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19031v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19031v1
|
Evaluating Large Language Models for Health-Related Text Classification Tasks with Public Social Media Data
| 2024-03-27T22:05:10 | 2024-03-27T22:05:10 |
Yuting Guo, Anthony Ovadje, Mohammed Ali Al-Garadi, Abeed Sarker
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable success in NLP
tasks. However, there is a paucity of studies that attempt to evaluate their
performances on social media-based health-related natural language processing
tasks, which have traditionally been difficult to achieve high scores in. We
benchmarked one supervised classic machine learning model based on Support
Vector Machines (SVMs), three supervised pretrained language models (PLMs)
based on RoBERTa, BERTweet, and SocBERT, and two LLM based classifiers (GPT3.5
and GPT4), across 6 text classification tasks. We developed three approaches
for leveraging LLMs for text classification: employing LLMs as zero-shot
classifiers, us-ing LLMs as annotators to annotate training data for supervised
classifiers, and utilizing LLMs with few-shot examples for augmentation of
manually annotated data. Our comprehensive experiments demonstrate that
employ-ing data augmentation using LLMs (GPT-4) with relatively small
human-annotated data to train lightweight supervised classification models
achieves superior results compared to training with human-annotated data alone.
Supervised learners also outperform GPT-4 and GPT-3.5 in zero-shot settings. By
leveraging this data augmentation strategy, we can harness the power of LLMs to
develop smaller, more effective domain-specific NLP models. LLM-annotated data
without human guidance for training light-weight supervised classification
models is an ineffective strategy. However, LLM, as a zero-shot classifier,
shows promise in excluding false negatives and potentially reducing the human
effort required for data annotation. Future investigations are imperative to
explore optimal training data sizes and the optimal amounts of augmented data.
|
[
0.018552983179688454,
-0.6872832775115967,
0.6725658178329468,
0.006478975992649794,
-0.4155850112438202,
0.10453923046588898,
-0.39820900559425354,
-0.6607933640480042,
0.2965048551559448,
0.5367868542671204,
-0.27574053406715393,
-0.9066893458366394,
-0.844217836856842,
0.34793633222579956,
-0.3718939423561096,
1.0963144302368164,
-0.0382160022854805,
0.2864992320537567,
-0.27967074513435364,
-0.16978514194488525,
-0.2852173149585724,
-0.8672497272491455,
-0.5730817317962646,
-0.5520491003990173,
0.7778553366661072,
0.3693434000015259,
0.5379558801651001,
0.573650598526001,
0.7957859039306641,
0.19587771594524384,
-0.0853475034236908,
0.17755374312400818,
-0.5326551198959351,
0.023018423467874527,
-0.016433943063020706,
-0.2242565155029297,
-0.46574199199676514,
0.10791528970003128,
0.4012373983860016,
0.7636749744415283,
0.19010384380817413,
0.2564639151096344,
0.04663936048746109,
0.520175039768219,
-0.5758931040763855,
0.02566641941666603,
-0.5912646651268005,
0.023578593507409096,
-0.15891820192337036,
-0.42562785744667053,
-0.3293391168117523,
-0.38154903054237366,
0.14286571741104126,
-0.3212457001209259,
0.09272807836532593,
-0.1055360659956932,
0.762428879737854,
0.28263840079307556,
-0.5379443764686584,
-0.09204675257205963,
-0.7938898801803589,
0.793408215045929,
-0.7562507390975952,
0.3509477972984314,
0.56488037109375,
0.18099729716777802,
-0.003168757539242506,
-0.6266583800315857,
-0.38400086760520935,
-0.1684630960226059,
0.010003414005041122,
0.10947985202074051,
-0.2380499243736267,
0.20433993637561798,
0.3161839544773102,
0.2370881736278534,
-0.6934854984283447,
0.44197091460227966,
-0.4302781820297241,
-0.010082961060106754,
0.8102564215660095,
0.010582100600004196,
0.16474434733390808,
-0.4442284405231476,
-0.25323066115379333,
0.058356206864118576,
-0.5988972187042236,
-0.17653638124465942,
-0.03980094939470291,
0.4665677547454834,
-0.011048294603824615,
0.7388148903846741,
-0.37826865911483765,
0.675990104675293,
-0.2482285350561142,
-0.3239254355430603,
0.608202338218689,
-0.17514429986476898,
-0.34400108456611633,
0.049239691346883774,
0.8336470723152161,
0.6536139845848083,
0.2488524466753006,
-0.31617313623428345,
-0.16998682916164398,
0.1829633116722107,
0.2194051444530487,
-0.9231389760971069,
-0.05932444706559181,
0.102796770632267,
-0.458330899477005,
-0.3627612590789795,
-0.18604302406311035,
-0.45534181594848633,
-0.6007870435714722,
-0.4278584122657776,
0.5160377621650696,
-0.3392152786254883,
0.029690001159906387,
0.3471214473247528,
0.06500301510095596,
-0.020334679633378983,
0.39205512404441833,
-0.6571729183197021,
0.36794722080230713,
0.7828844785690308,
0.9681333899497986,
-0.3780115246772766,
-0.00323743699118495,
-0.5874213576316833,
0.053630102425813675,
-0.3174121677875519,
0.7414442300796509,
-0.4473717510700226,
-0.13538305461406708,
0.24322271347045898,
0.08737717568874359,
-0.045407332479953766,
-0.5325064659118652,
0.8783295154571533,
-0.32161450386047363,
0.11728547513484955,
-0.23464509844779968,
-0.7725292444229126,
-0.14079533517360687,
0.3653149902820587,
-0.5184467434883118,
0.9954066872596741,
0.05324472859501839,
-0.8994863629341125,
0.45901432633399963,
-0.46328651905059814,
-0.700043261051178,
0.26590582728385925,
-0.22971086204051971,
-0.6157307028770447,
0.11434266716241837,
0.4212135076522827,
1.1208083629608154,
-0.3815973997116089,
0.2315845489501953,
-0.6494378447532654,
-0.5694541931152344,
0.11824037879705429,
-0.36406469345092773,
0.570104718208313,
-0.10817213356494904,
-0.1659216582775116,
0.16111013293266296,
-0.703765869140625,
-0.22795285284519196,
0.22928456962108612,
-0.31669846177101135,
-0.5591186285018921,
0.010940363630652428,
0.22235646843910217,
0.26413410902023315,
0.07789096981287003,
-0.6626638174057007,
0.09452399611473083,
-0.4284519851207733,
0.43509405851364136,
0.4656684398651123,
0.1375972479581833,
0.22122378647327423,
-0.5766511559486389,
0.3265519440174103,
-0.3742924630641937,
0.1495037078857422,
-0.08165193349123001,
-0.4853813350200653,
-0.47064918279647827,
-0.3305116593837738,
0.25159892439842224,
0.5900842547416687,
-1.0184003114700317,
0.5465530753135681,
-0.6604810953140259,
-0.6451319456100464,
-0.5531486868858337,
0.23109593987464905,
0.13590824604034424,
0.5669618844985962,
0.5242912173271179,
-0.13215652108192444,
-0.2888847589492798,
-0.8552465438842773,
-0.18184584379196167,
-0.08291247487068176,
-0.29193514585494995,
0.3821101188659668,
0.44474002718925476,
-0.4218084216117859,
0.6288313269615173,
-0.36279889941215515,
-0.3286416530609131,
-0.3871743381023407,
0.2245534509420395,
0.029463304206728935,
0.1054956242442131,
0.428642600774765,
-0.7110251784324646,
-0.44005388021469116,
0.049184560775756836,
-0.7556201219558716,
-0.29409059882164,
0.11630760133266449,
0.2740135192871094,
0.16706113517284393,
0.1647004783153534,
-0.5361805558204651,
0.5352540016174316,
0.5576304793357849,
0.03486258164048195,
0.2819577753543854,
0.05774371698498726,
0.21081192791461945,
-0.9540395736694336,
0.027097824960947037,
0.4337034523487091,
-0.47804754972457886,
-0.8730692267417908,
-0.35662946105003357,
0.13531853258609772,
-0.03454658389091492,
-0.5190576314926147,
0.44470110535621643,
-0.23830646276474,
0.04636336863040924,
-0.4476453959941864,
-0.03799258545041084,
-0.03513528034090996,
0.1777491718530655,
0.19940419495105743,
0.26527029275894165,
0.5117006897926331,
-0.3865549564361572,
0.37491264939308167,
-0.08891749382019043,
-0.2518722712993622,
0.3288492262363434,
-0.6683304309844971,
0.14359281957149506,
-0.33103933930397034,
0.2828158438205719,
-0.7740289568901062,
-0.39641156792640686,
0.16977155208587646,
-0.40658149123191833,
0.22905462980270386,
0.05882667377591133,
-0.8456591367721558,
-0.4921572506427765,
-0.6676838397979736,
0.07873009145259857,
0.4225294291973114,
-0.48646533489227295,
0.4014703035354614,
0.4520758390426636,
-0.13394376635551453,
-0.291136771440506,
-0.7311767339706421,
0.17923176288604736,
-0.3587648570537567,
-0.47579002380371094,
0.49649524688720703,
0.11563211679458618,
-0.06099189072847366,
0.05784178525209427,
-0.07546766847372055,
-0.014847341924905777,
0.12823738157749176,
0.3195319175720215,
0.42889776825904846,
0.06697870045900345,
0.530453622341156,
-0.041295964270830154,
0.043358445167541504,
-0.11781337857246399,
0.06629916280508041,
0.4457883834838867,
0.05634554475545883,
-0.3564969003200531,
-0.5463001728057861,
0.08660425245761871,
0.35170820355415344,
-0.1162252128124237,
0.7348132729530334,
0.6714490056037903,
-0.7122208476066589,
-0.09138031303882599,
-0.7312357425689697,
-0.23296687006950378,
-0.36879509687423706,
0.3631088137626648,
0.15925006568431854,
-1.1145267486572266,
0.04614173620939255,
0.0008560818387195468,
0.19561493396759033,
0.32301247119903564,
0.6251773834228516,
-0.11435602605342865,
0.8989887237548828,
0.4657933712005615,
-0.35215577483177185,
0.4367027282714844,
-0.1134650856256485,
0.11769410967826843,
-0.5013562440872192,
-0.002265285002067685,
-0.38214829564094543,
-0.09346885234117508,
-0.5824636220932007,
-0.6286509037017822,
0.35443609952926636,
-0.012302401475608349,
0.00009671991574577987,
0.2553979456424713,
-0.6152980327606201,
0.23710885643959045,
0.25593507289886475,
0.42232745885849,
0.3230472207069397,
0.044818077236413956,
0.40511375665664673,
-0.06344328075647354,
-0.5893323421478271,
-0.6925681233406067,
1.4126782417297363,
0.7432961463928223,
0.7098520994186401,
-0.2750293016433716,
0.782660961151123,
0.21323497593402863,
0.7923344373703003,
-0.9167553186416626,
0.44573819637298584,
-0.5255218148231506,
-0.4674472510814667,
-0.21621885895729065,
-0.5405941009521484,
-0.8401705622673035,
0.12497976422309875,
-0.5951361060142517,
-0.5785355567932129,
-0.25142306089401245,
-0.016350526362657547,
-0.41397610306739807,
0.15498726069927216,
-0.6790897250175476,
0.7314742207527161,
-0.5854876041412354,
-0.34272199869155884,
-0.019630584865808487,
-0.4936326742172241,
0.3026216924190521,
-0.3761429786682129,
0.30993902683258057,
-0.2891369163990021,
-0.09591545164585114,
0.8149753212928772,
-0.188582181930542,
0.8945154547691345,
0.03470185026526451,
0.16289189457893372,
0.013014939613640308,
-0.4873787760734558,
0.2539026141166687,
-0.08610062301158905,
-0.10205619782209396,
0.34379881620407104,
-0.024563880637288094,
-0.29350391030311584,
-0.4797343611717224,
0.6391196846961975,
-0.6722296476364136,
-0.3921734392642975,
-0.48645392060279846,
-0.2192697525024414,
-0.3408692181110382,
0.08104082942008972,
0.16097846627235413,
0.26142165064811707,
-0.00626190984621644,
0.5545353293418884,
0.4851182699203491,
-0.30501943826675415,
0.15984396636486053,
0.6276609897613525,
-0.2825716733932495,
-0.4119265079498291,
0.8864506483078003,
0.33020827174186707,
0.09644842892885208,
0.5202937722206116,
0.3279089331626892,
-0.22841985523700714,
-0.8611911535263062,
-0.09911539405584335,
0.2186705619096756,
-0.5773388147354126,
-0.36879944801330566,
-0.6897522807121277,
-0.4535508155822754,
-0.6057595610618591,
0.007487453054636717,
-0.07775876671075821,
-0.1160341128706932,
-0.42515772581100464,
-0.3298869729042053,
0.49590763449668884,
0.7412935495376587,
0.13054393231868744,
0.3476071059703827,
-0.8345081806182861,
0.44566991925239563,
0.17242880165576935,
0.31000179052352905,
-0.13678096234798431,
-0.4191528856754303,
-0.27007031440734863,
-0.09944002330303192,
-0.204194575548172,
-1.0137248039245605,
0.3640492558479309,
0.08805394172668457,
0.4924573302268982,
0.3075549304485321,
0.10658814758062363,
0.4933893084526062,
-0.589831531047821,
0.614283561706543,
0.2615526020526886,
-0.5957120060920715,
0.48427167534828186,
-0.3157420754432678,
0.12898977100849152,
0.7060371041297913,
0.7232176661491394,
-0.5546171069145203,
-0.23920559883117676,
-0.2674235701560974,
-0.8269329071044922,
0.472152441740036,
0.2984369397163391,
0.07668744772672653,
-0.15474578738212585,
0.44511678814888,
0.011969028040766716,
0.054688550531864166,
-0.7998318672180176,
-0.17851439118385315,
0.13124094903469086,
-0.36235255002975464,
-0.25587838888168335,
-0.1813390552997589,
0.07869206368923187,
-0.35407814383506775,
0.628487229347229,
-0.0998525321483612,
-0.05440843105316162,
0.2982361316680908,
-0.07032672315835953,
-0.1900506317615509,
0.29228296875953674,
0.24219848215579987,
0.4012109637260437,
-0.3143823444843292,
0.16406524181365967,
0.34235918521881104,
-0.33453425765037537,
-0.03761521354317665,
0.4360387921333313,
-0.29146164655685425,
0.15087363123893738,
0.6783025860786438,
0.8399192690849304,
0.3214597702026367,
-0.7583643794059753,
0.7140968441963196,
-0.10665159672498703,
-0.20632904767990112,
-0.11642266809940338,
-0.03363722935318947,
0.16228102147579193,
0.08897174894809723,
0.3053551912307739,
-0.2946107089519501,
0.17532140016555786,
-0.3174991309642792,
0.1872844398021698,
0.43478813767433167,
-0.4700433909893036,
-0.2706665098667145,
0.38675421476364136,
0.09205407649278641,
-0.2803295850753784,
0.05315874144434929,
-0.07808168977499008,
-0.3153236210346222,
0.20338258147239685,
0.27347350120544434,
0.669700562953949,
-0.17380961775779724,
0.2814169228076935,
0.2531742751598358,
0.3603774905204773,
-0.27842655777931213,
0.19508472084999084,
0.1813231259584427,
-0.6444613933563232,
-0.726453959941864,
-0.7159048914909363,
-0.43144649267196655,
0.5198532938957214,
-0.5897209644317627,
0.4617052376270294,
-0.40203410387039185,
-0.38917261362075806,
0.42590245604515076,
0.14210514724254608,
-0.8518854379653931,
0.30811479687690735,
0.36813101172447205,
0.7202814817428589,
-1.0794183015823364,
0.8815165162086487,
0.7924228310585022,
-0.29252296686172485,
-0.583229660987854,
0.10031989961862564,
0.11285973340272903,
-0.5890534520149231,
0.5453455448150635,
0.5913811922073364,
0.0751691460609436,
-0.27166977524757385,
-0.6381418704986572,
-0.5354077816009521,
1.032495141029358,
0.3081187307834625,
-0.7136824727058411,
0.020583467558026314,
0.32774433493614197,
0.8384012579917908,
-0.2564004361629486,
0.01712115854024887,
0.40892112255096436,
0.1514715552330017,
0.14649730920791626,
-1.0310497283935547,
-0.054573580622673035,
-0.014218092896044254,
0.037340398877859116,
-0.0343795120716095,
-0.35330989956855774,
0.4790278375148773,
0.09524310380220413,
-0.2731930911540985,
-0.14858679473400116,
0.47067347168922424,
0.3022077977657318,
0.4911239445209503,
0.47457799315452576,
0.6653012037277222,
0.7049636840820312,
0.1299300342798233,
1.0150963068008423,
-0.12071749567985535,
0.3527972400188446,
0.9792616963386536,
-0.6379404067993164,
1.0634361505508423,
0.21101014316082,
-0.1488885134458542,
0.10030098259449005,
0.6690526604652405,
0.044508252292871475,
0.2753642201423645,
0.21029658615589142,
-0.3536454737186432,
-0.21044716238975525,
-0.42148759961128235,
-0.10048441588878632,
0.3617152273654938,
0.3052220642566681,
-0.5436107516288757,
-0.1511945128440857,
0.2937191128730774,
0.11056581884622574,
0.12915854156017303,
-0.34663188457489014,
0.8965246677398682,
0.2288789600133896,
-0.25802889466285706,
0.5318406820297241,
0.16487516462802887,
0.8904269337654114,
-0.40707552433013916,
0.040557898581027985,
0.22535063326358795,
0.043228600174188614,
-0.38659223914146423,
-0.7295072674751282,
0.3132147789001465,
0.31856709718704224,
-0.04479886218905449,
-0.2533724009990692,
1.2055799961090088,
-0.3773857355117798,
-0.8447926640510559,
0.5063663125038147,
0.35430920124053955,
0.2132561206817627,
-0.25434228777885437,
-0.6280096173286438,
0.15197454392910004,
-0.22990623116493225,
-0.313273549079895,
0.3331417739391327,
0.31728777289390564,
-0.07242827862501144,
0.515336811542511,
0.7548893094062805,
0.39251914620399475,
-0.20161257684230804,
0.3403892517089844,
0.9151159524917603,
-0.5900902152061462,
-0.10948013514280319,
-1.0209800004959106,
0.16183927655220032,
-0.2599392235279083,
-0.07697872072458267,
0.7907121777534485,
0.5622732639312744,
0.7950326204299927,
0.2269963026046753,
0.9422425031661987,
0.28428107500076294,
1.039798378944397,
-0.4527730643749237,
0.6343211531639099,
-0.6034988164901733,
0.1515299528837204,
-0.28051045536994934,
-0.653162956237793,
-0.67934250831604,
0.5240952968597412,
-0.7984520196914673,
-0.03167827054858208,
0.45912832021713257,
0.5489765405654907,
0.1810295581817627,
-0.002935894997790456,
0.4185830354690552,
0.021738670766353607,
0.32845979928970337,
0.48315221071243286,
0.6518028378486633,
-0.26502570509910583,
0.2725684940814972,
-0.4930398464202881,
-0.3544967472553253,
-0.33709144592285156,
-0.8276264071464539,
-1.2081526517868042,
-0.2851438522338867,
-0.29627561569213867,
-0.15567080676555634,
0.1766672283411026,
1.250849723815918,
0.8084211945533752,
-0.6628614664077759,
0.1373741179704666,
0.15981197357177734,
-0.14275120198726654,
0.04613984748721123,
-0.20820391178131104,
0.37559446692466736,
-0.1500672549009323,
-0.5214173793792725,
0.28530991077423096,
0.42923644185066223,
0.11875762045383453,
-0.25149983167648315,
0.06971164792776108,
-0.13038387894630432,
-0.18167851865291595,
0.9157798886299133,
0.04156818240880966,
-0.6481869220733643,
-0.22002945840358734,
0.10392550379037857,
-0.30422571301460266,
0.02310789003968239,
0.527407169342041,
-0.6137016415596008,
0.27424922585487366,
0.3759409189224243,
1.0424563884735107,
0.5038920640945435,
0.18997734785079956,
0.18451529741287231,
-0.5925260186195374,
-0.15370336174964905,
0.6136166453361511,
0.27313926815986633,
0.7183511257171631,
-0.312850683927536,
0.49027082324028015,
0.2223527580499649,
-0.6282118558883667,
-0.8927374482154846,
-0.1510263979434967,
-0.9948537349700928,
-0.33278000354766846,
1.4674032926559448,
-0.012270367704331875,
-0.19716374576091766,
-0.16546137630939484,
-0.18674984574317932,
0.29253312945365906,
-0.3026745319366455,
0.7990575432777405,
0.6211555004119873,
-0.1631971299648285,
-0.11105652153491974,
-1.016791582107544,
0.42140549421310425,
0.20047728717327118,
-1.0730913877487183,
-0.008734792470932007,
0.4186627268791199,
0.2554815113544464,
0.03237755969166756,
0.8314883708953857,
-0.009052915498614311,
-0.0317983515560627,
-0.6033108234405518,
0.031324755400419235,
0.0451502650976181,
-0.19645193219184875,
-0.5642969012260437,
0.02912195213139057,
-0.03739249333739281,
-0.02524750493466854
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19021v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19021v2
|
IDGenRec: LLM-RecSys Alignment with Textual ID Learning
| 2024-03-27T21:22:37 | 2024-05-17T04:05:18 |
Juntao Tan, Shuyuan Xu, Wenyue Hua, Yingqiang Ge, Zelong Li, Yongfeng Zhang
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Generative recommendation based on Large Language Models (LLMs) have
transformed the traditional ranking-based recommendation style into a
text-to-text generation paradigm. However, in contrast to standard NLP tasks
that inherently operate on human vocabulary, current research in generative
recommendations struggles to effectively encode recommendation items within the
text-to-text framework using concise yet meaningful ID representations. To
better align LLMs with recommendation needs, we propose IDGen, representing
each item as a unique, concise, semantically rich, platform-agnostic textual ID
using human language tokens. This is achieved by training a textual ID
generator alongside the LLM-based recommender, enabling seamless integration of
personalized recommendations into natural language generation. Notably, as user
history is expressed in natural language and decoupled from the original
dataset, our approach suggests the potential for a foundational generative
recommendation model. Experiments show that our framework consistently
surpasses existing models in sequential recommendation under standard
experimental setting. Then, we explore the possibility of training a foundation
recommendation model with the proposed method on data collected from 19
different datasets and tested its recommendation performance on 6 unseen
datasets across different platforms under a completely zero-shot setting. The
results show that the zero-shot performance of the pre-trained foundation model
is comparable to or even better than some traditional recommendation models
based on supervised training, showing the potential of the IDGen paradigm
serving as the foundation model for generative recommendation. Code and data
are open-sourced at https://github.com/agiresearch/IDGenRec.
|
[
-0.30155500769615173,
-0.23225820064544678,
0.4780668318271637,
0.12973767518997192,
-0.23415660858154297,
0.16234733164310455,
-0.09627480059862137,
-0.3280106782913208,
0.2748056948184967,
0.43062520027160645,
-0.9454875588417053,
-0.9608191847801208,
-0.21452753245830536,
0.19520646333694458,
-0.594493567943573,
1.1938378810882568,
0.16889825463294983,
-0.019174091517925262,
-0.6817159056663513,
-0.17558260262012482,
-0.645373523235321,
-0.32240772247314453,
-0.4799964725971222,
-0.7986515760421753,
0.4969633221626282,
0.4619184136390686,
0.33643922209739685,
0.6306204795837402,
0.6158472299575806,
0.14302927255630493,
0.04756953939795494,
0.21639588475227356,
-0.678926944732666,
0.3243674039840698,
-0.4643332064151764,
-0.24260197579860687,
-0.39792394638061523,
-0.0961764007806778,
0.2565763592720032,
0.6438202261924744,
-0.18906615674495697,
0.21999722719192505,
0.264076292514801,
0.9482119083404541,
-0.4064463675022125,
-0.11557578295469284,
-0.7013649940490723,
0.055166471749544144,
-0.13387475907802582,
-0.35764116048812866,
-0.6822590827941895,
-0.4340483546257019,
0.34914785623550415,
-0.6628512144088745,
0.3151552081108093,
0.1716342568397522,
0.7170478105545044,
0.24425765872001648,
-0.3623841106891632,
-0.3109394907951355,
-0.9138725399971008,
0.5440808534622192,
-0.44820740818977356,
0.13358207046985626,
0.34327569603919983,
0.15388108789920807,
-0.35728710889816284,
-0.8517458438873291,
-0.1947837620973587,
-0.2246759980916977,
-0.11196586489677429,
-0.07561242580413818,
-0.1986570954322815,
0.033609602600336075,
0.02757507935166359,
0.6323797702789307,
-0.8122318387031555,
0.31121155619621277,
-0.10818341374397278,
0.09578152745962143,
0.5649283528327942,
0.20812411606311798,
0.236336350440979,
0.1771525889635086,
-0.7563020586967468,
0.002553284168243408,
-0.8701651692390442,
-0.15060997009277344,
0.47808563709259033,
0.45943957567214966,
-0.1718408167362213,
0.5753629207611084,
-0.4499303102493286,
0.7273755669593811,
0.5852848291397095,
-0.050742316991090775,
0.32571834325790405,
-0.6482749581336975,
-0.06449435651302338,
0.24578647315502167,
0.798393964767456,
0.6557014584541321,
0.47376975417137146,
-0.45721080899238586,
0.0008076914236880839,
0.16472621262073517,
0.26995888352394104,
-0.8120388388633728,
-0.2787645161151886,
0.10649421811103821,
-0.3062160015106201,
-0.6025578379631042,
0.25775548815727234,
-0.6168808937072754,
-0.4398168921470642,
-0.48498669266700745,
0.07518255710601807,
-0.6075975298881531,
-0.09196294844150543,
0.13319022953510284,
-0.08126833289861679,
0.17584538459777832,
0.1636475920677185,
-1.1820224523544312,
0.27775099873542786,
0.5534111261367798,
0.6748645305633545,
-0.43040066957473755,
-0.297070175409317,
-0.426141619682312,
0.22208069264888763,
-0.22922037541866302,
0.9683362245559692,
-0.4733976721763611,
-0.5911725759506226,
0.10236110538244247,
0.08288710564374924,
0.28646838665008545,
-0.5273624062538147,
0.5114233493804932,
-0.3406440019607544,
0.22109957039356232,
-0.17036961019039154,
-0.7532966732978821,
-0.13283978402614594,
0.18924273550510406,
-0.3422330915927887,
1.0648999214172363,
0.08480153977870941,
-0.7187362313270569,
0.6086580157279968,
-0.48735883831977844,
-0.4352843761444092,
0.4104287922382355,
-0.38501736521720886,
-0.23816567659378052,
-0.1006382554769516,
0.1399843394756317,
0.49283337593078613,
-0.557863175868988,
0.6178250908851624,
-0.5157261490821838,
-0.37905338406562805,
0.028787989169359207,
-0.31229135394096375,
0.5415500998497009,
0.1339239776134491,
-0.2960832715034485,
0.367533415555954,
-0.6976852416992188,
-0.023561693727970123,
0.19648347795009613,
-0.20129995048046112,
-0.43236035108566284,
-0.1391744762659073,
0.02687942236661911,
-0.10497484356164932,
0.3387637138366699,
-0.5213615894317627,
0.3692565858364105,
-0.7506642937660217,
0.34328150749206543,
0.7931298613548279,
0.06258781254291534,
0.6555015444755554,
-0.4996851980686188,
0.45472636818885803,
-0.24924156069755554,
-0.309414267539978,
-0.5750478506088257,
-0.2842763066291809,
-0.5595849752426147,
-0.15838555991649628,
0.437639057636261,
0.4508300721645355,
-0.5397182106971741,
0.8830083608627319,
-0.46337053179740906,
-0.3592362105846405,
-0.34653979539871216,
0.2062070518732071,
0.393343448638916,
0.35643312335014343,
0.14053542912006378,
-0.22470983862876892,
-0.6424785852432251,
-0.8930075168609619,
-0.09731751680374146,
-0.2840366065502167,
-0.10778804123401642,
0.19511789083480835,
0.20143896341323853,
-0.5245237350463867,
1.137740969657898,
-0.43589383363723755,
-0.4306367337703705,
-0.22381460666656494,
0.13178735971450806,
0.19147077202796936,
0.34051012992858887,
0.6378198266029358,
-0.33054324984550476,
-0.42978358268737793,
0.07308495044708252,
-0.6900151968002319,
-0.14313487708568573,
0.0365137904882431,
-0.22905585169792175,
-0.09520096331834793,
0.45817387104034424,
-0.35142242908477783,
0.3681689202785492,
0.4518687129020691,
-0.5418359041213989,
0.10936950147151947,
-0.35091352462768555,
0.038307804614305496,
-1.3425697088241577,
0.1510787010192871,
0.3265138268470764,
-0.25632697343826294,
-0.3362266719341278,
-0.14157871901988983,
-0.0405493825674057,
-0.17190155386924744,
-0.1128961518406868,
0.6524290442466736,
-0.08734668791294098,
0.15006190538406372,
-0.24640041589736938,
0.13346073031425476,
0.09645478427410126,
0.5396181344985962,
-0.27863311767578125,
0.7228366136550903,
0.1025674045085907,
-0.5168560147285461,
0.504199743270874,
0.4116453230381012,
-0.5173527002334595,
0.9351528882980347,
-0.5888697504997253,
0.14509724080562592,
-0.1931839883327484,
0.3675113618373871,
-1.3396539688110352,
-0.025837359949946404,
0.17757175862789154,
-0.2524941563606262,
0.2897379994392395,
-0.17386087775230408,
-0.45382389426231384,
-0.1415458470582962,
-0.26745617389678955,
0.4766443073749542,
0.3557107150554657,
-0.9236008524894714,
0.41630175709724426,
0.10269171744585037,
-0.10685093700885773,
-0.6015104055404663,
-0.4165157377719879,
0.16140839457511902,
-0.26271435618400574,
-0.5698055624961853,
1.0611854791641235,
-0.37584778666496277,
-0.2385820746421814,
0.10276410728693008,
0.18577493727207184,
0.288475900888443,
0.04741140827536583,
0.5947259664535522,
0.4506261944770813,
-0.1467510312795639,
0.4941698908805847,
-0.02458130195736885,
-0.4351687729358673,
-0.19086575508117676,
-0.5669351816177368,
0.5637845396995544,
-0.1702306866645813,
-0.30312055349349976,
-0.5007740259170532,
0.23264354467391968,
0.6988411545753479,
-0.17514920234680176,
0.3567469120025635,
0.4097221791744232,
-0.24267072975635529,
-0.2164023220539093,
-0.49180683493614197,
-0.18743611872196198,
-0.4227372109889984,
0.14635859429836273,
-0.3399762809276581,
-0.6643511056900024,
0.09515190124511719,
-0.23486082255840302,
0.21081146597862244,
0.6114295125007629,
0.6889086961746216,
-0.3060052692890167,
0.7288579940795898,
0.8686701059341431,
-0.22450245916843414,
0.45888665318489075,
-0.4079657196998596,
0.046400852501392365,
-0.6173086166381836,
-0.2877836525440216,
-0.3228429853916168,
-0.42822420597076416,
-0.30946093797683716,
0.11769512295722961,
-0.0798366442322731,
-0.10137724131345749,
-0.27367261052131653,
0.2626703381538391,
-0.6922250986099243,
0.4151584804058075,
0.6432140469551086,
0.08790777623653412,
0.49735698103904724,
0.1375332921743393,
-0.3381776511669159,
-0.060050953179597855,
-0.5318118333816528,
-0.3898340165615082,
1.1552659273147583,
0.23132750391960144,
0.9191491603851318,
-0.08978904783725739,
0.5754867792129517,
0.5769159197807312,
0.3460497260093689,
-0.8541526198387146,
0.35308676958084106,
-0.6052845120429993,
-0.32400181889533997,
0.06503024697303772,
0.08577965199947357,
-0.8528938889503479,
-0.14073090255260468,
-0.3584514558315277,
-0.4842509925365448,
0.34751513600349426,
0.05985467508435249,
-0.47867411375045776,
0.22062264382839203,
-0.41149893403053284,
0.8814489841461182,
-0.4298502802848816,
-0.15539105236530304,
-0.1806252896785736,
-0.4091241657733917,
0.31137850880622864,
-0.0423956960439682,
-0.24588902294635773,
-0.42529505491256714,
0.19489528238773346,
0.5276851058006287,
-0.25862425565719604,
0.8201901912689209,
0.056525085121393204,
-0.09101323038339615,
0.025417521595954895,
0.04670364782214165,
0.6444025039672852,
-0.020703308284282684,
-0.05764845386147499,
0.19337858259677887,
-0.03557601198554039,
0.014499054290354252,
-0.3165966868400574,
1.1108403205871582,
-0.6420056223869324,
-0.5347408652305603,
-0.28417643904685974,
-0.33375170826911926,
-0.07257474213838577,
0.12158060818910599,
0.5857178568840027,
0.4575093388557434,
-0.5486609935760498,
0.5363994240760803,
0.8425405621528625,
0.01330252829939127,
0.12757498025894165,
0.47802627086639404,
-0.4502047598361969,
-0.7219396233558655,
0.7819119095802307,
-0.18407876789569855,
-0.01389633771032095,
0.582428514957428,
-0.08403328061103821,
-0.3630066215991974,
-0.45507749915122986,
-0.6142415404319763,
0.2606225907802582,
-0.628101110458374,
-0.3501361608505249,
-0.6413498520851135,
-0.12030026316642761,
-0.21220923960208893,
-0.2829703092575073,
-0.23598188161849976,
-0.07163422554731369,
-0.645768940448761,
-0.3850395381450653,
0.7114673256874084,
0.613290548324585,
0.3814409077167511,
0.1997472643852234,
-0.3676214814186096,
0.3483637869358063,
0.15602770447731018,
0.6921327114105225,
-0.2611047923564911,
-0.5408411026000977,
-0.17856405675411224,
-0.03224923461675644,
-0.08130072802305222,
-0.5580078959465027,
0.2799513339996338,
0.2266475111246109,
0.5000264048576355,
0.6189270615577698,
0.3323429822921753,
0.49828818440437317,
-0.48906710743904114,
0.5120609402656555,
0.33914950489997864,
-0.39294224977493286,
0.5942121148109436,
-0.38152632117271423,
0.44816333055496216,
0.9611721634864807,
0.3388451039791107,
-0.3396643400192261,
-0.10174015164375305,
-0.3606375455856323,
-0.6951709985733032,
0.44675448536872864,
-0.07468118518590927,
0.07432626932859421,
0.002754004905000329,
0.6178995966911316,
0.4620237946510315,
0.0554024912416935,
-0.4404297173023224,
-0.3599187731742859,
-0.049001432955265045,
-0.6798904538154602,
-0.26030397415161133,
-0.6137474775314331,
-0.28623470664024353,
-0.048290930688381195,
0.6442804336547852,
-0.16617977619171143,
-0.14283260703086853,
0.048655398190021515,
0.13365601003170013,
-0.23756705224514008,
0.08255298435688019,
0.430679589509964,
0.5882706046104431,
-0.49499839544296265,
-0.2279987931251526,
-0.16147959232330322,
-0.18698155879974365,
0.47677284479141235,
0.18684373795986176,
-0.2840660810470581,
0.0581485778093338,
-0.07474257797002792,
0.7010018825531006,
0.2948172688484192,
-0.6391001343727112,
0.5806293487548828,
-0.3456908166408539,
-0.4645826518535614,
-0.7652120590209961,
-0.05462616682052612,
0.039198342710733414,
0.06348656862974167,
0.25824397802352905,
0.21261152625083923,
-0.07118191570043564,
-0.369109183549881,
0.35389918088912964,
0.5776185989379883,
-0.658974826335907,
-0.12611952424049377,
0.6765114665031433,
0.6646304130554199,
-0.33559972047805786,
0.7275757789611816,
0.046397969126701355,
0.24079233407974243,
0.35655295848846436,
0.5689494013786316,
1.385230541229248,
0.16632308065891266,
0.19435065984725952,
0.39624616503715515,
0.20591534674167633,
-0.16429850459098816,
-0.24233372509479523,
-0.16283529996871948,
-0.7779468894004822,
-0.2206876277923584,
-0.645504891872406,
-0.2668024003505707,
0.0642395094037056,
-0.6147579550743103,
0.7236523032188416,
-0.5779241919517517,
-0.2710537016391754,
0.01768060401082039,
-0.23497159779071808,
-0.734458863735199,
-0.04905733838677406,
0.02543044649064541,
0.8106259107589722,
-0.7151885628700256,
0.8549053072929382,
0.6202196478843689,
-0.3481552302837372,
-0.17395032942295074,
-0.003628239268437028,
0.08565699309110641,
-0.6424688696861267,
0.6085706353187561,
0.20012211799621582,
-0.405912309885025,
0.259042352437973,
-0.2648220360279083,
-0.7961850762367249,
1.4706207513809204,
0.4150770902633667,
-0.6344918608665466,
0.010213550180196762,
-0.2540188729763031,
0.5859860777854919,
-0.8806628584861755,
-0.09123274683952332,
0.2855842411518097,
0.11265825480222702,
0.3366861045360565,
-0.57269287109375,
-0.0006765639991499484,
-0.39473941922187805,
0.2152954339981079,
0.23579417169094086,
-0.24945726990699768,
0.4484316408634186,
-0.2364686280488968,
-0.5865380764007568,
0.5388319492340088,
0.47782614827156067,
0.30855196714401245,
0.388640820980072,
0.4046223759651184,
0.8742197751998901,
0.515982985496521,
-0.07594864815473557,
1.0427181720733643,
-0.5943911671638489,
-0.00022841054305899888,
1.2502422332763672,
-0.4453445374965668,
0.7059112191200256,
0.3557979166507721,
-0.1554749310016632,
0.9005776047706604,
0.8646901845932007,
-0.16381870210170746,
0.6582711935043335,
0.024089757353067398,
-0.24065488576889038,
-0.03796065226197243,
-0.3583644926548004,
-0.42899394035339355,
0.23890744149684906,
0.22067123651504517,
-0.5684958696365356,
-0.12972141802310944,
0.047826871275901794,
-0.28876787424087524,
0.396441787481308,
0.07401329278945923,
1.1827914714813232,
-0.10542948544025421,
-0.6563296914100647,
0.6038433313369751,
0.0345185250043869,
0.9374006390571594,
-0.7657127380371094,
-0.2682410478591919,
-0.3107045292854309,
0.2604686915874481,
-0.2274760752916336,
-0.5820754766464233,
-0.16178850829601288,
-0.10780946910381317,
-0.6834739446640015,
-0.264305055141449,
0.6524214744567871,
-0.5376786589622498,
-0.501401960849762,
0.29498761892318726,
0.25210997462272644,
-0.14121419191360474,
0.1797708123922348,
-0.4750683903694153,
-0.33624622225761414,
0.17575065791606903,
0.36698028445243835,
0.47885820269584656,
0.2777620255947113,
0.22500079870224,
0.8067612648010254,
0.7131050229072571,
-0.2157522290945053,
-0.4934932291507721,
0.039845824241638184,
0.5149111151695251,
-0.7462645173072815,
-0.5176780819892883,
-0.9058240056037903,
0.43197834491729736,
0.0581040121614933,
-0.3920421898365021,
0.5700985789299011,
0.4216702878475189,
0.9319742918014526,
-0.04131530970335007,
0.7467479109764099,
0.3489606976509094,
0.518937885761261,
-0.367221862077713,
0.3521397113800049,
-0.3423711955547333,
0.7606106996536255,
0.09565950930118561,
-1.0552996397018433,
-0.22817803919315338,
0.14752045273780823,
-0.15336677432060242,
0.007520916871726513,
0.47519463300704956,
0.6953951120376587,
0.16144859790802002,
-0.19854162633419037,
0.2399289757013321,
-0.1254451721906662,
0.14089873433113098,
0.3795490562915802,
0.7638384699821472,
-0.26589471101760864,
0.47564125061035156,
-0.24592632055282593,
-0.08838321268558502,
-0.5587283968925476,
-0.8015352487564087,
-0.7684847712516785,
-0.6301150918006897,
-0.3440236747264862,
-0.40202829241752625,
0.18797247111797333,
1.1660784482955933,
0.36774298548698425,
-0.7310667037963867,
-0.37177661061286926,
-0.3444086015224457,
0.06846628338098526,
-0.3057956099510193,
-0.25059300661087036,
0.213701069355011,
-0.20638978481292725,
-0.6160515546798706,
0.569903552532196,
0.6189053654670715,
0.3516934812068939,
-0.6481667160987854,
-0.04472190886735916,
-0.17916694283485413,
-0.27570632100105286,
0.5266351103782654,
0.2315167933702469,
-0.9527310132980347,
0.026730826124548912,
-0.06647079437971115,
-0.33617374300956726,
0.051144178956747055,
0.9458020329475403,
-1.0552706718444824,
0.7420839667320251,
0.4755900502204895,
0.7437951564788818,
0.3958685100078583,
0.20285752415657043,
1.0927506685256958,
-0.6906198263168335,
0.058472733944654465,
0.07095552235841751,
0.3103933334350586,
0.38948485255241394,
-0.5137882828712463,
0.6534011960029602,
0.20340101420879364,
-0.4221123158931732,
-0.7077202200889587,
0.24947093427181244,
-0.8327268362045288,
-0.2311309576034546,
1.1345934867858887,
-0.11233904212713242,
0.2891078591346741,
-0.030546801164746284,
-0.24765050411224365,
-0.2506341338157654,
-0.4131104350090027,
0.77297043800354,
0.4719475209712982,
0.1410616636276245,
0.08406968414783478,
-0.14344166219234467,
0.4213525652885437,
0.2856404483318329,
-0.39455774426460266,
0.1589929759502411,
0.3578014373779297,
0.21374861896038055,
-0.08466346561908722,
0.535487174987793,
-0.08182654529809952,
0.11513973027467728,
-0.32601994276046753,
0.2466517984867096,
0.023141484707593918,
-0.29561707377433777,
-0.47326967120170593,
0.11649151891469955,
0.31367626786231995,
-0.17205551266670227
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19012v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19012v2
|
ReflectSumm: A Benchmark for Course Reflection Summarization
| 2024-03-27T21:10:07 | 2024-04-23T02:28:10 |
Yang Zhong, Mohamed Elaraby, Diane Litman, Ahmed Ashraf Butt, Muhsin Menekse
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper introduces ReflectSumm, a novel summarization dataset specifically
designed for summarizing students' reflective writing. The goal of ReflectSumm
is to facilitate developing and evaluating novel summarization techniques
tailored to real-world scenarios with little training data, %practical tasks
with potential implications in the opinion summarization domain in general and
the educational domain in particular. The dataset encompasses a diverse range
of summarization tasks and includes comprehensive metadata, enabling the
exploration of various research questions and supporting different
applications. To showcase its utility, we conducted extensive evaluations using
multiple state-of-the-art baselines. The results provide benchmarks for
facilitating further research in this area.
|
[
-0.5293123722076416,
-0.3398496210575104,
0.2974615693092346,
0.24547509849071503,
-0.12713803350925446,
0.36302614212036133,
-0.34515634179115295,
-0.18403850495815277,
0.4921254813671112,
0.5951290726661682,
-0.4097954332828522,
-0.7661972641944885,
-0.4051971137523651,
-0.019678808748722076,
-0.39730414748191833,
1.35440993309021,
-0.14018332958221436,
0.307756245136261,
-0.5926305055618286,
-0.5608965158462524,
-0.38655465841293335,
-0.3777288496494293,
-0.10341791063547134,
-0.11490145325660706,
0.568463921546936,
0.7506716847419739,
0.059389255940914154,
0.1325879693031311,
0.7877418398857117,
0.10207194834947586,
0.3060073256492615,
0.25339388847351074,
-0.6525747776031494,
0.212166428565979,
-0.1393204778432846,
-0.28789588809013367,
-0.6922005414962769,
0.3596380352973938,
1.1129980087280273,
0.9762192964553833,
-0.26064997911453247,
0.8927019834518433,
0.21119524538516998,
0.9050416946411133,
-1.1162022352218628,
-0.03363680839538574,
-0.07131046801805496,
0.07589313387870789,
-0.04166186600923538,
-0.289182186126709,
-0.5388615131378174,
-1.0243126153945923,
0.0395335927605629,
-0.2896415889263153,
0.3318489193916321,
-0.16822247207164764,
0.40049129724502563,
-0.06052564084529877,
-0.46496379375457764,
-0.20645909011363983,
-0.5097641348838806,
0.7339950203895569,
-0.8768009543418884,
-0.0827118381857872,
-0.20658496022224426,
0.5951156616210938,
0.11125534772872925,
-0.8574601411819458,
-0.15778625011444092,
0.24225153028964996,
-0.09859682619571686,
0.7202344536781311,
0.617185115814209,
-0.13281738758087158,
-0.003481138963252306,
0.8554641008377075,
-0.7136865854263306,
-0.5285856127738953,
-0.1634463369846344,
0.229821115732193,
0.5493587851524353,
0.7057632207870483,
0.011529935523867607,
0.08388311415910721,
-0.35779210925102234,
-0.1597784459590912,
-0.6203359365463257,
-0.17720526456832886,
0.31225648522377014,
0.3636392056941986,
-0.043693143874406815,
0.31822535395622253,
-0.48678338527679443,
0.46732521057128906,
-0.6080084443092346,
0.15133191645145416,
0.22870780527591705,
-0.2183435559272766,
-0.08045168220996857,
0.07436966150999069,
0.4974082112312317,
1.083636999130249,
0.020564449951052666,
-0.027004217728972435,
-0.2966572344303131,
0.004920291714370251,
0.39546993374824524,
-1.1218783855438232,
-0.3344915211200714,
-0.07508720457553864,
-0.6143682599067688,
-0.36411383748054504,
0.3798297643661499,
-0.9369908571243286,
-0.31679484248161316,
-0.3672618865966797,
0.4163290560245514,
0.10690828412771225,
-0.41147691011428833,
0.17534755170345306,
-0.2641342282295227,
0.3264061212539673,
0.41542860865592957,
-0.6774988174438477,
0.9982497692108154,
0.8268071413040161,
0.9765505194664001,
-0.5468780398368835,
-0.41901451349258423,
-0.21183764934539795,
0.07230166345834732,
-0.2562820315361023,
0.8662177324295044,
-0.25925496220588684,
-0.6174192428588867,
0.29686588048934937,
-0.12817753851413727,
0.07575815171003342,
-0.7261298894882202,
0.45978018641471863,
-0.16154316067695618,
0.5238420963287354,
-0.6524682641029358,
-0.7476734519004822,
-0.5262301564216614,
0.4052552878856659,
-0.5237381458282471,
1.393433928489685,
0.35667526721954346,
-0.6690080761909485,
0.6181461215019226,
-0.3356691300868988,
-0.5792376399040222,
0.07187463343143463,
-0.07939276844263077,
-0.6026641130447388,
0.36290034651756287,
-0.29023128747940063,
0.5102418065071106,
0.005627007689327002,
0.2251538187265396,
-0.002807807642966509,
-0.703125,
0.056730613112449646,
0.019380031153559685,
0.46475130319595337,
0.005899354815483093,
-0.1400546133518219,
-0.09542138129472733,
-0.7848668098449707,
0.030423451215028763,
-0.05520334094762802,
-0.159337118268013,
-0.47534555196762085,
0.04676026478409767,
0.4051819145679474,
0.1561337411403656,
0.37192314863204956,
-0.25550511479377747,
0.26189371943473816,
0.06816496700048447,
-0.3239888548851013,
0.6360654234886169,
0.33935973048210144,
0.2462679147720337,
-0.670067548751831,
0.5601944327354431,
-0.23841169476509094,
-0.10159176588058472,
-0.3697125315666199,
-0.18415367603302002,
-0.7915684580802917,
-0.21838778257369995,
-0.016474364325404167,
0.31366264820098877,
-0.261096328496933,
-0.13070815801620483,
-0.26084139943122864,
-0.6564239859580994,
-0.43899160623550415,
0.14617358148097992,
0.6272404193878174,
0.7010494470596313,
0.48873433470726013,
-0.6181507706642151,
-0.7528455853462219,
-0.7337204217910767,
-0.755698561668396,
-0.013609323650598526,
0.06478669494390488,
0.1490239053964615,
0.559280514717102,
0.18531033396720886,
0.8772426247596741,
-0.9503306746482849,
-0.6127331852912903,
-0.4968794882297516,
0.42138662934303284,
0.18742723762989044,
0.4408896565437317,
0.6517318487167358,
-0.34299787878990173,
-0.5666842460632324,
-0.698650062084198,
-1.1142311096191406,
-0.12050020694732666,
-0.2876652777194977,
-0.197841614484787,
-0.20362438261508942,
0.09583978354930878,
0.030147964134812355,
0.1768273264169693,
0.11695697903633118,
-0.18352675437927246,
0.5277215242385864,
-0.15712934732437134,
0.5378718376159668,
-1.0818923711776733,
0.08842649310827255,
0.07041473686695099,
-0.31667786836624146,
-0.43366801738739014,
0.15090076625347137,
0.0710471123456955,
0.2478124499320984,
-0.40824928879737854,
0.4172744154930115,
-0.6937226057052612,
-0.19306212663650513,
-0.2876936197280884,
0.3767176568508148,
0.14231503009796143,
0.37411582469940186,
0.21783693134784698,
0.7189203500747681,
0.24235232174396515,
-0.44962698221206665,
-0.012339312583208084,
0.26965510845184326,
-0.4824979305267334,
0.7012433409690857,
-0.448499858379364,
-0.054698530584573746,
-0.09012948721647263,
0.22920173406600952,
-1.0394549369812012,
-0.0632370337843895,
-0.1612178236246109,
-0.3889133036136627,
0.15602970123291016,
0.30544084310531616,
-0.29829344153404236,
-0.06616946309804916,
-1.0370211601257324,
0.2611444890499115,
0.4134376645088196,
-0.4332442879676819,
0.591956377029419,
0.37872397899627686,
-0.13292869925498962,
-0.6072632670402527,
-0.5338159203529358,
0.4764924645423889,
-0.2764253318309784,
-0.07668423652648926,
0.06472820788621902,
-0.24953605234622955,
-0.3981557786464691,
-0.19539031386375427,
-0.031412944197654724,
0.37591224908828735,
0.1295570433139801,
0.4188331365585327,
0.45979413390159607,
-0.22133363783359528,
-0.33089736104011536,
0.025712570175528526,
-0.10935171693563461,
0.3696144223213196,
0.10216760635375977,
0.12669962644577026,
-0.25497663021087646,
-0.03224001079797745,
0.11582023650407791,
0.5259072780609131,
0.32160112261772156,
0.06696401536464691,
0.7037273049354553,
0.2570948004722595,
-0.2930782437324524,
-0.6678726077079773,
-0.6832566261291504,
-0.26719602942466736,
-0.38681715726852417,
0.28938326239585876,
-0.08946099132299423,
-0.5598858594894409,
0.6246660947799683,
-0.09250003099441528,
0.6155344247817993,
0.1562928855419159,
0.5410985350608826,
-0.1624254286289215,
0.8056750297546387,
0.43491530418395996,
-0.14008034765720367,
0.2728457748889923,
-0.4904038608074188,
-0.03206856921315193,
-1.1162043809890747,
-0.2973111569881439,
-0.22570616006851196,
-0.3523518145084381,
-0.36471277475357056,
-0.11406507343053818,
0.12918399274349213,
-0.565369188785553,
0.11146048456430435,
0.275700181722641,
-0.7237769961357117,
0.536094605922699,
0.40815967321395874,
0.0908023938536644,
0.53755122423172,
-0.5483099222183228,
0.29694995284080505,
-0.18606163561344147,
-0.42153221368789673,
-0.983015775680542,
1.2323853969573975,
-0.08372350037097931,
0.5112314820289612,
0.16585132479667664,
0.8135055303573608,
0.550817608833313,
0.9954956769943237,
-0.6951339244842529,
1.058319330215454,
-0.15389366447925568,
-0.5023167133331299,
0.03142797574400902,
-0.37830495834350586,
-0.30752208828926086,
0.5026670098304749,
-0.18000441789627075,
0.03311235457658768,
-0.24436013400554657,
-0.011367724277079105,
-0.04941564053297043,
0.363731324672699,
-0.41193887591362,
0.6304817199707031,
0.22397658228874207,
-0.39609724283218384,
-0.07368049770593643,
-0.7920131683349609,
0.4943178594112396,
0.39206263422966003,
0.20351627469062805,
-0.3244992792606354,
0.04629381746053696,
1.2081557512283325,
-0.27041786909103394,
0.6538837552070618,
-0.42498093843460083,
0.021277308464050293,
0.3237178325653076,
0.16581565141677856,
-0.14040590822696686,
0.16310237348079681,
0.06874250620603561,
0.0007258045952767134,
-0.07078217715024948,
-0.42547616362571716,
-0.44000953435897827,
0.7171114683151245,
-0.2968491315841675,
-0.24454008042812347,
-0.7701860666275024,
-0.41819262504577637,
-0.3591279685497284,
0.15995275974273682,
0.12120579183101654,
0.6663627624511719,
-0.8137252330780029,
-0.1531972587108612,
0.815772294998169,
0.16131161153316498,
0.4581034481525421,
0.9618805646896362,
-0.2500649690628052,
-0.5768149495124817,
1.2586567401885986,
0.3619963228702545,
0.15278823673725128,
0.3008174002170563,
0.0006173168658278883,
0.0169281717389822,
-0.6092497110366821,
-0.28265032172203064,
0.18408478796482086,
-0.8849070072174072,
-0.21034395694732666,
-0.5021495223045349,
-0.04314950108528137,
-0.34433266520500183,
-0.4082504212856293,
-0.3312928378582001,
-0.6665775179862976,
-0.02942129224538803,
-0.3599523603916168,
-0.16742031276226044,
0.7737480401992798,
0.19988423585891724,
0.09023398160934448,
-0.6496326327323914,
0.38033369183540344,
0.21511685848236084,
0.486876904964447,
0.012004904448986053,
-0.4661365747451782,
-0.5329079031944275,
-0.28017228841781616,
-0.2504146099090576,
-0.6180442571640015,
0.19101209938526154,
0.4611654579639435,
0.49829956889152527,
0.42002052068710327,
0.14433641731739044,
0.22840115427970886,
-0.4595590829849243,
1.0641392469406128,
0.09795328229665756,
-0.671282947063446,
0.6695953607559204,
-0.3553276062011719,
0.458514541387558,
1.3198844194412231,
0.1928291767835617,
-0.785682201385498,
-0.7769936323165894,
-0.4434979259967804,
-0.9335384368896484,
0.35558760166168213,
-0.16184203326702118,
0.17043998837471008,
-0.039849694818258286,
0.4909548759460449,
0.5169398188591003,
0.3794073462486267,
-0.15854352712631226,
-0.5641125440597534,
-0.2205989509820938,
-0.5902853608131409,
-0.3670459985733032,
-0.45868629217147827,
-0.23294951021671295,
-0.145236998796463,
0.8737584352493286,
-0.02491937205195427,
-0.14268159866333008,
0.0473501980304718,
-0.43783479928970337,
0.17591580748558044,
0.030763177201151848,
0.9022591710090637,
0.9414456486701965,
-0.6607393026351929,
0.6116214990615845,
0.5212469696998596,
-1.1637040376663208,
0.14540958404541016,
-0.325279176235199,
-0.2619782090187073,
0.297909140586853,
0.5656230449676514,
0.012484797276556492,
0.32335296273231506,
-0.5839950442314148,
0.7102092504501343,
-0.4729398190975189,
-0.2209310680627823,
-0.4157411754131317,
0.24990762770175934,
-0.32973548769950867,
-0.24767901003360748,
0.7020515203475952,
-0.1051301658153534,
0.8314992785453796,
-0.4826580882072449,
0.12675493955612183,
0.12834493815898895,
-0.5197566747665405,
-0.4064972996711731,
0.6993353366851807,
0.15117698907852173,
-0.02719838172197342,
0.14938773214817047,
0.25381386280059814,
-0.3569730818271637,
0.5145611763000488,
0.24525350332260132,
1.0722569227218628,
-0.31718844175338745,
0.27152180671691895,
0.6919497847557068,
0.10393533110618591,
-0.22931867837905884,
0.42221561074256897,
-0.31386134028434753,
-0.2654871642589569,
0.009987235069274902,
-0.2652945816516876,
-0.9981677532196045,
-0.43649864196777344,
-1.2239060401916504,
0.22630710899829865,
-0.43078500032424927,
0.035854682326316833,
-0.36856481432914734,
0.2000366896390915,
0.038757313042879105,
0.5775479078292847,
-0.2565082311630249,
0.8739815950393677,
-1.1286355257034302,
0.12518887221813202,
0.9211239814758301,
-0.3539770245552063,
-0.27782416343688965,
-0.3574143946170807,
0.15885117650032043,
-0.3943222463130951,
0.05651476979255676,
0.30460020899772644,
-0.6841488480567932,
-0.3358892500400543,
-0.4715496003627777,
0.02776937745511532,
1.0279957056045532,
-0.05901859700679779,
-0.16063962876796722,
0.18030203878879547,
0.21769386529922485,
0.4854657053947449,
-0.394509494304657,
0.42487773299217224,
0.5026259422302246,
0.1965319961309433,
-0.08758051693439484,
-0.08310267329216003,
0.2411937564611435,
-0.5985841155052185,
-0.06286554038524628,
0.1996009647846222,
-0.9981073141098022,
0.4631379246711731,
-0.09352976083755493,
-0.041620686650276184,
-0.20227603614330292,
0.8013160824775696,
0.12852860987186432,
0.6678307056427002,
-0.017962146550416946,
0.48152485489845276,
0.5196918249130249,
-0.2844245135784149,
0.5471298694610596,
-0.269081175327301,
0.4427245557308197,
1.769335150718689,
-0.37785667181015015,
0.6945016384124756,
0.49371543526649475,
-0.1083652526140213,
0.4942948520183563,
0.6053329706192017,
-0.036970242857933044,
0.6428399085998535,
0.2723468840122223,
-0.5939038395881653,
-0.003005798440426588,
0.13617660105228424,
-0.7163447141647339,
0.08211061358451843,
0.09854043275117874,
-0.13056185841560364,
-0.2014654576778412,
-0.035085588693618774,
0.0575968474149704,
0.546555757522583,
-0.2508501708507538,
1.0746463537216187,
0.17386707663536072,
-0.6872127652168274,
0.07512786984443665,
-0.3355376124382019,
0.4463951289653778,
-0.2560405135154724,
-0.24283498525619507,
-0.6905726194381714,
0.22290568053722382,
-0.5592960119247437,
-0.9091188311576843,
0.3707497715950012,
-0.10916725546121597,
-0.042052559554576874,
-0.4678020775318146,
0.34497129917144775,
-0.35942262411117554,
-0.3882420063018799,
-0.09662199020385742,
0.24995161592960358,
0.1744159609079361,
0.2467668652534485,
0.14550763368606567,
-0.05847717449069023,
-0.5245746970176697,
-0.41154971718788147,
0.3351913094520569,
0.3374785780906677,
0.4083710312843323,
0.4527435302734375,
0.11133532226085663,
0.2604435086250305,
-0.21734970808029175,
0.47611531615257263,
0.8974814414978027,
-0.707981526851654,
-0.3364121615886688,
-0.698819637298584,
0.6595965027809143,
-0.30457979440689087,
-0.4472929835319519,
1.3437435626983643,
1.4155113697052002,
0.6294566988945007,
-0.06073065847158432,
0.8237238526344299,
0.39210474491119385,
0.9425959587097168,
-0.2286384552717209,
0.8708193898200989,
-0.3404744863510132,
0.25325843691825867,
-0.5206687450408936,
-1.2509475946426392,
-0.4965873956680298,
0.49272313714027405,
-0.09590643644332886,
0.119939424097538,
0.5963269472122192,
0.3291190266609192,
0.25973108410835266,
0.18008722364902496,
0.1142444834113121,
-0.2507915496826172,
0.269565224647522,
0.5428171753883362,
0.9538114666938782,
-0.6584339737892151,
-0.04522968828678131,
-0.16593442857265472,
-0.3455561101436615,
-0.3446441888809204,
-0.785886824131012,
-1.1513911485671997,
-0.7532858848571777,
-0.6648543477058411,
-0.2716565728187561,
0.09947525709867477,
0.6524456143379211,
0.4102698266506195,
-0.9169479012489319,
-0.5587617754936218,
0.10701008141040802,
-0.03509511798620224,
-0.42479443550109863,
-0.27562248706817627,
0.1733849197626114,
-0.16720528900623322,
-0.4222254157066345,
0.04347728192806244,
0.3418489396572113,
-0.10558957606554031,
-0.4227057099342346,
0.0003557589661795646,
-0.045185837894678116,
0.32490554451942444,
0.48030194640159607,
-0.04488401859998703,
0.11605213582515717,
-0.18998421728610992,
0.07604187726974487,
-0.33639875054359436,
0.26538774371147156,
1.1005711555480957,
-0.5903210043907166,
0.4054518938064575,
0.3821104168891907,
0.13726195693016052,
0.8066433072090149,
0.14144882559776306,
0.31889405846595764,
-0.6815634369850159,
-0.27198684215545654,
0.37891310453414917,
0.1359136402606964,
0.4280901551246643,
-0.23537901043891907,
0.723961591720581,
-0.033201489597558975,
-0.4376271963119507,
-1.1134659051895142,
-0.37224581837654114,
-1.1478887796401978,
-0.05413898453116417,
0.6534717679023743,
-0.25318169593811035,
0.1156957596540451,
0.11724267899990082,
-0.19820035994052887,
0.2572169601917267,
-0.1508527398109436,
1.0968923568725586,
0.686137318611145,
-0.07742346078157425,
-0.13966116309165955,
-0.5158963203430176,
0.4810878038406372,
0.32714730501174927,
-1.2056244611740112,
0.20662184059619904,
0.5454421639442444,
0.3903104364871979,
-0.23554909229278564,
0.7530686855316162,
-0.23331066966056824,
0.36240047216415405,
-0.06984397768974304,
0.1758085936307907,
-0.05981089547276497,
-0.38269129395484924,
-0.2948673963546753,
0.4620477557182312,
-0.016536815091967583,
-0.07216621935367584
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18976v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18976v1
|
"Sorry, Come Again?" Prompting -- Enhancing Comprehension and Diminishing Hallucination with [PAUSE]-injected Optimal Paraphrasing
| 2024-03-27T19:45:09 | 2024-03-27T19:45:09 |
Vipula Rawte, S. M Towhidul Islam Tonmoy, S M Mehedi Zaman, Prachi Priya, Aman Chadha, Amit P. Sheth, Amitava Das
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Hallucination has emerged as the most vulnerable aspect of contemporary Large
Language Models (LLMs). In this paper, we introduce the Sorry, Come Again (SCA)
prompting, aimed to avoid LLM hallucinations by enhancing comprehension
through: (i) optimal paraphrasing and (ii) injecting [PAUSE] tokens to delay
LLM generation. First, we provide an in-depth analysis of linguistic nuances:
formality, readability, and concreteness of prompts for 21 LLMs, and elucidate
how these nuances contribute to hallucinated generation. Prompts with lower
readability, formality, or concreteness pose comprehension challenges for LLMs,
similar to those faced by humans. In such scenarios, an LLM tends to speculate
and generate content based on its imagination (associative memory) to fill
these information gaps. Although these speculations may occasionally align with
factual information, their accuracy is not assured, often resulting in
hallucination. Recent studies reveal that an LLM often neglects the middle
sections of extended prompts, a phenomenon termed as lost in the middle. While
a specific paraphrase may suit one LLM, the same paraphrased version may elicit
a different response from another LLM. Therefore, we propose an optimal
paraphrasing technique to identify the most comprehensible paraphrase of a
given prompt, evaluated using Integrated Gradient (and its variations) to
guarantee that the LLM accurately processes all words. While reading lengthy
sentences, humans often pause at various points to better comprehend the
meaning read thus far. We have fine-tuned an LLM with injected [PAUSE] tokens,
allowing the LLM to pause while reading lengthier prompts. This has brought
several key contributions: (i) determining the optimal position to inject
[PAUSE], (ii) determining the number of [PAUSE] tokens to be inserted, and
(iii) introducing reverse proxy tuning to fine-tune the LLM for [PAUSE]
insertion.
|
[
-0.39627817273139954,
-0.901717483997345,
0.888798177242279,
0.3380357325077057,
-0.4554796814918518,
-0.08534082770347595,
-0.24031542241573334,
-0.19192908704280853,
0.19697663187980652,
0.5709021687507629,
-0.5390249490737915,
-0.2707185447216034,
-0.36653098464012146,
0.33852559328079224,
-0.30030161142349243,
0.7549418210983276,
0.12394683808088303,
-0.09578444808721542,
-0.3316669464111328,
-0.12747640907764435,
-0.8553172945976257,
-0.4430149495601654,
-0.906788170337677,
-0.3049122095108032,
0.7838306427001953,
0.5907081365585327,
0.7590446472167969,
0.5075655579566956,
0.0797710195183754,
0.2758684456348419,
-0.26031720638275146,
0.2836971580982208,
-0.37999963760375977,
0.3452950119972229,
-0.28399091958999634,
-0.579240620136261,
0.06831836700439453,
-0.1787433624267578,
0.5314107537269592,
0.7731687426567078,
-0.300528347492218,
-0.1596524715423584,
0.0909295454621315,
0.554523766040802,
-0.6717140674591064,
-0.20613475143909454,
-0.7287938594818115,
0.056548383086919785,
-0.04748555272817612,
-0.6273325085639954,
-0.6716821789741516,
-0.4976848363876343,
0.2600483298301697,
-0.5470442175865173,
0.30675026774406433,
0.16939373314380646,
0.6022087335586548,
0.4949870705604553,
0.01732640527188778,
-0.6693844795227051,
-0.41120490431785583,
0.7406336069107056,
-0.7285484075546265,
0.24282002449035645,
0.2426958978176117,
0.11310827732086182,
-0.338890016078949,
-0.8063937425613403,
-0.7762138247489929,
-0.3912961483001709,
-0.024851439520716667,
-0.06323544681072235,
-0.12591595947742462,
-0.11956707388162613,
0.08880538493394852,
0.044111110270023346,
-0.5354628562927246,
0.0499829426407814,
-0.31853464245796204,
-0.253726989030838,
0.09484869986772537,
0.2846093475818634,
0.5430451035499573,
-0.08584962040185928,
-0.21414116024971008,
0.13631488382816315,
-0.730920135974884,
-0.006280134432017803,
0.3470146059989929,
0.30792149901390076,
0.1924314647912979,
0.4749689996242523,
-0.030634194612503052,
0.5684033036231995,
0.13423973321914673,
-0.08271142095327377,
0.1671784371137619,
-0.2165103405714035,
-0.11712700873613358,
0.18719126284122467,
0.6286624073982239,
0.45319169759750366,
0.3381359875202179,
-0.246186763048172,
-0.06403165310621262,
0.011944866739213467,
0.3937789797782898,
-0.47504398226737976,
-0.2253672480583191,
0.2329058200120926,
-0.3153742849826813,
-0.17934256792068481,
-0.13382674753665924,
-1.0396711826324463,
-0.5882567763328552,
-0.37012672424316406,
0.4315699338912964,
-0.4490143060684204,
0.08089827746152878,
0.3474448621273041,
-0.15556396543979645,
0.17194385826587677,
0.16955141723155975,
-0.9063383340835571,
0.21349221467971802,
0.46797019243240356,
1.202469825744629,
-0.2578393220901489,
-0.5998279452323914,
-0.7494215965270996,
0.12214014679193497,
-0.4792812764644623,
0.8257474899291992,
-0.4025129973888397,
-0.3364347517490387,
0.16062015295028687,
0.14133863151073456,
-0.037304408848285675,
-0.572048544883728,
0.5423082113265991,
-0.36337581276893616,
0.26597440242767334,
-0.4495178163051605,
-0.29219484329223633,
-0.07559968531131744,
-0.01626763679087162,
-0.49287429451942444,
0.6996901631355286,
-0.020869886502623558,
-0.6983294486999512,
0.22831270098686218,
-0.21733351051807404,
-0.6366895437240601,
0.04815712571144104,
-0.2119094580411911,
-0.1818179041147232,
0.31763190031051636,
0.40817540884017944,
0.3455709218978882,
-0.2071664184331894,
0.27323341369628906,
-0.02748716250061989,
-0.5379608273506165,
0.45644205808639526,
-0.5190234184265137,
0.7233439087867737,
0.08565773814916611,
-0.4493429958820343,
0.07869182527065277,
-0.5452157258987427,
-0.2070515751838684,
0.07071451097726822,
-0.19695211946964264,
-0.22073815762996674,
-0.16753052175045013,
-0.2020389586687088,
0.25997626781463623,
0.20801402628421783,
-0.30754727125167847,
-0.16153062880039215,
-0.627609133720398,
0.6881364583969116,
0.9251972436904907,
0.2832386791706085,
0.3668622672557831,
-0.4560813307762146,
0.7017624378204346,
-0.020509716123342514,
0.11893519759178162,
-0.48237448930740356,
-0.3639013171195984,
-0.7044187188148499,
-0.01457394938915968,
-0.276924192905426,
0.7066472768783569,
-0.8345250487327576,
0.2071986198425293,
0.044993359595537186,
-0.19169571995735168,
-0.5589670538902283,
0.1012837141752243,
0.3570388853549957,
0.6130790710449219,
0.6009445786476135,
0.19630782306194305,
-0.430326372385025,
-0.6956096291542053,
-0.22889365255832672,
-0.10070905834436417,
0.02165365405380726,
0.16354084014892578,
0.19551429152488708,
0.09004641324281693,
0.5864949226379395,
-0.39834079146385193,
-0.11986961215734482,
-0.4292030334472656,
-0.00930462684482336,
0.14069561660289764,
0.23722520470619202,
0.16001282632350922,
-0.5488628149032593,
-0.2783769369125366,
-0.1241343766450882,
-0.7714880704879761,
-0.30821123719215393,
-0.7517475485801697,
0.023255227133631706,
0.2934095561504364,
0.9508625268936157,
-0.956784725189209,
0.2550176680088043,
0.13039639592170715,
-0.23405323922634125,
0.6570318937301636,
-0.4257223308086395,
0.029333477839827538,
-1.0590730905532837,
-0.03275400027632713,
-0.4337611496448517,
0.1793718785047531,
-0.35824069380760193,
0.11491089314222336,
-0.05108705163002014,
0.08956979215145111,
-0.5328924655914307,
0.6190806031227112,
-0.5981137156486511,
0.12592023611068726,
-0.34622880816459656,
0.5585900545120239,
0.030542641878128052,
0.3508763611316681,
-0.19543926417827606,
0.9056567549705505,
0.6856023073196411,
-0.8785472512245178,
0.301175594329834,
0.31991344690322876,
-0.27263009548187256,
0.7454888224601746,
-0.73841792345047,
0.2453850358724594,
-0.457212895154953,
0.3536692261695862,
-1.1559720039367676,
-0.29903310537338257,
0.508415699005127,
-0.49648967385292053,
0.24602562189102173,
0.2651854157447815,
-0.2259286642074585,
-0.4631090462207794,
-0.4318538308143616,
0.33913254737854004,
0.4669567346572876,
-0.6858919262886047,
0.4686746299266815,
0.10594954341650009,
-0.3681643307209015,
-0.6474764347076416,
-0.8022586107254028,
0.5786831974983215,
-0.3785383403301239,
-0.5096478462219238,
0.2884884774684906,
-0.28419768810272217,
-0.16854648292064667,
-0.3278034031391144,
-0.02487720549106598,
0.32056576013565063,
-0.12440162152051926,
0.11501280218362808,
0.05966193601489067,
-0.14865563809871674,
0.16271880269050598,
0.3501828908920288,
-0.2588023543357849,
0.09853395074605942,
-0.18230962753295898,
0.8570658564567566,
0.02497291937470436,
-0.07439759373664856,
-0.8274168968200684,
0.548794686794281,
0.7405098676681519,
0.10057589411735535,
0.8571086525917053,
0.401623398065567,
-0.36485785245895386,
-0.144944965839386,
-0.6742238402366638,
-0.36837130784988403,
-0.4687972366809845,
0.11061889678239822,
-0.498440682888031,
-0.5885916352272034,
0.5342528820037842,
0.213004931807518,
-0.0070766243152320385,
0.0907275527715683,
0.6848963499069214,
0.06446882337331772,
0.8995239734649658,
0.3470241129398346,
0.05783955007791519,
0.23270900547504425,
0.038837239146232605,
0.3704374432563782,
-0.8085464239120483,
-0.4379844069480896,
-0.5449859499931335,
-0.1544506847858429,
-0.2668108344078064,
-0.31697025895118713,
0.011516014114022255,
0.26395878195762634,
0.001322987605817616,
0.14313898980617523,
-0.4691537320613861,
0.5435633063316345,
0.49636003375053406,
0.20144976675510406,
0.24242335557937622,
-0.19649507105350494,
-0.1719948947429657,
-0.13571840524673462,
-0.5950186252593994,
-0.519326388835907,
0.7168558835983276,
0.17356011271476746,
0.6292946338653564,
-0.040616508573293686,
0.7942498326301575,
0.04406135529279709,
-0.12017285078763962,
-0.767677903175354,
0.7223151326179504,
0.20933997631072998,
-0.14727212488651276,
-0.3396260142326355,
-0.2175019532442093,
-0.9761173725128174,
0.12572599947452545,
0.17833556234836578,
-0.8329922556877136,
0.3904823660850525,
0.1735529899597168,
-0.7791010141372681,
0.07023531198501587,
-0.4622165858745575,
0.6073936820030212,
0.1607249230146408,
-0.22205132246017456,
-0.12872354686260223,
-1.0114110708236694,
0.23477019369602203,
-0.1336965411901474,
0.2000764161348343,
0.15160350501537323,
-0.4040939211845398,
0.5232566595077515,
-0.23890961706638336,
0.7409383654594421,
-0.055901747196912766,
-0.05514395982027054,
0.2256128489971161,
0.10718661546707153,
0.7478018999099731,
0.18772602081298828,
0.10645440220832825,
-0.21985985338687897,
-0.13589142262935638,
-0.43599891662597656,
-0.6771866679191589,
0.8484070301055908,
-0.4013993442058563,
-0.753735363483429,
-0.3482104539871216,
-0.5193493962287903,
-0.1037992537021637,
-0.03540465608239174,
0.8060511946678162,
0.19344528019428253,
0.10595594346523285,
0.20728245377540588,
0.9473348259925842,
-0.5887798070907593,
0.6147789359092712,
0.1488994061946869,
-0.024657052010297775,
-0.5609233975410461,
0.8845729231834412,
0.021195223554968834,
0.22483251988887787,
0.0955563560128212,
0.3330148160457611,
-0.4364449977874756,
-0.7633144855499268,
-0.41393229365348816,
0.45560169219970703,
-0.7962237596511841,
-0.18025071918964386,
-1.0732886791229248,
-0.12645919620990753,
-0.5537367463111877,
-0.4701838195323944,
0.017953265458345413,
-0.1315789669752121,
-0.5962982773780823,
-0.2465892881155014,
0.27686578035354614,
0.4642520844936371,
-0.3042007088661194,
0.48933038115501404,
-0.6070637106895447,
0.5242880582809448,
0.15713635087013245,
-0.13807885348796844,
0.19503818452358246,
-0.8245092630386353,
-0.029184643179178238,
-0.12782683968544006,
-0.16064424812793732,
-0.8463977575302124,
0.25500836968421936,
0.039670590311288834,
0.5623929500579834,
0.3792322278022766,
0.08765073865652084,
0.7834839224815369,
-0.6949783563613892,
0.9604042768478394,
0.2508443295955658,
-0.8047510981559753,
0.36604058742523193,
-0.11399586498737335,
0.46535804867744446,
0.6545556783676147,
0.10290849953889847,
-0.749200165271759,
-0.7549778819084167,
-0.48936179280281067,
-1.2089093923568726,
0.4461374878883362,
-0.01720939576625824,
0.6661797761917114,
-0.6242356300354004,
0.6335901021957397,
0.30516061186790466,
0.1406262218952179,
-0.6173598766326904,
-0.19782507419586182,
0.04425523057579994,
-0.07092215120792389,
0.01286262646317482,
-0.5141090154647827,
0.005536306649446487,
-0.03204183280467987,
0.5983465313911438,
0.040748197585344315,
0.011435886844992638,
0.3452843129634857,
-0.14114589989185333,
-0.19717378914356232,
0.11988919973373413,
0.840360701084137,
0.998819887638092,
0.1941586583852768,
0.24677084386348724,
0.26025405526161194,
-0.44605761766433716,
0.1273348033428192,
-0.15008710324764252,
-0.2501470446586609,
0.22519196569919586,
0.43779417872428894,
0.7567830681800842,
0.23275570571422577,
-0.7617089152336121,
0.30446887016296387,
0.09513735771179199,
-0.02695714682340622,
-0.2984757721424103,
-0.1339566856622696,
0.04037433862686157,
0.5353707075119019,
0.41023898124694824,
-0.16287507116794586,
0.11901804804801941,
-0.5382594466209412,
0.5012789964675903,
0.24433787167072296,
-0.05370903015136719,
-0.053924281150102615,
0.7484375834465027,
-0.2188986986875534,
-0.6313097476959229,
0.5535394549369812,
-0.1072300598025322,
-0.4760548174381256,
0.2880535125732422,
0.8135004043579102,
1.007227897644043,
-0.4240070879459381,
0.5313407778739929,
0.36876440048217773,
0.3690946102142334,
-0.280301958322525,
0.2740326523780823,
-0.07830433547496796,
-0.5250149369239807,
-0.34915226697921753,
-0.5756986141204834,
-0.1645643711090088,
0.20538756251335144,
-0.709699273109436,
0.1495688110589981,
-0.4763365089893341,
-0.01646239310503006,
-0.2139749675989151,
-0.3830176889896393,
-0.3314633071422577,
0.11065245419740677,
-0.11353778094053268,
0.6657808423042297,
-0.6530795097351074,
0.4726458489894867,
0.2501792013645172,
-0.4908519387245178,
-0.4496387839317322,
0.363920658826828,
-0.1713448017835617,
-0.8523185849189758,
0.1589626669883728,
0.41437792778015137,
-0.25896063446998596,
0.13260473310947418,
-0.588233470916748,
-0.5698561072349548,
0.7816357612609863,
0.2795047461986542,
-0.631165623664856,
-0.2789233326911926,
-0.05001883581280708,
0.45598623156547546,
-0.17297106981277466,
-0.19658471643924713,
0.9934033751487732,
0.39717426896095276,
0.3022783398628235,
-0.4065507650375366,
0.3957408666610718,
0.21354007720947266,
0.04695574566721916,
0.13955579698085785,
-0.4119390547275543,
0.8438717722892761,
-0.6143761277198792,
-0.17565596103668213,
0.475966215133667,
0.615997314453125,
0.4530468285083771,
0.4570658802986145,
0.4377730190753937,
0.5771397352218628,
0.9416956305503845,
0.32757100462913513,
0.8699093461036682,
-0.09636489301919937,
-0.08130519092082977,
1.323553442955017,
0.02482656016945839,
0.7248045802116394,
1.044278860092163,
0.07826589792966843,
0.2755434215068817,
0.7363781332969666,
0.30304744839668274,
0.6411325335502625,
0.4093320071697235,
-0.30991867184638977,
-0.06585787236690521,
-0.1979900598526001,
-0.4370307922363281,
-0.009117948822677135,
0.4206017553806305,
-0.39811286330223083,
-0.16905280947685242,
0.5168192386627197,
0.28365200757980347,
0.2292880266904831,
-0.0423622727394104,
0.7707488536834717,
0.3407590389251709,
-0.7608445286750793,
0.7070994973182678,
-0.2823614180088043,
0.41278019547462463,
-0.23644700646400452,
0.017607400193810463,
-0.6829742789268494,
-0.09219177067279816,
-0.059579938650131226,
-0.6306223273277283,
0.30264848470687866,
-0.2619747221469879,
-0.07100271433591843,
0.06274563819169998,
0.19118145108222961,
-0.4625976085662842,
-0.22807234525680542,
0.3373717665672302,
0.2757120132446289,
0.4272215962409973,
-0.19504845142364502,
-0.6348561644554138,
0.23853008449077606,
-0.005387025885283947,
-0.28990721702575684,
0.009098853915929794,
0.7914292812347412,
0.08522465080022812,
0.7580417990684509,
0.6602338552474976,
0.17279238998889923,
0.19162821769714355,
0.30395379662513733,
0.6565001010894775,
-0.7655672430992126,
-0.5506061911582947,
-1.1703201532363892,
0.40472885966300964,
-0.04425393044948578,
-0.4678958058357239,
0.5996290445327759,
0.2250470370054245,
0.45805689692497253,
0.08743348717689514,
0.523625373840332,
0.18580205738544464,
0.3520021438598633,
-0.7568171620368958,
0.4565463662147522,
-0.602855920791626,
0.3748347759246826,
-0.27390146255493164,
-1.0009106397628784,
-0.3768867552280426,
0.5640649795532227,
-0.09804796427488327,
-0.1399187445640564,
1.035365343093872,
0.9057846665382385,
0.34867802262306213,
-0.10044697672128677,
0.494512140750885,
0.3189859986305237,
0.1352936178445816,
0.6661391854286194,
0.9493640661239624,
-0.2177361100912094,
0.7789351344108582,
-0.020007900893688202,
-0.13234029710292816,
-0.30873560905456543,
-0.5994170308113098,
-0.8537138104438782,
-0.5796937942504883,
-0.11766118556261063,
-0.5912075042724609,
0.17438723146915436,
0.7040684223175049,
0.1226586326956749,
-0.7672625780105591,
0.09773819893598557,
-0.5304991602897644,
0.248468816280365,
-0.11466231197118759,
-0.2836514115333557,
0.3700854480266571,
-0.8333452343940735,
-0.7016777992248535,
0.45411455631256104,
0.45331287384033203,
0.16806134581565857,
-0.3511800467967987,
-0.009653033688664436,
-0.19496317207813263,
0.46250155568122864,
0.4934033751487732,
0.2912627160549164,
-1.0468941926956177,
-0.4057881832122803,
0.08448068797588348,
-0.10800450295209885,
0.06772348284721375,
0.8902906179428101,
-0.7115380764007568,
0.5033173561096191,
0.44373026490211487,
0.8804802298545837,
0.1574488878250122,
-0.1459304392337799,
0.5888640880584717,
-0.532329261302948,
0.2130047082901001,
0.3185396194458008,
0.22371040284633636,
0.4837808310985565,
-0.5327293872833252,
0.14869356155395508,
0.18899762630462646,
-0.6431229710578918,
-1.0578402280807495,
0.285587340593338,
-0.8431203365325928,
-0.5462543368339539,
1.125563621520996,
-0.049268938601017,
-0.07707349210977554,
-0.41758397221565247,
-0.6296371817588806,
0.3550930321216583,
-0.38991251587867737,
0.9829198122024536,
1.0030485391616821,
-0.04238647595047951,
-0.3765782117843628,
-0.5924413204193115,
0.6431729793548584,
0.6324453949928284,
-0.7271595001220703,
0.24507923424243927,
0.5441576838493347,
0.018148206174373627,
0.10526871681213379,
0.5398048162460327,
-0.026439348235726357,
0.449174165725708,
0.050665535032749176,
-0.33704665303230286,
0.18401426076889038,
-0.7659093737602234,
-0.3939261734485626,
0.18631722033023834,
-0.09712059795856476,
-0.3712749481201172
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18975v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18975v1
|
A Novel Corpus of Annotated Medical Imaging Reports and Information Extraction Results Using BERT-based Language Models
| 2024-03-27T19:43:45 | 2024-03-27T19:43:45 |
Namu Park, Kevin Lybarger, Giridhar Kaushik Ramachandran, Spencer Lewis, Aashka Damani, Ozlem Uzuner, Martin Gunn, Meliha Yetisgen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Medical imaging is critical to the diagnosis, surveillance, and treatment of
many health conditions, including oncological, neurological, cardiovascular,
and musculoskeletal disorders, among others. Radiologists interpret these
complex, unstructured images and articulate their assessments through narrative
reports that remain largely unstructured. This unstructured narrative must be
converted into a structured semantic representation to facilitate secondary
applications such as retrospective analyses or clinical decision support. Here,
we introduce the Corpus of Annotated Medical Imaging Reports (CAMIR), which
includes 609 annotated radiology reports from three imaging modality types:
Computed Tomography, Magnetic Resonance Imaging, and Positron Emission
Tomography-Computed Tomography. Reports were annotated using an event-based
schema that captures clinical indications, lesions, and medical problems. Each
event consists of a trigger and multiple arguments, and a majority of the
argument types, including anatomy, normalize the spans to pre-defined concepts
to facilitate secondary use. CAMIR uniquely combines a granular event structure
and concept normalization. To extract CAMIR events, we explored two BERT
(Bi-directional Encoder Representation from Transformers)-based architectures,
including an existing architecture (mSpERT) that jointly extracts all event
information and a multi-step approach (PL-Marker++) that we augmented for the
CAMIR schema.
|
[
-0.22751884162425995,
-0.5382030606269836,
0.6836142539978027,
0.0036378938239067793,
-0.400471031665802,
-0.15113812685012817,
-0.23970375955104828,
-0.7960453033447266,
0.37981536984443665,
0.36273154616355896,
-0.13199463486671448,
-0.4613344371318817,
-0.7138490676879883,
-0.09870397299528122,
-0.12892794609069824,
1.1234749555587769,
-0.02738184668123722,
0.4236002564430237,
-0.010897649452090263,
-0.09326215833425522,
-0.4168621599674225,
-0.24754385650157928,
-0.23955433070659637,
-0.14830900728702545,
0.6921933889389038,
0.24481846392154694,
0.9272231459617615,
0.49269014596939087,
0.9456357955932617,
0.1614730805158615,
0.34168681502342224,
0.2974364459514618,
0.0960986539721489,
0.08542744815349579,
-0.000760997470933944,
0.1721947342157364,
-0.3413369059562683,
-0.33609601855278015,
0.5637432932853699,
0.6398013830184937,
0.3201146423816681,
0.06112515926361084,
-0.2825358211994171,
0.20328207314014435,
-0.40532806515693665,
0.5276709794998169,
-0.3696956932544708,
-0.029033564031124115,
-0.1353691816329956,
-0.6176940202713013,
-0.46458667516708374,
-0.0353940911591053,
0.23623058199882507,
-0.5908411145210266,
0.10928080230951309,
-0.36721503734588623,
1.0985841751098633,
-0.10779821127653122,
-0.24321378767490387,
-0.45904847979545593,
-0.5820375084877014,
0.6122313141822815,
-0.38277438282966614,
0.023228447884321213,
0.26324135065078735,
0.5402272343635559,
0.01571797765791416,
-0.9335286617279053,
-0.2401568740606308,
0.11521871387958527,
-0.4080076515674591,
0.2880861163139343,
-0.106717050075531,
0.10645255446434021,
0.006510429084300995,
0.09433966875076294,
-0.4255511462688446,
0.08278824388980865,
-0.6968743205070496,
-0.3294350504875183,
0.6795448064804077,
0.14840294420719147,
0.40935418009757996,
-0.40705811977386475,
-0.4663078486919403,
-0.14327795803546906,
-0.36504003405570984,
-0.3453651964664459,
-0.2733110189437866,
0.20833584666252136,
-0.04325230047106743,
0.6723957061767578,
0.14985336363315582,
0.45070594549179077,
-0.2888217270374298,
-0.26433324813842773,
0.4460613429546356,
-0.043652914464473724,
-0.1474289745092392,
0.1713949292898178,
0.6869543194770813,
0.4375537931919098,
-0.166693776845932,
-0.11374688148498535,
-0.14757922291755676,
0.059971146285533905,
0.04796266555786133,
-0.7008883357048035,
-0.21434494853019714,
0.3238462805747986,
-0.9858591556549072,
-0.41623982787132263,
-0.02909739688038826,
-0.8993859887123108,
-0.4801854193210602,
-0.2037450522184372,
0.5629234313964844,
-0.7901182770729065,
-0.2133912891149521,
0.12115363031625748,
-0.2743690311908722,
0.504389762878418,
0.4176234304904938,
-0.5300675630569458,
0.12273889034986496,
0.5126838088035583,
0.6658677458763123,
0.20120641589164734,
0.022353461012244225,
-0.5375394821166992,
0.3154096007347107,
-0.12550537288188934,
0.996249258518219,
-0.7103820443153381,
-0.5004614591598511,
0.16896988451480865,
-0.02453153394162655,
0.014029783196747303,
-0.2009393870830536,
0.5497908592224121,
-0.5335580110549927,
0.05663314834237099,
0.02558888867497444,
-0.28767359256744385,
-0.19049271941184998,
-0.06371545046567917,
-0.6314789652824402,
0.6627903580665588,
-0.02435004524886608,
-0.7082163095474243,
0.3699111044406891,
-0.7988450527191162,
-0.747105062007904,
0.4201800525188446,
-0.7528942823410034,
-0.1879236400127411,
0.18899458646774292,
0.2868964970111847,
0.45830869674682617,
-0.39951077103614807,
0.4438965618610382,
0.09138734638690948,
-0.1149226501584053,
0.1881943941116333,
-0.046325523406267166,
0.5329921841621399,
0.4972507953643799,
0.14683310687541962,
0.12837912142276764,
-0.7380399703979492,
-0.08098504692316055,
0.2164251208305359,
-0.18197497725486755,
-0.2950661778450012,
0.19869451224803925,
0.353915274143219,
0.28822609782218933,
0.25977736711502075,
-0.8723700642585754,
0.12936557829380035,
0.027095863595604897,
0.06197953224182129,
0.28610554337501526,
0.06844854354858398,
0.0957312360405922,
-0.5789920091629028,
0.23260389268398285,
0.17055849730968475,
0.162305548787117,
-0.6779959797859192,
-0.6812174320220947,
-0.47752517461776733,
-0.9477120041847229,
0.20230917632579803,
0.46345579624176025,
-0.8196415901184082,
0.11178962886333466,
-0.5733373165130615,
-0.3902435302734375,
-0.8909720778465271,
-0.4567200839519501,
0.3890909254550934,
0.7341152429580688,
0.3344942033290863,
-0.38820353150367737,
-0.785599410533905,
-0.9827743172645569,
0.09119563549757004,
-0.14500893652439117,
-0.112483449280262,
0.12561236321926117,
0.2158617526292801,
-0.35953861474990845,
0.8950409889221191,
-0.3865562379360199,
-0.59351646900177,
-0.3261446952819824,
0.8727265000343323,
0.23100575804710388,
0.3738696277141571,
0.4025179445743561,
-0.7646549940109253,
-0.12545648217201233,
0.4538326561450958,
-0.8525615334510803,
-0.05759358033537865,
-0.6110081672668457,
-0.06425775587558746,
0.491456538438797,
0.24639937281608582,
-0.434906005859375,
0.7811635732650757,
0.06500528007745743,
-0.09905894100666046,
0.38523775339126587,
-0.4410870671272278,
0.1265895813703537,
-0.8789135813713074,
0.2441788762807846,
-0.12251564860343933,
-0.2122258096933365,
-0.2662292718887329,
-0.16487348079681396,
0.13353000581264496,
-0.0571785606443882,
-0.1876782774925232,
0.13388791680335999,
-0.535249650478363,
-0.2968711256980896,
-0.06301507353782654,
-0.2706010639667511,
0.183547705411911,
0.23856763541698456,
0.5626010298728943,
0.0832848846912384,
0.5921991467475891,
-0.2742704749107361,
0.011613211594522,
0.4540506601333618,
-0.2537328600883484,
0.06854647397994995,
-0.42929425835609436,
0.12679438292980194,
-0.574407696723938,
0.040520090609788895,
-0.7847394347190857,
-0.30605098605155945,
-0.05660263076424599,
-0.7017081379890442,
0.644092321395874,
-0.25538188219070435,
-0.8273267149925232,
-0.10531322658061981,
-0.3185352683067322,
0.03952346369624138,
0.48275020718574524,
-0.27105167508125305,
0.9146907925605774,
0.5927330255508423,
-0.2936636209487915,
-0.35347414016723633,
-0.9006232619285583,
0.24489173293113708,
0.2998611032962799,
-0.6894813179969788,
0.32857170701026917,
0.1638079732656479,
-0.19388632476329803,
0.2997160255908966,
0.3235209882259369,
-0.40418243408203125,
-0.15941037237644196,
0.3018507957458496,
0.8145772218704224,
-0.3474592864513397,
0.3330044746398926,
0.05965057387948036,
-0.059744756668806076,
-0.040614333003759384,
0.09545151144266129,
0.30937638878822327,
-0.16191335022449493,
-0.42682045698165894,
-0.3315560221672058,
0.8644530177116394,
0.6282510757446289,
-0.1527693122625351,
0.4691828489303589,
0.6837549805641174,
-0.5788500308990479,
0.5061869025230408,
-0.5831508636474609,
-0.1385173201560974,
-0.23802852630615234,
0.5650548338890076,
-0.35137248039245605,
-0.5157246589660645,
0.6119526624679565,
0.15336212515830994,
0.2200334072113037,
0.49631527066230774,
0.636073648929596,
-0.33265241980552673,
1.053896427154541,
0.22757144272327423,
0.20913700759410858,
0.19869071245193481,
0.07976370304822922,
0.19411684572696686,
-0.611212968826294,
-0.39456456899642944,
-0.3069133162498474,
-0.1312754899263382,
-0.4433329999446869,
-0.3885071873664856,
0.4715445637702942,
-0.4693179428577423,
0.09585326164960861,
-0.02477097511291504,
-0.5099824070930481,
0.23488669097423553,
0.27492913603782654,
0.11200783401727676,
0.2626601457595825,
0.11240291595458984,
0.027757694944739342,
-0.30542054772377014,
-0.5167310833930969,
-0.5894082188606262,
1.025705099105835,
0.4405064880847931,
0.6126965284347534,
0.09026423841714859,
0.5845364332199097,
0.2833156883716583,
0.6535489559173584,
-0.9146193861961365,
0.2835962772369385,
-0.3641867935657501,
-0.7004323601722717,
0.051191966980695724,
0.013806665316224098,
-0.9601243734359741,
0.2444596290588379,
-0.310127854347229,
-0.5849263668060303,
0.4488207995891571,
-0.3378858268260956,
-0.5113859176635742,
0.19170649349689484,
-0.6516861319541931,
0.557340681552887,
-0.44413861632347107,
-0.18082483112812042,
-0.10476054251194,
-1.0800193548202515,
0.1543179452419281,
-0.05826050043106079,
0.7017968893051147,
-0.15811073780059814,
-0.05254731327295303,
0.4542384445667267,
-0.20655176043510437,
0.8107337355613708,
-0.12909166514873505,
0.3730465769767761,
0.25477278232574463,
0.2641207277774811,
0.12195149064064026,
-0.00259521696716547,
0.14224302768707275,
0.3186202049255371,
0.42442089319229126,
-0.18368834257125854,
-0.24649198353290558,
0.3176637291908264,
-0.6290842294692993,
-0.04933371767401695,
-0.5503101944923401,
-0.726608395576477,
-0.053103771060705185,
0.22460122406482697,
0.2725774645805359,
0.7208376526832581,
-0.04160038009285927,
0.02863343618810177,
0.3164142966270447,
-0.43292325735092163,
0.38821184635162354,
0.5586483478546143,
-0.20021763443946838,
-0.4056415259838104,
0.8665874004364014,
0.09706979990005493,
0.0015190080739557743,
0.5857491493225098,
0.08471336215734482,
-0.02215537801384926,
-0.5833076238632202,
-0.16179980337619781,
0.2643651068210602,
-0.8248434662818909,
-0.4934823215007782,
-0.6732876300811768,
-0.33678361773490906,
-0.5111932158470154,
-0.2848028540611267,
-0.35477301478385925,
-0.5343207716941833,
-0.2407066971063614,
0.13189607858657837,
0.2730960249900818,
0.44271859526634216,
-0.39845144748687744,
0.0588410310447216,
-1.0945043563842773,
0.1144450232386589,
-0.24088136851787567,
0.0011104341829195619,
-0.38092494010925293,
-0.30032554268836975,
-0.2559582591056824,
-0.3520161509513855,
-0.08938191831111908,
-0.6570937037467957,
0.7386649250984192,
0.27245548367500305,
0.5016862154006958,
0.38112348318099976,
0.022165611386299133,
0.8424889445304871,
-0.23608846962451935,
0.46777409315109253,
0.44903668761253357,
-0.45919710397720337,
0.7635364532470703,
-0.40400436520576477,
0.00023936241632327437,
0.48178690671920776,
0.2361690104007721,
-0.34016066789627075,
-0.22765156626701355,
-0.691999614238739,
-0.9828778505325317,
0.6077369451522827,
-0.052749622613191605,
-0.16262146830558777,
-0.4270358085632324,
0.08468960225582123,
0.3425444960594177,
-0.09998903423547745,
-0.46821996569633484,
-0.02181173302233219,
-0.13338732719421387,
-0.4538663923740387,
0.32266664505004883,
-0.43830010294914246,
-0.41273781657218933,
-0.1766585111618042,
0.3922014832496643,
-0.1350512057542801,
0.6600787043571472,
0.7053225636482239,
-0.4988819360733032,
0.09395170956850052,
0.16212812066078186,
0.4107697904109955,
0.5743409991264343,
-0.5772411823272705,
0.38538163900375366,
-0.28016629815101624,
-0.5376062393188477,
-0.7131582498550415,
0.27743077278137207,
0.19945862889289856,
0.4524209201335907,
0.7094311714172363,
0.39180636405944824,
0.32877492904663086,
-0.8907414078712463,
0.7727165222167969,
-0.2274291217327118,
-0.12051380425691605,
-0.5385298132896423,
-0.45502761006355286,
-0.3381894826889038,
0.18766267597675323,
0.5214965343475342,
0.12107482552528381,
0.3937191665172577,
-0.44842374324798584,
0.41812682151794434,
0.3398229479789734,
-0.5189008116722107,
-0.36635908484458923,
0.2954101860523224,
0.17817284166812897,
0.3063938021659851,
0.4299671947956085,
-0.008606180548667908,
0.046411752700805664,
0.5118809938430786,
0.317611962556839,
0.5251006484031677,
0.27806228399276733,
0.2629503905773163,
0.40042370557785034,
0.4347745180130005,
0.1805548369884491,
0.4841357469558716,
0.033094558864831924,
-0.701061487197876,
-0.5898465514183044,
-0.35110393166542053,
-0.15664593875408173,
0.15057827532291412,
-0.9252951741218567,
0.4400677978992462,
-0.44748780131340027,
-0.04897889122366905,
0.443594753742218,
-0.20337629318237305,
-0.5209943652153015,
0.02824181504547596,
0.6388491988182068,
0.9121302962303162,
-0.5343436598777771,
1.0340834856033325,
0.8152798414230347,
-0.771700382232666,
-0.648268461227417,
-0.45508354902267456,
0.040373288094997406,
-0.8473690748214722,
0.6869006156921387,
0.10121069103479385,
0.19687572121620178,
-0.4103074371814728,
-0.42430105805397034,
-0.5519715547561646,
1.1258398294448853,
0.2484312206506729,
-0.20753113925457,
0.08421895653009415,
0.050991714000701904,
0.5460427403450012,
-0.7763354182243347,
0.37099722027778625,
0.49271324276924133,
0.373041570186615,
0.5934115052223206,
-0.8233602046966553,
0.027388865128159523,
-0.33150631189346313,
-0.08307231962680817,
0.02957559935748577,
0.02981993928551674,
0.6595157384872437,
-0.4564622938632965,
-0.3509470224380493,
0.15047810971736908,
0.36877506971359253,
0.002100211102515459,
0.37847259640693665,
0.04408467933535576,
0.2809816300868988,
0.5092030763626099,
-0.03066743165254593,
1.2073898315429688,
-0.2055363953113556,
0.16789720952510834,
1.033803105354309,
-0.3365185260772705,
0.7229809761047363,
0.5987687706947327,
0.2920833230018616,
0.4826459288597107,
0.5000488758087158,
-0.010751239955425262,
0.6700438261032104,
-0.23171676695346832,
-0.2591410279273987,
-0.31441906094551086,
-0.3334210515022278,
-0.3912315368652344,
0.6818115711212158,
0.7086027264595032,
-0.6655651330947876,
-0.4691607654094696,
-0.04722278192639351,
0.10569535195827484,
-0.3425484299659729,
-0.2578641474246979,
0.8695384860038757,
-0.1269739419221878,
-0.36914879083633423,
0.19322988390922546,
-0.16882739961147308,
0.3079511225223541,
-0.7133706212043762,
-0.15206685662269592,
0.1539185494184494,
0.15632566809654236,
-0.2514732778072357,
-0.8129021525382996,
0.6518030762672424,
-0.09954564273357391,
0.03138640895485878,
-0.10139760375022888,
1.0032719373703003,
-0.23909412324428558,
-0.6674751043319702,
0.15744884312152863,
0.2202332317829132,
0.2971751391887665,
0.28853562474250793,
-0.1911201924085617,
0.3095342516899109,
-0.18499810993671417,
0.02570955455303192,
0.3721230626106262,
0.4806770384311676,
-0.14391712844371796,
0.1687559187412262,
0.48880478739738464,
0.21232302486896515,
-0.24350450932979584,
-0.04403701424598694,
0.9988324642181396,
-0.5555822849273682,
-0.24179819226264954,
-0.4782530665397644,
0.8261850476264954,
-0.3265250325202942,
-0.21465885639190674,
0.00815799180418253,
0.6937514543533325,
0.21720024943351746,
-0.09378206729888916,
1.0414611101150513,
-0.2731679677963257,
0.5575345158576965,
-0.34762686491012573,
0.6329012513160706,
-0.29934343695640564,
0.2248079925775528,
0.02568822167813778,
-0.04369077458977699,
-0.8014797568321228,
0.5940217971801758,
-0.4282367527484894,
-0.45017823576927185,
0.7266508936882019,
0.5985603332519531,
0.22385093569755554,
0.15170462429523468,
0.2795410454273224,
0.1806815266609192,
0.3251303434371948,
0.5037918090820312,
0.7022813558578491,
-0.2457648068666458,
0.6792424917221069,
0.030787590891122818,
-0.5364864468574524,
-0.42108744382858276,
-0.8318458199501038,
-0.5615611672401428,
-0.7351649403572083,
-0.5549483895301819,
-0.27965015172958374,
-0.1031312644481659,
0.7173073291778564,
0.6204929947853088,
-0.6611014008522034,
0.1750468909740448,
0.43990787863731384,
-0.17286531627178192,
0.006474838126450777,
-0.19125042855739594,
0.6849043965339661,
-0.6299836039543152,
-0.19840481877326965,
0.030934840440750122,
0.5845069289207458,
-0.13869626820087433,
0.23411180078983307,
0.20207494497299194,
-0.2075003981590271,
-0.13128997385501862,
0.6369501948356628,
0.4359094202518463,
-0.3953306972980499,
-0.37584200501441956,
-0.24431496858596802,
-0.29407477378845215,
0.3505472242832184,
0.8364649415016174,
-0.7422414422035217,
0.8162660002708435,
0.2818388342857361,
0.67430180311203,
0.5304181575775146,
-0.5394518971443176,
0.28019073605537415,
-0.5811392664909363,
0.3898628354072571,
0.5626220703125,
0.5304811000823975,
0.1654856652021408,
-0.2549322843551636,
0.3245926797389984,
0.10724300891160965,
-0.19590026140213013,
-0.7723593711853027,
0.06656117737293243,
-1.4097610712051392,
-0.5521854162216187,
1.1744807958602905,
-0.18634018301963806,
-0.24261291325092316,
-0.3437899351119995,
-0.3528619110584259,
0.2566074728965759,
-0.26500052213668823,
0.6987720131874084,
0.42208579182624817,
-0.587665319442749,
-0.302141934633255,
-0.4412813186645508,
0.10363300889730453,
0.035136640071868896,
-0.568885087966919,
-0.3467487692832947,
0.695794939994812,
0.10215741395950317,
0.4097248315811157,
0.7079148888587952,
-0.9255832433700562,
0.4813958704471588,
-0.1663554161787033,
0.4192834794521332,
-0.29303404688835144,
-0.17731089890003204,
-0.1345871239900589,
0.19222690165042877,
-0.03759435564279556,
-0.5802010297775269
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18973v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18973v1
|
Conformal Intent Classification and Clarification for Fast and Accurate Intent Recognition
| 2024-03-27T19:42:01 | 2024-03-27T19:42:01 |
Floris den Hengst, Ralf Wolter, Patrick Altmeyer, Arda Kaygan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present Conformal Intent Classification and Clarification (CICC), a
framework for fast and accurate intent classification for task-oriented
dialogue systems. The framework turns heuristic uncertainty scores of any
intent classifier into a clarification question that is guaranteed to contain
the true intent at a pre-defined confidence level. By disambiguating between a
small number of likely intents, the user query can be resolved quickly and
accurately. Additionally, we propose to augment the framework for out-of-scope
detection. In a comparative evaluation using seven intent recognition datasets
we find that CICC generates small clarification questions and is capable of
out-of-scope detection. CICC can help practitioners and researchers
substantially in improving the user experience of dialogue agents with specific
clarification questions.
|
[
-0.2656605541706085,
-0.5440409183502197,
0.9556912183761597,
-0.02597874589264393,
0.0815841481089592,
-0.18966171145439148,
-0.3838726878166199,
-0.18103663623332977,
-0.04967343434691429,
0.40663158893585205,
-0.5849428772926331,
-0.6172837018966675,
-0.5379363298416138,
-0.25736716389656067,
-0.4144434630870819,
0.6924209594726562,
0.09482492506504059,
-0.06295223534107208,
-0.39065203070640564,
-0.2038930058479309,
-0.30964797735214233,
-0.25432339310646057,
-0.5761076211929321,
0.18187713623046875,
0.3249626159667969,
1.0513643026351929,
0.45570090413093567,
0.2161073088645935,
0.577677309513092,
0.2520889639854431,
-0.13785181939601898,
0.09117458015680313,
-0.41807839274406433,
0.18845082819461823,
-0.18903106451034546,
-0.5601971745491028,
-0.2410425841808319,
-0.22851161658763885,
0.45258018374443054,
0.7827985286712646,
-0.14005620777606964,
0.3665234446525574,
-0.10855268687009811,
0.5818493962287903,
-0.9747740626335144,
0.3806332051753998,
-0.5265111923217773,
-0.3935144245624542,
-0.24296578764915466,
-0.0895589217543602,
-0.6849215030670166,
-0.4402126669883728,
0.43600231409072876,
-0.6355394721031189,
0.32184427976608276,
0.062078122049570084,
0.5027132630348206,
0.37711313366889954,
-0.4553200900554657,
-0.6483386754989624,
-0.6714351773262024,
0.5452994108200073,
-0.3992409110069275,
0.5421274304389954,
0.154758021235466,
0.7275358438491821,
-0.39561203122138977,
-0.9693886041641235,
-0.5660995841026306,
-0.10492537915706635,
-0.1047803983092308,
-0.06393317878246307,
0.04602225497364998,
0.4086042642593384,
0.4605422914028168,
0.464011013507843,
-0.3745380938053131,
-0.3772943317890167,
-0.5555573105812073,
-0.2589045464992523,
0.5514401197433472,
0.0882636308670044,
0.0069796061143279076,
0.4886617064476013,
-0.23514124751091003,
-0.08731215447187424,
-0.6136621236801147,
0.6506515741348267,
0.1773662269115448,
0.06329043954610825,
0.02497193031013012,
0.36979764699935913,
-0.42038679122924805,
0.6490311026573181,
0.7174935936927795,
-0.05858071520924568,
-0.06828676164150238,
-0.1439380794763565,
-0.11611726880073547,
0.4118146598339081,
0.5583791732788086,
0.3474322557449341,
-0.051182687282562256,
0.12505082786083221,
0.08262285590171814,
0.022752342745661736,
0.1706741452217102,
-0.7587951421737671,
0.0030369418673217297,
0.35369744896888733,
-0.470775306224823,
0.10105253010988235,
0.3809835612773895,
-0.3044944703578949,
-0.3934185802936554,
-0.10701246559619904,
-0.10089961439371109,
-0.12701167166233063,
-0.09644889831542969,
0.3527310788631439,
-0.10140201449394226,
0.34916916489601135,
0.7320486307144165,
-0.7118688821792603,
0.2759440243244171,
0.6256930232048035,
0.5619837641716003,
-0.13895632326602936,
0.1823708713054657,
-0.4498138129711151,
0.19689173996448517,
-0.0815596878528595,
0.8468923568725586,
-0.5333570837974548,
-0.5305494070053101,
0.07587496936321259,
0.22069615125656128,
-0.10019081085920334,
-0.2905614674091339,
0.6556059718132019,
-0.5824576616287231,
0.24005389213562012,
-0.3939987123012543,
-0.6820815801620483,
-0.6179254055023193,
0.34470051527023315,
-0.6303041577339172,
0.6706101298332214,
0.37498241662979126,
-0.5736545324325562,
0.5855176448822021,
-0.9578657150268555,
-0.2637105882167816,
0.358732134103775,
-0.1545371562242508,
-0.2507191002368927,
-0.015368059277534485,
-0.07982348650693893,
0.2262660712003708,
-0.28984349966049194,
0.23595163226127625,
-0.4361870288848877,
-0.39848676323890686,
0.2544232904911041,
-0.38884323835372925,
0.6700698733329773,
0.5002489686012268,
-0.4923984110355377,
0.24705319106578827,
-0.4434802234172821,
0.35692137479782104,
-0.5176035165786743,
-0.013860573060810566,
-0.15073345601558685,
-0.05916641652584076,
-0.3666498064994812,
0.1605800986289978,
0.4405452013015747,
-0.5568902492523193,
0.0939495712518692,
-0.19256943464279175,
0.4110167920589447,
0.3283260464668274,
0.16692504286766052,
0.5772943496704102,
-0.17525984346866608,
0.3615621030330658,
0.24404560029506683,
0.6357899308204651,
-0.17600961029529572,
-0.9170875549316406,
-0.7451976537704468,
-0.2918252646923065,
0.07976168394088745,
0.4501553475856781,
-0.4088766872882843,
0.5775068402290344,
-0.021212099120020866,
-0.48415809869766235,
-0.31461361050605774,
-0.010157802142202854,
0.33134886622428894,
0.2831711769104004,
0.16064946353435516,
-0.4393814206123352,
-0.15020275115966797,
-0.6358814239501953,
-0.22477973997592926,
-0.701680600643158,
0.11890197545289993,
0.2888467311859131,
0.36601993441581726,
-0.18517835438251495,
1.1952091455459595,
-0.6612080931663513,
-0.44259822368621826,
-0.3223855197429657,
0.12150917947292328,
0.011390136554837227,
0.20363286137580872,
0.3544846177101135,
-1.1551048755645752,
-0.7611600160598755,
0.029600314795970917,
-0.3183407485485077,
-0.014107312075793743,
-0.23056557774543762,
0.0299022626131773,
-0.01974266581237316,
0.9324346780776978,
-0.48768073320388794,
0.9847812056541443,
0.06566639989614487,
-0.39282897114753723,
0.25235500931739807,
-0.1620354801416397,
0.37869665026664734,
-0.546737015247345,
-0.02543170191347599,
-0.1843440979719162,
-0.41570964455604553,
-0.7749412655830383,
-0.40565723180770874,
0.3102450966835022,
0.22386875748634338,
-0.7935331463813782,
0.3927941918373108,
-0.33043497800827026,
0.05196187645196915,
-0.16314838826656342,
0.17353419959545135,
-0.0023522579576820135,
0.5325340032577515,
0.27210482954978943,
0.695172131061554,
0.3868028521537781,
-0.8297575116157532,
0.20272807776927948,
0.24984775483608246,
-0.33807072043418884,
0.6923264861106873,
-0.43123117089271545,
0.04057783633470535,
-0.13979768753051758,
0.36943426728248596,
-1.2276242971420288,
-0.5013585090637207,
0.43217992782592773,
-0.4216162860393524,
0.027403630316257477,
-0.18642491102218628,
-0.12917183339595795,
-0.2603697180747986,
-0.20556418597698212,
0.8364500403404236,
0.2976665496826172,
-0.6306799054145813,
0.6068564057350159,
0.2621837258338928,
0.21471308171749115,
-0.2954567074775696,
-0.30460426211357117,
-0.5539571046829224,
-0.17325003445148468,
-0.4286341071128845,
0.013206269592046738,
-0.33411940932273865,
-0.352723091840744,
-0.4497981667518616,
-0.11730129271745682,
-0.40431150794029236,
-0.07552133500576019,
0.6868776679039001,
-0.014523017220199108,
-0.04540136083960533,
-0.013491228222846985,
0.06270616501569748,
0.18644100427627563,
0.0471251979470253,
-0.2751264274120331,
0.1297573745250702,
-0.6336672306060791,
-0.6651923060417175,
-0.7378248572349548,
0.38594377040863037,
0.9314571619033813,
0.1581597924232483,
0.3440791666507721,
0.46111491322517395,
-0.25912347435951233,
0.1965055912733078,
-0.592092752456665,
-0.10889992117881775,
-0.5078490376472473,
-0.21820084750652313,
-0.43844664096832275,
-0.9517221450805664,
0.5671843886375427,
-0.1695084273815155,
0.19893093407154083,
0.37097808718681335,
0.5557806491851807,
-0.02657955139875412,
1.086082100868225,
0.7975740432739258,
0.35257628560066223,
0.5902451276779175,
-0.16097433865070343,
0.3031918406486511,
-0.8004412055015564,
-0.2796500027179718,
-0.5259448885917664,
-0.06587494909763336,
-0.35212379693984985,
-0.32248786091804504,
0.3790304958820343,
0.02109149470925331,
-0.04231711104512215,
0.5186680555343628,
-0.6711283326148987,
0.3603838086128235,
0.4418017864227295,
0.06325200200080872,
0.3368617594242096,
-0.5820882320404053,
0.14142675697803497,
0.11580602824687958,
-0.44119465351104736,
-0.5398617386817932,
1.02469003200531,
0.392439067363739,
0.8011691570281982,
0.3532448709011078,
0.3861922025680542,
0.48834851384162903,
0.45044809579849243,
-0.904563844203949,
0.5044085383415222,
0.2108973115682602,
-1.101340889930725,
-0.34413254261016846,
-0.10428918898105621,
-0.5485056042671204,
-0.06062277778983116,
0.29882532358169556,
-0.9930860996246338,
0.7592512369155884,
0.33079004287719727,
-0.8098577857017517,
0.16398082673549652,
-1.0428985357284546,
0.852587103843689,
-0.1525276005268097,
-0.02634900063276291,
0.04742049053311348,
-0.8806471228599548,
0.3738960325717926,
0.09570054709911346,
-0.040453098714351654,
-0.1314699351787567,
-0.03886416554450989,
0.5101500153541565,
-0.47333115339279175,
0.8432514667510986,
-0.3674681782722473,
-0.1882503479719162,
0.886615514755249,
-0.10650969296693802,
0.3382740318775177,
0.3753564953804016,
0.16946029663085938,
0.12647438049316406,
0.23682276904582977,
-0.07657851278781891,
-0.6680581569671631,
0.3017209470272064,
-0.21557025611400604,
-0.6481481194496155,
-0.42318806052207947,
-0.5090656876564026,
-0.20237095654010773,
0.23409342765808105,
0.5155046582221985,
0.26532623171806335,
-0.2929506003856659,
0.33586499094963074,
1.0062785148620605,
0.23196180164813995,
0.2914882302284241,
0.5809550285339355,
0.1864267736673355,
0.029940469190478325,
0.392675518989563,
-0.30284246802330017,
0.489108145236969,
0.4929974377155304,
-0.07651713490486145,
-0.7418562173843384,
-0.5524928569793701,
-0.2741706073284149,
0.06568542122840881,
-0.9039003252983093,
-0.0826592892408371,
-0.36417606472969055,
-0.07710372656583786,
-0.7725553512573242,
-0.39661169052124023,
-0.29138436913490295,
-0.4020587205886841,
-0.4294165372848511,
0.3671130836009979,
0.1526005119085312,
0.7740679979324341,
0.10130096226930618,
0.8864372968673706,
-0.578353762626648,
0.14750581979751587,
0.19359906017780304,
0.21183153986930847,
-0.66115802526474,
-0.5560569167137146,
-0.08792402595281601,
0.28111425042152405,
-0.5299354791641235,
-0.7030184864997864,
-0.129587322473526,
0.4295959174633026,
0.4605896472930908,
1.1050995588302612,
0.560049831867218,
0.6871912479400635,
-0.022312065586447716,
0.986376166343689,
0.5510591864585876,
-0.9200863242149353,
0.5935970544815063,
-0.024104012176394463,
0.441720575094223,
1.1955190896987915,
0.40126320719718933,
-0.46800661087036133,
-0.3883363604545593,
-0.7260001301765442,
-0.5206056237220764,
0.8371909856796265,
0.10516159981489182,
-0.5134268403053284,
0.0850701779127121,
0.5623266696929932,
0.1504126787185669,
0.20603206753730774,
-0.29837071895599365,
-0.1221093162894249,
-0.10857370495796204,
-0.49885860085487366,
0.07485675066709518,
-0.2837534248828888,
-0.17572152614593506,
-0.18488426506519318,
0.5933857560157776,
-0.5006194114685059,
0.39207923412323,
0.5748787522315979,
-0.38572803139686584,
-0.07759629189968109,
0.4588863253593445,
0.8532232642173767,
0.6186258792877197,
-0.3560534715652466,
-0.1607818901538849,
0.28870779275894165,
-0.7844045162200928,
0.17146827280521393,
-0.3227371871471405,
-0.11464297026395798,
0.03201756253838539,
-0.008591719903051853,
0.35961470007896423,
-0.09131713211536407,
-0.6922605633735657,
0.9935555458068848,
-0.7228492498397827,
-0.26163509488105774,
-0.7651187181472778,
0.3526114821434021,
-0.381894588470459,
0.3457380533218384,
-0.08457735925912857,
0.21975748240947723,
0.6416944861412048,
-0.6117682456970215,
0.15002162754535675,
0.36309340596199036,
-0.9414072036743164,
-0.11115790158510208,
0.44762006402015686,
0.1805877536535263,
-0.16119234263896942,
0.38913533091545105,
-0.49251946806907654,
-0.5343838930130005,
0.39477306604385376,
0.047726090997457504,
1.006008505821228,
-0.13388808071613312,
0.16907714307308197,
0.38629451394081116,
-0.010912558063864708,
-0.2974860966205597,
0.3141010105609894,
-0.8740677833557129,
-0.4201291501522064,
0.053820863366127014,
-0.13493412733078003,
-0.7520151138305664,
-0.11486081033945084,
-0.8183631300926208,
0.45157182216644287,
-0.7075424790382385,
-0.3807910084724426,
-0.014994842931628227,
-0.13106359541416168,
-0.3959154486656189,
0.09919093549251556,
0.0028764803428202868,
1.1298315525054932,
-0.41491106152534485,
0.8601546287536621,
0.7051201462745667,
-0.054375309497117996,
-0.6465796828269958,
0.19228941202163696,
0.14482516050338745,
-0.28934118151664734,
0.5919884443283081,
0.3112199008464813,
-0.6561328768730164,
-0.17822226881980896,
-0.7390207648277283,
-0.7089254856109619,
1.118288516998291,
-0.08260596543550491,
-0.7265039086341858,
-0.11830473691225052,
0.14734181761741638,
0.40339910984039307,
-0.7302002906799316,
0.6294716000556946,
0.8411494493484497,
0.6494303941726685,
0.5972956418991089,
-0.883169412612915,
-0.03720160201191902,
0.057059817016124725,
-0.2540532350540161,
0.10397310554981232,
-0.4859040081501007,
0.4334312379360199,
-0.5156890153884888,
-0.4870418906211853,
0.2852579653263092,
0.7369334101676941,
-0.05208348110318184,
0.8289027810096741,
0.8971672654151917,
0.19123664498329163,
0.7070826888084412,
-0.5575581192970276,
0.5917035341262817,
-0.22154106199741364,
0.2911706268787384,
1.1435059309005737,
-0.33044296503067017,
0.4880116283893585,
0.45438212156295776,
0.1420595943927765,
0.661769688129425,
0.7073323726654053,
0.509691059589386,
0.6859217286109924,
0.05762740224599838,
-0.5180846452713013,
-0.34139004349708557,
-0.03145404905080795,
-0.2500109076499939,
0.3910090923309326,
1.0265618562698364,
-0.06216895952820778,
-0.18430252373218536,
0.0049752769991755486,
-0.1583632230758667,
-0.021267538890242577,
-0.425629585981369,
1.029758334159851,
-0.0291662085801363,
-0.965914249420166,
0.4905956983566284,
-0.32057473063468933,
0.42882129549980164,
-0.6129677891731262,
-0.042643994092941284,
0.24524910748004913,
0.6674410700798035,
-0.43091192841529846,
-0.8938201665878296,
0.20719890296459198,
-0.30403822660446167,
-0.21214993298053741,
-0.1015772745013237,
0.6777424812316895,
-0.5895891189575195,
0.14088058471679688,
-0.0701153501868248,
-0.1260683238506317,
0.3165275752544403,
-0.24450065195560455,
-0.7153724431991577,
-0.13084104657173157,
0.06448683887720108,
0.2133282721042633,
-0.25640833377838135,
0.569165825843811,
-0.40418875217437744,
0.8389374017715454,
0.587785542011261,
-0.2525039315223694,
0.03450434282422066,
-0.017013560980558395,
0.7346127033233643,
-0.4366375803947449,
-0.7675032019615173,
-0.2739814221858978,
0.5087634921073914,
-0.34262725710868835,
-0.4112124443054199,
0.5665150284767151,
0.3489718437194824,
0.8251250982284546,
0.07229170948266983,
0.6592805981636047,
-0.3302614986896515,
0.47736120223999023,
-0.15411445498466492,
0.32446637749671936,
-0.42410972714424133,
0.35403910279273987,
0.1560766100883484,
-0.6091881394386292,
-0.23557236790657043,
0.3757404685020447,
-0.49712279438972473,
0.06113487854599953,
0.9780368208885193,
0.7000149488449097,
-0.061327360570430756,
0.38269245624542236,
0.3670443594455719,
-0.15747401118278503,
0.4469090402126312,
0.7437525987625122,
0.9635167717933655,
-0.4048648774623871,
0.6789736151695251,
-0.24202296137809753,
-0.4318597912788391,
-0.7278602719306946,
-0.5577294826507568,
-0.9136559963226318,
-0.848187267780304,
-0.5182574987411499,
-0.18399320542812347,
-0.08499287813901901,
0.8194212317466736,
0.9083189964294434,
-0.9872400760650635,
-0.21490424871444702,
-0.171822190284729,
0.35165905952453613,
-0.2931772470474243,
-0.25596481561660767,
0.06366623193025589,
-0.4948694407939911,
-0.6071486473083496,
0.16635797917842865,
0.42686983942985535,
0.05338885635137558,
-0.17248913645744324,
-0.30295032262802124,
-0.18623286485671997,
0.0909348726272583,
0.40382295846939087,
0.73283851146698,
-0.7171685099601746,
-0.4021010994911194,
0.09578966349363327,
-0.2074897289276123,
0.005613630171865225,
1.289267659187317,
-0.32591038942337036,
0.5419492721557617,
0.4900716543197632,
0.0969153642654419,
0.23962906002998352,
0.11300604790449142,
0.3647356331348419,
-0.7004284858703613,
0.18595770001411438,
0.28293731808662415,
0.29603075981140137,
0.04241814464330673,
-0.7766892910003662,
0.2542285919189453,
-0.047312408685684204,
-0.6877492666244507,
-0.5381631255149841,
0.5265302658081055,
-1.4677859544754028,
-0.11521562933921814,
1.10355806350708,
-0.5029626488685608,
-0.7299677729606628,
-0.8926672339439392,
-0.48329025506973267,
-0.03581472486257553,
-0.7506631016731262,
0.5013204216957092,
0.5628148317337036,
-0.47891896963119507,
0.02475854568183422,
-0.1016068160533905,
0.9023453593254089,
0.05123506486415863,
-0.8154237270355225,
0.18478944897651672,
0.4746817648410797,
0.18660694360733032,
0.5701422691345215,
0.7604053020477295,
-0.2902432084083557,
0.8948081731796265,
-0.3465525507926941,
-0.02959258109331131,
0.19288355112075806,
-0.5887661576271057,
-0.08596344292163849,
0.25404149293899536,
0.2193036824464798,
-0.3811037838459015
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18969v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18969v2
|
A Survey on Large Language Models from Concept to Implementation
| 2024-03-27T19:35:41 | 2024-05-28T02:34:26 |
Chen Wang, Jin Zhao, Jiaqi Gong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IT, cs.LG, math.IT
|
Recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs), particularly those built
on Transformer architectures, have significantly broadened the scope of natural
language processing (NLP) applications, transcending their initial use in
chatbot technology. This paper investigates the multifaceted applications of
these models, with an emphasis on the GPT series. This exploration focuses on
the transformative impact of artificial intelligence (AI) driven tools in
revolutionizing traditional tasks like coding and problem-solving, while also
paving new paths in research and development across diverse industries. From
code interpretation and image captioning to facilitating the construction of
interactive systems and advancing computational domains, Transformer models
exemplify a synergy of deep learning, data analysis, and neural network design.
This survey provides an in-depth look at the latest research in Transformer
models, highlighting their versatility and the potential they hold for
transforming diverse application sectors, thereby offering readers a
comprehensive understanding of the current and future landscape of
Transformer-based LLMs in practical applications.
|
[
-0.4179786145687103,
-0.7802292108535767,
0.5880774259567261,
0.06802798062562943,
0.2350206971168518,
0.2681905925273895,
-0.2925925552845001,
-0.4535493850708008,
-0.15117408335208893,
0.6849908232688904,
-0.4197802245616913,
-0.08413249254226685,
-0.8721291422843933,
0.07253937423229218,
-0.7842717170715332,
0.7471532225608826,
0.13431289792060852,
-0.08187680691480637,
0.07179573178291321,
0.19510112702846527,
-0.5074774622917175,
-0.5445362329483032,
-0.6237953305244446,
-0.5642942786216736,
0.29677823185920715,
-0.032789818942546844,
0.9647637605667114,
0.1530267596244812,
0.7711226940155029,
0.4766739010810852,
-0.08826528489589691,
-0.006708997767418623,
-0.30748704075813293,
0.06784989684820175,
0.016186239197850227,
-0.4932514429092407,
-0.2384314239025116,
-0.01982199214398861,
0.7579053640365601,
0.7927295565605164,
-0.11839742213487625,
-0.013798288069665432,
-0.03296646475791931,
0.34118136763572693,
-0.11320112645626068,
0.47414630651474,
-0.6223409175872803,
-0.03883253037929535,
-0.07625944167375565,
0.13079288601875305,
-0.6675254702568054,
-0.22391799092292786,
0.2707868218421936,
-0.06951157748699188,
0.1056911051273346,
-0.01574924774467945,
0.5378841757774353,
0.35404548048973083,
-0.5657551288604736,
-0.4760907292366028,
-1.3454073667526245,
0.948688268661499,
-0.8668814897537231,
0.5637568235397339,
-0.1215549185872078,
0.5698490738868713,
-0.3811435401439667,
-0.9854447841644287,
-0.6180744171142578,
-0.36944350600242615,
-0.18727225065231323,
-0.12910021841526031,
-0.568119466304779,
0.018348170444369316,
0.12091781944036484,
0.6163417100906372,
-0.4956394135951996,
0.4094921052455902,
-0.42431575059890747,
0.040854137390851974,
0.5276135802268982,
0.2754739224910736,
0.5316864848136902,
0.032800979912281036,
0.06834615767002106,
0.0889425203204155,
-0.5804530382156372,
-0.12720395624637604,
0.08570729941129684,
0.30208781361579895,
-0.1538802832365036,
0.7211339473724365,
0.07681428641080856,
0.7092693448066711,
-0.26236310601234436,
-0.08419599384069443,
-0.06473870575428009,
-0.19889338314533234,
-0.3933522701263428,
-0.3868183195590973,
0.914764940738678,
0.01771599054336548,
0.3628569543361664,
-0.43181711435317993,
-0.13177849352359772,
0.05265007168054581,
0.28006330132484436,
-0.7446438670158386,
-0.22479432821273804,
0.13039378821849823,
-0.3265126943588257,
-0.2755195200443268,
-0.12158326804637909,
-0.6596734523773193,
-0.5922466516494751,
-0.4944058060646057,
-0.03120863251388073,
-0.25287747383117676,
-0.3494480550289154,
0.33217334747314453,
0.049738191068172455,
0.6278278231620789,
0.2789478302001953,
-0.9766015410423279,
0.3252066373825073,
0.96136474609375,
0.8643780946731567,
-0.16369248926639557,
-0.04844209924340248,
0.005304284859448671,
-0.0015879700658842921,
-0.30223798751831055,
0.6947563290596008,
-0.678796648979187,
-0.44850268959999084,
0.20792149007320404,
-0.021156011149287224,
-0.058652203530073166,
-0.4889766275882721,
0.5170736908912659,
-0.7697950601577759,
0.24077026546001434,
0.41703739762306213,
-0.4737021327018738,
-0.1930081844329834,
0.33097338676452637,
-0.8697966933250427,
0.7160552740097046,
0.09548572450876236,
-0.41813376545906067,
-0.05018705502152443,
-1.0306185483932495,
-0.48602280020713806,
0.1531723439693451,
-0.1350998878479004,
-0.3605218827724457,
0.318006694316864,
0.22024917602539062,
0.5871338248252869,
-0.7181757688522339,
0.4916617274284363,
0.19600963592529297,
-0.1902417242527008,
0.2625047266483307,
-0.7486907243728638,
0.7490177154541016,
0.04789043217897415,
-0.16992662847042084,
0.3467628061771393,
-0.467963308095932,
-0.19652137160301208,
0.34518682956695557,
-0.1607729196548462,
-0.0024852361530065536,
0.15563896298408508,
0.2321128100156784,
0.34103286266326904,
0.12575894594192505,
-0.4580410122871399,
0.38478392362594604,
-0.31011146306991577,
0.9750790596008301,
0.5292515754699707,
-0.3115502893924713,
0.5409460067749023,
0.0017507501179352403,
0.5720415711402893,
-0.1716778725385666,
0.15188010036945343,
-0.3537087142467499,
-0.689693033695221,
-0.6940761208534241,
-0.1108471006155014,
0.12257793545722961,
0.5491265654563904,
-0.7672819495201111,
0.4027041792869568,
-0.5886464715003967,
-0.8263447284698486,
-0.48706236481666565,
-0.055287331342697144,
-0.2117011696100235,
0.1380196213722229,
0.26431000232696533,
0.14592035114765167,
-0.4239260256290436,
-1.0466041564941406,
-0.208654522895813,
-0.04986976459622383,
-0.3566463887691498,
0.19277404248714447,
0.3466815650463104,
-0.6907384395599365,
1.0389891862869263,
-0.5108041763305664,
-0.006874650716781616,
-0.7121541500091553,
0.09562736749649048,
0.488383948802948,
0.23045267164707184,
0.29657039046287537,
-0.9861466884613037,
-0.3875124454498291,
0.14654459059238434,
-0.4832512140274048,
0.1668224036693573,
-0.19143615663051605,
0.2355467528104782,
0.033326681703329086,
0.4443499743938446,
-0.9103505611419678,
0.18181894719600677,
0.8645951151847839,
-0.08129609376192093,
0.4783279001712799,
-0.04624045640230179,
-0.060727715492248535,
-0.9326320290565491,
0.04482978582382202,
0.06571462005376816,
-0.20839661359786987,
-0.9482187628746033,
0.06779724359512329,
-0.06494452059268951,
-0.26527246832847595,
-0.3143283724784851,
0.5254981517791748,
-0.3895981013774872,
-0.04168670251965523,
-0.3421544134616852,
-0.0859140008687973,
-0.23857572674751282,
0.1498780995607376,
0.07717180252075195,
0.9047279357910156,
0.47678327560424805,
-0.5059283971786499,
0.5542862415313721,
0.3425893187522888,
-0.37996944785118103,
0.13294263184070587,
-0.8467651605606079,
0.2465876042842865,
-0.13254183530807495,
0.2725769877433777,
-0.9448542594909668,
-0.15104873478412628,
0.0073186252266168594,
-0.20311705768108368,
0.2579164505004883,
-0.09366833418607712,
-0.7294805645942688,
-0.7898037433624268,
-0.06286405771970749,
0.2609653174877167,
0.6606600880622864,
-0.4328720271587372,
0.8716928958892822,
0.43341782689094543,
-0.3925491273403168,
-0.2537899911403656,
-0.7222932577133179,
0.47980231046676636,
-0.18710267543792725,
-0.5817899703979492,
0.23986473679542542,
0.024161607027053833,
-0.2978610396385193,
-0.26056107878685,
0.20915573835372925,
-0.09838121384382248,
0.0011663268087431788,
0.08532695472240448,
0.4750223457813263,
-0.38129866123199463,
0.03702313452959061,
-0.37083759903907776,
-0.18764536082744598,
0.09784112870693207,
-0.19251656532287598,
0.9848748445510864,
-0.39019811153411865,
-0.38930028676986694,
-0.32014182209968567,
0.24875332415103912,
0.7969743013381958,
-0.35904380679130554,
0.8451303839683533,
0.603503942489624,
-0.25982534885406494,
-0.11729702353477478,
-0.6150472164154053,
-0.11573289334774017,
-0.5317801833152771,
0.6606572866439819,
-0.19298458099365234,
-1.2542599439620972,
0.4493407607078552,
-0.35306480526924133,
0.2397015243768692,
0.5407789349555969,
0.7553367018699646,
0.21181292831897736,
0.9156098961830139,
0.9438735246658325,
-0.49136266112327576,
0.5523142218589783,
-0.22366397082805634,
0.770277738571167,
-0.7274587750434875,
0.07250693440437317,
-0.4895486831665039,
-0.24325807392597198,
-0.8087612390518188,
-0.5063992738723755,
0.27235734462738037,
-0.34461578726768494,
-0.304497629404068,
0.39233770966529846,
-0.5462114214897156,
0.4623454511165619,
0.3001459538936615,
-0.3817746937274933,
0.5027839541435242,
-0.21333713829517365,
0.4901118278503418,
0.14645694196224213,
-0.5047497749328613,
-0.65190190076828,
1.0956305265426636,
0.6927527189254761,
0.7738189697265625,
0.014387871138751507,
0.15267819166183472,
0.21670448780059814,
0.5816640853881836,
-1.0141254663467407,
0.4066510796546936,
-0.2520744204521179,
-0.6260197758674622,
-0.590413510799408,
-0.2778841555118561,
-0.9077297449111938,
0.1232907697558403,
0.19634917378425598,
-0.6728531122207642,
-0.23040516674518585,
-0.20879952609539032,
-0.09904173761606216,
0.6447582244873047,
-0.6172464489936829,
0.7432008385658264,
-0.35347750782966614,
0.07506681233644485,
-0.16611680388450623,
-0.49850714206695557,
0.5486451983451843,
-0.19968761503696442,
0.1905433088541031,
0.05044446885585785,
0.14054059982299805,
0.45407986640930176,
0.023114603012800217,
0.8609272837638855,
-0.041786905378103256,
-0.6036784648895264,
0.3158993422985077,
-0.10653690993785858,
0.6550337076187134,
-0.1848323494195938,
-0.1691531538963318,
0.3496261537075043,
-0.35542118549346924,
-0.08718807250261307,
-0.5816269516944885,
0.47372496128082275,
-0.5854039788246155,
-0.6459462642669678,
-0.10188990086317062,
-0.7651247978210449,
-0.2953934371471405,
0.2535691559314728,
-0.15237155556678772,
0.2458823025226593,
-0.247100830078125,
0.3212112784385681,
0.5193159580230713,
-0.2703528106212616,
0.6723455190658569,
0.21514160931110382,
-0.40909963846206665,
-0.07434900850057602,
0.6342145800590515,
-0.06131190434098244,
0.24552665650844574,
0.5001731514930725,
-0.011552157811820507,
-0.28840431571006775,
-0.7755322456359863,
-0.42596668004989624,
0.2735782861709595,
-0.5034158825874329,
-0.09629212319850922,
-0.5358089804649353,
-0.5288265943527222,
-0.40374529361724854,
-0.10196962207555771,
-0.5465646386146545,
-0.12650328874588013,
0.12324731796979904,
0.023954147472977638,
0.30323588848114014,
1.217644214630127,
0.5786502361297607,
0.7010382413864136,
-0.7554072737693787,
0.3604331910610199,
0.47073689103126526,
0.5906710028648376,
0.01864481158554554,
-0.360332190990448,
-0.13998234272003174,
0.006303778849542141,
-0.3062831461429596,
-0.50967937707901,
0.44229716062545776,
0.040364157408475876,
0.5316452383995056,
0.057063471525907516,
-0.4105849862098694,
0.25906792283058167,
-0.8727004528045654,
0.8646695017814636,
0.09637279808521271,
-0.8534134030342102,
0.230989009141922,
-0.46110963821411133,
0.3956333100795746,
0.05679502338171005,
0.2893010079860687,
-1.0251870155334473,
-0.1121327131986618,
-0.30443841218948364,
-0.797183096408844,
0.5481590628623962,
0.17492301762104034,
0.5812072157859802,
0.2440120428800583,
0.13629333674907684,
0.08834587782621384,
0.28433024883270264,
-0.7493608593940735,
-0.17838943004608154,
-0.006179850082844496,
-0.22820492088794708,
-0.29089608788490295,
-0.034841153770685196,
0.2271639108657837,
-0.13949696719646454,
0.5320897698402405,
-0.23852311074733734,
0.5837247371673584,
-0.3457198143005371,
-0.09575177729129791,
0.22555850446224213,
0.5677281022071838,
0.4275597929954529,
0.4913851320743561,
0.1527671068906784,
-0.08981363475322723,
0.0182684063911438,
-0.47416481375694275,
0.03305840864777565,
0.14911428093910217,
-0.13265638053417206,
-0.010612917132675648,
0.32862499356269836,
0.7410767674446106,
0.13218465447425842,
-0.6552463173866272,
0.30020806193351746,
-0.03374101594090462,
0.1094115599989891,
-0.43481045961380005,
-0.062443915754556656,
0.38314875960350037,
0.44801124930381775,
0.3903596103191376,
-0.01008269190788269,
0.15988995134830475,
-0.5151393413543701,
0.0671413466334343,
0.6616449952125549,
-0.34570685029029846,
-0.34170451760292053,
0.5456224679946899,
0.06027951091527939,
-0.4665112793445587,
0.826977550983429,
0.21290522813796997,
-0.5341253876686096,
0.5862039923667908,
0.6915478706359863,
0.9402251243591309,
-0.21890754997730255,
0.12303619086742401,
-0.06371862441301346,
0.4196223318576813,
-0.09082643687725067,
-0.09953674674034119,
0.2188013345003128,
-0.8985488414764404,
-0.6767867803573608,
-0.6197702288627625,
-0.5363143086433411,
0.28935444355010986,
-0.12450563907623291,
0.2754821181297302,
-0.3013696074485779,
-0.07638206332921982,
0.23227046430110931,
-0.3324299156665802,
-0.8749683499336243,
0.007510682567954063,
0.49521464109420776,
0.8122975826263428,
-0.6711236834526062,
0.8507876992225647,
0.6572577357292175,
-0.23555785417556763,
-0.5958670973777771,
-0.11261254549026489,
-0.13866877555847168,
-0.8643245100975037,
0.49754732847213745,
0.1410437822341919,
-0.0525502935051918,
0.18187519907951355,
-0.6016630530357361,
-0.7916272878646851,
0.9483492374420166,
0.17738917469978333,
-0.6911072134971619,
-0.40969985723495483,
0.7684996724128723,
0.7595975399017334,
-0.2561718225479126,
0.4507425129413605,
0.8990415930747986,
0.6342538595199585,
0.003958186134696007,
-1.0631572008132935,
-0.25909659266471863,
-0.22837629914283752,
0.20085683465003967,
0.4282796382904053,
-0.5557008981704712,
0.7016023397445679,
0.10049596428871155,
0.0033264965750277042,
0.02036946825683117,
0.526565670967102,
-0.061493538320064545,
-0.21523120999336243,
0.24698176980018616,
0.17347446084022522,
0.4428729712963104,
-0.23647087812423706,
1.1200368404388428,
-0.2458105981349945,
0.2800328731536865,
0.7871865630149841,
-0.220303475856781,
0.7385190725326538,
0.34183600544929504,
-0.5738459229469299,
0.4548082947731018,
0.05282698571681976,
-0.29456621408462524,
0.09241892397403717,
0.2903650403022766,
-0.17777982354164124,
-0.05065341666340828,
-0.11837458610534668,
-0.09954718500375748,
0.5535597205162048,
0.6252581477165222,
-0.3215753436088562,
-0.27455365657806396,
0.03519703075289726,
-0.047974489629268646,
-0.1272341012954712,
-0.362985759973526,
0.6465830206871033,
0.16594190895557404,
-0.31109580397605896,
0.2146344929933548,
0.18408848345279694,
1.0917537212371826,
-0.6443331241607666,
0.03885776177048683,
0.010196938179433346,
0.2353857010602951,
-0.02900916524231434,
-0.9397862553596497,
0.489797443151474,
-0.0024241863284260035,
-0.07681282609701157,
-0.4157693386077881,
0.8864402174949646,
-0.2689723074436188,
-0.695598840713501,
0.2496648132801056,
0.6667001843452454,
-0.12030133605003357,
-0.267460435628891,
-0.5367477536201477,
0.05379088968038559,
-0.17105597257614136,
-0.3341785669326782,
-0.09343504160642624,
0.337248295545578,
-0.04305131733417511,
0.8674843907356262,
0.44450169801712036,
-0.08209476619958878,
0.21580791473388672,
0.21099764108657837,
0.9364594221115112,
-0.7493563890457153,
-0.17378342151641846,
-0.9103650450706482,
0.7028027772903442,
0.10163647681474686,
0.050301630049943924,
0.655950665473938,
0.5434361696243286,
0.6070399284362793,
-0.271114319562912,
1.045710563659668,
-0.014586999081075191,
0.4271976351737976,
-0.21823175251483917,
0.7423377633094788,
-0.10104544460773468,
0.24793051183223724,
-0.29418283700942993,
-0.9232773184776306,
-0.5640783309936523,
0.19883163273334503,
-0.7137997150421143,
0.1298181414604187,
0.2845339775085449,
0.5128810405731201,
-0.10331007838249207,
0.32751959562301636,
0.35337331891059875,
0.20567990839481354,
0.8498134016990662,
0.516749382019043,
0.9201799035072327,
-0.5420860052108765,
0.4784768223762512,
-0.032790035009384155,
-0.01721521094441414,
-0.16633784770965576,
-0.7820099592208862,
-0.8581268191337585,
-0.49424806237220764,
-0.05743406340479851,
0.187001034617424,
-0.22084598243236542,
0.6830797791481018,
0.4975135922431946,
-0.9448187351226807,
-0.29487553238868713,
-0.26300981640815735,
0.019494783133268356,
0.08374182879924774,
-0.21675294637680054,
0.2061963826417923,
-0.261531800031662,
-0.9586396813392639,
0.38756176829338074,
0.2655729055404663,
0.06766311079263687,
-0.6146227121353149,
0.10106035321950912,
-0.01183818094432354,
0.1035650447010994,
0.9098115563392639,
0.21102316677570343,
-0.7179934978485107,
-0.18842880427837372,
0.1952696293592453,
-0.03248433396220207,
0.2761293947696686,
0.9314244389533997,
-0.7993759512901306,
0.00025446692598052323,
0.3775014281272888,
0.9522850513458252,
0.3963228762149811,
-0.2976705729961395,
0.6735233664512634,
-0.39753034710884094,
0.048500917851924896,
0.4000248312950134,
0.3658585250377655,
0.48190072178840637,
-0.17611712217330933,
0.5249074101448059,
-0.062369294464588165,
-0.6552980542182922,
-0.6842899918556213,
0.3718867301940918,
-0.7548112273216248,
-0.14906209707260132,
0.926712691783905,
0.2324194759130478,
0.028533320873975754,
-0.14581720530986786,
-0.2485741674900055,
0.19156989455223083,
-0.13432931900024414,
0.7384949922561646,
0.7086159586906433,
-0.22568100690841675,
-0.48505643010139465,
-0.8518970012664795,
0.21367615461349487,
0.10069460421800613,
-0.9812139868736267,
0.24153724312782288,
0.37704792618751526,
-0.011923391371965408,
0.3750852048397064,
0.22809793055057526,
-0.20860016345977783,
-0.2518443763256073,
-0.14690421521663666,
0.1866253912448883,
0.06652342528104782,
-0.31439584493637085,
-0.503889799118042,
0.21010752022266388,
0.17273323237895966,
0.2534562945365906
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08661v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08661v1
|
The Comparison of Translationese in Machine Translation and Human Transation in terms of Translation Relations
| 2024-03-27T19:12:20 | 2024-03-27T19:12:20 |
Fan Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This study explores the distinctions between neural machine translation (NMT)
and human translation (HT) through the lens of translation relations. It
benchmarks HT to assess the translation techniques produced by an NMT system
and aims to address three key research questions: the differences in overall
translation relations between NMT and HT, how each utilizes non-literal
translation techniques, and the variations in factors influencing their use of
specific non-literal techniques. The research employs two parallel corpora,
each spanning nine genres with the same source texts with one translated by NMT
and the other by humans. Translation relations in these corpora are manually
annotated on aligned pairs, enabling a comparative analysis that draws on
linguistic insights, including semantic and syntactic nuances such as hypernyms
and alterations in part-of-speech tagging. The results indicate that NMT relies
on literal translation significantly more than HT across genres. While NMT
performs comparably to HT in employing syntactic non-literal translation
techniques, it falls behind in semantic-level performance.
|
[
-0.3479704260826111,
-0.4009501039981842,
0.3924412429332733,
0.4052482843399048,
-0.25009289383888245,
0.4310472309589386,
-0.3258626163005829,
-0.754288911819458,
0.3909451365470886,
0.35951778292655945,
-0.5132793188095093,
-0.21032479405403137,
-0.4190671741962433,
0.7139323949813843,
-0.28424763679504395,
0.8751434683799744,
-0.22666959464550018,
0.3007688522338867,
-0.09764877706766129,
-0.4517562985420227,
-0.5900803804397583,
-0.7210840582847595,
-0.7130095958709717,
-0.41561099886894226,
0.6443220376968384,
-0.17872726917266846,
1.0533545017242432,
0.7248459458351135,
1.0929306745529175,
0.3493477404117584,
-0.03737989440560341,
-0.02322804555296898,
0.030868537724018097,
0.09147132933139801,
-0.3059841990470886,
-0.511386513710022,
-0.3227575421333313,
0.004569648299366236,
0.621759831905365,
0.7325376868247986,
0.4230562150478363,
0.3357272446155548,
0.020083419978618622,
0.6787746548652649,
-0.35089111328125,
-0.019358336925506592,
-0.4130300283432007,
0.13076092302799225,
-0.3715500235557556,
-0.24268820881843567,
-0.17329084873199463,
-0.3962898850440979,
0.27843236923217773,
-0.6177104115486145,
0.23063449561595917,
0.3399096727371216,
1.058671236038208,
0.49685123562812805,
-0.4404323399066925,
-0.07821831107139587,
-0.59758460521698,
0.6016459465026855,
-0.7164414525032043,
0.4983648657798767,
0.3349137604236603,
0.33437174558639526,
0.2653159201145172,
-0.4610871970653534,
-0.4094391465187073,
-0.44694751501083374,
-0.35593920946121216,
0.037327542901039124,
0.014406934380531311,
-0.031648118048906326,
0.2873174250125885,
0.43383803963661194,
-0.8565418720245361,
-0.052935101091861725,
-0.4810514450073242,
-0.20534518361091614,
0.3370075523853302,
0.10554379969835281,
0.5291873812675476,
-0.6765144467353821,
-0.603712797164917,
-0.3319510817527771,
-0.7582709193229675,
-0.5284377336502075,
0.3179122507572174,
0.14917118847370148,
-0.02676333487033844,
0.6651490330696106,
0.06170640140771866,
0.5580424070358276,
-0.18975389003753662,
0.043388281017541885,
0.40481987595558167,
-0.6326280832290649,
-0.19359031319618225,
0.10407857596874237,
1.197474479675293,
0.554553747177124,
0.41329964995384216,
-0.6506789326667786,
-0.31073230504989624,
0.26775404810905457,
0.36115625500679016,
-0.601050078868866,
0.3501034379005432,
-0.42295894026756287,
-0.5545715689659119,
-0.1171899363398552,
0.09627943485975266,
-0.6002333164215088,
-0.13484856486320496,
-0.5084969401359558,
0.45390450954437256,
-0.4474647641181946,
-0.33798423409461975,
-0.11878768354654312,
-0.2831764817237854,
0.3257163166999817,
-0.16552512347698212,
-0.5808954834938049,
0.5195092558860779,
0.7207467555999756,
1.0601922273635864,
-0.514045774936676,
-0.5253350734710693,
-0.013493088074028492,
-0.08002839237451553,
-0.3863793909549713,
0.5058810710906982,
-0.07371716946363449,
-0.09646815061569214,
-0.2098236083984375,
-0.11163023859262466,
-0.33604392409324646,
-0.8412272334098816,
0.41092759370803833,
-0.6259778738021851,
0.003501815488561988,
-0.42282992601394653,
-0.28348836302757263,
-0.23780950903892517,
0.24290889501571655,
-0.7889025807380676,
0.7474637031555176,
0.15704219043254852,
-0.8327171206474304,
0.12397068738937378,
-0.6556186676025391,
-0.5817723870277405,
-0.15102063119411469,
-0.1304936558008194,
-0.08383704721927643,
0.08106791973114014,
-0.20765861868858337,
0.27451011538505554,
-0.7054980993270874,
0.2844589352607727,
-0.145570307970047,
-0.4578581154346466,
0.5598892569541931,
-0.26581087708473206,
0.5921866297721863,
0.3657379746437073,
-0.44029778242111206,
-0.06497655808925629,
-0.6819829940795898,
-0.17371371388435364,
0.21585136651992798,
-0.22651460766792297,
-0.4209221303462982,
-0.17416095733642578,
0.23087038099765778,
0.49221935868263245,
0.12677651643753052,
-0.4641764163970947,
-0.06826413422822952,
-0.47653746604919434,
0.8241725564002991,
0.27933579683303833,
-0.0003838559496216476,
0.6030184030532837,
-0.11785836517810822,
0.508674681186676,
-0.08664520829916,
-0.09221138805150986,
0.14079061150550842,
-0.4732947051525116,
-0.5410026907920837,
0.3718787729740143,
0.7355598211288452,
0.8297359943389893,
-0.9921133518218994,
0.2573566138744354,
-0.5123791098594666,
-0.08224713057279587,
-0.9008622765541077,
-0.16073329746723175,
0.7280740737915039,
0.5210015177726746,
0.6308838725090027,
-0.4034658670425415,
-0.6497458815574646,
-1.2169636487960815,
-0.49277463555336,
-0.2196148782968521,
-0.13684754073619843,
0.008500698953866959,
0.4010525643825531,
0.002862723544239998,
0.5767719745635986,
-0.07697919756174088,
-0.17490118741989136,
0.04629802331328392,
0.44873493909835815,
-0.16787844896316528,
0.39645272493362427,
0.5585644245147705,
-0.7372052669525146,
-0.6784967184066772,
0.47025540471076965,
-0.957092821598053,
-0.0367986299097538,
-0.12923339009284973,
-0.2205301821231842,
0.15495051443576813,
0.47195136547088623,
-0.6721301078796387,
0.47225746512413025,
0.41008657217025757,
-0.25179409980773926,
0.3232644498348236,
0.039758168160915375,
0.47978290915489197,
-1.2340755462646484,
0.1880079209804535,
-0.10601701587438583,
-0.17320746183395386,
-0.5604672431945801,
0.09499002993106842,
0.2913985252380371,
-0.011787265539169312,
-0.5343993902206421,
0.24375970661640167,
-0.4941071569919586,
-0.49050214886665344,
-0.09898252040147781,
0.05357426404953003,
0.08299511671066284,
0.5585992336273193,
0.2629255950450897,
1.1308224201202393,
-0.06854773312807083,
-0.3426259756088257,
0.21438756585121155,
0.24197350442409515,
-0.09122447669506073,
0.6085520386695862,
-0.8550935387611389,
0.3132900297641754,
0.35248884558677673,
-0.09369303286075592,
-0.7596680521965027,
0.06564591825008392,
0.36109083890914917,
-0.9180198311805725,
0.21935132145881653,
0.037078857421875,
-0.8129780292510986,
-0.012518527917563915,
-0.15762369334697723,
0.5417538285255432,
0.699799120426178,
-0.02934812195599079,
0.16574208438396454,
0.0038221278227865696,
-0.07416698336601257,
-0.5088623762130737,
-1.1644854545593262,
0.4994345009326935,
-0.3570573925971985,
-0.6964540481567383,
0.5002135038375854,
0.3765205442905426,
-0.5085167288780212,
0.28047192096710205,
-0.1120770052075386,
-0.26664575934410095,
0.019087085500359535,
-0.019292818382382393,
0.31927430629730225,
-0.701792299747467,
0.08512204140424728,
-0.07291970402002335,
-0.17850442230701447,
0.31688958406448364,
-0.29417169094085693,
0.28310835361480713,
-0.11085883527994156,
0.07079096883535385,
-0.4622228741645813,
0.4391991198062897,
0.6293559074401855,
-0.2610701024532318,
0.8156550526618958,
0.652452826499939,
-0.17436617612838745,
0.5225675702095032,
-0.4641149938106537,
-0.24336788058280945,
-0.3304577171802521,
0.19808538258075714,
-0.6981717944145203,
-0.5960021615028381,
0.36763665080070496,
0.21691571176052094,
-0.13369373977184296,
0.6596394181251526,
0.35021570324897766,
-0.15464913845062256,
0.7133507132530212,
0.27777233719825745,
-0.023687563836574554,
0.19321554899215698,
-0.11842307448387146,
-0.04051947966217995,
-1.1756786108016968,
0.06917040050029755,
-0.7472437620162964,
-0.5602613687515259,
-0.9332718849182129,
-0.311596155166626,
0.07066357880830765,
-0.17913351953029633,
-0.28066539764404297,
1.156921148300171,
-0.3877582252025604,
0.19794367253780365,
0.3077482581138611,
-0.33375051617622375,
0.544655978679657,
-0.21751868724822998,
-0.04357731714844704,
-0.40416690707206726,
-0.4625262916088104,
-0.48652708530426025,
0.9247856736183167,
0.18408291041851044,
0.34658631682395935,
0.272821307182312,
0.5918700098991394,
0.08050604164600372,
0.3490518629550934,
-0.8478199243545532,
0.41845566034317017,
-0.12704747915267944,
-0.7196399569511414,
-0.05335162952542305,
-0.7933682203292847,
-1.0109219551086426,
0.5521748065948486,
-0.12754641473293304,
-0.26701223850250244,
0.12531481683254242,
-0.29157009720802307,
-0.016179369762539864,
0.2927559018135071,
-0.786679744720459,
0.7865904569625854,
-0.22430329024791718,
-0.3152991831302643,
0.03625636175274849,
-1.2286524772644043,
0.11160764843225479,
0.019105611369013786,
0.03155076131224632,
0.0146125927567482,
-0.41716665029525757,
0.8431376218795776,
-0.17023910582065582,
0.5402452349662781,
0.259080708026886,
0.13214589655399323,
-0.020864827558398247,
0.302998811006546,
-0.008214946836233139,
-0.3266475200653076,
-0.09207428991794586,
0.4252915382385254,
0.0806213915348053,
-0.1501765102148056,
-0.6569961905479431,
0.6354840993881226,
-1.0144705772399902,
-0.269616037607193,
-0.5555449724197388,
-0.6937576532363892,
-0.34923452138900757,
0.36198848485946655,
0.5323547124862671,
0.07271777093410492,
-0.20908428728580475,
0.16115932166576385,
0.48777902126312256,
-0.017210233956575394,
0.3469003438949585,
0.2737937867641449,
-0.15583369135856628,
-0.593107283115387,
0.8339988589286804,
0.28536561131477356,
0.590467631816864,
0.8831964731216431,
-0.004094824194908142,
-0.5499426126480103,
-0.15042230486869812,
-0.7577599883079529,
0.5892819762229919,
-0.5079739093780518,
-0.17649763822555542,
-0.5546543598175049,
-0.14670144021511078,
-0.416057825088501,
0.07085409015417099,
-0.38841718435287476,
-0.5776233673095703,
-0.01501916628330946,
0.04007751867175102,
0.15565428137779236,
0.7550711035728455,
0.3157571256160736,
0.10835422575473785,
-0.7513389587402344,
0.4357537031173706,
-0.06922338902950287,
-0.14226724207401276,
-0.24076227843761444,
-0.4416481852531433,
-0.039547428488731384,
-0.09659046679735184,
-0.2911420166492462,
-1.2928828001022339,
0.19561083614826202,
-0.1834254115819931,
0.14132060110569,
-0.07199142128229141,
-0.23640666902065277,
0.6917363405227661,
-0.5989887714385986,
0.5716020464897156,
0.3406181037425995,
-0.9717544913291931,
0.11526042968034744,
-0.3467767834663391,
0.17618964612483978,
0.7956696152687073,
0.46325019001960754,
-0.9300893545150757,
-0.23661357164382935,
-0.6059604287147522,
-0.5749315023422241,
0.5218842625617981,
0.4715062975883484,
-0.0709228664636612,
0.0605323500931263,
0.2616899013519287,
-0.05924859270453453,
0.43977776169776917,
-0.5037652850151062,
-0.267477422952652,
-0.048144061118364334,
-0.10238566249608994,
-0.21777203679084778,
0.3200162947177887,
0.08036404848098755,
-0.27050429582595825,
0.19004471600055695,
-0.010063246823847294,
0.3302779793739319,
0.3426807224750519,
-0.30522361397743225,
0.04414789006114006,
0.2680438756942749,
0.4639666974544525,
0.6080841422080994,
-0.14350257813930511,
0.30527302622795105,
0.21582750976085663,
-0.34915414452552795,
0.35317403078079224,
-0.2450341135263443,
-0.3235383927822113,
0.31342339515686035,
0.483621209859848,
0.9162412881851196,
0.4195621609687805,
-0.1394452303647995,
0.27534961700439453,
-0.040977876633405685,
-0.42761263251304626,
0.0731813982129097,
-0.42000868916511536,
0.47271862626075745,
-0.11102781444787979,
-0.20346273481845856,
0.5546255707740784,
0.4053345024585724,
-0.38552191853523254,
-0.10545267909765244,
-0.041760679334402084,
-0.4388706684112549,
-0.44580525159835815,
0.6224360466003418,
0.24723531305789948,
-0.6551560163497925,
0.726397693157196,
-0.15009820461273193,
-0.44843947887420654,
0.6223515868186951,
0.5063049793243408,
1.1646524667739868,
-0.10903211683034897,
0.03507671877741814,
0.39937570691108704,
0.5863474011421204,
-0.08039254695177078,
-0.17315872013568878,
-0.21496012806892395,
-0.4434610903263092,
-0.7322184443473816,
-0.41994309425354004,
-0.3971113860607147,
-0.055550716817379,
-0.9827197790145874,
0.1043255552649498,
-0.06691792607307434,
-0.4153561294078827,
0.07034749537706375,
-0.1415330171585083,
-0.6422606706619263,
-0.20694991946220398,
-0.13569027185440063,
0.7234368324279785,
-0.6447025537490845,
0.8966652154922485,
0.9532995223999023,
-0.7265505790710449,
-0.6970587372779846,
0.33883580565452576,
-0.06099790707230568,
-0.449057936668396,
0.8833035826683044,
0.018991338089108467,
-0.28864461183547974,
0.008498335257172585,
0.12465139478445053,
-0.5871734023094177,
1.0056427717208862,
0.5180026888847351,
-0.371143639087677,
-0.19293957948684692,
0.5168207883834839,
0.755401074886322,
0.12941661477088928,
-0.042222168296575546,
0.7637946605682373,
0.7611207365989685,
-0.219063863158226,
-1.3507091999053955,
0.16560357809066772,
-0.12132305651903152,
0.39814168214797974,
0.45190033316612244,
-0.5751850008964539,
0.744481086730957,
0.2716728448867798,
-0.3774494230747223,
0.1437503546476364,
0.607128918170929,
-0.12752053141593933,
0.31408271193504333,
0.1726786196231842,
0.49540725350379944,
0.10284888744354248,
-0.06047334894537926,
1.0044957399368286,
-0.09342602640390396,
0.14166194200515747,
0.8540899157524109,
-0.3161033093929291,
0.8130211234092712,
0.9097792506217957,
-0.4100547432899475,
0.15061071515083313,
0.6149395108222961,
0.13865257799625397,
0.3497026860713959,
0.34400925040245056,
0.0531592071056366,
0.052986323833465576,
-0.039440568536520004,
-0.5112957954406738,
0.14347247779369354,
0.09746476262807846,
-0.28711238503456116,
-0.12880027294158936,
0.01909010298550129,
0.2592223584651947,
0.31021010875701904,
0.10029846429824829,
0.964863121509552,
0.4277037978172302,
-1.0420300960540771,
0.762322723865509,
0.20599807798862457,
0.8593859076499939,
-0.3228912651538849,
0.11377722024917603,
-0.04723753035068512,
0.07089684158563614,
-0.06082634627819061,
-0.6925199627876282,
0.8175987005233765,
0.002314708661288023,
-0.23345325887203217,
-0.1514488011598587,
0.5529095530509949,
-0.30177825689315796,
-0.11068783700466156,
0.6365154385566711,
0.7444096207618713,
0.2627168297767639,
-0.06749650835990906,
-0.7670105695724487,
0.11647268384695053,
-0.26800814270973206,
-0.16135619580745697,
0.4244125783443451,
0.4273550510406494,
-0.3838520348072052,
0.2569703161716461,
0.4310372769832611,
0.24587813019752502,
0.18963907659053802,
-0.08862683176994324,
0.4043521285057068,
-0.7979884743690491,
-0.11227045208215714,
-0.9241713881492615,
-0.08260419964790344,
0.021980099380016327,
-0.5127773880958557,
0.7641934752464294,
0.3624271750450134,
0.8855535387992859,
-0.32655757665634155,
0.6106101870536804,
-0.1618310511112213,
0.3005695939064026,
-0.4624500870704651,
0.600345253944397,
-0.4196014702320099,
-0.12925978004932404,
-0.019960790872573853,
-1.1351534128189087,
-0.3337455987930298,
0.49296700954437256,
-0.31693166494369507,
-0.055056728422641754,
1.3145360946655273,
0.5748777389526367,
-0.15521171689033508,
-0.07597261667251587,
0.3572179675102234,
-0.11538811773061752,
-0.18597525358200073,
0.6048999428749084,
1.017258882522583,
-0.720206618309021,
0.4623611867427826,
-0.2784293591976166,
0.22195035219192505,
0.05855759605765343,
-0.6239307522773743,
-0.7430738806724548,
-0.6798526644706726,
-0.13376876711845398,
-0.1804337501525879,
0.18099479377269745,
0.8910838961601257,
0.6723414659500122,
-0.4957661032676697,
-0.5198527574539185,
0.016298843547701836,
0.06388404965400696,
-0.4958246052265167,
-0.2291237860918045,
0.27014192938804626,
-0.34061571955680847,
-0.7679690718650818,
0.34872379899024963,
0.2565392553806305,
-0.034857235848903656,
-0.4173761308193207,
-0.2382899671792984,
-0.16178861260414124,
-0.07462216168642044,
0.5549517869949341,
0.12654457986354828,
-0.6271904706954956,
-0.056082308292388916,
0.40151843428611755,
-0.43405720591545105,
0.2991369068622589,
1.01246976852417,
-0.3961239159107208,
-0.06005844473838806,
0.9739888906478882,
0.975211501121521,
0.35583803057670593,
-0.10266373306512833,
0.4529981017112732,
-0.7722060084342957,
0.07189802080392838,
0.32658886909484863,
0.10779254883527756,
0.5066025853157043,
-0.27315446734428406,
0.7623392939567566,
0.45106008648872375,
-0.5880240201950073,
-0.6163327097892761,
0.10966438800096512,
-0.8241130709648132,
-0.16320523619651794,
1.1069999933242798,
-0.11704184859991074,
-0.4142429232597351,
-0.14487262070178986,
-0.14275655150413513,
0.4137307405471802,
-0.12231320142745972,
0.3271988034248352,
0.8549184203147888,
-0.07523219287395477,
0.19622492790222168,
-1.0369696617126465,
0.4039795696735382,
0.48289236426353455,
-0.6616913676261902,
-0.38628509640693665,
0.0831712856888771,
0.2589607536792755,
0.45543333888053894,
0.43947580456733704,
-0.42403388023376465,
0.2497931271791458,
-0.05033637210726738,
0.26032716035842896,
0.062281932681798935,
-0.22593793272972107,
-0.19693247973918915,
-0.0038159755058586597,
0.019629985094070435,
-0.4499359726905823
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18957v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18957v1
|
Moderating Illicit Online Image Promotion for Unsafe User-Generated Content Games Using Large Vision-Language Models
| 2024-03-27T19:02:13 | 2024-03-27T19:02:13 |
Keyan Guo, Ayush Utkarsh, Wenbo Ding, Isabelle Ondracek, Ziming Zhao, Guo Freeman, Nishant Vishwamitra, Hongxin Hu
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SI
|
Online user-generated content games (UGCGs) are increasingly popular among
children and adolescents for social interaction and more creative online
entertainment. However, they pose a heightened risk of exposure to explicit
content, raising growing concerns for the online safety of children and
adolescents. Despite these concerns, few studies have addressed the issue of
illicit image-based promotions of unsafe UGCGs on social media, which can
inadvertently attract young users. This challenge arises from the difficulty of
obtaining comprehensive training data for UGCG images and the unique nature of
these images, which differ from traditional unsafe content. In this work, we
take the first step towards studying the threat of illicit promotions of unsafe
UGCGs. We collect a real-world dataset comprising 2,924 images that display
diverse sexually explicit and violent content used to promote UGCGs by their
game creators. Our in-depth studies reveal a new understanding of this problem
and the urgent need for automatically flagging illicit UGCG promotions. We
additionally create a cutting-edge system, UGCG-Guard, designed to aid social
media platforms in effectively identifying images used for illicit UGCG
promotions. This system leverages recently introduced large vision-language
models (VLMs) and employs a novel conditional prompting strategy for zero-shot
domain adaptation, along with chain-of-thought (CoT) reasoning for contextual
identification. UGCG-Guard achieves outstanding results, with an accuracy rate
of 94% in detecting these images used for the illicit promotion of such games
in real-world scenarios.
|
[
-0.23874613642692566,
-0.7700306177139282,
0.1808168888092041,
0.1711885780096054,
-0.6516833305358887,
-0.031892329454422,
-0.15282042324543,
-0.6683945059776306,
-0.07681979984045029,
0.9349704384803772,
-0.43429166078567505,
-0.6093108654022217,
-0.637023389339447,
-0.026224449276924133,
-0.48212939500808716,
0.8355346322059631,
0.09966070204973221,
-0.11107978224754333,
-0.09679864346981049,
0.052654530853033066,
-0.5127629637718201,
-0.6843166351318359,
-0.8696221113204956,
0.2015397846698761,
0.28938350081443787,
0.06217338517308235,
0.3627696931362152,
0.5225881338119507,
0.6308106780052185,
0.30000361800193787,
0.18068920075893402,
0.04640365391969681,
-1.0888067483901978,
0.31196579337120056,
-0.3857123553752899,
0.024845773354172707,
-0.12122904509305954,
-0.17212757468223572,
0.024658450856804848,
0.014142777770757675,
-0.12321685999631882,
0.10653315484523773,
0.17174214124679565,
0.5036366581916809,
-0.7787380218505859,
0.04675142839550972,
-0.7109823822975159,
0.09390141069889069,
-0.19565676152706146,
-0.4979232847690582,
-0.6092932820320129,
-0.020313935354351997,
-0.15836085379123688,
-0.7187291383743286,
-0.02025035209953785,
-0.025618024170398712,
0.7671436667442322,
-0.16750852763652802,
-0.4101002812385559,
-0.21628844738006592,
-0.7792719006538391,
0.5498862862586975,
-0.21415020525455475,
0.17219699919223785,
0.43835118412971497,
0.22493375837802887,
-0.3316975235939026,
-0.6630783081054688,
-0.2993515133857727,
-0.13843971490859985,
0.006161000579595566,
0.1450689435005188,
-0.5442827343940735,
0.17238645255565643,
0.15682032704353333,
-0.235123410820961,
-0.442914754152298,
0.2269122302532196,
-0.369739294052124,
-0.3207703232765198,
0.9742914438247681,
0.19555898010730743,
0.6645758152008057,
-0.017772605642676353,
-0.7977135181427002,
-0.19006384909152985,
-0.8434562087059021,
0.2309992015361786,
0.5702636241912842,
-0.04351435601711273,
-0.1469564586877823,
0.5914308428764343,
-0.17804238200187683,
0.296790212392807,
0.28915709257125854,
0.019665690138936043,
-0.08220771700143814,
-0.30412325263023376,
0.02879628725349903,
0.10480402410030365,
1.0101702213287354,
1.0306390523910522,
0.3241710066795349,
0.04669930040836334,
-0.4135271906852722,
0.30363425612449646,
0.4683871865272522,
-0.8173316121101379,
-0.18679650127887726,
-0.11631032824516296,
-0.5576050281524658,
-0.7150396108627319,
0.2322365790605545,
-0.9656117558479309,
-0.7258400321006775,
0.183785542845726,
0.5207018852233887,
-0.07802001386880875,
-0.2611102759838104,
0.20792165398597717,
-0.10055292397737503,
0.2573167681694031,
0.2935076951980591,
-0.6376990079879761,
-0.018122121691703796,
0.2450007200241089,
0.38449040055274963,
-0.4127417802810669,
0.006656508892774582,
-0.3402215838432312,
0.3675951361656189,
-0.4499703049659729,
0.7367505431175232,
-0.4521666467189789,
-0.48065492510795593,
0.5285356044769287,
0.3401138186454773,
0.26795265078544617,
-0.22334136068820953,
0.798759937286377,
-0.8807673454284668,
-0.22313185036182404,
-0.16631656885147095,
-0.24450081586837769,
0.14037777483463287,
0.4102153182029724,
-0.4754372239112854,
0.6801564693450928,
-0.17486046254634857,
-0.7285566926002502,
0.5888491272926331,
-0.33715930581092834,
-0.3836190104484558,
0.4220065474510193,
-0.0638536661863327,
-0.4460887610912323,
0.04756972938776016,
0.38319921493530273,
0.46530643105506897,
0.13749848306179047,
0.15821070969104767,
-0.5055338740348816,
-0.5032516121864319,
0.30824169516563416,
-0.7036707401275635,
0.8767081499099731,
0.39514878392219543,
-0.446853905916214,
0.20037515461444855,
-0.05027991533279419,
-0.15715186297893524,
0.34274691343307495,
-0.04932718351483345,
-0.6054181456565857,
0.11088905483484268,
0.1111120879650116,
0.23444022238254547,
0.053705956786870956,
-0.49000683426856995,
0.3040209412574768,
0.3019472062587738,
0.10090535879135132,
0.7547919154167175,
0.41145408153533936,
0.2955366373062134,
-0.017140217125415802,
0.578646183013916,
0.04956432804465294,
0.660625159740448,
-0.11019253730773926,
-0.7378135919570923,
-0.3007839620113373,
-0.1455317586660385,
0.036239247769117355,
0.440248042345047,
-1.288118839263916,
0.21921029686927795,
-0.14992575347423553,
-0.267387330532074,
-0.00834483653306961,
0.0828315019607544,
0.5833716988563538,
0.21940511465072632,
0.10369139164686203,
-0.4902273416519165,
-0.3056844174861908,
-0.5152389407157898,
-0.2369719296693802,
-0.3954932987689972,
-0.06705669313669205,
0.5268431901931763,
0.30234554409980774,
-0.2385065257549286,
0.283334881067276,
-0.43539589643478394,
-0.7542392015457153,
-0.17710727453231812,
0.20275332033634186,
-0.29703545570373535,
0.4621429443359375,
0.7270042896270752,
-0.9164825081825256,
-0.7114474773406982,
-0.20231789350509644,
-0.8138152956962585,
-0.19873251020908356,
-0.3148612380027771,
-0.30826935172080994,
-0.023454574868083,
0.6396844983100891,
-0.19856445491313934,
0.6666700839996338,
0.4160396158695221,
-0.6276461482048035,
0.5548219680786133,
-0.3545697331428528,
0.6214462518692017,
-0.4579451084136963,
-0.22663235664367676,
0.2611992061138153,
-0.17002668976783752,
-0.621076762676239,
0.49842071533203125,
-0.055536556988954544,
-0.11511122435331345,
-0.6859562993049622,
0.34275588393211365,
-0.5283887386322021,
0.3425542414188385,
-0.2659730315208435,
-0.018186474218964577,
-0.23728230595588684,
0.3120892643928528,
0.13296164572238922,
0.7523216605186462,
0.9314076900482178,
-0.485309362411499,
0.36074838042259216,
0.0865318551659584,
-0.4156664311885834,
0.7382047772407532,
-0.4796280562877655,
0.30636677145957947,
-0.14590051770210266,
0.26750966906547546,
-0.8679762482643127,
-0.38806015253067017,
0.4636980891227722,
-0.45342713594436646,
0.21238097548484802,
-0.6169217824935913,
-0.3968030512332916,
-0.5027759075164795,
-0.45455434918403625,
0.45465925335884094,
0.6386822462081909,
-0.6312130093574524,
0.14802885055541992,
0.9086683392524719,
0.20493805408477783,
-0.6749168634414673,
-0.3817276060581207,
0.3453819453716278,
-0.4792649745941162,
-0.5544511079788208,
0.3067544400691986,
0.16973190009593964,
-0.13485807180404663,
0.07812385261058807,
0.07380010187625885,
-0.22839359939098358,
0.16179043054580688,
0.30639129877090454,
0.3950921893119812,
0.18241465091705322,
-0.28150275349617004,
0.0556049682199955,
0.1571412831544876,
0.1972290575504303,
-0.23231422901153564,
0.37003371119499207,
0.08109279721975327,
-0.3565753698348999,
-0.29578128457069397,
0.4966450333595276,
0.21251453459262848,
-0.13355720043182373,
0.6143587231636047,
0.7770580649375916,
-0.3474344313144684,
-0.43142884969711304,
-0.24780070781707764,
-0.30641019344329834,
-0.5582805871963501,
0.2272741049528122,
0.09706923365592957,
-0.8582870364189148,
0.3752434551715851,
0.07351434975862503,
-0.14135202765464783,
0.11730325222015381,
0.4016207158565521,
-0.15728704631328583,
1.43229079246521,
0.5760031342506409,
0.031039079651236534,
0.48731961846351624,
-0.26860934495925903,
0.1431455910205841,
-0.3822862207889557,
-0.4900464415550232,
-0.11522573232650757,
-0.20036926865577698,
-0.667171835899353,
-0.35167399048805237,
0.46618396043777466,
0.15104863047599792,
0.14212550222873688,
0.508849561214447,
-0.5583395957946777,
0.8851485848426819,
0.24429084360599518,
0.31211721897125244,
0.08837033063173294,
0.20430180430412292,
-0.2256990671157837,
-0.034047145396471024,
-0.47732746601104736,
-0.29603078961372375,
1.1981779336929321,
-0.0035327787045389414,
1.1458500623703003,
0.3517926037311554,
0.47324684262275696,
0.8847130537033081,
0.4789293110370636,
-0.6218149065971375,
0.5956693291664124,
-0.3055288791656494,
-0.886035680770874,
-0.24497205018997192,
-0.23480047285556793,
-1.089660882949829,
0.04571032151579857,
-0.6435681581497192,
-1.0021922588348389,
0.24160639941692352,
0.27132996916770935,
-0.3863730728626251,
0.44835588335990906,
-0.5475270748138428,
0.5828643441200256,
-0.4549226760864258,
-0.8836542963981628,
-0.12142565101385117,
-0.5504013895988464,
0.6488124132156372,
-0.14443236589431763,
0.341033399105072,
0.07881928235292435,
0.12129251658916473,
0.5867215991020203,
0.0030540996231138706,
0.8529190421104431,
-0.22111938893795013,
0.008567369543015957,
0.5960972905158997,
0.3078499138355255,
0.43591365218162537,
0.13763830065727234,
0.49371472001075745,
0.1955079883337021,
-0.22779366374015808,
-0.255190372467041,
-0.15409623086452484,
0.9857872724533081,
-0.5651302337646484,
-0.6005600690841675,
-0.41417115926742554,
-0.16812264919281006,
-0.13173286616802216,
0.42533978819847107,
0.4430229067802429,
0.33096566796302795,
-0.19579467177391052,
0.44778627157211304,
0.8884971141815186,
-0.36142101883888245,
0.36713436245918274,
0.07396697252988815,
-0.3546985983848572,
-0.3498871922492981,
0.9282844066619873,
-0.19767147302627563,
0.22270460426807404,
-0.12384221702814102,
0.18478040397167206,
-0.6426864862442017,
-0.7970091104507446,
-0.6305203437805176,
-0.04717044532299042,
-0.5723798871040344,
-0.25533363223075867,
-0.3364599645137787,
-0.11177361756563187,
-0.44053345918655396,
-0.2608109414577484,
-0.016034815460443497,
0.10993842780590057,
-0.1277918815612793,
0.05006709694862366,
0.1875135898590088,
0.7213921546936035,
-0.19668728113174438,
0.444913387298584,
-0.7377870678901672,
0.32772698998451233,
0.5059450268745422,
0.5358251333236694,
-0.26699039340019226,
-0.48822537064552307,
-0.04738396778702736,
-0.05051332339644432,
-0.3416701555252075,
-0.9490979909896851,
0.4722593426704407,
-0.014382216148078442,
0.6260423064231873,
1.042865514755249,
0.3868764042854309,
0.401745080947876,
-0.2910380959510803,
0.8802642822265625,
0.4039766788482666,
-0.3892055153846741,
0.29621610045433044,
-0.8648545742034912,
-0.35159340500831604,
0.6421679258346558,
0.5870352983474731,
-0.49869030714035034,
0.050573889166116714,
-0.5777856111526489,
-0.7868189811706543,
0.5812174081802368,
0.3304566442966461,
0.5050784945487976,
-0.031170139089226723,
0.15154580771923065,
-0.19816818833351135,
0.2865350544452667,
-0.8080844283103943,
-0.33349788188934326,
-0.15313728153705597,
0.13120636343955994,
0.28428858518600464,
-0.3275807499885559,
-0.4159015417098999,
0.01819017343223095,
0.5033267140388489,
-0.059335753321647644,
0.30126509070396423,
0.02456255443394184,
-0.2914639711380005,
-0.19492287933826447,
0.0012417155085131526,
0.28052476048469543,
0.31837257742881775,
-0.1216934397816658,
0.2864837050437927,
-0.2315768003463745,
-0.7775689363479614,
0.3474327325820923,
-0.2183263599872589,
-0.6033382415771484,
-0.4480721354484558,
0.059244684875011444,
0.5911046266555786,
0.11170711368322372,
-0.7578330636024475,
0.9433496594429016,
-0.326204776763916,
-0.25136277079582214,
-0.2863215506076813,
0.20769768953323364,
-0.37071871757507324,
-0.07413723319768906,
0.29004186391830444,
-0.055113621056079865,
0.2528189718723297,
-0.5892031788825989,
0.4689357578754425,
0.5895329713821411,
-0.6645760536193848,
-0.22340907156467438,
0.8374593257904053,
0.347223699092865,
-0.20187318325042725,
0.398264080286026,
-0.43742313981056213,
-0.5813376903533936,
0.5083025097846985,
0.6435529589653015,
0.8646709322929382,
-0.13060691952705383,
0.6104701161384583,
0.47402024269104004,
0.4391779601573944,
-0.20165838301181793,
0.24392521381378174,
0.19832493364810944,
-0.8486912846565247,
-0.13300010561943054,
-0.36800485849380493,
-0.007997897453606129,
0.49260416626930237,
-0.5275288224220276,
0.318683385848999,
-0.6950514316558838,
-0.4448526203632355,
-0.27879437804222107,
-0.3930257260799408,
-0.5515187382698059,
0.11199211329221725,
0.6618115305900574,
0.3559828996658325,
-0.9629015922546387,
0.561056911945343,
0.5273152589797974,
-0.27741336822509766,
-0.6193004250526428,
-0.07591194659471512,
0.3037315309047699,
-0.6390664577484131,
0.3563694953918457,
0.12923182547092438,
-0.22474008798599243,
0.11267000436782837,
-0.9698643684387207,
-0.5181241035461426,
0.7625005841255188,
0.009008773602545261,
-0.42820224165916443,
0.05845508351922035,
0.2943488359451294,
0.43500450253486633,
-0.5707411170005798,
0.016393249854445457,
0.20941704511642456,
0.24368976056575775,
0.18959940969944,
-0.22268447279930115,
0.07275290787220001,
-0.15351009368896484,
-0.022215845063328743,
0.17866846919059753,
-0.317353218793869,
0.37520474195480347,
-0.32310375571250916,
-0.5528923273086548,
-0.09846924245357513,
0.27544528245925903,
0.3568807542324066,
0.2600705623626709,
0.7341697812080383,
0.4439832866191864,
-0.02493234910070896,
-0.1884015053510666,
0.8792517781257629,
-0.20818312466144562,
0.2557876408100128,
0.6004526615142822,
-0.08600588887929916,
0.660873293876648,
0.3470461070537567,
0.16149097681045532,
0.19109106063842773,
0.5280973315238953,
-0.4373016357421875,
0.6219232678413391,
0.18278247117996216,
-0.341852068901062,
-0.6326397061347961,
-0.5241258144378662,
-0.16501735150814056,
0.4758758544921875,
0.4127918481826782,
-0.3351552486419678,
-0.20840677618980408,
-0.001546125509776175,
0.030223503708839417,
0.2511989176273346,
-0.6020004749298096,
0.6646647453308105,
-0.08845754712820053,
-0.3704838454723358,
0.32803335785865784,
-0.0021855717059224844,
0.768313467502594,
-0.5786983966827393,
-0.12105835974216461,
-0.16421297192573547,
0.12285951524972916,
-0.07676916569471359,
-0.8832687735557556,
-0.11231581121683121,
0.42500489950180054,
0.779549777507782,
-0.2655700147151947,
1.3311753273010254,
-0.29534855484962463,
-0.4781625270843506,
0.3246103823184967,
0.3121193051338196,
0.05237098038196564,
-0.008637357503175735,
-0.867572009563446,
0.09498090296983719,
-0.129762664437294,
0.061162639409303665,
0.5517193675041199,
0.30460572242736816,
-0.38614240288734436,
0.4976627826690674,
0.9575567841529846,
0.21353136003017426,
0.10440584272146225,
0.05345779284834862,
0.7613733410835266,
-0.34339746832847595,
-0.6008114814758301,
-0.655650794506073,
0.46738654375076294,
-0.39963531494140625,
-0.17552436888217926,
0.9658487439155579,
0.2766404151916504,
1.0325736999511719,
-0.10923515260219574,
0.6041512489318848,
0.0073720491491258144,
-0.3227979838848114,
-0.2850969433784485,
1.215820550918579,
-0.440504789352417,
0.13820740580558777,
-0.5036396980285645,
-0.647146999835968,
-0.28270331025123596,
0.15510499477386475,
-0.015832748264074326,
-0.26702433824539185,
0.1912183314561844,
0.7074867486953735,
-0.170489102602005,
-0.26337623596191406,
0.5503145456314087,
-0.21571342647075653,
0.46553346514701843,
0.2750520706176758,
1.0668672323226929,
-0.28178709745407104,
0.775305986404419,
-0.46980124711990356,
-0.29004693031311035,
-0.4164276719093323,
-0.997138500213623,
-1.175787329673767,
-0.3743538558483124,
-0.17666764557361603,
-0.5586011409759521,
0.11986387521028519,
0.8134796619415283,
0.5795090794563293,
-0.7985429167747498,
-0.19251123070716858,
0.10637021064758301,
-0.25065991282463074,
-0.1618087887763977,
-0.14959272742271423,
0.17018595337867737,
0.3489532470703125,
-0.40192219614982605,
0.13445410132408142,
0.13786040246486664,
0.2398919314146042,
-0.49286210536956787,
0.09193535149097443,
0.07980453222990036,
0.30321618914604187,
0.7040970325469971,
0.33719709515571594,
-0.443539023399353,
-0.33515432476997375,
0.23022091388702393,
-0.1805979311466217,
-0.20541901886463165,
0.86086505651474,
-0.4429178237915039,
0.5514624118804932,
0.48539999127388,
0.6188831329345703,
0.424715518951416,
0.07799879461526871,
0.3895662724971771,
-0.4689265787601471,
0.08577097952365875,
0.07393616437911987,
0.3652466833591461,
0.28671959042549133,
-0.5644698739051819,
0.3711335062980652,
0.42823925614356995,
-0.38796794414520264,
-0.8704737424850464,
0.2537771165370941,
-0.8474341630935669,
-0.22150272130966187,
1.3234869241714478,
-0.4320983290672302,
-0.3222718834877014,
-0.26046279072761536,
-0.3089140057563782,
0.10322369635105133,
-0.5545421242713928,
1.155889868736267,
0.32109686732292175,
0.1077173501253128,
0.02915726602077484,
-0.3947880268096924,
0.7072513699531555,
-0.1987151801586151,
-0.8437644243240356,
0.16222795844078064,
0.670882523059845,
0.14796684682369232,
0.002144400728866458,
0.3796568810939789,
-0.3095009922981262,
0.29787495732307434,
-0.009882771410048008,
-0.06943211704492569,
-0.1683986783027649,
-0.43667498230934143,
-0.2956157326698303,
0.16521809995174408,
-0.26199695467948914,
-0.04340256378054619
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18938v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18938v1
|
Reshaping Free-Text Radiology Notes Into Structured Reports With Generative Transformers
| 2024-03-27T18:38:39 | 2024-03-27T18:38:39 |
Laura Bergomi, Tommaso M. Buonocore, Paolo Antonazzo, Lorenzo Alberghi, Riccardo Bellazzi, Lorenzo Preda, Chandra Bortolotto, Enea Parimbelli
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7; J.3
|
BACKGROUND: Radiology reports are typically written in a free-text format,
making clinical information difficult to extract and use. Recently the adoption
of structured reporting (SR) has been recommended by various medical societies
thanks to the advantages it offers, e.g. standardization, completeness and
information retrieval. We propose a pipeline to extract information from
free-text radiology reports, that fits with the items of the reference SR
registry proposed by a national society of interventional and medical
radiology, focusing on CT staging of patients with lymphoma. METHODS: Our work
aims to leverage the potential of Natural Language Processing (NLP) and
Transformer-based models to deal with automatic SR registry filling. With the
availability of 174 radiology reports, we investigate a rule-free generative
Question Answering approach based on a domain-specific version of T5 (IT5). Two
strategies (batch-truncation and ex-post combination) are implemented to comply
with the model's context length limitations. Performance is evaluated in terms
of strict accuracy, F1, and format accuracy, and compared with the widely used
GPT-3.5 Large Language Model. A 5-point Likert scale questionnaire is used to
collect human-expert feedback on the similarity between medical annotations and
generated answers. RESULTS: The combination of fine-tuning and batch splitting
allows IT5 to achieve notable results; it performs on par with GPT-3.5 albeit
its size being a thousand times smaller in terms of parameters. Human-based
assessment scores show a high correlation (Spearman's correlation
coefficients>0.88, p-values<0.001) with AI performance metrics (F1) and confirm
the superior ability of LLMs (i.e., GPT-3.5, 175B of parameters) in generating
plausible human-like statements.
|
[
-0.07036948204040527,
-0.34872424602508545,
0.7206882834434509,
0.11459116637706757,
-0.5989383459091187,
-0.09846249222755432,
-0.18467599153518677,
-0.5672005414962769,
0.2513643503189087,
0.564019501209259,
-0.20809704065322876,
-0.6539136171340942,
-0.7334451079368591,
0.4522494971752167,
-0.5386993885040283,
1.2600250244140625,
-0.08339700847864151,
0.19205917418003082,
-0.20990604162216187,
0.03460611402988434,
-0.48181676864624023,
-0.15546388924121857,
-0.6536908745765686,
-0.23766478896141052,
0.7251946926116943,
0.26088595390319824,
0.7102741599082947,
0.8550482988357544,
0.9134377837181091,
0.22527168691158295,
-0.0742672011256218,
0.0848890095949173,
-0.09713637083768845,
0.2794429063796997,
-0.01906241476535797,
-0.14275752007961273,
-0.7474285364151001,
0.03523101285099983,
0.49877604842185974,
0.6495960354804993,
-0.2749495804309845,
-0.049413684755563736,
0.1458459198474884,
0.4437074363231659,
-0.32076045870780945,
0.3554151654243469,
-0.3114357590675354,
0.07911977916955948,
-0.03468960151076317,
-0.5596374273300171,
-0.7091888785362244,
-0.4888772964477539,
0.019843483343720436,
-0.6848008632659912,
0.5201244950294495,
-0.060567185282707214,
0.9211799502372742,
0.06873813271522522,
-0.40438395738601685,
-0.401215523481369,
-0.7181509137153625,
0.527802586555481,
-0.649547815322876,
0.03921258822083473,
0.39758288860321045,
0.5802959203720093,
0.06863521039485931,
-1.1997076272964478,
-0.02141622267663479,
-0.23836028575897217,
-0.5734561085700989,
0.36285755038261414,
-0.14175714552402496,
0.3629613220691681,
0.2236005961894989,
0.522377610206604,
-0.764297366142273,
-0.0347527451813221,
-0.6550536155700684,
-0.23493258655071259,
0.7887381911277771,
0.31217697262763977,
0.44231855869293213,
-0.24513937532901764,
-0.3254809081554413,
0.11234220862388611,
-0.5790490508079529,
-0.290738582611084,
-0.3234971761703491,
0.598309338092804,
-0.0981103703379631,
0.6163768768310547,
-0.27121007442474365,
0.6394621729850769,
0.005941955838352442,
-0.2719002664089203,
0.01776491478085518,
-0.32519882917404175,
-0.1825530081987381,
0.07808516174554825,
1.0063199996948242,
0.45418792963027954,
0.22877749800682068,
-0.3540606200695038,
-0.10156663507223129,
-0.12967921793460846,
0.4097871780395508,
-0.8147825598716736,
-0.3507052958011627,
0.3660716414451599,
-0.6691523194313049,
-0.3418636918067932,
0.01987633854150772,
-0.5506076216697693,
-0.20073822140693665,
-0.0730266347527504,
0.3479050397872925,
-0.5174296498298645,
0.01242641732096672,
0.010827424004673958,
-0.058790355920791626,
0.03573557361960411,
0.5717262625694275,
-0.6028680205345154,
0.20610536634922028,
0.381165474653244,
0.7860232591629028,
0.0018360186368227005,
0.27737876772880554,
-0.714124321937561,
0.25475630164146423,
-0.1554088145494461,
0.9183252453804016,
-0.4358646869659424,
-0.727681040763855,
-0.10813583433628082,
0.039561789482831955,
-0.4717143774032593,
-0.454513281583786,
0.6581684947013855,
-0.47934603691101074,
0.7780609726905823,
0.16484865546226501,
-0.497988224029541,
0.16456495225429535,
0.1929292529821396,
-0.65154629945755,
0.7245433926582336,
0.2625689208507538,
-0.6575497984886169,
0.3001521825790405,
-0.6029049754142761,
-0.35427650809288025,
0.3292998969554901,
-0.3148398995399475,
-0.2963694930076599,
-0.060476742684841156,
0.36151668429374695,
0.42789220809936523,
-0.45032548904418945,
0.4389213025569916,
0.23491428792476654,
-0.26108020544052124,
0.07652710378170013,
-0.1473124474287033,
0.5033766031265259,
0.27960991859436035,
-0.07025883346796036,
0.38756436109542847,
-0.7386310696601868,
0.2874806523323059,
-0.10350048542022705,
-0.4581502676010132,
-0.01476318296045065,
-0.1305467039346695,
-0.05442335829138756,
0.42628827691078186,
-0.06269696354866028,
-0.569028913974762,
0.4332442581653595,
-0.4319361448287964,
0.037485040724277496,
0.36055296659469604,
0.15286387503147125,
0.23593753576278687,
-0.5640370845794678,
0.7727645635604858,
0.1881752759218216,
0.1756417155265808,
-0.16424015164375305,
-0.6547921299934387,
-0.5954126119613647,
-0.6060528755187988,
0.38107210397720337,
0.4479164481163025,
-0.7823274731636047,
0.0779888853430748,
-0.7057462930679321,
-0.37834829092025757,
-0.745086133480072,
-0.2569772005081177,
0.4208800494670868,
0.8035237193107605,
0.6629907488822937,
-0.31207725405693054,
-0.7860794067382812,
-1.0092530250549316,
-0.22436843812465668,
0.015675561502575874,
-0.4805631935596466,
0.023341534659266472,
0.19118350744247437,
0.021487977355718613,
0.8651185631752014,
-0.637998640537262,
-0.7961900234222412,
-0.5426231622695923,
0.13039959967136383,
0.22246941924095154,
0.20457340776920319,
0.009941883385181427,
-0.46750959753990173,
-0.5515220165252686,
0.05144428834319115,
-0.7158216834068298,
-0.11471325904130936,
-0.08735919743776321,
0.422383576631546,
0.223639577627182,
0.4459016025066376,
-0.5038198828697205,
0.6282655000686646,
0.24625515937805176,
-0.20496350526809692,
0.046877406537532806,
-0.47475022077560425,
0.18492192029953003,
-1.2335566282272339,
0.32408833503723145,
-0.006036907900124788,
-0.3253032863140106,
-0.6882354617118835,
-0.13630248606204987,
0.11072125285863876,
0.07378320395946503,
-0.15952324867248535,
0.28878578543663025,
-0.45157602429389954,
-0.0398128367960453,
-0.15987975895404816,
0.25494641065597534,
0.038253024220466614,
0.21366797387599945,
0.16331955790519714,
0.5295117497444153,
0.018950633704662323,
-0.31788092851638794,
-0.15706340968608856,
0.22628153860569,
-0.4266343414783478,
0.0930839478969574,
-0.5361515879631042,
0.23670387268066406,
-0.39407652616500854,
0.37667128443717957,
-0.9554935693740845,
-0.20062367618083954,
0.15182317793369293,
-0.503105640411377,
0.4253884553909302,
-0.3297107517719269,
-0.20633873343467712,
-0.13508908450603485,
-0.2089584469795227,
0.17677393555641174,
0.42458394169807434,
0.2317216694355011,
0.5728273987770081,
0.009438857436180115,
-0.28374943137168884,
-0.4068952798843384,
-0.45200812816619873,
0.27763983607292175,
-0.008539803326129913,
-0.5615180134773254,
0.5131507515907288,
0.06125042960047722,
-0.21391193568706512,
-0.008842883631587029,
0.06587201356887817,
-0.1565021276473999,
-0.07092111557722092,
0.2043127566576004,
0.303129643201828,
-0.28736183047294617,
-0.27141082286834717,
-0.2152540385723114,
-0.11598917096853256,
-0.11626610904932022,
0.13707536458969116,
0.33506059646606445,
-0.10609593242406845,
-0.14624883234500885,
-0.6467162370681763,
0.4768090844154358,
0.5857047438621521,
0.0839499980211258,
0.5793707966804504,
0.34356528520584106,
-0.3300818204879761,
0.027785882353782654,
-0.1201678141951561,
-0.11707694828510284,
-0.3346940875053406,
0.06516499817371368,
-0.4169195592403412,
-0.9124448895454407,
0.4270722568035126,
0.3684608042240143,
0.193844273686409,
0.8404431939125061,
0.5733375549316406,
-0.23356792330741882,
1.004156231880188,
0.5108892321586609,
0.2981513440608978,
0.09167665988206863,
-0.07063449174165726,
0.3114086389541626,
-0.7170058488845825,
-0.4685474932193756,
-0.5273203253746033,
-0.08705224841833115,
-0.6392735838890076,
-0.5673162937164307,
0.7244016528129578,
-0.32096150517463684,
0.1515023410320282,
0.12173852324485779,
-0.6951463222503662,
0.1891087144613266,
0.12834486365318298,
0.17618726193904877,
0.5713021755218506,
0.024210931733250618,
0.07996263355016708,
-0.21692335605621338,
-0.7324114441871643,
-0.4592598080635071,
1.1143094301223755,
0.29213783144950867,
0.48235785961151123,
0.11046664416790009,
0.6568728685379028,
0.3163665533065796,
0.7868812084197998,
-0.9297642111778259,
0.5055453777313232,
-0.38731804490089417,
-0.34881678223609924,
-0.1387765109539032,
-0.25513043999671936,
-1.0970778465270996,
0.2300375998020172,
0.0859350860118866,
-0.50396329164505,
-0.10386452823877335,
-0.0405159518122673,
-0.6901260614395142,
0.11937730014324188,
-0.40290936827659607,
0.43763306736946106,
0.00980308186262846,
-0.06427643448114395,
0.05085920915007591,
-0.8722232580184937,
0.2446248084306717,
0.2200622409582138,
0.3413012623786926,
-0.06407211720943451,
-0.07116768509149551,
0.5743201971054077,
-0.5041325688362122,
0.6769242286682129,
-0.11994653940200806,
-0.16172431409358978,
0.1953076273202896,
0.13716062903404236,
0.38714635372161865,
-0.19626997411251068,
0.06594105064868927,
-0.04753677174448967,
0.2871086597442627,
-0.1436387449502945,
-0.6103338003158569,
0.4116292893886566,
-0.6976494789123535,
-0.5376395583152771,
-0.4902641177177429,
-0.6120693683624268,
-0.20887315273284912,
0.1494419276714325,
0.35557088255882263,
0.5792463421821594,
-0.0653490424156189,
0.32214656472206116,
0.33905118703842163,
-0.07162833213806152,
0.18008174002170563,
0.45889270305633545,
-0.10731492936611176,
-0.5486230254173279,
0.6287142038345337,
0.1534615010023117,
0.11108138412237167,
0.801254391670227,
0.3077152967453003,
-0.16620545089244843,
-0.5997041463851929,
-0.36389783024787903,
0.07627663016319275,
-0.5794752836227417,
-0.39653828740119934,
-0.7228679656982422,
-0.5380597710609436,
-0.5330635905265808,
-0.07514931261539459,
-0.1195249930024147,
-0.7753540277481079,
-0.22153525054454803,
-0.0026905604172497988,
0.16086126863956451,
0.7015581727027893,
0.053216639906167984,
0.12361913919448853,
-0.8447479605674744,
0.22304828464984894,
-0.12682771682739258,
0.2678416073322296,
-0.2726229429244995,
-0.7863729596138,
-0.3778325617313385,
-0.09855999797582626,
-0.1989426165819168,
-0.6921238303184509,
0.7784111499786377,
0.39609870314598083,
0.252259761095047,
0.23271982371807098,
0.06388524174690247,
0.8086056709289551,
-0.22675736248493195,
0.6816438436508179,
0.11177949607372284,
-0.45493489503860474,
0.6666505336761475,
-0.6896784901618958,
0.2406030148267746,
0.3436906933784485,
0.32461416721343994,
-0.6245421767234802,
-0.5426093339920044,
-0.6799479126930237,
-1.1296281814575195,
0.7524569630622864,
0.29295411705970764,
-0.40244510769844055,
-0.21603067219257355,
0.3974701762199402,
-0.005089493002742529,
-0.05561129376292229,
-0.5335454344749451,
0.04055964946746826,
-0.2548891305923462,
-0.4016331136226654,
-0.10774322599172592,
-0.4538222551345825,
-0.6192880272865295,
-0.20769931375980377,
0.3558610677719116,
-0.37026891112327576,
0.6119915246963501,
0.5560482740402222,
-0.1667104959487915,
0.0023377123288810253,
0.536446750164032,
0.8596929907798767,
0.6820593476295471,
-0.42855703830718994,
0.2510834038257599,
-0.03420636057853699,
-0.5146097540855408,
-0.09899435192346573,
-0.07026881724596024,
-0.07750009745359421,
0.17664502561092377,
0.597408652305603,
0.4767342507839203,
0.12182629108428955,
-0.4546498656272888,
0.5473376512527466,
-0.3031119108200073,
-0.4845846891403198,
-0.3018440902233124,
-0.018848245963454247,
-0.07288915663957596,
-0.1118989884853363,
0.3708992600440979,
-0.1446564793586731,
0.13609547913074493,
-0.20846164226531982,
0.4217621982097626,
0.10811445116996765,
-0.7140390276908875,
-0.4027927815914154,
0.7084383964538574,
-0.05201034992933273,
-0.06750944256782532,
0.7989290356636047,
0.30924534797668457,
0.1845182180404663,
0.5605909824371338,
0.6147493124008179,
0.9958921074867249,
-0.056721363216638565,
0.2701334059238434,
0.6305969953536987,
0.3590616285800934,
-0.04525882378220558,
0.34867554903030396,
0.11076683551073074,
-0.5102395415306091,
-0.5546044707298279,
-0.30994096398353577,
-0.24148154258728027,
0.23516911268234253,
-0.8795053362846375,
0.09227274358272552,
-0.8223909139633179,
-0.02792336605489254,
0.00992573145776987,
-0.16869091987609863,
-0.29521214962005615,
0.4452537000179291,
-0.031111039221286774,
0.977385938167572,
-0.40003135800361633,
1.0078693628311157,
0.7440961003303528,
-0.4969751536846161,
-0.9322055578231812,
-0.10742451250553131,
-0.0813128724694252,
-0.7061390280723572,
0.7295769453048706,
0.291077584028244,
0.0640774667263031,
-0.19713082909584045,
-0.3761976659297943,
-0.8501808047294617,
1.2983044385910034,
0.059395261108875275,
-0.23311758041381836,
-0.32017970085144043,
0.3051876723766327,
0.8833540678024292,
-0.49172329902648926,
0.5224472880363464,
0.3877490758895874,
0.1613065004348755,
0.2589735984802246,
-1.1783443689346313,
0.2941322326660156,
-0.34433045983314514,
-0.08342733234167099,
0.25063958764076233,
-0.4396205544471741,
0.5340277552604675,
-0.1663777381181717,
-0.362196683883667,
0.1815178543329239,
0.4816599488258362,
0.04661477357149124,
0.2717776298522949,
0.29202547669410706,
0.42428702116012573,
0.5024251341819763,
-0.1433863788843155,
1.0772475004196167,
-0.5422995090484619,
0.31086671352386475,
0.8278414607048035,
-0.21832452714443207,
0.6790586709976196,
0.48127371072769165,
-0.062058474868535995,
0.6988291144371033,
0.3518458604812622,
0.17537324130535126,
0.4850795269012451,
0.021695047616958618,
-0.3096790313720703,
-0.30244970321655273,
-0.16429588198661804,
-0.18590311706066132,
0.3489671051502228,
0.3308856189250946,
-0.6716555953025818,
-0.4513663351535797,
-0.2806199789047241,
0.24872560799121857,
-0.092502161860466,
-0.0806937888264656,
1.0369123220443726,
0.17191486060619354,
-0.8373547792434692,
0.5848665833473206,
0.1381833851337433,
0.2980462908744812,
-0.7341173887252808,
-0.056731853634119034,
-0.4968784749507904,
0.2299375832080841,
-0.4624994099140167,
-0.7988091111183167,
0.6948717832565308,
0.14127381145954132,
-0.28528112173080444,
-0.5546337366104126,
0.549247145652771,
-0.4226977527141571,
-0.3251304626464844,
-0.11079151183366776,
0.3089546859264374,
0.14295516908168793,
0.19120749831199646,
-0.30372145771980286,
-0.20761117339134216,
0.1736856997013092,
-0.1926051825284958,
0.6587696075439453,
0.008180138655006886,
-0.4435376524925232,
0.8162438273429871,
0.4131825268268585,
0.09993374347686768,
-0.46988484263420105,
0.10658492147922516,
0.8324687480926514,
-0.694858968257904,
-0.2657753825187683,
-0.5827950239181519,
0.6597488522529602,
0.012823186814785004,
-0.26180142164230347,
0.4564324617385864,
0.6909281015396118,
0.42304736375808716,
0.006448929198086262,
0.7202575206756592,
-0.13286083936691284,
0.7423923015594482,
-0.42101263999938965,
0.6676645278930664,
-0.385800838470459,
0.4419367015361786,
-0.1477142721414566,
-0.184578537940979,
-0.6719462275505066,
0.27622076869010925,
-0.3258203864097595,
-0.0603012852370739,
0.7655024528503418,
0.7341846823692322,
0.13707751035690308,
0.06364279985427856,
0.3066975474357605,
0.2620337903499603,
0.5966934561729431,
0.5313013792037964,
0.5143944621086121,
-0.5624340772628784,
0.7943334579467773,
-0.18632638454437256,
-0.04737154766917229,
-0.19407358765602112,
-0.6960374116897583,
-0.42588624358177185,
-0.5195474028587341,
-0.4101712107658386,
-0.6090052723884583,
0.02209494449198246,
0.8586477637290955,
0.3127180337905884,
-0.6560958027839661,
-0.15391048789024353,
0.35417866706848145,
0.0038898540660738945,
-0.1933605670928955,
-0.25767943263053894,
0.6851235032081604,
-0.23455126583576202,
-0.43946486711502075,
0.558395504951477,
0.45771437883377075,
-0.044202882796525955,
0.19752858579158783,
0.3036367893218994,
-0.0021554245613515377,
-0.2767501771450043,
0.7348512411117554,
0.11946871876716614,
-0.5569679737091064,
-0.3851891756057739,
0.11141064763069153,
-0.34328117966651917,
0.3047215938568115,
0.9917280077934265,
-0.8628057241439819,
0.5812706351280212,
0.45376887917518616,
0.25031641125679016,
0.42855849862098694,
0.04164150729775429,
0.7023071050643921,
-0.8492581248283386,
-0.05941486731171608,
0.5235549211502075,
0.10146640986204147,
0.2956138253211975,
-0.304037481546402,
0.3872205913066864,
0.3421224057674408,
-0.4676622748374939,
-0.7199037671089172,
0.058605778962373734,
-1.1779024600982666,
-0.20285990834236145,
1.1728334426879883,
-0.1615714579820633,
0.13542214035987854,
-0.4198817014694214,
-0.18023307621479034,
0.2566927671432495,
-0.302849680185318,
0.8939381837844849,
0.2133331149816513,
-0.6127811670303345,
-0.4144589900970459,
-0.40543922781944275,
0.8331348896026611,
0.15443909168243408,
-0.5855795741081238,
-0.2571069300174713,
0.5407044887542725,
0.5345123410224915,
-0.0030078734271228313,
1.1344366073608398,
-0.5034224390983582,
0.34553223848342896,
-0.428244411945343,
0.035772163420915604,
-0.13480393588542938,
-0.20057331025600433,
-0.2971614897251129,
0.639416515827179,
0.0715569332242012,
-0.04312389716506004
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18933v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18933v5
|
SemEval-2024 Task 1: Semantic Textual Relatedness for African and Asian Languages
| 2024-03-27T18:30:26 | 2024-04-17T19:49:12 |
Nedjma Ousidhoum, Shamsuddeen Hassan Muhammad, Mohamed Abdalla, Idris Abdulmumin, Ibrahim Said Ahmad, Sanchit Ahuja, Alham Fikri Aji, Vladimir Araujo, Meriem Beloucif, Christine De Kock, Oumaima Hourrane, Manish Shrivastava, Thamar Solorio, Nirmal Surange, Krishnapriya Vishnubhotla, Seid Muhie Yimam, Saif M. Mohammad
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present the first shared task on Semantic Textual Relatedness (STR). While
earlier shared tasks primarily focused on semantic similarity, we instead
investigate the broader phenomenon of semantic relatedness across 14 languages:
Afrikaans, Algerian Arabic, Amharic, English, Hausa, Hindi, Indonesian,
Kinyarwanda, Marathi, Moroccan Arabic, Modern Standard Arabic, Punjabi,
Spanish, and Telugu. These languages originate from five distinct language
families and are predominantly spoken in Africa and Asia -- regions
characterised by the relatively limited availability of NLP resources. Each
instance in the datasets is a sentence pair associated with a score that
represents the degree of semantic textual relatedness between the two
sentences. Participating systems were asked to rank sentence pairs by their
closeness in meaning (i.e., their degree of semantic relatedness) in the 14
languages in three main tracks: (a) supervised, (b) unsupervised, and (c)
crosslingual. The task attracted 163 participants. We received 70 submissions
in total (across all tasks) from 51 different teams, and 38 system description
papers. We report on the best-performing systems as well as the most common and
the most effective approaches for the three different tracks.
|
[
-0.55415940284729,
-0.36370930075645447,
0.616595983505249,
0.5665046572685242,
-0.45979446172714233,
-0.284445196390152,
-0.32839128375053406,
-0.857333242893219,
0.506359338760376,
0.7637285590171814,
-0.7337993383407593,
-0.532978355884552,
-0.5785149335861206,
0.5731058120727539,
-0.30410030484199524,
0.8908075094223022,
-0.4137914776802063,
-0.23800216615200043,
-0.5208760499954224,
-0.8016275763511658,
-0.391918808221817,
-0.7385210990905762,
-0.26077359914779663,
-0.16844898462295532,
0.5162645578384399,
0.3753424882888794,
0.547345757484436,
0.5360428690910339,
0.8497150540351868,
0.2690774202346802,
0.12983748316764832,
-0.007771167438477278,
-0.1808103322982788,
0.3515455424785614,
-0.5682079792022705,
-0.3276421129703522,
-0.3380071818828583,
-0.4450339674949646,
0.181370347738266,
0.7592805027961731,
0.4033517837524414,
0.20784923434257507,
0.28369832038879395,
0.6488053202629089,
-0.44440439343452454,
0.1670456826686859,
-0.4686150550842285,
-0.24906498193740845,
-0.5034021139144897,
-0.33233293890953064,
-0.027040237560868263,
-0.059764813631772995,
0.1324785202741623,
-0.5444409847259521,
0.18264052271842957,
-0.1742761880159378,
1.081051230430603,
0.34926438331604004,
-0.7394083142280579,
-0.6551514863967896,
-0.27694112062454224,
0.7313223481178284,
-0.5743361115455627,
0.19655334949493408,
0.8789669871330261,
0.016720321029424667,
0.06834297627210617,
-0.6397461891174316,
-0.45439204573631287,
0.3356013894081116,
-0.039651595056056976,
0.22878511250019073,
0.16530916094779968,
-0.1575891375541687,
-0.09949278086423874,
0.07691418379545212,
-0.5831418633460999,
-0.0846630334854126,
-0.24989868700504303,
-0.4143522083759308,
0.802346408367157,
0.04713057726621628,
0.4106115400791168,
-0.3076713979244232,
-0.5041133165359497,
0.28508269786834717,
-0.8571429252624512,
-0.2610582113265991,
0.30444246530532837,
0.34737837314605713,
-0.24434922635555267,
0.6048482060432434,
-0.3266393542289734,
0.4194783866405487,
-0.50113445520401,
0.13620778918266296,
0.50665283203125,
-1.1726878881454468,
0.2473759651184082,
0.07421883195638657,
0.8229004740715027,
0.37854501605033875,
0.14900346100330353,
-0.037246592342853546,
-0.08440572023391724,
0.3122906982898712,
-0.020811598747968674,
-0.40826818346977234,
0.14783909916877747,
-0.11394912749528885,
-0.5979447364807129,
-0.017793074250221252,
-0.29896819591522217,
-0.6082965135574341,
-0.0431942455470562,
-0.464967280626297,
0.647777795791626,
-0.5377147197723389,
-0.15000857412815094,
-0.20412825047969818,
0.22917234897613525,
0.40703436732292175,
0.2708509862422943,
-0.9582151770591736,
0.40664955973625183,
0.8286025524139404,
0.690933883190155,
-0.3468710780143738,
-0.6242545247077942,
-0.08858735114336014,
0.24275989830493927,
-0.047343481332063675,
0.8811994791030884,
-0.7851442694664001,
-0.21330733597278595,
-0.015273378230631351,
0.3350333869457245,
-0.09476613253355026,
-0.45904698967933655,
1.0121986865997314,
-0.3145603835582733,
0.03669070824980736,
-0.623516857624054,
-0.545410692691803,
-0.43242648243904114,
0.19185613095760345,
-0.7731459140777588,
1.2243441343307495,
-0.0024284315295517445,
-0.8364712595939636,
0.5212374925613403,
-0.337496280670166,
-0.6730349659919739,
0.062439028173685074,
-0.3336103856563568,
-0.23052284121513367,
-0.11899422109127045,
0.07806476950645447,
0.5372787117958069,
-0.18637539446353912,
0.16244402527809143,
-0.24406728148460388,
-0.352779358625412,
-0.2810281813144684,
-0.09182851016521454,
0.6171138882637024,
0.40300050377845764,
-0.5224884152412415,
0.06302964687347412,
-0.7386550903320312,
-0.12549641728401184,
0.049966905266046524,
0.03324291482567787,
-0.869301438331604,
-0.3054465651512146,
0.24434341490268707,
0.4260508716106415,
0.49182260036468506,
-0.5574241876602173,
-0.1367942988872528,
-0.5521551370620728,
0.5191783308982849,
0.40764686465263367,
0.22854603826999664,
0.3752821683883667,
-0.17429953813552856,
0.43996983766555786,
0.16415804624557495,
-0.25803491473197937,
-0.3996034860610962,
-0.521356999874115,
-0.8262850642204285,
0.11886058002710342,
0.3884391486644745,
0.6181544661521912,
-0.8155420422554016,
0.19236527383327484,
-0.4537048637866974,
-0.3645617365837097,
-0.2820455729961395,
0.03224693983793259,
0.29168763756752014,
0.09820050001144409,
0.21807648241519928,
-0.24715527892112732,
-0.6475628018379211,
-1.2047460079193115,
-0.27384814620018005,
-0.12794184684753418,
0.2505819797515869,
0.2486148476600647,
0.8920202255249023,
-0.2616446018218994,
0.3992767035961151,
-0.04967963322997093,
-0.351553738117218,
0.09874732792377472,
-0.10999132692813873,
0.09141112864017487,
0.2424418181180954,
0.705451488494873,
-0.7772470712661743,
-0.5829344987869263,
0.27822747826576233,
-0.7814520597457886,
-0.29768142104148865,
0.38520991802215576,
-0.31938058137893677,
0.6657756567001343,
0.7001622319221497,
0.04565891996026039,
0.5940325260162354,
0.6189270615577698,
-0.5524744987487793,
0.059304624795913696,
-0.2252379059791565,
0.34724709391593933,
-1.515395998954773,
0.034363485872745514,
-0.4256743788719177,
-0.1787225753068924,
-0.3944268822669983,
0.06570922583341599,
-0.13373596966266632,
-0.08658625930547714,
-0.31940433382987976,
0.6407870650291443,
-0.26925337314605713,
-0.20525529980659485,
-0.18272176384925842,
0.28945985436439514,
-0.23392288386821747,
0.48071953654289246,
0.12030578404664993,
0.872869610786438,
0.20226585865020752,
-0.684475302696228,
0.19409389793872833,
0.3872694969177246,
-0.22353649139404297,
0.6323502659797668,
-0.6907947063446045,
-0.021720515564084053,
0.10321977734565735,
-0.007353025954216719,
-0.9299423098564148,
-0.1344856321811676,
-0.08504423499107361,
-0.627001941204071,
-0.1789274960756302,
0.28506097197532654,
-0.40424954891204834,
0.0700325146317482,
-0.09934254735708237,
0.8233485817909241,
-0.0077041881158947945,
-0.1421656757593155,
0.4031349718570709,
0.6162449717521667,
-0.6936511993408203,
-0.4819639325141907,
-0.925271213054657,
0.3096926510334015,
-0.22622162103652954,
-1.0874308347702026,
0.22714613378047943,
0.38842278718948364,
-0.147706538438797,
0.32863399386405945,
-0.07988758385181427,
-0.1404130905866623,
0.1128346249461174,
0.312565416097641,
-0.01126613188534975,
-0.17628724873065948,
0.24612733721733093,
0.06397193670272827,
-0.16917309165000916,
-0.021218685433268547,
-0.2835044264793396,
0.47189003229141235,
-0.14655476808547974,
-0.2632743716239929,
0.10278813540935516,
0.6406922340393066,
0.1646677851676941,
-0.40296298265457153,
0.8862028121948242,
0.5601356029510498,
-0.48372408747673035,
0.06436597555875778,
-0.3818202018737793,
0.01877775974571705,
-0.36464330554008484,
0.219132661819458,
-0.8407814502716064,
-1.3590723276138306,
0.8252322673797607,
0.006673082709312439,
-0.05405111983418465,
0.7471611499786377,
0.740813672542572,
0.07817952334880829,
0.5851020216941833,
0.8052132725715637,
0.1381797045469284,
0.13023719191551208,
-0.01087714172899723,
0.17532777786254883,
-0.47667622566223145,
-0.33046823740005493,
-0.9532030820846558,
-0.10789156705141068,
-1.1655412912368774,
-0.5390102863311768,
0.23174919188022614,
-0.18130576610565186,
-0.08609611541032791,
0.8641263246536255,
-0.11027035117149353,
0.21692484617233276,
0.5202972888946533,
-0.2387063354253769,
0.30705446004867554,
0.15155084431171417,
-0.5263985991477966,
-0.2960011959075928,
-0.6296334266662598,
-0.809108555316925,
0.9107904434204102,
0.026721876114606857,
0.2727814018726349,
0.2677144706249237,
1.0887176990509033,
0.14171111583709717,
-0.3559933602809906,
-0.409756064414978,
0.6810003519058228,
-0.3194110691547394,
-0.5172086358070374,
-0.3867105543613434,
-0.15537020564079285,
-1.1907421350479126,
0.12730653584003448,
-0.02340938150882721,
-0.5582242608070374,
0.17404179275035858,
-0.47012901306152344,
0.12022770196199417,
-0.21402204036712646,
-0.3553432524204254,
0.8411564230918884,
-0.01701858825981617,
-0.4898311197757721,
-0.25040489435195923,
-1.0682294368743896,
0.06974277645349503,
-0.24584649503231049,
0.41161787509918213,
-0.3600671887397766,
-0.49702486395835876,
0.9310193061828613,
-0.7612236738204956,
0.4461771547794342,
0.3046838343143463,
-0.30287694931030273,
0.2802772521972656,
0.016296833753585815,
0.19417805969715118,
-0.1501885950565338,
-0.34602120518684387,
0.30705052614212036,
0.5584406852722168,
-0.7342380881309509,
-0.43178337812423706,
0.9521868824958801,
-0.7643747925758362,
-0.1259901225566864,
-0.6511334776878357,
-0.29567867517471313,
-0.2592785954475403,
0.5539994239807129,
0.3564060628414154,
0.5099082589149475,
-0.3493281900882721,
0.24285690486431122,
0.3809356093406677,
-0.22970683872699738,
0.48182007670402527,
0.30169734358787537,
-0.22701865434646606,
-0.423227459192276,
0.9608900547027588,
0.0700295940041542,
0.13683085143566132,
0.5931437611579895,
-0.29145729541778564,
-0.32909679412841797,
-0.3734125792980194,
-0.33439940214157104,
0.43211597204208374,
-0.6904184818267822,
-0.06029283627867699,
-0.8160898685455322,
-0.14994710683822632,
-0.4899674952030182,
-0.2711183726787567,
-0.0652313232421875,
-0.7422510981559753,
-0.06824927777051926,
-0.003532910253852606,
0.2907751798629761,
0.7133879661560059,
0.03789808973670006,
-0.13373537361621857,
-0.9934271574020386,
0.09753326326608658,
0.0032574860379099846,
0.25732898712158203,
-0.3541976809501648,
-0.4718923568725586,
-0.20396935939788818,
-0.050582949072122574,
0.001877788221463561,
-0.5990752577781677,
0.25071683526039124,
0.37235018610954285,
0.5923685431480408,
0.04375482350587845,
0.2753475308418274,
0.5274445414543152,
-0.6052731275558472,
0.8928893208503723,
-0.10415267199277878,
-0.8968067169189453,
0.8014149069786072,
-0.5701122879981995,
0.4012190103530884,
1.1586884260177612,
0.5101370811462402,
-0.6476569175720215,
-0.5292881727218628,
-0.5103915929794312,
-1.041506290435791,
0.6510180234909058,
0.6879138350486755,
0.122507743537426,
-0.09430614858865738,
0.040595393627882004,
0.31684452295303345,
0.10457810014486313,
-0.33808189630508423,
-0.28523048758506775,
-0.127400204539299,
-0.45497170090675354,
-0.15681929886341095,
-0.2658348083496094,
0.15741881728172302,
0.17037136852741241,
0.7871007919311523,
-0.13163796067237854,
0.2919273376464844,
0.36663204431533813,
-0.1544044017791748,
0.1381499469280243,
0.5592222809791565,
0.6486799120903015,
0.7735331654548645,
0.19149498641490936,
0.24536651372909546,
0.34083351492881775,
-0.6614125967025757,
0.26065972447395325,
0.1469579041004181,
-0.2907516062259674,
0.07915937155485153,
0.7090656161308289,
0.8614746928215027,
0.35714370012283325,
-0.4386674165725708,
0.48567086458206177,
-0.11792066693305969,
-0.24478714168071747,
-0.39801278710365295,
-0.38074663281440735,
0.2634385824203491,
-0.06009421497583389,
0.08703868836164474,
0.05634802579879761,
0.3230172395706177,
-0.7250539660453796,
0.3767385482788086,
0.07335133105516434,
-0.8077557682991028,
-0.49147504568099976,
0.5037096738815308,
0.5575439929962158,
0.03340686485171318,
0.06018870323896408,
-0.08360837399959564,
-0.8912502527236938,
0.6692021489143372,
0.4570425748825073,
0.6123567819595337,
-0.18790198862552643,
0.11944452673196793,
0.5311080813407898,
0.45144039392471313,
0.23200340569019318,
0.7179204225540161,
-0.04907292127609253,
-0.6467366814613342,
-0.447904109954834,
-0.7941464185714722,
-0.13961470127105713,
-0.2166677564382553,
-0.6425114870071411,
0.6009392142295837,
0.15176811814308167,
-0.00205704546533525,
0.1039784699678421,
0.30659621953964233,
-0.7336772084236145,
0.13926038146018982,
-0.045859064906835556,
0.7505713105201721,
-0.8654693365097046,
0.7191092371940613,
1.132637858390808,
-0.4363396167755127,
-0.910189151763916,
-0.21750006079673767,
0.15626567602157593,
-0.621939480304718,
0.622646689414978,
0.08802106231451035,
-0.05187453329563141,
-0.12185532599687576,
-0.1473643183708191,
-0.8433272838592529,
1.0956535339355469,
0.12439055740833282,
-0.44617050886154175,
0.133170023560524,
0.3862254321575165,
0.694573700428009,
-0.3179261088371277,
0.181635320186615,
0.549771249294281,
0.3869491219520569,
0.19420570135116577,
-1.232460618019104,
0.023342199623584747,
-0.4662845730781555,
-0.02742008864879608,
0.6798763275146484,
-0.8859378695487976,
0.40367165207862854,
0.1867751032114029,
-0.3145488202571869,
0.29916658997535706,
0.8116374611854553,
0.12404493242502213,
0.7112195491790771,
0.2959291338920593,
0.6805192828178406,
0.488277792930603,
-0.17903068661689758,
0.7870229482650757,
-0.4237012267112732,
0.07778134942054749,
1.1689586639404297,
-0.668072521686554,
0.8193973302841187,
0.5170759558677673,
-0.3020535707473755,
0.352029412984848,
0.6156095266342163,
0.4549821615219116,
0.43543267250061035,
-0.12307112663984299,
-0.29150500893592834,
-0.09807690232992172,
-0.703270435333252,
-0.6312493085861206,
0.6260440945625305,
0.3154509365558624,
-0.26981058716773987,
-0.23949190974235535,
0.12101580947637558,
0.08296692371368408,
0.45261847972869873,
-0.3500896990299225,
1.0057278871536255,
0.3068634271621704,
-0.8343416452407837,
0.2676856815814972,
-0.09430151432752609,
0.5804281234741211,
-0.6890749931335449,
-0.06631097942590714,
-0.17317622900009155,
0.0647674947977066,
-0.2539093792438507,
-0.8702574968338013,
0.6992495059967041,
-0.040249086916446686,
-0.13566213846206665,
0.05515867844223976,
1.0540214776992798,
-0.7169023156166077,
-0.483484148979187,
0.5548079609870911,
0.6074029207229614,
0.255650132894516,
0.2194707691669464,
-0.38838693499565125,
0.1680372655391693,
0.025736771523952484,
0.3249152898788452,
0.33954963088035583,
0.8994511961936951,
-0.5584962964057922,
0.4271634519100189,
0.3343372046947479,
0.09676489233970642,
0.15202294290065765,
0.05550750344991684,
0.6469403505325317,
-0.8827370405197144,
-0.5442356467247009,
-0.5806112289428711,
-0.2004542499780655,
0.09494824707508087,
-0.4168309271335602,
1.1972295045852661,
0.6355945467948914,
1.1684235334396362,
0.16846208274364471,
0.8738595247268677,
-0.11218347400426865,
0.7023037075996399,
-0.39228203892707825,
0.47259020805358887,
-0.6295282244682312,
0.14068710803985596,
-0.6138902306556702,
-1.3369427919387817,
-0.09724404662847519,
0.42323336005210876,
-0.2684464156627655,
-0.16684404015541077,
1.0561879873275757,
0.6019294857978821,
0.012481181882321835,
0.4413239657878876,
0.32530710101127625,
-0.11641479283571243,
-0.13747601211071014,
0.7123808264732361,
0.7311978340148926,
-0.8316233158111572,
0.5635332465171814,
-0.3296422064304352,
0.08148196339607239,
-0.04189373925328255,
-0.760754406452179,
-0.7345104813575745,
-1.051123023033142,
-0.14743855595588684,
-0.33343735337257385,
0.08589252084493637,
0.9387316107749939,
0.2577950060367584,
-1.1124216318130493,
-0.17334699630737305,
0.04774361476302147,
-0.0656721442937851,
0.011614249087870121,
-0.18928276002407074,
0.4318211078643799,
-0.07196131348609924,
-0.5786259174346924,
0.0724199116230011,
0.5694593787193298,
-0.14976488053798676,
0.04457086697220802,
-0.14379708468914032,
-0.6896212100982666,
0.09062191098928452,
0.7486221194267273,
0.0616702176630497,
-0.6053526997566223,
-0.4478716254234314,
0.1476370096206665,
-0.34851109981536865,
-0.41326409578323364,
0.7503457069396973,
-0.5666965246200562,
0.38474541902542114,
0.9205087423324585,
0.8246375322341919,
0.5061027407646179,
-0.04393848776817322,
0.5009360909461975,
-0.3720044195652008,
0.40621688961982727,
0.3286280333995819,
0.36121731996536255,
0.39685386419296265,
0.03660909831523895,
1.2311651706695557,
0.2727474868297577,
-0.9047120809555054,
-0.5626624822616577,
0.2613462209701538,
-0.9239380359649658,
0.05587964877486229,
1.1280975341796875,
-0.2874316871166229,
-0.37258273363113403,
-0.6202421188354492,
-0.17154386639595032,
0.22956421971321106,
-0.0742408037185669,
0.13160863518714905,
1.0692570209503174,
0.059022556990385056,
0.13766658306121826,
-0.5422122478485107,
0.3264561891555786,
0.6033864617347717,
-0.9149179458618164,
-0.38021084666252136,
0.32295531034469604,
0.12808620929718018,
0.22027786076068878,
0.7913416028022766,
-0.2426026612520218,
0.2864062786102295,
-0.037330493330955505,
-0.16076703369617462,
0.3330148458480835,
-0.15723440051078796,
-0.34087926149368286,
-0.12746644020080566,
-0.15652619302272797,
0.02441979944705963
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18932v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18932v1
|
Measuring Political Bias in Large Language Models: What Is Said and How It Is Said
| 2024-03-27T18:22:48 | 2024-03-27T18:22:48 |
Yejin Bang, Delong Chen, Nayeon Lee, Pascale Fung
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We propose to measure political bias in LLMs by analyzing both the content
and style of their generated content regarding political issues. Existing
benchmarks and measures focus on gender and racial biases. However, political
bias exists in LLMs and can lead to polarization and other harms in downstream
applications. In order to provide transparency to users, we advocate that there
should be fine-grained and explainable measures of political biases generated
by LLMs. Our proposed measure looks at different political issues such as
reproductive rights and climate change, at both the content (the substance of
the generation) and the style (the lexical polarity) of such bias. We measured
the political bias in eleven open-sourced LLMs and showed that our proposed
framework is easily scalable to other topics and is explainable.
|
[
-0.5492442846298218,
-0.8487960696220398,
0.6015612483024597,
0.1781894862651825,
-0.27815818786621094,
0.03055977262556553,
-0.5935263633728027,
-0.051685184240341187,
0.4928132891654968,
0.8267328143119812,
-0.5393267273902893,
-0.525212287902832,
-0.7937376499176025,
-0.2103891223669052,
-0.4715864956378937,
1.0418716669082642,
0.03887055069208145,
0.49991747736930847,
-0.26392537355422974,
-0.1542065143585205,
-0.29844987392425537,
-0.5627543330192566,
-0.3700169026851654,
-0.5528996586799622,
0.5219128727912903,
0.4681837260723114,
0.8420869708061218,
0.5708304643630981,
0.3920860290527344,
0.3002754747867584,
-0.6234395503997803,
-0.11502683162689209,
-0.649098813533783,
0.12914806604385376,
-0.6169751882553101,
-0.4946894645690918,
-0.44777196645736694,
0.3777810335159302,
0.7238759398460388,
0.6751815676689148,
0.033806346356868744,
0.3707515299320221,
0.11474139243364334,
0.8282538652420044,
-0.7128998637199402,
0.08796840161085129,
-0.9085604548454285,
0.00013755576219409704,
-0.40656420588493347,
-0.199043408036232,
-0.08174107223749161,
-0.3871617615222931,
-0.005637171678245068,
-0.12431337684392929,
0.26601356267929077,
0.09645974636077881,
0.3220020532608032,
-0.08271016925573349,
-0.637018084526062,
-0.5672247409820557,
-0.6024508476257324,
1.0788068771362305,
-0.9131835103034973,
0.44203808903694153,
0.2629390358924866,
0.15031036734580994,
-0.13738255202770233,
-0.2734162211418152,
-0.7619088888168335,
-0.2512834668159485,
0.08764675259590149,
0.059596527367830276,
-0.03655217960476875,
-0.11102031916379929,
0.12526214122772217,
0.5181790590286255,
-0.2434302717447281,
0.012016444467008114,
-0.03469859063625336,
-0.17656680941581726,
0.7596067786216736,
0.15553390979766846,
0.17767144739627838,
-0.43348732590675354,
-0.2747524380683899,
-0.030606497079133987,
-0.8155189752578735,
-0.3068695366382599,
1.0435348749160767,
0.33254560828208923,
-0.2173195332288742,
0.9033193588256836,
-0.012034140527248383,
0.37474504113197327,
-0.12162446230649948,
0.19280262291431427,
0.03255107253789902,
-0.787188708782196,
-0.03470119461417198,
-0.025505078956484795,
0.8392946124076843,
0.5564385652542114,
0.24751973152160645,
0.15449191629886627,
-0.15628129243850708,
-0.13472087681293488,
-0.04699680581688881,
-0.6998443603515625,
0.27405256032943726,
0.15772689878940582,
-0.5631580352783203,
-0.3129310607910156,
0.11454379558563232,
-1.2934621572494507,
-1.0503315925598145,
-0.39889925718307495,
-0.20947261154651642,
0.05423961579799652,
-0.6845335960388184,
-0.026412680745124817,
-0.17498408257961273,
0.24557726085186005,
0.1686636507511139,
-0.9519058465957642,
0.18239697813987732,
1.0441508293151855,
0.7856631875038147,
-0.49742668867111206,
0.03719773516058922,
-0.21833781898021698,
-0.19516147673130035,
-0.4250851571559906,
0.696662425994873,
-0.514744222164154,
-0.25940796732902527,
0.3068074584007263,
-0.1401224285364151,
0.2496679723262787,
-0.649965226650238,
0.3147740364074707,
-0.33896324038505554,
0.27313610911369324,
-0.7508088946342468,
-0.6008424162864685,
0.056328799575567245,
0.28172388672828674,
-0.576294481754303,
0.8359501957893372,
-0.12376362830400467,
-1.0469027757644653,
0.6221228837966919,
-0.6765986084938049,
-0.06256771832704544,
-0.3851783275604248,
-0.3084857165813446,
-0.43487268686294556,
0.1421511471271515,
-0.022290488705039024,
0.4005778729915619,
-0.5261176824569702,
0.7244099974632263,
-0.5578428506851196,
-0.002539736684411764,
0.5659487247467041,
-0.3581196963787079,
0.8691942691802979,
0.004305940121412277,
-0.4677446484565735,
0.657473623752594,
-0.6669350266456604,
-0.28408247232437134,
0.07626009732484818,
-0.2631394565105438,
-0.30847829580307007,
0.4181485176086426,
0.28436991572380066,
0.1027633473277092,
0.308050274848938,
-0.6489529609680176,
0.09723226726055145,
-0.2505514919757843,
0.5914885401725769,
0.9627494812011719,
-0.12856581807136536,
0.7412750124931335,
-0.14836327731609344,
0.3933172821998596,
0.0525851771235466,
0.010204698890447617,
0.2807636559009552,
-0.41067826747894287,
-0.7159608006477356,
-0.10626275092363358,
0.25260549783706665,
0.3564029335975647,
-0.35900169610977173,
0.3827216327190399,
-0.13346153497695923,
-0.382985383272171,
-0.16353055834770203,
0.23686832189559937,
0.06416817009449005,
0.16140612959861755,
0.02315855771303177,
-0.3087201714515686,
-0.41130590438842773,
-0.9576939344406128,
-0.7158729434013367,
-0.39185652136802673,
-0.11990547925233841,
0.4724169373512268,
0.8562484979629517,
-0.15444225072860718,
0.9026826024055481,
-0.18569183349609375,
-0.04845859110355377,
-0.17792481184005737,
0.2496667206287384,
0.08284135162830353,
0.1893259882926941,
0.41877368092536926,
-0.5662825703620911,
-0.0820157453417778,
-0.08847217261791229,
-0.36169013381004333,
-0.5498948693275452,
0.2282952219247818,
-0.24790528416633606,
0.12502874433994293,
0.43090516328811646,
-0.33037298917770386,
0.16745147109031677,
0.7590783834457397,
-0.7181581854820251,
0.47802481055259705,
0.250322163105011,
0.14026392996311188,
-1.0628907680511475,
-0.19952544569969177,
0.1863182932138443,
-0.3242492079734802,
-0.4020771384239197,
-0.10861723870038986,
-0.10851804912090302,
0.16093187034130096,
-0.730381965637207,
0.5071147084236145,
-0.30943235754966736,
-0.4368656575679779,
-0.40541818737983704,
0.395683616399765,
-0.03835372254252434,
-0.17921940982341766,
-0.018626803532242775,
0.7462643980979919,
0.35311996936798096,
-0.21944613754749298,
0.4160395860671997,
-0.039061449468135834,
-0.38645514845848083,
0.7559109330177307,
-0.44183671474456787,
0.20359638333320618,
-0.19982492923736572,
0.28084081411361694,
-0.9950792193412781,
-0.06682072579860687,
0.22283698618412018,
-0.25666648149490356,
-0.03526121377944946,
-0.15414594113826752,
-0.46732833981513977,
-0.08070175349712372,
-0.46853023767471313,
0.10648427903652191,
0.23493175208568573,
-0.3000352680683136,
0.4895133078098297,
0.695598840713501,
-0.06248854473233223,
-0.4028738737106323,
-0.5000317096710205,
0.03754653409123421,
-0.41926124691963196,
-0.6449538469314575,
0.05904703587293625,
-0.04886432737112045,
-0.7908567786216736,
0.032263755798339844,
0.0629458799958229,
-0.008757033385336399,
-0.04242807626724243,
0.11001584678888321,
-0.025587676092982292,
-0.4228566884994507,
0.08952534943819046,
-0.06819994002580643,
0.27582353353500366,
0.4530068635940552,
-0.01597360149025917,
0.8789895176887512,
0.02717539481818676,
-0.33825981616973877,
-0.1946772187948227,
0.410666286945343,
0.7924396991729736,
-0.1601705551147461,
0.9503940343856812,
0.4815749228000641,
-0.20033596456050873,
-0.1648516058921814,
-0.6541987061500549,
-0.17202873528003693,
-0.39786720275878906,
0.3046438992023468,
0.2700972557067871,
-0.9528663754463196,
0.8079150915145874,
-0.13631853461265564,
0.05341115593910217,
0.5206403732299805,
1.0639857053756714,
0.2546038329601288,
0.9656944870948792,
0.6770119667053223,
-0.11815064400434494,
0.49906206130981445,
-0.06600310653448105,
0.15965162217617035,
-0.6066272258758545,
-0.2553015947341919,
-0.7014559507369995,
-0.19333688914775848,
-0.959423840045929,
-0.38704943656921387,
-0.10044409334659576,
-0.10976769030094147,
-0.5429766178131104,
-0.27212703227996826,
-0.4068583548069,
0.4675159156322479,
0.614672839641571,
-0.12157216668128967,
0.12104150652885437,
0.025641171261668205,
0.03400511294603348,
-0.2942883372306824,
-0.3147425949573517,
-0.7034783959388733,
1.0715718269348145,
0.5380393266677856,
0.8732436299324036,
0.007873252034187317,
0.3360830545425415,
0.2742530107498169,
0.4785290062427521,
-0.7587350010871887,
0.5418221950531006,
-0.05333247780799866,
-0.8746989965438843,
-0.3067809045314789,
-0.4439455270767212,
-0.5355151891708374,
0.4018312990665436,
-0.2754984498023987,
-0.5542643070220947,
0.13492712378501892,
0.049236610531806946,
0.30955517292022705,
0.6632118225097656,
-0.22672922909259796,
0.7057842016220093,
-0.30403682589530945,
-0.43782010674476624,
-0.2694454491138458,
-0.12780866026878357,
0.43117544054985046,
-0.009888858534395695,
0.35180357098579407,
-0.46270447969436646,
-0.1775244176387787,
1.0733178853988647,
-0.409506618976593,
0.8532567620277405,
-0.16485542058944702,
-0.31760212779045105,
0.20957890152931213,
-0.16200098395347595,
0.15152262151241302,
0.14765140414237976,
-0.2699171304702759,
0.5716540217399597,
-0.14506453275680542,
-0.33988314867019653,
-0.2064785212278366,
0.9005277752876282,
-0.7849410772323608,
-0.6612670421600342,
-0.6613965630531311,
-0.720383882522583,
-0.12764059007167816,
0.0699765756726265,
0.12099330872297287,
-0.08349853754043579,
-0.399874746799469,
0.406976580619812,
0.5238710045814514,
-0.3673122525215149,
0.27295535802841187,
0.6092408895492554,
-0.4511815011501312,
-0.28066661953926086,
0.5855754017829895,
0.3602364957332611,
0.30724743008613586,
-0.053767163306474686,
0.7029041647911072,
-0.3114297389984131,
-0.4848170876502991,
-0.34180259704589844,
0.17432528734207153,
-0.5327538251876831,
0.0405370332300663,
-0.21790499985218048,
-0.11800489574670792,
-0.31674784421920776,
0.04356623440980911,
-0.5806232690811157,
-0.1381012201309204,
-0.38112035393714905,
0.008014907129108906,
0.33125072717666626,
0.9768660664558411,
0.05698876827955246,
0.43572989106178284,
-0.17403583228588104,
0.1931736171245575,
0.0987502932548523,
0.45601192116737366,
-0.3381122052669525,
-0.544454038143158,
0.13289472460746765,
0.15791597962379456,
-0.5419195294380188,
-1.1146172285079956,
0.3522903323173523,
-0.10534562170505524,
0.2534463107585907,
0.35819298028945923,
-0.02711033821105957,
0.14736543595790863,
-0.5807684659957886,
1.1890606880187988,
0.10990411043167114,
-1.0963103771209717,
0.6022074222564697,
-0.41053080558776855,
0.059134095907211304,
0.3113483488559723,
0.2788977324962616,
-0.37960413098335266,
-0.7462360858917236,
-0.41815003752708435,
-0.722173810005188,
0.48352283239364624,
0.1480034440755844,
0.5216457843780518,
-0.23851263523101807,
0.26709526777267456,
0.17103148996829987,
0.441283643245697,
-0.8191977739334106,
-0.4606994092464447,
-0.13370519876480103,
-0.040458932518959045,
-0.12118228524923325,
-0.64795982837677,
-0.4052715301513672,
-0.058866195380687714,
0.5749817490577698,
-0.06400462239980698,
0.007090904749929905,
0.05713748559355736,
0.1977146565914154,
-0.3475666344165802,
0.6475352048873901,
0.7106149792671204,
1.1432007551193237,
-0.1311129629611969,
0.2059120237827301,
-0.07761628180742264,
-0.4256718158721924,
0.08475491404533386,
-0.19669191539287567,
-0.3722914755344391,
0.2078435719013214,
0.2527923882007599,
0.6256781816482544,
-0.18609924614429474,
-0.42969459295272827,
0.6531367301940918,
0.05189784988760948,
-0.20701828598976135,
-0.3768455386161804,
-0.19925688207149506,
0.37697088718414307,
0.3358352780342102,
0.14104099571704865,
-0.3060305714607239,
0.07557101547718048,
-0.9354685544967651,
-0.09348296374082565,
0.9526678919792175,
-0.5140122175216675,
-0.23038209974765778,
0.6525888442993164,
0.3578411042690277,
-0.2523568570613861,
0.20088918507099152,
0.01860758662223816,
-0.5387080907821655,
0.5872515439987183,
0.5085790753364563,
0.6626374125480652,
-0.26015499234199524,
0.33122050762176514,
0.19480545818805695,
0.6018181443214417,
-0.010466944426298141,
0.4905111491680145,
0.3794145882129669,
-0.8213498592376709,
-0.3763542175292969,
-0.49758559465408325,
-0.6391077041625977,
0.5415488481521606,
-0.6861869096755981,
0.22237280011177063,
-0.44495078921318054,
-0.44279396533966064,
0.13937479257583618,
0.14366808533668518,
-0.43587180972099304,
-0.07772891223430634,
0.2971051037311554,
0.8380112648010254,
-1.2176154851913452,
0.29296112060546875,
0.5953124761581421,
-0.1080344095826149,
-0.14912129938602448,
0.07433295994997025,
0.37698203325271606,
-0.7630130052566528,
0.43584391474723816,
0.010380562394857407,
-0.08957229554653168,
-0.6778779029846191,
-0.7946849465370178,
-0.7186660170555115,
0.8002395033836365,
0.7263553142547607,
-0.6757521033287048,
0.348310261964798,
0.47470638155937195,
0.37368109822273254,
-0.5011125206947327,
0.23254716396331787,
0.6832202672958374,
0.6112498641014099,
-0.30509886145591736,
-0.7950435280799866,
-0.04335847124457359,
0.09112526476383209,
0.10324162244796753,
0.299501895904541,
-0.6958620548248291,
0.9135651588439941,
0.2829265594482422,
-0.14122164249420166,
-0.35130560398101807,
0.7042955756187439,
0.008714055642485619,
0.6427869200706482,
0.493308424949646,
0.21537846326828003,
0.7530577778816223,
-0.2620100975036621,
1.0632020235061646,
-0.4074772298336029,
0.46882903575897217,
0.8598055243492126,
-0.48496657609939575,
0.6092172861099243,
0.7120330929756165,
-0.17542578279972076,
0.24316145479679108,
0.5020429491996765,
0.26446953415870667,
0.1761729121208191,
0.8551962375640869,
-0.27208212018013,
-0.02047685533761978,
-0.6445966362953186,
-0.1984168440103531,
0.37583842873573303,
0.35305577516555786,
-0.609315037727356,
-0.051464345306158066,
-0.08129406720399857,
0.33765825629234314,
0.407178670167923,
-0.5451356172561646,
0.7784839868545532,
0.2106248438358307,
-0.5563016533851624,
0.11631288379430771,
-0.0022174017503857613,
0.7785571813583374,
-0.4299828112125397,
0.0782868042588234,
-0.17181392014026642,
-0.055888060480356216,
-0.31284084916114807,
-1.3084607124328613,
0.40767747163772583,
0.16814102232456207,
-0.3340054154396057,
-0.2558565139770508,
0.635733962059021,
-0.5529711246490479,
-0.5387051105499268,
0.475625216960907,
0.729733943939209,
0.07722970843315125,
-0.11700432002544403,
-0.7322598695755005,
0.6182616949081421,
-0.13150127232074738,
-0.5817490220069885,
0.3517380356788635,
0.3767780661582947,
-0.07321994751691818,
0.5671690702438354,
0.5691289305686951,
0.6018441915512085,
0.24761712551116943,
0.3277069628238678,
0.7223799228668213,
-0.5145396590232849,
-0.12663157284259796,
-1.0920294523239136,
0.18426132202148438,
-0.37180840969085693,
-0.3536127507686615,
0.8101116418838501,
0.5627412796020508,
0.7953659892082214,
0.3089319169521332,
0.7372697591781616,
0.07590103149414062,
0.4691702127456665,
-0.5275608897209167,
0.8789252638816833,
-0.28498923778533936,
0.17540058493614197,
-0.15771189332008362,
-1.2984519004821777,
-0.07264761626720428,
0.621296763420105,
-0.5718732476234436,
0.07922884821891785,
0.5162855982780457,
0.8240121603012085,
-0.07618824392557144,
-0.04236719757318497,
0.13217319548130035,
0.33227258920669556,
0.10998871177434921,
-0.13868167996406555,
0.9667301774024963,
0.09623115509748459,
0.11826705932617188,
-0.22683313488960266,
-0.2549636960029602,
-0.07549180835485458,
-1.1377538442611694,
-1.0040212869644165,
-0.5012867450714111,
-0.4261172115802765,
-0.54509437084198,
0.07771411538124084,
0.8497183322906494,
0.5818459391593933,
-0.8103775978088379,
-0.5801666975021362,
0.006461600307375193,
0.4609697163105011,
0.33169642090797424,
-0.2752266526222229,
0.21415910124778748,
-0.011613037437200546,
-0.710439920425415,
-0.0918908417224884,
0.1334841251373291,
-0.4134138226509094,
-0.8700342178344727,
0.1588030755519867,
-0.06793291866779327,
0.5087442994117737,
0.7308024168014526,
-0.07063253968954086,
-1.0109310150146484,
-0.6122378706932068,
-0.2562841475009918,
-0.13695178925991058,
-0.014365977607667446,
1.0702881813049316,
-0.07883679866790771,
0.4979326128959656,
0.7466261982917786,
0.27831944823265076,
0.15878549218177795,
-0.05710368603467941,
0.5673308372497559,
-0.44426143169403076,
-0.004808507394045591,
0.16406768560409546,
0.5402637124061584,
0.6316157579421997,
-0.16203022003173828,
0.3404468297958374,
0.03416222333908081,
-0.6820090413093567,
-0.8073057532310486,
0.42053893208503723,
-0.8420424461364746,
-0.04382115602493286,
1.5574754476547241,
0.1082664355635643,
-0.11262276023626328,
0.14547720551490784,
-0.21921563148498535,
0.13116642832756042,
-0.3738957345485687,
0.4891282320022583,
0.8772517442703247,
0.05496571213006973,
-0.11873937398195267,
-1.0135021209716797,
0.3084644377231598,
0.14285045862197876,
-0.7436648607254028,
0.2967143654823303,
0.5615123510360718,
0.4906911253929138,
0.11006493121385574,
0.6184262037277222,
-0.35432255268096924,
-0.10712859034538269,
-0.3435021638870239,
0.054798200726509094,
0.4342285990715027,
0.040660418570041656,
-0.39241963624954224,
-0.09129305928945541,
0.06344480812549591,
0.19667737185955048
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10636v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10636v2
|
What are human values, and how do we align AI to them?
| 2024-03-27T18:12:02 | 2024-04-17T16:27:37 |
Oliver Klingefjord, Ryan Lowe, Joe Edelman
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.LG
|
There is an emerging consensus that we need to align AI systems with human
values (Gabriel, 2020; Ji et al., 2024), but it remains unclear how to apply
this to language models in practice. We split the problem of "aligning to human
values" into three parts: first, eliciting values from people; second,
reconciling those values into an alignment target for training ML models; and
third, actually training the model. In this paper, we focus on the first two
parts, and ask the question: what are "good" ways to synthesize diverse human
inputs about values into a target for aligning language models? To answer this
question, we first define a set of 6 criteria that we believe must be satisfied
for an alignment target to shape model behavior in accordance with human
values. We then propose a process for eliciting and reconciling values called
Moral Graph Elicitation (MGE), which uses a large language model to interview
participants about their values in particular contexts; our approach is
inspired by the philosophy of values advanced by Taylor (1977), Chang (2004),
and others. We trial MGE with a representative sample of 500 Americans, on 3
intentionally divisive prompts (e.g. advice about abortion). Our results
demonstrate that MGE is promising for improving model alignment across all 6
criteria. For example, almost all participants (89.1%) felt well represented by
the process, and (89%) thought the final moral graph was fair, even if their
value wasn't voted as the wisest. Our process often results in "expert" values
(e.g. values from women who have solicited abortion advice) rising to the top
of the moral graph, without defining who is considered an expert in advance.
|
[
-0.461847722530365,
-0.4635571241378784,
0.46893638372421265,
-0.25934526324272156,
-0.06999348104000092,
0.12944979965686798,
0.03275405988097191,
-0.5006116032600403,
-0.05580796301364899,
0.12501031160354614,
-0.43028923869132996,
-0.1718466430902481,
-0.530546247959137,
-0.1552022099494934,
-0.06061411276459694,
1.19649076461792,
0.16858211159706116,
0.2682531774044037,
-0.008563761599361897,
-0.5440979599952698,
-0.4936286211013794,
-0.6684859395027161,
-0.6893150806427002,
-0.5268207788467407,
0.608697772026062,
0.3210955560207367,
1.0182970762252808,
0.929286003112793,
0.35532400012016296,
0.2951973080635071,
-0.18044184148311615,
0.07417923212051392,
-0.5850499868392944,
-0.15672233700752258,
-0.40460625290870667,
-0.21613730490207672,
-0.5835065841674805,
0.8351677656173706,
0.2932433485984802,
0.947658896446228,
-0.07401260733604431,
0.3821808099746704,
0.1551957130432129,
0.8137311935424805,
-0.5095308423042297,
-0.08059895783662796,
-0.4663776159286499,
0.07134407013654709,
0.10573756694793701,
0.09775589406490326,
-0.2869791090488434,
-0.7919887900352478,
0.25723597407341003,
-0.35334381461143494,
-0.026301225647330284,
0.17250610888004303,
1.2601361274719238,
0.3546718955039978,
-0.5370848774909973,
-0.33663102984428406,
-0.46592164039611816,
1.071717381477356,
-0.5259475111961365,
0.11541718244552612,
0.3758123517036438,
0.19469952583312988,
-0.06884243339300156,
-0.2886815369129181,
-0.6917539834976196,
0.05486038327217102,
-0.07258827984333038,
0.006675167009234428,
-0.08005804568529129,
0.11106110364198685,
0.24820661544799805,
0.10333245247602463,
-0.19543801248073578,
0.2151111215353012,
-0.3717542290687561,
-0.130058154463768,
0.8498091697692871,
0.2355543076992035,
0.42669710516929626,
0.02604534476995468,
-0.30846577882766724,
-0.3772234320640564,
-0.5568878650665283,
0.520515501499176,
0.878156304359436,
0.4699426293373108,
0.15252147614955902,
0.7083060145378113,
0.24542710185050964,
0.7383756637573242,
0.5297213792800903,
-0.02342773601412773,
0.1916765421628952,
-0.5544164180755615,
0.04329182952642441,
0.17930753529071808,
0.7390356659889221,
0.7472490072250366,
0.8992061614990234,
0.18558897078037262,
-0.24479447305202484,
0.3115922212600708,
0.5990470051765442,
-0.820338249206543,
0.13638931512832642,
0.20832546055316925,
-0.5440203547477722,
-0.5202821493148804,
-0.04693939536809921,
-0.6217119693756104,
-0.39017024636268616,
-0.6789841651916504,
0.22005505859851837,
-0.2627045512199402,
-0.08327863365411758,
-0.10208562761545181,
-0.14912180602550507,
0.39598777890205383,
0.303467333316803,
-1.427132248878479,
0.2969103455543518,
0.6408933997154236,
0.39528587460517883,
0.0127557422965765,
-0.35161495208740234,
-0.6321352124214172,
-0.09199409186840057,
-0.3913530707359314,
0.6822574734687805,
-0.5156077742576599,
-0.24712030589580536,
-0.3234550654888153,
-0.2738327383995056,
0.1752183884382248,
-0.3770579695701599,
0.39817455410957336,
-0.2262054979801178,
0.47888338565826416,
-0.6360279321670532,
-0.7268916368484497,
-0.1278282254934311,
0.27449581027030945,
-0.5920230150222778,
0.8698545694351196,
0.1386258751153946,
-0.4906943440437317,
0.43577098846435547,
-0.8143007159233093,
-0.29596659541130066,
-0.173042893409729,
-0.3496103286743164,
-0.40005600452423096,
-0.18333543837070465,
0.20311899483203888,
0.3267652690410614,
-0.29380667209625244,
0.4584212899208069,
-0.27972280979156494,
-0.34193554520606995,
0.44871577620506287,
-0.5177825093269348,
1.1610780954360962,
0.18548694252967834,
-0.366995632648468,
0.2037799060344696,
-0.1597679853439331,
0.33198851346969604,
0.061127904802560806,
-0.1564517617225647,
-0.017377814278006554,
0.10486375540494919,
-0.15805470943450928,
0.2523595094680786,
0.12894150614738464,
-0.3428328037261963,
0.2211528867483139,
-0.49448779225349426,
0.4674554169178009,
1.035352110862732,
-0.15679782629013062,
0.7684730887413025,
-0.5466880202293396,
0.3046666383743286,
-0.18227079510688782,
0.22765257954597473,
0.2136426568031311,
-0.6438469886779785,
-0.4855196475982666,
-0.06406250596046448,
0.15521623194217682,
0.7500871419906616,
0.13001307845115662,
0.8338937163352966,
-0.08641763776540756,
-0.3392919898033142,
-1.0592154264450073,
0.04432031512260437,
0.3499932885169983,
0.7290304899215698,
0.36515212059020996,
-0.14716990292072296,
-0.3446941375732422,
-0.9653295278549194,
-0.31445932388305664,
-0.6503324508666992,
-0.10124637186527252,
0.19008035957813263,
0.4008188247680664,
0.10216667503118515,
1.2420953512191772,
-0.4887801706790924,
0.12847572565078735,
0.025765597820281982,
0.3525228500366211,
0.13650746643543243,
0.5082027316093445,
0.43230512738227844,
-0.9703713655471802,
-0.41235241293907166,
0.0726979523897171,
-0.6622863411903381,
-0.2298206239938736,
0.14209875464439392,
-0.2668209671974182,
-0.08449355512857437,
0.15833128988742828,
-0.19395865499973297,
0.3704562485218048,
0.4031606614589691,
-0.4956374764442444,
0.22035948932170868,
0.08579368889331818,
0.5574104189872742,
-1.1940016746520996,
0.25699764490127563,
0.002662027021870017,
-0.23024797439575195,
-0.6599323749542236,
-0.2815384864807129,
-0.1765911728143692,
-0.14817006886005402,
-0.5396028161048889,
0.8481597900390625,
-0.20021232962608337,
-0.08943962305784225,
-0.26055851578712463,
0.27343520522117615,
0.12257421761751175,
0.40647023916244507,
-0.29173940420150757,
0.9242025017738342,
-0.01782803423702717,
-0.4354005753993988,
0.48329874873161316,
0.40468552708625793,
-0.11348345875740051,
1.2833495140075684,
-0.5765122175216675,
0.27206921577453613,
-0.49643999338150024,
-0.06337754428386688,
-0.8502426743507385,
-0.002962383208796382,
0.37266671657562256,
-0.6473837494850159,
-0.10308192670345306,
-0.26640796661376953,
-0.09784332662820816,
-0.19390912353992462,
-0.03917192295193672,
0.5710462331771851,
0.8011408448219299,
-0.2600642144680023,
0.5561767220497131,
0.9086678624153137,
-0.25598400831222534,
-0.8424752354621887,
-0.3572312295436859,
0.029953662306070328,
-0.4034126102924347,
-0.7134842872619629,
0.3306519389152527,
-0.23867034912109375,
-0.44706371426582336,
0.2442186176776886,
0.31624165177345276,
-0.11785047501325607,
0.12070377171039581,
0.11802442371845245,
0.36728838086128235,
-0.13004781305789948,
0.18211166560649872,
-0.09411527961492538,
-0.528570294380188,
-0.1716344803571701,
-0.3466532528400421,
0.24645113945007324,
-0.5915486812591553,
-0.5411777496337891,
-0.4928685426712036,
0.4633050560951233,
0.4777044653892517,
-0.36437252163887024,
0.5670920014381409,
0.5377602577209473,
-0.5519379377365112,
0.24108341336250305,
-0.51228928565979,
-0.21282505989074707,
-0.44444021582603455,
0.2344510704278946,
0.14537088572978973,
-0.8207738995552063,
0.4874187707901001,
0.18074914813041687,
0.26284059882164,
0.28109538555145264,
0.6855772137641907,
-0.4846242666244507,
1.4480600357055664,
0.5779150724411011,
-0.2208302617073059,
0.484185129404068,
0.04961017891764641,
0.4468383491039276,
-0.6678910851478577,
-0.03818805143237114,
-0.48835211992263794,
-0.734103262424469,
-0.47110673785209656,
-0.24008063971996307,
0.26350221037864685,
0.30073282122612,
-0.6702426075935364,
0.2602559030056,
-0.8344143033027649,
0.6129931807518005,
0.5225154161453247,
-0.1226135790348053,
-0.07194336503744125,
-0.2872953414916992,
0.03930336982011795,
-0.10367706418037415,
-0.4394262135028839,
-1.0469684600830078,
0.7071858644485474,
0.20762215554714203,
0.6382232308387756,
0.007168861106038094,
0.5454573035240173,
0.13202114403247833,
0.724139928817749,
-0.8558064699172974,
0.4483432173728943,
0.0465288907289505,
-0.8324925899505615,
-0.647175133228302,
-0.3498874306678772,
-1.1200097799301147,
0.22410203516483307,
-0.29648977518081665,
-0.7590749263763428,
0.12740148603916168,
0.36830899119377136,
-0.5604661703109741,
0.14369294047355652,
-0.7983423471450806,
1.1890898942947388,
-0.6273728013038635,
-0.08604869991540909,
-0.1511199027299881,
-0.8791050314903259,
-0.002305936301127076,
0.178023099899292,
0.03238200023770332,
-0.6193271279335022,
0.14509913325309753,
0.5913876891136169,
-0.1978362649679184,
0.904587984085083,
-0.16313491761684418,
0.09826154261827469,
0.4225739538669586,
-0.3529866635799408,
0.3867487907409668,
-0.2900991439819336,
-0.253878116607666,
0.023198481649160385,
0.035042956471443176,
-0.5826053619384766,
-0.7156323194503784,
0.1295977383852005,
-0.9282103180885315,
-0.5498691201210022,
-0.3006918728351593,
-0.5702133774757385,
0.019263118505477905,
0.33377787470817566,
0.07024981826543808,
0.0780470073223114,
-0.5594232678413391,
-0.15672342479228973,
0.4192352294921875,
-0.06372625380754471,
0.21167759597301483,
0.15092314779758453,
-0.10268092900514603,
-0.6241682171821594,
0.8290650248527527,
0.059997085481882095,
0.5643657445907593,
0.10082298517227173,
0.35084056854248047,
-0.3819568157196045,
-0.03859882801771164,
-0.5935441851615906,
0.2228306531906128,
-0.9174306392669678,
-0.01758996956050396,
-0.3579217791557312,
-0.22874478995800018,
-0.25644102692604065,
-0.6756853461265564,
-0.43297335505485535,
-0.07051882147789001,
-0.5461050868034363,
-0.30749496817588806,
0.1914573758840561,
0.654910683631897,
0.1407323181629181,
-0.02382328361272812,
-0.8820410370826721,
0.24069775640964508,
0.43006226420402527,
0.14319860935211182,
-0.12134623527526855,
-0.2697910964488983,
-0.007540554739534855,
0.6144916415214539,
-0.3138313591480255,
-0.8509436249732971,
0.21697790920734406,
-0.1910347044467926,
0.6829548478126526,
0.407018780708313,
0.0588434599339962,
0.8683232665061951,
-0.4782363474369049,
0.6660078167915344,
0.19133181869983673,
-1.1936707496643066,
0.4554678201675415,
-0.1323419064283371,
-0.08894801884889603,
0.9309189319610596,
0.2900502383708954,
-0.842323899269104,
-0.2603312134742737,
-0.485928475856781,
-0.45853009819984436,
0.39140769839286804,
0.3307649791240692,
0.360215425491333,
-0.03923569247126579,
0.5184053182601929,
-0.17482422292232513,
0.1920146644115448,
-0.7975310683250427,
-0.05518539622426033,
-0.3531823754310608,
-0.8660126328468323,
0.1879202127456665,
0.2236565500497818,
-0.3808537721633911,
-0.295789897441864,
0.2928110957145691,
-0.4190526008605957,
0.04392426833510399,
-0.07936180382966995,
0.08772394806146622,
-0.4404769539833069,
0.27426931262016296,
0.5072619915008545,
0.7921726107597351,
-0.04187428951263428,
0.12194573134183884,
0.21224461495876312,
-0.08688444644212723,
0.7588326334953308,
-0.03825009614229202,
-0.12822316586971283,
-0.7035786509513855,
0.1528785228729248,
0.755556046962738,
-0.11301246285438538,
-0.5428187847137451,
0.6898789405822754,
0.07974144071340561,
0.07571495324373245,
-0.06364817172288895,
0.2400560975074768,
0.16912341117858887,
0.2240149974822998,
0.08947283774614334,
-0.016347087919712067,
-0.21058841049671173,
-0.5760301351547241,
0.09316498041152954,
0.6413325071334839,
-0.6273979544639587,
-0.36267977952957153,
0.6913732886314392,
0.48483988642692566,
-0.6544167399406433,
1.1018762588500977,
-0.32246071100234985,
-0.6571130156517029,
0.6660069823265076,
0.274463951587677,
0.7472286820411682,
-0.34455639123916626,
0.20231600105762482,
0.40443629026412964,
0.3299640417098999,
-0.11156781762838364,
0.25601357221603394,
0.3188180923461914,
-1.3307733535766602,
-0.4771856665611267,
-0.4197182059288025,
-0.47400087118148804,
-0.49470582604408264,
-0.7639036774635315,
0.3807688057422638,
-0.037398528307676315,
-0.33751294016838074,
0.06787814944982529,
0.004429280292242765,
-0.5179376602172852,
0.24218209087848663,
0.14335305988788605,
0.31600046157836914,
-1.0879759788513184,
0.571429967880249,
0.5594790577888489,
-0.6829903721809387,
-1.0230176448822021,
-0.26013052463531494,
0.23512619733810425,
-0.901439368724823,
0.486855685710907,
0.27679961919784546,
-0.2796977162361145,
0.21350237727165222,
-0.5933001637458801,
-0.8223289251327515,
1.0111451148986816,
0.500029981136322,
-0.09951244294643402,
-0.11320414394140244,
0.1918010413646698,
0.4900832176208496,
-0.6701348423957825,
0.18802271783351898,
0.5159790515899658,
0.8169214725494385,
0.021114280447363853,
-0.7266775369644165,
-0.021926485002040863,
-0.40272074937820435,
-0.09306381642818451,
0.3876197338104248,
-0.3681333363056183,
0.7052174210548401,
-0.537206768989563,
-0.33778709173202515,
-0.10778047889471054,
0.4399365782737732,
0.2408098429441452,
0.1928805559873581,
0.7688976526260376,
0.48699796199798584,
1.2589473724365234,
0.01405902486294508,
0.892081618309021,
-0.25907397270202637,
0.23837217688560486,
0.7603743076324463,
-0.45221659541130066,
0.5038565993309021,
0.438441663980484,
-0.17068298161029816,
0.2638215720653534,
0.810763418674469,
-0.1681947112083435,
0.1832248866558075,
0.041015420109033585,
-0.03157797455787659,
-0.23516219854354858,
-0.23736800253391266,
-0.06283150613307953,
0.4353349208831787,
0.22760148346424103,
-0.24519450962543488,
0.08993164449930191,
-0.2509268522262573,
0.11851685494184494,
0.1451391577720642,
0.037816036492586136,
0.898001492023468,
0.01747678779065609,
-1.0301514863967896,
0.38751235604286194,
-0.14310553669929504,
0.0610990934073925,
-0.3585016429424286,
-0.23592321574687958,
0.03265708312392235,
-0.026225663721561432,
-0.03765816614031792,
-1.19741952419281,
0.26497504115104675,
0.09752834588289261,
-0.44179993867874146,
-0.5609751343727112,
0.2249896228313446,
-0.6094151735305786,
-0.3207200765609741,
0.12412144243717194,
0.3681771159172058,
0.14756228029727936,
0.23692919313907623,
-0.7999846339225769,
-0.2590281069278717,
0.053838588297367096,
0.07600808888673782,
0.26254090666770935,
0.2616894841194153,
-0.19785110652446747,
0.532313346862793,
0.7604620456695557,
-0.05349869653582573,
-0.36063674092292786,
0.04334632679820061,
0.652029812335968,
-0.9330572485923767,
-0.4901110529899597,
-1.077143907546997,
1.0018397569656372,
-0.1671002209186554,
-0.5728793740272522,
0.2687225043773651,
0.21506312489509583,
0.7387458086013794,
0.515946626663208,
0.6911015510559082,
0.13517434895038605,
0.2419888824224472,
-0.40681979060173035,
0.7239487171173096,
-0.22658143937587738,
-0.02337305061519146,
-0.26067203283309937,
-0.8929768800735474,
-0.11305448412895203,
0.9097043871879578,
-0.18214434385299683,
0.29825928807258606,
0.43216076493263245,
0.8341466188430786,
0.21859990060329437,
-0.06679603457450867,
0.1917712688446045,
-0.20452408492565155,
0.5844106674194336,
0.3972766399383545,
1.0571720600128174,
-0.17789754271507263,
0.4358820915222168,
0.0784514844417572,
-0.3808813989162445,
-0.11596189439296722,
-1.0656390190124512,
-0.5044002532958984,
-0.583716630935669,
-0.14051726460456848,
-0.3807677924633026,
-0.06394530832767487,
1.3678933382034302,
0.8424365520477295,
-0.7061811089515686,
-0.43199294805526733,
0.04638427868485451,
0.34602126479148865,
-0.3633180856704712,
-0.11193952709436417,
0.2267543375492096,
-0.24935588240623474,
-0.8973008990287781,
0.018746672198176384,
0.39292821288108826,
0.33058610558509827,
-0.17828738689422607,
-0.26898378133773804,
-0.13907331228256226,
0.3028165102005005,
0.3244664967060089,
0.24568556249141693,
-0.8661738038063049,
-0.7905702590942383,
0.043818410485982895,
-0.5808793902397156,
0.3741905689239502,
0.7018781900405884,
-0.4557918608188629,
0.5570654273033142,
0.31864064931869507,
0.6798726320266724,
0.004822786431759596,
0.5544590353965759,
0.8505948185920715,
-0.36729931831359863,
-0.11908524483442307,
0.6139862537384033,
0.3005102574825287,
0.37640875577926636,
-0.4195282757282257,
0.45195794105529785,
-0.009171070531010628,
-0.8271563649177551,
-0.6749314069747925,
0.565676748752594,
-0.742094099521637,
-0.14061971008777618,
0.6864615082740784,
0.07768081873655319,
-0.12311427295207977,
-0.1366116851568222,
-0.41576987504959106,
0.42770761251449585,
-0.22438807785511017,
0.7983296513557434,
0.7624614238739014,
-0.3131861984729767,
0.06857620179653168,
-0.33183860778808594,
0.3590472936630249,
0.37448981404304504,
-0.9926420450210571,
0.0256669782102108,
0.5764437913894653,
0.07931133359670639,
0.2842237651348114,
0.667901873588562,
-0.08924926072359085,
0.24313873052597046,
-0.30014970898628235,
0.40813395380973816,
0.2156800925731659,
0.00391266867518425,
-0.24246113002300262,
-0.03633755072951317,
0.12765838205814362,
-0.02213384211063385
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18814v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18814v1
|
Mini-Gemini: Mining the Potential of Multi-modality Vision Language Models
| 2024-03-27T17:59:04 | 2024-03-27T17:59:04 |
Yanwei Li, Yuechen Zhang, Chengyao Wang, Zhisheng Zhong, Yixin Chen, Ruihang Chu, Shaoteng Liu, Jiaya Jia
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
In this work, we introduce Mini-Gemini, a simple and effective framework
enhancing multi-modality Vision Language Models (VLMs). Despite the
advancements in VLMs facilitating basic visual dialog and reasoning, a
performance gap persists compared to advanced models like GPT-4 and Gemini. We
try to narrow the gap by mining the potential of VLMs for better performance
and any-to-any workflow from three aspects, i.e., high-resolution visual
tokens, high-quality data, and VLM-guided generation. To enhance visual tokens,
we propose to utilize an additional visual encoder for high-resolution
refinement without increasing the visual token count. We further construct a
high-quality dataset that promotes precise image comprehension and
reasoning-based generation, expanding the operational scope of current VLMs. In
general, Mini-Gemini further mines the potential of VLMs and empowers current
frameworks with image understanding, reasoning, and generation simultaneously.
Mini-Gemini supports a series of dense and MoE Large Language Models (LLMs)
from 2B to 34B. It is demonstrated to achieve leading performance in several
zero-shot benchmarks and even surpasses the developed private models. Code and
models are available at https://github.com/dvlab-research/MiniGemini.
|
[
-0.31901052594184875,
-0.4253295958042145,
0.5390517711639404,
-0.13030411303043365,
-0.32462820410728455,
-0.1968061923980713,
-0.06684119999408722,
-0.5584005117416382,
0.2099771350622177,
0.6563459634780884,
-0.6756839752197266,
-0.5429096221923828,
-0.40444937348365784,
-0.07006092369556427,
-0.39362144470214844,
0.6050290465354919,
0.3778834044933319,
0.22110356390476227,
-0.2943488657474518,
-0.19349032640457153,
-0.5204300880432129,
-0.3800239861011505,
-0.49471402168273926,
0.007086340803653002,
0.5242278575897217,
0.5063478350639343,
0.7369622588157654,
0.9243017435073853,
0.5141039490699768,
0.271785706281662,
-0.06323577463626862,
0.19464878737926483,
-0.23596426844596863,
-0.04329569637775421,
0.0325147919356823,
-0.5583522915840149,
-0.4504675567150116,
-0.3176839053630829,
0.4956803321838379,
0.43968573212623596,
-0.18723928928375244,
0.32230767607688904,
-0.22264063358306885,
0.558959424495697,
-0.46081727743148804,
0.49537166953086853,
-0.8504219651222229,
-0.18185922503471375,
-0.48237717151641846,
0.10082493722438812,
-0.21386116743087769,
0.2568698227405548,
0.15460629761219025,
-0.5105904936790466,
0.2457839846611023,
0.3034401834011078,
0.7602048516273499,
0.47977134585380554,
-0.3611132800579071,
-0.19814269244670868,
-0.32439181208610535,
0.7601452469825745,
-0.5564762949943542,
0.39266520738601685,
0.10325226932764053,
0.4737110137939453,
0.17198729515075684,
-0.9726687669754028,
-0.7284508347511292,
-0.44703760743141174,
-0.18571431934833527,
0.12056007981300354,
-0.14058053493499756,
0.23916380107402802,
0.38527700304985046,
0.3658551871776581,
-0.4010070562362671,
-0.10094562917947769,
-0.4768884778022766,
-0.25756269693374634,
0.1661304086446762,
0.5575512647628784,
0.10595617443323135,
-0.5516700148582458,
-0.14932172000408173,
-0.0017678249860182405,
-0.6394414901733398,
0.18282349407672882,
0.17709854245185852,
0.2482830286026001,
-0.10384595394134521,
0.9214896559715271,
-0.21990278363227844,
1.053015947341919,
-0.24935849010944366,
-0.13378413021564484,
0.1423470675945282,
-0.780846893787384,
-0.4122878909111023,
-0.4465828835964203,
0.6022982597351074,
0.27869635820388794,
0.018340248614549637,
0.3507736027240753,
-0.24306620657444,
0.3647794723510742,
0.16787675023078918,
-0.7122878432273865,
-0.31285393238067627,
-0.1285800337791443,
-0.7682369351387024,
-0.5138489007949829,
0.001237744465470314,
-0.655418872833252,
-0.4557129144668579,
-0.568764328956604,
0.391914427280426,
-0.4455417990684509,
-0.3074686527252197,
0.010545846074819565,
-0.32336363196372986,
0.2291429191827774,
0.3683110475540161,
-0.8873815536499023,
0.16555005311965942,
0.6503629088401794,
0.6804038286209106,
0.07157250493764877,
-0.27162933349609375,
-0.5954451560974121,
0.09484098851680756,
-0.28109878301620483,
0.5362485647201538,
-0.7610772848129272,
-0.29518014192581177,
-0.12736643850803375,
-0.31559163331985474,
-0.06112029030919075,
-0.690448522567749,
0.33793020248413086,
-0.20283854007720947,
0.23962028324604034,
-0.16780178248882294,
-0.1352977752685547,
-0.01955406367778778,
0.37732386589050293,
-0.6982418894767761,
1.0796172618865967,
0.13182014226913452,
-0.8000903129577637,
0.44025635719299316,
-0.8388715386390686,
-0.2415911853313446,
0.12675422430038452,
-0.6094000935554504,
-0.19952836632728577,
0.4790145456790924,
0.2720288038253784,
0.15223869681358337,
-0.47811147570610046,
-0.004602632485330105,
-0.3088397979736328,
-0.41463854908943176,
0.10938230901956558,
-0.41871723532676697,
0.5299696922302246,
0.20941756665706635,
-0.20364883542060852,
0.4914800524711609,
-0.8105984926223755,
-0.030871951952576637,
-0.051441166549921036,
-0.24233004450798035,
-0.33178335428237915,
-0.07527467608451843,
0.10368381440639496,
0.4809620976448059,
0.2963113486766815,
-0.5136885046958923,
0.18870049715042114,
-0.4235844314098358,
0.3067678213119507,
0.7209652662277222,
-0.40128210186958313,
0.3855351507663727,
-0.09972579777240753,
0.4459501802921295,
0.38683637976646423,
0.7663277983665466,
-0.5827171802520752,
-0.7274559736251831,
-1.2563515901565552,
-0.6651607751846313,
0.36518430709838867,
0.44936755299568176,
-1.4700263738632202,
0.05238955095410347,
-0.26737895607948303,
-0.3134555220603943,
-0.8813981413841248,
0.19439654052257538,
0.40768957138061523,
0.5971079468727112,
0.22377941012382507,
-0.44862794876098633,
-0.6552107930183411,
-1.0873453617095947,
-0.1153610423207283,
-0.3515629470348358,
0.11801403760910034,
0.5498297810554504,
0.4381752908229828,
-0.45340800285339355,
1.0747864246368408,
-0.29082778096199036,
-0.26131173968315125,
-0.31785091757774353,
-0.0640411302447319,
0.4584035277366638,
0.18815314769744873,
0.7004364728927612,
-0.8911802768707275,
-0.49464496970176697,
-0.06462673097848892,
-0.7784580588340759,
-0.027388492599129677,
0.02610063925385475,
-0.05822260305285454,
0.33573484420776367,
0.5631491541862488,
-0.6661362648010254,
0.6737408638000488,
0.6859303116798401,
-0.4703528881072998,
0.46982118487358093,
-0.1657070368528366,
-0.06825879961252213,
-0.8717777132987976,
0.04250563681125641,
-0.0064285616390407085,
-0.42561623454093933,
-0.5829789042472839,
0.09305524826049805,
0.10526800155639648,
-0.10824599117040634,
-0.599130392074585,
0.554840087890625,
-0.4225505292415619,
-0.1491461545228958,
-0.4044426381587982,
-0.1382472813129425,
-0.24548311531543732,
0.34506967663764954,
0.11505533754825592,
0.5475648045539856,
1.1282294988632202,
-0.401138037443161,
0.5273312330245972,
-0.05312539264559746,
-0.23254604637622833,
0.5899084210395813,
-0.5473470687866211,
-0.21141839027404785,
-0.2939774990081787,
-0.04714857041835785,
-0.7603266835212708,
-0.11568379402160645,
0.30690616369247437,
-0.43571585416793823,
0.21038857102394104,
-0.46694013476371765,
-0.62141352891922,
-0.5157924294471741,
-0.40912702679634094,
0.19942954182624817,
0.5651073455810547,
-0.6248618364334106,
0.9297896027565002,
0.28174111247062683,
-0.04975418746471405,
-0.6590226888656616,
-0.5045462250709534,
0.34539785981178284,
-0.050966084003448486,
-0.8244627118110657,
0.25155845284461975,
-0.0950295552611351,
-0.1823902577161789,
0.20507606863975525,
0.010326547548174858,
0.33204400539398193,
-0.22000353038311005,
0.3961278796195984,
0.6300075650215149,
-0.21664677560329437,
-0.04819612577557564,
-0.11185979843139648,
-0.45972940325737,
-0.2675783634185791,
-0.44775962829589844,
0.5419538021087646,
-0.5428054332733154,
-0.36236003041267395,
-0.17909665405750275,
0.30856966972351074,
0.7998560667037964,
-0.23389755189418793,
0.7047280073165894,
0.8406055569648743,
-0.4120261073112488,
0.04045524448156357,
-0.4555995464324951,
-0.18742209672927856,
-0.49973174929618835,
0.29878100752830505,
-0.6326608061790466,
-0.8744120001792908,
0.26966625452041626,
0.08147464692592621,
-0.08149703592061996,
0.5000478625297546,
0.769300639629364,
-0.23825247585773468,
1.194264531135559,
1.1468256711959839,
0.11576718091964722,
0.8769294619560242,
-0.35483917593955994,
-0.10187959671020508,
-0.7355260848999023,
-0.25690242648124695,
-0.08346658945083618,
-0.11639293283224106,
-0.49414098262786865,
-0.7659510374069214,
0.5006684064865112,
-0.09205783903598785,
0.05487054958939552,
0.21232348680496216,
-0.21752558648586273,
0.4516347646713257,
0.9076322913169861,
-0.11597702652215958,
0.3285823166370392,
0.10341772437095642,
-0.4865763485431671,
-0.10088668018579483,
-0.8869010210037231,
-0.41232964396476746,
1.103479266166687,
0.2521059215068817,
0.8892150521278381,
0.10620677471160889,
0.5173623561859131,
0.1327095478773117,
0.47504961490631104,
-0.7310733795166016,
0.5858222246170044,
-0.2658023536205292,
-0.7653602361679077,
-0.11940185725688934,
-0.5005514621734619,
-0.5794342756271362,
0.5795318484306335,
-0.4097481966018677,
-0.49887803196907043,
0.08350161463022232,
0.33240827918052673,
-0.26622822880744934,
0.06271322816610336,
-0.6222365498542786,
1.0445982217788696,
-0.4347529113292694,
-0.345384418964386,
-0.28742942214012146,
-0.7687379717826843,
0.570428192615509,
-0.031577032059431076,
0.20756062865257263,
0.0203438438475132,
-0.19474634528160095,
0.2864862084388733,
-0.5962620973587036,
1.0072249174118042,
-0.19948208332061768,
0.27332115173339844,
0.32988202571868896,
-0.03756337985396385,
0.24409571290016174,
0.08699461817741394,
0.08425337076187134,
0.30408939719200134,
0.1527555137872696,
-0.3231228291988373,
-0.25289544463157654,
0.7729413509368896,
-0.5476457476615906,
-0.4269012212753296,
-0.43908804655075073,
-0.3319947123527527,
-0.08703156560659409,
0.2822015881538391,
0.24951638281345367,
0.47158563137054443,
0.09853292256593704,
0.22631853818893433,
0.3718506097793579,
-0.17583057284355164,
0.522701621055603,
0.5069981813430786,
-0.5778126120567322,
-0.5301758050918579,
0.9589246511459351,
-0.10138365626335144,
0.16121259331703186,
0.22573235630989075,
0.11663586646318436,
-0.3810924291610718,
-0.6204434633255005,
-0.7888959050178528,
0.3834144175052643,
-0.6334146857261658,
-0.15304286777973175,
-0.4806380271911621,
-0.008557260036468506,
-0.40087229013442993,
0.19333899021148682,
-0.5139691233634949,
-0.35693347454071045,
-0.21091556549072266,
0.13494859635829926,
0.18175619840621948,
0.6068443059921265,
-0.29381063580513,
0.3102833926677704,
-0.7966205477714539,
0.6017208099365234,
0.4187343716621399,
0.2662118375301361,
-0.21874411404132843,
-0.3712312877178192,
-0.4391765296459198,
-0.07899884879589081,
-0.17306579649448395,
-0.6096763610839844,
0.38077154755592346,
0.0825091004371643,
0.7318586111068726,
0.2195277363061905,
-0.3639540672302246,
0.963873028755188,
-0.28538966178894043,
0.8744621276855469,
0.5741689801216125,
-1.023369312286377,
0.587645411491394,
-0.2625252306461334,
0.14282457530498505,
0.4222102463245392,
-0.21624235808849335,
-0.5500470995903015,
-0.14936015009880066,
-0.604189395904541,
-0.8036611676216125,
0.7021500468254089,
0.417770117521286,
-0.053317081183195114,
0.15421368181705475,
0.2681948244571686,
0.03421034663915634,
0.45929160714149475,
-0.7562769651412964,
-0.30944839119911194,
-0.3875507414340973,
-0.6102543473243713,
0.08739041537046432,
-0.13182762265205383,
-0.1931849718093872,
-0.41476649045944214,
0.34906429052352905,
-0.5206571817398071,
0.20576326549053192,
-0.054371148347854614,
-0.1539885401725769,
-0.08791711181402206,
-0.13435231149196625,
0.4220787286758423,
0.5510354042053223,
0.05989924073219299,
0.15251149237155914,
0.16831520199775696,
-0.4156539738178253,
-0.3212195038795471,
0.09928712248802185,
-0.23684288561344147,
0.08507462590932846,
0.2982252240180969,
0.864959716796875,
-0.1263255625963211,
-0.8753252625465393,
0.7920777797698975,
-0.4367198646068573,
0.039728134870529175,
-0.3587842881679535,
0.14126113057136536,
-0.005977345630526543,
0.402925580739975,
0.08694519102573395,
0.53284752368927,
0.10357026755809784,
-0.8373415470123291,
0.08094019442796707,
0.469468355178833,
-0.5351986885070801,
-0.18061359226703644,
0.6953917741775513,
0.28429439663887024,
-0.03988494351506233,
0.670444130897522,
0.030982855707406998,
-0.36761972308158875,
0.5307884216308594,
0.22060829401016235,
0.5463342666625977,
0.2952989637851715,
0.0420331209897995,
0.06430236995220184,
0.5657973289489746,
0.08707263320684433,
0.6407262086868286,
-0.09699562937021255,
-0.6405342221260071,
-0.5465590953826904,
-0.5993413925170898,
-0.42646241188049316,
-0.10437270998954773,
-0.47488588094711304,
0.5019224882125854,
-0.3777098059654236,
-0.3716675043106079,
-0.22620117664337158,
-0.22475169599056244,
-0.9063502550125122,
0.2122379094362259,
0.6219346523284912,
1.0343937873840332,
-0.5397293567657471,
1.197935938835144,
0.7179281711578369,
-0.3901253640651703,
-0.3988417983055115,
-0.20939843356609344,
0.24122798442840576,
-0.8769960403442383,
0.5994874238967896,
0.23384959995746613,
-0.3346691429615021,
-0.12993884086608887,
-0.4765108823776245,
-0.8510358929634094,
1.2058435678482056,
0.2920704483985901,
-0.7213926911354065,
0.04551416262984276,
0.03828064724802971,
0.6138203144073486,
-0.5572986006736755,
0.12951208651065826,
0.6925802230834961,
0.42531818151474,
0.3246813416481018,
-0.9429023265838623,
-0.25155988335609436,
-0.3620530068874359,
0.28327661752700806,
0.08585978299379349,
-0.5551466941833496,
0.8363628387451172,
-0.4877315163612366,
-0.1002281904220581,
0.4267376959323883,
0.6133348345756531,
0.4056982398033142,
0.4313887059688568,
0.5784828066825867,
0.655032753944397,
0.5416762828826904,
-0.33581891655921936,
1.07663893699646,
-0.34957000613212585,
0.14384691417217255,
0.8296035528182983,
-0.012448578141629696,
0.7803848385810852,
0.731631875038147,
0.301078736782074,
0.4064922332763672,
0.40701723098754883,
0.03461870178580284,
0.7179487347602844,
0.012364774942398071,
-0.12253905832767487,
-0.5655795335769653,
-0.04183444008231163,
-0.2831743359565735,
0.5449650287628174,
0.589951753616333,
-0.5326831340789795,
0.26292985677719116,
0.10988926887512207,
-0.3337627351284027,
-0.2773019075393677,
-0.44803956151008606,
0.6579328179359436,
0.06502202153205872,
-0.4837568700313568,
0.2602672874927521,
0.239462211728096,
0.9381656646728516,
-0.6271483302116394,
0.04957990348339081,
-0.1652323454618454,
0.39590954780578613,
-0.17581553757190704,
-0.6306594014167786,
0.2437022179365158,
0.15373408794403076,
-0.1307634711265564,
-0.22891627252101898,
0.9115322232246399,
-0.40269461274147034,
-0.7269089818000793,
0.16009855270385742,
0.7367866635322571,
-0.11578809469938278,
-0.1320561319589615,
-0.8377131223678589,
0.24889852106571198,
0.07185614854097366,
-0.09738307446241379,
0.12713292241096497,
0.45690739154815674,
0.1258518099784851,
0.5936509966850281,
0.934518575668335,
0.15780682861804962,
0.41065841913223267,
0.27852049469947815,
1.0792111158370972,
-0.9681982398033142,
-0.24153953790664673,
-0.9150142669677734,
0.7060517072677612,
-0.31252843141555786,
-0.28876304626464844,
0.6834366917610168,
0.6236765384674072,
0.8107009530067444,
-0.32559144496917725,
0.7775903344154358,
-0.1890268325805664,
0.27711036801338196,
-0.6094838380813599,
0.3361894190311432,
-0.7984137535095215,
0.30499351024627686,
-0.10227774828672409,
-0.6753578186035156,
-0.49552011489868164,
0.6284310817718506,
-0.13370026648044586,
-0.0959780141711235,
0.6055525541305542,
1.0114415884017944,
-0.09005513042211533,
-0.11796934902667999,
0.6176077723503113,
0.12332966178655624,
0.5277266502380371,
0.45734378695487976,
1.266631007194519,
-0.3582187294960022,
0.9861266016960144,
-0.13912968337535858,
-0.346223920583725,
-0.3333551287651062,
-0.8534575700759888,
-0.8407642841339111,
-0.31502678990364075,
-0.17033357918262482,
-0.13834938406944275,
-0.25533097982406616,
0.6106376647949219,
0.9506776332855225,
-0.32203617691993713,
-0.1454535722732544,
-0.01907811313867569,
0.043592870235443115,
-0.21577417850494385,
-0.18521665036678314,
-0.10336998850107193,
-0.13734285533428192,
-0.6925877928733826,
0.3891182243824005,
0.7093762755393982,
0.18736661970615387,
-0.47073620557785034,
-0.26606279611587524,
0.40285009145736694,
0.18276873230934143,
0.912258505821228,
0.11698995530605316,
-0.9430459141731262,
-0.19621209800243378,
0.16893842816352844,
-0.17335060238838196,
-0.1589461714029312,
1.0143285989761353,
-0.9477142691612244,
0.5736251473426819,
0.4296742379665375,
0.08894205093383789,
0.8112671375274658,
-0.3218775987625122,
0.3131618797779083,
-0.7231894135475159,
0.2434578239917755,
0.06377068161964417,
0.76125168800354,
0.4419707655906677,
0.06634525954723358,
0.5054126977920532,
0.542011022567749,
-0.05226272717118263,
-0.6331884860992432,
0.5486831068992615,
-1.1704070568084717,
-0.1781802773475647,
1.0520411729812622,
0.24175067245960236,
-0.1977265626192093,
-0.09038984775543213,
-0.6412026882171631,
-0.13108372688293457,
-0.11359892040491104,
0.5283024907112122,
0.44308409094810486,
-0.34657880663871765,
-0.42433974146842957,
-0.43872833251953125,
0.44167476892471313,
0.14838790893554688,
-0.7170190215110779,
-0.012459320947527885,
0.7072466611862183,
0.2535492181777954,
0.13913895189762115,
0.7613784670829773,
-0.38977569341659546,
0.36106646060943604,
0.27460983395576477,
-0.20007458329200745,
-0.3831544518470764,
-0.6881287693977356,
-0.19786784052848816,
0.20326873660087585,
0.043433912098407745,
-0.20776395499706268
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18804v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18804v1
|
Is Modularity Transferable? A Case Study through the Lens of Knowledge Distillation
| 2024-03-27T17:50:00 | 2024-03-27T17:50:00 |
Mateusz Klimaszewski, Piotr Andruszkiewicz, Alexandra Birch
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The rise of Modular Deep Learning showcases its potential in various Natural
Language Processing applications. Parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT)
modularity has been shown to work for various use cases, from domain adaptation
to multilingual setups. However, all this work covers the case where the
modular components are trained and deployed within one single Pre-trained
Language Model (PLM). This model-specific setup is a substantial limitation on
the very modularity that modular architectures are trying to achieve. We ask
whether current modular approaches are transferable between models and whether
we can transfer the modules from more robust and larger PLMs to smaller ones.
In this work, we aim to fill this gap via a lens of Knowledge Distillation,
commonly used for model compression, and present an extremely straightforward
approach to transferring pre-trained, task-specific PEFT modules between
same-family PLMs. Moreover, we propose a method that allows the transfer of
modules between incompatible PLMs without any change in the inference
complexity. The experiments on Named Entity Recognition, Natural Language
Inference, and Paraphrase Identification tasks over multiple languages and PEFT
methods showcase the initial potential of transferable modularity.
|
[
-0.42402637004852295,
-0.6783681511878967,
0.8026445508003235,
-0.06174866110086441,
-0.346363365650177,
0.16582351922988892,
-0.5238338708877563,
-0.09886100888252258,
-0.2774125039577484,
0.49061042070388794,
-0.6070142984390259,
-0.2306399792432785,
-0.7804803252220154,
0.12343338876962662,
-0.3247755467891693,
0.9397431015968323,
-0.016600877046585083,
-0.20324578881263733,
-0.2542390525341034,
-0.1369301676750183,
-0.3998624086380005,
-0.5623889565467834,
-0.4825305938720703,
-0.23570609092712402,
0.28508260846138,
0.36052626371383667,
0.2831486165523529,
0.22914892435073853,
0.30718299746513367,
0.3361113369464874,
-0.1441802829504013,
0.447238951921463,
-0.3536747097969055,
-0.05722060427069664,
-0.6453617811203003,
-0.6117103695869446,
-0.45901748538017273,
-0.16430974006652832,
0.6275665163993835,
0.8085203766822815,
-0.08365780860185623,
0.3733775019645691,
0.2262357920408249,
0.8945044875144958,
-0.4205580949783325,
0.38306745886802673,
-0.9329181909561157,
0.0003551282861735672,
-0.01944960467517376,
0.08458069711923599,
-0.464664101600647,
-0.2994631230831146,
0.37481051683425903,
-0.5765408277511597,
0.07722070068120956,
-0.07538123428821564,
0.5388992428779602,
0.3169668912887573,
-0.40952345728874207,
-0.044627729803323746,
-0.678552508354187,
0.6996047496795654,
-0.8986059427261353,
-0.1079912856221199,
0.3889448046684265,
0.4604484438896179,
-0.06546620279550552,
-0.8447805643081665,
-0.7017619609832764,
-0.0006275044870562851,
-0.2726190686225891,
-0.2644214332103729,
-0.19104211032390594,
0.07993993163108826,
0.1169738620519638,
0.6078056693077087,
-0.3165534436702728,
0.018475981429219246,
-0.4641236364841461,
-0.07336057722568512,
0.33090052008628845,
0.006064244545996189,
0.32936060428619385,
-0.16483889520168304,
-0.3408471941947937,
0.1520448476076126,
-0.46163398027420044,
-0.0466419942677021,
0.34519171714782715,
0.47287651896476746,
0.1620313972234726,
0.33814534544944763,
-0.31637048721313477,
0.776206374168396,
0.4782699942588806,
-0.08860494941473007,
0.09961123019456863,
-0.6304099559783936,
-0.2635567784309387,
0.007285298779606819,
0.5509534478187561,
-0.06942827999591827,
0.2104264795780182,
-0.17176604270935059,
-0.13415536284446716,
-0.5769643783569336,
0.4704073965549469,
-0.5985144376754761,
-0.5764485001564026,
-0.09988675266504288,
-0.4524986743927002,
-0.12267043441534042,
0.08519396185874939,
-0.5220792293548584,
-0.11927343904972076,
-0.5502447485923767,
0.890985906124115,
-0.37535718083381653,
-0.33971622586250305,
0.3817828297615051,
-0.12355940788984299,
-0.08172763139009476,
0.17095103859901428,
-1.2192676067352295,
0.4308621883392334,
0.832034170627594,
0.7684136629104614,
-0.27410560846328735,
-0.2876390218734741,
-0.2512032687664032,
0.2704109251499176,
0.07611585408449173,
0.7057779431343079,
-0.367766797542572,
-0.09049476683139801,
-0.18832148611545563,
0.19300444424152374,
-0.48677125573158264,
-0.6411937475204468,
0.2543289363384247,
-0.2967621088027954,
0.13099005818367004,
-0.027717506512999535,
-0.6429694294929504,
-0.32564228773117065,
0.23896829783916473,
-0.5745624899864197,
0.7093802690505981,
0.18672390282154083,
-0.6022990942001343,
0.21125757694244385,
-0.22951409220695496,
-0.6813507080078125,
-0.05045293644070625,
0.10718490928411484,
-0.33621591329574585,
0.4812612533569336,
0.1435997635126114,
0.6437333822250366,
-0.1714291125535965,
0.38375478982925415,
-0.409794420003891,
-0.0928640365600586,
0.026889469474554062,
-0.3890872001647949,
0.6028563380241394,
0.21672241389751434,
-0.2911069989204407,
-0.10414093732833862,
-0.9006535410881042,
-0.07472696900367737,
-0.3548263609409332,
-0.572414755821228,
-0.3969423770904541,
-0.07923424243927002,
-0.3175666928291321,
0.10511910170316696,
0.38742831349372864,
-0.25415560603141785,
0.6080793142318726,
-0.0892719253897667,
0.8597957491874695,
0.6694163084030151,
-0.0766994059085846,
0.9778240919113159,
-0.33145076036453247,
0.18813063204288483,
0.18642625212669373,
0.267376184463501,
-0.15534207224845886,
-0.3875628709793091,
-0.8645797967910767,
-0.40323758125305176,
0.23502294719219208,
0.3460816740989685,
-0.7837592959403992,
0.7925476431846619,
-0.23968717455863953,
-0.4603644609451294,
-0.2937759757041931,
0.20685282349586487,
0.13091330230236053,
0.6933269500732422,
0.41242697834968567,
-0.2669934630393982,
-0.4462375044822693,
-1.1975198984146118,
-0.22698701918125153,
-0.29113784432411194,
0.12125606834888458,
0.07470066845417023,
0.23941630125045776,
0.1054036021232605,
0.7317421436309814,
-0.5069684386253357,
-0.36352676153182983,
-0.571496844291687,
0.4225166440010071,
0.3318961262702942,
0.731218695640564,
0.5411503911018372,
-0.7114919424057007,
-0.5349474549293518,
0.23388637602329254,
-0.31497836112976074,
-0.0239550918340683,
-0.1446886956691742,
-0.11551219969987869,
-0.10364582389593124,
0.5036015510559082,
-0.7715227603912354,
0.05301966518163681,
0.4845569431781769,
-0.08139517903327942,
0.5529890656471252,
-0.40775105357170105,
0.20916858315467834,
-1.4462019205093384,
-0.031363595277071,
-0.4666633605957031,
-0.4241465628147125,
-0.7296238541603088,
-0.12755733728408813,
0.11604582518339157,
0.23740999400615692,
-0.48397865891456604,
0.3685934245586395,
-0.3994823694229126,
0.266518771648407,
-0.2978436052799225,
-0.3117242753505707,
0.22084666788578033,
0.5358986854553223,
-0.11085044592618942,
0.5869734287261963,
0.8057369589805603,
-0.6997400522232056,
0.22747385501861572,
0.24479714035987854,
-0.5489619374275208,
0.7398735880851746,
-0.1773252785205841,
0.10664859414100647,
-0.03010585531592369,
0.18441224098205566,
-0.8009076118469238,
0.00010029026452684775,
0.1667814552783966,
-0.07844583690166473,
0.4503140449523926,
-0.6141058206558228,
-0.4306992292404175,
-0.007064675446599722,
-0.017154309898614883,
0.545732855796814,
0.8799797296524048,
-0.49313274025917053,
0.7166449427604675,
0.26337888836860657,
-0.3504217565059662,
-0.29782626032829285,
-0.9039598703384399,
-0.05813479423522949,
-0.43345218896865845,
-0.4912034273147583,
0.3871105909347534,
-0.17174187302589417,
-0.0008336150203831494,
0.024481846019625664,
-0.343109667301178,
-0.6897172927856445,
0.10422421991825104,
0.0005393110332079232,
0.08917348086833954,
-0.4108886122703552,
0.25055089592933655,
0.36732733249664307,
0.0875639095902443,
-0.22397853434085846,
-0.8056318759918213,
0.20884083211421967,
-0.04537106677889824,
-0.2793290913105011,
-0.5690469741821289,
0.10149487107992172,
0.746279776096344,
0.023974930867552757,
0.7815379500389099,
0.4854651987552643,
-0.38305041193962097,
-0.5145670175552368,
-0.7407656908035278,
-0.11819460242986679,
-0.5046977996826172,
0.26322445273399353,
-0.44329628348350525,
-1.0197880268096924,
0.37505215406417847,
-0.29052260518074036,
-0.20556816458702087,
0.3731556534767151,
0.44859549403190613,
0.15182696282863617,
0.5985640287399292,
0.7690088748931885,
-0.1206594929099083,
0.5316042304039001,
-0.07783032208681107,
0.26496702432632446,
-0.6166940927505493,
-0.20471729338169098,
-0.40596047043800354,
-0.5425230860710144,
-0.06117823347449303,
-0.4628213047981262,
-0.14659731090068817,
0.2875809669494629,
0.08171840757131577,
0.8700660467147827,
-0.21383661031723022,
0.6869961619377136,
0.4049084782600403,
0.0015119496965780854,
0.6378931403160095,
-0.04052110016345978,
-0.08668956905603409,
0.19681306183338165,
-0.763002872467041,
-0.410161554813385,
0.808868408203125,
-0.04142579063773155,
0.46025389432907104,
0.05240543559193611,
0.6771458387374878,
0.265569806098938,
-0.046334605664014816,
-0.6113535761833191,
0.5377429723739624,
-0.5953158140182495,
-0.6560724973678589,
-0.18398211896419525,
-0.545920729637146,
-0.48917269706726074,
0.013777198269963264,
-0.10123054683208466,
-0.8134750723838806,
0.4271949231624603,
0.028055623173713684,
-0.535651683807373,
0.7114847898483276,
-0.8661104440689087,
0.778974175453186,
-0.04208134114742279,
0.05521132051944733,
-0.37129831314086914,
-0.45770472288131714,
0.43449926376342773,
-0.48103612661361694,
0.167034313082695,
-0.3992142081260681,
0.17605388164520264,
0.2918094992637634,
-0.2979219853878021,
0.7604745030403137,
-0.00816162396222353,
0.00880370382219553,
0.15326425433158875,
0.19206862151622772,
0.19980385899543762,
0.2817082405090332,
-0.11193488538265228,
0.11409398168325424,
0.19857162237167358,
-0.5146116614341736,
-0.7898240089416504,
0.6751983165740967,
-0.46951380372047424,
-0.8367555737495422,
0.0453210212290287,
-0.5848390460014343,
-0.2619474530220032,
0.28655996918678284,
0.1176052913069725,
0.40748468041419983,
-0.09515645354986191,
0.0747205913066864,
0.8804654479026794,
0.015181411989033222,
0.4953479468822479,
0.5683868527412415,
-0.013636087998747826,
-0.04148615524172783,
1.0432770252227783,
0.1780729591846466,
0.5068464875221252,
0.8077402710914612,
0.14616626501083374,
0.06846693903207779,
-0.9598850607872009,
-0.3822568655014038,
-0.15665873885154724,
-0.4962865114212036,
-0.19099298119544983,
-0.4676617383956909,
-0.24283701181411743,
-0.22837598621845245,
-0.085627980530262,
-0.6636478900909424,
-0.8222248554229736,
-0.5667654275894165,
-0.21645250916481018,
0.2590331435203552,
0.8574995398521423,
-0.0903305634856224,
-0.038994692265987396,
-1.0562617778778076,
0.2504555881023407,
0.8200150728225708,
0.24518075585365295,
-0.1082887053489685,
-0.7765346765518188,
-0.1582150161266327,
-0.11935778707265854,
0.07606770098209381,
-0.5359322428703308,
0.14898234605789185,
0.6398860216140747,
0.5093108415603638,
0.2945384681224823,
0.29191434383392334,
0.7179504632949829,
-0.6444727182388306,
0.7600364685058594,
0.15972478687763214,
-1.0363408327102661,
0.30496352910995483,
-0.23196768760681152,
0.3835110068321228,
1.1091793775558472,
0.2130788266658783,
-0.07516272366046906,
-0.22803948819637299,
-0.4347468316555023,
-0.6813088655471802,
0.7385172247886658,
0.1340794861316681,
0.3503139913082123,
0.1583157777786255,
0.5910158157348633,
0.7756860256195068,
0.21679507195949554,
-0.4196372926235199,
-0.07029270380735397,
0.10729710012674332,
-0.31622329354286194,
0.021822718903422356,
-0.07430723309516907,
-0.08069814741611481,
-0.5481187701225281,
0.5369839072227478,
-0.20056624710559845,
-0.17105276882648468,
0.11039616167545319,
-0.5143018960952759,
0.37660762667655945,
0.4431789815425873,
0.3207322657108307,
0.7052034139633179,
-0.03786346688866615,
0.6808633208274841,
0.3099227547645569,
-0.3452339172363281,
0.3235953748226166,
0.16495762765407562,
0.013881603255867958,
-0.1607542186975479,
0.04807581007480621,
0.7372488975524902,
0.5437814593315125,
-0.4779115915298462,
0.4494428038597107,
-0.1917129009962082,
-0.4149109423160553,
0.06948705017566681,
0.10362106561660767,
0.24667584896087646,
0.6488268375396729,
0.3870598077774048,
0.3818610608577728,
0.1738438904285431,
-0.6787583231925964,
0.31598275899887085,
0.17005591094493866,
-0.398120254278183,
-0.7379409670829773,
0.3796459138393402,
0.13916023075580597,
-0.25946417450904846,
0.4844396412372589,
-0.1214817613363266,
-0.3763703405857086,
0.4028220772743225,
0.21578074991703033,
0.9197019338607788,
0.07662653923034668,
0.37683379650115967,
0.23455579578876495,
0.27200400829315186,
-0.5724589228630066,
-0.1893310844898224,
-0.33979254961013794,
-0.5216034650802612,
-0.4574248492717743,
-0.7333028316497803,
-0.17673884332180023,
-0.0016583586111664772,
-0.7801311016082764,
0.16137537360191345,
-0.4320915937423706,
-0.0777750015258789,
0.027821766212582588,
-0.29707640409469604,
-0.46744877099990845,
-0.25188517570495605,
0.3739497661590576,
0.8773401379585266,
-0.6926546692848206,
1.1854668855667114,
0.6933292746543884,
-0.30797260999679565,
-0.664212167263031,
-0.03309418633580208,
-0.17172136902809143,
-0.5638161301612854,
0.49616894125938416,
0.003912954591214657,
0.24114322662353516,
0.08879352360963821,
-0.2317669540643692,
-0.6498871445655823,
1.2021735906600952,
0.842914342880249,
-0.5907274484634399,
-0.13655434548854828,
0.16951622068881989,
0.480881929397583,
-0.2381914108991623,
-0.25252658128738403,
0.7910495400428772,
0.5407088398933411,
-0.12517404556274414,
-1.2630387544631958,
0.13373315334320068,
-0.05279848724603653,
-0.2175249308347702,
0.13281866908073425,
-0.614067792892456,
1.0041859149932861,
0.09785264730453491,
-0.2066229283809662,
0.2825518250465393,
0.38451340794563293,
-0.22350111603736877,
0.05239642783999443,
0.4239809513092041,
0.7209502458572388,
0.6955760717391968,
0.029006045311689377,
0.691049337387085,
-0.1909501701593399,
0.44905397295951843,
1.0602362155914307,
-0.07992950826883316,
0.8941104412078857,
0.6618289351463318,
-0.27195847034454346,
0.46470317244529724,
0.18527136743068695,
0.09606784582138062,
0.7045190334320068,
0.0626208707690239,
-0.46781569719314575,
-0.4692702293395996,
0.17482706904411316,
-0.21398796141147614,
0.07335872203111649,
0.11292603611946106,
-0.24034687876701355,
-0.31301969289779663,
0.043188780546188354,
-0.24045473337173462,
0.021589474752545357,
-0.4167724847793579,
0.9954612851142883,
0.2903731167316437,
-0.8047152757644653,
0.2818775773048401,
-0.34380200505256653,
0.7402963042259216,
-0.7106317281723022,
0.09823061525821686,
-0.190410777926445,
0.26844489574432373,
-0.2690102458000183,
-0.49873602390289307,
0.5330780744552612,
-0.3526996970176697,
-0.4554730951786041,
-0.5540168285369873,
0.9445777535438538,
-0.6192613244056702,
-0.38217318058013916,
0.032900698482990265,
0.7487921118736267,
-0.002083785133436322,
-0.1958191990852356,
-0.3856852650642395,
-0.5344161987304688,
0.03801279515028,
-0.20623253285884857,
0.8072299957275391,
0.5130845308303833,
0.36295467615127563,
0.4794657826423645,
0.45813751220703125,
0.15524595975875854,
0.4372884929180145,
-0.21008992195129395,
0.9298781156539917,
-0.3029511868953705,
-0.22536858916282654,
-0.9493374824523926,
0.5821554660797119,
0.06349366158246994,
-0.20138972997665405,
0.6324772834777832,
0.1814832240343094,
0.7309843301773071,
-0.3918573558330536,
0.8101078867912292,
-0.08170568197965622,
0.0005638696602545679,
-0.6779671311378479,
0.8128873109817505,
-0.39638906717300415,
0.2936377227306366,
0.050231464207172394,
-1.1054790019989014,
-0.1866365373134613,
0.42187222838401794,
-0.13330577313899994,
-0.4978656470775604,
0.8682669997215271,
0.45177364349365234,
-0.3796057403087616,
0.04913977161049843,
0.4091758728027344,
0.20986221730709076,
0.004704277962446213,
0.6792638301849365,
0.6815903186798096,
-0.1026030108332634,
0.62615966796875,
-0.2588052451610565,
-0.04364549368619919,
0.0565219484269619,
-0.9740358591079712,
-0.9661992788314819,
-0.769179105758667,
-0.4822169840335846,
0.23516860604286194,
0.2197624146938324,
0.6051208972930908,
0.912196695804596,
-0.8299819231033325,
0.03521232679486275,
-0.3797582685947418,
0.21120238304138184,
-0.23386645317077637,
-0.15619242191314697,
0.1373242437839508,
-0.5006080865859985,
-0.7579181790351868,
0.5933781266212463,
0.5376607775688171,
-0.06633641570806503,
-0.30241498351097107,
0.2920359969139099,
-0.2783939242362976,
0.10917001217603683,
0.5490497946739197,
0.2700439393520355,
-0.47086215019226074,
-0.4277009963989258,
-0.15531311929225922,
0.16420838236808777,
0.07156725227832794,
1.0503315925598145,
-0.8238869309425354,
0.4285500943660736,
0.7913070321083069,
0.8588297963142395,
0.37468329071998596,
-0.14920520782470703,
0.9078842997550964,
-0.8583794236183167,
0.10318537056446075,
0.009401600807905197,
0.455430269241333,
0.18303035199642181,
-0.15968075394630432,
0.24026574194431305,
0.19114157557487488,
-0.5238008499145508,
-0.7028040289878845,
0.36456289887428284,
-1.1117254495620728,
-0.5382797718048096,
1.0621901750564575,
-0.48301735520362854,
-0.0789933130145073,
-0.34366729855537415,
-0.2579888105392456,
0.14535798132419586,
-0.07385572791099548,
0.8113303184509277,
0.8430227637290955,
0.04529133066534996,
-0.02556135319173336,
-0.27829626202583313,
0.47599440813064575,
0.4370288550853729,
-0.8072611093521118,
0.10500860214233398,
0.06049812212586403,
0.5538082122802734,
0.07658158987760544,
0.2909940481185913,
-0.0023252766113728285,
-0.07222597301006317,
-0.19723500311374664,
-0.2440498173236847,
-0.31198129057884216,
-0.19727595150470734,
-0.5477457046508789,
0.2872675061225891,
0.10190778225660324,
0.010587821714580059
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18803v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18803v1
|
Projective Methods for Mitigating Gender Bias in Pre-trained Language Models
| 2024-03-27T17:49:31 | 2024-03-27T17:49:31 |
Hillary Dawkins, Isar Nejadgholi, Daniel Gillis, Judi McCuaig
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Mitigation of gender bias in NLP has a long history tied to debiasing static
word embeddings. More recently, attention has shifted to debiasing pre-trained
language models. We study to what extent the simplest projective debiasing
methods, developed for word embeddings, can help when applied to BERT's
internal representations. Projective methods are fast to implement, use a small
number of saved parameters, and make no updates to the existing model
parameters. We evaluate the efficacy of the methods in reducing both intrinsic
bias, as measured by BERT's next sentence prediction task, and in mitigating
observed bias in a downstream setting when fine-tuned. To this end, we also
provide a critical analysis of a popular gender-bias assessment test for
quantifying intrinsic bias, resulting in an enhanced test set and new bias
measures. We find that projective methods can be effective at both intrinsic
bias and downstream bias mitigation, but that the two outcomes are not
necessarily correlated. This finding serves as a warning that intrinsic bias
test sets, based either on language modeling tasks or next sentence prediction,
should not be the only benchmark in developing a debiased language model.
|
[
-0.41689640283584595,
-0.6974918246269226,
0.30617234110832214,
0.5406022667884827,
-0.022515831515192986,
0.0844821184873581,
-0.2814621329307556,
-0.30308839678764343,
-0.054752953350543976,
0.27319326996803284,
-0.545584499835968,
-0.16376672685146332,
-0.7006708979606628,
0.01472290325909853,
-0.4364718794822693,
0.709256649017334,
-0.11133267730474472,
0.3466496765613556,
-0.24193915724754333,
0.16962498426437378,
-0.4234912693500519,
-0.6983294486999512,
-0.21833199262619019,
-0.3864186704158783,
0.33907395601272583,
0.18506821990013123,
0.39993301033973694,
0.0049348571337759495,
0.5690048336982727,
0.1741875261068344,
-0.2724585235118866,
-0.11804001778364182,
-0.4917767345905304,
0.16967926919460297,
0.16406631469726562,
-0.301310271024704,
-0.21788598597049713,
0.3200647532939911,
0.7915421724319458,
0.9744762778282166,
0.09467735141515732,
0.2225874960422516,
0.3646753430366516,
1.009300708770752,
-1.0378754138946533,
0.10022152960300446,
-0.7427307963371277,
0.37386542558670044,
-0.1558666229248047,
-0.13909241557121277,
-0.4509272873401642,
-0.4944964051246643,
0.3826878070831299,
-0.15445777773857117,
0.3468470573425293,
0.12126065790653229,
0.6260728240013123,
0.07579033076763153,
-0.26885727047920227,
-0.07117640227079391,
-0.9335541129112244,
1.0190595388412476,
-0.6475547552108765,
0.3262496590614319,
0.6963495016098022,
-0.09434417635202408,
-0.04889066889882088,
-0.20151086151599884,
-0.4461020529270172,
-0.7164731621742249,
-0.011412565596401691,
0.015513678081333637,
-0.029613099992275238,
0.17715014517307281,
0.37139689922332764,
0.17384852468967438,
-0.30642828345298767,
-0.08202632516622543,
-0.31460466980934143,
0.028305595740675926,
0.4765892028808594,
-0.2173563688993454,
0.1520581692457199,
-0.2033141553401947,
-0.2801700234413147,
-0.21393711864948273,
-1.0310500860214233,
-0.06177256628870964,
0.9248858094215393,
0.3202739655971527,
0.20985929667949677,
0.8349477052688599,
-0.040503691881895065,
0.4012020230293274,
0.1865541636943817,
0.24339255690574646,
0.16335250437259674,
-0.09946727752685547,
0.015469164587557316,
0.3318555951118469,
0.5588038563728333,
0.27145126461982727,
0.5408455729484558,
-0.20635145902633667,
-0.057595640420913696,
0.19295260310173035,
0.41693663597106934,
-0.5708556771278381,
-0.3284914791584015,
0.15868434309959412,
-0.6928585171699524,
-0.37723737955093384,
-0.22671198844909668,
-0.7290098667144775,
-0.5557718276977539,
-0.2700498700141907,
0.3014318645000458,
-0.5350824594497681,
-0.3194124698638916,
-0.14320120215415955,
-0.2933376729488373,
0.19580848515033722,
0.07537171989679337,
-1.2383391857147217,
0.348115473985672,
0.8589287400245667,
0.6917734742164612,
0.3139025866985321,
-0.2385951578617096,
-0.40998539328575134,
0.02671016938984394,
-0.49734067916870117,
0.6385278701782227,
-0.7446173429489136,
-0.3337479531764984,
0.15674172341823578,
-0.46553584933280945,
-0.06509943306446075,
-0.3051949739456177,
0.3566448986530304,
-0.054984305053949356,
0.35850778222084045,
-0.6359573006629944,
-0.6661995053291321,
-0.051841676235198975,
0.27809855341911316,
-0.2506466507911682,
1.083897352218628,
0.09785493463277817,
-1.201278805732727,
0.6796939373016357,
-0.421004980802536,
-0.13758063316345215,
-0.24461650848388672,
-0.13754062354564667,
-0.3209652006626129,
0.3798612356185913,
0.28291308879852295,
0.2601652145385742,
-0.055292416363954544,
0.15166132152080536,
-0.5178781747817993,
-0.3301911950111389,
-0.07260946184396744,
-0.23274289071559906,
0.5425071716308594,
-0.3079282343387604,
-0.4883517622947693,
0.06981941312551498,
-0.3037038743495941,
-0.13816304504871368,
-0.043815456330776215,
0.23074619472026825,
-0.6173073053359985,
0.519450306892395,
-0.10715316236019135,
0.15747447311878204,
0.11545770615339279,
-0.7941408157348633,
0.1642334759235382,
-0.40439170598983765,
0.006338588427752256,
0.9852775931358337,
-0.44355982542037964,
0.7481927275657654,
-0.25742655992507935,
0.41883212327957153,
-0.253556489944458,
0.19648222625255585,
0.4476865530014038,
-0.6274571418762207,
-0.909309983253479,
-0.15714654326438904,
0.4229044020175934,
0.43419894576072693,
-0.46408379077911377,
0.5638269186019897,
0.0391404815018177,
-0.4627721607685089,
-0.522129237651825,
0.17336811125278473,
0.4480116367340088,
0.5575441122055054,
0.28755125403404236,
-0.3412362337112427,
-0.6385953426361084,
-1.1421760320663452,
-0.5175997614860535,
-0.38674822449684143,
-0.08006225526332855,
-0.004657173529267311,
0.47265884280204773,
-0.07814880460500717,
0.9925856590270996,
-0.29299187660217285,
-0.4932166039943695,
-0.42684829235076904,
0.48326680064201355,
0.017692359164357185,
0.6379479169845581,
0.6786405444145203,
-0.5004476308822632,
-0.35987982153892517,
-0.5187075138092041,
-0.41854360699653625,
-0.29332658648490906,
-0.027402004227042198,
-0.26784011721611023,
0.2242918610572815,
0.39518168568611145,
-0.2623402774333954,
0.4715907573699951,
0.6080594658851624,
-0.5276107788085938,
0.7159289121627808,
-0.24218718707561493,
-0.2303677201271057,
-0.4603049159049988,
-0.14244920015335083,
0.1955772191286087,
-0.15129771828651428,
-0.6263947486877441,
-0.07013355195522308,
0.04418548569083214,
0.21571023762226105,
-0.29063865542411804,
0.40253058075904846,
-0.42845308780670166,
-0.04233584925532341,
-0.2832619249820709,
0.06490267068147659,
-0.20547109842300415,
0.3377273678779602,
0.2695681154727936,
0.5537126660346985,
0.5773048400878906,
-0.5205074548721313,
-0.20771658420562744,
0.4024287760257721,
-0.30654340982437134,
0.26351726055145264,
-0.6080418229103088,
0.26237988471984863,
-0.534011960029602,
0.11274353414773941,
-0.9315028190612793,
0.4992298185825348,
0.3963063359260559,
-0.372809499502182,
0.3642214834690094,
-0.19651304185390472,
-0.516776978969574,
-0.3831560015678406,
-0.8046825528144836,
0.037041861563920975,
0.6135080456733704,
-0.4894580841064453,
0.5028388500213623,
0.2585197389125824,
-0.2517884373664856,
-0.6638017296791077,
-0.6760790944099426,
-0.2608036398887634,
-0.08195909112691879,
-0.42196109890937805,
0.5016044974327087,
0.12338977307081223,
-0.3346499800682068,
-0.21760959923267365,
-0.15936462581157684,
-0.02902321331202984,
0.10597407817840576,
0.13706566393375397,
0.2375984489917755,
0.14003436267375946,
0.29922574758529663,
0.27517902851104736,
-0.12767288088798523,
0.2129817008972168,
-0.03351594880223274,
0.9099186658859253,
-0.18983373045921326,
-0.2097661793231964,
-0.1901683360338211,
0.581817090511322,
0.10329793393611908,
-0.156522735953331,
0.9610645771026611,
0.8038763403892517,
-0.3556746542453766,
-0.0030975325498729944,
-0.7139101028442383,
-0.49850571155548096,
-0.46020832657814026,
0.3825187683105469,
-0.0036419611424207687,
-0.7235107421875,
0.3307451605796814,
0.16708925366401672,
0.033934932202100754,
0.33421817421913147,
0.604025661945343,
-0.35913121700286865,
1.1771548986434937,
0.7777811288833618,
-0.13318684697151184,
0.5858607888221741,
-0.26296180486679077,
0.5314069390296936,
-1.3407357931137085,
-0.043148886412382126,
-0.6075985431671143,
-0.4953475892543793,
-0.8610188961029053,
-0.24369890987873077,
0.051362045109272,
0.1091998815536499,
-0.3928094506263733,
0.06056187301874161,
-0.5420173406600952,
0.2784403860569,
0.9878798127174377,
0.13487175107002258,
-0.04822814092040062,
-0.14964722096920013,
0.05990463122725487,
-0.3635503053665161,
-0.4930795431137085,
-0.5738962888717651,
1.3043731451034546,
0.4498240351676941,
0.6695255041122437,
0.030361255630850792,
0.6767456531524658,
0.1931590586900711,
0.4978489875793457,
-0.44740724563598633,
0.5469305515289307,
-0.4553701877593994,
-0.8310097455978394,
-0.19798347353935242,
-0.4493744671344757,
-0.5855500102043152,
0.36492919921875,
-0.44029924273490906,
-0.9894333481788635,
0.3585548996925354,
0.36579009890556335,
-0.15774410963058472,
0.4508645236492157,
-0.7078174948692322,
0.5407865643501282,
-0.033060312271118164,
-0.4516657888889313,
-0.1717713624238968,
-0.3635156452655792,
0.40643709897994995,
0.0415041521191597,
-0.21393127739429474,
-0.4527662992477417,
0.21733790636062622,
0.9122813940048218,
-0.24845747649669647,
0.799166738986969,
-0.46894022822380066,
-0.1345522552728653,
0.028796080499887466,
0.2247719019651413,
0.27724796533584595,
0.05365918576717377,
0.005720812361687422,
0.19191423058509827,
-0.0009413473308086395,
-0.3763209581375122,
-0.27369362115859985,
0.5159703493118286,
-0.6962870359420776,
-0.555525541305542,
-0.6552252173423767,
-0.5718432664871216,
-0.5193064212799072,
-0.08650446683168411,
0.17386755347251892,
0.3342745006084442,
-0.0903555303812027,
0.18448063731193542,
0.5107210874557495,
-0.46619534492492676,
0.604137659072876,
0.2789120078086853,
-0.28700366616249084,
-0.008886905387043953,
0.4956054091453552,
-0.13473165035247803,
0.22609074413776398,
0.2938528060913086,
0.6727981567382812,
-0.4734458923339844,
-0.3610578179359436,
0.09208052605390549,
0.13432757556438446,
-0.4057481288909912,
0.030681980773806572,
-0.6543075442314148,
0.03945581614971161,
-0.7038304209709167,
-0.05296735838055611,
-0.5314720273017883,
-0.448154091835022,
0.010512558743357658,
0.08184870332479477,
0.11528670787811279,
0.43880602717399597,
-0.06269939988851547,
0.3579753339290619,
-0.6467223167419434,
0.5017668008804321,
0.42095330357551575,
0.20904593169689178,
0.02623784728348255,
-0.3017396330833435,
0.3254743814468384,
0.20590539276599884,
-0.41388124227523804,
-0.8989992737770081,
0.6017917394638062,
0.3579063415527344,
0.4455367922782898,
0.34841838479042053,
0.1153469905257225,
0.3492102324962616,
-0.5947184562683105,
0.7795986533164978,
0.15010537207126617,
-1.2714754343032837,
0.7076150178909302,
-0.3952554762363434,
0.026645533740520477,
0.7208767533302307,
0.4076841175556183,
-0.43270617723464966,
-0.6023065447807312,
-0.4262844920158386,
-0.8091945052146912,
0.558623731136322,
0.48021072149276733,
0.44033172726631165,
-0.1507132649421692,
0.27861061692237854,
0.18558447062969208,
0.5007867813110352,
-0.7942287921905518,
-0.2976851463317871,
0.032177120447158813,
-0.0723968893289566,
-0.007786701899021864,
-0.7298651933670044,
0.015036145225167274,
-0.6082067489624023,
0.7485532760620117,
0.014321677386760712,
0.6745002269744873,
0.3486918807029724,
-0.19613690674304962,
0.010358454659581184,
0.1707489937543869,
0.5501233339309692,
0.6013420224189758,
-0.8692509531974792,
-0.14998525381088257,
-0.007791238371282816,
-0.6534621715545654,
0.033736810088157654,
0.15412840247154236,
-0.29653361439704895,
0.0902690440416336,
0.346682071685791,
0.6471065878868103,
-0.12554939091205597,
-0.39918455481529236,
0.6470044255256653,
-0.04419207572937012,
-0.2259298712015152,
-0.4421021044254303,
-0.29638615250587463,
-0.23755159974098206,
0.0942191630601883,
0.35658544301986694,
0.03345168009400368,
0.10204265266656876,
-0.5834954380989075,
-0.14806635677814484,
0.5866057276725769,
-0.6597245335578918,
-0.18856045603752136,
0.4801774322986603,
0.3173786699771881,
-0.04542810469865799,
0.8394461274147034,
-0.17028914391994476,
-0.7656804919242859,
0.49026018381118774,
0.5361403226852417,
1.2279183864593506,
-0.329938143491745,
0.3968835771083832,
0.26019299030303955,
0.6568099856376648,
-0.09572504460811615,
0.43711721897125244,
-0.0032902800012379885,
-0.9137203097343445,
-0.6117220520973206,
-0.45964208245277405,
-0.49639278650283813,
-0.19557888805866241,
-0.5776618123054504,
0.06699512898921967,
-0.39151185750961304,
-0.18982060253620148,
-0.41225141286849976,
-0.009885771200060844,
-0.5456735491752625,
-0.0985274463891983,
0.5536143183708191,
0.8160069584846497,
-0.9261640310287476,
0.6706562638282776,
0.4825011193752289,
-0.20047177374362946,
-0.3979935646057129,
0.1541840136051178,
-0.1592053771018982,
-0.6094278693199158,
1.0856958627700806,
0.39508774876594543,
0.0015554489800706506,
-0.3430398106575012,
-0.2591717839241028,
-0.728463888168335,
0.4855729639530182,
0.5193360447883606,
-0.6988478899002075,
-0.07577874511480331,
0.19609110057353973,
0.45307838916778564,
-0.11844661831855774,
0.5392041206359863,
0.5460708141326904,
0.5668011903762817,
-0.45613136887550354,
-0.901813805103302,
-0.16812439262866974,
-0.08993349969387054,
0.12546321749687195,
0.2571069300174713,
-0.18398606777191162,
0.920979917049408,
0.08980300277471542,
0.2907409369945526,
-0.07737670093774796,
0.5118335485458374,
0.24085605144500732,
-0.05307637155056,
0.7188064455986023,
0.4677356779575348,
0.5474603176116943,
-0.34399184584617615,
1.2683995962142944,
-0.24501429498195648,
0.45668843388557434,
1.0901048183441162,
-0.5104286670684814,
0.8175294399261475,
0.7584295868873596,
-0.29656466841697693,
0.5611717700958252,
0.3757171034812927,
0.2728821933269501,
0.7409812211990356,
0.6212534308433533,
-0.18400393426418304,
-0.12283868342638016,
-0.10799019783735275,
-0.5217262506484985,
0.6285502910614014,
0.2092331051826477,
-0.4791342318058014,
-0.22219318151474,
0.10783617198467255,
-0.020203253254294395,
0.04961986839771271,
-0.2163403034210205,
0.5490948557853699,
0.011857151985168457,
-0.4384561777114868,
0.27664148807525635,
-0.20883677899837494,
0.977419376373291,
-0.6920496821403503,
0.07891373336315155,
-0.28687939047813416,
0.4598585069179535,
0.12870514392852783,
-0.5848034620285034,
0.4112289547920227,
-0.03444685414433479,
-0.030311143025755882,
-0.6178398132324219,
0.8794010281562805,
-0.4913580119609833,
-0.7991625666618347,
0.41110995411872864,
0.4716744124889374,
-0.37441280484199524,
-0.5005426406860352,
-0.5718166828155518,
-0.21407324075698853,
-0.043673593550920486,
-0.217659592628479,
0.26992717385292053,
-0.13597401976585388,
0.19633331894874573,
0.7674379944801331,
0.4909786581993103,
0.3850184381008148,
0.10285720229148865,
0.29285934567451477,
0.7189013361930847,
-0.5427070260047913,
-0.3256228268146515,
-0.9342983365058899,
0.26879504323005676,
-0.14916230738162994,
-0.355989933013916,
0.7782897353172302,
0.24614502489566803,
0.5841275453567505,
-0.18424178659915924,
0.5305349826812744,
-0.021828945726156235,
0.5158207416534424,
-0.4840782880783081,
0.7786304950714111,
-0.2711676061153412,
0.12755681574344635,
-0.7725343704223633,
-1.4413681030273438,
-0.38000133633613586,
0.9699432253837585,
-0.573998749256134,
0.1792391985654831,
0.7779328227043152,
0.5872273445129395,
0.18830813467502594,
0.11992188543081284,
-0.03610030561685562,
-0.0006637214100919664,
0.39193078875541687,
0.3454105854034424,
1.1508201360702515,
-0.32159343361854553,
0.09093835949897766,
-0.836264967918396,
-0.2943108081817627,
-0.04076557233929634,
-1.2132703065872192,
-1.1175117492675781,
-0.44013386964797974,
-0.4200948178768158,
-0.1672278791666031,
0.27140650153160095,
0.9364901185035706,
0.7081692814826965,
-0.7400290369987488,
-0.04246000200510025,
-0.3189147412776947,
0.0160015020519495,
-0.2577798068523407,
-0.19132958352565765,
0.49544093012809753,
-0.4793705940246582,
-0.6564341187477112,
0.10645963996648788,
0.07881554961204529,
-0.21147429943084717,
-0.4405314326286316,
0.17531265318393707,
-0.3223418891429901,
-0.07757697999477386,
0.6302633285522461,
-0.22576552629470825,
-0.5317543148994446,
-0.5170883536338806,
0.0023369858972728252,
0.26952436566352844,
-0.09012123942375183,
0.9292472004890442,
-0.8745636343955994,
0.5141875743865967,
0.7754184007644653,
0.1703304499387741,
0.13134586811065674,
-0.13639725744724274,
1.0207537412643433,
-0.9297779202461243,
0.4580933749675751,
0.5370319485664368,
0.5086573958396912,
0.37655848264694214,
-0.17999470233917236,
0.3675587475299835,
-0.050566162914037704,
-0.33306777477264404,
-0.8500322699546814,
0.13953419029712677,
-0.7725005149841309,
-0.13490308821201324,
1.2070013284683228,
0.07726842164993286,
-0.04963356629014015,
-0.03986809775233269,
-0.2907496988773346,
0.10347701609134674,
-0.33786627650260925,
1.1439805030822754,
0.6793861985206604,
0.06540699303150177,
-0.08258381485939026,
-0.2884545922279358,
0.49899598956108093,
0.9122878909111023,
-0.5498671531677246,
0.21240243315696716,
0.11969693750143051,
-0.18194587528705597,
0.1915394812822342,
0.417706698179245,
-0.10004573315382004,
0.05805650353431702,
-0.10881073772907257,
0.27271029353141785,
0.20623749494552612,
-0.16159527003765106,
-0.15996606647968292,
-0.24344487488269806,
0.0075528002344071865,
-0.2921285331249237
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18802v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18802v3
|
Long-form factuality in large language models
| 2024-03-27T17:48:55 | 2024-04-03T20:54:11 |
Jerry Wei, Chengrun Yang, Xinying Song, Yifeng Lu, Nathan Hu, Jie Huang, Dustin Tran, Daiyi Peng, Ruibo Liu, Da Huang, Cosmo Du, Quoc V. Le
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) often generate content that contains factual
errors when responding to fact-seeking prompts on open-ended topics. To
benchmark a model's long-form factuality in open domains, we first use GPT-4 to
generate LongFact, a prompt set comprising thousands of questions spanning 38
topics. We then propose that LLM agents can be used as automated evaluators for
long-form factuality through a method which we call Search-Augmented Factuality
Evaluator (SAFE). SAFE utilizes an LLM to break down a long-form response into
a set of individual facts and to evaluate the accuracy of each fact using a
multi-step reasoning process comprising sending search queries to Google Search
and determining whether a fact is supported by the search results. Furthermore,
we propose extending F1 score as an aggregated metric for long-form factuality.
To do so, we balance the percentage of supported facts in a response
(precision) with the percentage of provided facts relative to a hyperparameter
representing a user's preferred response length (recall).
Empirically, we demonstrate that LLM agents can outperform crowdsourced human
annotators - on a set of ~16k individual facts, SAFE agrees with crowdsourced
human annotators 72% of the time, and on a random subset of 100 disagreement
cases, SAFE wins 76% of the time. At the same time, SAFE is more than 20 times
cheaper than human annotators. We also benchmark thirteen language models on
LongFact across four model families (Gemini, GPT, Claude, and PaLM-2), finding
that larger language models generally achieve better long-form factuality.
LongFact, SAFE, and all experimental code are available at
https://github.com/google-deepmind/long-form-factuality.
|
[
-0.23367878794670105,
-1.042548656463623,
0.9823833107948303,
0.11503561586141586,
-0.06116476282477379,
0.06003354489803314,
-0.6972317099571228,
-0.6147409081459045,
-0.026156853884458542,
0.28128206729888916,
-0.24326235055923462,
-0.5864400267601013,
-0.5260151624679565,
0.2076537162065506,
-0.28633153438568115,
1.0896652936935425,
-0.04597528278827667,
-0.3820001482963562,
-0.5570566654205322,
-0.20353946089744568,
-0.05376060679554939,
-0.7111462950706482,
-0.7029268741607666,
-0.1575290411710739,
0.6863216161727905,
0.13302592933177948,
1.0530166625976562,
0.49747219681739807,
0.47125014662742615,
0.3149614930152893,
0.04267308861017227,
0.30460450053215027,
-0.5502733588218689,
0.13710249960422516,
-0.41299933195114136,
-0.35235294699668884,
-0.6865019202232361,
0.33417391777038574,
0.6580512523651123,
0.4461349546909332,
-0.1465204507112503,
-0.0533951073884964,
-0.1315077394247055,
0.6508610844612122,
-0.5820809006690979,
0.5007467269897461,
-0.3661381006240845,
-0.2753939628601074,
-0.13220064342021942,
0.038403935730457306,
-0.5467086434364319,
-0.7582509517669678,
0.0877770185470581,
-0.3819630742073059,
0.21314111351966858,
0.1924188882112503,
0.7532610297203064,
0.3194187879562378,
-0.5490162372589111,
-0.5731275677680969,
-0.7423404455184937,
0.6766042709350586,
-0.7901180386543274,
0.5834246277809143,
0.5636215209960938,
0.2597755491733551,
-0.3811153769493103,
-0.5588087439537048,
-0.8197404146194458,
-0.8452252149581909,
-0.1462971568107605,
-0.03587927669286728,
-0.19831755757331848,
0.2235100269317627,
0.4814448952674866,
0.17806600034236908,
-0.6391189098358154,
0.22602131962776184,
-0.2325189709663391,
-0.44502586126327515,
0.7975533604621887,
-0.1203431487083435,
0.15050938725471497,
-0.06738711893558502,
-0.44196516275405884,
0.05396026745438576,
-0.8729671239852905,
0.1926761120557785,
0.2963522970676422,
0.2721008062362671,
-0.12873625755310059,
0.686443030834198,
-0.5076892971992493,
0.4254431128501892,
0.0025633445475250483,
-0.5522204637527466,
0.251829594373703,
-0.29476267099380493,
-0.15773360431194305,
0.10865376889705658,
0.8858820199966431,
0.344441682100296,
0.3308519124984741,
-0.26888367533683777,
-0.4743729829788208,
0.07825609296560287,
-0.09151340276002884,
-0.986956000328064,
0.06575101613998413,
0.30353355407714844,
-0.10201948136091232,
-0.0950125902891159,
0.07376469671726227,
-0.6011112332344055,
-0.45689937472343445,
-0.3736487030982971,
0.3948056697845459,
-0.314958781003952,
-0.04788142070174217,
0.27348408102989197,
0.2533435821533203,
0.16998730599880219,
0.5639617443084717,
-0.4224422872066498,
0.4223260283470154,
0.872791588306427,
0.8327662944793701,
-0.2521604299545288,
-0.3181481957435608,
-0.9318097233772278,
-0.09931448847055435,
-0.4163631796836853,
0.7758723497390747,
-0.26107490062713623,
-0.2257142812013626,
0.09129384160041809,
0.0862702876329422,
0.035398297011852264,
-0.37551572918891907,
0.7210310697555542,
-0.7916123270988464,
0.38647177815437317,
-0.3522871434688568,
-0.6732408404350281,
-0.2472720444202423,
0.48132050037384033,
-0.8153231143951416,
0.9956713914871216,
-0.1500130146741867,
-0.5508350729942322,
0.5374774932861328,
-0.7999704480171204,
-0.537542462348938,
-0.14211104810237885,
-0.1034155935049057,
-0.44129714369773865,
-0.06129289045929909,
0.18147122859954834,
0.6718941330909729,
-0.37258395552635193,
0.6861027479171753,
-0.6040884852409363,
-0.23667772114276886,
0.6045151352882385,
-0.8085075616836548,
0.5986432433128357,
-0.03884522616863251,
-0.5866924524307251,
0.045507363975048065,
-0.7669346332550049,
-0.3002074062824249,
0.12955443561077118,
-0.6715430021286011,
-0.13531029224395752,
0.09814026206731796,
-0.2579509913921356,
0.27423933148384094,
0.24241289496421814,
-0.6511726379394531,
0.07449489086866379,
-0.2587061822414398,
0.13325384259223938,
0.7349361777305603,
-0.11337142437696457,
0.029216917231678963,
-0.41946566104888916,
0.24139432609081268,
-0.08053918182849884,
0.02995646744966507,
0.03294854983687401,
-0.39275673031806946,
-0.7493541836738586,
-0.5178824663162231,
0.22939614951610565,
0.4799341559410095,
-0.5524044036865234,
0.586459219455719,
-0.531307578086853,
-0.280354380607605,
-0.18913371860980988,
0.0801200419664383,
0.23655293881893158,
0.523865282535553,
0.11620055139064789,
-0.04025087133049965,
-0.11220443248748779,
-0.8509141206741333,
-0.18182335793972015,
-0.36613401770591736,
0.17256468534469604,
0.13728833198547363,
0.6876668334007263,
-0.2153681069612503,
1.1049827337265015,
-0.450552374124527,
0.17504629492759705,
0.023067248985171318,
0.23203045129776,
0.2714560627937317,
0.11763133108615875,
0.5457204580307007,
-0.7441491484642029,
-0.2171480655670166,
-0.06733735650777817,
-0.7781692147254944,
0.19134487211704254,
0.0006114552961662412,
0.2348596155643463,
0.840400218963623,
0.31084802746772766,
-1.257624626159668,
0.49817052483558655,
0.47188156843185425,
-0.3888252377510071,
0.6282570958137512,
-0.2630487084388733,
0.358210951089859,
-0.8629621267318726,
0.30172199010849,
0.10733562707901001,
-0.6095536351203918,
-0.3591070771217346,
0.18616673350334167,
0.08128716796636581,
0.04126671701669693,
-0.4870116710662842,
0.6236639618873596,
-0.3477621376514435,
-0.05996602773666382,
-0.2819853723049164,
0.2897849977016449,
-0.001671132748015225,
0.3661976456642151,
-0.051957033574581146,
1.0827442407608032,
0.26396963000297546,
-0.49356427788734436,
0.7071366906166077,
-0.19728250801563263,
-0.6367183923721313,
0.1834975928068161,
-0.6499773263931274,
0.38873305916786194,
-0.31065481901168823,
0.6021068692207336,
-0.9677119255065918,
-0.5289683938026428,
0.10657180100679398,
-0.30641230940818787,
0.26466986536979675,
-0.06548619270324707,
-0.8511983156204224,
-0.2893263101577759,
-0.36379268765449524,
0.23027829825878143,
0.48242342472076416,
-0.592170238494873,
0.5526087284088135,
0.11009985953569412,
-0.44177401065826416,
-0.6494081616401672,
-0.2916717231273651,
0.2675963044166565,
-0.163345605134964,
-0.7692330479621887,
-0.1390397697687149,
-0.3083895444869995,
-0.44463902711868286,
-0.004117147531360388,
0.030201490968465805,
0.1185976043343544,
0.237335667014122,
0.2666815221309662,
0.3770207166671753,
-0.3580138683319092,
0.3603875935077667,
-0.2665461301803589,
0.03372702747583389,
0.4121392071247101,
-0.0001671259815338999,
0.4642450511455536,
-0.44588157534599304,
-0.5317366123199463,
-0.24044528603553772,
0.22520871460437775,
0.8319562673568726,
-0.2510039210319519,
0.8916750550270081,
0.40629205107688904,
-0.44452497363090515,
-0.08877793699502945,
-0.9185191988945007,
-0.004048921167850494,
-0.4280800521373749,
0.3401064872741699,
-0.20914284884929657,
-1.1413111686706543,
0.506857693195343,
0.02679309993982315,
0.18932834267616272,
0.6559769511222839,
0.6047888398170471,
0.08611701428890228,
0.8630322813987732,
0.3795812726020813,
-0.3856756389141083,
-0.17894060909748077,
0.08494699746370316,
0.33274364471435547,
-0.04553349316120148,
-0.19031190872192383,
-0.4328467547893524,
0.13402236998081207,
-0.6390642523765564,
-0.6278836727142334,
0.4504588842391968,
-0.11824705451726913,
-0.29542893171310425,
-0.19771331548690796,
0.23972971737384796,
0.5509861707687378,
0.4780227839946747,
0.1942845582962036,
0.32177501916885376,
-0.09417873620986938,
0.07184842973947525,
0.25479525327682495,
-0.2466476410627365,
-0.44726935029029846,
0.9746525883674622,
0.6019672155380249,
0.6772377490997314,
0.374299556016922,
0.6123545169830322,
0.49670225381851196,
0.49255630373954773,
-0.9802563786506653,
0.546479344367981,
0.07044243067502975,
-0.902698814868927,
-0.5506677627563477,
-0.4353044331073761,
-0.49438169598579407,
-0.18212805688381195,
-0.2770155668258667,
-0.42983320355415344,
-0.13906577229499817,
0.10514272004365921,
-0.5079105496406555,
0.1655919849872589,
-0.46493932604789734,
0.5026656985282898,
-0.4591478705406189,
-0.46577516198158264,
-0.29481378197669983,
-0.5981975197792053,
0.5174853205680847,
-0.3776417076587677,
0.36211955547332764,
-0.24300268292427063,
0.038008783012628555,
0.543027400970459,
-0.26376622915267944,
0.9974307417869568,
-0.11333084851503372,
-0.3321709930896759,
0.39415106177330017,
0.03332994878292084,
0.9085114598274231,
0.21122485399246216,
-0.12273095548152924,
0.05121682211756706,
-0.3618963658809662,
-0.33093079924583435,
-0.8731751441955566,
0.6822949051856995,
-0.6960740685462952,
-0.942013680934906,
-0.6707463264465332,
-0.36653417348861694,
-0.2604539394378662,
0.2755848467350006,
-0.14701467752456665,
0.4411605894565582,
-0.33946678042411804,
0.320850670337677,
0.8064928650856018,
-0.15122340619564056,
0.447165310382843,
0.5801318883895874,
-0.3739733099937439,
-0.35350117087364197,
0.7129862904548645,
0.0036047406028956175,
0.3435777425765991,
0.3252856731414795,
0.40033164620399475,
-0.5910042524337769,
-0.4134982228279114,
-0.36988529562950134,
0.3395954966545105,
-0.7928691506385803,
-0.1574070155620575,
-0.5958347916603088,
-0.30627864599227905,
-0.4021521210670471,
0.12860076129436493,
-0.3337737023830414,
-0.35542404651641846,
0.03974903002381325,
-0.46198326349258423,
0.4733673334121704,
0.6686939597129822,
-0.11549758166074753,
-0.10836907476186752,
-0.7873956561088562,
0.4024410843849182,
0.6052908897399902,
0.4587598443031311,
-0.30617401003837585,
-0.4033783972263336,
-0.2344016432762146,
0.1407696157693863,
0.1343705952167511,
-0.46727919578552246,
-0.07627832889556885,
0.14054280519485474,
0.4046143591403961,
0.49044349789619446,
0.16670361161231995,
0.38308918476104736,
-0.4972257614135742,
0.8316684365272522,
0.12490525096654892,
-0.7377676963806152,
0.28368741273880005,
-0.37732064723968506,
-0.0780801996588707,
0.521342396736145,
0.5171566009521484,
-0.37248462438583374,
-0.14163506031036377,
-0.3012925386428833,
-0.5466068387031555,
0.36303526163101196,
0.10922388732433319,
0.07228322327136993,
-0.22853437066078186,
0.29244929552078247,
0.2903992831707001,
0.15181350708007812,
-0.7602763772010803,
-0.016291091218590736,
-0.02191215753555298,
-0.14438487589359283,
-0.38837188482284546,
-0.4529339075088501,
-0.3735432028770447,
-0.1101951003074646,
0.7381836771965027,
-0.29236966371536255,
0.02972075715661049,
0.2597291171550751,
-0.0706268846988678,
-0.0887032151222229,
0.5083357691764832,
0.9411830306053162,
0.8972522616386414,
-0.4359557628631592,
0.2652612626552582,
0.12329693883657455,
-0.3442111611366272,
0.14164836704730988,
0.45500943064689636,
-0.0536549910902977,
-0.036909010261297226,
0.5244506001472473,
0.7060790061950684,
0.07955622673034668,
-0.7508603930473328,
0.7812705039978027,
0.02310814894735813,
-0.16878552734851837,
-0.44565021991729736,
0.0337405726313591,
0.18744412064552307,
0.20466528832912445,
0.2082531899213791,
-0.14206987619400024,
0.13661129772663116,
-0.8023785352706909,
0.1278662532567978,
0.42106613516807556,
-0.06609345227479935,
-0.4136466383934021,
0.4401273727416992,
0.36730480194091797,
-0.043835919350385666,
0.6388314962387085,
-0.26165133714675903,
-0.5722948312759399,
0.472209632396698,
0.4589252769947052,
0.9341143369674683,
0.04120347648859024,
0.15065757930278778,
0.17859797179698944,
0.32877546548843384,
-0.29778000712394714,
0.1414952576160431,
0.09127850830554962,
-0.6339046359062195,
-0.7695944309234619,
-0.5548652410507202,
-0.4354318082332611,
0.320295512676239,
-0.2778484523296356,
0.14250697195529938,
-0.4564805030822754,
-0.22269344329833984,
-0.06687388569116592,
0.1930430680513382,
-0.7264371514320374,
0.3969535231590271,
0.29192599654197693,
1.0528907775878906,
-0.7096767425537109,
0.6785289645195007,
0.5431867241859436,
-0.30501410365104675,
-0.7313780188560486,
0.07026933133602142,
0.08228027075529099,
-0.7546502351760864,
0.692656934261322,
0.27616631984710693,
-0.38936230540275574,
-0.5773420929908752,
-0.8170299530029297,
-1.0018888711929321,
0.9411447048187256,
0.44674983620643616,
-0.698472797870636,
-0.1496082991361618,
0.3383733332157135,
0.4383912980556488,
-0.1544969379901886,
0.09316004067659378,
0.53485107421875,
0.6018536686897278,
-0.012869003228843212,
-1.0064905881881714,
0.3252425193786621,
0.04547989368438721,
-0.4638073444366455,
0.19708971679210663,
-0.7852209806442261,
0.6954965591430664,
-0.34009724855422974,
-0.2589402198791504,
-0.03839743509888649,
0.9118285775184631,
0.42686596512794495,
0.6391854882240295,
0.6679319739341736,
0.4259096682071686,
0.9861224293708801,
0.13985125720500946,
1.07783842086792,
-0.3805299699306488,
0.4549494981765747,
1.0291093587875366,
-0.4082300066947937,
0.7787303924560547,
0.21563506126403809,
-0.1931503564119339,
0.3210769593715668,
0.35371270775794983,
0.26215824484825134,
0.1679454892873764,
0.10463683307170868,
-0.4485533535480499,
-0.34900352358818054,
0.07220359891653061,
-0.11000987887382507,
0.4373392164707184,
0.20089571177959442,
-0.19099590182304382,
-0.1838241070508957,
-0.26104700565338135,
0.5363551378250122,
-0.009347465820610523,
-0.06314972043037415,
0.5576352477073669,
0.050584208220243454,
-0.8225055932998657,
0.5558578372001648,
-0.0013826546492055058,
0.5685743093490601,
-0.5184041857719421,
-0.03510865941643715,
-0.2863210439682007,
-0.02911463938653469,
-0.08732413500547409,
-0.9596716165542603,
-0.12094778567552567,
0.21932406723499298,
-0.33464983105659485,
0.10280285775661469,
0.7350284457206726,
-0.4013586640357971,
-0.5229772329330444,
0.07798521965742111,
0.5337625741958618,
0.1611635982990265,
-0.20900985598564148,
-0.3671383559703827,
-0.07490728050470352,
-0.2529769539833069,
-0.4566640853881836,
0.1841699182987213,
0.4828605055809021,
-0.2105102390050888,
0.6750892400741577,
0.7811033129692078,
0.00024292795569635928,
-0.07713428884744644,
-0.0536874495446682,
0.9001834988594055,
-0.794345498085022,
-0.2496071606874466,
-1.012243628501892,
0.37642911076545715,
-0.22531414031982422,
-0.15091249346733093,
0.6035760641098022,
0.7583238482475281,
0.7303109765052795,
0.0841129869222641,
0.916199803352356,
0.08668061345815659,
0.652788519859314,
-0.7861185073852539,
0.7854866981506348,
-0.29621365666389465,
-0.03276047483086586,
0.04326954111456871,
-0.943641185760498,
-0.20050370693206787,
0.16604524850845337,
-0.31836506724357605,
0.139241024851799,
0.5929579138755798,
0.7839044332504272,
-0.14731062948703766,
-0.05798983573913574,
0.36663585901260376,
0.3431248664855957,
0.6073334813117981,
0.23116326332092285,
0.9889101386070251,
0.009352562017738819,
0.21821735799312592,
-0.24859069287776947,
-0.25591200590133667,
-0.26052215695381165,
-1.1294587850570679,
-1.0637885332107544,
-0.34039369225502014,
-0.3025840222835541,
-0.4598924219608307,
0.3066725730895996,
1.3310734033584595,
0.47692573070526123,
-0.6740835905075073,
-0.05923515185713768,
0.4392019808292389,
0.08052206039428711,
0.2531139552593231,
-0.22298851609230042,
0.6141465306282043,
-0.29373863339424133,
-0.5042948722839355,
0.5587342381477356,
0.23741692304611206,
-0.03300005570054054,
-0.2469959408044815,
-0.125953808426857,
-0.00810878537595272,
0.30937424302101135,
0.891853928565979,
0.30618390440940857,
-0.8387895822525024,
-0.9218536019325256,
-0.00006728078733431175,
-0.22936534881591797,
-0.011157638393342495,
0.6222892999649048,
-0.6888518929481506,
0.27829015254974365,
0.2056281566619873,
0.7218865752220154,
0.2015695720911026,
0.153847336769104,
0.449436217546463,
-0.3966715931892395,
-0.0638062059879303,
0.1627335399389267,
0.3891356289386749,
0.43026161193847656,
-0.42050257325172424,
0.42300114035606384,
0.25425291061401367,
-0.7338343858718872,
-0.7438479065895081,
0.09991408884525299,
-1.0706483125686646,
-0.07597365230321884,
1.442941427230835,
-0.3020819425582886,
-0.37122035026550293,
0.10653340071439743,
0.007625426631420851,
0.18110981583595276,
-0.621981680393219,
0.8950539827346802,
0.8996193408966064,
-0.026125453412532806,
0.0976632609963417,
-0.5563205480575562,
0.6118215918540955,
0.02141893282532692,
-0.9564250707626343,
0.22005853056907654,
0.8443132638931274,
0.5561259388923645,
0.24611493945121765,
0.510347306728363,
0.12219064682722092,
0.3424348533153534,
-0.35144415497779846,
-0.04638535901904106,
-0.15352702140808105,
-0.47765445709228516,
-0.12171406298875809,
0.1263784021139145,
0.2807086110115051,
0.07765035331249237
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19716v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19716v1
|
Capability-aware Prompt Reformulation Learning for Text-to-Image Generation
| 2024-03-27T17:41:16 | 2024-03-27T17:41:16 |
Jingtao Zhan, Qingyao Ai, Yiqun Liu, Jia Chen, Shaoping Ma
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.IR
|
Text-to-image generation systems have emerged as revolutionary tools in the
realm of artistic creation, offering unprecedented ease in transforming textual
prompts into visual art. However, the efficacy of these systems is intricately
linked to the quality of user-provided prompts, which often poses a challenge
to users unfamiliar with prompt crafting. This paper addresses this challenge
by leveraging user reformulation data from interaction logs to develop an
automatic prompt reformulation model. Our in-depth analysis of these logs
reveals that user prompt reformulation is heavily dependent on the individual
user's capability, resulting in significant variance in the quality of
reformulation pairs. To effectively use this data for training, we introduce
the Capability-aware Prompt Reformulation (CAPR) framework. CAPR innovatively
integrates user capability into the reformulation process through two key
components: the Conditional Reformulation Model (CRM) and Configurable
Capability Features (CCF). CRM reformulates prompts according to a specified
user capability, as represented by CCF. The CCF, in turn, offers the
flexibility to tune and guide the CRM's behavior. This enables CAPR to
effectively learn diverse reformulation strategies across various user
capacities and to simulate high-capability user reformulation during inference.
Extensive experiments on standard text-to-image generation benchmarks showcase
CAPR's superior performance over existing baselines and its remarkable
robustness on unseen systems. Furthermore, comprehensive analyses validate the
effectiveness of different components. CAPR can facilitate user-friendly
interaction with text-to-image systems and make advanced artistic creation more
achievable for a broader range of users.
|
[
-0.44313278794288635,
-0.4161623418331146,
0.47346022725105286,
0.022445514798164368,
-0.20665429532527924,
0.036531299352645874,
-0.4859769642353058,
-0.33753305673599243,
-0.051883768290281296,
0.6654720902442932,
-0.8287604451179504,
-0.387893408536911,
-0.2939092814922333,
0.3052841126918793,
0.04310670495033264,
1.0363929271697998,
-0.13695576786994934,
-0.23953738808631897,
-0.27051109075546265,
-0.1647184193134308,
-1.4412399530410767,
-0.2168826460838318,
-0.6950752139091492,
-0.01314521674066782,
0.5831728577613831,
0.7168413400650024,
0.5961794853210449,
0.5022837519645691,
0.3929569721221924,
0.3113950192928314,
0.32077836990356445,
0.32913756370544434,
-0.5249687433242798,
0.436200886964798,
-0.04908984154462814,
-0.3141253590583801,
-0.16616173088550568,
0.03480951488018036,
0.5876100659370422,
0.3566405177116394,
0.20401355624198914,
-0.09928268194198608,
0.4008976221084595,
0.5394160747528076,
-0.456330269575119,
0.3484621047973633,
-0.7073132991790771,
0.05736405774950981,
0.005600211210548878,
-0.29409676790237427,
-0.6137526035308838,
-0.2787204384803772,
-0.05127429589629173,
-1.0674134492874146,
0.5451206564903259,
0.20994079113006592,
0.9165635108947754,
0.1486208736896515,
-0.2895551323890686,
-0.38584479689598083,
-0.5563378930091858,
0.7321400046348572,
-0.14586468040943146,
0.3934575617313385,
0.15506455302238464,
0.6775513887405396,
-0.12237149477005005,
-1.1282902956008911,
-0.5345544815063477,
-0.09208562225103378,
-0.21125110983848572,
0.009296582080423832,
-0.11796678602695465,
0.10908407717943192,
0.3721238970756531,
0.26833605766296387,
-0.27938705682754517,
0.027521824464201927,
-0.4010199308395386,
-0.5240259170532227,
0.5270431637763977,
0.20562538504600525,
0.560092031955719,
-0.3188325762748718,
-0.5920148491859436,
-0.47895923256874084,
-0.5213051438331604,
0.5744657516479492,
0.3298023045063019,
0.4190155863761902,
0.03804686293005943,
0.43977996706962585,
0.007835001684725285,
0.5358933210372925,
0.3073715567588806,
-0.10786296427249908,
0.10631819814443588,
-0.41963309049606323,
-0.10526205599308014,
-0.1858920007944107,
1.025748372077942,
0.45452138781547546,
-0.047871485352516174,
-0.12005401402711868,
-0.6475473642349243,
-0.3318595588207245,
0.3325425684452057,
-0.8922214508056641,
-0.2738914489746094,
-0.18658486008644104,
-0.366026371717453,
-0.06062457337975502,
0.19744724035263062,
-0.5712722539901733,
-0.41602158546447754,
-0.43688929080963135,
0.578679084777832,
-0.8013187050819397,
0.08583376556634903,
-0.21021467447280884,
-0.18235449492931366,
-0.009106875397264957,
0.49799802899360657,
-0.8440721035003662,
-0.09375909715890884,
0.4002159833908081,
0.5108106732368469,
-0.19393065571784973,
-0.17762315273284912,
-0.8308517336845398,
-0.09761777520179749,
-0.40490618348121643,
0.725821852684021,
-0.44627639651298523,
-0.5467322468757629,
-0.027420056983828545,
0.09059973806142807,
-0.014835965819656849,
-0.4604972302913666,
0.4794899821281433,
-0.7023527026176453,
0.29528558254241943,
-0.7712251543998718,
-0.3556854724884033,
-0.15894091129302979,
0.12832020223140717,
-0.9011446237564087,
0.5884717106819153,
0.35009947419166565,
-0.6506325602531433,
0.9009816646575928,
-0.6632593870162964,
-0.20024380087852478,
0.376844197511673,
-0.4283122420310974,
-0.5747615098953247,
-0.1488269865512848,
0.2140929102897644,
0.459523469209671,
-0.1293284147977829,
0.39686498045921326,
0.005503523163497448,
-0.058222781866788864,
0.3453235924243927,
-0.4683937132358551,
0.5023221373558044,
0.405720978975296,
0.04992273449897766,
0.3425874412059784,
-0.4480613172054291,
-0.01905210316181183,
-0.099349744617939,
-0.20510655641555786,
0.12657040357589722,
-0.524385929107666,
0.29406511783599854,
-0.019068963825702667,
0.4006706178188324,
-0.494083434343338,
0.25361940264701843,
0.1410963088274002,
0.27083271741867065,
0.5032886862754822,
0.28712084889411926,
0.5676137804985046,
-0.5940893292427063,
0.6065674424171448,
-0.08948266506195068,
0.15039287507534027,
-0.9593839049339294,
-0.47035154700279236,
-0.3561258316040039,
-0.6789506673812866,
0.2839833199977875,
0.5181230306625366,
-1.0643627643585205,
0.43385085463523865,
0.0032440025825053453,
-0.23401102423667908,
-0.28509417176246643,
0.33413341641426086,
0.5257899165153503,
0.8803424835205078,
0.42190662026405334,
-0.5995803475379944,
-0.38150709867477417,
-0.7319169640541077,
-0.18752461671829224,
-0.26057207584381104,
-0.17051361501216888,
0.3448137640953064,
0.15874677896499634,
-0.029164442792534828,
1.1623135805130005,
-0.3428019881248474,
-0.5756581425666809,
-0.3785087466239929,
0.33486801385879517,
-0.1520262360572815,
0.6971244215965271,
0.3355081379413605,
-0.6561819911003113,
-0.3246373236179352,
-0.12818670272827148,
-0.6071053147315979,
-0.1457241028547287,
-0.7048358917236328,
-0.06281424313783646,
0.20557579398155212,
0.6969109773635864,
-0.3308863937854767,
0.47902020812034607,
0.10329939424991608,
-0.5287055969238281,
0.7118901610374451,
-0.5211236476898193,
0.6132855415344238,
-1.0770710706710815,
0.15133614838123322,
-0.01937839575111866,
-0.19577297568321228,
-0.5527551770210266,
0.03927721828222275,
0.3720582127571106,
-0.29303786158561707,
-0.2939518094062805,
0.4639487862586975,
-0.64037024974823,
0.0014910197351127863,
-0.20972879230976105,
-0.22433266043663025,
0.4064939320087433,
0.3641783595085144,
0.08473556488752365,
0.937547504901886,
0.41157102584838867,
-0.45335063338279724,
0.0836847797036171,
0.40600529313087463,
-0.3520154356956482,
0.7519129514694214,
-0.4746873378753662,
-0.04638132080435753,
-0.13113920390605927,
0.12822717428207397,
-1.2979919910430908,
-0.5043244957923889,
0.25512272119522095,
-0.4356396496295929,
0.5570113062858582,
-0.04512456804513931,
-0.6212149262428284,
-0.10917092114686966,
-0.0656718909740448,
0.5409078001976013,
0.7757897973060608,
-0.6452503204345703,
0.6293020248413086,
-0.02726735547184944,
-0.08251149952411652,
-0.47628140449523926,
-0.4912600517272949,
0.2493716925382614,
-0.14103437960147858,
-0.7229794859886169,
0.38475048542022705,
-0.08364173769950867,
0.23233045637607574,
-0.10111220926046371,
0.32949358224868774,
0.06869897246360779,
-0.22006374597549438,
0.34550929069519043,
0.31797486543655396,
0.036063652485609055,
0.2952249050140381,
0.3088885247707367,
-0.11680390685796738,
-0.1414419412612915,
0.05752892792224884,
0.4168367087841034,
-0.09471168369054794,
-0.609456479549408,
-0.8518127799034119,
0.18634629249572754,
0.35700058937072754,
-0.4175264239311218,
0.44955945014953613,
0.7190255522727966,
-0.06829048693180084,
-0.047501444816589355,
-0.5587365031242371,
-0.4409712851047516,
-0.5375850796699524,
0.06298216432332993,
-0.4251828193664551,
-0.8711367249488831,
0.7299817800521851,
-0.06472435593605042,
0.4444938004016876,
0.2927613854408264,
0.0749717727303505,
-0.16632167994976044,
0.7316429018974304,
0.7627699375152588,
0.5811501145362854,
0.6636894345283508,
-0.38876479864120483,
0.02822938747704029,
-0.8278743028640747,
-0.6504067182540894,
-0.24573564529418945,
-0.4165816903114319,
-0.393662691116333,
-0.377507746219635,
0.46717405319213867,
0.1974724978208542,
-0.20263439416885376,
0.3467842638492584,
-0.527677059173584,
0.3851493000984192,
0.3904974162578583,
0.4221954047679901,
0.3125689625740051,
0.24785006046295166,
-0.11295296996831894,
-0.3141794800758362,
-0.7399441003799438,
-0.569293200969696,
0.899353563785553,
0.2239025980234146,
0.5490847229957581,
-0.2667448818683624,
0.6776717901229858,
0.33883732557296753,
0.5123529434204102,
-0.8663815855979919,
0.6648618578910828,
0.023006722331047058,
-0.19735801219940186,
-0.4987764060497284,
-0.21336768567562103,
-1.0564689636230469,
-0.34383058547973633,
-0.516448974609375,
-0.4255523979663849,
0.31907132267951965,
0.471934050321579,
-0.3471889793872833,
0.4712962508201599,
-0.8017616868019104,
0.8265947103500366,
0.050770144909620285,
-0.32986271381378174,
0.09669166058301926,
-0.5541203022003174,
0.1963055431842804,
-0.19512459635734558,
0.03293181210756302,
0.09353628754615784,
-0.2437879890203476,
0.46248722076416016,
-0.4313070774078369,
1.0961949825286865,
-0.2859361469745636,
0.061934005469083786,
0.5100282430648804,
0.19873476028442383,
0.2744641900062561,
0.10625915974378586,
-0.06364274770021439,
-0.05079429969191551,
-0.3098776936531067,
-0.29531267285346985,
-0.6729380488395691,
0.4747385084629059,
-0.5280635356903076,
-0.7395516633987427,
0.11812111735343933,
-0.7842076420783997,
0.03667939826846123,
0.25319093465805054,
0.6125072836875916,
0.6380975842475891,
-0.31677713990211487,
0.0703950896859169,
0.7253465056419373,
-0.28800246119499207,
0.6057620644569397,
0.09092964231967926,
-0.11405616253614426,
-0.6458030343055725,
0.810838520526886,
0.1439201831817627,
0.1639241874217987,
0.18948698043823242,
-0.03611089661717415,
-0.45462584495544434,
-0.34617969393730164,
-0.8488934636116028,
0.02457387186586857,
-0.6850774884223938,
-0.45097512006759644,
-0.48966699838638306,
-0.15114499628543854,
-0.12469810992479324,
-0.5139104723930359,
-0.03268003091216087,
-0.2196134328842163,
-0.7601969242095947,
0.3461047112941742,
0.5539777278900146,
0.2897680997848511,
0.049215320497751236,
0.4230751097202301,
-0.7440111041069031,
0.19285105168819427,
0.5550298094749451,
0.386309951543808,
-0.11055127531290054,
-0.7643612623214722,
0.1257823258638382,
-0.16545066237449646,
-0.5987491011619568,
-0.935941755771637,
0.3128089904785156,
0.26096197962760925,
0.38721996545791626,
0.6140567064285278,
0.24891318380832672,
0.3286404311656952,
-0.44144493341445923,
0.7817935943603516,
0.6390431523323059,
-0.8067353367805481,
0.4609755277633667,
-0.2810373306274414,
0.3163279891014099,
0.7072400450706482,
0.04066164046525955,
-0.5553416013717651,
-0.26477038860321045,
-0.6144056916236877,
-0.6013935804367065,
0.49515289068222046,
-0.007278946693986654,
0.34444019198417664,
0.12000121921300888,
0.470575213432312,
0.6032458543777466,
0.15398676693439484,
-0.4059090316295624,
0.2675950825214386,
-0.5330045819282532,
-0.2951405942440033,
0.017731614410877228,
-0.017946835607290268,
-0.022339319810271263,
0.03152598813176155,
0.3650009036064148,
-0.2877395749092102,
-0.12043968588113785,
0.26265212893486023,
0.015565917827188969,
-0.12462004274129868,
0.29887816309928894,
0.18310734629631042,
0.5810309052467346,
0.35396575927734375,
-0.17505435645580292,
0.10842739790678024,
-0.4505971372127533,
0.2848207354545593,
-0.03979017958045006,
-0.4018550217151642,
-0.18285684287548065,
0.35310301184654236,
1.128082513809204,
-0.04897967725992203,
-0.7398955225944519,
0.6440461874008179,
-0.22356002032756805,
-0.35755592584609985,
-0.08540357649326324,
0.40221869945526123,
-0.3650965094566345,
0.12375166267156601,
0.5117851495742798,
0.41456884145736694,
0.23588618636131287,
-0.23838336765766144,
0.275333046913147,
0.5347718596458435,
-0.6885920763015747,
-0.3155718147754669,
0.5550372004508972,
0.19506292045116425,
-0.4386863708496094,
0.5235009789466858,
-0.54571932554245,
-0.13395971059799194,
0.6085307002067566,
0.5093989968299866,
0.7325229644775391,
-0.2104373425245285,
0.4526299238204956,
0.48111799359321594,
0.24679017066955566,
0.04927190765738487,
0.35187259316444397,
-0.19189424812793732,
-0.5534459352493286,
-0.304423063993454,
-0.15535613894462585,
-0.2434236854314804,
0.17380496859550476,
-0.6212843060493469,
0.5255479216575623,
-0.46290135383605957,
-0.4630929231643677,
-0.22217226028442383,
-0.14595960080623627,
-0.8939172029495239,
0.21170257031917572,
-0.3548193871974945,
0.8567220568656921,
-0.7515398263931274,
0.33101940155029297,
0.8783807754516602,
-0.475803017616272,
-1.057847499847412,
0.12430784106254578,
-0.2199990302324295,
-0.604855477809906,
0.5523313879966736,
0.4951552450656891,
0.23224793374538422,
0.023685386404395103,
-0.4489114582538605,
-0.16452690958976746,
1.3809609413146973,
0.5147413015365601,
-0.5802047252655029,
0.2494877278804779,
0.031702253967523575,
0.4057030975818634,
-0.6454823613166809,
0.1788518875837326,
0.32482364773750305,
0.402496337890625,
0.32739949226379395,
-0.6944703459739685,
0.44069409370422363,
-0.009029140695929527,
0.3439948260784149,
0.12874892354011536,
-0.6188918352127075,
0.5199378728866577,
-0.6719756126403809,
-0.5599703788757324,
0.24574925005435944,
0.9059297442436218,
0.41300201416015625,
0.5706919431686401,
0.8374778628349304,
0.3131366968154907,
0.7706568241119385,
-0.11801967769861221,
0.6794120669364929,
-0.38206055760383606,
-0.2671450078487396,
0.6319372057914734,
0.11709855496883392,
0.48846435546875,
0.5246126651763916,
0.47258374094963074,
0.556130051612854,
0.5128077268600464,
-0.09915332496166229,
0.37808674573898315,
-0.09008081257343292,
-0.4990001916885376,
-0.3726678192615509,
-0.1984039843082428,
-0.12602145969867706,
0.1872578114271164,
0.20142509043216705,
-0.482718288898468,
-0.11632046848535538,
0.3238776624202728,
-0.0021869889460504055,
0.4787213206291199,
-0.25789666175842285,
0.8512764573097229,
-0.2661779224872589,
-0.797398030757904,
0.5293747186660767,
-0.08674939721822739,
0.5807404518127441,
-0.4150795340538025,
-0.2034817337989807,
-0.15772107243537903,
-0.3931114375591278,
-0.22252130508422852,
-1.1158607006072998,
0.034436214715242386,
0.09099790453910828,
-0.2047886699438095,
-0.3274002969264984,
0.9110187888145447,
-0.45599961280822754,
-0.26185861229896545,
-0.2642883360385895,
0.38652291893959045,
-0.053900010883808136,
0.15529577434062958,
-0.44586941599845886,
0.26999372243881226,
0.15283367037773132,
-0.10077525675296783,
0.23875044286251068,
0.6583052277565002,
-0.2139093279838562,
0.6064695715904236,
0.6027758121490479,
-0.17311090230941772,
-0.46513015031814575,
0.0077837142162024975,
0.9289475083351135,
-0.2602781355381012,
-0.45932433009147644,
-0.45333361625671387,
0.8444398045539856,
-0.061839509755373,
-0.29161909222602844,
0.3106587529182434,
0.46793103218078613,
0.6755791306495667,
-0.24163559079170227,
0.8441585898399353,
0.006908029783517122,
-0.024684488773345947,
-0.5267436504364014,
0.9751057028770447,
-0.34546253085136414,
0.3599630296230316,
0.022332657128572464,
-0.694446861743927,
-0.1426151692867279,
0.040349531918764114,
-0.35595273971557617,
0.13601382076740265,
0.3258497416973114,
0.9267016649246216,
-0.3140909671783447,
0.026078080758452415,
0.31146833300590515,
-0.4504905045032501,
0.4845363199710846,
0.25724726915359497,
0.6444384455680847,
-0.3383116126060486,
0.7767296433448792,
-0.1159396767616272,
-0.5083387494087219,
-0.0845029279589653,
-1.1533480882644653,
-0.8362192511558533,
-1.005307912826538,
-0.22259409725666046,
-0.20145294070243835,
-0.07549800723791122,
0.8957465887069702,
0.6909143924713135,
-0.5441676378250122,
-0.06619541347026825,
-0.185015007853508,
-0.16777554154396057,
-0.12224937230348587,
-0.2348155379295349,
0.17873965203762054,
-0.8069505095481873,
-0.4658908247947693,
0.05418342724442482,
0.10475800931453705,
0.22650794684886932,
-0.14951683580875397,
-0.2128256857395172,
0.6584625840187073,
0.10395026206970215,
0.4257028102874756,
0.5244755148887634,
-0.5039089918136597,
-0.15684162080287933,
0.019717250019311905,
-0.06825654953718185,
0.16581730544567108,
1.0244516134262085,
-0.9235938191413879,
0.78067946434021,
0.5345661640167236,
0.6637573838233948,
0.14972399175167084,
0.006991707254201174,
0.532477855682373,
-0.9659401178359985,
-0.016646843403577805,
-0.0008039967506192625,
0.18154875934123993,
0.7619143128395081,
-0.5813236236572266,
-0.0782279372215271,
0.1810234636068344,
-0.5134926438331604,
-0.5812331438064575,
0.47763609886169434,
-0.9626675248146057,
-0.1645827293395996,
0.7750813961029053,
-0.25058311223983765,
0.04046677052974701,
0.08278613537549973,
-0.742247998714447,
0.4732572138309479,
-0.8001411557197571,
0.8921540975570679,
0.25271958112716675,
-0.14406487345695496,
-0.46081042289733887,
-0.018221791833639145,
0.6366538405418396,
0.18715611100196838,
-0.8043886423110962,
0.04384027421474457,
0.7607353329658508,
0.23146070539951324,
0.1402483731508255,
0.5294269323348999,
-0.1728932410478592,
0.558940589427948,
-0.262545645236969,
0.31390896439552307,
-0.5566264986991882,
-0.5405697226524353,
-0.22726546227931976,
0.3261331021785736,
0.23910434544086456,
-0.0724087730050087
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18783v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18783v1
|
Towards a World-English Language Model for On-Device Virtual Assistants
| 2024-03-27T17:31:39 | 2024-03-27T17:31:39 |
Rricha Jalota, Lyan Verwimp, Markus Nussbaum-Thom, Amr Mousa, Arturo Argueta, Youssef Oualil
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Neural Network Language Models (NNLMs) for Virtual Assistants (VAs) are
generally language-, region-, and in some cases, device-dependent, which
increases the effort to scale and maintain them. Combining NNLMs for one or
more of the categories is one way to improve scalability. In this work, we
combine regional variants of English to build a ``World English'' NNLM for
on-device VAs. In particular, we investigate the application of adapter
bottlenecks to model dialect-specific characteristics in our existing
production NNLMs {and enhance the multi-dialect baselines}. We find that
adapter modules are more effective in modeling dialects than specializing
entire sub-networks. Based on this insight and leveraging the design of our
production models, we introduce a new architecture for World English NNLM that
meets the accuracy, latency, and memory constraints of our single-dialect
models.
|
[
-0.6075471043586731,
-0.5594430565834045,
0.2851455509662628,
0.3037249445915222,
0.010795851238071918,
-0.2788759768009186,
-0.16949160397052765,
-0.6093106269836426,
0.637744665145874,
0.8023397326469421,
-0.24015867710113525,
0.06099359691143036,
-0.1511085331439972,
0.2523554563522339,
-0.09956417232751846,
0.40821000933647156,
0.28527891635894775,
-0.0689210295677185,
-0.38903605937957764,
-0.4154263138771057,
-0.6639324426651001,
-0.5009767413139343,
-0.9560399651527405,
-0.29770001769065857,
0.29507380723953247,
0.3626231849193573,
0.6382178068161011,
0.6210171580314636,
0.34479767084121704,
0.3778187334537506,
-0.2608811557292938,
0.3747064769268036,
0.09102904796600342,
0.3079356849193573,
0.06483113765716553,
-0.4197409451007843,
-0.9764419198036194,
-0.38211044669151306,
0.23900778591632843,
0.6217198967933655,
-0.17857596278190613,
-0.2725277543067932,
-0.08646683394908905,
0.1286562979221344,
-0.19962015748023987,
-0.09071803092956543,
-0.768667995929718,
0.021784361451864243,
0.5221680402755737,
0.12358203530311584,
-0.40217694640159607,
-0.3058951199054718,
0.40864434838294983,
-0.9012744426727295,
0.2826782464981079,
-0.04485679045319557,
0.9160663485527039,
0.07354658842086792,
-0.3150865137577057,
0.09425175935029984,
-1.049276351928711,
0.5907884240150452,
-0.818914532661438,
0.6789992451667786,
0.18169787526130676,
0.46208950877189636,
0.02468734048306942,
-0.7611916661262512,
-0.7997980713844299,
-0.3503471612930298,
0.1749582141637802,
-0.07651370763778687,
-0.31722331047058105,
0.11693280190229416,
-0.1506364345550537,
0.20110109448432922,
-0.3195245563983917,
0.4008631408214569,
-0.2122279852628708,
-0.005534407217055559,
0.6082687973976135,
0.24743260443210602,
0.381477028131485,
0.2110397219657898,
-0.17151571810245514,
0.447797030210495,
-0.7221078276634216,
-0.4063997268676758,
-0.031957246363162994,
0.6180037260055542,
-0.32603925466537476,
0.11059994250535965,
-0.2884730398654938,
1.0506385564804077,
-0.00504628662019968,
-0.2694037854671478,
0.08466275781393051,
-0.4622511565685272,
-0.1659409999847412,
-0.17105261981487274,
0.6373564600944519,
0.5586335062980652,
0.15430356562137604,
-0.39831316471099854,
-0.33350080251693726,
-0.17482909560203552,
0.4998801052570343,
-0.624908447265625,
-0.21556027233600616,
0.2828482687473297,
-0.2783033549785614,
-0.3554234206676483,
-0.3774196207523346,
-0.661900520324707,
-0.4577797055244446,
-0.3365919888019562,
0.5183800458908081,
-0.15132975578308105,
-0.6358570456504822,
0.05205070599913597,
-0.14356736838817596,
0.11717909574508667,
0.16984021663665771,
-0.7748778462409973,
0.6752970218658447,
0.5031570792198181,
1.1727851629257202,
-0.019181808456778526,
-0.4446336328983307,
-0.3262801766395569,
-0.12121304124593735,
-0.2540346384048462,
0.6485576629638672,
-0.30474627017974854,
-0.4782496392726898,
0.22956334054470062,
0.12013892084360123,
0.09316330403089523,
-0.7941198945045471,
0.15083326399326324,
-0.44318029284477234,
0.26892387866973877,
-0.07132117450237274,
-0.3323448598384857,
-0.08087093383073807,
0.5336719751358032,
-0.9199511408805847,
0.7544886469841003,
-0.17476385831832886,
-0.333222359418869,
0.29661059379577637,
-0.7292087078094482,
-0.5076428651809692,
0.010592950507998466,
0.12765875458717346,
-0.2960908114910126,
0.34959933161735535,
0.3305291533470154,
0.5216876268386841,
-0.4907887279987335,
0.18871429562568665,
-0.12389285862445831,
-0.2330981194972992,
0.029643915593624115,
-0.46879270672798157,
0.6709316372871399,
0.02374514564871788,
-0.008478492498397827,
-0.10942405462265015,
-1.0690429210662842,
-0.08012306690216064,
0.12697744369506836,
-0.37827008962631226,
-0.4961403012275696,
0.12201698124408722,
0.4233080744743347,
0.23524492979049683,
0.22600099444389343,
-0.7699414491653442,
0.3354038596153259,
-0.5628780126571655,
0.6246278882026672,
0.3281152546405792,
-0.1894199103116989,
0.4543597400188446,
-0.5165587663650513,
0.5045520663261414,
-0.09673785418272018,
0.20393158495426178,
-0.08385864645242691,
-0.5572660565376282,
-0.9360671639442444,
-0.02676329016685486,
0.20137527585029602,
0.5673264265060425,
-0.9499244093894958,
0.34201449155807495,
-0.46562913060188293,
-0.5597651600837708,
-0.44673028588294983,
-0.02206292748451233,
0.3856830894947052,
0.36341145634651184,
0.15576571226119995,
-0.5270163416862488,
-0.7625925540924072,
-0.8617132306098938,
-0.020034529268741608,
-0.34119129180908203,
-0.17044991254806519,
0.4815582036972046,
-0.14598706364631653,
-0.08846811950206757,
0.9969342350959778,
-0.12661340832710266,
-0.18922744691371918,
-0.5975676774978638,
-0.3702857494354248,
0.11620798707008362,
0.1833358258008957,
0.45210495591163635,
-0.8977587819099426,
-0.6070478558540344,
0.614790141582489,
-0.7141239047050476,
-0.3727650046348572,
-0.1148492693901062,
0.3350944519042969,
0.24326616525650024,
0.44592469930648804,
-0.4755341112613678,
0.12948590517044067,
0.5128395557403564,
-0.20654569566249847,
0.5778738260269165,
-0.5518856048583984,
-0.2068789154291153,
-1.4943641424179077,
-0.3821481466293335,
0.3686195909976959,
-0.20156534016132355,
-1.1169761419296265,
0.20304429531097412,
0.007465710863471031,
-0.02655945159494877,
-0.854083240032196,
0.8297425508499146,
-0.5245205163955688,
-0.11213809251785278,
-0.42810970544815063,
0.2602943778038025,
0.5136394500732422,
0.25216859579086304,
0.06664380431175232,
0.8609427809715271,
0.5016906261444092,
-0.9575036764144897,
0.42606204748153687,
0.023096997290849686,
0.11270903795957565,
0.7605599164962769,
-0.9009427428245544,
-0.07052899897098541,
0.02478790283203125,
-0.18966133892536163,
-0.6556532979011536,
-0.0773167833685875,
-0.6468052268028259,
-0.193800687789917,
0.19581778347492218,
-0.3076722025871277,
-0.14648015797138214,
-0.11578983813524246,
0.036673665046691895,
0.10328003764152527,
0.500914454460144,
-0.8128504157066345,
0.9120157361030579,
0.5705347657203674,
0.042740218341350555,
-0.2390652596950531,
-0.6796387434005737,
0.17324106395244598,
-0.42478567361831665,
-0.8724622130393982,
0.6785102486610413,
0.19170300662517548,
-0.42131224274635315,
0.023357419297099113,
0.04562680050730705,
-0.5304754376411438,
0.12105216085910797,
0.11802756786346436,
0.2000742107629776,
-0.7532747983932495,
-0.01786629669368267,
-0.15988761186599731,
0.15564222633838654,
-0.13747915625572205,
-0.4961570203304291,
0.41821444034576416,
0.08377456665039062,
0.009770340286195278,
-0.46851781010627747,
0.3682692050933838,
0.78920978307724,
-0.15261483192443848,
0.7018203139305115,
0.20116093754768372,
-0.6384814381599426,
-0.35325348377227783,
-0.6399959325790405,
-0.06146307662129402,
-0.49275773763656616,
0.7209465503692627,
-0.6773068904876709,
-0.6866061091423035,
0.6097619533538818,
-0.13971872627735138,
0.35345762968063354,
0.07873053848743439,
0.40497148036956787,
0.09280475229024887,
0.6156529188156128,
0.8975275158882141,
-0.27458125352859497,
0.5457929372787476,
-0.19660896062850952,
0.2989015281200409,
-1.0287621021270752,
-0.10766491293907166,
-0.47187164425849915,
-0.14931240677833557,
-0.5715109705924988,
-0.4400661289691925,
0.4026266932487488,
-0.012257429771125317,
-0.22578352689743042,
0.6301410794258118,
-0.31446656584739685,
0.622170627117157,
0.48675280809402466,
-0.23872904479503632,
0.19140665233135223,
0.23028364777565002,
-0.1445130705833435,
-0.03433316946029663,
-0.9934213757514954,
-0.5908345580101013,
1.138047695159912,
0.24035479128360748,
0.5638704895973206,
0.4906036853790283,
0.4344685673713684,
0.07447344064712524,
0.060170210897922516,
-0.5584494471549988,
0.5180820226669312,
-0.676798403263092,
-0.22389066219329834,
-0.21058794856071472,
-0.20995186269283295,
-1.0636245012283325,
0.573671281337738,
-0.013446494936943054,
-0.9414150714874268,
0.18991835415363312,
0.4022895395755768,
-0.43988481163978577,
0.5368285179138184,
-0.8186940550804138,
0.8816260695457458,
-0.18489143252372742,
-0.33271241188049316,
0.23598754405975342,
-0.11270751804113388,
0.10009536147117615,
0.20054011046886444,
0.1957438737154007,
0.13667909801006317,
-0.14677844941616058,
0.2441873997449875,
-0.5804342031478882,
0.761110782623291,
-0.1666044145822525,
0.19173674285411835,
0.2984282970428467,
0.12534813582897186,
0.3451627194881439,
0.0335790254175663,
-0.18725530803203583,
0.3905867338180542,
-0.34877169132232666,
-0.26402828097343445,
-0.598975419998169,
1.037480354309082,
-0.8896459937095642,
-0.5564334392547607,
0.04271657392382622,
-0.3482796847820282,
-0.4368562400341034,
0.07872691005468369,
0.0701599270105362,
0.839048445224762,
-0.6015535593032837,
-0.06854985654354095,
0.707730770111084,
-0.33603566884994507,
0.5888643264770508,
0.5890522003173828,
-0.4920220375061035,
-0.1707201451063156,
1.0366402864456177,
0.3230508863925934,
0.5890864133834839,
0.4975505471229553,
0.20891989767551422,
-0.23344573378562927,
-0.37959161400794983,
-0.8920426368713379,
-0.06041104719042778,
-0.3848952651023865,
0.024893926456570625,
-0.7477693557739258,
-0.30914053320884705,
-0.2886706292629242,
-0.11240677535533905,
-0.47123080492019653,
-0.47208142280578613,
-0.22317300736904144,
-0.028632214292883873,
0.5612280964851379,
1.0358058214187622,
0.10557438433170319,
0.6967206001281738,
-0.5352115631103516,
0.2476486712694168,
0.4424645006656647,
0.4174313545227051,
0.02286636084318161,
-0.6831961274147034,
-0.3544032573699951,
-0.22736257314682007,
-0.3849807381629944,
-0.8326286673545837,
0.5251824855804443,
0.48016586899757385,
0.5258538126945496,
0.19892190396785736,
-0.4516463875770569,
0.599914014339447,
-0.767002522945404,
0.978745698928833,
-0.03855941444635391,
-0.5924155116081238,
0.25292205810546875,
-0.1510034203529358,
0.3524971604347229,
0.050977375358343124,
0.1461951732635498,
-0.7644974589347839,
-0.2037288099527359,
-0.3231531083583832,
-0.9103049635887146,
0.48418426513671875,
-0.0881904661655426,
0.5954757928848267,
-0.06486142426729202,
0.28985628485679626,
-0.04133150354027748,
-0.11334163695573807,
-0.6227933168411255,
-0.37044355273246765,
-0.07202641665935516,
-0.14753969013690948,
0.20113146305084229,
-0.08377035707235336,
0.2771868407726288,
-0.17063194513320923,
0.672764003276825,
-0.11763869971036911,
0.35658079385757446,
0.20256875455379486,
0.1096758246421814,
0.25530365109443665,
0.1766466498374939,
0.3784315586090088,
0.46506267786026,
0.06436567008495331,
-0.019665470346808434,
0.4224313199520111,
-0.4965806007385254,
0.3067643344402313,
-0.1108846664428711,
-0.4588838517665863,
0.4844781756401062,
0.27626848220825195,
1.0241401195526123,
-0.012134216725826263,
-0.5065679550170898,
0.33993208408355713,
-0.5072404742240906,
0.0634390339255333,
-0.3975646495819092,
0.07978260517120361,
0.428911417722702,
0.11145182698965073,
-0.11417137831449509,
0.016305148601531982,
-0.012344337068498135,
-0.2978664040565491,
0.12317867577075958,
0.4482289254665375,
-0.3811608552932739,
-0.398804634809494,
0.7934961915016174,
0.5393086075782776,
-0.9811458587646484,
0.353633314371109,
-0.4018097519874573,
-0.35774561762809753,
1.0602666139602661,
0.9526205062866211,
0.9910634160041809,
-0.43772196769714355,
-0.017558852210640907,
0.21560615301132202,
0.5843247175216675,
0.007207150105386972,
0.66533362865448,
0.45777514576911926,
-0.8367925882339478,
-0.40750065445899963,
-0.6318013668060303,
-0.3851397931575775,
0.311955988407135,
-0.419291228055954,
0.40019723773002625,
-0.5455949306488037,
-0.29086834192276,
0.0228990837931633,
-0.5152853727340698,
-0.9840225577354431,
0.30806323885917664,
-0.09754624217748642,
0.83525550365448,
-0.8588767647743225,
1.0488557815551758,
0.982525110244751,
-0.06746529787778854,
-0.8362154960632324,
0.12601931393146515,
-0.10292021185159683,
-0.4870697557926178,
0.14436571300029755,
0.10146407037973404,
0.2627620995044708,
-0.3428660035133362,
0.3559269607067108,
-0.8944592475891113,
0.8458371758460999,
0.21604283154010773,
-0.8149807453155518,
0.016280343756079674,
0.21787935495376587,
0.639379620552063,
-0.6206148266792297,
0.4318505823612213,
0.4784858226776123,
-0.06831733137369156,
-0.37290528416633606,
-1.3893314599990845,
-0.25781992077827454,
-0.3864770829677582,
0.3819747865200043,
0.3376736640930176,
-0.6234893798828125,
1.034464716911316,
0.018207725137472153,
0.41093310713768005,
-0.12155498564243317,
0.4773319661617279,
-0.0168728306889534,
0.20522361993789673,
0.499863862991333,
0.5456821322441101,
0.46840333938598633,
0.14233949780464172,
0.9611852169036865,
-0.4059266149997711,
-0.17357084155082703,
1.2971699237823486,
-0.3937340974807739,
0.9516736268997192,
0.5173576474189758,
-0.30939915776252747,
0.4157756268978119,
0.14976777136325836,
0.5759943723678589,
0.2521529495716095,
0.17825637757778168,
-0.5064337849617004,
0.06315676122903824,
-0.402479887008667,
-0.18526221811771393,
0.4788724184036255,
0.37535950541496277,
-0.18782496452331543,
0.19337479770183563,
0.17365030944347382,
0.06478781253099442,
0.21694670617580414,
-0.3379318118095398,
1.0134307146072388,
0.027680547907948494,
-0.572799563407898,
0.6157639622688293,
0.3359846770763397,
0.9417351484298706,
-0.32011523842811584,
0.1254773885011673,
-0.7250563502311707,
0.016921278089284897,
0.022831907495856285,
-0.10762576013803482,
0.5977414846420288,
0.24550466239452362,
-0.28506678342819214,
0.125608429312706,
0.6049426198005676,
-0.37769922614097595,
-0.7559109330177307,
0.35603368282318115,
0.542275607585907,
0.24249562621116638,
0.028284868225455284,
-0.3155316412448883,
0.14278103411197662,
-0.14913679659366608,
-0.10465971380472183,
0.3444414734840393,
0.5804445743560791,
-0.18830963969230652,
0.553161084651947,
0.25114303827285767,
0.47855135798454285,
0.5706978440284729,
0.12771691381931305,
0.5194600224494934,
-0.4158964157104492,
-0.6441635489463806,
-0.7900054454803467,
0.5342345833778381,
-0.25642985105514526,
-0.6621087193489075,
0.6330994367599487,
0.5440570116043091,
1.0231369733810425,
0.03643633797764778,
1.04813551902771,
-0.18135426938533783,
0.19251184165477753,
-0.3067011833190918,
0.6918324828147888,
-1.0085740089416504,
0.4291238486766815,
0.11178991943597794,
-0.8359670639038086,
-0.19451293349266052,
0.4855039715766907,
0.19861260056495667,
-0.1112462505698204,
0.29364585876464844,
1.0135843753814697,
-0.5341854095458984,
0.009120311588048935,
0.7267413139343262,
0.1850295513868332,
0.26873454451560974,
0.5457387566566467,
0.27047762274742126,
-0.559439480304718,
0.3882599174976349,
-0.5804923176765442,
0.030081583186984062,
-0.17947988212108612,
-0.8870998024940491,
-0.7369702458381653,
-0.5335850119590759,
-0.36812907457351685,
-0.389762818813324,
-0.015323962084949017,
1.0203959941864014,
0.9184854030609131,
-0.671247661113739,
-0.5971372723579407,
-0.05473398044705391,
0.12333258986473083,
-0.3575052320957184,
-0.13860298693180084,
-0.059423040598630905,
-0.16878077387809753,
-0.8802278637886047,
0.6941744685173035,
0.25306829810142517,
0.021453704684972763,
-0.5910662412643433,
-0.3022984564304352,
0.1057022213935852,
0.4619116485118866,
0.6418554782867432,
0.272493451833725,
-0.9560107588768005,
-0.18136359751224518,
0.22579215466976166,
0.09203869849443436,
0.18070153892040253,
0.736754834651947,
-0.6651782393455505,
0.9471627473831177,
0.27704206109046936,
0.8908734917640686,
0.0342608317732811,
-0.48233655095100403,
0.7333517670631409,
-1.1927051544189453,
0.4627244770526886,
0.13424769043922424,
0.655949592590332,
0.4510580897331238,
-0.17403709888458252,
0.21086730062961578,
0.08764448761940002,
-0.43365198373794556,
-0.9111062288284302,
0.27480536699295044,
-0.610645592212677,
-0.08091802150011063,
1.071154236793518,
-0.2871685326099396,
-0.15671095252037048,
-0.48656514286994934,
-0.12078402191400528,
-0.013930379413068295,
-0.038026049733161926,
0.6366891264915466,
0.4727722406387329,
0.04411676526069641,
-0.11246752738952637,
-0.757664680480957,
0.17071379721164703,
0.46509701013565063,
-0.8061994314193726,
-0.06826773285865784,
0.31013181805610657,
0.33479464054107666,
0.11772187799215317,
0.7497833371162415,
0.39633864164352417,
0.29490333795547485,
0.21632073819637299,
0.424179345369339,
-0.08004723489284515,
-0.5837064981460571,
-0.6125637888908386,
0.12287819385528564,
0.441094309091568,
-0.3488275110721588
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18771v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18771v1
|
CheckEval: Robust Evaluation Framework using Large Language Model via Checklist
| 2024-03-27T17:20:39 | 2024-03-27T17:20:39 |
Yukyung Lee, Joonghoon Kim, Jaehee Kim, Hyowon Cho, Pilsung Kang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce CheckEval, a novel evaluation framework using Large Language
Models, addressing the challenges of ambiguity and inconsistency in current
evaluation methods. CheckEval addresses these challenges by dividing evaluation
criteria into detailed sub-aspects and constructing a checklist of Boolean
questions for each, simplifying the evaluation. This approach not only renders
the process more interpretable but also significantly enhances the robustness
and reliability of results by focusing on specific evaluation dimensions.
Validated through a focused case study using the SummEval benchmark, CheckEval
indicates a strong correlation with human judgments. Furthermore, it
demonstrates a highly consistent Inter-Annotator Agreement. These findings
highlight the effectiveness of CheckEval for objective, flexible, and precise
evaluations. By offering a customizable and interactive framework, CheckEval
sets a new standard for the use of LLMs in evaluation, responding to the
evolving needs of the field and establishing a clear method for future
LLM-based evaluation.
|
[
-0.22559808194637299,
-0.5361552238464355,
0.26523759961128235,
0.4228900372982025,
-0.11083722114562988,
0.441785991191864,
-0.20772849023342133,
-0.7803257703781128,
0.05073301121592522,
0.40912213921546936,
-0.45163097977638245,
-0.5706150531768799,
-0.6150562763214111,
-0.04069000855088234,
-0.4718669652938843,
0.9653834104537964,
-0.3097364604473114,
0.03107023425400257,
-0.3905037045478821,
-0.41166701912879944,
-0.07227011024951935,
-0.5249740481376648,
-0.29924967885017395,
-0.6942470669746399,
0.05953006073832512,
0.2039392739534378,
0.8503037691116333,
0.15877342224121094,
0.8884141445159912,
0.35780373215675354,
-0.18537291884422302,
0.32560327649116516,
-0.49977779388427734,
0.28560835123062134,
-0.39975279569625854,
-0.3853052854537964,
-0.5739152431488037,
-0.1928091049194336,
0.42121046781539917,
0.6658419370651245,
-0.3066219985485077,
0.6252570748329163,
-0.07292696088552475,
0.4419853091239929,
-0.9331438541412354,
0.17987871170043945,
-0.5225733518600464,
-0.0009067936334758997,
0.16204950213432312,
-0.11712761968374252,
-0.11560654640197754,
-0.7232177257537842,
0.11924347281455994,
-0.1407928466796875,
-0.13772262632846832,
-0.11467590183019638,
0.7060718536376953,
0.34991174936294556,
-0.3502349257469177,
-0.1577911376953125,
-0.5688248872756958,
0.7780465483665466,
-0.7593177556991577,
0.6396443247795105,
0.49257203936576843,
0.5281678438186646,
0.08941234648227692,
-0.7420288324356079,
-0.32090064883232117,
-0.4575199782848358,
0.30122798681259155,
0.1806117743253708,
-0.033924128860235214,
-0.03298713266849518,
0.20887978374958038,
0.7853397727012634,
-0.4959868788719177,
0.10618195682764053,
0.020938921719789505,
-0.42059919238090515,
0.7560563683509827,
0.22211895883083344,
0.2855880558490753,
0.09608269482851028,
-0.4622843563556671,
0.08988340944051743,
-0.6650490164756775,
0.22477562725543976,
0.006062218453735113,
0.1890200674533844,
-0.24837887287139893,
0.8182505965232849,
-0.44379764795303345,
0.5027139782905579,
0.06432300060987473,
-0.10549794882535934,
0.17020170390605927,
-0.549257755279541,
-0.3805191218852997,
-0.13494811952114105,
0.6065078973770142,
0.5640876889228821,
0.0014405885012820363,
-0.06041346490383148,
-0.6119273900985718,
0.31878751516342163,
0.05408415570855141,
-0.9254630208015442,
-0.16695886850357056,
0.4306342303752899,
-0.5317321419715881,
-0.6707236766815186,
-0.11365319043397903,
-0.8541142344474792,
-0.7472757697105408,
-0.22191987931728363,
0.6015872955322266,
-0.22166499495506287,
-0.1158997192978859,
0.276937335729599,
0.3572700619697571,
0.32844677567481995,
0.5585722327232361,
-0.6572535634040833,
0.5114363431930542,
0.7143735289573669,
0.6383602619171143,
-0.22107113897800446,
-0.18884330987930298,
-0.8810158371925354,
-0.3419921100139618,
-0.5611064434051514,
0.6377352476119995,
-0.7870627641677856,
-0.3605091869831085,
0.5072236657142639,
-0.26386773586273193,
0.27624621987342834,
-0.7788438200950623,
0.6811778545379639,
-0.7030829787254333,
0.22528208792209625,
-0.13496850430965424,
-0.4854985773563385,
-0.21709026396274567,
0.7814557552337646,
-0.48304983973503113,
1.2685186862945557,
0.3159240484237671,
-0.5358365178108215,
0.612934410572052,
-0.8319311738014221,
-0.3992885947227478,
0.31397494673728943,
-0.08449497818946838,
-0.4670809209346771,
-0.06843008100986481,
0.2697320282459259,
0.34308314323425293,
-0.5974403023719788,
0.25904449820518494,
-0.3479846715927124,
-0.3721655011177063,
0.22537174820899963,
-0.2941277325153351,
0.6973823308944702,
0.2619035243988037,
-0.6052866578102112,
0.6324620842933655,
-0.7566534876823425,
0.2348722219467163,
-0.20773713290691376,
-0.7002876400947571,
-0.10617708414793015,
0.10628613084554672,
0.2056020349264145,
0.27094149589538574,
0.6572235226631165,
-0.37785327434539795,
0.04222039878368378,
-0.3925665616989136,
0.2582537829875946,
0.4969470202922821,
0.032202526926994324,
0.04295807331800461,
-0.4115769565105438,
0.8943628668785095,
-0.14418956637382507,
0.26720282435417175,
-0.4208731949329376,
-0.053891461342573166,
-0.9070326685905457,
-0.2979084551334381,
0.3937532901763916,
0.7129406929016113,
-0.4919857680797577,
0.6836460828781128,
-0.11563803255558014,
-0.7398097515106201,
-0.5161765813827515,
0.39135608077049255,
0.3753786087036133,
0.29718154668807983,
0.32190871238708496,
-0.12027325481176376,
-0.5737883448600769,
-0.7631361484527588,
-0.08028974384069443,
-0.5296869874000549,
0.03348619118332863,
-0.010247919708490372,
0.66153484582901,
-0.5169432759284973,
0.6110544800758362,
-0.043251410126686096,
0.036216944456100464,
-0.32032620906829834,
-0.05483713373541832,
0.22995968163013458,
0.36608433723449707,
0.2931118309497833,
-0.691635251045227,
-0.10885889083147049,
0.23853179812431335,
-0.6468345522880554,
-0.21022368967533112,
-0.2314537763595581,
-0.13275648653507233,
-0.09987395256757736,
0.4194137156009674,
-0.25143012404441833,
0.2590165138244629,
0.4485020339488983,
-0.4207134246826172,
0.6612883806228638,
-0.015819108113646507,
0.38387390971183777,
-0.9510981440544128,
0.08335644751787186,
-0.16587303578853607,
-0.6364228129386902,
-0.14434696733951569,
0.5056191682815552,
0.26551058888435364,
-0.08521538227796555,
-0.2958264648914337,
0.49155697226524353,
-0.11211571097373962,
-0.03778758645057678,
0.09507454186677933,
0.2613436281681061,
0.16880810260772705,
0.0055234599858522415,
-0.2499164491891861,
0.7908651828765869,
0.6140801906585693,
-0.4720347225666046,
0.5360140800476074,
0.37135061621665955,
-0.7173925042152405,
0.9150344133377075,
-0.7383877635002136,
-0.058969300240278244,
0.29166725277900696,
0.0900752991437912,
-0.9093014001846313,
-0.1656142920255661,
-0.14158183336257935,
-0.07754053175449371,
0.3794082999229431,
0.14268732070922852,
-0.3405109643936157,
-0.3288753628730774,
-0.6031827330589294,
0.3278600573539734,
0.28180357813835144,
-0.8093948364257812,
0.4772777259349823,
0.40734753012657166,
-0.007411756087094545,
-0.5484427213668823,
-0.6430968046188354,
0.2755941152572632,
-0.08708841353654861,
-0.734135091304779,
-0.001290612737648189,
-0.32434144616127014,
-0.5247523784637451,
-0.31958043575286865,
-0.36866551637649536,
-0.10438231378793716,
0.2800222337245941,
0.20505841076374054,
0.5176761150360107,
-0.3665149211883545,
0.03021739237010479,
-0.24682694673538208,
0.03567272052168846,
0.02301623485982418,
-0.28186193108558655,
0.30581653118133545,
-0.6566183567047119,
-0.8041870594024658,
-0.1541908085346222,
0.3390112519264221,
0.7980050444602966,
-0.7072606086730957,
0.3155916631221771,
0.40970978140830994,
-0.70646733045578,
-0.11446241289377213,
-0.8618690967559814,
0.12523572146892548,
-0.46775320172309875,
0.5788549780845642,
-0.3700592517852783,
-1.1695475578308105,
0.5922411680221558,
-0.3505006730556488,
0.31526297330856323,
0.3751719295978546,
1.036076307296753,
0.3556131422519684,
0.8835198879241943,
0.6150385737419128,
-0.029793549329042435,
0.10229445993900299,
-0.09599234163761139,
0.14252020418643951,
-0.8712338805198669,
-0.46687549352645874,
-0.5563647747039795,
-0.155918687582016,
-0.39394131302833557,
-0.5703654885292053,
0.10402680933475494,
0.27327653765678406,
-0.325288325548172,
0.026293830946087837,
-0.3711746633052826,
0.4735703766345978,
0.10751862078905106,
-0.03806085139513016,
0.38583609461784363,
-0.4382683038711548,
-0.42478471994400024,
0.058011073619127274,
-0.342121958732605,
-0.715345025062561,
0.9054024815559387,
0.43731024861335754,
0.8491549491882324,
0.3468940258026123,
0.7416226267814636,
0.5010234117507935,
0.6358088254928589,
-0.9794692993164062,
0.6056745052337646,
0.2896193563938141,
-0.5972738862037659,
-0.21975591778755188,
-0.12382116168737411,
-0.7476627826690674,
0.43815428018569946,
-0.4068809449672699,
-1.096151351928711,
0.17185355722904205,
-0.1321253627538681,
-0.3176625967025757,
0.2827230989933014,
-0.5120478272438049,
0.783499002456665,
-0.5289233326911926,
-0.5585425496101379,
0.004034338518977165,
-0.40718376636505127,
0.4032520651817322,
-0.18103548884391785,
0.03503045812249184,
-0.025035997852683067,
-0.24325600266456604,
0.6545305848121643,
-0.6225372552871704,
0.6895449161529541,
0.24615423381328583,
-0.12459549307823181,
0.2147773653268814,
0.42882028222084045,
0.6730261445045471,
0.010964506305754185,
-0.5406590700149536,
0.2122294157743454,
0.4052305221557617,
-0.30285632610321045,
-0.4560348391532898,
0.7369214296340942,
-0.5770415663719177,
-0.28036969900131226,
-0.5787529349327087,
-0.47590935230255127,
-0.6667420864105225,
0.3747331202030182,
-0.018898669630289078,
0.3318950831890106,
-0.4740772843360901,
0.2443581223487854,
0.5332377552986145,
-0.19827772676944733,
0.2723460793495178,
0.6863245368003845,
-0.7623744606971741,
-0.4539748728275299,
0.7216556668281555,
-0.2374991476535797,
0.18876616656780243,
0.6394378542900085,
0.24762068688869476,
-0.5684581995010376,
-0.6232605576515198,
-0.21955524384975433,
-0.03115023672580719,
-0.791954755783081,
-0.23737303912639618,
-0.2535858154296875,
-0.07478996366262436,
-0.24629171192646027,
-0.3023681938648224,
-0.47510409355163574,
-0.36525020003318787,
0.1850896179676056,
-0.39643529057502747,
-0.002801171038299799,
0.6896021962165833,
0.15326139330863953,
-0.32769492268562317,
-0.6812611818313599,
0.2045004963874817,
0.37569841742515564,
0.6274435520172119,
-0.2779393792152405,
-0.3661910891532898,
-0.2143213003873825,
-0.28837642073631287,
-0.15821132063865662,
-0.7612496018409729,
0.04087404906749725,
0.1599893420934677,
0.7798433899879456,
0.6144142150878906,
0.1367092728614807,
0.7012472748756409,
-0.27542638778686523,
0.9244120717048645,
0.2642643451690674,
-1.081101655960083,
0.6039220094680786,
-0.3405216336250305,
0.5165796875953674,
0.9983166456222534,
0.10890544205904007,
-0.44630196690559387,
-0.11680849641561508,
-0.5613856315612793,
-0.8826517462730408,
0.22808940708637238,
0.10454705357551575,
-0.14787063002586365,
0.11691101640462875,
0.10575365275144577,
0.05522740259766579,
0.3877440094947815,
-0.5787655115127563,
0.10715322941541672,
-0.10487554967403412,
-0.3037526607513428,
0.08758024126291275,
-0.5899035334587097,
-0.4145723581314087,
-0.015517096035182476,
0.547967791557312,
-0.10919827967882156,
-0.06503687798976898,
0.2650916278362274,
-0.3129102885723114,
-0.22011150419712067,
0.5181798934936523,
0.5575327277183533,
1.0978847742080688,
-0.24932505190372467,
0.2570677101612091,
0.4972288906574249,
-0.3712952136993408,
0.08589158207178116,
0.18849831819534302,
-0.14638128876686096,
-0.29300397634506226,
0.6026071906089783,
0.43094781041145325,
0.4104073941707611,
-1.0098947286605835,
0.6172163486480713,
0.10428433120250702,
-0.18850764632225037,
-0.14417415857315063,
-0.08853090554475784,
-0.05034720525145531,
0.5324788093566895,
0.07548748701810837,
0.08598628640174866,
0.31207719445228577,
-0.38125869631767273,
0.3318258225917816,
0.520266056060791,
-0.8589698672294617,
-0.04041638225317001,
0.7351561188697815,
0.3049684464931488,
-0.43391862511634827,
0.17418326437473297,
-0.13166692852973938,
-0.6602861881256104,
0.28757166862487793,
0.5312473773956299,
1.1385316848754883,
-0.4126322567462921,
0.2833361029624939,
0.06306494027376175,
0.8959481716156006,
0.020534051582217216,
0.6482921242713928,
-0.3469220697879791,
-0.45728185772895813,
-0.5635426044464111,
-0.9851353764533997,
-0.8894267678260803,
0.1243281289935112,
-0.6021055579185486,
0.1882329285144806,
-0.6885238885879517,
0.10341640561819077,
-0.34197697043418884,
0.03585278242826462,
-0.7630407810211182,
0.3045762777328491,
0.008871792815625668,
1.0649924278259277,
-0.5293760895729065,
0.3729438781738281,
1.0535969734191895,
-0.39337238669395447,
-0.7506297826766968,
-0.11175617575645447,
0.23256301879882812,
-0.7480518221855164,
0.44812285900115967,
0.18722444772720337,
-0.4387444257736206,
-0.658254086971283,
-0.2731766998767853,
-0.6307137608528137,
0.9054070711135864,
0.349946528673172,
-0.537101149559021,
0.5585587620735168,
0.11405978351831436,
0.6626731157302856,
-0.4949493408203125,
0.4940476715564728,
0.5175400376319885,
0.5464612245559692,
0.17761096358299255,
-0.9345040917396545,
0.23380988836288452,
-0.5654222965240479,
-0.01834043674170971,
0.20325268805027008,
-0.6427596807479858,
0.26504090428352356,
-0.2835273742675781,
0.03732607513666153,
0.07891693711280823,
0.4778558015823364,
0.2961268424987793,
0.434911847114563,
0.342673659324646,
0.3284067213535309,
1.1605318784713745,
-0.08200902491807938,
1.2259535789489746,
-0.39901697635650635,
0.4072534143924713,
1.216389775276184,
-0.6195389628410339,
1.1246167421340942,
0.1883898675441742,
-0.4607163071632385,
0.3837316930294037,
0.7296573519706726,
-0.04904130473732948,
-0.01469479687511921,
0.2916981279850006,
-0.4182899296283722,
-0.7272404432296753,
-0.17802311480045319,
-0.3404495120048523,
0.5005606412887573,
0.28024429082870483,
-0.13926781713962555,
-0.3641565442085266,
-0.4139642119407654,
-0.12973695993423462,
0.2581782341003418,
-0.30194318294525146,
0.39215150475502014,
-0.09586724638938904,
-0.4875715970993042,
0.40609174966812134,
0.043769605457782745,
0.5418047904968262,
-0.7333353757858276,
-0.12966223061084747,
-0.0409608893096447,
0.17106199264526367,
-0.539639413356781,
-0.6270748376846313,
0.136078342795372,
-0.05894356220960617,
0.04779736325144768,
0.051253437995910645,
0.9679542183876038,
-0.2587764859199524,
-0.8308989405632019,
0.18600137531757355,
0.5301171541213989,
0.10756100714206696,
-0.010657554492354393,
-0.781495988368988,
0.1250016838312149,
-0.034105103462934494,
-0.1328788548707962,
0.17589575052261353,
0.2652362585067749,
-0.2569068670272827,
0.9258717894554138,
0.8907427191734314,
0.06908473372459412,
-0.04065508767962456,
0.34605100750923157,
0.7510613203048706,
-0.5072252750396729,
-0.4719335436820984,
-0.7539403438568115,
0.6839566230773926,
-0.138851597905159,
-0.4389716386795044,
0.7704493403434753,
0.8070492148399353,
0.5811333060264587,
0.2336161583662033,
0.7438320517539978,
0.2858507037162781,
0.41485896706581116,
-0.42727920413017273,
0.6921806335449219,
-0.44968074560165405,
0.653032660484314,
-0.42117875814437866,
-1.0875416994094849,
-0.5760928988456726,
0.7365327477455139,
-0.3240165114402771,
0.27297717332839966,
0.6115310192108154,
0.6110159754753113,
0.05187511816620827,
0.09421327710151672,
0.5618036985397339,
0.2438582330942154,
0.42219027876853943,
0.47792887687683105,
0.9995686411857605,
-0.39505311846733093,
0.47781500220298767,
-0.03120087832212448,
-0.5003050565719604,
-0.28784021735191345,
-0.9605648517608643,
-1.0560216903686523,
-0.22775804996490479,
-0.6676769256591797,
-0.39664989709854126,
-0.05608229339122772,
1.1523371934890747,
0.6441323757171631,
-1.0686715841293335,
-0.40514227747917175,
0.2613685429096222,
0.3281267285346985,
-0.3095782995223999,
-0.2100103497505188,
0.31181275844573975,
-0.2169894129037857,
-0.45470964908599854,
0.5093233585357666,
0.8542366027832031,
-0.3768497109413147,
-0.6556317210197449,
-0.16103608906269073,
-0.20803433656692505,
0.3002496063709259,
0.849794328212738,
0.20554611086845398,
-0.6203265190124512,
-0.34982427954673767,
-0.07278403639793396,
0.046934861689805984,
-0.06616520136594772,
0.6678984761238098,
-0.6892485618591309,
0.7890915870666504,
0.504284679889679,
1.0298984050750732,
0.5258024334907532,
-0.24509240686893463,
0.3624056577682495,
-0.31129780411720276,
-0.15075801312923431,
0.27191197872161865,
0.6094726920127869,
0.5180525779724121,
-0.19144856929779053,
0.7139875888824463,
-0.31941506266593933,
-0.6373823881149292,
-0.8495612740516663,
0.4012664556503296,
-1.164418339729309,
0.2217046171426773,
1.050492286682129,
-0.17155644297599792,
0.13045312464237213,
-0.22095677256584167,
-0.2066706269979477,
-0.17936351895332336,
-0.07494641840457916,
0.8187714219093323,
0.8254562020301819,
-0.17674656212329865,
-0.05906517803668976,
-0.22446425259113312,
0.1544157862663269,
0.5012584328651428,
-1.0512155294418335,
-0.21497279405593872,
0.5592513680458069,
0.3078744113445282,
0.29829713702201843,
0.38003623485565186,
-0.46113353967666626,
0.36766982078552246,
-0.1272253394126892,
-0.04571622982621193,
0.025000981986522675,
0.0709659606218338,
-0.425456166267395,
0.3998754322528839,
0.4251059889793396,
-0.01785372383892536
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18769v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18769v1
|
Improved Neural Protoform Reconstruction via Reflex Prediction
| 2024-03-27T17:13:38 | 2024-03-27T17:13:38 |
Liang Lu, Jingzhi Wang, David R. Mortensen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Protolanguage reconstruction is central to historical linguistics. The
comparative method, one of the most influential theoretical and methodological
frameworks in the history of the language sciences, allows linguists to infer
protoforms (reconstructed ancestral words) from their reflexes (related modern
words) based on the assumption of regular sound change. Not surprisingly,
numerous computational linguists have attempted to operationalize comparative
reconstruction through various computational models, the most successful of
which have been supervised encoder-decoder models, which treat the problem of
predicting protoforms given sets of reflexes as a sequence-to-sequence problem.
We argue that this framework ignores one of the most important aspects of the
comparative method: not only should protoforms be inferable from cognate sets
(sets of related reflexes) but the reflexes should also be inferable from the
protoforms. Leveraging another line of research -- reflex prediction -- we
propose a system in which candidate protoforms from a reconstruction model are
reranked by a reflex prediction model. We show that this more complete
implementation of the comparative method allows us to surpass state-of-the-art
protoform reconstruction methods on three of four Chinese and Romance datasets.
|
[
-0.21418510377407074,
-0.2368800938129425,
0.4052388072013855,
0.06477875262498856,
-0.024732859805226326,
0.08092737942934036,
-0.5744394659996033,
-0.5424553751945496,
0.7676631808280945,
0.2440507560968399,
-0.37728115916252136,
-0.09351692348718643,
-0.27648213505744934,
0.35630562901496887,
-0.5053508877754211,
0.5841748714447021,
0.5191330909729004,
0.30605196952819824,
-0.1486402004957199,
0.000042879499233094975,
0.10104044526815414,
-0.4778355360031128,
-0.4581218361854553,
-0.6647073030471802,
0.26857423782348633,
0.2368580847978592,
0.49067166447639465,
0.3504464030265808,
0.5826631188392639,
0.30903032422065735,
-0.3620608150959015,
-0.08557870239019394,
-0.22955322265625,
0.06833292543888092,
0.23294834792613983,
-0.722740113735199,
-0.6594789028167725,
-0.16081659495830536,
0.6927225589752197,
1.0244871377944946,
-0.025636449456214905,
-0.04116923734545708,
0.2195310890674591,
0.8604592680931091,
-0.525141179561615,
-0.03967101499438286,
-0.36849644780158997,
0.10762210190296173,
-0.266444593667984,
-0.4815911650657654,
-0.5335164070129395,
-0.43099889159202576,
0.19754168391227722,
-0.4091160297393799,
0.6925324201583862,
-0.2792697548866272,
0.6395123600959778,
-0.09480787068605423,
-0.035793423652648926,
0.28829824924468994,
-0.8971786499023438,
0.4064350724220276,
-0.9738600850105286,
0.7533646821975708,
0.20445849001407623,
0.3583417534828186,
-0.268285870552063,
-0.8689684271812439,
-0.5225050449371338,
-0.44815975427627563,
-0.296648234128952,
0.17344003915786743,
-0.1413949429988861,
0.0480884350836277,
0.40709882974624634,
0.40167036652565,
-0.8468788266181946,
0.13587671518325806,
-0.2661220133304596,
-0.4082956910133362,
0.3549503982067108,
0.10575152933597565,
0.08940774947404861,
-0.2440364956855774,
-0.22254887223243713,
-0.21447226405143738,
-1.0904662609100342,
0.039176955819129944,
0.35669225454330444,
0.49574586749076843,
0.09097886085510254,
0.13430257141590118,
-0.5186086893081665,
0.8047499060630798,
0.3792051374912262,
-0.19881421327590942,
0.4131699502468109,
-0.20968499779701233,
-0.12726347148418427,
-0.13322865962982178,
0.6440300941467285,
0.38149014115333557,
0.355728417634964,
-0.3874746263027191,
-0.1617208868265152,
-0.000979489996097982,
0.09968698024749756,
-0.6088523268699646,
-0.36782053112983704,
0.006692378781735897,
-0.5893905758857727,
-0.09037638455629349,
0.10267479717731476,
-0.9376136064529419,
-0.29039981961250305,
-0.27797800302505493,
0.17805582284927368,
-0.2408830225467682,
-0.5328777432441711,
0.1011863425374031,
-0.16702556610107422,
0.13625000417232513,
0.042305294424295425,
-1.0672262907028198,
0.555342435836792,
0.8290517926216125,
0.7620968818664551,
0.11842799931764603,
-0.4266442358493805,
-0.1105043962597847,
-0.4608933925628662,
-0.40517038106918335,
1.0692167282104492,
-0.30720704793930054,
-0.3228323459625244,
-0.03269919753074646,
0.02543356828391552,
0.19315743446350098,
-0.9218365550041199,
0.37315213680267334,
-0.5063942670822144,
0.09855633229017258,
-0.29060599207878113,
-0.3919650912284851,
-0.3996816575527191,
0.18232524394989014,
-0.7849864959716797,
0.5806605815887451,
0.03749082610011101,
-0.7338882088661194,
0.4500691592693329,
-0.11991765350103378,
-0.45168250799179077,
-0.14543962478637695,
0.032028425484895706,
-0.49639204144477844,
0.19689980149269104,
0.13393382728099823,
0.28638577461242676,
-0.5300829410552979,
0.3449130356311798,
-0.4647899866104126,
-0.3526890277862549,
-0.016148485243320465,
-0.19134211540222168,
0.8503355383872986,
-0.1302468180656433,
-0.5163037776947021,
0.2741885483264923,
-0.8098815083503723,
-0.046787600964307785,
-0.017194366082549095,
-0.11889373511075974,
-0.26748552918434143,
0.008262495510280132,
-0.34795182943344116,
-0.028441250324249268,
-0.11360576003789902,
-0.6846532821655273,
0.18451105058193207,
-0.7089929580688477,
0.4459669888019562,
0.5192039608955383,
-0.1734258383512497,
0.6501458883285522,
-0.387734979391098,
0.28201207518577576,
-0.31834280490875244,
0.051650602370500565,
-0.03845173493027687,
-0.3562328815460205,
-0.9398982524871826,
0.10950468480587006,
0.5222107768058777,
0.2596122622489929,
-0.5265851616859436,
0.14098650217056274,
-0.7152459025382996,
-0.6996970176696777,
-0.3278628885746002,
-0.4232018291950226,
0.49628138542175293,
0.584851861000061,
0.35900425910949707,
-0.6591957211494446,
-0.9035886526107788,
-1.0328537225723267,
-0.26274439692497253,
-0.6026357412338257,
-0.1403293013572693,
0.11612936854362488,
-0.040551356971263885,
0.32026568055152893,
0.7118098139762878,
-0.3390343189239502,
-0.15289537608623505,
-0.033266980201005936,
0.050412680953741074,
0.3935684263706207,
0.5373947620391846,
0.5833609104156494,
-0.6674163341522217,
-0.39273470640182495,
-0.24036574363708496,
-0.5191692113876343,
-0.0015008982736617327,
0.06128240376710892,
0.09345802664756775,
-0.23441939055919647,
0.6141895055770874,
-0.29853448271751404,
0.31791895627975464,
0.44278886914253235,
-0.21774274110794067,
0.9211650490760803,
0.04585421830415726,
0.23753012716770172,
-0.8889483213424683,
0.29623284935951233,
-0.19662359356880188,
-0.18192216753959656,
-0.8317636251449585,
0.07050248235464096,
0.2497667819261551,
0.2706685960292816,
-0.3024778664112091,
0.3205833435058594,
-0.5906531810760498,
-0.2599528431892395,
-0.26954135298728943,
-0.2776748836040497,
-0.3999328017234802,
0.4036067724227905,
0.35186031460762024,
0.6267293095588684,
0.6312267780303955,
-0.6107814908027649,
0.3205602765083313,
0.31740307807922363,
-0.33252817392349243,
0.26994451880455017,
-0.5510855913162231,
0.3403171896934509,
-0.12125460058450699,
0.3582012355327606,
-0.8323033452033997,
0.013264935463666916,
0.0773734375834465,
-0.8934248089790344,
0.48613324761390686,
-0.1579364389181137,
-0.10771432518959045,
-0.2938361167907715,
-0.42019733786582947,
0.5570749640464783,
0.7634546756744385,
-0.6853284239768982,
0.4661312699317932,
0.19568729400634766,
-0.29907578229904175,
-0.757743775844574,
-0.4822874069213867,
0.10972479730844498,
-0.2269236296415329,
-0.3316798210144043,
0.5846144556999207,
0.15604229271411896,
-0.2846481204032898,
-0.16590481996536255,
0.08621855825185776,
0.04743675887584686,
-0.05377287417650223,
0.2024320811033249,
0.3625035285949707,
-0.4818630814552307,
0.08980075269937515,
-0.4434596300125122,
-0.2538197934627533,
0.044352877885103226,
-0.34756308794021606,
0.6030792593955994,
0.189928337931633,
-0.1453414410352707,
-0.0038309704978019,
0.03981596603989601,
0.5125203132629395,
-0.10441017150878906,
0.09743891656398773,
0.22221338748931885,
-0.44696855545043945,
-0.08635476231575012,
-0.6469140648841858,
-0.7484318614006042,
-0.4005357623100281,
0.25855785608291626,
-0.3468734622001648,
-0.6157939434051514,
0.5175729393959045,
-0.23820379376411438,
0.016576901078224182,
0.2902594208717346,
0.4229462742805481,
0.0970427393913269,
0.7149490118026733,
0.7973663210868835,
-0.3077273368835449,
0.5988215804100037,
-0.3690337538719177,
-0.03891623020172119,
-0.9959551692008972,
-0.17476028203964233,
-0.645333468914032,
-0.40898728370666504,
-0.5542972683906555,
0.005562517326325178,
0.23330053687095642,
-0.19438660144805908,
-0.16168798506259918,
0.7745510339736938,
-0.22847731411457062,
0.29876431822776794,
0.6965280175209045,
0.2237759679555893,
0.34823018312454224,
0.16862434148788452,
-0.2152189463376999,
-0.0701403021812439,
-0.8620253801345825,
-0.36990246176719666,
1.2277085781097412,
-0.06851258128881454,
0.48920780420303345,
0.08074183762073517,
0.9194868803024292,
-0.044918227940797806,
0.6332783102989197,
-0.8232036232948303,
0.6720027923583984,
-0.4000082015991211,
-0.5310643911361694,
-0.13438627123832703,
-0.2502502501010895,
-1.1451632976531982,
0.26627200841903687,
-0.26308512687683105,
-0.7408075332641602,
0.7581642866134644,
0.25100409984588623,
-0.7843151688575745,
0.3588249981403351,
-0.26481133699417114,
0.32585564255714417,
0.26275089383125305,
-0.46190834045410156,
-0.229164257645607,
-0.7259525656700134,
0.4594975411891937,
0.1598534733057022,
0.005602529272437096,
0.06027652695775032,
0.279389351606369,
0.849146842956543,
-0.3783760368824005,
0.895429790019989,
-0.07544948160648346,
-0.03134893998503685,
0.04381069913506508,
0.3743107318878174,
0.13944625854492188,
-0.2546223998069763,
-0.28808072209358215,
-0.022869419306516647,
-0.20346665382385254,
-0.15367209911346436,
-0.6659450531005859,
0.6529744863510132,
-0.3096783757209778,
-0.6009790897369385,
-0.18097332119941711,
0.045518018305301666,
-0.28949350118637085,
0.033113669604063034,
0.6866450309753418,
0.776039183139801,
-0.6578751802444458,
-0.11465705931186676,
0.16965390741825104,
0.13079294562339783,
0.7504196166992188,
0.6435783505439758,
-0.13970106840133667,
-0.5378741025924683,
0.8099638223648071,
0.013548323884606361,
0.263506680727005,
0.396223247051239,
0.04287930205464363,
-0.3078153431415558,
-0.673801064491272,
-0.2408393919467926,
0.2608359456062317,
-0.5459818840026855,
-0.3614582121372223,
-0.28616026043891907,
0.0183099415153265,
-0.4815131723880768,
0.042000070214271545,
-0.40517500042915344,
-0.49163389205932617,
-0.03739533573389053,
0.046690646559000015,
-0.04803241044282913,
0.5794568657875061,
-0.4294644892215729,
-0.12168611586093903,
-0.878508985042572,
0.3368164896965027,
0.20092536509037018,
0.35370394587516785,
0.2031370848417282,
-0.6265257000923157,
0.020491912961006165,
-0.13831615447998047,
-0.02184215374290943,
-0.8908381462097168,
0.7024245262145996,
0.5221854448318481,
0.41216370463371277,
0.3045141100883484,
-0.0011325418017804623,
0.7382911443710327,
-0.879504382610321,
0.7154904007911682,
0.14489507675170898,
-0.5263019800186157,
0.32902655005455017,
0.1728128343820572,
0.0913543775677681,
0.4575973451137543,
0.3354473412036896,
-0.5575447678565979,
-0.2586766183376312,
-0.9403226971626282,
-0.7138099670410156,
0.18524934351444244,
-0.11126132309436798,
-0.06612703949213028,
-0.09524952620267868,
0.3638930320739746,
0.5522527694702148,
-0.13178615272045135,
-0.45407772064208984,
0.008952259086072445,
0.15301616489887238,
0.1414572298526764,
-0.543688178062439,
-0.03676289692521095,
0.1499972641468048,
-0.3476804792881012,
0.4207216203212738,
-0.15883758664131165,
0.6110357046127319,
0.3667345941066742,
-0.20126207172870636,
-0.21154353022575378,
0.15225400030612946,
0.4824572801589966,
0.49711427092552185,
-0.23110193014144897,
0.3624434173107147,
0.06940070539712906,
-0.541953980922699,
0.3986268937587738,
0.05369344353675842,
-0.5948550701141357,
0.36081379652023315,
0.6872379779815674,
0.7726250886917114,
0.21528387069702148,
-0.34252890944480896,
0.3801529109477997,
0.10908666253089905,
-0.05140667408704758,
-0.5076262354850769,
-0.30733153223991394,
-0.05131629854440689,
0.3593825101852417,
0.09521754831075668,
0.5433655977249146,
0.5347970128059387,
-0.534021258354187,
0.40118408203125,
0.2072393000125885,
-0.2792395055294037,
-0.9255951046943665,
0.47191527485847473,
0.28256815671920776,
-0.5754798054695129,
0.7230772376060486,
0.10599742084741592,
-0.8115904927253723,
0.6927942037582397,
0.6250916123390198,
1.168332815170288,
-0.3802000880241394,
0.02493038959801197,
1.0203044414520264,
-0.08264017105102539,
-0.5729560852050781,
0.48082709312438965,
0.02755090408027172,
-0.8767428994178772,
-0.45960724353790283,
-0.4683265686035156,
-0.278472900390625,
-0.08077208697795868,
-0.721122145652771,
0.29545533657073975,
-0.29542332887649536,
-0.5351166129112244,
0.10898184031248093,
-0.43902406096458435,
-0.45888951420783997,
0.056060418486595154,
0.32798391580581665,
0.9262676239013672,
-0.7696821093559265,
0.6980723738670349,
0.5409508943557739,
-0.24052459001541138,
-0.5296542048454285,
0.2538159191608429,
0.06318828463554382,
-0.47379228472709656,
0.779185950756073,
-0.008220627903938293,
-0.25495535135269165,
0.1335117220878601,
-0.2845907509326935,
-0.7396479845046997,
0.7004272937774658,
0.5512682795524597,
-0.68453049659729,
-0.036959461867809296,
-0.2514626085758209,
0.6506277918815613,
-0.03584359213709831,
0.46842584013938904,
0.6723320484161377,
0.30354881286621094,
-0.262188196182251,
-1.3989843130111694,
0.192149817943573,
-0.33104407787323,
-0.30159637331962585,
0.37321367859840393,
-0.5866401195526123,
0.8542184233665466,
-0.5823304653167725,
-0.4194762408733368,
0.3142305910587311,
0.6161471009254456,
-0.1254696100950241,
-0.10113433748483658,
0.5368769764900208,
0.41605690121650696,
0.329022616147995,
-0.1980672925710678,
0.835074245929718,
-0.22920505702495575,
0.2537611722946167,
1.0107753276824951,
-0.08727183938026428,
1.2334589958190918,
0.4056490659713745,
-0.5552427768707275,
0.6166325807571411,
0.6221756339073181,
0.23246996104717255,
0.568811297416687,
0.18217620253562927,
-0.24209558963775635,
-0.19700099527835846,
0.10919228196144104,
-0.37407931685447693,
0.6949921250343323,
0.10261843353509903,
-0.38074690103530884,
-0.16864408552646637,
-0.16873565316200256,
-0.3662005662918091,
0.07231652736663818,
-0.11096560955047607,
1.1290364265441895,
0.006322826724499464,
-0.9753562808036804,
1.080734133720398,
-0.3511955440044403,
0.9391322731971741,
-0.48247912526130676,
-0.2096078097820282,
-0.403842955827713,
0.28995922207832336,
-0.21279454231262207,
-0.5567322373390198,
0.2975212037563324,
-0.4208980202674866,
0.07448205351829529,
-0.026261236518621445,
0.9517764449119568,
-0.4549754858016968,
-0.0083638746291399,
0.4222255349159241,
0.6751267910003662,
0.1996161937713623,
-0.10881686210632324,
-0.24247126281261444,
-0.29006651043891907,
-0.014771518297493458,
-0.1453828662633896,
0.18493056297302246,
-0.2172655612230301,
0.05767739564180374,
0.60491943359375,
0.4635279178619385,
0.5689917206764221,
-0.058234646916389465,
0.11204167455434799,
0.7869930267333984,
-0.8461439609527588,
-0.5071613192558289,
-0.944193422794342,
0.35174301266670227,
0.09084763377904892,
-0.18691232800483704,
0.33411911129951477,
0.537946343421936,
0.9496735334396362,
-0.276298850774765,
0.5997529029846191,
0.017841946333646774,
0.6708135604858398,
-0.4386626183986664,
0.5744639039039612,
-0.3597857654094696,
-0.040546152740716934,
-0.33230045437812805,
-1.1060113906860352,
-0.44093647599220276,
0.4403418302536011,
-0.09409081935882568,
-0.16900505125522614,
0.6317521929740906,
1.0115139484405518,
-0.021761668846011162,
-0.014711083844304085,
0.32352909445762634,
0.21255530416965485,
-0.003838134929537773,
0.6702951192855835,
0.7702722549438477,
-0.2623445987701416,
0.17766661942005157,
-0.6368733048439026,
-0.43584710359573364,
-0.2765575051307678,
-0.7095304727554321,
-0.3020945191383362,
-0.9728910326957703,
-0.012303904630243778,
-0.38458454608917236,
0.21847648918628693,
0.9485226273536682,
0.6870625019073486,
-1.0010508298873901,
-0.6058210134506226,
0.01762905903160572,
-0.3144315183162689,
-0.6280767321586609,
-0.11728930473327637,
0.3931673467159271,
-0.09193866699934006,
-0.7573080658912659,
0.6071548461914062,
0.20485487580299377,
0.23253755271434784,
-0.08473534882068634,
-0.02856988087296486,
0.16476258635520935,
-0.30330947041511536,
0.5079874992370605,
0.7588820457458496,
-0.779607892036438,
-0.29872196912765503,
0.307381272315979,
0.049611374735832214,
0.37204161286354065,
1.1033844947814941,
-1.2254120111465454,
0.4625328779220581,
0.931626558303833,
0.2805075943470001,
0.31437015533447266,
-0.2104170173406601,
0.9125990867614746,
-0.36892402172088623,
0.2684212923049927,
0.5378820300102234,
0.6510171294212341,
0.5583714246749878,
-0.06235601380467415,
0.6005105376243591,
0.39094486832618713,
-0.19524595141410828,
-0.6611644625663757,
0.42423439025878906,
-0.7304622530937195,
-0.2658251225948334,
1.054304838180542,
-0.22992533445358276,
-0.20110353827476501,
0.030986085534095764,
-0.13421355187892914,
0.4796156883239746,
-0.019551504403352737,
0.9870710968971252,
0.46776875853538513,
-0.1704227775335312,
-0.17796118557453156,
-0.11104093492031097,
0.6684969067573547,
0.7550825476646423,
-0.37486037611961365,
0.1661781221628189,
0.3555237650871277,
0.3233093023300171,
0.3435520529747009,
0.6486944556236267,
-0.23200911283493042,
0.4643554985523224,
0.21938684582710266,
0.2521970272064209,
0.13052143156528473,
-0.45962125062942505,
-0.4989987015724182,
0.1411087065935135,
0.26318487524986267,
-0.0877683088183403
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18746v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18746v1
|
CYCLE: Learning to Self-Refine the Code Generation
| 2024-03-27T16:45:02 | 2024-03-27T16:45:02 |
Yangruibo Ding, Marcus J. Min, Gail Kaiser, Baishakhi Ray
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL
|
Pre-trained code language models have achieved promising performance in code
generation and improved the programming efficiency of human developers.
However, their self-refinement capability is typically overlooked by the
existing evaluations of code LMs, which focus only on the accuracy of the
one-time prediction. For the cases when code LMs fail to implement the correct
program, developers actually find it hard to debug and fix the faulty
prediction since it is not written by the developers themselves. Unfortunately,
our study reveals that code LMs cannot efficiently self-refine their faulty
generations as well.
In this paper, we propose CYCLE framework, learning to self-refine the faulty
generation according to the available feedback, such as the execution results
reported by the test suites. We evaluate CYCLE on three popular code generation
benchmarks, HumanEval, MBPP, and APPS. The results reveal that CYCLE
successfully maintains, sometimes improves, the quality of one-time code
generation, while significantly improving the self-refinement capability of
code LMs. We implement four variants of CYCLE with varied numbers of parameters
across 350M, 1B, 2B, and 3B, and the experiments show that CYCLE consistently
boosts the code generation performance, by up to 63.5%, across benchmarks and
varied model sizes. We also notice that CYCLE outperforms code LMs that have
3$\times$ more parameters in self-refinement.
|
[
-0.29870834946632385,
-0.28881150484085083,
0.3590433895587921,
0.4800579845905304,
-0.0722239762544632,
0.5019627809524536,
-0.01802661083638668,
-0.3927193582057953,
-0.12976500391960144,
0.6089489459991455,
-0.9091280698776245,
-0.35322776436805725,
-0.03444060683250427,
0.3706046938896179,
-0.38278132677078247,
0.9187989234924316,
-0.12178061157464981,
0.18764756619930267,
-0.26453280448913574,
-0.061257246881723404,
-0.6134481430053711,
-0.3839896321296692,
-0.33214271068573,
-0.4218837320804596,
0.23981863260269165,
0.757900059223175,
0.13063758611679077,
0.617387056350708,
0.3012552261352539,
0.30723100900650024,
0.5632336139678955,
0.27048128843307495,
-0.7494981288909912,
0.3711089789867401,
-0.041776854544878006,
-0.3399593234062195,
-0.14013026654720306,
0.05646916478872299,
0.00855053961277008,
0.25403761863708496,
-0.2943219542503357,
0.4580724835395813,
0.18592248857021332,
1.2099547386169434,
-0.5008120536804199,
0.08208199590444565,
-0.6212332844734192,
0.15993458032608032,
0.02029259316623211,
-0.40755942463874817,
-0.3758641481399536,
-0.48128247261047363,
-0.48152899742126465,
-0.39388030767440796,
0.49359622597694397,
0.12778140604496002,
0.4675784111022949,
0.752521812915802,
0.0590546615421772,
-0.5514436960220337,
-1.0015794038772583,
0.6634069085121155,
-0.8005582690238953,
0.177435964345932,
0.13701950013637543,
0.2727174758911133,
-0.16236847639083862,
-0.7592990398406982,
-0.44342947006225586,
-0.26876434683799744,
0.16647672653198242,
0.03154326230287552,
0.22204525768756866,
-0.1973342001438141,
0.18757183849811554,
0.5002357363700867,
-0.5391541719436646,
-0.024917876347899437,
-0.6533067226409912,
-0.3106481730937958,
0.8000930547714233,
0.27917298674583435,
0.0167420394718647,
-0.08051790297031403,
-0.5146897435188293,
0.11175459623336792,
-0.8825410008430481,
-0.08334866911172867,
0.4953802227973938,
0.1643938571214676,
0.287774920463562,
0.09018450975418091,
-0.1958169937133789,
0.636387825012207,
0.3519536256790161,
-0.007491033989936113,
0.4818316400051117,
-0.37664633989334106,
-0.14438366889953613,
-0.11163118481636047,
0.504274308681488,
0.0747789815068245,
0.2620463967323303,
-0.201362743973732,
-0.2784833014011383,
-0.05970074236392975,
0.7107552886009216,
-0.9626055359840393,
-0.3865031898021698,
0.38993602991104126,
-0.4915236532688141,
-0.5428401827812195,
0.05889817327260971,
-0.8710207343101501,
-0.21208177506923676,
-0.2600308954715729,
0.09890999644994736,
-0.4959297478199005,
-0.32996806502342224,
0.24956710636615753,
0.38037002086639404,
0.024819817394018173,
0.14643584191799164,
-0.4759692847728729,
-0.2525864243507385,
0.46765491366386414,
0.42598170042037964,
-0.07213415950536728,
-0.5201948285102844,
-0.3825203478336334,
-0.25128087401390076,
-0.575514018535614,
0.7080250382423401,
-0.35328248143196106,
-0.5930551290512085,
-0.019789107143878937,
-0.1883748173713684,
0.054830849170684814,
-0.7233598828315735,
-0.08292444050312042,
-0.6684808731079102,
0.1629730463027954,
-0.14690479636192322,
-0.6122041344642639,
0.1052672266960144,
0.10151741653680801,
-0.37153539061546326,
1.0187638998031616,
0.4373331069946289,
-0.5069307088851929,
0.4169156849384308,
-0.48963022232055664,
-0.37387871742248535,
-0.05037585273385048,
-0.25927096605300903,
-0.719189465045929,
0.1212620809674263,
-0.09566173702478409,
0.19977445900440216,
-0.09620414674282074,
0.004121249075978994,
-0.4383839964866638,
-0.3311895430088043,
0.055806536227464676,
0.0313853994011879,
0.42883411049842834,
0.8296529054641724,
-0.564658522605896,
0.14821936190128326,
-1.2589759826660156,
0.6977927088737488,
0.08962775021791458,
-0.36483246088027954,
0.2771992087364197,
0.07382797449827194,
-0.3760875165462494,
0.492883563041687,
0.10352437943220139,
-0.3930371403694153,
0.39008206129074097,
-0.3792850971221924,
0.5623344779014587,
0.788175642490387,
0.14859436452388763,
0.34114202857017517,
-0.16364498436450958,
0.9852109551429749,
0.03294605761766434,
0.1749413013458252,
-0.6833560466766357,
-0.1639360636472702,
-0.8376942873001099,
0.10185924917459488,
0.3428257703781128,
0.4296725392341614,
-0.7997680306434631,
0.31102699041366577,
0.18759921193122864,
-0.3264918327331543,
-0.5896944403648376,
0.9709400534629822,
0.7775405645370483,
0.4065901041030884,
0.4095023572444916,
-0.3739627003669739,
-0.7316625118255615,
-0.43853887915611267,
-0.2503010928630829,
-0.3112642765045166,
0.293935090303421,
0.011427872814238071,
0.3671376705169678,
-0.49239981174468994,
1.1611778736114502,
-0.43550869822502136,
-0.045616451650857925,
-0.16085641086101532,
0.3610292673110962,
-0.049839019775390625,
0.6582287549972534,
0.2784178853034973,
-0.2994837462902069,
-0.2240663766860962,
-0.428753525018692,
-0.4391689896583557,
-0.3492773473262787,
-0.20149320363998413,
0.0813855305314064,
0.5007727742195129,
0.8773770332336426,
0.3633784055709839,
0.27832701802253723,
0.6597610116004944,
-0.39994022250175476,
0.7559095621109009,
-0.5595972537994385,
-0.0264807790517807,
-0.7746967077255249,
-0.00022070114209782332,
-0.4442315697669983,
-0.4430809020996094,
-0.19331736862659454,
0.2096000760793686,
0.15296530723571777,
-0.25235265493392944,
-0.19811473786830902,
0.3101539611816406,
-0.6156765222549438,
-0.09429187327623367,
-0.5625079870223999,
-0.08416665345430374,
-0.031050872057676315,
0.4471410810947418,
-0.5731306672096252,
0.9188445210456848,
0.2009754180908203,
-0.7547629475593567,
0.17200006544589996,
-0.19057780504226685,
-0.4749923050403595,
0.09320446848869324,
-0.4314647316932678,
0.6493898034095764,
-0.02137322910130024,
0.01661081239581108,
-0.8647382855415344,
0.004406209569424391,
0.10015608370304108,
-0.31610843539237976,
0.47734197974205017,
0.04957982897758484,
-0.37923282384872437,
-0.7839153409004211,
-0.04618636146187782,
0.3918226361274719,
0.5034278035163879,
-0.6641402840614319,
0.12812791764736176,
-0.10614019632339478,
0.33945685625076294,
-0.524898111820221,
-0.4923332929611206,
-0.2942674160003662,
0.1682872772216797,
-0.5667600631713867,
0.04141887277364731,
-0.49904412031173706,
0.12578518688678741,
-0.03408633917570114,
-0.39994075894355774,
0.10671761631965637,
0.08616787940263748,
0.5874475836753845,
0.05950305983424187,
-0.10082553327083588,
0.4700973331928253,
-0.5347791314125061,
-0.542518138885498,
-0.06409753113985062,
-0.5181440711021423,
0.7045866847038269,
-0.2657143175601959,
-0.5921340584754944,
0.0051522525027394295,
-0.07938090711832047,
0.43713998794555664,
-0.4421819746494293,
0.20321062207221985,
0.39931559562683105,
0.11543796211481094,
-0.6892957091331482,
-0.6220384836196899,
0.02016001008450985,
-0.46744808554649353,
0.18078388273715973,
-0.4379957914352417,
-0.9013357758522034,
0.40337899327278137,
-0.31787148118019104,
-0.16262958943843842,
0.47878408432006836,
0.4240674376487732,
-0.04842619597911835,
0.9578218460083008,
0.8800560832023621,
-0.24755945801734924,
0.2704143226146698,
-0.5558574199676514,
0.2643768787384033,
-0.5198948979377747,
-0.08192364126443863,
-0.5352563858032227,
-0.11628726869821548,
-0.687766432762146,
-0.4444084167480469,
0.09015259146690369,
0.5736909508705139,
-0.5118409395217896,
0.3363189995288849,
-0.8308439254760742,
0.44276827573776245,
0.5561593174934387,
0.17749080061912537,
0.265443354845047,
-0.13065288960933685,
-0.23740777373313904,
0.14795444905757904,
-0.7501789331436157,
-0.4287205636501312,
0.9872124195098877,
0.28856122493743896,
0.9188728928565979,
-0.4247533082962036,
1.2054387331008911,
0.32906028628349304,
0.4999188780784607,
0.0005908376770094037,
0.31356850266456604,
0.05779644101858139,
-0.6709782481193542,
-0.10627321898937225,
-0.6841855049133301,
-0.7768002152442932,
-0.2098807990550995,
0.15961484611034393,
-0.21118150651454926,
0.2561196982860565,
0.5277482271194458,
-0.6108070015907288,
0.05200495198369026,
-0.6778171062469482,
0.9980575442314148,
-0.4273472726345062,
-0.4251539707183838,
-0.5441902279853821,
-0.29542526602745056,
0.32533279061317444,
-0.30313900113105774,
0.4700627624988556,
-0.15844830870628357,
0.19624358415603638,
0.2520676255226135,
-0.7896871566772461,
0.8167983293533325,
-0.1939169317483902,
-0.22015652060508728,
0.7078605890274048,
0.396047979593277,
0.24899965524673462,
0.11941023916006088,
-0.18899574875831604,
-0.06432434916496277,
0.023644352331757545,
-0.4559565484523773,
-0.6202540993690491,
0.7354031801223755,
-0.5987052321434021,
-0.634760856628418,
-0.30356496572494507,
-0.10196330398321152,
-0.2269338071346283,
0.29038482904434204,
0.4818810820579529,
0.3876941204071045,
0.031183242797851562,
-0.13842061161994934,
0.24278071522712708,
-0.32114890217781067,
0.6449329257011414,
0.7667738199234009,
-0.8648717403411865,
-0.4385494589805603,
0.9882940053939819,
-0.199408158659935,
0.30239731073379517,
-0.35740774869918823,
0.08688993752002716,
0.11688914149999619,
-0.3844234049320221,
-0.5542574524879456,
-0.023338379338383675,
-0.6402064561843872,
-0.6285889148712158,
-0.22955241799354553,
-0.2816007733345032,
-0.2707943916320801,
-0.06131340190768242,
-0.7021846175193787,
-0.28399893641471863,
-0.1705053448677063,
-0.11835359036922455,
0.13666929304599762,
0.9894688725471497,
-0.23968857526779175,
0.030095309019088745,
-0.8222883939743042,
0.2180115431547165,
0.3327435553073883,
0.6816872358322144,
-0.06225880607962608,
-0.22019025683403015,
-0.23610444366931915,
-0.05618003383278847,
-0.7073488235473633,
-0.8543482422828674,
0.26724761724472046,
0.02115364745259285,
0.20838989317417145,
0.36430710554122925,
-0.06135803833603859,
0.8638582229614258,
-0.544710099697113,
0.6887896656990051,
0.3347068727016449,
-1.068178653717041,
0.7367807030677795,
0.17264512181282043,
0.36023685336112976,
0.7870984077453613,
-0.16587267816066742,
-0.206450954079628,
-0.3908998668193817,
-0.7552469372749329,
-0.6516514420509338,
0.5492860674858093,
0.15707747638225555,
0.07256974279880524,
-0.12014070898294449,
0.86747807264328,
0.18206477165222168,
0.28932616114616394,
-0.7513124346733093,
-0.3393899202346802,
-0.44514521956443787,
-0.010128025896847248,
-0.05673801526427269,
-0.30510827898979187,
0.28690382838249207,
-0.1201847642660141,
0.7656875848770142,
-0.1556335687637329,
0.09478020668029785,
0.47350841760635376,
-0.059531036764383316,
-0.5869155526161194,
0.22290700674057007,
0.5880186557769775,
1.0259196758270264,
-0.006208180449903011,
-0.08526352047920227,
0.053847216069698334,
-0.05150264501571655,
0.2750304937362671,
-0.25332072377204895,
-0.21813265979290009,
-0.2650863528251648,
0.4014846682548523,
0.38738834857940674,
0.2808901369571686,
-0.6373960971832275,
0.20314109325408936,
0.2750414311885834,
-0.019209103658795357,
-0.3329179883003235,
0.49608737230300903,
-0.04387468099594116,
0.24946250021457672,
0.2562086582183838,
0.27638474106788635,
-0.10583031922578812,
-0.7693115472793579,
0.5043395757675171,
0.1727854460477829,
-0.3659897744655609,
-0.21206672489643097,
0.6231796145439148,
0.43276768922805786,
-0.4509042203426361,
0.6163225769996643,
-0.7589021921157837,
-0.8807471394538879,
0.7462707757949829,
0.6688698530197144,
1.0387530326843262,
-0.41955485939979553,
0.27213603258132935,
0.7137444019317627,
0.16803434491157532,
-0.13104252517223358,
0.481894314289093,
-0.03919019177556038,
-0.676441490650177,
-0.5075182318687439,
-0.7941794991493225,
-0.10266180336475372,
-0.06611919403076172,
-0.42304864525794983,
0.15967132151126862,
-0.5145918130874634,
-0.04102623090147972,
-0.4908375144004822,
0.15786167979240417,
-0.704882025718689,
0.3612447679042816,
-0.05365954712033272,
0.925987958908081,
-0.16749975085258484,
1.0351179838180542,
0.4201400578022003,
-0.738133430480957,
-0.8095136284828186,
0.045090027153491974,
-0.18198738992214203,
-1.063746690750122,
0.8861165046691895,
0.22891078889369965,
-0.3535665273666382,
0.14962278306484222,
-0.5903500914573669,
-0.7783684730529785,
1.0181673765182495,
0.23713912069797516,
-0.9211257696151733,
-0.05514353886246681,
0.03172078728675842,
0.657843291759491,
-0.7573806047439575,
0.051692549139261246,
0.28187501430511475,
0.26249781250953674,
-0.04828839749097824,
-0.6221428513526917,
-0.034730199724435806,
-0.09949249029159546,
0.1631176918745041,
0.16437770426273346,
-0.7794113159179688,
0.5940214991569519,
-0.7413888573646545,
-0.4193585515022278,
0.15746599435806274,
0.5647313594818115,
0.2502133250236511,
0.5538490414619446,
0.5850792527198792,
0.5050529837608337,
0.6251933574676514,
0.0947832390666008,
1.0587412118911743,
-1.160785436630249,
0.7169160842895508,
1.2121394872665405,
-0.2962384819984436,
0.6497763991355896,
0.06662391126155853,
-0.1867518275976181,
0.9368681311607361,
0.43241608142852783,
-0.130789652466774,
0.42202097177505493,
0.6232271194458008,
0.14479002356529236,
-0.430373877286911,
0.882117509841919,
-0.5529245138168335,
0.29465362429618835,
-0.16531305015087128,
-0.32815492153167725,
-0.21713340282440186,
-0.04597123712301254,
-0.15370288491249084,
0.3406311869621277,
-0.290963351726532,
0.4861181974411011,
0.11240044981241226,
-0.8869734406471252,
0.6030353903770447,
-0.05161983519792557,
0.34319907426834106,
-0.3341253995895386,
-0.06210244074463844,
-0.41232818365097046,
0.5619304776191711,
-0.4205554127693176,
-0.21153172850608826,
0.4212259352207184,
-0.06423504650592804,
-0.2868620455265045,
-0.4576205611228943,
0.7636333703994751,
-0.28689059615135193,
-0.5121912360191345,
0.5245522856712341,
0.4310954511165619,
-0.1578383892774582,
-0.11079282313585281,
-0.8515412211418152,
0.0890033096075058,
0.3546006679534912,
-0.12951816618442535,
0.031249426305294037,
0.2826787233352661,
0.5746581554412842,
0.9742907881736755,
0.5144203305244446,
0.06325884908437729,
0.35752949118614197,
-0.0214181337505579,
0.7681193947792053,
-0.9378161430358887,
-0.2545870840549469,
-0.6632503867149353,
0.4130968451499939,
0.05787261947989464,
-0.5234617590904236,
0.7391741871833801,
0.6884201169013977,
1.1216322183609009,
-0.13881683349609375,
0.6541337966918945,
0.07066889852285385,
0.7141989469528198,
-0.6340039968490601,
0.3634354770183563,
-0.43179047107696533,
0.6828356981277466,
-0.020967790856957436,
-0.7731921076774597,
0.055168647319078445,
0.5191313624382019,
-0.10087152570486069,
0.4509188234806061,
0.824362576007843,
0.8357515335083008,
0.39345604181289673,
0.06906463950872421,
0.2889341413974762,
0.3308424949645996,
0.272222638130188,
0.49899986386299133,
0.8021531105041504,
-0.43078044056892395,
0.7154109477996826,
-0.42762577533721924,
-0.14563477039337158,
-0.17009447515010834,
-0.8974071741104126,
-0.6707884073257446,
-0.5101869106292725,
-0.5137039422988892,
-0.769282877445221,
0.17231816053390503,
0.860359787940979,
0.8380654454231262,
-0.8153968453407288,
-0.1415790319442749,
-0.5869770050048828,
-0.023709477856755257,
-0.19166900217533112,
-0.21505014598369598,
-0.16741101443767548,
-1.462807536125183,
-0.32901355624198914,
0.4699498116970062,
0.3467384874820709,
-0.3762887120246887,
-0.6989002823829651,
-0.4447585642337799,
0.42740315198898315,
-0.023709310218691826,
0.3643839359283447,
0.5388924479484558,
-0.47765809297561646,
-0.2882744371891022,
0.03251902759075165,
-0.24028676748275757,
0.2592025101184845,
1.3510724306106567,
-1.006333351135254,
0.766418993473053,
0.11912301182746887,
0.4871766269207001,
0.6216555237770081,
-0.03175899758934975,
0.7034971714019775,
-0.5992024540901184,
-0.2976893484592438,
0.09120038896799088,
0.30376312136650085,
0.08645410090684891,
-0.33679771423339844,
0.6974923014640808,
0.1897573173046112,
-0.9855786561965942,
-0.6720343232154846,
0.4803072512149811,
-0.42488691210746765,
-0.5086668133735657,
1.0049190521240234,
-0.033248383551836014,
-0.0470268614590168,
-0.07908088713884354,
-0.12357334047555923,
0.19825461506843567,
0.043835561722517014,
1.202532410621643,
0.5873481631278992,
-0.23009701073169708,
-0.08064780384302139,
-0.490709125995636,
0.6969765424728394,
0.48466476798057556,
-0.7701640129089355,
0.14415109157562256,
0.4266868531703949,
0.7000777125358582,
0.4697500467300415,
0.8071256875991821,
-0.28549137711524963,
0.2709881663322449,
-0.1396266371011734,
0.5079214572906494,
-0.23750019073486328,
-0.30565696954727173,
-0.4290193021297455,
0.23836737871170044,
0.11325287073850632,
-0.17545373737812042
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18715v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18715v2
|
Mitigating Hallucinations in Large Vision-Language Models with Instruction Contrastive Decoding
| 2024-03-27T16:04:47 | 2024-06-05T13:53:42 |
Xintong Wang, Jingheng Pan, Liang Ding, Chris Biemann
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MM
|
Large Vision-Language Models (LVLMs) are increasingly adept at generating
contextually detailed and coherent responses from visual inputs. However, their
application in multimodal decision-making and open-ended generation is hindered
by a notable rate of hallucinations, where generated text inaccurately
represents the visual contents. To address this issue, this paper introduces
the Instruction Contrastive Decoding (ICD) method, a novel approach designed to
reduce hallucinations during LVLM inference. Our method is inspired by our
observation that what we call disturbance instructions significantly exacerbate
hallucinations in multimodal fusion modules. ICD contrasts distributions from
standard and instruction disturbance, thereby increasing alignment uncertainty
and effectively subtracting hallucinated concepts from the original
distribution. Through comprehensive experiments on discriminative benchmarks
(POPE and MME) and a generative benchmark (LLaVa-Bench), we demonstrate that
ICD significantly mitigates both object-level and attribute-level
hallucinations. Moreover, our method not only addresses hallucinations but also
significantly enhances the general perception and recognition capabilities of
LVLMs.
|
[
-0.40694254636764526,
-0.7055044174194336,
0.33391308784484863,
0.21702848374843597,
-0.5933526754379272,
-0.21548008918762207,
-0.2780244052410126,
-0.4271896183490753,
0.11733359843492508,
0.6792587041854858,
-0.5199307799339294,
-0.7303404808044434,
-0.37788599729537964,
-0.07955019176006317,
-0.34479978680610657,
0.6806681156158447,
-0.07937033474445343,
0.32037732005119324,
-0.2372416853904724,
-0.07831466943025589,
-0.31317922472953796,
-0.5976567268371582,
-0.5215400457382202,
-0.19545695185661316,
0.45277026295661926,
0.020931417122483253,
0.6156997084617615,
0.49592819809913635,
0.7510210871696472,
0.26598408818244934,
0.0006818257970735431,
0.5045534372329712,
-0.5125985145568848,
0.21364690363407135,
-0.06090216338634491,
-0.1639954000711441,
-0.25268828868865967,
-0.5536906123161316,
0.442046195268631,
0.8247078657150269,
-0.29743674397468567,
-0.3853553235530853,
0.3164401650428772,
0.5789985656738281,
-1.1623001098632812,
0.3411843478679657,
-0.388846755027771,
0.3588097393512726,
0.18832708895206451,
-0.36241990327835083,
-0.8354318141937256,
-0.024509094655513763,
-0.029314178973436356,
-0.5216690897941589,
0.2786417007446289,
-0.014183751307427883,
0.4060884118080139,
0.6169683337211609,
-0.032550644129514694,
-0.31473594903945923,
-0.7881897687911987,
0.7326193451881409,
-0.4400762617588043,
0.6829010248184204,
0.478054940700531,
0.07081761956214905,
-0.10084473341703415,
-0.445542573928833,
-0.7100691795349121,
-0.3047912120819092,
-0.11202634871006012,
0.18973073363304138,
-0.07798317074775696,
0.39751118421554565,
0.3112604022026062,
0.05397779867053032,
-0.5602226853370667,
0.27394554018974304,
-0.3781038522720337,
-0.30003535747528076,
0.28081926703453064,
0.2942963242530823,
0.06439097970724106,
0.011525461450219154,
-0.3572137951850891,
-0.517790675163269,
-0.5005103349685669,
-0.17505884170532227,
0.1028919443488121,
0.00917215645313263,
-0.06192503869533539,
0.44726473093032837,
-0.12929359078407288,
0.4934702217578888,
0.017856577411293983,
-0.225058913230896,
0.32603558897972107,
-0.11035072058439255,
-0.356332927942276,
0.2761465907096863,
0.4273878037929535,
0.831836462020874,
-0.11664172261953354,
-0.36392131447792053,
-0.4008321166038513,
0.38184475898742676,
0.29479530453681946,
-0.733971893787384,
-0.5379524827003479,
0.08486131578683853,
-0.6350430846214294,
-0.11451423913240433,
0.010644531808793545,
-1.1946779489517212,
-0.7852354049682617,
-0.28905224800109863,
0.5617176294326782,
-0.4853101074695587,
0.016180653125047684,
0.2767780125141144,
0.06440350413322449,
0.5144537687301636,
0.5140995383262634,
-0.9848117232322693,
0.32620975375175476,
0.44061723351478577,
0.6747385263442993,
-0.40680328011512756,
-0.35487085580825806,
-0.6400693655014038,
0.2171189934015274,
-0.6033757925033569,
0.8012005686759949,
-0.5522864460945129,
-0.4392578601837158,
0.011843036860227585,
-0.21542909741401672,
0.10954242944717407,
-0.8234734535217285,
0.3547152280807495,
-0.2801004648208618,
-0.15709161758422852,
0.004012611228972673,
-0.24727465212345123,
-0.14626652002334595,
0.18620583415031433,
-0.7148277163505554,
0.4938589036464691,
-0.06194836646318436,
-0.61688232421875,
0.14205384254455566,
-0.18808089196681976,
-0.47177842259407043,
-0.02791915088891983,
-0.2907586097717285,
-0.49468255043029785,
0.3290182054042816,
0.48981112241744995,
0.3905033469200134,
-0.04985673725605011,
-0.09719499945640564,
-0.16663552820682526,
-0.5642961859703064,
0.07430709153413773,
-0.6030541658401489,
0.3953113853931427,
0.23155087232589722,
-0.4645461440086365,
0.3645997941493988,
-0.7983951568603516,
-0.10517631471157074,
-0.07895410060882568,
-0.04411587491631508,
-0.5512840151786804,
0.16362957656383514,
-0.15664830803871155,
-0.09934508055448532,
-0.12879960238933563,
-0.029468433931469917,
-0.022500943392515182,
-0.2795281410217285,
-0.06954709440469742,
0.854625403881073,
0.06903739273548126,
0.279931902885437,
-0.07215358316898346,
0.3671025335788727,
0.4975728392601013,
0.18770268559455872,
-0.3710082471370697,
-0.08426173031330109,
-1.085159182548523,
-0.10339628159999847,
-0.20025335252285004,
0.4136468172073364,
-1.2883421182632446,
0.4291277825832367,
0.08149364590644836,
-0.17183054983615875,
-0.73598712682724,
-0.0769321620464325,
0.6428630948066711,
0.488530695438385,
0.7200494408607483,
-0.18341994285583496,
-0.3927578628063202,
-0.9061194658279419,
0.2675038278102875,
-0.030994800850749016,
-0.01830582693219185,
0.054248660802841187,
0.3807777166366577,
-0.35545700788497925,
0.06577973812818527,
-0.5329738259315491,
-0.31088173389434814,
0.10740701854228973,
0.06441105157136917,
-0.4282687306404114,
0.6523061990737915,
0.2960839867591858,
-0.754834771156311,
-0.14203597605228424,
0.10578873008489609,
-0.6124000549316406,
-0.1047116369009018,
-0.3828372359275818,
-0.10774344950914383,
0.5741948485374451,
0.6466994285583496,
-0.5781910419464111,
0.7074941396713257,
0.394859254360199,
-0.3540889024734497,
0.6268176436424255,
-0.4248769283294678,
0.4489695727825165,
-0.8474761843681335,
-0.32951557636260986,
-0.11794004589319229,
0.2451329380273819,
-0.5662528276443481,
0.40279534459114075,
0.06711286306381226,
0.11093275994062424,
-0.356319397687912,
0.17170530557632446,
-0.42798659205436707,
-0.035332102328538895,
-0.12317396700382233,
0.08419731259346008,
0.10767624527215958,
0.4691312313079834,
0.15614600479602814,
0.6952507495880127,
0.6978816986083984,
-0.5706160068511963,
0.3773728609085083,
0.14007893204689026,
-0.4982004463672638,
0.5844380259513855,
-0.26984018087387085,
0.21462231874465942,
-0.4491163194179535,
0.1307920515537262,
-0.7777208685874939,
-0.21074062585830688,
0.4837740659713745,
-0.03726457431912422,
0.26253828406333923,
0.413525253534317,
-0.39387956261634827,
-0.09439840167760849,
-0.5111541152000427,
0.5267177224159241,
0.5731624364852905,
-0.930486798286438,
0.6757327318191528,
-0.0499933660030365,
0.23046469688415527,
-0.6217198371887207,
-0.8082921504974365,
0.09038650989532471,
-0.03263239189982414,
-0.30425548553466797,
0.4622809886932373,
-0.39189615845680237,
-0.4208526909351349,
-0.03960788995027542,
-0.2522895038127899,
-0.04517560824751854,
-0.034542061388492584,
0.11386241018772125,
0.33094456791877747,
-0.27438032627105713,
0.21868382394313812,
0.0690627321600914,
0.008200835436582565,
0.2211684137582779,
0.008637885563075542,
0.7933216094970703,
0.1649247109889984,
-0.6667934060096741,
-0.6432624459266663,
0.5160771608352661,
0.5488759875297546,
-0.3773666322231293,
0.8099284768104553,
0.7203660607337952,
-0.416033536195755,
-0.4438357949256897,
-0.5544013381004333,
-0.5699923634529114,
-0.43937698006629944,
0.6140210032463074,
-0.37935778498649597,
-0.3590775728225708,
0.537667989730835,
0.18449072539806366,
-0.2437218576669693,
0.11066605895757675,
0.48846977949142456,
0.14553861320018768,
1.251619815826416,
0.34013617038726807,
0.2257297933101654,
0.30967119336128235,
-0.16326330602169037,
0.30639299750328064,
-0.8052416443824768,
-0.7143595218658447,
-0.4940589666366577,
-0.2080257683992386,
-0.31678786873817444,
-0.6553725004196167,
0.23976965248584747,
0.13358338177204132,
0.0546126589179039,
-0.42747294902801514,
-0.6398259401321411,
0.7654011249542236,
0.4378807842731476,
0.4566023647785187,
0.1395701766014099,
0.23572994768619537,
-0.07848579436540604,
-0.19991405308246613,
-0.3409295678138733,
-0.16124896705150604,
0.6343775391578674,
-0.10085272789001465,
1.26058030128479,
-0.014775969088077545,
0.8535729646682739,
0.1997843086719513,
-0.0342603363096714,
-0.7185457944869995,
0.703641951084137,
-0.27864933013916016,
0.19513510167598724,
0.04013359919190407,
-0.4519629180431366,
-0.5545573234558105,
0.599471926689148,
-0.49654367566108704,
-0.8380157947540283,
0.4060749411582947,
0.23045744001865387,
-0.26263904571533203,
0.4150829613208771,
-0.8002198934555054,
0.6062613129615784,
-0.16223835945129395,
-0.41357889771461487,
-0.37155064940452576,
-0.5258607268333435,
0.47078341245651245,
-0.020237725228071213,
0.04619885981082916,
0.4587828516960144,
0.00692435959354043,
0.4658207893371582,
-0.15259431302547455,
0.8909816145896912,
-0.1012561097741127,
-0.225041925907135,
0.014936109073460102,
0.1413639932870865,
0.5308085083961487,
-0.2512763738632202,
0.07858394831418991,
0.013682984746992588,
-0.3226011097431183,
-0.2283317744731903,
-0.7785793542861938,
0.9064436554908752,
-0.6746106743812561,
-0.6671493053436279,
-0.20962372422218323,
-0.801510214805603,
0.05427929759025574,
-0.023816822096705437,
0.30216172337532043,
0.5781165957450867,
0.023545634001493454,
0.3527725040912628,
1.0000005960464478,
-0.4390425980091095,
0.3774562478065491,
0.1797233372926712,
-0.18243426084518433,
-0.4514867067337036,
0.9358769655227661,
-0.08759035915136337,
0.39830243587493896,
0.399217426776886,
-0.04083665832877159,
-0.1578657329082489,
-0.880608081817627,
-0.07011345028877258,
0.018330147489905357,
-1.2318310737609863,
-0.1289689987897873,
-0.5437736511230469,
-0.1341332644224167,
-0.46914026141166687,
-0.34662580490112305,
-0.11849834769964218,
0.0005414514453150332,
-0.48078295588493347,
-0.047421179711818695,
-0.1305582970380783,
0.5582545399665833,
0.06815487146377563,
0.05662788078188896,
-0.5243668556213379,
0.7437952756881714,
0.1983959674835205,
0.2843605577945709,
0.19129639863967896,
-0.26024532318115234,
-0.06986075639724731,
-0.06429439038038254,
-0.1792515218257904,
-0.8187656402587891,
0.35073208808898926,
0.0037960477638989687,
0.5128617882728577,
0.610771119594574,
0.5296234488487244,
1.0012656450271606,
-0.3416339159011841,
0.8654595017433167,
0.4052988290786743,
-0.9089374542236328,
0.3691820502281189,
0.3742039203643799,
0.3681010603904724,
0.10288170725107193,
0.09006065130233765,
-0.2227751910686493,
-0.5028690695762634,
-0.19396266341209412,
-0.8593041896820068,
0.6036308407783508,
0.12408237159252167,
0.16530384123325348,
-0.2161761373281479,
0.2655523121356964,
0.16025663912296295,
0.06080692261457443,
-0.7963138818740845,
-0.17869998514652252,
-0.2850762605667114,
-0.34465259313583374,
0.03419545292854309,
-0.4303961396217346,
-0.12924613058567047,
-0.24225077033042908,
0.44990161061286926,
0.015588171780109406,
0.18373875319957733,
0.2901381850242615,
-0.0785335972905159,
-0.14795199036598206,
0.1388188600540161,
1.1145687103271484,
0.6304583549499512,
-0.14543023705482483,
0.6163330078125,
0.1622946858406067,
-0.5713807940483093,
-0.09770725667476654,
0.02157992497086525,
-0.16857872903347015,
-0.0732555165886879,
0.5817334651947021,
1.0487003326416016,
0.02545231580734253,
-0.7405171394348145,
0.22596843540668488,
-0.09149546921253204,
-0.135618656873703,
-0.02767352946102619,
0.25127241015434265,
-0.23827026784420013,
0.5322478413581848,
0.31262362003326416,
0.2008344680070877,
0.1841813325881958,
-0.2963563799858093,
0.11840253323316574,
0.3626612424850464,
-0.36521127820014954,
-0.165706068277359,
0.6145191192626953,
0.09195861220359802,
-0.44714540243148804,
0.6701528429985046,
-0.09741160273551941,
-0.3589918613433838,
0.6136259436607361,
0.9110864400863647,
0.9194028973579407,
-0.3496369421482086,
0.05030205845832825,
0.09359466284513474,
0.43094494938850403,
-0.062373463064432144,
0.12829042971134186,
-0.12000523507595062,
-0.7452078461647034,
-0.26919156312942505,
-0.4049217104911804,
-0.3338383436203003,
0.3864264488220215,
-0.9988950490951538,
0.18265967071056366,
-0.4274781048297882,
0.31717124581336975,
-0.02950439043343067,
-0.5100260972976685,
-0.3146366775035858,
0.0807650238275528,
0.32724910974502563,
0.5224652886390686,
-0.5215002298355103,
0.7037173509597778,
0.389390230178833,
-0.23178668320178986,
-0.5102388262748718,
0.4869030714035034,
-0.20397955179214478,
-0.5741044282913208,
0.5044965147972107,
0.31549370288848877,
-0.5261833667755127,
-0.009064887650310993,
-0.5663017630577087,
-0.10402100533246994,
0.8228885531425476,
0.3987467885017395,
-0.6129729747772217,
0.07643590867519379,
-0.1711871176958084,
0.5204646587371826,
-0.4750945568084717,
-0.20190107822418213,
0.6042502522468567,
0.3660789430141449,
0.23823870718479156,
-0.5121445059776306,
0.08167234063148499,
-0.12635476887226105,
-0.01272071897983551,
0.3168834149837494,
-0.231888547539711,
0.7798215746879578,
-0.6000407338142395,
-0.15452523529529572,
0.0801975205540657,
0.4488292634487152,
0.252109557390213,
0.4297454357147217,
0.5332970023155212,
0.5339648127555847,
0.7385472059249878,
-0.029879005625844002,
0.9824085831642151,
-0.2930125594139099,
0.1598452627658844,
0.9882427453994751,
-0.297455757856369,
0.857129693031311,
0.777747392654419,
0.24326997995376587,
0.3248574435710907,
0.33173230290412903,
-0.04487107694149017,
0.9565309882164001,
0.09010589122772217,
-0.492524117231369,
-0.31186988949775696,
-0.15894964337348938,
-0.5316240787506104,
0.3530791103839874,
0.4450555741786957,
-0.3884337544441223,
-0.21294428408145905,
0.4518158733844757,
-0.22273319959640503,
0.2520527243614197,
-0.60867840051651,
0.866844892501831,
-0.07392171770334244,
-0.6528139114379883,
0.9038174748420715,
-0.301116406917572,
0.4900948107242584,
-0.33751970529556274,
-0.5452293157577515,
-0.34561049938201904,
0.45216798782348633,
-0.09597302228212357,
-0.5427770018577576,
0.12137623131275177,
-0.3043367564678192,
-0.19086188077926636,
0.08703142404556274,
0.4745689630508423,
-0.7294452786445618,
-0.39216622710227966,
0.4648192822933197,
-0.03534331172704697,
0.08867592364549637,
0.013571340590715408,
-0.31736478209495544,
0.5572183132171631,
0.13130126893520355,
0.07535293698310852,
0.25699058175086975,
0.2946586012840271,
-0.052944544702768326,
0.6052074432373047,
0.35771793127059937,
0.03965327888727188,
-0.05803142115473747,
0.2895182967185974,
1.0054370164871216,
-0.6484681367874146,
-0.47002342343330383,
-0.9193577766418457,
0.3678344786167145,
-0.005821872036904097,
-0.09538500756025314,
0.3776038885116577,
0.25381678342819214,
0.9235424399375916,
-0.4116014540195465,
0.39858582615852356,
0.327650249004364,
-0.06553132832050323,
-1.0565444231033325,
0.5625275373458862,
-0.5473110675811768,
0.5747749209403992,
-0.22399617731571198,
-0.9733930826187134,
-0.7378175258636475,
0.8950074315071106,
0.02217906154692173,
-0.02866198681294918,
0.9458388686180115,
1.0495795011520386,
0.011513940058648586,
-0.2841860055923462,
0.5885664820671082,
0.4079333543777466,
0.2916955053806305,
0.5119748115539551,
0.9103549122810364,
-0.14812330901622772,
0.6630352735519409,
-0.5705531239509583,
-0.0394858717918396,
-0.3852727711200714,
-0.5966330170631409,
-1.06780207157135,
-0.543701171875,
-0.37680086493492126,
-0.4678005576133728,
0.35895687341690063,
0.8838413953781128,
0.42888206243515015,
-0.8744537234306335,
-0.00015524312038905919,
-0.012761741876602173,
0.26954153180122375,
-0.32899877429008484,
-0.21112796664237976,
0.6331075429916382,
-0.4507497251033783,
-0.7474470138549805,
0.22188571095466614,
0.522327721118927,
0.31214985251426697,
-0.5389935970306396,
-0.3756653368473053,
0.25911200046539307,
-0.04100906476378441,
0.7184150218963623,
-0.2894647419452667,
-1.1290321350097656,
-0.4179682731628418,
-0.10454285144805908,
-0.1709146946668625,
0.11448507010936737,
0.6199938058853149,
-0.6588793992996216,
0.7868064045906067,
0.3123879134654999,
0.45414820313453674,
0.20978690683841705,
-0.01871730573475361,
0.19048912823200226,
-0.5932447910308838,
0.5180383324623108,
0.2060716599225998,
0.24412304162979126,
0.3143433928489685,
-0.36198899149894714,
0.1736813336610794,
0.08504397422075272,
-0.2633434236049652,
-0.9946621060371399,
0.2841241657733917,
-0.9563580751419067,
-0.46855029463768005,
0.9941632151603699,
-0.006110284477472305,
-0.21025043725967407,
0.019438501447439194,
-0.5402053594589233,
-0.06500072032213211,
-0.17366118729114532,
1.1619296073913574,
0.4759953022003174,
-0.0048655360005795956,
-0.6122316718101501,
-0.2479046732187271,
0.5755534768104553,
0.34261077642440796,
-0.9550302624702454,
0.2659229040145874,
0.8053789138793945,
-0.3786279559135437,
0.32111677527427673,
0.17118734121322632,
0.12571245431900024,
0.4852164089679718,
0.3542903661727905,
0.2740866243839264,
0.034567058086395264,
-0.6032570004463196,
-0.4577513039112091,
0.2533145844936371,
-0.07022648304700851,
-0.3501371741294861
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18697v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18697v2
|
The Invalsi Benchmarks: measuring Linguistic and Mathematical understanding of Large Language Models in Italian
| 2024-03-27T15:46:25 | 2024-06-17T21:55:24 |
Andrea Esuli, Giovanni Puccetti
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While Italian is a high resource language, there are few Italian-native
benchmarks to evaluate Large Language Models (LLMs) generative abilities in
this language. This work presents two new benchmarks: Invalsi MATE to evaluate
models performance on mathematical understanding in Italian and Invalsi ITA to
evaluate language understanding in Italian. These benchmarks are based on the
Invalsi tests, which are administered to students of age between 6 and 18
within the Italian school system and have been validated by several experts in
teaching and pedagogy.
We use these benchmarks to evaluate 9 powerful language models showing that
current language models are bound by 70% accuracy in mathematical
understanding, achieved by Llama 3 70b and by 85% in language understanding. We
also compare LLMs with the average performance of Italian students to show that
Llama 3 is the only one to perform better than students on Invalsi MATE while
most models outperform students on Invalsi ITA.
We will make data and evaluation code openly available to pave the way for
the future development of larger and harder benchmarks to evaluate LLMs'
mathematical and linguistic understanding in Italian.
|
[
-0.2998192012310028,
-0.5102583169937134,
0.6795221567153931,
0.560949981212616,
-0.20914609730243683,
0.13060767948627472,
-0.29144805669784546,
-0.5838320851325989,
-0.24179768562316895,
0.2862999141216278,
-0.24634133279323578,
-0.20624114573001862,
-0.5093736052513123,
0.21458639204502106,
-0.326713502407074,
0.7309001684188843,
-0.1864200383424759,
0.938530445098877,
-0.5733319520950317,
-0.32485851645469666,
-0.25067824125289917,
-0.5163571834564209,
-0.7083764672279358,
-0.700130045413971,
0.10369481146335602,
0.3529648184776306,
0.4373365044593811,
0.3625786304473877,
0.7185624241828918,
0.31967833638191223,
-0.608747124671936,
-0.10618466883897781,
-0.3997570276260376,
-0.04463287070393562,
-0.29571694135665894,
-0.8488641977310181,
-0.2827800214290619,
-0.13516727089881897,
0.9244964718818665,
0.7572171688079834,
-0.11173202097415924,
0.23130959272384644,
0.004187220707535744,
0.6471964716911316,
-0.6621602773666382,
0.4703598916530609,
-0.6081414222717285,
-0.1390371024608612,
-0.38600093126296997,
0.06983718276023865,
-0.39045584201812744,
-0.6933593153953552,
-0.2520083785057068,
-0.3884643018245697,
-0.1590857207775116,
-0.11472564190626144,
0.7280557751655579,
0.1784030646085739,
-0.20504561066627502,
-0.3646574318408966,
-0.32399171590805054,
0.6882455348968506,
-0.7751426100730896,
0.4040795564651489,
0.44552066922187805,
0.6435485482215881,
-0.2190808206796646,
-0.3726118206977844,
-0.5203921794891357,
-0.4783942401409149,
0.2646864652633667,
-0.10303139686584473,
-0.16182298958301544,
-0.3198026418685913,
0.39085665345191956,
0.6721649765968323,
-0.5107089281082153,
0.36410877108573914,
-0.16117866337299347,
0.15785247087478638,
0.7213535904884338,
0.2442665547132492,
0.16825474798679352,
0.11316531896591187,
-0.41443589329719543,
-0.18869461119174957,
-1.098806619644165,
-0.01697850599884987,
0.34655487537384033,
0.09894614666700363,
-0.15015460550785065,
0.691409170627594,
-0.08225271105766296,
0.6348509788513184,
-0.4647691249847412,
-0.3219267427921295,
0.27412232756614685,
-0.4287484586238861,
-0.10690172761678696,
-0.04805465787649155,
0.7617429494857788,
0.02482520416378975,
0.6734474897384644,
-0.21690255403518677,
-0.21198461949825287,
0.19461053609848022,
-0.441459059715271,
-0.9134644865989685,
0.2894371449947357,
-0.4427074193954468,
-0.12026278674602509,
-0.014722833409905434,
-0.1539348065853119,
-0.7958751320838928,
-0.27307894825935364,
-0.21404965221881866,
0.49353015422821045,
-0.48672595620155334,
0.070828877389431,
0.27257847785949707,
0.10926809906959534,
0.17254076898097992,
0.15476761758327484,
-0.8942250609397888,
0.5572587847709656,
0.804092526435852,
0.8042995929718018,
-0.03522658720612526,
-0.2949915826320648,
-0.38581934571266174,
0.08759673684835434,
-0.41730326414108276,
0.7632938027381897,
-0.7214779257774353,
-0.43130114674568176,
-0.008158005774021149,
-0.20526038110256195,
-0.2109413743019104,
-0.897285521030426,
0.6747528910636902,
-0.3426502048969269,
0.13626325130462646,
-0.11339957267045975,
-0.7918238639831543,
-0.5064792037010193,
0.04445737972855568,
-0.5420773029327393,
1.1034895181655884,
0.11650785058736801,
-0.35938015580177307,
0.369045227766037,
-0.7772986888885498,
-0.056377388536930084,
0.18851338326931,
0.04709397256374359,
-0.3015565872192383,
0.3001228868961334,
0.20288807153701782,
0.2901281416416168,
-0.91120445728302,
0.4600466787815094,
-0.4902270436286926,
-0.38680362701416016,
0.39445486664772034,
-0.5466150641441345,
0.8035826683044434,
0.29102030396461487,
-0.38469478487968445,
-0.12789888679981232,
-0.8410018086433411,
0.19210141897201538,
0.18334072828292847,
-0.21401239931583405,
-0.21920305490493774,
0.04174480214715004,
-0.06597717851400375,
-0.07457872480154037,
0.3786078095436096,
-0.48173093795776367,
0.05391451716423035,
-0.49848034977912903,
0.7253550291061401,
0.4855527877807617,
-0.13689441978931427,
0.24008458852767944,
-0.1253337413072586,
0.47395676374435425,
-0.10723911225795746,
0.18497499823570251,
-0.2003965973854065,
-0.49810484051704407,
-0.835748553276062,
-0.28065136075019836,
0.2069804072380066,
0.46362894773483276,
-0.627806544303894,
0.2917220890522003,
-0.3438221216201782,
-0.8172194957733154,
-0.3509489595890045,
0.27972033619880676,
0.6232815384864807,
0.1928262859582901,
0.009903567843139172,
-0.2417706400156021,
-0.08729147911071777,
-0.8104812502861023,
-0.4816352128982544,
-0.3737912178039551,
-0.03714156523346901,
0.2980898916721344,
0.8234646916389465,
0.069426529109478,
0.5444086194038391,
-0.020084407180547714,
-0.16601304709911346,
-0.19518043100833893,
0.03901565819978714,
0.4946557879447937,
0.4918377697467804,
0.7662965059280396,
-0.6562432646751404,
-0.27534037828445435,
0.21394315361976624,
-0.7911791205406189,
0.08516020327806473,
0.5334237217903137,
0.0027601593174040318,
-0.07707923650741577,
0.26591944694519043,
-0.16556990146636963,
0.3563029170036316,
0.5320633053779602,
-0.4340231120586395,
0.07042974978685379,
-0.2420228272676468,
0.1442735642194748,
-1.0341286659240723,
-0.29403722286224365,
0.21721407771110535,
-0.09867169708013535,
-0.2128564715385437,
0.27688300609588623,
0.17290261387825012,
-0.1911957710981369,
-0.5736815929412842,
0.5544530749320984,
-0.4256879985332489,
-0.5067229866981506,
0.26619288325309753,
0.0006181133212521672,
-0.1895395964384079,
0.21635541319847107,
-0.042666416615247726,
1.2815544605255127,
0.5165004134178162,
-0.259751558303833,
0.43546754121780396,
0.02210911177098751,
-1.0383440256118774,
0.545814573764801,
-0.8105299472808838,
0.040050238370895386,
0.12029985338449478,
-0.04279680177569389,
-0.8762866854667664,
-0.14480774104595184,
0.16502119600772858,
-0.3701331615447998,
0.037252482026815414,
-0.07458663731813431,
-0.7270330190658569,
-0.13534772396087646,
0.20914781093597412,
0.6713760495185852,
0.19461005926132202,
-0.6525435447692871,
0.47338923811912537,
0.30361416935920715,
-0.194811150431633,
-0.1845228672027588,
-0.6925278306007385,
0.11649655550718307,
-0.4857068359851837,
-0.5484362840652466,
0.19318069517612457,
-0.34134119749069214,
-0.5977495908737183,
0.04438233748078346,
0.26908251643180847,
-0.6486704349517822,
0.2124137580394745,
-0.055865347385406494,
0.16063572466373444,
-0.5620523691177368,
0.23514048755168915,
-0.1400032490491867,
-0.2297021746635437,
0.1910073608160019,
0.04104309156537056,
0.6206170916557312,
-0.41525155305862427,
-0.5978827476501465,
-0.7100147008895874,
0.06560681760311127,
1.0121697187423706,
-0.5535567998886108,
0.7439472079277039,
-0.03242120519280434,
-0.44075068831443787,
0.07389072328805923,
-0.5327835083007812,
0.04305042698979378,
-0.3736235499382019,
0.40336883068084717,
-0.8095017075538635,
-0.6060828566551208,
0.5451198220252991,
-0.06219308078289032,
-0.056417886167764664,
0.5037912130355835,
0.5587750673294067,
0.17415276169776917,
1.2146704196929932,
0.6493948101997375,
-0.4820175766944885,
0.37307193875312805,
-0.2513715624809265,
0.11975637078285217,
-0.6852830052375793,
-0.47312024235725403,
-1.1660276651382446,
-0.12190691381692886,
-0.47840023040771484,
-0.32746362686157227,
0.44497811794281006,
0.22699744999408722,
-0.38786765933036804,
0.3107810616493225,
-0.15809038281440735,
0.8101176619529724,
0.32249873876571655,
0.09397329390048981,
0.5271813273429871,
0.20206502079963684,
-0.03925797715783119,
-0.2692674398422241,
-0.609542727470398,
-0.7712326645851135,
1.0682011842727661,
0.2773081660270691,
0.8410413861274719,
0.40234866738319397,
0.40563899278640747,
-0.17402584850788116,
0.3223450481891632,
-0.8658309578895569,
0.43690794706344604,
-0.1919964700937271,
-0.7195832133293152,
-0.1748393476009369,
-0.6841272115707397,
-0.422473281621933,
0.3843979835510254,
-0.006316874176263809,
-0.6759436130523682,
0.24361637234687805,
-0.4114353060722351,
-0.13385167717933655,
0.45048537850379944,
-0.7626990675926208,
0.7967276573181152,
-0.47691065073013306,
-0.5705187320709229,
-0.6506544351577759,
0.07675690948963165,
0.17011600732803345,
0.01840440183877945,
0.3294908404350281,
-0.5179305076599121,
-0.3804228901863098,
0.6464624404907227,
-0.35311591625213623,
0.46431538462638855,
0.10827096551656723,
-0.021681178361177444,
-0.03888747841119766,
0.05832225829362869,
0.12027791887521744,
0.4231649935245514,
-0.8458835482597351,
0.24640579521656036,
0.05013201758265495,
-0.6272826790809631,
-0.6311494708061218,
0.7142921090126038,
-0.7545335292816162,
-0.38201189041137695,
-0.6016169786453247,
-0.4830755293369293,
-0.25146475434303284,
-0.11778559535741806,
0.21206383407115936,
0.562117874622345,
-0.3503668010234833,
0.41486215591430664,
0.6998066306114197,
-0.02668158896267414,
0.6304880380630493,
0.8834649920463562,
0.19254077970981598,
-0.5752572417259216,
0.7924260497093201,
-0.06475155800580978,
0.31505057215690613,
0.25188949704170227,
0.05845649167895317,
-0.3564680814743042,
-0.5160350799560547,
-0.7604121565818787,
0.48619234561920166,
-0.5470162034034729,
-0.1806575059890747,
-0.027160145342350006,
-0.23157811164855957,
0.026072805747389793,
-0.07374794781208038,
-0.38494741916656494,
-0.1440000683069229,
-0.258827805519104,
0.10370621085166931,
0.3724673390388489,
1.116728663444519,
0.24159419536590576,
0.2528667747974396,
-0.4694482386112213,
-0.1627616286277771,
0.14777348935604095,
0.3854638338088989,
-0.23330558836460114,
-0.7323230504989624,
-0.23241356015205383,
0.04608132690191269,
-0.19758287072181702,
-0.7996854186058044,
0.31026536226272583,
0.3495675027370453,
0.7160041332244873,
0.6892990469932556,
-0.434464693069458,
0.8122713565826416,
-0.3047512471675873,
0.6780368685722351,
0.16815583407878876,
-1.3404446840286255,
0.4026814103126526,
-0.13307850062847137,
0.03450273722410202,
0.6892703771591187,
0.4956550896167755,
-0.2743089497089386,
-0.10335475206375122,
-0.4136406481266022,
-0.1658710241317749,
0.5984600782394409,
0.15996281802654266,
0.19403690099716187,
0.28725504875183105,
0.4843169152736664,
0.10117926448583603,
0.16843482851982117,
-0.7511383891105652,
0.07948584109544754,
0.5181564688682556,
-0.24440698325634003,
-0.6664411425590515,
-0.5083773136138916,
0.06466667354106903,
-0.481078177690506,
0.6065463423728943,
-0.09012719988822937,
-0.03462419658899307,
-0.25666671991348267,
-0.09583216160535812,
0.03987635672092438,
0.19313250482082367,
0.5372543334960938,
1.0412436723709106,
0.15717652440071106,
-0.18226341903209686,
0.6865690350532532,
-0.2471296638250351,
0.4288965165615082,
0.08427532762289047,
-0.06010178476572037,
0.08822423964738846,
0.5613405704498291,
0.8618205189704895,
0.8171401023864746,
-0.7598338723182678,
0.4784604609012604,
-0.1143474131822586,
-0.05384138226509094,
-0.4888540506362915,
0.11911119520664215,
0.08173736929893494,
0.23541487753391266,
0.12982957065105438,
-0.03199511393904686,
-0.032095495611429214,
-0.8760391473770142,
-0.12865453958511353,
0.30318498611450195,
-0.4286292791366577,
-0.34346458315849304,
0.6315122842788696,
0.10919368267059326,
-0.32087382674217224,
0.4231889545917511,
0.0024411603808403015,
-0.5481127500534058,
0.7625954151153564,
0.7043722867965698,
0.6753641963005066,
-0.39109519124031067,
0.13352617621421814,
0.530997633934021,
0.20388025045394897,
-0.19650228321552277,
0.22737444937229156,
-0.20592637360095978,
-0.7726364135742188,
-0.2866913676261902,
-0.5598624348640442,
-0.6419068574905396,
-0.23558159172534943,
-0.8330517411231995,
0.3135247230529785,
-0.2442205846309662,
0.11208915710449219,
0.17657651007175446,
0.3948666751384735,
-0.42644399404525757,
0.18640509247779846,
-0.3043130934238434,
1.141890048980713,
-1.0840599536895752,
0.8955021500587463,
0.8585357069969177,
-0.560103714466095,
-0.577829122543335,
-0.3619447350502014,
-0.13099727034568787,
-1.008256196975708,
0.8467541337013245,
-0.04881316050887108,
-0.0760919451713562,
-0.031751155853271484,
-0.35566282272338867,
-0.8570902347564697,
0.7352616786956787,
0.9213086366653442,
-0.6023331880569458,
0.0890892893075943,
0.1877633035182953,
0.4640916585922241,
-0.587015688419342,
0.8827818036079407,
0.7535347938537598,
0.5836435556411743,
0.24973949790000916,
-0.8977546095848083,
-0.6876957416534424,
-0.39988669753074646,
0.11982449144124985,
0.28151828050613403,
-0.8338506817817688,
0.8158182501792908,
-0.06702055782079697,
-0.15379318594932556,
0.6080974340438843,
0.5718057155609131,
0.10874076187610626,
0.6179158091545105,
0.45531603693962097,
0.8519611954689026,
0.5665671229362488,
-0.5834406614303589,
0.9911615252494812,
-0.2885526418685913,
0.11418742686510086,
0.8076819181442261,
-0.21727071702480316,
1.1934791803359985,
0.27167582511901855,
-0.5266067385673523,
0.5328432321548462,
0.7161254286766052,
0.19275467097759247,
0.0751471146941185,
0.3825266361236572,
-0.7307324409484863,
-0.324341744184494,
-0.3835441470146179,
-0.6942272782325745,
0.6133723855018616,
0.4417966902256012,
-0.11522229760885239,
-0.2302718460559845,
0.09718871861696243,
0.4132561683654785,
0.5305201411247253,
-0.343893826007843,
0.888403058052063,
0.00118365534581244,
-0.5943268537521362,
0.7335013747215271,
-0.24738118052482605,
0.339407742023468,
-0.6610332727432251,
0.053414810448884964,
-0.5473619103431702,
0.4948227107524872,
-0.002493392676115036,
-0.8394266366958618,
0.04403981566429138,
0.5201560258865356,
-0.08710627257823944,
-0.0790252834558487,
-0.14132584631443024,
-0.4106883108615875,
-0.910569965839386,
0.4333858788013458,
0.22266052663326263,
0.585091233253479,
0.057623397558927536,
-0.5129056572914124,
0.3097895681858063,
-0.003393240738660097,
0.11924652010202408,
0.17531169950962067,
0.40815889835357666,
-0.10280156880617142,
0.9241666197776794,
0.40904733538627625,
0.3717989921569824,
-0.00233049551025033,
0.2601020932197571,
0.7607014775276184,
-0.4363870322704315,
-0.1285899132490158,
-0.8591411113739014,
0.07870638370513916,
-0.17591004073619843,
-0.7601699829101562,
0.7271235585212708,
0.8462615609169006,
1.0590800046920776,
0.1946658343076706,
0.27898943424224854,
0.27592772245407104,
0.3660806715488434,
-0.5916294455528259,
0.6695759892463684,
-0.8667730689048767,
0.04391028359532356,
-0.1694723665714264,
-1.2911697626113892,
-0.2114938348531723,
0.6680362224578857,
-0.4646014869213104,
-0.04644789546728134,
0.6179111003875732,
0.8354403376579285,
0.27951568365097046,
0.12950384616851807,
0.4836791753768921,
0.14891092479228973,
0.20196016132831573,
0.9706284403800964,
1.068164348602295,
-0.48223358392715454,
0.21264709532260895,
-0.3470812439918518,
-0.3467448651790619,
0.06910441815853119,
-0.6679269671440125,
-0.9291602969169617,
-0.449383020401001,
-0.0637904554605484,
0.09349627792835236,
0.35460177063941956,
0.6502132415771484,
0.6812245845794678,
-0.9376658797264099,
-0.7998763918876648,
-0.12413114309310913,
0.14582659304141998,
-0.20350024104118347,
-0.14488337934017181,
0.04510312154889107,
-0.4676985740661621,
-1.2709790468215942,
0.6586324572563171,
0.30526259541511536,
0.08129352331161499,
-0.35478416085243225,
-0.13262929022312164,
0.07810619473457336,
-0.07241073250770569,
0.34340497851371765,
0.14131563901901245,
-0.6825047135353088,
0.19211897253990173,
-0.19478654861450195,
-0.08015978336334229,
-0.1419304758310318,
0.6328094005584717,
-0.6372791528701782,
0.6025128364562988,
0.5959354639053345,
0.49107491970062256,
0.6643598675727844,
-0.2504584491252899,
0.6837586760520935,
0.3264444172382355,
0.6312683820724487,
0.20755821466445923,
0.5111455917358398,
0.26839491724967957,
-0.08672919124364853,
0.7992600202560425,
0.14935356378555298,
-0.37239396572113037,
-0.9533380270004272,
0.051003772765398026,
-0.3223734498023987,
0.0061883083544671535,
0.5578635334968567,
-0.35838475823402405,
-0.23597365617752075,
0.40550583600997925,
0.09079431742429733,
-0.054910171777009964,
-0.1599118709564209,
0.5637117624282837,
0.8093736171722412,
0.2966928482055664,
0.01600312441587448,
-0.7145898938179016,
0.25726956129074097,
0.7836290597915649,
-0.9356516003608704,
-0.29971054196357727,
0.29504770040512085,
0.03686201944947243,
-0.19256949424743652,
-0.09141894429922104,
-0.4828963875770569,
0.36098381876945496,
-0.12463321536779404,
-0.03554750606417656,
0.1441318839788437,
-0.35924699902534485,
-0.3895372748374939,
0.07049534469842911,
0.212722510099411,
-0.05533136799931526
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18684v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18684v1
|
Scaling Laws For Dense Retrieval
| 2024-03-27T15:27:36 | 2024-03-27T15:27:36 |
Yan Fang, Jingtao Zhan, Qingyao Ai, Jiaxin Mao, Weihang Su, Jia Chen, Yiqun Liu
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Scaling up neural models has yielded significant advancements in a wide array
of tasks, particularly in language generation. Previous studies have found that
the performance of neural models frequently adheres to predictable scaling
laws, correlated with factors such as training set size and model size. This
insight is invaluable, especially as large-scale experiments grow increasingly
resource-intensive. Yet, such scaling law has not been fully explored in dense
retrieval due to the discrete nature of retrieval metrics and complex
relationships between training data and model sizes in retrieval tasks. In this
study, we investigate whether the performance of dense retrieval models follows
the scaling law as other neural models. We propose to use contrastive
log-likelihood as the evaluation metric and conduct extensive experiments with
dense retrieval models implemented with different numbers of parameters and
trained with different amounts of annotated data. Results indicate that, under
our settings, the performance of dense retrieval models follows a precise
power-law scaling related to the model size and the number of annotations.
Additionally, we examine scaling with prevalent data augmentation methods to
assess the impact of annotation quality, and apply the scaling law to find the
best resource allocation strategy under a budget constraint. We believe that
these insights will significantly contribute to understanding the scaling
effect of dense retrieval models and offer meaningful guidance for future
research endeavors.
|
[
-0.18930484354496002,
-0.5671913623809814,
0.5195105075836182,
0.3509471118450165,
-0.21965858340263367,
-0.5706980228424072,
-0.5352168083190918,
-0.5149710178375244,
0.2623628079891205,
0.6688369512557983,
-0.09564810246229172,
0.21036210656166077,
-0.4943699538707733,
-0.04422152787446976,
-0.44108012318611145,
0.908342719078064,
0.31258121132850647,
0.33884409070014954,
-0.2372923046350479,
-0.3518817126750946,
-0.593879222869873,
-0.6553444266319275,
-0.5248966217041016,
-0.4486149847507477,
0.6632996797561646,
0.09934987872838974,
0.982446014881134,
0.9692975282669067,
0.8847230672836304,
0.268639475107193,
-0.4232434332370758,
-0.14819657802581787,
-0.6029649972915649,
-0.0009970800019800663,
-0.10416818410158157,
-0.47233301401138306,
-0.2692648768424988,
-0.20326201617717743,
0.959771990776062,
0.8503841161727905,
-0.2941424548625946,
0.04255475476384163,
0.04317735880613327,
0.6386330723762512,
-0.8021335005760193,
-0.16988272964954376,
-0.7549949288368225,
0.0638735219836235,
0.08846995234489441,
-0.11341279745101929,
-0.5539885759353638,
-0.3181268572807312,
0.2123393714427948,
-0.6194142699241638,
0.39027032256126404,
0.21760720014572144,
0.7051207423210144,
0.2719370424747467,
-0.36344242095947266,
-0.3240538239479065,
-0.5224266052246094,
0.9198068976402283,
-0.8172833323478699,
0.1628049910068512,
0.447323739528656,
0.25026100873947144,
0.37806737422943115,
-0.8934410810470581,
-0.3490542471408844,
-0.41556471586227417,
-0.46976545453071594,
-0.3968346416950226,
-0.01998613402247429,
0.12486230581998825,
0.5810481905937195,
0.4270035922527313,
-0.4730173647403717,
0.32445964217185974,
-0.34956562519073486,
0.06722860783338547,
0.8637385368347168,
0.33268114924430847,
0.12553086876869202,
-0.20067068934440613,
-0.14194829761981964,
-0.2791101634502411,
-0.2941259443759918,
-0.4856603741645813,
0.08283941447734833,
0.678097665309906,
0.03146561607718468,
0.5779523849487305,
-0.27994614839553833,
0.5265940427780151,
0.028080793097615242,
0.1675960123538971,
0.26628050208091736,
-0.7368514537811279,
-0.12588199973106384,
0.19776548445224762,
0.685040295124054,
0.43034642934799194,
0.3847447633743286,
-0.2500626742839813,
-0.4636317193508148,
-0.6416026949882507,
0.49739208817481995,
-1.2436965703964233,
-0.174387127161026,
-0.2001335471868515,
-0.6634166836738586,
-0.2444266825914383,
-0.3259204030036926,
-0.5146811604499817,
-0.6074823141098022,
-0.3366982340812683,
0.9139866232872009,
-0.339510053396225,
-0.5139227509498596,
0.17872346937656403,
-0.056018296629190445,
0.16853030025959015,
0.19616049528121948,
-1.3832663297653198,
0.40469178557395935,
0.5895980596542358,
0.8867801427841187,
0.20295704901218414,
-0.10358132421970367,
-0.5379890203475952,
-0.3858083188533783,
-0.383662611246109,
0.1547078639268875,
-0.550641655921936,
-0.1878480762243271,
0.03657398372888565,
-0.31877169013023376,
-0.013312290422618389,
-0.8003572821617126,
0.38440534472465515,
-0.8178420066833496,
-0.4844876825809479,
-0.5744309425354004,
-0.5577066540718079,
-0.0423877090215683,
-0.13080212473869324,
-1.009730339050293,
0.7447196841239929,
-0.016756996512413025,
-0.7141474485397339,
0.6623968482017517,
-0.33957603573799133,
-0.45289915800094604,
0.23998397588729858,
-0.2655981779098511,
-0.5944439768791199,
0.5057359933853149,
-0.15268023312091827,
0.5283804535865784,
-0.5577574968338013,
0.31310558319091797,
-0.4592213034629822,
-0.5418053865432739,
0.22907178103923798,
-0.39540600776672363,
0.7197011113166809,
0.3073599338531494,
-0.4123627841472626,
-0.10718918591737747,
-0.624265730381012,
0.07369957119226456,
0.17673921585083008,
-0.37320321798324585,
-0.39630910754203796,
-0.03823506087064743,
0.23778687417507172,
-0.09121572226285934,
0.3593057096004486,
-0.571137547492981,
0.10564185678958893,
0.11647047847509384,
0.37742769718170166,
0.3734137713909149,
0.17090220749378204,
0.7205792665481567,
-0.10231444984674454,
0.019251888617873192,
-0.14523708820343018,
0.04660271108150482,
0.06638112664222717,
-0.07193721830844879,
-0.49801260232925415,
-0.1569192111492157,
0.4624939262866974,
-0.009738793596625328,
-0.11509862542152405,
0.1914965659379959,
-0.48326537013053894,
-0.46824610233306885,
-0.3699322044849396,
0.07194958627223969,
0.3776916265487671,
0.4037071764469147,
0.5218556523323059,
-0.27372536063194275,
-0.4943503439426422,
-1.1172404289245605,
-0.18641819059848785,
0.08197102695703506,
-0.12530839443206787,
0.8565687537193298,
0.5579109787940979,
0.10409141331911087,
0.565275251865387,
-0.4291534423828125,
-0.12160757184028625,
0.07322394102811813,
0.20937636494636536,
0.2214585542678833,
0.7904384732246399,
0.7118809223175049,
-1.1045491695404053,
-0.23505988717079163,
0.169862300157547,
-0.723010778427124,
-0.06373804062604904,
-0.16189715266227722,
0.12751983106136322,
-0.2166544795036316,
0.6044902205467224,
-0.3505217730998993,
0.1488932967185974,
0.14722014963626862,
-0.2992497682571411,
0.5539947152137756,
-0.4229664206504822,
0.08796103298664093,
-0.6654406785964966,
0.18443137407302856,
-0.03996162861585617,
0.09436259418725967,
-0.5981515049934387,
0.24256661534309387,
0.3643900454044342,
0.2468247413635254,
-0.15858466923236847,
0.36164727807044983,
-0.3254879117012024,
-0.3943723738193512,
-0.17129920423030853,
-0.10830441117286682,
0.03481675684452057,
0.13092826306819916,
0.1326265186071396,
0.8190537691116333,
0.20738114416599274,
-0.5789027214050293,
0.008596358820796013,
-0.28891122341156006,
-0.3198195695877075,
0.3244137763977051,
-0.8954638242721558,
-0.15158942341804504,
0.010764291509985924,
-0.0568770132958889,
-0.8033273816108704,
-0.07585744559764862,
-0.7179383635520935,
-0.10156761109828949,
0.41105952858924866,
-0.13337460160255432,
-0.9326955080032349,
0.09665237367153168,
0.05397755652666092,
0.7118996977806091,
0.5672556161880493,
-0.6009784936904907,
0.6068196296691895,
0.10614955425262451,
0.023386424407362938,
-0.5867084264755249,
-0.6875812411308289,
-0.32023459672927856,
-0.3785928189754486,
-0.3672500550746918,
0.270862877368927,
-0.252235472202301,
-0.538308322429657,
-0.12163873761892319,
0.14434024691581726,
-0.30723950266838074,
0.1568318009376526,
0.015084982849657536,
0.09421030431985855,
-0.5329461693763733,
0.23572738468647003,
-0.1422009915113449,
0.49321889877319336,
0.3804127275943756,
-0.3044855296611786,
0.5210944414138794,
-0.16205038130283356,
0.08923746645450592,
0.06170224770903587,
-0.02540471777319908,
0.4472044110298157,
-0.27438780665397644,
0.7590593695640564,
0.655653178691864,
-0.3634282648563385,
0.12479481846094131,
-0.841564416885376,
-0.4465523362159729,
-0.4618014395236969,
0.595183789730072,
-0.4544024169445038,
-0.6136357188224792,
0.6423944234848022,
0.24071021378040314,
0.04101979359984398,
0.5817962288856506,
0.4481097459793091,
0.10967507213354111,
1.0152524709701538,
0.5134046077728271,
0.08605396002531052,
0.6555054783821106,
-0.26598551869392395,
-0.24973440170288086,
-0.8837078809738159,
-0.17764516174793243,
-0.5881634950637817,
-0.6409321427345276,
-0.6816926598548889,
-0.2739688754081726,
0.006318832281976938,
0.3073357343673706,
-0.41253989934921265,
0.27075064182281494,
-0.5944234728813171,
0.6478767395019531,
0.4209972321987152,
0.2670215666294098,
0.2500413656234741,
0.23722334206104279,
-0.18749691545963287,
-0.23073022067546844,
-0.6539869904518127,
-0.0384589321911335,
1.3464845418930054,
0.02009044773876667,
0.5157164931297302,
0.15749672055244446,
0.5536416172981262,
0.20588810741901398,
0.29709768295288086,
-0.5912690162658691,
0.4327073097229004,
-0.31882888078689575,
-0.7385818362236023,
-0.5248875617980957,
-0.9775798916816711,
-1.0463234186172485,
0.5459591150283813,
-0.3150184750556946,
-0.5924323201179504,
0.49942758679389954,
-0.32120856642723083,
-0.41946250200271606,
0.38224634528160095,
-0.631352424621582,
0.5628177523612976,
-0.20994022488594055,
-0.5569594502449036,
-0.6333566904067993,
-0.4994875192642212,
0.07212186604738235,
-0.3401431739330292,
-0.04373732581734657,
0.026154255494475365,
-0.18313844501972198,
0.8829832673072815,
-0.44955000281333923,
0.6119459867477417,
-0.1685066819190979,
0.025076143443584442,
0.3582753837108612,
0.23166315257549286,
0.2839900255203247,
0.05539439246058464,
-0.4037002921104431,
0.0178314670920372,
-0.23530955612659454,
-0.5988267064094543,
-0.7819918394088745,
0.9081142544746399,
-0.8545837998390198,
-0.2466350495815277,
0.06177907809615135,
-0.9494385123252869,
0.2843163311481476,
0.43363943696022034,
0.2665662169456482,
0.4102928936481476,
0.10785731673240662,
0.6543027758598328,
0.950289785861969,
0.18435123562812805,
0.6003519892692566,
0.5592687726020813,
-0.17327533662319183,
-0.30261465907096863,
1.0377197265625,
0.7567746639251709,
0.3449455201625824,
0.38475996255874634,
0.24180546402931213,
-0.25567662715911865,
-0.8402814865112305,
-0.20140786468982697,
0.3475460112094879,
-0.5191202163696289,
-0.07523644715547562,
-0.6086063385009766,
-0.17061667144298553,
-0.1746082752943039,
-0.2774178981781006,
-0.38355037569999695,
-0.5629122853279114,
-0.34714242815971375,
0.04224396497011185,
0.4478924870491028,
0.6719394326210022,
-0.14087077975273132,
0.10519688576459885,
-0.3023998439311981,
-0.11473608762025833,
0.3369259238243103,
0.2867662012577057,
0.26345744729042053,
-0.8953001499176025,
-0.4382040202617645,
-0.20880810916423798,
0.0439525805413723,
-0.3497161865234375,
0.2790740728378296,
0.011392544023692608,
0.2385426014661789,
0.23118902742862701,
-0.007998225279152393,
0.5805466771125793,
-0.5089085698127747,
0.4467694163322449,
0.14448517560958862,
-0.379290372133255,
0.2647572457790375,
-0.21052362024784088,
0.21224656701087952,
0.5973003506660461,
0.33090683817863464,
0.03049595095217228,
0.1861536204814911,
-0.8673704862594604,
-0.8798943758010864,
0.4167560636997223,
0.16658389568328857,
0.5975196957588196,
0.13268224895000458,
0.9456191062927246,
-0.11525312811136246,
0.2765660285949707,
-0.6605957746505737,
0.005741300992667675,
-0.030463485047221184,
0.059295471757650375,
-0.11709388345479965,
-0.28440481424331665,
0.1505138874053955,
-0.032481174916028976,
0.3209606409072876,
0.019566256552934647,
-0.08403969556093216,
0.0955653190612793,
-0.06921666115522385,
0.05600644648075104,
0.022896289825439453,
0.47704944014549255,
0.49227604269981384,
-0.3558405935764313,
0.024786122143268585,
0.25397226214408875,
-0.6792920231819153,
0.01677551493048668,
0.24693918228149414,
-0.4003402292728424,
-0.0570649690926075,
0.3160328269004822,
0.7562653422355652,
0.3704623281955719,
-0.6843315362930298,
0.4261452853679657,
-0.17970439791679382,
-0.39248812198638916,
-0.22779959440231323,
0.082862488925457,
-0.05189055576920509,
0.3926580548286438,
0.44978368282318115,
-0.14667293429374695,
0.3797779083251953,
-0.17082004249095917,
0.2590673565864563,
0.4281466007232666,
-0.42508766055107117,
-0.13958799839019775,
0.7064165472984314,
-0.10251529514789581,
-0.15088516473770142,
1.2627034187316895,
0.006760234013199806,
0.1523633599281311,
0.8061800599098206,
0.42289018630981445,
0.4784778356552124,
0.004751879256218672,
-0.19800780713558197,
0.7126062512397766,
0.4031660556793213,
-0.26525047421455383,
0.06052364408969879,
-0.28750041127204895,
-0.4679127633571625,
-0.4790586829185486,
-0.6987062692642212,
-0.058566298335790634,
0.18593481183052063,
-1.039154291152954,
-0.06595209985971451,
-0.5951724052429199,
-0.2810182273387909,
0.15714554488658905,
0.4183170795440674,
-0.6667561531066895,
0.5105076432228088,
0.019923914223909378,
0.7119091153144836,
-0.5849376320838928,
0.5020679831504822,
0.3889063596725464,
-0.9007213711738586,
-0.8061493039131165,
-0.21343521773815155,
-0.21914410591125488,
-0.6610077619552612,
0.8436992764472961,
0.11847423762083054,
0.2525593638420105,
0.021717431023716927,
-0.3355386555194855,
-1.0827351808547974,
1.2539982795715332,
0.5759286880493164,
-0.5719904899597168,
-0.18788525462150574,
-0.06682398915290833,
0.7453632354736328,
-0.4892110824584961,
0.650706946849823,
0.5319488048553467,
0.16454018652439117,
0.025437576696276665,
-0.897188663482666,
0.29198285937309265,
-0.13136692345142365,
0.21202994883060455,
0.1741168051958084,
-0.7453466653823853,
1.0648999214172363,
-0.40701475739479065,
0.13308009505271912,
0.10598742216825485,
0.7307453155517578,
0.13942645490169525,
-0.024838212877511978,
0.5123781561851501,
0.6332868933677673,
0.66018146276474,
0.20178864896297455,
1.235579252243042,
-0.11669040471315384,
0.3774850368499756,
1.1065549850463867,
-0.26778003573417664,
1.1190232038497925,
0.41765519976615906,
-0.003760380670428276,
0.4135870039463043,
0.455971896648407,
-0.2614707052707672,
0.30048906803131104,
0.4998701512813568,
-0.14919741451740265,
-0.08182040601968765,
-0.5874360799789429,
-0.24339383840560913,
-0.03799189254641533,
0.23589739203453064,
-0.8663622736930847,
0.11817971616983414,
-0.20519541203975677,
0.009497684426605701,
0.09145238995552063,
-0.5846607089042664,
0.8172993659973145,
-0.11703025549650192,
-0.4812735617160797,
0.7802822589874268,
-0.3413878083229065,
0.48164623975753784,
-0.38749125599861145,
0.0921003520488739,
-0.377664715051651,
0.08517304062843323,
-0.24820619821548462,
-0.667505145072937,
-0.008251361548900604,
-0.22462968528270721,
-0.4894459545612335,
0.06954585015773773,
0.4463537037372589,
-0.21652103960514069,
-0.3885314166545868,
0.490644633769989,
0.04858784005045891,
0.2825830578804016,
-0.12345761805772781,
-0.49787774682044983,
0.1821829229593277,
-0.13768739998340607,
-0.39028027653694153,
0.7372104525566101,
0.4539165496826172,
0.02309076115489006,
0.5133951902389526,
0.3650759160518646,
0.2470872551202774,
0.3372267782688141,
0.4002608060836792,
0.7004966139793396,
-0.3622779846191406,
-0.07516417652368546,
-0.7159264087677002,
0.2670463025569916,
-0.4324144124984741,
-0.18769115209579468,
0.6234139800071716,
0.7085193991661072,
0.6910251975059509,
0.20827768743038177,
0.34741634130477905,
0.0815618559718132,
-0.08280312269926071,
-0.3562924265861511,
0.6308132410049438,
-0.6967172026634216,
0.1501287817955017,
-0.020055551081895828,
-1.121382713317871,
-0.31394705176353455,
0.46284377574920654,
-0.4316388666629791,
0.3897700905799866,
0.4627615809440613,
0.7566567659378052,
-0.08847944438457489,
-0.03296345844864845,
0.49922609329223633,
0.3058561384677887,
-0.039550796151161194,
0.22649022936820984,
0.13899563252925873,
-0.42182663083076477,
0.8519874811172485,
-0.25513550639152527,
-0.11998829990625381,
-0.4058936834335327,
-0.4004478454589844,
-0.5836637616157532,
-0.5384461879730225,
-0.28191283345222473,
-0.3897969424724579,
-0.08133561909198761,
0.4680387079715729,
0.9378204941749573,
-0.34308210015296936,
-0.43504568934440613,
-0.26497089862823486,
-0.34942129254341125,
-0.2851654589176178,
-0.25798913836479187,
0.33742424845695496,
-0.6495556235313416,
-0.5023936629295349,
0.0518924705684185,
-0.007437008898705244,
0.006889536511152983,
-0.30320897698402405,
-0.024174083024263382,
-0.2791329324245453,
0.27124637365341187,
0.5178512334823608,
0.18647487461566925,
-0.5232139825820923,
-0.07331191748380661,
-0.15596207976341248,
-0.5316352248191833,
-0.015960507094860077,
1.008926510810852,
-0.6403282880783081,
0.5859701037406921,
0.5405968427658081,
0.9396749138832092,
0.9242767095565796,
-0.2776980996131897,
0.3864349126815796,
-0.7544785737991333,
-0.05380746349692345,
0.3576934039592743,
0.42445775866508484,
0.2849113941192627,
-0.5508077144622803,
0.7234485149383545,
-0.12832093238830566,
-0.8089876174926758,
-0.9067827463150024,
0.060478225350379944,
-0.4807899594306946,
-0.137065127491951,
1.040230393409729,
0.006131939124315977,
-0.07661698013544083,
0.42475828528404236,
0.054141465574502945,
0.02670232579112053,
-0.287100225687027,
0.6478295922279358,
0.6266297101974487,
-0.03548216074705124,
-0.25241443514823914,
-0.7123618125915527,
0.3392515480518341,
1.1098698377609253,
-0.2349010407924652,
0.3911767899990082,
0.4119531810283661,
0.025482969358563423,
0.43738046288490295,
0.5248883366584778,
-0.12538030743598938,
0.23888543248176575,
0.29466086626052856,
-0.0725807324051857,
0.3665246367454529,
-0.013532415963709354,
-0.6282950043678284,
0.3763114809989929,
0.14270976185798645,
0.4021584987640381
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18680v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18680v2
|
Non-Linear Inference Time Intervention: Improving LLM Truthfulness
| 2024-03-27T15:22:16 | 2024-06-06T13:58:20 |
Jakub Hoscilowicz, Adam Wiacek, Jan Chojnacki, Adam Cieslak, Leszek Michon, Vitalii Urbanevych, Artur Janicki
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In this work, we explore LLM's internal representation space to identify
attention heads that contain the most truthful and accurate information. We
further developed the Inference Time Intervention (ITI) framework, which lets
bias LLM without the need for fine-tuning. The improvement manifests in
introducing a non-linear multi-token probing and multi-token intervention:
Non-Linear ITI (NL-ITI), which significantly enhances performance on evaluation
benchmarks. NL-ITI is tested on diverse multiple-choice datasets, including
TruthfulQA, on which we report over 16% relative MC1 (accuracy of model
pointing to the correct answer) improvement with respect to the baseline ITI
results. Moreover, we achieved a 10% relative improvement over the recently
released Truth Forest (TrFf) method that also focused on ITI improvement.
|
[
-0.21987736225128174,
-0.6169312000274658,
0.6107407808303833,
0.3950967490673065,
-0.14015735685825348,
0.11441943049430847,
-0.028736423701047897,
-0.45190927386283875,
0.20687070488929749,
-0.017003504559397697,
-0.8270419239997864,
-0.45047566294670105,
-0.5802995562553406,
0.010073336772620678,
-0.22391986846923828,
0.9005587100982666,
0.022723795846104622,
0.44537439942359924,
-0.12613189220428467,
-0.5504467487335205,
-0.347839891910553,
-0.36085599660873413,
-0.6839455366134644,
-0.476222962141037,
0.6505448222160339,
0.18574732542037964,
0.44757744669914246,
0.8631539940834045,
0.5706479549407959,
0.1745654195547104,
-0.1642914116382599,
0.24594005942344666,
-0.6903263926506042,
-0.5117934942245483,
-0.27583444118499756,
-0.6443716287612915,
-0.3756341338157654,
0.25320348143577576,
0.7547822594642639,
0.7218774557113647,
-0.04924684762954712,
0.5080710649490356,
0.05606646090745926,
0.8228198289871216,
-0.9459512829780579,
0.1308193951845169,
-0.36577722430229187,
0.3592000901699066,
-0.10380947589874268,
-0.5141445994377136,
-0.5863949060440063,
-0.6209490895271301,
0.11776047199964523,
-0.7138454914093018,
0.15932093560695648,
0.18283681571483612,
0.716188371181488,
0.7205716371536255,
-0.6904942989349365,
-0.10650360584259033,
-0.6910394430160522,
1.3299546241760254,
-1.1022371053695679,
0.42133861780166626,
0.05575181543827057,
0.18180549144744873,
-0.13267379999160767,
-0.5661287307739258,
-0.5237768888473511,
-0.10108137130737305,
0.10593019425868988,
0.2900671660900116,
-0.13464713096618652,
0.2708965539932251,
0.46884942054748535,
0.24528822302818298,
-0.2673262655735016,
0.019427252933382988,
-0.03245982900261879,
-0.2603187561035156,
0.6375023722648621,
0.34115496277809143,
-0.3830691874027252,
-0.008189927786588669,
-0.36669304966926575,
0.06351852416992188,
-0.5852460265159607,
0.06512702256441116,
0.44821399450302124,
0.028084643185138702,
0.11657563596963882,
0.765342116355896,
-0.10367395728826523,
0.7451084852218628,
0.346539705991745,
-0.5628361701965332,
0.36557695269584656,
-0.7853440046310425,
-0.31111395359039307,
0.0964943915605545,
0.32973426580429077,
0.8066756725311279,
-0.017904307693243027,
-0.17927756905555725,
-0.15441055595874786,
0.3320358097553253,
0.2143757939338684,
-0.7896014451980591,
0.23496566712856293,
0.5885268449783325,
-0.6905227303504944,
-0.41556674242019653,
-0.0006229570135474205,
-0.6759358644485474,
-0.37050625681877136,
-0.4804817736148834,
0.3635949492454529,
-0.42372995615005493,
-0.34407249093055725,
-0.03210717439651489,
-0.19597001373767853,
0.6135573983192444,
0.22984157502651215,
-0.3650791049003601,
0.13981805741786957,
0.6198098063468933,
0.9379372000694275,
-0.47222915291786194,
0.21097642183303833,
-0.6748512387275696,
0.21151968836784363,
-0.6579295992851257,
0.7638479471206665,
-0.5234586596488953,
-0.3944777548313141,
-0.22443635761737823,
-0.17660686373710632,
-0.24138838052749634,
-0.542537271976471,
0.6699709296226501,
-0.3979182541370392,
0.3666818141937256,
-0.5401455760002136,
-0.8512872457504272,
-0.2226293385028839,
0.5143150091171265,
-0.6359740495681763,
1.2405861616134644,
0.0035214906092733145,
-1.0046542882919312,
0.4180644452571869,
-1.2959742546081543,
-0.07139971107244492,
-0.540306806564331,
-0.026297062635421753,
-0.5937230587005615,
0.22090840339660645,
0.5826452374458313,
0.06880532950162888,
-0.1187172532081604,
0.5086725354194641,
-0.5536508560180664,
-0.5078611969947815,
0.3151990473270416,
-0.5340604782104492,
0.7046583294868469,
0.0743994414806366,
-0.5142026543617249,
0.4017123878002167,
-0.8763601183891296,
0.3858368992805481,
0.009880518540740013,
-0.1889125555753708,
-0.012451057322323322,
-0.16029661893844604,
0.04486619681119919,
0.027306338772177696,
0.15994063019752502,
-0.8664844036102295,
0.10091478377580643,
-0.43047183752059937,
0.35372576117515564,
1.1204880475997925,
0.36334630846977234,
0.3942265510559082,
-0.6189525723457336,
0.20512273907661438,
0.30240026116371155,
0.5881490707397461,
0.2058582454919815,
-0.528090238571167,
-0.8075925707817078,
-0.3168894052505493,
0.5768441557884216,
0.47017914056777954,
-0.881020188331604,
0.15860219299793243,
-0.24779027700424194,
-0.09717784821987152,
-0.6103092432022095,
0.01884264312684536,
0.5032690763473511,
0.8681671619415283,
0.19250360131263733,
-0.2752188742160797,
-0.49868303537368774,
-0.9711135625839233,
-0.34893375635147095,
-0.3140377700328827,
0.007235031109303236,
0.3118206858634949,
0.6015955209732056,
-0.28182947635650635,
1.0649099349975586,
-0.19261349737644196,
-0.22643886506557465,
0.05305678769946098,
0.4695625305175781,
0.49393466114997864,
0.20618653297424316,
0.6126078963279724,
-0.5916457772254944,
-0.3713393807411194,
-0.4731394648551941,
-0.9094277024269104,
-0.2521109879016876,
-0.16310973465442657,
-0.13202811777591705,
0.17031535506248474,
0.08667813986539841,
-0.1643272191286087,
0.7570214867591858,
0.2756637930870056,
-0.2336519956588745,
0.2875952124595642,
0.05309266224503517,
0.21697570383548737,
-0.8033806681632996,
0.18541575968265533,
0.0747496634721756,
-0.1705905795097351,
-0.7026864886283875,
-0.2024555802345276,
0.2318645417690277,
0.34305134415626526,
-0.4290194809436798,
0.5465823411941528,
-0.3497336804866791,
-0.3484242260456085,
-0.19622725248336792,
0.2803572714328766,
-0.0906420350074768,
0.8150755763053894,
-0.16872142255306244,
1.1980239152908325,
0.16259385645389557,
-0.5729613900184631,
-0.11452164500951767,
0.07725820690393448,
-0.2642612159252167,
0.7492610216140747,
-0.7165857553482056,
0.44074541330337524,
-0.4638757109642029,
0.18743263185024261,
-1.080614686012268,
-0.12159033119678497,
0.22057121992111206,
-0.29916149377822876,
0.12224172800779343,
0.2149389535188675,
-0.4525546133518219,
-0.16356679797172546,
-0.7914459705352783,
0.3255176842212677,
0.04725147783756256,
-0.6955653429031372,
0.9202701449394226,
0.09508828073740005,
0.3510366678237915,
-1.1858220100402832,
-0.6884996891021729,
-0.002738598734140396,
-0.29473626613616943,
-0.5406889915466309,
0.2208799421787262,
-0.5188361406326294,
-0.5102297067642212,
0.029197098687291145,
-0.5081261396408081,
-0.13308341801166534,
0.03524516522884369,
0.06204584240913391,
0.2974812388420105,
-0.2610987722873688,
0.10117890685796738,
-0.01177970226854086,
-0.21668316423892975,
-0.007526354398578405,
-0.3558793067932129,
0.08783126622438431,
-0.01015838049352169,
-0.5801258683204651,
-0.8781123161315918,
0.3647363483905792,
0.40278828144073486,
-0.12150094658136368,
0.608109176158905,
0.6087271571159363,
-0.24323977530002594,
0.16690462827682495,
-0.8071989417076111,
-0.175983726978302,
-0.3970194458961487,
0.018601709976792336,
-0.30083388090133667,
-0.780508816242218,
0.28603091835975647,
-0.3160605728626251,
0.4438146948814392,
0.12134888768196106,
0.3712693452835083,
-0.1397397518157959,
1.107534408569336,
0.7920437455177307,
-0.369209885597229,
0.7164300084114075,
-0.49568939208984375,
0.23948827385902405,
-1.1416349411010742,
-0.20314018428325653,
-0.15157291293144226,
-0.6147622466087341,
-0.2562512159347534,
-0.6725791096687317,
0.6257656216621399,
-0.1399659812450409,
-0.13164108991622925,
-0.21914701163768768,
-0.3964408040046692,
0.27479591965675354,
0.5357635021209717,
0.4139766991138458,
0.4353224039077759,
-0.19858437776565552,
-0.1469455510377884,
-0.34038013219833374,
-0.6275132894515991,
-0.3665238320827484,
1.5642470121383667,
0.46785300970077515,
0.7116807103157043,
0.18058979511260986,
0.4867883324623108,
0.3973812460899353,
0.5714499950408936,
-0.8336213827133179,
0.25175541639328003,
0.3683163523674011,
-0.7055036425590515,
-0.24642382562160492,
-0.4088670313358307,
-0.58614581823349,
0.10404440015554428,
-0.0684940293431282,
-0.7408765554428101,
0.48200076818466187,
0.2208823561668396,
-0.46217450499534607,
0.28401196002960205,
-0.7989535331726074,
0.43335410952568054,
-0.31998923420906067,
-0.6275561451911926,
-0.23419420421123505,
-0.6785606741905212,
0.27754202485084534,
-0.10788721591234207,
0.01899576745927334,
-0.1444559544324875,
-0.38191312551498413,
0.6867312788963318,
-0.20246779918670654,
0.8151492476463318,
-0.4651865065097809,
0.14169733226299286,
0.20040974020957947,
-0.3615993857383728,
0.7028178572654724,
0.1937015801668167,
-0.4206477701663971,
0.5071207284927368,
-0.24280241131782532,
-0.6150962710380554,
-0.9518693089485168,
0.29806792736053467,
-0.7154291272163391,
-0.5327442288398743,
-0.4376085102558136,
-0.871242105960846,
-0.4898734390735626,
-0.005472605116665363,
0.1237887516617775,
0.5215845108032227,
-0.14778272807598114,
0.1946215182542801,
1.1742370128631592,
-0.052510082721710205,
0.6661389470100403,
0.43722665309906006,
-0.13484205305576324,
-0.4224146902561188,
0.43417805433273315,
0.05224282294511795,
0.31586989760398865,
0.4972968101501465,
0.18920926749706268,
-0.7116689682006836,
-0.6674672961235046,
-0.24689659476280212,
0.3839130699634552,
-0.7392133474349976,
-0.11634369939565659,
-0.6939471364021301,
-0.1013660728931427,
-0.3276422321796417,
0.3254588544368744,
-0.36169230937957764,
-0.48677441477775574,
-0.17356295883655548,
-0.301304429769516,
0.28476446866989136,
0.8220888376235962,
-0.19440525770187378,
0.48221927881240845,
-0.24555468559265137,
0.32280194759368896,
0.08131391555070877,
0.22816389799118042,
-0.16375653445720673,
-0.5541967153549194,
-0.06884951889514923,
-0.06027008965611458,
-0.33783215284347534,
-0.6768598556518555,
0.1841745525598526,
0.2701215445995331,
0.7902383804321289,
0.5703970193862915,
0.10304291546344757,
1.112674355506897,
-0.2575089633464813,
0.7568760514259338,
0.17009000480175018,
-0.9491695761680603,
0.3597281575202942,
0.003412560559809208,
0.42977434396743774,
0.34911075234413147,
0.16831250488758087,
-0.20117613673210144,
-0.33280688524246216,
-0.2571212351322174,
-0.6142285466194153,
0.5653676986694336,
0.4265783727169037,
-0.3442005515098572,
0.3765992820262909,
0.4634057283401489,
-0.02665852941572666,
0.547422468662262,
-0.6825815439224243,
-0.5782243609428406,
-0.3282058537006378,
-0.3621178865432739,
0.07931478321552277,
-0.563905656337738,
-0.5353795886039734,
-0.25332537293434143,
0.7302526831626892,
-0.6932189464569092,
0.8456396460533142,
0.5547779202461243,
0.0021590222604572773,
-0.18347716331481934,
0.11784786731004715,
0.6498018503189087,
1.0235602855682373,
-0.1578994244337082,
-0.17997319996356964,
0.41597816348075867,
-0.11955710500478745,
0.061625465750694275,
-0.20904217660427094,
-0.033190708607435226,
0.14033754169940948,
0.632354736328125,
0.881446897983551,
0.07483352720737457,
-0.3979640603065491,
0.6422133445739746,
-0.31612125039100647,
-0.26896461844444275,
-0.4490106999874115,
-0.04223933443427086,
-0.03985297679901123,
0.5518133640289307,
0.4184252619743347,
0.009664957411587238,
0.4067070186138153,
-0.2000865936279297,
0.2537175714969635,
0.5592685341835022,
-0.3705904483795166,
0.09164838492870331,
0.7694673538208008,
-0.09323824197053909,
-0.12458383291959763,
0.5558204054832458,
0.11626377701759338,
-0.24418528378009796,
0.5342486500740051,
0.35928022861480713,
0.5996506810188293,
-0.28857406973838806,
0.27473655343055725,
0.48372042179107666,
0.33412399888038635,
0.16498492658138275,
0.5869146585464478,
-0.17382480204105377,
-0.6455157399177551,
-0.6439594626426697,
-0.1851024180650711,
-0.42200493812561035,
0.24986453354358673,
-0.8489351272583008,
-0.10066182911396027,
-0.7831008434295654,
-0.39370033144950867,
-0.11131418496370316,
0.17957139015197754,
-0.45604339241981506,
0.2002154141664505,
-0.18311060965061188,
1.2062058448791504,
-0.6067111492156982,
0.8177649974822998,
0.3894616365432739,
-0.09876309335231781,
-0.6872258186340332,
0.3137499690055847,
0.25825271010398865,
-0.7937725186347961,
0.6029596924781799,
0.2660152316093445,
-0.3330269455909729,
-0.035567011684179306,
-0.9370841979980469,
-1.1141371726989746,
1.370396375656128,
0.540757954120636,
-0.699750542640686,
0.045649152249097824,
0.22940272092819214,
0.4827595055103302,
-0.4011543393135071,
0.6013196706771851,
0.5807554721832275,
0.673008918762207,
0.1983427107334137,
-0.7472392320632935,
-0.3049197793006897,
-0.3505372703075409,
0.3773065507411957,
0.03616732731461525,
-0.8363645076751709,
0.5182294249534607,
-0.26883259415626526,
-0.2444649487733841,
0.09528853744268417,
0.8086375594139099,
0.2615164518356323,
0.6352092623710632,
0.7402607798576355,
0.5670444369316101,
1.271743893623352,
-0.20458008348941803,
1.1668163537979126,
-0.5881331562995911,
0.2687547504901886,
1.3447034358978271,
-0.2858477532863617,
0.404094934463501,
0.9832204580307007,
0.06867118179798126,
0.3501116931438446,
0.8802147507667542,
0.09475187212228775,
0.7718936800956726,
0.021065281704068184,
-0.44577550888061523,
-0.06328686326742172,
-0.49538499116897583,
-0.08380071818828583,
0.050672225654125214,
0.30360323190689087,
-0.20872509479522705,
-0.2116517871618271,
0.11027591675519943,
-0.029378892853856087,
-0.09902673214673996,
-0.2167700082063675,
0.7461138963699341,
-0.05032103508710861,
-0.44746309518814087,
0.40064284205436707,
-0.015994535759091377,
0.6629371047019958,
-0.5661230087280273,
-0.1800072193145752,
-0.28645384311676025,
0.3607248365879059,
-0.2435840219259262,
-0.5612409114837646,
0.30281850695610046,
-0.0668073520064354,
-0.23272162675857544,
-0.0815005972981453,
0.45268937945365906,
-0.0815252959728241,
-0.39660394191741943,
0.5929055213928223,
0.3892456889152527,
-0.04291021078824997,
0.1436598300933838,
-1.0124292373657227,
0.09295496344566345,
0.1921403706073761,
-0.4251188635826111,
-0.053441282361745834,
0.2863638997077942,
-0.19488444924354553,
0.8881025910377502,
0.6411076784133911,
-0.10110516101121902,
0.38084009289741516,
0.21909156441688538,
0.8201745748519897,
-0.6624671816825867,
-0.24170692265033722,
-0.745291531085968,
0.5633767247200012,
-0.48885685205459595,
-0.2905191481113434,
0.7261918783187866,
0.5776877999305725,
0.7345812320709229,
0.1496782898902893,
0.7372093796730042,
0.11298568546772003,
0.5627541542053223,
-0.5801670551300049,
0.07558203488588333,
-0.560581624507904,
0.20449954271316528,
-0.09595003724098206,
-0.7181780934333801,
-0.17703106999397278,
0.5293002724647522,
-0.26829564571380615,
-0.01005466841161251,
1.032401204109192,
0.975121259689331,
0.15466254949569702,
0.21891573071479797,
0.36535733938217163,
0.3099345266819,
0.3033747673034668,
0.6724762916564941,
0.7733759880065918,
-0.45576193928718567,
0.26615265011787415,
-0.4061511754989624,
-0.44668275117874146,
0.10622283071279526,
-1.0983752012252808,
-1.0969809293746948,
-0.07402203232049942,
-0.31251755356788635,
-0.362529456615448,
0.14085987210273743,
0.8631747364997864,
0.7743905782699585,
-1.0063711404800415,
-0.1777373105287552,
0.027935100719332695,
0.1538379192352295,
-0.5260385274887085,
-0.2397470325231552,
0.23441815376281738,
-0.36419084668159485,
-0.8711274862289429,
0.4638701379299164,
0.4022696912288666,
-0.3228221833705902,
-0.24927841126918793,
-0.04865580424666405,
-0.3167779743671417,
0.32036805152893066,
0.4843584895133972,
-0.1970900297164917,
-0.6304559707641602,
-0.5251215100288391,
0.2536950409412384,
0.07452323287725449,
0.583963930606842,
0.9772433042526245,
-0.5085073709487915,
0.529532790184021,
0.054930850863456726,
1.0001100301742554,
0.7073895335197449,
0.13532274961471558,
0.5065997242927551,
-0.9215465188026428,
0.1954786479473114,
0.12434347718954086,
0.28642886877059937,
0.3150041401386261,
-0.7524600625038147,
0.9963734149932861,
0.4589104652404785,
-0.37941649556159973,
-0.7631840705871582,
0.2410043179988861,
-0.8630793690681458,
-0.07643771916627884,
1.04979407787323,
-0.30267566442489624,
-0.6159536242485046,
-0.3271164298057556,
-0.15398962795734406,
0.36945512890815735,
-0.5391676425933838,
0.8071300983428955,
0.7908449172973633,
-0.5668708682060242,
-0.16188791394233704,
-0.724711537361145,
0.17502935230731964,
0.4901984930038452,
-0.7985256910324097,
-0.35132697224617004,
0.30490586161613464,
0.42973262071609497,
0.3270263671875,
0.7959097027778625,
-0.37569066882133484,
0.02951148711144924,
-0.20777440071105957,
-0.12169883400201797,
0.001366790966130793,
-0.39204150438308716,
-0.45076754689216614,
0.06707587838172913,
-0.09641063213348389,
-0.4066711664199829
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18671v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18671v1
|
Fact Checking Beyond Training Set
| 2024-03-27T15:15:14 | 2024-03-27T15:15:14 |
Payam Karisani, Heng Ji
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Evaluating the veracity of everyday claims is time consuming and in some
cases requires domain expertise. We empirically demonstrate that the commonly
used fact checking pipeline, known as the retriever-reader, suffers from
performance deterioration when it is trained on the labeled data from one
domain and used in another domain. Afterwards, we delve into each component of
the pipeline and propose novel algorithms to address this problem. We propose
an adversarial algorithm to make the retriever component robust against
distribution shift. Our core idea is to initially train a bi-encoder on the
labeled source data, and then, to adversarially train two separate document and
claim encoders using unlabeled target data. We then focus on the reader
component and propose to train it such that it is insensitive towards the order
of claims and evidence documents. Our empirical evaluations support the
hypothesis that such a reader shows a higher robustness against distribution
shift. To our knowledge, there is no publicly available multi-topic fact
checking dataset. Thus, we propose a simple automatic method to re-purpose two
well-known fact checking datasets. We then construct eight fact checking
scenarios from these datasets, and compare our model to a set of strong
baseline models, including recent domain adaptation models that use GPT4 for
generating synthetic data.
|
[
-0.23904192447662354,
-0.5098667144775391,
0.5449355244636536,
-0.22092412412166595,
-0.18837881088256836,
0.17189674079418182,
0.12600408494472504,
-0.35562700033187866,
-0.21867772936820984,
0.6039443612098694,
-0.4327593147754669,
-0.39376264810562134,
-1.0530019998550415,
0.05848412215709686,
-0.5246068835258484,
1.2447398900985718,
0.027348503470420837,
-0.23389768600463867,
-0.1184053122997284,
-0.3465478718280792,
-0.1137571930885315,
-0.45251011848449707,
-0.35550081729888916,
-0.48516377806663513,
0.2908215820789337,
0.10053016245365143,
0.8635315895080566,
0.6671557426452637,
0.4388868808746338,
0.31100279092788696,
0.004599140956997871,
0.5420026779174805,
-0.4603886902332306,
-0.09084288030862808,
-0.3862931728363037,
-0.7747910618782043,
-0.10001439601182938,
0.017927344888448715,
0.513218343257904,
0.17741885781288147,
-0.11470518261194229,
0.09366969019174576,
-0.16831184923648834,
0.6581553816795349,
-0.954685389995575,
0.1930139660835266,
-0.8425387144088745,
0.05889294296503067,
-0.33522090315818787,
-0.3220899701118469,
-0.7011699676513672,
-0.565153181552887,
0.10409833490848541,
-0.447284072637558,
1.0133126974105835,
0.10226061940193176,
1.0852980613708496,
0.36160290241241455,
-0.7817345261573792,
-0.48791342973709106,
-0.66237872838974,
0.5734697580337524,
-0.24822108447551727,
0.5901288986206055,
0.4262157082557678,
0.12355916202068329,
0.032590482383966446,
-0.5800777673721313,
-0.7266111373901367,
0.07220788300037384,
-0.21818295121192932,
0.14384974539279938,
-0.1954224705696106,
-0.2736484110355377,
0.29587364196777344,
0.17694543302059174,
-0.6679835319519043,
-0.33913061022758484,
-0.2793652415275574,
-0.3138355612754822,
0.523108720779419,
-0.08831510692834854,
0.15727144479751587,
0.05790078267455101,
-0.3982887268066406,
-0.34467852115631104,
-0.9567895531654358,
-0.20231488347053528,
0.4928470551967621,
0.0013669199543073773,
0.22016461193561554,
0.4953392446041107,
0.019144704565405846,
0.6047869324684143,
0.2098693996667862,
-0.016903290525078773,
0.20291955769062042,
-0.35639694333076477,
-0.17171837389469147,
0.2093813270330429,
0.3787783980369568,
0.24482528865337372,
-0.19307513535022736,
-0.3731783926486969,
-0.07906828820705414,
0.1601463109254837,
0.4985320270061493,
-0.7401922345161438,
-0.5452883243560791,
0.2559176981449127,
-0.3298134505748749,
-0.23257920145988464,
0.09822418540716171,
-0.8363746404647827,
-0.9884365797042847,
-0.1832379847764969,
0.28823065757751465,
-0.47724148631095886,
-0.13426542282104492,
0.21499821543693542,
-0.2765195965766907,
0.20139959454536438,
0.3692694306373596,
-0.8287429809570312,
-0.0653657615184784,
0.7582166790962219,
0.8302939534187317,
-0.004771602805703878,
-0.18793357908725739,
-0.804822564125061,
0.1529596596956253,
-0.41375434398651123,
1.1781939268112183,
-0.22875484824180603,
0.07691163569688797,
0.1847972869873047,
0.16108094155788422,
-0.17131294310092926,
-0.3716769814491272,
0.8484435081481934,
-1.1117706298828125,
0.12576830387115479,
-0.40072497725486755,
-0.5599227547645569,
-0.1108010783791542,
0.7213690876960754,
-0.9000445008277893,
0.7588580846786499,
-0.0788082554936409,
-1.110323429107666,
0.6696928143501282,
-0.4749775826931,
-0.46513378620147705,
-0.30070948600769043,
0.07380541414022446,
-0.7649473547935486,
-0.0988384485244751,
0.47518491744995117,
0.022904546931385994,
-0.08072993904352188,
0.19111090898513794,
-0.2564612925052643,
-0.061971452087163925,
0.4629589915275574,
-0.6025617122650146,
0.972028374671936,
0.2196698784828186,
-0.44039154052734375,
-0.25987333059310913,
-0.7431526780128479,
-0.19552232325077057,
-0.08350231498479843,
-0.44438251852989197,
-0.3651454448699951,
0.320403516292572,
-0.3227517306804657,
-0.03296612575650215,
-0.019580001011490822,
-0.734366774559021,
0.17898638546466827,
-0.2209629863500595,
0.13862666487693787,
0.5816524624824524,
0.06324905902147293,
0.2898251414299011,
-0.33823949098587036,
0.1192622259259224,
0.3043830990791321,
0.08579110354185104,
-0.03617408499121666,
-0.02602379210293293,
-0.9066768884658813,
-0.20962221920490265,
0.6336205005645752,
0.7127878665924072,
-1.0972803831100464,
0.5186497569084167,
-0.3046319782733917,
-0.26212987303733826,
-0.6051665544509888,
-0.006904770620167255,
0.14384667575359344,
0.531378984451294,
0.47099271416664124,
-0.10738596320152283,
-0.25187888741493225,
-0.5293454527854919,
-0.5123797655105591,
-0.3067319393157959,
-0.005728594027459621,
-0.32657909393310547,
0.3724048435688019,
-0.154905304312706,
0.9323551058769226,
-0.7880819439888,
-0.07540101557970047,
0.02039806917309761,
0.30374687910079956,
0.05692724511027336,
0.13539735972881317,
0.4220488369464874,
-1.0368502140045166,
-0.1438065618276596,
-0.12138061225414276,
-0.9031534790992737,
0.17112727463245392,
-0.3603510558605194,
-0.2126167267560959,
0.19458284974098206,
0.3197213411331177,
-0.8016074895858765,
0.42271846532821655,
0.24622590839862823,
-0.5160722136497498,
0.3690505623817444,
-0.16424518823623657,
0.2530878782272339,
-0.7061277031898499,
-0.06359566003084183,
0.08129944652318954,
-0.312959760427475,
-0.5586187839508057,
0.19291569292545319,
0.38771042227745056,
0.05100778862833977,
-0.405254065990448,
0.21593256294727325,
-0.5506426692008972,
0.07391834259033203,
-0.31954246759414673,
-0.12989264726638794,
0.22141484916210175,
0.10628516227006912,
0.15850430727005005,
0.6682016253471375,
0.4195616543292999,
-0.6462918519973755,
0.5473508834838867,
0.5789175033569336,
-0.4876135587692261,
0.7656314969062805,
-0.3469991981983185,
0.16846682131290436,
-0.21035294234752655,
0.38426196575164795,
-0.8332651853561401,
0.13368651270866394,
0.36096692085266113,
-0.2719782888889313,
0.4666738212108612,
-0.39882200956344604,
-0.5687112808227539,
-0.1922416090965271,
-0.21390198171138763,
-0.2642100751399994,
0.1939576417207718,
-1.120432734489441,
0.5564101934432983,
0.22892658412456512,
-0.1453571915626526,
-0.8586603999137878,
-0.6651557087898254,
0.16295412182807922,
-0.19549869000911713,
-0.5405597686767578,
0.06092187762260437,
-0.00588558055460453,
-0.22356855869293213,
0.09139613807201385,
-0.35390734672546387,
-0.36990591883659363,
-0.03569015488028526,
-0.07831436395645142,
0.19034048914909363,
-0.06485198438167572,
0.245529443025589,
-0.11046662926673889,
-0.13692086935043335,
0.1674404889345169,
-0.3261175751686096,
-0.14414244890213013,
0.02317727357149124,
-0.6457810401916504,
0.024067072197794914,
0.1440930962562561,
0.4366638958454132,
-0.1922401487827301,
0.9627837538719177,
0.701574981212616,
-0.1225837841629982,
-0.31372886896133423,
-0.6010918021202087,
-0.12141246348619461,
-0.46988382935523987,
0.2841609716415405,
-0.3976292908191681,
-0.4322517514228821,
0.30287954211235046,
-0.2353825718164444,
0.3546299636363983,
0.39572983980178833,
0.5041858553886414,
0.014572222717106342,
0.6974563598632812,
0.5695186853408813,
-0.012537769041955471,
0.41451016068458557,
-0.3344065248966217,
0.4283565878868103,
-0.3771647810935974,
-0.11104965955018997,
-0.5817278623580933,
-0.02721874974668026,
-0.3773138225078583,
-0.3658004403114319,
0.33164113759994507,
-0.2262982279062271,
-0.03893851861357689,
0.19413813948631287,
-0.46209755539894104,
0.6817594170570374,
0.4286477267742157,
0.26450151205062866,
0.5653322339057922,
0.1651289463043213,
0.26937374472618103,
0.052153367549180984,
-0.6287161707878113,
-0.38462644815444946,
1.2334164381027222,
0.22795505821704865,
0.7284278869628906,
0.23011142015457153,
0.3600657284259796,
0.7401386499404907,
0.5775261521339417,
-0.5917354822158813,
0.21545346081256866,
-0.16429388523101807,
-0.8229159712791443,
-0.2881380617618561,
-0.4267551302909851,
-0.8610680103302002,
0.5559400320053101,
-0.19767557084560394,
-0.1387035846710205,
0.6749327778816223,
0.0452343225479126,
-0.09499083459377289,
0.5396013259887695,
-0.7023684978485107,
0.5842725038528442,
-0.16968245804309845,
-0.314914345741272,
-0.15022103488445282,
-0.7146912813186646,
0.39055508375167847,
-0.08707291632890701,
0.1150227040052414,
0.1296837329864502,
0.2523159384727478,
0.2849077880382538,
-0.37070199847221375,
0.7710536122322083,
-0.24784351885318756,
-0.20934085547924042,
0.40868139266967773,
0.16344621777534485,
0.7994855642318726,
0.19424261152744293,
-0.29478055238723755,
0.1109834760427475,
0.0044234152883291245,
-0.49657222628593445,
-0.7564125061035156,
0.2187907099723816,
-0.9550983905792236,
-0.5218690037727356,
-0.8682830333709717,
-0.4033239185810089,
-0.25528910756111145,
0.16434237360954285,
0.4654026925563812,
0.5543515086174011,
-0.4258958399295807,
0.2282199263572693,
1.1662310361862183,
0.23314455151557922,
0.15237057209014893,
0.8536196947097778,
0.6156913042068481,
-0.2393474578857422,
1.0404789447784424,
0.10928183794021606,
0.06171052157878876,
0.6831108927726746,
0.0037541287019848824,
-0.7882512807846069,
-0.7566562294960022,
-0.7052194476127625,
0.016350463032722473,
-0.9398598670959473,
-0.327804833650589,
-0.7188358306884766,
-0.1501532644033432,
-0.4446546137332916,
0.03540122136473656,
-0.41771265864372253,
-0.27322933077812195,
-0.1948864609003067,
-0.14268724620342255,
0.23858240246772766,
0.5774831771850586,
-0.06770311295986176,
0.17219235002994537,
-0.7501481771469116,
0.7247615456581116,
0.4529531002044678,
0.247312530875206,
-0.5907901525497437,
-0.5075527429580688,
-0.2895536422729492,
0.17884093523025513,
-0.5968729853630066,
-0.7075382471084595,
0.2728850841522217,
0.12476738542318344,
0.3922206163406372,
0.4262464642524719,
0.5391058921813965,
0.16230598092079163,
-0.43763303756713867,
0.5341261029243469,
-0.010636080987751484,
-0.7642913460731506,
0.3852958083152771,
0.08873409032821655,
-0.10215679556131363,
0.4890413284301758,
0.5171817541122437,
-0.3461219072341919,
-0.2988847494125366,
-0.6637884378433228,
-0.39406049251556396,
0.6535966396331787,
0.18368631601333618,
-0.22670960426330566,
0.14106245338916779,
0.15058615803718567,
0.26403728127479553,
0.15991325676441193,
-0.47850310802459717,
-0.2289256453514099,
-0.6525285243988037,
-0.09646235406398773,
-0.15195782482624054,
-0.08438296616077423,
-0.6488677263259888,
0.15095537900924683,
0.7064282894134521,
-0.4154781699180603,
0.22443708777427673,
0.30382201075553894,
-0.39913275837898254,
0.03136606886982918,
0.5800971984863281,
0.19094407558441162,
0.7996090650558472,
-0.23855315148830414,
0.51949542760849,
-0.015184986405074596,
-0.6689178943634033,
0.4883500635623932,
0.4725346863269806,
-0.443127304315567,
0.20240941643714905,
0.3908137381076813,
0.693518877029419,
-0.11856220662593842,
-0.21041449904441833,
0.4939271807670593,
-0.16851139068603516,
-0.32767459750175476,
0.03922947868704796,
0.10108021646738052,
-0.1499921679496765,
0.3199022710323334,
0.22596724331378937,
0.4338532090187073,
0.2687564492225647,
-0.5858010649681091,
0.34128522872924805,
0.16154278814792633,
0.024951878935098648,
-0.29797545075416565,
0.45552149415016174,
0.2274547964334488,
0.15893159806728363,
0.6879025101661682,
-0.3894615173339844,
-0.5664219856262207,
0.5014411211013794,
0.39490818977355957,
0.6774293184280396,
-0.022335540503263474,
0.48229721188545227,
-0.04364771023392677,
0.6119874715805054,
-0.42490044236183167,
-0.09413622319698334,
0.03442918509244919,
-1.110875129699707,
-0.2525622546672821,
-0.169310063123703,
-0.6338788866996765,
0.06377612799406052,
-0.5088101625442505,
0.05752433463931084,
-0.2547949552536011,
-0.13892878592014313,
0.11441406607627869,
0.22748662531375885,
-0.7520443201065063,
0.3418712317943573,
-0.16658560931682587,
0.7197632789611816,
-1.042635440826416,
0.6762613654136658,
0.5424578189849854,
-0.14280720055103302,
-0.08610960096120834,
0.33792930841445923,
0.2527892589569092,
-0.6246539950370789,
0.5240656733512878,
-0.24194200336933136,
-0.14484959840774536,
-0.18240992724895477,
-0.5354032516479492,
-0.7034246921539307,
0.8933327794075012,
0.6652436256408691,
-0.4218056797981262,
0.13700735569000244,
-0.032726842910051346,
0.5273247361183167,
0.13082678616046906,
0.22587227821350098,
0.7283997535705566,
0.37141478061676025,
0.2472458779811859,
-0.30343344807624817,
0.06147227808833122,
-0.03226475417613983,
-0.44453972578048706,
0.20617859065532684,
-0.8489222526550293,
0.697852611541748,
-0.14684709906578064,
-0.2957725524902344,
-0.41725078225135803,
0.7524093985557556,
0.2686489522457123,
0.47925058007240295,
0.6006772518157959,
0.6171091794967651,
1.0908901691436768,
-0.04738875478506088,
1.1589707136154175,
-0.042433205991983414,
0.5398950576782227,
1.0526936054229736,
-0.5585427284240723,
0.40872475504875183,
0.1472601294517517,
-0.2726404666900635,
0.47747835516929626,
0.5732088088989258,
-0.29883408546447754,
0.8135176301002502,
-0.1137208640575409,
-0.4065469801425934,
-0.3121221959590912,
0.015940651297569275,
-0.39721229672431946,
0.198047935962677,
0.41890987753868103,
-0.1710958033800125,
-0.3611488342285156,
-0.21835412085056305,
-0.03835649415850639,
-0.12033108621835709,
0.03863779455423355,
0.5442548394203186,
-0.22273822128772736,
-0.6524854898452759,
0.5594333410263062,
0.01804850995540619,
0.42217209935188293,
-0.5278396606445312,
0.06174908205866814,
-0.14199431240558624,
0.5015929937362671,
-0.17017348110675812,
-0.958368718624115,
0.47590112686157227,
0.065510593354702,
-0.3990156054496765,
-0.22253122925758362,
1.0664019584655762,
-0.3826551139354706,
-0.3424222767353058,
-0.13108481466770172,
0.5159013867378235,
-0.1428336799144745,
-0.10115349292755127,
-0.7487680315971375,
0.08768277615308762,
-0.012705687433481216,
-0.38828641176223755,
0.3172496557235718,
0.7834190130233765,
0.053238313645124435,
0.6651641726493835,
0.6810247898101807,
0.17846634984016418,
0.0756133571267128,
0.047068655490875244,
0.7337020039558411,
-0.37899842858314514,
-0.7421692609786987,
-0.5972256660461426,
0.19539861381053925,
-0.16580678522586823,
-0.04514048248529434,
0.6848780512809753,
0.4886711537837982,
0.6278397440910339,
-0.05660206452012062,
1.0853610038757324,
-0.02049669623374939,
0.5372112393379211,
-0.6590890288352966,
0.7971059083938599,
-0.056623753160238266,
0.02654705010354519,
0.16629835963249207,
-0.6727588176727295,
-0.24595025181770325,
0.3917299211025238,
-0.4123693108558655,
-0.3482626974582672,
0.8749070167541504,
0.6898653507232666,
-0.3624178469181061,
0.2859874367713928,
0.1484372317790985,
0.15319736301898956,
0.5810632705688477,
0.3703902065753937,
0.8090419173240662,
-0.6181608438491821,
0.8082811236381531,
0.04139997437596321,
-0.038123637437820435,
-0.19036176800727844,
-0.9857646822929382,
-1.0408083200454712,
-0.27038058638572693,
-0.7579289674758911,
-0.713786244392395,
0.30762964487075806,
0.24810437858104706,
0.9102421402931213,
-0.9164460897445679,
0.35376662015914917,
-0.06536416709423065,
0.5752608776092529,
-0.2751884460449219,
-0.19244571030139923,
0.6158655881881714,
-0.20388171076774597,
-0.44237592816352844,
0.4022097885608673,
-0.13129088282585144,
-0.12663820385932922,
-0.030873598530888557,
0.1469787210226059,
-0.20889820158481598,
0.08523505181074142,
0.47250092029571533,
0.39472976326942444,
-0.22978715598583221,
-0.29979532957077026,
-0.32188454270362854,
-0.09014720469713211,
0.11843831092119217,
1.122092843055725,
-0.5590412616729736,
0.6045131087303162,
0.6588824987411499,
1.071030616760254,
0.685280442237854,
0.2148696333169937,
0.2875858247280121,
-0.8494587540626526,
-0.10099483281373978,
-0.11004458367824554,
0.26807549595832825,
0.5391064286231995,
-0.6818890571594238,
0.6176619529724121,
0.5755792856216431,
-0.6250625848770142,
-0.7050287127494812,
0.21873031556606293,
-0.4231880009174347,
-0.3175908029079437,
0.8093975186347961,
-0.2742765545845032,
-0.2219856083393097,
-0.5345811247825623,
0.05759299919009209,
0.366022527217865,
-0.27325329184532166,
1.1387616395950317,
0.9433713555335999,
-0.08722127974033356,
-0.1065293699502945,
-0.47410348057746887,
0.5369380116462708,
0.0823257640004158,
-0.908850908279419,
0.3648727834224701,
0.5206119418144226,
0.6397366523742676,
0.22689206898212433,
0.5102612972259521,
-0.07232369482517242,
0.19423867762088776,
0.3698912262916565,
-0.03586181625723839,
0.008665273897349834,
-0.42262426018714905,
-0.3559715151786804,
0.3282240033149719,
-0.28244251012802124,
-0.34139320254325867
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18667v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18667v1
|
Improving Content Recommendation: Knowledge Graph-Based Semantic Contrastive Learning for Diversity and Cold-Start Users
| 2024-03-27T15:11:00 | 2024-03-27T15:11:00 |
Yejin Kim, Scott Rome, Kevin Foley, Mayur Nankani, Rimon Melamed, Javier Morales, Abhay Yadav, Maria Peifer, Sardar Hamidian, H. Howie Huang
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Addressing the challenges related to data sparsity, cold-start problems, and
diversity in recommendation systems is both crucial and demanding. Many current
solutions leverage knowledge graphs to tackle these issues by combining both
item-based and user-item collaborative signals. A common trend in these
approaches focuses on improving ranking performance at the cost of escalating
model complexity, reducing diversity, and complicating the task. It is
essential to provide recommendations that are both personalized and diverse,
rather than solely relying on achieving high rank-based performance, such as
Click-through Rate, Recall, etc. In this paper, we propose a hybrid multi-task
learning approach, training on user-item and item-item interactions. We apply
item-based contrastive learning on descriptive text, sampling positive and
negative pairs based on item metadata. Our approach allows the model to better
understand the relationships between entities within the knowledge graph by
utilizing semantic information from text. It leads to more accurate, relevant,
and diverse user recommendations and a benefit that extends even to cold-start
users who have few interactions with items. We perform extensive experiments on
two widely used datasets to validate the effectiveness of our approach. Our
findings demonstrate that jointly training user-item interactions and
item-based signals using synopsis text is highly effective. Furthermore, our
results provide evidence that item-based contrastive learning enhances the
quality of entity embeddings, as indicated by metrics such as uniformity and
alignment.
|
[
-0.42708656191825867,
-0.4193470776081085,
0.30192163586616516,
-0.16911347210407257,
-0.5407268404960632,
0.23650424182415009,
-0.13887418806552887,
-0.43793973326683044,
0.3275299072265625,
0.42061182856559753,
-0.5685465931892395,
-0.8458261489868164,
-0.7299293875694275,
-0.061147887259721756,
-0.1986650675535202,
1.4755682945251465,
0.12045809626579285,
-0.17015062272548676,
-0.3711976408958435,
-0.40136009454727173,
-0.76185142993927,
-0.1312190592288971,
-0.7071918249130249,
-0.4138822555541992,
0.8851702809333801,
0.5390340685844421,
0.6851304769515991,
0.4475501477718353,
0.23013684153556824,
0.33479371666908264,
0.18811628222465515,
0.6135954856872559,
-0.7396710515022278,
0.4310813546180725,
-0.452272891998291,
-0.043902959674596786,
-0.17295704782009125,
-0.16235803067684174,
0.11713411659002304,
0.8219914436340332,
-0.10774020850658417,
-0.2292144000530243,
0.45408299565315247,
0.5721495151519775,
-0.5927404165267944,
0.17586034536361694,
-0.4287068843841553,
-0.09216564148664474,
-0.15387111902236938,
-0.11697275191545486,
-0.18309056758880615,
0.16575299203395844,
0.5647491812705994,
-1.136091709136963,
0.234855055809021,
0.4502755403518677,
0.7335940599441528,
-0.13038183748722076,
-0.8915185928344727,
-0.4077994227409363,
-0.7149083018302917,
1.0586999654769897,
-0.25696805119514465,
0.6322252154350281,
0.374300479888916,
0.0060085332952439785,
0.041029490530490875,
-0.6872842311859131,
-0.37650397419929504,
-0.015720687806606293,
-0.18051621317863464,
0.32616671919822693,
-0.09591729938983917,
-0.024020981043577194,
-0.03643123805522919,
0.3877835273742676,
-0.4577915072441101,
0.16282132267951965,
-0.3594375550746918,
-0.2673945128917694,
0.32588425278663635,
0.3011651039123535,
0.40271565318107605,
0.07302166521549225,
-0.5439108610153198,
-0.31643515825271606,
-0.17544816434383392,
-0.01950417459011078,
0.454481303691864,
0.501001238822937,
-0.15397599339485168,
0.5538266897201538,
-0.4669967293739319,
0.6741114258766174,
0.03570892661809921,
-0.24210982024669647,
0.49073633551597595,
-0.8689806461334229,
-0.020471030846238136,
-0.27515193819999695,
0.5523338913917542,
0.8951330780982971,
-0.102930448949337,
-0.4895615875720978,
-0.06051313504576683,
0.09196087718009949,
0.17412753403186798,
-0.6964333057403564,
-0.4822823405265808,
-0.04966795817017555,
-0.5656337141990662,
-0.17959493398666382,
0.1433459222316742,
-0.6274487972259521,
-0.6893081665039062,
-0.44548720121383667,
0.3180261552333832,
-0.7736001014709473,
-0.13749156892299652,
-0.014722475782036781,
-0.41696760058403015,
-0.4531266391277313,
0.5309231877326965,
-0.8157751560211182,
0.7782143950462341,
0.28774598240852356,
0.5944547653198242,
-0.4209422469139099,
-0.4353434443473816,
-0.5372984409332275,
0.33867311477661133,
0.12780988216400146,
1.0936665534973145,
-0.48886820673942566,
-0.3985541760921478,
-0.11413157731294632,
-0.14725299179553986,
0.02408072166144848,
-0.5598625540733337,
0.35454580187797546,
-0.5035095810890198,
0.43080559372901917,
-0.6076394319534302,
-0.5631438493728638,
-0.32525569200515747,
0.3581103980541229,
-0.6995030641555786,
1.0041829347610474,
0.4143613278865814,
-0.9576147198677063,
0.9110917448997498,
-0.5647068619728088,
-0.7140507698059082,
0.026272853836417198,
0.1923159956932068,
-0.2961043119430542,
-0.3823704123497009,
0.28584781289100647,
0.34641072154045105,
-0.2968023121356964,
-0.004331811796873808,
-0.3512323200702667,
-0.32540908455848694,
-0.24222201108932495,
0.27930426597595215,
0.2854548692703247,
0.33299320936203003,
-0.09518168121576309,
0.4605973958969116,
-0.506836473941803,
-0.3797667324542999,
-0.004092911724001169,
-0.2146887183189392,
-0.880268931388855,
-0.057096488773822784,
0.3059353828430176,
0.27764278650283813,
0.15479691326618195,
-0.3983345031738281,
-0.042405273765325546,
-0.4768321216106415,
-0.03368956223130226,
0.5773496031761169,
0.11466286331415176,
0.5526348948478699,
-0.6442623138427734,
0.19563645124435425,
0.4870982766151428,
-0.248409241437912,
-0.25854650139808655,
-0.5553783774375916,
-0.5518206357955933,
-0.057813022285699844,
0.16622264683246613,
0.41925477981567383,
-1.1484099626541138,
0.5087621212005615,
0.21963509917259216,
-0.3446890711784363,
-0.19584567844867706,
0.6766209006309509,
0.28962522745132446,
0.672313928604126,
0.6703179478645325,
-0.7945122122764587,
-0.5180308222770691,
-0.45953473448753357,
-0.19879235327243805,
-0.013159411028027534,
0.02246185578405857,
0.7779489755630493,
0.2702650725841522,
-0.27370738983154297,
0.7636248469352722,
-0.5674442052841187,
-0.6277874708175659,
-0.5091415643692017,
0.13144245743751526,
0.2531068027019501,
0.3236319422721863,
0.2686918079853058,
-0.7652762532234192,
-0.4570685029029846,
-0.12647199630737305,
-0.47067970037460327,
0.17379799485206604,
0.22374416887760162,
-0.24076664447784424,
-0.1767844259738922,
0.09026715904474258,
-0.17243027687072754,
0.051352277398109436,
0.42536404728889465,
-0.7622535824775696,
0.09628266841173172,
-0.329059362411499,
0.2652713358402252,
-1.4571226835250854,
-0.20935367047786713,
0.41643795371055603,
-0.06620055437088013,
-0.5408612489700317,
-0.3221800625324249,
-0.27289053797721863,
-0.12166503071784973,
-0.24868233501911163,
0.570749819278717,
-0.1295222043991089,
0.04393814876675606,
-0.3051187992095947,
0.34467917680740356,
0.16329295933246613,
0.43392321467399597,
-0.021537544205784798,
0.3230668902397156,
0.34629783034324646,
-0.6930225491523743,
0.370198130607605,
0.3752957582473755,
-0.3203253746032715,
0.9363514184951782,
-0.488820344209671,
-0.004487941972911358,
-0.12587179243564606,
0.3537694811820984,
-1.0081387758255005,
0.2200264036655426,
0.3317679166793823,
0.1885119527578354,
0.025763655081391335,
-0.09243284165859222,
-0.5117989182472229,
0.027174444869160652,
-0.447299063205719,
0.5126703977584839,
0.1909189224243164,
-0.4505596160888672,
0.6168577075004578,
0.2927172780036926,
0.02391766756772995,
-0.6741341352462769,
-0.12407862395048141,
-0.13235655426979065,
-0.05710890144109726,
-0.6932472586631775,
0.6877103447914124,
-0.2303999960422516,
-0.08979032933712006,
0.36695459485054016,
-0.027510514482855797,
0.1305234730243683,
0.25375866889953613,
0.28057244420051575,
0.3342897891998291,
0.04753446951508522,
0.5157566666603088,
0.11180365830659866,
-0.27066585421562195,
-0.5333836674690247,
-0.9154670834541321,
0.5477331280708313,
0.05408664420247078,
-0.102861687541008,
-0.1664746254682541,
0.31302523612976074,
0.08490751683712006,
-0.18509124219417572,
0.8195702433586121,
1.0928020477294922,
-0.21026314795017242,
-0.27090439200401306,
-0.4089946746826172,
-0.47943106293678284,
-0.435960978269577,
0.432922899723053,
-0.09379418939352036,
-0.971450686454773,
0.18058276176452637,
-0.2004072517156601,
0.07258528470993042,
0.4442683160305023,
0.4405963718891144,
-0.38296419382095337,
0.6690091490745544,
0.7590203881263733,
-0.09462129324674606,
0.6534860134124756,
-0.4015921950340271,
0.09696552157402039,
-0.7741071581840515,
-0.5021191835403442,
-0.23937435448169708,
-0.546826183795929,
-0.4851095676422119,
-0.21997223794460297,
0.17650289833545685,
-0.004812043160200119,
-0.14216558635234833,
0.30965402722358704,
-0.3204791843891144,
0.3188555836677551,
0.8428811430931091,
0.5484458208084106,
0.41183605790138245,
0.0015761815011501312,
-0.550911545753479,
-0.060573313385248184,
-0.7697588801383972,
0.0859551653265953,
1.1614094972610474,
-0.0346539132297039,
0.7295073866844177,
-0.004414043389260769,
0.8048675656318665,
0.5491418242454529,
0.05150366201996803,
-0.8009271621704102,
0.1669735312461853,
-0.6675729751586914,
-0.14191342890262604,
-0.3686312139034271,
-0.38545936346054077,
-1.0783154964447021,
0.1860816776752472,
-0.7731596827507019,
-0.6420453786849976,
0.1456216275691986,
0.20911043882369995,
-0.20620806515216827,
0.31634315848350525,
-0.6367456316947937,
0.981779932975769,
-0.0330195277929306,
-0.35169652104377747,
-0.4508246183395386,
-0.4093499779701233,
0.10612374544143677,
0.19291260838508606,
0.25005412101745605,
-0.15428362786769867,
-0.04580085352063179,
1.0380629301071167,
-0.26428624987602234,
0.964298665523529,
-0.14511248469352722,
0.18506203591823578,
0.126114159822464,
0.11655537039041519,
0.6302375197410583,
-0.07933793216943741,
0.0796283483505249,
-0.14762447774410248,
-0.31080037355422974,
-0.49032989144325256,
-0.6091598272323608,
0.776346743106842,
-1.0167828798294067,
-0.3363416790962219,
-0.09683359414339066,
-0.8517922163009644,
-0.2755905091762543,
0.38458314538002014,
0.09728475660085678,
0.5963067412376404,
-0.045157235115766525,
0.2250949591398239,
0.7283378839492798,
-0.08740068972110748,
0.017406271770596504,
0.41441264748573303,
0.16392117738723755,
-0.7693206667900085,
1.2983382940292358,
0.05359424278140068,
0.023760227486491203,
0.4570130705833435,
0.20484548807144165,
-0.14596466720104218,
-0.6865437030792236,
-0.13505464792251587,
0.13891981542110443,
-0.7840821743011475,
0.0459040068089962,
-0.9389230608940125,
0.38240471482276917,
-0.3523062765598297,
-0.13937342166900635,
0.058160200715065,
-0.2920994162559509,
-0.3033634424209595,
-0.07225063443183899,
0.2579561769962311,
0.7145469188690186,
0.2793312668800354,
0.13504824042320251,
-0.5350691080093384,
0.352220743894577,
0.47119298577308655,
0.4524165987968445,
0.09233967959880829,
-0.1870798021554947,
-0.5971202254295349,
-0.43805113434791565,
-0.4499569237232208,
-0.7401095032691956,
0.11591190844774246,
0.030151650309562683,
0.7703197598457336,
0.5917868614196777,
0.4139973521232605,
0.17941470444202423,
-0.024469295516610146,
0.7026164531707764,
0.4099293351173401,
-0.6720877885818481,
0.3598270118236542,
-0.2899765074253082,
0.3354592025279999,
0.6305409073829651,
0.6260212659835815,
-0.7053980827331543,
-0.3754582703113556,
-0.616131603717804,
-0.99077969789505,
0.6584028005599976,
0.07236350327730179,
-0.054739709943532944,
0.1668991595506668,
-0.16800472140312195,
0.3771519958972931,
0.33124539256095886,
-0.2468309998512268,
-0.4886925220489502,
-0.4693009555339813,
-0.4345865845680237,
-0.4152471423149109,
-0.2013397514820099,
-0.26651597023010254,
0.026225954294204712,
0.6333458423614502,
-0.34313324093818665,
-0.09743060916662216,
-0.08574257791042328,
-0.08825601637363434,
0.014405922964215279,
0.23869799077510834,
0.3000686764717102,
0.510231077671051,
-0.13994060456752777,
0.14758345484733582,
0.355035662651062,
-0.3044430911540985,
-0.051707617938518524,
0.2709522247314453,
-0.0012231770670041442,
-0.3590867221355438,
0.23031367361545563,
0.7368654608726501,
0.518230676651001,
-0.48290175199508667,
0.4928138852119446,
-0.018243685364723206,
-0.044241905212402344,
0.2252240777015686,
0.07636860758066177,
0.06372623145580292,
0.19523294270038605,
0.026603734120726585,
0.30571192502975464,
0.41288813948631287,
-0.6651641726493835,
0.24635709822177887,
0.2960722744464874,
-0.6444454193115234,
-0.1151842251420021,
0.2543845772743225,
0.6362887024879456,
0.0849088579416275,
0.8313091397285461,
0.031222861260175705,
-0.3796379268169403,
0.33392393589019775,
0.5765553712844849,
0.6653494238853455,
0.10152851790189743,
0.43906936049461365,
0.15438513457775116,
0.09143641591072083,
0.20837253332138062,
0.11707329750061035,
-0.5566451549530029,
-1.1485710144042969,
0.0356856994330883,
-0.37044665217399597,
-0.6056360602378845,
-0.2802894711494446,
-0.5058873295783997,
0.40694817900657654,
-0.3966883420944214,
-0.10556479543447495,
0.062312014400959015,
0.3717152774333954,
-0.9090340733528137,
0.45409324765205383,
-0.05063381791114807,
0.6418271660804749,
-0.8961188197135925,
0.6382220983505249,
0.9154639840126038,
-0.4958900809288025,
-0.5079898834228516,
-0.23910847306251526,
0.0017106891609728336,
-0.5194391012191772,
0.5154502391815186,
-0.07859238237142563,
-0.11002320796251297,
-0.13547855615615845,
0.12849438190460205,
-0.6674798130989075,
1.3653979301452637,
-0.009111683815717697,
-0.27607470750808716,
0.006741452030837536,
-0.3349442780017853,
0.48749861121177673,
-0.5972505807876587,
0.5864551067352295,
0.05041312426328659,
0.32580435276031494,
0.2510741353034973,
-0.6149855256080627,
0.21281994879245758,
-0.30927902460098267,
0.02078239619731903,
0.23230193555355072,
-0.6062331795692444,
0.699150562286377,
-0.37538811564445496,
-0.09583737701177597,
-0.1323525607585907,
0.6639941930770874,
0.30470916628837585,
0.6876175999641418,
0.9365127086639404,
0.6448837518692017,
0.8348970413208008,
0.1126239001750946,
1.1022132635116577,
-0.40626195073127747,
0.00866333581507206,
1.2015149593353271,
-0.38345831632614136,
0.51055508852005,
0.3058137893676758,
0.05513451248407364,
1.056178331375122,
0.6413492560386658,
-0.2712383568286896,
0.7070633172988892,
-0.12039544433355331,
-0.24720355868339539,
-0.3698067367076874,
-0.6871433854103088,
-0.2115829437971115,
-0.09850003570318222,
0.2542508840560913,
-0.5510521531105042,
-0.3476579189300537,
0.08136928826570511,
-0.22545482218265533,
0.12344244122505188,
-0.034684956073760986,
1.170957326889038,
0.048395756632089615,
-0.37688779830932617,
0.03726379945874214,
0.09709376841783524,
0.8488244414329529,
-0.6557416319847107,
-0.14832325279712677,
-0.018120182678103447,
-0.1313205361366272,
-0.3707990348339081,
-0.6168509721755981,
-0.21425558626651764,
-0.4229310154914856,
-0.5302581191062927,
-0.1632262021303177,
0.9702621102333069,
-0.5146136283874512,
-0.10337604582309723,
0.5237708687782288,
0.5844606757164001,
-0.3265478014945984,
0.24988211691379547,
-0.5010502934455872,
-0.31644847989082336,
-0.2741856575012207,
0.22326169908046722,
0.5805420875549316,
0.16610689461231232,
0.022787688300013542,
0.5375357270240784,
0.8322290182113647,
-0.06848418712615967,
-0.422365665435791,
0.221293106675148,
0.9768723845481873,
-0.4858015775680542,
-0.9284368753433228,
-0.39944884181022644,
0.5151382684707642,
-0.2503793239593506,
-0.39201685786247253,
0.6689236760139465,
0.4779336452484131,
1.1972612142562866,
0.1403367519378662,
0.7476396560668945,
0.2044774889945984,
0.3675442039966583,
-0.43196484446525574,
0.319946825504303,
-0.45433327555656433,
0.5097774863243103,
-0.40627726912498474,
-1.0942896604537964,
-0.003543060040101409,
-0.22891204059123993,
-0.23368850350379944,
0.4186331629753113,
0.8487359285354614,
0.4471524655818939,
-0.2096404731273651,
-0.10851803421974182,
0.45643994212150574,
-0.06862986087799072,
-0.03209029883146286,
0.5831741094589233,
0.7270755767822266,
-0.27070948481559753,
0.88555508852005,
-0.5350893139839172,
-0.2004120796918869,
-0.033107005059719086,
-0.5866760611534119,
-1.0622299909591675,
-0.7032186388969421,
-0.449160099029541,
-0.5989786982536316,
0.4087463319301605,
1.1345423460006714,
0.8885208964347839,
-0.8896342515945435,
-0.403378963470459,
0.16388998925685883,
0.42395278811454773,
-0.648428738117218,
-0.19018131494522095,
0.4837491512298584,
-0.27845683693885803,
-0.5213073492050171,
0.4275527596473694,
0.21073146164417267,
-0.04752739518880844,
-0.05069863051176071,
-0.293144553899765,
0.0072145103476941586,
-0.27093032002449036,
0.5332766175270081,
-0.0401030108332634,
-0.464685320854187,
0.1447165608406067,
-0.19896727800369263,
0.007612933870404959,
-0.22330407798290253,
1.0648300647735596,
-1.0385968685150146,
0.6210035085678101,
0.5389296412467957,
0.4966599643230438,
0.6763981580734253,
-0.04492915794253349,
0.6390059590339661,
-0.6316018104553223,
-0.2033034861087799,
-0.07951325923204422,
0.3749600946903229,
0.4225417375564575,
-0.43630972504615784,
0.1532682478427887,
0.7581688761711121,
-0.16868025064468384,
-0.22487632930278778,
0.2739240229129791,
-1.056319236755371,
-0.2335905134677887,
0.893525242805481,
-0.30540236830711365,
0.2644880414009094,
-0.5772185921669006,
-0.2814297676086426,
0.23984061181545258,
-0.8791825175285339,
0.805224597454071,
0.4824554920196533,
-0.07493413984775543,
-0.12043970078229904,
0.06786897778511047,
0.37265658378601074,
0.3282622694969177,
-0.6644168496131897,
-0.35858413577079773,
0.22523704171180725,
0.4447569251060486,
0.04698432981967926,
0.26230552792549133,
0.2756083905696869,
0.3067767322063446,
-0.036771874874830246,
-0.15922749042510986,
-0.3796519637107849,
-0.3767395615577698,
0.00124359130859375,
0.45225435495376587,
0.11780591309070587,
0.0076571376994252205
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18647v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18647v2
|
SDSAT: Accelerating LLM Inference through Speculative Decoding with Semantic Adaptive Tokens
| 2024-03-27T14:54:27 | 2024-04-01T09:48:46 |
Chengbo Liu, Yong Zhu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We propose an acceleration scheme for large language models (LLMs) through
Speculative Decoding with Semantic Adaptive Tokens (SDSAT). The primary
objective of this design is to enhance the LLM model's ability to generate
draft tokens more accurately without compromising the model's accuracy. The
core strategies involve: 1) Fine-tune the model by incorporating semantic
adaptive tokens that possess flexible decoding capabilities without changing
its structure, allowing them to generate high-quality draft tokens. 2) By
employing a training method that does not affect the standard tokens, the model
can acquire parallel decoding abilities atop its original framework with
minimal training overhead. 3) We have designed the "two-step-draft-then-verify"
generation strategies using both greedy search and nucleus sampling.
Experiments conducted on the CodeLlama-13B and 7B models have yielded speed
increases of over 3.5X and 3.0X, respectively. Please refer to
https://github.com/hasuoshenyun/SDSAT.
|
[
-0.18096785247325897,
-0.7306142449378967,
0.7132915258407593,
0.537875235080719,
-0.46835798025131226,
0.1812228262424469,
-0.24088704586029053,
-0.46992236375808716,
0.48745283484458923,
0.7225639820098877,
-0.7435840368270874,
-0.5371611714363098,
-0.7801434993743896,
0.2501707375049591,
-0.4724281132221222,
0.5162899494171143,
-0.04255980625748634,
0.19089077413082123,
-0.27683353424072266,
0.1600482314825058,
-0.28158923983573914,
-0.21318283677101135,
-0.5319633483886719,
-0.033653344959020615,
0.175801619887352,
0.4149291515350342,
0.5377716422080994,
0.977558434009552,
0.5119978189468384,
0.3151775002479553,
-0.4071454107761383,
0.41431817412376404,
-0.5460402965545654,
0.29383233189582825,
-0.052232883870601654,
-0.551065981388092,
-0.6842598915100098,
-0.3436829149723053,
0.7254941463470459,
0.6135665774345398,
-0.17912255227565765,
0.18889117240905762,
-0.5123614072799683,
0.7761624455451965,
-0.7863951325416565,
0.19449272751808167,
-0.9329224824905396,
-0.38141104578971863,
-0.2774868607521057,
-0.44317513704299927,
-0.6119272112846375,
-0.1780555695295334,
-0.30152690410614014,
-0.8691824674606323,
0.2908571660518646,
0.17523860931396484,
0.49706247448921204,
0.4653761386871338,
-0.3675207495689392,
-0.4143511652946472,
-0.4232165217399597,
0.5707973837852478,
-0.7621006369590759,
0.3836635947227478,
0.27737903594970703,
0.3016469478607178,
-0.49794647097587585,
-1.0023713111877441,
-0.5097246766090393,
-0.2610349953174591,
0.3556145131587982,
0.3155716061592102,
0.10212971270084381,
0.21653902530670166,
0.5147697329521179,
0.2181781530380249,
-0.4793661832809448,
0.5532220602035522,
-0.4769882261753082,
-0.3900323212146759,
0.7227471470832825,
0.5671948790550232,
-0.0635172426700592,
-0.00014246763021219522,
-0.4664582312107086,
-0.0535188652575016,
-0.7282491326332092,
-0.17462700605392456,
0.5675627589225769,
0.4984802305698395,
-0.21744796633720398,
0.8682175278663635,
-0.7180572152137756,
0.6647080779075623,
-0.1485169678926468,
0.06969048827886581,
0.3163618743419647,
-0.6609607934951782,
-0.013264750130474567,
0.28802216053009033,
0.23995958268642426,
0.41714221239089966,
-0.1466076672077179,
-0.10152161121368408,
-0.4041828215122223,
0.6355792284011841,
0.2749215066432953,
-1.0638858079910278,
0.0755826085805893,
0.45892712473869324,
-0.5696282386779785,
-0.2876035273075104,
0.004678313620388508,
-0.8064982295036316,
-0.4882279932498932,
-0.31737130880355835,
0.1914849579334259,
-0.33911412954330444,
-0.3611317574977875,
0.8922114968299866,
-0.396361380815506,
0.3534160852432251,
0.3415534496307373,
-1.011994481086731,
0.5498143434524536,
0.9637273550033569,
0.5882928967475891,
-0.27976083755493164,
-0.3999275863170624,
-0.7426692247390747,
0.07154575735330582,
-0.5634640455245972,
1.1514664888381958,
-0.6817817091941833,
-0.45576491951942444,
0.08425651490688324,
-0.2465551793575287,
0.14415207505226135,
-0.4110238254070282,
0.8983491063117981,
-0.6882556080818176,
-0.5013049244880676,
-0.5468118190765381,
-0.9539173245429993,
0.21016615629196167,
-0.03545238450169563,
-0.7145942449569702,
1.2372461557388306,
-0.10801835358142853,
-0.6015761494636536,
0.5213574171066284,
-0.9598138928413391,
-0.31818535923957825,
0.12270072847604752,
-0.08293314278125763,
-0.12980866432189941,
0.5618987083435059,
0.5173426866531372,
0.5076450705528259,
-0.4454026520252228,
0.0633239671587944,
-0.4340159595012665,
-0.9301416873931885,
0.18485131859779358,
-0.19966252148151398,
0.5419883728027344,
0.38204705715179443,
-0.1323527991771698,
0.31992778182029724,
-0.9938366413116455,
-0.08515986800193787,
0.2960945963859558,
-0.3954414129257202,
-0.12371690571308136,
0.1920989751815796,
-0.09787075966596603,
-0.1577901989221573,
0.20948107540607452,
-0.6760163307189941,
0.36482736468315125,
-0.5419577956199646,
0.4129592180252075,
0.9581992626190186,
-0.036610230803489685,
0.4206521809101105,
-0.20913253724575043,
0.4330441653728485,
0.24392251670360565,
-0.14202086627483368,
-0.3538700342178345,
-0.36408862471580505,
-0.7887871861457825,
-0.5197049975395203,
0.4438667893409729,
0.16363558173179626,
-0.989399254322052,
0.44480153918266296,
-0.5251832008361816,
-0.3274364173412323,
-0.7453091740608215,
-0.037745002657175064,
0.04360136017203331,
0.07147088646888733,
0.3080282211303711,
-0.04513079673051834,
-0.7999037504196167,
-0.6354506611824036,
-0.3172991871833801,
-0.25350049138069153,
0.1987966001033783,
0.006193341687321663,
0.4984596371650696,
-0.22345037758350372,
0.6879954934120178,
-0.5232148766517639,
0.2057037502527237,
-0.2987557053565979,
0.11431051790714264,
0.13011807203292847,
0.37596723437309265,
0.5032756328582764,
-0.7633477449417114,
-0.13446693122386932,
-0.21435871720314026,
-0.5331496596336365,
-0.25676244497299194,
-0.0654471218585968,
-0.1159588098526001,
0.23896685242652893,
0.8263325095176697,
-0.7765020132064819,
0.3315541446208954,
0.3861314356327057,
-0.6034517884254456,
0.7025524377822876,
-0.22328577935695648,
-0.11620454490184784,
-1.2018316984176636,
-0.276619553565979,
-0.28467419743537903,
-0.09820960462093353,
-0.5655035972595215,
0.4059717059135437,
0.1807076781988144,
0.14211907982826233,
-0.5091263651847839,
0.6166266798973083,
-0.35707521438598633,
-0.33365970849990845,
-0.7037055492401123,
0.2586531341075897,
-0.2133338898420334,
0.05031517893075943,
0.13201187551021576,
1.1901353597640991,
0.7536076307296753,
-0.5379851460456848,
0.34590789675712585,
-0.01071092952042818,
-0.48121878504753113,
0.2051432877779007,
-0.5441229939460754,
0.09919966012239456,
-0.2447330802679062,
0.326110303401947,
-1.0614625215530396,
-0.06482022255659103,
-0.08845823258161545,
-0.44775310158729553,
0.022863566875457764,
0.2562463581562042,
-0.7165313959121704,
-0.44215697050094604,
-0.2533924877643585,
0.3998744487762451,
0.4834353029727936,
-0.7590763568878174,
0.8058528900146484,
0.09754772484302521,
0.07621143013238907,
-0.553492546081543,
-0.5140126943588257,
0.15459652245044708,
-0.029219279065728188,
-0.600495457649231,
0.42061853408813477,
-0.15201635658740997,
-0.16182515025138855,
0.06281702220439911,
-0.18189874291419983,
0.26853322982788086,
0.28476840257644653,
0.15143437683582306,
0.29266664385795593,
-0.4019582271575928,
-0.05604955181479454,
0.3182288706302643,
-0.38742637634277344,
0.17311790585517883,
-0.6130160689353943,
0.5549644231796265,
-0.17173069715499878,
-0.19452451169490814,
-0.42807939648628235,
0.24562649428844452,
0.6132423281669617,
-0.06231268122792244,
0.6995642781257629,
0.6818965077400208,
-0.3021579384803772,
-0.28891682624816895,
-0.6847047209739685,
-0.29471924901008606,
-0.5580509901046753,
0.6366618275642395,
-0.7834440469741821,
-0.9885985255241394,
0.6999068856239319,
-0.3666670322418213,
-0.09359047561883926,
0.40252405405044556,
1.0226428508758545,
0.2654819190502167,
0.8201378583908081,
0.6334481239318848,
0.07536235451698303,
0.26247546076774597,
-0.13771402835845947,
-0.13449354469776154,
-0.82757568359375,
-0.054681722074747086,
-0.7168205976486206,
-0.09258344024419785,
-0.6332675814628601,
-0.7242582440376282,
-0.22820353507995605,
-0.026617445051670074,
-0.089840829372406,
0.26864418387413025,
-0.19439572095870972,
0.5410493016242981,
0.3843841850757599,
0.1257428079843521,
0.22064028680324554,
-0.042585648596286774,
-0.44183579087257385,
0.02619829773902893,
-0.6128509044647217,
-0.17960987985134125,
1.2495579719543457,
0.3432442843914032,
0.891963005065918,
0.09248591959476471,
0.6181097030639648,
0.269184410572052,
0.10243729501962662,
-0.6806193590164185,
0.8076826930046082,
-0.28914254903793335,
-0.44247522950172424,
-0.13961894810199738,
-0.5825405120849609,
-0.5072831511497498,
0.30689898133277893,
-0.2895888388156891,
-0.5833858251571655,
0.11864162981510162,
-0.07044247537851334,
-0.044183216989040375,
0.10330278426408768,
-0.5680460929870605,
0.4710305333137512,
0.03656826540827751,
-0.2088497132062912,
-0.5214241743087769,
-0.5069494247436523,
0.36495381593704224,
-0.11834926903247833,
-0.17066475749015808,
-0.3696909546852112,
-0.4243369698524475,
0.7240243554115295,
-0.19625726342201233,
0.7751880288124084,
-0.5174806118011475,
0.0013679050607606769,
0.16517817974090576,
-0.03965578228235245,
0.8367689847946167,
0.02853144146502018,
-0.5680762529373169,
-0.01370178535580635,
-0.02382514625787735,
-0.840589702129364,
-0.5824328660964966,
0.5290985703468323,
-0.749316394329071,
-0.6348991990089417,
-0.290350079536438,
-0.9384332299232483,
-0.33240124583244324,
0.284819632768631,
-0.11614999175071716,
0.20260800421237946,
-0.04744396358728409,
0.19467517733573914,
0.4047650694847107,
0.010009000077843666,
0.26265090703964233,
0.709661602973938,
-0.1650652289390564,
-0.3569240868091583,
0.8513330221176147,
-0.2092391699552536,
0.3664723336696625,
0.33956378698349,
0.08174174278974533,
-0.6470473408699036,
-1.2290829420089722,
-0.4173502027988434,
0.29784634709358215,
-0.8464439511299133,
-0.24066145718097687,
-0.452929824590683,
-0.13507413864135742,
-0.5237143635749817,
-0.06973927468061447,
-0.6193956136703491,
-0.6368352770805359,
-0.2395249903202057,
-0.3596537709236145,
0.48182111978530884,
0.6079006195068359,
0.1306522935628891,
0.5332099199295044,
-0.5213282704353333,
0.3717760443687439,
-0.24332216382026672,
0.2916470170021057,
-0.2153991311788559,
-0.7292687892913818,
-0.22692275047302246,
-0.05287613347172737,
0.05189533531665802,
-0.2721775472164154,
0.033094748854637146,
-0.0030013639479875565,
0.5757989287376404,
0.3214260935783386,
0.32579201459884644,
1.0324110984802246,
-0.44620010256767273,
0.8145561814308167,
-0.03163154795765877,
-0.9783766865730286,
0.3387490510940552,
-0.26455897092819214,
0.26862844824790955,
0.5038366913795471,
0.1476343721151352,
-0.04804905876517296,
-0.49495378136634827,
-0.3825921416282654,
-0.6205232739448547,
0.7116228342056274,
0.11923350393772125,
0.33232352137565613,
-0.11547379195690155,
0.8051491379737854,
0.12491121143102646,
-0.021478477865457535,
-0.22538158297538757,
-0.017072567716240883,
-0.1008315160870552,
-0.2819088101387024,
0.010462312959134579,
-0.6670135259628296,
0.006524259224534035,
-0.043979573994874954,
0.6152946949005127,
-0.5277592539787292,
0.35714486241340637,
0.04050755128264427,
0.08587958663702011,
-0.08588386327028275,
-0.013496448285877705,
0.9029737114906311,
0.6885693073272705,
-0.2698138952255249,
0.0876522809267044,
0.18972285091876984,
-0.6758104562759399,
0.12195933610200882,
0.1831291913986206,
-0.04875578731298447,
-0.2757938802242279,
0.3303733468055725,
1.1578528881072998,
0.1503933221101761,
-0.7995937466621399,
0.4247165322303772,
-0.42194998264312744,
-0.5738175511360168,
0.0448114387691021,
0.11525329202413559,
0.2749936580657959,
0.42334356904029846,
0.30915191769599915,
0.06273801624774933,
-0.012765211053192616,
-0.06962904334068298,
0.258762001991272,
0.31091105937957764,
0.08669480681419373,
-0.24919022619724274,
0.7437787652015686,
0.12099200487136841,
0.02589908428490162,
0.673620879650116,
-0.23254698514938354,
-0.17701342701911926,
0.6611967086791992,
1.1115354299545288,
0.9108493328094482,
0.06732632219791412,
0.03426789864897728,
0.12600645422935486,
0.36857640743255615,
-0.2366543561220169,
0.6040311455726624,
-0.1308043897151947,
-0.8652852177619934,
-0.6629229784011841,
-1.0068628787994385,
-0.44188636541366577,
-0.2183435559272766,
-0.8383978605270386,
0.33098116517066956,
-0.20617419481277466,
0.0033086093608289957,
0.05736557021737099,
0.17769084870815277,
-0.3792226016521454,
0.008757994510233402,
0.06881862878799438,
1.6346838474273682,
-0.8879089951515198,
1.0858685970306396,
0.5557205677032471,
-0.021538743749260902,
-0.5832482576370239,
0.1303609013557434,
-0.10462386906147003,
-1.0805267095565796,
0.675406277179718,
0.14643068611621857,
-0.12270589917898178,
0.19290433824062347,
-0.3001921772956848,
-0.9742050766944885,
1.2130560874938965,
0.5565477013587952,
-0.4201147258281708,
0.0022557713091373444,
0.20442071557044983,
0.4677981734275818,
-0.5009185671806335,
-0.016612583771348,
0.7116402387619019,
0.327502578496933,
0.415462851524353,
-0.3415779173374176,
0.2542355954647064,
-0.2182321846485138,
0.526589572429657,
0.08648074418306351,
-0.46694546937942505,
0.5781874656677246,
-0.20023594796657562,
-0.14221641421318054,
0.7557974457740784,
1.2446244955062866,
0.5865415930747986,
0.10925248265266418,
0.548463761806488,
0.7328689694404602,
0.7816110849380493,
-0.15107373893260956,
1.1032534837722778,
-0.5289069414138794,
0.1443488448858261,
0.8208345174789429,
-0.7123762369155884,
0.977302074432373,
0.6924646496772766,
-0.0985335111618042,
0.1941142976284027,
0.7760890126228333,
0.10162044316530228,
0.5098736882209778,
0.18591220676898956,
-0.25295084714889526,
-0.42122387886047363,
-0.1666954755783081,
-0.24016118049621582,
0.5304683446884155,
0.66038578748703,
-0.042464423924684525,
-0.16179656982421875,
-0.0581614226102829,
-0.3264194428920746,
0.12036287784576416,
-0.3752322793006897,
0.7023336291313171,
-0.017923584207892418,
-0.5243462920188904,
0.5962525010108948,
0.2970244884490967,
0.44544216990470886,
-0.7217459678649902,
0.11641928553581238,
-0.10847381502389908,
0.2539876401424408,
0.03605863079428673,
-0.5336979627609253,
0.24829626083374023,
-0.07067355513572693,
-0.12336206436157227,
0.11442076414823532,
0.7143633365631104,
-0.09638262540102005,
-0.7699382305145264,
0.539725124835968,
0.28731244802474976,
0.13351479172706604,
0.22998012602329254,
-0.7105366587638855,
0.8571275472640991,
-0.26931822299957275,
-0.10577618330717087,
0.2820436954498291,
0.4394867718219757,
0.02336466684937477,
0.5471775531768799,
1.0094704627990723,
0.4563567340373993,
0.3310348391532898,
0.24816013872623444,
1.1830369234085083,
-0.6311722993850708,
-0.6782056093215942,
-0.779954195022583,
0.34982526302337646,
0.03410295397043228,
-0.0848480686545372,
0.6567437052726746,
0.5068492293357849,
0.7424805760383606,
-0.04191255196928978,
0.49853023886680603,
0.17511150240898132,
0.256966769695282,
-1.1570147275924683,
0.2679762542247772,
-0.5032260417938232,
0.5216488838195801,
-0.049816083163022995,
-0.9009918570518494,
-0.41416794061660767,
0.26987433433532715,
-0.14791010320186615,
-0.008035811595618725,
0.6838356852531433,
1.1936372518539429,
0.0802353098988533,
0.3010926842689514,
0.2610541582107544,
0.5323096513748169,
0.42818108201026917,
0.36151012778282166,
0.8262695074081421,
-0.45992669463157654,
0.20986853539943695,
-0.14561589062213898,
-0.21751455962657928,
-0.22032341361045837,
-0.9311591982841492,
-0.8456121683120728,
-0.3546063303947449,
-0.1305922269821167,
-0.5258999466896057,
0.34292495250701904,
0.9971712231636047,
0.5543988943099976,
-0.5636677145957947,
-0.25815457105636597,
-0.38024476170539856,
-0.05305270105600357,
-0.3515506088733673,
-0.16420581936836243,
0.46925169229507446,
-0.6846878528594971,
-0.7226518988609314,
0.7843120098114014,
0.3768393099308014,
-0.14166387915611267,
-0.20101000368595123,
-0.3005799949169159,
-0.09184610098600388,
0.36387819051742554,
0.4979947805404663,
-0.09637532383203506,
-0.9084917306900024,
-0.15561209619045258,
0.012323268689215183,
-0.11916939914226532,
-0.11789925396442413,
1.0572245121002197,
-0.7130457162857056,
0.4927704334259033,
0.46315956115722656,
1.16777765750885,
0.7224671840667725,
0.12574931979179382,
0.37308788299560547,
-0.5032244920730591,
0.6054561138153076,
0.08882572501897812,
0.32983535528182983,
0.020917721092700958,
-0.4313199818134308,
0.32436293363571167,
0.39481985569000244,
-0.38589242100715637,
-1.117659091949463,
0.24533507227897644,
-1.2203446626663208,
-0.32383957505226135,
1.1388036012649536,
0.07865381240844727,
-0.49492505192756653,
0.13576780259609222,
-0.07658544927835464,
-0.02911882847547531,
-0.4034985899925232,
0.646518349647522,
0.474641352891922,
-0.033529870212078094,
0.08234498649835587,
-0.47150811553001404,
0.30828166007995605,
0.5512298941612244,
-0.7002207040786743,
0.42064306139945984,
0.24189764261245728,
0.12269018590450287,
-0.116679847240448,
0.7487952709197998,
-0.23601034283638,
0.6054380536079407,
0.5414544939994812,
-0.2752862274646759,
-0.33668991923332214,
-0.3854788541793823,
-0.40565547347068787,
-0.0615505687892437,
0.16231563687324524,
-0.09100756049156189
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18624v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18624v1
|
Vulnerability Detection with Code Language Models: How Far Are We?
| 2024-03-27T14:34:29 | 2024-03-27T14:34:29 |
Yangruibo Ding, Yanjun Fu, Omniyyah Ibrahim, Chawin Sitawarin, Xinyun Chen, Basel Alomair, David Wagner, Baishakhi Ray, Yizheng Chen
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL
|
In the context of the rising interest in code language models (code LMs) and
vulnerability detection, we study the effectiveness of code LMs for detecting
vulnerabilities. Our analysis reveals significant shortcomings in existing
vulnerability datasets, including poor data quality, low label accuracy, and
high duplication rates, leading to unreliable model performance in realistic
vulnerability detection scenarios. Additionally, the evaluation methods used
with these datasets are not representative of real-world vulnerability
detection.
To address these challenges, we introduce PrimeVul, a new dataset for
training and evaluating code LMs for vulnerability detection. PrimeVul
incorporates a novel set of data labeling techniques that achieve comparable
label accuracy to human-verified benchmarks while significantly expanding the
dataset. It also implements a rigorous data de-duplication and chronological
data splitting strategy to mitigate data leakage issues, alongside introducing
more realistic evaluation metrics and settings. This comprehensive approach
aims to provide a more accurate assessment of code LMs' performance in
real-world conditions.
Evaluating code LMs on PrimeVul reveals that existing benchmarks
significantly overestimate the performance of these models. For instance, a
state-of-the-art 7B model scored 68.26% F1 on BigVul but only 3.09% F1 on
PrimeVul. Attempts to improve performance through advanced training techniques
and larger models like GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 were unsuccessful, with results akin
to random guessing in the most stringent settings. These findings underscore
the considerable gap between current capabilities and the practical
requirements for deploying code LMs in security roles, highlighting the need
for more innovative research in this domain.
|
[
-0.24624347686767578,
-0.6191020011901855,
0.2131081223487854,
-0.2393846958875656,
-0.2972303330898285,
0.22235113382339478,
-0.14369718730449677,
-0.4051450788974762,
-0.4038592278957367,
0.400346577167511,
-0.19207745790481567,
-0.6923502683639526,
-0.6051464676856995,
-0.2740856409072876,
-0.22960230708122253,
0.9150351285934448,
0.2392173707485199,
-0.14965155720710754,
-0.1788448840379715,
-0.12940526008605957,
-0.7233082056045532,
-0.8078953623771667,
0.01011814083904028,
-0.12429522722959518,
0.08777888119220734,
0.5362582206726074,
0.9851927161216736,
0.28962409496307373,
0.5648604035377502,
0.1593976467847824,
-0.06321682780981064,
-0.0020530754700303078,
-0.46527159214019775,
0.017215553671121597,
0.015064497478306293,
-0.6392719745635986,
-0.45054954290390015,
-0.18822027742862701,
0.3768569827079773,
0.5498545169830322,
0.1825411468744278,
0.19830575585365295,
-0.038636110723018646,
0.8286543488502502,
-0.8979344367980957,
0.05572374910116196,
-0.5710586905479431,
0.21892638504505157,
-0.2927990257740021,
-0.024631785228848457,
-0.5181688070297241,
-0.4506002962589264,
0.034906189888715744,
-0.043480101972818375,
0.24978642165660858,
-0.13896697759628296,
0.33372777700424194,
0.03765932470560074,
-0.3539797365665436,
-0.1926409900188446,
-0.6814862489700317,
0.6683015823364258,
-0.6305555701255798,
0.5351430177688599,
0.5320833325386047,
0.4059831500053406,
-0.023560190573334694,
-0.5147130489349365,
-0.14979054033756256,
-0.5984627604484558,
0.2770709693431854,
-0.35882434248924255,
-0.24136081337928772,
-0.27693334221839905,
0.34789231419563293,
0.49694374203681946,
-0.9981920719146729,
0.28785404562950134,
-0.49202460050582886,
-0.4556424915790558,
0.6249984502792358,
0.37514549493789673,
0.07135985791683197,
0.12725438177585602,
-0.4811665415763855,
-0.18857872486114502,
-0.8080750107765198,
0.10468828678131104,
0.484335720539093,
0.1504158079624176,
-0.16819065809249878,
0.2516043484210968,
0.26797935366630554,
0.8833191990852356,
-0.43591541051864624,
-0.01964789442718029,
0.42038169503211975,
-0.18844078481197357,
-0.18469849228858948,
-0.32578983902931213,
0.6022472381591797,
0.37153586745262146,
0.19101408123970032,
-0.20719817280769348,
-0.3175738751888275,
0.2901098430156708,
0.4134044051170349,
-0.6519540548324585,
-0.513578474521637,
0.2915287911891937,
-0.5744597315788269,
-0.5725275874137878,
0.24306702613830566,
-0.8658377528190613,
-0.8861712217330933,
0.16731278598308563,
0.18784794211387634,
-0.49428117275238037,
-0.5718646049499512,
0.29639384150505066,
0.019879907369613647,
0.28460049629211426,
-0.18004554510116577,
-0.5681896805763245,
0.20890381932258606,
0.811283528804779,
0.7777301669120789,
-0.29976019263267517,
-0.08004289865493774,
-0.4461081027984619,
-0.3185858428478241,
-0.3658597767353058,
0.6278892755508423,
-0.5166355967521667,
-0.654532790184021,
0.19703738391399384,
-0.11047584563493729,
0.0994967594742775,
-0.7272951006889343,
0.5557764768600464,
-0.5443258881568909,
-0.45007258653640747,
-0.1150895431637764,
-0.645730197429657,
0.212397962808609,
0.20787733793258667,
-0.8279582858085632,
0.8044725656509399,
0.21338409185409546,
-0.6955545544624329,
0.3289135694503784,
-0.32677873969078064,
-0.2728239595890045,
-0.007795181591063738,
-0.055080562829971313,
-0.7309665679931641,
0.04272976890206337,
0.07869305461645126,
0.4632089138031006,
-0.3683937191963196,
0.16341960430145264,
-0.5077428817749023,
-0.5438302755355835,
0.7794327139854431,
-0.7075452208518982,
0.5129296779632568,
0.5180763602256775,
-0.27248039841651917,
-0.09414716064929962,
-0.6390239596366882,
0.26531291007995605,
0.1196598932147026,
-0.07750926166772842,
-0.08922657370567322,
-0.044548824429512024,
0.11656750738620758,
-0.09213434904813766,
0.13357320427894592,
-0.26195111870765686,
0.4251871407032013,
-0.32165196537971497,
0.3839620351791382,
0.6447734832763672,
-0.08375199884176254,
0.551378607749939,
-0.33406901359558105,
0.7970091104507446,
0.08284083753824234,
0.6798191666603088,
-0.17427346110343933,
-0.328023225069046,
-0.41706693172454834,
-0.0832948312163353,
0.33048081398010254,
0.6893570423126221,
-0.4884507656097412,
0.5520026683807373,
-0.1839894950389862,
-0.7035953998565674,
-0.12738174200057983,
0.12708064913749695,
0.7570622563362122,
0.0869242250919342,
0.20589573681354523,
-0.4187304973602295,
-0.423748254776001,
-0.8573369383811951,
-0.417251318693161,
-0.3359105885028839,
0.08983996510505676,
-0.1890505999326706,
0.7624883651733398,
-0.18504035472869873,
0.8385553956031799,
-0.7488489151000977,
-0.20102612674236298,
-0.3719217777252197,
-0.03534173220396042,
0.23401597142219543,
0.5647972822189331,
0.5031479597091675,
-0.9619084596633911,
-0.12620805203914642,
-0.06117565929889679,
-0.5937744379043579,
0.06184007227420807,
0.359237402677536,
0.3230724334716797,
0.15135876834392548,
0.41972270607948303,
-0.07533475756645203,
0.5410354137420654,
0.6089690923690796,
-0.29290327429771423,
0.5984168648719788,
-0.08114723116159439,
0.06099833548069,
-0.7140955924987793,
0.07517623156309128,
-0.18372252583503723,
-0.17278560996055603,
-0.7718639969825745,
0.20470666885375977,
0.4771355390548706,
-0.5112457275390625,
-0.6184125542640686,
0.3015049397945404,
-0.5766576528549194,
-0.27834683656692505,
-0.2195138782262802,
-0.30003970861434937,
-0.1033044308423996,
0.355741947889328,
-0.34512725472450256,
0.8671167492866516,
0.7316464781761169,
-0.3437344431877136,
0.42833104729652405,
-0.1638445407152176,
-0.5202234983444214,
0.26932674646377563,
-0.447672039270401,
0.5436229705810547,
0.2073938548564911,
0.2254616767168045,
-0.8535774350166321,
-0.025550713762640953,
0.37874606251716614,
-0.45251747965812683,
0.5584785342216492,
-0.538714587688446,
-0.4429172873497009,
-0.49771976470947266,
-0.5206937789916992,
0.5474103689193726,
0.5957317352294922,
-0.1690504550933838,
0.19997638463974,
0.5432770848274231,
0.22373244166374207,
-0.5673959851264954,
-0.7300588488578796,
-0.01949019357562065,
-0.20828311145305634,
-0.6969320774078369,
-0.031560469418764114,
-0.08092129975557327,
-0.24728462100028992,
-0.1140381321310997,
-0.44226452708244324,
-0.45266392827033997,
0.4052312672138214,
0.5307397246360779,
0.21431829035282135,
-0.24705694615840912,
0.30201148986816406,
-0.639680027961731,
-0.36702847480773926,
0.012372259981930256,
-0.5001435875892639,
0.19245322048664093,
-0.5973278880119324,
-0.7687690854072571,
-0.11601342260837555,
0.28834253549575806,
0.5258065462112427,
-0.45232078433036804,
0.6767000555992126,
0.42785462737083435,
-0.4750816524028778,
-0.2086697369813919,
-0.47592687606811523,
0.039150629192590714,
-0.41108956933021545,
0.34231579303741455,
-0.3991144001483917,
-0.6428712010383606,
0.5247766375541687,
0.04072378948330879,
-0.14425218105316162,
0.14379659295082092,
0.42863377928733826,
0.29435381293296814,
0.5691049695014954,
0.7873124480247498,
-0.46900123357772827,
0.3588967025279999,
-0.5114395022392273,
0.3550407290458679,
-0.3644113838672638,
-0.1610187143087387,
-0.4733135402202606,
0.07243295013904572,
-0.5111556053161621,
-0.6978378295898438,
0.3761936128139496,
0.0859353095293045,
0.047759342938661575,
0.3439111113548279,
-0.5257537364959717,
0.6296452879905701,
0.07396066933870316,
0.22200924158096313,
0.24034152925014496,
-0.31644928455352783,
0.2561120390892029,
-0.05577133595943451,
-0.667842447757721,
-0.5974056720733643,
1.3078068494796753,
0.5451949238777161,
1.0823495388031006,
0.19597847759723663,
0.5582044720649719,
0.7574262619018555,
0.3403376042842865,
-0.4757758677005768,
0.32332685589790344,
0.04557682201266289,
-0.5670202374458313,
-0.22111356258392334,
-0.2615748345851898,
-0.9061881303787231,
0.09025958180427551,
-0.03476440906524658,
-0.5444430708885193,
0.15098820626735687,
0.18347910046577454,
-0.44229891896247864,
0.3434677720069885,
-1.0312782526016235,
1.1520438194274902,
-0.19169433414936066,
-0.3391212821006775,
0.13179850578308105,
-0.5927737951278687,
0.43431323766708374,
-0.1704787313938141,
0.37389740347862244,
-0.18716903030872345,
-0.016744442284107208,
0.4833090901374817,
-0.48449522256851196,
0.9376100301742554,
-0.23784080147743225,
-0.4054618775844574,
0.49563977122306824,
0.05380307137966156,
0.5310429930686951,
0.18929624557495117,
-0.11250171810388565,
0.21528342366218567,
-0.0645856037735939,
-0.4547935724258423,
-0.3771960735321045,
0.6876663565635681,
-0.5007640719413757,
-0.39863288402557373,
-0.5878321528434753,
-0.42124831676483154,
-0.3898170292377472,
-0.12115120887756348,
0.47973573207855225,
0.6584790349006653,
-0.2871958315372467,
0.08599629253149033,
0.9029818773269653,
-0.41383567452430725,
0.19311809539794922,
0.5844197869300842,
-0.05258965119719505,
-0.2444329559803009,
0.9225326180458069,
0.14459000527858734,
0.32980096340179443,
0.33465680480003357,
-0.037099629640579224,
-0.13187934458255768,
-0.6742423176765442,
-0.14698967337608337,
-0.1383654773235321,
-0.6936920881271362,
-0.612366259098053,
-0.3378535211086273,
-0.342724084854126,
-0.532897412776947,
-0.17099037766456604,
-0.5550667643547058,
-0.07646997272968292,
0.017916042357683182,
-0.1756158024072647,
0.46500498056411743,
0.5542884469032288,
-0.001158395898528397,
0.04952001944184303,
-0.9613276124000549,
0.2977116107940674,
0.1283760964870453,
0.4724161922931671,
-0.19659560918807983,
-0.49097737669944763,
-0.3569454550743103,
-0.08232396095991135,
-0.37436458468437195,
-1.1028735637664795,
0.3001742959022522,
-0.032215870916843414,
0.4036168158054352,
0.04729817435145378,
0.17466440796852112,
0.31057286262512207,
-0.24561716616153717,
0.8086576461791992,
0.049373481422662735,
-0.8866900205612183,
0.6542787551879883,
-0.1883953958749771,
0.2816712558269501,
0.45233240723609924,
0.10785267502069473,
-0.3060073256492615,
-0.4435427486896515,
-0.5352084040641785,
-0.7772639989852905,
0.35315269231796265,
0.3267228305339813,
0.03113522008061409,
0.15313898026943207,
0.13556595146656036,
0.26916709542274475,
-0.06476642191410065,
-0.6231493353843689,
-0.34569329023361206,
0.047801680862903595,
0.15003538131713867,
0.012264094315469265,
-0.4273865520954132,
0.1993228942155838,
0.054538413882255554,
0.43945664167404175,
-0.1287381649017334,
0.3349546194076538,
-0.09919440746307373,
-0.39327508211135864,
0.09051479399204254,
0.3963841497898102,
0.4923999607563019,
0.8171913027763367,
-0.17280754446983337,
0.08660364151000977,
0.24073795974254608,
-0.6297897696495056,
0.26576176285743713,
0.13516949117183685,
0.2731810212135315,
-0.14089739322662354,
0.6294100284576416,
0.5404626131057739,
0.29979008436203003,
-0.8417145013809204,
0.9966285228729248,
-0.040981028228998184,
0.08243276923894882,
-0.5549375414848328,
0.2641724944114685,
-0.09024042636156082,
0.348432332277298,
0.44505375623703003,
-0.06943715363740921,
0.04298481345176697,
-0.4757702052593231,
0.3815747797489166,
0.23274528980255127,
-0.38120099902153015,
-0.2975662350654602,
0.5336296558380127,
0.19491057097911835,
-0.26534318923950195,
0.5063619017601013,
-0.07553373277187347,
-0.5678356885910034,
0.938459038734436,
0.212104931473732,
0.82603520154953,
-0.3846968412399292,
0.053149692714214325,
0.008701183833181858,
0.6169655919075012,
-0.05572870746254921,
0.328358918428421,
0.058052826672792435,
-0.4969089925289154,
-0.2558489143848419,
-0.27825307846069336,
-0.383137583732605,
0.3375920355319977,
-0.7816815376281738,
0.3893739879131317,
-0.3066941499710083,
-0.29754412174224854,
-0.18891550600528717,
-0.11334172636270523,
-0.7048175930976868,
-0.06237335875630379,
0.30935195088386536,
1.1247553825378418,
-1.03621244430542,
0.8545512557029724,
0.32989534735679626,
-0.3304949998855591,
-0.4632188379764557,
0.03326575458049774,
-0.0020312892738729715,
-0.6494919657707214,
0.4123827815055847,
0.37416115403175354,
0.2803479731082916,
-0.4153090715408325,
-0.3930538594722748,
-0.4953141212463379,
0.8912315964698792,
0.5646623373031616,
-0.5568748712539673,
0.2306637465953827,
0.3574411869049072,
0.4298675060272217,
0.03037319704890251,
0.033768050372600555,
0.6191761493682861,
0.29842111468315125,
-0.4933871030807495,
-0.8148905038833618,
-0.18425756692886353,
-0.2595576345920563,
0.15547986328601837,
0.5155848264694214,
-0.4126830995082855,
0.6218588948249817,
-0.36797261238098145,
-0.11926110833883286,
0.12011270970106125,
0.579425573348999,
0.1407850831747055,
0.47831425070762634,
0.4766322076320648,
0.34713900089263916,
0.6158183217048645,
-0.020624402910470963,
1.1570686101913452,
-0.17186270654201508,
0.5157331824302673,
0.9153271317481995,
-0.4378321170806885,
0.6128801107406616,
0.04470395669341087,
-0.3818269968032837,
0.12248139828443527,
0.4180848002433777,
-0.15323899686336517,
0.417093962430954,
0.4267946183681488,
-0.18084008991718292,
-0.32947057485580444,
0.12158016115427017,
-0.7224196791648865,
0.14609183371067047,
0.33901867270469666,
-0.3860553205013275,
-0.15136413276195526,
0.3796670436859131,
-0.18686485290527344,
0.09703277051448822,
-0.2004234492778778,
0.31422534584999084,
0.13214488327503204,
-0.2606457471847534,
0.7450940608978271,
-0.05451864376664162,
0.45069342851638794,
-0.6599385142326355,
-0.08930531144142151,
-0.30039480328559875,
0.3498117923736572,
-0.06126474589109421,
-0.872539222240448,
0.24971245229244232,
0.36338603496551514,
-0.11536023020744324,
-0.1428157091140747,
1.0025269985198975,
-0.05409986525774002,
-0.20295660197734833,
0.2407664805650711,
0.3454969823360443,
0.16601718962192535,
-0.1290961056947708,
-0.48608464002609253,
0.5713860988616943,
-0.17645099759101868,
-0.07791939377784729,
0.4142402410507202,
0.3030411899089813,
-0.04088794067502022,
0.7291486859321594,
0.5842030048370361,
-0.15450210869312286,
0.04816354066133499,
0.012278459034860134,
0.8896774649620056,
-0.7087100744247437,
-0.34639304876327515,
-0.8936775922775269,
0.49825260043144226,
-0.10575368255376816,
-0.38841667771339417,
0.5347871780395508,
0.7651793360710144,
0.7113242745399475,
-0.22027802467346191,
0.8020301461219788,
0.08115088939666748,
0.1567295491695404,
-0.5928077101707458,
0.39648154377937317,
0.03210819512605667,
0.6409696340560913,
-0.10070786625146866,
-0.7545956969261169,
-0.2898139953613281,
0.2738504111766815,
-0.27702781558036804,
-0.0013200464891269803,
0.6279188394546509,
1.0718532800674438,
0.04925491288304329,
-0.04020379111170769,
0.6886197328567505,
0.17962120473384857,
0.3398968279361725,
1.0051287412643433,
1.065962553024292,
-0.5729155540466309,
0.6706345677375793,
-0.14982716739177704,
-0.30053260922431946,
-0.32556289434432983,
-0.9044916033744812,
-0.7794623374938965,
-0.5703624486923218,
-0.37483739852905273,
-0.3225209712982178,
0.5284155011177063,
0.5732948184013367,
0.6052412986755371,
-0.7670905590057373,
0.08511663973331451,
0.004098072648048401,
0.11797799915075302,
-0.2765059769153595,
-0.2065826803445816,
0.28365036845207214,
-0.16634666919708252,
-0.17579041421413422,
0.38645440340042114,
0.24063123762607574,
-0.11601995676755905,
-0.4120652675628662,
0.014103639870882034,
0.26860275864601135,
-0.34594014286994934,
0.3200167417526245,
0.4624403417110443,
-0.46095263957977295,
-0.27383720874786377,
-0.10414004325866699,
-0.3576759099960327,
-0.16091863811016083,
1.0632901191711426,
-0.6680847406387329,
0.3008502721786499,
0.5140762329101562,
0.679847240447998,
0.16401739418506622,
-0.5132468342781067,
0.48473644256591797,
-0.7082725167274475,
0.21858784556388855,
0.374152809381485,
0.2684474289417267,
0.3407018482685089,
-0.3881467282772064,
0.6429761648178101,
0.14557580649852753,
-0.5618624687194824,
-1.1099611520767212,
0.33934497833251953,
-0.6479994058609009,
-0.2968035340309143,
1.2933019399642944,
-0.2712039053440094,
-0.17306838929653168,
-0.36985573172569275,
-0.057809390127658844,
-0.051221802830696106,
-0.09960349649190903,
0.3876379728317261,
0.4545380175113678,
0.21784435212612152,
0.20325824618339539,
-0.7468791007995605,
0.31663987040519714,
0.18443652987480164,
-0.5561594367027283,
0.5001673698425293,
0.4378278851509094,
0.3357667624950409,
-0.04527594521641731,
0.6188158392906189,
-0.22658148407936096,
0.5891677141189575,
0.01282251626253128,
0.08142973482608795,
-0.20385463535785675,
-0.1795940399169922,
-0.6727074980735779,
0.26305168867111206,
0.32985517382621765,
-0.31914353370666504
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18609v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18609v1
|
A survey on learning models of spiking neural membrane systems and spiking neural networks
| 2024-03-27T14:26:41 | 2024-03-27T14:26:41 |
Prithwineel Paul, Petr Sosik, Lucie Ciencialova
|
cs.NE
|
cs.NE, cs.CL
|
Spiking neural networks (SNN) are a biologically inspired model of neural
networks with certain brain-like properties. In the past few decades, this
model has received increasing attention in computer science community, owing
also to the successful phenomenon of deep learning. In SNN, communication
between neurons takes place through the spikes and spike trains. This
differentiates these models from the ``standard'' artificial neural networks
(ANN) where the frequency of spikes is replaced by real-valued signals. Spiking
neural P systems (SNPS) can be considered a branch of SNN based more on the
principles of formal automata, with many variants developed within the
framework of the membrane computing theory. In this paper, we first briefly
compare structure and function, advantages and drawbacks of SNN and SNPS. A key
part of the article is a survey of recent results and applications of machine
learning and deep learning models of both SNN and SNPS formalisms.
|
[
-0.18284524977207184,
-0.6491525173187256,
0.46139514446258545,
0.1170545220375061,
0.028734738007187843,
0.20329007506370544,
0.07536838203668594,
-0.46493372321128845,
0.6831408739089966,
0.23671381175518036,
-0.12714262306690216,
0.14038926362991333,
-0.824886679649353,
0.08499766886234283,
-0.5791299939155579,
0.9187749624252319,
0.10674495995044708,
0.41483280062675476,
0.10250051319599152,
0.018541645258665085,
-0.08618757128715515,
-0.26919063925743103,
-0.5070549845695496,
-0.7647021412849426,
0.8430933952331543,
-0.05875604599714279,
0.17628730833530426,
0.7524121403694153,
0.54121994972229,
0.26620736718177795,
-0.4122537672519684,
-0.0709405317902565,
0.08525168895721436,
0.3946409523487091,
-0.10132231563329697,
-0.4100292921066284,
-0.055427636951208115,
-0.10635324567556381,
0.5892992615699768,
0.9693695902824402,
0.0650363340973854,
-0.041712354868650436,
0.0056397817097604275,
0.7509759068489075,
-0.42701396346092224,
0.14820466935634613,
-0.5476694107055664,
0.6160616278648376,
0.07381797581911087,
-0.29552212357521057,
-0.23099108040332794,
-0.31478601694107056,
0.596794605255127,
-0.22035498917102814,
0.19220833480358124,
-0.3056967556476593,
0.6870161294937134,
0.058236341923475266,
-0.37521326541900635,
-0.3978944718837738,
-0.3642411231994629,
0.4476167857646942,
-0.4635425806045532,
0.4795660674571991,
0.11465016007423401,
0.38106831908226013,
-0.2727162539958954,
-0.7162209749221802,
-0.02586868219077587,
-0.6755861639976501,
0.2622871994972229,
0.19822658598423004,
0.07718372344970703,
0.1585087925195694,
0.36696571111679077,
0.6469541192054749,
-0.35577529668807983,
0.07007016986608505,
-0.664747416973114,
-0.039502330124378204,
0.5536293387413025,
-0.1877153366804123,
0.248893603682518,
-0.2384919375181198,
-0.6803101301193237,
0.34536221623420715,
-0.5329279899597168,
0.08469240367412567,
0.37200501561164856,
0.09651724249124527,
0.14373604953289032,
0.40420183539390564,
-0.23190027475357056,
0.46314001083374023,
-0.018250619992613792,
0.20082993805408478,
-0.012813318520784378,
0.06806662678718567,
-0.40303653478622437,
0.08667930960655212,
0.7135211825370789,
0.19177967309951782,
0.33536994457244873,
-0.4204148054122925,
-0.3418880105018616,
0.16593880951404572,
0.173091858625412,
-0.604769229888916,
-0.6022551655769348,
0.11401364207267761,
-0.8430517315864563,
-0.3832884132862091,
-0.5664529204368591,
-0.5245020389556885,
-0.5925443172454834,
-0.3631105422973633,
0.7083501815795898,
-0.5390578508377075,
-0.661237359046936,
0.33265259861946106,
-0.44267958402633667,
-0.030392231419682503,
0.5396150946617126,
-1.0102216005325317,
0.5381015539169312,
0.5803424119949341,
0.9889883995056152,
-0.4331735670566559,
-0.6705266237258911,
0.10812430083751678,
-0.4449055790901184,
-0.40570250153541565,
0.7039167881011963,
0.04040536656975746,
-0.0840274766087532,
-0.2537458837032318,
-0.0877416580915451,
-0.04821042716503143,
-0.5951976776123047,
-0.2584528923034668,
-0.6090308427810669,
-0.6517508029937744,
-0.015915950760245323,
-0.6378536820411682,
-0.25457361340522766,
-0.08550971001386642,
-0.6278524398803711,
0.8803853988647461,
-0.29623639583587646,
-0.7192761898040771,
0.5303247570991516,
-0.6027843356132507,
-0.39195969700813293,
0.07402493804693222,
-0.15377277135849,
-0.41902536153793335,
0.2924032211303711,
-0.3650537431240082,
0.8789291977882385,
-0.08494995534420013,
0.5904962420463562,
-0.2901107966899872,
0.02179238200187683,
0.5088505148887634,
-0.3455847203731537,
0.9493760466575623,
0.6194894313812256,
-0.4560033679008484,
0.306477427482605,
-0.9586692452430725,
-0.32519590854644775,
0.09677945077419281,
-0.15293456614017487,
0.13769374787807465,
0.2494065910577774,
-0.343843549489975,
0.11916579306125641,
0.10220322012901306,
-0.579210638999939,
0.22996748983860016,
-0.23749426007270813,
1.0628604888916016,
0.6200096011161804,
0.09058891981840134,
0.5419251322746277,
-0.44402453303337097,
-0.05950488522648811,
0.3068303167819977,
0.08870135992765427,
-0.47501859068870544,
-0.7000947594642639,
-0.6874946355819702,
-0.22394636273384094,
0.3899451792240143,
0.27307936549186707,
-0.4586499333381653,
0.4471641182899475,
0.07863452285528183,
-0.6708493232727051,
-0.21813389658927917,
-0.3301539421081543,
-0.10382888466119766,
0.33334171772003174,
0.35573509335517883,
-0.4654786288738251,
-0.36142992973327637,
-0.7700561285018921,
-0.3042648732662201,
0.03336772322654724,
0.10009719431400299,
0.3547264337539673,
0.661801278591156,
0.12483353912830353,
0.6142587661743164,
0.10961142182350159,
0.5897899866104126,
-0.15619957447052002,
0.05453256145119667,
0.15568287670612335,
0.6789909601211548,
0.2686368227005005,
-0.46820810437202454,
-0.2912158668041229,
0.10163996368646622,
-0.7062283158302307,
0.1863633394241333,
-0.025731002911925316,
0.4485267400741577,
-0.17678548395633698,
0.19845081865787506,
-0.6022256016731262,
1.0139825344085693,
0.02876058593392372,
0.15666750073432922,
0.9249487519264221,
-0.13857333362102509,
0.22275763750076294,
-0.8378303050994873,
-0.06899025291204453,
-0.06725966930389404,
-0.23943781852722168,
-0.9767021536827087,
0.23710061609745026,
0.195684015750885,
-0.28900986909866333,
-0.4366971552371979,
0.15907135605812073,
-0.4768788516521454,
-0.5585147738456726,
-0.3044649064540863,
-0.48952382802963257,
-0.11348052322864532,
0.37243926525115967,
0.35787463188171387,
0.35887351632118225,
1.36068856716156,
-0.961933970451355,
0.5149572491645813,
-0.20833143591880798,
-0.43561071157455444,
0.08116806298494339,
-0.6482375264167786,
-0.23433391749858856,
-0.053832825273275375,
0.231523334980011,
-0.8653972744941711,
-0.09694437682628632,
0.2462177574634552,
-0.7908152937889099,
0.13679645955562592,
-0.397599458694458,
-0.3516177833080292,
-0.13647088408470154,
-0.04725339263677597,
0.4001047909259796,
0.2832843065261841,
-0.49345049262046814,
0.41048315167427063,
0.5020989179611206,
0.26378965377807617,
-0.523993968963623,
-0.8759458065032959,
0.06470134109258652,
-0.15296638011932373,
-0.32457172870635986,
0.04623544588685036,
0.16513365507125854,
0.2354585975408554,
-0.10611457377672195,
-0.1728241741657257,
-0.20000727474689484,
0.3815680742263794,
0.21468092501163483,
-0.17025326192378998,
-0.2863428592681885,
0.2824043929576874,
-0.31533801555633545,
-0.21055951714515686,
0.015313664451241493,
-0.509606659412384,
0.6716675162315369,
-0.0026429519057273865,
-0.5231794118881226,
-0.7428701519966125,
0.6026477217674255,
0.6370468735694885,
-0.227701798081398,
0.3422818183898926,
0.04200219735503197,
-0.500454843044281,
-0.3476230800151825,
-0.1588076651096344,
-0.7203288674354553,
-0.45435038208961487,
0.1649211198091507,
-0.3834169805049896,
-0.6482968926429749,
0.6045700311660767,
-0.36935821175575256,
-0.3053857982158661,
0.21868476271629333,
0.35893386602401733,
-0.13802802562713623,
0.8207125067710876,
0.5385801196098328,
0.06759107857942581,
0.5616701245307922,
-0.3966842293739319,
0.4213748276233673,
-0.6720895767211914,
-0.09100012481212616,
-0.43356987833976746,
-0.4967709183692932,
-0.6682448983192444,
-0.1339762955904007,
0.03335706144571304,
0.10555809736251831,
-0.5355052351951599,
0.27251607179641724,
-0.846185028553009,
0.08677521347999573,
0.4797733426094055,
-0.00035872330772690475,
-0.38449209928512573,
0.47343629598617554,
-0.4748974144458771,
0.1894240379333496,
-1.2390468120574951,
-0.1767086535692215,
1.0402071475982666,
0.8922688961029053,
0.618151068687439,
-0.33654531836509705,
0.7144543528556824,
0.06068771332502365,
-0.0013742911396548152,
-1.1585935354232788,
0.5879484415054321,
-0.05050855875015259,
-0.726080596446991,
0.018667953088879585,
-0.5901731252670288,
-1.0280089378356934,
-0.04095906764268875,
-0.3177298903465271,
-1.1687089204788208,
0.39849746227264404,
-0.14535197615623474,
-0.3758549392223358,
1.0729109048843384,
-0.43870607018470764,
0.30724477767944336,
-0.2297269105911255,
-0.24786561727523804,
0.026975933462381363,
-0.793708324432373,
0.16192716360092163,
0.48198994994163513,
-0.40276291966438293,
-0.07430530339479446,
0.21343562006950378,
0.8544091582298279,
-0.2372836321592331,
0.8919363021850586,
-0.17607557773590088,
0.23562514781951904,
0.35500970482826233,
0.1754751354455948,
0.09649477899074554,
-0.02945849299430847,
-0.25812092423439026,
0.4436933398246765,
0.1265011429786682,
-0.3166866898536682,
-0.4273728132247925,
0.5634959936141968,
-0.7952563166618347,
-0.2689696252346039,
-0.8091410994529724,
-0.41764405369758606,
0.1263016313314438,
0.3488929569721222,
0.15284596383571625,
0.5030422210693359,
0.3421177268028259,
0.3151004910469055,
0.9275303483009338,
-0.15926288068294525,
0.4795699715614319,
0.1701185703277588,
-0.48398929834365845,
-0.5342415571212769,
0.9470539689064026,
0.6709162592887878,
0.21751335263252258,
-0.19069550931453705,
0.1705481857061386,
-0.010379547253251076,
-0.6984102725982666,
-0.639915406703949,
0.03129245340824127,
-0.45539993047714233,
-0.16568875312805176,
-0.7036959528923035,
-0.9175986647605896,
-0.39863288402557373,
0.06516578048467636,
-0.38206595182418823,
-0.37744349241256714,
-0.26847532391548157,
-0.16234877705574036,
0.6462414264678955,
0.9908761978149414,
-0.40375393629074097,
0.41129592061042786,
-0.4812033772468567,
0.32846808433532715,
0.27227336168289185,
0.5762889981269836,
0.3455248177051544,
-0.1847785860300064,
-0.13772013783454895,
-0.08836448937654495,
-0.20011429488658905,
-1.4407784938812256,
0.12906217575073242,
0.10889152437448502,
0.45461297035217285,
0.43739983439445496,
-0.7458552122116089,
0.49787887930870056,
-0.6158627271652222,
0.8362791538238525,
0.5431095957756042,
-0.6473038792610168,
0.45525476336479187,
-0.21387802064418793,
-0.2839186489582062,
0.2275760918855667,
0.7278355360031128,
-0.6614055633544922,
0.3142649531364441,
-0.8649371266365051,
-0.8396145105361938,
0.490975022315979,
0.057420358061790466,
-0.231886088848114,
0.1535702645778656,
0.8883412480354309,
0.28014034032821655,
0.3975525498390198,
-0.5403746366500854,
-0.7066171169281006,
-0.2361069917678833,
0.04952986165881157,
-0.0008761065546423197,
0.17695574462413788,
0.012923299334943295,
-0.415261447429657,
0.37867099046707153,
0.13520120084285736,
0.5138226747512817,
0.3203383684158325,
0.05042047053575516,
0.08333714306354523,
-0.1840357482433319,
0.32308897376060486,
0.20818477869033813,
-0.10749392211437225,
0.2739518880844116,
0.23873509466648102,
-0.5481685400009155,
0.5751659274101257,
-0.192164346575737,
-0.42988279461860657,
0.009723844937980175,
0.006668009329587221,
0.8928285241127014,
0.020626766607165337,
0.06285067647695541,
0.4013853967189789,
0.018053129315376282,
-0.3800762891769409,
0.12008198350667953,
0.1597558856010437,
0.19021674990653992,
0.12770208716392517,
0.3488691747188568,
0.656663715839386,
0.3310554623603821,
-0.630695641040802,
0.5444706082344055,
0.275602787733078,
-0.5983424782752991,
-0.3775474429130554,
0.14391429722309113,
-0.1285882443189621,
-0.8272837996482849,
-0.05563819408416748,
-0.11388914287090302,
-0.6242069602012634,
1.1355762481689453,
0.8578892350196838,
0.7864280343055725,
-0.31325387954711914,
0.2073598951101303,
0.15640881657600403,
0.15475454926490784,
-0.02114240825176239,
0.38216981291770935,
-0.6603550314903259,
-0.7360155582427979,
-0.17566737532615662,
-0.6969233751296997,
-0.14064235985279083,
0.39108210802078247,
-0.5995692610740662,
0.050559088587760925,
-1.028370976448059,
-0.3002765476703644,
0.3943980634212494,
0.18790468573570251,
-0.3876687288284302,
0.4547165632247925,
-0.035508688539266586,
1.3636945486068726,
-1.0110256671905518,
0.6995788216590881,
0.8120579123497009,
-0.20317135751247406,
-0.8077017664909363,
-0.3272267282009125,
-0.33941414952278137,
-0.5123172998428345,
0.8364437818527222,
0.2282305210828781,
-0.18521179258823395,
0.11961855739355087,
-0.6232178211212158,
-0.9730342030525208,
0.5883199572563171,
-0.18534798920154572,
-0.2970498204231262,
0.340255469083786,
0.06407256424427032,
0.383990615606308,
-0.44347700476646423,
0.4483605921268463,
0.46013206243515015,
-0.08666505664587021,
-0.13622091710567474,
-0.6284493803977966,
-0.38241830468177795,
-0.4080931842327118,
-0.1430843025445938,
0.031399961560964584,
-0.6656374931335449,
1.0074762105941772,
0.3669995963573456,
-0.2906727194786072,
0.2781319320201874,
0.5731534957885742,
0.633552074432373,
0.6248728632926941,
0.32566139101982117,
0.5696827173233032,
0.5782076120376587,
-0.21505533158779144,
0.4655176103115082,
-0.5431786179542542,
0.14076577126979828,
0.5150575637817383,
-0.3682595491409302,
0.6354668736457825,
0.45574843883514404,
-0.27912965416908264,
0.17511411011219025,
1.0297000408172607,
0.09518644213676453,
0.28518614172935486,
0.8248996138572693,
-0.2086506187915802,
-0.021690355613827705,
0.36813923716545105,
-0.6893743872642517,
0.10128703713417053,
0.8123846054077148,
-0.26568734645843506,
-0.1875075250864029,
0.09402008354663849,
-0.4440804123878479,
-0.3176799416542053,
-0.6316339373588562,
0.854659378528595,
0.25923994183540344,
-0.4182049036026001,
0.2582491338253021,
-0.3658972680568695,
0.8075494170188904,
-0.5921497941017151,
-0.021932192146778107,
-0.02264283038675785,
-0.28444257378578186,
-0.2910873591899872,
-0.6003940105438232,
0.1552959829568863,
-0.09542747586965561,
-0.24066513776779175,
-0.09016875177621841,
1.1740761995315552,
0.10006263107061386,
-0.16678300499916077,
0.50602787733078,
0.2494286149740219,
0.7470182776451111,
0.4835435450077057,
-0.969868540763855,
-0.2603687644004822,
-0.409629225730896,
0.004284400027245283,
0.21432514488697052,
0.41428041458129883,
0.24144895374774933,
1.0069550275802612,
0.7363150119781494,
0.7879003882408142,
0.5387803316116333,
-0.3642108738422394,
0.6565298438072205,
-0.8457971811294556,
-0.6796274185180664,
-0.44956862926483154,
0.3526836335659027,
-0.0388304740190506,
-0.24278998374938965,
0.6719080805778503,
0.44202661514282227,
0.5347066521644592,
0.019842352718114853,
0.7556500434875488,
0.19658909738063812,
0.4985748529434204,
-0.22288201749324799,
1.1171752214431763,
-0.5861184597015381,
-0.02423614077270031,
0.1402314454317093,
-0.6504521369934082,
-0.5426568984985352,
0.875491201877594,
-0.358182817697525,
0.15690593421459198,
0.5847858786582947,
0.936032772064209,
-0.379278302192688,
0.2947041094303131,
0.4690246284008026,
0.01905878260731697,
0.061636313796043396,
0.2818736433982849,
1.4157631397247314,
-0.5508644580841064,
-0.44175586104393005,
-0.3092024624347687,
-0.287044882774353,
-0.6229940056800842,
-0.8150529861450195,
-0.4699335992336273,
-0.7684510350227356,
-0.308799684047699,
-0.28847259283065796,
0.2693841755390167,
0.755641758441925,
1.0710728168487549,
-0.9814508557319641,
-0.3096654713153839,
-0.6686846613883972,
0.227945938706398,
-0.21568360924720764,
-0.14053314924240112,
0.4062609076499939,
-0.6139613389968872,
-0.14150124788284302,
0.6636494398117065,
0.661912202835083,
0.06742935627698898,
-0.4685450792312622,
0.1880086362361908,
-0.4478268325328827,
0.31256043910980225,
0.2828722596168518,
0.5909408330917358,
-0.3401910066604614,
-0.17755337059497833,
0.12969276309013367,
-0.2558129131793976,
0.27609241008758545,
0.7309298515319824,
-0.7184838652610779,
0.33591967821121216,
0.9925181269645691,
0.6508459448814392,
0.3980245292186737,
-0.649423360824585,
0.16887785494327545,
-0.0688595250248909,
-0.027103357017040253,
0.34250858426094055,
0.43765246868133545,
0.22450967133045197,
-0.14586517214775085,
0.035667262971401215,
0.28383272886276245,
-1.05601167678833,
-0.8762487173080444,
0.6533106565475464,
-0.7496987581253052,
-0.23391635715961456,
0.8511723279953003,
-0.4157150089740753,
-0.7038381695747375,
-0.26505064964294434,
-0.06018181890249252,
0.6255754828453064,
0.049729492515325546,
0.8486618399620056,
0.3982155919075012,
-0.23062807321548462,
0.06441333889961243,
-0.6575983166694641,
0.9157136678695679,
0.8279443383216858,
-0.23926536738872528,
-0.2250283807516098,
-0.0070549678057432175,
0.47739678621292114,
0.2170684039592743,
0.19785059988498688,
0.09010886400938034,
0.5707963109016418,
0.13510438799858093,
0.09527842700481415,
0.14192414283752441,
-0.9965255260467529,
-0.881397008895874,
0.39685699343681335,
-0.19592978060245514,
-0.35532987117767334
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18591v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18591v1
|
Safety Verification of Wait-Only Non-Blocking Broadcast Protocols
| 2024-03-27T14:17:33 | 2024-03-27T14:17:33 |
Lucie Guillou, Arnaud Sangnier, Nathalie Sznajder
|
cs.LO
|
cs.LO, cs.CL, cs.MA
|
We study networks of processes that all execute the same finite protocol and
communicate synchronously in two different ways: a process can broadcast one
message to all other processes or send it to at most one other process. In both
cases, if no process can receive the message, it will still be sent. We
establish a precise complexity class for two coverability problems with a
parameterised number of processes: the state coverability problem and the
configuration coverability problem. It is already known that these problems are
Ackermann-hard (but decidable) in the general case. We show that when the
protocol is Wait-Only, i.e., it has no state from which a process can send and
receive messages, the complexity drops to P and PSPACE, respectively.
|
[
-0.45974770188331604,
-0.5338475108146667,
0.6426766514778137,
0.5603271126747131,
0.052975136786699295,
0.07848366349935532,
0.07339437305927277,
-0.7236535549163818,
0.6998631358146667,
0.6289046406745911,
-0.6757891178131104,
0.07221662253141403,
-0.9199270606040955,
0.22395579516887665,
-0.3968391716480255,
0.4395735561847687,
-0.6728688478469849,
-0.4243215024471283,
-0.09591088443994522,
-0.045354947447776794,
-0.20678499341011047,
-0.37472909688949585,
-0.5626534819602966,
-0.2855774760246277,
0.017464423552155495,
0.6322600245475769,
0.7869478464126587,
0.6858771443367004,
0.49603772163391113,
0.30080774426460266,
-0.3362029790878296,
0.12304022908210754,
-0.42967620491981506,
0.4454226493835449,
0.05370892584323883,
-0.09669941663742065,
-0.1421537697315216,
0.21652965247631073,
0.765723705291748,
0.9918922185897827,
0.07525911927223206,
-0.2127676010131836,
-0.2950317859649658,
0.6779965162277222,
-0.8008028268814087,
-0.0015767805743962526,
-0.2559070587158203,
0.31768760085105896,
-0.2795030176639557,
-0.5077747702598572,
-0.7023583650588989,
-0.42882969975471497,
0.13265740871429443,
-0.8059087991714478,
-0.05893980711698532,
0.3037909269332886,
0.5803218483924866,
0.1341463327407837,
-0.7572453618049622,
0.011252622120082378,
-1.0537348985671997,
0.6387525200843811,
-0.34059327840805054,
0.18377789855003357,
0.5406737327575684,
0.2694700360298157,
-0.5380690693855286,
-0.5125381946563721,
-0.50472092628479,
-0.41067826747894287,
-0.07926566898822784,
0.08752712607383728,
-0.12668928503990173,
0.4452970325946808,
0.5585771799087524,
0.4325335621833801,
-0.43893763422966003,
0.04115840792655945,
-0.31433814764022827,
-0.4498864412307739,
0.5466079115867615,
0.11100948601961136,
0.27783966064453125,
0.2076921910047531,
-0.5758764147758484,
0.07562708854675293,
-0.2873595952987671,
0.03485951945185661,
0.2626826763153076,
-0.2526010572910309,
-0.283376544713974,
0.26299721002578735,
-0.8065928220748901,
0.5923031568527222,
-0.19882766902446747,
0.3931620717048645,
-0.015757277607917786,
-0.03892834484577179,
-0.5671829581260681,
0.08672581613063812,
0.6192207336425781,
0.03161892294883728,
-0.3226737380027771,
-0.3319706916809082,
0.15381932258605957,
0.22744989395141602,
0.07423751056194305,
-0.5068175196647644,
-0.43142178654670715,
0.5523148775100708,
-0.4196864664554596,
-0.13571089506149292,
0.3133510649204254,
-0.20256957411766052,
-0.07796884328126907,
0.3085757791996002,
0.5251718163490295,
0.007600666955113411,
-0.943683385848999,
0.08179865032434464,
-0.08163794875144958,
0.38003304600715637,
0.31301993131637573,
-0.703751266002655,
0.6979743838310242,
0.7394759058952332,
0.8978416919708252,
-0.019665472209453583,
-0.3925511837005615,
-0.2923769950866699,
0.09368930011987686,
-0.7889551520347595,
0.5328702926635742,
-0.10054447501897812,
-0.20552663505077362,
0.0008955950033850968,
0.32024946808815,
-0.5124768018722534,
0.04161908105015755,
0.1965588629245758,
-0.6355549097061157,
-0.3330266773700714,
-0.34126731753349304,
-0.8381033539772034,
-0.03757968172430992,
0.08528050035238266,
-0.7514256834983826,
0.3788433074951172,
-0.2968559265136719,
-1.0716862678527832,
0.18150261044502258,
-0.6151471734046936,
-0.7985802292823792,
-0.05950881913304329,
0.2892320454120636,
-0.4767434597015381,
-0.0639822855591774,
-0.6073731780052185,
0.2983110547065735,
0.254628449678421,
-0.3206956088542938,
-0.40248969197273254,
-0.43545830249786377,
0.38448819518089294,
-0.24235080182552338,
0.5672258734703064,
0.23471865057945251,
-0.30668678879737854,
0.053066905587911606,
-0.6586117744445801,
0.55446857213974,
0.030770743265748024,
-0.3369766175746918,
0.07713045924901962,
0.14689332246780396,
0.06554500758647919,
0.30325552821159363,
-0.01780184544622898,
-0.9151985049247742,
0.08899126201868057,
-0.12145014852285385,
0.7925064563751221,
0.5929425954818726,
0.24555709958076477,
0.43995732069015503,
-0.7057821154594421,
0.3510913550853729,
0.06884612143039703,
0.5753472447395325,
-0.13157546520233154,
-0.6604112386703491,
-0.9479460120201111,
-0.03940929099917412,
-0.0369005911052227,
0.7527692317962646,
-0.6902264952659607,
-0.16590173542499542,
0.4282653033733368,
-0.6127506494522095,
0.024781977757811546,
-0.3821108639240265,
0.7004157900810242,
-0.11495823413133621,
-0.10245359688997269,
-0.5385540127754211,
-0.6190046072006226,
-0.8217294216156006,
0.3061608076095581,
-0.3665717840194702,
0.6642390489578247,
0.023847367614507675,
0.41536441445350647,
0.28073033690452576,
0.20768791437149048,
-0.2861526608467102,
0.07673700898885727,
0.10363655537366867,
0.015582692809402943,
0.4353412389755249,
0.7780966758728027,
0.07037032395601273,
-0.36804279685020447,
-0.3621250092983246,
-0.011621116660535336,
-0.9491381049156189,
0.09501286596059799,
0.03012710064649582,
-0.03213170915842056,
0.44926998019218445,
0.5784543752670288,
-0.6543950438499451,
0.6213351488113403,
0.6810362339019775,
-0.36536526679992676,
0.5715107917785645,
-0.4629838764667511,
0.34916943311691284,
-0.41592201590538025,
0.07369621098041534,
-0.5091158151626587,
-0.6135488152503967,
-1.1229727268218994,
0.18644872307777405,
-0.24797090888023376,
-0.25615549087524414,
-0.7160195708274841,
0.2825680077075958,
-0.49862053990364075,
-0.22859930992126465,
-0.4133239984512329,
-0.3342781364917755,
-0.020989056676626205,
0.12778499722480774,
0.34731388092041016,
0.4145844280719757,
1.0292658805847168,
-0.8739270567893982,
0.21967405080795288,
0.3134593069553375,
-0.37934473156929016,
0.3392387628555298,
-0.7462875247001648,
0.1677536517381668,
-0.256314754486084,
0.5373680591583252,
-1.182904839515686,
-0.32480907440185547,
0.559003472328186,
-0.2877822816371918,
-0.08401814103126526,
-0.24572376906871796,
-0.3803735375404358,
-0.2791283428668976,
0.3179382085800171,
0.34691449999809265,
0.2275158166885376,
-0.1795191466808319,
-0.20021383464336395,
0.29171305894851685,
0.3196537494659424,
-0.6277256608009338,
-0.5326347351074219,
-0.07617012411355972,
0.22263693809509277,
-0.8056879639625549,
-0.029142513871192932,
-0.14811301231384277,
-0.21577335894107819,
-0.09450995922088623,
-0.5938512086868286,
-0.43505680561065674,
0.3845105469226837,
0.7843574285507202,
-0.3354230523109436,
0.1972302496433258,
-0.1546413004398346,
0.07354404777288437,
-0.5541569590568542,
-0.11177632212638855,
-0.2516511082649231,
0.2811101973056793,
-0.12005547434091568,
-0.6887243390083313,
-1.0921260118484497,
1.1124794483184814,
0.5550813674926758,
0.15595389902591705,
0.7179105877876282,
-0.027785340324044228,
-0.3504953980445862,
-0.12317044287919998,
-0.3197433650493622,
-0.4594882130622864,
-0.4655277729034424,
-0.20070882141590118,
-0.42330360412597656,
-0.9354503154754639,
0.7907888889312744,
0.026953861117362976,
0.29219937324523926,
0.19403870403766632,
0.1972677856683731,
-0.15790005028247833,
0.5725379586219788,
0.7398067712783813,
0.25087183713912964,
0.05516938492655754,
-0.13873395323753357,
0.13505573570728302,
-0.05768746882677078,
-0.38238316774368286,
-0.4746427536010742,
-0.2579074800014496,
-0.8012245297431946,
-0.15313543379306793,
0.23863400518894196,
0.31378933787345886,
-0.38227006793022156,
0.5770929455757141,
-0.5634227991104126,
0.710343062877655,
0.6503934264183044,
-0.016459191218018532,
0.5526700615882874,
-0.39680415391921997,
-0.16304397583007812,
0.10922557860612869,
-0.7729732990264893,
-0.07924094051122665,
0.44908034801483154,
0.40925681591033936,
0.43267014622688293,
0.19624127447605133,
0.9049624800682068,
0.4514235556125641,
0.13452444970607758,
-0.5017892122268677,
0.6311981678009033,
0.04135965555906296,
-0.9640654921531677,
-0.39707696437835693,
-0.6261146068572998,
-0.9480346441268921,
0.21234942972660065,
-0.07895872741937637,
-0.7853574752807617,
0.3488391637802124,
0.40977969765663147,
0.043636906892061234,
0.6865200400352478,
-0.42332178354263306,
0.6132820844650269,
0.24599924683570862,
0.036873266100883484,
-0.08509452641010284,
-0.936485767364502,
0.4376732110977173,
0.4360974431037903,
0.17008677124977112,
-0.5207065939903259,
0.314010351896286,
0.7170815467834473,
-0.6863545775413513,
0.7912712693214417,
-0.14496485888957977,
0.25656014680862427,
0.16280536353588104,
0.5551679134368896,
0.5273547172546387,
0.1850549429655075,
0.05083281546831131,
0.18338952958583832,
0.5518909692764282,
-0.6724556088447571,
-0.11710327863693237,
0.3519727885723114,
-0.7582847476005554,
-0.48996448516845703,
-0.9108518362045288,
-0.13490043580532074,
0.05195373296737671,
0.3011905252933502,
0.3316749334335327,
0.21872200071811676,
0.08696182072162628,
-0.10058041661977768,
0.7084048986434937,
0.030918743461370468,
0.6357606649398804,
0.6053867936134338,
-0.05785422772169113,
-0.1403566151857376,
0.48268792033195496,
0.12716816365718842,
0.5935142040252686,
0.2860988676548004,
-0.3942536413669586,
0.13046111166477203,
-0.39290061593055725,
-0.1666385531425476,
-0.022628720849752426,
-0.707611083984375,
0.13621652126312256,
-0.6854928135871887,
-0.8018181324005127,
0.15721678733825684,
-0.10201124101877213,
-0.733276903629303,
-0.5514368414878845,
0.1921297311782837,
-0.03363320603966713,
0.3846057951450348,
0.7471429705619812,
-0.7564486861228943,
0.584845781326294,
-0.39345479011535645,
0.08313052356243134,
0.3087158799171448,
0.8167638182640076,
-0.11717924475669861,
-0.18877576291561127,
0.11710070073604584,
-0.22286485135555267,
-0.21637652814388275,
-1.078099012374878,
-0.25352802872657776,
-0.01779632642865181,
0.5944923162460327,
0.5891023874282837,
0.45324212312698364,
0.047978416085243225,
-0.4364323616027832,
0.2792271077632904,
0.27255791425704956,
-1.149796724319458,
0.3312641978263855,
-0.44553858041763306,
-0.2155461460351944,
0.4279381334781647,
0.21119143068790436,
-0.9268786311149597,
-0.3825892508029938,
-0.8044220209121704,
-0.7120437622070312,
0.7183724045753479,
0.6940367221832275,
0.05673380568623543,
-0.08133195340633392,
0.3384473919868469,
-0.15646690130233765,
0.028585121035575867,
-0.3474338948726654,
-0.481842577457428,
-0.13189776241779327,
0.9398301243782043,
0.13909630477428436,
-0.48307836055755615,
-0.3060155212879181,
0.34900566935539246,
0.7201409339904785,
0.36273446679115295,
0.7657591104507446,
0.4164126515388489,
0.4295175075531006,
-0.3582478165626526,
0.5631742477416992,
0.7687613368034363,
0.9625633358955383,
-0.44752413034439087,
0.24440670013427734,
-0.286287397146225,
-0.16455553472042084,
0.8324030041694641,
-0.22358284890651703,
-0.007399151101708412,
0.16454923152923584,
0.35891711711883545,
0.9722188115119934,
0.00759989395737648,
-0.169630765914917,
0.451261430978775,
-0.0799921378493309,
-0.8331736922264099,
-0.3583713471889496,
0.014417679980397224,
-0.33521583676338196,
0.3664471209049225,
0.1406577080488205,
0.14061854779720306,
0.08495365083217621,
-0.32206350564956665,
0.5000989437103271,
0.40438324213027954,
-0.3865412175655365,
-0.1132054328918457,
0.7396213412284851,
0.024871619418263435,
-0.21196508407592773,
0.42914220690727234,
-0.46661239862442017,
-0.13797646760940552,
0.9694885015487671,
0.7353060245513916,
0.6008069515228271,
-0.22008603811264038,
0.9255282878875732,
0.009680056013166904,
0.7359852194786072,
-0.47518211603164673,
0.7882643938064575,
-0.01956126093864441,
-0.5539020895957947,
-0.7691031098365784,
-0.10892592370510101,
-1.4528911113739014,
0.136217400431633,
-0.79999840259552,
-0.39503881335258484,
-0.8082283139228821,
-0.32068324089050293,
0.28198638558387756,
0.09653086215257645,
-0.2238321304321289,
0.19267749786376953,
-0.23060117661952972,
0.9869088530540466,
-1.2994881868362427,
0.5224814414978027,
0.7961287498474121,
0.39446184039115906,
-0.6644110083580017,
-0.09838203340768814,
-0.23755837976932526,
-0.5851471424102783,
0.25566232204437256,
0.2972930073738098,
0.23602212965488434,
-0.20343339443206787,
-0.2829243838787079,
-0.9744102358818054,
0.747143566608429,
0.22509275376796722,
-0.6049588918685913,
0.37449562549591064,
-0.10921967029571533,
0.17502379417419434,
0.3114917278289795,
0.07976756989955902,
0.1702669858932495,
0.6231423020362854,
0.8433803915977478,
-1.342520833015442,
0.18475186824798584,
-0.13771748542785645,
-0.03950958698987961,
0.46568337082862854,
-0.7240755558013916,
0.6606451869010925,
-0.1585180163383484,
-0.4279618263244629,
0.22466371953487396,
0.5322402715682983,
0.3707151412963867,
0.6736932396888733,
0.5453752875328064,
0.5679275989532471,
0.8264221549034119,
-0.2570808529853821,
0.9168187975883484,
-0.11803992837667465,
0.4123031497001648,
0.7078360319137573,
-0.1241060122847557,
0.49522024393081665,
0.4172780513763428,
-0.39551660418510437,
-0.1308564990758896,
0.7621589303016663,
0.421398401260376,
0.5081338882446289,
0.517761766910553,
-0.25770410895347595,
-0.5097944736480713,
-0.04293689504265785,
-0.6499934792518616,
0.30183592438697815,
0.038522448390722275,
-0.0029335760045796633,
-0.23274898529052734,
0.014422910287976265,
0.3621549904346466,
-0.23776954412460327,
-0.3430686593055725,
0.4595320522785187,
0.2040669173002243,
-0.613304078578949,
0.5928807258605957,
0.23344896733760834,
0.062164925038814545,
-0.41164153814315796,
0.2568793296813965,
-0.1372370421886444,
0.08305014669895172,
-0.32902389764785767,
-0.7216760516166687,
0.6744422912597656,
-0.8263341188430786,
-0.3755180835723877,
-0.14260107278823853,
0.5385368466377258,
-0.042131055146455765,
-0.08587558567523956,
0.2814125716686249,
0.25537797808647156,
0.4866081774234772,
0.330283522605896,
-0.03615041449666023,
0.32186436653137207,
-0.3646348714828491,
-0.07448286563158035,
0.09272237867116928,
-0.10376188158988953,
-0.14995095133781433,
0.8505762815475464,
0.5812888145446777,
0.2551657259464264,
0.4884880781173706,
-0.32885023951530457,
0.6186544895172119,
-0.17952589690685272,
-0.8373732566833496,
-0.6627563238143921,
0.02751215733587742,
-0.15302585065364838,
0.12062840163707733,
0.4992656111717224,
0.07267925143241882,
0.49172428250312805,
-0.017040841281414032,
0.9728923439979553,
-0.3426346480846405,
0.16203519701957703,
-0.4506128430366516,
0.5207300186157227,
-0.08982530236244202,
-0.10901904106140137,
-0.29719752073287964,
-0.6245549917221069,
-0.46525609493255615,
0.6231732368469238,
-0.08135686069726944,
-0.12579257786273956,
0.7680703401565552,
0.4128713011741638,
-0.02534068562090397,
0.45125246047973633,
0.4078473448753357,
0.026019854471087456,
0.09699811786413193,
1.0802154541015625,
0.8310720920562744,
-0.39810216426849365,
0.3098326027393341,
-0.42900875210762024,
-0.5677596926689148,
-0.15147197246551514,
-1.0273953676223755,
-0.8521103858947754,
-0.5891960859298706,
-0.5344902873039246,
-0.7746812105178833,
0.3659835159778595,
0.3212188482284546,
1.2571755647659302,
-0.9027600884437561,
-0.0671602189540863,
-0.1837039440870285,
0.5674464702606201,
-0.8815129995346069,
-0.12685716152191162,
0.45885351300239563,
0.03965764865279198,
-0.16242876648902893,
0.3697988986968994,
0.4328326880931854,
0.12069497257471085,
-0.1019941046833992,
0.09796811640262604,
-0.05317559093236923,
0.34977003931999207,
0.2178792506456375,
1.1374220848083496,
-0.235206738114357,
-0.25128066539764404,
-0.3539028465747833,
0.22542917728424072,
-0.18655601143836975,
0.9589551091194153,
0.007340347394347191,
0.2774043679237366,
0.7817370295524597,
0.2972227931022644,
0.5447049736976624,
-0.4101127088069916,
0.06686684489250183,
-0.6661798357963562,
0.4837245047092438,
-0.23048177361488342,
0.26128339767456055,
-0.22410941123962402,
-0.374820739030838,
0.1421290934085846,
0.3630516231060028,
-0.930483341217041,
-0.6381080746650696,
0.8680819869041443,
-1.1974998712539673,
0.019963394850492477,
0.7782027125358582,
-0.4340709149837494,
0.052516255527734756,
-0.6783691048622131,
0.4036543667316437,
0.007699085399508476,
-0.21375669538974762,
0.5987441539764404,
0.40381935238838196,
-0.2571200430393219,
-0.5885436534881592,
-0.7682717442512512,
0.549511730670929,
0.2670179009437561,
-0.609104573726654,
-0.15812765061855316,
0.00889577902853489,
0.6509882807731628,
0.1434636265039444,
1.3876136541366577,
-0.052734434604644775,
0.23627938330173492,
-0.1437249630689621,
-0.3146519660949707,
-0.4015580117702484,
-0.7963576316833496,
0.15888912975788116,
0.3609541654586792,
-0.12403396517038345,
-0.7096379399299622
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01317v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01317v1
|
Intelligent Learning Rate Distribution to reduce Catastrophic Forgetting in Transformers
| 2024-03-27T13:40:09 | 2024-03-27T13:40:09 |
Philip Kenneweg, Alexander Schulz, Sarah Schröder, Barbara Hammer
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Pretraining language models on large text corpora is a common practice in
natural language processing. Fine-tuning of these models is then performed to
achieve the best results on a variety of tasks. In this paper, we investigate
the problem of catastrophic forgetting in transformer neural networks and
question the common practice of fine-tuning with a flat learning rate for the
entire network in this context. We perform a hyperparameter optimization
process to find learning rate distributions that are better than a flat
learning rate. We combine the learning rate distributions thus found and show
that they generalize to better performance with respect to the problem of
catastrophic forgetting. We validate these learning rate distributions with a
variety of NLP benchmarks from the GLUE dataset.
|
[
-0.7477526664733887,
-0.4685382843017578,
0.13874541223049164,
0.20265783369541168,
-0.22873739898204803,
-0.10317890346050262,
-0.5023576021194458,
-0.05406881123781204,
0.09804915636777878,
0.33323240280151367,
-0.6630553007125854,
-0.27661004662513733,
-0.5193324685096741,
-0.029673300683498383,
-0.2733389437198639,
1.3453549146652222,
0.19359998404979706,
-0.09028547257184982,
-0.20079652965068817,
-0.15487030148506165,
-0.42569833993911743,
-0.4422403872013092,
-1.1150100231170654,
-0.5374327898025513,
0.4868236482143402,
0.2916492819786072,
0.6704808473587036,
0.6424545049667358,
0.7462823987007141,
0.24391375482082367,
-0.29053038358688354,
0.08223211020231247,
-0.841128945350647,
0.0025465998332947493,
-0.3369302451610565,
-0.7764474153518677,
-0.279086172580719,
-0.1074865311384201,
0.6124195456504822,
0.9000986814498901,
-0.4588817358016968,
0.06520159542560577,
0.05202775076031685,
0.902040421962738,
-0.8118083477020264,
0.15380333364009857,
-0.7727031707763672,
0.48067858815193176,
0.02326524443924427,
-0.6032404899597168,
-0.6326829791069031,
-0.4651089012622833,
0.13988417387008667,
-0.3467165529727936,
0.848627507686615,
-0.10393719375133514,
0.5968966484069824,
0.5562657713890076,
0.13441769778728485,
-0.24582602083683014,
-1.177412509918213,
0.8113775849342346,
-0.3193935751914978,
0.5080446600914001,
0.35332411527633667,
0.3409707844257355,
-0.1162305399775505,
-0.5781563520431519,
-0.452962189912796,
-0.1001172736287117,
0.13690254092216492,
0.28349876403808594,
-0.26306504011154175,
0.04370721057057381,
0.25669029355049133,
0.3797851502895355,
-0.5141187310218811,
0.28679683804512024,
-0.3314739465713501,
-0.08920162171125412,
0.41552504897117615,
0.2811865508556366,
-0.20923304557800293,
0.13670770823955536,
-0.2957841753959656,
-0.4857786297798157,
-0.4536481201648712,
0.030436456203460693,
0.6565085649490356,
0.22382302582263947,
0.24227924644947052,
0.17986023426055908,
-0.04810450226068497,
0.3626137971878052,
0.017528759315609932,
-0.0861491709947586,
0.3234088122844696,
-0.016910186037421227,
-0.041892457753419876,
0.013555135577917099,
0.6550790667533875,
0.2734382152557373,
0.7944294214248657,
-0.2726605534553528,
-0.4205997884273529,
0.061492711305618286,
0.7494263648986816,
-0.4581889510154724,
-0.5397968888282776,
0.035323768854141235,
-0.1976676732301712,
-0.041176971048116684,
-0.30999401211738586,
-0.4115656614303589,
0.020832831040024757,
-0.2807241976261139,
0.35876092314720154,
-0.5865873694419861,
-0.22164137661457062,
0.23671430349349976,
-0.2274838089942932,
-0.15896442532539368,
0.07325606048107147,
-1.2974507808685303,
0.28545841574668884,
0.4183446168899536,
0.4849361181259155,
-0.008289337158203125,
-0.5225054621696472,
-0.34366023540496826,
0.027151329442858696,
-0.4023008644580841,
1.1221418380737305,
-0.0659380853176117,
-0.085518479347229,
-0.07417970150709152,
-0.16402530670166016,
-0.5247099995613098,
-0.8816304802894592,
0.7094164490699768,
-0.5099606513977051,
-0.039900388568639755,
0.09794675558805466,
-0.6547555923461914,
-0.099612757563591,
0.05262884125113487,
-0.7083775997161865,
0.8764829039573669,
0.03769444674253464,
-0.8129780888557434,
0.5698248147964478,
-0.6029691696166992,
-0.4800201654434204,
0.07264149188995361,
0.4968718886375427,
-0.8150913119316101,
0.19207169115543365,
0.12983159720897675,
0.7303709387779236,
-0.1430038958787918,
0.43807315826416016,
-0.16356587409973145,
-0.5655632019042969,
-0.19405575096607208,
-0.8501420021057129,
0.44760721921920776,
0.2612423002719879,
-0.19680467247962952,
-0.0943012684583664,
-0.7606809735298157,
-0.20210257172584534,
0.011651537381112576,
-0.4158879816532135,
-0.419318288564682,
0.27306875586509705,
0.23680554330348969,
-0.027998819947242737,
-0.12963570654392242,
-0.30489566922187805,
0.24040257930755615,
-0.6191901564598083,
0.4844520688056946,
0.7328929901123047,
0.28715458512306213,
0.41650626063346863,
-0.26519477367401123,
0.10918379575014114,
0.41299644112586975,
0.5146642923355103,
-0.000474821834359318,
-0.2738916575908661,
-0.9864899516105652,
-0.041965797543525696,
0.05117090046405792,
0.44503262639045715,
-0.5805513262748718,
0.4722350537776947,
-0.27619826793670654,
-0.7416282892227173,
-0.6173737049102783,
0.19586776196956635,
0.2917861342430115,
0.6733805537223816,
0.8295188546180725,
-0.2561049163341522,
-0.20788231492042542,
-0.95084547996521,
-0.29981401562690735,
-0.07661911845207214,
-0.19615325331687927,
-0.07736724615097046,
0.5087977051734924,
-0.25372403860092163,
0.8731392621994019,
-0.7112929224967957,
-0.5124607682228088,
-0.3555833399295807,
0.2016959935426712,
0.318058580160141,
0.5100730657577515,
0.37462082505226135,
-0.934043288230896,
-0.23670852184295654,
-0.2730204164981842,
-0.4879143536090851,
0.2996169924736023,
-0.18984070420265198,
0.08665727078914642,
0.37908855080604553,
0.5930218696594238,
-0.5910749435424805,
0.27458813786506653,
0.3956516981124878,
0.05843391641974449,
0.5261234641075134,
-0.4620613157749176,
-0.3046528697013855,
-0.984047532081604,
0.018063567578792572,
0.2143300324678421,
-0.03957899659872055,
-0.4903673827648163,
-0.2407977432012558,
0.12706275284290314,
0.09013097733259201,
-0.5892184376716614,
0.09633968770503998,
-0.12219414860010147,
0.22535119950771332,
-0.1221686527132988,
0.03844263032078743,
-0.33517953753471375,
0.7550394535064697,
-0.0760277584195137,
0.7886528372764587,
0.4502336084842682,
-0.8265213966369629,
0.23597906529903412,
0.30673569440841675,
-0.14195242524147034,
0.44578519463539124,
-0.6309463381767273,
-0.09680140763521194,
-0.518842875957489,
0.1389709860086441,
-0.7146905064582825,
-0.004009043797850609,
-0.11975093185901642,
-0.03278727829456329,
0.1981147676706314,
-0.06478285789489746,
-0.5327799320220947,
-0.6275903582572937,
-0.024644147604703903,
0.1527010053396225,
0.6613191366195679,
-0.5002021789550781,
0.2730168402194977,
0.29542893171310425,
0.12658394873142242,
-0.6852917075157166,
-0.32445627450942993,
-0.25752177834510803,
-0.21208687126636505,
-0.3625144958496094,
0.22776354849338531,
-0.11824274063110352,
0.32579416036605835,
0.00463308347389102,
-0.009997603483498096,
-0.08944918215274811,
0.10445407778024673,
0.08194468915462494,
-0.15142887830734253,
-0.3257486820220947,
0.3111420273780823,
-0.07337349653244019,
-0.5831895470619202,
-0.0366368405520916,
-0.4376477897167206,
0.841497540473938,
-0.20921364426612854,
-0.3338502049446106,
-0.4663780629634857,
0.13041876256465912,
0.5812541842460632,
-0.16132424771785736,
1.012647032737732,
0.6578218936920166,
-0.3073529601097107,
-0.345845103263855,
-0.6367365717887878,
-0.3226016163825989,
-0.48112747073173523,
0.4732741415500641,
-0.15183575451374054,
-0.6365805864334106,
0.6592486500740051,
-0.22901414334774017,
-0.0276934914290905,
0.6439868807792664,
0.6316559314727783,
-0.23143112659454346,
0.8434680700302124,
1.0479449033737183,
-0.3528596758842468,
0.3414171636104584,
-0.4783882200717926,
0.3448580503463745,
-0.5404499769210815,
-0.24346470832824707,
-0.4072956144809723,
-0.21632955968379974,
-0.5481409430503845,
-0.1334981620311737,
0.46021413803100586,
0.23716314136981964,
-0.1358543187379837,
0.5858612060546875,
-0.4399430453777313,
0.6071821451187134,
0.8513535857200623,
0.05493941530585289,
0.3424938917160034,
-0.10009472072124481,
-0.13822627067565918,
0.1414351612329483,
-0.8998174071311951,
-0.2843392789363861,
0.841912031173706,
0.33915993571281433,
0.6631836891174316,
-0.45818784832954407,
0.6060551404953003,
0.012488974258303642,
0.18670712411403656,
-0.7415511012077332,
0.2898896336555481,
-0.33979955315589905,
-0.34336698055267334,
-0.41666850447654724,
-0.5340359807014465,
-1.0843766927719116,
-0.3039136230945587,
-0.25756093859672546,
-0.39771029353141785,
0.016898851841688156,
0.48902666568756104,
-0.22752490639686584,
0.5382667183876038,
-0.671658456325531,
0.8320276141166687,
0.34848928451538086,
0.32131272554397583,
-0.27825281023979187,
-0.5362163782119751,
0.1983460932970047,
-0.3750911355018616,
-0.22474996745586395,
-0.07100240886211395,
0.4337623715400696,
0.7124565839767456,
-0.1561029553413391,
0.5574193596839905,
-0.12261451035737991,
0.3188704550266266,
0.27000632882118225,
-0.3367530405521393,
0.4637894034385681,
-0.024502037093043327,
-0.20198267698287964,
0.0638081431388855,
-0.4497750699520111,
-0.3980194926261902,
-0.5427412390708923,
0.41642990708351135,
-0.9268366098403931,
-0.15947464108467102,
-0.01375091914087534,
-0.7187252640724182,
-0.23100246489048004,
-0.0036062144208699465,
0.6803827881813049,
0.4067637622356415,
-0.07757693529129028,
0.36436572670936584,
1.040647029876709,
-0.09042800962924957,
0.835739254951477,
0.13582783937454224,
0.38314172625541687,
-0.13645634055137634,
1.070094108581543,
0.37826696038246155,
0.5318090319633484,
0.3634859025478363,
0.057968445122241974,
-0.22711268067359924,
-0.6502410173416138,
-0.20943887531757355,
0.1285790055990219,
-0.7527301907539368,
-0.2848237454891205,
-0.9343801736831665,
-0.44237610697746277,
-0.17357797920703888,
-0.298130601644516,
-0.7862286567687988,
-0.36380791664123535,
-0.22208423912525177,
-0.11395440995693207,
0.48752105236053467,
0.4730820655822754,
0.10121718794107437,
0.555669903755188,
-0.7591353058815002,
0.29034942388534546,
0.15197139978408813,
0.5632641911506653,
0.165483757853508,
-0.3194526433944702,
-0.3943670988082886,
-0.1308019906282425,
-0.5285520553588867,
-0.23172704875469208,
0.319815069437027,
0.5202423930168152,
0.7039609551429749,
0.4392511546611786,
0.24650982022285461,
0.46742281317710876,
-0.7600783109664917,
0.46583274006843567,
0.31373414397239685,
-0.40263572335243225,
0.4753577709197998,
-0.21427567303180695,
0.5713708996772766,
0.6236915588378906,
0.8606303334236145,
-0.5877236127853394,
-0.7167174816131592,
-0.7560867667198181,
-1.0238763093948364,
0.46495357155799866,
0.1369308978319168,
0.36015641689300537,
-0.15949276089668274,
0.25339359045028687,
0.03999660909175873,
-0.08643069118261337,
-0.37909629940986633,
-0.6118212938308716,
-0.022585619240999222,
-0.19230113923549652,
-0.5108153820037842,
-0.016345620155334473,
-0.05404238402843475,
-0.35908225178718567,
0.570231020450592,
-0.18630382418632507,
0.2816186249256134,
-0.03613279387354851,
-0.14396539330482483,
-0.21221515536308289,
0.02780691720545292,
0.5489173531532288,
0.6114897131919861,
-0.16512806713581085,
-0.08345823734998703,
0.4353272616863251,
-0.9962815642356873,
0.20158889889717102,
-0.10688500851392746,
-0.206854447722435,
-0.09818623960018158,
0.13904716074466705,
1.0040650367736816,
0.39959716796875,
-0.4167580306529999,
0.44316229224205017,
-0.254431813955307,
-0.13227081298828125,
-0.4906042814254761,
0.44391492009162903,
0.4359114468097687,
0.030446957796812057,
0.7014057636260986,
0.8455246090888977,
-0.06550312787294388,
-0.27237609028816223,
0.49986299872398376,
0.15206082165241241,
-0.5974949598312378,
-0.2618802487850189,
0.6150059700012207,
-0.0797484889626503,
-0.6526844501495361,
1.121390700340271,
-0.023422585800290108,
-0.6741206049919128,
0.5939255952835083,
0.6476117968559265,
0.9920207262039185,
-0.23517318069934845,
0.3873874843120575,
0.3219928741455078,
0.46870577335357666,
-0.4970129728317261,
-0.1450267732143402,
0.249110147356987,
-0.6130311489105225,
-0.5016129612922668,
-0.9402479529380798,
-0.3659449517726898,
0.05960814282298088,
-0.7187635898590088,
0.5037641525268555,
-0.3476323187351227,
-0.20433004200458527,
0.17079764604568481,
-0.31782761216163635,
-0.9340749979019165,
0.49425995349884033,
0.0720338374376297,
1.0528823137283325,
-0.9796628355979919,
0.6671795845031738,
0.292791485786438,
-0.36109960079193115,
-0.9144241809844971,
-0.05641109496355057,
-0.3719704747200012,
-0.5191982984542847,
0.5582612156867981,
0.08875793218612671,
0.022552741691470146,
0.2958785891532898,
-0.2925723195075989,
-0.6606737375259399,
0.7247982621192932,
0.43100425601005554,
-0.4368989169597626,
-0.09440959244966507,
0.3149169683456421,
0.8122010827064514,
-0.06236056983470917,
0.4554579257965088,
0.6337419748306274,
0.11480404436588287,
0.03804730251431465,
-0.8891521096229553,
-0.45607349276542664,
-0.12911146879196167,
-0.015625685453414917,
0.6659904718399048,
-0.5369935631752014,
0.8816643357276917,
-0.21597518026828766,
0.017866458743810654,
-0.46606358885765076,
0.6193915605545044,
-0.09554368257522583,
0.43298664689064026,
0.463208943605423,
0.7563800811767578,
0.6276824474334717,
-0.010490701533854008,
0.9935900568962097,
-0.020468123257160187,
0.7039515376091003,
0.6646050214767456,
0.2141714096069336,
0.9663490653038025,
0.5629316568374634,
-0.06559517234563828,
0.1713184118270874,
0.37943747639656067,
-0.05627148598432541,
0.55829918384552,
0.218131422996521,
-0.2565251886844635,
-0.17473599314689636,
0.07240433990955353,
-0.17607346177101135,
0.2711294889450073,
0.24287626147270203,
-0.17910686135292053,
-0.5084953308105469,
0.3734501004219055,
-0.05922131612896919,
0.08603602647781372,
-0.3201406002044678,
0.7433009147644043,
0.05253532528877258,
-0.6720976233482361,
0.941339910030365,
-0.3622592091560364,
0.5464181303977966,
-0.5182185173034668,
0.16397173702716827,
-0.4396775960922241,
0.6390735507011414,
-0.1270068734884262,
-0.6626819372177124,
0.4399261474609375,
-0.35809338092803955,
-0.6428027749061584,
-0.2240048050880432,
0.3578082323074341,
-0.3585842251777649,
-0.36628103256225586,
0.2557950019836426,
0.11367927491664886,
0.17873631417751312,
-0.07857779413461685,
-0.5460915565490723,
-0.29148387908935547,
-0.21871249377727509,
-0.6197392344474792,
0.4414099454879761,
0.41114768385887146,
-0.02437361143529415,
1.177419900894165,
0.6914624571800232,
0.02883954904973507,
0.23947210609912872,
0.17521612346172333,
0.851285457611084,
-0.5355246663093567,
-0.40549036860466003,
-0.7118333578109741,
0.36453893780708313,
0.10766101628541946,
-0.7842779755592346,
0.4346216917037964,
0.38098952174186707,
1.0909569263458252,
-0.5046809315681458,
0.3710664212703705,
0.3465915024280548,
0.37268587946891785,
-0.4131040871143341,
0.9857773780822754,
-0.1737273782491684,
-0.025516627356410027,
-0.34662044048309326,
-1.4877198934555054,
-0.5268443822860718,
0.48469701409339905,
-0.08425124734640121,
-0.19201041758060455,
0.8372132182121277,
0.6455168128013611,
-0.2588576376438141,
0.16846910119056702,
0.4013702869415283,
0.0293546412140131,
0.250099241733551,
0.8138119578361511,
0.604616105556488,
-0.6576038599014282,
0.6877775192260742,
-0.6503029465675354,
0.025007573887705803,
-0.23080652952194214,
-0.9045304656028748,
-0.7825402617454529,
-0.6625111699104309,
-0.26039770245552063,
0.03667984530329704,
0.14716477692127228,
0.8279973864555359,
0.5119505524635315,
-0.7242153286933899,
0.005516843870282173,
-0.34362319111824036,
-0.09259569644927979,
-0.5515700578689575,
-0.2326653152704239,
0.41126731038093567,
-0.9366593956947327,
-0.7393544316291809,
0.12224655598402023,
0.3228069245815277,
-0.03294885903596878,
-0.17852893471717834,
0.09512779861688614,
-0.1727788746356964,
-0.11809755861759186,
0.3600936830043793,
0.29676899313926697,
-0.059614427387714386,
-0.4341297149658203,
-0.028523007407784462,
-0.18611954152584076,
0.08028290420770645,
0.6041850447654724,
-0.8447559475898743,
0.10483063757419586,
0.26205700635910034,
0.7211784720420837,
0.5567647814750671,
-0.19934408366680145,
0.46901366114616394,
-0.6113559603691101,
0.33947834372520447,
0.6450124979019165,
0.13544099032878876,
0.21896527707576752,
-0.3072933852672577,
0.37644898891448975,
0.279306024312973,
-0.8468289375305176,
-0.8078117370605469,
0.03657568618655205,
-0.7125246524810791,
0.10776596516370773,
0.7009157538414001,
-0.10041607171297073,
-0.24132144451141357,
-0.35582149028778076,
0.07385031133890152,
0.32905301451683044,
-0.0353313572704792,
0.9605332612991333,
0.4436227083206177,
-0.003658033674582839,
0.030508989468216896,
-0.6085556149482727,
0.6612975597381592,
0.659067690372467,
-0.47733718156814575,
0.0012186173116788268,
-0.0010300717549398541,
0.31950777769088745,
0.476010262966156,
0.4040584862232208,
0.29060930013656616,
0.15385130047798157,
-0.10842708498239517,
0.14081287384033203,
0.22404877841472626,
-0.8172033429145813,
-0.10142481327056885,
0.3922901749610901,
-0.18546345829963684,
0.10217417031526566
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18555v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18555v1
|
Debiasing Sentence Embedders through Contrastive Word Pairs
| 2024-03-27T13:34:59 | 2024-03-27T13:34:59 |
Philip Kenneweg, Sarah Schröder, Alexander Schulz, Barbara Hammer
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Over the last years, various sentence embedders have been an integral part in
the success of current machine learning approaches to Natural Language
Processing (NLP). Unfortunately, multiple sources have shown that the bias,
inherent in the datasets upon which these embedding methods are trained, is
learned by them. A variety of different approaches to remove biases in
embeddings exists in the literature. Most of these approaches are applicable to
word embeddings and in fewer cases to sentence embeddings. It is problematic
that most debiasing approaches are directly transferred from word embeddings,
therefore these approaches fail to take into account the nonlinear nature of
sentence embedders and the embeddings they produce. It has been shown in
literature that bias information is still present if sentence embeddings are
debiased using such methods. In this contribution, we explore an approach to
remove linear and nonlinear bias information for NLP solutions, without
impacting downstream performance. We compare our approach to common debiasing
methods on classical bias metrics and on bias metrics which take nonlinear
information into account.
|
[
-0.4408121109008789,
-0.8594428896903992,
0.5436351299285889,
0.3123384118080139,
-0.31383728981018066,
-0.12681730091571808,
-0.08269623667001724,
-0.42982128262519836,
0.3495849668979645,
0.43072688579559326,
-0.3872934579849243,
-0.22941826283931732,
-0.8588982820510864,
0.019018733873963356,
-0.1237834095954895,
1.3596402406692505,
-0.0852874368429184,
0.4474710524082184,
-0.5585029721260071,
-0.4804651141166687,
-0.36629053950309753,
-0.4710873067378998,
-0.4059247672557831,
-0.6686481237411499,
0.05920126289129257,
-0.12548279762268066,
1.0533968210220337,
0.46896734833717346,
0.39657703042030334,
0.23461684584617615,
-0.23952187597751617,
-0.14700496196746826,
-0.3747301399707794,
0.4085220694541931,
-0.2369341105222702,
-0.4903542101383209,
-0.015588664449751377,
0.21160046756267548,
0.3263654112815857,
0.9860038757324219,
0.2884378433227539,
-0.09939812123775482,
0.4009788930416107,
0.8036978244781494,
-0.7169639468193054,
0.05643150955438614,
-0.7852073907852173,
0.6523979902267456,
0.1217140480875969,
-0.15036408603191376,
-0.31284138560295105,
-0.36262258887290955,
0.5037658214569092,
-0.4898071885108948,
0.2448662966489792,
-0.061938609927892685,
0.8025082945823669,
0.5141908526420593,
-0.35460957884788513,
-0.6622533798217773,
-0.6200683116912842,
1.1874122619628906,
-0.8184075951576233,
0.19620545208454132,
0.5074142217636108,
-0.36566269397735596,
-0.029224185273051262,
-0.2478569895029068,
-0.459928423166275,
-0.051644064486026764,
-0.30498117208480835,
0.11980239301919937,
-0.4276094436645508,
0.0031256761867552996,
0.18918578326702118,
0.1717490553855896,
-0.4078580141067505,
0.20866484940052032,
-0.09777654707431793,
-0.027387183159589767,
0.32824191451072693,
-0.0857614055275917,
-0.019629592075943947,
-0.502194881439209,
-0.6235896944999695,
0.11719995737075806,
-0.461833119392395,
-0.15611736476421356,
0.4994841516017914,
0.0703296884894371,
-0.06921442598104477,
0.5103880167007446,
0.13791529834270477,
0.38878577947616577,
0.3010062575340271,
0.13530759513378143,
0.5928587913513184,
-0.23806503415107727,
-0.2670045495033264,
-0.07645872980356216,
0.7845067977905273,
0.5953763127326965,
0.18931978940963745,
-0.5381990075111389,
-0.29891183972358704,
0.3291531503200531,
0.2326773703098297,
-0.49684563279151917,
-0.2871519923210144,
0.23602259159088135,
-0.6224872469902039,
-0.5256412625312805,
-0.010139891877770424,
-1.2837642431259155,
-0.6501048803329468,
-0.3271595239639282,
0.4760741591453552,
-0.23537114262580872,
0.20223556458950043,
-0.054192837327718735,
-0.34233638644218445,
0.18728496134281158,
-0.11012139916419983,
-0.6911671161651611,
0.513757050037384,
0.5989930033683777,
0.7920851111412048,
-0.12345638871192932,
0.22860942780971527,
-0.8886520862579346,
-0.26459991931915283,
-0.13916133344173431,
0.37812134623527527,
-0.7954884171485901,
-0.3277314007282257,
0.17100532352924347,
-0.49121206998825073,
0.3050630986690521,
-0.7507695555686951,
0.7261677980422974,
-0.36295315623283386,
0.7488798499107361,
-0.3613172173500061,
-0.6743577718734741,
-0.24209485948085785,
0.05924699455499649,
-0.6133432984352112,
0.8450139164924622,
-0.20537814497947693,
-1.295472264289856,
0.4348800480365753,
-0.3004092574119568,
-0.33964836597442627,
-0.35168391466140747,
-0.33669736981391907,
-0.5482178926467896,
0.3103569746017456,
0.6481443047523499,
0.31518107652664185,
-0.1411442756652832,
0.2716847062110901,
-0.667906641960144,
-0.3890191316604614,
0.04669364169239998,
-0.45894190669059753,
0.940543532371521,
0.09626653045415878,
-0.8013940453529358,
-0.284500390291214,
-0.6057732701301575,
-0.16297072172164917,
-0.04823026433587074,
-0.08970925211906433,
-0.916139543056488,
0.09010421484708786,
0.06911326199769974,
0.3856932520866394,
0.021877840161323547,
-0.5601058006286621,
0.03127400949597359,
-0.6005838513374329,
0.42062628269195557,
1.0802874565124512,
-0.07870078086853027,
0.6571944355964661,
-0.11604905128479004,
0.41432297229766846,
0.4733344316482544,
-0.1755095273256302,
0.2423343062400818,
-0.2494952380657196,
-1.0914815664291382,
-0.130925253033638,
0.3286386728286743,
0.6917722821235657,
-0.9351168274879456,
0.6983451247215271,
0.006893443409353495,
-0.0621316060423851,
-0.7251453995704651,
0.37312355637550354,
0.5689451694488525,
0.42827901244163513,
0.6000327467918396,
-0.23041656613349915,
-0.7570233345031738,
-1.0889825820922852,
-0.6956844925880432,
0.3054586350917816,
-0.18853411078453064,
0.3200201392173767,
0.5077263116836548,
-0.17076465487480164,
0.8729650974273682,
-0.6851664781570435,
-0.3297315537929535,
0.08940308541059494,
0.3052491545677185,
0.2517663240432739,
0.5667450428009033,
0.6820316910743713,
-0.7893472909927368,
-0.2683286964893341,
-0.6040204167366028,
-0.8950844407081604,
-0.24589510262012482,
-0.2220870405435562,
-0.028874073177576065,
0.23636215925216675,
0.6282564401626587,
-0.40244823694229126,
0.4650530219078064,
0.595975935459137,
-0.46254122257232666,
0.16009686887264252,
-0.2306116372346878,
-0.2210930734872818,
-1.0983655452728271,
-0.08529634028673172,
0.3619142770767212,
-0.36210453510284424,
-0.43075162172317505,
-0.06857409328222275,
-0.4396435022354126,
0.2966899871826172,
-0.06962089240550995,
0.37077996134757996,
-0.521594762802124,
-0.08370669186115265,
-0.1356794238090515,
0.7546594142913818,
0.26961711049079895,
0.40587347745895386,
-0.1677454262971878,
0.44630569219589233,
0.45274466276168823,
-0.5231698751449585,
0.269907683134079,
0.39733386039733887,
-0.03628241643309593,
0.7348669767379761,
-0.8229694366455078,
0.36362478137016296,
-0.4949325621128082,
0.38979077339172363,
-0.8272185325622559,
0.6072961688041687,
0.535341739654541,
-0.1898551732301712,
-0.068613201379776,
0.07686980068683624,
-0.18757177889347076,
-0.11480506509542465,
-0.7759113907814026,
0.2028268724679947,
0.5083032846450806,
-0.6520042419433594,
0.006544260308146477,
0.4286315441131592,
-0.17428801953792572,
-0.8656383752822876,
-0.9534462690353394,
-0.16266180574893951,
-0.4096468687057495,
-0.007091359701007605,
0.6398608088493347,
0.15808917582035065,
-0.5200415253639221,
0.3700609505176544,
-0.3112156391143799,
-0.19239550828933716,
-0.00659134378656745,
0.2633931040763855,
0.28371602296829224,
0.04544726386666298,
0.3912903964519501,
0.04843226820230484,
-0.21491456031799316,
0.16891886293888092,
-0.47744593024253845,
0.5939624905586243,
0.08626206964254379,
-0.04979712516069412,
-0.3740623891353607,
0.4139109253883362,
0.2878556549549103,
-0.03276560455560684,
0.8985557556152344,
0.9495152831077576,
-0.4304557144641876,
-0.1278049647808075,
-0.49587324261665344,
-0.2290271818637848,
-0.3972732722759247,
0.252180814743042,
-0.20262011885643005,
-0.6394985914230347,
0.3078670799732208,
0.192888543009758,
0.08588803559541702,
0.38854631781578064,
0.3344229459762573,
-0.14288100600242615,
0.8858680725097656,
0.4678398668766022,
-0.5340681672096252,
0.4572227895259857,
-0.1631743609905243,
0.42463579773902893,
-0.8688151240348816,
0.035594791173934937,
-0.6754372119903564,
-0.6639837026596069,
-0.827397346496582,
-0.3824111521244049,
0.06442137807607651,
0.261272132396698,
-0.021733149886131287,
0.1845831274986267,
-0.2819855809211731,
0.3161585330963135,
0.6418458819389343,
0.41111987829208374,
0.11163737624883652,
-0.01407252810895443,
-0.3336316645145416,
-0.40443816781044006,
-0.39324939250946045,
-0.49206432700157166,
1.2675102949142456,
0.18751074373722076,
0.47052767872810364,
-0.09921514987945557,
0.7906929850578308,
0.4224341809749603,
-0.33322766423225403,
-0.5843414068222046,
0.2570193111896515,
-0.4749723970890045,
-0.2640056908130646,
0.15845763683319092,
-0.6799523830413818,
-0.7398489117622375,
0.5854617953300476,
-0.6034463047981262,
-0.5788695216178894,
0.2812312841415405,
0.06307017803192139,
-0.028676865622401237,
0.4834645688533783,
-0.40713927149772644,
0.5318246483802795,
0.12249338626861572,
-0.5855445861816406,
-0.37234896421432495,
-0.4862561821937561,
-0.06367645412683487,
0.15111111104488373,
0.2437327802181244,
0.185801163315773,
-0.12706241011619568,
0.8722546696662903,
-0.13611753284931183,
0.7644039392471313,
-0.4815653860569,
-0.08164432644844055,
-0.10338283330202103,
0.09390894323587418,
0.4958779215812683,
0.18327605724334717,
-0.2895738184452057,
0.12325625121593475,
-0.24062685668468475,
-0.5653255581855774,
-0.6345676779747009,
0.8958402872085571,
-0.6636751294136047,
-0.41311922669410706,
-0.47071462869644165,
-0.4908125102519989,
-0.41832056641578674,
-0.008758594281971455,
0.28559720516204834,
0.4884064793586731,
-0.15771901607513428,
0.41242241859436035,
0.42917847633361816,
-0.46964582800865173,
0.6203486323356628,
-0.10213277488946915,
-0.12535502016544342,
-0.5315312743186951,
0.36256566643714905,
-0.04349152743816376,
0.1160460039973259,
0.4005739092826843,
0.24802294373512268,
-0.1984783560037613,
-0.4531348645687103,
0.033515799790620804,
-0.02225956879556179,
-0.6206235885620117,
-0.01459595188498497,
-0.7308008670806885,
0.1306580752134323,
-0.3695405423641205,
-0.2723428010940552,
-0.10221774876117706,
-0.48858797550201416,
-0.39999502897262573,
-0.22865507006645203,
0.09484732151031494,
0.5330314636230469,
0.05981246381998062,
-0.04380561038851738,
-0.6393370628356934,
0.6202026605606079,
0.10611744970083237,
0.1733676791191101,
-0.17727826535701752,
-0.3925548791885376,
0.016936590895056725,
0.26515689492225647,
-0.5209930539131165,
-0.7701129913330078,
0.46817952394485474,
0.14457003772258759,
0.5056294202804565,
0.3798638582229614,
0.29622817039489746,
0.6197218298912048,
-0.35212603211402893,
0.9403993487358093,
0.14665406942367554,
-1.3848766088485718,
0.47741031646728516,
0.05027252435684204,
0.11214466392993927,
0.6982115507125854,
0.6802020072937012,
-0.37960293889045715,
-0.43219202756881714,
-0.6645772457122803,
-0.98183274269104,
0.35099220275878906,
0.29878130555152893,
0.23320820927619934,
0.031705811619758606,
0.3742154836654663,
0.3825961947441101,
0.5419984459877014,
-0.9490914940834045,
-0.31193435192108154,
-0.11119389533996582,
-0.2976633906364441,
-0.31832051277160645,
-0.19885292649269104,
-0.045215122401714325,
-0.12395341694355011,
0.5570265054702759,
0.12764769792556763,
0.23510538041591644,
0.396065890789032,
-0.3937743306159973,
0.20554471015930176,
0.33875757455825806,
0.29243165254592896,
0.3365088701248169,
-0.20077410340309143,
0.32763203978538513,
0.16809435188770294,
-0.3792051672935486,
-0.05854643136262894,
-0.16580936312675476,
-0.6458509564399719,
0.38799986243247986,
0.39833641052246094,
0.9134278297424316,
0.23879864811897278,
-0.3289295732975006,
0.6669989228248596,
0.3160995543003082,
-0.1392725557088852,
-0.12689805030822754,
-0.34409812092781067,
-0.21803569793701172,
0.3595034182071686,
-0.03691257908940315,
0.5168499946594238,
0.3544785976409912,
-0.4406498968601227,
0.31995293498039246,
0.5845451951026917,
-0.9517312049865723,
-0.24786067008972168,
0.49340978264808655,
0.47548338770866394,
-0.10072024166584015,
0.6415103077888489,
-0.1414729803800583,
-0.7374440431594849,
0.31522756814956665,
0.5057908296585083,
1.1547802686691284,
0.21369527280330658,
0.2395494431257248,
0.24672217667102814,
0.08663570135831833,
0.17841389775276184,
-0.027640726417303085,
-0.026238977909088135,
-0.8680527806282043,
-0.13340623676776886,
-0.4848986268043518,
-0.30664893984794617,
0.2236945927143097,
-0.9731453061103821,
0.08904796093702316,
-0.5078966021537781,
-0.28483274579048157,
0.033157121390104294,
0.13790684938430786,
-0.7849051356315613,
0.015417595393955708,
0.1264636218547821,
0.3304494619369507,
-1.0063657760620117,
0.5679191946983337,
0.5328491926193237,
-0.4462209641933441,
0.07108309864997864,
0.5252457857131958,
0.06454826891422272,
-0.3452332317829132,
0.7912904024124146,
0.26642322540283203,
-0.17425155639648438,
-0.44781166315078735,
-0.22100691497325897,
-0.31698015332221985,
0.5958379507064819,
0.33409419655799866,
-0.40380996465682983,
-0.1363866925239563,
-0.02692292630672455,
0.4870544373989105,
-0.2702898383140564,
0.26662805676460266,
0.36459285020828247,
0.3350462317466736,
-0.48033836483955383,
-0.7204293608665466,
0.01090134959667921,
-0.18328805267810822,
0.08406084775924683,
-0.02342843823134899,
-0.2394896000623703,
0.8886783719062805,
0.10196110606193542,
-0.02893109619617462,
-0.20966428518295288,
0.4182751774787903,
-0.15055769681930542,
0.22480057179927826,
0.7295421957969666,
0.7925837635993958,
0.6766587495803833,
-0.04466468095779419,
0.6930321455001831,
-0.08948194235563278,
0.5562230944633484,
1.2126535177230835,
-0.4118308126926422,
0.8545436263084412,
1.030070424079895,
-0.3537566363811493,
0.7137928009033203,
0.13166889548301697,
-0.11601153761148453,
0.7378417253494263,
0.4541023075580597,
-0.03522513434290886,
0.01768617331981659,
-0.018428204581141472,
-0.2516752779483795,
0.5738710761070251,
-0.003722942667081952,
-0.6631932258605957,
-0.2471512109041214,
0.1625419706106186,
0.43087291717529297,
0.609626829624176,
-0.02787892520427704,
0.7216097712516785,
0.15373533964157104,
-0.5414825081825256,
0.35045260190963745,
-0.06647375971078873,
1.2436115741729736,
-0.2185843139886856,
0.050359271466732025,
-0.24407163262367249,
0.5420587658882141,
-0.28003668785095215,
-0.46696504950523376,
0.646841824054718,
0.04158315807580948,
-0.33759045600891113,
-0.3424382209777832,
0.374796986579895,
-0.30523133277893066,
-0.4038219451904297,
0.6603695154190063,
0.47831857204437256,
-0.23547029495239258,
0.11672727018594742,
-0.6954739689826965,
-0.1476016640663147,
0.2506391704082489,
-0.1637604683637619,
0.2781559228897095,
0.07576014846563339,
0.5061929225921631,
0.5756510496139526,
0.474639892578125,
0.3523675203323364,
-0.10219220072031021,
-0.11222364008426666,
0.7947034239768982,
-0.6742169260978699,
-0.48881232738494873,
-1.1212579011917114,
0.16153810918331146,
-0.3721453845500946,
-0.4414927363395691,
0.7677220106124878,
0.4706137180328369,
0.7554517984390259,
-0.18030478060245514,
0.7744578123092651,
0.08108063787221909,
0.4022906720638275,
-0.7350092530250549,
0.3864646553993225,
-0.35979393124580383,
0.4176234006881714,
-0.7053403854370117,
-1.1601872444152832,
-0.3748394250869751,
0.8914405107498169,
-0.517859697341919,
0.05599498748779297,
0.7905008792877197,
0.5573599338531494,
0.10035490244626999,
0.1557658463716507,
-0.04640135169029236,
0.2411748468875885,
0.32975533604621887,
0.5993892550468445,
0.3736124634742737,
-0.791031539440155,
0.36495399475097656,
-0.4329141676425934,
-0.14929482340812683,
-0.10947845876216888,
-1.0963759422302246,
-0.7760120630264282,
-0.4085439443588257,
-0.39395615458488464,
-0.3767564296722412,
0.2556651830673218,
1.0598037242889404,
0.36441269516944885,
-0.948837399482727,
0.11034680902957916,
-0.3310242295265198,
0.20339429378509521,
-0.35340186953544617,
-0.26413407921791077,
0.3721807301044464,
-0.605751097202301,
-0.8278067708015442,
0.08468342572450638,
0.06052786484360695,
-0.3272930085659027,
-0.2980934977531433,
0.04551973193883896,
-0.24676872789859772,
0.17662692070007324,
0.4901924729347229,
-0.30679917335510254,
-0.7100202441215515,
-0.4989669620990753,
-0.3410737216472626,
-0.25300726294517517,
0.17910900712013245,
0.6828331351280212,
-1.1380641460418701,
0.4231940507888794,
0.8018701672554016,
0.6085824966430664,
0.3507065773010254,
-0.048859525471925735,
0.8136500716209412,
-0.8106079697608948,
0.5937488675117493,
0.3572559654712677,
0.4229435920715332,
0.33261924982070923,
-0.19235797226428986,
0.4273640811443329,
0.35750812292099,
-0.4426214396953583,
-0.6706441044807434,
0.35860705375671387,
-0.7744031548500061,
-0.3102434575557709,
1.0782819986343384,
-0.2858896851539612,
0.20928938686847687,
-0.11109034717082977,
-0.0987209752202034,
0.20831350982189178,
-0.09094378352165222,
0.7890395522117615,
0.6938308477401733,
0.1335618495941162,
0.22507166862487793,
-0.4415774643421173,
0.3480324149131775,
0.7418258786201477,
-0.5827121138572693,
-0.11517792195081711,
0.4564172625541687,
0.20794421434402466,
0.277518093585968,
0.16554546356201172,
-0.12559066712856293,
-0.29228660464286804,
0.287982314825058,
-0.09504356980323792,
0.2455558329820633,
0.09678054600954056,
-0.6554861068725586,
0.27306312322616577,
-0.35931161046028137,
-0.5567534565925598
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18542v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18542v1
|
Attention-aware semantic relevance predicting Chinese sentence reading
| 2024-03-27T13:22:38 | 2024-03-27T13:22:38 |
Kun Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In recent years, several influential computational models and metrics have
been proposed to predict how humans comprehend and process sentence. One
particularly promising approach is contextual semantic similarity. Inspired by
the attention algorithm in Transformer and human memory mechanisms, this study
proposes an ``attention-aware'' approach for computing contextual semantic
relevance. This new approach takes into account the different contributions of
contextual parts and the expectation effect, allowing it to incorporate
contextual information fully. The attention-aware approach also facilitates the
simulation of existing reading models and evaluate them. The resulting
``attention-aware'' metrics of semantic relevance can more accurately predict
fixation durations in Chinese reading tasks recorded in an eye-tracking corpus
than those calculated by existing approaches. The study's findings further
provide strong support for the presence of semantic preview benefits in Chinese
naturalistic reading. Furthermore, the attention-aware metrics of semantic
relevance, being memory-based, possess high interpretability from both
linguistic and cognitive standpoints, making them a valuable computational tool
for modeling eye-movements in reading and further gaining insight into the
process of language comprehension. Our approach underscores the potential of
these metrics to advance our comprehension of how humans understand and process
language, ultimately leading to a better understanding of language
comprehension and processing.
|
[
-0.08603373169898987,
-0.6197687387466431,
0.6961802840232849,
0.2099195271730423,
-0.39021438360214233,
-0.6975259780883789,
-0.26053717732429504,
-0.7702671885490417,
0.2948260009288788,
0.6682808995246887,
-0.5901885032653809,
-0.2399752289056778,
-0.21145762503147125,
0.19431172311306,
-0.44060879945755005,
0.6310023069381714,
0.18257631361484528,
-0.09359964728355408,
-0.26560676097869873,
-0.11647940427064896,
-0.5761606693267822,
-0.31730586290359497,
-0.30719101428985596,
-0.13114452362060547,
0.6962576508522034,
0.12846384942531586,
0.6910551190376282,
1.0663024187088013,
0.8373104929924011,
0.24254439771175385,
-0.12873832881450653,
-0.29902929067611694,
-0.31728753447532654,
-0.018108850345015526,
-0.08421032130718231,
-0.7601461410522461,
-0.25760382413864136,
-0.04169058799743652,
0.799699604511261,
0.7010225653648376,
0.29311466217041016,
-0.057079460471868515,
0.13053907454013824,
0.6118682622909546,
-0.5206508040428162,
0.19765612483024597,
-0.6620786190032959,
0.16844221949577332,
-0.21487794816493988,
-0.3778543472290039,
-0.5630059838294983,
-0.09540785849094391,
0.5460672378540039,
-0.7950026988983154,
0.5460447669029236,
0.1880069077014923,
0.6241909861564636,
0.4045892357826233,
-0.29906585812568665,
0.06141286715865135,
-0.32917800545692444,
0.6647526025772095,
-0.7576788067817688,
0.445774108171463,
0.42590510845184326,
0.2557038962841034,
0.13764479756355286,
-0.6393212676048279,
-0.5602951049804688,
-0.39974620938301086,
-0.32410353422164917,
0.38173359632492065,
0.5357481837272644,
0.05237279459834099,
0.24205048382282257,
0.49372047185897827,
-0.715694010257721,
-0.2950252592563629,
-0.2667614221572876,
-0.25963521003723145,
0.30410778522491455,
0.25196579098701477,
0.547980785369873,
-0.1956600695848465,
-0.5347597002983093,
-0.11222565174102783,
-0.4023757576942444,
0.22050848603248596,
-0.06682160496711731,
0.2811872065067291,
0.10740146785974503,
0.45208999514579773,
-0.6008228063583374,
0.9471153020858765,
-0.14169175922870636,
0.09576641768217087,
0.2763890326023102,
-0.6353683471679688,
-0.12142706662416458,
0.17284156382083893,
0.41073063015937805,
0.5804106593132019,
0.30900847911834717,
-0.44370225071907043,
0.1515687257051468,
0.2958050072193146,
0.3684632182121277,
-0.6016499400138855,
-0.1400042623281479,
0.25531962513923645,
-0.3947557508945465,
0.026106109842658043,
0.11822748929262161,
-0.6166602373123169,
-0.05652504786849022,
-0.40765467286109924,
0.11300995945930481,
-0.591428816318512,
0.021508371457457542,
0.25970834493637085,
-0.10007340461015701,
0.4130726754665375,
0.3043435513973236,
-1.064542293548584,
-0.11927056312561035,
0.7581828236579895,
0.853466272354126,
-0.30284684896469116,
-0.4338189959526062,
-0.5182057619094849,
0.37825754284858704,
-0.129022017121315,
0.9440780878067017,
-0.44271090626716614,
0.1376527100801468,
-0.05673930421471596,
0.06396286189556122,
-0.2825739085674286,
-0.22465780377388,
0.7283588647842407,
-0.7127127647399902,
0.1509760469198227,
-0.04609597474336624,
-0.5180783867835999,
-0.43362948298454285,
0.4692082107067108,
-0.942345380783081,
0.811966061592102,
-0.019434545189142227,
-0.9794808030128479,
0.4765043258666992,
-0.5636429190635681,
-0.513613760471344,
0.11693379282951355,
0.30463430285453796,
-0.13722293078899384,
-0.03620942309498787,
0.1770482212305069,
0.43540188670158386,
-0.0835425853729248,
0.15695485472679138,
-0.2900635898113251,
-0.48022139072418213,
0.1340475082397461,
-0.2779094874858856,
0.4229418933391571,
0.2368854433298111,
-0.17231127619743347,
0.32759663462638855,
-0.41624829173088074,
0.06093011796474457,
-0.17361047863960266,
-0.02531084045767784,
-0.506953775882721,
0.12290720641613007,
0.20992796123027802,
0.2722046375274658,
0.38342201709747314,
-0.6508619785308838,
-0.2293805330991745,
-1.0135185718536377,
0.38467466831207275,
0.3607942461967468,
-0.018754655495285988,
0.5452064871788025,
-0.07871121168136597,
0.19215086102485657,
0.19631780683994293,
0.04432293772697449,
-0.6331261396408081,
-0.29293960332870483,
-0.602775514125824,
-0.037179455161094666,
0.22545240819454193,
0.7487555742263794,
-0.5424878001213074,
0.2590046226978302,
-0.3349304795265198,
-0.37529924511909485,
-0.4765354096889496,
-0.06480549275875092,
0.47129955887794495,
0.6234700679779053,
0.415183961391449,
-0.2463357001543045,
-0.08310718834400177,
-0.5894124507904053,
-0.5287137031555176,
-0.15825191140174866,
-0.10454265028238297,
0.4047580361366272,
0.12744465470314026,
-0.22473891079425812,
0.9354947209358215,
-0.7252467274665833,
-0.43852341175079346,
-0.1858551800251007,
-0.196363165974617,
0.25385454297065735,
0.2934131324291229,
0.4474138617515564,
-1.0364272594451904,
-0.530879020690918,
0.24724027514457703,
-0.5565343499183655,
0.11545068770647049,
-0.22321981191635132,
-0.3878665268421173,
0.06808163970708847,
0.5664712190628052,
-0.3255056142807007,
0.3783115744590759,
0.07230272889137268,
-0.5379698276519775,
0.38046976923942566,
-0.20568428933620453,
0.135940283536911,
-1.1053651571273804,
0.2175789326429367,
0.12092895805835724,
-0.19013695418834686,
-0.5559790134429932,
0.22737117111682892,
0.3330856263637543,
0.09578587859869003,
-0.4858361780643463,
0.7270291447639465,
-0.44755929708480835,
-0.07787512987852097,
-0.15579624474048615,
0.6640164852142334,
-0.13584761321544647,
0.5542845129966736,
0.38771918416023254,
0.58109050989151,
0.2741023600101471,
-0.7355359792709351,
0.18562108278274536,
0.17021863162517548,
-0.38465526700019836,
0.1626547873020172,
-0.6212713718414307,
-0.18349497020244598,
0.0023633206728845835,
-0.14865240454673767,
-1.130529522895813,
-0.1159421056509018,
0.1706877052783966,
-0.6286535859107971,
0.027307284995913506,
0.5054923892021179,
-0.4818183481693268,
-0.2188003659248352,
-0.2861696779727936,
0.4264560341835022,
0.05964783951640129,
-0.42193740606307983,
0.48006880283355713,
0.08223719894886017,
-0.092824786901474,
-0.5666543841362,
-0.6208128929138184,
-0.06089387089014053,
-0.2248545140028,
-0.6425363421440125,
0.5084918737411499,
0.008938700892031193,
0.05530959740281105,
0.09257879108190536,
0.05675191059708595,
-0.06332910805940628,
0.25474846363067627,
-0.12717494368553162,
0.466350257396698,
-0.23053283989429474,
0.18280966579914093,
-0.31674888730049133,
-0.2890506386756897,
0.05183713883161545,
-0.2637403905391693,
0.1531197875738144,
-0.02107737958431244,
0.10113189369440079,
-0.3679407835006714,
0.19971314072608948,
0.32925277948379517,
-0.5492210984230042,
0.6034266948699951,
0.7722928524017334,
-0.3724791407585144,
0.1355873942375183,
-0.36927759647369385,
-0.42078348994255066,
-0.4132995903491974,
0.5117121338844299,
-0.29502493143081665,
-0.9891681671142578,
0.46478271484375,
0.23808327317237854,
0.030214302241802216,
0.45336055755615234,
0.5077081322669983,
-0.0040807356126606464,
0.9271876811981201,
0.9199543595314026,
-0.3323436975479126,
1.016025185585022,
0.2379845231771469,
0.1469937115907669,
-0.990680992603302,
0.09648261219263077,
-0.34599432349205017,
-0.05558443069458008,
-0.45099401473999023,
-0.4101720452308655,
0.022339170798659325,
-0.025939490646123886,
0.07795900106430054,
0.5787014365196228,
-0.6400187611579895,
0.4175478518009186,
0.41528916358947754,
0.0578448548913002,
0.3677271902561188,
-0.115615613758564,
-0.2778673470020294,
-0.20881862938404083,
-0.4390195608139038,
-0.26653993129730225,
0.9039101004600525,
-0.020662005990743637,
0.43454036116600037,
-0.030522393062710762,
0.22528435289859772,
0.29051798582077026,
0.28248658776283264,
-0.8164841532707214,
0.4823653995990753,
-0.013184028677642345,
-0.4201222062110901,
-0.5227543115615845,
-0.238729327917099,
-1.0825037956237793,
0.3760780096054077,
0.17253407835960388,
-0.9451590180397034,
-0.2266678512096405,
0.08232411742210388,
-0.33925074338912964,
-0.13374575972557068,
-0.7186369299888611,
1.267877221107483,
0.02938772365450859,
-0.35288384556770325,
-0.48112475872039795,
-1.0539377927780151,
0.11166158318519592,
0.13430821895599365,
-0.06539247184991837,
-0.18525323271751404,
-0.2718563973903656,
0.5899432301521301,
0.012253183871507645,
0.8008617162704468,
0.2374851256608963,
0.031512752175331116,
0.40639618039131165,
-0.1911255270242691,
0.05144587904214859,
0.05429272726178169,
-0.041472118347883224,
-0.12950055301189423,
0.29262569546699524,
-0.48062437772750854,
-0.698286235332489,
0.6176095604896545,
-0.46843016147613525,
-0.6812812089920044,
-0.501811683177948,
-0.8136891722679138,
-0.12735125422477722,
0.49007299542427063,
0.03250772878527641,
0.31069692969322205,
-0.14645521342754364,
-0.0082603944465518,
0.5669310092926025,
0.2528584599494934,
0.5928261876106262,
0.5815247893333435,
-0.106972835958004,
-0.25422403216362,
0.771984338760376,
0.01117442362010479,
0.22612106800079346,
1.0553401708602905,
-0.010367067530751228,
-0.3182947039604187,
-0.2452784776687622,
-0.24638572335243225,
0.36175206303596497,
-0.6205212473869324,
0.19255931675434113,
-0.7238711714744568,
-0.016184691339731216,
-0.48173168301582336,
-0.21384483575820923,
0.06745929270982742,
-0.2178625464439392,
-0.34188929200172424,
0.05171327292919159,
0.3431849181652069,
0.22029459476470947,
0.32294631004333496,
0.0980818048119545,
-0.7436830401420593,
0.3652975559234619,
-0.0564299039542675,
0.49979734420776367,
0.08286305516958237,
-0.5519551634788513,
-0.5381386876106262,
-0.1697603315114975,
-0.2781147062778473,
-0.7523104548454285,
0.5820996761322021,
0.14252892136573792,
0.6392296552658081,
0.5359089374542236,
0.27673909068107605,
0.4635884463787079,
-0.5613527297973633,
0.8036589622497559,
-0.04848501831293106,
-0.7704737186431885,
0.8121721148490906,
-0.30440598726272583,
0.6013542413711548,
0.526883602142334,
0.06875906139612198,
-0.8165898323059082,
-0.4638882577419281,
-0.2929409146308899,
-0.7540909647941589,
0.7845675349235535,
0.012233513407409191,
0.11503598093986511,
-0.19831839203834534,
0.49107399582862854,
-0.151432603597641,
-0.13648661971092224,
-0.7150223255157471,
-0.1428752839565277,
-0.04349998012185097,
-0.2739041745662689,
-0.4454706907272339,
-0.17470340430736542,
0.44611209630966187,
-0.2523399889469147,
0.5187687277793884,
-0.41548436880111694,
0.4663001298904419,
0.6457304358482361,
-0.3300429880619049,
0.1253151297569275,
0.10764285176992416,
0.5400812029838562,
0.43276289105415344,
-0.3591628074645996,
-0.18019840121269226,
0.17409250140190125,
-0.8588849306106567,
-0.3754187822341919,
0.008134294301271439,
-0.27139949798583984,
0.09413253515958786,
0.4318290948867798,
0.5432074666023254,
0.44075313210487366,
-0.8965082764625549,
0.2570131719112396,
0.04447232186794281,
0.2916363477706909,
-0.280882865190506,
0.09775137156248093,
0.10731996595859528,
0.1602628231048584,
0.036900751292705536,
0.04357043653726578,
0.6616401672363281,
-0.3538793921470642,
0.37662482261657715,
0.12389687448740005,
-0.9256325960159302,
-0.27112939953804016,
0.8217430114746094,
0.2154037058353424,
-0.05156385153532028,
0.5713781118392944,
0.11578305810689926,
-0.6367862224578857,
0.8526299595832825,
0.6797655820846558,
0.945814847946167,
-0.18894867599010468,
-0.21229736506938934,
0.6392582654953003,
0.1207614466547966,
0.000020474086340982467,
0.04581217095255852,
-0.38851088285446167,
-0.776335597038269,
-0.47011879086494446,
-0.372219443321228,
-0.31346648931503296,
-0.46202704310417175,
-0.8117237687110901,
0.23621061444282532,
-0.039939358830451965,
-0.10045433044433594,
0.08044330030679703,
0.0993385761976242,
-0.3021708130836487,
0.34761103987693787,
0.30888813734054565,
0.8833746314048767,
-0.499897301197052,
0.9950181841850281,
0.7520660758018494,
-0.30870047211647034,
-0.4302574098110199,
0.4460821747779846,
-0.38291501998901367,
-0.38370245695114136,
0.35832175612449646,
0.8505020141601562,
-0.17918816208839417,
0.0653027892112732,
0.0143356304615736,
-0.8462549448013306,
1.3562822341918945,
0.18966123461723328,
-0.2917329967021942,
0.00490976870059967,
-0.14127220213413239,
0.7637380361557007,
-0.3698076903820038,
0.4155803620815277,
0.5873365998268127,
0.20858195424079895,
0.04510561376810074,
-0.7225121855735779,
-0.09761685132980347,
-0.39572253823280334,
0.25966060161590576,
0.16423454880714417,
-0.7845462560653687,
0.5568897128105164,
-0.4088573455810547,
-0.2687709629535675,
0.07454235106706619,
1.0289275646209717,
-0.14482560753822327,
0.46745678782463074,
0.25321510434150696,
0.43488070368766785,
0.5084397196769714,
0.05840107426047325,
1.3406933546066284,
-0.635079562664032,
0.3559004068374634,
1.0295979976654053,
-0.2231529951095581,
1.133637547492981,
0.37927865982055664,
-0.12430021911859512,
0.3652138113975525,
0.7218425869941711,
0.15146096050739288,
0.7665959000587463,
-0.13708442449569702,
-0.14278699457645416,
-0.25906240940093994,
-0.24079196155071259,
-0.310926616191864,
0.03742126002907753,
0.18498438596725464,
-0.4203730821609497,
0.09677211195230484,
-0.09875240921974182,
-0.2736550271511078,
0.2929912209510803,
-0.5405531525611877,
0.8578503727912903,
0.11018641293048859,
-1.0259766578674316,
0.2808680236339569,
-0.006636387202888727,
0.645953893661499,
-0.4335823655128479,
-0.029929932206869125,
0.07510624080896378,
0.47866687178611755,
0.05681674927473068,
-0.9737940430641174,
0.3964577317237854,
-0.23929351568222046,
-0.5607309937477112,
-0.027547616511583328,
0.6657569408416748,
-0.559783399105072,
-0.41327837109565735,
0.4823588728904724,
0.256455659866333,
0.12118137627840042,
-0.12617647647857666,
-0.4884605407714844,
-0.35814201831817627,
0.08603736758232117,
-0.2330895960330963,
0.3545876741409302,
0.4422565996646881,
-0.07621344923973083,
0.6729168891906738,
0.466225802898407,
-0.19623321294784546,
0.10549396276473999,
-0.0023232712410390377,
0.4682454764842987,
-0.994332492351532,
-1.0096124410629272,
-0.8722867369651794,
0.17670579254627228,
0.07443567365407944,
-0.4168173372745514,
0.7252064943313599,
0.48607757687568665,
0.8013095259666443,
-0.18225298821926117,
0.43098366260528564,
0.2517215311527252,
0.6058837175369263,
-0.36953678727149963,
0.7136556506156921,
-0.5033143162727356,
0.006541895214468241,
-0.36178502440452576,
-1.031723141670227,
-0.5712636113166809,
0.6316382884979248,
-0.6786261200904846,
-0.16571269929409027,
0.8813634514808655,
0.6326642036437988,
0.01706511899828911,
0.2863912880420685,
0.43712833523750305,
-0.02927783690392971,
-0.13992470502853394,
0.8140583634376526,
0.4084261655807495,
-0.42457956075668335,
0.44269251823425293,
-0.18974068760871887,
0.0012916093692183495,
-0.41338661313056946,
-0.7290137410163879,
-0.8395141959190369,
-0.7298766374588013,
-0.2284213900566101,
-0.02085069939494133,
-0.08595022559165955,
0.4576004147529602,
0.40366390347480774,
-0.7934647798538208,
0.09080280363559723,
-0.09447281807661057,
0.07454073429107666,
-0.6117260456085205,
-0.2827982008457184,
0.6300544142723083,
-0.6797856688499451,
-0.8246347904205322,
-0.22815819084644318,
0.4666132926940918,
-0.21445126831531525,
0.004198550246655941,
0.12031031399965286,
-0.37104669213294983,
0.10855067521333694,
0.6592705249786377,
0.1119559034705162,
-0.9896437525749207,
-0.25765010714530945,
0.2297750860452652,
-0.5122095942497253,
0.1058947890996933,
0.6815968751907349,
-1.030685544013977,
0.7268269658088684,
0.6733343601226807,
0.9075613617897034,
0.4954531490802765,
0.06871073693037033,
0.48642587661743164,
-0.2511211037635803,
0.21725647151470184,
0.23303759098052979,
0.29493603110313416,
0.244005486369133,
-0.8741494417190552,
0.6906651854515076,
0.24101296067237854,
-0.48605474829673767,
-0.41315019130706787,
0.06723698228597641,
-1.1823893785476685,
0.04292123764753342,
0.8410264849662781,
-0.4693714380264282,
-0.6607810258865356,
-0.0872960239648819,
-0.3192731738090515,
0.3868441581726074,
-0.263448029756546,
0.7097871899604797,
0.9115594625473022,
-0.08545619249343872,
-0.3326025605201721,
-0.6643366813659668,
0.30192187428474426,
0.8483277559280396,
-0.6970878839492798,
0.284980446100235,
0.3046826720237732,
0.08065077662467957,
0.24269039928913116,
0.33378690481185913,
-0.10850964486598969,
0.6654209494590759,
-0.06299684941768646,
-0.12423641234636307,
0.17938119173049927,
-0.22406408190727234,
-0.21833644807338715,
-0.029172174632549286,
-0.18028074502944946,
-0.03817771002650261
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18537v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18537v1
|
A Path Towards Legal Autonomy: An interoperable and explainable approach to extracting, transforming, loading and computing legal information using large language models, expert systems and Bayesian networks
| 2024-03-27T13:12:57 | 2024-03-27T13:12:57 |
Axel Constant, Hannes Westermann, Bryan Wilson, Alex Kiefer, Ines Hipolito, Sylvain Pronovost, Steven Swanson, Mahault Albarracin, Maxwell J. D. Ramstead
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LO
|
Legal autonomy - the lawful activity of artificial intelligence agents - can
be achieved in one of two ways. It can be achieved either by imposing
constraints on AI actors such as developers, deployers and users, and on AI
resources such as data, or by imposing constraints on the range and scope of
the impact that AI agents can have on the environment. The latter approach
involves encoding extant rules concerning AI driven devices into the software
of AI agents controlling those devices (e.g., encoding rules about limitations
on zones of operations into the agent software of an autonomous drone device).
This is a challenge since the effectivity of such an approach requires a method
of extracting, loading, transforming and computing legal information that would
be both explainable and legally interoperable, and that would enable AI agents
to reason about the law. In this paper, we sketch a proof of principle for such
a method using large language models (LLMs), expert legal systems known as
legal decision paths, and Bayesian networks. We then show how the proposed
method could be applied to extant regulation in matters of autonomous cars,
such as the California Vehicle Code.
|
[
-0.2936992347240448,
-0.5190929770469666,
1.0211472511291504,
0.014851018786430359,
-0.15876401960849762,
-0.09999707341194153,
-0.16645848751068115,
-0.5035668015480042,
-0.10666540265083313,
0.9305406212806702,
-0.319954514503479,
-0.4654659330844879,
-0.47060534358024597,
-0.2949933409690857,
-0.5155034065246582,
0.6701768040657043,
0.011718575842678547,
0.06599260121583939,
-0.20778143405914307,
-0.19485998153686523,
-0.34857356548309326,
-0.3621014952659607,
-0.3265538513660431,
0.12034910917282104,
0.36972540616989136,
0.10320530831813812,
0.9957414269447327,
1.1840002536773682,
0.5481850504875183,
0.44637998938560486,
0.3373912274837494,
-0.2922036647796631,
0.07588474452495575,
0.0752575695514679,
-0.6045559048652649,
-0.6308804750442505,
-0.08527606725692749,
-0.07586170732975006,
0.4137885868549347,
0.17988280951976776,
-0.30388644337654114,
-0.18420466780662537,
-0.3600257635116577,
0.5197939872741699,
-0.6307929754257202,
0.4192490875720978,
-0.409839004278183,
-0.007996811531484127,
0.012886698357760906,
-0.2782760262489319,
-0.08742719888687134,
-0.3462461829185486,
-0.21665772795677185,
-0.6785939931869507,
-0.1560233235359192,
-0.011489060707390308,
0.7819367051124573,
0.8924300074577332,
-0.5797026753425598,
-0.5379690527915955,
-1.1089595556259155,
0.30499520897865295,
-0.9313474297523499,
0.2315348982810974,
0.347781240940094,
0.71100914478302,
-0.34964749217033386,
-0.6666274070739746,
-0.9340676665306091,
-0.5262021422386169,
-0.07085520029067993,
0.1030832976102829,
-0.3629445433616638,
0.2860740125179291,
0.2133534550666809,
-0.19663402438163757,
-0.25971904397010803,
0.5131476521492004,
-0.348433256149292,
0.006357505451887846,
0.9116538763046265,
0.0664191022515297,
0.4145953357219696,
0.2872750759124756,
0.15649551153182983,
0.10042329877614975,
-0.6270921230316162,
0.22630442678928375,
0.6276935935020447,
0.3067440092563629,
-0.04384910687804222,
0.8281567692756653,
-0.3093433380126953,
0.49522969126701355,
-0.04840642586350441,
-0.2940264642238617,
-0.1318873167037964,
-0.10083046555519104,
-0.10350773483514786,
0.196383535861969,
0.975841224193573,
0.0492512509226799,
0.15903830528259277,
-0.16614627838134766,
-0.18618859350681305,
-0.41883936524391174,
0.4234890639781952,
-0.48758721351623535,
0.00826974306255579,
0.4501377046108246,
-0.46954411268234253,
0.07715728133916855,
0.43257084488868713,
-0.5021333694458008,
-0.5394251942634583,
-0.7694690227508545,
0.5191376805305481,
-0.2650125026702881,
-0.2196868509054184,
0.3157798647880554,
0.023657891899347305,
0.6161171197891235,
0.3779679238796234,
-0.8495563864707947,
0.2700321078300476,
0.8445202708244324,
0.43177247047424316,
0.47260648012161255,
-0.1257001906633377,
-0.34438496828079224,
0.3272523283958435,
-0.42402613162994385,
0.3956691026687622,
-0.3929394483566284,
-0.14236734807491302,
-0.09808102995157242,
0.08841609209775925,
0.29206591844558716,
-0.3038395941257477,
0.05472709983587265,
-0.6216691732406616,
-0.26895734667778015,
-0.059474583715200424,
-0.4514142572879791,
-0.7486280202865601,
-0.06132413446903229,
-0.5174936056137085,
0.08883675932884216,
-0.10294657200574875,
-0.2711223065853119,
0.6181161403656006,
-0.7466536164283752,
-0.7125445008277893,
0.29038742184638977,
-0.7293477654457092,
-0.07367192953824997,
-0.06481791287660599,
-0.06834737211465836,
0.5670639872550964,
-0.3964902460575104,
0.6997646689414978,
-0.34888672828674316,
0.0917360857129097,
-0.022904101759195328,
-0.5767011046409607,
1.309780240058899,
0.2648996114730835,
-0.846886157989502,
0.2840360701084137,
-0.7185543775558472,
-0.31898289918899536,
-0.06463707238435745,
-0.500785768032074,
-0.2330748736858368,
0.6391313076019287,
-0.5924290418624878,
0.27994078397750854,
0.3073357343673706,
-0.41349706053733826,
0.15560340881347656,
-0.12755592167377472,
0.44181859493255615,
0.9193657636642456,
-0.03811582550406456,
0.393043577671051,
-0.23905767500400543,
0.6422033309936523,
-0.16528388857841492,
0.11914722621440887,
0.20593079924583435,
-0.3250163197517395,
-0.4741850793361664,
-0.1286633014678955,
0.09981031715869904,
0.7570040225982666,
-0.402898907661438,
0.760998010635376,
-0.3164587914943695,
-0.5793666243553162,
-0.6717819571495056,
0.026532026007771492,
-0.002920864149928093,
0.2319057136774063,
0.1914919763803482,
-0.026096878573298454,
-0.15187494456768036,
-0.9733050465583801,
-0.20328389108181,
-0.5825321078300476,
0.35437363386154175,
0.48719310760498047,
0.5897981524467468,
-0.27091193199157715,
1.1954827308654785,
0.3001229763031006,
-0.0671810582280159,
-0.21425478160381317,
0.11901828646659851,
0.18813252449035645,
0.6598720550537109,
0.2573748826980591,
-1.0444748401641846,
-0.23539113998413086,
0.6691015958786011,
-0.948297917842865,
-0.11674033105373383,
-0.629421591758728,
0.11810057610273361,
-0.28725796937942505,
0.6307947635650635,
-0.6175260543823242,
0.8741763830184937,
-0.3259493112564087,
-0.43754667043685913,
0.6906874179840088,
-0.7179330587387085,
0.11511833965778351,
-0.4956744313240051,
-0.10095217823982239,
-0.05723784491419792,
-0.4906559884548187,
-0.29731252789497375,
0.371549516916275,
-0.22185759246349335,
0.4510612487792969,
-0.4492727220058441,
0.3041266202926636,
-0.27496814727783203,
-0.4798419177532196,
-0.6198297142982483,
-0.14409011602401733,
-0.34404584765434265,
0.1327599436044693,
-0.1611570417881012,
0.5457484722137451,
0.7959083318710327,
-0.840369701385498,
0.7444242835044861,
0.007049619220197201,
-0.2244536429643631,
0.5088380575180054,
-0.4847886562347412,
-0.34727612137794495,
-0.5113140940666199,
0.1509341150522232,
-0.35789263248443604,
-0.40763816237449646,
0.531602680683136,
-0.06358437985181808,
-0.11949308961629868,
-0.3167397081851959,
-0.7084837555885315,
-0.0753532201051712,
0.519997775554657,
0.27945470809936523,
0.5909206867218018,
-0.3749047517776489,
1.009317398071289,
0.7508071660995483,
-0.08889055252075195,
-0.659738302230835,
-0.5986166596412659,
0.2843320667743683,
-0.5683504939079285,
-0.2170487642288208,
0.2560403347015381,
0.010234897024929523,
-1.0277342796325684,
0.36268818378448486,
0.318309485912323,
-0.16165904700756073,
0.396416574716568,
0.7752990126609802,
-0.2715446650981903,
-0.14069423079490662,
0.23014317452907562,
0.4502198398113251,
0.028141818940639496,
0.6046187877655029,
-0.17846637964248657,
0.20570285618305206,
-0.057416677474975586,
-0.6311271786689758,
-0.7749944925308228,
0.3567207455635071,
0.6811640858650208,
-0.2645958662033081,
0.42952001094818115,
0.15950697660446167,
-0.3332623839378357,
-0.19911420345306396,
-0.26050448417663574,
0.28133171796798706,
-0.5201424360275269,
0.16257357597351074,
-0.36274147033691406,
-0.6186593770980835,
0.37715891003608704,
-0.18922173976898193,
0.4610617160797119,
0.7355570197105408,
0.7757559418678284,
0.11244402080774307,
0.7649524807929993,
0.8039683699607849,
-0.06464769691228867,
0.2247461974620819,
0.08658106625080109,
0.17754842340946198,
-0.033742379397153854,
-0.36521196365356445,
-0.6639301180839539,
-0.08713238686323166,
-0.799008309841156,
-0.1267338991165161,
0.20506682991981506,
-0.023437373340129852,
-0.5594587922096252,
0.3924177587032318,
-0.20767121016979218,
0.7605077028274536,
0.8906289339065552,
0.10255521535873413,
0.26333242654800415,
-0.3868449926376343,
-0.08258417248725891,
0.4902854263782501,
-0.6655095219612122,
-0.6372075080871582,
0.9326475262641907,
0.2975538671016693,
0.6311550736427307,
0.2613304555416107,
0.6962230801582336,
0.40296339988708496,
-0.08885312080383301,
-0.9751594066619873,
0.8225031495094299,
-0.041155267506837845,
-0.742542028427124,
-0.35614636540412903,
-0.3619846999645233,
-0.9869471788406372,
-0.12197863310575485,
-0.2982601225376129,
-0.8446105122566223,
0.42039790749549866,
-0.30395954847335815,
-0.7839762568473816,
0.3421481251716614,
-0.18266728520393372,
0.5106472373008728,
-0.7340667843818665,
-0.5127230286598206,
-0.49554237723350525,
-1.0561528205871582,
0.023837480694055557,
-0.15822163224220276,
0.32598304748535156,
-0.30937641859054565,
-0.029293572530150414,
0.8044742941856384,
-0.7554374933242798,
0.7645655274391174,
-0.27262261509895325,
-0.09046245366334915,
0.6882159113883972,
0.08851601183414459,
0.21490803360939026,
0.09845656156539917,
-0.07124480605125427,
-0.11246481537818909,
0.1999734491109848,
0.013924699276685715,
-0.7001129388809204,
0.2998017966747284,
-0.7670623660087585,
-0.9234466552734375,
-0.26732414960861206,
-0.7149963974952698,
0.16257083415985107,
0.44822701811790466,
-0.023644106462597847,
0.11689642816781998,
0.1391405463218689,
0.14583446085453033,
0.1957535296678543,
-0.19084855914115906,
0.7396029233932495,
0.7857686877250671,
-0.06524942815303802,
-0.09731905162334442,
0.7627914547920227,
0.3844764232635498,
-0.2350221574306488,
0.2845534086227417,
0.2282731831073761,
-0.4697175621986389,
-0.7085610032081604,
-0.19817879796028137,
0.14880573749542236,
-0.9294070601463318,
0.11034853756427765,
-0.3820435404777527,
-0.26438575983047485,
-0.42282721400260925,
-0.06656923145055771,
-0.18521985411643982,
-0.3356514275074005,
-0.4512205719947815,
-0.023452037945389748,
0.3272347152233124,
1.1782466173171997,
-0.5427422523498535,
0.497639536857605,
-0.5531010031700134,
0.2197876274585724,
0.3986854553222656,
0.05884607136249542,
-0.3787453770637512,
-0.26522132754325867,
-0.11608534306287766,
-0.002335349330678582,
-0.009758825413882732,
-0.8980638384819031,
0.38510170578956604,
-0.19109630584716797,
0.8318239450454712,
0.6658426523208618,
0.17551328241825104,
0.562406599521637,
-0.61390620470047,
0.3653523027896881,
-0.06873217225074768,
-1.0411545038223267,
0.44069844484329224,
-0.27564260363578796,
-0.4893700182437897,
0.5860602259635925,
0.45764198899269104,
0.09380882978439331,
-0.3928498327732086,
-0.5850344300270081,
-0.6651850938796997,
0.18293291330337524,
0.07009878009557724,
0.10385023802518845,
0.4493199288845062,
0.8256388902664185,
0.3200332522392273,
0.21295182406902313,
-0.8875757455825806,
0.35234755277633667,
0.14259018003940582,
-0.37324944138526917,
0.010744357481598854,
0.4237334430217743,
-0.12391724437475204,
-0.26757103204727173,
0.7123168110847473,
-0.05840502679347992,
0.21309514343738556,
0.30128225684165955,
0.020336227491497993,
0.15189717710018158,
0.1687694936990738,
0.3033842444419861,
0.7874900698661804,
0.24854570627212524,
0.2200835794210434,
-0.5153726935386658,
-0.06614725291728973,
0.5450502038002014,
0.4053131937980652,
-0.2386494278907776,
-0.31005847454071045,
0.14910201728343964,
0.6010521054267883,
-0.7864903807640076,
-0.8312886953353882,
0.4088222086429596,
0.04913405701518059,
-0.2716217339038849,
-0.5092877149581909,
0.5117844939231873,
-0.22949248552322388,
0.8688293099403381,
0.22248511016368866,
0.07860051840543747,
0.2675268054008484,
-0.602874755859375,
0.2918035686016083,
0.5341446399688721,
-0.45383942127227783,
0.025060754269361496,
0.8937457203865051,
-0.3505306541919708,
-0.4913654327392578,
0.2192627489566803,
-0.20768411457538605,
-0.10420209914445877,
0.9450509548187256,
0.2839204668998718,
0.6230197548866272,
0.17983277142047882,
0.2717609107494354,
0.03746962547302246,
0.6310217380523682,
-0.4484841823577881,
0.031999487429857254,
-0.2641696631908417,
-0.6205551624298096,
-0.3218365013599396,
-0.10246754437685013,
-0.32226935029029846,
-0.08138396590948105,
-0.32756397128105164,
-0.018529187887907028,
-0.8440873026847839,
-0.1005576029419899,
0.04217347875237465,
-0.3458905816078186,
-0.4558452367782593,
0.3330399990081787,
-0.07335074990987778,
0.575864851474762,
-0.44776496291160583,
0.8039788007736206,
0.40199440717697144,
-0.5907934308052063,
-0.831954300403595,
0.20162466168403625,
0.01136974710971117,
-0.5825338959693909,
0.4225119948387146,
0.08630773425102234,
-0.24188347160816193,
0.01340516097843647,
-0.8329458236694336,
-0.48269549012184143,
1.1220959424972534,
0.42196452617645264,
-0.6181110143661499,
-0.05553222447633743,
0.4352948069572449,
0.476446270942688,
-0.4681779146194458,
0.007890385575592518,
0.7440386414527893,
0.5773753523826599,
-0.20205897092819214,
-0.6029534935951233,
0.13297221064567566,
-0.27625924348831177,
-0.4076481759548187,
-0.17471246421337128,
-0.3296620547771454,
0.6933255791664124,
-0.42645522952079773,
-0.1427208036184311,
0.1849461793899536,
0.7236143946647644,
-0.1556268185377121,
0.30053552985191345,
0.48219287395477295,
0.3715215027332306,
0.7611193656921387,
0.09598258882761002,
0.9674109220504761,
-0.38682085275650024,
0.1156228557229042,
1.1556330919265747,
-0.35161033272743225,
0.6181085705757141,
0.40360549092292786,
-0.05606328323483467,
0.583127498626709,
0.5324316620826721,
-0.15132464468479156,
0.34713014960289,
0.2677989900112152,
-0.39071300625801086,
-0.2566728889942169,
-0.18454872071743011,
0.22327351570129395,
0.8139553666114807,
0.34417054057121277,
-0.5337533354759216,
-0.014311064034700394,
0.11659251898527145,
-0.13684798777103424,
-0.021877160295844078,
-0.48810014128685,
1.0453561544418335,
-0.2701853811740875,
-0.7838219404220581,
-0.06394162774085999,
0.22845113277435303,
-0.025439999997615814,
-0.3825819790363312,
-0.0906178206205368,
0.2551533579826355,
-0.04864475503563881,
-0.15926732122898102,
-1.0040301084518433,
0.27778732776641846,
0.1509346216917038,
0.27605319023132324,
-0.18288654088974,
0.5319617986679077,
-0.06395116448402405,
-0.4281628727912903,
0.25614866614341736,
0.5775057077407837,
0.39561471343040466,
0.23827232420444489,
-0.9120206236839294,
-0.5314423441886902,
-0.18694251775741577,
0.017371831461787224,
-0.04374455288052559,
0.5825893878936768,
-0.05075132101774216,
0.8658568859100342,
0.4334832727909088,
0.2829427123069763,
0.36644020676612854,
-0.4070793092250824,
0.6733972430229187,
-0.5839976072311401,
-0.7738275527954102,
-1.0986336469650269,
0.6782927513122559,
0.20227091014385223,
0.08730050921440125,
0.45611467957496643,
0.2656928300857544,
0.41070571541786194,
0.5070228576660156,
1.1552627086639404,
-0.4429299831390381,
-0.04077399894595146,
-0.7526344656944275,
0.7285627722740173,
-0.6379216313362122,
0.4160958528518677,
0.06502979248762131,
-0.5195698142051697,
-0.4558835029602051,
0.6341770887374878,
-0.48087018728256226,
-0.05401536449790001,
0.13752499222755432,
0.8262242674827576,
-0.18858741223812103,
-0.2473478615283966,
0.21782904863357544,
0.09477833658456802,
0.49965786933898926,
0.3093515932559967,
0.7475459575653076,
0.09854673594236374,
0.27848589420318604,
-0.36261406540870667,
-0.22244873642921448,
0.18823561072349548,
-0.6805295944213867,
-0.5002667903900146,
-0.5057769417762756,
-0.24594488739967346,
-0.3109397292137146,
-0.05978573113679886,
0.8992068767547607,
0.7145561575889587,
-0.4568737745285034,
-0.6093720197677612,
-0.8185612559318542,
0.22631849348545074,
-0.18376241624355316,
-0.16115997731685638,
0.04503219574689865,
-0.15813753008842468,
-0.46969279646873474,
0.5900431275367737,
0.35983213782310486,
0.32637444138526917,
-0.4344685673713684,
-0.34462040662765503,
-0.1413053274154663,
0.3713274598121643,
0.12351566553115845,
0.7333571314811707,
-0.8075904846191406,
-0.23901568353176117,
-0.7260069847106934,
-0.1278562992811203,
0.24959278106689453,
0.7464033365249634,
-0.5662341117858887,
0.7345064878463745,
0.3842703402042389,
0.9153372645378113,
0.04908270761370659,
0.09942714124917984,
0.7518889307975769,
0.04770324006676674,
0.1434514969587326,
0.36018306016921997,
0.47197043895721436,
-0.33414021134376526,
-0.4686269760131836,
0.5122369527816772,
-0.07061327248811722,
-0.7557136416435242,
-0.25456008315086365,
0.35720905661582947,
-0.8800241351127625,
-0.5994815230369568,
0.9673753380775452,
-0.568548858165741,
-0.4127733111381531,
-0.34994325041770935,
-0.12513548135757446,
0.4766058027744293,
-0.1596999615430832,
0.7330806851387024,
0.24241437017917633,
-0.1456603705883026,
-0.15062260627746582,
-0.7821922898292542,
0.2096043825149536,
-0.010160870850086212,
-1.1560988426208496,
0.08084068447351456,
0.725571870803833,
0.05087944120168686,
0.15141837298870087,
0.5269966125488281,
-0.0659969374537468,
0.17745481431484222,
0.0209786519408226,
-0.12254395335912704,
0.006063596811145544,
-0.6305612325668335,
-0.5018318295478821,
0.1825229972600937,
-0.12902943789958954,
0.06354827433824539
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02555v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02555v1
|
PhoWhisper: Automatic Speech Recognition for Vietnamese
| 2024-03-27T13:10:06 | 2024-03-27T13:10:06 |
Thanh-Thien Le, Linh The Nguyen, Dat Quoc Nguyen
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL
|
We introduce PhoWhisper in five versions for Vietnamese automatic speech
recognition. PhoWhisper's robustness is achieved through fine-tuning the
Whisper model on an 844-hour dataset that encompasses diverse Vietnamese
accents. Our experimental study demonstrates state-of-the-art performances of
PhoWhisper on benchmark Vietnamese ASR datasets. We have open-sourced
PhoWhisper at: https://github.com/VinAIResearch/PhoWhisper
|
[
-0.0032619705889374018,
-0.337290495634079,
0.41977208852767944,
0.26495158672332764,
-0.3009931445121765,
0.15289369225502014,
-0.1472400277853012,
-0.7614805698394775,
0.03876153379678726,
0.5917547941207886,
-0.3491132855415344,
-0.5036413669586182,
-0.5387609004974365,
0.33769187331199646,
-0.3512091040611267,
0.5708574652671814,
0.25152653455734253,
-0.03253243863582611,
0.5468397736549377,
-0.3672589659690857,
-0.4134616553783417,
-0.418914258480072,
-0.6289462447166443,
-0.3409729301929474,
0.08007597923278809,
0.7874971032142639,
0.5256815552711487,
0.7324634790420532,
0.7253187298774719,
0.4407980740070343,
0.18258056044578552,
0.2882983684539795,
-0.17558379471302032,
0.26485493779182434,
0.14323748648166656,
-0.23766809701919556,
-0.43465641140937805,
-0.050052572041749954,
0.5211266279220581,
0.3444441854953766,
-0.44409415125846863,
0.2612791955471039,
-0.3098561763763428,
0.3450951874256134,
-0.5572319030761719,
0.11068525165319443,
-0.9080188870429993,
-0.1961270570755005,
-0.30961474776268005,
-0.24337662756443024,
-0.3587033152580261,
-0.32851335406303406,
0.8824679851531982,
-0.6861042976379395,
0.2785632908344269,
-0.07292097061872482,
0.7394752502441406,
0.47404012084007263,
-0.43454134464263916,
-0.29342615604400635,
-0.7172229886054993,
0.8762912154197693,
-0.6108053922653198,
0.4570454955101013,
0.531964898109436,
0.7528147101402283,
0.1516270786523819,
-0.9672108888626099,
-0.39438289403915405,
-0.12933720648288727,
0.07243646681308746,
0.19615241885185242,
-0.4565414786338806,
0.11806938797235489,
0.10389671474695206,
0.5660725831985474,
-0.6979466676712036,
-0.043550942093133926,
-0.5540218353271484,
-0.527320921421051,
0.9515779614448547,
0.12005946785211563,
0.246501162648201,
-0.19208213686943054,
-0.10642768442630768,
-0.05204583704471588,
-0.07463360577821732,
0.06726623326539993,
0.3997136056423187,
0.5222338438034058,
-0.03910605609416962,
0.544852077960968,
-0.375090628862381,
0.8188172578811646,
0.17073754966259003,
-0.5935810208320618,
0.4604097306728363,
0.2961497902870178,
-0.3234829306602478,
0.5812315940856934,
0.6254876255989075,
0.43087220191955566,
0.33637356758117676,
0.20000919699668884,
-0.31341618299484253,
0.3596809208393097,
0.08348463475704193,
-0.683452844619751,
-0.7617479562759399,
0.47023653984069824,
-0.6900640726089478,
-0.22906485199928284,
0.3320099413394928,
-0.6280493140220642,
-0.38904374837875366,
-0.23854076862335205,
0.7857624292373657,
-0.7218534350395203,
-0.7249706387519836,
0.46691474318504333,
-0.5590805411338806,
0.354218989610672,
0.30893653631210327,
-0.6435094475746155,
0.6860305070877075,
0.6201659440994263,
1.050459384918213,
-0.6477646231651306,
-0.7051875591278076,
-0.8294919729232788,
0.01656108722090721,
-0.13861460983753204,
0.7958189249038696,
-0.5795382857322693,
-0.9697755575180054,
-0.18210965394973755,
0.2807809114456177,
-0.2155573070049286,
-0.9795507788658142,
0.5221894979476929,
0.04317629709839821,
0.39510276913642883,
0.3495537042617798,
-0.8922648429870605,
-0.4260489344596863,
-0.41022589802742004,
-0.7053784132003784,
1.1356977224349976,
0.1300678551197052,
-0.6835435628890991,
0.30708959698677063,
-0.6381301283836365,
-0.36848142743110657,
0.3631013333797455,
0.2893199920654297,
-0.6509807705879211,
0.2845369875431061,
0.11553342640399933,
0.31902024149894714,
0.22298307716846466,
-0.24021820724010468,
0.1672087162733078,
-0.49985471367836,
-0.003217387245967984,
-0.24202190339565277,
1.2383908033370972,
0.4181707203388214,
-0.30274999141693115,
0.4190044403076172,
-1.4061394929885864,
0.018884144723415375,
0.14002971351146698,
-0.14349983632564545,
-0.5126635432243347,
-0.14751893281936646,
0.405925452709198,
-0.05475005879998207,
0.21196377277374268,
-0.5245360136032104,
-0.1176457479596138,
-0.5824646949768066,
0.5734411478042603,
0.42496854066848755,
0.0926373302936554,
0.3534233570098877,
-0.5454539060592651,
0.4538825750350952,
-0.1661013960838318,
0.24693357944488525,
-0.480133980512619,
-0.787688136100769,
-0.7861014604568481,
-0.6010921597480774,
-0.004678555764257908,
0.8384990692138672,
-0.3158484101295471,
0.5401031970977783,
0.11440270394086838,
-0.8991569876670837,
-1.1457185745239258,
-0.06755760312080383,
0.20181871950626373,
0.44082269072532654,
0.5470290184020996,
0.04477860778570175,
-0.9905012845993042,
-0.7487911581993103,
-0.17593133449554443,
-0.4668702185153961,
-0.38277962803840637,
0.010869288817048073,
0.4313395917415619,
-0.5306456089019775,
0.8421871662139893,
-0.4318150579929352,
-0.21193666756153107,
0.06782887876033783,
0.18084761500358582,
0.0532713308930397,
0.291858971118927,
0.42801544070243835,
-0.8995731472969055,
-0.7503079771995544,
-0.0027205399237573147,
-0.20700272917747498,
-0.3158208131790161,
0.4411832094192505,
0.2836167514324188,
0.18424011766910553,
0.3156720995903015,
-0.6392049193382263,
0.25882962346076965,
0.8091059923171997,
-0.2713918387889862,
0.692684531211853,
-0.03723689913749695,
0.016841912642121315,
-1.126591682434082,
-0.06568215787410736,
-0.25602906942367554,
-0.4551662802696228,
-0.6698673367500305,
-0.20090481638908386,
0.05466718599200249,
-0.35024282336235046,
-0.4706858694553375,
0.4746240973472595,
-0.3873520493507385,
0.13487538695335388,
-0.32476329803466797,
-0.27605780959129333,
-0.09044826775789261,
-0.12001905590295792,
0.5177179574966431,
0.8393306136131287,
0.8338196277618408,
-0.6018083691596985,
0.7079951167106628,
0.14826759696006775,
-0.1531703621149063,
0.7082226276397705,
-0.9524664878845215,
0.27163025736808777,
0.3135184049606323,
0.008186307735741138,
-0.9343110918998718,
-0.4581197500228882,
-0.05102965608239174,
-0.6328212022781372,
0.04281115159392357,
-0.23401083052158356,
0.07863520830869675,
-0.3791109025478363,
-0.5934804081916809,
0.08265747129917145,
0.7694212794303894,
-0.7622420787811279,
0.6297628879547119,
0.6984555721282959,
-0.1286790817975998,
-0.13210764527320862,
-0.16040311753749847,
0.1124766543507576,
-0.7195680737495422,
-0.33103200793266296,
0.2928745150566101,
-0.08686087280511856,
-0.5313543677330017,
-0.36657947301864624,
-0.04511212930083275,
-0.20453570783138275,
-0.32721900939941406,
0.39497822523117065,
0.03445863723754883,
-0.46880415081977844,
-0.06459296494722366,
-0.5691056251525879,
-0.4878162741661072,
-0.18760176002979279,
-0.3848302960395813,
0.255106657743454,
-0.2936486303806305,
-0.07812045514583588,
-0.8597290515899658,
0.33760878443717957,
0.7340160608291626,
-0.24340085685253143,
-0.058686763048172,
0.6486491560935974,
-0.42478033900260925,
-0.3782752454280853,
-0.7708544135093689,
-0.1880103051662445,
-0.5790238380432129,
0.20218431949615479,
-0.6850457787513733,
-0.598271906375885,
0.41515567898750305,
0.04131896421313286,
-0.16245651245117188,
0.4144972562789917,
0.3046691119670868,
-0.10235261917114258,
1.199060320854187,
0.8743480443954468,
-0.22412505745887756,
0.41231390833854675,
0.058143097907304764,
-0.33170220255851746,
-0.4738502502441406,
-0.001788605935871601,
-0.5843325257301331,
0.362991064786911,
-1.0481698513031006,
-0.3153463900089264,
0.11719664186239243,
-0.6607025861740112,
-0.18249931931495667,
0.38459354639053345,
-0.9266776442527771,
0.30783355236053467,
0.8029487729072571,
-0.08615455031394958,
0.5153616666793823,
-0.13243673741817474,
0.3027397692203522,
-0.4235885739326477,
-0.3578071892261505,
-0.5639390349388123,
0.7836177945137024,
0.3561544418334961,
0.8317239880561829,
-0.17463062703609467,
0.5074335336685181,
0.194468691945076,
-0.43939512968063354,
-1.0519064664840698,
0.41441887617111206,
-0.15259891748428345,
-0.32450973987579346,
-0.4560229182243347,
-0.09890908002853394,
-0.9507168531417847,
0.1090940535068512,
0.23955614864826202,
-0.582859218120575,
0.348285049200058,
0.09967488050460815,
-0.08928430825471878,
0.02972424030303955,
-0.9099395275115967,
0.6577560901641846,
-0.04721135273575783,
0.4555065631866455,
-0.00506502715870738,
-0.6317353844642639,
0.14731718599796295,
0.10035132616758347,
-0.37284576892852783,
-0.3601865768432617,
-0.16965924203395844,
0.8464344143867493,
-0.7370372414588928,
0.6138695478439331,
-0.301340788602829,
-0.0563686266541481,
0.35054901242256165,
0.009057216346263885,
0.37999019026756287,
-0.011528752744197845,
-0.13429659605026245,
0.3632603883743286,
0.07795500755310059,
-0.3482934236526489,
-0.062190357595682144,
0.4774251878261566,
-0.8220464587211609,
-0.2778772711753845,
-0.6346198320388794,
-0.17926377058029175,
-0.1731901615858078,
0.2793302536010742,
0.7211374044418335,
0.26357337832450867,
-0.12609504163265228,
0.1800471693277359,
0.5739990472793579,
-0.08581358939409256,
0.1702532172203064,
1.0512340068817139,
-0.22550228238105774,
-0.5166105628013611,
1.2424205541610718,
0.3366493582725525,
-0.046080365777015686,
0.3755379319190979,
0.372978150844574,
-0.24432960152626038,
-0.5257130861282349,
-0.13061340153217316,
0.23009847104549408,
-0.4570087492465973,
-0.0518755242228508,
-0.6097539067268372,
-0.5826641321182251,
-0.06515151262283325,
-0.15357065200805664,
-0.4333038926124573,
-0.4339516758918762,
-0.09080298244953156,
-0.16725504398345947,
0.9039674997329712,
0.7442623376846313,
-0.001319920178502798,
0.48508504033088684,
-0.3600755035877228,
0.5543359518051147,
0.9981663823127747,
0.20397450029850006,
-0.5432355403900146,
-0.4825756847858429,
0.044333115220069885,
-0.212196484208107,
-0.060963910073041916,
-0.8199883103370667,
0.44321373105049133,
0.6291355490684509,
0.44801270961761475,
0.35151997208595276,
0.13929611444473267,
0.7705397605895996,
-0.7286744713783264,
0.8333996534347534,
-0.14960786700248718,
-1.087066888809204,
1.171972632408142,
-0.45113012194633484,
0.6104634404182434,
0.38412633538246155,
0.23546749353408813,
-0.3283205032348633,
-0.7197117209434509,
-0.6504266858100891,
-0.6554257869720459,
0.48426470160484314,
0.244172602891922,
-0.2965072691440582,
0.3947043716907501,
-0.05752401426434517,
0.5803641676902771,
0.1405937373638153,
0.08440995216369629,
-0.0915106013417244,
-0.7151488661766052,
-0.2549780011177063,
-0.2831318974494934,
-0.3044827878475189,
0.28727057576179504,
-0.5265916585922241,
0.49106189608573914,
-0.12249623984098434,
-0.006263806950300932,
0.29962339997291565,
-0.26880383491516113,
-0.13230006396770477,
0.0235101580619812,
0.36847618222236633,
0.7961558699607849,
-0.6473281979560852,
0.24561092257499695,
0.32610297203063965,
-1.1523338556289673,
0.23176172375679016,
0.2959273159503937,
-0.10642947256565094,
0.6894981861114502,
0.5517325401306152,
0.6819403171539307,
0.1022447720170021,
-0.723146915435791,
0.25448518991470337,
-0.34986501932144165,
-0.0702953040599823,
-0.592830240726471,
0.3414548635482788,
-0.12502843141555786,
0.01663532294332981,
0.822119414806366,
-0.1599697768688202,
0.6737914085388184,
-0.40529099106788635,
0.197560653090477,
-0.030163325369358063,
-0.5276300311088562,
-0.5164398550987244,
0.7447604537010193,
0.2740260362625122,
-0.7646273970603943,
0.47400447726249695,
0.17198653519153595,
-0.5162471532821655,
0.48899203538894653,
0.416662335395813,
1.1149351596832275,
-1.1468815803527832,
0.16466917097568512,
0.26928970217704773,
0.23570941388607025,
-0.18609939515590668,
0.6680236458778381,
-0.12079153954982758,
-0.4175414443016052,
0.006937639322131872,
-0.49356332421302795,
-0.9722274541854858,
0.2683087885379791,
-0.8365383744239807,
0.6499708890914917,
-0.02207716926932335,
-0.41687634587287903,
0.23605558276176453,
0.2442728728055954,
-0.3675898611545563,
0.25221651792526245,
0.03427164629101753,
1.0277142524719238,
-0.5585185885429382,
0.8226519823074341,
0.8146089911460876,
-0.0032574038486927748,
-0.4911673367023468,
0.21349027752876282,
0.2848573923110962,
-0.8150371313095093,
-0.05341101810336113,
0.28697678446769714,
-0.5773632526397705,
0.30979087948799133,
-0.428142786026001,
-0.585072934627533,
0.9162927865982056,
0.3405037522315979,
-0.6836426258087158,
0.21394683420658112,
-0.15181905031204224,
0.46817630529403687,
-0.2559524476528168,
-0.0968950018286705,
0.950149416923523,
0.4735616147518158,
-0.15666325390338898,
-1.6502329111099243,
-0.4923858344554901,
-0.47008228302001953,
0.08616318553686142,
-0.2707115113735199,
-0.6997128129005432,
0.8363247513771057,
-0.247234046459198,
-0.2024969458580017,
0.19380024075508118,
0.4991896450519562,
0.4833190441131592,
0.476113498210907,
0.6417917013168335,
0.05812051519751549,
1.1975045204162598,
0.039434436708688736,
0.6096802353858948,
-0.21128788590431213,
0.06091977655887604,
1.244670033454895,
-0.4423418641090393,
1.0988070964813232,
0.2053699791431427,
-0.345572292804718,
0.3705174922943115,
0.6606261730194092,
-0.05694226920604706,
0.5719797015190125,
-0.17614829540252686,
-0.20775839686393738,
0.09039895981550217,
-0.10657785832881927,
-0.4724278748035431,
0.961845338344574,
0.4292168915271759,
0.2133590281009674,
0.3073791265487671,
0.33312469720840454,
-0.03245142847299576,
0.02052329108119011,
-0.213428795337677,
1.1149636507034302,
0.047218941152095795,
-0.16803410649299622,
0.6561060547828674,
-0.3144678771495819,
1.0235153436660767,
-0.9180489778518677,
-0.16762228310108185,
0.2602865397930145,
0.40557339787483215,
-0.2440878003835678,
-0.6667450666427612,
0.19897910952568054,
-0.22034737467765808,
-0.2629453241825104,
0.1499432623386383,
1.0048680305480957,
-0.4884318709373474,
-0.5585759282112122,
0.4895915985107422,
0.36085671186447144,
0.07832673192024231,
-0.21062490344047546,
-0.580359160900116,
0.47053882479667664,
-0.33167287707328796,
-0.07749591022729874,
-0.23113757371902466,
0.5679729580879211,
0.1652795672416687,
0.706258237361908,
0.3771604001522064,
0.4231204390525818,
0.1596975177526474,
0.05800112336874008,
0.3870116174221039,
-0.5881701707839966,
-0.95289146900177,
-0.7061247229576111,
0.39631855487823486,
-0.281049519777298,
-0.6542448997497559,
1.3139902353286743,
0.7760786414146423,
0.7924342155456543,
-0.18500782549381256,
0.9808110594749451,
0.43374425172805786,
1.0605807304382324,
-0.15501345694065094,
0.6511212587356567,
-0.345348984003067,
-0.23598121106624603,
-0.4218209683895111,
-0.7800439596176147,
-0.1820153146982193,
0.9570330381393433,
0.029339350759983063,
-0.22424155473709106,
0.4651040732860565,
0.6923224925994873,
-0.1879231333732605,
0.15026135742664337,
0.45626166462898254,
0.31868863105773926,
0.17127150297164917,
0.2442941665649414,
1.025418996810913,
-0.597812831401825,
0.4206264019012451,
-0.623391330242157,
-0.08748015016317368,
-0.6369579434394836,
-0.5011980533599854,
-0.8068422675132751,
-1.0039886236190796,
-0.4181062877178192,
-0.08675297349691391,
0.45027852058410645,
0.996219277381897,
1.1652108430862427,
-1.1806358098983765,
-0.7219003438949585,
0.31958749890327454,
-0.11214012652635574,
-0.43343886733055115,
-0.31065550446510315,
0.4616440534591675,
0.01151319220662117,
-0.837149977684021,
0.6278350949287415,
0.4423844516277313,
0.21037182211875916,
-0.12829196453094482,
-0.3728746771812439,
0.2425418496131897,
0.09407000988721848,
0.6582418084144592,
0.33128368854522705,
-0.6013233065605164,
-0.18691153824329376,
-0.11787104606628418,
-0.004520141985267401,
0.10456066578626633,
0.6866377592086792,
-0.8209064602851868,
0.7400783896446228,
0.4391717314720154,
0.0007729540811851621,
0.4473426938056946,
0.06056402623653412,
0.7242342233657837,
-0.5473933815956116,
0.6614378094673157,
0.46471384167671204,
0.41818076372146606,
0.6858992576599121,
-0.17645832896232605,
0.5028778314590454,
0.1786360889673233,
-0.7293400764465332,
-1.1730691194534302,
-0.04632776230573654,
-0.8793240785598755,
-0.03052327409386635,
1.0541234016418457,
0.2230706661939621,
-0.12082032859325409,
-0.7404710650444031,
-0.8665053248405457,
-0.12129216641187668,
-0.791461706161499,
0.6230717897415161,
0.5168866515159607,
-0.26384150981903076,
-0.288686066865921,
-0.6177874803543091,
0.9397789239883423,
-0.37063443660736084,
-0.40498635172843933,
-0.1264733076095581,
0.2717190682888031,
0.44837814569473267,
0.12215223163366318,
0.9078793525695801,
0.2081557959318161,
0.6277984380722046,
0.27904680371284485,
-0.25141388177871704,
0.18930861353874207,
-0.42541006207466125,
-0.45932698249816895,
0.026528291404247284,
0.22259244322776794,
-0.5873621702194214
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18525v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18525v1
|
Language Plays a Pivotal Role in the Object-Attribute Compositional Generalization of CLIP
| 2024-03-27T12:59:44 | 2024-03-27T12:59:44 |
Reza Abbasi, Mohammad Samiei, Mohammad Hossein Rohban, Mahdieh Soleymani Baghshah
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Vision-language models, such as CLIP, have shown promising
Out-of-Distribution (OoD) generalization under various types of distribution
shifts. Recent studies attempted to investigate the leading cause of this
capability. In this work, we follow the same path, but focus on a specific type
of OoD data - images with novel compositions of attribute-object pairs - and
study whether such models can successfully classify those images into
composition classes. We carefully designed an authentic image test dataset
called ImageNet-AO, consisting of attributes for objects that are unlikely
encountered in the CLIP training sets. We found that CLIPs trained with large
datasets such as OpenAI CLIP, LAION-400M, and LAION-2B show orders-of-magnitude
improvement in effective compositional OoD generalization compared to both
supervised models and CLIPs trained with smaller datasets, such as CC-12M and
YFCC-15M. Our results provide evidence that the scale and diversity of training
data and language supervision play a key role in unlocking the compositional
generalization abilities of vision-language models.
|
[
-0.42239895462989807,
-0.45140352845191956,
0.28589993715286255,
0.13659079372882843,
-0.10685114562511444,
0.12190740555524826,
-0.2851220667362213,
-0.6410987973213196,
-0.042034249752759933,
0.518774151802063,
-0.13758565485477448,
-0.3856183886528015,
-0.5219734907150269,
-0.11259734630584717,
-0.6086407899856567,
0.6961377859115601,
-0.2433091402053833,
0.086695097386837,
-0.10815468430519104,
-0.5796220898628235,
-0.5442678332328796,
-0.32521674036979675,
-0.2192356288433075,
-0.07084672898054123,
0.17096224427223206,
0.22070005536079407,
0.7817394137382507,
0.9781352877616882,
0.7133886814117432,
0.2223302125930786,
0.16982538998126984,
0.2701387107372284,
-0.4246562719345093,
-0.23765040934085846,
-0.3731980621814728,
-0.6991281509399414,
-0.29739293456077576,
0.011144362390041351,
0.7495087385177612,
0.7213641405105591,
-0.17756088078022003,
-0.019026927649974823,
-0.12550075352191925,
0.5229559540748596,
-1.0247012376785278,
0.19465665519237518,
-0.642733633518219,
0.16761735081672668,
-0.2511022090911865,
0.17551860213279724,
-0.5226951241493225,
0.17239269614219666,
0.31361064314842224,
-0.5791175365447998,
0.43835175037384033,
0.19067440927028656,
0.9340066909790039,
-0.12087424844503403,
-0.17852891981601715,
-0.16885270178318024,
-0.6415327787399292,
1.0565822124481201,
-0.3809349834918976,
0.28332993388175964,
0.35342463850975037,
0.32245028018951416,
0.32980385422706604,
-0.28437724709510803,
-0.4522287845611572,
0.15802502632141113,
0.08590757846832275,
-0.02617991529405117,
0.0861673653125763,
-0.05061058700084686,
0.012342732399702072,
0.6669512987136841,
-0.2143334448337555,
0.25323617458343506,
-0.43803420662879944,
0.19154593348503113,
0.7616644501686096,
0.3067796230316162,
0.7639925479888916,
0.07640928030014038,
-0.424776166677475,
-0.49240437150001526,
-0.735214352607727,
0.014690411277115345,
0.41565975546836853,
-0.0437505766749382,
-0.167995423078537,
0.6800647377967834,
0.028161372989416122,
0.7859699726104736,
-0.013587919995188713,
-0.2642996907234192,
0.08259395509958267,
-0.302531898021698,
-0.10939054191112518,
-0.07855098694562912,
0.920301079750061,
0.5451272130012512,
0.19289061427116394,
-0.1877468377351761,
-0.17375548183918,
0.01696774922311306,
-0.04046281427145004,
-0.8836800456047058,
-0.5256798267364502,
-0.17940348386764526,
-0.5055149793624878,
-0.38767513632774353,
0.5273012518882751,
-0.32414519786834717,
-0.21581047773361206,
-0.28135108947753906,
0.5042809247970581,
-0.5001077055931091,
-0.2227822095155716,
0.4890056550502777,
-0.3316049575805664,
0.34482577443122864,
0.15825819969177246,
-1.1208369731903076,
0.26575160026550293,
0.6329380869865417,
1.0338952541351318,
-0.6769133806228638,
-0.4353252351284027,
-0.2329827845096588,
0.24870625138282776,
-0.5879154801368713,
0.8616987466812134,
-0.5994430184364319,
-0.21030190587043762,
-0.1529754102230072,
0.0791996568441391,
-0.2973632216453552,
-0.9507079720497131,
-0.02453259937465191,
-0.3842504918575287,
0.062251292169094086,
-0.19590795040130615,
-0.49263209104537964,
-0.2688126862049103,
-0.0022881559561938047,
-0.8031916618347168,
0.9165630340576172,
0.36456766724586487,
-0.7437000274658203,
0.625285267829895,
-0.5376209020614624,
-0.4276416003704071,
-0.10426000505685806,
-0.42381343245506287,
-0.4786646366119385,
0.198395237326622,
0.37475207448005676,
0.5001885294914246,
-0.3019031882286072,
0.019323598593473434,
-0.6411606669425964,
-0.39830175042152405,
0.6528825163841248,
0.0239688940346241,
0.47151175141334534,
-0.028978688642382622,
-0.1683087795972824,
-0.36557701230049133,
-0.5987939834594727,
-0.24832642078399658,
0.23768264055252075,
0.04446549341082573,
-0.5798304677009583,
0.008103945292532444,
-0.16181693971157074,
-0.10527234524488449,
-0.19312746822834015,
-0.6839422583580017,
0.05805029720067978,
-0.2678166925907135,
0.41873490810394287,
0.6560692191123962,
-0.039319563657045364,
0.7774115800857544,
-0.34169164299964905,
0.5048806071281433,
0.22850383818149567,
0.2098148614168167,
-0.5090371370315552,
-0.4168435037136078,
-0.7111151814460754,
-0.503555417060852,
-0.06860660761594772,
0.4614550769329071,
-0.8269883394241333,
0.37998634576797485,
-0.16751842200756073,
-0.35237348079681396,
-0.30640339851379395,
0.24972663819789886,
0.4726904332637787,
0.5199525952339172,
0.24271400272846222,
-0.6416066884994507,
-0.25820422172546387,
-0.8407188057899475,
0.18583737313747406,
-0.09271625429391861,
0.01113896258175373,
0.49831172823905945,
0.4071377217769623,
-0.08248566091060638,
1.3183523416519165,
-1.1936620473861694,
-0.5589155554771423,
-0.3807714283466339,
-0.05114060640335083,
-0.053925056010484695,
0.360146164894104,
1.0993099212646484,
-0.7247504591941833,
-0.652422308921814,
0.19623754918575287,
-0.8529569506645203,
0.053272753953933716,
0.2477375566959381,
-0.40460604429244995,
-0.04413013160228729,
0.22629675269126892,
-0.06338877230882645,
0.45393654704093933,
0.4450579881668091,
-0.008754757232964039,
0.42521145939826965,
-0.09999363869428635,
0.03513301536440849,
-0.8219305872917175,
-0.1064472645521164,
-0.14122287929058075,
-0.04667862877249718,
-0.5653337240219116,
0.140108123421669,
-0.023101510480046272,
-0.3357624113559723,
-0.8257312178611755,
0.2810158133506775,
-0.3892079293727875,
-0.2258269488811493,
-0.3919220566749573,
-0.32970160245895386,
0.2886229455471039,
0.45421355962753296,
0.4016667306423187,
0.8615873456001282,
1.0521587133407593,
-0.646855354309082,
0.4600723385810852,
0.5490766763687134,
-0.6322194337844849,
0.7433481216430664,
-0.839907705783844,
0.0599287673830986,
-0.43007132411003113,
-0.018838051706552505,
-0.7918975353240967,
-0.3864383399486542,
0.03132504224777222,
0.2644535303115845,
0.2270572930574417,
-0.1334543526172638,
-0.3473708927631378,
-0.04359736666083336,
-0.4651629626750946,
0.9230058193206787,
0.48624011874198914,
-0.5680402517318726,
0.4885511100292206,
0.38741666078567505,
0.25862571597099304,
-0.5260195732116699,
-1.0358059406280518,
-0.403831422328949,
-0.21792247891426086,
-0.6513505578041077,
0.29442963004112244,
0.04453284665942192,
-0.07961655408143997,
0.202296644449234,
0.18676581978797913,
-0.33298400044441223,
-0.16538845002651215,
0.18140047788619995,
0.36355316638946533,
-0.3592158555984497,
0.12475140392780304,
-0.18241947889328003,
0.4388168752193451,
-0.19985118508338928,
-0.1647198647260666,
0.4973362684249878,
-0.11285332590341568,
-0.4423099458217621,
-0.10063973814249039,
0.4301909804344177,
0.24051128327846527,
-0.3559255301952362,
0.8514708876609802,
0.5618271231651306,
0.12337284535169601,
-0.5452467203140259,
-0.2869414985179901,
-0.055853355675935745,
-0.41413289308547974,
0.6006507277488708,
-0.12063060700893402,
-0.6106529235839844,
0.6219879984855652,
0.5256311297416687,
-0.1935204714536667,
0.15233969688415527,
0.10353020578622818,
-0.1924733817577362,
0.7583132982254028,
0.5332686305046082,
-0.2502778470516205,
1.001214861869812,
-0.8962679505348206,
-0.12560543417930603,
-1.0378293991088867,
-0.10228908807039261,
0.03407139331102371,
-0.3493795096874237,
-0.2566400468349457,
-0.5721210241317749,
0.46397024393081665,
-0.0654880553483963,
0.19781777262687683,
0.4826503396034241,
-0.3040907680988312,
0.8779515027999878,
0.3131854832172394,
0.5818061828613281,
0.06483123451471329,
0.16038453578948975,
0.3447384238243103,
0.2580321431159973,
-0.45003920793533325,
0.03672829642891884,
1.3486078977584839,
0.31100448966026306,
1.1035221815109253,
-0.0022481544874608517,
0.5448645949363708,
0.28600046038627625,
0.04727008938789368,
-0.8100735545158386,
0.5954576730728149,
-0.7248432040214539,
-0.4277532398700714,
-0.13576117157936096,
-0.21203754842281342,
-0.7358858585357666,
0.35715317726135254,
0.01525505818426609,
-0.3964810073375702,
0.49681511521339417,
0.28210899233818054,
-0.11205513775348663,
0.5089595317840576,
-0.7497764825820923,
0.8540667295455933,
-0.2997593879699707,
-0.09227912873029709,
0.08759477734565735,
-0.513677179813385,
0.5037006735801697,
-0.010878430679440498,
0.0589444562792778,
-0.32942816615104675,
-0.11684581637382507,
0.5893320441246033,
-0.5917893052101135,
0.7523525953292847,
0.046219345182180405,
-0.14240121841430664,
0.7494043111801147,
0.004114202689379454,
0.1989838182926178,
-0.18084511160850525,
0.4073683023452759,
0.04885116592049599,
-0.16861316561698914,
-0.35014691948890686,
-0.880391001701355,
0.15568643808364868,
-0.9045992493629456,
-0.11480274796485901,
0.01843644678592682,
-0.5400508642196655,
-0.1014467179775238,
-0.14985379576683044,
0.5322059392929077,
0.8934810161590576,
-0.02964545227587223,
0.5037757754325867,
0.8505696654319763,
-0.11367858946323395,
0.46512138843536377,
0.22606292366981506,
-0.38297250866889954,
-0.5596076250076294,
1.2572402954101562,
0.14684543013572693,
0.7212309837341309,
0.5675085186958313,
0.4166307747364044,
-0.13347114622592926,
-0.43756812810897827,
-0.41463473439216614,
0.1945153921842575,
-0.9807696342468262,
-0.22742711007595062,
-0.46668708324432373,
-0.04226365312933922,
-0.32261553406715393,
-0.11983126401901245,
-0.4000874161720276,
-0.20175309479236603,
-0.518604040145874,
-0.04362967237830162,
0.2147722840309143,
0.7632541656494141,
0.2700408399105072,
0.3986377418041229,
-0.6132300496101379,
0.29995959997177124,
0.5372138619422913,
0.26288893818855286,
0.0965954139828682,
-0.5015510320663452,
-0.31847575306892395,
-0.1453525424003601,
-0.3935191333293915,
-0.8293396234512329,
0.12827198207378387,
0.9405971765518188,
0.4624032974243164,
0.8529263734817505,
-0.03205933794379234,
0.667971134185791,
-0.26007506251335144,
0.8159445524215698,
0.33152735233306885,
-0.8114702105522156,
0.3711734414100647,
-0.36799269914627075,
0.06267732381820679,
0.36363404989242554,
0.08449938893318176,
-0.4661196768283844,
-0.4906638562679291,
-0.36896347999572754,
-0.6632550954818726,
0.9781185388565063,
0.0383717343211174,
0.20931965112686157,
-0.08933593332767487,
-0.03411716967821121,
0.32445773482322693,
0.2694490849971771,
-0.5719500184059143,
-0.1050734594464302,
-0.4422912001609802,
-0.2614522874355316,
0.014228981919586658,
-0.1331431120634079,
0.12596769630908966,
-0.07233899086713791,
0.24802498519420624,
-0.234848290681839,
0.16826757788658142,
0.05031287670135498,
-0.25464823842048645,
0.277493953704834,
0.10897894203662872,
0.6878923177719116,
0.4400985538959503,
-0.1071244403719902,
0.2108646035194397,
-0.021333198994398117,
-0.6422051787376404,
0.3853508532047272,
-0.4738208055496216,
-0.5100454688072205,
-0.1425924003124237,
0.4566856920719147,
1.083142638206482,
0.1798715889453888,
-0.7493940591812134,
0.9843084216117859,
0.41289860010147095,
-0.17558740079402924,
0.04073752835392952,
0.40214839577674866,
-0.4345536231994629,
-0.07985055446624756,
0.22265802323818207,
0.06599918007850647,
0.33473068475723267,
-0.8760976195335388,
-0.0015282467938959599,
0.33778494596481323,
-0.18931476771831512,
-0.7280289530754089,
0.3229830861091614,
-0.05402141064405441,
0.43714067339897156,
0.41419342160224915,
-0.22895853221416473,
-0.5018422603607178,
0.58389812707901,
0.559942901134491,
0.8335258364677429,
0.08330149948596954,
0.417330801486969,
0.023258402943611145,
-0.017277739942073822,
-0.49803242087364197,
0.2072937935590744,
-0.11267707496881485,
-0.9556699395179749,
-0.26274606585502625,
-0.33222532272338867,
-0.2885681390762329,
-0.19870688021183014,
-0.7841582894325256,
0.22958485782146454,
-0.39422598481178284,
-0.07026061415672302,
-0.32228752970695496,
-0.8701837062835693,
-0.5986077189445496,
0.16847696900367737,
0.07007752358913422,
0.49219900369644165,
-1.2223573923110962,
0.5415864586830139,
0.7684696316719055,
-0.45610958337783813,
-0.9078192114830017,
-0.21157203614711761,
-0.6114375591278076,
-0.7690308690071106,
1.0514732599258423,
0.1634170114994049,
-0.028843557462096214,
-0.31794214248657227,
-0.713862419128418,
-0.7969678044319153,
0.9447097182273865,
0.637825071811676,
0.04076787829399109,
-0.10437492281198502,
0.5159275531768799,
0.33793842792510986,
-0.551167905330658,
0.12309776246547699,
0.42039763927459717,
0.004053259734064341,
0.3993041515350342,
-0.8855591416358948,
-0.3806180953979492,
0.1432114839553833,
0.5005119442939758,
0.3525559604167938,
-0.856652021408081,
1.1086227893829346,
-0.04118504002690315,
-0.30141863226890564,
0.025557324290275574,
0.602634608745575,
-0.10286351293325424,
0.1868463158607483,
0.3525838255882263,
0.7670677900314331,
0.14507853984832764,
-0.08447159081697464,
0.8553983569145203,
0.24914661049842834,
0.36566200852394104,
0.9762417078018188,
-0.3083115518093109,
0.8441646695137024,
0.2739914655685425,
-0.29119613766670227,
0.6812386512756348,
0.13015396893024445,
-0.4070413410663605,
0.7518162131309509,
-0.07581819593906403,
-0.2570796012878418,
-0.20015260577201843,
-0.5333723425865173,
-0.20441237092018127,
0.7793158888816833,
-0.013909561559557915,
-0.49926838278770447,
-0.013789445161819458,
0.6279313564300537,
-0.21711629629135132,
0.09622418880462646,
-0.4879004657268524,
0.8323851823806763,
-0.1241052970290184,
-0.43295419216156006,
0.3644513189792633,
-0.15496747195720673,
0.6363339424133301,
-0.4381866753101349,
0.10221746563911438,
-0.2110900729894638,
0.34899064898490906,
-0.1666780412197113,
-1.0326706171035767,
0.2583952248096466,
-0.31962546706199646,
-0.14709031581878662,
-0.019563063979148865,
0.5896913409233093,
-0.6042254567146301,
-0.4123910367488861,
-0.10069622844457626,
-0.21077774465084076,
0.043678853660821915,
-0.23430588841438293,
-0.23178118467330933,
0.22771728038787842,
-0.4022856652736664,
0.2934603989124298,
0.2528073489665985,
0.32679858803749084,
-0.1779899299144745,
0.5529806613922119,
0.2775040566921234,
0.2703377902507782,
0.3179705739021301,
-0.23146013915538788,
0.8007614612579346,
-0.38443800806999207,
-0.6033774018287659,
-0.7891629934310913,
0.2892026901245117,
-0.11985829472541809,
-0.13007807731628418,
0.5371479392051697,
0.6902645230293274,
1.057802438735962,
-0.7935158610343933,
0.6194404363632202,
-0.16050949692726135,
0.116363525390625,
-0.759522557258606,
0.41965773701667786,
-0.4012473523616791,
-0.25022992491722107,
-0.36237984895706177,
-0.8730913400650024,
-0.17667368054389954,
0.2985787093639374,
-0.23286227881908417,
-0.1267683207988739,
0.7069125175476074,
0.628567099571228,
-0.32991889119148254,
-0.30334222316741943,
0.39678841829299927,
-0.5490841865539551,
0.447221964597702,
0.6923372745513916,
0.9968605637550354,
-0.648658275604248,
0.6038877367973328,
-0.4661622941493988,
0.03431585058569908,
-0.29980751872062683,
-0.8009466528892517,
-1.1921072006225586,
-0.5500373840332031,
-0.5090373754501343,
0.16492250561714172,
-0.22701194882392883,
0.6714268326759338,
1.1339622735977173,
-0.8045048713684082,
-0.27125298976898193,
-0.08800134062767029,
-0.2556811273097992,
-0.2218666821718216,
-0.18483243882656097,
0.28748825192451477,
-0.110379658639431,
-0.6145616173744202,
0.13970670104026794,
0.5117377042770386,
0.5145483016967773,
-0.28558093309402466,
-0.030904991552233696,
0.4140738546848297,
-0.005293300841003656,
0.5519034266471863,
0.35405904054641724,
-0.6529954671859741,
-0.15181739628314972,
0.1880408078432083,
0.019569898024201393,
0.22940543293952942,
1.182332158088684,
-0.29233062267303467,
0.5439496040344238,
0.6338288187980652,
0.59565669298172,
0.23421217501163483,
0.23695458471775055,
0.5331289768218994,
-1.1127300262451172,
0.5266973376274109,
-0.12455324828624725,
0.5016278028488159,
0.37232354283332825,
-0.0029801111668348312,
0.4013763964176178,
0.49873265624046326,
-0.21705208718776703,
-0.8151015639305115,
0.5337285995483398,
-1.0901869535446167,
-0.04035179316997528,
1.129148244857788,
-0.29151326417922974,
-0.5153799057006836,
0.1922139823436737,
-0.4228833019733429,
-0.31039589643478394,
-0.2947489321231842,
0.46890226006507874,
0.6123566031455994,
0.02516922727227211,
-0.4790055453777313,
0.20450639724731445,
0.11345325410366058,
0.12418684363365173,
-0.8797617554664612,
-0.0934782549738884,
0.35127371549606323,
0.28117671608924866,
0.13336560130119324,
0.3237763047218323,
-0.13725082576274872,
0.3289189338684082,
-0.17674270272254944,
-0.12924638390541077,
-0.3357175588607788,
-0.3542945384979248,
0.0526903010904789,
0.2442810982465744,
0.21806886792182922,
-0.7293928861618042
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18504v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18504v1
|
AcTED: Automatic Acquisition of Typical Event Duration for Semi-supervised Temporal Commonsense QA
| 2024-03-27T12:33:42 | 2024-03-27T12:33:42 |
Felix Virgo, Fei Cheng, Lis Kanashiro Pereira, Masayuki Asahara, Ichiro Kobayashi, Sadao Kurohashi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We propose a voting-driven semi-supervised approach to automatically acquire
the typical duration of an event and use it as pseudo-labeled data. The human
evaluation demonstrates that our pseudo labels exhibit surprisingly high
accuracy and balanced coverage. In the temporal commonsense QA task,
experimental results show that using only pseudo examples of 400 events, we
achieve performance comparable to the existing BERT-based weakly supervised
approaches that require a significant amount of training examples. When
compared to the RoBERTa baselines, our best approach establishes
state-of-the-art performance with a 7% improvement in Exact Match.
|
[
-0.14030566811561584,
-1.0158610343933105,
0.8088064789772034,
-0.08815566450357437,
-0.6352454423904419,
-0.20413890480995178,
0.11477512866258621,
-0.7292867302894592,
0.17607957124710083,
-0.13065828382968903,
-0.32765328884124756,
-0.43012142181396484,
-0.2888525426387787,
0.12119946628808975,
-0.5194573998451233,
1.0244596004486084,
0.22901767492294312,
-0.17947356402873993,
0.059976186603307724,
-0.3027058243751526,
0.06772402673959732,
-0.5071567893028259,
-0.8043534755706787,
-0.1010669693350792,
0.4023105800151825,
0.44975417852401733,
0.7792552709579468,
0.3511227071285248,
-0.006488242652267218,
0.36143672466278076,
-0.13503442704677582,
0.4418867230415344,
-0.4104333817958832,
-0.6673052310943604,
-0.1867981106042862,
-0.31535977125167847,
-0.5949565172195435,
0.5272889137268066,
0.8635923266410828,
0.5069307684898376,
-0.21626128256320953,
0.31896844506263733,
-0.49227309226989746,
0.3498731553554535,
-0.5303969979286194,
0.24403972923755646,
-0.28105005621910095,
0.3746023178100586,
-0.32358595728874207,
-0.3772779107093811,
-0.4091375470161438,
-0.32162514328956604,
0.34145718812942505,
-1.083453893661499,
0.28097817301750183,
0.29993149638175964,
0.9916093349456787,
0.026782304048538208,
-0.6699538230895996,
-0.02708457224071026,
-0.7587155103683472,
1.0936203002929688,
-0.7465292811393738,
0.17777204513549805,
0.4760443866252899,
0.3757650852203369,
-0.12496452033519745,
-1.4453171491622925,
-0.936704158782959,
-0.24618791043758392,
-0.20601773262023926,
0.21287228167057037,
-0.4691476821899414,
0.2629024386405945,
0.4132448136806488,
0.14141465723514557,
-0.6683902144432068,
0.1464342176914215,
-0.307632178068161,
-0.2889578342437744,
0.7700632810592651,
0.4205252230167389,
0.5926330089569092,
-0.365315318107605,
-0.3215042054653168,
0.10065599530935287,
-0.2868384122848511,
0.11903232336044312,
0.3544607162475586,
-0.008885306306183338,
-0.2109408676624298,
0.6390070915222168,
-0.46139413118362427,
1.1012988090515137,
0.17551036179065704,
0.13513752818107605,
0.17812900245189667,
-0.48937511444091797,
-0.2905261516571045,
-0.06627090275287628,
0.642192542552948,
0.3450532853603363,
0.3793155252933502,
-0.24857613444328308,
-0.240837961435318,
-0.09710738807916641,
0.09028580784797668,
-0.4002629518508911,
-0.6491936445236206,
0.31189486384391785,
-0.28577160835266113,
-0.18583333492279053,
0.02465280517935753,
-0.6498215794563293,
0.1712166666984558,
-0.81711745262146,
0.8661261200904846,
-0.16894695162773132,
0.06760374456644058,
-0.12477361410856247,
-0.3442470133304596,
0.3959342837333679,
0.4033256471157074,
-0.2008693665266037,
0.03179143741726875,
0.4227295219898224,
0.7444119453430176,
-0.3706526458263397,
-0.14546357095241547,
-0.9503620266914368,
0.1684134602546692,
-0.48130467534065247,
0.8258721232414246,
-0.5141343474388123,
-0.3433553874492645,
-0.11362850666046143,
0.07409588247537613,
-0.12152161449193954,
-0.39881640672683716,
0.37229129672050476,
-0.927805483341217,
0.37812310457229614,
0.14626699686050415,
-0.7033244371414185,
0.23913729190826416,
0.16899000108242035,
-0.5841030478477478,
1.1381081342697144,
0.08684023469686508,
-0.45590144395828247,
0.8038093447685242,
-0.6581722497940063,
-0.5195932388305664,
0.13335947692394257,
0.11195199936628342,
-0.6727240681648254,
-0.18863724172115326,
0.4345914125442505,
0.41364842653274536,
0.4781968593597412,
0.36717626452445984,
-0.40894463658332825,
-0.600568950176239,
0.49495041370391846,
-0.5240594744682312,
0.7685450315475464,
0.20798644423484802,
-0.2258777916431427,
0.31908920407295227,
-0.9676145911216736,
-0.010506866499781609,
-0.0885874330997467,
-0.07349926233291626,
-0.3127938508987427,
0.09919314086437225,
0.1666497141122818,
0.19505193829536438,
0.38313356041908264,
-0.7011234760284424,
0.12597061693668365,
-0.42179349064826965,
0.1978381872177124,
0.7416359782218933,
0.624708890914917,
0.6681406497955322,
-0.41237854957580566,
0.18999265134334564,
0.02170337736606598,
0.6798737645149231,
0.6033808588981628,
-0.5317133069038391,
-0.5016659498214722,
-0.4641658067703247,
0.2706774175167084,
0.4286727011203766,
-0.9700115323066711,
0.19189028441905975,
-0.25525012612342834,
-0.40369948744773865,
-0.127121701836586,
0.12813103199005127,
0.4032317101955414,
0.6510708332061768,
0.5791204571723938,
-0.10252394527196884,
-0.4501977860927582,
-0.8272045850753784,
-0.0562167651951313,
-0.6562492251396179,
-0.09086103737354279,
0.37183529138565063,
0.29408028721809387,
-0.041650500148534775,
1.2853119373321533,
-0.5496731400489807,
-0.457526296377182,
-0.20366042852401733,
0.9198384284973145,
0.24439910054206848,
0.22263193130493164,
0.6664175987243652,
-1.0853395462036133,
-0.3436167240142822,
-0.3973356783390045,
-0.5446160435676575,
-0.3347180187702179,
-0.30364447832107544,
0.031805362552404404,
0.40419262647628784,
0.33978143334388733,
-0.059889618307352066,
0.6347445845603943,
0.43776342272758484,
-0.45749950408935547,
0.6195144653320312,
-0.28679159283638,
0.34508809447288513,
-0.6588085889816284,
0.04022430628538132,
-0.18867342174053192,
-0.64839768409729,
-0.60079026222229,
-0.42953598499298096,
-0.05581793561577797,
-0.0708569884300232,
-1.0877020359039307,
0.737877607345581,
-0.413527250289917,
-0.34253817796707153,
-0.1749228835105896,
0.2585894763469696,
-0.3919113278388977,
0.5384911298751831,
0.6031813025474548,
0.8191556334495544,
0.07970598340034485,
-1.014414668083191,
0.36476609110832214,
0.07619960606098175,
-0.3758302927017212,
0.6477925777435303,
-0.6927526593208313,
0.3896401524543762,
0.11762875318527222,
0.3917894959449768,
-0.9562390446662903,
-0.336761474609375,
-0.023615991696715355,
-0.4869994521141052,
0.1835564225912094,
-0.522567868232727,
-0.8077955842018127,
-0.25407013297080994,
0.07717439532279968,
0.46830180287361145,
0.6618622541427612,
-0.5946335792541504,
0.7030826807022095,
0.4440000653266907,
0.16296498477458954,
-0.31423747539520264,
-0.4218705892562866,
0.1597362607717514,
-0.12537924945354462,
-0.41204142570495605,
0.1480497121810913,
0.0724276527762413,
-0.2055278718471527,
0.22988058626651764,
-0.08053326606750488,
-0.4962446987628937,
-0.07627055048942566,
-0.04522380977869034,
0.18208052217960358,
-0.10002630949020386,
0.059691935777664185,
0.06809086352586746,
-0.1185324490070343,
-0.23642981052398682,
-0.07574319839477539,
0.030956173315644264,
-0.046497974544763565,
-0.34361985325813293,
-0.9811208248138428,
0.09143861383199692,
0.321003258228302,
0.03667640686035156,
0.5595470666885376,
0.5371975302696228,
-0.31150612235069275,
-0.47821077704429626,
-0.3880366384983063,
-0.18770362436771393,
-0.46123987436294556,
0.08606276661157608,
-0.14037251472473145,
-0.7372159957885742,
0.42966485023498535,
0.08760062605142593,
0.1766704022884369,
0.4110970199108124,
0.2829079329967499,
-0.8367120027542114,
0.908408522605896,
0.26888495683670044,
-0.004816652275621891,
0.7370386123657227,
-0.26178252696990967,
-0.11842910200357437,
-0.4841848909854889,
0.06732752919197083,
-0.2600207030773163,
-0.4818861484527588,
-0.22090454399585724,
-0.6495957970619202,
0.6294636130332947,
-0.14430749416351318,
0.09277104586362839,
0.18611757457256317,
-0.20191596448421478,
0.3035760819911957,
0.573188304901123,
0.3395417630672455,
0.24543866515159607,
-0.6635770797729492,
0.3138121962547302,
-0.036864351481199265,
-0.740584671497345,
-0.4536657929420471,
0.9698081016540527,
-0.08889618515968323,
0.33330070972442627,
0.3047231137752533,
0.6818894147872925,
0.9579460024833679,
0.3921337425708771,
-0.4807898700237274,
0.6135549545288086,
-0.10617585480213165,
-0.9696540832519531,
-0.8449481129646301,
-0.3768616318702698,
-0.9249812960624695,
-0.3607480823993683,
-0.04963790997862816,
-0.6772666573524475,
0.41233471035957336,
0.49362418055534363,
-0.22361664474010468,
0.1827988177537918,
-0.7054318189620972,
0.8051541447639465,
-0.0887724831700325,
-0.30323106050491333,
-0.25678861141204834,
-0.843366801738739,
0.2250198870897293,
-0.20944389700889587,
0.10837475955486298,
0.02591596730053425,
-0.1335684359073639,
1.3408784866333008,
-0.1956210434436798,
1.1875250339508057,
-0.4466090500354767,
0.47687283158302307,
0.7939934730529785,
0.0581328459084034,
0.8350343108177185,
0.27416613698005676,
0.23873472213745117,
-0.17666471004486084,
0.3605683445930481,
-0.802716076374054,
-0.8154892921447754,
0.12873703241348267,
-0.7455326318740845,
-0.0926433727145195,
-0.565531313419342,
-0.2734118103981018,
-0.41746819019317627,
-0.1273501217365265,
-0.04050794616341591,
0.8158668279647827,
-0.5452779531478882,
0.04569627344608307,
0.7356530427932739,
-0.07461287081241608,
0.627336323261261,
1.194896936416626,
0.3782397508621216,
-0.1664000153541565,
0.6973177790641785,
0.1644151210784912,
0.19746080040931702,
0.6376299858093262,
0.21779799461364746,
-0.7818563580513,
-0.6781978607177734,
-0.4487670361995697,
0.09446015954017639,
-0.48981553316116333,
-0.06223611161112785,
-0.8122363090515137,
0.20350895822048187,
-0.29434826970100403,
-0.2622581422328949,
-0.32717791199684143,
-0.624570369720459,
-0.6598311066627502,
-0.3304697573184967,
0.2887946665287018,
0.4525752663612366,
-0.5148947238922119,
0.38976654410362244,
-1.073269009590149,
0.6615859866142273,
0.6842285394668579,
-0.005686659831553698,
-0.322456032037735,
-0.9820358157157898,
-0.004277926869690418,
-0.23933915793895721,
0.24244324862957,
-0.9721820950508118,
0.04859795421361923,
0.39908361434936523,
0.8535525798797607,
0.5264354944229126,
0.6415194272994995,
0.7528378963470459,
-0.20252001285552979,
1.216710090637207,
-0.06076192110776901,
-0.944507360458374,
0.755395233631134,
-0.2493099868297577,
0.10053351521492004,
0.4112324118614197,
0.29952001571655273,
-0.282505601644516,
-0.5562436580657959,
-1.080117106437683,
-0.6917940378189087,
0.8764891624450684,
0.2832612991333008,
-0.032774459570646286,
-0.3610369861125946,
0.06428094953298569,
-0.3563265800476074,
-0.2852558493614197,
-0.44964104890823364,
-0.14937032759189606,
0.07425036281347275,
-0.001394808292388916,
-0.23226669430732727,
-0.5776545405387878,
-0.17988434433937073,
-0.05173632502555847,
0.7193286418914795,
-0.12295624613761902,
0.2939828038215637,
0.5009764432907104,
-0.5988561511039734,
0.165920689702034,
0.4027411937713623,
0.6784425973892212,
0.9615892767906189,
-0.5182191133499146,
0.18165630102157593,
0.6628421545028687,
-0.25019410252571106,
0.264790803194046,
0.12086571007966995,
0.025640707463026047,
0.04556110501289368,
0.7799619436264038,
0.33280715346336365,
0.55111163854599,
-0.5904216766357422,
0.6509553790092468,
0.17487166821956635,
0.02673281542956829,
-0.4376519024372101,
-0.1105685904622078,
-0.3155326843261719,
0.13508695363998413,
0.36876916885375977,
-0.6688080430030823,
0.4703468084335327,
-0.7074620723724365,
1.1251847743988037,
-0.18717007339000702,
-0.607975423336029,
-0.5304085612297058,
0.41213569045066833,
0.3276749551296234,
-0.021144933998584747,
0.8300464153289795,
-0.5830855369567871,
-0.5565032362937927,
0.7890653014183044,
0.4075429439544678,
0.576810359954834,
0.017718777060508728,
0.45586565136909485,
0.4836781322956085,
0.22001561522483826,
0.06696587800979614,
0.3350568115711212,
-0.3091973662376404,
-0.5748522877693176,
-0.5021855235099792,
-0.6048703193664551,
-0.4895511567592621,
-0.1561424285173416,
-0.7158218622207642,
0.007071034051477909,
-0.27736443281173706,
-0.24799217283725739,
-0.20596325397491455,
0.3926837742328644,
-0.490381121635437,
0.6559700965881348,
-0.08116207271814346,
0.8503581285476685,
-1.4193086624145508,
0.8849886655807495,
0.9078311324119568,
-0.4135473370552063,
-0.9080879092216492,
-0.34057703614234924,
0.18264268338680267,
-0.46736040711402893,
0.6306803822517395,
-0.7024015784263611,
0.13812975585460663,
0.051001206040382385,
-0.4441390931606293,
-0.43083587288856506,
0.9293397068977356,
-0.3419608771800995,
-0.5682756304740906,
-0.0006577547756023705,
-0.09014493227005005,
0.8084301948547363,
0.22739088535308838,
0.231145977973938,
0.5102474093437195,
0.5984646677970886,
0.21679259836673737,
-0.8885695934295654,
-0.29601752758026123,
-0.012293062172830105,
-0.3936172425746918,
0.2639974355697632,
-0.399591326713562,
0.0064087375067174435,
-0.06446470320224762,
-0.4290183186531067,
0.030355846509337425,
1.305262565612793,
0.2767566442489624,
1.239192008972168,
0.697137713432312,
0.4880385100841522,
0.6883407831192017,
0.053886160254478455,
1.2377854585647583,
0.242410346865654,
0.30570152401924133,
1.3565030097961426,
0.026554688811302185,
0.6922366619110107,
0.3603096306324005,
-0.4762232303619385,
-0.02168196439743042,
0.7070294618606567,
0.15699808299541473,
0.4969322681427002,
-0.05872455611824989,
-0.2222580909729004,
-0.7089354395866394,
-0.08132043480873108,
0.22399210929870605,
0.37527427077293396,
0.19583486020565033,
-0.1474081128835678,
-0.17723572254180908,
0.054369352757930756,
-0.14629638195037842,
0.05426500737667084,
-0.24819567799568176,
0.9428925514221191,
0.1221289336681366,
-0.47015616297721863,
-0.09738198667764664,
-0.2008991539478302,
0.3223297595977783,
-0.5068802833557129,
-0.19462883472442627,
-0.2842182219028473,
-0.17580540478229523,
-0.043407659977674484,
-1.133567214012146,
0.39692947268486023,
0.11644275486469269,
0.09637612104415894,
-0.0857909694314003,
0.43609505891799927,
-0.045165713876485825,
-0.27673977613449097,
0.05535353347659111,
0.36119723320007324,
0.5509557127952576,
0.36859774589538574,
-0.5602134466171265,
-0.2967406213283539,
-0.17431403696537018,
-0.27931636571884155,
0.20124271512031555,
0.601055920124054,
-0.4469448924064636,
0.3745090365409851,
0.6904463768005371,
0.10381073504686356,
0.466647744178772,
0.04820898175239563,
0.4772822856903076,
-0.4515000581741333,
-0.6060211062431335,
-0.20017172396183014,
0.391289085149765,
-0.2860596776008606,
-0.5894734859466553,
0.34366923570632935,
0.7184972167015076,
0.7685008645057678,
0.12597163021564484,
0.12654432654380798,
-0.20556563138961792,
0.5978677272796631,
-0.7405891418457031,
0.5414710640907288,
-0.6782254576683044,
-0.012431745417416096,
-0.22494103014469147,
-0.6854702830314636,
-0.260768324136734,
0.10399578511714935,
-0.5684494972229004,
-0.10253547132015228,
0.44577887654304504,
0.765165388584137,
-0.4521057605743408,
-0.28293076157569885,
0.573586106300354,
-0.022803831845521927,
0.49450352787971497,
0.6181885004043579,
1.0672986507415771,
0.02430034801363945,
0.571667492389679,
-0.4764959216117859,
-0.43702176213264465,
-0.2685978412628174,
-0.9238959550857544,
-0.93211430311203,
-0.8216148018836975,
-0.77387535572052,
0.01295614242553711,
0.396941602230072,
0.7791319489479065,
0.766636073589325,
-0.9142400026321411,
0.3492959141731262,
0.36227312684059143,
-0.14276166260242462,
-0.3510681390762329,
-0.34517422318458557,
0.8561353087425232,
-0.33837437629699707,
-1.0438613891601562,
0.458851158618927,
-0.06088155135512352,
0.17429639399051666,
0.6159246563911438,
0.10858456790447235,
-0.4279611110687256,
0.30614688992500305,
0.5443351864814758,
0.6760339140892029,
-0.42841416597366333,
-0.6635269522666931,
-0.2983473539352417,
-0.19298475980758667,
-0.35926884412765503,
0.64286869764328,
-0.8461565971374512,
0.6778082847595215,
0.7651112675666809,
0.34465518593788147,
0.7730429768562317,
0.3863382935523987,
0.4559827446937561,
-0.863802969455719,
0.11300401389598846,
0.5859404802322388,
0.0644998773932457,
-0.20171956717967987,
-0.2625454068183899,
0.6213456392288208,
0.5581405758857727,
-0.4278314709663391,
-0.8516437411308289,
0.02367822267115116,
-1.5270358324050903,
-0.2193233072757721,
1.152205467224121,
-0.25869449973106384,
-0.30149975419044495,
-0.5761427879333496,
0.10130686312913895,
0.6440536975860596,
-0.263639360666275,
0.8062360286712646,
0.18555396795272827,
-0.387333482503891,
-0.19063536822795868,
-0.35133475065231323,
0.6744492650032043,
0.26464855670928955,
-0.6111911535263062,
-0.3348519802093506,
0.7288030982017517,
0.41873806715011597,
-0.020743904635310173,
0.967562198638916,
-0.32486653327941895,
0.848731279373169,
-0.28409239649772644,
-0.27842697501182556,
-0.26603150367736816,
-0.47466641664505005,
-0.14304734766483307,
0.06119994446635246,
-0.19582971930503845,
-0.4504553973674774
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18447v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18447v1
|
Can Language Beat Numerical Regression? Language-Based Multimodal Trajectory Prediction
| 2024-03-27T11:06:44 | 2024-03-27T11:06:44 |
Inhwan Bae, Junoh Lee, Hae-Gon Jeon
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG, cs.RO
|
Language models have demonstrated impressive ability in context understanding
and generative performance. Inspired by the recent success of language
foundation models, in this paper, we propose LMTraj (Language-based Multimodal
Trajectory predictor), which recasts the trajectory prediction task into a sort
of question-answering problem. Departing from traditional numerical regression
models, which treat the trajectory coordinate sequence as continuous signals,
we consider them as discrete signals like text prompts. Specially, we first
transform an input space for the trajectory coordinate into the natural
language space. Here, the entire time-series trajectories of pedestrians are
converted into a text prompt, and scene images are described as text
information through image captioning. The transformed numerical and image data
are then wrapped into the question-answering template for use in a language
model. Next, to guide the language model in understanding and reasoning
high-level knowledge, such as scene context and social relationships between
pedestrians, we introduce an auxiliary multi-task question and answering. We
then train a numerical tokenizer with the prompt data. We encourage the
tokenizer to separate the integer and decimal parts well, and leverage it to
capture correlations between the consecutive numbers in the language model.
Lastly, we train the language model using the numerical tokenizer and all of
the question-answer prompts. Here, we propose a beam-search-based most-likely
prediction and a temperature-based multimodal prediction to implement both
deterministic and stochastic inferences. Applying our LMTraj, we show that the
language-based model can be a powerful pedestrian trajectory predictor, and
outperforms existing numerical-based predictor methods. Code is publicly
available at https://github.com/inhwanbae/LMTrajectory .
|
[
-0.24417047202587128,
-1.0536319017410278,
0.9592355489730835,
0.24265910685062408,
-0.051745448261499405,
0.3520947992801666,
-0.13519629836082458,
-0.39376014471054077,
0.10082821547985077,
0.4800083339214325,
-0.6802266836166382,
-0.2124336212873459,
-0.43002504110336304,
-0.08696236461400986,
-0.23229913413524628,
0.8518825173377991,
-0.2086217850446701,
0.1453232765197754,
-0.34769365191459656,
0.09729950875043869,
-0.6651277542114258,
-0.43055084347724915,
-0.4346444010734558,
-0.2362014651298523,
0.826309859752655,
-0.07373747229576111,
0.6802809238433838,
0.5790174007415771,
0.46385109424591064,
0.3463332951068878,
0.13482119143009186,
-0.07068270444869995,
-0.15726998448371887,
0.31655144691467285,
0.2616669237613678,
-0.31657931208610535,
0.08906099945306778,
-0.4022027850151062,
0.5176696181297302,
0.5177695751190186,
-0.2706593871116638,
-0.09083479642868042,
-0.4773128926753998,
0.393354594707489,
-0.28498780727386475,
0.4130525588989258,
-0.3654308617115021,
-0.19502362608909607,
-0.23607023060321808,
-0.4105361998081207,
-0.4679601788520813,
-0.5251030325889587,
-0.33093732595443726,
-0.10612139850854874,
-0.16376115381717682,
0.08266336470842361,
0.30405038595199585,
0.46098828315734863,
-0.8866152167320251,
-0.1880244016647339,
-0.8525907397270203,
0.9182888269424438,
-0.42248398065567017,
0.5954676270484924,
0.4078323245048523,
0.8466277718544006,
-0.1463078260421753,
-0.466340571641922,
-0.40589433908462524,
-0.36526697874069214,
0.032953690737485886,
-0.0323253832757473,
0.030920149758458138,
0.0983445793390274,
0.18933311104774475,
-0.12175750732421875,
-0.9664198160171509,
-0.24093404412269592,
-0.5736445784568787,
-0.1918952614068985,
0.3945803642272949,
0.408824622631073,
0.4181652367115021,
-0.22299820184707642,
-0.3636220097541809,
-0.10661230236291885,
-0.3123818635940552,
0.41344913840293884,
-0.08485496789216995,
0.507712185382843,
-0.10080769658088684,
0.5099846720695496,
-0.17208519577980042,
0.78963702917099,
-0.2306809425354004,
-0.5007555484771729,
0.2107984870672226,
-0.29902157187461853,
0.04947948083281517,
0.16565579175949097,
0.7635381817817688,
0.21824899315834045,
0.3843136727809906,
-0.23704734444618225,
0.0023634792305529118,
0.009700900875031948,
-0.18375751376152039,
-0.8322076201438904,
-0.14656388759613037,
0.3662373423576355,
-0.19712664186954498,
-0.0867767333984375,
-0.13641071319580078,
-0.932816743850708,
-0.39523181319236755,
-0.21520692110061646,
0.042990803718566895,
-0.5872645974159241,
-0.1694003790616989,
0.29713696241378784,
0.31234413385391235,
0.04452930763363838,
0.5072005391120911,
-0.9269710183143616,
0.01774280145764351,
0.6007273197174072,
0.9262282252311707,
0.18633872270584106,
-0.3197878897190094,
-0.4569823741912842,
0.10506345331668854,
-0.18954290449619293,
0.7862634062767029,
-0.8494539856910706,
-0.2931269705295563,
-0.23657605051994324,
-0.230666384100914,
-0.13249504566192627,
0.05504798889160156,
0.16449449956417084,
-0.5139705538749695,
0.42632725834846497,
-0.010006016120314598,
-0.1678188443183899,
-0.4317740201950073,
0.2732034921646118,
-0.550023078918457,
1.1503783464431763,
-0.0255671888589859,
-0.7440662384033203,
0.1642851084470749,
-0.5474885702133179,
-0.2739975154399872,
-0.030299346894025803,
-0.15033464133739471,
-0.19387656450271606,
-0.029381630942225456,
0.4796414375305176,
0.4716646671295166,
-0.4358614683151245,
1.038010597229004,
-0.21492281556129456,
-0.29339006543159485,
0.2099333554506302,
-0.6845126748085022,
0.5474059581756592,
0.17982062697410583,
-0.2864017188549042,
0.2804388999938965,
-0.7104441523551941,
0.019016452133655548,
0.013230014592409134,
-0.5333269834518433,
-0.17733946442604065,
0.05314810201525688,
0.22044743597507477,
0.4915197789669037,
0.2891463041305542,
-0.6023691892623901,
0.1731840819120407,
-0.10578092932701111,
-0.02465035207569599,
0.898623526096344,
-0.12415565550327301,
0.4000721573829651,
-0.3362963795661926,
0.958845853805542,
-0.10865125060081482,
-0.03364085778594017,
-0.6218767166137695,
-0.7945088148117065,
-0.143804669380188,
-0.32608720660209656,
-0.11855177581310272,
0.6483170390129089,
-1.032744288444519,
-0.3523118793964386,
-0.45848360657691956,
-0.6622907519340515,
-0.2631024420261383,
-0.2412668615579605,
0.3370073139667511,
0.4961072504520416,
0.319256454706192,
0.2987452745437622,
-0.8428004384040833,
-0.39194750785827637,
-0.1669037938117981,
-0.5702223777770996,
0.39028027653694153,
0.28416359424591064,
0.38875675201416016,
-0.1265079379081726,
0.9143671989440918,
-0.6204108595848083,
0.1873362958431244,
-0.47149884700775146,
0.2961060702800751,
0.37085214257240295,
0.3211837708950043,
0.680383026599884,
-1.046093463897705,
-0.522749662399292,
0.04877069219946861,
-0.8085459470748901,
0.007142466958612204,
-0.17431531846523285,
0.11064176261425018,
0.007054726593196392,
0.4895707964897156,
-0.47439008951187134,
0.23181873559951782,
0.6546105742454529,
-0.3952857255935669,
0.43779951333999634,
-0.11558344215154648,
0.37467214465141296,
-1.2645996809005737,
0.008132976479828358,
0.11748703569173813,
-0.32152044773101807,
-0.9437431693077087,
0.0487944632768631,
-0.13461236655712128,
-0.08515787124633789,
-0.6331294178962708,
0.7234627604484558,
0.0518905334174633,
-0.040609560906887054,
-0.20703263580799103,
-0.36225900053977966,
-0.5151522159576416,
0.5014978051185608,
0.1637595146894455,
0.8084955811500549,
0.5847448706626892,
-0.305175244808197,
0.5017297863960266,
0.03349744528532028,
-0.5165630578994751,
0.12240978330373764,
-0.470620721578598,
0.06987789273262024,
-0.689116895198822,
0.42879799008369446,
-1.172894835472107,
-0.3238525092601776,
0.05811882019042969,
-0.454587459564209,
-0.07081303000450134,
-0.12785027921199799,
-0.5984070897102356,
-0.4643334150314331,
0.01794288121163845,
0.6135827898979187,
0.3276861906051636,
-0.1727875918149948,
0.8973067998886108,
0.12139067053794861,
-0.3618974983692169,
-0.591705322265625,
-0.619841992855072,
0.16170476377010345,
-0.20696602761745453,
-0.5445223450660706,
-0.17273883521556854,
-0.4732552468776703,
-0.274564266204834,
-0.4748857915401459,
0.3925042748451233,
-0.2600058913230896,
0.148241326212883,
0.41451770067214966,
0.39349889755249023,
-0.13835985958576202,
0.16480478644371033,
-0.2947961091995239,
-0.3336828947067261,
0.12208514660596848,
-0.09515079110860825,
0.8915645480155945,
-0.1266833394765854,
-0.41178098320961,
-0.17840850353240967,
0.2683808505535126,
0.8466455340385437,
-0.08487790822982788,
0.6582226157188416,
0.9034513831138611,
-0.3393966257572174,
0.5725719332695007,
-0.3988091051578522,
-0.16453610360622406,
-0.4814867377281189,
0.7069252729415894,
-0.48280268907546997,
-0.9668808579444885,
0.29411637783050537,
0.017399149015545845,
-0.07328207790851593,
-0.011804447509348392,
0.726585865020752,
0.04915031045675278,
1.395719051361084,
0.7526000142097473,
-0.12233874946832657,
0.49785757064819336,
0.26977983117103577,
0.188768208026886,
-0.1887902319431305,
-0.5445787906646729,
-0.4951004683971405,
-0.14834149181842804,
-0.6489099860191345,
-0.5401724576950073,
0.4710442125797272,
-0.2860143184661865,
-0.31987595558166504,
0.38175609707832336,
-0.1285974085330963,
0.32192984223365784,
0.4244227707386017,
0.0753314271569252,
0.039556749165058136,
-0.11418458074331284,
-0.25479021668434143,
-0.4392114281654358,
-0.50545334815979,
-0.22785936295986176,
0.7308330535888672,
0.3977425992488861,
0.8673678040504456,
0.237566277384758,
0.6328424215316772,
-0.03756016492843628,
0.4518318176269531,
-0.6432414054870605,
0.749767541885376,
-0.03195382282137871,
-0.6251493692398071,
-0.11873035877943039,
-0.632990837097168,
-0.5285516381263733,
0.1228661835193634,
-0.0422847606241703,
-0.9756315350532532,
-0.06665891408920288,
-0.05202537029981613,
-0.11771123111248016,
0.5434767603874207,
-0.23689942061901093,
0.7756987810134888,
-0.6827846169471741,
-0.3149794340133667,
-0.023835133761167526,
-0.6759302020072937,
0.3929079473018646,
-0.31996357440948486,
0.7463840842247009,
-0.2806342840194702,
0.23240621387958527,
0.6169716119766235,
-0.07197629660367966,
0.859512984752655,
-0.4210471510887146,
-0.03228280320763588,
0.08871058374643326,
0.33701637387275696,
0.460980623960495,
-0.27289706468582153,
-0.25851893424987793,
-0.2098536491394043,
0.17657724022865295,
-0.27476176619529724,
-0.7143198251724243,
0.5038783550262451,
-0.3532298505306244,
-0.42356595396995544,
-0.462531179189682,
-0.7144344449043274,
-0.3322041630744934,
0.0814291387796402,
-0.19206920266151428,
0.6104596853256226,
0.030017400160431862,
0.11742650717496872,
0.2066187858581543,
-0.2498045563697815,
0.7637242674827576,
0.42093735933303833,
-0.7871589660644531,
-0.45740994811058044,
1.1346046924591064,
-0.3939402997493744,
0.08272584527730942,
0.7671141028404236,
0.5881981253623962,
-0.5615584850311279,
-0.284919798374176,
-0.5363800525665283,
0.11612942814826965,
-0.7198240756988525,
-0.045748356729745865,
-0.7405709028244019,
0.07840438187122345,
-0.20594587922096252,
-0.36796876788139343,
-0.11624942719936371,
-0.2313622087240219,
-0.01972953788936138,
-0.215870201587677,
0.5217918753623962,
0.8628756403923035,
0.007633004803210497,
0.1860075742006302,
-0.8011865019798279,
0.11966811865568161,
0.19528932869434357,
-0.04082629084587097,
-0.06294617056846619,
-0.2652581036090851,
-0.19902651011943817,
0.24456512928009033,
0.10509738326072693,
-0.6027804017066956,
0.7393485307693481,
-0.0007173517951741815,
0.16178801655769348,
0.2918432056903839,
-0.11920633167028427,
0.9366545081138611,
-0.5541829466819763,
0.7772791981697083,
0.5114966034889221,
-0.5354518294334412,
0.5123425722122192,
-0.5856239795684814,
0.5556236505508423,
0.5223095417022705,
0.45711106061935425,
-0.6585702300071716,
-0.43677160143852234,
-0.01396069023758173,
-0.6160969138145447,
0.5554975271224976,
-0.10407878458499908,
0.13623295724391937,
-0.07883106917142868,
0.059871383011341095,
0.12618298828601837,
0.32576408982276917,
-1.0249685049057007,
-0.0555788092315197,
-0.20950408279895782,
-0.459096223115921,
-0.4783489406108856,
-0.17305245995521545,
0.4754427671432495,
-0.2466871589422226,
0.19686102867126465,
-0.37219157814979553,
0.24969498813152313,
-0.2841756343841553,
0.20025433599948883,
-0.21356160938739777,
0.25278446078300476,
0.8991348147392273,
0.6010333299636841,
-0.5869133472442627,
0.2525274455547333,
0.08016153424978256,
-0.45711180567741394,
0.32914766669273376,
-0.09897711127996445,
-0.1358678787946701,
0.11801786720752716,
0.23681329190731049,
0.720047116279602,
0.41191110014915466,
-1.0094976425170898,
0.3360316753387451,
-0.14671389758586884,
-0.02670157328248024,
-0.29986342787742615,
-0.3286615014076233,
-0.07128026336431503,
0.1897880584001541,
0.5425543189048767,
0.34918123483657837,
-0.12043517827987671,
-0.6084266901016235,
0.21912626922130585,
0.3389996588230133,
-0.7538124322891235,
-0.441116064786911,
1.0507025718688965,
-0.19604480266571045,
-0.1973838061094284,
0.15239688754081726,
0.19775934517383575,
-0.7219321727752686,
0.6363532543182373,
0.6078205108642578,
0.646318256855011,
-0.3166714906692505,
0.31686294078826904,
0.3113521635532379,
0.18511146306991577,
-0.22680559754371643,
0.5287431478500366,
-0.0015825709560886025,
-0.49178335070610046,
-0.7297666668891907,
-0.823083221912384,
-0.25610870122909546,
-0.38149380683898926,
-0.22614525258541107,
0.13082820177078247,
-0.37341931462287903,
-0.060533422976732254,
-0.09052672982215881,
-0.3067321479320526,
-0.42626678943634033,
0.3486836552619934,
0.1177116334438324,
0.6955893039703369,
-0.8745982050895691,
0.9026516675949097,
0.7518865466117859,
-0.4893835783004761,
-0.5046505928039551,
-0.02976612001657486,
0.04634958878159523,
-0.7878450155258179,
1.2090799808502197,
0.30293476581573486,
-0.29248136281967163,
-0.029570255428552628,
-0.38463082909584045,
-1.004784345626831,
0.9266474843025208,
0.4702107906341553,
-0.32521337270736694,
-0.2811794579029083,
0.39110803604125977,
0.4383470416069031,
-0.18337799608707428,
0.49249130487442017,
0.11505468189716339,
0.6408307552337646,
0.4588720500469208,
-0.9447380900382996,
-0.011536887846887112,
0.019415628165006638,
-0.07078699767589569,
0.44313013553619385,
-0.32993626594543457,
0.9703589081764221,
-0.3207189738750458,
-0.011714537627995014,
0.3106370270252228,
0.5805441737174988,
0.2255672961473465,
0.5190505981445312,
0.32204434275627136,
0.21737556159496307,
0.5238186717033386,
-0.2345447540283203,
1.3089860677719116,
-0.4691865146160126,
0.31596991419792175,
0.79387366771698,
-0.15428844094276428,
1.0656474828720093,
0.6293551325798035,
-0.24932873249053955,
0.6703529357910156,
0.5407196283340454,
0.4971623420715332,
0.7832633256912231,
0.011718503199517727,
-0.44836780428886414,
-0.3685941994190216,
-0.12001954764127731,
0.019727934151887894,
0.580132782459259,
0.18453159928321838,
-0.11856506019830704,
-0.3322308361530304,
0.41533204913139343,
0.08438203483819962,
0.1288156807422638,
-0.18504856526851654,
0.6203630566596985,
-0.1926720291376114,
-0.6012019515037537,
0.3348604738712311,
0.22076867520809174,
0.6798579692840576,
-0.655102550983429,
0.09712184965610504,
-0.05993691086769104,
0.10011003911495209,
0.06912316381931305,
-0.8486833572387695,
0.3853720426559448,
-0.15942811965942383,
-0.03026648797094822,
-0.5722891092300415,
0.4932901859283447,
-0.5508624911308289,
-0.6987366080284119,
0.15231764316558838,
0.6908295750617981,
0.14148257672786713,
0.04961363226175308,
-0.5915917158126831,
-0.0915537029504776,
0.13835033774375916,
0.09844282269477844,
0.2937535047531128,
0.1311316341161728,
-0.21265748143196106,
1.1868096590042114,
0.7766866087913513,
-0.10685095936059952,
0.13419707119464874,
-0.05284900590777397,
0.7534055709838867,
-0.7998009920120239,
-0.4579210877418518,
-0.9594151377677917,
0.4576810598373413,
0.534389853477478,
0.03466075658798218,
0.4982692301273346,
0.5602400898933411,
0.33961084485054016,
-0.1167791336774826,
0.6904237866401672,
-0.05964916944503784,
0.40252789855003357,
-0.6495872735977173,
0.20849579572677612,
-0.5009746551513672,
0.059520214796066284,
-0.32500749826431274,
-0.8437036871910095,
-0.4475953280925751,
0.5161322951316833,
-0.5119222402572632,
0.39902952313423157,
0.5912206172943115,
0.821485698223114,
0.004953082650899887,
-0.07774819433689117,
0.4824620187282562,
-0.020605625584721565,
0.49459943175315857,
0.7174370288848877,
0.8651757836341858,
-0.22244364023208618,
0.6041015982627869,
-0.27364927530288696,
0.025486033409833908,
-0.2025851011276245,
-0.772844135761261,
-0.8571247458457947,
-0.8950932621955872,
-0.08854322880506516,
-0.276509165763855,
0.19492720067501068,
1.0614521503448486,
0.5880647301673889,
-0.7330380082130432,
-0.3757167160511017,
-0.22675861418247223,
-0.07494254410266876,
0.13960100710391998,
-0.3066509962081909,
0.19114209711551666,
0.05419771745800972,
-0.6332215070724487,
0.5103570222854614,
0.4436837136745453,
0.2650340497493744,
-0.39451175928115845,
-0.07385095953941345,
-0.3059020936489105,
-0.08302565664052963,
0.4906821846961975,
0.23843184113502502,
-0.8263251781463623,
-0.3525508642196655,
0.26267874240875244,
-0.13347797095775604,
-0.010375453159213066,
0.8355085849761963,
-1.0322332382202148,
0.5477905869483948,
0.34289777278900146,
0.4953771233558655,
0.49671798944473267,
0.13412712514400482,
0.6466389298439026,
-0.7715601325035095,
0.3113979399204254,
0.19402404129505157,
0.5068742632865906,
0.38462314009666443,
-0.2360779494047165,
0.2570301592350006,
0.09830551594495773,
-0.35930612683296204,
-0.6278879642486572,
0.367453932762146,
-0.9559906125068665,
-0.23471415042877197,
1.099221110343933,
0.16273419559001923,
-0.4602676033973694,
-0.2830306887626648,
-0.5818665623664856,
-0.14542412757873535,
-0.5550139546394348,
0.8042762875556946,
0.39226454496383667,
-0.10823813825845718,
-0.8595883846282959,
-0.6865353584289551,
0.2386765480041504,
0.2539982199668884,
-0.7755923271179199,
0.09246836602687836,
0.5111455321311951,
-0.04617099091410637,
0.10586003214120865,
0.6496564149856567,
0.21309025585651398,
0.3063627779483795,
-0.24336306750774384,
-0.13117875158786774,
-0.27955347299575806,
-0.3146446943283081,
-0.23005236685276031,
0.2573583722114563,
-0.030770830810070038,
0.13548116385936737
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18435v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18435v1
|
DELTA: Pre-train a Discriminative Encoder for Legal Case Retrieval via Structural Word Alignment
| 2024-03-27T10:40:14 | 2024-03-27T10:40:14 |
Haitao Li, Qingyao Ai, Xinyan Han, Jia Chen, Qian Dong, Yiqun Liu, Chong Chen, Qi Tian
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Recent research demonstrates the effectiveness of using pre-trained language
models for legal case retrieval. Most of the existing works focus on improving
the representation ability for the contextualized embedding of the [CLS] token
and calculate relevance using textual semantic similarity. However, in the
legal domain, textual semantic similarity does not always imply that the cases
are relevant enough. Instead, relevance in legal cases primarily depends on the
similarity of key facts that impact the final judgment. Without proper
treatments, the discriminative ability of learned representations could be
limited since legal cases are lengthy and contain numerous non-key facts. To
this end, we introduce DELTA, a discriminative model designed for legal case
retrieval. The basic idea involves pinpointing key facts in legal cases and
pulling the contextualized embedding of the [CLS] token closer to the key facts
while pushing away from the non-key facts, which can warm up the case embedding
space in an unsupervised manner. To be specific, this study brings the word
alignment mechanism to the contextual masked auto-encoder. First, we leverage
shallow decoders to create information bottlenecks, aiming to enhance the
representation ability. Second, we employ the deep decoder to enable
translation between different structures, with the goal of pinpointing key
facts to enhance discriminative ability. Comprehensive experiments conducted on
publicly available legal benchmarks show that our approach can outperform
existing state-of-the-art methods in legal case retrieval. It provides a new
perspective on the in-depth understanding and processing of legal case
documents.
|
[
-0.2391180545091629,
-0.475591242313385,
0.7971182465553284,
-0.2699490785598755,
-0.75452721118927,
0.11210808902978897,
-0.07317645102739334,
-0.17708654701709747,
0.3083805739879608,
0.5620855689048767,
-0.09013199061155319,
-0.6240562200546265,
-0.6939191222190857,
-0.28707751631736755,
-0.49510657787323,
0.9688683748245239,
0.10023225098848343,
0.27459248900413513,
-0.021098623052239418,
-0.3926642835140228,
-0.7270409464836121,
-0.7430916428565979,
-0.23011496663093567,
-0.09402671456336975,
0.23824173212051392,
0.11099617183208466,
0.5391058325767517,
0.8473309874534607,
0.5479686856269836,
0.2663726210594177,
0.0328543446958065,
-0.4104169011116028,
-0.3771355152130127,
0.18801671266555786,
-0.018823811784386635,
-0.6254511475563049,
-0.24852144718170166,
-0.18892771005630493,
0.4652743935585022,
0.6182563900947571,
-0.21421951055526733,
-0.04231835529208183,
-0.1057511493563652,
0.732519268989563,
-0.9117937684059143,
0.15001481771469116,
-0.6576911807060242,
0.15143118798732758,
-0.5045814514160156,
-0.27717071771621704,
-0.256450891494751,
-0.39033088088035583,
0.13748466968536377,
-0.781371533870697,
0.4911315143108368,
0.10764937102794647,
0.8781983256340027,
0.3863864243030548,
-0.8560076355934143,
-0.6033036112785339,
-0.36218348145484924,
0.2852575182914734,
-0.5552669763565063,
0.5940955281257629,
0.06725272536277771,
0.6091967821121216,
0.043642494827508926,
-0.8758925199508667,
-0.622854471206665,
-0.13276776671409607,
-0.010119624435901642,
0.015389970503747463,
0.00023342629719991237,
0.30738139152526855,
0.2848977744579315,
0.27788883447647095,
-0.4002222418785095,
0.10515683889389038,
-0.3577078580856323,
-0.3790355324745178,
0.4060015380382538,
0.07851037383079529,
0.2794541120529175,
-0.006953443866223097,
-0.04776295647025108,
-0.19751794636249542,
-0.7948206663131714,
0.08335386961698532,
0.26770609617233276,
0.5068374276161194,
0.010216853581368923,
0.7167437076568604,
-0.13251641392707825,
0.5005516409873962,
0.4920406639575958,
0.18994516134262085,
0.3989449441432953,
-0.33210182189941406,
-0.16683751344680786,
0.6622272729873657,
0.3659275770187378,
0.3614749610424042,
0.09871355444192886,
-0.1837657243013382,
-0.1775217354297638,
-0.4246944189071655,
0.39706265926361084,
-0.7559136748313904,
0.08212222158908844,
0.18755245208740234,
-0.6463602185249329,
0.23467230796813965,
0.3802102208137512,
-0.5369405746459961,
-0.5423406362533569,
-0.39751505851745605,
0.3024808168411255,
-0.2493007928133011,
-0.17867602407932281,
0.19884362816810608,
-0.3214229345321655,
0.5727495551109314,
0.1550506204366684,
-0.71934974193573,
0.12352295964956284,
0.8141504526138306,
0.6518836617469788,
0.21087166666984558,
0.4249953627586365,
-0.4358230233192444,
0.24964430928230286,
-0.5378344655036926,
0.4958767592906952,
-0.6450545191764832,
-0.061911944299936295,
0.5550620555877686,
0.08426836878061295,
0.28290605545043945,
-0.5117678046226501,
0.6632267832756042,
-0.8940401673316956,
-0.1558637022972107,
-0.8171656727790833,
-0.7055147886276245,
-0.1980118304491043,
-0.013556251302361488,
-0.7757242918014526,
0.3891274333000183,
-0.169844850897789,
-0.6685428023338318,
1.2364757061004639,
-0.6855810284614563,
-0.5281755924224854,
0.42417216300964355,
-0.46280553936958313,
-0.48991304636001587,
0.2923271358013153,
0.18861404061317444,
0.42150038480758667,
0.012379585765302181,
0.22057168185710907,
-0.26680153608322144,
-0.4574834704399109,
-0.11159193515777588,
0.11266224086284637,
0.759876549243927,
0.3608955144882202,
-0.36561766266822815,
0.027050867676734924,
-0.3036559522151947,
-0.32916897535324097,
-0.055510882288217545,
-0.4693518280982971,
-0.7401931285858154,
-0.12873512506484985,
-0.2798721194267273,
0.19386906921863556,
0.25785455107688904,
-0.624270498752594,
0.08340004831552505,
-0.2327101081609726,
0.3110691010951996,
0.4631173014640808,
0.05584992840886116,
0.6530641317367554,
0.017348896712064743,
0.4665924906730652,
0.2970789074897766,
-0.14223983883857727,
-0.13210704922676086,
-0.05982543155550957,
-0.677001416683197,
-0.32381752133369446,
0.5729113817214966,
0.3168054223060608,
-0.4735879600048065,
0.3478775918483734,
-0.4532732665538788,
0.05854327976703644,
-0.7992890477180481,
0.058872345834970474,
0.3509337604045868,
0.20104600489139557,
0.381217360496521,
-0.32059532403945923,
-0.777418851852417,
-0.9766256809234619,
-0.3804490566253662,
0.20204441249370575,
0.008074174635112286,
0.1758446842432022,
0.6812465786933899,
-0.049300093203783035,
1.0908160209655762,
-0.13383780419826508,
-0.543494462966919,
0.04477842524647713,
0.33139294385910034,
0.3282613158226013,
0.31281933188438416,
0.5110992193222046,
-0.8636098504066467,
-0.4760281443595886,
0.14365284144878387,
-0.8856250643730164,
0.07758913189172745,
-0.11140578240156174,
-0.08350574225187302,
-0.010481839999556541,
0.8995471000671387,
-0.7366784811019897,
0.5779985189437866,
-0.39599502086639404,
-0.5032340884208679,
0.1778949648141861,
-0.30402615666389465,
0.2757399380207062,
-0.8126218914985657,
-0.0897798016667366,
-0.25862520933151245,
-0.2501128613948822,
-0.46877995133399963,
0.1419958472251892,
0.3670903444290161,
0.002732764696702361,
-0.5646301507949829,
0.2135665863752365,
-0.826765239238739,
-0.2954421937465668,
-0.294193834066391,
0.22366122901439667,
-0.1268841028213501,
0.19533474743366241,
0.022308100014925003,
0.7235559821128845,
0.3545663356781006,
-0.7663508653640747,
0.3109392821788788,
0.044723205268383026,
-0.3512728810310364,
0.9009693264961243,
-0.489921510219574,
0.06353043019771576,
-0.4092367887496948,
0.1594667136669159,
-0.6210722327232361,
0.05715715140104294,
-0.05139892175793648,
0.008191782981157303,
0.49956318736076355,
-0.3406163454055786,
-0.5680350065231323,
-0.42006614804267883,
-0.17975112795829773,
0.42485228180885315,
0.36723777651786804,
-0.4782986342906952,
0.6592532396316528,
0.6248157024383545,
0.017440712079405785,
-0.6498879194259644,
-0.4285432994365692,
-0.04062078148126602,
-0.4969463050365448,
0.0024110323283821344,
0.5232163667678833,
0.3885789215564728,
-0.24297283589839935,
0.20339737832546234,
-0.16361427307128906,
-0.23071859776973724,
-0.036645036190748215,
0.2784822881221771,
-0.29495251178741455,
-0.35400906205177307,
0.4916906952857971,
0.15543140470981598,
0.1708105504512787,
0.19080056250095367,
-0.35468363761901855,
0.4028759002685547,
-0.0325070284307003,
-0.4825710952281952,
-0.12332534044981003,
0.49547410011291504,
0.47177866101264954,
-0.1445649415254593,
0.46978962421417236,
0.0322425402700901,
-0.5737619400024414,
0.13416193425655365,
-0.6481184363365173,
-0.1844101846218109,
-0.4328988194465637,
0.4747525453567505,
-0.6772698760032654,
-0.8838773369789124,
0.5618609189987183,
-0.10303281992673874,
0.044515594840049744,
0.38676717877388,
0.5646736025810242,
-0.221776083111763,
0.6026548147201538,
0.691490113735199,
-0.16904836893081665,
0.45321959257125854,
0.029285430908203125,
0.29347914457321167,
-0.6785755753517151,
-0.3333710730075836,
-0.40396207571029663,
0.00853396113961935,
-0.332852303981781,
-0.17600427567958832,
0.004225786309689283,
0.39890849590301514,
-0.46031081676483154,
0.6104970574378967,
-0.32359516620635986,
0.4637726843357086,
0.5269709229469299,
0.11725842952728271,
0.06947925686836243,
-0.17394421994686127,
-0.6412138342857361,
-0.032587096095085144,
-0.5572491884231567,
-0.3364674746990204,
1.3135936260223389,
0.33176207542419434,
0.32801592350006104,
0.3088221848011017,
0.5277745723724365,
0.5148496031761169,
0.08218716084957123,
-0.6207010746002197,
0.2683302164077759,
-0.21381030976772308,
-0.8221760988235474,
-0.28289178013801575,
0.0296726506203413,
-1.0649186372756958,
0.14260873198509216,
-0.2739742696285248,
-0.478089302778244,
0.4960256516933441,
-0.14242589473724365,
-0.5038428902626038,
-0.07568678259849548,
-0.4547327756881714,
0.7358426451683044,
-0.1539401262998581,
-0.2219422310590744,
-0.28549879789352417,
-0.44150444865226746,
0.15174265205860138,
-0.37830981612205505,
0.05075369030237198,
0.1308477371931076,
0.21013905107975006,
0.8114417791366577,
-0.6688464879989624,
0.7294382452964783,
-0.39985790848731995,
-0.15123511850833893,
0.27597323060035706,
-0.03936732932925224,
0.3447619080543518,
-0.15618054568767548,
0.1583443284034729,
0.02557354047894478,
0.029840469360351562,
-0.33653077483177185,
-0.806972324848175,
0.3038136661052704,
-0.34995171427726746,
-0.8568555116653442,
-0.45079997181892395,
-0.29785585403442383,
0.16577912867069244,
0.22165299952030182,
0.2006789743900299,
0.08871288597583771,
-0.17157557606697083,
0.44480711221694946,
0.402401864528656,
0.033297549933195114,
0.5646468997001648,
0.8652420043945312,
0.2912884056568146,
-0.13134720921516418,
0.5717329978942871,
0.3565509617328644,
-0.4783610999584198,
0.48631978034973145,
-0.15153978765010834,
-0.7417742609977722,
-0.488239586353302,
-0.27564698457717896,
0.20036669075489044,
-0.9923934936523438,
-0.27247968316078186,
-0.5909426212310791,
-0.07088638842105865,
-0.49455350637435913,
-0.30600088834762573,
-0.396017849445343,
-0.25229668617248535,
-0.12997156381607056,
-0.3874242305755615,
0.18197722733020782,
0.5601704120635986,
-0.057372141629457474,
0.2781202793121338,
-0.4515073001384735,
0.26944535970687866,
0.2779296040534973,
0.2858990728855133,
-0.25711318850517273,
-0.642739474773407,
-0.41078779101371765,
-0.09015525877475739,
-0.08303802460432053,
-0.8247731328010559,
0.17250443994998932,
0.10376198589801788,
0.8439570069313049,
0.7907448410987854,
0.2681773602962494,
0.8092544078826904,
-0.6084766983985901,
0.3855339586734772,
0.16234441101551056,
-1.0203732252120972,
0.7041856050491333,
0.01152441743761301,
0.018790001049637794,
0.7193406224250793,
0.5596953630447388,
-0.1560572236776352,
-0.24619178473949432,
-0.2611534595489502,
-0.7682657837867737,
0.282322496175766,
0.10717081278562546,
0.25323230028152466,
0.08560288697481155,
0.7235382795333862,
0.013791254721581936,
0.39035096764564514,
-0.5205698013305664,
0.05163322761654854,
-0.6378782987594604,
-0.3021213710308075,
0.15752054750919342,
-0.34433886408805847,
-0.12275689095258713,
-0.37396010756492615,
0.3172033131122589,
-0.06118055805563927,
0.5141701102256775,
0.10412659496068954,
-0.36190065741539,
0.3100622892379761,
0.16727706789970398,
0.47251826524734497,
0.3937118649482727,
-0.32818731665611267,
0.07636956125497818,
0.2375587373971939,
-0.6297138929367065,
0.26897916197776794,
0.0014114573132246733,
-0.14054538309574127,
0.06442263722419739,
0.5411506295204163,
0.744644045829773,
0.056452080607414246,
-0.4242810606956482,
0.8014590740203857,
-0.08215369284152985,
-0.20586983859539032,
-0.49092018604278564,
-0.2414834350347519,
-0.18268448114395142,
0.38454651832580566,
0.5785545706748962,
-0.559698760509491,
0.4390668272972107,
-0.6478824615478516,
0.6528475284576416,
0.576810359954834,
-0.5996564626693726,
0.01872779242694378,
0.684833288192749,
0.34492814540863037,
0.04438885301351547,
0.6217181086540222,
-0.09373927116394043,
-0.6784948110580444,
0.6297169327735901,
0.35529544949531555,
0.7137378454208374,
0.13474668562412262,
-0.10493512451648712,
0.36591506004333496,
0.15451978147029877,
-0.13370801508426666,
0.12384381145238876,
-0.35091352462768555,
-0.6632339358329773,
-0.23931710422039032,
-0.3363741636276245,
0.15863429009914398,
-0.043699752539396286,
-0.82444167137146,
0.32877689599990845,
-0.39514151215553284,
-0.3142213523387909,
-0.34078529477119446,
0.19492316246032715,
-0.8773545622825623,
0.23038360476493835,
-0.12890958786010742,
0.7133278846740723,
-0.7492653727531433,
1.009953498840332,
0.404721200466156,
-0.6426659226417542,
-0.4772307872772217,
0.14235803484916687,
-0.0979074090719223,
-0.5004929900169373,
1.2510473728179932,
0.18393708765506744,
0.058665741235017776,
-0.20173074305057526,
-0.19143854081630707,
-0.6468563675880432,
1.1803854703903198,
0.6484352946281433,
-0.9100987315177917,
-0.03704281896352768,
0.2921260595321655,
0.5192880630493164,
-0.6399514079093933,
0.27460190653800964,
0.5303676128387451,
0.2762552797794342,
0.046809855848550797,
-0.7024156451225281,
0.2559281587600708,
-0.2157258242368698,
0.02050892822444439,
-0.06539969146251678,
-0.22136515378952026,
0.6625369787216187,
-0.10653578490018845,
-0.597973644733429,
-0.4061093032360077,
0.829102098941803,
0.011030951514840126,
0.2861233949661255,
0.43513450026512146,
0.6843855381011963,
0.912501871585846,
-0.24274608492851257,
1.0509130954742432,
-0.5584654808044434,
0.1937803030014038,
1.0308771133422852,
-0.32408377528190613,
0.622110903263092,
0.5610230565071106,
0.20010393857955933,
0.5494112372398376,
0.6318866610527039,
-0.0424390584230423,
1.0411320924758911,
0.35901251435279846,
-0.2051980346441269,
-0.30543893575668335,
-0.11440754681825638,
-0.4297579526901245,
0.4630514085292816,
0.2602439522743225,
-0.47695374488830566,
-0.17871788144111633,
0.10675588250160217,
-0.08470158278942108,
0.18804730474948883,
-0.37079834938049316,
0.872144341468811,
0.0172723438590765,
-0.42110922932624817,
0.2912003993988037,
-0.08291231840848923,
0.4707218408584595,
-0.25248754024505615,
-0.3070964217185974,
-0.3383347690105438,
0.018751205876469612,
-0.009885242208838463,
-0.6838261485099792,
0.3269869089126587,
-0.21390318870544434,
-0.13847219944000244,
-0.031083254143595695,
0.5055781602859497,
-0.15094678103923798,
-0.12891779839992523,
0.4282824397087097,
0.1864258050918579,
0.24868248403072357,
-0.18637721240520477,
-0.5206957459449768,
-0.2041570097208023,
-0.4749911427497864,
0.07699856907129288,
0.09377453476190567,
0.7624012231826782,
-0.2158820778131485,
0.6009088754653931,
0.5223355293273926,
-0.06941293925046921,
0.31808608770370483,
0.3397051692008972,
0.8452749252319336,
-0.780577540397644,
-0.6926713585853577,
-0.8204641342163086,
0.3377234637737274,
-0.19246937334537506,
-0.22183559834957123,
0.5135350227355957,
0.6466420292854309,
0.7088570594787598,
-0.07744578272104263,
0.5904685258865356,
0.13786399364471436,
0.10962677747011185,
-0.7890934348106384,
0.70358806848526,
-0.33603325486183167,
0.16698817908763885,
-0.11554982513189316,
-0.8657853603363037,
-0.2539672255516052,
0.7513713240623474,
-0.09675612300634384,
0.05984682962298393,
0.8052763342857361,
0.587952196598053,
-0.08319824934005737,
-0.26109084486961365,
0.38661277294158936,
0.1276022493839264,
0.17779749631881714,
0.5969805121421814,
0.4896741211414337,
-0.40421921014785767,
0.47152891755104065,
0.1753726750612259,
0.0254267156124115,
-0.4483972489833832,
-0.8770010471343994,
-1.0131926536560059,
-0.7920913696289062,
-0.4234379529953003,
-0.21554413437843323,
0.3418940305709839,
0.6002297401428223,
1.0291666984558105,
-0.8483368158340454,
0.07600106298923492,
-0.4893844723701477,
0.02032184787094593,
-0.15224745869636536,
-0.13855591416358948,
0.6027447581291199,
-0.3796641528606415,
-0.37268927693367004,
0.21962103247642517,
0.11394332349300385,
0.10051265358924866,
0.01191580668091774,
-0.17760978639125824,
-0.20066338777542114,
0.13933813571929932,
0.44014772772789,
0.3138062655925751,
-0.721689760684967,
-0.39575716853141785,
-0.51570725440979,
-0.31453394889831543,
0.09939275681972504,
1.2117341756820679,
-0.6683419346809387,
0.47197067737579346,
0.3812532424926758,
0.8533303737640381,
0.6654691100120544,
0.043317414820194244,
0.7680428624153137,
-0.8827338814735413,
0.1661495715379715,
-0.018356651067733765,
0.64327472448349,
0.10134919732809067,
-0.5500484704971313,
0.2561228573322296,
0.1220308244228363,
-0.06976286321878433,
-0.5314470529556274,
0.1962611973285675,
-0.6743432283401489,
-0.39924156665802,
0.6520655751228333,
-0.32187432050704956,
-0.2539041340351105,
-0.5974698066711426,
-0.020995818078517914,
0.6000618934631348,
-0.40107086300849915,
0.8687882423400879,
0.7748640179634094,
0.17128562927246094,
-0.3227611184120178,
-0.45385950803756714,
0.4656333923339844,
0.2803269028663635,
-0.5055621862411499,
-0.06529214978218079,
0.25462573766708374,
0.19468198716640472,
0.27246278524398804,
0.6349502205848694,
-0.3633419871330261,
0.204713836312294,
0.03898073360323906,
0.30196189880371094,
-0.15594308078289032,
-0.20046421885490417,
-0.4842183291912079,
0.40807226300239563,
-0.1855466067790985,
-0.3129691779613495
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18430v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18430v1
|
Exploring language relations through syntactic distances and geographic proximity
| 2024-03-27T10:36:17 | 2024-03-27T10:36:17 |
Juan De Gregorio, Raúl Toral, David Sánchez
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, physics.data-an, physics.soc-ph, stat.AP
|
Languages are grouped into families that share common linguistic traits.
While this approach has been successful in understanding genetic relations
between diverse languages, more analyses are needed to accurately quantify
their relatedness, especially in less studied linguistic levels such as syntax.
Here, we explore linguistic distances using series of parts of speech (POS)
extracted from the Universal Dependencies dataset. Within an
information-theoretic framework, we show that employing POS trigrams maximizes
the possibility of capturing syntactic variations while being at the same time
compatible with the amount of available data. Linguistic connections are then
established by assessing pairwise distances based on the POS distributions.
Intriguingly, our analysis reveals definite clusters that correspond to well
known language families and groups, with exceptions explained by distinct
morphological typologies. Furthermore, we obtain a significant correlation
between language similarity and geographic distance, which underscores the
influence of spatial proximity on language kinships.
|
[
-0.4606810212135315,
-0.5207710862159729,
0.7630177736282349,
0.001406955299898982,
0.07785981148481369,
0.028595730662345886,
-0.43491584062576294,
-0.6310951113700867,
0.4493786692619324,
0.3246658146381378,
-0.2866603136062622,
-0.5957013964653015,
-0.46550849080085754,
0.14527417719364166,
-0.22349412739276886,
0.43903079628944397,
0.1937936395406723,
-0.37026599049568176,
0.09910798817873001,
-0.5716817378997803,
0.1642855852842331,
-0.8638181090354919,
-0.1742444932460785,
0.11713671684265137,
0.5563221573829651,
0.2925996780395508,
0.881844162940979,
0.9568247199058533,
0.4572605490684509,
0.29187309741973877,
-0.31173545122146606,
-0.17002247273921967,
-0.22103296220302582,
0.2831025719642639,
-0.18701371550559998,
-0.8210064172744751,
0.385527104139328,
-0.4615274667739868,
0.8442022204399109,
1.3341752290725708,
0.10273272544145584,
0.21434029936790466,
-0.1514114886522293,
0.8162848353385925,
-0.41452956199645996,
0.20026510953903198,
-0.49679386615753174,
0.19426557421684265,
-1.0113656520843506,
-0.177719846367836,
0.051390983164310455,
-0.5239222049713135,
0.435651570558548,
-0.3538312017917633,
0.548656702041626,
0.045952439308166504,
1.1029387712478638,
0.17029845714569092,
-0.22381740808486938,
-0.08330556005239487,
-0.848522961139679,
0.5886204242706299,
-0.40933099389076233,
0.34136396646499634,
0.5744959115982056,
0.18528617918491364,
-0.32832983136177063,
0.04294601455330849,
-0.39474570751190186,
-0.19580954313278198,
-0.36882805824279785,
-0.26233458518981934,
-0.26763811707496643,
-0.0633791908621788,
0.35027703642845154,
0.33613431453704834,
-0.6279036402702332,
-0.1938110888004303,
-0.3665596544742584,
-0.0367446094751358,
0.4954378604888916,
0.033227525651454926,
0.9132055044174194,
-0.24960359930992126,
0.04661092162132263,
0.13477341830730438,
-0.9705697894096375,
0.18223270773887634,
0.6455771327018738,
0.5395153164863586,
-0.3937704563140869,
0.5728811621665955,
-0.06616804748773575,
0.7420992851257324,
-0.15342456102371216,
-0.08724977821111679,
0.20498348772525787,
-0.6377412676811218,
0.5705142021179199,
-0.014458099380135536,
0.9261040091514587,
0.13664419949054718,
0.6911655068397522,
-0.39687955379486084,
0.5479564666748047,
-0.15824739634990692,
-0.29983213543891907,
-0.07082583755254745,
-0.16685356199741364,
-0.3372504413127899,
-0.42316991090774536,
0.09702683240175247,
0.10391934216022491,
-0.9191629886627197,
-0.13649389147758484,
-0.18163616955280304,
-0.23910120129585266,
-0.5776970982551575,
-0.5098715424537659,
-0.03652491793036461,
-0.12953320145606995,
0.2775675356388092,
-0.44302648305892944,
-1.3121006488800049,
0.38685888051986694,
0.5768681168556213,
0.8543290495872498,
0.08756951242685318,
-0.6749972105026245,
-0.15782463550567627,
0.5086941719055176,
-0.04033762216567993,
1.0153759717941284,
-1.0341373682022095,
-0.3706108033657074,
-0.1526993215084076,
-0.29741552472114563,
-0.15819957852363586,
-0.67601078748703,
-0.11141988635063171,
-0.06960628926753998,
0.07282409071922302,
-0.5391393303871155,
-0.22209200263023376,
-0.2561030983924866,
-0.2934242784976959,
-0.7491800785064697,
1.2141050100326538,
0.4822976589202881,
-1.0135929584503174,
0.24638999998569489,
-0.2361791580915451,
-0.7601414918899536,
0.004153863526880741,
-0.531926155090332,
0.032028768211603165,
0.3154451549053192,
-0.07933217287063599,
0.21555694937705994,
-0.1237315908074379,
0.06861865520477295,
-0.5127518177032471,
0.0007584546692669392,
-0.17229601740837097,
0.19183075428009033,
0.7324485182762146,
0.13770335912704468,
-0.37137919664382935,
-0.06621628254652023,
-0.9002069234848022,
-0.4033341109752655,
0.1724684238433838,
-0.12939779460430145,
-0.8028014302253723,
0.15318630635738373,
-0.584963858127594,
-0.03808622434735298,
0.04882560297846794,
-0.4514898657798767,
0.1952575296163559,
-0.5422389507293701,
0.4624844491481781,
0.2734524607658386,
0.09532869607210159,
0.6837576031684875,
-0.06751400232315063,
0.5868620872497559,
-0.19045117497444153,
0.11273109912872314,
0.14103376865386963,
-0.4837820529937744,
-0.5212264657020569,
-0.012247026897966862,
0.07958848774433136,
0.45226240158081055,
-0.5761876106262207,
0.5375792384147644,
-0.4123043119907379,
-0.41561633348464966,
-0.2544292211532593,
-0.12071400880813599,
0.3249744772911072,
0.3411654829978943,
-0.03653354570269585,
-0.3972775936126709,
-0.513394296169281,
-0.8921647071838379,
-0.1995122879743576,
-0.4158731698989868,
-0.00027837930247187614,
0.10482218861579895,
0.030714230611920357,
0.3485104441642761,
1.1798385381698608,
-0.4404241740703583,
0.05741541460156441,
-0.12755241990089417,
-0.19954201579093933,
0.02171052247285843,
-0.10340934991836548,
1.0792020559310913,
-0.2956124246120453,
-0.6680731177330017,
0.3418632447719574,
-0.5445308685302734,
-0.29106107354164124,
0.5477533340454102,
-0.29865607619285583,
-0.1581052988767624,
0.5337594747543335,
-0.29828789830207825,
0.5175614953041077,
0.8257519602775574,
-0.48224347829818726,
0.44766858220100403,
0.062171049416065216,
-0.03637407347559929,
-1.1340276002883911,
-0.013490329496562481,
0.09942253679037094,
0.03492267429828644,
-0.6304152011871338,
-0.0021650956477969885,
-0.6445023417472839,
-0.018612446263432503,
-0.29781484603881836,
0.3599480390548706,
-0.39571264386177063,
-0.5102532505989075,
0.2895488142967224,
0.3282068371772766,
-0.39825576543807983,
0.3040634095668793,
0.1578468531370163,
0.7779673337936401,
0.6598899960517883,
-0.3863260746002197,
0.2835492193698883,
0.24155130982398987,
-0.2166173756122589,
0.42509394884109497,
-0.4303070604801178,
-0.24462692439556122,
0.0015313398325815797,
-0.059051692485809326,
-1.2020941972732544,
-0.25314804911613464,
0.19332505762577057,
-0.4974018931388855,
0.0421309694647789,
-0.18985922634601593,
-0.5585969090461731,
0.08947118371725082,
-0.051989756524562836,
0.753156304359436,
0.21613773703575134,
-0.3257785439491272,
0.3881527781486511,
0.8176459670066833,
-0.6697664260864258,
-0.20026752352714539,
-0.5022521615028381,
-0.11725407838821411,
-0.5496505498886108,
-0.8547097444534302,
-0.16174833476543427,
0.3954245448112488,
-0.7404874563217163,
0.1844114363193512,
0.060869406908750534,
-0.20923437178134918,
0.06100734323263168,
0.28334155678749084,
-0.11855435371398926,
-0.37858355045318604,
0.278192400932312,
-0.3298155665397644,
-0.01383222360163927,
-0.06629905849695206,
-0.3075301945209503,
0.5883704423904419,
-0.11378559470176697,
-0.029147041961550713,
0.0980021208524704,
0.5010181665420532,
0.4634740352630615,
-0.3185153603553772,
0.7593496441841125,
0.13455574214458466,
-0.34905606508255005,
-0.06074118986725807,
-0.47775378823280334,
0.0206686370074749,
-0.34786638617515564,
0.2147325724363327,
-0.5762266516685486,
-0.9293264746665955,
0.691294252872467,
0.03124668262898922,
-0.3869656026363373,
0.412352055311203,
0.1927339732646942,
-0.10134641081094742,
0.24948956072330475,
0.6709718704223633,
-0.40067777037620544,
0.6072325110435486,
0.20008714497089386,
0.37986770272254944,
-0.48451319336891174,
-0.1731906533241272,
-1.0604064464569092,
0.003917016554623842,
-0.6766212582588196,
-0.2653264105319977,
0.2675468623638153,
0.1935873180627823,
-0.08626362681388855,
0.7478541135787964,
-0.06817834824323654,
0.8065641522407532,
0.6040614247322083,
-0.3864471912384033,
0.22161129117012024,
0.28309568762779236,
-0.3941175937652588,
-0.12918433547019958,
-0.8141072392463684,
-0.3392747938632965,
0.7363929152488708,
0.00023348261311184615,
0.3397141396999359,
0.24197684228420258,
0.7633746266365051,
-0.07040788978338242,
-0.21530863642692566,
-0.4041263163089752,
0.5396472811698914,
-0.5718657970428467,
-0.14166727662086487,
-0.426982045173645,
-0.6466668844223022,
-1.2919002771377563,
-0.07056423276662827,
-0.031221069395542145,
-1.0455714464187622,
0.14739364385604858,
-0.34644439816474915,
-0.3220318853855133,
0.36404865980148315,
-0.7605554461479187,
0.4009075462818146,
-0.25091832876205444,
-0.08905427157878876,
0.17244485020637512,
-1.172935962677002,
0.050959061831235886,
0.11688162386417389,
0.4012743830680847,
-0.2960951328277588,
0.335457980632782,
0.6803854703903198,
-0.531807005405426,
0.6448384523391724,
0.28737571835517883,
-0.3208945691585541,
0.3030024468898773,
0.3566507399082184,
-0.28718703985214233,
-0.5367082357406616,
-0.04600464552640915,
0.5767564177513123,
0.20488470792770386,
-0.4643545150756836,
-0.4683764576911926,
0.681586742401123,
-0.6485506296157837,
-0.22904591262340546,
-0.24541345238685608,
-0.8041955828666687,
-0.38311657309532166,
0.3614325523376465,
0.2243693321943283,
0.32233840227127075,
0.08358938992023468,
-0.24681982398033142,
0.2621800899505615,
-0.29501402378082275,
0.6124523282051086,
0.41947445273399353,
-0.1555033028125763,
-0.24860329926013947,
0.7991881966590881,
0.13092000782489777,
0.46476784348487854,
0.6590831279754639,
0.3611517548561096,
-0.5049005150794983,
-0.2667212188243866,
0.09729088842868805,
0.8040127158164978,
-0.25740471482276917,
0.24324502050876617,
-0.15172725915908813,
0.018694067373871803,
-0.39373236894607544,
-0.0846315547823906,
-0.14529165625572205,
-0.5297839641571045,
0.05049751326441765,
-0.09789641201496124,
0.4536084830760956,
1.3097940683364868,
-0.09151408076286316,
0.23173369467258453,
-0.9239482283592224,
0.3239193558692932,
0.08638367056846619,
0.5095030069351196,
-0.05520864576101303,
-0.1323312669992447,
0.07214809954166412,
-0.18860431015491486,
0.10090558975934982,
-1.1491992473602295,
0.056843437254428864,
0.2963241934776306,
0.5296022891998291,
0.407827764749527,
-0.14305338263511658,
0.8465098738670349,
-0.623784601688385,
0.9059717059135437,
0.31827202439308167,
-0.9233590960502625,
0.4833383858203888,
-0.691941499710083,
0.23151037096977234,
0.5495136976242065,
0.3909028172492981,
-0.6388229727745056,
-0.7883120775222778,
-0.7678698301315308,
-0.7524705529212952,
0.47568652033805847,
0.31701093912124634,
-0.4475086033344269,
-0.2719387710094452,
0.410216748714447,
-0.006541636772453785,
-0.17042407393455505,
-0.314710408449173,
-0.36319366097450256,
0.6065397262573242,
-0.29098424315452576,
-0.06992612779140472,
0.007081451825797558,
-0.013468428514897823,
-0.050207577645778656,
0.10887421667575836,
0.148184671998024,
0.00628488976508379,
0.020443977788090706,
0.0825301855802536,
-0.26157599687576294,
0.2272615134716034,
0.4693015515804291,
0.7789221405982971,
0.18948420882225037,
0.5550296306610107,
-0.06954643875360489,
-0.48057669401168823,
0.13136078417301178,
0.1765139102935791,
0.1025073379278183,
0.45996618270874023,
0.6077440977096558,
0.39033299684524536,
0.07590649276971817,
-0.37429410219192505,
0.38505426049232483,
0.0860188752412796,
0.12501849234104156,
0.07973988354206085,
-0.2550918161869049,
0.5297561883926392,
0.26741155982017517,
0.0018119263695552945,
0.055906955152750015,
0.018687773495912552,
-0.7561392188072205,
0.3039068579673767,
0.17203953862190247,
-0.24123235046863556,
-0.6228024959564209,
0.25262320041656494,
0.2951781749725342,
-0.40528810024261475,
0.46543633937835693,
-0.1425609141588211,
-0.7118982076644897,
0.6551609039306641,
0.1856391280889511,
0.5299632549285889,
-0.5661178231239319,
0.17286814749240875,
0.42516231536865234,
0.21295879781246185,
0.10451209545135498,
0.18748125433921814,
-0.23088186979293823,
-0.5631215572357178,
-0.2822474241256714,
-0.6812597513198853,
-0.024805795401334763,
-0.20746876299381256,
-0.7425095438957214,
0.25642645359039307,
-0.1939849704504013,
0.04565301910042763,
0.04366646334528923,
-0.24210606515407562,
-0.38762998580932617,
-0.2151973992586136,
0.39728477597236633,
0.32051825523376465,
-1.030489206314087,
0.6411033272743225,
0.3804648518562317,
-0.29541659355163574,
-1.1723378896713257,
0.1452159285545349,
-0.026704179123044014,
-0.8252595067024231,
0.7762008309364319,
-0.04625731706619263,
-0.3405109941959381,
-0.2413378208875656,
-0.1518695205450058,
-1.0005180835723877,
0.6250377893447876,
0.5282433032989502,
-0.8053997755050659,
-0.0068259816616773605,
0.7166488170623779,
0.8400791883468628,
-0.07451966404914856,
0.032950762659311295,
0.9739371538162231,
0.15179327130317688,
-0.26278772950172424,
-1.0469759702682495,
0.05928175896406174,
-0.13080991804599762,
0.06898186355829239,
1.0154869556427002,
-0.6528481841087341,
0.5960235595703125,
-0.3072117269039154,
-0.5009182691574097,
0.08235818892717361,
0.3070676624774933,
0.18073305487632751,
0.010152939707040787,
0.4028584659099579,
0.5195257067680359,
0.5771422386169434,
-0.2677733600139618,
0.867267370223999,
-0.5933334231376648,
0.4023154377937317,
1.334492802619934,
-0.29185906052589417,
0.7905093431472778,
0.6693965196609497,
-0.7344931364059448,
0.4882034361362457,
0.44428694248199463,
0.14351755380630493,
0.15860047936439514,
0.5402507781982422,
-0.583507239818573,
0.21837106347084045,
-0.505113422870636,
-0.4119355082511902,
0.37083080410957336,
0.5197847485542297,
-0.2692318856716156,
-0.5536043047904968,
-0.3444678783416748,
0.09842093288898468,
0.32866546511650085,
0.08664580434560776,
0.7284350395202637,
0.011403494514524937,
-0.4825090765953064,
0.36870428919792175,
-0.5850302577018738,
0.22522331774234772,
-0.8610979318618774,
-0.06078409403562546,
-0.29381248354911804,
-0.300801545381546,
-0.3391537666320801,
-1.1611881256103516,
0.4110453128814697,
-0.06234500929713249,
-0.1139659658074379,
0.24046450853347778,
0.42970702052116394,
-0.8149117827415466,
-0.05773073434829712,
0.6555271148681641,
0.39338400959968567,
0.369780957698822,
0.2651018500328064,
-0.13999491930007935,
-0.11318929493427277,
0.020925061777234077,
0.2709656059741974,
0.05380232632160187,
0.7395855188369751,
-0.17578373849391937,
0.42390328645706177,
0.4223135709762573,
0.6591449975967407,
0.6629491448402405,
0.2601848542690277,
0.35036951303482056,
-0.7487543821334839,
-0.49204349517822266,
-0.8970181345939636,
-0.1397048830986023,
0.2582724988460541,
-0.21140846610069275,
0.9267427325248718,
0.48330041766166687,
1.0016489028930664,
0.0009316093637607992,
1.0028715133666992,
-0.29776161909103394,
0.5193238258361816,
-0.2929086685180664,
0.23416008055210114,
-0.26761388778686523,
0.11192631721496582,
-0.23348446190357208,
-1.0489158630371094,
-0.6143887042999268,
0.4771440625190735,
-0.6073676347732544,
-0.4438256621360779,
1.014365792274475,
0.7133591175079346,
0.04029374569654465,
0.023916883394122124,
0.2307479828596115,
0.19543685019016266,
0.06126993149518967,
0.6930251717567444,
1.0426256656646729,
0.08700283616781235,
0.6546528935432434,
-0.5040061473846436,
-0.15887665748596191,
0.2576430141925812,
-0.5444062352180481,
-0.6953198313713074,
-0.8126825094223022,
-0.05808788165450096,
-0.25364699959754944,
0.14017245173454285,
0.6284880042076111,
0.5553547143936157,
-0.6637960076332092,
-0.5007292628288269,
-0.14500807225704193,
-0.005847937893122435,
0.04067399352788925,
-0.29882970452308655,
0.39318788051605225,
-0.19182614982128143,
-0.4883381426334381,
0.10312245041131973,
0.5733969807624817,
0.10183016955852509,
0.0008096317178569734,
0.25694137811660767,
-0.3039436340332031,
-0.20266969501972198,
0.46706080436706543,
0.6583816409111023,
-0.7433911561965942,
-0.5960647463798523,
-0.21896958351135254,
0.05258376896381378,
0.1649579405784607,
0.9048981666564941,
-0.15826290845870972,
0.44752219319343567,
0.7657442092895508,
0.368021696805954,
-0.09222142398357391,
0.10200194269418716,
0.6277187466621399,
-1.0159766674041748,
0.39787065982818604,
-0.046870194375514984,
0.3452904522418976,
0.35415351390838623,
-0.22476695477962494,
0.5586066246032715,
0.337959885597229,
-0.43740832805633545,
-0.2589748203754425,
0.7890762686729431,
-1.0450387001037598,
0.01750154048204422,
1.514541506767273,
-0.1999807208776474,
-0.3118341565132141,
-0.41918954253196716,
-0.20456463098526,
0.2962116599082947,
-0.10030912607908249,
0.6964577436447144,
0.8601155281066895,
-0.2839309871196747,
0.10456116497516632,
-0.10245832055807114,
0.41472309827804565,
0.33548200130462646,
-0.8783160448074341,
0.03395569697022438,
0.3246139585971832,
0.628754198551178,
0.6000562310218811,
0.3981461822986603,
-0.2502421438694,
-0.15504518151283264,
0.04841654747724533,
-0.029364991933107376,
0.5867651104927063,
-0.41628411412239075,
-0.3658633828163147,
0.17321373522281647,
0.027821362018585205,
-0.354595422744751
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18426v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18426v2
|
TriviaHG: A Dataset for Automatic Hint Generation from Factoid Questions
| 2024-03-27T10:27:28 | 2024-05-10T17:10:47 |
Jamshid Mozafari, Anubhav Jangra, Adam Jatowt
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Nowadays, individuals tend to engage in dialogues with Large Language Models,
seeking answers to their questions. In times when such answers are readily
accessible to anyone, the stimulation and preservation of human's cognitive
abilities, as well as the assurance of maintaining good reasoning skills by
humans becomes crucial. This study addresses such needs by proposing hints
(instead of final answers or before giving answers) as a viable solution. We
introduce a framework for the automatic hint generation for factoid questions,
employing it to construct TriviaHG, a novel large-scale dataset featuring
160,230 hints corresponding to 16,645 questions from the TriviaQA dataset.
Additionally, we present an automatic evaluation method that measures the
Convergence and Familiarity quality attributes of hints. To evaluate the
TriviaHG dataset and the proposed evaluation method, we enlisted 10 individuals
to annotate 2,791 hints and tasked 6 humans with answering questions using the
provided hints. The effectiveness of hints varied, with success rates of 96%,
78%, and 36% for questions with easy, medium, and hard answers, respectively.
Moreover, the proposed automatic evaluation methods showed a robust correlation
with annotators' results. Conclusively, the findings highlight three key
insights: the facilitative role of hints in resolving unknown questions, the
dependence of hint quality on answer difficulty, and the feasibility of
employing automatic evaluation methods for hint assessment.
|
[
-0.5169888734817505,
-0.7686351537704468,
0.7687860727310181,
-0.03765930235385895,
-0.32797837257385254,
0.020818565040826797,
-0.1821826696395874,
-0.24707812070846558,
0.14399833977222443,
0.17534705996513367,
-0.6658705472946167,
-0.7464640140533447,
-0.23278245329856873,
0.26608386635780334,
-0.20388174057006836,
1.1637723445892334,
0.12332414835691452,
-0.24953138828277588,
-0.6980605125427246,
0.10808054357767105,
-0.29164958000183105,
-0.255806565284729,
-0.7187353372573853,
0.053401220589876175,
0.4534066617488861,
0.6841799020767212,
0.7657386064529419,
0.7512150406837463,
0.427259236574173,
0.17720693349838257,
0.1733686327934265,
0.45734652876853943,
-0.329349160194397,
0.09192660450935364,
-0.025759946554899216,
-0.4173176884651184,
-0.33378976583480835,
-0.06507786363363266,
0.4099099338054657,
0.6976330280303955,
-0.10863339155912399,
0.8147047162055969,
-0.0817926898598671,
0.2552954852581024,
-0.49542251229286194,
0.1217893660068512,
-0.518057107925415,
-0.21241828799247742,
-0.3781875967979431,
-0.5966110825538635,
0.10748232156038284,
-0.9071534872055054,
0.23173107206821442,
-0.8876033425331116,
0.5100052952766418,
0.46436527371406555,
0.8294528722763062,
0.5554850697517395,
0.056073982268571854,
-0.6460489630699158,
-0.4165978729724884,
0.5695851445198059,
-0.49893975257873535,
-0.4197445213794708,
0.3205944001674652,
0.6350434422492981,
-0.14150922000408173,
-0.20325368642807007,
-0.29956182837486267,
-0.21557290852069855,
0.008013495244085789,
-0.22979693114757538,
-0.09621143341064453,
-0.0830761268734932,
0.6212825179100037,
0.2029220163822174,
-0.2780601978302002,
-0.48772993683815,
-0.29982054233551025,
-0.3861767053604126,
0.8449365496635437,
0.31275027990341187,
0.48943331837654114,
-0.34636080265045166,
-0.04606648534536362,
0.09743202477693558,
-0.6037468314170837,
0.10546539723873138,
0.30572983622550964,
0.10659799724817276,
0.2601311504840851,
0.4885846972465515,
-0.3137075901031494,
0.7156270742416382,
0.2017088234424591,
-0.03619851544499397,
0.1931326687335968,
-0.6602504253387451,
0.436563640832901,
0.09686513990163803,
0.7351431250572205,
0.6575004458427429,
0.6478381156921387,
-0.13318228721618652,
-0.20120590925216675,
0.0031399966683238745,
0.0013592008035629988,
-0.3123915493488312,
-0.3575601279735565,
0.4754699766635895,
-0.10230396687984467,
-0.3531024754047394,
-0.25481927394866943,
-0.6760082244873047,
-0.30394911766052246,
0.02590894140303135,
0.5529639720916748,
-0.49493736028671265,
-0.23821842670440674,
-0.021061647683382034,
-0.4751153588294983,
0.2618798613548279,
0.3543487787246704,
-0.684736967086792,
0.1994132250547409,
0.5651873350143433,
0.6369872093200684,
-0.005555168725550175,
-0.14900223910808563,
-0.6446097493171692,
0.22511409223079681,
-0.40146610140800476,
0.8800679445266724,
-0.3601156771183014,
-0.3101576268672943,
-0.05660128593444824,
-0.35650867223739624,
0.3791065216064453,
-0.31126099824905396,
0.6763538122177124,
-0.4809005856513977,
0.23112007975578308,
-0.5944063067436218,
-0.49115607142448425,
0.04485630616545677,
0.27956724166870117,
-0.7961679697036743,
1.0357059240341187,
-0.08882027119398117,
-0.9335640668869019,
0.5481746792793274,
-0.8910424709320068,
-0.4093879461288452,
0.43670883774757385,
-0.08390729874372482,
-0.20233455300331116,
0.0015194376464933157,
0.7173948884010315,
0.17874382436275482,
-0.5748369693756104,
0.294558048248291,
-0.2663944363594055,
-0.4396165907382965,
0.12612539529800415,
-0.12016310542821884,
1.0152868032455444,
-0.06056809797883034,
-0.4140905737876892,
-0.20155522227287292,
-0.4133704900741577,
0.3350759446620941,
0.13902713358402252,
0.19843314588069916,
-0.46980276703834534,
-0.3702821433544159,
-0.4237336814403534,
0.16842664778232574,
0.3691979944705963,
-0.5432882905006409,
0.01891843043267727,
-0.18066735565662384,
0.01657182350754738,
0.4562772512435913,
0.6420543789863586,
-0.05064532533288002,
-0.6182963252067566,
0.8390079140663147,
-0.29751572012901306,
0.2906329929828644,
0.10917244851589203,
-0.7384825944900513,
-0.4823153614997864,
0.09674519300460815,
0.3938242197036743,
0.47239792346954346,
-0.9595630764961243,
0.37660136818885803,
-0.34028470516204834,
-0.4479507803916931,
-0.9090297818183899,
0.14048326015472412,
0.5993937849998474,
0.39501887559890747,
0.14531253278255463,
0.13310369849205017,
-0.3441385328769684,
-0.7438113689422607,
-0.3744208812713623,
-0.3060563802719116,
-0.31542229652404785,
0.6828901767730713,
0.5753076672554016,
0.555875837802887,
1.4193894863128662,
-0.7602500319480896,
0.12486238032579422,
0.0663866251707077,
0.5520381331443787,
0.01008933037519455,
0.1818067580461502,
0.3950250446796417,
-0.6638771891593933,
-0.026909250766038895,
-0.34900355339050293,
-0.7907954454421997,
-0.2923467755317688,
0.18975266814231873,
-0.30481281876564026,
-0.08156571537256241,
0.442312091588974,
-0.42267537117004395,
0.03127250075340271,
0.06618192791938782,
-0.2884368300437927,
0.794037938117981,
-0.1544838547706604,
0.24341873824596405,
-0.9345018267631531,
0.2502385973930359,
-0.21521888673305511,
0.05420077592134476,
-0.3478960692882538,
-0.34005409479141235,
-0.31938380002975464,
0.08432266861200333,
-0.12298059463500977,
0.88313889503479,
-0.5891631841659546,
-0.11912646144628525,
0.28730738162994385,
0.4434845447540283,
-0.12239235639572144,
0.46218442916870117,
0.09202864021062851,
0.544093906879425,
0.41182655096054077,
-0.7288587689399719,
0.5951518416404724,
0.35665610432624817,
-0.28930020332336426,
0.8096889853477478,
-0.833196759223938,
0.2445690929889679,
-0.28754332661628723,
0.008687282912433147,
-1.2861295938491821,
-0.5334882140159607,
0.33428725600242615,
-1.0086348056793213,
-0.14844591915607452,
-0.07201742380857468,
-0.4404650628566742,
-0.7710791826248169,
-0.39323362708091736,
0.5221114754676819,
0.4759136140346527,
-0.3471498489379883,
0.34057798981666565,
0.40338894724845886,
-0.32614028453826904,
-0.603196918964386,
-0.16457779705524445,
0.06161181256175041,
-0.39779555797576904,
-0.7723537087440491,
-0.1474275439977646,
-0.23022642731666565,
-0.32582128047943115,
0.21419654786586761,
-0.019450027495622635,
0.04291951283812523,
0.09851270169019699,
0.21692872047424316,
0.3501134216785431,
0.02601824887096882,
0.41565608978271484,
-0.13394705951213837,
-0.21712781488895416,
0.5459217429161072,
-0.4995593726634979,
0.06558531522750854,
-0.1527639776468277,
-0.2816542685031891,
0.0026920223608613014,
0.20355869829654694,
0.22164508700370789,
-0.3042224645614624,
0.08124988526105881,
0.674319326877594,
-0.3187766671180725,
-0.17694973945617676,
-0.6540665626525879,
-0.17253035306930542,
-0.39287304878234863,
-0.08314444124698639,
-0.4546137750148773,
-0.5893636345863342,
0.5230579972267151,
-0.10325372219085693,
0.23369833827018738,
0.3772321939468384,
0.3828650414943695,
-0.2994444966316223,
0.9811325073242188,
0.18768835067749023,
0.19190989434719086,
0.014102300629019737,
-0.0043400912545621395,
-0.06806585937738419,
-0.7105103135108948,
-0.19490845501422882,
-0.42562833428382874,
-0.01669151335954666,
-0.2724665105342865,
-0.5574572682380676,
0.609096884727478,
-0.1338084489107132,
0.14842839539051056,
-0.04764566943049431,
-0.5296693444252014,
0.5550164580345154,
0.8642198443412781,
0.18388833105564117,
0.3749753534793854,
-0.10976143181324005,
-0.24883237481117249,
0.26653963327407837,
-0.8959264755249023,
-0.4584861397743225,
1.4907569885253906,
0.0385141484439373,
0.37356120347976685,
-0.0447101853787899,
1.045830488204956,
0.4854079484939575,
0.2039269357919693,
-0.6041346788406372,
0.5627145171165466,
0.30622002482414246,
-0.9758527278900146,
-0.793289065361023,
-0.560637891292572,
-0.5670344829559326,
-0.6133804321289062,
-0.1478392332792282,
-0.5672154426574707,
-0.1328706592321396,
0.33221691846847534,
-0.8878675699234009,
-0.005445454269647598,
-0.6153294444084167,
0.5496698617935181,
-0.35700517892837524,
-0.47931981086730957,
0.3471975326538086,
-0.9079959392547607,
0.4808178246021271,
0.11938345432281494,
0.12114309519529343,
-0.1267460435628891,
0.027303529903292656,
1.034147024154663,
-0.12057874351739883,
0.4241899847984314,
-0.5243659019470215,
-0.2792665660381317,
0.7185497879981995,
0.01813242956995964,
0.3816980719566345,
0.24092599749565125,
-0.008883652277290821,
-0.030372193083167076,
0.13243970274925232,
-0.3925487697124481,
-0.7970852255821228,
0.3125832974910736,
-0.3741035759449005,
-0.6924951672554016,
-0.13717973232269287,
-0.6931530833244324,
-0.3646923005580902,
0.10965532064437866,
0.6037773489952087,
0.5786187052726746,
-0.3833799958229065,
-0.40793928503990173,
0.8993628025054932,
0.0000634233292657882,
0.1596548855304718,
0.2630096673965454,
-0.05498117953538895,
-0.4862414300441742,
0.9267331957817078,
-0.05669953674077988,
0.278648316860199,
0.09637530148029327,
0.2318316549062729,
-0.6340935826301575,
-0.43148404359817505,
-0.4277133345603943,
0.337968647480011,
-0.6703574061393738,
-0.1634947806596756,
-0.38800233602523804,
-0.0129085723310709,
-0.24200285971164703,
-0.0879339724779129,
0.2103920429944992,
-0.568566620349884,
0.03506772220134735,
-0.06768240034580231,
0.6489031314849854,
0.8327254056930542,
-0.3385382890701294,
-0.05434755980968475,
-0.49150779843330383,
0.49144288897514343,
0.6801241636276245,
0.3434012532234192,
-0.029666928574442863,
-0.12666192650794983,
-0.08232469111680984,
0.15067602694034576,
0.4339068830013275,
-0.6485040187835693,
-0.17889069020748138,
0.17222724854946136,
0.4230400323867798,
0.33372974395751953,
0.36071911454200745,
0.2681296169757843,
-0.2592194974422455,
0.865622341632843,
-0.14059728384017944,
-0.6680212616920471,
0.6351915597915649,
-0.6406179070472717,
0.4962135851383209,
0.8132143616676331,
0.49056127667427063,
-0.4764408469200134,
-0.3394206762313843,
-0.9742813110351562,
-0.43387937545776367,
0.6041828393936157,
0.2892427146434784,
-0.34813711047172546,
-0.22942037880420685,
0.4592963755130768,
0.04922235757112503,
0.3902822434902191,
0.040108464658260345,
-0.36595064401626587,
0.02958180010318756,
-0.2627027928829193,
0.20330867171287537,
-0.2573804259300232,
-0.6983526945114136,
-0.1675364375114441,
0.43625614047050476,
-0.37668830156326294,
0.42293933033943176,
0.023687349632382393,
0.019979489967226982,
-0.0822657123208046,
0.2510579228401184,
0.268404483795166,
0.6484942436218262,
-0.6533901691436768,
-0.14602597057819366,
0.17192409932613373,
-0.3858335018157959,
0.1622621715068817,
0.05521988496184349,
-0.4061102569103241,
0.18403150141239166,
0.2933155298233032,
0.37468212842941284,
0.09565287083387375,
-0.4930972754955292,
0.522345781326294,
-0.24435417354106903,
-0.29124653339385986,
-0.31165897846221924,
0.25159895420074463,
0.10703485459089279,
-0.16976961493492126,
0.5458826422691345,
-0.23406477272510529,
0.30532509088516235,
-0.4330156445503235,
0.521972119808197,
0.6360384225845337,
-0.17231538891792297,
-0.012244878336787224,
0.3770716190338135,
0.41689011454582214,
-0.3206537663936615,
0.5667098164558411,
-0.6535507440567017,
-0.5659083127975464,
0.5673198699951172,
0.2467995136976242,
0.9360538125038147,
-0.06900545954704285,
0.5367874503135681,
0.6218948364257812,
0.17193292081356049,
0.04868794605135918,
0.5116309523582458,
-0.5130952000617981,
-0.5095394849777222,
-0.16149412095546722,
-0.5585057139396667,
-0.3344506323337555,
-0.33016252517700195,
-0.6545734405517578,
0.2784299850463867,
-0.2859894931316376,
-0.23892183601856232,
0.07511643320322037,
0.2952113449573517,
-0.6929532885551453,
0.21196456253528595,
0.29263418912887573,
0.9385188221931458,
-0.807442843914032,
0.28004807233810425,
0.6594191789627075,
-0.45778021216392517,
-0.9072521924972534,
0.24917928874492645,
0.12839022278785706,
-0.7815706729888916,
0.31638288497924805,
-0.24908730387687683,
-0.3511699438095093,
0.2028355449438095,
-0.859269380569458,
-0.8700594305992126,
1.20155668258667,
0.12004446238279343,
-0.22448815405368805,
-0.6448920965194702,
0.2118433117866516,
0.5212620496749878,
-0.38463467359542847,
0.6976057887077332,
1.0433828830718994,
0.6873165965080261,
0.6230021715164185,
-0.8574216961860657,
0.2905738055706024,
-0.4711242616176605,
-0.19580629467964172,
0.07329599559307098,
-0.25260135531425476,
0.31508755683898926,
-0.8304367065429688,
-0.5064657926559448,
0.057866815477609634,
0.4310421049594879,
0.5038846135139465,
0.39891302585601807,
0.5692064762115479,
0.3557697534561157,
1.1318718194961548,
-0.11119667440652847,
0.8378102779388428,
-0.30399277806282043,
0.09582686424255371,
1.1296404600143433,
0.17205560207366943,
0.35446223616600037,
0.29609817266464233,
0.05779494717717171,
0.31930190324783325,
0.5395428538322449,
0.0637560710310936,
0.2856963872909546,
0.5279013514518738,
-0.04434344917535782,
-0.4920942485332489,
-0.5144604444503784,
-0.23496825993061066,
0.18994012475013733,
0.6422763466835022,
-0.0025740538258105516,
-0.5698658227920532,
-0.27326762676239014,
0.10716032236814499,
-0.13360948860645294,
-0.38512495160102844,
0.7800144553184509,
-0.13069751858711243,
-0.8634814023971558,
0.780555784702301,
-0.7987829446792603,
0.48531287908554077,
-0.4974762797355652,
-0.28770092129707336,
-0.1892150640487671,
-0.44674152135849,
-0.34011760354042053,
-1.1569790840148926,
-0.10972290486097336,
0.12244639545679092,
0.03174585476517677,
0.18864914774894714,
0.4737096130847931,
-0.587081789970398,
-0.4833005666732788,
-0.27278465032577515,
0.5557917952537537,
0.2846268117427826,
-0.07676853239536285,
-0.5617677569389343,
-0.38764488697052,
0.03356779366731644,
0.2617933750152588,
-0.4725480079650879,
0.8894569873809814,
-0.25157371163368225,
0.8408843278884888,
0.4670744836330414,
0.22538338601589203,
-0.016363700851798058,
-0.1950826644897461,
0.6599202156066895,
-0.684006929397583,
-0.460478812456131,
-0.4427064061164856,
0.36519038677215576,
-0.29494646191596985,
-0.4676017761230469,
0.9897561073303223,
0.1788545697927475,
0.24120134115219116,
0.10542261600494385,
1.0807918310165405,
-0.29431408643722534,
0.6791674494743347,
-0.4858594834804535,
0.45867252349853516,
-0.4154605567455292,
0.1811293065547943,
-0.5954911112785339,
-0.6807024478912354,
-0.0973953902721405,
-0.05078064277768135,
-0.6210386753082275,
0.1259789764881134,
0.6477457880973816,
0.6736065149307251,
0.30563774704933167,
0.0234987735748291,
-0.07660578191280365,
-0.05323703959584236,
0.1486186981201172,
0.8679815530776978,
0.8019446730613708,
-0.22903072834014893,
0.9054796099662781,
-0.08084151148796082,
-0.3973545730113983,
-0.2641473710536957,
-0.8148545622825623,
-0.8612861633300781,
-0.7478727102279663,
-0.3030390739440918,
-0.2898128926753998,
0.31695765256881714,
0.8502157330513,
0.3579080402851105,
-0.6141082048416138,
0.0017661824822425842,
0.115079365670681,
0.24765869975090027,
-0.3250608444213867,
-0.22411468625068665,
0.6671127080917358,
-0.2636708915233612,
-0.3760843276977539,
-0.0822545662522316,
-0.02203565649688244,
-0.1301371306180954,
-0.37757691740989685,
0.07326073944568634,
-0.19127897918224335,
0.03863229230046272,
0.021139763295650482,
0.3965410590171814,
-0.49377012252807617,
-0.3330274224281311,
0.13479068875312805,
0.0989411249756813,
-0.1718788743019104,
0.629485011100769,
-0.8019625544548035,
0.5606892704963684,
0.4806329309940338,
0.45749229192733765,
0.10309027880430222,
0.5705965757369995,
0.841442883014679,
-0.7661740183830261,
-0.4185083508491516,
0.5108112096786499,
-0.13770613074302673,
0.47479456663131714,
-0.6045200228691101,
0.4412551522254944,
-0.103316530585289,
-0.37413597106933594,
-0.5237091779708862,
-0.07549045979976654,
-0.5875250101089478,
0.1399468332529068,
1.206811785697937,
-0.055042024701833725,
-0.6884331703186035,
-0.43221965432167053,
-0.2231147289276123,
0.22519652545452118,
-0.6012709140777588,
1.0261998176574707,
1.0161973237991333,
-0.22171461582183838,
0.08102001249790192,
-0.47185489535331726,
1.335873007774353,
0.26711517572402954,
-0.8989177942276001,
0.345547080039978,
0.5671495795249939,
0.3361528813838959,
0.5011813640594482,
0.7040681838989258,
-0.019283989444375038,
0.782038152217865,
0.07422436028718948,
0.11133450269699097,
-0.13243617117404938,
-0.4810165464878082,
-0.2851124107837677,
0.1620117574930191,
0.2228773683309555,
-0.21036061644554138
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18423v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18423v1
|
SemRoDe: Macro Adversarial Training to Learn Representations That are Robust to Word-Level Attacks
| 2024-03-27T10:24:25 | 2024-03-27T10:24:25 |
Brian Formento, Wenjie Feng, Chuan Sheng Foo, Luu Anh Tuan, See-Kiong Ng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Language models (LMs) are indispensable tools for natural language processing
tasks, but their vulnerability to adversarial attacks remains a concern. While
current research has explored adversarial training techniques, their
improvements to defend against word-level attacks have been limited. In this
work, we propose a novel approach called Semantic Robust Defence (SemRoDe), a
Macro Adversarial Training strategy to enhance the robustness of LMs. Drawing
inspiration from recent studies in the image domain, we investigate and later
confirm that in a discrete data setting such as language, adversarial samples
generated via word substitutions do indeed belong to an adversarial domain
exhibiting a high Wasserstein distance from the base domain. Our method learns
a robust representation that bridges these two domains. We hypothesize that if
samples were not projected into an adversarial domain, but instead to a domain
with minimal shift, it would improve attack robustness. We align the domains by
incorporating a new distance-based objective. With this, our model is able to
learn more generalized representations by aligning the model's high-level
output features and therefore better handling unseen adversarial samples. This
method can be generalized across word embeddings, even when they share minimal
overlap at both vocabulary and word-substitution levels. To evaluate the
effectiveness of our approach, we conduct experiments on BERT and RoBERTa
models on three datasets. The results demonstrate promising state-of-the-art
robustness.
|
[
-0.4669461250305176,
-1.107690691947937,
0.21302436292171478,
-0.27646249532699585,
-0.24845439195632935,
-0.12642459571361542,
-0.22214199602603912,
-0.3494938910007477,
0.126099094748497,
0.27104103565216064,
-0.4384893476963043,
-0.5477385520935059,
-1.1196858882904053,
-0.0006118934252299368,
-0.38740357756614685,
0.8827618956565857,
0.22923114895820618,
0.2256903499364853,
0.010569521225988865,
-0.4578624367713928,
-0.35720545053482056,
-0.5490257740020752,
-0.4082435965538025,
-0.1595977544784546,
0.48978492617607117,
-0.22208242118358612,
1.0455639362335205,
0.47540387511253357,
0.5267751812934875,
0.3339579105377197,
-0.02153915725648403,
0.3015401363372803,
-0.49787551164627075,
0.39155226945877075,
-0.41231784224510193,
-0.38545528054237366,
-0.3086715042591095,
-0.02715417370200157,
0.3471926748752594,
0.6409114599227905,
0.1627092808485031,
-0.2202206403017044,
0.23304803669452667,
0.29545122385025024,
-0.8561729192733765,
-0.24876278638839722,
-1.2230371236801147,
0.04044752195477486,
-0.3490866720676422,
-0.024163831025362015,
-0.5227747559547424,
-0.04746006429195404,
0.12645858526229858,
-0.46431124210357666,
0.30215033888816833,
-0.18459953367710114,
1.1647785902023315,
0.2053031027317047,
-0.27936112880706787,
-0.20332877337932587,
-0.41995444893836975,
0.5849675536155701,
-0.6698682308197021,
0.19508740305900574,
0.20051871240139008,
0.3414419889450073,
-0.41647785902023315,
-0.5253865122795105,
-0.30154407024383545,
-0.2251826822757721,
0.19777606427669525,
0.08626119047403336,
-0.5734856724739075,
0.012854439206421375,
0.2220468968153,
0.056330606341362,
-0.7269397974014282,
0.055467937141656876,
0.008538337424397469,
-0.40001368522644043,
0.23930992186069489,
-0.09937965124845505,
0.657206118106842,
-0.12981152534484863,
-0.681061863899231,
-0.360100656747818,
-0.8831124901771545,
-0.20420962572097778,
0.35920098423957825,
0.5077779293060303,
0.23346997797489166,
0.6342214941978455,
0.27457040548324585,
0.5565020442008972,
-0.1546415090560913,
0.06000043824315071,
-0.18483203649520874,
0.029832134023308754,
-0.14589108526706696,
-0.06835612654685974,
0.702218234539032,
0.09341282397508621,
0.18065990507602692,
-0.34881168603897095,
-0.49866050481796265,
0.5449798703193665,
0.6013131737709045,
-0.551067590713501,
-0.12084823846817017,
-0.10028179734945297,
-0.11916956305503845,
-0.47549301385879517,
0.33219459652900696,
-0.7345046401023865,
-0.41483667492866516,
0.06992858648300171,
0.9145587086677551,
-0.833299994468689,
0.07319759577512741,
-0.0016516768373548985,
-0.21441607177257538,
0.161529079079628,
0.06937800347805023,
-0.7599815130233765,
0.5328438878059387,
0.6935414671897888,
0.8205811381340027,
-0.09820850193500519,
-0.4831133484840393,
-0.852428674697876,
0.28462839126586914,
-0.39756280183792114,
0.6569116115570068,
-0.4196944534778595,
-0.4505630433559418,
0.19234564900398254,
-0.08232846856117249,
-0.23332802951335907,
-0.5870935320854187,
0.2255024015903473,
-0.7821511030197144,
0.1386302411556244,
-0.05042458325624466,
-0.7106402516365051,
-0.07365428656339645,
0.5447666049003601,
-0.835132360458374,
0.8290024995803833,
0.22049075365066528,
-1.142873764038086,
0.2472241371870041,
-0.2625429332256317,
-0.5040551424026489,
-0.1383010745048523,
-0.1676350235939026,
-0.5936480760574341,
0.15508770942687988,
0.4299371540546417,
0.394895076751709,
0.10430730879306793,
-0.14194725453853607,
-0.6910427808761597,
-0.1328626424074173,
0.328676700592041,
-0.5955395102500916,
0.7591114044189453,
0.12235050648450851,
-0.41893133521080017,
0.06092298775911331,
-0.6120120882987976,
-0.0706498846411705,
0.41666078567504883,
-0.14957280457019806,
-0.6949321031570435,
-0.13899356126785278,
-0.32894274592399597,
-0.11020153015851974,
0.31671321392059326,
-0.45827242732048035,
0.10708033293485641,
-0.5700745582580566,
0.14541441202163696,
0.8200879096984863,
0.01507057249546051,
0.6509557366371155,
-0.19414164125919342,
0.5469266772270203,
-0.04980861768126488,
0.06464716047048569,
0.12217801809310913,
-0.19360767304897308,
-0.4590885043144226,
-0.4128521680831909,
0.543494462966919,
0.663750410079956,
-1.0279598236083984,
0.3342326581478119,
-0.3660047948360443,
-0.13269087672233582,
-0.4331382215023041,
0.36342501640319824,
0.32264989614486694,
0.319796621799469,
0.4403824806213379,
-0.15263375639915466,
-0.552066445350647,
-0.6200034618377686,
-0.467035174369812,
0.09772195667028427,
-0.11488424241542816,
-0.03595634177327156,
0.6606951355934143,
-0.5696935057640076,
0.6473689079284668,
-0.3416464924812317,
-0.18954910337924957,
-0.5145542025566101,
0.1478503793478012,
-0.15238358080387115,
0.25330281257629395,
0.6119844317436218,
-0.7412899732589722,
-0.34244441986083984,
-0.06996005028486252,
-0.5736904740333557,
-0.136739119887352,
-0.08629897236824036,
-0.2761058807373047,
0.1001339852809906,
0.4509127140045166,
-0.5292276740074158,
0.5266351103782654,
0.5217460989952087,
-0.29439324140548706,
0.2873407006263733,
-0.3194270431995392,
-0.2813555896282196,
-1.2119786739349365,
-0.29853448271751404,
-0.0725133940577507,
-0.5193793177604675,
-0.7434119582176208,
0.27352574467658997,
0.042336687445640564,
-0.29538652300834656,
-0.4393884241580963,
0.3738479018211365,
-0.23424038290977478,
0.07462026923894882,
-0.3209797739982605,
0.20359207689762115,
0.07457390427589417,
0.3197661340236664,
-0.07368668168783188,
0.6573944687843323,
0.7033201456069946,
-0.5360100865364075,
0.2637552320957184,
0.1653415858745575,
-0.1622074991464615,
0.6990011930465698,
-0.7685385942459106,
0.1684788018465042,
0.0011423990363255143,
-0.021102754399180412,
-0.644198477268219,
-0.19099637866020203,
0.1640234738588333,
-0.6848521828651428,
0.7234071493148804,
0.06008384749293327,
-0.37388086318969727,
-0.13710357248783112,
-0.5433632135391235,
0.09322847425937653,
0.34154030680656433,
-0.6977313160896301,
0.5430530905723572,
0.4077337086200714,
0.057072434574365616,
-0.570430338382721,
-0.7250296473503113,
0.26403528451919556,
-0.37500110268592834,
-0.7240049242973328,
0.464083731174469,
0.3156966269016266,
-0.20182083547115326,
0.14998605847358704,
-0.04931686818599701,
-0.08324018865823746,
0.3109431564807892,
-0.04330427944660187,
0.3764406740665436,
-0.14607223868370056,
-0.0598907545208931,
-0.37571707367897034,
-0.1293911337852478,
0.010891897603869438,
-0.3689959943294525,
0.6065168976783752,
-0.12689131498336792,
-0.6205785274505615,
-0.18544360995292664,
0.5085638165473938,
0.5541695952415466,
-0.2355317622423172,
0.9685272574424744,
0.898341953754425,
-0.6854420900344849,
-0.480843722820282,
-0.18910209834575653,
-0.24802656471729279,
-0.4699802100658417,
0.6138705015182495,
-0.3485502600669861,
-0.7258395552635193,
0.437228262424469,
0.06214476376771927,
-0.2009476274251938,
0.38158273696899414,
0.3143058717250824,
0.023115500807762146,
1.1584280729293823,
0.4735933840274811,
-0.470615416765213,
0.32796356081962585,
-0.45590654015541077,
0.16257405281066895,
-0.7425037622451782,
-0.02716696262359619,
-0.22378502786159515,
-0.11720595508813858,
-0.37847885489463806,
-0.37601402401924133,
0.471253901720047,
-0.03178516402840614,
-0.2977012097835541,
0.6300255060195923,
-0.05439658463001251,
0.29394733905792236,
0.5784339904785156,
0.33469268679618835,
-0.34875962138175964,
0.026210464537143707,
-0.23161379992961884,
-0.13544921576976776,
-0.9171683192253113,
-0.523216962814331,
0.9143028855323792,
0.5021275877952576,
1.0714420080184937,
0.30697470903396606,
0.774994432926178,
0.5060142278671265,
-0.026292774826288223,
-0.712149977684021,
0.521867036819458,
-0.37086373567581177,
-0.22001999616622925,
-0.28321823477745056,
-0.41533026099205017,
-0.9556607007980347,
0.4100172817707062,
-0.23759716749191284,
-0.6520660519599915,
-0.06975175440311432,
-0.04249871149659157,
-0.20755848288536072,
0.6554269790649414,
-0.4436098337173462,
0.8305626511573792,
-0.2261553555727005,
-0.28874918818473816,
-0.008556257002055645,
-0.5972263216972351,
-0.018184946849942207,
0.07986930012702942,
0.1049400120973587,
0.272705078125,
0.03769192472100258,
0.5176700353622437,
-0.7142152190208435,
0.9468362927436829,
-0.1373925507068634,
-0.11142737418413162,
0.2377190887928009,
0.47711119055747986,
0.8038144707679749,
-0.08097463101148605,
0.1571023166179657,
-0.09702345728874207,
-0.2613460123538971,
-0.6423724293708801,
-0.7375297546386719,
0.4803176820278168,
-0.6579685807228088,
-0.8008788228034973,
-0.4227909743785858,
-0.5351045727729797,
-0.25331419706344604,
0.25691694021224976,
0.5850738883018494,
0.7078208923339844,
-0.51912522315979,
0.18209266662597656,
0.9493542313575745,
-0.2274419516324997,
0.17946796119213104,
0.13915859162807465,
0.4327576756477356,
-0.7264354228973389,
0.8576462864875793,
-0.055667050182819366,
0.6330494284629822,
0.5193491578102112,
0.15064792335033417,
-0.4672639071941376,
-0.4007187783718109,
-0.24769897758960724,
-0.036043643951416016,
-0.824889063835144,
-0.45676925778388977,
-0.4015561044216156,
-0.3224910795688629,
-0.6746919751167297,
-0.337631493806839,
-0.398254930973053,
-0.23886601626873016,
-0.26448291540145874,
0.00827037077397108,
0.06809499859809875,
0.8095536828041077,
-0.1159220039844513,
0.1819770336151123,
-0.5190553069114685,
0.2840953767299652,
0.5881291627883911,
-0.19214904308319092,
-0.15961399674415588,
-0.6687946319580078,
-0.1343054324388504,
0.18420515954494476,
-0.39512377977371216,
-1.0041990280151367,
0.5435330271720886,
0.4070291221141815,
0.6166066527366638,
0.5416972041130066,
0.1816713660955429,
0.4538419842720032,
-0.5959237217903137,
0.7227562069892883,
0.1656394600868225,
-0.9466938376426697,
0.6992694735527039,
-0.32632115483283997,
0.3168591260910034,
0.32761019468307495,
0.20539076626300812,
-0.18140052258968353,
-0.741824209690094,
-0.781607449054718,
-0.6843223571777344,
0.29805803298950195,
0.26050251722335815,
0.2138328105211258,
-0.15859635174274445,
-0.0014035651693120599,
-0.07517756521701813,
-0.13745035231113434,
-0.85394287109375,
0.0699315294623375,
-0.4245756268501282,
-0.30467885732650757,
0.15513676404953003,
-0.13121826946735382,
-0.23894003033638,
0.06976024061441422,
0.6470093727111816,
-0.12350879609584808,
0.274030476808548,
0.24466001987457275,
-0.44312039017677307,
0.3657950162887573,
0.329092800617218,
0.47797393798828125,
0.1453603208065033,
0.002665494102984667,
0.8102190494537354,
0.5706864595413208,
-0.40239858627319336,
0.12238117307424545,
0.05961378291249275,
0.04207608103752136,
0.08823081851005554,
0.8048769235610962,
0.7622851729393005,
0.17474991083145142,
-0.4426039159297943,
0.953311562538147,
0.008349735289812088,
-0.15294970571994781,
0.07168038189411163,
-0.02160404808819294,
-0.2596856355667114,
0.2750861644744873,
-0.15224045515060425,
0.2552168071269989,
-0.07738145440816879,
-0.45503756403923035,
0.3813513219356537,
0.8577215671539307,
-0.5206230878829956,
-0.36757466197013855,
0.7254764437675476,
-0.28267166018486023,
-0.07702292501926422,
0.1695653796195984,
-0.2624663710594177,
-1.142843246459961,
0.5389747619628906,
0.8073340058326721,
0.864435076713562,
-0.2727055847644806,
0.26855090260505676,
-0.02860233746469021,
0.392154723405838,
-0.0026602917350828648,
-0.030180005356669426,
0.060877855867147446,
-0.7409409880638123,
0.26676487922668457,
-0.36575546860694885,
-0.15893010795116425,
0.2388898879289627,
-0.6892927885055542,
0.1699722409248352,
-0.5196408629417419,
-0.21550631523132324,
-0.30635324120521545,
-0.18055790662765503,
-0.44834378361701965,
0.11892667412757874,
0.29173263907432556,
0.894653856754303,
-0.7374663352966309,
0.806261420249939,
0.6728163957595825,
-0.22506611049175262,
-0.5287140607833862,
0.06303004175424576,
0.08407574146986008,
-0.7145379185676575,
0.5331993103027344,
0.03630485758185387,
-0.396363228559494,
-0.5199527740478516,
-0.45793411135673523,
-0.656347930431366,
0.8177782893180847,
0.43424248695373535,
0.06284237653017044,
0.1571076363325119,
0.29194170236587524,
0.481188029050827,
-0.37497493624687195,
-0.28924474120140076,
0.2868402898311615,
0.061404142528772354,
-0.007591364439576864,
-0.2867312729358673,
0.0460050068795681,
-0.27317753434181213,
0.3591175079345703,
0.12668709456920624,
-0.3851797580718994,
0.733062207698822,
-0.09612711519002914,
-0.3148247003555298,
0.2104293406009674,
0.9073865413665771,
-0.016189558431506157,
0.029047589749097824,
0.5806850790977478,
0.8089020252227783,
0.8394885063171387,
-0.05808030813932419,
1.152010202407837,
-0.2216634303331375,
0.2993757426738739,
1.0997257232666016,
-0.1348579078912735,
0.8680974245071411,
0.18924634158611298,
-0.01028952095657587,
0.2805885672569275,
0.45843812823295593,
-0.06994394212961197,
0.8190574645996094,
0.09707468003034592,
-0.31470924615859985,
-0.22570227086544037,
0.12515589594841003,
-0.33731934428215027,
0.40699487924575806,
0.4723389148712158,
-0.2665388286113739,
-0.44796982407569885,
0.2500733733177185,
0.22421057522296906,
0.34900403022766113,
-0.17461061477661133,
0.7102656364440918,
0.04325060173869133,
-0.25939324498176575,
0.771999180316925,
-0.09904737025499344,
0.6306331157684326,
-0.917643129825592,
0.3037841320037842,
-0.05138358473777771,
0.4855805039405823,
0.11850669980049133,
-0.360678106546402,
0.32709822058677673,
0.03523845225572586,
0.0718909353017807,
0.015825845301151276,
0.961760938167572,
-0.4385387897491455,
-0.38652142882347107,
0.403382807970047,
0.20549355447292328,
-0.3438977003097534,
0.06377123296260834,
-0.7010959386825562,
-0.02219962142407894,
-0.17506976425647736,
-0.09620819240808487,
0.3673381209373474,
0.6056767702102661,
0.15315453708171844,
0.6287452578544617,
0.27068763971328735,
0.5179518461227417,
0.21959355473518372,
0.23980137705802917,
0.9660632014274597,
-0.3413451313972473,
-0.42190682888031006,
-1.0720876455307007,
0.017694618552923203,
-0.215439110994339,
0.03429821878671646,
0.9085283279418945,
0.2718886435031891,
0.7828700542449951,
-0.04724540188908577,
0.828498899936676,
0.15609221160411835,
0.387879878282547,
-0.678059995174408,
0.6677980422973633,
-0.4398365914821625,
0.3354164958000183,
-0.34399980306625366,
-0.7144697904586792,
-0.4781228303909302,
0.6227329969406128,
-0.31381955742836,
-0.13734300434589386,
0.5884178876876831,
1.019134759902954,
-0.19826006889343262,
-0.14675234258174896,
0.4898900091648102,
0.13343535363674164,
0.5275384783744812,
0.6774159669876099,
0.8745748400688171,
-0.48089051246643066,
0.5097253322601318,
-0.1690666675567627,
-0.16722966730594635,
0.029055727645754814,
-0.6916335821151733,
-1.1772526502609253,
-0.39303210377693176,
-0.22346512973308563,
-0.5980452299118042,
0.3952861428260803,
0.8762673139572144,
0.5738703608512878,
-0.9693278074264526,
0.18655861914157867,
-0.08110261708498001,
-0.014799809083342552,
-0.024069910869002342,
-0.1910938322544098,
0.5183258652687073,
-0.6657798886299133,
-0.5699256658554077,
0.3900165557861328,
0.1930009126663208,
0.4705970585346222,
-0.37201905250549316,
-0.047989919781684875,
-0.09880063682794571,
0.33299121260643005,
0.5054847598075867,
0.16777238249778748,
-0.6311277747154236,
-0.44522157311439514,
-0.014791094698011875,
-0.34615767002105713,
-0.12074033915996552,
0.592560350894928,
-0.5253399610519409,
0.48845380544662476,
0.3811923861503601,
1.0659116506576538,
-0.19403919577598572,
-0.033025581389665604,
0.7024573087692261,
-0.7882304787635803,
0.28991350531578064,
0.16096898913383484,
0.6653186082839966,
0.5325242280960083,
-0.36785340309143066,
0.2752258777618408,
0.2694631814956665,
-0.2786661386489868,
-0.6838736534118652,
0.38967201113700867,
-0.70451420545578,
-0.6147675514221191,
1.3295865058898926,
-0.41935500502586365,
-0.5745165348052979,
0.059707917273044586,
-0.17150156199932098,
0.23870283365249634,
-0.045608438551425934,
0.8492623567581177,
0.6098795533180237,
0.4308288097381592,
0.3483012318611145,
-0.3397468626499176,
0.45247897505760193,
0.47345101833343506,
-0.5011476278305054,
-0.17336001992225647,
0.15336193144321442,
0.1866082102060318,
0.04669550806283951,
-0.0629182904958725,
-0.2654567360877991,
0.2115674763917923,
0.2060689926147461,
-0.4453258812427521,
0.023516114801168442,
-0.44951286911964417,
-0.4348832070827484,
0.18199682235717773,
0.01866108737885952,
-0.5207307934761047
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18421v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18421v1
|
BioMedLM: A 2.7B Parameter Language Model Trained On Biomedical Text
| 2024-03-27T10:18:21 | 2024-03-27T10:18:21 |
Elliot Bolton, Abhinav Venigalla, Michihiro Yasunaga, David Hall, Betty Xiong, Tony Lee, Roxana Daneshjou, Jonathan Frankle, Percy Liang, Michael Carbin, Christopher D. Manning
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Models such as GPT-4 and Med-PaLM 2 have demonstrated impressive performance
on a wide variety of biomedical NLP tasks. However, these models have hundreds
of billions of parameters, are computationally expensive to run, require users
to send their input data over the internet, and are trained on unknown data
sources. Can smaller, more targeted models compete? To address this question,
we build and release BioMedLM, a 2.7 billion parameter GPT-style autoregressive
model trained exclusively on PubMed abstracts and full articles. When
fine-tuned, BioMedLM can produce strong multiple-choice biomedical
question-answering results competitive with much larger models, such as
achieving a score of 57.3% on MedMCQA (dev) and 69.0% on the MMLU Medical
Genetics exam. BioMedLM can also be fine-tuned to produce useful answers to
patient questions on medical topics. This demonstrates that smaller models can
potentially serve as transparent, privacy-preserving, economical and
environmentally friendly foundations for particular NLP applications, such as
in biomedicine. The model is available on the Hugging Face Hub:
https://huggingface.co/stanford-crfm/BioMedLM.
|
[
-0.34515702724456787,
-0.5525906085968018,
0.7841156125068665,
0.056754205375909805,
-0.37893539667129517,
-0.10327064990997314,
0.040477193892002106,
-0.822378933429718,
0.11780969798564911,
0.5648643374443054,
-0.36010318994522095,
-0.23232212662696838,
-0.5649604797363281,
0.18316566944122314,
-0.13360841572284698,
1.1936025619506836,
0.22093455493450165,
0.3333286941051483,
-0.3739881217479706,
-0.4702069163322449,
0.03664424642920494,
-0.6378675103187561,
-0.8439216613769531,
-0.40555301308631897,
1.182726502418518,
-0.04232563450932503,
0.736762523651123,
0.7648119926452637,
0.6843020915985107,
0.10256250202655792,
-0.20699886977672577,
0.0872945562005043,
-0.2547077238559723,
0.1723119467496872,
-0.2707473635673523,
-0.18660667538642883,
-0.587568998336792,
0.3550666868686676,
0.558564305305481,
0.9307006597518921,
-0.06833861023187637,
0.5199198126792908,
-0.038582589477300644,
0.827251672744751,
0.057353243231773376,
0.11801936477422714,
-0.42573267221450806,
-0.23493464291095734,
-0.048127610236406326,
0.1548636555671692,
-0.4722525477409363,
-0.3099418580532074,
-0.05832703784108162,
-0.09160372614860535,
0.1630411595106125,
0.20081116259098053,
0.7835515141487122,
0.5151836276054382,
-0.40171581506729126,
0.12932831048965454,
-0.4517340362071991,
0.5117404460906982,
-0.8188785910606384,
0.5078383088111877,
0.5186920166015625,
0.36396607756614685,
-0.03790300711989403,
-0.9243924617767334,
0.005493501201272011,
-0.22320596873760223,
-0.07886924594640732,
-0.11107095330953598,
-0.14960584044456482,
0.18851150572299957,
0.25901439785957336,
-0.014095868915319443,
-0.9367467761039734,
0.11571735888719559,
-0.8029447197914124,
-0.06237848103046417,
0.7377801537513733,
0.2842899560928345,
0.08681827783584595,
-0.1104905754327774,
-0.025705453008413315,
0.168527752161026,
-0.6557910442352295,
-0.15774492919445038,
-0.028416704386472702,
0.32220780849456787,
-0.08585696667432785,
0.5130234956741333,
-0.11983317136764526,
0.8072986006736755,
-0.11506220698356628,
0.15427717566490173,
-0.07542634755373001,
-0.33989131450653076,
-0.23645801842212677,
-0.2553403377532959,
0.8000644445419312,
0.21076901257038116,
-0.24936111271381378,
-0.07192488014698029,
0.10510197281837463,
-0.18660219013690948,
0.48725780844688416,
-1.1066124439239502,
-0.554266631603241,
0.513954758644104,
-0.779319703578949,
-0.32949724793434143,
-0.4299050569534302,
-0.6055883169174194,
-0.34547004103660583,
-0.1422683149576187,
0.4318009316921234,
-0.2717849910259247,
0.09811490774154663,
0.06608418375253677,
0.015131835825741291,
0.24229244887828827,
0.3745684325695038,
-0.7153420448303223,
0.21587827801704407,
0.46173399686813354,
1.0262558460235596,
0.002976051066070795,
0.01748489961028099,
-0.35070839524269104,
-0.017896641045808792,
-0.2540018558502197,
0.7069353461265564,
-0.47444403171539307,
-0.3718656301498413,
-0.584823489189148,
-0.08218438178300858,
-0.12453468143939972,
-0.40147098898887634,
0.08660129457712173,
-0.5489585399627686,
0.3674912452697754,
-0.39796367287635803,
-0.5715469121932983,
-0.043988391757011414,
0.03916288912296295,
-0.6119020581245422,
0.777718722820282,
0.30295658111572266,
-0.6784632205963135,
0.1474747210741043,
-0.6627873182296753,
-0.2206677347421646,
0.15937736630439758,
-0.24868613481521606,
-0.6613745093345642,
0.07515875995159149,
-0.06785504519939423,
0.3338448703289032,
-0.538317859172821,
0.3490372896194458,
-0.5786903500556946,
0.022519968450069427,
0.07672691345214844,
-0.42759427428245544,
0.9907472133636475,
0.29816922545433044,
-0.16124218702316284,
0.08656101673841476,
-0.5362057089805603,
0.20730356872081757,
0.12117737531661987,
-0.5570129156112671,
-0.19167719781398773,
-0.04935915768146515,
0.055384498089551926,
0.5066291689872742,
0.22322557866573334,
-0.5795868039131165,
0.26491469144821167,
-0.6340348124504089,
0.5523605942726135,
0.21615856885910034,
-0.011669177561998367,
0.16367752850055695,
-0.43709394335746765,
0.6268309950828552,
-0.3265076279640198,
0.44405585527420044,
0.24989880621433258,
-1.048457384109497,
-0.21005356311798096,
-0.5497324466705322,
0.6286715269088745,
0.23910841345787048,
-0.31608250737190247,
0.13976545631885529,
0.2619779706001282,
-0.8493269681930542,
-0.8412799835205078,
0.07991790026426315,
0.41577136516571045,
0.7194917798042297,
0.5462999939918518,
0.061591628938913345,
-0.3262564241886139,
-1.0380700826644897,
-0.38106071949005127,
-0.42378196120262146,
-0.21027855575084686,
0.49821385741233826,
0.523993730545044,
-0.34863442182540894,
0.8969816565513611,
-0.4690167307853699,
-0.07113499939441681,
-0.10592158883810043,
0.2010963261127472,
0.13662849366664886,
0.4439590573310852,
0.6900101900100708,
-0.8006967902183533,
-0.39795342087745667,
-0.07171853631734848,
-0.5909309387207031,
-0.39618805050849915,
0.28149303793907166,
-0.022050445899367332,
0.08148603141307831,
0.49565038084983826,
-0.7963554263114929,
0.24031031131744385,
0.7010970115661621,
-0.416485458612442,
0.41807085275650024,
-0.5778524875640869,
-0.285035640001297,
-0.9335482120513916,
0.3886995315551758,
-0.08489618450403214,
-0.5235556960105896,
-0.5008918642997742,
0.2832202911376953,
0.19481472671031952,
-0.238136425614357,
-0.4415307343006134,
0.9444190859794617,
-0.3123881220817566,
0.05462527275085449,
-0.28055351972579956,
-0.3104477524757385,
0.19931155443191528,
0.17741592228412628,
0.07626626640558243,
0.5387386083602905,
0.15480124950408936,
-0.4124149680137634,
0.18014468252658844,
0.2609531283378601,
0.02025030553340912,
0.038713376969099045,
-0.9542742371559143,
0.17658059298992157,
-0.150833398103714,
0.46832993626594543,
-0.9018911719322205,
-0.43781137466430664,
0.05798656865954399,
-0.40873464941978455,
0.19656549394130707,
-0.0919346809387207,
-0.439947247505188,
-0.5362365245819092,
-0.22613880038261414,
0.3239401876926422,
0.8575448393821716,
-0.27931880950927734,
0.4437403082847595,
0.4236522614955902,
-0.6080191731452942,
-0.12660516798496246,
-0.5676108598709106,
-0.1362898200750351,
-0.015097885392606258,
-0.17328883707523346,
-0.051350925117731094,
-0.2022528201341629,
-0.03452124446630478,
0.0193621926009655,
0.0009178976179100573,
-0.14725583791732788,
0.027532348409295082,
0.19136562943458557,
0.27189958095550537,
-0.27362334728240967,
0.20399022102355957,
0.34491583704948425,
-0.04803801327943802,
0.17439231276512146,
-0.3403794467449188,
0.2882409691810608,
-0.10611594468355179,
-0.39319559931755066,
-0.055628854781389236,
0.5804100036621094,
0.7054527997970581,
-0.1597473919391632,
0.8137593269348145,
0.4891203045845032,
-0.4405493140220642,
0.16109566390514374,
-0.33528631925582886,
-0.3002014756202698,
-0.3870410919189453,
0.4221741259098053,
-0.04049789905548096,
-0.9174879193305969,
0.3017561733722687,
0.15968677401542664,
0.21367837488651276,
0.6644060015678406,
0.8659655451774597,
-0.244359090924263,
1.4758902788162231,
0.57783442735672,
0.1140693873167038,
-0.13569341599941254,
0.13498859107494354,
0.016992423683404922,
-0.647342324256897,
-0.3234555721282959,
-0.5781698822975159,
-0.3713954985141754,
-0.5187948346138,
-0.5990762114524841,
0.5286619663238525,
-0.04248005151748657,
-0.31758376955986023,
0.2229917347431183,
-0.7146281003952026,
0.20053178071975708,
0.6616802215576172,
0.3269732892513275,
0.10582377761602402,
-0.28159356117248535,
-0.2231302708387375,
0.01568828895688057,
-0.8472550511360168,
-0.5217655897140503,
0.9769945740699768,
0.6592058539390564,
0.55929034948349,
0.2076178938150406,
0.5862555503845215,
0.022354722023010254,
0.5988427996635437,
-0.5765876770019531,
0.4200931489467621,
-0.2443682700395584,
-1.0748234987258911,
-0.37377509474754333,
-0.49262890219688416,
-0.9168533086776733,
0.292445570230484,
-0.06101231649518013,
-0.5692488551139832,
0.20560918748378754,
0.47493091225624084,
-0.6815071105957031,
0.2012750506401062,
-0.5197126269340515,
1.0006027221679688,
-0.2392372488975525,
-0.31266072392463684,
0.06749007850885391,
-1.1580613851547241,
0.09481382369995117,
-0.466072142124176,
0.13587822020053864,
-0.3648986220359802,
-0.37174561619758606,
0.6665114760398865,
-0.4359460175037384,
0.8220911622047424,
-0.1776130646467209,
0.0902344137430191,
-0.006145695224404335,
-0.05198612064123154,
0.20359130203723907,
0.21757221221923828,
-0.14589840173721313,
0.39326438307762146,
0.44362208247184753,
-0.6078751683235168,
-0.35062792897224426,
0.40451765060424805,
-0.4960794150829315,
-0.42727452516555786,
-0.36077308654785156,
-0.5200421214103699,
-0.4208103120326996,
0.19502617418766022,
0.5387218594551086,
0.3105795979499817,
0.008588159456849098,
0.29311180114746094,
0.7926648259162903,
-0.44385233521461487,
0.15944011509418488,
0.6695165038108826,
-0.40912359952926636,
-0.15675126016139984,
0.6252897381782532,
-0.035815365612506866,
0.20792077481746674,
0.2957233488559723,
0.5332151651382446,
-0.5351549983024597,
-0.5725662112236023,
-0.48339253664016724,
0.45656973123550415,
-0.3722418248653412,
-0.3238522410392761,
-1.0489331483840942,
-0.47571927309036255,
-0.36462175846099854,
-0.021506033837795258,
-0.35539641976356506,
-0.34430620074272156,
-0.3833494186401367,
0.10184583812952042,
0.5881397724151611,
0.7219653129577637,
-0.19723433256149292,
0.013556704856455326,
-0.9559402465820312,
0.39059537649154663,
0.38023948669433594,
0.4980630576610565,
-0.43295934796333313,
-0.5859102010726929,
-0.1576416790485382,
-0.013208935968577862,
0.08670533448457718,
-0.9315295219421387,
0.5520042777061462,
0.3284403681755066,
0.2846943140029907,
0.04089413955807686,
-0.11802530288696289,
0.23745879530906677,
-0.9203804135322571,
0.7020828723907471,
0.036305516958236694,
-0.25701749324798584,
0.5484110116958618,
-0.5723952054977417,
0.39425429701805115,
0.6657626628875732,
0.4875534176826477,
-0.2550384998321533,
-0.6416979432106018,
-0.7931774258613586,
-0.6793612241744995,
0.49403250217437744,
0.026824062690138817,
0.1025691106915474,
-0.04072045907378197,
0.6225836277008057,
0.21556703746318817,
0.31084492802619934,
-0.4454430043697357,
-0.1990317404270172,
0.12260544300079346,
-0.5163891911506653,
-0.07946670800447464,
-0.3399811387062073,
-0.07821375131607056,
-0.6110423803329468,
0.4599078297615051,
-0.08033385872840881,
0.3561173379421234,
0.1587221920490265,
0.20787493884563446,
0.15227054059505463,
0.054071683436632156,
0.6674208045005798,
0.43014711141586304,
-0.33758479356765747,
0.048774123191833496,
0.0015523819020017982,
-0.7350159883499146,
0.038674671202898026,
0.36807385087013245,
-0.2117653787136078,
0.22646473348140717,
0.09229205548763275,
0.46339723467826843,
0.052744802087545395,
-0.6373736262321472,
0.2480093538761139,
0.019165746867656708,
-0.5048359632492065,
0.26332294940948486,
0.008135885000228882,
0.32380422949790955,
0.32627254724502563,
0.18873126804828644,
0.06060655415058136,
0.40006351470947266,
-0.27495917677879333,
0.5169981718063354,
0.43406760692596436,
-0.5721855163574219,
-0.1870782971382141,
1.346077799797058,
0.19542625546455383,
-0.21203666925430298,
0.3277722895145416,
-0.008663448505103588,
-0.31585580110549927,
0.5525561571121216,
0.4133189916610718,
0.4579414129257202,
-0.4159207046031952,
0.2660866975784302,
0.23929552733898163,
0.3386910855770111,
-0.2417592853307724,
0.3598611652851105,
0.33212146162986755,
-0.1252925992012024,
-0.4778693616390228,
-0.9067354798316956,
-0.6792542338371277,
0.2595665156841278,
-0.5601270794868469,
-0.009868084453046322,
-0.5978866815567017,
-0.40931832790374756,
0.44981980323791504,
0.024203257635235786,
-0.47240644693374634,
0.4276174008846283,
-0.011744511313736439,
0.8790790438652039,
-0.7860128879547119,
0.9358200430870056,
0.8115962743759155,
-0.4352523684501648,
-0.8109676241874695,
-0.39490923285484314,
-0.014639449305832386,
-0.7092833518981934,
0.6917819976806641,
-0.09662257134914398,
0.194528728723526,
0.07599999010562897,
-0.7022252678871155,
-0.8994041085243225,
0.6272342801094055,
0.577992856502533,
-0.5613880753517151,
-0.28744882345199585,
-0.059115249663591385,
0.8437666893005371,
-0.2275885045528412,
0.025405919179320335,
0.43400856852531433,
0.2870798110961914,
-0.1989056020975113,
-1.0568901300430298,
0.03785465657711029,
-0.19619043171405792,
-0.038202621042728424,
0.23158320784568787,
-0.7187250852584839,
0.9006858468055725,
-0.3329247832298279,
0.3615851104259491,
0.2318284809589386,
0.29354327917099,
0.3413555324077606,
0.3778362274169922,
0.10690660774707794,
0.130161315202713,
0.7593148946762085,
0.08565504848957062,
1.2338753938674927,
-0.1826612502336502,
0.3494836986064911,
1.06047523021698,
-0.34068921208381653,
0.8978414535522461,
0.3360127806663513,
-0.35771554708480835,
0.2830045223236084,
0.9065511226654053,
0.015408297069370747,
0.4320571720600128,
0.0459645576775074,
-0.21791239082813263,
-0.2216874659061432,
0.04961852729320526,
-0.4623146057128906,
0.25400781631469727,
0.34163787961006165,
-0.5357942581176758,
-0.10366673022508621,
0.21210318803787231,
0.0011837455676868558,
-0.16034162044525146,
-0.25928422808647156,
0.6894485950469971,
0.3535480201244354,
-0.20507606863975525,
0.2175569087266922,
0.022813808172941208,
0.19663739204406738,
-0.6045151948928833,
-0.0925491601228714,
-0.22923029959201813,
-0.07606669515371323,
0.0805768221616745,
-0.4965275824069977,
0.4136979579925537,
0.06424713134765625,
-0.3193933963775635,
-0.07953303307294846,
0.8447703123092651,
-0.5711154937744141,
-0.5861315727233887,
0.0731172189116478,
0.48470956087112427,
0.46159565448760986,
-0.10961642861366272,
-1.0196425914764404,
-0.23060373961925507,
-0.27578309178352356,
-0.2985713481903076,
0.48292288184165955,
0.04758372902870178,
0.03385232388973236,
0.7057343125343323,
0.5323168635368347,
0.40023863315582275,
-0.0693332850933075,
0.0541345477104187,
0.6199007630348206,
-0.614676296710968,
-0.33353450894355774,
-0.7798229455947876,
0.1740509271621704,
-0.1351451575756073,
-0.15833845734596252,
0.6087390780448914,
0.5861528515815735,
0.24977335333824158,
-0.05427451804280281,
0.6603198647499084,
0.16506919264793396,
0.9979720711708069,
-0.35002362728118896,
0.9530903697013855,
-0.7785865664482117,
-0.03443098068237305,
0.06725683808326721,
-0.6777897477149963,
-0.49386900663375854,
0.5144575834274292,
-0.1963052600622177,
0.45164090394973755,
0.6956554651260376,
0.41183581948280334,
0.09251265972852707,
-0.09684571623802185,
0.5537122488021851,
0.25447869300842285,
0.12546037137508392,
0.46738508343696594,
0.35258957743644714,
-0.28416118025779724,
0.35727638006210327,
-0.0066413660533726215,
-0.14451846480369568,
-0.44732534885406494,
-0.7210355997085571,
-0.8509638905525208,
-0.3377309739589691,
-0.38453301787376404,
-0.4218601584434509,
0.14268772304058075,
1.0326675176620483,
0.7573345899581909,
-0.6788104772567749,
0.1952272355556488,
0.2775682806968689,
-0.24466972053050995,
-0.2106860876083374,
-0.11446511000394821,
0.44991767406463623,
-0.11653629690408707,
-0.38955703377723694,
0.3159538805484772,
0.5041625499725342,
0.10586851090192795,
-0.33135583996772766,
0.1562996208667755,
-0.10566362738609314,
0.38633421063423157,
0.6441442370414734,
0.5528013110160828,
-0.6471748352050781,
-0.2918306291103363,
0.06658860296010971,
-0.5831952691078186,
-0.06606793403625488,
0.5729459524154663,
-0.6169097423553467,
0.20630291104316711,
0.29130545258522034,
0.9082745909690857,
0.3625282943248749,
0.015645869076251984,
0.5853495001792908,
-0.7628653049468994,
-0.03314502537250519,
0.4883573651313782,
0.28657346963882446,
0.2483409196138382,
-0.4997571110725403,
0.5506078600883484,
0.04516066983342171,
-0.7462656497955322,
-0.7692852020263672,
0.16143831610679626,
-0.9182358980178833,
-0.67151939868927,
1.2279136180877686,
0.24160146713256836,
-0.14854654669761658,
-0.4295869469642639,
-0.25495532155036926,
0.17662543058395386,
-0.0978143960237503,
0.6656824946403503,
0.3513754606246948,
-0.37311139702796936,
-0.18999117612838745,
-1.004783272743225,
0.7550878524780273,
0.44003090262413025,
-0.8674448728561401,
-0.006112538743764162,
0.5562362670898438,
0.3980407118797302,
-0.19013555347919464,
0.9523622393608093,
-0.2622569501399994,
0.31482818722724915,
0.010887260548770428,
-0.11449487507343292,
-0.017897965386509895,
-0.2951820194721222,
-0.39358648657798767,
0.11744991689920425,
0.24158670008182526,
-0.024395808577537537
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18406v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18406v1
|
An Image Grid Can Be Worth a Video: Zero-shot Video Question Answering Using a VLM
| 2024-03-27T09:48:23 | 2024-03-27T09:48:23 |
Wonkyun Kim, Changin Choi, Wonseok Lee, Wonjong Rhee
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Stimulated by the sophisticated reasoning capabilities of recent Large
Language Models (LLMs), a variety of strategies for bridging video modality
have been devised. A prominent strategy involves Video Language Models
(VideoLMs), which train a learnable interface with video data to connect
advanced vision encoders with LLMs. Recently, an alternative strategy has
surfaced, employing readily available foundation models, such as VideoLMs and
LLMs, across multiple stages for modality bridging. In this study, we introduce
a simple yet novel strategy where only a single Vision Language Model (VLM) is
utilized. Our starting point is the plain insight that a video comprises a
series of images, or frames, interwoven with temporal information. The essence
of video comprehension lies in adeptly managing the temporal aspects along with
the spatial details of each frame. Initially, we transform a video into a
single composite image by arranging multiple frames in a grid layout. The
resulting single image is termed as an image grid. This format, while
maintaining the appearance of a solitary image, effectively retains temporal
information within the grid structure. Therefore, the image grid approach
enables direct application of a single high-performance VLM without
necessitating any video-data training. Our extensive experimental analysis
across ten zero-shot video question answering benchmarks, including five
open-ended and five multiple-choice benchmarks, reveals that the proposed Image
Grid Vision Language Model (IG-VLM) surpasses the existing methods in nine out
of ten benchmarks.
|
[
-0.6434299945831299,
-0.7710718512535095,
0.5870177149772644,
0.061683207750320435,
-0.714634895324707,
0.01579299196600914,
0.1893823742866516,
-0.06503178924322128,
-0.43701961636543274,
0.5171149373054504,
-0.5570644736289978,
-0.5597708821296692,
-0.27316465973854065,
-0.22250649333000183,
-0.4565250277519226,
0.7782878279685974,
-0.27257072925567627,
0.17253001034259796,
-0.6428810954093933,
-0.3833667039871216,
-0.4519428014755249,
-0.13225986063480377,
-0.23542451858520508,
-0.27279335260391235,
0.37913987040519714,
0.1862860471010208,
0.6221954226493835,
0.7758488655090332,
0.44104963541030884,
0.2551133632659912,
0.10157033801078796,
0.06970661878585815,
-0.4933473467826843,
-0.11153018474578857,
0.07641849666833878,
-0.29846206307411194,
-0.146549254655838,
-0.29612767696380615,
0.7016226053237915,
0.6687949895858765,
0.004662512335926294,
0.6577051281929016,
-0.30890408158302307,
0.4923624098300934,
-0.8657189607620239,
-0.3491230905056,
-0.869244396686554,
0.36137229204177856,
-0.01643478497862816,
-0.38948774337768555,
-0.3091928958892822,
0.08046995103359222,
-0.27801215648651123,
-0.522882342338562,
0.3102049231529236,
-0.1653936207294464,
0.9317846894264221,
0.46587851643562317,
-0.2750087082386017,
0.5103733539581299,
-0.7779055833816528,
0.4119127690792084,
-0.48411551117897034,
0.42697733640670776,
0.21233218908309937,
0.8273612260818481,
0.5967156887054443,
-0.5205852389335632,
-0.6579084992408752,
0.09470584243535995,
0.11378395557403564,
0.14464159309864044,
-0.013252024538815022,
0.2083132266998291,
0.3571101129055023,
0.14657096564769745,
-0.9878510236740112,
-0.1132025346159935,
-0.3924824297428131,
0.1270209699869156,
0.6045984625816345,
0.5598409175872803,
0.3730916380882263,
-0.20485174655914307,
-0.8296643495559692,
0.17189154028892517,
-0.4839804172515869,
0.3393957316875458,
0.04558466002345085,
-0.07271821051836014,
-0.1377013921737671,
0.7300018668174744,
-0.1706855744123459,
1.1013402938842773,
-0.2952342927455902,
-0.3676179349422455,
-0.24630753695964813,
-0.573969841003418,
-0.7330473065376282,
-0.096621572971344,
0.42610594630241394,
0.5543960332870483,
0.07842843979597092,
-0.15088002383708954,
-0.33889567852020264,
0.3668988347053528,
0.4075978398323059,
-0.7975057363510132,
0.16515283286571503,
0.04167624190449715,
-0.4630081355571747,
0.032708387821912766,
-0.13528822362422943,
-0.8121204972267151,
-0.07061265408992767,
-0.34285038709640503,
0.9248921871185303,
-0.23726774752140045,
-0.1066027358174324,
0.35730859637260437,
-0.2070508450269699,
0.675798237323761,
0.6759129166603088,
-0.4558466374874115,
0.42597687244415283,
0.4538576602935791,
0.9160928726196289,
0.3170680105686188,
-0.33685609698295593,
-0.7210873365402222,
0.24752923846244812,
-0.463364839553833,
0.7676968574523926,
-0.5936667323112488,
-0.4116803705692291,
0.10566969960927963,
-0.10136555880308151,
-0.05380890145897865,
-0.156373530626297,
-0.06771738082170486,
-0.6853370666503906,
0.22121195495128632,
-0.21200089156627655,
-0.27181705832481384,
-0.17664988338947296,
0.4196271300315857,
-0.46550896763801575,
0.637463390827179,
-0.05709293484687805,
-0.5465078353881836,
0.2559526264667511,
-0.3335898816585541,
0.04173647239804268,
0.3615105450153351,
-0.5247467160224915,
-0.32938745617866516,
-0.03315307945013046,
0.2503848671913147,
0.1043517142534256,
-0.26673972606658936,
0.159935861825943,
-0.3975624740123749,
-0.4329166114330292,
0.05777712166309357,
-0.7319821119308472,
0.3002524971961975,
0.30302953720092773,
0.022877339273691177,
-0.26145491003990173,
-0.5577231645584106,
0.1644497662782669,
-0.04869675636291504,
-0.07220982760190964,
-0.0873284712433815,
-0.27430760860443115,
0.02649209275841713,
0.4058671295642853,
0.10314484685659409,
-0.7123729586601257,
0.03129645064473152,
0.1617891937494278,
0.00004222690040478483,
0.5838028192520142,
-0.036318182945251465,
0.3889739513397217,
-0.35635945200920105,
0.8895424008369446,
0.18015903234481812,
0.28117862343788147,
-0.5778933763504028,
-0.30055928230285645,
-0.5491877794265747,
-0.18622882664203644,
-0.06647364050149918,
0.4556279182434082,
-1.0090081691741943,
-0.5504350662231445,
-0.3239367604255676,
-0.3533173203468323,
-0.7848401069641113,
0.277494877576828,
0.739755392074585,
0.49091511964797974,
0.37574905157089233,
-0.39650240540504456,
-0.4856334924697876,
-0.7811182737350464,
-0.011669706553220749,
-0.1343933641910553,
0.006286927033215761,
0.5092356204986572,
0.3334881365299225,
0.3889467120170593,
0.9489066004753113,
-0.5287236571311951,
-0.11120816320180893,
-0.07194506376981735,
-0.047017212957143784,
0.25034037232398987,
-0.07051630318164825,
0.7123683094978333,
-0.9013512134552002,
-0.60882967710495,
0.2963433563709259,
-1.1512773036956787,
0.14500918984413147,
-0.3316338062286377,
0.14073167741298676,
-0.022385472431778908,
0.48758867383003235,
-0.4196259379386902,
0.9649403095245361,
0.3115610182285309,
-0.39903524518013,
0.4787118136882782,
-0.27762553095817566,
0.21364547312259674,
-0.33469972014427185,
0.09593679755926132,
0.045725733041763306,
-0.4249413311481476,
-0.7897214293479919,
0.015689559280872345,
-0.18230456113815308,
-0.5020613074302673,
-0.907573938369751,
0.7826558351516724,
-0.4912545680999756,
-0.5057440400123596,
-0.16235384345054626,
0.1574898511171341,
0.12184864282608032,
0.5785684585571289,
-0.018322546035051346,
0.8538265228271484,
0.7833750247955322,
-0.5277474522590637,
0.3279285728931427,
0.3834444284439087,
-0.3935619294643402,
0.8418807983398438,
-0.7632889151573181,
-0.1588534414768219,
-0.872800886631012,
-0.22678989171981812,
-1.375874400138855,
0.058764949440956116,
-0.22886058688163757,
-0.3457068204879761,
0.21323949098587036,
-0.3114704191684723,
0.22547975182533264,
-0.39656490087509155,
-0.05850524082779884,
0.6784695982933044,
0.4747381806373596,
-0.4804193079471588,
0.4586479961872101,
0.14819477498531342,
0.03736858069896698,
-0.7439365386962891,
-0.6027075052261353,
0.3330153822898865,
-0.23854464292526245,
-0.7268087267875671,
0.18100637197494507,
-0.042555294930934906,
-0.28589802980422974,
0.45484626293182373,
-0.25798937678337097,
-0.2233324646949768,
-0.11325784027576447,
0.26727527379989624,
0.31662070751190186,
-0.4045119881629944,
0.24535733461380005,
-0.48957255482673645,
-0.06693655252456665,
-0.41448649764060974,
-0.12790028750896454,
0.4185156226158142,
-0.18229421973228455,
-0.6150331497192383,
-0.22939875721931458,
0.7687467336654663,
0.8048678040504456,
-0.30988508462905884,
0.4975581765174866,
0.6572014689445496,
-0.19219407439231873,
-0.15392494201660156,
-0.5958986878395081,
0.13613706827163696,
-0.4173731803894043,
0.3965272307395935,
-0.5342966318130493,
-0.7053328156471252,
0.3542821705341339,
0.2999681830406189,
0.02231367863714695,
-0.29109999537467957,
0.3930908441543579,
-0.3099914789199829,
0.8907535672187805,
0.5228466391563416,
0.33311599493026733,
0.530418872833252,
-0.4652445614337921,
0.3082062005996704,
-0.6136419773101807,
-0.3785802721977234,
-0.08398671448230743,
-0.31630396842956543,
0.031547822058200836,
-0.521162211894989,
0.8509564399719238,
0.12771448493003845,
-0.68611741065979,
0.026904793456196785,
-0.07614251226186752,
0.5985344052314758,
0.255703866481781,
0.21151979267597198,
0.38503554463386536,
0.21542024612426758,
-0.044986650347709656,
0.05990102142095566,
-1.0043988227844238,
-0.47670918703079224,
0.7520772814750671,
0.2134631723165512,
1.0136792659759521,
0.17488247156143188,
0.23481032252311707,
0.17696671187877655,
-0.01920158416032791,
-0.5055995583534241,
0.8947401642799377,
-0.2911423444747925,
-0.30390921235084534,
-0.43469712138175964,
0.08675835281610489,
-0.7694091796875,
0.615202784538269,
-0.14778771996498108,
-0.6673637628555298,
0.08248816430568695,
0.09177088737487793,
-0.4224289655685425,
0.6713544130325317,
-0.37108778953552246,
0.9569635391235352,
-0.4554649293422699,
-0.854919970035553,
0.03153927996754646,
-0.6755254864692688,
0.5136706829071045,
0.2947671413421631,
0.26654163002967834,
0.04839439317584038,
-0.1141250729560852,
0.1805558204650879,
-0.6607910990715027,
0.7222256064414978,
-0.10726634413003922,
0.2366025447845459,
0.5218402743339539,
0.22155632078647614,
0.06346332281827927,
0.13893945515155792,
0.3237112760543823,
-0.012019664980471134,
0.17683298885822296,
-0.6086102724075317,
-0.8577181696891785,
0.43296289443969727,
-0.7301381826400757,
-0.9048441648483276,
-0.08050983399152756,
-0.44016459584236145,
-0.1387193650007248,
0.005103544797748327,
0.013313154689967632,
0.8684990406036377,
-0.05116761848330498,
0.28077998757362366,
0.5680163502693176,
-0.04577229917049408,
0.9997742176055908,
0.3641587495803833,
-0.5974473357200623,
-0.5560217499732971,
0.7191277146339417,
0.06406491994857788,
0.619938313961029,
0.34322401881217957,
-0.2519344687461853,
-0.27249687910079956,
-0.29553061723709106,
-0.7243278622627258,
0.24076542258262634,
-0.70585036277771,
-0.38760942220687866,
-0.6502657532691956,
-0.37841761112213135,
-0.1873064637184143,
-0.3731186091899872,
-0.23788931965827942,
-0.04960083216428757,
-0.14897041022777557,
-0.224178746342659,
0.24230660498142242,
0.31678399443626404,
0.13724708557128906,
0.23135334253311157,
-0.8148725628852844,
0.5715256929397583,
1.0925337076187134,
0.5722621083259583,
0.024611573666334152,
-0.3447081446647644,
-0.15385475754737854,
0.06319758296012878,
-0.20493601262569427,
-0.9915310740470886,
0.4517505168914795,
0.20344898104667664,
0.7099558711051941,
0.4330081045627594,
-0.324823260307312,
1.2134379148483276,
-0.6024545431137085,
1.1166993379592896,
0.4900127649307251,
-0.7103684544563293,
0.225466787815094,
-0.35986918210983276,
0.574017345905304,
0.38810139894485474,
0.2365105301141739,
-0.7656224370002747,
0.21760980784893036,
-0.42791053652763367,
-0.4243316650390625,
0.26939281821250916,
-0.008145439438521862,
0.0953228548169136,
0.14200866222381592,
0.1135220155119896,
0.06543389707803726,
0.4341762661933899,
-0.6722339987754822,
0.03673738241195679,
-0.647728443145752,
0.2291639894247055,
-0.07947735488414764,
-0.10250948369503021,
-0.37242424488067627,
-0.23680977523326874,
0.268923819065094,
-0.32117027044296265,
0.33908748626708984,
0.431838721036911,
-0.1739482879638672,
-0.35778969526290894,
0.24927769601345062,
0.5127948522567749,
0.6714170575141907,
-0.1284836083650589,
0.3843620717525482,
0.27256351709365845,
-0.1620292365550995,
0.41846659779548645,
-0.5549255609512329,
-0.4692789912223816,
0.40713778138160706,
0.3345586061477661,
1.3610455989837646,
0.05963395535945892,
-0.7650178670883179,
0.7950626611709595,
0.2591567039489746,
-0.5313075184822083,
-0.09996199607849121,
-0.11800443381071091,
-0.20847563445568085,
0.2809501588344574,
0.24899521470069885,
-0.156517893075943,
-0.24887636303901672,
-0.5790928602218628,
0.3130849599838257,
0.8642346262931824,
-0.6433168649673462,
-0.2566515803337097,
0.7124109864234924,
-0.050247956067323685,
-0.4064914882183075,
0.22108310461044312,
-0.04475431144237518,
-0.3352135419845581,
0.7276242971420288,
0.462872713804245,
0.7097198963165283,
0.08923991769552231,
0.8626492023468018,
0.389213502407074,
0.26010218262672424,
-0.0012599139008671045,
0.5020056962966919,
-0.2679779529571533,
-0.5573525428771973,
-0.5567264556884766,
-0.5532904863357544,
-0.15172503888607025,
0.09498131275177002,
-0.5960900783538818,
0.39127421379089355,
-0.32241714000701904,
0.040448546409606934,
-0.33095595240592957,
-0.29774779081344604,
-1.0498080253601074,
0.3124949336051941,
0.5567935109138489,
1.010254979133606,
-0.9516686797142029,
0.5871587991714478,
0.733919620513916,
-0.5391228199005127,
-0.5184977054595947,
-0.542799711227417,
-0.17235320806503296,
-0.9098050594329834,
0.5758597254753113,
-0.20948532223701477,
-0.04331471771001816,
0.024078400805592537,
-0.8213695883750916,
-0.662438690662384,
1.2404510974884033,
0.12034976482391357,
-0.4304291903972626,
-0.09290880709886551,
0.11326918005943298,
0.46309682726860046,
-0.4716373085975647,
0.3829164505004883,
0.23339296877384186,
0.3236336410045624,
0.6221009492874146,
-0.8434451222419739,
-0.2789772152900696,
-0.2952236235141754,
0.2759157121181488,
0.2922815680503845,
-0.5833629965782166,
0.8094356060028076,
-0.4777740240097046,
-0.4617466330528259,
0.06785307824611664,
0.3232385218143463,
0.000010667238711903337,
0.7903855443000793,
0.5144567489624023,
0.7947292923927307,
0.23673678934574127,
0.288737416267395,
0.8922065496444702,
0.002336702076718211,
0.3614508807659149,
1.105786919593811,
-0.22449171543121338,
0.6196280717849731,
0.8561526536941528,
-0.23114486038684845,
0.25276535749435425,
0.28234386444091797,
0.047980278730392456,
0.7432741522789001,
0.06908677518367767,
-0.5890867114067078,
-0.9894600510597229,
-0.41714826226234436,
-0.43744704127311707,
0.5920097827911377,
0.12829101085662842,
-0.022198079153895378,
-0.9377371072769165,
0.37768781185150146,
-0.25723832845687866,
0.39035141468048096,
-0.7209994196891785,
0.839279055595398,
-0.029800979420542717,
-0.6061157584190369,
0.6454609632492065,
-0.6260690689086914,
0.1691994071006775,
-0.7078415155410767,
-0.0947936624288559,
-0.3644457757472992,
-0.27653080224990845,
-0.20950964093208313,
-0.8247178196907043,
0.0433184951543808,
0.18211373686790466,
-0.02081633359193802,
-0.23320595920085907,
0.515119194984436,
-0.7935783863067627,
-0.5547593235969543,
-0.10411299020051956,
0.8064973950386047,
-0.032668787986040115,
0.33125025033950806,
-0.2745996117591858,
-0.07875538617372513,
-0.23506197333335876,
0.10254033654928207,
0.3902356028556824,
0.3520851135253906,
-0.061959780752658844,
0.8902711272239685,
0.4427490234375,
0.034232329577207565,
0.055875785648822784,
-0.08137775957584381,
1.0592633485794067,
-0.6804478168487549,
-0.438323974609375,
-0.7477837204933167,
0.8084686398506165,
-0.013750128448009491,
-0.04330873489379883,
0.6579393744468689,
0.3162257969379425,
0.7365579009056091,
-0.16948482394218445,
0.9416897296905518,
0.3298008143901825,
-0.11175905913114548,
-0.6356459856033325,
0.20596054196357727,
-0.8727255463600159,
0.14816084504127502,
-0.19609402120113373,
-0.6686851978302002,
-0.39756593108177185,
0.243783637881279,
-0.40023893117904663,
-0.3647066056728363,
0.6519724130630493,
0.9091092944145203,
-0.04443635791540146,
-0.0708782896399498,
0.9793943166732788,
0.08001309633255005,
0.30439436435699463,
0.767896831035614,
0.861835241317749,
-0.43228667974472046,
0.6318960189819336,
-0.08269248902797699,
0.0662119910120964,
-0.1369561403989792,
-1.0121766328811646,
-0.7941483855247498,
-0.41641852259635925,
-0.2941025495529175,
-0.15219996869564056,
0.2545407712459564,
0.4975825250148773,
0.5450358986854553,
-0.08879469335079193,
-0.29105111956596375,
0.13897749781608582,
0.17335709929466248,
-0.2890334129333496,
-0.10782218724489212,
-0.04086188226938248,
-0.06408398598432541,
-0.3018009662628174,
0.1523270308971405,
0.6728427410125732,
0.0876917913556099,
-0.6556817889213562,
-0.007109804544597864,
-0.24676568806171417,
0.16043660044670105,
0.6309259533882141,
0.5251456499099731,
-0.7004913687705994,
-0.5469011664390564,
0.25535276532173157,
-0.02037765271961689,
0.20482772588729858,
0.9822123050689697,
-1.0606961250305176,
0.9812140464782715,
0.7115929126739502,
0.6950902938842773,
0.9159289598464966,
0.32468852400779724,
0.2369687557220459,
-0.508678138256073,
0.25280600786209106,
0.08664091676473618,
0.3296099901199341,
0.28887465596199036,
-0.11484483629465103,
0.41277268528938293,
0.30007287859916687,
-0.33131852746009827,
-0.8946971297264099,
0.4287734925746918,
-1.1647952795028687,
-0.3886600732803345,
1.1831845045089722,
0.06558451801538467,
-0.47052767872810364,
-0.1924787312746048,
-0.32427778840065,
-0.18343187868595123,
0.1934291124343872,
0.529752254486084,
0.4071258306503296,
0.22462016344070435,
-0.7135274410247803,
-0.6451617479324341,
0.05368245393037796,
0.37294450402259827,
-0.49455538392066956,
-0.2968394160270691,
0.43742647767066956,
0.1811140775680542,
-0.1753750741481781,
0.7226460576057434,
-0.015828756615519524,
0.6452974081039429,
0.22494082152843475,
0.033584654331207275,
-0.5122865438461304,
-0.5410248041152954,
-0.6005572080612183,
0.6129603385925293,
-0.2802480161190033,
-0.6055189967155457
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18381v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18381v1
|
Improving Attributed Text Generation of Large Language Models via Preference Learning
| 2024-03-27T09:19:13 | 2024-03-27T09:19:13 |
Dongfang Li, Zetian Sun, Baotian Hu, Zhenyu Liu, Xinshuo Hu, Xuebo Liu, Min Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models have been widely adopted in natural language
processing, yet they face the challenge of generating unreliable content.
Recent works aim to reduce misinformation and hallucinations by resorting to
attribution as a means to provide evidence (i.e., citations). However, current
attribution methods usually focus on the retrieval stage and automatic
evaluation that neglect mirroring the citation mechanisms in human scholarly
writing to bolster credibility. In this paper, we address these challenges by
modelling the attribution task as preference learning and introducing an
Automatic Preference Optimization (APO) framework. First, we create a curated
collection for post-training with 6,330 examples by collecting and filtering
from existing datasets. Second, considering the high cost of labelling
preference data, we further propose an automatic method to synthesize
attribution preference data resulting in 95,263 pairs. Moreover, inspired by
the human citation process, we further propose a progressive preference
optimization method by leveraging fine-grained information. Extensive
experiments on three datasets (i.e., ASQA, StrategyQA, and ELI5) demonstrate
that APO achieves state-of-the-art citation F1 with higher answer quality.
|
[
-0.09955858439207077,
-0.356532484292984,
0.806189239025116,
-0.016340985894203186,
-0.3220827877521515,
-0.29316017031669617,
-0.32547926902770996,
-0.3380889594554901,
0.11477350443601608,
0.45368656516075134,
-0.35461732745170593,
-0.36163854598999023,
-0.5357627868652344,
0.4160555303096771,
-0.09365899115800858,
1.2700096368789673,
-0.08550301939249039,
-0.22482101619243622,
-0.4212241768836975,
-0.0002663563354872167,
-0.008829109370708466,
-0.5251186490058899,
-0.7020193338394165,
-0.5088309645652771,
0.7069724202156067,
0.6191685795783997,
0.6859889030456543,
0.8049330115318298,
0.24831445515155792,
0.19879010319709778,
0.2059604674577713,
0.5982468128204346,
-0.41545915603637695,
0.2773008346557617,
-0.3353802263736725,
-0.27416470646858215,
-0.2995266318321228,
0.15136250853538513,
0.6683116555213928,
0.4832099676132202,
0.18838030099868774,
0.27332058548927307,
0.037304386496543884,
0.7657278776168823,
-0.8572733402252197,
0.05412924662232399,
-1.019755244255066,
-0.29928508400917053,
-0.3011086583137512,
-0.4498932659626007,
-0.8049477338790894,
-0.7691985368728638,
0.3836170434951782,
-0.7901728749275208,
0.2505585551261902,
0.25400078296661377,
0.8439855575561523,
0.057901594787836075,
-0.3751690089702606,
-0.7055091857910156,
-0.30208590626716614,
1.1266952753067017,
-0.47179970145225525,
0.06999070197343826,
0.6454686522483826,
-0.26809000968933105,
0.04778474196791649,
-0.4962637424468994,
-0.2870620787143707,
-0.3222101032733917,
-0.1637316346168518,
-0.18609654903411865,
-0.07938617467880249,
-0.30288833379745483,
-0.2592988908290863,
0.1174284815788269,
-0.4180774688720703,
-0.15838117897510529,
-0.04056304693222046,
-0.16314619779586792,
0.6844004988670349,
-0.22778883576393127,
-0.1219947561621666,
-0.5521347522735596,
-0.09916875511407852,
-0.30975934863090515,
-0.6726652979850769,
-0.23622292280197144,
0.6116567254066467,
0.4488958716392517,
0.5170787572860718,
0.5776260495185852,
0.038896799087524414,
0.5134172439575195,
0.21549773216247559,
0.18908260762691498,
0.3639879822731018,
-0.10639400780200958,
0.13645048439502716,
0.25426220893859863,
0.9135059118270874,
0.28667527437210083,
0.511602520942688,
-0.4127986431121826,
-0.0980047732591629,
-0.17113341391086578,
0.4686800241470337,
-0.6748524904251099,
-0.3769383430480957,
0.02175898663699627,
-0.344713032245636,
-0.6259404420852661,
0.07425053417682648,
-0.6003549098968506,
-0.2624029219150543,
-0.5231320261955261,
0.30486899614334106,
-0.47393736243247986,
0.033989351242780685,
-0.07966358959674835,
0.08708909898996353,
-0.18645669519901276,
0.3209397494792938,
-0.9745930433273315,
-0.025121141225099564,
0.39455199241638184,
0.8340588808059692,
-0.4933610260486603,
-0.21246200799942017,
-0.8108919858932495,
0.47170937061309814,
-0.1544453650712967,
1.0196343660354614,
-0.6997584700584412,
-0.40237075090408325,
0.06848198920488358,
-0.23812568187713623,
0.13527953624725342,
-0.5766059756278992,
0.9533184170722961,
-0.5547933578491211,
0.22651439905166626,
-0.32847532629966736,
-0.47564631700515747,
0.1548527181148529,
0.06476271897554398,
-0.6171311140060425,
1.0135574340820312,
-0.03946761041879654,
-0.6851396560668945,
0.46653133630752563,
-0.8419151306152344,
-0.5649895071983337,
-0.08399954438209534,
0.04466531425714493,
-0.6464853882789612,
0.14952857792377472,
0.2636409401893616,
0.3588952422142029,
-0.3526695966720581,
0.5302516222000122,
-0.2807447612285614,
0.18949270248413086,
0.2816050946712494,
-0.22744213044643402,
0.5057371854782104,
0.41074296832084656,
-0.1554633229970932,
0.39053815603256226,
-0.8204877376556396,
-0.09365415573120117,
0.1340118944644928,
-0.3429243862628937,
-0.8365480303764343,
0.3386467695236206,
0.13497281074523926,
-0.06285054236650467,
0.16724836826324463,
-0.528494119644165,
0.1424705535173416,
-0.35681501030921936,
0.371517539024353,
1.006112813949585,
-0.013022959232330322,
0.6358231902122498,
-0.24558261036872864,
0.16027674078941345,
-0.24245527386665344,
-0.08265798538923264,
0.0897315964102745,
-0.2269645631313324,
-0.5929953455924988,
0.06557343900203705,
0.02052806131541729,
0.13218820095062256,
-0.7126703262329102,
0.5994569659233093,
-0.5172142386436462,
-0.24881164729595184,
-0.4219307005405426,
0.32617729902267456,
0.4042695164680481,
0.6865776777267456,
0.550452470779419,
-0.09239258617162704,
-0.6194804906845093,
-0.8914908766746521,
-0.47430214285850525,
-0.5447222590446472,
-0.17755959928035736,
0.4907435178756714,
0.3915938138961792,
-0.07881812006235123,
1.2567700147628784,
-0.9899366497993469,
-0.27782660722732544,
-0.1699269860982895,
0.5611245632171631,
-0.2154189497232437,
0.5119649171829224,
0.47998693585395813,
-0.8794077038764954,
-0.6494542956352234,
-0.1061127632856369,
-0.4743538796901703,
-0.2223697155714035,
-0.01305335108190775,
-0.4111361503601074,
0.29747456312179565,
0.2815043032169342,
-0.2782049775123596,
-0.15055590867996216,
0.11794226616621017,
-0.11266811937093735,
0.6496715545654297,
-0.04047597199678421,
0.09655604511499405,
-1.1112923622131348,
0.35627302527427673,
0.24738439917564392,
-0.23899683356285095,
-0.29668447375297546,
-0.057241011410951614,
0.05016423016786575,
0.08205894380807877,
-0.2646317183971405,
0.6040172576904297,
-0.4068511724472046,
0.3973807692527771,
-0.3644428849220276,
-0.03871731832623482,
0.09409182518720627,
0.2613072097301483,
0.41465649008750916,
0.4911123514175415,
0.0917082205414772,
-0.4387299120426178,
0.29140862822532654,
0.3559354841709137,
-0.0357559435069561,
0.3116355836391449,
-0.6034327149391174,
0.35626497864723206,
-0.2070920765399933,
0.3952178955078125,
-0.9112840294837952,
-0.36448934674263,
0.015044182538986206,
-0.5829836130142212,
0.2591978907585144,
-0.24513399600982666,
-0.45706939697265625,
-0.15531092882156372,
-0.578654944896698,
0.43700939416885376,
0.16173577308654785,
-0.595797061920166,
0.40880870819091797,
0.32191815972328186,
-0.19985854625701904,
-0.42889097332954407,
-0.3485826253890991,
0.01816864125430584,
-0.2982868552207947,
-0.3756757974624634,
0.42084401845932007,
-0.025819828733801842,
-0.1917933225631714,
-0.09555467963218689,
0.02977362647652626,
0.010865696705877781,
-0.07999185472726822,
0.038024112582206726,
0.4329604506492615,
0.04497688636183739,
0.4106794595718384,
0.008663863874971867,
-0.19443534314632416,
0.11126483231782913,
-0.3897430896759033,
0.4989102780818939,
-0.11152350157499313,
-0.030636943876743317,
-0.13823731243610382,
0.5007942318916321,
0.3559848964214325,
-0.22952954471111298,
0.763687789440155,
0.41289228200912476,
-0.09267670661211014,
-0.17067170143127441,
-0.49613189697265625,
-0.2940938472747803,
-0.4562070667743683,
0.2163763791322708,
-0.2331235408782959,
-0.5604211688041687,
0.13938412070274353,
0.20561857521533966,
0.23495551943778992,
0.5528513193130493,
0.5457185506820679,
0.05005182698369026,
0.7739151120185852,
0.33469122648239136,
-0.27063557505607605,
0.5524935722351074,
-0.0368712842464447,
0.12225239723920822,
-0.564181923866272,
-0.014670982025563717,
-0.7411236763000488,
0.01538584940135479,
-0.4810011386871338,
-0.2289104163646698,
0.38058552145957947,
-0.22147685289382935,
-0.19438959658145905,
0.330600380897522,
-0.5641865730285645,
0.41292572021484375,
0.6910678148269653,
0.20016832649707794,
0.590110182762146,
0.21714136004447937,
0.24375148117542267,
-0.11856944859027863,
-0.4809934198856354,
-0.8195356726646423,
1.5758763551712036,
0.13293640315532684,
0.7116010785102844,
-0.004975715186446905,
0.8194295763969421,
0.41561633348464966,
0.616232693195343,
-0.8306583166122437,
0.34509512782096863,
-0.26910144090652466,
-0.5208398103713989,
-0.3780321478843689,
-0.49142175912857056,
-0.7457249164581299,
-0.0031990159768611193,
-0.30184146761894226,
-0.4545046091079712,
0.19190433621406555,
0.5777305960655212,
-0.2608594000339508,
0.02464774064719677,
-0.7554812431335449,
0.6131015419960022,
0.16116823256015778,
-0.7067100405693054,
-0.07410874217748642,
-0.6840798854827881,
0.19707636535167694,
-0.11498098075389862,
0.1342153400182724,
0.2083289474248886,
0.13294072449207306,
0.8758490681648254,
-0.14673134684562683,
0.410672128200531,
0.0017755668377503753,
-0.23174704611301422,
0.36012527346611023,
-0.16482387483119965,
0.8707271814346313,
0.2172335982322693,
-0.505990743637085,
-0.41919925808906555,
-0.38784709572792053,
-0.2489655464887619,
-0.33369091153144836,
0.8242211937904358,
-0.7586954832077026,
-0.24374604225158691,
-0.38989055156707764,
-0.5232427716255188,
-0.42636632919311523,
0.0021365538705140352,
0.6280385255813599,
0.4104693531990051,
-0.14344482123851776,
0.31678879261016846,
0.7142071723937988,
0.005243111401796341,
0.4560777246952057,
0.26534244418144226,
0.21116308867931366,
-0.5087580680847168,
1.187159776687622,
-0.1387365311384201,
0.32904818654060364,
0.3844127655029297,
0.34632012248039246,
-0.45524540543556213,
-0.6198219656944275,
-0.41797253489494324,
0.36283639073371887,
-0.5721009373664856,
-0.35860762000083923,
-0.7797219157218933,
0.038084566593170166,
-0.6381357908248901,
-0.31311288475990295,
-0.5158348083496094,
-0.273220956325531,
-0.632841169834137,
-0.058190952986478806,
0.27960529923439026,
0.2623445987701416,
0.12224290519952774,
0.20396418869495392,
-0.6140742301940918,
0.21821315586566925,
0.35964351892471313,
0.12349104136228561,
0.2810443639755249,
-0.46893972158432007,
-0.32431691884994507,
0.0016996751073747873,
-0.6505069732666016,
-0.6421517133712769,
0.45347490906715393,
0.4043944478034973,
0.28488609194755554,
0.44881269335746765,
0.470368355512619,
0.5773075222969055,
-0.6914357542991638,
0.6529994606971741,
0.22012688219547272,
-0.8946085572242737,
0.8485832214355469,
-0.41913163661956787,
-0.06967411935329437,
0.9220361709594727,
0.6853926181793213,
-0.12601850926876068,
-0.31790781021118164,
-0.7312356233596802,
-1.167597770690918,
0.6883034706115723,
0.32849055528640747,
0.09712550044059753,
-0.19699975848197937,
0.42508041858673096,
0.3846627175807953,
0.20925408601760864,
-1.0941355228424072,
-0.20608526468276978,
-0.22649401426315308,
-0.4038875102996826,
-0.2671525180339813,
-0.2522692084312439,
-0.14973925054073334,
-0.22857442498207092,
1.0927791595458984,
-0.41806158423423767,
-0.00035252643283456564,
0.24862515926361084,
-0.34945380687713623,
-0.3197057545185089,
0.3222900331020355,
0.47749218344688416,
0.618130624294281,
-0.39017024636268616,
0.14071445167064667,
-0.35483068227767944,
-0.49326643347740173,
0.12405014038085938,
0.07184620201587677,
-0.37652719020843506,
0.19917136430740356,
0.2505877614021301,
0.7056927680969238,
-0.20867857336997986,
-0.4925535321235657,
0.4533688724040985,
0.3657419979572296,
-0.18523091077804565,
-0.23231381177902222,
-0.025320107117295265,
-0.15783411264419556,
-0.28685441613197327,
0.8328199982643127,
0.014451895840466022,
0.3839893639087677,
-0.6012002825737,
0.20782281458377838,
0.46380457282066345,
-0.2773049771785736,
-0.2721231281757355,
0.5194240212440491,
0.3842860460281372,
0.0042092581279575825,
0.33131247758865356,
-0.11678466945886612,
-0.3967372179031372,
0.07424835115671158,
0.5008189082145691,
0.9725125432014465,
-0.07824365794658661,
0.41962558031082153,
0.5284289717674255,
0.017292222008109093,
-0.1860332041978836,
-0.37599533796310425,
-0.19245873391628265,
-0.761258602142334,
-0.34451061487197876,
-0.8872693777084351,
-0.39750880002975464,
0.15213727951049805,
-0.7551072239875793,
0.21843302249908447,
-0.07184173166751862,
-0.17977911233901978,
0.12362765520811081,
0.08177264779806137,
-0.10687220841646194,
0.17319022119045258,
-0.027024852111935616,
0.4885513186454773,
-1.0915277004241943,
0.850009560585022,
0.8234042525291443,
-0.3648052215576172,
-0.4763997793197632,
0.2365027368068695,
-0.18516317009925842,
-0.5352815389633179,
0.6871604919433594,
-0.034474462270736694,
-0.1920485645532608,
0.29038113355636597,
-0.707301914691925,
-0.7483929991722107,
0.693439781665802,
0.5238224267959595,
-0.16698236763477325,
-0.2190283089876175,
-0.14752893149852753,
0.31240400671958923,
-0.6037460565567017,
0.1570945531129837,
0.4397367238998413,
0.46125754714012146,
0.26653414964675903,
-0.700717031955719,
0.10815133899450302,
-0.16780951619148254,
0.038747627288103104,
0.13915807008743286,
-0.43226495385169983,
0.5744879245758057,
-0.1586945652961731,
0.12568317353725433,
-0.026590591296553612,
0.796107828617096,
0.4026663899421692,
0.15177473425865173,
0.6334866881370544,
0.2995311915874481,
0.6475396752357483,
0.05153355374932289,
0.8252431154251099,
0.16945359110832214,
0.34872305393218994,
1.408166527748108,
-0.17538221180438995,
0.8733985424041748,
0.8384896516799927,
-0.11212486028671265,
0.6677087545394897,
0.581778883934021,
0.054988257586956024,
0.7393204569816589,
0.1010340079665184,
-0.25096574425697327,
-0.4213462173938751,
-0.3745909333229065,
-0.22464923560619354,
0.1983628273010254,
-0.02987140230834484,
-0.9232658743858337,
-0.11847212165594101,
0.06893538683652878,
0.10251092910766602,
0.40464478731155396,
-0.22981946170330048,
0.9392498731613159,
-0.16517025232315063,
-0.9565073847770691,
0.5558974146842957,
-0.10020825266838074,
0.6499358415603638,
-0.6213747262954712,
0.2060556411743164,
-0.07205044478178024,
0.17792218923568726,
-0.3185841739177704,
-0.5970851182937622,
0.32301926612854004,
0.2206723988056183,
-0.6505774855613708,
-0.5644146800041199,
0.5869149565696716,
-0.43905383348464966,
-0.4570959806442261,
-0.12214776873588562,
0.016815979033708572,
0.05199477821588516,
-0.24122914671897888,
-0.25965574383735657,
-0.10399797558784485,
0.14648613333702087,
-0.5194206237792969,
0.3641278147697449,
0.2478470504283905,
-0.08436936140060425,
0.5459513664245605,
0.8152915239334106,
0.14631766080856323,
-0.20725038647651672,
-0.00761802215129137,
0.8806986808776855,
-0.27976757287979126,
-0.4287470579147339,
-1.0208611488342285,
0.3783809244632721,
-0.44103655219078064,
-0.3402622640132904,
0.7395458817481995,
0.7684675455093384,
0.5962997078895569,
-0.1975967288017273,
0.9267870783805847,
-0.012597572058439255,
0.5572073459625244,
-0.4003472626209259,
0.672269344329834,
-0.632780909538269,
0.10909780859947205,
-0.6700314283370972,
-1.0343551635742188,
-0.2824971675872803,
0.7343103289604187,
-0.5105088949203491,
-0.2535688877105713,
0.6161426305770874,
0.5054478049278259,
-0.051204096525907516,
-0.0313275046646595,
-0.26184138655662537,
-0.04951492324471474,
0.4306647479534149,
0.5622813701629639,
0.3725566267967224,
-0.43116530776023865,
0.695658266544342,
0.0012490550288930535,
-0.3582233488559723,
-0.34694525599479675,
-1.1926531791687012,
-0.6342678666114807,
-0.7765053510665894,
-0.39828911423683167,
-0.3971722424030304,
0.03896046429872513,
1.2262839078903198,
0.6339371204376221,
-0.8946343064308167,
-0.14809682965278625,
-0.33043694496154785,
0.027121685445308685,
0.17196044325828552,
-0.2628939151763916,
0.5607398152351379,
-0.598763644695282,
-0.8337650299072266,
0.008954107761383057,
-0.02501216158270836,
-0.043702322989702225,
-0.012581400573253632,
-0.12430410832166672,
-0.37015601992607117,
-0.0019997667986899614,
0.773204505443573,
0.1334684193134308,
-0.5408465266227722,
-0.39349398016929626,
-0.025275010615587234,
-0.08633366972208023,
0.14813750982284546,
0.9710625410079956,
-0.6030409932136536,
0.3174436092376709,
0.42136093974113464,
0.5074187517166138,
0.4226533770561218,
0.30683788657188416,
0.8682699799537659,
-0.6513619422912598,
-0.2035345882177353,
0.4349966049194336,
-0.013845264911651611,
0.5451789498329163,
-0.4488462805747986,
0.3511328399181366,
0.2797490358352661,
-0.6480336785316467,
-0.9262229204177856,
0.10976941883563995,
-0.8795914053916931,
-0.28504955768585205,
1.3510513305664062,
-0.20655275881290436,
-0.023318622261285782,
-0.08860313892364502,
-0.20945900678634644,
0.22415123879909515,
-0.7979377508163452,
0.9816094040870667,
0.8954730033874512,
-0.1579645425081253,
0.20627780258655548,
-0.035858772695064545,
0.8711272478103638,
0.5042481422424316,
-0.7432311177253723,
0.45090413093566895,
0.7458134889602661,
0.12906356155872345,
0.34289923310279846,
0.3806867301464081,
-0.03129526600241661,
0.07040394842624664,
-0.43995219469070435,
-0.02179982326924801,
-0.08261223882436752,
-0.34145674109458923,
0.13060273230075836,
0.39310455322265625,
0.2186514288187027,
0.004733551759272814
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18365v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18365v1
|
BLADE: Enhancing Black-box Large Language Models with Small Domain-Specific Models
| 2024-03-27T08:57:21 | 2024-03-27T08:57:21 |
Haitao Li, Qingyao Ai, Jia Chen, Qian Dong, Zhijing Wu, Yiqun Liu, Chong Chen, Qi Tian
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) like ChatGPT and GPT-4 are versatile and capable
of addressing a diverse range of tasks. However, general LLMs, which are
developed on open-domain data, may lack the domain-specific knowledge essential
for tasks in vertical domains, such as legal, medical, etc. To address this
issue, previous approaches either conduct continuous pre-training with
domain-specific data or employ retrieval augmentation to support general LLMs.
Unfortunately, these strategies are either cost-intensive or unreliable in
practical applications. To this end, we present a novel framework named BLADE,
which enhances Black-box LArge language models with small Domain-spEcific
models. BLADE consists of a black-box LLM and a small domain-specific LM. The
small LM preserves domain-specific knowledge and offers specialized insights,
while the general LLM contributes robust language comprehension and reasoning
capabilities. Specifically, our method involves three steps: 1) pre-training
the small LM with domain-specific data, 2) fine-tuning this model using
knowledge instruction data, and 3) joint Bayesian optimization of the general
LLM and the small LM. Extensive experiments conducted on public legal and
medical benchmarks reveal that BLADE significantly outperforms existing
approaches. This shows the potential of BLADE as an effective and
cost-efficient solution in adapting general LLMs for vertical domains.
|
[
-0.15793825685977936,
-0.9392407536506653,
0.6738986968994141,
-0.0734352394938469,
-0.22698257863521576,
0.34869226813316345,
-0.1744655817747116,
-0.386924684047699,
0.13524805009365082,
0.8576880097389221,
-0.48412761092185974,
-0.7021816968917847,
-0.43405258655548096,
-0.37093743681907654,
-0.11055778712034225,
1.010352373123169,
-0.08346234261989594,
0.18814490735530853,
-0.025211934000253677,
-0.15920725464820862,
-0.7712003588676453,
-0.6694403886795044,
-0.7790517210960388,
-0.4449111521244049,
0.32610371708869934,
0.39410629868507385,
0.7508289813995361,
0.6365387439727783,
0.48670610785484314,
0.20155398547649384,
0.189349964261055,
0.30951201915740967,
-0.6570122241973877,
-0.10418407618999481,
-0.5029570460319519,
-0.3585846722126007,
-0.6795563101768494,
-0.43380799889564514,
0.657647967338562,
1.0207141637802124,
-0.1386672705411911,
-0.04464655742049217,
0.06665101647377014,
0.5494718551635742,
-0.5502635836601257,
0.3006483018398285,
-0.9287868738174438,
-0.1874643862247467,
-0.3725135326385498,
-0.0026503605768084526,
-0.25112372636795044,
-0.12755553424358368,
0.23813308775424957,
-0.6512699723243713,
0.300498366355896,
0.11630994081497192,
0.8152312636375427,
0.01922573335468769,
-0.2640545666217804,
0.09125804901123047,
-0.8586770296096802,
0.6901941895484924,
-0.6169499754905701,
0.5191473364830017,
0.3250414729118347,
0.5132076144218445,
-0.13430413603782654,
-0.7830374836921692,
-0.47027844190597534,
0.04350358620285988,
0.11814099550247192,
-0.0445244126021862,
-0.40356236696243286,
0.3246256411075592,
0.048165176063776016,
0.15133506059646606,
-0.5877070426940918,
0.26467350125312805,
-0.3016318082809448,
-0.10036979615688324,
0.48450833559036255,
0.30778735876083374,
0.3683367967605591,
0.21148696541786194,
-0.22418996691703796,
-0.06276096403598785,
-0.9934177398681641,
0.022484619170427322,
0.1105547547340393,
0.3968590497970581,
-0.17791859805583954,
0.5325784683227539,
-0.0772719606757164,
0.812554121017456,
-0.03147547319531441,
-0.2653162479400635,
0.14271073043346405,
-0.2919621765613556,
-0.3241857588291168,
-0.19829757511615753,
0.49527937173843384,
0.30368348956108093,
0.2709939479827881,
-0.11427106708288193,
-0.28439652919769287,
0.010492012836039066,
0.3732720911502838,
-0.8496490716934204,
-0.20839208364486694,
0.05247119814157486,
-0.15701892971992493,
-0.17746877670288086,
-0.4009784758090973,
-0.697420060634613,
-0.2908385694026947,
-0.25170400738716125,
0.7139026522636414,
-0.41093507409095764,
-0.10091221332550049,
0.6283839344978333,
-0.008038999512791634,
0.2255934625864029,
0.5202274918556213,
-0.8431609272956848,
0.4558688998222351,
0.8393456339836121,
0.7005826234817505,
-0.27836063504219055,
-0.11634102463722229,
-0.7512137293815613,
0.4360421299934387,
-0.6131137013435364,
0.6337448358535767,
-0.8259636163711548,
-0.3561266362667084,
0.20428822934627533,
-0.10337086021900177,
-0.054858751595020294,
-0.549437403678894,
0.4563528299331665,
-0.6579927206039429,
-0.08409370481967926,
-0.02204759232699871,
-0.24985237419605255,
-0.24149875342845917,
0.21778792142868042,
-0.49046242237091064,
0.7018630504608154,
0.2630905508995056,
-0.6753966212272644,
0.18541879951953888,
-0.5912835001945496,
-0.634604275226593,
0.356008380651474,
-0.5856103897094727,
-0.4531099498271942,
0.010637590661644936,
0.3804469704627991,
0.5627545118331909,
-0.7948499917984009,
0.39988863468170166,
-0.558774471282959,
-0.26802048087120056,
-0.06698991358280182,
-0.21629954874515533,
0.6005194783210754,
-0.026976794004440308,
-0.07539752870798111,
0.05448130890727043,
-0.5209528803825378,
-0.0839848741889,
0.2182254195213318,
0.0371515154838562,
-0.5084293484687805,
0.013329478912055492,
-0.30664345622062683,
-0.004468715749680996,
0.10939270257949829,
-0.45900148153305054,
0.20862248539924622,
-0.6969446539878845,
0.3696226179599762,
0.6635869145393372,
0.29671695828437805,
0.40104296803474426,
-0.47906294465065,
0.751753568649292,
0.1074458435177803,
0.09596721827983856,
0.024070730432868004,
-0.5409055948257446,
-0.7447654604911804,
-0.4635534882545471,
0.4302198886871338,
0.6031899452209473,
-1.0621485710144043,
0.17795230448246002,
-0.5757927298545837,
-0.3757656514644623,
-0.7586960792541504,
0.1844610571861267,
0.3673282563686371,
0.43388885259628296,
0.39466848969459534,
-0.489254891872406,
-0.35982632637023926,
-1.0798181295394897,
-0.16178666055202484,
-0.05324200913310051,
-0.0686899796128273,
0.4202510416507721,
0.4718013405799866,
-0.5342252254486084,
0.9956719279289246,
-0.8428599834442139,
-0.4815254509449005,
-0.3775683343410492,
-0.03088141605257988,
0.3176330327987671,
0.29993000626564026,
0.5270738005638123,
-0.7573224902153015,
-0.6195253133773804,
0.4113074541091919,
-0.39588531851768494,
0.005252157337963581,
0.06780852377414703,
-0.15580259263515472,
-0.14321736991405487,
0.11398477107286453,
-0.6560722589492798,
0.3850620985031128,
0.40326833724975586,
-0.08191856741905212,
0.6373623013496399,
-0.33397385478019714,
-0.03889796882867813,
-0.943993330001831,
-0.025774352252483368,
0.09163344651460648,
-0.2765207886695862,
-0.901373565196991,
0.011318251490592957,
0.07558976113796234,
-0.3328765034675598,
-0.4278605878353119,
0.8827706575393677,
-0.3031802177429199,
-0.09952192008495331,
-0.3255356252193451,
0.09639186412096024,
0.1785389930009842,
0.6475098729133606,
0.1682763546705246,
0.8823089003562927,
0.6047905683517456,
-0.48052310943603516,
0.0516943484544754,
0.16225896775722504,
-0.3422020673751831,
0.6051610708236694,
-0.71613609790802,
0.14128951728343964,
-0.13133373856544495,
-0.04695065692067146,
-0.5869802236557007,
-0.26519736647605896,
0.2330992966890335,
-0.21990782022476196,
0.2811463177204132,
-0.4693355858325958,
-0.3929354250431061,
-0.18231353163719177,
-0.28007879853248596,
0.27283450961112976,
0.6941365003585815,
-0.4661220908164978,
0.6765371561050415,
0.8167628049850464,
-0.44677338004112244,
-0.5737342238426208,
-0.45946428179740906,
-0.09947575628757477,
-0.048506855964660645,
-0.640535295009613,
0.5040231347084045,
-0.20699231326580048,
-0.2583594024181366,
-0.05530083179473877,
-0.2521132230758667,
-0.4045988917350769,
-0.02403760328888893,
0.09971580654382706,
0.2857655882835388,
-0.4027746021747589,
0.012484587728977203,
0.4678977131843567,
0.0932319238781929,
-0.02583053894340992,
-0.6130736470222473,
0.4570152759552002,
0.04784339293837547,
-0.40250644087791443,
0.06376226991415024,
0.38754960894584656,
0.21202482283115387,
-0.5047293901443481,
0.4799995720386505,
0.2756761610507965,
-0.6140779852867126,
-0.8136098384857178,
-0.47833123803138733,
-0.08305441588163376,
-0.5334717035293579,
0.4874918460845947,
-0.645856499671936,
-1.2175288200378418,
0.24565330147743225,
-0.13420414924621582,
0.04407649114727974,
0.31281787157058716,
0.5072472095489502,
0.13491804897785187,
1.0158779621124268,
0.734066903591156,
-0.2998524010181427,
0.1422872692346573,
-0.17483077943325043,
0.16857030987739563,
-0.6424311995506287,
0.11534272879362106,
-0.5658285021781921,
0.18658478558063507,
-0.22694358229637146,
-0.8023616075515747,
0.3859142065048218,
0.11387520283460617,
-0.24404148757457733,
0.2060638815164566,
-0.27791959047317505,
0.506398618221283,
0.14287598431110382,
0.01530920248478651,
0.25498995184898376,
0.2317754030227661,
-0.38855546712875366,
-0.007751984987407923,
-0.8872632384300232,
-0.3873574733734131,
1.1362601518630981,
0.5639786720275879,
0.8702723383903503,
0.03853869065642357,
0.5305517911911011,
0.38226598501205444,
0.1966768205165863,
-0.6675199270248413,
0.5347848534584045,
-0.4728277325630188,
-0.5012692809104919,
-0.29561081528663635,
-0.448359876871109,
-1.0291523933410645,
0.3922634422779083,
-0.08374146372079849,
-0.7165265679359436,
0.16657356917858124,
0.17481626570224762,
-0.37893152236938477,
0.24223795533180237,
-0.6025717854499817,
0.9518746137619019,
-0.3401222825050354,
-0.4315812289714813,
-0.2283516526222229,
-0.3219447731971741,
0.2829618752002716,
-0.6398663520812988,
0.4575445055961609,
-0.07652931660413742,
-0.0784352496266365,
0.6899547576904297,
-0.3006558418273926,
1.0345261096954346,
-0.25153636932373047,
-0.16364896297454834,
0.09681779891252518,
0.09318430721759796,
0.667263925075531,
0.10267249494791031,
0.08350292593240738,
0.1924431174993515,
-0.08140161633491516,
-0.24163126945495605,
-0.7577399611473083,
0.6639824509620667,
-0.7245224714279175,
-0.8736514449119568,
-0.25469762086868286,
-0.46520259976387024,
-0.678529679775238,
0.4681698977947235,
-0.305420845746994,
0.41946595907211304,
-0.21893785893917084,
0.23160691559314728,
0.7760578989982605,
-0.21720179915428162,
-0.2169867902994156,
0.8784064650535583,
-0.368089497089386,
-0.4973364472389221,
0.983273983001709,
0.14900150895118713,
0.26746827363967896,
0.6284989714622498,
0.13065648078918457,
-0.13536015152931213,
-1.0441175699234009,
-0.45178231596946716,
0.4425332844257355,
-0.6094134449958801,
-0.3970644772052765,
-0.6501925587654114,
-0.39147090911865234,
-0.2989468574523926,
-0.15758918225765228,
-0.24080239236354828,
-0.21460244059562683,
-0.1072758361697197,
-0.0293109230697155,
0.3409811854362488,
0.5637354254722595,
0.2709890604019165,
0.5913220643997192,
-0.7051152586936951,
0.5804123282432556,
0.33129405975341797,
0.5706536769866943,
-0.13845539093017578,
-0.5989935994148254,
-0.42952245473861694,
0.29953011870384216,
-0.17958597838878632,
-0.596561849117279,
0.4793405830860138,
0.2669254243373871,
0.6038833856582642,
0.27637195587158203,
0.012429430149495602,
0.8429407477378845,
-0.9138152003288269,
0.5626054406166077,
0.20319297909736633,
-0.8044015169143677,
0.39743658900260925,
-0.49999070167541504,
0.1879325956106186,
0.39874958992004395,
0.5086690783500671,
-0.29120931029319763,
-0.35089632868766785,
-0.4162752330303192,
-0.6009804606437683,
0.7207640409469604,
0.014087253250181675,
0.15732745826244354,
0.3100720942020416,
0.4058206081390381,
0.2579333484172821,
0.13518278300762177,
-0.48882266879081726,
0.006371825467795134,
0.09225834906101227,
-0.37703582644462585,
-0.2094995528459549,
-0.10544130951166153,
-0.24402377009391785,
-0.17869511246681213,
0.7380040287971497,
-0.3135516345500946,
0.19513195753097534,
-0.1893375813961029,
-0.17489488422870636,
-0.0643756240606308,
0.195985347032547,
0.2829793691635132,
0.7667966485023499,
-0.09474501013755798,
-0.0068129426799714565,
0.3970564603805542,
-0.5338820815086365,
0.12196145951747894,
0.24731417000293732,
-0.32109880447387695,
-0.023945212364196777,
0.27354148030281067,
0.9920814633369446,
0.42366838455200195,
-0.6851730942726135,
0.5653882026672363,
0.16724121570587158,
-0.3486192226409912,
-0.1519516557455063,
0.34313762187957764,
0.12155596911907196,
0.4193280339241028,
0.24234087765216827,
-0.1395500749349594,
0.061862725764513016,
-0.38451722264289856,
0.28708672523498535,
0.6097572445869446,
-0.34072253108024597,
-0.3185838758945465,
0.5893887281417847,
0.15457865595817566,
-0.3638326823711395,
0.0018021281575784087,
0.10923412442207336,
-0.3945885896682739,
0.12290254235267639,
0.6714829206466675,
0.7575501799583435,
-0.09651615470647812,
0.2386632263660431,
-0.08646532893180847,
0.3069742023944855,
-0.11763564497232437,
0.236854687333107,
0.12726238369941711,
-0.8328073620796204,
-0.5743713974952698,
-0.6716835498809814,
-0.5458815097808838,
0.4477353096008301,
-0.33652159571647644,
0.3558956980705261,
-0.5605893135070801,
-0.22920779883861542,
0.21574391424655914,
0.17420002818107605,
-0.8574485182762146,
0.28502607345581055,
-0.23033705353736877,
0.9204424023628235,
-0.5337406396865845,
1.4567246437072754,
0.5356495976448059,
-0.38495147228240967,
-0.7118404507637024,
-0.033384401351213455,
-0.18348172307014465,
-0.8730228543281555,
0.48042139410972595,
-0.14437814056873322,
-0.3738201856613159,
0.06530316174030304,
-0.30596452951431274,
-0.6420471668243408,
0.8876519799232483,
0.6198810338973999,
-0.7501354813575745,
-0.22850239276885986,
0.4671194553375244,
0.5853251814842224,
-0.5783858895301819,
-0.25059956312179565,
0.5859375596046448,
0.22738493978977203,
-0.064351387321949,
-0.8340441584587097,
-0.08554893732070923,
-0.0534895583987236,
0.2166190892457962,
0.28555867075920105,
-0.36103954911231995,
0.635377049446106,
0.0656130239367485,
-0.11131386458873749,
-0.24942730367183685,
0.5522841811180115,
0.33567577600479126,
0.19177348911762238,
0.36195749044418335,
0.31054696440696716,
0.6652193665504456,
0.13068996369838715,
0.9043773412704468,
-0.27324843406677246,
-0.05115896463394165,
1.1105067729949951,
-0.7337726950645447,
0.8928520679473877,
0.210172638297081,
-0.14850546419620514,
0.2539909780025482,
0.2833805978298187,
0.04750772565603256,
0.48818010091781616,
0.1163162961602211,
-0.28024178743362427,
-0.2610677182674408,
0.07444895803928375,
-0.2385292500257492,
0.2468751072883606,
0.5567670464515686,
-0.18405774235725403,
-0.1276824176311493,
0.13045762479305267,
0.17890340089797974,
0.048735279589891434,
-0.4734537601470947,
0.7915427684783936,
0.2970069944858551,
-0.566918134689331,
0.6780559420585632,
0.4557298421859741,
0.4187670946121216,
-1.052824854850769,
-0.12558066844940186,
-0.21041493117809296,
0.33611926436424255,
0.15932391583919525,
-0.7659876942634583,
0.15896567702293396,
0.1202683225274086,
-0.043580904603004456,
-0.18597741425037384,
1.1398415565490723,
-0.5222643613815308,
-0.44106993079185486,
0.5423920750617981,
0.5420944094657898,
-0.10196849703788757,
-0.021856725215911865,
-0.7120404243469238,
0.2333126962184906,
0.01971137896180153,
0.14602050185203552,
0.5766799449920654,
0.5267031192779541,
-0.24770453572273254,
0.655197262763977,
0.6502276659011841,
0.37561923265457153,
-0.20956610143184662,
0.0739089623093605,
1.0575013160705566,
-0.5683386921882629,
-0.4619389772415161,
-0.6744800806045532,
0.342153400182724,
-0.06315229833126068,
-0.010194585658609867,
0.683678150177002,
0.6176401376724243,
0.9194019436836243,
-0.17906184494495392,
1.0477708578109741,
0.4236113131046295,
0.7484305500984192,
-0.6333885192871094,
0.7895665168762207,
-0.5386964082717896,
0.34984174370765686,
-0.16875730454921722,
-0.7538314461708069,
-0.35342878103256226,
0.48407357931137085,
-0.6406081914901733,
-0.00959016103297472,
0.4316515028476715,
0.9334279894828796,
-0.3353491425514221,
-0.1405612677335739,
0.5570109486579895,
0.09753943234682083,
0.3117890954017639,
0.5616111755371094,
0.356643944978714,
-0.018087754026055336,
0.5495120286941528,
0.0032503597903996706,
-0.25292569398880005,
-0.21104197204113007,
-0.5904081463813782,
-1.0350422859191895,
-0.4918615221977234,
-0.25934144854545593,
-0.04555245116353035,
0.519655704498291,
0.7685628533363342,
0.8923108577728271,
-0.6798489093780518,
-0.5141209959983826,
0.2859020531177521,
0.10012491047382355,
-0.12583273649215698,
-0.12300984561443329,
0.3250042796134949,
-0.3390648663043976,
-0.3925654888153076,
0.6403427720069885,
0.3669063150882721,
-0.08010571449995041,
-0.19732053577899933,
-0.19854691624641418,
-0.045303039252758026,
0.44985032081604004,
0.8227137327194214,
0.23072296380996704,
-0.4892480969429016,
-0.4837176501750946,
-0.2099202275276184,
0.0028263647109270096,
0.21074920892715454,
0.8014358878135681,
-0.5878960490226746,
0.36597344279289246,
0.14726829528808594,
1.0649194717407227,
0.7781171202659607,
-0.12739062309265137,
0.8730297088623047,
-0.6962453722953796,
-0.010368135757744312,
0.31220319867134094,
0.3075658679008484,
0.19390396773815155,
-0.05309547483921051,
0.402805894613266,
0.14381082355976105,
-0.3281669616699219,
-0.884374737739563,
0.33386313915252686,
-0.86897212266922,
-0.3959285020828247,
1.042227864265442,
-0.09471481293439865,
-0.2599809467792511,
-0.27198269963264465,
-0.27136534452438354,
-0.0917198583483696,
-0.298258513212204,
0.29487672448158264,
0.43736204504966736,
0.20250017940998077,
-0.16257037222385406,
-0.8621550798416138,
0.5877382755279541,
0.14271686971187592,
-0.9641180038452148,
0.17715513706207275,
0.4802391529083252,
0.383065402507782,
-0.19800099730491638,
0.8405571579933167,
-0.10668860375881195,
0.19692067801952362,
-0.10850895941257477,
-0.09110089391469955,
-0.05795631557703018,
-0.5494284629821777,
-0.37833988666534424,
0.30921313166618347,
0.3703041970729828,
0.035818714648485184
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18350v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18350v2
|
Evaluation of Semantic Search and its Role in Retrieved-Augmented-Generation (RAG) for Arabic Language
| 2024-03-27T08:42:31 | 2024-05-30T12:16:39 |
Ali Mahboub, Muhy Eddin Za'ter, Bashar Al-Rfooh, Yazan Estaitia, Adnan Jaljuli, Asma Hakouz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The latest advancements in machine learning and deep learning have brought
forth the concept of semantic similarity, which has proven immensely beneficial
in multiple applications and has largely replaced keyword search. However,
evaluating semantic similarity and conducting searches for a specific query
across various documents continue to be a complicated task. This complexity is
due to the multifaceted nature of the task, the lack of standard benchmarks,
whereas these challenges are further amplified for Arabic language. This paper
endeavors to establish a straightforward yet potent benchmark for semantic
search in Arabic. Moreover, to precisely evaluate the effectiveness of these
metrics and the dataset, we conduct our assessment of semantic search within
the framework of retrieval augmented generation (RAG).
|
[
-0.6575933694839478,
-0.503876268863678,
0.30371806025505066,
-0.08083362132310867,
-0.35798710584640503,
0.3228051960468292,
-0.04997702315449715,
-0.42676374316215515,
0.09454423934221268,
0.37776675820350647,
-0.4682031571865082,
-0.6276565194129944,
-0.8344784379005432,
0.4467484951019287,
-0.5490410923957825,
0.8913220763206482,
-0.2279975861310959,
-0.11796493083238602,
-0.11034593731164932,
-0.5173832178115845,
-0.5363055467605591,
-0.10826129466295242,
-0.5275341272354126,
-0.12583306431770325,
0.431024968624115,
0.3124220073223114,
0.8247730731964111,
0.4971331059932709,
0.6057820320129395,
0.4280736744403839,
-0.067078597843647,
0.4550844132900238,
-0.385267049074173,
0.5315871238708496,
-0.39882978796958923,
0.0631725862622261,
-0.0087999626994133,
-0.05890163779258728,
0.84359210729599,
0.6662958264350891,
0.05716929957270622,
0.41756269335746765,
-0.16289298236370087,
1.0615956783294678,
-1.0063759088516235,
-0.09246132522821426,
-1.0107192993164062,
-0.06023533269762993,
-0.36270344257354736,
-0.2623012363910675,
0.050050996243953705,
-0.31261077523231506,
0.16418272256851196,
-0.4855644404888153,
0.4324488341808319,
0.13932503759860992,
0.9884799122810364,
0.16525624692440033,
-0.5915321707725525,
-0.7622228264808655,
-0.38883835077285767,
0.8172566890716553,
-0.31040412187576294,
0.5224772095680237,
0.5430107116699219,
0.5258430242538452,
-0.46194592118263245,
-0.8786659836769104,
-0.6395511627197266,
-0.5442496538162231,
0.04465804249048233,
0.1467595249414444,
0.048837754875421524,
-0.19015078246593475,
0.022324539721012115,
0.4155327379703522,
-0.38300156593322754,
-0.26011133193969727,
0.02861580066382885,
-0.13037018477916718,
0.4511914849281311,
0.10988480597734451,
0.585561215877533,
-0.19200561940670013,
-0.48463183641433716,
-0.2438029944896698,
-0.5808854699134827,
-0.13729999959468842,
0.46966904401779175,
0.2951236367225647,
0.22278907895088196,
0.6558707356452942,
-0.7214633226394653,
0.8452972173690796,
-0.34375977516174316,
-0.26822513341903687,
0.568683922290802,
-0.5742979049682617,
0.1776992380619049,
0.16322417557239532,
0.3428190350532532,
0.3091695308685303,
-0.04958508536219597,
-0.5164059400558472,
-0.37837082147598267,
0.09821398556232452,
0.6716489791870117,
-0.8242787718772888,
0.2878154218196869,
-0.06309118866920471,
-0.47950664162635803,
-0.050087738782167435,
0.2519034147262573,
-0.6112034320831299,
-0.14121833443641663,
-0.23063667118549347,
0.5710808634757996,
-0.41517373919487,
-0.13943608105182648,
-0.025416739284992218,
-0.28553688526153564,
0.5429080724716187,
0.13641808927059174,
-0.5389242172241211,
0.4868304431438446,
0.9992532730102539,
0.5927647948265076,
-0.36302319169044495,
-0.2066308557987213,
-0.5524434447288513,
0.09050246328115463,
-0.5253780484199524,
0.8564803004264832,
-0.6454241871833801,
-0.6048412322998047,
-0.0055019729770720005,
-0.40935856103897095,
-0.10976465791463852,
-0.7577975392341614,
1.1847141981124878,
-1.042684555053711,
-0.0746535137295723,
0.012992087751626968,
-0.633596658706665,
-0.5457999110221863,
0.45898494124412537,
-0.7117393612861633,
1.2824686765670776,
0.33864161372184753,
-0.8057114481925964,
0.6076127886772156,
-0.4915958046913147,
-0.3009180426597595,
0.3468528985977173,
-0.3624863624572754,
-0.6216075420379639,
0.12390860915184021,
0.1335589736700058,
0.07647831737995148,
-0.6017377376556396,
-0.10892723500728607,
-0.13406157493591309,
-0.48844611644744873,
0.26341068744659424,
-0.13322854042053223,
0.37243524193763733,
0.3925856053829193,
-0.5510197281837463,
-0.2948952317237854,
-0.9223594069480896,
0.4230634868144989,
-0.08723679184913635,
-0.25250154733657837,
-0.6862265467643738,
-0.06421142816543579,
0.06422918289899826,
0.184238463640213,
0.5303093791007996,
-0.8128520846366882,
0.04998728260397911,
-0.7792068719863892,
-0.4198035001754761,
0.2738073766231537,
0.10315535217523575,
0.15419234335422516,
-0.4424428939819336,
0.46681416034698486,
-0.14608553051948547,
-0.32367897033691406,
0.2576236426830292,
-0.24987342953681946,
-0.6332912445068359,
-0.2804093360900879,
0.6050220131874084,
0.3023354411125183,
-0.603842556476593,
0.24307066202163696,
-0.3984660804271698,
-0.7809451222419739,
-0.8328603506088257,
0.32349419593811035,
0.6268441081047058,
0.5481114387512207,
0.32937315106391907,
-0.343068391084671,
-0.5527461767196655,
-0.8663005828857422,
-0.6934400200843811,
0.18893863260746002,
0.09823018312454224,
0.710015058517456,
0.4199114441871643,
-0.7242256999015808,
0.8078647255897522,
-0.28285732865333557,
-0.4160871207714081,
-0.11428071558475494,
0.3928880989551544,
0.29561367630958557,
0.21038411557674408,
0.45934104919433594,
-1.338017463684082,
-0.737827479839325,
0.4104986786842346,
-0.439871221780777,
-0.32419881224632263,
0.5026799440383911,
-0.1645764410495758,
0.4116666316986084,
0.3853176236152649,
-0.5405706167221069,
0.8119261264801025,
0.302839070558548,
-0.527266263961792,
0.4524368941783905,
-0.17129449546337128,
0.5084752440452576,
-0.9984566569328308,
0.46083396673202515,
-0.6014206409454346,
-0.039930738508701324,
-0.34718355536460876,
0.5784482955932617,
-0.11589110642671585,
0.0788671001791954,
-0.26795315742492676,
0.8088694214820862,
-0.3428676724433899,
-0.26904696226119995,
-0.550248920917511,
0.3578220307826996,
-0.14042039215564728,
-0.03060310147702694,
-0.2729422450065613,
1.1263636350631714,
0.40162593126296997,
-0.7206763029098511,
0.31606799364089966,
0.25796201825141907,
-0.6105153560638428,
0.30196258425712585,
-0.6197373867034912,
0.2150498926639557,
-0.11305533349514008,
-0.022895466536283493,
-0.9208205342292786,
0.06318247318267822,
-0.14339397847652435,
-0.6443949341773987,
0.22018851339817047,
0.12631136178970337,
-0.6104190349578857,
0.004560980945825577,
-0.39726778864860535,
0.6570475697517395,
0.37435582280158997,
-0.42017847299575806,
0.8025863170623779,
0.2089352309703827,
-0.08000779151916504,
-0.8504042625427246,
0.10319320857524872,
0.0906977653503418,
-0.2321920394897461,
-0.45118391513824463,
0.6380231976509094,
0.29928410053253174,
-0.4481951892375946,
0.08045781403779984,
-0.29224494099617004,
0.18050837516784668,
0.24783927202224731,
0.27592626214027405,
0.08721248805522919,
-0.1264062225818634,
0.06045347452163696,
-0.10736365616321564,
-0.3531649708747864,
-0.23020416498184204,
-0.070832759141922,
0.6629279255867004,
-0.13311930000782013,
-0.38846173882484436,
0.17451049387454987,
0.41999682784080505,
0.2598055899143219,
-0.4893684983253479,
0.8397089838981628,
0.9641156196594238,
-0.15253055095672607,
0.06111961975693703,
-0.6562522053718567,
0.1172649934887886,
-0.44598543643951416,
0.4895629286766052,
-0.7353436350822449,
-0.6500710248947144,
0.43875306844711304,
-0.5837662816047668,
-0.3411846458911896,
0.8527945876121521,
0.7444544434547424,
0.09994927048683167,
1.1394282579421997,
0.4745098948478699,
0.17577619850635529,
-0.04003680497407913,
-0.15556320548057556,
0.08797543495893478,
-0.9869351387023926,
-0.33078283071517944,
-1.0760999917984009,
-0.08347921073436737,
-1.246138334274292,
-0.15368230640888214,
0.47682496905326843,
0.21166257560253143,
-0.3979780375957489,
0.2901208698749542,
-0.3802584409713745,
0.18653857707977295,
0.5284626483917236,
-0.16224244236946106,
0.2036561369895935,
0.11344838887453079,
-0.5015907883644104,
-0.17753387987613678,
-0.30411145091056824,
-0.4770274758338928,
0.9543749094009399,
-0.2499142289161682,
0.343860000371933,
0.49075496196746826,
1.0452088117599487,
0.5690070986747742,
0.043770045042037964,
-0.57040935754776,
0.48755741119384766,
-0.19865188002586365,
-0.5098361968994141,
-0.18547026813030243,
-0.4106678068637848,
-1.405804991722107,
0.3927357494831085,
-0.21734218299388885,
-0.6040748357772827,
-0.31977492570877075,
-0.467114120721817,
0.3128902316093445,
-0.15451794862747192,
-0.2386130541563034,
0.7623257040977478,
-0.06217353045940399,
-0.14056377112865448,
-0.5731512308120728,
-0.6279980540275574,
-0.16267617046833038,
-0.2378227710723877,
0.1263171285390854,
-0.4026295840740204,
-0.5469661951065063,
0.7616350650787354,
-0.5076070427894592,
-0.08191414177417755,
0.005518090445548296,
0.2664491534233093,
0.26912450790405273,
0.21239487826824188,
0.22242066264152527,
-0.11333311349153519,
-0.21624255180358887,
-0.05586099252104759,
0.06984960287809372,
-0.4776066839694977,
-0.7406647205352783,
0.9457563161849976,
-0.8289352059364319,
-0.4757767617702484,
-0.5624076128005981,
-0.47212451696395874,
-0.30628255009651184,
0.46081286668777466,
0.0025669801980257034,
0.4093775749206543,
-0.34569233655929565,
0.18510369956493378,
0.24951545894145966,
-0.23892176151275635,
0.25330850481987,
0.6442517638206482,
-0.4008997678756714,
-0.34690868854522705,
1.0618849992752075,
-0.19212326407432556,
-0.2021888792514801,
0.48662006855010986,
0.21694543957710266,
-0.5484806299209595,
-0.4111553728580475,
-0.5610948801040649,
0.0761784091591835,
-0.4668695628643036,
-0.4294804036617279,
-0.6222254037857056,
-0.3133271634578705,
-0.2429669052362442,
0.07954385876655579,
-0.22225052118301392,
-0.337552011013031,
0.11894848197698593,
0.2809228301048279,
0.5198046565055847,
0.6375892162322998,
0.2585716247558594,
-0.16599908471107483,
-0.8964495062828064,
0.6530483365058899,
0.2632916271686554,
0.4218698740005493,
0.07934177666902542,
-0.5200525522232056,
-0.2360702008008957,
-0.18425193428993225,
-0.3592647910118103,
-0.5626158714294434,
0.3738851249217987,
0.37281328439712524,
0.6859639883041382,
-0.04909257963299751,
0.13542847335338593,
0.5159368515014648,
-0.6876164078712463,
0.6030364632606506,
-0.25399544835090637,
-0.7668541669845581,
0.4729033410549164,
-0.04748913645744324,
0.41168880462646484,
1.0256822109222412,
0.50986248254776,
-0.2505658268928528,
-0.16465319693088531,
-0.6705154180526733,
-1.110137939453125,
0.2908886671066284,
0.619568407535553,
0.11040235310792923,
-0.14048488438129425,
0.11339309811592102,
0.23396308720111847,
0.30472949147224426,
0.13872630894184113,
-0.510668933391571,
0.051794737577438354,
-0.13517265021800995,
0.2076002061367035,
-0.34886014461517334,
0.21181592345237732,
-0.20384261012077332,
0.7769524455070496,
0.13810093700885773,
0.1393911987543106,
0.10603812336921692,
-0.11747384071350098,
0.27204880118370056,
0.4091639220714569,
0.40180110931396484,
0.5789666771888733,
-0.28480684757232666,
0.03513511270284653,
0.2722885012626648,
-0.8475108742713928,
0.16070672869682312,
0.46228379011154175,
-0.13143901526927948,
0.34729254245758057,
0.29898205399513245,
0.4061972498893738,
0.21302129328250885,
-1.0173780918121338,
0.410839706659317,
-0.0628221407532692,
0.09987059980630875,
-0.46608567237854004,
-0.0673162117600441,
-0.07273493707180023,
-0.11150023341178894,
0.6206622123718262,
-0.1311074197292328,
0.6790453791618347,
-0.3747119903564453,
0.43663981556892395,
0.6837102174758911,
-0.1898234486579895,
0.28114694356918335,
0.23187066614627838,
-0.07501882314682007,
-0.4110764265060425,
0.6134642362594604,
-0.255867063999176,
-0.8089656233787537,
0.4675391912460327,
0.4760877788066864,
0.8178398013114929,
-0.03843913972377777,
-0.06943043321371078,
0.3009587526321411,
-0.1509825736284256,
0.4293323755264282,
0.41839599609375,
-0.45981138944625854,
-0.7564148306846619,
-0.28921225666999817,
-1.0507146120071411,
-0.2693920135498047,
-0.33122166991233826,
-0.7244600653648376,
0.18053852021694183,
-0.06896595656871796,
-0.19448219239711761,
0.01880984753370285,
0.6760176420211792,
-0.8270918726921082,
0.4738354980945587,
-0.12431650608778,
0.9110572934150696,
-0.03798479959368706,
0.5990747213363647,
0.8785355091094971,
-0.36109867691993713,
-0.7096983790397644,
-0.19786874949932098,
-0.19616930186748505,
-0.9283183813095093,
1.0926053524017334,
0.31181904673576355,
-0.7073155045509338,
-0.18958450853824615,
-0.08107012510299683,
-0.9255645871162415,
0.9144212007522583,
-0.053359340876340866,
-0.07718934118747711,
0.3606318533420563,
0.20025433599948883,
0.620356023311615,
-0.374591588973999,
0.3260601758956909,
0.6563141345977783,
0.422375351190567,
0.2125631719827652,
-0.9170344471931458,
-0.15839523077011108,
-0.4239502549171448,
0.4110584259033203,
0.4712904393672943,
-0.2088039219379425,
0.6428371667861938,
0.20062340795993805,
-0.27498409152030945,
0.5292107462882996,
0.7379191517829895,
0.2630060315132141,
0.5535430908203125,
0.3163119852542877,
0.9454376101493835,
0.26802346110343933,
0.12404504418373108,
1.1572469472885132,
-0.4901711940765381,
0.318819135427475,
0.9862408638000488,
-0.3876689672470093,
1.0220260620117188,
0.3361263573169708,
-0.24613435566425323,
0.5368151664733887,
0.17424100637435913,
0.29068881273269653,
0.6402561068534851,
0.27024245262145996,
-0.6055874228477478,
-0.0035897023044526577,
-0.5300462245941162,
-0.49549663066864014,
0.9351986050605774,
0.42689311504364014,
-0.38275638222694397,
-0.612038791179657,
-0.2790425717830658,
-0.10445349663496017,
0.6796969175338745,
-0.337512731552124,
1.2064810991287231,
-0.07261543720960617,
-0.6123235821723938,
0.601705014705658,
0.24976971745491028,
0.3058067560195923,
-0.5451643466949463,
-0.42135724425315857,
-0.006060098297894001,
0.12955619394779205,
-0.04473533108830452,
-0.5437310934066772,
0.4385576546192169,
-0.07428023219108582,
-0.20997795462608337,
0.17333446443080902,
0.9242085814476013,
-0.15345333516597748,
-0.5037917494773865,
0.45865046977996826,
0.5321129560470581,
0.26511821150779724,
0.018491756170988083,
-0.7826536297798157,
0.19551800191402435,
-0.20714114606380463,
0.028505908325314522,
0.39294177293777466,
0.4713442325592041,
0.00704770116135478,
0.49096062779426575,
0.5213951468467712,
0.1616969108581543,
0.019743051379919052,
0.08364971727132797,
0.6919698715209961,
-0.7755476832389832,
-0.1432487666606903,
-0.6332509517669678,
-0.05103785917162895,
-0.19441841542720795,
-0.3380447030067444,
1.013935923576355,
0.6723141670227051,
1.041650652885437,
0.08256591111421585,
0.4792490303516388,
-0.1776411235332489,
1.151752233505249,
-0.3941071331501007,
0.8881109952926636,
-0.6236827373504639,
-0.030977429822087288,
-0.4128419756889343,
-1.2687348127365112,
-0.025649406015872955,
0.5909132957458496,
-0.07453575730323792,
0.31738895177841187,
0.40750083327293396,
0.8989672660827637,
-0.012349141761660576,
-0.16419953107833862,
0.3093857169151306,
-0.07835114747285843,
-0.17937029898166656,
0.06915838271379471,
0.7778589725494385,
-0.656097948551178,
0.2691836953163147,
-0.04932596534490585,
-0.03508710488677025,
-0.16899274289608002,
-0.7505723237991333,
-0.5942199230194092,
-0.8708553910255432,
-0.002826384734362364,
-0.42014047503471375,
0.11564204096794128,
1.0341287851333618,
0.0819036066532135,
-0.713405191898346,
-0.1513085514307022,
0.01860615611076355,
0.1544523686170578,
-0.18692579865455627,
-0.13236351311206818,
0.7466554641723633,
-0.5005561113357544,
-0.6024910807609558,
0.13429388403892517,
0.1817535161972046,
-0.25928908586502075,
-0.040431730449199677,
-0.07081560790538788,
-0.5934538841247559,
-0.07626395672559738,
0.6504862308502197,
0.263935387134552,
-0.793506383895874,
-0.11381121724843979,
-0.19975581765174866,
-0.4304420053958893,
-0.2866568863391876,
0.6069467663764954,
-1.2686450481414795,
0.6263077855110168,
0.3791930377483368,
1.1927049160003662,
0.5451174378395081,
0.1688462495803833,
0.31933653354644775,
-0.46501249074935913,
0.13609091937541962,
0.299584299325943,
0.05976060405373573,
0.4912647306919098,
0.01457808818668127,
0.766708493232727,
-0.08557251840829849,
-0.5668760538101196,
-0.5501123666763306,
0.3023087978363037,
-0.8769712448120117,
0.028270389884710312,
0.9958545565605164,
-0.005070126615464687,
-0.14885520935058594,
-0.28458598256111145,
-0.44016504287719727,
0.31167224049568176,
-0.10669423639774323,
0.962917149066925,
0.42106473445892334,
0.010858922265470028,
0.2885092496871948,
-0.4239528477191925,
0.60825514793396,
0.6430394649505615,
-0.2678302526473999,
-0.6240866184234619,
0.1970931738615036,
-0.02623845636844635,
0.19767142832279205,
0.15286141633987427,
-0.26724138855934143,
0.5221502780914307,
0.14293956756591797,
-0.2898915410041809,
0.1791142076253891,
-0.05504629388451576,
0.03298715502023697,
0.10718895494937897,
0.32740285992622375,
-0.28142496943473816
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18349v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18349v2
|
Rejection Improves Reliability: Training LLMs to Refuse Unknown Questions Using RL from Knowledge Feedback
| 2024-03-27T08:39:56 | 2024-04-07T07:41:28 |
Hongshen Xu, Zichen Zhu, Situo Zhang, Da Ma, Shuai Fan, Lu Chen, Kai Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) often generate erroneous outputs, known as
hallucinations, due to their limitations in discerning questions beyond their
knowledge scope. While addressing hallucination has been a focal point in
research, previous efforts primarily concentrate on enhancing correctness
without giving due consideration to the significance of rejection mechanisms.
In this paper, we conduct a comprehensive examination of the role of rejection,
introducing the notion of model reliability along with corresponding metrics.
These metrics measure the model's ability to provide accurate responses while
adeptly rejecting questions exceeding its knowledge boundaries, thereby
minimizing hallucinations. To improve the inherent reliability of LLMs, we
present a novel alignment framework called Reinforcement Learning from
Knowledge Feedback (RLKF). RLKF leverages knowledge feedback to dynamically
determine the model's knowledge boundary and trains a reliable reward model to
encourage the refusal of out-of-knowledge questions. Experimental results on
mathematical questions affirm the substantial efficacy of RLKF in significantly
enhancing LLM reliability.
|
[
-0.3656807541847229,
-0.8274670839309692,
0.7905146479606628,
0.2310941219329834,
-0.036058228462934494,
0.09807520359754562,
-0.2394263595342636,
-0.40721094608306885,
0.09755370765924454,
0.5271434783935547,
-0.7833228707313538,
-0.20678049325942993,
-0.5458323955535889,
0.09921163320541382,
-0.46308931708335876,
1.1071149110794067,
-0.0676388368010521,
0.1929786503314972,
-0.5453064441680908,
-0.10581037402153015,
-0.5770004391670227,
-0.31544575095176697,
-0.6694337725639343,
-0.75287926197052,
0.7179034352302551,
0.26604098081588745,
0.6415144205093384,
0.49840056896209717,
0.4523054361343384,
0.26002177596092224,
-0.10952090471982956,
0.2070382982492447,
-0.7381892204284668,
0.43234753608703613,
0.010993669740855694,
-0.6962697505950928,
-0.09094515442848206,
-0.15214984118938446,
0.8177462816238403,
0.9013224244117737,
-0.3342779576778412,
-0.17405198514461517,
0.22146761417388916,
0.7789301872253418,
-0.4453211724758148,
0.05335473269224167,
-0.7721328139305115,
0.20763947069644928,
0.2899380028247833,
-0.10801912844181061,
-0.5610311031341553,
-0.6582701802253723,
0.10157622396945953,
-0.6521944403648376,
-0.0395742729306221,
-0.02087029255926609,
0.7650845050811768,
0.4880073070526123,
-0.10521649569272995,
-0.4695917069911957,
-0.8817307949066162,
0.6863914728164673,
-0.5011773109436035,
0.6673889756202698,
0.5502989888191223,
0.3404237627983093,
-0.43391793966293335,
-0.24857842922210693,
-0.486644446849823,
-0.5124155282974243,
-0.08090341836214066,
0.04054979979991913,
0.2755626440048218,
0.02790176495909691,
0.22471946477890015,
0.09425407648086548,
-0.5701450705528259,
0.15916982293128967,
-0.506496250629425,
-0.44836631417274475,
0.3681909143924713,
0.10562516003847122,
0.24468153715133667,
0.07198778539896011,
-0.3680201768875122,
-0.17842775583267212,
-0.7924397587776184,
0.03120233863592148,
0.5492510795593262,
0.05842369794845581,
0.4807206988334656,
0.5072217583656311,
-0.24723906815052032,
0.8726666569709778,
0.005708103068172932,
-0.2429073303937912,
0.031312886625528336,
-0.08458750694990158,
0.084531769156456,
0.047639183700084686,
0.49939024448394775,
0.2527601718902588,
0.16435082256793976,
-0.4703993797302246,
-0.4976655840873718,
0.012799463234841824,
0.5184141397476196,
-0.41662338376045227,
-0.07447567582130432,
0.3117879033088684,
-0.431549608707428,
-0.36625227332115173,
0.14169526100158691,
-0.7078707814216614,
-0.5830054879188538,
-0.11602222919464111,
0.5206905603408813,
-0.5704897046089172,
-0.1853911131620407,
0.03761834278702736,
-0.12731629610061646,
0.34915098547935486,
0.48037397861480713,
-0.772304356098175,
0.29690635204315186,
0.7285193204879761,
0.5001777410507202,
-0.41904550790786743,
-0.6371258497238159,
-0.7563836574554443,
0.015949802473187447,
-0.3793383836746216,
0.797924816608429,
-0.3642232418060303,
-0.2816338837146759,
-0.21080239117145538,
-0.07467113435268402,
-0.1376325637102127,
-0.9901419281959534,
0.3700502812862396,
-0.6322725415229797,
0.10271678119897842,
-0.4259239137172699,
-0.585502564907074,
-0.2849620282649994,
0.6057036519050598,
-0.5756956338882446,
0.535929799079895,
0.14841653406620026,
-0.4807419180870056,
0.35809487104415894,
-0.16676980257034302,
-0.39574968814849854,
-0.1344994753599167,
-0.1714935451745987,
-0.5882182121276855,
0.17643524706363678,
0.10265299677848816,
0.09062162786722183,
0.06182984262704849,
0.4012850522994995,
-0.6630873084068298,
-0.4868936836719513,
0.5568393468856812,
-0.4872848689556122,
0.30184128880500793,
0.18508146703243256,
-0.30674001574516296,
0.18220479786396027,
-0.9889236092567444,
0.07149641960859299,
0.1295005828142166,
-0.3994171619415283,
-0.271110475063324,
-0.08152061700820923,
-0.26637670397758484,
0.17912447452545166,
-0.1121700331568718,
-0.39701494574546814,
-0.13106073439121246,
-0.5024881362915039,
0.07031633704900742,
0.8023791909217834,
-0.07975374162197113,
0.4123888611793518,
-0.598383903503418,
0.7335726022720337,
-0.07295431196689606,
0.11310098320245743,
0.38913339376449585,
-0.20101644098758698,
-0.8942350745201111,
0.24680811166763306,
0.05682734400033951,
0.46715182065963745,
-0.9155250191688538,
0.23669104278087616,
-0.015079337172210217,
-0.41919130086898804,
-0.6451148986816406,
0.15930651128292084,
0.49453839659690857,
0.6223411560058594,
0.21403400599956512,
-0.3431924879550934,
-0.5543681383132935,
-0.8498422503471375,
-0.21640752255916595,
-0.6612837910652161,
0.17049002647399902,
0.1022561565041542,
0.5166555643081665,
0.015641042962670326,
0.7007241249084473,
-0.28209391236305237,
-0.3380860686302185,
-0.2882516086101532,
-0.05755233392119408,
-0.22961433231830597,
0.39825233817100525,
0.3116139769554138,
-0.6320154070854187,
0.040692269802093506,
-0.18543967604637146,
-0.8768022656440735,
0.13513866066932678,
-0.17377442121505737,
-0.016621369868516922,
0.37095293402671814,
0.40275755524635315,
-0.6143704056739807,
0.4678124189376831,
0.6021944284439087,
-0.3103635907173157,
0.8268837332725525,
0.014164959080517292,
0.1268034428358078,
-0.7144671678543091,
0.0918501690030098,
-0.4477633535861969,
-0.13660354912281036,
-0.31315186619758606,
-0.13076871633529663,
-0.12271365523338318,
0.08461841940879822,
-0.42446690797805786,
0.569258987903595,
-0.09801904112100601,
-0.28250032663345337,
-0.20403024554252625,
0.20311331748962402,
-0.1252441257238388,
0.40673935413360596,
0.18440081179141998,
0.5815170407295227,
0.11099622398614883,
-0.8542540073394775,
0.5587942600250244,
0.4476871192455292,
-0.3512081801891327,
0.8147631883621216,
-0.543931245803833,
-0.020924266427755356,
-0.27402111887931824,
0.11218767613172531,
-0.9407342672348022,
-0.09937221556901932,
0.4788183271884918,
-0.7528665661811829,
0.10246161371469498,
0.026701049879193306,
-0.1278984248638153,
-0.3305874764919281,
-0.1565290093421936,
0.18527060747146606,
0.32263484597206116,
-0.548933207988739,
0.409000039100647,
0.058313999325037,
-0.060977380722761154,
-0.8465830683708191,
-0.5985771417617798,
-0.2807748317718506,
-0.10950015485286713,
-0.23483330011367798,
-0.10300248116254807,
-0.38081467151641846,
-0.31796959042549133,
0.23290568590164185,
-0.10948877781629562,
-0.013762678019702435,
0.450185090303421,
0.302847295999527,
0.2391379326581955,
0.11272813379764557,
0.2563343942165375,
-0.14819957315921783,
-0.07694652676582336,
0.4090953469276428,
-0.396933913230896,
0.4476279318332672,
0.1698312610387802,
-0.6330156326293945,
-0.42075634002685547,
-0.027786914259195328,
0.6315695643424988,
0.1828446090221405,
0.9597911834716797,
0.5311688780784607,
-0.18357573449611664,
-0.40774744749069214,
-0.6182144284248352,
-0.7449142932891846,
-0.39422863721847534,
0.594009280204773,
-0.27134740352630615,
-1.0242587327957153,
0.541022002696991,
0.19926422834396362,
-0.09702099859714508,
0.20859870314598083,
0.3497268855571747,
-0.03960353881120682,
0.862548828125,
0.46200305223464966,
-0.2503502070903778,
0.28368037939071655,
0.11422784626483917,
0.11800350993871689,
-0.7792659401893616,
-0.4946063756942749,
-0.5813124775886536,
-0.15925829112529755,
-0.21726791560649872,
-0.023220065981149673,
0.1912897378206253,
0.12522761523723602,
-0.1357693076133728,
-0.07578910887241364,
-0.36226052045822144,
0.36333316564559937,
0.3456190228462219,
0.2269257754087448,
0.4019556939601898,
0.16606879234313965,
-0.13507327437400818,
-0.21411249041557312,
-0.7709907293319702,
-0.3418521285057068,
0.9347104430198669,
0.5133913159370422,
0.9417996406555176,
-0.02882724069058895,
0.7494723796844482,
0.06854795664548874,
0.3826768100261688,
-0.8892342448234558,
0.5904938578605652,
0.6320309638977051,
-0.5053229331970215,
-0.5812772512435913,
-0.8663488030433655,
-0.7413821220397949,
0.3495001494884491,
-0.27006223797798157,
-0.5367969870567322,
-0.0955008789896965,
0.22191844880580902,
-0.42936471104621887,
0.5778874754905701,
-0.2243996113538742,
0.47466179728507996,
-0.3191177546977997,
-0.32066935300827026,
-0.18838156759738922,
-0.359211266040802,
0.6146135926246643,
-0.08210084587335587,
0.26705241203308105,
0.26252830028533936,
0.24889008700847626,
0.8686228394508362,
-0.41105183959007263,
0.6703914403915405,
-0.11736740916967392,
-0.318685919046402,
0.23685555160045624,
0.5707703828811646,
0.7065916061401367,
0.1066884696483612,
-0.20899324119091034,
-0.2988412380218506,
-0.07439190149307251,
-0.15435712039470673,
-0.9043781161308289,
0.6678503155708313,
-0.8061172366142273,
-0.6627404093742371,
-0.3303831219673157,
-0.7436764240264893,
-0.4577292203903198,
0.1662314087152481,
0.2675517499446869,
0.07693038880825043,
-0.17223455011844635,
0.0913095772266388,
0.9116917848587036,
-0.3594820201396942,
0.10875886678695679,
0.45659273862838745,
-0.6279426217079163,
-0.6233705282211304,
0.9026749134063721,
0.1232009306550026,
0.6746600270271301,
0.08807358890771866,
-0.09059648215770721,
-0.37151381373405457,
-0.7568866610527039,
-0.2765651345252991,
0.39484015107154846,
-0.9465247988700867,
-0.09032987803220749,
-0.7493928074836731,
-0.41564616560935974,
-0.4172185957431793,
0.109524667263031,
-0.5308064222335815,
-0.3860676884651184,
-0.21686483919620514,
-0.400866836309433,
0.25338655710220337,
1.1408562660217285,
-0.0751311257481575,
-0.17282195389270782,
-0.6657339334487915,
0.027289623394608498,
0.5309840440750122,
0.6234923601150513,
0.37463098764419556,
-0.7900213599205017,
-0.01735503040254116,
0.004801126196980476,
-0.24904699623584747,
-0.4899318814277649,
0.2906185984611511,
-0.31848853826522827,
0.7217815518379211,
0.12369650602340698,
0.1637800633907318,
0.5400300025939941,
-0.21077992022037506,
0.47056928277015686,
0.09465192258358002,
-0.7054063081741333,
0.49469155073165894,
-0.11445733159780502,
0.0646592453122139,
0.5795721411705017,
0.36338913440704346,
-0.5654085278511047,
-0.7522951364517212,
-0.571283221244812,
-0.5932731628417969,
0.5838375091552734,
0.06204374134540558,
-0.18023565411567688,
0.14657281339168549,
0.6407498717308044,
0.39790335297584534,
0.2916063368320465,
-1.0235991477966309,
-0.16407549381256104,
0.1108773872256279,
-0.04117993265390396,
0.027488654479384422,
-0.33793556690216064,
-0.14656510949134827,
-0.10027267038822174,
0.9743503332138062,
-0.0887361541390419,
0.17120647430419922,
0.37006211280822754,
-0.4256191849708557,
-0.3977636992931366,
0.3245199918746948,
0.9380250573158264,
0.8444985747337341,
-0.21043241024017334,
0.10762492567300797,
0.3053978979587555,
-0.281241774559021,
0.295099675655365,
-0.2949937880039215,
-0.4619649052619934,
-0.09633583575487137,
0.3743167519569397,
0.85382080078125,
-0.043569762259721756,
-0.5236856341362,
0.09609037637710571,
-0.07731976360082626,
-0.43867212533950806,
-0.34584489464759827,
0.06080376356840134,
-0.12745435535907745,
0.201152965426445,
0.15115457773208618,
0.04435759037733078,
-0.08804327994585037,
-0.35773420333862305,
0.5943081378936768,
0.5464327931404114,
-0.9282239079475403,
-0.23292355239391327,
0.5523446798324585,
-0.051191821694374084,
-0.3561210334300995,
0.79878169298172,
-0.1482507288455963,
-0.7733126282691956,
0.6045869588851929,
0.6152924299240112,
0.5047048926353455,
-0.09669085592031479,
0.5339460372924805,
0.2771846055984497,
0.6077148914337158,
-0.3449280858039856,
0.17049458622932434,
0.12833821773529053,
-0.8871749043464661,
-0.4213857352733612,
-0.6531303524971008,
-0.6109452843666077,
0.3161790370941162,
-0.7477165460586548,
-0.07493450492620468,
-0.6833727955818176,
0.04595218598842621,
-0.7098382711410522,
-0.2971495985984802,
-0.4104786813259125,
0.0895848497748375,
0.1420818269252777,
0.543504536151886,
-0.8737144470214844,
0.6742879748344421,
0.6357638239860535,
-0.5565491914749146,
-1.052137017250061,
0.011994913220405579,
0.03519502654671669,
-0.8901313543319702,
0.7297180891036987,
0.01059471070766449,
-0.11795931309461594,
0.017628367990255356,
-0.4920675754547119,
-0.8185978531837463,
0.873120129108429,
0.31212136149406433,
-0.5236997604370117,
0.2655605971813202,
0.1680782437324524,
0.3986113965511322,
-0.15269428491592407,
0.2645343840122223,
0.5251541137695312,
0.5918304920196533,
0.3210577368736267,
-0.9563874006271362,
0.26288244128227234,
0.205670565366745,
-0.11389950662851334,
-0.02155727706849575,
-0.599411129951477,
0.5141350030899048,
-0.443353533744812,
0.1613866090774536,
0.24717412889003754,
0.6862537264823914,
0.6510947346687317,
0.16560865938663483,
0.6653962731361389,
0.7107397317886353,
0.8810209035873413,
-0.17455057799816132,
0.9008715152740479,
0.12142404168844223,
0.3284969925880432,
1.0196077823638916,
-0.43140462040901184,
0.762694776058197,
0.696340799331665,
-0.09216562658548355,
0.5686498880386353,
0.4913143217563629,
0.0808788314461708,
0.529183030128479,
0.40034958720207214,
0.11032921075820923,
-0.3673242926597595,
-0.18755488097667694,
-0.3226463794708252,
0.1678280383348465,
0.18108464777469635,
-0.18181756138801575,
-0.1803050935268402,
0.37909916043281555,
-0.031183550134301186,
0.29387161135673523,
-0.1980973184108734,
0.8886464834213257,
0.11576183885335922,
-1.020623803138733,
0.6808642148971558,
-0.41109132766723633,
0.510919988155365,
-0.6091596484184265,
-0.15897102653980255,
-0.4828338921070099,
0.33880946040153503,
-0.23010437190532684,
-0.6424209475517273,
0.4221859574317932,
-0.5101844668388367,
-0.20112048089504242,
-0.09532283246517181,
0.7654589414596558,
-0.47203952074050903,
-0.2900092601776123,
0.5773473978042603,
0.5234271883964539,
0.011873124167323112,
0.03122391551733017,
-0.7226704359054565,
0.43091538548469543,
-0.006541429087519646,
-0.18873071670532227,
0.47125399112701416,
0.35111919045448303,
0.15752512216567993,
1.1560163497924805,
0.49833524227142334,
0.4752560555934906,
-0.2338603138923645,
-0.03483737260103226,
0.6823505759239197,
-0.742828905582428,
-0.3068627119064331,
-0.7673851847648621,
0.23916469514369965,
0.2358609288930893,
0.07747374475002289,
0.6600409150123596,
0.14179283380508423,
1.0665454864501953,
-0.012555154040455818,
0.9489158391952515,
0.22293725609779358,
0.5539983510971069,
-0.6340189576148987,
0.9600566029548645,
-0.5955988168716431,
0.617760956287384,
-0.20883867144584656,
-1.06808602809906,
-0.4257752597332001,
0.6819472312927246,
-0.3559001088142395,
0.19348633289337158,
0.9141356348991394,
0.814439594745636,
0.3908180594444275,
-0.0742274820804596,
0.6147664189338684,
0.1951541304588318,
0.27979186177253723,
0.6659435629844666,
1.324638843536377,
-0.3765549659729004,
0.8203104734420776,
-0.26401597261428833,
0.16211922466754913,
-0.22637581825256348,
-0.40602171421051025,
-0.9474400877952576,
-0.46460533142089844,
-0.23537887632846832,
-1.0316981077194214,
0.2805606722831726,
0.9528765678405762,
0.4662337005138397,
-0.907805323600769,
-0.3146894574165344,
-0.10156751424074173,
0.7611701488494873,
-0.20949549973011017,
-0.240411177277565,
0.14702090620994568,
-0.5881060361862183,
-0.3384383022785187,
0.2644262909889221,
0.33359017968177795,
0.12337493896484375,
-0.40856772661209106,
-0.35348889231681824,
-0.01727522537112236,
-0.2229403555393219,
0.39542314410209656,
0.377906858921051,
-0.8677934408187866,
-0.6444509029388428,
0.1870366930961609,
-0.11500870436429977,
-0.18036621809005737,
0.7268056869506836,
-0.9169481992721558,
0.28483548760414124,
0.38791900873184204,
0.8927054405212402,
-0.17272554337978363,
-0.1950974017381668,
0.7605071663856506,
-0.2256522923707962,
0.022672096267342567,
0.2574966847896576,
0.09317746758460999,
0.37426313757896423,
-0.42402389645576477,
0.44035452604293823,
0.5155532956123352,
-0.5569607615470886,
-1.0122183561325073,
0.36066728830337524,
-0.36531564593315125,
-0.31287384033203125,
1.2261955738067627,
-0.05141022428870201,
-0.39684486389160156,
-0.24331152439117432,
-0.19901911914348602,
0.12285994738340378,
-0.20091955363750458,
1.1042555570602417,
1.0866507291793823,
0.0969429612159729,
-0.3623378574848175,
-0.44859808683395386,
0.7213214635848999,
1.0315146446228027,
-0.6837512254714966,
0.11540540307760239,
0.4245453476905823,
0.40174606442451477,
-0.10109800845384598,
0.42971089482307434,
-0.1995459794998169,
0.351346492767334,
-0.29826024174690247,
0.12003540992736816,
-0.0747983455657959,
-0.46394503116607666,
-0.5356233716011047,
0.23642045259475708,
0.6618493795394897,
0.16173340380191803
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18346v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18346v3
|
Quantifying and Mitigating Unimodal Biases in Multimodal Large Language Models: A Causal Perspective
| 2024-03-27T08:38:49 | 2024-04-03T17:18:51 |
Meiqi Chen, Yixin Cao, Yan Zhang, Chaochao Lu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have facilitated the
development of Multimodal LLMs (MLLMs). Despite their impressive capabilities,
MLLMs often suffer from an over-reliance on unimodal biases (e.g., language
bias and vision bias), leading to incorrect answers in complex multimodal
tasks. To investigate this issue, we propose a causal framework to interpret
the biases in Visual Question Answering (VQA) problems. Within our framework,
we devise a causal graph to elucidate the predictions of MLLMs on VQA problems,
and assess the causal effect of biases through an in-depth causal analysis.
Motivated by the causal graph, we introduce a novel MORE dataset, consisting of
12,000 VQA instances. This dataset is designed to challenge MLLMs' abilities,
necessitating multi-hop reasoning and the surmounting of unimodal biases.
Furthermore, we propose two strategies to mitigate unimodal biases and enhance
MLLMs' reasoning capabilities, including a Decompose-Verify-Answer (DeVA)
framework for limited-access MLLMs and the refinement of open-source MLLMs
through fine-tuning. Extensive quantitative and qualitative experiments offer
valuable insights for future research. Our project page is at
https://opencausalab.github.io/MORE.
|
[
-0.4416595697402954,
-1.133523941040039,
0.7454237341880798,
0.2851046621799469,
-0.062038619071245193,
-0.15263085067272186,
-0.08187523484230042,
-0.16450399160385132,
0.0207295473664999,
0.8420926332473755,
-0.6405567526817322,
-0.22286996245384216,
-0.4193723797798157,
-0.1401090770959854,
-0.19729982316493988,
0.6637136936187744,
-0.14330296218395233,
0.42926570773124695,
-0.6843379139900208,
-0.4416138529777527,
-0.7497212290763855,
-0.2517971694469452,
-0.5911394357681274,
-0.12025197595357895,
0.7667694091796875,
0.20213709771633148,
0.6681671738624573,
0.33489033579826355,
0.43353527784347534,
0.3182455003261566,
-0.03254224359989166,
0.17441701889038086,
-0.46511346101760864,
0.2344210147857666,
-0.3050794005393982,
-0.5577970147132874,
-0.22232966125011444,
-0.40623849630355835,
0.574233889579773,
0.8370591402053833,
0.22961778938770294,
0.4741819500923157,
0.05463305860757828,
0.6312376856803894,
-0.787858247756958,
0.184982568025589,
-0.45705920457839966,
-0.08612193167209625,
-0.1357986330986023,
-0.43726158142089844,
-0.47667813301086426,
-0.07713781297206879,
-0.05499163642525673,
-0.5614110827445984,
-0.01943558268249035,
0.016067728400230408,
0.5703043937683105,
0.6204671859741211,
-0.9118315577507019,
0.2945294976234436,
-0.7217950820922852,
0.7440669536590576,
-0.7026693820953369,
0.39616087079048157,
0.2723780572414398,
0.29858195781707764,
-0.18806397914886475,
-0.6091997027397156,
-0.6346951723098755,
0.0268759373575449,
0.014889020472764969,
0.1399947702884674,
-0.3991101086139679,
0.09934339672327042,
0.550035297870636,
-0.1874980628490448,
-0.6900575757026672,
0.14529681205749512,
-0.314587265253067,
-0.40652182698249817,
0.29168450832366943,
0.4636128842830658,
0.5075042843818665,
-0.07069829106330872,
-0.568496584892273,
-0.03566558659076691,
-0.7379374504089355,
0.2518543004989624,
0.24986322224140167,
0.1913023740053177,
0.053298793733119965,
0.907467246055603,
-0.3095386326313019,
0.7010254859924316,
-0.22361552715301514,
0.05741516500711441,
0.24140319228172302,
-0.5453884601593018,
-0.3294118344783783,
-0.29740554094314575,
0.6341924071311951,
0.59925776720047,
0.4547821879386902,
-0.008802157826721668,
0.052526190876960754,
0.21684324741363525,
0.10786735266447067,
-0.6209333539009094,
-0.019839119166135788,
0.31364694237709045,
-0.28973954916000366,
-0.04972967505455017,
-0.2693374752998352,
-0.9284699559211731,
-0.7077398896217346,
-0.5464463233947754,
0.6108382940292358,
-0.00843879021704197,
-0.1963925063610077,
0.04746874049305916,
-0.28803250193595886,
0.1281472146511078,
0.44357559084892273,
-0.39553284645080566,
-0.21722939610481262,
0.11006499081850052,
0.4136262536048889,
0.19618739187717438,
-0.5053141713142395,
-0.6573955416679382,
0.19358721375465393,
-0.24130558967590332,
0.7133241891860962,
-0.37566858530044556,
0.08789259940385818,
0.16709685325622559,
-0.007300176657736301,
-0.15743333101272583,
-0.32201331853866577,
0.4710221290588379,
-0.6788256168365479,
0.21658329665660858,
-0.6342224478721619,
-0.2847755253314972,
-0.1466943472623825,
0.3304142653942108,
-0.761167585849762,
0.7131046056747437,
-0.14100104570388794,
-1.0362292528152466,
0.3755561411380768,
-0.2870243191719055,
-0.24141132831573486,
-0.3112238645553589,
-0.25836503505706787,
-0.302524209022522,
0.053469467908144,
0.5746463537216187,
0.23631681501865387,
-0.5950098633766174,
0.5513188242912292,
-0.6738055944442749,
-0.035627081990242004,
0.41994795203208923,
-0.7361451983451843,
1.0438587665557861,
0.007058573886752129,
-0.5241544842720032,
0.4584917724132538,
-0.7286386489868164,
0.10979929566383362,
0.0941934585571289,
-0.19055712223052979,
-0.5096485614776611,
0.0458521693944931,
0.07719090580940247,
0.478877991437912,
0.03296130523085594,
-0.4855475127696991,
-0.0398038849234581,
0.16183075308799744,
0.30872011184692383,
1.0076451301574707,
-0.053717248141765594,
0.3320700526237488,
0.07192505896091461,
0.4480627477169037,
0.36447131633758545,
0.4950851798057556,
-0.17588239908218384,
-0.4660235345363617,
-0.8874062895774841,
-0.3600131869316101,
-0.05937129259109497,
0.43508419394493103,
-1.3031299114227295,
-0.31651121377944946,
-0.13821886479854584,
0.035465095192193985,
-0.5001161098480225,
0.2737387716770172,
0.5584890246391296,
0.6614418625831604,
0.4312628507614136,
-0.30725714564323425,
-0.3950715959072113,
-1.0855222940444946,
-0.2664356231689453,
-0.2127518504858017,
-0.08154880255460739,
0.30511969327926636,
0.4363376498222351,
-0.39574021100997925,
0.9308925271034241,
-0.4463431239128113,
-0.43683940172195435,
0.11581409722566605,
0.11696846038103104,
-0.16097651422023773,
0.1459149867296219,
0.45976725220680237,
-0.9340978264808655,
0.07971611618995667,
-0.37856680154800415,
-0.9620895385742188,
-0.39768388867378235,
-0.33280810713768005,
-0.19876070320606232,
0.07045609503984451,
0.7747067213058472,
-0.6439542770385742,
0.3824644684791565,
0.41163408756256104,
-0.735468327999115,
0.5318400859832764,
-0.0983547791838646,
0.12234222888946533,
-0.684036374092102,
0.10461729019880295,
0.13512668013572693,
0.07763823866844177,
-0.5549095273017883,
-0.045064184814691544,
0.001500284648500383,
0.1651419997215271,
-0.45186886191368103,
0.666658341884613,
-0.4299081861972809,
-0.0464942492544651,
0.0021719015203416348,
0.21245817840099335,
0.17814317345619202,
0.8858067989349365,
-0.11713846027851105,
0.5179561376571655,
0.5131251811981201,
-0.29724177718162537,
0.3385900855064392,
0.16364285349845886,
-0.18792442977428436,
0.7140438556671143,
-0.6867519021034241,
-0.20923547446727753,
-0.624661922454834,
0.06369423121213913,
-1.2239247560501099,
-0.0060627656057477,
0.08977477252483368,
-0.43349501490592957,
0.11531933397054672,
0.0040277643129229546,
-0.5548332929611206,
-0.29024502635002136,
-0.33765536546707153,
0.641131579875946,
0.04392664134502411,
-0.599612832069397,
0.6737692356109619,
0.3516216576099396,
0.09512929618358612,
-0.8053828477859497,
-0.5778404474258423,
0.11236560344696045,
-0.2291206568479538,
-0.7475956082344055,
-0.3361784517765045,
-0.20334097743034363,
-0.44462379813194275,
0.07886286079883575,
0.09197128564119339,
-0.08823226392269135,
-0.02099367044866085,
0.21605347096920013,
0.224125936627388,
-0.2669083774089813,
0.2155257761478424,
-0.05048597976565361,
-0.07271348685026169,
0.38049647212028503,
-0.22245779633522034,
0.38142964243888855,
-0.0650252252817154,
-0.6350662708282471,
-0.01274500135332346,
0.364802747964859,
0.9751577973365784,
-0.4870775043964386,
0.6296345591545105,
0.7645718455314636,
-0.12194222211837769,
-0.06070985272526741,
-0.5526934862136841,
-0.16759300231933594,
-0.40410494804382324,
0.4424363374710083,
-0.09434957802295685,
-0.9161221981048584,
0.615816593170166,
0.11527954041957855,
-0.12287965416908264,
0.24748307466506958,
0.8038759231567383,
-0.026341639459133148,
1.2533774375915527,
0.5364055633544922,
-0.0019248907919973135,
0.440775066614151,
0.011993429623544216,
0.09102149307727814,
-1.009743094444275,
-0.4617884159088135,
-0.20586484670639038,
-0.19401980936527252,
-0.5244389176368713,
-0.6105960607528687,
0.6453331708908081,
-0.025667088106274605,
-0.5349054932594299,
-0.17998676002025604,
-0.04349114000797272,
0.3445263206958771,
0.763578474521637,
0.2396494597196579,
0.30687233805656433,
-0.11942356079816818,
-0.19584739208221436,
0.12057647109031677,
-0.7693129181861877,
-0.2397809475660324,
1.1336982250213623,
0.2585587203502655,
0.9317800998687744,
0.2736552357673645,
-0.12300342321395874,
0.08062223345041275,
0.060373373329639435,
-0.3187061846256256,
0.4752684533596039,
0.2781149744987488,
-0.9470687508583069,
-0.5010940432548523,
-0.5477373600006104,
-0.8368592858314514,
0.5989721417427063,
-0.31007716059684753,
-0.6998451948165894,
0.4353760778903961,
0.34434354305267334,
-0.04688488692045212,
0.3214000165462494,
-0.7742317318916321,
1.0910407304763794,
-0.3292066156864166,
-0.9779632091522217,
0.05757446587085724,
-0.859080970287323,
0.598273754119873,
-0.018720723688602448,
0.2145875245332718,
0.07979252934455872,
0.13230016827583313,
0.5352874994277954,
-0.08249810338020325,
1.24101722240448,
-0.15744973719120026,
-0.15633897483348846,
0.25549042224884033,
-0.06644678860902786,
0.2773825526237488,
0.11465753614902496,
0.44634392857551575,
0.1656109243631363,
-0.04023827239871025,
-0.5787612795829773,
-0.7170519232749939,
0.6616478562355042,
-0.7361669540405273,
-0.5173934102058411,
-0.14192166924476624,
-0.6136767268180847,
-0.5560072660446167,
0.3160380721092224,
0.13265958428382874,
0.6996805667877197,
-0.014253724366426468,
-0.006556529086083174,
0.9063165187835693,
-0.4810749590396881,
0.31582459807395935,
0.5144369006156921,
-0.3526214361190796,
-0.40157783031463623,
0.7044693231582642,
0.031147725880146027,
0.43963825702667236,
0.44093039631843567,
0.13919560611248016,
-0.40358272194862366,
-0.3946121037006378,
-0.6946982741355896,
0.2415839582681656,
-0.9978537559509277,
-0.19704443216323853,
-0.5368947982788086,
0.20521458983421326,
-0.31763607263565063,
0.18541602790355682,
-0.15828664600849152,
-0.26363202929496765,
-0.1890946328639984,
-0.09575510025024414,
0.16344788670539856,
0.41348814964294434,
0.02395554631948471,
0.020240506157279015,
-0.5109445452690125,
0.46328628063201904,
0.6277931928634644,
0.31911295652389526,
0.17523276805877686,
-0.37230899930000305,
-0.10759389400482178,
0.21001331508159637,
-0.1549706906080246,
-0.8612967133522034,
0.2337866872549057,
-0.2033739537000656,
0.5277090668678284,
0.450408935546875,
0.10040993988513947,
0.6531756520271301,
-0.41358640789985657,
0.7045965790748596,
0.2899540662765503,
-0.6711779832839966,
0.32359781861305237,
-0.5100908875465393,
0.464861661195755,
0.35918956995010376,
0.2810865342617035,
-0.42921948432922363,
-0.5157813429832458,
-0.2308558076620102,
-0.9799058437347412,
0.2753075063228607,
0.166107639670372,
0.004904347006231546,
0.036637093871831894,
-0.031141070649027824,
-0.3037954270839691,
0.35135719180107117,
-0.6932507753372192,
-0.31365442276000977,
-0.13519375026226044,
0.010885187424719334,
-0.3383578956127167,
-0.4840663969516754,
-0.31051525473594666,
-0.25705862045288086,
0.44456467032432556,
-0.3154190480709076,
0.06873137503862381,
0.20739330351352692,
-0.3973199129104614,
-0.19228842854499817,
0.29988572001457214,
0.7570050954818726,
0.8624301552772522,
-0.025286762043833733,
0.5283246636390686,
0.05310547724366188,
-0.22567076981067657,
-0.1047123447060585,
-0.12967737019062042,
-0.37678489089012146,
-0.2231149524450302,
0.6991993188858032,
0.9197969436645508,
0.08560466021299362,
-0.983238160610199,
0.6258823871612549,
-0.12470413744449615,
0.1443256139755249,
-0.1050298810005188,
-0.417441189289093,
0.12093055993318558,
0.5776612162590027,
0.21240481734275818,
0.035244882106781006,
0.21591417491436005,
-0.5933281183242798,
0.13533417880535126,
0.6738285422325134,
-0.5487815141677856,
-0.29612264037132263,
0.9086083173751831,
0.14189720153808594,
0.16436827182769775,
0.6115429997444153,
0.3869503140449524,
-0.5072181820869446,
0.681873619556427,
0.39476683735847473,
0.7204614877700806,
-0.04990903660655022,
0.33614328503608704,
0.17894093692302704,
0.6931763887405396,
0.21566654741764069,
0.2703549861907959,
0.156765878200531,
-0.7762225270271301,
-0.5642359256744385,
-0.3717813491821289,
-0.16706116497516632,
0.12935121357440948,
-0.6651065349578857,
0.024740545079112053,
-0.14291808009147644,
-0.18527816236019135,
0.09084125608205795,
-0.5368859767913818,
-0.7055864930152893,
0.21232940256595612,
0.21369969844818115,
0.5016637444496155,
-1.1478443145751953,
0.5563076138496399,
0.684648334980011,
-0.7327573895454407,
-0.5680791139602661,
-0.29297390580177307,
0.24456821382045746,
-0.9414366483688354,
0.8288370370864868,
-0.20419096946716309,
-0.18665587902069092,
-0.2311377078294754,
-0.5530386567115784,
-0.7264474630355835,
0.8605055809020996,
0.5980563759803772,
-0.30300888419151306,
0.1314111351966858,
0.35384127497673035,
0.6116734743118286,
0.03215871751308441,
0.4048205018043518,
0.3519275486469269,
0.5391260981559753,
0.035428278148174286,
-0.8590766787528992,
0.15494289994239807,
-0.2640800476074219,
0.02598751150071621,
0.2738799452781677,
-0.43397602438926697,
0.7741479277610779,
-0.5537458658218384,
-0.02580459788441658,
-0.335476815700531,
0.34432101249694824,
-0.006652805022895336,
0.49287375807762146,
0.31652864813804626,
0.605689525604248,
0.5644069314002991,
0.0742092877626419,
1.02240788936615,
0.12884768843650818,
0.2500288188457489,
1.1277377605438232,
-0.10839883238077164,
0.5907941460609436,
1.0022059679031372,
-0.0014817244373261929,
0.07956553995609283,
0.28628280758857727,
0.3449842631816864,
0.41740167140960693,
0.22361677885055542,
-0.23108990490436554,
-0.5388361811637878,
-0.35144349932670593,
-0.08169247955083847,
0.3855971097946167,
0.010054434649646282,
-0.27070945501327515,
-0.3640914559364319,
0.2731315791606903,
0.0795091837644577,
0.07308326661586761,
-0.37858060002326965,
0.5626980066299438,
0.029272548854351044,
-0.549140989780426,
0.4579412341117859,
-0.3107104003429413,
0.2874997556209564,
-0.4871179163455963,
-0.02417154423892498,
-0.41762372851371765,
0.2871127724647522,
-0.11004352569580078,
-0.8771988153457642,
0.030811704695224762,
-0.12963637709617615,
-0.2937313914299011,
-0.22216705977916718,
0.4899093806743622,
-0.60882967710495,
-0.501289963722229,
0.4142822027206421,
0.8199907541275024,
-0.33431100845336914,
-0.13757483661174774,
-0.5081702470779419,
0.21229536831378937,
0.015286934562027454,
-0.35952311754226685,
0.44180217385292053,
0.5775895714759827,
-0.5390486121177673,
0.9300272464752197,
0.6422920823097229,
-0.2230585366487503,
0.3062209486961365,
0.30491453409194946,
1.0243555307388306,
-0.44047653675079346,
-0.1310194432735443,
-0.8840678334236145,
0.7165133953094482,
0.014198483899235725,
-0.4010153114795685,
1.058578610420227,
0.29845547676086426,
0.8360788226127625,
-0.12322302162647247,
0.5243281722068787,
0.22387173771858215,
0.08529780060052872,
-0.7086243629455566,
0.49944621324539185,
-0.7562417387962341,
0.30071160197257996,
-0.5465816855430603,
-0.7206870317459106,
-0.455112099647522,
0.14921371638774872,
-0.30764102935791016,
-0.07162664085626602,
0.647284209728241,
0.8611141443252563,
0.16429071128368378,
-0.34166988730430603,
0.45781853795051575,
0.36353209614753723,
0.3203983008861542,
0.6783779263496399,
1.0599993467330933,
-0.11658667027950287,
0.5412445068359375,
-0.045704856514930725,
-0.3019736409187317,
-0.013934842310845852,
-0.7199193239212036,
-1.0399359464645386,
-0.7279859781265259,
-0.28896620869636536,
-0.30300408601760864,
-0.0368921160697937,
0.34227997064590454,
0.24055086076259613,
-0.47732338309288025,
-0.03171780705451965,
0.21100327372550964,
0.5229553580284119,
-0.10912624001502991,
-0.21365129947662354,
0.46710315346717834,
-0.20143799483776093,
-0.4142136871814728,
-0.05378378927707672,
0.2959088683128357,
-0.22660937905311584,
-0.4699130356311798,
0.15428751707077026,
-0.21958526968955994,
0.17871065437793732,
0.9922904968261719,
0.24067753553390503,
-0.7669397592544556,
-0.3547752797603607,
0.188653364777565,
0.0061867875047028065,
-0.09875452518463135,
0.9274234175682068,
-0.7564926147460938,
0.776320219039917,
0.5635289549827576,
0.5758862495422363,
0.3863902688026428,
-0.2021535336971283,
0.4678668677806854,
-0.4564899206161499,
-0.00020684805349446833,
0.05254243686795235,
0.49133849143981934,
0.22229450941085815,
-0.1609928160905838,
0.2820919156074524,
0.18885073065757751,
-0.326053261756897,
-0.8696947693824768,
0.43554532527923584,
-1.035155177116394,
-0.5044043660163879,
1.2785637378692627,
0.167504221200943,
-0.2402941882610321,
-0.20512178540229797,
-0.4567672908306122,
0.051134247332811356,
0.04628002271056175,
0.6698880791664124,
0.5408642888069153,
-0.08244316279888153,
-0.2942418158054352,
-0.762630820274353,
0.20883284509181976,
0.5266997814178467,
-0.8714417815208435,
0.27770236134529114,
1.003862977027893,
0.26682552695274353,
0.11552838236093521,
0.5713443160057068,
-0.15254749357700348,
0.28408360481262207,
-0.01625351421535015,
0.1955248862504959,
-0.16560348868370056,
-0.48683345317840576,
-0.34198203682899475,
0.16742919385433197,
0.03205961361527443,
-0.05278973653912544
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18341v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18341v1
|
IterAlign: Iterative Constitutional Alignment of Large Language Models
| 2024-03-27T08:32:19 | 2024-03-27T08:32:19 |
Xiusi Chen, Hongzhi Wen, Sreyashi Nag, Chen Luo, Qingyu Yin, Ruirui Li, Zheng Li, Wei Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the rapid development of large language models (LLMs), aligning LLMs
with human values and societal norms to ensure their reliability and safety has
become crucial. Reinforcement learning with human feedback (RLHF) and
Constitutional AI (CAI) have been proposed for LLM alignment. However, these
methods require either heavy human annotations or explicitly pre-defined
constitutions, which are labor-intensive and resource-consuming. To overcome
these drawbacks, we study constitution-based LLM alignment and propose a
data-driven constitution discovery and self-alignment framework called
IterAlign. IterAlign leverages red teaming to unveil the weaknesses of an LLM
and automatically discovers new constitutions using a stronger LLM. These
constitutions are then used to guide self-correction of the base LLM. Such a
constitution discovery pipeline can be run iteratively and automatically to
discover new constitutions that specifically target the alignment gaps in the
current LLM. Empirical results on several safety benchmark datasets and
multiple base LLMs show that IterAlign successfully improves truthfulness,
helpfulness, harmlessness and honesty, improving the LLM alignment by up to
$13.5\%$ in harmlessness.
|
[
-0.05469254404306412,
-0.22594399750232697,
0.4401753544807434,
0.34935301542282104,
-0.172151580452919,
0.34132787585258484,
-0.4663161635398865,
-0.2573074698448181,
0.3197815418243408,
0.5517565608024597,
-0.6356692910194397,
-0.7002304196357727,
-0.3594174385070801,
0.09625791758298874,
-0.2941775321960449,
0.9296671748161316,
-0.10318683087825775,
-0.008930515497922897,
0.006359115708619356,
-0.12966518104076385,
-0.38923221826553345,
-0.36166876554489136,
-0.5165343284606934,
-0.3647584021091461,
0.44367802143096924,
0.7034549713134766,
0.6244856715202332,
1.268047571182251,
0.5137966871261597,
0.39923352003097534,
0.14217910170555115,
-0.02547294646501541,
-0.6364457607269287,
-0.22882433235645294,
-0.5335798263549805,
-0.14454075694084167,
-0.25201407074928284,
-0.0010572230676189065,
0.7566654086112976,
0.5920743346214294,
-0.43666377663612366,
0.06111368536949158,
0.01319271419197321,
0.8560130596160889,
-0.5478585958480835,
0.26730844378471375,
-0.7700410485267639,
-0.16282586753368378,
-0.5828220844268799,
-0.07241686433553696,
-0.346436083316803,
-0.5397326350212097,
0.03909846395254135,
-0.7007095217704773,
-0.09407852590084076,
0.45689836144447327,
0.9716825485229492,
0.5826845765113831,
-0.45769309997558594,
-0.2279869019985199,
-0.54525226354599,
0.7882958054542542,
-0.8581053614616394,
0.37829354405403137,
0.19801774621009827,
0.2441086620092392,
-0.3358323574066162,
-0.5939459204673767,
-0.8136784434318542,
-0.38605496287345886,
-0.08551278710365295,
0.19256068766117096,
0.13050901889801025,
0.3002934455871582,
-0.18658609688282013,
0.4562924802303314,
-0.6299805045127869,
0.5697853565216064,
-0.6255512833595276,
-0.2838684320449829,
0.7020949721336365,
0.3989330530166626,
0.14847393333911896,
-0.11502990871667862,
-0.4262787103652954,
-0.10768110305070877,
-0.8900467753410339,
0.14252308011054993,
0.611301064491272,
0.5164419412612915,
0.0630742758512497,
0.7001861333847046,
-0.006192646920681,
0.5950672626495361,
0.3777906596660614,
-0.09407472610473633,
0.08465839177370071,
-0.3877906799316406,
-0.06603490561246872,
0.319927841424942,
0.948432445526123,
0.3855316638946533,
0.26222723722457886,
-0.23261241614818573,
-0.07323213666677475,
0.16669151186943054,
0.6385685205459595,
-0.6375693678855896,
-0.2356923520565033,
0.5728302001953125,
-0.24303734302520752,
-0.3326548933982849,
0.021912511438131332,
-0.4020034372806549,
-0.5090240836143494,
-0.8078791499137878,
0.23889347910881042,
-0.4791070222854614,
-0.3790850341320038,
0.15464507043361664,
0.15949741005897522,
0.15233318507671356,
0.08953370153903961,
-1.1647279262542725,
0.22663001716136932,
0.9828765988349915,
0.5563894510269165,
-0.6059437394142151,
-0.5612727999687195,
-0.34172558784484863,
0.33842313289642334,
-0.5627731084823608,
1.032492995262146,
-0.3737725615501404,
-0.07760480791330338,
-0.012212400324642658,
0.10168702900409698,
-0.255199134349823,
-0.5262269973754883,
0.6410133838653564,
-0.303749144077301,
0.18196715414524078,
-0.22689750790596008,
-0.7999470233917236,
-0.07969600707292557,
0.39749959111213684,
-0.9360358715057373,
0.714346706867218,
-0.1413368582725525,
-0.5615347027778625,
0.6691138744354248,
-0.6103011965751648,
-0.367206335067749,
-0.10029609501361847,
-0.37443479895591736,
-0.8060717582702637,
-0.08279412984848022,
-0.03413653373718262,
0.11980807781219482,
-0.35270699858665466,
0.421551376581192,
-0.4202367961406708,
-0.25148069858551025,
0.13311153650283813,
0.04717119410634041,
1.1145431995391846,
0.1414034515619278,
-0.4703644812107086,
0.571976900100708,
-0.7654688954353333,
0.14926372468471527,
-0.20936299860477448,
-0.5816024541854858,
-0.08186569064855576,
0.09647052735090256,
-0.14445894956588745,
0.09353971481323242,
0.2801605761051178,
-0.6055676341056824,
0.4849160313606262,
-0.5263352394104004,
0.4980764091014862,
1.1633059978485107,
-0.2643692195415497,
0.9122841358184814,
-0.4904406666755676,
0.1488092541694641,
-0.1752428561449051,
0.36599063873291016,
0.4087478518486023,
0.013214600272476673,
-0.6072229146957397,
-0.6305684447288513,
0.5038595199584961,
0.5655616521835327,
-0.18312889337539673,
0.6831204295158386,
-0.3527671694755554,
-0.2771318256855011,
-0.7785215377807617,
0.26662763953208923,
0.1406909078359604,
0.5208855271339417,
0.2522107660770416,
-0.0403510145843029,
-0.6670303344726562,
-0.7903025150299072,
-0.1703251600265503,
-0.6009904742240906,
0.3688831329345703,
-0.012522817589342594,
0.5069494247436523,
-0.3643324077129364,
0.732576310634613,
0.28157278895378113,
-0.730461835861206,
0.06359463930130005,
0.05184490606188774,
0.060246553272008896,
0.5625240206718445,
0.2804761826992035,
-0.2912287712097168,
-0.29766157269477844,
0.09551912546157837,
-0.5290934443473816,
-0.20168928802013397,
-0.2041398584842682,
-0.2071004956960678,
0.41242843866348267,
0.4366810619831085,
-0.10276301950216293,
0.30314916372299194,
0.6456311941146851,
-0.359157919883728,
0.42597147822380066,
-0.17863959074020386,
0.2557139992713928,
-1.0595307350158691,
0.2561771273612976,
-0.43482506275177,
-0.12454884499311447,
-0.37051936984062195,
-0.033935222774744034,
0.49896180629730225,
0.23997311294078827,
-0.05613389238715172,
0.5562825202941895,
-0.45396631956100464,
-0.08829400688409805,
-0.15159602463245392,
0.16312354803085327,
-0.4072561264038086,
0.43601396679878235,
-0.009517633356153965,
0.8813177347183228,
0.2236211746931076,
-0.593888521194458,
0.23815502226352692,
0.4706149399280548,
-0.17246559262275696,
0.859704852104187,
-0.3556191027164459,
0.07712956517934799,
-0.15535561740398407,
0.03764501214027405,
-0.9398996233940125,
-0.27040189504623413,
0.0001712118391878903,
-0.1938094049692154,
0.33203405141830444,
-0.02979804016649723,
-0.285110205411911,
-0.2466188669204712,
-0.4319337010383606,
0.11171042919158936,
-0.11393614858388901,
-0.7885368466377258,
0.8569539189338684,
0.64305180311203,
-0.15097875893115997,
-0.9028290510177612,
-0.3421696424484253,
0.5536773204803467,
-0.2825247347354889,
-0.7374356389045715,
0.8012009263038635,
-0.23447152972221375,
-0.4969298839569092,
-0.0099008334800601,
0.003695347346365452,
-0.06510744988918304,
0.009262963198125362,
0.3798227906227112,
0.37867191433906555,
0.09279362112283707,
0.25733354687690735,
-0.15359310805797577,
-0.3410804569721222,
-0.3148217499256134,
-0.5810213088989258,
0.37496575713157654,
-0.29604363441467285,
-0.19974954426288605,
-0.8423815965652466,
0.44913041591644287,
0.6081588864326477,
-0.2861972749233246,
0.5167788863182068,
0.0593770295381546,
-0.21807169914245605,
-0.06787844747304916,
-0.5915173888206482,
-0.22943715751171112,
-0.4959588646888733,
-0.06730224192142487,
-0.15263497829437256,
-0.933986246585846,
0.4559682011604309,
-0.30181750655174255,
0.747538149356842,
0.5209277272224426,
0.6515846848487854,
-0.2003905475139618,
0.8657921552658081,
0.8168652653694153,
-0.3291647136211395,
0.6156932711601257,
-0.002773560583591461,
0.0781908929347992,
-0.3757263720035553,
-0.19146297872066498,
-0.662440836429596,
-0.3066110610961914,
-0.6844244003295898,
0.09866073727607727,
0.2633555829524994,
-0.16323721408843994,
-0.5745171308517456,
0.7114476561546326,
-0.5069674253463745,
0.4186447560787201,
0.5185338854789734,
0.03649745509028435,
0.5357813835144043,
-0.11414557695388794,
-0.35362493991851807,
-0.3469368815422058,
-0.3937702476978302,
-0.620049774646759,
1.1291812658309937,
0.1415090262889862,
1.0156093835830688,
0.5393620133399963,
0.9570273160934448,
0.12351831048727036,
0.5342682600021362,
-0.7247358560562134,
0.24018335342407227,
-0.291016548871994,
-0.6167830228805542,
-0.20255081355571747,
-0.2751835584640503,
-0.7336733341217041,
-0.361391544342041,
-0.3797163963317871,
-0.7421462535858154,
0.18234212696552277,
0.47132954001426697,
-0.5693773031234741,
0.018134500831365585,
-0.38750624656677246,
0.8895887136459351,
-0.5557801127433777,
-0.5001817941665649,
-0.4424659311771393,
-0.504968523979187,
0.27685126662254333,
-0.07149443030357361,
-0.08613336831331253,
0.015303720720112324,
-0.11351390182971954,
0.5116259455680847,
-0.5914657711982727,
0.8086712956428528,
0.17791441082954407,
-0.4965859353542328,
-0.13559262454509735,
0.012948933057487011,
0.7461302280426025,
-0.005037125665694475,
-0.3866643011569977,
0.15963461995124817,
-0.0015876350225880742,
-0.17134332656860352,
-0.29447489976882935,
0.8946036100387573,
-0.6595680713653564,
-0.7135698199272156,
-0.2978168725967407,
-0.4837784171104431,
0.019873058423399925,
0.1781569868326187,
0.21706396341323853,
0.1431669294834137,
-0.10506023466587067,
0.1743827909231186,
0.6389516592025757,
0.09286576509475708,
0.38186800479888916,
0.7736914157867432,
-0.04345915839076042,
-0.8594864010810852,
0.8055689930915833,
0.1259351372718811,
0.17522576451301575,
0.26538410782814026,
0.07726629078388214,
-0.610253632068634,
-0.5488976240158081,
-0.6265736818313599,
0.2518104314804077,
-0.5816997289657593,
-0.22973355650901794,
-0.4701893925666809,
0.08329790085554123,
-0.48701098561286926,
-0.13013187050819397,
-0.7898554801940918,
-0.7084274888038635,
-0.3121739625930786,
-0.16661778092384338,
0.21732479333877563,
0.6296237707138062,
-0.4081592559814453,
0.3193471431732178,
-0.3178982436656952,
0.1868748664855957,
0.31371960043907166,
0.4129619598388672,
-0.6784273386001587,
-0.5086636543273926,
0.256565123796463,
-0.38076475262641907,
-0.23591573536396027,
-0.6798766255378723,
0.05651599541306496,
0.33196768164634705,
0.5606964230537415,
0.5542221069335938,
0.23069676756858826,
1.000348448753357,
-0.591759979724884,
0.4871281683444977,
0.027589058503508568,
-0.9921429753303528,
0.12083199620246887,
-0.022433560341596603,
-0.12745745480060577,
0.9308023452758789,
0.05684548616409302,
-0.3982914686203003,
-0.34971949458122253,
-0.3086397051811218,
-0.7607288956642151,
0.35357943177223206,
0.03947307914495468,
-0.10190890729427338,
0.1240115836262703,
0.524700403213501,
0.024946734309196472,
0.04748957231640816,
-0.6970332860946655,
-0.08812813460826874,
-0.17703735828399658,
-0.6764209270477295,
0.4156034290790558,
0.030869850888848305,
-0.5427504181861877,
-0.18203586339950562,
0.9317321181297302,
-0.5205230712890625,
0.2253832072019577,
0.05251505225896835,
-0.13472947478294373,
-0.2999379634857178,
0.22175845503807068,
0.7893452644348145,
0.6247904300689697,
0.17356908321380615,
0.1799955815076828,
0.04728393629193306,
-0.06499329954385757,
0.17725275456905365,
0.2662714123725891,
0.09135988354682922,
-0.3643302917480469,
0.21502186357975006,
0.5028528571128845,
0.12575340270996094,
-0.5753021240234375,
0.5396631360054016,
-0.24703115224838257,
-0.3221466839313507,
-0.6790265440940857,
0.10203871130943298,
0.1556144803762436,
0.5226366519927979,
0.12600457668304443,
-0.14805692434310913,
-0.0847894474864006,
-0.5814276933670044,
0.3813806474208832,
0.6681843400001526,
-0.3517249524593353,
-0.130973219871521,
0.8031996488571167,
0.12994712591171265,
-0.2503229081630707,
0.5155215859413147,
-0.08137398213148117,
-0.6461694240570068,
0.37990278005599976,
0.4785648584365845,
0.7310917973518372,
-0.2863277494907379,
0.12681759893894196,
0.6797082424163818,
0.5115548372268677,
-0.2893049120903015,
0.37968680262565613,
-0.17410480976104736,
-0.6977348327636719,
-0.48833194375038147,
-0.24170519411563873,
-0.5147565603256226,
0.033476799726486206,
-0.27972984313964844,
0.29117876291275024,
-0.9108348488807678,
-0.14345042407512665,
-0.10781215131282806,
0.19322732090950012,
-0.19011767208576202,
-0.12573961913585663,
-0.13810046017169952,
0.7217787504196167,
-0.5103824734687805,
0.6292177438735962,
0.3493969738483429,
-0.39981040358543396,
-0.8879666924476624,
0.021573340520262718,
0.4166314899921417,
-0.8656837940216064,
0.5441584587097168,
0.15724705159664154,
-0.13235989212989807,
0.25218677520751953,
-0.6937668919563293,
-0.7898561358451843,
1.0950374603271484,
0.6051657795906067,
-0.9694486260414124,
-0.1126701757311821,
0.1765480637550354,
0.3124603033065796,
-0.2412610799074173,
-0.2085036039352417,
0.6335192918777466,
0.6767807602882385,
0.0850868821144104,
-1.1820074319839478,
0.07590532302856445,
-0.14711716771125793,
-0.269596129655838,
0.2490365356206894,
-0.6318950057029724,
0.7885075211524963,
-0.5557050704956055,
-0.6070343255996704,
0.32493165135383606,
0.6249179244041443,
0.2947397232055664,
-0.15549711883068085,
0.49600696563720703,
0.8334907293319702,
1.1593759059906006,
-0.1195010244846344,
0.5561223030090332,
-0.5344798564910889,
0.14820902049541473,
1.2958171367645264,
-0.5129371881484985,
0.6276139616966248,
0.6166077256202698,
0.22094175219535828,
0.564585268497467,
0.6171811819076538,
0.06406460702419281,
0.4720607399940491,
0.22547800838947296,
-0.5045204162597656,
-0.31511634588241577,
-0.0469411201775074,
0.12088379263877869,
0.454243540763855,
0.21564441919326782,
-0.32511818408966064,
-0.2275903970003128,
-0.1746295839548111,
0.12287738174200058,
0.3421976864337921,
-0.14856109023094177,
1.242655873298645,
-0.2120082676410675,
-0.9062013030052185,
0.6094015836715698,
-0.09383202344179153,
0.47095486521720886,
-0.38685569167137146,
-0.06405860185623169,
-0.1349005550146103,
0.621553897857666,
-0.30992355942726135,
-0.7507020831108093,
0.3562362790107727,
-0.10010592639446259,
-0.031049301847815514,
-0.2979520857334137,
0.3269646167755127,
-0.5260536670684814,
-0.0315934456884861,
0.17405040562152863,
-0.08209343999624252,
-0.3642743229866028,
0.06682927161455154,
-0.783847987651825,
0.1069016307592392,
-0.02592368796467781,
0.14039719104766846,
-0.1783626526594162,
0.2769758701324463,
-0.35823386907577515,
0.7618869543075562,
0.5381147861480713,
0.13671019673347473,
-0.07994712889194489,
-0.032067954540252686,
0.8583958148956299,
-0.7832520604133606,
-0.5029976963996887,
-0.8522570133209229,
0.5483523011207581,
-0.4278818368911743,
-0.26212117075920105,
0.31194525957107544,
0.4786573350429535,
0.750037670135498,
0.29601818323135376,
0.6932192444801331,
-0.053715918213129044,
0.41595903038978577,
-0.6009017825126648,
0.6918080449104309,
-0.28476884961128235,
0.32042625546455383,
0.01989223249256611,
-0.5563793778419495,
-0.41554194688796997,
0.7342351675033569,
-0.20390476286411285,
-0.45096927881240845,
0.7511172294616699,
1.161258578300476,
0.17943143844604492,
-0.053049854934215546,
0.08623946458101273,
0.095540851354599,
0.5860192775726318,
0.4112253487110138,
0.6163148283958435,
-0.23009295761585236,
0.6386460065841675,
-0.23203612864017487,
-0.18090590834617615,
0.0324564054608345,
-1.180086612701416,
-0.969716489315033,
-0.7609952688217163,
-0.32245388627052307,
-0.3476158380508423,
0.07909401506185532,
1.4253844022750854,
0.5902453064918518,
-0.9798569083213806,
-0.33062228560447693,
-0.4288007616996765,
-0.06943609565496445,
-0.18439717590808868,
-0.19000248610973358,
0.2868209481239319,
-0.45461174845695496,
-0.6706576347351074,
0.3957032561302185,
0.4786316752433777,
-0.027981817722320557,
-0.36766618490219116,
-0.23050105571746826,
-0.08618378639221191,
-0.022751182317733765,
0.06300976872444153,
0.7174364924430847,
-0.817635178565979,
-0.541171133518219,
0.044889602810144424,
-0.4292653203010559,
0.10798250138759613,
0.9698923826217651,
-0.4779904782772064,
0.4635772109031677,
0.35903802514076233,
0.8974440693855286,
0.15182746946811676,
-0.05286243557929993,
0.8838360905647278,
-0.49495750665664673,
-0.10747980326414108,
0.08176997303962708,
0.43187350034713745,
0.44808855652809143,
-0.40991297364234924,
0.4702690839767456,
-0.02788688614964485,
-0.754601776599884,
-0.4460200369358063,
0.2192705124616623,
-0.827369749546051,
-0.03468532860279083,
0.8834077715873718,
0.029920976608991623,
-0.4527324438095093,
-0.2571064531803131,
-0.47740885615348816,
0.2676127254962921,
-0.3883463442325592,
1.420274019241333,
0.30378028750419617,
0.08184823393821716,
-0.18126235902309418,
-0.17283053696155548,
0.8268711566925049,
0.3823796212673187,
-1.1038320064544678,
0.4795342683792114,
0.580665111541748,
0.4717434048652649,
0.21345026791095734,
0.5684181451797485,
-0.27992987632751465,
0.4240475594997406,
-0.5613921880722046,
0.19811561703681946,
0.08681175112724304,
-0.32786324620246887,
-0.24514999985694885,
0.017517639324069023,
0.011216871440410614,
0.09662117063999176
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.